id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16536v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16536v1 | C-LLM: Learn to Check Chinese Spelling Errors Character by Character | 2024-06-24T11:16:31 | 2024-06-24T11:16:31 | Kunting Li, Yong Hu, Liang He, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chinese Spell Checking (CSC) aims to detect and correct spelling errors in
sentences. Despite Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit robust capabilities and
are widely applied in various tasks, their performance on CSC is often
unsatisfactory. We find that LLMs fail to meet the Chinese character-level
constraints of the CSC task, namely equal length and phonetic similarity,
leading to a performance bottleneck. Further analysis reveal that this issue
stems from the granularity of tokenization, as current mixed character-word
tokenization struggles to satisfy these character-level constraints. To address
this issue, we propose C-LLM, a Large Language Model-based Chinese Spell
Checking method that learns to check errors Character by Character.
Character-level tokenization enables the model to learn character-level
alignment, effectively mitigating issues related to character-level
constraints. Furthermore, CSC is simplified to replication-dominated and
substitution-supplemented tasks. Experiments on two CSC benchmarks demonstrate
that C-LLM achieves an average improvement of 10% over existing methods.
Specifically, it shows a 2.1% improvement in general scenarios and a
significant 12% improvement in vertical domain scenarios, establishing
state-of-the-art performance. The source code can be accessed at
https://github.com/ktlKTL/C-LLM. | [
0.0515157022,
0.0281320587,
0.0300030485,
0.0274357814,
-0.0259195864,
0.0059942966,
0.0202196091,
0.0146815963,
0.0268734992,
-0.0408872999,
-0.0109326467,
-0.0784341693,
0.0453115143,
-0.0101075592,
0.0326297693,
0.0082273614,
0.0806953609,
-0.018159885,
-0.0016103067,
-0.0014425181,
0.0321858637,
-0.0113305328,
0.0003186311,
0.0337718092,
-0.0329634957,
-0.0310717169,
0.0184355322,
0.0451086536,
0.0137572419,
-0.0360855572,
0.0279492866,
0.0209540986,
-0.0334703177,
0.0685734823,
0.0000019666,
-0.0382359102,
-0.0483203083,
-0.0169369318,
0.0089421691,
0.0846001133,
0.0486533493,
-0.0071235443,
-0.0575017855,
0.0482937098,
0.0345137566,
0.0166044272,
0.0637334511,
0.0613347329,
0.0311932117,
0.0643829703,
-0.0080758519,
0.0150105832,
0.020380402,
-0.0067274468,
-0.0205814913,
-0.0097501939,
0.0409427695,
0.0034634396,
-0.0055943807,
-0.0641226918,
-0.0452925526,
0.022780437,
-0.0585717075,
-0.0166820586,
-0.0081888596,
-0.0028936719,
-0.008926929,
-0.0016903565,
-0.015827518,
0.0367288068,
-0.0531398058,
-0.0456633456,
0.002711419,
0.0196297225,
-0.0278920811,
-0.0104629174,
0.0037274424,
0.005857605,
-0.034637209,
0.0300097857,
0.0461106002,
-0.0470758639,
0.0494153574,
0.02459847,
-0.0140546588,
0.049525477,
0.0395730436,
-0.0869892612,
-0.0451666415,
0.0208558142,
0.0222711358,
-0.0356546752,
0.0322682448,
0.0131178265,
-0.0633641109,
-0.0120512675,
-0.0230577681,
-0.0488763414,
0.0009211033,
-0.0099124089,
0.0053177397,
0.0183530264,
-0.0235157777,
0.0073178206,
-0.0521314964,
0.0643119067,
-0.0031559106,
0.0263798367,
-0.0159408003,
-0.0277217515,
-0.0082770819,
-0.0166427959,
-0.042802982,
0.0265264623,
0.0156499427,
-0.0094091129,
-0.0583993345,
-0.0129112909,
-0.0230375566,
0.0383033156,
0.0184475463,
-0.0463748723,
-0.021810988,
-0.0224475022,
0.0142297,
0.0288099423,
0.014355191,
0.0209151078,
-0.0132872378,
0.0084180646,
-0.0242810044,
0.0087461378,
0.0386337377,
-0.0238007996,
0.0421582311,
0.0576613508,
-0.0080708768,
-0.0371183716,
-0.0235344749,
0.0352220461,
-0.0360193662,
-0.0169685632,
-0.0692869648,
-0.0616399609,
-0.0271195136,
-0.038465783,
0.0443271287,
-0.0225303285,
0.0268523768,
-0.0040280614,
-0.0060350266,
0.0831991285,
-0.0186432209,
0.0099886302,
-0.0131684933,
-0.0068480745,
0.0201770458,
0.0116281062,
0.0385987833,
-0.009965539,
0.0591296032,
0.0048770248,
0.0528597422,
0.0416462719,
-0.0528980978,
-0.0165374223,
-0.0179736074,
-0.0458667688,
0.0175017286,
0.0356377475,
0.051489681,
0.1057337001,
-0.0109776398,
0.030163303,
0.0433557965,
0.0397418365,
0.0144043919,
-0.0212604962,
0.0058891294,
-0.0481947511,
-0.0036527149,
0.0055575301,
-0.0382830463,
-0.0173576362,
-0.0338968821,
0.0223666653,
0.040964704,
0.0374744013,
-0.0328112468,
-0.0389722064,
-0.0597672202,
-0.0127664348,
0.007055827,
-0.0386651456,
0.0370050371,
-0.0062787351,
-0.0380869173,
0.0495716035,
0.0104861697,
-0.0736187845,
0.0128746722,
-0.0436197929,
0.0549591295,
0.1367913783,
0.091429837,
-0.02119519,
-0.015384228,
0.0049969438,
-0.0412371382,
0.059718091,
0.035582792,
-0.0250313543,
-0.0114263091,
-0.05753088,
0.0185930021,
0.0465865508,
0.0006398286,
-0.0153643833,
0.0524782687,
0.0368338674,
-0.0074425433,
-0.0583258569,
-0.0443324596,
0.0425943099,
-0.0093435869,
-0.0106342742,
-0.0187497679,
0.0158896763,
0.0009896159,
-0.0018929131,
-0.050878033,
0.0234908592,
-0.0292678569,
-0.0472550876,
-0.0378152654,
-0.0144369854,
-0.0257283933,
-0.0509933531,
0.0944537446,
-0.0434635468,
-0.0425577313,
0.0473432578,
-0.0317051485,
-0.0476899892,
-0.0035123781,
-0.0127057219,
0.0175944697,
-0.0798755661,
0.0748439506,
-0.0122457938,
0.004843493,
-0.0088669648,
0.0372938439,
-0.0016201254,
0.0109107979,
-0.0140276579,
0.0338233784,
-0.005778369,
-0.0464101508,
-0.0764925629,
-0.0186475441,
0.0113743264,
0.0464722067,
0.0103986468,
0.037747018,
-0.0014104309,
-0.0310105514,
-0.0607653782,
0.0080162482,
-0.0283006597,
-0.0048692161,
0.0053483001,
0.0284492187,
-0.0074112201,
-0.0082187764,
-0.0230513606,
0.013541772,
0.0098484382,
-0.0143751567,
0.0552415885,
-0.0619805716,
-0.0483848043,
-0.0674308166,
0.0029885939,
-0.0223094746,
-0.0223625507,
-0.0170514379,
-0.0635562465,
-0.0798315778,
0.0149616217,
-0.0005867184,
0.0298807211,
0.0423047543,
-0.0567457825,
-0.0346560962,
-0.0311808959,
0.05394537,
0.0232780054,
0.0037494861,
-0.007116619,
0.0374759659,
-0.0081348866,
-0.0086651202,
0.0025992126,
0.0344263725,
0.0057122922,
-0.0080470154,
-0.0247916654,
-0.0017083046,
0.0753579587,
-0.0072544185,
-0.0074220393,
-0.0238711443,
-0.0365918577,
-0.0226010922,
0.0142124658,
-0.0248978678,
-0.0095146159,
-0.0347828716,
-0.0264348947,
-0.0447954871,
-0.030716503,
0.0682665631,
-0.0649116561,
0.0022839187,
-0.0375220664,
0.0069836322,
-0.0294500422,
-0.0009427753,
-0.0253696777,
0.0225526169,
-0.0293865353,
-0.0648749396,
-0.02391636,
0.0374455638,
0.0042797914,
-0.0427052416,
0.0510632992,
-0.0373763666,
0.0369032435,
-0.0079462333,
-0.0201999452,
-0.0237145331,
0.007797963,
-0.0585235283,
0.0075347438,
0.040362455,
-0.0208121464,
0.0000848633,
0.0746475756,
-0.0041922047,
0.0679692104,
0.0141317779,
0.0123543721,
-0.0069469772,
0.0116054136,
0.0132171782,
0.0085465014,
0.0385603569,
-0.0270564519,
0.053143099,
0.0394665897,
0.0212332848,
-0.0078685712,
0.0208472088,
-0.0167760067,
0.0397771411,
-0.051642552,
0.0289054029,
-0.0126218162,
0.0630105138,
-0.042155847,
-0.0565570742,
0.1212111115,
0.0329272114,
-0.0347549878,
-0.0118369004,
-0.0066196937,
0.0027072714,
-0.0040573948,
-0.0083104242,
-0.0741422251,
-0.0445762835,
0.0610390641,
0.0157627631,
0.0094589964,
-0.0109202079,
0.0362438299,
-0.1367036253,
0.0390772,
0.0347307771,
-0.0083119906,
-0.0714240819,
0.0082098972,
0.0065321983,
-0.0108435303,
0.0836064219,
0.0581665225,
-0.0233734176,
-0.0471673124,
0.0184420459,
-0.0577652901,
-0.0414733402,
0.0143796187,
-0.0746949688,
0.0513496622,
0.0369911492,
0.0063023278,
0.0059613474,
-0.0348931029,
0.0225397367,
0.0286581181,
-0.0256647859,
-0.0030141869,
-0.0055713397,
0.0048324158,
-0.0289257728,
-0.0102893943,
0.0096950084,
-0.0282120816,
-0.0064470223,
0.0161585212,
0.0351645909,
-0.0021454759,
0.0000143023,
0.0214235391,
0.0114994934,
0.0010171718,
0.0900187418,
0.025387926,
-0.0677677169,
-0.073885195,
-0.0303429104,
-0.0438947529,
-0.0752151906,
-0.0003171819,
0.0481109396,
-0.0486948676,
0.0167748947,
-0.0916441977,
0.0017199315,
0.0017187924,
0.0105681904,
0.0096547045,
0.0285069477,
-0.0149010615,
0.0254837051,
-0.0263927169,
-0.0408827253,
-0.0302646402,
0.0481316485,
-0.107009612,
0.0310661308,
-0.0254270546,
-0.0219233092,
0.0174574647,
0.0227709524,
-0.0647198707,
-0.0371176302,
0.0262423474,
0.0020886774,
0.0052226046,
0.0353052206,
-0.0481531955,
-0.0102380272,
0.0295173246,
0.019579744,
0.0070786951,
0.0265430436,
-0.0054014153,
-0.0335315056,
-0.002527188,
0.0182576105,
-0.0495709889,
0.0089662271,
0.0081453575,
0.0722329244,
0.0023936285,
0.0182591248,
0.035987664,
0.0446466506,
0.0522650667,
-0.0502684824,
0.0262495112,
-0.0559373088,
0.0305859856,
0.007215993,
-0.0332125612,
-0.0003859476,
-0.0147736445,
0.0327375866,
-0.0116803059,
-0.0306866821,
-0.0158475172,
-0.0088670813,
0.0059546907,
0.0224835258,
-0.0005333758,
-0.0301797595,
0.0312743597,
0.0325606316,
-0.0296627339,
0.0010806428,
0.0314270556,
0.0182828307,
0.0054762005,
-0.0046258126,
-0.0320365392,
-0.0021974694,
0.0270344876,
-0.0306506399,
0.0332934335,
-0.0106280958,
0.0297885872,
-0.0199782774,
0.0063487035,
0.1107097119,
-0.0159497149,
0.0676926896,
-0.0457325317,
-0.008984088,
-0.0397430547,
-0.0140421903,
0.0034822549,
0.0101647992,
0.0040376042,
0.0055472194,
-0.0224277116,
-0.0474230461,
0.0677462518,
0.0221193731,
0.0419331528,
-0.0164249446,
-0.0502903424,
-0.0165028013,
-0.0022198614,
-0.0077826348,
-0.0205878261,
-0.0551483929,
-0.0256252587,
-0.0513071492,
-0.0658042654,
0.0297267325,
0.0434324257,
0.0016502477,
0.0284173377,
-0.0220521688,
0.0275497586,
0.0281371213,
0.0310845971,
-0.0385034271,
-0.0288476646,
0.058900658,
-0.0355306379,
0.0321886949,
-6.098516855e-33,
-0.0269458424,
0.0055914531,
-0.002526422,
-0.0158591084,
-0.0090841353,
0.0133999055,
-0.034439221,
0.001953641,
0.0094125587,
0.0104945377,
-0.0215762779,
0.0260956232,
0.0248994231,
0.0108798286,
0.0302090943,
0.0311271921,
0.065605998,
0.0315447934,
-0.0052605248,
-0.0453614332,
0.0530605949,
0.0491719991,
0.05115363,
-0.00770145,
-0.0083077094,
0.0074526067,
-0.0238146,
0.0219959728,
0.0026619416,
0.05009472,
-0.0104544749,
0.0405884944,
0.0214364082,
0.0482523926,
-0.0246101003,
-0.0020126931,
-0.1151612327,
0.0008022047,
0.0082036145,
0.0351649262,
0.0147688147,
-0.0419459641,
0.0367724523,
-0.0024190289,
-0.0241674129,
0.0178473797,
0.0085891215,
-0.0369377732,
0.018255448,
-0.0271617174,
-0.0517716594,
0.0365783013,
0.0325045139,
0.0124614649,
-0.008852263,
-0.0128816422,
-0.0103831431,
0.029657105,
-0.0687973872,
0.0065376838,
0.0132665401,
0.0758571327,
0.0157377068,
0.0193747431,
-0.0381229371,
0.0432874709,
-0.0040752222,
-0.0264474433,
-0.0138007198,
0.0001071148,
0.0403414294,
-0.0118583459,
0.0566470437,
0.0415250957,
0.0285100564,
-0.0493417531,
-0.0569708012,
0.0378405116,
0.013414409,
0.0241472069,
0.0133846514,
0.0242840964,
-0.0363752209,
-0.0292771012,
0.0213445481,
0.0325440057,
-0.0541120991,
0.0093174102,
0.0394335017,
0.0530956797,
-0.0205833279,
-0.0242583156,
0.0049107457,
-0.0204397254,
-0.0288657993,
-0.0096262833,
0.0308778007,
-0.011004407,
-0.043885421,
0.0302715898,
-0.0429204702,
-0.0703349784,
-0.009779565,
0.0116098216,
-0.0200160276,
0.003693541,
0.0476437956,
0.0311205331,
-0.100041233,
0.0234058779,
0.006838874,
0.0150750503,
0.0250273272,
-0.0018697859,
0.0018183779,
-0.0231233016,
0.0453421883,
-0.020011507,
0.0327468179,
-0.0017109108,
-0.0046897298,
-0.0215558857,
-0.0280277133,
0.0216825567,
-0.0241731368,
0.0359527729,
-0.0605397187,
0.0072674234,
0.0112789348,
-0.0689440072,
0.0131505486,
0.0071902862,
2.641e-7,
0.0324311778,
0.0460777394,
0.0423639081,
-0.0088075567,
0.0187905561,
-0.0080847936,
-0.0529216677,
0.0096692424,
-0.0509018153,
0.0496311821,
0.0557145663,
-0.0062960004,
0.0751501396,
0.009853946,
-0.0594211295,
0.0334605314,
-0.0432349332,
0.0303069726,
-0.005302886,
-0.0017268503,
-0.0295325574,
0.0685734153,
-0.0125734676,
-0.0207472611,
-0.0187886003,
-0.0782857761,
0.0209156908,
0.0268276427,
-0.0040480099,
0.0337395258,
0.0673750713,
0.0185885336,
0.0255681276,
-0.0042255069,
-0.0201070886,
0.0111639043,
0.0661411658,
0.031428013,
-0.0265985187,
0.0243309252,
-0.0018586664,
-0.0086365314,
-0.0061345785,
-0.0429275855,
0.0441231094,
0.0529437736,
0.0589739643,
-0.0422653593,
0.0049702995,
-0.0010543088,
-0.0112365065,
-0.0309449565,
-0.0299423486,
0.0439103395,
0.0416291207,
0.0167699438,
-0.0317392088,
-0.0457239188,
-0.0441068262,
-0.0069896751,
0.0021775337,
-0.0379342064,
0.0206175726,
-0.0059953588,
-0.0076656425,
-0.0438958034,
-0.0263487119,
2.449930428e-34,
0.0410954542,
-0.0367484987,
-0.0042204247,
0.0195090082,
0.030377401,
-0.0162365269,
-0.010331816,
0.0079111308,
-0.0310613681,
-0.0455569215,
-0.0298867915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16535v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16535v1 | Token-based Decision Criteria Are Suboptimal in In-context Learning | 2024-06-24T11:16:26 | 2024-06-24T11:16:26 | Hakaze Cho, Yoshihiro Sakai, Mariko Kato, Kenshiro Tanaka, Akira Ishii, Naoya Inoue | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In-Context Learning (ICL) typically utilizes classification criteria from
probabilities of manually selected label tokens. However, we argue that such
token-based classification criteria lead to suboptimal decision boundaries,
despite delicate calibrations through translation and constrained rotation. To
address this problem, we propose Hidden Calibration, which renounces token
probabilities and uses the nearest centroid classifier on the LM's last hidden
states. In detail, we use the nearest centroid classification on the hidden
states, assigning the category of the nearest centroid previously observed from
a few-shot calibration set to the test sample as the predicted label. Our
experiments on 3 models and 10 classification datasets indicate that Hidden
Calibration consistently outperforms current token-based calibrations by about
20%. Our further analysis demonstrates that Hidden Calibration finds better
classification criteria with less inter-categories overlap, and LMs provide
linearly separable intra-category clusters with the help of demonstrations,
which supports Hidden Calibration and gives new insights into the conventional
ICL. | [
-0.033200141,
0.0154117402,
-0.0054722899,
0.0282964204,
0.0079793008,
0.0256568119,
0.0493199117,
0.0179986805,
-0.0418957546,
-0.0246610492,
-0.0404197052,
-0.0017224582,
0.0383643731,
-0.0089208176,
0.0041638203,
-0.0415715948,
0.0128438137,
-0.0148746753,
0.0236866307,
0.0106209833,
-0.0309600383,
-0.0206363425,
-0.0218834989,
0.0501458012,
-0.0841248184,
-0.0141779864,
-0.0138469273,
0.0282349903,
0.040613994,
-0.0363545865,
0.0358885527,
0.0198677778,
0.0048013432,
0.0213927664,
0.0000022746,
-0.0426431,
-0.0463660993,
-0.01984814,
0.0019425612,
-0.0337173641,
0.029272072,
-0.0371297784,
0.0138476659,
0.0103358896,
-0.0266551208,
0.0058453591,
0.0462552533,
0.038445618,
-0.0036293957,
0.0372210704,
-0.0221123192,
-0.0013921988,
-0.0172781013,
-0.011185796,
0.001343063,
-0.0542495325,
0.021693714,
-0.0243499707,
-0.0789568424,
-0.0328680277,
-0.030691037,
0.0150257992,
0.0323328786,
0.0328583196,
0.0312307272,
0.0639741346,
-0.0288943723,
0.0020596681,
0.0025821612,
0.0346155651,
-0.0461374149,
-0.0302819312,
-0.0172363501,
-0.0362210907,
0.0316948146,
-0.0379309803,
-0.0378094055,
0.0130795045,
-0.0109161921,
0.0281651616,
-0.022524748,
0.0708073452,
0.0279428922,
-0.028099224,
-0.0282118693,
0.0591263808,
-0.0241148341,
-0.0068533686,
-0.0311024319,
0.0116726421,
-0.0245592371,
-0.0192294791,
0.0071562724,
0.010274658,
-0.0508412346,
0.006140721,
-0.0335114188,
0.0459886715,
-0.0086589772,
-0.0018588221,
0.020133771,
0.0442546494,
-0.0096189352,
0.0276413672,
-0.0257326439,
0.0540214442,
0.0086141517,
0.048878964,
-0.0586673915,
-0.0088821501,
-0.0300280396,
0.0153623493,
-0.0163901299,
0.000573274,
-0.00388197,
-0.0176228937,
-0.0721424073,
0.0233196858,
-0.022017641,
0.0128794014,
-0.0333765969,
0.0370627306,
-0.0183813814,
0.024338698,
0.0088014323,
0.0234177429,
-0.0141651575,
0.0377159305,
0.0197662041,
0.0059727365,
-0.0014207466,
0.037424203,
-0.0106726782,
-0.008603394,
0.0096245529,
0.0370518193,
-0.0027369142,
-0.0333180577,
-0.0049447762,
-0.0122830085,
-0.0403800905,
-0.0128728859,
0.0107091879,
-0.0373565406,
0.004351059,
0.0357816592,
0.030766625,
-0.0129638873,
-0.0315850526,
-0.0116006015,
0.033762224,
0.069180876,
0.0374414064,
-0.0280856546,
0.0272535235,
-0.0045322976,
-0.0391173586,
0.0676362067,
0.0031333948,
0.0627763346,
0.0352593586,
-0.0039616087,
0.0284992885,
0.0179575011,
0.0347923115,
0.0080412189,
-0.0710645616,
0.0110578723,
0.0633867458,
0.0159041323,
0.0150057338,
-0.0470598899,
-0.0167292915,
-0.0015265378,
0.0477997437,
0.062254373,
0.0152548905,
-0.0333732739,
-0.0672840774,
-0.0471002348,
-0.0209067687,
-0.0415669754,
-0.0659806654,
0.0296264812,
-0.0440897197,
-0.0314845815,
0.0165331364,
-0.0111634089,
-0.017845653,
-0.0476462245,
-0.001230684,
-0.0157937985,
-0.0111339819,
-0.0015459821,
0.0351202786,
0.0061436822,
0.0343276262,
0.0454282984,
0.0006325268,
-0.0075332117,
-0.0196705386,
-0.0391987637,
-0.0009116912,
-0.0046996702,
0.0157049224,
-0.03484568,
-0.015099545,
-0.0188295301,
0.0728301704,
0.0050743469,
0.0018388659,
-0.0300453231,
0.0247508697,
-0.0101025812,
-0.0653084591,
0.0284432489,
0.0326785333,
-0.0291570108,
0.0181141831,
0.0311362669,
0.0003772843,
-0.0724436268,
0.037717443,
0.0309414193,
0.0489065163,
-0.013411615,
0.0351888239,
0.0547315255,
0.0311237071,
-0.005434515,
0.037000645,
-0.0390592963,
0.0369401611,
-0.006216235,
0.0293943398,
-0.0191651788,
-0.0833586082,
-0.0590232909,
0.0197500251,
-0.0022184015,
-0.0074975239,
-0.0832497254,
-0.0401440077,
-0.0201428607,
-0.0056138318,
0.0141907288,
0.0423738658,
-0.0062882784,
0.0098701082,
-0.0227501187,
0.0070660412,
-0.0629217848,
0.0641208291,
-0.0270232316,
0.0427625515,
0.0037550752,
-0.012800484,
0.0173611715,
0.018522054,
0.0197517965,
-0.0174054224,
-0.0283745378,
0.0191581771,
0.0097648706,
0.0135644879,
-0.0178662892,
-0.0105801905,
-0.0695079938,
-0.0133783333,
-0.0150386579,
-0.0241104141,
0.0201214943,
-0.0050687054,
-0.0169479568,
-0.0170006473,
-0.0102893794,
0.0054075997,
-0.0520421937,
0.0062605157,
0.0205015484,
0.012583496,
-0.0545278899,
0.0280942358,
0.0147880139,
-0.0129852807,
0.0520925298,
0.0139445858,
0.0197836533,
-0.0517633446,
-0.0309416875,
0.011938218,
-0.0299115926,
-0.0174345337,
0.0421743393,
0.0344166942,
-0.0065084621,
-0.0348636881,
0.0938634574,
-0.0200833827,
0.052079726,
0.0372560024,
0.0364114493,
-0.055626791,
-0.0046057156,
-0.0156079615,
0.0144573906,
-0.0397174358,
0.0006460278,
0.0228849743,
0.0221063606,
0.0062990612,
0.0082308454,
-0.0370434783,
0.0131142111,
-0.0111237327,
-0.0358493961,
-0.0811704099,
0.0421712771,
-0.0024513358,
0.0473603234,
-0.0010571595,
-0.0484211929,
0.0589299165,
-0.0053235181,
-0.0071481662,
-0.0305611156,
-0.033927612,
-0.013884603,
-0.0102541829,
-0.0325103737,
0.0138760339,
-0.0024915419,
-0.0283712465,
-0.0304873139,
-0.0139779281,
-0.0196708553,
-0.0088021914,
0.0279420633,
-0.010430539,
-0.004318024,
-0.0227251519,
-0.0419843048,
-0.0510631204,
0.0235354509,
0.0040144147,
0.0250025168,
-0.0244280491,
-0.0230013579,
-0.0345582291,
0.0114562539,
0.0010357389,
0.0674670041,
-0.0193861201,
-0.0367094763,
0.0002212469,
0.0115949474,
-0.022967197,
-0.032455761,
-0.0182366688,
-0.0471475981,
-0.0161716994,
0.0571730696,
0.0463892967,
-0.0355980508,
-0.0210879371,
0.0381037816,
0.0447871238,
-0.0035694859,
0.0107447747,
0.0345983803,
0.0358552635,
-0.0126819815,
-0.0298905224,
0.0837677419,
0.0295205563,
-0.111955896,
-0.008828233,
-0.0169866383,
-0.0021053464,
0.037179891,
-0.0136324493,
-0.0320320092,
-0.0463119484,
0.0052201618,
0.0294026919,
0.031378556,
-0.005570882,
0.0390674099,
-0.045341868,
0.0261332281,
0.0209676605,
-0.1233529598,
-0.0816735923,
-0.0229026936,
0.0061205686,
-0.0088781714,
0.0232338179,
0.0011066088,
-0.0092509901,
-0.0297333021,
0.0440390706,
0.0083503611,
-0.0255718734,
0.0179925133,
-0.041245807,
-0.0253621619,
0.0181945842,
0.0169156976,
0.0219058786,
-0.0480569787,
0.0906134173,
-0.0383787863,
0.0343325809,
-0.0342867635,
-0.0197786521,
-0.0078382418,
0.0211884473,
0.0007824784,
0.0333603695,
-0.0245563723,
-0.0514739044,
0.0048968042,
0.0839877576,
-0.0329715647,
-0.0056801401,
-0.020342432,
-0.0698991492,
0.0325947627,
0.021679895,
0.0030592124,
-0.0685294271,
-0.0107857352,
-0.0289865006,
0.0218673218,
0.032674294,
0.0734269917,
-0.0088115297,
-0.0104845259,
-0.0583734848,
-0.0484028198,
0.0157540869,
0.0269093681,
0.0771774575,
-0.0039783036,
-0.022706775,
-0.0338197425,
0.0103131803,
-0.0598980673,
0.0316139981,
-0.0237579811,
0.0202002339,
-0.0259926599,
0.0228623953,
0.0477568023,
-0.0264998097,
-0.0344847925,
-0.0109717371,
-0.0148608545,
-0.048579853,
0.0075450521,
0.0166773889,
0.0154650826,
0.1043176353,
-0.0083477609,
-0.0295555275,
0.1374409348,
0.0974939466,
0.0200254954,
0.0281860027,
0.0081068547,
0.0180099104,
-0.0324137211,
0.0075840722,
-0.0358561426,
-0.0112863099,
0.0475846045,
-0.0221600663,
-0.0982712656,
-0.0058965096,
0.0177113712,
-0.0717631951,
0.114835076,
-0.0481139719,
-0.0500731394,
-0.0030718106,
0.0366732553,
0.0324879922,
-0.0233188085,
0.0208585989,
-0.0625550821,
0.0491601601,
0.0160543174,
-0.0007772119,
0.0587164871,
0.0451299436,
0.0038635249,
0.0203882009,
-0.0221065097,
0.0162835792,
0.0853991807,
0.0100741936,
0.0191733539,
-0.0100694457,
-0.0022177331,
0.0141899344,
0.0417819917,
-0.0215524733,
0.0384497792,
0.0403897427,
0.0072572441,
-0.0631065369,
0.0509610772,
-0.0555415601,
0.0496041551,
-0.0849827603,
0.0192367546,
0.020270966,
-0.0065825256,
-0.0295143165,
-0.0038012362,
-0.02459912,
-0.0224561151,
0.0267675333,
-0.0033513107,
-0.0547305048,
0.0135260634,
0.0042929449,
0.0032490951,
0.0143759726,
0.0495629758,
0.0198922269,
-0.0087869475,
-0.0295488443,
0.0192986149,
-0.0416616164,
0.0431857742,
0.0528368019,
0.0175071228,
-0.02162694,
-0.0053028096,
-0.0343605354,
-0.0403278507,
0.0412211046,
-0.0115636634,
0.0089957109,
0.0154557582,
-0.0093931267,
0.0612320937,
-0.0010348269,
-0.0642960742,
-0.0170584302,
-0.0227627009,
0.057003092,
-0.0054805283,
-0.0297070667,
-6.761020328e-33,
-0.0134112872,
-0.0384914726,
-0.0197010562,
-0.0097951377,
0.0397823825,
-0.0188257582,
-0.0098028174,
0.0157447569,
0.0646390393,
-0.0055950698,
-0.0145064564,
-0.0118001746,
0.0241867751,
0.0203594808,
0.0129240938,
-0.0289596617,
0.0298092701,
-0.0047748191,
-0.0397844166,
0.0081798062,
0.0414851978,
0.0181402676,
0.0422213785,
-0.0903469846,
-0.004752208,
0.0253583062,
-0.0358465724,
0.0115502039,
-0.0099356398,
0.0189039707,
-0.0055705886,
0.0117390901,
0.0275701173,
0.006790563,
-0.0049678059,
-0.0202587638,
-0.0749274194,
-0.021394955,
-0.0335376598,
0.0821359381,
0.0503995828,
-0.0325087868,
0.0631730855,
0.0187814888,
-0.0733737126,
-0.0015462594,
0.0322549827,
-0.0491846055,
-0.0491414368,
-0.038439732,
-0.0147586819,
-0.0045469464,
-0.0142811062,
-0.0054089865,
-0.0004530429,
0.0425057076,
0.0253363959,
0.0432737656,
-0.1243015081,
0.0195677411,
-0.0613186657,
-0.0122261681,
0.0702526793,
0.0887730047,
-0.0007688437,
0.0569940917,
0.0542945452,
-0.0069650109,
0.0024186436,
-0.0540319383,
0.0594456345,
0.0327611938,
0.0112076038,
0.0441477187,
0.0965201631,
-0.0477187932,
-0.0581651442,
0.062656194,
-0.0454630926,
-0.019514095,
0.0259483848,
0.0454417691,
-0.0797694698,
-0.0338190608,
-0.0119343791,
-0.0631801113,
-0.0387142785,
0.0275073964,
0.0521032885,
0.0627264455,
-0.0385700651,
0.0178337377,
0.0200659614,
-0.0419391692,
-0.0350208543,
-0.0108168395,
0.0464918502,
0.0320728645,
0.0046614138,
-0.0348265693,
-0.01011639,
-0.0704017133,
0.0263686813,
-0.0032406617,
0.0397606567,
-0.0217323191,
0.0723918974,
-0.0012486116,
-0.0437768213,
-0.00876904,
0.0002219713,
-0.0101694986,
0.0249620266,
-0.0097339246,
0.0460956693,
-0.0081548421,
-0.0117008537,
0.0541737154,
0.0030523243,
0.0056795948,
0.0014182983,
-0.0042156912,
-0.0380780511,
0.0265139826,
-0.0187981073,
-0.020506857,
0.0001935055,
-0.0200653803,
0.0205403976,
-0.0468795523,
-0.0115574552,
0.0035268851,
2.924e-7,
0.0383555628,
0.0365133807,
-0.0111262146,
-0.0591756515,
0.0328989178,
0.0615638606,
-0.0564068444,
0.0024883945,
0.0319463834,
-0.0175141152,
0.0171485487,
0.0069935587,
0.0343840122,
0.0588327311,
-0.0661315247,
0.0205057468,
0.024123989,
0.0512002744,
-0.0291659031,
0.0366513915,
-0.0135962386,
0.080889143,
0.0172014441,
-0.0450308025,
0.03857347,
-0.0304117668,
0.029304171,
-0.0464230031,
0.0913416743,
-0.0135704279,
-0.0230858382,
0.0165964924,
0.0244605523,
0.03956021,
-0.0088914419,
0.026797168,
-0.0059816996,
0.026364442,
-0.0231194943,
-0.051611077,
-0.0239229556,
0.0314665437,
0.0440166369,
-0.0777639151,
0.0507914759,
-0.0762519836,
0.0346968658,
-0.0277195815,
-0.0255646966,
-0.0045556375,
0.0394297093,
0.0322968774,
-0.0077976245,
0.0215677619,
0.0015905927,
0.0210678689,
-0.0050140773,
-0.0587350689,
-0.0632357821,
0.0138673177,
-0.0566084981,
-0.0290820971,
0.0248971879,
0.0545837991,
0.0349221937,
0.0177152138,
-0.0063953516,
2.80680707e-34,
-0.008827325,
-0.0248121005,
0.0321078226,
0.0264376383,
-0.0250491537,
-0.0203616899,
-0.0057058102,
0.0001111839,
0.0402563289,
-0.0162177198,
0.0105058821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16529v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16529v1 | Towards Better Graph-based Cross-document Relation Extraction via Non-bridge Entity Enhancement and Prediction Debiasing | 2024-06-24T11:08:28 | 2024-06-24T11:08:28 | Hao Yue, Shaopeng Lai, Chengyi Yang, Liang Zhang, Junfeng Yao, Jinsong Su | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-document Relation Extraction aims to predict the relation between
target entities located in different documents. In this regard, the dominant
models commonly retain useful information for relation prediction via bridge
entities, which allows the model to elaborately capture the intrinsic
interdependence between target entities. However, these studies ignore the
non-bridge entities, each of which co-occurs with only one target entity and
offers the semantic association between target entities for relation
prediction. Besides, the commonly-used dataset--CodRED contains substantial NA
instances, leading to the prediction bias during inference. To address these
issues, in this paper, we propose a novel graph-based cross-document RE model
with non-bridge entity enhancement and prediction debiasing. Specifically, we
use a unified entity graph to integrate numerous non-bridge entities with
target entities and bridge entities, modeling various associations between
them, and then use a graph recurrent network to encode this graph. Finally, we
introduce a novel debiasing strategy to calibrate the original prediction
distribution. Experimental results on the closed and open settings show that
our model significantly outperforms all baselines, including the GPT-3.5-turbo
and InstructUIE, achieving state-of-the-art performance. Particularly, our
model obtains 66.23% and 55.87% AUC points in the official
leaderboard\footnote{\url{https://codalab.lisn.upsaclay.fr/competitions/3770#results}}
under the two settings, respectively, ranking the first place in all
submissions since December 2023. Our code is available at
https://github.com/DeepLearnXMU/CoRE-NEPD. | [
0.0135760363,
0.0240324773,
0.0264534261,
0.0692233145,
0.0000973428,
-0.0191244669,
-0.0245305337,
-0.028931478,
0.0290261041,
-0.0157306865,
-0.0323512666,
0.0132539207,
-0.0116262957,
0.0184484627,
0.0032291024,
-0.0315652825,
0.0210075565,
0.0177922938,
0.0168636143,
-0.0077586514,
-0.0049602999,
0.0483656004,
0.0166559368,
-0.029227661,
-0.0209983755,
-0.0268102717,
0.0093918154,
0.0376206599,
0.0181838386,
-0.0532137156,
0.0269871149,
0.0172177665,
0.0174861606,
0.0070256339,
0.0000020371,
-0.0537768267,
-0.0474255644,
0.0175337959,
-0.0221873689,
-0.0325671472,
-0.0106886439,
-0.0582420565,
0.0289553571,
-0.0148996385,
-0.0133445906,
-0.0834055468,
0.0176497009,
0.0751190707,
-0.0050957594,
0.0884948075,
-0.0412197411,
-0.0291456357,
0.042381037,
-0.056562379,
0.017574368,
-0.0570032299,
0.0314055979,
0.0016703389,
-0.0112214973,
-0.0079108095,
-0.0510743633,
0.0020415329,
0.0273857433,
-0.0161793921,
0.0422457792,
0.0420812927,
0.007480463,
0.0184710082,
0.0260551423,
0.0960395932,
-0.013115623,
0.011211711,
0.0372290276,
0.0111443447,
-0.0004885513,
0.0442075953,
-0.0384871364,
-0.0464314595,
-0.0237364247,
0.004130349,
0.0214973781,
0.0026977924,
0.0759988427,
0.0204262622,
0.0116399163,
0.031987723,
0.0112539185,
-0.0179216079,
0.0458681807,
0.0474122614,
0.0247198939,
-0.0345889181,
0.0235791225,
0.0231494904,
-0.0053410488,
0.0170331039,
-0.0364314206,
-0.0035379026,
-0.0067917155,
-0.0118195247,
-0.0045303358,
-0.0356343873,
-0.0100227008,
0.0627081841,
-0.0500162579,
-0.0132531971,
-0.0531128943,
-0.0040445812,
0.0025826183,
-0.0317778029,
-0.0168218426,
0.0216351859,
-0.0162167288,
0.0509529635,
-0.00344624,
-0.0162897296,
-0.0484452844,
-0.0186547693,
0.0023006953,
0.0116874753,
0.0240305681,
0.0341150314,
-0.0400282852,
-0.0323886313,
-0.0046026045,
0.0328682996,
-0.0236537457,
-0.0027696739,
-0.0374421328,
-0.016786823,
-0.0045174123,
-0.0389174744,
0.0481080115,
-0.0536100417,
0.0238670669,
0.068658188,
0.0280974582,
-0.0345568508,
-0.0280362032,
-0.0473477095,
0.0330468491,
-0.077826038,
0.0516282618,
-0.0370494165,
0.0554164089,
0.0147934938,
-0.0096160714,
-0.0239587333,
0.0269095004,
-0.0381378569,
-0.0733694434,
0.0344223753,
0.0008863368,
-0.0195717085,
0.0141507778,
-0.0032244162,
0.0207152069,
0.0596461967,
0.0471990258,
0.0127165746,
0.0450962596,
0.0356254764,
-0.0130295698,
0.0202972051,
0.0507052392,
-0.0388856903,
0.0496049188,
-0.0047296206,
-0.0148473326,
0.0082910443,
0.084376052,
0.025597807,
-0.0421596095,
-0.0661829859,
0.0130776642,
-0.0327786729,
0.0196100194,
0.0489640795,
0.0290727261,
-0.0132496916,
-0.0167993996,
0.0152882384,
-0.0651488006,
0.0261420403,
-0.0018601537,
0.0496268682,
-0.0010317449,
0.0202640966,
-0.0137874046,
0.0149686905,
0.0501692332,
-0.0343815796,
0.0059277122,
-0.0056820679,
0.0833666995,
0.0214154851,
-0.0643782392,
0.0395259038,
0.0403083898,
-0.0276856143,
0.013110606,
0.0376124121,
0.0123795727,
0.0161130112,
0.0585741401,
-0.0063134958,
-0.0671228617,
-0.0257339031,
-0.0321775824,
0.0262619779,
0.0431228094,
-0.0425672308,
0.0573575646,
-0.0479269736,
-0.0649633706,
-0.038498491,
-0.0142783904,
0.0473172441,
0.0599766858,
0.0276734177,
0.0503147282,
-0.0693552718,
0.008538329,
0.0101902522,
-0.0379569903,
-0.0239580981,
0.0048490921,
0.0305751823,
-0.0089205932,
0.0391791537,
-0.0067391251,
-0.0047786087,
0.0396187827,
-0.0173929706,
-0.0086905276,
-0.0109703839,
-0.0461573042,
-0.0276241712,
0.0350124724,
-0.0671834275,
-0.0289986338,
0.0108260503,
-0.0230658744,
-0.0480341949,
0.033724647,
0.0094065359,
0.0633570924,
-0.0018157813,
-0.0195571054,
0.0354469232,
0.020998707,
0.0462701693,
0.0706869364,
-0.0102096414,
-0.0156102413,
0.010730559,
-0.0193820726,
-0.0028304339,
-0.0089965295,
-0.0306468084,
0.0177454241,
0.0214957967,
-0.0323282257,
0.0301846899,
-0.009924504,
-0.0603649653,
-0.0179698523,
-0.0651282892,
0.0199825875,
0.0207910091,
0.030710822,
-0.0130052958,
0.0392163843,
-0.0010285627,
-0.0361005738,
-0.0450664088,
-0.0146324132,
-0.025525894,
0.0078228265,
0.0374309793,
-0.0029076191,
0.0007909343,
-0.0316365995,
-0.0326898545,
-0.0206867121,
0.0539655536,
0.0129189743,
-0.035670951,
0.0418566987,
0.0574384183,
-0.0359717607,
0.0422659889,
-0.0227416269,
0.0457812361,
-0.0398036391,
0.0092848549,
0.0223010462,
0.0243886989,
-0.0532070212,
0.0169614106,
-0.0342127234,
-0.0317507274,
-0.029856557,
0.0253279284,
-0.0267861914,
0.0322965942,
-0.0071949745,
-0.0316833034,
-0.0530468561,
0.0315614864,
-0.0238594897,
-0.0064868941,
-0.0084724827,
-0.0283690281,
0.028308047,
0.0051999595,
0.0110765407,
-0.0165299252,
0.0376844667,
-0.0421078652,
-0.0611863658,
-0.004179596,
0.0663140193,
-0.0141520705,
-0.0044958196,
-0.0037234379,
0.0219661631,
-0.0604381636,
0.0616606399,
0.0008037604,
-0.0103328936,
0.019839121,
-0.0382456705,
-0.0420032591,
-0.0219350401,
0.0367126167,
-0.0208345372,
0.0180638582,
0.0121426154,
0.0403865278,
-0.0072772801,
-0.0290526673,
-0.0172098316,
0.0230758507,
-0.0174607877,
0.0210046936,
-0.0057906597,
-0.0040374412,
0.0038251691,
0.0056066383,
-0.0138262343,
0.0186858997,
-0.0568557978,
-0.0111571644,
-0.0009501487,
0.0956449732,
0.0847388133,
-0.0320830308,
-0.0060285926,
-0.024088297,
-0.0088904761,
0.0488676205,
0.0025471319,
-0.0060043498,
-0.0224600229,
0.0075459848,
-0.0465516523,
-0.0215598904,
-0.0162715968,
-0.0571695194,
-0.000750115,
-0.0787368491,
0.0081025464,
0.0792969838,
-0.005639784,
-0.0363267101,
-0.0150486697,
0.0307017155,
0.0036105048,
0.0233396273,
0.0028998037,
-0.0705343932,
-0.0206355955,
-0.0188881047,
-0.0223328024,
0.0469035022,
-0.0797207132,
0.007521512,
-0.0976226404,
-0.0134168128,
0.0120527213,
-0.0117496382,
-0.0128106708,
-0.0720366091,
0.0053715059,
-0.0300733373,
-0.0108232209,
-0.0187425315,
-0.0116841756,
-0.0040317765,
-0.0100663882,
0.0089096008,
-0.0361014754,
0.0059445901,
-0.0451428778,
0.0120817777,
0.0181813594,
0.0427337028,
-0.0124265319,
0.0229704939,
0.0333992057,
-0.0411181748,
-0.0320323408,
-0.0215749275,
0.1025493592,
-0.0723126903,
0.0165171977,
-0.0103058591,
0.0210507978,
-0.0423322991,
0.0221392475,
-0.012545675,
0.0877894312,
0.0367065743,
-0.0305825304,
-0.0260199979,
-0.029227756,
-0.0100676529,
0.0276313219,
-0.00770484,
0.0147681255,
-0.0572198071,
0.0051151188,
0.022982521,
-0.0319847539,
0.0346588008,
-0.0276288707,
-0.056908071,
-0.0131068695,
-0.0452707559,
-0.112217024,
0.0272830371,
-0.0008885339,
-0.0155420098,
0.0228000209,
0.0040020165,
-0.003394319,
-0.0571923442,
0.0067598997,
-0.0165421553,
0.021361148,
0.0319989584,
0.0190854147,
0.0236318577,
-0.0013006059,
-0.0098593747,
0.0112746619,
-0.0393588133,
-0.0586993806,
-0.0384010151,
-0.0027659358,
0.0170461796,
0.1103764847,
-0.0198755991,
-0.0180490632,
0.0607681535,
0.0295808073,
-0.0400733165,
-0.0181984287,
0.0375867896,
-0.0056919619,
-0.0017435777,
0.0401738994,
-0.0764244124,
0.0255293231,
0.019445071,
0.0297655631,
-0.0167991333,
-0.0488002263,
-0.0082079824,
0.0108038196,
0.0312600359,
0.013088854,
0.0581390485,
-0.0853765309,
0.0241946969,
-0.0396483131,
0.0103595341,
-0.0073833438,
0.0371028744,
0.030890815,
0.0059228241,
-0.0114709008,
-0.0160083883,
0.0062335143,
0.0401885621,
-0.0287337527,
-0.0143230157,
0.0225810222,
0.0139332078,
0.0012694707,
-0.0103700226,
-0.0056756982,
0.0241598822,
0.0481793471,
0.0302106757,
-0.0316249318,
-0.0002894763,
0.0106628211,
-0.0046598474,
-0.0286005158,
-0.0258329064,
-0.0602540784,
0.069783017,
-0.0521057844,
0.0420581102,
0.0454916842,
-0.0183646511,
0.0620878488,
-0.0058795596,
0.0059171203,
0.0022487075,
0.0407805592,
0.0007209437,
0.005124351,
0.032652501,
0.0220730118,
-0.014021947,
0.0784898922,
0.0739249289,
-0.0028050137,
0.0607173741,
0.0239732713,
-0.0323961526,
-0.0552997477,
-0.0167281535,
0.0359999351,
0.0107409498,
-0.0212203898,
0.0044718813,
-0.034124881,
-0.0689337999,
0.047222361,
-0.0190191548,
0.0026404532,
0.0070046564,
0.0036397756,
0.020367559,
0.0316234529,
-0.0408453718,
-0.023882471,
0.0428345315,
-0.0560377575,
-0.033728715,
-0.0039344002,
-5.986373959e-33,
-0.0314894728,
-0.0083224904,
0.0040273946,
0.0066125998,
-0.0798249692,
0.0539535731,
-0.0663897097,
-0.0557487942,
-0.0338570699,
0.0482041389,
-0.0302132219,
0.0257236306,
0.0100957369,
0.0075274599,
-0.0409088247,
-0.0252583642,
0.0353568718,
0.0253143683,
0.023899531,
0.0610244311,
0.0122870849,
0.0731771365,
0.0758386701,
-0.1113946065,
0.0518955179,
-0.0408449993,
-0.0031123476,
-0.0128821889,
0.0614352971,
0.0344168842,
-0.0418254919,
0.0168297719,
0.0291577987,
-0.0085275993,
0.0131406356,
0.0052690939,
-0.1386238933,
-0.0290376619,
-0.0353261456,
-0.0107354186,
-0.0530614778,
-0.0125945779,
0.023418013,
0.0313743539,
0.0659466088,
-0.0711488351,
0.0368765742,
-0.0063175401,
-0.0441918001,
-0.0531413145,
-0.0346610174,
0.0476415455,
0.0137584545,
0.0048993379,
0.0288043246,
-0.0046402337,
0.0396251567,
0.0015839781,
-0.059466552,
-0.0289768726,
-0.0074822633,
-0.0064372546,
0.0040447302,
-0.0254110433,
-0.006073833,
0.0447308458,
0.0182830784,
-0.0038208419,
0.0245517828,
0.010294768,
0.00385721,
0.039414119,
-0.0432138033,
0.038593173,
0.0204465259,
-0.0226533208,
-0.1127499044,
0.0497461818,
0.0329135209,
0.0513011701,
-0.0250610746,
0.0067448141,
-0.0286172088,
-0.0139484452,
0.0200255141,
-0.0649150312,
0.0050953492,
-0.0534870028,
-0.0172077417,
0.0109441169,
-0.0198998433,
0.0417406298,
-0.0067119692,
-0.0534559973,
-0.0555204712,
0.0694726184,
0.0033690417,
-0.0027568538,
0.0060187667,
-0.0014410831,
-0.0460634828,
-0.0109830303,
0.0050937417,
-0.0088778306,
0.0072610998,
0.0170595497,
0.0643773898,
-0.0132348519,
-0.0570663735,
-0.0297056492,
-0.0403461307,
-0.0016909839,
-0.0141716758,
0.0347307511,
0.0115458826,
0.0225102361,
-0.008659278,
0.0331928693,
0.0737037435,
0.0691160932,
-0.0113866497,
0.0382727906,
0.0354627967,
0.0381217189,
0.0052624517,
-0.0290528033,
0.0130637297,
-0.0178063679,
0.0326709375,
-0.0668559074,
-0.0259236246,
-0.0118349353,
2.76e-7,
0.0184240062,
0.0022873138,
0.0951500908,
-0.0067996001,
0.01232161,
0.031927634,
0.0138676707,
0.0750905499,
0.0025949581,
-0.0312086977,
0.0293191224,
-0.0124494378,
0.0178887639,
0.0361767039,
-0.0876617953,
0.0048669204,
-0.04906822,
-0.0562271141,
-0.0262969583,
-0.019165162,
-0.0134051424,
0.0475119948,
0.0356112793,
-0.0172616616,
-0.030818088,
-0.0170860514,
0.0539144613,
-0.0263128709,
-0.0269103833,
0.0260871816,
0.0232001524,
0.0086209746,
-0.0384457782,
0.0231688395,
-0.0200866554,
0.0943344533,
0.0218741298,
0.044584468,
-0.0190735683,
0.0166748818,
0.0147823067,
-0.0398902744,
0.0115804188,
-0.0015573021,
0.0665267333,
-0.025342036,
-0.0134704094,
-0.0215508845,
-0.0587005019,
0.0206436906,
0.0245477129,
0.0214459971,
-0.0208691955,
0.0311243646,
0.0204906221,
-0.0217771921,
-0.0086780414,
-0.0523703806,
0.0164347123,
0.0561066568,
0.005233861,
-0.0172624681,
0.0351306237,
0.0002620625,
0.0112631945,
-0.0211465228,
0.0154870581,
2.415785991e-34,
0.0133386338,
-0.0027538617,
-0.0054055946,
0.0052296622,
0.044928398,
-0.0548745841,
-0.0881837383,
-0.0041078017,
0.005946782,
-0.0576619543,
-0.0102724107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16528v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16528v1 | Evaluating the Ability of Large Language Models to Reason about Cardinal Directions | 2024-06-24T11:07:01 | 2024-06-24T11:07:01 | Anthony G Cohn, Robert E Blackwell | cs.CL | cs.CL | We investigate the abilities of a representative set of Large language Models
(LLMs) to reason about cardinal directions (CDs). To do so, we create two
datasets: the first, co-created with ChatGPT, focuses largely on recall of
world knowledge about CDs; the second is generated from a set of templates,
comprehensively testing an LLM's ability to determine the correct CD given a
particular scenario. The templates allow for a number of degrees of variation
such as means of locomotion of the agent involved, and whether set in the first
, second or third person. Even with a temperature setting of zero, Our
experiments show that although LLMs are able to perform well in the simpler
dataset, in the second more complex dataset no LLM is able to reliably
determine the correct CD, even with a temperature setting of zero. | [
0.0140125798,
0.0480229147,
-0.0247537307,
0.0342497528,
-0.049441848,
0.0443974771,
0.0033206583,
-0.005961353,
0.0083967661,
-0.0334733911,
-0.0186310112,
-0.0906778276,
0.0196060929,
-0.0273033939,
0.0322036818,
-0.0295192301,
0.0149027538,
-0.080044806,
-0.0154366568,
-0.0205008108,
-0.064296037,
-0.039909523,
-0.0071784616,
0.0179468319,
0.0038700441,
-0.0039796657,
0.0077548921,
-0.0093853483,
0.0132623697,
-0.0253011119,
-0.0514116287,
-0.0163143668,
0.0779518485,
0.0250616893,
0.0000017012,
-0.0312234256,
0.0170132481,
-0.0070618866,
-0.0177236628,
-0.0297812615,
0.0117147025,
-0.0348049067,
-0.0034430732,
-0.0091820229,
-0.0303541422,
-0.0187785253,
0.0390821621,
0.0287231747,
0.0112210866,
0.0960532501,
0.0172119811,
-0.0835968554,
-0.0018116444,
-0.0035837276,
0.0140733374,
-0.0347646587,
0.0438729711,
0.0461172834,
0.0020203318,
0.0217961874,
-0.0215699971,
0.05534821,
0.0245901551,
0.0277015902,
-0.0469729938,
0.074630484,
0.0096962824,
-0.0127182798,
0.0183257684,
0.0508453585,
0.009678713,
-0.0196712501,
0.0186500289,
0.0024169357,
-0.0109534692,
0.0290931985,
-0.0473464653,
0.0746373236,
0.0226712525,
0.0316511057,
0.0186530184,
0.0251213294,
0.0506235883,
-0.0121294316,
-0.0714343637,
0.1204952076,
0.0025280858,
-0.0289421696,
-0.0094016595,
-0.000808086,
-0.0201124735,
-0.0603084341,
-0.0431830063,
0.0391521938,
-0.0264781639,
0.0462002754,
0.0227936395,
0.0630645528,
-0.0025344219,
-0.0714768022,
0.0823022425,
0.0272723585,
-0.0020616876,
0.0358781181,
-0.0105156414,
0.0743346512,
-0.0389454253,
0.0231853388,
-0.0292598512,
-0.0233239979,
-0.0344720744,
-0.0110950582,
0.0003919736,
-0.0045114774,
0.0320910998,
0.0070351283,
-0.0528875999,
0.0125061357,
0.0255461317,
0.057955794,
-0.0075307386,
-0.0038440661,
0.0261770952,
-0.0361164771,
-0.0221311599,
0.0054195425,
-0.0492316112,
0.0353426225,
-0.0152587304,
-0.0193530563,
0.0228152759,
0.0182691589,
-0.035691645,
-0.0231508762,
-0.0036990819,
0.0960662365,
0.046932783,
0.002239482,
-0.0226822719,
-0.0131342728,
-0.0364048295,
-0.0980567932,
0.0021825098,
-0.076087296,
0.016188439,
0.0356536098,
0.0010127806,
-0.0397488736,
0.0260335207,
-0.0156156486,
-0.0575796366,
0.0596043319,
0.0401023179,
0.0443235077,
0.0330130197,
0.0010600785,
0.0164493583,
0.0817290321,
0.0494624265,
0.0029052717,
0.0463358089,
-0.019271886,
0.0168478116,
0.0087306835,
-0.0190050155,
0.0211682077,
-0.0368090644,
0.0241007693,
0.0378430709,
0.0598928854,
0.001933165,
0.0531813651,
-0.0188816804,
-0.0530671664,
0.0573219024,
0.0722274184,
0.0112450365,
-0.0281765256,
0.0392185561,
-0.0330387205,
-0.0079198657,
0.021158997,
-0.050732296,
0.0031311314,
-0.019806616,
-0.0053876052,
0.026935501,
-0.0039650914,
-0.0480303057,
-0.0426713079,
-0.0477452837,
-0.0133538302,
-0.0263408758,
0.0011905122,
0.0647961572,
-0.0714187771,
0.0273240656,
-0.0075803013,
0.0131286616,
-0.0511632487,
-0.0176500361,
0.0132357404,
0.0139731523,
0.0236237217,
-0.0123380888,
-0.0257366858,
-0.0169362929,
0.0308852717,
0.0101418979,
0.0055454513,
0.0485095978,
0.0256728828,
-0.0026698706,
-0.0477334149,
0.0017043567,
0.0324239284,
0.0323538706,
0.0278950203,
-0.0294582732,
0.0199831184,
0.0046834201,
-0.0310634747,
0.0175698344,
0.0424280763,
-0.0438825935,
-0.0108745713,
-0.0115502467,
-0.0103767412,
0.0290331375,
-0.0179687422,
-0.0193636622,
0.0092645548,
0.0333926454,
-0.0356671624,
-0.0523642711,
0.0645069852,
-0.0616254285,
-0.0315896198,
0.0470875315,
-0.0251792055,
-0.0143545857,
-0.0278176218,
-0.0110201268,
-0.0528048091,
0.0263509378,
-0.0242699943,
0.0330439694,
-0.0196945816,
0.0211382452,
0.0038151431,
-0.0229057986,
-0.0172746014,
0.0959050879,
-0.0072086384,
0.0603804588,
0.0255144574,
-0.0231286902,
0.0287785865,
-0.0596222319,
-0.0008889305,
0.0062532132,
0.0163510069,
0.0088248551,
0.0068836091,
-0.0354337543,
-0.0106594618,
-0.0341824517,
-0.0189948976,
0.0045516803,
-0.0103211086,
0.0222838093,
0.0047776555,
-0.0519726425,
-0.0110065388,
0.0053609712,
-0.0567770824,
0.0236794092,
0.0247940049,
0.0294780731,
0.0427396297,
-0.0026446953,
-0.0230196621,
-0.0025658808,
0.0085738283,
-0.0381672718,
0.0455963276,
0.0184573028,
0.0094358008,
-0.0555558093,
0.0609367713,
-0.0309321173,
0.0379926302,
-0.055882033,
-0.0272395834,
0.0318202004,
-0.0227039438,
-0.0040807747,
0.0405462012,
-0.0097542852,
-0.0106497379,
0.0949613079,
-0.0181271899,
-0.040733546,
-0.0339254439,
-0.0347343199,
-0.0279947761,
-0.0627157092,
-0.0706210956,
-0.0144067667,
0.0623581596,
0.018055601,
-0.0149362739,
-0.0183433592,
0.0163099691,
-0.0186450873,
-0.0228702519,
-0.0436848998,
0.0240889341,
-0.008995872,
0.0876014903,
0.0132446848,
-0.0311744921,
0.0478567593,
-0.0339102782,
-0.0089425892,
0.0182778798,
0.0057151942,
-0.0461294651,
0.062242534,
0.001797976,
0.0005664669,
-0.0246248823,
0.0008115435,
-0.0446598306,
-0.0458194725,
0.0228986572,
0.0031040446,
0.0133450031,
-0.0728265047,
0.0274770707,
-0.029378552,
-0.0307067577,
-0.0409064703,
-0.0377416089,
-0.0296631455,
0.0170275513,
-0.0208268594,
-0.0484627895,
-0.046860911,
0.0324472561,
0.0637118295,
-0.0077718766,
-0.0013894209,
0.0031874652,
-0.0148282116,
-0.0102007287,
0.0469661728,
0.0492032319,
0.034707617,
-0.0618394874,
0.0397216231,
0.0423019603,
0.0028799351,
0.0356779024,
-0.0269514173,
0.0130520342,
0.0215306971,
0.0058640572,
-0.0507492423,
0.0303578209,
0.049085319,
-0.0405175537,
-0.0199733842,
0.1363828182,
0.0385565236,
-0.0510458723,
0.0074614766,
-0.0235346444,
-0.0251502413,
0.0119413286,
-0.0047468063,
-0.0757509246,
-0.0191773809,
-0.008873242,
0.0086537153,
-0.0271489583,
-0.0472800024,
0.0077892859,
-0.1116100103,
0.0203359742,
0.0306227691,
-0.0339999609,
-0.0244641285,
-0.045578178,
0.0010361612,
-0.0093840687,
-0.00880739,
-0.0101316096,
0.0011526285,
-0.0085092848,
0.0013653873,
-0.0293752439,
-0.038311094,
0.0273110233,
-0.0279597435,
0.0660302117,
0.016132459,
0.0471276827,
-0.0207241625,
-0.0515924171,
-0.0148030594,
-0.0173496809,
0.0040862611,
0.0108837085,
-0.0268443264,
0.0175865553,
-0.0125985835,
0.0294601545,
0.0122087076,
-0.060046602,
0.0031724281,
0.0183828361,
0.0781822652,
-0.0564377978,
-0.0401862934,
0.0147559159,
0.0220538992,
-0.0191631168,
0.1138997078,
0.0093210181,
0.0144930463,
-0.0342069045,
-0.0506082997,
-0.0132883983,
0.0214500856,
-0.0567699261,
0.0065921983,
0.0170373134,
-0.0620276518,
-0.0775257722,
0.013074859,
0.015368795,
0.0440494008,
0.005636286,
-0.0032297466,
0.0274461005,
-0.0219539516,
-0.0081289615,
-0.0104132816,
-0.0526270717,
0.0172884166,
-0.0516561903,
0.0001868504,
0.0669331402,
-0.0280352421,
-0.0172980148,
0.02286149,
-0.0217215493,
-0.1155551523,
0.0182185192,
0.0211567171,
0.0350129083,
0.0309101604,
-0.001574888,
-0.0381978787,
-0.0070198304,
0.0515663959,
-0.0223106556,
0.0416758582,
0.0064623645,
0.048225835,
0.0156747326,
0.037835706,
-0.0120090824,
0.0266629737,
0.0208800994,
0.0097244643,
-0.0986152813,
-0.0590749495,
-0.0025743495,
-0.0043899026,
0.0098159872,
0.0079473136,
-0.0181758255,
0.0059744688,
0.0236949231,
-0.0514372885,
-0.0267709419,
-0.0171252247,
0.0012167189,
0.0513130724,
0.0066749067,
-0.0113322511,
-0.0217587259,
-0.0234879144,
0.0015747192,
-0.010417589,
0.0068308902,
0.0706727803,
0.0533696003,
-0.0154359043,
-0.0028712826,
-0.0024233595,
0.0486421324,
-0.0011323923,
0.0673324987,
0.0325482786,
0.0321202837,
0.0322788842,
0.0089498656,
-0.0378467329,
0.0034098057,
-0.1070661023,
-0.0982382894,
0.0595262758,
0.0090900501,
0.0766594186,
0.015249732,
0.011838234,
-0.0591350608,
0.0175856892,
-0.0046810117,
0.033476647,
0.0465116873,
-0.0081720855,
0.0351812206,
0.0184432529,
-0.05474931,
0.0232728533,
0.0641769692,
0.0201739259,
0.0376652591,
0.0230104383,
-0.0442363806,
-0.0018287569,
0.0043693865,
-0.0075558154,
-0.0264610704,
-0.0179517586,
0.0291884542,
-0.0756003112,
-0.067491293,
-0.0166397952,
0.0434760451,
-0.0159719456,
0.010803964,
0.0069439989,
0.0394315794,
0.0123963133,
-0.0141775059,
-0.0342711657,
0.0197604317,
-0.0347139314,
0.0080529535,
-0.0565344878,
-5.641194451e-33,
-0.0387242325,
-0.0136357201,
0.0501969941,
-0.0531759597,
0.0229933113,
-0.0294773262,
-0.0209625773,
0.0353188664,
-0.0589897409,
0.0052216123,
0.0107244849,
0.0017074241,
0.0154762054,
-0.0057844701,
0.0141878091,
-0.0104065863,
-0.00681426,
0.0111158676,
-0.0252719317,
-0.0099342791,
0.0979812443,
-0.0160397422,
0.0588076115,
-0.0668091327,
0.0109887123,
-0.0180500057,
0.0083066914,
0.0476032086,
-0.0468571782,
0.0132156396,
-0.0405891612,
0.0091942102,
0.0078235939,
0.0113644088,
-0.0331582576,
0.0092343204,
-0.0087860776,
-0.045916196,
0.0343631431,
0.0154634044,
0.0150083657,
-0.0473961271,
0.0181804188,
-0.0072224685,
-0.024208162,
0.0357462689,
0.0262070186,
-0.0259001739,
-0.022644408,
0.0200299118,
-0.0086767804,
0.0375541635,
-0.0073152748,
-0.0251989048,
-0.0131238028,
-0.0180773046,
-0.0326746888,
-0.0042343903,
-0.0362011008,
0.0349004082,
0.0477533303,
0.0066403979,
0.0341742449,
0.0227261242,
0.0456198528,
0.0701131523,
0.0553614758,
0.0236167256,
-0.0488792062,
-0.0551326349,
0.025734121,
0.0439268276,
0.0268070679,
0.0520344228,
-0.0069433614,
0.0116220377,
-0.0600911453,
0.003504883,
0.0211102087,
0.0064775716,
0.0517067052,
0.0019437481,
-0.0450655073,
-0.0351950787,
-0.0268778894,
-0.014031956,
-0.0130048627,
0.0182420798,
0.0151209198,
-0.0342269577,
0.0326143131,
-0.0396557115,
0.0481956042,
-0.04777072,
-0.016275553,
0.0166454371,
0.0102829868,
0.0182076208,
0.030478932,
0.0258408971,
-0.0601769127,
-0.0408559069,
-0.025051292,
0.0253670141,
0.0101630138,
0.0193285644,
0.009498788,
-0.0043451055,
-0.0266233105,
-0.0260380525,
-0.028671775,
-0.0560122095,
-0.0091481153,
-0.0211718082,
0.0244778357,
-0.0012088654,
-0.015858531,
0.0219414644,
-0.0233583637,
-0.0183336623,
0.0043625184,
0.014168323,
-0.0280676652,
0.0368607678,
-0.0089961458,
-0.002282029,
-0.0279906746,
0.0453505889,
0.0640227571,
-0.0107892631,
-0.00168555,
0.033927381,
2.593e-7,
0.0562963672,
0.048414737,
0.0156808849,
0.0183940604,
0.0197087899,
0.0412212089,
-0.0758239031,
-0.0287328307,
0.0141408062,
-0.0286794547,
0.0205351133,
0.0406091064,
0.0367200896,
0.049831856,
-0.0303640887,
0.031707827,
-0.0257079676,
-0.0184463374,
-0.0261311512,
0.0162928421,
0.019448014,
0.0650674552,
0.0216119215,
0.0140334256,
0.0116088195,
-0.033613842,
0.0677679479,
-0.0684188753,
0.0133128669,
-0.0124604562,
-0.0074482122,
-0.0023305223,
0.0050310567,
0.013935714,
0.0627319366,
0.0238133557,
-0.0344250277,
0.043457333,
-0.0003432153,
-0.0114203095,
-0.0346383043,
-0.0390745327,
-0.0253183637,
-0.0729033276,
0.0720328242,
-0.0482278056,
-0.0570841618,
-0.0015001864,
0.0037701023,
0.0068158791,
0.0145009523,
0.0198920872,
-0.0023413138,
-0.0032491654,
0.0000973405,
-0.0186908208,
0.0183673371,
-0.0805446208,
-0.0146083189,
0.0128340721,
-0.0625727549,
-0.0611787289,
-0.0064786356,
0.0248896573,
0.0388155803,
-0.0537697561,
-0.0116039189,
2.167929334e-34,
0.0393242389,
0.0147957094,
-0.0370607115,
0.0026527578,
0.0188877229,
-0.005038504,
-0.0100681772,
0.0032798511,
0.034872923,
-0.0747189671,
0.0019774518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16527v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16527v1 | SyROCCo: Enhancing Systematic Reviews using Machine Learning | 2024-06-24T11:04:43 | 2024-06-24T11:04:43 | Zheng Fang, Miguel Arana-Catania, Felix-Anselm van Lier, Juliana Outes Velarde, Harry Bregazzi, Mara Airoldi, Eleanor Carter, Rob Procter | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.DL, cs.LG | The sheer number of research outputs published every year makes systematic
reviewing increasingly time- and resource-intensive. This paper explores the
use of machine learning techniques to help navigate the systematic review
process. ML has previously been used to reliably 'screen' articles for review -
that is, identify relevant articles based on reviewers' inclusion criteria. The
application of ML techniques to subsequent stages of a review, however, such as
data extraction and evidence mapping, is in its infancy. We therefore set out
to develop a series of tools that would assist in the profiling and analysis of
1,952 publications on the theme of 'outcomes-based contracting'. Tools were
developed for the following tasks: assign publications into 'policy area'
categories; identify and extract key information for evidence mapping, such as
organisations, laws, and geographical information; connect the evidence base to
an existing dataset on the same topic; and identify subgroups of articles that
may share thematic content. An interactive tool using these techniques and a
public dataset with their outputs have been released. Our results demonstrate
the utility of ML techniques to enhance evidence accessibility and analysis
within the systematic review processes. These efforts show promise in
potentially yielding substantial efficiencies for future systematic reviewing
and for broadening their analytical scope. Our work suggests that there may be
implications for the ease with which policymakers and practitioners can access
evidence. While ML techniques seem poised to play a significant role in
bridging the gap between research and policy by offering innovative ways of
gathering, accessing, and analysing data from systematic reviews, we also
highlight their current limitations and the need to exercise caution in their
application, particularly given the potential for errors and biases. | [
0.024075238,
0.0284844786,
-0.0118118459,
-0.0548397675,
-0.0191854201,
0.0423971228,
0.0460471325,
0.0219328012,
-0.0332917459,
-0.008707271,
0.0222999062,
0.063868314,
0.0145699224,
0.0908435881,
0.0099304356,
-0.0421962328,
0.0040338524,
0.043490313,
0.0065337047,
0.0159924794,
-0.0426798873,
0.0022859662,
0.0041510398,
0.0545568317,
0.0275187399,
0.0155224707,
-0.001283178,
-0.0021975373,
0.0096004391,
-0.0593151227,
0.0046280725,
0.016989613,
-0.015905831,
0.0399852172,
0.000002276,
-0.0251236651,
-0.0293851253,
0.0324069746,
0.0289881937,
-0.0128986491,
0.0353250913,
-0.0546941273,
0.0273568928,
0.0245838705,
-0.0123270778,
0.0006389436,
0.049718082,
0.0096391495,
-0.0328252353,
-0.0129066808,
-0.0233014543,
0.010282049,
0.0194823984,
-0.0189489517,
0.0174993649,
0.0191193055,
0.0258070696,
-0.0062584113,
0.0176971033,
-0.0202522948,
0.0141860079,
0.0445924252,
-0.0043946989,
0.0041959407,
0.0059185433,
0.0442018695,
-0.0176289175,
-0.0570138246,
0.0033376915,
0.0063537238,
0.0568153746,
0.0057549388,
0.0038976562,
-0.0428791642,
0.0307864007,
0.0412587263,
-0.0255514253,
0.0194781441,
-0.0283168461,
-0.0078549637,
0.0248297788,
0.0366502553,
0.0248110536,
0.0243900046,
-0.0314138792,
0.0131087508,
-0.037766654,
-0.0093019698,
0.0816054568,
0.0612277463,
0.1009333208,
-0.0110789463,
-0.0118485661,
-0.0123083303,
-0.0243157092,
-0.0082767671,
0.0397384167,
0.0306936372,
0.0952643603,
-0.0189093892,
0.0361853577,
-0.0540583469,
-0.0078128502,
0.0265977345,
0.0359047987,
-0.0932025984,
-0.0518582053,
0.0527685806,
-0.0018754263,
0.0393734574,
-0.0319664329,
0.0041066529,
0.0449590459,
-0.0337458923,
-0.0169247948,
0.0127753625,
-0.0391500071,
0.0058529032,
-0.0288193766,
0.0105906241,
-0.0148574794,
0.0456875898,
-0.0149606913,
0.0186814182,
-0.0217268523,
-0.0157012641,
-0.0107551757,
0.0902798325,
-0.0474985167,
0.0240701437,
0.0561910756,
0.0113471663,
0.0338714831,
0.0231349617,
0.0431133769,
0.032396175,
0.039273113,
-0.0274149887,
-0.0066678822,
0.0038797269,
-0.007311136,
-0.0168731213,
0.0384065956,
-0.0675019175,
-0.02761559,
-0.0223788563,
0.0077164029,
-0.0180658456,
-0.0372000113,
-0.0060375547,
-0.0434172302,
0.0088046873,
-0.1129588634,
-0.0144486353,
0.0129886148,
0.0153738577,
-0.0044832486,
0.0070190798,
-0.0040496401,
0.0312040579,
-0.0094194347,
-0.0261128526,
0.0259912852,
-0.0136641199,
-0.0180654712,
0.002672333,
0.0380955413,
0.0069128745,
-0.0504256263,
0.0098447157,
-0.0323027782,
0.0068102772,
-0.0321050584,
0.0296159815,
0.0258760378,
0.023573352,
0.0284401812,
0.0234221593,
-0.0018929132,
-0.0083444742,
0.0073718973,
-0.0407764576,
-0.0012260047,
-0.0152663663,
0.050604254,
-0.0163385458,
-0.0171333309,
0.0143781127,
0.0044515599,
-0.0475744754,
0.0088689281,
0.0044341283,
-0.0196734145,
0.0367163382,
0.0659414157,
0.0107975928,
0.0449335575,
-0.0511210449,
0.0175637938,
0.0666604638,
-0.0154215051,
-0.0224795491,
-0.0151139973,
-0.0021517167,
0.018276237,
-0.0698141679,
-0.0098594781,
-0.0636731759,
-0.0531772785,
0.0039788154,
-0.0139425192,
-0.0066040838,
0.0051905476,
0.0278540105,
-0.0545226596,
-0.0111745838,
-0.0000306348,
0.0154762166,
-0.0074308971,
0.0195777062,
-0.0301931985,
-0.0264530592,
-0.0459295586,
0.0716134012,
-0.0186384134,
0.006583015,
0.0519381799,
-0.0283742473,
0.0465105958,
0.0425090268,
-0.0122733712,
0.0369173214,
0.0354782343,
0.0046558073,
-0.0069137462,
0.0223016683,
0.0609707199,
0.0538227297,
-0.0198167749,
-0.0848653391,
-0.0093177594,
0.0159593355,
-0.0614048317,
0.0304178707,
-0.0413695052,
0.0296244081,
0.0253113639,
0.0202157553,
-0.0289897937,
-0.0077862148,
-0.0135559002,
-0.0039737835,
-0.0037984198,
-0.0096438536,
-0.0297206566,
-0.0193494484,
-0.1244390309,
0.0017478674,
-0.0002470366,
0.0233365782,
0.0119734444,
-0.0414024368,
0.0231609903,
0.0352058411,
0.0281463955,
-0.0054934542,
0.0053786398,
-0.0763873234,
-0.0023642788,
0.0206438713,
-0.0254839249,
0.001878193,
-0.0393611006,
-0.0005184521,
-0.0105089247,
0.007870364,
-0.0514618084,
-0.0023610559,
0.0091560949,
0.03180857,
0.03410808,
0.0222879369,
-0.0508493818,
-0.0512473211,
-0.0229947772,
0.0490287021,
0.062035799,
0.0262661707,
0.0012649465,
-0.0222335216,
0.0081833377,
-0.0282497592,
-0.007288917,
0.0346767716,
0.0160875265,
0.0319164135,
-0.1012135744,
0.0056834794,
-0.0165846087,
0.0213673376,
0.0803149641,
0.0100508481,
-0.0140084783,
0.0014346333,
-0.0176725294,
0.0443140976,
-0.0326009654,
-0.0473476052,
0.0632350668,
-0.0273587573,
-0.0099702058,
0.0246149916,
0.0066271862,
0.0152068092,
0.0233253632,
-0.0443312488,
-0.0810958594,
-0.0322290808,
-0.0060553909,
0.0780675858,
-0.0041992189,
-0.071862191,
0.0303053632,
0.0072274106,
0.0572022982,
-0.080035679,
-0.0120301917,
-0.0382692479,
0.012273944,
0.0028105199,
-0.0007722895,
-0.0134525727,
0.0198263768,
0.0254149642,
-0.0251141321,
0.0296812262,
0.0102819474,
-0.0217695739,
-0.0235138349,
0.0290909745,
0.0008231834,
-0.0295853205,
-0.0179240741,
-0.0601429865,
-0.0143190976,
0.0086598741,
0.0221004505,
0.0011516886,
-0.0804072469,
0.0061120563,
0.0483640954,
0.0535287708,
0.0178738348,
-0.0252066031,
0.0269472972,
-0.0527098067,
0.0226628762,
-0.0682845935,
0.0542639755,
0.0009564657,
-0.0370403752,
0.0128717413,
-0.0198690686,
0.0115632797,
-0.0516201705,
-0.0043758471,
-0.0395727195,
-0.0751220509,
0.0125443758,
0.0123059973,
-0.0278128441,
-0.0316387266,
0.0328183174,
0.0197882913,
0.0124420114,
-0.0996962115,
0.0029299527,
-0.0140214991,
-0.0357895494,
-0.0390048362,
-0.0258491766,
-0.0642235577,
0.0187701676,
0.0180901773,
0.0515905358,
-0.0576393194,
-0.008694998,
0.0026330592,
0.0173481014,
0.0755489394,
-0.0185924154,
-0.0274625905,
-0.0480892882,
-0.0292736404,
0.0258614123,
-0.0697328746,
-0.0562315919,
-0.028610725,
-0.0251171682,
0.0044601136,
0.0060454877,
-0.0702731833,
-0.0493701212,
-0.0051351371,
-0.0190462638,
0.0474477671,
0.0435970053,
0.0034317255,
-0.0276490469,
0.0654147863,
0.0288344119,
-0.0236075521,
-0.0286054574,
0.0190593731,
0.1205308214,
0.0014664241,
0.0422126465,
-0.0326709449,
0.0345702618,
-0.0332846455,
-0.0488358214,
0.0823414028,
0.0541742705,
-0.047743313,
-0.0209998116,
-0.0500994883,
0.0307657439,
-0.0271164402,
0.0194569491,
0.0190424826,
0.0093877194,
0.0050509796,
0.0202220716,
-0.0053837765,
0.0507509299,
0.0069391616,
0.0592555441,
-0.0507998019,
-0.0252359957,
0.0212928317,
-0.0770457461,
0.0411564112,
0.012724191,
-0.0000177194,
0.0339509286,
0.0684098676,
-0.0387175791,
-0.0137069887,
0.058751937,
0.0191949215,
0.0207791533,
-0.0000437505,
-0.014322103,
0.016630752,
0.0296361744,
-0.0042820456,
-0.027442785,
0.0444240458,
-0.0033130478,
-0.0124551021,
0.059669897,
0.0215172283,
0.0067022243,
0.0097176405,
-0.0024274162,
0.0487465039,
0.0261793286,
0.0112471227,
-0.0727843344,
0.0193171091,
-0.0097557018,
-0.0243145227,
-0.0693199411,
-0.006976278,
-0.0012346386,
-0.032234773,
-0.0523829907,
-0.0312993489,
0.0338731036,
0.0361991152,
-0.0218911897,
0.0517466255,
-0.0604902282,
-0.0458087362,
-0.0107008461,
-0.0111390492,
0.0096942084,
0.0031970367,
-0.0407842323,
-0.0038244554,
0.0299620107,
0.0162521265,
-0.0530794039,
0.0150515335,
-0.0755786747,
0.0095201051,
-0.0642826259,
0.122937277,
0.0475201793,
0.0353509896,
0.0211508982,
-0.0295136962,
-0.0146921752,
-0.0212176051,
-0.008858311,
0.033555463,
0.0108912773,
-0.0106906416,
0.0109111052,
0.0063015479,
-0.0097421156,
0.0477456637,
-0.0439944603,
-0.0638670325,
-0.0024045869,
-0.0467871837,
-0.0088311238,
0.0112968683,
-0.0170300361,
-0.0412671641,
-0.0130900396,
-0.0276450589,
-0.0033774921,
-0.0392283797,
0.0323505513,
0.0051150476,
-0.0139206229,
-0.061502289,
-0.0620159432,
0.0392980874,
0.0298003126,
0.0009311239,
-0.0261790827,
-0.0424679331,
-0.0132800443,
-0.0799759328,
0.0145858964,
0.01680783,
-0.0320606865,
-0.0390990749,
-0.0520998649,
-0.0110136913,
-0.0380829908,
-0.0241751391,
0.0216679648,
-0.0024510573,
-0.0726232454,
0.0140085705,
0.0370086543,
-0.0385148562,
-0.0395923033,
0.0079634152,
-0.0317041241,
-0.0431955084,
0.0140171628,
-5.610486865e-33,
0.0215340983,
-0.0160899553,
0.00203151,
-0.0069237612,
0.0231528617,
0.0376755781,
-0.0081385029,
-0.0195049811,
0.0227511022,
0.0374913551,
0.0041641272,
0.0086245323,
-0.0031175541,
0.0059857685,
0.0678312778,
0.0255374834,
0.0118189575,
0.0182167199,
0.0050649662,
0.0026307241,
-0.10247197,
-0.0169925615,
-0.0091320667,
-0.057490278,
0.0781141371,
0.0687125996,
-0.0117827309,
-0.0131771155,
-0.0228815749,
0.0531076677,
0.0050310325,
0.0243899077,
0.0447812602,
0.0010138954,
-0.0279824734,
0.0458402745,
-0.0959605724,
0.0117235286,
-0.0203704704,
-0.0355121009,
-0.0114664296,
0.0109083327,
0.0793303102,
0.0404426754,
-0.0247120503,
-0.0442191847,
0.0319082811,
-0.0524297059,
-0.0207247697,
-0.0816701353,
-0.038885802,
0.0274987705,
-0.0534531996,
0.0499042012,
0.0144556472,
0.0997853354,
-0.0002160543,
0.0399488062,
-0.0122002633,
0.0258996375,
0.0164309237,
-0.0294809714,
0.0319959112,
-0.0036856765,
-0.0047017364,
0.0221000984,
-0.0276057478,
-0.0384344533,
-0.0016130779,
0.0046261097,
0.0338140391,
0.0135965804,
0.013311726,
0.0520991832,
0.0215382278,
0.0121458536,
-0.0768964961,
0.0606983118,
-0.0207054727,
0.0402731225,
0.0455675684,
-0.0133907553,
-0.0001919309,
-0.0088837007,
-0.0519484021,
-0.0849860683,
0.009209807,
0.0160886645,
0.0129119931,
-0.0032811167,
-0.0401904583,
0.0423304364,
0.0141387498,
-0.0149948951,
0.0117393238,
0.0302562993,
0.0094337929,
0.0108995168,
0.0032430543,
-0.0128367506,
-0.0735020563,
-0.0003708662,
-0.0111790607,
0.0284486692,
0.0717499778,
-0.0160754658,
0.0366040394,
-0.0442270935,
-0.0491711088,
0.0190134048,
0.021959465,
0.0322018899,
0.0067777387,
0.0160159264,
0.0349210165,
0.0136943888,
0.0188410021,
0.0037465284,
0.0051743905,
0.0336383581,
-0.0109751504,
-0.0222946666,
-0.0421602912,
-0.0266646482,
-0.0128408838,
-0.0085680718,
0.0022887455,
0.0006360469,
0.0731892958,
-0.0053427895,
0.0301836673,
-0.0229374617,
2.804e-7,
0.0899173543,
0.0571367331,
-0.0224693995,
-0.0412755162,
0.0307512283,
0.0315376595,
0.0192451179,
0.0039023703,
0.0240081213,
0.0273651294,
0.0839284584,
-0.0310633183,
0.0066938126,
0.0257550701,
-0.0146492599,
-0.0410636477,
-0.0333718099,
-0.0234007314,
-0.0811331794,
-0.0059305094,
-0.0027087405,
0.0368662067,
0.0001160025,
-0.0018225928,
-0.0061013345,
0.002836871,
-0.0408418067,
-0.0834119171,
0.0307353754,
-0.0241200496,
0.0449324921,
-0.0214868858,
0.024740383,
0.0240600742,
-0.0397840105,
-0.0125162015,
-0.0714748502,
0.0177363642,
-0.0122910505,
0.0372897685,
0.0057164002,
-0.0401695929,
0.0531285256,
-0.0602527931,
0.0206557382,
-0.0504854582,
-0.0515684038,
-0.0237973239,
-0.009575827,
-0.0095132086,
0.1129294559,
-0.0040657599,
0.0236904491,
0.0212020557,
-0.0158058796,
0.0022625681,
-0.0037606284,
-0.0167579092,
0.0369075052,
0.0623083338,
-0.0125732329,
-0.0090276143,
0.0242778491,
-0.033759594,
-0.0131069515,
-0.055180952,
0.0463273749,
2.527200356e-34,
0.0126618752,
0.0027878513,
-0.0113785416,
0.0046229125,
0.0059096795,
0.0296584424,
-0.025531102,
0.0216159765,
0.001624739,
-0.0401359387,
0.0263384264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16524v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16524v1 | The Privileged Students: On the Value of Initialization in Multilingual Knowledge Distillation | 2024-06-24T10:59:26 | 2024-06-24T10:59:26 | Haryo Akbarianto Wibowo, Thamar Solorio, Alham Fikri Aji | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50 | Knowledge distillation (KD) has proven to be a successful strategy to improve
the performance of a smaller model in many NLP tasks. However, most of the work
in KD only explores monolingual scenarios. In this paper, we investigate the
value of KD in multilingual settings. We find the significance of KD and model
initialization by analyzing how well the student model acquires multilingual
knowledge from the teacher model. Our proposed method emphasizes copying the
teacher model's weights directly to the student model to enhance
initialization. Our finding shows that model initialization using copy-weight
from the fine-tuned teacher contributes the most compared to the distillation
process itself across various multilingual settings. Furthermore, we
demonstrate that efficient weight initialization preserves multilingual
capabilities even in low-resource scenarios. | [
0.0293846,
0.0655251443,
-0.0108437585,
0.0443144701,
-0.0268093832,
0.0163235236,
0.0036257238,
-0.0146264173,
-0.0468660183,
-0.0354122221,
0.0060295197,
-0.0227202456,
-0.0310458411,
-0.0119719431,
0.0129809128,
-0.0566554703,
0.0282027703,
-0.0474201851,
-0.0103165172,
-0.0418730117,
0.008806522,
-0.0103525445,
-0.0020963005,
0.0056163883,
0.0028696221,
-0.0271446146,
-0.0035717173,
0.0078396397,
-0.00944399,
-0.0028581866,
0.0137210926,
0.0841048285,
0.0065877554,
0.0067319842,
0.0000022324,
-0.0523786172,
-0.0307829715,
-0.0054018181,
-0.0355818421,
0.0016061204,
0.0184317511,
-0.0316510461,
0.0321988091,
-0.004593404,
-0.0566732362,
0.015970666,
0.0174993295,
0.0306237713,
0.0432536006,
0.0203068648,
-0.0026426499,
-0.043373812,
-0.0114276623,
-0.0014221444,
-0.0386390127,
-0.0738871172,
0.0134113701,
0.0460023955,
-0.0286360197,
-0.002339069,
-0.0429369248,
0.0500715673,
0.0141453445,
0.0258876849,
-0.0133319041,
0.0022220984,
-0.0293435007,
-0.0413581282,
-0.0300935041,
0.0698412955,
-0.039991457,
-0.012469139,
0.0090851337,
0.0163733363,
0.027327409,
-0.0011041528,
-0.0380930416,
0.0354979597,
-0.0071523017,
0.0214597415,
0.0387477912,
-0.0061470964,
0.0173363928,
0.0287497956,
-0.0127986511,
0.0352321789,
0.0004928056,
-0.0393497571,
0.0225448385,
0.0472732857,
-0.0458602794,
-0.0653810129,
-0.0079192994,
0.026140891,
0.015812505,
0.0341631584,
-0.0195320621,
-0.0431924202,
0.0022258267,
-0.0177293438,
0.0192552991,
0.0325950794,
0.0289511122,
0.0287195891,
-0.0265443586,
0.0419326574,
0.0036918221,
0.0384198055,
-0.0162109695,
-0.0202341843,
-0.098260209,
0.0067796931,
-0.0490759499,
0.0496664047,
-0.0130626671,
0.0024830557,
-0.0002709846,
-0.0107533196,
-0.0325040109,
-0.0194370635,
0.0262607634,
-0.0146129318,
-0.0206449162,
0.0325566866,
-0.0360945798,
0.1124962643,
-0.0565012358,
-0.0072503658,
0.002287664,
-0.0531485826,
-0.0293445177,
-0.0309895705,
0.0111492248,
-0.0162764303,
-0.0008190772,
0.0305314232,
-0.0410145931,
-0.0271975026,
-0.0290694386,
-0.0417206846,
-0.0018737832,
-0.088462621,
0.0096837357,
-0.0758059546,
0.0613914616,
0.0245481879,
0.0449375324,
-0.072023809,
0.0139797116,
-0.0132832415,
-0.0328779332,
0.0605252758,
-0.0065523973,
0.0277843382,
-0.015051757,
0.0141750993,
-0.0366134346,
0.1243778542,
-0.0163411368,
0.0008815356,
0.0391444303,
-0.0016489412,
-0.0248518325,
0.0285499711,
0.0453626439,
0.0246276874,
-0.0045043468,
-0.0337179936,
0.0014050369,
-0.0091103381,
0.034323778,
0.0390811637,
-0.0594155863,
0.0776650086,
0.0524109825,
0.0264824759,
0.0293135699,
0.0083021903,
0.0252278857,
-0.0028824431,
-0.0200366601,
0.063280426,
-0.0305456314,
-0.0043285484,
-0.0116296699,
-0.015246694,
0.0124416584,
0.0815752745,
-0.0147035252,
-0.0346725173,
-0.0064340755,
-0.013820461,
0.0181974638,
0.0154050896,
0.0400377326,
0.0770638436,
0.0218984354,
0.0992278606,
0.0707334578,
-0.0586580336,
0.0240370352,
-0.0257759374,
-0.03352632,
0.0465739258,
0.0041746837,
0.010315259,
0.007196316,
0.0041963612,
-0.0078419829,
0.0050367792,
0.0660745576,
-0.0409227386,
0.0436246991,
-0.044820942,
-0.0541030355,
-0.0056036715,
0.0256004389,
0.0119933756,
0.0295482241,
0.0321699344,
-0.0043485025,
-0.0431616344,
-0.0716888905,
0.016954232,
-0.0562907569,
-0.051020693,
-0.0293495376,
0.0333596729,
0.0013028482,
0.0259005856,
-0.0001864175,
-0.03169211,
0.0039933412,
-0.0329107344,
-0.0208125077,
-0.0077547245,
-0.0319410674,
-0.0888325721,
0.04281516,
-0.0096314112,
0.0220771227,
0.0132519267,
-0.0130093014,
-0.0680481717,
0.0336893946,
0.044376716,
0.0455650575,
-0.005212259,
0.0350344665,
-0.0217742808,
0.0070386725,
-0.0345904641,
0.0613582097,
-0.0032209479,
0.0031292739,
0.0134408344,
-0.0353272483,
0.0075776293,
-0.0011870802,
-0.0711276755,
0.0299298838,
-0.0083386293,
0.0303511284,
0.0369611718,
0.0266051441,
-0.0222131107,
-0.0228281561,
-0.0610011145,
0.0091873137,
-0.0482905209,
-0.0141656017,
0.0333411209,
0.0365851484,
0.0178763792,
-0.0165001266,
-0.0429475307,
-0.0272603594,
-0.0093438532,
0.032904163,
-0.0064545954,
0.0274778698,
0.038711518,
-0.001966367,
-0.0222144518,
0.0349336155,
0.0354579054,
-0.0102682356,
0.0071255867,
-0.0011501668,
0.0340016037,
-0.0467388816,
0.0269568674,
0.0146464026,
-0.008624766,
0.0044073239,
0.0064281868,
0.0169391911,
0.0277415402,
-0.0627945065,
0.0273889657,
0.0614586473,
0.0071566063,
-0.075872086,
0.0365021564,
-0.007914789,
-0.007384018,
-0.0458107591,
-0.0238334686,
-0.0235838536,
0.0926728472,
-0.017953096,
-0.0334402025,
-0.0398803093,
-0.0005025913,
-0.0629322231,
-0.0494674668,
-0.0349857025,
0.0171926003,
0.0003243704,
0.0473689698,
-0.0279387962,
-0.0201967005,
0.0657266006,
0.0016340218,
-0.0002741875,
-0.074223496,
0.0089224847,
0.0009470719,
0.0219847579,
-0.0137117542,
0.0376294106,
-0.0218245443,
0.0057979343,
-0.0465811305,
0.018994024,
0.05139146,
-0.0231218506,
0.0582957529,
-0.0739583895,
-0.0059144786,
-0.0096733952,
-0.0577771887,
-0.0361896902,
0.000917666,
-0.001135707,
0.0396017805,
0.0418232381,
-0.0015812424,
-0.0105384132,
-0.0097618438,
0.047255069,
0.0216187462,
-0.0144963413,
0.0001144857,
-0.0239749327,
0.0252993703,
0.0357863568,
0.0037581013,
0.0077369949,
-0.0395770669,
0.049311053,
0.0315158702,
0.0487060845,
-0.0231231898,
0.0203005262,
0.0080427034,
0.0612886027,
-0.021571653,
-0.0469309278,
-0.0060781045,
0.0542185567,
-0.0342909917,
0.0098281195,
0.0896454006,
0.0048471801,
-0.0404861234,
-0.0078054895,
0.0097068045,
0.0448846556,
0.0322388038,
0.0049587479,
-0.1054622605,
-0.0297748279,
0.0021428571,
0.0010385667,
0.0188693255,
-0.037231259,
-0.0254565179,
-0.0838942006,
-0.0298789032,
-0.0013354723,
-0.0371836312,
-0.0199206267,
-0.025551917,
-0.0182824247,
-0.0322977602,
0.033316277,
-0.0031471269,
-0.0277177375,
0.0421417728,
0.0355786197,
0.0015365055,
-0.0825283006,
-0.0081159184,
-0.0312688611,
0.0137415389,
0.0503995121,
0.0166930985,
-0.0252896603,
-0.0193824191,
-0.0200624727,
-0.0081410203,
-0.0041955621,
-0.0083727678,
0.0453916192,
0.0123028113,
-0.0220934805,
0.029185921,
0.0008643206,
-0.0378070436,
-0.0103816437,
-0.000510629,
0.0480479598,
0.0413247757,
-0.0635845363,
0.0223681033,
-0.0516975746,
0.0379869789,
0.0913056657,
0.0492136516,
-0.0442618504,
-0.0361168943,
-0.0128621403,
-0.0331344754,
-0.0607212968,
-0.0089898715,
0.0416529328,
-0.0185021181,
-0.0186098777,
-0.0752292722,
-0.0602199063,
0.0282132886,
0.0459051281,
0.0204654466,
0.0451770872,
0.0156021817,
0.0048379274,
-0.0114405779,
-0.0002187782,
-0.0352820083,
0.0011397565,
-0.0373491496,
-0.0562814884,
0.0009792483,
-0.0062901624,
-0.0227422956,
-0.0009870039,
-0.0836367235,
-0.0863074511,
0.0169929676,
0.0580075309,
0.0223724432,
0.0533962213,
-0.0050487453,
-0.0567088388,
0.0596273504,
-0.0352190733,
0.0013083004,
0.0016501653,
0.0457158424,
-0.0224694386,
0.0202249065,
0.0577808991,
-0.0197005868,
0.0310998354,
0.0211979598,
0.0667398348,
-0.0599831827,
-0.0101242485,
0.011668249,
0.0564202964,
0.0049325344,
-0.0247316416,
-0.0029105123,
-0.0323395282,
-0.0044436087,
0.0070167156,
-0.0223475713,
-0.0551358797,
0.0182078183,
0.0380105004,
0.0412659459,
0.0060580373,
0.0175127834,
0.0464965478,
-0.007297602,
-0.0264713932,
0.0011560537,
0.0220682323,
-0.0207689963,
0.0726495609,
0.0381593779,
0.000053574,
0.0432807878,
0.013978661,
0.0243879277,
-0.0375226848,
0.0195994247,
0.0372094512,
0.0189162698,
-0.0058899154,
0.0189468004,
-0.0487733409,
-0.0523647293,
0.006456851,
0.0020176999,
0.0706270784,
-0.0371377617,
0.0916014612,
-0.016148543,
0.0035992295,
0.0128234951,
-0.0036905897,
-0.0100921886,
-0.0274100807,
0.0286313742,
0.0173016582,
-0.004073509,
0.0063016382,
0.1237220466,
-0.0310078822,
0.0607837923,
-0.0359886587,
0.0358758643,
-0.0130697489,
-0.0144558707,
0.0303524323,
0.0272515323,
-0.0001450894,
0.0547535382,
-0.0529650152,
-0.0725534484,
-0.0148801226,
-0.0253043212,
0.0016189439,
-0.0117805107,
0.0609534346,
0.0694079548,
-0.0225073826,
-0.0090503693,
-0.0528101809,
-0.0466512069,
0.0350429639,
-0.0119027793,
0.0266182628,
-6.908317852e-33,
-0.0033001066,
0.017675804,
0.0060137552,
0.0149451904,
0.0334028378,
0.0123487851,
0.006488238,
0.0091664325,
-0.0545020923,
0.0414612442,
-0.0485101417,
0.0065316116,
0.0261468645,
0.0224684682,
0.019431904,
0.0166166108,
0.0585791096,
-0.0027621172,
-0.007895492,
0.029529728,
0.0438140891,
0.0616718642,
0.0837111548,
-0.0220425017,
0.0349054486,
-0.0093206726,
0.0155659141,
-0.0149773154,
-0.0091874795,
0.008053082,
-0.0142551716,
0.0726587698,
0.0406214781,
-0.0672292039,
-0.0405971482,
-0.0387000069,
-0.0749955252,
-0.0623947531,
0.032920327,
0.0105332471,
-0.0333951004,
-0.0248722639,
0.0338291861,
-0.0123773096,
0.0039415346,
-0.0158822145,
0.024368573,
0.0071472134,
-0.0226524584,
-0.0404753983,
-0.0817556307,
-0.0181932505,
0.0022848835,
-0.0206148736,
0.0709183738,
-0.0180411544,
-0.0235478915,
-0.050728403,
-0.0510141216,
0.0124825183,
0.0381086245,
0.0437366627,
0.0542345531,
0.0144888572,
-0.0220046658,
0.0425527357,
-0.0194308497,
0.0366701521,
0.0325895846,
-0.0354510695,
0.048535645,
0.0376363024,
-0.0124638425,
0.0309336521,
0.0630234554,
-0.0244503748,
-0.0327613391,
-0.0120534291,
0.0154042933,
0.0254133437,
-0.0290339682,
-0.0105817877,
-0.0086779548,
-0.0508869179,
-0.0824532881,
-0.0487903394,
-0.0238071885,
-0.0221369751,
0.0157717802,
0.018665161,
-0.0325470641,
0.0151865128,
0.0268163253,
-0.0591302253,
-0.0481244773,
0.0338497087,
0.0055583026,
-0.0010263884,
-0.0102041624,
-0.0059936414,
-0.090155609,
-0.009725146,
-0.0008441028,
-0.0008482752,
0.0024245037,
0.0454535075,
0.0615533702,
0.0057093031,
-0.0355178267,
-0.0034154025,
-0.0613896735,
0.0301549844,
0.0584412627,
0.0446159169,
0.0202693716,
0.0195787754,
-0.0278670173,
-0.0106097907,
0.0676603317,
-0.0206267666,
-0.0297317877,
0.0117196571,
0.0100225257,
0.0178524554,
-0.0418210141,
-0.0161042809,
-0.0224820841,
0.0072011431,
0.0281958655,
-0.0254455693,
-0.0189796519,
-0.0148820262,
2.91e-7,
0.0446188152,
0.0291514732,
-0.0052390764,
-0.0283734836,
-0.0015223654,
0.006552578,
-0.0273062214,
0.0189999957,
-0.0084899198,
-0.0405995697,
-0.0337555669,
0.0575297438,
0.0298654642,
0.0412972905,
-0.1092426181,
-0.0105795972,
-0.0131107131,
-0.008657896,
-0.0078464169,
-0.0484764129,
0.0074362522,
0.0457589701,
0.0089237271,
-0.0140779242,
-0.0411428846,
-0.0192135032,
0.0300470181,
0.0098380372,
0.0234171767,
0.054096587,
0.0450496748,
-0.0213014092,
0.0006362647,
0.0409101732,
-0.0238334108,
0.013866582,
0.0263356529,
0.0567529425,
-0.0161247794,
0.0015248661,
0.0042687273,
-0.0182724819,
-0.0160262734,
-0.0537904166,
0.0600626171,
-0.0366200916,
0.0107990569,
0.005153947,
-0.0017093328,
0.0051802937,
0.0230631158,
0.0022421791,
-0.0045616748,
0.0700247437,
0.0087202564,
0.0253569372,
-0.045634862,
-0.0642985329,
-0.0162392333,
-0.0157822333,
0.0182381906,
-0.0663073584,
0.0010756821,
-0.1011592671,
-0.0161104277,
-0.0490103476,
0.0125047034,
2.519435894e-34,
0.0132127982,
-0.001427561,
0.0521580055,
0.0182868149,
0.0092783971,
-0.0399999246,
-0.0607784688,
0.007890882,
-0.0171246622,
-0.0407731533,
-0.0066794669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16521v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16521v1 | Carrot and Stick: Inducing Self-Motivation with Positive & Negative Feedback | 2024-06-24T10:55:31 | 2024-06-24T10:55:31 | Jimin Sohn, Jeihee Cho, Junyong Lee, Songmu Heo, Ji-Eun Han, David R. Mortensen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Positive thinking is thought to be an important component of self-motivation
in various practical fields such as education and the workplace. Previous work,
including sentiment transfer and positive reframing, has focused on the
positive side of language. However, self-motivation that drives people to reach
their goals has not yet been studied from a computational perspective.
Moreover, negative feedback has not yet been explored, even though positive and
negative feedback are both necessary to grow self-motivation. To facilitate
self-motivation, we propose CArrot and STICk (CASTIC) dataset, consisting of
12,590 sentences with 5 different strategies for enhancing self-motivation. Our
data and code are publicly available at here. | [
0.0473906286,
0.0514401197,
0.0047552986,
-0.0097113149,
0.0001410757,
0.0060804584,
-0.0589239039,
-0.0283712652,
0.0243988261,
0.0127885398,
-0.0029026901,
0.0591096766,
-0.0051436028,
0.0228064787,
0.023313228,
-0.077554442,
0.0328729786,
0.0094934693,
0.0361253284,
-0.0219001789,
0.017398674,
-0.0023799054,
-0.0187588148,
0.0044079921,
-0.0320138261,
-0.0134078618,
0.0372169949,
0.0268573351,
0.0021134757,
-0.0549694933,
0.0300431047,
0.0405727737,
-0.0178221241,
0.0003465727,
0.0000021431,
-0.0356919393,
-0.0143786902,
-0.0500669889,
-0.0324726067,
-0.0240945555,
0.0872185156,
-0.0197982583,
-0.0108781839,
0.0023379652,
-0.0567608736,
0.0474801473,
0.0183839705,
0.0482993983,
0.1006420404,
0.0621597096,
-0.0150362998,
-0.0228082668,
-0.0249220971,
0.0056953277,
0.0391697511,
0.0294748098,
0.0211124178,
0.005344179,
-0.00373202,
0.0113219768,
-0.0181293748,
0.0066388762,
-0.0210841149,
0.0037750483,
0.0620220937,
0.0177310687,
-0.0495939404,
-0.0022874617,
-0.0294606835,
0.0287307389,
0.0487926118,
-0.0137401838,
-0.0210471991,
-0.0220041741,
0.0455396213,
-0.0036619126,
-0.0322788656,
0.0037831543,
0.0206024889,
0.0462325849,
-0.0182258449,
0.0294649135,
0.0093643852,
-0.0087593151,
0.0446869358,
0.0216334853,
-0.0224678218,
-0.069337137,
0.056636855,
0.0396421775,
0.0362400375,
-0.0254772026,
0.008187538,
-0.007519837,
0.0242749602,
0.0050516902,
-0.0028003238,
0.0014761302,
-0.0156256799,
-0.0473631024,
0.0292702634,
0.0131043429,
-0.0314957798,
0.0055342051,
-0.001977056,
-0.0111805508,
0.0075709354,
0.0038978143,
-0.0218687672,
0.030540891,
-0.0608342029,
0.0057900548,
-0.0447331369,
0.0568108968,
0.0621702559,
0.0017826015,
-0.0910931453,
-0.0199152995,
-0.052570276,
-0.0499002375,
-0.0322284997,
-0.0039713886,
0.0071638734,
0.0248424951,
-0.0376263969,
0.0519601852,
-0.0498724468,
-0.0168792959,
-0.0236642137,
0.0089070825,
-0.0128793428,
0.0021636272,
0.0269896574,
-0.0252370015,
0.0560041182,
0.0112082921,
0.0021514159,
-0.0311399046,
-0.0585310496,
0.0079511097,
-0.0121967727,
-0.0172849875,
-0.014499777,
-0.06464158,
0.0030135389,
-0.0499422364,
0.0255836546,
-0.0413320065,
0.0238208491,
0.0051291445,
-0.0059068077,
0.0285880044,
-0.0352107286,
-0.0111391572,
0.0146073438,
0.0048490451,
0.0070947632,
0.0301166698,
0.0247056652,
0.0576760955,
0.0608451553,
-0.0589773282,
0.0516913682,
0.0062236609,
0.0539566465,
-0.0122135896,
0.0154101951,
-0.0156411119,
-0.0371776335,
0.0284577422,
-0.0264616758,
0.0162640177,
-0.0050993329,
0.0780006647,
0.0455216467,
0.0683155581,
-0.0166684929,
-0.0349336639,
-0.0291561279,
0.0247932058,
-0.0136009818,
-0.0545309223,
-0.0036583943,
0.0416610017,
-0.0056253676,
-0.0003691764,
0.0059994357,
0.0222429354,
-0.028970696,
-0.0376451723,
-0.0198215414,
-0.0407991223,
0.0123004597,
0.0059543955,
0.051464498,
-0.0170141961,
-0.0085386783,
-0.0028628183,
0.029162718,
-0.1145734116,
-0.0031239644,
-0.023730306,
0.0359316282,
0.0387362465,
0.0150330355,
-0.0107211061,
-0.0490414165,
-0.0443512015,
0.0111680757,
0.0423731171,
0.0272070616,
-0.0159388017,
-0.0409971401,
-0.020611871,
0.0081336405,
0.0118930647,
-0.0125619611,
-0.0362030379,
-0.0049045635,
0.002735097,
-0.0275239274,
0.0548957177,
-0.0216228496,
0.0254371762,
0.0269921012,
-0.0205359254,
0.0336206928,
0.0164098423,
0.0275007617,
0.0527084321,
0.0129313283,
-0.0046454645,
0.0235932749,
0.0024531051,
-0.0554723851,
0.056868501,
-0.0350432955,
-0.0200455673,
0.0213533752,
-0.057134252,
0.0117883775,
0.0358771719,
0.015523687,
0.0078409938,
0.0400363579,
-0.0012471096,
0.0233490244,
0.0239269715,
0.0341004282,
-0.0224822555,
0.0342587866,
-0.0121340379,
0.0215132907,
0.0208382867,
0.017540941,
-0.0512830131,
-0.0428659618,
0.001805242,
-0.0183759034,
0.0047897231,
-0.0552183688,
-0.0005554591,
0.0096404534,
0.0296082757,
0.0212670881,
-0.0806713179,
-0.0098269721,
-0.0754055828,
-0.0485780053,
0.0294613279,
0.0015457043,
0.0083806189,
-0.0180521794,
0.0044051632,
-0.0323002115,
-0.0248205829,
0.0241914615,
0.0089253774,
0.0058096033,
0.0305622537,
-0.0250937175,
0.0313083865,
-0.0273960158,
-0.0093026506,
-0.0405703336,
-0.0287393089,
0.033145804,
-0.0015834101,
-0.0566698276,
0.0363398083,
-0.0225141346,
-0.0169561468,
-0.0024456941,
-0.0382068455,
0.0276201684,
0.0050285282,
0.0973281115,
0.0320606977,
0.0129352547,
-0.0040110946,
0.0146564357,
-0.006091903,
-0.0379798487,
0.0033306978,
-0.0387872458,
0.043368049,
-0.0119874356,
-0.0592423007,
0.0227628909,
0.0190581288,
0.0471402667,
-0.0106593687,
-0.0731380284,
0.0355666466,
-0.0419673733,
-0.0027240773,
-0.0641065687,
0.0080737835,
0.0035905379,
0.0149994837,
0.0197296254,
-0.0343738571,
0.0528442934,
0.0106902616,
-0.024265103,
0.0076608742,
0.011989098,
-0.0072489497,
0.0699202493,
-0.0145493317,
-0.0240842365,
0.0374677032,
0.0373936035,
0.0271151178,
-0.0538107157,
0.0082254857,
-0.0132117495,
0.0473396853,
-0.0263554435,
-0.0188301019,
-0.0126777682,
-0.0638263524,
-0.039209459,
-0.0865432844,
-0.0058730626,
-0.0322969891,
0.0114769163,
0.0060705952,
-0.0212191362,
-0.0551508702,
0.0217034519,
-0.0211452004,
-0.0192090254,
-0.0438699648,
0.0423149616,
-0.0359069556,
0.0540779978,
0.0292497519,
0.0426291563,
-0.0063211424,
-0.0159510206,
0.0196380354,
0.0225757491,
-0.0199965145,
0.0023388427,
-0.0248452369,
0.0359241068,
-0.0001896042,
0.0371800177,
-0.0070400895,
0.0542975292,
0.023154052,
-0.0578687564,
0.0931198895,
-0.0063968915,
-0.0289002042,
0.0098124854,
-0.0657237098,
0.0234715678,
0.0307150632,
0.0303448252,
-0.0696419999,
-0.0388217382,
-0.0143647129,
0.0455827005,
-0.0130951703,
-0.0144371539,
-0.0005872559,
-0.1196379438,
0.0468240157,
0.0341199227,
0.0124126533,
0.0094602555,
-0.0193506312,
-0.0590699278,
0.000277828,
-0.0813893899,
-0.0059047691,
-0.0250839256,
0.0260454509,
0.0083949016,
-0.0115407724,
-0.0084262239,
0.0228074268,
-0.0113094049,
0.0678234547,
0.035850551,
0.041605778,
-0.0086216098,
-0.0416096225,
0.0212178603,
0.0209516995,
-0.0268079713,
-0.0275196191,
0.0746136159,
-0.0265597403,
0.0077653928,
-0.029007284,
0.0258045364,
-0.1006387174,
-0.0015037159,
0.0785558745,
0.0767294392,
0.0255827922,
-0.0271876939,
-0.0324318148,
0.0321252272,
0.0115483012,
0.0947373286,
-0.0269229375,
-0.0493634492,
0.0442802906,
-0.0105017088,
-0.0179321636,
-0.0199953131,
-0.0722815543,
-0.0227473862,
-0.0235180706,
0.0666203797,
-0.0655599684,
-0.0753193721,
0.0165515319,
0.0057473863,
0.0016333341,
0.0000165455,
-0.0287983734,
0.0449115336,
-0.0449293181,
0.0011083611,
-0.0319761522,
0.0108405761,
-0.0630603582,
-0.042292174,
0.0236915518,
-0.0309293084,
-0.0116872676,
-0.0261068363,
-0.0504140556,
-0.008903753,
-0.0064008515,
0.0826313198,
0.0165345017,
0.0091995439,
0.0213404652,
0.0041308147,
-0.0307233706,
0.0829482004,
-0.0231147408,
0.0368163548,
0.0623667613,
0.0427958556,
0.0291550681,
0.000988986,
-0.004618316,
0.0554195903,
0.0467679687,
0.0062508741,
0.0283396691,
0.0241913758,
0.0184963029,
0.0326606557,
0.0443499945,
-0.0227522608,
-0.0492640659,
-0.0373758413,
-0.000617445,
-0.0131858168,
-0.040603999,
-0.0345072486,
-0.0057783956,
0.008963096,
0.0039695636,
0.0011911129,
-0.0131812617,
-0.0429767445,
-0.0022149277,
-0.0538756773,
0.0032074095,
0.014592113,
0.0662269741,
-0.0015474788,
0.0069651753,
0.0030965533,
0.0149988076,
0.0161752403,
0.0237562619,
-0.0279252231,
0.081213817,
0.0062786951,
0.0151721342,
0.0047566025,
0.0198191423,
-0.0483383499,
0.0351475589,
0.0061409767,
-0.0450704545,
0.0208947714,
0.0256808754,
0.0904849842,
0.018184403,
0.0066389078,
0.0024343345,
0.0250795092,
-0.0605256073,
-0.0104308752,
0.0157636181,
-0.025466688,
-0.0252769496,
-0.0507474169,
0.0226817597,
-0.1065771431,
0.0167401377,
0.015870871,
0.0145371929,
-0.0470101088,
-0.0142847216,
0.0152593702,
0.0050474713,
0.0088119181,
0.0147552751,
-0.0481392853,
-0.0173310991,
0.0010493494,
-0.0101187769,
0.0225921199,
-0.0116329752,
0.0527941957,
0.0128751751,
-0.0286263954,
-0.0135409245,
-0.0414145701,
0.0461518466,
-0.0349757224,
-0.0146591952,
-0.0130560063,
-6.211123336e-33,
-0.000267714,
-0.0034188214,
0.0137072792,
0.0728874207,
-0.0225453135,
-0.0306966864,
-0.0248446893,
0.0482850447,
0.0261202324,
0.0279356781,
-0.0110703204,
0.020278303,
-0.013646163,
0.0330792405,
0.0533702746,
0.0268557537,
0.0437997952,
-0.0005899714,
-0.0267781187,
-0.001455789,
0.0301167909,
0.0485282205,
0.0757867992,
-0.067257002,
0.0601747893,
0.0056974147,
-0.0271590892,
0.0233043712,
0.0479317382,
0.0277424846,
-0.0206233095,
0.0214223862,
0.0235612579,
0.0007874303,
0.004086568,
0.0120956041,
-0.0128267016,
-0.0894126594,
0.0037414196,
-0.0272389501,
-0.0710310489,
-0.0379658341,
0.0149841439,
-0.0117661916,
-0.0703554526,
0.0327772163,
0.0311886482,
-0.0053615603,
0.0315497927,
0.0290128775,
-0.089849852,
-0.0089328587,
0.0025116957,
-0.0202539098,
-0.0149687408,
0.0676218644,
-0.0086297225,
0.0175959989,
-0.0229518525,
0.099273555,
-0.0279487707,
0.0359900557,
0.0142110586,
-0.0196700133,
0.0033187154,
0.0715396777,
0.0265576746,
-0.0039605401,
-0.0125863897,
-0.0012831799,
0.0159405451,
-0.0110292351,
0.1045585871,
0.0442653298,
0.0316480994,
-0.0629283041,
-0.0212384034,
0.0303798802,
0.0406602994,
-0.0505046472,
0.0272052977,
0.0120226732,
-0.0245789699,
0.0001162199,
0.0091130855,
-0.023596026,
-0.0077419891,
-0.0321307406,
0.0165087786,
0.0059335902,
-0.0321550071,
-0.0094672432,
-0.0318587609,
-0.0087543046,
-0.0289759282,
0.0427799188,
-0.0302165728,
0.003781501,
0.0082519772,
-0.0806303993,
-0.0929670706,
0.0053709801,
-0.0410060659,
0.0628339127,
0.040581964,
0.0137486663,
0.037697088,
0.0238552988,
-0.0666330382,
-0.0167202037,
-0.0078649772,
0.048820667,
-0.0076999087,
-0.053933654,
-0.0201594979,
0.0369630381,
-0.0074772579,
0.0685499907,
0.0295419507,
-0.0482575037,
-0.0564822927,
0.0478025116,
0.0376940705,
-0.0014098499,
0.0076414687,
-0.0276128296,
-0.014450402,
0.0131094856,
0.0223550368,
-0.0594227798,
-0.0137107475,
-0.0751252621,
2.812e-7,
-0.036075525,
0.0618408695,
0.0072898744,
0.0244005565,
-0.0024234878,
0.0679500699,
-0.0421086177,
-0.0283757467,
-0.0118573988,
0.0328516997,
0.0038335768,
0.0112112667,
0.0125485351,
0.0156514738,
-0.0763480738,
0.0126456562,
-0.0000337631,
-0.015235113,
0.0307257548,
-0.0105004814,
0.091896452,
0.0131497486,
0.0737470612,
-0.0165854301,
-0.0260342062,
0.0179197621,
0.0667558908,
-0.057886187,
0.0178627409,
0.0092443749,
-0.0562381297,
-0.0345777906,
-0.0292170811,
-0.0147871366,
0.0119295586,
-0.0284381583,
-0.033695247,
0.0542142242,
-0.0080553731,
0.0017293474,
-0.0010185131,
0.0606240444,
-0.0159082115,
0.0044717574,
-0.0067906827,
-0.0916563347,
-0.0556765758,
-0.0700538456,
-0.0007640971,
-0.015833348,
0.0362306759,
-0.0140669653,
-0.0257434435,
-0.0633681193,
0.0455551557,
0.0413111709,
-0.0577652045,
-0.0651596114,
-0.024072079,
-0.0111038396,
-0.0048721083,
-0.0313488208,
-0.0402090177,
0.0771541074,
-0.0479518399,
-0.0554717295,
0.0100067277,
2.010568981e-34,
0.0130621837,
0.0043031909,
0.0297358576,
-0.0422596931,
0.0060570743,
-0.015868742,
0.0004755305,
-0.0023168321,
0.0199038666,
0.0046072388,
-0.0290168598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16508v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16508v1 | Large Vocabulary Size Improves Large Language Models | 2024-06-24T10:27:07 | 2024-06-24T10:27:07 | Sho Takase, Ryokan Ri, Shun Kiyono, Takuya Kato | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper empirically investigates the relationship between subword
vocabulary size and the performance of large language models (LLMs) to provide
insights on how to define the vocabulary size. Experimental results show that
larger vocabulary sizes lead to better performance in LLMs. Moreover, we
consider a continual training scenario where a pre-trained language model is
trained on a different target language. We introduce a simple method to use a
new vocabulary instead of the pre-defined one. We show that using the new
vocabulary outperforms the model with the vocabulary used in pre-training. | [
0.0425213426,
0.048165597,
-0.0177172013,
0.0231424887,
-0.024583932,
0.0168231428,
0.0209888499,
0.0540863425,
-0.0326618329,
-0.0718758106,
-0.032279294,
-0.0787709951,
-0.0174091198,
0.0196013935,
0.0293006599,
-0.0444230549,
0.0330355801,
-0.0837680399,
-0.0437381715,
-0.0162196178,
-0.0163332783,
0.0078143682,
0.0386100411,
0.0200972464,
-0.0024503754,
0.0182111766,
-0.0039536231,
-0.0098119434,
-0.0320716798,
-0.0297121946,
-0.0001086248,
0.0059836977,
0.0586326793,
0.0437355749,
0.0000018752,
-0.0345379487,
0.002145627,
-0.0115196863,
-0.0178718138,
0.0507335663,
0.0868519172,
-0.0145678874,
0.0099829827,
0.0526941605,
0.0084030703,
-0.0380239561,
0.0254939068,
0.0454796739,
-0.0055033173,
0.0689081922,
-0.0048174793,
-0.0622224957,
0.0286763608,
-0.0546748862,
-0.036249496,
-0.0492505841,
0.0424611196,
0.0543499738,
0.0171428658,
0.010544043,
-0.0247210208,
0.0130221862,
-0.0109643349,
0.0176550839,
0.0105330292,
0.0403571092,
0.0204434209,
-0.0147195831,
0.0095586954,
0.0310401879,
-0.0402991325,
-0.006345625,
-0.0186245888,
-0.0238880794,
-0.0404896848,
0.0347967334,
-0.0386852436,
0.0328163691,
0.0219413117,
0.0209624488,
0.0282830782,
-0.009407199,
0.0443369597,
0.0210572667,
-0.0744683892,
0.0328383781,
0.046020668,
-0.0215162933,
0.0094666844,
-0.0327774025,
-0.020798007,
-0.058693286,
-0.0338096023,
0.0159615222,
-0.0242430661,
0.0439002365,
-0.0249559395,
-0.0005095146,
0.0294724088,
-0.0736923665,
0.0591317154,
0.0007296377,
0.0031461925,
0.0513393767,
-0.0004952902,
0.0271901954,
-0.0070800195,
-0.0123562878,
-0.0831979215,
-0.011011227,
-0.0386818387,
-0.0034586275,
-0.0553407408,
0.0208609011,
0.0233639218,
-0.0440020189,
-0.0319926478,
0.0144394096,
0.0563307069,
-0.002657888,
-0.0057494938,
-0.0391249619,
-0.0396029875,
-0.0159527361,
-0.003662542,
0.0307962336,
-0.0256999526,
0.0310623366,
-0.0239759255,
-0.0449312814,
0.0307076052,
0.0044977963,
0.0021672098,
-0.0413358659,
0.0172608383,
0.0667298958,
0.0216912478,
-0.0681944638,
-0.0332542062,
0.0269552488,
-0.0071127764,
-0.0596645214,
-0.0328644253,
-0.0666652098,
-0.0073584933,
0.0125308866,
0.0308971517,
-0.0231692567,
0.0011238096,
0.001572832,
-0.0512087382,
0.0640721917,
-0.0220529363,
0.0311509781,
0.0130273076,
-0.0177112371,
0.0606601983,
0.1006176844,
0.0476417653,
0.0144840851,
0.0639835149,
-0.0430036485,
-0.0224079527,
0.0377326868,
-0.0002975526,
0.0157436281,
-0.0545015484,
-0.0083209658,
0.049931556,
0.0321890935,
-0.001815447,
0.0491317436,
-0.0187968425,
0.0158282351,
0.0473692007,
0.0666116029,
0.0426778533,
0.0210352726,
0.0349674337,
0.0168646593,
-0.0057078125,
0.0007643278,
-0.0162912682,
-0.0269595124,
-0.0114013478,
0.0142763471,
0.0223986357,
0.0294060186,
-0.0411527343,
-0.0369214304,
-0.0676936805,
-0.0220353175,
0.0247948021,
-0.0145060597,
0.0904033035,
-0.010827302,
-0.0143625988,
0.0682470351,
0.0605656393,
-0.03122814,
0.0213394277,
-0.0613156408,
0.0241657495,
0.067316249,
0.0420313403,
-0.0121784797,
0.0138815148,
-0.0034572757,
0.0331804156,
0.0409327857,
0.0733817071,
-0.0038200507,
-0.0093227765,
-0.0649112463,
-0.0066816332,
0.0034266894,
0.0101512857,
0.016003415,
0.0443883352,
0.0310066827,
0.0148935029,
-0.0360108502,
-0.0726871789,
0.0288856626,
-0.071803771,
-0.0264267921,
-0.0178114418,
-0.0241194684,
0.0237468034,
0.0009004625,
-0.0415376723,
-0.0061031734,
0.0138416048,
-0.0294391848,
-0.0233483277,
-0.021742709,
-0.0395600386,
0.0246056989,
0.0476985872,
0.0506360121,
0.0500444993,
0.0091749197,
-0.0211942773,
-0.0056930101,
0.0103216171,
-0.0379476286,
0.1029964611,
-0.0492683537,
0.0434614345,
-0.0420773476,
0.0158561654,
-0.0449610688,
0.0258287676,
-0.0026679065,
0.0200440958,
-0.0292263869,
0.0153191006,
0.0210359376,
-0.0210357923,
-0.0203095581,
0.0545474365,
0.0103244772,
0.0224881247,
0.0219225883,
-0.0079274569,
-0.026857309,
-0.0534629859,
-0.0719956681,
-0.0157254934,
-0.0248783007,
-0.0267011989,
-0.0231485441,
0.024604287,
0.0019360365,
0.0061650816,
-0.0102817612,
0.0289487094,
0.0094788959,
0.0310449991,
-0.0064224768,
0.0153111536,
-0.049969729,
-0.0557943769,
-0.0308844987,
0.0271515362,
0.0709163994,
-0.0017718885,
-0.0221425071,
-0.0326151513,
0.0562154986,
-0.0364497378,
0.020492781,
-0.0189463068,
-0.0574511886,
-0.0118322792,
-0.0380373374,
0.022825988,
0.0306755919,
0.0315942019,
0.0258254092,
0.0866828039,
-0.0045511615,
-0.0456236564,
-0.0154766347,
0.0005762317,
-0.0869474858,
-0.0444282331,
-0.0224027615,
-0.0231310558,
0.0890755951,
-0.026987236,
0.004549135,
-0.0337000936,
0.0038674278,
-0.0516043752,
-0.0085238032,
-0.021035444,
0.0075104386,
-0.0268313233,
0.0194536727,
0.008956939,
-0.076051034,
0.0188822933,
-0.0227801185,
0.027754385,
-0.0370485485,
-0.0349075831,
-0.0470308885,
0.0636110604,
0.0210672691,
0.0242162719,
-0.0058192532,
-0.0034300897,
-0.0108468151,
-0.0438509211,
0.0032945508,
-0.0240562707,
0.0529062524,
-0.0455540344,
0.0467996374,
-0.0061810641,
-0.01558981,
-0.0599097349,
-0.0374129564,
-0.0457489155,
0.0142911682,
0.0255246591,
-0.0158881098,
-0.0257031079,
0.0371204764,
0.0239051729,
0.0218602549,
0.0218495857,
0.0048155384,
0.0189730767,
0.0188073069,
0.0484136231,
0.0153619684,
0.0052732793,
-0.0678354129,
0.0194020327,
-0.0029717798,
0.0336964242,
0.0073443521,
-0.0419927277,
-0.0224519167,
0.0292065013,
-0.0345609747,
-0.0365072563,
0.0314989537,
0.0183849689,
-0.0366075933,
-0.0010952078,
0.1248519421,
0.0208101161,
-0.013246364,
0.0152389798,
-0.0180306472,
0.0484394021,
0.0280129872,
0.0303817801,
-0.0556437336,
-0.0109135322,
-0.0030577988,
0.0081634531,
0.0313416645,
0.0076701967,
-0.0497126058,
-0.1046046913,
-0.0004805858,
0.0320557617,
-0.0426786095,
-0.0054465993,
-0.0387173146,
-0.013791468,
-0.0156029491,
0.0152532542,
0.0149305528,
-0.0542298593,
-0.0318120085,
0.0187484808,
-0.0473659188,
-0.0632732511,
0.0217273179,
-0.0526662022,
0.0580047891,
0.0515193492,
0.0212585386,
-0.0462649427,
-0.0150836911,
0.0610404499,
0.0001661713,
0.0185285211,
-0.0214550272,
0.0444827825,
-0.0321567543,
-0.0056817089,
0.0401928946,
-0.024063902,
0.0078483066,
0.0009219502,
0.0277152006,
0.0289955568,
0.0096341362,
-0.042106621,
0.0077489829,
-0.0264914017,
-0.0032796534,
0.0658457503,
0.0298312716,
-0.0474235937,
-0.0017355839,
0.0197137874,
-0.0483075939,
0.0050502266,
-0.0132343872,
0.0061529656,
-0.0416184589,
-0.0266334675,
-0.0239461921,
-0.0127419727,
0.0160695445,
0.0133768404,
0.0222492423,
0.0443442389,
0.0000614386,
0.017428752,
-0.0282272976,
0.0089165466,
-0.0314589068,
0.0259814262,
-0.0724349469,
-0.0433833189,
0.0557346679,
-0.002185548,
-0.0027566671,
-0.0209641494,
-0.0802281722,
-0.0527144335,
0.0097971819,
0.0213908441,
0.0203513578,
0.0423142016,
0.040953394,
-0.0909758583,
0.0244451053,
-0.023448823,
-0.031866841,
0.023140965,
0.0255680606,
-0.0145570338,
0.0126410387,
0.0451700985,
-0.0383407623,
0.0346601494,
0.0153613947,
0.0163997747,
-0.0139560979,
-0.019834796,
-0.0172200371,
0.0139611699,
0.0044268556,
-0.0342148766,
0.0164283775,
-0.0522056893,
0.0046588262,
-0.0183972176,
0.0030921972,
-0.0193316359,
0.018138228,
0.0362539031,
-0.002194077,
-0.0271668956,
-0.0080244048,
-0.0346379317,
0.0191252586,
0.0143699115,
0.044752147,
-0.0152573111,
-0.0050603775,
0.0731287524,
0.0079116328,
-0.0499226712,
-0.0045359791,
-0.0221082959,
0.017602969,
-0.0161994491,
0.0214044824,
-0.012344406,
-0.0178140588,
-0.0322715938,
0.0130543318,
-0.0312365163,
-0.0753747523,
-0.0174019877,
0.0594779812,
0.0512908548,
-0.0361318029,
0.0172635652,
-0.0404259451,
0.009739236,
-0.0473509505,
0.0078664217,
-0.0280323308,
-0.0436985046,
0.0526546948,
0.0184827335,
-0.0568242036,
0.0302250385,
0.0856850147,
0.0546385832,
0.029287314,
0.0057780021,
0.0198981836,
-0.0255406443,
0.0216619726,
0.0158046037,
0.0433525667,
-0.0401289836,
0.051422216,
-0.0394826345,
-0.0721960962,
-0.0097200042,
-0.0068765483,
-0.0034930191,
0.0097502368,
0.0220905021,
0.0666215792,
0.0064056707,
0.0246118251,
-0.0383942202,
0.0093348119,
0.0005586598,
-0.0074431901,
0.0302592628,
-6.036426141e-33,
-0.0256565679,
0.0044920729,
0.0306084137,
0.0063546617,
-0.0370409153,
0.0131411124,
-0.0135896271,
0.0085739819,
-0.0145553509,
-0.0021191561,
-0.0259032901,
0.0105691198,
0.0031999557,
0.0110157989,
0.0287445225,
0.0201387424,
0.0788680613,
-0.0051097679,
0.0024874362,
0.0041786819,
0.00990438,
0.0397044383,
0.0290370919,
-0.0195771176,
-0.0121707264,
-0.0015806992,
0.0173777398,
0.0158718973,
0.0251779296,
0.0699182451,
-0.0414364561,
0.0414964668,
0.0268527828,
-0.026905952,
-0.0281531923,
-0.0079895463,
-0.025562942,
-0.017912779,
0.0382254645,
0.0212910213,
0.0016937018,
-0.0090052597,
0.0198687613,
-0.0193449929,
-0.0419849902,
0.0066786124,
0.0197359044,
-0.0393041037,
-0.0718519911,
0.0257546119,
-0.0668329,
0.049189698,
0.0467397496,
0.0149921356,
0.0389611237,
-0.0069485218,
-0.0093018711,
-0.0237141214,
0.0132530387,
0.0294479523,
0.0799902454,
0.0553187877,
0.0328719839,
0.0624253824,
0.002059713,
0.0572900921,
0.0275904704,
-0.0207021404,
0.010085931,
-0.0190998055,
0.0507098772,
0.0198834911,
0.0289692506,
0.0277426429,
0.0312233027,
-0.0471799374,
-0.0600546375,
-0.0188588575,
0.007484864,
0.0700538084,
0.0437500253,
0.0360021405,
-0.0316849425,
-0.0398767143,
-0.0640500635,
0.0054068645,
-0.0341368429,
-0.0465709902,
0.0580717064,
0.0407479219,
-0.0006495548,
-0.0386815444,
0.0407331288,
-0.0487337485,
-0.0711785853,
0.0218291413,
-0.0066585592,
-0.0055427086,
-0.0387102254,
0.0217496175,
-0.0721036941,
-0.058142744,
-0.0182715245,
-0.0061656297,
-0.0103951711,
-0.0224412046,
-0.0131167825,
0.0241399016,
-0.0743315816,
-0.0182436276,
-0.0076374002,
-0.0398603044,
0.0231214594,
0.0315367132,
0.0513912924,
-0.0023294517,
-0.0009524953,
0.0610059053,
0.0013769362,
-0.0707532912,
-0.0225272495,
-0.0443407148,
0.0153317153,
0.0551846176,
-0.0505613051,
0.0146645606,
-0.0507871546,
0.0157668963,
0.0473357923,
-0.0139356898,
-0.0240562055,
-0.0022137191,
2.491e-7,
0.0237696301,
0.0776604488,
-0.0278148782,
0.0150455758,
0.0046806834,
-0.0010710746,
-0.0394252911,
0.0175032709,
-0.030795455,
0.0152800567,
-0.0062912581,
0.0370993912,
0.0494266339,
-0.0002216669,
-0.0628911927,
-0.0009296666,
-0.0476438813,
0.0443529375,
-0.0524071194,
-0.0067676296,
0.023281889,
0.1121007651,
0.0211793091,
-0.0157610103,
-0.02512113,
-0.0625309572,
0.062583454,
-0.0540561192,
-0.0253700707,
0.0302069634,
0.0181949455,
0.0865298212,
0.0011289418,
0.0167542286,
-0.0248922054,
0.0372039713,
-0.0099805407,
0.0427116081,
-0.0216562953,
0.035017781,
0.0374281816,
-0.0077278526,
-0.0403052643,
-0.0566528104,
0.0532876998,
-0.0429616459,
0.0001963518,
-0.0565155409,
0.0282557774,
-0.0148036256,
0.0245390777,
-0.0331421942,
-0.0386336297,
0.0169700813,
0.0270571224,
-0.0170994774,
-0.0123109929,
-0.0562772714,
0.0061751786,
0.0274057873,
-0.0364790596,
-0.0690928325,
-0.0484960414,
-0.0050804466,
0.0191671625,
0.0030329013,
0.0172921382,
2.007309281e-34,
0.0827994943,
-0.0170562677,
0.0069957441,
0.0195630547,
0.0169958863,
-0.0234476253,
0.012727553,
0.0218074899,
-0.0164138172,
-0.1003293321,
0.0093777552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16495v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16495v2 | OTCE: Hybrid SSM and Attention with Cross Domain Mixture of Experts to construct Observer-Thinker-Conceiver-Expresser | 2024-06-24T10:05:23 | 2024-06-25T02:20:14 | Jingze Shi, Ting Xie, Bingheng Wu, Chunjun Zheng, Kai Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent research has shown that combining Mamba with Transformer architecture,
which has selective state space and quadratic self-attention mechanism,
outperforms using Mamba or Transformer architecture alone in language modeling
tasks. The quadratic self-attention mechanism effectively alleviates the
shortcomings of selective state space in handling long-term dependencies of any
element in the sequence. We propose a position information injection method
that connects the selective state space model with the quadratic attention, and
integrates these two architectures with hybrid experts with cross-sharing
domains, so that we can enjoy the advantages of both. We design a new
architecture with a more biomimetic idea: Observer-Thinker-Conceiver-Expresser
(OTCE), which can compete with well-known medium-scale open-source language
models on a small scale in language modeling tasks. | [
0.040632531,
0.0482226089,
-0.0009745553,
0.0257327072,
-0.0241871197,
-0.0057222559,
0.029354291,
-0.0357716419,
0.0061792182,
-0.0363443755,
-0.0550972894,
-0.0390607081,
-0.0121606207,
0.0710639209,
0.0337688401,
-0.0239294134,
0.0454069525,
-0.0222767889,
0.0028945496,
0.0158494711,
0.0019363161,
-0.0357627869,
0.0050892825,
0.0544121824,
0.0106595103,
0.0089430874,
-0.0593973435,
-0.0140907317,
0.0252250507,
-0.0116020702,
-0.0334771723,
0.0290205479,
0.0468834415,
0.0436857045,
0.0000019198,
-0.0056904373,
0.0002487858,
-0.0094484175,
0.0034014184,
-0.0370453037,
-0.0191910956,
-0.0309059564,
-0.0421974659,
0.020275062,
-0.026883753,
-0.013685314,
0.0643527806,
0.0216973051,
0.0718531311,
0.122174412,
-0.0133684324,
-0.0191987976,
0.0484933369,
-0.0484161824,
-0.0090633566,
-0.0313439369,
0.0235231183,
-0.0408604257,
0.0298295803,
0.0314973071,
-0.0683288053,
0.0749723837,
0.0307481196,
-0.0197002999,
0.022557199,
0.0149024045,
0.0345975272,
-0.0218625069,
-0.0560485274,
0.0333596468,
-0.0142089166,
-0.0249609202,
-0.0048621451,
0.0096696112,
0.0052357852,
-0.0016780453,
-0.0371356867,
0.0011179703,
0.0082444381,
0.03623759,
0.0344183482,
0.0199329834,
0.0062891236,
-0.0135639934,
-0.0628830492,
0.0928765535,
0.0079347454,
-0.043387752,
-0.0464732721,
-0.0005109773,
0.0198199097,
-0.0493724532,
0.0431239419,
0.0831787512,
-0.0054082577,
0.0065458617,
-0.0552703515,
-0.0574917272,
-0.0568372346,
-0.0359167308,
0.0540559329,
0.0550801046,
0.0042833239,
0.0420819037,
0.0040444839,
0.0357052125,
-0.0667417124,
0.015080167,
-0.0493557416,
0.0172264036,
-0.0425610282,
-0.0164020471,
-0.0186689403,
0.0210549831,
-0.0342464037,
-0.0572868697,
-0.0035193844,
0.0483112969,
0.0082624685,
-0.0432313457,
0.0155609408,
0.0166789517,
-0.0241872147,
-0.0187201779,
-0.0261391606,
0.0686965734,
0.0166400447,
-0.0004364469,
0.0332039781,
-0.063085027,
-0.0250548627,
0.02942832,
-0.0050932867,
-0.0084923105,
-0.0375139453,
0.0660096258,
-0.0068555097,
-0.0528695434,
0.00516108,
0.0012623679,
-0.0167284478,
-0.0587878004,
0.0270367172,
-0.0266398322,
0.0229222346,
-0.0079460908,
-0.0137395831,
-0.0623422675,
0.0297783557,
-0.0009426813,
-0.0179382786,
0.0384657905,
-0.0068832394,
-0.0065826541,
0.0044370522,
-0.0031396328,
0.0213398598,
0.0667750463,
0.049638804,
-0.020268416,
-0.0249099545,
0.0126002487,
0.0064176638,
0.0328412391,
0.0118803456,
-0.0117736682,
-0.04631304,
-0.0114789503,
-0.0340448059,
0.027258426,
0.0318813808,
0.026439162,
0.0320197865,
-0.0000077974,
0.0460869037,
0.0167945642,
0.0243438166,
0.0408268236,
0.0637405887,
0.0108121764,
-0.0329145789,
0.0061659859,
-0.01285291,
0.0720495433,
0.0188622177,
0.0188162476,
0.0404749885,
0.0495516695,
-0.0138277765,
-0.0305165872,
0.0038807162,
-0.016218679,
-0.0289485678,
0.0150109557,
0.06166704,
0.00129583,
-0.0757327601,
0.0739372522,
0.0037530116,
-0.0341415703,
-0.0070698424,
-0.0158618242,
0.0002188047,
0.062681891,
0.014831393,
-0.0370630026,
-0.0252244901,
-0.0267685428,
-0.0004988019,
0.0650176257,
0.032641612,
0.055499889,
-0.0394677073,
-0.019089641,
-0.0532168895,
0.0125665097,
-0.0014460081,
0.020676041,
-0.0129262414,
0.0254958458,
0.0182586592,
0.0314589776,
0.0298226122,
0.019379206,
-0.0138231469,
0.0049764747,
-0.0407647491,
-0.0054116426,
0.0453286842,
0.0149697829,
-0.0038113133,
0.0459069721,
0.0264017079,
-0.0318606608,
-0.0099054854,
0.0199765731,
-0.0881964788,
-0.0483998992,
0.0456829295,
-0.0148470365,
0.017210437,
0.0334044956,
0.007560607,
-0.0931808054,
0.0426696613,
-0.0660326108,
0.0357008502,
-0.0279607233,
0.0204648599,
0.0229549967,
0.0556121804,
-0.0038061072,
0.0323672667,
-0.0122195436,
-0.0174247716,
0.0134373279,
0.0344951712,
-0.0073178583,
-0.0153775001,
-0.0167059731,
-0.0437858775,
-0.0129885692,
0.0144949313,
-0.0223094746,
-0.0352053791,
-0.0153928176,
-0.0386050455,
-0.0530325621,
-0.0033128872,
-0.031490054,
0.0326949209,
-0.003014286,
0.049855724,
0.008178765,
0.0151481861,
-0.0438754968,
0.0082323477,
-0.0027760249,
-0.0022805152,
-0.0049687945,
-0.0035610234,
-0.0209558345,
-0.0222126953,
-0.0227306262,
-0.0249163955,
0.0399299003,
-0.0103544276,
-0.0345912091,
-0.0635953546,
0.0029389206,
-0.0261612516,
0.0655156896,
-0.0073121474,
-0.0299602058,
0.0094328569,
-0.034930665,
0.0380233303,
0.030022854,
0.0094256075,
0.0160501003,
0.0281548388,
-0.0304167904,
-0.0018117969,
0.0523119941,
-0.0147746513,
0.054495655,
-0.0245639421,
0.0625764653,
0.0221172199,
0.1091335937,
-0.0374152735,
-0.0275180303,
-0.0632421523,
0.0103627816,
0.0245937724,
-0.0330097713,
0.0658864677,
-0.0204718318,
-0.0777872205,
0.0324002132,
-0.0321176983,
-0.0176952966,
0.0875001326,
-0.0314897783,
-0.031195987,
-0.0161361489,
0.0035500005,
-0.052787926,
-0.0104293749,
-0.0131962635,
0.0046980614,
-0.02150172,
0.0012754817,
-0.015769165,
0.0505869649,
-0.0244812258,
-0.0107443258,
0.0104659498,
-0.0032510983,
0.0251577664,
-0.0018716851,
-0.0219692606,
-0.0221473854,
0.0314836875,
-0.0634189919,
0.0243033636,
0.0339137875,
-0.0156588741,
-0.0592722259,
0.0776002854,
0.032400243,
0.0416935459,
-0.0273511875,
0.0083940895,
-0.0479051396,
0.016528612,
0.0548658893,
0.034305077,
-0.0068424498,
-0.024277145,
0.018339619,
0.0329579972,
0.0671469271,
-0.0102048069,
-0.006394729,
0.0070713689,
0.0318318494,
-0.017535463,
-0.0164734814,
0.0185263157,
0.0356814377,
-0.080187209,
-0.0477111302,
0.1106002852,
0.0110394377,
-0.0478608534,
-0.0053644516,
-0.0254480503,
0.0023547052,
0.0340886116,
0.0306347981,
-0.0438019522,
-0.0393148176,
-0.0082463305,
-0.0232876297,
0.0163952168,
-0.0004333453,
-0.0253491309,
-0.0715917423,
0.0003630532,
0.0251322817,
-0.0943665802,
-0.0632076487,
0.0095944777,
0.013948842,
0.0302478839,
-0.0312427431,
0.0581719205,
0.0057749627,
-0.0221908744,
0.0339211188,
-0.0096669663,
-0.0440922715,
-0.0202451386,
-0.0227486826,
0.0132107893,
0.0674939975,
-0.0142244566,
0.0256358497,
-0.0619294122,
0.0246400554,
-0.005493796,
0.0313748233,
-0.0109451823,
0.000125686,
-0.030129388,
-0.0483271256,
-0.0183095485,
0.0113724861,
-0.0357742868,
0.0228350628,
-0.0420147441,
0.1333203167,
-0.0172617231,
-0.0047319098,
-0.0240307171,
-0.0031127147,
0.0006797133,
0.0208116807,
0.0502730273,
-0.0603787228,
-0.0659340024,
-0.0206658356,
-0.0169194769,
-0.029181283,
-0.040836174,
-0.0062308135,
0.0421290807,
-0.101316005,
-0.0396926515,
-0.0428304598,
0.0217323266,
0.0566327125,
0.0182423498,
0.0196512807,
0.0623199232,
-0.0352971628,
-0.0480717979,
-0.0178540777,
-0.0250973552,
0.0170343015,
-0.0286427177,
0.015191664,
0.0465787686,
-0.0007424331,
-0.0029230067,
0.0131929116,
-0.0659395903,
-0.0815173835,
-0.0136965858,
0.0777784288,
0.0222309735,
0.0180955827,
-0.0358952507,
-0.0303351674,
0.0618868731,
-0.0055120112,
-0.0483414233,
0.0150515828,
0.0469256602,
-0.0212784912,
0.0142045133,
0.0253322646,
-0.0057250732,
-0.0188630316,
0.0204048902,
0.0435289852,
-0.0302315522,
-0.0364558138,
-0.0092911618,
-0.0515340455,
0.0491525419,
0.0123241888,
0.0396418013,
-0.0155659113,
0.0495435037,
0.0004400353,
0.0202065799,
-0.095415771,
0.0070305266,
0.0111301877,
0.0052517308,
0.0492546819,
-0.0127563411,
-0.0103989579,
-0.0327636115,
0.0321968347,
0.0614981391,
0.000312365,
-0.007161695,
0.0251968447,
-0.0027000243,
0.0028709627,
-0.0049138358,
0.013404862,
0.0189851597,
-0.0247779936,
0.0605409332,
0.0146634551,
0.0087861829,
-0.0007920944,
0.0067740087,
-0.0723212808,
-0.0259638894,
-0.016929619,
0.0343599878,
0.0704752505,
-0.0000618286,
0.0688220933,
0.029797215,
-0.0081734974,
-0.0175996404,
0.0748791918,
-0.0288321991,
-0.0437905826,
0.0252324324,
0.0190654099,
0.0107547585,
0.0047484897,
0.0512991361,
0.0150932027,
-0.0057549039,
-0.0006554382,
-0.0213453323,
-0.0337607153,
-0.0077211382,
-0.002748928,
0.0105165746,
-0.008317152,
0.0202154852,
-0.0798324421,
-0.0752174482,
0.0142076854,
-0.0257254466,
-0.0120489802,
-0.0343049206,
0.046865724,
-0.0043523409,
0.0001798427,
-0.0066001099,
-0.021045411,
-0.0217054915,
0.0206969865,
-0.052553948,
0.0202008076,
-6.4576965e-33,
-0.0325250924,
-0.0026203585,
0.0163276922,
-0.0201608371,
-0.0493198372,
-0.0334987938,
-0.0704839453,
0.0056904461,
0.0110590979,
-0.0134692974,
-0.0301103983,
0.0152144767,
0.0052767065,
0.0364478864,
0.0250234231,
0.0018399261,
0.0221521258,
0.0108409859,
-0.0016351419,
0.009782413,
0.0266521182,
0.0832322836,
0.0790378302,
-0.0148678888,
-0.0062612751,
0.0235544257,
0.0483496562,
-0.0076619131,
-0.0406407006,
0.0488365293,
-0.0200065002,
0.0354007073,
0.0144306207,
-0.0557061099,
-0.0486991182,
0.0275308359,
-0.0179099739,
-0.0192496963,
0.001217066,
0.0147549231,
-0.0123874377,
-0.0253567137,
0.0463715792,
0.0161738489,
0.0211356468,
-0.022032734,
0.0390878059,
-0.0212457925,
-0.0387236066,
-0.0027610231,
-0.0379711799,
0.0195898581,
-0.0036421828,
-0.0227252115,
0.0445973128,
0.0284337588,
-0.0121073443,
-0.0312773995,
-0.0123884045,
0.0082248263,
0.0175084863,
0.0755556524,
0.0630084723,
0.0341018848,
0.000380985,
0.0003307206,
0.0234543439,
-0.0319403484,
-0.0283885188,
-0.0064177588,
0.0302124005,
0.0164185967,
0.0476366244,
-0.0280539859,
-0.0256244056,
0.0029352447,
-0.0226863921,
-0.0278690979,
0.0064809001,
0.0530791208,
0.0278577786,
0.040316157,
-0.0254046563,
-0.0275217071,
0.0220725257,
-0.0164192338,
-0.040749941,
-0.0255130623,
0.0217211191,
0.0081078894,
-0.0288592502,
0.0308418497,
0.0752921402,
-0.0459490903,
0.0045164493,
0.0013266957,
0.0028368013,
0.0321796648,
0.0106494511,
0.0130271753,
-0.0836980268,
-0.0140556591,
0.0204340741,
0.0280701406,
-0.0229314864,
-0.032612443,
-0.0168834981,
0.0452382118,
-0.073614195,
-0.020537816,
-0.051821582,
-0.0048912326,
0.0180326011,
0.015285532,
0.0473739207,
-0.0279247146,
-0.0173236243,
0.0565969422,
-0.002118066,
-0.032092493,
-0.0132024409,
0.0188079141,
-0.0191765744,
0.0389235094,
-0.036478091,
0.0109475171,
-0.0669324398,
0.0665852353,
-0.004864621,
-0.0738036111,
-0.0243373308,
0.0445183888,
2.846e-7,
0.0405806489,
0.0046803812,
0.0450193956,
-0.0173147675,
0.0490215421,
0.0221190043,
-0.0139481546,
0.0505913682,
0.0162833445,
0.0237437729,
0.0069688922,
0.0268499367,
0.053780634,
-0.0453866608,
-0.1329020262,
-0.0328296013,
-0.0545454323,
0.0300109927,
-0.0407122187,
-0.0133888284,
0.0009152981,
0.0993694216,
0.0059640938,
0.0024568676,
-0.0111602051,
-0.0063089454,
0.0544669256,
0.0260648783,
0.0219735354,
0.0105873151,
0.0142194265,
0.0080960477,
-0.0630898252,
-0.0252026208,
-0.0088831577,
0.0326041579,
-0.0135419527,
0.0557986498,
0.01205552,
-0.0138338711,
0.0455716439,
0.0449947491,
-0.0256298929,
-0.0294745918,
0.0463797525,
-0.0676197186,
-0.0405862629,
-0.0269240923,
-0.0011912897,
-0.0008996942,
-0.0464519188,
-0.0063112406,
-0.0139533253,
-0.0010737614,
0.0019547779,
-0.0232006907,
0.0004458732,
-0.0502266698,
-0.0351264253,
-0.0303883925,
-0.0733713508,
-0.0083852047,
-0.0586174354,
-0.0156535879,
0.0552036576,
0.0025013236,
-0.0283430666,
2.653560488e-34,
0.0163712818,
-0.0135225737,
0.0109803658,
0.0731776133,
-0.0147421639,
-0.0321508199,
-0.0172755308,
0.0240237489,
0.0481811874,
-0.058282271,
-0.0532566123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16490v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16490v1 | eagerlearners at SemEval2024 Task 5: The Legal Argument Reasoning Task in Civil Procedure | 2024-06-24T09:57:44 | 2024-06-24T09:57:44 | Hoorieh Sabzevari, Mohammadmostafa Rostamkhani, Sauleh Eetemadi | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study investigates the performance of the zero-shot method in
classifying data using three large language models, alongside two models with
large input token sizes and the two pre-trained models on legal data. Our main
dataset comes from the domain of U.S. civil procedure. It includes summaries of
legal cases, specific questions, potential answers, and detailed explanations
for why each solution is relevant, all sourced from a book aimed at law
students. By comparing different methods, we aimed to understand how
effectively they handle the complexities found in legal datasets. Our findings
show how well the zero-shot method of large language models can understand
complicated data. We achieved our highest F1 score of 64% in these experiments. | [
0.0302119981,
0.0632960871,
0.0062745884,
0.0211879387,
-0.0488196239,
0.0429037958,
0.0484066457,
0.0262711179,
-0.0245037135,
-0.1229409948,
0.0048099603,
-0.0256770104,
-0.0143944547,
-0.0125182811,
-0.0066151894,
-0.0698017925,
0.0194939096,
-0.0165763497,
0.0724071786,
0.0050018542,
-0.0043205582,
0.0040309941,
0.0029777884,
0.0103487438,
0.0036884535,
-0.0281658228,
-0.0061902395,
-0.0046800794,
-0.0147576975,
-0.0083026281,
0.0010695419,
0.0983422026,
0.0334972888,
0.060779389,
0.0000017555,
-0.0755711645,
0.0281544216,
0.0049887937,
-0.0633948669,
0.0320623294,
0.0327004679,
-0.0400102362,
0.0118795019,
0.0142795723,
-0.014727056,
-0.0227742139,
0.0012656495,
0.0523837395,
0.0349731185,
0.1056370884,
-0.0059338938,
-0.0984403789,
0.0174991637,
-0.03046331,
0.0337609984,
-0.0291775092,
0.0381044187,
0.0060012694,
0.0374324769,
0.0080247913,
0.0179393999,
-0.0210299082,
0.0468044505,
-0.0213394966,
-0.0210580733,
0.0215355512,
-0.0748736039,
0.0172186084,
0.0252200868,
0.0566026308,
0.0146287307,
-0.0248567909,
-0.0151197352,
-0.0095141595,
0.0303137563,
0.0050595663,
-0.0336573198,
0.0631251261,
-0.0069913138,
0.0229940955,
0.0241618156,
0.0175141376,
0.0089752199,
0.0229238886,
-0.0496096797,
0.049423065,
-0.0311315749,
-0.0144492136,
0.0303905737,
-0.0043887696,
-0.0074862801,
-0.0688938275,
0.0029330205,
0.0647850186,
-0.0186314806,
0.0306275059,
-0.0323489234,
-0.0383063555,
0.0741930902,
-0.0608301833,
0.0222078152,
0.0091198683,
0.0019372458,
0.0849516019,
-0.049672015,
0.0044880477,
0.0081154527,
0.0171383284,
0.0055666086,
-0.0381882153,
-0.0802492201,
-0.0085149705,
-0.0181213357,
0.0581640154,
-0.0433950312,
-0.0070463633,
-0.027089145,
-0.0232952703,
-0.0159808006,
0.0058318386,
-0.020665016,
-0.0179779623,
0.0041535972,
-0.0312267728,
-0.0667784661,
-0.0234747455,
-0.060914807,
0.0398284718,
0.0070485477,
-0.0171794742,
0.005931763,
0.0041517708,
0.0192583743,
-0.0122563401,
-0.0046847756,
0.0691195726,
-0.0206822883,
-0.0211623348,
-0.0552972667,
-0.0557106063,
0.0029700571,
-0.0872345492,
-0.0412686169,
-0.0808705837,
0.0001223719,
-0.0117131025,
-0.020514017,
-0.0302186143,
0.0062358109,
0.040445365,
-0.015019659,
0.075463444,
0.005995628,
-0.018584026,
0.0015636192,
0.0284667201,
0.0024062411,
0.0618477911,
-0.0256951787,
0.0106556285,
0.0234587882,
-0.0224988163,
0.0586472452,
0.0007693614,
-0.0034889281,
0.0138470838,
0.0062447796,
0.0361851715,
-0.0276184659,
0.0322844088,
-0.0089992024,
0.0234476998,
-0.0313418694,
-0.0512696505,
-0.0003115016,
0.0690706,
0.015372593,
0.0082441531,
0.0142705636,
-0.0042792554,
0.0363810696,
-0.0104244715,
-0.039191775,
-0.0135472147,
-0.0372954533,
-0.0146111026,
-0.0357922427,
-0.0109047387,
-0.043407049,
-0.0627391711,
-0.0229790229,
-0.0222711228,
-0.0128004113,
0.0218036938,
0.0482365377,
0.0031590941,
-0.0172781516,
0.0141687905,
0.0233111922,
-0.0163854565,
-0.0430466905,
-0.0244436655,
0.0189120732,
0.0085387034,
0.0117741451,
-0.054032471,
-0.0375684313,
-0.0368727036,
0.0809793174,
0.0272458494,
0.0530391037,
-0.0126745356,
-0.0040470762,
-0.0396385752,
-0.0435297079,
-0.0197747964,
0.0472836047,
-0.0003189621,
0.0040713875,
0.0207867399,
0.0375574082,
-0.0340684764,
-0.0100155445,
0.0329679176,
-0.0135114016,
-0.0524688326,
0.0353625529,
-0.0070970375,
0.0338246524,
0.0155197121,
0.0057583963,
-0.0122669442,
0.0068732225,
-0.0202066246,
0.0003344302,
-0.0105174892,
0.0022340042,
-0.0096986704,
0.0469374508,
-0.0458212942,
-0.0381785035,
-0.0102789477,
-0.0630696416,
-0.0177446324,
-0.0117876111,
0.0109706558,
-0.0133083407,
-0.0238405243,
-0.005616697,
-0.0204290841,
0.0073826043,
-0.0308378115,
0.0650936738,
0.0489927009,
-0.0014640244,
0.0089013111,
-0.0150383255,
0.0546859391,
-0.0334998071,
-0.0156678893,
0.0066801794,
-0.0286474545,
0.0073206886,
0.0090862792,
-0.0180856939,
-0.0369277187,
-0.0131703326,
-0.0772005469,
0.0020510254,
-0.0294864252,
0.0061366167,
-0.0143777011,
-0.0609356873,
-0.0006095723,
-0.0117338514,
-0.0418838784,
-0.0049582031,
-0.007424558,
0.009584073,
0.030195117,
-0.0107620964,
0.001034918,
-0.0055704955,
-0.0167936347,
-0.0332891271,
0.0625467971,
0.0375985168,
0.032136187,
-0.0102644647,
0.0566318184,
-0.0017390323,
-0.0294277221,
-0.0139745912,
0.0049511846,
0.0104881311,
0.0088028368,
-0.0387699045,
0.0446332023,
0.0136173852,
0.0235945079,
0.0076550604,
0.019955175,
-0.0560452193,
-0.0230195019,
0.0052603125,
0.0289377086,
-0.0399297923,
-0.0181429423,
-0.0104957074,
0.0394815505,
-0.0316072032,
-0.002489222,
-0.0380903035,
0.0634454414,
0.0057399897,
-0.0045429328,
-0.024749225,
-0.0086152963,
0.0217235424,
0.0654148832,
0.0045135231,
-0.0334005095,
0.0511334911,
0.0151302889,
0.0527798533,
-0.0413759723,
-0.0055300212,
-0.0618667081,
0.0833124593,
-0.003699861,
-0.0097640213,
0.0129373856,
-0.0281208269,
0.0135936365,
-0.0345989652,
0.0487050414,
-0.0319417343,
0.0846760273,
-0.0029803969,
0.017735742,
-0.033403866,
-0.0328745246,
-0.0394891016,
-0.0683981404,
-0.0248506591,
0.039073348,
-0.0184258837,
0.0096599301,
-0.0548770651,
-0.0133564584,
-0.0214138124,
0.0219256431,
0.0023502302,
-0.0187194031,
-0.0040554283,
0.0119594801,
0.0128368344,
0.000435536,
0.0167693458,
-0.0275345854,
0.060337998,
0.0223138444,
0.0229824428,
0.0340431929,
-0.0038019451,
-0.0050091622,
-0.0068445993,
-0.0726007149,
-0.016717406,
0.0225453172,
0.004300992,
-0.0612331815,
0.0452515408,
0.1170432121,
0.0296622571,
-0.0197477471,
-0.0047208131,
-0.020853648,
0.0145732481,
0.0461190715,
0.0279285163,
-0.1158341765,
-0.0104181953,
0.0005543177,
-0.0171985179,
-0.0465988927,
-0.0411923081,
0.0130900526,
-0.1323579103,
0.0695839599,
0.0205707233,
-0.0157803558,
-0.0173286535,
-0.0429346301,
0.0168362353,
-0.0134378066,
-0.0072885971,
-0.0113851801,
-0.0349046476,
-0.0126134334,
0.024754528,
-0.0171871241,
-0.0160054825,
0.0581749976,
-0.0314807184,
0.058642868,
-0.010828631,
0.0361480899,
-0.0257324502,
-0.0016631053,
0.0371744893,
0.0002098784,
-0.0195862073,
0.0041267453,
0.0635243803,
0.0179609023,
0.0214611422,
-0.0106214657,
0.0448362865,
-0.0411669277,
-0.0396573097,
0.0502910763,
0.0643341616,
-0.0287817549,
-0.0348035321,
-0.0205867011,
-0.0223895274,
-0.0413769893,
0.0687232316,
0.0276561752,
0.0135129318,
-0.0732386932,
-0.0300361942,
-0.0372214764,
-0.0507095046,
-0.0049924999,
0.0196364615,
-0.0018533369,
-0.0268701818,
-0.0069180857,
-0.0531096905,
0.0468736887,
0.0534250401,
-0.0073438063,
0.0294416659,
-0.0036447407,
0.0051072277,
-0.018188389,
0.035859473,
-0.0297296904,
0.0123350974,
-0.0298746545,
-0.0002085057,
-0.0070346226,
0.0232786871,
-0.0114498334,
-0.0397634245,
-0.0072037731,
-0.0291309301,
-0.0120907752,
0.0051340694,
0.0284951963,
0.0134614753,
-0.0231826603,
-0.0533223264,
0.0378052965,
0.0420289561,
-0.0021969953,
-0.0223128963,
0.0702466667,
-0.0239192341,
-0.0007374743,
0.0070122154,
0.014183444,
0.0331297629,
0.0325437635,
0.0103993071,
-0.0616218224,
0.0120656099,
0.0144253457,
0.0357752033,
0.0346009023,
0.0191925447,
-0.0611511879,
-0.0157451723,
-0.000939953,
-0.0413410626,
-0.0174012966,
-0.0038269628,
-0.010669305,
0.0218877494,
-0.0176248718,
-0.0380076841,
0.0064420355,
-0.0418249555,
0.0253245588,
-0.0428927019,
0.0436808951,
0.0395558849,
-0.0244428497,
-0.0073065078,
-0.0255735591,
-0.0084829098,
0.0236689355,
-0.0039466321,
0.0477946661,
-0.0216000136,
0.0700229332,
0.0261851847,
0.0467632636,
-0.0317468606,
-0.0132821659,
-0.05037608,
-0.0294003952,
0.0188099351,
0.036336951,
0.0331494063,
-0.0391041562,
-0.0041817953,
-0.0006744292,
-0.0136665758,
-0.0039559803,
0.0361196175,
-0.0080423187,
-0.0039084381,
0.0475168452,
0.0533432513,
-0.0252145957,
0.0165712256,
0.0415625609,
0.0014274064,
0.0058330582,
0.026335502,
-0.020840859,
-0.0185195003,
-0.0135829607,
0.0228905287,
0.0238823388,
-0.0088947844,
-0.0303380601,
-0.0864369795,
-0.0553419404,
-0.0126764858,
0.0017537768,
-0.0128888246,
0.0426283516,
0.0062579392,
0.0476839617,
0.0124460673,
-0.003383979,
-0.0667529181,
0.0256528854,
0.0091337953,
-0.0276017971,
0.0024891323,
-5.558334956e-33,
-0.0107278107,
-0.0374544486,
0.0035631219,
0.0172873456,
-0.0039255368,
-0.0048222383,
-0.0180885512,
0.002126371,
-0.0328790508,
0.0499945544,
0.0000159789,
0.0229750089,
0.0246972814,
-0.0073455446,
0.0080381026,
-0.0526821278,
-0.0035936597,
0.0105979471,
-0.0147783235,
-0.0013596526,
-0.0055316123,
-0.0079853572,
-0.0137031348,
-0.0688545033,
0.0351626091,
0.0269189402,
0.0086948946,
-0.004447788,
-0.0413484313,
0.0844255462,
-0.0012258642,
0.0580366589,
0.0417592004,
-0.0520360544,
0.0171040315,
0.0468947515,
-0.0696951523,
-0.0127215497,
0.0123348385,
-0.0084872385,
0.0097943572,
-0.0608079992,
0.0255630184,
0.0040893243,
0.0084002642,
-0.0492636859,
0.0498345196,
-0.0461483151,
-0.0273755565,
-0.0408174843,
-0.0976867378,
0.0603110418,
-0.0396533199,
0.0048215473,
0.0395414717,
0.0468867868,
-0.0027573744,
0.0737799034,
-0.0473629795,
-0.0067478954,
0.0088499356,
-0.0185024012,
0.0099995956,
-0.0284241308,
-0.0147657786,
0.0552567728,
0.0337247811,
0.0120495548,
-0.0711865872,
0.0082745217,
0.0325095803,
0.063567467,
0.0428681895,
0.0473834202,
0.0717087016,
-0.0155571466,
-0.0897574946,
-0.036544133,
0.0516725592,
0.0201716609,
0.0183111187,
-0.0394371301,
-0.0297479834,
-0.0252415575,
-0.0559426211,
-0.0308699235,
-0.0345101804,
-0.0053963992,
0.0100484863,
0.0016247074,
0.0241057053,
-0.0015064611,
0.0337921977,
-0.0331329554,
-0.0173175205,
0.043401964,
0.0213860404,
0.0245998129,
-0.0116818203,
0.0417682938,
-0.043186307,
-0.0364983715,
0.0210743584,
-0.0173732601,
0.0499572344,
-0.0242762864,
0.0749076679,
-0.0326668955,
-0.0537269302,
-0.0459087379,
-0.0222995523,
0.0004185476,
0.0077572553,
0.0676770136,
0.0084646093,
0.0615586378,
0.0376602449,
0.0288388785,
0.015846204,
-0.052212093,
-0.0129254181,
-0.007923835,
-0.0192064978,
-0.0217662025,
0.0141341612,
-0.0118438983,
0.0207161289,
0.015412787,
0.034570571,
-0.0273402054,
0.0226855185,
0.0494940355,
2.459e-7,
0.0829623789,
0.0533565283,
-0.0333610214,
-0.0024941058,
-0.0068546627,
0.0443755612,
-0.0213605277,
0.0073634507,
0.0404058173,
-0.0225684233,
0.015689062,
0.0355716795,
0.0651907101,
0.0528577901,
-0.0771247819,
-0.0332640409,
-0.0397480689,
-0.0473956987,
-0.055625584,
0.0457394384,
0.1016549617,
0.1076052561,
0.0211205948,
-0.0136824241,
-0.0040294803,
-0.0082230465,
0.0365981087,
-0.030663874,
-0.0037735512,
0.0171895493,
0.0608517118,
-0.0458277166,
0.0276249517,
0.0710742697,
0.0023241625,
0.0364687033,
-0.0317139663,
0.0643757358,
-0.0154962251,
0.0243646558,
-0.0321135744,
-0.0418769605,
0.0123853693,
-0.0387615673,
0.0854178593,
-0.0645052716,
-0.0521679595,
-0.0049719177,
-0.0395001471,
-0.0345021263,
0.0399998501,
0.0274034999,
-0.0084459363,
-0.0002040152,
0.0356855616,
-0.0406379625,
0.0168412048,
-0.0861436278,
-0.0027115594,
0.0447654612,
-0.0399718732,
0.0403447524,
0.0063096946,
-0.0139780231,
0.0804534256,
-0.0485121235,
0.0262218956,
2.084706859e-34,
0.0482460037,
-0.0030582855,
0.0081732413,
0.0387827195,
0.0399875268,
0.0344814509,
-0.0139211165,
0.0078679435,
0.0089489026,
-0.0678215176,
0.0246828217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16489v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16489v1 | Deepfake tweets automatic detection | 2024-06-24T09:55:31 | 2024-06-24T09:55:31 | Adam Frej, Adrian Kaminski, Piotr Marciniak, Szymon Szmajdzinski, Soveatin Kuntur, Anna Wroblewska | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study addresses the critical challenge of detecting DeepFake tweets by
leveraging advanced natural language processing (NLP) techniques to distinguish
between genuine and AI-generated texts. Given the increasing prevalence of
misinformation, our research utilizes the TweepFake dataset to train and
evaluate various machine learning models. The objective is to identify
effective strategies for recognizing DeepFake content, thereby enhancing the
integrity of digital communications. By developing reliable methods for
detecting AI-generated misinformation, this work contributes to a more
trustworthy online information environment. | [
0.0785520002,
0.0381814837,
-0.0066083763,
0.0492381342,
-0.0586152636,
-0.0082594911,
0.0460567884,
0.0203196034,
0.028344579,
-0.0456401967,
0.0026700282,
-0.0438929573,
-0.0090709226,
0.0988626257,
0.0090535823,
-0.0237280838,
0.0399018973,
0.0200026408,
0.0509357341,
0.0086175194,
0.0082947761,
0.0309947487,
-0.0115441252,
0.0506690964,
-0.0540809445,
-0.036449451,
0.0329576917,
0.0060474174,
0.0379295647,
-0.0099754827,
0.0241297614,
0.0338847265,
-0.0027835644,
0.0978725031,
0.0000017626,
-0.022235211,
-0.0191936959,
-0.0191604961,
-0.0547930971,
0.0103400135,
0.0721649155,
-0.0094422363,
-0.0259248074,
0.0217253603,
-0.0517347939,
0.007366207,
0.0581725352,
0.0757070109,
0.0706969574,
0.1037650779,
-0.0369836763,
-0.007386507,
0.0478938743,
0.0230349824,
-0.0240235887,
-0.0423179306,
0.0221357383,
-0.0449698605,
-0.0606819987,
0.0107344873,
0.0183023084,
0.0128196431,
0.014783402,
-0.0477941558,
-0.005657807,
-0.0241267998,
-0.0449756123,
-0.0823337361,
0.0039493949,
0.0515676551,
-0.0348115675,
-0.0491416529,
0.0339540429,
-0.0243195742,
-0.0061899731,
0.0201337915,
0.0098939659,
0.0368006714,
-0.0278843977,
-0.0050494722,
0.0032073348,
-0.003642231,
0.0513591617,
0.0504849814,
0.0165867601,
0.0384435505,
-0.0135591626,
-0.0212675426,
-0.0202781111,
-0.0293969773,
0.0164999217,
-0.0736590028,
0.0405650921,
0.0042502582,
-0.009294915,
-0.0241780374,
-0.0755509436,
-0.0526092723,
0.0073308796,
-0.0360647887,
0.0052789357,
-0.0054541705,
-0.0389749371,
0.0247115809,
0.0137857404,
-0.0020833206,
-0.0029386398,
0.0275103897,
0.0302326549,
-0.0165462084,
-0.008577521,
0.0046480419,
-0.0107900491,
0.0073080719,
-0.0010388461,
-0.002415979,
-0.0876405761,
-0.0176811926,
-0.021161342,
0.0133144734,
-0.0161095262,
0.0115095358,
-0.0329041481,
0.0102433646,
-0.011526457,
0.0324263349,
0.0120459236,
0.0413142629,
-0.0082774702,
-0.0824695975,
0.0158004258,
0.0297606643,
0.0463570468,
-0.0080569703,
0.0296371039,
0.0382934064,
0.0351842232,
-0.0554968975,
-0.0414711535,
-0.0562442541,
-0.025208272,
-0.0456190445,
-0.0058774492,
-0.0654488206,
-0.0054922267,
-0.0348895304,
-0.0105830068,
-0.0129390331,
-0.0239172801,
0.0184363909,
-0.0379821062,
0.0316910632,
-0.0385354459,
0.0242321342,
0.0354097635,
0.0096058883,
-0.0080269733,
0.02041962,
0.0503014289,
0.1098630726,
0.0753121227,
-0.0032910926,
0.0312567949,
0.0273936596,
0.0363585204,
-0.0039151898,
0.0238422025,
-0.0151522467,
-0.0895593688,
-0.010820468,
-0.0153831653,
0.0383312926,
-0.0014316071,
-0.0071921628,
0.0653809309,
0.0285332054,
0.0064356979,
0.002835992,
0.0436903425,
0.0496681444,
0.0307349525,
-0.0369984992,
-0.0359229147,
0.0045502982,
-0.0467421263,
-0.0382446162,
0.0183642469,
0.0568710566,
-0.0085866088,
-0.0382755436,
0.0015986006,
-0.0376108699,
0.0436601676,
-0.0319372565,
0.0235447604,
0.0189759023,
-0.0428390503,
-0.0188556816,
-0.0258750468,
-0.0057807434,
-0.0306647439,
-0.0566058308,
0.0156899802,
0.0150525598,
0.0229480676,
-0.0126322983,
0.0352342799,
-0.054909315,
0.0224030875,
0.0481026508,
-0.0052900948,
0.0040024202,
0.0179530326,
0.0039252336,
-0.0307859648,
-0.0244095847,
-0.0030672499,
-0.007440134,
0.0387507267,
0.022670975,
0.0223490596,
0.0133312736,
-0.0552337877,
0.0002701181,
0.0081603257,
-0.0188535489,
0.0088741984,
0.0275846459,
0.0163652245,
0.0498368405,
-0.0116247702,
-0.0134201488,
0.0120617338,
0.0062380182,
-0.0411986932,
-0.0185691882,
-0.010306119,
0.0193945933,
0.0122927101,
-0.0818499923,
-0.0486203693,
0.0788969621,
-0.0597399026,
0.0074641234,
0.0624433681,
-0.0203258675,
0.0090095438,
-0.0557739399,
-0.0255892407,
-0.0412772447,
0.0254585445,
0.047561273,
0.0743666589,
-0.021334596,
-0.0506144501,
-0.0418421738,
-0.0129367374,
0.0307908095,
0.0137719316,
0.0131449699,
0.0018883386,
-0.0469951741,
0.029197393,
0.0391179621,
-0.0063979765,
-0.0370919369,
0.0339096598,
-0.0123481378,
-0.0209614411,
-0.029943848,
0.0028690705,
0.0156568773,
0.0027720032,
-0.0003396641,
0.019539617,
0.0158352815,
-0.0128012681,
0.0412761681,
0.0131193763,
0.0248931684,
-0.0386894196,
-0.0023319412,
-0.0197139159,
0.0031704332,
-0.0433228277,
0.0258866008,
0.0460966863,
-0.0406883061,
-0.0141341547,
0.0181865394,
-0.023913458,
-0.0019745254,
0.0013914283,
-0.044734735,
0.0142911412,
0.0244223364,
-0.0539198443,
0.0466519184,
0.0343244635,
0.0666410327,
0.0037198456,
0.0524183363,
0.0179450624,
-0.0078313444,
-0.0042462246,
0.0115932422,
-0.0197063088,
-0.024923889,
0.0237876736,
0.0430024005,
0.0317390226,
0.003401295,
-0.0133946044,
0.0583935045,
-0.0160323046,
-0.0199138131,
0.0345440693,
-0.0585475042,
-0.0127825337,
0.045581948,
-0.0303703249,
-0.0727161393,
0.0688586235,
-0.0157961156,
0.0182124171,
-0.0210894067,
-0.052596204,
0.0181218665,
0.012319142,
0.006770792,
0.0348251946,
0.0542368926,
-0.0130121512,
0.0232799873,
0.0046681124,
0.042393215,
-0.0167500284,
0.0122785345,
0.0205405876,
0.0216781944,
0.0159544013,
0.0120529421,
-0.0662309974,
-0.0573209897,
-0.0547850356,
-0.0330847912,
0.0025607345,
-0.073724106,
-0.037768241,
-0.0319352411,
0.0388420299,
0.0121047366,
0.0067481953,
0.0118316077,
-0.0041725542,
0.0304181725,
0.0369536728,
-0.0282916036,
0.0396978706,
-0.0112818806,
-0.01819879,
0.045935858,
0.0078522647,
0.0227997657,
-0.0363018177,
-0.041185651,
-0.0354067832,
0.0053995149,
0.0234381389,
0.0070321029,
0.028907543,
-0.0362178832,
0.0039604488,
0.0767761692,
0.0034048154,
0.0066425866,
0.014676881,
0.0492521748,
-0.0248545706,
-0.0124614034,
-0.0244890973,
-0.1044646949,
-0.0309449602,
-0.0159983449,
-0.0096034426,
-0.0604125597,
-0.0252466295,
-0.0164762046,
-0.0928265303,
0.0243381467,
-0.0008675645,
0.0184877235,
-0.0493813343,
-0.0477144644,
-0.0201476682,
0.0026106145,
0.03305161,
-0.064290747,
0.0181026272,
-0.0023265718,
-0.0122743193,
-0.057313215,
-0.0834105462,
0.0361563563,
-0.0445940569,
0.0594331771,
0.0593386292,
0.0598715581,
-0.0500146709,
-0.0201796591,
-0.0039884546,
0.0092625841,
-0.0212168489,
-0.0155236963,
0.0861895159,
-0.0310965162,
-0.01474219,
-0.0056980574,
0.0422806032,
-0.0320815332,
0.0092870928,
-0.0553902872,
0.0329636522,
-0.0252578259,
-0.0495889522,
-0.0140912719,
0.0142007507,
0.037277557,
0.0442033485,
0.0421153791,
-0.0164197218,
-0.0195781067,
-0.0411301963,
0.0129342256,
-0.0362949222,
-0.0663930178,
0.0194735359,
0.0098564466,
-0.022806881,
-0.0577725768,
-0.0130877709,
-0.0168045703,
-0.0061692982,
-0.0283606872,
-0.0267450791,
0.0094482759,
0.004103729,
-0.0429359227,
0.0213240329,
-0.0178953689,
0.0589256436,
-0.0120021477,
-0.0152179515,
-0.0134230293,
-0.0088574653,
-0.0023716944,
0.0553590283,
-0.0833461657,
-0.0656989366,
0.0180921238,
0.0265506376,
0.025992142,
-0.0048966631,
-0.0368541591,
-0.0392322838,
0.0713775009,
0.0734863505,
-0.0226039942,
-0.0361632034,
0.0521870628,
0.0172234699,
0.0198809635,
0.019036714,
-0.0068909894,
0.0106988456,
0.0122260815,
-0.0147105129,
-0.0209930483,
-0.0132861156,
-0.0043551628,
0.0459051691,
0.0535730608,
-0.0135907745,
-0.0106770899,
-0.016784301,
-0.0524356999,
-0.0062541915,
-0.0283159055,
-0.0220935773,
0.04199595,
0.0247017071,
0.0155968126,
-0.0056891697,
0.0027547735,
-0.0443899147,
0.0205838755,
0.0110718971,
0.0110906772,
0.0312906876,
0.0690566078,
-0.0063781529,
-0.0091267936,
0.0153117934,
0.0390676335,
0.0234314371,
0.0154111031,
0.0268653985,
-0.0294794701,
0.007405926,
-0.0174261462,
-0.0247014817,
0.0147564672,
-0.0189335626,
-0.0246775039,
-0.0330800824,
0.0038283693,
0.0708431005,
-0.0449548438,
0.0206881892,
-0.0340743773,
0.0123130893,
0.0004325031,
0.0231936164,
0.0186968371,
-0.0138833346,
-0.0259164087,
-0.0178033672,
-0.0311975069,
0.064180918,
0.0583969913,
0.009661206,
0.0527204946,
0.0421861447,
-0.0187494308,
-0.0325292684,
-0.0003987584,
-0.0381961316,
0.037707027,
-0.0078695817,
0.0000749809,
-0.0187392719,
-0.0621541366,
0.0338160247,
-0.0358638465,
0.031551566,
0.0436167046,
-0.0196262784,
0.0710241944,
0.0275603328,
0.0185589753,
-0.050247021,
-0.011667517,
0.0199357346,
-0.0471920706,
0.0152057847,
-6.409164747e-33,
0.0742853135,
-0.0776136518,
-0.033226531,
0.0114940414,
-0.0044682873,
0.0446020216,
-0.0184071139,
-0.0287486427,
-0.0400384106,
0.0187673829,
0.0018086139,
0.058812581,
0.003036144,
0.0148198949,
-0.0281794593,
-0.035672728,
0.039979741,
-0.0115287909,
-0.0188402198,
0.0369663164,
0.0377018191,
0.0026945299,
0.0601152517,
-0.1195103899,
0.0373329185,
-0.0338148028,
-0.0370387509,
0.0058815414,
0.0010114359,
0.0652158707,
-0.0254638828,
0.0469855852,
0.0338526815,
-0.0255671125,
0.0039619021,
0.029776806,
0.0023686013,
-0.0036834965,
-0.0262363274,
-0.0171553008,
-0.0465236418,
-0.0278706644,
0.0611302257,
-0.0056196484,
-0.0392606445,
0.0147514232,
0.0360384993,
-0.0044031013,
0.0268733744,
-0.0317310095,
-0.0514928997,
0.0030941239,
-0.0131157786,
0.0057885586,
0.0233832505,
0.0622991957,
0.0227927566,
0.0098180333,
-0.0839400887,
0.0234890301,
-0.0092745582,
-0.0282609928,
0.016688237,
-0.0607078411,
-0.0328031071,
0.048147887,
0.0388849378,
-0.0098483935,
-0.0394589603,
-0.0044438853,
0.012911547,
0.049853202,
0.0346140824,
0.1289130598,
0.0485338308,
-0.0436226465,
-0.0863009617,
0.0139395744,
-0.0020850652,
0.0411835238,
-0.0109833851,
-0.0391248949,
-0.0383864529,
0.0294847656,
-0.0088045551,
-0.0497789197,
-0.0436717868,
-0.0195006765,
-0.0311953202,
0.0125054615,
-0.0475090034,
0.034255866,
0.020855343,
-0.093657203,
0.0089759771,
0.0031745005,
0.012597451,
0.0095604891,
0.025330089,
0.0489512943,
-0.0362140611,
-0.0189686213,
0.0195153635,
0.0075371116,
0.0462941676,
-0.0100329872,
0.022313768,
0.0534263179,
-0.0441381857,
0.0231082607,
0.0186602715,
0.0243993849,
-0.0116992127,
-0.0273214206,
-0.01424486,
0.0003100642,
-0.0170990825,
0.00652039,
0.0290598515,
0.0380385928,
-0.013879478,
0.0108246664,
-0.0406196453,
0.0121763814,
-0.0196261313,
-0.0295313187,
-0.0528137088,
-0.0217824038,
0.0148502709,
-0.095953241,
0.0028418417,
-0.0487703606,
2.631e-7,
-0.0202092845,
0.0904597938,
0.015527905,
-0.0120697338,
0.0133357849,
0.0733544827,
0.0421792604,
0.0289478675,
-0.0417612791,
-0.0532191098,
-0.004489053,
0.0144882118,
0.048757717,
0.0308704246,
-0.0256291628,
0.0229473449,
-0.0822821856,
-0.0067581288,
-0.0753417015,
0.0269622058,
0.0174302384,
0.0803999826,
0.0615379363,
-0.0655555204,
0.0100693274,
-0.054824926,
0.0228544753,
0.0431193747,
0.0080783535,
0.013402177,
0.093563132,
-0.0062530129,
0.0461551733,
0.0024335661,
-0.0411764756,
-0.0087100426,
0.0059212083,
0.023351077,
0.0068262247,
0.0096794115,
-0.0359968878,
-0.0365825221,
0.0246787835,
-0.0452184156,
0.0388701744,
-0.0141485222,
-0.0391822681,
-0.0582784563,
-0.0106268255,
-0.0223864652,
0.0550866127,
-0.0119481264,
-0.0079421988,
0.0410892852,
0.0054098349,
0.0088551184,
0.0062745372,
-0.0544374734,
0.0019567274,
-0.0186245125,
-0.0088893836,
0.0377302133,
0.0111676874,
-0.0491449907,
0.0506375283,
-0.0163970143,
0.0409104712,
2.194132297e-34,
0.0329260118,
-0.0344213359,
0.0000677294,
-0.0126430281,
0.0149756037,
0.038964089,
0.012869467,
-0.0243160184,
-0.0104377447,
-0.0067488113,
0.0098307813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16478v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16478v1 | EMMI -- Empathic Multimodal Motivational Interviews Dataset: Analyses and Annotations | 2024-06-24T09:32:28 | 2024-06-24T09:32:28 | Lucie Galland, Catherine Pelachaud, Florian Pecune | cs.CL | cs.CL | The study of multimodal interaction in therapy can yield a comprehensive
understanding of therapist and patient behavior that can be used to develop a
multimodal virtual agent supporting therapy. This investigation aims to uncover
how therapists skillfully blend therapy's task goal (employing classical steps
of Motivational Interviewing) with the social goal (building a trusting
relationship and expressing empathy). Furthermore, we seek to categorize
patients into various ``types'' requiring tailored therapeutic approaches. To
this intent, we present multimodal annotations of a corpus consisting of
simulated motivational interviewing conversations, wherein actors portray the
roles of patients and therapists. We introduce EMMI, composed of two publicly
available MI corpora, AnnoMI and the Motivational Interviewing Dataset, for
which we add multimodal annotations. We analyze these annotations to
characterize functional behavior for developing a virtual agent performing
motivational interviews emphasizing social and empathic behaviors. Our analysis
found three clusters of patients expressing significant differences in behavior
and adaptation of the therapist's behavior to those types. This shows the
importance of a therapist being able to adapt their behavior depending on the
current situation within the dialog and the type of user. | [
0.0737203062,
-0.0142076388,
-0.0363132209,
-0.0025586877,
0.0076697166,
0.0377713032,
0.0431804433,
-0.0069216113,
0.0017535504,
0.0018006992,
-0.0261724051,
-0.0100102909,
-0.0044784108,
0.0123148002,
0.0526519753,
-0.1216883734,
0.0056178346,
0.0509433225,
0.0455348752,
0.0321914703,
0.0504033342,
0.0456795804,
-0.0519489087,
0.0363516435,
-0.0258486774,
-0.0302900318,
0.0193234682,
0.0284144729,
0.0608593412,
-0.0561362393,
-0.0222604536,
-0.0028170357,
0.0526875556,
-0.008267682,
0.0000022594,
-0.0131327659,
-0.0043146941,
-0.0078911558,
0.0037067654,
-0.0712741539,
0.0915940627,
-0.0162827242,
0.01056985,
0.0249725748,
-0.0246011242,
-0.0516854674,
0.0655848235,
0.0265269224,
0.0746396631,
0.0278263371,
-0.0426267087,
0.0370337702,
-0.0368614495,
0.0220330488,
-0.0074279155,
0.0559340566,
-0.0525987372,
0.0090347612,
0.0707612261,
-0.0357706174,
-0.0121989138,
0.0067218565,
-0.0265061297,
0.0081516244,
0.0417575687,
0.0203791223,
0.0223066248,
-0.0634235814,
-0.0136790322,
0.0832195207,
0.0750892013,
0.0931092277,
0.0303598419,
0.0098539311,
0.0183121394,
0.0462488793,
-0.0345058627,
0.0065400982,
-0.0196240954,
-0.0133249015,
-0.0240593012,
0.0420765914,
-0.0089852568,
-0.0196245108,
0.0464843772,
-0.0590431131,
0.0079701552,
0.0262031984,
0.0135873398,
-0.0462014154,
-0.016376622,
-0.0583885387,
-0.0034086932,
0.0134850154,
-0.0458850451,
0.0138756847,
-0.0455207564,
0.0088772178,
0.0078069847,
-0.0204684976,
0.0544861369,
0.0419676639,
-0.0180542525,
-0.0050432468,
0.0934318304,
-0.0118053118,
-0.0007315701,
-0.0019734821,
0.00118058,
0.0400499701,
-0.0373033434,
0.0030349132,
-0.0113500562,
-0.0020114735,
-0.0097236233,
-0.0244907588,
-0.0314279161,
0.0183241088,
-0.0546809509,
0.0269469805,
-0.0575461797,
0.0060989009,
-0.0067835315,
0.0687903389,
-0.016401697,
0.0248057395,
-0.0694140047,
0.0166139714,
0.0112099908,
-0.082391493,
0.0339047275,
0.0005097357,
0.0220395513,
-0.0454846434,
0.0272990484,
0.0326542966,
-0.0118805757,
-0.0475480109,
0.0195250232,
-0.0158875342,
0.0100240801,
-0.0036155507,
0.0531768948,
-0.0032065397,
0.0549575835,
-0.0411073864,
0.0190783907,
-0.0027496479,
0.0141104776,
0.0083375182,
-0.0094012599,
0.1053438261,
-0.0192822367,
0.0120196398,
0.0599000715,
0.0330028199,
-0.0067636077,
0.0084188543,
0.0181655101,
-0.0330430157,
0.0386321656,
-0.067632325,
0.0435637869,
0.0187454727,
-0.0161234681,
-0.0140212206,
0.0306499097,
-0.0375046991,
-0.0090330401,
0.0856571943,
-0.0180204902,
0.0040577585,
-0.0565967262,
-0.0061773257,
0.0372493118,
0.0858973861,
0.0097126933,
-0.0230792388,
0.0052717398,
-0.0088347038,
0.0075674998,
0.0098393438,
-0.0249198154,
0.0617564358,
0.0517247356,
-0.0461850874,
-0.0195490643,
0.0103104664,
-0.041823592,
-0.0070131612,
-0.015751902,
-0.0058875163,
0.0160407647,
0.002115875,
-0.0367555879,
-0.0010023781,
-0.0047526974,
-0.0224912819,
0.0153660122,
-0.0736694932,
-0.0169057492,
-0.0266659204,
-0.0201081224,
0.0926702023,
0.0446794182,
-0.0260308385,
-0.0604823306,
-0.0342028551,
-0.0064586126,
0.0327311307,
0.0019229027,
-0.0194397382,
-0.0026563257,
-0.0160657316,
0.000904923,
-0.0240684897,
-0.0014396968,
0.0076086158,
-0.085918352,
0.0106441593,
-0.0567294955,
-0.0064554154,
0.0313115232,
0.0517132916,
-0.0463828817,
-0.0020021831,
-0.0298687834,
0.009725377,
0.0501084514,
0.0472682454,
-0.027012011,
-0.0143331243,
0.0154203195,
-0.0082982117,
0.0270717181,
0.105655387,
-0.017445229,
-0.0013226398,
-0.0101306001,
-0.0768294856,
0.0160431936,
0.0276903659,
0.0194023829,
-0.0057930164,
0.0116211614,
-0.0530628748,
0.0713439211,
-0.0201973543,
-0.006199562,
0.0351679996,
0.0471150912,
0.0114826793,
-0.0390721969,
-0.0087073864,
-0.0021866844,
0.0073496704,
-0.0352787599,
-0.0458745509,
-0.0349719599,
-0.0042883912,
0.0166894123,
-0.0180849563,
-0.0251279045,
-0.0281460453,
-0.0301801171,
-0.0504482612,
0.0014607427,
-0.1360759586,
-0.020656012,
0.006032086,
-0.0539462194,
0.0115031954,
-0.012790571,
-0.0349059962,
-0.025815852,
-0.0309994332,
0.0283970628,
0.0471641719,
-0.0083354432,
0.0293315817,
0.011701867,
0.0019535499,
-0.0527197421,
-0.0059394282,
-0.044811178,
0.0317896083,
-0.0213782545,
0.0020385373,
-0.0101860967,
-0.0217852946,
-0.0450391211,
0.0154916011,
-0.0322292335,
-0.0597904399,
0.0351087637,
0.0214861594,
0.0054977648,
-0.0033961714,
0.0254388433,
0.0759423524,
0.0199323073,
-0.0074309316,
-0.0331801847,
0.0110059706,
0.0286761541,
0.0058897729,
-0.0254993252,
-0.0841996744,
0.0146589652,
0.0401076265,
0.0130460085,
0.0633929446,
-0.0302218311,
-0.0094786109,
0.033938311,
-0.0002238021,
0.0356355719,
-0.0099967895,
-0.0143906726,
0.0070428927,
0.0089170411,
0.0092660449,
0.0278734583,
-0.0228337329,
-0.0534735546,
-0.0121695707,
-0.0030225713,
0.0104849404,
0.0501996987,
-0.0366075747,
0.0161586646,
0.0472161882,
-0.0161201023,
0.0022024061,
-0.037576858,
0.0358526669,
-0.0090280054,
-0.0235632509,
-0.0380430259,
-0.0244869944,
0.0054676649,
0.0257911105,
-0.0229435619,
-0.0578138232,
0.0011061624,
-0.0542464107,
0.0080990968,
0.0120019922,
-0.0332670063,
-0.033024583,
0.0182893015,
0.0465763174,
0.0177995414,
-0.0173475947,
-0.0100671295,
-0.0185515508,
0.0516458526,
0.0420812964,
-0.0251286514,
-0.0126986308,
0.0565589219,
0.0358759388,
0.0023898631,
-0.0273275208,
-0.0367282629,
-0.0113548394,
0.0003642936,
0.0048262309,
0.0052763997,
-0.0220925976,
0.0421266258,
0.0245291051,
0.0021935911,
0.0828716308,
-0.000224177,
-0.0520215407,
0.0266831107,
-0.0282604806,
-0.0376967005,
0.0068076975,
-0.0101787988,
-0.0765185207,
-0.0037645963,
-0.0291576721,
0.0482031479,
-0.0387926437,
-0.0257754065,
0.0054405467,
-0.0590252876,
0.057262253,
-0.0284657814,
0.0119744344,
0.0059081824,
-0.0087334812,
0.0362403467,
0.0097659109,
0.0039849756,
-0.0204726942,
0.0116371596,
0.0039970865,
0.0286828112,
0.000284629,
-0.0337926261,
0.053828869,
-0.0312343109,
0.088369213,
0.0095048798,
0.079720974,
0.0220306888,
-0.0311839618,
-0.0626187399,
0.0871816501,
0.0378058776,
-0.0000333106,
0.0492960066,
-0.0465873815,
0.0199839938,
-0.0081508169,
0.0809362456,
0.0073947343,
0.0062930509,
0.0127576813,
0.0469744876,
-0.0616266318,
0.0221079309,
-0.0284600332,
0.0480411239,
0.0284448452,
0.008899143,
-0.0049058958,
-0.034704227,
0.0329421088,
0.0707737058,
0.0713063031,
0.0274017509,
-0.015709674,
0.001411473,
-0.0465056337,
-0.0184402708,
-0.0577513725,
-0.0710928366,
0.0158361029,
0.0405993201,
-0.0137640089,
-0.0605111718,
-0.0168519318,
0.0593791604,
-0.0375317782,
0.0459952764,
0.0436406732,
0.0396366343,
0.0314275846,
-0.009672353,
0.0058028181,
-0.0271398481,
0.0282122176,
-0.0186199341,
0.0420526415,
-0.0016509184,
-0.0021936868,
0.0491095185,
0.0194048025,
0.026007764,
0.0564998239,
-0.0289165825,
-0.0184386037,
-0.0204231348,
-0.0548803322,
0.0120284678,
0.0107932417,
0.0255053807,
-0.0267547015,
-0.0219304711,
0.0125534749,
0.0252692737,
-0.024699036,
-0.0105440235,
-0.0277262442,
-0.0192481894,
-0.0197225697,
0.0173289198,
0.0422912426,
-0.0511884764,
0.0339156128,
-0.025159277,
-0.0406785384,
-0.0219929796,
0.0276235845,
-0.0533590838,
-0.0106148459,
-0.0248546693,
-0.0087362137,
-0.0095177721,
-0.0620240718,
-0.0737319663,
-0.0097038457,
-0.0472212732,
0.0297964774,
0.0271290448,
-0.0500703752,
-0.0871421397,
0.0285135247,
0.0097293211,
0.0498521775,
-0.0111070601,
0.0110885371,
-0.003522292,
0.1059888601,
0.0219745506,
-0.0109052537,
0.0165489241,
0.0739059523,
0.0074488879,
-0.0069682156,
-0.0081547378,
0.0165536329,
0.0339031294,
0.0266966186,
0.0355497636,
-0.0170390531,
0.0308756381,
0.0111939805,
0.0166912898,
-0.0244056843,
-0.035809651,
0.0173781291,
-0.0005639287,
-0.0076055052,
-0.0346710719,
0.0012574152,
-0.0994166434,
0.0422481634,
-0.0284080766,
-0.01336715,
-0.0503703058,
0.0141711645,
0.0630675629,
0.0044513084,
-0.0046258848,
-0.0191742573,
-0.0511209071,
-0.0402414091,
-0.0045738919,
-0.0319431312,
-0.052386906,
-0.052642297,
0.0287962426,
0.0054728268,
0.0106497649,
0.0197556727,
-0.0373058617,
-0.0026327218,
-0.0406096242,
0.0181358699,
-0.0021417884,
-5.520368693e-33,
-0.0187568385,
-0.0073428513,
0.0178444609,
-0.0013823619,
-0.0654915795,
-0.0149878152,
-0.0385240614,
0.0155786201,
-0.0030240661,
0.0039235093,
0.0063741184,
0.0136470497,
-0.0000235575,
-0.0097542312,
0.0063174241,
0.0125264786,
0.0161921233,
-0.0185168944,
-0.0329924934,
-0.0010210621,
-0.0158061571,
0.0352616198,
0.0383399688,
-0.0805989206,
0.0390466265,
0.0050602574,
-0.047682371,
0.0122614438,
0.0499204807,
0.0177179351,
-0.0314657465,
0.0113988044,
0.0185912438,
-0.0299233124,
0.0239719748,
0.0357206389,
-0.0442081392,
-0.0334271826,
0.0188919008,
0.0094454149,
-0.1050676256,
-0.0039349464,
-0.0207856987,
-0.0358631946,
0.0089042233,
-0.0214975644,
0.0383203588,
-0.0031552997,
0.0497517847,
0.05079218,
-0.0291046463,
-0.0211035069,
-0.039274931,
-0.061440926,
-0.0017490707,
0.0753248632,
-0.0128621897,
-0.0240749139,
-0.0444910154,
0.0246824566,
-0.0507320613,
-0.0533889793,
0.0297481045,
0.0057980223,
0.0148783289,
0.0536992252,
0.0192707255,
0.0081637995,
-0.0120415287,
0.050377734,
0.0050317841,
0.0508174635,
0.012114957,
0.071617417,
-0.0585189424,
-0.0216640998,
0.0284291878,
0.0440757312,
0.027025504,
-0.00088525,
0.0025556905,
0.0103117973,
0.0089532211,
0.0042211111,
-0.0326014049,
-0.0324846916,
0.0064659328,
-0.0560408048,
0.0057493704,
-0.0339085609,
-0.0207185186,
-0.0109425345,
0.0219794214,
-0.003380985,
0.0251789223,
-0.0259156693,
-0.019320678,
0.0549945198,
-0.005541326,
-0.0539165772,
0.013800893,
-0.0076259156,
0.0246037412,
-0.0126693137,
0.0999189317,
0.0124613605,
-0.0350196064,
0.0037766465,
-0.0120305251,
-0.0263904296,
0.0169358142,
0.0580098517,
-0.0143541181,
-0.0103680305,
-0.0174224526,
-0.0076444168,
-0.0391678587,
0.0260785762,
0.0151683278,
0.0257197525,
-0.0661153272,
-0.0415043049,
-0.0499327257,
0.0034969395,
-0.0456076637,
0.008908472,
-0.0298882108,
-0.0340482369,
0.0591095239,
-0.0143453218,
0.0038449748,
-0.0338849053,
2.958e-7,
-0.050589487,
0.0304631423,
0.0113378288,
-0.0181592274,
0.03788279,
0.0630462766,
0.0043751015,
0.0932866782,
0.0016010923,
-0.0836910605,
0.0540019348,
-0.0089072194,
0.0490290448,
0.0326838568,
0.008307307,
-0.0361306593,
-0.0191177111,
-0.0305453651,
-0.0165766571,
0.0156760961,
0.065308705,
0.0258136857,
0.0223966017,
-0.0274794567,
0.0084140534,
0.0250678696,
0.0083107417,
-0.0414322168,
-0.0323069282,
0.0078542046,
-0.0102661317,
-0.0382020883,
-0.0059638456,
0.0237409566,
-0.0073594386,
-0.0254953466,
0.012108379,
0.0534168705,
-0.08729399,
-0.0304783285,
0.0120054614,
0.0478461534,
-0.04039957,
0.000988876,
0.0021444713,
-0.0730260015,
-0.064438276,
-0.020593442,
-0.0287979785,
-0.0142895347,
0.0378638096,
-0.0364345685,
-0.0277995132,
0.0627973974,
-0.0063840826,
-0.0010054901,
-0.0220943037,
-0.0417944267,
0.0339324027,
-0.0090392688,
-0.055993408,
-0.0464012325,
0.0411133841,
-0.0342833064,
-0.0214508362,
-0.030957194,
-0.0144329602,
1.853743112e-34,
-0.0398587286,
0.0495129637,
0.0078831241,
0.0159815922,
0.0305954926,
0.012556728,
-0.0038735617,
0.0395815261,
0.036977008,
-0.0243928544,
-0.0345618501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16477v1 | DaLPSR: Leverage Degradation-Aligned Language Prompt for Real-World Image Super-Resolution | 2024-06-24T09:30:36 | 2024-06-24T09:30:36 | Aiwen Jiang, Zhi Wei, Long Peng, Feiqiang Liu, Wenbo Li, Mingwen Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Image super-resolution pursuits reconstructing high-fidelity high-resolution
counterpart for low-resolution image. In recent years, diffusion-based models
have garnered significant attention due to their capabilities with rich prior
knowledge. The success of diffusion models based on general text prompts has
validated the effectiveness of textual control in the field of text2image.
However, given the severe degradation commonly presented in low-resolution
images, coupled with the randomness characteristics of diffusion models,
current models struggle to adequately discern semantic and degradation
information within severely degraded images. This often leads to obstacles such
as semantic loss, visual artifacts, and visual hallucinations, which pose
substantial challenges for practical use. To address these challenges, this
paper proposes to leverage degradation-aligned language prompt for accurate,
fine-grained, and high-fidelity image restoration. Complementary priors
including semantic content descriptions and degradation prompts are explored.
Specifically, on one hand, image-restoration prompt alignment decoder is
proposed to automatically discern the degradation degree of LR images, thereby
generating beneficial degradation priors for image restoration. On the other
hand, much richly tailored descriptions from pretrained multimodal large
language model elicit high-level semantic priors closely aligned with human
perception, ensuring fidelity control for image restoration. Comprehensive
comparisons with state-of-the-art methods have been done on several popular
synthetic and real-world benchmark datasets. The quantitative and qualitative
analysis have demonstrated that the proposed method achieves a new
state-of-the-art perceptual quality level, especially in real-world cases based
on reference-free metrics. | [
0.0065676868,
0.1039084941,
0.0409883559,
0.0603234321,
-0.0338291526,
-0.0013112397,
-0.023339631,
0.0689988509,
-0.0297108125,
-0.0200702902,
0.0211916044,
-0.0483839512,
0.0422532633,
-0.0212101694,
0.021659866,
-0.0919298381,
-0.0139591843,
-0.0199032743,
0.0037454504,
-0.0110651739,
0.0269739535,
-0.0250235032,
0.0158910677,
-0.0221784785,
-0.072698541,
-0.0389198512,
0.0051880949,
0.0506150611,
0.0646955296,
0.0041438928,
-0.0091502871,
0.0467081703,
0.0623173527,
-0.0364933945,
0.0000021795,
-0.0350848623,
0.0106750801,
0.0226630848,
0.0074522728,
0.0045460123,
0.0785980374,
-0.0169578511,
-0.0256137308,
-0.051960595,
0.0011770952,
-0.0032859792,
0.0683264881,
0.0697075799,
0.1051936597,
0.0226613954,
-0.0279738009,
-0.0770455301,
0.0070746546,
-0.0006879597,
0.0272186976,
0.0009314523,
0.0559661612,
0.0723423138,
-0.0228345413,
0.0174865238,
-0.0105258394,
0.0186142605,
0.016964443,
-0.0154467616,
0.0230659675,
-0.0035748449,
0.0561978146,
-0.0240712482,
-0.029406298,
0.0245279465,
-0.0360089801,
0.0222950391,
-0.0456988476,
-0.0015984512,
-0.0033142513,
0.0060970322,
-0.0224521346,
-0.0071094935,
-0.0005636479,
0.04684259,
-0.102728337,
-0.0105403997,
0.0252894536,
-0.0022636603,
-0.034604799,
0.0200647432,
0.0115550924,
-0.0042187003,
-0.0107634291,
0.0013799742,
-0.0516836606,
0.007402814,
0.0549750701,
-0.0182161834,
0.0055542891,
-0.0172277,
-0.0477170348,
-0.0458180793,
0.024327822,
-0.0318552889,
0.0256501846,
-0.0254928116,
-0.0368088931,
0.0425591357,
-0.0124186417,
0.0351642929,
-0.0070080399,
0.0333053842,
-0.043739412,
-0.0110006072,
0.0094235074,
-0.0146685326,
0.0070715998,
0.0082041835,
-0.0402181409,
0.0065890532,
0.0038941475,
-0.0189951193,
0.0007668013,
0.0041377265,
0.0002945962,
0.0241811853,
-0.0824729353,
-0.0669806004,
-0.0435882248,
0.0276318882,
0.0396602936,
0.0129547613,
0.038706746,
-0.0005208096,
-0.0092555396,
0.0359081738,
0.0097212549,
-0.026588982,
-0.0132637834,
0.0927687287,
-0.0457956567,
-0.0076681115,
-0.027343804,
0.0172085557,
-0.0439976975,
-0.0229913816,
-0.0307044182,
-0.0517929383,
0.0224329401,
-0.0257648528,
-0.0091763344,
-0.0897757635,
0.0038110502,
0.0066386699,
-0.0404250622,
0.0670796782,
-0.0744335502,
-0.0154962363,
0.0746666193,
0.0019876987,
0.0259765666,
0.0419626758,
0.0312189236,
0.0376610272,
-0.0053707287,
0.0183854457,
0.0009393063,
0.0445528477,
0.0073028635,
0.056321431,
-0.0708125606,
-0.0392246805,
0.0283609144,
0.0260430574,
0.092252247,
0.0847962648,
-0.0298640206,
-0.0206600968,
0.0955603495,
0.0240639113,
0.0036291182,
0.004454128,
0.0287700146,
0.0653027222,
-0.0354114994,
0.0276590697,
0.0071123522,
0.0088573238,
0.0533818379,
0.0272596292,
0.0667229369,
0.0335254185,
-0.0249534771,
-0.0627681166,
0.0074050673,
-0.0113262078,
0.0147226071,
-0.0306195002,
0.0516543463,
0.0099931462,
-0.0390101857,
-0.0223657899,
0.0278896037,
-0.0149158686,
0.0233511515,
-0.0678269193,
0.0084166834,
0.0810154229,
0.0539657585,
-0.0502257608,
0.0708079264,
0.0086586569,
0.0182928946,
0.0517807901,
-0.0648749322,
0.0430689119,
0.0354774743,
-0.0398641825,
-0.0749272108,
0.0301021822,
-0.0118407859,
-0.0041103037,
-0.0675562918,
-0.0174095836,
-0.0068030115,
-0.0443886444,
-0.0582690574,
0.0317079797,
0.0319516994,
0.0277484749,
0.0268397536,
-0.0006480016,
-0.0170468967,
-0.0014839215,
-0.0437876061,
-0.0292206798,
0.0271387324,
-0.007667054,
-0.0142587842,
-0.0431422442,
-0.0451405309,
-0.045748245,
0.0344521105,
-0.0336638354,
0.0168113597,
0.0328208692,
-0.0473708957,
0.0032152841,
-0.0163656995,
-0.0037186374,
-0.0072115967,
-0.0676576495,
0.0040611709,
-0.0021370868,
0.0169565901,
-0.0289365817,
0.061715547,
-0.0376749821,
-0.0385146104,
0.0422510058,
0.0075682998,
-0.0282399673,
-0.0077473093,
-0.0422174446,
-0.0494236313,
-0.0053760656,
0.0440707356,
0.0460512377,
0.0018863608,
-0.0610819869,
0.0158403385,
0.0109165423,
-0.012029035,
-0.039143797,
-0.0024913067,
0.0025302935,
0.016565498,
0.0176856462,
-0.0135203069,
0.0144830812,
0.0351007432,
-0.0097760204,
-0.0084300227,
0.0482943989,
-0.0050940281,
0.0450607575,
-0.0331443883,
-0.0084550763,
0.0754551217,
0.0369647183,
-0.019873973,
-0.0707523078,
-0.1020681337,
0.0822605267,
0.0178314205,
0.0089572482,
-0.0297264922,
-0.0435345471,
-0.0361070149,
-0.0140682468,
0.0287987161,
0.0460606031,
-0.0048749587,
0.0001079629,
-0.0069250534,
-0.006725789,
-0.0142698018,
-0.0343659781,
-0.0108012576,
-0.0435060263,
-0.0241616759,
-0.0480493866,
-0.0369486511,
0.0282684416,
0.0387739837,
0.0568202287,
-0.0483834967,
-0.0074538914,
-0.0293505862,
-0.0286508501,
-0.0184214655,
0.0079058735,
-0.0238989461,
0.0090595093,
-0.0482812896,
-0.0528974459,
0.0366746038,
-0.0095952265,
-0.0107623274,
-0.0043359483,
0.0006489241,
0.0479081087,
-0.0005484707,
0.0210948009,
0.0314352997,
-0.0019120474,
-0.0140077947,
-0.0706284419,
-0.0136243002,
0.0205087494,
-0.0283981878,
0.0150156133,
-0.0788256228,
-0.0072947247,
-0.0158684812,
0.0041025695,
0.0031878951,
-0.0374903232,
0.0411668979,
-0.0041998243,
-0.0492802374,
0.0277171712,
-0.022965271,
0.0003208951,
0.0097448444,
-0.0142869493,
0.0434495434,
-0.0401849933,
-0.0061067026,
0.0741175115,
0.0372062922,
0.0279748496,
-0.0137211792,
-0.0488662943,
0.0245690942,
0.0513706356,
-0.0064807925,
0.0014166954,
-0.0543395989,
-0.0012286109,
-0.0053895721,
0.0845575333,
0.0260025002,
0.0552569963,
0.0692266747,
-0.0334511213,
-0.0179064982,
0.0259801429,
-0.0150676873,
-0.0885251537,
-0.0138310976,
-0.0100886952,
0.0587644987,
-0.0109635973,
-0.0658692047,
-0.0754980445,
-0.0418732092,
-0.0317561254,
-0.0103749586,
0.0193468258,
0.0246517491,
-0.0087779397,
-0.011619769,
0.0456247814,
0.0488832742,
0.0242023226,
-0.0003490017,
-0.0376385488,
0.0281598736,
-0.0160206594,
0.0409836844,
-0.0069173686,
0.0359631218,
-0.0025257352,
0.0192054082,
0.0456334166,
-0.0833927318,
-0.0355334021,
-0.0117391376,
-0.0161601454,
0.0916564614,
-0.0005472489,
-0.029187372,
-0.0296572633,
0.0196919665,
-0.0242400654,
0.0156692695,
0.0175336283,
0.063421458,
0.0058382964,
0.0122061512,
-0.0331180654,
0.0542727709,
-0.0053923517,
-0.0138555765,
0.0020039687,
0.0162883885,
0.0025272283,
-0.0092236288,
-0.0266770814,
-0.0228051227,
0.0424428694,
0.0109500615,
0.0304670669,
-0.0397514366,
-0.0314559191,
-0.004687163,
0.0688323602,
-0.0013857511,
-0.0310269836,
0.0174150243,
-0.0168970115,
-0.0234849062,
-0.0578680001,
0.0073695858,
-0.0052010366,
0.0208549593,
-0.0189261213,
-0.0028663825,
-0.0130860396,
-0.0350700542,
-0.0559259318,
0.0199245103,
-0.0250904635,
-0.005729794,
-0.0381870717,
0.0133503955,
-0.0186554175,
-0.0175612886,
-0.0114581995,
0.0185855161,
-0.0911749825,
-0.0404933468,
0.0134624895,
0.0702107176,
0.0083413525,
0.0410467722,
0.0118077993,
-0.0710467398,
0.0550385863,
0.0500278138,
0.0162627399,
0.0168807115,
0.0107142534,
-0.0180885084,
-0.031102797,
0.0430099927,
-0.0491206124,
0.0454651862,
0.0110097881,
-0.0045968965,
0.006659023,
-0.0132821826,
0.0408639312,
-0.0147643918,
0.0458898395,
-0.0342200845,
0.0110751595,
0.0229449496,
-0.0153262503,
-0.0141430711,
-0.0550079904,
-0.0323627405,
0.0187684372,
0.0043671746,
-0.0206155181,
0.0254745502,
0.0052143233,
0.002877523,
0.0190789904,
-0.0366686508,
-0.0080012549,
-0.0074191578,
-0.0199078843,
0.0415466093,
0.0374500863,
0.0184979849,
-0.0098287882,
0.0055815205,
0.0487073958,
0.0131589156,
0.0479101539,
0.0130928531,
-0.0255641583,
0.0112916352,
0.0284750182,
0.0227257255,
-0.0515441112,
-0.065734379,
0.0025277361,
0.0564351678,
-0.0053188689,
0.073625505,
-0.0054008714,
-0.0005715137,
-0.0677397177,
0.0206999723,
0.064076826,
0.000018067,
0.0152791291,
-0.0129476003,
0.0135274697,
0.027867537,
0.0418755636,
-0.0375330187,
-0.0203682259,
-0.0372262225,
0.0142404111,
-0.0034034953,
-0.0300671868,
-0.0348076187,
-0.007124335,
0.0190374106,
0.0047926819,
-0.0039736931,
-0.025990285,
-0.0422369763,
0.0027091259,
-0.0091730421,
-0.0136350943,
0.0332371742,
0.0117383394,
-0.0550185554,
0.0129311113,
0.0236969423,
-0.0045957421,
0.0040724683,
-0.0146844266,
0.0095570013,
-6.201915542e-33,
0.00320661,
-0.0118717169,
-0.0046850052,
-0.0618174635,
-0.0265216138,
-0.0188759342,
-0.0230648089,
-0.0292649642,
0.0009866046,
0.054527726,
0.0213004965,
0.013146393,
0.005183612,
0.0637063086,
-0.0551094413,
0.0340563171,
0.0256418623,
-0.009341835,
-0.0315176696,
0.0113953045,
0.0419058241,
0.0020882206,
0.0508043766,
-0.0236312523,
0.0030235001,
0.0005949686,
-0.0300971307,
-0.0215305816,
0.0831795856,
0.0394885913,
-0.0494152717,
0.0553039163,
0.0169338416,
-0.0398953632,
-0.049969621,
0.0096037667,
-0.0242140274,
0.0175182167,
-0.0460571013,
-0.0156079978,
-0.0791816562,
-0.0056796116,
0.0459937826,
0.0217929631,
-0.0153200673,
-0.0076789022,
0.0751610622,
-0.0767014697,
-0.0139125856,
0.0313952975,
-0.0198504012,
0.0303923767,
-0.0517056622,
0.0051212288,
0.0492796861,
0.0180973448,
-0.0125754243,
0.0280602854,
-0.0634636506,
-0.0012506773,
0.0106533905,
0.0390022509,
0.0384123586,
0.033764407,
-0.0046100132,
0.0394473821,
-0.0143327797,
0.0149833057,
0.0395331196,
-0.0400021262,
-0.0257740431,
0.0221680813,
0.0434387401,
0.0760340393,
0.0487892702,
-0.0223665107,
-0.0295601822,
0.0269985646,
-0.0853131935,
0.0598379225,
0.0321680941,
0.0368046314,
0.0124778086,
-0.030026393,
-0.0410872363,
0.0341319591,
-0.0260166638,
-0.0472219102,
0.0059175072,
-0.0290941745,
0.0061246762,
-0.0109996907,
0.0411384851,
0.0045631207,
-0.0243660789,
-0.0095424736,
-0.0272011776,
0.0413973406,
-0.0205612183,
0.004010689,
0.0068127541,
-0.0046073194,
0.0255067274,
0.0758853629,
-0.0049109012,
0.0015121937,
-0.0244363919,
-0.006879448,
-0.0111624813,
0.0183404442,
-0.0273176618,
-0.0061165043,
0.0079349754,
0.0020590343,
-0.0056068785,
-0.0143900476,
-0.0259663202,
0.1060187295,
-0.0024942502,
-0.0115643172,
0.0260163285,
-0.0013591243,
0.0133612966,
-0.0016283602,
-0.0176614858,
0.0235610679,
-0.0372570008,
-0.0276504736,
0.0483664609,
-0.0423089676,
-0.0334486328,
0.0264025759,
2.772e-7,
0.0052274889,
0.0514520742,
0.0160542782,
-0.0260084942,
0.0073737525,
0.0416296124,
-0.0054123541,
-0.0071359617,
-0.015828304,
-0.0931843817,
0.0226169489,
0.0279328767,
0.0511930697,
-0.0125482958,
-0.0221931655,
0.0282987859,
-0.0481696203,
-0.0220478997,
-0.0253846366,
0.0019701002,
0.0939764753,
0.039769344,
-0.0536242612,
-0.0459349751,
0.057120014,
-0.0060906755,
0.0555807762,
-0.027393572,
0.0137438215,
0.0200408753,
-0.0072743944,
0.0043413239,
0.0218252204,
0.0226891711,
-0.0036969131,
-0.056435924,
0.0525083132,
0.0156816505,
-0.0549626909,
-0.0146723632,
-0.002311409,
0.0475008674,
0.0038832426,
-0.0394005999,
0.0443466268,
-0.0140224379,
-0.0082589602,
0.0100909267,
-0.0863197371,
-0.0213175397,
0.0243894029,
-0.0581684746,
-0.046066545,
0.00320283,
0.0204173308,
0.0993149802,
-0.0572680682,
-0.0544795506,
0.0042761937,
0.0142444866,
-0.0206845142,
-0.0266110338,
-0.0404862799,
0.0061700819,
0.0432852358,
-0.0659264028,
0.0187041108,
2.060034105e-34,
0.0190727133,
0.0002448038,
0.0061946944,
-0.02476383,
-0.0070950631,
0.0062167179,
0.0056917374,
0.0143382177,
-0.030945871,
-0.0559817925,
-0.0040861596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16469v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16469v1 | Evaluating Visual and Cultural Interpretation: The K-Viscuit Benchmark with Human-VLM Collaboration | 2024-06-24T09:18:15 | 2024-06-24T09:18:15 | Yujin Baek, ChaeHun Park, Jaeseok Kim, Yu-Jung Heo, Du-Seong Chang, Jaegul Choo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | To create culturally inclusive vision-language models (VLMs), the foremost
requirement is developing a test benchmark that can diagnose the models'
ability to respond to questions reflecting cultural elements. This paper
addresses the necessity for such benchmarks, noting that existing research has
relied on human annotators' manual efforts, which impedes diversity and
efficiency. We propose a semi-automated pipeline for constructing cultural VLM
benchmarks to enhance diversity and efficiency. This pipeline leverages
human-VLM collaboration, where VLMs generate questions based on guidelines,
human-annotated examples, and image-wise relevant knowledge, which are then
reviewed by native speakers for quality and cultural relevance. The
effectiveness of our adaptable pipeline is demonstrated through a specific
application: creating a dataset tailored to Korean culture, dubbed K-Viscuit.
The resulting benchmark features two types of questions: Type 1 questions
measure visual recognition abilities, while Type 2 assess fine-grained visual
reasoning skills. This ensures a thorough diagnosis of VLM models across
various aspects. Our evaluation using K-Viscuit revealed that open-source
models notably lag behind proprietary models in understanding Korean culture,
highlighting areas for improvement. We provided diverse analyses of VLM
performance across different cultural aspects. Besides, we explored the
potential of incorporating external knowledge retrieval to enhance the
generation process, suggesting future directions for improving cultural
interpretation ability of VLMs. Our dataset and code will be made publicly
available. | [
0.0208035968,
0.0320313908,
-0.050061591,
0.0556540377,
-0.0292125791,
0.0493732914,
0.0191597175,
-0.001600443,
0.0319946371,
-0.0497428887,
-0.0170480404,
-0.0290521514,
0.0271979906,
0.0355913118,
0.0064380271,
-0.1037422717,
0.0123916939,
-0.011702965,
0.0156154754,
0.0049096621,
-0.0268015265,
0.0104631465,
0.013391573,
0.0386880822,
-0.0022714785,
-0.016016528,
0.009110095,
0.0218024012,
0.0320714414,
-0.0210427623,
-0.0427949913,
0.0222947635,
-0.0061226771,
-0.019516347,
0.0000024504,
-0.0539729446,
0.0349598713,
-0.020801967,
0.033624839,
0.0126525378,
0.0381239578,
-0.0353634581,
0.0028124598,
-0.0337367393,
-0.0402915888,
-0.0256688762,
0.0514651202,
0.0123808496,
0.027696047,
-0.0032833312,
0.0033215138,
0.0010331371,
-0.0493475273,
0.0148918945,
-0.0162567273,
-0.0090255942,
0.028642863,
0.0828493163,
0.0155311851,
-0.0558527075,
-0.052012343,
0.0503320619,
0.0382105894,
-0.0124639617,
-0.0094290432,
-0.0116762184,
-0.0850192532,
-0.0426433831,
0.0196266957,
0.0533762909,
0.0251718182,
0.0124346875,
0.0036320069,
-0.0026343721,
-0.005577473,
0.0137680005,
-0.0346794017,
0.0326151475,
-0.0226097479,
-0.0236852597,
-0.0557494685,
-0.0097802812,
0.0133957323,
0.0076336442,
0.0306893662,
0.0312829278,
-0.0001122284,
0.0251870658,
-0.0267365444,
-0.0113257812,
-0.0202467218,
-0.0368088856,
-0.0088743959,
0.0088276314,
0.015661994,
0.0137744145,
0.0216563139,
0.0147197274,
0.0095791444,
-0.0423624031,
0.0548074096,
0.064783439,
-0.0752801672,
0.0226240195,
-0.0149248252,
0.108576864,
0.0340422913,
0.0456898808,
-0.0495951623,
-0.0010986369,
-0.0464870073,
-0.0017562446,
-0.0019929851,
-0.0622233562,
-0.0334651768,
0.008576218,
-0.0672684535,
-0.000933686,
-0.0631448254,
0.0142514864,
-0.0012642436,
-0.0185484458,
-0.0044181594,
0.0057091825,
-0.0491487272,
0.0215879753,
-0.035268005,
-0.0198420733,
-0.044548668,
-0.0839294866,
0.0553768091,
0.0294381604,
-0.024279451,
-0.0111462548,
-0.0264609437,
0.0073760906,
0.0005104545,
-0.0048901266,
-0.0523219071,
-0.0137864808,
-0.0167077538,
-0.023245763,
0.0393443108,
-0.075871788,
0.0168581139,
0.0032906719,
0.0190948248,
-0.0153509686,
-0.0149151897,
0.0070361863,
0.0141113466,
0.047732763,
0.044294253,
0.0407830551,
0.0301613994,
0.0196913611,
-0.0150710838,
0.0904338583,
0.00313347,
-0.0014974987,
0.055830881,
-0.0259949546,
-0.0326987132,
0.0271495357,
-0.0256408919,
-0.0309081543,
-0.0562836006,
0.0260163415,
0.0189227462,
0.0066379267,
0.0100788968,
0.0499592684,
0.0027625682,
-0.0403389744,
0.0239297971,
0.0735803023,
-0.0035624658,
-0.0139180515,
0.0818319842,
0.0187926032,
0.0206370968,
-0.0013661404,
-0.0151644358,
0.0381302163,
0.0035530888,
-0.0018106867,
-0.0604581684,
0.0751087144,
-0.034084212,
-0.0367454328,
-0.0355901085,
0.0052817459,
0.050493747,
0.0428843722,
0.0519390367,
-0.0002111025,
0.0189647954,
-0.0127915619,
0.0258063879,
-0.0269285962,
-0.0057952167,
-0.0333368592,
0.0105771264,
0.0658996701,
0.0054089176,
0.0380930826,
0.0383710936,
0.0150564052,
0.0197130237,
0.0180785153,
0.069336459,
-0.0107978629,
0.0051701679,
-0.03402064,
-0.0281022303,
0.0097614806,
-0.0084232287,
0.0341987945,
0.01212506,
0.0129340431,
0.0465055816,
-0.0327736773,
-0.0264159702,
0.020572627,
-0.0389781669,
0.0348729491,
-0.0372643583,
0.0197125375,
0.0063103368,
0.0439739749,
-0.0125746522,
-0.0016341653,
-0.0167035703,
-0.0375415571,
0.0424554758,
0.0750771686,
-0.0406233855,
0.0042091263,
0.0177991819,
-0.0897376761,
-0.0334442854,
0.0074729025,
0.0165238734,
-0.008839556,
0.026384471,
-0.0118244672,
-0.0399671495,
-0.0619563758,
0.0061068982,
-0.0346787497,
-0.0179021265,
-0.0215766877,
0.0736827031,
-0.0364040881,
0.0020611689,
-0.0031866769,
-0.0338765569,
0.0460719615,
-0.057983119,
-0.0277535338,
0.0274039079,
-0.0253316537,
0.0184045378,
-0.0041748476,
0.0142888939,
-0.0612459593,
0.0195867885,
-0.1112576649,
-0.0391451009,
-0.0229306463,
-0.0412718616,
-0.0208732635,
-0.0352734253,
-0.0367257334,
-0.0426623859,
-0.0142874401,
0.0254243854,
0.0197919197,
0.0413334817,
0.0082995007,
-0.0087936902,
0.0051914668,
0.0332568027,
-0.0442385301,
-0.0041250894,
0.0523917489,
0.0339995548,
0.0025901308,
-0.0172845107,
-0.0286162216,
-0.0518121831,
-0.0270347036,
-0.0153292604,
-0.0276207738,
0.0275137927,
0.0150407115,
0.0106220702,
0.0553059913,
-0.0007232652,
-0.0063592098,
0.0351210311,
-0.0412726589,
-0.0126532344,
-0.0151170371,
0.0272886995,
0.0039924309,
0.0083464961,
-0.0955930948,
-0.0357683636,
0.0062255324,
-0.0165478271,
0.0083722109,
-0.0717725977,
0.0477504767,
-0.0549932979,
-0.0770179704,
-0.0718469843,
-0.0200346299,
0.0092299152,
0.0881045386,
-0.0511012562,
-0.0337359123,
0.0692590326,
0.0076831896,
-0.0003042798,
0.0118754767,
0.0372362919,
-0.0550113209,
0.0769325644,
0.0022022626,
0.0277331341,
0.0036739227,
0.0059852353,
-0.0518125445,
-0.0124012325,
0.0218659788,
-0.0497288778,
0.0721763,
-0.0579286963,
-0.036415644,
-0.0368671007,
0.0051417248,
-0.0548283793,
0.0674147978,
-0.0308222324,
0.0192961451,
-0.0276457183,
0.028996259,
-0.0032094675,
0.0539719611,
0.0177615341,
-0.033398781,
0.0105133085,
0.0182637889,
0.012347592,
-0.0291262884,
0.0287723169,
0.0052560936,
-0.016986385,
-0.035759747,
0.0279925577,
0.041724015,
0.0366208665,
-0.0231174361,
-0.011112364,
0.0662223399,
0.0208480135,
0.0354721434,
-0.0075939456,
0.0036526993,
0.0840537921,
-0.0480827689,
0.0425165184,
0.0641151741,
0.0151347732,
-0.0364897624,
-0.0144248223,
-0.0550275408,
-0.0119883176,
0.0505928844,
0.0418189503,
-0.0878153369,
0.0254261028,
-0.0016014186,
0.0062893904,
-0.0228614714,
-0.0409385748,
0.0050617447,
-0.0968707874,
0.0579630844,
0.0171956401,
-0.0406845436,
-0.0442637131,
0.0117452191,
0.0047838977,
-0.0093310103,
0.0058398773,
0.0086467555,
0.0024600828,
-0.0029499263,
-0.0087374095,
-0.0196622536,
-0.0492604375,
0.0772066787,
-0.0511324406,
-0.0159492735,
0.0389780067,
0.0388490781,
0.042395208,
-0.0947281048,
-0.0373080224,
-0.0346430019,
0.0298186094,
0.0045584617,
0.0309311133,
0.0172620993,
-0.0509396717,
-0.0061214077,
0.0044158068,
0.0105932299,
-0.0209189393,
0.0021174124,
-0.006840657,
0.0144886021,
-0.0235037319,
-0.0167256352,
0.002242794,
-0.0210217386,
0.0435815006,
0.0375276729,
-0.024039695,
-0.0022603141,
-0.0285201557,
0.0037919411,
-0.0389381982,
-0.0973255038,
0.0463672616,
-0.0155941825,
-0.0406887531,
-0.0596814826,
-0.0545600913,
0.0207487363,
0.0316948704,
0.0065099047,
-0.0782207176,
-0.020056732,
0.0426320285,
-0.0673336461,
0.0945567265,
-0.006342914,
0.0395050831,
-0.0050293826,
-0.0257073492,
-0.0346526019,
-0.0499417633,
0.0038584501,
0.0092819985,
-0.0321468376,
-0.0133499531,
0.029196687,
0.071881637,
0.0119134923,
0.000761589,
0.0477904044,
-0.0231560767,
-0.0179561116,
0.0046844799,
0.0551954173,
0.0081002023,
-0.0282328445,
-0.0203775782,
-0.0102036605,
0.0260164458,
-0.0295183845,
0.041653309,
-0.0041719833,
0.0322483294,
-0.0140461121,
-0.0160313919,
0.0066593862,
0.0038595204,
0.0037464162,
-0.0280092247,
-0.0198278297,
-0.0090184473,
-0.0365321822,
-0.0150466301,
-0.0295383371,
-0.041290652,
-0.0291381441,
0.0021554804,
0.0085747298,
0.0318018161,
0.0062789228,
-0.0108372821,
-0.0045950613,
-0.0489399657,
0.0253062472,
0.0732016265,
0.0614102222,
-0.0434608236,
0.0179658122,
-0.0191873182,
0.0032789195,
-0.0434837379,
0.0625577718,
0.0232926477,
0.1019987166,
-0.0054233959,
0.0019029113,
0.0150593091,
-0.0107035255,
0.0092293695,
-0.0612423457,
0.0240766536,
0.0006161865,
0.0659379438,
-0.0396292955,
0.0122767026,
-0.0156179816,
-0.0213224124,
-0.0366062112,
0.0092354584,
0.016264189,
-0.0574428104,
0.0356377736,
0.0394444279,
0.0096587176,
-0.0663499609,
0.0257388968,
-0.032554213,
-0.0213133115,
-0.0182585772,
-0.0304822847,
-0.0297693461,
-0.0383417942,
0.052124545,
0.0096314885,
-0.0260286443,
0.0192918535,
-0.0935323313,
-0.0915635079,
-0.0126153128,
0.0366194211,
0.0268126298,
0.0420816839,
0.0146611789,
0.0700619146,
0.0145131992,
-0.0455302075,
-0.0394719914,
-0.0165554918,
-0.059657298,
0.0315485559,
0.0431896932,
-6.725803987e-33,
-0.0422678851,
-0.0276486464,
0.0234775934,
-0.0085695107,
0.0249067079,
0.0072078318,
-0.0371972769,
0.0191385802,
-0.0605716743,
0.029020125,
0.040014293,
-0.0258021671,
0.0113561014,
0.0122987228,
0.0313651487,
0.0192360859,
0.0050428649,
0.0313328989,
-0.02465613,
-0.0288575199,
0.027891133,
-0.0124822007,
0.0261974428,
-0.0885261297,
0.039851658,
0.0293307044,
0.0379558243,
0.008060243,
0.0384268165,
0.076326862,
-0.0180976558,
0.0378446095,
0.0516454689,
0.033960443,
-0.0212794654,
-0.017067939,
-0.0593121648,
-0.0085677179,
0.0320132636,
0.0660021156,
-0.0546707883,
-0.0045488449,
0.0087631484,
-0.0387061015,
-0.0192073751,
-0.0214302391,
0.0543271862,
-0.0574699491,
-0.0104374439,
0.0303920358,
-0.0155413924,
0.0350351892,
-0.0191820972,
0.0019159851,
0.0571484454,
0.0724092126,
-0.0153771201,
0.0238201302,
-0.0469762869,
0.0507487506,
0.001625866,
-0.0200828295,
0.125327602,
0.0468379036,
0.0257692989,
0.03142941,
0.0531157553,
-0.0001607867,
0.0029382794,
-0.0597673878,
0.0569792651,
0.0578558408,
0.0117932912,
0.0980396345,
0.0058436217,
-0.0082475692,
-0.0070170439,
0.0056357183,
-0.0179706346,
0.0507550612,
0.0212962963,
0.0179739725,
-0.0483159721,
-0.0038021945,
-0.0236881468,
-0.0309453197,
-0.0483929105,
-0.0265806876,
0.0545484088,
-0.0021031213,
-0.0288569741,
0.0360153504,
0.0444617942,
-0.042506218,
0.0535812303,
-0.0020519136,
0.016591683,
0.0097444737,
0.0313522592,
0.01096211,
-0.0392382741,
0.0120467599,
0.0253851321,
0.0232738871,
0.0146856708,
0.0152719654,
-0.0028863656,
-0.0074499752,
-0.0188238602,
-0.0073728948,
-0.0313962288,
-0.0356315598,
-0.0291055199,
-0.0031600879,
0.0401897542,
0.0125867883,
-0.0476953462,
0.0168012306,
0.0315984897,
-0.031349618,
-0.0316391885,
-0.0332600996,
-0.0086020473,
0.0138021363,
-0.0160815939,
0.002019211,
-0.0184343085,
-0.0063668503,
0.0349383578,
0.0134499744,
0.0200121906,
0.0257479493,
3.064e-7,
0.032370694,
0.0032471539,
0.0091015417,
0.0269174892,
0.0158835966,
0.0259422418,
-0.0367862098,
-0.0163398292,
0.0602379106,
-0.0349602848,
0.0042756042,
0.0479795001,
0.0673944578,
0.0161273815,
-0.0450915881,
0.0453675166,
0.0112762908,
0.0050078565,
-0.0466702059,
0.0270566251,
0.0193421338,
0.0027770328,
-0.0259323791,
-0.0170888826,
-0.0004497806,
-0.0513062105,
0.0534757748,
-0.0535880625,
0.0053839376,
-0.0168918762,
0.0338778682,
-0.0162622891,
0.0337437205,
0.0397343859,
-0.0072593405,
-0.0077768485,
0.0432137921,
0.0351066776,
0.0043744245,
0.0063307523,
-0.0161817279,
0.0282174516,
-0.0171191655,
-0.1100428998,
0.0518404208,
-0.0108263725,
-0.0241988599,
-0.0093546221,
-0.01137638,
0.0112496307,
0.0258064829,
0.0095044058,
-0.0100325244,
0.0402371585,
0.0285636317,
-0.0404399112,
-0.013367516,
-0.0299322549,
-0.0249946602,
-0.0579909272,
-0.0095468806,
-0.0259383656,
-0.0352009833,
-0.0141972518,
-0.047300633,
0.0396372713,
-0.0252233036,
2.48899105e-34,
0.021413615,
0.0222239625,
-0.0110349553,
-0.0115425866,
0.0206455309,
-0.0354909673,
-0.0631818622,
0.0111702541,
0.0029149803,
-0.0171635542,
0.0098160682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16464v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16464v2 | InterCLIP-MEP: Interactive CLIP and Memory-Enhanced Predictor for Multi-modal Sarcasm Detection | 2024-06-24T09:13:42 | 2024-06-26T05:40:16 | Junjie Chen, Subin Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | The prevalence of sarcasm in social media, conveyed through text-image
combinations, presents significant challenges for sentiment analysis and
intention mining. Current multi-modal sarcasm detection methods have been
proven to struggle with biases from spurious cues, leading to a superficial
understanding of the complex interactions between text and image. To address
these issues, we propose InterCLIP-MEP, a robust framework for multi-modal
sarcasm detection. InterCLIP-MEP introduces a refined variant of CLIP,
Interactive CLIP (InterCLIP), as the backbone, enhancing sample representations
by embedding cross-modality information in each encoder. Furthermore, a novel
training strategy is designed to adapt InterCLIP for a Memory-Enhanced
Predictor (MEP). MEP uses dynamic dual-channel memory to store valuable
historical knowledge of test samples and then leverages this memory as a
non-parametric classifier to derive the final prediction. By using InterCLIP to
encode text-image interactions more effectively and incorporating MEP,
InterCLIP-MEP offers a more robust recognition of multi-modal sarcasm.
Experiments demonstrate that InterCLIP-MEP achieves state-of-the-art
performance on the MMSD2.0 benchmark. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/CoderChen01/InterCLIP-MEP. | [
0.0265908819,
0.0164624844,
-0.0461243056,
0.0342812352,
-0.0178082753,
0.0161147509,
-0.0028240201,
0.0378978066,
-0.0115760565,
-0.0565392375,
-0.0391984358,
0.0010403534,
-0.0333478078,
0.0413665399,
-0.0078195352,
-0.0548661426,
0.0178312715,
0.0284535028,
-0.021006871,
-0.0179270525,
0.0433689766,
0.0116411895,
-0.0327705555,
0.0414876863,
-0.023524791,
0.0021632384,
-0.0174225681,
0.0655210614,
0.019657813,
-0.0431746095,
0.032736782,
0.0137824165,
0.026199881,
0.0003310842,
0.000002054,
-0.0037088552,
-0.0060325987,
-0.0055497889,
-0.0234075617,
-0.016900979,
0.0892645717,
-0.0716707632,
-0.0128048463,
0.0001277476,
-0.0316367261,
0.0233978871,
0.0478512831,
0.0124442372,
0.054913342,
0.0463273339,
-0.0223018397,
0.0227157902,
-0.0089800078,
0.0086179245,
0.034991622,
-0.0194690451,
0.0054460559,
0.0014683888,
-0.0476237871,
0.018234171,
-0.0337286443,
0.0058072251,
-0.0402860679,
0.0245957579,
-0.024001563,
0.0266704466,
0.0140029779,
-0.004771634,
-0.0477877744,
0.0356223658,
0.0349298343,
-0.0018345905,
-0.0132627543,
0.0032822341,
0.0031693121,
-0.0225207936,
-0.0237478465,
-0.0001628284,
0.0001014302,
0.0060417829,
-0.0507019795,
0.0414502844,
-0.0155139994,
0.0231698994,
0.0316906758,
-0.0112707252,
0.0052886819,
-0.0260034669,
0.0066198236,
0.0077291806,
-0.0096083703,
0.0138296075,
0.0297953878,
0.0249815751,
0.0466450192,
-0.0013429408,
-0.0355035439,
-0.0842444971,
0.0363795459,
-0.0352381878,
-0.032618437,
0.0064591803,
-0.029808918,
0.0517863072,
-0.0061472915,
-0.0076086898,
0.0070229308,
0.046836827,
-0.0197905768,
-0.0308097638,
-0.047168117,
0.0117515437,
-0.0200524647,
-0.0040999069,
-0.0075141042,
-0.017239362,
-0.0638271049,
0.0212788247,
-0.0400060974,
-0.0171669926,
0.0077132648,
0.0096096424,
-0.0184199791,
0.0253349561,
-0.0150471935,
0.0601748489,
-0.0186886396,
0.0151426233,
-0.0532188788,
-0.0303702652,
-0.0222327281,
0.0398971625,
0.0278119054,
-0.0134705072,
0.0544546619,
0.0847452208,
-0.0033310882,
-0.0623390973,
-0.0691463649,
-0.0165322088,
-0.0605418906,
-0.0336758867,
0.0595205203,
-0.0242562145,
0.0403392538,
-0.0007981072,
-0.0259125624,
0.0169848967,
-0.003230717,
0.0020566988,
-0.039029751,
0.08436656,
-0.0329543389,
-0.0581300557,
0.0058149253,
0.0121457316,
-0.0691170841,
0.0733977929,
0.0098175192,
0.0291967075,
0.0457573645,
0.0296421684,
-0.0391141251,
-0.0041671572,
0.0486001261,
-0.0018539662,
-0.0749975741,
0.0096565466,
-0.0329214968,
-0.014626707,
0.032381475,
0.0158060789,
-0.0552298985,
-0.0310927574,
0.0078469981,
-0.00757303,
-0.0521497913,
0.0302411467,
0.0338123329,
0.0125752985,
-0.0163150113,
-0.0319559686,
-0.0265848227,
0.0423896611,
-0.0696412623,
-0.0267536901,
-0.0323442072,
0.0186618827,
-0.0320994556,
-0.010430065,
-0.0056999954,
-0.0413076915,
0.0414886102,
-0.0196308866,
0.0473083369,
-0.0013341081,
-0.0319181979,
0.0587342791,
-0.0020601186,
-0.015316328,
-0.0593661852,
-0.021473784,
-0.005168194,
0.051052656,
-0.018023828,
-0.0401561037,
-0.0389771983,
-0.0051461789,
-0.0555577092,
0.0018680186,
-0.0500764772,
0.0046472107,
0.0477078259,
-0.0417640172,
0.0009956989,
-0.0475387536,
0.0017807868,
0.004275721,
0.0095324945,
0.0596123822,
-0.009762113,
0.0205583833,
0.118377246,
0.0031022625,
0.0265697353,
0.0036217775,
-0.0216370206,
0.0319861583,
0.0279128365,
-0.0213502888,
-0.0070092157,
-0.0420620739,
0.0247443076,
-0.0492789559,
-0.0646781251,
0.0372709669,
-0.0351491794,
-0.1221049055,
0.0271040648,
-0.0801649019,
-0.023289619,
0.0210738052,
-0.0349671319,
-0.0171326492,
0.0529366881,
-0.0221097209,
0.032987833,
-0.0664055869,
-0.0237098485,
-0.0272952113,
0.0445501208,
0.0285146125,
0.0438511036,
-0.0273353346,
-0.0460212454,
0.034602657,
0.031975884,
0.0078199338,
0.0584045611,
-0.0463139042,
0.0027874873,
0.001582298,
0.0075940732,
-0.0074313357,
0.0308631621,
-0.0506640933,
-0.0464396849,
-0.1083896831,
-0.0008203131,
-0.0020857898,
-0.0088894032,
0.0169518664,
-0.0174227506,
0.0189132635,
-0.0039640539,
-0.0006739492,
0.0167017784,
-0.0264524315,
0.0298403818,
-0.0035898306,
-0.0013175231,
0.0417193323,
0.0053710928,
-0.0036882018,
0.0124062244,
0.027944902,
-0.028037589,
-0.0178357456,
0.0007524893,
-0.0041306261,
-0.0237844344,
0.0042446353,
-0.0112301167,
-0.0588762239,
0.0019016435,
-0.0055047441,
0.0062779891,
0.0573034249,
0.0370024368,
0.0430780686,
-0.0093938932,
-0.0007513217,
-0.0230444837,
0.0294381641,
0.0213053357,
0.0431493782,
-0.0077417362,
-0.0196230821,
-0.0519519299,
0.0466283076,
-0.0114831552,
0.0427118726,
-0.047347229,
0.0088506313,
0.0179923363,
-0.0103180287,
0.0102752149,
-0.0083178561,
-0.0192455854,
-0.030096611,
0.011272653,
-0.0412860438,
0.0456826575,
-0.0068730628,
-0.0578387529,
-0.008005972,
-0.0027321549,
-0.0041393396,
0.083565861,
-0.0468672439,
0.0233978927,
0.0224389695,
0.0051491647,
0.0042088805,
-0.0372954831,
0.014029976,
-0.0252339281,
0.0147172818,
0.0141079947,
-0.0107174823,
-0.0000180661,
-0.0534857549,
-0.024567727,
-0.034194991,
-0.0643087253,
-0.0157223567,
-0.0017708361,
0.0039899964,
-0.0101959426,
0.0070634475,
0.0126712192,
-0.0348909907,
-0.0240439139,
-0.021798918,
0.0229791384,
0.0401958041,
0.038406454,
-0.0220265239,
0.0271290168,
0.0010183345,
-0.026350813,
0.0829953626,
-0.0245901328,
0.0158842169,
-0.0241905432,
0.0157586671,
0.0219919924,
0.0411367975,
0.0139383441,
-0.0237026177,
0.0203308444,
-0.0106566688,
-0.000519229,
0.074456282,
0.0075336699,
-0.080535315,
-0.0056252307,
0.0066608228,
-0.0096130325,
0.0495165549,
-0.0172505341,
-0.0438533388,
-0.0857059211,
-0.0179041326,
-0.0024527353,
-0.0427672528,
0.0258916635,
-0.039812047,
-0.0958757773,
0.0011360015,
-0.0117000872,
0.0048919218,
0.0435726158,
0.0286025312,
-0.0062199035,
0.0046644369,
0.0073110024,
-0.0541638955,
0.0077519109,
-0.0224675331,
-0.0181815475,
-0.0333941318,
-0.0515154451,
0.0192897655,
0.0238167662,
0.0313190147,
-0.0082800891,
0.0686384067,
0.0028784906,
-0.0658573285,
-0.0145522729,
-0.071870923,
0.0265175626,
-0.0382913649,
0.1093718708,
-0.0536264293,
0.0149851134,
-0.031804882,
-0.0011352469,
-0.0016391712,
0.0232241284,
-0.0175211746,
0.0351099595,
-0.0418718196,
0.0050583794,
-0.0483591706,
0.0281618927,
0.0189535525,
0.0356560051,
0.0095271738,
-0.0544610731,
-0.0221427884,
0.0040020007,
-0.016392367,
-0.0559773073,
0.0005281683,
0.0201879144,
0.0139264325,
0.0253047589,
-0.0387251228,
-0.0224317238,
0.0167422183,
0.0448924974,
-0.0648004264,
-0.0384656228,
-0.0351587869,
0.0091630481,
-0.054760959,
-0.0059237476,
0.0032451374,
0.0065401429,
0.0181501079,
-0.00004796,
0.0417615287,
-0.0257437304,
-0.0066140355,
0.0478207283,
-0.0819252133,
-0.0432312004,
-0.0130595807,
0.0938241184,
0.0120131262,
0.0449257903,
0.0100680888,
0.0075067007,
0.0517495051,
0.0135430694,
0.023027081,
0.0342642181,
0.0774394795,
0.042333588,
-4.657e-7,
0.0379695855,
-0.0224487111,
0.0536784679,
0.0199263059,
-0.0116076013,
-0.0084826406,
-0.0161733218,
-0.0154439341,
-0.0271392092,
0.0537110455,
-0.0161412805,
-0.040407747,
0.0534404181,
0.0333837532,
-0.0302342027,
0.010050999,
-0.0474951342,
0.000907941,
-0.0292792022,
-0.0205084365,
-0.0562615283,
-0.0256544743,
0.0120007684,
-0.0131752752,
0.0095325764,
0.0421664305,
0.0432889462,
0.0095587559,
-0.0179481804,
0.0454079546,
-0.0332405865,
-0.0166120455,
0.0365514345,
-0.0013488235,
-0.0252919048,
0.0748035982,
0.0227354281,
-0.01085163,
-0.0139827644,
0.0351613127,
-0.0019051007,
0.0624222159,
0.0278222524,
0.0028337059,
0.0534155034,
-0.0067744665,
0.0417096689,
-0.0144297443,
0.0111854244,
0.0291970987,
0.03064394,
-0.0398248062,
-0.0609530807,
0.0112290476,
-0.0030962774,
-0.0166608971,
-0.0020538766,
0.0109288143,
-0.1049134359,
0.0278215483,
-0.0002028264,
-0.0075168977,
-0.0338262469,
0.0197177026,
0.0532020293,
-0.0084775342,
0.0043312595,
-0.0066574197,
-0.0523212403,
-0.0365247466,
0.1052304804,
-0.050834097,
-0.0002237086,
0.0144760916,
0.0570030734,
0.0165367238,
0.008967665,
0.0133572528,
0.013428553,
0.0025400158,
-0.0385114327,
0.0474101156,
-0.0065718344,
-6.308121456e-33,
-0.0144623844,
0.0020927095,
-0.0202750601,
-0.0042382549,
-0.0224269778,
0.0483500622,
-0.0211000405,
-0.0121533489,
0.0049426388,
-0.0001041225,
0.0129278852,
0.0027760486,
0.0028239866,
0.010263714,
0.0175240543,
0.000508341,
0.0431854129,
0.0082386723,
-0.0106672486,
-0.0066767219,
0.0581032857,
0.0471670739,
0.0808558688,
-0.0814045295,
-0.0313875042,
0.0036200655,
-0.0515546612,
0.0071043829,
0.0732688606,
0.0710236728,
0.0024067035,
0.0618526712,
0.015071746,
-0.0196657293,
-0.0003003176,
0.0207833219,
-0.0462533943,
-0.0175483003,
-0.0254026037,
0.0068783532,
-0.0430515446,
-0.002637835,
0.032606598,
0.0005851552,
-0.009512037,
-0.0162413195,
0.0252725966,
-0.0051500723,
0.0308973659,
-0.0538736358,
-0.051361531,
0.0104500474,
-0.0058461758,
-0.0012214169,
0.0358387195,
0.0183026809,
0.0478534028,
0.0181512367,
-0.064338848,
0.0375425257,
-0.1023364738,
-0.0400975719,
-0.0051032738,
-0.0019186583,
0.0322128758,
0.0838298351,
0.0083879717,
0.0039893673,
0.0534873232,
-0.0258315876,
0.0555502698,
0.0163363479,
0.0386996381,
0.0963970646,
0.0615520552,
-0.0545491353,
-0.0159166474,
-0.0053168549,
0.0712486878,
0.0014049282,
0.0284753814,
-0.0036714552,
-0.0412951857,
0.0250762384,
0.0164864548,
0.0347396173,
-0.0079589682,
-0.0555594563,
0.0027963137,
0.0657098368,
-0.0070239948,
0.0599999018,
0.0560972393,
-0.0296720341,
0.0150147974,
0.0102774752,
-0.0210877508,
0.0416798852,
-0.0046947617,
0.0190899689,
0.005047271,
-0.0391901769,
0.0337544009,
-0.0121648749,
0.0251977146,
0.0166227296,
0.1069286242,
0.0322207846,
-0.0576627403,
-0.0138961328,
0.0002144377,
0.0299022272,
-0.0373629406,
0.0271994714,
-0.0048410455,
0.0452634506,
-0.0373823717,
0.0107599944,
-0.0046178605,
0.0583883747,
-0.0364244319,
-0.0524991937,
0.0201110207,
0.0325366482,
-0.0528336093,
-0.0185260288,
-0.0119720176,
-0.1048443392,
-0.025258882,
-0.0978050232,
-0.0028772221,
-0.0104822638,
2.965e-7,
0.0015979351,
0.0602439642,
-0.0087728584,
-0.0074254097,
0.0389250778,
0.0547017381,
-0.0187351163,
0.0249511339,
-0.0340465419,
-0.0310984701,
0.0205642506,
0.0169926118,
0.0032056496,
0.0333066322,
-0.0556330793,
0.0332587324,
-0.0082595991,
0.0005448505,
0.0023432593,
0.0358546823,
0.0865668505,
0.0685508251,
0.0355080925,
-0.0191157144,
0.0149396025,
-0.0203379504,
0.0892958716,
0.0188571028,
0.0464510694,
-0.0545630381,
-0.0072585843,
-0.0105062332,
-0.0214173179,
0.0303658899,
-0.0141972015,
-0.0214565173,
-0.0328055471,
0.0629033819,
-0.0390268192,
-0.0548627116,
0.0089060944,
0.0402547643,
-0.0221010614,
0.0036855929,
0.048218023,
-0.0314780362,
-0.0169846732,
-0.0644490123,
-0.0373184867,
0.0001619009,
0.0547001436,
0.0081567466,
-0.0265290607,
0.0301757585,
0.0089113582,
-0.0043037054,
-0.0275638737,
-0.1345429122,
0.0207508858,
0.0063667004,
-0.0214364585,
-0.0059917839,
-0.0252337418,
-0.0129693942,
0.0707453564,
-0.0971185043,
-0.0222418644,
2.299361311e-34,
0.0354496054,
-0.0118732071,
0.0271643084,
-0.0041455445,
0.0025537449,
0.0041304161,
0.0153408591,
-0.0131380409,
0.0343762338,
0.0035114365,
-0.0255035535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16450v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16450v1 | Building on Efficient Foundations: Effectively Training LLMs with Structured Feedforward Layers | 2024-06-24T08:43:21 | 2024-06-24T08:43:21 | Xiuying Wei, Skander Moalla, Razvan Pascanu, Caglar Gulcehre | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art results in large language models (LLMs) often rely on scale,
which becomes computationally expensive. This has sparked a research agenda to
reduce these models' parameter count and computational costs without
significantly impacting their performance. Our study focuses on
transformer-based LLMs, specifically targeting the computationally intensive
feedforward networks (FFN), which are less studied than attention blocks. We
consider three candidate linear layer approximations in the FFN by combining
efficient low-rank and block-diagonal matrices. In contrast to many previous
works that examined these approximations, our study i) explores these
structures from the training-from-scratch perspective, ii) scales up to 1.3B
parameters, and iii) is conducted within recent Transformer-based LLMs rather
than convolutional architectures. We first demonstrate they can lead to actual
computational gains in various scenarios, including online decoding when using
a pre-merge technique. Additionally, we propose a novel training regime, called
\textit{self-guided training}, aimed at improving the poor training dynamics
that these approximations exhibit when used from initialization. Experiments on
the large RefinedWeb dataset show that our methods are both efficient and
effective for training and inference. Interestingly, these structured FFNs
exhibit steeper scaling curves than the original models. Further applying
self-guided training to the structured matrices with 32\% FFN parameters and
2.5$\times$ speed-up enables only a 0.4 perplexity increase under the same
training FLOPs. Finally, we develop the wide and structured networks surpassing
the current medium-sized and large-sized Transformer in perplexity and
throughput performance. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/CLAIRE-Labo/StructuredFFN/tree/main}. | [
-0.0054245722,
0.0621846355,
0.013337695,
0.0516749695,
0.0023556084,
0.0221737605,
0.0304762572,
-0.0226097256,
-0.002481801,
-0.0018877621,
-0.0617992394,
-0.0608928613,
0.0138378814,
0.0109465811,
0.0230489559,
0.0240140725,
0.0129910158,
-0.0585329458,
-0.0707763135,
-0.009120658,
-0.0051271166,
0.0292227902,
-0.0161418132,
0.0229961574,
0.0103812367,
-0.0229310747,
-0.0310976654,
0.0131749315,
-0.0070801037,
-0.0204554591,
0.0047428026,
0.0507705286,
0.0503719337,
0.0485485308,
0.0000023285,
0.0161412098,
0.021106448,
-0.0198600348,
-0.0241215359,
0.0526062623,
0.0298964325,
-0.0313940197,
-0.0505995825,
0.0099219158,
-0.0072173425,
-0.0739651248,
0.0518254153,
0.039983701,
0.0317962132,
0.051230669,
0.0112982476,
-0.0916027054,
0.0742010996,
-0.0428291559,
-0.0474302322,
-0.0240454432,
0.0291392487,
-0.0107726613,
-0.055859983,
0.0127507998,
-0.0271941088,
0.0447349958,
0.0444023944,
0.0054718531,
0.0191507358,
0.0428542159,
-0.0247657467,
-0.0220504198,
-0.0081809834,
0.0582554489,
-0.0443695709,
-0.0340062268,
0.0037850048,
-0.0122227343,
-0.0276775081,
-0.0115592377,
-0.0277026705,
0.0538333282,
0.0223129001,
0.0159610771,
0.00670355,
0.008785042,
0.0684067681,
0.0270155855,
-0.0412596986,
0.0292257424,
0.0113824317,
-0.0141176451,
-0.0152453082,
-0.0241406504,
0.0185305644,
-0.0237541087,
-0.0079818182,
0.0295576211,
0.0250389446,
-0.0030275097,
-0.0457003191,
-0.0478216894,
-0.0151047623,
-0.0463327803,
0.0815761983,
0.0469592884,
-0.0173726212,
0.0474453643,
-0.0714247301,
0.0195276029,
-0.060386315,
0.0179576986,
-0.0362474844,
0.0232486632,
-0.0145933591,
-0.0026551727,
-0.0322944596,
0.0087762838,
-0.02949984,
-0.0275096279,
-0.0105363792,
0.0048598917,
0.0126777161,
-0.0013803393,
0.0059561203,
-0.0189763214,
-0.0282566417,
-0.0294864662,
0.0318941996,
0.0382647626,
0.0457990058,
0.0034073913,
-0.0029889736,
-0.0599721149,
-0.0373929515,
0.0220479798,
0.0257815141,
-0.0046850606,
0.0208076015,
0.0485715643,
-0.0169628356,
-0.0484430864,
-0.0663924217,
0.0441681407,
-0.0282639489,
-0.0295320451,
0.0157631561,
-0.0745642781,
0.0571810082,
-0.0249690693,
-0.0103478562,
-0.0020722833,
0.034245532,
0.0385395028,
-0.0248337556,
0.0511422753,
0.0127951531,
0.021850314,
0.0239964593,
-0.0066710068,
0.0180170685,
0.0455832481,
0.0183163751,
0.0438951403,
-0.0114038736,
-0.0494648218,
-0.0230073277,
0.0738132149,
0.0309858136,
0.0288979653,
-0.0473423302,
-0.0305662099,
0.0036998675,
0.0096741533,
0.061071638,
0.0615419596,
-0.0479365177,
-0.0004093288,
0.0773413628,
0.0405782126,
0.055922281,
0.0933282301,
0.0175525099,
0.0254124627,
0.0165122543,
-0.0145763159,
-0.0254854765,
0.0433427505,
0.0128482524,
0.0079391683,
0.0344575569,
0.0588187613,
-0.0739080757,
-0.0060409289,
0.0118984357,
-0.0221708231,
0.0259913784,
0.0115388799,
0.0753368363,
0.0302064959,
-0.0695983842,
0.0677675828,
0.0257281382,
-0.0536367819,
-0.0119181974,
-0.0300423577,
-0.0098388717,
0.0271631628,
0.038140092,
0.0113971587,
0.0064229788,
-0.0003503817,
0.0261838697,
0.0209120866,
0.0124586141,
0.0344504341,
0.0091796443,
-0.0612400472,
0.0115909595,
0.0207594149,
0.0058984719,
0.0131072327,
0.0014867954,
-0.020911267,
0.0125707956,
-0.0168197956,
-0.0401077643,
0.0268775281,
-0.018164333,
-0.0021522308,
0.03638459,
0.0027591947,
0.0151529666,
0.0171791259,
0.0004869189,
0.0135515491,
0.0422269851,
-0.0698668957,
-0.0115089947,
-0.0437273346,
-0.0845559016,
-0.0377129503,
0.0313125439,
0.0309196822,
0.0052584922,
0.0791742504,
-0.0367522128,
-0.0404906236,
0.0358252823,
-0.0521741323,
0.0448127426,
-0.0539065041,
0.024041893,
0.0166167747,
0.0484130159,
-0.0027226002,
0.0211544242,
-0.0428512059,
0.0151290027,
-0.0279713497,
-0.0091895293,
0.0022255778,
-0.0218700413,
-0.0425556041,
0.0094693042,
-0.0312893353,
0.0137985898,
-0.0473158658,
-0.0202573631,
-0.0004891215,
-0.026151849,
-0.0389951505,
-0.0062262742,
-0.0429650322,
0.0181772262,
0.0145631107,
0.0123462034,
0.0253493898,
-0.0077871941,
-0.0178538952,
0.0203041099,
-0.0221781153,
-0.0061545367,
0.0035035952,
-0.0037567806,
-0.069194302,
-0.0215217806,
-0.0729048923,
0.0062437328,
0.0540076755,
-0.039737653,
-0.0356165096,
-0.0524086729,
0.0010496166,
0.0235032924,
0.0358617119,
-0.0361308753,
-0.0639554113,
-0.0206571203,
-0.0458296388,
0.0209378339,
0.0430291705,
0.0111608561,
-0.0193039645,
0.0402224511,
0.0121681681,
-0.0114496332,
0.000501313,
-0.0258704927,
-0.0225238595,
-0.0182265565,
-0.0202118661,
-0.0080357483,
0.0783873349,
0.0005390314,
0.012469423,
-0.0487561971,
-0.0393079296,
0.0281699728,
-0.0095264958,
-0.0099493628,
-0.0041105305,
-0.0105186906,
0.0193072762,
-0.0170323309,
-0.0407499522,
0.0480688289,
-0.0678927004,
-0.0348765776,
0.0106279384,
-0.0375688225,
-0.043494422,
0.0428938493,
0.0182390604,
0.0245888885,
-0.0344768055,
-0.0386709459,
-0.0289330501,
0.0065871119,
-0.0070182336,
-0.0316857547,
0.0660438389,
-0.0115124527,
0.0312053841,
-0.0401886925,
-0.0348075628,
-0.0283919852,
-0.0193695985,
-0.0133725675,
0.0011290287,
0.0333100222,
-0.0244757943,
-0.0158788562,
0.0509025902,
0.016798107,
0.0788714588,
-0.0098893112,
0.0155197028,
-0.0258467328,
0.049421005,
-0.0040785549,
0.0156359673,
0.0406945571,
-0.0159942023,
0.0588330925,
0.0557876304,
0.0290952362,
0.0205385964,
-0.0808527619,
0.0038421676,
0.055560749,
0.0121691786,
-0.0029981649,
0.0214765593,
0.0367978066,
-0.0758623406,
0.005130752,
0.1023598984,
0.0041202763,
-0.0527348481,
0.0005730413,
0.0242945049,
0.0158693437,
-0.0154630896,
0.0340628289,
-0.051846493,
-0.0145447552,
0.0090880021,
0.015627658,
0.0443179905,
-0.0100898296,
-0.0002647393,
-0.116394937,
0.0393353328,
0.0374755673,
0.0133718532,
-0.0582619794,
-0.0460918322,
-0.0380469449,
-0.0022805578,
0.0159584209,
0.0297446214,
-0.0032338274,
-0.039147988,
0.0203167535,
-0.0097256126,
-0.0203311034,
0.0203911066,
-0.0310569387,
0.0421669781,
0.0419909768,
-0.0169040021,
-0.0158351883,
-0.0801942274,
0.0470095761,
-0.0367663987,
-0.0012963094,
0.0085219545,
0.0304475185,
-0.0064376802,
-0.0202801619,
0.0047938093,
0.0338970423,
-0.0771157965,
-0.0226006936,
-0.0352904722,
0.0478526577,
0.0049635763,
-0.0052129282,
0.0169824529,
0.0153389079,
-0.0454760566,
0.0638332963,
0.0298710074,
-0.033816807,
-0.0074903462,
0.0044467789,
0.0264664982,
-0.0426427685,
-0.0572369322,
0.0335044302,
0.0432608463,
-0.0272808932,
-0.0151163321,
0.0052177398,
-0.0038865514,
0.0137637248,
-0.0248974077,
-0.0442836843,
0.0437134989,
0.0026687977,
-0.0521233268,
0.0475900844,
-0.034806598,
0.0270069167,
-0.0598049834,
0.0000065511,
0.058897838,
-0.0287967212,
0.0019579967,
-0.0070235212,
-0.1339537799,
-0.0234588888,
-0.0087114442,
0.0122057255,
0.0066134064,
0.0324320272,
0.0067117237,
-0.0287986845,
-0.0075102365,
0.0024234096,
-0.0549178757,
0.0262464397,
0.0305330977,
-0.0179496035,
0.0180429537,
0.0308985822,
-0.0285590477,
0.0368747152,
0.0308934934,
0.0425293446,
-0.0201206729,
-0.0190522596,
0.0308954939,
-0.0261502303,
0.0548370928,
0.0240119621,
0.006586642,
-0.0180476084,
0.0420740061,
0.0250763018,
0.0153274927,
-0.0390494168,
-0.0210470203,
0.0415652543,
0.0105189141,
0.0039738491,
0.0061414712,
0.0535051674,
-0.0132350689,
0.0035532243,
0.0133145163,
-0.0382574387,
-0.0436807238,
0.02422994,
-0.0019361328,
-0.0648600385,
0.0068570692,
0.0281033628,
0.0105755543,
-0.0088186841,
0.0380879529,
0.0051396745,
0.014606338,
-0.0691106245,
0.0282913037,
-0.0626432598,
-0.0714420304,
-0.0539224744,
-0.042802684,
0.0506505854,
-0.0191517603,
0.0019946394,
0.0015236423,
-0.0085007241,
-0.0247224998,
0.0037466865,
-0.0366378911,
-0.0102610299,
0.0650556386,
0.0329482518,
0.0003086162,
0.0028021671,
0.0528277382,
0.036890462,
0.0290239975,
0.0332997106,
0.0427846014,
-0.0208326709,
-0.0317671746,
-0.0301930625,
0.0367389061,
-0.031763956,
-0.0237777308,
-0.0134219453,
-0.0842844918,
0.0069523035,
-0.0001332998,
0.0008893469,
-0.0521487221,
0.0261817388,
0.0272698738,
0.0164502654,
0.00720328,
-0.0134776505,
-0.0071427599,
0.0331309065,
-0.0428754948,
-0.029487446,
-6.70701224e-33,
0.0011057729,
0.0082664508,
0.0042578895,
0.0255460795,
-0.031064406,
0.0061438284,
-0.0257660635,
0.0024943885,
-0.0429750048,
-0.0151691921,
-0.034790691,
0.0181699879,
0.0046902965,
0.0646625087,
-0.0033851275,
-0.0208517537,
0.0556880943,
-0.0285699982,
0.0229561068,
0.0185262319,
-0.0264056288,
0.036121767,
0.0157132987,
-0.0177063234,
-0.0677580312,
-0.0269180015,
-0.0157814287,
-0.002305781,
0.0193344709,
0.0265653003,
-0.0541850626,
0.0179266725,
0.0228379834,
-0.0595325343,
-0.022337772,
0.0131003996,
-0.0937647969,
0.0397887565,
-0.0116080446,
0.0316480212,
-0.0092022065,
-0.0029828746,
0.0688191876,
0.0234771259,
-0.023324661,
-0.0389346033,
-0.0032394594,
-0.0211175494,
-0.0464928262,
-0.0187987927,
-0.0106966309,
0.0330614634,
0.0050190603,
-0.0162657406,
0.0677895248,
-0.0027451033,
-0.0400039926,
0.0501580909,
-0.1001761332,
0.0147233643,
0.0098048262,
0.0692617595,
0.0675072372,
0.0485425144,
0.0083605712,
0.017940592,
0.0467822663,
-0.0105632721,
-0.0533362292,
0.0097049857,
0.0391337126,
0.0266302396,
0.0388839282,
0.0034176654,
0.0482335836,
-0.0046348074,
-0.0644825473,
-0.0277150888,
0.0134676853,
0.0468028747,
0.0273323953,
0.0359254181,
-0.0078935344,
-0.0427238382,
-0.0293674283,
-0.0184084643,
-0.0452538505,
-0.006203867,
0.0132487863,
0.0121870562,
0.0023590429,
-0.0307730194,
0.0099295564,
-0.0511810668,
0.0206590462,
0.0109396344,
0.0200024452,
0.0643787906,
-0.0006715982,
0.0129898069,
-0.0832633302,
-0.0202444475,
-0.0154608591,
-0.010873423,
-0.0038009884,
0.0110905571,
0.0337277688,
0.0450819843,
-0.0754190758,
-0.0458182879,
-0.0332882181,
-0.0093727456,
0.0226978231,
0.0803375393,
0.0518926121,
-0.0047142301,
0.0096310796,
0.0585007854,
-0.0163028333,
0.0307254586,
0.001077111,
0.0149194151,
0.027911298,
0.0535209067,
-0.0139869787,
-0.0072416933,
-0.0599986091,
0.0218576957,
0.0486447774,
-0.083731249,
-0.0406666026,
0.054038018,
3.012e-7,
0.0286719073,
0.0280762017,
0.01240052,
0.0050467276,
0.0398535542,
0.0239332654,
0.0172043722,
-0.0016369042,
-0.0004709215,
-0.0163278058,
0.0203592535,
0.0263752993,
0.0664471164,
-0.0095148068,
-0.0681791157,
-0.0027425182,
-0.079297334,
0.0390774421,
-0.0132437358,
-0.0370985828,
-0.0204541255,
0.1228004172,
-0.013967528,
-0.0089816684,
0.0235373899,
-0.00079111,
0.0586843826,
0.0028596832,
0.0080376305,
-0.0069343722,
-0.0237348694,
-0.0017978696,
-0.0594479404,
-0.006050501,
-0.0147469891,
0.0352187715,
-0.0109120868,
0.0727064833,
0.0208318103,
-0.009230285,
0.0318460874,
0.0127566457,
-0.0315863863,
-0.0463065207,
0.0511238351,
-0.0690505132,
-0.0315738879,
0.0050637932,
-0.0153854517,
0.0304915477,
-0.0533930659,
-0.016049426,
0.0239982437,
0.0128216958,
0.0431364365,
-0.0249578971,
0.0172168668,
-0.0797108114,
0.0126214121,
0.0198817849,
-0.0705679655,
-0.0422378071,
-0.0779020488,
-0.0207772292,
0.0699802637,
-0.005885439,
-0.0239519067,
3.114185297e-34,
0.0127112018,
-0.0137267746,
0.0175091513,
0.0386713073,
-0.0255775191,
-0.0249541476,
0.0206661895,
0.0096371621,
-0.0171091203,
-0.1235102117,
-0.0332438946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16441v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16441v1 | UniCoder: Scaling Code Large Language Model via Universal Code | 2024-06-24T08:32:48 | 2024-06-24T08:32:48 | Tao Sun, Linzheng Chai, Jian Yang, Yuwei Yin, Hongcheng Guo, Jiaheng Liu, Bing Wang, Liqun Yang, Zhoujun Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Intermediate reasoning or acting steps have successfully improved large
language models (LLMs) for handling various downstream natural language
processing (NLP) tasks. When applying LLMs for code generation, recent works
mainly focus on directing the models to articulate intermediate
natural-language reasoning steps, as in chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting, and
then output code with the natural language or other structured intermediate
steps. However, such output is not suitable for code translation or generation
tasks since the standard CoT has different logical structures and forms of
expression with the code. In this work, we introduce the universal code
(UniCode) as the intermediate representation. It is a description of algorithm
steps using a mix of conventions of programming languages, such as assignment
operator, conditional operator, and loop. Hence, we collect an instruction
dataset UniCoder-Instruct to train our model UniCoder on multi-task learning
objectives. UniCoder-Instruct comprises natural-language questions, code
solutions, and the corresponding universal code. The alignment between the
intermediate universal code representation and the final code solution
significantly improves the quality of the generated code. The experimental
results demonstrate that UniCoder with the universal code significantly
outperforms the previous prompting methods by a large margin, showcasing the
effectiveness of the structural clues in pseudo-code. | [
0.0488867238,
0.0258346871,
-0.0196587127,
0.0241745859,
-0.0272153262,
0.0540174916,
-0.0074890116,
-0.0311181042,
0.0239490047,
-0.0085287858,
-0.0021175793,
-0.0241460539,
-0.0027753271,
0.0363869071,
0.0530752726,
-0.0232861117,
0.0165493842,
-0.0569175482,
-0.0050311149,
0.0033437235,
-0.0034239078,
0.0402010009,
0.0130343847,
0.0389010645,
0.0198675543,
-0.0427904427,
-0.0343084186,
0.0136392917,
0.0219124071,
-0.0464730635,
0.0083762212,
0.0321902856,
0.040652141,
-0.0249480568,
0.0000022136,
-0.0593115687,
-0.0197946634,
-0.0023724977,
-0.0204519033,
-0.0042061424,
0.0208309535,
0.006477776,
-0.0037053446,
0.0520473607,
-0.0374073274,
-0.0197398737,
0.0603788197,
0.031334199,
0.0742473677,
0.0805227086,
0.0006028945,
-0.0610547215,
0.0041828239,
0.0001823616,
0.018574141,
-0.0258933082,
0.0172367804,
0.0580224395,
0.0280654915,
0.0171141624,
0.0129390806,
0.003774385,
0.0543842912,
0.0024844937,
-0.0180912483,
0.041178111,
0.013063781,
-0.0386742204,
-0.0342251211,
0.0563136972,
-0.0413669236,
-0.0220049601,
0.009105715,
-0.0098186871,
0.0004538624,
-0.0754597783,
-0.0332169905,
0.0586703941,
-0.0216090865,
0.0265902206,
0.0607106946,
0.0038020131,
0.0031150784,
-0.0007993313,
-0.0631331429,
0.0514886528,
-0.0085995784,
-0.0291635692,
-0.0171813276,
-0.0240948852,
0.0080368128,
-0.0675173402,
0.0277821068,
0.0738308653,
-0.04268362,
0.0122403866,
-0.0250926781,
-0.0012252432,
0.0073060426,
-0.0472354256,
0.0667251274,
0.04437593,
-0.0252364129,
0.0163821727,
-0.0495567806,
0.0660531819,
-0.0461330935,
0.0103482464,
-0.0384835005,
0.0257099699,
-0.0651680678,
-0.0066722413,
-0.0394689925,
0.0599793382,
-0.0196482465,
0.002092819,
-0.0019061995,
0.0646308064,
0.0168499351,
0.038836237,
0.0457513928,
-0.0214659031,
-0.0155357542,
0.0000930882,
-0.0052585043,
0.0388399623,
-0.027890332,
-0.0274205822,
-0.0103330314,
-0.0305065662,
0.0020191974,
0.0355325341,
0.003927445,
-0.0354662612,
0.0444419384,
0.056854628,
-0.0030670352,
0.0153054623,
-0.0565948226,
-0.0289742537,
0.0119757969,
-0.0730611756,
0.0207485482,
-0.0916993693,
-0.0023745634,
0.0186803024,
-0.003629029,
-0.0272693355,
0.0219676904,
0.0346348621,
-0.0079506049,
0.056843821,
-0.0464359075,
0.0066402513,
-0.0254756585,
-0.0131239835,
-0.009156215,
0.0455704816,
0.052917514,
0.022667218,
-0.0038464637,
-0.0288774967,
-0.0163005777,
0.0139399832,
-0.0068544904,
-0.0087268697,
0.0170385111,
0.0466353633,
0.0154933091,
0.015258613,
0.0123133957,
0.0402134843,
-0.012949938,
0.0406794325,
-0.0158578344,
0.0060285679,
0.0166690294,
0.035657946,
0.0777322948,
0.042729035,
-0.0370567925,
-0.0110774934,
-0.036719162,
0.0637613088,
-0.0248328894,
0.0183685888,
0.0055433009,
0.0594756231,
-0.0266721062,
-0.0701392442,
-0.015505516,
0.0013695351,
0.024283424,
0.0190876983,
0.0222944282,
0.0104979202,
-0.0727064162,
0.0088984566,
0.0085171973,
-0.0461727716,
-0.0069816727,
-0.0547846667,
0.0254757572,
0.0590961352,
0.022430785,
0.000238015,
-0.0164927952,
-0.0293485839,
0.0305135474,
-0.0007787778,
-0.0255764723,
-0.0095270388,
-0.0312683843,
-0.0665998161,
-0.0249358211,
-0.0225906242,
-0.0395234451,
0.0153397908,
0.0080038374,
-0.0200868137,
0.0129430015,
0.0168930553,
-0.0565374605,
0.0478115343,
-0.0120791821,
0.0155488886,
0.0240142234,
0.0128646102,
0.042259261,
0.0039998693,
-0.0196587555,
0.0306017231,
0.0044493079,
-0.0391964801,
-0.0462327115,
-0.0247792974,
-0.0474535301,
-0.0731983557,
0.0367178097,
-0.0375647023,
-0.022791015,
0.0232966058,
-0.0405673273,
-0.0287665669,
0.0225487445,
-0.0383934155,
0.004965954,
-0.01998288,
0.0200183745,
0.0124241496,
-0.036777582,
-0.0142532112,
0.0845763087,
0.0111979768,
0.0231477059,
0.0278556459,
0.059487123,
0.0057935566,
-0.0009111451,
0.0153142391,
0.0381454155,
-0.0408113785,
0.0049551036,
0.0329565108,
0.0975001082,
-0.0111211594,
-0.0445630886,
-0.1001920849,
0.0328918658,
-0.0260082427,
0.011624489,
0.014875683,
0.0265627839,
0.0087890346,
-0.0232187528,
-0.04981374,
-0.0221260842,
-0.0162536632,
0.0051459959,
0.0222513415,
-0.0308860149,
-0.0638113245,
0.0052580652,
0.0017548095,
-0.0333876424,
0.0310340133,
0.0023052904,
-0.0262633804,
-0.0960652679,
0.0887344778,
-0.0083839111,
-0.0091084838,
-0.0036805777,
-0.0199541245,
0.033288274,
-0.0285780635,
0.0724262074,
0.0518214405,
-0.0095949359,
0.0250886008,
0.0531926155,
-0.0011218613,
-0.0353698917,
0.0423276201,
0.004415995,
-0.0440516584,
-0.0230360478,
-0.0441656373,
0.0129347527,
0.049661018,
0.0319560766,
-0.0026539434,
-0.0701936111,
-0.011752991,
0.0067386534,
0.0021801505,
-0.0039245673,
-0.0268393438,
-0.02294215,
0.0496213771,
-0.0061913035,
-0.0598960333,
0.0710840225,
-0.0163907949,
-0.0350773968,
-0.0777937025,
-0.0266886614,
-0.0505695269,
0.0787959322,
-0.0078849914,
0.0236470439,
0.0045352867,
-0.0625045225,
-0.0386301875,
0.0346316956,
-0.0175503995,
-0.0317929871,
0.0006454425,
-0.0515351407,
0.0017994337,
-0.0085020177,
-0.0330303572,
-0.0567741469,
0.0173707865,
-0.0217463151,
-0.0018425505,
0.0261127744,
-0.008067878,
0.0269177072,
0.0064438996,
0.0327050053,
0.0423011929,
0.0003295763,
-0.0153542403,
-0.0221349504,
-0.0212607589,
0.0119542517,
-0.0124125248,
-0.0072871386,
0.0002155732,
0.0259742457,
0.0044427901,
0.0256127305,
0.0389490947,
-0.0591274425,
0.0527993068,
0.0332525969,
-0.0130831487,
-0.0256504286,
0.0679217577,
0.0584358089,
-0.0580550469,
-0.0112433694,
0.1155428067,
0.0541485138,
-0.0221767146,
0.0130439308,
-0.0330854394,
0.0325810052,
0.0507409424,
0.0281628761,
-0.0809043422,
-0.0471608117,
0.0083090831,
-0.0080129458,
-0.0165258162,
-0.0150096398,
-0.0180842653,
-0.121523194,
0.0436030179,
0.0104626399,
-0.0039568972,
-0.0501158535,
-0.0482175499,
-0.0234546959,
0.0100425277,
-0.0332315825,
0.0260128994,
-0.0137312822,
0.0000062902,
0.0233284254,
-0.0130041977,
-0.0158775505,
0.0290662255,
-0.0391294956,
0.0212420095,
0.1027502343,
0.0201813634,
0.0302960165,
-0.0172942597,
0.0188843887,
-0.0180813652,
0.0404168963,
-0.0405538715,
0.0131432628,
0.0048830225,
-0.0253563803,
-0.0407303832,
0.0477128252,
-0.0870441794,
-0.0164415929,
0.0538880564,
0.1024085507,
-0.0282110274,
-0.0315427892,
-0.0126430122,
0.0041714548,
0.0014551424,
0.0574912652,
0.0338919982,
-0.039849326,
-0.029618524,
-0.0394242443,
-0.0158211589,
-0.0530927889,
-0.0396340191,
0.0108055416,
0.0033299194,
0.0283851177,
-0.0372609086,
-0.0328898951,
0.0651028156,
0.051030241,
0.0183876306,
-0.0264846906,
0.041541893,
-0.0028933932,
-0.0614290945,
-0.016476823,
-0.0253996775,
0.0389176682,
-0.0290791932,
-0.0195647106,
0.024353886,
-0.0033558512,
-0.0095801968,
0.0510879308,
-0.0782514215,
-0.0511020347,
-0.064972572,
0.0513158925,
0.0157628004,
0.0325810947,
-0.0125880493,
-0.0339651033,
-0.0393483229,
-0.006865459,
-0.0235114694,
-0.0181207564,
0.0203619599,
0.0134829776,
0.0250187628,
0.0156779308,
-0.035669595,
-0.0047510299,
-0.0014554957,
0.0676961169,
-0.0192923285,
0.005172492,
0.0649457872,
0.0403907336,
-0.0418417491,
-0.0217111744,
-0.039788682,
-0.0144365868,
0.0214796476,
-0.0004012295,
-0.0409512818,
-0.0587515645,
0.0490197018,
0.0163354464,
-0.0095946202,
0.029563833,
-0.0132962577,
-0.005067592,
0.0131855756,
0.0043658419,
0.0364181846,
0.0028114868,
0.0950535014,
0.0522412844,
-0.0084276004,
-0.0546298772,
0.0294262264,
0.0213063322,
-0.0048796497,
0.0015981708,
0.0841533989,
0.0321516432,
0.0125963846,
-0.0019702285,
0.0258575138,
-0.0267023593,
-0.0828427896,
-0.0210641455,
-0.0137700401,
0.0497990027,
0.0567782894,
0.0324233733,
-0.0295904167,
0.0227443408,
-0.0047434354,
0.0818846077,
-0.0151778925,
-0.0759775341,
0.0281106886,
0.0263143815,
-0.0123402029,
-0.0620666668,
0.072438024,
-0.0171144884,
0.0029794418,
-0.0029875559,
0.0020033186,
-0.051564686,
-0.026021244,
0.0179203302,
-0.005725638,
0.0069761775,
0.0201441161,
-0.0134577584,
-0.0697845221,
-0.0292391311,
-0.0072694449,
0.0241603218,
-0.0062929387,
0.0380667485,
0.0698394179,
-0.0030618247,
-0.0399305522,
-0.0197251048,
0.0091035934,
0.0400430039,
-0.0547644421,
-0.0581136011,
-6.633273479e-33,
-0.0150020113,
-0.0282129124,
0.0356005579,
0.0188717358,
0.0007860925,
-0.0309115164,
-0.0457678288,
-0.0175809115,
0.0186597295,
-0.0231827144,
0.0281923823,
0.0031552899,
0.0008260128,
0.0073655308,
0.0170949772,
-0.0096046152,
0.0479633659,
0.003841819,
-0.0154419271,
0.0330744274,
0.0087601468,
0.0117747327,
0.0278746989,
-0.0414830931,
0.0101143103,
-0.0177516267,
-0.0005757438,
0.0374249369,
0.0113066807,
0.0424375199,
-0.0071594594,
0.007447883,
0.0195176359,
-0.0391092785,
-0.02254075,
0.0248244796,
-0.0449102446,
-0.0366543941,
0.0467713661,
0.0114388214,
-0.0392065048,
-0.0682587624,
0.0117345713,
-0.0336591601,
-0.0121317385,
-0.0229648836,
0.0379324183,
0.0025413546,
0.015993312,
-0.0383501723,
-0.069734998,
0.0158745181,
-0.0386301503,
-0.0218263771,
-0.0140052466,
0.0738521144,
-0.0295748692,
0.006808422,
-0.0167131126,
0.0061336653,
0.0132451039,
0.0246748384,
0.0513694845,
-0.0159253422,
0.005570564,
-0.0000556395,
0.0263642035,
-0.0095475866,
-0.0428421199,
0.0359839723,
-0.0042890613,
0.0507476963,
0.0262179151,
-0.0036734538,
0.0096569192,
0.0367556736,
-0.0773885176,
-0.0124686938,
-0.0175524149,
0.0567149334,
0.0279610958,
0.027881667,
-0.0326432101,
-0.0296111554,
-0.0344090499,
-0.0142602101,
-0.0310804471,
-0.0584757365,
0.0601609126,
-0.0027969531,
-0.0353354514,
0.0230523814,
0.0343204215,
-0.0285599232,
-0.0028160808,
0.0370628908,
-0.009819624,
0.0374334715,
-0.001797596,
0.0409916975,
-0.0270941127,
-0.022339385,
0.0559218489,
-0.0377730019,
0.0539631359,
0.004139984,
0.0155186886,
0.0297209695,
-0.0523258746,
-0.0225793738,
-0.0620146468,
0.0059063281,
-0.0057187648,
0.0266464613,
0.0219805744,
0.018036684,
-0.0101046106,
0.043823801,
-0.0109920846,
-0.0440878198,
-0.0588390417,
0.0095873997,
-0.0085601732,
0.044948142,
-0.027788477,
-0.0246802047,
-0.0656938255,
0.0400801748,
0.0278529674,
-0.0495944917,
-0.0509281941,
0.0537360199,
3.083e-7,
-0.0095721874,
0.0283165891,
0.0203133766,
0.0704896823,
-0.0170456488,
0.0353771634,
-0.015504227,
0.0094451299,
0.0411880687,
-0.0303148422,
-0.0154615389,
0.0275819302,
0.0370407477,
0.0043193223,
-0.0755058378,
0.0228162687,
-0.0046234573,
-0.0188354719,
-0.0574843735,
0.0312657692,
0.0841757953,
0.0843297616,
-0.0130337244,
0.0023013877,
0.0223986562,
-0.0189102478,
-0.0012075023,
-0.0055930689,
0.0073977928,
0.0000876997,
-0.0888866857,
-0.0048094834,
-0.0297973007,
0.0137335993,
0.0214091372,
0.0105256699,
-0.0073313513,
0.0548750311,
-0.0051428308,
0.0446369611,
0.0281206015,
-0.0072641056,
0.0014979653,
-0.064715609,
0.0650293753,
-0.0616062321,
-0.0277108625,
0.0157055613,
0.0073576369,
-0.0000796745,
-0.016661372,
-0.0253839288,
0.0213078093,
0.0189071596,
0.0141426576,
-0.0301524941,
-0.0020890506,
-0.05108805,
-0.0034517229,
0.0070632724,
-0.0104590291,
-0.0313750654,
-0.0518857017,
0.0420844033,
0.0280616023,
-0.0580985658,
0.0263587199,
3.258971992e-34,
0.0179844853,
-0.0643246099,
0.0183872171,
0.0285103656,
0.0597705469,
0.0017689937,
-0.0493556485,
0.0189863555,
0.0214770529,
-0.0746100247,
-0.0477292873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16416v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16416v1 | Multilingual Knowledge Editing with Language-Agnostic Factual Neurons | 2024-06-24T08:06:56 | 2024-06-24T08:06:56 | Xue zhang, Yunlong Liang, Fandong Meng, Songming Zhang, Yufeng Chen, Jinan Xu, Jie Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual knowledge editing (MKE) aims to simultaneously revise factual
knowledge across multilingual languages within large language models (LLMs).
However, most existing MKE methods just adapt existing monolingual editing
methods to multilingual scenarios, overlooking the deep semantic connections of
the same factual knowledge between different languages, thereby limiting edit
performance. To address this issue, we first investigate how LLMs represent
multilingual factual knowledge and discover that the same factual knowledge in
different languages generally activates a shared set of neurons, which we call
language-agnostic factual neurons. These neurons represent the semantic
connections between multilingual knowledge and are mainly located in certain
layers. Inspired by this finding, we propose a new MKE method by locating and
modifying Language-Agnostic Factual Neurons (LAFN) to simultaneously edit
multilingual knowledge. Specifically, we first generate a set of paraphrases
for each multilingual knowledge to be edited to precisely locate the
corresponding language-agnostic factual neurons. Then we optimize the update
values for modifying these located neurons to achieve simultaneous modification
of the same factual knowledge in multiple languages. Experimental results on
Bi-ZsRE and MzsRE benchmarks demonstrate that our method outperforms existing
MKE methods and achieves remarkable edit performance, indicating the importance
of considering the semantic connections among multilingual knowledge. | [
0.0546153486,
0.0145769529,
-0.0047661196,
0.0570329912,
-0.040215984,
-0.0100085456,
0.0274101738,
-0.0425905734,
-0.0533248037,
-0.0369375832,
-0.0645838827,
-0.0226367805,
0.0307579562,
-0.0251131579,
0.0091764927,
-0.0204044376,
0.0746635571,
-0.0109328125,
-0.0162928421,
-0.0159809552,
-0.0049548736,
0.0206156671,
0.0101230079,
0.0118482616,
-0.0269626342,
-0.0302327517,
-0.0026822954,
-0.0021274849,
0.0216775183,
0.0252548195,
-0.008137567,
0.0399390385,
0.0081700133,
0.0974261984,
0.0000020691,
-0.0247739051,
-0.0252876133,
0.0121868709,
-0.0167486239,
0.0559208803,
0.0270668864,
-0.016105907,
-0.0409043282,
-0.0476079211,
0.0061491248,
-0.0263114627,
0.0759355351,
0.0264274664,
0.0720371976,
0.0775616765,
-0.0089086043,
-0.0288857371,
-0.0034316783,
-0.0414403975,
0.0024189185,
-0.0223870333,
0.0415908881,
0.0314874202,
-0.0767446384,
0.0058365669,
-0.0346424133,
0.0614600405,
0.0233526193,
-0.0250065923,
-0.0125560034,
0.0112739978,
-0.0003979721,
-0.0112513844,
0.034113124,
0.0397452191,
-0.0483910777,
-0.0278082527,
-0.0225794949,
0.0207692441,
0.0040762075,
-0.0054981238,
-0.0339549743,
0.0251260344,
0.0072135734,
0.0092702294,
-0.0031427494,
-0.0668590069,
0.0480291173,
0.0373132825,
-0.0182266217,
0.0725363567,
0.0435644463,
-0.0045663752,
-0.0360486545,
0.0134853721,
-0.0000464087,
-0.0786575302,
0.022567058,
-0.007584481,
-0.0288431384,
0.0344793759,
-0.0426626839,
-0.026264729,
0.0161165521,
-0.0842419341,
0.0379429497,
0.0500016101,
-0.0222759545,
0.0738173351,
-0.0470359959,
0.0200769491,
-0.0220076889,
0.0126993498,
-0.0064974958,
-0.0238372851,
-0.0432084687,
-0.0197047796,
-0.0233963933,
0.0234158281,
-0.0381833054,
0.0174350161,
-0.0329985432,
0.0022133272,
-0.022115333,
0.0183493365,
-0.0266194306,
-0.003613994,
-0.0316480808,
-0.0143113593,
-0.0245677456,
0.0732172206,
-0.0250019375,
-0.0000448008,
-0.0204589851,
-0.0164426509,
-0.0176326912,
-0.0030964632,
0.0055452194,
-0.0556741878,
0.0242580548,
0.0118681928,
-0.0511151068,
0.0003101258,
-0.0703712776,
-0.028619213,
0.0206518564,
-0.0540747456,
-0.0007491446,
-0.079800427,
0.0696917772,
-0.0312966965,
-0.0337622985,
-0.0619427748,
0.0145571074,
0.0099634631,
-0.0380357839,
0.0777284428,
0.0018297177,
-0.0065080198,
0.060706526,
0.0058320253,
-0.0179025419,
0.054959435,
0.0240348428,
-0.0159228574,
0.0824743807,
0.0353752412,
-0.0337320007,
0.0533481687,
0.0225251745,
-0.0013902385,
0.0063663279,
-0.0189023409,
0.0294152703,
0.0492237844,
0.0680323169,
0.0114676002,
-0.0404401124,
-0.0292491186,
0.0922979936,
0.0072401003,
0.0085918577,
0.0601038225,
0.0617914647,
-0.0429665223,
0.00473026,
0.0006268119,
-0.028450422,
0.0613564253,
-0.0013324851,
0.0139869377,
-0.009997569,
0.0474947542,
-0.0136348139,
-0.019121699,
0.0221598484,
0.0002367739,
-0.0019630948,
-0.0133530395,
0.02010113,
0.0187061392,
-0.0078180116,
0.0804434791,
0.030348463,
-0.032969214,
0.0260171704,
-0.0088794576,
-0.030251259,
0.0420909487,
0.0202249326,
-0.0311173461,
-0.0822573081,
-0.0092628421,
-0.0031146735,
0.0595385544,
0.0463217162,
-0.0188955963,
0.0412464365,
-0.0382722989,
-0.0166993812,
-0.0838013217,
0.0109444857,
0.0362843573,
0.045861572,
0.0248118639,
0.0084699411,
-0.0271395259,
-0.0098272515,
0.0023465047,
-0.0495256968,
0.0305186342,
0.0023329072,
0.0195404105,
-0.0281562097,
0.0058007552,
-0.0364764892,
-0.0052390345,
-0.0295339078,
-0.0206618812,
-0.0102327289,
0.0257453267,
-0.0255498346,
-0.0553072356,
0.0756736994,
0.0209738407,
-0.0427401178,
-0.0164578594,
-0.0228148066,
-0.0099959588,
0.0179090556,
-0.0251719542,
0.0214366447,
-0.0473757014,
0.0190242771,
0.0043335659,
-0.0104184709,
0.0141991191,
0.0281005669,
0.0055541056,
-0.0142203048,
0.01711688,
-0.0159234852,
0.0328280292,
-0.0255181696,
-0.0301794242,
0.0385673009,
0.0122875562,
-0.0049658334,
-0.0049963593,
0.0017235192,
-0.005095575,
0.0068114847,
-0.0540810712,
-0.0110291066,
-0.0268200617,
-0.0267021041,
0.0396937132,
0.0277344789,
0.0043910728,
-0.0002693321,
-0.021331545,
0.0127231115,
-0.0230990015,
0.0542884581,
0.0414228216,
0.0147261741,
0.0238085873,
-0.0435235389,
0.0051685874,
0.0205428749,
0.0719949752,
0.0150464308,
-0.0425614677,
-0.0425227359,
0.0154458182,
-0.0948080719,
0.0234564021,
0.0173065085,
-0.0433724336,
-0.0356833339,
0.0156604294,
0.0543500893,
0.0537432022,
-0.0403511226,
-0.0136199221,
0.0754993781,
-0.0382137112,
-0.0134236356,
0.029400954,
0.0214817468,
0.0151291704,
-0.0351648591,
-0.0167373735,
0.0017916933,
0.0406827964,
0.0056831697,
-0.059144605,
-0.0211338326,
0.0145305665,
-0.0049143983,
-0.0370594189,
-0.0474291891,
0.0115955686,
0.0055567441,
0.0288817771,
-0.0629883334,
0.0196505617,
0.0790281445,
-0.0182761662,
0.0051018223,
-0.0528334454,
-0.0016359825,
-0.0145720681,
0.0305771455,
-0.0228043105,
0.0775147751,
-0.0534112714,
0.009735602,
-0.0804603249,
-0.0098988712,
0.042357251,
0.004764861,
0.047934413,
-0.0628455728,
0.0127866101,
-0.0063710697,
-0.0375940017,
0.0051350472,
0.0179962888,
0.015284989,
0.0277592372,
0.0028794485,
-0.0357613564,
-0.0395675898,
-0.0398638211,
0.0822146088,
0.0931560174,
0.006782792,
-0.0104158036,
-0.0089135589,
-0.0078166202,
0.0422778837,
0.0306293853,
0.0119381631,
-0.0058123572,
0.0068401056,
0.0540070683,
-0.015768759,
-0.0606245697,
0.0030585737,
-0.0017451027,
-0.0011840652,
-0.0744823962,
-0.0286985096,
-0.0713089556,
0.0427585356,
-0.0435248055,
-0.0097677903,
0.0829692781,
0.0319419987,
-0.0500964485,
0.006486502,
-0.0714046508,
-0.0344899446,
0.045075763,
0.047918275,
-0.0992721617,
-0.0055754418,
0.0008593875,
-0.0434578061,
0.010149871,
-0.0401517376,
-0.0334383994,
-0.1006449312,
-0.0131505718,
0.0017972243,
-0.0455030724,
-0.0434306227,
-0.0014142937,
0.0019023219,
0.0080326973,
0.0108146658,
0.0187188406,
0.0324338004,
-0.0214481428,
-0.0566308238,
0.0211707503,
-0.0357840657,
0.0274029858,
-0.0538092293,
0.021261666,
0.0193166938,
0.0340035707,
-0.0096821859,
0.0158377364,
-0.0003913716,
0.0402836874,
-0.0086978162,
-0.0204727687,
0.0255373754,
0.0164089948,
-0.0147550656,
0.0240587704,
-0.0121323317,
0.0353715383,
-0.02645161,
0.0166461933,
0.0767058581,
0.0154202199,
0.0256288201,
0.0393255576,
0.0066376361,
-0.0223687962,
0.0560395382,
0.0257220268,
-0.0177199598,
0.0126719354,
-0.0418279245,
-0.0275451671,
-0.0545585752,
-0.0034451876,
-0.0034111284,
-0.0589072593,
-0.0321093723,
-0.0691103041,
-0.0324911624,
0.0264383033,
-0.0190867875,
0.0396341458,
0.011634062,
0.0523326471,
-0.0373410322,
-0.0176700484,
-0.0081518367,
-0.0413227566,
0.0207326077,
5.781e-7,
-0.0099977348,
0.0346682407,
-0.0593392365,
-0.0092634596,
-0.0328614525,
-0.0281783883,
-0.0590307489,
0.006759427,
0.0508884303,
0.0076995427,
0.0497340634,
-0.003120126,
-0.0413564853,
0.0473922342,
-0.0052494612,
-0.0203887243,
0.055814594,
0.0237971954,
0.0145833949,
-0.0191221312,
0.0578186065,
-0.0238115098,
-0.0129148485,
0.0368659161,
0.0493038557,
-0.0262809452,
-0.0258745626,
0.0046367561,
0.0095890351,
0.0026627991,
0.0265212543,
0.0293814018,
-0.069520779,
0.0355062596,
-0.0226383489,
-0.0194032937,
-0.0158232041,
0.011162715,
0.0343190469,
0.003530479,
-0.0097713741,
0.0068152086,
0.0401485339,
-0.0145666432,
0.031877581,
-0.0554190427,
-0.0107786702,
-0.017819941,
0.0280126892,
0.026091326,
-0.0217688624,
0.0411787182,
-0.0278957319,
0.0059505091,
-0.0556539409,
0.0311933346,
0.0203687456,
-0.0457914993,
-0.0520813875,
0.0245268382,
-0.0358539931,
-0.0223837793,
0.0032054598,
0.0446322486,
0.1098212376,
0.0083315857,
0.0618088916,
-0.0505861007,
-0.0633140206,
-0.0020307442,
0.0264299978,
0.0289767478,
-0.0196829662,
0.0144164199,
-0.0028642179,
0.0198511239,
0.0114356354,
0.067642957,
-0.0248854551,
0.0989549309,
-0.0353965461,
-0.0407354087,
-0.0112475557,
-0.0573434681,
-0.0259845685,
-0.0181066468,
-0.0560486987,
-0.0026666012,
-0.0384219773,
-0.0611814298,
0.0217331219,
0.0128687676,
-0.03506089,
0.0060172412,
0.0079789152,
0.0703207999,
0.0277026389,
-0.0023396628,
-0.0165208951,
0.0342027843,
0.0216925126,
-0.0185318869,
-0.0026866917,
-6.062155141e-33,
-0.0325137377,
0.0126083856,
0.043756064,
0.0116239255,
-0.0367804617,
0.0025117663,
-0.0348233208,
0.0073435702,
-0.0278276969,
0.0417860113,
-0.0105219036,
0.0226686131,
-0.0000472224,
0.0203277059,
0.011087412,
0.0061688065,
0.0673133731,
0.0032719616,
-0.0013287172,
-0.007537114,
0.0467873551,
0.0263927616,
0.1170115098,
-0.004276257,
0.0390991196,
0.054476615,
0.0194519125,
0.0642087683,
-0.0533842742,
0.0424553156,
-0.0065632458,
0.0448966138,
0.0076469206,
-0.0379713103,
-0.0187057555,
-0.0802697465,
-0.0465122238,
-0.0387561284,
0.0474038199,
0.0572716258,
-0.0107625108,
-0.0748795196,
0.0421600752,
-0.0257033128,
0.0124682402,
-0.0399252437,
0.0040610004,
-0.0502270758,
0.0011540789,
-0.0002324105,
-0.0711314157,
0.0000060076,
0.0252726395,
-0.0036023674,
0.0033180141,
-0.0314732417,
0.0243492611,
-0.0362590812,
-0.1379036903,
-0.0038542331,
-0.0246009659,
0.0566370785,
0.0498523824,
-0.024123732,
0.0226924289,
0.0328287184,
0.0111583043,
0.0251984708,
-0.021788748,
0.0344720446,
0.0087224459,
-0.007996751,
0.0338257365,
0.101255253,
-0.0027167683,
-0.0001349681,
-0.0658019036,
-0.0267578345,
0.0013468189,
0.0221620351,
-0.0118791722,
0.0175343677,
0.0642280579,
-0.0153483786,
-0.045561187,
0.0220544674,
-0.0330625549,
-0.0235239584,
-0.0055824956,
-0.0141702797,
0.0035186384,
0.0216411259,
0.0236671381,
-0.0022079439,
0.0023990353,
0.0302715059,
-0.0041707098,
0.0459732749,
0.0151669458,
-0.0010437475,
-0.041858241,
0.0410848148,
-0.0283244736,
-0.0214981511,
-0.0047552814,
0.0312968642,
0.0648069531,
0.0306531452,
-0.0313573107,
0.0251298882,
-0.0247248784,
0.0035807868,
0.0035113608,
0.0042528356,
-0.0241072439,
-0.0092275646,
-0.0214585122,
-0.0102332234,
0.0807492509,
0.0216239635,
0.0058071874,
0.0040279222,
0.0151398359,
0.0505005643,
-0.0309316963,
0.0241940767,
-0.0586428382,
-0.004014398,
0.0027682334,
-0.0585838221,
-0.0171327572,
-0.0124968663,
2.846e-7,
0.0447001494,
0.0290843286,
-0.0033152951,
0.0229435321,
0.0329662673,
0.0356668644,
-0.0339735411,
0.0105929971,
-0.0216593239,
-0.0081575196,
-0.0050021717,
0.0487241,
-0.0125396363,
0.0330602527,
-0.0632971674,
0.001783623,
-0.038048625,
0.0077157654,
-0.043085862,
-0.0526006557,
-0.019374907,
0.0386350453,
0.030141985,
-0.0222823676,
-0.0023345901,
-0.051672142,
0.0888630748,
-0.0137659237,
-0.0287724026,
0.0164335743,
0.0321594253,
0.0051140911,
-0.002928474,
0.0103431949,
-0.0259264912,
-0.0111655854,
0.0231559835,
0.0511280671,
-0.0116018951,
0.0454311967,
-0.0067151911,
-0.0185154174,
-0.0385332927,
-0.0554252192,
0.0427956171,
-0.0318676867,
0.0183824711,
0.006402778,
0.0170851108,
0.0378273092,
0.0501140691,
-0.0647855848,
-0.0360791571,
-0.0025060333,
0.0163069069,
0.0477330908,
-0.0310357474,
-0.0082603199,
-0.0562037118,
-0.0005731167,
-0.0087726424,
-0.0439460129,
-0.0310119186,
-0.0664051771,
0.0264663994,
-0.0600917563,
0.010969949,
2.370057883e-34,
-0.0048008333,
0.0115059949,
0.0163627379,
-0.000280535,
0.0438883565,
-0.0316476598,
-0.0423078611,
-0.0057286592,
-0.0436874703,
-0.0099691609,
-0.0495208949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16408v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16408v1 | A Symmetry Property of Christoffel Words | 2024-06-24T08:05:21 | 2024-06-24T08:05:21 | Yan Lanciault, Christophe Reutenauer | math.CO | math.CO, cs.CL | Motivated by the theory of trapezoidal words, whose sequences of cardinality
of factors by length are symmetric, we introduce a bivariate variant of this
symmetry. We show that this symmetry characterizes Christoffel words, and
establish other related results. | [
-0.0120915938,
0.0339138694,
-0.0412545986,
0.0604214817,
-0.0436470322,
0.0339880735,
0.0064485366,
0.0412152745,
-0.0822304711,
-0.010174457,
0.0017916777,
-0.036708314,
-0.0105175888,
-0.0267074239,
0.0226672869,
-0.0805485845,
0.0093367612,
0.0300850347,
-0.0664591864,
-0.0106071848,
-0.0111231878,
0.0042230887,
-0.0328448154,
-0.0128579251,
-0.0145299723,
-0.0400617346,
0.0142107951,
-0.0795732886,
-0.0150220748,
-0.0096156206,
-0.021024758,
0.076981172,
-0.0457548276,
0.0067888815,
9.815e-7,
-0.0606503114,
-0.0216119569,
0.0042049862,
-0.0440597273,
-0.001058472,
0.0165359527,
-0.0061998009,
0.0117941201,
-0.0051664547,
-0.0100050298,
0.008136834,
0.0110397032,
0.0086226147,
-0.0375833362,
-0.0504986793,
0.014049449,
-0.0697312653,
-0.0067875558,
-0.0253782701,
0.0370790735,
0.0091799423,
0.0001596039,
-0.0447552316,
0.0087604858,
0.02508118,
-0.0000904268,
0.0042855493,
-0.0195471197,
0.0221683327,
0.0409701802,
-0.0173262265,
0.0258719474,
-0.0083043929,
0.0126705701,
-0.0005231471,
-0.0564733706,
-0.0021385944,
-0.0010187564,
-0.0019650643,
0.0626168698,
0.0152537832,
-0.0341301486,
0.0182553139,
0.0132849822,
-0.0179717112,
0.0067891311,
0.0483545586,
-0.025174547,
-0.0584790185,
-0.0249848869,
0.0478269719,
0.0637361705,
-0.0286997948,
-0.0293032601,
-0.0287216101,
-0.0488918461,
-0.0363938287,
-0.0458314344,
0.0471578762,
0.0243734326,
0.0194490086,
-0.0463811904,
-0.0440974571,
0.0001681679,
-0.0794002414,
0.0332466923,
-0.0641429946,
0.0066866027,
-0.0500603057,
0.0086046653,
0.0355759971,
0.0489083603,
0.0284975059,
-0.0006486841,
0.0179915205,
-0.0169133171,
0.0006961296,
-0.0439484417,
-0.0152351409,
0.0173537657,
0.0072435411,
-0.0239715856,
0.0762803927,
0.0402535275,
0.0001975055,
0.0056878142,
0.0078574503,
0.0137656666,
0.0107809464,
0.0118412143,
-0.0083567742,
-0.0569312684,
-0.0019658962,
-0.0150239589,
-0.0334623083,
0.0490940437,
0.0237828419,
0.0352530293,
-0.0211575031,
-0.0120966816,
0.0002446871,
0.0389284007,
-0.0398901217,
0.0810349956,
0.0321908034,
-0.0364327654,
-0.0087542553,
-0.0114313215,
-0.0520912819,
-0.0100788232,
0.056439016,
-0.0034882233,
-0.0286752563,
0.0131522017,
-0.0163132697,
-0.0215442423,
0.0249681249,
0.0227576345,
0.0022246931,
-0.0030751803,
0.0147004677,
0.0197663475,
0.0146616418,
0.0254089814,
-0.000800819,
0.0545070246,
-0.038791351,
-0.0005120424,
0.0128744431,
-0.010346489,
-0.0189461038,
-0.029605832,
-0.0328867212,
0.0742811188,
-0.0028558583,
0.0146310823,
0.0021378861,
0.0208314452,
-0.0763504058,
-0.0201889556,
0.0670855045,
0.0050522308,
0.0707969218,
-0.0255821366,
-0.0500701517,
-0.0201017596,
0.0455011055,
0.0713836104,
-0.0254841559,
0.1086149141,
-0.0074730115,
0.0584121272,
0.0194626525,
-0.0207704846,
0.0070560914,
-0.0208177529,
-0.0168002024,
-0.0063348897,
-0.0627822876,
0.0284818429,
-0.0263643079,
-0.0196764655,
0.0165285431,
-0.0092708636,
-0.0262400769,
-0.0140943844,
-0.0059861694,
-0.0092144003,
0.0125194537,
-0.0349214226,
-0.0063416609,
0.002965437,
0.0367883779,
-0.0631537214,
0.0294702314,
-0.0416141674,
0.0205746293,
-0.0280918162,
0.0013539657,
0.006688721,
0.0016375392,
0.0375543088,
-0.0122560728,
-0.0379777513,
0.0227274708,
0.025567431,
0.0537994727,
-0.0474878512,
0.0011642143,
0.0727321506,
-0.0040060519,
-0.0350757465,
-0.00433402,
-0.0123871844,
-0.0155351534,
0.0236662626,
0.0774522051,
0.0442618094,
-0.0746655986,
-0.03824725,
-0.039983388,
0.0220042504,
-0.0283645224,
0.0085837003,
-0.0419180244,
0.0829634145,
-0.0196885765,
0.0433137231,
0.0273960233,
0.045190949,
-0.018218942,
0.0246523134,
0.0200567972,
0.0392227098,
0.0048015378,
0.0510202833,
0.0133687509,
0.0019911812,
-0.0360163078,
0.0920684338,
-0.0679007918,
-0.0230389293,
-0.0078428155,
0.0552614518,
0.0288841706,
-0.0134151122,
0.007896632,
0.0222928524,
0.0064097466,
-0.0430968814,
0.0183534417,
-0.0766089708,
0.0001026148,
-0.0217515659,
-0.0252730437,
0.0059288498,
-0.0137257632,
0.0092336312,
0.0240537729,
0.0151289962,
-0.0324172974,
0.0091572953,
0.0541450903,
0.0102448771,
0.0554462448,
-0.0337286256,
-0.0450296998,
0.0373929217,
0.0187891666,
0.0491959415,
-0.0104957437,
-0.0274687652,
0.0465714037,
-0.0279345438,
0.0129803978,
-0.0756148398,
0.0214178972,
-0.0074787466,
-0.0266741104,
0.0455828942,
0.0230710935,
0.0187354386,
0.0031126679,
0.0386992171,
-0.0250654295,
-0.074111864,
-0.0073990249,
0.0608962215,
-0.0448914804,
-0.0514557473,
-0.0142532177,
-0.0109569803,
0.0037867276,
0.0688397512,
0.030497063,
0.0071611465,
-0.0366192833,
-0.0045450637,
-0.0324525125,
-0.0289955568,
0.0748076811,
0.019891154,
-0.0282949861,
-0.0318409801,
0.0043590092,
0.0053762249,
-0.0333161987,
-0.0825634748,
-0.0304422006,
-0.0148987891,
-0.0285476632,
-0.0085185012,
-0.0336763486,
0.0499198176,
0.0613884404,
0.0144106001,
-0.0134736206,
0.0188234467,
-0.0339676738,
-0.0218671691,
-0.0080923848,
-0.0524518155,
-0.0179034676,
-0.0219469313,
-0.0204274412,
0.0283374544,
-0.0164255667,
-0.0062909499,
-0.0720550343,
0.0459505729,
-0.0290187243,
0.0867644101,
-0.0714111254,
0.0012294698,
0.0626975521,
0.0005756319,
0.0030047183,
0.0266594533,
0.0248572435,
0.0227144081,
-0.0056593097,
0.0302880798,
0.0140656633,
-0.0134017132,
-0.0004414998,
-0.0168836508,
-0.0008370863,
0.0019788586,
0.068879731,
0.061739549,
0.0204934906,
0.0012097019,
-0.004156481,
0.0007033752,
0.0314079672,
-0.0351682343,
0.0573893003,
-0.0064373454,
0.0640037209,
0.0158842057,
0.0000729609,
0.0681622773,
-0.0081880456,
0.0031564024,
-0.0025539384,
-0.0529816635,
0.0051921527,
0.0549650081,
-0.0245200172,
-0.0629453436,
-0.0480300337,
0.0161619317,
-0.0178283248,
-0.059299618,
-0.0697042719,
-0.0082434434,
-0.033756271,
-0.0312256385,
0.0340968966,
-0.018981507,
0.0316464342,
-0.0311372317,
0.0446789376,
-0.0165840834,
0.0007099095,
0.0888449103,
0.0639314726,
0.0171904266,
0.0103477025,
-0.0260138586,
-0.0362305865,
-0.0430020168,
0.0087976046,
0.0035052458,
-0.1091122553,
-0.0491398126,
-0.0197832379,
-0.0254088826,
0.0384066477,
-0.0285890661,
0.0001674377,
-0.0303939376,
0.0059779044,
0.0011593101,
-0.0300716329,
-0.0235399157,
0.0035046313,
0.0112676406,
0.0515073538,
-0.0064731035,
0.041801244,
0.0435907766,
-0.0191039667,
0.0399445482,
0.0358078666,
0.0076408884,
0.0627317205,
0.0343753099,
0.0347247384,
-0.0053529539,
-0.0128582697,
0.0076048211,
0.0084795933,
-0.0336099379,
-0.0733567029,
0.0129177328,
-0.0462906398,
0.1067765206,
-0.0425541326,
0.0093861651,
0.0064227907,
-0.0323898233,
0.0029426434,
-0.014336884,
0.0170737077,
-0.0142899333,
-0.0460592955,
0.0124988668,
-0.0265199915,
0.0366201438,
-0.0408839285,
-0.0240129903,
-0.0673476532,
-0.0048518162,
0.0214259829,
0.011222952,
0.0316618383,
-0.0318901911,
0.0087236501,
0.0220342837,
-0.0860793889,
0.0616460294,
-0.0140664103,
0.0033133579,
0.0420637056,
-0.0200897641,
0.0277671851,
0.0362207703,
0.0391264744,
-0.0061991471,
-0.0323177949,
-0.0363560803,
-0.052809637,
-0.0382000394,
-0.0101608802,
-0.0392717607,
-0.0431210175,
0.0161597375,
0.0401925407,
0.0273493715,
0.0134684257,
-0.019654898,
-0.0189442057,
0.0180779621,
0.0251022149,
-0.0396080017,
-0.0342210196,
-0.0394719355,
-0.0729348287,
-0.0192925278,
-0.0060369354,
0.063271299,
0.0180801749,
-0.0366382375,
0.015626302,
-0.0199023429,
0.0406689122,
0.0118051311,
0.0267319437,
-0.0232253131,
0.0183246061,
0.019560514,
0.010638969,
0.0016309832,
0.0257419012,
-0.0235080384,
0.0163850747,
-0.0068818699,
-0.0343558602,
-0.0279039145,
-0.0011056312,
-0.0450434536,
-0.0045528072,
-0.0359769315,
-0.0318234563,
0.0051230644,
0.0189666618,
-0.0463387109,
-0.0433922261,
0.0495100915,
-0.0368542895,
-0.0075120898,
-0.0164282676,
-0.0451250076,
0.0624917224,
-0.0183892921,
0.0233065207,
0.0086757354,
-0.0356908776,
-0.0355865844,
0.0179623067,
0.0213839561,
-0.0014402011,
0.0657663941,
0.0314324871,
-0.0800520033,
-0.02580088,
0.0433629453,
-0.0114324447,
0.0727267191,
0.040053308,
0.0090943901,
0.0430526063,
-0.0596431494,
0.0320656523,
0.0066996026,
0.0441837199,
0.032713078,
-0.0296915248,
0.0177330654,
-4.291313309e-33,
-0.019551266,
0.0164969247,
-0.0229091886,
0.0028922753,
-0.0067096082,
-0.0031991098,
0.0534389205,
0.0269042905,
-0.0030021681,
-0.0476672053,
0.0237920973,
0.0002627618,
0.0136789372,
0.0226962958,
0.0251051355,
-0.0034217357,
-0.0380761586,
-0.0251269136,
-0.0396158062,
0.0133640161,
0.0102705834,
-0.0174785368,
0.0477133133,
0.0985266194,
0.0514930077,
-0.0338962786,
0.052811943,
0.045330584,
-0.0045164907,
0.007809896,
-0.0313909687,
-0.0333516747,
0.0373511016,
-0.0568046644,
0.0040376997,
0.0221364181,
0.0344015621,
-0.0909538493,
0.0408417135,
0.0240773633,
0.0319010429,
0.0007634875,
0.0117096817,
-0.0235976763,
-0.0390027948,
0.0427579582,
-0.0186229646,
0.0465070009,
-0.1083128825,
0.0046919663,
0.0288455784,
0.0337792002,
-0.0008101252,
-0.0459473059,
-0.0539118387,
-0.1051697135,
0.0257860534,
0.0010716027,
0.0603708476,
0.0192300677,
0.0261234827,
0.0700748563,
-0.072808288,
-0.0091580702,
-0.009434063,
-0.0079682721,
0.035821408,
0.0250095744,
0.0151878083,
0.0438781492,
0.0391024314,
0.0691855624,
0.047342252,
0.0153917884,
0.0781920403,
0.0381791443,
0.0251951516,
-0.0153295156,
-0.0582605451,
-0.0266302116,
0.019695852,
0.0036171372,
-0.0377034284,
-0.0344319753,
-0.0240380783,
-0.0768125728,
-0.0119593302,
0.0733233988,
-0.016635159,
0.0205148477,
0.0114391204,
-0.0327889957,
0.0025195866,
-0.0181159247,
-0.1075675935,
-0.0081007862,
0.0638978779,
0.0188704636,
-0.0025807659,
0.0047629694,
0.0403026715,
0.0259227213,
-0.0397274904,
0.0678312257,
0.0039608036,
0.0063816449,
-0.0676101074,
-0.0196515881,
-0.0403024517,
-0.0200687535,
-0.0171021633,
-0.0493128896,
0.0444243215,
-0.0249376521,
-0.0027018841,
0.0087356279,
-0.0161188319,
0.0234791134,
0.0289384611,
-0.0423426405,
0.0726507381,
0.001813931,
-0.0090886625,
0.0054113548,
0.0057186089,
-0.0301455967,
0.0101999603,
0.0086352602,
0.0724564716,
-0.0336927213,
0.0139286676,
0.0220185351,
1.974e-7,
0.066287525,
-0.0233008228,
0.0313096121,
-0.0166094489,
0.0606117807,
-0.0118105756,
-0.0264390595,
0.0143779395,
-0.0418545008,
-0.0010183196,
-0.0063948384,
0.0086886222,
0.0214024745,
-0.0141991917,
0.0390061401,
0.048399888,
-0.0528070107,
-0.0268579032,
-0.0382394977,
0.0311955772,
0.0581641421,
0.0397817716,
0.0338460281,
0.0166800618,
-0.0417850427,
-0.0101724938,
-0.0346477218,
0.0294065122,
0.0115313288,
-0.0352216214,
0.0064154575,
-0.0506146364,
0.0184409637,
0.0173251666,
0.013590985,
0.03667932,
0.034083005,
-0.0741407424,
0.0366937742,
0.0689335018,
0.004767179,
-0.0973672941,
-0.0277542546,
-0.0337583832,
0.0016362334,
-0.0073215198,
0.0024377671,
-0.0161579382,
-0.0104068639,
0.0805933028,
0.0360431559,
0.0071487334,
-0.0516773723,
0.0402987525,
0.0222137515,
-0.0118235163,
0.0409833454,
-0.0191225968,
0.000135039,
0.0321221687,
-0.0241495315,
0.0178135056,
-0.0241688918,
0.0123612341,
0.0602555312,
0.0322508477,
-0.0147859557,
1.632631362e-34,
-0.0034640278,
-0.0131766312,
-0.0200286657,
0.0120067578,
0.0034698092,
-0.0219086986,
0.0193350706,
-0.0119186044,
0.0160774849,
-0.0492567122,
-0.0122027919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16382v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16382v1 | UNO Arena for Evaluating Sequential Decision-Making Capability of Large Language Models | 2024-06-24T07:47:34 | 2024-06-24T07:47:34 | Zhanyue Qin, Haochuan Wang, Deyuan Liu, Ziyang Song, Cunhang Fan, Zhao Lv, Jinlin Wu, Zhen Lei, Zhiying Tu, Dianhui Chu, Xiaoyan Yu, Dianbo Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sequential decision-making refers to algorithms that take into account the
dynamics of the environment, where early decisions affect subsequent decisions.
With large language models (LLMs) demonstrating powerful capabilities between
tasks, we can't help but ask: Can Current LLMs Effectively Make Sequential
Decisions? In order to answer this question, we propose the UNO Arena based on
the card game UNO to evaluate the sequential decision-making capability of LLMs
and explain in detail why we choose UNO. In UNO Arena, We evaluate the
sequential decision-making capability of LLMs dynamically with novel metrics
based Monte Carlo methods. We set up random players, DQN-based reinforcement
learning players, and LLM players (e.g. GPT-4, Gemini-pro) for comparison
testing. Furthermore, in order to improve the sequential decision-making
capability of LLMs, we propose the TUTRI player, which can involves having LLMs
reflect their own actions wtih the summary of game history and the game
strategy. Numerous experiments demonstrate that the TUTRI player achieves a
notable breakthrough in the performance of sequential decision-making compared
to the vanilla LLM player. | [
0.0060673477,
0.0780572444,
-0.0314402618,
-0.0150955878,
-0.0414395407,
0.001895292,
-0.0233452134,
0.0024433634,
-0.0140573895,
-0.0082457773,
-0.0416360609,
-0.0366270542,
-0.0010755669,
0.0447643064,
-0.0220281165,
-0.0446789078,
0.0267260652,
-0.0673751384,
0.0248139426,
-0.0106161823,
-0.0662480518,
-0.055046998,
-0.0248515066,
0.0721306503,
0.0521024205,
-0.0185768008,
-0.0328450315,
-0.0328178406,
0.017261602,
-0.0451365262,
-0.027729338,
0.0431509092,
0.0244895369,
0.0425844304,
0.0000019772,
-0.0392939299,
-0.011309823,
-0.0189598426,
0.0072013806,
-0.004590007,
0.0203828178,
0.0350463465,
-0.0177292563,
0.0317950547,
-0.0596672334,
-0.0156693198,
0.04349906,
0.0068618092,
0.0275696162,
0.0428894125,
0.0163449738,
-0.0068557844,
0.01666696,
-0.0597604029,
-0.024123149,
-0.0722609982,
0.024412198,
-0.00944243,
0.0098339207,
-0.0362058096,
-0.0328387097,
0.0027281633,
0.0270479769,
0.0164283011,
-0.0664452836,
0.0558478497,
0.0205461793,
0.0614265501,
-0.0247201398,
0.0162085369,
-0.0491121076,
0.0110040382,
0.0114323087,
-0.0037899537,
0.0173877571,
-0.0129953418,
-0.0156457406,
0.0343022011,
0.026861487,
0.0252462607,
0.0128779951,
0.0454792343,
0.0456165299,
0.0163802635,
-0.0563928522,
0.0997588336,
0.00141684,
-0.0492161587,
0.0055339611,
0.0000349979,
-0.0054699467,
-0.0760126859,
-0.0556568615,
0.0300346315,
-0.0852466747,
0.0137906438,
-0.0072014364,
0.018439794,
-0.0139364088,
-0.0164781101,
0.0591440946,
0.0323863998,
0.0348845571,
0.0439178608,
0.0215212274,
0.0748300329,
-0.0148401279,
0.0077516702,
-0.0294424668,
0.0298959352,
-0.0375280753,
-0.0065807388,
-0.0219783112,
0.032380607,
-0.0452797562,
-0.03733043,
-0.0736198649,
0.0127377911,
-0.0186888203,
0.038267646,
0.0078758802,
-0.0088856937,
0.0042480086,
0.0171303675,
-0.0761866346,
-0.0036418922,
-0.0223818198,
0.0171559453,
0.0138501255,
-0.0160371587,
0.016843928,
-0.0104240859,
-0.0634786263,
-0.0392219014,
0.0009760727,
0.1202032715,
-0.0119493613,
-0.0301568974,
-0.0086198514,
0.0372773111,
-0.0015983511,
-0.0942307189,
0.0024714328,
-0.0580994897,
-0.0045480537,
-0.010667841,
0.0073847733,
0.0036888157,
0.0036259599,
0.0007740894,
-0.0017633963,
0.0489130653,
0.0329767391,
0.0220621061,
-0.0150111569,
-0.0099400114,
0.0148081388,
0.0673098266,
0.0541242771,
0.038309183,
0.0167035665,
-0.0012909792,
0.0005578069,
0.0563111492,
-0.0267227441,
0.0074479706,
-0.0625053942,
-0.0085741896,
0.0011436249,
0.0666626096,
-0.0026409647,
0.0398301519,
-0.0582805388,
0.0169894602,
0.0735209063,
0.0034372651,
0.0384661146,
0.0095056929,
0.0550956428,
0.0005650843,
0.0007336694,
0.019264387,
-0.0506937988,
0.0474210009,
0.0064811138,
0.0386894345,
0.029835863,
0.0194640141,
-0.0003341904,
-0.0706415102,
0.0153857609,
-0.0281693265,
0.0079507092,
0.0159339681,
0.0542436019,
-0.0267571025,
-0.0568897687,
0.0043329024,
0.0179054961,
0.0193036795,
-0.0451816581,
-0.1010551304,
0.0544481985,
0.0606941618,
0.0630587861,
-0.0675661042,
-0.0097205341,
-0.0272920989,
-0.0759766474,
0.0311544966,
0.0399174243,
0.0011116897,
0.0196145512,
-0.0230908729,
-0.0368856862,
0.0141067235,
0.0169508047,
0.0856951848,
0.0043457015,
0.0381922424,
-0.0312076472,
0.0212250482,
-0.0075295917,
0.0233559292,
0.0026256361,
-0.0550072119,
0.033463195,
-0.0144364946,
0.0684743822,
-0.0196519643,
-0.0324719884,
0.0160256308,
0.0125888633,
0.0017253782,
0.0044004302,
-0.0070830602,
-0.0400768146,
-0.0094488347,
0.0333468728,
0.0236377958,
0.0046277395,
0.0276203863,
-0.0310460646,
-0.0358065479,
0.0270069242,
0.0108115664,
0.0178283751,
-0.0273827165,
-0.0064702546,
-0.0238633547,
0.0007179964,
-0.0218295008,
0.0892106071,
-0.0445578396,
0.041133292,
0.0510991886,
-0.0156776439,
0.0070989965,
-0.0679779649,
0.0057755825,
0.0249362309,
0.0026969737,
-0.006416983,
0.0369347669,
0.0335881226,
-0.0160740241,
-0.0645352304,
-0.0448955335,
0.0074596223,
-0.0323277824,
0.0174722597,
-0.0138169015,
-0.0349649712,
-0.0202151332,
-0.019582605,
0.0012049156,
-0.0197203476,
0.0176730007,
-0.0030222745,
0.0271397103,
0.0436190329,
-0.0186441019,
-0.0538155474,
-0.0361606628,
0.0038223607,
0.0563873649,
-0.0417157859,
0.0137449205,
-0.0310428012,
-0.0377455764,
0.0035251705,
0.0401799753,
-0.0367650054,
-0.0176645219,
0.0467924625,
-0.0510925204,
0.0517687425,
0.0793184713,
0.0223158523,
0.0515204668,
0.0787960067,
-0.0263378378,
-0.0115976315,
0.0431780703,
-0.0257751402,
-0.0373942666,
-0.0777613893,
-0.0215264149,
0.0320405215,
0.1034030318,
-0.0440541506,
-0.0049040043,
-0.0523146093,
0.0063032764,
-0.0030798553,
-0.0440741442,
-0.0431418754,
-0.0061788736,
-0.0389076322,
0.0196131468,
0.0025817922,
-0.0306730382,
0.0546503551,
0.0055731707,
0.028423639,
-0.0326370299,
-0.0058998303,
-0.0273514818,
0.0747938976,
0.0456365459,
-0.0032448662,
-0.0624832287,
-0.0262715723,
-0.059408918,
-0.0637445748,
0.0231380388,
-0.0263883527,
0.014519765,
-0.0642172843,
-0.0010361529,
0.003578994,
-0.0257312823,
-0.0161623154,
0.0146724861,
-0.0352255628,
0.0265892595,
0.0179399904,
-0.0170903075,
-0.0708594173,
0.0168799106,
0.0397994407,
0.0344911367,
-0.0218041819,
-0.0113554951,
-0.0057673049,
0.0105017098,
0.0653904155,
0.0285860319,
0.0341277122,
-0.064216584,
0.0725790784,
0.0177031029,
0.0335038267,
-0.0262784548,
-0.0282750875,
0.005770741,
0.0187175814,
-0.0608714186,
-0.0355968773,
0.0944878161,
-0.0296684224,
-0.0566304401,
-0.0118313804,
0.0862910524,
0.0292924978,
0.0012751768,
-0.0027125259,
-0.0080887731,
0.0319254026,
-0.0017995839,
0.0286934264,
-0.0652922615,
-0.0173835121,
-0.0106134592,
0.026945062,
-0.0141635332,
-0.0426925197,
0.0261951406,
-0.1012880877,
0.0059627634,
-0.0057457844,
-0.0820545778,
-0.0218819417,
0.0294122752,
-0.0176127777,
-0.0254300423,
0.0171694458,
0.0319182985,
0.0053075734,
-0.0053112586,
0.003473754,
-0.024804851,
-0.0002193172,
0.0291645285,
-0.0218846966,
0.0186118688,
0.0655720979,
0.0455757156,
-0.0178357996,
-0.0226194374,
-0.0113518033,
0.0117820054,
0.005732147,
0.0219646096,
0.0153643107,
-0.0083654849,
0.0053368746,
0.0061219595,
-0.0001069799,
0.0353645943,
-0.0236091204,
-0.0029677413,
0.040061079,
-0.0252794772,
-0.0558290146,
0.0094362544,
-0.0250900947,
0.0293321032,
0.0250137113,
-0.0226332378,
-0.0602992512,
-0.0808940828,
-0.0171949547,
-0.012569868,
-0.0696760416,
-0.026478203,
-0.0139059974,
0.0333665088,
-0.0094575863,
-0.0618974715,
-0.0285284836,
-0.020782182,
0.0062700156,
-0.0049347878,
0.0470181741,
-0.0079958607,
0.015336046,
-0.004043512,
-0.0205223337,
-0.0234658476,
0.0322049707,
-0.0825216472,
-0.0113848792,
0.0247010756,
-0.038698785,
-0.0358399786,
0.0327550769,
-0.0241467077,
-0.0140195778,
0.029927766,
0.0742849559,
0.0264001209,
-0.0195176546,
0.0206029974,
-0.0273012388,
0.0309368018,
0.0039817952,
0.0169112086,
0.0040214569,
0.0411506332,
0.0080579864,
0.009384905,
0.0353894643,
-0.0408893935,
0.0012928692,
-0.0125171859,
0.053999912,
-0.0265933275,
-0.0375552922,
-0.0012982859,
-0.0621665008,
0.0644356161,
-0.0241758339,
-0.0018260841,
-0.0137965567,
0.0354311615,
-0.0113063361,
0.0044754604,
-0.0174787417,
-0.0004672319,
0.0689622536,
0.0554941632,
0.0214957893,
-0.0202672929,
0.020001946,
-0.0434547439,
0.0056929193,
0.0113033038,
0.0659961328,
0.0351902694,
0.0340359285,
-0.0121556772,
0.0158601329,
-0.0120980944,
0.019104233,
0.0334443115,
0.0175820142,
0.0511695407,
0.0379777998,
-0.0180690903,
0.002639987,
0.0188745409,
-0.0784956068,
-0.0371816531,
0.0330885872,
0.0437973104,
0.0829479992,
0.002266428,
0.0005139773,
-0.0614031963,
0.0121740513,
-0.0144371493,
-0.0246181376,
-0.0018266055,
-0.0374449119,
0.0051868623,
0.0332685709,
-0.0293036867,
0.0265228804,
0.0716015622,
0.0524115637,
0.0212868694,
-0.0099327192,
0.0084905094,
-0.0263380222,
-0.0458810925,
-0.0007251845,
0.0368497893,
-0.0644357949,
-0.0014615895,
-0.0687505752,
-0.0123260533,
-0.0066501154,
0.0947087035,
0.0119579015,
-0.0395599529,
0.0281865746,
0.0081846593,
-0.0090134284,
0.0035922197,
-0.0634161234,
0.0147416648,
0.0036532818,
0.0062688682,
-0.0283221155,
-5.759063841e-33,
-0.027206758,
-0.0110352626,
0.0632342622,
-0.0366813876,
-0.0150741348,
-0.0397918411,
-0.0308011211,
0.0084393611,
0.0136521263,
0.0028320998,
-0.0161708295,
-0.0013092788,
0.0089468276,
0.0103461612,
0.0223091729,
-0.0233180672,
0.041581098,
-0.0175636522,
-0.0351146087,
-0.0055846409,
0.0011036997,
0.002848278,
0.0297462232,
-0.0383700915,
-0.007441673,
0.0026098771,
-0.0171893071,
0.0100487573,
-0.0487382598,
0.0677961707,
-0.0008952817,
-0.0199592188,
-0.0081036743,
-0.0682903826,
0.0019240802,
-0.0028211528,
-0.0374887325,
-0.0299466643,
-0.0059739044,
-0.0004408082,
-0.0332329683,
-0.0060493499,
-0.0248053484,
0.0467675067,
-0.0466304794,
0.0059837466,
0.0091681145,
-0.034879487,
-0.0551422648,
-0.0367605649,
-0.0181895662,
0.0260655135,
0.0004625015,
-0.0075140288,
0.0223854929,
0.0188147072,
-0.0240686517,
-0.0234971289,
-0.0205959622,
0.0503901802,
0.0499175377,
0.0010830007,
0.0165926088,
0.0392742828,
0.0625905991,
0.0365490839,
0.0230616666,
-0.0128814252,
-0.0041302368,
0.0048620929,
0.015657628,
0.0579094701,
0.039646443,
0.0029690887,
0.024000058,
-0.0040248479,
-0.067968592,
0.0148718739,
0.0608359724,
0.0586713105,
0.041696623,
0.0098344069,
-0.0212390795,
-0.0037945358,
-0.028599862,
-0.0279876608,
-0.0052747601,
-0.0290234163,
0.0445060581,
0.0042025764,
0.0302203856,
-0.0505772643,
0.0378160998,
-0.0308316033,
-0.018605819,
0.0109290853,
-0.0319918394,
0.0322225764,
-0.0165471155,
0.0323086157,
-0.0681080893,
-0.0619641505,
0.0253856797,
-0.0344271995,
-0.0123154512,
-0.0056816498,
-0.018090643,
0.0398238301,
-0.0648769364,
0.0253481865,
0.0104124714,
0.0491933152,
0.0237373859,
0.0051003043,
0.0557696633,
-0.0500877202,
0.0158266798,
0.0006987481,
-0.0094051296,
-0.0483779944,
-0.0110703036,
0.0110860718,
-0.0218187254,
0.0101485904,
0.0110273194,
0.0163697228,
-0.0824564621,
0.0773962438,
-0.0292892642,
-0.0141426213,
-0.0102827633,
0.0498585589,
2.749e-7,
0.0043321801,
0.0615211166,
-0.0031702516,
0.0191696212,
0.0103466026,
0.0327123925,
-0.0808581486,
-0.0126292072,
0.0261953399,
0.0563706495,
0.0759890527,
0.0115676979,
0.0323687308,
-0.0210528281,
-0.0874619707,
0.0022914498,
-0.0746992454,
0.0224907342,
-0.0411772691,
-0.0132614514,
0.012981208,
0.0783931762,
0.0202523172,
0.0166906901,
0.0164618474,
-0.0540696681,
0.0429127179,
-0.0409258306,
0.0200054962,
0.0263167899,
0.0313533992,
0.0095651206,
-0.0498804338,
-0.0198937263,
0.0079065654,
0.0609008782,
-0.00239474,
0.0449409485,
0.0348445401,
-0.053194724,
0.0136722084,
0.0045872484,
0.0200181827,
-0.0381579548,
0.0764449388,
-0.0562999696,
-0.0259426646,
-0.018734552,
0.0042694891,
-0.0147627685,
0.0221404973,
-0.0154579906,
-0.0287393667,
-0.0060108956,
0.0012605413,
0.0149486475,
0.0289752372,
-0.0553452373,
-0.0070857019,
0.0507438146,
-0.0229880065,
-0.0498268194,
-0.0737960711,
0.0065674991,
0.0239522196,
-0.0400689617,
-0.0157054011,
2.407450083e-34,
0.0433039255,
-0.0291475784,
-0.0028417294,
-0.0254484788,
0.0096616084,
0.0006556778,
0.0016213121,
0.0397157297,
0.0693967491,
-0.0448316522,
-0.0141354809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16377v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16377v1 | On the Transformations across Reward Model, Parameter Update, and In-Context Prompt | 2024-06-24T07:42:32 | 2024-06-24T07:42:32 | Deng Cai, Huayang Li, Tingchen Fu, Siheng Li, Weiwen Xu, Shuaiyi Li, Bowen Cao, Zhisong Zhang, Xinting Huang, Leyang Cui, Yan Wang, Lemao Liu, Taro Watanabe, Shuming Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the general capabilities of pre-trained large language models (LLMs),
they still need further adaptation to better serve practical applications. In
this paper, we demonstrate the interchangeability of three popular and distinct
adaptation tools: parameter updating, reward modeling, and in-context
prompting. This interchangeability establishes a triangular framework with six
transformation directions, each of which facilitates a variety of applications.
Our work offers a holistic view that unifies numerous existing studies and
suggests potential research directions. We envision our work as a useful
roadmap for future research on LLMs. | [
0.0406246297,
0.0515166856,
-0.0092945825,
0.0087816762,
-0.0007758216,
0.0218688585,
0.015442335,
-0.0200648922,
-0.0472681895,
-0.0416447408,
-0.1105496436,
-0.0043004439,
-0.0093421005,
0.015718516,
-0.0043325555,
-0.094637163,
0.0581794195,
-0.0872788131,
0.0033030596,
0.0013265574,
-0.0263453461,
-0.0052843373,
-0.0096224975,
0.0273409057,
0.0225211531,
-0.0052325032,
0.0006549492,
0.0163110811,
0.003680676,
-0.0277385321,
0.0049876384,
0.0468073636,
0.0300022233,
0.0381006822,
0.0000018729,
-0.0806232914,
-0.0009561644,
-0.0371747501,
-0.0434293598,
0.0578580461,
0.0521388613,
-0.0014314593,
-0.0261609163,
0.0362190381,
-0.0209834687,
-0.0449323393,
0.0482274331,
0.0191680472,
0.0717478842,
0.0882693753,
-0.0100189382,
-0.0063567925,
-0.0094600935,
-0.0514376126,
-0.0100577874,
-0.0242497362,
0.0411112644,
-0.0041976441,
0.0265991017,
0.0040618903,
-0.0278697833,
0.0401872918,
0.0192816462,
-0.0271558501,
-0.0016797265,
0.0281085633,
0.0292578731,
-0.0120157227,
-0.0612004474,
0.0588935539,
-0.0404462516,
-0.012389781,
-0.0185884368,
-0.0254847966,
0.0064468551,
-0.0033924095,
-0.0259584486,
0.0022455405,
0.063281782,
0.0162168778,
0.0297187287,
-0.0126315355,
0.0344877243,
0.0126056317,
-0.0720083416,
0.0382829644,
0.0411102325,
-0.0263900831,
0.0070653367,
-0.0005844916,
-0.0248616245,
-0.0576786771,
0.0056361551,
0.0449185893,
-0.0472814217,
0.0195897985,
-0.0653199255,
-0.0175477806,
-0.0230807886,
-0.0111496402,
0.0751162022,
0.0235573445,
-0.0359249786,
0.0663153529,
-0.0225207713,
0.019308757,
-0.0112315156,
0.0482761748,
-0.0473372452,
0.0313903429,
0.0034371861,
-0.0001645865,
-0.0805878863,
-0.0193381999,
-0.01170443,
-0.0224775597,
-0.0093175378,
0.0675612241,
0.0186488293,
-0.0094952844,
0.014072191,
-0.0356220752,
-0.0304525569,
-0.0264800247,
-0.006797879,
0.0395203084,
-0.0216183737,
0.0309301466,
0.0231711064,
-0.0307265595,
-0.0035919077,
0.0110714287,
0.0190811865,
-0.0143358223,
0.0123320678,
0.0461529978,
-0.0059983791,
-0.0378745012,
-0.0562643595,
0.0312717445,
-0.0071963696,
-0.0295447744,
-0.0244249832,
-0.0408436358,
0.0148909511,
-0.0205078777,
0.0233301278,
0.0005370807,
-0.0279365852,
-0.019430751,
-0.0285595171,
0.0528311767,
0.0015978101,
0.0428698882,
0.0398499779,
-0.0145813059,
0.0114778178,
0.0498224236,
0.0291365292,
0.017533917,
0.0310251005,
-0.0316461064,
-0.0114371981,
0.0650694296,
0.0229800716,
0.0431245193,
0.014322672,
0.0095818341,
0.0492368266,
0.0425843,
0.0409694351,
0.0347757898,
-0.0267452858,
0.035682492,
0.0987907499,
0.0314140543,
0.0306064188,
-0.0298166741,
0.0585109629,
-0.0056329742,
-0.0100470707,
-0.0006837124,
-0.0811659917,
-0.010822068,
-0.0302362051,
0.0097096795,
0.0182788465,
0.0291571058,
-0.0565182529,
-0.0411112756,
0.0108264145,
-0.0221969318,
0.0017110527,
0.0393494852,
0.0575805865,
0.036745593,
-0.0367191471,
-0.017013086,
0.0249639396,
-0.0269952491,
0.0484997369,
-0.0652872548,
0.0581269413,
0.0697710067,
0.0389415063,
-0.0485534929,
0.012300604,
0.0088338628,
0.0186657924,
0.0318271294,
0.0522790626,
-0.0212641079,
0.0109192682,
-0.0326328203,
0.0042302711,
0.0017291615,
0.0051519326,
0.0324949101,
0.0233824477,
0.0164516009,
0.0029232719,
0.0217441395,
-0.0310744289,
0.0195162315,
-0.0136232534,
-0.040112894,
0.0338229835,
0.0067681791,
0.0156162912,
-0.0073519028,
-0.008952749,
0.0053760805,
0.0025342633,
0.0027690073,
0.0328003801,
0.0141495056,
-0.0951770395,
-0.0193056576,
-0.0067008724,
0.0632125214,
0.0264560971,
0.0007085584,
-0.0170624349,
-0.0368206464,
0.0010142553,
0.0112394849,
0.0830948427,
-0.0216408614,
0.0627875999,
-0.012669486,
0.0060641691,
-0.0511706434,
0.0053736828,
0.0305235386,
-0.0373362042,
0.0317755565,
0.0407944806,
-0.0328902937,
-0.0298527349,
-0.0414556973,
0.0300463196,
0.0070693712,
0.0174932405,
0.0138613153,
0.0296459422,
-0.0363389477,
-0.0314576626,
-0.0605274662,
0.0006822213,
-0.0506712124,
0.0093130721,
0.041520793,
0.0420075879,
-0.0500990078,
-0.0382094756,
-0.0263082515,
0.0180743635,
0.0207556896,
0.0171741564,
0.0110563533,
0.0282194577,
0.0120500894,
-0.0571285635,
-0.0228268355,
0.022252487,
0.0234057903,
-0.0169592444,
-0.0232982952,
-0.1033279002,
0.0671029538,
0.0036940069,
0.0411548391,
0.0051505989,
-0.0057958448,
0.0159334112,
-0.0403224789,
0.1208327562,
0.0788579136,
0.0121409195,
0.037352439,
0.0528808087,
-0.0179528911,
-0.0487589464,
0.0125916107,
-0.040061377,
-0.1028801128,
-0.0451198556,
0.008977931,
0.0546574704,
0.0497750826,
-0.0213167761,
-0.0116390772,
-0.0597043075,
-0.0071935961,
-0.03254655,
-0.0541018695,
-0.0520394072,
-0.0174831152,
-0.0105125504,
0.030712828,
0.0024276183,
-0.0650291741,
0.0442698561,
-0.0535331219,
-0.0036125458,
-0.0398245528,
-0.0182605125,
-0.0273827743,
0.0369985886,
0.0087073678,
-0.0016626893,
-0.0072186319,
-0.043039076,
-0.0403097793,
-0.0050030435,
0.0043258909,
-0.0122670047,
0.0462455489,
-0.0215619206,
-0.0025401476,
0.0050642891,
-0.0271306764,
-0.0381018929,
-0.0474786945,
-0.0147560267,
-0.0110211438,
0.004827756,
-0.0187467486,
-0.0021769076,
0.0019612496,
0.0245192908,
0.0697111562,
0.0037935458,
-0.0110720033,
-0.0311594959,
-0.0030262226,
0.0658325925,
0.0367401913,
0.0314226747,
-0.0371312164,
0.0414468944,
-0.0153102838,
0.0446995497,
-0.0329751484,
-0.0269374643,
0.0038269022,
0.0600376017,
-0.0395877995,
0.0150104193,
0.0361411721,
0.0366520621,
-0.0346288271,
-0.0066190022,
0.1062483788,
0.0333070457,
-0.0787549615,
0.0126039619,
-0.0313705839,
0.0273171328,
-0.0037546267,
0.0382082835,
-0.0800824165,
-0.0118107125,
0.0038563185,
0.0058280802,
0.011889034,
-0.0066024708,
-0.0086870268,
-0.1077642217,
0.0255903937,
0.0189271439,
-0.0179408398,
0.0026514758,
-0.024422491,
0.0145722711,
0.0114960903,
0.0324249677,
0.0289021544,
-0.019113306,
-0.017518593,
0.003721158,
0.0291126966,
-0.0445225574,
0.0126348399,
-0.0377941281,
0.0510017425,
0.0828725696,
-0.0248362161,
0.0069944318,
-0.0066432725,
0.012235919,
-0.0127029559,
0.0096234502,
-0.0352030843,
-0.0143373162,
-0.0273602903,
-0.0296672285,
0.0047025685,
0.0358002074,
-0.0082563339,
-0.0114852898,
0.033368323,
0.0511542186,
-0.012091551,
-0.0160382893,
-0.0032556567,
-0.0194506291,
0.0472680926,
0.0707148165,
0.0249226727,
-0.08558283,
0.0059213173,
0.0130238421,
-0.0545876473,
0.0093989754,
-0.0069000381,
-0.0056177769,
-0.0381982066,
-0.0036149381,
-0.0687802136,
-0.0142821483,
0.0339673273,
0.032793466,
0.0229767077,
-0.0098408321,
0.0040097921,
-0.0023736118,
0.0158368815,
0.0339968652,
-0.0513415709,
0.0179715045,
-0.1045838892,
-0.0251724906,
0.0326409638,
-0.04605598,
0.0082077654,
-0.0298377164,
-0.0550234355,
-0.0638067499,
-0.0008820274,
0.0520452857,
0.0134340469,
0.0610437728,
-0.0272753425,
-0.0744682625,
0.0714013726,
-0.0143084284,
-0.0179314837,
0.0572164804,
0.0344898514,
0.0270485226,
-0.0167557895,
0.0232912116,
-0.0454172716,
0.034978278,
0.0224878211,
0.0142866643,
0.007135693,
-0.045816008,
0.0069860718,
0.0181632116,
0.0483211353,
-0.0072646379,
0.0009856769,
-0.0620168559,
0.0416173525,
-0.0209049489,
0.0021887033,
-0.0367706493,
-0.0077123176,
0.0419448167,
0.0204131473,
-0.0243531018,
-0.0267192572,
0.0109903123,
0.0157015026,
-0.0401750803,
0.005684216,
0.003599484,
0.0216883142,
0.0454887934,
0.021575626,
-0.0150866089,
0.0243163556,
0.0036061988,
0.0169209298,
-0.0093712779,
0.0765502825,
0.025880862,
-0.0221740808,
-0.016877247,
0.0433096364,
-0.0638290867,
-0.064448379,
-0.0220256392,
0.0379852988,
0.044418063,
0.0093845418,
0.0644605905,
-0.0250708293,
-0.0073954207,
-0.0326495804,
-0.0025282111,
0.012529009,
-0.017975213,
0.0225621797,
0.0001162598,
0.0017681981,
0.0328703076,
0.0265308134,
-0.0184469484,
0.0498664118,
0.0046860236,
0.030563388,
-0.008058426,
-0.0192810968,
0.0028037033,
-0.0103809247,
-0.0642835647,
0.017314218,
0.0149940671,
-0.0434780009,
-0.0516489707,
0.0261714775,
-0.0366161503,
-0.020859262,
0.0263055041,
0.0515168235,
-0.0215169024,
-0.0039191851,
-0.0295014083,
0.0022524372,
-0.0073088012,
-0.0342910215,
0.0118325157,
-6.436904944e-33,
-0.0472751781,
0.0524821542,
0.0347353742,
0.0025146054,
-0.0178141352,
-0.0129609546,
-0.0220775306,
0.0165518336,
-0.0112153608,
-0.0291711334,
-0.0368174948,
-0.0029885571,
0.027635185,
0.0167247001,
-0.0082123373,
-0.0128918681,
0.0743365139,
-0.0170551594,
-0.0470747501,
0.0353957638,
0.0071514705,
0.0076101101,
0.0488503277,
-0.0428848118,
0.0322268903,
0.0142755369,
-0.0241665766,
0.0310637057,
-0.0203447342,
0.0467423201,
-0.0202779155,
0.0398086719,
-0.004890359,
-0.0193789378,
-0.0506813265,
0.0599774607,
-0.0884279385,
-0.014849687,
0.044770319,
0.0305573307,
-0.0502200201,
-0.0410894752,
-0.0080767414,
-0.0142777693,
-0.0085964864,
0.0214118138,
-0.0011080179,
-0.0158136096,
-0.0147301629,
-0.0016130542,
-0.0662041381,
0.0010838981,
0.0022463785,
-0.0112994248,
0.0095956046,
0.0325065665,
-0.0459576175,
0.0196180809,
-0.0273936037,
0.0566862784,
0.0821663439,
0.0452331156,
0.0395456553,
0.0485013314,
0.0116398558,
0.0112301456,
-0.0122776609,
-0.0107142441,
0.0250676665,
-0.0129794758,
0.0555081926,
0.0049046022,
0.0180568416,
-0.0001907168,
-0.0101054981,
-0.0267623533,
-0.027560398,
-0.0097638275,
0.0050087823,
0.0009481568,
0.0188072585,
0.0056691179,
0.003318941,
-0.0151143912,
-0.0674198419,
0.006971837,
-0.0311553236,
-0.0396317765,
0.0658355951,
0.0316351354,
-0.0114960177,
-0.0090533514,
0.0472464077,
-0.007593892,
-0.0161973201,
-0.0058264597,
-0.0045648683,
0.0358032212,
-0.0362623185,
0.0225866307,
-0.0724944025,
-0.0397424251,
0.0342866294,
-0.0279949177,
-0.0231472515,
0.0122284004,
0.0205086153,
0.0508886985,
-0.0553252064,
0.0034201271,
0.0205369368,
0.0385342911,
0.0127794771,
-0.0017221235,
0.0071226517,
-0.0219309479,
-0.0062430659,
0.0539761223,
0.0077851908,
-0.0629660934,
-0.0236051492,
-0.0230927337,
0.0125736026,
0.0326504372,
-0.0417139009,
-0.0025713483,
-0.0235363506,
-0.0052918522,
0.0462294966,
-0.0660185292,
-0.0193901118,
-0.0158182643,
2.643e-7,
0.0153682716,
0.0287397299,
-0.008492928,
0.0006581508,
0.0183606241,
0.0021519307,
-0.0151547771,
0.0379251465,
0.0422719941,
0.0533330813,
0.0341632664,
0.029312849,
0.0164088383,
-0.0257313848,
-0.0596021451,
-0.0348104686,
-0.0776306018,
0.041525647,
-0.0573004447,
-0.0254354533,
0.0223606844,
0.082554616,
0.0037953702,
-0.0081495773,
0.0060264086,
-0.0488355197,
0.0495936833,
-0.0810411274,
-0.0144294063,
0.0383570008,
0.0309138522,
0.0171114095,
-0.005071593,
-0.010161181,
0.0082021719,
0.0529136583,
-0.0151384166,
0.0674673766,
0.0122455861,
-0.0047250241,
-0.0078123123,
0.0147507889,
0.0025589371,
-0.064305529,
0.0653274506,
-0.0964815542,
-0.0139000341,
-0.0577220619,
0.0180819985,
-0.0562248081,
0.0030575236,
-0.0604805984,
-0.0158217326,
0.0037620615,
0.0438354351,
0.0411723964,
-0.0267841648,
-0.0760905072,
0.003121488,
0.0249978583,
-0.0074905865,
-0.0605737008,
-0.0831533223,
0.0073269112,
-0.0021701441,
-0.0693450645,
0.0259107295,
2.054914276e-34,
0.0420188978,
-0.0206470788,
0.0373946242,
0.0006580048,
0.0082577905,
0.0278524458,
-0.0023229783,
0.0032407201,
0.0413438305,
-0.1400456578,
-0.0284557324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16374v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16374v1 | KEHRL: Learning Knowledge-Enhanced Language Representations with Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning | 2024-06-24T07:32:35 | 2024-06-24T07:32:35 | Dongyang Li, Taolin Zhang, Longtao Huang, Chengyu Wang, Xiaofeng He, Hui Xue | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge-enhanced pre-trained language models (KEPLMs) leverage relation
triples from knowledge graphs (KGs) and integrate these external data sources
into language models via self-supervised learning. Previous works treat
knowledge enhancement as two independent operations, i.e., knowledge injection
and knowledge integration. In this paper, we propose to learn
Knowledge-Enhanced language representations with Hierarchical Reinforcement
Learning (KEHRL), which jointly addresses the problems of detecting positions
for knowledge injection and integrating external knowledge into the model in
order to avoid injecting inaccurate or irrelevant knowledge. Specifically, a
high-level reinforcement learning (RL) agent utilizes both internal and prior
knowledge to iteratively detect essential positions in texts for knowledge
injection, which filters out less meaningful entities to avoid diverting the
knowledge learning direction. Once the entity positions are selected, a
relevant triple filtration module is triggered to perform low-level RL to
dynamically refine the triples associated with polysemic entities through
binary-valued actions. Experiments validate KEHRL's effectiveness in probing
factual knowledge and enhancing the model's performance on various natural
language understanding tasks. | [
0.0621752217,
-0.0178670716,
-0.0067599104,
0.0273008756,
-0.0081180092,
0.0090887183,
-0.0437817797,
-0.0244508944,
0.0640128478,
-0.091428332,
-0.0097429343,
0.0439709164,
-0.0216296483,
0.0484167784,
0.0303498711,
-0.0299935192,
0.0956418812,
-0.0079300553,
0.0421778634,
-0.0081722327,
-0.0011473279,
0.0192763656,
-0.0072905193,
-0.015093199,
-0.0240470413,
0.0075001079,
-0.0169087593,
-0.0012660322,
0.02076203,
-0.0103365416,
0.0123490086,
0.025935119,
0.063760303,
0.0261502955,
0.0000020784,
-0.0634845048,
-0.0365442373,
-0.0174079929,
-0.0483094864,
-0.0380542912,
-0.0052107819,
-0.014948667,
0.0011237967,
-0.0208002776,
-0.0606264994,
-0.0164186191,
0.0015418181,
0.073199898,
0.0712719485,
0.0819319487,
-0.0061064502,
0.0259409826,
0.0054739565,
-0.0086127613,
0.0338351913,
0.0060891472,
0.0358858928,
0.060947258,
-0.0172932688,
0.0322298929,
-0.0226671938,
0.0329107493,
0.0227530301,
-0.0173886213,
0.0602923408,
0.0276728161,
-0.0012981702,
0.0153628374,
-0.028070515,
0.0790792927,
-0.0361287445,
-0.0169792324,
-0.0229195859,
-0.0110231936,
0.0081203226,
0.0327183865,
0.0141526796,
-0.0263147242,
0.012408982,
0.0089273425,
0.0121172415,
-0.002905607,
0.0379658006,
0.0186519083,
-0.0348733217,
0.0864904895,
0.0041041682,
-0.0471265987,
0.0370245986,
-0.0090031018,
0.0240673795,
-0.0288280174,
-0.0142781567,
0.0413365811,
0.0184411537,
0.0674430802,
-0.0336417854,
0.0092879003,
-0.004853521,
-0.0623575225,
-0.0142309163,
0.0430307463,
0.0247417036,
0.0670486167,
-0.0546745025,
0.0052167848,
0.0032599675,
0.0442448929,
-0.0331047885,
0.0105224727,
-0.0418886505,
-0.0241394956,
-0.0199720133,
0.0489254817,
-0.0188705511,
-0.0265449528,
-0.0332259759,
0.0391279496,
-0.0214748438,
0.042112533,
-0.0074953423,
0.0353382044,
-0.0000609716,
-0.0243338142,
-0.0657239929,
0.0470197871,
-0.0386701524,
0.0141907409,
-0.0362090357,
0.0071190265,
-0.0050813141,
-0.0285993069,
0.0342941917,
-0.032983277,
0.0039734202,
0.0600311495,
-0.0035472708,
-0.050981652,
-0.0370074138,
-0.0438746959,
0.0225807503,
-0.0291721616,
-0.0033567243,
-0.0331530757,
0.0299450383,
-0.0318967029,
-0.0391048566,
-0.0595101304,
0.0359654762,
-0.0099600265,
-0.0585080907,
0.0938642249,
-0.0875844583,
-0.0445753448,
-0.0103622694,
0.0219861232,
-0.0202347673,
0.0610875003,
0.0255722087,
-0.0118908118,
0.0076515437,
0.0058984193,
-0.0490297116,
-0.0063616154,
0.0290057044,
0.014277,
-0.0010399465,
0.0198932067,
-0.016277831,
0.031376332,
0.0473840162,
-0.0042769182,
-0.0111114997,
0.0271772537,
0.0568712205,
0.0179279149,
-0.016286321,
-0.0084697697,
0.0323509648,
0.0279021319,
-0.0004651543,
-0.000971845,
-0.0549737699,
0.0153884487,
-0.0246464591,
0.0015661161,
-0.0155023504,
0.0253821034,
0.0154887391,
-0.0477270409,
0.0401025824,
-0.0210668538,
0.0443851724,
0.0308889505,
0.0485120378,
0.0374204852,
-0.0500216484,
0.0133083416,
0.0474561043,
-0.0036473481,
0.0304245707,
0.0009575708,
0.0273800977,
0.0944090858,
0.0262194816,
-0.0561758615,
-0.0270429179,
-0.0305041708,
-0.0565195419,
0.0203722287,
0.0107113793,
-0.0245609656,
0.0003491636,
-0.0181919355,
-0.0659499615,
-0.0292295553,
0.0089436099,
0.0356561504,
0.0294289291,
0.0154060926,
0.0165301766,
0.0094665634,
0.0215547029,
0.0211633015,
-0.0040716552,
-0.0330954194,
-0.0095761642,
0.0388772525,
-0.0192749202,
0.0333953723,
0.0207327362,
0.002389601,
0.0301708821,
0.0085397251,
-0.0492050759,
-0.0148569886,
-0.0346191823,
-0.0773661509,
0.0276110228,
0.0188844986,
-0.0526760705,
-0.0188212469,
-0.0125419553,
-0.0322144814,
0.0070821512,
-0.0062998864,
0.0820494294,
-0.0200897586,
-0.0171536319,
0.0329753384,
-0.0085649733,
-0.0321694836,
0.0881060734,
-0.0101900436,
0.0156111168,
-0.0178176984,
-0.0202007629,
-0.0046000509,
0.0156616587,
-0.0075649628,
-0.0227544438,
0.0045062951,
0.0051364959,
0.0339491516,
-0.0039226147,
-0.067950666,
0.0338779874,
-0.03360378,
-0.0126090692,
0.0237648208,
-0.0082311444,
0.0101085156,
0.0042550615,
0.00509308,
-0.0381523706,
-0.0280471761,
0.0018692487,
-0.0168996975,
0.0069897012,
0.0422495604,
0.0040793777,
0.0175116323,
-0.0304934401,
0.0098289642,
-0.0404887125,
0.0499716848,
0.0006347964,
0.0200714134,
-0.0012052178,
-0.0152234035,
-0.0327342451,
0.0459331274,
-0.012272018,
-0.0223073307,
-0.0136654032,
-0.0247053783,
0.0371991359,
0.0672660321,
-0.0077907261,
0.0401104875,
0.0510353372,
-0.0308211055,
-0.0634473115,
0.0416293442,
-0.0322742537,
0.0371292755,
-0.0581922568,
0.0543931983,
-0.0092079313,
0.0476355106,
0.0094172442,
-0.0417547561,
-0.0532253236,
0.0429948345,
0.0065657878,
-0.061760135,
-0.0492259935,
-0.0099938391,
-0.0139621338,
0.0114263864,
-0.0402382314,
0.0044224309,
0.0787617862,
-0.0089361342,
0.0007745112,
-0.0191665627,
-0.0113881519,
-0.0321198963,
0.0309373662,
0.006735228,
0.0352943055,
-0.0300072748,
0.0037443035,
-0.0644148514,
-0.011923247,
0.0381972305,
-0.0190531518,
0.0463983938,
-0.0160006844,
0.0014587813,
0.041876968,
-0.005806277,
-0.0516882502,
-0.0092229219,
0.0019963491,
-0.0089127142,
-0.005072359,
-0.0085314019,
-0.0086318301,
-0.0269293934,
0.0395499915,
0.0287381373,
0.0099176252,
-0.0430537127,
-0.031137418,
0.0282157622,
0.0551230907,
0.0268115811,
0.0259143282,
0.040948581,
0.0227873176,
0.0323433019,
-0.0119863851,
-0.063494876,
-0.0056925579,
0.0534471348,
-0.0100615034,
-0.0879048109,
0.0044828835,
-0.0135477483,
0.0046225516,
-0.0755990371,
0.0124562066,
0.1184408218,
0.0371631905,
-0.0091151446,
0.0041602226,
-0.0037497168,
-0.0225572232,
0.0616866313,
0.0307842474,
-0.0757184327,
0.001706281,
-0.0260267779,
-0.0368981659,
0.0074861459,
-0.0559379309,
-0.0282308515,
-0.1342444718,
-0.0306499414,
0.0119302832,
0.0005614261,
-0.0489630252,
-0.0009782894,
-0.0004534311,
0.0292381234,
-0.0333272703,
-0.028778363,
-0.0145394569,
0.0004394905,
-0.0129499678,
-0.0035196908,
-0.0387728624,
0.0111087291,
-0.0316234492,
0.0458295755,
0.0182157811,
0.048969727,
-0.0112995487,
0.0359391458,
-0.069775112,
0.003257046,
-0.0153233521,
0.0021827491,
0.0237476043,
-0.0425379016,
0.0053475383,
-0.0205452088,
-0.0042476468,
-0.017239796,
-0.0283292495,
-0.0261980016,
0.105078049,
0.0060042669,
0.0039109834,
-0.0006406205,
-0.0052944934,
0.0329910442,
0.0546168461,
-0.0057436647,
-0.0037410345,
0.0122223645,
-0.0329170451,
-0.0095019219,
-0.0078231925,
-0.002682073,
0.0495595932,
-0.0227084756,
0.0251829848,
-0.0828128755,
-0.0772685334,
0.056080617,
0.0081973793,
0.0316547602,
0.0310373139,
0.0272185914,
-0.0061769378,
-0.0442576446,
-0.0266400948,
-0.0223042779,
0.0083720302,
0.0396537036,
-0.0126879532,
-0.0213823691,
-0.0437666625,
-0.0396608934,
-0.0326490849,
0.0129984478,
-0.0514732935,
-0.0123835895,
0.066979751,
0.0086726621,
0.0881757662,
-0.0359636098,
0.0062374398,
0.0841728598,
0.0230184998,
-0.0852445513,
-0.0103762094,
0.0360856913,
0.0210653376,
-0.0013033149,
0.0352259576,
-0.0484522618,
-0.0045187655,
-0.0329627432,
0.0035708493,
-0.0415322743,
-0.0418436304,
0.0313155763,
-0.0164796393,
0.0253435075,
0.0063038548,
0.0244363211,
-0.054598242,
0.0068195215,
-0.0374216922,
-0.0379966795,
-0.0334006548,
-0.008294723,
0.0239452515,
-0.0042943265,
-0.0108877569,
-0.0132897664,
0.0398619659,
0.0129425535,
0.0190041177,
-0.0354413576,
0.0461962707,
0.0100805126,
0.016088428,
0.0183980241,
0.0049242615,
0.0788628757,
-0.0081020026,
0.0092741959,
-0.0396019258,
0.0331340358,
0.0076499749,
-0.0529072471,
-0.0315771215,
-0.0122285727,
-0.0550325774,
0.001441805,
0.0120369699,
-0.0096034678,
0.070820637,
-0.0194298998,
0.0479144678,
-0.0411060825,
-0.0139937596,
0.0462239534,
0.0126802512,
-0.0162680671,
-0.0153841544,
0.0335311443,
0.0250915568,
-0.0123995533,
0.0009866146,
0.0479549132,
0.0453825332,
0.0672322884,
-0.007415941,
-0.0110635916,
-0.0543194599,
-0.013381782,
0.0322389528,
0.0670414194,
-0.0244322717,
0.0566853806,
-0.0546106026,
-0.103887625,
-0.0294177942,
-0.0036148275,
-0.0504590645,
0.0044053984,
0.0331921093,
0.0009667875,
0.0154347969,
-0.0259329528,
-0.05449678,
0.0141402651,
-0.0257576667,
0.0064589358,
0.0285063032,
-6.50394706e-33,
-0.0571222715,
-0.0287637003,
0.0128545957,
-0.0078597954,
-0.0269261263,
0.009358055,
-0.0414004475,
-0.0307994336,
-0.0121324062,
0.0355015509,
0.0137532037,
0.0196110327,
-0.0181997865,
-0.0053593144,
-0.0162865072,
0.0125931585,
0.0196770951,
0.0070762993,
0.016655501,
0.000477896,
0.0446473844,
0.049697645,
0.0812950283,
-0.0317557603,
0.0202215258,
0.0193109829,
-0.021940425,
0.0451297089,
-0.0074457712,
0.0437260009,
-0.0040716734,
0.0343196765,
0.0037147223,
-0.0221276376,
0.0022863406,
0.0347497649,
-0.1508696973,
-0.0731318071,
0.0505764782,
0.0120797623,
-0.0352011733,
-0.0113758491,
0.0275157001,
-0.021417534,
0.0828469619,
-0.0342764817,
0.0404022746,
-0.0037875853,
-0.0386368781,
-0.0561726764,
-0.06978558,
0.0032463267,
-0.009061235,
0.0085666012,
0.0049262904,
-0.0092485845,
0.0652422979,
-0.0445696972,
-0.0849920064,
0.0119361738,
-0.017375974,
0.0090916008,
0.0305116959,
0.0130493362,
-0.0047499775,
0.0521561764,
-0.0524956509,
-0.0088765537,
-0.0301304813,
0.0103877513,
0.0480447225,
0.048283264,
-0.0049477308,
0.0483085848,
0.0109047005,
0.0164204538,
-0.0533092394,
0.0102745527,
0.0003944158,
0.0360172838,
-0.0257327612,
0.0039661541,
-0.0516556986,
-0.019578075,
-0.0589961,
0.0227697678,
-0.0211594757,
-0.0787588656,
0.0149147408,
0.0015773941,
-0.0283834953,
0.0102923289,
-0.0142442258,
-0.054020375,
-0.0144949993,
0.0450575612,
-0.017422745,
-0.0027088008,
0.0009397368,
0.035978891,
-0.0475785248,
-0.0140993837,
0.0238551758,
-0.0486786701,
-0.0001623522,
0.0299058501,
0.0301180854,
0.0142731024,
-0.0744175762,
0.0029440732,
-0.023577936,
0.0015024384,
0.0156881213,
0.0081483666,
0.0278355964,
0.0416809209,
-0.0312089771,
0.02049754,
0.0524765886,
0.0075453361,
-0.0056286124,
0.0223466456,
-0.005610785,
0.0233145077,
-0.0143831782,
-0.0176284909,
-0.0486096255,
-0.0108221937,
0.0054134373,
-0.0919537842,
0.000646416,
0.0121441819,
2.931e-7,
0.0518170483,
0.0572197586,
-0.0003907375,
0.0310349278,
0.0075782398,
0.0389626995,
0.0075051282,
0.0248157755,
-0.0092679309,
-0.0284739509,
0.0424810722,
0.0422717333,
-0.028175259,
0.0255369693,
-0.091767855,
-0.0398755632,
-0.0261162091,
-0.0360517465,
-0.0397762358,
-0.0106422622,
0.0703361407,
0.0585249513,
0.0746729076,
0.0091097793,
-0.0392975658,
-0.0393251069,
0.0716257393,
0.0270643905,
-0.0194355808,
0.012869888,
0.0217445586,
0.0332826264,
-0.0409244336,
0.069364123,
-0.0379917622,
0.0462064408,
-0.0132747581,
0.0267608184,
-0.0116185499,
0.0047047399,
-0.0111943763,
-0.0074102953,
0.0189602096,
-0.0459279642,
0.0754917637,
-0.0838419795,
0.0011959047,
0.0220792145,
-0.0342286304,
-0.0312265009,
-0.0005578773,
0.0084429979,
-0.0274844822,
0.0040999376,
0.0096881939,
0.0115883471,
0.0101946788,
-0.1046738923,
-0.0212549902,
0.0516640805,
0.001193924,
-0.0252159256,
-0.0143933576,
-0.027607901,
0.0374179669,
-0.032163281,
0.02356866,
2.805727543e-34,
-0.0037750101,
-0.0100288447,
0.0013430121,
-0.0000212002,
0.0535224043,
0.0129990587,
-0.0350746512,
-0.0023082499,
0.0710011497,
-0.0711683705,
0.00444614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16372v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16372v1 | UniPSDA: Unsupervised Pseudo Semantic Data Augmentation for Zero-Shot Cross-Lingual Natural Language Understanding | 2024-06-24T07:27:01 | 2024-06-24T07:27:01 | Dongyang Li, Taolin Zhang, Jiali Deng, Longtao Huang, Chengyu Wang, Xiaofeng He, Hui Xue | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual representation learning transfers knowledge from resource-rich
data to resource-scarce ones to improve the semantic understanding abilities of
different languages. However, previous works rely on shallow unsupervised data
generated by token surface matching, regardless of the global context-aware
semantics of the surrounding text tokens. In this paper, we propose an
Unsupervised Pseudo Semantic Data Augmentation (UniPSDA) mechanism for
cross-lingual natural language understanding to enrich the training data
without human interventions. Specifically, to retrieve the tokens with similar
meanings for the semantic data augmentation across different languages, we
propose a sequential clustering process in 3 stages: within a single language,
across multiple languages of a language family, and across languages from
multiple language families. Meanwhile, considering the multi-lingual knowledge
infusion with context-aware semantics while alleviating computation burden, we
directly replace the key constituents of the sentences with the above-learned
multi-lingual family knowledge, viewed as pseudo-semantic. The infusion process
is further optimized via three de-biasing techniques without introducing any
neural parameters. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our model
consistently improves the performance on general zero-shot cross-lingual
natural language understanding tasks, including sequence classification,
information extraction, and question answering. | [
0.0048745973,
-0.0182076599,
0.0028203083,
0.0819580182,
-0.0103034554,
0.0056602955,
0.0113565316,
-0.0324866399,
-0.0052495119,
-0.0449696109,
-0.0455411784,
0.0192977246,
-0.0100557106,
-0.0045855874,
0.0221474264,
-0.0497696921,
0.1063433662,
-0.0042463224,
0.0025340912,
0.0055266125,
0.0113616725,
0.0108126616,
-0.0053629372,
0.0061004898,
-0.039075613,
-0.0142650995,
-0.0244883616,
-0.0202982612,
0.0176394638,
-0.0061585596,
-0.0315462612,
0.019911848,
0.0591622181,
0.0714955404,
0.0000019749,
-0.0363013558,
-0.0245536324,
-0.006322043,
-0.0150728775,
-0.0177139565,
0.040676713,
-0.072183758,
0.0173670966,
-0.0398968309,
-0.0264081024,
-0.0525513217,
0.0456497669,
0.0452265553,
0.04397377,
0.0713617802,
-0.0173381679,
-0.0158987809,
0.0042251032,
-0.0127197979,
0.0424540266,
-0.0483465195,
0.0099174157,
-0.0001257679,
-0.0274526607,
0.0060524549,
-0.011638022,
0.0146114035,
0.0325933583,
0.0193212423,
0.0076268618,
0.0359030701,
-0.0772433057,
-0.0008499345,
0.003713293,
0.0988629609,
-0.0317140892,
-0.0251987968,
-0.0186673943,
0.00546131,
-0.01815743,
-0.038542334,
-0.0544701219,
-0.0055613844,
0.0322764143,
0.0161306951,
0.0423478521,
0.0168265775,
0.0365855768,
0.0292762741,
-0.0372198634,
0.1049916968,
-0.0065372032,
0.0098315626,
-0.0211653858,
0.0102779642,
-0.0167296119,
-0.0407768823,
-0.0023808579,
0.0329979993,
-0.0295938421,
0.0304828808,
-0.0196688585,
-0.0453485027,
0.0158929005,
-0.0085793501,
-0.0184189864,
0.0652477294,
-0.0414325967,
0.0675777644,
-0.062686488,
-0.0166268256,
-0.0240215939,
0.0376940854,
-0.0531973466,
-0.0675997436,
-0.0467733108,
-0.014278058,
-0.0439921468,
0.0536011048,
-0.0841912404,
0.0059375409,
-0.0043174443,
0.014945114,
0.0086320424,
-0.0139172664,
-0.0061922502,
0.0063013323,
-0.0291710943,
-0.0084737921,
-0.0105894823,
0.061062485,
-0.0601216666,
0.0099787097,
-0.0110614365,
-0.0491975695,
-0.0274827611,
0.0208319724,
0.0314629413,
-0.0345774926,
-0.0106701879,
0.0899707824,
-0.0247846656,
-0.0230159648,
-0.0683712959,
-0.028871987,
0.0223244075,
-0.0469745249,
-0.0259185266,
-0.0500178784,
0.0677723736,
-0.0107546235,
-0.0187634788,
-0.0038615412,
-0.0063062157,
-0.0046103005,
-0.0319526792,
0.0648920611,
-0.0621524006,
-0.0560370199,
-0.0113840401,
-0.0034628299,
0.0030199408,
0.0859821588,
-0.0094229644,
-0.0190608054,
0.063201949,
0.0147959981,
-0.0607159026,
0.0116743231,
0.0388080813,
0.0060369927,
-0.0219467208,
0.0310658496,
0.0371543355,
0.0161033887,
0.047603894,
-0.0075163874,
-0.0611641631,
-0.0083356733,
-0.0310614258,
0.0366945863,
-0.0332372487,
0.0296008829,
0.0505330376,
0.006932776,
-0.0379822887,
0.0177913439,
-0.0172266215,
0.0479198359,
-0.0064047636,
0.0117197679,
0.0259967837,
0.0131087676,
-0.0693920329,
-0.047947254,
0.0266458988,
-0.0315304846,
0.0403356813,
0.0137905246,
0.059416566,
0.023027705,
0.0084865848,
0.0690609664,
0.0642517507,
-0.0413381383,
0.0353910252,
0.0010076046,
0.0473834723,
0.0698424876,
-0.0102819651,
-0.0436745137,
-0.0356075615,
-0.0138344122,
0.0312584788,
0.0287704263,
-0.0010347771,
-0.027820915,
0.0539055653,
-0.0504934527,
-0.0285353754,
-0.038268216,
-0.0071103964,
0.0454185419,
-0.0409793183,
0.0064119976,
0.0372341797,
-0.0729845986,
0.0206755213,
0.0164893009,
-0.0401885435,
-0.0116841132,
0.03475352,
0.032937739,
0.0146342311,
0.0469935834,
0.0261261072,
-0.0184251331,
0.0307784379,
-0.0576548576,
-0.0068010185,
0.004068628,
-0.0490146726,
-0.0676476732,
0.0247531384,
-0.0236949921,
-0.0316799134,
-0.0254877433,
-0.0532572642,
-0.0464600213,
0.0602959916,
0.0058769807,
0.0762273297,
-0.073973313,
-0.0352059491,
0.0049009342,
0.0295873154,
-0.0100824367,
0.0679192096,
0.0247757267,
0.0293114297,
0.0072027575,
-0.0067535816,
0.0634133443,
-0.0238044411,
0.0040394585,
0.009386858,
-0.0227100868,
-0.0114855543,
0.025455337,
-0.0147259366,
-0.0472052842,
0.0314582959,
-0.1205604076,
-0.0026623891,
-0.0202697217,
0.0038193765,
0.0343079455,
0.0596185178,
0.0124886278,
-0.0416751504,
-0.0502514765,
-0.0042744791,
0.014921342,
0.0231823232,
0.0508735441,
0.0166908,
0.0295585785,
-0.0239004046,
-0.0000975395,
-0.0095883869,
0.0349617973,
-0.0060313893,
-0.0118141687,
-0.0212773904,
-0.0032644572,
-0.0535066687,
0.0231893845,
-0.0076898471,
-0.0249592587,
-0.023857519,
0.0034671787,
0.0000896402,
0.0413887724,
-0.0352270268,
-0.0404729545,
0.0302317664,
-0.0141314771,
-0.0661967099,
0.021513477,
0.0197125804,
0.0403890051,
-0.0114476038,
0.023949584,
0.0159180611,
0.053510543,
-0.0221989844,
-0.0466142185,
-0.0442054048,
-0.0141469734,
-0.0009215715,
-0.0334280394,
-0.0370728225,
0.0093255714,
0.0345228724,
0.0392017849,
-0.0556600615,
0.0196474735,
0.0692509487,
-0.0302015692,
-0.0343841203,
-0.0682995394,
-0.0192015655,
-0.0578524433,
0.0085362578,
-0.0138024883,
0.0401023217,
-0.0323420428,
-0.0238810908,
-0.0126743661,
-0.0434379652,
-0.0225883052,
0.0201040767,
0.0224984847,
0.0222479105,
0.0095618907,
-0.013586605,
0.0105691385,
-0.0317576528,
-0.0373710804,
-0.0226882044,
0.0243887827,
-0.0119483974,
0.0097602988,
-0.0363792032,
-0.0282894019,
0.0535555817,
0.0587609634,
-0.013213438,
0.0180243477,
-0.0319094546,
0.0474866144,
0.0143861463,
0.0015151841,
-0.0133540714,
0.0117633715,
0.0213286318,
0.0343472511,
0.0415381119,
-0.0430776775,
-0.0014195413,
0.0200636014,
0.01063722,
-0.0111656915,
-0.0245120805,
-0.0253003351,
0.0079624373,
-0.0311460588,
-0.0045146625,
0.1010836139,
0.0198896267,
-0.0449731164,
0.0057928581,
-0.0525804348,
-0.0122507187,
0.0530574992,
0.0164375082,
-0.082300812,
-0.0515927039,
-0.0166418795,
-0.0436092056,
0.0188645422,
-0.0264871381,
-0.0106954863,
-0.107090421,
-0.0211910941,
-0.006647361,
-0.1434251815,
-0.0065646879,
-0.0506482609,
0.0030588363,
-0.016959887,
0.0524247475,
-0.0302732736,
0.0333979651,
-0.0200267155,
0.0028510469,
0.0374406092,
-0.057657484,
0.0039326567,
-0.0446870774,
-0.0105703501,
0.022185389,
0.0294936989,
-0.009591518,
-0.0376737155,
0.0142861446,
-0.0366775952,
0.0036702231,
-0.0233594086,
0.0376624204,
-0.0297206789,
-0.0207044799,
0.0184021145,
0.031700395,
-0.0384260267,
-0.0108332196,
0.0042606983,
0.0865077302,
0.0374853425,
0.0367701799,
0.0242732279,
-0.0323278569,
-0.0139086554,
0.0599777326,
-0.002072514,
0.0118390741,
0.0189210214,
-0.0026982529,
0.0025850558,
-0.0444821045,
0.0069647543,
0.0002127942,
-0.0364575088,
-0.0321630202,
-0.0405516326,
-0.0627836436,
0.0511320345,
0.0490184836,
-0.0082022417,
0.0365786664,
-0.0242697913,
-0.0385823809,
-0.0570103452,
0.0383403935,
-0.047936108,
-0.004450222,
0.0059773959,
-0.0073928111,
0.000940123,
-0.0305196252,
-0.0136233401,
-0.0165105183,
-0.0105282795,
-0.0703080595,
-0.0268053412,
0.0211093258,
0.005430765,
0.087546058,
-0.0293705333,
-0.030532591,
0.0828559026,
0.045816306,
-0.060072612,
-0.0286395159,
0.0225027148,
0.0129131274,
0.0165427122,
0.049763348,
-0.0314391777,
-0.0131084165,
0.0192793701,
0.0352439992,
-0.0506455489,
0.017880274,
0.0296893734,
0.0005172383,
0.0709738582,
0.0215896796,
0.0386031941,
-0.0226879586,
0.0205337517,
-0.0578300692,
-0.0213187262,
-0.003764767,
-0.0087264627,
-0.0014374194,
-0.0496375114,
0.0222941358,
0.0251386501,
-0.0560824648,
0.0019063683,
0.0230250992,
-0.0079648355,
0.0294604897,
0.0235752631,
-0.034780357,
0.0161492415,
-0.0058005545,
-0.0343722403,
-0.0129457712,
0.025261471,
-0.0775312483,
-0.0085330857,
0.0228582174,
-0.0072375187,
-0.0531270429,
0.0217110142,
-0.0436689705,
0.0456109419,
0.0114933215,
0.02929339,
0.05500843,
-0.0574932136,
0.0091575226,
0.0346884429,
-0.0259352457,
0.0116398539,
-0.0032151414,
-0.0089282906,
-0.0398209915,
0.0055840774,
0.0238215774,
-0.0223839544,
0.0061166957,
0.0874256864,
-0.0313604251,
0.0300110281,
-0.0038235476,
0.0101101827,
-0.0326279253,
0.0192356333,
0.0481409691,
0.0614188574,
-0.0289639439,
0.0169686005,
-0.0186778866,
-0.069693163,
0.0066282637,
0.0115694655,
-0.0229473375,
0.0295338817,
0.0357169025,
0.0471585542,
0.0023784083,
-0.0122028375,
-0.0206220485,
0.0158747192,
0.0220010951,
-0.0234094132,
0.0130483489,
-6.480636273e-33,
-0.0018413315,
0.0227941237,
-0.0068117767,
-0.0162015688,
-0.0088613247,
0.0118924798,
-0.0292591043,
-0.0182267483,
-0.0066216704,
0.0155562013,
0.0093250694,
-0.0005016148,
0.0204886701,
0.0468942635,
-0.012877455,
-0.0092175649,
0.0309564378,
0.0235987119,
0.0051982766,
0.0244549587,
0.0823285133,
0.0251519084,
0.0762034208,
-0.0141790602,
0.0325792395,
-0.0165629573,
0.0448851436,
0.0537978299,
0.0666137859,
0.0432515442,
-0.0065607801,
0.0462224931,
0.0369058475,
-0.0163492672,
-0.0055534923,
0.0131751113,
-0.1083295643,
-0.0675715804,
0.0683562085,
0.0169608016,
-0.0393055975,
-0.0552107319,
0.0167317446,
-0.0349666439,
0.0576814078,
0.0249293819,
0.0203107651,
-0.0139603624,
-0.0225393437,
0.0388974883,
-0.0634589195,
-0.0023847148,
-0.0223853644,
0.0189951435,
0.0432942063,
0.0827190205,
0.0199663863,
0.0338412151,
-0.0727988631,
0.006442884,
-0.0855420753,
0.0338331796,
0.0635044947,
0.016018549,
0.0112451278,
0.0421652682,
0.0524022169,
-0.0100649474,
-0.0092289932,
0.0340275764,
0.0301605538,
-0.0160383098,
-0.0059698564,
0.0905154869,
0.0423978046,
0.0030413757,
-0.0717137679,
0.0413496755,
-0.01627554,
0.0117214313,
-0.0084414519,
0.0078796512,
0.0120871672,
-0.0020908804,
-0.0370170511,
-0.0349297523,
-0.0499998219,
-0.0385020189,
-0.000631619,
-0.0121752946,
-0.0435127988,
0.0147160478,
0.0296205115,
-0.0117941173,
0.0150359143,
0.0312793218,
0.0458180718,
-0.012562478,
0.0325851366,
0.039242696,
-0.0407926776,
-0.0413364619,
0.0277962983,
0.0151028447,
0.0080323424,
0.0062305136,
0.0757390782,
-0.0314923339,
-0.0247859415,
0.0063297651,
-0.0324403532,
-0.003106694,
-0.0496633761,
0.0016545712,
0.0027282753,
0.0382613353,
-0.0408753119,
0.0371101871,
0.0262178276,
-0.01715599,
0.0071926694,
0.0045754123,
-0.0147362687,
0.0443785898,
-0.0152421268,
-0.0084891291,
-0.0091462359,
-0.0060118642,
0.0269705132,
-0.0551778227,
-0.0060669747,
0.0428760983,
2.708e-7,
0.0083865188,
0.0074177473,
0.0318201482,
-0.0271585323,
0.0141392574,
0.0413827449,
-0.0279445369,
0.0238611251,
-0.0126216505,
-0.0487891547,
0.0017777911,
0.0521150716,
-0.0103251217,
0.0209047981,
-0.0859403983,
0.0280404259,
0.0133436564,
-0.0112478109,
-0.0303822458,
0.0083003994,
0.0350482799,
0.0888462514,
0.0000789634,
0.0012663323,
-0.0015726555,
-0.0205367822,
0.0468394272,
0.013067212,
-0.0333695225,
-0.0101691475,
-0.0422559418,
0.0312330686,
0.0236914195,
0.0407227091,
-0.0079111401,
0.0445780195,
0.0246116426,
0.0072079487,
-0.0366113074,
-0.0120236687,
0.0076726684,
-0.0056957067,
-0.0016143991,
-0.0365247354,
0.1039750427,
-0.0595718212,
-0.0145787979,
0.0100915935,
-0.0501107275,
0.0542374663,
0.0271186866,
0.0005885881,
-0.0720415339,
0.0617949925,
0.0398683436,
-0.0128418384,
-0.0164110586,
-0.0214614589,
-0.0070571359,
0.0033974634,
-0.0144551918,
0.0174997095,
0.0020212538,
0.0042658844,
0.0339019373,
-0.012485194,
0.0186470095,
1.906584453e-34,
0.0064043826,
-0.0062859263,
0.0014313238,
-0.0362630822,
-0.000708285,
-0.0407073759,
-0.050502643,
-0.0231694337,
0.0137182781,
-0.0191231724,
0.0060925242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16356v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16356v1 | Evaluation of Instruction-Following Ability for Large Language Models on Story-Ending Generation | 2024-06-24T06:53:36 | 2024-06-24T06:53:36 | Rem Hida, Junki Ohmura, Toshiyuki Sekiya | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable
performance across various benchmark tasks. While providing instructions to
LLMs for guiding their generations is user-friendly, assessing their
instruction-following capabilities is still unclarified due to a lack of
evaluation metrics. In this paper, we focus on evaluating the
instruction-following ability of LLMs in the context of story-ending
generation, which requires diverse and context-specific instructions. We
propose an automatic evaluation pipeline that utilizes a machine reading
comprehension (MRC) model to determine whether the generated story-ending
reflects instruction. Our findings demonstrate that our proposed metric aligns
with human evaluation. Furthermore, our experiments confirm that recent
open-source LLMs can achieve instruction-following performance close to
GPT-3.5, as assessed through automatic evaluation. | [
0.0214658305,
0.0192710496,
-0.0127840647,
0.0285105165,
-0.0190834552,
0.0243703201,
0.0113376398,
-0.0335555822,
0.0217746645,
-0.007988682,
0.0033734292,
-0.0166224279,
-0.0125492103,
0.0349999517,
0.0209574867,
-0.0561261922,
0.0355908163,
-0.0411774702,
-0.0136414068,
0.0258362368,
0.0020958327,
0.0389686078,
-0.0099338237,
0.0588924587,
0.0458528101,
-0.0440874398,
-0.0046187821,
0.0192551818,
0.0431891195,
-0.0337170921,
-0.0045512682,
-0.0071395137,
0.0093799066,
0.0055626598,
0.0000017359,
-0.0558687374,
-0.0157059636,
-0.0084889773,
-0.0168710016,
0.0247274749,
0.0474878922,
-0.0127790496,
-0.0219113212,
0.0152305961,
0.018233696,
0.0291697346,
0.0193898231,
0.0216302183,
0.0854742005,
0.0789899155,
0.0119683836,
-0.0353512838,
0.0172873829,
-0.014837943,
0.0239432584,
-0.053563267,
-0.028134698,
0.0164479483,
0.0464870781,
-0.0013622729,
-0.0021995003,
0.0507574342,
0.0494038314,
-0.0173347592,
-0.0308335591,
0.0430064872,
0.0163525995,
0.034019962,
-0.0397316478,
0.0713732541,
0.0294575356,
-0.0070832628,
-0.0181441288,
-0.0157114957,
0.0088007916,
-0.0012076224,
-0.0485561118,
0.0389686078,
-0.0059430925,
0.0092896838,
0.0154121919,
0.0011806033,
0.0166699812,
0.0083957044,
0.0193022247,
0.0680789053,
0.0361256227,
-0.0168448407,
-0.0278919414,
0.0175563619,
-0.0363723561,
-0.0558100119,
0.0347034782,
0.0492871739,
-0.0440618694,
0.0158592332,
-0.083817631,
0.0409939885,
-0.0070576812,
-0.007885444,
0.0703804642,
0.0517207347,
0.0091887005,
0.0288594682,
-0.0119176544,
0.0740938634,
-0.0076647829,
-0.0191260576,
-0.040590629,
0.0311411526,
-0.0384582393,
-0.0080157807,
-0.0383096114,
0.0064991964,
-0.0546596386,
-0.0449831299,
-0.0372870415,
0.0459421016,
0.0373296216,
0.0084213493,
-0.0151700005,
0.0002176297,
-0.0341741964,
-0.0242137164,
-0.0200371929,
0.0206285715,
-0.057020355,
-0.0209268797,
0.0414545871,
0.0045060785,
-0.021927001,
0.0073126657,
-0.0155671798,
-0.0166829936,
0.0152815804,
0.0589829572,
-0.0251456052,
-0.0115551036,
-0.0643663481,
-0.053673014,
-0.0055466043,
-0.0801825151,
-0.0499887019,
-0.0288980808,
0.0183831565,
0.0199644975,
0.0274180919,
-0.0112844687,
-0.0003151624,
0.0212426353,
-0.0117152156,
0.0156358685,
0.0245706737,
0.0164074823,
0.0164270606,
0.0114496816,
-0.004749618,
0.0489153154,
0.0752799734,
0.0454272218,
0.0395553559,
0.0142918741,
0.0038470235,
0.033001963,
-0.0283670444,
0.0003666866,
-0.0105806915,
-0.0020146549,
-0.0341034606,
0.0729742423,
0.0492498726,
0.0599803366,
-0.0176478382,
0.0066109658,
0.0889025182,
0.0279539209,
0.0356204845,
0.0131011633,
0.1269452125,
0.043134734,
0.0057236981,
0.0744159967,
-0.046222765,
0.0180953871,
-0.0041978848,
0.0502811708,
0.0101003507,
0.0089826016,
-0.0116073163,
-0.0249806065,
0.0101568867,
0.0187289752,
-0.0375500023,
-0.0083495947,
0.0034367547,
0.0038776556,
-0.1066120267,
-0.0122402851,
-0.0046967259,
-0.0557860658,
0.0276863035,
-0.031011682,
0.0536772944,
0.1021377519,
0.0733745694,
0.0224553104,
-0.0516770035,
-0.0005628403,
0.0068291775,
0.0427127182,
0.0154925035,
-0.021842476,
0.0308525246,
-0.0496400222,
0.009029517,
-0.0135800643,
0.0031733327,
0.0146834059,
0.0060663638,
0.0112406714,
0.0202680044,
-0.0381878577,
-0.0498572253,
0.0464067236,
-0.0525010861,
-0.0230642837,
-0.0306478366,
0.012209448,
-0.0230138693,
0.0072432067,
-0.0207003709,
-0.0141457561,
0.0133092357,
-0.0129325166,
0.0123542128,
0.0364249609,
-0.0783931985,
-0.0362163894,
-0.0061704479,
-0.0403841324,
-0.0238891989,
0.0095913503,
0.0147801666,
-0.0396361835,
-0.0033252076,
-0.0613716841,
0.0336624682,
-0.0335645117,
0.0470790341,
-0.006042344,
-0.0413119271,
-0.0271565486,
0.0225093383,
-0.0068866061,
-0.0014278342,
0.045308847,
0.0139324665,
-0.0346011594,
-0.0278273672,
-0.0132760331,
0.0087333713,
0.0308913067,
-0.0161750913,
0.0192575026,
0.015222393,
-0.0326003879,
-0.0521041192,
-0.0676967874,
0.0546097346,
-0.011376421,
0.0186384041,
0.0533261001,
-0.0160218943,
-0.0399229527,
0.0146612478,
-0.0055659087,
-0.0165329278,
0.0144413244,
-0.0160586722,
0.0310456026,
0.0294161402,
-0.0264101475,
-0.0341372676,
0.011385601,
-0.0085035358,
0.0325406119,
0.0451348089,
0.0460924245,
-0.102203384,
0.0347259715,
0.0047785556,
-0.0115259737,
-0.0116776861,
-0.0592122227,
0.0328971297,
0.0237433277,
0.0805444047,
0.0750138089,
0.0096544316,
0.0206012204,
0.0476281866,
-0.041562479,
-0.0345085226,
0.0226546489,
-0.002360452,
-0.0287701823,
-0.0353005603,
-0.0533603132,
0.0086936392,
0.0784205645,
0.0162775777,
0.0249569826,
-0.0551325902,
0.0001058238,
-0.028199302,
-0.0409808271,
-0.0057363282,
-0.0222189426,
-0.0368594304,
0.0205241647,
-0.028947534,
-0.0424320325,
0.0980897471,
-0.0602709837,
-0.0366348848,
-0.0442713723,
0.0062171845,
-0.0512067452,
0.0621680692,
-0.0005361494,
0.0276308022,
-0.0285191294,
-0.0464984477,
-0.0511349253,
0.0171828829,
0.0093549844,
0.0071466109,
0.0395139977,
-0.0725455657,
-0.0423267446,
0.0267419629,
0.0134837888,
-0.0418659635,
-0.0030026471,
-0.0145438705,
-0.0186658818,
0.0449350178,
-0.0376511067,
-0.0473607443,
0.0269200411,
0.0276324973,
0.0291466583,
-0.0412295051,
-0.0250920001,
-0.03294985,
0.0121688498,
0.0668864623,
-0.0155580677,
-0.0005279721,
-0.0877657011,
0.0773459971,
0.0233993754,
0.0252927151,
-0.0038224822,
0.0102095557,
0.0208811481,
0.0518264063,
-0.0488710441,
-0.0010413599,
0.0291822106,
0.0943583101,
-0.1015888453,
-0.0201169588,
0.1260928214,
0.0216707438,
-0.0259117763,
-0.0011328997,
0.0136482297,
0.0422515757,
-0.0009627587,
0.0170587599,
-0.0704333112,
-0.0365896299,
0.0153575977,
0.0685299784,
-0.0007816586,
-0.0269646626,
-0.032381136,
-0.0802783668,
0.0578197129,
0.0253140703,
-0.0453313403,
-0.0499600843,
0.0200712141,
-0.0018784079,
0.0100277038,
0.0352318212,
0.0260381456,
-0.0526877046,
-0.0056378441,
-0.0244209822,
-0.0222925134,
-0.0266214814,
0.0103268996,
-0.0580126904,
0.0523950085,
0.0960649922,
0.0102550471,
0.009591301,
0.0144123528,
-0.0011861894,
-0.0214012954,
-0.0012976986,
0.0114469528,
0.0431904197,
-0.0530843027,
-0.0038397715,
-0.0344572477,
0.0360080265,
0.0353501104,
-0.0017906191,
0.0264118761,
0.0428101197,
-0.0046100714,
-0.0574050583,
-0.02342676,
0.0525220856,
0.000130273,
0.0940032154,
0.0576590821,
-0.0817028061,
-0.0411772169,
-0.0262963064,
-0.0034933479,
-0.0887340158,
-0.0088406783,
0.0029969248,
-0.0436422713,
0.0206154119,
-0.0714352801,
-0.0896386802,
0.0477247089,
0.0147526236,
0.0281661861,
-0.0001388683,
0.0186856557,
-0.0182197317,
-0.0199816972,
0.0101943528,
-0.0115804411,
0.0139666544,
-0.1106245294,
-0.0165643599,
0.0224788748,
-0.0367358699,
-0.0077617322,
0.0621690415,
-0.0669942051,
-0.0486352071,
-0.0104081463,
0.0220681094,
0.0210726075,
0.0438663326,
-0.0041388222,
-0.0609352887,
0.0015003661,
-0.0315235443,
-0.0294397268,
0.0434729829,
0.0024095373,
0.0175339207,
-0.0185604375,
0.0232287589,
0.0027715063,
0.013020332,
-0.0366665833,
0.0665506646,
-0.0060967617,
-0.0274101291,
0.0219142977,
-0.0043389061,
-0.0400316045,
-0.0470295548,
-0.010307692,
-0.0573217943,
0.0043945615,
-0.0295865703,
-0.0049179285,
-0.063794136,
0.0129223252,
0.0460754149,
-0.0283966996,
-0.0198059473,
-0.0126909874,
-0.044719927,
0.0143773975,
-0.0636869147,
0.0218681581,
-0.0143236956,
0.017359877,
0.0300835799,
0.0070555094,
-0.036088679,
-0.0051223217,
-0.0393972322,
0.0630285516,
0.0125928316,
0.0974774882,
0.0097697228,
-0.0100720683,
0.0163960736,
0.0573993772,
-0.036297325,
0.0012881971,
-0.020813439,
0.0374414772,
0.0375523828,
0.0090652965,
0.0816321969,
-0.0260145292,
0.0059332983,
-0.0227279887,
0.0310111865,
-0.0084615285,
-0.0159022678,
-0.0356617756,
0.0342493132,
-0.0008267806,
0.0128683262,
0.0385492668,
0.0026852519,
0.0450915806,
-0.0133778341,
0.0049425862,
-0.0340072289,
-0.0283527877,
-0.0066601578,
0.012504952,
-0.0028292874,
0.0030499201,
-0.0534482226,
-0.0422668532,
-0.0298614148,
0.0391043425,
0.0140090259,
-0.0386845358,
-0.0020408281,
0.0311593711,
-0.0342710875,
-0.0208562482,
-0.039357435,
-0.0070222518,
-0.0043934109,
-0.0163890626,
-0.0417310521,
-5.490747337e-33,
-0.0594453588,
-0.0212866459,
0.0294522885,
-0.0246276297,
-0.0521756336,
-0.0026537746,
-0.0524524786,
-0.0144512495,
0.0384093523,
0.0113093397,
0.0182025861,
-0.0069285668,
0.0036166024,
0.003800422,
-0.0152271306,
0.0304004084,
0.0593663603,
0.0096918745,
-0.0718196779,
0.0397387557,
0.0034858305,
0.0257887915,
0.0184167437,
-0.0146259824,
0.0216295496,
-0.0457803085,
-0.0434359126,
0.000891389,
0.0229785815,
0.0548771992,
-0.0086239185,
-0.0002908853,
0.0078865401,
-0.0170846432,
-0.0339963622,
0.0226930697,
-0.0404382981,
0.0093018226,
0.0471794344,
-0.0098942211,
-0.0466848947,
-0.0450355597,
0.0096418494,
-0.0282441024,
-0.0000058709,
-0.0181739014,
0.0252366904,
-0.0102625871,
0.0359997936,
0.0206534546,
-0.0737478286,
0.0142511921,
-0.0257302132,
-0.0677466542,
-0.0208780505,
0.0579501465,
0.0111244824,
0.0033036615,
-0.0046145711,
0.0211589634,
0.0476398133,
0.0152116995,
0.0442919657,
0.0098924562,
-0.0374938361,
0.0414924808,
0.0099133998,
0.0007229088,
-0.031434685,
0.0252657719,
0.0111758588,
0.0168601144,
0.0174909588,
0.0095001552,
0.0054120673,
0.0281288959,
-0.0164471455,
0.0531666316,
0.0088030146,
0.0303700939,
0.0249668807,
-0.0126361763,
-0.0574993268,
0.0010352993,
-0.0390532538,
-0.0245554559,
-0.0129626039,
-0.0383698158,
0.0609340481,
-0.0085768662,
-0.0359732173,
-0.021184627,
0.0295160059,
-0.009992661,
0.0383266397,
0.007840679,
-0.0538860857,
0.0391525403,
-0.0093127033,
0.0554120801,
-0.0308573917,
0.0049144547,
0.029964162,
-0.0175575837,
0.0275134388,
-0.008936163,
-0.014986489,
0.046537187,
-0.0309180859,
0.024986824,
-0.0321320146,
0.0324272923,
-0.0316408463,
-0.0163500495,
0.0168380551,
-0.0134262498,
-0.0299619213,
0.0449441001,
-0.0246497262,
-0.0025111439,
-0.040110901,
-0.0263976995,
0.0046187779,
0.0335986316,
-0.0520849153,
0.0305921752,
0.0007659421,
0.0239551608,
-0.0119334003,
-0.0420409963,
0.0048901555,
0.0287050288,
2.444e-7,
-0.0097101526,
0.0321324319,
0.0446077622,
0.070120886,
-0.0401603654,
0.0096566509,
-0.0190764647,
-0.0009470159,
0.0590608157,
0.0036543738,
0.0281829368,
0.0267510805,
0.0601524562,
0.0060378215,
-0.0819412842,
-0.0051495666,
-0.0242672618,
0.0388344489,
-0.0612782799,
-0.0318219736,
0.056005381,
0.0094696777,
0.0085918047,
0.0168379359,
0.0271434095,
-0.0402089879,
0.0369758904,
-0.0207010377,
-0.0323589966,
0.0346790478,
-0.0115495715,
0.0118030878,
-0.0290500298,
-0.0153324055,
0.0065690265,
0.0164137073,
0.0099773714,
0.0904481858,
0.0227791779,
-0.023565216,
0.0159458239,
-0.0061053997,
-0.005207133,
-0.0411344171,
0.0477701463,
-0.0349261388,
-0.0023991272,
0.0032331222,
-0.0195128024,
-0.0360005386,
-0.0194727015,
-0.044150807,
-0.0406490341,
0.0382132716,
0.0146991555,
-0.0397454426,
0.0106431572,
-0.0381205119,
-0.0200373027,
0.031233253,
-0.0332093015,
-0.0480218567,
-0.0492734723,
-0.0248666611,
-0.0155697009,
-0.0800815001,
-0.0062414766,
2.201648114e-34,
0.0212755762,
-0.0149041982,
0.0401893519,
0.0358125493,
0.0478968099,
0.0245645139,
-0.0053533199,
0.0049662474,
0.0205798149,
-0.0712525845,
-0.0487485453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16342v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16342v1 | ADVSCORE: A Metric for the Evaluation and Creation of Adversarial Benchmarks | 2024-06-24T06:27:47 | 2024-06-24T06:27:47 | Yoo Yeon Sung, Eve Fleisig, Ishani Mondal, Jordan Lee Boyd-Graber | cs.CL | cs.CL | Adversarial benchmarks validate model abilities by providing samples that
fool models but not humans. However, despite the proliferation of datasets that
claim to be adversarial, there does not exist an established metric to evaluate
how adversarial these datasets are. To address this lacuna, we introduce
ADVSCORE, a metric which quantifies how adversarial and discriminative an
adversarial dataset is and exposes the features that make data adversarial. We
then use ADVSCORE to underpin a dataset creation pipeline that incentivizes
writing a high-quality adversarial dataset. As a proof of concept, we use
ADVSCORE to collect an adversarial question answering (QA) dataset, ADVQA, from
our pipeline. The high-quality questions in ADVQA surpasses three adversarial
benchmarks across domains at fooling several models but not humans. We validate
our result based on difficulty estimates from 9,347 human responses on four
datasets and predictions from three models. Moreover, ADVSCORE uncovers which
adversarial tactics used by human writers fool models (e.g., GPT-4) but not
humans. Through ADVSCORE and its analyses, we offer guidance on revealing
language model vulnerabilities and producing reliable adversarial examples. | [
0.0353353582,
0.0831215158,
-0.0096741151,
0.0481637307,
-0.015900027,
0.0141139785,
-0.0029634917,
0.0044514816,
0.0229887385,
-0.0401636809,
-0.0372307263,
-0.0145563371,
0.015027551,
0.01334331,
0.0573977903,
-0.0269878451,
0.0338853598,
-0.0180140398,
0.0051517002,
-0.0217602346,
-0.0075383801,
-0.0079695024,
0.0060947058,
0.0291290451,
0.0279003233,
-0.0423143245,
0.0246376749,
0.0139145451,
0.0240636505,
-0.0153742889,
0.0483092554,
0.0460383333,
-0.0214663949,
0.0986334309,
0.0000017079,
-0.022885723,
-0.0071150456,
0.0186293181,
-0.0485825799,
0.0304559357,
0.0016981828,
-0.0239382125,
0.0013474453,
0.0282285083,
-0.0500841439,
-0.0125316437,
0.0272473283,
0.0268228576,
0.0630057752,
0.0890085846,
-0.0055471756,
-0.01546924,
0.0453566313,
-0.0501681082,
-0.0180818979,
-0.0781542957,
0.0233290475,
-0.0027217017,
-0.0296486467,
0.0065879798,
0.001864183,
0.0163545106,
0.0577235222,
0.0399645083,
-0.0386183858,
0.0233867876,
-0.0267303046,
0.0235809349,
0.00663521,
0.0778334513,
-0.0115265567,
-0.0280303396,
-0.0055180681,
0.0185049064,
0.0146768922,
0.0044932519,
-0.0294064116,
-0.0177211184,
0.0107734157,
-0.0290035717,
-0.019927945,
0.008376658,
0.0544129722,
0.03631448,
0.0329015516,
0.015106922,
0.0269890148,
-0.0025649711,
0.0135184051,
-0.0187184643,
-0.0367656387,
-0.0462702699,
-0.0007571363,
-0.0061005489,
-0.0221657772,
0.0137024885,
-0.0828788951,
-0.0349740721,
0.0546553805,
-0.021815788,
0.0487232022,
-0.0136148361,
-0.0062114368,
0.0557214543,
-0.0363734178,
0.0604588836,
-0.028654838,
0.0636039078,
-0.0201724898,
-0.0206471998,
-0.0015835948,
-0.0397398323,
-0.0090498161,
-0.01706204,
-0.0032275293,
0.0205447022,
-0.0288850944,
0.0036126042,
-0.0416372195,
0.0268608388,
-0.0218019001,
0.0477272011,
-0.0231239144,
-0.0057446267,
-0.0113550052,
-0.0337700471,
-0.0650136545,
0.0071387268,
0.0182831436,
-0.0968186632,
-0.0397031121,
0.0115990667,
-0.0540536791,
-0.0421330146,
0.0114250612,
0.1042078882,
0.0114256851,
-0.0291816704,
-0.0091928402,
-0.019002907,
0.0035739806,
-0.0463083163,
0.0301858764,
-0.0470172316,
0.0139442887,
-0.0030177732,
-0.0242672339,
-0.0806307569,
-0.0204075426,
0.006300563,
0.0158074871,
0.088087976,
0.0136649087,
-0.0365643129,
0.0406120382,
0.036545936,
-0.0128129553,
0.0816895589,
-0.0071045756,
0.0542951487,
0.0638398379,
0.0093947938,
0.045740895,
0.0279101599,
0.0658836439,
0.03437775,
-0.0041403952,
0.0637311861,
0.0008400435,
0.0067635733,
-0.0094994232,
0.0224901382,
0.0005526872,
-0.1018283665,
0.0796774998,
0.0079315482,
-0.0441150181,
0.0261338819,
-0.004470096,
-0.0263376217,
0.0086098555,
0.0033873122,
-0.0585455075,
0.0356767066,
-0.0652138516,
-0.0410761274,
0.0136802802,
0.0133548258,
-0.0298185293,
-0.0507385656,
0.0012890535,
0.0027235192,
0.0333677605,
0.0278676394,
0.0120358635,
0.0290958248,
-0.0512716584,
0.0058650393,
-0.0101310303,
-0.0147589026,
-0.0278032254,
-0.0656956062,
0.0018655127,
-0.0136254039,
0.0857865512,
-0.0414458737,
0.0155906482,
-0.0289804526,
0.0420754813,
0.0109546883,
0.0549919866,
-0.0168084744,
0.0264991764,
-0.0070744092,
-0.0237294696,
-0.0654662102,
0.0145400297,
0.0242313277,
0.0666057542,
0.0046118386,
0.0117923059,
-0.0629695132,
-0.0173824988,
0.0451608151,
-0.007854308,
-0.0540485904,
0.0122562526,
0.0213464275,
0.0345493853,
0.0010362996,
-0.0095865931,
0.0271550957,
0.0589631498,
-0.0045607081,
-0.0172804147,
-0.0295541398,
0.0097611854,
-0.0024965142,
0.0086798584,
-0.0603469945,
-0.0405765697,
0.1175976619,
-0.0377059877,
0.0148243438,
0.0293031316,
-0.0421047769,
-0.0108646937,
-0.0068190154,
-0.026020715,
-0.0119305616,
0.042968262,
-0.0146529321,
0.0670002848,
-0.0174926128,
0.0366071686,
-0.0068895211,
0.0322969332,
0.0130913006,
-0.0167538971,
-0.0009058939,
0.0232145339,
-0.0437475257,
0.0254901908,
0.0344065912,
-0.0199640803,
-0.0475649238,
-0.0033751442,
-0.032892447,
-0.0032287766,
-0.0336586162,
0.0263188649,
0.0408102162,
-0.0268634465,
0.0092265448,
-0.0084257768,
-0.0479456373,
-0.0380200036,
-0.0091106333,
0.027426647,
0.0173991732,
-0.005457724,
0.010037072,
-0.0217441954,
-0.011848093,
0.0022922589,
0.0668219253,
-0.0165110249,
0.0410327092,
0.0099017425,
-0.0114221834,
-0.0065313503,
0.0471615791,
-0.031686414,
-0.0646459907,
0.0340186805,
0.0434628576,
-0.04411887,
0.0971856266,
0.0224184077,
0.0289266221,
0.0232783668,
0.0554255918,
-0.0060903919,
-0.0031610685,
0.0106665241,
-0.015330784,
-0.0260591079,
-0.0377022512,
0.0183497295,
0.0226685926,
0.0240628254,
-0.0060684355,
-0.0301234424,
0.1051368117,
-0.027771797,
-0.0669170246,
-0.0383030549,
0.0173353348,
-0.0181031246,
0.0049748463,
-0.0392533988,
-0.055603832,
0.0657316074,
-0.0178718306,
-0.0062427814,
-0.02332565,
-0.0301353168,
0.0054961266,
0.0568787493,
0.0028299061,
0.0083919559,
0.0074515217,
0.0262710061,
-0.0750306845,
-0.0465836748,
0.0386634991,
-0.0326301754,
0.0127986632,
-0.0135173835,
-0.0015226953,
-0.0063168453,
-0.0335465521,
-0.08267124,
-0.0413235761,
-0.0128100747,
0.0322389267,
0.0116148489,
-0.0321460366,
-0.0349736847,
-0.0601161011,
0.0081465114,
0.007648685,
-0.03876229,
-0.0066275485,
-0.0082948366,
0.0661402196,
0.0835454017,
0.0044639921,
0.0353468247,
-0.0176391639,
0.039300818,
0.0695327446,
0.0051872814,
0.0293865371,
-0.0163100399,
-0.0195056107,
-0.0038150284,
-0.0041979817,
0.0209512189,
0.0084859515,
0.0511441864,
-0.0355047844,
-0.0031232713,
0.0478388295,
0.0127586154,
0.0104847774,
0.0205762815,
0.0267397501,
0.020007059,
0.0222450271,
-0.0039473409,
-0.062222749,
-0.0357348099,
0.0044546342,
0.0700283349,
-0.0248473901,
-0.0195825286,
-0.0239901319,
-0.0949500874,
-0.0002749676,
-0.0214971192,
-0.0472027548,
-0.030112043,
-0.0524167493,
-0.0225898903,
-0.0381078087,
0.0269708224,
-0.02586741,
0.0382900685,
0.0011154232,
-0.0161623135,
0.0141994059,
-0.0255323742,
0.044230476,
-0.0083334511,
0.0234999917,
0.0848395601,
0.0559875555,
-0.0214597918,
-0.0358246602,
0.0010570296,
-0.0522721,
-0.0392676219,
0.0228784122,
0.096105881,
-0.0108281272,
-0.0270067565,
-0.0173614826,
0.0637172908,
-0.031200001,
0.0023151871,
0.0280933399,
0.025301965,
0.0230203923,
-0.0250890963,
-0.0230996776,
-0.0201074462,
0.0087124323,
0.0693565831,
0.012282053,
-0.0313572325,
-0.0298867561,
-0.0685255677,
0.0146348085,
-0.0701089501,
-0.0500950627,
0.0151747968,
0.0218351167,
0.001212227,
-0.0625056699,
-0.0534004718,
0.0062170788,
0.0043867836,
-0.0262641609,
-0.0000038501,
-0.0765706822,
0.0254047774,
-0.0405157954,
0.0166259706,
-0.0203677937,
0.0492332876,
-0.0339291729,
-0.0264954455,
-0.017037224,
-0.0245680269,
-0.0393869057,
0.0399166122,
-0.0658237711,
-0.0439022481,
0.0095485765,
0.052266784,
0.0149429627,
0.0217420477,
-0.0293908902,
-0.0663835183,
0.0466154963,
0.0428802073,
-0.0192220192,
-0.01427049,
0.0887730867,
-0.0402149893,
0.0080626709,
0.0462179892,
-0.0522149466,
-0.0040265112,
0.0499921553,
-0.0291992314,
-0.0121296234,
0.0164767392,
0.0198377278,
0.0098247435,
0.0403697714,
-0.0136011411,
-0.0160934776,
0.0356485099,
-0.000019076,
0.0005830466,
-0.0222192649,
-0.0119829634,
-0.0070200847,
0.0306673329,
-0.0173276998,
0.0035498592,
0.0204200707,
-0.0079213753,
0.0148885138,
-0.0376464799,
0.0207033623,
0.0341518894,
0.0624874532,
0.0116595561,
-0.0047653392,
-0.0178109426,
0.0142682437,
-0.0176135059,
0.0471083261,
-0.0096545015,
0.0157402158,
0.021179514,
-0.0019336723,
0.0230971444,
0.0238449462,
-0.0752327293,
-0.0408352613,
-0.0311921611,
0.0251984689,
0.0315147042,
0.0057783769,
0.0173614584,
-0.0217564534,
-0.0277739,
-0.0161073208,
-0.0377121307,
0.0122618144,
-0.0101974513,
0.0474727936,
0.0199311133,
-0.0155415898,
0.0162765812,
0.0888932347,
0.0401696749,
0.0526974835,
0.0226082634,
-0.0156396814,
-0.036144942,
-0.0492021069,
0.0257059895,
-0.0152308298,
0.0041699475,
0.0065084728,
-0.0336808115,
-0.0960177183,
-0.0386584923,
0.0170386396,
0.0071788207,
0.0124309156,
0.0037896137,
0.0479039438,
-0.010644435,
0.0176259018,
-0.0557215773,
0.0417295359,
-0.0204812624,
-0.049829606,
-0.0051914905,
-5.626129021e-33,
0.0167903528,
-0.054068543,
-0.0246179588,
-0.0539421216,
0.0356670544,
0.0261112545,
-0.024758609,
-0.0174062867,
-0.0650220662,
0.0152508365,
-0.0076243556,
0.0132123102,
-0.0134688085,
0.0211560521,
-0.0367885232,
-0.0722921193,
0.0359076411,
-0.0447609834,
-0.059580043,
0.0162097085,
0.0143467588,
0.010654889,
0.0305288918,
-0.0372916833,
0.0629738718,
-0.0254648533,
-0.0501843393,
0.0190808587,
-0.0264573582,
0.0485065877,
-0.0060365582,
0.0484832488,
0.0088546854,
-0.0253190883,
0.0087534338,
0.0014577742,
-0.0268211029,
-0.0273545664,
0.0051907632,
0.0016844145,
-0.0681700706,
-0.0255854391,
0.0276753902,
-0.0304558799,
-0.003367099,
-0.020530263,
-0.0044194083,
-0.025552433,
0.0100549264,
-0.0235965531,
-0.0155044887,
0.020457115,
-0.0326870903,
-0.0358795598,
0.0044603837,
0.0648319572,
0.0382652245,
0.0002018836,
-0.05881254,
0.0039598704,
0.0030080592,
0.0125367539,
0.0631825104,
-0.0041536372,
0.0185075756,
0.0467854664,
0.0559458137,
0.0125526227,
0.0015487302,
-0.0091226632,
-0.0032490811,
0.0260192137,
0.1221610829,
0.1029641256,
0.0617355742,
-0.0305810347,
-0.0605710074,
0.0292526372,
-0.0157485213,
0.0030507247,
0.0121264355,
-0.0000179495,
-0.0517574176,
-0.0008103916,
-0.0449144803,
-0.0441808924,
-0.0213187896,
-0.0235758126,
0.0292352922,
0.0018515257,
-0.0530408509,
-0.0139746694,
-0.0198743735,
-0.0608400777,
0.0259100161,
0.0784769207,
-0.0129403286,
-0.0147157665,
0.036436528,
0.0166119207,
-0.0126374261,
0.0465129055,
0.0430598892,
-0.0102175483,
0.0501971059,
-0.0109261498,
0.0394154415,
0.0186706446,
-0.0291191675,
0.0049158465,
-0.0431361757,
0.0598284416,
0.0156892966,
0.0087403841,
0.0187821109,
-0.0145278098,
-0.0209202133,
-0.0194169451,
0.0173876099,
0.0098722838,
-0.0360279977,
0.038851615,
-0.0152903665,
0.0210462306,
-0.0335981548,
-0.0502900481,
-0.0261661932,
0.0044598794,
0.0333418138,
-0.0715408176,
0.0086446805,
-0.0211481117,
2.357e-7,
0.0111833569,
0.0256194584,
0.0087001696,
0.0388937257,
0.0336360671,
0.0709900036,
0.002140136,
0.0503365174,
-0.0322883353,
-0.0255801473,
-0.0353571549,
0.0007495784,
0.0743396133,
0.0643738061,
-0.0397219732,
0.0139907114,
-0.0931909606,
0.0007705981,
-0.0270635635,
-0.0149119003,
0.0006744846,
0.0927222297,
0.0262147933,
-0.0208581742,
0.0054069478,
-0.0503274798,
0.0284139309,
-0.0374338552,
0.0185796171,
-0.0113548823,
0.0356623605,
0.0278112795,
0.031384062,
0.0018688664,
-0.0444826409,
-0.0161962826,
0.0268096589,
0.0293056499,
0.0132078826,
-0.0655809939,
-0.0419063531,
-0.0262827165,
0.016760923,
-0.0682784766,
0.1000036374,
-0.0036781128,
-0.0402910225,
-0.038376186,
-0.0174020678,
-0.0019043315,
0.0500246063,
-0.0269982684,
-0.0195389874,
0.0044271243,
-0.0142012136,
-0.0072730929,
0.042908445,
-0.0198728126,
-0.0265800003,
-0.0162343122,
-0.0200873408,
-0.0306493752,
-0.0274793077,
0.0135545861,
0.0240711439,
-0.0108278599,
0.0102552734,
2.020544612e-34,
0.0177290626,
-0.0234399252,
0.0279083773,
-0.0241479594,
0.0364723504,
-0.0162493177,
0.0409820601,
-0.0306493193,
0.0186361764,
-0.0139218783,
-0.024393959
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16341v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16341v1 | EHRCon: Dataset for Checking Consistency between Unstructured Notes and Structured Tables in Electronic Health Records | 2024-06-24T06:26:50 | 2024-06-24T06:26:50 | Yeonsu Kwon, Jiho Kim, Gyubok Lee, Seongsu Bae, Daeun Kyung, Wonchul Cha, Tom Pollard, Alistair Johnson, Edward Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Electronic Health Records (EHRs) are integral for storing comprehensive
patient medical records, combining structured data (e.g., medications) with
detailed clinical notes (e.g., physician notes). These elements are essential
for straightforward data retrieval and provide deep, contextual insights into
patient care. However, they often suffer from discrepancies due to unintuitive
EHR system designs and human errors, posing serious risks to patient safety. To
address this, we developed EHRCon, a new dataset and task specifically designed
to ensure data consistency between structured tables and unstructured notes in
EHRs. EHRCon was crafted in collaboration with healthcare professionals using
the MIMIC-III EHR dataset, and includes manual annotations of 3,943 entities
across 105 clinical notes checked against database entries for consistency.
EHRCon has two versions, one using the original MIMIC-III schema, and another
using the OMOP CDM schema, in order to increase its applicability and
generalizability. Furthermore, leveraging the capabilities of large language
models, we introduce CheckEHR, a novel framework for verifying the consistency
between clinical notes and database tables. CheckEHR utilizes an eight-stage
process and shows promising results in both few-shot and zero-shot settings.
The code is available at https://github.com/dustn1259/EHRCon. | [
0.0423230454,
0.0839917287,
-0.0058113923,
-0.0133896042,
-0.0016586039,
0.0556047149,
-0.0284439772,
0.0372280031,
0.0301498994,
0.0072990586,
0.0110369138,
-0.0541109666,
0.0063084355,
0.0277299695,
0.0072163776,
-0.0107075432,
0.0498427153,
0.0299771838,
0.0143544618,
0.0392955467,
0.006949944,
0.0002715737,
-0.0351000875,
0.0209984649,
0.0184261464,
0.0020605894,
-0.0212300308,
0.0401178636,
0.0032222522,
-0.0598469302,
0.0019283432,
0.0566743277,
-0.0306685418,
0.0231110174,
0.0000018974,
-0.0348274931,
-0.0410198271,
0.0378733873,
-0.0607663393,
-0.0340901315,
0.0255640633,
-0.0766658708,
-0.0204440821,
-0.0102884453,
-0.0028001349,
-0.0750059932,
0.0390961394,
0.0505274758,
0.0397387668,
0.071794495,
-0.0324199982,
0.0371991172,
0.0292615928,
-0.0038464721,
0.0590872206,
-0.0148380175,
0.047701098,
0.0388015583,
0.0165094957,
-0.0148798274,
0.0498562939,
0.0240963213,
-0.0210957155,
0.002425804,
-0.022525819,
0.0162868947,
-0.0444035083,
0.0275986306,
0.005632103,
0.0552553199,
0.0276603419,
0.0118144993,
0.0581688248,
-0.004421683,
-0.03806822,
-0.0017131752,
-0.01767282,
-0.0064675254,
-0.0441335067,
-0.0149326446,
-0.0026814116,
-0.0276467409,
0.0300142728,
-0.017559845,
-0.0292092953,
-0.0003934685,
0.0186017919,
-0.058571279,
-0.0083501646,
-0.0298986491,
0.0148901511,
-0.0701348335,
0.0250142794,
0.0442143716,
-0.0444037691,
-0.0023864093,
-0.0277440846,
-0.0355972312,
0.0999026522,
-0.0397476628,
0.0468338579,
0.0172000565,
-0.0179667287,
0.0337108485,
0.0071962248,
0.0154005904,
-0.0234443154,
0.0247475598,
-0.0077768401,
0.0062875105,
-0.0531548634,
0.0093225511,
-0.0163864456,
-0.0091803176,
-0.0071650622,
-0.0087191444,
-0.0537701175,
-0.0056283013,
-0.0285594594,
0.104225494,
0.0408444926,
-0.0066613574,
-0.0161303356,
0.0246643946,
-0.0256127287,
-0.0133079616,
0.009285382,
-0.005783841,
-0.0062344484,
-0.0454563871,
0.0166048016,
0.0132854581,
0.0391747579,
-0.013547115,
0.0217092112,
0.0413322188,
0.02953762,
0.01315316,
-0.0348814167,
-0.0603421703,
-0.0210614353,
-0.0363879651,
0.0089353621,
-0.0657019764,
0.0501796231,
-0.0102428589,
-0.024305433,
-0.0611592568,
0.0009794104,
0.0548681058,
-0.040363051,
0.0701409131,
-0.0852029845,
0.0010254369,
0.0012998277,
0.0041672923,
0.0033143584,
0.0058211302,
0.0069247619,
-0.0734101757,
0.0179010592,
0.0013194367,
0.0060917456,
0.0280053541,
0.0059666773,
-0.0236076266,
0.0198382493,
0.0453204736,
0.0456012674,
0.0528107397,
-0.0553583093,
0.0729771033,
-0.0077886432,
-0.0105805155,
0.0221434738,
0.0266887862,
0.0374794118,
0.0041031903,
-0.0046765455,
-0.0356530659,
0.0159251746,
0.0090613337,
-0.0306690503,
-0.0176208168,
0.0210344978,
0.0020803548,
0.0033063286,
-0.0336228646,
-0.0337735638,
-0.0208510943,
-0.0682309642,
0.0014580429,
-0.015368945,
-0.0475607552,
0.0285635144,
-0.0076753772,
-0.0313813835,
0.0536070541,
0.0210898742,
-0.0666872486,
-0.0495839752,
-0.0103953965,
-0.0073257592,
0.0926532596,
0.0504712388,
-0.0634859055,
-0.0490288921,
-0.0034060378,
0.0081659835,
-0.0011640323,
0.01820313,
-0.0489381664,
0.0033442234,
-0.0348400474,
-0.0110698165,
0.0543510318,
0.0265850089,
-0.0385895818,
0.0181906726,
0.0253047235,
-0.0021810045,
-0.0378228314,
-0.0375237949,
0.0382774323,
-0.0461513586,
-0.0026791047,
-0.0202251989,
0.010945092,
0.0180507433,
0.0437408909,
-0.0197507422,
0.0444454812,
0.0557623059,
-0.0141909262,
-0.0096502025,
-0.0084707607,
-0.007561978,
0.0166124851,
0.0404837728,
0.0010118589,
-0.0403664149,
-0.0560139976,
-0.0337496139,
-0.0403151363,
-0.0487366766,
-0.0240618531,
-0.0024991231,
-0.0128767695,
0.0388012938,
0.0498643741,
-0.0174778495,
-0.0223683603,
0.0091147274,
-0.0173854921,
0.0138121042,
0.0156803876,
-0.0689504519,
0.0453571714,
-0.0236348659,
-0.0030471503,
0.0258033965,
0.0074420101,
0.0385925919,
-0.0161950737,
0.0020601156,
-0.0572635308,
0.0019138436,
-0.111368835,
0.0097319884,
-0.0051255296,
0.0700711235,
0.0360817239,
0.0151812127,
0.0047549456,
-0.0289241802,
-0.0322364904,
-0.0331572108,
0.0138535621,
0.0130017921,
0.0410423167,
0.0171016715,
-0.0194100961,
-0.0328292176,
-0.0243844967,
-0.0602776334,
0.0244342517,
-0.01927476,
-0.0356720053,
-0.0361327976,
-0.0358145684,
-0.0039622756,
0.0080143837,
0.0176727902,
0.0281958096,
0.0068667131,
-0.0169298854,
0.0145586589,
0.0187373124,
-0.0424943157,
-0.0025400033,
0.0218698792,
-0.021288652,
-0.0167552847,
-0.0113938553,
0.0091847396,
0.0249127205,
0.0556438826,
-0.0460748523,
0.0020732936,
0.0368974097,
-0.0177215487,
0.0121275401,
-0.0273631569,
-0.025993783,
0.0014525759,
0.0706973374,
-0.0425509438,
0.0076448102,
0.0032323909,
0.0069340188,
-0.0171702523,
0.0259942822,
0.0672198087,
-0.0637304932,
0.0545045808,
-0.0220109597,
-0.0131914746,
-0.0315468721,
0.018108014,
-0.0040484485,
0.0029553522,
0.0159453657,
-0.017392721,
-0.002874986,
-0.0030659691,
0.0293457173,
-0.0385359935,
0.0679796562,
-0.0100237662,
0.050346721,
0.0033716857,
-0.0106002335,
-0.0258936584,
0.0058319573,
-0.0294496063,
0.0188698433,
-0.0110567454,
0.0026044599,
-0.0523224548,
0.01324871,
-0.0453338772,
0.0965414196,
0.0333529711,
-0.0228016414,
-0.0000710431,
0.0239782706,
0.0094945887,
-0.0333195478,
-0.0069025042,
-0.035311766,
0.0080770999,
0.0734715611,
0.0041826437,
0.0238876604,
-0.0014106535,
0.0129927499,
-0.016287446,
-0.0564540215,
0.0110137975,
0.0193244275,
-0.0201748628,
-0.0677671954,
-0.0125992019,
0.0771517232,
0.0188323986,
-0.0366203189,
-0.0003520253,
-0.0087089818,
-0.0338505879,
-0.0029870982,
0.0175659172,
-0.1050683483,
-0.0137847373,
-0.0006365608,
0.0062669571,
0.0194616187,
-0.0534818321,
0.0203776043,
-0.0323573016,
0.0351983048,
-0.0089210402,
-0.0621917248,
-0.0505542643,
-0.0423861891,
0.018197719,
-0.0109865712,
0.0185439214,
0.0395988822,
-0.034860488,
-0.0340471007,
-0.0093198549,
-0.057538271,
-0.0524391718,
0.0213114787,
-0.0828738287,
0.0635822266,
0.0721701011,
0.0254076999,
0.0185755305,
-0.0482324772,
0.0115492698,
0.0177455749,
-0.0291728694,
-0.0186346937,
0.0903292447,
-0.0064248713,
0.0001559238,
-0.0269904323,
0.0079938453,
-0.0483987518,
-0.0275028944,
-0.009255643,
0.0635263473,
-0.0394363217,
-0.0122618414,
-0.0346697867,
-0.0036321771,
0.0350208133,
0.0393033512,
0.0148779182,
0.0334850885,
-0.0441441499,
0.0201498754,
0.0345113352,
-0.0134723801,
0.035945002,
0.0916153193,
-0.0592045225,
-0.0146158291,
-0.050623782,
-0.027300071,
0.0222941358,
-0.010887038,
0.0103157805,
0.0133552402,
0.0404770114,
-0.0202924851,
-0.0796522573,
0.0105848992,
-0.0211458486,
0.020635603,
-0.0305142906,
-0.0425354615,
-0.0119060911,
0.0448176935,
-0.0035092048,
-0.0292216521,
-0.0273543354,
0.0034742532,
0.0261452086,
0.0173522606,
0.0224591345,
0.0014852649,
0.0166049171,
0.0031228797,
-0.0501796082,
0.0084589282,
-0.0488976128,
-0.0625395328,
-0.0239880458,
-0.057137087,
-0.0293656643,
0.0048527354,
-0.0145506766,
0.0009757873,
0.0061858888,
0.0282388739,
0.0163104348,
-0.0103215128,
0.0190847088,
0.0483451635,
0.0360428169,
0.039536804,
-0.0323268808,
-0.0296829063,
0.0470132381,
-0.0376888067,
-0.0119242249,
0.0029800499,
0.0163379852,
-0.0383069292,
-0.0168931335,
-0.0122392066,
0.0149354152,
-0.0601113625,
-0.0001545084,
-0.0539247803,
0.0094722882,
0.0178604368,
0.0061504641,
0.0305909868,
-0.048134692,
-0.0054487106,
0.0629680604,
0.0014941827,
0.0296313018,
-0.0320241414,
0.0270489529,
0.0104033789,
0.0309518203,
-0.02381639,
0.0472446717,
-0.016605841,
-0.0087142717,
-0.0320956521,
-0.0303677209,
0.0491261221,
0.0063684625,
0.0454223789,
-0.025778411,
-0.0032990368,
-0.0264861062,
0.0043923124,
0.0206422433,
0.025698578,
0.0137534151,
0.0221004076,
-0.0129477065,
-0.01601509,
0.0782960579,
0.0030735631,
0.0642597079,
-0.0019934624,
-0.0483051464,
-0.0416091233,
0.0011629412,
0.0456484072,
-0.0125650959,
-0.0719910562,
-0.067772612,
-0.0331783332,
-0.0429148339,
0.0618947186,
0.0787548572,
-0.0407286249,
0.0505239964,
0.0138137694,
0.0201986749,
0.0454680324,
-0.0067689633,
0.0038103778,
0.0098225921,
-0.0278753377,
-0.0417558774,
0.026847383,
-5.559927016e-33,
-0.000653767,
-0.0383069403,
0.0026612978,
-0.0348397754,
0.0243448354,
0.0061448002,
-0.0655739084,
-0.0257102828,
0.0197056662,
0.0313868932,
-0.0252819136,
0.0429702215,
0.0349646732,
0.0058327983,
0.0421050526,
-0.0449223481,
0.0345788933,
0.0285457522,
-0.0117228413,
0.0028526043,
0.014539999,
0.0214626864,
0.0267821699,
-0.0694266185,
0.0572686493,
-0.0141173741,
0.0114422143,
0.0087477062,
-0.0248224121,
0.0667011291,
-0.0468851589,
0.0239405669,
0.0301161744,
-0.0015141489,
-0.0193590056,
-0.0132528627,
-0.1392807066,
-0.022340307,
-0.0266066734,
-0.0223242957,
-0.0175602771,
-0.0358735286,
0.0355423503,
-0.0397675969,
-0.0128348311,
-0.0096945288,
0.0042805327,
-0.029327875,
-0.0200529601,
-0.0447245166,
-0.0264221132,
0.0665652156,
0.0063616163,
0.030384047,
0.0268015806,
-0.0038764197,
0.0064404206,
-0.0176725741,
-0.0700216666,
-0.0009369676,
-0.0008951068,
0.0172080416,
0.007081246,
-0.0370276645,
-0.0187206846,
0.0734107047,
0.017244054,
0.0138444947,
-0.0312689096,
0.0183970481,
-0.0214098673,
0.0422940813,
0.0142606823,
0.0197315365,
0.0497655496,
-0.0187099781,
-0.0848370716,
0.0827158242,
-0.0826276317,
0.0451274365,
-0.0236780234,
-0.0168131236,
-0.0448896438,
-0.0182513669,
-0.0104707917,
0.0112367487,
-0.050063923,
-0.0192844234,
0.0207470339,
-0.0040643197,
0.0058399392,
0.0274857786,
-0.0112840049,
-0.0226670299,
-0.0250455774,
-0.0118704364,
0.0173338279,
-0.0287583377,
-0.0395246595,
0.0050046239,
-0.0138617232,
-0.0401185639,
0.0397725143,
0.0022796926,
0.0591919087,
0.0523431525,
0.0675196201,
-0.0150190741,
-0.0673648641,
-0.0004627444,
0.0425562002,
0.0082322471,
-0.0475946106,
-0.0007615965,
0.0361201949,
0.0235692449,
0.0322436839,
0.0658614188,
0.0168805495,
-0.0085984711,
-0.0442573987,
0.031606745,
0.0272505209,
0.0269707236,
0.0132233854,
0.0025670854,
-0.0634898543,
0.0025120787,
0.030898856,
-0.0109991431,
0.0398602746,
0.0433747135,
2.564e-7,
0.0932138264,
0.0409576334,
0.077691257,
-0.0112495758,
0.0072096963,
-0.0087300865,
-0.0403569117,
-0.0168820396,
-0.0453254879,
-0.0239465553,
0.0716752857,
-0.0195713211,
0.0682697222,
0.0611309446,
-0.0169726312,
-0.052519653,
-0.0859460086,
-0.0403879881,
-0.0398341529,
-0.0065486711,
0.0698622391,
0.029463334,
-0.0697088242,
-0.028187681,
-0.0092843259,
0.0399999879,
0.0132470094,
-0.0191207826,
0.0444966517,
0.0106966794,
0.0083946791,
-0.0289344899,
0.0268128421,
0.0677859113,
-0.0148591101,
-0.0227957647,
-0.0015249875,
0.1099832654,
-0.0520514846,
0.0612734854,
0.0116833616,
-0.0602938533,
0.0209627207,
-0.0247920174,
0.0564249307,
-0.0243420918,
-0.0129536148,
0.0317510329,
-0.0457591303,
0.0020153462,
0.0610984601,
0.0289869029,
-0.0204094835,
0.0438245796,
0.0362445414,
0.0386505947,
-0.0186681729,
-0.0512646139,
0.0077657034,
0.0634930432,
-0.0058716671,
-0.0037485405,
0.0499772318,
-0.0330842808,
-0.0153227923,
-0.0996559486,
0.0117997983,
2.501332592e-34,
0.0191736892,
0.0251841117,
0.0070103761,
0.00277859,
0.0554282069,
-0.038540151,
0.0462264456,
0.0208314769,
-0.0231951345,
-0.0655652657,
-0.0112593006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16332v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16332v1 | DemoRank: Selecting Effective Demonstrations for Large Language Models in Ranking Task | 2024-06-24T06:10:13 | 2024-06-24T06:10:13 | Wenhan Liu, Yutao Zhu, Zhicheng Dou | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Recently, there has been increasing interest in applying large language
models (LLMs) as zero-shot passage rankers. However, few studies have explored
how to select appropriate in-context demonstrations for the passage ranking
task, which is the focus of this paper. Previous studies mainly apply a
demonstration retriever to retrieve demonstrations and use top-$k$
demonstrations for in-context learning (ICL). Although effective, this approach
overlooks the dependencies between demonstrations, leading to inferior
performance of few-shot ICL in the passage ranking task. In this paper, we
formulate the demonstration selection as a \textit{retrieve-then-rerank}
process and introduce the DemoRank framework. In this framework, we first use
LLM feedback to train a demonstration retriever and construct a novel
dependency-aware training samples to train a demonstration reranker to improve
few-shot ICL. The construction of such training samples not only considers
demonstration dependencies but also performs in an efficient way. Extensive
experiments demonstrate DemoRank's effectiveness in in-domain scenarios and
strong generalization to out-of-domain scenarios. Our codes are available
at~\url{https://github.com/8421BCD/DemoRank}. | [
0.0192882884,
0.0542989299,
0.0016510374,
0.0497016273,
-0.0233993754,
-0.0135806762,
0.0304388423,
0.0232743397,
0.0468733907,
-0.0578171313,
-0.016690569,
-0.0525753833,
-0.0076249042,
-0.0215648822,
0.0411385335,
-0.0759482086,
-0.0086463187,
-0.0495283827,
0.0104561951,
-0.0080936141,
-0.0284677576,
-0.0078879064,
-0.0107361954,
0.010698799,
0.055035539,
-0.00930495,
-0.0174393263,
-0.0074692355,
0.0388557911,
-0.073596634,
0.0020234934,
0.0361100473,
0.0669459328,
0.0078706499,
0.0000020073,
-0.0297652148,
-0.0188761614,
0.0046672304,
-0.025862867,
0.0060281232,
0.0334037952,
0.0211419314,
0.0149657093,
0.0112511953,
-0.0342720486,
-0.0126213171,
-0.0216589179,
0.0332467817,
0.0599533059,
0.0744199604,
0.0193515867,
-0.0160617158,
-0.01544833,
-0.0576710552,
0.0152087472,
-0.0484215096,
0.0408389047,
0.0029490886,
0.036651928,
0.0490602143,
-0.041098617,
0.0122098075,
0.0185220819,
0.0029873415,
-0.0008528869,
0.0393502563,
-0.0445758514,
0.0560091995,
0.0009286209,
0.0736371577,
-0.01301469,
-0.0103750229,
-0.0043261121,
0.0055610733,
0.0197752155,
0.0126215871,
-0.084449105,
0.0097178435,
0.0137601011,
0.0059303972,
-0.0138447434,
0.0468028672,
0.025466729,
0.0062503708,
-0.0228058137,
0.0491292402,
0.0017704155,
-0.0520856641,
-0.0051093781,
-0.0036197323,
-0.0204396378,
-0.0404787213,
-0.0137132918,
-0.0017332827,
-0.054697223,
0.0374261215,
0.0041319849,
-0.0266383104,
-0.0095453328,
-0.0252860468,
0.0299420878,
0.0045873211,
0.0259340424,
0.0424062498,
-0.0282238964,
0.0975110158,
0.0284136347,
0.0460674874,
-0.0417325646,
0.0497194976,
-0.0153436521,
0.0062246486,
-0.0032097872,
0.0405859351,
-0.0158412009,
-0.0141029311,
-0.0365963466,
-0.0175730214,
-0.01958449,
0.027070811,
-0.0180966295,
-0.0108166495,
-0.0522866249,
-0.0121766869,
0.0031856182,
0.0261457637,
0.0027097862,
-0.0195536781,
-0.0086928112,
0.0131030288,
-0.0305983704,
-0.0067221327,
-0.0162743833,
-0.0145593919,
0.0034588319,
0.0597954206,
-0.0337090269,
-0.0730747283,
-0.0060001789,
0.0208524484,
0.011294784,
-0.0540561378,
-0.0216600411,
-0.0741484463,
0.0339326374,
0.0155536141,
0.0554651394,
-0.0182415452,
0.0344994292,
0.0406955592,
-0.0174248107,
0.0493503623,
0.0775148049,
0.0000684596,
-0.0024983096,
0.0410330258,
-0.0158849414,
0.073806569,
0.015246246,
0.0296728425,
0.0383781604,
0.0231643002,
0.0189623889,
0.0348446816,
0.0258423239,
0.0345471352,
-0.0334496312,
0.0091563631,
0.0125492383,
0.0326268114,
0.0067087817,
0.0195088405,
-0.0537765212,
0.0055889767,
0.0514248572,
0.0357548073,
0.0407974608,
-0.046695631,
0.0292088017,
0.0197778977,
0.008061328,
0.0321984626,
-0.029756546,
-0.0168182477,
0.0075240405,
0.0232213512,
0.0412636138,
0.0206818953,
-0.0092033157,
-0.0311019327,
-0.0087511223,
0.0178058762,
-0.0071425722,
0.0282286443,
0.0723667815,
0.0267992895,
-0.0635304898,
0.0142883575,
0.0341273174,
-0.0344671011,
0.0095162094,
-0.0338618867,
-0.0232785661,
0.0563801676,
0.0806807354,
-0.0381171778,
-0.0151416361,
-0.0279119425,
0.0498818271,
0.0220037717,
-0.0041717398,
-0.0541711003,
0.0048232093,
-0.0232774038,
-0.0159753896,
-0.005207214,
0.0150987329,
0.0287820622,
0.039247755,
0.0118683772,
0.0031669529,
-0.0708351657,
-0.0204362031,
0.032907065,
-0.027862398,
-0.0245635882,
0.0161717907,
-0.0153245153,
0.0152678005,
0.0218443442,
-0.0257941559,
-0.0208608154,
0.0579689555,
-0.0294877682,
0.0185459107,
-0.0106168315,
-0.0425473116,
-0.1102818921,
0.0359876789,
-0.0271065813,
0.0067450437,
0.0640169531,
-0.0442470126,
-0.0230525192,
-0.0299306214,
-0.0036137141,
0.0237491094,
0.0067160665,
0.0362668224,
0.0101254582,
-0.0613310188,
-0.0585094653,
0.1059107557,
-0.0197032001,
0.0576959886,
0.0641853958,
0.0339475349,
-0.0329103023,
-0.0364995562,
-0.039493762,
0.0404011533,
-0.0010403094,
0.0163689721,
0.0225365274,
0.0252867714,
-0.0351144634,
-0.0098569114,
-0.0802834183,
0.023085393,
-0.0314946026,
0.0054350356,
-0.0210021883,
-0.0020840862,
-0.0136851622,
-0.016602844,
-0.0198084451,
-0.0695588589,
0.0006947016,
-0.0121379001,
-0.0142710684,
0.0347937569,
-0.0028774706,
-0.0093809338,
-0.0157850981,
0.0075679547,
0.0713843331,
-0.0362396501,
0.0174176507,
-0.0387662612,
0.0404378735,
0.0163368955,
0.0254428778,
-0.0432687066,
0.0047540264,
0.0256236885,
-0.0171629768,
0.011004786,
0.0364579335,
0.0241923351,
0.0293511804,
0.0268025398,
-0.0087444773,
-0.0910265744,
0.0191100668,
0.0039445828,
0.0124282939,
-0.0313364193,
0.0053737508,
-0.0005762086,
0.0230445806,
0.0008636541,
-0.0089930138,
-0.0457277782,
0.0237262901,
-0.0397210345,
-0.0106929941,
-0.0653635934,
-0.004646874,
-0.0402422585,
-0.0245456342,
-0.0019204257,
-0.0122337146,
0.0586007871,
-0.0283247549,
-0.0124543197,
-0.059595421,
0.0146272406,
-0.0355290733,
0.0423427522,
0.0064626965,
0.0058000544,
-0.0402009301,
-0.0226063598,
-0.0219314676,
0.0140334684,
-0.0006079698,
-0.0630801171,
0.0380280763,
-0.0419008434,
0.0067472914,
-0.007199978,
-0.0792990029,
-0.0642238185,
-0.0413137339,
0.0244967714,
-0.0017789635,
-0.0358701348,
0.0190441702,
-0.0310654268,
-0.0107506588,
0.0344079994,
0.0540023968,
-0.024380004,
-0.0084365075,
-0.0068173264,
0.0571544543,
0.0386912748,
-0.0134006692,
-0.0217394233,
-0.0595139116,
0.0239723492,
0.0404404216,
0.0992473587,
-0.0130965849,
0.0261471625,
-0.0130235497,
0.0388872214,
-0.0551414005,
0.0260005891,
0.037844114,
0.0249094795,
-0.0546759963,
-0.0061993198,
0.081702821,
0.0401577987,
-0.0557008795,
0.0024980479,
0.0121558206,
-0.0007957791,
0.009975329,
0.0457874201,
-0.0854376778,
0.0150292544,
0.0114103341,
0.0438636243,
-0.0121671045,
-0.0104931425,
0.00260301,
-0.1883047372,
0.0395401344,
0.0418236032,
-0.0533407331,
-0.0096488558,
-0.0394013375,
0.0032246136,
-0.0092491582,
-0.0092353141,
0.0490120091,
-0.0251390263,
0.0023266023,
0.0046489798,
0.0413166136,
-0.1028351262,
0.0039376966,
-0.0308052022,
0.0307040401,
0.0016265764,
0.0204157345,
-0.0281845983,
0.0100626592,
0.000233766,
-0.0438072942,
-0.0045849457,
-0.010217445,
0.0386560075,
-0.0360833853,
0.0144927818,
0.0025744976,
0.0500339605,
0.0285833739,
-0.0128781348,
0.0002103322,
0.0329122208,
-0.002670171,
0.0083417036,
-0.0139011201,
-0.0199419223,
0.0247031581,
0.0478729568,
-0.0035784007,
-0.0293883178,
-0.0067881513,
-0.0474062264,
0.0189500861,
-0.0199855287,
-0.0360956155,
0.005307008,
-0.0024868511,
0.0329613052,
-0.0663636103,
-0.0136127416,
0.02820432,
0.0694297254,
-0.0102013443,
0.0413046591,
-0.0750966147,
0.0111919148,
-0.0335912704,
0.0160113759,
-0.0167486127,
0.017459847,
-0.0373930484,
-0.0103356382,
0.0545013621,
-0.0356122553,
-0.0252423808,
0.001077982,
-0.0306919515,
-0.0564232357,
-0.010090922,
0.0625350848,
0.0192602519,
0.0475271903,
0.0016036046,
-0.0293864794,
0.0692673847,
0.0661573187,
-0.0188824255,
0.0171689037,
0.0236675646,
-0.0054369611,
-0.029014634,
0.0147208637,
-0.058372844,
-0.0024986214,
0.0061988374,
0.0563524365,
-0.0185938459,
-0.0092912102,
0.0249094218,
-0.0070037716,
0.0447196625,
0.0013572572,
-0.0374268293,
-0.0329717696,
0.0510981679,
-0.0439910814,
-0.0621720627,
-0.018495135,
0.0201292746,
0.0138759259,
0.0015980059,
-0.0111586004,
-0.0306763779,
-0.0031181311,
0.0247266907,
-0.0791855901,
0.0027655587,
0.0503604002,
-0.0765822828,
0.0345089361,
0.0073623531,
-0.0349382274,
-0.0459590927,
0.0227249637,
0.0544461794,
0.0051598861,
0.0521186404,
0.0326468237,
-0.0371058956,
-0.0252046362,
0.034216579,
-0.0622066818,
0.0195616968,
-0.0809077173,
0.049540706,
0.0586140044,
0.0006987383,
0.0474342369,
-0.0082139466,
0.0056787673,
-0.0077059586,
-0.0433326289,
-0.0101037817,
-0.0303850509,
-0.009613988,
0.0639843121,
0.0461355746,
0.0756620616,
0.0907787755,
0.0307130087,
-0.0004136044,
0.0334168598,
-0.0073948391,
-0.0447438285,
-0.0180632304,
0.0346503668,
0.0692815781,
0.0224085879,
-0.0120671587,
-0.0549205616,
-0.0296577755,
0.0009860803,
0.0093402993,
0.0010204593,
-0.0503087714,
0.018339999,
0.0490502156,
-0.0186872073,
-0.0142923808,
-0.0773139,
-0.0291856807,
0.0332643501,
-0.049436938,
-0.0306243598,
-5.767009815e-33,
-0.0423221402,
-0.0314306878,
0.0042144256,
-0.005853801,
-0.0489170998,
0.0051499144,
-0.0104140127,
-0.0030191962,
0.0295870882,
0.0127415657,
-0.0441833436,
-0.0136542395,
0.0091038365,
0.0111298813,
0.0081050703,
0.010271335,
0.0535800718,
-0.0060888617,
-0.0671361759,
0.0128193386,
0.0206176154,
0.0429446734,
0.0163604133,
-0.0443718918,
0.0390810966,
-0.0384182744,
-0.0177727696,
-0.0200733971,
-0.014966948,
0.0388514102,
0.0047540884,
0.0301625133,
0.0243280772,
-0.0672616139,
0.0051751244,
0.0119741,
-0.0449262038,
-0.0249627344,
-0.004141693,
0.0078210151,
-0.0212456398,
0.010690541,
0.0414038412,
-0.0230971444,
0.0028488296,
-0.0142376227,
0.020746531,
-0.0106626786,
-0.0353543349,
-0.0480266921,
-0.0125086838,
0.0319659822,
-0.0096783834,
-0.0426118262,
0.0367129445,
0.0674848855,
0.0080073504,
0.0001429334,
-0.0251077693,
0.0339537598,
0.0538388602,
0.0443699472,
0.0419058912,
0.0163067728,
-0.0135257915,
0.0787563771,
-0.0280424301,
-0.0013363092,
0.0506488085,
-0.0512308478,
0.020423675,
0.0152753061,
0.0357390083,
0.0350285508,
0.0309104137,
0.0256110001,
-0.0538772605,
0.0511369593,
0.0562166013,
-0.0041636517,
0.0414725728,
0.0280468538,
-0.0790148303,
-0.0463977158,
-0.0371374264,
-0.016171826,
-0.0062084808,
-0.0571276881,
0.0378477834,
0.0357085727,
-0.0492751114,
-0.0027563469,
0.0392278731,
-0.0573408864,
-0.0636122376,
0.0323905088,
-0.0037230658,
0.0556846671,
-0.0226276722,
-0.0083807865,
-0.0300593004,
-0.013562155,
0.0109533984,
-0.0131226256,
-0.0163758863,
-0.0204481483,
0.0157642718,
0.0166958943,
-0.0447495021,
0.0109649841,
-0.0015466514,
-0.012053133,
-0.0039505837,
0.0403745435,
0.0183468554,
0.0044335159,
-0.007654903,
0.0682939887,
0.0237823892,
-0.0542650446,
-0.0249175187,
0.0382932685,
-0.0272821058,
-0.0355339088,
-0.0286548529,
0.0056721661,
0.0080454173,
0.0718307421,
0.0084258849,
-0.0379133709,
-0.0148223974,
0.0133278081,
2.638e-7,
-0.0027796654,
0.0345295034,
-0.0182353351,
0.024993388,
0.0205860659,
0.00299386,
-0.0414620973,
0.0455098301,
0.0418435782,
-0.0088280756,
0.0264709741,
0.0009215265,
0.0366002321,
0.0302236117,
-0.1314680427,
-0.0303543471,
-0.036531724,
-0.0455236249,
-0.0425797924,
-0.0580295958,
0.0228744075,
0.0640512034,
-0.0027352963,
0.0311002098,
-0.010899676,
-0.0459419563,
0.0550166182,
-0.0199170467,
-0.0325415991,
-0.0079901945,
0.0099026058,
0.0273080729,
-0.0119676245,
0.0168562327,
-0.0070771822,
0.058272887,
0.0383741595,
0.0573566072,
0.0090796938,
-0.0017859275,
0.0143773928,
0.0289070271,
-0.0010664539,
-0.042286355,
0.0617904067,
-0.0790853277,
-0.0064358586,
0.0008438663,
-0.0319570526,
-0.0491513461,
0.0009284848,
-0.0133370236,
-0.0268093478,
0.0386002809,
0.0049686432,
0.0178745575,
-0.0101196561,
-0.0690693781,
-0.0318363048,
-0.001419025,
-0.0581257604,
-0.033622589,
0.0036329336,
-0.0098496797,
-0.0715876371,
-0.080731757,
-0.0035973354,
2.586757053e-34,
0.0511519536,
-0.0091048693,
-0.0168115254,
0.0252623446,
0.0215295311,
-0.0195035525,
-0.0096760411,
0.0188353397,
0.0414331853,
-0.0697031319,
-0.0160952434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16330v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16330v1 | Pruning via Merging: Compressing LLMs via Manifold Alignment Based Layer Merging | 2024-06-24T05:57:55 | 2024-06-24T05:57:55 | Deyuan Liu, Zhanyue Qin, Hairu Wang, Zhao Yang, Zecheng Wang, Fangying Rong, Qingbin Liu, Yanchao Hao, Xi Chen, Cunhang Fan, Zhao Lv, Zhiying Tu, Dianhui Chu, Bo Li, Dianbo Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While large language models (LLMs) excel in many domains, their complexity
and scale challenge deployment in resource-limited environments. Current
compression techniques, such as parameter pruning, often fail to effectively
utilize the knowledge from pruned parameters. To address these challenges, we
propose Manifold-Based Knowledge Alignment and Layer Merging Compression (MKA),
a novel approach that uses manifold learning and the Normalized Pairwise
Information Bottleneck (NPIB) measure to merge similar layers, reducing model
size while preserving essential performance. We evaluate MKA on multiple
benchmark datasets and various LLMs. Our findings show that MKA not only
preserves model performance but also achieves substantial compression ratios,
outperforming traditional pruning methods. Moreover, when coupled with
quantization, MKA delivers even greater compression. Specifically, on the MMLU
dataset using the Llama3-8B model, MKA achieves a compression ratio of 43.75%
with a minimal performance decrease of only 2.82\%. The proposed MKA method
offers a resource-efficient and performance-preserving model compression
technique for LLMs. | [
-0.0581484996,
0.0432101786,
-0.0012005377,
0.0514777787,
-0.0364324339,
0.0177245121,
-0.0068117185,
0.0204020701,
-0.0020975249,
0.0139594441,
-0.0316009857,
-0.0189337563,
0.0343193486,
-0.0105422409,
0.0467227362,
-0.0232326295,
0.0254588556,
-0.0439073816,
0.0002180546,
-0.0193999223,
-0.0152791198,
0.0317378603,
0.0296541527,
0.0214951746,
0.011977341,
-0.0146487206,
0.0099287611,
0.0105239563,
0.0057163811,
0.0058525195,
-0.0194891021,
0.0510893539,
0.0422727913,
0.0684354529,
0.0000020249,
-0.0309461374,
0.0114696445,
0.0148803201,
-0.0390322618,
0.053241726,
0.0272218864,
-0.0365932472,
-0.0201714709,
0.009456085,
-0.0074975151,
-0.0480365157,
0.0323092416,
0.0121364631,
0.0674822181,
0.0512756631,
-0.0178102273,
-0.0327364467,
0.0020286299,
-0.0218808651,
-0.0573314242,
-0.0335639641,
0.0433959775,
0.0009575409,
-0.0106261596,
-0.0301684197,
-0.0240162946,
0.0565461665,
-0.0135622974,
0.0160489976,
0.0160006434,
0.055305507,
-0.0258577038,
-0.0266383067,
0.0175849535,
0.0759294406,
-0.0572644211,
-0.0333245695,
0.0309531838,
0.0095200688,
-0.0150185023,
-0.0282122772,
-0.0528929122,
-0.0038653929,
0.0179536194,
0.029560186,
-0.0283981282,
-0.0432127789,
0.0602635369,
-0.0141355544,
-0.0464832745,
0.0357071646,
0.0404206626,
-0.0081226071,
-0.0263114423,
-0.0598180033,
0.0011439384,
-0.05994609,
-0.0315332972,
0.0035250874,
0.015885571,
0.0008536702,
-0.072098121,
-0.024652943,
0.010388853,
-0.0569477417,
0.0488107018,
0.0411762334,
0.0421962216,
0.0837732628,
-0.0154421721,
0.0475492254,
-0.0178342145,
0.0278461576,
-0.0593942255,
-0.0168301333,
0.0038827574,
-0.0118701244,
0.0035836026,
0.0314841382,
-0.0043897415,
-0.0192343369,
-0.039242316,
0.0071740947,
0.0038462118,
0.0206556972,
0.0185062587,
-0.0266806763,
0.0264662076,
-0.0128419111,
-0.0041938308,
0.0093535557,
0.0184495132,
0.0254574213,
-0.0201619081,
-0.0113530932,
-0.0249946602,
0.0253217854,
0.0099408962,
-0.0114428205,
0.0099807093,
0.0264089648,
0.0107250698,
0.0117436172,
-0.0120741446,
-0.0192732606,
0.0106258979,
-0.0713994801,
0.0095957387,
-0.0682826415,
0.0733650699,
-0.0574250557,
-0.0088866623,
-0.0715998635,
-0.0251465309,
-0.0190657154,
-0.0472528785,
0.0544193722,
-0.0035019813,
0.0497548319,
0.0878990367,
-0.001159837,
0.0338423923,
0.0815339163,
0.0291493498,
0.0002236717,
0.0149379373,
-0.034671329,
-0.0248156227,
0.0449346565,
0.0631225631,
0.0328265242,
-0.040812999,
-0.0203166045,
0.0193589274,
0.045568496,
0.0581562705,
0.084505111,
-0.0552929379,
-0.055778183,
0.0211719871,
0.0225605834,
0.0561862588,
0.0219883826,
0.0032348891,
0.0343211144,
-0.0065170759,
-0.0059143319,
-0.0251138322,
0.0465416722,
-0.0182976369,
0.0068945508,
0.082565926,
0.0597692728,
-0.0601107106,
-0.0099037383,
-0.0378151946,
-0.0418911353,
-0.020933209,
0.0106411278,
0.0261363089,
-0.0213683248,
-0.0269772224,
0.0899856612,
-0.0029922808,
-0.059414655,
-0.0130055854,
-0.0243545547,
-0.0273990538,
0.0244258195,
-0.0079142451,
0.0160944387,
-0.0336557589,
0.0285403598,
0.0091256676,
-0.0056312694,
0.0052703489,
-0.0037189797,
0.035081923,
-0.075338237,
-0.0458241254,
0.0163749773,
-0.0037568389,
0.003589242,
0.014606501,
-0.0131372456,
0.0151499547,
-0.058636792,
0.0034182966,
0.0412995666,
-0.04267646,
-0.011400342,
0.0026057258,
-0.0037684373,
0.0477381274,
-0.0073875622,
-0.0111439181,
0.0004911147,
0.0609836727,
-0.0492712148,
-0.0244778749,
-0.0180902574,
-0.0285959505,
-0.0715658665,
0.0617664829,
0.0177186988,
0.0364860073,
0.0550110079,
-0.0469988473,
-0.0664724782,
0.0085259173,
-0.0219194312,
0.041245766,
-0.0303798653,
0.0150905503,
-0.022228783,
0.0460633971,
-0.0061704386,
0.0289711375,
-0.0471824184,
-0.0094375154,
0.0104331877,
-0.0287709311,
0.0110137463,
-0.0108401524,
-0.0336671062,
0.0377179496,
0.0252097026,
0.0354135334,
-0.0144037027,
-0.0273309313,
0.0027772717,
-0.0274234153,
-0.0729717389,
-0.0003926213,
-0.0073185018,
0.0394361205,
0.0131755266,
0.0175854396,
-0.0018893018,
0.0189874377,
0.0160231013,
-0.006655585,
-0.0041173971,
0.003580028,
-0.0025434003,
-0.0102489935,
-0.053948693,
-0.0247124918,
-0.0444066599,
0.0136426305,
0.0608537756,
-0.0738447607,
-0.0528574623,
-0.0274401773,
0.0287040863,
-0.0643018186,
0.0341566093,
-0.0190328881,
-0.0207612105,
-0.0223422218,
-0.0252698287,
0.0461067334,
0.0376045778,
-0.0157168489,
-0.0337260701,
0.100305073,
-0.0043554232,
-0.0395079628,
0.0120099233,
-0.0153289428,
-0.016644977,
-0.0188073628,
-0.0457460433,
-0.0204299875,
0.0634627864,
0.0072319242,
-0.0058355401,
-0.0579722747,
-0.0165371485,
-0.0193536282,
-0.0160255209,
-0.0326595269,
0.0009941112,
-0.0206730198,
0.0554515794,
-0.0008648523,
-0.0731861293,
0.0463606492,
-0.0666601285,
-0.005660085,
0.0042201355,
-0.0231970213,
-0.0582492203,
0.0222810898,
0.0119142048,
0.017545918,
-0.0286983717,
0.00475686,
-0.042051129,
0.0161081329,
0.0037196793,
-0.0237933546,
-0.0056783105,
-0.0566108562,
0.0496688038,
-0.0063121389,
-0.0111462837,
0.0164778084,
-0.0009590093,
-0.0067734784,
0.0108462377,
-0.0219707116,
-0.0405379422,
-0.0106206518,
0.0441606455,
0.0027724793,
0.0426457636,
0.0224290919,
0.0308563374,
0.0137029262,
0.0127471834,
0.0382648446,
0.0492512472,
0.0238729846,
-0.0216651801,
0.055238314,
0.0278926566,
0.0319656655,
0.057182163,
-0.0449491106,
-0.0352465063,
0.0506380647,
0.0280626453,
-0.0384751968,
0.0152945565,
0.0010904224,
-0.0127852215,
0.0282459147,
0.1008840948,
0.0095410431,
-0.025427578,
-0.0123629496,
0.0182165205,
0.0725888088,
0.0061516576,
0.0100350669,
-0.0283852853,
0.0039465083,
0.015950093,
-0.001581484,
0.0540626794,
0.0007497654,
-0.0168821663,
-0.079979822,
0.0128315715,
0.0476251878,
-0.0227144845,
0.0049672937,
-0.0526750125,
-0.0087284315,
-0.0077018151,
0.0341528878,
-0.0008526843,
0.0049623586,
-0.0401735865,
0.0069534094,
-0.0521454364,
-0.0822329447,
0.006881312,
-0.0115867788,
0.0531571433,
0.0016614669,
0.0492009968,
0.0167630948,
-0.0361989252,
0.0417352803,
0.0307636,
-0.0323370285,
-0.0313891061,
0.0219748002,
0.033254113,
0.018949924,
0.0476927795,
0.0180644561,
-0.0295932814,
0.0077974931,
0.0021923718,
0.0967964455,
-0.0130880838,
0.0022163007,
-0.0290893223,
-0.0120359603,
-0.0736063644,
0.0819587857,
0.0166716091,
0.0240704548,
0.0034950171,
0.0241901744,
0.0012612023,
0.0119204149,
-0.0125089539,
0.0400284156,
-0.036512088,
-0.0584267303,
-0.0322140418,
0.0318402275,
0.0118119922,
0.0194624756,
-0.0121723758,
0.0314162709,
-0.0014917898,
0.0020711445,
-0.0783006623,
0.0009110298,
-0.0286619235,
0.0179034173,
-0.0362180248,
0.0230829753,
0.0059941765,
0.0183649007,
-0.0206348393,
-0.0250934735,
-0.1278970242,
-0.0822208449,
-0.0209659971,
0.022204658,
0.0114479419,
0.0705895573,
0.0195129048,
-0.0770454928,
0.0118670398,
0.0210669599,
-0.019532036,
0.0955985487,
0.0026402718,
-0.0467924066,
0.0018277046,
0.0354766101,
-0.0582417175,
-0.0141697414,
-0.0222747009,
-0.0054011014,
-0.0439631566,
-0.0077012037,
-0.0294120386,
0.0312693268,
0.0192456655,
-0.0363149121,
-0.0270685293,
-0.0038374842,
0.0315706097,
-0.0156309623,
0.0014508859,
-0.0317239538,
-0.0009140034,
0.0139476964,
0.0425428264,
0.0140936198,
0.0428387076,
0.0519065596,
-0.0089507271,
-0.005124901,
-0.0007240834,
-0.0273771957,
-0.0085917842,
0.0541161895,
0.0001124242,
-0.0059276624,
-0.0011544044,
-0.0239491072,
0.004316627,
-0.0426002219,
-0.0276156757,
0.0090946406,
0.0601290613,
-0.0517040938,
0.0399690494,
-0.0145877805,
-0.0838544443,
-0.0193244312,
0.0155937178,
0.0631035566,
0.0104447668,
0.076400362,
-0.0146630453,
-0.0055438578,
-0.0324318334,
0.0103232227,
-0.0044962228,
-0.0107722115,
0.0767543986,
0.014055388,
-0.0175819416,
0.0097130993,
0.0707262829,
0.0336382464,
0.0219876394,
-0.0236453917,
0.018677339,
-0.0483996607,
-0.0139582101,
-0.02487351,
0.0485859327,
-0.0033453794,
-0.0281079784,
-0.028236825,
-0.0494771227,
0.0215477124,
-0.0020415233,
-0.0453865081,
-0.0097810701,
0.0361415073,
0.0415034741,
-0.0134675615,
-0.0132525833,
-0.0017433078,
-0.0626790971,
-0.0253116135,
-0.0448637679,
0.039896667,
-6.250240115e-33,
-0.0255900808,
-0.0009335771,
0.02971806,
-0.0079728803,
-0.0443399027,
0.0287962519,
-0.008932963,
-0.0310497601,
-0.0148196835,
-0.0218066163,
-0.0073837577,
0.0292312484,
-0.0017453332,
0.0127575872,
-0.0283796601,
0.0231266059,
0.0588685125,
-0.0111906491,
-0.0036139027,
0.0379228927,
-0.004051521,
0.0386231281,
0.0279912129,
-0.0037948787,
-0.058259435,
0.017189011,
0.0048145126,
0.0219303854,
-0.002538742,
0.0480404496,
-0.0615473725,
0.0166540276,
0.0001800346,
-0.002747596,
-0.0242545791,
-0.0211227555,
-0.0376004726,
-0.0144197894,
0.0272149127,
0.010217553,
-0.0004557506,
-0.0362822153,
0.0612147972,
0.035937015,
-0.0276951436,
-0.0544509701,
0.0262672938,
-0.0113170836,
-0.0659672022,
-0.04945473,
-0.0223116819,
0.0481897593,
0.0134428283,
-0.0030416264,
0.1042404473,
-0.0245347749,
-0.0085708303,
0.038213443,
-0.0778073967,
0.0221681334,
-0.0082578147,
0.0733065903,
0.0970898494,
0.045291841,
0.0073161763,
0.0402618386,
0.0122366166,
-0.0298185889,
-0.0298690237,
0.0703467056,
0.0676189139,
0.0225451961,
0.0230227895,
0.0355138741,
-0.0167158116,
-0.014748726,
-0.0615629479,
0.0290469006,
-0.0229924694,
0.0041627474,
-0.0057487912,
0.0774579644,
-0.0121067883,
-0.0541041605,
-0.0575472228,
0.0342868157,
-0.0320597254,
0.0210512616,
-0.0031772552,
0.0106653031,
-0.0046068276,
-0.0637764409,
0.0178248957,
-0.0418302231,
-0.0306504462,
-0.0069659594,
-0.0110961376,
0.0162762068,
0.0125350365,
0.0252267756,
-0.0648911372,
-0.0227386542,
0.0195697155,
0.0064587342,
0.0300519615,
-0.0048157815,
-0.0150638809,
0.0547209084,
-0.0660268739,
-0.0135493418,
-0.0283020437,
-0.0595843978,
0.0048871748,
0.0257857889,
0.0441360399,
0.0101715941,
0.0238380171,
0.0284711868,
0.0191446152,
0.0197169278,
-0.0094650341,
0.0019511114,
-0.0065657338,
0.0300013069,
-0.0279924069,
0.0033996257,
-0.0216845144,
-0.0200625081,
0.0909718871,
-0.0518148877,
-0.0491710752,
0.0512346327,
2.648e-7,
0.016765302,
0.0223656781,
0.0068011698,
-0.0471770428,
-0.0052568493,
0.0224428605,
-0.0334736407,
-0.0043795123,
-0.0273730233,
-0.0138664423,
0.0371656343,
0.0218568873,
0.0576801971,
0.0217831917,
-0.1070405245,
0.0512585603,
-0.0491233654,
-0.0178494826,
-0.0492789783,
-0.0155190406,
0.0244881175,
0.1159878448,
0.0366280489,
-0.0254211109,
0.005505065,
-0.005990216,
0.0339065455,
-0.041430492,
0.0113698067,
0.0188772976,
0.0273028482,
-0.0052548568,
-0.0272171702,
-0.0161575172,
-0.005938434,
0.0174439214,
-0.0249992721,
0.0738954991,
-0.0176107176,
0.0148810456,
0.0215688553,
0.0243952405,
-0.0580952503,
-0.0663680509,
0.0535773076,
-0.0129931495,
-0.033217594,
-0.0706376284,
0.016614154,
0.0212176535,
0.0319473743,
0.0157476254,
0.0049213925,
0.042915605,
0.0220318679,
-0.0429868624,
0.020467259,
-0.0854561627,
-0.0327037238,
0.0250876434,
-0.078226544,
-0.0302103795,
-0.0354183018,
0.0009122188,
0.0336227342,
-0.0284622945,
-0.0093645053,
2.639440092e-34,
-0.0087643657,
-0.0377218127,
0.0300318114,
0.0422084779,
-0.0184845962,
-0.0355260298,
-0.028346315,
0.0397010073,
-0.0431003273,
-0.0832503513,
-0.0001284553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16320v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16320v1 | What Do VLMs NOTICE? A Mechanistic Interpretability Pipeline for Noise-free Text-Image Corruption and Evaluation | 2024-06-24T05:13:19 | 2024-06-24T05:13:19 | Michal Golovanevsky, William Rudman, Vedant Palit, Ritambhara Singh, Carsten Eickhoff | cs.CL | cs.CL | Vision-Language Models (VLMs) have gained community-spanning prominence due
to their ability to integrate visual and textual inputs to perform complex
tasks. Despite their success, the internal decision-making processes of these
models remain opaque, posing challenges in high-stakes applications. To address
this, we introduce NOTICE, the first Noise-free Text-Image Corruption and
Evaluation pipeline for mechanistic interpretability in VLMs. NOTICE
incorporates a Semantic Minimal Pairs (SMP) framework for image corruption and
Symmetric Token Replacement (STR) for text. This approach enables semantically
meaningful causal mediation analysis for both modalities, providing a robust
method for analyzing multimodal integration within models like BLIP. Our
experiments on the SVO-Probes, MIT-States, and Facial Expression Recognition
datasets reveal crucial insights into VLM decision-making, identifying the
significant role of middle-layer cross-attention heads. Further, we uncover a
set of ``universal cross-attention heads'' that consistently contribute across
tasks and modalities, each performing distinct functions such as implicit image
segmentation, object inhibition, and outlier inhibition. This work paves the
way for more transparent and interpretable multimodal systems. | [
-0.0049741156,
0.0229217429,
-0.0146890981,
0.0498535968,
-0.015609798,
0.0152466819,
0.0207941923,
0.026487032,
-0.0161777772,
-0.0533791669,
-0.0365940109,
-0.0141167119,
0.0404700264,
0.0552793257,
0.0522532202,
-0.065148823,
0.0440724567,
-0.0385918505,
0.0116461199,
0.0101883942,
0.0410573818,
-0.0220448337,
0.0316703729,
0.0577975586,
-0.0446452945,
-0.0311235376,
0.0003258701,
0.0412615426,
0.0116101475,
0.0304739717,
-0.0658490062,
0.0834864378,
0.0046019661,
0.0290494505,
0.0000021126,
-0.0256997328,
0.0113633061,
0.0196795799,
0.0185279995,
-0.0006560167,
0.0271713436,
-0.0177613106,
0.001330669,
-0.0205839127,
0.0107665481,
0.0182776917,
0.1037945598,
0.0527582131,
0.0625555441,
0.0309633613,
-0.0231124405,
0.0125240302,
0.0032060258,
-0.0128856478,
0.0728000477,
-0.014657462,
0.0376513712,
-0.0334463641,
-0.051570598,
-0.0148074329,
-0.0692896917,
0.0152850114,
0.0071719275,
-0.0241072644,
0.028918948,
-0.0051195705,
0.0126743838,
-0.0733213052,
-0.0226183198,
0.07272131,
-0.0332824737,
-0.0204764549,
-0.0045580054,
-0.0047344025,
0.0096797785,
0.0124547416,
-0.0234742649,
-0.0166307129,
0.0180043709,
0.0355214775,
-0.0294218846,
-0.0090834033,
0.0513467938,
-0.0233646128,
-0.0036088405,
-0.0061095487,
-0.0065003824,
-0.0024495495,
-0.0326989777,
0.0259527564,
-0.0061974567,
-0.0663678572,
0.0176536776,
-0.0160366464,
-0.013044375,
-0.0017888098,
-0.0616596229,
-0.0738212392,
0.003183861,
-0.0274717752,
0.0415119119,
0.023866171,
-0.0909135267,
0.0661845133,
-0.0119366013,
0.0663802922,
-0.017645834,
0.0615670793,
0.0067920112,
-0.0104161995,
0.0131494906,
-0.0242289416,
0.0149153201,
-0.0308433622,
-0.0801190585,
-0.0365270525,
0.0122325467,
0.0079112453,
-0.056476716,
-0.0002864833,
-0.0298784506,
0.0065368628,
-0.035596177,
-0.0018156699,
-0.0306769796,
0.0334155448,
0.0305729657,
-0.0020669815,
-0.0111577362,
-0.0498787984,
-0.0325095877,
0.0655839592,
-0.0049479473,
-0.0132240681,
-0.030248221,
0.0921369791,
-0.0030799154,
-0.0292195976,
-0.0145630389,
-0.0308059473,
-0.0360829011,
-0.0374021642,
0.034028586,
-0.0213109218,
0.0112985363,
-0.0064603193,
-0.008119964,
-0.0382120386,
0.0257867202,
0.009265813,
-0.0663000941,
0.099049449,
-0.0047928747,
-0.0194454081,
-0.0424306057,
0.0089236414,
0.0010621176,
0.0586791709,
0.0248324368,
0.0247026868,
0.0053628008,
-0.0023702395,
0.032377366,
0.0287385378,
0.0281210709,
0.0209471565,
-0.0818205178,
-0.0295021385,
-0.000472923,
-0.0032803926,
0.0403356776,
0.0704605877,
-0.0447062813,
-0.0507184044,
0.1000182331,
-0.0011535679,
-0.0293146931,
0.0007080358,
0.0103692962,
-0.0187206566,
-0.025328787,
0.0164056588,
-0.0773661435,
0.0550013855,
-0.0137542607,
-0.024406286,
0.0009002262,
0.0164453015,
-0.0221655387,
-0.0472947657,
-0.0346732698,
-0.0071708444,
0.0198683441,
0.0196236148,
0.0811177492,
0.0067690201,
-0.0441426635,
-0.0146997366,
-0.0075026588,
-0.0101998951,
-0.0056131324,
-0.0639341101,
0.0232962612,
0.0497081019,
0.0450546406,
-0.0206946004,
0.016728688,
-0.0276883077,
0.0029359395,
0.0456089564,
-0.0421508551,
0.0367382243,
0.0589680523,
-0.0387681574,
-0.0370571278,
-0.0046318998,
0.0152264014,
0.0023943293,
-0.0390657373,
-0.0663211793,
-0.0125806835,
-0.0451691635,
-0.0111239264,
0.0523808077,
0.0856227502,
0.0003346162,
-0.0474233963,
0.0326428302,
0.0139386123,
-0.0035625086,
-0.0336507149,
0.0014689913,
0.0300283413,
-0.0266746618,
0.0194908753,
0.0408751369,
0.0011079244,
-0.0234227274,
0.0268383827,
-0.0582607687,
-0.0268212911,
0.0431900285,
-0.0048659514,
-0.031091569,
0.0357981957,
-0.0432358198,
-0.007856057,
-0.0677640811,
-0.0003030494,
-0.0080841696,
0.0322381146,
-0.0254831556,
0.038778048,
-0.0350265577,
-0.0328988582,
0.0351878293,
-0.0062898723,
0.0310798995,
-0.0213156994,
-0.0296247751,
0.0024945494,
-0.0126148527,
0.0012882197,
-0.0135747045,
-0.016477054,
-0.0422161333,
-0.0101684975,
-0.0407677181,
-0.0502083637,
-0.0456144921,
-0.0248482171,
0.0194909833,
-0.0041091843,
0.0128893573,
-0.0306000318,
0.0244248081,
0.0434222519,
0.0063680932,
0.0109133841,
0.031118881,
-0.0352278128,
0.000266413,
0.0015205914,
-0.0143019632,
-0.0027974967,
0.0801034719,
-0.0146480566,
-0.0670145527,
-0.0591699928,
0.0067094318,
0.0165121518,
0.0263306368,
-0.0114069749,
-0.0383252911,
0.0055581755,
0.0074653151,
0.04518025,
0.0866267085,
-0.0247805659,
0.063054122,
0.0239729583,
-0.0101419035,
-0.0093771173,
-0.0067059933,
0.017613288,
0.0324734449,
-0.0263144765,
-0.0245663337,
-0.0235590637,
0.0564359464,
0.0044826809,
0.0184583981,
-0.0782741532,
0.024507802,
0.0097412383,
-0.1046689823,
-0.0386864804,
-0.017357586,
-0.0271352436,
0.0311421957,
-0.0641726553,
-0.0714777932,
0.0583640039,
-0.0433640927,
-0.0557141863,
0.0349860415,
0.0452131517,
0.001683503,
0.0452875271,
0.0408050865,
0.0277545992,
-0.0028619103,
-0.0434245653,
-0.0513725094,
-0.0370573737,
-0.0031399373,
0.0098968726,
0.0245787464,
-0.0297285058,
-0.0088915406,
0.0052972068,
0.0122478334,
-0.0024183406,
0.0017255739,
-0.0033505235,
-0.0073143649,
-0.0275184102,
0.0018544047,
-0.0431283303,
0.0285555981,
0.0587384515,
-0.0070236796,
-0.0258969292,
-0.0103762988,
-0.0256479736,
0.0086762886,
0.0267226901,
0.0048706294,
0.0445825718,
-0.0668463111,
-0.0250202958,
0.074056536,
0.0060040699,
-0.0284309387,
-0.0370968953,
0.0448471159,
0.0226562489,
0.0627427399,
0.002324037,
0.0208371952,
0.0715218633,
-0.0732368901,
-0.0138018467,
0.0534323528,
-0.0047814874,
-0.0377524607,
-0.000839545,
-0.0175636578,
0.0203320459,
0.0434099659,
-0.0247393809,
-0.0651746541,
-0.0453964397,
0.0182858258,
0.0068608215,
-0.0074888058,
0.0205775145,
-0.0010012079,
0.0065853652,
0.0850016028,
0.0110795284,
-0.0298563316,
-0.0076655322,
-0.0111653116,
0.0117212534,
-0.0249611884,
0.0155162876,
-0.0033583648,
0.0180780925,
0.0005629979,
-0.0066682184,
0.0431913212,
-0.0214024596,
-0.0231833868,
-0.0015284072,
0.0217722636,
0.0926542208,
-0.0016089566,
-0.0072956765,
-0.0683921501,
0.0409995764,
0.0019037214,
0.0358597189,
-0.0316372514,
0.0746486858,
-0.0032834481,
-0.0505109504,
-0.0141778244,
0.0444754101,
-0.0283070095,
-0.0353778265,
-0.0884662196,
0.0307202712,
-0.0092670834,
-0.0094235372,
-0.0314366482,
-0.0137488376,
0.0057613165,
0.0450811684,
0.0507844798,
-0.0475785509,
-0.0625849962,
-0.01926977,
-0.0073807733,
-0.0292425565,
-0.0307944827,
0.006922367,
0.0327753164,
-0.0785889849,
-0.0186003894,
-0.0612216145,
0.0155130047,
0.0452083983,
-0.0373706929,
0.003932836,
-0.0241985694,
0.0093141915,
-0.0296367835,
0.0717731193,
-0.0074231103,
0.0218403321,
-0.018197123,
0.0194319356,
-0.0512470715,
-0.0406081341,
-0.0265713632,
0.023285199,
-0.0735463202,
-0.0525187887,
0.0099353762,
0.0841123387,
0.0295008384,
0.0411685519,
-0.0116906706,
-0.0616957322,
0.0139620192,
0.0117597245,
0.0249761418,
0.0676593482,
0.030714348,
-0.055757653,
-0.0184577629,
0.0409456193,
-0.0202661511,
0.0117994724,
0.0451285243,
0.0001726754,
0.005261031,
0.0443386398,
0.0204332247,
-0.0060122577,
0.0717625916,
-0.0128870504,
0.0041742544,
-0.0161219575,
-0.0061500855,
-0.0123243667,
-0.0005441782,
-0.0788369998,
0.016898822,
-0.009344277,
0.0338869318,
0.0085955868,
-0.0218788795,
-0.0166557673,
0.0043024975,
-0.0213848278,
0.032771688,
0.0029319031,
0.0074160243,
-0.0003739064,
0.0538595654,
0.0089196423,
0.0355389342,
-0.0269524213,
0.0210862141,
0.01706017,
0.0353730768,
0.0392433368,
-0.0018427254,
-0.0282271877,
0.0435623527,
-0.0508356914,
-0.0128519488,
-0.0070536816,
0.0066740853,
0.0288638901,
0.0066045718,
0.0727580786,
0.0088520227,
-0.0122256428,
-0.0368355475,
0.0481894203,
0.0341642722,
-0.0109440582,
0.0174347907,
-0.0137333376,
0.0003338524,
-0.0180542655,
0.0495241694,
-0.0149652297,
0.0162215177,
-0.0192241855,
-0.0064519485,
-0.0301559754,
-0.0346231833,
0.0236161351,
0.0387655161,
-0.0272870325,
-0.0107001085,
-0.0591040999,
-0.0632086769,
0.008341711,
0.0080610178,
0.0307503678,
-0.0087246979,
0.0129362904,
0.0601257607,
0.0088161426,
0.00283025,
0.0057865246,
-0.0344325341,
0.0109943012,
-0.0035405944,
0.0274687409,
-6.701634353e-33,
-0.0081233885,
-0.0475706086,
-0.0032696798,
-0.0248610731,
-0.0048343018,
0.0523029193,
-0.0363416113,
-0.0004381429,
0.0166026819,
0.0410020314,
0.0212097764,
0.0153320208,
0.0064305398,
0.0118370801,
-0.0361442491,
0.0007004419,
0.0349877998,
0.0178567879,
-0.0169261899,
-0.0034565919,
0.0635877699,
0.0074040457,
0.0596016981,
-0.0733274519,
0.0224514958,
0.0619172156,
-0.0486409292,
-0.0011340079,
-0.0088125197,
0.078474097,
-0.0180006381,
0.0421463512,
0.0360144861,
-0.0072063538,
-0.0462713651,
0.0264914837,
-0.0360172093,
0.0063839448,
0.0392616354,
0.0240683891,
-0.0919615775,
-0.0182902813,
0.0840156972,
-0.0072182021,
0.0032328027,
-0.0322554186,
0.0341616198,
-0.0156577192,
-0.00039549,
0.0182683524,
-0.0693425685,
-0.0038388877,
-0.0182888024,
-0.006634023,
0.062496148,
0.0191035848,
-0.0012908345,
0.0668676719,
-0.0564771779,
0.0090721212,
-0.0335850976,
-0.0220136736,
0.0851744339,
0.0596846491,
0.0001593346,
0.0583587885,
0.0554579832,
-0.0141503047,
0.0023133645,
-0.0392688997,
0.0418216027,
0.0596194193,
0.0680444762,
0.0479070693,
-0.0031310634,
-0.0010166776,
-0.0535639785,
-0.0160015766,
-0.0294561684,
0.0357928164,
0.0296960659,
0.023479525,
-0.0107720681,
0.0092592929,
-0.0448037907,
-0.0541178137,
-0.0673253909,
-0.0035424607,
0.04870487,
0.0076829693,
-0.0141306175,
0.0328130722,
0.0650960729,
-0.0155317737,
0.0318589509,
-0.0331622697,
0.009033096,
0.0566452406,
0.0244877152,
0.0023769978,
-0.0225813035,
-0.0024748899,
0.0655837283,
0.0247818772,
0.0199003387,
0.0070357798,
0.027211355,
-0.0150437886,
-0.025924148,
-0.0129295588,
-0.0415786728,
0.0081027718,
0.0164682884,
0.0381675959,
0.0510100871,
-0.0097955372,
-0.0386810936,
0.0289091915,
0.005730438,
0.0187820364,
-0.018284956,
0.0124167996,
-0.0262531731,
0.0264561754,
-0.0194088202,
-0.0272466019,
-0.0358305462,
-0.0416900702,
0.0641596168,
-0.0474816002,
-0.0218091421,
0.0217970405,
2.819e-7,
0.039094571,
0.0575846583,
0.0163310207,
-0.00534839,
0.068069838,
0.0758052468,
0.0069183484,
0.0372909755,
-0.0104994532,
-0.0434850119,
-0.0094879111,
0.0136514371,
0.0414240099,
-0.0258948933,
0.0160292313,
0.0203834847,
0.0055468958,
-0.0086782807,
-0.017001247,
0.0412180014,
0.0420743227,
0.0402594209,
-0.0185729396,
-0.0100221885,
0.0661869347,
-0.0244133975,
0.0686526671,
-0.0508594774,
0.0235485695,
-0.0281606205,
-0.0098123048,
-0.0443630293,
0.0046506957,
0.0427229926,
0.0035325594,
-0.0230178125,
0.0164425597,
0.0184844024,
-0.0773189962,
-0.0407094061,
-0.0478382744,
0.0251837745,
-0.0151402364,
-0.073714368,
0.0575704426,
-0.0268252343,
-0.0548086315,
-0.0099617392,
-0.0306288321,
0.0031660066,
0.0333074443,
0.0164568443,
-0.0161260776,
0.0067761606,
0.0229985248,
-0.0044687856,
-0.035746485,
-0.047641594,
-0.0298190229,
-0.0435457528,
-0.0394678414,
-0.0414638408,
-0.0849369541,
0.0111556621,
0.0264501404,
-0.0410433747,
-0.0768512636,
3.03592125e-34,
0.0303448159,
-0.0394382514,
0.0343667679,
0.0008770877,
-0.003773836,
-0.0270532612,
-0.0478993692,
-0.0001075468,
-0.0217235126,
-0.0594202429,
-0.024726335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16319v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16319v1 | Modelled Multivariate Overlap: A method for measuring vowel merger | 2024-06-24T04:56:26 | 2024-06-24T04:56:26 | Irene Smith, Morgan Sonderegger, The Spade Consortium | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper introduces a novel method for quantifying vowel overlap. There is
a tension in previous work between using multivariate measures, such as those
derived from empirical distributions, and the ability to control for unbalanced
data and extraneous factors, as is possible when using fitted model parameters.
The method presented here resolves this tension by jointly modelling all
acoustic dimensions of interest and by simulating distributions from the model
to compute a measure of vowel overlap. An additional benefit of this method is
that computation of uncertainty becomes straightforward. We evaluate this
method on corpus speech data targeting the PIN-PEN merger in four dialects of
English and find that using modelled distributions to calculate Bhattacharyya
affinity substantially improves results compared to empirical distributions,
while the difference between multivariate and univariate modelling is subtle. | [
-0.0269851815,
0.0531760678,
0.0037069502,
-0.02209929,
-0.065913178,
0.0012591202,
-0.0197185259,
-0.040204227,
-0.0559517182,
0.0262307748,
-0.0282786936,
-0.0773689598,
0.1332746297,
-0.0383607335,
0.0336624756,
-0.0197087713,
-0.0224762503,
-0.0184164438,
-0.0026133023,
0.0014410008,
0.0483728945,
0.0300367251,
-0.0593523718,
0.0571081601,
-0.050201565,
0.0365942419,
-0.0011250323,
-0.0054039508,
0.0257529598,
0.0311737023,
-0.008167861,
0.0633103028,
-0.0422359668,
0.0127732446,
0.0000015386,
-0.0706034899,
0.0154489232,
0.0075147646,
-0.0207332466,
0.02996324,
0.0312402956,
0.0639856681,
-0.0200407263,
0.0122509003,
0.0466772132,
0.0251061469,
0.0758068487,
-0.0595110916,
-0.0194692723,
-0.0272985902,
-0.0214699879,
-0.0360010639,
-0.0160355512,
0.0015199523,
-0.0218110681,
0.0173329916,
0.0440466441,
-0.0418659672,
0.0391855799,
-0.0972105339,
-0.0161803197,
0.027023688,
-0.0426273644,
0.0000529106,
-0.0326614752,
0.0164028667,
0.0117728505,
-0.0545891859,
0.026405355,
0.0064369855,
-0.0126180565,
-0.0288544148,
0.0622652136,
0.0293544363,
0.0090312408,
0.0224701427,
-0.0124078384,
-0.0419418104,
-0.0269867443,
-0.0222656969,
0.0200476348,
0.0180714522,
-0.0222685896,
-0.0220333114,
-0.0007394624,
0.0386306942,
0.0719859526,
-0.0357466675,
-0.0043317247,
0.0008038814,
0.059934359,
-0.0014957972,
-0.0059406999,
0.0278357957,
-0.0393425785,
0.0023094546,
0.0175770819,
-0.0605506077,
0.0451991446,
0.006775117,
0.0163843501,
-0.0131874355,
-0.0481219031,
-0.027445592,
0.0246040262,
0.01633876,
-0.0405069552,
-0.031580504,
-0.0313077942,
0.0231308695,
0.0336938873,
-0.0254434012,
0.0191541892,
-0.057319805,
-0.0005248776,
0.0323062278,
-0.0316073857,
-0.0069429777,
-0.0197025277,
-0.0456957668,
0.0177185945,
-0.036135219,
-0.0139713138,
-0.0058077024,
0.0036657774,
0.0205483641,
-0.0179266669,
0.0578742251,
-0.0487062857,
-0.0522578582,
0.0323737077,
0.0241424646,
0.0131186172,
0.023431126,
-0.0016548886,
0.0286249779,
-0.0063140243,
0.0643984303,
0.0149176465,
0.0174538326,
-0.0878462791,
-0.0420207307,
-0.0588314049,
-0.0657051429,
0.0660453141,
-0.0358392932,
-0.0366091207,
0.0151184285,
-0.0353832841,
-0.0147164864,
0.0180327427,
0.0352025293,
0.0122659765,
0.0577011071,
0.0489426143,
-0.0082169659,
0.0204473659,
0.0486518294,
-0.0160587709,
-0.0466612838,
0.0185566191,
-0.0380420908,
0.0269003808,
0.0386546031,
0.0260512009,
-0.0138733434,
0.0006757397,
-0.063621223,
0.0068740221,
0.0134704011,
0.04114623,
0.0553853102,
-0.0268120058,
-0.0537675768,
0.0226685554,
0.0757667199,
0.0478016883,
-0.022658404,
0.0096344547,
0.0182517916,
0.0101767275,
0.0200489759,
0.0260268264,
-0.0478779636,
-0.0377556682,
0.0035761497,
0.0476765558,
0.0803734213,
-0.0063082194,
0.0079654306,
-0.0430291891,
-0.0368656181,
-0.0163619108,
0.0012417026,
0.0462445915,
-0.0351153091,
-0.0056566433,
-0.0039048302,
-0.0019475924,
-0.0460995734,
0.0556374267,
-0.0285151117,
0.0367962867,
-0.040453475,
-0.0358152315,
-0.0364350975,
0.015054225,
0.0075387694,
-0.0538956448,
0.0194161013,
-0.0212295242,
-0.0123409955,
0.0293981824,
-0.0415746793,
-0.0104182893,
0.0718800798,
0.0181168262,
0.0208614487,
-0.0270988662,
0.0421509035,
-0.0025712368,
-0.0359541625,
0.0718463287,
-0.0082786996,
0.0241952688,
0.0359315388,
-0.0289928075,
-0.0006027016,
0.0484925769,
0.0457128547,
-0.0341877863,
0.0524777584,
0.0003544132,
0.0310545173,
-0.0187989678,
0.0000755179,
0.0656731352,
0.0437803753,
0.057474874,
-0.0131484652,
0.0278987512,
-0.0392396562,
0.0459922329,
-0.0360483192,
0.01417288,
-0.046775993,
0.0602251142,
-0.0053689042,
0.0466551408,
-0.0089290123,
-0.0044718985,
-0.017293822,
0.0018238269,
0.0231384877,
-0.0033775852,
-0.0081590964,
-0.0264424272,
0.026630234,
-0.0497049391,
-0.0073320982,
0.0111451503,
-0.0480310507,
0.0337229148,
0.0162603352,
-0.067266129,
-0.0178917721,
-0.0791060254,
-0.0678279847,
-0.0238790791,
0.0406335555,
0.04505454,
-0.0065137129,
0.0157161411,
-0.0200131796,
0.0275348444,
-0.0005397268,
-0.047395248,
0.0225660484,
0.024052633,
-0.0257326718,
-0.0192442555,
-0.0346006453,
-0.0536691025,
-0.0235998966,
-0.007211545,
0.002782413,
-0.0185133461,
-0.0657750666,
-0.0136175761,
-0.026474338,
-0.0204279851,
-0.0464978442,
0.0088725444,
-0.0295113213,
0.0050145942,
-0.0071354508,
0.0944480598,
-0.0467376895,
-0.0267279427,
-0.031740766,
0.0368681252,
-0.0894540325,
0.0038998255,
-0.0177447237,
0.0188104305,
0.0428306945,
-0.0333037935,
-0.0007463327,
-0.0267803706,
0.012050312,
0.0112903165,
-0.0164349023,
-0.0283898227,
0.0046259053,
-0.0378151312,
-0.0186685659,
-0.0270256195,
-0.0573036708,
-0.0264556743,
0.0674083084,
-0.0638273433,
-0.0479000509,
-0.0076390635,
-0.0874005631,
-0.0152112395,
-0.0545557961,
-0.0103228642,
0.0010020024,
-0.0045101852,
-0.0532201715,
-0.0175586492,
-0.0037764022,
-0.0338020101,
-0.038922403,
0.0241042748,
-0.005424357,
-0.0274308454,
0.0312995128,
-0.0615725555,
0.0241861288,
0.0324262343,
0.0458781943,
0.0189546868,
-0.0007366489,
-0.0182675421,
-0.0253371056,
0.0170900188,
-0.048599951,
0.1007752642,
0.0311974976,
-0.0327897407,
-0.0232514907,
-0.0038732402,
0.0511622168,
0.0172901768,
0.0430406593,
0.0329669975,
0.0532785207,
-0.0394058712,
0.0072947806,
-0.0521807447,
-0.0548641793,
0.0251437109,
0.0442502536,
0.016715521,
-0.0225423798,
0.0338667259,
-0.0036332735,
0.0004381525,
-0.0007624085,
-0.0086642075,
0.023493316,
0.0632811561,
0.0501536988,
0.0068459813,
0.0791701749,
-0.0079239858,
-0.0308921169,
0.089754872,
-0.0183169506,
0.0012532328,
0.0102343997,
0.0460288636,
0.0455515943,
-0.0251040179,
0.0219924804,
0.0537851639,
-0.0047319271,
-0.0948613733,
-0.025615653,
0.0082642213,
-0.0512306802,
0.0126925642,
-0.000051748,
0.026054902,
-0.0214188118,
-0.04109874,
0.0515384786,
-0.0144906705,
-0.0182675831,
0.030815579,
-0.0797277763,
-0.0154003697,
-0.0253086351,
-0.0711943135,
0.0260700155,
-0.0034303088,
0.0045412127,
-0.0420868583,
-0.0483470671,
0.0154821277,
-0.0242657568,
-0.0699484497,
0.0029608852,
0.0285283048,
0.0745721906,
0.0017807377,
-0.0503980182,
0.0134315491,
-0.0083768982,
0.0024934902,
-0.0214335751,
0.0279657561,
0.0202205162,
0.0025648349,
0.0165999625,
0.0417919792,
-0.0110862395,
0.0180465244,
0.0444648601,
-0.0514870845,
0.0053987321,
0.027501978,
-0.0024105143,
0.043836236,
-0.0093860701,
0.0318448208,
0.0417105593,
-0.1255756319,
-0.0669030175,
-0.0172216203,
-0.0296187308,
0.0561350286,
0.0561312065,
0.0495840684,
-0.0106199719,
-0.0081148902,
0.0071302676,
-0.0156014673,
0.0402681231,
0.0669141039,
-0.0243174806,
0.0550622642,
0.0207631011,
0.0219951235,
-0.0385530517,
-0.0085800551,
-0.0576255172,
-0.0772177428,
0.0511871912,
-0.0015800321,
0.0325091258,
-0.013089261,
-0.0466799587,
-0.0376671068,
0.0429072343,
-0.0202995036,
0.0405457243,
0.0472461879,
0.0236674305,
-0.0219812058,
0.0388666056,
0.0060363053,
-0.0190344062,
-0.0051432392,
-0.0886149257,
-0.0269847214,
-0.0174712949,
-0.0600806549,
-0.0125049194,
-0.0183526129,
0.0144194001,
-0.032712549,
0.0063678706,
-0.0398112126,
-0.0336258225,
0.0072840597,
0.0429519266,
0.0266362242,
-0.0958053768,
0.0340856388,
0.0192419365,
-0.0169073101,
-0.0800637156,
-0.0365788229,
-0.0100203147,
0.0237137787,
0.028238913,
0.0385556966,
0.0397056118,
-0.0002167986,
0.0082588848,
0.0177140757,
0.0319574475,
-0.0512715057,
0.0085951872,
-0.0045374306,
-0.0527446792,
-0.0261757001,
-0.0425137244,
0.0525524803,
0.0152331488,
0.0442924649,
-0.0025171535,
0.0064864163,
-0.0254989229,
0.0282005947,
-0.0297559574,
0.0596810505,
-0.0022944871,
0.0118687572,
-0.0426577143,
0.0027908906,
-0.0302738901,
0.0429591909,
0.0294725057,
-0.0018085606,
-0.0168866422,
-0.0086974502,
0.0084959995,
-0.033303313,
0.0204255097,
-0.0501766056,
0.0137291811,
0.0143266153,
-0.0530248955,
-0.0300498866,
-0.0330125093,
-0.0408933498,
-0.0277950112,
-0.0528245606,
-0.0532307886,
0.0403813906,
0.0259245541,
0.0384989269,
0.0135818087,
-0.001173479,
-0.0017004752,
-0.0406374708,
0.0552139319,
0.0393170305,
-0.0327584893,
0.0127068423,
-0.0132071329,
0.056686569,
-5.54945777e-33,
-0.0099566299,
-0.0088086249,
-0.0128622074,
-0.030134825,
-0.0215231553,
0.021591967,
0.0174193829,
0.0197510887,
-0.0241752099,
-0.0006872828,
0.0357023366,
-0.0146313198,
0.0155855333,
-0.0159049425,
0.0201587658,
0.0206342693,
0.0045222952,
0.0483122282,
0.0293470379,
-0.0740648508,
0.0044097831,
-0.0101098288,
-0.0069355201,
-0.0402255431,
0.0128722778,
0.0188936945,
-0.0462850221,
0.0167848803,
-0.0346124098,
0.0433669388,
0.0024127981,
0.0498056784,
-0.0059582898,
0.030560283,
0.0110563207,
0.046808783,
-0.0153525239,
-0.0307725221,
0.0315582268,
0.0264171828,
0.0335671157,
0.0039463835,
0.0124969371,
0.0210672002,
-0.0289507434,
-0.0036016218,
-0.0015479013,
-0.0083855577,
0.0440647267,
0.0023797024,
-0.0404160917,
-0.0169726163,
-0.0040307613,
-0.0197276976,
0.0706028715,
0.025600452,
0.0070063537,
-0.0611435138,
-0.0269804541,
0.0421044119,
0.0383770168,
0.0648290515,
0.0708708316,
0.0174093992,
-0.028950287,
-0.0005033926,
0.0298478585,
-0.0982532576,
0.0210726205,
0.0017555859,
0.0313969031,
0.0398428552,
-0.0030535087,
0.0011822804,
0.0185940396,
-0.0173923317,
-0.0001663975,
0.0375875831,
0.0705835074,
0.008891942,
-0.0651153401,
0.0471103303,
-0.0142048718,
-0.0141493455,
-0.0178528782,
-0.0255729351,
-0.0239253137,
0.0364732221,
0.0273694955,
-0.0510522872,
0.0161569603,
0.0382467099,
0.0283175092,
-0.0044828015,
-0.0081693614,
-0.0176871773,
0.0123247821,
0.0146491555,
0.0049409461,
0.0120232552,
0.0505127907,
-0.0195011552,
0.0385880135,
0.0598803572,
0.0251168124,
-0.0275037102,
-0.0471736975,
-0.0124614909,
-0.0736559629,
0.0292509198,
0.0064120912,
-0.0195727069,
0.0284284744,
-0.0006480894,
0.0747684762,
-0.0173773058,
0.012624843,
-0.0245462116,
0.0549486652,
0.0005644452,
0.0133704832,
0.0077859485,
-0.017643217,
-0.013375259,
0.0023388898,
0.030253524,
0.0469668247,
-0.0376677141,
0.008319661,
-0.0044971206,
-0.0180359222,
0.0081777023,
2.554e-7,
0.0117488345,
0.0100200269,
0.0724540129,
-0.0078089423,
0.0049986551,
-0.031110853,
-0.0603581741,
-0.0214639585,
-0.0118980231,
-0.0023171229,
0.0184642673,
-0.0450620241,
0.0968459547,
0.0261583887,
-0.0350860357,
-0.0520928577,
-0.0293110143,
0.0141983172,
-0.0801579282,
0.0287139993,
0.0149251558,
0.0253683608,
-0.008759534,
-0.0504536964,
-0.0128502622,
0.011707183,
-0.0055119484,
-0.0200477391,
0.028684184,
0.0351079889,
0.028876042,
-0.0726522356,
0.0413398445,
0.0565644652,
-0.0324271619,
0.0375694819,
0.0582096875,
-0.0120253665,
-0.0329108611,
0.0359348096,
0.036781095,
0.0356998406,
-0.0499248579,
-0.0375030152,
0.0397437029,
0.0530574918,
0.0086320145,
-0.0332933739,
-0.0194623843,
0.0006740059,
0.0611823499,
0.018967608,
0.0084741674,
-0.0138149234,
0.0051468117,
-0.0164279416,
0.0006659935,
0.0198035911,
-0.0223777834,
0.0586961694,
-0.0503880866,
-0.0114947418,
0.0417058766,
0.0009421711,
-0.0011479976,
-0.0597130656,
-0.0038968909,
1.958489531e-34,
0.0355784297,
-0.0362267792,
0.0587201826,
0.0175665114,
0.0184637289,
-0.0047669932,
0.044458162,
0.0405747369,
0.0014004721,
-0.0154876085,
-0.0143845305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16316v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16316v1 | Does Cross-Cultural Alignment Change the Commonsense Morality of Language Models? | 2024-06-24T04:50:12 | 2024-06-24T04:50:12 | Yuu Jinnai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Alignment of the language model with human preferences is a common approach
to making a language model useful to end users. However, most alignment work is
done in English, and human preference datasets are dominated by English,
reflecting only the preferences of English-speaking annotators. Nevertheless,
it is common practice to use the English preference data, either directly or by
translating it into the target language, when aligning a multilingual language
model. The question is whether such an alignment strategy marginalizes the
preference of non-English speaking users. To this end, we investigate the
effect of aligning Japanese language models with (mostly) English resources. In
particular, we focus on evaluating whether the commonsense morality of the
resulting fine-tuned models is aligned with Japanese culture using the
JCommonsenseMorality (JCM) and ETHICS datasets. The experimental results show
that the fine-tuned model outperforms the SFT model. However, it does not
demonstrate the same level of improvement as a model fine-tuned using the JCM,
suggesting that while some aspects of commonsense morality are transferable,
others may not be. | [
0.0543125793,
0.0817430019,
-0.0230170283,
0.0180270225,
-0.0345991328,
0.0264495332,
0.0209197532,
-0.0083719967,
0.0151188066,
0.0061301985,
-0.0663256869,
-0.0253545195,
0.0173728261,
-0.0366580151,
-0.02520914,
-0.0401828848,
0.0491255522,
0.0266885478,
0.0234556664,
-0.0299621187,
0.0368464775,
0.0396722257,
0.042643629,
0.0249279346,
0.015024757,
-0.0110083465,
0.0508675389,
-0.0270939842,
0.05326543,
0.0040182723,
0.0253590718,
0.0509019792,
-0.0057804058,
0.0139395865,
0.0000018114,
-0.0572464578,
0.0205304697,
-0.0004263686,
0.0376940742,
0.0466605835,
0.0817925632,
0.0055558798,
-0.0226722192,
-0.0073321653,
-0.0473750681,
0.0351891443,
0.0565783344,
0.0012787376,
0.0264748149,
0.020096289,
-0.0106064817,
-0.0183126368,
-0.0210116338,
-0.015081401,
-0.0273222793,
0.0054950123,
0.0201997533,
0.0344939455,
-0.0442653261,
-0.0002338876,
-0.0030015178,
0.0079149976,
-0.0051316787,
-0.0007650841,
-0.0372223444,
-0.0273401923,
-0.0306672081,
-0.0143830618,
0.027638929,
0.0441733599,
0.0626144633,
-0.0074713901,
-0.0028350954,
0.0214038473,
0.0140988715,
0.025444556,
0.0080759712,
0.0064103738,
0.0018437739,
0.0244842283,
0.0836556703,
-0.0068282867,
0.0067596552,
0.0513814427,
0.0341351219,
0.0454486832,
-0.0018015372,
-0.0261716079,
-0.008506679,
-0.0104983626,
-0.0298416503,
-0.0386187471,
0.0137715135,
-0.0174982287,
-0.0039270427,
0.0365708545,
-0.0045053558,
0.0335142091,
0.0483256839,
-0.0945384502,
0.0045949812,
0.054448206,
-0.0054423339,
0.0096626943,
0.0528410897,
0.0303830728,
-0.0082071545,
0.0432515107,
-0.0421630293,
0.0231231824,
0.0051272972,
-0.0151446881,
0.0520494543,
-0.0132082915,
-0.0142751047,
0.0500560291,
-0.0940435529,
-0.0093053095,
-0.052626539,
0.0218996387,
0.0079647191,
-0.0255617481,
-0.0453195758,
-0.014448951,
-0.0469160043,
0.0555326045,
-0.0490960851,
0.0275682453,
-0.0092850113,
-0.0019276455,
0.0655059442,
-0.0229334496,
-0.0428495109,
-0.0239891652,
0.0085489508,
0.0679289103,
0.0150495162,
0.0262054019,
-0.0130324522,
0.0083077317,
-0.0352003984,
-0.0301001109,
-0.0264683515,
-0.066693455,
0.0275222771,
0.0223558601,
-0.0126350001,
-0.0576612167,
0.0037254542,
0.0198219512,
-0.0228849817,
0.0406190492,
0.0061902273,
0.0310653802,
0.0085027581,
0.0006756886,
-0.0148597667,
0.0751912668,
-0.0109912651,
-0.0076211565,
0.0574535839,
-0.0187172294,
-0.037411429,
0.0279510487,
-0.0409837179,
0.0345059969,
-0.0522202663,
0.0147026246,
-0.0151120825,
0.0052459417,
0.068970941,
0.0212523509,
-0.0123016518,
-0.0057134465,
0.0452964529,
0.084884271,
-0.0091209812,
0.0320477523,
-0.0148351267,
0.0005132926,
-0.0217810031,
0.0400885046,
-0.0573598966,
0.0058837533,
-0.0248745345,
0.0123327551,
-0.044164151,
0.0556504466,
-0.0142986868,
-0.0390659049,
-0.0076084426,
-0.0089833215,
0.0586567149,
0.0108822305,
0.0153059633,
-0.0235095583,
0.0279797111,
0.0157121792,
0.0750911608,
-0.0651873946,
-0.0226615425,
0.0137012536,
0.0401143208,
0.0844732299,
-0.0101333149,
0.0152958659,
-0.0104244808,
-0.0023173913,
-0.01277899,
0.0540875942,
0.0734537914,
-0.0298222229,
-0.0288727917,
-0.0493162982,
-0.0406576768,
0.0018808579,
-0.0185472071,
0.0190173816,
-0.0126891918,
0.0302385651,
0.0083376728,
-0.0222171359,
-0.0543088242,
-0.013071198,
-0.0301762708,
0.0445368588,
-0.0730538592,
0.0291158743,
0.0591378883,
-0.0078706229,
0.0000349297,
-0.0227450579,
-0.02559058,
-0.0006960317,
0.043726977,
0.0655910894,
-0.015599668,
0.0174101088,
0.0552884601,
-0.054904338,
-0.0247853398,
0.0427176617,
-0.0089078993,
0.0191818345,
-0.0500832349,
0.0202609412,
0.0267189257,
-0.0634337962,
-0.0065886783,
-0.0677897558,
-0.0130181564,
-0.0164024737,
0.027165873,
-0.0486918949,
0.0307506658,
-0.0065103471,
-0.0792150497,
0.0451385565,
-0.0059311297,
-0.0502945185,
0.0441771708,
-0.0023227797,
0.0407256186,
0.0659858137,
0.0430664457,
-0.0121006696,
-0.0058123609,
-0.0853432044,
-0.0176381022,
0.012521687,
0.00988816,
0.0045014829,
-0.0005766555,
-0.0190765876,
0.0171497427,
-0.0704494491,
-0.0096664913,
0.0026465433,
0.0548229739,
0.025635872,
-0.0380243734,
0.014984603,
-0.0098397853,
-0.0206615776,
-0.0116635896,
-0.0403197892,
-0.0120249614,
0.0143420622,
-0.0280978419,
0.028740244,
-0.0842493773,
-0.0275372639,
-0.0043659662,
-0.092262201,
0.0019297255,
0.0539357886,
0.0050074733,
0.0531060286,
0.0376739502,
0.0062580076,
0.0463313125,
0.0236417819,
-0.0523151346,
-0.0283664782,
0.0086605512,
-0.0178152025,
-0.0228196867,
-0.0676607713,
-0.0125689898,
0.048059389,
-0.0317089297,
0.0053848596,
-0.0496889874,
-0.000477667,
-0.0588783547,
-0.036121022,
-0.0093830731,
-0.0144741051,
-0.0119362669,
0.0720181689,
-0.0141894249,
-0.0496939793,
0.0754402429,
0.0330489278,
0.0215237346,
-0.0395069085,
0.0204927195,
-0.0053459588,
0.0050787786,
-0.0323077738,
0.0541323982,
-0.0172201693,
-0.0440783799,
-0.0447814241,
-0.0071829828,
0.0827888101,
-0.0493281148,
0.056368541,
0.0004470123,
-0.0069603152,
-0.0279222392,
-0.0713718832,
-0.017743798,
-0.0555417538,
-0.0056170598,
-0.0188647583,
0.0297512002,
0.0047777919,
0.0037246682,
0.0240382776,
0.0207236074,
-0.0188585781,
0.0111320019,
0.0301938467,
0.0270109884,
-0.0562180504,
0.0529778823,
0.0184753183,
0.0066107502,
-0.0034298738,
0.0044741239,
0.0118675288,
-0.0138534959,
-0.0389308333,
0.0563588329,
0.0373864584,
0.0788851455,
-0.0001284632,
-0.0337857902,
0.0265004206,
0.0705665946,
-0.0110928128,
0.0256501157,
0.0742606446,
0.0151347918,
-0.0554126129,
-0.0180417094,
-0.0539912842,
-0.003013436,
0.0126127396,
0.0201120004,
-0.0738657787,
0.0092260735,
-0.0058459984,
0.0184277929,
-0.0371431187,
-0.0206869803,
0.0278577525,
-0.0937207714,
-0.0193010531,
0.0414245389,
-0.0898458213,
-0.0238013826,
-0.0050864173,
0.0006511641,
-0.0368499309,
0.0746010467,
-0.0275553055,
0.0072353855,
-0.0394388735,
-0.0123538245,
0.013016412,
-0.0511356704,
0.0348835289,
-0.028328741,
0.0555503033,
0.0662005097,
0.0439085662,
-0.0124818478,
-0.076548323,
-0.0176301301,
0.0284595564,
-0.0145270526,
-0.0034764614,
-0.0367863588,
-0.0137151331,
-0.0236398969,
-0.0517515317,
0.0205760077,
0.0207551233,
-0.0161019396,
-0.0039968388,
0.0354103222,
0.0321533494,
-0.0017299325,
-0.0263640471,
0.01357025,
-0.0001951674,
0.0649286434,
-0.0062763463,
-0.067409128,
0.0378295854,
-0.0465833582,
-0.054198321,
0.0141952997,
-0.0280723497,
0.0011826378,
-0.0285203177,
-0.0524048582,
-0.0595924444,
-0.0728484169,
-0.0515265651,
0.0085949646,
0.0595068783,
-0.0217205398,
0.0278284475,
0.003145345,
-0.0016332789,
0.0263810363,
-0.0273554996,
0.0033621334,
-0.0198262818,
0.0177386571,
0.0118227918,
-0.0142864939,
0.010701743,
-0.0230005626,
0.0772504658,
-0.0551158935,
0.011159895,
0.0570366569,
0.014739939,
0.0296669565,
0.0069077513,
-0.0047438331,
-0.0311978534,
0.0575340651,
-0.0436116569,
0.0040750541,
0.0450830795,
0.0244761631,
0.0015382249,
0.0302720331,
-0.0135674849,
-0.0067122076,
0.026424991,
0.0206028372,
-0.0571201965,
-0.0193559136,
0.0382724851,
0.0295200069,
-0.0049545597,
-0.037830092,
0.0207062252,
-0.0375721157,
-0.0564928874,
-0.0333251432,
-0.0594246946,
-0.0087240739,
-0.0408096947,
0.0560235232,
-0.0241768099,
0.0072267307,
0.0464468189,
-0.0571409203,
-0.0023170307,
-0.0330248773,
0.025176011,
0.0194569807,
0.0702143312,
-0.0125421761,
0.0193245839,
-0.0375031531,
-0.0210297722,
0.0063078976,
0.0321477167,
0.0020267414,
0.1154286265,
0.0190963279,
-0.0038465129,
0.0444882363,
0.0158676207,
-0.007867842,
-0.0025447509,
-0.0016564991,
-0.0185747892,
0.0211778842,
-0.0546784364,
0.052085232,
-0.0058982684,
-0.024670098,
-0.0243028048,
0.045323737,
0.0014709294,
-0.0588719882,
0.0312468708,
-0.0060265651,
-0.0321491472,
-0.0393668525,
0.0498491749,
-0.0534807518,
-0.0300826561,
-0.0063132723,
-0.0335033759,
-0.0106713073,
-0.0338725485,
0.056187667,
0.0057039768,
-0.0256825462,
-0.039276801,
-0.0860435367,
-0.0627784356,
-0.0649002045,
0.0014845527,
0.002851553,
-0.0166701023,
-0.0041234647,
0.0671232119,
-0.0451287106,
0.0026737065,
-0.031321384,
0.0004683317,
-0.0709491596,
0.0221023373,
-0.0309679266,
-5.327625088e-33,
-0.0213812031,
0.0009744706,
-0.0068371431,
-0.0031752556,
-0.0161352362,
-0.0486677624,
-0.003530646,
0.0344194844,
-0.0647113621,
0.0287095495,
-0.0254142117,
-0.0024159604,
0.0106508741,
-0.0374683402,
0.0404225104,
-0.0203781743,
0.0002109365,
0.0393413007,
-0.0408593975,
-0.0220797621,
0.0296376068,
-0.0275028236,
0.0894667804,
-0.0515483171,
0.0776183084,
0.0283188876,
-0.005085194,
0.0017980324,
-0.0135692377,
0.0513123013,
0.0009223892,
0.0732334256,
0.0057589873,
-0.0086161587,
0.0065360386,
0.0319065228,
0.0063577387,
-0.020768268,
0.089760296,
0.0181072075,
0.057165157,
-0.0656783134,
0.0162920132,
-0.010056057,
-0.053987667,
0.0103486935,
0.0442637727,
-0.049094338,
-0.0308631174,
0.0105651412,
-0.058585804,
-0.0072474033,
-0.0339939892,
0.0132572427,
-0.0160786714,
0.0402902141,
-0.0106982505,
0.0094145369,
-0.0077600572,
0.0524168499,
0.0021433129,
-0.0041587432,
0.0775584057,
-0.0338202901,
0.0317457691,
0.0461190008,
-0.026160907,
0.0295611639,
0.0016457454,
0.0102105318,
0.0362618901,
0.0205916744,
0.0084631145,
0.1000716984,
-0.0109917903,
-0.0758112222,
-0.0117944963,
0.0229184665,
-0.0032721274,
0.0255114958,
0.0222764555,
0.0133438474,
-0.0620244481,
-0.0406296365,
-0.0183947757,
-0.0575800873,
-0.0221454706,
-0.0469540358,
0.0133190658,
-0.0508554801,
-0.0350590497,
-0.0080187721,
0.0154858083,
-0.0474803336,
-0.0297671147,
0.0655553043,
-0.0292297862,
-0.0112328557,
0.009777694,
0.0231222101,
-0.0509980954,
-0.0135723595,
-0.0623055957,
0.0077395793,
-0.0067914939,
0.0303093065,
0.0323837772,
-0.0101037063,
-0.0281715859,
-0.0058178958,
-0.0141795166,
-0.0156471413,
-0.00321475,
-0.0315699242,
0.0607610345,
-0.0041586142,
0.0080474475,
0.0094349207,
0.0595849939,
-0.0064546973,
-0.0504350998,
-0.0497057885,
-0.0102851875,
0.033734791,
0.0032465307,
0.001255599,
-0.0165739637,
0.0288941152,
0.0278095603,
-0.001255365,
-0.0313540213,
0.019259626,
2.432e-7,
0.0001914357,
-0.0047949282,
-0.0257237386,
-0.0099634938,
-0.0426758043,
0.0590585694,
0.0064184908,
0.024262188,
0.066958718,
-0.006403232,
0.0188383851,
-0.0091859074,
0.0798028186,
0.0115561159,
-0.0480470546,
0.0172671974,
-0.0396116786,
0.0095331045,
-0.0389170982,
0.0497639216,
-0.0213199221,
0.0380357541,
0.0101333521,
-0.0043257074,
-0.0024413669,
0.015627116,
0.0479722098,
-0.1047793999,
-0.030659724,
-0.002480722,
-0.0087829288,
-0.0095845452,
0.0059140413,
-0.0096942428,
0.0210049413,
0.0142136412,
0.0309190154,
0.0793336853,
0.0026037709,
-0.0150886355,
-0.0184767079,
-0.0293051638,
-0.0068305237,
-0.063566193,
0.0390970707,
-0.0228266343,
-0.0382089429,
-0.0431207977,
-0.0118389744,
-0.0140283341,
0.0416859947,
-0.0392187499,
-0.0182831194,
0.0018663176,
0.043161612,
0.0048674084,
-0.0111743798,
0.0072444589,
0.0023446328,
0.0267391186,
0.0227205642,
-0.0658948123,
-0.0006804497,
0.0507608838,
-0.0015953893,
-0.0372495987,
0.0456368513,
1.712977893e-34,
-0.0076390449,
-0.0292407125,
0.0360886231,
-0.0096366685,
0.0230932254,
0.0335388444,
0.019905936,
0.028588675,
0.0157273412,
0.0053101392,
0.0070710145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16315v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16315v1 | Song Data Cleansing for End-to-End Neural Singer Diarization Using Neural Analysis and Synthesis Framework | 2024-06-24T04:48:29 | 2024-06-24T04:48:29 | Hokuto Munakata, Ryo Terashima, Yusuke Fujita | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | We propose a data cleansing method that utilizes a neural analysis and
synthesis (NANSY++) framework to train an end-to-end neural diarization model
(EEND) for singer diarization. Our proposed model converts song data with
choral singing which is commonly contained in popular music and unsuitable for
generating a simulated dataset to the solo singing data. This cleansing is
based on NANSY++, which is a framework trained to reconstruct an input
non-overlapped audio signal. We exploit the pre-trained NANSY++ to convert
choral singing into clean, non-overlapped audio. This cleansing process
mitigates the mislabeling of choral singing to solo singing and helps the
effective training of EEND models even when the majority of available song data
contains choral singing sections. We experimentally evaluated the EEND model
trained with a dataset using our proposed method using annotated popular duet
songs. As a result, our proposed method improved 14.8 points in diarization
error rate. | [
-0.0347026177,
0.0719000101,
-0.0155350473,
0.0371945538,
0.0314400345,
-0.0025063797,
0.0678662509,
-0.00987902,
-0.039493829,
0.0467445776,
-0.060998477,
-0.0202174708,
0.0008067898,
0.0020420668,
0.0115391444,
-0.0309952926,
0.0377479643,
0.0081392992,
0.0211003348,
0.0081620682,
-0.0591270551,
-0.0245462768,
-0.0255941674,
0.012708338,
-0.0372744091,
-0.0229544435,
-0.015591288,
0.0118290279,
-0.002459019,
0.0054772664,
0.0114180008,
0.0071111908,
0.0052845352,
0.0332865044,
0.0000019272,
-0.0143330852,
-0.0001160184,
0.0178391393,
-0.00659006,
0.0047683194,
0.0051760096,
0.0788997114,
-0.0446060486,
0.0262971595,
0.0050619086,
-0.0170649588,
0.0009750769,
0.0323576741,
0.1144030765,
0.0730130672,
0.0264794361,
-0.0513900518,
-0.0090560382,
-0.0276181474,
-0.0110173607,
0.0313421749,
0.019980479,
-0.0600496605,
-0.0203557294,
-0.0792762041,
0.0182571225,
0.0769718885,
0.0176444687,
0.0353545696,
0.062256977,
0.0476812273,
-0.0415389985,
-0.0497186184,
0.0367372595,
-0.003566053,
0.0180077683,
0.010511633,
0.0586620159,
0.013668553,
-0.0071276133,
-0.0266682468,
-0.0049516838,
-0.0056058019,
0.0157962367,
-0.0122505594,
-0.0818325207,
-0.0076606222,
0.0814107955,
-0.0369011238,
0.0242396258,
-0.0198256243,
0.0095080389,
-0.0590595566,
0.0303244572,
-0.0238702148,
0.0137849599,
-0.0509319641,
0.0419997089,
0.0121937031,
-0.0128827905,
-0.0393152349,
-0.0232737344,
-0.0074346182,
-0.0391689166,
0.0110604558,
0.0555295311,
-0.0414281413,
-0.0141416099,
0.030525215,
0.0087142773,
-0.0157653727,
-0.0154588344,
-0.0164237488,
0.003193435,
0.012500979,
-0.0067579765,
-0.0111430204,
-0.0138423992,
0.0145543376,
0.0501867384,
0.019307401,
-0.0117373727,
-0.0440578572,
-0.110093981,
-0.0040660966,
0.0134301931,
0.0068637491,
0.0056013884,
-0.0087568806,
-0.0047624572,
0.0041601532,
0.0041196072,
0.0384782515,
-0.0102828182,
0.0478262343,
0.0242960025,
0.0196182057,
0.004712278,
0.0209849942,
0.0662380308,
-0.0257035047,
0.0362058915,
-0.0158535689,
-0.0095555848,
-0.0007188067,
-0.0089148581,
-0.0491779409,
-0.0110064242,
-0.0866868347,
0.0284813605,
-0.0876608118,
-0.0076349494,
-0.0495443866,
-0.0242558531,
0.0146050202,
0.0095766485,
0.0359194167,
0.0028746652,
0.047784593,
0.010283432,
0.028662527,
-0.0061598034,
0.0052951258,
0.054605592,
0.0091828676,
0.0236610267,
-0.0282559358,
0.0403014272,
0.0439175144,
0.0093265148,
-0.0282976683,
-0.0561329313,
-0.041503381,
0.0015087713,
0.0467223153,
0.0319386534,
0.007545663,
0.0107716629,
-0.0383787826,
0.0091356104,
0.0234041661,
0.0630883723,
0.044047609,
0.0255501475,
0.0226996411,
0.0416230112,
0.0141251525,
-0.011298852,
0.0581479371,
0.0300176293,
-0.0315554887,
0.061399933,
0.0337802954,
-0.0351224467,
-0.011905428,
0.0439177901,
-0.015390561,
-0.0335276239,
0.0302498583,
-0.0262636803,
0.0106529035,
0.0224679075,
0.0144310789,
0.0026254512,
-0.0994851217,
0.0398213826,
-0.0243541766,
-0.0079586972,
0.0393468924,
0.0195966419,
-0.0330598988,
0.0350817405,
-0.0389752649,
-0.0359107144,
0.0030609542,
-0.0674650967,
-0.0555520244,
0.0553976633,
-0.0282730032,
-0.0276546292,
0.0155998915,
-0.0068843374,
-0.0190255735,
-0.0330294594,
-0.0447046272,
0.0067407866,
0.017312929,
0.0370025747,
0.017905701,
-0.0423961692,
-0.0364662856,
0.0164072122,
0.0573513843,
0.0288104545,
0.0853524059,
-0.0275123157,
-0.0120183052,
0.0164225064,
0.0265195575,
0.0116206696,
-0.0587272868,
-0.043940194,
-0.0369003639,
0.0390219241,
-0.0032949666,
-0.0289293285,
0.067414321,
-0.0070192707,
-0.0378698409,
0.0346593596,
0.0316093341,
-0.0607652068,
0.0087147625,
0.0103594223,
-0.0241836943,
-0.0255527105,
0.0368285775,
0.0017596683,
0.0470043384,
0.0279266555,
0.0158898942,
0.0083514797,
0.0368827097,
-0.0596747175,
-0.0820378065,
0.0336590335,
-0.0165329613,
0.0372038297,
-0.0291757435,
-0.0536383837,
0.0059733605,
-0.0277205184,
-0.0595353581,
0.0538068973,
-0.0177150257,
-0.0385298692,
-0.0051001855,
-0.008740766,
0.0033245147,
-0.0022088194,
0.0009518591,
-0.0087429266,
-0.0084195659,
-0.0037002994,
-0.0355863683,
-0.0099152233,
-0.0866287053,
0.0391670577,
-0.0003742605,
-0.0108008822,
-0.0242670197,
-0.021584427,
-0.030178709,
0.0116943233,
-0.0176021308,
-0.0059899865,
0.0186592024,
0.0163552072,
0.0249877628,
-0.0114140892,
0.0051387791,
-0.0100663844,
0.0265522487,
0.0047703097,
-0.0613589361,
0.0918583497,
0.0096675893,
0.0032827954,
0.0173795018,
0.0465508252,
0.0422042571,
0.0007247805,
-0.0321480408,
0.0412124172,
-0.0039899098,
0.0579361767,
-0.0117669664,
0.0114679364,
0.0368382558,
-0.0316166207,
-0.0120163132,
-0.0393559746,
0.013481142,
-0.0539057031,
0.0177384,
-0.037099421,
-0.0135827232,
0.0194610916,
0.0155029632,
-0.0200176295,
-0.0136362165,
-0.0505664647,
-0.0051569324,
-0.0481188446,
-0.045814164,
0.0213556401,
0.0233857576,
-0.0537981428,
-0.0674446523,
-0.0119043002,
-0.0177405123,
-0.0726024881,
0.0442318469,
-0.026008103,
-0.0108915819,
-0.0119928829,
-0.0086906077,
-0.0190145206,
-0.0022997097,
0.0640970692,
0.0193127841,
-0.06707187,
-0.0184697565,
0.0624255277,
-0.0246414319,
0.0094086276,
0.0331500843,
0.0185284559,
0.0351873226,
0.0238012262,
0.0608769767,
-0.065876022,
-0.0376193449,
-0.0387882032,
-0.0259442329,
0.0099887783,
0.0018584451,
0.0348350368,
0.0248452798,
-0.0553976372,
-0.020334553,
-0.0287820566,
0.0031080048,
-0.0071683927,
0.0179923307,
-0.0434883162,
-0.0395493843,
0.0370802134,
0.0679726601,
0.0109120412,
-0.0709552541,
-0.0156907272,
0.0957119912,
-0.0383044891,
0.0237838719,
-0.0125815794,
0.0146068055,
0.0292031765,
0.0385093316,
0.0428470895,
0.0584706143,
0.0214847662,
-0.0204910412,
-0.0353861265,
0.027454488,
0.0144027239,
-0.0097834282,
-0.0282955654,
-0.0118556274,
0.0010547643,
-0.0166253746,
-0.0084672254,
0.0259798374,
-0.0029454348,
-0.0052784272,
-0.0044120736,
-0.0073961625,
-0.0492536612,
-0.0315773003,
-0.0983747616,
0.0934410617,
0.0130710965,
0.0568214618,
-0.0042525292,
-0.0149433967,
0.0038023351,
-0.010003618,
0.0066432627,
0.0359100178,
0.0867557153,
0.0599658415,
0.0321554653,
0.0232709087,
-0.0125186099,
-0.0392399542,
-0.0010514278,
0.0213568434,
0.039100714,
0.023377588,
0.0001029159,
0.0077765789,
0.0399383307,
0.0169738922,
0.0747849047,
0.051038567,
-0.0054289326,
0.0184086245,
0.0548729599,
0.0174992532,
-0.0296371654,
-0.0274355691,
0.0064466675,
-0.0233964361,
-0.0781937987,
-0.0283719562,
0.000744678,
-0.0215454027,
0.0160770863,
0.0201614462,
0.0420013927,
-0.0343245044,
-0.0409188494,
-0.0309942625,
0.0296563599,
-0.0148946736,
0.059956912,
-0.0246850476,
-0.0650457218,
-0.0086488398,
0.0269915462,
-0.0068195066,
-0.0415592417,
-0.062869668,
-0.0157472007,
0.027710652,
-0.0332266055,
0.0142668756,
0.0688424781,
-0.0121993041,
-0.0268850159,
0.0004140137,
0.0227360763,
0.0273157153,
0.0284087583,
0.0426092409,
-0.0063838186,
-0.0048773233,
0.0112001719,
-0.036512319,
0.0607186295,
0.0211516172,
-0.0223929882,
0.0052666836,
-0.0352140106,
-0.0135962712,
0.0003030377,
0.0092382375,
0.0295644049,
0.0250819884,
-0.0636047423,
-0.020441344,
-0.0201688465,
-0.0021384417,
-0.0077497507,
-0.0129886111,
0.0696098432,
0.0521334521,
-0.0188729949,
0.0076108593,
-0.0034067475,
-0.0590289682,
-0.079014793,
0.0073350966,
0.0235964581,
-0.0176612437,
0.0035012895,
0.0352546051,
0.0344397649,
0.0102321859,
0.0710574389,
-0.026143061,
0.0240134634,
-0.01818005,
0.0031894932,
0.0030453829,
-0.0579484925,
0.0303292889,
-0.0365327969,
-0.0480390228,
-0.01507119,
-0.0390746109,
0.0305761937,
0.0249487273,
-0.0223933198,
0.0356898643,
-0.0059181992,
0.0121029094,
0.006743208,
-0.0044624377,
-0.0055174688,
-0.0243207347,
-0.0018629027,
-0.0070998957,
-0.0239391271,
0.0533313714,
-0.0371122845,
0.0224897191,
-0.0610580593,
0.0117362756,
0.0264570471,
0.0123653123,
-0.0069253738,
-0.0221698377,
-0.0324452408,
-0.0258242693,
0.0134687144,
-0.0560806915,
-0.0226231497,
-0.0138622383,
0.040589612,
0.0024567179,
0.0056167585,
-0.021267103,
0.0049540694,
0.0233451631,
0.034263283,
-0.0497374646,
0.0082919151,
-0.0428368971,
-0.0370270275,
-5.31993809e-33,
0.007015815,
0.0581467599,
0.0138005652,
-0.0061007817,
-0.0406298377,
-0.0147520415,
-0.0537449047,
-0.0360802636,
0.0172024928,
-0.0061189295,
-0.0116362181,
0.0631679446,
-0.0057966718,
-0.0092315096,
0.0147947976,
-0.0012855328,
0.1407761425,
-0.0187158957,
-0.0547583513,
0.0288490243,
0.0772911981,
0.0492305346,
-0.0343483984,
-0.1066273451,
-0.0652981177,
0.0031336001,
-0.0261351708,
0.039520964,
-0.0202052183,
0.0034699168,
-0.0310626663,
-0.0058616283,
0.0293738488,
-0.0126283728,
-0.0284821205,
0.0391803943,
-0.0557712652,
-0.0461181402,
-0.0664315671,
0.0056639039,
0.0197192803,
-0.0417737663,
0.0615917444,
-0.01110732,
-0.0572460406,
0.0022856235,
0.0688776374,
-0.0183436312,
0.0014754435,
-0.0665179566,
0.0174623765,
-0.0102435034,
0.0075961677,
-0.0525408685,
0.061341051,
0.0190968066,
-0.0232070088,
0.0094805369,
-0.0596177541,
0.0014516896,
0.0124227107,
0.0087114619,
0.0351376496,
0.0658761263,
-0.0175300799,
0.0329151228,
0.1064077616,
-0.0389489494,
0.0251817629,
-0.016716009,
-0.0049166367,
0.0550019778,
0.0258330014,
-0.0184589643,
0.0900843218,
-0.0516408719,
0.0039997068,
0.036966946,
-0.0063817734,
-0.0384423025,
-0.0281114783,
0.041961439,
-0.0275909938,
-0.0183767285,
-0.0184587575,
-0.0517787524,
-0.0622737668,
-0.0087885866,
0.0253117625,
0.0060316236,
-0.0264433287,
-0.0020035212,
-0.0275527462,
-0.0076087718,
0.0348651037,
0.0040924181,
0.0148100266,
0.0066276086,
0.0434243456,
-0.0625211596,
-0.0224417392,
-0.0289917141,
0.0924772024,
0.017358046,
0.0494609997,
-0.0337733291,
0.0035993294,
0.0691187009,
-0.041885294,
0.0066735656,
-0.0040047569,
-0.0080636069,
0.0599185936,
0.0017524835,
0.018674776,
0.0159261841,
0.0147713237,
0.0138440244,
0.0400651693,
0.0360431559,
-0.0054979194,
-0.0205134172,
-0.0088320933,
0.004597106,
0.0370845832,
0.0136097288,
0.00406641,
-0.0271916352,
0.0448563546,
-0.0353669338,
-0.0110243866,
-0.0163130779,
2.793e-7,
-0.0074430825,
-0.0571063682,
0.0130452467,
-0.0330979116,
0.0379474685,
0.0232612435,
-0.1153002679,
-0.0178990718,
0.0024420545,
0.0196965877,
0.0369992182,
-0.0539722592,
0.0760273039,
0.0477246083,
-0.0804517269,
-0.0282081421,
-0.015406183,
0.0272365287,
-0.0433181748,
-0.018818561,
-0.0189361125,
0.0261908602,
0.0480910204,
-0.073698774,
0.0075927489,
-0.0184059385,
-0.0021545163,
0.0018829374,
0.0001249967,
-0.0529929511,
0.0232318733,
-0.0342865773,
0.0356184877,
0.0184934679,
-0.0399478525,
0.0529420786,
0.0328811705,
0.0211677812,
0.031143399,
0.0192955863,
0.0026358652,
0.049444478,
0.0116211362,
0.0230482277,
0.0572454147,
-0.0202856138,
-0.034494292,
-0.0456472002,
-0.0800206661,
0.0116929058,
-0.00252686,
0.0404039249,
-0.0169855896,
-0.0335102566,
-0.0258445293,
-0.0025681912,
0.0391006581,
-0.0605383217,
0.0058392705,
0.02866593,
-0.0905404016,
-0.0121694105,
0.0305618551,
-0.0041683563,
0.0068865572,
-0.0517471917,
0.0228978544,
2.04877691e-34,
0.0230919328,
-0.0418256782,
0.0083127227,
-0.0203641169,
0.0066341115,
-0.0269479901,
-0.0374433286,
-0.0447232202,
-0.0294437017,
0.0096660275,
-0.0359511189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16308v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16308v1 | Anomaly Detection of Tabular Data Using LLMs | 2024-06-24T04:17:03 | 2024-06-24T04:17:03 | Aodong Li, Yunhan Zhao, Chen Qiu, Marius Kloft, Padhraic Smyth, Maja Rudolph, Stephan Mandt | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown their potential in long-context
understanding and mathematical reasoning. In this paper, we study the problem
of using LLMs to detect tabular anomalies and show that pre-trained LLMs are
zero-shot batch-level anomaly detectors. That is, without extra
distribution-specific model fitting, they can discover hidden outliers in a
batch of data, demonstrating their ability to identify low-density data
regions. For LLMs that are not well aligned with anomaly detection and
frequently output factual errors, we apply simple yet effective data-generating
processes to simulate synthetic batch-level anomaly detection datasets and
propose an end-to-end fine-tuning strategy to bring out the potential of LLMs
in detecting real anomalies. Experiments on a large anomaly detection benchmark
(ODDS) showcase i) GPT-4 has on-par performance with the state-of-the-art
transductive learning-based anomaly detection methods and ii) the efficacy of
our synthetic dataset and fine-tuning strategy in aligning LLMs to this task. | [
0.0012154969,
0.0398807526,
-0.0225694571,
0.0843972862,
-0.0221546143,
0.0253144037,
0.0076087951,
0.0234950632,
-0.003271461,
-0.0065807845,
0.026621338,
-0.0588044412,
-0.0286717173,
0.0639312267,
0.0365317985,
0.0503778718,
0.057539653,
-0.0376455076,
0.0244444106,
0.0031721361,
-0.0326599479,
-0.047170382,
0.0181977544,
-0.0242767744,
0.0026364045,
-0.0060947929,
-0.0154108526,
0.003240898,
0.0271539204,
0.0008562172,
0.0086879116,
0.0279163644,
0.024907846,
0.1249833182,
0.0000021427,
-0.0088636447,
-0.0497746915,
-0.0174647868,
0.005419991,
0.0209482759,
-0.0416504927,
-0.0934733525,
-0.0318475217,
-0.0131104495,
-0.024532048,
-0.0232333206,
0.0023829374,
0.0213230103,
0.0426024795,
0.1045171693,
-0.01967787,
-0.0100878961,
0.009095937,
-0.0116370264,
0.0489382483,
-0.0156247402,
0.0487335138,
-0.0178411249,
0.0007206593,
-0.0191535354,
-0.0211956277,
-0.0231200159,
0.0341510326,
-0.0239880327,
0.0129441712,
0.0322417133,
-0.0287159085,
0.0189242624,
0.0135288406,
0.0673935339,
-0.0780273452,
-0.005818279,
0.0381112322,
-0.0210028719,
0.0297113247,
-0.0377110131,
-0.0184840616,
0.0311582889,
-0.0288397241,
0.0305312146,
0.0384206027,
-0.0161644053,
0.0170653462,
0.0005806548,
-0.0636810437,
0.0305167567,
-0.0218605101,
-0.0711414292,
-0.0726631209,
-0.0027029854,
-0.0106156264,
-0.0249812361,
-0.0009543322,
0.0394280404,
-0.0632770285,
-0.0121694263,
-0.0222481228,
-0.0571080074,
0.0418577269,
-0.0293127615,
0.0581649728,
0.00487138,
-0.0513644442,
0.0257711895,
-0.0111010456,
0.077355884,
-0.0361985452,
0.0689271465,
-0.0057954276,
-0.0021920451,
0.004170612,
-0.0026094124,
0.0084074251,
0.0093005514,
-0.0440702811,
0.0150485141,
-0.0114670349,
0.0387626626,
0.0189234596,
0.044425115,
-0.0044671232,
-0.0413602702,
-0.0128566334,
-0.0332522355,
0.0180784669,
-0.0236674026,
0.0047174296,
0.0056788246,
-0.0326380357,
-0.0797157958,
-0.0594601594,
0.0454315953,
-0.0420828983,
-0.0356436297,
0.0264470298,
0.0315038785,
0.008416933,
-0.0045173327,
-0.0946327373,
-0.024746757,
-0.0495368131,
-0.0295907855,
-0.0137293851,
-0.0481765531,
-0.0235517211,
-0.0247620158,
0.0111196944,
0.0085629169,
0.0194054767,
0.003815236,
-0.021884989,
0.0455759466,
-0.0346789882,
0.0170665849,
-0.0143804252,
-0.0191931538,
0.0098325228,
0.0554753058,
0.0184035394,
-0.0172440819,
0.008363327,
-0.0335608125,
0.0682689101,
0.0188704561,
0.0345233902,
0.0037243711,
-0.0502003916,
0.0354987495,
0.0162461009,
0.0007473173,
0.0553321615,
-0.0073222513,
0.030922221,
-0.0530455224,
0.0399926379,
0.0099361995,
-0.0415415578,
0.0327379219,
-0.0034332045,
-0.0133385267,
-0.0643381029,
0.0144563094,
-0.0014653844,
0.0057594357,
-0.046710223,
-0.031372983,
0.009715667,
0.0188923031,
-0.0400882401,
-0.04213202,
-0.0303454902,
-0.0089135859,
-0.0545728058,
-0.0409268737,
0.0578162596,
-0.0070328214,
-0.0211477634,
-0.0469003357,
-0.0042776749,
-0.0138898548,
-0.0168674625,
-0.0595530197,
0.0411410071,
0.0644017607,
0.0437953807,
-0.0713649541,
-0.0113814333,
-0.057572905,
-0.0120801143,
0.0049078148,
-0.0110727148,
0.0054395651,
0.0153165655,
-0.0192740615,
0.0237497389,
0.009690349,
0.0387191363,
-0.002984331,
-0.0248749666,
0.0149045214,
-0.0021490376,
-0.1167068258,
-0.0644909218,
0.0387026332,
0.0326038077,
-0.0552594997,
0.03323102,
0.0182978492,
0.0340340175,
-0.022122262,
-0.022958599,
-0.0159481894,
0.0318770148,
-0.0302744284,
-0.0071941684,
-0.01696725,
-0.0063102054,
-0.0189291984,
0.0281617567,
-0.0069871265,
-0.0573245957,
0.0136290137,
-0.0458152108,
-0.0143372435,
0.0160375778,
-0.0377442986,
-0.0153252343,
-0.0735659152,
0.0142120542,
0.0073696878,
0.0597196855,
0.0193003993,
0.0860928521,
-0.024055507,
0.0181626789,
0.0024985087,
-0.0423093513,
0.033805538,
-0.0359425843,
0.0033773507,
-0.0018999926,
-0.0321766399,
0.0372147746,
-0.0135245109,
0.0019301814,
-0.0022675402,
0.0061176312,
-0.004373536,
0.0062740576,
-0.0554766618,
0.0125748646,
0.0190205146,
0.0205500908,
-0.037677221,
-0.0511484034,
0.0070145307,
-0.0261518415,
0.0515884832,
0.0027159939,
0.0863103867,
0.0007555955,
-0.0236256346,
0.0036408375,
-0.0086322781,
-0.0438783951,
0.0515996441,
-0.0188309643,
-0.0133929998,
-0.0501169264,
0.0129160341,
0.0389588289,
0.0208186917,
-0.0164964143,
-0.0323328935,
-0.0206431244,
-0.0599978045,
0.0137911597,
0.0855949372,
0.0033274943,
0.0433006659,
-0.0046602366,
-0.0112779709,
-0.0222670436,
0.009232006,
-0.0006284472,
0.0108363628,
-0.0365330279,
-0.0047366121,
0.0388650335,
0.045161169,
-0.0091520902,
-0.0344174467,
-0.023259541,
0.0336279757,
0.0331142247,
0.0055921436,
-0.039107427,
0.0159093402,
-0.0248485766,
0.0344410725,
-0.0166366939,
-0.0409419425,
0.0237033255,
-0.0116702095,
0.0020336565,
-0.0199028458,
-0.0320950709,
-0.027979305,
0.0068055079,
0.0327886492,
-0.0051183514,
-0.0239495654,
-0.0525275394,
0.0094858799,
-0.0081567504,
0.0100292619,
-0.0057812491,
0.0412104167,
-0.0531087816,
0.0036649425,
0.0197012499,
-0.0094789779,
-0.0691033155,
-0.0747222155,
0.0286698099,
-0.0362057425,
0.0004593389,
-0.0372508988,
-0.052041281,
0.0216527469,
-0.0033696657,
0.0796480775,
-0.0012210874,
-0.0187318977,
-0.020133825,
0.0465057231,
-0.0072306111,
-0.0710539073,
0.0027202577,
-0.0654729083,
-0.0009738746,
0.0389249511,
-0.040432632,
0.0094856787,
-0.0131329764,
0.0149691412,
-0.0181917604,
0.0064767948,
-0.0060100942,
0.0277561881,
-0.0049283127,
-0.0437898859,
-0.0532446913,
0.0932039022,
0.0422944687,
0.0428841189,
-0.0001038363,
-0.0055088042,
0.0557008274,
0.0074432399,
0.0009790518,
-0.0689396337,
0.0335919596,
0.0076081492,
0.0266718194,
-0.0130632296,
-0.0664217249,
0.0117340023,
-0.1051325351,
0.0543621629,
0.0274817981,
-0.0579614118,
-0.1119692549,
-0.0343457088,
0.0210740995,
-0.0346585922,
0.0598289967,
0.0367841348,
0.0157423411,
-0.0049778195,
0.0370186791,
-0.0724587813,
-0.0871226117,
-0.0128935194,
-0.0230593644,
0.0400508642,
0.0358719192,
0.0152954236,
-0.0477774218,
-0.0098842336,
0.0106345303,
0.0328959674,
0.0277107973,
-0.0033149691,
0.0477058217,
0.0096560549,
-0.0244010836,
-0.0045138374,
0.0299573001,
-0.0811899155,
0.0251405314,
0.0270263627,
0.0927255377,
-0.0710155517,
-0.01240505,
0.0102279661,
-0.0338884406,
0.0348209478,
0.0607644208,
0.007060139,
-0.0228239186,
-0.0101922592,
0.002133559,
-0.0558575243,
-0.0290226899,
0.0603154264,
0.0536792949,
0.0509351492,
-0.0589992777,
-0.03319313,
-0.047354117,
0.0021270944,
0.0077129309,
-0.0090161851,
0.0120780347,
-0.0720407143,
-0.0266037565,
-0.0251392554,
-0.0505675375,
-0.0301846005,
0.0180312395,
0.004168421,
0.0315423682,
0.0079721101,
-0.0064240834,
-0.0360264368,
0.0105197662,
-0.0699131861,
-0.0439681858,
0.0046770666,
-0.0179907456,
0.0125952382,
0.0512009934,
-0.008201926,
0.031430278,
0.0265236981,
0.0778682753,
-0.0300589278,
0.0035196501,
0.0072969426,
-0.1186466217,
0.0162771195,
-0.0104218908,
0.0303200297,
0.0204102397,
0.0265559535,
-0.0258266181,
-0.0699976087,
-0.0394736491,
0.0410058424,
0.0209788103,
0.0443010069,
0.0284415763,
-0.0273731239,
-0.0218688753,
0.0516135246,
-0.0106765479,
-0.0020812852,
0.0104699535,
0.0192336012,
0.0618578158,
0.0132450275,
-0.0321230553,
0.0252888035,
-0.0153516503,
0.0307199806,
-0.0480673909,
0.0325396881,
0.0055400967,
0.0011141323,
0.0440989062,
-0.0264322627,
0.024680309,
0.0105885314,
0.0523622073,
0.0698987544,
0.0193740856,
0.0181963779,
0.0283019654,
0.0093638888,
-0.0038776505,
-0.00952332,
-0.0440546498,
0.0043152971,
-0.0300142616,
0.0261470247,
0.029716637,
-0.0120098731,
-0.0345019214,
-0.0379677266,
0.0142332697,
-0.0101255346,
0.0397507995,
0.0522082634,
0.0314079262,
0.0100125605,
0.0128775276,
-0.0466656685,
-0.0040155677,
0.067211695,
0.0147349797,
0.032217823,
0.0252000466,
0.0102852201,
-0.0595658757,
0.0410804302,
0.0313601978,
0.0140136164,
-0.0066718133,
0.0055439919,
-0.0202962402,
-0.0244777519,
0.0338629261,
0.0297956448,
-0.002763324,
0.0397179425,
-0.0307221673,
0.0937467366,
-0.0060740793,
0.0263419021,
-0.0279150847,
-0.0015626887,
0.0136948526,
-0.0282685906,
0.0071603218,
-5.863577044e-33,
-0.0152025763,
-0.0386436656,
-0.0156870876,
-0.0172901005,
0.0449973606,
-0.0279491935,
-0.0124248769,
-0.0401655957,
0.0280762352,
0.0112089505,
-0.0160489231,
0.0470560417,
0.0126033267,
-0.000100369,
0.011064807,
-0.0379253924,
0.0417818613,
-0.005759045,
0.0360632874,
0.0058554569,
0.0270433966,
0.0522821844,
0.0574138761,
-0.0579106361,
0.016054675,
-0.0425809212,
-0.031341821,
0.0344155207,
-0.0073649175,
0.0301295649,
-0.0070440806,
0.0615439788,
0.0338852368,
-0.0244145151,
-0.0239484794,
-0.0148408944,
-0.003703899,
-0.000786425,
-0.0211825967,
0.0230722073,
0.0396426916,
-0.0592296086,
0.0113381874,
-0.0278973058,
-0.0100135822,
-0.0089050513,
0.0354985669,
-0.0638880581,
0.0314548239,
0.0370441787,
-0.0430461913,
0.0371041521,
-0.0303257946,
0.0283034556,
0.0350218713,
-0.0194127951,
0.018042231,
-0.0122939842,
-0.0450356901,
0.0307873655,
0.0519227795,
0.0023091813,
-0.0049164654,
0.0060554692,
-0.0237903744,
0.0200984925,
0.0301113985,
0.0021908523,
-0.0163742527,
0.0240011569,
0.0024208031,
0.0263076499,
0.0118361153,
0.0652703494,
0.0500150733,
-0.0205835775,
-0.1044462919,
0.0371974744,
-0.0088555356,
-0.035411384,
0.0452709198,
-0.0180065818,
-0.0564781353,
0.0170330927,
0.0278189555,
-0.0236826558,
-0.0001293937,
0.0215567444,
0.0113837188,
0.0055581117,
0.0117301615,
-0.0242106132,
0.0356056467,
-0.0574265271,
-0.005062988,
0.0260132235,
-0.0315505788,
-0.0380622298,
0.0138041964,
0.0086044976,
0.0037131526,
-0.0470570549,
0.0288282838,
0.0247803815,
0.0301133953,
0.0022530288,
0.0829362422,
0.0437135696,
-0.0755912811,
-0.008519494,
-0.0018997608,
0.0512454361,
-0.0035646628,
0.0549728647,
0.0078883003,
-0.0336103067,
-0.0051028086,
0.0727099478,
-0.008167211,
-0.0049717836,
-0.0129274065,
0.0400711857,
-0.0527459159,
-0.0109257586,
-0.0053298445,
-0.0031537835,
-0.0064645316,
0.0040320423,
0.0625302494,
-0.0303789228,
0.0260977428,
0.0002109181,
2.798e-7,
0.0217448324,
0.0403731428,
0.0416012183,
-0.0033713207,
0.0463121831,
0.0161810704,
-0.0315588862,
0.0256521422,
-0.0264449045,
-0.043453753,
0.0618005395,
-0.0210005343,
0.0538317934,
0.0297625549,
-0.0485486649,
0.0204523578,
-0.0880844742,
-0.0189989842,
-0.0941019133,
-0.0081954962,
0.0405977368,
0.1004722267,
0.0006813501,
-0.0458264835,
0.0749346316,
-0.0757136047,
0.0210369118,
-0.0216300488,
-0.0055762962,
0.0368473269,
0.0269001611,
0.0356526561,
0.0270697512,
0.0748134926,
-0.0055363518,
0.0052227159,
-0.0350417942,
0.0580995418,
-0.0210186876,
0.0494417511,
-0.0241291039,
-0.0208666194,
-0.0018593713,
-0.0998799726,
0.060751155,
-0.0146438954,
0.015056246,
0.0249114614,
-0.0086684432,
-0.0097140661,
0.0204979554,
-0.017525617,
0.0473398045,
0.01436189,
0.0215865616,
-0.0107375663,
0.0353151932,
-0.0074977805,
-0.004788198,
0.0079455832,
-0.0401223488,
-0.0232260451,
0.011394226,
-0.0042772847,
0.0386905298,
-0.0055863569,
0.015903037,
2.878343936e-34,
0.0527869426,
-0.0115571525,
0.0132034691,
-0.0305598583,
0.0300799347,
0.0112575963,
-0.0222209543,
0.0052084629,
-0.0126944128,
-0.0450667292,
0.003621184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16306v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16306v1 | Cascade Reward Sampling for Efficient Decoding-Time Alignment | 2024-06-24T04:08:35 | 2024-06-24T04:08:35 | Bolian Li, Yifan Wang, Ananth Grama, Ruqi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | Aligning large language models (LLMs) with human preferences is critical for
their deployment. Recently, decoding-time alignment has emerged as an effective
plug-and-play technique that requires no fine-tuning of model parameters.
However, generating text that achieves both high reward and high likelihood
remains a significant challenge. Existing methods often fail to generate
high-reward text or incur substantial computational costs. In this paper, we
propose Cascade Reward Sampling (CARDS) to address both issues, guaranteeing
the generation of high-reward and high-likelihood text with significantly low
costs. Based on our analysis of reward models (RMs) on incomplete text and our
observation that high-reward prefixes induce high-reward complete text, we use
rejection sampling to iteratively generate small semantic segments to form such
prefixes. The segment length is dynamically determined by the predictive
uncertainty of LLMs. This strategy guarantees desirable prefixes for subsequent
generations and significantly reduces wasteful token re-generations and the
number of reward model scoring. Our experiments demonstrate substantial gains
in both generation efficiency and alignment ratings compared to the baselines,
achieving five times faster text generation and 99\% win-ties in GPT-4/Claude-3
helpfulness evaluation. | [
0.0358350202,
0.0413063355,
-0.005581168,
0.0019853765,
-0.0632968694,
-0.0058985334,
-0.0584551319,
0.010638088,
-0.0529824756,
-0.0195139293,
-0.0090088574,
-0.0269146189,
0.0158690829,
0.0122946324,
0.0017487325,
-0.0728572682,
0.0487783961,
-0.0283254869,
0.0082098292,
-0.0090490673,
0.0180850755,
0.0325535014,
0.0042880252,
0.0556659885,
-0.0187259428,
-0.0151245976,
-0.0099412287,
0.0117116868,
0.0152874701,
-0.0726005584,
0.0083388463,
0.0341479667,
-0.0076387892,
0.0712924302,
0.0000020487,
-0.0385132395,
-0.0391913094,
0.0097354185,
-0.0343547799,
-0.0041278019,
0.0541138835,
-0.014656553,
-0.0067261085,
0.0465845019,
0.005130725,
0.0251755062,
0.0577903613,
-0.0021842555,
0.0269426983,
0.0416799001,
-0.0001822834,
0.0064350083,
0.0101689352,
-0.0248621851,
0.0248297304,
-0.0384689383,
-0.015110665,
0.0229565073,
0.022428751,
-0.0132156555,
-0.0065054167,
0.0375829823,
0.0165251754,
-0.0019820677,
0.0403372534,
0.036751166,
0.0348672643,
0.008253553,
-0.0470512882,
0.0220114589,
-0.0127036041,
-0.0420928411,
-0.0124211982,
-0.0310197305,
-0.0091759628,
-0.054488454,
-0.0409195647,
0.0238144714,
-0.0093602426,
0.0452594496,
0.0785392448,
0.0392152406,
0.0180421174,
-0.010497719,
-0.0135154976,
0.0657188818,
0.0436566211,
-0.0606353246,
-0.0193658508,
0.0282380953,
-0.0051424475,
-0.051599782,
0.0159385707,
-0.0041770916,
-0.0490857773,
0.0392877646,
-0.0971846879,
-0.0239918232,
0.0128135281,
0.0248961616,
0.0187618043,
0.0557864755,
0.0301211495,
0.0266467314,
-0.0197152849,
0.0320990421,
-0.0020652481,
-0.0083386833,
-0.0625592023,
-0.0093446895,
-0.0129540879,
-0.0172213744,
-0.0448151119,
0.0475235581,
-0.056886822,
-0.0383555032,
-0.0724703074,
0.0370350778,
0.0363048427,
0.0210362878,
0.0420635007,
-0.0055668056,
-0.0572475344,
0.0045315274,
-0.0050102738,
0.0057399082,
-0.0351502337,
-0.0292089675,
0.0276028402,
-0.028165346,
-0.0116108852,
0.0030349842,
-0.0046695271,
-0.0379989706,
-0.0304892119,
0.06742616,
-0.0291429069,
-0.0454060175,
-0.0197117794,
-0.0262808148,
-0.0242728628,
-0.0201960672,
-0.0289508495,
-0.0812007561,
0.0038151999,
0.0141849322,
-0.0061887158,
-0.0112784673,
0.0253122766,
0.0104001733,
-0.0262221955,
0.0384805016,
-0.021563394,
0.0357426815,
0.0104846181,
-0.0255835205,
0.0160983242,
0.0705559552,
0.053047318,
0.0661204085,
0.0473586023,
0.0356595404,
-0.020237105,
0.06354139,
0.0251172855,
0.0112732248,
-0.0132285627,
-0.0274204742,
0.0293753538,
0.0577916056,
0.0523660704,
0.0538225248,
-0.019587433,
0.0407063924,
0.0815424919,
0.0381539874,
-0.0047083623,
-0.0185749549,
0.0400135368,
0.0293619521,
-0.0328637511,
-0.0257686097,
-0.0258278605,
0.0103589157,
-0.03750965,
0.0352960527,
0.0548766218,
0.0338470899,
-0.0030070203,
-0.0341693163,
-0.0164610278,
-0.0127648143,
0.0056418641,
0.0060308292,
0.0627347901,
-0.0061418316,
-0.0991447344,
0.0227584857,
0.0309426244,
-0.0356723219,
0.0310591422,
-0.0297117345,
0.0460746586,
0.1021642834,
0.0873954967,
-0.0019081462,
0.0015256032,
0.0149183264,
-0.0538766012,
0.0588996001,
0.0343426429,
-0.0156275071,
-0.0128967939,
-0.0581878312,
-0.0330321565,
0.0409691967,
-0.0083383666,
0.0348576494,
0.0533109494,
0.0029588286,
0.0082376981,
-0.015779715,
-0.0388295427,
0.0527806729,
0.0065772217,
-0.0098945927,
0.0078972559,
0.0008866629,
0.0377748348,
0.0263724495,
-0.0114049921,
0.0195119958,
0.0137892682,
-0.0347725749,
-0.0175123271,
0.0079589225,
-0.0622252896,
-0.0548364148,
0.0206105728,
-0.028392842,
-0.0187663399,
0.0409418978,
-0.0153638562,
-0.0425753817,
-0.009263128,
-0.0710553527,
0.0555711538,
-0.0208489951,
0.0718826875,
0.0131417736,
-0.0267440267,
-0.0649992824,
0.0397505946,
-0.0132047711,
0.0142560964,
-0.0051724757,
-0.0024590194,
0.0056034955,
-0.0608279258,
-0.0239142794,
0.0035157213,
-0.0187648833,
-0.0013529306,
0.0419581048,
0.0410928689,
-0.0261899084,
-0.05489856,
-0.0565396324,
0.0246002078,
-0.0140127707,
0.0292329006,
0.0212923307,
0.0045374315,
0.0034613805,
0.0022995903,
-0.0562489182,
-0.0251037572,
0.0303527229,
-0.0054118494,
0.0383187607,
-0.00776147,
-0.0347393528,
-0.0383750908,
0.0029625839,
-0.000546036,
0.0119788554,
0.0284617841,
-0.0073778043,
-0.0747295544,
0.0082552284,
-0.0015264322,
-0.018744275,
0.0237480737,
-0.0232748073,
-0.0046807448,
0.0142159751,
0.0422699265,
0.0249605905,
0.0357793048,
0.0226113293,
-0.015182591,
0.0180270728,
-0.0630597025,
-0.0216042902,
-0.0514942743,
-0.03172208,
-0.0089981752,
-0.0652050078,
0.0395632908,
0.0807608962,
0.0311432332,
0.0265191142,
-0.097648412,
0.0013104636,
-0.0249694716,
-0.0407720245,
-0.0259452127,
0.0001047716,
-0.0320388749,
0.0228075795,
-0.0424724035,
-0.0752846375,
0.0681690425,
-0.0536683276,
0.0008594493,
-0.0577098727,
0.018852761,
-0.0143433483,
0.0622624531,
-0.0013287297,
0.0379323177,
0.0236900914,
-0.0588507131,
-0.0235587172,
0.0060624019,
0.0243220832,
-0.0460949726,
0.035377156,
-0.0586668588,
0.0064860759,
0.0013341183,
-0.0484227575,
-0.0425734147,
-0.0332815498,
0.0029349888,
0.0007032044,
0.054678835,
0.0033283285,
-0.0108869309,
0.0179360602,
0.0265703313,
0.0264709517,
-0.0226361752,
0.0079199336,
-0.0264067389,
0.030836504,
0.0884269252,
-0.0224562455,
0.0086837541,
-0.0509052239,
-0.0261162017,
0.0304411333,
0.0571379401,
0.0264713019,
0.0110772988,
-0.0193980951,
0.0706360638,
-0.0455776602,
-0.0041313749,
0.0464898609,
0.0312756114,
-0.0243515335,
-0.0009106789,
0.1122677103,
0.052671127,
-0.042235896,
0.0215377379,
-0.0197402462,
0.0546900854,
0.0001338139,
0.0018691026,
-0.0978538096,
-0.0183662139,
0.0266876668,
0.0470946096,
-0.0164921582,
0.0054813279,
0.0051095807,
-0.1337234974,
0.0122287693,
0.0152044538,
-0.0499013588,
-0.0156660397,
0.0045330469,
-0.0370390676,
0.0175403357,
0.0059358552,
0.0511923358,
0.0131976334,
0.0153806796,
0.0251885764,
0.0047295662,
-0.0178787131,
0.0080763567,
-0.0379572138,
0.0763106495,
0.1072438285,
0.0275175516,
0.0174262971,
-0.0179805215,
-0.0244012047,
-0.0244830847,
-0.0247021802,
-0.0025622179,
0.0087558245,
-0.0294418857,
0.0043160715,
-0.0030367863,
0.0382652432,
-0.0291242376,
0.0050500915,
0.0219121892,
0.0612260364,
0.0153603982,
0.0344594531,
-0.0241807513,
-0.0071133384,
0.0337108783,
0.0812550187,
0.020807622,
-0.0611354187,
-0.0241081063,
-0.0096946238,
0.0010979833,
-0.0803156048,
0.0124516813,
0.0092858877,
-0.0302296188,
-0.001635415,
-0.0983907431,
-0.0288873054,
0.01858183,
0.0667913556,
0.0202940274,
0.0183819365,
-0.0155397309,
-0.0170978345,
-0.0426225215,
0.0009347238,
-0.0564166866,
0.0120854676,
-0.1036295295,
-0.0122720459,
-0.0302805342,
-0.0611881502,
-0.0161794256,
0.0259387642,
-0.0354828686,
-0.0545927994,
-0.0180125348,
0.0467286743,
0.0273930989,
0.0537545681,
-0.0059495289,
-0.0253801923,
0.0220076144,
0.0307821725,
0.0038177476,
0.0072629321,
-0.0220671352,
0.0333926827,
-0.0211229734,
0.03015217,
-0.0554280579,
0.0152911423,
-0.0004272769,
0.0589308925,
0.0430149585,
0.0028875102,
0.048712004,
0.0367029086,
0.0127669908,
-0.0765639171,
0.0002181101,
-0.0089049498,
0.0299248938,
-0.0521962531,
-0.0107286545,
-0.0326571874,
0.0066207862,
0.0224982128,
-0.0142879067,
-0.0057710465,
-0.0404258445,
-0.0226455871,
0.030521078,
-0.0402314998,
-0.0256384425,
-0.069455117,
0.0375431217,
0.0420617424,
-0.0143851582,
-0.0188599732,
-0.0293868873,
-0.004666578,
0.0229404308,
-0.0371705517,
0.0366224162,
0.0377389453,
0.0041182213,
-0.0056128753,
0.0347543955,
0.0012083949,
0.0250301659,
-0.0460619219,
-0.0166380834,
0.0860812441,
0.0094133355,
0.0774956122,
-0.0348070376,
-0.0010579083,
-0.0068087163,
0.0409815311,
-0.0120305065,
-0.0483647473,
0.0163801704,
0.0017505885,
-0.0236386955,
-0.0437257886,
0.0654805154,
-0.0143502308,
0.0157840177,
-0.0070815925,
-0.0269711576,
-0.0275386032,
-0.0199179295,
0.0106309447,
0.0045769904,
-0.0516686998,
-0.0198549349,
-0.0698895454,
-0.0296490155,
-0.0146789923,
0.0703797936,
0.0086726965,
-0.0262184124,
0.0683873445,
0.0466286354,
-0.0436245836,
-0.0219131541,
-0.050643988,
0.0217601173,
-0.0259060171,
-0.0382632464,
-0.0369983874,
-6.493291939e-33,
-0.0391452312,
-0.009390004,
0.0117959725,
0.0031714302,
-0.0581819639,
0.0190070011,
-0.0350851193,
-0.0022476888,
0.0591525473,
-0.0238741785,
-0.0302493069,
-0.0468233041,
0.0210241619,
0.0461505242,
0.0071376697,
0.0243956223,
0.0568925403,
-0.0209754836,
-0.0656298175,
0.0177622028,
0.0281143691,
0.0101112714,
0.0354962237,
-0.0103076613,
0.0335603915,
-0.0009651366,
-0.0119722597,
-0.0037517857,
0.0312343892,
0.0541638955,
0.0030331784,
0.0246133357,
0.0082154935,
-0.0446175709,
-0.0078107473,
-0.0020780219,
-0.0746507421,
0.0017982428,
0.0498333722,
-0.0047201472,
-0.0371972732,
-0.034056969,
0.0193446595,
-0.0151546849,
-0.054618787,
0.0510964468,
-0.001407392,
-0.0204916205,
-0.0430503264,
-0.0212877076,
-0.0841104165,
0.0269670505,
-0.0029060626,
-0.0160603393,
0.0201842841,
0.0188515186,
0.0074864198,
0.0566218942,
-0.0080386745,
0.0399786122,
0.0281721894,
0.0572472699,
0.0844812468,
0.0216193367,
0.0239066985,
0.0458712615,
-0.0116326781,
-0.0176651962,
0.0232705269,
0.0082541555,
0.030134432,
-0.0340572111,
0.0366595276,
0.0179152694,
0.0517425872,
-0.016987782,
-0.0183199532,
0.0442778543,
0.0131004145,
-0.0229136795,
0.0435535163,
0.0246824939,
-0.0510703661,
-0.0024617009,
-0.0541657209,
-0.0295798928,
-0.0172010288,
-0.0535455085,
0.0472296476,
0.0313105322,
-0.0174562093,
0.0069146422,
0.0441918038,
-0.0025787253,
-0.0039371494,
-0.0255917851,
-0.0046363981,
0.0326223113,
-0.0544171557,
0.0160665996,
-0.0746643394,
-0.0196888261,
0.0012548083,
-0.0121240439,
0.0081849182,
0.0195721947,
-0.0034639915,
0.0038564648,
-0.0629764125,
0.0442471579,
-0.0375629738,
0.0404214934,
-0.030476978,
-0.0303294901,
0.0619347915,
-0.0112405289,
0.0091133891,
0.0255555082,
0.0251888074,
-0.0321320333,
-0.0490004495,
-0.0244349875,
0.0001332574,
0.0181329325,
-0.0378260724,
0.0198343527,
-0.0299386047,
0.0065940833,
0.0264875125,
-0.0260903277,
-0.0304564107,
0.0096991379,
2.768e-7,
0.0340622924,
0.0612910464,
0.0533381589,
0.0147143593,
0.0091258362,
0.0189045537,
0.0357612111,
0.0297773574,
-0.0159498509,
0.036052689,
-0.0077055264,
-0.0289847218,
0.0538088046,
0.0017601384,
-0.1029647514,
0.023655111,
-0.0502291918,
0.0191513244,
-0.0447060354,
0.0052016941,
0.0589124933,
0.0851366594,
0.0053184289,
0.0053827823,
-0.0140771121,
0.013530992,
0.0374187902,
-0.0241745207,
-0.0385650508,
0.0339846015,
0.0042529083,
-0.0197636057,
-0.0219819769,
-0.0129507575,
-0.0110934144,
0.0127864694,
0.0097659649,
0.0398381501,
-0.0178988762,
-0.010352483,
-0.0060625654,
-0.0110391062,
-0.0120727206,
-0.065143846,
0.0226546936,
-0.055167675,
-0.0027602138,
-0.0193224344,
-0.0268717501,
0.0020435015,
-0.0259001367,
-0.0112492451,
-0.0258408953,
0.0361340791,
0.0256116204,
0.0340082757,
-0.0045744902,
-0.0555070266,
-0.0227316301,
-0.0057437802,
-0.0215107575,
-0.0471727885,
-0.0424755737,
0.0414496064,
-0.0021828937,
-0.0881835893,
-0.0201479848,
2.937094547e-34,
0.0350156873,
-0.0295815449,
0.0034292119,
0.0176532213,
0.033228986,
0.0028622048,
0.0257386584,
0.031224912,
0.0180766601,
-0.0372502208,
-0.0212579183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17808v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17808v1 | Training-Free Exponential Extension of Sliding Window Context with Cascading KV Cache | 2024-06-24T03:59:17 | 2024-06-24T03:59:17 | Jeffrey Willette, Heejun Lee, Youngwan Lee, Myeongjae Jeon, Sung Ju Hwang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The context window within a transformer provides a form of active memory for
the current task, which can be useful for few-shot learning and conditional
generation, both which depend heavily on previous context tokens. However, as
the context length grows, the computational cost increases quadratically.
Recent works have shown that saving a few initial tokens along with a
fixed-sized sliding window leads to stable streaming generation with linear
complexity in transformer-based Large Language Models (LLMs). However, they
make suboptimal use of the fixed window by naively evicting all tokens
unconditionally from the key-value (KV) cache once they reach the end of the
window, resulting in tokens being forgotten and no longer able to affect
subsequent predictions. To overcome this limitation, we propose a novel
mechanism for storing longer sliding window contexts with the same total cache
size by keeping separate cascading sub-cache buffers whereby each subsequent
buffer conditionally accepts a fraction of the relatively more important tokens
evicted from the previous buffer. Our method results in a dynamic KV cache that
can store tokens from the more distant past than a fixed, static sliding window
approach. Our experiments show improvements of 5.6% on long context generation
(LongBench), 1.2% in streaming perplexity (PG19), and 0.6% in language
understanding (MMLU STEM) using LLMs given the same fixed cache size.
Additionally, we provide an efficient implementation that improves the KV cache
latency from 1.33ms per caching operation to 0.54ms, a 59% speedup over
previous work. | [
0.0160087198,
0.050425306,
-0.0011679139,
0.0147168767,
-0.0358536094,
0.0257037915,
0.0214145351,
-0.0188607555,
-0.0229921378,
-0.0360491164,
-0.0051124329,
-0.0968531221,
-0.0094227931,
0.0261890367,
0.0245007183,
-0.028033603,
0.0736652985,
-0.0544381365,
-0.0446661375,
-0.0152041353,
-0.0372657888,
0.0015737476,
-0.0131336087,
0.0172519814,
-0.0112656802,
-0.0243977457,
-0.0458723977,
-0.0155191859,
-0.00030947,
-0.0176608637,
-0.0059814574,
0.0432463661,
0.0196553729,
0.0273881853,
0.0000024443,
-0.0168016553,
-0.0149804587,
-0.0215749219,
-0.055917833,
0.0261840634,
0.0338565372,
-0.0132012656,
-0.0329529978,
0.0167194884,
-0.0139095709,
-0.0607955828,
0.0462291799,
-0.0361272804,
0.0495474041,
0.0370400362,
-0.0056193178,
-0.0637007579,
0.023713043,
-0.0218045134,
0.045589529,
-0.0825901553,
0.0224538315,
-0.0392155387,
-0.04690836,
-0.0151746599,
-0.0458664,
0.0326676667,
0.0450686701,
-0.0096326396,
0.0063016852,
0.0618449338,
-0.0524937101,
-0.0249814019,
-0.0122317262,
0.0186230354,
-0.0018645545,
-0.0398219824,
0.005753038,
-0.0020681233,
-0.0309080314,
-0.0307388026,
-0.0352662131,
0.0375394709,
-0.0074727358,
-0.0118562384,
0.0127401929,
-0.0136315888,
0.0149913868,
0.0175484344,
-0.0691784397,
-0.0031216405,
0.0492615849,
-0.0018863804,
-0.0668504015,
-0.0309000351,
-0.0119667938,
-0.0555560328,
-0.0291420333,
0.0368130803,
-0.0150030861,
0.0419764817,
-0.0516123027,
0.0117939757,
0.0079536224,
-0.0168622062,
0.0144786313,
0.0644771904,
0.0155627523,
0.0437933691,
-0.0682738349,
0.0598887652,
-0.0352141336,
-0.0214731917,
-0.0482571349,
-0.0112430025,
-0.0343535878,
-0.0231391769,
-0.0533601008,
0.0323615111,
0.0087416926,
-0.0152814854,
-0.0483934097,
0.0434459783,
0.0268249009,
-0.0050188415,
-0.0014665619,
-0.0048898463,
-0.0235202126,
0.0095507111,
0.0460951924,
0.0400182158,
-0.0288193617,
-0.0267959032,
-0.0071303053,
-0.0662714988,
-0.0311538354,
0.0232297163,
0.0116863614,
-0.0158644766,
0.0103636961,
0.0623041429,
-0.0065153735,
-0.0475014709,
-0.0456591621,
-0.0060923574,
-0.0120413518,
-0.0403088182,
0.006640357,
-0.0615283661,
-0.0033024158,
0.0323363058,
0.0018412626,
0.0203862544,
0.0041947463,
0.025308948,
0.0014621496,
0.0184239075,
0.0113600958,
0.0025843363,
0.0092467507,
0.0075638164,
-0.0036964323,
0.0816487223,
0.0210531522,
0.011689119,
0.0179429092,
-0.0084269838,
-0.0324997902,
0.0314198881,
0.0338375866,
0.0026375598,
-0.0430866666,
-0.0066565447,
0.0484085307,
0.0030457957,
0.0261168033,
0.0523310304,
-0.0548303016,
-0.0395202599,
0.0198984388,
0.0368187986,
0.0047621964,
0.0301268343,
0.039959155,
-0.0033139035,
-0.0110050421,
0.0329383761,
-0.014011709,
0.0404709131,
0.029094575,
0.0198112819,
0.0073401364,
0.0360767059,
-0.0531793237,
-0.0081910063,
-0.0155937979,
-0.0001234875,
0.0044365115,
-0.0056606149,
0.0472121239,
0.030649364,
-0.0514299124,
0.1025497317,
0.0109769739,
-0.0554918312,
-0.0119321551,
-0.071945861,
-0.0043201256,
0.0941983387,
0.0415197872,
0.033735618,
-0.058250349,
0.0191230755,
0.0033490704,
0.0015413967,
0.031909585,
-0.005838925,
0.0314634219,
-0.0463846624,
-0.0024295459,
-0.015991684,
0.0021736468,
0.0181624498,
0.0494969934,
0.0190668777,
0.0198584404,
0.0246758498,
0.0623424724,
0.0126758516,
-0.0516738445,
-0.0247971471,
0.022092754,
-0.0160383843,
0.0126266899,
-0.0168771055,
-0.0221322756,
0.0172851197,
0.0192619003,
-0.0502910614,
0.0055602025,
0.0454605632,
-0.1202571169,
-0.0384125188,
0.0082476502,
0.045617912,
0.0263141897,
-0.0064788121,
-0.0357364565,
-0.0480361283,
0.0180401169,
-0.0134241572,
0.0754527673,
-0.026046617,
0.0544407479,
-0.0171834975,
0.0262836851,
-0.0175689664,
0.0623286664,
-0.0332045294,
0.0166054927,
-0.0072958283,
0.0368725285,
-0.0170755051,
-0.0002537652,
-0.0170707554,
0.0009295772,
-0.0241062492,
-0.0249579195,
-0.0176445022,
-0.0252217241,
-0.0498788394,
-0.0169331115,
-0.0925517306,
0.0225429963,
-0.0196081009,
0.0285672545,
0.0108356858,
0.0496756136,
0.001653533,
0.0064844051,
-0.0086350637,
0.008667022,
0.0033892198,
0.0431824401,
-0.0203984864,
0.0050513577,
-0.0358109586,
0.0011624221,
-0.0473477356,
-0.0000509349,
0.0780268982,
-0.0315091684,
-0.0356391966,
-0.0315905213,
0.0482262,
0.0218915381,
0.0190602671,
-0.0251876153,
0.0055542993,
-0.0108592054,
-0.0332774557,
0.0274058245,
0.0292148124,
0.0590554327,
-0.0166290235,
-0.0008767309,
-0.0363707989,
-0.0323027596,
0.0146163115,
-0.0110635441,
-0.0600836277,
-0.0132950908,
0.010007157,
-0.0144205866,
0.0791697428,
-0.0101478053,
-0.0180162787,
-0.0441937149,
-0.0139405197,
0.0136621734,
-0.0232659616,
-0.0150738861,
-0.0124058332,
-0.0264554992,
0.0076957243,
-0.0207692459,
-0.0459607653,
0.040948607,
-0.0276491083,
-0.0119558601,
-0.018018309,
0.0175146498,
-0.0591725893,
0.0450732335,
-0.0031925139,
0.0215334669,
-0.0367597453,
-0.0137485405,
-0.0344475619,
0.0030475203,
-0.0306191109,
-0.0330073647,
0.0417200476,
-0.0122648655,
0.0214810986,
-0.018928986,
-0.0343246013,
-0.086789608,
-0.0095305881,
0.024561014,
-0.0118757505,
0.061111033,
-0.0040910421,
-0.0046019335,
0.0381781124,
0.0062562879,
0.0856977329,
-0.0089211892,
-0.0084233955,
-0.0060371072,
0.0351923145,
0.0339407176,
-0.0093657831,
0.0108812889,
-0.0297627226,
0.077645652,
0.0884556249,
0.0995942056,
0.0433267877,
-0.016713934,
0.0116253756,
0.0385393314,
-0.0046169939,
-0.0228822436,
0.0007800463,
0.0203981772,
-0.0639941767,
-0.0321942791,
0.0988136008,
0.0358490273,
-0.0841408297,
-0.0196765158,
-0.0208985563,
0.0260319803,
0.0201500822,
0.0391381271,
-0.1204247326,
-0.0190639328,
0.0130125443,
0.0065994761,
-0.0072450638,
-0.0283615757,
-0.0286490917,
-0.1163225546,
0.0244134441,
0.0136937192,
-0.0083358223,
0.0468643233,
-0.0525077358,
-0.0221708808,
0.0213738251,
0.004017361,
0.0540397651,
-0.0125698075,
-0.0170287676,
0.0147223389,
0.0289588515,
-0.0393144973,
0.0338143371,
-0.0255933329,
0.0028566117,
0.0203974005,
-0.0164027475,
0.0345378332,
-0.0355506688,
0.0246704891,
-0.0194174945,
0.0185039137,
-0.0049782451,
-0.0088429758,
-0.0245135352,
-0.0051182983,
-0.0078998031,
0.0084286928,
0.0096105943,
-0.0404025465,
-0.0135580366,
0.0481390581,
-0.0047763465,
-0.0122627588,
0.0111250551,
-0.0216347557,
-0.0267164242,
0.0583902895,
0.0237357225,
-0.0442455523,
-0.0218871292,
-0.0042857556,
0.0173711702,
-0.0129285213,
-0.020156689,
-0.0007646636,
0.0394548438,
-0.048553858,
-0.0345047563,
0.0565531179,
0.0032104366,
0.0614822693,
-0.0162688978,
0.0217331704,
0.0075940234,
0.0128541598,
-0.082892336,
-0.0170854703,
-0.0309483055,
-0.0012065074,
-0.0682877302,
-0.0229718797,
0.0770807266,
-0.0224129278,
-0.0178104229,
0.0224695932,
-0.1293003261,
-0.0623331629,
0.0138945887,
0.0222156085,
0.0142149841,
0.0838654339,
0.0278926902,
0.0001233629,
0.0384308286,
0.0616165921,
-0.0372223891,
0.0528512746,
0.0096726902,
0.011645861,
-0.0103187393,
0.0270479843,
-0.0398766659,
0.0004943041,
-0.0013850447,
0.0464825146,
-0.0092880484,
0.0754751042,
-0.0000178907,
-0.0269376934,
0.0052170637,
-0.0243208203,
0.0138023943,
0.0245528854,
0.0807909444,
0.0139271654,
0.0167091452,
-0.0209646728,
0.0201206114,
0.0123851448,
-0.021500783,
0.0203127749,
-0.0295451097,
0.0420389511,
-0.0151450373,
0.0031136717,
-0.0041207825,
-0.0143064447,
-0.0141903544,
0.0327720381,
-0.0010099309,
-0.0220154654,
-0.0100364741,
0.0283035263,
0.0193802249,
-0.0650301352,
0.0505229346,
0.005105922,
-0.0048849243,
-0.0376117229,
0.0247537177,
-0.0683425292,
-0.0545496084,
-0.0292010251,
0.0410097018,
0.0404522531,
0.0037195175,
0.0032023904,
-0.0106482049,
-0.0093981074,
-0.0191293247,
-0.010522143,
0.0037022764,
-0.0580406636,
-0.0071788896,
0.0523526222,
0.0022296184,
0.0074371388,
0.0619636066,
0.0107162995,
0.0441357531,
0.0101087987,
0.0122490907,
-0.0131589537,
-0.0267089698,
-0.0235036723,
0.014288119,
0.0174137335,
0.0128893275,
-0.0629747882,
-0.0560883619,
0.0011713459,
-0.0240375772,
0.0170355216,
-0.0185738802,
0.0314257219,
0.0547924042,
0.0078991111,
-0.0278649647,
-0.0264543127,
0.0297704637,
0.0443588272,
-0.004929347,
-0.0024677035,
-7.210508797e-33,
-0.0199329797,
0.003991182,
0.0369585603,
0.0129592847,
-0.0120852748,
0.0129084997,
-0.0304033644,
-0.0296599735,
-0.0054008546,
-0.0611684844,
-0.0203146245,
0.0123422276,
0.0286667794,
0.0363549665,
-0.0073790979,
-0.0277615376,
0.0565218031,
0.0034500917,
-0.0105414214,
0.0799651071,
0.0489333048,
0.0471027233,
0.0313898288,
-0.0091791004,
-0.0512303226,
-0.0293963403,
0.0360920466,
-0.006121051,
-0.0112800533,
0.0360941105,
-0.0236279629,
0.0265499093,
0.0183715113,
-0.0714629516,
-0.0239901394,
-0.0174705572,
-0.0969039798,
0.0085021928,
0.0302777626,
0.02377728,
0.0079474421,
-0.0387066491,
0.0103078019,
0.0276439674,
-0.016892422,
-0.0040332158,
-0.0250581298,
-0.0102653261,
-0.0444984511,
-0.0449119955,
-0.0331198014,
0.0188468881,
0.0164255016,
0.0066611255,
0.0054561743,
0.022279134,
-0.0044799028,
0.0437093377,
-0.0482613146,
0.0300110411,
-0.0030467918,
0.0774386451,
0.0796071067,
0.0330931656,
0.0498691946,
0.043314416,
0.0790674761,
0.0049332315,
-0.0260676127,
-0.0125002814,
0.049408976,
0.0128178718,
-0.0079704421,
-0.0073941872,
0.0986727998,
-0.0366646163,
-0.0347143523,
-0.0412725322,
0.0148897264,
0.0702973008,
0.0764482617,
0.0055645024,
-0.0126463752,
-0.0452057943,
-0.0608053468,
0.0110906903,
-0.0422300398,
0.0044394033,
0.0312482137,
0.0691718534,
-0.0256040748,
-0.0411563106,
0.0742452666,
-0.0143704973,
0.0142983496,
0.0718491003,
-0.0096290903,
0.0347269028,
-0.0264835097,
0.0452185497,
-0.0162565131,
-0.0381176211,
0.0066932305,
-0.009738938,
0.0083932187,
0.0002149929,
0.0075501623,
0.0515392646,
-0.0582087263,
-0.0195881762,
-0.0610591695,
0.0280082468,
0.0105980756,
-0.0033762681,
0.0371464118,
0.0327165835,
0.012946357,
0.0581304096,
0.0004039734,
-0.0108622583,
0.0025269534,
-0.0477451198,
0.0091413958,
0.0509909205,
-0.0263191219,
0.0082555944,
-0.021241555,
0.0153799411,
0.026782332,
-0.0860599577,
-0.0295518823,
0.0477820411,
3.144e-7,
-0.002186805,
0.0397409946,
0.0336900465,
0.0012992661,
0.0350677818,
-0.0070375321,
0.012474128,
-0.0051316759,
0.021792125,
0.0217997655,
-0.0180173572,
0.028582111,
0.0255691577,
0.023844175,
-0.1060492173,
0.0236060042,
-0.0801283047,
0.0269602276,
-0.0351606831,
-0.0098246373,
0.0233323276,
0.1115810573,
-0.0191160124,
-0.0275475048,
0.0305522494,
-0.0038442337,
0.053665109,
0.0001440169,
0.0240625273,
0.0145518892,
-0.0299746394,
0.0189234857,
0.0078457817,
0.0111158332,
-0.0046733236,
0.0088647651,
-0.0635553077,
0.0482781939,
0.0284500998,
-0.0396599397,
0.0445786789,
-0.003033662,
-0.0277249403,
-0.0445426889,
0.1011444405,
-0.0410826802,
-0.0011230235,
-0.0553895198,
-0.0003012711,
-0.0074111442,
-0.0368865319,
0.0038342427,
0.0081762709,
0.0632518679,
-0.0047246744,
-0.0079754423,
-0.0111228405,
-0.0943020731,
-0.0290838163,
-0.0411431417,
-0.0729956701,
-0.0339622982,
-0.0473928116,
-0.0127414856,
0.0118796024,
-0.0123785064,
-0.0108850254,
3.351966452e-34,
0.0436794497,
-0.0035715424,
-0.0011877575,
0.0437251143,
0.0047913794,
-0.0297072548,
-0.0077557438,
0.0346213579,
0.0060002157,
-0.0802680999,
-0.0474664122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16299v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16299v1 | Compensate Quantization Errors: Make Weights Hierarchical to Compensate Each Other | 2024-06-24T03:52:52 | 2024-06-24T03:52:52 | Yifei Gao, Jie Ou, Lei Wang, Yuting Xiao, Zhiyuan Xiang, Ruiting Dai, Jun Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, F.2.3 | Emergent Large Language Models (LLMs) use their extraordinary performance and
powerful deduction capacity to discern from traditional language models.
However, the expenses of computational resources and storage for these LLMs are
stunning, quantization then arises as a trending conversation. To address
accuracy decay caused by quantization, two streams of works in post-training
quantization methods stand out. One uses other weights to compensate existing
quantization error, while the other transfers the quantization difficulty to
other parts in the model. Combining both merits, we introduce Learnable
Singular value Increment (LSI) as an advanced solution. LSI uses Singular Value
Decomposition to extract singular values of the weights and make them learnable
to help weights compensate each other conditioned on activation. Incorporating
LSI with existing techniques, we achieve state-of-the-art performance in
diverse quantization settings, no matter in weight-only, weight-activation or
extremely low bit scenarios. By unleashing the potential of LSI, efficient
finetuning on quantized model is no longer a prohibitive problem. | [
-0.0358307213,
0.0990082473,
0.0177209619,
0.038990546,
0.0184936337,
0.0237033032,
0.0221023392,
0.0062876795,
-0.0119512025,
-0.0211155917,
0.0095740026,
-0.0333373919,
-0.043368496,
0.029539546,
0.0177311692,
0.0094955117,
0.0514053181,
-0.046676185,
0.0099575929,
-0.0207536295,
-0.0031957098,
-0.0116792144,
0.0247267485,
-0.0064109489,
0.0135697061,
-0.0111607574,
-0.0226199199,
0.0093778316,
0.010758725,
-0.0378970988,
0.0157479532,
0.0626469627,
0.0671758801,
0.0654614419,
0.0000019353,
-0.0290448964,
-0.0273882281,
-0.0084321862,
-0.07818719,
0.0432172455,
0.0037969728,
-0.03472469,
-0.055603005,
-0.0067328955,
-0.023837531,
-0.0442893058,
0.0528601259,
0.0075802701,
0.0522274226,
0.052001033,
-0.0059210882,
-0.0515501611,
0.0255768206,
-0.0314946882,
-0.0088029932,
-0.0452898704,
0.0277364887,
0.0537111312,
-0.0414699726,
-0.0237951614,
-0.0180615596,
0.0254500136,
0.0243666917,
-0.0077790692,
-0.0287022982,
0.0241526458,
-0.0257917345,
0.0041366429,
-0.0274126288,
0.0562459752,
-0.0811111704,
-0.0436816141,
-0.0043323878,
0.0163449682,
-0.0171137545,
-0.0900393501,
-0.0257669501,
0.0269834045,
0.0336510465,
0.0523752533,
0.0257120151,
-0.0514167771,
0.0424631871,
0.039411094,
-0.0553296134,
0.0349743776,
0.0300616622,
-0.0221813563,
-0.0307035521,
-0.0135178212,
-0.1008863598,
-0.0223234836,
0.0121989902,
0.0119029563,
-0.0136103118,
-0.0068231067,
-0.0583303832,
-0.0495280139,
-0.0230209734,
-0.0174402446,
0.0426262952,
0.0275774989,
-0.0264743604,
0.0418280959,
-0.0168260355,
0.0472966358,
-0.0247527547,
0.0185400397,
-0.0354493,
0.0417106859,
0.0090001142,
-0.0110641699,
-0.0515812151,
0.0499685183,
-0.0199211091,
-0.0026270256,
-0.0582042001,
-0.0106975818,
-0.0327684693,
-0.0008340122,
0.0103963437,
0.0018695147,
-0.0237944052,
-0.0157638341,
0.0453860424,
0.0512447134,
-0.0290445741,
0.0188669488,
0.0024143411,
-0.0234320164,
-0.0216121133,
0.0378597751,
0.0323488079,
-0.0055887406,
0.0391037241,
-0.0282895733,
-0.008034179,
-0.0252849646,
-0.0240998827,
-0.0012513684,
-0.0224238224,
-0.0487085469,
-0.0084195854,
-0.0590166375,
0.0003463418,
-0.0307620559,
-0.0131522659,
-0.0481531769,
0.0140467538,
-0.0140050985,
-0.0080538671,
0.0644249544,
-0.0502629653,
-0.0099043725,
-0.0199637618,
-0.003557089,
0.045669008,
0.0569979958,
0.0378347002,
0.05124522,
0.0061062286,
0.0079417061,
-0.0164167415,
0.0553319119,
0.0471902341,
-0.0021236853,
-0.0846134722,
-0.0309463013,
-0.0371892266,
0.0239990558,
0.0860829353,
0.0814814493,
-0.0714012533,
-0.0111019118,
0.0278196596,
0.0547715016,
0.0213358235,
0.0173320472,
0.018227132,
0.029755652,
-0.0124914674,
0.0224297922,
-0.0358965807,
0.0015997757,
-0.0285511836,
-0.0097340802,
0.0273069832,
0.0409897566,
-0.0376573317,
-0.0433720388,
-0.0089054275,
-0.0284846146,
0.0153081855,
0.0037239681,
0.0488033332,
0.0319119506,
0.0133671248,
0.0961060822,
0.0487133227,
-0.070901908,
0.0046119792,
-0.0815734789,
0.0434305109,
0.0536216199,
0.0325464197,
-0.0140796443,
0.0368754677,
0.0153091298,
-0.0204742271,
0.0011621061,
-0.0271632839,
-0.0187679138,
0.0199301019,
-0.0512349047,
-0.00730782,
0.0418504961,
0.0206355713,
0.010817443,
0.000404886,
-0.0216077082,
-0.0052811936,
-0.0045223744,
-0.0158862118,
0.015212046,
0.0335578658,
-0.0488821678,
0.046914164,
-0.0151899476,
0.0324794985,
0.0179920644,
-0.0191294923,
0.0094890362,
0.0260142218,
-0.0469345488,
-0.0076044658,
-0.0411574803,
0.0005657235,
-0.0630329996,
0.0766747743,
0.0281609818,
0.0222791135,
0.0386133529,
-0.0420350097,
-0.041285146,
0.0465682335,
-0.0188105609,
-0.0048727687,
-0.0737549067,
0.0087635769,
-0.0108897919,
0.0458293334,
-0.0407316387,
0.0653033257,
-0.0287713259,
-0.0071747401,
-0.013089044,
0.0030545066,
-0.0155274542,
-0.0381482802,
-0.0528175868,
0.0087567298,
-0.0249358322,
0.0530171245,
-0.0030162116,
-0.0059566256,
0.0039878958,
-0.0149344793,
-0.1111306399,
-0.0122950142,
-0.0696446002,
0.0300684664,
0.0068634977,
0.0186822526,
0.0069684209,
-0.027606355,
-0.0338598005,
-0.0317006297,
0.0130090499,
-0.0133542251,
-0.0064591835,
-0.0066696862,
0.010475249,
-0.0507507361,
-0.0440475903,
0.010267687,
0.0395420343,
-0.0556523651,
-0.0142338434,
-0.1032939255,
0.0245043673,
-0.0112286499,
0.0606437512,
-0.0135863731,
-0.038375061,
0.0025102426,
-0.037262015,
0.0169800222,
0.0756524801,
0.0094549991,
0.0481113717,
0.0672777072,
0.0031971412,
-0.0267658513,
0.0208536349,
-0.0100797592,
-0.0296553038,
-0.0354698487,
0.015501718,
-0.0123468209,
0.0689404905,
-0.0397752747,
-0.0001074345,
-0.0225578547,
0.0165646542,
-0.011961963,
-0.0255873278,
-0.0127084795,
-0.0017801916,
-0.0269192327,
0.0427577123,
0.0039021184,
-0.0439400114,
0.0421922915,
-0.016426919,
-0.0002981633,
-0.0219369568,
-0.0159391277,
-0.0224358756,
0.0271850154,
0.0247855876,
0.0381699018,
-0.0017958686,
-0.0087952977,
-0.0483530089,
-0.0136285685,
0.0085537815,
-0.0371564962,
0.0413665697,
-0.0410345793,
0.0450965352,
-0.0343867689,
-0.0421595909,
0.0021651143,
-0.0047007385,
-0.0182238668,
0.0116639147,
0.0137588568,
-0.0295310821,
0.0453061759,
0.0256977566,
0.0032306118,
0.0560513362,
-0.0146135967,
0.0281295888,
-0.0346038081,
0.0492835417,
0.0612411015,
0.0158541016,
0.0293552577,
-0.015659431,
0.007461919,
0.037427254,
0.0335651264,
0.0490595549,
-0.0741486698,
0.0304896142,
0.0399627462,
-0.0091708023,
-0.0063514602,
-0.0057624765,
0.043844685,
-0.0484846048,
-0.004069089,
0.0989455283,
0.0168182384,
-0.0658071339,
0.0106386617,
0.0018769207,
0.0511205457,
-0.0030504421,
0.0060060881,
-0.1317026466,
-0.0314450264,
-0.0059278798,
0.0101944152,
0.0147035085,
-0.0081220306,
0.0094648311,
-0.0755963102,
0.036503654,
0.0472767949,
0.0029826504,
-0.000996494,
0.0036403609,
-0.0293278191,
-0.0227970853,
0.0666683093,
0.0360744484,
-0.0190083273,
0.0007940617,
0.0277659427,
-0.0121275019,
-0.0749923289,
0.0289707519,
-0.0280402154,
0.0420350805,
0.0687654763,
0.0196910203,
-0.0162719116,
-0.0051828725,
-0.013026814,
-0.0024231854,
-0.0307991859,
0.0051178965,
0.0125055499,
0.0235664081,
-0.0201569702,
0.0038290957,
0.0312945172,
0.0012515823,
-0.0204570442,
-0.0121657168,
0.0456766263,
-0.0005066633,
-0.0293655284,
0.0131315365,
-0.0500446074,
-0.0121154971,
0.0299030803,
0.0184431113,
-0.037751507,
-0.0617051311,
-0.0160038155,
0.0107475603,
-0.0123429969,
-0.037628565,
-0.0138319312,
-0.0136045301,
-0.0620726161,
-0.0505785719,
-0.0019820665,
0.0077803452,
0.0425294936,
-0.0512101203,
0.0026493263,
0.0273265615,
-0.0139883598,
-0.0857869908,
0.0021760587,
-0.0402757823,
0.0119322408,
-0.0392989852,
0.0119003402,
0.0308600478,
-0.0102187116,
-0.0036192618,
-0.0466380417,
-0.11252404,
-0.0804172829,
0.022356566,
0.008246975,
0.0236604288,
0.0357129462,
-0.0174376834,
-0.0959661826,
0.0714233592,
0.0434522219,
0.0097820172,
0.0320349783,
0.0476170927,
-0.0155992815,
-0.0067820242,
0.0432203598,
-0.0195686035,
0.0611812025,
-0.0030712294,
0.045587521,
-0.0945828259,
-0.0103848483,
0.0081329327,
0.0338502117,
0.0574655309,
-0.0091542676,
0.0055821445,
0.0013749466,
0.0324067771,
0.0006568256,
-0.0046013393,
-0.0485856123,
0.0051609902,
0.0262631234,
0.008492196,
-0.0249312576,
0.0161324851,
0.0542159006,
-0.0138562564,
-0.0033876915,
-0.0045198351,
-0.0260361154,
0.0655524954,
0.053278029,
-0.0200705826,
-0.0199445263,
0.0360329524,
0.0152573762,
0.0428183153,
-0.0221556816,
0.0222750045,
0.0074245306,
0.0007101729,
-0.0451151133,
0.0370270312,
-0.0290149581,
-0.0402713045,
-0.0468465127,
-0.0077248462,
0.0768294558,
0.0419861376,
0.0702822059,
0.0236390959,
-0.029693475,
-0.0177876391,
0.0210388601,
-0.0014700081,
-0.0367435887,
0.0344609804,
0.0279375054,
-0.033018928,
0.03476125,
0.0435558036,
0.0206703022,
0.0195816234,
-0.0206546169,
0.004719628,
-0.0163350962,
-0.0422443673,
-0.0723715797,
-0.0006764762,
-0.0241840854,
0.0238884985,
-0.0153914271,
-0.0501317605,
0.0022330573,
0.0354279429,
0.0209637247,
-0.0244454648,
0.0265962202,
0.0341180153,
-0.0245624576,
-0.021219369,
-0.0336128734,
-0.0605146773,
0.0030144497,
-0.0138995163,
-0.0131141022,
-6.494401311e-33,
-0.0178197548,
0.0276487675,
0.0204936601,
-0.0132549629,
-0.0277795661,
-0.0074333544,
-0.0194704663,
0.0309736952,
-0.0272588544,
0.0017698655,
-0.0091912607,
0.0284398235,
0.0261119176,
0.0168627445,
-0.0037931043,
0.0066853324,
0.0825293213,
-0.0195170585,
-0.0121546937,
0.0314148553,
0.0139186094,
0.0046426342,
0.066270031,
-0.0008359947,
-0.0228458084,
0.0204038061,
-0.0243484639,
0.0323361866,
0.0076081692,
0.0331559926,
-0.032012701,
0.0148162413,
0.0057516987,
0.05099402,
-0.0167879835,
-0.024486579,
-0.0611076429,
0.0180206448,
-0.0136156892,
0.0157438871,
-0.0199624486,
-0.0181629863,
0.0370410122,
0.015063202,
-0.0401572473,
-0.0160413925,
-0.018241208,
-0.0231211931,
-0.0233652219,
-0.0727395788,
-0.0308925081,
0.0437301546,
0.0320106745,
0.0271268543,
0.0644643083,
-0.0265856571,
-0.0227541979,
-0.0155608291,
-0.0700614527,
-0.0047091972,
0.0311243478,
0.0706405342,
0.0585421734,
0.0357375406,
-0.0111063058,
0.0388455465,
0.0583617054,
-0.0442133136,
-0.0115174707,
0.0237067342,
0.0621205792,
0.0387985855,
0.0667498335,
0.0210657474,
0.1053600907,
0.0117027182,
-0.0723957792,
-0.0357416607,
0.0263184123,
0.0413031317,
0.0207048226,
0.0724359155,
-0.0124918437,
-0.036478363,
-0.0435023643,
-0.0196895041,
-0.0384069458,
-0.0404978506,
-0.0070425807,
0.0191366505,
-0.0419579074,
0.0043709441,
0.0354634896,
-0.0464376956,
-0.0249257032,
-0.0102019692,
0.0109478524,
0.0195623077,
0.0009336919,
0.037553478,
-0.040751256,
-0.0167501569,
0.0113136144,
-0.0097191194,
-0.0052354396,
0.0028849361,
0.0377233624,
0.0593817495,
-0.0539855734,
-0.0148546612,
-0.0109027419,
-0.0187169928,
-0.0044904938,
0.068147555,
0.0259481687,
0.0032972002,
0.0208493248,
0.0380735435,
-0.0068817893,
0.0298185907,
-0.0443165787,
0.0138173234,
0.0259405691,
0.0497649349,
-0.0343650803,
0.0023381328,
-0.0347624347,
0.0343458131,
0.0516431369,
-0.0740910396,
-0.0105460277,
0.0286867414,
2.728e-7,
0.0152037246,
0.0088846982,
0.0285559986,
-0.0259611178,
0.0087988591,
0.0221838672,
-0.0107930889,
0.0088487165,
-0.0037287844,
-0.0034165056,
0.0189439654,
0.0208742563,
0.0306886137,
0.017450422,
-0.0410602093,
-0.0001222679,
-0.0430422984,
-0.0044113304,
-0.0347019508,
-0.0411115997,
0.035345979,
0.1281981766,
-0.0036062789,
-0.0053873761,
0.0518927239,
-0.0127405003,
0.0485026725,
0.0371158943,
0.0065817581,
0.0349573456,
0.0346604958,
0.0204013288,
-0.0138284825,
-0.0467106737,
-0.0090690693,
0.0204144064,
-0.0194602516,
0.0639787614,
-0.0256827995,
-0.0019556535,
-0.0161071718,
0.0023537837,
0.0005457086,
-0.0022852521,
0.049774874,
-0.0589113273,
-0.0231217183,
-0.1032888144,
-0.0253888592,
-0.0093107801,
-0.0239636302,
-0.0174502786,
0.007675414,
0.0391115472,
0.0282729287,
-0.0051667723,
-0.0191095602,
-0.1197452918,
-0.0233246889,
0.0357970297,
-0.0149317086,
-0.0322533026,
-0.0281971693,
-0.012758771,
0.0164191071,
-0.0374759138,
0.0279164836,
2.563447826e-34,
0.0592917167,
-0.0236578584,
0.0130472695,
0.0415909626,
0.0110268015,
-0.0125551438,
-0.0401092209,
0.035498105,
-0.0028278285,
-0.0702179298,
-0.0093919951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16294v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16294v1 | LangSuitE: Planning, Controlling and Interacting with Large Language Models in Embodied Text Environments | 2024-06-24T03:36:29 | 2024-06-24T03:36:29 | Zixia Jia, Mengmeng Wang, Baichen Tong, Song-Chun Zhu, Zilong Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown inspiring
achievements in constructing autonomous agents that rely on language
descriptions as inputs. However, it remains unclear how well LLMs can function
as few-shot or zero-shot embodied agents in dynamic interactive environments.
To address this gap, we introduce LangSuitE, a versatile and simulation-free
testbed featuring 6 representative embodied tasks in textual embodied worlds.
Compared with previous LLM-based testbeds, LangSuitE (i) offers adaptability to
diverse environments without multiple simulation engines, (ii) evaluates
agents' capacity to develop ``internalized world knowledge'' with embodied
observations, and (iii) allows easy customization of communication and action
strategies. To address the embodiment challenge, we devise a novel
chain-of-thought (CoT) schema, EmMem, which summarizes embodied states w.r.t.
history information. Comprehensive benchmark results illustrate challenges and
insights of embodied planning. LangSuitE represents a significant step toward
building embodied generalists in the context of language models. | [
0.0452051423,
0.0140830819,
-0.0464431494,
0.0221568774,
-0.0249049049,
0.0144402981,
0.0087824175,
0.012963579,
0.0292551573,
-0.0394490696,
-0.02803519,
-0.0480866134,
0.0092295008,
0.0338301286,
0.0451382175,
-0.0614612997,
0.0269315653,
-0.0597601645,
-0.0155363372,
0.0036634204,
0.0067796474,
-0.0027111324,
-0.0383175686,
0.0450816415,
-0.0116904285,
0.0133299557,
-0.0705407858,
-0.0078556407,
0.0236428007,
-0.0477128513,
-0.0329655334,
0.0186690949,
0.0707713217,
0.0491717979,
0.0000021615,
-0.0219013374,
0.0314088948,
-0.0372972786,
0.0164180361,
-0.0196139384,
0.0345115699,
-0.0105497791,
-0.0135286981,
-0.0275894143,
-0.0318232924,
-0.0189147573,
0.0469663106,
0.0080357334,
0.035443861,
0.050792139,
-0.0083864192,
0.0272112004,
-0.0083802659,
0.0100286761,
0.0017789762,
0.0226609819,
0.031542033,
-0.0116213728,
0.0949386135,
-0.0160846338,
-0.0501917973,
0.0380306803,
0.052353058,
-0.02775231,
-0.0308487117,
0.056648422,
-0.0022419931,
-0.0300202891,
-0.0113000441,
0.0782915503,
0.0373899043,
-0.0304669235,
0.021172205,
0.0093141114,
-0.0153209055,
-0.0112135569,
-0.0108910548,
0.0512876473,
0.012525592,
0.0140808849,
-0.0085307807,
0.0201389436,
0.0116539383,
0.0131870164,
-0.0395308882,
0.0607414655,
0.0129291648,
-0.0192433167,
0.0048791347,
-0.0019842444,
-0.0076932465,
-0.061426837,
0.0345750451,
0.0531639308,
-0.0312981755,
0.0390334688,
-0.0290442985,
-0.024772903,
-0.0157833099,
-0.0426621847,
0.0434799939,
0.0404124483,
0.0324458778,
0.029162949,
-0.0197270736,
0.0665137693,
-0.0178684928,
0.0142535605,
-0.018244613,
0.0270847548,
-0.0438303128,
-0.0069376933,
-0.0381080322,
0.0376379862,
-0.065712072,
-0.0741672292,
0.038846001,
0.045710247,
0.0061164903,
0.0011803659,
-0.0464714803,
0.0174995195,
0.0088221114,
-0.0081429267,
-0.0560423099,
-0.0435262397,
-0.0284586996,
0.0171381906,
0.0036652987,
-0.0313742459,
-0.0014706444,
0.0075792652,
0.0151017969,
-0.0400205068,
-0.038630873,
0.0650894344,
0.0018831489,
-0.0249915104,
0.0272865985,
-0.0117966179,
-0.0140287634,
-0.0481058136,
0.002424208,
-0.0529759228,
0.0448882915,
-0.0362401418,
0.0077523715,
-0.0272060391,
0.0302048326,
-0.0018012821,
0.0103411647,
0.0360854641,
0.0149432225,
0.0230990108,
0.011797606,
-0.0014314915,
0.0445755161,
0.0685612187,
0.0565562584,
0.0176445302,
-0.0299195778,
0.039650701,
-0.0078700632,
0.0707956329,
-0.0045230803,
0.0141139356,
-0.0416735746,
-0.0109887263,
0.0070519499,
0.0802226663,
-0.0008390724,
0.0498014055,
-0.0411050357,
-0.0079792999,
0.0671773031,
0.0657483488,
-0.0408891439,
-0.0301716942,
0.0754087269,
-0.0054046419,
0.0207684021,
-0.0400549248,
-0.0402769558,
0.0440473221,
0.0182170011,
-0.0151605196,
-0.0336495228,
0.0002876257,
-0.006101829,
-0.0077203256,
-0.0008183919,
0.0289622173,
0.021993313,
0.0053155827,
0.0234396365,
0.0141189564,
-0.0260056313,
0.0192902721,
0.0037220055,
-0.0370925814,
-0.0001692442,
-0.019156104,
0.025066955,
0.0729363188,
0.03114748,
-0.0277617425,
-0.0321130566,
-0.0064385571,
0.0324157998,
0.1284256577,
-0.0079518305,
-0.0180775374,
0.0089134267,
-0.010894238,
-0.0092271809,
-0.004015917,
-0.0035829046,
0.0263453294,
0.0041757217,
0.0275586098,
-0.0304915234,
0.0241668746,
-0.0132416999,
0.0487586111,
-0.0895459875,
-0.0040993011,
-0.0532796383,
0.0039074561,
0.0098458799,
-0.0049062921,
-0.0473532379,
-0.0211110078,
0.0271622166,
-0.0469486862,
-0.043300271,
0.044816494,
-0.0398920998,
-0.0293418616,
0.0469659194,
-0.0344760455,
0.0004254434,
0.0089582652,
0.0289369058,
-0.0478654131,
0.0275336821,
-0.0371754616,
0.0712892488,
-0.0029908058,
0.011483497,
-0.0239827055,
-0.0237234253,
-0.0176321454,
0.0152870901,
-0.0146633005,
-0.0187407825,
0.0505346358,
0.0216835979,
0.0101369517,
-0.0307018366,
-0.0275564063,
0.0369442143,
0.0347879007,
0.0077845575,
0.0387663767,
0.0119828675,
-0.0392590985,
-0.0435577966,
-0.0973115712,
-0.0190358702,
-0.0090284618,
-0.0104919672,
0.0261721388,
-0.0308195967,
-0.0468454175,
0.0104410741,
-0.016082786,
0.0466211736,
-0.0277055651,
-0.0088802362,
0.0224249493,
0.0135656428,
-0.0248640794,
-0.0425773039,
0.0203334466,
-0.0240515526,
0.0315454938,
0.0049668606,
-0.0356236361,
-0.0375465564,
0.020477863,
-0.0546779074,
0.0460122153,
-0.0151280379,
-0.0370504186,
0.0351275243,
-0.0476170741,
0.0049796016,
0.0278609209,
-0.0125070177,
0.0481545813,
0.0821299106,
-0.0474557318,
-0.0636132434,
0.0296574254,
-0.0103354836,
0.0369684584,
-0.059205886,
-0.0035970018,
-0.005670052,
0.0827846006,
0.0183991753,
0.0219146274,
-0.0829991177,
0.013137931,
-0.0238821115,
-0.0864106417,
-0.0279092714,
0.0129779158,
-0.0546726957,
0.0148079889,
-0.0672099441,
-0.0234987494,
0.074757725,
-0.0315917805,
-0.0124114119,
0.0178689826,
0.0143613089,
-0.0117355334,
0.105135791,
0.0338789448,
0.0231914911,
0.0037794688,
0.0100478902,
-0.0248612426,
0.0389766172,
-0.0143710813,
-0.0083338376,
0.0089813387,
-0.073192358,
0.0186880995,
0.0081672361,
-0.0274345484,
-0.0031534445,
0.0153754214,
-0.044074256,
0.0083571663,
-0.0331524424,
-0.0265331995,
-0.0322576389,
0.0070945267,
0.0584303997,
0.0583767518,
-0.014191336,
-0.0006782252,
-0.048234567,
-0.0314094722,
0.0688702464,
0.0345538221,
-0.0078853779,
-0.030651819,
0.0643034875,
0.0202589408,
0.0107745416,
-0.0050234986,
-0.0406332836,
0.0004589816,
0.0196132734,
-0.010538918,
0.0077911471,
-0.0005562056,
0.0412391908,
-0.0641711131,
-0.0258905347,
0.1038186327,
0.015907038,
-0.018994242,
0.0204315986,
-0.0114116743,
0.0485553257,
0.0320110507,
0.0258539394,
-0.0637432858,
0.0036476506,
-0.0008330536,
-0.0358571485,
0.0066730771,
-0.0744896978,
-0.0051055541,
-0.1230093613,
0.002879174,
0.0053139008,
-0.0636465698,
0.0139990374,
0.0223538447,
0.0282086041,
0.0351800621,
-0.0102492161,
0.0210678894,
0.0110225352,
-0.0040046372,
-0.0140592474,
-0.0205045603,
-0.0083672004,
-0.0085756583,
-0.0275927614,
0.0684004053,
0.02529631,
0.0503329299,
-0.0113524338,
-0.0140288528,
-0.0163028389,
-0.0169371068,
0.0191850252,
-0.0048705144,
0.005781705,
0.0058952323,
-0.0220265612,
-0.0067569939,
0.0170139689,
-0.0304177925,
-0.0147325611,
0.0061422153,
0.097424522,
-0.0505911894,
-0.0014918637,
-0.0154773146,
-0.0081655718,
0.0019146975,
0.0312603936,
0.0237606503,
-0.0831728652,
-0.0416573733,
-0.0336646736,
-0.0641594157,
-0.0060955742,
-0.0863341391,
-0.0130842561,
-0.0054275086,
0.0196662322,
-0.088097319,
-0.036256168,
0.0559944063,
0.0669619665,
0.042153161,
0.0037601907,
-0.0083387736,
-0.0383029245,
-0.0117175961,
-0.0041831271,
-0.0219329279,
0.0272346009,
-0.0037737854,
-0.010483142,
0.0272772983,
-0.0591814704,
0.018793866,
0.0427509621,
-0.0249376856,
-0.0664326474,
-0.0000811412,
0.0489608198,
0.0212083608,
0.0372559391,
-0.0169462822,
-0.0459219478,
0.0653452501,
-0.018062098,
-0.0003051677,
0.0798077807,
-0.0199152138,
0.0412031189,
0.0009308782,
0.043707557,
-0.0281942375,
0.0112821916,
0.0117693432,
0.0458602831,
0.0257751253,
-0.0170606617,
0.0139917182,
-0.0080963224,
0.0043099122,
-0.0393613912,
-0.0266155545,
-0.039176207,
-0.0087181283,
-0.0512555428,
-0.0217284802,
-0.0501219891,
0.0192532614,
0.0290620737,
0.0189479869,
0.009803026,
0.0140081979,
0.0247385316,
0.0337004513,
0.0102859,
0.0047180853,
0.0238958672,
0.0198211856,
0.0159208849,
0.0579734519,
0.0051835417,
0.0354979262,
-0.0723720789,
0.0432053581,
0.0146434549,
0.0568202585,
0.0074534751,
-0.0672179163,
-0.0208935104,
0.0110461405,
-0.0514194556,
-0.0495226942,
0.0307535138,
0.0204662979,
0.0392100699,
0.0111689642,
0.0747733489,
-0.0650769994,
0.000771285,
0.0150200957,
0.0023180798,
0.0182875339,
-0.0638141856,
0.0155538172,
0.0211782958,
0.0013631205,
-0.0000901789,
0.0033185517,
-0.00029105,
0.0831870064,
0.0450579561,
0.0198482815,
-0.0235459525,
-0.0118386718,
-0.0028638169,
-0.0022168935,
-0.0133372247,
0.0104782842,
-0.0793852955,
-0.0540466309,
0.023230277,
0.0538089909,
-0.0315367654,
-0.0232451726,
0.0448875614,
-0.0382407717,
0.0110251624,
0.0036875969,
-0.0360671282,
-0.0014173638,
-0.0196768399,
-0.0310549755,
-0.0226495601,
-5.781397866e-33,
-0.0636571348,
-0.0112881502,
0.0451969393,
-0.0363079458,
-0.0672903731,
0.005959379,
-0.0858660489,
0.0179454889,
0.0101521872,
0.0165488683,
0.0177922323,
0.0025447847,
-0.0079469699,
0.0015101136,
0.0197656713,
0.0125117172,
-0.0040746205,
-0.0287787877,
-0.0256742332,
-0.0157216862,
0.055545032,
0.0244106464,
0.0162962209,
-0.0306111742,
0.0078009111,
0.0251357853,
-0.0224901773,
0.034175422,
-0.0118005956,
0.0458014831,
-0.0677946806,
0.0155929197,
0.0070386152,
0.0336460546,
-0.0311760344,
0.0200851969,
-0.0396634452,
-0.0252004862,
0.0108864941,
0.0114241261,
-0.0412258059,
-0.0250077751,
0.023727525,
-0.0295432433,
-0.0295206737,
0.0248703863,
0.0105897197,
-0.0236433782,
-0.0045970385,
0.0254977271,
-0.0681825876,
0.0147017781,
-0.0160291251,
-0.0162467696,
0.0406763963,
0.0211016536,
0.0039031624,
-0.0213371217,
-0.0325360335,
0.0067810821,
-0.0326802023,
-0.0358770974,
0.0477351919,
0.029406745,
0.0687677562,
0.1193006486,
0.0287946872,
0.0222617481,
-0.0646868199,
0.0315999985,
0.0731082931,
0.0328230299,
0.0049184808,
0.0682916492,
-0.0449239425,
0.0247299261,
0.0019326271,
-0.0037895304,
0.0207997058,
0.0166854504,
0.0259582624,
0.0239678677,
-0.0302271079,
-0.0047399155,
-0.0605254769,
0.0058802264,
0.0015793568,
-0.026901409,
0.0205171052,
0.0102947606,
-0.0064334488,
-0.0517373942,
0.0408429056,
-0.03575892,
-0.0251146071,
0.0095616216,
-0.0404668376,
0.0718503147,
0.0239175372,
0.0085237045,
-0.0337715447,
-0.0274590589,
0.0363401137,
0.0158245414,
0.0253552981,
0.0177064538,
-0.0182053093,
0.0707556829,
-0.0333189629,
-0.0195625331,
-0.0434448794,
-0.0115947761,
0.0301963836,
-0.0152931325,
0.0398635417,
-0.0318698622,
-0.0293361843,
0.0149198696,
0.0134973573,
-0.0560186021,
0.0169983581,
0.0446903184,
-0.0398509987,
-0.007252417,
-0.0297850315,
0.006682389,
-0.0545197576,
0.0550933704,
0.0528861955,
-0.0897750556,
0.0250868071,
0.0308818482,
2.9e-7,
0.0196453258,
0.0279447325,
0.0327046961,
-0.0074542705,
0.0571586825,
0.0075954283,
-0.0471523106,
0.0464991182,
-0.0570502654,
-0.0852014124,
0.008010759,
0.0493554883,
0.0502003208,
-0.0049435096,
-0.1006547958,
-0.0052783568,
-0.0186717864,
-0.0438751802,
-0.0712159798,
-0.0243765637,
0.0172320735,
0.0616518222,
0.0372251645,
0.0073275706,
0.0028098784,
-0.0187386479,
0.0397703014,
-0.0528119914,
0.0337095223,
-0.0211533569,
-0.0425864086,
-0.0088302046,
-0.0193500314,
-0.0278239213,
0.0182465725,
0.0437498279,
0.0019848198,
0.0615442544,
-0.0057554264,
0.0322056003,
0.0146606723,
-0.0216266587,
-0.0187210832,
-0.0374736339,
0.0669142231,
-0.0329223201,
0.0033065081,
-0.0009534388,
0.0145440856,
-0.0118457368,
-0.0164358541,
-0.0298513435,
0.0001508299,
0.0298035964,
-0.0111223916,
-0.0206401069,
0.0105036804,
-0.071309641,
-0.0328235179,
-0.0127858147,
-0.0492949449,
-0.0176018476,
-0.0556224957,
0.0106707579,
-0.0239367969,
-0.0850376487,
-0.0042841216,
2.535347771e-34,
-0.0094974702,
0.0028818001,
-0.0126873422,
0.035452567,
0.0505031385,
-0.0123478146,
0.0120466379,
0.0132236611,
0.0383447036,
-0.0657483786,
-0.0440593511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16293v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16293v1 | Combining Supervised Learning and Reinforcement Learning for Multi-Label Classification Tasks with Partial Labels | 2024-06-24T03:36:19 | 2024-06-24T03:36:19 | Zixia Jia, Junpeng Li, Shichuan Zhang, Anji Liu, Zilong Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Traditional supervised learning heavily relies on human-annotated datasets,
especially in data-hungry neural approaches. However, various tasks, especially
multi-label tasks like document-level relation extraction, pose challenges in
fully manual annotation due to the specific domain knowledge and large class
sets. Therefore, we address the multi-label positive-unlabelled learning
(MLPUL) problem, where only a subset of positive classes is annotated. We
propose Mixture Learner for Partially Annotated Classification (MLPAC), an
RL-based framework combining the exploration ability of reinforcement learning
and the exploitation ability of supervised learning. Experimental results
across various tasks, including document-level relation extraction, multi-label
image classification, and binary PU learning, demonstrate the generalization
and effectiveness of our framework. | [
0.0258370452,
0.0022489906,
0.0232704096,
0.0097470451,
-0.0118062748,
0.0402278863,
-0.0098555125,
-0.0230878517,
0.0078455461,
-0.0233108439,
-0.0404574499,
0.0152666513,
-0.0623862445,
-0.0357086733,
-0.0242973492,
-0.068972677,
0.0112267053,
-0.0124665201,
0.0702515915,
0.0190486163,
-0.0179020818,
-0.0139296148,
-0.0228824504,
-0.006640573,
-0.0590407178,
0.0266036559,
-0.0180320833,
0.0162586756,
0.0227600951,
-0.0187330134,
-0.003648615,
0.0154353492,
0.0245551951,
0.0120764859,
0.0000017205,
-0.0637292191,
-0.0664240122,
0.0045723091,
0.0157340039,
-0.0736504644,
0.0413269438,
-0.004037932,
0.0233133771,
-0.0155650759,
-0.0271895938,
-0.0187452119,
0.0416930541,
0.1074508578,
0.0476869047,
0.0497286282,
-0.0200314578,
-0.0145255458,
0.0121865375,
-0.0278128702,
0.0551779568,
-0.0415809527,
0.020793939,
0.0174840558,
0.0795868933,
-0.0276867766,
-0.0166835859,
0.0167363267,
0.03225144,
-0.0198954381,
-0.0075398115,
0.0593937635,
-0.0146614732,
-0.0427680649,
0.0013604315,
0.0564211495,
-0.01632227,
0.0262209717,
0.0135571808,
-0.0250832513,
0.0428525545,
-0.01698431,
0.0334161669,
0.0327726714,
-0.0344537944,
0.0324364491,
-0.0214586444,
0.0207190886,
0.0179104414,
0.0025577371,
-0.0031220627,
0.0487898365,
-0.0350505337,
-0.0696951225,
0.0629810616,
0.0538256355,
0.0384042449,
0.0103481729,
-0.0045592389,
0.0140240099,
-0.0120146424,
0.0410134755,
-0.0183076877,
-0.0597614273,
0.0143208019,
-0.0281713922,
-0.0356588438,
-0.030829858,
-0.0127240242,
0.0951819718,
-0.0147903394,
-0.0514288582,
-0.0311808642,
0.0391335636,
-0.0054487642,
-0.0124776782,
-0.0392993428,
0.0160857812,
-0.0461634323,
0.0912313312,
-0.0025072694,
0.0219588988,
-0.0598019734,
0.0027346378,
-0.0414481945,
0.0164257456,
0.0096892677,
-0.0130098471,
-0.0136404075,
-0.0124665843,
-0.0075599817,
-0.0039328136,
-0.012653932,
-0.0007039678,
-0.0198306758,
0.0212601162,
0.0101058222,
-0.0121062882,
0.0083985757,
-0.0601028763,
-0.0063490146,
0.1134902611,
-0.036592856,
-0.0772683322,
-0.0446869843,
-0.0185859185,
0.0295206066,
-0.0231408011,
0.0320396461,
-0.0248604082,
0.0152679067,
-0.0106102554,
0.0020538638,
-0.0065024761,
0.0254578739,
-0.0108969519,
-0.0143425371,
0.0730107203,
0.0014262223,
-0.0302430876,
0.0125620905,
0.0074411733,
-0.0451009572,
0.0650606975,
0.0000290446,
-0.0023654636,
0.0091905687,
0.0479546376,
0.0359031223,
-0.0036505801,
0.0362470448,
-0.0136075215,
0.0104658138,
-0.033984337,
0.0228470601,
0.0083769392,
0.0009913853,
-0.0115835937,
-0.0401530415,
-0.0334121548,
0.0073150182,
-0.0494951606,
-0.0189587828,
-0.0286103804,
0.0077945874,
0.0298937913,
-0.0071279532,
-0.0239854921,
-0.0188155286,
0.0340522155,
-0.0453671627,
0.0219790153,
-0.0185245387,
-0.0130569236,
0.0061348048,
-0.03521128,
0.0053410549,
-0.0646896511,
0.0093515441,
0.0117548872,
0.1158699766,
0.0121412016,
-0.0503331721,
-0.0288124271,
0.0645243898,
0.0038897118,
-0.0253308769,
-0.0266656466,
0.06262777,
-0.0239359736,
-0.0023428588,
-0.1265392154,
-0.0193938706,
-0.0666737333,
-0.0057525914,
0.0562691204,
0.0306842513,
-0.011320672,
0.0193400905,
0.0048144716,
-0.0436375588,
-0.0046237344,
0.0193446074,
0.0533505417,
0.0073940433,
0.0000314957,
-0.0359958,
-0.006277028,
0.0216546282,
0.0269763172,
-0.0079569779,
-0.0253002532,
0.0192364398,
0.0375299044,
0.0221630819,
-0.017653795,
-0.0468142889,
-0.0177675802,
0.0438077487,
-0.0139670251,
-0.0789067149,
-0.0349838175,
-0.0118745808,
-0.0062483521,
0.0350284539,
0.0075411936,
-0.0424684025,
-0.0217151027,
-0.0133282803,
-0.0198160559,
-0.0425703973,
0.0093655279,
0.0268249922,
-0.0145100253,
-0.0349626876,
0.04485026,
-0.0017096305,
-0.0409138538,
0.0716757029,
-0.0215747189,
0.0311541688,
-0.0029044792,
-0.0922319442,
0.0065070158,
-0.0042899977,
-0.0357605405,
-0.0228579268,
-0.0017659862,
0.0081012081,
0.0462853387,
0.0515647419,
-0.0377517268,
-0.018498674,
-0.0076746028,
-0.0334305055,
0.0050454661,
-0.0246261489,
0.0006735016,
0.0093907528,
-0.0091929613,
-0.0676391721,
0.0121784285,
-0.0415942892,
-0.0295647196,
-0.0094207646,
0.0425788946,
0.0565928556,
0.0323852077,
0.0133792534,
-0.0116042737,
0.0016686316,
0.0209308844,
0.0044061234,
-0.0237774383,
0.0202096645,
-0.044450298,
-0.0167748462,
0.033897344,
0.0136604179,
0.0194054972,
-0.0118788499,
-0.0507307798,
-0.024138324,
0.0449570231,
-0.0075434186,
0.0718446299,
0.01881871,
-0.0047610109,
-0.0107504111,
0.0747551173,
-0.0331795476,
-0.0099006891,
-0.0295686945,
0.0211976655,
-0.0226800963,
0.0731642842,
-0.0594277084,
0.0080320649,
-0.0336813591,
-0.0253162254,
-0.0063675493,
-0.0885250643,
-0.0560072102,
0.066563189,
-0.0183410533,
0.0057709324,
-0.0317832306,
-0.0219673999,
0.0875404775,
0.0597646981,
-0.0468346737,
-0.0215081628,
-0.0309081636,
-0.0172353033,
0.0404225811,
-0.0007065538,
0.0423562378,
-0.0080261761,
0.0142365517,
-0.0065027298,
-0.0415903032,
0.0393726453,
0.0190616995,
0.0153209828,
-0.0089119999,
0.0324700922,
-0.0230890978,
-0.0588323586,
-0.0238650497,
-0.0509921685,
0.0171170551,
0.0109929331,
-0.0747745335,
0.0012474348,
-0.0456633829,
-0.0274280608,
0.0206042174,
0.0253254399,
-0.0158582814,
-0.0326473191,
0.0130639272,
0.0303055532,
0.0408931673,
-0.0090082288,
-0.0205316041,
-0.0278578214,
0.0028497779,
0.0194902848,
0.0101273507,
-0.0294335783,
0.011239484,
0.0258285943,
0.0107773375,
-0.0700457245,
0.0259752292,
0.002599953,
0.0077751842,
-0.0284070335,
-0.0183932018,
0.0712312534,
0.0393035673,
-0.0454814807,
-0.0336205177,
-0.0437585525,
0.0144852269,
0.047552567,
0.0621846914,
-0.051155366,
-0.0070212139,
-0.0368770733,
0.0265687834,
0.0207314845,
-0.035114754,
0.0256081503,
-0.1044870988,
-0.0052511357,
-0.0161747895,
-0.0997829437,
0.014643494,
-0.0346553437,
-0.0110870767,
-0.01048264,
-0.0699741021,
0.0098320879,
-0.0034627118,
-0.0103444336,
0.0088878144,
0.0536354631,
-0.0475976057,
-0.0071304631,
-0.0055286922,
0.0017746352,
0.0250947364,
0.0186735503,
-0.0520632826,
-0.0183353387,
0.023130497,
0.0408201441,
-0.0310326125,
-0.0170004275,
0.0567567535,
-0.0312162768,
-0.0086598927,
0.0162936114,
0.0289315879,
-0.0188672692,
-0.0297192521,
-0.0102266138,
0.0818211436,
0.0245865714,
-0.0028443132,
-0.0388591848,
-0.0621561334,
0.0413441733,
0.0200055614,
-0.0393975861,
-0.0679556355,
-0.0459611863,
0.0367991515,
0.0012478761,
-0.0050563589,
0.0679751635,
-0.0083730258,
-0.0868257731,
-0.0173657164,
-0.028953407,
-0.0497699529,
0.0138063636,
0.0694107562,
-0.0342864655,
-0.0270374939,
0.0244707409,
0.0354149304,
-0.0472346991,
-0.0149781294,
-0.0135375094,
0.0217482336,
-0.0130927917,
-0.0480430238,
0.0327818021,
-0.0680051371,
-0.0560148098,
-0.0669296384,
-0.011667002,
-0.0169718824,
-0.0326644294,
0.0586273149,
0.0095997695,
0.0627421886,
-0.0078561641,
-0.017821556,
0.0095457947,
0.0957159102,
-0.0427786857,
-0.0066419132,
0.0520602055,
-0.0210614577,
-0.008047835,
0.0186794735,
-0.0838167816,
0.0509775616,
0.0050504762,
-0.021566825,
-0.0247055423,
0.0359628722,
0.0287812334,
-0.0185030997,
0.0740222186,
0.0018125487,
0.0128332302,
-0.0322520584,
0.0151062515,
0.0054049557,
-0.0509706549,
-0.0289003253,
0.0033151121,
0.0228935704,
0.0018030076,
-0.0188547596,
-0.026945103,
0.0287143439,
0.0650139898,
0.0143785561,
-0.037633054,
0.0778352097,
0.0079837786,
-0.038200222,
0.01692155,
0.0286337901,
0.0211818703,
0.0408276543,
0.0426696017,
0.0280542374,
0.0370937362,
0.0383703746,
0.0346359573,
0.0014745304,
-0.0230696332,
-0.0226549935,
0.0487519465,
-0.0028009904,
0.0750853196,
0.0547482818,
0.0117453001,
0.0122336028,
-0.0133969933,
-0.0225741453,
0.0191502627,
-0.0073964023,
-0.0407864265,
-0.0127114588,
0.0373670682,
0.0204252619,
0.0211182851,
0.0330771469,
0.0620488636,
-0.0232705474,
0.0165036339,
-0.0056968071,
-0.0184830148,
-0.0516213328,
0.010206122,
0.0247880369,
0.0560492612,
0.0236729793,
0.0249832664,
-0.039027568,
-0.0213510375,
-0.0019507507,
0.0189442039,
-0.0016195095,
0.0571911409,
0.0304250997,
0.0173723921,
0.023092946,
-0.0266171042,
-0.075883843,
-0.0119693158,
0.01246526,
0.021734057,
0.0021622586,
-5.570496547e-33,
-0.0290332381,
-0.0269812495,
0.0125486106,
0.0021029192,
-0.0126737962,
0.0270529147,
0.0354049541,
-0.0093139689,
0.0237791333,
0.0382729284,
-0.004832183,
-0.0274312049,
-0.0088164518,
0.0370171331,
0.0166608952,
-0.0198020674,
0.0377515554,
0.0308899991,
0.0012898193,
0.0079145674,
0.0261927545,
0.0237499494,
0.0278851371,
-0.1116817221,
-0.0108442465,
0.0209472869,
-0.0328930728,
0.0242117029,
-0.0315784626,
0.0508784167,
0.0242197979,
0.0004573826,
0.0284903478,
-0.0153904855,
0.010074378,
-0.0251049884,
-0.1448806673,
-0.0423423871,
-0.0474785827,
0.0089972187,
-0.0453984551,
0.0434031934,
0.016829947,
0.0210739207,
0.0573859029,
-0.0004316477,
0.0591317266,
0.0018708273,
-0.0043909005,
-0.1012271866,
-0.028215006,
0.01873767,
0.0162408687,
0.0033081167,
0.0219598711,
0.0184215028,
-0.004641518,
0.0376049839,
-0.0263251793,
-0.025122501,
-0.0108176218,
-0.0305738542,
0.016937552,
0.0373237729,
0.0047711814,
0.0243828557,
-0.0182923153,
0.0213663857,
0.0160571765,
-0.0315041617,
0.0014965883,
0.0405314043,
-0.0219775084,
0.0318120867,
0.0166350901,
0.0259000678,
-0.0348565206,
0.0050815679,
0.0593834259,
0.0138165373,
0.0134417657,
0.057574939,
-0.0034600615,
0.0252749082,
-0.0237106867,
0.0005025021,
-0.0105216317,
-0.0098485593,
0.0209666044,
0.038627889,
-0.0475583002,
0.0408479013,
-0.0127880536,
-0.0099594472,
-0.0581698678,
0.0118942801,
-0.0313146114,
0.0444243737,
-0.0048241061,
-0.0793781579,
-0.0516397357,
-0.0476597585,
0.0039996621,
-0.0397198051,
-0.0311031565,
0.020446958,
0.0790317431,
0.0185424238,
-0.0662621409,
0.0077616894,
0.0053577363,
0.0447748974,
0.0231017563,
0.0284882504,
0.0235197674,
-0.0055934559,
-0.0376521572,
0.0559070595,
0.0367751829,
0.0243948624,
-0.0226019751,
0.0099216094,
-0.0310362726,
-0.0435099192,
0.0132461265,
-0.0122930128,
0.0368493311,
0.0221047793,
0.0111004617,
-0.0984791368,
0.0164763909,
-0.0004218112,
2.481e-7,
0.0104558673,
0.0375562571,
0.0300596431,
-0.0060277008,
0.0242066607,
0.0615962781,
-0.0311695375,
0.0070192041,
-0.0030144737,
0.0264263079,
0.0313501433,
-0.0124819009,
-0.026228182,
0.0226917695,
-0.0587315112,
-0.0234225262,
-0.0417442173,
-0.0159479994,
-0.0556004047,
-0.0349089205,
0.0696368292,
0.0539284497,
0.1095711067,
-0.0242158212,
0.0051665208,
-0.0278702807,
0.0733002797,
-0.0206148606,
0.0292933248,
-0.0355824269,
0.0462152511,
0.009881082,
0.0093995864,
0.0265293047,
0.0182993691,
0.0318734013,
0.0080545945,
0.0433116779,
-0.0224238206,
0.0198883284,
0.0378309786,
0.0393401571,
0.0117411343,
0.0227674358,
0.0516995899,
-0.0752287507,
0.0135162761,
-0.0258428548,
-0.0286808535,
-0.0177272856,
0.0338900238,
-0.0060414542,
-0.0058177826,
0.0470478684,
-0.0115231778,
0.0083965855,
-0.0330125988,
-0.0483323075,
0.0137335882,
0.0310060419,
0.0218349919,
0.0410167538,
0.0024656495,
0.0604366735,
-0.0199498683,
-0.0438995436,
-0.0421728045,
1.79874731e-34,
0.0298445243,
-0.0156619083,
-0.0337964967,
0.0279803798,
-0.0176364426,
-0.0018632512,
-0.0991102755,
0.0152910007,
0.0028854846,
0.0296471715,
0.0346709341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16288v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16288v1 | PlagBench: Exploring the Duality of Large Language Models in Plagiarism Generation and Detection | 2024-06-24T03:29:53 | 2024-06-24T03:29:53 | Jooyoung Lee, Toshini Agrawal, Adaku Uchendu, Thai Le, Jinghui Chen, Dongwon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent literature has highlighted potential risks to academic integrity
associated with large language models (LLMs), as they can memorize parts of
training instances and reproduce them in the generated texts without proper
attribution. In addition, given their capabilities in generating high-quality
texts, plagiarists can exploit LLMs to generate realistic paraphrases or
summaries indistinguishable from original work. In response to possible
malicious use of LLMs in plagiarism, we introduce PlagBench, a comprehensive
dataset consisting of 46.5K synthetic plagiarism cases generated using three
instruction-tuned LLMs across three writing domains. The quality of PlagBench
is ensured through fine-grained automatic evaluation for each type of
plagiarism, complemented by human annotation. We then leverage our proposed
dataset to evaluate the plagiarism detection performance of five modern LLMs
and three specialized plagiarism checkers. Our findings reveal that GPT-3.5
tends to generates paraphrases and summaries of higher quality compared to
Llama2 and GPT-4. Despite LLMs' weak performance in summary plagiarism
identification, they can surpass current commercial plagiarism detectors.
Overall, our results highlight the potential of LLMs to serve as robust
plagiarism detection tools. | [
0.0622020513,
0.0323719308,
-0.0070720874,
0.0799554437,
-0.0813298523,
0.0008058685,
0.0418414138,
0.0044329138,
0.0274457056,
-0.0552719757,
-0.0278848838,
0.0208740178,
0.0033235205,
-0.0282280874,
0.0737900883,
0.0305236392,
0.0003528479,
-0.007044286,
-0.0057818955,
0.0085209664,
0.0291335285,
0.0231680386,
0.0740468055,
0.036255341,
0.0190029629,
-0.041021321,
0.0410378464,
-0.0002300923,
0.0298676658,
0.0296152066,
0.0194269549,
0.0325311795,
-0.026688775,
0.1104284301,
0.0000015802,
-0.0503892079,
-0.0113743693,
0.0245089754,
-0.0002685767,
0.0678689033,
0.0822031945,
0.0139624225,
0.0126295341,
-0.0104668392,
-0.0123826675,
0.0043522515,
-0.0285252724,
0.0395479202,
0.081530109,
0.0623209402,
-0.0307279695,
-0.0251642801,
0.0581683852,
-0.0027037405,
-0.0208094586,
-0.0028306961,
0.0531579517,
0.0155755235,
0.0229522493,
0.0466603264,
0.0173555389,
0.0383402742,
-0.0109753609,
-0.0445541292,
-0.0041908869,
-0.0321416222,
-0.0378284156,
0.0431621037,
0.0340520963,
0.0184765421,
-0.0437088497,
-0.0877768099,
0.0229776986,
-0.0168881901,
0.022694014,
0.0432495698,
-0.0067078923,
0.0592824891,
-0.0540744588,
0.017769793,
0.0145097431,
-0.0106184166,
0.0219739061,
0.0390184969,
0.0487891734,
0.007634921,
0.0357441194,
-0.0397957526,
-0.0339768603,
-0.013652131,
-0.0024834729,
-0.0445198379,
0.0248620342,
0.0066508255,
0.0297302268,
-0.0326471291,
-0.0588019378,
-0.0725235492,
0.0441033952,
-0.0313240699,
0.0593860894,
0.0228664968,
-0.0086741839,
0.0280317254,
-0.048593726,
0.06553711,
-0.0438812785,
0.0388171561,
-0.0247633308,
-0.0140126524,
-0.0212673992,
-0.0103090266,
-0.0170028247,
0.0249081384,
0.0139673119,
0.0021892381,
-0.0510799102,
0.0131176831,
0.0053162645,
0.0242834575,
-0.0465949029,
-0.0298695322,
0.0182252564,
0.0213595852,
0.0317267329,
-0.0037601748,
0.0274939276,
0.0297425184,
-0.0194876567,
-0.0594545417,
-0.0224183369,
0.0327522159,
0.0036955622,
-0.0278660581,
0.0309955925,
0.0524371602,
0.0262399595,
-0.0246406291,
-0.0175987538,
-0.0653562099,
0.0122033665,
-0.0499164462,
-0.0330691412,
-0.0686690733,
-0.0003429019,
-0.0107045341,
-0.0138776004,
-0.0648454279,
-0.0223201271,
0.0531588271,
-0.0483062752,
0.0000952916,
-0.0130690094,
0.0183803644,
0.0258373898,
-0.0021845957,
-0.0434354059,
-0.0281085502,
0.0291573573,
0.0440808684,
0.0512525216,
0.0300688222,
0.0330646001,
0.0495629162,
0.0283295289,
0.0418663882,
0.0069961431,
-0.0111130374,
0.0250678658,
-0.0002676023,
0.0241693426,
0.0729846954,
-0.02125456,
-0.0304051153,
0.1090369076,
0.0640295371,
-0.0398671851,
0.0528423339,
0.0359820276,
0.020532649,
0.0390993208,
0.0007813014,
-0.0372058116,
-0.025815662,
-0.0286741797,
0.0056065349,
-0.0133150769,
0.0310772602,
0.0321570076,
0.0191396177,
-0.0093135284,
-0.0023219106,
-0.0504621305,
-0.0023107508,
-0.0170536581,
0.0118480381,
-0.0241052676,
0.0236000493,
-0.0248337835,
-0.0675344691,
-0.0079194671,
-0.0479217544,
0.0527976416,
0.0564583838,
0.0944953561,
-0.01098355,
0.0460290462,
-0.0587916635,
0.0093946727,
0.0303515363,
0.0130839711,
-0.0216055699,
-0.0036992871,
-0.0322781615,
-0.0429230072,
-0.0337957479,
-0.0042099385,
-0.0099056792,
0.0407007076,
-0.017558014,
0.0300346855,
-0.0246625487,
-0.0936425328,
0.0443027429,
-0.0426700786,
0.0111296745,
-0.0125759598,
-0.0117217693,
-0.0013489245,
0.0055647236,
-0.0330630727,
0.0262103807,
-0.0042258413,
-0.049116645,
0.0038826016,
-0.0227606576,
0.026551988,
0.0337821878,
0.0681985691,
-0.0474319607,
0.0026935232,
0.0280216094,
-0.0156015512,
0.0223512575,
0.0141137568,
-0.0157658309,
-0.0055544181,
-0.0625126883,
0.0298545212,
-0.0740224421,
0.0507322103,
-0.0188273806,
0.0396565981,
0.0022912174,
0.0317768492,
0.0587518588,
-0.0229182225,
0.0499886684,
0.0054405699,
-0.0486410893,
-0.0477458984,
0.0293338653,
0.0106925145,
-0.0047625462,
-0.006347036,
-0.0130395275,
-0.041197788,
-0.0380012654,
0.0103876591,
0.0044354685,
0.0206969138,
0.0480168872,
-0.0101854298,
-0.0293968339,
0.0264476072,
0.0050066346,
-0.0429693311,
0.0107680876,
-0.0068985033,
0.0289969817,
-0.0148002692,
-0.01200948,
-0.0296006631,
0.0227271449,
-0.0134623013,
0.0513549,
0.0412221104,
-0.0131238308,
-0.0686679184,
0.0499982461,
0.0313962027,
-0.0193603281,
0.0013407822,
0.0099052414,
-0.0474450961,
-0.0256444886,
0.0081552221,
0.0655810684,
0.009215124,
-0.0348510072,
0.0263136402,
0.0231101066,
-0.049804952,
-0.0414297618,
-0.0041795992,
-0.0190140437,
-0.033560995,
-0.0460523143,
0.035752967,
-0.0242116395,
0.0296424814,
-0.0445912667,
0.0032405008,
0.0303578619,
-0.00535732,
0.0015924997,
0.0375072062,
-0.0545776226,
-0.031097522,
-0.0259879399,
-0.0276293121,
-0.0588054098,
0.0310711917,
-0.0578140803,
0.0308645666,
0.0053168321,
-0.0005996208,
-0.0360173658,
0.0109192068,
-0.0012348574,
0.0315809138,
0.0111768842,
0.0068571232,
-0.0174160469,
-0.0116533982,
0.0750921592,
-0.0132126696,
0.0465433374,
-0.0149810649,
0.0380002111,
-0.009400039,
-0.0043266998,
-0.0199484881,
-0.0807033628,
-0.0192319918,
0.0086818505,
-0.0165313799,
-0.0054067415,
-0.0306770355,
-0.0628025159,
0.0502971224,
0.0553281009,
-0.0536516793,
0.0026741805,
-0.0158503558,
0.0446891226,
0.0217555966,
-0.0437950045,
0.0055426434,
-0.0534067973,
-0.0222457945,
0.0283028334,
-0.0080069508,
0.0495689586,
-0.0079008788,
-0.0161731318,
-0.0039169965,
-0.0265479926,
0.0078171743,
-0.0226613432,
0.0255659521,
-0.0458435006,
-0.0176613722,
0.0878817812,
-0.0393479392,
-0.0372960716,
-0.0500212237,
-0.0325538442,
0.0219642054,
0.0157950092,
-0.0107067851,
-0.0758361146,
-0.020777354,
-0.0039750552,
0.0377760977,
-0.0250682682,
-0.0329790078,
-0.0044453531,
-0.0884380713,
0.012833464,
0.0127544207,
-0.0429690517,
-0.0300561897,
-0.016515756,
-0.029299112,
0.0144465845,
-0.0174687244,
-0.0139831994,
-0.0183358528,
0.002251334,
-0.0157008674,
-0.0163136013,
-0.0377025418,
-0.0028632015,
-0.0712095797,
0.0092695551,
0.0519545749,
0.0380432308,
-0.0298546664,
-0.024548158,
0.0266771354,
-0.0099820914,
-0.0508331209,
0.004732063,
0.0492272116,
-0.0247827973,
0.0187038369,
-0.014277963,
0.06513457,
-0.0086297439,
-0.0155094871,
0.0461667627,
0.0663113743,
0.0224410091,
-0.0219767746,
-0.0279964525,
-0.0021703842,
0.0113174003,
0.0476921275,
0.0648246929,
-0.0003956424,
-0.0514227077,
-0.0158261973,
-0.027370356,
-0.0576867871,
-0.0534208752,
0.032129284,
-0.0123966793,
0.0148899611,
-0.0507685281,
-0.020046806,
-0.0440294258,
-0.0468411036,
0.0565689392,
0.0634283945,
-0.0164262187,
-0.0393916517,
-0.0390176065,
-0.0255495179,
-0.081040509,
0.045662161,
-0.0001293949,
0.0246681031,
0.0172498506,
0.0003359956,
-0.0017308391,
0.0297083054,
-0.1081736982,
-0.055563543,
-0.00231642,
0.0279747881,
0.0165364165,
0.0415675081,
-0.0000585962,
-0.020107314,
0.0614521913,
0.0110214762,
0.0015076807,
0.050471779,
-0.0010214886,
-0.0825563073,
-0.0099522108,
0.0312082283,
-0.0321603678,
0.006137535,
0.0562093779,
-0.0463357903,
-0.0224370454,
-0.0234990977,
0.0044821161,
0.0503384247,
-0.0045582303,
-0.0314628221,
0.0314017609,
-0.0209292602,
-0.0005355106,
-0.0161629636,
-0.0131562781,
-0.0185410585,
0.0326871797,
0.061060477,
-0.0081439149,
0.0010866588,
0.029741697,
-0.0028713117,
0.0536078736,
-0.0084792394,
0.0375268087,
-0.0339640304,
0.0486623794,
-0.0007417836,
-0.015717661,
-0.0204365309,
0.0088990973,
-0.0330296643,
0.0571259335,
0.0154970894,
0.0334238037,
0.0358555019,
-0.0081423409,
0.0312929787,
0.0319030955,
-0.0909809023,
-0.0019087952,
-0.0298345368,
-0.0091633582,
0.0525264665,
-0.0353882313,
0.0684116557,
-0.0172958802,
-0.0223983172,
-0.0363126285,
0.0348589867,
-0.0297129564,
-0.0136241671,
-0.0436902195,
-0.0049300324,
-0.0187969487,
0.0565676503,
0.0730860978,
0.0416563712,
0.0485489555,
0.0158606935,
-0.0494483747,
-0.0075971549,
-0.0451776311,
0.0222277455,
-0.0108458819,
-0.0067494344,
-0.0550807267,
-0.0495025292,
-0.0330312103,
0.0320743211,
0.0547316372,
0.008332422,
-0.0152687905,
-0.0056627109,
0.0340234302,
-0.0065008835,
0.0150703201,
-0.0663303062,
0.0719774961,
0.0365313515,
-0.0383453518,
-0.0027270524,
-4.31956154e-33,
0.0162122715,
-0.0390486978,
-0.023303574,
0.032466054,
-0.0431735963,
0.012702642,
-0.0172916856,
-0.0703240782,
-0.0287092812,
0.0311227664,
-0.0305549968,
0.0241078772,
-0.0114357714,
0.0101683717,
0.0291999038,
-0.0102556599,
0.043588046,
0.0134384306,
-0.0351235382,
0.0046719802,
0.0191606935,
0.0138836047,
0.0246426575,
-0.051858183,
0.0448846258,
-0.0832200274,
-0.0428045541,
-0.0396766327,
-0.0551754683,
0.0257511325,
-0.0127885323,
0.0334298797,
0.0106362998,
-0.0107957451,
-0.0259423945,
-0.009509624,
-0.0240153577,
0.005931796,
0.0111253262,
-0.0039981231,
0.0082468847,
-0.0603891797,
0.0765661672,
-0.0207980275,
-0.0078267623,
-0.0134984255,
0.0630859286,
-0.053448543,
-0.0184571408,
-0.0165062901,
-0.0281764865,
0.0149483299,
-0.0012619054,
0.0405685231,
0.0266455077,
0.0019498891,
0.0068477602,
0.0742526576,
-0.0624393523,
0.0210376997,
-0.0052283392,
0.0253307261,
0.0000132566,
-0.0139388591,
0.0219498631,
0.0591590069,
0.0181068648,
-0.0336771533,
0.0258893892,
0.0022333784,
-0.0128413746,
0.0119520286,
0.0636259839,
0.114994742,
0.0112750968,
-0.0329185165,
-0.0205048155,
0.0370521322,
0.0089381114,
-0.0080672223,
0.0244528167,
-0.045750834,
-0.0255209263,
-0.0224819668,
-0.0127081098,
-0.0628163591,
-0.0151660023,
0.0006914811,
0.0398918986,
-0.0191347413,
0.0091566592,
0.0098889833,
0.0079516284,
-0.0680050924,
-0.0245646853,
0.0239473525,
-0.0528950244,
0.0083747255,
0.0031326776,
0.0163282715,
-0.0127540305,
-0.0064099864,
-0.0128765935,
-0.0137495585,
0.0364448242,
0.0131895412,
0.0882917866,
0.0249143355,
-0.0609866343,
0.0168822147,
0.0053206529,
-0.0106230378,
0.0069091222,
0.0085239811,
-0.0112467092,
0.0231715962,
0.0483980775,
-0.0081182737,
0.0176811069,
0.0121757891,
-0.0436985008,
0.0118154595,
0.009279131,
0.0170686785,
0.0083334576,
-0.0124693541,
-0.0273959581,
0.0733381808,
-0.0052495399,
-0.0591053329,
0.0256143399,
-0.0003718821,
2.233e-7,
0.0350458324,
0.0089684464,
0.0169079676,
-0.0419422872,
-0.009024865,
0.0636869147,
-0.0263501834,
0.0320315138,
-0.0076293815,
0.0103520565,
0.0011754504,
0.0000012109,
0.0325012766,
-0.0003554052,
-0.1206508875,
0.0399733968,
-0.0535798185,
-0.0452438332,
-0.0710649118,
-0.0093597732,
0.0437882356,
0.0559517592,
0.0468718074,
-0.0555532351,
-0.0187558718,
-0.0775715113,
0.0463608764,
0.0094667086,
-0.0383185446,
0.0330271162,
0.0539679416,
-0.0213046931,
0.0077976706,
0.0090853069,
-0.0075448765,
0.0203746222,
0.0173244458,
0.0326786153,
0.0192056429,
0.022828158,
-0.0278344397,
-0.0769324824,
0.0035251225,
-0.0639713854,
0.0384924784,
0.0484967604,
0.0468982533,
-0.0520566478,
-0.0537991002,
-0.0352044478,
0.0198354628,
-0.0210463293,
0.0004363423,
0.0038638788,
-0.0145282345,
0.0257993285,
0.0043481528,
-0.0438488685,
-0.0116047924,
-0.0336834192,
-0.0377536044,
-0.0265883896,
-0.0151656354,
-0.0144249983,
0.0470522642,
-0.0712843314,
0.0552031212,
2.043256678e-34,
0.0395336561,
-0.0320059285,
0.0274643805,
0.0346649326,
-3.433e-7,
0.0123799266,
-0.0121492138,
0.0272622723,
-0.0501975492,
0.0109431176,
0.0020803462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16275v1 | Investigating the Influence of Prompt-Specific Shortcuts in AI Generated Text Detection | 2024-06-24T02:50:09 | 2024-06-24T02:50:09 | Choonghyun Park, Hyuhng Joon Kim, Junyeob Kim, Youna Kim, Taeuk Kim, Hyunsoo Cho, Hwiyeol Jo, Sang-goo Lee, Kang Min Yoo | cs.CL | cs.CL | AI Generated Text (AIGT) detectors are developed with texts from humans and
LLMs of common tasks. Despite the diversity of plausible prompt choices, these
datasets are generally constructed with a limited number of prompts. The lack
of prompt variation can introduce prompt-specific shortcut features that exist
in data collected with the chosen prompt, but do not generalize to others. In
this paper, we analyze the impact of such shortcuts in AIGT detection. We
propose Feedback-based Adversarial Instruction List Optimization (FAILOpt), an
attack that searches for instructions deceptive to AIGT detectors exploiting
prompt-specific shortcuts. FAILOpt effectively drops the detection performance
of the target detector, comparable to other attacks based on adversarial
in-context examples. We also utilize our method to enhance the robustness of
the detector by mitigating the shortcuts. Based on the findings, we further
train the classifier with the dataset augmented by FAILOpt prompt. The
augmented classifier exhibits improvements across generation models, tasks, and
attacks. Our code will be available at https://github.com/zxcvvxcz/FAILOpt. | [
0.0381244607,
0.0011580595,
-0.0351398103,
0.04739099,
-0.0185678322,
0.0194685068,
0.0148046967,
0.0240602121,
0.0394302234,
-0.0392347276,
-0.0411055274,
0.0075568203,
0.0176317859,
0.0238461159,
0.0548007265,
0.0215648599,
0.0457539819,
-0.0213536024,
-0.0400849655,
0.0009112601,
-0.01627714,
0.0077410475,
-0.005643283,
0.0501855947,
0.0033364459,
-0.0041709696,
-0.0295662563,
0.0168031882,
0.032815814,
-0.0237725936,
0.0209879223,
0.0274696443,
-0.0243780091,
0.0633862391,
0.000002171,
-0.0062633003,
-0.0079153785,
-0.0136974566,
-0.0682515875,
0.0193751454,
0.0068984861,
-0.0170343574,
-0.0260790382,
-0.0000711889,
-0.0147450622,
0.0105007822,
0.0159029681,
0.060612198,
0.0313489661,
0.1020661294,
-0.0131427599,
0.0495711006,
0.0183167104,
-0.0654447824,
0.0345446356,
-0.051833991,
-0.0122279515,
-0.0808420628,
0.0124540934,
0.0385118425,
0.0049542687,
0.0129308933,
0.0275138803,
0.0053215157,
-0.0402708575,
0.0588169247,
0.027816942,
0.0022279036,
-0.0299589168,
0.0575358383,
-0.0504999906,
-0.0291548595,
0.0332610868,
-0.018969804,
0.054881718,
-0.0109234294,
0.0194702689,
0.012179113,
-0.0354477614,
-0.0224767178,
-0.0089241555,
-0.0255917795,
0.0118759451,
0.0022091295,
0.0348026678,
0.0118624549,
-0.0020324735,
-0.017469734,
0.0067527071,
-0.039766144,
-0.0314244889,
-0.0837037638,
0.025043739,
0.0300720613,
-0.0382962562,
-0.0131087601,
-0.1182582676,
-0.0398066528,
0.0258425735,
-0.0191217978,
0.0628339574,
0.0091142431,
-0.0499591567,
0.0001618344,
-0.0473454073,
0.0793299675,
-0.0335991904,
0.0517492592,
-0.010398834,
0.0488712117,
-0.0179593116,
-0.0002133763,
-0.0000636547,
0.0071036192,
-0.0136834271,
-0.0073467642,
-0.0225823,
0.0381632857,
-0.0130547145,
0.0340174139,
-0.039455615,
0.0078909323,
-0.0305601303,
0.0458746888,
0.0278632045,
-0.0511694103,
-0.0263765454,
0.0079494864,
0.0195314419,
-0.050006263,
-0.0560169034,
0.0576934367,
-0.0223100968,
-0.0124058789,
0.0101583889,
0.0667902008,
-0.0039123702,
-0.0449022911,
-0.0484603047,
-0.0720186457,
-0.0585374199,
-0.0208362918,
0.0218501259,
-0.0507831164,
-0.0152052203,
-0.048520308,
-0.0161911994,
-0.0253342334,
-0.0088877194,
0.0405100733,
-0.0193530768,
0.0683403835,
0.0190599281,
-0.0539083816,
0.0384918861,
0.0324326791,
-0.0204917081,
0.0286779273,
-0.004009896,
0.1369517297,
0.0493442528,
-0.0195275694,
0.0209367499,
0.0436241291,
0.0555816591,
0.03481986,
0.0441076532,
-0.0037814935,
0.0050877267,
-0.0050224476,
-0.0006343959,
0.0314865634,
-0.0045469822,
-0.0635507107,
0.0573749542,
0.0230320022,
-0.0314802192,
-0.0114861522,
0.0497584343,
0.0234261155,
-0.0418450721,
0.0253151935,
-0.0444599353,
0.0068887193,
-0.0891684815,
-0.0462552123,
-0.0121032577,
-0.0104596475,
-0.0158999208,
-0.0210434236,
0.0179128386,
-0.0512154885,
-0.0109968679,
0.0055127037,
0.0209396686,
0.033198934,
-0.0666055828,
-0.0273909867,
-0.0064241113,
-0.0152016645,
-0.0366235226,
-0.0845322609,
0.0266592763,
0.0121902693,
0.0443977639,
0.0021177628,
0.0339636467,
-0.0106065022,
0.0156227695,
-0.0095330626,
0.0219237655,
-0.0075651761,
0.0151386503,
-0.0159041472,
-0.0259963311,
-0.0569093823,
-0.0131222857,
0.0598595701,
0.0114812721,
0.006013725,
0.0341660753,
0.0020104889,
0.0039858171,
0.044373285,
0.0233962517,
-0.08923392,
0.0330939963,
0.0428555012,
0.0344053209,
-0.0062242406,
-0.0010605643,
0.0306904782,
0.0495326519,
-0.0283376276,
-0.0072995755,
-0.0518130846,
-0.0133624813,
-0.044390589,
-0.0087387273,
-0.0190474186,
-0.0254327226,
0.0591665171,
-0.0352597386,
-0.014130814,
-0.0178877935,
-0.0454541706,
-0.0162013266,
-0.016600281,
0.015451191,
0.0246807467,
0.048462078,
-0.0153810298,
0.0674368218,
-0.0183535106,
-0.0289054532,
0.0174688399,
0.0311196446,
0.0465146452,
-0.042661164,
0.0149515411,
0.0074057025,
-0.0323356725,
-0.0442011915,
0.0240783263,
0.0336159058,
-0.0234881733,
-0.0325161107,
-0.0652092248,
0.0032544758,
-0.0274173431,
0.00140382,
0.0254537929,
-0.0197204109,
-0.0129739614,
-0.0052029304,
-0.0088351481,
-0.0214505568,
-0.02253001,
0.0091781951,
-0.0033513047,
0.0077404054,
0.005622087,
0.0064492472,
0.003933317,
-0.0027816475,
0.0399873592,
-0.0030568854,
-0.0139219239,
-0.0466134772,
0.0269740168,
0.0378385261,
0.0277552158,
-0.0421991311,
-0.0308200531,
0.0322680213,
0.0473771431,
-0.0071888808,
0.110855639,
0.0322973132,
0.0386009365,
0.038490694,
0.0532710515,
-0.0215287041,
0.0161536988,
0.0346740559,
0.001540942,
-0.0364947356,
-0.0609129369,
0.0571228601,
0.044018019,
0.0371736325,
0.0045542358,
-0.0231483858,
0.0082631484,
0.0195670854,
-0.0543661676,
-0.0203587785,
-0.0420766175,
-0.0347650424,
-0.0016076121,
-0.029586548,
-0.0710716248,
0.0676549971,
-0.051926665,
0.0118170604,
-0.0097046141,
-0.0327102207,
0.0279740971,
0.0242000092,
0.0129435062,
-0.0114229284,
0.0304395445,
-0.0092463726,
-0.0388808474,
0.0158622954,
0.0164449085,
-0.0061980546,
0.0351636671,
-0.0248460323,
-0.0171481259,
-0.0058698407,
-0.0285409316,
-0.0864996538,
-0.0899071842,
0.0195437297,
-0.0300320722,
0.0391482413,
-0.0462088659,
-0.0213393997,
-0.045632448,
0.029759828,
0.0486802533,
-0.0339622721,
-0.0081150755,
-0.0405596979,
0.043396879,
0.092750445,
-0.0729981437,
0.0071549937,
-0.0307921059,
0.021974735,
0.0697874874,
0.0095653236,
0.0209361985,
0.0014783244,
-0.0134762879,
0.0178775936,
0.0135912746,
-0.007897974,
0.0542101376,
0.0302396026,
0.0031860296,
-0.0070842141,
0.0746032149,
0.0244315863,
-0.0643570945,
0.037423443,
0.0550391041,
0.0369826704,
0.0017493814,
-0.0049182684,
-0.0688053593,
-0.0430659764,
0.0137959374,
0.0590233803,
-0.0447720736,
0.0085667083,
-0.0227221549,
-0.1002957523,
0.0119080627,
-0.0030787594,
-0.0135681098,
-0.0390115753,
0.0004172639,
-0.0066973241,
0.0223612897,
0.0158105139,
-0.0311175771,
-0.0011218534,
0.0017063339,
0.0060113934,
0.0205201115,
-0.0202953741,
0.0233818684,
-0.0041212668,
0.0342961922,
0.0923062414,
0.0162852295,
0.0027975142,
-0.0123841893,
0.0291859433,
-0.0074784593,
0.0199116301,
-0.00012756,
0.0706534237,
-0.0099584777,
0.0062227286,
0.0222656056,
0.0729191154,
-0.0340325497,
-0.0075304094,
0.0883125216,
0.0070609497,
-0.0347817726,
-0.0447742417,
-0.0185509175,
-0.0219805054,
0.0427667797,
0.0547139458,
0.0285392012,
-0.0504306257,
-0.0065634083,
-0.0400589034,
0.0236228444,
-0.0644348562,
-0.0449257381,
0.0097537963,
-0.0107321674,
-0.0476369672,
-0.0570877045,
-0.0315327942,
-0.0213167481,
0.0213827584,
-0.0096971644,
-0.029782651,
-0.0664624572,
0.0058981404,
-0.0470357165,
-0.0172500741,
-0.0103409924,
0.0498051718,
-0.0556205288,
-0.0198634844,
0.003302769,
-0.052203998,
-0.0121761579,
0.0522553809,
-0.103555724,
-0.0443773456,
-0.0069665471,
0.0532569215,
0.0078236265,
0.0384580381,
-0.0357069224,
-0.0357092768,
0.0593328513,
0.0378129631,
-0.0117668053,
0.044417914,
0.0680009201,
-0.0261752103,
-0.0201414246,
0.0160587654,
-0.0326417461,
0.0204460751,
0.0797354952,
-0.0568716526,
-0.0205862522,
-0.0085263047,
0.0307481699,
-0.0079773655,
0.0519064963,
-0.0633362308,
0.0019838142,
0.0301547144,
0.038330391,
0.0224406179,
0.0025199873,
-0.0025537629,
0.022656925,
0.0058658603,
-0.018020235,
0.0411146022,
-0.0186609458,
-0.0186176281,
0.0328625627,
-0.0727377832,
0.0453186482,
0.0226999205,
0.0805039331,
0.0411977433,
0.0048764148,
0.0032216012,
0.0567412749,
0.028869262,
0.0384295359,
-0.0065885587,
0.0697567463,
0.021496566,
-0.0247600377,
0.0093197459,
0.052815862,
-0.0398701318,
0.0061723278,
-0.0329600722,
0.0283003598,
0.0204441007,
-0.0268197395,
-0.0163763762,
-0.0250891503,
-0.000099614,
-0.0218766313,
-0.0258902423,
0.0036506662,
-0.0452744365,
-0.0146766147,
-0.000958873,
0.0083102575,
0.0019923528,
0.0889621675,
0.0009779846,
0.0512476675,
0.024599487,
-0.0082171261,
-0.0701823756,
-0.0185752641,
0.0383740701,
0.0144327274,
-0.0108270478,
0.0101609873,
-0.0102991844,
-0.0535890087,
0.0175731257,
-0.0137691572,
0.0184247587,
0.0217915624,
0.0111140003,
0.0513363741,
-0.038675867,
0.0123758418,
-0.0387921371,
0.015488985,
-0.0116822468,
-0.0530752838,
-0.0320706628,
-5.951266351e-33,
0.0006468567,
-0.0576993227,
-0.040886499,
-0.0099702487,
0.0456623398,
0.0411123708,
-0.0146909151,
-0.0334741808,
-0.0210707579,
-0.0212973393,
-0.0235130936,
0.0181720778,
0.0030529236,
0.0119683873,
-0.0366039313,
-0.0548429675,
0.0241081975,
-0.0270054955,
-0.0690243244,
0.0414089784,
0.0298393071,
-0.0124029536,
0.0455021486,
-0.0755115449,
0.0302230436,
-0.0193668325,
-0.0536178052,
-0.0229870267,
-0.048240684,
0.0634818375,
0.0091755362,
0.0410058573,
0.0177488141,
-0.0057263258,
0.0171057917,
0.0738244206,
-0.0084024332,
-0.0383745842,
-0.0462654382,
-0.0106300591,
-0.0461114533,
-0.0981395021,
-0.0069509312,
-0.0190904271,
-0.000566498,
0.0220516901,
0.0274686068,
-0.0067627612,
0.003738408,
-0.0068415995,
-0.0337863117,
-0.0100440271,
-0.0017446721,
-0.0467540547,
0.0071876193,
0.0532644242,
0.0450794511,
-0.0277794469,
-0.0681052059,
0.0385795981,
0.0427309088,
0.0330868587,
0.0462239012,
0.0100429198,
-0.0152222663,
0.0370255262,
0.0504376478,
0.0196381193,
-0.0095379343,
-0.0077302656,
-0.0052726539,
0.0079404162,
0.0747513175,
0.0430767573,
0.037698999,
-0.0521594845,
-0.042508278,
0.0195067581,
0.0409993343,
-0.0163946021,
0.0085356971,
-0.0236973204,
-0.0552146323,
0.0063780714,
-0.0272745453,
-0.0213627014,
-0.0061792708,
-0.0096949507,
0.0411840081,
0.0431095958,
-0.0038536189,
0.0017395971,
0.0079241609,
-0.0313749909,
0.0130593609,
0.0123359216,
-0.009553263,
-0.0319357663,
0.0163894799,
-0.0222752225,
0.0058120489,
-0.0058582826,
0.0783607885,
-0.0607441664,
0.0452336334,
0.0068679373,
0.0422512218,
0.0471315086,
-0.0426777266,
-0.0126318671,
-0.0249902215,
0.0493546389,
0.0240388308,
-0.0154684549,
0.0215941779,
-0.0238965396,
-0.02624912,
0.0443257652,
-0.0084563708,
-0.0326042138,
-0.0356857628,
-0.0024634057,
-0.0500563681,
0.0012316804,
-0.0416878127,
-0.0001220681,
0.0031120018,
0.0120963817,
0.023615744,
-0.0584442504,
0.0058853175,
-0.024317462,
2.896e-7,
-0.0230343733,
0.0016642894,
0.0353619009,
0.0233816374,
0.0200445931,
0.0663365424,
0.0148855671,
0.0516564697,
-0.0382339135,
-0.0667997375,
-0.0017098975,
-0.0123562394,
0.0520187058,
0.0078356015,
-0.0527165867,
0.028977545,
-0.0364438482,
0.0460779332,
-0.0612326413,
0.0113262041,
0.0532533266,
0.0989017263,
0.0112032788,
-0.0308675971,
0.0295777302,
-0.0228382032,
-0.0052895634,
-0.0295193288,
0.0375160463,
-0.0057234,
0.0258352105,
-0.0283871051,
0.0106220217,
0.0484996662,
-0.0592460185,
-0.0252704322,
0.0011593312,
0.0376942195,
0.0058844364,
-0.0510048643,
-0.022780085,
-0.0190633293,
0.0064712078,
-0.0181545541,
0.0949032977,
-0.0038568105,
-0.0017205239,
-0.0213517435,
-0.0008137116,
-0.0164964758,
0.020316964,
-0.0427922346,
0.0252606124,
0.0214232933,
0.0131168356,
0.0089659775,
0.0145721259,
-0.0608858205,
-0.0132305445,
-0.0231827293,
-0.0234304145,
-0.0091471272,
-0.0556088425,
0.0239049718,
0.0522841737,
-0.0429238863,
-0.0108863907,
2.735988127e-34,
-0.0219147578,
-0.0327925272,
0.0034351801,
0.0019811364,
0.0369778238,
-0.0039510867,
0.0114798583,
0.0081677148,
0.0198063757,
-0.0176566951,
-0.034831319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16264v1 | One Thousand and One Pairs: A "novel" challenge for long-context language models | 2024-06-24T02:03:57 | 2024-06-24T02:03:57 | Marzena Karpinska, Katherine Thai, Kyle Lo, Tanya Goyal, Mohit Iyyer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Synthetic long-context LLM benchmarks (e.g., "needle-in-the-haystack") test
only surface-level retrieval capabilities, but how well can long-context LLMs
retrieve, synthesize, and reason over information across book-length inputs? We
address this question by creating NoCha, a dataset of 1,001 minimally different
pairs of true and false claims about 67 recently-published English fictional
books, written by human readers of those books. In contrast to existing
long-context benchmarks, our annotators confirm that the largest share of pairs
in NoCha require global reasoning over the entire book to verify. Our
experiments show that while human readers easily perform this task, it is
enormously challenging for all ten long-context LLMs that we evaluate: no
open-weight model performs above random chance (despite their strong
performance on synthetic benchmarks), while GPT-4o achieves the highest
accuracy at 55.8%. Further analysis reveals that (1) on average, models perform
much better on pairs that require only sentence-level retrieval vs. global
reasoning; (2) model-generated explanations for their decisions are often
inaccurate even for correctly-labeled claims; and (3) models perform
substantially worse on speculative fiction books that contain extensive
world-building. The methodology proposed in NoCha allows for the evolution of
the benchmark dataset and the easy analysis of future models. | [
0.0283653922,
0.0231166184,
-0.005536824,
0.0929824188,
-0.058383882,
0.0036206567,
0.0302914195,
-0.0028151418,
0.0364532433,
-0.0478504412,
-0.012177906,
-0.0313457586,
0.0222751014,
0.0104822526,
0.0355379917,
-0.010146074,
0.017504802,
-0.0239287633,
0.0406014509,
-0.0058533559,
-0.0262437277,
0.0241440348,
0.0097919088,
0.0272006039,
0.0065392852,
-0.0479410887,
-0.0007968187,
0.0005799427,
0.0319546685,
-0.0262932144,
0.0018385637,
0.0313344486,
0.056885872,
0.0312244222,
0.0000016867,
-0.0532536209,
0.0103606302,
0.0142643759,
-0.0409038477,
0.0164161455,
0.006176691,
-0.002885448,
0.0158355255,
-0.0268057007,
-0.0124777881,
0.0142610837,
-0.0149443476,
0.0637866408,
0.0299932249,
0.0941229314,
0.0141057363,
-0.0388566926,
0.0304847136,
-0.0274668485,
0.0453142487,
-0.0626839846,
0.0296246633,
0.0209293682,
0.0227802321,
0.045187939,
-0.0222009756,
0.0247229356,
0.0403664745,
0.0200943723,
-0.0314769559,
0.036484234,
-0.0353393406,
0.0181427393,
0.0347815044,
0.0662191734,
0.0317512006,
-0.0481123812,
-0.0243998952,
0.0203816276,
-0.009013216,
0.0095856059,
-0.0285903253,
0.0623233877,
-0.056398876,
0.0092687504,
0.0599561185,
-0.01249961,
0.0503268391,
0.0012895108,
-0.0146332905,
0.0710899979,
0.0048222924,
-0.0412182622,
0.0181061961,
-0.0113559207,
-0.0683874041,
-0.0540968962,
-0.0133908978,
0.0242123641,
0.0150635224,
0.0230470542,
-0.025755411,
0.0317992494,
0.042517513,
-0.0329652838,
-0.0170628689,
0.0333269052,
-0.0503294691,
0.0834191293,
-0.0533935428,
0.035533715,
-0.0179723743,
-0.0005201554,
0.0019461183,
-0.0409541391,
-0.0188793503,
-0.0100780483,
0.0026787415,
0.0181925762,
-0.0579436868,
-0.0144959427,
-0.0313776731,
-0.0274983142,
0.0148705672,
0.0257747862,
-0.002946069,
-0.0089238919,
-0.0182109904,
-0.0373500213,
-0.0630759895,
-0.0041688583,
-0.0310255103,
0.0273808632,
-0.0193955135,
-0.0611122102,
-0.0200712103,
0.0067597991,
-0.0069985325,
-0.0313655138,
0.0169600751,
0.0525417775,
0.0149585316,
-0.0260486472,
-0.0625503883,
-0.0462774113,
-0.0286067352,
-0.0916258544,
-0.0227615107,
-0.0356807858,
0.0088347625,
0.0011924119,
-0.0010501861,
-0.0197743122,
0.00481355,
0.0424532257,
-0.0351939499,
0.0645534843,
0.0028745497,
-0.0132188201,
0.0319738127,
0.0363712236,
-0.0038445247,
0.0494046472,
0.0314529799,
0.0227167197,
0.0487463661,
0.045446381,
-0.0059300559,
-0.0014955392,
0.0292531829,
0.0234068278,
0.0041748602,
0.0243744645,
0.0040765931,
0.0204986036,
-0.000623696,
0.0499738865,
-0.0398693644,
-0.0645754784,
0.0536847413,
0.0496518984,
0.0444760434,
0.0027395445,
0.0698349923,
-0.0254658256,
0.0221114904,
0.0206595063,
-0.0509332344,
0.0217959639,
-0.0661178082,
0.0105507188,
0.0239562504,
-0.0208137631,
-0.0041932799,
-0.0273215882,
-0.0215469673,
0.0010591382,
-0.01904447,
0.0138544291,
0.046333544,
-0.0073727253,
-0.0496452041,
0.0154356994,
0.0143054649,
-0.0546588711,
-0.0167020019,
-0.019557476,
0.0835165977,
0.0419321284,
0.0462173112,
-0.0209567174,
-0.0138264522,
-0.0168725457,
0.0111151729,
0.0396542437,
0.0183970425,
-0.0020163681,
0.0313906446,
-0.0191314593,
-0.0019307343,
-0.0676253811,
0.0212548301,
0.0020793397,
0.0312938914,
0.0218886528,
0.0283679124,
-0.0871812478,
0.0120854285,
0.0357926562,
-0.0694356114,
-0.0154836429,
-0.0507766195,
0.0070912507,
-0.0107998541,
0.0079562003,
0.0133897755,
-0.0079839872,
0.0320642628,
-0.057037916,
-0.0347754955,
-0.0010883095,
-0.0180628728,
-0.0410627909,
0.0515333936,
-0.0477306657,
-0.0270937029,
-0.0042250492,
-0.0114532793,
-0.0213250834,
-0.0160710197,
0.0136577999,
0.0181071553,
-0.0406973511,
-0.0270676054,
0.0057781544,
0.0047295815,
-0.030016141,
0.1054869965,
0.0057787164,
0.0344345793,
0.0112805208,
0.0327672958,
0.026260851,
-0.0474255346,
-0.0129505247,
-0.0051795123,
0.0466835201,
-0.0251135975,
0.0290930066,
-0.0271705445,
-0.0302790515,
-0.0282154046,
-0.0857540518,
0.0238093697,
-0.0164817367,
-0.0083275195,
0.0046918821,
-0.0377447754,
-0.0117049897,
0.0172233954,
-0.0329659246,
-0.0280980114,
-0.0237864573,
0.0118849427,
0.0305576511,
0.0025433323,
0.009696777,
-0.0209269654,
0.007550233,
-0.0300396904,
0.0543157496,
0.0128967902,
0.0072328816,
-0.0670622364,
0.0238378886,
-0.0411458127,
0.0133969141,
-0.0563961789,
0.0177816004,
0.0243894104,
-0.0197816659,
0.0107734157,
0.0618058704,
0.0041797692,
-0.0076456689,
0.0432136878,
-0.0064468645,
-0.0404566489,
0.023438273,
0.0206454918,
-0.0274707843,
-0.037650317,
-0.0249118526,
-0.0199097246,
0.0369530469,
0.0036881366,
-0.0265638493,
-0.0360382609,
0.0124457031,
-0.0003484644,
-0.0199546143,
-0.0013708342,
-0.0296380967,
0.0044627679,
0.0845793709,
-0.0285646655,
-0.0235968381,
0.076987043,
-0.0527035892,
0.017246224,
-0.0142083559,
0.0045448164,
-0.0596874766,
0.0736217573,
-0.0259198453,
-0.0013890613,
0.0031925191,
0.0042877872,
-0.0192316622,
-0.0138101811,
0.0406413078,
-0.019360628,
0.0669810325,
-0.0251839608,
0.0346841142,
-0.0104645817,
-0.0328033641,
-0.041996073,
-0.038565889,
-0.0651150197,
-0.0308089275,
-0.0399742462,
-0.0033859564,
-0.0230556689,
-0.019222917,
0.0475107543,
0.0228244346,
0.0055107498,
-0.0137140462,
0.012244748,
-0.0061548259,
0.05303213,
0.0155831659,
0.0234615132,
-0.0648085847,
0.0156900901,
0.0583008192,
-0.0510775559,
0.016349718,
-0.0426180214,
-0.0116403624,
-0.0208682008,
-0.0179468617,
-0.0312366001,
0.0067749759,
0.0336811803,
-0.0976351947,
0.0225676727,
0.1145179421,
0.0016905817,
-0.0175441504,
-0.0022074322,
-0.0175457187,
-0.0090854373,
0.024412604,
-0.0128194746,
-0.1165470704,
-0.0462519415,
0.008988305,
-0.0114012836,
0.0158820171,
-0.0580870435,
-0.0321063362,
-0.094620049,
0.03937665,
0.0090853926,
-0.0133531643,
-0.0192422066,
-0.0421713479,
0.0074918331,
0.0093814377,
0.0004324891,
0.0375002511,
0.0166774038,
0.0058486755,
-0.0614111461,
0.0245673656,
0.0173664745,
0.0713497996,
-0.0158891492,
0.0146970917,
-0.0027372607,
0.0452922173,
0.0152020045,
-0.0297731627,
0.0309458654,
-0.0142791048,
0.0007619666,
0.0029098266,
0.0599007681,
-0.0272462443,
0.0195309762,
-0.0176161248,
0.0466289856,
-0.0456742868,
-0.0480562523,
0.032607425,
0.0545678772,
0.0168599058,
-0.0175430551,
-0.0339285545,
0.0399555862,
-0.0113459146,
0.1097859517,
0.0048700054,
0.0177072305,
-0.0583604127,
-0.0291999765,
-0.0306929071,
-0.0279262085,
-0.0313744247,
0.0200178977,
0.0178510547,
0.0228368528,
-0.0571036264,
-0.0453618914,
-0.004426511,
0.0353155211,
-0.0009703488,
0.0434542596,
0.0170988049,
-0.006671791,
-0.0185961295,
0.0293543525,
-0.0700528249,
0.0207228437,
-0.003481247,
0.0685284212,
0.049888365,
-0.0601831712,
0.0197205972,
0.0502887964,
-0.0589794256,
-0.0634952486,
-0.0289208665,
-0.0268901959,
0.023744436,
0.0566576608,
-0.009811745,
-0.0395249836,
0.0249685794,
0.0057989275,
-0.0399188958,
0.0585380197,
0.0164893437,
0.0517196022,
0.0128719853,
0.0426211357,
-0.037358541,
0.0134000881,
0.0086090202,
0.018805543,
-0.0350014977,
-0.0342998169,
0.0253024306,
0.0303747337,
0.0314578824,
-0.0036824576,
0.0097679496,
-0.039526552,
0.0320759751,
-0.0457847007,
-0.017216865,
0.0001446074,
0.037694063,
0.008883968,
-0.0637793913,
-0.0197371598,
-0.0136164855,
-0.0033381064,
0.0747159868,
-0.0481522195,
0.0160413049,
0.0162089206,
0.0146620683,
-0.0026872922,
-0.0151926167,
-0.0365836881,
-0.0013591673,
-0.0364477746,
0.1013853848,
0.0092298137,
0.0434487872,
0.0379066914,
0.0044891625,
-0.0094313249,
-0.0217240918,
-0.0789900646,
-0.0159535334,
0.0298593901,
0.0195522215,
0.0377238207,
0.0114525156,
0.0470005348,
-0.0211298577,
-0.0209365841,
-0.0134355696,
0.0327124745,
0.0065197246,
-0.0022556195,
0.0113851437,
0.029223593,
-0.0401841253,
0.0566244796,
0.0655330047,
0.0039143092,
0.0499754213,
0.0496821366,
-0.0240239315,
-0.0462010317,
-0.0536451526,
-0.0439097472,
0.0556963943,
0.0287321042,
0.0054497058,
-0.0777917504,
-0.0650749803,
0.0519900806,
0.0237545557,
-0.0148133412,
-0.0075192573,
-0.0164378993,
0.0651641488,
0.0045570349,
-0.0232964493,
-0.032738518,
0.0217942968,
0.0004959168,
0.001123631,
-0.0125211952,
-5.724856588e-33,
-0.0235228054,
-0.0298429877,
0.0248515885,
0.0120015237,
-0.037062943,
0.0199223161,
-0.0406522825,
-0.0055889916,
-0.0392015204,
0.0544422083,
0.0144508639,
0.0276965406,
-0.0033967285,
-0.0150466887,
-0.0338772535,
-0.0294364784,
0.01094444,
0.0462869778,
-0.0455931276,
0.0053644581,
0.0961478874,
0.0123009346,
0.0418024771,
-0.0768542141,
0.050189469,
-0.0264226533,
-0.0112684192,
0.0129575022,
-0.0590669699,
0.0585344136,
-0.0248673372,
0.0452711694,
0.031812001,
-0.03454981,
0.010096034,
0.0071784817,
-0.0871682614,
0.0001594907,
0.0573397093,
-0.0512655228,
-0.0394402221,
-0.0326021351,
0.0354768932,
0.0282603502,
0.0090867914,
-0.0407091826,
0.0448664837,
-0.0584891513,
-0.0023046727,
-0.0099459291,
-0.0691416711,
0.0349145718,
0.0027416225,
0.0154160196,
-0.0005482546,
0.0148053365,
0.0131182885,
0.0686984584,
-0.0701798946,
0.0020878778,
-0.0092992401,
0.0112851206,
0.0153396986,
-0.0320254602,
0.0066082529,
0.0609922148,
0.0104494756,
0.0070076999,
-0.0560897738,
-0.0023773487,
0.0140596423,
0.0176842418,
0.0396015011,
0.114862211,
0.0433623604,
0.0127466517,
-0.1048913524,
-0.0079049598,
0.0220787302,
0.0169670526,
0.0257940814,
0.0017051845,
-0.0397846922,
-0.0229149275,
-0.0651816949,
0.0186081342,
-0.0380303711,
0.0189887658,
0.0180275701,
0.0059833964,
-0.013315117,
-0.0148673803,
0.0204183068,
-0.0247098655,
0.0228004325,
0.0291651487,
-0.0368423052,
-0.0116834855,
0.0205791015,
0.0380474664,
-0.0373389721,
0.0209591761,
-0.0035406915,
0.0183920078,
0.0201696735,
-0.0160451103,
0.0417416021,
0.0095518557,
-0.0538642034,
-0.0110935746,
-0.0424131528,
0.0046638474,
-0.0105082877,
-0.0032313927,
0.0242553297,
0.0133129107,
-0.0031285787,
0.0476657301,
-0.0208289679,
0.0072729471,
-0.0351321697,
-0.0079659503,
0.000059822,
-0.0115549285,
-0.0169595852,
-0.0055305385,
0.0245010611,
0.0205846429,
0.03804975,
-0.0803632885,
0.0103415633,
0.0623384118,
2.388e-7,
0.0115965363,
0.0193144586,
0.0437338017,
0.0089772027,
0.0160075873,
0.0407523476,
-0.0019566726,
0.0151329599,
0.0221053436,
-0.1013730615,
-0.0419431031,
0.0511619747,
0.0437939018,
0.0494547337,
-0.0641599745,
0.0139578283,
-0.0260575693,
-0.0384244397,
-0.0549898073,
0.0026668017,
0.0455319732,
0.0384084918,
0.0384608507,
-0.0132460296,
0.0271278322,
-0.0489700548,
0.0863604173,
-0.0282796398,
-0.0402812771,
0.010648977,
0.0299985856,
0.0369896926,
0.0104684271,
0.0147389583,
0.0007106943,
0.0453068204,
0.001122351,
0.0541009046,
0.0197014436,
-0.0611227527,
-0.0253599267,
-0.0338627733,
-0.0212209597,
-0.0474105813,
0.0831721947,
-0.0137536032,
-0.0249119736,
-0.01156752,
-0.0114272945,
-0.0034732979,
-0.0052712471,
0.0211213958,
0.0037856856,
0.000569527,
-0.0004796201,
0.0034042005,
0.0130972313,
-0.0863729492,
-0.0344458595,
0.0050458219,
-0.0723260865,
-0.0336733758,
-0.0054628393,
-0.00721187,
0.0174560789,
-0.0933158472,
0.0028692102,
2.327181268e-34,
0.0455321036,
-0.025708057,
-0.0056054564,
-0.0167668276,
0.0558922142,
0.0151511729,
-0.0123671256,
-0.0176632628,
0.0264853518,
-0.0693375021,
-0.0290544238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16254v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16254v1 | Confidence Regulation Neurons in Language Models | 2024-06-24T01:31:03 | 2024-06-24T01:31:03 | Alessandro Stolfo, Ben Wu, Wes Gurnee, Yonatan Belinkov, Xingyi Song, Mrinmaya Sachan, Neel Nanda | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite their widespread use, the mechanisms by which large language models
(LLMs) represent and regulate uncertainty in next-token predictions remain
largely unexplored. This study investigates two critical components believed to
influence this uncertainty: the recently discovered entropy neurons and a new
set of components that we term token frequency neurons. Entropy neurons are
characterized by an unusually high weight norm and influence the final layer
normalization (LayerNorm) scale to effectively scale down the logits. Our work
shows that entropy neurons operate by writing onto an unembedding null space,
allowing them to impact the residual stream norm with minimal direct effect on
the logits themselves. We observe the presence of entropy neurons across a
range of models, up to 7 billion parameters. On the other hand, token frequency
neurons, which we discover and describe here for the first time, boost or
suppress each token's logit proportionally to its log frequency, thereby
shifting the output distribution towards or away from the unigram distribution.
Finally, we present a detailed case study where entropy neurons actively manage
confidence in the setting of induction, i.e. detecting and continuing repeated
subsequences. | [
0.0291753523,
0.0597626343,
-0.0122962091,
0.0086974446,
-0.028708227,
0.005369232,
-0.002042528,
-0.0102313589,
-0.0593457483,
0.0127304131,
-0.022581974,
-0.1031325236,
0.0196334552,
0.0324600562,
0.0624923259,
-0.0299008731,
0.0548776388,
-0.0261014942,
0.0188241582,
-0.0176602509,
-0.0089934068,
-0.0400183834,
0.0119187189,
0.07359308,
-0.0097184582,
0.0010171122,
0.0039283312,
0.008917748,
-0.0444275327,
-0.0329934172,
0.0052714627,
0.0758160725,
0.0295672361,
0.0731471777,
0.0000016936,
-0.036266353,
0.0401356332,
-0.029158378,
-0.0161118992,
0.0223307069,
0.0269685388,
-0.0116469366,
-0.034242291,
0.0052732457,
-0.0114896148,
-0.0341152214,
0.0807113796,
0.0363324322,
-0.0191178843,
0.0586461984,
0.0172531214,
-0.0493681915,
0.0519929044,
-0.0292923898,
0.0223585516,
-0.0071091172,
0.0336885303,
-0.0486819409,
-0.0427020267,
-0.0271332581,
-0.0407524146,
0.019565329,
0.0383649282,
-0.0103462292,
0.0239955913,
0.0398382694,
0.0229451656,
-0.05860487,
-0.0189886894,
0.0108770598,
-0.0194203667,
-0.0638241023,
-0.0262274724,
-0.0012163285,
0.0203317329,
-0.052245453,
-0.0608917102,
0.032373555,
0.0434496887,
0.0309768133,
0.0088914679,
-0.0062710075,
0.0588143766,
-0.0045564021,
-0.0187254045,
0.0488158613,
0.017202802,
-0.0289289262,
-0.0133555187,
-0.0029992238,
-0.0180102605,
-0.0586936921,
0.0133597869,
0.0240147468,
-0.0212449841,
0.0172503311,
-0.0197654888,
-0.0035317801,
0.0133189922,
-0.0197333638,
-0.0051539689,
0.0392933264,
0.0176884085,
-0.0236851275,
0.0032635287,
0.0351033211,
0.0140487086,
0.0738392547,
-0.00319236,
0.0149057871,
0.0223281067,
-0.031673003,
0.0008815408,
0.0230619665,
0.0223760847,
-0.045195505,
-0.063532047,
0.0222517475,
0.0011001503,
-0.0021888965,
-0.0089737456,
0.0315663479,
-0.0077680023,
-0.0017194689,
-0.0166134834,
0.0240268018,
-0.0267816875,
0.0406053849,
0.0329290405,
-0.0503622144,
-0.0210622344,
-0.0018016623,
-0.0120349405,
0.0063469885,
0.0166084133,
0.0448925793,
0.0055271978,
-0.038748417,
-0.0391056649,
0.0150653971,
-0.0151248695,
-0.0338201374,
0.0032057567,
-0.0595875829,
-0.0501086973,
0.0250928085,
-0.0074173864,
-0.0336105339,
0.0179674141,
0.001769751,
-0.036457438,
0.0508452468,
-0.0321957357,
0.0012800747,
0.0064478437,
0.0044721928,
-0.0027140575,
0.0488651432,
0.0562993921,
0.046283748,
0.037096262,
0.011493478,
-0.0020318148,
0.011726331,
0.0289086178,
-0.0291405097,
-0.0900947228,
-0.0615167283,
-0.0312542133,
0.047686018,
0.0603973158,
0.068734549,
-0.0429705791,
-0.0344478451,
0.0813456401,
0.0755789727,
0.0001625297,
0.0201909374,
0.0353099704,
-0.0598213151,
0.0184257906,
0.072327517,
-0.0748412609,
0.0347849578,
0.0232976973,
0.0199507736,
0.0724503025,
0.0222140122,
-0.0178984739,
-0.0576128364,
-0.0213627703,
0.0126952277,
-0.0369566344,
-0.0478922911,
0.0081834327,
0.0114402929,
-0.012736937,
0.0197671,
-0.0004589622,
-0.0128726969,
0.0258778222,
-0.0374906287,
0.0420280509,
0.0475883074,
0.0159600135,
-0.0002849459,
0.0043604514,
0.0046163248,
-0.0057343123,
0.0580441058,
0.0300063398,
0.0223345831,
0.0132728545,
-0.0473676808,
-0.0032396074,
0.0266494602,
0.0280200001,
0.025081858,
-0.0155254444,
-0.0054529202,
-0.0017377174,
-0.026422821,
-0.0284598675,
0.03700931,
-0.0007684225,
-0.0202312544,
0.0240625516,
-0.0240259133,
0.0139350863,
-0.0098080421,
-0.0281446166,
0.0583812147,
0.0377306379,
-0.0328221023,
-0.0440133177,
0.0300391298,
-0.0820624754,
0.0055609639,
0.0645036623,
0.0330936722,
0.0488040149,
-0.0115962951,
0.010424966,
-0.0532786027,
0.0606689751,
-0.0207349323,
0.1050088555,
-0.0603238754,
-0.0071811979,
-0.0087060472,
0.057785809,
-0.0220177993,
0.0167208109,
-0.0134370765,
0.03817733,
0.007832,
0.0056154495,
-0.0117796594,
0.0124901123,
-0.0019263754,
0.0217608381,
-0.0403072052,
0.0158766117,
0.0287444908,
-0.0408467278,
-0.0121344561,
0.003857271,
-0.0332687125,
-0.0170442555,
0.002526829,
0.0114445593,
-0.0038935272,
0.0004032878,
-0.005306052,
-0.0106584392,
-0.0342428461,
0.0218329802,
0.01646295,
0.0278582443,
0.0439966172,
-0.0111014824,
-0.0252067875,
-0.0576878153,
-0.0447745174,
-0.0313478187,
0.0699486881,
-0.0037345232,
0.0092712026,
-0.0541048907,
0.0423265994,
-0.013669366,
0.0265071392,
0.0126514509,
-0.0635289401,
0.0233066361,
-0.0215211585,
0.0230546594,
0.0194180589,
0.0334101766,
0.0037505687,
0.0662577078,
-0.0052176025,
-0.0211758148,
-0.0256743487,
-0.0524779595,
0.0287579149,
-0.0286818165,
0.0137036704,
-0.0260637514,
0.0983913839,
0.0324538499,
-0.0228821486,
-0.0441074744,
-0.0007842398,
-0.0037241839,
-0.0188057367,
0.0021328221,
-0.0158948805,
-0.0554865785,
0.0637923852,
-0.0009760797,
-0.0565518476,
0.0728457943,
-0.027790105,
-0.0016710558,
0.0079760496,
0.0095923729,
0.000248821,
0.0386756994,
0.0692258328,
-0.0015540685,
0.051944077,
-0.0350605473,
-0.0358247533,
-0.0147855086,
-0.0093699684,
-0.0000011478,
-0.0047847056,
-0.0098761469,
-0.0404612683,
0.0119230077,
-0.0280410219,
-0.0428504869,
-0.0325213373,
-0.020884471,
0.017420942,
0.0531501211,
-0.0483609252,
-0.0184824709,
-0.0336981304,
0.0233375449,
0.0470740199,
-0.0705524534,
-0.0141976913,
-0.0248909928,
0.0329919606,
0.041349519,
0.0156436414,
0.115791291,
-0.0363276117,
0.0227394085,
0.0474895425,
0.0333917551,
0.0420554876,
-0.0509222746,
-0.0009601444,
0.0367430598,
-0.0034312534,
-0.0074101314,
0.0367308073,
0.0575109124,
-0.0186179932,
-0.0016880912,
0.1395692527,
0.002051957,
-0.0602887943,
0.0259346869,
-0.0188100785,
0.0901804715,
0.0313951187,
0.0027057191,
-0.0635936409,
-0.0262582358,
0.0246487502,
0.0050297352,
-0.0165182482,
-0.0199921951,
-0.0073251068,
-0.065356046,
0.0159104634,
0.0344763994,
-0.0553607866,
-0.0151505861,
-0.049699191,
-0.0057464736,
-0.0011950688,
0.0595407039,
0.0203846525,
0.0009057351,
0.0121416217,
0.0456957482,
-0.020124197,
-0.0441493914,
-0.0013213553,
-0.0628907308,
0.1037291288,
0.0413740762,
-0.0027553895,
-0.0288042035,
-0.0323282741,
0.0480531603,
-0.030033201,
-0.007593554,
0.0009536665,
0.0379621014,
0.0256180614,
-0.0091602961,
-0.0162834469,
0.01259821,
-0.0368309282,
-0.0151961036,
-0.0624253042,
0.0326901935,
-0.0017903897,
-0.0676695704,
-0.0135609368,
0.0245438889,
-0.0145964138,
0.070508346,
0.0554376207,
-0.0302923582,
-0.0419459641,
-0.0623893738,
0.0306305364,
-0.0421217866,
0.0050253132,
-0.0115699228,
0.0386674143,
-0.0792159289,
-0.0508266874,
-0.0138271898,
-0.0214873385,
0.0055251499,
0.0027482354,
-0.0114038996,
0.009600509,
-0.0449101292,
-0.0321561322,
-0.0397109911,
0.0144642545,
0.0173842683,
-0.0867645517,
0.0439321287,
-0.0019570787,
-0.0060163834,
-0.0203715377,
0.0293681901,
-0.0959204733,
-0.1016941741,
0.007540735,
0.018419316,
0.0220273249,
0.0039453614,
0.0033234109,
-0.0741526186,
0.063412413,
0.0498504862,
-0.042911768,
0.0122933919,
0.0210602563,
-0.0199822132,
0.0017131157,
0.0508673601,
0.0215335339,
-0.0012727628,
0.0219566505,
0.048265554,
0.0134076886,
-0.0349925011,
0.018086737,
-0.0148064326,
0.0525067188,
-0.0103545217,
-0.0042999238,
-0.0169613156,
0.0191886015,
0.0019643945,
0.0161952861,
-0.0105233816,
-0.0007382758,
0.0464942269,
0.0096610254,
-0.0475369208,
-0.033314392,
0.0200169068,
0.0226190612,
0.0166347865,
-0.0304321665,
-0.0297693685,
0.0285249297,
-0.0000246592,
-0.0249405187,
-0.0139321815,
0.0275506228,
-0.0135062747,
0.0305536594,
-0.0004248753,
-0.006906067,
0.0228175595,
-0.0007962959,
-0.0287123676,
-0.0019111702,
-0.1231853142,
-0.0084265051,
-0.0113111213,
0.0045925798,
0.0438426621,
0.0284509268,
0.0368399359,
-0.0345248431,
0.0134603512,
-0.0145494509,
-0.0022117067,
-0.0189240966,
-0.0035668174,
0.0360741168,
0.0050069066,
-0.0342895761,
-0.0081190411,
0.0561994277,
0.0367713682,
0.0519381277,
-0.0065503772,
-0.0225184709,
0.0078387549,
-0.0216524433,
0.0094752312,
0.05444948,
-0.0355558097,
-0.0098065902,
-0.0420139879,
-0.0735393018,
0.0069034747,
0.0406075269,
0.0180770624,
-0.0316901058,
-0.0183812249,
0.044396434,
0.0030248882,
-0.0304271337,
-0.0058521978,
-0.0025609471,
0.0346971974,
-0.0039263857,
-0.0178827029,
-6.330170057e-33,
-0.0135138193,
-0.010492187,
0.0079140449,
0.0321216434,
0.0071052262,
-0.0143126883,
-0.031951651,
0.0227255505,
-0.0050381315,
0.0402987674,
-0.0444166586,
0.0179872289,
0.0184678808,
0.020868266,
0.0428298339,
-0.0037474688,
0.0429388992,
-0.0423701815,
0.0077633648,
0.0117212636,
0.0388352945,
0.0290564205,
0.0758943111,
-0.0019887236,
0.0211464744,
0.0475524403,
-0.0290992279,
0.0281974673,
-0.0129400315,
0.0177208763,
-0.0441140831,
0.0247576013,
0.0058514015,
-0.0573268011,
-0.0414546542,
-0.0203792937,
-0.0468695164,
-0.0679064021,
0.0195176844,
0.0155284768,
-0.0194420144,
-0.0263425056,
0.0644376129,
-0.0502326936,
-0.0447065644,
0.0217294246,
-0.0036706042,
-0.018516684,
-0.0448993333,
-0.0416552275,
-0.0541266575,
0.0118938601,
0.007049053,
-0.0047579692,
-0.0166692026,
-0.0336685516,
-0.0321426019,
-0.0567095801,
-0.0652960688,
0.0405987576,
0.0108456211,
0.0749579221,
0.0070939632,
0.0249883588,
-0.0034099605,
0.0377656482,
0.0814145729,
-0.0248813909,
-0.0490309708,
0.0019109732,
0.0611324422,
-0.0147939622,
0.0349455774,
-0.0031905235,
0.0854563788,
-0.0389205627,
-0.0210844949,
-0.0094077019,
0.0445565172,
0.0468825735,
0.0381786898,
0.0155229066,
0.0066812099,
-0.0416666865,
-0.024212148,
-0.0789132565,
-0.0239872001,
-0.0244411174,
-0.010794377,
0.0107825259,
0.0524785891,
-0.0195396692,
-0.0031367824,
-0.0375518762,
-0.0408851728,
0.0524915606,
0.0030486367,
-0.0047098547,
0.0305019617,
0.001635161,
-0.0523392074,
0.006307641,
0.0103236353,
0.0403050631,
-0.01824148,
0.0312563032,
0.0282409135,
0.0380709432,
-0.0519810803,
-0.0071713836,
-0.0460914597,
-0.0122419382,
0.0383731835,
-0.0072869132,
0.0430914648,
-0.0240074564,
-0.002906811,
-0.0165077001,
-0.0167517029,
0.015516297,
-0.0263923444,
0.0648814887,
0.0112206917,
0.0590822585,
-0.0440634899,
-0.0433325991,
-0.0770097002,
0.0004164265,
0.0405547433,
-0.0474053994,
-0.0207822211,
-0.0079244319,
2.581e-7,
0.001715434,
0.0371180587,
0.0265590865,
0.0057076686,
0.052890189,
0.0240411516,
-0.0157684181,
0.0246341284,
-0.0037655842,
-0.0373911634,
0.005564508,
-0.011955536,
0.0304917824,
0.0209940579,
-0.051246725,
-0.043506097,
-0.0693502128,
0.0277565476,
-0.0103269126,
0.009227152,
0.0064123552,
0.1259042323,
0.0144758299,
-0.0475624129,
0.03875212,
-0.0561858341,
0.03527309,
0.0021907121,
0.0486224033,
0.0032684749,
0.0503558703,
-0.0292164907,
0.0101885851,
-0.0034928948,
-0.0058306563,
0.0259179212,
-0.060205441,
0.031195689,
0.0025721455,
-0.0161599908,
-0.0001215895,
-0.0106628686,
-0.0023244207,
-0.0731931552,
0.0243382417,
-0.0043006274,
-0.0259111878,
-0.0434452184,
0.0573218875,
-0.0202996992,
0.0412846804,
-0.0327165313,
-0.0331235342,
-0.0012128453,
0.0210091788,
0.0163728129,
-0.0315590389,
-0.0632916763,
-0.0483768433,
-0.0265453383,
-0.0388082676,
-0.0099229375,
-0.0703811273,
-0.0152045768,
0.0179346371,
-0.0558493584,
-0.0054418151,
2.634716763e-34,
0.0543363802,
-0.0430568643,
0.0183857083,
-0.0007119953,
0.0290488824,
-0.0080985529,
0.0368680544,
0.0273203272,
0.020752484,
-0.0698991418,
-0.0358058587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16253v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16253v2 | LLMs Assist NLP Researchers: Critique Paper (Meta-)Reviewing | 2024-06-24T01:30:22 | 2024-06-25T18:04:38 | Jiangshu Du, Yibo Wang, Wenting Zhao, Zhongfen Deng, Shuaiqi Liu, Renze Lou, Henry Peng Zou, Pranav Narayanan Venkit, Nan Zhang, Mukund Srinath, Haoran Ranran Zhang, Vipul Gupta, Yinghui Li, Tao Li, Fei Wang, Qin Liu, Tianlin Liu, Pengzhi Gao, Congying Xia, Chen Xing, Jiayang Cheng, Zhaowei Wang, Ying Su, Raj Sanjay Shah, Ruohao Guo, Jing Gu, Haoran Li, Kangda Wei, Zihao Wang, Lu Cheng, Surangika Ranathunga, Meng Fang, Jie Fu, Fei Liu, Ruihong Huang, Eduardo Blanco, Yixin Cao, Rui Zhang, Philip S. Yu, Wenpeng Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL | This work is motivated by two key trends. On one hand, large language models
(LLMs) have shown remarkable versatility in various generative tasks such as
writing, drawing, and question answering, significantly reducing the time
required for many routine tasks. On the other hand, researchers, whose work is
not only time-consuming but also highly expertise-demanding, face increasing
challenges as they have to spend more time reading, writing, and reviewing
papers. This raises the question: how can LLMs potentially assist researchers
in alleviating their heavy workload?
This study focuses on the topic of LLMs assist NLP Researchers, particularly
examining the effectiveness of LLM in assisting paper (meta-)reviewing and its
recognizability. To address this, we constructed the ReviewCritique dataset,
which includes two types of information: (i) NLP papers (initial submissions
rather than camera-ready) with both human-written and LLM-generated reviews,
and (ii) each review comes with "deficiency" labels and corresponding
explanations for individual segments, annotated by experts. Using
ReviewCritique, this study explores two threads of research questions: (i)
"LLMs as Reviewers", how do reviews generated by LLMs compare with those
written by humans in terms of quality and distinguishability? (ii) "LLMs as
Metareviewers", how effectively can LLMs identify potential issues, such as
Deficient or unprofessional review segments, within individual paper reviews?
To our knowledge, this is the first work to provide such a comprehensive
analysis. | [
0.095831342,
0.0195994023,
-0.0244492237,
-0.0013794948,
-0.0342830047,
0.0119815022,
0.0313809104,
-0.0276150294,
-0.0563760735,
-0.083948344,
-0.0658785552,
-0.0063367183,
-0.0106082512,
-0.0003333388,
0.0212682132,
-0.0304313768,
-0.0085750818,
-0.0158689246,
0.0437500067,
0.0119406283,
0.0230198707,
0.023635745,
0.0036591815,
0.0699446574,
0.0519446842,
-0.0259552747,
0.0119290901,
-0.0061239009,
-0.0034967782,
-0.0203540735,
0.0014397877,
0.1006295308,
-0.0031730346,
0.0719481334,
0.0000019947,
-0.0219128132,
0.0195798464,
0.0044012708,
0.0140300905,
0.0027387317,
0.0765992552,
-0.0306114797,
-0.0102507127,
0.0005017569,
0.0063147568,
-0.0558161922,
0.0205658376,
0.0499041565,
0.0366973467,
0.0449104831,
0.0026817108,
-0.0001193834,
0.0019617302,
0.0185988825,
-0.0005498725,
0.0230304729,
0.0119366907,
0.0132615175,
0.0077976077,
0.0396470986,
0.0358536467,
0.021984892,
0.0085533224,
-0.087881662,
0.0198033266,
-0.0041874046,
-0.0211317036,
-0.0070754723,
0.0079294089,
0.0372152813,
0.0443084389,
-0.0312464666,
0.0005943548,
0.0044708233,
-0.0003916184,
0.1005163714,
-0.0510231853,
0.0256587192,
0.0099034235,
-0.0196056049,
-0.0240178835,
-0.0150033198,
0.0326864533,
0.0228719581,
0.0666139722,
0.0359724127,
0.0046971091,
-0.0293966439,
0.0063251988,
0.0622420013,
0.0205012765,
-0.0573587641,
-0.0183537621,
0.0313864276,
-0.0015589347,
0.005443559,
0.0190232899,
-0.043146532,
0.0389988832,
-0.0238091592,
0.1015119851,
-0.0270406362,
0.0036004044,
0.0391337611,
0.0178761669,
-0.014753893,
0.0033842546,
0.0193188917,
-0.0225419905,
0.0301358141,
-0.0574509725,
-0.0383295156,
0.0027548885,
-0.0011036686,
0.0053798584,
0.0070959083,
-0.0247894488,
-0.0085041169,
-0.0239856821,
-0.0207714718,
0.0129975742,
0.0200461894,
0.0117470669,
0.0008634237,
-0.0701230466,
0.0374469981,
-0.006880803,
0.0435882807,
-0.0237963405,
-0.0019565315,
0.0277584009,
0.0295732208,
0.0007821162,
-0.0389381833,
0.0065266467,
0.0257418025,
0.0391229168,
-0.0276604816,
-0.0120981662,
-0.0062500178,
-0.0142587395,
-0.0640009269,
0.0066686906,
-0.0678470582,
-0.0023366713,
0.0143056177,
-0.0044781221,
-0.021251794,
-0.018108109,
-0.0042970832,
-0.0065273205,
0.0564748496,
-0.0715438128,
0.0404218137,
0.0079881074,
0.0083065974,
-0.0234339852,
0.0424636453,
0.0215985365,
-0.029395679,
0.0265200604,
-0.0381727219,
0.0651037991,
-0.0024845169,
-0.0432264768,
0.0089950599,
-0.0166635755,
-0.0179177336,
-0.0246588066,
0.0107946349,
0.0491026118,
0.0475271977,
-0.0344402045,
0.0308308993,
0.0892367885,
0.0794182345,
0.004496343,
0.0381952897,
0.0352760553,
-0.0093423445,
0.0293439068,
0.0243888982,
-0.0112749999,
0.037830662,
0.014281312,
-0.0121462876,
-0.0177302938,
0.0079517812,
-0.0167380255,
-0.045794148,
-0.0269157849,
0.0152487438,
-0.0286905002,
0.0041380129,
0.0322022028,
0.0190487094,
0.001609818,
-0.0060802149,
-0.0025244679,
-0.0312776864,
0.0200135056,
-0.0249248408,
0.0179512929,
0.0757202581,
0.0489781946,
0.0008013684,
-0.0085051926,
-0.0463879928,
-0.0037101654,
0.0554634817,
0.0316514522,
-0.0142406924,
-0.0501550175,
-0.0003486363,
-0.020536406,
-0.0355225876,
0.0269936547,
-0.0104510617,
0.0014011419,
-0.0048756688,
0.0017295248,
-0.0479321405,
-0.1098819897,
0.0230335481,
-0.0278732311,
-0.0127631193,
-0.022836186,
-0.0070327842,
0.0157892946,
0.0430766456,
-0.0178330969,
0.0456216037,
0.0184473768,
-0.0256439541,
-0.0000587411,
0.0294149481,
0.0602498539,
0.0231202245,
0.0180487931,
-0.0718510449,
-0.0157479029,
0.0126890829,
0.0139937652,
-0.0577374175,
0.0047555086,
-0.0070860223,
0.0351119377,
-0.00478866,
0.0120231099,
-0.0200614277,
-0.0428664833,
-0.0290639307,
0.0150856534,
0.0024321552,
0.0659962893,
-0.0017763316,
-0.0451914184,
-0.0249458496,
0.0013270838,
-0.0437563211,
0.0217359308,
0.0363765471,
0.0253474563,
0.0283958092,
0.0009182625,
-0.035522446,
-0.0643283576,
-0.07721214,
-0.0137800211,
-0.0013140008,
0.0298055261,
0.0527867973,
-0.0657035708,
0.0078692567,
0.0334081724,
-0.0273080971,
-0.0358638354,
0.0312869996,
-0.0017312055,
0.0457136966,
0.0094894925,
0.0150095718,
-0.058014784,
-0.0142602893,
-0.017553471,
0.0369055904,
0.0565862805,
-0.0216302648,
-0.0543844923,
0.0598465689,
-0.019274082,
-0.0409617014,
-0.0063055027,
-0.015400378,
0.0218961295,
0.0222994983,
0.0012460073,
0.0150932539,
-0.000086719,
0.0087234499,
0.0866377652,
-0.0018912631,
-0.0326682739,
-0.0293389075,
0.0217310339,
0.0095413914,
-0.0103187403,
-0.076990284,
0.0609878972,
0.0570226535,
-0.0210200064,
-0.0111836847,
-0.011790568,
0.0522500612,
-0.0344379283,
-0.0260442551,
0.0156174721,
-0.0486390777,
-0.0063765151,
0.0486171097,
-0.0176228527,
-0.0166034754,
0.0282069054,
-0.0374946967,
0.0162227098,
-0.0403863266,
-0.002606038,
-0.0454125591,
0.0499201715,
-0.0155799109,
0.004802254,
-0.0112923179,
0.0031876359,
-0.0101204067,
-0.0139197987,
0.0324797854,
-0.0127281342,
0.0460063629,
-0.0452995189,
0.0237661954,
-0.0144962948,
-0.0016149534,
0.0156307537,
-0.0102691045,
-0.0568959229,
0.0032255754,
0.0462302379,
-0.014736075,
-0.0482872725,
0.039089445,
0.0223104116,
0.0248593483,
-0.0298629515,
-0.0127091277,
-0.0153906904,
0.0156013872,
0.0504659787,
-0.007221261,
0.0373956785,
-0.0428752974,
0.0371100903,
0.0328380391,
-0.0056075961,
0.0229938552,
-0.0220232885,
-0.0464094058,
0.0346389599,
-0.0405017287,
-0.0425260402,
-0.020750396,
0.052105654,
-0.0677376911,
0.0040764431,
0.1059846804,
0.0145023149,
-0.120664157,
-0.0387729555,
-0.0251445789,
-0.0292055737,
0.0327636339,
0.0164398383,
-0.0151545228,
0.0209296625,
0.0183203313,
0.0250238981,
-0.0425593406,
-0.0221102741,
-0.0107506532,
-0.0868736953,
0.0393520407,
-0.015408841,
-0.0347782709,
-0.0140796108,
-0.0334687009,
0.0056395861,
0.0227305703,
0.0070837266,
0.0199530981,
-0.0443302467,
0.0283706449,
0.0387356728,
-0.0531901941,
-0.05805365,
0.0199481044,
-0.0442562103,
0.0767829195,
0.0328123644,
0.0133087439,
-0.0169511382,
0.0106592616,
0.0697313324,
-0.0083126063,
-0.0039519235,
-0.0001147424,
0.0600331947,
-0.0232747383,
0.0220562685,
-0.0498463921,
0.009104196,
-0.0591348708,
0.0046906248,
0.0283021834,
0.0472370461,
-0.0216320008,
-0.0347321965,
-0.0376133062,
0.0214944948,
-0.0295297597,
0.0812350735,
0.0489504002,
-0.0616300963,
-0.0332696512,
0.0103422189,
0.0124423234,
-0.0272633508,
-0.0653903261,
0.0250410046,
-0.0070322528,
-0.0270704441,
-0.0436905213,
-0.0665360838,
0.02573983,
0.0311353095,
0.0669889227,
0.0310156997,
-0.0059091086,
-0.0242954232,
-0.0031007098,
0.0472067185,
-0.004453314,
-0.0054259417,
-0.0533460602,
-0.0359900855,
0.0465953536,
-0.0006336237,
0.02677764,
-0.0469934307,
-0.0484807082,
-0.0365857743,
-0.0234306902,
0.038431894,
0.0311944894,
-0.0079267994,
0.016160069,
-0.0898155198,
-0.0328093953,
0.0097545804,
-0.0096968105,
-0.0153417718,
-0.0126017686,
0.022212211,
-0.0083066234,
-0.0087345466,
-0.040140368,
0.03169531,
0.032168936,
0.0074768341,
-0.0294111595,
-0.0428771153,
0.0223866571,
-0.0020719355,
0.0036602109,
-0.0022384461,
0.056394089,
-0.0591389798,
-0.0329951271,
-0.0363566205,
-0.0262002647,
-0.0568980388,
0.0089125624,
0.013171671,
-0.0042220368,
-0.0220258776,
0.0405793078,
-0.0463113524,
0.04515763,
-0.0559912361,
0.0870442912,
0.0247197244,
-0.0022146658,
-0.0213983171,
-0.0135014961,
-0.036026746,
-0.0003136271,
-0.0352049507,
0.0114902416,
0.0432004444,
0.0368141048,
0.0154796671,
0.0070747593,
0.0081347916,
0.0219993964,
-0.0863115042,
-0.0525747985,
-0.0185818803,
0.0021300321,
0.0302819051,
-0.0025259126,
0.0720529109,
-0.020101523,
-0.0056678178,
-0.0289069079,
0.0464692712,
0.0312260855,
0.0297411531,
0.0536225885,
0.0262286793,
-0.0165485349,
-0.0530238114,
0.0680950806,
0.0069832718,
0.007637972,
-0.0067619164,
-0.05128121,
-0.0076540536,
-0.0385866575,
-0.0310400426,
-0.0183445495,
-0.0079481043,
-0.0084582195,
-0.0917008892,
-0.0392649882,
0.0087080467,
-0.0009819274,
0.0149742533,
-0.0636197999,
-0.0305227749,
0.0596198104,
0.0340218805,
-0.0121398317,
-0.082260482,
0.0274636671,
0.0049537392,
0.0024028146,
-0.0032329126,
-5.883838893e-33,
-0.0124937017,
-0.0976835117,
0.0010570784,
-0.0275631286,
-0.0122161349,
0.0286000147,
-0.0348253101,
0.0206171349,
0.0152847571,
0.0263515431,
-0.0334696099,
0.0130439587,
-0.0040827049,
-0.0171858054,
0.0510071367,
0.013310547,
0.0776689351,
-0.0023711266,
-0.0123151988,
0.0042150272,
-0.0145218987,
-0.0104091456,
0.0338788368,
-0.0388136916,
0.0947071686,
-0.0194533858,
-0.0014503377,
-0.0078788493,
0.0257292949,
0.0608312897,
-0.0190921295,
0.0310400072,
0.0556400456,
-0.0108187944,
-0.002628888,
0.0158141665,
-0.0695968568,
0.0085158944,
0.0521919914,
0.0137092918,
-0.0092314482,
-0.0415060483,
0.0793108121,
-0.0151753295,
-0.0574271642,
0.0279809162,
0.0805452317,
-0.0438835695,
-0.0322371833,
-0.0399139412,
-0.0382088535,
0.0263972171,
-0.0160520207,
0.0205234159,
0.0155801503,
0.0525924414,
-0.0269525293,
0.0209484547,
-0.0719703734,
0.0191455912,
0.007833505,
0.0248039961,
0.0122654233,
0.0179173164,
0.0165298712,
0.057343442,
-0.0027945552,
0.0647455975,
-0.0165264178,
-0.0193792265,
0.0252495557,
0.0074977046,
0.0106393602,
0.066153422,
0.044349134,
-0.0348100029,
-0.0077172462,
0.0184683353,
0.0103480536,
0.0300220493,
0.0859712735,
-0.0459734984,
-0.0102187125,
-0.0381122939,
-0.041052036,
-0.0696665794,
-0.0182484183,
-0.0310336724,
0.0192197412,
0.0074203047,
-0.0156523287,
-0.0753070936,
0.0093387403,
-0.0365809798,
-0.0215238314,
-0.0240210164,
-0.0367222168,
0.0721781403,
-0.0024944381,
-0.0264637433,
-0.0377802141,
0.00182915,
-0.0282612275,
0.0391365699,
0.0233613905,
-0.0066852765,
0.0544033572,
-0.0124882804,
-0.0703559965,
-0.0147577496,
-0.0278336797,
0.0280993097,
0.0233941004,
0.0169413369,
0.0252052527,
-0.0248981882,
0.0117246816,
0.0229378156,
0.0014996183,
0.0132434694,
-0.0090086497,
0.0454304032,
-0.0286474917,
-0.0027489814,
-0.0244251061,
-0.0026257907,
-0.0021410692,
0.0122044636,
0.0467130952,
-0.0248969551,
-0.0094794044,
-0.0539686494,
2.731e-7,
0.0730595589,
0.0472862571,
-0.0359114073,
-0.0352465697,
0.0651053637,
0.0064690853,
-0.0275688842,
-0.0142059168,
0.0250642188,
-0.0081086643,
0.0218822975,
-0.0008622154,
0.0370563604,
0.0330149941,
-0.0783021227,
0.0266462229,
-0.0781279057,
0.0084517477,
-0.0410283953,
0.0145792412,
0.002024058,
0.0160476118,
-0.0168827251,
-0.0047113886,
-0.0519881062,
-0.0486749038,
0.0681626871,
-0.0601262189,
-0.009068029,
0.0336846374,
0.100521557,
-0.0204149932,
0.0052280775,
0.0044264509,
-0.0032037373,
0.0137040764,
0.0066524367,
0.0514224805,
-0.0015618724,
0.0019976951,
0.0363544226,
-0.0220212769,
0.038589403,
-0.0368495844,
0.0555282272,
-0.018038746,
-0.0543293245,
-0.1019327044,
-0.028005708,
-0.0523190945,
0.036817912,
-0.0182308704,
-0.0235921778,
0.0593486838,
-0.0230886582,
-0.0473763682,
0.0002306315,
-0.0409413055,
-0.013183495,
0.031907808,
-0.0081377504,
-0.0600292198,
-0.0048129437,
-0.0502594449,
-0.0060326648,
-0.0530054942,
0.0122423954,
2.33749095e-34,
0.0731489658,
0.0042321477,
0.0072484459,
0.036309354,
0.0328981206,
0.048828017,
-0.0530308411,
-0.0179326031,
0.0099352719,
-0.0493470691,
-0.0162633918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16985v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16985v1 | Unveiling LLM Mechanisms Through Neural ODEs and Control Theory | 2024-06-23T22:56:34 | 2024-06-23T22:56:34 | Yukun Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | This study presents a novel approach that leverages Neural Ordinary
Differential Equations (Neural ODEs) to unravel the intricate relationships
between inputs and outputs in Large Language Models (LLMs), and employs robust
control to fine-tune outputs to meet predefined standards. Central to our
methodology is the transformation of LLM inputs and outputs into a
lower-dimensional latent space, facilitating a detailed examination of the
information processing pathways within LLMs. Neural ODEs play a pivotal role in
this investigation by providing a dynamic model that captures the continuous
evolution of data within the LLMs. Additionally, robust control mechanisms are
applied to strategically adjust the model's outputs, ensuring they not only
maintain high quality and reliability but also adhere to specific performance
criteria. This fusion of Neural ODEs and robust control represents a
significant advancement in LLM interpretability, offering a comprehensive
framework that elucidates the previously opaque mechanisms of these complex
models. Our empirical results validate the effectiveness of this integrated
approach, making a substantial contribution to the field of explainable AI by
merging advanced machine learning techniques with the critical need for
transparency and control in AI outputs. | [
0.0248402823,
0.0664278567,
-0.0477632806,
0.0525486805,
0.0127118127,
0.0022979905,
-0.0047839507,
-0.0117846718,
-0.0217950996,
0.0110374913,
-0.0254113078,
-0.0361132771,
0.0039178026,
0.0618509687,
0.0628654584,
-0.0264232121,
0.0384551026,
-0.0622837953,
-0.0292770211,
-0.0016819173,
-0.0028032414,
-0.0159898903,
0.0125521235,
0.0451092385,
0.0083310707,
-0.0028258828,
-0.0223590899,
-0.0057375305,
-0.0316523761,
0.0345199965,
-0.0071068686,
-0.0015605486,
0.0593601838,
0.0681493878,
0.0000020358,
-0.0423400253,
0.0286651123,
-0.0124024525,
-0.0650208145,
0.0187510308,
0.0166457966,
-0.0152696948,
-0.0008417053,
-0.0295134485,
-0.0148964822,
0.0393581763,
0.0462287515,
-0.0063704685,
0.0680154115,
0.0765291452,
0.0175848398,
-0.0321421213,
0.0500607044,
-0.0222689752,
-0.0133414408,
-0.0210916847,
0.0241901204,
-0.0118892528,
0.0190407485,
-0.0139865009,
-0.0553800352,
0.0138008725,
0.0419924743,
-0.0536064729,
0.0056993016,
0.0180875584,
0.0335826315,
-0.032007914,
-0.0121380743,
0.0582761504,
-0.0547151119,
-0.0365516245,
0.0016101262,
-0.0307836179,
-0.011290187,
-0.0048068441,
-0.0617620088,
-0.0134092048,
0.0319653302,
0.0407385379,
0.0090685934,
-0.0308180265,
0.0716213211,
0.0189056061,
-0.0320126079,
0.0664187521,
-0.0028415769,
-0.0272208974,
-0.0374976136,
0.0000425963,
0.0025567438,
-0.0328024849,
0.0307395514,
0.0741254538,
-0.0145184677,
0.0250689518,
0.0024251568,
-0.0444076583,
-0.0125678787,
-0.0714602023,
0.0401721746,
0.0248856302,
0.0075014578,
0.0159131419,
-0.0099590914,
0.1153911501,
-0.0615019538,
0.0230287984,
0.0158668365,
0.0238341298,
-0.0488467589,
-0.0415581018,
0.0280137043,
0.0246051382,
-0.0049929922,
-0.0119042397,
-0.0048631593,
0.050446853,
-0.0328791551,
-0.0063937251,
0.0078122546,
0.0144222407,
-0.0053912252,
-0.0181488506,
-0.0362003967,
0.0110385809,
-0.0288388804,
0.0197212473,
0.0014750381,
-0.0243328586,
-0.0081044501,
0.0203437414,
-0.0123618655,
-0.0051879096,
-0.0274320003,
0.0889850035,
0.0170999076,
0.0315541774,
-0.0377332978,
-0.0336747207,
-0.0230620373,
-0.0311992485,
0.0426752232,
-0.0278670043,
0.0143096987,
-0.00381546,
-0.0120100332,
-0.0970610082,
-0.0127144679,
-0.0203392245,
-0.0606326014,
0.0514582545,
-0.0113721844,
0.0178466067,
0.0409357026,
0.0114687132,
0.0088741574,
0.0313773043,
0.068316631,
0.0207389761,
0.0186399445,
-0.0122364648,
0.0717551857,
0.0472669303,
0.0365667753,
0.0141214887,
-0.0636782721,
-0.0401790701,
-0.0530996844,
0.0485675298,
0.0734821409,
0.042745322,
-0.0127834827,
-0.0152292699,
0.0802328214,
0.0243248567,
0.0218307786,
0.0443214588,
0.0596975796,
-0.0152059449,
-0.0024958593,
0.0393140689,
-0.0645824447,
0.0565305352,
0.0487511046,
0.0077421637,
0.0000808717,
0.0042960425,
-0.0126089379,
-0.0541819744,
0.0021876004,
0.0147057883,
0.0008033122,
0.0021404827,
0.0423780307,
-0.0261731297,
-0.0294064917,
0.0432428531,
0.0045630974,
0.0006693013,
0.0468159281,
-0.0862054676,
0.0458335765,
0.0803449228,
0.0288630333,
-0.0142181627,
-0.0307811536,
-0.0124221798,
-0.0054493733,
0.073894389,
-0.0146648549,
-0.0032640479,
0.0034501429,
-0.0402202643,
-0.0189308599,
-0.0290713124,
0.0327035114,
0.0095529854,
-0.0452577099,
-0.0343308821,
0.0041222875,
-0.0038609859,
-0.0359220803,
0.0384997316,
-0.039033059,
-0.0324968584,
-0.0125429686,
-0.0209070481,
0.0414857678,
-0.0018394128,
-0.0065270206,
0.0242052544,
-0.0009578437,
-0.0183142237,
0.0010343064,
0.0082969321,
-0.0245210007,
0.0268514846,
0.0450004749,
0.0095747923,
0.0188439805,
0.0329402983,
-0.0289944913,
-0.0628261715,
0.0762969479,
-0.049598299,
0.009148418,
-0.0222150851,
-0.0088542327,
-0.0145714637,
0.0253800042,
-0.0199061874,
0.037314821,
-0.030414246,
-0.0194030125,
0.0141480966,
0.0290456228,
0.0105107715,
-0.0071115149,
0.0040729684,
0.0147549435,
-0.0162850376,
0.0072176526,
0.0205309037,
-0.0223029479,
0.0066495971,
-0.0219305363,
0.0203755051,
-0.0594416335,
-0.0216634162,
-0.0108891791,
0.0234452896,
-0.0264895819,
0.0125615299,
0.0208864566,
0.0033679528,
0.0182302687,
0.0203992128,
-0.0175331086,
0.0531994589,
0.0057559446,
-0.0466290638,
-0.0791594461,
-0.0220480673,
-0.0189380217,
0.0517197773,
-0.0093113165,
-0.011963468,
-0.073276408,
0.0044072196,
0.0057754465,
0.0236983635,
-0.0256344024,
-0.0617009699,
0.0295828916,
-0.0233629663,
-0.0011329664,
0.0544262193,
-0.0121760871,
0.0430182777,
0.058327809,
0.0055444054,
-0.0511795171,
0.0049328548,
-0.0354991704,
-0.0051210821,
-0.0641073063,
-0.0245425906,
-0.0101170773,
0.0993890539,
0.0208654162,
-0.0321384668,
-0.0587649681,
0.0213989746,
-0.0180773232,
-0.0381262153,
-0.0392171629,
-0.0438867621,
-0.047610797,
0.0554120131,
-0.0333248787,
-0.079215385,
0.0853997245,
-0.0168879051,
0.0097832205,
0.033695057,
-0.0070440429,
-0.024338495,
0.0413404405,
-0.0005598747,
-0.0292922296,
0.0039957385,
-0.026595071,
-0.0502335913,
-0.0013413924,
-0.0138320979,
0.0009033395,
0.0573122688,
-0.0646741539,
-0.0256510992,
0.0425252169,
0.0029387427,
-0.0174931102,
-0.0114491023,
-0.0124694705,
0.0285198186,
0.0397445112,
-0.0427310169,
0.0119516132,
-0.0219205674,
0.0319339894,
0.0228767525,
-0.0383102819,
-0.0004583097,
-0.0401309244,
-0.0021264544,
0.0465831533,
0.0251605436,
0.0451562367,
-0.0696323812,
0.0217437912,
-0.0161855184,
0.0089504737,
0.0098804114,
-0.0652943328,
0.0240756255,
0.0119475061,
0.0119893299,
-0.0301004834,
0.0270295683,
0.0021583969,
-0.0713521317,
-0.0573971681,
0.1170162782,
0.0021241442,
-0.0530195907,
0.0240812916,
-0.0092026554,
0.015216995,
0.0179569069,
0.0457234755,
-0.0216865111,
0.0148597639,
-0.0009355852,
0.0325559042,
0.0174647812,
-0.0119732218,
-0.0002977053,
-0.0707120523,
0.0339927487,
0.0127267335,
-0.0085147973,
-0.032878153,
-0.0239313673,
-0.0317784026,
-0.0041137724,
0.0343424492,
0.016271919,
0.0271099787,
-0.0064492342,
0.030102741,
-0.0243051965,
-0.0356003791,
0.0208852328,
-0.0268458668,
0.0613970459,
0.1017826125,
0.032400351,
-0.0240493268,
0.0071393978,
0.0552415475,
-0.0158374086,
0.0233788453,
-0.0058633266,
0.0225184448,
0.050054796,
-0.0207203515,
-0.0222065672,
0.0540217906,
-0.0299828928,
0.0023003032,
-0.0570980012,
0.0940381885,
-0.0324528404,
-0.0305083916,
-0.0283993687,
-0.0159878507,
0.0007770817,
0.0681825355,
0.0864792764,
-0.0585348867,
-0.0598644465,
-0.0379402675,
-0.0076845028,
-0.0380058214,
-0.0430618152,
-0.0163561571,
0.0174810402,
-0.0180603433,
-0.0573759638,
-0.0162122156,
-0.0204383079,
-0.0230602194,
0.0278666988,
-0.0124941636,
0.0329195932,
-0.0585888401,
-0.0021646847,
0.0121252863,
0.0072456645,
0.0089772111,
-0.0432582125,
0.008202388,
0.0184806455,
-0.057955388,
-0.0129980985,
0.013313706,
-0.0484842993,
-0.082320638,
0.0397936478,
0.0429969095,
0.0318684168,
0.0206374098,
-0.0167540386,
-0.1257407963,
0.0184957255,
-0.0106966039,
-0.0058915927,
0.0259181038,
0.0178118851,
0.0254938286,
-0.0087879589,
0.0602622218,
-0.0406825803,
0.0081654964,
0.0494221859,
0.0094288513,
-0.0371195562,
-0.0048578302,
0.0178051572,
-0.0290128123,
0.0198730193,
-0.0136217,
-0.0247036275,
-0.0466447175,
-0.0073732403,
-0.0011986947,
-0.0031873453,
-0.0557517372,
0.0010957174,
0.0326328725,
-0.0063043213,
-0.0328225605,
-0.0299531389,
0.0376314931,
0.0252430253,
-0.0391488522,
-0.0145690627,
-0.0081015332,
0.0286170375,
0.0133667598,
0.0528884009,
0.021368593,
0.0446050689,
-0.0608313978,
0.0169052016,
0.0160571095,
0.0567531735,
0.0278979521,
0.0129733682,
-0.0339068547,
-0.0189919956,
-0.0791213289,
-0.0471910387,
0.0127229374,
0.017908046,
0.060049057,
0.0102449376,
0.0466743894,
-0.024821505,
0.0085865483,
-0.0134796938,
0.0398734286,
0.0033386245,
0.0067546587,
0.029345395,
0.0191117749,
-0.0119331926,
-0.0342653245,
0.066124931,
0.0231075883,
0.0228141248,
-0.0258124769,
0.0297304615,
-0.0037231455,
-0.0091496846,
-0.0049913023,
0.0105498601,
-0.0208319351,
0.0122587653,
-0.0212830622,
-0.0742460862,
0.0019655663,
0.0288241506,
0.0123889446,
-0.0422212407,
0.0078000678,
0.0404814407,
-0.0176352207,
-0.012979785,
-0.0277070608,
0.0013717172,
0.0157105364,
-0.0267718919,
-0.0275001246,
-6.34491443e-33,
-0.0236956496,
-0.0255972389,
0.0394893251,
0.0034935535,
-0.0215161424,
-0.0177585967,
-0.0674889833,
-0.0206851698,
-0.0402266309,
0.0281032473,
-0.0032409225,
0.0575545467,
-0.0058534862,
0.0379686169,
0.0337894037,
-0.0379705541,
0.0281575173,
-0.0279914364,
0.0039783185,
0.0277288686,
0.0651244745,
0.0437303148,
0.0343634747,
-0.0491151549,
0.0475729555,
0.0248361472,
-0.0108047007,
0.0486598574,
-0.0176348034,
0.0483366176,
-0.0553778745,
0.0225662515,
0.035071332,
-0.0281915199,
-0.0462419726,
-0.0054684952,
-0.0355791412,
-0.0164582692,
0.0110200197,
-0.0011600014,
0.0017724494,
-0.0761738047,
0.1002672389,
-0.015631292,
-0.013934263,
-0.0069555654,
0.0265638083,
-0.0167585686,
-0.0149926161,
-0.0286380257,
-0.058681827,
0.004738885,
-0.0292283017,
-0.0041105752,
0.0293616578,
0.0038652639,
-0.0374201089,
0.0293961894,
-0.0499361902,
-0.011554651,
0.0039556869,
0.0231412109,
0.0781226009,
0.0360606425,
0.0341372453,
0.0516734011,
0.0446283445,
-0.0016355808,
-0.0817028135,
-0.0091049513,
0.0535745956,
0.0336675532,
0.0837570503,
-0.0079180086,
-0.0151211387,
-0.0039206399,
-0.0531734899,
-0.0441426076,
-0.0133631825,
0.0352406166,
0.0222689155,
0.036766313,
-0.0531540811,
-0.0336263627,
-0.0366692692,
-0.0034670555,
-0.0309663657,
-0.0096127149,
0.0229956172,
-0.0278709903,
-0.0171979647,
-0.0424464568,
0.0316789262,
-0.0815913901,
0.0185302217,
0.0059242109,
0.0163938068,
0.0418777838,
0.0500242226,
0.0054177423,
-0.026163334,
-0.0134913707,
-0.0406581387,
0.0061298413,
0.0282076653,
0.0169702955,
-0.0330387615,
0.0570863672,
-0.0061732214,
-0.0029816062,
-0.0504276492,
-0.0190486386,
0.037507385,
-0.00499214,
0.0167657826,
-0.0026577159,
-0.0162573494,
0.0413213708,
0.0134780835,
0.0158911273,
0.0414722636,
0.0224580634,
-0.0065809549,
0.0400216281,
-0.0540702119,
-0.0435729288,
-0.0465262569,
0.0149056772,
0.0529441312,
-0.0788778588,
0.0015925651,
0.0178063214,
2.687e-7,
0.0420395546,
0.0474723764,
0.0294271596,
0.0487118699,
0.076887697,
0.0051184432,
-0.0314569138,
-0.0113428542,
-0.0053965962,
-0.0446170382,
0.0032349923,
0.0188606381,
0.0641889498,
-0.0009612637,
-0.0315552168,
-0.0141377514,
-0.062180534,
0.0001221956,
-0.0191571955,
-0.0198036451,
0.0033663202,
0.0734320432,
0.0025506404,
-0.0040871459,
0.0056760153,
-0.044067435,
0.0535699464,
-0.0265682321,
0.0567414872,
0.0249649789,
0.006446477,
-0.0241526049,
0.0048633851,
-0.0288634095,
-0.01924715,
0.04253681,
-0.0385180265,
0.0890930369,
-0.0010368141,
-0.0350261852,
-0.0122207273,
-0.0446602851,
0.0191706419,
-0.0972754732,
0.0256566666,
-0.0427846014,
-0.0297918208,
-0.0198648721,
0.0294386651,
-0.0361341536,
0.0001446056,
-0.0351359248,
0.0147074535,
0.003547312,
-0.0134838177,
-0.0172984079,
0.0166024622,
-0.0596633889,
-0.0555701517,
0.0012566379,
-0.0783688575,
0.0101500433,
-0.0640703812,
0.0017989901,
0.0537562072,
-0.0245643724,
-0.0017319047,
2.501553916e-34,
0.0219394192,
-0.0189629178,
0.0051815528,
0.0401146561,
0.0189768951,
-0.0005554667,
-0.020538846,
0.0354102179,
0.071406208,
-0.0757098719,
-0.0436134972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16235v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16235v1 | Preference Tuning For Toxicity Mitigation Generalizes Across Languages | 2024-06-23T22:53:47 | 2024-06-23T22:53:47 | Xiaochen Li, Zheng-Xin Yong, Stephen H. Bach | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | Detoxifying multilingual Large Language Models (LLMs) has become crucial due
to their increasing global use. In this work, we explore zero-shot
cross-lingual generalization of preference tuning in detoxifying LLMs. Unlike
previous studies that show limited cross-lingual generalization for other
safety tasks, we demonstrate that Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) training
with only English data can significantly reduce toxicity in multilingual
open-ended generations. For example, the probability of mGPT-1.3B generating
toxic continuations drops from 46.8% to 3.9% across 17 different languages
after training. Our results also extend to other multilingual LLMs, such as
BLOOM, Llama3, and Aya-23. Using mechanistic interpretability tools like causal
intervention and activation analysis, we identified the dual multilinguality
property of MLP layers in LLMs, which explains the cross-lingual generalization
of DPO. Finally, we show that bilingual sentence retrieval can predict the
cross-lingual transferability of DPO preference tuning. | [
0.0024522273,
0.0501806736,
0.0003406947,
0.0137163717,
0.0130676543,
0.031028023,
0.0231955778,
0.0100424755,
0.0026337025,
0.0054110521,
-0.0478469692,
0.0132459253,
-0.0452360064,
0.0193877332,
0.0153871225,
-0.012750457,
0.0557146296,
-0.0263282768,
-0.031651929,
-0.0326034054,
0.0114835128,
0.0097340615,
0.0303850807,
0.0436749086,
0.0574565977,
-0.0162423737,
0.0394354686,
-0.0071335398,
0.0350558572,
-0.0675221682,
0.0222955756,
-0.0035873235,
0.0352197513,
0.0301268622,
0.0000019227,
-0.0262427945,
-0.037629988,
0.0142178098,
0.0014139235,
-0.0333031863,
0.0394215696,
-0.0360671766,
-0.0045344657,
0.0157521758,
-0.0003450112,
0.0106847631,
0.0857512802,
0.0315898843,
0.0237099659,
0.0689927489,
-0.0176492427,
-0.0363850631,
0.0375010818,
-0.0285596866,
0.0202870816,
0.0073994594,
0.0288394429,
-0.0334104411,
-0.0260607842,
-0.0092813121,
-0.0227589756,
0.0435242616,
0.0216730684,
0.01875313,
-0.0309289061,
0.0058093402,
0.0261751208,
-0.0559815355,
0.0093794065,
0.057007689,
-0.0443665013,
-0.0228944682,
-0.0041497131,
-0.0123916855,
-0.0078802193,
-0.0266010445,
-0.0284950025,
-0.010214488,
0.0143702943,
0.0353270844,
0.0411297902,
0.0106192995,
0.0346167348,
0.0064014373,
-0.0180729479,
0.1176306754,
0.0024540147,
-0.0274307765,
0.0563067012,
0.0177933816,
0.0080107674,
0.0159894526,
0.0268255081,
-0.0511132404,
-0.0314219445,
0.0237856135,
0.0325672887,
-0.0179746617,
0.0464664176,
-0.1214425266,
0.0459600687,
0.0043418547,
-0.0489517748,
0.0079764212,
-0.0239458382,
0.0091495682,
-0.0112150479,
0.0400212407,
-0.0278331414,
0.0148168541,
-0.0189417601,
-0.0106910393,
0.0214864518,
-0.0142850718,
-0.0142924041,
0.0534428768,
-0.0644465461,
0.0136829121,
-0.0613598153,
-0.0358378366,
-0.0186661221,
0.0207875632,
-0.0498239435,
0.0226735938,
-0.0162949041,
0.0724195242,
-0.0184407178,
0.0124944914,
-0.0136799281,
-0.01914002,
-0.0205842871,
0.00384463,
-0.0533770435,
-0.0640991405,
0.0156439468,
0.121602945,
-0.0276846644,
0.0063821464,
-0.02590519,
0.003539813,
-0.024663955,
-0.0488395467,
0.0145383636,
-0.0380929895,
0.0037841208,
-0.0260708425,
0.0358279124,
-0.0686862022,
0.006968142,
-0.01765549,
-0.0575848632,
0.0377346314,
0.0152736176,
-0.0116479816,
-0.0124944309,
-0.0166046731,
0.0050360579,
0.0986316726,
0.0186826363,
0.0273139812,
0.019933736,
-0.0191175472,
-0.0306779556,
0.0102421306,
0.0021401979,
0.0483131111,
-0.0478638224,
-0.0404923409,
0.0078012641,
0.0130038755,
0.0464768633,
-0.0196679793,
-0.0423822142,
-0.0072919512,
0.0703475252,
-0.0042154579,
0.0277098287,
-0.0006741446,
0.0390326679,
-0.0165615436,
-0.0545590855,
0.0279931966,
-0.0720058829,
0.0073096971,
-0.0137925185,
-0.0263734236,
0.0030414737,
0.0601893067,
0.0103414943,
-0.035555657,
0.0324099958,
0.0113779334,
0.0233232882,
0.0088049294,
0.0539629757,
-0.0221536681,
-0.0123918029,
0.0229095723,
0.0466034152,
-0.0376451947,
0.0003747238,
-0.0273771193,
-0.0151767656,
0.0844027475,
0.011307315,
-0.0342483781,
-0.0154782254,
-0.0297944415,
-0.0464980826,
0.0072263991,
0.0005883005,
0.0082398839,
0.0765403137,
-0.0224943273,
-0.0211133976,
-0.0034591928,
0.0020178992,
0.010592862,
-0.0118064051,
0.0215903614,
-0.0189908072,
-0.0244836807,
-0.0745788589,
0.0213387981,
-0.0170263816,
-0.045893874,
0.0161615927,
0.0279547833,
0.0278432425,
0.0066380603,
-0.0170487929,
-0.0061179488,
0.0335258432,
-0.0319781192,
-0.0280136205,
0.0282925311,
-0.0207751133,
0.0023143673,
0.0252004117,
-0.021921942,
-0.000363881,
0.0267345868,
-0.0243707299,
-0.019781027,
-0.0188878011,
0.0158447009,
0.0347399078,
0.0180356186,
-0.0011716975,
-0.0357620083,
0.0341556408,
-0.0396006964,
0.0337638445,
0.0138851423,
-0.0311358925,
-0.0420477875,
-0.0553240739,
0.0298452824,
-0.0509109274,
-0.0322983563,
0.023107389,
0.0198106859,
0.0273835249,
0.0675473958,
0.0285532195,
-0.0259458255,
0.0255142581,
-0.0545416214,
0.0308694001,
-0.0122308563,
0.011835916,
0.0110410713,
-0.0258998126,
-0.0000773904,
-0.0022104818,
-0.0336624719,
0.0059080902,
-0.0005141002,
0.0684641823,
-0.0030370387,
-0.0064241644,
0.0108761657,
-0.0181480832,
-0.0174588747,
-0.0365016907,
0.0593071766,
-0.0351078026,
-0.0654378161,
0.0004306498,
0.0340563841,
-0.0214974433,
0.0031388397,
-0.0113856262,
-0.0624771081,
0.0242726859,
0.0432290137,
0.0279897656,
0.0833226293,
-0.0097689759,
-0.0085319476,
0.091023922,
0.0315803625,
-0.0646168217,
0.0020380483,
-0.0339884125,
-0.0482658595,
-0.022545252,
-0.0308878832,
-0.0242364537,
0.0605921112,
-0.0249491856,
-0.0236368701,
-0.0222628117,
-0.0076630996,
-0.0314197987,
-0.0671260208,
-0.0318304561,
-0.0095839389,
0.0001816619,
0.0358144939,
-0.0004751848,
-0.0788660496,
0.0632516071,
0.0388205461,
0.0277189538,
-0.0768657327,
-0.0242249817,
0.0123602897,
0.0005559268,
0.0000686453,
0.0496259667,
0.0338394232,
0.0120337848,
-0.0260275509,
-0.0207679179,
0.0376778021,
0.0082203047,
0.0266183577,
-0.0412851572,
-0.012592027,
0.013501402,
-0.0829221457,
0.0007839623,
0.0094578126,
-0.0055097807,
-0.0032464301,
0.0269606914,
-0.0074874284,
-0.0507472269,
-0.0074865525,
0.0782439858,
-0.0214969162,
-0.0326895714,
0.0019217113,
-0.007724307,
-0.0520967394,
0.05042357,
-0.0449649803,
0.0594805256,
-0.0231670029,
0.0583440661,
0.06946823,
-0.0207041875,
-0.0281426199,
0.0050118174,
0.0561146028,
0.0171697922,
0.0292675421,
-0.0379312672,
0.0053369654,
0.0357652754,
-0.0225626398,
0.0133199878,
0.0239093974,
-0.0101879258,
-0.0745210052,
0.0256178174,
-0.0307278614,
0.0169052817,
0.0099822553,
0.0432125218,
-0.0929183438,
-0.0185257364,
-0.003572711,
0.0086637149,
-0.0544559509,
0.0039165742,
0.0154082254,
-0.0594441965,
0.0053827781,
0.0280858427,
-0.0840166137,
0.0026118029,
-0.0481459349,
-0.0248053875,
-0.0723314807,
0.048894491,
-0.0235257223,
-0.0110218581,
-0.0348006487,
0.0053922958,
0.0138352802,
-0.0561205894,
0.0056102839,
-0.0165171456,
0.0261524189,
0.0495116077,
-0.0068110158,
-0.023643801,
0.0110607287,
0.0548685417,
0.0166819002,
-0.0202797335,
-0.0140230795,
0.0452679023,
0.0344405845,
-0.0094857225,
-0.0323647521,
0.0288033783,
-0.0118097737,
-0.0510193892,
-0.0168330278,
0.0757883489,
0.0120459395,
-0.0533890724,
-0.0169208497,
0.0276189316,
-0.0093128541,
0.0411192849,
0.0027021819,
-0.0605778284,
-0.0330725163,
-0.0755986571,
-0.0370613821,
-0.072153829,
-0.0361591987,
0.003892015,
-0.0739959553,
-0.0909800008,
-0.0291273948,
0.0144427354,
0.0024271451,
0.0123887267,
0.0183797069,
0.0072018229,
-0.0128098642,
-0.0185274314,
0.0301002022,
0.0585034974,
0.0176310316,
0.0013779735,
-0.0711868033,
-0.0179630723,
0.0163962059,
-0.0027895765,
-0.030102564,
0.0519470125,
-0.0103331469,
-0.0924004093,
0.0173666645,
0.077638872,
0.0182753392,
0.00950462,
0.0190406367,
-0.0719524994,
0.0832858607,
0.0527421236,
0.0280842297,
-0.0106622614,
0.0604284517,
-0.0026187042,
0.0131263332,
0.0229496434,
-0.0345337465,
0.0086399987,
0.0483586341,
0.0369025096,
-0.0444591753,
0.0580628887,
0.0507968254,
0.029651409,
0.0332257524,
-0.0504513383,
0.0017095701,
-0.0375532769,
0.0109837996,
0.0077367062,
-0.0179952271,
-0.0141612692,
0.0114573687,
0.0446057394,
-0.0243402477,
-0.0021641667,
-0.0177334454,
-0.0134597104,
-0.0293847881,
-0.0276468862,
0.0366009511,
0.055594977,
0.0034380783,
0.0702676177,
0.0414334312,
-0.012262525,
0.0386013798,
-0.0101141138,
0.0235097725,
-0.0110478932,
-0.0086493297,
-0.0063214656,
-0.0071532894,
-0.0229673721,
0.0475183912,
-0.025141241,
-0.0573905967,
-0.0180838648,
-0.0334111266,
0.0809592456,
-0.0187362395,
0.0648907796,
-0.001167428,
-0.0127249788,
-0.0327804498,
0.0030609865,
-0.0062551294,
0.0027478165,
-0.0055158832,
-0.0188270304,
-0.034978494,
-0.0190657619,
0.1004948243,
0.032668259,
0.0613217503,
-0.0247302186,
-0.0267406162,
0.0012312816,
-0.0347227119,
0.0196626987,
0.0607068241,
-0.0543860309,
-0.0220632404,
-0.0414206199,
-0.0717580765,
-0.009198932,
0.0152694415,
0.012360407,
-0.0068578715,
-0.0312217623,
0.0228442885,
-0.008894233,
-0.0528362058,
-0.0452582017,
-0.0135835446,
0.0370527171,
-0.0135374665,
-0.0018026511,
-6.049992815e-33,
0.014458512,
0.0066117314,
0.0002927967,
-0.032735046,
0.0173059013,
-0.0258574914,
-0.0180024821,
0.010115792,
-0.0063292449,
0.0451053046,
0.0056235516,
-0.0205542911,
0.0069735553,
-0.0242910683,
0.0302957203,
-0.0012872996,
-0.0105054323,
0.0174728595,
-0.015230597,
0.0214645006,
0.0973135978,
0.0562355407,
0.07030119,
-0.0463136546,
0.0265202876,
0.0759507343,
-0.013174518,
-0.0033579599,
-0.0716463923,
0.0691836774,
0.0137556288,
0.0719149634,
0.018527627,
-0.0495395474,
-0.006828397,
-0.0118882144,
-0.0214027055,
0.0006783996,
0.0357155316,
-0.0546141155,
-0.0117549989,
-0.0640027374,
0.0794770941,
0.0107983975,
-0.0245215259,
0.0192722511,
0.0185230616,
-0.0508906655,
-0.0040242923,
-0.014501024,
-0.0634974539,
-0.0073742904,
-0.0103228688,
0.0287967864,
0.0012353356,
0.048435118,
-0.0061832904,
0.0688887388,
-0.0246973131,
0.0391795933,
-0.0184854362,
0.0231697969,
0.0489062332,
0.008236629,
0.0242281146,
0.0580601767,
0.0090105655,
0.0328493342,
0.0380754359,
-0.0454787239,
0.0517160781,
-0.0016385793,
0.0299535077,
0.0476928204,
0.0322638042,
-0.0344514959,
-0.1007020995,
0.022510333,
0.0039694537,
0.0353149511,
0.0042061429,
0.0377304181,
0.0243820511,
-0.0357158296,
-0.0437659137,
-0.0258299075,
-0.0214664079,
-0.0279027838,
0.0115104346,
-0.02314445,
-0.0319883861,
-0.0138921319,
0.0447267182,
-0.0324193798,
0.0080766669,
0.0149359191,
-0.0143231582,
-0.0007134576,
0.0188973825,
0.0268385708,
-0.0678144172,
-0.005939573,
-0.0546885096,
-0.0463420562,
0.0241086259,
0.0125126271,
0.0643580556,
-0.0033441172,
-0.0228370205,
0.0226514172,
-0.0691592246,
-0.0130429082,
0.0849519596,
0.0679375082,
-0.0031938255,
0.0143921115,
0.0278447084,
0.0303536262,
0.0711751431,
-0.0050252047,
-0.0219122171,
-0.0363148116,
0.0022002629,
0.0408343151,
-0.012753088,
0.0024478892,
-0.0224006977,
0.0525728576,
0.0209562052,
-0.0793611258,
-0.0184824988,
-0.024282733,
2.82e-7,
0.0503915101,
0.0243115462,
-0.0228732266,
0.0049271118,
0.0003672451,
0.0434329845,
-0.0099022882,
0.0354130007,
-0.0163022839,
0.023564633,
0.0093625244,
0.0043132389,
0.0447027758,
0.0371318646,
-0.0522389002,
0.0078529138,
-0.0390474424,
-0.0047296714,
-0.0489295237,
-0.0061294599,
-0.0004470071,
0.0699204654,
0.0093529001,
-0.0095280465,
0.0333500057,
-0.0001878068,
0.0363962874,
-0.0978576466,
-0.0131558813,
0.0002769891,
-0.0133114429,
0.0003671577,
0.0028325154,
0.0230455659,
-0.0336754061,
-0.0148276594,
-0.0072116884,
0.0611952357,
-0.0301525909,
-0.0507569015,
0.0142862871,
-0.0279153306,
-0.00981683,
-0.0668128133,
0.0468066782,
-0.0078041414,
-0.0137462756,
-0.0036076384,
-0.0259286463,
-0.0424067117,
0.0684419125,
-0.0478082187,
-0.038636107,
0.0255920719,
-0.0048657469,
0.0466336869,
-0.0073872395,
-0.0315062813,
-0.0142701482,
0.0154333021,
-0.0140180467,
-0.0681199655,
-0.0445060097,
0.0249553882,
-0.0230557173,
-0.027487969,
0.0030960406,
2.47938322e-34,
0.0254536029,
-0.0169222094,
0.0209757723,
-0.0428040326,
0.0704963058,
0.0012794404,
-0.0032061879,
0.0165691674,
-0.0229410473,
-0.070229426,
-0.0063163028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16229v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16229v1 | Multi-Objective Linguistic Control of Large Language Models | 2024-06-23T21:56:48 | 2024-06-23T21:56:48 | Dang Nguyen, Jiuhai Chen, Tianyi Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs), despite their breakthroughs on many challenging
benchmark tasks, lean to generate verbose responses and lack the
controllability of output complexity, which is usually preferred by human users
in practice. In this paper, we study how to precisely control multiple
linguistic complexities of LLM output by finetuning using off-the-shelf data.
To this end, we propose multi-control tuning (MCTune), which includes multiple
linguistic complexity values of ground-truth responses as controls in the input
for instruction tuning. We finetune LLaMA2-7B on Alpaca-GPT4 and WizardLM
datasets. Evaluations on widely used benchmarks demonstrate that our method
does not only improve LLMs' multi-complexity controllability substantially but
also retains or even enhances the quality of the responses as a side benefit. | [
0.0130702909,
0.0769161433,
-0.0215968471,
0.0411753617,
-0.02085834,
0.0134540191,
-0.0174678974,
0.0136918407,
-0.0305722803,
-0.0188548155,
-0.0546520501,
-0.0158115011,
0.016527582,
-0.0005185414,
0.0363357849,
-0.0425377041,
0.0505469926,
-0.0743271783,
-0.0287097748,
-0.0316587836,
-0.0024109925,
0.0247586463,
0.0142020863,
0.0439982824,
-0.0125581976,
-0.0011361975,
0.0003804071,
0.0045714923,
-0.0351510309,
0.0042152265,
0.0300222989,
0.0458257869,
0.0026338946,
0.0431062132,
0.0000021892,
-0.0483236536,
-0.0003658082,
-0.0095646931,
0.0148584042,
0.0645813122,
0.0934489071,
-0.0222801119,
-0.0301840585,
0.0370131172,
-0.0032647422,
0.0085991491,
0.067218408,
0.0094251605,
0.0510843955,
0.0771004707,
0.0061318795,
-0.0389252976,
-0.0118267573,
-0.0221030638,
-0.035618607,
-0.0340091474,
0.0148117375,
-0.0116290851,
0.0289932415,
0.0085444516,
-0.039266564,
0.0224730354,
0.0127092376,
-0.0068479688,
-0.0857666358,
-0.0028468871,
0.0032473798,
-0.0519629419,
-0.0129083516,
0.0512899198,
-0.0443910249,
-0.0262955073,
-0.0031461674,
-0.0165207051,
-0.0091719301,
-0.0380382463,
-0.0362371877,
0.0189040098,
0.0280239191,
0.0317858793,
0.0064190244,
-0.0282203127,
0.0155169051,
0.0035476172,
-0.0590703972,
0.1012616009,
0.0234070607,
-0.0283351596,
-0.001444413,
-0.0057736291,
0.0301517509,
-0.0307256021,
-0.0013356542,
0.0260580722,
-0.0745438933,
0.0078634247,
-0.0519481599,
-0.0305620134,
0.0414793976,
-0.056383092,
0.0823777616,
0.0428801365,
-0.0447382294,
0.0156193171,
-0.0080394167,
0.0763390511,
-0.0323118232,
0.0236308966,
-0.0455380455,
-0.0137358969,
-0.0016767367,
0.0204296708,
-0.0115741743,
-0.005950158,
-0.0500128902,
0.0130637689,
-0.0394173935,
0.0279273298,
-0.0044698552,
-0.0003803176,
-0.0105336988,
-0.0369798839,
-0.038190905,
-0.006076002,
-0.0140901096,
0.0632927939,
-0.0432114825,
0.0285922252,
-0.0170807838,
-0.0863425136,
-0.008339704,
0.0338316262,
0.0050702123,
-0.0259404015,
0.0294520184,
0.0805413872,
-0.0184260942,
-0.0109447325,
-0.016158428,
-0.0225461833,
0.0069724908,
-0.0700446889,
0.0055236304,
-0.0409096517,
0.0296145715,
0.0016276453,
-0.0007597371,
-0.0434156321,
-0.0101645309,
-0.0067050071,
-0.0260403585,
0.0510191061,
0.012886636,
0.0166884065,
0.0156227024,
-0.0111942226,
0.0061414144,
0.104341425,
0.0287359674,
0.0290412027,
0.036415942,
-0.0205680002,
-0.0012166585,
0.0700216815,
0.0229140092,
0.0230303574,
-0.0359550826,
-0.0183829758,
0.0236823242,
0.0174029805,
0.0878873691,
0.0685518607,
-0.0146286618,
0.0076690842,
0.0531874634,
0.0207593497,
0.0397594906,
-0.0162577182,
0.0380688421,
-0.0123413485,
0.0143597452,
0.0395555608,
-0.0378054902,
0.040445704,
-0.032353472,
0.0291689783,
0.0313301757,
0.0715714991,
-0.0076481998,
-0.0270230751,
-0.0098900376,
-0.0158452839,
0.0057350765,
0.0033825983,
0.0385305062,
-0.0070747673,
-0.050487794,
0.0147160739,
0.0602420755,
-0.0206004828,
-0.0170696713,
-0.0752512068,
0.0070622517,
0.0239179768,
0.0195976458,
0.0077283829,
-0.0240328964,
0.0075391256,
0.0262073129,
0.0763766766,
0.0574074984,
0.0029482562,
0.0124773262,
-0.0525611527,
-0.01200868,
-0.0010321378,
0.0207886156,
0.0328710824,
0.0239575151,
-0.004405254,
0.0005240439,
0.0171260983,
-0.0211962294,
0.0444836207,
-0.0170402937,
-0.0158777907,
-0.0095019173,
-0.0029679886,
0.059953656,
-0.010917793,
-0.014925682,
-0.0023073121,
0.0257922802,
-0.0252168272,
0.0052957842,
-0.0529848374,
-0.0194093604,
0.0156664476,
0.0515208542,
0.0128341401,
0.008740847,
0.0280162785,
-0.0282756202,
-0.0477939025,
0.0404365286,
-0.023176115,
0.0530973859,
-0.0390417911,
0.0150094135,
-0.0329886675,
0.0387752876,
-0.0431465358,
0.0143497055,
-0.0025649222,
0.0307064876,
0.0283147302,
-0.0089444574,
-0.0106276749,
-0.0134446044,
-0.019033704,
0.0537106171,
0.01103005,
0.0154667245,
0.0137822907,
0.0610547662,
-0.0066725365,
-0.0682294816,
-0.0287926849,
-0.0019207284,
-0.0376323685,
0.0266076159,
0.015187161,
0.003089766,
-0.0084760375,
-0.0066797314,
-0.020361118,
0.0185319725,
0.0080684321,
0.0359823965,
0.0162273347,
0.0161354896,
-0.0705612227,
-0.0501330197,
-0.0135150319,
0.0120525043,
0.0098582078,
-0.0279534161,
-0.0160825755,
-0.0576514341,
0.0205578487,
-0.0194535349,
0.0492046364,
-0.0125173125,
-0.0731536746,
0.0071763988,
-0.0143574569,
0.0161981657,
0.0569837615,
-0.0194073189,
0.0281978548,
0.0812330544,
-0.0042492975,
-0.0506742299,
0.0179539379,
-0.0259128269,
-0.0841916874,
-0.0524859838,
-0.0019646378,
-0.0123553304,
0.0958764032,
-0.0225124639,
-0.0074214106,
-0.0445959866,
0.002623539,
-0.0296247303,
-0.0390868001,
0.0076225982,
0.0065895305,
-0.0394601412,
0.0418015979,
-0.0214719288,
-0.0680825785,
0.0532918386,
-0.0308411419,
-0.0335562564,
-0.0448033288,
-0.0069745458,
-0.0258253608,
0.041384168,
0.0131338956,
0.0231759846,
0.0088246586,
-0.0081211822,
-0.0446258187,
-0.0089476844,
0.0184803512,
-0.0242187306,
0.0503444672,
-0.0552221872,
0.0126088066,
-0.0398686826,
-0.0404599905,
0.0141115077,
0.0261073131,
-0.0183099061,
0.0053458363,
0.0488296747,
-0.0577237122,
-0.0150756901,
-0.0303687155,
0.0452490598,
0.0385809429,
-0.0257617384,
0.0102566974,
-0.0376443639,
-0.0138636893,
0.0614862926,
0.0564534441,
0.0242313594,
-0.0486294515,
-0.0048339902,
0.0002219051,
0.0058008125,
-0.014713495,
-0.0050758268,
0.0237033181,
0.0550945848,
-0.0057322118,
-0.0108600706,
0.0359803028,
0.036232423,
-0.0520295501,
-0.0144021427,
0.1044682339,
0.0240425132,
-0.0035813684,
0.034189757,
-0.0246982258,
0.0677233562,
0.0266010389,
0.0716840476,
-0.0434721932,
-0.0171510652,
0.0037939569,
0.024336569,
-0.0193968546,
0.0299673676,
-0.0212947,
-0.1298019141,
0.0152193923,
0.009888839,
-0.0621208102,
-0.0263722073,
-0.0280482657,
-0.0136986068,
0.0043320642,
0.0464203432,
0.0210586265,
-0.0020647026,
-0.0240494404,
0.011817256,
0.0198886711,
-0.0562384948,
0.0276305638,
-0.0030043204,
0.0907160267,
0.0640119463,
-0.0097079398,
-0.0009578184,
-0.0205009971,
0.0890699401,
-0.009227396,
-0.0171071813,
-0.0256471541,
-0.028095318,
0.056077268,
-0.0426465981,
-0.0072767097,
0.0310953502,
-0.0039640227,
0.0370257981,
-0.0261116866,
0.0645578206,
0.0029121402,
-0.0246568769,
0.0041844705,
-0.0292320512,
-0.0071711717,
0.0448424444,
0.0531665832,
-0.0702576041,
-0.0517222919,
-0.0549484007,
-0.0611254945,
-0.0704153404,
-0.0499389619,
0.0033953779,
-0.0191564802,
-0.0209361557,
-0.0466321446,
-0.0140379881,
0.0262176804,
0.0137289492,
0.0028525775,
-0.0080238897,
0.0300056394,
-0.0229929555,
0.0121834325,
-0.0019092285,
-0.0183538608,
0.0314497724,
-0.1015370563,
-0.0286608431,
0.065231666,
0.0102575514,
-0.0087201372,
0.0465920568,
-0.050878033,
-0.0899741575,
0.0176955648,
0.048148483,
0.0259287655,
0.0183507949,
0.0037091104,
-0.1003326923,
0.0137368022,
0.0498602912,
-0.0513498671,
0.0773847178,
0.0341278985,
0.0291425362,
-0.0141486451,
0.0683925524,
-0.0348416492,
0.0288047958,
0.011532628,
0.0442775898,
-0.010877843,
-0.07015156,
-0.0019417579,
0.0214376245,
0.0182696357,
-0.0139099918,
-0.0228008237,
-0.0282335654,
0.0215463992,
-0.0410676934,
-0.00147383,
-0.0472510308,
-0.0211391784,
-0.0048944941,
-0.0144257452,
-0.0087483963,
-0.0383074917,
0.0183403604,
0.0272960849,
-0.025698524,
0.0311653763,
-0.0430171564,
0.0095863743,
0.0275240969,
0.0202160571,
0.0002146717,
0.0551479235,
0.0220605079,
0.0352601558,
-0.0281398073,
0.0273975413,
0.0113334842,
0.0102971988,
-0.0577817447,
0.0198566169,
-0.0038933379,
-0.0002758123,
-0.0368707888,
0.0238831881,
0.0563581474,
0.0190609656,
0.1054596379,
-0.0143629583,
-0.0185102914,
-0.0252057128,
0.0297077727,
0.0119419442,
-0.0142407632,
0.0342226103,
0.0040882244,
-0.025148401,
-0.0264347289,
0.0740824267,
0.0260809362,
0.0453176871,
-0.0072210957,
0.0542574413,
-0.0179050881,
-0.0502272248,
-0.0267543234,
-0.0044627795,
-0.0204541143,
0.0063344729,
-0.0468014069,
-0.062885657,
-0.0131580271,
0.0243315883,
-0.0071330611,
-0.030562086,
0.0344747454,
0.0187902749,
-0.0103914291,
-0.0142498035,
-0.039827887,
-0.0512747653,
0.0224153586,
-0.03017883,
-0.010902198,
-7.189089085e-33,
-0.0682456791,
-0.0107497172,
0.0036822422,
-0.0165614393,
-0.0121427411,
-0.0193311423,
-0.0115457317,
0.0179968495,
-0.0449550934,
-0.0082473885,
-0.0191313289,
-0.0247466769,
0.0105230305,
0.0144681493,
0.010666701,
0.0392401367,
0.0359168611,
-0.023935793,
-0.018545147,
0.0194951817,
0.0341397077,
0.0047211484,
0.0309171285,
-0.0520649329,
-0.0219597388,
0.039501179,
-0.0423117206,
0.0113733755,
-0.0338233896,
0.087763682,
-0.0272573978,
0.0473190881,
-0.003717697,
-0.0424686708,
-0.0478630625,
-0.0163794998,
-0.0450438522,
-0.0566175282,
0.0273498744,
0.0186120383,
0.0075903665,
-0.0580893345,
0.0473804772,
-0.0071931831,
-0.043378599,
-0.0063468604,
-0.0091530187,
-0.011803058,
-0.0179271139,
0.0165717043,
-0.0665856004,
0.0079286126,
0.0174626075,
-0.0079905102,
0.0121007813,
0.0118245557,
-0.0068163527,
0.0050554588,
-0.0208513886,
0.0163908713,
0.0472280979,
0.0839137882,
0.0814316869,
0.0434616096,
0.0075309668,
0.0004813707,
0.0148009807,
-0.0059915683,
-0.0054516131,
-0.0174656957,
0.0559381545,
0.0147141581,
0.0316472165,
0.032305304,
-0.0046847528,
-0.0378767326,
-0.0638698563,
-0.0051268279,
0.0342436433,
0.0459462404,
0.0344794281,
0.0302678198,
-0.0279518627,
-0.0327440575,
-0.0492119193,
0.047353331,
-0.0459320396,
-0.0069967224,
0.042911943,
0.0009811146,
-0.0178329386,
-0.0387628563,
0.042367734,
-0.0245952643,
-0.026268268,
-0.0120691983,
-0.0561424904,
0.0379038416,
-0.0007735019,
0.0234590787,
-0.020469971,
-0.0526101664,
0.0055875606,
-0.01168101,
0.0274554882,
-0.0092800856,
-0.0039307973,
0.0364713483,
-0.0938438177,
0.0210703239,
-0.042872373,
0.0014570055,
0.0294871479,
0.0227777883,
0.025829345,
-0.0401050411,
0.0123253195,
0.0534933358,
-0.0048854724,
-0.048476506,
-0.0221967269,
-0.0401931964,
0.0197584145,
0.0404237583,
-0.0515451878,
0.0227744915,
-0.0451054089,
0.0094333487,
0.0176263247,
-0.0272648465,
-0.0381873697,
-0.0016391268,
2.892e-7,
0.0175947119,
0.077793844,
0.0049347403,
0.0888929367,
0.0202677101,
0.0185268298,
-0.0234717578,
0.0102062235,
-0.0248158183,
-0.0199487824,
-0.0351828709,
0.015564804,
0.0449064262,
0.0095120659,
-0.0435430221,
0.0072822119,
-0.0243255626,
0.0387743525,
-0.058681231,
-0.0430796072,
0.032972835,
0.0957965776,
-0.0050585219,
0.0069513945,
-0.0010754573,
-0.017302094,
0.0296241678,
-0.0291892774,
0.0134220198,
0.0224365331,
-0.0008926362,
0.0185188763,
-0.0086784558,
-0.0128421234,
-0.0095753623,
0.01872609,
-0.0262878146,
0.1108919531,
0.0076114293,
-0.0490835123,
0.0455821566,
-0.0168265607,
-0.0310969185,
-0.052068755,
0.0606372133,
-0.0011379935,
-0.012536576,
-0.0326586924,
0.0529908948,
-0.0310795978,
0.0025143242,
-0.0697766915,
-0.0217956435,
0.0357951075,
0.0293227006,
0.0029346438,
-0.0209814534,
-0.0486807637,
-0.0232310705,
0.0122170337,
-0.0290658735,
-0.0612590611,
-0.0577182136,
0.0426541902,
0.0073453384,
-0.0199110489,
-0.0044325884,
3.127160963e-34,
0.0322920308,
-0.0417846106,
0.0389951393,
0.0228461232,
0.0108879749,
-0.0055771051,
-0.0231613275,
0.0445898622,
0.0206613597,
-0.0936245248,
-0.0156595148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16223v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16223v1 | Continuous Output Personality Detection Models via Mixed Strategy Training | 2024-06-23T21:32:15 | 2024-06-23T21:32:15 | Rong Wang, Kun Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The traditional personality models only yield binary results. This paper
presents a novel approach for training personality detection models that
produce continuous output values, using mixed strategies. By leveraging the
PANDORA dataset, which includes extensive personality labeling of Reddit
comments, we developed models that predict the Big Five personality traits with
high accuracy. Our approach involves fine-tuning a RoBERTa-base model with
various strategies such as Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) integration, and
hyperparameter tuning. The results demonstrate that our models significantly
outperform traditional binary classification methods, offering precise
continuous outputs for personality traits, thus enhancing applications in AI,
psychology, human resources, marketing and health care fields. | [
0.0375688113,
0.0740151405,
-0.0459769964,
-0.0135151176,
0.0116493022,
0.0154932039,
0.0258015916,
-0.0068745017,
-0.0123819159,
-0.0109644635,
-0.0444314145,
0.0160676725,
-0.0226311311,
0.0056151766,
0.0171163864,
-0.0336876884,
0.0512076616,
0.0437195674,
0.0138706621,
0.002625932,
0.0018271249,
0.0342997611,
0.0010206165,
0.0349611789,
-0.0283997674,
-0.037227232,
0.0217136331,
0.0058018682,
0.0570535846,
-0.0058103087,
0.0722889155,
0.0332834907,
-0.013010391,
0.0175991803,
0.0000018033,
-0.0037542363,
-0.0244635418,
-0.0357214212,
0.0073305988,
-0.0546096377,
0.0711093619,
0.0011794905,
0.022159487,
0.0387336686,
-0.0421202593,
-0.0523405559,
0.0400116481,
0.0809745491,
0.0853662044,
0.0557243377,
-0.0092939651,
-0.0697596222,
0.0243600067,
-0.0074467263,
0.0030949351,
0.0030692762,
0.0187710654,
-0.0481272824,
-0.0222703628,
0.0068037068,
0.0405892283,
-0.0107801622,
-0.0069151982,
0.0484224558,
-0.0247278959,
-0.0083856639,
-0.0014677561,
-0.014132211,
0.0032367725,
0.0512168258,
-0.0434209518,
-0.0160395894,
-0.0206300877,
-0.0357405432,
0.0211958811,
-0.0589260086,
0.0322340652,
-0.0159949437,
-0.0149647566,
0.0033616824,
0.0308296923,
0.0444014706,
0.0044073937,
-0.0060809143,
-0.0150704971,
0.0296356902,
-0.0428590439,
-0.0147113455,
0.0226030238,
0.0039176638,
0.0252893753,
-0.029572783,
0.0374137424,
0.0042661037,
0.0060661626,
0.0051790895,
-0.0572053306,
0.0184568726,
0.0025726338,
-0.0412205644,
0.0163892247,
0.0021211694,
-0.0443418436,
-0.0070651285,
0.0508414283,
0.0028015431,
0.010132649,
-0.0015900934,
0.0041939132,
0.0067693559,
-0.087435931,
0.017145725,
0.0458446853,
0.0096576046,
0.0624185912,
-0.015244633,
-0.081660077,
0.0148488134,
-0.0405876301,
0.0192077029,
-0.006660339,
-0.0104217175,
-0.0040617711,
0.0395959504,
-0.0264446344,
0.0456480011,
-0.030637946,
-0.0161521602,
-0.0118879629,
-0.0084616691,
0.0295422934,
0.0043872921,
0.041027572,
-0.0170923676,
0.043873135,
0.0245238505,
0.0442626849,
-0.0408282429,
-0.0616688207,
-0.0424363874,
-0.0098535949,
-0.063336432,
0.0209256653,
-0.0075806454,
0.0577408709,
-0.0274215229,
-0.0124957692,
-0.0337757766,
0.0045942725,
0.006858177,
0.0201721638,
0.0549672246,
-0.0026936992,
-0.014120047,
0.0063841562,
0.0031963061,
-0.0012610037,
0.0573132001,
-0.0006211762,
0.0075138835,
0.028101055,
-0.0495680682,
0.0330884159,
0.0470298454,
-0.0012562503,
-0.0504573509,
-0.0208752733,
-0.0225950051,
-0.0158119854,
0.008924189,
0.0372797102,
0.0023486353,
-0.0329657383,
-0.0170878824,
0.052489046,
0.0120095275,
0.0322613381,
0.0570157766,
-0.0042834538,
0.0146893719,
0.0345369987,
-0.0012261388,
-0.0153405322,
-0.0019306599,
-0.0139406407,
-0.0103069395,
-0.0225372314,
0.0030831317,
-0.0181874782,
-0.056026794,
-0.0208384953,
-0.0441577174,
0.0201698057,
0.0054528667,
-0.0298955403,
-0.020246869,
-0.0325592719,
-0.0307153333,
0.0589279532,
0.0028813165,
-0.0285793711,
-0.0748755336,
-0.0028989904,
0.0989202484,
0.007925272,
-0.0551726446,
-0.0288991202,
-0.0381392315,
-0.0430655479,
0.000412943,
0.0301026944,
-0.0151905073,
0.0435068607,
-0.0439839885,
0.024505768,
-0.0093838274,
0.0194248743,
0.0258957725,
-0.0009567616,
0.0173153337,
-0.0331422649,
0.0496203117,
0.000258043,
0.0134135773,
-0.0274835099,
-0.0477161221,
0.0309944861,
0.0356642902,
0.0220545232,
0.0247962456,
0.0038778847,
-0.0357674733,
-0.0011112103,
-0.002992485,
-0.0255585499,
0.0077393358,
0.0225615371,
-0.0504596159,
0.0165444165,
0.0152781513,
-0.0349890292,
0.0552166663,
-0.003689378,
0.0217590164,
0.0087918527,
-0.0406772681,
0.0343264267,
0.0253169406,
-0.0158783533,
-0.0182982124,
0.0857190937,
-0.0161240846,
0.0393206403,
-0.018343281,
0.019457614,
-0.0034054862,
-0.0699076578,
-0.0352458209,
-0.0590853132,
-0.0248971358,
-0.0677210763,
0.0228520017,
0.0120001528,
-0.0220493525,
0.0383639038,
-0.0168713313,
-0.0480113775,
-0.0612023436,
0.0051150685,
0.0252003819,
-0.0098929172,
-0.0152244512,
-0.01323679,
-0.0203746744,
-0.0059226598,
-0.0201155674,
0.0102238972,
-0.0006100383,
0.0245190803,
0.0401110649,
-0.0108513227,
-0.0145770777,
-0.0609182529,
-0.020564856,
-0.0251062922,
0.027273586,
-0.0126555897,
0.0316210464,
0.002662604,
-0.0288354736,
-0.043044176,
0.019895805,
0.0056813066,
-0.0206845738,
-0.0017255443,
-0.0022822213,
-0.0444652326,
0.0785791278,
0.0220296718,
0.0615550093,
-0.0303894524,
0.0270822272,
-0.0217208471,
0.0265331902,
-0.0435807928,
0.00594771,
-0.0332012773,
-0.0244972371,
-0.012228258,
0.0353872553,
0.0080750808,
0.0212489516,
-0.0420640633,
0.0336857662,
0.0462439954,
-0.0341986604,
0.0727817714,
0.0323741287,
0.002333503,
0.0346877575,
0.0248970259,
0.0153237665,
0.055567883,
0.0248506349,
0.026798645,
-0.0207317509,
-0.0734759569,
-0.0185306203,
0.0157611147,
0.0132956533,
0.0025050391,
0.0361976996,
0.0037245061,
0.0037717703,
-0.0549109988,
-0.007624126,
-0.0134277726,
-0.0011939267,
0.0495210364,
-0.0520858094,
0.0511851609,
-0.0537432395,
-0.0545611233,
-0.0605935007,
-0.0489405878,
-0.0364884622,
0.0152427107,
-0.0084237186,
-0.0411200151,
-0.0358772874,
0.0098093161,
0.0084703919,
-0.0226433724,
-0.0383094996,
0.0161120202,
-0.0013007417,
0.0590123497,
0.0014708615,
0.0249738358,
-0.0796678737,
-0.0255756211,
0.0025270486,
-0.0558397174,
0.0275061186,
-0.0086227907,
-0.0116614169,
0.0023967917,
0.0098251821,
-0.014297545,
-0.0146392221,
-0.0270994119,
-0.024413513,
0.0090405783,
0.116078265,
0.0222388413,
-0.0151237538,
0.0278974101,
0.0450732633,
0.0122421617,
0.015603154,
0.0542108715,
-0.0151179088,
-0.0324376933,
-0.0418204255,
0.027217865,
-0.0263198968,
-0.0314051807,
-0.0098507199,
-0.0738264024,
0.0318612047,
-0.001139863,
-0.017384639,
0.0022913578,
-0.0202025697,
-0.0026812367,
-0.038658876,
-0.0455376394,
-0.0728118122,
0.0294136666,
-0.0208372064,
-0.0173337385,
-0.0677051172,
-0.0336533189,
0.0482455753,
-0.0197298694,
0.0307869464,
0.0120319501,
0.0442727357,
-0.0054331995,
-0.0478058159,
-0.0000740148,
0.0236934721,
0.0219594277,
0.0090857474,
0.072700642,
-0.0504847206,
0.0254000481,
-0.0460486636,
0.0015017111,
-0.0209371354,
0.0350437835,
0.0178057849,
0.0280858558,
0.0037479349,
-0.0616825335,
-0.0251706466,
0.0476128459,
0.0602304786,
0.0193288811,
-0.0261432808,
-0.1109312996,
-0.0278563853,
0.0044313921,
0.0183194,
-0.0482954755,
-0.0456760079,
-0.0262580775,
0.0042118467,
-0.0418509543,
-0.0127517562,
-0.0795901343,
-0.0324644782,
0.0276067965,
-0.0305064842,
-0.0878929198,
0.004577369,
0.0406665094,
-0.0407616943,
0.0041925129,
0.036588423,
0.0174835678,
-0.0006823839,
-0.0418944322,
0.062084768,
-0.0427722782,
-0.0190465972,
0.0227808785,
-0.0898292512,
-0.0399706103,
0.0223966558,
0.0455518514,
0.0134436181,
0.0531357676,
0.0108589288,
-0.061515037,
0.0288848635,
0.0152546307,
-0.0017239787,
0.038676437,
0.0400161184,
0.0303909145,
-0.0190508887,
0.0206369311,
-0.0334694386,
0.0513496473,
0.0005231321,
-0.075299859,
-0.0513537079,
-0.0573054887,
-0.0328121707,
-0.0361523442,
-0.0009657695,
0.0188555978,
-0.033369977,
-0.0126654897,
-0.0414234512,
-0.0011947786,
0.0151574165,
0.0134318294,
-0.0886996314,
0.0212834831,
0.0051662768,
-0.0507631861,
-0.0470846593,
0.0182188209,
0.0038344066,
-0.0616172925,
-0.0066921897,
0.0443925224,
0.0158311464,
-0.0469939858,
-0.0196684003,
-0.0545316115,
0.00697876,
0.0232036468,
0.0545013063,
0.0218337495,
0.0293284096,
-0.015936736,
0.0040535787,
-0.0195676871,
0.0401295759,
-0.0522153601,
-0.013338442,
-0.0246738736,
-0.0087178787,
0.002405575,
0.0298051611,
0.0331121087,
-0.0078634387,
-0.029729763,
-0.0125221517,
0.0474190116,
-0.0273455568,
-0.0146309445,
0.0092583662,
0.01762655,
-0.0091127036,
-0.0426417738,
0.0220373701,
0.0306939203,
-0.0038649596,
-0.0366621986,
-0.028364189,
-0.0653115883,
0.0558133647,
-0.0046146433,
0.0951405019,
0.0139315547,
0.0225962326,
-0.0500168055,
-0.079479903,
0.1031644717,
-0.0038267788,
0.0171070583,
0.0075693009,
0.0023514342,
0.0050524771,
0.0202129334,
-0.0149869155,
-0.0493705384,
-0.0034044373,
-0.0051304735,
0.0044772974,
-0.0060251155,
-5.522760456e-33,
-0.0147656836,
0.0170488507,
-0.0057245628,
0.0379106291,
-0.0256185196,
-0.0159800351,
0.004502052,
0.0209771469,
-0.0041317856,
-0.0061668251,
-0.0221585222,
0.0170954671,
-0.0085207559,
-0.0031980418,
0.0049338578,
-0.0154016213,
0.035292387,
-0.0200073496,
0.0173586607,
0.0131814731,
0.025571188,
0.0299202465,
0.0505507328,
-0.1014205143,
-0.0323578604,
0.0050485292,
-0.0301525649,
0.0106365997,
0.0237686262,
0.0724250153,
0.0037148099,
0.0584957004,
0.0282409918,
-0.0096215671,
0.0079380153,
0.0239094403,
-0.039532315,
-0.0606829897,
-0.040250171,
0.0366019309,
-0.0092181796,
-0.0345950052,
0.0338773094,
0.0036584672,
-0.012207157,
-0.0402375348,
0.0664176792,
0.0112915142,
0.071643576,
-0.0068301605,
-0.0126625812,
0.0199931189,
-0.0242045783,
0.0063230824,
-0.0254686531,
0.0557243079,
0.0056431657,
0.0200550705,
-0.122136429,
0.036111407,
-0.0259495042,
-0.0118948286,
-0.0256614983,
0.0376109108,
-0.0087276064,
0.0400446504,
0.1196815521,
0.0554490462,
-0.0027993612,
-0.002916344,
0.0250235759,
0.0529294163,
-0.0056125754,
0.0441470109,
-0.01276513,
-0.0621961877,
-0.0321485028,
0.0037896882,
0.1359514296,
-0.0930280313,
0.0444057025,
-0.0121884989,
-0.0650317594,
-0.0210896805,
0.0421676189,
-0.0248625465,
-0.0081833247,
-0.0134609016,
-0.0044654268,
-0.0038403375,
-0.0207387693,
0.0166602321,
-0.0040307031,
-0.0391150191,
-0.0112961745,
0.0345217995,
-0.0589600652,
0.0211554188,
0.0044806306,
-0.0225696526,
-0.0170740299,
-0.0022387952,
0.0025586446,
-0.0043331236,
0.0805504322,
0.013114755,
0.0526567698,
0.0441076234,
-0.0615208298,
-0.0410615653,
0.046492219,
0.0473892987,
-0.00137857,
0.0831339881,
-0.0123543842,
0.0149263265,
0.0002351379,
0.0383246057,
0.0059426595,
0.0477012396,
-0.0335939527,
0.0237661526,
0.051823806,
0.0118188011,
0.0325376019,
-0.0385953672,
-0.0255902559,
-0.01243403,
-0.0394495912,
-0.0735475197,
0.0000391281,
0.014677288,
2.526e-7,
-0.0332365409,
0.0360860936,
-0.0235493463,
0.0179596599,
0.0511010326,
0.0650785342,
0.0276823621,
0.0061839777,
0.0427494831,
-0.0255937222,
0.0048969546,
0.0315949135,
0.0158151463,
0.0334715322,
-0.0352430083,
-0.0425157994,
0.0555015653,
0.0421551131,
-0.044381354,
-0.0137958052,
0.0655865669,
0.0959049463,
0.0668004379,
-0.0206871498,
0.0350019783,
0.0466640554,
0.0379341245,
0.0425328799,
0.0018478081,
0.0154141625,
-0.0234209988,
0.0016326088,
-0.0093887402,
0.0303654894,
-0.0060435589,
0.0292874258,
-0.0144685255,
0.0792663097,
-0.0404496752,
-0.0419037938,
0.0387391634,
0.0612028651,
-0.0325562097,
-0.0050751083,
0.0328922793,
0.0047149262,
-0.0284827836,
-0.0531176142,
-0.0059795808,
-0.0472958758,
0.052113235,
0.0115687232,
-0.0258051995,
0.0131861987,
0.0136988172,
-0.0288585834,
-0.0235835072,
-0.0822544321,
0.0293897633,
0.022939302,
-0.0720715299,
-0.0359904505,
0.0326162316,
0.029284576,
0.0635420308,
-0.028340688,
0.0255193841,
2.05883106e-34,
-0.0001037699,
0.0175161101,
0.0145050865,
-0.0439087972,
0.0443245582,
0.0324392468,
0.0199615639,
-0.0136330798,
0.0555060431,
-0.0665173531,
-0.0202070195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16203v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16203v3 | LLMs' Classification Performance is Overclaimed | 2024-06-23T19:49:10 | 2024-07-03T13:18:50 | Hanzi Xu, Renze Lou, Jiangshu Du, Vahid Mahzoon, Elmira Talebianaraki, Zhuoan Zhou, Elizabeth Garrison, Slobodan Vucetic, Wenpeng Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL | In many classification tasks designed for AI or human to solve, gold labels
are typically included within the label space by default, often posed as "which
of the following is correct?" This standard setup has traditionally highlighted
the strong performance of advanced AI, particularly top-performing Large
Language Models (LLMs), in routine classification tasks. However, when the gold
label is intentionally excluded from the label space, it becomes evident that
LLMs still attempt to select from the available label candidates, even when
none are correct. This raises a pivotal question: Do LLMs truly demonstrate
their intelligence in understanding the essence of classification tasks?
In this study, we evaluate both closed-source and open-source LLMs across
representative classification tasks, arguing that the perceived performance of
LLMs is overstated due to their inability to exhibit the expected comprehension
of the task. This paper makes a threefold contribution: i) To our knowledge,
this is the first work to identify the limitations of LLMs in classification
tasks when gold labels are absent. We define this task as Classify-w/o-Gold and
propose it as a new testbed for LLMs. ii) We introduce a benchmark, Know-No,
comprising two existing classification tasks and one new task, to evaluate
Classify-w/o-Gold. iii) This work defines and advocates for a new evaluation
metric, OmniAccuracy, which assesses LLMs' performance in classification tasks
both when gold labels are present and absent. | [
0.0482716113,
0.0518575311,
-0.0150502538,
0.0373765118,
-0.0454141125,
0.0500440672,
0.0362324044,
-0.0030035728,
0.0363871157,
-0.1019947305,
-0.0802409425,
0.0054441951,
0.0214170776,
0.0050269044,
0.0028616388,
-0.0109781865,
0.0463497974,
-0.0445625931,
0.0375048034,
0.0045709708,
-0.0530639663,
0.0115181124,
-0.0232573561,
0.0413176157,
-0.0114797493,
0.0002890474,
0.0342964083,
-0.0333937593,
-0.0103737656,
-0.0216101892,
0.0196963437,
0.0505120642,
-0.0195929743,
0.1041507199,
0.0000018517,
-0.0645991564,
0.0281748362,
-0.0180514101,
-0.0599548258,
0.0070607532,
0.0122728599,
-0.004925706,
0.0257540084,
0.0356077813,
-0.0449582525,
-0.0305774286,
0.0233705752,
0.0497930534,
0.0258615427,
0.058297053,
0.0025023199,
-0.0238611251,
0.0386007689,
-0.0197689105,
0.0056666895,
-0.0796793252,
0.0340572149,
-0.0047980421,
0.0029757032,
0.0108054737,
0.0131785851,
0.0584020838,
0.0006218438,
-0.0089238547,
0.0106062954,
0.0482040904,
-0.0498764068,
-0.0214461461,
0.0071215141,
0.0567971766,
-0.0268937629,
-0.0115988487,
-0.007159105,
0.0068606436,
0.0046888622,
-0.0404083803,
-0.0243511554,
0.0422298573,
0.0033601222,
0.0325703137,
0.0284394827,
0.0376986153,
0.060705483,
0.0424157456,
-0.0232415292,
0.0814661458,
-0.0177754965,
-0.0338464305,
0.0409919061,
0.0337416418,
-0.0573672131,
-0.0490250513,
0.0065559261,
0.022910893,
-0.0016775648,
0.0124501903,
-0.0332973301,
-0.0143526988,
0.0221078265,
-0.0445280299,
0.0328872614,
0.0010941501,
-0.0257577728,
0.0807962567,
-0.0572003312,
0.0626373217,
0.0229662675,
0.0472289398,
-0.0186062641,
-0.0287974291,
-0.0586975813,
-0.0189232584,
-0.0141155496,
0.0413947329,
0.0479710624,
-0.0297586974,
-0.0360107757,
-0.0023455548,
-0.0231108293,
0.0350390598,
0.0162003394,
-0.0075710081,
0.0207328256,
-0.0184433796,
-0.0373532474,
-0.0067213662,
-0.00594733,
0.0415859111,
-0.0219658837,
-0.0483811013,
0.0180566628,
0.0447445996,
-0.0171093624,
-0.0097133433,
0.0314709321,
0.0773170069,
-0.0122709321,
-0.0512554795,
-0.0355120189,
0.02836309,
-0.0161692984,
-0.0659490824,
-0.0085700871,
-0.0244268216,
0.0157629978,
0.0328463018,
0.0049218712,
-0.0343751349,
0.018002728,
-0.0050379676,
-0.0163086876,
0.0859346986,
-0.0064474349,
0.0037254004,
0.06423565,
0.0044679265,
-0.0088235848,
0.0370015353,
0.0446127206,
0.0212484486,
0.0428995118,
-0.0066878358,
0.0508323312,
0.0334270224,
-0.0288807154,
-0.0309099462,
-0.035809435,
-0.0107883904,
0.0094250338,
0.041750785,
0.0083081806,
0.0483452864,
0.029360652,
-0.0172749273,
0.0767830089,
0.0407966897,
-0.0220550057,
-0.0122311329,
0.0080338111,
-0.0015190053,
0.0105134901,
0.0119913528,
-0.0571997575,
-0.0069800583,
-0.0686004236,
-0.0177983828,
0.0321342722,
-0.0211091656,
-0.0260470212,
-0.0959618986,
-0.0428265668,
-0.0480541624,
-0.0111283092,
0.034821339,
0.0708569735,
-0.0118671348,
-0.0245693754,
0.0293244701,
-0.0011922817,
-0.0101077491,
-0.006033293,
-0.1149500161,
0.031819623,
0.0125516653,
0.0435187928,
-0.0676940307,
0.0115754316,
-0.0148611935,
0.0120499972,
0.021498315,
0.0531903952,
-0.010507944,
-0.0020215232,
-0.0547878444,
-0.0198543258,
0.0000676548,
0.0447003506,
-0.0066476925,
0.0197060965,
-0.0205259565,
0.0357111953,
-0.05208629,
-0.0438465662,
0.067153357,
0.0232507084,
-0.0422665142,
0.0282508936,
0.0112903807,
0.0172805749,
-0.0072732642,
-0.0065573691,
0.0142085291,
0.0416689552,
-0.0361426771,
-0.0408748239,
-0.0513277613,
-0.0073397625,
0.00848014,
0.0554410033,
-0.0073710661,
-0.0349969566,
0.0742178112,
-0.0385710075,
-0.0276218113,
0.0069472459,
-0.0334105156,
0.0192194302,
-0.0354467705,
0.0402166359,
-0.0171748288,
0.0261784475,
-0.055013746,
0.0628556535,
-0.0037136353,
0.024465533,
-0.0229741298,
-0.0188214947,
0.0207976196,
-0.0272829961,
-0.0251448881,
0.024035003,
-0.0018689755,
0.0405755043,
0.0112861646,
-0.0120794317,
-0.022902064,
-0.0495772064,
-0.0928614959,
-0.0007326804,
-0.0120353308,
0.0083676577,
-0.0097485185,
-0.0428813882,
-0.0106551014,
-0.017812591,
-0.0048106872,
-0.0125297653,
0.0045626187,
-0.0136979772,
0.0391978621,
0.0086238161,
0.0002451112,
-0.0170797706,
-0.0025365471,
-0.0030972669,
0.0412306041,
0.0087926649,
-0.0157867838,
-0.0314817205,
0.0171968192,
-0.0265085176,
0.0254394431,
-0.0086501446,
-0.0236246679,
-0.0010072412,
-0.0296486951,
-0.03419929,
0.063523449,
0.0268297866,
0.0343287662,
0.0858111084,
0.0446953997,
-0.0359845273,
-0.0093492605,
-0.000043941,
-0.0311938729,
-0.0310179405,
0.0027585356,
0.0192588475,
0.0929159597,
-0.0007843209,
0.0038533045,
-0.0121961283,
0.01022097,
-0.0333192721,
-0.0101990141,
-0.0563456342,
0.0249290187,
-0.0094400262,
0.0394974723,
-0.0132171437,
-0.0670245364,
0.0458584838,
-0.0366071835,
-0.0110953897,
-0.0301476941,
-0.044716619,
-0.0529150814,
0.0642900169,
-0.0018890229,
0.0064188149,
0.0194291975,
-0.0198635384,
-0.0120433103,
-0.0145132113,
-0.0229093116,
-0.0381360762,
0.0551313795,
-0.0493956506,
0.0273754075,
-0.0111193648,
-0.0267960671,
-0.0459972396,
-0.0193044059,
-0.0616812445,
0.03441884,
-0.0304839872,
0.0015319457,
-0.0842771083,
0.0169467684,
0.0154176652,
0.0577083565,
-0.0035783667,
-0.0125624817,
-0.0061640628,
0.0358558521,
0.0388521366,
0.0154345669,
0.0125785936,
-0.0375138931,
0.0175633207,
0.0128261512,
-0.0008307244,
0.0364496298,
-0.016967386,
-0.0228481647,
0.0648294985,
-0.0091869449,
-0.0438384004,
0.0224758666,
-0.0349774472,
-0.0451828726,
0.0118079018,
0.156625852,
0.0549168624,
-0.0432537906,
-0.0166889559,
-0.0022512011,
0.0015737679,
0.0470760427,
-0.0046144263,
-0.0361158103,
-0.039822299,
0.0153333927,
0.0349254906,
-0.0190441497,
-0.0131272087,
-0.0192445684,
-0.1037351266,
0.0448348932,
0.0015861084,
-0.0449343212,
-0.0117555223,
-0.0325810313,
0.0085336408,
-0.0163618457,
0.0075495755,
-0.0433730185,
0.0055247312,
-0.0287602972,
0.0420948826,
-0.0636427104,
-0.0820814669,
0.0336988047,
0.0030038462,
0.0694130883,
0.061222177,
0.0478239469,
-0.0379918627,
-0.0458034649,
0.0610863715,
-0.0066641122,
-0.0001781749,
-0.030334007,
0.0386931524,
-0.005321533,
0.0009945191,
0.024627788,
-0.0200736132,
-0.0457088277,
0.0156163843,
0.0216622427,
0.089764148,
-0.0300312247,
-0.0605460666,
0.0150931859,
-0.0251317471,
0.0006378949,
0.0881327689,
0.0359934419,
-0.0469133444,
-0.0501564667,
-0.0240495428,
0.0192900226,
-0.0267568342,
-0.0264857318,
0.0581942312,
0.0028767129,
-0.0446876846,
-0.0377870314,
-0.0342259631,
0.0433408506,
-0.0001929938,
-0.0166732818,
0.0087349862,
-0.0319757089,
0.0005775845,
-0.0238085557,
0.0027687943,
-0.0527480431,
0.0150905894,
-0.0925796703,
-0.0176288709,
0.0448265001,
-0.0224990882,
-0.0346293859,
0.0094231982,
-0.0345704854,
-0.0468806475,
0.0060312711,
0.0357563421,
0.0339866839,
-0.0246430356,
-0.0130209876,
-0.081715472,
0.0345275775,
0.0344035551,
-0.0145120174,
0.0125457607,
0.0397973992,
-0.0068789087,
-0.0280136932,
0.0424739383,
-0.0434781983,
0.0367999338,
0.010063719,
-0.0110251354,
-0.0395082645,
-0.0282573514,
0.0012201442,
0.0245389249,
0.058283098,
-0.0195720289,
-0.0002819742,
-0.021223709,
0.0065400256,
0.0349499881,
-0.0450575724,
-0.0093598813,
-0.0200379677,
0.0542536266,
0.017007485,
-0.0162583273,
0.0320086591,
-0.0213076901,
0.0159667321,
-0.0293672066,
-0.0032161064,
0.0227195565,
0.0431425497,
0.0071898028,
-0.0024293019,
-0.0439149663,
0.0119564459,
0.0446979851,
0.0202167146,
0.0002865912,
0.037219502,
-0.0080079138,
0.0315212645,
-0.0441084914,
0.0374329612,
-0.0665432438,
-0.0357292034,
0.0033351495,
0.0344526693,
0.0765262544,
-0.0190132596,
0.0220449213,
-0.0183997545,
-0.0340032503,
-0.049691774,
0.014033867,
0.0170324389,
-0.0275613125,
0.0099207647,
0.0239252876,
-0.0321937576,
0.021553399,
0.0894647762,
0.0134153403,
0.0428232998,
-0.0368034206,
-0.0200633649,
-0.0424623415,
-0.0303621814,
0.0099685322,
-0.0024614835,
-0.0122641874,
0.0303605385,
-0.0482522659,
-0.0944521651,
0.0240486637,
-0.0086625591,
0.0132181607,
-0.0275722891,
0.0141703188,
0.0592512116,
0.0086321905,
-0.000288392,
-0.0695472062,
-0.0352804549,
0.0037136746,
-0.000913089,
-0.0596402474,
-6.08614845e-33,
-0.0271677841,
-0.0458817966,
-0.0003662488,
-0.0008658401,
0.0080278702,
0.0519153625,
-0.0302198995,
0.0024619328,
-0.0183651038,
0.0092043122,
0.0067200009,
0.0051329751,
0.0086328434,
0.0120519334,
0.0085999109,
-0.0291077588,
0.032542143,
-0.0271262322,
-0.0461007059,
-0.0065000369,
0.0214493331,
0.0057005449,
0.0116475243,
-0.106236577,
0.0280624647,
-0.0048645032,
-0.0184157845,
0.0262095574,
0.0068225451,
0.0597487465,
-0.0369580947,
0.0770667121,
0.0441664495,
-0.0164931398,
0.0163810626,
0.0191217475,
-0.0460486859,
-0.0123678893,
-0.027290754,
-0.0010239191,
-0.0019566151,
-0.0216047019,
0.0231130496,
0.0231266338,
-0.0322733074,
-0.0047691078,
0.0554514304,
-0.0259691477,
-0.0267106704,
-0.0248883404,
-0.0387289897,
0.0266735666,
-0.0127926944,
-0.010884448,
0.051103875,
0.0249719843,
0.0012594742,
0.0187694412,
-0.0427469425,
0.0164254662,
0.0142023144,
0.020025054,
0.0712448359,
0.036452312,
-0.0395210199,
0.0387404263,
0.0279979389,
0.0218402781,
-0.0048666685,
-0.0161552262,
0.038055867,
0.028667869,
0.0573295504,
-0.0082825646,
0.0041032559,
-0.030121509,
-0.0415903218,
0.0117736021,
0.0196030345,
-0.0237558,
0.0188803505,
0.009189277,
-0.057762254,
-0.033762075,
-0.0341744386,
0.0005584281,
-0.0547639504,
0.0219960846,
0.0344983153,
0.0059654503,
-0.002761316,
-0.0232940689,
0.0016338894,
-0.0375702158,
-0.0238667689,
0.0022865389,
0.0225681867,
0.0456436649,
0.0116204442,
0.0062292037,
-0.0530932471,
-0.0536138266,
0.0159321129,
-0.0036354673,
0.0411305204,
-0.0299386736,
0.05801351,
0.033169087,
-0.0563128963,
-0.0069545181,
-0.0248352159,
0.011711943,
0.0278122071,
0.007564716,
-0.0021423649,
0.0129889706,
0.0102860704,
0.0459511206,
-0.0140959453,
0.0097164251,
0.0018580246,
0.0132508911,
-0.0060026455,
0.013015802,
-0.0406455845,
-0.0235376209,
-0.0066027469,
0.004240463,
0.0080814753,
-0.0312451907,
-0.0053796833,
-0.0091162119,
2.543e-7,
0.0671712682,
0.052605018,
-0.0234260093,
-0.0026345043,
0.0203586426,
0.0699486956,
-0.0569790974,
-0.0005398769,
0.00194713,
0.0178240929,
0.0060676546,
0.0375311151,
0.0897727162,
0.0252540968,
-0.0709293634,
-0.0076969718,
-0.0419915132,
0.0068040183,
-0.0518417321,
0.0377235301,
0.0663549006,
0.0793981254,
0.0192706119,
-0.0263137855,
-0.0453347117,
-0.083039403,
0.0553223193,
-0.0255328771,
0.021302063,
0.0205312055,
0.0654744431,
0.0569376349,
-0.0113174366,
0.0388817154,
-0.0027256487,
0.0203378275,
0.0564159527,
0.0712036565,
-0.0213643108,
-0.0397344828,
-0.0146051459,
0.0093132816,
0.0226191916,
-0.0546322241,
0.0912391022,
-0.0251554921,
-0.0263684653,
-0.0410511866,
0.0350444168,
-0.0149373347,
0.0296023935,
-0.0139788697,
-0.015076099,
0.0195050444,
0.0196075235,
-0.0362382233,
-0.0320592001,
-0.1106484756,
-0.0208556782,
0.0062661269,
-0.0555192567,
-0.0182042234,
-0.0193098988,
0.0553565323,
0.0337109044,
-0.059013769,
0.0230852067,
2.25566713e-34,
0.0156394318,
-0.0136291459,
-0.0015171024,
0.0243294593,
0.0272212625,
0.0166088212,
-0.0110119218,
0.0052775205,
-0.0047302768,
-0.0603329204,
0.0303231776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16201v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16201v1 | Blind Baselines Beat Membership Inference Attacks for Foundation Models | 2024-06-23T19:40:11 | 2024-06-23T19:40:11 | Debeshee Das, Jie Zhang, Florian Tramèr | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Membership inference (MI) attacks try to determine if a data sample was used
to train a machine learning model. For foundation models trained on unknown Web
data, MI attacks can be used to detect copyrighted training materials, measure
test set contamination, or audit machine unlearning. Unfortunately, we find
that evaluations of MI attacks for foundation models are flawed, because they
sample members and non-members from different distributions. For 8 published MI
evaluation datasets, we show that blind attacks -- that distinguish the member
and non-member distributions without looking at any trained model -- outperform
state-of-the-art MI attacks. Existing evaluations thus tell us nothing about
membership leakage of a foundation model's training data. | [
-0.0196478255,
0.119927153,
-0.0176772885,
0.0481521524,
-0.0501354635,
-0.004213158,
0.0461137109,
-0.0136080524,
-0.0084113823,
-0.0227656048,
-0.0098293014,
0.0147252921,
0.0074580573,
0.0259262118,
0.0236627236,
0.040893387,
0.04362363,
0.0081486516,
-0.0417545959,
-0.0299695972,
-0.0149079897,
-0.0198612493,
0.0220179316,
-0.0116841299,
-0.0047162203,
-0.0295174271,
-0.0222123321,
-0.0096681034,
-0.0045538344,
0.0046861982,
0.0070241136,
0.0618579425,
0.0012225282,
0.0699625239,
0.0000017277,
0.0002868049,
-0.0637691393,
0.0562833697,
-0.0406670943,
0.0353251696,
-0.0109445192,
0.0395511799,
0.0203337669,
0.015934987,
-0.0049779117,
0.0306742769,
-0.0000897873,
0.0495076478,
0.0382144451,
0.0599485897,
-0.0004714023,
0.0360348895,
-0.0025005578,
-0.0203533489,
-0.0017797077,
0.0105329584,
-0.0003769682,
-0.0401614048,
-0.0643478408,
-0.0211931728,
0.0027106907,
0.0027456346,
0.0065040723,
0.0389329232,
0.0147193987,
0.0377722383,
-0.0368433818,
-0.0098396232,
0.0206942819,
0.0275990218,
0.0296207275,
-0.0115990443,
0.0248982068,
0.0297396854,
0.0391725861,
0.0528639257,
-0.0006321977,
0.0626511276,
-0.0154326623,
-0.0073782932,
-0.0323841386,
-0.0032531063,
0.0548261367,
0.0051727891,
-0.0230051875,
0.0390154608,
0.0250848513,
-0.0118249664,
0.0045072814,
-0.0151771568,
0.0265024323,
-0.0258336384,
-0.0301331524,
-0.0476011895,
0.0383224115,
0.0129610216,
-0.0836349875,
0.0142237078,
0.0277510807,
-0.0142800752,
0.0240546726,
-0.0330172367,
-0.0254606511,
0.0561251529,
-0.0036121788,
-0.0229327027,
-0.0060728439,
0.0633212253,
0.0197954942,
0.0479534902,
-0.0163053535,
0.0089704832,
0.056536831,
0.062467508,
0.0279604532,
-0.0140221631,
-0.027366139,
0.0407789573,
-0.043999929,
0.0218093786,
-0.0744552165,
0.0110191284,
0.0071615931,
0.0420491062,
0.0073424098,
-0.0369541906,
0.0177040827,
0.019035561,
-0.0048135631,
-0.0987479836,
-0.0344379805,
-0.0131047266,
-0.0476906858,
-0.0175736435,
0.0181067139,
0.0847039446,
0.0609163493,
-0.0405286141,
-0.0333191454,
-0.093778953,
0.0298346039,
-0.0234024636,
0.0116332937,
-0.0343664214,
-0.0223495699,
-0.0195524786,
0.0091928802,
-0.0321374424,
-0.0194612872,
-0.0005163247,
-0.0553542078,
0.0433775708,
-0.0060087545,
-0.0003113059,
-0.0150015512,
0.0167651065,
-0.0649743974,
0.0341780484,
-0.0259591118,
0.0244008694,
0.0568864383,
-0.0045956173,
0.0276187714,
0.0137740858,
0.0568812825,
0.0034721557,
0.0112694893,
0.0195817444,
0.0081128301,
-0.05637981,
-0.0611772202,
-0.001768571,
-0.0258364752,
-0.0464697927,
0.0671468526,
0.0327054039,
-0.0294780005,
0.0173219219,
-0.0284617413,
-0.0193545632,
0.0385207869,
0.0028033513,
-0.0795850456,
-0.048376333,
-0.1060151905,
-0.0411864109,
-0.0455936156,
0.0192418955,
-0.0168998875,
0.002835019,
-0.0118496008,
-0.0519209392,
0.0011365293,
0.0278732013,
0.0576530732,
0.0352144279,
0.0429530255,
0.0376501307,
0.0236705225,
-0.0292262528,
-0.0215950068,
-0.049438592,
0.0321948119,
-0.0223687645,
0.0509997904,
-0.0302550793,
0.0176377278,
-0.0235717949,
-0.0072500622,
-0.0372161455,
-0.0052404003,
-0.0118175196,
0.0300412718,
0.0061342521,
-0.0336185656,
-0.0122302501,
0.0316229537,
0.026138531,
0.0359031595,
-0.0343489014,
0.0238990709,
-0.0746369958,
-0.0222386587,
0.0359231494,
-0.0009595904,
0.0043412903,
0.0255017765,
0.0251137819,
0.0571183413,
0.0114391977,
-0.0418704413,
-0.0021896737,
0.0495105647,
0.0418579206,
-0.0154287256,
-0.0134104704,
0.0811159313,
0.0186851341,
-0.0006286199,
-0.0490700491,
0.0233989581,
0.0542235598,
-0.0351550765,
0.0188120902,
0.0369410664,
-0.0140709681,
0.0026006503,
0.0007232553,
0.0108177448,
-0.0389763862,
0.0485396348,
-0.013846539,
0.0448849238,
-0.0077673793,
-0.0178972278,
0.0436669812,
-0.0256039351,
0.0418430269,
-0.0499321707,
-0.0357677042,
-0.0064531388,
-0.0575294495,
0.0032728186,
0.0054508522,
-0.0409343876,
-0.0248846635,
0.0534356087,
-0.0148564139,
0.0057755788,
-0.0171625242,
0.0315613151,
0.0024950248,
-0.0081944764,
-0.0332977138,
-0.0283241197,
0.0326830447,
-0.032457266,
-0.0215015858,
0.0259901192,
-0.0221393239,
-0.0134873977,
-0.0084076617,
0.0088105109,
-0.0285287369,
-0.0132241389,
0.0930122063,
0.0265742429,
0.0235691369,
0.0074078627,
-0.008895875,
-0.0361795649,
-0.0018075214,
-0.011646756,
0.0027796472,
-0.0063404543,
-0.0005943158,
-0.1388817132,
0.0795746073,
0.0208446737,
0.0716399103,
0.030213749,
0.0234900713,
-0.0095464885,
-0.0392269604,
0.0147803444,
0.0066264481,
-0.0141491424,
-0.011168398,
0.0353925861,
0.0125029944,
0.0333801992,
-0.0339239761,
0.0059541357,
0.0684819296,
0.0069913999,
-0.005060771,
-0.0068477569,
0.0015509713,
-0.0122099621,
-0.013445993,
0.002072375,
-0.1069439799,
0.0418119244,
-0.0595618524,
0.0547546633,
-0.0019309082,
-0.0285986699,
0.0251665916,
0.0004099444,
0.0313430391,
0.0083199367,
0.0580078959,
0.0027211418,
-0.0023278242,
0.0362078883,
0.1051617116,
-0.0474888198,
-0.0184596516,
0.0002028431,
-0.0046178414,
-0.0064217388,
-0.006839524,
-0.063937299,
-0.057540793,
0.0233145896,
-0.0128159216,
-0.0410834476,
-0.0064319456,
-0.0052079028,
-0.0324802585,
-0.0133027723,
-0.0151392147,
-0.0147156464,
0.0142004993,
-0.0019198996,
0.0229177382,
-0.0029069129,
-0.0787810832,
0.0301451385,
-0.0644739568,
-0.0177012011,
0.0380485505,
0.0397348143,
0.0377874598,
-0.0144597385,
-0.0190272015,
-0.0072259577,
-0.0019737945,
0.0375139564,
0.0231923666,
-0.0190007556,
-0.0221574958,
-0.0064663566,
0.031439092,
-0.0003258356,
0.0013360486,
0.0007222975,
0.0442857668,
0.0137573201,
0.0059475908,
-0.0192335211,
-0.099555552,
0.0071416944,
0.0493016876,
0.0799944475,
-0.0297767036,
-0.0306812376,
0.0412970074,
-0.0772644058,
0.0233114455,
0.0047364323,
-0.0477239341,
0.0129850693,
-0.0698890612,
0.0058236676,
-0.0412054695,
-0.0202789512,
-0.0373587236,
0.0037975567,
0.0284485742,
0.0012282144,
-0.0217521545,
-0.0833540931,
-0.0043752175,
-0.0413909107,
0.0246141311,
0.0512704961,
-0.0401019864,
-0.0352789685,
-0.0140561676,
0.0347649828,
-0.0606866702,
-0.0195058342,
0.0163251031,
0.100223884,
-0.0172188468,
-0.0010836055,
0.0318311676,
0.0705290586,
0.0032944041,
0.0100848069,
0.0416301154,
0.0076498091,
-0.0311404783,
-0.0140676629,
-0.033603929,
-0.0511390194,
0.024916295,
0.0466496833,
0.0190308467,
-0.0082626389,
-0.0029399728,
-0.0415874459,
-0.0003484547,
0.0597052164,
-0.0106734764,
0.0511330478,
-0.0195030589,
-0.0430434346,
-0.0405795537,
-0.0028960314,
-0.0264731292,
0.0504330024,
0.0066469056,
-0.0085138055,
-0.0241475347,
0.0123129049,
-0.0463918485,
0.0297125261,
-0.0278671719,
0.032840047,
-0.0369970724,
-0.0032848895,
-0.0148940412,
0.0094617484,
-0.0361774601,
-0.0228928067,
-0.0670662373,
-0.0746080503,
0.0037697922,
0.0560587533,
0.0257002078,
0.0437112264,
-0.0409657434,
-0.0062199794,
0.072192058,
0.0204245485,
-0.0230996795,
0.001042561,
0.0645417944,
-0.1366700977,
-0.0048814607,
0.0007223877,
-0.04661927,
0.0064159036,
0.0713683367,
-0.052430138,
-0.0028462908,
0.0424432829,
0.0040709665,
0.0354591273,
0.0912108123,
0.0158771314,
0.0129096406,
0.0206725299,
0.0283722356,
0.0027626394,
-0.0185962468,
-0.0043653171,
-0.0097366432,
0.0202957783,
0.0258394554,
0.0253416523,
0.0170615781,
0.0112427734,
0.0718661547,
-0.0125365593,
0.0121512897,
0.0390146151,
0.0024859386,
0.0180338677,
-0.0209929887,
-0.0009021978,
0.0036294886,
0.0236983504,
0.033568874,
0.0113932779,
0.0442270711,
-0.0001957208,
0.02146299,
0.0023587453,
-0.0012336014,
-0.0570883267,
-0.0336044095,
-0.0087299803,
0.0245092288,
-0.0153598133,
0.00073731,
-0.0295771901,
-0.0093780048,
-0.0100711575,
-0.0375208221,
-0.0115291001,
-0.019908214,
-0.0420743711,
0.0256823059,
-0.0029761789,
-0.0076847724,
0.0648123845,
0.0593426116,
0.0647648349,
0.0597049743,
-0.0705346912,
-0.0439617224,
-0.0287670959,
0.0024898231,
0.05049273,
0.0052813506,
-0.0161789935,
-0.0462553278,
-0.0454766341,
-0.0669262409,
0.0340883322,
-0.0029529731,
0.0536000952,
0.0361160599,
-0.0247506015,
0.0530003458,
-0.0147846416,
0.0170361716,
-0.0534179769,
0.0123378048,
-0.0306154732,
-0.0178612676,
-0.0046965028,
-5.367050066e-33,
0.0107615907,
-0.0141313644,
-0.0727988034,
0.0124824503,
0.0117112258,
0.0540139675,
0.0260209031,
-0.019529717,
-0.0308486298,
-0.0358134024,
-0.0297276396,
0.0218691044,
-0.0039087553,
0.0223856922,
-0.0119073996,
-0.0413051248,
0.0202216543,
-0.0126459748,
-0.0543762967,
0.020273542,
0.032404989,
0.0231512003,
0.0153121473,
-0.0787962228,
-0.0108958911,
-0.0289827306,
-0.0287821237,
-0.0111927744,
-0.067307286,
0.0527555496,
0.0193840712,
-0.0061294525,
0.0070193107,
-0.0000753561,
0.0139761325,
-0.0343348868,
-0.0178567339,
0.035541743,
-0.0381220542,
0.0116354823,
0.0319372602,
0.000669834,
0.0345481709,
-0.0075400053,
0.0222262628,
-0.0431013256,
0.0145858536,
-0.049144458,
-0.0153087396,
-0.0347491913,
0.0224127471,
0.0125759747,
-0.0393174477,
0.0377926752,
0.0148797501,
0.0188995767,
0.0131913386,
-0.0402740799,
0.0069945189,
0.0294469986,
0.0685404018,
-0.045608066,
0.0407914296,
0.030224748,
0.0271174852,
0.053167738,
0.0514355861,
-0.0009815004,
0.038639199,
-0.0125431279,
0.014723178,
0.0748851374,
0.0427825414,
0.0908126682,
0.0481106266,
0.01648058,
-0.0461779237,
0.0171538163,
0.012028778,
-0.0099894842,
0.0293588843,
-0.0354828313,
-0.0449058339,
-0.0003359234,
-0.0487706214,
-0.0793979391,
-0.0197009575,
-0.0190751888,
0.0280373394,
0.025877852,
-0.0638851672,
-0.0240334272,
0.0055195554,
-0.0666514337,
-0.0224151202,
0.0583391786,
0.0034029773,
-0.0140567524,
-0.0248011257,
-0.038329836,
-0.0295646787,
-0.0255986694,
0.027947275,
-0.0495886393,
0.0518293716,
-0.0114318691,
0.0666123629,
0.0136960773,
-0.0068915971,
0.0093338508,
-0.0128961857,
-0.0019062288,
0.0146840448,
0.0409662202,
0.0519278906,
-0.0102056665,
0.0099549918,
-0.0186564699,
0.0083665121,
0.0650380626,
-0.0787085742,
0.0305886101,
-0.0348420292,
-0.0263291895,
0.0031875819,
-0.0403918624,
0.01743274,
0.028283203,
0.0297311321,
-0.0765311643,
0.0155027881,
-0.0230249222,
2.632e-7,
-0.0188867748,
-0.0166431833,
-0.0064414479,
-0.0486090258,
0.0157218557,
0.0548661724,
-0.0379978158,
0.0722104907,
0.0060676378,
-0.0317702219,
-0.0091290232,
-0.0183857083,
0.0283367205,
0.014247003,
-0.0309048351,
0.0060482696,
-0.0342012979,
-0.003164971,
-0.0663688555,
-0.0166951381,
-0.0097559225,
0.065529272,
0.0485750064,
-0.0271186475,
0.037804693,
-0.0489473008,
0.004477025,
-0.0129964082,
-0.0113134356,
-0.0319698602,
0.059344098,
0.0346376635,
-0.0000043394,
0.0246657506,
-0.0463937558,
0.032508608,
-0.0254894476,
-0.0027538496,
0.0344634652,
0.0422186628,
-0.0532996431,
-0.0410774648,
0.0160152856,
0.0338311344,
0.0707879439,
0.0158547796,
-0.0127889235,
-0.0512895063,
-0.0689634159,
-0.0894645676,
0.0192990731,
0.0072010374,
0.034549512,
0.0102863917,
-0.029858768,
-0.0086791068,
0.0041738339,
-0.0520436019,
0.0136828199,
-0.0551062748,
-0.0460960716,
-0.0330194309,
0.0431094356,
-0.0053804726,
0.0182008799,
-0.022274306,
-0.0044078561,
2.69345245e-34,
0.0006622913,
-0.0288451072,
0.0186657198,
0.0201083086,
0.037064068,
-0.0286791921,
0.0496984683,
-0.0200396478,
-0.0410376117,
-0.0377792567,
0.0107891746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16176v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16176v1 | GraphEval2000: Benchmarking and Improving Large Language Models on Graph Datasets | 2024-06-23T18:01:56 | 2024-06-23T18:01:56 | Qiming Wu, Zichen Chen, Will Corcoran, Misha Sra, Ambuj K. Singh | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, H.2.8, I.2.6, I.2.7 | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success in natural
language processing (NLP), demonstrating significant capabilities in processing
and understanding text data. However, recent studies have identified
limitations in LLMs' ability to reason about graph-structured data. To address
this gap, we introduce GraphEval2000, the first comprehensive graph dataset,
comprising 40 graph data structure problems along with 2000 test cases.
Additionally, we introduce an evaluation framework based on GraphEval2000,
designed to assess the graph reasoning abilities of LLMs through coding
challenges. Our dataset categorizes test cases into four primary and four
sub-categories, ensuring a comprehensive evaluation. We evaluate eight popular
LLMs on GraphEval2000, revealing that LLMs exhibit a better understanding of
directed graphs compared to undirected ones. While private LLMs consistently
outperform open-source models, the performance gap is narrowing. Furthermore,
to improve the usability of our evaluation framework, we propose Structured
Symbolic Decomposition (SSD), an instruction-based method designed to enhance
LLM performance on GraphEval2000. Results show that SSD improves the
performance of GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and GPT-4o on complex graph problems, with an
increase of 11.11\%, 33.37\%, and 33.37\%, respectively. | [
0.0142073035,
0.0772628784,
-0.0238547791,
0.0569284894,
-0.0654494911,
0.0095184529,
0.0003879258,
0.0125105735,
0.0730930492,
-0.0198781416,
0.0172413886,
-0.02285433,
0.0055559529,
0.0378719904,
-0.0081421975,
-0.0232105907,
0.0195568316,
-0.0341233984,
0.0326328464,
0.0026998995,
0.0010110537,
0.0474294797,
0.0332559794,
0.0117396628,
-0.0080587426,
-0.0326676928,
0.0030735505,
0.0208536349,
-0.0221722089,
-0.0553725474,
-0.0369127095,
0.0186684839,
0.0254707821,
0.0452369787,
0.0000022502,
-0.0220328998,
-0.0422531627,
0.023924198,
-0.0392911881,
0.0415114909,
0.0501381867,
-0.0351422094,
0.0261896215,
0.0154992221,
-0.0362767465,
-0.0599550046,
0.0197273884,
0.0334636904,
0.0663473606,
0.0811783075,
-0.0177572649,
-0.0461644679,
-0.0059600682,
0.0091628376,
-0.0209209099,
-0.0220128521,
0.0255693141,
0.0349085033,
0.0183213465,
-0.0250167046,
-0.0402889214,
0.0058926153,
0.0091730673,
0.0256802738,
0.00192568,
0.0140904654,
-0.0492870286,
0.0054215011,
-0.0006575462,
0.0876017585,
-0.0118970266,
-0.0101634953,
0.0159558579,
-0.014250461,
-0.039049536,
0.0115381116,
-0.039590776,
0.0182621963,
-0.045836255,
0.0475961789,
0.0158149209,
-0.0404628478,
0.0485715009,
-0.0052981693,
-0.0340842865,
0.1094179749,
-0.0052380827,
-0.0117325336,
0.0084348535,
-0.0395646505,
-0.0668545738,
-0.0343737528,
0.0356405191,
0.0255119186,
-0.0085179107,
0.0286083911,
-0.030105697,
-0.011224092,
-0.0028163707,
-0.0400173888,
0.0453727394,
0.0005621829,
0.040749941,
0.0484765768,
-0.0027978895,
0.0666334778,
-0.0373736881,
0.058299996,
-0.0320145562,
-0.0048570889,
-0.0686133951,
-0.0045671039,
-0.0686316416,
0.0613678731,
-0.0388814919,
-0.0321839079,
-0.0159875881,
0.0293165054,
0.0021936141,
-0.009196233,
0.0489140861,
-0.0036917352,
0.0433348827,
-0.0211200211,
-0.0085200798,
0.0230037086,
-0.000019078,
-0.0195574127,
-0.0536433384,
-0.0237493403,
0.0020257584,
0.0018101598,
0.0431305915,
-0.0361662284,
0.028216552,
0.090290159,
0.0464723147,
-0.0550552271,
-0.0165178962,
-0.0376009494,
0.0039232802,
-0.0746716931,
0.0116116283,
-0.0756116286,
0.0436656885,
0.0299630128,
-0.0068148226,
-0.0510861687,
0.0262607671,
-0.0022405968,
-0.0277869292,
0.0579080619,
-0.0079403566,
0.0299405847,
-0.0063152281,
-0.0226008557,
0.0057256464,
0.0299846809,
0.0290598683,
0.0020174147,
0.0243078433,
-0.0118628228,
-0.0391497239,
0.0247698482,
0.0025214213,
-0.0089340862,
-0.0125010256,
0.0097338855,
-0.0592256896,
-0.0035083825,
-0.0311261471,
0.1197050139,
-0.0131146312,
-0.0264535584,
0.0072532371,
0.0618011206,
-0.0043463302,
-0.0097549474,
0.0176652689,
0.06117668,
0.0073304181,
-0.0212728772,
-0.0455092043,
-0.0328040384,
-0.0082699228,
-0.0025445737,
-0.0287698023,
0.012656589,
0.0274104625,
-0.0390707478,
-0.0514611676,
0.0054961867,
0.0764433071,
-0.0068539898,
0.0622263961,
-0.0246037822,
-0.0589856692,
0.0306310784,
0.0207901578,
-0.0349884182,
-0.0230992101,
-0.0071599241,
-0.0159266479,
0.0663554966,
0.0652503297,
0.0039821151,
-0.027875511,
0.0182557348,
-0.0195528734,
-0.013497293,
0.0188656133,
-0.0112334751,
-0.009651728,
-0.0511526465,
-0.0152792959,
-0.0088624042,
-0.0057626357,
0.0130777322,
0.0373938158,
-0.0125062354,
-0.0092833657,
-0.0722071454,
-0.0615254119,
0.0033964918,
0.0333711728,
-0.0101029668,
-0.006354914,
-0.0131173301,
0.0189048089,
0.0225486886,
-0.0038693913,
0.0358900577,
0.031450849,
-0.0128741162,
-0.0013692237,
-0.013639763,
-0.0213360209,
-0.0508256517,
0.0656773299,
-0.0325419344,
-0.0346728973,
0.0358129293,
-0.0528920852,
-0.0330670923,
0.0621829033,
-0.0743370801,
0.034141019,
0.0085153123,
0.0190564692,
0.001839433,
-0.001279498,
0.0094266776,
0.0747322366,
-0.0020111187,
0.003814212,
0.0139527405,
0.01076781,
0.0126941325,
-0.0190655254,
0.0117811318,
0.0376543701,
0.0048515485,
0.0064999051,
0.0032155518,
0.0173418839,
-0.0248684678,
0.0305783972,
-0.0635162517,
0.0157926213,
-0.0123817241,
0.0480263159,
0.0164109524,
-0.0012536694,
-0.0101418886,
0.0037279399,
-0.032072071,
0.0276022218,
0.0338900499,
0.0106659047,
0.0233399421,
-0.0435757264,
-0.0363880545,
-0.0187065359,
-0.0578560121,
-0.0597633012,
0.0619704537,
0.003696044,
-0.0405388027,
0.0078923739,
0.0625507683,
-0.0260019321,
0.0427755304,
-0.0152513599,
0.0085988771,
0.0056886626,
-0.0396987051,
0.0518714935,
0.0321059711,
-0.0404902473,
0.0410435386,
0.0541444458,
-0.0332660228,
-0.0159717668,
-0.0032446345,
-0.023956582,
0.0035577028,
-0.0404062159,
-0.0574047603,
-0.0276336093,
0.055633612,
0.0183976423,
-0.0152275665,
-0.0304518342,
-0.0207830295,
-0.0404840335,
0.0515570343,
-0.0117056007,
-0.0257696416,
0.0212438032,
0.0031677193,
-0.0497613512,
-0.0267638881,
0.0952668488,
-0.0340981036,
-0.0005906107,
-0.0070816013,
-0.042749133,
-0.0905347839,
0.1049509943,
0.0431077071,
0.0192655791,
-0.0097925114,
-0.0398052335,
-0.0258320626,
-0.0103194863,
0.0395164676,
-0.0419256613,
0.0238188542,
-0.0235043112,
0.0323525183,
0.0000189307,
0.0088066719,
0.0022023551,
-0.0107250083,
-0.0484913588,
0.0289921854,
0.0427390374,
-0.0293687414,
0.0341357663,
0.0159943718,
-0.0251400992,
0.0127016706,
0.0014120737,
0.0134950103,
-0.0347132795,
0.0198398922,
0.0219487436,
-0.0477224402,
0.0159389749,
-0.0367958695,
0.0296881068,
0.0501535647,
0.0492388159,
-0.0275637154,
-0.039344918,
0.0239457581,
-0.0015103281,
-0.0254497603,
-0.0295318961,
-0.011918053,
0.0364510007,
-0.0914858431,
0.0080508459,
0.0866029486,
0.0510008335,
-0.0308634117,
0.0136899753,
0.0238543861,
0.0152242407,
0.0330879986,
0.0113870762,
-0.1201126054,
-0.0320043489,
-0.0167848188,
-0.0003603697,
0.0201188494,
-0.0582806543,
-0.036321193,
-0.1202744469,
0.0251513515,
0.0363251045,
-0.0081657823,
-0.036336612,
-0.0742712766,
-0.051499512,
0.0061509651,
-0.0228340589,
-0.003000309,
-0.0391506217,
0.007243007,
0.0108756926,
-0.0374428667,
0.000699327,
0.0503379852,
0.0048212307,
0.0049625598,
-0.0177428722,
0.0377841666,
0.0226441734,
-0.0062073288,
0.0624272823,
0.0209887139,
-0.0101978406,
-0.0375402682,
0.018573463,
0.0217182618,
-0.002656996,
-0.0369925573,
0.0034083719,
-0.0817013085,
-0.0206713062,
-0.0235660207,
0.1221007779,
0.0092775691,
-0.0224961974,
-0.0069223754,
-0.0258954149,
-0.0537758954,
0.0265223142,
0.0378756262,
0.0463847741,
-0.0935704187,
-0.0417500325,
0.0187043734,
-0.0301874969,
-0.0475505628,
0.0260684602,
-0.01909752,
0.0061146379,
-0.0153269107,
-0.0156416912,
0.0519251339,
-0.0045231115,
-0.0300475806,
0.0086750314,
0.0332528912,
-0.0297363028,
-0.0974636376,
0.03771355,
-0.0318510346,
0.0500344597,
-0.0180622917,
-0.0058964659,
-0.0085968496,
0.0101100253,
-0.0129145076,
0.0160105061,
-0.0859967023,
-0.0886075422,
-0.0361308157,
-0.0183900371,
0.0226223916,
0.0440980718,
-0.0181564428,
-0.0090579186,
-0.0185507853,
0.0124445437,
-0.011668318,
-0.0107062049,
0.0125103891,
-0.0087299347,
0.0143721197,
0.0329984985,
-0.0130453473,
0.0193239562,
-0.0063534323,
0.0512083061,
-0.0237912666,
0.0118347378,
0.040044561,
0.1147690862,
0.0199861713,
0.0394791588,
-0.0200428143,
-0.0183786657,
-0.0125938514,
-0.0489810742,
-0.0328432061,
-0.0286713336,
-0.0028985469,
0.0240754448,
-0.0105058188,
-0.040406175,
-0.0374366567,
0.010631267,
0.0350609869,
-0.0190501604,
0.0326577947,
0.031520132,
-0.0256323963,
0.0616035312,
-0.0126180258,
0.000342478,
0.0291208308,
-0.0064551583,
-0.0033122434,
-0.0022429237,
0.0200126544,
-0.0015180408,
-0.0100088306,
-0.0495419689,
0.000136698,
-0.0414682589,
-0.0499212146,
0.0123190936,
-0.0046436097,
0.0380095802,
0.0240236353,
0.0578851663,
-0.0101193292,
0.0157142635,
-0.026162833,
0.0481726341,
0.0011709783,
-0.0563804768,
0.037287239,
0.038081456,
0.0019216446,
0.0190141667,
0.0666359812,
0.066969417,
0.0241010636,
0.0276284833,
-0.0442376435,
-0.0258434322,
-0.0175928753,
-0.0015302852,
0.0188045446,
-0.0105991,
0.0033114078,
-0.0606398657,
-0.1014261395,
0.0005301367,
0.0130793825,
0.0230726432,
-0.0107952291,
0.027298335,
0.0230329204,
0.0290642567,
-0.0433026366,
-0.0351007134,
0.0319745094,
-0.0215493254,
-0.0319507942,
0.008653664,
-6.48428104e-33,
-0.0037268256,
-0.0721910372,
0.0279868562,
0.0111271329,
-0.0345732644,
0.0293141045,
-0.0567853972,
0.0048428979,
-0.0034299691,
-0.0108509557,
-0.0007416583,
0.0413727053,
-0.0071734078,
0.0170616526,
-0.0217291433,
-0.0152942082,
0.008700232,
-0.0007408081,
-0.0041386406,
0.0165652223,
0.0340171158,
0.018390432,
0.0535048954,
-0.0390972756,
-0.0036220544,
-0.0137640843,
0.0195674095,
0.0105315354,
-0.0138586173,
0.031948816,
-0.0245466121,
0.0288905725,
0.0316733792,
0.0201785099,
-0.0114475042,
0.0018104992,
-0.0689630583,
-0.0233768206,
0.0496400818,
0.0053380667,
-0.0485374443,
-0.0228295103,
0.0438881032,
0.0046865754,
0.0071276128,
-0.0249639917,
0.0144276647,
0.0113477521,
-0.0041493783,
0.0014742785,
-0.00813301,
0.0564442314,
-0.0239069574,
0.0127331819,
0.0550426915,
0.0120850094,
-0.0146973282,
0.0217006914,
-0.0049576922,
0.0234902911,
-0.0082734777,
-0.0071073505,
0.0281308386,
-0.0260592923,
0.0236916523,
0.0275400057,
0.011779936,
-0.0182081647,
-0.0238266028,
0.0402487479,
0.0019729459,
0.1161232665,
-0.0102607468,
-0.0042690155,
0.0174942482,
0.0216753706,
-0.083667174,
-0.0074414015,
0.0095924987,
0.011765372,
-0.0146588571,
0.0309621617,
-0.0298999287,
-0.0537201874,
-0.0219819844,
-0.0365230665,
-0.0410413221,
-0.0090150321,
0.0028179057,
-0.0291785505,
-0.0326542705,
0.0056374315,
-0.0018192219,
-0.0668806732,
-0.0393359885,
0.078369379,
-0.0114804413,
0.0377247483,
0.0007187537,
0.060343124,
-0.0555735081,
-0.0173334535,
-0.0051366729,
-0.0313486792,
0.0376986489,
0.0115960967,
-0.0033817082,
0.0182481762,
-0.0468473956,
-0.0121137565,
-0.0598831102,
-0.02511275,
-0.0584632233,
0.0006925496,
0.0630075485,
0.0525480211,
0.0076884949,
0.0557609014,
0.0410254747,
0.031160621,
-0.022841258,
0.0420187935,
-0.0041384613,
0.0377898142,
0.0167738087,
-0.021999009,
-0.020833008,
0.0163036827,
0.0614266507,
-0.0464807972,
-0.0254775099,
-0.0158698354,
3.029e-7,
0.0620141067,
0.0757940635,
0.0635137707,
0.0521369688,
0.0103188306,
0.0042297496,
-0.0255995002,
0.0128970416,
-0.0088744257,
-0.0042333324,
0.0255631674,
0.0499348603,
-0.0112578049,
0.0460885614,
-0.0307133589,
0.0591065809,
-0.0563662983,
-0.0451449007,
-0.0745055377,
0.0274997801,
0.0511605963,
0.0491024926,
0.0393675305,
-0.0161918737,
-0.0562661998,
-0.0339728743,
0.0203919802,
-0.0140452962,
-0.0246828534,
-0.0224478915,
-0.0424722768,
0.0021911848,
-0.0231765211,
-0.0008486073,
0.0104677025,
0.0198917463,
0.025416743,
0.0434272178,
-0.0273056701,
0.0152264088,
0.0169636849,
-0.0613046624,
-0.037999969,
0.0113790883,
0.0841237009,
-0.0196935181,
-0.0695548728,
-0.0019490849,
-0.0419215672,
-0.017502876,
-0.0135024302,
0.0298598781,
0.0168059506,
0.0338609666,
0.0053556343,
-0.0585214198,
0.0089446967,
-0.0524535216,
0.0009496607,
0.015486896,
0.0010322562,
-0.017083738,
-0.0224574376,
0.0522078201,
0.0271062944,
-0.0095315073,
-0.0067503788,
3.193061656e-34,
0.0414325669,
-0.0116820093,
0.0021360149,
-0.0015610757,
0.0698088855,
-0.0431906432,
-0.0469728559,
0.036703229,
0.0029805489,
-0.1047779843,
-0.0219537709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16167v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16167v1 | FS-RAG: A Frame Semantics Based Approach for Improved Factual Accuracy in Large Language Models | 2024-06-23T17:18:19 | 2024-06-23T17:18:19 | Harish Tayyar Madabushi | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a novel extension to Retrieval Augmented Generation with the goal
of mitigating factual inaccuracies in the output of large language models.
Specifically, our method draws on the cognitive linguistic theory of frame
semantics for the indexing and retrieval of factual information relevant to
helping large language models answer queries. We conduct experiments to
demonstrate the effectiveness of this method both in terms of retrieval
effectiveness and in terms of the relevance of the frames and frame relations
automatically generated. Our results show that this novel mechanism of Frame
Semantic-based retrieval, designed to improve Retrieval Augmented Generation
(FS-RAG), is effective and offers potential for providing data-driven insights
into frame semantics theory. We provide open access to our program code and
prompts. | [
0.0159437358,
0.0302218311,
-0.0251325425,
0.0405936986,
-0.0222596936,
-0.010407229,
-0.0128809335,
0.0000680313,
-0.0008147067,
-0.0911457539,
0.0209951699,
-0.0405871272,
-0.0139157074,
0.0220767017,
0.0041487864,
-0.0425513573,
0.0902494267,
0.020289138,
-0.0137990592,
0.0075251567,
-0.0065205903,
0.0393985622,
-0.018495094,
0.0258209836,
-0.0521107875,
-0.001819431,
0.0005040983,
-0.0105248112,
-0.0048232558,
-0.0084632356,
0.0113652069,
0.022022564,
0.0287211165,
0.0658322498,
0.0000020291,
-0.059695676,
-0.0046149865,
0.0091604097,
-0.0468730144,
0.0122826602,
0.0441443585,
0.0575169921,
0.0113900835,
0.0134344967,
-0.0350947343,
-0.0706615672,
0.0280224644,
0.0155024286,
0.0385674164,
0.0535877496,
-0.003718317,
-0.0195869878,
-0.0084854886,
0.0265163984,
0.0216937587,
-0.0166223049,
-0.005555063,
0.0433026776,
0.0554418452,
0.0203354023,
-0.0030367277,
0.0291934852,
-0.0087771835,
-0.0431374758,
-0.0337396748,
0.0184439905,
-0.0436060764,
-0.0332747735,
0.0349434279,
0.039821852,
0.104110986,
-0.0318768919,
-0.0099976473,
0.0245576389,
0.0121298861,
0.0878407955,
-0.0515429638,
0.019930033,
-0.0128202178,
-0.0050146123,
0.0319576152,
-0.002194888,
0.0177534856,
0.0141522111,
-0.0409200862,
0.0572644807,
0.0298241638,
-0.0125260474,
-0.0360947512,
-0.0176727474,
0.011997249,
-0.017869642,
-0.0186939295,
0.0266336463,
-0.0448849276,
0.0225770101,
-0.002117357,
-0.0094755255,
0.026867047,
-0.0249663144,
-0.0006985541,
0.0431372784,
-0.0016039911,
0.0287476517,
-0.0384950191,
0.037700288,
-0.0212805085,
0.0111450013,
-0.0692289099,
-0.0219079666,
-0.0716527775,
-0.032293465,
-0.0715659708,
0.0553334318,
-0.0481492169,
0.0032261645,
-0.0216392484,
0.0207258929,
-0.0131049529,
0.0014876592,
-0.0520136133,
0.0301081557,
-0.0222906824,
0.0030132311,
-0.0829181671,
0.0224119443,
-0.0125318216,
-0.0089633642,
0.0151549736,
-0.0958658606,
-0.0002365768,
0.0064127897,
-0.0101642851,
-0.0339124836,
-0.0183884148,
0.0064857127,
-0.0035686039,
0.001859286,
-0.0321427062,
-0.0789987743,
-0.0143351434,
-0.0195720792,
-0.0320483781,
-0.1020690054,
0.0189844258,
0.05866234,
-0.0090785697,
-0.0269362666,
0.0195236672,
0.0489634275,
-0.0424679033,
0.0339652784,
-0.0412814468,
0.011638415,
0.0450738221,
0.0162658524,
0.0614213347,
0.0570555739,
-0.0058075874,
0.0160966944,
0.0458453819,
0.0146228652,
-0.0124222133,
0.0027305675,
-0.0005569046,
0.0034711172,
-0.027778808,
0.0277835559,
0.0650252476,
0.0300777406,
0.0161759071,
0.0306357127,
-0.0250455793,
0.0016510354,
-0.0004919584,
-0.0116238762,
0.0456939153,
0.0078356368,
0.0662616044,
0.0074880761,
0.0130536463,
0.0109563405,
-0.0066759111,
0.0081412354,
-0.0273594037,
0.0173060782,
-0.003914197,
0.0251673572,
-0.0157261416,
-0.0302551631,
-0.0066768359,
0.0295353811,
-0.0103273056,
0.0164106525,
0.0454594158,
0.0364917032,
0.008559945,
0.1331607848,
0.0375189297,
-0.0759645626,
0.0180792976,
-0.0442165844,
0.001820725,
0.0481969789,
0.046580229,
-0.0475384928,
-0.0450837128,
0.017649183,
0.0147701846,
0.0413279869,
0.0731086731,
-0.0127979964,
-0.0502808839,
-0.0290025864,
0.0138938203,
-0.0018655574,
0.006191365,
0.0119804675,
0.0012884511,
-0.0041633467,
0.0359488651,
0.0132145528,
-0.0328658894,
0.0299710706,
-0.0018991266,
-0.0019172824,
-0.0318275765,
0.0034413801,
-0.0093127424,
0.0270752832,
-0.0205019116,
0.0448392257,
0.0237293616,
-0.0096747698,
-0.0333025977,
0.0168115776,
-0.0282391179,
-0.0096221119,
0.0276485104,
0.0133150443,
-0.0002343355,
-0.0172849931,
-0.0261493344,
-0.0357418358,
0.0192174707,
-0.0564302579,
0.0363750458,
-0.0482467264,
-0.0008261973,
0.0095738471,
-0.042766884,
-0.0615454987,
0.064301379,
0.0249969531,
0.0600211844,
0.0355409831,
0.0058126156,
0.0427554287,
-0.069262974,
0.0069050854,
0.0283235013,
-0.0265522674,
0.0164756496,
0.1006104723,
-0.0306677464,
-0.0340442285,
0.0080153178,
-0.0860875696,
-0.0045167543,
-0.018245887,
-0.0167628247,
0.0359836631,
0.0168939028,
-0.0193900149,
-0.0093780831,
0.008153568,
-0.0191506203,
0.0274841692,
0.0179609004,
0.0272503737,
0.0143913524,
-0.0328637213,
-0.0229216088,
0.0010550794,
-0.0356528834,
0.0485416465,
0.0169404168,
-0.0288331918,
-0.0419011153,
0.0413899384,
-0.0610918924,
0.016035663,
-0.0096329888,
0.0078136018,
0.0134126628,
-0.0311696529,
-0.0356410891,
-0.0023812787,
0.0224246625,
0.0352150314,
0.0411483794,
-0.0339548104,
-0.0650459826,
0.0226700455,
-0.0483306274,
-0.0492222868,
-0.012574465,
-0.0498688519,
0.013117047,
0.0126413517,
0.0325914286,
-0.0118214479,
-0.0267492216,
0.0312582813,
-0.0508995913,
-0.014447392,
-0.0523991548,
-0.0159974098,
0.0030695475,
0.0753347203,
-0.0179926045,
-0.0131444447,
0.0468930304,
-0.0310028624,
0.000258488,
-0.0399393626,
0.0255438183,
-0.0285410117,
0.0648200214,
0.0035141122,
0.0490208492,
-0.0165656786,
-0.0251615644,
-0.0556393825,
-0.0017539419,
0.0569407791,
-0.0581224114,
0.0676234886,
-0.0388681106,
0.0439834893,
0.0098976158,
-0.0222615432,
-0.0770804062,
-0.0438907929,
0.0017947934,
-0.001233557,
-0.0538097359,
0.0100595169,
-0.0539747514,
-0.0116692688,
0.0349308252,
-0.009779592,
0.0087295603,
-0.0176784862,
-0.0116940802,
0.0557594448,
0.0332578868,
0.0316643827,
0.0191465449,
0.0270901602,
0.0437500514,
0.0585145205,
-0.0065782689,
0.0231309701,
-0.0161238629,
-0.0334649235,
0.0222877264,
-0.0454650894,
-0.0375075005,
0.0108446646,
0.0187323075,
-0.0657976568,
-0.032765083,
0.1163713858,
0.0833338276,
0.0330461748,
-0.0242690854,
-0.0290165506,
0.0029846255,
0.0568202063,
0.0447769351,
-0.0658058822,
-0.0099295741,
0.0132414829,
-0.004507774,
-0.0312087722,
-0.026894711,
0.0041092047,
-0.1432477385,
0.0563917719,
-0.0040724636,
0.0284944642,
-0.0339963064,
-0.0578424074,
-0.0108727077,
0.0346340053,
-0.0097722113,
0.0606067106,
-0.0231441017,
0.0074014557,
0.0127754658,
0.0322758369,
-0.0091270953,
0.0013784377,
-0.0097808605,
0.0271255914,
0.0249116085,
0.0333306529,
-0.0494179279,
-0.0418776982,
-0.0366761088,
-0.0552437156,
0.0148393288,
-0.0244050603,
0.0313488021,
0.0152242677,
-0.0034714828,
-0.040049959,
-0.0132120652,
0.0363912508,
-0.0564243831,
-0.0073840665,
0.0572557598,
-0.0434283204,
0.0059948158,
-0.0237172954,
0.0106007718,
-0.01687718,
0.0709452182,
0.0212592091,
0.0249433909,
0.0132701155,
-0.0482212268,
-0.0147887943,
-0.0013107134,
-0.0353855751,
0.0050307726,
0.0008549822,
0.0361668095,
-0.0561586134,
-0.0119867567,
0.0212010983,
0.0116175124,
-0.0140770497,
0.000144794,
0.0066059614,
-0.0087867463,
-0.0958676934,
0.0402743518,
-0.0452817865,
0.0179626346,
-0.0154791065,
-0.0038537998,
0.0591383055,
-0.0345720574,
-0.0339742973,
0.0185007323,
0.0423603766,
-0.0615776554,
0.0248732232,
0.0195313524,
0.0177480578,
0.0191696566,
-0.0083319033,
-0.0211250819,
0.0381789804,
0.0599539019,
-0.0883515552,
-0.0096379798,
-0.002769581,
-0.038147945,
-0.0290783122,
0.0182577316,
-0.0558091886,
0.0084622698,
-0.0274756774,
0.0679879338,
0.0186940711,
-0.0271603428,
0.0793918371,
0.045485612,
0.0351953879,
-0.0031250559,
0.0289649665,
-0.0297186598,
0.0014490541,
-0.057625588,
-0.0438253433,
0.0158249047,
0.0152454451,
0.0006463205,
-0.025375396,
0.0264571868,
-0.0106634116,
-0.0394977666,
0.0436181277,
0.0256230794,
-0.0156140886,
-0.0547576584,
0.0351005979,
0.0318770595,
0.0132599948,
-0.0093517452,
0.0280618854,
0.0075883213,
0.0612408631,
-0.0606772825,
0.0800829753,
0.0367059186,
-0.0094887884,
-0.0454357527,
0.0021878448,
-0.0306193121,
-0.0241717249,
-0.025074793,
0.045961,
0.0345911272,
-0.0302053187,
0.0189705789,
-0.0364470147,
-0.0409737118,
-0.0085078757,
-0.0075400174,
0.0610257834,
-0.0291992798,
0.0455844998,
0.0409784764,
-0.0154413208,
-0.0155378105,
0.0497577563,
-0.0184605867,
0.0363797024,
0.0041201878,
-0.0523807853,
-0.0105487341,
-0.0391895734,
-0.016539257,
0.0150313172,
-0.0385860801,
-0.0006277112,
-0.1033246294,
-0.0559222698,
0.0390867442,
0.0268614255,
-0.0144612007,
-0.0108545218,
0.0467425287,
0.0666827634,
0.0489509031,
-0.023920916,
-0.0565364771,
0.0374097191,
-0.0748663917,
0.0049602473,
-0.0248034038,
-6.016596653e-33,
-0.072648108,
-0.027134994,
0.0251800064,
0.0280719884,
-0.016256731,
-0.0155682266,
-0.0212742276,
-0.0020540988,
-0.0177329294,
0.0263133552,
0.0190568138,
-0.0035003189,
0.0109053338,
0.0217354558,
-0.0147161279,
-0.0252507254,
0.0267946608,
0.0294457506,
-0.0213525668,
0.0101176621,
0.0595878027,
-0.0100101149,
0.0192737468,
-0.0366330035,
0.016640529,
-0.0254548714,
0.0389267989,
0.0394273736,
0.0087800371,
0.0504362732,
0.0065465448,
0.0844924524,
0.0324281007,
-0.050232105,
0.0090255635,
0.0200469941,
-0.05588907,
-0.0464606881,
0.0608657375,
-0.0146719115,
-0.0046624788,
-0.0102929128,
-0.0091353487,
-0.0019948406,
-0.0557024814,
0.024079768,
0.0494023263,
-0.006728732,
-0.0016403932,
0.0250607599,
-0.0689382032,
-0.0027479129,
0.0267977268,
0.0104000634,
-0.0097809806,
0.0183900911,
0.0138685536,
0.0042602625,
-0.0516489223,
0.0109516717,
-0.0353384279,
0.062006399,
0.033883702,
0.0413908921,
-0.0051417183,
0.0404619388,
0.0073363567,
0.0032653955,
-0.0580457486,
0.0306212921,
0.0081738066,
0.0307328869,
0.0323984288,
0.0868097544,
0.0032437532,
-0.0242938213,
-0.0683482066,
0.0405944623,
-0.0436564013,
0.0951925367,
0.0180692673,
-0.0228724256,
-0.0251363926,
-0.0136700282,
-0.1030312032,
0.0546886623,
-0.0519974791,
-0.008136089,
0.0357235819,
-0.0096748676,
-0.0234771483,
-0.0368907526,
0.0119203683,
-0.0088633243,
-0.0191565063,
-0.0227241945,
-0.0302224141,
-0.0054214387,
-0.0298569929,
0.0464675836,
0.0169462878,
-0.0123819951,
0.0118119176,
-0.0123055642,
-0.000489336,
0.0028192571,
-0.0003133326,
0.0275778696,
-0.034256909,
0.0277070198,
-0.0358160101,
0.0002615663,
-0.0525630377,
-0.0659360811,
0.0156163946,
0.0547238216,
-0.0210307073,
0.0219874233,
0.0215113759,
0.0238782261,
-0.0422153473,
-0.0358304642,
0.029375175,
0.0152974008,
-0.0376261584,
0.0247720722,
-0.0331942812,
0.0300077256,
0.0432595089,
-0.0391636379,
-0.018940879,
-0.0098548047,
2.739e-7,
0.0547437519,
0.0455807671,
0.0232180785,
0.0348769799,
-0.0194698386,
0.014946145,
0.0061728279,
0.0130378939,
0.055195421,
-0.0393284708,
-0.0278678089,
0.0110772708,
-0.0004030413,
0.0326610655,
-0.0738928169,
0.0424383543,
-0.0181854293,
-0.022884097,
-0.03969758,
0.0154030062,
0.0467332602,
0.0567177907,
-0.0077136047,
0.0060006706,
-0.0112278406,
-0.0741914809,
0.0458441861,
0.0071296841,
-0.0530743077,
0.0346491411,
0.0337254144,
0.0501779094,
0.0377171449,
-0.0163090806,
-0.0030755124,
0.0157871488,
0.0072330916,
-0.0108991871,
-0.0202743094,
-0.0008792356,
-0.0503118336,
-0.0502680875,
0.0065297745,
-0.0457796752,
0.0367582254,
-0.0389125906,
0.0197150204,
-0.0263067018,
-0.0394919664,
0.0326888561,
-0.0190175567,
-0.0059668007,
-0.0248385165,
0.0123748202,
0.0136312628,
0.0248372629,
-0.0066085295,
-0.0547056459,
-0.0395024121,
0.0075168945,
-0.0306391902,
-0.0542447455,
0.0093665496,
-0.0172746889,
-0.0029926137,
-0.020218024,
0.0165178068,
2.664468249e-34,
0.0190081112,
0.0678296834,
0.0045017074,
-0.0322683342,
0.0478564799,
-0.0110003762,
-0.0615078248,
0.0201501958,
0.017109843,
-0.0787448958,
-0.0033242204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16152v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16152v1 | Towards Region-aware Bias Evaluation Metrics | 2024-06-23T16:26:27 | 2024-06-23T16:26:27 | Angana Borah, Aparna Garimella, Rada Mihalcea | cs.CL | cs.CL | When exposed to human-generated data, language models are known to learn and
amplify societal biases. While previous works introduced benchmarks that can be
used to assess the bias in these models, they rely on assumptions that may not
be universally true. For instance, a gender bias dimension commonly used by
these metrics is that of family--career, but this may not be the only common
bias in certain regions of the world. In this paper, we identify topical
differences in gender bias across different regions and propose a region-aware
bottom-up approach for bias assessment. Our proposed approach uses
gender-aligned topics for a given region and identifies gender bias dimensions
in the form of topic pairs that are likely to capture gender societal biases.
Several of our proposed bias topic pairs are on par with human perception of
gender biases in these regions in comparison to the existing ones, and we also
identify new pairs that are more aligned than the existing ones. In addition,
we use our region-aware bias topic pairs in a Word Embedding Association Test
(WEAT)-based evaluation metric to test for gender biases across different
regions in different data domains. We also find that LLMs have a higher
alignment to bias pairs for highly-represented regions showing the importance
of region-aware bias evaluation metric. | [
0.0228207894,
0.0752797425,
-0.0292404108,
0.0081192423,
-0.0097635044,
0.0199854411,
0.0400765762,
-0.0239294227,
0.0329456665,
-0.0619380027,
-0.0121946679,
-0.0375792235,
0.0437780768,
-0.0160562955,
0.0269284118,
-0.0443598069,
0.0364079289,
0.0622717813,
0.0475049354,
-0.0352113582,
0.0175699443,
0.0271816943,
0.0113510927,
0.0609565005,
0.0242009033,
-0.0083048455,
0.0818683729,
-0.0241505951,
0.0121955695,
-0.007331837,
0.0746911243,
0.0418735556,
-0.0213631298,
-0.013434628,
0.00000191,
-0.0693856552,
0.0079571288,
0.0082848594,
0.042317573,
0.0099434806,
0.0729671493,
-0.0181841087,
-0.0317598507,
0.045722831,
-0.0200072527,
-0.0298578423,
0.0151886633,
-0.0172413494,
0.0254203659,
0.0246451795,
-0.020876918,
0.0216183327,
-0.064094238,
-0.0209171586,
-0.0225932356,
0.0073920521,
0.0475996695,
-0.0373080857,
-0.0617970526,
-0.0263355449,
-0.0404493324,
-0.0183420442,
-0.0283825211,
0.0045964033,
0.0082480256,
0.016151689,
-0.0405084938,
-0.022534268,
0.0260458142,
0.0209413022,
0.0328137651,
-0.0047868798,
0.0113333389,
-0.0075239236,
0.0133705148,
0.0469774082,
-0.0314049572,
0.0142457457,
0.0092174569,
-0.0076374859,
0.0229029134,
-0.0162848495,
0.0130904736,
0.0663047805,
-0.0122493701,
0.0948063731,
0.0303090606,
-0.0438426547,
-0.00990743,
0.0026715745,
0.0416916721,
-0.0430536531,
0.0103910025,
-0.0379275344,
0.0110951988,
0.0018965194,
0.007891234,
0.0070663686,
0.0343769602,
-0.0418492109,
-0.0334088616,
0.0175978411,
-0.0141857984,
0.0005031237,
0.002382694,
0.0208852645,
0.0241998043,
0.0107537527,
-0.0201789867,
-0.0468108244,
-0.0043699741,
0.0119891828,
0.0264490675,
-0.0581934676,
0.0158875547,
0.0453586765,
-0.0399842821,
-0.0180564616,
-0.0922415406,
0.006999386,
0.0066836318,
0.0149433967,
0.0097620888,
-0.0069416212,
-0.0186661705,
0.0333867818,
-0.071293734,
0.0324747674,
-0.0621311143,
-0.0481028706,
0.017284682,
0.0106904898,
0.0198115427,
0.0010104233,
-0.0098329,
-0.0080679851,
0.0427724011,
-0.0023532477,
-0.0212977156,
0.0096835243,
-0.0514627881,
-0.0364366509,
0.0083707655,
-0.0472373702,
0.0058745188,
0.0282988157,
0.0194359291,
-0.0182898026,
-0.0253038816,
0.0218618847,
-0.0447309129,
-0.0053209681,
0.0525430776,
0.0179344714,
0.0996082872,
0.0157822408,
-0.0040712738,
0.1127670929,
0.0310406387,
0.0159690045,
0.0655265674,
0.0023641158,
-0.0349644609,
0.0333351903,
0.03838953,
0.0522372238,
-0.0611217655,
0.023887245,
-0.0259209797,
0.0207604207,
0.0845445618,
-0.0068878508,
0.0028565866,
-0.0007966101,
0.0115234489,
0.0795155615,
0.0436495915,
0.0316564217,
0.0074401805,
0.0429946594,
-0.0300942995,
-0.0056302319,
-0.0466079153,
-0.0369538106,
-0.0178514849,
-0.03856273,
0.0234592129,
0.030084243,
-0.0173651837,
-0.0122673502,
-0.0288331751,
0.0230248831,
0.0135295372,
-0.0144119533,
0.0247061122,
0.0180785246,
0.0360937975,
0.0563551486,
0.0534691736,
-0.0404197499,
0.0176197812,
-0.0133525804,
0.0284600463,
0.0290956404,
-0.0079201395,
-0.0154823605,
-0.0006631661,
-0.0059087384,
-0.0198804494,
0.0230121966,
0.0418449491,
0.000605877,
-0.0088037355,
-0.0395172648,
-0.0317545459,
0.0522369407,
0.0515090749,
0.008781624,
0.0678656846,
0.0316492468,
0.006141468,
-0.0668882206,
-0.0058581261,
0.016774511,
-0.0011094543,
0.0084525011,
0.0232704245,
0.0082302801,
0.014579515,
0.0113614611,
-0.0376631357,
0.0060018017,
-0.0179073513,
-0.0163368955,
0.0087534925,
0.0155349663,
-0.04222681,
0.0184173286,
-0.0153745031,
-0.0807465464,
-0.0429680124,
0.0078571467,
-0.0023490491,
0.0064302851,
0.0620644465,
-0.0026757896,
0.0170075558,
-0.0131235169,
-0.0098939165,
-0.0531359501,
0.0274086837,
-0.0130159426,
0.039162416,
-0.0569685884,
0.0006758927,
0.0086868489,
-0.0131396158,
0.0224355459,
-0.0270151962,
-0.0268237963,
-0.0182454828,
-0.0031124104,
-0.022008907,
0.0369255468,
-0.0422162749,
-0.0242409091,
-0.0661854371,
-0.090927206,
-0.0062394794,
-0.0236187894,
-0.0030388723,
0.0076280409,
-0.004320364,
-0.0477522239,
-0.0073933308,
-0.0106584746,
-0.0175841339,
-0.0006114583,
0.0602529123,
0.0190116391,
-0.0555634648,
0.0312074553,
-0.0468383208,
-0.02631809,
-0.0603478551,
0.0551926531,
0.0061410652,
-0.0070333574,
-0.051939778,
-0.0031819157,
-0.0260724388,
-0.0189471561,
-0.0084806057,
-0.012287138,
0.0028435688,
0.0488303341,
0.0428962,
0.0498439856,
0.0322632641,
-0.0021341443,
0.0635535195,
-0.0059500239,
-0.0459284298,
-0.0444614477,
0.0163260028,
0.0545732155,
0.0115735084,
-0.095702,
-0.0125834448,
0.0366495699,
0.026352087,
-0.0185844507,
-0.0310372654,
0.0611366592,
-0.0668265298,
-0.0146708339,
-0.016338855,
-0.0192224421,
0.002444328,
0.037917342,
-0.0390903316,
-0.0701060742,
-0.0036475861,
0.0105452519,
0.0392310619,
-0.0120702004,
-0.0164311621,
-0.0660617352,
0.0323595256,
-0.0152695933,
0.0217250939,
-0.0099199973,
-0.0314761102,
-0.0601259843,
-0.0511474013,
0.0216735825,
-0.0233234726,
0.0325302668,
-0.0168121159,
-0.0125205619,
0.0126430457,
-0.0329685248,
-0.0228963029,
-0.0313365087,
-0.0080253333,
0.0138246967,
0.0324363336,
-0.0351668671,
-0.0004550152,
0.0133127458,
-0.0146262348,
-0.007168849,
-0.0147143276,
0.0086798398,
0.0154081527,
0.0000456274,
0.057777591,
0.0205726512,
-0.0049837101,
0.007206595,
-0.0242287498,
-0.0066468753,
0.0132381003,
0.0506662875,
0.0012047528,
0.0194742065,
0.0449578986,
-0.0569081642,
-0.0079091871,
-0.0215415247,
0.0215772875,
-0.0234610792,
0.015168136,
0.0916383862,
0.0232973918,
-0.087534003,
0.0015441601,
-0.0320026316,
0.0423131995,
0.0479315892,
0.020046873,
-0.0712965131,
0.0328982696,
0.0187876262,
-0.0122612696,
-0.0238177069,
-0.0333761536,
-0.0354989171,
-0.1094273031,
0.0067627504,
0.0042121536,
-0.0132280756,
-0.0289525762,
-0.0428897105,
0.0210462864,
-0.019689437,
0.03683725,
-0.0133311991,
-0.0104365246,
0.0016781021,
0.0041650971,
-0.1042072773,
-0.0679019168,
0.0365742482,
-0.0685748234,
0.0522376299,
0.000842027,
0.0652604029,
-0.0264026113,
-0.0100468313,
0.0017157877,
0.0047090743,
-0.0252438709,
-0.0200148989,
0.0142978663,
-0.0632557273,
-0.0217855219,
-0.0389368758,
0.0139874807,
0.0631215572,
0.0178345628,
0.0037117761,
0.0284375083,
0.0254220944,
0.0100260945,
-0.0555130728,
0.0052094823,
-0.0026599602,
0.0771616548,
0.0140420115,
-0.0513272099,
0.0135137131,
-0.0322621427,
0.0169604179,
0.0720257089,
-0.0490186736,
-0.0059606158,
0.0152970133,
-0.0200969931,
-0.0229509696,
-0.0574675165,
0.0319178775,
-0.0076095439,
0.0064899595,
-0.0424007289,
0.0222473312,
-0.0195988175,
-0.0599997491,
0.0303636137,
-0.0121338554,
0.0107663209,
0.0407270528,
-0.0183199551,
-0.0125723137,
-0.0211761128,
-0.0419190563,
0.0112209758,
-0.0412099212,
-0.0256665535,
0.0628728494,
-0.0243948791,
0.0091735953,
0.0363431387,
-0.0241118483,
-0.0698926151,
0.0690645203,
0.0190906581,
-0.039089296,
0.0241905097,
0.0153464815,
0.014285163,
0.0199246686,
0.0264434777,
-0.0508775301,
0.0338479467,
0.0082880938,
0.0093568824,
-0.0091379136,
-0.0476616509,
-0.010177156,
-0.0218268298,
0.0458383523,
-0.046037104,
0.0134337787,
-0.0696583614,
-0.0417775214,
-0.0121626891,
-0.0385106653,
0.0102416286,
-0.0401881821,
0.0509197451,
-0.0053714179,
-0.038085375,
-0.0073252609,
-0.0485784635,
0.0020649466,
-0.0198758952,
0.0487094186,
0.0047624991,
0.0773846135,
-0.0401494354,
-0.0018090977,
0.0012357888,
-0.027186539,
-0.0441249274,
0.0331812277,
0.0021776091,
0.024070546,
-0.0098477015,
0.0128136678,
-0.0178403128,
0.0092638088,
-0.036322277,
0.0258240104,
-0.0081571704,
0.013701994,
0.0156956092,
-0.0758088753,
0.0350791626,
0.0211068522,
0.0044590156,
0.0063805925,
-0.0041489038,
-0.025709128,
-0.0310551357,
0.0294178128,
0.0000133917,
-0.007550722,
0.0250515528,
0.0255873688,
0.0632603914,
0.0297570024,
-0.0189845059,
-0.0476039127,
-0.0140358927,
-0.0194626115,
0.0582956634,
-0.0210778005,
-0.0322829373,
-0.0122355036,
-0.117361024,
-0.0263425484,
-0.0016916135,
-0.0196613595,
0.0046158126,
-0.0094521474,
-0.0034755773,
0.0733359233,
-0.0499716215,
-0.0389946923,
-0.0402765423,
-0.0247613639,
-0.0296105985,
-0.0133913867,
-0.0214472972,
-6.094268912e-33,
-0.0329853073,
-0.0558074526,
-0.0025021594,
-0.0552351363,
-0.0178130623,
0.0164215527,
0.0097732078,
0.0123147815,
-0.013644998,
0.0339852907,
0.0013236884,
0.0387645215,
0.011473028,
-0.0171872694,
0.0134037929,
0.0042282101,
0.0237348657,
0.0265771337,
-0.0151826441,
-0.0235790443,
-0.0214551948,
0.0096191233,
0.0439456291,
-0.0666612834,
0.1048434749,
0.0032198965,
-0.0138439229,
-0.0052409824,
0.0169597343,
0.0212029088,
-0.0291003492,
0.0723479316,
0.0253730752,
-0.029374022,
0.016938258,
0.056818556,
-0.0438753851,
-0.0670972764,
0.0252043027,
0.0038086444,
0.0501317643,
0.0008881739,
0.0251096934,
0.0457943231,
-0.0619136207,
-0.0180058796,
0.0765285343,
0.0255617108,
0.0380368344,
0.0494057871,
-0.0365522951,
0.0406504236,
-0.0289327353,
0.0426035225,
0.0074901693,
0.0101942774,
0.0245226827,
0.0356423371,
-0.0469391681,
0.0344680846,
0.0159830395,
0.0249507222,
0.0334573872,
-0.0103318524,
0.0236650184,
0.0738849491,
0.0608799644,
0.0405614898,
-0.0173407476,
-0.086591199,
0.0713710859,
-0.0270080809,
0.0008751954,
0.0744949654,
0.0118047297,
0.0081165638,
-0.0431015752,
-0.0335993357,
0.0421633162,
0.0341929831,
0.0132484939,
-0.0291117039,
-0.08279524,
-0.0600537285,
-0.0400771648,
-0.0674286485,
-0.0191938281,
-0.0027451904,
0.0380660594,
0.0151672736,
-0.0134339398,
0.00699864,
-0.019470688,
-0.0590786524,
-0.0011024855,
0.0323225893,
-0.0308787394,
-0.0600663014,
0.0475298651,
0.0282677058,
-0.0632767305,
0.009807487,
-0.0096595343,
0.054296311,
0.0220678449,
0.0081721358,
-0.0270457603,
0.0069817821,
-0.1030713245,
-0.0221132357,
-0.0145584848,
-0.0413642786,
-0.0396187939,
0.0187640414,
0.036754366,
0.0366601013,
0.0000455165,
0.0027750216,
0.0667310134,
0.0652491227,
0.0056549334,
-0.0149103571,
-0.0354297087,
0.0484037325,
-0.0014242842,
-0.0108857201,
0.0253900457,
0.0241395049,
0.0481154546,
-0.0316430926,
-0.0050139958,
-0.0449772924,
2.458e-7,
0.0203356873,
0.1058337167,
-0.0161069911,
0.0279731806,
0.0231640097,
0.0129886428,
0.01595602,
0.0138013745,
0.0570342541,
0.0294519104,
-0.0132810567,
-0.000242885,
0.0014449664,
0.0380290374,
-0.0744163767,
0.0564060695,
-0.0948235318,
0.0411467589,
0.0162172262,
0.0042037168,
-0.017076565,
0.0456470102,
0.0419037715,
0.0002665131,
-0.045988176,
-0.0189691633,
0.0272403583,
-0.0417215489,
-0.0045983219,
0.0456434116,
0.0000724295,
0.0048541198,
0.044607874,
0.0184109788,
0.0121775297,
0.0577687547,
0.0130423745,
0.0268888231,
-0.0115783308,
0.0316062868,
-0.0279786363,
-0.0109110475,
-0.0252877064,
-0.1004864722,
0.0425150394,
0.0117231198,
-0.0337440856,
-0.0934899747,
-0.0146526815,
0.0213584471,
0.0926349908,
-0.0173910707,
-0.0203681476,
-0.0252700727,
0.0337610804,
0.0073412093,
-0.0161219705,
-0.0383669399,
-0.0385474637,
-0.0291726049,
-0.0062589189,
-0.053952679,
0.0069267238,
0.057936687,
0.0357775539,
-0.0347267613,
0.0424233861,
1.970852196e-34,
0.0063768388,
0.022718925,
0.0062930351,
-0.0223262906,
0.0350228846,
0.0023160197,
-0.0050732945,
-0.008427362,
0.0457274467,
-0.0156009784,
0.0315520354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02518v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02518v1 | INDICT: Code Generation with Internal Dialogues of Critiques for Both Security and Helpfulness | 2024-06-23T15:55:07 | 2024-06-23T15:55:07 | Hung Le, Yingbo Zhou, Caiming Xiong, Silvio Savarese, Doyen Sahoo | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.MA, cs.PL | Large language models (LLMs) for code are typically trained to align with
natural language instructions to closely follow their intentions and
requirements. However, in many practical scenarios, it becomes increasingly
challenging for these models to navigate the intricate boundary between
helpfulness and safety, especially against highly complex yet potentially
malicious instructions. In this work, we introduce INDICT: a new framework that
empowers LLMs with Internal Dialogues of Critiques for both safety and
helpfulness guidance. The internal dialogue is a dual cooperative system
between a safety-driven critic and a helpfulness-driven critic. Each critic
provides analysis against the given task and corresponding generated response,
equipped with external knowledge queried through relevant code snippets and
tools like web search and code interpreter. We engage the dual critic system in
both code generation stage as well as code execution stage, providing
preemptive and post-hoc guidance respectively to LLMs. We evaluated INDICT on 8
diverse tasks across 8 programming languages from 5 benchmarks, using LLMs from
7B to 70B parameters. We observed that our approach can provide an advanced
level of critiques of both safety and helpfulness analysis, significantly
improving the quality of output codes ($+10\%$ absolute improvements in all
models). | [
0.0196151827,
0.0735230297,
-0.016840348,
0.041875653,
-0.0228913706,
-0.0099512702,
-0.0429296829,
-0.0438439101,
0.0022267769,
-0.0048474101,
-0.0204178244,
-0.0101946602,
-0.0189728234,
0.022603415,
0.0678889453,
0.0111253336,
0.0442271158,
-0.0684085339,
0.0095621822,
0.0234383401,
0.0260898173,
0.0087013468,
-0.0035550196,
0.0527309068,
0.028409211,
-0.0154790515,
-0.0415921733,
0.0399907269,
0.0156998411,
-0.046362333,
0.0369130038,
0.0362271592,
0.002236973,
0.0286698248,
0.0000024242,
-0.0331880748,
-0.0019495349,
0.0212525614,
0.0026510668,
0.0322278887,
-0.00341407,
-0.0373397358,
-0.0064288718,
0.0253980439,
-0.0355299897,
-0.0006211448,
0.0661200285,
0.0193559453,
0.1142933965,
0.0887768343,
0.0208896492,
0.0161795635,
0.0197047126,
0.0109577086,
0.013547211,
-0.0432138406,
-0.0050685676,
0.0099862861,
-0.0073159691,
0.0443403572,
0.0106548239,
-0.0097129904,
0.0265682489,
-0.0653105453,
0.0014417113,
-0.0029047157,
-0.0320622176,
-0.0272759236,
-0.0184188876,
0.0295470338,
-0.0455181003,
-0.0214812625,
0.0076318621,
-0.0259348396,
0.0028880329,
-0.0388361402,
-0.0078136418,
0.0176158678,
-0.0066596302,
-0.0119473692,
0.0138936015,
0.0077753426,
0.0332894698,
0.0061788862,
0.0241109245,
0.0330444723,
-0.0234089512,
-0.0297124293,
0.0007387882,
-0.0168937799,
-0.0046100137,
-0.0669913441,
-0.0264407825,
0.0674294084,
-0.025166817,
0.0031585156,
-0.0332373641,
-0.0222886391,
0.046196878,
-0.0337944217,
0.0350980312,
0.0389590077,
-0.0214002598,
-0.0200514942,
-0.0204175711,
0.0417529121,
-0.002035212,
0.0504498743,
0.0013418391,
0.0394583791,
-0.0095692119,
-0.0151411444,
-0.0214550551,
0.0336271487,
0.0120740039,
0.053155899,
-0.0304659083,
0.0539152138,
-0.0465260334,
0.0873789042,
-0.0305660032,
-0.0008517069,
-0.0063231024,
0.0157135278,
-0.002850343,
-0.0371461995,
-0.0307512544,
-0.0419992805,
-0.0059827422,
-0.044200711,
-0.0234145764,
0.0245300382,
-0.06765984,
-0.0115633504,
-0.0105262529,
0.1437602788,
0.0164497755,
0.0397406667,
-0.0297631472,
-0.074567385,
-0.0236766282,
-0.0280420147,
0.0047392682,
-0.0797979012,
-0.0380355418,
-0.0127005279,
-0.0252654664,
-0.0929850787,
0.0238324385,
0.0052158684,
0.0012875096,
0.0583901256,
-0.0522633083,
-0.0190957896,
-0.0049599451,
0.042481754,
-0.0068917396,
0.0265181419,
0.0238236934,
0.0126254782,
0.0131834969,
-0.0360052884,
0.0561580546,
0.0051176413,
0.0065466524,
0.0142257912,
0.0047203661,
0.0361240022,
0.0140329758,
-0.018400861,
-0.000570288,
0.0657418743,
-0.0111817243,
-0.0103079509,
0.0333775803,
-0.0028338854,
-0.0274505969,
0.043109037,
0.0578764714,
0.0493003987,
-0.0289062448,
-0.014183308,
-0.0613469929,
0.0608699247,
-0.0386127345,
-0.0183878727,
0.0016539489,
0.0121047823,
0.0043452494,
-0.0433775522,
0.0156076988,
-0.0132261142,
0.0223490726,
0.0044263378,
-0.010034658,
0.0122728245,
-0.0182865169,
-0.0042821872,
0.0165697336,
-0.0476037748,
-0.0387492627,
-0.0621734858,
0.0452469289,
0.0888763592,
0.0328567624,
-0.0303919911,
-0.0628262386,
-0.0275893789,
-0.0310826842,
-0.0223017782,
0.0161864311,
-0.0064905011,
0.022630617,
-0.0643439814,
-0.0202461928,
-0.0529196672,
0.010894388,
0.002306394,
0.0185407232,
-0.0386464708,
0.0591200702,
0.0514349118,
-0.0672685727,
0.0412493162,
0.0318800695,
-0.0205493178,
0.0221514069,
-0.012849329,
0.0031141678,
-0.0022552577,
-0.0259146001,
0.0516256653,
0.0345021263,
0.0033456243,
-0.0263994671,
-0.0112567851,
-0.0518870316,
-0.0227643177,
0.00833668,
-0.0240163058,
0.009188964,
0.0279246513,
-0.0369299129,
-0.0007482059,
0.0774493068,
-0.0564625897,
-0.0325402878,
0.0027340059,
0.0181511603,
-0.0003649173,
-0.0399004631,
-0.0327193365,
0.0198328607,
0.0062231524,
-0.0097806547,
-0.025699228,
0.0648626983,
-0.0022465999,
-0.0177602749,
-0.0234948583,
-0.0257935859,
-0.0321088918,
0.0372079983,
0.0455811284,
0.0965184644,
-0.0019861415,
-0.0420142822,
-0.0618493706,
0.0125099141,
-0.0226699244,
0.0158546995,
0.0218101721,
0.0159372035,
-0.0036641262,
-0.0281299204,
-0.0157031175,
0.0045128451,
-0.0004568632,
-0.0020666658,
0.0307850875,
0.0147587415,
-0.0508235805,
-0.0185472611,
0.0055513927,
-0.0260654893,
0.0126122851,
-0.0050553018,
-0.0099744368,
-0.0642723739,
0.042086862,
-0.0201652758,
0.0069872821,
-0.0090239225,
-0.0528702512,
0.026832819,
-0.0139791016,
0.018307576,
0.0267986078,
0.0071975803,
0.0031510349,
0.0732383877,
0.0004012587,
-0.0711131617,
0.0175674669,
0.0499155819,
-0.0433339402,
0.0071942345,
-0.0069766543,
0.0408014208,
0.0674200729,
0.0095470827,
-0.0146184666,
-0.0410412401,
0.0652508959,
0.0082795387,
-0.0071715266,
0.0117714256,
-0.0836935863,
-0.0028407066,
0.0395476073,
-0.0285343546,
-0.0973405913,
0.0865214393,
-0.0305204876,
-0.0114624389,
-0.0157460067,
-0.0351739265,
-0.0330244638,
0.0694696903,
-0.0101243872,
0.0187565647,
0.0417224504,
-0.0283278916,
-0.0201108679,
-0.0095233284,
0.0265208799,
-0.0179644655,
0.0581453852,
-0.0790620074,
-0.0191984791,
-0.004243033,
-0.0596156977,
-0.0577491708,
-0.0492531881,
-0.0146767534,
-0.0234507937,
0.0185649246,
0.0043662824,
0.0461142063,
-0.0227668621,
0.0170199685,
0.0222066697,
0.0001149906,
-0.0331695229,
-0.0133641828,
-0.0634795502,
-0.0139387352,
-0.07958626,
-0.0227764864,
-0.017745195,
0.0373230949,
0.0551463552,
0.0286509078,
0.0332368761,
-0.0747807771,
-0.0189135782,
0.006025454,
0.0086486358,
-0.0120740207,
0.0590056367,
0.0852359235,
-0.0547932684,
-0.0610137619,
0.0686952025,
-0.0046213497,
-0.0390726514,
0.034107592,
-0.0346803255,
0.0119316112,
0.0354713351,
0.0366279744,
-0.0748446584,
-0.0300670993,
-0.0007166914,
0.0681401193,
-0.0197793301,
-0.0168889724,
-0.0188079737,
-0.098441422,
0.0303241536,
0.0240569208,
0.0132893352,
-0.0128319459,
-0.0062919348,
-0.0422409214,
0.0025401381,
-0.0339819305,
0.0256346334,
0.0105973938,
-0.0057553663,
0.0109527698,
-0.0425345078,
0.0198426582,
0.0304309893,
-0.0485911556,
0.0348970443,
0.1064495593,
-0.0142090684,
0.028352052,
0.0164422765,
0.0584025532,
0.005572929,
0.0113720968,
-0.0000486287,
0.0225535538,
-0.0019952552,
-0.0087045319,
-0.0081170816,
0.035362985,
-0.0342136696,
-0.0421484634,
0.0810992643,
0.0306434967,
-0.0351683237,
-0.0038820461,
-0.0394426137,
0.0374952517,
0.033555977,
0.0395040996,
0.038466882,
-0.0239668377,
-0.0134770665,
-0.0565758198,
-0.0259526428,
-0.0891168416,
-0.0320392959,
-0.0120909959,
0.0234630425,
-0.0197906103,
-0.0490108281,
-0.0127479676,
-0.0242155846,
0.0101881521,
0.0409186855,
-0.0777990371,
0.0109806079,
0.0117674572,
-0.0445695035,
-0.0000027973,
-0.0280494131,
0.0179448109,
0.006352528,
0.0156658925,
-0.0089857373,
-0.0011691577,
-0.0073367627,
0.047333993,
-0.0674109757,
-0.0702386647,
-0.0455377549,
0.1172784343,
0.0179649312,
0.0285064224,
-0.0607134029,
-0.0511498749,
-0.0204625186,
0.0218378939,
-0.0730944276,
-0.0391273573,
0.0357610174,
-0.0259088296,
0.0539009646,
-0.0105266022,
-0.0547519661,
-0.0196007006,
0.0499244817,
-0.0050728042,
-0.0241540875,
0.0002789978,
0.0506402999,
0.0283462908,
0.0208046194,
0.0011967487,
0.0373504981,
0.0158593096,
-0.0003720168,
-0.01271684,
-0.0610075854,
-0.0245353654,
0.0423485972,
0.0175013803,
-0.034442082,
0.0323493257,
0.0005510434,
-0.0152675631,
0.0485258624,
-0.0155141838,
0.0489006229,
0.0361615047,
0.0768253058,
0.0624758862,
0.0032471837,
-0.0438185595,
0.066612184,
-0.0043044877,
0.0121325282,
-0.0050252257,
0.034790758,
0.000645587,
0.0473805033,
0.0209601056,
0.0449947342,
-0.0488050915,
-0.0789470524,
-0.0039780722,
0.0198272672,
0.0121511919,
0.0565560125,
0.0149377212,
-0.0067070695,
0.0285597201,
-0.0421337485,
0.0671766922,
-0.0267181452,
-0.094028227,
0.0091735721,
0.0341186188,
-0.0055512073,
-0.0782328025,
0.0798066929,
-0.0339812115,
0.0167479087,
-0.0068403976,
-0.0278337561,
-0.0573030598,
-0.0204136446,
0.031257458,
0.0203819424,
-0.0268380828,
-0.0298969671,
-0.0179358162,
-0.0622642748,
-0.0334573202,
0.0329179615,
0.0500402749,
0.0166196488,
0.0261218976,
0.057012748,
0.0048719654,
-0.0336628668,
-0.0270274729,
0.0182634722,
-0.0054983576,
-0.0392185077,
-0.0577943549,
-5.866901856e-33,
-0.0189510994,
-0.0284106396,
-0.0108279921,
0.0181355979,
-0.0105214156,
-0.0245444179,
-0.0607559979,
0.0162743963,
0.0162834451,
-0.0071356087,
0.0332097448,
0.0340140127,
-0.0099268956,
-0.0118322074,
0.0491592251,
0.0022715598,
0.0290905293,
0.0225500036,
-0.0529919825,
0.0539143458,
-0.0069741034,
0.0019018776,
0.0055998666,
-0.0680025071,
0.0324224196,
-0.0235476922,
0.003450349,
0.0169855375,
-0.015676681,
0.0572782904,
0.0251684878,
0.0148361186,
0.0098735774,
-0.0048275418,
-0.0359532163,
-0.002881709,
0.0176019743,
-0.0286619216,
0.0064662085,
-0.0351118445,
-0.030887451,
-0.0941597,
0.0684760064,
-0.0149949845,
-0.0166230761,
0.0137195159,
-0.020941427,
0.0125761637,
0.0328801163,
-0.0488974266,
-0.051105421,
0.026506817,
-0.0755223557,
-0.0432971083,
-0.0362066813,
0.0260196477,
0.0117707849,
-0.0228212588,
0.0221667476,
0.0193940084,
0.0438863412,
0.0108136432,
0.0403543897,
-0.0067482539,
-0.0386221707,
0.0296590999,
-0.0165920574,
0.0028677415,
-0.0265278928,
-0.001082889,
0.0050415783,
0.0532876849,
0.0407994837,
0.0636881813,
0.0101459408,
-0.0196774267,
-0.0655328408,
0.0316174291,
-0.0070258295,
0.0534142032,
0.038895987,
0.0084340414,
-0.0510345437,
-0.010346151,
-0.0316544622,
0.0101807294,
-0.0192554332,
-0.0302460846,
0.040406134,
0.0087667936,
-0.0341095552,
-0.0174339656,
-0.0206253137,
-0.0296350643,
0.0646817759,
0.0210176893,
-0.0390657,
-0.0497741476,
-0.0376769975,
0.0081956834,
-0.0049740458,
-0.0211250745,
0.0057656378,
-0.0292360745,
0.0510707311,
0.0155871995,
0.0387401469,
0.0307852719,
-0.0625408441,
-0.0038032227,
-0.0543430597,
0.0621160865,
-0.0120272832,
0.0223454088,
0.0135658132,
0.0013588879,
-0.018472556,
0.0371712893,
-0.0037624163,
-0.025595,
-0.0449979343,
0.0135266483,
0.0235636923,
0.0288553927,
-0.0149716437,
-0.0150176734,
0.0036076969,
0.0070009609,
0.0103631513,
-0.036849197,
-0.0365658253,
0.0160800181,
3.119e-7,
0.0053762593,
0.0137422876,
0.0246576723,
0.0375962593,
0.0152077936,
0.0584216677,
-0.0271141157,
0.0510315634,
-0.0188138094,
-0.0051586432,
-0.0208178386,
0.0294275954,
0.0224934183,
0.055970218,
-0.0148138236,
0.0018651302,
-0.0533853285,
-0.0029507542,
-0.0552301146,
0.0106339315,
0.069909066,
0.0487101823,
-0.0192571096,
0.0057779578,
0.0074113272,
-0.0597371347,
0.0207276028,
0.0004801072,
0.0018217384,
0.0237202197,
-0.0052408348,
0.0292757526,
0.0091816075,
0.0223263931,
-0.0054980507,
-0.0275470708,
-0.0421589725,
0.0842150599,
0.0094968434,
0.0261687208,
-0.0025308814,
-0.0059836106,
0.0162268616,
-0.0600048639,
0.0250222851,
-0.0309110358,
-0.0130773075,
-0.0086620497,
0.0083063534,
-0.0190913025,
0.0217632595,
-0.0319720209,
-0.0069151297,
-0.0012865638,
-0.0049363961,
-0.0030070918,
0.0001618144,
-0.0287019666,
-0.0389317833,
-0.0072376011,
0.0149875376,
-0.0334239639,
-0.0363222547,
0.0296887383,
0.0066131079,
-0.0322142504,
0.0541178659,
2.855011751e-34,
0.0315134004,
-0.0483716987,
0.0187092219,
-0.0161836073,
0.0648144409,
0.0222330876,
-0.0406638309,
0.0315382592,
0.0305707622,
0.0448365584,
-0.0430620238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16144v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16144v1 | Chain-of-Probe: Examing the Necessity and Accuracy of CoT Step-by-Step | 2024-06-23T15:50:22 | 2024-06-23T15:50:22 | Zezhong Wang, Xingshan Zeng, Weiwen Liu, Yufei Wang, Liangyou Li, Yasheng Wang, Lifeng Shang, Xin Jiang, Qun Liu, Kam-Fai Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current research found the issue of Early Answering in large language models
(LLMs), where the models already have an answer before generating the
Chain-of-Thought (CoT). This phenomenon suggests a potential lack of necessary
dependency between the predicted answer and the reasoning process.
Consequently, two important questions arise: (1) Is CoT still necessary if the
model already has an answer? (2) Can the correctness of the answer serve as
valid evidence for the correctness of CoT? To address these questions, we
propose a method, namely Chain-of-Probe (CoP), to probe changes in the mind
during the model's reasoning. The probing results show that in a significant
number of question-answer cases, CoT appears to be unnecessary, and this
necessity correlates with the simplicity of the task, defined by reasoning
steps required. Furthermore, by analyzing patterns in mind change, we examine
the correctness of the model's reasoning. Our validation reveals that many
responses, although correct in their final answer, contain errors in their
reasoning process. To this end, we propose a strategic approach based on CoP to
prioritize answers with correct reasoning among multiple candidates, thereby
bolstering the reliability of the model's reasoning. | [
0.0816672593,
0.0508885793,
-0.0286876205,
0.0006303788,
-0.0593284257,
0.010554621,
-0.0094186515,
0.0039300714,
0.0044747246,
-0.0338575803,
-0.0021700414,
-0.0547886118,
0.0191152841,
0.0013521094,
0.0182471294,
-0.0355739668,
0.0304280482,
-0.0614331625,
0.0332476906,
-0.0237735584,
-0.0253038984,
0.0080214357,
-0.0200091898,
0.0267260373,
0.0295255352,
-0.0342527516,
-0.067577742,
-0.0383490175,
0.0139889522,
-0.0372138545,
-0.007860478,
0.0871251523,
0.0121143973,
0.030101236,
0.0000022001,
-0.0797899589,
-0.006426225,
-0.0258771703,
-0.0315846317,
0.0291802101,
-0.0252286643,
0.0623432137,
0.0197610073,
0.0632541105,
-0.0481498912,
0.027033871,
0.0258551892,
0.0027136651,
0.0301272757,
0.0242707785,
0.007277342,
-0.0110581517,
0.0073389378,
-0.0142482761,
0.0093924655,
-0.0614732727,
0.0344170183,
0.0117809316,
0.0144707561,
0.0267971046,
-0.038098257,
0.0150510008,
0.0038913938,
-0.0121000903,
-0.0067424774,
0.0194088835,
0.0432888381,
-0.0502248704,
-0.0159295574,
0.0430298112,
-0.0052537047,
-0.0278681871,
-0.0159331132,
-0.0271970183,
0.0231079217,
0.0405363441,
-0.0297508594,
0.0203804858,
0.0092584165,
-0.0033295278,
0.0419380181,
-0.0106953606,
-0.008302344,
0.0089538153,
-0.0441153049,
0.076957427,
-0.0113628348,
-0.0402414724,
0.0234740563,
0.0295213237,
0.0169211514,
-0.106165722,
-0.0217705127,
0.0426929332,
-0.0486995243,
0.0243216529,
0.0254609548,
0.017407896,
0.0042642094,
0.0025680477,
0.0472268835,
0.0493508242,
0.0010701667,
0.0281436201,
-0.0077081695,
0.0374561809,
-0.0213349871,
-0.0036212781,
-0.0534633063,
0.0098476689,
-0.0517238341,
-0.0372818559,
-0.003615828,
0.0446680821,
0.0139547987,
-0.0072689927,
-0.010103072,
0.0026312342,
-0.0048407987,
-0.0171737466,
-0.0248925388,
0.0462652184,
0.0533985496,
0.0085042883,
-0.0746670365,
0.0871077552,
-0.0460661575,
0.0507675633,
0.0290193558,
-0.0206455011,
-0.0048570265,
-0.0026730718,
0.014750029,
-0.0049180766,
0.0311070494,
0.0199713781,
-0.0590084791,
-0.0102484422,
-0.0088776303,
-0.050931707,
-0.0182590466,
-0.0782583579,
0.0374169238,
-0.0736023188,
-0.0103092063,
0.0342153646,
0.0075695291,
0.0068737706,
0.0148522323,
0.0282962825,
-0.043918021,
0.0367650352,
0.0344805345,
0.0493634641,
0.0049112905,
0.022691099,
-0.0129179442,
0.0651311055,
0.0244400688,
0.0329895653,
-0.000461509,
-0.0271654092,
0.0078377808,
0.0272887424,
0.0072039538,
-0.0047852588,
0.0143325813,
0.0379516259,
-0.0285167862,
0.0369054303,
0.0117315454,
0.030927198,
-0.0126504917,
0.0337159857,
0.0694500133,
0.0844063535,
-0.0128096966,
0.0008554856,
-0.0050624437,
-0.0035260336,
0.0413843095,
0.0361224413,
-0.0293146875,
0.0377247818,
-0.0272044931,
-0.0013821655,
0.0131520471,
0.0129383057,
-0.0234642178,
-0.0225582775,
-0.0140836705,
0.0428285487,
0.0175374337,
0.0628937632,
0.019045949,
-0.0117972558,
-0.0217703134,
0.0356421955,
-0.0088584209,
-0.0099914223,
-0.0058871345,
-0.085559383,
0.0465722866,
0.0025688384,
0.0282179248,
0.0159735698,
-0.0335775316,
-0.008832098,
-0.004961289,
0.0376183018,
0.0325451456,
-0.0281820185,
-0.0223164447,
-0.0010663734,
-0.019451024,
-0.0014114869,
-0.0045546293,
-0.0058909473,
0.0094904909,
0.0015910488,
-0.0207709,
-0.0085203284,
0.0382985361,
0.0021363697,
-0.0235750768,
-0.0069255582,
-0.0287645273,
0.0263028219,
0.0223209281,
0.00543145,
0.0150324721,
0.0459512882,
0.0054944139,
0.0168180242,
-0.0082839271,
-0.0167087559,
-0.0403405316,
0.0071949302,
0.0255976599,
-0.0291037187,
-0.0410506949,
0.0111513631,
-0.0071909558,
-0.0503116846,
0.0212911032,
-0.0317415558,
0.0241682455,
-0.0195365995,
0.0160588082,
-0.05827602,
-0.019820584,
-0.0436838605,
0.0645911172,
-0.0196925644,
0.0235721823,
0.0261655748,
-0.0182556976,
0.0167618673,
-0.0023160719,
-0.0275247414,
0.0145414816,
0.020770032,
-0.0073442236,
0.0449249223,
0.0102811949,
-0.0974734426,
-0.0297351964,
-0.0957988873,
-0.0263980012,
0.0060164873,
0.0124738794,
0.0199910067,
0.0080001671,
-0.0049561127,
-0.0079137562,
-0.0681767687,
0.0120642595,
0.0361115821,
0.0340013541,
0.0117157502,
-0.0183610544,
0.0047072028,
-0.020519007,
0.0072047254,
-0.0340415984,
0.0292980261,
-0.0014351333,
-0.0180064905,
-0.0634407997,
0.0522577837,
-0.0495866649,
0.0166448429,
0.0110105118,
-0.0447247699,
0.0452578068,
-0.0028128445,
0.0283351466,
0.0750584453,
0.028668195,
-0.0206710324,
0.0946992114,
-0.0301360395,
-0.0538464338,
0.0016687445,
-0.0059898444,
-0.0150190732,
-0.0207730252,
-0.0634069964,
-0.0094745811,
0.084033452,
0.0246781129,
-0.0189516284,
-0.0554859042,
0.0137008587,
-0.0390735641,
-0.040082965,
-0.0570337251,
-0.0334368348,
-0.0350109488,
0.1006832495,
0.0168512966,
-0.0299384724,
0.1021004692,
-0.0228325147,
0.0216097869,
-0.0527800918,
0.035680715,
-0.0244569164,
0.0795660242,
-0.0211635288,
-0.0004682844,
0.0230677221,
-0.013529921,
-0.093586266,
-0.0396848097,
0.0094490983,
-0.0432810225,
0.0520860888,
-0.0658276752,
-0.0151197296,
0.0081638331,
-0.0223017372,
-0.052017916,
-0.0218335148,
-0.0718889683,
-0.0110558383,
-0.0040688333,
-0.0170097966,
-0.0021976002,
-0.0283597559,
0.0517037772,
-0.0018505567,
-0.0268950276,
-0.0207798555,
0.0008843375,
0.0335325003,
0.0790643468,
0.0320198908,
0.0538021997,
-0.0229528956,
0.0482142121,
0.0691191778,
0.0311525539,
0.0366197601,
-0.0041131913,
-0.0073393015,
0.0386842117,
0.0173611231,
-0.0345043316,
0.0498951338,
0.0254890602,
-0.0152048348,
-0.0305790454,
0.0797381327,
0.0438815169,
-0.0503531322,
-0.0118194707,
-0.0456836969,
0.0378561728,
0.0210793149,
0.0336480029,
-0.0820678845,
-0.0124148512,
0.013119868,
0.0081216367,
-0.0480475798,
-0.0349582881,
-0.0243436452,
-0.1305058151,
0.0047805258,
-0.0266118385,
-0.0009912722,
0.0101652825,
-0.0524312221,
0.0295248628,
0.0442179441,
-0.0027273379,
0.0221523084,
0.0002225957,
0.0081754113,
0.025804298,
-0.0360756703,
-0.0270731859,
0.0657824129,
-0.0022476562,
0.0513549,
0.0428701043,
0.0229953621,
0.0113402633,
-0.0520492271,
0.0321158394,
-0.0206505992,
0.0257799868,
-0.015600061,
0.0072691101,
0.0365377925,
0.0263236426,
-0.0333322436,
0.0194415674,
-0.0075313258,
-0.0179406535,
0.0491970815,
0.1092779264,
-0.0314564742,
-0.0517321862,
-0.0168466419,
0.0154969813,
-0.0060615279,
0.067461893,
0.0489683263,
-0.0944745541,
-0.0042682961,
-0.0035359459,
-0.0197603218,
0.0131979324,
-0.0568633713,
0.0199552327,
0.0444658846,
0.0486006364,
-0.0469798334,
-0.0288758595,
0.0395613164,
0.0440000743,
0.0050172503,
0.03529194,
0.0130549893,
0.0322924145,
-0.0080062505,
0.0215271991,
-0.0180704594,
0.0207888056,
-0.0593056306,
0.0174510404,
0.0017703109,
-0.0462324023,
-0.0099850846,
-0.0098312665,
-0.0926766247,
-0.0433768034,
0.0203245468,
0.0216839463,
0.0392678268,
-0.0090282913,
0.0084193116,
-0.0716576651,
-0.0003845847,
-0.0486448668,
0.0013430892,
0.0256958082,
0.0005358572,
0.02696109,
-0.0197349545,
0.0206521004,
-0.0089877257,
-0.0006770828,
0.0317398347,
0.0289597269,
-0.0002661567,
-0.0619064197,
0.0336266533,
0.0252723806,
0.0399470106,
0.0061590872,
0.0164461546,
-0.0296985973,
0.0125512211,
0.0088577271,
-0.009773287,
-0.0240180474,
-0.0265865363,
0.039563328,
-0.010246003,
0.0081394501,
-0.0672062933,
-0.0151537191,
0.0032013697,
0.0013633688,
0.0057620639,
0.0120814815,
0.034004584,
0.0403915234,
0.0074020354,
-0.0205289647,
-0.0173450708,
0.0003186004,
0.0522716679,
0.0223122463,
0.1065514609,
0.0253644548,
-0.0449061505,
-0.0128681958,
0.0106429541,
-0.0739597976,
-0.082140483,
0.0336053967,
0.0203717034,
0.0046629072,
0.0016576854,
0.0277138222,
-0.0277215149,
0.0116545437,
0.0104733072,
-0.0041064494,
-0.0141740702,
-0.0374101289,
0.0381903313,
0.0091493605,
0.0068443152,
-0.0047712657,
0.0304404348,
-0.0024577505,
-0.0007919247,
-0.0232090838,
-0.0197897591,
-0.0210348293,
0.0155945169,
-0.041925095,
0.0123077361,
-0.0177644882,
0.0313677862,
-0.0977255031,
-0.0513043329,
-0.0403352417,
0.0019668215,
0.0002494095,
-0.0252332352,
0.0366163626,
0.067151092,
0.0161275286,
-0.0344245695,
-0.0310363173,
0.0281199645,
0.0036017115,
-0.0240871441,
-0.0291690957,
-6.791298858e-33,
0.0157262292,
-0.0429458059,
0.0203445423,
-0.0264445078,
-0.0173473489,
-0.007446649,
-0.0456568599,
0.0368150398,
-0.0354309306,
-0.0024092325,
-0.0541043505,
-0.0067517348,
0.0088492911,
0.0040185335,
0.0621138848,
-0.0156087279,
0.0212059263,
-0.0047406033,
-0.0364730954,
-0.0136964908,
0.0407232046,
-0.0214655623,
0.040077135,
-0.0177489128,
0.0458384976,
0.0159208626,
-0.0034685866,
0.0373146497,
-0.0790904388,
0.0227613747,
-0.0000960407,
0.0056996848,
0.0270622317,
-0.0471698157,
-0.0092696175,
0.0399352573,
-0.0508373752,
-0.0780703723,
0.0708304271,
-0.0176402014,
-0.0479198433,
-0.0136367697,
-0.0256872438,
0.0008464395,
-0.0109355338,
-0.02424822,
0.010514251,
0.0063483841,
0.0244770851,
0.0207176711,
-0.0437954776,
-0.0171191562,
-0.0174018554,
-0.0221660286,
-0.0009076538,
0.0950406939,
-0.0253869873,
-0.044716768,
-0.0578529239,
0.0440553762,
0.0294217952,
0.021535093,
0.0531150252,
0.0261449404,
0.0092277247,
0.0634695292,
0.0205286033,
0.0001396319,
-0.0393249206,
-0.0359222889,
0.0253645517,
-0.0006167927,
0.0723119453,
-0.0088916169,
0.0065955296,
0.0034285346,
-0.0614165477,
0.0106045837,
0.0572978891,
0.0167654715,
0.0482723117,
-0.0105027156,
-0.0084108114,
-0.0537862554,
-0.072312288,
-0.0113213882,
-0.0465710536,
-0.0310756359,
0.0414418168,
0.0025390438,
-0.0294311084,
-0.0515539274,
0.0586044788,
-0.028332755,
-0.0013119811,
-0.0008134431,
-0.0118629346,
0.0529975407,
0.0059183245,
0.032002531,
-0.0686218143,
0.0287838448,
-0.0047091967,
0.0042747678,
0.0248345584,
0.0102201663,
-0.0288985036,
-0.0083754184,
-0.0481761135,
-0.0112960236,
-0.0464789085,
0.023250768,
0.0112840356,
-0.043004211,
0.0335109308,
0.0191673525,
-0.0080152545,
0.0036683171,
0.0176626444,
-0.0049327863,
-0.0554060787,
0.0477042869,
-0.014082999,
0.0184103809,
-0.0120891724,
0.0068497723,
-0.0325337723,
0.0418763384,
0.0166626833,
-0.024488952,
-0.0257051662,
0.0361118279,
2.88e-7,
0.0247957446,
0.0510403886,
-0.0174106397,
0.0257834364,
0.0231973622,
0.0471763723,
-0.0043691262,
-0.0169267561,
0.1007190198,
-0.0518162437,
-0.0196594894,
-0.0055757137,
0.0290051457,
0.0539140888,
-0.0782199278,
-0.0244515836,
-0.0481987745,
0.0014113041,
-0.0140982913,
0.0069328733,
0.0305908993,
0.0219526812,
0.0171990544,
-0.024105262,
-0.0609752201,
0.0401111916,
0.0277072396,
-0.0113515221,
0.011327805,
0.0069151949,
0.0385784432,
-0.042599991,
0.0349362269,
0.0655985102,
0.0087073343,
0.0198351517,
-0.0331584327,
-0.0306726377,
0.0078948224,
-0.0271315351,
-0.0337298922,
-0.0094506238,
0.0372703932,
-0.1260798723,
0.0734227449,
-0.0620523505,
-0.035799697,
-0.0515673645,
0.0418287069,
-0.031635996,
0.0274453145,
-0.0032635089,
0.0073234383,
0.0073017902,
0.0030498675,
0.0167119075,
0.017324632,
-0.0614932775,
-0.00973,
0.0164680164,
-0.0168826953,
-0.0657525584,
-0.0309685133,
-0.0092883725,
0.0012300948,
-0.0723141432,
-0.0060025104,
2.361822765e-34,
0.0044865073,
-0.000674081,
0.0440298617,
0.0012684256,
0.0333103687,
-0.0132179568,
0.0028224064,
0.0111774141,
0.0535884053,
-0.112825878,
-0.0387010835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16135v1 | Crosslingual Capabilities and Knowledge Barriers in Multilingual Large Language Models | 2024-06-23T15:15:17 | 2024-06-23T15:15:17 | Lynn Chua, Badih Ghazi, Yangsibo Huang, Pritish Kamath, Ravi Kumar, Pasin Manurangsi, Amer Sinha, Chulin Xie, Chiyuan Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are typically multilingual due to pretraining on
diverse multilingual corpora. But can these models relate corresponding
concepts across languages, effectively being crosslingual? This study evaluates
six state-of-the-art LLMs on inherently crosslingual tasks. We observe that
while these models show promising surface-level crosslingual abilities on
machine translation and embedding space analyses, they struggle with deeper
crosslingual knowledge transfer, revealing a crosslingual knowledge barrier in
both general (MMLU benchmark) and domain-specific (Harry Potter quiz) contexts.
We observe that simple inference-time mitigation methods offer only limited
improvement. On the other hand, we propose fine-tuning of LLMs on
mixed-language data, which effectively reduces these gaps, even when using
out-of-domain datasets like WikiText. Our findings suggest the need for
explicit optimization to unlock the full crosslingual potential of LLMs. Our
code is publicly available at
https://github.com/google-research/crosslingual-knowledge-barriers. | [
0.0025945639,
0.0355601311,
-0.0070403395,
0.0864475295,
-0.023219673,
0.0331714936,
0.0307355691,
-0.0326916948,
0.0258284807,
-0.0193977095,
-0.0502287634,
-0.0445593856,
0.0036979993,
-0.0135875912,
0.0386653394,
-0.0462129824,
0.0451708436,
-0.0612519458,
-0.0395432152,
-0.0381267294,
-0.0266156793,
0.0134194391,
0.0058734724,
0.0120632956,
0.0132133774,
-0.0451807454,
0.0277665649,
-0.013304458,
0.0274126381,
-0.0254910924,
0.0044551417,
0.0197925474,
0.0198022015,
0.0736018717,
0.0000020141,
-0.0404833555,
0.0028278644,
0.0068464563,
0.0257394854,
0.0393027142,
0.0172148366,
-0.042578537,
0.0060476088,
-0.0001342584,
-0.0199887045,
-0.0237489641,
0.0643921047,
0.0129295364,
0.0225317385,
0.0692477524,
-0.0120798433,
-0.0116940588,
0.0337635837,
-0.0631516129,
0.0111600785,
-0.0732387826,
0.0058994698,
0.0174498986,
-0.0235393345,
0.017886579,
-0.0482751206,
0.053493306,
0.0262380168,
0.0145747745,
-0.0401063785,
0.0130452216,
-0.0072542094,
-0.0216937549,
-0.0040500136,
0.0743826181,
-0.0321661383,
-0.0132370843,
-0.0295287725,
-0.0051608752,
-0.0149083696,
0.0241387319,
-0.0486847088,
0.0236763973,
0.0095952107,
-0.0031647533,
0.0403171964,
0.0055031879,
0.0608106405,
-0.0072444919,
-0.0343673117,
0.0614110343,
0.0522734337,
-0.0251702089,
0.0203947891,
0.0350535586,
0.0030513238,
-0.0449564606,
-0.0080775451,
-0.0021751877,
-0.0241751317,
0.0113510322,
-0.0337048806,
-0.0264537781,
0.0174071901,
-0.0261126291,
-0.0061855461,
0.0409983546,
-0.013475717,
0.0761243701,
-0.0183768813,
0.0522990748,
-0.0558979847,
0.0186515246,
-0.0525138602,
-0.0548515879,
-0.0101084458,
0.0021140852,
0.0031325354,
-0.0316146873,
-0.0501274504,
-0.0176630933,
-0.0149908522,
0.0095234169,
-0.0051774359,
-0.0001432862,
0.0191965252,
-0.0535523593,
-0.0551865436,
-0.0126647335,
-0.0090669272,
0.0798585415,
-0.0315321796,
-0.0141031463,
-0.0247715395,
-0.0312648006,
-0.0270324871,
0.0155200213,
-0.0272992775,
-0.0938921422,
0.0191994458,
0.0827098489,
-0.0289398115,
-0.0079426141,
-0.0153718144,
0.0008584573,
-0.0141247921,
-0.0843453705,
0.0423061065,
-0.0637562796,
0.0635931268,
0.0115176421,
0.0538773164,
-0.0365564078,
-0.0062806159,
0.0030312024,
-0.038997069,
0.0728087574,
0.0219975282,
0.0030370378,
0.0174180176,
-0.0064490233,
-0.0201287735,
0.0842212364,
0.0074997814,
-0.0160383377,
0.0483211987,
-0.0179931242,
-0.0501815304,
0.0787121505,
0.0294032171,
0.0316257812,
-0.0236004442,
0.0170890484,
0.0230826065,
0.0441420227,
0.0499739572,
0.008001891,
-0.0087270811,
-0.0000801361,
0.0511255749,
0.0483467765,
0.0207825676,
0.0422451943,
0.0547705367,
-0.0188940912,
-0.0138980383,
0.0210382435,
-0.0257517863,
0.0064471373,
0.0040573268,
0.0082860943,
0.0223156996,
0.093675375,
-0.0298791993,
0.0150843803,
0.0058720051,
-0.0295229275,
0.0333666503,
0.0060857423,
0.0489036441,
-0.0022402506,
-0.0183862206,
0.0626295954,
0.0546472184,
-0.0415207148,
0.0203147978,
-0.0188898109,
0.0112503478,
0.0422232524,
-0.0045255371,
-0.0108242827,
-0.0325876847,
-0.0039624195,
0.0288033243,
0.0451055169,
0.0833430812,
-0.0134097803,
0.0433255509,
-0.0508478656,
-0.017702179,
-0.0456929728,
0.0032890853,
0.0575516373,
0.0114230374,
0.0713977218,
0.0127366707,
-0.0804264471,
0.0070508467,
0.0035598089,
-0.1104407683,
-0.008077723,
-0.0107442718,
0.0251402445,
0.0109632546,
0.0041381228,
-0.0089443298,
-0.0049867467,
-0.0080913706,
-0.052769836,
-0.010610736,
0.0184443835,
-0.0362225883,
-0.0469391458,
0.0363042541,
-0.0533572547,
-0.0221345201,
0.0320880339,
-0.0238465946,
-0.0276728049,
0.0110948393,
0.025947528,
0.0289331134,
-0.0293792784,
0.0010097624,
-0.0207062829,
0.0325316824,
-0.0180059858,
0.0432281196,
0.0061439909,
0.0250036977,
0.0182800647,
-0.0360839441,
0.0152186099,
0.006492387,
-0.0333025157,
0.0451499745,
0.0216733683,
0.032834895,
0.0285776798,
0.02031314,
-0.0267073773,
-0.0102972751,
-0.0877441987,
0.0224368908,
-0.0132983942,
0.0123038534,
0.0160187334,
0.0457938574,
-0.0171253923,
0.0001055771,
-0.0358950458,
-0.0113343718,
0.0019221165,
0.0524755381,
-0.0031620148,
0.0000385439,
0.0433585458,
-0.0089448486,
-0.0226691272,
0.0087807374,
0.0574654937,
-0.0250105523,
0.0019029614,
-0.0184347667,
0.0422800332,
-0.0398880206,
-0.0048712417,
-0.0233806521,
-0.0151586607,
-0.0203956347,
0.005816062,
0.0608138591,
0.0455431379,
-0.044647675,
-0.015841132,
0.0337978676,
-0.0492584221,
-0.0461818986,
0.0446236767,
0.0175149366,
-0.0313939005,
-0.0414736718,
-0.0156273264,
0.0041436865,
0.0847902969,
-0.0179584716,
-0.0489614643,
-0.0723217204,
0.0032889647,
-0.0313490033,
-0.0218106341,
-0.0583762489,
0.0488874502,
0.0197061896,
0.0265373569,
-0.0299706571,
-0.0298223756,
0.0580808446,
-0.0512963645,
0.0068559083,
-0.0461041518,
0.0049164663,
-0.0521234795,
0.0538815558,
-0.0158534646,
0.0328531079,
-0.0173971634,
-0.019729767,
-0.0513573363,
0.0322785974,
0.0269702021,
-0.0113030113,
0.0292726569,
-0.0325639881,
-0.0256244931,
-0.0403027646,
-0.0330625996,
0.0077638724,
-0.0353515372,
-0.0166380424,
-0.0239170529,
-0.0061130412,
-0.0246347431,
-0.0149537483,
0.0012730857,
0.0277200863,
0.0185167268,
-0.0251413696,
0.0207399633,
-0.0042117615,
0.0179086123,
0.0387235656,
0.011899299,
0.0016726624,
-0.0700640157,
0.024539452,
0.0024333561,
0.0059520802,
-0.0016100722,
0.0127484212,
0.0060779857,
0.0494598709,
0.0034306808,
-0.0629595667,
-0.0262916442,
0.0642319322,
-0.0389434136,
0.0073142885,
0.083623901,
-0.0078833178,
-0.0313489214,
-0.0016755826,
-0.0447757244,
0.023870647,
0.0225594193,
0.034759704,
-0.0915317833,
-0.0331932418,
0.0132753178,
-0.0246761478,
0.0396924242,
-0.0215144977,
-0.0200491082,
-0.1286827028,
-0.0039330791,
0.0175613705,
-0.0695397854,
-0.0579559021,
-0.0306521542,
-0.0315732509,
-0.0104656555,
0.0496254005,
-0.0507464074,
0.0056853052,
0.0021718757,
-0.0176595785,
0.0196501501,
-0.0718130395,
0.0496949963,
-0.035468787,
0.0146891121,
0.0218481962,
0.0585122108,
-0.0075746509,
-0.042913992,
0.0127551854,
-0.0233789366,
-0.0453932248,
-0.0066359635,
0.0235175192,
-0.0006973462,
-0.0218366869,
0.0292412098,
0.0215652641,
-0.0198009908,
0.0005037508,
0.0286090542,
0.1129025593,
0.0488913618,
-0.0220740158,
0.0088654859,
-0.0325294398,
0.0169900972,
0.0839053169,
0.0061800596,
-0.0539954118,
-0.0054493691,
-0.0168119408,
-0.0196961444,
-0.0310035087,
-0.0264304951,
0.0352756195,
-0.0253479034,
0.0002021708,
-0.0327634923,
-0.0528976507,
0.0164246615,
0.0116485441,
0.0320970491,
0.0171662644,
-0.0251758434,
-0.0222849902,
-0.0190220997,
0.0495545752,
-0.0653338283,
0.0403210148,
-0.0293807443,
0.0292970333,
0.0149177127,
-0.0231425818,
-0.0104455752,
0.0204856955,
-0.0700752959,
-0.0678718835,
-0.0516447313,
0.042775549,
0.0128019089,
0.0585345291,
-0.0034046776,
-0.0441892706,
0.0502036102,
-0.0421919711,
-0.0270363409,
0.0058130268,
0.0318179131,
0.011370318,
-0.0031503292,
0.06608174,
-0.0301259793,
-0.0272676405,
0.0195367765,
0.0558777899,
-0.0058642053,
-0.0260062218,
-0.0214185305,
0.0040094703,
0.0104249381,
-0.0346385539,
-0.0349251516,
-0.0480050966,
0.0207750443,
-0.0299198665,
-0.0246654619,
-0.037748076,
-0.0404775664,
0.074503921,
-0.0298520643,
0.0203664843,
0.0018219454,
0.0456113555,
0.0034953037,
-0.0449740887,
0.0178555865,
0.0108578429,
0.0203022137,
0.0423630662,
0.0344907306,
0.0017734648,
-0.0056555169,
-0.0093273493,
0.0364508443,
-0.0406089425,
0.0365045816,
0.0031040534,
0.0064713703,
0.0040671392,
-0.0003705387,
-0.0226723608,
-0.0392987765,
0.0384336151,
0.0280075707,
0.0806803033,
-0.0338940807,
0.0989732593,
0.0063998457,
-0.0358840786,
-0.0245392844,
0.0357650444,
0.0194392726,
0.0007659085,
0.0497287326,
-0.00452882,
-0.0119898804,
0.0191262402,
0.097159259,
0.020931175,
0.0308745839,
0.0214854721,
-0.0108621176,
-0.0253758654,
-0.0223101787,
0.0504689626,
0.0012775412,
-0.0138890361,
0.0287092477,
-0.0604738146,
-0.0925370827,
0.0048268177,
-0.0085996278,
-0.0302817356,
0.01495119,
-0.0164269526,
0.0912425667,
-0.0219657868,
0.0056465776,
-0.0427254997,
-0.0006736929,
0.0225692634,
-0.0215458721,
0.0070758583,
-6.195058736e-33,
-0.0343913101,
0.0148953581,
0.0283005722,
-0.0305679552,
-0.0269995369,
0.013368506,
-0.0266393386,
-0.0090156011,
-0.018660849,
0.01881635,
-0.0121889943,
-0.0028274513,
0.0051084878,
0.0326276086,
0.0161783043,
-0.0010796286,
0.0257746857,
0.0207864903,
-0.0230179057,
0.0344499722,
0.0321469568,
0.0219526011,
0.0659687072,
-0.0045096758,
0.0390953757,
-0.0064923665,
0.0266676843,
0.0064519974,
0.0149176316,
0.0419309475,
-0.0453914516,
0.0320231095,
0.0272187684,
-0.0484283753,
-0.0252268165,
0.0199205223,
-0.0851697028,
-0.0212878939,
0.0403353646,
0.0063463743,
0.0063921614,
-0.0715459287,
0.0055769202,
0.0009327191,
0.0228352994,
-0.0698849708,
0.0214759875,
-0.012787044,
0.0101433424,
-0.006517096,
-0.0920727998,
0.0149656413,
-0.0340288505,
-0.0092200153,
0.0400972292,
0.0527998656,
0.0304955095,
0.0260199811,
-0.063275747,
0.0279824026,
-0.0367271379,
0.0177090857,
0.0790957585,
-0.0053230622,
0.0014744751,
0.0242145211,
-0.0090747336,
-0.0117086684,
0.0360464752,
0.0344770141,
0.0355602242,
-0.0104219951,
0.0261896998,
0.0887041688,
0.0159698855,
-0.0177593417,
-0.0981009156,
0.0165986549,
-0.0137595348,
0.0045216852,
-0.0001229846,
0.002107756,
0.0086405929,
-0.0188131798,
-0.0564680621,
-0.002490809,
-0.0273399483,
-0.021396637,
0.022805173,
-0.0309159085,
-0.0186752118,
-0.0179311279,
0.0697356239,
-0.0325021185,
-0.0448124744,
0.0240486562,
-0.0055192891,
-0.0009793109,
-0.0094791893,
0.0832362324,
-0.0556016341,
-0.0370768942,
-0.018154474,
0.0000016877,
0.031403482,
0.0167547353,
0.0393516533,
0.0167682264,
-0.0744512081,
-0.0035092086,
-0.0399908684,
0.002390478,
0.0002191889,
0.0626627877,
0.0323560499,
0.0013568401,
-0.0022501384,
0.0332646333,
0.0455536284,
-0.0134977149,
-0.0071073407,
-0.030233983,
0.0147089818,
0.0245199259,
-0.0168885384,
-0.01216684,
-0.035684783,
-0.0263845138,
0.0481698886,
-0.0679344386,
-0.0308911912,
-0.0232008286,
2.711e-7,
0.0403601155,
0.0198039822,
-0.0212015323,
0.0327220447,
0.0128871473,
0.0335738063,
-0.0292267371,
0.0415615849,
0.0186003037,
0.0090106186,
-0.0122182984,
0.0374911204,
0.0743316412,
0.0329085328,
-0.0752452612,
-0.0098416433,
-0.0144077828,
0.027489746,
-0.0479648225,
0.0012506461,
-0.0053258445,
0.0725603774,
0.0115194097,
-0.0019108929,
-0.012628343,
-0.0612819418,
0.086161375,
-0.0536654368,
-0.050290864,
0.025486717,
-0.011749804,
0.0347229205,
-0.0098589556,
0.0222046599,
-0.0303451233,
0.0456402004,
0.0527759418,
0.0513039902,
0.0250873715,
0.0017930148,
-0.0003601832,
-0.018499719,
-0.042940028,
-0.075357914,
0.0818319991,
-0.0283655841,
-0.0381664,
-0.0156447887,
0.0163669232,
-0.0043886667,
0.0781102479,
-0.0575628728,
-0.0349322036,
0.0034196896,
0.0496357121,
0.0079286136,
-0.0118534565,
-0.0308181979,
-0.0225444622,
0.0084371343,
-0.0420223065,
-0.0521066189,
-0.0113930795,
-0.0313222595,
-0.0032351299,
-0.0481745973,
0.0242896006,
2.475206542e-34,
0.0480786972,
-0.0070459833,
0.0253363289,
-0.0288905706,
0.0353454426,
-0.0555495247,
0.0009771793,
-0.0076014143,
-0.0025156769,
-0.0655304119,
-0.0125321159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16120v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16120v1 | Contextualized End-to-end Automatic Speech Recognition with Intermediate Biasing Loss | 2024-06-23T14:22:59 | 2024-06-23T14:22:59 | Muhammad Shakeel, Yui Sudo, Yifan Peng, Shinji Watanabe | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Contextualized end-to-end automatic speech recognition has been an active
research area, with recent efforts focusing on the implicit learning of
contextual phrases based on the final loss objective. However, these approaches
ignore the useful contextual knowledge encoded in the intermediate layers. We
hypothesize that employing explicit biasing loss as an auxiliary task in the
encoder intermediate layers may better align text tokens or audio frames with
the desired objectives. Our proposed intermediate biasing loss brings more
regularization and contextualization to the network. Our method outperforms a
conventional contextual biasing baseline on the LibriSpeech corpus, achieving a
relative improvement of 22.5% in biased word error rate (B-WER) and up to 44%
compared to the non-contextual baseline with a biasing list size of 100.
Moreover, employing RNN-transducer-driven joint decoding further reduces the
unbiased word error rate (U-WER), resulting in a more robust network. | [
-0.0467982776,
0.0539317764,
0.0406513885,
0.04256754,
0.0072035515,
-0.0029598959,
0.0336942226,
-0.0373092517,
-0.0329299942,
-0.0314913131,
-0.0330870263,
0.0107060401,
0.0228919964,
0.0014023519,
0.0351774544,
-0.0626770332,
0.0150283556,
-0.0214876141,
0.0309191309,
-0.0128852772,
0.0219733473,
0.0108154984,
-0.0482944921,
0.0394367203,
-0.0340892263,
0.0334757119,
-0.0197917111,
0.0378003754,
0.0351689123,
-0.0374141745,
-0.0047590933,
-0.0189273637,
0.0376101695,
0.010259998,
0.000002093,
-0.0341690555,
-0.0134239653,
-0.0030928922,
-0.0703751519,
-0.0095053744,
0.0542813092,
-0.0140279811,
-0.01771334,
0.038050767,
0.0139768291,
-0.0108239558,
0.0632797331,
0.0310781635,
0.020747358,
0.0535537563,
-0.0063989796,
-0.0597809963,
0.0264254287,
-0.0295085423,
0.018688228,
-0.0599519312,
-0.0267770477,
-0.0331551805,
-0.0208542999,
-0.0389329456,
-0.0479619689,
0.0357122011,
0.0360154361,
0.0017627111,
0.0022136387,
0.0261546727,
-0.0046308916,
-0.0335116051,
-0.0242226571,
0.0836832225,
-0.003571983,
-0.0082901306,
-0.02160847,
-0.0104845092,
-0.022458924,
-0.0595991984,
-0.0053394898,
0.0405664891,
-0.003179363,
-0.0068564061,
0.016715629,
0.0661083236,
0.0412924439,
-0.0073340121,
-0.0552166477,
-0.0048834938,
0.0111275399,
-0.0149558354,
0.0058869366,
0.0008466222,
0.020924408,
-0.0144034605,
0.036934223,
0.0016426336,
-0.0134117249,
0.0098087518,
-0.0310544688,
-0.0069722994,
-0.02695507,
-0.0129586793,
-0.0365324169,
0.0548810698,
-0.0864277929,
0.0181313325,
-0.0242754836,
0.0127222072,
-0.0144304391,
-0.003117118,
-0.0320569873,
-0.0324573107,
0.0224252436,
0.0034596296,
-0.040959686,
0.0168551579,
-0.0388484187,
-0.0124983862,
-0.0532253571,
0.009135562,
-0.0246289335,
0.019524537,
-0.004032399,
0.0391275138,
-0.077358529,
-0.0331351086,
0.0491233207,
0.0402879156,
-0.0096468255,
0.043712642,
0.0186171196,
-0.0356917754,
-0.0322641358,
0.0361035764,
0.0358437411,
-0.0318704359,
0.0089859422,
0.069311969,
0.015642859,
-0.0369880274,
-0.044642251,
0.0155121861,
-0.0401365347,
-0.011694205,
-0.0273094028,
-0.0352623798,
0.0418971069,
-0.0060928226,
0.011884464,
-0.0118310601,
-0.01585095,
-0.0462754145,
0.0228752587,
0.0779068843,
-0.0077566765,
-0.042387262,
0.0484614447,
-0.0113114407,
0.0242102426,
0.0606839843,
0.0631379113,
0.0026865788,
0.0062606572,
-0.002306941,
-0.0377090722,
0.0346155278,
0.0459598824,
-0.0029762576,
-0.0595033243,
-0.0122320568,
0.0232379679,
0.0504164211,
0.1006164178,
0.0240225047,
-0.0555895865,
0.0035498219,
0.0400669947,
0.0068102009,
0.0300516337,
0.0261694603,
0.0246472061,
-0.0034080576,
-0.0348074473,
-0.0056539145,
-0.0141558414,
0.0246311501,
0.0053630099,
0.0338689089,
0.0581394508,
0.0193999689,
-0.0327903703,
-0.0208841041,
0.0235828124,
-0.0311350226,
0.0052545005,
0.0079603605,
0.0541841723,
0.0206014365,
-0.0646135435,
0.0617406145,
0.0043934355,
-0.0623803735,
0.0564474277,
0.0040623895,
-0.0260339454,
0.0461413227,
0.0104391221,
-0.0276568066,
-0.0290794279,
-0.0353387892,
-0.0033027544,
0.0485102534,
0.0227379315,
-0.0120239686,
0.091988422,
-0.0919974744,
-0.0433586501,
0.0338353552,
0.0004336278,
0.0551791526,
-0.0502422452,
0.0387129225,
0.0147796441,
-0.0335036665,
0.0411736034,
0.003685476,
-0.0302500352,
-0.0484726056,
0.0011299781,
0.0398616195,
0.0402111188,
0.0571744367,
-0.0460148752,
-0.0128603037,
0.025526939,
-0.051742848,
0.0077410401,
0.0211271141,
-0.1082378924,
-0.0539057329,
0.0133214807,
-0.0425912663,
0.0156099787,
0.0164351426,
-0.0120403832,
-0.0650300384,
0.0367315225,
0.0049049854,
0.0731101036,
-0.0414192341,
-0.0012125042,
0.0274415277,
-0.0155031104,
-0.011255404,
0.0011105577,
-0.001441766,
-0.0065027918,
0.0367368683,
-0.0351512656,
-0.0316278338,
-0.0754243657,
-0.0324982852,
-0.009806375,
0.007128201,
0.0144541692,
0.009186876,
-0.0101407431,
-0.0122242458,
-0.004613129,
-0.1082839891,
-0.0219441056,
-0.028602764,
0.0359732881,
0.0176773891,
0.0820935965,
0.003274923,
-0.0379190743,
-0.0072780061,
-0.0297915861,
-0.0342071876,
-0.0281079318,
0.005023038,
0.0250949152,
-0.0461717583,
-0.0235459041,
0.0133473966,
0.0121466909,
0.0177676938,
0.0136817889,
-0.027111223,
-0.039465826,
-0.0040871878,
0.0714307576,
0.0215512216,
-0.0193354171,
-0.0040799319,
-0.0063698324,
0.0141076362,
-0.0216651093,
0.0474910699,
0.014074292,
0.0117674125,
0.0024969243,
-0.0148689663,
-0.0707926825,
0.0189944264,
-0.0105165606,
-0.0184491742,
-0.0363162868,
0.0074633015,
-0.0146187646,
0.0316507854,
0.0228759106,
0.0576911271,
-0.023753373,
-0.0210510232,
0.0095495433,
-0.0172488913,
-0.013481901,
-0.0724310353,
-0.0272354484,
0.0077301906,
-0.0166901089,
0.00359015,
0.0339457206,
-0.0550498217,
-0.0203899052,
-0.0190640762,
-0.009490069,
0.0043957913,
-0.007748662,
-0.029066436,
0.0272901207,
-0.021466827,
-0.0760857463,
-0.0460019447,
-0.0105326921,
0.01057522,
-0.002401463,
0.0165532511,
-0.0122122997,
0.0034644792,
-0.0155848088,
-0.0503027886,
-0.0268473253,
0.0110194981,
-0.0075016585,
0.0142122805,
0.0134200128,
0.0014723163,
-0.021589525,
0.0049801571,
0.0155688701,
0.0887072161,
0.0118790697,
0.0108100194,
-0.0185803156,
0.0792081729,
-0.011659503,
0.024074953,
0.0331293792,
0.0117829787,
0.0442267656,
0.0276364181,
0.0708597898,
0.0089300321,
-0.072930567,
0.0014101274,
0.032434307,
-0.0044688331,
0.0225790907,
-0.0021022977,
0.0489983968,
-0.0409257747,
-0.0108757326,
0.0879511163,
-0.0148257334,
-0.0935069844,
-0.0153914066,
0.0146465423,
0.015823029,
-0.003838022,
-0.0151938172,
-0.0887579769,
-0.0599551238,
0.0506240092,
0.0639593676,
0.0214834567,
0.0061835102,
0.0043030041,
-0.1048719287,
0.0088798655,
0.0322735682,
-0.0467116609,
-0.0257079098,
-0.0323298573,
-0.0222147759,
-0.053776186,
0.0755186751,
0.0148851015,
0.0108620953,
-0.0411688574,
0.0534449704,
-0.0402694978,
-0.0782653317,
-0.0180387571,
-0.0604405291,
0.0786159784,
0.0388351902,
0.0162468534,
-0.0209601931,
0.0445058271,
0.1271812916,
-0.0556012727,
-0.0007470419,
0.00436308,
0.0313349664,
-0.0443817824,
-0.0100462949,
0.0414630845,
0.0448834747,
-0.0239212215,
0.015102285,
0.0217753462,
0.0465986542,
-0.0072069527,
0.0634057149,
-0.005438582,
-0.0078173252,
0.0388142914,
0.0521988384,
0.0132383751,
-0.0454161614,
0.0004595547,
-0.0121079944,
0.0314790718,
-0.0345909782,
0.0163379759,
-0.0189272575,
-0.0029687793,
-0.0167505648,
-0.0487105288,
-0.0497159027,
0.00262005,
0.0480521619,
0.0077452953,
-0.0415988043,
-0.0187542252,
0.018511055,
-0.0649600998,
0.0068310141,
0.0116524762,
0.0200363491,
-0.0440836139,
0.0299183037,
-0.0068706479,
-0.0842989311,
-0.0107006254,
0.0412867703,
-0.0350260846,
-0.052310206,
0.036227636,
0.0033559611,
0.0130607029,
0.1145551652,
-0.0121332137,
-0.0611358471,
0.1165392324,
0.0534907505,
-0.0558250174,
-0.0047334167,
0.0449786521,
0.0414147936,
-0.0143472152,
0.01016651,
-0.0887072459,
0.0142105231,
-0.0194706675,
0.045761399,
-0.0020817404,
-0.0287128873,
-0.0154633401,
-0.0166282319,
0.0403750166,
-0.0327311046,
0.039188046,
-0.04602018,
0.0444299877,
0.0183518715,
0.0321069136,
-0.0165369455,
0.0172277745,
0.0122595299,
0.0179153644,
0.002482248,
-0.0189309493,
0.0167415254,
-0.0299375169,
-0.0144678922,
0.0854155272,
0.0245863665,
0.0447504632,
-0.0065588285,
0.0105911652,
-0.0311006326,
0.0223896317,
0.0033621138,
0.029675616,
-0.0460218526,
0.0097031975,
0.0181708243,
0.0013431803,
-0.0182967354,
0.0212615095,
-0.0444714129,
0.0460361056,
-0.0524777137,
-0.0010118145,
0.0182247926,
-0.0183436107,
0.052723866,
-0.0014924549,
0.0125781987,
0.0039704992,
0.0206174124,
-0.0269794594,
-0.0231630541,
0.032781899,
0.0149794975,
-0.0113692461,
0.0308240429,
0.0140275052,
-0.0037346196,
0.0391538963,
-0.0328187197,
0.0370453149,
-0.0351621769,
-0.0203779135,
0.0038446926,
0.0150790941,
-0.0414393395,
-0.0080824317,
0.0109924832,
-0.0495204814,
0.0332397036,
0.001211674,
0.0284616798,
-0.0247681588,
0.0175725948,
-0.0183419902,
-0.0299759135,
0.007864628,
0.0491171181,
-0.0054632751,
0.0083684595,
-0.0107321944,
-0.0096802628,
-6.524639434e-33,
-0.0349155031,
-0.0121704265,
-0.0040095802,
-0.0539909862,
-0.0346381888,
0.0379225127,
-0.0123351468,
-0.0111852344,
-0.0008847135,
-0.0060788104,
0.0033868332,
0.0032480629,
0.0370935276,
0.0235752799,
-0.009918727,
-0.0123939319,
0.0590219349,
-0.0099524893,
0.0047679823,
0.0125826504,
0.0410682596,
0.047728952,
0.0294281896,
-0.0747522265,
0.012856584,
0.0294575002,
-0.0295962412,
0.0221767817,
0.061550796,
0.0378984287,
-0.0158726554,
0.0210266989,
-0.0224218965,
-0.014169829,
0.0004203022,
0.0044193873,
-0.1246110499,
-0.0051815626,
-0.0337835401,
0.0543256253,
0.0161560867,
-0.0167546254,
0.0607953072,
0.0135948006,
-0.0530530214,
-0.0227486771,
0.0234948713,
-0.01763089,
-0.0295750201,
-0.0357587449,
-0.0277471878,
0.0395473428,
-0.0367004387,
0.0129533149,
0.043101497,
0.0293224473,
-0.0027550471,
0.0053854808,
-0.095756799,
0.000261867,
-0.0546460748,
-0.0137510067,
0.0526218936,
0.0076314304,
-0.0242855679,
0.0334502906,
0.0990259498,
-0.0368194468,
-0.0076523721,
-0.0231740903,
0.0047346856,
-0.0333009847,
0.023112217,
0.0434284844,
0.0399449915,
-0.0100142574,
-0.0329540558,
-0.0127199749,
0.010890685,
0.0326799676,
0.0535511486,
0.03985136,
-0.0463910028,
-0.0020382171,
-0.0489810668,
-0.067953676,
-0.0348956622,
0.0069832713,
0.0374364927,
0.034515176,
0.0355514362,
-0.0107779466,
0.0553615354,
-0.0055365926,
0.0329594053,
0.029091496,
0.0230098572,
-0.0093459832,
-0.0168491323,
0.010391389,
-0.0478099287,
0.00302063,
0.0217255633,
0.054857377,
0.0271845963,
-0.0183936041,
0.0206769835,
0.0522908904,
-0.0646495372,
-0.017101381,
-0.0388538279,
0.0000891425,
-0.0008615025,
0.0282395203,
0.068510592,
-0.0275446437,
0.0033377272,
0.0552462004,
0.0032848308,
0.005680826,
0.0303483568,
-0.0160581339,
0.0023978876,
0.0240313243,
-0.048437845,
0.0002701439,
0.0672994927,
-0.0071337814,
0.0118214665,
-0.0464646593,
-0.0171767063,
0.0008214596,
2.917e-7,
-0.0318142101,
0.0037974147,
0.0935019031,
-0.0438308567,
-0.0031119492,
0.020663172,
-0.0009676374,
0.0061523458,
-0.0503145196,
0.044957649,
0.0295880139,
-0.0229550842,
0.0603411905,
0.0333543308,
-0.0845571309,
-0.0170448348,
-0.0400125198,
0.0466743074,
0.0080061685,
0.0213140473,
0.0171289109,
0.0658715814,
-0.0121267261,
-0.02887276,
0.0272867251,
-0.037379548,
0.0078248139,
-0.0246028751,
0.0217613019,
-0.0401899293,
-0.0231611431,
-0.0115196379,
-0.0298478119,
0.0003789665,
-0.0047275443,
0.0157866552,
0.0175205991,
0.0101036588,
-0.0207155906,
-0.1013242677,
0.0171655752,
0.0471113622,
-0.0016337942,
-0.013925327,
0.0191363357,
-0.0250652991,
-0.0172656756,
-0.0179097094,
-0.0737144351,
-0.001503838,
0.0037333837,
0.0081438553,
0.0224090312,
-0.0074420208,
0.0247600693,
0.0114117032,
-0.0334948786,
-0.1214809492,
-0.0086107673,
0.0152942277,
-0.0322631039,
-0.025580097,
-0.0170622692,
0.0245717168,
0.0605030656,
-0.026178984,
0.0082282182,
2.404009007e-34,
0.0399775058,
-0.0453636162,
0.0238603763,
0.0034432248,
0.0062451754,
-0.0210906249,
0.00607451,
-0.009822214,
0.0376336165,
-0.031753432,
-0.0319667496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16107v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16107v1 | Decoder-only Architecture for Streaming End-to-end Speech Recognition | 2024-06-23T13:50:08 | 2024-06-23T13:50:08 | Emiru Tsunoo, Hayato Futami, Yosuke Kashiwagi, Siddhant Arora, Shinji Watanabe | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | Decoder-only language models (LMs) have been successfully adopted for
speech-processing tasks including automatic speech recognition (ASR). The LMs
have ample expressiveness and perform efficiently. This efficiency is a
suitable characteristic for streaming applications of ASR. In this work, we
propose to use a decoder-only architecture for blockwise streaming ASR. In our
approach, speech features are compressed using CTC output and context embedding
using blockwise speech subnetwork, and are sequentially provided as prompts to
the decoder. The decoder estimates the output tokens promptly at each block. To
this end, we also propose a novel training scheme using random-length prefix
prompts to make the model robust to the truncated prompts caused by blockwise
processing. An experimental comparison shows that our proposed decoder-only
streaming ASR achieves 8% relative word error rate reduction in the LibriSpeech
test-other set while being twice as fast as the baseline model. | [
-0.0262193792,
0.0212757234,
0.0318798907,
0.0394098312,
-0.0283039249,
-0.0032789297,
0.0558842383,
0.0028698926,
0.0012342,
-0.0030719272,
0.0082919663,
-0.0611590929,
0.0145690637,
0.0483806804,
0.0100080185,
-0.0364153683,
0.022057388,
-0.0464091972,
0.0059343819,
-0.0170970317,
-0.0013151364,
0.0075508794,
-0.0303421002,
0.0155219072,
0.0015380621,
-0.010506819,
-0.0279389899,
0.0036814914,
0.0063832696,
-0.0495764613,
-0.025654953,
-0.028625641,
0.0712418705,
0.0204604119,
0.0000019131,
-0.0005427922,
-0.04597532,
0.0018718248,
-0.1014074013,
-0.0131117739,
0.0393167958,
-0.0010278788,
-0.0228172839,
0.0545077994,
0.0153832817,
-0.0439950339,
0.041139964,
0.0448014326,
0.0239490755,
0.0518684536,
-0.0037234996,
-0.0454045273,
0.0312460177,
-0.0114373267,
-0.0444158316,
-0.0204500761,
-0.0348483957,
-0.0375688486,
0.0211856812,
0.0165895596,
-0.0384969041,
0.0491618291,
0.0250469428,
0.0181186888,
0.0026655698,
-0.0063155247,
-0.0171187595,
-0.0160178896,
-0.0523848869,
0.0236721803,
0.0130247576,
-0.0344987735,
0.0090619717,
0.0067474791,
-0.0125956861,
-0.0622919723,
-0.0028704687,
0.0502862372,
-0.0190329514,
-0.0042280531,
0.0021450166,
0.0397914052,
0.0090152761,
-0.0180301219,
-0.0283948425,
0.0015753725,
-0.004342122,
-0.0248100497,
-0.0156590603,
-0.0189968217,
0.031279251,
-0.0286540668,
0.0376779474,
-0.0017685598,
-0.0186147876,
-0.0075380867,
-0.030535318,
-0.0153352944,
-0.0590393655,
-0.0158038475,
0.0136336368,
0.0773531795,
-0.0467077084,
0.0051149712,
-0.0444194078,
0.0580299571,
-0.0010577941,
-0.005860812,
-0.026753569,
0.0070014102,
-0.010424247,
-0.0093549378,
-0.0622860529,
0.0569236167,
-0.0542696305,
-0.0508211479,
-0.0151145877,
0.0411275625,
0.0310373399,
-0.0121714901,
0.0200493876,
-0.0055257715,
-0.0259777177,
-0.0188214462,
0.050710842,
0.0256427824,
0.0171504505,
0.0207974892,
0.0176042244,
-0.0738763362,
-0.0291956123,
0.0254814494,
0.0550648309,
0.0205962155,
-0.0050008097,
0.0055337856,
-0.0029829713,
-0.0786659792,
-0.052429188,
0.011844256,
0.0128180878,
-0.0161096528,
-0.0095026083,
-0.0468857959,
0.0285046995,
0.0145256883,
0.0340637602,
-0.0138635049,
-0.0036671197,
-0.0243161023,
0.0228320323,
0.0684936121,
-0.030876264,
-0.0236353092,
0.0341577195,
-0.0010465912,
0.0220625419,
0.0496560112,
0.0372706503,
-0.0022043327,
0.0130247539,
-0.0176967718,
-0.0410423577,
0.0310451686,
0.0000052027,
-0.0329070799,
-0.0654546097,
0.0110129016,
0.0631435439,
0.0084540807,
0.0441847444,
0.0271428674,
-0.0138378767,
0.0127283074,
0.0368083119,
0.0471716337,
0.0220898725,
0.0393349938,
0.041379787,
0.0171317067,
-0.0121959876,
0.0293250997,
0.0358849838,
0.0172849745,
0.0132976016,
0.0182886254,
0.065950036,
0.0370584726,
-0.057462953,
-0.0093098208,
-0.0157787055,
-0.0443299226,
-0.0061122393,
0.0252481475,
0.04897682,
0.0011730139,
-0.066804193,
0.0186749063,
-0.0069621126,
-0.0627162308,
0.0002289611,
-0.038165357,
0.0070759384,
0.0588295609,
0.0305461939,
-0.0169016458,
0.0036291792,
-0.0342888385,
0.0120735178,
0.0259553157,
0.0074222786,
0.0044677788,
0.040541023,
-0.0502860397,
0.0166978985,
0.0750643164,
-0.0179303866,
0.0650947765,
-0.0329015329,
0.0234303847,
0.0047073583,
0.0174247995,
0.0076299203,
-0.0114993583,
-0.0122925071,
-0.0346489958,
0.0339603275,
-0.0044297604,
0.0449113995,
0.0240758341,
-0.0235598926,
-0.0159708075,
0.0317881629,
-0.0552709885,
0.0275842343,
0.0324986652,
-0.0979065746,
-0.098244898,
0.0292024519,
0.0046382817,
0.0497024804,
0.0953115672,
0.0127545511,
-0.0872494653,
0.023073012,
-0.0189273991,
0.0645822063,
-0.0489780866,
0.0550045632,
0.0308605675,
0.0200314038,
0.0393484235,
0.0066358061,
-0.0162006579,
0.0258130133,
0.0277458001,
0.0199352093,
-0.0456547253,
-0.081441991,
-0.0594553426,
0.0156820435,
-0.0376174003,
-0.0108876675,
-0.0146075878,
-0.0309815612,
0.0368552618,
0.0394993983,
-0.0818086416,
-0.0179074071,
-0.0333496034,
0.030826794,
-0.0156870726,
0.0641187951,
0.0071782125,
-0.0525329076,
-0.0188779421,
-0.004267924,
0.0102918884,
-0.0032886462,
-0.0452857427,
0.0266700871,
-0.0698362291,
0.0020828655,
-0.0221092235,
0.0287146363,
0.0327809528,
-0.0393022224,
-0.0434737839,
-0.0769142136,
0.0264707729,
0.0607603081,
0.0674037859,
-0.0226469934,
0.0014467958,
-0.0087057874,
0.011661944,
-0.0064693042,
0.021813279,
0.0155354505,
-0.0068144924,
-0.0137753477,
0.0046020942,
-0.0371554643,
0.0145577816,
0.0063712345,
0.022666499,
0.0171698611,
-0.0080713173,
-0.0015612905,
0.0308443476,
0.0182316676,
0.0382877141,
-0.028828226,
-0.0562072471,
-0.0069441455,
-0.0405511744,
-0.0518392362,
-0.0423921756,
-0.0694584176,
0.0184262581,
0.0141140623,
-0.0513291284,
0.0120740952,
-0.0857079104,
-0.0406582206,
-0.0127927521,
-0.0394609794,
-0.0229288135,
0.0181652773,
0.0219280161,
0.0111662196,
-0.0273815859,
-0.0617041923,
-0.0017589581,
0.0250243228,
-0.0145354364,
-0.0542331859,
0.0117559712,
-0.0242213402,
0.0106375348,
-0.0122778201,
-0.0166452676,
-0.0382971801,
-0.0183248222,
-0.0003753915,
0.0452621616,
0.0594478138,
-0.0139797265,
0.029358035,
0.0869776383,
0.0068038087,
0.0860355273,
0.0019037431,
0.0177789163,
-0.0375776067,
0.0725888312,
0.0075967363,
0.0358254015,
0.0148370285,
0.025551958,
0.0713318214,
0.0083306422,
0.0772477835,
0.0094797863,
-0.0616012514,
-0.0165675208,
0.0321483053,
-0.0003814642,
-0.0002423097,
0.0535330139,
0.0390132405,
-0.0505604483,
-0.0158702061,
0.0958453938,
0.0219489392,
-0.0263631213,
-0.0521304533,
-0.000551255,
0.0034319612,
-0.0078967446,
-0.0048718532,
-0.0372281708,
-0.0187607817,
0.0434619896,
0.0579396002,
0.005056967,
-0.0003414714,
-0.0312438663,
-0.0797712579,
0.0489410236,
0.0252244808,
-0.0129229268,
-0.0455090664,
-0.0605107024,
-0.0543182008,
0.0132348491,
0.0173085462,
0.0413696989,
-0.0124524031,
-0.0590476319,
0.049640771,
-0.081614092,
-0.0486607216,
0.0046560019,
-0.0249191113,
0.0999467969,
0.0704711825,
-0.0271105785,
-0.0091574769,
0.0061000395,
0.040146511,
-0.0352869742,
0.0035641061,
-0.0166496132,
-0.0282910168,
-0.0237929597,
0.0071584946,
0.0476368591,
0.0047684833,
-0.0002700275,
0.0222804826,
-0.0006916332,
0.0840223879,
-0.0150962817,
0.0271746274,
0.0123146558,
0.0153817069,
0.0134971272,
0.0536769032,
0.0081244977,
-0.0154324453,
-0.0003345424,
0.0137705514,
0.0145673128,
-0.0128466729,
0.0109221954,
0.0127133131,
-0.0011926063,
-0.0317086354,
0.0075548673,
0.0209468063,
0.0177669376,
0.0001101021,
-0.0035384034,
0.0369933471,
-0.0141981114,
0.0416591391,
-0.0312184487,
-0.0391287804,
-0.0006531635,
0.0102336742,
-0.0954028219,
0.0073499433,
0.0117255589,
-0.0774520114,
-0.0061872262,
0.0508240052,
-0.0673889667,
-0.0283034611,
-0.0144932512,
-0.0000187476,
0.0129193133,
0.0529717468,
-0.0119964415,
-0.000512108,
0.0445171148,
0.0304007065,
-0.0474949479,
0.0242011268,
0.0407796688,
0.0157789532,
-0.0091789123,
0.0195874497,
-0.0342138968,
0.0259562042,
-0.033182282,
-0.0097757503,
-0.0138797499,
-0.013270312,
0.0044349404,
0.0321048312,
0.0206125434,
-0.014122623,
0.0033938738,
-0.0064058034,
0.0794563591,
0.0095842769,
0.0742046982,
-0.0310577471,
0.0319730602,
0.0005669725,
-0.0045659817,
-0.0031014951,
0.0223706029,
-0.0086833136,
-0.0325685143,
-0.0137640489,
0.0860653892,
-0.0332284532,
-0.0253989156,
0.0262613203,
-0.009941278,
-0.0157399345,
-0.0236529782,
0.0567333512,
0.0016261785,
-0.0337405875,
0.0358489752,
0.0074269404,
0.0327404067,
0.0145158218,
0.0406185016,
-0.0476276316,
0.0155551946,
-0.0332012624,
0.0183129683,
-0.0197861493,
-0.0072803251,
-0.0037515284,
-0.0128108449,
0.0426474251,
-0.0639191568,
0.0245350301,
0.0103416489,
-0.0280565899,
0.0680401772,
0.0176540464,
-0.0305847563,
0.0132545894,
0.0212018229,
0.022111401,
0.0059408676,
0.0100233806,
0.0088706054,
-0.0646001846,
-0.0206554569,
-0.0236799158,
0.0284679402,
-0.0316827856,
-0.0089963581,
0.0063612591,
-0.0383132175,
0.04674704,
-0.0275031142,
0.0447187908,
-0.0589846857,
-0.012132409,
-0.0014644819,
-0.0034301756,
0.0010083494,
0.0251571257,
0.0020586296,
0.0115439007,
-0.0102469893,
-0.005628766,
-6.306399357e-33,
-0.0348690413,
0.0356811509,
0.0105827553,
-0.0622841194,
-0.0152561953,
0.0277278591,
-0.0105355969,
-0.0176512096,
-0.0049045533,
-0.0635967329,
-0.0615336224,
0.0220647417,
0.0368304737,
0.0232364815,
-0.0433923677,
-0.0129811196,
0.0989629701,
-0.0496199504,
0.0049908403,
0.0117406473,
0.0432571694,
0.0512725972,
-0.0131395943,
0.0015592613,
-0.022067111,
-0.0210979227,
0.0152762765,
-0.0137248626,
0.0635888129,
-0.004862586,
-0.0115446877,
0.0172776282,
0.0118114175,
-0.0808293894,
-0.0264280811,
0.0688670948,
-0.1007473618,
0.0279663205,
-0.0139879799,
0.0434597433,
-0.0151294516,
-0.0321632177,
-0.0126266265,
0.0298561994,
-0.0291861314,
-0.0203584209,
-0.0198971219,
-0.0233733151,
-0.041852247,
-0.0373798721,
0.0275007822,
0.0405421034,
-0.0097632548,
-0.0230261236,
0.0766996518,
0.0169256907,
-0.0222480875,
-0.0151036186,
-0.0848683566,
0.0361193419,
0.0266195573,
0.0572799258,
0.0126630375,
0.0052174721,
0.005208937,
-0.0091167251,
0.0131709734,
-0.0782427117,
-0.0156261791,
-0.0066309664,
0.0159631819,
0.0040615178,
0.0196383018,
-0.0107148765,
0.0604618303,
-0.0532891564,
-0.026534535,
-0.0232487544,
0.0326481946,
0.000646635,
0.0433365814,
0.0085807052,
-0.0628497675,
-0.0089927223,
0.0037689558,
-0.0645842776,
-0.0278312098,
-0.0037479331,
0.0720793009,
0.0377989449,
0.0123013174,
-0.0294689555,
0.099828437,
-0.018883206,
0.0583567433,
0.016435137,
0.0343084075,
0.0151205445,
0.0007432661,
0.0305443611,
-0.0502512455,
-0.0143560804,
0.0024965801,
-0.0056001707,
-0.0088041285,
-0.0293198656,
0.0081301695,
0.0801230446,
-0.0788289756,
-0.0160945598,
-0.0143223694,
0.0451081432,
0.0087035093,
0.0348937996,
0.051339291,
-0.0127768284,
0.0135622695,
0.0525237881,
-0.0576545671,
-0.001595951,
-0.0006546747,
-0.0421494506,
-0.0128254015,
0.0170206968,
-0.0338579863,
0.0097886529,
-0.006968441,
0.0554225557,
0.0395257249,
-0.0148717528,
-0.0034885581,
0.0260153599,
2.784e-7,
-0.0746887848,
-0.0015589318,
0.0498949289,
-0.0158546586,
0.0222583916,
-0.0212078579,
0.0145654632,
0.0239016935,
-0.014584397,
0.0052001528,
-0.0055880458,
-0.0216151197,
0.0647984818,
0.0050791767,
-0.1313851178,
0.012368287,
-0.0373860262,
0.0341825224,
0.0025146636,
-0.0150325047,
0.0426890217,
0.1007073075,
-0.0397129133,
-0.0131427571,
0.0027431052,
0.020538792,
-0.0097362176,
0.0035285088,
0.0049599707,
-0.0357391499,
-0.0044947099,
-0.0046286178,
-0.0492697321,
0.0242674984,
-0.0287684146,
0.046196077,
-0.0224427935,
0.0229867399,
0.0271893069,
-0.049936004,
0.0283548813,
0.0357160829,
-0.0395088457,
0.020888539,
0.0602606684,
0.0502617061,
0.0131679429,
-0.0296944492,
-0.0546517186,
-0.0130544379,
-0.0477144606,
0.0104783569,
0.0511174798,
0.0193763673,
-0.0019799457,
-0.0262082145,
-0.0035565435,
-0.0604393557,
0.0260767955,
-0.0497377887,
-0.0527482331,
-0.030417379,
-0.0410239995,
0.0442003794,
0.0532953739,
-0.0284300335,
-0.0028060272,
2.354858879e-34,
0.0305954255,
-0.0028542264,
0.0092399176,
0.0216947291,
-0.0360277668,
-0.0594568476,
0.0377021655,
0.0273022056,
0.0050491211,
-0.0998546556,
-0.0621999539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17807v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17807v1 | Enhancing Commentary Strategies for Imperfect Information Card Games: A Study of Large Language Models in Guandan Commentary | 2024-06-23T11:58:26 | 2024-06-23T11:58:26 | Meiling Tao. Xuechen Liang, Yiling Tao, Tianyu Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have unlocked the
potential for generating high-quality game commentary. However, producing
insightful and engaging commentary for complex games with incomplete
information remains a significant challenge. In this paper, we introduce a
novel commentary method that combine Reinforcement Learning (RL) and LLMs,
tailored specifically for the Chinese card game \textit{Guandan}. Our system
leverages RL to generate intricate card-playing scenarios and employs LLMs to
generate corresponding commentary text, effectively emulating the strategic
analysis and narrative prowess of professional commentators. The framework
comprises a state commentary guide, a Theory of Mind (ToM)-based strategy
analyzer, and a style retrieval module, which seamlessly collaborate to deliver
detailed and context-relevant game commentary in the Chinese language
environment. We empower LLMs with ToM capabilities and refine both retrieval
and information filtering mechanisms. This facilitates the generation of
personalized commentary content. Our experimental results showcase the
substantial enhancement in performance achieved by the proposed commentary
framework when applied to open-source LLMs, surpassing the performance of GPT-4
across multiple evaluation metrics. | [
0.0614123084,
0.0451703295,
-0.0380253233,
0.0506401397,
0.000486266,
-0.0008233191,
-0.0404805839,
0.0213220529,
-0.0330672264,
0.0015030989,
-0.0351537503,
-0.0187152941,
0.0238321666,
0.0479751639,
0.0132553875,
-0.0578144789,
-0.0062931073,
-0.0194969121,
0.0538740344,
-0.0016025286,
0.0136989933,
0.0135887852,
-0.0038717899,
0.0519097187,
0.0165718365,
-0.0241602752,
-0.0464580879,
0.0206505358,
0.0227837041,
-0.0652293488,
-0.0164705589,
-0.0102568651,
0.0050784522,
0.010508256,
0.0000021565,
-0.0364409722,
-0.0048832376,
-0.0575991943,
0.0620332621,
0.0041614212,
0.0674808919,
0.0289846137,
0.0323080048,
-0.0100197876,
-0.0558155216,
-0.027521858,
0.0737661868,
0.0876284987,
0.0776029676,
0.0665766671,
0.0002014781,
-0.0337547511,
-0.0066591967,
-0.008744902,
0.0405737087,
-0.0834937841,
-0.011067614,
0.0246840473,
0.0139767388,
-0.0213360153,
-0.0103943581,
0.0050917501,
-0.0188135859,
-0.0204262398,
-0.021576371,
0.0336741842,
0.0550492965,
0.0661188811,
0.0058630798,
0.0369451642,
0.0448257327,
0.0033028228,
-0.0045665945,
-0.0067210272,
0.0215357058,
0.0040887222,
-0.0241008084,
0.0300163366,
-0.0054432312,
0.0092737144,
0.0109028406,
0.0097170006,
0.0227424726,
0.0301206112,
-0.0129487514,
0.0011005092,
-0.0329491608,
-0.0566012599,
-0.0490528531,
0.0010665712,
-0.0256589595,
-0.0682553127,
-0.0527076125,
0.0443599746,
-0.0829055607,
0.0052261385,
0.0417974107,
0.0167297125,
-0.0172914509,
-0.0182395317,
0.0793265104,
0.0518695898,
0.0258548427,
0.0334923342,
0.0303562433,
0.0090336669,
0.0040059523,
-0.0012621079,
-0.0534574091,
0.0115137817,
-0.0584366731,
-0.0308507755,
-0.0382360704,
0.0639495477,
-0.0391696729,
-0.0431778915,
-0.0389172845,
-0.0068378369,
-0.0261924267,
0.057758864,
-0.0099753272,
0.028382251,
0.0053003868,
0.0322025642,
-0.0767470077,
0.0149109047,
-0.0438724309,
-0.0266086236,
0.0195659697,
-0.0056221103,
-0.0111508109,
-0.0019858188,
-0.0065223845,
-0.0179766007,
0.0145436367,
0.0347625427,
-0.003835228,
0.009185004,
-0.0131320553,
0.0084676314,
0.0004711974,
-0.078567192,
0.0067701237,
-0.0475803725,
-0.0283652432,
-0.0412708521,
0.0091917841,
0.0054253615,
0.0067989905,
0.0285434518,
0.0071563306,
0.0438903309,
-0.0118791154,
-0.0056097219,
0.0046587684,
0.0051315101,
0.01823451,
0.071508646,
0.0418215543,
0.0117881401,
0.0158376638,
0.0088404631,
0.0247409884,
0.0192869771,
-0.0245212,
-0.0216608029,
-0.0543936044,
0.0024952234,
-0.0020477476,
0.0575735942,
-0.0012114097,
0.0288883634,
-0.0488650203,
0.0674671978,
0.0784367248,
0.027044978,
0.0421949774,
0.0431194939,
0.0786061659,
0.0424946919,
-0.0129473004,
0.0289835799,
-0.0075075114,
0.0641742423,
0.0289143063,
0.0246904269,
0.0330581032,
-0.005136658,
-0.002313274,
-0.0846007243,
0.0214167908,
-0.0179851837,
0.0376295783,
0.0200552773,
0.019668214,
-0.0146479206,
-0.0507163666,
0.0057178228,
0.039249599,
-0.0215994753,
-0.0215616021,
-0.0685369149,
0.0605780147,
0.1166290417,
0.056944374,
-0.0520875379,
-0.0062082238,
-0.0386331938,
-0.0476414226,
0.0780725032,
0.0369214043,
-0.0032718482,
-0.0184174422,
-0.0722821131,
-0.023806097,
-0.0456895158,
0.0272580348,
0.0610213503,
-0.0150047168,
0.0362647548,
0.0047116578,
0.0464656837,
-0.0364614166,
-0.0014345974,
0.0241792593,
-0.0893918574,
-0.0053942576,
-0.0040800832,
0.0166535359,
0.0413026921,
-0.0430685915,
0.0232659075,
0.0018589859,
0.0085867606,
-0.0310684387,
0.0340927802,
-0.0449545048,
-0.0185976792,
0.0342912339,
-0.037261311,
-0.0141814901,
-0.0069638891,
-0.004127787,
-0.0353718959,
0.0251184367,
-0.0285977088,
0.0355514586,
-0.0410492085,
-0.0296427421,
-0.0248056501,
0.0060875029,
-0.0025746897,
0.0649952963,
-0.0119335456,
0.0154157458,
0.0174127296,
-0.0565237962,
0.0201049242,
-0.0196772292,
0.0365791619,
0.0164202433,
0.0253075771,
0.0088769151,
0.0436532237,
0.0768225417,
-0.0147331888,
-0.0360165909,
-0.0918647498,
0.00684619,
-0.0044129947,
-0.0110327313,
0.0101136472,
-0.013647873,
-0.026754247,
0.0183034148,
-0.0375014283,
-0.0297148861,
0.0269022081,
-0.0091863414,
0.0363896713,
0.0632835999,
0.0257888827,
-0.0083225556,
0.0225246716,
-0.0158865396,
0.0213661697,
0.0121798273,
-0.0222913492,
-0.0443939716,
-0.0459020957,
-0.0361740813,
0.0144556528,
-0.0354180187,
-0.0416009538,
0.0389880724,
-0.0319764242,
-0.0234395992,
0.0145492842,
0.0028458233,
0.0158428401,
0.0570508242,
-0.0493401401,
-0.012946629,
0.0546733066,
0.0090585342,
-0.0345706716,
-0.0365858711,
-0.0385693572,
0.019433273,
0.0632800534,
-0.020434672,
0.0290584639,
-0.0905187204,
0.0232151188,
0.0179679394,
-0.007116043,
-0.0032805689,
-0.02063022,
-0.0211087931,
0.0109946132,
-0.028466098,
0.0384897366,
0.0642227978,
-0.0166183561,
-0.0172236096,
-0.0545486957,
0.0119028445,
-0.0562191382,
0.0703832507,
-0.0055729318,
0.038284272,
-0.002196752,
-0.0226281304,
-0.0364034213,
-0.0404643416,
0.0573351979,
-0.0216946583,
0.0106562041,
-0.0174961537,
-0.0420961194,
0.0106253242,
-0.0167622883,
-0.0009971219,
-0.0069203228,
-0.0380149707,
-0.0060081533,
0.0747832507,
-0.0231223162,
-0.055008918,
-0.0077333744,
0.042957224,
0.0062811584,
-0.0287944879,
-0.0378814079,
-0.0013403725,
-0.0019705219,
0.0685704425,
-0.0039262078,
0.0188594423,
-0.0656969994,
0.0541352294,
0.0340438262,
-0.0377342366,
-0.0205258019,
0.0328993127,
-0.0189354103,
0.0435535423,
-0.0042673238,
-0.027891431,
0.0480869599,
0.007648462,
-0.0646580309,
0.0040258504,
0.1205869988,
0.0349631086,
-0.0571957119,
-0.0380728208,
-0.0362941325,
0.009823285,
0.0008000351,
0.0327136889,
-0.0939737633,
0.0091504883,
-0.0018132424,
0.0128486445,
-0.0229040012,
-0.0213450715,
0.0020862825,
-0.1299693435,
0.0215978846,
0.0058458382,
-0.029301662,
-0.0192921627,
0.021063773,
-0.0171660334,
0.03681916,
-0.0309013147,
0.0082340864,
-0.016954679,
0.0166381449,
-0.006060224,
-0.0224551074,
0.0042738961,
0.0035204184,
-0.0432750955,
0.0383223668,
0.0752924383,
0.0904532447,
-0.0036462063,
-0.0493060537,
0.0063212947,
0.0259834658,
0.0090985233,
-0.0121460948,
0.0576753765,
-0.0418851413,
0.0305909254,
-0.0146710435,
-0.005405541,
0.0406955928,
0.0105597395,
0.049342297,
0.0202338323,
0.0201511923,
-0.0155605022,
0.0067016473,
0.0372260436,
0.0337548703,
0.0509708561,
0.0254202392,
-0.0711360723,
0.0094231945,
-0.0302820951,
0.0142440917,
-0.0714346543,
-0.0282810815,
-0.0151667539,
0.0161880534,
0.0027268671,
-0.08381363,
-0.0683831796,
-0.0432822034,
0.0237859357,
0.0239279903,
0.0642339438,
-0.0329105668,
0.012966942,
0.006211041,
-0.0227151141,
-0.0475594886,
-0.0190596245,
-0.0015383363,
-0.0380943306,
-0.0051922752,
-0.1052757874,
0.0174909495,
0.0318159424,
0.0123715037,
-0.0014036692,
-0.0287959836,
0.0655564591,
0.0167017933,
0.0256734006,
0.0166666489,
-0.0296203587,
0.0099300547,
-0.006352515,
-0.0297356322,
-0.0007622316,
0.0267652497,
0.0577904172,
0.0097205201,
0.0185768567,
-0.0321496576,
-0.0199728832,
0.0029291995,
0.0476878807,
-0.0330736265,
0.0107062496,
0.0302443039,
-0.025233008,
0.0180609077,
-0.0405724905,
-0.0180027205,
-0.0089914845,
0.0215810295,
-0.0557577983,
-0.042347692,
-0.035533011,
-0.0305601545,
0.048558414,
0.0087871514,
-0.0033038903,
-0.0300365724,
0.0013647166,
-0.0148479566,
-0.0378056318,
0.02680148,
0.0386242606,
-0.0042899009,
-0.0134997265,
0.0049670148,
-0.0125943292,
-0.0030067735,
-0.0039984337,
0.0279080551,
0.0205554571,
0.0859612525,
0.0506443046,
-0.0696167052,
0.0273237806,
0.0003745813,
-0.0311944783,
-0.04659082,
0.0366515256,
0.0235036742,
0.0981778651,
-0.0240351073,
0.0025996489,
-0.0419742242,
0.0050483542,
0.0407337137,
-0.0236688014,
0.0047901263,
-0.0662318692,
-0.0427467972,
0.0232990943,
-0.0154711939,
-0.0151524134,
0.0282822624,
0.0068693785,
0.0143373255,
-0.0104005877,
-0.0475273319,
-0.0344287939,
0.0009682059,
-0.0073889876,
0.0909857601,
-0.0350474641,
0.0200720262,
-0.0944195539,
-0.0022299618,
0.0096906051,
0.0427853055,
-0.0143452995,
-0.0102254013,
0.0337536708,
0.0211739298,
0.0192378238,
-0.0106013874,
-0.0556290038,
0.0221316293,
-0.0516677201,
-0.0197626352,
-0.0085813366,
-6.220841736e-33,
-0.0386119857,
-0.0300425943,
0.0500253923,
0.0104366783,
-0.0323090106,
-0.0176686142,
-0.0629468486,
-0.00497708,
0.0274468716,
0.0331694633,
-0.0249387473,
-0.0251698401,
-0.0076415516,
0.0244299658,
0.0109977117,
-0.0357814915,
0.0389475897,
0.0119125945,
-0.0322510488,
0.012501548,
0.0271278471,
0.0223363489,
0.038946446,
-0.1040712297,
0.0202970654,
-0.0303793214,
-0.0072838757,
0.0209020637,
-0.0027156093,
0.0367409252,
0.0013080498,
-0.014968981,
0.0034660441,
-0.0437214784,
0.0086163394,
-0.0273162294,
-0.0146689452,
-0.0332819782,
0.0371456482,
-0.0251598917,
0.0163835716,
-0.0433029048,
-0.0092672808,
0.0165975653,
0.0042541088,
0.0045493543,
0.0579554699,
-0.0240040664,
0.0182971414,
-0.0423518568,
-0.0568089597,
0.0145821832,
-0.0356414095,
0.0009389374,
0.0123750726,
0.0272221528,
0.0043508178,
-0.0205707457,
-0.0478099026,
0.0315851085,
0.0506211296,
0.0067142276,
0.0168835856,
0.032430917,
0.0424229838,
0.0288619753,
0.0196140781,
0.0277336948,
-0.0774246082,
-0.0035477825,
0.0118168434,
0.017474765,
0.0277268011,
0.0395985395,
-0.0081122257,
-0.029985562,
-0.0406833887,
0.0294928849,
0.0353908427,
0.0857660919,
0.053760644,
0.0273764897,
-0.048968263,
0.0071485443,
-0.0184283797,
-0.0363480635,
-0.0189084988,
-0.0453988947,
-0.0076309,
0.0125891604,
-0.0039736233,
-0.0240995511,
0.0085006151,
-0.0159090199,
-0.0079706199,
-0.0070978291,
-0.0421170965,
0.0455049723,
-0.0356985666,
-0.0098439371,
-0.0389362499,
-0.003385447,
0.0007872069,
-0.0207185801,
0.0093594939,
0.0403596982,
0.0282925721,
0.0539161414,
-0.0644861013,
0.0163241737,
-0.017602168,
0.0396654718,
-0.005236859,
-0.038415771,
-0.0093664322,
-0.0065715555,
-0.0164298769,
-0.0253639463,
0.0056790202,
-0.0178610645,
-0.0138681969,
-0.0232715774,
-0.0221176688,
-0.0138179967,
-0.0039152224,
0.0353976823,
-0.0183173958,
0.0654721111,
0.008826945,
-0.0265784971,
-0.0255721454,
0.0178797785,
3.091e-7,
-0.0167306904,
0.0539631993,
-0.0440055318,
-0.0143455043,
0.0006043084,
0.0646856576,
-0.0405254848,
-0.0173885301,
0.0189326704,
0.0044819475,
0.0789294094,
0.0659814328,
0.0346512906,
0.0111367265,
-0.1337727755,
-0.0146719962,
-0.0424830355,
-0.028626319,
-0.0256781783,
0.0371584818,
0.0276977178,
0.0288584903,
0.04350904,
-0.0067871176,
0.0141469697,
-0.0117050083,
0.0406922437,
-0.0530898049,
0.0067347041,
0.0221680254,
0.0264102537,
-0.0107041895,
-0.0587303638,
-0.0521762073,
0.0070340247,
0.0463292785,
0.0130279474,
0.0405104794,
0.0105148181,
0.0139841959,
0.0167525411,
0.0290756244,
-0.0109262159,
-0.079322964,
0.0238160398,
0.0191315934,
-0.0378989168,
-0.0246776715,
-0.0263108369,
-0.0205926821,
0.0250959415,
-0.0199318025,
-0.0437616631,
0.0189500432,
-0.0390664712,
-0.0131073277,
0.0161975827,
-0.051156763,
0.003919031,
-0.0022107405,
-0.0015803012,
-0.0080705201,
-0.0395467579,
0.0200956948,
-0.0325189047,
-0.0753111318,
0.028797932,
2.753976634e-34,
0.0160083529,
-0.0360423476,
-0.0087372558,
-0.0354568772,
0.0792209506,
0.0169344284,
-0.0312380865,
0.0306504052,
0.0674549043,
-0.0419392847,
-0.0165267233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16086v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16086v1 | SEAM: A Stochastic Benchmark for Multi-Document Tasks | 2024-06-23T11:57:53 | 2024-06-23T11:57:53 | Gili Lior, Avi Caciularu, Arie Cattan, Shahar Levy, Ori Shapira, Gabriel Stanovsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Various tasks, such as summarization, multi-hop question answering, or
coreference resolution, are naturally phrased over collections of real-world
documents. Such tasks present a unique set of challenges, revolving around the
lack of coherent narrative structure across documents, which often leads to
contradiction, omission, or repetition of information. Despite their real-world
application and challenging properties, there is currently no benchmark which
specifically measures the abilities of large language models (LLMs) on
multi-document tasks. To bridge this gap, we present SEAM (a Stochastic
Evaluation Approach for Multi-document tasks), a conglomerate benchmark over a
diverse set of multi-document datasets, setting conventional evaluation
criteria, input-output formats, and evaluation protocols. In particular, SEAM
addresses the sensitivity of LLMs to minor prompt variations through repeated
evaluations, where in each evaluation we sample uniformly at random the values
of arbitrary factors (e.g., the order of documents). We evaluate different LLMs
on SEAM finding that multi-document tasks pose a significant challenge for
LLMs, even for state-of-the-art models with 70B parameters. In addition, we
show that the stochastic approach uncovers underlying statistical trends which
cannot be observed in a static benchmark. We hope that SEAM will spur progress
via consistent and meaningful evaluation of multi-document tasks. | [
0.0149200112,
0.0311973672,
0.0318103731,
0.0198899694,
-0.0516823716,
0.0060320287,
0.0191397686,
-0.0315031037,
0.0028509705,
-0.0393377878,
-0.0263191387,
-0.0403132923,
0.023763638,
0.0021438994,
0.0069200704,
-0.0262209438,
0.0432487279,
-0.0560201257,
0.0028212594,
-0.0133887464,
-0.0034636157,
0.0132503184,
0.0033350869,
0.0293231383,
0.0084218532,
-0.0363327041,
0.009664312,
0.0019368184,
0.0167846084,
0.0064295046,
0.0114745554,
0.0403585881,
0.0156405792,
0.0427546427,
0.0000017586,
-0.0570287481,
-0.0078121834,
0.0097492933,
-0.0216128863,
0.0326524489,
0.0259436853,
-0.0154323475,
0.0156460982,
0.0030397363,
-0.0182124712,
0.0149995023,
-0.0052198926,
0.05408765,
0.0477744564,
0.0608047657,
0.0034884869,
-0.0174012687,
0.0190391298,
-0.0397877954,
-0.0108091244,
-0.0777446553,
0.0145536168,
0.0202603117,
0.0401897021,
-0.0108551597,
-0.0072829388,
0.036966376,
0.0312327482,
0.0027091422,
-0.0291170813,
0.0449859984,
-0.0509598851,
0.0238788072,
-0.0121056242,
0.0982108116,
0.0042613251,
0.0244774558,
0.0090326257,
0.0034111592,
-0.010548831,
-0.0024072502,
-0.0853338987,
0.0258553624,
-0.0105736544,
0.0003228993,
0.0043930737,
-0.00458659,
0.0352973156,
0.0186228566,
-0.022954477,
0.0628052354,
0.0281693786,
-0.0115478253,
0.010242112,
0.0149656069,
-0.0336708091,
-0.0657858998,
0.0022635767,
0.0275690705,
-0.0540583059,
0.0108923884,
-0.0753712803,
-0.0145231318,
0.0289801601,
-0.0468865,
0.0283358078,
0.0081931148,
-0.0028857556,
0.1203182042,
-0.0281285383,
0.0477036275,
-0.0100780642,
0.0048165158,
-0.0368283689,
-0.0292277411,
-0.0473297164,
0.0169696864,
-0.0123613989,
0.0415511243,
-0.0551007986,
-0.0610538237,
0.0015238287,
0.0257754643,
0.0047747018,
0.0012280376,
0.0114346324,
-0.0015370047,
-0.0203382019,
-0.0171294957,
-0.0096096909,
0.0280836038,
-0.0544198677,
-0.0013254889,
0.028612433,
-0.035732381,
-0.0383221991,
0.0227742661,
0.0093280207,
-0.0243998989,
0.0060325726,
0.0346534662,
-0.0462743416,
-0.0172028895,
-0.0113678463,
-0.0451461561,
-0.0283945631,
-0.0657248497,
-0.0160293076,
-0.0823947713,
0.0470949523,
0.011215467,
-0.0065650931,
-0.0228205603,
-0.0039033473,
0.017279679,
-0.0573962815,
0.0443043895,
0.0650047362,
0.014855477,
0.029368395,
0.0062127383,
0.0093723554,
0.0918650255,
0.0442051888,
0.0132660102,
0.065211542,
0.0396478921,
-0.0165159553,
0.0457786694,
0.0121526783,
0.0481593683,
0.0310464893,
0.0209884662,
-0.0086237192,
0.0314297862,
0.0357297063,
0.07077346,
-0.0547041707,
-0.0359811895,
0.0609048009,
0.0483710282,
-0.0012786161,
-0.0356459916,
0.035530325,
-0.0094668744,
0.0282250699,
0.0579904988,
-0.0374333523,
0.0321671143,
-0.0189373624,
0.0321816728,
0.094416596,
0.0094479211,
-0.052193515,
-0.0052810065,
-0.0298525263,
-0.0099569149,
-0.017901158,
0.001941507,
0.0418267548,
-0.0002516466,
-0.0582711361,
0.0289414749,
0.0005345427,
-0.0447163619,
0.0100267669,
-0.0305012874,
0.0159978308,
0.0436077602,
0.0725442171,
-0.0197847169,
-0.0343789682,
-0.0215425324,
0.0520456806,
0.0329141431,
0.0586048029,
-0.0255202521,
0.0409518741,
-0.0374178439,
-0.0192121882,
-0.0266462956,
0.004315557,
0.0377625786,
0.0263157096,
-0.0086494582,
0.0153127434,
-0.0734992325,
0.0009228868,
0.0262072254,
-0.0469553508,
-0.0148260863,
0.0081831263,
-0.0175503325,
0.0121478653,
0.0033835329,
-0.027018372,
0.0219225064,
0.0239621401,
-0.0290901531,
-0.02447428,
-0.0088142883,
-0.0458599329,
-0.0404182002,
0.0337729827,
-0.0496937521,
-0.0353987217,
0.0133819208,
-0.0368686877,
-0.0674216896,
0.0094131595,
-0.0274229161,
0.0002512828,
-0.0373142622,
-0.0044050911,
0.0321323313,
0.0245460179,
-0.0281554945,
0.0529598333,
-0.0171748605,
0.0316306278,
0.0187926888,
0.0185020249,
0.0143570546,
-0.0487765409,
-0.0183560383,
0.017178718,
0.0052332268,
0.0102818562,
0.0402305052,
0.0096640317,
-0.0215728804,
-0.0628204271,
-0.1124510095,
0.0258280095,
-0.0394164845,
0.0288394913,
0.0287054926,
0.0160690621,
0.0002999923,
-0.005553924,
-0.035669636,
-0.0259304158,
0.028549131,
0.0467077345,
0.0088688703,
0.0151850712,
0.0203926917,
-0.051818762,
-0.0351750813,
-0.0059949639,
0.0758066773,
-0.0082996031,
0.0063407104,
-0.0227385014,
-0.0014857391,
-0.0310443901,
0.0060214736,
-0.0210885964,
-0.0010752232,
0.0141786225,
-0.0229109135,
0.08864595,
0.0686844438,
0.0042675091,
0.0128927361,
0.0450800806,
-0.0344603881,
-0.0645118877,
0.0157804117,
-0.0055033118,
0.0000130539,
-0.0388762355,
-0.0303075984,
0.0140481079,
0.0584770143,
0.0214251,
0.0016975786,
-0.0386002213,
0.0179072246,
-0.0120925,
-0.0164975058,
-0.0366788581,
-0.0183150861,
-0.005280497,
0.0237655304,
-0.0308512244,
-0.0120560117,
0.0721365958,
-0.0452903621,
-0.0028469558,
-0.033596687,
0.0116057387,
-0.063627623,
0.0575086921,
-0.0078328652,
0.002563274,
-0.0210517179,
-0.0228169113,
-0.03740279,
-0.0038827891,
0.0226555355,
-0.0327024087,
0.0572793111,
-0.0532567054,
0.0399560928,
-0.021769423,
-0.0309228078,
-0.0125120049,
-0.0320567973,
-0.0204507299,
0.0179504342,
0.0050136833,
0.0055110203,
-0.0476958528,
0.0046084155,
0.0345425382,
0.0655855462,
-0.0426816493,
-0.0147905657,
-0.0205359664,
0.0884906873,
0.064380914,
0.0029424871,
0.0442641564,
-0.0762728378,
0.02819659,
0.0355222709,
0.0520776846,
0.0102090109,
-0.0053244592,
-0.0090519981,
-0.0044927909,
-0.0410285778,
0.0008031518,
-0.018342467,
0.0546040237,
-0.0400517732,
-0.0185824111,
0.115227066,
0.0253628846,
-0.0312855951,
-0.0171188246,
0.007074845,
0.0409231856,
0.0022560803,
0.0136223678,
-0.0656294152,
-0.0380477272,
-0.0006478248,
0.0284997988,
0.0144279292,
-0.04841711,
0.002596505,
-0.0830882117,
0.0086266482,
-0.0129077109,
-0.0309937,
-0.0158738457,
-0.0431712456,
0.0164793041,
-0.002862267,
0.0453766882,
0.0132094882,
-0.0112043303,
-0.005113129,
-0.0179024804,
-0.0377003402,
-0.0121253254,
0.0563037507,
-0.0273463558,
0.0168563258,
0.0514651574,
0.0179399718,
0.0066966075,
0.0157532487,
0.0427787602,
-0.0198578313,
-0.0176694319,
0.0192821268,
0.0535332598,
-0.0119190961,
0.0082550291,
-0.0061825239,
0.0425778665,
-0.0342677459,
0.0067362813,
0.0030267313,
0.0250350274,
0.0098186415,
-0.0387607142,
-0.0356125906,
0.0043298118,
-0.0008445907,
0.1080057919,
0.0231366679,
-0.0234022681,
-0.0663233325,
-0.0264463332,
-0.0094189271,
-0.0519095287,
0.0074083186,
0.0116425836,
-0.0001423675,
0.0176793188,
-0.0787202194,
-0.0640565231,
0.0176289491,
0.025284281,
-0.0240991227,
-0.0038204114,
-0.0001469282,
-0.0004570093,
-0.0239125658,
0.0209798384,
-0.0334399864,
0.0213337,
-0.0735122263,
0.039569322,
0.064955309,
0.0051665413,
-0.0233731046,
0.0645421222,
-0.1292106956,
-0.0617492162,
-0.0208208617,
0.0038156284,
0.0216246732,
0.0619448051,
-0.0368662849,
-0.0515575744,
0.037841022,
-0.0111825923,
-0.0273759514,
0.055697009,
0.0229526367,
-0.0001663282,
-0.0188712943,
0.0502112731,
-0.0716948956,
0.0082572876,
-0.0141900508,
0.0540483296,
0.0002801515,
-0.0577648766,
-0.0335353538,
0.0164299607,
-0.0038551919,
0.007176517,
0.0192502234,
-0.0106324432,
-0.002266557,
-0.0136431037,
-0.0232402571,
-0.0196602736,
0.0051569263,
0.0139081553,
-0.0404311307,
-0.004062268,
0.0801301822,
0.0134891504,
0.0459423065,
-0.0301436279,
-0.0294323619,
0.0136123765,
-0.0306868851,
-0.0054636006,
-0.0297131948,
-0.0318860039,
-0.0092498465,
-0.0254884437,
0.051339522,
-0.0128560122,
0.0319818743,
0.026083691,
-0.0074804756,
0.0109808408,
0.0030277497,
-0.1163855419,
-0.014550996,
-0.0358070806,
0.0258387029,
0.0300606042,
-0.0085816113,
0.100916177,
-0.0092340345,
-0.0155999605,
-0.0522646643,
-0.0051587126,
0.0258992016,
0.0316232666,
-0.0048123188,
0.0335546546,
0.0072126123,
0.0683478341,
0.1070489138,
0.0223298129,
0.0325268432,
0.0078992052,
-0.0070542558,
-0.0322141238,
-0.0527417734,
-0.0332646295,
0.0330245271,
-0.013870487,
-0.0005803953,
-0.0536761619,
-0.0135279326,
0.0397000201,
0.0429073051,
-0.0044549201,
-0.0075105731,
0.0168020595,
0.0729468316,
0.0083329454,
0.0279996935,
-0.0467490219,
-0.0027809909,
-0.0000698246,
-0.0261868723,
-0.0056049917,
-6.249888936e-33,
-0.0386908464,
-0.0015195264,
0.0035316697,
-0.0102776969,
-0.0076413853,
0.0164196305,
-0.0645403117,
0.0103806397,
-0.0183113273,
0.0132186618,
-0.031027494,
0.0138797145,
0.0135912038,
0.0441745035,
-0.0062105395,
-0.0058614584,
0.0397700183,
-0.0083242254,
-0.0543943569,
0.0265653897,
0.047533039,
-0.0040075164,
0.0509914607,
-0.0104296124,
0.0280372836,
-0.0173337478,
-0.0198320579,
-0.0017366364,
0.0382173322,
0.0547221601,
-0.0231880117,
0.0106299156,
0.0248892065,
-0.0404365361,
-0.0521824807,
0.0164861605,
-0.0886336714,
-0.0407542884,
0.0224442668,
-0.0199019276,
-0.055422239,
-0.0213892534,
0.0205839053,
0.0079639573,
0.0206227843,
-0.051736787,
0.0241294447,
-0.0054169334,
-0.0498251803,
-0.0398470908,
-0.0283943452,
0.0380460806,
-0.0284607802,
-0.0306525715,
-0.0083871223,
0.0318854377,
-0.0016146449,
0.0269844402,
-0.04923876,
0.0053300275,
-0.0054186182,
0.0304739047,
0.0432506017,
0.0073955059,
-0.0063432427,
0.0544253588,
-0.011965544,
0.0021194981,
-0.0254488196,
-0.0162281934,
0.0248584617,
0.0146421166,
0.0080745844,
0.0596098192,
0.0207088217,
0.0655398443,
-0.0732212961,
0.0692706481,
0.0441670828,
0.0116902124,
0.0361667387,
0.0085560502,
-0.0204464365,
-0.0159997791,
-0.0636054575,
0.0191734396,
-0.0182574056,
-0.0015749565,
0.0259906054,
0.0089476937,
-0.0055199768,
-0.0205428023,
0.0677736029,
-0.0409507416,
-0.0257064383,
0.045315221,
-0.006697651,
0.0322401673,
0.0130494861,
0.0582349114,
-0.0247700699,
0.0275453273,
0.0207394548,
0.0337050632,
-0.0058856285,
-0.0059497938,
0.0265342258,
-0.0205203649,
-0.067181319,
0.0050853551,
-0.0122528933,
0.0289241187,
-0.0526720509,
0.0017574492,
0.0264220908,
-0.0173284113,
0.0054105334,
0.0624965355,
-0.0252893623,
-0.0030281637,
-0.0200858396,
-0.0187745895,
0.0266590733,
0.0151163284,
-0.0206845347,
0.0102752186,
-0.0523016714,
-0.0049493825,
0.0242959745,
-0.0150693497,
0.0121970428,
0.0673888251,
2.441e-7,
0.0372042656,
0.0291955136,
0.0532236546,
0.028407326,
0.0247314926,
0.0156081812,
-0.0416331291,
0.0245725326,
0.0012154789,
-0.0468871742,
-0.0069555468,
0.0430621356,
0.0775243342,
0.0332486816,
-0.0885603875,
-0.0307245925,
-0.071576409,
0.0031504135,
-0.0587087348,
-0.0710189566,
0.0154575175,
0.0831595212,
-0.0018897387,
0.0029196744,
-0.0282875076,
-0.04083753,
0.0761919469,
-0.0116616599,
-0.0490639098,
0.0343432873,
0.0140142264,
-0.0016139944,
0.0034386234,
-0.0080435015,
-0.0094072549,
0.0109509071,
0.0591761358,
0.0877828076,
0.0284026247,
-0.04218987,
-0.0072232266,
-0.0436210297,
0.0129127782,
-0.0152816474,
0.0904654115,
-0.0355948508,
-0.0058773984,
-0.0496719442,
-0.0190126486,
-0.0045065363,
0.0259137359,
-0.0107366294,
-0.0290780999,
0.05127085,
-0.0026946319,
-0.0121385744,
0.0069463956,
-0.0740938112,
-0.0231989697,
0.0179149732,
-0.0413132943,
-0.0531780608,
-0.0126431556,
-0.0128819952,
0.0040263138,
-0.0730758235,
-0.0234111436,
2.439904288e-34,
0.0950545445,
-0.0039418843,
-0.0072653103,
-0.0003880515,
0.0261418372,
-0.0239225868,
-0.0495684259,
-0.0248135775,
-0.005934183,
-0.1167424619,
-0.0053224359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16079v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16079v1 | EERPD: Leveraging Emotion and Emotion Regulation for Improving Personality Detection | 2024-06-23T11:18:55 | 2024-06-23T11:18:55 | Zheng Li, Dawei Zhu, Qilong Ma, Weimin Xiong, Sujian Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Personality is a fundamental construct in psychology, reflecting an
individual's behavior, thinking, and emotional patterns. Previous researches
have made some progress in personality detection, primarily by utilizing the
whole text to predict personality. However, these studies generally tend to
overlook psychological knowledge: they rarely apply the well-established
correlations between emotion regulation and personality. Based on this, we
propose a new personality detection method called EERPD. This method introduces
the use of emotion regulation, a psychological concept highly correlated with
personality, for personality prediction. By combining this feature with emotion
features, it retrieves few-shot examples and provides process CoTs for
inferring labels from text. This approach enhances the understanding of LLM for
personality within text and improves the performance in personality detection.
Experimental results demonstrate that EERPD significantly enhances the accuracy
and robustness of personality detection, outperforming previous SOTA by
15.05/4.29 in average F1 on the two benchmark datasets. | [
0.0257194582,
0.0255516116,
-0.0441885628,
0.0083098151,
-0.0045458865,
0.0032977855,
0.0261024591,
-0.003951441,
0.0160187315,
0.000458825,
-0.0350712352,
0.0073278444,
-0.0219343342,
-0.0190869495,
-0.0120778689,
-0.0396251976,
0.0230423938,
0.0364762545,
0.0736166462,
0.0104521951,
0.0284164883,
0.0591191314,
0.0000770541,
0.0388697833,
-0.039725028,
-0.0286387503,
0.0095573096,
0.0084282858,
0.0595741123,
-0.0381805003,
0.0621487051,
0.036158178,
-0.0164642595,
-0.0403678752,
0.0000021465,
-0.035623949,
-0.0546943098,
-0.0155772064,
0.0203996822,
-0.0353057645,
0.0698419213,
-0.0003844761,
0.0174134187,
0.0446198247,
-0.0348086394,
-0.0167696681,
0.0095467465,
0.0961694941,
0.0776731223,
0.0578905903,
-0.0200620703,
-0.0154949967,
-0.0397752821,
0.0235080402,
0.0339755826,
-0.0152011057,
0.0302952677,
-0.0683765039,
-0.0409698188,
-0.0193301551,
-0.0078976918,
-0.0279543437,
-0.0476526991,
0.0248334333,
-0.01865541,
-0.0131665282,
-0.0169889312,
-0.0276434999,
0.0117058391,
0.0448587872,
0.0155133707,
-0.0190459117,
0.0113022476,
-0.0246809255,
0.015397287,
0.00531465,
0.039686162,
-0.010445416,
-0.030796811,
-0.0162220765,
0.0058299182,
0.0122941788,
-0.0316802971,
0.0004460655,
-0.0119670182,
0.0324667022,
-0.0266241375,
-0.0475526862,
0.0348660685,
-0.0140709477,
0.0384107791,
-0.0262988023,
-0.0020027978,
0.0135683054,
0.0097681917,
0.0081224134,
-0.0856684893,
-0.0135284392,
0.0011020349,
-0.0227273908,
-0.0473712683,
-0.0141694583,
-0.029991325,
0.0045369882,
0.0485101566,
0.0263870247,
0.0524298958,
0.033674866,
0.0138374297,
-0.0101176547,
-0.0871396214,
0.0215387773,
0.0259474181,
0.0190472789,
0.0351668783,
-0.0142861158,
-0.0840118453,
0.0071238829,
-0.0191669259,
0.009633366,
0.0229062736,
-0.0343825407,
0.034622658,
0.0557987839,
-0.0447624288,
-0.0031075974,
-0.0240695644,
-0.0278339759,
-0.0432917885,
0.0194223728,
0.0269423053,
-0.0001504591,
0.0404636711,
-0.0130121484,
0.0603920072,
0.0314124823,
0.0575218797,
-0.0675057173,
-0.0569215417,
-0.0446448922,
-0.0482299216,
-0.0565337688,
0.0167619046,
0.0042927195,
0.0330027975,
-0.0232544821,
-0.0018015408,
-0.0610554032,
0.0048624231,
0.0110024903,
0.0275067445,
0.0544470958,
-0.0302161016,
0.0153237432,
-0.0046108086,
0.0128718363,
-0.0032198911,
0.0153329065,
0.0062877862,
0.0058120214,
0.0782305598,
-0.0249180421,
0.0615915656,
0.0425107703,
0.0046415948,
-0.0249450039,
0.0154969664,
-0.0353897922,
-0.0159641337,
-0.0109287659,
0.0497921146,
0.0010476506,
-0.005461819,
-0.0018146005,
0.0604736395,
0.051802624,
-0.0054473346,
0.0291046444,
-0.0396960378,
0.0784443095,
0.0433085822,
-0.0054832646,
-0.0178121049,
0.031533014,
-0.0377101935,
-0.0099241817,
-0.0334236696,
0.0150979124,
-0.0157564804,
-0.0346315578,
-0.0398164541,
0.0080364076,
-0.0214802567,
0.0248824246,
-0.0470844992,
-0.0287512746,
-0.0072294939,
0.001092852,
0.064760983,
-0.0185568985,
-0.0415207595,
-0.0452847593,
0.0347287394,
0.0940542445,
0.0068979235,
-0.0511340238,
-0.0220991075,
-0.0191655755,
-0.0391743593,
0.0108246049,
0.0296638068,
0.0016428566,
0.0253296774,
-0.029434327,
0.031820558,
0.0087810513,
0.0005800932,
-0.025207581,
0.009755847,
0.0330485515,
-0.0288662892,
0.0421016663,
0.0106042624,
0.0313665234,
-0.0631217882,
-0.0529098995,
0.042325668,
0.0717440844,
0.0181207452,
-0.0044286111,
-0.0246730838,
-0.0543577448,
0.0073630451,
0.0383106135,
-0.0195209403,
0.0232164674,
0.0414857976,
-0.0659354404,
0.0082655987,
0.0189953893,
-0.0411361344,
0.0182765592,
-0.0008185193,
0.0008583427,
-0.0149693424,
-0.0365904905,
0.0014283593,
-0.0103739016,
0.0187308975,
-0.0339320637,
0.0871864259,
-0.0059040398,
0.0274547618,
0.0102993306,
0.0117525859,
-0.0125321196,
-0.0300642401,
-0.01614739,
-0.0029349413,
-0.0255031455,
-0.0612697899,
0.0076775602,
0.0016201457,
0.0034292897,
0.0145824784,
-0.0354679935,
-0.0433417149,
-0.0301294904,
0.019652281,
0.0278712157,
-0.0037918675,
0.0013003347,
-0.0332690962,
-0.0513551235,
0.0218798351,
-0.0211372208,
0.0001857874,
-0.019123923,
-0.0014939182,
0.0248853546,
-0.0318945721,
-0.0235444196,
-0.050731089,
0.0442083478,
-0.0259994399,
0.0060220612,
-0.0451200269,
-0.0032586101,
-0.0152281011,
0.0394372046,
-0.040561486,
0.0096747596,
0.0106048789,
-0.0340729505,
0.014513908,
0.0074016983,
-0.0095253736,
0.0471239053,
0.0074043646,
0.025534207,
-0.0061270841,
0.0157117471,
-0.0047524194,
0.0213374961,
-0.0003403413,
0.0359798335,
-0.0240599643,
-0.0345178768,
-0.0108137131,
0.0137577821,
0.0206619799,
0.020671742,
-0.0557487942,
0.0286510475,
0.0435984209,
-0.0371576101,
0.0296610706,
0.043006517,
-0.0194195751,
0.0097532673,
0.0163972545,
0.0032277782,
0.0649385229,
0.0219535399,
-0.0070332182,
-0.0171220768,
-0.0579651594,
-0.0268047377,
0.0732638389,
-0.0152545571,
0.0023445832,
0.072922945,
0.0163077023,
0.0012944298,
-0.0706831217,
0.0009579005,
-0.0322804935,
0.0209854878,
0.0143998368,
-0.0570858009,
0.0412751436,
-0.0602979362,
-0.0277546905,
-0.0658439025,
-0.0368431248,
-0.0385391228,
0.003388071,
-0.0582183152,
-0.0216634516,
-0.0777791142,
0.0373772979,
-0.0334461741,
-0.0109574171,
-0.0551264957,
0.0286202729,
0.0047072503,
0.0879515633,
-0.0106185824,
0.0191486459,
-0.04602018,
0.0128616579,
0.0222918447,
-0.0667728707,
-0.0030969554,
0.003196259,
-0.0081384918,
0.0020183194,
0.0154539114,
0.0030251564,
-0.0007129917,
0.0303024445,
-0.0090529602,
0.0032807612,
0.1263542473,
0.0310422443,
0.0106580472,
0.0266455766,
0.0189924464,
0.0243411623,
0.0471961722,
0.037523929,
0.0242566522,
-0.0360907018,
-0.0269457363,
0.0374779068,
-0.0414576605,
-0.0138833961,
-0.0302785486,
-0.0513087101,
0.0349312276,
-0.0053340942,
-0.0161680747,
0.0000715884,
-0.0414396673,
0.0176591594,
-0.0423214994,
-0.0286043324,
-0.0596722104,
0.0027140996,
-0.0136706093,
-0.0307028349,
-0.1006710604,
-0.0214857534,
0.1008162498,
-0.0248086695,
0.0010294951,
-0.0270545054,
0.0566551052,
-0.0021579966,
-0.055810567,
-0.0555063039,
0.0200418718,
0.0056496453,
0.0280606821,
0.0982260406,
-0.0415544659,
-0.0069948621,
-0.0941246152,
0.0313032269,
-0.0060250997,
0.0218204614,
0.0370648056,
0.0298900921,
-0.0179939233,
-0.0488243736,
-0.0277133472,
0.0135597028,
0.0384020172,
0.0454828367,
-0.0332792886,
-0.1064678431,
-0.0313599631,
0.0368750393,
-0.0104168998,
-0.0423127674,
-0.0969035253,
-0.016535962,
-0.0079914099,
0.0118640596,
-0.0327553116,
-0.0817419887,
-0.0099277645,
0.0261288378,
-0.0264381878,
-0.0381639153,
-0.0221728999,
0.0335812569,
-0.0253751781,
-0.0016906679,
0.0107714823,
0.0185432285,
0.0226668194,
-0.0086801518,
0.0713933408,
-0.0060419049,
-0.0062970966,
0.0262604449,
-0.0255595893,
-0.0299885888,
0.0260319244,
0.0063197613,
0.0094163734,
0.0120483693,
0.0301706269,
-0.0653364956,
0.0415396579,
0.0198831111,
-0.0127593307,
0.0495660752,
0.0082540307,
0.0235179774,
-0.0306082405,
0.0284326151,
-0.0221326891,
0.0505298302,
0.0042552915,
-0.0677942932,
-0.0362581462,
-0.064461194,
0.0037552968,
0.0248724297,
0.0235555526,
-0.0141637838,
-0.0708610192,
-0.005400022,
-0.0110637583,
-0.019684745,
-0.0044711428,
0.0168614592,
-0.082679145,
-0.0175997391,
-0.0261440985,
-0.0622915737,
-0.0182022657,
0.0089324676,
-0.0183006953,
-0.0140977977,
0.0178993903,
0.0026016207,
0.0379476398,
-0.0455400608,
0.025280403,
-0.0059402399,
-0.0329493843,
0.0266815424,
0.0258914772,
0.0030274526,
0.0513349511,
-0.022738602,
0.0020198724,
-0.00964157,
0.0123584447,
-0.0329062678,
0.0305102244,
0.0048721265,
-0.0140909692,
0.0093617151,
0.0001065498,
0.0289447065,
-0.025430033,
-0.0086856913,
-0.0136685632,
0.0490133651,
-0.0392328501,
-0.0056631104,
0.010388419,
-0.0071814479,
-0.025721997,
-0.0491058119,
0.0037646927,
0.025612684,
0.0003390091,
-0.0034000778,
-0.0483256541,
-0.0586067252,
0.0440140367,
0.0295313615,
-0.0254353285,
-0.0013851919,
0.0161343664,
-0.0847008377,
-0.0487756021,
0.0970361084,
-0.0563679077,
0.0047059073,
-0.0100694671,
0.0016874634,
0.0257034414,
-0.0106020682,
-0.0255715381,
-0.0493680909,
-0.0195574891,
-0.0435036868,
0.0160698332,
-0.0071798693,
-5.841326772e-33,
-0.0019019332,
-0.0148395766,
0.0122322198,
0.0599720106,
0.0017749221,
-0.0159336012,
0.0129453531,
0.0264079124,
0.0022555843,
0.01932301,
-0.023878267,
0.0224320274,
-0.0036851494,
-0.0187786408,
-0.0120098507,
0.0051103071,
0.0410209261,
-0.0071633612,
-0.0009613098,
-0.0044260547,
0.0390977301,
0.0330525115,
0.0472819619,
-0.1164570898,
-0.0157847106,
-0.018617522,
-0.0303399898,
-0.0303364005,
0.04766066,
0.0645799413,
0.0074726022,
0.0655848458,
0.0219677258,
-0.0089639956,
-0.0021008046,
0.0160772987,
-0.0321982801,
-0.0509893484,
-0.0339822024,
0.0050779115,
0.0002140036,
-0.0218364671,
-0.0043810098,
-0.0056723128,
-0.0316353552,
-0.0487911254,
0.065768607,
0.0029839443,
0.0385945849,
-0.0107787251,
-0.036009945,
0.0288579222,
-0.0054634553,
0.0145366406,
0.0239155907,
0.038632527,
0.0019160446,
-0.0105189634,
-0.0861379877,
0.0027288552,
-0.0669264123,
-0.0164873786,
-0.072350949,
0.0210143421,
-0.0031346518,
0.0883070752,
0.0550666675,
0.0412662439,
0.0213518254,
-0.0033371891,
0.0555289462,
0.0844403729,
-0.0014126947,
0.0720076412,
-0.0055509806,
-0.0880216733,
-0.0362535752,
0.0363365598,
0.0768107548,
-0.0566630512,
0.0584677197,
-0.034831699,
-0.0681688264,
0.0030373363,
0.0130498605,
0.0344259404,
-0.021410048,
-0.0025370463,
0.0126438215,
0.0100665055,
-0.0138358558,
-0.0114433737,
-0.0224449262,
-0.0526529476,
0.0176917203,
0.0499559343,
-0.0662462413,
0.0211040396,
-0.0108831367,
-0.0308830831,
-0.0330833718,
-0.016466463,
0.0121801766,
0.0355969667,
0.0932905972,
-0.0055497661,
0.0543828607,
0.0478940234,
-0.0887077302,
-0.0179234091,
0.0423761271,
0.0602316409,
-0.0378770865,
0.0125082694,
-0.0150627028,
0.0080624828,
-0.0060902475,
-0.0148780737,
0.0077410303,
0.0429841429,
0.0021962519,
0.001519986,
0.0570969097,
0.01232561,
0.0214787629,
-0.0059801145,
-0.0114183184,
-0.0455337539,
0.0003592793,
-0.0399646908,
0.0258266069,
-0.0039326996,
2.834e-7,
-0.0385428965,
0.0375797711,
-0.020459082,
0.0149453767,
0.0172843989,
0.0548029058,
-0.0058861133,
0.0309443045,
0.0127371456,
-0.0479387604,
0.036232166,
0.0061414875,
0.0455933996,
0.0365637206,
-0.0503693633,
-0.0263306554,
0.0604625493,
0.0239077862,
-0.0213517565,
-0.004844801,
0.1089341342,
0.0692203194,
0.0637728423,
-0.0280207731,
0.025739355,
0.0494331494,
0.0347980633,
0.0245827306,
0.0203295685,
0.0266360212,
-0.0462855175,
-0.0057715555,
0.0053347149,
0.0309733115,
-0.0280023888,
0.0112305088,
-0.0506491922,
0.0766860619,
-0.0174504202,
-0.0241671912,
0.0292286668,
0.0468845628,
-0.0276599489,
0.0128040891,
0.0419451259,
0.0285214093,
-0.0289088488,
-0.0437552892,
-0.0163736884,
-0.0101409061,
0.0304218326,
0.0104273129,
-0.0271605831,
0.0380386338,
0.0109294308,
-0.0361182988,
0.0050790082,
-0.1086121276,
0.0295878667,
0.0534044951,
-0.0245928392,
0.0060227276,
0.0121178189,
0.0436325409,
0.052494105,
-0.0645378679,
0.0272054467,
2.195281388e-34,
-0.0387779251,
0.0306999721,
-0.0181467701,
-0.033060398,
0.0273462925,
0.0147144618,
0.0258677546,
-0.0078915143,
0.0209178906,
-0.0414757244,
0.0302931368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16078v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16078v1 | First Heuristic Then Rational: Dynamic Use of Heuristics in Language Model Reasoning | 2024-06-23T11:11:46 | 2024-06-23T11:11:46 | Yoichi Aoki, Keito Kudo, Tatsuki Kuribayashi, Shusaku Sone, Masaya Taniguchi, Keisuke Sakaguchi, Kentaro Inui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-step reasoning is widely adopted in the community to explore the better
performance of language models (LMs). We report on the systematic strategy that
LMs use in this process. Our controlled experiments reveal that LMs rely more
heavily on heuristics, such as lexical overlap, in the earlier stages of
reasoning when more steps are required to reach an answer. Conversely, as LMs
progress closer to the final answer, their reliance on heuristics decreases.
This suggests that LMs track only a limited number of future steps and
dynamically combine heuristic strategies with logical ones in tasks involving
multi-step reasoning. | [
0.0485828854,
0.0280014239,
-0.0329777859,
0.0038852803,
-0.0758813396,
0.0047142915,
0.0092107877,
-0.0174324699,
-0.0179596264,
-0.0615389049,
0.0142668365,
-0.0672397166,
0.0383132026,
-0.0185657591,
0.0178208314,
-0.0442630798,
0.0471725315,
-0.0773684978,
0.0022572824,
-0.0262242947,
-0.0380577557,
0.0248124823,
-0.0288410373,
0.02237368,
0.019271398,
-0.0138271563,
-0.0202839319,
0.0042054919,
-0.0093006082,
-0.0226197708,
-0.0296499431,
0.0498247258,
-0.0042365803,
0.0231612828,
0.0000023674,
-0.0698949769,
-0.0148494933,
-0.0339179672,
-0.0380953997,
0.0243489109,
0.0349787362,
0.0353536084,
-0.0067293011,
0.0494571701,
-0.0293258801,
0.0216739457,
-0.0103185531,
-0.0174319893,
-0.0079920311,
0.0152424825,
0.0022884728,
-0.0135794766,
-0.0472793616,
0.0059014307,
-0.0196936373,
-0.0520778298,
0.0031401142,
0.0675390586,
0.0501413792,
-0.0104119116,
-0.0217801761,
0.0445036516,
-0.0062862798,
0.0102162287,
-0.0585342608,
0.0492945798,
0.0307180677,
-0.032439582,
0.0231064949,
0.0220258348,
-0.0105159683,
-0.0320701785,
0.0040489095,
-0.0087862862,
-0.0234410446,
0.0146024255,
-0.0452922657,
0.0381486826,
-0.0346140042,
0.0211513415,
0.0229175631,
-0.0440359153,
0.0421721302,
0.0259637907,
-0.0577418767,
0.1346370131,
0.0038927516,
-0.0208396651,
0.0171601325,
-0.0213012453,
0.0378735885,
-0.0881720111,
0.0213701092,
0.0619655363,
-0.0089364303,
0.0431330241,
0.0113618607,
0.0211180933,
0.0149099641,
-0.0334072746,
0.0422479883,
0.0618200339,
0.0519906804,
0.011720458,
-0.0184960794,
0.0076680789,
0.0034051549,
0.0015735574,
-0.0461230502,
0.0353427529,
-0.0498119779,
-0.0430578664,
-0.0207305066,
0.0306613743,
0.005491232,
-0.019257959,
-0.0171672255,
0.0161295142,
0.0389057361,
-0.018115826,
-0.0195829887,
-0.0298145805,
0.044119589,
-0.0156184118,
-0.054094471,
0.0038562533,
-0.0562867001,
0.0635579601,
-0.0217215605,
-0.0270062275,
0.0076177861,
-0.0124018174,
-0.0205950066,
-0.0192309655,
-0.0017913377,
0.046211876,
0.0066124243,
0.0043062796,
-0.0818979666,
-0.0425769836,
-0.0053653894,
-0.0878215283,
0.0175836515,
-0.0827814564,
0.0034765799,
0.041057419,
-0.0193121154,
0.0024408468,
-0.0004098328,
0.0162795503,
-0.0410121903,
0.0718589276,
0.0057150908,
0.0580814183,
0.0370433144,
0.0272404645,
0.0121765658,
0.0825339854,
0.0135273365,
0.0031113811,
-0.0023743666,
0.0058349152,
0.0119541679,
0.0373420715,
-0.0157859176,
-0.0003670008,
-0.0571419895,
-0.0258350745,
0.0004974961,
0.0108630294,
0.0241859369,
0.0405097194,
-0.03998046,
0.0503200814,
0.0410753489,
0.0757303834,
0.0416333601,
-0.0001227182,
0.0312821977,
-0.0018495572,
-0.0201135706,
0.0312761068,
-0.032649491,
-0.0210524797,
-0.0631772503,
0.0110683497,
-0.0164601468,
0.0251698755,
-0.0093091577,
-0.0340225957,
-0.0630777106,
0.028057266,
0.0325623415,
0.0121511593,
0.033192683,
-0.000767579,
-0.0345826335,
0.0563735999,
-0.0251926184,
-0.0370245352,
-0.0122853862,
-0.0509771891,
0.030455146,
0.0924741328,
0.0519959405,
0.0053683971,
-0.0620646253,
0.0406324007,
0.0285609923,
0.0100852074,
0.050709486,
0.0045836298,
-0.0114729023,
-0.0512075573,
-0.0410314612,
-0.0199977793,
-0.0023730888,
0.0103797913,
0.0200170763,
0.004265666,
0.0203502197,
-0.0202507861,
-0.0226093847,
0.0252338257,
-0.0673061088,
0.0075310352,
-0.051234629,
0.0106111346,
0.0065737884,
-0.00266597,
0.0180710368,
0.0419263877,
-0.0091161411,
0.004642549,
-0.0404936746,
0.0479721129,
-0.0200937595,
-0.0022843713,
0.0567145459,
0.0223104395,
-0.0011538474,
-0.0266118981,
0.0067331693,
-0.0178017598,
0.0268742647,
-0.0152404755,
0.0254995562,
-0.0153137026,
0.0512360707,
-0.0350119546,
-0.0181322414,
-0.0371388495,
0.0563273281,
-0.0072039003,
0.020155197,
0.0087352581,
0.0220708158,
0.0044365958,
-0.0143868783,
0.0150350751,
0.0334543698,
-0.0140223382,
-0.0083714286,
-0.0148378843,
0.0159798246,
-0.0557367913,
-0.0185567122,
-0.0625939518,
-0.0254470948,
0.0169645566,
0.020100506,
-0.0078514526,
-0.0316198319,
-0.028879175,
0.0189355779,
0.0165790003,
-0.0112317484,
0.0158760957,
0.0345528312,
0.0049573421,
0.0109026907,
-0.0528398715,
-0.0221506525,
-0.0201792847,
-0.051919464,
0.032316573,
0.0016080524,
0.013341778,
-0.0530720279,
0.008358093,
-0.070721969,
0.0061045527,
-0.0000304784,
-0.0163734145,
0.0318197459,
-0.0304617174,
0.0195422452,
0.0386674441,
0.0027285339,
-0.0015492336,
0.0903751776,
-0.0503395498,
-0.0514774211,
0.0034266815,
0.0134091796,
0.0162345488,
-0.0307334308,
-0.0560582317,
-0.0462503433,
0.0762504414,
0.0155580239,
0.0045403172,
-0.0169044677,
0.0185581241,
-0.0302998554,
-0.012577909,
-0.0361977406,
-0.0425173678,
-0.0216333698,
0.1235078871,
0.0018758717,
-0.0276745837,
0.0698211715,
-0.0337665901,
0.0149595188,
-0.0579903536,
0.0237038061,
-0.0117144249,
0.0662730038,
-0.0598728247,
0.0210705809,
-0.0132978139,
-0.0364518724,
-0.0312732309,
-0.0258903727,
0.0239758566,
-0.0330217369,
0.0561672077,
-0.0671091899,
0.0049042962,
-0.0006213551,
-0.024790626,
-0.0534848012,
0.0317637958,
-0.0657596961,
0.0211892594,
-0.0017899296,
0.0141800577,
-0.0223674681,
0.0296759326,
0.0116040679,
0.0277975425,
-0.0024117383,
-0.0203248691,
0.0129590947,
0.0007162381,
0.0076239565,
0.0103767477,
0.0550819784,
-0.0215371139,
0.0506785661,
0.0176977403,
0.1009995118,
-0.0047903317,
-0.009798713,
0.0078756176,
0.0698638409,
-0.0386244133,
-0.0493797921,
0.04715221,
-0.0035234559,
-0.0523630232,
-0.0007325448,
0.1298204213,
0.0726197585,
0.0207532011,
0.018661676,
-0.0978444591,
0.0413712189,
0.021720726,
0.047458265,
-0.0708875731,
-0.0126871234,
0.0452436432,
0.0035883903,
-0.0111850947,
-0.0070396815,
-0.0223628636,
-0.1039054692,
0.0171439536,
0.0263892505,
-0.0412131809,
0.0413842052,
-0.0335361771,
-0.0161439609,
0.0354320481,
0.0000753438,
0.068158865,
-0.0413074605,
-0.0094223795,
0.0143190566,
-0.0550685376,
-0.0484609604,
0.0211783089,
-0.0161022861,
-0.0044850027,
0.0382038206,
0.0118197678,
0.0142717464,
-0.0317963324,
0.0956751704,
0.0262208693,
0.047939349,
-0.0483754091,
-0.0070154383,
0.0145375691,
0.0296346135,
-0.0087698195,
-0.0067818537,
-0.0293805636,
-0.0456030965,
-0.0080716787,
0.0672399402,
-0.031107489,
-0.039963901,
-0.0001083803,
0.0499605201,
-0.0290322024,
0.0632749498,
0.0346246213,
-0.0296998918,
-0.040489383,
-0.0193866976,
-0.0105604939,
-0.0214169398,
-0.0191635005,
0.0165389758,
0.0324855149,
0.0046383026,
-0.0230483841,
-0.0486381128,
0.0394305997,
0.0741423741,
0.0116025554,
0.0190090872,
-0.0085500898,
0.0058901338,
-0.0159081351,
0.0155546973,
-0.018925786,
0.0134106902,
-0.0359620489,
0.0070922514,
-0.007848897,
-0.0104251923,
-0.0165358707,
0.011206951,
-0.0347383022,
-0.0667272136,
0.0049425084,
0.0168093592,
0.0387513563,
0.0047312216,
-0.0184765588,
-0.0257318709,
-0.0051359837,
-0.067708075,
0.0197127312,
0.0051084277,
0.0277884286,
-0.0118199997,
0.0203535333,
0.0292053055,
0.0074353237,
0.0294223856,
0.0054837349,
0.0629482344,
-0.033755783,
-0.0635363981,
0.0108644869,
0.0321874991,
0.0171491615,
-0.0379684269,
-0.008722743,
-0.0221854895,
0.0195747148,
-0.0280454438,
-0.0284330025,
0.0014441309,
0.0125995632,
0.0184324309,
0.0118633704,
0.0040969844,
-0.0185259283,
-0.0474259146,
0.0137543194,
0.005438718,
0.007552003,
-0.0061778184,
0.0260850303,
0.0461931452,
-0.0170102641,
0.0035331119,
0.0248471666,
-0.0082957232,
0.0199276488,
-0.0160835087,
0.0874131024,
0.0136309108,
0.0040099332,
-0.0763984546,
-0.0027059335,
-0.0256921854,
-0.1045188382,
0.0155675095,
0.0026790707,
0.0452066474,
-0.0235493574,
0.0071846116,
-0.0455107018,
0.0140834125,
0.0069670654,
-0.0119485818,
0.0157032926,
-0.0581883751,
0.0302068777,
0.0346032381,
-0.0325705335,
-0.0259258486,
0.072340019,
-0.0313667692,
0.0381310508,
-0.0258280654,
-0.0302782096,
-0.0006760963,
-0.066956006,
-0.0216835998,
0.0191214103,
-0.0371677428,
0.0025383714,
-0.0823183805,
-0.0869316012,
-0.0116284089,
-0.0145688588,
-0.0080765653,
-0.030119909,
0.0262244344,
0.0926725417,
0.0257164519,
-0.0328028873,
-0.0136665506,
-0.0147010684,
-0.0189326014,
0.0020545141,
-0.0144780213,
-6.828562764e-33,
-0.0270687025,
-0.0265976675,
0.0720571354,
-0.0238842648,
-0.0215283837,
-0.0368153416,
-0.039528314,
0.0498094596,
-0.0207976345,
-0.0117720785,
-0.0243150126,
0.0322373286,
0.0204547476,
-0.0317184068,
0.0184660219,
0.0243801754,
0.0133633548,
0.0269127786,
-0.0514008515,
-0.0696432665,
0.0141772898,
0.0140711227,
0.0119273029,
-0.0042198785,
-0.0190095585,
0.0126163308,
-0.0041516968,
0.0281301793,
-0.0696822628,
0.0283560641,
0.0124857118,
-0.0204293355,
0.0337809063,
-0.0353874937,
-0.0286365747,
0.0675006732,
-0.0080660675,
-0.036994569,
0.0827916041,
-0.0085476097,
-0.0072945934,
-0.0316728018,
0.017207833,
0.0332336985,
-0.0369612239,
0.0158807598,
0.0075110304,
-0.037735492,
-0.0154229328,
0.0165519286,
-0.0634404421,
0.0348205455,
-0.0002840996,
0.0057873302,
0.0389181934,
0.0524941869,
-0.0202119015,
-0.0199361388,
-0.0259390473,
0.0486397035,
0.0171758775,
0.0171564389,
0.0984557495,
0.0222649798,
-0.0185859185,
0.0324409157,
-0.0159623511,
-0.0012345618,
-0.0266222022,
0.0097718388,
0.0588067845,
0.033146169,
0.0030011991,
-0.0437969528,
-0.0162105598,
-0.0242584571,
-0.0329590999,
0.0036211922,
0.0081490772,
0.0413094945,
0.0438744798,
0.017679194,
-0.0352495722,
-0.0606950782,
-0.0772740543,
0.0540115461,
-0.0440699905,
-0.0416790694,
0.0375448577,
-0.0159858186,
-0.0127690937,
-0.0062819449,
0.0117173092,
-0.0019179704,
-0.0352225825,
0.0349012464,
-0.0261850841,
-0.0001673747,
-0.0301222354,
0.0533076152,
-0.0375323966,
-0.0207018908,
-0.0290100724,
-0.0000384607,
0.0050793667,
0.0151723316,
-0.0269233957,
0.0193763319,
-0.0482538566,
-0.0147553962,
-0.0459963083,
-0.0059740273,
0.0213253628,
-0.0149956429,
0.0796557814,
0.0104309628,
0.0072482126,
-0.0016638121,
0.028772939,
-0.0417699963,
-0.0394778438,
0.0441932306,
-0.030469479,
0.0455631949,
0.0026149631,
-0.0259319022,
-0.0492619351,
0.0052901846,
0.0331678838,
-0.0330853909,
-0.0436771736,
0.0435092673,
3.075e-7,
0.0480097234,
0.0751247332,
-0.0247938726,
0.0281818099,
0.0041461405,
0.0056972634,
-0.0446290597,
-0.0710374489,
0.0253838412,
0.0154712396,
0.0077645159,
0.057211604,
0.0459978394,
0.0443468839,
-0.0172904767,
-0.0313653201,
-0.0512355827,
0.033865042,
-0.0518531874,
0.01313286,
-0.0007744267,
0.0232489463,
0.0208537728,
0.0003647243,
-0.0383992828,
-0.0739751831,
0.0408502109,
0.0005637186,
0.0258872081,
0.0594541356,
0.0081254384,
-0.0084647369,
0.028254617,
0.0442225002,
0.0035564145,
0.0180368144,
-0.0178800654,
0.0617639422,
-0.0222467445,
-0.023966847,
-0.0023208035,
-0.0321174897,
-0.0102970451,
-0.0750543997,
0.0894566327,
-0.0208770763,
-0.0214994606,
-0.0081515498,
0.0497942492,
-0.0333374143,
-0.0040192218,
0.0101188878,
0.0052879192,
0.0312298425,
-0.0018278272,
-0.011847605,
-0.0032688249,
-0.1019318253,
-0.0260326583,
0.0661021769,
-0.0343159474,
-0.0044711777,
-0.0193467345,
-0.0185106508,
0.0467887819,
-0.0322659761,
-0.0020752826,
2.75890269e-34,
0.0322956592,
-0.0063170483,
0.0297250859,
0.0761105493,
0.0435400456,
0.0115244519,
0.0110363476,
0.0528418794,
0.0131873041,
-0.0522340722,
-0.0105873346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16071v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16071v1 | Dancing in the syntax forest: fast, accurate and explainable sentiment analysis with SALSA | 2024-06-23T10:47:01 | 2024-06-23T10:47:01 | Carlos Gómez-Rodríguez, Muhammad Imran, David Vilares, Elena Solera, Olga Kellert | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | Sentiment analysis is a key technology for companies and institutions to
gauge public opinion on products, services or events. However, for large-scale
sentiment analysis to be accessible to entities with modest computational
resources, it needs to be performed in a resource-efficient way. While some
efficient sentiment analysis systems exist, they tend to apply shallow
heuristics, which do not take into account syntactic phenomena that can
radically change sentiment. Conversely, alternatives that take syntax into
account are computationally expensive. The SALSA project, funded by the
European Research Council under a Proof-of-Concept Grant, aims to leverage
recently-developed fast syntactic parsing techniques to build sentiment
analysis systems that are lightweight and efficient, while still providing
accuracy and explainability through the explicit use of syntax. We intend our
approaches to be the backbone of a working product of interest for SMEs to use
in production. | [
0.0181016661,
0.079760924,
-0.0207845774,
0.0390768424,
-0.0282216296,
0.0007430141,
-0.037341062,
-0.0058557782,
0.0142617961,
-0.0427422449,
0.017419504,
0.0218786784,
-0.0194140952,
0.0586907379,
-0.023915112,
-0.0459303819,
0.0224718042,
0.0469133966,
0.0320182964,
0.0271117557,
0.0440675989,
0.027606044,
-0.0058742729,
0.0226074439,
-0.0100709638,
-0.005731829,
-0.0084394161,
-0.0090302723,
-0.0186602585,
0.0023756933,
-0.0081699146,
0.0091529852,
-0.0277143829,
0.0166907609,
0.0000021136,
-0.014090389,
-0.0314776786,
0.0027668236,
0.0319134966,
0.0398802757,
0.0833991244,
-0.0226431023,
-0.0095386086,
0.0267450213,
-0.0564764142,
-0.02372347,
0.0303501487,
-0.0212611482,
0.0655287355,
0.0680051669,
-0.0365643911,
-0.0555296317,
-0.0863814056,
0.0075052613,
0.0044893152,
0.01703557,
0.0033859627,
-0.0643780082,
-0.0106072947,
-0.0063641397,
0.0128771989,
-0.0080944831,
-0.0234731082,
-0.0234531909,
0.0132075092,
-0.0295723788,
-0.0419593714,
-0.019739585,
-0.0234876983,
0.0039968588,
0.0234424639,
-0.0249412134,
0.0319739766,
0.0087486673,
-0.0188819598,
-0.0447866097,
-0.0326386765,
-0.0025070249,
0.0058296151,
0.0534132011,
0.0031015819,
0.0440690853,
-0.015086174,
0.0168919191,
0.0129396133,
0.0573910326,
-0.0330566429,
-0.0119282855,
0.0074769715,
0.0330683328,
0.012258634,
-0.0290960222,
-0.0008864193,
-0.0069514303,
0.0202243347,
-0.0025958291,
0.0068594329,
-0.0042201835,
0.0150276627,
-0.1009154022,
-0.0194378383,
0.0167643391,
-0.0089892419,
0.0418987647,
0.0034616818,
-0.0138369761,
0.0036352875,
-0.0320942625,
0.0014900576,
0.0188905597,
-0.0422504544,
0.0137947099,
-0.0175342206,
0.0279513858,
-0.0382657573,
0.0051806141,
-0.0480251722,
0.0106288707,
-0.0367822684,
0.0223411396,
0.0214199629,
0.0024010816,
0.0288052093,
0.0435939543,
-0.0517531112,
0.0302172974,
-0.05681457,
0.0053613828,
-0.0418647565,
-0.0333254337,
-0.0043470724,
0.07120502,
0.024589248,
0.0009623106,
0.015436301,
0.0371820107,
0.0380700491,
0.0127599929,
-0.0091708833,
-0.0528917015,
-0.0309973173,
-0.0266337339,
-0.0075877155,
-0.0487055033,
0.0045671659,
0.0421973094,
0.0048669977,
-0.0417766422,
-0.0038176563,
0.0009440518,
-0.007289933,
0.0359566286,
-0.0627127588,
-0.0361626893,
-0.0875155255,
-0.0395941176,
0.0002049562,
0.0454879999,
0.0039442698,
0.047863055,
0.0355918482,
-0.0269463733,
0.0070450446,
-0.0104163261,
-0.0232439414,
-0.0350160226,
-0.0546375178,
0.0348409154,
-0.0450166091,
-0.0359521955,
-0.002808817,
0.0516048223,
0.022626318,
0.0089215953,
0.0121501805,
-0.0299338102,
-0.0510806032,
0.0591982119,
0.0344290733,
0.0234445762,
-0.016113814,
-0.034918189,
-0.0180515479,
0.0114216842,
-0.0001058696,
-0.0075911614,
-0.018378133,
0.0098165255,
0.0063605835,
-0.0763387159,
-0.036269363,
0.0006565378,
0.03097005,
-0.0159241688,
-0.0138559695,
-0.0090455161,
-0.0266641714,
0.0272908453,
0.0383859985,
-0.0829511806,
-0.0330467671,
-0.0152720986,
0.021703884,
0.0874111354,
-0.003502842,
-0.0234359577,
0.014660052,
-0.0175376311,
0.0220958907,
0.0201729424,
0.0273580942,
0.0199397448,
-0.0111569017,
-0.0312316958,
0.0378159359,
-0.0008547634,
0.0295449179,
0.0193140414,
-0.0200339016,
-0.0128242895,
-0.0178136341,
-0.0071120285,
-0.0082739266,
-0.0069959178,
0.1110912636,
-0.0410315357,
0.0158771779,
0.018295465,
0.0593396872,
0.0564994849,
0.0005605647,
0.0043843356,
0.0227826051,
-0.0142986244,
-0.0132016055,
0.0433090143,
0.0325903744,
-0.0285999104,
0.0024999939,
0.0016613288,
-0.0331334472,
0.0377404839,
-0.0252941884,
0.0016390295,
0.0271897074,
-0.0284341518,
0.0269017424,
0.0023369137,
-0.0177968349,
-0.0492041819,
0.0185842458,
0.0126683973,
0.0310191885,
0.030887533,
0.006535403,
-0.0643964037,
-0.051562421,
0.0033885508,
0.0278996788,
-0.0345915146,
-0.0022766222,
0.0168477464,
0.0283220485,
0.0092876824,
-0.0068430202,
0.0067817867,
-0.0143019399,
-0.0834383219,
0.0075597037,
-0.0135693131,
0.0504111573,
0.0127757285,
0.0259182341,
0.0156950969,
0.0276786517,
-0.0043366873,
0.0505947135,
-0.024168063,
0.0250703916,
0.0592061803,
0.0146637289,
-0.0703447014,
-0.0241695121,
0.0068147476,
-0.0532160737,
0.0333135091,
0.0493882895,
-0.0326994993,
-0.0098003866,
0.0245943218,
-0.026000157,
0.0052485527,
0.0221490506,
-0.0738238245,
0.0040551736,
-0.0535845049,
-0.0305399727,
0.0163854789,
-0.0320831202,
0.0437176712,
0.0000382828,
-0.0007589686,
-0.0303869676,
0.0028400456,
-0.049045518,
0.0422876626,
-0.0399511866,
-0.001622611,
0.0210719407,
0.0796447545,
0.0180899128,
-0.0222900603,
-0.0518425442,
0.0216397718,
-0.0053284951,
0.0269932207,
-0.0005045831,
0.0055462592,
0.0178406406,
0.0273135491,
0.0498574786,
-0.0451539233,
0.0525269732,
-0.0067181541,
-0.0206456669,
-0.0497635938,
-0.0391296633,
-0.0725647733,
0.0581447147,
-0.0101062115,
0.0045961253,
-0.0100187417,
-0.015176326,
0.0512919165,
-0.0285286084,
0.0142789157,
0.0120741269,
-0.0015651399,
-0.0420062095,
0.0076889382,
0.0242229998,
-0.0505610369,
0.0457292832,
-0.0795141459,
-0.0776800066,
-0.0167296566,
0.055109743,
-0.0146514988,
0.0285742059,
0.0162586719,
-0.0183629058,
-0.040659681,
0.0093521988,
-0.0206969138,
-0.0073916186,
-0.0659143254,
-0.0424223356,
-0.0526423492,
0.0466111228,
0.0288160536,
-0.0215697568,
0.070805639,
0.0644477308,
-0.0174769424,
-0.0752926469,
0.0020518894,
-0.0072954413,
-0.0188672282,
-0.0268017258,
-0.0477440469,
0.025149161,
-0.0472089723,
0.0142182875,
0.089851588,
0.0255192537,
-0.0256464258,
0.0148998527,
0.0265506096,
0.0380002633,
0.027790986,
0.0277154762,
-0.0532273315,
-0.0458236225,
-0.013790465,
0.0600198023,
-0.0082777683,
-0.0161101632,
0.0044724625,
-0.07505171,
0.0421485752,
-0.0000179728,
0.0169743039,
-0.03064874,
-0.0693111867,
-0.0222569518,
-0.0416343696,
-0.0755852312,
-0.000084551,
-0.0205164384,
0.0396384336,
0.0144397682,
-0.0879407972,
-0.0028558658,
0.012395178,
0.0000184975,
-0.0304207299,
0.0480899252,
0.0672732741,
-0.0139147956,
-0.0125891138,
0.0107728969,
-0.0255941581,
-0.008185219,
-0.0542491823,
0.0544410907,
0.0048825289,
-0.0390578806,
-0.0086440314,
0.0146320667,
-0.0821494833,
0.043960683,
-0.000597706,
0.0381326973,
-0.0033812334,
-0.001972738,
0.0155546153,
0.0194840431,
0.0413941592,
0.0590840317,
0.0289351884,
-0.0373619609,
-0.0354124941,
-0.0719946176,
-0.0407106429,
-0.0333701372,
-0.0429867506,
-0.0263978727,
-0.0016119903,
-0.071530439,
-0.072408475,
-0.0288991425,
0.0608443953,
0.0359643325,
-0.0379452519,
-0.0375839621,
0.007210054,
-0.0037764381,
-0.0268137138,
-0.001464906,
0.035790991,
0.0139356563,
0.0057771821,
-0.0142206391,
0.0287201274,
0.0593497828,
-0.0389568061,
-0.0214613825,
-0.052782964,
-0.0253123567,
0.0321774594,
0.0535692498,
0.0260121301,
-0.0134717515,
-0.000368438,
-0.0068186317,
-0.0456403829,
0.1001376808,
-0.0450472347,
0.0001239724,
0.0288120545,
0.0337954387,
0.0529271513,
0.0224112179,
-0.005674927,
-0.0007505568,
-0.028972391,
0.006669343,
-0.0553788655,
-0.007027016,
0.022130549,
0.0238156579,
0.0745597333,
0.0330430456,
-0.0599744245,
0.0372438394,
0.0143565796,
-0.0538939722,
-0.0514057614,
-0.0362335481,
-0.0142291887,
-0.0529366843,
0.0203099512,
-0.0558830425,
0.0186131895,
-0.0321698673,
0.0262152348,
-0.0004348271,
0.0854532719,
0.008071403,
-0.015561169,
0.031127153,
0.0137985991,
0.0070784795,
0.0129731055,
0.0126962252,
0.0023761673,
-0.0096738189,
-0.0085458411,
0.0170262661,
0.0092173386,
-0.019432161,
-0.0201755743,
-0.0212162752,
-0.0278741103,
0.0306709167,
0.0157462563,
-0.0147486413,
-0.0326526761,
0.1027607471,
-0.0301444381,
-0.0097253546,
0.0184835438,
0.0418859124,
-0.0033232186,
-0.0245019719,
-0.0021134445,
-0.01867323,
-0.0466221906,
-0.0788984671,
0.0628691539,
-0.0661974102,
0.0008107407,
0.0415504687,
-0.0401996374,
-0.0514439568,
-0.0120346099,
0.0261824951,
-0.0056776213,
0.0422405414,
-0.0167066809,
-0.0513300262,
-0.0177277979,
0.0710018352,
-0.0326191299,
0.0252664592,
-0.0289909467,
0.0493562706,
0.0647581816,
0.0410654694,
0.0075716334,
-0.0639852062,
0.0199755691,
-0.0651960447,
-0.0174602531,
-0.0004535155,
-6.636221766e-33,
0.0076178345,
-0.0167290978,
-0.0363031216,
0.0475528352,
0.0252136942,
-0.0026877716,
-0.0172637608,
0.0283587147,
0.0623333007,
0.0481321253,
0.0221809819,
0.0467686467,
0.030583363,
0.009061683,
0.0387880877,
0.0039753253,
0.0451613218,
-0.0094608897,
0.0194893703,
-0.0152836284,
0.0637612268,
0.0048970892,
0.003426916,
-0.0704930052,
0.0579423085,
0.0227878615,
-0.0624585524,
0.0046152142,
0.047037527,
0.0240195747,
0.0229172129,
0.023477735,
-0.0052747205,
0.0175948199,
-0.0041246149,
0.033585906,
0.0069798995,
-0.0321360789,
0.0080474652,
0.045504123,
-0.0049190838,
-0.0051172273,
0.0376696289,
0.0134599619,
-0.0257224198,
0.0426928848,
-0.0040235943,
-0.0225738268,
0.0337273479,
-0.05721182,
-0.0249667764,
0.0194086749,
-0.0339821167,
0.0355335735,
0.0500083528,
0.0230531488,
-0.0019661749,
0.0279950257,
-0.0686898753,
0.0112280697,
-0.0681345463,
0.0177342091,
0.0037181904,
-0.0631868094,
0.0197012462,
0.0380144045,
0.0241148658,
-0.0090517718,
-0.0009400584,
0.1243074238,
-0.0222249068,
0.0418168269,
0.0350785255,
0.0664408579,
0.0255241562,
-0.0173758306,
-0.0575887226,
0.0291556977,
0.0382482708,
0.004480029,
0.0274838787,
0.0186573509,
-0.0651562959,
-0.0233782642,
0.0322687998,
0.0289627314,
-0.0135818087,
-0.0311806779,
-0.0286259688,
-0.0425647721,
-0.0439763516,
0.0349770561,
-0.0232304092,
-0.0260397121,
-0.0691314265,
0.0057057589,
-0.0638176352,
0.0389162563,
0.0144058913,
-0.0049962183,
0.0112087838,
-0.0101338597,
-0.058821585,
0.0157729145,
0.0469105579,
0.007245949,
0.0250318702,
0.0272206347,
-0.0941858515,
-0.0115245208,
-0.0116099855,
0.0389773436,
-0.036453113,
0.0213307925,
0.0307914764,
0.0275894739,
0.0291999429,
0.0614782646,
0.014080653,
0.0623178445,
0.0081943125,
-0.0025437269,
-0.0009845068,
0.0177146755,
-0.0434147194,
-0.0767276958,
0.0125799151,
-0.0354692638,
-0.0199026186,
-0.0436077416,
-0.0299257487,
-0.012832663,
2.895e-7,
0.0732585266,
0.0899033323,
-0.0079689827,
0.042211663,
0.0297123175,
0.0525630414,
0.0508228205,
0.0136486962,
-0.0431456752,
-0.0160968844,
-0.0249653663,
0.0076048239,
0.0187369417,
0.0583761185,
-0.0829286873,
-0.0099379756,
0.0033185298,
-0.0379957408,
-0.0463395938,
0.0411765911,
0.0752078295,
0.0724852011,
0.0484982543,
0.0231135935,
-0.012296495,
-0.017749954,
0.0316906087,
-0.0211838894,
-0.0108946059,
0.0144810695,
-0.0199454799,
-0.0426302776,
-0.0424427725,
-0.0420188196,
-0.005095501,
-0.0046031969,
-0.0287269484,
0.0725336894,
0.0222852528,
0.0519519784,
0.0367119685,
-0.0290835295,
0.0058212322,
-0.0165091213,
0.0475704595,
-0.064065598,
-0.0677763447,
-0.0444268323,
0.0022768057,
0.0006223676,
-0.0091247028,
0.0118635315,
-0.0424548984,
-0.0042992774,
-0.0122960676,
-0.0683042482,
-0.0325216278,
-0.0319458283,
-0.0494569689,
-0.0086489636,
-0.0296693109,
-0.0231968015,
0.0125574348,
0.0543719009,
0.0404412411,
0.0209516417,
0.0161630586,
2.798977864e-34,
0.0734147355,
-0.0026504998,
0.017911952,
0.0290634148,
0.0660795569,
0.0176664125,
-0.0389075242,
-0.0044032042,
0.0291523039,
-0.0229894072,
-0.0037874072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16069v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16069v1 | FastMem: Fast Memorization of Prompt Improves Context Awareness of Large Language Models | 2024-06-23T10:36:35 | 2024-06-23T10:36:35 | Junyi Zhu, Shuochen Liu, Yu Yu, Bo Tang, Yibo Yan, Zhiyu Li, Feiyu Xiong, Tong Xu, Matthew B. Blaschko | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) excel in generating coherent text, but they
often struggle with context awareness, leading to inaccuracies in tasks
requiring faithful adherence to provided information. We introduce FastMem, a
novel method designed to enhance instruction fine-tuned LLMs' context awareness
through fast memorization of the prompt. FastMem maximizes the likelihood of
the prompt before inference by fine-tuning only the last Feed-Forward Network
(FFN) module. This targeted approach ensures efficient optimization without
overfitting, significantly improving the model's ability to comprehend and
accurately follow the context. Our experiments demonstrate substantial gains in
reading comprehension, text summarization and adherence to output structures.
For instance, FastMem improves the accuracy of Llama 3-8B-Inst on the NQ-SWAP
dataset from 59.1% to 71.6%, and reduces the output structure failure rate of
Qwen 1.5-4B-Chat from 34.9% to 25.5%. Extensive experimental results highlight
FastMem's potential to offer a robust solution to enhance the reliability and
accuracy of LLMs in various applications. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/IAAR-Shanghai/FastMem | [
0.0133158928,
0.0272855163,
0.0072286413,
0.0403028652,
-0.0286016185,
0.0066775358,
0.0181054976,
-0.0500683524,
-0.0019128551,
-0.0162526816,
-0.0433401093,
-0.0495285839,
0.0322377346,
0.029593654,
0.0480270274,
-0.0320943817,
0.058435183,
-0.0550071485,
-0.0323495008,
0.0009125204,
0.0190317221,
0.0233151242,
-0.0046621026,
0.0279899016,
0.0153863719,
-0.0358545072,
-0.0261268578,
0.0278415959,
0.0273068864,
-0.0378292389,
0.0140945921,
0.043774385,
-0.0150251221,
0.0436375178,
0.0000023282,
-0.0305033866,
-0.0182906743,
-0.0291688703,
-0.0357035287,
0.0770120472,
0.0340318717,
-0.0236645807,
-0.0271467287,
0.041671142,
0.0140391914,
0.02902258,
0.0579673946,
0.0211919583,
0.0557912402,
0.0755458549,
0.0149924047,
-0.0100567099,
0.0395119898,
-0.042760808,
0.0073195496,
-0.0622080192,
0.025936665,
0.0116862962,
-0.0023537879,
0.0126043232,
-0.0214782488,
0.0615622588,
0.0495961532,
0.0172921605,
-0.0147360107,
0.058531709,
0.0113844955,
-0.014645189,
-0.0147199584,
0.071193561,
-0.0097833462,
-0.0294195544,
-0.0108425878,
-0.02427225,
-0.0236100741,
-0.0270964,
-0.0568923354,
0.042297408,
-0.0199497845,
0.0259685498,
0.040346235,
-0.0073723099,
0.0417985506,
0.0226947255,
-0.035950318,
0.0305035338,
0.0186393168,
-0.0132417297,
-0.0254391935,
-0.0044542877,
-0.0192218795,
-0.0477253497,
0.0352251269,
0.0556200333,
-0.0588999428,
0.0393911265,
-0.0458683483,
-0.0419021621,
0.0234234706,
-0.0872436389,
0.0155468276,
0.064181447,
-0.039453622,
0.0230517127,
-0.0367280804,
0.0458796285,
0.0033882067,
0.0265113786,
-0.0448724627,
0.0049358653,
-0.0129478648,
-0.0278168507,
-0.0335445032,
0.0056741736,
-0.0513128303,
-0.0423442498,
-0.05283124,
0.0401073955,
0.0208019875,
-0.0017183321,
-0.0064512235,
-0.000478005,
-0.0596182458,
0.0049542612,
0.0010349202,
0.0462154374,
-0.0338012129,
0.0043127597,
0.0165389627,
-0.0503712222,
-0.0258510765,
-0.0028364635,
0.0034812212,
-0.0113204382,
-0.004045744,
0.0685236678,
-0.0215605069,
-0.0420681797,
-0.0865490213,
-0.0107056918,
-0.0195827633,
-0.061201334,
-0.0004259999,
-0.0771128908,
0.0049715261,
0.0031951442,
-0.0052567017,
-0.0100302175,
0.0112466523,
0.0279734395,
-0.0062918412,
0.0450676121,
-0.0142035289,
0.001075245,
0.0272383615,
0.0062159956,
0.0254186951,
0.0855478868,
0.0203117728,
0.0326346271,
0.0196367353,
0.0171966292,
-0.0296914913,
0.0518343039,
0.022858575,
0.0105573647,
-0.0210378412,
-0.0370436125,
0.003839178,
0.0436300337,
0.0566504113,
0.0513373353,
-0.014368766,
0.025340775,
0.0740411952,
0.0188462958,
0.0423668995,
-0.0012535978,
0.0333948024,
0.0155005287,
0.0189425722,
0.0180395544,
-0.0525762625,
0.0575365238,
-0.0232012812,
0.058003258,
0.0524971895,
0.055703219,
-0.0338181555,
-0.0420934185,
-0.0021701083,
-0.0031611575,
-0.0179568809,
0.0284026787,
0.0471580736,
0.0134722097,
-0.0701427609,
0.0279953182,
0.0486444458,
-0.0179767143,
0.006728027,
-0.0261755157,
0.0524766594,
0.083710961,
0.034509819,
-0.0029925785,
-0.0373823456,
0.022749275,
0.0100604445,
0.0454174429,
0.0275649894,
-0.0017763451,
0.0198338572,
-0.0575800091,
-0.0173906218,
0.0219176318,
0.0205286536,
0.0313683674,
0.01729526,
-0.0026853832,
0.0367044322,
0.0096685067,
-0.0369096734,
0.0477253348,
-0.0714611337,
-0.0222965218,
-0.0188839827,
0.0091092167,
0.0158467703,
0.0260829479,
0.003812521,
0.0131723946,
0.0206543989,
-0.0229018237,
0.0361641161,
0.0108403396,
-0.1193926632,
-0.0676273778,
0.0336419046,
0.0158728939,
-0.007868371,
0.0081446934,
-0.037215922,
-0.0624421351,
-0.0029387707,
-0.0432244651,
0.0286990441,
-0.0607074909,
0.0172102768,
0.0058772266,
0.0115604168,
-0.0360337235,
0.0432784855,
-0.0110790506,
0.0183900483,
0.0638781339,
0.0418393463,
-0.0194294881,
-0.0421702713,
-0.0103447819,
0.0002686527,
0.0028084735,
0.006492415,
-0.0163002983,
0.0441156849,
-0.0512562469,
-0.0049193343,
-0.0713294446,
0.0231903531,
-0.0502762385,
0.0026364764,
0.0647644773,
0.0226515103,
-0.0082384991,
0.0026185832,
-0.02596163,
0.0216001384,
0.0055409353,
0.0111081516,
0.0157423634,
0.0061306264,
-0.0356718451,
-0.0387486219,
-0.0182128381,
-0.0089625092,
0.0256608911,
-0.003395953,
-0.0295491181,
-0.073948577,
0.0110706342,
0.0054423688,
-0.0002540799,
-0.0133786257,
-0.0283990018,
-0.0083545893,
-0.0113784699,
0.0495282225,
0.0432271287,
0.0048300247,
0.0036323434,
0.0417326316,
0.0007746701,
-0.0470049568,
-0.0094824564,
-0.0202098675,
-0.0069639781,
-0.0033896188,
-0.0527390912,
-0.0155406203,
0.070668377,
0.0174027067,
0.0102312621,
-0.0341747142,
0.0036513293,
-0.0218061563,
-0.0011872099,
-0.0538653098,
-0.0127034448,
-0.0477858,
0.0404783934,
-0.0419762209,
-0.0447900668,
0.0821623206,
-0.0730160773,
0.0073269987,
-0.0389278904,
-0.0189803634,
-0.0429516658,
0.0271700267,
0.0042834198,
0.0289919674,
0.0294136833,
-0.0553170852,
-0.0429843254,
0.0087557407,
-0.0067941668,
-0.007752026,
0.0607813261,
-0.0385879986,
-0.002847149,
-0.0116617484,
-0.0020947186,
-0.0457292683,
0.0007362513,
-0.0317805149,
0.0278083049,
0.0103904139,
0.0056461552,
-0.0109076304,
0.0280106831,
0.0335265696,
0.0696632713,
-0.0574015565,
0.007895953,
-0.0430308543,
0.0392680764,
0.0269980934,
-0.0047053955,
0.039701011,
-0.0770010501,
0.0264901631,
0.0389879644,
0.015406468,
0.0032723399,
-0.0385084897,
-0.0088109188,
0.009494097,
-0.0208955351,
0.0157366488,
0.0320791304,
0.0776157603,
-0.0796838626,
-0.0367498323,
0.1144764423,
0.0179889165,
-0.0282798912,
0.0062708878,
0.004688472,
0.0549554266,
0.0065971813,
0.0316370539,
-0.0725803897,
-0.0363708176,
0.0296181869,
0.0557901971,
0.0146144098,
0.0091766734,
-0.0242030807,
-0.0982509032,
0.006048664,
0.0421241559,
-0.0798137933,
-0.0459372886,
-0.0371853374,
-0.0096855732,
0.0080030058,
0.0776985213,
0.0632638782,
-0.0085358974,
-0.0152150635,
0.034188699,
0.006773463,
-0.0391472839,
0.0017221315,
-0.0384110771,
0.0755115598,
0.0590206832,
-0.0228888765,
-0.0007458442,
-0.011565974,
0.0711944625,
-0.0275143627,
0.0030790977,
-0.0073916651,
0.0272360425,
-0.0106094182,
-0.0090353414,
-0.0132724345,
0.0305831898,
-0.0243440084,
-0.0291235615,
-0.0086643444,
0.0303000566,
-0.012594658,
-0.0014122741,
-0.0154150343,
0.0273361355,
-0.0108142747,
0.0647063032,
0.0733987838,
-0.0232551154,
-0.0309204496,
-0.0471359603,
-0.0119559867,
-0.0796162933,
0.0016311829,
0.0112448558,
-0.0362332575,
-0.0276395418,
-0.0545341633,
-0.0401662365,
0.0284047425,
0.0189560298,
0.0278183687,
-0.0027829164,
0.0124045545,
-0.0204731077,
-0.0083435671,
0.0174717046,
-0.040814206,
0.0327459909,
-0.0723748505,
-0.0013376273,
0.0446097106,
-0.0482266881,
-0.0025443523,
0.0515001342,
-0.0877844989,
-0.0575584248,
-0.0013360323,
0.037187051,
0.0210697856,
0.0674556941,
-0.0043348498,
-0.0432539247,
0.0319903977,
0.0346770696,
-0.0288894027,
0.0253961068,
0.003865771,
0.026160134,
-0.003705105,
0.0208050124,
-0.0293975715,
0.0242562704,
-0.0062557571,
0.0681803301,
0.0235136673,
-0.0357167572,
0.0127055533,
0.0042379303,
0.0181595385,
-0.0181478206,
-0.0147606004,
-0.064570412,
0.0240236558,
-0.0201430302,
0.0028540792,
-0.0272573754,
0.0229981635,
0.0061385399,
-0.0095888656,
-0.0018644361,
-0.0350642726,
0.0253885873,
0.0220553745,
-0.0337203853,
-0.0084438119,
-0.0236768592,
0.0209875349,
0.0148665104,
-0.0140821477,
-0.0563013181,
0.0154076098,
-0.0103971241,
0.0322942548,
-0.0371030159,
0.0580441989,
0.0179807898,
-0.0177544039,
-0.0603919886,
0.0269208141,
-0.0557570979,
-0.018114822,
-0.052637022,
0.052602876,
0.0760715082,
-0.0228131283,
0.0420867763,
-0.0473243222,
0.0111483755,
-0.0341731757,
0.0365990549,
0.0133250905,
-0.0208715666,
0.0433044657,
0.0182755757,
0.0118707772,
-0.0205586608,
0.0706387311,
0.0184049401,
0.0222053174,
0.0097294636,
0.0003670231,
-0.0184946731,
-0.0287940595,
-0.0072477008,
0.0375340581,
-0.0657806471,
-0.0327938721,
-0.0242096353,
-0.0636725575,
0.0056151389,
0.031702999,
-0.0124576753,
-0.0250120945,
0.0345646478,
0.0369600244,
0.0061926921,
-0.0134631414,
-0.0218075402,
0.0139218895,
0.0039795842,
-0.0209113471,
0.0010542521,
-7.188292688e-33,
-0.0608026013,
-0.024390934,
0.0197497122,
-0.01538081,
-0.0447323509,
0.0046897153,
-0.0876832008,
0.002613029,
0.0156805739,
-0.0181302577,
-0.0203269478,
-0.0009017116,
0.025530437,
0.0353981704,
-0.0094775725,
0.0026285849,
0.0628054813,
-0.0052067759,
-0.0157235395,
0.0389332697,
0.0413695052,
0.0499473698,
0.0532061942,
-0.0082520153,
0.0204989817,
0.0001614047,
-0.0085616987,
0.0163797364,
-0.029267421,
0.0311571676,
-0.025291197,
0.0320159458,
0.0257393867,
-0.0370407365,
-0.0637834817,
0.037090499,
-0.0981998444,
-0.0020389999,
0.0353692584,
0.0068441052,
-0.0403686203,
-0.0576512478,
0.0821596831,
-0.0167058129,
0.0171321575,
-0.0011392736,
0.0220623538,
-0.0337595791,
-0.0529124178,
0.00715861,
-0.0648913309,
0.0186145455,
-0.0009765086,
-0.0225952361,
-0.0023154898,
0.034462288,
-0.0172588993,
0.0110744098,
-0.0503191911,
0.0102260103,
0.0480187163,
0.0597590618,
0.0730487853,
0.0769513175,
0.0047391821,
0.0515125766,
0.0362065956,
-0.0139997359,
-0.0028713811,
-0.0087310402,
0.0469915494,
-0.0063672294,
0.0331198946,
0.0347145312,
0.0285316724,
-0.0356935486,
-0.0627204999,
0.0204056669,
0.0019987191,
0.0065899333,
0.0621057115,
0.0003251913,
-0.0213702172,
-0.0402125604,
-0.0357154943,
0.0068993527,
-0.0448290221,
-0.0148586826,
0.0268080179,
0.0156759284,
-0.0259710327,
-0.0438520983,
0.0375450999,
-0.0328841023,
0.0166275986,
0.0166702773,
-0.0282232482,
0.0227775481,
-0.0262721777,
0.0385790132,
-0.0863609239,
-0.0101626925,
-0.0050003096,
-0.0021891189,
-0.0124118188,
0.0122533878,
0.0401735492,
0.0185841788,
-0.0390639454,
0.0043843202,
-0.0532425232,
0.018165132,
0.0074310726,
0.0313795432,
0.0263553057,
-0.0156390537,
-0.0099909455,
0.0575024821,
-0.0014511044,
-0.0214095749,
-0.0238179266,
-0.0201310404,
-0.0185162742,
0.0547242202,
-0.058020968,
0.0038281877,
-0.0551998354,
0.0323415957,
0.0363190658,
-0.0633469224,
-0.0176699869,
0.0402739123,
2.929e-7,
0.0495479479,
0.0292757098,
0.0490464978,
0.0212860089,
0.0167049281,
0.0142282555,
-0.0408039652,
0.016410999,
0.0292670187,
0.003541962,
0.0246498697,
0.0321558975,
0.0511158071,
0.0072110537,
-0.0979107991,
-0.0125479149,
-0.0732872933,
0.0389824472,
-0.054503683,
-0.0136310952,
0.0128287338,
0.1055251509,
-0.0260003377,
-0.0147827854,
0.030565504,
-0.01873146,
0.0427359939,
-0.0127480458,
-0.0117958821,
0.0146234185,
-0.0025897869,
0.0294333901,
-0.0175418742,
-0.0182457287,
-0.0090040648,
-0.0237900801,
-0.0221736021,
0.0773566961,
0.0429570563,
-0.0657598153,
0.0144134574,
0.022419814,
0.0111922678,
-0.0607510433,
0.0521666221,
-0.0709783658,
-0.0087035019,
-0.012533484,
-0.0078642247,
-0.0201265104,
-0.004046171,
-0.0120047526,
-0.0242529437,
0.0245820992,
0.0064448589,
-0.0149950143,
-0.0309882071,
-0.0691240728,
-0.0558895841,
-0.0021142254,
-0.0383360125,
-0.0482981876,
-0.0554626957,
-0.0299912058,
0.0148376254,
-0.0696924925,
-0.0001192665,
3.120996047e-34,
0.0421291478,
-0.0319846384,
0.0077268318,
0.0511928163,
-0.0044596605,
-0.0243764613,
0.0141103119,
0.0201891847,
0.00548054,
-0.0820341706,
-0.0527001135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16061v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16061v1 | PORT: Preference Optimization on Reasoning Traces | 2024-06-23T09:51:06 | 2024-06-23T09:51:06 | Salem Lahlou, Abdalgader Abubaker, Hakim Hacid | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Preference optimization methods have been successfully applied to improve not
only the alignment of large language models (LLMs) with human values, but also
specific natural language tasks such as summarization and stylistic
continuations. This paper proposes using preference optimization methods on
Chain-of-Thought steps in order to improve the reasoning performances of
language models. While the chosen answers are obtained from datasets that
include reasoning traces, we propose two complementary schemes for generating
rejected answers: digit corruption, and weak LLM prompting. Our approach leads
to increased accuracy on the GSM8K, AQuA-RAT, and ARC benchmarks for
Falcon2-11B and Mistral-7B. For example, the approach can lead to up to a
relative 8.47% increase in accuracy on the GSM8K benchmark without any extra
annotations. This work suggests that spending resources on creating more
datasets of reasoning traces would further boost LLM performances on informal
reasoning tasks. | [
0.0414803773,
0.0530074202,
-0.0002398279,
0.0330230519,
-0.0669588447,
-0.0037639511,
-0.026913438,
-0.0219125748,
-0.0072150938,
-0.032225512,
0.006463889,
-0.0668345839,
0.0340632461,
-0.0098211244,
0.0142098125,
-0.0379996449,
0.0445846096,
-0.0722479299,
0.0325174108,
-0.0123450141,
0.0084250085,
0.017707983,
-0.0019402996,
0.0174483247,
0.0368578434,
-0.0237347726,
-0.006594677,
-0.0124808298,
0.0435876884,
-0.0394095778,
-0.0205768477,
0.0463907681,
-0.0132180667,
0.0504478738,
0.0000025312,
-0.0710343942,
-0.0210309513,
-0.0055314363,
-0.0328708105,
0.0167460777,
0.0470903665,
0.0282393638,
-0.0084016556,
0.0509120151,
-0.0345192105,
0.0283443257,
0.0154861687,
0.0396036021,
0.0523802936,
0.0780734643,
0.0120304655,
-0.0247955397,
0.0169647578,
-0.0038145459,
-0.0025625862,
-0.0163973458,
0.0208309628,
0.0232821126,
0.0326365717,
0.0167547297,
0.0175069515,
0.0337152109,
0.0070021371,
-0.0111568766,
-0.0300633777,
-0.0066398983,
-0.0340158232,
-0.0171418507,
0.0167726446,
0.0690342784,
0.0050545866,
-0.0400487371,
0.0055302512,
-0.0083449939,
-0.0256841369,
-0.0264913421,
-0.0289530773,
0.0256214701,
-0.0343734249,
0.0185041316,
0.0536777191,
-0.0089185694,
0.0014651673,
0.0087016905,
-0.0614440665,
0.1152840853,
0.0092315376,
-0.0243264828,
-0.0181465521,
-0.0188243333,
-0.0447385535,
-0.09498512,
0.0421357155,
0.0249224398,
-0.0512904115,
0.0179632194,
-0.0490061156,
-0.012145252,
0.017304033,
-0.0470900796,
0.0599560179,
0.0668573454,
0.012146513,
0.0312082954,
-0.0276789051,
0.0321893767,
-0.0271448977,
0.0187600553,
-0.0542612895,
0.0048455843,
-0.0345272385,
-0.0109925326,
-0.0141021805,
0.0495184325,
-0.0474649705,
-0.0075949556,
-0.0390148014,
0.016471196,
0.0101613104,
0.0031791066,
0.0281739347,
-0.0000081115,
0.0108381836,
-0.0094364705,
-0.0853903592,
0.0177072063,
-0.0419432595,
0.0217363387,
0.007289927,
-0.015644405,
0.0083691366,
-0.0029505829,
0.0139975268,
-0.0423722081,
0.0102948425,
0.0525500514,
-0.0082432022,
-0.0045849239,
-0.0321466736,
-0.0364833437,
-0.0059251389,
-0.0861523971,
-0.0297680069,
-0.0752957687,
-0.0061453357,
0.0147385085,
-0.0344314799,
-0.0184741542,
0.0041073179,
0.0497672297,
-0.0484749153,
0.0559342578,
-0.0221865904,
0.0206988491,
-0.0090245223,
-0.0231441502,
-0.0358315334,
0.0361813195,
0.0428807065,
0.0210439824,
0.0356346741,
-0.0124206347,
-0.0190319978,
0.0279840548,
0.0186129287,
-0.0229396988,
-0.040858157,
0.0338821597,
-0.0356505327,
0.0341925845,
0.0323802568,
0.0940490738,
-0.0187530704,
0.0072845193,
0.0797569007,
0.0547141358,
0.0306460671,
-0.0199279394,
-0.0054524294,
0.0127901798,
0.0270820223,
0.0269454643,
-0.0539195649,
0.0171625279,
-0.0617261417,
0.0362474322,
0.0441738181,
0.0480347201,
0.010130466,
-0.0592357069,
-0.0133175114,
0.0267895181,
0.0424700938,
0.0380687825,
0.0259769727,
-0.024463255,
-0.0529844202,
-0.0095208529,
-0.0053571179,
-0.0408023819,
-0.0426089354,
-0.0359594598,
0.0780941844,
0.1028601453,
0.0489534102,
0.004289275,
-0.0221398436,
-0.006887774,
-0.0115279667,
0.0293913353,
0.0162891112,
-0.0213062968,
-0.0271649361,
-0.0526476763,
-0.0080046589,
0.0497402288,
-0.0036549789,
-0.0019489094,
0.0117282616,
0.0090436181,
0.0062858234,
-0.0620940849,
-0.0252120476,
0.0268947463,
0.0281540565,
-0.0128646791,
-0.0094843917,
0.0206740368,
0.0353557616,
0.0285021719,
0.0044247741,
0.0287151523,
-0.000618396,
-0.0327179916,
-0.016766686,
-0.017919695,
-0.0744085163,
-0.043716915,
0.0827420503,
-0.0076893037,
-0.0303475168,
0.0405152142,
-0.0046814452,
-0.0608725771,
-0.0047711837,
-0.0367034711,
0.0196621325,
-0.0441442356,
0.0501955673,
0.0006920951,
-0.0333486944,
-0.0507444367,
0.0891798809,
-0.0018792974,
0.0001535632,
0.0222362988,
-0.0048149889,
0.0267219916,
-0.0600949414,
-0.0002124473,
0.026646981,
0.0137515143,
0.0371456854,
0.058798261,
0.0198260006,
-0.0310592782,
-0.0090717208,
-0.085235253,
0.0093021998,
-0.0159764159,
0.0276392549,
0.0068906764,
0.00491068,
-0.0038112388,
-0.0010100742,
-0.0574880093,
-0.0288959239,
0.0228462722,
0.0167271141,
0.0394112468,
-0.0044128783,
-0.0139650106,
-0.0470218174,
-0.0212658569,
-0.0256663486,
0.0067466046,
-0.0329505056,
-0.0020360893,
-0.0603572764,
0.0419756807,
-0.0291680805,
0.0042486209,
0.0099588353,
-0.0096741943,
0.0282993205,
0.0003143308,
0.0238023624,
0.0672264695,
0.0301096626,
-0.0267954189,
0.0531341098,
0.0214899629,
-0.0620558374,
-0.0128017515,
-0.0166023057,
0.0298848879,
-0.0072781215,
-0.0182654243,
-0.0172191337,
0.0653222576,
-0.0133345835,
-0.007613481,
-0.0556454584,
0.0344526023,
0.0145781925,
0.0055901273,
-0.0036596966,
-0.0172175299,
-0.0271316748,
0.0955724418,
-0.0264250915,
-0.0254034754,
0.1068483666,
-0.0456039384,
0.0350726545,
-0.0732121617,
-0.0019018636,
-0.0534947962,
0.0384602956,
-0.0018021507,
0.0234075803,
0.0298351981,
0.0159446392,
-0.0691173151,
-0.0459236316,
0.0618177094,
-0.0464097746,
0.0595466755,
-0.0581593402,
0.0386515483,
-0.0069486359,
-0.0366754383,
-0.0397918746,
-0.0189194214,
-0.0488701165,
0.018957831,
0.01796785,
-0.010239711,
-0.0061159246,
0.0221064482,
0.0217982512,
0.0468553342,
-0.0253257044,
-0.0013211512,
-0.0270641036,
0.0235898104,
0.063871488,
-0.0075859749,
0.0371380672,
0.0051578069,
0.0284594428,
0.0427403525,
0.0658431947,
0.0194399431,
-0.0127744172,
-0.0032814012,
0.0354998633,
-0.051455345,
-0.031215746,
0.0245272275,
0.0677397251,
-0.0480013601,
0.0099114096,
0.1183901057,
0.0483028665,
-0.0056502484,
0.0109685445,
-0.0302797593,
0.0476671122,
0.007770461,
0.0532573014,
-0.0807648674,
-0.0429418758,
0.0234498959,
0.039262943,
-0.0325619951,
-0.0180816911,
0.0010701189,
-0.1503473073,
-0.0067112143,
0.0047257803,
-0.0477970168,
0.007543976,
-0.0459080748,
-0.0008212153,
-0.0311742574,
0.0308000427,
0.0458907895,
-0.0009664014,
0.0025981988,
0.0139601389,
-0.0404954366,
-0.0422264785,
0.0237734299,
-0.0345428996,
0.0412528403,
0.0592492819,
0.0216042995,
0.0232752804,
-0.0391959399,
0.0290439799,
0.0080841603,
-0.0036142142,
-0.0135227768,
0.0162691977,
0.0104442146,
0.0038541318,
-0.0430367179,
0.0519291498,
-0.0183584634,
-0.0137700848,
0.019377118,
0.0800952464,
-0.0269461107,
-0.0155928899,
-0.0288737323,
0.0018765101,
-0.0155085223,
0.0665472224,
0.0084853871,
-0.0634970963,
-0.0421344303,
-0.0440678,
-0.034358561,
-0.0507540703,
-0.0343161374,
-0.0062790317,
0.0115592489,
0.0115550403,
-0.0773874596,
-0.0350910239,
0.0426520295,
0.0522665419,
0.0013581055,
0.0370543376,
0.0119872186,
0.0101164617,
-0.017518485,
0.0298949871,
-0.0393386111,
0.0446354859,
-0.0702315122,
0.0371556319,
-0.0030889593,
-0.0364660174,
-0.01887949,
0.0175432153,
-0.0522552095,
-0.0807837993,
-0.0222883709,
0.0581860952,
0.036704272,
0.0553908274,
-0.006845966,
-0.0550263524,
0.0113653857,
-0.0151855731,
0.0123698637,
0.010629232,
-0.0016482056,
0.0015329879,
-0.0152099868,
0.029643273,
-0.0150904059,
-0.0032879137,
-0.0044550914,
0.0864037722,
-0.0409982614,
-0.0417099707,
0.0533855446,
0.0478281192,
-0.0013884857,
-0.0142536694,
-0.0253188759,
-0.0168393869,
0.040840432,
-0.044075992,
-0.0257610027,
-0.0216450132,
0.0072859633,
0.0103107756,
-0.0147234369,
-0.0008085754,
-0.0738253519,
-0.0315690301,
0.0147483563,
-0.0071457005,
0.0271950793,
0.0035996661,
0.0492343418,
0.0479602292,
-0.0087337131,
-0.0300072245,
0.0050939424,
-0.0028350388,
0.0696487799,
-0.0111059854,
0.0415614434,
0.0360591039,
-0.0054929238,
-0.0117917219,
0.0235979855,
-0.0522941016,
-0.0632426962,
-0.0135606807,
-0.0060605933,
0.0462681465,
-0.0197567418,
0.042082984,
-0.0169891343,
-0.0139828734,
-0.0398065262,
0.0256304704,
0.0273303483,
-0.0046973201,
0.0186942406,
0.0298927184,
-0.0292472746,
0.0067293867,
0.0553241223,
0.0075691654,
0.0035839933,
-0.0004080325,
-0.0339157805,
-0.0347606391,
-0.0250841882,
-0.0597891994,
0.0338555686,
-0.0327350087,
-0.033195518,
-0.0782931149,
-0.0844977349,
0.0240116511,
0.022497844,
-0.0047604893,
-0.0552095398,
0.0344892554,
0.0470189974,
0.0166141521,
-0.0003040057,
-0.0295108706,
-0.0324722528,
-0.0387714729,
-0.0176557228,
-0.0621216893,
-7.080333817e-33,
-0.0080219172,
-0.0254008733,
0.0187362134,
-0.0304315723,
-0.0081301983,
-0.0296104141,
-0.0355796255,
0.0176474396,
-0.0210464969,
-0.0166680198,
-0.0405401886,
-0.0133389328,
0.0126904091,
0.0286935009,
-0.0161753818,
0.0035427823,
0.0412690602,
-0.007428911,
-0.0478092097,
-0.0441458113,
0.0541136079,
0.0027616506,
0.0055339173,
-0.0598229654,
0.0139369806,
0.022119686,
-0.011997968,
0.0368665531,
-0.0339225419,
0.0732224509,
-0.0094212154,
0.0204596836,
-0.0055522621,
-0.0524850674,
-0.0219677035,
0.0070526344,
-0.0649444908,
-0.0238698088,
0.0734141693,
-0.0007326686,
0.0003662249,
-0.046942573,
0.0189152006,
-0.0037949993,
-0.0257255193,
0.009881068,
0.0270600133,
-0.0361159034,
-0.0393407457,
-0.0023290382,
-0.0603354126,
0.0349514037,
0.0046657519,
-0.0218691193,
0.0304281935,
0.024311278,
-0.0287542976,
0.0178341791,
-0.0415055715,
0.0281530544,
0.0138106514,
0.0126003521,
0.0671926141,
0.0090809567,
0.0050776093,
0.0617022812,
0.021408109,
-0.0167043936,
-0.0251861028,
-0.0103372913,
0.0138570396,
0.0349828154,
0.048531767,
0.0239340402,
0.0486387126,
0.0245603062,
-0.0468360148,
0.0261971615,
0.0345383398,
-0.0067192558,
0.0485978574,
0.0185515378,
-0.0487825908,
-0.0351347998,
-0.0630679131,
-0.0054693702,
-0.0492512435,
-0.0332621373,
0.0255579036,
-0.0049054069,
-0.0288693216,
-0.0322199911,
0.0351746455,
-0.04236589,
-0.0316240527,
-0.0072232666,
-0.0320785269,
0.041918043,
0.0014878405,
0.0507541411,
-0.0466595218,
0.0346774347,
0.013385565,
0.0067044841,
0.0096925441,
0.0310689565,
0.021859061,
-0.0049525327,
-0.0516062528,
-0.0015109463,
-0.0266967602,
-0.003700553,
-0.0371947922,
0.0130283805,
0.053916052,
0.0046047256,
0.0183346067,
0.0492036492,
-0.0215384997,
-0.0084709954,
-0.0434981696,
-0.0144238258,
-0.001965231,
0.0449062251,
-0.0139425946,
0.0136269853,
-0.0061538145,
0.0257037524,
-0.0077195982,
-0.0299400445,
-0.001527347,
0.0429014415,
3.192e-7,
0.0432504825,
0.0626885295,
0.0369801745,
0.0351350307,
-0.0261027403,
0.0543512329,
0.0011760161,
-0.0291684233,
0.0338914692,
-0.0099750375,
0.0175318047,
0.0078121414,
0.0515551753,
0.0330328383,
-0.0889119655,
-0.0201797541,
-0.0141233616,
0.00041992,
-0.0414332077,
0.0070865676,
0.0498657227,
0.0859231502,
-0.0020558324,
-0.0265254471,
-0.0204171874,
0.0076485532,
0.0328149423,
-0.0372372419,
-0.0209247824,
-0.0091416193,
0.0253718775,
-0.0185612012,
-0.0018126047,
0.0268462114,
0.016663868,
0.0048500691,
0.013848206,
0.0430955328,
-0.0080178063,
-0.0324384086,
-0.0268569849,
-0.029305337,
0.0085725514,
-0.043649748,
0.0902531222,
-0.028375173,
-0.0373858325,
-0.0129274502,
-0.0109067932,
-0.0178754162,
-0.0191325787,
0.0075650485,
-0.0071633793,
0.0194916334,
0.0186512638,
0.0172144827,
0.0021171828,
-0.0794676989,
-0.0281441566,
0.0370677449,
-0.0051960205,
-0.0698123127,
-0.0237173159,
0.0489446856,
0.0482983291,
-0.0561953634,
-0.0210415944,
3.457304751e-34,
0.0618166737,
-0.0073450883,
0.0120564988,
0.0243336055,
0.0383778699,
0.0033963772,
0.027585905,
0.0017611792,
0.0428642929,
-0.1073733494,
-0.025143927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16033v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16033v1 | Unlocking the Future: Exploring Look-Ahead Planning Mechanistic Interpretability in Large Language Models | 2024-06-23T06:54:47 | 2024-06-23T06:54:47 | Tianyi Men, Pengfei Cao, Zhuoran Jin, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Planning, as the core module of agents, is crucial in various fields such as
embodied agents, web navigation, and tool using. With the development of large
language models (LLMs), some researchers treat large language models as
intelligent agents to stimulate and evaluate their planning capabilities.
However, the planning mechanism is still unclear. In this work, we focus on
exploring the look-ahead planning mechanism in large language models from the
perspectives of information flow and internal representations. First, we study
how planning is done internally by analyzing the multi-layer perception (MLP)
and multi-head self-attention (MHSA) components at the last token. We find that
the output of MHSA in the middle layers at the last token can directly decode
the decision to some extent. Based on this discovery, we further trace the
source of MHSA by information flow, and we reveal that MHSA mainly extracts
information from spans of the goal states and recent steps. According to
information flow, we continue to study what information is encoded within it.
Specifically, we explore whether future decisions have been encoded in advance
in the representation of flow. We demonstrate that the middle and upper layers
encode a few short-term future decisions to some extent when planning is
successful. Overall, our research analyzes the look-ahead planning mechanisms
of LLMs, facilitating future research on LLMs performing planning tasks. | [
0.034747608,
-0.010502018,
-0.0437623486,
0.0181574039,
-0.0233307909,
-0.0069705667,
-0.0356999375,
0.0112266662,
0.0077474816,
-0.0305569042,
-0.0382913537,
-0.0465955213,
0.0102161579,
0.0343933292,
0.0414430127,
-0.0340725966,
0.0385689698,
-0.0556626953,
-0.0192270577,
-0.0093430458,
-0.0082024531,
-0.0187874995,
-0.0003642626,
0.0721378177,
0.0106162224,
-0.0213571824,
-0.0640671477,
0.0027576762,
-0.0100133419,
-0.0468262136,
-0.0483250953,
0.0158745851,
0.0255722776,
0.0414323956,
0.0000021852,
-0.0516875908,
0.0376538858,
-0.047892265,
-0.0515203476,
0.0085979952,
-0.017259622,
-0.0119753452,
-0.0353931114,
-0.0184014998,
-0.0132602565,
0.031273488,
0.0337748006,
0.0430209562,
0.0244962573,
0.0454125144,
-0.0026511818,
-0.0293071233,
0.010876148,
0.0102737742,
0.0091213305,
-0.0544805825,
0.0264665857,
-0.0618433319,
-0.0122213662,
-0.0049347612,
-0.041289743,
0.0100771161,
0.0206529293,
-0.0062228725,
-0.021118788,
0.0501736291,
0.0176286269,
-0.0617102198,
-0.0228911806,
0.0526289567,
-0.0124265607,
-0.0233639926,
0.0169354416,
-0.0232101083,
-0.0079072593,
-0.0054227444,
-0.0361497626,
0.0316031016,
0.0223146863,
0.0099570742,
0.0192286633,
0.0215789154,
0.023255717,
-0.0091437846,
-0.0513605699,
0.0897692293,
-0.0250338539,
-0.0188990533,
0.0166317187,
-0.0096044429,
0.0683939904,
-0.0805560872,
0.0228121765,
0.0623032451,
0.0012013861,
0.0279163886,
-0.0046292003,
0.0212179068,
-0.0154813817,
-0.0856743976,
0.0565785356,
0.0391985029,
0.0065146927,
0.0274068881,
-0.0177531112,
0.0400034972,
-0.0673048645,
0.0378665738,
-0.0410246477,
0.0635052919,
0.0131655382,
-0.0135846771,
-0.0091800876,
0.0297892261,
-0.0054492233,
-0.0526355617,
-0.0167136714,
0.0532507114,
-0.004978837,
-0.0018409612,
-0.0462081805,
0.0008834187,
0.0074736038,
-0.0286169257,
-0.0741804987,
0.0214309189,
-0.0312772021,
-0.0139780063,
-0.0137610277,
-0.0252682008,
-0.0232462771,
0.0214564651,
-0.0072486033,
-0.0025385141,
-0.042666316,
0.1027940512,
0.001185037,
-0.0047430815,
-0.0237048585,
-0.0324452966,
0.0005525108,
-0.0603616424,
0.0786091685,
-0.0056319227,
0.0031717108,
0.0097819306,
0.0011259092,
-0.018393321,
0.00446575,
-0.0117270267,
0.0253069531,
0.0291474704,
0.0395710431,
0.0388779789,
-0.0115657346,
0.0057746046,
0.0159294326,
0.0679422691,
0.0386434011,
0.0756459981,
-0.0086883884,
-0.0093253711,
0.0145736998,
0.0389591791,
-0.0062340894,
-0.00050016,
-0.0220680218,
-0.0060890694,
-0.0020489802,
0.0440808348,
0.0409268588,
0.0216906108,
-0.0205886196,
-0.0339328013,
0.051860556,
0.0607932359,
0.0330267549,
-0.0224621054,
0.0600584894,
0.0025545415,
-0.0164433494,
0.0181298424,
-0.0492184646,
0.0751584172,
-0.0108764833,
-0.0128024416,
-0.0074011078,
0.0138148833,
-0.0244111754,
-0.0441782139,
-0.0035043214,
0.0283181258,
-0.0118685737,
-0.0104368692,
0.0276763029,
-0.0112569258,
-0.0417262912,
-0.0014870539,
-0.0289351791,
0.0075782845,
0.009744972,
-0.0878913105,
0.0253000781,
0.0726604983,
0.0223192703,
-0.0053978185,
-0.0403893329,
0.0164491516,
-0.0078450879,
0.0508688129,
0.006471863,
-0.0062627625,
0.0027004411,
-0.0052183261,
-0.0254142955,
-0.0022167929,
-0.0027172398,
0.0484349467,
-0.0692255124,
-0.0162614584,
-0.0152117955,
0.0299734734,
-0.0067504863,
0.0333003551,
-0.0313961245,
0.0009762747,
-0.0550580099,
0.0394605249,
0.0308829397,
-0.0082720658,
0.0025003245,
0.0292114895,
0.0603450164,
0.0014154994,
0.0007576842,
0.0303046089,
-0.053400062,
0.0068598022,
0.0343299061,
-0.0150259929,
-0.0081412131,
0.0017342874,
0.0297392532,
-0.0697361678,
0.0640409291,
-0.0452441387,
0.0484441705,
0.0029560437,
0.0393964276,
0.0076266541,
0.0098699378,
-0.0026750893,
0.0400837101,
-0.0044742585,
-0.0239027981,
0.0215421449,
0.0168519001,
0.0238473266,
-0.0348108597,
-0.0018211039,
0.0715422705,
0.004733657,
-0.003336051,
0.0378592163,
-0.0066980412,
-0.0587987676,
-0.0228009354,
-0.0467976332,
-0.0430627279,
-0.0201492403,
0.0123120071,
0.0121326968,
-0.035220813,
0.0000554335,
-0.0079847472,
-0.0001907025,
0.0695901364,
-0.0177763384,
0.0038885365,
0.0226776339,
0.0072592604,
-0.0374278761,
-0.0281981714,
-0.0090787876,
-0.024951579,
0.0269932263,
0.0059810174,
-0.0529976562,
-0.0618835762,
0.0213607717,
-0.0086390199,
0.0195202213,
-0.0247465055,
-0.0632688925,
0.0419169068,
-0.043945346,
0.016770212,
0.0675161108,
-0.0105972551,
0.0804374367,
0.089098312,
-0.0283059124,
-0.0441473052,
0.0273596458,
-0.039898444,
0.0490338504,
-0.0873056799,
-0.00824703,
0.0044822111,
0.1033984125,
0.0105306758,
0.0209475178,
-0.0667436942,
-0.0070868116,
0.0047645848,
-0.0939117,
0.0122024976,
0.0132669648,
-0.0560582429,
0.1050827876,
0.0060955351,
-0.0337736867,
0.0765912756,
-0.0066811885,
-0.0424180366,
0.0518438481,
0.0244340841,
-0.0174034722,
0.0937118009,
0.0173123945,
0.0261743777,
0.0202411599,
-0.0441348217,
-0.0440194644,
0.0289739072,
-0.0370461084,
0.0008450992,
0.0219482109,
-0.0390256718,
-0.0113361469,
-0.0106413849,
-0.006079718,
-0.0254349187,
0.0045498428,
-0.0407995693,
-0.0111208949,
-0.0112858303,
-0.0318120234,
-0.0411124751,
0.0078403633,
0.0558192767,
0.0240437128,
-0.0203149114,
-0.0188621301,
-0.0313625149,
-0.0443968587,
0.0323666297,
0.063292332,
0.0371844918,
-0.0194746945,
0.0685221627,
0.0410213247,
0.045082137,
0.010631551,
-0.029023245,
0.0018710579,
0.0619387627,
-0.0116611272,
-0.0238755737,
0.0527296737,
0.0476165265,
-0.0682508498,
-0.0155965537,
0.0755194202,
0.0116140768,
-0.0422042757,
0.0324326903,
-0.0440023616,
0.0121944938,
0.038132716,
0.0237048678,
-0.0000540382,
-0.020987099,
0.0064790929,
-0.0307615697,
-0.0254453998,
-0.0353126265,
0.0020787087,
-0.0903216302,
0.0345647894,
-0.004843602,
-0.0369733647,
0.008876279,
-0.0139247328,
0.0042056283,
0.0312622339,
0.0184183829,
0.0225822646,
-0.0057607037,
-0.0149232447,
-0.0043194499,
-0.0310109053,
0.0101603288,
0.0199345611,
0.0191430915,
0.0660529062,
0.0809381753,
0.0548301041,
-0.0315788537,
-0.0126213264,
0.0332793221,
-0.0362876691,
0.0459511913,
-0.0172652677,
0.0256289262,
0.0159980897,
-0.0086950231,
-0.0121580819,
-0.015070105,
-0.0272787847,
-0.0182983074,
0.0009850658,
0.0736305639,
-0.073706463,
-0.0505103618,
-0.0183383785,
0.0322749615,
-0.047474172,
0.0505257361,
0.0266432744,
-0.0569838881,
-0.0509644412,
-0.0496613383,
0.0168683641,
-0.0450627953,
-0.0673641488,
0.019448014,
0.0243959241,
-0.0219458491,
-0.0383291505,
-0.0736082643,
0.0238877553,
0.0290939584,
0.0439390689,
-0.0132137937,
0.0269278362,
-0.0098994179,
0.0053411345,
-0.0086475722,
-0.0150491055,
0.0168997459,
-0.059562128,
-0.0090061165,
0.0042680399,
-0.0707756206,
0.0207609516,
0.0442033522,
-0.0202262755,
-0.0556110814,
0.0132328104,
0.0380920768,
0.0251707267,
-0.0010692165,
-0.0121108908,
-0.0626777858,
0.015174536,
-0.0418693721,
-0.0424100719,
0.0498558097,
0.0337329023,
0.0447049402,
-0.0130514046,
0.0476093479,
-0.0175974928,
-0.0016097866,
0.0099230036,
0.0202461444,
-0.0108966576,
-0.0443320982,
0.0390997641,
0.0163550079,
0.0425939448,
-0.0061958567,
0.0280684438,
-0.0067932373,
-0.008695526,
-0.0093470942,
0.0135201281,
-0.0425972641,
-0.0016730152,
0.0385415778,
0.0136848893,
0.0326759219,
0.0076586949,
-0.003010008,
-0.0448774584,
0.011342668,
0.0125649637,
0.0062561519,
0.0139311738,
0.0060732383,
0.0376123153,
0.0066584451,
0.0243684705,
-0.0339182205,
0.0205442104,
0.0355951265,
0.0534574203,
0.0306013841,
-0.0252325702,
-0.0432382822,
0.0146335475,
-0.0964960009,
-0.0780719593,
0.0642256811,
-0.009388756,
0.0260801613,
-0.0022961027,
0.0531296246,
-0.0326846354,
0.0301790964,
-0.0187981669,
0.0228289478,
-0.0240482111,
-0.0563299805,
0.0192837529,
0.011295638,
-0.0211945157,
-0.053408511,
0.0327843875,
-0.0097105624,
0.0485543646,
0.0010993798,
-0.0082645155,
-0.0290944651,
-0.0372694619,
0.0057953317,
0.0447978117,
-0.028032938,
-0.0116717331,
-0.0735382363,
-0.0541632995,
-0.0050959089,
0.0134899402,
-0.0008251627,
-0.0654668361,
0.0261328369,
0.0204243399,
0.0028325794,
-0.0339426324,
-0.0387849435,
-0.0171881989,
-0.0128296344,
0.0126026282,
-0.0033565194,
-6.4189669e-33,
-0.023293566,
-0.0559770428,
0.0403168984,
-0.0285376739,
-0.035044428,
-0.0103105046,
-0.0676240325,
0.0032130815,
-0.0174213182,
0.0122127961,
-0.0353873372,
-0.0006361916,
0.0157855432,
-0.0160331242,
0.0485742092,
-0.0091771288,
0.0238188133,
-0.0221982673,
-0.0246240553,
0.0064838766,
0.0430598259,
0.0012898941,
0.0779741406,
-0.0068856142,
-0.0046965405,
0.0234808438,
-0.0114939678,
0.0302596502,
-0.02796828,
0.0473742038,
-0.0466091037,
0.0028253077,
0.0350059271,
-0.0440023839,
-0.0475504883,
0.0228000171,
-0.0079239188,
-0.0618850291,
0.0241679549,
0.0376612581,
-0.0510276444,
-0.0156926773,
0.0435743742,
-0.0039548734,
-0.0536646396,
0.0144516071,
0.0190866329,
0.0024821053,
-0.0187266599,
0.0343611985,
-0.0823295861,
-0.0049281791,
-0.0263648722,
-0.0163426623,
0.1014331579,
0.030321084,
-0.0095312865,
-0.0115688965,
-0.0336257964,
0.0427915901,
-0.0455811284,
0.0021447362,
0.0694381148,
0.0695535988,
0.0383698791,
0.0810422152,
0.0757471472,
0.0324959755,
-0.0401938446,
-0.0035487239,
0.0477110408,
0.0383342132,
-0.030438032,
-0.0289505608,
-0.0042328555,
0.0099466192,
0.00704238,
-0.0093655791,
0.0054429229,
0.0760906786,
0.0457438156,
0.0297256131,
-0.0339504443,
-0.0120015414,
-0.0261124335,
-0.0181450546,
-0.0102585973,
-0.0145337116,
0.0098802382,
0.0098341396,
0.0264252666,
-0.0030762393,
0.0581566617,
-0.022586586,
0.0131808501,
0.0159799047,
-0.0447953716,
0.0429755114,
0.0235219672,
0.0161347613,
-0.0401211604,
-0.0174561962,
-0.0124219097,
-0.0275871456,
0.0056948559,
0.0223739129,
-0.0671077669,
0.0538900532,
-0.0187512599,
-0.0238293316,
-0.0608602948,
-0.0500136949,
0.0434928425,
-0.0515662804,
0.0815621391,
-0.0409165472,
-0.0428874567,
-0.0137393037,
0.0079126768,
-0.0305214059,
-0.0166746639,
0.0177365895,
-0.0106314765,
0.0255289227,
-0.0659302026,
-0.0307354461,
-0.0739433467,
0.0636015162,
0.0661594644,
-0.0666756034,
-0.0288741272,
0.0157446321,
3.052e-7,
0.0200833157,
0.0335286148,
0.0021394219,
0.0588339828,
0.0430774502,
0.0564823598,
-0.020288663,
0.0247409008,
-0.013616153,
-0.0613956451,
0.0151120741,
0.0295606107,
0.0094871921,
-0.0109082246,
-0.0532557815,
-0.0093637295,
0.0139332497,
0.0154566402,
-0.0093204239,
0.0023941961,
0.027209226,
0.0747357309,
0.0099910432,
0.0003969193,
-0.0005550096,
0.0110032568,
0.0392242,
-0.0571567789,
0.0438465029,
-0.0016524568,
-0.0147831449,
-0.028479768,
-0.0214063134,
-0.0006347137,
0.0213120878,
0.0325443856,
-0.0268403161,
0.0514675044,
-0.0187271833,
0.0021571848,
0.0080802916,
-0.0055928007,
0.0024963089,
-0.0474220589,
0.039712891,
-0.0399055928,
-0.0638817027,
-0.0161855351,
0.0613156632,
-0.0083777523,
-0.0087344814,
0.0151059274,
0.0265410095,
0.0011056233,
-0.0229716282,
-0.03623721,
-0.0049316911,
-0.0864402577,
-0.0190286357,
-0.0043126773,
-0.0401618108,
-0.0108791487,
-0.0891522467,
0.0088756168,
0.0440187268,
-0.0670439452,
-0.0440439396,
2.580411909e-34,
-0.0025369332,
-0.0210405458,
0.0069660479,
0.0347878858,
0.0220238995,
-0.0213520825,
0.0133285215,
0.0469430387,
0.0419699922,
-0.0539055727,
-0.0634550974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16030v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16030v1 | Zero-Shot Cross-Lingual NER Using Phonemic Representations for Low-Resource Languages | 2024-06-23T06:38:56 | 2024-06-23T06:38:56 | Jimin Sohn, Haeji Jung, Alex Cheng, Jooeon Kang, Yilin Du, David R. Mortensen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing zero-shot cross-lingual NER approaches require substantial prior
knowledge of the target language, which is impractical for low-resource
languages. In this paper, we propose a novel approach to NER using phonemic
representation based on the International Phonetic Alphabet (IPA) to bridge the
gap between representations of different languages. Our experiments show that
our method significantly outperforms baseline models in extremely low-resource
languages, with the highest average F-1 score (46.38%) and lowest standard
deviation (12.67), particularly demonstrating its robustness with non-Latin
scripts. | [
-0.0297688562,
0.053449437,
-0.0026269834,
0.0301336683,
-0.0239482336,
-0.0033076012,
0.0302910842,
0.0079316245,
-0.0387097821,
-0.0024253149,
-0.0530992262,
-0.0406163484,
0.060126137,
-0.0196514726,
0.0562136509,
-0.0138308126,
0.001153635,
-0.0412516221,
0.0224945135,
0.0031568117,
0.0102192936,
0.0303592812,
-0.0321928076,
0.0674683452,
-0.0123750605,
0.000016416,
-0.0401621945,
0.0448232889,
0.0246001706,
-0.0640797243,
-0.022234669,
0.0245171264,
-0.0093392208,
0.0401172638,
0.0000016958,
-0.0508165024,
-0.0210017432,
0.0078394152,
-0.0086385962,
-0.0335016213,
0.0512046926,
-0.0795948952,
-0.0322238617,
0.0363323539,
0.0335294306,
0.0080708014,
0.0748774782,
0.055949714,
0.0015681305,
0.0769934207,
-0.0192555934,
-0.0256725717,
0.0072374092,
-0.0075196177,
0.0325270295,
-0.0050102146,
0.020397868,
-0.0502151549,
-0.036241129,
-0.0560453981,
-0.0329350233,
0.008636836,
-0.0121261515,
0.0184550546,
-0.0565191023,
0.0385894999,
-0.0305988472,
0.0043707686,
0.0043885116,
0.0375605598,
-0.0589420646,
0.0135093555,
-0.012782082,
0.0145950336,
-0.0695961863,
-0.0545423627,
-0.0408873931,
-0.0146886548,
-0.0084082149,
0.004541799,
0.0635946244,
0.0143020591,
0.0185990203,
-0.0399763323,
-0.018945206,
0.0452067889,
0.0582130663,
-0.0429314114,
0.0190278608,
-0.0052476334,
0.031069573,
0.0039612469,
0.0194408186,
0.0265408084,
0.014342797,
0.0245582368,
0.0007592618,
0.0182841513,
0.0185574386,
0.0064020283,
0.0645793378,
0.049084235,
-0.0062857666,
-0.0125252046,
-0.0264471341,
0.0149685638,
0.0352829993,
-0.0337385088,
0.0219487492,
-0.0505176522,
-0.026854638,
0.011067614,
-0.0217180364,
0.0205137078,
-0.021582365,
0.0186849255,
-0.0330080017,
-0.0357305221,
0.0165177826,
-0.0166004933,
0.0416990072,
-0.0188751966,
-0.0392174982,
-0.0014046191,
-0.000887493,
0.0966818482,
0.0069292858,
0.0048587499,
-0.0645708591,
-0.0634346604,
-0.0002527153,
-0.0057649864,
0.0096447067,
0.0077156518,
0.0059432313,
0.0857668892,
-0.0119007155,
-0.0566096157,
-0.0552191809,
-0.008324529,
-0.0156902187,
-0.0790929049,
-0.0504478142,
-0.0469514951,
0.0451512039,
-0.0025645841,
0.043516729,
-0.0473453887,
-0.0046899468,
-0.0056412276,
0.0216014944,
0.0963792354,
0.0113947913,
-0.0100103915,
-0.0050421874,
-0.0151798269,
0.0145097245,
0.0635038242,
0.029853709,
-0.0640953407,
0.018087836,
0.0110466965,
-0.039970424,
0.0440283939,
-0.0024209535,
0.0232402924,
-0.0109984344,
-0.0293295309,
-0.0280521289,
0.0088286446,
0.0267487727,
0.0397339426,
-0.0214139838,
-0.0157544948,
0.0196463205,
0.0764564574,
0.0774867088,
0.0073784045,
0.0118478956,
-0.0064086248,
-0.0343423896,
-0.0348558016,
0.0086100949,
0.0263518207,
-0.0313353166,
0.0299047399,
0.0266038664,
0.0457748882,
-0.0396008901,
0.0094319033,
0.0072529977,
-0.0374057367,
-0.0421505868,
-0.0207754187,
0.0636606067,
-0.0253264904,
-0.0343847834,
0.0347235352,
0.0357768536,
-0.0323362313,
0.0621629395,
-0.0026296764,
0.0210632998,
0.0521428511,
0.0137000317,
-0.0103228539,
-0.0555296429,
-0.0124669718,
-0.0894172788,
0.0845847204,
-0.0659963265,
-0.0200258754,
0.0822737813,
-0.0569803901,
0.0028718484,
0.0062211971,
0.0020382283,
0.0771885365,
-0.0477454551,
0.0877344087,
0.0169961546,
-0.0434250236,
-0.0124302497,
0.0007184352,
-0.0925225616,
-0.0061600613,
0.0232679751,
0.0309542082,
0.016039636,
0.0591788366,
-0.022954477,
-0.0032677469,
-0.0056163068,
-0.0581316091,
0.0320528671,
-0.023726834,
-0.0187565256,
-0.0800419003,
0.0229843967,
-0.0879339874,
0.0032747157,
0.0418848507,
0.0117328661,
-0.0872900933,
0.0193606112,
0.0304781739,
0.0322430283,
-0.0510530248,
0.0179832503,
0.022480173,
0.0074677072,
0.0271352679,
-0.0188687742,
0.0173981749,
0.0433328152,
0.0343305878,
-0.0196571387,
0.0582801737,
-0.0617137179,
-0.0769322067,
0.0397136621,
0.0091200136,
0.0102548525,
0.030412579,
0.0127184549,
0.010510684,
-0.0228963364,
-0.0794978738,
-0.0071799215,
-0.0192858595,
0.0294550862,
0.0052817464,
0.0353838429,
0.01611045,
-0.0220132861,
-0.0426063836,
0.0080083171,
-0.0101056909,
0.0054447902,
-0.0065436028,
-0.0023922508,
-0.0256282948,
-0.0092489682,
-0.0032186583,
0.0000900033,
0.0190630704,
-0.0037250572,
-0.0228114538,
-0.0589175224,
0.0051726256,
-0.043761313,
-0.0046455218,
-0.0025461521,
0.0126688499,
0.0303990729,
0.0071080057,
-0.0135840923,
-0.035248965,
-0.073016189,
-0.0385881364,
0.0125791673,
-0.0115744686,
-0.0455683023,
-0.0243563931,
0.030166002,
0.0376694463,
-0.0232459698,
-0.056217812,
-0.0174725745,
0.0753049627,
-0.0093336198,
0.0109022865,
-0.0564566664,
-0.0184986349,
-0.038514588,
-0.0337661095,
-0.0450173356,
0.041630052,
-0.0164158158,
0.0141641451,
-0.0162380524,
-0.0026173019,
0.0623293296,
-0.0717051104,
-0.0373036079,
-0.0409816355,
-0.0180409458,
-0.0646076873,
-0.0006244872,
-0.043104779,
-0.0019257932,
0.0497097932,
-0.0927419215,
-0.0148003465,
0.0097240768,
0.0046365312,
-0.0174930748,
0.0539118014,
0.012424957,
0.0175363682,
-0.0283044986,
-0.0167079587,
-0.0053376327,
0.0079474049,
-0.0175110828,
0.0563869625,
-0.0072241277,
-0.0287798569,
0.0016991058,
0.0856705084,
0.016508719,
0.0295515116,
-0.0140820462,
-0.0059296205,
-0.003098232,
0.0704999417,
0.0223467592,
-0.0412320457,
-0.0466935299,
-0.0180708524,
0.0384253003,
-0.0094424039,
-0.001017148,
0.022570448,
-0.0197761562,
0.0325297639,
0.0214368924,
0.0166544355,
0.0103925318,
0.0058799954,
-0.0289628338,
0.0221138094,
0.0087458203,
0.0948147327,
-0.0051775561,
-0.0513513125,
-0.0122120725,
-0.0342494026,
0.0427474305,
0.0189312957,
0.0141995819,
-0.0626943856,
-0.0410941653,
0.0100757834,
0.0282061063,
0.0099267866,
-0.0519763641,
-0.0018241411,
-0.1373606324,
-0.0089202737,
0.0238862336,
-0.0606101751,
-0.0092076464,
-0.0487295799,
0.0107751992,
-0.0454610102,
0.0420240425,
-0.021421222,
0.0151862614,
-0.0294358116,
0.0212629102,
0.0016695797,
-0.0419387855,
-0.0105526559,
-0.0398665667,
0.0230971724,
-0.0161099359,
0.0434079356,
-0.0046288585,
0.0135164876,
-0.0193938483,
-0.051376041,
0.0153329503,
-0.0198329799,
0.0371148773,
-0.0067454535,
-0.0261473861,
0.0081715146,
-0.0275059752,
-0.0324303359,
-0.0163467005,
-0.0021396098,
0.0503998138,
0.0065194215,
0.0380052514,
0.0299088191,
0.0047550369,
0.0481919646,
0.0396945775,
0.00715636,
-0.0226690844,
-0.0248673316,
-0.0084846849,
-0.0040830891,
-0.0411319956,
-0.0414416529,
0.0143223898,
0.0077214511,
-0.0775714293,
-0.0342950001,
-0.0551221669,
0.0413606316,
0.0376142077,
0.0310013387,
0.0200429484,
0.0038184277,
0.0119712604,
0.0006028665,
-0.0474582426,
-0.0081048002,
0.0210415125,
-0.0458867513,
0.0121315243,
0.0210174732,
0.0315823965,
0.0105816191,
-0.0249042064,
0.0244138744,
-0.0513459444,
-0.0197407231,
0.0250267871,
0.0184400845,
0.0405121818,
-0.0022570826,
-0.028987525,
0.0710947737,
0.0336330496,
0.0229196232,
-0.0020164805,
0.0242341682,
0.0333544426,
-0.0074466849,
0.0322333276,
-0.0285878833,
0.0052815066,
-0.0059750848,
0.082304284,
-0.0348399505,
-0.0794669986,
0.0251458865,
0.0277732443,
0.0141685754,
-0.0426892675,
-0.0055273818,
-0.0370685756,
0.0012641,
-0.0393606648,
0.0673471764,
-0.0006388692,
-0.0314359255,
0.0523029007,
-0.0091133201,
-0.0102945948,
0.0426748507,
-0.0520813912,
0.0022434208,
-0.0345215686,
0.0428558625,
0.0711280555,
0.0389016196,
-0.0118788853,
0.0265537258,
-0.0059443936,
0.0225589145,
0.0118487794,
0.0290794503,
-0.0410657115,
0.0234538,
-0.0323739909,
0.0261237323,
-0.0139101958,
0.0192800704,
0.0272493772,
0.0090479357,
-0.0038354737,
-0.0269394461,
0.0570656657,
0.0453820452,
0.0748816133,
-0.0038146588,
0.0309148692,
-0.021885246,
0.0193898641,
-0.0274879988,
0.0061494722,
0.0294693131,
0.007119142,
0.0154248532,
0.0207015201,
0.0558994897,
-0.0018337158,
0.0014477342,
0.0027737713,
0.0301733166,
-0.0124208461,
0.0133658638,
0.0554977767,
-0.0175644774,
-0.0519280769,
0.0009091711,
-0.0670762658,
-0.0707204342,
0.0405609757,
-0.0278623868,
-0.0191028584,
-0.0053726127,
-0.0148829529,
-0.0175087564,
-0.0038895968,
0.0453611501,
-0.0102130072,
-0.0326055922,
-0.0234053563,
-0.0151649872,
0.0004363699,
-5.695626451e-33,
0.002618226,
0.0353644565,
-0.0133549087,
-0.0215219595,
-0.008397093,
0.0215458423,
-0.0422416031,
0.0099969003,
0.0200883802,
-0.0380648561,
-0.0025079439,
-0.0210183728,
0.016377328,
-0.0096563138,
0.0098873787,
0.0005246762,
0.0531625897,
0.0312321261,
-0.0105084339,
-0.0005035121,
0.0796228126,
0.0740975663,
0.0936754271,
-0.0220493525,
0.01387583,
-0.0131403841,
0.0133427251,
-0.0179836769,
0.0619991794,
0.0496392325,
-0.0134472828,
0.0667545423,
0.0196241196,
-0.0977877006,
-0.006641821,
-0.0093940245,
-0.0691668764,
-0.0277448464,
0.023110278,
0.0180778932,
0.009734448,
-0.0128960805,
-0.0162249189,
0.0087044099,
0.0063206819,
0.0077261659,
0.0132467924,
0.0010162981,
-0.0384952463,
0.0161914192,
-0.0766193122,
0.0242421739,
-0.0211729631,
-0.0043694004,
0.0654645264,
0.0783151686,
-0.0072761024,
-0.0301107708,
-0.0932793468,
0.011943101,
-0.0154390065,
0.0221455805,
0.0360838883,
0.0275788512,
-0.04650883,
0.0017968975,
0.066215232,
-0.0263165515,
0.0415859111,
-0.0312933773,
0.0405994691,
-0.0117608188,
0.0023483182,
0.0544005781,
0.0408475511,
-0.0160032641,
-0.0347416587,
0.0520897135,
0.0320743918,
0.0492844395,
0.016885763,
0.0025376696,
-0.0267803799,
-0.0255843028,
-0.0053942092,
-0.0890542418,
-0.0409779027,
-0.0449714884,
0.0350520387,
-0.002558419,
-0.0012460112,
0.0174373686,
0.0759930611,
-0.0081717018,
0.0059653083,
0.0397476293,
0.0212171916,
0.0260014664,
-0.0061474391,
0.0186964273,
-0.0575246066,
-0.0393125564,
0.0192111097,
0.0049698884,
0.0520378277,
-0.057068862,
0.0354957059,
0.0302042998,
-0.0629787445,
-0.0158121567,
-0.0276724342,
0.0159084164,
-0.0175566431,
0.061631076,
-0.0094013587,
-0.0149154318,
0.0020456384,
-0.014040173,
0.0153592965,
-0.0296327379,
0.0495637283,
0.0246314388,
0.0455559902,
0.0192775894,
-0.0482996032,
0.018218305,
-0.0121853324,
-0.0099467309,
0.0138153154,
-0.0031463346,
-0.0124328779,
0.0265641604,
2.385e-7,
0.0020822645,
-0.0336873792,
0.0304937903,
-0.0081800716,
0.0030189147,
0.0116855782,
-0.0754316077,
0.0202013124,
-0.0071097924,
0.017377995,
0.0069831889,
-0.0239788648,
0.0586995445,
0.0255190916,
-0.1269042194,
-0.0250155255,
-0.0180007145,
0.0201522149,
-0.0398670845,
0.0551344864,
0.032883469,
0.0863605067,
-0.0503004678,
-0.0337033831,
-0.0261642188,
-0.0033825312,
0.0473884493,
0.0123787727,
-0.0028374009,
-0.038633395,
0.0187006835,
0.0046613067,
-0.0039422577,
0.0134943314,
-0.0291611068,
0.0341249183,
0.0074481419,
0.0476392657,
-0.0514318161,
-0.0643391237,
0.0302022025,
0.0427000113,
-0.037130855,
-0.0243143197,
0.0551724546,
0.0089292815,
-0.047758624,
0.0395215116,
-0.0368816294,
0.037111681,
0.0172114111,
-0.0140174776,
-0.0478710122,
-0.0001599151,
0.0431303419,
-0.0392673612,
-0.0174693633,
-0.0076048598,
0.0188245364,
0.0686005428,
0.0192513317,
-0.0179441497,
0.0105524482,
-0.0432814509,
0.0127802799,
-0.0429334007,
0.0183196962,
1.694145876e-34,
0.0133530423,
-0.0226879548,
0.0304714441,
0.0241968222,
-0.0084940149,
-0.0201497376,
-0.0096523631,
0.0097296303,
-0.0017168105,
-0.0594455115,
-0.0465996414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16021v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16021v1 | Harvesting Events from Multiple Sources: Towards a Cross-Document Event Extraction Paradigm | 2024-06-23T06:01:11 | 2024-06-23T06:01:11 | Qiang Gao, Zixiang Meng, Bobo Li, Jun Zhou, Fei Li, Chong Teng, Donghong Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Document-level event extraction aims to extract structured event information
from unstructured text. However, a single document often contains limited event
information and the roles of different event arguments may be biased due to the
influence of the information source. This paper addresses the limitations of
traditional document-level event extraction by proposing the task of
cross-document event extraction (CDEE) to integrate event information from
multiple documents and provide a comprehensive perspective on events. We
construct a novel cross-document event extraction dataset, namely CLES, which
contains 20,059 documents and 37,688 mention-level events, where over 70% of
them are cross-document. To build a benchmark, we propose a CDEE pipeline that
includes 5 steps, namely event extraction, coreference resolution, entity
normalization, role normalization and entity-role resolution. Our CDEE pipeline
achieves about 72% F1 in end-to-end cross-document event extraction, suggesting
the challenge of this task. Our work builds a new line of information
extraction research and will attract new research attention. | [
0.0143701555,
0.0201170202,
0.0191520154,
0.038528502,
-0.0551380068,
-0.0045674471,
-0.0251163151,
-0.0138164489,
0.0551274009,
-0.0378949419,
0.0076326588,
0.0459010825,
-0.0407160893,
0.0368745737,
-0.0420835912,
-0.0440067239,
0.0527954102,
0.0319278054,
0.0163702108,
0.0273993704,
0.0215436779,
0.0381759368,
-0.0119965672,
0.0203893259,
-0.0267043971,
0.008264035,
0.0053861253,
-0.020326484,
0.0498094521,
-0.0109483544,
-0.0062779416,
-0.0259884484,
0.0484993085,
0.0098375715,
0.0000016408,
-0.0455077738,
-0.0399830826,
0.0011007757,
0.0212458484,
0.0028460305,
-0.0139545295,
-0.0467788465,
-0.0119252289,
-0.0255910344,
-0.0005607926,
-0.0342908166,
-0.0016316281,
0.0898258314,
-0.0137792891,
0.064748548,
-0.0416689403,
-0.0102808885,
0.0479733199,
-0.0138722835,
-0.0069866478,
-0.0704440698,
0.028485978,
-0.0178124476,
0.0256617833,
-0.0115895197,
0.0340932645,
-0.0009283491,
-0.0088626752,
-0.0052660778,
-0.0230143107,
0.0206057038,
-0.0559459813,
0.007476544,
-0.0144472085,
0.0162731856,
0.0174955241,
0.0284080133,
0.079697296,
-0.0013306177,
-0.0272819791,
0.0179805309,
-0.0461537838,
0.0055812933,
-0.0175973363,
0.016756773,
0.0645934567,
0.0237227697,
-0.002951198,
0.0092154043,
0.0156957544,
0.0732502267,
0.0235948563,
0.0010844078,
-0.0202641264,
0.0291186329,
0.0330982804,
-0.0413055755,
0.0655652881,
0.0032300763,
-0.0013951887,
0.0326972194,
-0.0406301133,
0.0466417298,
0.0035057839,
-0.0659705624,
-0.036184635,
-0.0019678273,
-0.0037242924,
0.0668099001,
-0.0052667744,
-0.0273078419,
-0.0332482867,
-0.0127166724,
-0.0141045665,
-0.0517256185,
-0.0233327784,
0.0446284711,
-0.0035671152,
0.0164651442,
-0.0662056059,
-0.0189050958,
-0.0145792048,
-0.0127457697,
0.0232589673,
0.001610499,
0.0029132429,
-0.0120159611,
-0.028815046,
-0.0299265385,
0.0101914182,
0.0252762083,
-0.0339028612,
0.0165463109,
-0.0349245332,
-0.0214234237,
-0.0150142508,
0.0047170403,
0.0666834489,
-0.0165688507,
-0.0259955022,
0.0428391062,
-0.0120650278,
-0.0306723472,
-0.06234283,
-0.0567839891,
0.0015326586,
-0.0188334342,
-0.030908538,
-0.0336656868,
0.0655771419,
-0.0119325742,
-0.0122723039,
-0.0376804173,
0.0278951209,
-0.0115799708,
-0.0634435341,
0.0180605259,
-0.0189451221,
-0.0000686104,
0.0453504845,
-0.0037046252,
0.0207449179,
0.0594522879,
0.0643131584,
0.0119296834,
0.0632185191,
0.0209523346,
-0.0393828042,
0.0338826478,
0.0271737929,
-0.0063049104,
0.0704584569,
-0.0216818135,
-0.0325120948,
-0.0139930146,
0.0494300835,
-0.0320578925,
-0.0158734545,
0.00063285,
0.0089251343,
0.0205406547,
-0.0487171113,
-0.0338467807,
0.0029084929,
0.0013742615,
-0.024035776,
0.030909989,
0.0118737025,
-0.0225463286,
0.0299040452,
-0.0110278931,
0.0292236563,
-0.0181324426,
-0.0147921517,
0.0160754807,
0.030313326,
-0.0436327383,
-0.0144977821,
0.000517826,
0.0662519336,
-0.0225424301,
-0.017669145,
0.0589712784,
0.0335902572,
-0.0548418872,
0.0324989296,
0.0389519781,
-0.0075917984,
-0.0072375839,
0.0282232687,
-0.0568932593,
-0.0508388095,
0.0151759377,
0.0073745088,
0.0333351344,
0.0306796748,
-0.0427043289,
0.0499871634,
0.0056383582,
-0.0196591895,
0.0039145169,
0.0024599868,
0.0082300901,
0.036070805,
-0.0022270125,
0.0104406066,
0.0161271114,
-0.0013862831,
0.0203218907,
-0.0358561724,
-0.0272582751,
0.006471233,
-0.0016509546,
0.0066223159,
0.0181367882,
-0.0059587508,
-0.0159257427,
0.0442146957,
-0.0377863534,
-0.0072115255,
0.0587098524,
-0.0019036657,
0.0009443836,
0.0316511616,
-0.032340169,
-0.0399892144,
0.0016661868,
-0.0181904677,
-0.0713897571,
0.0071113156,
0.0326900072,
0.0115719037,
-0.0032771418,
-0.0055897529,
0.0250388235,
-0.0202270038,
-0.023017833,
0.0549591146,
0.0367892459,
-0.010063149,
-0.0168065242,
-0.0363259129,
0.0210644286,
-0.0184362195,
-0.0139301419,
0.0265838336,
-0.0197849516,
-0.0183852892,
0.0671464056,
-0.042826429,
-0.0639605969,
0.0054091034,
-0.0553263575,
0.0326433703,
-0.0015636828,
0.0670601279,
0.0512752794,
0.0569882207,
-0.0176387131,
0.0005884173,
-0.0293590724,
-0.06468229,
0.0047398475,
-0.0151540386,
0.0562355034,
0.0188336782,
-0.005866704,
-0.0405719206,
0.0177727621,
-0.0602774248,
0.0412414819,
-0.0034548459,
-0.0355139785,
-0.0262949429,
0.0375042222,
0.0086550182,
0.0439862646,
-0.0117531773,
0.037696898,
-0.0159198828,
0.0125926165,
0.0201320332,
0.0386338457,
-0.0083867898,
0.0399077758,
-0.0259588156,
-0.0632258803,
-0.0507334098,
0.0128947664,
-0.0186580662,
0.0123726781,
-0.0231109727,
-0.0079876715,
0.0322918743,
0.0453107841,
0.0163202118,
0.0227221344,
-0.0135794906,
-0.0550172403,
-0.0141643779,
-0.0215118341,
0.0207695365,
-0.0507822894,
-0.0217232089,
0.0374972299,
-0.0335360728,
0.0301901679,
0.0421158746,
-0.0241969582,
0.0013338552,
-0.03032705,
0.0233814009,
-0.0791566893,
0.0826289728,
-0.0279447436,
0.0218717456,
0.0131379869,
-0.0807415694,
0.0410171188,
-0.0304955691,
0.0373003595,
0.0119153084,
0.0267363135,
-0.044002898,
0.0485626496,
-0.0402912982,
-0.0281845238,
-0.0256817602,
-0.0217553787,
0.0060732272,
0.0067195287,
-0.0153369037,
0.0068267314,
-0.0485549085,
0.0035012462,
0.0134615479,
0.0273154564,
-0.0028760224,
0.005736141,
0.0087686628,
0.1072444692,
0.0212304741,
-0.0158235431,
-0.0433875434,
0.0101779727,
-0.0483601727,
0.0655618981,
0.0332036242,
0.0252266303,
0.010207165,
-0.0054765679,
0.0080292383,
-0.1042028591,
0.0163659528,
-0.0695767477,
0.0623059906,
-0.0742497146,
-0.0004291264,
0.0768054277,
0.0276718307,
-0.0386816822,
-0.0142738931,
0.0379409641,
-0.0378143266,
-0.0084990142,
-0.0005746118,
-0.0498500131,
-0.0135618951,
-0.0302067194,
-0.0236033481,
0.0082071116,
-0.0432906114,
0.0091892909,
-0.0320848003,
-0.0116121508,
0.0137200914,
-0.0112200305,
-0.0473201722,
-0.0579013675,
0.0500039645,
-0.0190427676,
-0.0372074917,
0.0019453685,
-0.0049546701,
-0.0421255752,
-0.0264574625,
-0.0568983331,
-0.0580771118,
0.02890772,
-0.029394703,
-0.012508194,
0.0302394181,
0.0376222394,
0.0114868823,
0.0709100366,
-0.0027883868,
-0.0485746749,
-0.0276645999,
-0.0101516126,
0.0360351689,
-0.0237739068,
0.0003356018,
0.0014998086,
0.0567484982,
-0.0134007353,
-0.0279958863,
0.0177901927,
0.0635251701,
0.0294008777,
0.0146768065,
0.0126573443,
-0.0115020489,
0.0389938653,
0.0423549749,
-0.0124530504,
0.012296536,
-0.00710674,
0.0083656935,
-0.0007659846,
-0.0521124974,
0.0097981961,
-0.006925974,
-0.054559458,
-0.0461593755,
-0.0481637456,
-0.0701777562,
0.0158161279,
-0.0234498847,
-0.0399042182,
0.0060008927,
0.0633626878,
0.0018750255,
-0.0376209915,
0.0306475814,
-0.051627662,
0.0098764161,
0.0418298133,
0.015569794,
0.0231859125,
0.0755989179,
-0.0191431958,
0.0833707228,
0.0029737195,
-0.0352343693,
-0.0133731887,
-0.0864396542,
0.0080171358,
0.0592293777,
-0.0151040321,
0.0190508775,
-0.0151492395,
-0.0001798157,
-0.0278591998,
-0.0349633172,
0.019586524,
0.0094603226,
-0.0222544093,
0.0452407263,
-0.0309379026,
0.0256613195,
-0.0463182516,
0.0522370897,
-0.05341167,
-0.0495077334,
-0.0135557037,
0.0081747025,
0.0396080017,
-0.0041735126,
0.0245833993,
-0.0543578081,
0.0177563,
-0.058174435,
0.007795136,
-0.0000011694,
0.0203290712,
-0.0239882246,
-0.0051738867,
-0.0073786029,
0.0391534455,
-0.0461876579,
0.0103563145,
-0.0574641228,
0.0337724276,
0.0540315807,
0.0381568559,
-0.0302251428,
-0.0176167935,
-0.0216276515,
0.0064199301,
0.0078273071,
0.0166048016,
-0.069902204,
-0.0438789986,
0.0008272243,
0.0006984213,
-0.0047163996,
-0.0408713296,
-0.0860061347,
0.0794653594,
-0.0182095375,
-0.0013483019,
0.0712247863,
-0.0403673798,
0.1013696939,
-0.0047162436,
-0.015539852,
0.0142171206,
0.0185150988,
-0.0082613546,
0.0322772004,
-0.0108432351,
0.0046426146,
-0.033522483,
0.0474270061,
0.0584064871,
-0.0077694287,
0.0723331198,
0.0075359792,
-0.0266184621,
-0.0412158668,
-0.0445723943,
0.0356268585,
0.0418841839,
-0.0224600323,
-0.0361465141,
-0.0467159972,
0.0555178262,
0.0626495555,
-0.0042667189,
-0.0175835397,
-0.008574795,
-0.0071756006,
0.031327296,
0.0495307446,
0.0054548467,
-0.0312869139,
0.0294476151,
0.0096929213,
-0.042576205,
-0.0117168957,
-5.494061496e-33,
-0.0503867529,
-0.0019211095,
-0.0059037819,
0.0891148672,
-0.0330376551,
0.0422679633,
-0.0434204489,
-0.0442131609,
0.0069095502,
-0.0007738571,
-0.0168498326,
-0.0115946624,
0.033668384,
-0.0111175859,
0.0314690433,
0.006947177,
0.0278240126,
0.018142309,
0.0092373136,
0.0535258055,
0.0696342215,
0.0451694205,
0.089457944,
-0.1216219515,
0.0711561143,
0.0354705118,
-0.0084851943,
-0.0357673503,
0.1045858711,
0.0216580667,
0.004876303,
0.0133010568,
0.0154828196,
-0.0572777428,
-0.0042576143,
0.0139495516,
-0.1225754172,
-0.0272365976,
0.0189898144,
-0.0038705349,
0.0096290242,
-0.0159300864,
-0.00027709,
-0.0105389114,
0.0432326384,
-0.0170769803,
0.0262438934,
-0.0007698845,
-0.0258557592,
-0.0762908086,
-0.0759215057,
0.0751751065,
-0.0070207547,
0.0059401207,
0.0330244824,
-0.0065221996,
0.0542832762,
0.0347220264,
-0.0190821234,
0.0312396958,
-0.0799547955,
0.0139587922,
-0.0168461259,
-0.0403850339,
-0.0305099543,
0.0371554717,
-0.0167198572,
-0.0035995604,
-0.0150556704,
0.02698428,
-0.0330881029,
0.0659260899,
-0.0380426124,
0.0667791814,
-0.0036532802,
-0.0096850116,
-0.1119491905,
0.0918407291,
0.077572003,
-0.0283513702,
-0.045367308,
0.0169687141,
-0.0216963086,
0.0014589924,
0.0152062718,
0.0077806432,
0.0172530413,
0.0091574239,
-0.0323687494,
0.0088549489,
0.0087624844,
0.1017949954,
0.0112220515,
-0.0256380066,
-0.0349869579,
0.0436041579,
0.0209339466,
0.0256951116,
-0.012741643,
-0.0123692658,
-0.0482189283,
-0.0435416549,
-0.0115069626,
0.014736711,
0.018882351,
-0.007156495,
0.0017060619,
-0.0334183425,
-0.0339624062,
0.0074303858,
-0.0003806679,
-0.0163851399,
-0.0537791923,
-0.0017123413,
0.0077961036,
-0.0167197045,
0.0155976843,
0.001887759,
0.0308494307,
0.0541896224,
0.0044701896,
-0.0178078469,
-0.0022109514,
0.0611854866,
0.0306331292,
0.011288668,
-0.0262797568,
0.0308304448,
0.0117856171,
0.0117730862,
0.0015546188,
-0.0056222351,
2.327e-7,
0.0434268452,
-0.0125164464,
0.0585412458,
0.0520994961,
-0.0091872113,
0.0206503477,
0.0043889917,
0.0617804825,
-0.0003961538,
0.0148559315,
-0.0055701016,
-0.0142567456,
0.0131587917,
0.0704554021,
-0.0851494148,
-0.0725321099,
-0.0350013711,
-0.0395822488,
-0.0649375319,
0.0123217842,
0.0182362236,
0.0061913235,
0.0339670628,
-0.0075105089,
-0.0355485752,
-0.0140386857,
0.0287815686,
-0.0139806764,
-0.0855872408,
0.0481266864,
-0.0115710087,
0.0345752984,
-0.0367940366,
0.0163493119,
-0.0305888541,
0.0555722527,
-0.0188383386,
0.0640148446,
-0.0008641604,
0.0065065781,
-0.0015096249,
-0.0554287508,
-0.0041610417,
0.0259653814,
0.0588058271,
-0.0213240571,
-0.0049736989,
-0.0715181679,
-0.0330862515,
0.0444204807,
-0.0471868478,
0.022565268,
-0.0345212892,
0.035923738,
-0.0066581969,
-0.0043837535,
-0.0253537055,
-0.0854611248,
0.0007357484,
0.0603069812,
0.0027522014,
-0.0032297552,
0.0348986611,
-0.0382486247,
-0.0213748813,
-0.0243890099,
0.0074441833,
1.90431118e-34,
-0.0243176054,
0.0403181538,
-0.0393808112,
0.0135211796,
0.0296670925,
-0.033056248,
-0.0487396419,
-0.0115698893,
-0.0131387627,
-0.006885618,
0.0178220794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16020v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16020v2 | AudioBench: A Universal Benchmark for Audio Large Language Models | 2024-06-23T05:40:26 | 2024-06-25T12:27:06 | Bin Wang, Xunlong Zou, Geyu Lin, Shuo Sun, Zhuohan Liu, Wenyu Zhang, Zhengyuan Liu, AiTi Aw, Nancy F. Chen | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | We introduce AudioBench, a new benchmark designed to evaluate audio large
language models (AudioLLMs). AudioBench encompasses 8 distinct tasks and 26
carefully selected or newly curated datasets, focusing on speech understanding,
voice interpretation, and audio scene understanding. Despite the rapid
advancement of large language models, including multimodal versions, a
significant gap exists in comprehensive benchmarks for thoroughly evaluating
their capabilities. AudioBench addresses this gap by providing relevant
datasets and evaluation metrics. In our study, we evaluated the capabilities of
four models across various aspects and found that no single model excels
consistently across all tasks. We outline the research outlook for AudioLLMs
and anticipate that our open-source code, data, and leaderboard will offer a
robust testbed for future model developments. | [
-0.0293681305,
0.0621218272,
0.0099390466,
0.0850974172,
-0.01880184,
-0.0050289929,
0.04080984,
-0.0204708856,
-0.0635223165,
-0.0031283244,
-0.0959004238,
-0.0453852341,
0.0283607226,
0.0400908068,
0.0284667388,
-0.0584740676,
0.0099141998,
-0.0958418623,
-0.0112407068,
0.0083585866,
0.0120867817,
-0.0009020987,
-0.0396333076,
0.0498021953,
-0.0114120645,
-0.025684854,
0.0088466629,
0.0531082526,
0.0239513312,
-0.027380975,
-0.0291061793,
-0.000023794,
0.0404868498,
0.0407306366,
0.0000014014,
-0.0269651711,
0.0194367897,
-0.0109892348,
-0.0439718477,
0.0149577232,
0.0117395362,
-0.0216657482,
-0.0441728719,
-0.0005420264,
0.0008304343,
-0.0443926267,
0.0443453677,
-0.0026227599,
0.0567358285,
0.0623719282,
-0.0106892744,
-0.0564182177,
0.0004762746,
-0.0392220691,
-0.0173568614,
-0.0396132283,
0.0043807654,
0.0386570282,
0.0078827292,
-0.0257025938,
-0.038499821,
0.0648275092,
0.0123661598,
0.0099037578,
0.002273812,
0.0111928703,
-0.0450659022,
-0.0450736061,
-0.00385998,
0.0958050489,
-0.0002253616,
0.0053524701,
-0.0120909996,
0.033152245,
-0.0533133931,
-0.0388989262,
-0.0523543172,
0.0238063484,
0.0101794684,
-0.0052643237,
-0.0413701907,
0.0469645225,
0.0667889789,
-0.0250217672,
-0.0038583295,
0.028058948,
0.0266369563,
-0.0000598337,
0.0123616131,
-0.046782013,
-0.020229144,
-0.0117332647,
0.0261187721,
0.0032860136,
-0.0302847531,
-0.0020172931,
-0.0107227806,
0.0007944134,
-0.0252034869,
-0.0232926533,
0.0514430739,
0.0286499523,
-0.0756972358,
0.1013186201,
-0.0076636695,
0.0581934936,
-0.0161190219,
-0.017104052,
-0.021858491,
-0.0068720067,
-0.0115103377,
-0.0019882391,
-0.0253181122,
-0.037903782,
-0.0263210721,
-0.0520934835,
0.012585423,
-0.0185436346,
-0.0252018645,
0.0265030209,
0.0154516622,
-0.008257905,
-0.0285210982,
-0.0304012317,
0.0576258115,
0.0632050037,
-0.0063742679,
0.0368833728,
-0.0330299437,
-0.0728805438,
-0.0021723171,
0.0406109914,
0.0116918068,
-0.0109443357,
0.0015919126,
0.0732281208,
0.0130007062,
-0.0117534772,
0.0135086766,
0.0167541802,
-0.0204207357,
-0.0783271492,
-0.0218324829,
-0.0364896357,
0.0444203317,
-0.023125302,
0.0202295985,
0.0019441884,
-0.0200456623,
-0.0407243483,
0.0378160924,
0.0794039816,
0.0140407644,
0.0392294899,
0.0367233753,
0.0372957587,
0.0090247868,
0.0649857596,
0.0412430651,
0.0043031476,
0.0121403085,
-0.0381845124,
-0.0245326981,
0.089554511,
-0.011650973,
0.0087657897,
-0.0422638208,
-0.0022438017,
0.0105152559,
0.0684818923,
0.0430861525,
0.0591561534,
-0.0420690887,
-0.0532506816,
0.069200635,
0.0290073901,
0.0156721268,
-0.041373387,
0.0228222907,
-0.0089608338,
0.0181637835,
-0.0105502978,
-0.0275243763,
0.0222039092,
0.0362057537,
0.0155159039,
0.0230735987,
0.0285416618,
-0.0134987542,
0.0290381201,
-0.0192500111,
-0.0257939305,
-0.0324117355,
0.0120901214,
0.0442843698,
0.0133871865,
-0.0149166519,
0.0382893756,
-0.0067536971,
-0.0314773843,
-0.0001038684,
-0.0258057378,
0.0132139213,
0.0493762866,
0.0332194865,
-0.0234109778,
-0.0196537934,
-0.0121394647,
0.0254505593,
0.0530041605,
0.0294018295,
-0.0249263216,
0.0926248431,
-0.0564708002,
-0.01713215,
0.0140437838,
0.0107561676,
0.0556072034,
-0.0182443243,
-0.013336502,
0.0002184565,
-0.0664114505,
0.0395662338,
-0.0138047123,
-0.021901371,
-0.0123320716,
0.002165298,
0.0116788652,
0.0475930087,
0.025329046,
-0.0504032187,
-0.0181042738,
0.0118822865,
-0.0450961888,
0.0579264574,
0.0427630171,
-0.0874004513,
-0.023664264,
0.0553589053,
-0.0247589797,
-0.0048112106,
0.0702707469,
-0.0233105496,
-0.0434011333,
0.0451255813,
-0.0206018463,
0.0390242077,
-0.047487434,
0.0064009842,
-0.013270597,
0.0367381722,
0.0126406783,
-0.0079216799,
0.019737225,
-0.0121112196,
0.033161629,
0.018315699,
0.0108564226,
-0.0445870273,
-0.0477360189,
0.0579735674,
-0.0020375499,
0.0120992651,
-0.0379115492,
-0.0435045585,
-0.0366925336,
-0.0061216834,
-0.0806698203,
0.0035185223,
-0.0431157723,
0.0041969283,
0.0038257823,
-0.0010945469,
-0.0103068901,
-0.0453429185,
-0.0038938171,
-0.0144010838,
0.0039205956,
0.0035394691,
-0.070639506,
0.0190751348,
-0.0288933665,
-0.0198700875,
-0.0157390945,
0.0404516645,
0.0271225143,
-0.0329321325,
-0.010578474,
-0.0214356668,
-0.0065775095,
-0.0165387373,
0.0275658146,
-0.0201304592,
-0.0229550079,
-0.0287820268,
-0.02414608,
0.0437774062,
0.0367926955,
-0.0131973336,
0.0165995304,
0.0489114374,
-0.0356743895,
-0.0327940099,
0.0000567339,
0.053572394,
-0.0017325864,
-0.051343102,
0.0042822999,
-0.0405734889,
0.0595289208,
0.036073897,
0.0477452464,
-0.0132913096,
-0.0192624163,
-0.0457669199,
-0.0238748919,
-0.0383607931,
-0.0355566442,
-0.0413240232,
0.0320242345,
-0.0407015868,
-0.038174741,
0.032920856,
-0.096557118,
-0.0626160502,
-0.0196395889,
-0.0464917049,
-0.0298919678,
0.0543023087,
-0.0027093864,
0.009810294,
-0.0308582764,
-0.0301758349,
-0.0112013938,
0.0110606747,
0.0266025886,
-0.0544846244,
0.0369284637,
-0.0216120798,
-0.0051761921,
-0.0217237063,
-0.0286991149,
-0.0140384641,
-0.0156180272,
-0.0585947111,
-0.001038808,
-0.0116894851,
-0.0156381149,
-0.0246446226,
0.0765961483,
0.014082212,
0.0514498129,
-0.011255065,
0.0320965052,
-0.0025466275,
0.045770295,
0.044185508,
0.0237865169,
-0.0100104297,
-0.060276024,
0.0515973233,
-0.0057240217,
0.0372238718,
0.0073500876,
-0.0888954028,
0.0379667319,
0.0218556728,
0.043014586,
-0.0323324576,
0.0145311859,
0.0379876904,
-0.0638563558,
0.0322067738,
0.0965605527,
-0.0143109681,
-0.0343120396,
-0.0103142196,
0.0096302908,
0.0278747547,
0.0214689113,
-0.0292917527,
-0.054097347,
-0.0485949963,
0.0392750278,
0.0236456897,
0.0589073487,
0.0271411277,
-0.0105565479,
-0.0624858923,
0.0377988033,
0.0174865592,
-0.0597377419,
-0.0228395034,
-0.0120859416,
0.0117344763,
-0.0262455996,
0.0455198511,
0.0121164545,
-0.0115401074,
-0.0270927344,
0.0171437934,
-0.0337700807,
-0.0561395846,
0.0529809333,
-0.0479496941,
0.0858644098,
0.0659466237,
0.0141708134,
-0.0071281437,
0.0033246244,
0.0495107509,
0.0058989739,
-0.0110099521,
0.0211126637,
0.0313381962,
0.0086742379,
-0.0386295877,
0.0408606194,
0.0165619422,
-0.0128679201,
-0.0033451279,
0.0130585469,
0.036874596,
-0.0029190874,
-0.0057844259,
-0.0051832171,
0.0478313714,
-0.0031221381,
0.0740293562,
0.0339532383,
-0.003471646,
-0.0050535323,
0.0168290548,
0.0264227316,
-0.0462489538,
0.007736953,
0.0088549359,
0.0231715627,
-0.0255454667,
-0.0028142896,
0.0194973033,
-0.0183145069,
0.0433300957,
0.0325188898,
0.0032197156,
-0.015528149,
0.0044285194,
-0.0364497714,
0.0496685803,
-0.0036596758,
0.0721055344,
-0.0521831401,
-0.0008460928,
0.0526588038,
-0.028340783,
-0.0035713697,
0.0438262336,
-0.0954205245,
-0.0373750515,
-0.0023295404,
-0.0004529521,
0.0262904186,
0.0550784916,
-0.0208186172,
-0.0614107586,
-0.0233624931,
-0.0388503894,
-0.0220354851,
0.0508655719,
0.0192926284,
-0.0120921489,
-0.0197400022,
0.0513460822,
-0.0686491504,
0.0417368673,
-0.0143633969,
0.0364396237,
-0.0005041815,
-0.0313886553,
-0.0252099577,
-0.0074399649,
0.0351690985,
0.0034669079,
0.0255304351,
-0.029094778,
0.0314198248,
-0.001584608,
0.0257542841,
-0.0440074019,
-0.0047674887,
0.0517002903,
0.020965619,
-0.0245876629,
0.0239090975,
0.0252996143,
0.0049647526,
-0.0311624724,
0.0639375672,
0.0283218808,
-0.0584996007,
0.0324491374,
-0.0094178775,
-0.0012551164,
0.0477937013,
-0.0013718806,
0.0205930229,
0.0223573986,
0.0414745696,
-0.0040374324,
-0.025034273,
0.0068205763,
0.020820627,
-0.0233347658,
-0.0205975138,
0.0029287837,
0.0251921359,
0.0561442897,
-0.0178801697,
0.0555245169,
0.0169037115,
0.0142658465,
-0.0571077876,
0.0354592353,
-0.023554543,
-0.03029323,
0.0396819562,
0.0176421031,
-0.0104362192,
0.0438381881,
0.0508038402,
0.0186643433,
0.0186924804,
-0.0022987581,
0.056864012,
-0.028829284,
-0.0214561,
-0.0158295687,
0.0121658193,
-0.0274978522,
0.0107609555,
-0.0005231762,
-0.0839478448,
-0.0042924425,
0.0140454499,
0.0281241853,
-0.0086441375,
-0.0017134378,
0.0389387347,
-0.0172178894,
-0.0005371812,
0.0244021993,
-0.0408031605,
-0.0238304157,
0.0001990572,
0.0124942046,
-5.179770306e-33,
-0.0255768523,
0.0244545843,
0.0044952692,
-0.0418101251,
-0.0323907621,
0.0216673259,
-0.0645271987,
-0.0014079697,
-0.0000223165,
0.006488889,
0.0308931693,
0.0298993923,
0.0208431128,
0.0180915818,
-0.0373538211,
-0.0167763066,
0.0821588114,
-0.0181840137,
-0.0256471708,
-0.012723757,
0.0131064467,
0.0390050411,
0.0157038476,
-0.0410042368,
-0.0414461792,
0.0017326025,
-0.022766225,
0.0236318186,
-0.0030778253,
0.0706122369,
-0.0214190762,
0.0136566833,
-0.0014878417,
-0.0257270504,
-0.0292007141,
0.0199197512,
-0.0777624547,
0.0407096259,
0.0198927056,
0.0733676925,
-0.0121995052,
0.0073828907,
0.0279475898,
0.013443036,
-0.0208401158,
-0.0430533886,
0.0087307291,
-0.0392182879,
-0.0189629328,
-0.0122574028,
-0.0230435282,
0.0394508839,
-0.0418573171,
-0.0484160222,
0.0657309592,
0.0418424904,
-0.0215398632,
-0.0018407358,
-0.0447653085,
0.0181564223,
-0.0234301686,
0.0302377865,
0.0975874737,
0.0758711398,
-0.0214438681,
0.0643808842,
0.0445737243,
-0.0851192251,
0.0058406214,
-0.0173726305,
0.036458075,
0.0514649935,
-0.0032609529,
0.0153216431,
-0.0062448876,
0.0145144779,
0.0084331986,
-0.0205361843,
0.0190871414,
0.0124700321,
0.0254196562,
0.0546403974,
-0.0285122264,
0.0046567223,
-0.0619291104,
-0.0069376552,
-0.0510130189,
0.0059815305,
0.0673741698,
-0.0198779684,
0.0011260605,
-0.0000924741,
0.0794625953,
-0.0611817576,
0.0079689743,
0.0371284969,
-0.010723643,
0.0033564232,
-0.0002693525,
0.0717735067,
-0.0221689921,
0.0116865691,
0.063037768,
0.0256239772,
0.0222969018,
-0.0559603833,
-0.0194303133,
0.0411371738,
-0.0387494043,
-0.016040938,
-0.0054470827,
-0.0146591002,
-0.0199438464,
0.0677141622,
0.04636636,
-0.0048134346,
-0.0409518592,
0.0565851517,
-0.031454511,
0.0166358408,
-0.0198975299,
-0.0285700951,
-0.0360859707,
0.0154798878,
-0.0459851138,
0.023173444,
-0.0045859581,
-0.0636600927,
0.0379367881,
-0.0348605774,
-0.0180986486,
0.0194515735,
2.186e-7,
-0.0073167472,
-0.0092742229,
0.0370494686,
-0.0082000634,
0.0406519473,
0.0150496569,
-0.0818773359,
-0.0053278618,
0.0041124467,
-0.0200538896,
-0.0159813035,
0.034774866,
0.1084853783,
0.0057033501,
-0.079084903,
-0.0069627352,
-0.0854110345,
0.0161075108,
-0.0414245911,
-0.0115551138,
0.0090100402,
0.1138683632,
-0.0256282259,
-0.0395087861,
0.0524222106,
-0.0425617471,
0.0175622515,
-0.0348124616,
-0.0112407943,
-0.0111320391,
0.0063741659,
0.0032357755,
-0.0020747795,
-0.0161555279,
0.0035697753,
-0.0011941887,
0.0387781039,
0.0614354461,
0.0099962652,
-0.0516725816,
-0.0236596223,
0.0475087948,
-0.0401385948,
-0.027612254,
0.0577083528,
0.0253067221,
-0.0455665588,
-0.0624396577,
-0.0552181304,
-0.0402798392,
-0.0125949765,
0.0023644415,
-0.0050312057,
0.0049578622,
0.0215898063,
-0.0410942771,
-0.0367810428,
-0.0662912428,
-0.0340957232,
0.0170242451,
-0.0800183341,
-0.0185174737,
-0.0288117118,
-0.022437552,
0.0222189128,
-0.0445899405,
-0.0361512974,
1.357307281e-34,
0.0524799861,
-0.0533738434,
0.0299675278,
-0.0099013969,
0.0108341444,
-0.0436951332,
-0.0155029222,
-0.0056575453,
-0.0290330444,
-0.0497508049,
-0.0017968715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16013v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16013v1 | Database-Augmented Query Representation for Information Retrieval | 2024-06-23T05:02:21 | 2024-06-23T05:02:21 | Soyeong Jeong, Jinheon Baek, Sukmin Cho, Sung Ju Hwang, Jong C. Park | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Information retrieval models that aim to search for the documents relevant to
the given query have shown many successes, which have been applied to diverse
tasks. However, the query provided by the user is oftentimes very short, which
challenges the retrievers to correctly fetch relevant documents. To tackle
this, existing studies have proposed expanding the query with a couple of
additional (user-related) features related to the query. Yet, they may be
suboptimal to effectively augment the query, though there is plenty of
information available to augment it in a relational database. Motivated by
this, we present a novel retrieval framework called Database-Augmented Query
representation (DAQu), which augments the original query with various
(query-related) metadata across multiple tables. In addition, as the number of
features in the metadata can be very large and there is no order among them, we
encode them with our graph-based set encoding strategy, which considers
hierarchies of features in the database without order. We validate DAQu in
diverse retrieval scenarios that can incorporate metadata from the relational
database, demonstrating that ours significantly enhances overall retrieval
performance, compared to existing query augmentation methods. | [
0.0244770423,
0.0067937686,
-0.0271279365,
-0.0243717674,
-0.0182996001,
0.0135885952,
-0.0229318477,
0.0450468585,
0.0037753102,
-0.0425030775,
0.0021491747,
0.0183783602,
-0.0524998531,
0.0360639282,
0.0020971231,
-0.0724124089,
0.0141234323,
0.0219730735,
-0.0411003716,
0.0224330164,
0.0138835805,
0.0310021862,
0.0578125119,
0.0043912274,
-0.0243678577,
0.0337042809,
-0.0339808203,
0.0511649437,
-0.0447726846,
-0.0042298129,
-0.0232045185,
0.0353938341,
0.0310101211,
0.0135699576,
0.0000020803,
-0.0100653544,
-0.0826727152,
0.0367070027,
-0.0250489879,
-0.003968196,
0.0552323498,
-0.0160728861,
0.0564990602,
-0.0091654016,
0.0052535553,
-0.0532018244,
0.0122163845,
0.0285287909,
0.0200145058,
0.0462914445,
-0.0008534515,
-0.0388776772,
0.0017854584,
0.0034650937,
0.0851672441,
-0.0325580612,
0.0143430745,
0.0277893059,
0.1154429317,
0.0576098636,
0.003776995,
0.0098901084,
-0.035217531,
-0.0045149624,
0.0743981972,
-0.0177905113,
-0.0269644558,
0.0534064211,
0.0373223871,
0.0212237239,
0.0508090518,
-0.0300630201,
0.0009520781,
0.0178718157,
-0.0115776286,
0.0745343193,
-0.061468862,
-0.0620800368,
-0.0163301099,
-0.01063364,
-0.0506275967,
-0.0112567255,
0.0349241011,
-0.0049027847,
-0.0302432198,
0.0463977531,
-0.0056356778,
-0.0029726834,
-0.0346018188,
-0.0297814421,
0.004861725,
-0.0058234399,
0.0311704818,
0.0088344598,
-0.0068421429,
0.0255816095,
-0.0065226033,
-0.0164032336,
0.0526238941,
-0.0370724797,
-0.0156089291,
0.039537929,
0.0015519155,
0.060163442,
0.0059325164,
0.0048773531,
-0.0213125646,
0.016746249,
-0.0440463461,
-0.0407987349,
-0.0827631578,
-0.0259285308,
-0.0435231104,
0.0333668254,
-0.015599071,
-0.0049573118,
-0.0155314207,
0.0582680702,
-0.0056866962,
-0.0013475452,
0.0205910746,
0.0489212945,
-0.0048698639,
-0.0039289496,
-0.0490755066,
-0.0160149224,
-0.0262738355,
-0.0282016527,
0.0304551795,
-0.0391638651,
0.008857348,
-0.0078252992,
0.0440486185,
-0.0214947537,
0.0024121045,
-0.018607365,
0.0310291704,
-0.0308007989,
-0.0326285213,
-0.0666458383,
0.0475888886,
0.0383097827,
-0.0191898812,
-0.0272189081,
0.0599883087,
0.0254120752,
-0.0223405138,
0.0086681284,
-0.0233794507,
0.0423708856,
-0.0275647026,
0.0368475094,
-0.0300066192,
0.0239583738,
0.0355458967,
-0.0086541725,
0.0064592315,
0.0286644828,
0.0024658828,
0.040938355,
0.0341835245,
0.0048738117,
-0.0321133547,
-0.0396185704,
0.0332202502,
0.0003486751,
-0.0242822226,
0.0649800375,
0.0048985919,
0.0237802528,
-0.0486831181,
-0.001658156,
-0.0558595434,
-0.0035388402,
-0.0144473026,
0.0095012877,
0.008897325,
-0.0327752978,
-0.014094051,
0.0336518399,
-0.0082605295,
-0.0207086019,
0.0162604693,
0.0223666653,
-0.0027408251,
-0.0265834406,
0.0189235508,
-0.0186721385,
-0.0380104445,
-0.0249506906,
0.0041750451,
-0.0044567077,
0.0052456344,
0.0484159514,
0.0213424433,
-0.0166498031,
0.0277241226,
0.0087371962,
-0.0115997987,
-0.023068836,
0.0237627048,
-0.0127859963,
-0.0482803509,
0.1054583788,
0.0571037717,
-0.0566208586,
0.0097773438,
0.0097398935,
0.0231367797,
-0.0519577004,
0.036149431,
-0.0222913511,
-0.0265935957,
-0.0208037626,
-0.0634608343,
0.0048362482,
0.0124549074,
0.0283574779,
-0.0161605813,
0.0192650501,
0.0386683941,
-0.0860195905,
-0.0270098224,
-0.0034233702,
0.0087010721,
-0.003028861,
0.0378322825,
0.0144977458,
-0.0093698986,
0.0495538525,
0.0227284841,
0.036021933,
0.0550294966,
0.0097498391,
-0.0419959053,
-0.0710071474,
0.0304176584,
0.0517934263,
-0.0040147877,
-0.0006141978,
0.0315794796,
-0.0453183427,
0.0106318984,
-0.0556315631,
-0.0164660048,
-0.0265475642,
0.0069370787,
-0.0298248939,
0.0158676486,
-0.0306179579,
-0.0050630257,
-0.0544523187,
0.0370251834,
0.0297699291,
-0.0117757777,
-0.0247738231,
-0.0499878414,
0.0258894973,
-0.0333303958,
0.0015011862,
0.0418786146,
0.0292965379,
0.0486519262,
0.0429942869,
-0.0412294567,
-0.0398745127,
0.0505581461,
-0.0768682584,
0.0089921579,
0.000487854,
-0.0094434395,
-0.0083813779,
0.0679900274,
-0.0020785315,
-0.0100580323,
-0.0654573739,
-0.0403026156,
-0.0096818721,
0.0130588431,
-0.0200326499,
0.0336630493,
-0.0159305707,
-0.0115382485,
-0.053421475,
-0.0247345846,
0.0310633034,
-0.0405010469,
-0.0411407202,
0.0302355774,
-0.0145926122,
-0.0400203466,
0.0056739147,
0.0174333043,
0.0450434238,
-0.000394293,
-0.0756156519,
-0.0388233922,
0.0315606929,
0.0023367533,
-0.0102686537,
0.0306765921,
0.0069798217,
-0.0648734495,
0.0096600847,
-0.0307530258,
0.0300474856,
0.035263665,
-0.0591045283,
0.0167408437,
-0.12168625,
0.0019052024,
0.0221307017,
-0.060745012,
-0.0245527849,
0.0486770384,
-0.0018759578,
-0.0882640556,
-0.0008089016,
0.0693873838,
0.0497777574,
-0.0061565591,
0.0106591629,
0.053267736,
0.0066237687,
0.031129783,
0.0421835147,
0.0118902801,
-0.055392053,
0.0712902695,
0.0082159033,
0.0160502903,
-0.0290746875,
-0.0219580214,
0.0123746488,
-0.006247106,
0.0433353037,
-0.0716286376,
0.0049385703,
0.045852229,
0.0282397978,
0.0367523544,
-0.0377231278,
0.0013523943,
-0.002140098,
0.0204996951,
0.0234820396,
-0.0042059212,
-0.0058270176,
-0.0554818176,
0.0121732512,
0.0097073326,
0.0003780042,
-0.0232937653,
-0.0125968894,
0.0157471187,
-0.004651641,
0.0266945343,
-0.0117327897,
-0.0362084582,
0.018220393,
-0.0019675421,
0.0251876693,
0.0121188676,
-0.0830116197,
0.0240124967,
0.0215399154,
0.0206631925,
-0.0324766673,
-0.0271059219,
-0.0267607849,
-0.0453360565,
-0.0440615825,
-0.0109312702,
0.0371890403,
0.0526022911,
-0.0238508377,
-0.031886287,
-0.0261174738,
0.047326155,
0.0289745666,
0.0514149889,
-0.0759878084,
0.0008852363,
0.0034080988,
0.0606151186,
0.0018429077,
-0.0272861272,
0.0151869142,
-0.0650042966,
0.0069894586,
-0.0165709481,
0.0194223486,
-0.0068999259,
-0.0989784151,
0.003707015,
0.0048793936,
-0.0144905336,
0.0413550436,
-0.0032354444,
-0.0118645411,
0.0189766493,
0.0387755521,
-0.0337953195,
-0.021909304,
-0.0165739246,
-0.0353274643,
0.0119761908,
0.0247518569,
0.0455395654,
0.0177595243,
-0.053017769,
0.0174996182,
0.0116311256,
-0.031425871,
0.0856208131,
-0.0456051752,
0.0394288786,
0.0179119837,
-0.0552474111,
-0.0136042712,
0.0348798297,
-0.0393671691,
0.0978938565,
-0.0658728257,
0.0608890727,
-0.0601296686,
-0.0813327283,
-0.0170427039,
0.0439705178,
0.0031637447,
0.0423404239,
-0.002466986,
-0.0296389703,
0.0092008328,
0.0024907531,
0.0443602987,
0.0397431552,
-0.0359958261,
-0.0252202842,
-0.0308553074,
-0.0716429725,
0.0103392713,
-0.015412448,
-0.0144127021,
0.0415122472,
0.0063223517,
-0.0290364791,
-0.0678124949,
-0.0244589094,
-0.0212260764,
-0.0013023783,
-0.0104561057,
-0.0376498029,
0.0252959505,
-0.0400722437,
-0.0021541486,
-0.0588803478,
0.0061662318,
-0.0167709421,
-0.0282692816,
-0.0146013312,
0.0067852219,
0.0239481721,
-0.0163339339,
-0.082952857,
0.0064116693,
0.065770857,
-0.027184505,
-0.0723083168,
0.0082780132,
-0.0641467348,
-0.0253315195,
0.0453130007,
-0.0754822642,
-0.0026500123,
-0.0770218968,
0.0213805344,
-0.0402316377,
-0.0249221902,
0.0730176792,
0.0508201905,
0.0219353531,
0.0513338596,
-0.0183203109,
-0.0120989187,
0.0307788998,
-0.0933384895,
-0.062592797,
-0.0059145852,
0.0262903236,
0.008144822,
-0.0344810076,
0.015369134,
-0.0013992401,
0.0106036672,
0.0281033181,
-0.0359581485,
0.0084107928,
-0.0666597784,
-0.0173671599,
0.0163380429,
0.016008744,
-0.0060071503,
0.0343491919,
0.0324457847,
0.0279020332,
-0.0540292449,
-0.0318249874,
0.0297164526,
-0.0177766848,
-0.0509540774,
0.0148378629,
-0.0991697088,
-0.0218217671,
0.0344235078,
-0.0119691379,
-0.0003571232,
-0.0092845578,
-0.0108374814,
-0.0002227577,
-0.0406255163,
-0.0296019576,
-0.0092362026,
0.0680218786,
-0.0129809827,
-0.0238394942,
0.0387865566,
0.0126581984,
0.0091688987,
0.0293747783,
0.0053586457,
0.0197924022,
-0.0704554915,
-0.0810033828,
-0.0263971705,
-0.0212021787,
0.0491997451,
0.0580718368,
-0.0423072018,
-0.0274695698,
-0.0020670795,
0.0011395852,
0.0445798188,
-0.0307170097,
-0.0244042762,
-0.0181741193,
0.0631201714,
0.0578623153,
0.03911075,
-0.0222034063,
-0.0454390571,
-0.0024211488,
-0.0647237524,
0.0083491821,
0.0470695086,
-6.187245372e-33,
-0.0311259776,
0.0160871428,
0.0068856524,
0.0034519455,
0.0137816472,
-0.0174401645,
0.0084918132,
-0.0277091209,
-0.0225160662,
-0.0322297141,
-0.0333325565,
0.03620141,
0.0124180801,
-0.0136097297,
0.0005154082,
-0.0201501139,
0.037729755,
-0.0110001452,
-0.0015606034,
0.0357132033,
0.0946432874,
0.0507025868,
-0.0060942164,
-0.0481338277,
0.0049508391,
-0.0249450058,
-0.021721188,
0.0002485387,
0.0238436405,
0.0712974668,
0.0146967005,
0.0489113368,
0.0234945044,
0.0104308184,
0.0114054102,
-0.0464549512,
-0.0836879835,
-0.0094727604,
-0.0146990092,
0.0272902381,
0.027274292,
-0.0059177997,
0.0323221907,
-0.0146425134,
-0.0098693846,
-0.0012893551,
0.0252902694,
-0.0284815859,
-0.0808387771,
-0.0490205623,
0.0392379835,
0.0283640288,
0.0237680953,
0.0400517099,
0.0470169671,
0.0482044071,
0.0155476499,
0.0370894857,
-0.0154407322,
0.0289969482,
-0.0276291482,
0.0367671698,
-0.0249167103,
0.0245949719,
0.0290844198,
0.0283973161,
0.0519882366,
0.0328756981,
0.0251201391,
0.042649284,
0.0024242369,
0.0265703425,
-0.000259346,
0.0230997391,
0.0092894798,
-0.0129309697,
-0.0435430482,
0.058990065,
-0.0232887473,
0.0084371828,
-0.0046256832,
0.0687415525,
-0.0864801258,
-0.0514311902,
-0.0150559079,
0.0216589104,
-0.0523693748,
-0.0100003537,
0.0225589555,
0.0346471518,
0.0060123759,
0.0203233007,
-0.0003629602,
0.0067687551,
-0.0569940507,
0.0695154443,
-0.0136495912,
-0.0199354235,
-0.0048745773,
0.0218339469,
0.0037235587,
-0.0169863533,
0.0331912413,
-0.0493272133,
-0.0265318044,
0.0059215664,
0.0649100989,
-0.0066606677,
-0.035894122,
-0.0025179337,
0.026852401,
-0.0398744494,
-0.0606366098,
-0.0564204939,
0.0316583142,
0.0505047441,
0.0356536321,
0.0703871697,
0.0516815521,
0.0267423559,
-0.0280219503,
-0.0740800276,
0.0040964331,
-0.002134186,
0.0299602486,
0.0290838592,
-0.0213897824,
-0.0481701493,
0.0557656102,
-0.0382485129,
-0.006352508,
0.0505117662,
2.837e-7,
0.0270979293,
0.0274599139,
0.0197383873,
0.0460522212,
-0.0034480528,
0.0141702322,
-0.0085785342,
0.0178833939,
0.0356067009,
-0.0289799236,
0.0725882798,
0.0297337845,
0.0209071748,
0.010320114,
-0.0336839668,
-0.0174554233,
-0.0077823182,
-0.0584022701,
-0.0570697673,
0.0136400023,
0.0441332906,
0.0377452597,
-0.0051977471,
0.0189834554,
-0.0105873151,
-0.0420128368,
0.0350221619,
-0.0208405945,
-0.0166902877,
0.0053689159,
0.0340318941,
0.0432381555,
-0.0047957911,
0.0070007769,
-0.0035770219,
0.0362188332,
0.0348012261,
0.0129531017,
-0.0362209938,
0.022264475,
-0.016371673,
-0.0587190799,
0.0283249468,
-0.0088877231,
0.0933519974,
0.0362883098,
0.0139966859,
0.0624530017,
-0.0444256626,
0.0207243171,
0.0074892319,
-0.0116952565,
-0.0760028511,
-0.0108425468,
0.0149479415,
0.027998209,
0.0104363374,
-0.0403476544,
0.0205754004,
0.0329205319,
-0.0183200072,
0.0077663288,
-0.0516350791,
0.0695503131,
-0.0424540937,
0.0171126388,
-0.0317491293,
2.672775459e-34,
0.0388331637,
0.0498667061,
-0.0017684905,
-0.0220093317,
0.0385573469,
-0.0279818624,
-0.0188732762,
-0.0074711712,
0.0253381524,
-0.0776673853,
-0.0271167029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16008v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16008v2 | Found in the Middle: Calibrating Positional Attention Bias Improves Long Context Utilization | 2024-06-23T04:35:42 | 2024-07-03T17:40:00 | Cheng-Yu Hsieh, Yung-Sung Chuang, Chun-Liang Li, Zifeng Wang, Long T. Le, Abhishek Kumar, James Glass, Alexander Ratner, Chen-Yu Lee, Ranjay Krishna, Tomas Pfister | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs), even when specifically trained to process long
input contexts, struggle to capture relevant information located in the middle
of their input. This phenomenon has been known as the lost-in-the-middle
problem. In this work, we make three contributions. First, we set out to
understand the factors that cause this phenomenon. In doing so, we establish a
connection between lost-in-the-middle to LLMs' intrinsic attention bias: LLMs
exhibit a U-shaped attention bias where the tokens at the beginning and at the
end of its input receive higher attention, regardless of their relevance.
Second, we mitigate this positional bias through a calibration mechanism,
found-in-the-middle, that allows the model to attend to contexts faithfully
according to their relevance, even though when they are in the middle. Third,
we show found-in-the-middle not only achieves better performance in locating
relevant information within a long context, but also eventually leads to
improved retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) performance across various tasks,
outperforming existing methods by up to 15 percentage points. These findings
open up future directions in understanding LLM attention bias and its potential
consequences. | [
0.0307868775,
0.028696157,
-0.0105434721,
0.0266689155,
0.0039457679,
-0.008967544,
-0.0261099394,
-0.0322065651,
-0.0483225323,
-0.0383433588,
-0.0402070098,
-0.0589579344,
0.0142767867,
0.0057251491,
0.0483533144,
-0.0409901366,
0.0551406033,
-0.009982286,
0.0322952755,
0.0302039161,
-0.0032257522,
0.0051235184,
0.0187131502,
0.055085253,
-0.0336554945,
-0.002943885,
0.0117274867,
0.039139878,
0.0052308068,
-0.0233277977,
0.0180444233,
0.0157795418,
-0.0096503384,
0.0498478487,
0.0000020276,
-0.0391103849,
-0.0080478452,
-0.0270252582,
-0.0264749136,
0.0366727971,
0.0435657166,
0.0279146377,
-0.0065782419,
0.0392766558,
-0.0176832024,
0.0413589589,
0.0228345562,
0.0271009374,
0.0009563593,
0.0496630147,
0.0123806736,
0.0166417342,
-0.0048051071,
-0.0690833703,
0.0536774769,
-0.0441676043,
-0.0015952401,
-0.0253579859,
-0.0055513107,
0.0216873251,
-0.0299515892,
0.0412259772,
0.0371034667,
0.015045343,
0.0184218716,
0.0700639486,
-0.0476377904,
0.0093138153,
-0.0156210409,
0.0576593243,
-0.0399340428,
-0.0291367248,
-0.008845577,
-0.0111040669,
0.032718543,
-0.071101822,
-0.0701098964,
0.0626064464,
0.001552406,
0.0127935158,
0.0247043762,
0.0052097808,
0.0351514518,
0.013231229,
-0.0677716881,
0.0486877821,
0.0183055531,
-0.0242000651,
-0.0489038788,
0.0133082317,
-0.0287960153,
-0.0325765572,
0.0109425504,
0.0381736979,
-0.0259812083,
0.0302781146,
-0.0500507988,
-0.0148076527,
0.03465271,
-0.0205745716,
0.0094030425,
0.0439178199,
-0.065148063,
0.0196915101,
-0.0346485265,
0.0190611724,
-0.0348612554,
0.0120517807,
-0.0425208285,
0.0085905418,
0.0407257304,
-0.0173937213,
-0.020364102,
-0.0029064673,
-0.063485153,
-0.0402620696,
-0.0311916415,
0.0474688224,
-0.0072682174,
-0.0458738841,
-0.0077011515,
0.0497763269,
-0.0267989133,
0.0107085677,
0.0231632628,
0.0501390956,
-0.0450680591,
0.0302612092,
0.0428695939,
-0.0501230694,
-0.04268099,
0.0493902415,
0.0158349182,
-0.0536030345,
0.0078417659,
0.0369133539,
-0.0209649038,
-0.0451528877,
-0.04282967,
-0.0362318344,
-0.0662135258,
-0.0564242788,
-0.0011623086,
-0.0350277238,
0.0188264437,
0.0256204717,
-0.0172431432,
-0.0262817722,
0.02837524,
0.0424100719,
-0.0383464433,
0.0278675593,
0.0486410707,
0.0088732997,
0.0288390853,
0.0057099606,
0.0342454799,
0.0378718078,
0.0526042692,
0.0345724374,
0.0061202571,
0.0244047903,
-0.0316405818,
0.0195198674,
0.0550672077,
-0.0021288036,
-0.0073067485,
0.0005671037,
-0.0125106471,
0.0529293045,
0.1030475572,
0.0550662801,
-0.0390054733,
-0.0054916781,
0.0454772972,
0.0325471945,
0.023443887,
0.0012602698,
0.0407318212,
0.004868485,
-0.0668669418,
0.0119225755,
-0.0769348741,
0.0588606857,
-0.0226119105,
0.0383833721,
0.0834860951,
0.0233837832,
-0.007264582,
-0.0369356461,
-0.0043365201,
0.0097683193,
-0.0118972575,
0.0188348722,
0.0178197529,
0.0159623083,
-0.0538227744,
0.0914687812,
0.0008144573,
-0.0521685854,
0.0350270495,
-0.0247868579,
0.0117382482,
0.0426752307,
0.0473089553,
-0.0135494573,
-0.029154567,
0.007886121,
0.0271412618,
0.0278340317,
0.0171971899,
0.0290294103,
0.0061092563,
-0.0375015102,
-0.027890902,
-0.0498095043,
0.0220656656,
0.0232873354,
0.0264711659,
0.020866638,
0.0545516573,
-0.049309954,
0.0077920598,
0.0350208692,
-0.0314732194,
-0.0433349945,
-0.0175253525,
0.0168219227,
0.0032941783,
0.0085300636,
-0.0125366785,
0.0645670965,
0.0338573307,
-0.0357928611,
0.0242286492,
0.0015998897,
-0.0933895707,
-0.0008108218,
0.0343623385,
-0.0028592797,
-0.0104144365,
-0.0078305202,
0.0025196867,
-0.0401764289,
0.0359213091,
-0.0261747576,
0.0623818934,
-0.0233163182,
0.0376718715,
0.033472497,
0.0397869088,
-0.0510194413,
0.0598194338,
-0.022697445,
0.0113958837,
0.0409150124,
0.0317285992,
0.0092408825,
-0.0414692797,
0.0226189904,
-0.0338806584,
-0.0252413601,
0.0080752587,
0.0250309482,
-0.0037025516,
-0.0434195623,
-0.0478171594,
-0.0801719576,
0.0249743573,
-0.0292965211,
0.0111565571,
0.0312267151,
0.022994522,
-0.0230987929,
-0.0229142681,
-0.0250721965,
-0.0325108021,
0.0081075039,
0.023945054,
0.0138989873,
0.028892545,
-0.0018573229,
-0.0724901557,
0.0014320562,
-0.0067888736,
0.0365967751,
-0.0103559401,
0.0006415837,
-0.0604895875,
0.036554262,
0.0035153294,
-0.010089023,
-0.0205763262,
-0.0205608718,
0.0029906821,
-0.0022000405,
0.0643922761,
0.0914973393,
0.0288904943,
0.0230047107,
0.044074107,
-0.0166087411,
-0.0629504099,
0.0131902341,
-0.0054363483,
-0.0216165222,
-0.0063465042,
-0.0142062474,
-0.0025831598,
0.0649255663,
0.0052093533,
0.0086173015,
-0.0163404476,
0.0013448326,
0.0113125918,
-0.0260570031,
-0.0283736698,
-0.0006006768,
-0.0567617267,
0.0455813818,
-0.0593084842,
-0.0481834672,
0.0241641998,
-0.0510200001,
-0.0035947382,
-0.0309291948,
0.0342198946,
-0.0584538467,
0.037812952,
-0.0066687153,
0.0146214031,
-0.0380869508,
-0.0550286807,
-0.0611407161,
0.0159219224,
-0.0137277171,
-0.0254270043,
0.059211161,
0.0001028541,
-0.0067181014,
-0.0153755834,
-0.0301452149,
-0.070052132,
-0.0191765167,
-0.0178301446,
0.0086700413,
0.0111897197,
-0.0140185766,
-0.0447899885,
-0.0150496271,
0.0413725972,
0.0629900247,
-0.0194746684,
0.0090171844,
-0.0222574193,
0.0378162712,
0.0653214976,
0.0114113847,
0.0626408383,
-0.0491474941,
-0.0302313492,
0.0687525868,
0.0479917862,
0.0177324992,
0.0063984543,
-0.0226962697,
0.0260882135,
-0.0066260123,
0.001864047,
0.0360375866,
0.0563678294,
-0.0799590871,
-0.0428916477,
0.0888270736,
0.0185077526,
-0.0614894927,
0.014925411,
-0.0165339243,
0.0624363981,
0.0434212349,
0.0173905343,
-0.0642070174,
-0.0301619992,
0.0225995723,
0.0262618531,
-0.0006513701,
0.0121301319,
-0.0064583025,
-0.1317637563,
0.0207713321,
0.0289642997,
-0.0482556485,
-0.036564406,
0.0060210577,
0.0173137784,
0.0411416553,
0.058765579,
0.0609585717,
-0.0158216059,
-0.0074829268,
0.0115719205,
0.0216974281,
-0.0363057442,
0.0030787787,
-0.0489632972,
0.0376228392,
0.0524215847,
0.0058060433,
0.0241486616,
-0.0057981377,
0.0810898766,
-0.0232882407,
0.0114462245,
0.0107161105,
0.0214798935,
-0.0361409672,
0.0059122555,
-0.0069314279,
0.0283133723,
-0.0439524539,
-0.0093058618,
0.002252185,
0.0652136877,
-0.0115476884,
0.0175177809,
-0.0449753329,
0.0047018505,
0.0083189765,
0.069391109,
0.0687520355,
-0.0359354988,
-0.0494681969,
-0.017940294,
0.0181597229,
-0.0623488128,
-0.005696319,
0.0121322712,
0.0163205434,
-0.0064803879,
-0.0584002733,
-0.0597489625,
0.0079453578,
0.0251945406,
-0.0121439751,
-0.0009938026,
-0.0456297323,
-0.0390077904,
-0.0606575981,
0.0455675088,
-0.0537894778,
0.0227345936,
-0.0696641877,
0.0099786464,
-0.0165867936,
-0.0828113779,
-0.009160419,
0.0371075943,
-0.0959925801,
-0.0452295952,
0.0020635705,
0.0320653394,
0.0176198632,
0.065586932,
0.0057802396,
-0.027835764,
0.0256257597,
-0.0013408692,
-0.0402273722,
0.0471435525,
-0.009998275,
0.0099445153,
0.003325593,
0.0273444224,
-0.0695137009,
-0.0173855051,
0.0257888231,
0.068508029,
0.0194312315,
-0.0357149579,
0.0160157848,
-0.0417394266,
0.052687943,
-0.0169564411,
0.021262994,
-0.0230312813,
0.0193382129,
0.0075873551,
-0.0090388097,
-0.0129343094,
-0.0084631955,
0.0213916134,
0.0038302937,
0.0050325189,
-0.0064801443,
0.0199674666,
0.0503198989,
-0.0301927682,
-0.0039986023,
-0.0248446018,
-0.0104944743,
0.0158355832,
0.0010352462,
-0.0154152578,
0.0340445042,
-0.0348029062,
0.0623203851,
-0.0210678317,
0.0407210216,
0.0143992575,
-0.029920144,
-0.0436160043,
0.0198813099,
-0.0820374787,
-0.0060118521,
-0.0115595758,
-0.0008289978,
0.068927519,
-0.0445549078,
0.0686289147,
0.0038987175,
-0.0106246518,
-0.0258686524,
0.003009147,
-0.0350707732,
-0.0499266423,
-0.0166847575,
0.0177750308,
-0.0044147423,
0.0017952363,
0.0540105477,
-0.0005322557,
0.0421567336,
-0.0405323245,
-0.0094722677,
-0.0112195658,
-0.0313033462,
-0.011581202,
0.0267528538,
-0.0281333197,
0.009811271,
-0.0527681559,
-0.0576065071,
0.0078332853,
-0.0043627424,
-0.0323863029,
-0.0398725756,
0.0209441222,
0.0654780641,
-0.0266755447,
-0.039882306,
-0.0136207286,
0.0033505869,
-0.0111936433,
-0.0188288279,
-0.0353814587,
-6.785992971e-33,
-0.0159128327,
-0.0357121639,
0.0357472785,
-0.0431574918,
-0.0645093247,
-0.0014918013,
-0.0550592504,
0.0174639728,
-0.018856341,
-0.0188864451,
-0.0158670768,
0.0145976488,
0.0173972193,
0.0184180997,
0.0117400102,
0.0036001864,
0.0419151522,
0.0150461812,
-0.0328061543,
0.041104041,
0.0525691845,
0.05466168,
0.031465739,
-0.0244709179,
-0.0100881029,
0.0089049209,
0.0235996339,
0.0127067827,
-0.0111530013,
0.0777550712,
0.0052575339,
0.041044306,
0.0287672449,
-0.0005887958,
-0.0420685969,
0.0337870643,
-0.0705976039,
-0.0040102969,
0.0048750164,
0.0049397941,
-0.0171573441,
-0.0648414269,
0.0846987814,
-0.0265239943,
-0.0044934051,
-0.0347328372,
0.0202639103,
-0.0251997281,
-0.0646805093,
0.0044534393,
-0.0766422972,
-0.0005541966,
0.0061792051,
-0.0338992476,
-0.0389172398,
0.0121119665,
0.018959552,
0.0429183058,
-0.0517919809,
0.0090009058,
-0.0228203256,
0.0663975701,
0.0480509587,
0.038949389,
-0.0091781132,
0.0433476306,
0.0439035632,
0.0198361408,
-0.0331391692,
-0.0690565035,
0.0383906588,
-0.0088636773,
0.0007427306,
0.0191207714,
0.0385125354,
-0.0205271672,
-0.0339522585,
-0.015207151,
-0.0109606851,
0.0476969779,
0.0562277101,
0.0129059218,
-0.0271157846,
-0.0189380161,
-0.0370455012,
-0.0148769375,
-0.0511978008,
-0.0028275673,
0.0666360855,
0.060240943,
0.0050678528,
-0.0376010239,
0.0620812662,
-0.0103980051,
0.013507355,
0.0464804806,
-0.0053519793,
-0.0042231595,
-0.0163344294,
0.033136107,
-0.0470865183,
-0.0057510016,
0.0296010971,
-0.0060403114,
-0.024746025,
0.0083016083,
0.0261400305,
-0.004559807,
-0.0560628884,
-0.000145022,
-0.0647020563,
0.0336561874,
-0.0155122159,
-0.0001856717,
0.0629761592,
0.0119679999,
0.0040212641,
0.0655171797,
0.0168238636,
0.0190040693,
-0.0269905012,
-0.0316182934,
-0.0234761015,
0.0321755707,
-0.0497913435,
0.02222104,
-0.0353242606,
0.0513972566,
0.0104416534,
-0.0683506951,
-0.0244189985,
0.0056689191,
2.807e-7,
0.05633213,
0.0107672075,
0.0486395024,
0.0031355375,
0.0097316913,
-0.0127180032,
0.0088465801,
0.0257279687,
0.0177998766,
-0.0066854805,
-0.0136626707,
0.0092501063,
0.0365846865,
-0.0280625187,
-0.0715696067,
0.0216473062,
-0.0703894198,
0.0272222254,
-0.0159422997,
-0.0351446308,
0.0077422275,
0.0834083781,
-0.027444208,
-0.0100831604,
0.0264007133,
-0.0529211573,
0.0573644042,
-0.0161728691,
0.0096261743,
0.0003260554,
0.0045517711,
0.0204774998,
0.0078453282,
-0.0466334783,
0.0039102212,
0.0488014705,
-0.0171165429,
0.0458505116,
0.0105195455,
-0.0850502849,
0.0104775457,
0.0141465422,
-0.0141620841,
-0.0773288682,
0.0375845321,
-0.0527586788,
0.0137471268,
-0.0527950861,
-0.0059685237,
0.0060838903,
0.008684597,
-0.0166960042,
-0.0082371188,
-0.0180926695,
0.0265843682,
0.0063915662,
-0.0006728357,
-0.1277558059,
-0.0615885705,
0.0309258401,
-0.0680967271,
-0.0096856998,
-0.0592696927,
-0.0112613067,
0.0515013188,
-0.038334135,
-0.0330171585,
2.665552827e-34,
0.0291318968,
-0.0422924273,
0.0328402966,
0.0264443792,
0.0236834269,
-0.0034106195,
-0.0079126423,
-0.0038020157,
0.0242774114,
-0.0492249429,
-0.0440652184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16007v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16007v1 | Distributed Rule Vectors is A Key Mechanism in Large Language Models' In-Context Learning | 2024-06-23T04:29:13 | 2024-06-23T04:29:13 | Bowen Zheng, Ming Ma, Zhongqiao Lin, Tianming Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable abilities, one of
the most important being In-Context Learning (ICL). With ICL, LLMs can derive
the underlying rule from a few demonstrations and provide answers that comply
with the rule. Previous work hypothesized that the network creates a "task
vector" in specific positions during ICL. Patching the "task vector" allows
LLMs to achieve zero-shot performance similar to few-shot learning. However, we
discover that such "task vectors" do not exist in tasks where the rule has to
be defined through multiple demonstrations. Instead, the rule information
provided by each demonstration is first transmitted to its answer position and
forms its own rule vector. Importantly, all the rule vectors contribute to the
output in a distributed manner. We further show that the rule vectors encode a
high-level abstraction of rules extracted from the demonstrations. These
results are further validated in a series of tasks that rely on rules dependent
on multiple demonstrations. Our study provides novel insights into the
mechanism underlying ICL in LLMs, demonstrating how ICL may be achieved through
an information aggregation mechanism. | [
0.0023283362,
0.0180897843,
-0.0062931818,
0.0576449968,
-0.0339433029,
0.0251107179,
0.0505465753,
0.0041714995,
-0.0369497947,
-0.0229176767,
-0.034180481,
-0.0308237225,
0.0020754891,
-0.0154033415,
0.0381070785,
-0.0077142385,
0.0117778825,
-0.0379186384,
-0.0162143596,
-0.0122884503,
-0.0115828151,
-0.0027308573,
-0.0102368118,
0.0334117301,
0.0097304983,
-0.0357071683,
-0.020557072,
-0.0173828006,
-0.0156477373,
-0.0108538531,
0.001074677,
0.0205697641,
0.0598767474,
0.0452990755,
0.0000019204,
-0.0356600806,
0.0219244938,
-0.0144068804,
-0.0344570652,
0.0386116467,
0.0003423007,
-0.0092793005,
-0.0356569141,
0.0144277764,
-0.0351602174,
-0.050871633,
0.054912243,
0.0190365259,
0.0545809492,
0.0884525627,
0.0207165796,
-0.0351665653,
0.0075484007,
-0.0480875485,
0.0140674748,
-0.0582615733,
0.0451361686,
0.0131598841,
0.0062849266,
-0.0250062719,
-0.0354845077,
0.0345522724,
0.0684068203,
-0.0107356487,
-0.0302529912,
0.059632685,
-0.0221848693,
0.0041787722,
-0.0078655612,
0.040074449,
-0.0599562302,
-0.0313108936,
-0.0084439395,
-0.0142986374,
0.0151258633,
0.0095318686,
-0.0736536607,
0.02903907,
0.0135454647,
0.0340522639,
0.0166171324,
0.0029002535,
0.0504199304,
-0.009344467,
-0.0310321283,
0.0447054841,
-0.0114621231,
-0.0167279541,
-0.0469985716,
0.0094861863,
-0.0330676809,
-0.0719618574,
-0.0132756904,
0.0524280071,
-0.0515703186,
0.0223674625,
-0.014056311,
-0.0103791365,
0.0081523927,
-0.0408452861,
0.097387284,
0.0273210984,
0.0291975904,
0.0568463989,
-0.0378617346,
0.0468314625,
-0.0493459515,
0.0455835871,
-0.0510815121,
-0.003849043,
-0.0579037778,
-0.0065960796,
0.0016028672,
0.0536917709,
-0.0444228165,
-0.0242134724,
-0.0061624888,
0.0680496469,
-0.0355517082,
0.0174482614,
-0.0203834325,
-0.0173736904,
-0.0169777554,
-0.0226449743,
0.0020745711,
0.040430598,
-0.0117868287,
0.027265152,
0.0095501198,
-0.0229218714,
-0.0314782783,
-0.0158092827,
0.0044274684,
0.009644419,
0.0067286687,
0.0742913485,
-0.0242150016,
-0.0260554682,
-0.0117885005,
-0.0301685836,
0.0189287905,
-0.0587539859,
0.0082647866,
-0.0877842158,
0.0407205783,
0.0109682269,
-0.0039904434,
-0.0277001038,
0.0008609524,
0.0290870536,
-0.0154964654,
0.0414706767,
0.0342709757,
0.0161140393,
0.0127501013,
0.0110050868,
-0.0085001299,
0.0611859672,
0.008354147,
-0.001070794,
0.0056696353,
0.0155840293,
0.0335979313,
0.0448502451,
0.0742597431,
0.0455675535,
-0.0121370386,
-0.0091354735,
0.0541441999,
0.0410684943,
0.0129812947,
0.0380448028,
-0.0705077574,
-0.0008587136,
0.0649281517,
0.0439838767,
0.040273767,
-0.0254604165,
0.0449701734,
-0.0165382754,
0.0223578345,
0.0203497335,
-0.08079952,
0.0080091236,
0.0103412513,
0.0081754178,
-0.0080816653,
0.0291228592,
-0.0540582463,
-0.0355720893,
-0.0034126122,
0.0084435465,
-0.032952141,
0.0163516812,
0.0505167581,
0.0309308879,
-0.015861446,
0.0061379569,
0.0330835097,
0.01300319,
0.0134351831,
-0.0464457385,
0.0349459127,
0.0408911966,
0.057259392,
-0.0194723047,
-0.0325887091,
-0.0187308695,
0.0775942132,
0.0246441904,
-0.0084329601,
-0.0481869429,
0.0040813405,
-0.0289104022,
-0.0223081503,
-0.0222997777,
0.0210231896,
0.0046731508,
0.012311562,
-0.0439329557,
-0.0232185163,
0.0041054548,
-0.0126304924,
0.0342182815,
-0.0367072895,
-0.0393727049,
-0.0024918243,
-0.0248365197,
0.0444940217,
-0.007105547,
-0.0356197506,
0.010891146,
0.0480867624,
-0.0459645428,
0.0011854082,
0.0048713749,
-0.0704584047,
-0.0716512278,
0.0451126657,
-0.0054973094,
-0.0151866563,
-0.0192337949,
-0.0410907231,
-0.0118705817,
-0.0213773306,
-0.0222648066,
0.0574214682,
-0.0225439258,
0.0015574433,
0.0168147702,
-0.019465236,
-0.0276703816,
0.0565554574,
-0.0066368403,
-0.0211084615,
0.0581569411,
0.0362497121,
-0.0224571619,
-0.0136983795,
0.0372891054,
0.0263482798,
-0.0029220823,
0.0319505669,
-0.0178607311,
0.0197021104,
-0.0118044326,
-0.0154697821,
-0.0618621781,
0.0224659294,
-0.0255899988,
0.0118736485,
0.0251772273,
-0.0097310189,
0.0051561841,
-0.0356170498,
-0.0321988501,
-0.0059101377,
0.0196780134,
0.021432342,
0.0146600399,
0.0377492532,
-0.0495151877,
-0.0032983697,
-0.0374042466,
-0.0084879445,
0.0702390149,
-0.0173237249,
0.0191538259,
-0.088117525,
0.0189795941,
-0.0054897843,
0.0396764763,
-0.0185155291,
0.0211017821,
0.0313162357,
-0.0262231529,
0.0096092755,
0.07769797,
-0.0170440134,
0.0404528864,
0.055061996,
-0.0204911251,
-0.074186109,
0.0017820853,
-0.0347961821,
-0.019697953,
-0.0729918107,
0.056540437,
0.000955056,
0.0524598509,
0.0005445428,
-0.0188165177,
-0.0475882888,
0.0397779197,
-0.004434966,
-0.0477088653,
-0.0859761164,
-0.0345019586,
-0.0295921229,
0.0029867005,
-0.0266896747,
-0.0683591515,
0.0678957775,
0.0130359428,
-0.0119098779,
-0.0422780104,
-0.0185143575,
-0.0205451306,
0.0572698489,
0.0156035656,
0.0239890963,
-0.0442141853,
-0.0388706438,
-0.043087054,
0.00118035,
0.0024867249,
-0.027441198,
0.0439516865,
-0.0733127892,
0.0024230268,
-0.0258829258,
-0.0669715181,
-0.0407849215,
-0.0307548046,
0.0020733809,
0.0438447818,
-0.0353931785,
-0.0082725836,
-0.0121901426,
-0.0279420037,
0.046236068,
0.0489548296,
-0.0144426338,
-0.0113762403,
-0.0558880046,
-0.0008413043,
0.0162736606,
-0.0010273653,
-0.0243656132,
-0.0432346463,
0.0077987127,
0.0655819327,
0.0911159217,
-0.0150363846,
-0.0060326508,
-0.0001269585,
0.0259813201,
-0.0169294495,
-0.0125178574,
0.0367457904,
0.0545987785,
-0.0756591037,
0.0015247521,
0.0798309445,
0.0215928052,
-0.06016469,
-0.0074658636,
0.0108483043,
-0.0137551185,
0.015929589,
0.0358392745,
-0.0943714231,
-0.0045426846,
0.0205157977,
-0.0243347343,
0.0307974685,
-0.0058722789,
-0.0259189364,
-0.1200752631,
0.0236647576,
0.0435925871,
-0.081545122,
-0.0461388603,
-0.0205718055,
-0.0005626372,
0.0102531584,
0.0534479618,
0.0402226187,
0.0018160912,
-0.0093783718,
0.0263799746,
0.0652315244,
-0.0616796874,
0.02640347,
-0.057233721,
0.0845918506,
0.055389028,
-0.0009042738,
0.0126460353,
-0.0551008247,
0.0359715261,
-0.0336212032,
0.0077360715,
-0.0352226943,
0.0162674915,
0.0016203703,
-0.012821544,
0.0082034497,
0.0438938364,
-0.0318690315,
-0.038817782,
-0.004406272,
0.0878372714,
-0.0157787837,
-0.0069290888,
-0.0054831645,
-0.0457700491,
0.0169522297,
0.049511198,
0.0098328134,
-0.0542490408,
-0.0183741059,
-0.0314289592,
-0.0469875112,
-0.0074350261,
-0.024140764,
-0.0041747997,
-0.0071793837,
-0.0094381897,
-0.0508576594,
0.0012488693,
0.0474657156,
0.068273522,
0.0043731174,
0.011054676,
0.0216557011,
-0.0087403692,
-0.0306736752,
-0.0018791569,
-0.0505534708,
0.0290294066,
-0.0324971452,
0.0044009653,
0.0304141827,
-0.0306212585,
-0.0190245416,
0.025509838,
-0.0477168262,
-0.0721965432,
0.0122738946,
0.0248789806,
0.0188279934,
0.0641082972,
-0.0043643131,
-0.0434857793,
0.1120960489,
0.0248289127,
-0.0108793378,
0.0490409359,
0.0268082153,
-0.0227902383,
0.0066721556,
0.0421704724,
-0.0309216473,
-0.0023542969,
0.0438603684,
0.0101291956,
-0.052126009,
0.0234103985,
0.0334966779,
-0.041352272,
0.0207717381,
0.0151974652,
-0.0312919617,
-0.0310062468,
0.0290700346,
0.001474557,
-0.0074518798,
-0.0462966971,
-0.008019845,
0.0077981567,
-0.0002536791,
0.0210242625,
0.0171367936,
0.0813108161,
0.0169736575,
-0.0050724363,
-0.0370671004,
0.0171855502,
-0.0300202705,
0.0454466343,
0.0377528295,
0.0061146365,
0.0062073995,
-0.0120377438,
0.0304718148,
-0.0335924402,
0.0480084345,
0.0527430736,
-0.0199979618,
-0.0460801423,
0.0243685637,
-0.0859254599,
-0.0182549506,
-0.0125281494,
0.0496163964,
0.0914530009,
0.0063700797,
0.0284163766,
-0.0231412463,
-0.0130221406,
-0.0218089074,
-0.0007866435,
-0.0296232291,
-0.0049460721,
0.0399472453,
0.0466029532,
0.0163837913,
0.0033563774,
0.066384919,
-0.005706158,
0.0579936914,
-0.0152073558,
0.0379120111,
-0.030018378,
-0.0035166324,
0.0414576381,
0.052128084,
-0.0243904088,
-0.010196832,
-0.0130920596,
-0.0431606956,
-0.0157649312,
0.0528004877,
-0.0353827737,
-0.0454235561,
0.0173223745,
0.0524878278,
0.0099801179,
-0.0544165224,
-0.0175822042,
-0.0147119826,
0.0183965806,
-0.0241705887,
0.0073068496,
-6.213149594e-33,
-0.0256168842,
-0.0308004189,
0.0566889308,
0.0345858447,
-0.0112049989,
0.0052498323,
-0.0171970651,
-0.0175274685,
-0.0046457364,
0.0192587841,
-0.0124633145,
0.0128351105,
0.0078048967,
0.0128059927,
0.0308389738,
-0.0367290229,
0.0360120535,
-0.024065556,
0.0003517381,
0.0540129021,
0.0192483775,
0.0072734104,
0.0349192023,
-0.0533639453,
0.0190117061,
-0.0021590788,
0.0028399169,
0.0639682412,
-0.0752438158,
0.0591693074,
-0.0150039792,
0.0228973534,
0.0222722869,
-0.0655466095,
-0.0485659242,
0.0208399296,
-0.061167378,
-0.0154884439,
0.0202591363,
0.0101372991,
-0.0392041579,
-0.0230511501,
0.066528067,
0.0018336306,
-0.018711891,
-0.020084152,
-0.0046181707,
-0.0102186492,
-0.0261507127,
-0.0205886494,
-0.0465579145,
0.005224816,
0.023588866,
-0.0476766117,
0.0179485269,
-0.0427646413,
0.0151995365,
-0.0207958072,
-0.0809245855,
0.0127267484,
-0.0266401023,
0.0385777317,
0.0473756753,
0.0278637372,
0.0177501906,
0.0531852357,
0.0358365402,
-0.0003855353,
-0.0169651806,
-0.0253582224,
0.0187388659,
0.0265160054,
0.0257082414,
0.0326082036,
0.0298508275,
0.0388022326,
-0.0541359708,
-0.0215432961,
0.0367587209,
0.0321938209,
0.0191541798,
0.0480800159,
-0.0184544809,
-0.025885256,
-0.0383448862,
0.0107442969,
-0.0169278961,
-0.0247972161,
0.0238041766,
0.0456786603,
0.0201505981,
0.0256813541,
0.0392526463,
-0.0634905323,
-0.0455284938,
0.0448338836,
0.0050290362,
0.0282537546,
-0.0020081229,
-0.0139882183,
-0.1045501307,
-0.0207380466,
-0.0179983787,
-0.0026975728,
-0.0170539953,
0.0063624708,
0.053711582,
0.0495366752,
-0.0610162206,
-0.0124418465,
-0.0339857414,
0.0054626786,
0.047558967,
-0.0108778877,
0.0552925356,
0.0075587896,
-0.0073112622,
0.0086124409,
0.0225376207,
-0.0684298277,
-0.0105019538,
0.0148289204,
-0.037067797,
0.0018642624,
-0.0200201161,
0.0065008993,
-0.0651471764,
0.0695473179,
0.0530159324,
-0.0290310513,
-0.0016467161,
0.0001261467,
2.65e-7,
0.0237330925,
0.0235882141,
0.0065595573,
0.0268183667,
0.0642210245,
0.0210187752,
-0.0539441258,
0.0184758119,
0.0627376586,
-0.016199369,
-0.0048534092,
0.0522989407,
0.0126755424,
0.0227183141,
-0.0904511213,
-0.0164806284,
-0.045450598,
0.0045607747,
-0.025688773,
-0.0046671899,
-0.0292367376,
0.0848521516,
0.0439945497,
-0.0159159657,
0.021476401,
-0.0485996194,
0.0610781983,
-0.0194906797,
-0.0063851853,
0.0034071365,
-0.0327724218,
-0.0035221959,
0.0085143233,
0.0373075157,
0.0175016001,
0.0519693308,
-0.0367171839,
0.0623661652,
0.0109226257,
0.0292680357,
-0.0249083433,
-0.0391524918,
-0.0074423277,
-0.0201239903,
0.0742762834,
-0.0985750109,
-0.0185161177,
-0.0388558283,
0.0587856062,
-0.0583324693,
0.0033566747,
0.0205526315,
0.0043237484,
-0.0075701112,
0.0061418074,
0.0013672601,
-0.0008544488,
-0.0677827746,
-0.0454623811,
0.0296298135,
-0.0481280088,
-0.0709172115,
-0.0188240446,
-0.0022368811,
0.0085789328,
-0.0564209931,
-0.0056950483,
2.348764216e-34,
0.0041151154,
-0.0198922921,
0.0271115638,
0.0646672621,
-0.008123368,
-0.0415065996,
-0.0385894068,
0.0136470823,
0.0336401984,
-0.0629038587,
-0.0202180929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15996v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15996v1 | Memorizing Documents with Guidance in Large Language Models | 2024-06-23T03:12:03 | 2024-06-23T03:12:03 | Bumjin Park, Jaesik Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Training data plays a pivotal role in AI models. Large language models (LLMs)
are trained with massive amounts of documents, and their parameters hold
document-related contents. Recently, several studies identified
content-specific locations in LLMs by examining the parameters. Instead of the
post hoc interpretation, we propose another approach. We propose document-wise
memory architecture to track document memories in training. The proposed
architecture maps document representations to memory entries, which softly mask
memories in the forward process of LLMs. Additionally, we propose document
guidance loss, which increases the likelihood of text with document memories
and reduces the likelihood of the text with the memories of other documents.
Experimental results on Wikitext-103-v1 with Pythia-1B show that the proposed
methods provide different memory entries for documents and high recall of
document-related content in generation with trained document-wise memories. | [
0.0313502438,
0.0356492959,
-0.0010728425,
0.0282553453,
-0.0252141524,
0.0064398549,
-0.0096153701,
0.0145386057,
0.013139355,
-0.0737330616,
-0.0437864885,
-0.0449861735,
0.0050103725,
-0.0233129561,
0.0024157383,
-0.0474472232,
0.0582418889,
-0.0379296206,
0.0003337794,
0.003330085,
0.0009648806,
-0.0094989948,
0.0150552224,
-0.0136262327,
-0.0344078392,
-0.0315486602,
-0.0417020544,
-0.0108100679,
-0.0275922082,
-0.0585088804,
0.017033156,
-0.0093624378,
0.0156518575,
0.0135742249,
0.0000022612,
-0.021572018,
-0.0259990711,
-0.0103363786,
-0.0221247356,
0.0352967046,
0.0409653224,
-0.0011173292,
-0.0079726819,
-0.0012897888,
-0.012312701,
-0.0295626651,
0.0243302323,
0.0838609189,
0.0445005707,
0.0938406065,
-0.0157088451,
-0.0133686615,
0.0594452731,
-0.0121257845,
0.0678417534,
-0.0389374383,
0.0149504552,
-0.0218693279,
-0.0153471408,
0.0041315937,
0.0082661919,
0.0258502327,
0.0090839369,
0.0227772295,
0.0310356654,
0.0602244772,
0.0064994371,
-0.0202671569,
-0.0076058423,
0.0088842064,
0.0136716124,
-0.0550486706,
0.025852751,
-0.007133767,
-0.003102947,
-0.0025214774,
-0.0659004524,
0.039293617,
-0.0272496846,
-0.0065381052,
0.069575727,
-0.0257298071,
0.0426402539,
0.0263986569,
-0.0282389838,
0.009366896,
0.0386812091,
-0.0342462473,
0.0037562058,
-0.0124425804,
0.026778115,
-0.0435157791,
0.0444546379,
0.0719804466,
0.0171419978,
0.0376929007,
-0.0550466217,
-0.0262298808,
0.0313280523,
-0.1055104136,
0.0533323884,
0.0190328415,
-0.0057527106,
0.0468756482,
-0.0710787922,
0.0503035858,
-0.0253826994,
-0.0027878769,
-0.0569344088,
0.0024054905,
-0.0335520469,
-0.0257017612,
-0.0449334942,
0.0456948243,
0.0294716191,
-0.045785483,
-0.0142221777,
0.03560853,
0.0144287525,
0.0166802369,
0.0017666235,
0.0255936496,
-0.025140658,
0.0003987369,
-0.0017764246,
0.003703862,
-0.0267802645,
-0.0006804071,
0.0108132707,
0.0093126986,
-0.0256963335,
0.0258148666,
0.0068676881,
-0.0216448456,
0.0185000002,
0.0658558756,
-0.0153645305,
-0.0398786552,
-0.0837544724,
-0.0519504473,
0.030097777,
-0.0716695189,
0.0370379649,
-0.0441628173,
0.009227409,
0.0307045914,
0.0056619886,
-0.0278610718,
0.0093589649,
0.0388674252,
-0.0270792693,
0.0284027588,
0.0429003946,
-0.0141098071,
0.0559062622,
0.0252527334,
-0.0081516132,
0.0362773649,
0.0337517895,
0.0452712886,
0.0217632074,
-0.0093437796,
0.0001492305,
-0.0069024521,
0.0378886312,
-0.0309445914,
-0.005903176,
-0.0035417494,
0.0560600422,
-0.0025496832,
0.0421732776,
0.034696158,
-0.0264751166,
-0.0122028068,
0.0395824052,
0.066535905,
0.0094868913,
0.0435715504,
0.0191766042,
-0.0271999389,
0.0491566956,
0.026749352,
-0.0242994465,
0.0153945191,
-0.0040987511,
0.0151241701,
-0.0041874633,
0.0118152089,
-0.0573387109,
0.0191774424,
-0.0303759724,
-0.0456703603,
0.0106449844,
-0.0393800065,
0.0277633872,
-0.0035225486,
-0.0541390553,
0.0785444677,
0.0166062582,
-0.06805446,
0.0092982827,
-0.0151593862,
0.0477391779,
0.0596096069,
0.0101205511,
-0.0427239537,
-0.0117764659,
0.0409060977,
-0.009020918,
-0.0043815891,
0.0491707139,
-0.0292302091,
0.0054091029,
-0.0726666078,
0.0197480526,
-0.0308177639,
0.0080380393,
0.0285972096,
0.0194729883,
0.0182283334,
0.0555868633,
-0.0210909601,
-0.0016560836,
0.0356489085,
-0.0382981822,
-0.0622579344,
-0.0255573727,
-0.0227895789,
-0.0031985678,
-0.0153974956,
0.0111216176,
0.0240391158,
0.069552213,
-0.0168265402,
0.0127781704,
-0.0018790198,
-0.1104633883,
0.020748999,
0.002931156,
0.0225496627,
0.0373312309,
0.0015522545,
0.0063976604,
-0.073198542,
0.0132506182,
-0.0528719984,
0.0819178224,
-0.0141014913,
0.0438937731,
0.0277092811,
-0.0107264183,
-0.0011917502,
0.0709084421,
-0.011693608,
0.0025910074,
0.019202888,
0.0202290453,
0.0123823388,
-0.0238785204,
-0.0043841256,
0.0525817424,
0.0232836455,
0.0392116867,
0.0446973145,
-0.0292639304,
-0.0700206682,
-0.0445468277,
-0.0965500101,
0.0186415501,
-0.0152497813,
0.0181964729,
0.0227638166,
-0.0075465459,
0.0026319779,
-0.0086264536,
-0.0512306876,
0.0208270103,
-0.0138427382,
0.038516853,
-0.0035888986,
-0.0000515349,
0.0406787395,
-0.0377046838,
-0.0272671636,
0.0061500627,
0.0351618454,
-0.0054688668,
-0.0229017437,
-0.0713897049,
0.0608344339,
-0.0051017799,
0.024504099,
-0.0206177086,
-0.0099032987,
0.0048060901,
-0.0358805545,
0.0814300478,
0.1038551107,
-0.0072140666,
0.0392864496,
0.0729104504,
-0.0439180098,
-0.0512199849,
-0.0123230238,
-0.0312430598,
0.0233587623,
-0.0081222653,
0.0084487051,
-0.0180572961,
0.0406995974,
-0.0015006694,
0.0300658885,
-0.0330268443,
-0.010931002,
-0.0231747907,
0.0024159087,
-0.0012686675,
-0.04013988,
-0.0239516646,
-0.0057016746,
0.0130721061,
-0.0440882966,
0.010794932,
-0.0386799574,
0.0324096195,
-0.0543017648,
0.0151043003,
0.0011315516,
0.0586325042,
0.026171824,
0.0379906259,
-0.0392505936,
-0.020931527,
-0.0356201567,
-0.0037791957,
-0.0002297685,
-0.0313473791,
0.0180247705,
-0.0320330523,
0.0068802079,
-0.0157755185,
-0.012491894,
-0.0642832071,
0.0079446733,
0.0125220241,
0.0096110608,
0.0036548818,
-0.0112684127,
-0.0626789182,
-0.0150186624,
0.0665005222,
0.0602626018,
-0.0217459984,
-0.006380843,
-0.0142728901,
0.0598469488,
0.0342694782,
-0.0384654328,
0.0284691565,
-0.053707011,
0.002450387,
0.0724230409,
0.0587712154,
0.0005478841,
-0.0019865134,
0.0068853819,
0.0141766388,
-0.0493791737,
-0.0488069765,
0.0048511378,
0.0180939902,
-0.0951348841,
-0.0431365035,
0.0963260755,
0.0570033826,
-0.106317468,
-0.0180222541,
-0.0108997338,
0.0314551517,
0.0147446543,
0.0116977636,
-0.0184873622,
-0.002396578,
0.0141492393,
0.0101609053,
-0.0043330509,
0.0010332896,
-0.0037345148,
-0.0850061476,
-0.0267670229,
0.028182108,
0.0190791432,
0.0085415095,
-0.0586715527,
-0.0597114451,
0.0462718382,
0.0173771698,
0.0285617094,
-0.0243319701,
-0.0162051376,
0.0115360143,
0.0102453483,
-0.0058901561,
-0.0055900244,
0.0003371716,
0.0329143703,
0.0364840552,
0.0334621891,
0.0125971315,
-0.0335784629,
0.0285982285,
-0.0118415197,
0.0195422489,
-0.0175863877,
0.0456616208,
-0.0013101458,
0.0176250618,
0.0058858115,
0.0209802091,
-0.0338359214,
-0.0439834297,
-0.0076746303,
0.0502664,
-0.0317097418,
-0.0382452458,
0.0138243465,
-0.0212317966,
-0.0305069834,
0.0684619322,
0.0161367077,
-0.0142013505,
-0.0608470179,
0.0006171328,
0.0451959223,
0.003411026,
0.033490818,
0.0045558112,
-0.0268536359,
-0.0024242443,
-0.1142883599,
-0.0555113256,
0.0018740341,
0.0310992394,
-0.004385483,
0.0112212989,
-0.0154777858,
-0.0521478988,
-0.0414058864,
0.0191280227,
-0.0257423408,
-0.0225650631,
-0.0601377897,
-0.0177914929,
0.0607391894,
-0.031115232,
-0.0092131123,
0.064320147,
-0.0934178606,
-0.0667980313,
0.0327353962,
0.0392352939,
0.0239946228,
0.066577442,
0.0374510139,
-0.0310940985,
0.0605829321,
-0.0067684012,
-0.0688634142,
0.0404484086,
0.0264647864,
-0.0098567028,
-0.0065308297,
0.0191877,
-0.0458494388,
0.0110343928,
-0.0004613062,
0.0280067399,
0.0129142581,
0.0339893512,
0.0112181799,
-0.0083897505,
-0.0083122589,
0.0073390687,
0.0155012067,
-0.0250486862,
0.0474734716,
-0.0244085658,
-0.0192690156,
-0.0047518765,
0.0156240817,
0.0142857963,
0.0050987722,
-0.0135210417,
-0.0187658314,
0.0469822697,
0.0368861854,
0.0191678982,
-0.0248337761,
0.0352889299,
0.0312621854,
0.0012198277,
0.0068322928,
-0.025797544,
0.0172523446,
-0.022100484,
0.0637533069,
-0.0552645512,
0.0882607773,
0.0003149088,
-0.0112100923,
-0.0415370166,
0.0074335001,
-0.0650725216,
-0.0567252859,
-0.0079495208,
0.0142949028,
0.050224144,
-0.0793727264,
0.0539334677,
-0.0726397187,
-0.0081072282,
-0.0129493354,
0.0007279024,
0.0343622193,
-0.0158655941,
0.0028311657,
0.0170816965,
0.0001438926,
0.0270879678,
0.0591761284,
0.0099033341,
0.049968794,
0.0038790656,
-0.0152102746,
-0.0293011833,
-0.0121621955,
0.039156545,
0.0514002293,
-0.0309605543,
-0.0228158943,
-0.026995508,
-0.0344991162,
0.0520390198,
-0.0273201503,
0.0123352297,
-0.0414898694,
0.0411604308,
0.0405616537,
-0.0171422735,
0.0121743344,
-0.0193186738,
0.0432719104,
-0.0430788361,
-0.0143159069,
-0.0362403691,
-6.889495983e-33,
-0.0304942839,
-0.0057026818,
0.0337379612,
0.0165436305,
-0.0204227362,
0.0303567983,
-0.0516400412,
-0.0152684143,
-0.004856762,
-0.0173595846,
-0.0189699512,
-0.0045163743,
0.0186018031,
0.0215822272,
-0.0245466623,
-0.0043608043,
0.0288162511,
-0.0252923761,
-0.0270677693,
0.0941818431,
0.0805579722,
0.0216551777,
0.0436529331,
-0.0572297461,
0.0163231082,
-0.019630529,
0.0110672154,
-0.039022807,
-0.0056851399,
0.0470510647,
-0.0731191561,
0.0043362426,
0.0109256739,
0.0049439468,
-0.0265574716,
0.0353854746,
-0.0678302944,
-0.0171356648,
-0.0097646192,
0.0090110619,
-0.0059818258,
-0.0538211726,
0.0209144838,
-0.0131629752,
0.0121348249,
0.0193756074,
0.008261702,
0.0041872715,
-0.0822069794,
-0.0215552486,
-0.0892484337,
0.0072857318,
0.0148370648,
0.0086581903,
0.023227727,
-0.0420848504,
-0.0022774667,
0.0083414363,
-0.0789647102,
-0.0329609178,
-0.0131983962,
0.0740830526,
0.0087378854,
0.0128807183,
-0.0022826169,
0.0804205388,
0.0504319109,
0.0125327716,
0.0127817607,
0.0061089895,
0.034783978,
-0.0026314002,
0.0305050239,
-0.0396061242,
0.0510137863,
-0.036303103,
-0.044675339,
0.0071882149,
0.0102898441,
0.0517502017,
0.0624819063,
0.0135991881,
-0.0223004464,
-0.0139296278,
-0.0395904966,
0.0051811277,
-0.0293753948,
-0.0000181688,
0.0228135902,
0.0178300682,
-0.0182972774,
-0.050383985,
0.036813613,
-0.0074792802,
-0.0112863975,
0.0558996573,
-0.0548867546,
0.0420159884,
-0.0278884731,
0.0313424282,
-0.0765269026,
-0.0310171116,
0.0004780468,
-0.0194766968,
-0.0085323351,
0.0469205752,
0.0325635746,
0.0367211439,
-0.0729854777,
-0.007491109,
-0.0429508872,
-0.0214268379,
0.0213443413,
0.0093908571,
0.0281196684,
0.0080776885,
0.0048309318,
0.0744596049,
0.0128485132,
-0.009135914,
-0.0238643307,
-0.075748384,
0.0091388905,
0.0097071594,
-0.0287280548,
0.0048322538,
-0.0602525659,
0.0303297043,
0.0654695332,
-0.0516954847,
0.0320647247,
0.0343254283,
2.951e-7,
0.003970264,
0.0406139866,
0.0258950889,
0.0080737565,
0.0071201092,
0.0152150085,
-0.0254002549,
0.0247651115,
0.0098398598,
-0.0123713063,
-0.0018218779,
0.0266278405,
0.0241200291,
0.0253807213,
-0.0840738937,
0.0281927474,
-0.0521955863,
-0.0277164336,
-0.0550046414,
-0.0103865061,
-0.0186260771,
0.0795415789,
0.0020908043,
-0.0318253785,
0.0065744263,
-0.0334756859,
0.1083160639,
-0.0217906553,
0.016480634,
-0.0055004051,
0.0387525372,
0.0190678127,
-0.0318827629,
-0.0039291703,
-0.0196152292,
0.0090360465,
-0.0089094825,
0.0670086145,
-0.0121088009,
-0.0293918848,
0.0105275074,
-0.0160177015,
0.0010434143,
-0.0365903005,
0.0376371332,
0.0033687123,
-0.0219963808,
-0.0478285477,
0.0101832943,
-0.0072304327,
-0.0107996613,
-0.0027065787,
-0.0098265195,
0.0514326617,
-0.0289536696,
0.0185696594,
-0.0057767178,
-0.0948219895,
-0.0160651915,
-0.0123463245,
-0.0223651547,
-0.0383017883,
-0.0463947169,
0.0118340962,
0.0042939391,
-0.086709477,
0.0016276193,
2.791174372e-34,
0.0272621792,
-0.0512224957,
-0.0344456732,
0.0533939898,
0.0327067412,
-0.0100926952,
0.0364128798,
0.0383564755,
0.0231570955,
-0.1034251824,
-0.0271403566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15992v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15992v1 | Can LLM Graph Reasoning Generalize beyond Pattern Memorization? | 2024-06-23T02:59:15 | 2024-06-23T02:59:15 | Yizhuo Zhang, Heng Wang, Shangbin Feng, Zhaoxuan Tan, Xiaochuang Han, Tianxing He, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate great potential for problems with
implicit graphical structures, while recent works seek to enhance the graph
reasoning capabilities of LLMs through specialized instruction tuning. The
resulting 'graph LLMs' are evaluated with in-distribution settings only, thus
it remains underexplored whether LLMs are learning generalizable graph
reasoning skills or merely memorizing patterns in the synthetic training data.
To this end, we propose the NLGift benchmark, an evaluation suite of LLM graph
reasoning generalization: whether LLMs could go beyond semantic, numeric,
structural, reasoning patterns in the synthetic training data and improve
utility on real-world graph-based tasks. Extensive experiments with two LLMs
across four graph reasoning tasks demonstrate that while generalization on
simple patterns (semantic, numeric) is somewhat satisfactory, LLMs struggle to
generalize across reasoning and real-world patterns, casting doubt on the
benefit of synthetic graph tuning for real-world tasks with underlying network
structures. We explore three strategies to improve LLM graph reasoning
generalization, and we find that while post-training alignment is most
promising for real-world tasks, empowering LLM graph reasoning to go beyond
pattern memorization remains an open research question. | [
0.0316616893,
0.0341742747,
-0.0040033413,
0.0498753525,
-0.0607256964,
0.0122322422,
-0.0053374856,
0.0092462171,
0.0416650325,
-0.0150235612,
-0.014749038,
-0.0207869541,
-0.0062512737,
0.0297196433,
0.0468896478,
-0.0091945007,
0.0316722468,
-0.0326984897,
-0.0022371288,
-0.015599424,
0.0024674842,
0.0460731089,
-0.0136925494,
-0.0044726557,
-0.0371729657,
-0.0227081738,
-0.0151903965,
0.0458970927,
-0.0168265607,
-0.0388865583,
-0.0462481156,
0.0062202066,
0.0425815657,
0.0084428303,
0.0000017045,
-0.0104014501,
-0.0076676207,
-0.0081327809,
-0.0410985909,
-0.0066503137,
-0.0162947401,
-0.0220771991,
0.0285483804,
-0.00768696,
-0.0523678809,
-0.0285982415,
0.0283611715,
0.0236586593,
0.0351144932,
0.0813446939,
-0.0198115762,
-0.0394618362,
-0.0014307742,
-0.0114695961,
-0.0004143823,
-0.0411706194,
0.0188485812,
0.0410544239,
0.0147857862,
-0.0550572053,
-0.0417229831,
0.0033573594,
0.0390973985,
-0.0023315751,
0.0454115383,
0.0418981761,
-0.0105669852,
0.0255953129,
0.0206913836,
0.1228995547,
-0.0115908328,
-0.019612696,
0.0087201372,
-0.0007263457,
-0.0075635682,
0.0443767384,
-0.0613699146,
-0.0211290773,
-0.027739333,
-0.0005840916,
-0.0278954916,
-0.0760172829,
0.0658555701,
-0.0084947757,
-0.0294362344,
0.1173186898,
-0.0052416311,
-0.0087365974,
0.0396494456,
-0.0061380439,
-0.0517576262,
-0.0242818724,
-0.0015551875,
0.066461727,
-0.0477218293,
0.0244224425,
-0.0139022376,
0.0367842391,
-0.0291736666,
0.0011989427,
0.0653627589,
0.0191004816,
0.0207088608,
0.0389944986,
-0.0455424786,
0.0809532925,
-0.0318311974,
0.0940613896,
-0.057058733,
-0.0051275501,
-0.0558293499,
-0.0056386362,
-0.0476435162,
0.0436023399,
0.0189358294,
-0.0546571054,
-0.0202414785,
0.0430853926,
-0.0105598839,
0.031510707,
0.030492859,
0.0343796983,
0.0226900689,
-0.04358688,
-0.0144244824,
0.0162654426,
-0.0066569247,
0.0156122399,
-0.0287976395,
-0.0078945179,
-0.0029665797,
0.0125217875,
0.0327494219,
-0.0318133533,
0.0260245726,
0.0806834549,
0.0144865699,
0.0009209302,
-0.0486283526,
-0.0214079283,
-0.0137873627,
-0.0766575113,
0.0496497527,
-0.0799226314,
0.027493231,
0.0451119356,
-0.0248178709,
-0.0229013246,
0.0205028802,
-0.0311919581,
-0.0482999794,
0.0504057258,
0.0362288319,
0.0417090319,
-0.0018455824,
-0.0283649769,
-0.0039738067,
0.0294455476,
0.0381241105,
0.0042595873,
0.0064072218,
-0.0170807466,
-0.0276627801,
0.0330744796,
0.0396966673,
0.0044331243,
-0.0319135226,
0.0102838576,
-0.015199773,
0.0225611255,
0.0235760119,
0.0691705495,
-0.0395063125,
-0.0529433489,
0.0474520102,
0.0507575497,
0.0109166736,
-0.0399931632,
0.0468213782,
-0.0187493358,
-0.0016815128,
0.0439391695,
-0.0748099834,
0.0199217722,
-0.0075308033,
0.0327919312,
-0.0309291463,
-0.0498920381,
-0.0094493385,
-0.0250653494,
-0.0278639309,
0.010781765,
0.0612420738,
0.0232057329,
0.0560336411,
0.0198018271,
-0.0524465814,
0.0260394886,
0.0155665241,
0.0041750148,
0.0057401764,
0.0020621608,
-0.0099772383,
0.0879546553,
0.0389873683,
0.012734687,
-0.0393297859,
0.0260673147,
-0.0044922717,
0.0043629194,
0.0457477309,
-0.0333988927,
-0.0285209846,
-0.0532960892,
-0.0244886484,
-0.0460260846,
-0.0162338354,
0.019963095,
0.0348382406,
-0.0192189775,
-0.0097756507,
-0.0968954116,
-0.0333472602,
0.0017396166,
-0.0104423957,
-0.0171452444,
-0.0264407732,
0.0173079576,
0.0030727419,
0.0018030083,
-0.0060100555,
0.0284538101,
0.0028819479,
0.0062254178,
-0.0113607384,
0.0056933439,
-0.0644719228,
-0.04330156,
0.0423738696,
-0.0258578472,
-0.0537610613,
0.0233862475,
-0.0655907616,
-0.0285978876,
0.0512719899,
-0.0501431413,
0.0450458974,
0.0017329506,
0.0123611223,
0.0176363774,
-0.0243957601,
-0.0031690737,
0.0575422086,
-0.0024249931,
-0.002055241,
-0.0068234652,
0.040901307,
-0.0064062476,
-0.0548128225,
0.0363642983,
0.0403223708,
0.0090436833,
0.0023875858,
-0.0100451475,
-0.0173127167,
-0.064561002,
0.024654299,
-0.0675745308,
0.0065735965,
0.0118629485,
0.0184554681,
0.0290772375,
-0.0178741589,
0.0031272674,
-0.0279420018,
-0.0548003577,
0.038918905,
0.0227048304,
0.026306957,
0.0380095765,
-0.0228688009,
-0.0318986662,
-0.0183297824,
-0.0452648401,
-0.0598020181,
0.0736137182,
0.0211197585,
-0.0149246063,
-0.0095029408,
0.0480848663,
-0.0533646643,
0.0322077125,
-0.0259831175,
0.0098110391,
0.0207808483,
-0.0299226921,
0.0260633677,
0.0849520937,
-0.0434133708,
0.0119553851,
0.0379899405,
-0.0072551426,
-0.0385370553,
-0.0012288751,
-0.044076696,
-0.024200568,
-0.0471190661,
-0.0322406702,
-0.0573558845,
0.0372817591,
0.0093717566,
0.0085777519,
-0.0322540067,
-0.0038397673,
-0.0111755133,
0.0312111061,
-0.0344017521,
-0.0256830659,
0.0285707563,
-0.0146308914,
-0.0811020657,
-0.0303384345,
0.0950652584,
-0.013319999,
-0.0052245324,
0.0299427025,
-0.0189382825,
-0.0724823847,
0.078519851,
0.0595812313,
0.0073173302,
-0.0215555988,
-0.0463489145,
-0.0603174083,
-0.0263772011,
0.0591010153,
-0.0197430793,
0.0456516929,
-0.0256328862,
0.0413068272,
0.0080045341,
-0.0126859779,
-0.0265753958,
0.029567821,
-0.0269909762,
0.0407776609,
-0.0016928914,
-0.0416377373,
0.0098933037,
0.013951974,
-0.0130413491,
-0.0128835617,
-0.0303888433,
0.008929221,
-0.0290054083,
0.0294511691,
0.0352326669,
-0.0017259018,
-0.0063322489,
-0.062229827,
-0.0257456284,
0.0261598267,
0.0217383374,
-0.0191292334,
-0.045400504,
0.0444708131,
-0.0135159008,
-0.0080702538,
0.0016699544,
-0.0171721168,
0.0377212763,
-0.055895336,
0.018362429,
0.0567364879,
0.0078169182,
-0.0061839302,
-0.0017959138,
0.0065605883,
0.0327017456,
0.0475845188,
0.0228488874,
-0.0778649375,
-0.0202037916,
-0.0027740265,
0.0018356101,
0.0401006266,
-0.0572216623,
-0.0140965153,
-0.1103315353,
-0.0034729682,
0.0356200337,
-0.0201491211,
-0.0272181388,
-0.0501117259,
-0.0128464596,
0.0097978245,
-0.0020939962,
-0.0197145343,
-0.0151221361,
-0.001412581,
0.037780758,
-0.0174226128,
-0.0086691873,
0.0161171444,
0.0015035871,
-0.0155361658,
-0.0292161237,
0.0187316816,
0.0341802463,
-0.0256137475,
0.0751025453,
0.0602114387,
0.0234745424,
-0.0295873415,
0.0294338502,
0.0156587549,
0.0064207208,
-0.0262079146,
0.0080347154,
-0.0451015532,
-0.0138683096,
-0.0529943667,
0.0907515213,
0.0031417939,
-0.0373784937,
0.0086227162,
0.0037975395,
-0.0385314897,
0.0120738875,
0.0376908332,
0.0423140116,
-0.0646098852,
-0.0530110933,
0.0058569545,
-0.053110823,
-0.0592342764,
0.0497569367,
-0.0039378158,
0.0337424725,
-0.0269758943,
-0.0048452304,
0.0401434414,
0.020788813,
-0.0122103849,
-0.0272378083,
0.0225477256,
-0.053713426,
-0.0868734494,
0.0518526137,
-0.0545214117,
0.0449717045,
0.0049923477,
-0.0245439522,
-0.0075233742,
-0.0123809837,
-0.0099069467,
0.0082477769,
-0.054426264,
-0.0924046189,
-0.0480289422,
-0.0077995267,
0.0209699571,
0.0975950882,
0.0159775596,
0.0092647672,
0.024322927,
0.0087427953,
-0.0063159899,
-0.004644657,
0.0181723628,
-0.0216741562,
-0.0014753076,
0.0196867846,
-0.061817918,
0.0080174068,
0.0663182288,
0.0634025112,
-0.0124020511,
-0.0051774713,
0.027248133,
0.0709465221,
0.0094417259,
0.0568204485,
0.0021572076,
-0.0486797728,
0.0014005634,
-0.0022056808,
-0.0385486558,
-0.0144159328,
-0.0395617969,
0.0303393677,
0.0127303395,
0.0156579148,
-0.0380563512,
0.014607247,
0.0493662916,
-0.0038059759,
-0.0190563835,
0.0125318244,
-0.0219186898,
0.0467254892,
0.0067396858,
-0.0119958874,
0.0237700455,
0.0096510341,
0.0294157695,
0.0032804271,
0.0299139041,
0.0392801277,
-0.0155841792,
-0.0794351548,
-0.0430094153,
-0.0613930486,
-0.069071874,
0.0094867712,
-0.0113673806,
0.0687955171,
-0.0151431952,
0.0109903291,
-0.0157383215,
0.0015189104,
0.0078541646,
0.0464911982,
0.0102742566,
-0.0424155742,
0.0494999178,
0.0530164205,
0.0209493022,
0.0207830593,
0.0281787906,
0.050275337,
0.0387523696,
-0.0186622702,
-0.0410622284,
-0.0170937572,
-0.0431344323,
-0.0025309366,
0.0207972303,
0.0007047383,
0.0144805191,
-0.0509565137,
-0.1112266257,
-0.0123074474,
0.0361297131,
-0.0010382521,
-0.0057205763,
0.0215366092,
0.0409692936,
0.0250814464,
-0.0361145772,
-0.0069778278,
0.0405308306,
-0.0102353487,
-0.0072887898,
-0.0146592343,
-5.817268444e-33,
-0.0110062137,
-0.0765480399,
0.0477603674,
0.0115684904,
-0.0472910702,
0.0194838718,
-0.060643252,
-0.0019000431,
-0.0424171723,
0.0190475937,
-0.0126927691,
0.0101816086,
-0.0012421798,
0.0042051356,
-0.0400914587,
-0.0176453814,
0.0129754096,
0.0165713038,
-0.0181711465,
0.0163460486,
0.0348293222,
0.0210603178,
0.0520981513,
-0.0492637046,
-0.0011804623,
-0.0151134944,
0.0236003045,
0.048401136,
-0.0234150272,
0.0514089391,
0.0039054099,
0.013317897,
0.037645001,
0.0058535375,
-0.0085000256,
0.0046168719,
-0.0784773156,
-0.016516313,
0.0524772964,
0.033442568,
-0.0586307608,
-0.0253643952,
0.0691739768,
-0.0067348587,
0.0072632036,
-0.0500143506,
0.0415427536,
-0.0030991524,
-0.0360334702,
0.0447529331,
-0.0277857222,
0.0106514292,
-0.0181800313,
0.014782181,
-0.0101590538,
-0.0197773147,
-0.0035904497,
0.0088048754,
-0.0358886793,
0.0416742675,
-0.0535940453,
-0.0108519541,
0.0565842129,
0.0402986407,
0.0210187379,
0.0479792356,
0.031746719,
0.0096149761,
-0.0267541613,
0.0001740571,
0.0120181935,
0.0985576361,
-0.0068144221,
-0.0098351138,
0.0098940553,
0.0042036427,
-0.0994180441,
-0.0224092789,
-0.013981184,
0.0320495293,
0.000950517,
0.0344855338,
-0.0112472121,
-0.0452403314,
-0.0259569585,
0.0054591019,
-0.0454311371,
-0.0190976914,
-0.0033148599,
-0.0094602508,
-0.0044656079,
0.0161250606,
-0.0061118081,
-0.0558457337,
-0.0307614263,
0.0617859364,
-0.0155316414,
0.0399447158,
-0.022477597,
0.0328011028,
-0.0325883888,
-0.0389832407,
-0.014393419,
-0.0137988226,
0.0336304009,
0.0279849265,
0.0750350729,
0.0277739353,
-0.0122277141,
-0.0229133796,
-0.0789870992,
-0.0460687876,
-0.0249681752,
-0.0160796307,
0.075314343,
0.0630499423,
-0.0166033357,
0.0614392124,
0.0143164573,
0.0141217634,
-0.0173960235,
0.0380465947,
-0.0238410626,
0.0500327349,
-0.0167366285,
-0.0145449759,
-0.0257254001,
0.014222594,
0.0409401171,
-0.0546652116,
-0.0186713152,
0.0110567035,
2.489e-7,
0.0470437258,
0.0405222811,
0.045811329,
0.0542953648,
0.0198119842,
0.0009882549,
-0.0444701463,
-0.0170958824,
0.0122587373,
-0.0385750048,
0.0324012563,
0.0899219364,
-0.0021173253,
0.0330251604,
-0.0280514359,
0.0587423556,
-0.0579768755,
-0.0332492776,
-0.0310569946,
0.0411710702,
0.012133589,
0.0258072652,
0.0375988372,
-0.0053241327,
-0.0084226262,
-0.0918640345,
0.0524965636,
0.0046061794,
-0.0007506324,
-0.0038014255,
-0.0234889723,
-0.0169885457,
-0.0094967643,
0.0347476117,
0.0231945049,
0.0073208087,
0.0219270885,
0.0452670641,
-0.0220229272,
-0.0082623111,
-0.0298986677,
-0.0508909635,
0.005127124,
-0.0157567896,
0.064859651,
-0.0527745709,
-0.0564811081,
0.0100779906,
-0.0259286761,
-0.0298839174,
0.0014958447,
0.0252716951,
0.0043289005,
0.0295293983,
0.0256162323,
-0.018046923,
0.0127639221,
-0.0536553748,
-0.0043705544,
0.0406939164,
-0.0170387533,
-0.0365786329,
0.0039369571,
0.0195616074,
0.0315942355,
0.0230926629,
-0.0001903589,
2.195887962e-34,
0.032085456,
0.0182338543,
0.0145164328,
-0.0074733016,
0.0490694977,
-0.0608250387,
-0.0355031751,
0.0284106489,
0.0328257717,
-0.1040373445,
-0.0215041935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15990v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15990v1 | Enhancing Cross-Document Event Coreference Resolution by Discourse Structure and Semantic Information | 2024-06-23T02:54:48 | 2024-06-23T02:54:48 | Qiang Gao, Bobo Li, Zixiang Meng, Yunlong Li, Jun Zhou, Fei Li, Chong Teng, Donghong Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing cross-document event coreference resolution models, which either
compute mention similarity directly or enhance mention representation by
extracting event arguments (such as location, time, agent, and patient),
lacking the ability to utilize document-level information. As a result, they
struggle to capture long-distance dependencies. This shortcoming leads to their
underwhelming performance in determining coreference for the events where their
argument information relies on long-distance dependencies. In light of these
limitations, we propose the construction of document-level Rhetorical Structure
Theory (RST) trees and cross-document Lexical Chains to model the structural
and semantic information of documents. Subsequently, cross-document
heterogeneous graphs are constructed and GAT is utilized to learn the
representations of events. Finally, a pair scorer calculates the similarity
between each pair of events and co-referred events can be recognized using
standard clustering algorithm. Additionally, as the existing cross-document
event coreference datasets are limited to English, we have developed a
large-scale Chinese cross-document event coreference dataset to fill this gap,
which comprises 53,066 event mentions and 4,476 clusters. After applying our
model on the English and Chinese datasets respectively, it outperforms all
baselines by large margins. | [
0.0442348123,
-0.0093623567,
-0.0042691724,
0.043013338,
-0.0317478478,
-0.0060725776,
-0.0283285044,
0.0109859817,
0.0671777651,
-0.0572931953,
-0.0094383052,
0.0097598964,
0.0103860144,
0.0047076996,
-0.0121159209,
-0.0628338605,
0.0452260748,
0.0075802905,
0.0755150542,
-0.0113251517,
0.0389266349,
0.0369329453,
0.0056590959,
0.0315807275,
-0.022859972,
-0.0370913297,
0.0058416738,
0.0112466402,
0.0431474186,
-0.0385179967,
0.012889198,
0.0166863613,
0.0137333265,
0.0258020721,
0.0000016541,
-0.0316666067,
-0.0298117511,
-0.0088054044,
0.0178609844,
0.0465693176,
0.0189884473,
-0.0109592956,
0.0053252974,
-0.0091696084,
-0.0005703198,
-0.0512938052,
0.0075668809,
0.1048473269,
0.0200771932,
0.0580236912,
-0.031173436,
-0.0040125996,
0.0299482681,
-0.0046176524,
-0.0544931106,
-0.0863380656,
0.0209138207,
0.0478684306,
0.0053624194,
0.0201223735,
-0.0087440396,
-0.0118359979,
-0.0163733549,
0.0230521951,
-0.0192775987,
0.0482058041,
-0.0576931126,
0.0452238768,
0.0151255215,
0.0667096525,
0.0709997267,
-0.0211337507,
0.0565777496,
0.0162349455,
-0.0197735429,
0.0092353681,
-0.056211669,
-0.0209481865,
-0.0369574316,
0.0305234157,
0.0769768059,
-0.009475681,
-0.0081066405,
0.017028302,
0.0284390859,
0.0431542173,
0.0138517646,
-0.0075999829,
-0.0256759655,
-0.0155559909,
-0.0382522829,
-0.0605563112,
0.0487298407,
0.0083630895,
-0.0342770442,
0.0320480093,
-0.0141281048,
0.0200979933,
0.0107302908,
-0.0965921134,
-0.0185565073,
-0.013233331,
0.0152723873,
0.0400889665,
-0.0168960579,
0.0135350032,
-0.0444603413,
-0.0127324834,
-0.0311705545,
-0.0467239469,
-0.0491409972,
0.0000398466,
-0.0550955012,
0.0488713309,
-0.0540117174,
-0.0349665247,
-0.0363760106,
-0.0226772092,
0.0088656927,
-0.0258931033,
-0.0116139343,
0.0137054101,
-0.0336447097,
-0.005999235,
-0.0162175857,
0.0152973067,
-0.0513560884,
0.0211847294,
-0.0737971663,
0.0126445312,
0.0072430158,
0.0342487283,
0.0283322036,
-0.0010347145,
-0.0391521715,
0.0369835123,
-0.0040559247,
0.0031676677,
-0.0061849975,
-0.0582605712,
-0.0389721319,
-0.0150715401,
-0.0212169811,
-0.0635695159,
-0.0053319004,
-0.0003441703,
0.0064005968,
-0.0509610623,
0.0416056812,
0.0086549567,
-0.0896853656,
0.0148165189,
0.023021834,
0.0036103679,
0.0328527242,
-0.0045030382,
0.0378464088,
0.0245160814,
0.0653668717,
0.0009302683,
0.0596141256,
0.0440244786,
-0.0306865219,
0.00042527,
0.0258831903,
0.0235269312,
0.0618273057,
-0.021714611,
-0.0209783036,
-0.008653583,
0.0028802082,
0.0256389417,
-0.0348999128,
-0.0216275696,
0.0042688772,
0.0399820842,
-0.0433607548,
-0.0289626792,
0.0087532531,
0.0070858342,
-0.0347905979,
0.0470008217,
0.0051218164,
-0.011246359,
-0.0059376471,
-0.0203322284,
0.0487167947,
-0.0187060628,
-0.0574250855,
-0.0088753654,
0.0014466359,
0.021157654,
0.0043583037,
-0.0328308456,
0.0436591208,
-0.0052715619,
-0.0587509871,
0.0412522592,
0.0232837982,
-0.0350855105,
-0.0119077228,
0.0092877392,
-0.0316206403,
-0.0137717575,
0.0305315852,
0.0012800486,
-0.0269410219,
0.0243686493,
0.0248386152,
0.0323735923,
0.0177168902,
-0.0288245548,
0.0058706389,
-0.0179003533,
-0.0159965549,
0.0070779035,
0.0031145881,
0.0233652703,
0.0281601641,
0.0159011483,
0.0130466642,
-0.0377911814,
-0.0135020083,
0.0065956404,
-0.0234840736,
-0.0057076118,
0.0047982344,
-0.0035557325,
0.046871949,
0.0324919857,
-0.0057482827,
-0.0179297645,
0.0179819353,
-0.0227851123,
-0.0102053294,
0.0483041182,
-0.0349852443,
-0.0257163271,
0.0328239202,
-0.0666134953,
-0.0143201649,
-0.0344005115,
-0.0175162517,
-0.0888378024,
0.0476350449,
-0.0059768264,
0.0348139815,
-0.0318984017,
0.0265342202,
0.0095752589,
-0.0157528408,
0.0041871723,
0.089577511,
0.035298612,
0.0248250347,
-0.0012830811,
0.0146943964,
0.0492658615,
-0.0181905963,
0.0041798651,
-0.0035258483,
0.0186036676,
-0.0105534932,
0.0629968494,
-0.0344908275,
-0.0430279486,
-0.0170997009,
-0.1450906545,
0.0286335386,
-0.0170460884,
0.0261319634,
0.0389102325,
0.0111998366,
-0.002829242,
-0.0039386726,
-0.0160072744,
-0.0298696533,
0.0074595977,
-0.0117832506,
0.0179960504,
-0.0027975256,
-0.0025440899,
-0.0305621345,
0.0046492368,
-0.0688657388,
0.0181676745,
0.0037376357,
-0.0638593808,
0.0055554374,
0.0348302275,
-0.0316088311,
0.0100831147,
-0.0201429911,
-0.0135460282,
-0.0061799614,
0.0314954221,
0.0559988692,
0.0256419685,
-0.0021644155,
0.0037872731,
-0.0058593135,
-0.0669354275,
-0.0644323975,
0.0106337545,
-0.0109455669,
0.012461164,
-0.0383419059,
-0.0206658151,
0.0256988909,
0.0537540652,
0.0484962277,
-0.0086809872,
-0.0497655682,
-0.0365115777,
-0.0171481781,
0.00442211,
0.0319325551,
-0.0381934531,
-0.0237388778,
0.0015892156,
-0.0353532955,
0.0173336789,
0.0415277928,
-0.0451973826,
0.0253844056,
-0.0334286019,
-0.0010032648,
-0.0644278526,
0.0794733167,
0.0173046496,
0.003112219,
0.048067797,
-0.0800617114,
0.0046919514,
-0.0156262405,
0.0227963328,
0.0090885302,
0.0219245777,
-0.0406945609,
0.0410677306,
-0.0026084124,
-0.0154735344,
-0.0135450484,
-0.0016474893,
-0.0281777438,
0.0093008811,
-0.043820221,
0.0307171308,
0.0033260989,
0.0287766289,
0.0110564837,
0.0273197871,
-0.0246175639,
0.0108092241,
-0.0259422418,
0.1040446982,
0.0272471998,
-0.0218725279,
-0.0245143194,
-0.0178642906,
-0.0018393412,
0.0731817931,
0.0173576251,
0.0090190852,
-0.0045540952,
-0.0134545127,
-0.0147563908,
-0.0635025874,
-0.0422819629,
-0.0287237242,
0.0586447194,
-0.030478403,
-0.0081901308,
0.0939134061,
0.0437311307,
-0.030415222,
-0.0064391927,
0.0163401049,
0.0181359258,
0.0225759987,
-0.0262943059,
-0.0253413394,
-0.0094249947,
-0.0064204806,
-0.044272095,
-0.0273551904,
-0.0539510697,
0.0128789218,
-0.05307585,
0.0157674663,
0.0019159485,
-0.0184573866,
-0.0402513482,
-0.0189906172,
0.0381690636,
0.0217213929,
-0.0241391473,
-0.0073785265,
-0.0048513431,
0.002582011,
-0.0165587515,
-0.0572369806,
0.0205909535,
0.0352360867,
-0.0327186882,
-0.0084049264,
0.0037300731,
0.0917267799,
0.0319837667,
0.0785273165,
-0.0049457531,
-0.0735053346,
-0.0182964485,
-0.0383542888,
0.0406228341,
-0.0048398646,
0.021854125,
-0.019571377,
0.0721415132,
-0.0136003485,
-0.0270163063,
0.0495625287,
0.049454134,
-0.0019977479,
0.0004410338,
-0.0190467276,
0.0570335276,
-0.0087412363,
0.0546822064,
0.0098333815,
0.0350493491,
-0.0370926298,
-0.0110553261,
0.0521247014,
-0.0448115282,
-0.0033111186,
-0.0010939229,
-0.0363866314,
0.0278405733,
-0.071232006,
-0.0619816072,
-0.0085965479,
0.0015826827,
-0.0228180941,
0.0539232492,
0.0298661515,
-0.0025348712,
-0.0243934561,
-0.0035075329,
-0.0475917198,
-0.023769334,
-0.0020115785,
0.0073333601,
0.0967966467,
0.0444285981,
-0.0246550906,
0.0646187514,
0.0093103237,
-0.0379146561,
-0.0377793685,
-0.0777262673,
0.0025191871,
0.0576996915,
-0.0234778505,
0.0261948016,
0.028323615,
-0.0111454418,
-0.053504061,
0.02450235,
0.016011104,
0.0022256232,
-0.0024842811,
0.0441139042,
-0.0246368498,
0.0645494759,
-0.0009506345,
0.0701611564,
-0.0592487566,
-0.0399600379,
-0.0040617404,
0.0294967629,
0.0377727412,
0.0305362176,
0.0166760962,
-0.0463944636,
0.0266693644,
-0.0580009632,
-0.0079617277,
-0.0080186268,
0.011142103,
-0.0235688444,
0.003925324,
-0.0373600908,
0.0248960909,
-0.0339394696,
0.0297402907,
-0.0168150049,
0.0068562897,
0.0617992394,
0.0191414375,
-0.0593066216,
-0.0253299605,
-0.0030633709,
-0.0126304077,
0.0157887973,
0.0222200379,
-0.0410494693,
0.0241816845,
-0.0020740421,
-0.006456573,
-0.0058196122,
-0.0251828469,
-0.0896431878,
0.0269079823,
-0.0197309162,
-0.0367843993,
0.0574240983,
-0.0251218975,
0.0711434931,
-0.0507339798,
0.0008097501,
-0.0049991221,
0.046090886,
-0.002326322,
0.0030210244,
-0.0045269374,
0.0152476542,
-0.0207185447,
0.0695100278,
0.0677772462,
0.0258409381,
0.0236213058,
0.0690557882,
-0.0396145321,
-0.0363907553,
-0.0677793473,
0.0139588965,
0.0120502505,
0.0149725731,
0.0139488978,
-0.043983195,
0.0070210998,
0.0799103677,
-0.0303934626,
-0.0134954201,
-0.0259938333,
0.0332031921,
0.0518021211,
0.0348571837,
-0.0047851522,
-0.0656915978,
0.0311312601,
0.007061237,
-0.027906904,
-0.0125991004,
-5.672143013e-33,
-0.0594918281,
-0.0505308136,
0.0055730655,
0.0575940907,
-0.018738756,
0.0512114428,
-0.0673435926,
-0.011944293,
-0.0145144789,
0.0362456515,
-0.0200017076,
0.0230174568,
0.0168761928,
0.0083851228,
-0.0102280863,
0.0054132403,
0.0230518077,
0.0172555093,
-0.0007889809,
0.0767377689,
0.0801315308,
0.0139722181,
0.0900881886,
-0.0945958793,
0.0398214608,
0.0169067439,
0.0089148972,
-0.0140380496,
0.0763529018,
0.0358211249,
-0.0012932776,
0.0490237847,
0.0304947849,
-0.0060568149,
-0.0021075646,
0.0101003284,
-0.1414308846,
-0.0486307889,
0.0467890799,
-0.040196985,
0.0095106764,
-0.0385047235,
0.0066486797,
-0.0050219162,
0.0198726039,
-0.0199160501,
0.077508755,
-0.0157489907,
-0.0330323651,
-0.0166169498,
-0.0722633526,
0.066403389,
-0.0194191951,
0.0374413542,
-0.0030248256,
0.040788535,
0.0168623682,
0.045795586,
-0.0371652916,
0.0322399996,
-0.0558094382,
0.0289487913,
-0.0604115166,
-0.0376603119,
0.0090883411,
0.0474156588,
-0.0142742274,
-0.0245967451,
-0.0110863717,
0.0437629037,
-0.0039674686,
0.0280382652,
-0.0195535012,
0.0933908448,
-0.0421289764,
0.0087298937,
-0.1083514765,
0.0304053333,
0.0311233774,
0.0118399402,
-0.0067799902,
-0.0113496613,
-0.0349221714,
-0.0466847308,
-0.0380805023,
-0.0260631721,
-0.0009179082,
-0.0215752907,
-0.0247617159,
-0.0153532475,
-0.0005367106,
0.0238573179,
0.0224491023,
-0.0323200338,
-0.0248787738,
0.0610214509,
0.0254956931,
0.0312178005,
0.0164558403,
0.0458502546,
-0.0347669721,
-0.0337638557,
-0.0179040469,
0.0130597055,
0.0313867666,
-0.019048091,
0.0053768614,
-0.050154388,
-0.0324313156,
0.0080013582,
0.0239517353,
-0.042354539,
-0.1011894196,
-0.0040163165,
0.0130897658,
0.01764277,
0.0376704372,
0.0506627485,
0.0205482412,
0.0269854125,
-0.0318287499,
-0.0551677458,
-0.0295198578,
0.0411795415,
-0.0161731914,
-0.0010375212,
-0.0154161043,
0.0428635813,
0.0344221145,
-0.0161774568,
-0.0269431993,
0.0017514961,
2.417e-7,
0.0210614502,
0.0178704392,
0.0563836619,
0.0142787583,
-0.001019747,
0.0320766903,
0.0001394908,
0.0608117133,
0.01915594,
-0.0321630053,
0.0216185991,
0.0291216094,
0.0151071073,
0.0533292219,
-0.0929065794,
0.0125815207,
-0.0871601328,
-0.0229695234,
-0.0428636,
0.0238259993,
-0.0129258344,
0.0421186611,
-0.0050244303,
0.02014523,
-0.0394953527,
-0.0178129766,
0.0411733687,
-0.0303362049,
-0.0815196708,
0.0596333183,
-0.0563964136,
0.0044835825,
-0.0297799557,
0.0214592014,
-0.000372774,
0.0490012728,
0.0391276665,
0.0595755018,
0.0003281918,
-0.0344944932,
-0.024503408,
-0.0256513581,
0.0196588822,
-0.0002885752,
0.0530257523,
-0.0055037588,
-0.0404160842,
-0.0243636407,
-0.0242540054,
0.0327482708,
-0.0072014756,
0.0470754094,
-0.0349653959,
0.0541859306,
-0.0109262308,
0.0045998613,
0.0033772048,
-0.0502289273,
-0.0069116359,
0.0286488477,
-0.0044157347,
-0.037301816,
0.0411179177,
-0.0475225672,
-0.0214336868,
-0.0276606828,
0.0182456989,
2.091710693e-34,
0.0265268851,
0.0020850743,
-0.0234554689,
-0.0075004823,
0.0375930183,
-0.0267316326,
-0.0063434872,
-0.010456467,
0.0264234226,
-0.040322572,
-0.0089982012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15981v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15981v1 | Serial Position Effects of Large Language Models | 2024-06-23T02:02:52 | 2024-06-23T02:02:52 | Xiaobo Guo, Soroush Vosoughi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in zero-shot
learning applications, generating responses to queries using only pre-training
information without the need for additional fine-tuning. This represents a
significant departure from traditional machine learning approaches. Previous
research has indicated that LLMs may exhibit serial position effects, such as
primacy and recency biases, which are well-documented cognitive biases in human
psychology. Our extensive testing across various tasks and models confirms the
widespread occurrence of these effects, although their intensity varies. We
also discovered that while carefully designed prompts can somewhat mitigate
these biases, their effectiveness is inconsistent. These findings underscore
the significance of serial position effects during the inference process,
particularly in scenarios where there are no ground truth labels, highlighting
the need for greater focus on addressing these effects in LLM applications. | [
0.0337139703,
0.0595360324,
-0.0338411257,
0.0253320448,
-0.0500842333,
0.0326044522,
0.0243723262,
-0.0161350463,
-0.0050937575,
-0.0587788299,
-0.0104160421,
-0.062326204,
0.0060013584,
-0.0126239182,
0.023917133,
-0.0243456475,
0.0530510396,
-0.0393225327,
0.0457734987,
-0.0251075886,
-0.0275656674,
0.004296856,
-0.0345009863,
0.0350392833,
-0.0062059425,
-0.0319634341,
0.0059139086,
0.0134964334,
0.0011183589,
-0.0605895668,
-0.0321370177,
0.0706329197,
0.0224187169,
0.05352249,
0.0000020537,
-0.0616466366,
0.006526235,
-0.0197087191,
-0.0468875468,
0.0009203742,
0.0315314457,
0.0038658364,
0.0162182786,
0.0236590263,
-0.0305541884,
0.004147524,
0.0558054708,
0.0244423877,
-0.0089898929,
0.0404833592,
-0.0076248636,
-0.0140262498,
-0.025195444,
-0.0174427815,
0.0238583181,
-0.0265963357,
0.0225125235,
-0.0297406819,
-0.0241288207,
0.0148895448,
-0.0128820362,
0.0253651477,
0.0090637058,
0.0384603888,
-0.0191857927,
0.0469163209,
-0.0275061354,
-0.0296402965,
-0.0138217686,
0.0607326701,
-0.0005940495,
-0.0285211168,
-0.006550645,
-0.0261476431,
0.0414327867,
0.0076373764,
-0.0810003504,
0.0858419314,
0.0138336318,
0.0010271491,
0.0005296052,
0.0009869834,
0.0134994965,
-0.0039750896,
-0.0615135692,
0.063927941,
0.0161081981,
-0.035477832,
0.0154681448,
0.0376136377,
-0.0200132802,
-0.042193085,
-0.0091132512,
0.0171619318,
-0.0475164279,
0.0369651802,
-0.0113771921,
-0.0003785155,
0.0281311087,
-0.0469942763,
0.0623116456,
0.0396590754,
-0.0395173505,
0.0103410818,
-0.0239614472,
0.0576519333,
-0.0122592906,
0.0003547125,
-0.0310913045,
0.0149766784,
-0.0100820875,
-0.0420102365,
0.0098882141,
0.0318295732,
0.0050284988,
0.003426746,
-0.0559020787,
0.0277818032,
0.0016437226,
-0.0025677155,
-0.0586621277,
0.026974868,
-0.0188168604,
-0.0277123284,
-0.0227701385,
0.0822153836,
-0.0232192501,
0.041163709,
-0.013334387,
-0.0841564313,
-0.015489812,
0.0060248319,
-0.0105254082,
-0.0254042502,
-0.0115612876,
0.0337740928,
-0.0148907276,
-0.021113066,
-0.0255828612,
-0.0214487668,
-0.0110458462,
-0.0678438619,
0.0029861624,
-0.0434923023,
-0.0032592614,
0.0660428479,
-0.0096661812,
-0.0248612631,
0.0035693171,
0.0346880779,
-0.0584520102,
0.0667663142,
0.0251718163,
0.0268807821,
0.0153152486,
-0.0009518777,
-0.0041439803,
0.0977527276,
0.0184280593,
0.0296997577,
0.0215771627,
0.0129043618,
0.0114676403,
0.0277704634,
-0.0213063229,
0.0056168311,
-0.0608504638,
-0.0028008018,
0.0043087094,
0.0115775866,
0.0489428639,
0.0151837021,
-0.0214720648,
0.011578192,
0.0686311126,
0.0645220727,
-0.0303075016,
-0.0405391231,
0.0028285377,
-0.0068856352,
-0.0087690782,
0.0429388583,
-0.0896364003,
0.0117137339,
-0.0060170949,
0.0036071721,
-0.0015581209,
0.016478641,
-0.0103430394,
-0.0227623004,
-0.0365315676,
0.0165624954,
-0.0206271708,
0.0525934659,
0.0417585969,
-0.0331335738,
-0.0340939648,
0.0570308752,
0.0184867568,
-0.0270800386,
-0.0348147824,
-0.0291904509,
-0.0085564181,
0.0348278694,
-0.0023216717,
-0.037597429,
-0.0383650884,
0.0109846061,
0.0141194668,
0.0563051254,
0.0459473915,
0.0100554638,
0.0061741765,
-0.0344427675,
-0.0240215492,
0.0138976583,
0.0258496739,
0.0142206755,
0.0007126394,
0.0079201227,
0.0148915295,
0.0068858163,
-0.0211792663,
0.0364728197,
-0.0187385362,
-0.0574375689,
-0.0185873415,
0.0070252563,
0.0177943818,
-0.00206112,
-0.0018747017,
0.0339211635,
0.0412649401,
0.0087535279,
0.0350977667,
0.0059613083,
-0.0786447003,
-0.0035252152,
0.03773522,
-0.0007203813,
-0.0422189645,
0.0140452692,
-0.0266137384,
-0.0180444438,
0.0059932172,
-0.0156842321,
0.0407413691,
0.0010839289,
0.0312891863,
-0.0252383165,
0.0030790495,
-0.0637927204,
0.0643343329,
0.008779061,
0.0257603042,
0.0726019144,
-0.0145750651,
0.0071220552,
-0.057106588,
-0.0175273605,
0.0012475859,
-0.0086132903,
-0.0037279746,
0.0109358542,
-0.0419606827,
-0.0485340543,
0.0096556144,
-0.123184368,
-0.0163277946,
-0.0184040722,
0.0028792964,
0.0109206578,
-0.0299655758,
-0.0402422175,
-0.0550009049,
-0.0328621045,
-0.017719835,
0.0222370997,
0.0839100108,
0.0095494855,
-0.0203671176,
-0.0125043504,
-0.0377182849,
-0.0211984701,
-0.0438390002,
0.0523758456,
0.0155835785,
-0.0082580959,
-0.0630906075,
0.0392592438,
-0.022778606,
0.0280226674,
0.004231384,
0.0009572684,
0.0444270037,
-0.0171917491,
0.0389570259,
0.1120655239,
0.0008390068,
0.0514788181,
0.0852670148,
-0.0094425622,
-0.0720629916,
-0.0321511105,
-0.0321798734,
-0.0302222073,
0.0026217801,
-0.0305190384,
-0.0435336605,
0.0817678347,
0.0266770739,
-0.0012042308,
-0.0223462693,
0.0273651108,
-0.0330496505,
-0.0336051136,
-0.0450434387,
-0.0038741175,
-0.0380693115,
0.0637036338,
-0.0194517169,
-0.0531381778,
0.0532003865,
0.0042415154,
0.0106624104,
-0.0235406626,
0.0211200342,
-0.0102864914,
0.0498135723,
0.0305843465,
0.0092507619,
0.0313839205,
-0.0410688147,
-0.0923131704,
-0.0172943622,
-0.006700939,
-0.0356167555,
0.0392233729,
-0.0402431674,
0.0024967473,
-0.0324953571,
-0.0428393111,
-0.076964356,
-0.0183198303,
-0.0464944839,
0.0135227134,
-0.0287368726,
0.0054977112,
-0.048387453,
-0.0086767673,
0.0635684878,
0.0111258319,
-0.017050229,
-0.0062745581,
-0.0103413453,
0.0175951086,
0.0527130589,
0.0162223876,
0.0333128721,
-0.0382232964,
-0.0036956987,
0.0424815305,
0.0170117617,
0.0318372324,
-0.0061070323,
0.0076892399,
0.052013699,
-0.0643749908,
-0.027315395,
0.0559508875,
0.0175187625,
-0.0531926565,
0.0044188024,
0.1170461178,
0.0450906493,
-0.0566025712,
0.0130295157,
-0.0271147005,
0.0424234197,
0.0496371649,
0.0066439766,
-0.0842917934,
-0.0170463547,
0.0221762136,
-0.0031461145,
-0.0326505192,
-0.0216302425,
-0.0076281196,
-0.156612426,
0.0444025137,
-0.0062346938,
-0.0712137148,
-0.0094659971,
-0.0375300273,
0.0072333114,
0.0137418285,
0.0168116484,
0.0259599742,
-0.0414282121,
-0.0049271751,
0.0337552615,
-0.0095752338,
-0.0544328839,
0.003889217,
-0.0347472094,
0.0371605828,
0.0289548393,
-0.01429768,
-0.0192883145,
-0.0316009559,
0.0114291301,
0.0165428128,
0.0210371483,
-0.0004796964,
0.0224509295,
-0.0141446711,
0.0042230338,
-0.0356845446,
-0.0100940531,
-0.0074928128,
-0.0182107594,
-0.0066535915,
0.072482571,
-0.0157136451,
-0.0237878077,
-0.02348198,
0.0003090151,
-0.0196568538,
0.0616457202,
0.0370470546,
-0.0304495208,
-0.0353978761,
-0.0356021635,
-0.0031720921,
-0.0020528897,
-0.0488890335,
0.033071544,
-0.002359374,
0.0000108073,
-0.0310492609,
-0.0383479409,
0.0226452015,
0.0305676181,
0.0170665439,
0.0390294194,
-0.002023106,
-0.0156171499,
-0.049634099,
0.0284860469,
-0.023278879,
0.0110968323,
-0.0696270913,
0.0178070664,
0.0438266061,
-0.0314944051,
-0.0156144844,
-0.0242065452,
-0.0609678924,
-0.0620159991,
0.0282640476,
0.032770291,
0.0332098901,
0.0281061903,
0.035736315,
-0.0546680987,
0.038793806,
0.0490984246,
-0.015191583,
0.0302445386,
0.0063767023,
0.0075886068,
-0.0004529839,
0.031888742,
-0.0417364687,
0.0346874744,
0.0199343972,
0.0299313553,
-0.0154658016,
-0.0397270545,
0.0231804438,
0.0378505848,
0.0870827511,
-0.0073016183,
-0.0066551631,
-0.027696427,
0.0153950797,
-0.04001664,
-0.0320922844,
-0.002396083,
0.0004549792,
0.0156150078,
0.0176446531,
-0.0061465707,
-0.0203806534,
-0.0259090941,
0.0404455289,
-0.0246563237,
0.0048117861,
-0.0017706221,
0.0044853585,
0.0340658762,
0.018557407,
-0.0422628894,
0.041704867,
0.0071290629,
0.0663935244,
0.0139305992,
0.0731611475,
0.0226866715,
-0.0115287993,
-0.0599691831,
0.0257049687,
-0.0728560612,
-0.0452257209,
0.0231787767,
-0.0061285277,
0.0744829625,
-0.0380822234,
0.0404260308,
-0.0327609666,
0.0085622063,
-0.0005600313,
-0.0085534928,
0.0211634431,
-0.0035385499,
0.0230529513,
0.0293650776,
-0.0180768874,
0.0515092649,
0.0724121481,
0.0403496139,
0.0233571623,
-0.0127967698,
-0.0395518281,
0.0096156383,
-0.008100206,
0.0605683215,
0.0185970273,
-0.018913867,
0.0041314517,
-0.0946308002,
-0.0727790967,
0.0196123384,
-0.0237719081,
0.0008632882,
-0.0625464171,
0.0275996197,
0.0707791075,
0.0035368504,
-0.0444028452,
-0.0371364951,
0.0276741665,
-0.0184837859,
-0.0112797851,
-0.0390718356,
-6.858227833e-33,
-0.0200772267,
-0.0449544191,
0.0143499644,
-0.0350233242,
-0.0116976025,
-0.0190573651,
-0.0101226084,
0.0604258291,
-0.026434334,
-0.0075598834,
-0.0267014652,
-0.0048301364,
0.031002691,
-0.0147334943,
0.0456880182,
0.0045497911,
0.0293345433,
0.0114558693,
-0.0299690049,
-0.0285875574,
0.0285964198,
0.0154407378,
0.0643959045,
-0.043170929,
0.0333773009,
-0.0168114677,
0.0453704558,
-0.0049548466,
-0.0448705219,
0.0523354188,
-0.0177440476,
0.0648619309,
0.042945493,
-0.05381139,
-0.0188546758,
0.0526801124,
-0.0136162108,
-0.0491035618,
0.0502016619,
0.0316491276,
0.021866424,
-0.0187677518,
0.0392578244,
-0.0219651293,
-0.0455614515,
0.000380989,
0.0323685221,
-0.0324045084,
-0.048484467,
0.0216884501,
-0.0766472369,
-0.0025501212,
0.0158275012,
0.0136578046,
0.0042543211,
0.0543351918,
-0.009726922,
0.0392092839,
-0.0743386373,
0.0274826121,
0.0233065914,
0.0355709493,
0.0679243207,
0.0745042786,
0.0013543239,
0.0569376647,
0.0636459589,
0.0301780049,
-0.0366919152,
-0.0241550282,
0.0418096855,
0.010139103,
0.0236587655,
0.0207138378,
0.0884302706,
0.0301627927,
-0.0674518198,
-0.0131567158,
0.0148237087,
0.0358911268,
0.0599744953,
0.0002024078,
-0.0394229814,
-0.0631566569,
-0.0519061498,
-0.0097671626,
-0.0476826988,
-0.0175186489,
0.0598878413,
-0.0145255905,
0.0078263003,
-0.0065130545,
0.0572327115,
-0.0287476778,
-0.0497921668,
-0.0067858333,
-0.0096894177,
0.0274538174,
-0.004521878,
0.0342000127,
-0.0647141263,
0.0077615622,
-0.018172916,
0.0309166219,
0.0248010661,
0.0334403291,
0.0270200353,
-0.0113398544,
-0.0533650629,
-0.0095546972,
-0.014128156,
-0.0317263864,
0.0235483851,
0.01617538,
0.0548416674,
0.0016472148,
0.0035411036,
0.0491610244,
0.01385298,
-0.0371153057,
-0.0182660818,
-0.0076925829,
-0.032033354,
0.0168038514,
-0.0165449549,
-0.0006931915,
-0.0425478965,
0.0790949911,
0.0198856406,
-0.0543982238,
-0.0290008113,
0.004850436,
2.8e-7,
0.039221447,
0.0622014813,
-0.0045927642,
0.0282391943,
0.007402204,
0.0326789692,
-0.0071202521,
-0.003437466,
0.0438791439,
0.0139552644,
-0.0073484187,
0.0489176512,
0.0243342035,
0.0202979296,
-0.0828583091,
-0.0241596419,
-0.0576095395,
0.0343664475,
-0.0628335476,
0.0357008874,
0.0362971425,
0.0644874945,
-0.0337801799,
0.0082547944,
0.0102972286,
-0.0128129562,
0.0506044738,
-0.0012687517,
0.0158107281,
-0.0135353543,
0.0248157643,
0.0079305954,
-0.002721932,
0.0330901816,
0.0185725596,
-0.0028021967,
-0.0127483951,
0.0305271205,
-0.0301523767,
-0.0322539359,
-0.0147955101,
-0.0041736672,
0.0075496351,
-0.074495472,
0.0683703646,
-0.0852517784,
-0.0300046727,
-0.0055327383,
-0.0237003006,
-0.0189009979,
0.0385589004,
0.0035826587,
-0.0284655206,
-0.0099309459,
0.0192329045,
0.0080027282,
-0.0400459059,
-0.0781772882,
-0.0372705497,
0.0279606488,
-0.0212140009,
-0.0595594496,
-0.0000905763,
-0.0275925808,
0.0131503437,
-0.0410826392,
-0.0075253737,
2.617121082e-34,
0.0347329415,
0.0023249816,
0.0458083265,
0.0447857156,
0.0021221652,
-0.0037192809,
-0.0406222083,
0.0360857062,
0.0390976928,
-0.0902394205,
-0.0083729494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15968v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15968v1 | ReCaLL: Membership Inference via Relative Conditional Log-Likelihoods | 2024-06-23T00:23:13 | 2024-06-23T00:23:13 | Roy Xie, Junlin Wang, Ruomin Huang, Minxing Zhang, Rong Ge, Jian Pei, Neil Zhenqiang Gong, Bhuwan Dhingra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The rapid scaling of large language models (LLMs) has raised concerns about
the transparency and fair use of the pretraining data used for training them.
Detecting such content is challenging due to the scale of the data and limited
exposure of each instance during training. We propose ReCaLL (Relative
Conditional Log-Likelihood), a novel membership inference attack (MIA) to
detect LLMs' pretraining data by leveraging their conditional language modeling
capabilities. ReCaLL examines the relative change in conditional
log-likelihoods when prefixing target data points with non-member context. Our
empirical findings show that conditioning member data on non-member prefixes
induces a larger decrease in log-likelihood compared to non-member data. We
conduct comprehensive experiments and show that ReCaLL achieves
state-of-the-art performance on the WikiMIA dataset, even with random and
synthetic prefixes, and can be further improved using an ensemble approach.
Moreover, we conduct an in-depth analysis of LLMs' behavior with different
membership contexts, providing insights into how LLMs leverage membership
information for effective inference at both the sequence and token level. | [
0.0513365716,
0.0964906365,
-0.0115737161,
0.0427412093,
-0.0398653299,
0.0207801703,
0.0112822512,
0.0150823034,
0.0096004121,
-0.0631047338,
-0.0073757078,
-0.0721882358,
0.0033612237,
-0.0008466106,
0.0347890817,
0.004354775,
0.0626702309,
-0.0372491665,
-0.0105448375,
-0.0274784211,
-0.0034939817,
0.0083232913,
0.0081341276,
0.0276100319,
-0.0051956465,
0.0258161835,
0.0291155074,
-0.0058767474,
0.0058966544,
0.002338819,
0.0159912053,
0.1002372727,
0.0150385192,
0.0837555602,
0.0000017502,
-0.0571814887,
-0.0451214835,
-0.0147973839,
-0.0412013009,
0.0253616925,
-0.0179536827,
-0.0035158847,
0.0152633507,
0.0201955829,
-0.0098315645,
-0.0416680649,
0.0473538898,
0.0108478675,
0.005011363,
0.0853286684,
0.014531849,
-0.0339302756,
-0.0179440919,
-0.0191753302,
0.025887873,
0.0031315912,
0.0474564619,
-0.0497573875,
-0.0296810865,
-0.0278765056,
0.0014561095,
0.0218380485,
-0.0049956171,
0.010106911,
-0.0005836913,
0.0330812186,
-0.0466534048,
-0.0156683493,
0.0235083476,
0.013103486,
0.0268711168,
-0.0322319306,
0.0191736836,
0.0113278078,
0.0057731224,
0.0147674289,
-0.018569611,
0.0351490416,
0.005672934,
0.0151627157,
-0.00061223,
0.02808173,
0.0574779809,
0.0217464976,
-0.0647844076,
0.0695109516,
0.0414490886,
-0.0086024124,
-0.0399011932,
-0.0019144862,
-0.0177152436,
-0.0420492329,
-0.0010214817,
-0.0195432063,
-0.0009708173,
0.0454842225,
-0.0662324652,
-0.0361661352,
0.0289637428,
-0.0280676913,
0.007418687,
0.0075932448,
0.024576949,
0.0368767716,
-0.0174098611,
0.0147720408,
0.0450240225,
0.0036241219,
-0.0227730907,
-0.0182313807,
-0.0341137014,
-0.0150071075,
0.0074673309,
0.0196134783,
0.0172969736,
0.0142838368,
-0.0802534297,
0.007296327,
0.0191154592,
0.0054653091,
0.0045360262,
-0.028864935,
-0.0155694736,
-0.0116734719,
0.0106321527,
-0.0089948531,
-0.011008325,
0.0144842835,
0.0009214025,
-0.0428230166,
-0.0185262896,
0.0209168717,
0.0205361005,
-0.0270923339,
0.0020650367,
0.0449982844,
0.0485501997,
-0.0739858598,
-0.0296201203,
-0.0486561954,
-0.0212138705,
-0.0397385694,
-0.0177358352,
-0.0755457282,
0.0279271342,
0.0257298704,
-0.0018070039,
-0.0217202753,
-0.0010132478,
0.0195563454,
-0.0421529002,
0.0769195408,
-0.01369425,
-0.0069054845,
-0.0153266564,
0.0121438578,
0.0412823744,
0.085903503,
-0.008978256,
0.0118186427,
0.0637499169,
0.001498242,
0.0073395246,
0.0784471929,
0.0390949734,
-0.0010268312,
-0.0087376721,
-0.002428574,
0.0594844073,
-0.0165911149,
-0.0008558707,
0.0324480347,
-0.01557275,
-0.0611520298,
0.0679303333,
0.0645149946,
-0.0403231755,
-0.0305732787,
0.0119567877,
-0.0157699157,
-0.0048979144,
0.0233589709,
-0.0511305816,
-0.0578413159,
-0.0575809702,
-0.0046864441,
0.0517637692,
0.0366775282,
0.0094628241,
-0.0013827924,
-0.0449196473,
-0.036330726,
-0.017671803,
0.0283085406,
0.055017475,
0.0257649999,
0.0096869087,
0.0648314878,
0.073493585,
-0.0536861271,
0.0070029092,
-0.0388242938,
0.0163954683,
-0.0006643308,
0.0482966565,
-0.0403131433,
0.0086385002,
-0.0000428531,
-0.011958003,
0.0074220458,
0.0265400857,
-0.0123900361,
0.0159915481,
-0.0432862937,
-0.0041322079,
0.0308484361,
0.0525495335,
0.0400469303,
0.0656206086,
-0.0214745775,
0.0369020812,
-0.0472894944,
-0.011335656,
0.0450276993,
-0.02214933,
-0.0151303858,
0.0153821949,
0.0031978858,
0.0278806482,
0.0258603878,
-0.009749542,
0.0078201285,
0.020049531,
-0.0338198133,
-0.0176694095,
0.0043568253,
-0.0027265982,
-0.0492240526,
0.0456038713,
0.014267737,
-0.0275316127,
0.0014612812,
-0.0286252704,
-0.043645788,
0.0409173183,
-0.0218363032,
0.0963308662,
-0.0336934999,
0.0132868476,
-0.0020239763,
0.0244394597,
-0.0395479538,
0.0761224106,
-0.0169780329,
0.0383443087,
0.0280032549,
-0.0392867327,
0.0010693808,
-0.0185779054,
-0.0501228869,
0.0018986353,
-0.0259821042,
-0.0175276417,
0.037584167,
-0.0758680478,
-0.0473416969,
0.0079186475,
-0.0654081255,
-0.0029382722,
-0.0312445145,
0.0258146748,
-0.015463748,
0.0393886045,
-0.0403650701,
-0.0146432938,
-0.0028104316,
-0.0241138451,
-0.0079822345,
0.0526553728,
-0.0128424959,
-0.008074793,
-0.0117473956,
-0.0359797776,
-0.0330092125,
-0.0228602495,
0.080941312,
0.0175586268,
-0.0126404129,
-0.0384368785,
-0.0019017316,
-0.0579430312,
0.0037191452,
-0.0190984495,
-0.001970639,
-0.0004005014,
-0.0205191486,
0.040877074,
0.0107566398,
0.0201484598,
-0.016994372,
0.0451755412,
-0.0207362715,
-0.0306940135,
-0.0471763611,
-0.0251197331,
-0.0027532016,
-0.0245813671,
-0.0347236954,
0.0091317603,
0.0657214075,
0.0106711658,
-0.0394350253,
-0.0237512831,
0.0213067699,
-0.0317008719,
-0.0077105677,
-0.0341711119,
-0.0212352481,
-0.0177916531,
0.0219870899,
0.0238140691,
-0.0704015344,
0.0634808391,
-0.0586370565,
0.0308313444,
-0.0032573638,
-0.0306845475,
0.0031224529,
0.0730211884,
0.0685175508,
0.0199776459,
0.059861891,
-0.031121321,
-0.0216350481,
0.0072983396,
0.0411628075,
-0.0417975038,
0.0161763914,
-0.0140529871,
0.0385820195,
-0.0098062549,
0.0067969621,
-0.0572418794,
-0.0431627221,
-0.0152156586,
-0.0134614343,
0.0034253497,
-0.032011535,
-0.0419429466,
0.0487724841,
0.0134610496,
0.0081787091,
-0.0038688611,
0.0287847128,
-0.0083959289,
0.0222419109,
0.0505287386,
-0.0324567631,
0.0203497764,
-0.0708395243,
-0.0404164307,
0.0542721562,
0.0392288007,
0.0055945185,
-0.0033696231,
-0.0566918254,
0.0355828889,
-0.0530800037,
-0.0006678678,
0.0203740094,
0.0303545408,
-0.0565522425,
0.0075827986,
0.1072173193,
0.0397976488,
-0.0818868503,
-0.0028430861,
0.0240183901,
0.0434225239,
0.0163543224,
-0.0004769713,
-0.0858979523,
-0.0263393521,
0.0410478786,
0.0167885032,
-0.0330513045,
-0.0614425838,
0.0042626252,
-0.1114478186,
0.0045914669,
-0.0012954365,
-0.0546227507,
-0.0238022394,
-0.0707952976,
0.0058701434,
-0.0128231561,
0.0095374882,
0.0021725502,
-0.0166478269,
0.0186221618,
0.0063158078,
-0.0469320007,
-0.0505555645,
0.007499692,
-0.0696912631,
0.0712976754,
0.0415771566,
-0.0173132885,
-0.0087190419,
0.0089859115,
0.0168799497,
-0.0565083623,
-0.038456019,
0.0026817315,
0.049290102,
-0.0155128911,
-0.0018752319,
-0.0002682044,
0.0181397852,
-0.0147794662,
-0.02418839,
0.0154232392,
0.0223840456,
-0.003558835,
0.0029829738,
-0.017680794,
-0.0082075214,
0.0119561125,
0.0841108114,
0.0430691503,
0.0048130802,
0.0141190486,
-0.0474992767,
0.0097426381,
0.0266519003,
-0.0352389403,
0.0060511148,
-0.0207941532,
-0.0496006571,
-0.0626964942,
-0.0217908584,
0.0379152037,
0.0463210754,
-0.0139559917,
0.0372748338,
-0.0305073187,
-0.0074833306,
-0.0478641503,
0.0288263559,
-0.0854964629,
0.0311646704,
-0.0451554768,
-0.0023593188,
0.0174540505,
0.024795875,
-0.0110111143,
0.0249800421,
-0.083913967,
-0.0972433239,
0.0006971738,
0.0423271582,
0.0287175812,
0.0399249159,
0.0015349181,
-0.0582715385,
0.0394189991,
0.0466650948,
0.0037648466,
0.0158403255,
0.0161457993,
-0.0396313481,
-0.0093464162,
0.0394704081,
-0.0411698595,
-0.0004085427,
0.0484761186,
0.018971283,
-0.0134401415,
0.024670979,
0.0161400829,
0.0121696079,
0.0430269204,
-0.0503824316,
-0.024927713,
-0.0317436345,
0.0158529598,
-0.02796028,
-0.0280783717,
0.0160998441,
-0.0035807185,
0.0046979603,
0.0165838841,
-0.0057300786,
-0.0190140158,
-0.0321404375,
0.0513126701,
-0.056396924,
0.0204234477,
0.032718569,
-0.01025707,
0.0466132574,
-0.0366118625,
0.0019772451,
0.0050852261,
0.0194065012,
0.0334050767,
-0.0222759936,
-0.0059701269,
-0.0152374301,
-0.0023607528,
-0.0373229347,
-0.0158666559,
-0.0605319329,
0.0048983074,
0.0122437309,
0.0362779126,
0.0367803201,
-0.0605445206,
0.0098953936,
-0.007204094,
-0.0069636088,
-0.0290557891,
-0.0002839798,
0.0112030478,
-0.0434743054,
0.0341451615,
0.0099936845,
-0.0425517745,
0.0787448362,
0.092324473,
0.0133860689,
0.0530725531,
-0.0005516114,
-0.0356379747,
0.0049321926,
-0.0393925272,
0.0368288457,
0.0233733188,
-0.0751440078,
-0.0047144606,
-0.0725584254,
-0.0835339352,
-0.0105155241,
-0.0203947313,
-0.0107570877,
0.0528086424,
0.0034036585,
0.0516989306,
0.0071494239,
0.001034387,
-0.0547105521,
0.0275305174,
0.0248826779,
-0.0211234894,
0.0277030896,
-6.247134605e-33,
-0.0099836225,
-0.0158698075,
-0.022653468,
-0.0000983942,
0.0112166731,
0.0172033031,
-0.0056514461,
0.0038490458,
-0.0113447793,
-0.0351716056,
-0.0210189093,
-0.0067646597,
0.0125829382,
0.047305841,
-0.0096951816,
-0.0157015473,
0.0171513315,
0.0378544591,
-0.0360742956,
0.0131605621,
0.0527878813,
0.0322347842,
0.0763759613,
-0.0159668121,
0.0421263501,
-0.034972582,
0.0152928969,
0.0031933228,
-0.0065442375,
0.0447119139,
-0.0085034603,
0.0398592018,
0.0116741145,
-0.0098818587,
-0.00602237,
-0.008860223,
-0.034142673,
-0.0049156095,
0.0296323299,
0.0002431011,
0.045386564,
-0.0094602844,
0.0304637011,
-0.0206430089,
0.0136040812,
-0.0121751996,
0.0251520891,
-0.0146966474,
-0.044949308,
-0.0285169519,
-0.0578933358,
0.0715703219,
0.0055425842,
0.0468637608,
0.0121362163,
0.0246691331,
0.0538998507,
0.0104839848,
-0.0688502863,
0.0498631373,
0.0303415265,
0.0441629887,
0.034526661,
0.0557735153,
0.0031457972,
0.0546983853,
0.0431777611,
-0.0030411186,
0.0152601562,
0.0057476107,
0.0266732033,
-0.0150378859,
0.0467545129,
0.0525153279,
0.0451104566,
-0.0276513472,
-0.0802622736,
0.0109941037,
0.0268522128,
-0.0274153594,
0.066131562,
0.0039662081,
-0.0490757488,
-0.0223269388,
-0.0248471983,
-0.0153771294,
-0.0301765427,
0.0032771488,
0.0055796523,
0.0140463887,
-0.0589693189,
-0.028313037,
0.0363959111,
-0.0440078266,
-0.061711479,
0.0222983509,
0.0362272635,
-0.021796504,
-0.0274662301,
0.032686539,
-0.03079441,
-0.0159102958,
0.0160284862,
-0.0734500065,
-0.0061285514,
-0.0071463808,
0.0518224202,
0.0185938086,
-0.064517498,
-0.0018304995,
-0.0115288412,
0.0116199236,
-0.0142568592,
-0.0083757918,
0.0732967407,
0.028063897,
0.0238377601,
-0.0025032067,
0.0632594451,
0.0074208365,
-0.0205676034,
0.0018906917,
-0.0327375345,
-0.0023969775,
-0.019625986,
-0.0205494314,
0.0100246379,
0.021687543,
0.041869916,
-0.0403325483,
0.0156376287,
-0.0206138622,
2.536e-7,
0.0628553554,
0.0140959388,
-0.0168158747,
-0.0224587172,
0.0031501588,
0.0217063446,
-0.0128083844,
0.0408381373,
0.0295656063,
-0.0220420267,
0.0001772772,
-0.0065285224,
0.0385711305,
0.0215468593,
-0.0945841298,
0.0328586772,
-0.0596155599,
-0.0147033585,
-0.0851594433,
0.0069835512,
-0.0108079957,
0.1525239646,
0.0363862738,
-0.0143849393,
-0.007967311,
-0.0631721392,
0.0399232954,
-0.0420191213,
-0.0476065725,
0.0100348517,
0.0838805959,
-0.0056736278,
0.0376617275,
0.0170706455,
-0.0564059801,
0.0371399261,
-0.0027484815,
0.0167316739,
0.0248241629,
0.0333180428,
-0.0315224752,
-0.0301408712,
0.0029203182,
-0.0526377782,
0.0823626667,
-0.0251628179,
-0.0277508888,
-0.0591397695,
-0.0138048846,
-0.0201819483,
0.014468872,
0.0006540132,
-0.0281921346,
0.0778289586,
0.0203244071,
-0.0079907281,
-0.0064078453,
-0.0983878747,
-0.0240025222,
-0.0606198721,
-0.049524866,
-0.0209839698,
-0.0056269984,
-0.0212085824,
-0.0136272023,
-0.0234382637,
0.0221567098,
2.74787715e-34,
0.0335227028,
0.0083033117,
-0.0467824452,
0.0398505665,
0.0578505397,
-0.0363817662,
0.0035075927,
0.0581686869,
-0.0132419737,
-0.0957192034,
-0.0023438809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15966v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15966v1 | Evaluating the Effectiveness of the Foundational Models for Q&A Classification in Mental Health care | 2024-06-23T00:11:07 | 2024-06-23T00:11:07 | Hassan Alhuzali, Ashwag Alasmari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) have the potential to transform mental
health support by providing accessible and culturally sensitive resources.
However, despite this potential, their effectiveness in mental health care and
specifically for the Arabic language has not been extensively explored. To
bridge this gap, this study evaluates the effectiveness of foundational models
for classification of Questions and Answers (Q&A) in the domain of mental
health care. We leverage the MentalQA dataset, an Arabic collection featuring
Q&A interactions related to mental health. In this study, we conducted
experiments using four different types of learning approaches: traditional
feature extraction, PLMs as feature extractors, Fine-tuning PLMs and prompting
large language models (GPT-3.5 and GPT-4) in zero-shot and few-shot learning
settings. While traditional feature extractors combined with Support Vector
Machines (SVM) showed promising performance, PLMs exhibited even better results
due to their ability to capture semantic meaning. For example, MARBERT achieved
the highest performance with a Jaccard Score of 0.80 for question
classification and a Jaccard Score of 0.86 for answer classification. We
further conducted an in-depth analysis including examining the effects of
fine-tuning versus non-fine-tuning, the impact of varying data size, and
conducting error analysis. Our analysis demonstrates that fine-tuning proved to
be beneficial for enhancing the performance of PLMs, and the size of the
training data played a crucial role in achieving high performance. We also
explored prompting, where few-shot learning with GPT-3.5 yielded promising
results. There was an improvement of 12% for question and classification and
45% for answer classification. Based on our findings, it can be concluded that
PLMs and prompt-based approaches hold promise for mental health support in
Arabic. | [
0.0834433883,
0.0165484995,
-0.0224381536,
0.0191708039,
-0.0336960927,
0.0541264005,
0.0399811938,
0.0020548005,
0.0404508524,
-0.0722969547,
0.0165906399,
-0.0685102269,
-0.0080353329,
0.0072871749,
-0.0161829274,
-0.0581013896,
0.0281404927,
0.0007205466,
0.0608745739,
0.0127098793,
0.024747774,
0.0307082646,
-0.0377121381,
0.0338859707,
0.0155606121,
0.0046138973,
0.0010245211,
-0.0284621734,
0.0181480497,
-0.0397455283,
0.0121173747,
0.078353405,
-0.0108997272,
-0.0064459392,
0.0000019108,
-0.0823830143,
-0.0196160283,
-0.0105017023,
-0.0125909057,
-0.034400899,
-0.0056288303,
-0.0566746742,
0.0137546053,
0.0369999036,
-0.047376167,
-0.0367772244,
0.0192484669,
0.1008155644,
0.0760259032,
0.0365489051,
-0.0131259244,
-0.0522147007,
0.0146676796,
0.0066303844,
0.0171092264,
-0.0084028104,
0.0504721366,
-0.0078895772,
0.0092798248,
0.0156207085,
0.0027202989,
0.0340036489,
-0.0277747624,
0.0194881279,
-0.0076011517,
-0.0041323029,
-0.0613205247,
-0.0452302843,
0.0043604281,
0.0783883259,
0.0193140451,
0.0408542193,
0.0006722043,
-0.011650457,
0.0081310757,
0.0183447879,
-0.0375498421,
0.0077130836,
-0.0221220758,
0.0063556824,
0.0462063514,
-0.0001427994,
-0.0061204419,
-0.0054250848,
-0.0051976368,
-0.0181185361,
-0.0160302836,
-0.0456527844,
0.0187752731,
0.0119901812,
-0.057942234,
-0.0203245059,
0.0140711609,
0.0370905064,
-0.0031945379,
0.0167536605,
-0.0026783857,
-0.0385640711,
0.0532267541,
-0.0566905327,
0.0119349929,
0.0420148112,
-0.0591486655,
0.023579495,
-0.0107223997,
0.0293980222,
0.0394510441,
0.0475131869,
-0.0269408394,
0.03906627,
-0.0872474462,
-0.0101620797,
-0.0259356275,
0.0623051189,
-0.0219126381,
-0.0039035182,
-0.0694201961,
0.0049894848,
0.0346302725,
0.0020807621,
-0.0169297494,
-0.0361830667,
0.0245054085,
0.0291299783,
-0.0263110362,
0.004691117,
-0.0349261016,
0.0220187828,
-0.0428039618,
-0.0906720906,
0.0248139556,
0.0014975513,
0.013345452,
-0.0091964472,
0.0110023944,
0.0478021652,
-0.0001598782,
-0.0764127672,
-0.0490439124,
-0.0031131944,
-0.0235440992,
-0.0209687427,
-0.014240399,
-0.0215418525,
0.0577460751,
0.0308030918,
-0.0120718749,
0.007481066,
0.045311898,
0.0196288936,
-0.0306780562,
0.059166275,
-0.0108941058,
0.0271833744,
0.0846396834,
0.0223595183,
0.0388859585,
0.0343688987,
0.0045176609,
-0.0289005078,
0.0514765196,
-0.0366120748,
0.016441552,
0.0010057807,
-0.0023983261,
-0.0469411649,
0.0196671635,
0.0449021012,
0.0197062679,
0.0452400148,
-0.0679633766,
0.0439674743,
-0.0008390666,
-0.0009733901,
0.0377324596,
0.0971442088,
-0.0139482571,
0.0418003537,
-0.000093528,
0.0400776491,
0.0291838497,
-0.0230686851,
-0.0151877152,
-0.0255342796,
-0.009966502,
-0.0152595127,
0.0206275582,
0.0184725244,
-0.0450633392,
-0.0680936277,
-0.0476744547,
-0.0258826371,
-0.017727945,
0.029256545,
0.0411427617,
-0.0062930179,
-0.0256357733,
0.0386324562,
0.0267710295,
-0.0108125964,
-0.0255833771,
-0.0819461942,
0.0296120942,
0.0334655121,
0.0027688285,
-0.0704145432,
-0.0147360144,
-0.0548414923,
0.0135033736,
0.0220679585,
0.0263694208,
0.0019147433,
0.0129008424,
-0.0203893464,
-0.0082368199,
0.0300189685,
-0.0051369504,
-0.0413031206,
0.0003310493,
0.0283478312,
-0.020489214,
0.028017709,
-0.0296960417,
0.0667135417,
0.0034906927,
-0.0505859032,
0.0240959208,
0.0082387831,
0.0444059372,
0.0437293202,
-0.0110587934,
-0.0043849759,
0.0196436457,
-0.0533028916,
-0.0420947075,
-0.021128159,
-0.0437084883,
-0.0359528139,
0.0048145358,
0.0427815057,
0.0173520092,
0.0374096036,
-0.0492199808,
-0.0164408777,
0.0229244083,
-0.0303917602,
-0.0177359767,
-0.0382667147,
0.0057068812,
-0.0163741503,
0.0212705247,
-0.0712776184,
0.0343258865,
-0.0268261768,
0.0135703608,
-0.0374840498,
-0.0541051365,
0.0001136084,
0.0098104915,
-0.0217285659,
0.0291744079,
-0.0415803865,
0.0304315053,
-0.0023551115,
0.0294705499,
-0.0247910619,
-0.016921768,
-0.121419549,
0.0101256631,
-0.0245018862,
0.009284378,
0.0074763959,
-0.0019556824,
-0.0413809381,
-0.0272663087,
-0.0712671801,
-0.0152977556,
0.0423478261,
0.0323500037,
0.0420806296,
0.0324448198,
0.0165521484,
-0.0547739677,
-0.0168362111,
-0.0101623386,
0.0395850465,
0.0325051099,
-0.0158609971,
0.0051642573,
-0.0326745473,
-0.052781634,
-0.0276490636,
0.0014185657,
-0.0201340467,
-0.0124620954,
-0.0260565933,
-0.0165040065,
-0.0017933637,
0.02815683,
0.0450291671,
0.0038864925,
0.0471966714,
-0.0112459864,
0.0181333479,
-0.041819334,
-0.0202734396,
-0.0127192689,
-0.0140939262,
0.0091361171,
0.0386738591,
0.0479106866,
-0.0011080613,
-0.044122234,
0.0337781869,
-0.0197521523,
0.0321305469,
-0.0647424459,
0.013230728,
-0.0048013804,
0.0621317998,
-0.0061372458,
-0.0553224348,
0.0375428721,
0.0179144628,
0.0122225154,
-0.0630321577,
-0.0388014056,
-0.0780280009,
0.0069812234,
-0.0169575699,
0.0257654451,
-0.0062479018,
-0.0356794223,
-0.0059265676,
-0.040846087,
-0.0258829705,
-0.0679324567,
0.0138962157,
-0.0261876751,
0.0039771651,
-0.0203043558,
-0.0206686053,
-0.0646771118,
-0.054635644,
-0.0569044687,
-0.0053716986,
-0.0153977536,
0.0439919345,
0.0184936598,
0.021669738,
0.0188256763,
0.0451291427,
-0.0223389752,
-0.0215372797,
0.0017356288,
0.0410181135,
0.0432346575,
0.0095203184,
0.0094879745,
-0.0209412146,
0.0580681004,
0.0399389789,
-0.0395957157,
0.0133070787,
0.0372448713,
0.0138844159,
0.0354539491,
-0.0127798021,
-0.0095780464,
0.0005560647,
0.0258997679,
-0.0391076766,
0.001037508,
0.1169307455,
0.0458902381,
-0.0256863199,
-0.0024546653,
-0.0388290733,
-0.0456951447,
-0.0062214551,
-0.0109788021,
-0.0796297565,
-0.0323750265,
-0.0492168926,
0.0469535962,
-0.0307389293,
-0.0076425527,
0.0426772498,
-0.0582786128,
0.0134749683,
-0.045273304,
-0.0773161724,
-0.0152585078,
-0.0317549519,
0.0096339565,
0.0204993002,
-0.0201782435,
-0.0313607417,
-0.0177882407,
0.009716115,
0.0355466232,
-0.0546310209,
-0.0567404106,
0.0337687731,
-0.0104066906,
0.012587104,
0.0684513897,
0.0057448866,
-0.0170209091,
-0.023320429,
0.0046559148,
-0.0445381701,
-0.0089864992,
-0.0198368877,
0.0551175438,
0.0059135491,
0.0125809629,
-0.0355738439,
0.0125147738,
-0.0615869164,
0.0203122087,
0.0300601088,
0.0722447932,
-0.0222194195,
-0.0108061675,
-0.0097702192,
0.0296277311,
0.0168532897,
0.056466423,
0.0228688624,
-0.0531391613,
-0.032736253,
0.0015316743,
-0.0087686768,
-0.0016395109,
-0.0728567541,
-0.0051776171,
0.0129737705,
0.0256593358,
-0.0494526066,
-0.0447588824,
0.0288421772,
-0.0351166055,
-0.0003155884,
0.0266391076,
0.0101645887,
0.0642816722,
-0.0540581197,
0.0073310682,
0.0223642457,
-0.0051601958,
-0.0602476038,
-0.0105167991,
0.0448148213,
-0.0481575727,
-0.0043210569,
-0.0431212373,
-0.0479452237,
-0.0173348691,
0.0443414748,
0.0348466225,
0.0100135775,
-0.0381714813,
0.0300611984,
-0.0419153795,
0.0370532572,
0.0254737344,
-0.0388388261,
-0.0162005816,
-0.0005543783,
0.0289351232,
-0.0236186981,
0.0422065631,
0.0351111591,
0.0424820036,
0.0334455557,
-0.022491008,
-0.0380317606,
-0.0168072172,
-0.0191927794,
-0.0015356501,
0.0439495929,
0.027369041,
-0.0940366387,
-0.0329913832,
-0.0100166406,
0.0080008414,
0.0203070119,
-0.0282836724,
-0.0174587574,
0.0300416555,
0.0033054601,
-0.0264917966,
-0.0241915304,
-0.0626373366,
0.003130933,
-0.031298168,
0.0227651112,
0.0064321756,
0.0059021893,
-0.0107800635,
0.0066281343,
-0.0112840934,
0.0084031485,
0.0201479644,
0.0088995444,
-0.0115183257,
0.0850457251,
-0.0238485038,
0.002534641,
0.0719944015,
0.0486314707,
-0.0180969164,
-0.1026455387,
-0.0148380669,
0.0171572994,
0.0296956394,
-0.0089327767,
0.0146159818,
0.0403079726,
-0.0050354875,
-0.0359355696,
0.0495691448,
0.0074590254,
-0.0107225534,
0.0616994649,
0.0168577358,
-0.0353374071,
0.006666834,
0.0374809355,
-0.0382099152,
-0.0186754055,
0.0428197719,
-0.0364736989,
-0.0205801185,
0.0325345434,
0.0128522888,
0.0080868639,
-0.0379844084,
0.0482599251,
-0.0536381751,
-0.0375923067,
0.029395204,
-0.0506557487,
-0.0076263538,
-0.0204660818,
0.034335319,
0.0710462928,
0.0223785136,
-0.021010695,
-0.0870151147,
0.030756345,
-0.0602219999,
-0.0295453202,
0.0040720962,
-5.950809377e-33,
0.0054401238,
-0.0064932429,
0.0018952189,
0.0103208628,
0.0183585808,
0.0018059514,
-0.0072491351,
0.0525047481,
-0.049098976,
-0.0113720084,
0.0173418894,
0.0349680297,
0.0016937383,
0.044741828,
0.0325587504,
-0.048484996,
0.0200805105,
-0.0367033519,
-0.0211992692,
0.0284094941,
0.0121203316,
0.0460595489,
0.0559550561,
-0.0782152414,
0.0224668756,
-0.0313131548,
0.0269783568,
0.0495711863,
0.0434535518,
0.0511290282,
-0.0555228963,
0.0752137452,
0.0511451624,
-0.0082553141,
0.0401991867,
0.0500773042,
-0.0559491217,
-0.0199281164,
-0.0030555462,
0.0011843359,
-0.0388051309,
-0.0111812837,
-0.0279270746,
-0.0029572241,
-0.0125060892,
-0.0066918749,
0.0411385149,
-0.0435020253,
0.0079433927,
-0.0245857053,
-0.0456295237,
0.0285179745,
-0.0044257725,
0.005130725,
-0.0048308233,
0.0793413147,
-0.0300315991,
0.0490283594,
-0.0287587345,
-0.0131323859,
0.0483157337,
0.0008708261,
0.0085298261,
-0.0093443664,
-0.0540351383,
0.037601769,
-0.001126353,
0.0089589953,
-0.0023352751,
0.0225973614,
-0.0016724269,
0.000350395,
0.0485483631,
0.0453165621,
0.0276005473,
0.0077902102,
-0.092441164,
0.0013727816,
0.0029228595,
0.0169453975,
0.038022764,
-0.0498425439,
-0.0305860545,
-0.0030003181,
-0.0297869705,
0.0170941297,
-0.0198611654,
-0.0172602534,
0.0269713681,
0.015015034,
-0.0226801597,
0.0290959198,
0.0067316862,
0.0137891062,
0.0250053331,
0.018555332,
-0.0212731902,
0.0034229411,
0.013712314,
0.0015210494,
-0.0676237047,
-0.0073916959,
-0.0022563597,
-0.0456015766,
0.0408331864,
-0.0084853992,
0.0422867052,
-0.0220641699,
-0.0625435039,
-0.0031962136,
0.0410623886,
0.0463738851,
-0.0043451521,
0.0779440254,
-0.0302510299,
0.0245011076,
-0.0069468818,
0.0584471226,
0.0068959035,
-0.009559718,
-0.069969289,
-0.0618342124,
-0.0209374558,
-0.0096231019,
-0.0117128566,
-0.0024041557,
-0.0290155914,
0.0458362587,
-0.0060423729,
-0.0657429025,
0.0071375575,
-0.0213352013,
2.593e-7,
0.0653835163,
0.039533928,
-0.0134927556,
-0.0238172673,
-0.0048522828,
0.0291558262,
0.0501271561,
0.0404712185,
0.0571505167,
0.014778452,
0.0092763873,
0.0420573987,
0.0620068014,
0.0511009209,
-0.0534820296,
-0.0493877418,
-0.0258703176,
-0.0006130974,
-0.0622695163,
0.0136642614,
0.1213485003,
0.1017508432,
-0.0494441316,
-0.0218299441,
-0.0517154224,
-0.0128235556,
0.0454869941,
-0.0213519372,
-0.012181689,
0.0426116586,
0.0371863022,
0.0066037611,
0.0193953309,
0.0123841912,
-0.0307676904,
0.0175101385,
0.0156935919,
0.068812333,
-0.0000659419,
-0.0391760878,
0.0138127757,
0.0663352311,
0.0206446182,
-0.0451123007,
0.0807363763,
-0.0786969066,
-0.0377605446,
0.0035504668,
-0.0071613309,
-0.0553874709,
0.0907549188,
-0.0220293328,
-0.0124507602,
0.0421921983,
0.0441870466,
-0.0172850061,
0.0369605124,
-0.0510373339,
0.0042050127,
0.0390706062,
-0.0223516803,
0.0145159662,
0.0198865626,
-0.0319253728,
-0.0306881256,
0.0007549101,
0.0384214334,
2.230801292e-34,
0.0151968943,
0.0134537881,
0.033819031,
0.0264707245,
0.0124957142,
0.0231388658,
-0.0048912712,
0.0157125201,
0.004603886,
-0.0722350031,
0.0241439231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15963v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15963v1 | Effectiveness of ChatGPT in explaining complex medical reports to patients | 2024-06-23T00:04:07 | 2024-06-23T00:04:07 | Mengxuan Sun, Ehud Reiter, Anne E Kiltie, George Ramsay, Lisa Duncan, Peter Murchie, Rosalind Adam | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, q-bio.OT | Electronic health records contain detailed information about the medical
condition of patients, but they are difficult for patients to understand even
if they have access to them. We explore whether ChatGPT (GPT 4) can help
explain multidisciplinary team (MDT) reports to colorectal and prostate cancer
patients. These reports are written in dense medical language and assume
clinical knowledge, so they are a good test of the ability of ChatGPT to
explain complex medical reports to patients. We asked clinicians and lay people
(not patients) to review explanations and responses of ChatGPT. We also ran
three focus groups (including cancer patients, caregivers, computer scientists,
and clinicians) to discuss output of ChatGPT. Our studies highlighted issues
with inaccurate information, inappropriate language, limited personalization,
AI distrust, and challenges integrating large language models (LLMs) into
clinical workflow. These issues will need to be resolved before LLMs can be
used to explain complex personal medical information to patients. | [
0.0700231344,
0.0408010259,
-0.0205323976,
-0.0228070058,
-0.0216990672,
0.0220737215,
0.0042334856,
0.0145881968,
0.0148654245,
-0.002895287,
0.0379479788,
-0.059621647,
0.0324777626,
0.0497123115,
-0.0140995905,
-0.0844729319,
-0.0003126497,
0.0178930499,
0.0487136431,
0.0241681226,
0.0214486606,
0.0346221626,
-0.0425225832,
0.0743413046,
0.0047463365,
-0.0159871355,
0.0110081434,
0.0044193505,
-0.0267813317,
-0.04605373,
-0.0144956978,
0.028136583,
-0.0276168119,
0.0202612393,
0.0000019593,
-0.0467282459,
-0.0123739103,
0.0449816287,
-0.0561210848,
-0.0046991846,
0.0472324416,
-0.0548679717,
0.0074098408,
0.0158194937,
-0.0102920681,
-0.0047561279,
0.0607417449,
0.0510533974,
0.0552203543,
0.0581195429,
-0.025838308,
0.0196950361,
-0.0031482643,
-0.0118389074,
0.03479366,
-0.0454637073,
0.0077364049,
0.0350643285,
0.0376271233,
0.012262769,
0.0489315279,
0.0311570149,
-0.0074191643,
0.0098820589,
-0.0191422403,
0.0600553043,
-0.0011350961,
-0.0203845743,
0.0056675943,
0.0359339789,
0.031936653,
0.0081915976,
0.0171364956,
0.0100442572,
-0.0030728155,
-0.0031774209,
-0.0567220375,
0.0065946262,
-0.044627998,
-0.0274687093,
-0.0350414626,
0.00298448,
0.0193056203,
-0.0057658199,
-0.009592073,
-0.0139076058,
-0.0068057594,
-0.0134567823,
-0.0154531077,
-0.0145070348,
0.0284974016,
-0.048593495,
0.0554159172,
0.0330294967,
-0.0505944379,
0.0310073942,
0.0165188052,
0.0008982149,
0.0655192286,
-0.0612538904,
-0.0161501784,
0.0238608792,
0.0072883307,
0.0281254631,
0.034898445,
0.0082998574,
-0.0002583998,
0.0170772709,
-0.0250551812,
-0.0025031739,
-0.0834022015,
-0.0429269262,
-0.0441861786,
0.0012334957,
-0.0164641831,
-0.0025023746,
-0.0541376472,
-0.0078910692,
-0.0040489268,
0.0442292131,
0.0402412042,
0.0172845908,
-0.0510326885,
-0.0150648309,
-0.0201793425,
0.0329714976,
-0.028550053,
0.0090310927,
0.0128373224,
-0.057607241,
0.0320463516,
0.0136157712,
-0.0045992215,
0.0214603245,
-0.0179070532,
0.049242381,
-0.0006118267,
0.0240002684,
-0.0099822255,
-0.0914117321,
-0.0385566019,
-0.0263773352,
-0.0076390398,
-0.0251107197,
0.0444345213,
0.0391094945,
0.0052246121,
-0.0553606488,
0.0057030837,
0.0128665902,
-0.0622525103,
0.0894450247,
-0.0508228242,
0.0290107224,
0.0368529484,
0.0551092662,
0.0020659263,
0.0004252283,
0.0064643323,
-0.0075759068,
0.000016289,
-0.0325780734,
0.0310476627,
0.0003208859,
0.0004851619,
-0.0205063839,
0.0213289838,
0.0255659651,
-0.0384403728,
0.0629410893,
-0.0457850695,
0.0750197545,
0.0051867086,
0.0274621062,
0.0514701195,
0.0526328087,
0.0659414828,
0.0637284219,
-0.0073640286,
-0.0062479968,
-0.0028952244,
-0.000627999,
-0.0136286682,
0.0240297019,
0.005992956,
-0.009177288,
-0.0157855023,
-0.015053832,
-0.0420987085,
-0.0443301648,
-0.0497064106,
-0.0084265517,
0.0030052497,
-0.0240410659,
0.0207363702,
-0.0264754388,
-0.0208031386,
0.030972546,
0.0367696993,
-0.0403506644,
-0.0416188426,
-0.0616852306,
-0.0055846917,
0.1169358343,
0.0512354486,
-0.0317205563,
-0.0366417132,
-0.0208774712,
0.0182503164,
-0.0046797153,
0.0309798773,
-0.0023994644,
-0.0357444584,
-0.0318699814,
-0.0217380375,
0.0404979102,
0.0151002258,
-0.0169550553,
0.0039642286,
0.0221595578,
-0.007442785,
-0.0373217463,
-0.0416527279,
0.0212282967,
-0.0357989408,
-0.0176334027,
-0.020049585,
-0.0076644057,
0.0304005928,
0.0580280349,
-0.0032187051,
0.0427263975,
-0.0056373551,
0.0081989402,
-0.0432346538,
0.0556242093,
-0.0199301578,
0.0269137323,
-0.0026148462,
-0.0303879045,
-0.0078127673,
-0.0601672083,
-0.0225567259,
-0.0118622826,
-0.039122235,
-0.0645622313,
0.0292238407,
0.0014489166,
-0.0033735007,
0.0560273826,
-0.0007286718,
-0.0135281077,
-0.0029207184,
-0.0231619384,
-0.0317024514,
-0.0187989287,
-0.0476718023,
0.0085717663,
-0.0287656635,
0.023823671,
0.0467532575,
0.0209161006,
0.0214759484,
-0.0137703996,
0.0091755288,
-0.0315391347,
-0.0200448688,
-0.1290914565,
-0.033923775,
-0.0057102684,
0.0082667815,
0.0489747897,
0.0227724034,
-0.0068456177,
-0.02865077,
-0.0623440668,
-0.0171983708,
0.0131721804,
0.0297109559,
0.0263345651,
0.0493703932,
0.0178777948,
-0.0326939635,
-0.0157064237,
-0.0440506637,
0.0141461706,
0.0625503659,
-0.0611689799,
-0.0465020351,
-0.0198190901,
-0.0371876024,
-0.0365167335,
0.0032448685,
-0.0338922106,
0.0311988275,
-0.0240305737,
-0.0074733589,
0.0325833559,
-0.0109020369,
0.0808654502,
0.0186715554,
-0.0042027002,
-0.0013116332,
-0.0153107364,
-0.0092383102,
-0.0287015494,
0.020649964,
-0.096443072,
0.0236678272,
0.0576617643,
0.02413035,
0.0333842225,
-0.0520797931,
0.0012538237,
-0.0373248197,
0.0315104984,
-0.0352324657,
-0.016090462,
-0.0081540253,
0.0276592355,
-0.0054386458,
-0.0080532618,
0.082526356,
-0.035311684,
0.005740779,
-0.0786203146,
-0.0254921559,
-0.025666263,
0.0630831569,
-0.0397166498,
0.0372825526,
0.024451213,
-0.0235820636,
0.0103392852,
-0.0314032473,
0.0053450293,
-0.0331601426,
0.0455481224,
-0.054959394,
0.0210945327,
0.0202316586,
0.0157287214,
-0.0159234516,
-0.0248316787,
-0.0325363465,
0.0019615958,
0.0406530984,
-0.0335420743,
-0.0531446859,
0.0270861778,
0.0312926956,
0.0594835952,
0.0299786925,
-0.0372914895,
0.0124784373,
-0.0427797809,
0.0069496362,
0.0095299715,
-0.0073746536,
-0.0326544084,
0.0396457687,
0.0579190291,
0.005419232,
-0.0044252332,
0.0115776295,
-0.0513856485,
-0.0256374907,
-0.0234162975,
-0.0088136727,
0.0163250323,
0.0384604745,
-0.0306127407,
0.0109967003,
0.1038043946,
0.0332675278,
-0.0642091706,
0.0261254515,
-0.0149042225,
-0.0349425897,
-0.0312452018,
0.0152350916,
-0.0556766354,
-0.0131739695,
-0.0191260278,
0.0220033489,
-0.0059704278,
-0.0182820261,
-0.0204424169,
0.0026582987,
0.0211097375,
0.0048540989,
-0.0243095718,
-0.0464300103,
-0.0242450777,
-0.0046992912,
0.0100561799,
0.0139916176,
-0.0197329912,
-0.0014081948,
0.0061636325,
-0.002635764,
-0.1138502583,
-0.0592229702,
0.0339202359,
0.0017645193,
0.0303453561,
0.0822242275,
0.0515729673,
-0.0260228533,
-0.0052376809,
-0.0048513282,
0.0596876629,
0.0339064039,
0.0065245917,
0.092887111,
0.0200158004,
0.0223096907,
-0.0661354363,
0.0276090279,
-0.0294814315,
0.0139051471,
0.0303478092,
0.0518041849,
-0.060149122,
-0.0213393923,
-0.0156974718,
0.0285073873,
0.0368067808,
0.0535913408,
0.0100133661,
0.0007430769,
-0.0219166707,
-0.0099190939,
0.0540585332,
0.0511910506,
-0.0126650315,
0.0446549952,
-0.005821208,
-0.0111880759,
-0.0519318171,
-0.05338943,
0.0574816354,
-0.0162483938,
0.0096837198,
0.0280655604,
0.0117072128,
0.0080733011,
-0.0247866903,
0.0438271314,
0.0386325493,
0.0307217874,
-0.016745938,
-0.0555587485,
0.013724979,
-0.0089439964,
0.0238275379,
0.0029784588,
-0.0020247218,
0.019917706,
-0.0149637358,
0.0112145608,
0.0327805839,
-0.0327438042,
-0.0073852395,
-0.0681109354,
-0.0235770997,
0.039106667,
-0.0511290319,
-0.0338813215,
-0.0255460348,
0.0481080823,
0.0144150881,
0.0065459483,
-0.0010931846,
-0.0074700154,
-0.020616943,
0.011549145,
-0.0513937026,
-0.0316724144,
0.0425044596,
0.0395056196,
0.0238430649,
0.0112846559,
-0.0312385894,
-0.0091775795,
0.0070717474,
-0.0575052984,
0.0140206842,
-0.0181046184,
-0.0202834923,
0.0042625959,
-0.0295495708,
0.0049271234,
-0.0068150931,
-0.0871378407,
-0.0562894009,
-0.0512849316,
0.0484808087,
0.0092194146,
-0.004499014,
0.0376621671,
-0.0303024668,
-0.0017953499,
-0.0144550754,
-0.0156149203,
-0.0028168499,
0.0034993649,
0.0662819222,
-0.0091955094,
0.0125708589,
0.0044166045,
0.0442176424,
-0.041651167,
-0.0991849527,
0.0107132662,
0.0227562059,
0.010789766,
0.0060579604,
0.0403431207,
-0.0767083168,
0.0095793223,
-0.0234117582,
0.022045983,
0.0169082303,
0.0371772796,
0.0261862744,
-0.0025922747,
-0.0017796705,
-0.0565350689,
0.0871719643,
-0.0248711575,
0.0273995139,
-0.0320327394,
-0.0699715093,
-0.0425255187,
-0.0182169471,
0.0204513203,
0.0125666792,
-0.0541456081,
-0.0047284169,
-0.0761007294,
-0.0255405009,
-0.0132893911,
-0.0222516358,
-0.0277358834,
-0.0593704507,
0.0548105799,
0.0815136582,
-0.0151587836,
-0.0275863558,
-0.0394008085,
0.0547466315,
-0.031558793,
-0.0059306659,
0.0228479914,
-5.606313125e-33,
0.0098278672,
-0.0710088909,
0.0170179158,
-0.0084028896,
0.0392038748,
0.0314394571,
-0.0566979572,
0.0185033437,
0.0220201425,
0.0591070652,
-0.0282787252,
0.0281196162,
0.0028249323,
0.0111560244,
-0.0034474703,
-0.0105819255,
0.076860711,
0.0185064878,
-0.0009330962,
0.0356457457,
-0.0087894425,
0.0245516226,
0.002336801,
-0.120899491,
0.0622320622,
0.0118765524,
-0.009126734,
0.0003836235,
-0.0117420526,
0.0536920838,
-0.0178840961,
0.0278210733,
0.0562241301,
0.0136002889,
-0.0202357452,
0.031040974,
-0.0390131027,
-0.0234159436,
0.0167987216,
-0.0208421722,
-0.0279093683,
-0.012397876,
0.0431862734,
-0.0374412909,
-0.0087660914,
-0.0051122671,
0.0199558493,
-0.0179300755,
-0.0229916107,
-0.0052186679,
-0.0180267692,
0.0480541587,
-0.0064301039,
0.0063454481,
-0.0095434217,
0.0259827748,
-0.0530943871,
-0.0047306893,
-0.0189277176,
-0.0038495429,
0.025919199,
0.0141581446,
0.0191050302,
-0.0437247343,
-0.0318475403,
0.0208740346,
0.0266737808,
0.014457372,
-0.0932434201,
0.0170558002,
-0.0583703294,
0.023410162,
0.050732594,
0.0267704353,
-0.0350113511,
-0.0184976105,
-0.0511398986,
0.048227638,
-0.0651331395,
0.0414932147,
0.04277483,
0.0074126236,
-0.0832224563,
-0.0110264067,
-0.0159683544,
0.0204714928,
-0.0170784704,
-0.0593744926,
0.0046207514,
-0.0182285644,
0.0096911192,
0.0022193389,
-0.0373747572,
-0.0106113972,
0.0208499376,
-0.027309902,
0.0368198492,
-0.0008227855,
-0.0294391681,
-0.0124943461,
-0.0388902016,
0.0299108028,
-0.0028870525,
0.0220359415,
0.0402053073,
0.0301584061,
0.038457714,
-0.0446837842,
-0.0444823168,
-0.0062552197,
0.0140322251,
0.0264584478,
-0.0296503063,
-0.0286398884,
0.0240907315,
0.0202953424,
-0.0196518879,
0.0568904988,
0.0088782106,
-0.0041145128,
-0.0378296338,
-0.0522137508,
-0.035601221,
-0.0154419737,
-0.0543290079,
-0.0015013886,
-0.0482628718,
-0.0003566668,
0.0705415756,
-0.0181161221,
-0.0007482405,
-0.0199379399,
2.666e-7,
0.0948285833,
0.0725607052,
0.0373397954,
-0.006121194,
0.0572107695,
0.0025974542,
0.015256092,
-0.0074688336,
-0.0223961603,
-0.0129890172,
0.068137072,
0.026739873,
0.036783684,
0.0589555465,
-0.0066711009,
-0.0493887179,
-0.0769701228,
-0.0330439471,
-0.0621414855,
0.0169632696,
0.1103144884,
0.0299040414,
-0.033618629,
-0.0147861997,
0.0051931087,
-0.0021376337,
0.0325181819,
-0.0502782501,
0.0238143355,
0.0248263013,
0.0382668227,
-0.0314458683,
0.0317119956,
0.0658799633,
-0.0207654051,
-0.0772866383,
-0.0005474958,
0.1046455353,
-0.0645264462,
0.0257590991,
0.0288282037,
-0.0239611957,
0.0245601553,
-0.0643512756,
0.0316751562,
-0.0512215197,
-0.0596281998,
0.020198945,
0.0260437317,
-0.045875933,
0.0638556629,
-0.0135693057,
-0.0448111892,
0.036873281,
0.0067247469,
0.0257591084,
-0.0100037474,
-0.0422017686,
0.0170259625,
0.0229185652,
-0.0385642909,
-0.0212721732,
0.0387264229,
-0.041494932,
-0.0008731399,
-0.0421109311,
0.0274739992,
2.206214175e-34,
0.0282182936,
0.0494129211,
0.0099060312,
-0.0037212577,
0.0538135134,
0.0341702886,
0.0454725847,
0.0219284166,
0.0386768617,
-0.0369125903,
-0.0177784264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17806v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17806v1 | MOSSBench: Is Your Multimodal Language Model Oversensitive to Safe Queries? | 2024-06-22T23:26:07 | 2024-06-22T23:26:07 | Xirui Li, Hengguang Zhou, Ruochen Wang, Tianyi Zhou, Minhao Cheng, Cho-Jui Hsieh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.CV, cs.LG | Humans are prone to cognitive distortions -- biased thinking patterns that
lead to exaggerated responses to specific stimuli, albeit in very different
contexts. This paper demonstrates that advanced Multimodal Large Language
Models (MLLMs) exhibit similar tendencies. While these models are designed to
respond queries under safety mechanism, they sometimes reject harmless queries
in the presence of certain visual stimuli, disregarding the benign nature of
their contexts. As the initial step in investigating this behavior, we identify
three types of stimuli that trigger the oversensitivity of existing MLLMs:
Exaggerated Risk, Negated Harm, and Counterintuitive Interpretation. To
systematically evaluate MLLMs' oversensitivity to these stimuli, we propose the
Multimodal OverSenSitivity Benchmark (MOSSBench). This toolkit consists of 300
manually collected benign multimodal queries, cross-verified by third-party
reviewers (AMT). Empirical studies using MOSSBench on 20 MLLMs reveal several
insights: (1). Oversensitivity is prevalent among SOTA MLLMs, with refusal
rates reaching up to 76% for harmless queries. (2). Safer models are more
oversensitive: increasing safety may inadvertently raise caution and
conservatism in the model's responses. (3). Different types of stimuli tend to
cause errors at specific stages -- perception, intent reasoning, and safety
judgement -- in the response process of MLLMs. These findings highlight the
need for refined safety mechanisms that balance caution with contextually
appropriate responses, improving the reliability of MLLMs in real-world
applications. We make our project available at
https://turningpoint-ai.github.io/MOSSBench/. | [
0.0407109745,
0.0577003807,
-0.0187809095,
0.0143148284,
-0.0176012218,
0.0090869116,
0.0050181909,
0.0153614832,
0.0264611486,
-0.0600696281,
-0.0683280602,
-0.0501192324,
-0.005231651,
0.0172433723,
0.0483436808,
-0.0287102796,
0.0585247613,
-0.0594857931,
0.0222008191,
-0.0100248875,
0.0312975124,
0.0135957832,
-0.0180473514,
0.057110671,
-0.0344004966,
-0.0361162312,
0.0154072409,
0.0426980481,
-0.0047587254,
-0.0513940454,
0.0063282815,
0.0489017405,
0.027165385,
0.0187455919,
0.0000021776,
-0.0625517964,
0.0101029947,
-0.012681501,
0.029331306,
-0.0096881967,
0.0672740191,
-0.0460037068,
0.0168983005,
0.0296232551,
-0.0368720405,
-0.006333319,
0.0492149107,
0.0431570187,
0.0307143312,
0.0398301966,
-0.0078326752,
0.0069103288,
0.0191721953,
0.0292157307,
0.0176964458,
-0.0582724586,
0.0283166673,
-0.0089272112,
-0.0005032415,
-0.013611448,
-0.0581381954,
0.0401208922,
-0.0115496954,
-0.0051326188,
-0.0394088887,
0.0110606486,
-0.019452678,
-0.079660289,
-0.015019658,
0.0835103616,
-0.0210639741,
0.0069148736,
-0.0060431533,
-0.0138262296,
-0.0123805786,
0.0357414596,
-0.0437158458,
0.0387192406,
-0.0072988137,
-0.015363805,
-0.0420832857,
0.0111556929,
0.0420714691,
0.036054071,
0.0336694345,
0.0472132415,
0.0110712489,
-0.0177316088,
0.0660926774,
-0.0330067202,
0.0044847177,
-0.0289939661,
-0.0007495509,
-0.0090120202,
-0.0491687767,
0.0115642492,
-0.0548994802,
-0.0314192437,
0.0648671091,
-0.0698493198,
0.0498495288,
0.0365189239,
-0.0359032452,
0.0300748628,
0.017742021,
0.0019741557,
-0.0412878096,
0.0406058878,
-0.0128634712,
0.0147527847,
0.0113177821,
-0.008479733,
-0.0038845688,
-0.0266990773,
-0.0295408629,
-0.0112098083,
-0.0266517624,
0.0211251918,
-0.0402882025,
-0.0218713507,
-0.0448816158,
0.0149200363,
-0.0096517392,
-0.0018626039,
-0.0318245925,
0.0145864077,
-0.0194613412,
0.0178853888,
-0.0120173004,
-0.078273192,
0.0076802135,
0.036608763,
-0.0100653134,
-0.0640216395,
-0.0005645223,
0.1089346856,
0.0020890292,
-0.0269203484,
-0.0418263935,
-0.0511058643,
-0.0293094888,
-0.0209447183,
0.0308407582,
-0.0208967384,
0.0275935531,
0.0093675265,
-0.0187505558,
-0.0484462567,
0.0108241988,
0.0270190258,
-0.0573540851,
0.0818366185,
0.0014355275,
0.0114968922,
-0.0003608968,
0.0449503735,
-0.0563200265,
0.086695008,
0.0385135859,
0.0372954011,
0.061269369,
0.0073571098,
0.0449386202,
0.0469461419,
-0.001942059,
0.0226291474,
-0.0557612814,
0.0192990433,
-0.0138648674,
0.0118153458,
0.0323999263,
0.0804576427,
-0.022318529,
-0.0304490719,
0.103205502,
0.0248554964,
-0.0418096855,
-0.0229735952,
0.0013228303,
-0.0008413798,
-0.0172907505,
0.0011000753,
-0.0893475637,
0.0460821353,
-0.0630341992,
-0.0193941388,
0.0236105546,
0.0453732461,
-0.0081463587,
-0.0003574906,
-0.0315586962,
-0.0078293523,
0.0438428,
0.0262025371,
-0.0046437462,
-0.0218606647,
-0.039804019,
-0.0104294661,
0.0199651271,
-0.0507753119,
-0.0004539648,
-0.0407117829,
-0.0128855463,
0.0589387305,
0.0553618893,
-0.0013219126,
-0.0188733526,
-0.0318626687,
-0.0040351804,
0.0094222073,
0.0491776206,
0.0087976409,
0.0501854233,
-0.0477006771,
-0.0460502766,
0.0129987178,
-0.0016503942,
-0.0305779539,
-0.0056326832,
0.0176381581,
-0.0074438006,
-0.0222388729,
-0.0018581841,
0.0371557809,
0.0198169965,
-0.0310129747,
-0.0636599511,
0.0108033847,
0.0085665565,
-0.0231280066,
-0.0003585388,
0.0156117184,
0.021266669,
0.0041759843,
0.0048477785,
0.0143405953,
-0.0393253788,
0.0131706735,
0.0047017047,
-0.0371383429,
-0.021096684,
0.0264616851,
-0.0187104754,
-0.0030126045,
0.0037766702,
-0.019871477,
-0.0016736737,
-0.0289972425,
-0.0149438642,
-0.0040614754,
0.0205502827,
-0.0356245935,
0.0460002758,
-0.026668705,
-0.0243706685,
-0.0111342873,
-0.0418911502,
-0.0080500394,
-0.0330177546,
-0.0701193586,
0.0251589231,
-0.0007529244,
0.045922827,
0.0150113059,
0.0031940786,
-0.0554441325,
0.0255773328,
-0.079474397,
-0.0469964966,
-0.0225916989,
-0.0211337749,
0.0018867076,
-0.0005322354,
-0.0317146145,
-0.0043462794,
0.0168387741,
0.0241406374,
-0.0176077913,
0.0900354385,
-0.0110478243,
-0.0146271922,
-0.0001714925,
-0.0302417465,
-0.0249213614,
-0.0354046486,
0.0696886778,
-0.0090561332,
-0.0324842334,
-0.0091367327,
0.014816083,
-0.0440713279,
0.0485618599,
-0.0061874869,
-0.0442707017,
0.0263473429,
-0.0177467689,
0.0168538745,
0.0878591463,
0.0401990153,
-0.0198819563,
0.0901837349,
-0.0020496445,
-0.0474839471,
0.0183283854,
-0.0036499123,
-0.045551762,
0.0137638524,
-0.0447750427,
-0.0071964264,
0.0298013482,
0.0118474523,
-0.004931754,
-0.0497248732,
0.0154129295,
-0.0492938273,
-0.092075564,
-0.0360269286,
-0.0493101589,
-0.0185181145,
0.0760202631,
0.0005825085,
-0.0533331148,
0.0713757202,
0.0306477547,
0.0025373125,
0.0056152106,
0.0145936441,
0.0206200089,
0.0841004327,
0.0109986616,
0.0493956506,
0.048235517,
0.0016568647,
-0.0676774085,
-0.0434626527,
0.0152323442,
-0.0299967267,
0.0631175414,
-0.0534510165,
0.0049863141,
-0.0106780976,
-0.048280634,
-0.0427069217,
-0.0649811104,
-0.0163239967,
-0.0325562097,
-0.0162896719,
0.006323508,
-0.0061185248,
0.0213281885,
0.0332165472,
-0.0098393559,
-0.0140324412,
-0.0208406392,
-0.0119807869,
-0.0234559067,
0.0778369531,
-0.0061624413,
0.0401454009,
-0.0403562263,
0.0040127295,
0.0798054487,
0.0330426171,
-0.0200266447,
-0.032154642,
0.036191728,
0.0411459245,
0.030358199,
-0.0256407298,
0.0602581836,
0.056195166,
-0.0321944393,
0.0305879079,
0.0451396927,
-0.0048940848,
-0.0405348539,
0.0249088928,
-0.0251476467,
0.0429551043,
0.0133520095,
-0.0173036475,
-0.0639292821,
-0.0411737487,
0.0089819226,
0.0273533948,
-0.0175175406,
-0.049911093,
0.0268613826,
-0.0682319254,
0.0376827419,
-0.0141260447,
-0.0313923061,
-0.0252420343,
-0.0196070988,
0.006942133,
-0.0171148758,
0.0627635717,
0.0473732054,
-0.0205507763,
-0.0176369641,
-0.0015930185,
0.0256524477,
-0.0529815927,
0.0329579003,
-0.0512574948,
0.0186385605,
0.0296076741,
0.0046374043,
-0.02375816,
-0.0386458859,
0.0507840216,
0.012371893,
0.024579484,
-0.0061186445,
0.0415971354,
-0.0213964581,
0.0072733415,
-0.023619324,
0.0024213295,
-0.002806206,
-0.0201399904,
-0.0144997044,
0.0579540618,
-0.0375876948,
-0.0129150311,
-0.0713647082,
0.0431602523,
0.0107188839,
0.0603279136,
0.022411935,
-0.0653640702,
-0.0185994077,
-0.0122070322,
0.0202694777,
-0.0221869089,
-0.0252617542,
0.0210474674,
0.0173883066,
-0.0227776822,
-0.0437840298,
-0.0269659385,
-0.0324015431,
0.0107559487,
0.0183482263,
-0.0147961294,
-0.0179059729,
0.0238019526,
-0.0074781179,
0.0730119497,
-0.0014890193,
0.0297997054,
-0.0136422403,
0.0860810801,
-0.0046187337,
-0.0162688438,
-0.0068545709,
0.0454563424,
-0.0330051631,
-0.074182108,
0.0053079333,
0.0630275682,
0.0295905285,
-0.0247709323,
-0.0042451504,
-0.0836057216,
0.0189350881,
0.0461916141,
-0.0403069481,
0.0235590227,
0.053373877,
-0.0241399202,
0.0136960568,
0.0361804552,
-0.0473810844,
-0.0159171168,
0.0109637789,
0.0509041212,
-0.0132721169,
-0.0398238115,
0.0123350443,
0.0434930176,
0.0414986424,
-0.0379619785,
0.0221403688,
0.0016461337,
-0.0074316096,
0.0198258106,
-0.0110290824,
-0.0261108205,
0.0218702033,
0.015618518,
0.0033521643,
-0.017092403,
-0.0151294377,
-0.0109429052,
0.0252435524,
-0.0286313351,
0.0464165397,
0.0153796161,
-0.0223157406,
0.0320042223,
0.0154354302,
-0.0212096628,
0.0402942598,
-0.026875874,
0.0018863926,
-0.002408142,
0.0676290169,
0.0100742923,
-0.0185996536,
-0.0235988814,
0.0394060537,
-0.0356434882,
-0.0513184257,
0.0145020485,
0.0171678066,
0.0454743654,
-0.0078905737,
0.0482359678,
-0.012082004,
0.000652171,
-0.0405820236,
0.0108966799,
0.0011196143,
-0.0444991998,
0.0640015081,
0.0257293861,
0.0010774867,
-0.0037630629,
0.0762236342,
-0.0387337916,
0.050634034,
0.0064496398,
-0.03006557,
-0.007883138,
-0.0256241634,
0.0819344968,
0.0381887443,
-0.0506433882,
-0.0095755076,
-0.1020241156,
-0.0852547139,
-0.0046245297,
0.001697281,
0.015163918,
-0.0227060281,
0.0251936466,
0.0550581701,
0.0307910834,
-0.0275447462,
-0.0229097512,
-0.0076585286,
-0.0082541527,
0.0128782541,
-0.0382627994,
-6.670444815e-33,
0.0326658115,
-0.0044908151,
-0.0045662974,
-0.0438131541,
-0.0277312845,
-0.002130704,
0.002571282,
0.0324844569,
-0.0456287749,
-0.0038944653,
-0.02104575,
0.0027936511,
-0.0042985603,
0.0014150734,
0.0115880035,
-0.0511201024,
-0.0265166927,
-0.0013810283,
-0.034374509,
-0.0222789627,
0.0297432113,
0.0088748159,
0.0209562425,
-0.0985092744,
0.0353168994,
0.0258629993,
-0.0407560021,
-0.0034167978,
-0.0482173748,
0.0696804002,
-0.0060779103,
0.0880608782,
0.0134416483,
0.0120197693,
-0.0008254866,
0.0485547148,
-0.000371374,
-0.014244277,
0.0331621245,
0.0036615117,
-0.0414095968,
-0.0139921354,
0.0652921349,
-0.027299542,
-0.04786947,
-0.0162629336,
0.0038703398,
-0.0152313774,
-0.0207853336,
-0.017777212,
-0.0295676757,
0.0082934741,
0.0101483017,
-0.0130519364,
0.005916209,
0.0910981819,
0.0253148768,
0.0542663895,
-0.055280894,
0.0167701319,
-0.025064107,
-0.0169870742,
0.0737871379,
0.0234719254,
0.003139816,
0.0688808858,
0.0038660602,
0.0144965826,
-0.0002755359,
-0.0417574458,
0.0332637951,
0.0363515131,
0.0016606643,
0.0814850852,
0.0240675174,
-0.0363523141,
-0.0555991419,
-0.0054728254,
-0.0303810537,
0.0735483989,
0.0797549114,
0.0234475583,
-0.0659436658,
-0.028235225,
-0.0518421307,
0.0268737208,
-0.0626566261,
0.0081884461,
0.0465103313,
-0.0033621825,
-0.0059786756,
0.0107818525,
0.0250981878,
-0.0398145132,
-0.0032681054,
-0.0075355372,
0.0169338379,
-0.0089217136,
0.0107641658,
0.0591491424,
-0.000847766,
0.0012207509,
0.0108804768,
-0.0431975089,
0.0194502138,
0.0109961424,
0.0119787324,
0.0418874659,
-0.0459620915,
-0.023920754,
-0.015418848,
0.0258373767,
0.021670118,
-0.0049349442,
0.0583255254,
-0.0015258074,
-0.0104722548,
-0.0047184653,
0.0679078549,
0.0095655564,
-0.0454034507,
-0.0469466485,
-0.0367443487,
0.0297710188,
-0.0109560816,
-0.002770466,
-0.0072240564,
-0.0337882712,
0.0464615859,
-0.0928526521,
-0.0245449338,
0.0283463001,
2.901e-7,
0.031439241,
0.061426416,
-0.0281381458,
0.0400628448,
0.0121916765,
0.083696492,
-0.0129969828,
0.0702938288,
0.0198731981,
-0.0296598356,
0.0015950083,
0.0084069436,
0.0260594562,
0.0483973771,
-0.0092103081,
-0.0177026484,
-0.0327328369,
0.0007904894,
-0.0305579342,
-0.0020307265,
0.0744995996,
0.038478706,
-0.0302502867,
-0.0432385243,
0.0085139628,
-0.0542823374,
0.047610715,
-0.0568249151,
0.0062998189,
-0.0120027885,
0.0425692908,
0.0069536911,
0.0239102151,
0.0686897263,
-0.0046710623,
-0.0458039008,
0.0145172505,
0.0361748375,
-0.0298815034,
-0.043279916,
0.0105292574,
-0.0388113335,
-0.0275665503,
-0.0937595069,
0.0725649074,
-0.0118638622,
-0.0158229731,
0.0036615562,
-0.0046551735,
-0.009998085,
0.0480054989,
-0.0481761545,
-0.0536799915,
-0.0074032606,
0.0316402502,
0.0145175885,
-0.0221573748,
-0.0586872622,
-0.0103370696,
-0.0004940227,
0.0074207503,
-0.0771605894,
-0.0220415182,
0.0341198035,
0.0008901114,
-0.0784857348,
-0.0365608707,
2.62124197e-34,
0.0501335934,
-0.0305771958,
0.0111124609,
-0.0344373733,
0.03975977,
0.0046047405,
-0.0245736726,
0.0095912972,
0.0127087794,
-0.0419500172,
-0.0352441445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17805v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17805v1 | Can LLMs Generate Visualizations with Dataless Prompts? | 2024-06-22T22:59:09 | 2024-06-22T22:59:09 | Darius Coelho, Harshit Barot, Naitik Rathod, Klaus Mueller | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Recent advancements in large language models have revolutionized information
access, as these models harness data available on the web to address complex
queries, becoming the preferred information source for many users. In certain
cases, queries are about publicly available data, which can be effectively
answered with data visualizations. In this paper, we investigate the ability of
large language models to provide accurate data and relevant visualizations in
response to such queries. Specifically, we investigate the ability of GPT-3 and
GPT-4 to generate visualizations with dataless prompts, where no data
accompanies the query. We evaluate the results of the models by comparing them
to visualization cheat sheets created by visualization experts. | [
-0.028535638,
0.0406111404,
-0.0354160257,
0.0492514074,
-0.027485691,
0.0023278126,
-0.0236046221,
0.0491798185,
0.0124269882,
0.0250859167,
-0.0088934433,
0.0010280174,
-0.002724512,
0.0283005368,
0.0118620768,
-0.0936131105,
0.0077739847,
-0.0265685543,
-0.0263616405,
-0.0011168875,
-0.0196870565,
0.0093598226,
-0.008143533,
0.013005387,
0.0083538145,
-0.0427739993,
-0.0483146869,
0.0170273799,
-0.011041767,
-0.079533644,
-0.0890903547,
0.0493551046,
0.0044216453,
0.0166157074,
0.0000021522,
-0.0518380105,
-0.0162721425,
0.0138551919,
-0.0539908409,
0.0584037863,
0.0043764007,
-0.0095990589,
0.0242429562,
0.0083779888,
-0.0146465581,
-0.0090184817,
0.0418436751,
0.0147647196,
0.073922582,
-0.0007223542,
0.0046696234,
-0.0147029385,
-0.0167155489,
-0.0028822077,
0.0649440661,
-0.0174427051,
-0.0210170485,
-0.0131340604,
0.0639629066,
0.0425521173,
-0.0066509494,
0.0334184617,
-0.0103362426,
-0.0345875211,
-0.0143389031,
0.032111194,
-0.0196850225,
-0.0168042574,
-0.0119370539,
0.0606649145,
0.0119075663,
-0.0123282066,
0.0018773193,
-0.0118998867,
0.0072249058,
0.075019598,
-0.1139502302,
-0.0033210951,
0.0044263271,
-0.0042729136,
-0.0097807813,
-0.0312227439,
0.0148195177,
-0.0378689691,
-0.0510567799,
0.0595421642,
0.0159089696,
-0.0079497267,
-0.0035694877,
-0.0195970815,
-0.0105670299,
-0.0706956983,
-0.0224114396,
0.0619967021,
-0.0370566063,
0.017104933,
0.0221628584,
-0.0175131056,
0.0462701097,
-0.0079839611,
0.0526800975,
0.0277584791,
-0.0307558682,
0.048981294,
0.0177693926,
0.0439579263,
-0.0238741674,
-0.0162557848,
0.0169168469,
-0.0213248301,
-0.0033395975,
-0.0049203974,
-0.0435129143,
0.0008849151,
-0.0557067543,
0.0395975672,
-0.0176617261,
0.0611717291,
-0.0035421648,
0.0496949777,
0.0239679646,
-0.0230873246,
-0.0009974036,
0.0064127087,
-0.0845636129,
-0.0124856774,
-0.0367909484,
-0.0616084747,
-0.0341983326,
-0.088017337,
0.0013003822,
0.0156509783,
0.0307442043,
-0.0122038936,
-0.0200817399,
0.0839303508,
0.0279076882,
0.0365290269,
-0.0662188157,
-0.0538954511,
0.0298655201,
-0.010736322,
-0.0052229408,
-0.0425189324,
0.0232921299,
0.0318412706,
0.0132793486,
-0.0001058227,
-0.0074227117,
0.0580628924,
-0.0152421175,
0.0681643039,
-0.0663755015,
0.0171488915,
-0.0180282202,
-0.0191742014,
0.002018424,
0.056233637,
-0.0059014866,
0.0123369563,
0.0237965006,
-0.0497034416,
0.0513519086,
0.0312182792,
0.0220339801,
0.0592435151,
-0.0624870323,
0.0235601664,
-0.0016078569,
0.0027489597,
-0.0350605734,
0.0077268006,
-0.0378757194,
0.010827899,
0.0483925007,
0.0815969333,
0.0768529475,
0.0083819497,
0.0408220924,
0.0280342568,
0.0402796194,
-0.0003252243,
-0.0323725492,
0.0445743464,
0.002296976,
0.0326203406,
-0.0226053763,
0.0072147325,
-0.0042138733,
-0.0358134508,
-0.0030176518,
0.023334749,
-0.0292436481,
-0.00800246,
0.0394781604,
0.0096181193,
0.0059142527,
0.0296914075,
0.0136932535,
-0.0664715394,
-0.0202634633,
-0.0048560398,
0.0287036952,
0.0846623629,
0.0512904525,
-0.0156776346,
-0.0220718607,
-0.0001040885,
0.02527944,
0.0347950906,
0.0676394776,
0.0060448926,
-0.0292954054,
-0.0277925562,
-0.0427165553,
-0.0021671711,
0.0117453421,
-0.0012982241,
-0.0044424958,
0.00005169,
0.005111963,
-0.0821335018,
0.00233056,
-0.013932351,
0.0205881614,
0.0001710935,
-0.0017423966,
0.0077705584,
-0.0100771785,
0.0794832185,
0.0170191415,
0.0316849202,
0.0576342195,
0.0158640034,
0.036039196,
-0.0142061533,
0.0332050994,
0.020484617,
0.0136760855,
-0.0399235785,
-0.0094327768,
-0.045607321,
-0.0458391197,
-0.0371360369,
-0.0207774825,
-0.0455535688,
0.0570253693,
-0.0009640009,
-0.003825706,
-0.0091267554,
-0.0341805741,
-0.0259913411,
0.0518631116,
0.004482978,
0.0347159915,
0.0633474663,
0.028250793,
0.0355974697,
-0.0560431108,
0.0127988886,
0.0361202843,
0.0258738212,
0.0064124074,
-0.0128685264,
0.0149224102,
-0.0218408611,
0.0329272263,
-0.0947513059,
-0.0418569669,
0.0137668923,
0.0406105742,
0.0364531092,
0.0440901332,
-0.0500708409,
-0.0283261519,
-0.0654050186,
0.0168461129,
0.0055683395,
0.0042004255,
0.0613287315,
0.0046961722,
-0.0240713228,
-0.0138089517,
-0.0013127356,
-0.0096153347,
0.000255404,
0.0302883983,
-0.024530394,
-0.0108232601,
0.0040761949,
-0.0286412202,
-0.001416042,
0.0353513882,
0.0182451718,
0.0249284916,
-0.0557007119,
0.0151336109,
0.0059627965,
-0.0225163642,
0.0221996102,
0.0266774744,
-0.0413344353,
-0.0700592175,
0.0194441434,
-0.0297738854,
0.0137329595,
0.0048170486,
-0.0459876806,
0.0551437922,
0.0165027976,
0.0115001332,
0.0195921808,
-0.0037846006,
0.0336402208,
0.0234726053,
0.0593143851,
-0.0694754198,
0.0189471096,
0.0004847999,
0.0643986613,
0.0013928518,
-0.0645046383,
0.0168746766,
-0.0608891658,
0.0060853008,
0.020765895,
-0.0307676792,
-0.0520020612,
0.0827438235,
0.0012032737,
0.0159213729,
-0.0187440608,
-0.0291166939,
-0.006646737,
0.0227578003,
0.027330773,
-0.0574948341,
0.0534726754,
-0.0342388414,
-0.0222337339,
-0.030498974,
0.0167337731,
-0.0161391255,
0.0168156624,
-0.0157981385,
-0.0499294512,
0.0474897437,
-0.0447886027,
0.0107878475,
0.0031560876,
0.0441168211,
0.0085888198,
0.0140818935,
-0.0392968208,
-0.0159149636,
-0.0091442205,
-0.0175927095,
0.0308963004,
-0.0550934412,
-0.0147190904,
0.0079106819,
0.050923422,
0.0087454459,
-0.0020768647,
0.0016286385,
0.0193483308,
0.014228832,
0.0077153556,
-0.0389570184,
0.0436826423,
-0.0196333025,
-0.0280603599,
0.0411600284,
0.0845735148,
0.0481435582,
-0.0574360788,
0.0035147858,
-0.0188465547,
0.0336249843,
0.0444108024,
0.0429242291,
-0.1287037432,
0.0187627468,
-0.0036096708,
0.0306686964,
0.0159386247,
-0.0415671207,
-0.0274021085,
-0.1089043319,
0.0856484696,
-0.0217939727,
-0.004414117,
0.0009379589,
-0.0503121056,
0.0019470863,
0.0075793345,
-0.0256849546,
0.011062488,
-0.0072609456,
0.0202251673,
-0.0282237772,
-0.0276749972,
-0.0366642773,
-0.0251659527,
0.0064181066,
-0.0044730306,
0.0146375773,
0.0421450734,
-0.0113878502,
-0.0536301062,
0.0385257453,
0.0467654169,
0.0037196202,
-0.0612757839,
0.0672513619,
0.0501195937,
-0.0308165029,
-0.0390801057,
-0.0380422063,
0.026917614,
0.0085959798,
0.004170713,
0.0755624399,
-0.0466861352,
0.025476642,
-0.0269373693,
-0.0331984311,
-0.0081637669,
0.0317583717,
0.0576864965,
0.0014430349,
-0.0213258378,
-0.1068379432,
0.0148914382,
-0.016294919,
-0.0615694895,
0.0153077552,
0.0006920248,
-0.0224414915,
-0.0115470663,
-0.0035685375,
0.0559177659,
0.04258826,
0.0299946945,
0.0149411336,
-0.0025018279,
-0.0256874878,
-0.0115529159,
-0.002379956,
-0.0568681657,
0.0137250116,
-0.0314439125,
-0.0194059219,
0.0247064605,
-0.0076950924,
-0.0063501536,
0.002081529,
-0.0275154281,
-0.0296694264,
-0.0367628559,
0.0089147035,
0.0356987193,
-0.0166638102,
-0.0135816513,
-0.0272147059,
0.026339896,
0.0704462379,
-0.0202910658,
-0.0620841384,
-0.0549044497,
0.0342440717,
0.0125133991,
-0.020614747,
-0.0260973703,
-0.0251085404,
-0.0377970003,
0.0103301574,
-0.0370201655,
-0.001281081,
0.0469300225,
0.0680818781,
0.0116901165,
0.0439538807,
-0.0124631738,
0.0024473318,
0.0286126528,
-0.0752358437,
-0.0251820218,
-0.004254627,
0.0059954207,
0.000079076,
-0.0727469921,
0.0451452285,
0.0002203441,
-0.0160731152,
0.005653589,
-0.0869409889,
0.023189025,
-0.005059266,
-0.0573487654,
0.0442769155,
-0.001897016,
0.000032026,
0.0001318684,
-0.0017445252,
0.04496447,
0.0196685735,
0.0301402621,
0.0041972278,
-0.0073280004,
0.019707026,
0.0030873234,
-0.0614768378,
-0.0948090628,
0.0206981897,
0.0385233127,
0.0471887104,
0.0355802774,
0.0251217838,
-0.0255546067,
-0.002694261,
0.006243031,
-0.0035646446,
0.0380443707,
0.021717988,
0.0307943206,
0.0046005007,
-0.0049038124,
-0.0566617064,
0.070664987,
0.0063801049,
0.0067001074,
-0.0247684084,
-0.0473488122,
-0.0526667833,
0.0017727658,
0.0324877053,
-0.0028308658,
-0.0145580173,
-0.0341115035,
-0.0721539557,
-0.0797605962,
-0.0046496708,
0.028336389,
-0.0190104004,
-0.0193786062,
0.0380422063,
0.0419700369,
0.0348646194,
-0.0096296584,
-0.0003955683,
0.0536485277,
-0.0240047406,
-0.0585924685,
-0.0062310756,
-6.121805234e-33,
-0.0266308859,
-0.0745448768,
0.0227397867,
-0.0119375819,
0.0216096472,
-0.0526857264,
-0.017011866,
-0.0096576605,
-0.0240728073,
-0.01509781,
-0.0250381399,
-0.0040823212,
0.009004537,
-0.0010714842,
0.0020706998,
-0.0316569917,
0.0386856347,
0.0128025739,
-0.0408226512,
0.0227163155,
0.0163731445,
-0.008125077,
0.0117277959,
-0.062406376,
0.0418494307,
-0.0111089768,
-0.0145603428,
0.0181408077,
-0.0031580583,
0.0373688638,
-0.0191191807,
0.0513580367,
0.017746605,
-0.0157765746,
-0.0386326648,
0.001616843,
-0.0371937342,
-0.0637579486,
0.0334033892,
-0.017891258,
-0.0262688696,
-0.0254135821,
0.0215895213,
0.0087036788,
-0.0019324748,
0.0132286651,
0.0097361933,
-0.0047934968,
-0.0337209441,
0.0089766104,
0.0223334767,
0.0411215499,
-0.0071281786,
0.0584262833,
0.0273043551,
0.0212800577,
0.0332163423,
0.0364207551,
-0.0176691487,
0.075334549,
0.1117668301,
-0.0053032092,
0.0644566193,
-0.0116425138,
0.0324843824,
-0.0028613789,
0.0133932391,
0.0107640596,
-0.0246308316,
0.0427083485,
-0.0219487567,
0.0594881251,
0.0411554463,
-0.0112467296,
-0.0186203457,
0.0111704692,
-0.0227895137,
0.0408162549,
-0.0539000481,
0.0057160608,
-0.0116857495,
0.0033363211,
-0.0340336412,
-0.0339774489,
-0.0173257329,
-0.0261557568,
-0.0542112738,
-0.02260256,
0.0252397694,
-0.0434032753,
0.0042028748,
-0.0105189867,
-0.0366985388,
0.0159170162,
-0.0721308365,
0.0077387854,
0.0200789608,
0.0194015633,
-0.0011983505,
-0.0388445631,
0.0280119013,
0.0001479132,
-0.0452552736,
-0.000748348,
0.0141519913,
0.055295039,
-0.0158845,
0.0125001855,
-0.088562116,
0.0059800949,
-0.0203829929,
-0.0220096931,
0.0041586421,
-0.0604547411,
0.0425606519,
-0.0377540924,
0.0065417695,
0.0466524735,
0.0260767601,
-0.0216174293,
-0.004532719,
-0.0221710484,
-0.0409056097,
-0.0099234255,
0.0263458882,
-0.020400757,
-0.0168460552,
0.0170141589,
0.093330279,
-0.0264632273,
-0.0280620847,
-0.0012652298,
2.719e-7,
0.0563494414,
0.0339143686,
0.023435317,
0.1016724333,
0.0117804147,
-0.0064010713,
-0.0176367741,
-0.0146334125,
0.0150886159,
-0.0275635757,
0.0035989441,
-0.0030399032,
0.0283072889,
0.0748360083,
-0.0665640756,
0.0170081221,
-0.0188940372,
-0.0501719899,
-0.0945806652,
0.0440696925,
0.1095422134,
0.0254035816,
-0.0103902845,
0.0169046652,
0.0068447166,
-0.0482802652,
0.0135373147,
-0.069513768,
-0.0164397731,
0.0030915602,
0.0396201834,
0.0145653067,
0.0176581424,
0.0258574449,
-0.0281302705,
-0.0192689188,
-0.0338957347,
0.0172722246,
0.0159352459,
0.0370376334,
0.0261160862,
-0.0985874012,
0.0206080228,
-0.0565821677,
0.0631680265,
-0.0026008,
0.0000210093,
0.0701505169,
0.024082765,
-0.0448237844,
0.0163627546,
-0.0466845334,
-0.0339621678,
-0.0001701904,
-0.0110290274,
0.000220635,
0.0050730351,
0.03717025,
-0.0339146815,
-0.0005819672,
-0.0111006377,
-0.0639977902,
-0.0530624799,
0.0270756651,
-0.0141236493,
0.0308484565,
-0.0024270355,
2.927772096e-34,
0.05081686,
0.0089133875,
0.0466021933,
0.0193017665,
0.0578731783,
0.0014968617,
0.0263408739,
0.009613446,
0.016320806,
-0.0828118324,
-0.0413830243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15951v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15951v1 | Modular Pluralism: Pluralistic Alignment via Multi-LLM Collaboration | 2024-06-22T22:07:40 | 2024-06-22T22:07:40 | Shangbin Feng, Taylor Sorensen, Yuhan Liu, Jillian Fisher, Chan Young Park, Yejin Choi, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | While existing alignment paradigms have been integral in developing large
language models (LLMs), LLMs often learn an averaged human preference and
struggle to model diverse preferences across cultures, demographics, and
communities. We propose Modular Pluralism, a modular framework based on
multi-LLM collaboration for pluralistic alignment: it "plugs into" a base LLM a
pool of smaller but specialized community LMs, where models collaborate in
distinct modes to flexibility support three modes of pluralism: Overton,
steerable, and distributional. Modular Pluralism is uniquely compatible with
black-box LLMs and offers the modular control of adding new community LMs for
previously underrepresented communities. We evaluate Modular Pluralism with six
tasks and four datasets featuring questions/instructions with value-laden and
perspective-informed responses. Extensive experiments demonstrate that Modular
Pluralism advances the three pluralism objectives across six black-box and
open-source LLMs. Further analysis reveals that LLMs are generally faithful to
the inputs from smaller community LLMs, allowing seamless patching by adding a
new community LM to better cover previously underrepresented communities. | [
0.0266340394,
0.0695095062,
-0.0268773939,
0.0228091832,
-0.0417359993,
0.0017120664,
-0.0012337788,
-0.0695408285,
-0.0226159841,
0.0154915974,
-0.0313890204,
-0.044498276,
-0.0028605335,
-0.011619525,
-0.0004167451,
-0.0239411984,
0.0511878654,
0.0129996529,
-0.0499263704,
-0.0425559506,
0.0605083108,
0.0434030406,
0.0167059526,
0.0483949743,
0.0157913137,
0.0059332401,
-0.0093524205,
0.0061505218,
0.0463082753,
0.0335846134,
0.0294677783,
0.0514255241,
0.0162536744,
0.0483697355,
0.0000019841,
-0.0488212295,
-0.0223366302,
-0.0233268514,
-0.0281967111,
-0.0082845269,
0.0221813321,
0.0104624955,
0.0181389786,
0.0074242135,
-0.0374033116,
0.0355639793,
0.0492422916,
-0.0061548403,
0.0420933217,
0.0404741913,
0.003633111,
-0.0368827768,
-0.0280378554,
-0.022061022,
-0.0085496465,
0.0248933602,
0.0059000761,
-0.0041121878,
0.0272082184,
0.0084006563,
-0.0007584236,
0.044727467,
0.0146173565,
-0.0193011984,
0.0104120551,
0.0132168671,
-0.0348455124,
-0.0481260158,
0.0064139613,
0.0965756178,
0.0137979342,
-0.0135683119,
-0.0142712286,
-0.0248852521,
0.0107292458,
0.0147475256,
-0.0511890277,
0.0095445542,
-0.0042149611,
0.019894613,
0.0237059016,
-0.0263431408,
0.0138047179,
0.0121262344,
-0.0148206763,
0.1067055389,
0.0067156018,
0.0116494615,
-0.0339634307,
0.021321252,
-0.0247355346,
-0.0317939632,
0.0272924844,
0.0272923391,
-0.0524903201,
0.03787902,
-0.0377526283,
-0.0025420771,
0.050809931,
-0.0073522767,
0.0325282402,
0.05681099,
-0.0405916721,
0.0416419394,
0.0321228281,
-0.0098961946,
-0.0422248021,
0.0274535865,
-0.0687267557,
-0.0290748011,
-0.0256802384,
-0.0168268345,
0.0091425367,
0.0322189964,
-0.0308287386,
0.0129432213,
-0.0287683159,
0.0589479096,
-0.0340220667,
0.0376994424,
0.0315378793,
0.0093452791,
-0.0073721837,
-0.0366673134,
-0.0067798663,
0.1298166662,
-0.0511632077,
0.0151483351,
0.01491143,
-0.0427639931,
0.0210387651,
0.030074738,
-0.0230058283,
-0.0344092697,
-0.0234880764,
-0.0011919142,
-0.0232419297,
0.0226953235,
0.0015507089,
-0.0189234633,
-0.0350048952,
-0.0527824871,
-0.0288606416,
-0.0927625969,
0.0760462657,
0.0198359974,
0.0029838162,
-0.0375399254,
-0.0111623723,
-0.0079021873,
-0.0028558199,
0.0429056771,
0.0196954887,
0.0400300324,
0.0633020326,
0.0086244661,
0.0093291141,
0.0921054929,
-0.0021924607,
-0.0081978207,
0.0314727202,
-0.0201918688,
-0.0100054946,
0.0500023142,
-0.0199721735,
0.0169298537,
-0.0267117545,
0.0508414097,
0.0279868841,
0.0149646308,
0.03517754,
0.0613892302,
0.0038898936,
-0.0559912771,
0.0746470392,
0.0297802165,
0.0110242758,
-0.0174528323,
0.0234596934,
0.0454365723,
-0.0264393091,
0.0112188058,
-0.0385813639,
0.0582473949,
-0.0479948744,
-0.0050366852,
-0.0038117189,
0.0659963414,
-0.0457778089,
-0.0208740886,
-0.0022219515,
-0.0097890357,
0.0391503535,
0.0318434127,
0.0303217079,
-0.0763798356,
0.0050511747,
0.0453026444,
0.0231478363,
-0.0373852402,
0.0090166125,
-0.0182651039,
0.0800138712,
0.0416548774,
0.0180358868,
-0.0204377342,
-0.0767545179,
-0.0155573096,
-0.0135261696,
0.0442419462,
0.0713691413,
-0.0223913547,
0.0066122855,
-0.0568838194,
-0.0312888995,
0.0205587894,
-0.0160951391,
0.0321459845,
0.0077056298,
-0.0404912643,
-0.0141810011,
0.023139365,
-0.0004929314,
0.012626077,
-0.0249363258,
0.0433896966,
-0.0247013029,
0.0069233226,
0.0498334169,
0.0319175981,
0.0185503215,
0.0085885879,
0.0083961729,
-0.0072633028,
-0.011707468,
0.0118893879,
-0.0788578391,
-0.0290697515,
0.0505824462,
-0.0211292747,
-0.030874569,
0.0218776483,
-0.0251003932,
-0.0420110114,
0.0031011601,
0.0089095356,
-0.0211102739,
-0.0267086942,
0.0243805349,
-0.0136566134,
-0.0159136355,
-0.0510171056,
0.0265883543,
-0.0261285994,
-0.00589723,
-0.0116952797,
-0.0099696396,
0.0056302841,
-0.0276824925,
-0.0573026575,
0.0217371006,
-0.0048255585,
0.00683054,
0.0350349918,
-0.0075815134,
-0.0524279475,
-0.0464030951,
-0.0944838747,
0.0003318922,
-0.0197187383,
0.0120858382,
0.0088740233,
0.0062858025,
-0.0012472955,
0.0140378438,
-0.0692337975,
-0.0026130092,
0.0165530089,
0.0281435978,
0.0179310013,
-0.0025350538,
0.0084948232,
-0.036001388,
-0.0134160118,
-0.0025205666,
-0.0099153165,
-0.0311218202,
-0.0117150778,
-0.0615080409,
-0.0380402766,
-0.0771583393,
-0.0123396982,
-0.030069584,
-0.0227986872,
0.0095142238,
0.0044168951,
0.084282957,
0.0264721606,
0.0107024377,
-0.0222747531,
0.0502960421,
0.0044466159,
-0.0681565925,
0.0023838948,
-0.0397724696,
-0.0008727699,
-0.0611014403,
-0.0491877832,
-0.010600647,
0.0754308254,
-0.0128968395,
-0.0283000134,
-0.0614076741,
-0.0099491086,
-0.0033202386,
-0.0304522216,
-0.0005957135,
-0.0243107621,
-0.0189987645,
0.0167953316,
-0.0299340561,
-0.0553167276,
0.0866205469,
0.0038364902,
-0.0299485326,
-0.0294311754,
-0.0152100595,
-0.0630797446,
0.0122391684,
-0.0163102876,
0.014563079,
0.0286563188,
-0.0156701654,
-0.0766405836,
0.0030630426,
0.0261506028,
-0.0430244356,
0.1329428107,
-0.0552223511,
-0.0045291446,
-0.0201467779,
-0.049074132,
-0.0274900571,
-0.0190174468,
-0.0142036546,
0.0384242833,
0.0519531332,
-0.0016570122,
-0.0532620549,
-0.0127448253,
0.0496564358,
0.0073525356,
-0.0138551341,
0.0302360728,
-0.008126149,
0.0091324225,
0.0806028247,
0.0626396015,
-0.0035600117,
-0.0428348966,
0.0099088186,
0.0335222967,
0.0504314713,
-0.0302654579,
0.0235650856,
-0.0295672119,
0.0695333555,
-0.0181624517,
-0.0260837022,
0.0157535337,
0.0977653861,
-0.0034461126,
0.0245976914,
0.1064474881,
0.0232396387,
-0.0745935738,
-0.017854806,
-0.0572687313,
0.0569254048,
0.034018103,
0.0271302033,
-0.0908141211,
0.0056618475,
-0.0091709597,
-0.0120877391,
0.0002771515,
-0.0180738084,
-0.0049147322,
-0.0986156017,
-0.0021404363,
0.0337745845,
-0.0620107912,
0.0344365425,
0.0063471748,
0.0189895108,
-0.0274153762,
0.0258079581,
0.0102670062,
0.0174256731,
-0.0281339809,
0.0268115401,
-0.0556018017,
-0.021342244,
0.0069806571,
-0.0449938551,
0.0880469605,
0.0172771905,
-0.0096882414,
0.0003013463,
-0.0222924072,
0.0111643737,
-0.017751364,
-0.0217784215,
-0.0168259144,
-0.0189169385,
-0.0050621233,
0.0106393006,
-0.0136048952,
0.0248069204,
-0.0187309273,
0.0014722105,
0.0258814264,
0.0670816079,
-0.0230456777,
-0.0019134561,
-0.0239282716,
0.0205845665,
-0.0004316281,
0.0798422545,
0.011435817,
-0.0563817173,
0.012883923,
-0.0155183272,
-0.0719449595,
-0.0140050687,
-0.0210712813,
0.0178597737,
-0.0048400513,
0.0057333643,
-0.027260296,
-0.0430991761,
0.0350796729,
0.0174139161,
0.0101909759,
-0.0038233607,
0.0346782058,
-0.0434983112,
-0.0092447875,
0.0239673778,
-0.0616096742,
0.0147045115,
-0.0823066533,
-0.0153573602,
0.0105420873,
-0.0466407686,
0.0185163319,
-0.0139114847,
-0.0811269358,
-0.1021552533,
0.0132651012,
0.0496964343,
0.0177451316,
0.0354517698,
-0.0019711854,
-0.0675544664,
0.0005236907,
0.0339683294,
0.0001661366,
-0.0027346916,
-0.006043002,
0.0431756005,
-0.017200442,
0.0380760431,
-0.0153755806,
0.0204923134,
0.0161625315,
0.0541849434,
-0.0676520467,
-0.0121215731,
0.0125911571,
-0.0066821161,
-0.0075324676,
-0.0158640351,
0.0319055058,
-0.0559396148,
-0.0004565449,
-0.0247310344,
-0.0299719442,
-0.0084598567,
-0.0382229872,
0.0453773476,
-0.0472045429,
0.0143635161,
0.0237947199,
0.00719374,
0.0611272305,
-0.0521338768,
0.0381344743,
0.0009532229,
-0.0108854165,
0.0262907818,
0.0326068178,
-0.0182927139,
0.025391221,
-0.0117228068,
0.0459365249,
0.0233309567,
0.0944600999,
-0.0016018645,
-0.0084241927,
-0.0037837836,
0.0034336189,
-0.003162212,
-0.0537325777,
0.0010911342,
0.0300071985,
0.0209869146,
0.0066685416,
0.054009825,
0.0018904974,
-0.0157479141,
-0.0568101071,
0.0481427051,
-0.0048710466,
-0.031680312,
0.0665654987,
0.0396425165,
-0.0370405391,
-0.0177569035,
0.0559261218,
-0.0540212467,
-0.0172587726,
-0.0170206111,
0.0005704706,
-0.0451962128,
-0.038169764,
0.0250422303,
0.0299133882,
-0.0819693208,
-0.0078345621,
-0.0655213073,
-0.0310941041,
0.0082022594,
0.0083742496,
-0.0197968315,
-0.0044704438,
0.0119424984,
0.0474745072,
-0.0465672389,
-0.025991451,
-0.0273703504,
0.0193661898,
-0.0358430594,
0.0009801096,
0.01011963,
-6.675458298e-33,
-0.0212470014,
-0.0136826457,
0.0354113616,
-0.0491164252,
-0.0177423842,
-0.0293909218,
0.0095815836,
0.0550008938,
-0.0351310521,
-0.0121488515,
0.0060324273,
-0.0119208433,
0.0143643972,
0.0207002405,
0.0580354407,
-0.0268596672,
0.0212775506,
0.023115119,
-0.0238824971,
0.0004767763,
0.0014000931,
0.0110483412,
0.0642898008,
-0.043223083,
0.0551837012,
-0.0045894138,
0.0154033015,
0.0264534634,
-0.0128117641,
0.0897109285,
0.0045988797,
0.0554208457,
0.0289601889,
-0.0283265896,
-0.0219617914,
0.022954097,
-0.0278901309,
-0.0184481274,
0.068439059,
-0.0104141068,
-0.0124534052,
-0.0402489416,
0.0146239586,
-0.0196703505,
-0.0136682559,
0.0093546882,
0.034661714,
-0.0218771901,
-0.0182171483,
0.019843081,
-0.0538783967,
0.0119009046,
-0.0073713707,
0.0133825764,
-0.0319682658,
0.0735754371,
-0.0023828861,
0.0576343499,
-0.0493588038,
0.0420381799,
-0.0207370315,
0.0078056585,
0.0870673433,
0.025431918,
-0.0047384487,
0.0327032767,
0.0064285561,
-0.0009532782,
-0.0327757224,
-0.0414857194,
0.0335536078,
0.0284006093,
0.0369833149,
0.0626924038,
-0.0528887883,
0.0099145025,
-0.0106510147,
0.0282910541,
0.0678451061,
-0.0056397938,
0.0320178233,
0.0553410463,
-0.030961765,
-0.0249008853,
-0.0030008329,
-0.0006421834,
-0.0343151726,
-0.0192196183,
0.0055009034,
0.0069721141,
-0.0178601574,
0.0447954349,
0.0691046342,
-0.0208519772,
-0.0121571282,
0.0219911616,
-0.0009542612,
0.0013254859,
0.0141092744,
0.0323967971,
-0.0863278881,
-0.0001287438,
-0.0041062417,
-0.0384931304,
-0.038878236,
0.0429778658,
0.0275009554,
0.0131014632,
-0.0582141206,
-0.0003864059,
-0.0266587008,
-0.0230264012,
-0.0266137365,
0.0027257381,
0.0561847426,
0.0050096465,
-0.0017061634,
0.0458084717,
0.0174078103,
-0.0270642675,
-0.0340450779,
-0.0415387452,
-0.0216681305,
0.0056924969,
-0.01145247,
0.0186942182,
-0.0045675882,
-0.0188025683,
0.0304423869,
0.0145641025,
-0.0106452219,
-0.0021158408,
2.675e-7,
0.0505478419,
0.0285082236,
-0.0038743315,
-0.0351931453,
0.0104935924,
0.0135202557,
-0.0239681825,
0.0081003001,
0.0258728862,
-0.0117262313,
0.0417988561,
0.035311114,
0.0747672692,
0.0146739865,
-0.0740356669,
0.0053277188,
-0.0242208224,
0.0316075422,
-0.0412323102,
0.0123289227,
0.0064080809,
0.072249867,
0.0329936743,
0.0244166236,
-0.033096496,
0.0436664559,
0.0661714524,
-0.0701992735,
-0.0383716226,
0.0575036928,
0.0082831159,
-0.0300977714,
0.0004861357,
-0.0246128011,
0.0207548514,
0.0126327146,
-0.0081684291,
0.1129736304,
0.0127993459,
-0.0551489107,
-0.0084141614,
0.0013034645,
-0.0030748858,
-0.0953638777,
0.0358605608,
-0.0512589552,
-0.0326401927,
-0.0425768606,
-0.0222822279,
-0.0125124445,
0.039431721,
-0.0062453048,
-0.017563764,
0.0086691622,
0.0362521335,
-0.0239180531,
-0.0324914083,
-0.0578421578,
-0.0248721726,
0.0036776226,
-0.0727793798,
-0.056725394,
-0.0002224851,
-0.0051203086,
-0.0115783783,
-0.0320695192,
0.0144640133,
2.220360055e-34,
0.0225917827,
-0.0032954796,
0.0210202541,
0.0302903317,
0.0063177864,
-0.012780291,
-0.0745864511,
0.030788539,
0.0242619421,
-0.0814655051,
-0.0182510745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15948v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15948v1 | Teaching LLMs to Abstain across Languages via Multilingual Feedback | 2024-06-22T21:59:12 | 2024-06-22T21:59:12 | Shangbin Feng, Weijia Shi, Yike Wang, Wenxuan Ding, Orevaoghene Ahia, Shuyue Stella Li, Vidhisha Balachandran, Sunayana Sitaram, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual LLMs often have knowledge disparities across languages, with
larger gaps in under-resourced languages. Teaching LLMs to abstain in the face
of knowledge gaps is thus a promising strategy to mitigate hallucinations in
multilingual settings. However, previous studies on LLM abstention primarily
focus on English; we find that directly applying existing solutions beyond
English results in up to 20.5% performance gaps between high and low-resource
languages, potentially due to LLMs' drop in calibration and reasoning beyond a
few resource-rich languages. To this end, we propose strategies to enhance LLM
abstention by learning from multilingual feedback, where LLMs self-reflect on
proposed answers in one language by generating multiple feedback items in
related languages: we show that this helps identifying the knowledge gaps
across diverse languages, cultures, and communities. Extensive experiments
demonstrate that our multilingual feedback approach outperforms various strong
baselines, achieving up to 9.2% improvement for low-resource languages across
three black-box and open models on three datasets, featuring open-book,
closed-book, and commonsense QA. Further analysis reveals that multilingual
feedback is both an effective and a more equitable abstain strategy to serve
diverse language speakers, and cultural factors have great impact on language
selection and LLM abstention behavior, highlighting future directions for
multilingual and multi-cultural reliable language modeling. | [
0.0196314901,
0.0475679934,
-0.0198588055,
0.0477843173,
-0.0355512835,
0.0150649995,
0.010834909,
0.0098404288,
0.039057184,
-0.0257655084,
-0.0274460036,
-0.0411633439,
-0.0241173599,
-0.0570412166,
0.0382949114,
-0.007144249,
0.0433521494,
-0.0322084315,
-0.0236577,
-0.0793037042,
0.0070560938,
0.0174635332,
0.008743749,
0.0138630522,
0.0265518799,
-0.035942141,
0.0130405389,
-0.0279756617,
0.0187202506,
-0.0146401552,
0.0119988378,
0.0670233741,
-0.0137227178,
0.0141601553,
0.0000021112,
-0.0487180054,
0.0058656097,
-0.0452342145,
-0.0179433115,
0.0102864364,
-0.0027545064,
0.0025826041,
0.0391468555,
0.0016125651,
-0.0447231792,
0.0401325785,
-0.0112165781,
-0.0005539382,
0.0342622101,
0.0191593878,
0.025377918,
0.0128573207,
-0.0081517044,
-0.0090110628,
0.048536513,
0.0002875268,
0.0059943656,
0.0199750159,
-0.0072767641,
-0.0107503515,
-0.0411463752,
0.0294102412,
0.041934628,
-0.0173000041,
-0.0156866126,
0.0220191833,
-0.0236662552,
-0.0282536,
0.0005231492,
0.0643296167,
0.0156125408,
-0.0362673067,
-0.0293611567,
-0.0159334876,
0.0203116946,
0.0184804723,
-0.0656269938,
0.019394191,
0.001655138,
0.0041518346,
0.0424918719,
-0.0309402309,
0.0333812609,
0.0318843685,
0.0143555831,
0.0811464489,
0.0034413412,
-0.0299081635,
0.0171047207,
0.0364978015,
-0.008037868,
-0.0386979319,
0.0032827079,
0.0530732498,
-0.0516325906,
0.0172142256,
0.0348419324,
-0.0187906493,
0.0613593087,
-0.0492311306,
0.0014910899,
0.0339077674,
-0.0684906393,
0.0493944846,
-0.0111620985,
0.0090190833,
0.0070248623,
0.0603731833,
-0.0218346044,
-0.0147950258,
-0.0114859454,
-0.0259803906,
0.0462718904,
0.0433620475,
0.0203270819,
0.0622688904,
-0.0307360832,
-0.003147135,
-0.05600724,
0.0295806527,
-0.0088445917,
-0.0090362076,
0.0027680434,
-0.0242564827,
-0.0595619231,
0.0776101127,
-0.0529541299,
0.0299598593,
0.0037337586,
-0.0687656105,
-0.0203924123,
0.0437339544,
-0.0598909482,
-0.023347199,
0.0455502011,
0.0337488465,
-0.011304169,
0.0154714175,
-0.0408090875,
-0.0126174511,
0.0172000937,
-0.0628659502,
0.0083602313,
-0.1027542129,
0.0165954214,
0.0204136278,
0.0144334557,
-0.0401148461,
0.0141513878,
0.0228570029,
0.0147020919,
0.0345024392,
-0.0068662832,
-0.0028740836,
0.0486326963,
0.021981895,
-0.0087425318,
0.0858835429,
-0.0101049105,
-0.0451704562,
0.0700585246,
-0.0157614797,
0.0077022538,
0.0249696616,
0.0138328066,
0.0394524336,
0.0011995942,
0.0399708003,
-0.0016293681,
-0.0121999616,
0.0292395689,
-0.0017186796,
-0.0141332243,
-0.0188478697,
0.0319548659,
0.0653439984,
-0.0184060764,
0.0387031734,
-0.011217461,
-0.0289059207,
-0.0087728715,
0.0361672156,
-0.0199298523,
0.057750158,
-0.0111897942,
-0.011322177,
0.0193263385,
0.0261920374,
-0.0486724339,
-0.0513285249,
-0.0029333343,
-0.0069047995,
0.0282426495,
0.0482456051,
0.0149431527,
-0.0038393838,
0.0089492099,
0.1028127372,
0.0427267104,
-0.0567058586,
0.0390115455,
-0.02159472,
0.049697075,
0.0152725521,
0.0195286479,
-0.0454604626,
-0.0496312082,
-0.0374736078,
0.0504451841,
0.0622699074,
0.0628869832,
-0.0198331848,
-0.0042347051,
-0.0621261485,
-0.0353161916,
0.0166800208,
-0.0144234952,
0.0093524028,
0.0051547782,
0.0184070878,
-0.0232539587,
-0.0416242853,
-0.0070179086,
0.0154593959,
-0.0589469336,
-0.0083550764,
-0.0025907732,
-0.0075107231,
0.0331167616,
0.0394932665,
0.0361526757,
0.0012717857,
0.0184220206,
-0.0327749513,
-0.0207665153,
0.0184037611,
-0.0465354472,
-0.0331500731,
0.0654358938,
-0.0183591973,
-0.0445726924,
0.0037124406,
-0.0273034107,
-0.0356492065,
-0.0016610194,
0.0190029051,
0.0139116663,
-0.0409489423,
-0.0176982339,
-0.021975005,
-0.0157895479,
-0.0466520898,
0.05148267,
-0.0435469523,
0.0696654171,
0.0217434242,
-0.029685488,
0.046212256,
-0.0224714223,
-0.0080594029,
0.0179852676,
0.0168334283,
0.0086762868,
0.0373381115,
0.0434909873,
-0.0508114807,
0.0043528131,
-0.0625300109,
-0.0214241855,
-0.0286756717,
0.0371659175,
-0.0144352783,
-0.0180204641,
0.0013232506,
-0.0191170685,
-0.0808493942,
-0.018311467,
0.0406674221,
0.0331104435,
0.0190383699,
-0.0054249018,
0.0372698754,
-0.0164559148,
-0.018563699,
0.018610321,
-0.0010281146,
-0.0185289532,
0.0108740395,
-0.0286703408,
-0.0055769267,
-0.0691288561,
-0.0249642357,
-0.0184068736,
-0.0189614501,
0.0029248067,
0.0066871392,
-0.0036237247,
0.0036847107,
-0.024563659,
-0.0375504903,
0.0664253533,
0.0107739531,
-0.0931483358,
0.0141889146,
0.0060555306,
-0.0007716063,
-0.0266690385,
-0.0182150844,
-0.0262302328,
0.0471471362,
0.0098080821,
-0.0276114792,
-0.0543586649,
-0.0122771356,
-0.0434114859,
-0.0394858904,
-0.0470223948,
0.0143778017,
-0.0137791345,
0.0521358289,
-0.0129331611,
-0.0347460285,
0.1001981944,
0.0131100258,
-0.0067247907,
-0.0394681245,
0.0273357276,
-0.0536677986,
-0.0105419019,
-0.0681541637,
0.0060976204,
-0.0268149674,
-0.0053506359,
-0.064254187,
-0.0270368457,
0.0396289825,
-0.0455438271,
0.0808573514,
-0.0193916503,
-0.01597609,
-0.0178472139,
-0.0429090299,
-0.04098114,
-0.0189869236,
-0.0071018697,
-0.0124952747,
-0.0302169882,
0.0140510993,
-0.023594806,
-0.053867206,
0.053823702,
-0.0374442488,
-0.0002269718,
0.0025817405,
0.0188900027,
-0.0152959768,
0.0418048501,
0.0515406132,
0.0448630825,
-0.0745496228,
0.0349439494,
0.0445017219,
0.0291543789,
-0.0363238752,
0.0756065995,
0.013585547,
0.0896996707,
-0.0152946413,
-0.030381849,
0.008989579,
0.0712044165,
-0.0240975954,
0.0116792191,
0.0852754936,
0.0202664956,
-0.0441211835,
-0.0136879142,
-0.1141263992,
0.0666818991,
0.0454550274,
0.0296042636,
-0.1181384623,
0.001171114,
-0.0162051748,
0.0198306404,
-0.0083192857,
-0.0182955693,
0.0192359444,
-0.1143986806,
0.0047871382,
0.0232821554,
-0.0362880304,
-0.0236510318,
-0.0300361421,
-0.0171789788,
0.0108213797,
0.0227154233,
0.0225220267,
0.0220223274,
-0.0132704051,
0.0324101597,
-0.0502931997,
-0.0154663874,
0.0275212545,
0.0036014239,
0.0038875556,
0.0103931753,
0.0058006351,
-0.0355411433,
-0.0667713359,
0.0420922451,
-0.0292470176,
-0.0148657728,
-0.0391110778,
-0.017837042,
0.0255857613,
-0.0061230948,
-0.0123147294,
0.0342499651,
-0.02579033,
-0.0258508474,
0.0542345382,
0.103088513,
-0.011290173,
-0.0001398137,
-0.004673514,
0.0154086286,
-0.0216286853,
0.0693433955,
0.0211374275,
-0.0288906284,
-0.0078935344,
-0.0498345122,
-0.0327245966,
-0.0266675688,
-0.0334628969,
0.0460127257,
0.0152197154,
0.0345390998,
-0.0102263745,
-0.0764647275,
0.0146030812,
-0.0197109245,
0.0239938758,
0.0478805937,
-0.0261995643,
-0.022140773,
0.0310063697,
0.0209046882,
-0.0465300828,
0.00676338,
0.005954518,
0.0144913476,
-0.0032107299,
-0.032417018,
0.010486193,
-0.0216530412,
-0.0487103313,
-0.0559782051,
-0.0384972878,
0.0673695132,
0.0181946065,
0.034250319,
0.0188343767,
-0.0576968305,
0.0387111008,
0.008040729,
0.0190863013,
0.0198215619,
0.0449871458,
0.0381783471,
-0.0018634356,
0.0613771081,
-0.0222195685,
-0.0202621631,
0.036465615,
0.0638209656,
-0.0512368418,
-0.0156539921,
0.0137297017,
-0.0114341471,
-0.020050589,
-0.0230841581,
-0.0168952215,
-0.0295680352,
0.0417950116,
-0.0070430739,
-0.0316769071,
0.0085830931,
-0.0137191927,
0.0052177887,
-0.0918778703,
0.0119619854,
0.0099105155,
-0.0256695095,
0.0438571647,
-0.0543430299,
0.0768736824,
0.0565908216,
0.0027838333,
-0.0063450434,
0.0049780821,
-0.0190979727,
-0.0229825452,
0.0121573741,
0.0297224093,
0.0094839074,
0.0846116096,
0.0078369789,
-0.0051766629,
0.0348700508,
-0.0443063341,
-0.0093291346,
-0.0350282304,
0.017886471,
0.0551949814,
0.0634205714,
0.0100631062,
0.0490596779,
0.0270186681,
-0.0166564453,
-0.0153644551,
0.0197944529,
0.0074118888,
-0.0227840524,
0.0662795976,
0.026161965,
-0.017160438,
-0.0000353501,
0.0705739185,
-0.0600837916,
0.0227521453,
-0.0088996282,
0.0233323462,
-0.0376250744,
-0.0510542728,
0.0121011464,
0.0230331607,
-0.0231434498,
0.045182161,
-0.0842726231,
-0.0628154948,
0.0058126454,
0.0181040205,
-0.0223615449,
-0.0104829296,
-0.010891811,
0.0764618739,
0.0005578621,
-0.0292811655,
-0.0438812375,
0.0262245499,
-0.0304860286,
-0.0038025179,
-0.0000909597,
-6.412761759e-33,
-0.0165332481,
-0.0487483069,
0.0269346852,
-0.0046591936,
0.0282969102,
-0.0373600535,
-0.0144773368,
0.0271616671,
-0.0295385048,
0.0231798943,
-0.0240677521,
-0.003291629,
0.0075813788,
0.0097801266,
0.060023427,
-0.0242519621,
0.0131140659,
0.0095369974,
-0.0160756037,
-0.0075010327,
-0.0100822188,
0.0196943767,
0.0868906602,
-0.0390803516,
0.1149376482,
-0.0421018079,
0.0123204598,
0.0167974122,
-0.0475252643,
0.0601518899,
-0.0151783824,
0.0765657797,
0.0252400693,
-0.0300730746,
-0.0238175243,
-0.0127214631,
-0.0421799496,
-0.0722687691,
0.0535717271,
-0.0034539455,
-0.013883654,
-0.0501836576,
0.0215327982,
0.0047931173,
-0.0373585559,
0.0036837226,
0.0284918882,
-0.0388693102,
-0.0200712308,
0.0092777722,
-0.0203886665,
0.0138459876,
-0.0020053424,
0.0235912483,
-0.0265442487,
0.1182619333,
-0.0169476271,
0.0047675618,
-0.070911862,
0.0281232167,
0.0114583159,
0.0082881944,
0.0816795006,
-0.0345332585,
-0.0022664033,
0.034963537,
-0.0095319245,
0.0219622441,
0.0257611461,
-0.0174538493,
0.0163132157,
0.0007077503,
0.0752213225,
0.093266122,
0.0038394728,
-0.0075253192,
-0.083117716,
0.0174406487,
0.004167262,
0.051154051,
0.0199622381,
-0.0086680204,
-0.0199638736,
-0.0255799908,
-0.0450429283,
-0.0217343103,
-0.0331832208,
-0.0287980139,
0.0214405991,
0.0068944083,
-0.0078468053,
-0.0071952194,
0.0358934477,
-0.0198903158,
-0.0563207418,
0.0086272806,
0.0060738116,
-0.028876083,
0.0300634857,
0.0289059486,
-0.0547994226,
-0.0054680132,
-0.0571212992,
-0.0290722139,
0.0145905437,
0.0376503281,
0.0422237627,
-0.0022499566,
-0.0601817705,
-0.0115666594,
-0.0210791398,
0.0140426364,
0.0094401632,
0.0082533741,
0.0265861657,
-0.0037215904,
-0.0023129296,
0.0487124659,
0.0257384665,
-0.0360576585,
-0.0210923832,
-0.0222667009,
-0.0269962121,
0.0247422289,
-0.0342919156,
-0.004629802,
-0.0024542061,
0.005143445,
0.0265107639,
-0.0298043974,
-0.0006191423,
0.0024256913,
2.596e-7,
0.027485963,
0.021628188,
-0.0265150331,
-0.0120150633,
0.0022866139,
0.0322156586,
-0.048807878,
-0.0104520395,
0.0346149579,
-0.025696544,
-0.0139606502,
0.0289562065,
0.0627030283,
0.0489440821,
-0.0794177726,
0.011464512,
-0.0501073226,
0.020492468,
-0.0239788704,
-0.0233614836,
0.00541519,
0.054192964,
-0.0140897455,
-0.0106708966,
-0.0598818772,
-0.0125880372,
0.0807286575,
-0.0593628883,
-0.0461780019,
0.0014807116,
0.0862591118,
-0.0159991551,
0.0359877907,
0.0145802004,
-0.0181344524,
-0.016390875,
0.0063657369,
0.0389407687,
0.0287082419,
-0.0830759779,
-0.0072991699,
-0.0033237615,
0.0212971829,
-0.0666637942,
0.0547796935,
0.0228081737,
-0.0062662968,
-0.0261265878,
0.0162318051,
-0.0326605402,
0.0862009674,
-0.0183477066,
-0.038334202,
-0.0041303989,
0.0238548387,
-0.0088265287,
-0.0155181857,
-0.0259914044,
-0.058574792,
0.0096135419,
-0.0081349136,
-0.0464820825,
0.0004395189,
-0.0062354226,
-0.0348147377,
-0.0509667546,
0.0132373134,
2.260164773e-34,
0.0168275256,
-0.0180862043,
0.0392196178,
0.067561537,
-0.0090597421,
-0.0071370099,
0.0016071338,
0.0093972534,
0.0263956655,
-0.0369014181,
-0.0120866913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15940v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15940v1 | Beyond Individual Facts: Investigating Categorical Knowledge Locality of Taxonomy and Meronomy Concepts in GPT Models | 2024-06-22T21:12:57 | 2024-06-22T21:12:57 | Christopher Burger, Yifan Hu, Thai Le | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The location of knowledge within Generative Pre-trained Transformer
(GPT)-like models has seen extensive recent investigation. However, much of the
work is focused towards determining locations of individual facts, with the end
goal being the editing of facts that are outdated, erroneous, or otherwise
harmful, without the time and expense of retraining the entire model. In this
work, we investigate a broader view of knowledge location, that of concepts or
clusters of related information, instead of disparate individual facts. To do
this, we first curate a novel dataset, called DARC, that includes a total of 34
concepts of ~120K factual statements divided into two types of hierarchical
categories, namely taxonomy and meronomy. Next, we utilize existing causal
mediation analysis methods developed for determining regions of importance for
individual facts and apply them to a series of related categories to provide
detailed investigation into whether concepts are associated with distinct
regions within these models. We find that related categories exhibit similar
areas of importance in contrast to less similar categories. However,
fine-grained localization of individual category subsets to specific regions is
not apparent. | [
0.0321198627,
0.0613496974,
-0.0299395677,
0.0071729515,
-0.0101028066,
0.0121217957,
0.009034289,
-0.0048870533,
-0.0446737297,
-0.0728990361,
-0.0397657007,
0.0122394757,
-0.0089173708,
-0.0291985702,
0.0142952362,
-0.062007606,
0.0398052521,
0.0430936292,
0.0157088134,
0.0136443777,
-0.0386417471,
-0.0137219392,
-0.008839692,
0.0366416126,
-0.0684739277,
-0.0493898578,
-0.0038701626,
-0.0149336308,
0.072428003,
0.0074258079,
0.0147105558,
0.0679786727,
0.0067109019,
0.0435871817,
0.0000021693,
-0.0210141856,
-0.0343775339,
0.0015563689,
-0.0040464727,
0.0115348697,
-0.0094098439,
0.0114803109,
-0.0048613269,
-0.0092046103,
-0.0155516937,
-0.0791321471,
0.0483645052,
0.0987939984,
0.0331323706,
0.0925080478,
-0.0266890358,
-0.0344347991,
0.0125086596,
-0.0506866388,
0.0383262187,
-0.0042288257,
0.0208399966,
0.0478155911,
-0.1171320081,
0.0367942415,
-0.0606821217,
0.0348962545,
0.0115635963,
-0.0008510776,
0.0021795188,
0.0202458035,
0.0078459028,
-0.0334845558,
0.0554580875,
0.0245376322,
0.0344474651,
-0.0313022286,
-0.0080192126,
-0.0043971315,
0.0713666454,
0.0848261565,
-0.0553609207,
0.0327782705,
0.0077202115,
-0.001756509,
0.0151289552,
0.0247282498,
0.005971801,
-0.0292076934,
-0.0413067192,
0.0496244542,
0.0098443124,
-0.0367580429,
-0.0315438658,
0.0219402276,
-0.0370335132,
-0.0613902621,
0.0024106207,
-0.0199179053,
0.016091641,
0.0172780138,
0.0046466095,
0.0317292437,
-0.0052220761,
-0.0378375575,
-0.003737024,
0.0300570782,
-0.0422281995,
0.0459801555,
-0.0034142677,
0.0483882241,
-0.0440637395,
0.054899659,
-0.0055176523,
-0.00270136,
-0.0595940985,
-0.0486948006,
-0.0222763922,
0.0089634787,
0.0115963528,
0.0232770462,
-0.0435209535,
-0.0205316767,
-0.0307472795,
-0.0123877553,
-0.0033160869,
0.0266499836,
-0.0325958766,
-0.0005856877,
-0.0312175322,
0.0548760109,
-0.041482579,
0.036817275,
-0.0102400864,
-0.022711331,
-0.0350105613,
0.0078711975,
-0.0039473642,
-0.0282904077,
-0.0074420888,
0.0203874763,
0.0129927425,
-0.0179890972,
-0.0591638312,
-0.0231323391,
-0.0103182718,
-0.0310274363,
0.0413493812,
-0.0183914583,
-0.0039213635,
0.0022552221,
0.0356724784,
-0.0211458392,
-0.0271691997,
0.0097768819,
-0.0317019075,
0.0554398745,
0.0473351777,
0.0210711248,
0.0342499427,
0.0293081738,
0.0004332481,
0.0344488285,
0.0112306327,
0.0273500904,
0.0270105843,
-0.0289201234,
-0.0000247882,
-0.0274511129,
0.01417147,
-0.0247922074,
0.0083070509,
-0.0281199832,
-0.0098791094,
0.0058347364,
0.0497275963,
-0.00984657,
-0.0357907787,
0.0122940158,
0.0907971561,
0.0287533738,
0.0389483348,
0.0618102774,
0.0469462872,
-0.0166927688,
0.0152210137,
0.0178405792,
-0.049421221,
0.029939713,
-0.0112982802,
-0.0092397491,
-0.0138423461,
0.0324218087,
-0.0187744256,
-0.0431494527,
-0.0000670384,
0.0186289903,
-0.0531744771,
-0.038946487,
0.0416371003,
0.0492889136,
-0.014841212,
0.0615922697,
0.0134403724,
-0.0489697084,
0.0058432543,
-0.0179936178,
-0.0130298389,
0.0169207323,
0.0586920157,
-0.0495074131,
-0.0649779812,
-0.0147405704,
-0.0245758817,
0.0222114436,
0.0299468655,
-0.0106526073,
-0.0329005867,
-0.0057164766,
-0.0137041388,
-0.0463163815,
0.0465669669,
-0.0012552696,
0.0943161249,
0.0261442568,
0.0046027009,
-0.0262590423,
0.0593086407,
0.0294645708,
0.0186195485,
-0.0113361469,
-0.0448350906,
-0.0018574279,
0.0335267782,
-0.0191092677,
-0.0171747077,
-0.0222823713,
0.01678502,
0.0093066189,
-0.0688594729,
0.0527544543,
-0.0683905482,
-0.0101931905,
0.0165256485,
-0.046752274,
-0.0348860584,
0.01671491,
-0.0467363447,
-0.0054487879,
0.0156037714,
-0.0132648358,
0.0434056111,
-0.026920164,
0.0150041981,
0.0184711162,
-0.0241875984,
-0.0059810085,
0.0759864524,
-0.0053244759,
-0.0032851712,
-0.0253599007,
-0.0304827224,
0.0335374512,
0.0190779343,
0.036040362,
-0.0369937867,
-0.0396697484,
-0.0183644015,
0.0163981821,
-0.0159345604,
-0.0333071053,
-0.011493207,
-0.0639251769,
0.0021294262,
-0.0077360785,
0.0109336162,
0.065099895,
-0.0230557173,
-0.0107259201,
-0.0032068773,
-0.0141896,
0.0087379264,
-0.0384349488,
0.0109710591,
0.0189623069,
-0.0343546532,
0.0238294918,
-0.0235563107,
0.0134476656,
-0.0182987191,
0.0534695014,
0.0066792369,
0.0007937098,
-0.0273336004,
0.0198637769,
-0.0262140129,
0.0070581944,
-0.0085406089,
-0.0341992043,
0.0185145233,
0.0193582643,
0.0901530236,
0.035871692,
0.0019210933,
0.0788710937,
0.0317904018,
-0.0351170823,
-0.0245913789,
0.000451396,
-0.0533638932,
-0.0120570799,
-0.014470364,
-0.0297559015,
0.0102657722,
0.097987026,
0.0222530551,
-0.0409637503,
-0.0649593696,
0.0145633612,
-0.0281264074,
-0.02700123,
-0.0290120039,
0.0072257933,
0.0045812805,
0.0246479064,
-0.0241425298,
-0.0507843979,
0.0255408324,
0.0090326462,
0.0164850317,
0.0172554329,
0.0199866984,
-0.0099670151,
0.0683798343,
0.0228895303,
0.0161586646,
0.0229307842,
-0.0275354423,
-0.0983045995,
0.0344014578,
0.0342651904,
-0.0066841394,
0.0314192176,
-0.0293260999,
-0.0099891955,
-0.0080036763,
0.0019930841,
-0.0325956568,
0.0148404837,
0.0561136454,
0.0010918522,
0.0385745317,
-0.0448952429,
-0.0457268208,
-0.023274852,
0.0243407618,
0.0820022002,
0.009669574,
-0.0391551964,
-0.0050058784,
0.0219633132,
0.0252556447,
0.0053526904,
0.0350891314,
-0.0107876686,
-0.0329045318,
0.0597681031,
-0.0712511912,
-0.0437506177,
-0.0159451254,
-0.0139622735,
-0.0202164147,
-0.0633766875,
-0.012350182,
-0.0435653292,
0.0451322533,
-0.023695061,
-0.0355590507,
0.1012208238,
0.0385672636,
-0.0139529128,
0.0129422406,
-0.0125979874,
-0.020816559,
0.0584780201,
-0.0143375788,
-0.0721921548,
0.0096062068,
-0.0061739767,
-0.0438839123,
-0.0067674075,
-0.0044269767,
0.006877414,
-0.0450648479,
0.0569957756,
-0.0295209512,
-0.0196912587,
-0.046017997,
0.0068608923,
0.0003604759,
-0.0292131025,
-0.0430606455,
-0.0109238867,
0.0090665324,
0.0117831621,
-0.0226584692,
-0.0110308286,
-0.0174209606,
0.0184562877,
-0.000632186,
0.01084862,
0.0033681425,
0.0247849841,
0.0044832192,
-0.0002830809,
-0.0016122423,
0.0031592401,
0.0087288795,
0.0338315405,
0.0632130876,
-0.004418808,
0.0008234311,
-0.0012353086,
-0.0013908447,
-0.0103028417,
-0.0625291392,
-0.0182580091,
0.0857617781,
-0.0189716555,
-0.0332029648,
-0.0064384546,
0.0194291137,
-0.0227513984,
0.0759123787,
0.0221449416,
0.0246533062,
0.0078353342,
-0.0286004785,
0.0369585752,
0.0275934059,
-0.0495025069,
-0.0063594268,
0.0311033819,
-0.0626894087,
-0.0728539675,
-0.0094519481,
0.0273881052,
0.002309659,
0.0071206833,
-0.0498837233,
0.0275318455,
-0.0107449237,
-0.0519751534,
0.0645157918,
-0.0462795012,
-0.0724455267,
-0.0106161339,
-0.0679724291,
0.0364534706,
-0.0235268883,
-0.0473385267,
0.0076575391,
-0.0511812232,
-0.0140585667,
0.039943032,
0.0422988236,
0.0221050829,
0.023873942,
-0.0068880832,
-0.0208737422,
0.0885439217,
0.0463239811,
-0.0463441014,
0.0431727469,
0.032303717,
-0.0369419865,
0.0050343978,
-0.0013742091,
-0.0037778909,
0.0511979908,
0.0237814132,
-0.0100081675,
-0.0401412919,
-0.0259354394,
0.0387993827,
-0.0437992625,
0.0949409232,
0.0046875542,
0.0154372538,
-0.0595726185,
0.0043645115,
-0.0120919198,
-0.0015573808,
-0.024087701,
-0.03402799,
0.0742208585,
0.027025247,
-0.0483450778,
0.0095557654,
-0.020443812,
0.0160180219,
-0.0075755036,
-0.0560961924,
0.0070027937,
0.0120167891,
-0.0065382333,
0.032513205,
0.0000682835,
-0.0055829166,
-0.0296223387,
0.0097531155,
-0.0040330626,
0.0920834318,
0.0110093346,
0.0168953575,
-0.0143556073,
0.0216457043,
-0.0669390634,
-0.0239666309,
-0.0179772563,
0.0181288477,
0.0536148958,
-0.0246974472,
0.0370070338,
-0.0567225181,
-0.0320757069,
0.0062312461,
0.028144747,
0.0195559729,
-0.0182756279,
-0.0012515015,
0.0044947439,
0.0010031213,
0.0088727949,
0.074741587,
-0.0100682378,
0.0822006464,
-0.0479584187,
-0.0633737668,
-0.032170143,
-0.0849698335,
0.0209193174,
-0.0437728986,
-0.0038805299,
0.0222962778,
-0.0835379511,
-0.0441551432,
-0.015827965,
-0.0196848661,
0.0048425305,
-0.0095862625,
0.0166930221,
0.0476159006,
-0.0233106539,
-0.050226476,
-0.0103422198,
0.0078321565,
0.0044870111,
0.0158024617,
-0.0401180834,
-6.977033578e-33,
-0.0783463567,
-0.033208251,
0.0227939952,
0.0287514497,
-0.0250509772,
0.0007243722,
-0.0167474672,
0.0026455659,
-0.0034604277,
0.08162985,
0.016237326,
0.0588429235,
-0.0132663893,
-0.0103604086,
0.0085592279,
0.0025878923,
0.0683140159,
0.0085691987,
-0.0432748459,
0.0388544165,
0.0443424769,
-0.0078808274,
0.1055426896,
-0.0719151273,
0.0097234705,
0.0463063754,
-0.022020489,
-0.0115809934,
-0.077999711,
0.0348089151,
-0.004636833,
0.0299737435,
0.0312117897,
-0.0913458169,
-0.0131123504,
-0.0052957884,
-0.0651933253,
-0.046627868,
0.0055116243,
0.0182005335,
0.004987923,
-0.0413830802,
0.0233439263,
0.0080457153,
0.0224546958,
-0.0698865578,
0.0520714857,
0.0006771376,
0.0364844985,
-0.0522984155,
-0.1061123163,
-0.0049664574,
-0.0123231206,
-0.0080950195,
-0.040217638,
-0.0060755964,
0.0352617987,
0.0378656052,
-0.0605297238,
0.0151307127,
0.0637433082,
0.0426184498,
0.0161134694,
-0.0125984484,
0.002107756,
0.0580199957,
-0.0366652645,
0.0158336516,
-0.0261860564,
0.0072274711,
-0.0081550665,
0.0308936574,
0.032267902,
0.0408038273,
0.0492537655,
0.0256434195,
-0.0602360703,
0.0026880733,
-0.0926482007,
0.0286885668,
-0.0071653756,
0.0056726923,
0.0362435728,
0.0102282856,
-0.0218533184,
0.0144450469,
-0.0232805498,
0.0104683358,
0.0195659865,
0.0135877868,
0.0069883913,
0.0211765748,
0.0091999024,
-0.0149368588,
0.0656879097,
-0.0113003505,
-0.0353455022,
0.0379819423,
-0.0109099532,
0.0007445856,
-0.0573000386,
-0.0025808692,
0.0594761148,
0.0028069625,
0.031536296,
0.0332681425,
0.0956451297,
0.0185421817,
-0.0529243648,
0.0025597655,
0.001052325,
-0.0007146951,
-0.0231959168,
-0.0437984504,
0.0097549725,
0.0271084979,
-0.0286491364,
0.0047854981,
0.0747613162,
0.0510013066,
-0.0104381535,
0.0242562853,
0.008547144,
0.0006739265,
0.0141770728,
-0.0118215168,
-0.042504631,
-0.0326670632,
0.0184852742,
-0.05638621,
-0.0370039754,
-0.0240631308,
3.015e-7,
0.0872260705,
0.0580045246,
0.023190761,
0.0102087706,
0.0478599593,
0.0263701491,
0.0242468733,
0.0038234273,
0.0306957625,
-0.0137003418,
0.036540702,
0.0404367857,
-0.0050306963,
0.0207771976,
-0.0687780753,
-0.0089230882,
-0.0111959241,
-0.0188626349,
-0.0216084365,
0.006421349,
0.0472466014,
0.0548302867,
0.0261409115,
-0.0012069029,
0.0260650404,
0.0129420785,
0.0807505324,
-0.0163862631,
0.0039829086,
0.0364879109,
0.0265449751,
0.0298181884,
-0.001820348,
0.0218106471,
0.0006889724,
-0.0272070598,
-0.0130814696,
0.0291189216,
-0.0023172649,
0.0026673565,
-0.0359397754,
0.0154833496,
-0.004993164,
-0.0622185208,
0.0337268636,
-0.118162781,
-0.0165998135,
0.0170794874,
-0.0310279205,
0.0328486115,
0.0256082322,
0.0096917404,
0.0089494307,
-0.0102399401,
-0.0241186377,
0.0645121112,
-0.0177013017,
-0.0655329898,
-0.0181900971,
0.0237760264,
-0.0397258326,
-0.0775589794,
0.0055766664,
-0.0489308946,
0.0128554245,
-0.0172073748,
-0.0213878676,
2.791836506e-34,
-0.0128722126,
0.027062647,
0.0431413054,
-0.0345684104,
0.0358813107,
-0.0367457159,
-0.0452777445,
-0.009815474,
-0.0261089709,
-0.049615819,
-0.0105020078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15938v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15938v1 | RuleR: Improving LLM Controllability by Rule-based Data Recycling | 2024-06-22T20:57:12 | 2024-06-22T20:57:12 | Ming Li, Han Chen, Chenguang Wang, Dang Nguyen, Dianqi Li, Tianyi Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) still lack delicate controllability over their
responses, which is critical to enhancing their performance and the user
experience. However, curating supervised fine-tuning (SFT) datasets to improve
LLM controllability usually relies on human experts or proprietary LLMs, which
requires additional costs. To bridge this gap, we propose Rule-based Data
Recycling (RuleR), a data augmentation method incorporating multiple
constraints into the original data samples according to predefined rules, which
creates new training tasks to consolidate the controllability of LLMs. Instead
of creating new data from scratch, RuleR ``recycles'' existing data by simply
applying rule-based edits to their responses and appending the
rule-instructions in their original instructions. Experimental results
demonstrate RuleR's effectiveness in improving LLM controllability while
maintaining general instruction-following capabilities. The code will be
released on https://github.com/MingLiiii/RuleR. | [
0.0499935672,
0.090589352,
-0.0267952774,
0.044194404,
-0.0145370206,
0.0060386057,
-0.0470073558,
0.0075558536,
-0.0065244394,
-0.0233268719,
-0.0699228048,
-0.001538018,
-0.0210368596,
0.01375564,
0.019695092,
-0.0627902746,
0.0372347683,
-0.0427034236,
-0.0039439248,
0.0108804824,
0.0184408855,
-0.0049699233,
0.0029082021,
0.0329576507,
-0.0149572892,
0.0086246422,
0.0080903592,
0.0131814033,
-0.0232726187,
0.0008284091,
0.0647321567,
0.0653299391,
0.0096497163,
0.043620415,
0.0000021473,
-0.0579000749,
-0.0268225092,
-0.0169474408,
-0.0150977448,
0.0442786328,
0.064332284,
-0.033851698,
-0.033017341,
0.0343662985,
-0.0516109727,
0.0028779784,
0.0320951529,
0.0408830307,
0.1114431322,
0.0925049558,
-0.0025604744,
-0.0110942135,
-0.0011216652,
-0.0260893032,
0.0111940354,
-0.0223971345,
0.0096140979,
0.0099144829,
0.0075042639,
-0.0204263739,
-0.0183049366,
0.0422533676,
0.0167070404,
-0.0292762816,
-0.0306972228,
-0.0284930095,
-0.0400856026,
-0.0184771195,
-0.0330207758,
0.0567528941,
-0.0175057538,
-0.0366926491,
0.0130432788,
-0.0120266927,
0.0149510922,
0.0072030015,
-0.06376037,
-0.0023645686,
0.016068019,
0.0360654667,
-0.0242311098,
-0.0531001873,
0.0258770697,
-0.0103598665,
-0.0442287885,
0.0925511345,
0.0133435214,
-0.0250085685,
-0.0296402909,
-0.0009072444,
0.0180688296,
-0.0419629477,
0.0079799127,
0.0418101586,
-0.0679913908,
0.0193478875,
-0.0769789591,
-0.0403051153,
0.0152591541,
-0.0076674623,
0.0688291788,
0.0530969054,
-0.0143252928,
0.0248597283,
-0.0187503994,
0.0352805033,
-0.0108088888,
0.0503772721,
-0.0401793085,
0.015355357,
-0.0600757189,
-0.0186409354,
-0.022939302,
0.0152275646,
-0.032827463,
0.0192398801,
-0.0295784995,
0.0444286577,
-0.0167823825,
-0.0026531601,
0.018950019,
-0.032544136,
-0.0179230291,
0.0039085527,
0.00240286,
0.0148368096,
-0.0238595642,
0.0051527508,
0.0087093003,
-0.0615347996,
-0.0038547316,
-0.0124334153,
-0.0007559571,
-0.0179196242,
0.0047158753,
0.083321847,
-0.0235390104,
-0.0061716191,
-0.0569632053,
-0.0385344625,
-0.0071869679,
-0.0312767588,
-0.0061101085,
-0.056859564,
0.0123372292,
-0.0110327862,
-0.0179613661,
-0.0735473409,
-0.0026406532,
0.009327394,
-0.0206665043,
0.0483021438,
-0.0484198034,
0.0179181769,
-0.0051390696,
0.0158210751,
-0.027222408,
0.0703170672,
0.0466602333,
0.0124485558,
0.0385299101,
-0.0119092846,
0.0547005087,
0.0710899457,
0.0117516294,
0.0205662064,
-0.0489416346,
-0.0344962887,
0.001280112,
0.0113201514,
0.0627140626,
0.0368828364,
-0.0165851973,
0.0197311379,
0.0440801457,
0.0110875228,
0.0316372886,
0.0238481015,
0.0223312899,
-0.0169418789,
0.0195785556,
0.0217348728,
-0.0784816667,
-0.0028893768,
0.0149813266,
0.0326992236,
-0.0263677072,
0.0318543948,
0.0013232991,
-0.05755971,
-0.0026571879,
-0.0030137016,
0.0165834706,
0.0006567268,
0.0437860824,
0.0355760045,
0.000155223,
0.0433609709,
0.0310413204,
-0.0854914933,
-0.0180570558,
-0.0626896024,
0.020284703,
0.0835605934,
0.0495864414,
-0.04656877,
-0.0533180311,
-0.0043015038,
0.0444362164,
-0.0013967904,
0.0491564907,
-0.0108676776,
0.0280117244,
-0.0443346165,
-0.0372731797,
-0.0066626328,
0.0291480459,
0.023412209,
0.0294552986,
-0.0312419385,
0.005233652,
-0.0131577579,
-0.0537573397,
0.0382663086,
0.0105493916,
-0.0216814987,
0.0064522391,
-0.0075904666,
0.0091646975,
-0.0061202142,
-0.0087199416,
-0.0111901388,
0.0534297451,
-0.0188051425,
0.0079156198,
-0.0120217549,
-0.045023527,
-0.0225654189,
0.05728269,
-0.0078104092,
-0.0194295142,
0.0210600756,
-0.0633684769,
-0.0531915724,
0.0044075754,
-0.0074698702,
0.0627022684,
-0.0293382704,
0.0269970801,
-0.0085762655,
-0.0040927385,
-0.0369323716,
0.0180307385,
-0.0129047036,
-0.0011354389,
0.0761188194,
-0.0015746757,
0.0056361575,
-0.0046437006,
-0.0109829633,
-0.0107961558,
-0.0236660596,
0.0253687762,
0.020966785,
0.0489678122,
-0.0424500443,
-0.0359085612,
-0.0160473809,
0.0018046764,
-0.0326393843,
0.0296636224,
0.0086008282,
0.0274085868,
-0.036262583,
-0.0323528834,
-0.0095463358,
-0.0351492539,
0.0143552208,
0.0150090614,
0.0162194259,
0.0030940345,
-0.0403604396,
-0.0555246286,
-0.0026445782,
0.0136543261,
-0.0318631344,
-0.0478186868,
0.0004776998,
-0.0738870874,
0.0197931696,
-0.0124546774,
0.0431446992,
-0.0074685114,
-0.0490236245,
0.0117795281,
-0.0322298296,
0.0386087224,
0.0430428609,
-0.041285038,
0.0239513256,
0.06951873,
-0.0214843489,
-0.0541673563,
0.0083492417,
0.024765173,
-0.0449444838,
-0.0403588712,
0.0057863947,
0.0191548355,
0.0602441207,
-0.0169246476,
0.0027008241,
-0.0412531905,
0.0277969576,
-0.0062812818,
-0.033900328,
-0.010498154,
0.0220410265,
-0.0644154921,
0.0423507802,
-0.0341101773,
-0.0841836557,
0.0505956337,
-0.0312637389,
-0.0151551906,
-0.0053006797,
-0.0274650902,
-0.045748625,
0.0489631929,
0.027781507,
0.0057178857,
-0.0122733321,
-0.0439853594,
-0.0504028872,
0.0061311102,
0.0322859809,
-0.0330564789,
0.063090004,
-0.0735501647,
-0.0063960985,
-0.0245569795,
-0.0415214039,
-0.0251716189,
-0.0043831971,
-0.0064971861,
-0.0284083374,
0.0436697192,
-0.0386506692,
-0.0157707706,
-0.0211010668,
0.029577272,
0.0607654825,
-0.0163797569,
-0.0032784331,
-0.0293457806,
-0.0107335169,
0.0446214676,
0.0546456613,
-0.0357670709,
-0.0184259787,
-0.0394651331,
0.0417337194,
0.0475524105,
-0.036741443,
-0.0096498681,
0.0460618436,
0.0516781025,
-0.0079519358,
-0.0132623902,
0.0147041567,
0.0701811835,
-0.0845749602,
-0.0197322983,
0.1032710522,
0.0405811407,
-0.0344368964,
0.0144568095,
-0.0198250096,
0.0832677037,
0.0462726913,
0.0525074042,
-0.0761126205,
-0.0349603966,
0.0338537619,
0.0598587655,
0.0132207768,
-0.0035092067,
-0.024709465,
-0.1041854471,
0.0314454623,
0.0089736348,
-0.061473161,
-0.0301307123,
-0.0130035589,
0.0114440322,
-0.0096899308,
0.0271652639,
0.0214644633,
-0.026787797,
-0.0073615666,
0.0097086178,
-0.041655574,
-0.0536538661,
-0.0221660566,
-0.0213628225,
0.0721969008,
0.0772801414,
0.0086642997,
0.0262247864,
-0.0259546898,
0.044044055,
-0.0099264011,
0.0060938504,
-0.0417655259,
0.01147273,
0.0400867723,
-0.0225614049,
0.0196598936,
0.0700522587,
-0.0051223235,
-0.0241215639,
0.009679608,
0.077830404,
-0.0004634074,
-0.0017170839,
-0.0130324857,
-0.0575062074,
0.0178524666,
0.0648849607,
0.0636909828,
-0.0449780449,
-0.0194096323,
-0.0702067465,
-0.0536398292,
-0.075208284,
-0.0280161649,
-0.0001683699,
-0.0285289865,
-0.0056356164,
-0.0730170384,
-0.0069757444,
0.0458529703,
0.035586331,
0.0268162787,
0.018927712,
-0.0075732404,
-0.0204502475,
-0.0287837349,
0.0008893711,
-0.0687254444,
0.0287570059,
-0.0925658122,
-0.0276103374,
-0.0075550112,
0.0043949243,
-0.0003132036,
0.0222338885,
-0.0465627499,
-0.0979364589,
0.0279973596,
0.0936905444,
0.0322633237,
0.0618293136,
-0.0024829388,
-0.0849668235,
0.009076518,
0.0307917427,
-0.0294219088,
0.0247516129,
0.0321726501,
-0.0072451988,
-0.0054224851,
0.0381279811,
-0.0755758286,
0.0138203083,
0.021855941,
0.0258957203,
-0.0270741228,
-0.0363074429,
0.017329108,
0.0225671362,
0.0033806458,
0.0006131945,
-0.0046104975,
-0.0182258766,
0.0250636488,
-0.0157905649,
-0.0048572668,
-0.0461643375,
0.0401610695,
-0.0160106737,
-0.0241854545,
-0.0009626803,
-0.01981158,
-0.01231171,
0.0094264261,
-0.0480719805,
0.0147549864,
-0.0159449633,
0.0022686783,
0.051265005,
0.0316054262,
0.0176912658,
0.0588639118,
0.0226656329,
0.0077800821,
-0.0139109232,
0.0245902948,
0.0318383053,
0.0200442746,
-0.0503766313,
0.0359662846,
-0.0564112477,
-0.0264094602,
-0.0035290043,
0.0036571575,
0.0401339084,
0.0043632998,
0.0805314109,
-0.0149227381,
-0.0180909224,
-0.0161426403,
0.0270348657,
0.0010502036,
0.0136419637,
0.0231451876,
0.0103480313,
-0.0098288879,
-0.0164179392,
0.0863781571,
0.0202828385,
0.0399027318,
-0.0164032485,
0.0124271316,
-0.0357377753,
-0.0190626327,
0.0058516827,
-0.0221574306,
-0.0246965662,
-0.0489903577,
-0.0273356568,
-0.0686452463,
-0.0139287626,
0.0374497138,
-0.008020795,
-0.036031317,
0.0235300343,
0.0333758257,
0.0054624043,
0.0061903582,
-0.0173162743,
-0.0386456214,
0.0582607388,
-0.048370596,
-0.0130849844,
-6.573428327e-33,
-0.0022641507,
0.0000676566,
0.0287073031,
0.0167022869,
-0.0346390605,
-0.0280199535,
-0.0417409427,
-0.0052101673,
0.0247509778,
-0.0070977891,
-0.0370413624,
0.0148476195,
0.0151717206,
0.0228447393,
0.0262996797,
0.0062620887,
0.0732475072,
0.0090184286,
-0.0464431159,
0.0282052569,
0.0206698906,
0.0541567765,
0.0475019701,
-0.0559833236,
-0.0013915916,
0.0365892984,
-0.006170758,
0.0486437157,
-0.0169748254,
0.075923115,
0.0268433206,
0.0200157147,
0.0188444797,
-0.0323339328,
-0.065847896,
0.0164206754,
-0.0720065013,
-0.0514251292,
0.0172730498,
0.01728113,
-0.0032108095,
-0.0532261916,
0.086595878,
-0.021081008,
0.0088198241,
0.0192083865,
0.0105202757,
-0.0279235635,
-0.0223494451,
-0.0172721036,
-0.0603492968,
0.0195552893,
0.0099619972,
-0.0360826626,
0.0093756486,
0.003974129,
0.0046072216,
-0.0248701628,
-0.0454707965,
0.0127382893,
0.0538354814,
0.0743340999,
0.0702641085,
0.0493334979,
-0.0063102851,
0.0276710596,
-0.0251640286,
-0.0010944012,
0.0077362093,
-0.0137601914,
0.0523880348,
0.0585396215,
0.0284850597,
0.0256717298,
0.0419925153,
-0.0550463721,
0.0074095624,
0.0253535993,
0.0201328713,
0.0531177744,
-0.0221736785,
0.0752369016,
0.0016178587,
-0.0210681483,
-0.0145081803,
0.0315571912,
-0.0365721732,
-0.0234804191,
0.0529375002,
0.0233147144,
-0.0413802415,
-0.0401614234,
0.0284702703,
-0.0154270744,
-0.041439373,
-0.000578747,
-0.021899147,
0.0414748006,
-0.0045217732,
0.0103625851,
-0.0296059567,
-0.0208199136,
0.020048622,
-0.0119483471,
0.0375445448,
0.0046305191,
0.0464210697,
0.0551569387,
-0.0764243975,
0.0186160374,
-0.0207371078,
0.0365529507,
0.0022065355,
0.0008234912,
0.0136479177,
-0.0127333421,
0.0077998787,
0.0275911894,
0.0090656728,
-0.02690164,
-0.0539369322,
0.0053536356,
0.04083018,
0.0116299372,
-0.0205194838,
-0.0188034698,
-0.0529557727,
0.0549804382,
0.0380899273,
-0.051887963,
-0.0132100787,
-0.0011884278,
2.843e-7,
0.0476439521,
0.0356132127,
0.0004145913,
0.0201497134,
0.0344026871,
0.0104243169,
-0.0590429828,
-0.0164489169,
0.0075580184,
0.0146025177,
-0.0080110412,
0.0022061712,
0.0620161444,
0.0035001079,
-0.082730554,
-0.0054440191,
-0.0358479768,
0.0032355848,
-0.0419159494,
-0.013068717,
0.040271055,
0.0975784063,
0.0055484101,
-0.0155732697,
0.0030402178,
-0.0299010742,
0.0070572202,
-0.0441122614,
0.0144778043,
0.0248174239,
0.054485701,
0.0343890525,
-0.001353836,
-0.0411599986,
-0.0401148088,
0.0065177968,
-0.0386221185,
0.0751052201,
0.0026500451,
0.0178472362,
0.0095535051,
-0.0281123277,
-0.0048844311,
-0.0106330328,
0.0576103218,
-0.0419968143,
0.0256016441,
-0.0209610667,
0.012699171,
-0.0261452664,
-0.0280421786,
-0.0394247659,
-0.0199331995,
0.0275915042,
0.0282658786,
0.0099957818,
-0.0423074327,
-0.0594991967,
-0.0191010591,
0.0175911263,
-0.0118483976,
-0.040556334,
-0.068784304,
0.0054365261,
-0.0316514336,
-0.0660482123,
-0.0088526858,
3.016230572e-34,
0.027596768,
-0.0456099063,
0.0262630787,
0.0410677344,
0.0389285274,
-0.0000496985,
0.0106611541,
0.0545917302,
0.0094564278,
-0.0707756504,
-0.0243726224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15927v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15927v1 | Semantic Entropy Probes: Robust and Cheap Hallucination Detection in LLMs | 2024-06-22T19:46:06 | 2024-06-22T19:46:06 | Jannik Kossen, Jiatong Han, Muhammed Razzak, Lisa Schut, Shreshth Malik, Yarin Gal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We propose semantic entropy probes (SEPs), a cheap and reliable method for
uncertainty quantification in Large Language Models (LLMs). Hallucinations,
which are plausible-sounding but factually incorrect and arbitrary model
generations, present a major challenge to the practical adoption of LLMs.
Recent work by Farquhar et al. (2024) proposes semantic entropy (SE), which can
detect hallucinations by estimating uncertainty in the space semantic meaning
for a set of model generations. However, the 5-to-10-fold increase in
computation cost associated with SE computation hinders practical adoption. To
address this, we propose SEPs, which directly approximate SE from the hidden
states of a single generation. SEPs are simple to train and do not require
sampling multiple model generations at test time, reducing the overhead of
semantic uncertainty quantification to almost zero. We show that SEPs retain
high performance for hallucination detection and generalize better to
out-of-distribution data than previous probing methods that directly predict
model accuracy. Our results across models and tasks suggest that model hidden
states capture SE, and our ablation studies give further insights into the
token positions and model layers for which this is the case. | [
-0.0167687163,
0.06839706,
-0.0026072718,
0.0510789827,
-0.0430860817,
0.0130653586,
-0.0219093189,
0.0362095647,
-0.0361039937,
-0.0528699011,
0.0015895962,
-0.0849133059,
0.0206885878,
-0.0317099616,
0.0140242903,
-0.02452478,
0.0760937184,
-0.0564194731,
-0.0224391203,
-0.0196502171,
-0.0479484126,
-0.0200092588,
0.000857572,
0.0542174838,
-0.0174256433,
-0.0299750865,
-0.0280381702,
0.0389601402,
0.002060527,
-0.0147465216,
-0.0258300081,
0.0596284494,
-0.0033455163,
0.1169742793,
0.0000019868,
-0.0473837741,
-0.0112881158,
0.0140261566,
-0.0230573397,
0.0288883001,
0.0339798629,
0.0321869515,
-0.0413854122,
0.0134878596,
0.0012687596,
0.0116792377,
0.0573522821,
0.0171814431,
0.0135464845,
0.0384475589,
-0.0004731784,
-0.0229811613,
0.0320944004,
0.0023083664,
0.0585264303,
-0.0187684149,
0.0293544549,
-0.0319609828,
-0.0587082915,
-0.0466274582,
-0.0169514138,
0.06233963,
0.0287837368,
0.0236795191,
-0.0201665033,
0.0231456794,
0.0096224993,
-0.0216665454,
0.0031005684,
0.0041831005,
-0.0571199507,
-0.030560391,
0.0068173604,
-0.0168892816,
-0.0019558484,
-0.0240793973,
0.0055221571,
0.0124489237,
-0.0022489624,
0.0262396168,
0.0247349627,
0.002951517,
0.0616552047,
0.0013986985,
-0.0347074941,
0.0922955573,
0.0229957756,
-0.0390794352,
-0.0010535155,
0.0028782706,
-0.0047272337,
-0.0446177833,
-0.0120972591,
0.0026326787,
-0.0444163047,
0.0240029395,
-0.0495170094,
-0.0245332737,
0.0273639429,
-0.049631726,
-0.0129005099,
0.0198933948,
-0.0252593867,
0.0374266841,
-0.0032841922,
0.0231132265,
-0.0051213629,
0.0606655329,
-0.0240017623,
-0.0140877953,
0.0038443459,
-0.0072410456,
-0.0256192237,
0.0068061128,
-0.0010998645,
-0.0390366428,
-0.0202924181,
0.0041421936,
-0.0295988806,
0.0143917808,
-0.0415223353,
0.0238458756,
0.0143776732,
-0.0052780281,
-0.0099524353,
0.0071472954,
0.017066123,
-0.0151523035,
0.0236901324,
-0.0854041725,
-0.0333167352,
0.0282318313,
-0.0295503903,
0.0027292296,
0.0226680394,
0.0354477242,
0.0222936329,
-0.0358813964,
-0.0491340682,
-0.0307635237,
-0.0362301618,
-0.0556171685,
0.028987227,
-0.0547427423,
-0.0312265325,
-0.0116012199,
0.0067606084,
-0.0708424002,
0.0281648394,
0.0054276548,
-0.0408732481,
0.0897789374,
-0.0481055304,
0.0015598985,
-0.0001625589,
0.0302428138,
0.0050073816,
0.1130424663,
0.0371001549,
0.0455076061,
0.0351774246,
0.0109301256,
0.0097153112,
0.0263111033,
-0.0020953014,
0.0213652998,
-0.0526401065,
-0.0429713726,
-0.0076442156,
0.0263768118,
0.017400261,
0.0789436102,
-0.0072073969,
-0.0384896286,
0.0515418537,
0.043758601,
-0.0256330483,
-0.0177275762,
0.0111615509,
-0.0096507911,
0.0029403295,
-0.0027406544,
-0.0623892918,
0.0015560753,
-0.0354279391,
0.0118179629,
0.077157706,
-0.0152117722,
-0.0137621537,
-0.0690511093,
-0.0502554104,
-0.0030915546,
-0.0041656168,
0.028384991,
0.0381936915,
0.0093081202,
-0.0357094705,
0.1002593413,
0.0284797233,
-0.0419867449,
-0.004932995,
-0.0736096576,
0.023761183,
0.0902847052,
0.0573854446,
-0.0404703766,
0.0161252469,
-0.0084278025,
0.0050678928,
0.0518975481,
-0.0002354838,
0.0191625804,
0.048952885,
-0.0403413661,
-0.0052174386,
0.0093970159,
0.0672868416,
-0.0079842275,
0.0140013136,
-0.0073851882,
0.0091372915,
-0.0551964194,
-0.0241885968,
0.0469808988,
-0.0010421303,
0.000102037,
0.004670104,
-0.0158938766,
0.0311488006,
0.0043856641,
-0.0303073805,
0.0384099968,
0.0229036119,
-0.0323337987,
-0.0376686901,
-0.0067851925,
-0.033157859,
-0.0069506303,
0.0451733433,
0.0209625252,
-0.0071749375,
0.0057836915,
-0.0350919776,
-0.0309446603,
0.0224235654,
-0.0573046096,
0.0565941669,
-0.0615629032,
0.0319086649,
-0.0437912829,
0.0422661789,
-0.0269734934,
0.05847295,
-0.061461702,
0.0114139589,
0.0076450533,
0.0164660197,
-0.0008894287,
-0.0035987971,
-0.0537026115,
0.003738754,
-0.0143666584,
0.0139059555,
-0.0316100009,
-0.0197328329,
-0.034217447,
-0.0064801229,
-0.057865981,
-0.0017092105,
-0.029043898,
0.0033377374,
0.0265301373,
-0.0079391161,
0.0015542402,
-0.0031774344,
0.0118734492,
0.0319011435,
-0.0119977398,
0.030854363,
-0.0027661077,
-0.0197518058,
-0.0396160446,
-0.0319451094,
-0.0028189372,
-0.0136767514,
0.0575748645,
-0.0435572863,
-0.0171468761,
-0.0838370398,
0.0647846982,
-0.0180934258,
0.0376580171,
0.0116077689,
-0.0304346569,
0.0201700982,
-0.0222667567,
0.006130565,
0.0525961667,
0.0186961312,
0.0529919714,
0.0827506781,
-0.0256410651,
-0.0160684101,
-0.0083764978,
0.0019767962,
0.0281165689,
-0.0271373577,
-0.0384772643,
-0.015289912,
0.0826783404,
0.0097353151,
-0.0034275588,
-0.0581340417,
-0.0035637051,
-0.0441463664,
-0.0644619912,
-0.005808332,
0.0096967136,
-0.0435821488,
0.0439070463,
-0.0111131975,
-0.0476515032,
0.0613561347,
-0.0681115761,
-0.0017534302,
0.0016653914,
-0.0099219494,
0.0400371812,
0.0582011864,
0.0021555368,
0.0017776635,
0.0157259107,
-0.0001944879,
-0.0235302467,
-0.0177259874,
-0.0081077907,
-0.0396405049,
0.0295097176,
-0.0400799774,
0.0049418896,
0.0227135681,
-0.0101412954,
-0.0517347343,
-0.0271817874,
-0.0500323474,
-0.0014276387,
-0.0090479506,
-0.0256710202,
-0.0103664137,
0.0085510639,
-0.0098947957,
0.02967236,
-0.0001498843,
-0.0250755809,
-0.0161054693,
0.0015287612,
0.070310764,
-0.0039622197,
0.0986647978,
-0.0355926901,
0.0105553512,
0.0810688436,
0.0375769585,
0.0591829754,
-0.0481058136,
-0.0375647917,
0.0374016464,
-0.0035922846,
-0.0013421302,
0.0384399258,
0.0387886092,
-0.0435074195,
-0.0416811295,
0.1230717823,
0.0386010706,
-0.0390089005,
0.0173267238,
-0.048528444,
0.0863693208,
0.0195627064,
-0.0395843461,
-0.0920566767,
-0.0550893582,
0.0368082561,
0.0239784922,
-0.0354051255,
-0.0037838097,
0.0060453978,
-0.0804429203,
0.0159976818,
-0.0022301662,
-0.0335958861,
0.0038992397,
-0.0258368235,
0.0168069806,
0.0226470456,
0.056823425,
-0.0112891132,
0.0189788267,
-0.0198271573,
0.0147267245,
-0.0492404848,
-0.0464377925,
0.0499662422,
-0.0171510298,
0.0685205683,
0.0733927116,
0.0086553041,
0.0024963422,
-0.0765244216,
0.0386691988,
-0.0351937301,
-0.011245681,
-0.0017529866,
0.0399409644,
0.0216823835,
0.0043584504,
0.019137904,
-0.0026626231,
-0.0354901664,
-0.0090364804,
-0.035745047,
0.0451274589,
-0.0474986471,
-0.0498076081,
0.0040584099,
0.0035190976,
0.017985655,
0.0840251967,
0.0440472513,
-0.0203451831,
-0.078115508,
-0.0269150864,
0.0534313507,
-0.0218884293,
-0.0221932866,
0.0359159186,
0.0439764969,
-0.0842405781,
-0.0340420455,
0.0086208722,
-0.0066672335,
0.0229803883,
-0.0289050527,
0.0244072881,
-0.006764533,
0.003301088,
-0.071104303,
-0.0040192981,
-0.0404705591,
0.0328738168,
-0.0436350703,
0.0126487305,
0.014662046,
0.0287589226,
-0.0187603328,
0.0566234253,
-0.1280519068,
-0.0881148949,
0.0610244088,
0.0233415961,
0.0308904201,
0.0211788006,
-0.0553986952,
-0.0510685891,
0.0934916064,
0.031551525,
-0.0086693307,
0.033740554,
0.0387422256,
-0.0115600135,
0.0064694732,
0.0552138835,
-0.0165092777,
-0.0332300998,
0.0214233249,
0.0137631167,
-0.0074943141,
-0.0233777147,
-0.001147425,
0.0062378207,
0.0481394678,
-0.0378683321,
-0.017786419,
0.0219170228,
0.0121483328,
0.0103231324,
0.0010835483,
-0.0339473933,
-0.0056947749,
0.024427576,
-0.034715943,
-0.006144484,
0.0030835257,
0.0072980323,
0.0114980787,
0.0082609579,
-0.0401283465,
-0.0041034375,
0.0286624357,
0.0456023328,
-0.0142474165,
-0.0145540424,
0.0287629776,
-0.0188319329,
0.0218392722,
0.0226062238,
0.0230875853,
0.022369951,
-0.0210590996,
-0.0370152816,
0.0338003859,
-0.0700718388,
-0.0818214267,
-0.0092041027,
0.0443929881,
0.0610770844,
0.0603635572,
0.0622583479,
-0.0369512066,
0.0085229455,
-0.0097525399,
0.0140385404,
0.0260530245,
-0.0581641905,
0.0248139091,
0.0137462961,
-0.0272210259,
-0.0022401069,
0.0565697961,
0.0075244806,
0.0669858009,
0.002923653,
-0.0315978862,
-0.0111992704,
-0.0533127002,
-0.0385951363,
0.0105650472,
-0.0453725532,
-0.0147196455,
-0.0637966841,
-0.0684598312,
-0.0123567702,
0.0247948878,
0.005148882,
-0.0074971099,
0.0201810542,
0.0682525113,
0.0038040483,
-0.0377159864,
-0.0134779792,
-0.0321865678,
0.0385067426,
-0.014417408,
0.0094575854,
-6.519365873e-33,
-0.000557721,
-0.0307081584,
-0.0076151905,
-0.047620669,
-0.000478843,
-0.026973797,
-0.0341801718,
0.0299705509,
0.0161429103,
0.0185836107,
0.0049080416,
0.03758635,
0.0328004658,
0.0202307794,
0.0108391885,
-0.0518755652,
0.061775364,
-0.0048346729,
-0.0119050974,
0.0147428997,
0.0516520478,
-0.0011199355,
0.0640876442,
-0.0101373848,
0.0128620397,
0.0152201233,
-0.035310626,
0.0333081335,
-0.0165857356,
-0.0037995449,
-0.0425884798,
0.0406186394,
-0.0075403047,
-0.0446211323,
-0.0178862028,
-0.0413397588,
-0.0285630524,
-0.0204775389,
-0.0055401186,
0.0434295684,
-0.0501565076,
-0.0293991901,
0.0459669046,
0.0136901569,
-0.0253660567,
0.0053144093,
0.0037156898,
-0.0135828536,
-0.018289553,
-0.0396691039,
-0.027835682,
0.0094505046,
0.0177603252,
-0.0175124779,
0.0359279141,
-0.0003193314,
-0.0049616126,
-0.0462353155,
-0.0653999001,
-0.0048579262,
0.0122433985,
0.0324643254,
0.0539760701,
0.0275036581,
0.0030516256,
0.0643000379,
0.0498299226,
-0.0088900737,
-0.0227859188,
0.0053702164,
0.0653918684,
0.0292205829,
0.0346955769,
-0.0130769312,
0.0707381666,
-0.0071063251,
-0.0265375208,
0.0095472923,
-0.000688833,
0.019585412,
0.0633763149,
0.0188608468,
-0.0340233594,
-0.0434865579,
-0.0318144597,
-0.003507022,
-0.0278194509,
-0.0268166196,
0.0355284736,
-0.0084703183,
-0.0175480861,
-0.0356698856,
0.04239415,
-0.0310118236,
0.0080175297,
0.019175712,
-0.0010964767,
0.0181639008,
0.0095813116,
0.0175741203,
0.0200715847,
-0.0205036812,
0.0329758525,
0.0105817327,
0.0299732834,
-0.0115192607,
-0.0133284256,
0.0104364268,
-0.0677597597,
0.0250042584,
-0.0341153257,
0.0167279746,
0.000600337,
-0.0376770161,
0.0383260734,
-0.0221715234,
0.0015991735,
-0.0039069634,
0.0063332221,
0.052182883,
-0.0105158268,
0.07202553,
-0.028822789,
0.0224686936,
-0.0165151134,
-0.0279782265,
-0.0457000099,
-0.0282770731,
0.052367609,
-0.0452744551,
-0.0198259819,
-0.0028193977,
2.749e-7,
0.0147874234,
0.0425165519,
0.0012187365,
0.0312154721,
0.035884928,
0.0453137085,
0.0168213006,
-0.0153344283,
-0.0137714399,
-0.0510398299,
-0.0152946301,
0.0155322738,
0.07362362,
0.0569468737,
-0.0726327449,
-0.0360996686,
-0.044140365,
0.0317940041,
-0.0419697054,
-0.0082684681,
0.0232802387,
0.0914748833,
0.0387958623,
-0.0262879841,
0.0340711661,
-0.0382036231,
0.0300629642,
-0.0317891464,
0.0404749066,
0.0204412118,
0.0479518957,
0.0002767426,
0.0330189615,
0.0040719365,
0.0085326331,
-0.0293419659,
-0.028861871,
0.0064771939,
-0.0126306666,
-0.055247426,
-0.0482153669,
-0.0175007079,
0.0066205026,
-0.0717495605,
0.0673998147,
0.0145735433,
-0.0149855129,
-0.0324637257,
0.0209866688,
-0.0243141428,
0.0517071225,
0.0047483165,
-0.0222601742,
-0.0001181192,
0.0031625545,
0.0042603225,
-0.02109598,
-0.0706560984,
-0.0426291563,
-0.0081056403,
-0.0529554524,
-0.0171706919,
-0.0223424379,
0.0142673217,
0.0083275996,
-0.1040650755,
-0.0035935172,
2.858993738e-34,
0.0513243154,
0.0048701512,
0.0148600945,
0.0427857339,
0.0189547241,
0.0098187346,
0.0411149897,
-0.0121371178,
-0.0108563965,
-0.0502100401,
-0.0025753342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15891v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15891v1 | The Unlikely Duel: Evaluating Creative Writing in LLMs through a Unique Scenario | 2024-06-22T17:01:59 | 2024-06-22T17:01:59 | Carlos Gómez-Rodríguez, Paul Williams | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | This is a summary of the paper "A Confederacy of Models: a Comprehensive
Evaluation of LLMs on Creative Writing", which was published in Findings of
EMNLP 2023. We evaluate a range of recent state-of-the-art, instruction-tuned
large language models (LLMs) on an English creative writing task, and compare
them to human writers. For this purpose, we use a specifically-tailored prompt
(based on an epic combat between Ignatius J. Reilly, main character of John
Kennedy Toole's "A Confederacy of Dunces", and a pterodactyl) to minimize the
risk of training data leakage and force the models to be creative rather than
reusing existing stories. The same prompt is presented to LLMs and human
writers, and evaluation is performed by humans using a detailed rubric
including various aspects like fluency, style, originality or humor. Results
show that some state-of-the-art commercial LLMs match or slightly outperform
our human writers in most of the evaluated dimensions. Open-source LLMs lag
behind. Humans keep a close lead in originality, and only the top three LLMs
can handle humor at human-like levels. | [
0.0573315173,
0.0297308248,
-0.010674159,
0.0105958851,
-0.0490064919,
0.0103969714,
0.0199813191,
0.0110934116,
-0.024057338,
-0.0508527644,
-0.0272953827,
-0.0265472736,
-0.0065298495,
0.0241932236,
0.0180433039,
0.0061112721,
-0.0028026935,
-0.0372603014,
0.0241518579,
-0.0185436215,
-0.0331334732,
0.0258704815,
-0.0001327662,
0.0434030145,
0.0213927701,
-0.0426826701,
0.0056863008,
0.0440150686,
0.0021194657,
-0.017839117,
0.0085313553,
0.0465338863,
0.0161839891,
0.0402305201,
0.0000019885,
-0.0622808188,
0.0112105738,
-0.032762073,
0.0212076325,
0.0305266511,
0.0550307296,
0.0391563065,
-0.0367273763,
-0.0079311533,
-0.0037501762,
0.0552523173,
0.0389459431,
0.0502383821,
0.0640395507,
0.0899139866,
0.0157749597,
-0.0528456978,
0.0401791967,
-0.026869813,
0.0053463811,
0.0310109481,
0.0104353614,
0.0252972506,
0.023931222,
-0.0339568928,
-0.0134150283,
0.0092672603,
0.0136869438,
-0.0384437852,
0.0027328455,
0.0347328074,
0.0026590647,
0.0451041386,
-0.020005364,
-0.0012706446,
0.0063509089,
-0.0036561121,
-0.0150320372,
0.0184877422,
0.007936528,
0.0064223041,
-0.0384851247,
0.0367530994,
0.0056571136,
-0.0001438957,
0.0306426585,
-0.0195958633,
-0.0039990172,
0.0211906824,
0.0588423498,
0.016136596,
0.0334106497,
-0.0160472374,
-0.0219896641,
0.0051279739,
-0.0137368934,
-0.0751964599,
0.0165001769,
0.0495231524,
-0.0205327142,
-0.0103644021,
-0.0514628068,
0.0002332467,
-0.0040401598,
-0.0822214782,
0.099038735,
0.0123412535,
0.0237346999,
0.0352705531,
-0.00519204,
0.0472491607,
-0.0040107938,
0.0391918719,
-0.0189834964,
0.0608784072,
-0.0446100086,
-0.0080329888,
-0.0413809344,
0.0143651534,
-0.0260153394,
-0.0388677083,
-0.042403724,
-0.0121492622,
0.0135132372,
0.0032946945,
0.0198527928,
0.0466397479,
-0.0222877152,
-0.0103860274,
-0.0375218019,
0.0052371523,
0.0113135763,
-0.0018437566,
0.0030203266,
0.0057411026,
0.0023713959,
0.0141588403,
-0.0169910714,
-0.0574871004,
0.0360410362,
0.0590947755,
-0.026179919,
-0.0305365603,
-0.053391397,
0.0017184878,
-0.0074657639,
-0.0511335395,
-0.0079143085,
-0.0659469739,
0.0167398304,
-0.0120108156,
0.0297214407,
-0.0671110749,
-0.0120535521,
0.0025006279,
-0.0162755251,
-0.0175158307,
0.0038426537,
0.0369419567,
0.0305442214,
0.0050367252,
-0.0148425186,
0.0180057697,
0.1016226336,
0.0575267673,
0.0087100146,
0.000307449,
0.0228185076,
0.0174957905,
-0.0579764284,
0.009361119,
-0.0647167191,
-0.011953041,
-0.0036221887,
0.088895984,
0.0373999327,
0.0843376294,
-0.0114571806,
0.0356993042,
0.1309906244,
0.0268189162,
0.0459424704,
0.0406680107,
0.0943614021,
-0.0053061708,
0.0368266106,
0.0399046615,
-0.0049832324,
0.0049463375,
-0.0146523667,
0.0219480377,
0.0072235125,
0.0295623392,
0.0042552566,
-0.01026484,
-0.0201514941,
0.0048868591,
-0.0261160024,
-0.0184277426,
-0.0198075138,
-0.002231013,
-0.0594902039,
-0.0114787435,
0.00990617,
-0.0584318005,
0.0029220504,
-0.0103372075,
0.0545037873,
0.1187979206,
0.0790095925,
0.0159294903,
-0.0051923371,
-0.047060091,
0.0121576581,
0.04578555,
0.0266407579,
-0.0049355975,
0.0123658376,
-0.0165560171,
0.0156742018,
-0.0756926611,
0.0188813657,
-0.0145754749,
-0.029853873,
0.0219095033,
-0.0217494704,
0.019086428,
-0.0659207702,
0.0603730977,
-0.0786525831,
-0.0515723228,
-0.0184663534,
-0.0235132053,
0.0147454934,
0.0079865353,
-0.0882683843,
0.0047356193,
0.0098212967,
-0.0581076071,
-0.0250166915,
0.0282460358,
-0.0227387957,
-0.0146600418,
0.0327991806,
-0.0664508715,
0.0159935523,
-0.0015107994,
0.0246027615,
-0.0077555217,
0.0103189768,
-0.0582625009,
0.022121314,
-0.0161823649,
0.0387280434,
-0.0357453153,
-0.0381241441,
-0.0290345494,
0.0469062775,
-0.0148531748,
0.0286645833,
-0.0066471891,
-0.0013645403,
-0.0170262586,
-0.0068886811,
-0.0325031132,
0.0157450195,
0.0490364842,
0.0234560724,
-0.0093981186,
0.0120501285,
-0.0154239032,
-0.098774448,
-0.0412815958,
0.0336171053,
0.0133516602,
0.005449872,
0.0284800455,
-0.0412944406,
-0.0578306504,
0.0497153103,
-0.0377624556,
-0.0653833151,
-0.0048951516,
-0.0210856758,
0.0226723608,
-0.0070878454,
-0.0150985923,
-0.0142827164,
0.0022655313,
0.0036073183,
0.0642033368,
0.0422282815,
0.0373495184,
-0.0262783356,
0.0922928676,
-0.0263189431,
-0.0414470844,
-0.0170605481,
-0.0486865528,
0.0174522493,
-0.009510952,
0.0465769246,
0.0653848425,
0.0264691915,
0.0060108509,
0.0808902755,
-0.0371340401,
0.0051684221,
-0.0087715844,
0.0186307915,
0.003811931,
-0.05470277,
-0.0521776155,
0.0038499907,
0.0533082746,
0.0149466321,
0.0048792576,
-0.0249877442,
0.0695412084,
-0.0057302648,
-0.0402260907,
-0.007464292,
-0.0385343842,
-0.0222758371,
0.0239666682,
-0.0316707529,
-0.0318296179,
0.0636333451,
-0.031314481,
-0.0137260864,
-0.0163279176,
0.0112727452,
-0.0508819744,
0.0662426725,
-0.0002729627,
0.0433516167,
-0.0054490394,
0.0091029704,
-0.0600226335,
-0.0199061129,
0.0478797331,
-0.0366693214,
0.0413864255,
-0.0117634796,
-0.0298411902,
-0.0187100843,
-0.014828844,
-0.0239137057,
-0.0142352628,
-0.025560474,
0.0072628944,
0.0531086139,
-0.0229577757,
-0.0256557167,
-0.0388343781,
0.0413759798,
-0.012721356,
-0.0209731609,
-0.0189012811,
0.0033208868,
0.0228282958,
0.041879762,
-0.0018270594,
-0.0285381302,
-0.0567629859,
0.0240556151,
-0.0036142094,
-0.0458330922,
0.0219988674,
-0.0319835208,
0.0206651501,
0.0275355726,
-0.01681762,
-0.0135202156,
0.0114121707,
0.0626996085,
-0.0631018505,
-0.0202027485,
0.1167149171,
0.0219985638,
0.0054069385,
0.0034695407,
0.0125046773,
0.0093478058,
0.0195789989,
0.0363151059,
-0.0372048095,
0.0024523044,
0.0011659962,
0.023523977,
-0.0124383783,
-0.0284117647,
-0.0319017358,
-0.0886700898,
0.0474627055,
0.0270758029,
0.0072646779,
0.0139959827,
0.0000406677,
-0.0526438244,
0.0015476998,
-0.0282753948,
0.0269750841,
-0.0111233015,
0.0093129706,
-0.0144782839,
0.0183182843,
-0.0337128602,
-0.0218762346,
-0.0479397215,
0.0531458706,
0.0512628928,
0.0550891832,
-0.0234611258,
-0.0448151752,
-0.0208308119,
-0.0048913429,
0.0176477563,
0.0047240388,
0.0203410704,
-0.0135943759,
0.0209282003,
-0.0470277444,
0.0152088311,
0.0201162901,
-0.0150757339,
0.0084374715,
0.0279674139,
-0.0205053184,
-0.024959268,
-0.027890373,
0.035264276,
-0.0016009602,
0.0727273375,
0.0535709523,
-0.0780443028,
-0.0394010171,
-0.056579385,
-0.0099863857,
-0.0938377082,
-0.0553165637,
0.0035465423,
-0.0007395191,
0.0276767723,
-0.0838459507,
-0.0096595809,
-0.0033834972,
0.0606969222,
0.049168773,
0.039830368,
-0.0981690884,
-0.0352950171,
-0.0206966959,
0.0129851326,
-0.0020030744,
0.0197327826,
-0.0569094941,
0.0088078072,
-0.0170076191,
-0.0650900304,
-0.0006110073,
0.0225815307,
-0.1020370796,
-0.0739913732,
0.0193905309,
0.0276671611,
0.022961529,
-0.0215688255,
0.015756622,
-0.0820022747,
0.0567974597,
0.056283135,
0.0155719295,
0.0686447248,
-0.0135716712,
0.0276344903,
0.0128806308,
0.0070291618,
-0.0161842108,
0.029112367,
0.0635016039,
0.0405183323,
0.0322442614,
-0.0241135694,
0.0093171028,
0.0149772521,
-0.0241236519,
-0.0674999952,
-0.0286074392,
-0.0420101322,
-0.0127253653,
-0.0220892131,
-0.0319316648,
-0.0341464691,
-0.0137377046,
0.0192003101,
-0.0172806289,
-0.0121765174,
0.00715895,
-0.0036162322,
0.0408077165,
-0.0802991241,
0.0315744504,
0.024614498,
-0.001729419,
0.0259209238,
0.0166323092,
-0.0236228518,
0.0451729782,
-0.0703705996,
0.0467989743,
0.0365825333,
0.0435519964,
0.0071667694,
0.0043746494,
0.0077531533,
0.0434624702,
-0.0671558604,
-0.0342543535,
0.009074389,
-0.0001888052,
0.0927752629,
-0.010306621,
0.055649329,
-0.0076448633,
0.0228942111,
-0.0299382117,
0.022049075,
-0.0098779835,
-0.0077408864,
-0.0377507657,
0.0124200443,
0.0057517807,
-0.0059474795,
0.0742495805,
-0.0341827683,
0.031000901,
0.0252240915,
-0.0250269771,
-0.0050162231,
-0.0325839557,
0.0113006635,
0.0241181888,
0.0409815088,
-0.0172975846,
-0.063791424,
-0.0142812813,
0.024238307,
0.0295202397,
0.0393788405,
-0.0519586802,
0.0065401401,
0.0270832442,
-0.0306044426,
0.0195501763,
-0.0521390587,
0.0084854504,
-0.0119166365,
-0.0128342146,
-0.0319669954,
-5.453322536e-33,
-0.0353921615,
-0.0204940997,
0.0179835781,
0.0010276095,
-0.0617149137,
-0.0062459093,
-0.0438345633,
0.0171917565,
0.0188059341,
0.0205870885,
-0.0282110553,
-0.0147305867,
-0.0272522029,
-0.0122815995,
0.0123523362,
0.0077490429,
0.0424472839,
-0.0065775719,
-0.0558250062,
-0.018398568,
0.0058253645,
0.0232129619,
-0.0018865607,
-0.0294318479,
0.0091117937,
-0.0399262868,
-0.0345054232,
-0.0352369957,
-0.0110832667,
0.0614091866,
-0.0018316609,
0.0348515175,
0.0172588993,
-0.0007468066,
-0.0036463363,
-0.031090498,
0.0326065086,
0.0022785426,
0.0036206539,
-0.0522864833,
0.0409872793,
-0.0779562443,
0.0583213381,
0.0044247261,
-0.047969684,
-0.016729882,
0.0229138695,
-0.0214912537,
-0.0155432643,
-0.0627575368,
-0.0733154044,
0.0025052547,
-0.0139136435,
-0.0498811118,
-0.0110134482,
-0.0308021195,
0.0175417289,
-0.0030233939,
-0.0286233928,
0.0426016077,
-0.0371738262,
0.0291056521,
0.0218627378,
-0.0155849522,
-0.0117465546,
0.0897898301,
0.0299425703,
0.068974793,
-0.0239870157,
0.0152579574,
-0.0125409784,
0.0603227913,
0.0526709519,
0.0652987584,
0.0025867538,
-0.0133358994,
0.0069829947,
0.0350853615,
-0.0090706367,
-0.0398084261,
0.0433560945,
0.0159175284,
-0.0274308808,
-0.0469166823,
-0.0091842851,
-0.0141673274,
0.0152657703,
-0.019104192,
0.0183008611,
-0.0200346746,
-0.0039130482,
-0.0213868879,
0.0168194622,
-0.0132467877,
0.0151993698,
-0.0195198413,
-0.0568493642,
0.0936337113,
-0.0111484621,
0.0131504368,
-0.0217379872,
0.0008445931,
0.03006454,
0.0389919356,
0.0318659395,
0.0186404809,
0.026194511,
0.0320187099,
-0.0515690148,
0.0126624061,
-0.0170220267,
0.0277526993,
0.0101606771,
-0.0084813843,
0.0077591282,
-0.0300762206,
0.0088204099,
-0.0279941615,
0.016563138,
-0.064003244,
-0.0074567436,
-0.0386747234,
0.0082283653,
0.0017885878,
-0.0193019994,
0.0380027592,
0.0032035471,
-0.0010495448,
0.0465910733,
-0.0275082961,
-0.0248752348,
-0.0311306212,
2.758e-7,
0.0236915518,
0.0270947441,
0.0110120792,
0.034529537,
0.0326513052,
0.0310010165,
-0.0462741219,
0.021000443,
0.002902973,
0.0165998638,
0.012842657,
0.0320180766,
0.0519729629,
0.0314134546,
-0.0908469483,
0.0178099442,
-0.0931806117,
0.0205730852,
-0.0842280164,
-0.0384904891,
0.0505805574,
-0.045662839,
0.0395504609,
-0.0530006662,
-0.0061944309,
-0.0673495233,
0.0301916003,
-0.038028989,
-0.0127969002,
0.0147250164,
0.0464386828,
-0.0273337699,
-0.0213461798,
0.0032933934,
-0.015208479,
0.0066459947,
-0.0042430945,
0.0613983311,
-0.0072628143,
0.0235628318,
0.0488143563,
-0.0032676256,
-0.0268033314,
-0.0591097958,
0.0523886941,
0.0673339516,
-0.0180026535,
-0.0423632972,
0.0048622084,
-0.0231621768,
0.0135050239,
-0.0317324102,
0.0164918341,
-0.0058428617,
0.016800411,
0.0108683007,
0.020520797,
-0.0077473707,
-0.0274698772,
0.0229738764,
-0.0504056141,
-0.0310378168,
-0.0427251421,
0.0166613497,
-0.0058918702,
-0.106023185,
-0.0115598245,
2.57223809e-34,
0.0480429903,
-0.0340093262,
0.0118268728,
0.0363972597,
0.0472103991,
0.04315814,
0.0507273525,
-0.0389201567,
-0.0091860825,
-0.0218127258,
-0.0149960499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15890v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15890v1 | Language Alignment via Nash-learning and Adaptive feedback | 2024-06-22T16:55:21 | 2024-06-22T16:55:21 | Ari Azarafrooz, Farshid Faal | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GT | Recent research has shown the potential of Nash Learning via Human Feedback
for large language model alignment by incorporating the notion of a preference
model in a minimax game setup. We take this idea further by casting the
alignment as a mirror descent algorithm against the adaptive feedback of an
improved opponent, thereby removing the need for learning a preference model or
the existence of an annotated dataset altogether. The resulting algorithm,
which we refer to as Language Alignment via Nash-learning and Adaptive feedback
(LANA), is capable of self-alignment without the need for a human-annotated
preference dataset. We support this statement with various experiments and
mathematical discussion. | [
0.021483615,
0.052572269,
-0.0288331304,
0.0355974138,
-0.0619399622,
-0.013301326,
-0.0714246929,
-0.0252207182,
-0.0491744056,
0.012394622,
-0.0600081012,
-0.0546282455,
0.0460212603,
-0.0441044383,
0.0348495878,
-0.0267249811,
0.0554022118,
-0.006546678,
-0.0118879303,
-0.0233934987,
0.0367897116,
-0.0274120253,
-0.0194414072,
0.0181426071,
0.0217681862,
0.0116162766,
-0.0270507354,
0.0029499342,
0.0289702248,
0.0150850294,
-0.006245947,
0.0268501826,
-0.0030875956,
0.0682073385,
0.0000015291,
-0.0477789193,
-0.0129744671,
-0.0340457745,
-0.0283504631,
-0.0395506397,
0.0210858211,
-0.0057348139,
-0.0173141602,
0.0119570084,
-0.020532392,
-0.018250417,
0.0809614882,
-0.0376675017,
0.0819451958,
0.0646608174,
0.0125421006,
-0.0544846654,
-0.0126677919,
-0.0260275062,
-0.0439776927,
-0.0603742599,
0.030972667,
0.0048203208,
-0.0109689645,
-0.0227560438,
-0.0010641655,
0.0440797284,
-0.0442788675,
0.0113631384,
0.0127451858,
0.0151810972,
0.0083200848,
0.0265293159,
-0.0144133428,
0.0714904815,
-0.0113686547,
-0.0569053814,
-0.0192148313,
-0.0051976866,
0.0193533413,
0.0016336227,
-0.0022217834,
-0.0214091055,
0.0197782405,
0.0579378903,
0.0653286204,
-0.0288794655,
0.0300021488,
-0.0279638991,
0.0081469994,
0.0886304751,
0.0239120517,
-0.0635850951,
-0.0143721784,
-0.0005179173,
-0.0070541124,
-0.0500519909,
-0.031873174,
-0.0054925168,
-0.0445625968,
0.0448359065,
-0.0622028299,
-0.0198492147,
-0.0207114685,
-0.0600066371,
0.0556339882,
0.0491096191,
0.0162847377,
0.0509029999,
0.0232250728,
0.0712705329,
-0.0117218578,
-0.0026198281,
-0.0613565445,
-0.000557946,
-0.0061532068,
-0.0044472832,
-0.0255410988,
0.0090311216,
0.0110021904,
0.01627695,
-0.030179495,
-0.0017197515,
-0.0066742827,
0.0960413665,
0.0034249164,
-0.0119973468,
-0.0326848738,
-0.0449162386,
-0.0162262674,
0.0464630686,
-0.0135916695,
0.0025482096,
-0.0002697579,
-0.0322620608,
-0.0031871109,
-0.0011303453,
-0.0230313838,
-0.0276892781,
-0.0035481958,
0.0582856201,
-0.0232764594,
0.0186261553,
-0.0039357571,
0.0295965038,
-0.0343479887,
-0.0600387119,
-0.0346788205,
-0.068272993,
0.043410372,
-0.0175025892,
-0.0266835298,
-0.080492951,
-0.0093549527,
-0.030207146,
-0.0375961959,
0.078633979,
-0.0224353112,
0.0290591829,
0.0258483104,
-0.0577833951,
-0.0043847011,
0.0738257021,
0.0410382599,
-0.0411004238,
0.0146001009,
-0.0154028907,
-0.0312975161,
0.0980613679,
0.0237362944,
0.0201046616,
-0.0352958366,
0.0020518322,
0.0508890226,
0.0919911563,
0.0021553237,
0.0158252083,
0.0053235334,
-0.0417030081,
0.0581154786,
0.0576858073,
0.0116675133,
0.0438041985,
-0.0345635563,
0.0273349024,
-0.0116412872,
0.0458425991,
-0.0170057267,
0.0153377149,
-0.0469440632,
0.0274130218,
0.0082755443,
0.0220308714,
-0.0080646407,
-0.0193948671,
-0.0239639245,
-0.0132620512,
-0.0111492937,
0.0099181645,
0.0462975726,
-0.0215068422,
-0.0329260603,
0.0142768575,
0.0449478962,
-0.0295937285,
-0.0032003105,
-0.0281867851,
-0.0067140362,
0.0406218171,
0.0061236173,
-0.037575949,
-0.0655298606,
0.0021356819,
-0.0577965491,
0.0760321021,
0.0686191246,
-0.0132954484,
-0.0281614419,
-0.043616239,
-0.0289213993,
0.028427925,
-0.0069642691,
0.0322582796,
-0.025271805,
-0.02146402,
-0.0330589227,
0.0159453191,
-0.0538933761,
0.0458476096,
-0.0119182086,
-0.0093238726,
-0.024717737,
0.039347358,
0.061234355,
-0.0015674484,
-0.0175912119,
-0.0014989084,
-0.0021691446,
-0.0014147736,
0.0147427944,
0.0489151366,
-0.01084805,
-0.0352536365,
0.0959380046,
-0.0055643679,
-0.0183579288,
0.0659241974,
-0.0130615719,
-0.0566451997,
0.0198627673,
-0.0342868455,
0.0149981808,
0.0059339451,
0.0741731003,
-0.0423788391,
-0.0296835359,
-0.0445726737,
0.0382065997,
0.0117185442,
0.0245732982,
-0.0155434506,
-0.0245436542,
0.0150759583,
-0.0548630022,
-0.0350985788,
0.0218348429,
0.0019587004,
0.0157057047,
0.0510701463,
-0.0562595278,
-0.0229233894,
-0.0095739318,
-0.0280575398,
0.018674992,
-0.0076725674,
0.0320427753,
0.0455197804,
-0.0195438098,
0.0076355538,
-0.0056829476,
-0.0613130331,
0.0240661949,
0.008633568,
-0.0038267081,
0.059732087,
0.0091981115,
-0.0356472358,
-0.0818575099,
-0.0066538258,
-0.0250647645,
-0.0031761341,
0.0001899209,
-0.0200264752,
-0.0859457254,
-0.0036151905,
-0.037651591,
0.0589150004,
-0.0135353608,
-0.0459494926,
-0.006844996,
0.0167844109,
0.0083576804,
0.0478270724,
0.0016904643,
-0.0201041345,
0.0541809499,
0.0275458116,
-0.0640105829,
-0.0061917887,
-0.017772438,
-0.0342899002,
-0.0688958094,
-0.0371301435,
0.0069480292,
0.1010583267,
-0.0007199834,
-0.0153176934,
-0.069430992,
0.0053397259,
0.0201918874,
0.0038128048,
-0.0085802553,
-0.0005144267,
-0.0446421355,
-0.0064648041,
-0.0575728938,
-0.0262402035,
0.0972477421,
-0.0409247167,
-0.0005068554,
-0.0468048193,
0.018535411,
-0.0199097022,
0.0202685166,
0.0177159756,
0.0215064809,
0.0057086516,
0.0005570047,
-0.0524581559,
-0.0347922742,
0.0574562177,
-0.0347407386,
0.05375183,
-0.0317476541,
0.0464157425,
-0.0255546812,
-0.0410538167,
-0.0232598335,
-0.047923997,
-0.0345134325,
-0.0077740434,
0.0678635761,
-0.0114205396,
-0.0480739623,
0.0282471478,
0.0126011735,
0.0204966459,
0.0145192267,
0.0331110768,
-0.0181683507,
0.0261164289,
0.0725751519,
0.0577850714,
-0.0154854245,
-0.0060415538,
0.0208061524,
0.0223600641,
0.07643269,
0.0014067685,
-0.0158497281,
-0.012647883,
0.0584005266,
-0.0576680042,
-0.001676454,
-0.0088324966,
-0.0224119816,
0.0105215833,
0.0033883578,
0.0774400607,
0.0266123749,
-0.0209292881,
-0.0093038948,
-0.0174001157,
0.0395874195,
0.0144799761,
0.0243474226,
-0.0614095032,
-0.0225929953,
-0.0023168642,
0.0231174789,
0.0283683818,
-0.0198861584,
-0.0269841291,
-0.1099108085,
-0.0476729199,
0.0624300465,
-0.0666973516,
-0.0017623496,
0.0015413306,
0.0191193987,
-0.0600280128,
0.0140247159,
0.0541927144,
0.0360164158,
-0.0053522526,
0.0116984528,
-0.000703998,
0.0055038114,
-0.0381348617,
-0.0803905204,
0.1021266654,
0.073182255,
0.0414611362,
-0.009505773,
-0.0282707121,
0.0258841272,
0.0164995324,
-0.0453481264,
0.0347709171,
0.0050963624,
-0.0381077155,
-0.0125778662,
0.0376049653,
0.0286386162,
0.0191591401,
0.0389671326,
0.023383569,
0.0555130541,
0.0376482643,
0.0241453499,
0.0612550005,
-0.0060368828,
-0.0002844834,
0.0603242591,
-0.0184215549,
-0.0423271134,
0.0229709558,
-0.0013368989,
0.0175629444,
-0.0282345414,
-0.0617647357,
0.0209736228,
0.0105132973,
0.0138033088,
-0.0763970613,
-0.0240343027,
-0.0259182546,
0.0456741899,
0.0443213508,
0.037568938,
0.0299935918,
-0.007571077,
0.0021751749,
-0.0120810298,
-0.0485507138,
-0.0162784141,
-0.0279017407,
-0.035501074,
0.0199293364,
-0.0655774996,
-0.0070088236,
-0.0135187535,
-0.0227312464,
-0.0945942551,
-0.0013161704,
0.0283521079,
0.0137729812,
0.0845227242,
0.0021386868,
-0.0061809528,
-0.0136947175,
0.0049356995,
0.0309085753,
0.0096680289,
0.0072557442,
-0.0246493835,
0.0073976489,
0.058511395,
-0.0220169537,
-0.044454217,
0.0331225581,
0.0361463055,
-0.0108318571,
-0.0223812535,
0.0708707422,
0.0200056415,
0.034595035,
-0.0325950049,
-0.0338465869,
-0.0064013726,
0.0106593613,
-0.0094935549,
-0.0468415134,
0.000784963,
-0.0467243083,
0.0240488835,
-0.0057729413,
0.0282661971,
-0.0441033617,
-0.0092007937,
-0.0204305369,
-0.0149821984,
-0.0243087523,
0.0123872859,
0.0225475319,
0.0065340195,
0.0380095951,
0.0107970117,
0.0280543007,
0.0195794348,
0.0483736396,
0.005932204,
-0.0043092649,
0.0644227266,
-0.0027388546,
-0.0185445324,
0.0112376846,
-0.0018006454,
-0.0489421971,
-0.0000688697,
0.0074490113,
0.098226808,
-0.0188175831,
0.0552329607,
-0.0138083436,
-0.0125957141,
0.0029829054,
-0.0070495103,
-0.0525451005,
-0.0406278856,
0.003676811,
0.0153325209,
-0.0239492804,
0.0224651229,
0.0445764512,
0.0137229506,
0.0352840237,
-0.0400087237,
0.0225575212,
-0.0240390748,
-0.0019421765,
-0.0373005271,
0.0170702171,
-0.0718481541,
-0.0327188782,
-0.0207850989,
-0.0501437932,
-0.0502570681,
0.0707760528,
-0.0022882237,
0.0410501137,
0.0460398272,
0.0450068898,
-0.0386253186,
-0.0020702784,
-0.0218792241,
0.0195551068,
-0.0138391163,
-0.0083139939,
0.001382545,
-5.419683928e-33,
-0.0512713082,
0.0162812341,
0.0307466965,
0.0064915908,
-0.0273166131,
-0.0638340339,
0.0016425808,
0.037137568,
-0.0343087614,
-0.0140658785,
-0.0061438368,
-0.0291277338,
0.0122604687,
-0.0080224639,
0.0253929943,
-0.0117148431,
0.014451785,
-0.022965746,
-0.0371818915,
-0.0436708145,
0.0123143662,
-0.0018678292,
0.058438208,
-0.0101606874,
0.0229010433,
-0.0033582223,
-0.0061098291,
0.0615372919,
-0.0145346904,
0.0380728655,
0.0144750271,
0.0020366558,
-0.0050596748,
-0.0439728796,
-0.0003716538,
-0.0180557184,
-0.0480784886,
0.0048277094,
0.0552534983,
0.0560478494,
-0.0038174535,
-0.0063132201,
0.070511952,
-0.017449053,
-0.0811568126,
0.0218725875,
0.0184731614,
-0.0372713506,
-0.0143592879,
0.1026052311,
-0.0649109781,
-0.0021789165,
-0.0155718755,
-0.0044648754,
0.0524284057,
0.0085652238,
0.0141115561,
-0.024236666,
-0.036476478,
0.0620883629,
-0.0139966505,
0.0434170589,
0.1022809222,
0.0357671864,
0.0153241521,
0.0437951609,
0.0788045451,
-0.0251763687,
0.0374952145,
-0.0629293397,
0.0035018504,
-0.0301263332,
0.058012858,
0.0181000102,
0.0019306429,
-0.0128689567,
-0.0116729876,
0.01224137,
0.0160478931,
0.0175588317,
-0.0183417853,
0.0298997872,
-0.0572392605,
-0.0109187979,
-0.0306449383,
-0.0584465154,
-0.0204754211,
-0.0262705497,
-0.0160136446,
-0.0178822707,
-0.0080506541,
0.0038713245,
0.0144182118,
-0.0420376621,
-0.0305878911,
-0.0097756423,
-0.0027308902,
0.0128471432,
-0.0430795252,
0.0313472487,
-0.0532638393,
-0.0240018945,
-0.0536119491,
0.0001554094,
0.0216776021,
0.0322540663,
0.015657749,
0.005959047,
-0.0445890054,
0.026630437,
-0.024981698,
-0.0345371589,
-0.0065159574,
-0.0436899774,
0.0643374324,
-0.0280014891,
0.0138789481,
0.032447271,
0.0607901923,
-0.044517301,
-0.0251657628,
-0.0084601399,
-0.0385548361,
0.0030971116,
-0.0039848909,
0.0448543429,
0.0036665602,
0.0505667999,
-0.0211990215,
-0.0127177685,
-0.013392346,
-0.031128265,
2.282e-7,
0.018729968,
0.0426865667,
0.049078092,
-0.0194795616,
-0.0284244902,
0.0514324605,
-0.0858648792,
0.004527282,
0.0200680345,
0.022305306,
0.0472283736,
-0.003187093,
0.0564950183,
0.0146323685,
-0.0646417737,
-0.0097000869,
-0.0681586638,
0.0419416092,
-0.0135627463,
-0.001916365,
0.0068131606,
0.0713803321,
0.0332803167,
0.0194831807,
-0.027442839,
-0.0192708895,
0.0308908895,
-0.0248751305,
0.0021567808,
0.0310216341,
0.0033897276,
-0.0354880877,
-0.0658718571,
-0.0239147563,
0.0127378451,
0.0760523602,
-0.02181972,
0.0173953474,
-0.0207121111,
0.0077801333,
-0.0315121114,
0.042626638,
-0.0140995374,
-0.0400883816,
0.0311015025,
-0.0286606904,
-0.037575148,
-0.0348541029,
-0.0078754704,
0.0161997974,
0.0052981423,
0.0087513635,
-0.0140280649,
0.0022428457,
0.0332228839,
0.0313913226,
-0.0192116089,
-0.0090609808,
-0.0433577932,
0.0415524617,
-0.037900418,
-0.0048498316,
0.0165119339,
0.0384340025,
0.0132328821,
-0.0340738893,
0.0062016319,
1.548477675e-34,
-0.0033649672,
-0.0256761704,
0.034048859,
0.0289833602,
-0.0016567663,
-0.0322759189,
0.0123142162,
0.0347506888,
0.0614956729,
-0.0234406609,
-0.0209863782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15888v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15888v1 | Real-time Speech Summarization for Medical Conversations | 2024-06-22T16:37:51 | 2024-06-22T16:37:51 | Khai Le-Duc, Khai-Nguyen Nguyen, Long Vo-Dang, Truong-Son Hy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | In doctor-patient conversations, identifying medically relevant information
is crucial, posing the need for conversation summarization. In this work, we
propose the first deployable real-time speech summarization system for
real-world applications in industry, which generates a local summary after
every N speech utterances within a conversation and a global summary after the
end of a conversation. Our system could enhance user experience from a business
standpoint, while also reducing computational costs from a technical
perspective. Secondly, we present VietMed-Sum which, to our knowledge, is the
first speech summarization dataset for medical conversations. Thirdly, we are
the first to utilize LLM and human annotators collaboratively to create gold
standard and synthetic summaries for medical conversation summarization.
Finally, we present baseline results of state-of-the-art models on VietMed-Sum.
All code, data (English-translated and Vietnamese) and models are available
online: https://github.com/leduckhai/MultiMed | [
0.0276874956,
-0.0077738287,
0.0314953811,
-0.0015111443,
0.0046504703,
0.0177365243,
-0.0229877103,
-0.007203225,
-0.0168403555,
-0.0055678939,
-0.0214393437,
-0.0409654863,
0.0373672806,
0.0174130742,
0.020321263,
-0.1085481197,
0.0311214644,
-0.0095100328,
-0.0054175938,
-0.0061493446,
-0.0001134756,
-0.0028133637,
-0.0412288457,
0.0255483352,
0.0192938354,
0.0302123632,
0.0075019449,
-0.0075623151,
0.0600431375,
-0.0490244403,
-0.0292901378,
0.0012858814,
0.00489137,
-0.0323928744,
0.0000017826,
-0.0374851115,
-0.0201273374,
0.0087474557,
-0.0192438271,
-0.0189816765,
0.0469504222,
-0.0381173305,
-0.0089439414,
0.0313786007,
-0.0313196294,
0.0316529833,
-0.0125391325,
0.0637796447,
0.0818304643,
0.0716106594,
-0.0179398656,
-0.0128640989,
0.0160717852,
-0.0258137379,
0.0002982334,
-0.0345604196,
-0.0000892751,
0.0272853896,
0.0429188944,
-0.031900961,
0.0253806543,
0.0381800979,
-0.017935073,
0.0303377565,
0.0088793272,
0.026552055,
-0.0584583394,
0.0026928091,
-0.0019465146,
0.1049394682,
0.0187376235,
0.0291119665,
0.0582293123,
0.0392195545,
0.0225495659,
-0.0441824012,
-0.0897068977,
0.0289891288,
-0.0106232185,
0.0272382852,
-0.0090630874,
0.0168920755,
0.0047448007,
0.0063452134,
0.0100558111,
-0.0035091324,
-0.0124901943,
-0.0037788872,
-0.0403265655,
-0.0221694801,
0.0041367123,
-0.0342709459,
0.0339406058,
0.0499078855,
-0.0272069313,
-0.0042236345,
-0.0262072179,
-0.0237492248,
0.0407850705,
-0.0779792592,
-0.0284634735,
-0.00237725,
-0.0083858138,
0.0553117022,
0.0086055947,
-0.0070157074,
0.0111903697,
0.0039906013,
-0.0396411717,
-0.0280446466,
-0.0090955365,
0.0116510009,
-0.0210132711,
0.0611590222,
-0.0342737287,
-0.0168774538,
-0.0995279551,
0.0080107832,
0.0217565037,
0.0129786124,
0.0291605499,
0.0338198692,
0.0012167826,
0.007747198,
0.0320159607,
0.0058530117,
-0.0296843778,
0.0110002896,
0.009923636,
-0.0599307343,
0.0007637877,
0.0501718298,
0.0186511446,
0.0488435328,
0.0003435134,
0.0345244855,
-0.0190718342,
-0.0146880494,
0.0138101801,
-0.0376204215,
-0.0214113649,
-0.0127456561,
-0.0171741918,
-0.0752397701,
0.0032866362,
-0.0080309985,
-0.0084050158,
-0.017362982,
0.0153613817,
-0.0066549168,
-0.0362583771,
0.0345444493,
-0.0669071153,
0.0386706628,
0.0604438521,
0.0349207185,
0.0231718644,
0.027552465,
0.0649115443,
-0.0199194979,
0.0401202887,
-0.0072252359,
0.0012012157,
0.0401589721,
-0.0055009401,
-0.0250955615,
0.0231641121,
-0.0374121554,
-0.0384070836,
0.0314205699,
-0.0031135096,
0.0730759501,
-0.0269659236,
0.0173757132,
0.0258112624,
0.0862111226,
0.0041111168,
0.0049053547,
-0.0128157297,
0.0092401411,
0.0364540145,
0.0360364169,
-0.0123121999,
0.0336470604,
-0.0314712003,
0.0411381945,
0.0775319338,
-0.0067374348,
-0.039148517,
-0.0299359281,
-0.0042918567,
-0.0425414667,
-0.0305601936,
-0.0154306702,
0.0250783898,
-0.0107560633,
-0.0159463063,
0.0921769142,
0.0214757565,
-0.0832180977,
-0.0279085916,
-0.0311702415,
-0.0280680768,
0.0520645268,
0.0470690206,
-0.0782795474,
-0.0351521559,
-0.0385201648,
-0.0123152249,
0.0275913961,
0.0266565345,
-0.0227743722,
0.0220479723,
-0.063183628,
0.0068438663,
0.0460802019,
-0.0065369173,
-0.0288047753,
-0.0089187026,
-0.0096726995,
0.0130666224,
0.0084283995,
-0.0069887196,
0.0156224528,
-0.0450206995,
0.0089106476,
-0.0081854695,
-0.0333907679,
0.0471085459,
0.0816231146,
-0.0177110061,
0.017353531,
0.0642675012,
-0.0361066796,
-0.001428192,
0.0459042303,
-0.037964724,
-0.044886712,
0.029857086,
-0.0481707267,
0.0092273038,
-0.0050546052,
-0.0126679409,
-0.0821500719,
-0.0268828738,
-0.0639831722,
0.0204212926,
-0.015818134,
0.02800625,
0.0463552512,
0.0241532233,
0.0112035116,
0.0103442445,
-0.0449099094,
-0.0166062955,
0.0763651058,
-0.0302594379,
-0.0184803624,
-0.0628389865,
0.005929762,
0.0347659029,
0.0092575746,
0.0021979059,
-0.0041847113,
-0.0197843835,
-0.0501803048,
-0.0275160596,
-0.1609322727,
0.0012375118,
0.006533301,
-0.0003511026,
0.0252280831,
0.0630852878,
-0.0203808211,
-0.0394470431,
-0.0553914756,
-0.0167119075,
0.0657374784,
-0.0133232521,
0.0158852432,
0.0252782535,
0.0223125611,
-0.0683237314,
0.0180888493,
-0.002654644,
0.0035688446,
-0.012905499,
-0.0759398118,
-0.015056774,
-0.0068883426,
-0.0171216689,
-0.0052283532,
0.0106448345,
-0.0025276144,
-0.005573133,
-0.0014241273,
0.0437927395,
0.0477138162,
0.056808345,
0.0091246804,
0.005187721,
0.0016152331,
-0.0163211804,
0.001628629,
-0.022426689,
0.0409532674,
-0.0062323208,
-0.0291973855,
0.0041621616,
0.0591314472,
0.0447552539,
0.0301148742,
0.0120727178,
-0.034354873,
-0.0010198303,
0.0048873825,
-0.0396238714,
0.0019688846,
-0.0630714744,
0.0299717616,
0.0169050898,
-0.0271273851,
0.0340759829,
-0.0345932953,
0.0082740579,
-0.0341785215,
-0.0555432141,
-0.0662431791,
0.0178292915,
-0.0449778512,
0.0083905049,
-0.048281651,
-0.0330700874,
0.0078904014,
0.0183625538,
0.0076673478,
-0.0831635445,
0.0672486201,
-0.0173518341,
0.0009126976,
-0.0280462038,
0.0010243106,
-0.026254138,
-0.0294872113,
-0.0727289841,
0.021041153,
0.0063033863,
0.0169971362,
-0.0545713976,
0.0185928568,
-0.0050057294,
0.0790263116,
0.0121034961,
0.0243640821,
-0.0140719218,
0.058173053,
0.035980355,
0.0301858317,
0.0074261092,
-0.0170390848,
0.0613827072,
0.0553466193,
0.0225638337,
0.0089498544,
0.0040185605,
-0.0129705975,
-0.0074613229,
-0.039057143,
-0.0070083593,
0.0035272634,
0.0387454219,
-0.0190099888,
0.069855459,
0.1140480116,
0.0031988833,
-0.0406444371,
0.0057764663,
-0.0120732263,
-0.0145985968,
-0.0029014896,
-0.0001480749,
-0.0786654353,
-0.0446446016,
0.0188354645,
0.0304541569,
0.0139004318,
-0.037982475,
-0.0122405393,
-0.0247028302,
0.0198235791,
0.0106262416,
-0.0566663183,
-0.0264564008,
-0.0238941032,
-0.0180449169,
-0.0020064274,
0.0287528578,
0.0125076799,
-0.0247179642,
-0.040604353,
0.0193907898,
-0.108470954,
-0.0136569226,
-0.0161352102,
0.0142522622,
0.0532994345,
0.0444012471,
0.0544117875,
0.0196148269,
0.0175176039,
0.0375639461,
0.0382753387,
-0.0105355494,
0.0073800771,
0.0943425447,
-0.0017600285,
-0.0077648703,
-0.0318015814,
0.0616158545,
-0.0254984871,
-0.0211815983,
0.0111475447,
0.0024889458,
-0.0178025551,
0.0018977071,
-0.0560193621,
0.088681303,
-0.0252219904,
0.0523089506,
-0.0081722215,
0.0119761592,
0.0003356632,
0.0199692678,
0.0102377562,
-0.0005323879,
-0.0441842414,
-0.004526034,
-0.0415396877,
-0.0170865301,
-0.0793362185,
-0.0176536851,
0.033714883,
-0.0447038151,
-0.0157135054,
0.0281240474,
0.0086558163,
0.045278687,
-0.0489427857,
0.006111824,
0.0032866483,
0.0056033125,
-0.0532554239,
-0.0310838763,
0.0853314251,
-0.0296285115,
0.0008427831,
0.0314557217,
-0.0666456223,
-0.0173641294,
-0.0331227817,
0.0346866772,
0.0274780467,
0.0506331548,
0.0255573243,
0.0073578213,
0.0258487333,
0.0226535015,
-0.0125860693,
0.022954518,
0.01249607,
0.0433219858,
-0.0292552207,
0.0097738812,
-0.041260533,
0.0307830144,
-0.0617262833,
0.0088028675,
-0.0628193691,
-0.0880646259,
-0.026016444,
0.0411211699,
0.0182433035,
0.0035883037,
0.0010718107,
-0.0120120132,
0.0113003636,
-0.0185171999,
0.0190349463,
-0.0276645608,
0.039092917,
-0.0383142903,
-0.0288922898,
0.0031320082,
0.0430748984,
-0.0362410508,
-0.064923279,
-0.0084717125,
0.0283742212,
-0.0266819354,
-0.0543299541,
-0.0208519269,
-0.015219247,
-0.0177003164,
0.0001150673,
-0.0250329711,
-0.0041667307,
0.0136179607,
0.0177703239,
-0.0294674356,
0.0073626502,
0.0292803179,
0.0591772571,
-0.0762309656,
-0.0037280708,
-0.039125789,
0.0813690796,
0.0478387363,
-0.0091155414,
0.077889584,
0.0098083382,
0.0334774852,
-0.0452866778,
0.0483564809,
-0.0457008891,
0.0247279555,
-0.0330968499,
-0.0103591131,
0.0106744152,
0.0164848231,
0.1003441513,
-0.0511654653,
0.0148060312,
0.010385314,
-0.0310973749,
-0.0580248423,
-0.0330302529,
0.0155221019,
0.0344111696,
-0.0230389703,
-0.018890528,
-0.0342119336,
-0.0135456929,
0.0458039977,
-0.0075232973,
0.0032430561,
-0.0334010124,
0.048325859,
-0.0066352086,
-0.0019190329,
0.0077486928,
-0.0172295682,
0.0085722283,
-0.0400387086,
0.0164279509,
0.05075901,
-5.41514652e-33,
-0.0345887356,
-0.0335944071,
-0.0120469425,
0.0392895341,
-0.051972717,
0.0252595339,
-0.0535525382,
0.0318435095,
0.0318848714,
-0.0232010111,
-0.0260431822,
0.0224575382,
0.0226056818,
0.039575927,
-0.0146651641,
-0.0069877813,
0.0280019753,
-0.0001200753,
-0.0220386758,
0.0556879826,
-0.013226456,
0.0311387312,
0.0266097542,
-0.0382246077,
0.0100231115,
-0.0169301257,
-0.0023272196,
-0.0049866918,
0.0412019417,
0.0262426753,
-0.0304540936,
0.0121194785,
0.038365718,
-0.0044820439,
-0.062255986,
0.0151486676,
-0.0792899206,
0.004278997,
0.0135196662,
-0.0079741692,
-0.0698218048,
-0.0123775695,
0.0420980714,
-0.0090449881,
-0.0002591558,
-0.0219170973,
0.0296591502,
-0.0841498002,
-0.0371903032,
-0.0656883866,
0.0206463095,
0.0644551516,
-0.0406044796,
-0.0366194472,
0.0268436726,
0.0293024145,
-0.0182686709,
0.0070679821,
-0.0292344429,
0.0530464835,
0.0270364098,
0.0153206019,
0.0203097519,
-0.0234335307,
-0.001563914,
0.0644581243,
0.047817912,
-0.0389430746,
-0.0352889001,
0.0072692414,
-0.0619769432,
0.0529820845,
0.0368530601,
0.0141973756,
0.017056711,
0.0108678406,
-0.041267965,
0.0724170431,
-0.0182023365,
-0.0138315409,
0.0173665751,
0.0144637479,
-0.0025647355,
0.0218659472,
-0.0073268116,
0.0157786608,
0.0210094303,
-0.0085418681,
-0.0084206825,
0.0214826334,
-0.0048380196,
-0.015070199,
0.011679057,
-0.0197487343,
0.0567856506,
-0.0249498151,
0.0144725032,
0.0082019242,
-0.0347332396,
-0.0496028513,
-0.0086393384,
0.0041347775,
0.024645241,
-0.0040297559,
0.0251141544,
0.0157512389,
0.0130315833,
-0.0169112626,
-0.0441307053,
0.0023981649,
0.051380422,
0.0230563916,
-0.0455112457,
0.0353811234,
0.0015226039,
-0.0256917458,
0.0147898123,
0.0783485547,
-0.0605312064,
0.0338925645,
-0.0499240682,
-0.0337891206,
0.0260002967,
0.008969456,
-0.062071871,
0.0247604214,
-0.0113347396,
0.0346431881,
0.0481632873,
-0.0235756431,
-0.0023560328,
-0.0236502979,
2.409e-7,
0.0493274182,
0.0293387603,
0.0786561444,
-0.0331343263,
0.0339353308,
0.0072915498,
-0.0015476365,
0.0269255321,
0.0054959608,
-0.0057139695,
0.0464635529,
0.0265750047,
0.0701542273,
0.0108642448,
-0.118638061,
-0.0385363959,
-0.0908008665,
-0.0530004501,
0.0007790581,
-0.0402339548,
0.0366974846,
0.0760244131,
-0.054216329,
-0.0311263017,
-0.0056761908,
0.0241718013,
0.0377753042,
-0.0523418523,
-0.0260372944,
0.0190254692,
0.0465330593,
0.0117172478,
0.0041664895,
-0.0077252393,
-0.0062853545,
-0.0250147302,
0.0716541782,
0.0858498141,
-0.0076422831,
-0.0228590518,
0.0156699233,
-0.0040486143,
0.0191695746,
0.0456827842,
0.0327219218,
-0.0297295507,
-0.031183511,
-0.0326010101,
0.0057477192,
0.01006734,
0.0154510485,
-0.0058321888,
-0.0221174359,
0.0411796272,
0.0087172333,
-0.016672546,
-0.0170845203,
-0.0684189796,
-0.0610259995,
0.0138491914,
-0.0407816358,
-0.0338943116,
0.0297565944,
-0.0357396826,
-0.0136701269,
-0.0529158935,
-0.008527128,
1.698001934e-34,
0.0634716302,
0.0122713465,
-0.0381503031,
0.0501698591,
0.0078928079,
-0.0555662811,
0.0007983364,
-0.0030459415,
0.0181681011,
-0.0500277914,
-0.0132613564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15883v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15883v1 | SimSMoE: Solving Representational Collapse via Similarity Measure | 2024-06-22T16:10:45 | 2024-06-22T16:10:45 | Giang Do, Hung Le, Truyen Tran | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Sparse mixture of experts (SMoE) have emerged as an effective approach for
scaling large language models while keeping a constant computational cost.
Regardless of several notable successes of SMoE, effective training such
architecture remains elusive due to the representation collapse problem, which
in turn harms model performance and causes parameter redundancy. In this work,
we present Similarity-based Sparse Mixture of Experts (SimSMoE), a novel
similarity of neural network algorithm, that guarantees a solution to address
the representation collapse issue between experts given a fixed FLOPs budget.
We conduct extensive empirical evaluations on three large language models for
both Pre-training and Fine-tuning tasks to illustrate the efficacy, robustness,
and scalability of our method. The results demonstrate that SimSMoE
significantly enhances existing routing policy and outperforms other SMoE
training methods in performance for the tasks. | [
-0.0074381777,
0.0880311206,
0.0017645035,
0.015051825,
-0.0044930764,
-0.0107767992,
0.0319225751,
-0.0014063799,
-0.0152983861,
-0.0260034762,
-0.035802234,
-0.0404092669,
0.0107703954,
0.0144301616,
0.0537145622,
-0.0233666338,
0.0308432598,
-0.0246250033,
-0.0560509898,
-0.0125601962,
0.0314366184,
0.0260382239,
0.0177325755,
0.0647168756,
-0.0061302404,
0.0065426766,
-0.0260668937,
0.0030424001,
0.0127929552,
-0.0135421306,
-0.0113738365,
0.0530903377,
0.0570862032,
0.0511106774,
0.0000020328,
0.0084782988,
-0.0224270038,
-0.0130150197,
-0.005891704,
0.0492976978,
0.038797535,
0.0185523015,
-0.0037902184,
0.0247582439,
0.0032549601,
-0.0504540838,
0.0822831243,
0.0644820035,
0.0519197099,
0.0909865797,
-0.0064110449,
-0.0253556203,
0.0534211844,
-0.0362164564,
-0.0156429838,
-0.0317841507,
0.0040116995,
0.0265401192,
-0.0210604668,
-0.013040022,
-0.0010635714,
0.0357854068,
0.0269945078,
0.0183978509,
-0.0355818346,
0.0486299284,
-0.0033106524,
-0.0211082231,
-0.0213801656,
0.0661916211,
-0.0584807657,
-0.0388617776,
-0.0039596492,
-0.0079271505,
-0.0286146887,
-0.0111562554,
-0.0081209773,
-0.0169205368,
0.0391829759,
0.0464730039,
0.0116024697,
0.0268623549,
0.0967207849,
0.0082820291,
-0.042702958,
-0.0293991491,
0.0343600065,
0.0014672017,
-0.019385973,
-0.0339482427,
-0.0293275397,
0.0026575469,
0.0132462196,
-0.007237148,
-0.0198878516,
0.0072677201,
-0.0509764664,
-0.0235093664,
0.0065680277,
-0.0391945727,
0.063308835,
0.063664265,
0.0039975299,
0.0574593507,
-0.044991862,
0.0338976011,
-0.0385025181,
0.0141135044,
-0.0393472128,
0.0097513171,
-0.0515240207,
-0.0135699715,
-0.0077161435,
0.0471055582,
0.0129086114,
-0.0470253341,
-0.0317653976,
-0.0005153391,
-0.0337104648,
-0.0169835798,
0.0062569212,
0.0413930379,
-0.0303878747,
-0.0135741681,
-0.002003812,
0.0718602389,
-0.0271901283,
0.0022597013,
0.0184935145,
-0.0286820531,
-0.0058666188,
0.0407897756,
-0.0225866195,
0.0171053912,
0.0237413887,
0.0590743124,
-0.03881694,
-0.0100308144,
-0.07791242,
0.0201734751,
-0.0115723675,
-0.0392232835,
-0.0071432795,
-0.0786712468,
0.069936417,
-0.0412919447,
0.0239929277,
-0.0726162195,
0.0128136175,
-0.0114750797,
-0.0406319797,
0.0796250254,
-0.0384993926,
-0.0120888501,
0.0177982934,
0.0140148848,
0.018335361,
0.050604865,
-0.0051031141,
-0.012624654,
0.0095544802,
0.0077765118,
-0.0150806447,
0.0337590501,
0.0209205765,
0.0001027826,
-0.0204808488,
-0.030857496,
0.0065574376,
0.0355172083,
0.0448031314,
0.0953731239,
-0.0546529591,
-0.0519892648,
0.0371537097,
0.0585472696,
0.0030125007,
0.090220131,
0.0385336801,
0.0053350125,
-0.0223977175,
0.0153948106,
-0.0463330969,
0.0118775535,
-0.0329318792,
0.0019120583,
0.0868325084,
0.0346813202,
-0.0684604868,
-0.0164501779,
-0.0002584006,
-0.0306063369,
-0.0071104253,
-0.0044114143,
0.0235608574,
-0.023015745,
-0.0432118811,
0.0702783614,
0.0400925614,
-0.0208769739,
0.0008904844,
-0.0264949854,
-0.0200154185,
0.0433860123,
0.0221466217,
-0.0367090739,
-0.0467416309,
-0.0062440503,
-0.0402021967,
-0.0272319205,
0.0312511176,
-0.0071209897,
0.0268367231,
-0.0878439918,
-0.021128308,
0.0135528892,
0.0253737401,
0.0313004442,
0.0069905357,
-0.0064472947,
0.0598152466,
-0.0036976575,
-0.0223475881,
0.034711536,
-0.0071144397,
0.0089177471,
0.0337768383,
0.0066899429,
0.030361563,
0.0117053427,
-0.0468684621,
0.01334072,
0.0142361233,
-0.037447378,
-0.0297516603,
-0.0227255132,
-0.1084473506,
-0.0345035344,
0.06817507,
-0.0110391025,
0.0422575921,
0.0607871749,
-0.0069024842,
-0.0554962493,
0.0232106466,
-0.0427592546,
0.0268577803,
-0.0655688941,
0.0122592049,
-0.0204421114,
0.0150091806,
-0.023330899,
0.0622974671,
-0.0435280465,
0.0157521106,
-0.012016505,
0.022149032,
0.0144049106,
-0.0537319556,
-0.0791698098,
-0.02918333,
-0.0002165626,
0.06227386,
0.0066502267,
-0.0113114268,
0.0087748673,
-0.0428534932,
-0.1045642942,
0.008302222,
-0.0392353386,
-0.0059217634,
0.0208873469,
0.0173155218,
0.0218677241,
0.0047689998,
-0.0285108965,
0.0138423676,
0.000872524,
0.001659145,
-0.0160927381,
-0.0037044596,
-0.0509779565,
-0.0562277399,
-0.0653885752,
-0.003884614,
0.0573655441,
-0.0427102298,
0.0002227716,
-0.0362327136,
0.016184425,
-0.0187957808,
0.024190357,
-0.0101118721,
-0.0363194942,
-0.0024657939,
-0.0392560847,
0.0415275358,
-0.0046412642,
0.00817795,
0.0098647187,
0.0821051821,
0.0210924204,
-0.0357799046,
-0.0020453983,
-0.0210602507,
0.0085472306,
-0.0545764677,
-0.0172075182,
-0.023532873,
0.0514364727,
-0.0116803618,
-0.0212047454,
-0.066231288,
-0.0447859503,
0.0062198485,
-0.0153561663,
-0.0238636583,
0.0108404746,
0.0097180428,
0.0110848835,
-0.022281995,
-0.0283758249,
0.0697786286,
-0.0296676215,
0.0075119361,
-0.0228165239,
-0.0476445369,
-0.0273549315,
0.0164170992,
0.0068495171,
0.0477985367,
-0.0298163891,
-0.0135842944,
-0.0549157038,
0.00915311,
-0.0176798515,
0.0056929411,
0.0178250019,
-0.0116596092,
0.0457220972,
-0.0069088694,
-0.0296765678,
-0.0147613017,
-0.037823502,
-0.0124877095,
0.0482837074,
0.0490874909,
-0.0208822489,
-0.0746478066,
0.0137786316,
-0.0238092151,
0.0623581931,
0.0102363685,
0.0069117029,
-0.0145112118,
0.0389204212,
0.0154692,
0.0370416418,
0.0372839794,
-0.0519324765,
0.022307273,
0.0227847323,
0.026189141,
-0.002347826,
-0.0969978198,
0.0266834479,
-0.0002056556,
0.0032589701,
-0.0113972258,
0.0337378681,
0.0055085788,
-0.0504925251,
0.0097139329,
0.1160390973,
-0.0019654159,
-0.0867070407,
0.0020314201,
0.0150700165,
0.0826957598,
0.0322272368,
0.0345808901,
-0.0385240205,
-0.0233360417,
-0.0171719491,
0.0111845722,
0.0229019038,
-0.0128225796,
0.029438749,
-0.0648541227,
-0.0205507074,
0.0311325062,
-0.0490692928,
-0.0380679481,
-0.0642490387,
-0.0110302558,
-0.0158782005,
0.0396380424,
-0.0098381536,
0.0065731234,
-0.0426979437,
0.0087446496,
0.0218669511,
-0.0569549389,
0.0153339198,
-0.0583951473,
0.0776943564,
0.0360153541,
-0.0163339097,
0.0058531528,
-0.0095142052,
0.003865985,
0.0151267136,
-0.0114478376,
-0.0018031887,
0.0162227303,
0.0127958208,
-0.0266778041,
0.0194511674,
0.0212006588,
-0.0402991027,
0.0010649107,
-0.0184905287,
0.0779108629,
-0.0118372198,
-0.0302287787,
0.0033012484,
-0.0124471616,
-0.013080244,
0.041002579,
0.0411740839,
-0.0095308209,
-0.0322061852,
0.0155697521,
0.0036882702,
-0.005433681,
-0.0390058756,
0.0105739022,
0.0278240684,
-0.02378284,
-0.0299138855,
0.0176721122,
0.0036505102,
0.0582773238,
0.0168432575,
-0.0052079209,
0.0327163748,
0.0090190191,
-0.0438000076,
0.0280268434,
-0.0226505641,
-0.0135650989,
-0.0742398649,
0.0098553384,
0.0243397262,
0.0147135854,
-0.0102127939,
-0.0205231179,
-0.115320228,
-0.0747339055,
-0.0160429981,
0.0550344102,
0.0064239074,
0.0153431408,
0.0089887688,
-0.0920158103,
0.0634977445,
0.0290748123,
-0.0404417813,
0.015175974,
0.0241463874,
-0.0691687465,
-0.0102933226,
0.052012939,
-0.0086912541,
0.0030998485,
0.0198538192,
0.0337249935,
-0.0312214307,
0.0098844627,
-0.0082587767,
-0.0281776283,
-0.0283049308,
-0.029394133,
0.0223320127,
-0.0495410189,
-0.0053788074,
0.0205900315,
0.0083003324,
-0.02627391,
0.001589359,
0.0358269252,
0.0106598865,
0.0316701531,
-0.0194890164,
0.0465309694,
0.0051456005,
-0.0029092866,
0.0045685507,
0.0263454262,
-0.0175451748,
0.0174529906,
0.0105683925,
-0.0255471263,
0.012035762,
0.0059854845,
-0.006928748,
-0.0443326049,
0.0212385859,
0.0191124771,
0.0089202812,
-0.0739111826,
0.0472350717,
-0.0325785391,
-0.0899951756,
-0.027023809,
0.0445839725,
0.0800826624,
-0.0296107586,
0.0117624113,
-0.0154817346,
0.0006964435,
-0.0434010029,
-0.0010655608,
-0.0324894786,
0.0103266304,
0.0324674472,
0.0384994857,
0.0087213563,
0.051151894,
0.0838634595,
0.0071296371,
0.0167644359,
0.037382409,
0.0069263461,
-0.0339735039,
-0.0099364901,
-0.0075829169,
0.092672199,
-0.051808551,
0.0096076401,
0.0167797282,
-0.0823579133,
-0.0204721112,
0.0069193072,
0.0055720266,
0.0215274785,
0.0435618907,
0.02629859,
-0.0327670984,
0.0497575291,
-0.0018353136,
-0.0147270542,
0.0276135858,
-0.000585553,
-0.0318988524,
-6.816460315e-33,
0.0028354623,
0.0213994663,
0.0096401908,
-0.0666854978,
-0.0118219499,
0.017325785,
-0.0383104458,
0.0252171811,
-0.0246685501,
-0.0081194537,
-0.0178003293,
0.0133747738,
-0.0070432923,
0.0448087193,
-0.0018611717,
-0.0053959144,
0.0891207457,
-0.009253175,
0.0106954277,
0.0441344529,
0.0032598781,
-0.0011059592,
0.0293537658,
-0.077462174,
-0.0523760952,
0.0266202446,
0.0127330367,
0.0218435209,
0.026228074,
0.0448487625,
-0.0501756556,
0.0351016782,
0.0195273124,
-0.0181508437,
-0.0311442968,
-0.029050393,
-0.0601723306,
-0.0292338636,
-0.003348791,
-0.0367437191,
0.0129780378,
-0.0280184392,
0.0755091384,
0.0147105064,
0.013483475,
-0.0258888528,
0.0144642638,
0.0100912564,
-0.0310980063,
0.0174894221,
-0.031184651,
0.0312755257,
-0.0176208876,
-0.0035024895,
0.0404132679,
-0.0271187369,
-0.0369028859,
-0.0061298623,
-0.0365627594,
-0.0087680556,
-0.013204962,
0.0768409595,
0.0436244011,
0.0371732153,
0.0030101393,
0.0700306222,
0.028088117,
0.005880787,
-0.030998392,
-0.008817276,
0.0900129303,
0.0370281562,
0.0385320932,
-0.017879637,
0.050264366,
-0.0309376679,
-0.0582763813,
0.0065738554,
0.0187844075,
0.0144883133,
0.0600014552,
0.0460349433,
-0.0234782379,
-0.0359166041,
-0.0356863104,
-0.0276401248,
-0.0443945453,
-0.0377357304,
-0.0106592411,
0.0182896238,
-0.0335890539,
0.0252654888,
0.0396215655,
-0.0664604306,
0.0109082442,
0.0156909414,
0.0190016013,
0.0157776084,
0.0149205374,
0.0305069778,
-0.0763935968,
-0.0637342185,
0.0021386468,
-0.0232642014,
-0.0006728338,
-0.0208975524,
0.0068632453,
0.007952475,
-0.0407216623,
-0.0412752368,
-0.0014671392,
-0.0326163583,
0.0145150628,
0.0766271427,
0.0229087137,
0.028262781,
0.0064468011,
-0.0041590994,
0.0059801624,
0.0013100938,
0.0197954234,
0.0189914145,
0.0388083011,
0.0332039818,
-0.0185243431,
-0.0126150018,
-0.0854016915,
-0.0051263012,
0.0531926751,
-0.0564079285,
-0.0437631048,
0.008399385,
2.681e-7,
0.0149993841,
0.0063547837,
0.017073404,
-0.0400968939,
0.003204325,
0.0241725631,
-0.0033892617,
0.0128065357,
-0.0125584481,
-0.0101198237,
0.056249056,
0.0255483165,
0.0210400466,
0.030589398,
-0.0811776072,
0.0179939121,
-0.0685507879,
0.0281040557,
-0.0481426977,
-0.0100046899,
0.0004473952,
0.1509966105,
0.0328718796,
-0.0290904548,
0.0325828902,
-0.0026358438,
0.0425265133,
-0.005276531,
0.0187941827,
0.0347567722,
0.021812465,
0.0511547774,
-0.0245983768,
0.0042095291,
0.0042521297,
0.06827005,
0.0058969008,
0.0345964469,
-0.0207075477,
-0.0213170275,
0.0267714635,
0.0082014324,
-0.0259716939,
-0.0405057482,
0.0534315296,
-0.0232028812,
-0.0127897011,
-0.0271301214,
0.007617312,
-0.0047806832,
0.0263205469,
-0.0263426136,
-0.0470328666,
0.0428021923,
0.0115675349,
-0.0478071161,
-0.0021638628,
-0.0765035376,
0.0073009343,
0.021372037,
-0.0704631805,
-0.0187128,
-0.0404616334,
-0.0209113564,
0.0611794665,
-0.0273344181,
0.0325970352,
2.619627732e-34,
0.0404561013,
-0.0087891435,
0.0171990786,
0.0454768278,
0.0247235447,
-0.0222107545,
-0.0258827806,
-0.0005582339,
-0.0106440848,
-0.0725556836,
-0.0352729149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15877v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15877v2 | BigCodeBench: Benchmarking Code Generation with Diverse Function Calls and Complex Instructions | 2024-06-22T15:52:04 | 2024-06-26T17:05:14 | Terry Yue Zhuo, Minh Chien Vu, Jenny Chim, Han Hu, Wenhao Yu, Ratnadira Widyasari, Imam Nur Bani Yusuf, Haolan Zhan, Junda He, Indraneil Paul, Simon Brunner, Chen Gong, Thong Hoang, Armel Randy Zebaze, Xiaoheng Hong, Wen-Ding Li, Jean Kaddour, Ming Xu, Zhihan Zhang, Prateek Yadav, Naman Jain, Alex Gu, Zhoujun Cheng, Jiawei Liu, Qian Liu, Zijian Wang, David Lo, Binyuan Hui, Niklas Muennighoff, Daniel Fried, Xiaoning Du, Harm de Vries, Leandro Von Werra | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Automated software engineering has been greatly empowered by the recent
advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) for programming. While current
benchmarks have shown that LLMs can perform various software engineering tasks
like human developers, the majority of their evaluations are limited to short
and self-contained algorithmic tasks. Solving challenging and practical
programming tasks requires the capability of utilizing diverse function calls
as tools to efficiently implement functionalities like data analysis and web
development. In addition, using multiple tools to solve a task needs
compositional reasoning by accurately understanding complex instructions.
Fulfilling both of these characteristics can pose a great challenge for LLMs.
To assess how well LLMs can solve challenging and practical programming tasks,
we introduce Bench, a benchmark that challenges LLMs to invoke multiple
function calls as tools from 139 libraries and 7 domains for 1,140 fine-grained
programming tasks. To evaluate LLMs rigorously, each programming task
encompasses 5.6 test cases with an average branch coverage of 99%. In addition,
we propose a natural-language-oriented variant of Bench, Benchi, that
automatically transforms the original docstrings into short instructions only
with essential information. Our extensive evaluation of 60 LLMs shows that LLMs
are not yet capable of following complex instructions to use function calls
precisely, with scores up to 60%, significantly lower than the human
performance of 97%. The results underscore the need for further advancements in
this area. | [
0.0029859061,
0.0557476282,
-0.0330361165,
0.0236008707,
-0.0271651018,
0.0071578734,
-0.0395175181,
-0.0237096176,
-0.0056974506,
-0.0341322534,
-0.0034364543,
0.0025265298,
0.0053419862,
0.0307880733,
0.0389444269,
-0.0215442944,
0.0404521078,
-0.0668415427,
-0.0481681712,
0.0140618477,
-0.0150322523,
0.0247253887,
0.0273671448,
0.0275737811,
0.0326015428,
-0.0274804514,
0.0039173476,
0.0410861634,
-0.0283022299,
-0.007376519,
0.0060931109,
0.0071082679,
0.0075656562,
-0.000934224,
0.0000026963,
-0.0537953004,
0.0122451102,
0.034745723,
-0.0030897323,
0.0527129993,
-0.0056225308,
0.0191150308,
0.0008035996,
0.0260768402,
-0.0272122435,
0.0093028322,
0.0371753722,
-0.0538194329,
0.0520807393,
0.0766161978,
0.0165726077,
-0.0371925011,
0.00688614,
0.0074373293,
0.0583678707,
-0.0272550061,
-0.0076426757,
0.0281074736,
0.0592462383,
-0.0028217882,
0.0026286547,
0.0051995595,
0.0257715508,
0.0214857422,
0.0039413804,
0.037240494,
0.0007353778,
-0.0252860971,
0.0108317919,
0.0309329256,
-0.0651475042,
-0.0088928854,
0.0358671248,
-0.0032442161,
-0.0402601026,
-0.0124394046,
-0.0378260389,
0.0498599894,
-0.012139122,
-0.0136297168,
0.0134002315,
-0.0090423469,
0.0272580273,
0.0114525007,
-0.0317050889,
0.0415007137,
0.007954916,
-0.0052579176,
-0.0019394165,
-0.0261115972,
0.008219244,
-0.068137601,
-0.0032490443,
0.0717352182,
-0.0252785161,
0.0071516717,
-0.0293784719,
-0.0204465874,
0.052237913,
-0.0307075884,
0.0166222155,
0.0470149145,
-0.0116149848,
0.0135162156,
-0.0470420122,
0.0727047324,
-0.0153666977,
-0.0405522771,
-0.0193738788,
0.0266858153,
-0.0492064729,
-0.0072029796,
0.0016300605,
0.05811809,
-0.0407557487,
0.0135894613,
-0.0414530523,
0.0407919213,
-0.0256889015,
0.0551696084,
-0.0215439219,
-0.0284907408,
-0.0179932564,
-0.0007243213,
0.0048549999,
-0.0162573066,
-0.0275226943,
-0.0437596552,
-0.0044660307,
-0.052429948,
0.0179214124,
0.0330163054,
-0.048283264,
-0.0080362363,
0.0509709753,
0.0823744908,
0.0082593421,
0.0354074053,
-0.0412399471,
-0.0638964996,
0.0167669356,
-0.0592942201,
0.0045307679,
-0.1260472983,
-0.0176933445,
0.0401270725,
-0.0186384022,
-0.0276479498,
0.0147627369,
0.0082414076,
0.0152229043,
0.0426024608,
-0.0248350482,
0.0290092789,
0.0332480147,
0.0426509529,
-0.0132796215,
0.0315244719,
0.0353015698,
0.0123750297,
0.0017768702,
-0.0294439681,
0.0385764688,
0.0340491906,
-0.0319984071,
-0.0236389451,
0.0467998348,
0.025337005,
0.0050533125,
0.0213418677,
0.0079094265,
0.0738244206,
-0.0048485524,
0.0137721822,
0.0075655761,
0.034695033,
0.0043721502,
0.0289659183,
0.0957023352,
0.0520395748,
0.0266252626,
-0.0149828875,
-0.0557013676,
0.0598110668,
-0.0265866369,
0.0321894661,
-0.0150035257,
0.0569848008,
-0.0018364525,
-0.0430962928,
-0.0000612598,
-0.0330287702,
-0.0140936701,
-0.00128349,
0.0265684202,
0.0052773985,
-0.0436973237,
0.0225371514,
0.007750636,
-0.0625175834,
-0.0181700829,
-0.0468240865,
0.0277765281,
0.0407913662,
0.042278409,
-0.049584914,
-0.0405513756,
0.0095000286,
0.0174909364,
0.001070803,
0.041523274,
-0.0025792841,
-0.0276864916,
-0.0571362861,
0.0040523042,
-0.0530049279,
-0.0113651259,
0.0381593555,
0.0435556136,
-0.0367794,
0.0424768291,
-0.0262873676,
-0.0641762018,
0.0260238033,
-0.0357377827,
-0.0280586425,
0.0242703874,
0.0006910412,
0.015397355,
-0.0393874757,
-0.0377742611,
0.045885358,
0.0301785208,
-0.0257181283,
-0.0278390069,
-0.0398006849,
-0.02971147,
0.0084482143,
0.0030982259,
-0.0592925064,
-0.0406345837,
0.0086150719,
-0.0464539155,
-0.025949521,
0.0509642586,
-0.0472554937,
-0.0042377412,
0.0264937896,
0.0257108025,
-0.0091385115,
-0.0325995982,
-0.0191136599,
0.0444422401,
0.0268459879,
0.0173726194,
0.016620351,
0.0669681504,
0.0013757532,
0.0323680118,
-0.025845021,
-0.0027321584,
-0.0340832844,
0.0194319729,
0.0179203339,
0.0539274774,
-0.0099369874,
-0.0388101339,
-0.0867689997,
0.050187625,
0.0032874011,
0.0461315401,
0.0256615691,
0.0310743991,
0.0182887502,
0.0297411531,
-0.0162262712,
-0.0146423141,
-0.0199213121,
0.0252604634,
0.0208115187,
-0.0191934947,
-0.0902310982,
-0.0136731984,
-0.0020679715,
-0.05825736,
0.0410795584,
-0.027072778,
0.0018822091,
-0.0529799387,
0.0518235154,
-0.0025651553,
0.0067428951,
-0.0352851488,
-0.0277846083,
0.0174744595,
-0.0296970699,
0.0814463124,
0.0661999062,
-0.0178121142,
0.0098044323,
0.0452703089,
-0.0068960153,
-0.0470175706,
0.0162419137,
0.0365899503,
-0.0342188403,
-0.001518389,
-0.0537785739,
0.0151310619,
0.0642508268,
-0.0065837661,
-0.0011226379,
-0.0117664915,
0.0139235137,
-0.0042561502,
0.0308872275,
0.0152319493,
-0.0320607983,
-0.0112141166,
0.0300861895,
-0.0222216398,
-0.0832853541,
0.0448200144,
-0.0388308875,
-0.0128712039,
-0.0112896338,
-0.0237939786,
-0.0590099804,
0.0969844386,
0.0044411519,
0.0214862432,
-0.0171449166,
-0.0143268006,
-0.0329990573,
0.0073081804,
-0.015826961,
-0.0478244349,
0.07818643,
-0.0749088824,
-0.0071744835,
-0.0210922714,
-0.0285970829,
-0.02255808,
0.0168550704,
-0.011415449,
0.0085162744,
0.0654631928,
-0.0126494281,
0.0098717799,
-0.0019198236,
0.0298306216,
0.0119341016,
0.0000907362,
-0.0271328408,
-0.0081597725,
-0.0578047633,
-0.0240252335,
-0.0712609664,
0.0012040066,
-0.0215085037,
0.0144925527,
0.0287585892,
0.0290573016,
0.0449746884,
-0.085927099,
-0.0062061432,
0.0013045889,
-0.031473767,
-0.0490104482,
0.0853041485,
0.0718977675,
-0.0789178684,
-0.0134466765,
0.0820857584,
0.0126231117,
-0.014222716,
0.0179170519,
-0.0212880746,
0.0226432476,
0.0731755942,
0.0599824153,
-0.0894816443,
-0.0474940725,
0.015365934,
0.0258114301,
-0.0237885751,
-0.0078289611,
-0.0054115937,
-0.1472295374,
0.0211617704,
0.0203154664,
-0.0036510725,
-0.0392036624,
-0.0529035442,
0.0013136051,
0.0445846096,
-0.0537857264,
0.0471309908,
-0.0029198229,
-0.012087347,
-0.0111001078,
-0.0898297727,
-0.0176455304,
0.0758372843,
-0.040526811,
-0.0012459804,
0.0861426294,
0.0156979635,
0.0187784042,
0.0093682613,
0.0619318262,
0.0050279652,
0.0355853699,
-0.0236761961,
0.0145321982,
0.0246458277,
-0.0143789118,
0.0233502891,
0.0475561097,
-0.0643028095,
-0.0069664931,
0.0362885296,
0.0669023618,
-0.0039198045,
-0.034765549,
-0.0329089649,
0.02782139,
-0.0002967616,
0.0512094386,
0.0341334529,
-0.0118934801,
-0.0594165623,
-0.0659641996,
-0.0287079811,
-0.0549929626,
-0.0177453235,
-0.0009697929,
-0.0075937426,
0.0054621152,
-0.0114098545,
0.0258833226,
0.043127615,
0.0170328803,
0.0492020436,
-0.0405936278,
0.0556066111,
-0.01475826,
-0.0640187785,
0.0134740565,
-0.0189152248,
0.0528399572,
-0.0345700644,
-0.0138905849,
0.023936253,
-0.010954801,
-0.0127761755,
0.0421168506,
-0.1004363745,
-0.0476896875,
-0.0495662056,
0.0879532546,
0.0217220727,
-0.0025378724,
-0.015271672,
-0.0503414497,
-0.0451263562,
0.0530594029,
-0.0511331856,
0.0185269602,
0.0067300731,
-0.0160810184,
0.016237732,
-0.0121794483,
-0.0698232427,
0.0146365622,
0.0112595959,
0.0083960649,
0.0128410393,
0.0315788686,
0.0246228445,
0.0428250954,
-0.0233078226,
0.0109704537,
-0.0123892901,
0.0346871801,
-0.0305207614,
-0.0031200096,
-0.0504706502,
-0.040527761,
0.0066231326,
-0.0019901472,
0.0033693255,
0.0424435474,
0.0034190654,
-0.0053015086,
0.0304030124,
0.0026346922,
0.0514409244,
-0.0146250566,
0.0355078094,
0.079852134,
-0.0222576465,
-0.0236900188,
0.0283806641,
-0.0218644142,
0.0101922471,
-0.0215994716,
0.0198938008,
0.0111118183,
0.0721625909,
-0.0137535054,
-0.0190355629,
-0.0152804684,
-0.0877896249,
0.0002690236,
-0.0251942389,
0.0266451705,
0.0289893877,
0.0169107504,
-0.0256802645,
0.018195238,
-0.030273037,
0.0440072976,
-0.0336524919,
-0.013006554,
0.0159163922,
0.0423314273,
-0.0136275468,
-0.0620297417,
0.0940930247,
-0.0123359673,
0.0038107636,
-0.0012427706,
-0.0117758047,
-0.0235434175,
-0.0210484546,
0.0371464118,
-0.0118328584,
-0.0107809911,
-0.0490267873,
-0.0446558557,
-0.0459092632,
0.0006162108,
0.0294558592,
0.0487948768,
-0.022865532,
0.0449825078,
0.0775443465,
0.0166406482,
-0.0286590066,
-0.0007771565,
0.0102556692,
-0.006491615,
-0.0292189308,
-0.0134022608,
-6.942942772e-33,
-0.0141251711,
-0.0335116051,
0.0324839503,
0.029267069,
0.0095197568,
0.0106642377,
-0.0676046461,
-0.0100712981,
0.0358213112,
-0.0168102738,
0.0358116738,
-0.0061124614,
-0.0252431668,
-0.025298981,
0.042786032,
0.0210566744,
0.0320690721,
0.0128481695,
-0.0448530838,
0.0194352791,
-0.0173490103,
0.0007511182,
-0.0221031476,
-0.0348855257,
-0.034558814,
-0.0053808689,
0.0004097052,
-0.0080696614,
-0.0132916952,
0.0366155989,
0.0127569959,
-0.0029395679,
-0.004076208,
-0.0236835424,
-0.0300655812,
0.0165034533,
-0.0346688777,
-0.0179914366,
0.0469782762,
-0.0193006713,
-0.0133464746,
-0.0559196658,
0.08331085,
0.0216115769,
-0.0385318212,
-0.0053432123,
0.0057191947,
0.0121936901,
0.020341523,
-0.0556103736,
-0.0779357105,
0.0358042754,
-0.038952712,
-0.0290807374,
-0.0528117456,
0.020793112,
-0.0283485837,
0.0492368788,
0.0299201328,
0.0101049347,
-0.0001846618,
0.0491196252,
0.0707487315,
-0.0229725353,
0.0157866664,
0.0256745219,
0.0234730337,
0.027922418,
-0.0561686307,
0.0320791677,
0.0093165291,
0.0863000676,
0.0200397652,
-0.0143448347,
0.0329894871,
0.0116282543,
-0.0527205803,
0.0206010118,
-0.0154524585,
0.0290241074,
0.039715305,
0.0178105514,
-0.0217747297,
-0.0135323657,
-0.035956081,
0.0271772463,
-0.0306758489,
-0.0047897571,
0.0307014119,
-0.0156125035,
-0.0323835239,
0.0188655797,
0.0051576686,
-0.0362899974,
0.0116019864,
0.0153818121,
-0.0482463799,
0.0325259753,
-0.0167173389,
0.0238402355,
-0.0068602571,
-0.0584070645,
0.0039676982,
-0.0018911937,
0.0840652883,
0.0300124921,
-0.0031221756,
0.0142830694,
-0.0570055209,
-0.0260576792,
-0.0732950717,
-0.0104736602,
-0.0170622524,
0.0419161208,
0.0198804699,
0.0122877574,
0.0135456529,
0.0425974913,
-0.0371198654,
-0.0438480452,
-0.0431773365,
-0.0077098906,
0.0075443112,
0.0280082673,
-0.0301518813,
-0.0275165532,
-0.0582807213,
-0.0078261252,
0.0292597171,
-0.023603579,
-0.0609791651,
0.0509964675,
3.496e-7,
0.0099319415,
0.0364267081,
-0.01273089,
0.0998018533,
0.0070550819,
0.0262235682,
-0.0173609126,
-0.0442482866,
0.0201870762,
-0.009309737,
-0.0298477057,
0.0280215163,
0.0362519361,
0.0191544145,
-0.0415163189,
0.0297527388,
-0.0057257451,
-0.0013782131,
-0.0800127611,
0.0050909584,
0.0208186135,
0.0330243595,
0.0096327253,
-0.0068385364,
0.0186285693,
-0.0399148129,
0.0082649477,
-0.0175418016,
0.0003981895,
0.0525676124,
-0.0628369972,
0.030991409,
-0.0099414755,
0.0025890423,
-0.0050152177,
-0.0287673995,
0.0185985062,
0.0920982957,
0.0125756031,
0.0656887442,
0.0456099622,
-0.034099929,
-0.0086940555,
-0.0373970978,
0.0367653407,
-0.0325512178,
-0.0147077721,
-0.04065172,
-0.017938897,
-0.0176467299,
-0.0331893042,
-0.0304921437,
0.0388283022,
0.0014764115,
-0.0253199581,
-0.0321890712,
-0.0374957621,
-0.0262347236,
-0.0264910627,
0.0547202937,
-0.0270935316,
-0.0403721146,
-0.0624970458,
0.0510872714,
0.0097164158,
-0.0271073896,
-0.010416585,
3.800787873e-34,
0.0233503003,
-0.0406641327,
0.0187248792,
0.0022052682,
0.0909414068,
-0.0009881071,
-0.0777483806,
0.0275523085,
-0.0166431312,
-0.0069390419,
-0.0383167155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15871v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15871v1 | Uncovering Hidden Intentions: Exploring Prompt Recovery for Deeper Insights into Generated Texts | 2024-06-22T15:16:11 | 2024-06-22T15:16:11 | Louis Give, Timo Zaoral, Maria Antonietta Bruno | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Today, the detection of AI-generated content is receiving more and more
attention. Our idea is to go beyond detection and try to recover the prompt
used to generate a text. This paper, to the best of our knowledge, introduces
the first investigation in this particular domain without a closed set of
tasks. Our goal is to study if this approach is promising. We experiment with
zero-shot and few-shot in-context learning but also with LoRA fine-tuning.
After that, we evaluate the benefits of using a semi-synthetic dataset. For
this first study, we limit ourselves to text generated by a single model. The
results show that it is possible to recover the original prompt with a
reasonable degree of accuracy. | [
0.0402254127,
0.0311499275,
-0.0214690994,
0.0420266427,
-0.0296649039,
0.0101152193,
0.0217712894,
0.0462226421,
0.0097053824,
-0.0380226076,
-0.0134364059,
-0.0262058172,
-0.0097116567,
0.0567752607,
0.0197957344,
-0.0047329073,
0.0037648226,
-0.0143059222,
0.0194360279,
0.0480934493,
0.0143955545,
0.012676823,
0.0190085191,
0.0512233898,
-0.0463800132,
-0.0394404568,
-0.0416983366,
0.0350460745,
0.0262637809,
0.0022843934,
0.0089735612,
0.0296247117,
0.0080997311,
0.0653173774,
0.000002056,
-0.0562411547,
-0.0541566201,
-0.0225156061,
-0.0870599598,
-0.0395585224,
0.0372150354,
-0.0314717814,
-0.0579522662,
0.0272360034,
-0.0313718244,
0.061097607,
0.011858955,
0.0420589,
0.0154910246,
0.0750923306,
-0.0202496797,
0.0233258847,
0.0278278422,
-0.0057005626,
0.0269897338,
0.0120404996,
0.0073055956,
-0.0731873065,
-0.0243098531,
0.0224827398,
0.0105097191,
0.0283772592,
0.0406228974,
-0.0700374022,
-0.0298358183,
-0.0069771698,
0.0200671852,
-0.0382096991,
-0.0374405123,
0.0366640463,
-0.0264122542,
0.0033778036,
0.024025714,
-0.050719142,
0.0100298496,
-0.0087676421,
-0.0134834964,
0.0325376391,
-0.0397890843,
-0.0178992003,
0.0029310586,
-0.0069984817,
-0.0175846908,
-0.0210368112,
0.0044053262,
0.0077979811,
0.0264584552,
-0.0268523339,
-0.0264824331,
-0.0064987279,
0.0209394637,
-0.0580818169,
0.0189284254,
0.0562799163,
-0.0129672736,
-0.0033668694,
-0.0626958385,
-0.0305655189,
0.0448402949,
0.031001918,
0.0800640807,
0.0194034409,
-0.0478633307,
0.0359331891,
-0.0282541197,
0.0432224497,
0.0068636509,
0.0365301296,
-0.0142689794,
0.0400689207,
-0.0129626803,
-0.0288923103,
-0.03224352,
0.0028218706,
-0.0253867861,
-0.001804002,
-0.0141036985,
0.028641304,
0.008757541,
0.0408484451,
-0.0353314094,
-0.0178891364,
-0.0519518144,
-0.005901773,
0.0081812311,
0.0080634085,
-0.022607768,
0.0506121852,
0.053284511,
-0.0917401537,
-0.0340664797,
0.0444528684,
0.050881315,
0.0094124377,
0.0071225357,
0.0732170641,
-0.0402785242,
-0.0634353086,
-0.0547180586,
-0.0955069438,
-0.0296055023,
-0.0368020684,
-0.0146232247,
-0.0307194535,
-0.0181784462,
-0.0328243598,
-0.0150281563,
-0.0055004032,
-0.0078460006,
0.0419207588,
0.023442978,
0.0476008616,
-0.0244772863,
-0.0454672948,
0.0227487162,
0.0217038579,
0.0003717371,
0.0335076936,
-0.0070962501,
0.129487738,
0.0399746187,
0.0176821928,
0.0409797989,
0.0433573946,
0.0326948762,
0.0093469163,
0.003216228,
-0.0169842765,
0.0096356198,
-0.0024866257,
0.0146961017,
0.0104946615,
-0.0329292081,
0.0081056776,
0.0692998469,
0.0536015145,
-0.0111690145,
-0.0336189158,
0.0594676919,
0.0144611001,
0.00017263,
0.0614502132,
-0.0117918886,
0.016892802,
-0.0529579185,
0.0004319574,
0.0093570165,
-0.0445052534,
-0.003843043,
-0.045283135,
0.0208910611,
-0.0312191434,
-0.0301969107,
-0.0199672915,
0.0594057478,
0.0637256727,
-0.059735477,
-0.0600229651,
0.0186172985,
-0.0478327796,
-0.0086247372,
-0.0735039786,
0.0875103474,
0.0461099446,
0.0290574711,
-0.0597078167,
0.0095715523,
-0.047077816,
0.0009752899,
0.04225187,
-0.0090887435,
-0.0161734242,
0.0141930822,
-0.0322285667,
-0.0286051519,
-0.0337467752,
0.0084813526,
0.0187433492,
-0.0380112156,
0.0041266493,
0.0193403233,
0.0349364653,
-0.0102437837,
0.0411285944,
-0.0242119581,
-0.0563022979,
0.0057019596,
0.0508290529,
0.0052044783,
0.0412990227,
0.0009065745,
-0.0015679995,
0.0354958922,
-0.0378072299,
-0.0131184645,
-0.030221276,
-0.0348650552,
-0.0644524992,
-0.0199214332,
-0.0175334662,
-0.0466073677,
0.0055890614,
-0.0196511894,
-0.0352494381,
-0.0175098982,
-0.0263587106,
-0.0047768033,
-0.0775482357,
0.0026206817,
0.0091396077,
-0.004265836,
-0.0349033736,
0.0393074676,
0.0121070873,
-0.0041637248,
0.0656790584,
-0.009347979,
0.0341286622,
-0.0368226767,
0.0181688741,
-0.0280418545,
-0.039613165,
-0.0047015715,
0.0546366498,
0.0188792981,
-0.0511079654,
-0.0425179452,
-0.0404049978,
-0.0116234971,
-0.0477973409,
-0.0043512271,
0.0293367077,
0.0129178436,
-0.0100476574,
-0.0260929242,
-0.0252197832,
0.0016688508,
0.0181737281,
0.0162048638,
0.0480217561,
-0.0099167032,
0.0231099352,
-0.049032338,
0.0166717377,
-0.009969404,
0.0242976453,
0.0406732373,
-0.0189439747,
-0.0606194735,
0.06997969,
0.0140980715,
-0.0191579536,
-0.0358775109,
-0.034430936,
0.0429879501,
-0.0310653616,
0.0206953138,
0.1043984666,
0.0172562804,
0.0423115306,
0.0072035776,
0.0345692448,
-0.0547235943,
-0.007235575,
-0.0094802631,
-0.0106929364,
-0.0033318377,
-0.0131495576,
0.0412456952,
0.0528182685,
0.0423964188,
0.0260591228,
-0.0270944238,
0.0231459569,
-0.0005022353,
-0.0388244875,
-0.0471989699,
0.0056343186,
-0.0367214382,
0.0628380254,
-0.0357745513,
-0.0836893842,
0.052281253,
-0.0053599989,
-0.0163304098,
0.0264755934,
-0.0251136925,
-0.0118474895,
0.0475803465,
0.0026662131,
0.0185305271,
0.0344821624,
-0.0408140533,
-0.0464256145,
0.0256382674,
0.0152586596,
-0.0045056818,
0.0161446892,
0.0032199027,
0.0004892127,
-0.0366379693,
-0.0338575095,
-0.0523861684,
-0.0857725069,
0.0138090765,
-0.0129613895,
-0.0221302789,
-0.0122577762,
0.0126054212,
-0.0520323701,
0.026241608,
0.0643408597,
-0.0116233509,
-0.0310211182,
-0.0555195659,
0.0847174227,
0.075293988,
-0.0337022729,
-0.0154615371,
-0.0587571524,
0.0227605253,
0.0400195904,
-0.0044405046,
0.0230541844,
0.0147774722,
0.0110042039,
0.0028216776,
0.0285462458,
0.0094690891,
0.0348561592,
0.0321231484,
-0.0334369093,
-0.0298732668,
0.0555905737,
0.0197503027,
-0.0566615313,
-0.0317269601,
-0.0417913012,
0.0144955441,
-0.0009034874,
-0.0138903102,
-0.0866530687,
-0.0472256579,
0.0196468607,
0.0132310484,
-0.0507059731,
0.0099007478,
-0.0080098063,
-0.1190118268,
0.0470950454,
-0.0315797105,
-0.0060409103,
-0.0152756916,
-0.0268312301,
-0.0009136313,
0.0407843553,
-0.0111113228,
-0.009930389,
-0.0008447275,
-0.0156466439,
-0.001191992,
0.0404342525,
-0.0192422904,
-0.0193231497,
-0.0105216904,
0.0410271995,
0.0831137672,
0.0376391411,
0.0063762143,
-0.0078530731,
0.0053925351,
-0.0156032033,
0.035676796,
0.0268138628,
0.0885410383,
0.0079637133,
-0.0074825292,
-0.0165882464,
0.0518315621,
-0.0224502925,
-0.016800303,
0.0321318954,
0.0086404867,
-0.0188303273,
-0.0282260776,
0.0056269742,
-0.0364825726,
0.0616515465,
0.0458740592,
0.0699666291,
-0.0378281251,
-0.0351555459,
-0.0451478995,
0.024278827,
-0.0308807474,
-0.020601606,
0.0031903498,
0.0067164181,
0.0008931186,
-0.0679907054,
-0.0545391925,
0.0231500119,
0.0418951064,
0.0105498796,
0.0017088136,
-0.0140615869,
-0.0204706416,
-0.0280427039,
-0.0037694445,
-0.0373905823,
0.0309219547,
-0.0505719148,
-0.0112933768,
-0.0046944465,
-0.0841211602,
0.0067249625,
0.0261381101,
-0.0502549931,
-0.0253711343,
0.0067105261,
0.059278015,
0.0162150897,
0.0320919305,
-0.0065759351,
-0.0396374911,
0.0978244394,
0.0373664238,
-0.0237861574,
0.0034241679,
0.0315040126,
0.0347965509,
-0.0447727926,
0.025181016,
-0.0300885011,
0.0329152234,
0.0624602586,
-0.0313729309,
-0.032837458,
-0.0328054763,
0.0420332849,
0.0145145245,
0.0203185752,
-0.009762275,
-0.0046026721,
-0.0577979349,
0.0012670869,
-0.0094117606,
-0.005929946,
-0.0384263024,
-0.0055644438,
-0.0051598912,
-0.0306249987,
0.0018515898,
-0.0102563649,
-0.0507737286,
0.0370178558,
-0.046071738,
-0.0073013292,
0.0403433442,
0.0940021425,
0.0197789725,
0.0252796225,
0.0008570427,
0.0763778687,
-0.0129310293,
0.0545417629,
0.0168808401,
0.0510639362,
0.0192883182,
-0.0121295415,
0.0157148298,
0.0511123799,
-0.0483963713,
-0.0094891442,
-0.0278548785,
0.0228006002,
0.0554181673,
-0.0123827728,
0.0267458763,
0.0032242755,
0.0086718928,
-0.0066004731,
0.0400276519,
0.0428930596,
-0.06575609,
-0.0433048569,
-0.0047248937,
-0.0145544177,
0.0072613293,
0.0644813403,
-0.0414443165,
0.0484404899,
-0.0096821487,
0.0372017883,
-0.0636011735,
0.029743569,
0.0588933043,
-0.0041432688,
0.0152530251,
-0.0106035443,
-0.0126212686,
-0.0482533313,
0.0494783483,
-0.0024890883,
0.0130327214,
0.0217708088,
0.0105250804,
0.030485509,
-0.0308972001,
0.0229720473,
-0.0302861705,
0.0251529235,
-0.0166150816,
-0.0222464241,
-0.0313814767,
-5.792879875e-33,
-0.0022617595,
-0.0738755539,
-0.0154144317,
0.0021649057,
0.0420017727,
0.0345877968,
-0.0634827986,
-0.0271586478,
0.0179865398,
0.0096949665,
-0.0449804999,
-0.0007049221,
0.0207458157,
0.0254330244,
-0.005291576,
-0.0312955938,
0.0402429476,
-0.0119184032,
-0.0387908816,
0.0167310294,
0.0778825656,
0.0148773808,
0.0148131354,
-0.0316654816,
0.0170378517,
-0.019807294,
-0.0442557521,
-0.0002144388,
-0.0238687899,
0.0692583099,
-0.0105022313,
0.0131152282,
0.0303550195,
-0.0308016259,
-0.0175106991,
0.0949746072,
-0.0286041405,
-0.0488830023,
-0.0478637703,
-0.0140370224,
-0.0649489462,
-0.0733050853,
0.00434518,
-0.0438817292,
0.003264593,
0.0155492155,
0.0417363755,
0.0177786276,
0.0081609935,
-0.0499915257,
-0.1137682199,
-0.0007900001,
-0.0039243079,
-0.0484959036,
0.0428189039,
0.0535583496,
0.0509002842,
-0.0053811641,
-0.064599365,
0.0187522881,
-0.0028890721,
0.0156237343,
0.0108658504,
0.0158559177,
-0.0427283421,
0.0590533875,
0.0365317427,
0.0285396725,
-0.027387755,
-0.0143087152,
-0.0218429156,
0.0179685596,
0.044298254,
0.0684827492,
0.0121169277,
-0.0191547945,
-0.0464658067,
0.0491897762,
0.0120725194,
-0.015515497,
0.036184717,
-0.0173044205,
-0.0137135955,
0.0251802951,
-0.0219557434,
-0.0583206005,
-0.0396679528,
0.0113034993,
0.0374177396,
0.0656775162,
-0.0316045173,
-0.0476907678,
0.0356705859,
-0.0233842544,
0.0418667011,
0.0196667835,
-0.0472736023,
0.0286464505,
0.007662348,
0.0125611536,
-0.0225004647,
-0.0181161407,
0.0452253968,
0.0022674066,
0.025608737,
0.0149357952,
0.0570236742,
0.0326736532,
-0.0577076003,
0.02369757,
-0.0239959378,
0.0584887192,
0.0297849551,
-0.019319728,
0.0394415893,
-0.0325879827,
-0.0243500788,
0.0396060199,
0.024258092,
0.0085488595,
-0.0289104637,
-0.0000471176,
-0.0263907984,
-0.0043173507,
-0.0527081601,
-0.0209445208,
0.0090090698,
0.0327872932,
0.0384131595,
-0.019163413,
0.0242140125,
-0.0354422405,
2.617e-7,
-0.0186612178,
0.00362129,
0.0556447245,
0.0162548106,
0.0145255979,
0.0655406117,
0.0025688261,
0.0323144197,
0.0195476133,
-0.0105707841,
-0.0112033747,
-0.0373079665,
0.0484457314,
-0.0195565224,
-0.0981020853,
0.0426173545,
-0.0300859548,
0.0041796733,
-0.0453320667,
0.0234618913,
0.0766378343,
0.0620153993,
-0.016164396,
-0.0417240001,
0.0363706537,
-0.0028367417,
0.029312795,
0.0052710413,
0.0064670881,
0.0021376519,
0.0448957384,
-0.0356372111,
-0.0155794136,
-0.0095731067,
-0.0054876897,
-0.01828802,
-0.0125107411,
0.0479643904,
-0.0064032343,
-0.028045373,
-0.0065553072,
0.0023428826,
0.029027164,
-0.0215233602,
0.0580770336,
-0.0175662339,
-0.0120460177,
-0.0372857004,
-0.0113772433,
-0.0539937317,
0.0315809995,
-0.0278545339,
-0.0041686953,
0.0231314898,
0.0069920896,
0.0408686474,
0.0023503099,
-0.0536982268,
-0.022115659,
-0.0473377854,
-0.0241512973,
-0.0152923362,
-0.0769128278,
0.0188879594,
0.0409901254,
-0.0970006138,
0.0293628424,
2.163596076e-34,
-0.0103224171,
-0.0055713486,
0.0186978076,
0.0104255378,
0.0024522925,
0.0116925798,
0.0155032454,
0.0123970723,
0.0410813838,
-0.0601493344,
-0.013656104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15869v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15869v1 | A multitask learning framework for leveraging subjectivity of annotators to identify misogyny | 2024-06-22T15:06:08 | 2024-06-22T15:06:08 | Jason Angel, Segun Taofeek Aroyehun, Grigori Sidorov, Alexander Gelbukh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Identifying misogyny using artificial intelligence is a form of combating
online toxicity against women. However, the subjective nature of interpreting
misogyny poses a significant challenge to model the phenomenon. In this paper,
we propose a multitask learning approach that leverages the subjectivity of
this task to enhance the performance of the misogyny identification systems. We
incorporated diverse perspectives from annotators in our model design,
considering gender and age across six profile groups, and conducted extensive
experiments and error analysis using two language models to validate our four
alternative designs of the multitask learning technique to identify
misogynistic content in English tweets. The results demonstrate that
incorporating various viewpoints enhances the language models' ability to
interpret different forms of misogyny. This research advances content
moderation and highlights the importance of embracing diverse perspectives to
build effective online moderation systems. | [
0.1045163199,
0.0350327343,
-0.0155644175,
-0.0294878483,
-0.0226612762,
0.0383463912,
0.0620261915,
-0.0271819495,
0.0315820053,
-0.0741274282,
-0.0011202723,
-0.0269056614,
-0.0285464134,
-0.0147112561,
0.013791753,
0.0005513985,
0.0141202761,
0.0391908698,
0.0496901125,
-0.0025262143,
0.0664850026,
0.0268245414,
-0.0068850704,
0.0518908389,
-0.0421472527,
-0.0312054902,
0.0589267537,
0.0157803334,
0.0225224346,
0.0078072902,
0.0932120234,
0.0374046899,
-0.0024012269,
0.0577991754,
0.0000015679,
-0.0623163022,
0.0009235173,
0.0255449172,
0.0206550583,
-0.0489896499,
0.0939682946,
-0.0087473784,
0.001663207,
0.0436353907,
-0.0212434791,
0.0348933078,
0.0462651588,
0.0516107194,
0.086607188,
0.022677213,
-0.0214276612,
0.0138836494,
-0.0394257009,
0.0091081876,
-0.0258841198,
0.0192488395,
0.045498658,
-0.0132517349,
-0.0721572563,
-0.0027428034,
0.0113297449,
0.0201342274,
-0.0038577232,
-0.0170415062,
-0.0099932803,
-0.0403084233,
-0.0016511437,
-0.059845794,
0.0086907856,
0.0336448886,
-0.0050502317,
-0.0163404457,
-0.0063578836,
0.0173348393,
0.0178351793,
0.0197390243,
-0.0537111945,
0.0011381106,
-0.0510451682,
-0.0060057109,
-0.0101762461,
-0.024934601,
0.0375546776,
0.0738682672,
0.0408831164,
0.0402751081,
-0.0377551168,
-0.0603377856,
0.0261956267,
0.0414432995,
0.0291671958,
0.0279564094,
0.0338700004,
-0.0161279421,
-0.003780314,
0.0143393073,
0.0006263454,
-0.0587829798,
0.0400464907,
-0.1074147671,
0.0007774518,
0.0148317097,
0.006682951,
0.0046945065,
0.0279639754,
-0.0180725288,
0.0217511114,
0.0243828893,
-0.0090406062,
-0.0413946696,
-0.075146988,
0.0040542795,
0.0195313878,
0.0185851902,
0.0298714805,
0.033192493,
-0.0633324012,
-0.0067246463,
-0.0688101202,
-0.0400545225,
0.0267087892,
0.0045105102,
0.0045707105,
0.0386118032,
-0.0105865682,
0.0108830268,
-0.0328664482,
0.0494758897,
-0.0457710512,
-0.0709049404,
0.0003166549,
0.0275335684,
-0.0229692422,
-0.0300637577,
0.0313573778,
0.0464341603,
0.0279176664,
-0.030041812,
-0.0401827209,
0.0001832441,
-0.0367801748,
-0.0546213873,
0.015390831,
-0.0542056374,
0.0277129207,
0.0130431382,
-0.0160733666,
-0.0380131863,
0.0058688666,
0.0345514603,
-0.0316089094,
0.0671673343,
0.0022392774,
-0.0138915395,
0.0822965577,
0.0279087238,
-0.0302634854,
0.0924177468,
0.0368552357,
0.0228055753,
0.0291531403,
0.041250363,
-0.0095136333,
0.0261239745,
0.017907463,
0.0099924859,
-0.0098644653,
0.0118439989,
-0.0652367547,
-0.0223213341,
-0.0040504988,
0.0239089914,
0.0009411246,
-0.000128567,
0.0433597006,
0.0566003621,
-0.0055984845,
0.0677181035,
0.0852912664,
0.0185725596,
-0.030984696,
-0.0249416642,
-0.0400503427,
-0.0014941168,
-0.0222294051,
-0.0514185578,
0.0019647428,
0.0250011049,
-0.0161571614,
-0.0712903067,
-0.0170685444,
-0.036501579,
0.0598942637,
-0.0248692557,
0.0183208305,
0.0092791794,
-0.0115320878,
0.0108581418,
0.0437431224,
-0.044721812,
-0.0090719275,
-0.0366101526,
0.0114125507,
0.0866043568,
-0.0126625253,
-0.0535331778,
-0.0304219015,
-0.091545023,
0.0429148264,
0.0172807723,
0.0486313924,
-0.0095232632,
-0.0122686671,
-0.0274610091,
-0.0208879393,
0.03698707,
0.0050815027,
0.0000746743,
0.0466050245,
0.0085405055,
-0.0174376164,
0.0488527082,
-0.0704501569,
0.0354103521,
0.0236435048,
-0.0090359645,
0.0117509412,
0.0344292186,
0.0333589166,
0.0201783311,
-0.0093873478,
-0.0255615003,
-0.013993633,
-0.0198947359,
-0.0473726131,
-0.002567749,
-0.0104803564,
0.0197614618,
0.0274705328,
-0.0292928442,
-0.0593582429,
0.0297103617,
0.0103017371,
0.0388198644,
0.0583595671,
-0.0222483706,
-0.0671638846,
-0.0509094149,
-0.053122934,
-0.0690561309,
0.0225051176,
-0.0265750848,
0.053073477,
-0.0535869487,
-0.0220665205,
-0.012518052,
-0.1115996093,
-0.0098439595,
0.0088122506,
-0.0169142168,
-0.0347282477,
-0.0077786315,
0.0260459613,
0.0277074408,
0.0050845277,
-0.0305361897,
-0.0413017869,
-0.0817909911,
-0.0350161381,
-0.0183585864,
-0.002332205,
-0.009113336,
-0.0198291186,
0.0006960392,
0.0162901916,
-0.0043249391,
-0.0492173694,
-0.0026456909,
0.0385709256,
0.0367772281,
-0.0615196861,
0.0209168866,
-0.0542055033,
-0.0139740575,
-0.0554121695,
0.0328031629,
0.0218472872,
-0.0576661639,
0.0187334269,
-0.0478895828,
-0.0204992276,
0.0035656365,
-0.0002429169,
-0.0139841763,
0.0331170373,
0.0247833356,
-0.0041532749,
0.0341163799,
0.049579028,
0.1052613854,
0.0254130885,
0.0335991755,
-0.0058498979,
0.0157362185,
0.0074449754,
0.0377490111,
-0.0111663369,
-0.018695889,
-0.0054859552,
0.0281461477,
-0.0180237815,
-0.0172107685,
-0.0692493021,
0.0851845443,
-0.0537061207,
-0.053450074,
-0.0251894873,
-0.042903617,
-0.0054087825,
-0.0134262415,
-0.0178547017,
-0.0282385871,
0.0590230078,
0.0268282183,
0.0125260269,
-0.0268857609,
-0.0373376086,
-0.0220204554,
0.0032577114,
-0.0639685541,
0.0547402352,
-0.0054570944,
0.0020219404,
0.0095577743,
-0.0356233567,
0.0508271828,
-0.0272994339,
0.0200276338,
-0.025647765,
0.0249791071,
0.0371005572,
-0.0589244366,
-0.04118523,
-0.053093683,
-0.0347154811,
-0.0288570002,
-0.0199972019,
0.0289643127,
-0.0485220067,
0.0286156498,
0.0003709914,
-0.0445284098,
-0.0007504034,
-0.0316209197,
0.0351867676,
-0.0396318287,
0.0141397398,
0.0061026597,
0.0143043278,
-0.0211292468,
0.0004354018,
0.0464671925,
-0.0504773632,
0.0016537586,
0.0145266848,
0.0031372223,
0.0283521712,
-0.039822612,
0.0020118537,
-0.0453439467,
0.0223650821,
-0.0214519221,
0.0023300345,
0.0805391669,
0.0311517157,
-0.0351943597,
0.0040974459,
-0.0092515862,
-0.0082764896,
0.0386740305,
0.0040039066,
-0.0306152385,
0.0010942225,
-0.0352301672,
0.0361454301,
-0.0779096708,
-0.0537318252,
-0.0071182507,
-0.0617337823,
-0.0154384058,
-0.0152011104,
-0.0336775072,
-0.0076994183,
0.0296446402,
-0.0048246668,
-0.0225123614,
0.0294027589,
-0.0480666123,
0.0267299581,
-0.0006285097,
0.0106610153,
-0.0465625301,
-0.0406995416,
0.0252180323,
-0.0209382437,
0.0357625484,
-0.0065982449,
0.0693148822,
-0.0368708335,
0.0009958592,
0.0293835253,
0.0152557613,
-0.0067288014,
-0.0347937569,
0.0298465192,
-0.0288119502,
-0.0124740517,
-0.0393117145,
0.0235739965,
0.03602897,
0.0031693084,
-0.0089659942,
0.041467417,
0.0398211703,
0.0093762884,
-0.0480893254,
0.0107926829,
0.0511287339,
0.0443202034,
0.0185041334,
-0.0765412673,
-0.0086890198,
-0.064203918,
-0.0171139985,
-0.0270869415,
-0.0725398436,
-0.0173250921,
0.0255057234,
0.0075413077,
-0.0072520548,
-0.0367279872,
0.0196272992,
-0.0086278534,
0.00433229,
-0.0117676444,
0.0409900583,
0.0009057185,
-0.0435758419,
-0.0429987796,
0.0120759662,
0.0408001095,
0.0462111868,
-0.0233164411,
-0.0118544884,
0.0003662238,
-0.0239877943,
0.0437805057,
-0.0191613548,
-0.0454831645,
0.0276083555,
0.065675281,
0.0149621684,
0.0318541303,
-0.021031484,
-0.0425600149,
0.0123447618,
0.0429802574,
-0.0122540826,
-0.0006241154,
0.0449705981,
0.0364458896,
0.0205935854,
0.0357941501,
-0.0303330906,
0.0129097719,
-0.0024994796,
-0.0547861382,
-0.0450800918,
0.0261783693,
-0.0143049732,
-0.0031359042,
0.0068190717,
-0.0010393407,
-0.0418626405,
-0.027935328,
-0.046138119,
-0.0091596721,
-0.0497026742,
0.0083033806,
-0.0033664098,
0.016799856,
-0.0226224624,
-0.0524409711,
0.0139012448,
-0.0180926323,
0.0282001439,
-0.0655768216,
0.0212764777,
0.0195863228,
0.0347453095,
-0.0325594656,
-0.0052154306,
-0.0281900652,
-0.0040699472,
0.0119860051,
-0.0263759848,
0.0037525163,
0.0152668674,
0.0040883743,
0.0326897725,
-0.0196059737,
0.0082248095,
-0.0138227772,
0.0112577584,
-0.0129801035,
0.0236223526,
-0.0074082003,
-0.0182344597,
0.0718054548,
0.0311494078,
-0.041669976,
-0.0084519759,
0.0004204791,
-0.0178875905,
-0.0004732403,
0.0118936962,
0.0299736615,
-0.0139716445,
-0.0088372119,
0.0230396371,
-0.0049919118,
0.0265638791,
0.0152847543,
-0.0729287639,
-0.0434932634,
-0.0270660967,
-0.001580412,
0.0315178223,
0.0240565315,
0.0283986256,
-0.0791630223,
-0.0100847241,
0.0224906094,
-0.0488461033,
0.047735218,
-0.0191981215,
-0.0285591371,
0.0696552247,
0.0094590327,
0.0072365617,
-0.0447513834,
-0.0364658646,
0.005451527,
-0.0346633792,
-0.0096837878,
-5.104828868e-33,
-0.0154787758,
-0.0409336202,
-0.0101134731,
0.0165996198,
-0.0139221409,
-0.0225559454,
0.0360769667,
0.0073468164,
-0.0061074835,
0.0188888609,
0.0374615043,
0.0380159058,
-0.0019919178,
-0.0067191981,
0.0339240544,
0.0008179949,
0.0425872467,
-0.0233648829,
-0.0066484837,
-0.0091839619,
0.0167946182,
0.0204233062,
0.0138294492,
-0.1047717556,
0.0939543098,
-0.0008291098,
-0.0210494976,
0.0233731065,
-0.0185115803,
0.0753531605,
-0.0018270368,
0.0992878601,
0.0349061452,
-0.0293715633,
0.0502332114,
0.0629064813,
-0.0501786061,
-0.0388935432,
0.0076966849,
0.0129837664,
0.0149040194,
-0.0246101245,
0.0408119075,
0.0232883152,
-0.0453757457,
-0.0230718367,
0.0640436932,
0.0065546217,
0.0612070411,
-0.0395335332,
-0.0615493283,
-0.0089628128,
-0.0683609918,
-0.021738708,
0.0286448672,
0.0573474392,
0.016070921,
0.0011018056,
-0.0844224244,
0.0291415732,
-0.0535371639,
-0.0526192859,
0.0051697469,
-0.0207050368,
0.004784191,
0.054809887,
-0.0058523207,
0.0582982823,
-0.0474866442,
0.025220206,
0.020699054,
0.010642454,
0.0307279862,
0.0543265678,
-0.0144631788,
-0.0752737969,
-0.0887345299,
-0.0403541997,
0.0490557663,
0.0115721039,
0.0230515413,
-0.0424813703,
-0.0624797605,
-0.0525339693,
-0.0049694749,
-0.0705287606,
-0.0231588632,
-0.0140051991,
0.0078232028,
-0.0121116322,
-0.0699911714,
0.0034315097,
-0.0292708483,
-0.0556411967,
-0.0236982815,
0.0458148532,
-0.0258662999,
-0.0146090984,
0.0631556511,
0.0156412069,
-0.026495073,
0.0181580149,
-0.0130432714,
-0.0010563018,
0.0421558842,
-0.002476776,
0.0933503285,
0.049912706,
-0.0530605353,
-0.0199445225,
0.0033807384,
0.0516398251,
-0.023359606,
0.0649690107,
-0.0056109945,
0.0544517525,
-0.007391674,
0.0009269981,
0.0739466995,
0.0363988876,
-0.0063295714,
-0.0003750442,
-0.0063003274,
-0.0125565771,
-0.0013622062,
-0.027622832,
0.0242813099,
0.0061473646,
0.0168011505,
-0.0617330335,
0.0128067695,
-0.0189252589,
2.225e-7,
0.0524525642,
0.0862678885,
-0.0144654457,
-0.006364652,
0.0416547582,
0.0337584727,
0.0178428311,
0.0399067961,
0.0065335389,
-0.0146805169,
-0.0170248169,
0.0513340011,
-0.0077002491,
0.05820686,
-0.0270181634,
-0.0361696258,
-0.0355176814,
0.0421362333,
-0.0321298353,
0.0496614054,
0.0302171614,
0.0323994607,
0.0413017273,
-0.046830181,
-0.0205951519,
0.002435619,
0.0580982454,
-0.0117953848,
-0.0112864664,
0.0181215052,
0.0612903684,
-0.0037583082,
0.0384092703,
0.002725505,
0.0179625116,
-0.0168044697,
0.0492058471,
0.0335507989,
-0.0051706927,
-0.0061149136,
0.0237770397,
0.0274874177,
0.0079562105,
-0.0140639897,
0.0511170141,
-0.0046772184,
-0.040722236,
-0.0781767815,
0.0160669722,
0.0004656755,
0.0816429108,
-0.0224015303,
-0.020604033,
-0.004562153,
0.0141183464,
0.0054747709,
0.0094508138,
-0.0300392359,
0.0016964853,
-0.0466658324,
-0.0251449235,
-0.0261680782,
0.009219395,
-0.0084099332,
0.0327116996,
-0.0016818359,
0.0732949525,
1.318981459e-34,
0.0188158657,
-0.0103554213,
0.027958326,
-0.0062859966,
0.0070506912,
0.0495983064,
0.0008606075,
-0.0042241304,
0.0189542416,
0.0011225573,
0.005045665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17803v1 | Understanding the Role of User Profile in the Personalization of Large Language Models | 2024-06-22T14:32:35 | 2024-06-22T14:32:35 | Bin Wu, Zhengyan Shi, Hossein A. Rahmani, Varsha Ramineni, Emine Yilmaz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Utilizing user profiles to personalize Large Language Models (LLMs) has been
shown to enhance the performance on a wide range of tasks. However, the precise
role of user profiles and their effect mechanism on LLMs remains unclear. This
study first confirms that the effectiveness of user profiles is primarily due
to personalization information rather than semantic information. Furthermore,
we investigate how user profiles affect the personalization of LLMs. Within the
user profile, we reveal that it is the historical personalized response
produced or approved by users that plays a pivotal role in personalizing LLMs.
This discovery unlocks the potential of LLMs to incorporate a greater number of
user profiles within the constraints of limited input length. As for the
position of user profiles, we observe that user profiles integrated into
different positions of the input context do not contribute equally to
personalization. Instead, where the user profile that is closer to the
beginning affects more on the personalization of LLMs. Our findings reveal the
role of user profiles for the personalization of LLMs, and showcase how
incorporating user profiles impacts performance providing insight to leverage
user profiles effectively. | [
0.0734704435,
0.0337839276,
-0.0483721085,
0.0263228472,
-0.0138773071,
-0.0171418358,
0.0539884418,
-0.002652412,
-0.0130784996,
-0.027733814,
-0.0318011083,
-0.0410734862,
-0.004822372,
0.0336413346,
0.0076644719,
-0.0991284698,
0.0346297026,
-0.0521284528,
-0.0212263502,
-0.0104595702,
0.0128608532,
0.0147387097,
0.0429092087,
0.0575506091,
0.0120562138,
-0.0112067228,
0.013767208,
-0.0093790246,
-0.0209985264,
-0.0093587777,
-0.0062944028,
0.0873604715,
-0.0050581484,
0.0280045122,
0.0000021259,
-0.0310740322,
-0.0056329509,
-0.0346085802,
-0.0230664164,
0.0673183054,
0.0989180356,
0.0830863044,
-0.010748513,
0.0188913271,
-0.026933765,
0.0167262591,
0.0266603827,
-0.0088938493,
0.0252601672,
0.0150941359,
0.0064982646,
-0.0116085606,
-0.036257498,
-0.019677937,
0.0124555975,
-0.0038923062,
-0.0084591815,
-0.0224289,
0.0058758389,
-0.0053377352,
-0.0318382122,
0.0335573666,
0.0119989067,
-0.0276842732,
0.0278540216,
0.0250892267,
0.0000772085,
-0.0133848004,
0.0248379428,
0.0690901428,
0.0159107912,
-0.0106410971,
-0.0289692357,
-0.0215887055,
-0.000247141,
0.0358374789,
-0.0306743998,
-0.0173071176,
-0.0155892922,
0.0043650293,
0.0137763517,
0.0037545857,
0.0294515751,
0.0175071787,
-0.038935367,
0.0812303349,
0.0259412136,
0.0027588198,
-0.0231798571,
-0.0040213978,
0.0134538934,
-0.0939564109,
0.0155702811,
0.0001169333,
-0.041892916,
0.0142491395,
-0.040164765,
-0.0086946487,
0.0241992865,
-0.0272522103,
0.0625956208,
0.0454029292,
0.0075388234,
0.0241935626,
-0.0062107551,
0.0419338271,
-0.0047243363,
-0.0301874112,
-0.0463361405,
-0.012235391,
-0.0357310884,
-0.012700947,
-0.0024663529,
0.0270498339,
-0.0107932389,
0.0179552361,
-0.0614915267,
0.0772966146,
0.0136323599,
0.0020143529,
0.0087895468,
0.0061815912,
-0.0198901221,
-0.0207705069,
-0.06034429,
0.0178922378,
-0.0710371286,
-0.0186582096,
0.010476822,
-0.0312981009,
0.0453668199,
0.0057120658,
0.0117897931,
-0.0323847234,
-0.0080924816,
0.0318046398,
0.0034495459,
-0.0287880041,
0.0032010372,
-0.0538507067,
0.0258196499,
-0.0623867474,
-0.0445390977,
-0.091023609,
0.0102159381,
0.0609678514,
0.0002782486,
-0.0651556104,
-0.0370570868,
0.0187910106,
-0.0122629739,
0.0480851904,
0.0016251408,
0.0163880046,
0.0288466215,
0.0066146399,
-0.0052918568,
0.0457934476,
0.0138772223,
0.048581548,
0.0450070091,
-0.0327784233,
0.0012739777,
0.0476248935,
-0.0487248041,
0.0081522446,
-0.0394150168,
0.021675067,
-0.017628368,
0.0047464999,
0.0438572429,
0.0389870368,
-0.0306634791,
-0.0027084122,
0.0658845976,
0.080603011,
0.0253182407,
0.0249231327,
0.0529448427,
-0.0021194611,
0.0214973111,
0.0267826151,
-0.0371914692,
-0.0019423178,
0.0067693731,
0.0013421488,
0.0229198709,
0.0313592739,
-0.0075168605,
-0.0358964689,
0.0106645357,
-0.0162843503,
0.0315272063,
0.0253900327,
0.0206516795,
-0.0272647757,
0.0104177641,
0.059552025,
0.0207549967,
-0.0607551709,
0.0483373925,
-0.0282444227,
0.0162563343,
0.1348600984,
0.0502161831,
0.0023139829,
-0.0296383109,
0.0044094371,
-0.0219721366,
0.0411638319,
0.0800129995,
-0.0227824356,
-0.0323465019,
-0.0308516789,
-0.0459995531,
0.0055826195,
-0.0117260367,
0.0299341828,
0.0350606814,
-0.0051417081,
0.0150029026,
-0.0163558293,
-0.0314576142,
-0.014730908,
-0.0692941546,
-0.0275716931,
-0.0060477806,
0.0158319958,
0.0057560685,
0.0329879299,
0.0396414399,
0.0123301782,
-0.0002528053,
-0.0121232802,
0.0291124862,
-0.0233782399,
-0.0502359681,
0.0320910178,
0.0601673312,
0.0222210363,
-0.0004808436,
0.0042971852,
0.0207202472,
-0.0436114445,
0.020182766,
-0.0006603299,
0.0668577254,
-0.0269798767,
0.0194165185,
-0.0295477975,
-0.0057834624,
-0.0602388196,
0.0423902683,
-0.0107695051,
0.0050340532,
0.0211202484,
-0.0031742763,
0.0109477872,
-0.0262223557,
-0.0288874526,
0.0067009879,
0.0342713594,
0.004530387,
0.0508470275,
-0.0294784382,
-0.0475612506,
0.0012456989,
-0.1046911627,
-0.0291297641,
-0.0060308794,
0.0176525377,
0.0253358614,
0.0400306769,
-0.0161910374,
-0.0214339271,
-0.0459260568,
-0.0291642956,
0.009513991,
0.0486109965,
0.0187062342,
0.0142733045,
-0.0354894847,
-0.0707672834,
-0.0230339766,
-0.001318801,
0.0310156383,
-0.0165535659,
-0.0437113233,
-0.0456920154,
0.0028929352,
-0.0566530228,
0.0286864229,
-0.0052432157,
-0.0219611414,
0.0320279226,
-0.0189372655,
0.0724520683,
0.0184318051,
-0.0181630161,
0.0247759819,
0.0723776743,
-0.0004640487,
-0.0571306758,
-0.0081258975,
-0.0380560607,
-0.0071799005,
-0.0579719804,
-0.0237822793,
-0.0013208864,
0.0613001101,
0.015124362,
-0.0058301506,
-0.0407957472,
0.0381040722,
-0.0290550925,
-0.0178329106,
-0.032573346,
-0.0032562539,
-0.0329477489,
0.0805180818,
0.0071670418,
-0.0612935461,
0.075199537,
-0.0077551208,
0.0082078148,
-0.0019392674,
-0.0123848123,
-0.0254695304,
0.0540462546,
0.026712399,
0.0480953008,
-0.031924285,
-0.037855465,
-0.0519158803,
-0.0205696728,
0.025917694,
-0.0500846095,
0.0292265788,
-0.0320536718,
-0.0171786565,
0.0103252437,
-0.0415286608,
-0.041062016,
-0.0654768497,
-0.0341202468,
0.0028310684,
0.028845055,
-0.0560698807,
0.0114415074,
-0.0053909519,
0.0275055096,
0.0257537253,
-0.0244112574,
0.005354085,
-0.0078194607,
-0.0090869479,
0.0499369018,
0.0105377799,
0.0042142151,
-0.0241851285,
0.0045612087,
0.0230707545,
0.0510891005,
-0.0307363644,
0.0026685162,
-0.0073988475,
0.0666938424,
-0.0653842092,
-0.0484817736,
0.0595689639,
0.0397775471,
-0.0581670329,
0.0234491769,
0.0966034755,
0.0445911512,
-0.0863922238,
-0.0020922252,
-0.0172578637,
0.045615986,
0.0448675826,
0.0529841408,
-0.0380936936,
-0.0077613601,
0.0035164431,
0.0223838259,
-0.004033315,
-0.0037711256,
-0.0345532298,
-0.1108885556,
0.0044322559,
-0.00029818,
-0.0533816591,
0.0140329916,
-0.0199064594,
0.0024282665,
0.026814742,
0.038666945,
0.0108169187,
-0.0323110856,
0.0153021552,
0.0113937054,
-0.0421573147,
-0.0725875273,
-0.0016164504,
-0.0367787667,
0.0604803413,
0.0570379421,
-0.0046582618,
0.0153691545,
-0.0224145483,
0.0359650403,
0.0426039547,
0.0451750979,
-0.0299966,
0.0360444263,
0.0169480648,
0.0177028514,
-0.0497141629,
-0.0114435339,
0.0007772296,
-0.0180527605,
-0.0156844817,
0.0813522041,
-0.0146492571,
0.0188105218,
-0.0043031611,
-0.0356288552,
-0.0104902396,
0.058787223,
0.0557908602,
-0.0833403766,
-0.0170974396,
-0.0773625225,
-0.0242310632,
-0.046538312,
-0.0445438884,
0.0071831867,
-0.0272466931,
-0.0230092853,
-0.0403456204,
-0.0645928383,
0.0331710875,
-0.0141102839,
0.0276244748,
0.0581154935,
-0.013732723,
-0.0436279811,
-0.0154772485,
0.0418346375,
-0.051134713,
0.0322322473,
-0.0811103284,
-0.0335253067,
0.0131705627,
-0.0389211513,
0.0129443565,
-0.0197197665,
-0.031913545,
-0.0561087243,
0.0139289582,
0.0289673973,
0.0257599056,
0.0401550867,
0.002900511,
-0.1231716722,
0.0464021228,
-0.0263451468,
-0.0122994808,
-0.0023030196,
-0.0098889079,
0.0148331458,
-0.010827383,
0.0421917401,
-0.0213350076,
-0.0421020314,
0.0260619689,
0.005338829,
-0.0209465474,
-0.0721744373,
0.0019022729,
0.0315299332,
0.0384397134,
-0.0221439358,
0.0029765598,
-0.0156082418,
-0.0007243037,
-0.0452134572,
-0.0206079669,
-0.0044188742,
-0.0226363149,
0.0363260582,
-0.0022030829,
0.0105959773,
-0.0084488401,
-0.0539259724,
0.0576422215,
-0.0414226204,
0.0392205305,
-0.0060686702,
-0.0033780911,
0.055740878,
0.0418075398,
-0.0191696938,
0.020920489,
0.0080047389,
0.0274049509,
-0.0416219682,
0.0359340981,
-0.0316862538,
-0.0132493442,
-0.0473842695,
0.0463540033,
-0.0347982161,
-0.0467418432,
0.0136924274,
0.015912367,
0.0358893164,
0.0011194652,
0.0406781919,
-0.0233080108,
-0.0141299106,
-0.0232713949,
-0.0009284078,
0.0336122178,
-0.0232652817,
-0.0128850564,
0.0033527408,
-0.0351756662,
-0.0022458823,
0.0801913962,
0.0199761633,
0.017990537,
-0.0506808609,
-0.0306457542,
-0.0255159512,
0.0225371551,
-0.0048715747,
0.0385418907,
-0.0631963387,
-0.015693577,
-0.0695639104,
-0.066212967,
-0.0044304435,
-0.0099991206,
-0.032468006,
-0.0145857325,
0.0444826595,
0.0578751005,
-0.0074802656,
-0.026992932,
-0.062353082,
0.016494358,
-0.0179731231,
-0.0183829349,
-0.0114101311,
-6.426376923e-33,
-0.0165246576,
-0.0289737713,
0.0276255701,
-0.0001695844,
0.0004048566,
-0.0322018228,
-0.0268269945,
0.0435396917,
0.019748278,
-0.0430955552,
-0.0609921142,
-0.0265334249,
0.0119002461,
-0.001587671,
0.0378254466,
0.0086806566,
0.0670549721,
0.0356638841,
-0.0256038606,
0.0089314831,
0.0388012789,
0.0124329552,
0.0500067808,
-0.059690211,
0.0340354405,
-0.0108488789,
0.0146441814,
-0.004007699,
-0.0066335611,
0.1062180623,
-0.0136066806,
0.0437966511,
0.0169630609,
-0.02061579,
-0.0357809439,
0.0143354051,
-0.0382117815,
-0.0379855707,
0.0579736568,
0.0368431546,
-0.0113912523,
-0.0823868662,
0.0267387908,
-0.0255983248,
-0.0448725484,
0.0260094348,
0.0299290959,
-0.0024637352,
-0.0314108431,
0.0199129507,
-0.0406996496,
0.016013857,
0.0401447006,
0.0490761064,
0.0330176316,
0.0148480572,
-0.0004594627,
0.0199615993,
-0.0312351584,
0.0337707847,
0.0262505058,
0.0378443822,
0.0941319019,
0.0647492632,
0.0047407146,
0.0397934988,
0.0257348642,
0.0353057534,
0.0045356792,
-0.0107473964,
0.0093353223,
0.0122128325,
0.0168612842,
0.0642903671,
-0.0147821773,
-0.0162200555,
0.0068225148,
0.0423368104,
0.0414211713,
0.0033869946,
0.0419908501,
0.0127847185,
-0.021618912,
-0.0284693167,
-0.0548553541,
-0.009149557,
-0.0586053431,
-0.055384282,
0.0205151625,
-0.0229998976,
-0.0248720702,
-0.034491919,
0.0386975296,
-0.0239529051,
-0.0695311874,
0.005360614,
-0.0401032716,
0.0366503038,
0.0369303599,
0.0037567788,
-0.0284841396,
0.0121983541,
-0.0241440963,
-0.0639162883,
-0.0101670763,
0.0239139963,
-0.0043955245,
0.0270073619,
-0.0602822118,
0.005252555,
-0.0238616988,
-0.0126745813,
-0.0026006449,
0.0245639663,
0.0702474862,
0.0035735785,
-0.0320891328,
0.047970552,
0.0432261825,
0.0183347911,
-0.037333861,
-0.0477476791,
0.0152652385,
0.0021675152,
-0.0241981782,
-0.0036150559,
-0.0455926061,
0.0650099367,
0.080995813,
0.0099672582,
-0.0208153445,
-0.0148671009,
2.708e-7,
0.0532794409,
0.0716052726,
-0.0200526305,
0.0230863262,
0.0236665551,
0.0391681269,
-0.0033269257,
-0.0245273113,
0.0297430307,
0.0382775404,
-0.0116301645,
0.0040397681,
0.035916876,
0.0505838767,
-0.0752573013,
-0.0149764232,
-0.0076850276,
0.0404531322,
-0.0627911314,
0.0112280436,
0.0185965002,
0.0650042444,
0.0256062299,
-0.0143734934,
-0.0099517517,
-0.0295224711,
0.0467246696,
-0.0732992813,
-0.0516578555,
0.0046582161,
0.0327086635,
-0.0066228481,
0.0172747932,
-0.0075731617,
-0.0158088692,
0.0068107634,
-0.0062739742,
0.065847069,
-0.0103452569,
-0.0197519138,
0.0116804559,
-0.0302476734,
-0.0123895537,
-0.0636467561,
0.0494557023,
0.0054730889,
0.0073086629,
-0.0177215952,
0.022510644,
-0.0189720467,
0.0251172464,
-0.0362107195,
-0.0283383559,
0.0326735824,
0.0163084306,
-0.0276192166,
-0.0208775122,
-0.045220159,
-0.0456618294,
-0.0035190892,
-0.0424641594,
-0.0491350144,
-0.0593657345,
0.0039562061,
0.0183893424,
-0.0285692196,
0.0181023739,
2.511146593e-34,
0.0281676594,
0.035572622,
0.0490112454,
-0.0163573474,
0.0298871677,
0.0047175055,
-0.0289087556,
0.0311224796,
0.0522354692,
-0.0895753577,
-0.0485188439
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15862v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15862v1 | Speech Analysis of Language Varieties in Italy | 2024-06-22T14:19:51 | 2024-06-22T14:19:51 | Moreno La Quatra, Alkis Koudounas, Elena Baralis, Sabato Marco Siniscalchi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Italy exhibits rich linguistic diversity across its territory due to the
distinct regional languages spoken in different areas. Recent advances in
self-supervised learning provide new opportunities to analyze Italy's
linguistic varieties using speech data alone. This includes the potential to
leverage representations learned from large amounts of data to better examine
nuances between closely related linguistic varieties. In this study, we focus
on automatically identifying the geographic region of origin of speech samples
drawn from Italy's diverse language varieties. We leverage self-supervised
learning models to tackle this task and analyze differences and similarities
between Italy's regional languages. In doing so, we also seek to uncover new
insights into the relationships among these diverse yet closely related
varieties, which may help linguists understand their interconnected evolution
and regional development over time and space. To improve the discriminative
ability of learned representations, we evaluate several supervised contrastive
learning objectives, both as pre-training steps and additional fine-tuning
objectives. Experimental evidence shows that pre-trained self-supervised models
can effectively identify regions from speech recording. Additionally,
incorporating contrastive objectives during fine-tuning improves classification
accuracy and yields embeddings that distinctly separate regional varieties,
demonstrating the value of combining self-supervised pre-training and
contrastive learning for this task. | [
-0.0420263037,
0.0784366056,
-0.0171673633,
0.0422512554,
-0.0088413088,
0.0230016466,
0.0432210527,
-0.0396363251,
0.044451151,
-0.0202951841,
-0.0607315674,
0.0060506156,
0.0171798002,
-0.0096801482,
0.0353499055,
-0.081361793,
0.0399574339,
-0.0364143401,
-0.0178647079,
-0.018546924,
0.0042312103,
-0.0146880616,
-0.0210205205,
-0.0064645335,
-0.0410315022,
0.0326317772,
-0.0028476424,
-0.0298741236,
-0.001514432,
0.0080795307,
0.0016867884,
0.0430758931,
0.0357895531,
0.0074419733,
0.0000019147,
-0.0520699099,
-0.0028395928,
-0.0140979253,
-0.004391198,
0.047317069,
0.0050622351,
0.0353563316,
-0.0210154913,
0.0006584121,
-0.0024159516,
-0.0349613465,
0.0515736118,
-0.0194140431,
0.0116732707,
0.0614448525,
-0.0291845333,
-0.0681730583,
-0.0126686916,
-0.0236069486,
-0.0526448935,
0.0468206145,
-0.0051008761,
-0.0443141982,
-0.0377642997,
0.0134174395,
-0.0291857477,
0.0310934577,
-0.0235625654,
0.015352224,
-0.0583977662,
0.029996153,
-0.0431352258,
0.0063248798,
0.0216899924,
0.0200971551,
0.0017803811,
-0.0207104348,
-0.0003395635,
0.0201105382,
-0.0264737196,
0.021055134,
-0.0000833429,
-0.0491469689,
-0.0029811582,
0.0707642585,
0.0693317726,
0.0471528992,
-0.0012612229,
0.002848722,
-0.0632342026,
0.048346851,
0.0254060086,
-0.024871679,
-0.000053893,
0.0102292346,
0.0216136836,
0.009453061,
0.0149978744,
0.021805007,
0.0191401988,
-0.030796269,
0.0255555511,
-0.0157687012,
0.0319428295,
-0.0038631035,
0.0018271495,
0.0046793986,
-0.0920327604,
0.0425665043,
0.0008382115,
0.0378459767,
-0.0120204687,
0.0019945223,
-0.0081133619,
-0.0311797783,
-0.0593746416,
0.0248521902,
-0.0468922816,
-0.0007238257,
-0.0259369053,
0.0541547947,
-0.0128591582,
-0.0070974692,
-0.0098241633,
0.0057256804,
0.0011801146,
-0.0379002653,
-0.0318298042,
-0.0035611584,
0.003214888,
0.0564550422,
-0.0740063637,
0.0079387007,
-0.0586996824,
-0.0541754849,
-0.001486083,
0.007814656,
0.0325362124,
0.0007343126,
0.0222939737,
0.0057519861,
0.0059562866,
-0.0422346294,
-0.0614348389,
0.0636688918,
-0.089649193,
-0.0337655097,
0.0113503113,
-0.0572153591,
0.0178777818,
-0.0417566299,
-0.0006744382,
-0.0599771477,
-0.0515667126,
-0.072514616,
0.0158903915,
0.0339847617,
-0.0581877492,
-0.005768307,
0.0375175811,
-0.040556334,
0.0134792766,
0.0438979082,
0.0141071798,
-0.0300792921,
0.0389640816,
-0.0452265628,
0.0000341088,
0.0105113471,
0.0301489215,
0.0192264449,
-0.0704840049,
0.0040680068,
-0.0312662683,
0.0006436099,
0.0781274512,
0.029426137,
0.0081493352,
-0.0320640057,
0.0603542328,
0.1066642553,
0.0591040626,
0.0195727684,
0.0408606268,
0.0357049108,
-0.0187890828,
0.0358360521,
0.0339935534,
-0.0315118134,
0.0129795568,
-0.0303853638,
0.0344007611,
0.0737318546,
-0.0709463581,
-0.0291063692,
-0.0020117199,
-0.0426830947,
0.0036463139,
0.0300325193,
0.1057704389,
0.0021440368,
0.0199644305,
-0.031584423,
0.0611212626,
-0.0171972942,
0.0127921635,
-0.0209734961,
0.0516160615,
0.0414639786,
-0.0522110984,
-0.0511385128,
0.0391184613,
0.006855322,
0.0011761209,
0.0141038056,
0.0572271794,
-0.0036394978,
0.0621287711,
-0.0496697612,
-0.0193405673,
-0.0255665742,
0.025315389,
0.0472466499,
-0.0261993483,
0.0312215015,
-0.0110596819,
-0.061320506,
0.0322040394,
-0.0087729422,
0.0004652322,
-0.0305515882,
0.0208074301,
0.0368482061,
-0.0208950769,
0.0238116588,
-0.0175726172,
-0.0176979564,
0.020703895,
-0.0295186006,
0.0393652953,
0.0405164249,
-0.0377312377,
-0.0469313785,
0.0150063466,
-0.0370727293,
0.0005010037,
-0.0056337249,
-0.0086366292,
-0.0544795357,
0.0978368595,
-0.0388528369,
0.0328502059,
-0.0281493533,
0.0018466397,
-0.0157325044,
0.0376318358,
-0.0019030896,
0.0407952294,
0.0303717479,
-0.0037945674,
-0.0188892242,
0.0047184979,
0.0568930767,
-0.043646723,
-0.0058951196,
-0.0461432897,
-0.0349213481,
-0.0010696773,
-0.0024219134,
-0.031800393,
-0.0085437428,
0.0064574578,
-0.063124001,
-0.0034740416,
-0.0547667816,
0.0293376651,
0.005959555,
0.0042818324,
-0.0103811352,
-0.0136970915,
0.0171659254,
-0.045726262,
-0.0341988951,
-0.0055778082,
0.0165070165,
-0.0228217896,
0.01458955,
-0.0353580378,
0.0057868925,
0.0173026044,
0.0351025574,
-0.0233180616,
-0.0114002842,
-0.0147638069,
-0.0222022999,
-0.0113962088,
0.0738426372,
-0.0085615953,
-0.0341132283,
0.0057355063,
-0.0063217767,
0.0420056731,
0.0435036756,
-0.0227935687,
-0.0031523793,
0.045457378,
-0.0594978929,
-0.0399284698,
0.0005728125,
-0.0220628344,
0.0483419076,
-0.0646753013,
-0.0238886066,
-0.0161614995,
0.0985518247,
0.0257094763,
0.0050575309,
-0.0145834722,
0.0064074281,
-0.0184029061,
0.0107668117,
0.0420458801,
0.0324339047,
-0.0191040281,
0.0784184858,
0.0040269494,
-0.0425401032,
0.0357749499,
-0.0392271876,
0.0218534991,
-0.0367639139,
-0.0705869645,
-0.0228349492,
0.0570222735,
-0.0081031211,
0.0040119202,
0.0157510899,
-0.0328832529,
-0.0157130696,
-0.0564731099,
0.0571774282,
-0.0058283671,
0.0405253284,
-0.0564462654,
0.0215157364,
0.0094161164,
-0.064150326,
0.0054098079,
-0.0313185975,
-0.0170207936,
0.0197188202,
0.0579196811,
-0.0362412892,
0.0498700812,
0.0466006324,
-0.0083850818,
0.0802841038,
-0.0057094553,
0.0254979283,
0.0101101007,
0.0663606226,
-0.0003299912,
0.0439434499,
-0.015949145,
0.0508928299,
0.0126121743,
-0.0152019262,
0.0283869356,
0.0168832857,
-0.0556478053,
0.0421251357,
-0.0108912392,
-0.055902645,
-0.0546611585,
-0.0255236086,
0.0263906997,
0.0186507963,
-0.0516932048,
0.0752426237,
0.0114634652,
-0.0305964388,
0.0057962257,
-0.0349024907,
0.0211327784,
0.0244755223,
0.0381769277,
0.0063232263,
0.0263526198,
-0.017236324,
-0.0003772918,
0.0039420137,
-0.0008427724,
0.0032565347,
-0.0959637016,
0.0501513109,
0.0047610905,
-0.0474092849,
-0.0449903272,
-0.0510783829,
-0.0172819365,
-0.0360821001,
-0.025058724,
-0.0221504699,
-0.02171579,
-0.0244090222,
0.0814543143,
-0.0699957237,
-0.0658697262,
0.011970629,
-0.0298345685,
0.0518751591,
-0.0155347465,
0.0129087484,
-0.072935842,
-0.000792619,
-0.0047178781,
-0.0077323681,
-0.0164492261,
-0.0351016894,
0.0628093705,
0.0642458051,
-0.0174188316,
0.004080493,
-0.0137239182,
0.0309716258,
-0.0341698229,
0.0244824588,
0.0610879213,
-0.020686917,
0.0479858406,
0.0207058024,
0.029004816,
0.0247072,
0.0199007969,
0.0692704469,
-0.0147522641,
0.0006752535,
0.0323285051,
0.0351576991,
-0.0387350433,
-0.0063668005,
0.0318007618,
0.0042924616,
-0.0297640022,
-0.0319872946,
-0.0262840763,
0.0234755166,
0.0236566048,
0.0158013627,
-0.0265252907,
-0.0008534783,
-0.0620767809,
-0.0502899066,
0.0836239159,
-0.0182530303,
-0.0248850305,
-0.0207559466,
-0.0682023317,
0.0931605548,
-0.0211281423,
-0.0163549446,
-0.0276098549,
-0.0542320125,
-0.0394664407,
0.0114839189,
0.0516468026,
0.0097851092,
0.0583749898,
0.0009249951,
-0.0442769378,
0.0859422311,
-0.0202837847,
-0.0173597261,
-0.0095105879,
0.0564421117,
-0.0173678268,
0.0114988191,
-0.0088339662,
-0.0269021224,
0.0434767008,
0.0049946355,
-0.0444138497,
-0.0847383365,
-0.0370278247,
-0.0079366015,
-0.0510004424,
0.1027565151,
-0.0239025671,
0.048983302,
-0.0632659644,
-0.0199032519,
0.0117378449,
0.0448160544,
-0.0067397817,
-0.000709967,
0.0474560075,
0.0217837784,
-0.011775705,
0.0035228236,
-0.0472655483,
-0.0244121403,
-0.0195819158,
-0.0011961954,
0.0369717851,
0.0347066969,
-0.0441027954,
0.0655552447,
-0.0014344696,
0.0810057968,
0.0078998515,
0.0618091226,
-0.0292085744,
-0.0092773605,
-0.010174823,
0.0318643637,
-0.0469926074,
0.0083819302,
-0.0164679363,
-0.0304157455,
-0.0269639436,
-0.0297570191,
0.074467212,
-0.0670474693,
0.0251495615,
0.0169159677,
-0.0162911955,
-0.017811399,
0.0213806927,
-0.043193046,
-0.0017200116,
0.0052432464,
0.0023847928,
-0.0243311767,
0.0424688347,
0.0291647669,
0.0056032701,
0.010642671,
0.0351823457,
0.0335870832,
-0.0257966127,
-0.0200321618,
-0.0010489996,
-0.0019856398,
-0.0448595323,
-0.0404587872,
-0.0335837826,
-0.0813997388,
0.0299698021,
-0.007152216,
-0.0284858998,
0.0349513069,
0.0483153984,
-0.0049892669,
-0.0192952789,
0.0356332026,
-0.0287011098,
-0.0113899261,
0.0242207069,
-0.0149610527,
-0.0219118148,
-6.218647234e-33,
-0.0235190671,
-0.0145456763,
0.0204414763,
-0.0293721743,
0.0283274725,
0.009238068,
-0.0043004821,
-0.0036061658,
-0.0247711781,
0.0021222366,
-0.008358093,
-0.0363478102,
0.0150679797,
0.0178080592,
0.004463451,
0.0063738883,
0.0386108197,
-0.0086470386,
0.0237880647,
-0.0067972876,
0.0280578826,
-0.0077078622,
0.0775520727,
-0.0848305449,
-0.0426992066,
0.0251728483,
-0.0319465734,
0.0243207477,
0.0094627272,
0.0524075143,
-0.012367215,
0.0358033478,
-0.0068564159,
-0.0350687988,
-0.0214500036,
-0.0299822856,
-0.049084235,
-0.0837492123,
-0.0308431294,
0.0207475983,
0.0128502892,
0.007717324,
0.00135093,
0.0086035421,
0.0101412134,
-0.0083184373,
0.0534235165,
0.043057438,
-0.008887982,
0.0144279813,
-0.0283291489,
0.0254890807,
-0.0357005373,
-0.0234286003,
0.0829410031,
0.0306234453,
0.0344565846,
-0.0035358665,
-0.0421016775,
0.0322325341,
0.0415307879,
0.0100207003,
0.044680696,
0.0157872159,
-0.0004557933,
0.0249966085,
0.0769233555,
-0.0495271012,
0.0493224189,
-0.0474705622,
0.075407587,
0.0135427695,
-0.0077011855,
0.0502935238,
0.0270217918,
-0.0318770967,
-0.0641222447,
0.0071642585,
0.0291306172,
-0.031941168,
-0.0613785982,
-0.0081544705,
-0.0130920308,
-0.0244308542,
-0.0193662792,
-0.0882999077,
0.0051086564,
-0.002757516,
0.0136456983,
-0.0375820585,
0.0423680432,
0.0290456135,
0.0428718887,
-0.0234541334,
-0.029127771,
-0.0107690496,
-0.0185159761,
-0.0079948325,
-0.0018349381,
0.0342701301,
-0.0387127399,
-0.0522871353,
-0.0107110087,
0.0405108593,
0.0146809919,
0.0285135731,
0.0374348201,
0.0183764491,
-0.0586755387,
0.0226533916,
-0.0152049251,
-0.0350473374,
-0.0170132779,
0.0363657847,
0.0043387511,
0.0184657387,
0.0136592267,
0.0584171787,
0.0821034387,
0.0071679964,
0.0087394845,
-0.0013276443,
-0.0246373247,
0.0447724201,
0.0204102136,
-0.0094170319,
0.0022905201,
0.0256053358,
0.0127589898,
-0.013647194,
0.0012053099,
-0.0055877399,
2.659e-7,
0.0354899317,
0.0299797114,
0.0175625365,
-0.0221740268,
0.0077872258,
0.0226431116,
-0.0124457497,
-0.0474944077,
-0.0123514719,
0.0508417971,
0.0374601074,
0.0355197117,
0.0451079383,
0.0791346803,
-0.0632777512,
0.0439381972,
-0.0565444566,
0.0192115717,
-0.0532361493,
-0.015589227,
0.0103480145,
0.0938415602,
0.0457836129,
-0.0430454984,
-0.01570604,
0.0064726472,
0.0653265491,
-0.0357189178,
-0.0025764797,
0.020136619,
-0.0286872741,
0.0191416331,
-0.0002544443,
-0.0025823058,
-0.0218866263,
0.0635280088,
-0.0556807704,
0.0249480344,
-0.0063962983,
-0.0635414198,
0.007115006,
-0.0064706542,
-0.0436113626,
-0.0321590193,
0.0313937068,
-0.0623846613,
-0.0012168563,
-0.0309390705,
-0.0321510658,
0.0130182244,
0.0508235469,
-0.0372210667,
0.0019248577,
0.0153179411,
0.0045311851,
-0.0136878183,
-0.0408495218,
-0.0372379236,
0.0019538037,
0.0569647104,
-0.0339735486,
0.013898097,
0.0452479273,
0.0104218153,
0.0218315367,
0.0362809934,
0.037353348,
1.917490377e-34,
-0.0218697023,
-0.001481264,
-0.0052990657,
0.0138925323,
-0.0036191118,
-0.0284137093,
-0.0515502468,
0.0013313072,
0.0226369593,
0.0154622328,
-0.0078898733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15846v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15846v1 | Revisiting Interpolation Augmentation for Speech-to-Text Generation | 2024-06-22T13:24:58 | 2024-06-22T13:24:58 | Chen Xu, Jie Wang, Xiaoqian Liu, Qianqian Dong, Chunliang Zhang, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu, Dapeng Man, Wu Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Speech-to-text (S2T) generation systems frequently face challenges in
low-resource scenarios, primarily due to the lack of extensive labeled
datasets. One emerging solution is constructing virtual training samples by
interpolating inputs and labels, which has notably enhanced system
generalization in other domains. Despite its potential, this technique's
application in S2T tasks has remained under-explored. In this paper, we delve
into the utility of interpolation augmentation, guided by several pivotal
questions. Our findings reveal that employing an appropriate strategy in
interpolation augmentation significantly enhances performance across diverse
tasks, architectures, and data scales, offering a promising avenue for more
robust S2T systems in resource-constrained settings. | [
0.0041078017,
0.0571529493,
0.0180741046,
-0.0004079331,
0.0082755685,
-0.0172081366,
0.0404550023,
0.0108726211,
-0.0472603478,
-0.0172577724,
-0.0683366731,
-0.0281677432,
0.0262820534,
0.0031485229,
0.0383899547,
-0.0842636824,
0.0157087073,
-0.0297623966,
-0.0168405324,
0.0120165423,
0.0169401094,
0.0326453261,
-0.0318666063,
0.032654658,
-0.0553667881,
0.0341910645,
-0.0031827863,
0.0240038596,
0.0384307653,
-0.0354443677,
-0.0058999765,
-0.0196952131,
0.0675257444,
0.0376286581,
0.0000017085,
0.0335728489,
-0.0075245616,
-0.0072970269,
-0.0493028201,
0.030870609,
0.076088734,
-0.0306526609,
-0.020586079,
0.0321419798,
-0.0225821342,
-0.0499526151,
0.0516443364,
0.0341978557,
0.0557229742,
0.0737542585,
-0.0188416652,
0.0120877735,
-0.0115310103,
-0.0286780931,
0.0052163079,
-0.0065312567,
-0.0269169416,
0.0123943361,
0.0206268653,
-0.0029020132,
0.0263461694,
0.0562887341,
0.0400200635,
-0.0229428131,
0.0300192367,
0.0482746288,
-0.0170489755,
-0.0043532322,
-0.03376491,
0.0654126033,
-0.02723586,
-0.0109530417,
-0.0176205765,
-0.015895715,
-0.0284849107,
-0.0561900139,
-0.0163744353,
0.0023704942,
0.0156831853,
0.0328497961,
0.0192404445,
0.0551471151,
0.0384932421,
-0.0288646948,
-0.0228163823,
0.0218096878,
-0.001552653,
-0.0392383486,
0.0057447175,
0.0382240117,
-0.0476617329,
-0.0190699436,
0.0449420437,
0.0271570273,
-0.0310092941,
-0.0025128664,
-0.1101365238,
-0.0449732542,
-0.0209662765,
0.0298154801,
0.0875557512,
0.0570007786,
0.0400364287,
-0.0434648022,
-0.019066615,
-0.0083201975,
0.0096205715,
0.0456738286,
-0.0471921861,
0.0348397233,
0.0109393429,
-0.0125656193,
-0.0561414473,
0.0322001949,
-0.0535286814,
-0.0180249494,
-0.0170639586,
-0.0065939105,
-0.0101397838,
0.0066684168,
0.0109313279,
0.0234540906,
-0.0801551938,
-0.0162246078,
0.0195624903,
0.019049732,
-0.030971799,
0.069592908,
0.0547215864,
-0.0818800926,
-0.0275262743,
-0.006974183,
0.0357122049,
-0.0036774869,
0.0304328855,
0.0716754869,
-0.0445822664,
-0.0386148356,
-0.0533193499,
-0.04450652,
0.0035006311,
-0.0431485772,
0.0002813141,
-0.058388304,
0.0475277938,
-0.0244017858,
0.0030977288,
0.0065179081,
0.01180741,
0.0125341807,
0.0150715299,
0.026262667,
-0.0616130792,
0.002065806,
0.040285524,
-0.0061073257,
0.0282527264,
0.0537110493,
0.0861295387,
-0.0096733663,
-0.0192552451,
0.0220606364,
-0.0068195988,
0.0529771931,
0.0501680486,
0.0067674401,
-0.0389903001,
-0.0380534381,
0.0059858556,
0.0365212113,
0.0865323246,
0.0514268242,
-0.061570406,
0.01103386,
0.0758355111,
0.0336614177,
-0.0151478378,
-0.0007019482,
0.1040431783,
0.0025330356,
0.0134154595,
0.0242506471,
-0.0096825566,
0.0286181048,
0.0725765005,
0.0502793565,
0.0407352075,
0.0335269459,
-0.0192926619,
-0.0636691377,
0.0169883613,
-0.0084909769,
-0.004836435,
-0.0091689276,
-0.0117046013,
0.0671365932,
-0.0113527309,
0.0450319983,
-0.0050914572,
-0.0494619645,
0.0636661723,
-0.0204193406,
-0.0451785885,
0.1034928858,
0.0155872721,
0.0022457908,
-0.0081419358,
-0.0442829356,
0.0040659313,
0.0526623987,
0.0041872305,
-0.0000551566,
0.0309284776,
-0.058173608,
-0.0047514951,
-0.0006369513,
-0.0053304639,
0.0243903659,
-0.0170644335,
0.0186620466,
0.0296794195,
-0.0406614505,
-0.0305811223,
0.0025722024,
-0.0402412936,
-0.0376483947,
0.0447614864,
0.0048209117,
0.0141714988,
0.0135220923,
-0.0348631069,
0.0298203211,
0.0122746779,
-0.0628033131,
-0.0125230066,
0.0106778508,
-0.0729218423,
-0.0426622927,
0.0009277925,
-0.0358498879,
0.0273930971,
-0.0187309012,
-0.0102724507,
-0.0827456862,
-0.0039225528,
-0.0659353957,
0.0257513393,
-0.00732684,
0.0183668826,
0.0521390066,
0.0056521278,
-0.0027277314,
-0.0185326859,
0.0011444421,
-0.0110406131,
0.032929536,
0.0681613684,
-0.017398145,
-0.0318157859,
0.018692106,
0.0242425129,
-0.0051259878,
-0.022041345,
-0.0273578446,
-0.0099666929,
-0.0163245406,
0.0166100133,
-0.0835894346,
0.0026813357,
-0.0061723683,
0.0358968563,
0.0401432589,
0.0330891833,
0.0155151198,
-0.011835685,
-0.0404538363,
-0.0327057987,
0.0333965905,
-0.0222632345,
0.0072276248,
0.0084618274,
0.0019577518,
-0.0307672881,
-0.0131273307,
0.0299406592,
-0.0102970488,
0.0134103009,
0.0153466687,
-0.0175728034,
0.023383908,
-0.0099608861,
0.0261051953,
-0.0054321662,
-0.0347023606,
0.0103083309,
-0.0153934732,
0.0298211556,
-0.0187922381,
0.0126893893,
-0.0268818587,
0.0051428457,
0.0019931956,
-0.0545684248,
0.0198079813,
-0.019619707,
0.0086852685,
-0.035302233,
-0.0372428522,
-0.0231966525,
0.0732542872,
0.0156025961,
0.0444441438,
-0.0468782037,
0.0077133314,
-0.01470776,
-0.0231660288,
0.0021269452,
-0.0136041241,
-0.0147789856,
-0.0055509503,
-0.0332634896,
-0.0576653183,
0.04688593,
-0.0700027868,
-0.0302955098,
-0.0433724374,
-0.0147793274,
-0.0038556682,
0.0005186682,
0.0153419413,
0.0161951352,
-0.0349908993,
-0.027663067,
-0.0334615298,
0.037524268,
-0.0133980028,
-0.0418383889,
0.0471739657,
-0.0162310544,
0.0106752124,
-0.0152502479,
-0.058157973,
-0.0203515701,
-0.0114975283,
-0.0165679995,
0.0171978232,
0.0348086841,
-0.0479698256,
0.0234803408,
-0.0047693765,
0.0254416056,
0.0695550367,
-0.0090881893,
-0.0169223361,
-0.0405793153,
0.0394062288,
0.0303148534,
0.0262532383,
0.0005801606,
-0.0010556345,
-0.0038794286,
0.0004034476,
0.077904366,
0.0578259118,
-0.0451557226,
0.0090989918,
0.0041600596,
0.0221098457,
-0.0241167229,
0.0057298942,
0.0239079185,
-0.0555199459,
-0.0295125581,
0.0847166628,
-0.0175508037,
-0.0141114015,
0.0235214736,
0.0518914759,
0.0802366063,
0.0221021213,
-0.0153075401,
-0.0490672514,
-0.010640556,
0.0109611852,
0.0514922328,
-0.0616287179,
0.0176674724,
-0.0432996787,
-0.0948589146,
0.0445979722,
0.0500504747,
-0.0375714675,
-0.0026968492,
-0.0246115383,
-0.0346980803,
0.0213763528,
0.0355632156,
-0.013415033,
-0.0201966111,
0.022192264,
0.065589577,
-0.0004782959,
-0.0864084885,
-0.0780224577,
-0.0074010044,
0.0457626618,
0.0727049932,
0.0028743476,
0.0013852032,
-0.0271408856,
0.0224225707,
0.0153628411,
-0.0026042939,
-0.0094325719,
0.0463814288,
-0.0057895523,
-0.0190312192,
0.0364780128,
0.0696132034,
-0.0164432265,
0.0442541428,
-0.0122958282,
0.0315512642,
-0.0148627637,
0.012876899,
0.0148059372,
0.0243401006,
0.0249947961,
0.0254532322,
0.0247339513,
-0.0351760164,
0.0127141932,
-0.0102021983,
0.0418311618,
-0.0982898772,
0.0091309017,
0.0373200178,
-0.0198509954,
-0.0323640816,
-0.061420925,
-0.040217407,
0.0009621202,
0.0718554854,
-0.0070840875,
-0.0178247914,
-0.0174712669,
0.002100345,
-0.0324785933,
-0.0181026105,
-0.013266487,
0.0475803055,
0.0035311631,
-0.0285486374,
-0.0022404862,
-0.050411135,
0.003864513,
0.0216583721,
-0.0883275568,
-0.0482937731,
-0.0059678452,
0.0537735261,
0.0177566875,
0.1032022014,
-0.0024883505,
-0.00072663,
0.1035586521,
0.066390723,
-0.0277979542,
0.0183477197,
0.0412582122,
-0.0134693515,
0.0086041065,
0.0253645536,
-0.0336345918,
0.0359099396,
0.0065109106,
0.0102231288,
0.0086171394,
-0.0179745927,
0.0157222189,
-0.0008265179,
-0.0069627981,
-0.0414454192,
0.0650625974,
-0.0047352575,
0.0192801226,
-0.0260541644,
0.0113409534,
-0.0684800372,
0.0054132612,
0.0373287201,
0.039274808,
-0.0096645663,
0.0043570641,
0.0311238896,
0.0272725616,
0.0373011678,
-0.0089036319,
-0.0280426387,
0.0075744102,
0.0287582539,
0.013138623,
-0.03860965,
0.0149882277,
-0.0096633537,
0.0156297013,
-0.0172047727,
0.0280585196,
0.0132990768,
-0.0171223786,
-0.028077241,
0.0151747679,
-0.0333493911,
-0.0100705428,
-0.0821391344,
-0.0007047937,
0.0158061907,
0.0089327451,
0.0922240242,
-0.0277417172,
0.02662047,
0.0025034749,
-0.0169868059,
-0.0195382107,
-0.0233790893,
-0.0249555092,
0.0005651615,
-0.0090488177,
-0.0002262064,
0.0397839434,
-0.0274355728,
0.0437629074,
-0.0534963086,
0.0303380564,
-0.0233778488,
-0.0462378189,
-0.0617549755,
0.0272611044,
0.0298348144,
-0.0337817147,
-0.0136073567,
-0.0586769767,
0.0169763267,
0.0003463964,
-0.0103986608,
-0.0424298197,
0.0692379922,
-0.0148285674,
-0.0415081233,
0.0202051792,
-0.0043363571,
-0.0281063039,
-0.0226337612,
-0.0130307665,
-0.0375050195,
-5.902017546e-33,
-0.0633817464,
-0.0004529045,
0.012310856,
-0.0210806616,
-0.0794176161,
0.0084313201,
-0.0258744117,
-0.0059212735,
0.030692419,
-0.0038103047,
-0.0027668739,
-0.0180883985,
0.0322463326,
0.0480086356,
-0.018938588,
0.0215309132,
0.1033844948,
-0.0326353535,
-0.0314241275,
0.0589832067,
0.0593778566,
0.0404566079,
0.0436907224,
-0.0428458378,
-0.0360615104,
-0.013689681,
-0.0185215212,
-0.0407608859,
0.0142131168,
0.0270281341,
-0.006463394,
0.0311340988,
-0.0013690417,
-0.0457027704,
-0.0181488935,
0.017024193,
-0.0791505426,
0.0085340207,
-0.0283985864,
0.0318291597,
-0.0458638184,
-0.0305612404,
0.0471952483,
-0.0200047251,
-0.0163127426,
-0.0040827617,
0.0086035961,
-0.0368341096,
-0.0036085364,
-0.0327107124,
-0.0423108749,
-0.0016308937,
-0.0116991745,
0.021851344,
0.0127837136,
0.0926353037,
-0.0330768637,
-0.0417464636,
-0.0458913632,
0.0234487541,
0.031764105,
0.0442709699,
0.0363345705,
0.0496011265,
-0.0071205022,
0.0271135643,
0.0248171035,
-0.0520260967,
0.0290156286,
0.0472097658,
0.0187870152,
-0.0217748266,
0.0084150219,
0.0387117267,
0.0241540819,
-0.0310710724,
0.0112897959,
0.0170433503,
0.0050539281,
-0.0651125088,
0.0276310351,
-0.0193120576,
0.0078985067,
0.0024435904,
-0.0352484174,
-0.0455210619,
0.0159428511,
-0.0522077382,
0.0364637747,
0.070122093,
-0.0142630376,
0.0108399121,
0.0494036414,
0.0016539054,
-0.0216411911,
-0.0382132791,
-0.0518559143,
0.0383648612,
-0.00982174,
-0.0262115803,
-0.0535194613,
-0.0592294261,
0.0512950011,
0.0452669375,
-0.005217527,
-0.0177550744,
0.0368728377,
0.0437098518,
-0.025931716,
-0.0042572734,
-0.0359835736,
0.0634494647,
0.0040759463,
0.0001540766,
0.058944039,
-0.0568157397,
-0.0390710533,
0.0421863906,
-0.0488620326,
0.0052067009,
0.0197471157,
-0.0439049862,
-0.0087281493,
0.0383347385,
-0.040830873,
0.0269248169,
-0.0181949809,
-0.0428284183,
0.006226094,
-0.065483734,
-0.0239189807,
-0.0131058497,
2.454e-7,
-0.0277973544,
-0.0284158699,
0.0557879061,
-0.0444115959,
0.0308684073,
0.0006404166,
0.0304508377,
0.0389012434,
-0.0314348228,
-0.0204405654,
0.024827607,
-0.0068993592,
0.0595964529,
0.0127907023,
-0.0605810024,
-0.0362359732,
-0.0706510395,
0.0414197147,
-0.0247535538,
-0.0178718623,
0.0137299122,
0.0632946566,
-0.0127965687,
-0.0417530462,
0.084920004,
-0.0017805609,
0.0399900265,
0.0328928083,
0.0000606593,
-0.0114306575,
0.0422682576,
0.0303332508,
-0.03843778,
0.031263791,
-0.0370253846,
-0.0070531028,
0.0121875834,
0.0460022502,
0.0254866835,
-0.0241466388,
-0.0077416729,
0.0386827178,
0.0114238001,
-0.0048940587,
0.0584411956,
-0.0290290192,
0.0040195342,
0.0074992785,
-0.0430252329,
0.0142372623,
-0.0466095433,
-0.0464497283,
-0.0261971541,
0.0221958086,
0.0152951032,
0.0277252998,
-0.0314900354,
-0.0299642161,
-0.0107877562,
0.0222897306,
-0.0629443973,
-0.0524886101,
-0.0852514058,
0.0362438112,
0.0100720124,
-0.020636294,
-0.0566075854,
1.955848801e-34,
0.0024791481,
-0.0523118936,
0.0534849986,
-0.014294141,
-0.0160664544,
-0.006699523,
0.0204909835,
0.0244298428,
-0.0158534143,
-0.0317502357,
-0.0600188971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02514v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02514v1 | LOGIC-LM++: Multi-Step Refinement for Symbolic Formulations | 2024-06-22T12:50:41 | 2024-06-22T12:50:41 | Shashank Kirtania, Priyanshu Gupta, Arjun Radhakirshna | cs.LO | cs.LO, cs.AI, cs.CL | In this paper we examine the limitations of Large Language Models (LLMs) for
complex reasoning tasks. While current approaches leverage formal languages as
intermediate representation of reasoning problems, they struggle with
generating intermediate formal specifications and refining these
representations. To address these issues, this paper proposes Logic-LM++, an
improvement on Logic-LM. It uses the ability of LLMs to do pairwise
comparisons, allowing the evaluation of the refinements suggested by the LLM.
The paper demonstrates that Logic-LM++ outperforms Logic-LM and LLM based
techniques on natural language reasoning tasks on two datasets, FOLIO and
AR-LSAT. Logic-LM++ show an average improvement of 13.5% on standard prompting,
11% on chain of thought prompting and 5% on Logic-LM. | [
0.0283535905,
0.0309336558,
-0.0204573981,
0.0390842333,
-0.0808447748,
0.011620882,
0.0188015178,
-0.0118981889,
0.039504692,
-0.0605940856,
0.0325967185,
0.0258092638,
-0.0159170795,
0.0376764536,
0.0016699177,
-0.0459348261,
0.0388066731,
-0.0418646932,
0.0426745117,
-0.0145564247,
-0.0061185621,
0.0332251452,
0.0151193244,
-0.0033080806,
0.0151527245,
-0.0326546915,
-0.0437049977,
0.0169364326,
0.0079697035,
-0.0382361077,
-0.0533499792,
0.0410267152,
0.0357109308,
0.0023512451,
0.0000023994,
-0.0769648552,
-0.0093332073,
0.0042104754,
-0.0535716452,
0.0135683604,
0.0117696021,
0.0067131664,
0.0229882486,
0.0197711233,
-0.0298287217,
-0.0258033723,
-0.0263960753,
0.0871639997,
0.0756170973,
0.0659720749,
0.00824448,
-0.0616572462,
0.0150523651,
0.0154533237,
-0.020146776,
-0.0158005971,
0.0452622734,
0.0544092394,
0.0400892682,
-0.0001786782,
0.0103318142,
0.0129038692,
0.0456504263,
-0.005463195,
-0.0286252461,
0.0046943203,
-0.0338169783,
0.0044343621,
-0.0039176848,
0.0555226021,
0.0119713526,
0.0074261883,
-0.0247897655,
0.00171508,
-0.0014892516,
-0.0268556401,
-0.0200063474,
0.0536885858,
-0.0482648164,
0.0027272103,
0.0512075201,
-0.0261780228,
0.0416318886,
0.035357818,
-0.0588848032,
0.106208995,
-0.0070674159,
-0.0461490005,
0.0352090411,
-0.0344352238,
-0.0392764919,
-0.0680839717,
0.0250856113,
0.0705762357,
-0.0579931475,
0.0078802267,
-0.0073334211,
0.0126040354,
0.0184869915,
-0.0582399517,
0.0371076651,
0.0487526692,
0.0278166179,
0.0474227406,
-0.0337864868,
0.0621614866,
-0.0030101214,
0.0444918275,
-0.0632730722,
0.0034386192,
-0.0570471436,
-0.0164929852,
-0.0512888692,
0.0493389294,
-0.0443856679,
-0.0085269744,
-0.0248033516,
0.0349305607,
0.0032886064,
0.0398638137,
-0.005642789,
-0.0282759201,
0.0334690101,
-0.0143266674,
-0.0443262532,
0.0086729731,
-0.0518422499,
0.0418391712,
0.001417201,
-0.0252792519,
0.0351075232,
0.0074579869,
-0.0118284225,
-0.0232944787,
0.0078545036,
0.0647980273,
0.0081612915,
-0.0037739105,
-0.0494830795,
-0.0617051609,
0.0382547081,
-0.0779862329,
-0.0111363931,
-0.0710457116,
0.0221890174,
0.0000679987,
-0.0197416693,
-0.0017768957,
0.0003286834,
0.0107453791,
0.0238986332,
0.0570095778,
-0.0000717888,
0.0145304548,
0.0292621106,
0.0291647259,
-0.0295304228,
0.0287675224,
0.0154311582,
0.00589144,
0.0137265977,
-0.0100249713,
-0.0199307278,
0.0215187706,
-0.0298150145,
-0.0003273897,
-0.0409714393,
0.0477022938,
-0.0282329321,
0.0427828915,
-0.0065534227,
0.0484348983,
-0.0318743028,
0.0065868702,
0.0114867762,
0.0058754827,
0.0497733802,
-0.0409049466,
0.0352936313,
0.0264463145,
0.0237393174,
-0.0084262909,
-0.0631144121,
0.0098957419,
-0.0487941839,
0.0092437724,
-0.0220607296,
0.0193575136,
-0.0087167034,
-0.0635021403,
-0.0133838216,
0.0317095704,
0.0317515433,
0.0311464891,
0.0397616178,
-0.0051941522,
-0.0028427683,
0.0398612879,
0.0030694946,
-0.018737765,
-0.0154186059,
-0.0435112379,
0.0548149422,
0.0832918733,
0.0508842953,
-0.0397788137,
-0.0535146333,
-0.0342598371,
-0.0091617098,
0.0343838073,
0.0218436811,
-0.0044902749,
-0.0210462846,
-0.0308819227,
-0.0329880081,
-0.0209397059,
0.0059536304,
0.0122940885,
0.0155048873,
-0.0176473595,
0.0104298675,
-0.0119351568,
-0.0011221122,
0.0430178605,
-0.005422798,
-0.0100838784,
-0.0155520095,
0.0090801641,
0.0526878685,
0.0224052779,
0.008621105,
0.0166669693,
0.0324000791,
-0.0210296996,
-0.0301888306,
-0.0228188634,
-0.0378590934,
-0.0388319045,
0.0705996677,
0.0085957274,
-0.0475165434,
0.0065927966,
-0.0855512843,
-0.0112807164,
0.0260968879,
0.0229248051,
-0.0112954332,
-0.0484440662,
0.0317087844,
-0.011564482,
-0.0535711236,
-0.0269878358,
0.0765100643,
-0.0003408196,
-0.0167180337,
0.0154599939,
0.0265504196,
0.0451330096,
-0.0360457562,
-0.0074364459,
0.0012690672,
-0.0040980591,
0.0074572768,
-0.0119705116,
0.0481521711,
-0.035695184,
-0.0136342132,
-0.0672505721,
0.0028381811,
-0.0005634628,
-0.0029325092,
-0.0065898006,
-0.0096433889,
-0.0004898645,
0.0185504444,
-0.0090582669,
-0.0278015435,
0.0238822345,
0.0218798053,
0.0401399881,
-0.0008742242,
-0.060833618,
0.0182637945,
-0.0201360527,
-0.032841146,
0.0104520041,
-0.0136862248,
0.0211972389,
-0.0531088822,
0.0048810015,
-0.0544487573,
0.0063167745,
-0.0140275266,
0.0104556726,
0.0186163094,
-0.028843496,
0.0237122271,
0.0558248013,
-0.0239356905,
-0.0129278768,
0.0705199987,
-0.0233525131,
-0.0400002897,
0.0254891738,
0.0150354216,
0.0199647527,
-0.0353553146,
-0.01478191,
-0.0141634736,
0.0191233661,
-0.0124710957,
0.0126201948,
-0.0328751653,
0.0182344764,
-0.021353947,
0.0000731885,
-0.0487936288,
-0.0464117415,
0.0045998017,
0.0607266761,
-0.0050804019,
-0.0388263911,
0.0985238329,
-0.0180764832,
0.0096333669,
-0.0472724363,
-0.0285861492,
-0.0676701367,
0.0934657902,
-0.0402566306,
0.0005697299,
-0.0172754917,
-0.0152223799,
-0.0209558383,
-0.0517783873,
0.0280449502,
-0.0305692982,
0.0743462145,
-0.059616413,
0.0022425414,
-0.0043733227,
-0.0174157936,
-0.0250070505,
-0.0246174671,
-0.075282447,
0.0193573553,
-0.0585115775,
0.0270779561,
-0.0124025671,
0.0120898457,
-0.0186277553,
-0.0025850812,
0.0036163274,
-0.0159012452,
-0.0304602161,
-0.0361546874,
0.0061127935,
-0.0054551191,
0.009039118,
0.0025770988,
0.0683637783,
0.0132006761,
-0.0004763893,
-0.0288802944,
-0.0463670306,
0.0350112803,
-0.000640896,
-0.0267181471,
-0.0056145387,
0.0328665413,
0.0256708916,
-0.084306486,
0.0026572773,
0.1217686757,
0.0309993681,
0.0418220013,
0.0097493073,
-0.0656270236,
0.010461567,
0.0238839574,
0.0548707396,
-0.0954653397,
-0.0521286502,
0.0284916647,
-0.0246140826,
-0.0058293468,
-0.0212001856,
-0.012301337,
-0.0894912556,
0.0411298312,
0.0241038073,
-0.0156088844,
-0.020594025,
-0.0340990722,
-0.0332380235,
0.0248730239,
-0.0093925186,
0.0441569909,
-0.0002973096,
-0.0324639566,
-0.0148388036,
-0.0262767542,
-0.0098951887,
0.0628713965,
-0.0506567322,
-0.0001269575,
0.0096843494,
0.0001869008,
0.0174671058,
-0.0345777534,
0.0504706614,
0.0302890353,
0.0378281772,
-0.0554068573,
-0.0266893022,
0.0098712556,
0.022114791,
-0.0655150339,
0.0364752784,
-0.0315480642,
-0.0309223309,
0.0363335609,
0.1160371155,
-0.0387624651,
-0.0202017967,
-0.0169063974,
0.0299874414,
-0.0509877764,
0.065014787,
-0.0016178461,
-0.0004747789,
-0.0329459161,
-0.0323822871,
-0.0858099759,
0.0163372029,
0.0052536721,
0.0145473462,
-0.0175474361,
0.036492724,
-0.0279607885,
-0.0151675688,
0.0645125508,
0.0234572124,
-0.0071475031,
0.0184584912,
0.0090951119,
-0.0162639469,
-0.0288513862,
0.0291743148,
-0.0380912423,
0.0511151589,
0.0121241743,
0.0544645153,
-0.0218075346,
-0.0221494157,
-0.0213565584,
0.030137971,
-0.048545748,
-0.040100012,
-0.0303710718,
0.0492125861,
0.030679971,
0.0458375476,
-0.010901127,
-0.0192142874,
-0.0025461952,
0.006102154,
0.0042477073,
-0.0012906331,
0.0224065706,
0.0157335643,
0.0114707593,
0.0348335765,
-0.0290337671,
0.0193665475,
-0.011888952,
0.0509380773,
-0.013467662,
-0.0295067616,
0.0389013439,
0.0742902011,
0.0094918581,
0.003101533,
-0.0417303331,
-0.0301823821,
0.0308522284,
-0.0556892343,
-0.0856319591,
-0.0211613309,
0.0349734798,
0.0222170353,
-0.0181699321,
-0.0142586455,
-0.0544103906,
0.0016789224,
0.0217038877,
0.0124633238,
0.0255734082,
0.0194897298,
0.0028634812,
0.043876797,
-0.0308068655,
-0.029685827,
-0.0127158556,
-0.0160106402,
0.0246622022,
-0.015027347,
0.0727198273,
0.0412949547,
0.0120922271,
-0.0714868307,
-0.0205792747,
-0.0098122768,
-0.092851907,
0.0633407012,
0.0082909008,
0.032320153,
0.028057497,
-0.0076710996,
-0.0324266665,
-0.0073038461,
-0.0006012132,
0.0321338288,
0.0240811482,
-0.0587538667,
0.0668270066,
0.0424005277,
-0.0186997578,
-0.0235859361,
0.0237531774,
-0.0319160186,
0.0293905865,
0.0119881546,
-0.0160538405,
-0.0680367276,
-0.0426012725,
-0.0170278531,
0.0263836514,
-0.0325005352,
-0.0123523893,
-0.0794130936,
-0.0565734245,
0.0141522782,
0.0154813873,
-0.0090293037,
-0.0129539957,
0.0141543467,
0.0546262413,
0.0369841307,
-0.0864248127,
-0.0115997838,
-0.0079378337,
-0.0183407366,
-0.0312502496,
-0.0091891633,
-6.440059677e-33,
-0.0167576503,
-0.0147072431,
0.0651915073,
-0.008308039,
-0.0433631204,
-0.0170161258,
-0.0277553685,
-0.0084395176,
0.0108083021,
0.0275636893,
-0.0078614289,
0.0117160641,
0.0043799384,
-0.0144059015,
0.0018739395,
-0.0223307759,
0.022083398,
0.0202716608,
-0.0230982378,
-0.0223084651,
0.0201451164,
-0.0051877829,
0.0023754553,
-0.0395441204,
0.013947268,
0.0161003973,
-0.0149121331,
0.0712433308,
-0.0882072598,
0.0383367836,
0.0079496875,
0.0023307861,
0.0280752536,
-0.0227147117,
0.004837675,
0.0158371665,
-0.0578889325,
-0.0228123758,
0.0668548048,
0.0014971007,
-0.0497242883,
-0.0306354593,
0.0296585094,
0.0120873805,
-0.0209509432,
-0.0082656844,
-0.0025067669,
-0.0367067866,
-0.0131872203,
-0.0111747859,
-0.0396698415,
0.0296501927,
-0.0206378382,
-0.0104268761,
-0.0191476475,
0.0697633401,
-0.0399717018,
-0.0002108632,
-0.0320602916,
-0.0096654529,
0.0441307425,
-0.0298463665,
0.0755626634,
-0.0081951041,
0.0048663625,
0.0402586348,
-0.0188274216,
-0.0155864405,
-0.0670984536,
0.060952004,
-0.0078029158,
0.0715178251,
0.0495656542,
-0.0045740372,
0.0202088822,
0.0249149948,
-0.0862668604,
0.0164879765,
-0.0125551531,
0.1174054593,
0.0539402179,
0.0299950205,
-0.0231308136,
-0.0384481661,
-0.0692325681,
0.0349912085,
-0.043541342,
-0.0123402644,
0.0427315608,
0.0073531806,
-0.0391225517,
-0.0264370963,
0.0111687556,
-0.0335750543,
-0.0138839567,
0.015703788,
0.0087917717,
0.0074287271,
-0.0104429647,
0.0443961062,
-0.0039950181,
-0.0189212523,
0.0331219248,
-0.0396334715,
0.018721303,
-0.0013449307,
0.0276227165,
0.0001882574,
-0.0292905532,
0.0091967359,
-0.0375632569,
-0.0152231082,
-0.0034026497,
0.0189380907,
0.0580950007,
0.0423857383,
-0.0073311245,
0.0508751087,
-0.0099496581,
-0.0351232998,
-0.0276361536,
0.0516607054,
0.0257786512,
0.0198640842,
0.0164828189,
0.0140935928,
-0.0317792892,
-0.0202739537,
0.027238436,
-0.04618828,
-0.0022636103,
0.0442592278,
3.079e-7,
0.0119954152,
0.0614394695,
0.0191429555,
0.0776646659,
-0.001800352,
0.0332340114,
-0.0206471346,
-0.036264807,
0.0214683749,
-0.0016089148,
0.0096967285,
0.0677310005,
0.0283197165,
0.015504214,
-0.0433532707,
-0.0003457344,
-0.0377930775,
-0.0399315208,
-0.0730815157,
0.0104956478,
0.1044651866,
0.0657625794,
0.024850674,
-0.0235202815,
-0.0191112049,
-0.0746358633,
0.0254680645,
-0.0310569331,
-0.00766485,
0.0012069016,
0.0266212039,
-0.00204978,
0.0288378838,
0.0617749691,
0.0436477363,
-0.0100091081,
-0.025228221,
0.084151037,
0.0105785346,
0.0321062542,
-0.01244043,
-0.0397622399,
0.0105784899,
-0.0448184311,
0.0863314196,
-0.0476378575,
-0.0592265017,
-0.0001171964,
-0.0421695933,
-0.0317765884,
-0.0018507545,
0.0085988566,
0.0117324935,
0.0247350149,
0.0117062945,
-0.0260686092,
0.0090208612,
-0.0499940515,
-0.038117364,
0.0126913367,
-0.0177765954,
-0.0104088364,
-0.0322141312,
0.0393538214,
0.0452754311,
-0.0627877712,
-0.0101059759,
3.046790899e-34,
0.0425146893,
-0.011571276,
0.0138332797,
0.0252922904,
0.0646686181,
0.0145572359,
-0.0653105155,
0.0278487261,
0.0235197991,
-0.1014888138,
0.0071130106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15823v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15823v1 | CaT-BENCH: Benchmarking Language Model Understanding of Causal and Temporal Dependencies in Plans | 2024-06-22T11:46:04 | 2024-06-22T11:46:04 | Yash Kumar Lal, Vanya Cohen, Nathanael Chambers, Niranjan Balasubramanian, Raymond Mooney | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding the abilities of LLMs to reason about natural language plans,
such as instructional text and recipes, is critical to reliably using them in
decision-making systems. A fundamental aspect of plans is the temporal order in
which their steps needs to be executed, which reflects the underlying causal
dependencies between them. We introduce CaT-Bench, a benchmark of Step Order
Prediction questions, which test whether a step must necessarily occur before
or after another in cooking recipe plans. We use this to evaluate how well
frontier LLMs understand causal and temporal dependencies. We find that SOTA
LLMs are underwhelming (best zero-shot is only 0.59 in F1), and are biased
towards predicting dependence more often, perhaps relying on temporal order of
steps as a heuristic. While prompting for explanations and using few-shot
examples improve performance, the best F1 result is only 0.73. Further, human
evaluation of explanations along with answer correctness show that, on average,
humans do not agree with model reasoning. Surprisingly, we also find that
explaining after answering leads to better performance than normal
chain-of-thought prompting, and LLM answers are not consistent across questions
about the same step pairs. Overall, results show that LLMs' ability to detect
dependence between steps has significant room for improvement. | [
0.017229354,
0.037282493,
-0.0186979454,
0.0360190459,
-0.0262362547,
0.0066947965,
-0.0209197123,
0.0215027835,
-0.0053992053,
-0.0496412739,
0.0168469604,
0.0020159106,
0.0044842307,
0.0179854631,
-0.0132739758,
-0.0341304168,
0.0226828679,
-0.0376283042,
0.0031062695,
0.0054760179,
-0.0430657975,
0.0010151784,
-0.0587548912,
0.0504386947,
0.0137730353,
-0.0353284776,
-0.0494265556,
0.004173385,
0.0005025193,
-0.0877941772,
-0.0227853991,
0.0629723743,
0.0304724816,
-0.0177488662,
0.0000022517,
-0.0578615963,
-0.0014331546,
-0.0181513447,
-0.0685968027,
0.0267044064,
-0.0633467212,
0.028887406,
0.0132987788,
0.0241539702,
-0.0453927293,
0.0560069494,
-0.0038923039,
0.0270742625,
0.0012332302,
0.0554682314,
0.0151361879,
-0.0467627272,
-0.0087786261,
0.0088466248,
0.0683362186,
-0.0288853571,
-0.0328037068,
0.0046730405,
0.037768025,
-0.0015421325,
-0.0194366183,
0.0072811046,
0.0355314724,
0.0008026896,
-0.0193735901,
0.0419544429,
0.0191273522,
-0.0215343069,
-0.0095249331,
0.0592977554,
0.0647140145,
0.0007332666,
0.0067644026,
-0.0293545406,
-0.0046051284,
0.027626168,
-0.0507230908,
0.0065637892,
-0.0222734958,
0.0100107314,
0.0099694123,
-0.0055123577,
0.0459899008,
0.0113008758,
0.0264566448,
0.1418347806,
-0.0358039364,
-0.0353464261,
0.0022379309,
0.0149379577,
0.0597086139,
-0.0838625208,
-0.0058869324,
0.0846347287,
-0.0530666672,
0.0362386666,
0.0451862812,
0.0788635984,
0.0078842193,
-0.0294893589,
0.0346151851,
0.06961862,
-0.0186764542,
0.0075332127,
0.0006603348,
0.0865206718,
0.0145586422,
0.0211320091,
-0.0449692011,
0.0812212452,
-0.065798752,
-0.0176769588,
0.0253645629,
0.0180670638,
-0.0389659405,
0.0071113133,
-0.0280223973,
0.0212944299,
-0.010773696,
0.0234478712,
0.0268443841,
0.0197518114,
0.0266504008,
-0.0055751889,
-0.140771687,
0.0203021485,
-0.0556342192,
0.0573028512,
-0.0042076623,
-0.0301044304,
-0.0114527047,
-0.009814187,
-0.0083272802,
0.0233839508,
0.0041907895,
0.0815397426,
-0.0321541689,
-0.0063236323,
-0.0828614458,
-0.0650596619,
0.0149630252,
-0.0707567111,
0.0119955484,
-0.0554271787,
0.0182153434,
0.049438417,
-0.0203242693,
0.0154232867,
0.0249027256,
0.0338198766,
-0.0274346787,
0.0650696978,
0.0557193384,
0.0419286899,
-0.0072830836,
0.0524150059,
-0.0241908655,
0.0582831874,
0.0322390571,
0.0383196212,
-0.0033379165,
-0.0145461969,
0.0118989693,
0.0115475124,
-0.0171559993,
0.0092441207,
-0.0471096449,
0.0191155598,
-0.0297580026,
0.0295126457,
0.0372915417,
0.026007995,
-0.0209429506,
0.0465357564,
0.0529567041,
0.0611108094,
0.0182517525,
0.0008285944,
0.0548555478,
0.0099197365,
0.0092119481,
0.0435902774,
-0.0490361862,
0.0490245596,
-0.0452699065,
0.000285594,
0.005123741,
-0.0200622603,
-0.0198497269,
-0.067706503,
-0.0361212902,
0.0041203881,
0.020580221,
-0.0019391372,
0.0095556881,
-0.0187966488,
-0.0700871795,
0.0545289107,
-0.0228047706,
-0.0133064082,
-0.0118532153,
-0.0229781382,
0.046057038,
0.1079274043,
0.0353478417,
-0.0228068586,
-0.032556396,
0.0107048806,
0.0349448957,
0.0017291779,
0.0526362173,
-0.0185574871,
0.0182284247,
-0.0073211789,
-0.0568703748,
-0.0328415111,
0.0100022303,
0.0043833102,
0.0151772033,
0.014305871,
-0.0039600446,
0.0091601731,
-0.0045314203,
0.0325541198,
-0.05188087,
-0.0356208831,
-0.0512401685,
0.0040084231,
0.0157078207,
0.0183601677,
0.0243576262,
0.0338196643,
0.0201542191,
-0.0172371045,
-0.0197771545,
0.0444777161,
-0.0443627797,
-0.0234740842,
0.0167341754,
-0.0213783327,
-0.0271921568,
-0.0246008411,
-0.0412974693,
-0.0446060896,
0.0224258658,
0.000179618,
0.0210874733,
-0.0016415659,
0.0136789819,
0.0272673666,
-0.0422291756,
-0.0349332877,
0.0734736547,
-0.0284412783,
0.046847187,
0.0116884373,
-0.0066701397,
-0.0046313247,
-0.0287990794,
0.0449890755,
0.0232353061,
0.0020169518,
-0.0066980058,
-0.0147774657,
0.0315043405,
-0.0790052488,
-0.0147587126,
-0.058598984,
-0.0073426319,
-0.0191844963,
0.0318969116,
0.0034902436,
-0.0516605228,
-0.0040667509,
-0.0218173619,
-0.0355286226,
0.0154672684,
-0.0161614269,
0.0348551646,
0.0396967791,
0.028525712,
-0.0217868295,
-0.0230345894,
0.0127694048,
-0.047105439,
0.007376953,
0.0330586359,
-0.0083039887,
-0.0649321079,
0.0089180851,
-0.0285581686,
-0.0190397445,
-0.0153630394,
-0.0188969374,
0.0381581932,
0.0008328762,
-0.0105548827,
0.0252050553,
-0.0142778438,
0.0206486341,
0.0779167488,
-0.0415282026,
-0.0666569471,
0.0206091572,
-0.0119461603,
0.0185325015,
-0.0292556733,
-0.0639837831,
-0.0386345759,
0.0819917023,
-0.0046351687,
0.0374883674,
-0.0337034315,
-0.0008262208,
-0.005397921,
-0.0289020836,
-0.0456127524,
-0.0330205299,
-0.0295634605,
0.0925040469,
0.0037353241,
-0.0581890419,
0.0674058124,
-0.0117062312,
-0.002356177,
-0.0004953913,
0.0111113004,
-0.0491271354,
0.0763707012,
-0.0028943687,
-0.0081503317,
-0.0019156239,
-0.0205596201,
-0.0815576091,
-0.0121761914,
0.0199285764,
-0.0321801789,
0.0564082116,
-0.0929126143,
-0.0180077441,
-0.0070640608,
-0.0095231608,
-0.0630024821,
-0.0339724757,
-0.0523838811,
-0.0084004756,
-0.0113247987,
-0.0144111216,
-0.0079822149,
-0.0380442068,
0.02063049,
-0.0113833463,
0.0023407054,
-0.0306416713,
-0.0062477766,
0.0023154628,
0.0197477229,
0.0276698992,
0.0178644899,
-0.0333586857,
0.0574218333,
0.0314979032,
0.037230175,
-0.0317134745,
-0.0299357474,
0.0304062795,
0.0259856302,
-0.0153876739,
-0.018857412,
0.0793568566,
0.032138586,
-0.0291613713,
0.0092000533,
0.1134494245,
0.0379748419,
-0.0131225055,
0.0369540006,
-0.0431259423,
0.0268524792,
0.043177247,
0.0318636224,
-0.0901651457,
-0.0293888431,
-0.0001064483,
0.0137458835,
-0.0361206122,
-0.020248007,
-0.036850553,
-0.0839326605,
0.0089373672,
-0.0197599735,
-0.0372817479,
0.0391316563,
-0.030107826,
-0.0379616283,
0.0199957564,
0.0122981304,
0.0184403844,
-0.0206033438,
0.0129968552,
0.0288359933,
-0.0639399514,
-0.0030140139,
0.0597437173,
0.0160078574,
0.0250780322,
0.0215373076,
0.0185913704,
-0.0221893545,
-0.0513196848,
0.0723512396,
0.0246396288,
0.0607531071,
-0.0377759226,
0.0297967903,
0.0301216524,
0.0230790209,
-0.0131151043,
0.0004392641,
-0.0180317611,
-0.0554684177,
0.014683607,
0.092327781,
-0.0399025753,
-0.0283871312,
-0.0046919384,
0.0238097291,
-0.0014245011,
0.0761803761,
0.0235600416,
-0.0024085834,
-0.0504680723,
-0.0330159888,
-0.0479283668,
-0.0458412133,
-0.0274388567,
0.0140486183,
0.0087030595,
0.0317339897,
-0.0457954705,
-0.0406586602,
-0.0117725916,
0.0250451267,
0.001312342,
0.033078596,
-0.0161707085,
0.0284150895,
-0.0119526982,
0.0525169186,
0.0182389673,
0.0013664265,
-0.0573666655,
-0.0066119572,
0.0136107095,
-0.0183258932,
0.0014055639,
0.0173656978,
-0.0639242232,
-0.0419431627,
-0.0265521873,
0.0465150401,
0.0321490951,
0.0323670469,
0.0416029952,
-0.0441106968,
-0.0057587149,
-0.0013321053,
0.0023514668,
0.018817002,
0.0161881801,
0.0379020944,
0.0106602926,
0.0127352411,
-0.0358750671,
0.0137805156,
-0.0307243932,
0.0571142174,
-0.0284284055,
-0.04743376,
0.0293253753,
0.0044342629,
0.0451633856,
-0.0139227156,
0.0119657945,
-0.0220800377,
0.0532699451,
-0.0337407626,
0.0019474315,
-0.0268738065,
-0.0115592852,
0.0262974035,
-0.0239886791,
0.0039126631,
-0.0554580912,
-0.0362519622,
-0.0022243008,
0.0055582244,
0.0320339948,
0.0050307964,
0.0035424209,
0.0139802499,
0.0108517166,
-0.0051505803,
0.007936148,
0.0094812578,
0.0305103343,
0.0369118378,
0.0943457484,
0.003463805,
0.0510588139,
-0.02401153,
-0.0255827196,
-0.045107305,
-0.0852114037,
0.0453871302,
-0.0335423276,
0.0292430576,
-0.03410431,
0.0420709029,
-0.0276753828,
0.0241525061,
0.0161928758,
0.0339148752,
0.0037313935,
-0.0120465122,
0.0826495886,
0.0273994915,
-0.0149613013,
-0.0115503706,
0.0857467502,
-0.0001818909,
0.0529235601,
-0.021042183,
-0.0108356187,
-0.0133160353,
-0.0459367856,
-0.0136808809,
0.0013373017,
-0.0232735071,
-0.0220304877,
-0.0954167247,
-0.0363073796,
-0.012123581,
-0.0007719471,
0.0078385761,
-0.0555934384,
0.0404604003,
0.0333825089,
0.015024907,
-0.0324657299,
-0.0027890168,
0.0081793806,
-0.0315853693,
-0.01413853,
-0.0374692641,
-6.620240186e-33,
-0.0239925366,
-0.0535536446,
0.0759575441,
0.0057400372,
0.025986176,
-0.001352913,
-0.05844111,
0.0374015532,
-0.000186338,
0.0087929768,
-0.0122097656,
0.0016273529,
0.0135582313,
-0.0280099865,
0.0363113396,
-0.0659459382,
0.0030539716,
-0.0023426749,
-0.0272672512,
-0.0355144218,
0.0224524494,
-0.0071838247,
0.017440429,
-0.0546239763,
0.0307005625,
0.0080558127,
-0.0006597908,
0.0140537098,
-0.0470284112,
0.0295190532,
-0.0061156088,
0.0034888966,
0.0416794643,
-0.0524542034,
-0.0144010074,
0.0332864337,
-0.0041852864,
-0.0947467238,
0.0509666912,
-0.0241199154,
-0.0627536103,
-0.0375335477,
0.0234835222,
0.0185489263,
-0.0522318445,
0.0188532397,
0.0226483755,
-0.0136227962,
-0.0148013448,
0.0145296976,
-0.0490753278,
0.0073409872,
-0.0345044099,
-0.0070522907,
0.0312542245,
0.0856771618,
0.0046118614,
-0.0124817248,
-0.0052794921,
0.0463469625,
0.010569429,
0.0114050834,
0.0844163969,
0.0067429719,
-0.0158251971,
0.0677522495,
-0.0016820526,
0.0273979958,
-0.0322986431,
-0.0106429309,
-0.0175675098,
0.0789502934,
0.0381918587,
-0.0257497337,
0.0229026098,
0.0259823818,
-0.0639998168,
0.0532063209,
0.0114055499,
0.0209085532,
-0.0153733296,
0.0121404575,
-0.0261934623,
-0.024825871,
-0.0573364422,
0.0361770801,
-0.0307562537,
-0.0302251708,
0.0386841334,
0.0022195701,
0.0400574096,
-0.0342322513,
-0.0026940794,
-0.0008630455,
-0.0064110826,
0.0064495122,
-0.0322905891,
-0.0179177485,
0.0060847118,
0.0118093295,
-0.1005581617,
-0.0057349568,
-0.0220383033,
0.0128300013,
0.0623906292,
0.0126662878,
0.0004904622,
0.010620364,
-0.026982436,
-0.0216603409,
-0.0586328804,
-0.0320907198,
0.0096723037,
-0.0438506939,
0.0565779433,
-0.0190863218,
-0.0264003687,
0.0260172822,
-0.0022235417,
-0.0313395262,
-0.0176654886,
0.0015888299,
-0.0130625516,
0.0078142164,
0.0051736082,
-0.0244989488,
-0.0120368889,
0.0372353308,
0.0408223197,
-0.0477327034,
-0.0136283115,
0.0230586957,
2.928e-7,
0.0485833734,
0.0480769537,
-0.0033784776,
0.0432723798,
0.0140224788,
0.0156691428,
-0.040949896,
-0.027047487,
-0.0029259538,
-0.0187605359,
0.0456592329,
0.0116422269,
0.0370118432,
0.0460422523,
-0.0292695928,
-0.017706668,
-0.0565705374,
0.0106119849,
-0.0415458903,
-0.0162484348,
0.0619111732,
-0.0083731841,
0.0099825328,
0.0021511537,
-0.0529659316,
-0.0131780459,
0.0433719531,
-0.0555777624,
0.0278398599,
-0.0130806705,
0.0106412517,
-0.0024830259,
0.0080487849,
0.008521799,
-0.0279469155,
-0.0311318766,
-0.0462859347,
0.0432701595,
0.0066493,
-0.0731286556,
-0.0178429019,
-0.0306790154,
0.0127743771,
-0.0446972027,
0.0689953268,
-0.0172030628,
-0.0278242286,
0.045667965,
0.0259759221,
-0.0184814092,
-0.0049063144,
0.0294194054,
0.0397622064,
0.0135577852,
-0.0190698989,
-0.0092622815,
-0.0042548496,
-0.0621592589,
-0.0520296991,
0.0428396016,
-0.0010455174,
-0.0403175279,
-0.0552073792,
0.0348981619,
-0.0063246102,
-0.0437444784,
-0.0480104908,
2.437038562e-34,
-0.0058129025,
0.0114361197,
0.01253385,
0.024588611,
0.0145914201,
0.0216797683,
-0.0272163134,
0.035249535,
0.0384697579,
-0.0604950935,
-0.0154204285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17801v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17801v1 | A multi-speaker multi-lingual voice cloning system based on vits2 for limmits 2024 challenge | 2024-06-22T10:49:36 | 2024-06-22T10:49:36 | Xiaopeng Wang, Yi Lu, Xin Qi, Zhiyong Wang, Yuankun Xie, Shuchen Shi, Ruibo Fu | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | This paper presents the development of a speech synthesis system for the
LIMMITS'24 Challenge, focusing primarily on Track 2. The objective of the
challenge is to establish a multi-speaker, multi-lingual Indic Text-to-Speech
system with voice cloning capabilities, covering seven Indian languages with
both male and female speakers. The system was trained using challenge data and
fine-tuned for few-shot voice cloning on target speakers. Evaluation included
both mono-lingual and cross-lingual synthesis across all seven languages, with
subjective tests assessing naturalness and speaker similarity. Our system uses
the VITS2 architecture, augmented with a multi-lingual ID and a BERT model to
enhance contextual language comprehension. In Track 1, where no additional data
usage was permitted, our model achieved a Speaker Similarity score of 4.02. In
Track 2, which allowed the use of extra data, it attained a Speaker Similarity
score of 4.17. | [
-0.0031584096,
0.0226918161,
-0.0079882955,
0.0172833186,
-0.0449475385,
-0.0395091176,
0.0276890602,
0.0073258285,
-0.0349612534,
0.0288250931,
-0.0628713295,
-0.0476738103,
0.0094230343,
-0.0018484256,
0.0505012944,
-0.0731593445,
0.0323598832,
-0.0165639892,
-0.031194644,
-0.0387919731,
-0.000425385,
0.030393403,
-0.0343959294,
0.0335578062,
-0.0056359745,
0.0075600347,
0.0036831424,
0.0138596101,
0.0347145386,
0.0128476014,
-0.0117476135,
0.0142700337,
0.0527982824,
0.063403748,
0.0000018951,
-0.0500080436,
-0.0265205558,
0.0070403153,
-0.0289886612,
0.0029158383,
0.0363678746,
0.0539277121,
0.0015056868,
0.0332558937,
0.0170234255,
0.0056932843,
0.0412321277,
-0.0192323755,
0.0742515177,
0.050367441,
-0.0295312293,
-0.0535272434,
-0.0023481697,
-0.004982193,
-0.0177245419,
-0.0227779485,
-0.0343037695,
-0.0000261395,
0.0518087968,
-0.0404140502,
0.0233213399,
0.0442087799,
-0.0127241267,
0.0144631015,
-0.0281949509,
-0.0263308361,
-0.0370577462,
-0.0547923371,
0.0334068276,
0.0583891608,
0.001046056,
-0.0354605615,
0.0275789928,
0.0551146381,
-0.0450912565,
-0.0255268794,
-0.0305850022,
-0.008272633,
-0.0078186756,
0.0068958369,
-0.0155340098,
0.0177367609,
-0.0126504479,
-0.0445437171,
0.0328696109,
-0.0485473238,
0.0562336929,
-0.0473686308,
-0.0142517677,
-0.0304957647,
-0.0001684666,
0.0096788285,
0.0539847389,
0.0197400358,
-0.0387984142,
-0.0027140016,
-0.0300755687,
-0.0588603914,
-0.0282124989,
-0.0470140539,
0.0342369676,
0.0511834063,
-0.0126337931,
-0.0084096966,
-0.0143469498,
0.0519056581,
0.0033766085,
0.0257860776,
-0.05266371,
-0.0527227558,
-0.0299246609,
0.0062705204,
-0.0453983471,
0.0260886941,
-0.0312225074,
0.0145068578,
-0.067172423,
-0.0131398458,
-0.0177894551,
0.0110453768,
-0.0076433588,
-0.019990731,
-0.0353013054,
-0.0238294322,
0.0124976374,
0.0185067505,
-0.0062399935,
0.0302710515,
-0.0294866711,
-0.0777133405,
-0.0109258927,
0.036149282,
0.0011310834,
-0.0073204874,
-0.0042938655,
0.0519996099,
-0.0219413862,
-0.0164734516,
-0.0327082239,
-0.0098049976,
-0.0025986801,
-0.0616683699,
-0.0152650671,
-0.047006119,
0.0436878763,
-0.0160585176,
-0.0257511754,
-0.0094613284,
-0.0232054647,
-0.0100985086,
0.0368715338,
0.0403845869,
0.0128546832,
0.0485272892,
0.0482067131,
0.0082365861,
0.0238524042,
0.0132092116,
0.0275523216,
-0.0501954295,
0.0067380951,
-0.0235979054,
-0.0019740886,
0.066510573,
0.0249538328,
0.0302364621,
-0.0472334512,
-0.0030211199,
0.0073638558,
0.0453139953,
0.0555567443,
0.0263295621,
-0.0342711583,
0.0173561908,
0.0468426906,
0.0599345639,
0.055500932,
0.0537550114,
0.0749960691,
0.0083524669,
0.0247326363,
-0.0222260132,
0.0026577127,
0.0113265617,
0.0024975762,
0.0220306851,
0.0322820656,
0.0170826223,
-0.0363258496,
0.0564124286,
0.011773373,
-0.0288298447,
-0.0499416627,
-0.0199330114,
-0.01598428,
0.0003755948,
-0.0319281183,
0.0829502419,
-0.0010716622,
-0.1187575087,
0.0245232899,
-0.0326831751,
0.0058053206,
0.0331024267,
0.0164670646,
0.0036606106,
0.0011299324,
-0.0298405979,
-0.032147482,
0.0501851737,
0.0380349457,
-0.0231472421,
0.0562072881,
-0.0693501234,
-0.0113492692,
0.0329130031,
-0.0517032221,
0.0510180555,
-0.0434594825,
0.0456623957,
0.0139336837,
-0.0423831455,
0.0266972966,
-0.0201998539,
-0.062747255,
-0.0022733549,
-0.011581894,
0.0140875895,
0.0713450983,
0.0488633774,
-0.0318648182,
0.0095526697,
0.0112552894,
-0.0326877162,
0.0056721666,
0.0594978593,
-0.0502367094,
-0.033756543,
0.0421383865,
-0.0680784881,
0.0297937933,
0.051086124,
0.0176776201,
-0.1052403674,
0.0610039942,
-0.0333596244,
0.0157423019,
-0.0380922072,
0.0318390541,
0.0089370562,
-0.0012103879,
0.0260429848,
-0.0039696116,
0.0284041185,
0.0164923128,
0.067074962,
-0.000642138,
0.0553208217,
-0.0854054913,
0.0065988647,
-0.0141526572,
0.0104035717,
0.0201416332,
-0.0123105375,
0.0178514868,
-0.0321947187,
-0.021759022,
-0.0841291919,
0.0047325343,
0.0181043502,
0.0373598747,
0.0012905754,
0.0361362174,
-0.0119944187,
-0.0168107115,
-0.0469051078,
-0.0510074422,
0.0206865612,
-0.033770144,
-0.0161292944,
-0.0226131529,
-0.0205507614,
-0.026193114,
0.0135729443,
0.0170039274,
0.0108529544,
-0.0355503783,
-0.0215055794,
-0.0409673005,
-0.012017508,
-0.0125884311,
0.0233984329,
0.0142962905,
-0.0347473174,
-0.0153440814,
-0.0022759044,
0.0790710226,
-0.0090886774,
0.0001742663,
-0.0505811349,
-0.0065376647,
-0.0098983105,
-0.0416226164,
0.0138659663,
0.0479174368,
0.0173789784,
-0.0105302576,
0.0152953258,
0.0000415076,
-0.0221401993,
0.0232385788,
0.0167148281,
-0.0600949377,
-0.0190251302,
0.0261460226,
-0.0047041881,
0.0477260202,
-0.0064517427,
-0.0590299107,
0.0112266764,
-0.0388227366,
-0.0002752943,
0.0186163932,
-0.0752840936,
-0.0456612334,
-0.0846535787,
-0.0131548587,
-0.0023354082,
0.019712748,
-0.0346538462,
0.0286519006,
-0.0150677748,
-0.0139941741,
-0.0651687905,
0.0293179173,
0.0141534451,
-0.0587937087,
0.0193344094,
-0.0388689078,
0.0244805533,
-0.0417501517,
-0.0355459936,
-0.0149335936,
0.0129432017,
0.0024124836,
0.031791091,
0.0347996131,
-0.0019905975,
0.0127717881,
0.0491918363,
0.0358703695,
0.0427477732,
0.0292846188,
0.0431712307,
-0.0068549514,
0.0601383857,
0.0211754553,
0.0440575033,
-0.0250157099,
-0.0135980388,
0.0410273559,
-0.047729928,
0.078354001,
0.0434028506,
-0.0088987043,
0.0086423308,
0.0439252071,
-0.0034563397,
-0.0383114852,
-0.0087387655,
0.091756627,
0.0253011081,
0.0047003138,
0.0926928818,
-0.022546554,
-0.0397777781,
-0.0226997994,
-0.059447784,
0.029742958,
0.0200370867,
0.014691053,
-0.0554120913,
-0.0225144625,
0.0716305152,
0.0232914146,
0.0112738004,
0.0192465,
-0.07026463,
-0.1110763624,
0.0171257704,
0.0241745375,
-0.0642489344,
-0.0477126986,
-0.0005109711,
-0.041688282,
0.0226353537,
0.0488758609,
0.0362095274,
-0.0288646184,
-0.0227069538,
0.0439548381,
-0.0436174273,
-0.0685293674,
0.0140514709,
-0.0451874137,
0.1018669605,
0.0455493107,
0.0348136909,
0.015815381,
-0.0287304968,
0.0271807313,
-0.058013387,
-0.0154885622,
0.0113273254,
0.0211766008,
0.0222386979,
-0.006093109,
-0.0263477005,
0.0475450046,
0.0197241325,
0.0252012871,
0.0012594418,
0.0556471422,
0.0092651462,
-0.0010887055,
0.0205984451,
0.0514791161,
-0.0006049093,
0.0458150096,
0.0689461008,
-0.0427143686,
-0.000479251,
0.0502202027,
0.0477257743,
-0.0994851664,
-0.0335342288,
0.0261203945,
-0.0287860334,
-0.0384778492,
-0.029345192,
-0.0297436323,
-0.0064685661,
0.0464944877,
0.0386000872,
0.0125659527,
-0.018321069,
0.0044344924,
-0.0123428721,
-0.0350427739,
-0.031040417,
0.0619446971,
-0.0746716261,
-0.0129547091,
0.0268067606,
-0.0503451526,
-0.014617824,
0.0160988662,
-0.039992664,
-0.0408170149,
-0.0238418058,
0.0363210291,
0.0293866415,
0.0763179734,
-0.0137859993,
-0.0110524651,
0.0455080345,
-0.0138936769,
-0.0126441149,
0.0112282252,
0.0622686408,
0.0083483094,
-0.0037044038,
0.0392589495,
-0.0373162404,
0.0373524316,
-0.0014813028,
0.0110026272,
0.0040540658,
-0.0583099537,
0.0162479896,
0.0503812097,
-0.0235232115,
-0.0355069116,
0.0346696004,
-0.0206451062,
0.0133819915,
-0.004947444,
0.0427318253,
-0.0342477746,
-0.0037443582,
0.0473387614,
0.0466512702,
0.0237852279,
-0.0070410063,
-0.0163952988,
0.0020655221,
0.0071665943,
0.052176889,
0.024745401,
0.0951601863,
0.0213748403,
-0.0222649723,
-0.0308607388,
0.0008968006,
-0.0110230306,
0.0122278603,
-0.0420142598,
0.0299592856,
-0.0125591205,
0.0158678517,
0.0409107842,
0.0534662567,
0.0129434234,
-0.0241064057,
-0.0212535802,
0.0200362168,
0.0387498923,
0.0398638584,
0.1075847223,
-0.0054781116,
0.0394862965,
-0.014731898,
0.0177688692,
-0.0809112415,
0.023628654,
-0.0039986982,
-0.0196179915,
-0.0070419786,
-0.0047749626,
0.0362656042,
-0.0181830712,
0.0153938737,
-0.038194783,
0.0406754501,
-0.0219179187,
-0.0507715531,
-0.0037828179,
-0.0081966687,
-0.0128011554,
-0.02465095,
-0.0377285518,
-0.0474061146,
0.0585065261,
-0.0087114582,
-0.0000342773,
-0.0275031477,
0.0277530979,
-0.0001618949,
-0.0350759923,
-0.0127665633,
0.0248351358,
-0.0312812142,
0.0033882163,
-0.0487223752,
0.0376266167,
-5.931184499e-33,
-0.0212599784,
0.0612400509,
0.009128754,
-0.0129295979,
-0.0671205595,
-0.0344426595,
-0.0551574118,
-0.0200745985,
-0.008227638,
-0.0212823525,
-0.0101083927,
-0.0259700101,
0.0095858071,
0.0296884179,
-0.007285004,
0.0150691504,
0.0640288442,
0.0197092965,
0.0095165558,
0.0399020426,
0.0409234874,
0.0347322188,
0.0530482493,
-0.0206947774,
-0.042949073,
-0.0268193074,
0.0215553641,
-0.0044847727,
-0.0201452635,
0.0066384799,
-0.0011504764,
0.0381964371,
-0.0090218903,
-0.0332405828,
-0.0235903971,
-0.0176249556,
-0.0587912463,
-0.0300083216,
0.0139546413,
0.0461011976,
0.0114081474,
0.00472546,
0.0432521999,
-0.0197394211,
-0.0432710573,
0.0165910758,
0.0091075078,
-0.0123526035,
0.0060220826,
-0.0217912309,
-0.0551183932,
0.02037194,
-0.0140232155,
-0.0200891849,
0.034341462,
0.1101463735,
-0.0337423496,
-0.033306621,
-0.0727110505,
0.0198791623,
-0.0410636924,
0.036078237,
0.0503192507,
0.0198614858,
-0.0251151137,
0.0021838422,
0.0449490361,
-0.1113464013,
0.0115376925,
0.0061022616,
0.0199696813,
0.0292721633,
0.0387476198,
0.062450137,
-0.0197695568,
-0.0657329708,
0.0022517068,
0.0338693261,
0.0608921014,
-0.0056714118,
-0.0042886958,
0.0166743081,
0.0003308881,
0.0033275711,
-0.0224446729,
-0.0646254867,
-0.0137279732,
-0.0212479141,
0.0653048083,
-0.0401032604,
0.0097378613,
-0.0237173457,
0.0788410231,
0.0082537439,
0.0171541907,
-0.0378216952,
-0.0411836132,
0.0103442827,
-0.0116875637,
0.0249678064,
-0.0401088819,
-0.0662965029,
0.051795654,
0.0625137985,
0.0111754416,
-0.0230961628,
-0.0246490519,
0.0587266795,
-0.0577355847,
0.0108594615,
-0.0017736176,
0.0461722352,
-0.0186435021,
0.0243477318,
0.0051778876,
-0.0016725427,
0.0265697148,
-0.0324797779,
0.0031203909,
0.0046273819,
0.0295345616,
0.0034292154,
0.0304924231,
0.0294757951,
-0.0251882672,
0.0411753133,
-0.0408822261,
0.0072396998,
0.0189490486,
-0.0214342438,
-0.005966553,
-0.009430917,
2.774e-7,
-0.0336440206,
-0.0147997225,
0.0389336124,
-0.0823343918,
0.0085967081,
0.0202700906,
-0.0423539579,
0.0186006818,
-0.0032820459,
0.0390861928,
-0.0005222012,
-0.0308200456,
0.0740907639,
-0.0001152523,
-0.1326861233,
-0.0165987499,
-0.0801268891,
0.0045452393,
-0.0412404165,
0.0191228241,
0.0129032871,
0.0563913509,
0.0039020129,
-0.0621596575,
0.0106648207,
-0.022357624,
0.0296989065,
-0.0135394176,
-0.0075839842,
-0.0024087881,
0.0066526956,
-0.0602837987,
-0.0287900064,
0.0131634297,
-0.0419312567,
0.031376604,
0.0327516273,
0.0498571768,
-0.0137604102,
-0.0255312789,
0.0073137013,
0.036618147,
-0.0460969992,
-0.0042103981,
0.036318019,
0.0324100703,
-0.0245019868,
-0.0126187755,
-0.0399739444,
0.0334673077,
-0.0009180736,
-0.000303769,
-0.0249385983,
0.0102674337,
0.0159563255,
-0.0055653313,
-0.0147139952,
-0.0269295219,
0.020117525,
0.0025973264,
-0.0491294377,
-0.0607532561,
-0.0320719481,
-0.0254027154,
0.0424823053,
-0.0200385153,
-0.008306778,
2.084700431e-34,
0.0005629767,
-0.0087463688,
0.0567844994,
-0.0403349586,
0.0033909704,
-0.035930451,
0.0057996404,
0.040584255,
0.0098379152,
0.0004365385,
-0.0523571372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15812v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15812v1 | Intrinsic Dimension Correlation: uncovering nonlinear connections in multimodal representations | 2024-06-22T10:36:04 | 2024-06-22T10:36:04 | Lorenzo Basile, Santiago Acevedo, Luca Bortolussi, Fabio Anselmi, Alex Rodriguez | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | To gain insight into the mechanisms behind machine learning methods, it is
crucial to establish connections among the features describing data points.
However, these correlations often exhibit a high-dimensional and strongly
nonlinear nature, which makes them challenging to detect using standard
methods. This paper exploits the entanglement between intrinsic dimensionality
and correlation to propose a metric that quantifies the (potentially nonlinear)
correlation between high-dimensional manifolds. We first validate our method on
synthetic data in controlled environments, showcasing its advantages and
drawbacks compared to existing techniques. Subsequently, we extend our analysis
to large-scale applications in neural network representations. Specifically, we
focus on latent representations of multimodal data, uncovering clear
correlations between paired visual and textual embeddings, whereas existing
methods struggle significantly in detecting similarity. Our results indicate
the presence of highly nonlinear correlation patterns between latent manifolds. | [
-0.0632592216,
0.0772629008,
-0.0285396576,
0.083874695,
-0.0177744851,
0.0089856843,
-0.0299998075,
0.0354136862,
0.0151359262,
0.0057256836,
-0.0483611003,
-0.0084138121,
0.0022822975,
0.0599752739,
0.050596226,
-0.0554025955,
-0.0149101662,
0.0210578553,
-0.0488653705,
-0.0185713712,
0.0029888626,
-0.0474566184,
0.0123370662,
0.0219927058,
-0.0398955755,
-0.0324151292,
-0.0018646753,
-0.0005452564,
0.0212727021,
-0.0035042178,
-0.0357054435,
-0.0125223175,
0.037577074,
0.0075453017,
0.0000019002,
-0.0086527383,
0.0208050478,
-0.0150142452,
0.0457050614,
0.0019167843,
-0.0328020751,
-0.0335345864,
0.0063194153,
-0.0557240807,
-0.0196797382,
-0.0290183406,
0.0432779454,
0.0455633774,
0.0558008328,
0.0150797116,
-0.0310925115,
-0.0021295024,
0.0199323557,
-0.0070594582,
0.026219368,
0.0293622948,
-0.0233963076,
-0.0098441923,
-0.0478550419,
-0.0272034593,
-0.0777401924,
-0.0006263349,
0.0366295092,
0.0381838121,
0.0432330705,
0.0520126224,
0.0012309296,
-0.0264491383,
0.0216536932,
0.1156823784,
-0.0365318023,
0.0104886992,
0.0093263974,
-0.001296167,
-0.0007893373,
0.0832510814,
-0.0458644293,
-0.033666037,
-0.0010583566,
0.0290271621,
-0.085899964,
0.0255422015,
0.0274440739,
-0.0291111488,
-0.0043032854,
0.0070046545,
0.0232123323,
0.0155869108,
-0.0321697257,
-0.0297914334,
0.0175802261,
0.0145296557,
-0.0391984805,
-0.0118938861,
0.0437764265,
-0.0571468286,
0.0253426954,
-0.0339285508,
-0.0115057016,
-0.0656943619,
0.050631389,
0.0086301146,
-0.0375908315,
0.0544598438,
-0.0508611836,
0.0698358268,
-0.0757891238,
0.0673413873,
-0.005582443,
0.024183305,
-0.031927716,
-0.0109410724,
0.0398255959,
-0.0018054539,
0.0217153654,
-0.0646704733,
-0.0169393532,
0.0375178978,
-0.0372056998,
0.0455003977,
-0.0628719255,
0.0565614849,
0.0602486208,
0.012470956,
-0.0435748808,
-0.0119661735,
-0.030421203,
0.032636933,
-0.0540081821,
0.0379218645,
0.0048745684,
0.0388743393,
0.0235436205,
-0.0153695988,
-0.0002113906,
0.0764410645,
0.001854847,
-0.0085660927,
-0.0117216269,
-0.0195166208,
-0.0242997054,
-0.01278916,
0.0635252148,
-0.0294999965,
0.0397492237,
-0.0236846879,
0.0103476737,
-0.0315572917,
-0.0213569272,
-0.0283206534,
-0.0369506329,
0.0866380036,
0.037907932,
-0.0164705273,
0.0289892945,
-0.0116730435,
0.0168816037,
0.0436674841,
0.022834247,
0.0586696751,
0.0357764512,
-0.0281213131,
-0.0025604346,
0.0036483076,
0.013937708,
-0.0140235014,
-0.0648281723,
-0.0241994131,
0.0237287916,
0.0294184368,
0.0512019657,
0.0486147739,
-0.0609309189,
-0.0591484606,
0.0386677124,
0.06296096,
0.0516887903,
0.0129329003,
0.0140446825,
-0.0341381393,
-0.0016463224,
0.0472075939,
-0.0349223875,
0.0983008593,
0.014215094,
-0.0127555849,
0.0969184786,
0.0309328623,
-0.0403614677,
-0.0193569846,
0.0075844796,
-0.0234510247,
0.0091201728,
-0.0254542399,
0.0415567048,
-0.0076700295,
0.0125145772,
-0.0338690504,
0.0043776412,
-0.0104078259,
-0.0006231259,
0.0144949127,
0.0044066827,
0.0445660837,
0.0208967812,
-0.0192179028,
0.0546407141,
0.0162340719,
-0.0054913368,
-0.0214285273,
-0.0425329022,
-0.0189497955,
0.0365375318,
-0.0232690126,
-0.0470272489,
-0.0401163623,
0.0258072782,
0.0098898606,
-0.0195123963,
-0.0107826376,
-0.012185052,
-0.0615764111,
0.0351547152,
-0.007409506,
-0.0162102841,
-0.0114290034,
0.0396350995,
0.0467682332,
0.0342671908,
0.0070499596,
0.001472743,
-0.0045663533,
0.0144706462,
-0.0444499291,
-0.054112453,
0.0344262421,
0.0299561732,
0.0090193106,
0.0049132244,
-0.0764256045,
0.0229781549,
-0.0012542986,
-0.0075852233,
-0.0358244032,
0.0861822069,
0.0091403173,
-0.0072707226,
-0.0259464029,
-0.0559639372,
-0.0033579338,
0.0719096363,
-0.0190619938,
0.0070901914,
-0.0356626697,
0.0078738583,
0.0050869356,
0.0268823635,
0.052810844,
0.0516912006,
-0.0203350801,
0.0292741582,
0.0215390176,
0.0149593595,
0.0015675511,
-0.0439080708,
-0.0068526692,
-0.0176140908,
0.0049570673,
-0.0413745269,
0.0051831035,
-0.0129283369,
-0.0073002842,
-0.0343031548,
0.0235676467,
-0.0334571339,
0.0180100072,
0.0303231981,
-0.0207621921,
0.0404341631,
0.0460825562,
-0.0131517136,
-0.0202642325,
-0.0118812686,
-0.0126337595,
-0.0086843502,
0.0865571797,
-0.0077545182,
0.0146079371,
-0.0244041346,
-0.0558643863,
-0.0204142816,
0.0014727188,
-0.0050663301,
-0.0220424924,
0.0008539161,
-0.0161740221,
0.0123978136,
0.0700892583,
0.0126390448,
0.0254169721,
0.0402156301,
0.0178031512,
-0.0143815167,
-0.0296318308,
-0.0259210765,
0.0219899416,
0.0294838324,
-0.0182086639,
-0.0278781764,
0.0104266824,
0.0219676103,
-0.0027344555,
-0.0575188585,
0.0227062311,
0.0157464724,
-0.0096575422,
-0.074621588,
-0.0052968883,
-0.0025224313,
0.0182477161,
-0.0116682611,
-0.0592819676,
0.0341496691,
-0.0031992868,
0.0354382172,
0.0611747168,
-0.0071731647,
-0.0304925703,
0.0789779127,
0.0466511101,
0.0163551793,
-0.0126255304,
-0.0024851118,
-0.0290812273,
0.0411928669,
0.0514263585,
0.0063443677,
-0.0085789496,
-0.0192815848,
-0.0182839353,
0.0150579643,
-0.0251130182,
-0.0325801522,
-0.0228731278,
0.0316127427,
-0.007045737,
-0.0369514227,
-0.0296382047,
0.0146865593,
-0.0492275134,
0.013772402,
0.0101275388,
-0.0120938737,
-0.0320584029,
-0.0019244342,
0.0573991947,
0.0419910103,
0.0021909517,
0.0120201577,
-0.0765625164,
0.015111817,
0.0262488835,
-0.0285949036,
0.0168507658,
-0.0561499931,
0.0402244627,
-0.0359879583,
0.0718487203,
-0.0023010499,
0.009423784,
-0.0182570536,
0.0094954828,
0.010664681,
0.0187575072,
-0.0111475252,
-0.0879417434,
0.009680762,
0.0113558937,
0.0234128088,
0.0545753054,
0.0039632861,
-0.017123498,
-0.0152336536,
-0.0286131632,
-0.031953074,
0.0262398534,
-0.0130783329,
0.0315446518,
-0.0196645558,
0.0027595814,
0.0025863517,
-0.0364234969,
-0.0366302021,
-0.051988475,
0.0170011893,
-0.005628488,
0.0091653578,
-0.0579832084,
-0.0019062008,
-0.0091697453,
0.0037482781,
-0.0196984634,
-0.0375755914,
-0.0093312552,
-0.0236646477,
-0.01637136,
0.0166207328,
0.0404787362,
-0.0320326127,
-0.0366428345,
-0.0244626105,
0.0386623405,
0.0392978825,
0.0223181602,
0.1035344675,
0.0011607655,
-0.0218659844,
-0.0040424475,
0.0441962816,
0.0094293691,
0.0143146394,
-0.0325968899,
0.083114706,
-0.0265006386,
-0.0023945589,
-0.0395276733,
-0.0364500321,
-0.0162954181,
-0.0022783347,
0.0342229195,
-0.0567495488,
-0.0123948185,
-0.0177090429,
0.0500180312,
0.0415136851,
-0.0493328013,
0.0026657095,
0.0291954912,
0.004653038,
-0.0744695738,
0.0418873243,
-0.0325854421,
0.0211607479,
0.0013235931,
-0.0405209996,
-0.027235413,
-0.0377488062,
-0.0664563999,
0.0561728105,
0.0528369807,
0.0176519826,
-0.0021959199,
0.0108805681,
0.01711463,
-0.0522650704,
-0.03907343,
-0.0145219639,
-0.0707683563,
-0.0338756256,
-0.038937185,
0.0286123101,
0.0009329627,
0.0567808449,
0.0236973707,
-0.0408400781,
0.020475721,
0.0478918664,
0.0027529204,
0.0234439839,
0.0115389116,
0.0190559253,
-0.0195054282,
0.0251297057,
-0.0259113442,
-0.0259292684,
0.0135478787,
-0.0213068929,
0.0203712191,
-0.0182225406,
0.0009523927,
-0.0266202744,
0.0846622288,
-0.0131040206,
-0.0477269292,
-0.0377472453,
-0.0272041857,
0.0137715712,
-0.0013686683,
-0.0343678333,
-0.0111101782,
0.0386226401,
0.018285932,
-0.0394992828,
0.0044822828,
0.0586966984,
0.0189519264,
-0.037855044,
-0.0430928282,
-0.0132608488,
-0.0034017041,
-0.0325714834,
0.0298825335,
0.0099118529,
0.0148828281,
-0.0372973569,
-0.0008764943,
0.0100273006,
0.0281977225,
0.0293004606,
0.03668667,
-0.070954904,
0.0252779312,
-0.0689269602,
-0.0075720912,
-0.0012166718,
0.0077531319,
0.0446929038,
-0.0114664733,
0.0259910636,
-0.0349483974,
-0.0067737,
0.0039578611,
0.0249406267,
0.0036937678,
-0.0095818313,
0.0377738699,
0.0054643536,
0.004513531,
0.0350496955,
0.0577994995,
-0.0323984288,
0.0063689896,
-0.0726522058,
0.032008104,
-0.0223118216,
0.0227764491,
0.0565590784,
0.0749184862,
-0.0074458639,
0.0276370794,
-0.043336682,
-0.0245598126,
-0.0090146801,
0.0090730255,
-0.016623294,
0.0354759991,
0.0309905317,
0.029950818,
0.0031251905,
-0.0002849141,
-0.0058425409,
-0.0327317752,
0.0174881537,
-0.0202723648,
0.0048104897,
-6.03448731e-33,
0.0086105699,
-0.0436887927,
-0.0368736051,
0.0137951616,
-0.0004375202,
0.0330145359,
-0.0185628366,
-0.0014310887,
-0.0062428182,
0.0371799767,
0.00711927,
-0.0047225975,
-0.022307748,
0.0038803511,
0.0403869264,
-0.0072555593,
-0.0060065533,
-0.0124202771,
-0.0018286454,
0.0267905295,
0.0776383728,
0.0046159062,
0.0263987519,
-0.0850494057,
-0.0326872319,
0.0551933832,
-0.0047993273,
0.0004512497,
0.0095903603,
0.0355351605,
-0.0713785663,
-0.0007460358,
0.0075791487,
0.0137874885,
-0.0341777727,
-0.01538515,
-0.0139097599,
-0.0111183189,
-0.0426683947,
-0.0096027097,
-0.0798639581,
-0.0113648642,
0.0581228174,
-0.0301328748,
-0.000690947,
-0.0587593429,
0.0891758129,
-0.00949327,
0.0016012391,
-0.0184629392,
-0.0237844512,
0.0090240045,
-0.0534264967,
0.0080121234,
0.0588165894,
0.0261857864,
-0.0056295209,
0.0201853905,
-0.0410728939,
0.0501564741,
-0.1150056049,
-0.030958306,
0.0301325321,
0.0231784489,
0.0660028532,
0.1091945469,
0.0755446926,
-0.0397866145,
-0.0751653537,
-0.0024920921,
0.0482690074,
0.0338651352,
0.0255059619,
0.0747383907,
0.051929649,
0.0158242583,
-0.0655266196,
0.0223769359,
-0.0210073404,
-0.0116314804,
0.0046685017,
0.0126394751,
-0.0174271856,
-0.0127316117,
-0.0059466017,
-0.0069200001,
-0.0401706398,
-0.0241031125,
0.0304779094,
-0.0144410972,
0.0272184499,
-0.0597539693,
0.0069703897,
-0.0490717627,
-0.0108034285,
0.0130896652,
-0.0039090626,
0.0496589653,
0.049117174,
-0.0332047381,
0.0353205577,
-0.0149141625,
0.0131471986,
-0.0218168553,
0.0813876614,
-0.0166287143,
0.0152332662,
0.0138824712,
-0.0184141658,
-0.0239775255,
-0.0156851653,
-0.0839231089,
0.0075494885,
-0.0381488763,
0.0347619094,
-0.0328349769,
-0.0130719608,
0.05614255,
-0.0073177912,
0.067091547,
-0.0204311591,
-0.0650083274,
-0.0036465228,
0.0381926186,
-0.0102911126,
0.0031817381,
-0.0396854468,
-0.094187066,
0.0536980554,
-0.097127676,
-0.0081525501,
0.0161789991,
2.615e-7,
-0.0342103466,
0.0378504209,
0.0055116625,
-0.0445065051,
0.0449758768,
0.0298941825,
-0.0348501317,
0.037668284,
-0.0589491837,
-0.0523800403,
0.0173610933,
0.0213373974,
0.0235135723,
0.0220685024,
-0.0103109125,
0.0173214357,
-0.0375510901,
0.0029394955,
-0.0247313939,
-0.0115743475,
0.0132270949,
0.0236575417,
0.0256067328,
0.0003085928,
0.079924576,
-0.0059563378,
0.0647710785,
-0.0296938941,
0.0565355271,
-0.0482252724,
-0.0187042039,
-0.0511419922,
0.0212349314,
0.0167226475,
-0.0200947896,
0.0063364161,
0.0552316681,
0.0006329286,
-0.0129431114,
-0.017319845,
-0.0407638699,
0.0328237228,
-0.0106681399,
-0.0426308699,
0.0849282891,
-0.0273200534,
-0.065363884,
-0.0331696309,
-0.0073372964,
0.0131632071,
0.0889315307,
0.0231580939,
-0.0349292755,
0.0289352629,
0.0244070683,
-0.0140086012,
0.0470901765,
-0.0686355382,
-0.0032740757,
0.0220723134,
-0.0751522258,
0.0109892106,
-0.0405746698,
-0.0054457546,
0.0749155432,
0.0277051404,
-0.0507874489,
2.137536835e-34,
0.0108709158,
-0.0008746918,
0.0573750027,
-0.0350620784,
0.0092408862,
-0.0744035169,
-0.0570400693,
-0.0116980104,
0.0281441398,
-0.0605968572,
-0.0183928143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15809v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15809v1 | LaMSUM: A Novel Framework for Extractive Summarization of User Generated Content using LLMs | 2024-06-22T10:25:55 | 2024-06-22T10:25:55 | Garima Chhikara, Anurag Sharma, V. Gurucharan, Kripabandhu Ghosh, Abhijnan Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance across
a wide range of NLP tasks, including summarization. Inherently LLMs produce
abstractive summaries, and the task of achieving extractive summaries through
LLMs still remains largely unexplored. To bridge this gap, in this work, we
propose a novel framework LaMSUM to generate extractive summaries through LLMs
for large user-generated text by leveraging voting algorithms. Our evaluation
on three popular open-source LLMs (Llama 3, Mixtral and Gemini) reveal that the
LaMSUM outperforms state-of-the-art extractive summarization methods. We
further attempt to provide the rationale behind the output summary produced by
LLMs. Overall, this is one of the early attempts to achieve extractive
summarization for large user-generated text by utilizing LLMs, and likely to
generate further interest in the community. | [
0.0456805602,
0.0447526686,
0.0057222852,
0.0375744291,
-0.0342548899,
0.0076722717,
-0.0493910126,
0.0010273946,
0.0072818729,
-0.0392105505,
0.0088288821,
-0.0149188647,
-0.0075112809,
-0.0002040137,
-0.0109911058,
-0.0821219608,
0.0011981609,
-0.0362580381,
0.0009908446,
-0.0061874464,
0.0274671596,
0.0004835953,
0.0449083187,
0.0007490095,
0.0254968498,
0.0187913198,
0.0219034664,
-0.0260046776,
0.014272986,
-0.0158791039,
-0.0264062658,
0.0106163519,
-0.0144550838,
-0.0040794774,
0.0000018812,
-0.0336921811,
-0.0179830566,
-0.0318493843,
0.0177687705,
0.0178155676,
0.0830316767,
0.0251602381,
0.0160845127,
0.0272027235,
-0.0392201543,
0.0163113363,
-0.0114817424,
0.022867946,
0.0928020403,
0.0514000952,
-0.0106938779,
-0.0422338992,
0.0065293266,
0.00305345,
-0.0312081892,
-0.0012994806,
0.0135764852,
0.0320870802,
0.0397372097,
-0.0004035896,
0.0331751555,
0.0332416184,
-0.0004846157,
-0.0225454718,
0.0212092046,
0.0349231213,
-0.033048857,
-0.024843622,
-0.004392562,
0.0845918059,
0.0118017886,
-0.0140096862,
0.0438198559,
0.0261812657,
-0.0016859379,
0.0102860807,
-0.0904731452,
0.0605669543,
-0.004351493,
0.0725979358,
0.0090035917,
0.0395696461,
-0.0192327425,
0.0309744664,
-0.0338995233,
0.0314265154,
0.0130240284,
0.0037357449,
-0.037763048,
0.0209080875,
0.0004228586,
-0.0910077915,
0.0171015188,
0.0618177578,
0.0233485326,
-0.0181175657,
-0.0391944088,
-0.056938801,
0.0402651094,
-0.0666281804,
0.0259976555,
-0.0139639471,
0.0127235362,
0.0794925019,
-0.0289594196,
-0.0072814655,
0.00833108,
0.0069956412,
-0.0458274595,
-0.0091945827,
-0.0157456063,
-0.0025531454,
-0.0045216931,
0.048584532,
-0.0320632979,
-0.0015361902,
-0.0404132977,
0.0367786773,
0.0178539827,
0.008942741,
0.0289107785,
-0.0032989753,
0.0403071754,
-0.0072224615,
-0.0243215803,
0.0160594154,
-0.0310768746,
-0.0187188014,
0.0324282907,
-0.0243246164,
0.0139344223,
0.0328264274,
0.0557167791,
0.0255569257,
0.0266820751,
0.0564655662,
0.0038299435,
-0.0254179519,
-0.0306562819,
-0.0050681378,
0.0040439717,
-0.0384084694,
-0.0252230782,
-0.1107395664,
0.0319395959,
0.017021941,
-0.005885886,
-0.0099556036,
0.0152625917,
0.038273748,
-0.0569167808,
0.0043793423,
-0.0660450161,
0.0350197442,
0.0488889925,
0.0059894081,
0.0186694078,
0.0230785087,
0.0353005156,
0.0842312649,
0.0637098476,
0.0143638514,
0.0306752417,
0.0471439213,
-0.0102897501,
0.014676786,
-0.0101685906,
0.0090087717,
-0.0297188722,
-0.0388313234,
0.0239467192,
0.0798165351,
-0.01220024,
0.0409597829,
0.0839506388,
0.0706687719,
-0.0277732648,
0.0091732033,
0.0017401887,
0.0155916121,
0.0597570688,
0.0275047291,
-0.0079071829,
0.0332152583,
-0.0431196801,
0.0305786841,
0.0816575959,
0.0542450249,
0.0007080889,
-0.0577548556,
-0.021458501,
-0.0214577522,
-0.002348097,
0.0225577205,
0.0374799147,
0.0018423892,
0.0165879335,
0.0438301153,
0.0329780653,
-0.0745733082,
0.0545871072,
-0.0360416956,
0.0506366901,
0.0257992055,
0.0223120861,
-0.0385121703,
0.0253030192,
-0.0046697343,
-0.00380845,
0.0377723202,
-0.0042168014,
-0.0161487311,
-0.047606077,
-0.0168950371,
-0.0194207709,
0.0364243612,
-0.0131150996,
-0.0318300948,
0.0024044148,
-0.0350659713,
0.0130768977,
-0.0085728504,
-0.0717688948,
0.0088491384,
-0.0004656819,
0.0006584519,
0.0098452047,
-0.0349341743,
0.020373892,
0.0302900635,
-0.017659178,
0.029422937,
0.0455033407,
-0.0512003601,
-0.0454812944,
0.0006799379,
-0.0278656594,
-0.0152933318,
0.0624899715,
-0.0337783583,
-0.0027984609,
0.0051778015,
-0.0097281402,
-0.0354171619,
0.0181544442,
-0.0297462754,
0.0179595854,
-0.0539524928,
0.0340310857,
0.0280358456,
-0.025102308,
-0.0704507455,
0.1061503813,
-0.0021602144,
-0.0014935711,
0.0312863179,
-0.0775143877,
-0.0078675235,
0.0115511632,
-0.0159228388,
0.0353065878,
0.0081768772,
0.0208373033,
0.0403907336,
-0.0058941226,
-0.0241285861,
-0.0582996979,
-0.078856878,
-0.0083356947,
-0.011229177,
0.0328749456,
0.0453676917,
0.0186411478,
-0.02747868,
-0.0087567978,
-0.0769601911,
-0.03823689,
0.0544482805,
-0.0004683629,
0.0425262563,
0.0152123589,
0.0398542732,
-0.0822757781,
-0.0122632692,
0.0124478443,
0.0363456719,
-0.0002740655,
-0.0151832355,
-0.0221991297,
0.0231301263,
-0.0383553244,
-0.0388829261,
0.0222355891,
0.0111677684,
-0.0419684686,
-0.06256897,
0.0554725006,
-0.0034293646,
0.0353665203,
0.0165033154,
0.0437092409,
-0.0197784025,
-0.0196478646,
-0.0330483988,
-0.0479273498,
0.0178492814,
0.004926526,
-0.0120727513,
0.0648481846,
0.0500636064,
0.0299119446,
0.0043205335,
0.0024878422,
0.0428972319,
-0.0284552369,
0.0340244919,
-0.045144923,
0.0003673498,
-0.0167192928,
0.0438636839,
-0.0188551079,
-0.0289357379,
0.0423844084,
-0.044626452,
0.0221446715,
-0.0330900736,
-0.0115899025,
-0.0746571869,
0.0203877762,
0.0333211757,
0.0446580239,
-0.0458967462,
0.014119924,
-0.0103060193,
-0.0410525501,
0.0393199213,
-0.0709171221,
0.0970976502,
-0.02995052,
0.0081100101,
-0.0499704294,
-0.0237572789,
-0.0114612253,
-0.0488989018,
-0.0163146779,
0.0218358096,
0.0367078818,
0.0118017271,
-0.0102509446,
-0.0082987882,
0.0306886993,
-0.0045723203,
-0.0139684286,
-0.0247152932,
0.0084052719,
0.1048073098,
0.0589293279,
-0.0088278698,
0.0236097686,
-0.0236490704,
0.010866276,
0.0750446692,
0.0251786504,
0.0003982191,
-0.0000179083,
-0.0195272267,
0.0465791151,
-0.0658220127,
0.0321417302,
-0.0251294281,
0.0409369133,
-0.0134613719,
0.0411952585,
0.1025657728,
0.0446718149,
-0.0501361005,
-0.0240079723,
-0.0185626578,
0.0319968648,
0.0110262586,
0.0213560909,
-0.0669022948,
-0.0003473471,
-0.0002695714,
0.0172131229,
-0.0008167356,
-0.0218259115,
0.0045183189,
-0.1010462195,
0.0361353531,
0.0031823665,
-0.0460235141,
-0.0019266874,
-0.034883704,
-0.0040485566,
-0.0194490273,
-0.0226487089,
0.0410643294,
-0.048055429,
0.0281759296,
0.0032431271,
-0.0801187903,
0.0151256425,
-0.036140535,
-0.0288515724,
0.0138229849,
0.0659302101,
0.0324246921,
-0.0190075245,
0.0134836109,
0.0357600227,
-0.0569866858,
-0.0230664387,
-0.0201863833,
0.0310564172,
-0.0068988129,
-0.0074052815,
-0.0587655827,
0.0402100682,
0.0104749817,
-0.0122398632,
0.0283141118,
0.0537249818,
0.0245111715,
-0.005491863,
-0.035505224,
0.0116432998,
-0.0230936948,
0.0590092838,
0.0642723888,
-0.0220978484,
-0.0355481803,
-0.0424620993,
-0.0491319448,
-0.0298887212,
-0.0651249737,
-0.0242011417,
-0.0262636691,
0.0276049487,
-0.0959795415,
-0.0480490699,
0.0448642783,
-0.0281091649,
-0.0000654907,
0.0128858136,
0.0033452683,
-0.0011025215,
-0.0169380866,
-0.0071256626,
-0.0368611664,
-0.0086663878,
-0.0418861359,
-0.0290494282,
0.0518832281,
-0.035831254,
-0.0146139273,
0.0132296504,
-0.0650266036,
-0.052372098,
-0.0358136483,
0.053910017,
0.0220826007,
-0.0128550408,
0.0096478676,
-0.0346884653,
0.0861787274,
0.0273954757,
0.0040405467,
0.0027260452,
-0.0289055202,
0.0721516237,
0.0123683801,
0.0182978176,
-0.0512613766,
0.0558983758,
-0.0210147835,
0.0378820784,
-0.0633684248,
-0.0466245897,
0.0175946262,
0.0597041957,
0.0011449602,
-0.027981149,
0.0028406538,
-0.0191496294,
-0.0411162004,
-0.0342200808,
-0.0404868908,
-0.029804403,
0.0509706587,
-0.0070502539,
-0.0038344201,
-0.0172312241,
0.06197837,
-0.000256314,
0.0369888432,
-0.0195117425,
0.0175974481,
-0.0115177352,
-0.0427331999,
-0.0278393999,
0.004820962,
-0.0414075218,
-0.0210948493,
-0.0428886674,
0.0016025136,
-0.0238869358,
0.0072296695,
-0.0055679292,
-0.0425937101,
0.0229690727,
0.0632108971,
-0.069089219,
-0.005724072,
-0.0408093296,
0.0248207208,
0.0687011182,
-0.0176490191,
0.0617584921,
0.0208349768,
-0.0266754031,
-0.022518117,
0.0316551924,
0.0247963462,
-0.0051858569,
-0.0327918082,
0.0143348621,
-0.0248203315,
-0.023174759,
0.072174035,
-0.0482544526,
-0.0119260224,
0.0165399946,
-0.0114905471,
-0.0467592105,
-0.0183804277,
-0.0145051638,
-0.0053864624,
-0.0103672668,
-0.0495369062,
-0.0487224907,
-0.0122145107,
0.0366024859,
0.0253935568,
0.0119749019,
-0.0046510883,
0.00991912,
0.0283070188,
0.0159259867,
0.025593698,
-0.0775936022,
-0.0016868238,
-0.0400740393,
0.0077175316,
0.0384535268,
-6.328982073e-33,
-0.0566089489,
-0.041180905,
-0.0173216667,
0.0558512248,
-0.0272481591,
-0.0111080278,
-0.0565337241,
0.017414866,
0.0247019231,
-0.0211197771,
-0.0206253417,
-0.0276659206,
0.0059220456,
0.0418381095,
0.0217281468,
0.0271955933,
0.0062300703,
-0.0090223197,
-0.0230741482,
0.0181694664,
0.0279002469,
0.0003844956,
-0.006579625,
-0.0402188525,
0.0138845379,
-0.0007501064,
-0.0238435995,
0.0080913687,
0.0405981913,
0.0173069164,
-0.0341262855,
0.0066609993,
0.0284084752,
-0.0148052769,
-0.0293337256,
0.0006796971,
-0.05990839,
-0.0015197394,
0.0078384047,
-0.0620341189,
-0.0336630158,
-0.0293214507,
0.0543202087,
-0.0253891982,
0.0040814197,
-0.0115509965,
0.0739129335,
-0.060436625,
-0.0365562141,
-0.0699758679,
-0.0202978905,
0.0407523401,
0.0077622244,
0.0206734892,
0.0156678725,
0.0337435901,
-0.010584279,
0.0644291192,
-0.0313782841,
0.0548180789,
0.0066426904,
0.0323865861,
0.0489354432,
0.0275014285,
0.0200041607,
0.0760768279,
-0.0157973878,
-0.0495120659,
-0.0616965443,
-0.0078448495,
-0.032424733,
0.0407478958,
0.045422148,
0.0366068371,
0.0018549801,
0.0265060235,
-0.028889535,
0.0850371346,
-0.0059399479,
-0.0054801563,
0.0247345679,
-0.0014483799,
0.0047511752,
0.0079709655,
-0.0138860485,
-0.0128216846,
-0.0152318086,
-0.0105998563,
-0.027320683,
0.015944453,
-0.0614794344,
-0.0262999106,
0.0081457011,
-0.0354680084,
-0.0111682201,
-0.0064003668,
-0.0178809781,
0.0388974547,
-0.0109993955,
-0.0353047736,
-0.0331836715,
0.0236527845,
-0.0264380425,
-0.0236240868,
-0.021567896,
0.0238579586,
0.0123102134,
-0.0139065543,
-0.0633017123,
0.0245497003,
-0.0091264872,
0.0152938524,
-0.0326222368,
0.0375780314,
0.0091625759,
-0.0137565965,
0.0170770846,
0.0282559376,
0.0055174422,
0.0321985558,
-0.0146734286,
0.0024033932,
0.0145451352,
-0.0032284637,
-0.013650394,
0.0323166177,
-0.0235492438,
0.0605763085,
0.0180626623,
-0.0145437578,
0.0113484636,
-0.0283809621,
2.419e-7,
0.0482152365,
0.0515141003,
0.0368144959,
-0.0025652882,
-0.0204452612,
0.0190386586,
-0.0254940465,
0.016227005,
0.0168319661,
-0.00657441,
0.0102828965,
0.0468948521,
0.0513931401,
0.0558330603,
-0.1105238348,
0.0127525348,
-0.0728726164,
-0.0712123364,
-0.0228667483,
-0.0480767936,
0.0939229652,
0.0392346606,
-0.0009095619,
-0.0113323638,
-0.0371158533,
-0.0491660088,
0.046063453,
-0.0145600736,
-0.0530020297,
0.0249163918,
0.0730192959,
-0.0059814602,
-0.0220464505,
-0.062807329,
0.0135431904,
-0.0074729128,
0.0617789105,
0.0683917105,
0.0052683526,
-0.0271569807,
0.0284113232,
-0.0462506674,
0.0345957577,
-0.0168280415,
0.0453611836,
-0.0245313346,
-0.0186822321,
-0.0701106414,
-0.0330761299,
-0.0195368957,
-0.0121163577,
-0.020180447,
-0.0174125489,
0.0490875691,
-0.0168505609,
-0.0178564526,
-0.0223518573,
-0.0577586032,
-0.0434598885,
-0.0086734416,
-0.0303195491,
-0.0553359613,
-0.0227711014,
0.0325064883,
-0.0057131331,
-0.0436739177,
0.0088001732,
2.269518448e-34,
0.0656331182,
0.0027331873,
-0.0337458476,
0.0167241078,
0.0192048047,
0.0016675646,
0.0073863673,
0.0042617447,
-0.017138347,
-0.1024825945,
0.0317739546
] |
Subsets and Splits