id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14774v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14774v1 | Evaluating Numerical Reasoning in Text-to-Image Models | 2024-06-20T22:56:31 | 2024-06-20T22:56:31 | Ivana Kajić, Olivia Wiles, Isabela Albuquerque, Matthias Bauer, Su Wang, Jordi Pont-Tuset, Aida Nematzadeh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Text-to-image generative models are capable of producing high-quality images
that often faithfully depict concepts described using natural language. In this
work, we comprehensively evaluate a range of text-to-image models on numerical
reasoning tasks of varying difficulty, and show that even the most advanced
models have only rudimentary numerical skills. Specifically, their ability to
correctly generate an exact number of objects in an image is limited to small
numbers, it is highly dependent on the context the number term appears in, and
it deteriorates quickly with each successive number. We also demonstrate that
models have poor understanding of linguistic quantifiers (such as "a few" or
"as many as"), the concept of zero, and struggle with more advanced concepts
such as partial quantities and fractional representations. We bundle prompts,
generated images and human annotations into GeckoNum, a novel benchmark for
evaluation of numerical reasoning. | [
0.0038501346,
0.0785785764,
0.0056212954,
0.0788986236,
-0.0254564174,
0.0104344878,
0.0314173959,
0.0149672264,
-0.041950658,
-0.0231868308,
-0.0070328801,
-0.0718449131,
0.0329559445,
0.0230486523,
0.0446975939,
-0.0952894911,
-0.0246454105,
-0.0395829268,
-0.0062637571,
-0.0067950157,
0.0053806542,
0.0154358642,
-0.0223854128,
0.0031457052,
-0.0738419294,
-0.0383004807,
0.0151171591,
-0.0111601511,
0.0198129937,
-0.0325210802,
-0.0466548577,
0.0360514112,
0.0429375693,
0.0330013521,
0.0000020731,
-0.0577831417,
0.0158697665,
0.0431582071,
-0.0263300613,
0.0155943856,
0.0607248433,
-0.0642163977,
-0.0145055773,
-0.028440468,
-0.0300666317,
0.0636409596,
0.0532809421,
0.0660996586,
0.0734636486,
0.0591998361,
-0.0076757991,
-0.047348652,
0.0298626404,
0.0002799431,
0.0642107353,
-0.0189544912,
-0.0130437966,
0.0597101673,
0.0308245588,
0.0417324975,
0.0008463492,
0.039701879,
0.0852867663,
-0.0252484605,
0.0224301219,
0.0608348697,
0.0075542787,
-0.0305830892,
0.0013593404,
0.0517729782,
-0.0352131538,
-0.0020224764,
-0.0067930026,
-0.0226233397,
-0.0153776873,
0.0020827188,
-0.042996157,
0.0360348634,
0.0135474987,
0.0150543097,
-0.0669360086,
0.0361825824,
0.0022829107,
-0.0148268761,
0.00797721,
-0.0095864721,
0.0050344206,
0.0327267535,
-0.0269178972,
0.0380178317,
-0.0817449391,
-0.0579848103,
0.0456786007,
0.0335505009,
0.0274894983,
0.0165192429,
-0.0376336239,
-0.0412859246,
-0.0048467764,
-0.0482553244,
0.0453114361,
0.0527230464,
-0.0393958986,
0.0455848686,
-0.0539533719,
0.0399803482,
-0.0031732353,
0.0108303744,
-0.020296324,
0.0258748382,
-0.0108483583,
-0.0237295516,
-0.0382744856,
-0.0083936742,
-0.0339168981,
-0.0384248905,
-0.0287137963,
-0.0299371481,
-0.0011975642,
0.0143825468,
0.033895608,
0.0488057658,
-0.0401838981,
-0.0348381624,
-0.0661029145,
-0.0227970835,
-0.0404658429,
0.0075554401,
0.009511305,
-0.0395766981,
-0.0037719535,
-0.0139507931,
0.0355787948,
-0.0199995041,
-0.0195072982,
0.0492006354,
-0.0616318695,
0.0289267413,
0.0021740044,
-0.0195617825,
-0.025659984,
-0.0627405718,
0.0097203832,
-0.0660524666,
0.0274823457,
-0.0036818571,
-0.0157534666,
-0.0555279441,
0.0293411892,
0.0051419665,
0.0120170349,
0.0651578233,
-0.0155727621,
-0.0096323835,
0.0185993426,
0.0133458562,
0.0028439267,
0.049126137,
0.0559518598,
0.0522536077,
-0.0144629953,
0.0011154828,
0.0226053949,
0.0255043469,
0.0101497211,
-0.0189641025,
-0.0327904709,
-0.0183692258,
-0.0217335727,
0.0518697836,
0.0549610369,
0.0756516755,
-0.031955827,
-0.0393629968,
0.0971815065,
0.0515661836,
-0.005743905,
0.0322820954,
0.0666181669,
-0.0008684804,
0.0244497024,
0.0037048061,
-0.0528070591,
0.0602430254,
0.0104256272,
0.0139680086,
0.0092361942,
0.0214687437,
-0.0004150819,
-0.0659705698,
-0.0104735531,
0.0230364911,
-0.0085989423,
-0.0547359809,
0.0505409129,
0.0270653404,
-0.0183612648,
-0.0019586342,
-0.0357124247,
-0.0346868373,
0.0128861992,
-0.029705232,
0.0374971814,
0.0566480644,
0.0222591329,
0.0046275868,
0.0023689116,
0.0095729986,
0.0208131634,
0.0697220117,
0.0244020205,
0.0256645512,
0.0017747297,
-0.0096610151,
0.006194361,
-0.028190542,
0.0160816945,
0.0122762546,
-0.0006079287,
0.0101453718,
0.0183622651,
-0.0549966283,
0.011495118,
0.038819313,
0.0088204704,
-0.0366553552,
-0.0264309645,
-0.0065859254,
-0.0372998416,
-0.0158845745,
-0.0100845965,
0.0260335784,
-0.0050575561,
-0.0090490691,
-0.0177900624,
-0.0218208358,
-0.0483053662,
-0.0303298403,
0.0302897505,
-0.046564579,
-0.0381281599,
-0.0237261262,
-0.0354826264,
-0.0108064208,
0.0243986901,
-0.0536471307,
0.0190900974,
-0.0406841747,
-0.0175817087,
0.0144451084,
0.006755529,
0.0454706587,
0.0780431628,
-0.0082972655,
0.001185957,
-0.0055676647,
-0.0022261974,
-0.0224167202,
-0.0647849143,
0.0179981366,
-0.0540708266,
-0.0074976473,
0.037314482,
-0.0093299467,
0.0320884958,
-0.048752062,
0.0157822389,
-0.0502759181,
-0.025619071,
-0.0026620412,
0.0163141042,
0.0042262725,
-0.0666218549,
0.0155798988,
-0.018356042,
-0.0333415791,
-0.0002992003,
-0.001626721,
0.0086042797,
0.0533719696,
-0.017915491,
0.0270299092,
-0.0416178405,
0.009927243,
-0.0086063854,
0.0582396016,
0.0687578991,
0.0400967896,
-0.0258184168,
0.0324702039,
-0.0482986197,
-0.0009702301,
0.0074233986,
-0.0128525142,
0.0557897277,
-0.0190848969,
0.0153458472,
0.0468345582,
0.0033874724,
0.0504056439,
-0.0124651613,
-0.0090581356,
-0.0539769679,
-0.0331415869,
-0.0220397674,
-0.0121122226,
0.0216810144,
-0.0434909426,
-0.047877647,
0.0787093416,
-0.00934273,
0.0006541355,
-0.0434808135,
0.0845207796,
-0.0148419989,
-0.0382201411,
-0.0710001886,
0.03928544,
0.033791922,
0.0525910594,
-0.0534939803,
-0.041324947,
0.0400318578,
-0.0307475179,
-0.0008479333,
0.019645825,
0.043102067,
0.0011638314,
0.0623214543,
0.0510480441,
0.0337400399,
0.0335402191,
0.0473862737,
-0.0412510037,
0.0366453528,
0.0256814379,
-0.0018932528,
0.0397790968,
-0.0499900244,
0.0127061931,
-0.0322148986,
-0.0301834568,
-0.0343101397,
-0.0227979291,
0.0127909267,
0.0428843386,
-0.0236357283,
-0.0218772758,
-0.0313915163,
0.0085954899,
0.0511326864,
0.0295910463,
-0.0109161558,
-0.0521660857,
-0.0328825824,
0.05027714,
0.0487280264,
0.0127235251,
0.0162106995,
-0.0454181246,
0.0191914029,
0.0440507941,
0.010222258,
0.0204274599,
-0.076485239,
0.0222289748,
-0.030770408,
0.0302822795,
-0.0087281279,
0.0553903542,
0.0802020654,
-0.0732111037,
-0.0177445002,
0.0565421693,
0.0196725298,
0.0338634849,
-0.0001106027,
-0.0211797282,
0.0156355761,
0.0005887391,
0.0191299133,
-0.0815845728,
-0.0141296526,
0.0096314671,
-0.0356579684,
0.0054677674,
-0.0377650335,
-0.0159837175,
-0.1102326661,
0.0702866018,
0.0072404901,
-0.0500326194,
-0.001713867,
-0.0225015916,
0.0192641914,
0.0081576426,
-0.0305752791,
0.0013742937,
-0.000430496,
0.0429935828,
0.0224584565,
0.0422661752,
-0.0208061505,
0.0220780112,
0.0057273339,
-0.0099927317,
0.0041634161,
0.0452936552,
0.0132875172,
-0.0578017347,
-0.0173625033,
0.0541208945,
-0.0092633786,
0.032879971,
0.0412423909,
0.0540493689,
-0.0140605476,
0.0009602374,
0.0417556129,
-0.0154445414,
-0.0217623077,
-0.038453687,
0.0447161123,
0.0139309894,
-0.0411827378,
-0.0326642133,
0.0074271727,
-0.0135776307,
0.0291511659,
0.0479876697,
-0.0097300969,
-0.0632148683,
-0.0584556721,
0.0356981196,
-0.0688789263,
-0.0583659485,
-0.0037440145,
0.0160985105,
-0.0617728047,
-0.0821035057,
-0.0041858032,
0.0168731585,
0.0438993014,
-0.0094420267,
-0.0851434171,
0.0211528018,
-0.0079900604,
0.0158227477,
0.0458168685,
-0.0449709482,
0.0382280238,
-0.0272699129,
0.0114665255,
0.0034829159,
-0.0641078129,
-0.0462347269,
0.0116432086,
-0.0797507465,
-0.0176982097,
-0.0318157487,
0.0713215172,
0.0224445388,
-0.0453045033,
-0.001291335,
-0.0406887159,
0.0222771335,
0.0618954264,
-0.0345805585,
-0.0054507297,
-0.0286029093,
0.0439730287,
0.0097959312,
0.0114389407,
-0.0151277101,
0.0679298788,
0.0179777909,
0.033158239,
-0.0730546638,
-0.0153066497,
0.0066017974,
-0.0062999418,
0.0066502728,
-0.0009635626,
0.0240540933,
-0.0205635149,
-0.0166114159,
-0.0262947381,
-0.014113416,
-0.0677828565,
-0.0077417726,
0.0223641805,
0.0476776734,
-0.0122179408,
-0.0220643301,
0.0373142175,
0.0648614094,
-0.0180415567,
-0.0399705842,
0.0682458133,
0.0025394941,
0.0003989618,
-0.011782554,
-0.0043222504,
0.0018832544,
-0.0660346299,
0.0766739473,
0.0067579988,
0.0600270964,
0.0076684128,
-0.0102677345,
-0.0322538912,
0.0004538713,
-0.0260218158,
-0.0487919264,
-0.0521108881,
0.0318985768,
0.0285176709,
0.0125306388,
0.0209346134,
-0.0584679283,
0.0002849015,
0.0010357499,
0.0302113183,
0.0278566442,
-0.0320460089,
0.0170072261,
0.0219047777,
0.0283209514,
-0.0657802224,
0.0216423273,
-0.0258395094,
0.0134000247,
-0.0146625731,
-0.0164525714,
0.0135953445,
-0.0413643681,
0.0027491059,
-0.034317717,
0.0530862547,
0.0179275442,
-0.0364819542,
-0.0907688141,
-0.0098301182,
0.0770151839,
-0.013224449,
0.007670539,
0.0460943468,
0.0068533607,
-0.0304370243,
0.0100603448,
0.0079167541,
0.0247550793,
-0.0202146098,
0.0083955759,
-0.0365825482,
-5.941430402e-33,
-0.0489688553,
-0.0732745752,
0.0237985775,
-0.0210761428,
0.0080600921,
-0.0188283734,
-0.0499637164,
0.0187563989,
0.0176893976,
0.023743242,
0.0000286912,
-0.0241600592,
0.0158047434,
0.0226221979,
0.0004652185,
0.0200076438,
0.0325513072,
-0.0352282673,
-0.0434663482,
-0.0085257944,
0.035465885,
-0.0061726505,
0.033042524,
-0.0616153963,
0.0280631334,
0.0334656723,
-0.0316897705,
-0.002588491,
0.0035978751,
0.0294478163,
-0.0311483294,
0.0147409718,
0.0058921399,
-0.0583682396,
-0.0361025445,
0.0114155896,
-0.0350792855,
-0.0360497534,
-0.0040573389,
0.001169119,
-0.0502423644,
-0.0082811117,
0.0403504893,
-0.0482288674,
0.0008961428,
-0.0429004095,
0.0644094795,
-0.0333932638,
0.0176997893,
-0.0150437346,
-0.0701854154,
0.0057519847,
-0.0352742746,
-0.0307537299,
0.0171849076,
0.0215028208,
-0.0063338047,
0.0107869869,
-0.0690163746,
0.0155039318,
0.0423995666,
0.0014314925,
0.0649387911,
-0.0056926133,
0.0008557648,
0.0350713246,
0.0457096845,
-0.0411073901,
-0.0741831213,
0.0148030473,
0.0046884553,
0.0542434976,
0.086530298,
0.0637007281,
0.0903808102,
0.0331949703,
-0.0273807384,
0.0340613164,
-0.0636584833,
0.0309623703,
0.0395707451,
0.0148833506,
-0.0075229374,
0.0091906805,
-0.0330113843,
-0.0113849631,
-0.0518896393,
-0.0354199968,
0.022773046,
-0.0196498875,
0.0034647186,
0.0276194569,
0.0230891928,
-0.0024550757,
-0.0392518006,
-0.0462297387,
-0.007479534,
0.0651816949,
-0.0001162896,
0.0204537325,
-0.041835092,
-0.0233781897,
0.0470044985,
0.0406423844,
0.0177152548,
0.0105634853,
0.0432599448,
0.0020820939,
-0.0215449538,
0.00030808,
-0.0563656241,
0.0051706377,
0.0149552608,
0.0486945324,
0.0106558073,
-0.0272402614,
-0.0534015186,
-0.0198757593,
-0.0445374735,
-0.0211993344,
-0.0272332206,
0.0078879576,
-0.0199677125,
-0.0177260153,
-0.0342074931,
0.0084839594,
-0.0455727018,
0.004656624,
0.0305863172,
-0.0434445478,
-0.0092379805,
0.0468977876,
2.659e-7,
0.0366544202,
0.0135581009,
-0.0051347092,
-0.00780433,
0.0162983742,
0.0408272333,
-0.0330021456,
0.0051175891,
0.0159253497,
-0.0667190254,
-0.0050002215,
0.0842429101,
0.0517109558,
0.049209509,
0.0207263418,
0.0305819232,
-0.0441184007,
0.0069433646,
-0.0162805263,
0.0155929737,
0.0390299708,
0.0344750658,
-0.0069411136,
-0.0122105125,
0.0483536869,
-0.0424239561,
0.0845437273,
-0.0265053976,
0.0303790942,
0.0026847944,
0.0149738751,
0.003298945,
-0.000763477,
-0.0080492962,
0.0055779805,
-0.0155536365,
0.0775492191,
0.0553542413,
-0.030250391,
0.0047080573,
-0.0229093637,
-0.0303949323,
-0.0132953273,
-0.0629157126,
0.0576011464,
-0.0629832894,
-0.0007056032,
0.0138149876,
0.0036059916,
-0.0070315781,
0.0088676708,
-0.0292256139,
-0.0186307319,
-0.0098404726,
0.04579762,
-0.0160030704,
-0.038735345,
-0.0187196117,
-0.0579398274,
-0.0027724353,
-0.0545294955,
-0.0499682724,
-0.0699514598,
0.0261662602,
0.0141715165,
0.0175435711,
-0.0558886454,
1.804868376e-34,
0.0149019966,
0.0111048054,
0.0069702147,
-0.0021763665,
0.039210096,
0.0171860922,
-0.0197457299,
0.0041513056,
0.0075511807,
-0.0452234708,
-0.0202558544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14765v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14765v1 | ChatGPT as Research Scientist: Probing GPT's Capabilities as a Research Librarian, Research Ethicist, Data Generator and Data Predictor | 2024-06-20T22:30:06 | 2024-06-20T22:30:06 | Steven A. Lehr, Aylin Caliskan, Suneragiri Liyanage, Mahzarin R. Banaji | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.IR, cs.LG, I.2.7; K.4.0; K.4.1; K.4.2 | How good a research scientist is ChatGPT? We systematically probed the
capabilities of GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 across four central components of the
scientific process: as a Research Librarian, Research Ethicist, Data Generator,
and Novel Data Predictor, using psychological science as a testing field. In
Study 1 (Research Librarian), unlike human researchers, GPT-3.5 and GPT-4
hallucinated, authoritatively generating fictional references 36.0% and 5.4% of
the time, respectively, although GPT-4 exhibited an evolving capacity to
acknowledge its fictions. In Study 2 (Research Ethicist), GPT-4 (though not
GPT-3.5) proved capable of detecting violations like p-hacking in fictional
research protocols, correcting 88.6% of blatantly presented issues, and 72.6%
of subtly presented issues. In Study 3 (Data Generator), both models
consistently replicated patterns of cultural bias previously discovered in
large language corpora, indicating that ChatGPT can simulate known results, an
antecedent to usefulness for both data generation and skills like hypothesis
generation. Contrastingly, in Study 4 (Novel Data Predictor), neither model was
successful at predicting new results absent in their training data, and neither
appeared to leverage substantially new information when predicting more versus
less novel outcomes. Together, these results suggest that GPT is a flawed but
rapidly improving librarian, a decent research ethicist already, capable of
data generation in simple domains with known characteristics but poor at
predicting novel patterns of empirical data to aid future experimentation. | [
0.0770865753,
0.0650535524,
-0.0312164035,
0.0064555062,
-0.0734699368,
0.009325102,
0.0287859961,
0.0054291571,
0.027733678,
-0.0020384283,
-0.0100987796,
0.0252463222,
0.0089760842,
0.0041985032,
0.0241173953,
-0.00172277,
-0.0060871607,
0.0465097874,
0.0717906505,
-0.0078368634,
0.0014209335,
0.0548294038,
0.0175279733,
0.0206092838,
0.0317500345,
-0.0418496542,
0.0308954492,
-0.0159856025,
0.0161526408,
-0.0539803579,
0.0518461652,
0.0475927331,
-0.0046443227,
0.0756543428,
0.00000226,
-0.0294879284,
-0.006776196,
0.0395988896,
0.0167599134,
0.0212522596,
0.0648428425,
0.032735344,
0.0095432019,
0.0031426314,
-0.0587846227,
-0.0218189508,
0.0319180079,
0.0114974044,
-0.0499481671,
0.0347087458,
0.0139067871,
0.0054083271,
0.0000526536,
0.0112244189,
0.0444449559,
0.0415291078,
0.0228478424,
0.0598875247,
0.0159873758,
0.063764669,
0.0035475346,
0.0209659059,
-0.0026595232,
0.0050284332,
-0.018562194,
0.0240782686,
-0.0771357417,
-0.0178204868,
0.0602772869,
0.0201442856,
0.0675740167,
-0.0254917685,
0.0141240405,
0.0362743139,
0.0058340761,
0.0660238042,
-0.017780859,
0.0119037917,
-0.0605384484,
-0.0360302217,
0.0298422128,
-0.0042906096,
0.0442451239,
0.0432834886,
0.0425068848,
0.0311150532,
-0.0207925029,
-0.0331756733,
0.0012776493,
0.0137772895,
0.0344145484,
-0.0472768322,
-0.0192692447,
-0.026399266,
0.0247428417,
0.0097760437,
0.0369638726,
0.0480007753,
0.0515830368,
0.0076403907,
-0.0329635888,
0.0473321378,
-0.0032157055,
-0.0080670835,
0.037147712,
-0.0057478407,
-0.044951532,
0.0650887042,
0.0102237975,
0.0203319043,
-0.0597149841,
-0.0475017726,
0.0280502401,
-0.0178636704,
0.0281286966,
0.0111919418,
-0.0256950147,
-0.0282744691,
-0.0004902473,
-0.0049278443,
-0.061355643,
0.0155317141,
-0.0550105087,
0.0018733011,
-0.0456088074,
0.011594126,
-0.0275252871,
0.0243131313,
-0.0178147759,
-0.0221252125,
-0.0172870792,
-0.0214784201,
-0.0188902598,
-0.018232109,
0.060892161,
0.013097981,
0.0212023444,
-0.0065494687,
-0.0167532973,
-0.0284768585,
0.0062809247,
-0.0790981054,
0.0794148743,
-0.0308777615,
0.0305855721,
0.035613887,
-0.0088255135,
-0.0314437933,
-0.0115522565,
0.0182700492,
-0.0077991462,
0.0477107167,
-0.0401704945,
-0.0016018441,
0.0431272723,
0.0640734136,
-0.0814830214,
0.0034451082,
0.0228858367,
-0.0024254243,
0.018765619,
-0.0039997101,
0.0325408876,
-0.013009185,
-0.0171025936,
0.0344190784,
0.0550384857,
0.0174447298,
-0.0131798266,
0.0360769592,
0.0082719773,
0.0249927621,
-0.0899281129,
0.0344539881,
0.0402477086,
0.081437476,
0.001760043,
0.1014812663,
0.0085213482,
0.0066346833,
0.0396904908,
0.0013258114,
-0.0347660445,
0.0234186295,
-0.0077439626,
0.0008857157,
-0.0541326553,
0.0357723162,
-0.0181606598,
0.0205430295,
0.0151907075,
0.0463016927,
0.0156626962,
0.0015294566,
-0.0414233357,
0.0031423555,
-0.013254975,
-0.0566736087,
0.009880282,
0.0184456762,
-0.0151363006,
-0.0086054876,
0.0019103246,
0.0428598858,
0.0564644597,
-0.0131992418,
-0.0018527511,
-0.0640836507,
0.0121248476,
0.0402221754,
0.0284486562,
0.0048997584,
-0.0329944007,
-0.0049125124,
-0.0078876093,
-0.050897792,
-0.0172534268,
0.0497564822,
-0.0111997854,
0.068127647,
-0.0189721324,
-0.0441298224,
-0.0113847684,
0.0087904362,
-0.0943448842,
0.0311704446,
-0.0271704774,
-0.0630740672,
0.033168938,
0.0134720374,
-0.0279472489,
0.0166871417,
-0.0121556371,
0.0117339119,
0.0011515568,
0.0601992831,
-0.0029809475,
0.0338596217,
-0.0095131239,
-0.1102377698,
-0.0009957706,
0.0136016421,
0.0139303515,
0.0425436161,
0.0042686267,
-0.0006545851,
0.0446461625,
-0.0389133804,
-0.043904867,
-0.0763795823,
0.0073037166,
0.0058181537,
0.0117188348,
0.0109938625,
0.0431904085,
0.0249459893,
-0.0169082694,
0.0449039675,
0.0100568142,
-0.0206705984,
0.0455898903,
0.0320023596,
-0.006053247,
0.0564700365,
-0.0224205349,
-0.036224179,
-0.0194713529,
-0.0235569309,
0.0150156803,
-0.013973332,
0.0067436192,
0.010382453,
-0.0712158754,
-0.05428553,
0.0315061212,
-0.0203290097,
-0.0486508943,
0.0138330767,
0.0315325633,
0.0214276519,
-0.00081703,
0.009128402,
-0.0216300935,
0.0020200575,
-0.0092716096,
0.0131183872,
0.0615399033,
0.0012716247,
-0.0473982207,
-0.035804648,
-0.0339758918,
-0.0364432521,
-0.0385538712,
-0.0111455005,
0.054917872,
0.0195767973,
0.0011969686,
-0.0311748199,
0.0097760642,
0.0173123777,
0.0441570319,
-0.0131739536,
-0.0127785979,
-0.0254090838,
-0.0083991857,
0.0068362756,
0.0186756179,
-0.064494431,
-0.0261017792,
-0.0448754318,
0.0183796957,
0.0122637702,
-0.0236026328,
0.0735225677,
-0.0078677582,
-0.0485023782,
0.0259447359,
-0.0516203567,
-0.0054401509,
0.0500984937,
-0.010652517,
-0.0290204473,
0.0243447758,
-0.0251123924,
-0.0091495384,
-0.0819067731,
0.0215141196,
0.0034602508,
0.058438614,
-0.0078056422,
0.0096369972,
0.0876834095,
0.0141549325,
-0.0444280915,
0.0191879962,
0.0453693569,
-0.0292551238,
-0.042001456,
-0.0087624332,
-0.0108451499,
0.000285708,
0.0051915869,
-0.0382235423,
-0.0201427117,
-0.0044581569,
-0.0071152179,
0.0349229462,
-0.0225997753,
-0.0490535162,
-0.0442928709,
0.0991672128,
0.0262883175,
-0.0013193927,
-0.0431158543,
0.0262864158,
-0.0801307634,
0.0166354924,
-0.0573425218,
0.0413340405,
0.0029261063,
-0.0245306324,
0.0359074734,
-0.0364279002,
-0.0194362104,
-0.0203376431,
-0.0032433555,
0.0007830273,
0.0082623102,
-0.0480650291,
-0.0065530967,
0.0202284362,
-0.0032327566,
0.0099797202,
0.0811116248,
-0.0039702603,
-0.0582787544,
-0.0145691754,
-0.0329632685,
0.0077285524,
0.0126765482,
0.0149678532,
-0.0947677866,
0.054297518,
-0.0179510005,
0.0343751274,
-0.104660213,
-0.0931831375,
-0.048958648,
-0.0482497104,
0.0643754601,
0.0119459657,
0.001036736,
0.0019269957,
-0.0408677794,
-0.0114832213,
-0.0047317152,
0.0014190871,
0.0006332247,
0.0105334204,
0.01723608,
-0.0105081564,
-0.0582326204,
-0.0018821468,
0.0545653366,
-0.0151915196,
0.0227191932,
0.0177055188,
0.0525851212,
-0.0322296508,
0.0025219279,
-0.0752860978,
0.0109725287,
-0.0170634892,
0.023579035,
0.005534796,
-0.015905872,
0.0329211652,
-0.0440350398,
0.0424655974,
-0.0307036825,
-0.0173374955,
0.0173420943,
0.0788603351,
0.0011703525,
-0.0388145298,
-0.0446876287,
0.0145719657,
0.0119907344,
0.0473599806,
-0.0338616557,
0.0018082154,
0.0017712333,
0.0058057928,
0.0322466977,
0.0555525571,
-0.0308932364,
-0.0296088737,
-0.0131648649,
0.0595722161,
-0.0282585025,
-0.0970587209,
-0.0240533743,
-0.0183952283,
-0.0046944157,
0.0022160006,
-0.0081067663,
-0.0394309647,
-0.0193823446,
0.0025760154,
0.0048816791,
-0.0055909576,
0.0614736006,
-0.0088370647,
0.0237323437,
-0.0227069259,
0.0251011401,
0.0017343879,
0.0486669056,
-0.0140144592,
-0.0012971378,
0.0150852101,
0.0307601858,
0.0169096291,
0.0341032408,
0.0152719682,
-0.0000329516,
0.0796867758,
-0.0385223292,
0.0021208499,
-0.0317157768,
0.0067046499,
-0.0060629151,
-0.0460171141,
0.0052922238,
0.0099690864,
-0.0017321978,
-0.0298449714,
-0.0450010858,
-0.0006518272,
0.0503003411,
0.0054894835,
0.0172604769,
-0.0717472062,
0.0309112482,
-0.0215160288,
-0.0731308237,
-0.0293227471,
0.0121261757,
0.0027897884,
-0.0231460985,
0.0487485193,
0.005964011,
-0.0141909206,
-0.0203328896,
-0.0680573657,
0.042707216,
-0.0541791953,
0.023780169,
0.0429126024,
0.0457815751,
0.0162778609,
-0.0129679432,
-0.0489206873,
-0.0297868866,
-0.0308341011,
0.0646140724,
0.0104217073,
0.0702454746,
0.0186103992,
-0.0254497062,
0.0274144281,
0.0124574751,
-0.0999670923,
-0.0712765455,
-0.0100742225,
0.022841379,
-0.0247460008,
0.023418339,
0.0110158809,
-0.0625415668,
0.0102694118,
-0.0283848885,
0.0106638325,
-0.0149674425,
0.0014867857,
0.0054526683,
0.0232478399,
-0.0636080131,
-0.0136878332,
0.0302884001,
0.013067076,
0.0384951271,
-0.0126331635,
-0.0539514795,
0.0021886451,
-0.0665373057,
-0.0362630449,
0.0194141902,
0.033091899,
-0.0210593678,
-0.0840092152,
-0.0281225815,
-0.0036905888,
-0.0087615242,
0.0183244143,
-0.0531740375,
-0.0452719443,
0.0607329048,
-0.0245013125,
-0.0210012738,
-0.0066684093,
0.0381977037,
-0.0380181335,
-0.0290068649,
-0.0201656725,
-6.326736879e-33,
0.0543485507,
-0.039393276,
0.0473051667,
0.0095409835,
-0.0420767963,
-0.0135367252,
-0.0151560577,
-0.0014369839,
-0.0467992909,
0.023037849,
-0.068901822,
-0.0155819012,
0.0043781358,
-0.057196375,
0.0109582599,
0.0061840676,
0.0207771696,
0.01465776,
-0.0360327885,
0.0075541446,
0.01024599,
-0.0068642162,
0.0480341576,
-0.069577001,
0.0514292791,
-0.0700891688,
-0.0017240117,
-0.036581099,
0.0078855818,
0.004620641,
-0.0221943408,
0.0193007477,
0.0156058604,
-0.062013723,
-0.007329063,
-0.0115244826,
-0.0166162178,
-0.0027929898,
0.0292819701,
-0.027812399,
0.0514040291,
0.017913606,
-0.0019723321,
-0.0225936025,
-0.0324222594,
-0.0353903323,
0.0192577019,
-0.0033085456,
0.0048305439,
-0.0112210568,
-0.0529543199,
-0.0021382202,
-0.0058672661,
0.0371233001,
-0.0280458108,
0.0465601124,
-0.0230868459,
-0.0182794202,
-0.0434947647,
0.0058789756,
-0.0015834273,
-0.041212298,
0.0087395618,
-0.01749653,
-0.0004978305,
0.0778740197,
0.0472395942,
0.0673195571,
0.0225696694,
-0.0202724282,
0.0207460802,
-0.0050242878,
0.0178701729,
0.1265631169,
0.015319882,
-0.0276661627,
-0.016369313,
-0.0193447284,
0.0646543279,
-0.0106358435,
0.0463173762,
-0.012073732,
-0.013714633,
-0.065677017,
0.0211429764,
-0.0146798473,
0.0091227423,
-0.0518690757,
0.0076120133,
-0.0332091339,
-0.0072923349,
0.0405541882,
0.0334249213,
-0.0077396953,
0.0197658781,
0.025433775,
-0.0870203078,
0.0179042537,
-0.0046417466,
0.0100606196,
-0.0915207341,
0.0212891418,
-0.009784908,
0.0519537516,
0.0409597456,
0.0314746797,
0.0038566589,
0.0218678061,
-0.0199418664,
-0.025100328,
-0.0095586916,
0.0523992851,
0.0448076949,
-0.0712055638,
0.0032633962,
0.0101621859,
0.0168135557,
-0.0522616468,
0.059527982,
0.0473275632,
-0.0368675403,
0.0342003591,
-0.0367969349,
0.0058026365,
0.0048834179,
-0.0068675354,
0.0061334255,
0.0169768613,
0.0316189602,
-0.0687452033,
-0.0058435109,
-0.0521398894,
3.17e-7,
0.0203942452,
0.0124388831,
0.0013018703,
-0.0066575059,
0.0185983703,
0.0116229281,
0.0086618355,
0.0467135608,
0.070315443,
-0.0585576259,
0.0358306468,
-0.0210655369,
-0.0206914339,
0.0775013417,
-0.0631001666,
-0.084388122,
-0.0349918976,
-0.0610058904,
-0.0349961668,
0.0048397984,
-0.0137850717,
-0.0591864102,
0.0287281126,
-0.0243896767,
-0.035367053,
-0.0366622508,
0.0470708087,
-0.0361337103,
0.0308666807,
0.0257909875,
0.0289764423,
0.0287463069,
0.0176712256,
0.0476395339,
0.0168248713,
-0.0263711736,
0.0121417334,
-0.0006309689,
0.0126771135,
0.024350971,
0.0246853568,
-0.0010383287,
-0.0217490885,
-0.0817156583,
0.0213299822,
-0.0200016294,
-0.0370965153,
0.0326018408,
-0.0482850596,
-0.0307684578,
0.0319137536,
-0.0278862156,
-0.0121800257,
0.0412608869,
-0.0225435868,
0.0478219651,
0.0023708534,
-0.0149907041,
0.0383632816,
0.0012616417,
-0.0423027761,
-0.0800221115,
-0.0121705849,
-0.0201348756,
0.0021927906,
-0.0572948605,
0.0454031564,
3.047742086e-34,
0.0291551221,
-0.0179442931,
0.0073378873,
-0.0226229895,
0.0427049249,
0.048698362,
0.0917356089,
0.0066360938,
0.0210685488,
0.0176740941,
-0.0264231209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14764v1 | RE-AdaptIR: Improving Information Retrieval through Reverse Engineered Adaptation | 2024-06-20T22:28:11 | 2024-06-20T22:28:11 | William Fleshman, Benjamin Van Durme | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) fine-tuned for text-retrieval have demonstrated
state-of-the-art results across several information retrieval (IR) benchmarks.
However, supervised training for improving these models requires numerous
labeled examples, which are generally unavailable or expensive to acquire. In
this work, we explore the effectiveness of extending reverse engineered
adaptation to the context of information retrieval (RE-AdaptIR). We use
RE-AdaptIR to improve LLM-based IR models using only unlabeled data. We
demonstrate improved performance both in training domains as well as zero-shot
in domains where the models have seen no queries. We analyze performance
changes in various fine-tuning scenarios and offer findings of immediate use to
practitioners. | [
0.0764137879,
0.0125377802,
-0.000388446,
0.0095073571,
-0.0002815764,
0.0214324649,
-0.0123692434,
0.0420637652,
0.0191909987,
-0.0719082728,
-0.0733010024,
-0.0032471523,
-0.0562826954,
-0.017739065,
-0.0030999519,
0.0234246701,
0.0442236066,
-0.011132584,
-0.016987199,
0.0218356457,
-0.0122516137,
0.03274085,
0.0491450056,
-0.0194666963,
0.065305613,
0.0423476808,
0.0025661089,
0.0507793501,
-0.0112786051,
-0.009006137,
0.0539251715,
0.0150086079,
0.0369480811,
0.0447768345,
0.0000016052,
-0.053714186,
-0.0409157537,
-0.0061552869,
-0.0279690623,
0.0346818455,
0.0602498241,
-0.0153624332,
0.0435957648,
0.0353786089,
-0.0189741068,
-0.039334029,
-0.0055268235,
0.0489897095,
0.0388290659,
0.0965995416,
0.0004000884,
-0.0281279162,
0.0232702214,
-0.041120179,
0.0347674303,
-0.058538314,
0.0585205257,
-0.0023719335,
0.0112562086,
0.0382187441,
0.0095688635,
0.0289493073,
-0.0529366471,
0.0110127237,
0.0428752303,
-0.02289089,
-0.0561032183,
0.0283555258,
0.0148196733,
0.0449880175,
-0.0207692273,
-0.0386912785,
-0.0033767021,
0.0085772043,
-0.0100538852,
0.0121275056,
-0.0251570474,
-0.0502428152,
-0.008585141,
0.0164928623,
-0.0126394797,
-0.0423661433,
0.026426401,
0.0215867832,
-0.0608122237,
0.0731122419,
0.0104371412,
-0.0456629768,
0.0111979553,
-0.0181982405,
-0.0012426116,
0.033743199,
0.0187691543,
0.0180956088,
0.0131133171,
0.0000960403,
0.0057250541,
-0.0552939586,
0.0184391681,
-0.0314159878,
0.0281475931,
0.03104854,
-0.0036753567,
0.0690454692,
-0.0438395552,
0.0314231664,
-0.0258597974,
0.0164180901,
-0.0626468956,
-0.0068078889,
-0.0651196688,
-0.0145009365,
-0.0481600501,
0.0377353281,
-0.0418188311,
-0.0121243391,
0.0055063665,
0.0564389639,
0.0341144204,
-0.0536065996,
0.0198498853,
-0.0170619395,
-0.067428574,
-0.0263848733,
-0.031576179,
0.0508468673,
0.0260621049,
0.0079188198,
-0.0239226036,
-0.0331085734,
0.0124787558,
-0.0141392881,
0.0288795419,
-0.0521701463,
0.0335489027,
0.0209378228,
-0.0233161729,
-0.0655255541,
-0.0375426933,
0.0150324758,
0.0120445397,
0.0010966598,
0.0068959631,
-0.0194644071,
-0.0005326576,
-0.0083112521,
0.0036316458,
-0.045791924,
-0.0062095909,
0.0193638895,
-0.0583229288,
0.0836745575,
-0.0111998394,
0.018956041,
0.0403176211,
-0.0198546723,
0.05589246,
0.0524767078,
-0.0255179033,
0.0124647897,
0.0437346138,
-0.0124162016,
0.0140509037,
0.0144232027,
0.0121918339,
0.0363289304,
-0.0171930417,
0.0338066891,
-0.006755779,
0.0152333295,
0.0296309404,
0.00713932,
-0.0142520815,
-0.0007420784,
0.0112327067,
0.0246827826,
0.0605895221,
0.0186074376,
-0.0124603165,
0.0188944265,
-0.0473944321,
-0.0128751518,
-0.0282489378,
0.0101550985,
-0.0794499815,
0.007100123,
0.0362081677,
-0.0049611512,
-0.0393829346,
-0.034235321,
-0.0262862202,
0.0422913618,
-0.0274823364,
0.0076809493,
0.0641537383,
0.0138021624,
-0.0072701406,
0.0080261286,
0.019775657,
-0.0311662164,
0.0308588352,
-0.0620866604,
0.0180328321,
0.0803466514,
0.0771484226,
-0.0802153572,
0.0114588225,
0.0034412604,
0.0206518173,
0.0015868909,
0.0267506707,
-0.0082835788,
-0.0010451386,
-0.0540357865,
-0.0445359312,
0.032295689,
0.0224960167,
0.008027398,
0.0134873558,
-0.0016226984,
0.0455733687,
-0.0751409978,
-0.0233901236,
0.0367310271,
-0.0488606058,
-0.0833493024,
0.0343975984,
-0.0154079674,
0.0047177053,
-0.0289530028,
-0.0213582665,
-0.0039798957,
0.0662295595,
0.0038501024,
-0.0231854375,
-0.0522592776,
0.0116350725,
-0.0053758677,
0.0204319004,
0.0137043921,
0.0667364076,
0.0446460992,
-0.0211983975,
-0.0207155552,
-0.0041117454,
0.0191750694,
0.0713830516,
-0.034742143,
0.038091328,
-0.0055454657,
0.0065966863,
-0.0834336504,
0.0222493969,
0.0355974101,
0.0268047601,
-0.0108277528,
-0.0402391963,
-0.0128693189,
-0.0305210017,
-0.0370978899,
0.0106387986,
-0.0129099367,
0.0220123697,
0.0185616706,
0.0006105466,
-0.0393634774,
0.0016467706,
-0.0943968222,
0.0171127357,
-0.0383598879,
0.0022557839,
0.0047029196,
0.0471102893,
0.0005415891,
-0.0313614234,
-0.0024728109,
-0.0108914338,
-0.0100962901,
0.0344649777,
0.0140159586,
0.0045812349,
0.0099831345,
-0.0498109125,
-0.047301244,
0.0150886467,
0.038920261,
-0.0524932332,
-0.02648299,
-0.0438290425,
0.0151834553,
-0.0357994772,
0.0346041806,
-0.0194784775,
-0.0009583794,
-0.0483715907,
-0.0731622279,
-0.0164147634,
0.0623995177,
0.0206706058,
-0.0202723574,
0.0129382266,
0.0281450339,
-0.0968396664,
0.0292348769,
-0.0341225341,
-0.0670360327,
-0.0187052265,
-0.0380917713,
0.0188910775,
0.0011898261,
-0.0188247971,
0.0112712597,
-0.0369354151,
0.0098591344,
0.0152130332,
-0.0007318459,
-0.0732884333,
0.0310717691,
0.0208773538,
0.0379347801,
-0.0202987455,
-0.0297616553,
0.0351787694,
0.0179939847,
0.0055825957,
-0.043621704,
-0.0253410693,
-0.0641388148,
0.05666795,
-0.0182600841,
0.017151868,
0.0114151519,
0.0231943782,
0.008357604,
-0.0195976291,
-0.0030754644,
-0.0367542654,
0.0591663793,
-0.0004424733,
0.0507269576,
-0.0032405346,
-0.0439945832,
-0.00980388,
-0.0511338264,
-0.0031082383,
-0.0154883452,
0.0025044132,
-0.0033234835,
-0.0749671981,
0.0517850257,
0.033583194,
0.0478660278,
0.0027496431,
-0.0421668515,
0.0027253081,
-0.0024480911,
0.0480790101,
-0.0173435844,
-0.044051718,
0.0220251717,
0.0029314123,
-0.0001330874,
0.04272037,
-0.029290976,
-0.0094654774,
-0.0053094998,
0.0697473884,
-0.0363520682,
-0.0132768946,
-0.016434662,
0.000692067,
-0.0009600767,
-0.0498689897,
0.0797282308,
0.0263303332,
-0.0594638996,
-0.0384523198,
-0.0568322726,
0.0292187668,
0.0380513184,
0.0695708171,
-0.0229777489,
-0.0437484942,
0.0207474213,
0.0590077825,
0.0107368017,
-0.0052850274,
0.0135740796,
-0.124843061,
0.0257931799,
0.0157766826,
-0.0370245166,
-0.0487975366,
-0.0597616844,
0.020964032,
-0.039152097,
0.0007301638,
0.058253672,
-0.0475276671,
-0.0122507764,
0.0308077354,
-0.0109643983,
-0.0621421225,
-0.0285047423,
0.000761072,
0.0267115515,
0.0445588194,
-0.0151491193,
0.0138125001,
-0.0006114297,
0.0413264073,
-0.0315518901,
0.0266109426,
-0.0408877879,
0.0517356917,
-0.0374113321,
0.0119891018,
0.0146697909,
-0.0174756441,
-0.0399545282,
0.0273136627,
0.008915551,
0.0350788943,
-0.0190614443,
0.0060289833,
-0.0357114784,
-0.0853939503,
-0.0291507822,
0.0629315302,
-0.0064423149,
-0.009188775,
-0.0031367636,
-0.0111517077,
-0.0151647413,
0.0051809745,
-0.0322194025,
0.0088570062,
-0.04010446,
0.0005617717,
-0.0330256745,
-0.0015705611,
0.0080527831,
0.0285805501,
0.0130493911,
0.0344983041,
-0.0310416277,
-0.0137447268,
-0.062120162,
0.0409116633,
-0.0611106306,
-0.0258579813,
-0.0659004822,
0.0112025859,
0.0534432642,
-0.0416302271,
-0.0139227649,
-0.0352761559,
-0.031695798,
-0.0513984896,
0.0052066636,
0.0114861773,
0.0231302194,
0.0360077322,
-0.0117582185,
-0.0633893758,
0.0418461934,
0.0575397015,
-0.0161577109,
0.0209308285,
0.0032614258,
-0.0226385072,
-0.0262938179,
0.0258614756,
-0.095656015,
0.024885932,
0.0299424436,
0.0201921891,
-0.0171213597,
-0.0665101036,
0.0296669155,
0.0604271404,
0.0723090917,
0.025033284,
-0.0450198278,
-0.0119849835,
0.029665282,
0.0024395853,
-0.0320638791,
-0.0209567696,
-0.0076022716,
0.0864209756,
-0.0172172524,
-0.0196840204,
0.0309132878,
-0.0285659395,
0.0521475151,
-0.0681984127,
-0.0211955234,
-0.006570532,
0.0098621631,
0.0222243257,
-0.0015321128,
-0.0414392091,
0.0310328864,
0.039981436,
0.0517547838,
-0.041662354,
-0.0204530638,
0.0034328126,
0.0013397842,
-0.0486828648,
0.0174284969,
-0.0804979205,
-0.0108015658,
-0.0423687696,
0.0291976705,
0.0335933194,
-0.0202911217,
0.0168696493,
0.0243471172,
-0.0225875508,
-0.0456740446,
-0.0323002413,
0.0355975553,
0.0222276021,
0.0110606533,
0.0209781677,
-0.0160818547,
0.0628228486,
0.0492812023,
0.0287424903,
0.0506449081,
-0.0451587401,
-0.0270495471,
-0.0147001678,
0.0162047781,
0.0436228365,
0.0196510609,
-0.0218246505,
-0.0084892064,
0.0038674679,
-0.0375563055,
0.0302501339,
-0.0479698926,
-0.0111982636,
-0.0455390848,
0.0365210585,
0.0763160363,
0.0271527097,
-0.0209778659,
-0.0464079268,
0.0015066859,
-0.0196374077,
-0.0060949414,
-0.0231316425,
-6.242753685e-33,
-0.014763969,
0.0202128571,
0.0135684088,
-0.0312189478,
-0.0044263336,
-0.0084459791,
0.0176768843,
-0.0324634798,
-0.0320363939,
-0.046535477,
-0.0333133638,
0.0220415238,
0.0043651438,
0.0121879801,
-0.0125475051,
0.0163704567,
0.0564339384,
0.0185104869,
-0.0308497697,
-0.0159983225,
0.0324505344,
0.0637678057,
0.0083585223,
-0.0676550344,
0.0016624354,
-0.0308384337,
-0.0012821878,
0.0472793765,
0.0305274967,
0.0602166913,
-0.0081031499,
0.0477474295,
0.047849115,
-0.0175522193,
0.0109513579,
0.0026994599,
-0.0798384175,
0.0113183577,
0.0090560084,
-0.0153206727,
0.0043799547,
-0.004562078,
0.0510568433,
-0.0074942862,
-0.0119078141,
0.0108055249,
0.0556729548,
-0.0197574757,
-0.0507929325,
-0.0042453357,
-0.0132214362,
0.0320602655,
0.0291849356,
-0.0026524027,
0.0285818968,
0.0585453473,
-0.002979114,
0.0696703121,
-0.0466223061,
-0.0085789831,
-0.0246689301,
0.0836068392,
0.0441822857,
0.0392539464,
-0.0220215973,
0.0152029078,
0.0194362719,
0.0392958783,
0.0230296794,
-0.0643894151,
0.0372723602,
0.0025187661,
-0.0029472522,
0.0590759479,
0.0299075767,
-0.0559655204,
-0.0485829413,
0.0216208044,
-0.0104544386,
0.0319614597,
0.0233474746,
0.0708515346,
-0.0597335584,
-0.0000496958,
-0.0440401472,
0.0415076502,
-0.0640155002,
0.0029670948,
0.0466840044,
0.0564283915,
-0.0141978106,
-0.0022576898,
0.0351239666,
-0.0097275246,
-0.0014566252,
0.020630721,
0.0149597004,
0.0116387838,
-0.0216685086,
0.0237893444,
-0.0102654854,
-0.0608754382,
0.0128556928,
0.0210787784,
-0.0140326219,
-0.030004669,
0.0190380253,
0.0123865651,
-0.0872734785,
-0.0223127529,
0.0084058782,
-0.0196986198,
-0.0120328357,
0.0358126722,
-0.0130550228,
0.0306177773,
0.022982046,
0.0502473041,
0.0435675867,
-0.0160939358,
-0.0208140593,
-0.0566824414,
0.0332009159,
-0.0277214199,
0.0046276255,
0.0157092605,
0.0194782242,
0.0416731574,
0.008374555,
-0.0216309633,
-0.0091395006,
0.0454928055,
2.563e-7,
0.0587995909,
0.0494609661,
-0.0288488325,
-0.0237991698,
-0.0052818367,
0.0233361926,
-0.0294892192,
0.046240408,
0.0655633658,
0.0247948896,
0.0249668509,
0.0022299557,
0.0417385623,
-0.0316825137,
-0.0807789117,
-0.0343671106,
-0.0125582237,
0.0110901641,
-0.0311008748,
-0.0360313542,
0.0219365377,
0.1032204553,
-0.0099064549,
-0.0018913195,
-0.0018701013,
-0.1049192697,
0.0519972816,
-0.0256677084,
-0.0157733764,
0.0201617088,
0.0288722273,
0.0844199285,
-0.0030528556,
-0.0144166378,
-0.0106232958,
0.0292228237,
0.0074776164,
0.0588892736,
-0.0511370674,
-0.0060745361,
0.008984834,
0.0099432813,
0.0277386084,
-0.0230270158,
0.0744225159,
-0.0312866606,
0.0420085229,
0.0241853688,
-0.0293387845,
-0.0063247802,
-0.0009233246,
-0.0149138821,
-0.0235069841,
-0.0047471379,
0.02051281,
0.0223511923,
-0.0487779304,
-0.1064349413,
0.0204466879,
0.0069442792,
-0.0354259759,
-0.0096652927,
-0.0454306379,
0.0189393014,
-0.005083085,
-0.0512779392,
0.0324934609,
2.047010454e-34,
0.0347471461,
0.0143967932,
-0.0056726551,
-0.0071736723,
0.0140164439,
-0.0059114797,
-0.0157346446,
0.0342326127,
0.0149891973,
-0.1295014024,
0.0027860617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14763v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14763v1 | A Learn-Then-Reason Model Towards Generalization in Knowledge Base Question Answering | 2024-06-20T22:22:41 | 2024-06-20T22:22:41 | Lingxi Zhang, Jing Zhang, Yanling Wang, Cuiping Li, Hong Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large-scale knowledge bases (KBs) like Freebase and Wikidata house millions
of structured knowledge. Knowledge Base Question Answering (KBQA) provides a
user-friendly way to access these valuable KBs via asking natural language
questions. In order to improve the generalization capabilities of KBQA models,
extensive research has embraced a retrieve-then-reason framework to retrieve
relevant evidence for logical expression generation. These multi-stage efforts
prioritize acquiring external sources but overlook the incorporation of new
knowledge into their model parameters. In effect, even advanced language models
and retrievers have knowledge boundaries, thereby limiting the generalization
capabilities of previous KBQA models. Therefore, this paper develops KBLLaMA,
which follows a learn-then-reason framework to inject new KB knowledge into a
large language model for flexible end-to-end KBQA. At the core of KBLLaMA, we
study (1) how to organize new knowledge about KBQA and (2) how to facilitate
the learning of the organized knowledge. Extensive experiments on various KBQA
generalization tasks showcase the state-of-the-art performance of KBLLaMA.
Especially on the general benchmark GrailQA and domain-specific benchmark
Bio-chemical, KBLLaMA respectively derives a performance gain of up to 3.8% and
9.8% compared to the baselines. | [
0.0689567327,
0.0324387178,
0.016739944,
0.0397797972,
-0.0128198573,
0.012924728,
-0.0315592922,
0.0064094295,
0.0056074862,
-0.0231312718,
0.0163746085,
0.0034966548,
-0.058223553,
0.0430615768,
0.0293095559,
-0.0478958525,
0.0361996256,
-0.0189153124,
0.0550529771,
-0.0233959761,
0.0284971409,
0.0171589907,
-0.0129028978,
0.0021282446,
-0.0082990201,
-0.0142380688,
-0.0167928897,
-0.0249455683,
0.0088157961,
-0.0002355608,
0.0184811465,
-0.0112260915,
0.0443467014,
-0.0243100915,
0.0000019886,
-0.059521772,
-0.0122542912,
0.0130500868,
-0.0615468398,
-0.0041825422,
-0.0292937402,
0.011672711,
0.0387352034,
-0.0021253207,
-0.0650014728,
-0.0101834815,
0.0296056643,
0.0437580347,
0.059491463,
0.0463320129,
0.017524397,
-0.0558447875,
0.0148526793,
-0.0037512402,
0.0480640382,
-0.0576474369,
0.0185040943,
0.034392409,
0.0339224599,
-0.0152100697,
-0.000839491,
0.0226792283,
0.0177725349,
-0.0052801627,
0.0244163908,
0.0369526446,
-0.0215710327,
0.0210405067,
0.0179175995,
0.1112649441,
0.0157536045,
-0.0070198965,
0.0092507256,
0.0092664938,
0.0210823305,
0.037722379,
-0.065213196,
0.0371617489,
-0.027065875,
-0.0317406841,
0.0229538474,
0.0023029197,
0.0287976954,
0.0275134128,
-0.0599478483,
0.1232845262,
0.0082923509,
-0.0186809693,
0.0305410642,
-0.0013072965,
-0.0536416508,
-0.0418780036,
-0.0097402008,
0.0838373229,
-0.0314777009,
0.029534813,
-0.0005706755,
0.0173820145,
0.0222920924,
-0.0314989686,
-0.0158587471,
0.0279119685,
-0.0011405719,
0.05919943,
-0.0427552983,
0.0459815301,
-0.0405285135,
0.0151466057,
-0.034772452,
-0.0295604765,
-0.0831772089,
-0.0369079299,
-0.021792816,
0.0656166375,
-0.0243935082,
-0.0205556769,
0.0072721997,
0.0420755371,
0.0047804518,
-0.0194369704,
0.0341053233,
0.0440428369,
-0.01457664,
-0.0306688547,
-0.0646255538,
0.0294485949,
-0.0746887252,
0.0330067948,
0.0308015309,
-0.0235824045,
-0.0227516461,
-0.0115705086,
0.0466328375,
-0.0038618592,
0.0067094387,
0.0375516079,
0.0015379075,
0.0285766907,
-0.0674388781,
-0.0661951378,
-0.0017132593,
-0.0365639143,
-0.0076377881,
-0.0403053015,
0.0487640873,
0.0153416917,
-0.0425979532,
-0.0266074874,
0.0061703613,
0.0004850991,
-0.0311785359,
0.0456986576,
-0.03142526,
-0.0118627939,
0.0387921408,
0.0253867265,
-0.0454231501,
0.0554122068,
-0.0022361446,
-0.0103511894,
0.0181352738,
0.0099638365,
-0.0403541252,
-0.0160226859,
0.0460438244,
-0.0139509095,
0.0162674598,
0.0705166459,
-0.0405592211,
0.0497419052,
0.0344740227,
0.0262175445,
-0.050566975,
0.0159794427,
-0.0017147191,
0.0209236406,
0.0136960447,
0.0000659259,
0.0457512401,
0.0065836827,
0.010859957,
-0.0027616867,
-0.015848428,
0.0187084563,
-0.0193107314,
0.0397297926,
-0.0089934748,
0.0301457681,
-0.035928838,
-0.035530284,
0.0210487265,
0.00917916,
-0.0061817514,
0.0242860988,
0.0286308601,
0.0415809229,
-0.0057647703,
0.0999439806,
0.0339769572,
-0.046597112,
0.0246388465,
-0.036727678,
0.0767867863,
0.0513251573,
0.0067360126,
-0.0434739739,
-0.0694263354,
0.0094771283,
-0.016419962,
0.0012232425,
-0.0160384551,
-0.0481685922,
0.0153096765,
-0.0249624606,
-0.021015089,
-0.0366793275,
0.0026034531,
0.000090976,
0.0352091566,
0.0155718215,
0.0337108858,
-0.0721106976,
0.0226027109,
0.0140914628,
-0.0103237173,
-0.0232953262,
-0.0052797864,
0.0050451723,
0.0236078445,
0.0250427239,
0.0096276356,
0.0483212322,
0.0431510322,
-0.0508935638,
-0.0641411096,
-0.0010512032,
-0.020112345,
-0.0728370696,
0.0465673842,
-0.0017743122,
0.0130885653,
-0.0271791425,
-0.0654522628,
-0.0552639775,
0.0129517419,
-0.0028130112,
0.0554434024,
-0.0266921353,
-0.051539395,
0.0315409005,
-0.0435665287,
-0.0464462675,
0.1054416895,
0.0052404269,
-0.018534502,
0.0135824978,
-0.0132928127,
0.003989147,
-0.0403308645,
0.0313143767,
-0.0010334714,
-0.0230675451,
0.009403551,
0.0346352682,
-0.00959526,
-0.0776459798,
0.0163414478,
-0.0528863631,
0.0129581308,
-0.0097447271,
0.0369517617,
0.0424193628,
0.0271202642,
0.0301748347,
-0.0151011283,
-0.0801283866,
0.0247411635,
-0.0015007233,
0.0324985422,
0.0331067964,
0.0678946674,
0.0090458216,
-0.0229033623,
-0.0063488651,
-0.0008484093,
0.049388133,
-0.018645281,
0.0483154245,
-0.0329192542,
-0.0131989783,
-0.0699192733,
0.0021785069,
-0.0031696397,
0.0150618665,
-0.0003437319,
-0.0394652747,
-0.016334122,
0.0505152047,
-0.0216640122,
-0.0371222459,
0.0282749254,
-0.0024036015,
-0.058204975,
0.0419773236,
-0.025399914,
0.0059202514,
-0.0269036535,
-0.0094926814,
0.0239000116,
0.0336798802,
-0.0017058607,
-0.0239734892,
-0.0591028742,
0.0541577041,
-0.0023232661,
0.0039739409,
-0.0799429342,
-0.0286614448,
0.0108439503,
0.0356559455,
-0.0268006492,
0.014372644,
0.0763067454,
0.0270927083,
0.0077423095,
-0.0520863347,
0.0294709634,
-0.0285451431,
0.0651927367,
-0.0483548306,
0.0196305085,
-0.0005206715,
-0.0085715512,
-0.0301962495,
-0.0150651783,
0.0166142937,
-0.0156370662,
0.0571983717,
-0.0533265062,
0.0343911387,
0.0204505902,
-0.0339535549,
-0.0338998735,
0.0033407619,
-0.0395567827,
-0.0108433412,
-0.0175426807,
-0.0056586214,
0.023432795,
-0.0068903426,
0.0368023105,
-0.0079059927,
-0.0046264553,
0.0078672068,
-0.0152726276,
0.0440458171,
0.0764960125,
0.0224907026,
0.0176430289,
0.0210643131,
-0.0034185026,
0.057890363,
0.0177911073,
-0.0292855818,
0.0144273015,
-0.0111708045,
-0.0117821051,
-0.0469986945,
-0.0305737983,
0.0013004299,
0.0041207317,
-0.0603795424,
0.0064133978,
0.0941477716,
0.0188471414,
0.0182884205,
-0.0055799549,
-0.0281816535,
0.0404806696,
0.0045981426,
0.0484852009,
-0.05868176,
-0.0268144924,
-0.014569236,
0.0080669522,
0.0086300997,
-0.032003507,
0.0187945385,
-0.1098296717,
-0.0079745064,
-0.0114983898,
-0.0497928299,
-0.0244386494,
-0.0336372741,
-0.0073529021,
-0.0253692511,
-0.0074640689,
0.0525410995,
-0.0094452407,
0.0379596949,
0.0111441249,
-0.0164312366,
-0.0417788625,
0.0320253558,
-0.0364260226,
-0.0058585582,
0.0621541925,
0.0294320695,
0.0220461544,
-0.0206578523,
-0.0468296893,
-0.0237890426,
0.0255207196,
-0.0203105845,
0.0419864245,
0.028397711,
-0.0067402222,
-0.024326995,
0.0197966676,
-0.0612252913,
-0.008510164,
0.0202382132,
0.0945936516,
0.0059625618,
-0.0110748243,
-0.0164655522,
-0.0252699759,
-0.0115140378,
0.0802530497,
0.016399812,
0.007281899,
-0.0244934279,
-0.0247897077,
-0.0289142597,
-0.0559878945,
-0.0273905583,
0.0263643395,
0.0138928546,
0.0138959326,
-0.1110757962,
-0.0301489104,
0.0463046096,
0.062834017,
-0.0223205928,
0.0237145927,
0.0157890152,
-0.0029469477,
-0.0364432596,
0.0343125165,
-0.0239618979,
-0.0134826731,
0.002888602,
-0.0012846279,
0.002121313,
-0.0261805188,
-0.0554562807,
0.0078094029,
-0.0045807767,
-0.071036078,
-0.0130330399,
0.0618148446,
0.0229721125,
0.0199145805,
-0.0127257481,
-0.0367480107,
0.0604171827,
-0.0230334476,
-0.0381341428,
-0.0225344133,
0.0347335674,
-0.0146540282,
-0.011977016,
0.0597004555,
-0.0899115428,
-0.0301506203,
0.0007663597,
0.0562107526,
-0.0325873159,
-0.0203621108,
0.0525484644,
0.008431579,
-0.0384881198,
0.0320240706,
-0.0172871985,
-0.0256158821,
0.0080937631,
-0.0239273068,
-0.024986051,
-0.0492074899,
0.027143361,
0.01479459,
-0.0413633324,
0.0018108246,
-0.0218208302,
-0.0126446001,
0.0269183218,
-0.0215944313,
-0.0535950772,
0.0653563067,
0.0384249836,
0.0657030493,
-0.0343829654,
-0.0392581634,
-0.0378505401,
-0.0181238968,
0.0221021771,
-0.0280067753,
0.0119002452,
0.0415444449,
-0.0048890305,
-0.0470040441,
-0.0196303539,
-0.0713177398,
-0.0853381008,
0.0121959681,
-0.0104140714,
0.0197253749,
0.0135567645,
0.047556594,
0.0071516065,
-0.0499289446,
0.0125115914,
0.0207357164,
0.0155525822,
-0.0187522415,
0.058293052,
0.0216023047,
-0.0178513303,
-0.0285849031,
0.0873163342,
-0.0045267008,
0.0678707585,
-0.0300102364,
-0.0034967156,
-0.0305295382,
-0.0278917421,
-0.0273153652,
0.0338717997,
-0.0231947713,
0.0350931287,
-0.0343842804,
-0.0484590158,
0.0331385955,
-0.0104623819,
-0.0399674624,
-0.0082243159,
0.0622552447,
0.0669878498,
0.0448118635,
-0.0717581436,
-0.0028077436,
0.0338659994,
-0.0608262457,
-0.0203633998,
-0.0237148367,
-6.601380848e-33,
-0.0132236602,
0.0193463061,
0.0318193808,
-0.0565767623,
-0.0223974958,
-0.0121118948,
-0.0451177061,
-0.0094601521,
-0.0487468988,
0.0411526412,
-0.0077409423,
0.0049495483,
-0.0097087994,
0.0185848605,
0.0033810416,
-0.0173475109,
-0.0001745811,
0.0320045501,
-0.0000900184,
0.041145727,
0.0596907288,
0.0546354316,
0.0437298641,
-0.020891685,
0.0077346177,
-0.0020936728,
-0.0023894529,
0.0556254983,
-0.0406913199,
0.0550605729,
0.0041929856,
0.0275935195,
0.0220999047,
-0.0251863953,
-0.0079758177,
0.0063686189,
-0.0958254263,
-0.0295472164,
0.0431491919,
-0.0393644795,
-0.0636538938,
-0.058479432,
0.0133961057,
0.0090529183,
0.0704331249,
-0.043070659,
0.0156740695,
-0.0184690561,
-0.0106466701,
-0.0239563044,
-0.0356593281,
0.0029102582,
0.0064601935,
0.0207113512,
-0.0522205569,
0.0244055018,
-0.0116543192,
-0.0018248385,
-0.0174661577,
0.0160208978,
0.0388799235,
0.0202094745,
0.0376422666,
0.0116216931,
0.0046810899,
0.0185803827,
-0.0357829742,
-0.0344599262,
-0.0231077373,
0.0052095163,
-0.0440292545,
0.0698547885,
0.0174753144,
0.0686458722,
0.0460335463,
0.0279456452,
-0.1061308533,
-0.0034387023,
-0.022893345,
0.0550299473,
-0.0209124852,
0.0068236631,
-0.0042622271,
-0.0283966083,
-0.0540870763,
0.0773571134,
-0.0374948047,
-0.0258447602,
0.0360002816,
0.0067634112,
-0.0242027659,
-0.0187637657,
-0.0129022133,
-0.0266145673,
0.0240116268,
0.0686572194,
-0.0111312727,
-0.0121411746,
0.0142527604,
0.0306833088,
-0.0660371333,
0.0064949924,
0.0172293633,
-0.0384426489,
-0.0121346014,
0.0465470776,
0.0247431304,
0.0091171386,
-0.0022938203,
0.0003834692,
-0.0510067083,
0.017753223,
-0.0286192,
0.0034292636,
0.0100296102,
0.0759971142,
-0.0080520185,
0.0480573736,
0.0160216652,
-0.0105260015,
-0.0154521139,
-0.0187036544,
0.0407856889,
0.0168444421,
-0.0207693614,
-0.000327907,
-0.005966553,
0.0015187131,
-0.0129042314,
-0.050933823,
-0.0283807665,
0.0257057473,
2.8e-7,
0.0633026734,
-0.0163142942,
0.0236593243,
0.0604748987,
-0.0065847533,
0.0029924687,
0.0346261486,
0.0082553457,
0.0058513037,
-0.0543964542,
-0.0131236911,
0.0421943851,
-0.0157253835,
0.0220886897,
-0.0716543868,
-0.0333035514,
-0.0319257341,
-0.0604517609,
-0.0226589758,
-0.0400738865,
0.0463536419,
0.0600239858,
-0.0048229741,
-0.0177357662,
0.0299325772,
-0.0670387,
0.0632218868,
0.020399224,
0.0048482628,
0.0337865986,
0.0591481403,
-0.001664858,
0.0066912817,
0.0534945726,
-0.0029538719,
0.0186134111,
-0.0172223896,
0.0356602632,
-0.0250104833,
-0.0299366377,
-0.0206838809,
-0.0541693419,
0.048417747,
-0.0502981693,
0.0905570909,
-0.0505029559,
0.0171985105,
0.0160906464,
-0.0279993303,
-0.0154024223,
-0.0413127616,
-0.0244810823,
0.0316219702,
-0.012305201,
0.008389106,
0.0032618612,
0.0204831418,
-0.0825814158,
-0.0183232017,
0.0496781394,
-0.0252389833,
-0.0224166587,
-0.0226956643,
-0.0116119683,
0.0213877149,
-0.0536335595,
0.0200033132,
2.296024928e-34,
0.0132337371,
0.0137933716,
0.0134656578,
0.0316871479,
0.0604606159,
-0.0120293638,
-0.0735299885,
-0.0325672776,
0.0446265489,
-0.0790508837,
-0.0111191999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14760v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14760v1 | An LLM Feature-based Framework for Dialogue Constructiveness Assessment | 2024-06-20T22:10:52 | 2024-06-20T22:10:52 | Lexin Zhou, Youmna Farag, Andreas Vlachos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Research on dialogue constructiveness assessment focuses on (i) analysing
conversational factors that influence individuals to take specific actions, win
debates, change their perspectives or broaden their open-mindedness and (ii)
predicting constructive outcomes following dialogues for such use cases. These
objectives can be achieved by training either interpretable feature-based
models (which often involve costly human annotations) or neural models such as
pre-trained language models (which have empirically shown higher task accuracy
but lack interpretability). We propose a novel LLM feature-based framework that
combines the strengths of feature-based and neural approaches while mitigating
their downsides, in assessing dialogue constructiveness. The framework first
defines a set of dataset-independent and interpretable linguistic features,
which can be extracted by both prompting an LLM and simple heuristics. Such
features are then used to train LLM feature-based models. We apply this
framework to three datasets of dialogue constructiveness and find that our LLM
feature-based models significantly outperform standard feature-based models and
neural models, and tend to learn more robust prediction rules instead of
relying on superficial shortcuts (as seen with neural models). Further, we
demonstrate that interpreting these LLM feature-based models can yield valuable
insights into what makes a dialogue constructive. | [
0.0895121098,
0.049451638,
-0.0078915479,
0.0440350287,
-0.018666653,
0.004683862,
-0.0109157702,
-0.0214363057,
-0.0060906829,
-0.0366608389,
-0.0556026921,
-0.0325277969,
-0.0021444042,
0.0636069253,
-0.0184068996,
-0.0325447433,
0.0293897577,
0.0184232891,
0.0478864163,
0.0187943727,
0.0159171056,
-0.0063223094,
-0.0231519677,
0.0640824586,
-0.0333727598,
0.0193500631,
-0.0334154144,
0.0102719134,
-0.0114098554,
0.0143949315,
0.0430674478,
0.0697278082,
0.0050945766,
0.0247427765,
0.0000016239,
-0.0566771664,
0.0077787298,
-0.0427714288,
-0.0307361539,
-0.0181147624,
0.0600907467,
0.0107601471,
-0.0027454915,
0.02094814,
-0.0594742335,
0.0238364432,
0.015396405,
0.0804278404,
0.0680141374,
0.0805437341,
0.0129696922,
-0.0234599188,
-0.0119164251,
-0.0026553199,
-0.0072365794,
-0.0242015142,
-0.0107763801,
0.0084609529,
-0.0563616492,
0.0147977723,
0.013665081,
0.0185888708,
-0.0007378151,
-0.0688926503,
0.0192674156,
-0.0213799551,
-0.0341627188,
-0.0345062502,
-0.0114706904,
0.0975550488,
0.0675422475,
-0.0033819962,
-0.0021348023,
-0.0285305995,
0.0188745335,
-0.0251916423,
-0.0483615436,
-0.0065500177,
0.0188741125,
0.012374606,
0.0063687786,
0.0217507258,
0.0311937146,
0.0155809885,
0.0491658412,
0.0382953547,
-0.0552761778,
-0.0317838565,
-0.0035567521,
0.0163612347,
0.017898798,
-0.0318302847,
-0.0119976671,
0.0284199324,
-0.0304453894,
0.0366412364,
-0.0072053131,
0.0429416485,
0.0461160205,
-0.0481396466,
0.054920055,
0.0141243292,
-0.0311275553,
0.042981457,
0.01618772,
-0.0138269179,
0.0080880011,
0.0301867183,
0.0003323373,
-0.0062949751,
-0.0688173026,
-0.0275382269,
0.0169531573,
0.0216098092,
-0.0138534689,
-0.0084325504,
-0.0270902365,
0.0247873291,
-0.0217160955,
0.0277839191,
0.0365311913,
0.0272722449,
0.000329712,
0.0187558383,
-0.0867547467,
0.0193550587,
-0.0275469329,
0.0223134942,
0.0028232783,
-0.0514644384,
-0.0034598145,
0.0480633937,
-0.0106116151,
-0.0182507746,
-0.0081258332,
0.0517703556,
0.0159448516,
-0.0277661905,
-0.0506356545,
-0.0347437076,
-0.0134062693,
-0.0250252169,
0.0197824035,
-0.0162894018,
0.0458469763,
-0.0414704941,
-0.0272055063,
-0.0530936867,
0.0102092149,
0.0068975515,
0.0249851532,
0.0246654488,
-0.0400126949,
-0.0008313486,
0.0568908006,
0.0156908166,
-0.0468431227,
0.0437697917,
0.0448682867,
-0.0237867646,
0.040658202,
-0.0022263422,
0.0139038609,
-0.0178088546,
0.0081158942,
-0.0183441229,
0.0071042879,
0.0295107979,
-0.0501109771,
0.0191861354,
0.0062617045,
0.0311003309,
-0.0352166556,
-0.0635993108,
0.0736668557,
0.0653890669,
0.006628606,
0.0338232815,
0.0267064366,
0.0585554466,
0.0213822033,
-0.0112831481,
-0.0231764019,
0.0151188308,
-0.034888491,
-0.0252906345,
0.0078321733,
-0.0216132496,
-0.0170651115,
-0.1132812276,
0.0118390266,
-0.0097304014,
0.0818928331,
0.0094720144,
-0.0017996948,
-0.0063510593,
-0.0313217714,
0.0360440351,
-0.0090395287,
-0.0824885145,
-0.0300127827,
-0.0374644026,
0.0402975529,
0.0472282618,
0.0309037641,
-0.0222425219,
-0.0736821294,
-0.058071278,
0.012331822,
0.0508971252,
0.0696786493,
-0.0119503224,
0.0476568192,
-0.0644819364,
0.0018727179,
-0.0310432278,
0.004560871,
0.0022333711,
-0.017188197,
-0.0481441133,
0.0121559212,
0.0679220855,
-0.0307721477,
0.0233074334,
0.0015902229,
-0.0084147695,
0.0275561661,
0.0257225782,
0.0489649698,
0.0377146788,
0.0104007684,
-0.0124479281,
0.0251798946,
-0.0015741454,
-0.049775023,
0.0505865403,
-0.0474741161,
-0.0233009793,
0.0279714707,
0.0073252078,
0.0050082761,
-0.0124263093,
-0.0423253849,
-0.0138931787,
0.0311934333,
-0.0442037545,
-0.0453678928,
-0.0658346564,
0.0034302066,
-0.0089185573,
0.0213166475,
-0.0266578272,
0.0232502986,
-0.0077273082,
-0.0043494999,
0.0352662727,
-0.0158560816,
0.0468215719,
-0.0431155153,
-0.0211967528,
0.0005359948,
0.0083788736,
0.0054856827,
0.0164130628,
0.0178887006,
-0.0554440133,
-0.0242453497,
-0.1195893437,
-0.0064787138,
-0.0253041759,
0.0245681852,
0.010732688,
-0.0432417654,
0.0160437915,
-0.0066002547,
-0.0401488841,
-0.0486778058,
0.0377756394,
-0.0142384842,
0.0884967074,
0.0176290963,
-0.0288814418,
-0.0338087901,
0.0072724801,
-0.0091362735,
0.0121443542,
-0.0165131129,
0.000729434,
-0.0245289337,
-0.0063251178,
-0.0377440266,
0.0108653316,
-0.0218095873,
-0.0585541911,
0.0314483792,
0.0296025239,
-0.0540338345,
0.0722147152,
0.0416849554,
0.0425192714,
0.0005187571,
-0.0227118339,
-0.0501056425,
0.0443222076,
-0.0191998389,
0.0360049307,
-0.0555000007,
-0.0202479567,
0.0280507002,
0.0387263857,
0.0040097875,
0.0191401634,
-0.0721515641,
0.0538437963,
0.0295006167,
-0.0423207805,
-0.0152833294,
-0.0186687,
-0.0303415041,
0.0546834953,
-0.017959822,
-0.0277482793,
0.093089506,
-0.0236098301,
-0.013793515,
-0.0094861789,
-0.045416519,
-0.0908627659,
0.032658767,
-0.0473416373,
-0.0321595855,
0.0220792741,
-0.0118748704,
-0.0038565865,
-0.0209704414,
0.0493573695,
-0.0420043208,
0.0743602887,
-0.0320223309,
-0.0309796967,
0.0233887993,
-0.009736388,
-0.0467123203,
-0.0509300344,
-0.0094955927,
-0.0062627317,
0.0037267627,
0.003850094,
0.0184356961,
-0.0296946932,
-0.016258955,
0.0043766536,
0.0048594321,
0.0128711835,
0.0104147689,
0.0149683673,
0.0077482169,
0.0867381468,
0.0191529803,
0.0142442835,
0.0517450981,
0.0333019868,
-0.0665598586,
-0.0133036524,
-0.0316200741,
0.0174986832,
-0.0123590641,
0.0005924727,
-0.0021967283,
-0.0006641547,
0.0799102411,
-0.0555967577,
0.0057954905,
0.1112679914,
0.0301315784,
-0.0091020064,
0.0017473205,
-0.0466003194,
0.0066810222,
0.0163059365,
0.0066257813,
-0.0557201654,
-0.0361810662,
-0.0178764109,
0.0066263177,
-0.0614022166,
-0.027299121,
-0.0131986234,
-0.0576336943,
0.023797635,
-0.0154696265,
0.000022457,
0.0037530104,
0.0170334317,
-0.0116581274,
-0.0279411748,
0.002676273,
-0.0134773599,
0.050400313,
-0.0270552784,
0.008818022,
-0.0404532775,
-0.0307464562,
0.0376404412,
0.0141772199,
0.0591050051,
0.058520142,
0.040283937,
0.0098954653,
-0.0314665847,
0.0125344768,
0.0167911854,
0.017294351,
0.0044758199,
0.0416513942,
-0.0044526923,
-0.0076759085,
0.0067055728,
0.016710382,
-0.026038181,
-0.0309610721,
0.0182660557,
0.0173980128,
-0.0478730761,
0.0194292665,
-0.0043118815,
0.0653564632,
0.0300322939,
0.0537030362,
0.0668063238,
-0.0308533832,
-0.0013227317,
-0.0356665067,
-0.0504045784,
-0.0234341286,
-0.0587613992,
0.006092215,
0.0647066161,
0.0303988867,
-0.0553272665,
-0.0734421462,
-0.0228517801,
-0.022779623,
-0.0239911955,
-0.0167125445,
-0.0219526645,
0.0056392197,
-0.006186266,
0.0571165793,
0.0057896278,
0.0048819729,
-0.048875384,
0.0110293394,
0.0525285788,
-0.0371360257,
-0.0345789902,
0.0336416848,
-0.0725816488,
-0.0501645878,
-0.0463947617,
0.0597549193,
0.0203842223,
0.0359782353,
-0.0015613118,
-0.0637668818,
-0.0268427692,
0.0278596953,
0.0207577646,
-0.009507061,
0.0732557178,
0.075436227,
-0.0017570537,
0.0374417678,
-0.0058295173,
-0.0020526757,
-0.0079530003,
0.0219852738,
-0.0407526642,
-0.0916608796,
-0.0153635954,
-0.016976431,
0.0438545756,
0.0707047358,
-0.0185915176,
-0.0276864879,
0.0212838911,
0.0062464727,
-0.0327449366,
-0.0588902496,
0.0053214245,
-0.0367697887,
-0.0342611335,
-0.0301902834,
-0.037033584,
-0.0698720664,
0.0401876234,
-0.0193165541,
0.0127855185,
0.0083772345,
-0.0047732587,
-0.0554666258,
0.0020316639,
-0.0380488299,
0.0481102653,
0.022312941,
0.0172439571,
0.0410238653,
0.101615414,
0.0031845386,
0.0035651876,
0.0063442122,
0.0428615957,
-0.0441584624,
-0.0144602852,
-0.0104269851,
0.030561721,
0.0105627701,
0.0190183073,
0.0125401411,
-0.0302343257,
0.0242403839,
-0.0035784573,
0.0859853923,
0.0033227357,
-0.0282556377,
0.0452028774,
0.0182405114,
-0.032595966,
-0.0227949601,
0.036359597,
-0.0332930572,
-0.0081059244,
-0.0036977339,
-0.0001118069,
-0.0619232729,
-0.0553435795,
0.0391116254,
0.027260704,
-0.0057283752,
0.0291579161,
-0.0414796695,
-0.0302017797,
0.0588554218,
0.0061013927,
0.0166414715,
-0.0163616203,
0.0134330234,
0.0395099334,
-0.0098395115,
0.0052809548,
-0.0559377894,
-0.0184883792,
0.0005342041,
0.0054353257,
-0.0462503061,
-5.240645486e-33,
-0.0092781298,
-0.0226016939,
0.0067913868,
0.0517402664,
-0.0423512124,
-0.0397032574,
-0.027418714,
0.0329743885,
-0.0410880707,
0.0115173692,
-0.0005733732,
0.0178475361,
0.0038853348,
0.0100372275,
-0.0115926573,
-0.0417849086,
0.0226150434,
0.0030166407,
-0.0210529603,
0.0001750924,
0.0117708873,
0.0051937937,
0.0462814122,
-0.1046176106,
0.0585225299,
0.0153288739,
-0.0038722779,
0.0417997576,
-0.0054740822,
0.0654383153,
0.0007183724,
0.0532814525,
0.0271183942,
-0.0528848432,
0.0095469179,
-0.0062816232,
-0.0096481387,
-0.0441270694,
0.019619612,
-0.0052300687,
-0.0429254957,
-0.0306166951,
0.0313880779,
-0.0016425089,
0.0009557074,
-0.013798208,
-0.0026082143,
-0.0072904457,
0.0094992844,
-0.0162291788,
-0.0300996881,
0.0244366024,
-0.0582729541,
-0.0514922813,
-0.0191886351,
0.0196943488,
-0.0100891152,
0.0051401085,
-0.0663211346,
0.0150779895,
0.0081885196,
-0.0005084683,
0.02403678,
-0.0259338673,
-0.0088058775,
0.0709184483,
0.032468956,
0.0524078198,
-0.0341411047,
-0.0214680079,
-0.0034715382,
0.034173362,
0.039118439,
0.0625857264,
-0.0125270123,
-0.0170182902,
-0.0349315666,
0.0025179815,
0.0308276284,
0.0218490958,
0.0109403078,
-0.0181859005,
-0.0260005798,
-0.009906319,
-0.0391616821,
-0.0364590734,
-0.0221332833,
-0.0437361449,
0.0178021733,
0.0120082032,
-0.0222763587,
0.0134216724,
0.015639076,
-0.0313377418,
0.0279345177,
0.0635323152,
-0.022734765,
0.000788059,
0.018193163,
-0.0417721197,
-0.0199547857,
-0.0161260385,
0.0017123565,
-0.0085190348,
0.0469648615,
-0.0295347776,
0.0288037788,
0.0163491424,
-0.0041411766,
-0.0147403851,
-0.0082363086,
0.059762083,
-0.0527178012,
0.0561309643,
-0.0213953778,
0.0108320918,
-0.0525950789,
0.1132634282,
-0.0322972983,
0.0156901609,
-0.0380036235,
-0.0251844786,
0.0402813442,
0.0054058861,
-0.0285964105,
-0.0146923009,
0.0204697233,
-0.0102294972,
0.001038279,
-0.0200525317,
0.012765537,
-0.0283911936,
2.267e-7,
0.0015813833,
0.0219498593,
0.0240212884,
0.0188736115,
0.0147155002,
0.0727797002,
-0.0270631947,
0.0214043278,
0.017922014,
-0.0459170043,
0.042948328,
0.0171282254,
0.0823476464,
0.017693257,
-0.0914758816,
-0.0386396907,
-0.0717359483,
-0.0312215611,
0.0090915356,
-0.0024824962,
0.0856437162,
0.0523186214,
-0.0063368385,
-0.0118968822,
-0.0107155861,
0.0119312303,
0.0513306372,
-0.0599401556,
-0.0269353259,
0.0155657912,
0.0672182813,
-0.0463374145,
0.0172875263,
-0.0036879578,
-0.0014738992,
0.0651488453,
-0.0387907699,
0.1015978754,
0.0045284904,
-0.0906961039,
-0.0118589327,
0.0193889551,
0.0283908509,
0.0143664386,
0.0164794084,
-0.0570894219,
-0.0466364808,
-0.02908778,
0.0236403439,
-0.032461606,
0.0692859888,
-0.0322504826,
-0.0050685117,
0.0173242725,
0.0129044633,
-0.0310783237,
0.0124379555,
-0.0799478814,
-0.022914568,
-0.034742374,
-0.0512961373,
-0.0185835008,
-0.0178523194,
0.0083321631,
-0.0000041886,
0.02084033,
0.0320974775,
1.485738304e-34,
0.0593319163,
-0.0107468814,
0.0285801124,
0.0599165782,
0.0668447539,
0.0426369905,
-0.0014251625,
-0.0143885557,
0.029244449,
-0.03474617,
0.0021166108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15516v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15516v1 | System Description for the Displace Speaker Diarization Challenge 2023 | 2024-06-20T21:40:02 | 2024-06-20T21:40:02 | Ali Aliyev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper describes our solution for the Diarization of Speaker and Language
in Conversational Environments Challenge (Displace 2023). We used a combination
of VAD for finding segfments with speech, Resnet architecture based CNN for
feature extraction from these segments, and spectral clustering for features
clustering. Even though it was not trained with using Hindi, the described
algorithm achieves the following metrics: DER 27. 1% and DER 27. 4%, on the
development and phase-1 evaluation parts of the dataset, respectively. | [
0.0302024037,
-0.003045063,
-0.0137112327,
0.0563657917,
-0.0263681281,
-0.0059572104,
0.0008083885,
-0.0271731708,
-0.0318701267,
0.0228460114,
-0.007167866,
-0.0016080702,
0.0306006018,
0.0269529112,
-0.0206955243,
-0.0951854885,
0.0340570211,
0.0078593083,
0.0068391515,
-0.0026597914,
0.0184239391,
0.0042115552,
-0.077650629,
0.0090961708,
-0.054872524,
0.0049439012,
-0.0019972625,
0.0061570243,
0.0360414237,
0.0052400026,
0.0418288559,
0.0535311289,
0.0442105681,
0.0460820571,
0.0000020149,
-0.0318437517,
-0.0162135381,
-0.019513119,
-0.0328659937,
-0.0296538752,
0.043739602,
0.0359265544,
-0.0082619172,
0.0115518197,
-0.0279055201,
-0.0251594596,
0.0564145036,
0.018349966,
0.0383543409,
0.0822933838,
-0.0006899983,
-0.0658285841,
0.0165250525,
0.0156556312,
-0.0310746953,
0.0312300138,
-0.0136702452,
-0.0052372641,
-0.0096165603,
-0.0734561309,
-0.0086020157,
0.0243011676,
0.0006411998,
-0.0085988101,
0.0371869281,
0.0054806229,
-0.0566407889,
-0.0567136072,
0.0532905757,
0.0688026622,
0.0306992773,
0.0387944058,
0.0374846384,
0.0611112975,
-0.034987282,
-0.0271800309,
0.0155049944,
-0.0173094422,
-0.0004101908,
-0.0167491138,
-0.0549384616,
0.0460948385,
0.0011226259,
-0.0226606783,
0.0000671321,
0.0052225981,
0.0031085503,
-0.0108133508,
-0.0185591783,
-0.0362097919,
0.0086352108,
0.0234098844,
0.0484591238,
-0.0199391246,
-0.0145581318,
-0.0009511035,
0.0069455463,
-0.052160129,
-0.0279534105,
-0.0019645302,
-0.0347668864,
-0.0018760319,
-0.0192267038,
-0.0052079116,
-0.0539957061,
0.0518408418,
-0.0105130067,
0.0045178193,
-0.0469575524,
-0.0104706958,
-0.0393984914,
0.0016642715,
-0.0189128686,
0.0223683547,
0.0247253794,
-0.0092285685,
-0.0940045416,
-0.0145934802,
-0.0316843688,
-0.0013282842,
0.0096263364,
0.0174889993,
-0.0250837281,
-0.0179912448,
-0.0127147501,
0.0240139533,
-0.0467144847,
0.0096551208,
-0.0026240537,
-0.0423486531,
0.0393951684,
0.0530672856,
-0.0120142922,
-0.0045065582,
-0.0377825163,
-0.0005207591,
-0.0072284834,
-0.043564152,
-0.0697588548,
0.012504085,
-0.0459373258,
-0.0655200556,
-0.0183281973,
-0.0975355729,
0.0213298332,
-0.010282605,
0.0104955258,
-0.0101461811,
-0.0119065745,
-0.0295205712,
0.0636560321,
0.0609773286,
-0.0361929797,
0.0269724242,
0.1107499301,
0.0104770856,
0.0460320972,
0.0173279624,
0.0217526685,
-0.0005528643,
0.0235778671,
-0.0216840729,
0.0124315815,
0.0367781483,
-0.0618957244,
-0.0291055888,
-0.0494108312,
-0.019058967,
0.0164312925,
0.0012780369,
0.0409295559,
0.0066717607,
-0.0369007811,
-0.0113959126,
-0.0175373405,
0.1160803586,
-0.000644755,
0.0233124942,
-0.0115997018,
0.0264360998,
0.0066595767,
0.0168213751,
0.0154880444,
-0.0098741902,
0.0134393396,
-0.0412295945,
0.048728589,
0.055122368,
-0.0313702635,
-0.0217344146,
0.0619827621,
-0.0345818289,
0.0192523096,
0.0089518037,
0.0350967497,
0.0066846367,
0.0274280906,
0.0561011024,
0.0510311909,
-0.0619644448,
-0.0043609431,
-0.04976511,
-0.0223759599,
0.0123541877,
-0.0102887377,
-0.0280644614,
0.0247152764,
-0.014530452,
0.0086934464,
0.000247202,
0.0052390085,
-0.0154867005,
-0.0206588767,
-0.0770990029,
-0.0190689713,
0.0767993107,
-0.0165866949,
0.0223951079,
-0.0024749436,
-0.0160047188,
0.041279301,
-0.0510229617,
-0.0192719121,
0.0076012341,
-0.0040960736,
0.0071119545,
0.0116735231,
0.0464767441,
0.0376763046,
0.0292915013,
-0.0309879836,
-0.0469817668,
0.010184885,
-0.0141398069,
0.0386963114,
0.0043991995,
-0.0226454381,
-0.0295980629,
0.0162909534,
-0.0820465758,
0.0032108752,
0.0678878948,
-0.0135699892,
-0.0779522136,
0.0841439739,
-0.0053541306,
-0.0331258252,
-0.0263851415,
0.033808697,
-0.0104726506,
0.0390295945,
-0.0144877005,
0.0366855189,
0.0259025972,
0.018149795,
-0.0244395398,
0.0074635511,
0.0551886074,
-0.0777797475,
-0.0381720401,
-0.0193620343,
-0.0261534862,
0.0334504545,
0.0038707696,
-0.0317627303,
-0.012385698,
-0.0503790639,
-0.0877803415,
-0.0050646476,
-0.0384323895,
-0.0129234493,
-0.0093247583,
0.029985819,
0.0003374839,
-0.0341719761,
0.0003021455,
0.0028886378,
0.0406557843,
-0.0312258955,
0.0142622907,
-0.0026753123,
-0.0926577374,
0.0051569245,
-0.0329716615,
0.0222057905,
0.0383789092,
-0.0334347226,
-0.0704722479,
-0.0013848215,
-0.0197791196,
-0.0014063894,
0.0089128446,
-0.0047819666,
-0.0412163772,
-0.0428397879,
0.0201482009,
0.0389351472,
0.0077472609,
0.0200970303,
0.0042591449,
-0.0265511367,
0.0091640791,
0.0107859578,
-0.0000976427,
-0.0046276073,
0.0335440747,
-0.0351090804,
-0.0494911447,
-0.0020617095,
-0.0285394043,
-0.0168746263,
0.0086072171,
-0.0012461635,
-0.0746608749,
-0.0423645303,
-0.0210558269,
-0.0002798565,
0.0147684012,
-0.0466951132,
0.0234596636,
-0.0364207774,
-0.0480923951,
0.0051963185,
-0.0352598913,
-0.002145347,
-0.0683597699,
-0.0666927323,
-0.0051587392,
-0.0233574361,
0.0242661312,
0.0429562628,
0.0127358278,
-0.0502059497,
-0.0359071754,
-0.0338993706,
0.0275288932,
-0.0196511466,
0.0471042581,
-0.0289508142,
0.0170445144,
-0.0446663313,
-0.0143415406,
-0.0384798013,
0.0218494628,
0.0371589027,
0.0256309938,
0.022656288,
-0.0401581004,
0.0008593159,
0.0473989919,
0.0091797384,
0.0118179023,
-0.0179183651,
0.0387674794,
-0.003293246,
0.0651988089,
0.0151677895,
0.04212052,
-0.0170618184,
-0.010695437,
0.0228053648,
0.0086665535,
0.0237738136,
0.0025189044,
-0.0422613472,
0.000523073,
-0.0013218737,
-0.0150005789,
-0.0407602973,
0.0216025319,
0.04758472,
0.0358026102,
0.0080377199,
0.0927800387,
0.0275398437,
-0.0874197781,
-0.0221619215,
-0.0137287909,
0.0033373011,
0.029643001,
0.0201935824,
-0.0517926142,
0.0223055724,
0.0458791219,
0.0087963156,
0.044740852,
-0.0032650197,
-0.0303547997,
-0.0232570805,
0.045568902,
0.0160232577,
-0.0040820013,
-0.0362758934,
-0.0180955324,
-0.0256230459,
0.0009622771,
0.0123028345,
-0.0098984726,
0.0123920301,
-0.0523092672,
0.0790521801,
-0.0567662604,
0.0060122684,
-0.0207564086,
-0.0297886357,
0.0470809527,
0.0516710617,
0.01500424,
0.0019309571,
-0.0066911345,
-0.0106943091,
-0.0507247001,
-0.0216271132,
0.004904673,
0.0679472089,
0.0348214582,
0.0145468786,
0.0095579727,
0.028143052,
-0.0242628381,
-0.0173707716,
0.0387536027,
0.0258581806,
0.0069132526,
0.0216490515,
0.0148307038,
0.0325727947,
-0.0018061894,
0.0073442277,
0.0448020063,
-0.0052650156,
-0.0171210058,
0.0056697093,
0.0623845719,
-0.0030012152,
-0.0154081257,
0.0018281367,
-0.0153018022,
-0.0695197955,
-0.0075490186,
-0.0180471763,
0.0038387643,
0.055348672,
0.0264015254,
0.0182995852,
0.0030780127,
0.0432795212,
-0.0327077881,
0.0093829297,
-0.0276148822,
0.063142851,
-0.1108203083,
0.009514791,
0.0181265231,
-0.0202541668,
-0.019552011,
-0.0700221285,
-0.0175146013,
-0.0111603597,
0.0584527254,
-0.0388176404,
0.0242358055,
0.0662895963,
-0.0536913089,
-0.064696312,
0.0860324055,
-0.0358685292,
-0.0073858127,
-0.0018084191,
0.029945232,
-0.0055501503,
-0.0485234857,
0.0235749483,
0.0087223118,
0.0619527251,
0.0145590492,
-0.0648768917,
-0.067499496,
-0.0208027977,
-0.0075052301,
0.0114041865,
0.0816535577,
-0.0155972037,
-0.0159165468,
-0.0601095967,
0.0030017756,
0.0632192418,
0.0121043818,
0.0012565824,
-0.0160811096,
0.0634067059,
0.0566746593,
0.0324559547,
0.0698869601,
0.0181802902,
-0.021424545,
0.0467733145,
0.0224801134,
0.052542869,
0.0829266608,
0.0092568938,
0.0362903401,
-0.0038816333,
-0.0043121702,
0.0340996385,
0.0357291736,
-0.0176210571,
0.048395656,
-0.0072091687,
0.0094759613,
-0.0007267109,
0.0792526007,
0.0291928835,
0.0186157171,
-0.0219292715,
0.0230704341,
0.0219462384,
0.0241298154,
0.0215723366,
0.0067450162,
0.015398317,
-0.0216536596,
0.0176213793,
-0.0423626378,
0.0321986191,
0.0371687673,
0.013632712,
-0.0190521907,
0.0207561292,
0.0467532016,
-0.0188417304,
-0.0255143344,
-0.0012967536,
-0.0240699686,
-0.0539338589,
-0.0515315756,
-0.0390245318,
0.0048520663,
-0.0043135509,
0.0201667864,
-0.0001978938,
-0.0594713651,
0.0062025725,
-0.0446409211,
0.0103272106,
0.0237691719,
0.0200316049,
0.0019607146,
-0.0050132321,
-0.0166789647,
-0.0065141427,
-0.0786340386,
-0.0108764172,
-0.0205816422,
0.0583333038,
-6.368613865e-33,
-0.0065136794,
-0.0022609537,
-0.012641727,
-0.0350636318,
-0.0250627548,
-0.0095879762,
0.0320373438,
0.0276980419,
-0.0253184531,
0.0161864758,
-0.0113103129,
0.0167263653,
0.034580484,
0.0458752587,
-0.0468884818,
0.008980507,
0.0689970553,
-0.0107104946,
-0.0018823576,
0.0296757314,
0.0340924524,
0.0221935995,
0.0370506495,
-0.06068464,
-0.0594818927,
-0.0059264489,
-0.012774433,
0.0515159629,
0.0073359637,
0.0205677841,
-0.0463706963,
0.031231571,
0.0072240788,
-0.0031003656,
0.0001319796,
0.02879747,
-0.1208190024,
-0.0054711085,
-0.0546938404,
0.1046995744,
-0.0138952192,
-0.0292814989,
0.0362482518,
0.0161983278,
-0.0354652032,
0.0279884562,
0.0600228757,
-0.0179861896,
-0.0157877393,
0.0409228988,
-0.0236156918,
0.0653594434,
-0.022826599,
-0.0055044689,
0.0418211371,
0.0523231253,
-0.0229226742,
-0.0682042539,
-0.1016545445,
0.0360167511,
0.0120695606,
0.0494664237,
0.0295832846,
0.0829034746,
-0.0368005149,
0.0278074667,
0.1083551869,
-0.0860505179,
0.0804203153,
-0.0694524497,
-0.0024011519,
0.0287083667,
-0.0136035038,
-0.0083373291,
-0.0112725012,
-0.0795559362,
-0.0209163912,
0.0255609676,
0.027921183,
0.0074758395,
-0.0013303083,
-0.0159605797,
-0.0618038923,
-0.0503534265,
0.0173807163,
-0.0292350948,
-0.0217500161,
-0.0456167385,
0.0391315259,
-0.0009336859,
0.0057831788,
-0.0105402032,
0.0237748679,
-0.0410200581,
0.0381660052,
0.0005404377,
0.0120250825,
0.0412429385,
0.0306464005,
-0.0232950933,
-0.0328119807,
-0.0525317229,
0.0719736889,
0.0517952889,
-0.0117801139,
-0.0381425023,
0.010826108,
0.0289265066,
-0.0413549356,
0.0103680873,
0.033437252,
0.0150027759,
0.0014104452,
0.0849599391,
-0.0227718297,
-0.0175540168,
-0.0162612107,
0.0371141359,
0.0279849526,
0.0275307652,
0.0134914909,
-0.0106312064,
0.0125881275,
0.039880354,
-0.0510109141,
0.0462634824,
-0.0247792993,
-0.0098728398,
0.0232912824,
-0.0294693001,
0.0014370793,
-0.0171420854,
2.859e-7,
-0.0247794278,
0.01444491,
0.0644670874,
-0.1092743874,
-0.0087315748,
0.0121802539,
-0.0154189607,
-0.0076852692,
-0.0039325086,
0.0317953937,
0.0319542736,
0.0117886048,
0.0418501049,
0.0209053364,
-0.091175735,
0.0054808962,
-0.0206923932,
0.0098669967,
-0.0282503106,
0.0200152695,
0.0080849482,
0.0703987554,
-0.0101117883,
-0.03367614,
-0.0074231182,
-0.0345036164,
-0.0209142994,
-0.0154657653,
-0.0043207128,
0.0202863179,
0.0331289098,
-0.0370196626,
-0.0158005878,
0.0153829036,
-0.0216018874,
0.0421940275,
0.0313467532,
0.0401658192,
-0.0112055475,
0.0029340072,
-0.011900357,
0.0780270025,
-0.0076579563,
0.0280381143,
0.0368755646,
0.0163621753,
-0.0563011616,
-0.02621332,
-0.0447144732,
0.0017108951,
-0.0001764276,
0.0222614855,
-0.030763723,
0.0160573479,
0.012604679,
-0.0442059189,
-0.0319151506,
-0.0651938543,
0.0107382033,
0.0281140413,
-0.0441421792,
-0.0661059543,
0.0146057578,
-0.012602753,
0.0448472351,
0.0461092815,
0.0370168872,
2.473075729e-34,
0.0052544535,
0.0569828413,
-0.0033081723,
-0.0317805484,
-0.0116463834,
-0.0389579237,
-0.0560322851,
-0.0039659091,
0.0093193203,
-0.050265234,
-0.018967703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14747v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14747v1 | An Adapter-Based Unified Model for Multiple Spoken Language Processing Tasks | 2024-06-20T21:39:04 | 2024-06-20T21:39:04 | Varsha Suresh, Salah Aït-Mokhtar, Caroline Brun, Ioan Calapodescu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Self-supervised learning models have revolutionized the field of speech
processing. However, the process of fine-tuning these models on downstream
tasks requires substantial computational resources, particularly when dealing
with multiple speech-processing tasks. In this paper, we explore the potential
of adapter-based fine-tuning in developing a unified model capable of
effectively handling multiple spoken language processing tasks. The tasks we
investigate are Automatic Speech Recognition, Phoneme Recognition, Intent
Classification, Slot Filling, and Spoken Emotion Recognition. We validate our
approach through a series of experiments on the SUPERB benchmark, and our
results indicate that adapter-based fine-tuning enables a single
encoder-decoder model to perform multiple speech processing tasks with an
average improvement of 18.4% across the five target tasks while staying
efficient in terms of parameter updates. | [
0.0037095703,
0.000042113,
0.0003555141,
0.0393395163,
0.0263337772,
0.0137739405,
0.0516653992,
-0.0466332883,
0.0032523393,
-0.0500248857,
-0.0627114698,
0.0127520617,
0.0162241571,
0.026734205,
-0.0239052735,
-0.023579618,
0.0295893922,
-0.0297617335,
0.0163303018,
0.0054442575,
-0.0278521031,
0.0297369938,
-0.0233300161,
0.058652088,
0.0024900469,
0.011906866,
-0.0205721632,
0.0438294001,
-0.0072958404,
0.002823764,
0.0242418088,
0.0484350696,
0.0176901687,
0.0122641847,
0.0000019261,
-0.0289701857,
-0.0217377953,
-0.0361526534,
-0.0864558741,
0.0070540654,
0.0181444827,
-0.0045709424,
-0.0136290714,
0.0491157472,
0.0130576994,
-0.0365101211,
0.040924713,
0.0339405127,
0.0444569811,
0.0708317682,
-0.0070473282,
-0.0278764591,
0.0235644002,
-0.0228487961,
-0.0169585366,
-0.031995412,
0.0257869735,
0.0012675354,
-0.0202091802,
-0.0637874156,
-0.0441752076,
0.0343299545,
-0.0022000617,
0.0184958261,
0.0512805544,
-0.0238915887,
-0.0223521367,
-0.0331703238,
-0.0565600209,
0.0339631215,
-0.0652882382,
0.0123762712,
-0.0126247965,
-0.0349403694,
-0.0043697362,
-0.0156447142,
0.0245938338,
-0.0337156393,
-0.0182379913,
0.012292414,
0.0102476701,
0.0279542357,
0.0048416583,
-0.0004635026,
-0.0557882227,
0.0581513532,
-0.0227375682,
-0.0107689453,
0.0186639559,
-0.0033126455,
0.0271952283,
-0.0139768645,
0.0293588433,
0.0090899179,
-0.0396765098,
-0.0091965655,
-0.0532905608,
-0.0593029708,
-0.047760278,
-0.0414702147,
0.0377679877,
0.0931416377,
-0.0204897635,
0.0297945086,
-0.0128406212,
0.0369740278,
0.0204916485,
-0.0075760288,
-0.0433051288,
0.0021288064,
-0.0212076269,
0.0164316371,
-0.0563545078,
0.0209409539,
-0.0856162682,
-0.0329820998,
-0.029654434,
0.0420408733,
0.0086099599,
-0.0287037026,
0.0329974033,
0.0061943186,
-0.0463148765,
-0.0107942307,
-0.0088229142,
0.0812305138,
0.0060848198,
0.0353371687,
-0.0095266094,
-0.0569617078,
0.0044530556,
0.0146522876,
0.0590755679,
-0.0290826038,
0.0285492521,
0.0406273417,
-0.0175876431,
-0.0248019621,
-0.0202294402,
0.0094648581,
-0.0243639965,
-0.0194307398,
-0.0256995093,
-0.0283643138,
0.0566835068,
0.0290079452,
0.0322706662,
-0.032199163,
-0.014516253,
-0.0501172952,
-0.0095331576,
0.0676961169,
0.0321518108,
0.0210766569,
0.0623418242,
-0.0084026679,
0.0288590062,
0.0610916354,
0.0464585945,
0.0214887746,
0.0106284851,
-0.0583531,
-0.0046713375,
0.0388046056,
-0.0334789976,
-0.0340877064,
0.0017170636,
-0.0047349599,
0.0113737639,
0.0211361367,
0.034884613,
0.017174039,
-0.0599284507,
-0.0234061107,
0.0364035107,
0.0143376011,
0.0543963797,
0.0123855947,
-0.0027974923,
0.021283349,
0.0193118714,
-0.0163152851,
-0.0300333537,
0.0455088653,
-0.0246180799,
-0.0137883341,
0.0021157877,
0.037191242,
-0.0263929591,
-0.0502461977,
0.0104229152,
-0.0345749184,
-0.0071669845,
-0.0065712947,
0.0252896957,
-0.0230051689,
-0.0658952743,
0.0143626863,
-0.0081637064,
-0.0510741137,
0.0071586664,
-0.0384400971,
-0.0153933372,
0.0946946442,
0.0020607016,
-0.0000377591,
-0.0655966327,
-0.0310718808,
-0.0229496751,
0.0209616739,
0.0545980148,
0.0045885979,
0.0609221272,
-0.0603631176,
-0.0369813219,
0.0128468806,
-0.0179585107,
0.0735549033,
-0.0433214568,
0.0012987854,
-0.0076398361,
0.0066883359,
0.0202294271,
-0.0078265741,
-0.0094583463,
-0.0353377648,
0.0580965802,
0.0165825114,
0.0539310127,
-0.0018758631,
-0.0123730013,
-0.0493867248,
0.0102857547,
-0.0286885984,
0.0240920633,
0.0553527139,
-0.0876040608,
-0.0311587173,
0.016414823,
0.0219320767,
0.0185122341,
0.0271035992,
-0.0052514286,
-0.102942802,
-0.0009672181,
0.0183626059,
0.0497139804,
-0.0210150126,
0.0387723148,
-0.0038556829,
0.0272229575,
0.0286570471,
0.0003677413,
0.0427900702,
-0.0229325723,
0.0321975723,
0.0021694247,
0.027387321,
-0.0334888473,
-0.0814280063,
-0.019285351,
-0.0202945173,
-0.0027551297,
-0.00308663,
-0.0207215156,
-0.0391703881,
-0.0563790426,
-0.0807543695,
-0.0150358407,
-0.0279123075,
-0.0092230765,
-0.0064025763,
0.0514995679,
-0.0083640981,
-0.0270743538,
0.0340895131,
-0.0033646533,
-0.0181169026,
0.0025953152,
-0.0531819835,
0.0071571283,
-0.0113523975,
-0.0281188022,
0.0202642847,
0.0166936852,
-0.0076296548,
-0.0212309528,
-0.0511436053,
-0.047414396,
-0.0541701168,
0.0523015,
0.0338587724,
0.0019307212,
-0.0578586683,
-0.0184020139,
0.0397046395,
0.0146543067,
0.1016574055,
0.0211313833,
0.0491914749,
0.0195822902,
-0.0093517266,
-0.0730283484,
0.0491161309,
0.0106298402,
0.0267085694,
-0.0460290946,
0.0495935418,
-0.0252045617,
0.0541470088,
0.0243698321,
0.0519887619,
-0.0419980995,
-0.0157966521,
0.0141816242,
-0.0568341874,
-0.0136042461,
-0.0552799627,
-0.0391887017,
0.0120219374,
-0.002503278,
-0.0484466478,
0.001787108,
-0.03376735,
-0.0469820909,
-0.0409521349,
-0.0260408837,
0.0033264691,
0.0347465388,
-0.0101310378,
0.0293091368,
0.0228812303,
-0.0440239757,
0.0054914095,
-0.0109090526,
-0.0017453913,
-0.044025857,
0.055932276,
-0.0068007046,
-0.0154045038,
-0.0010999035,
-0.0582332462,
-0.0358823799,
-0.0294805355,
-0.0307444483,
0.0130118653,
-0.0047002304,
-0.0327824913,
-0.0470441207,
0.0298925452,
-0.0055464958,
0.0330605917,
-0.0126946736,
-0.0107659232,
-0.0262858272,
0.0200242288,
0.0197100118,
0.0684825182,
-0.0609125271,
0.0337073505,
0.0533530936,
-0.0154370153,
0.0454070084,
0.0359101035,
-0.0387829393,
0.0402593352,
0.0595973916,
-0.0122735184,
0.0008164168,
0.0086060185,
0.0656498075,
-0.0526695177,
0.0097140055,
0.1466657668,
0.0245798044,
-0.0251068305,
-0.0367479809,
-0.0334396325,
-0.0210889336,
0.0179635454,
0.0285381507,
-0.0298006516,
-0.0545786396,
0.0190830007,
0.0349027328,
0.0252297446,
0.0294751488,
0.0366430543,
-0.0696651861,
0.0339877382,
0.0384681933,
-0.0329863392,
-0.0290985759,
-0.0155990794,
-0.0030232423,
-0.0590683855,
0.0503833964,
0.0060153869,
0.001924735,
-0.056175217,
0.0665699393,
-0.0264404286,
-0.0442093424,
0.0098988861,
-0.0118541904,
0.0869374946,
0.0174076743,
-0.0059803352,
-0.0036249224,
-0.0094673103,
0.0170862675,
-0.0203765165,
0.0244025197,
-0.0175247118,
0.03147972,
-0.0213101618,
-0.019789923,
0.054615587,
0.0110382559,
-0.0592217073,
0.0003145702,
-0.0172990132,
0.0458982289,
-0.025380671,
0.0263592005,
0.0048521301,
-0.0257449728,
-0.0004942944,
0.0736576319,
0.0078226039,
-0.0391975231,
-0.0056866221,
-0.0177544262,
0.0202254038,
-0.0691312626,
-0.0096621169,
0.0082904547,
0.014694931,
-0.0544836931,
0.0098608863,
-0.0037105794,
0.0485445037,
0.0334730633,
0.0158307608,
0.0038239895,
0.0456823744,
0.0188381001,
-0.0242255107,
-0.0169304777,
0.0036827261,
0.001174651,
-0.0431579649,
-0.04944776,
0.0604546443,
-0.036833901,
0.0013296049,
0.0233451296,
-0.0110289082,
-0.0435278341,
0.0224770363,
0.0251262113,
0.0244944431,
0.0922957584,
-0.0385093279,
-0.008877405,
0.0039241822,
0.0396224186,
-0.0267373286,
0.0271404907,
0.0616308786,
-0.011194393,
-0.045428358,
0.0129760634,
-0.0480026752,
0.0187133364,
-0.0157362819,
-0.0201178174,
-0.0190491546,
-0.126896292,
-0.0066844923,
0.0108635845,
0.0458477177,
0.005701676,
-0.0146114314,
-0.035048712,
0.0368089415,
0.0307802334,
0.0315980501,
-0.0337481312,
-0.04309275,
0.028669592,
0.0116080269,
-0.0268107653,
-0.0173236877,
0.0090712924,
-0.0377096012,
-0.0128965406,
0.0394927673,
-0.0087435786,
-0.0197875425,
-0.0098683732,
0.0131558925,
-0.0276643876,
0.012527708,
0.0772829652,
0.0183152575,
-0.0228022207,
0.0181421824,
-0.0262204576,
0.0211317111,
-0.0109693827,
0.0388474017,
-0.0198492743,
-0.0184582788,
-0.0584293976,
0.0161541104,
-0.0060673393,
-0.0567311496,
0.0329554491,
0.0093850717,
0.0395453535,
-0.0275539588,
0.0115135638,
-0.0174918007,
0.0344243385,
0.0201949775,
-0.0010538509,
-0.0260836985,
-0.0065027224,
0.0255274642,
-0.0576262623,
0.082968466,
0.019072894,
0.0344932452,
-0.0510328487,
-0.0237692203,
-0.0174079295,
0.0154566532,
-0.0141659407,
-0.0162524357,
-0.0037639523,
-0.0234871823,
0.0464219749,
-0.0164966136,
0.0372776389,
-0.0100560794,
0.0105827823,
0.0093307942,
-0.0504026972,
0.0192589145,
0.0143636856,
-0.0619797632,
-0.0406143144,
0.0191035327,
0.0308432095,
-6.117280683e-33,
-0.0419334471,
0.0506537072,
-0.0040961653,
0.0004592622,
0.0102444291,
-0.0130578475,
0.0046787802,
0.0176228136,
-0.0165579524,
-0.0587709099,
0.0015040151,
0.0077373637,
0.0406868123,
0.0171360355,
0.0113108456,
0.0158082973,
0.0959777609,
-0.0271665491,
-0.0185097568,
-0.0256141219,
0.0379852951,
0.0176227633,
0.0373136401,
-0.0364029557,
-0.0845826194,
0.0573681444,
-0.0088127051,
-0.0078828605,
0.0196873024,
0.0676254258,
0.0332510471,
0.0564627461,
0.0029001965,
-0.0204569139,
0.0042698625,
0.0246498138,
-0.0952145234,
-0.0228584763,
0.0001218542,
0.0643343627,
-0.004075421,
-0.0303383302,
0.0713270903,
0.0419639833,
-0.0304994062,
-0.0180347729,
0.0267317705,
-0.0253512375,
-0.0031312108,
0.0035261114,
-0.0146828648,
0.020048108,
-0.0336610116,
-0.0312070213,
0.0493515283,
0.0322556607,
0.0139600569,
-0.0296474509,
-0.0862276852,
0.0147726592,
-0.0309971869,
0.0359239802,
0.0256752297,
0.0233130641,
-0.0297831949,
0.0378838442,
0.0430728942,
-0.0469120964,
0.0600814559,
-0.0111454409,
0.012917513,
0.0709636062,
-0.0057641282,
0.0202642512,
0.0371227413,
-0.0642951354,
0.0060512447,
0.0637343302,
0.0575323142,
0.0159293804,
0.0520940311,
0.052475892,
-0.0413492657,
0.0203035977,
-0.0523729138,
-0.022729991,
-0.0378208421,
-0.0242193062,
0.0603192262,
0.023403326,
-0.0210714526,
0.0363174528,
0.0812314749,
-0.0281891599,
0.079202652,
0.0051690862,
-0.0233295169,
0.0216759741,
-0.0067411978,
0.0412042923,
-0.0100180646,
-0.0694706142,
0.0501107238,
0.0260092616,
0.0108122351,
-0.0072905933,
-0.0301104784,
0.058377903,
-0.079904899,
-0.0108580356,
-0.0166111775,
0.02401134,
-0.0243404545,
0.0574783757,
0.0035959827,
0.0130988434,
-0.029463673,
-0.0012435147,
-0.0597239621,
-0.0077932733,
-0.0291750524,
-0.0585596077,
0.0156772491,
0.0173813049,
-0.0095654242,
0.0064305281,
-0.001942241,
-0.0222770199,
0.0194702316,
-0.0044557033,
-0.000156605,
0.0332054459,
2.81e-7,
-0.0001779453,
0.0282590427,
-0.0051635304,
-0.0568052754,
0.0406918675,
0.0369752087,
-0.002836945,
0.0156333242,
0.0479398109,
-0.0119114472,
0.0152602792,
0.0169198252,
0.0316740721,
-0.0135295074,
-0.0999942273,
0.0085076233,
-0.0026480856,
0.0745943561,
-0.0003274401,
0.0207519177,
0.0236586165,
0.0927626714,
-0.0071458449,
-0.0095888218,
0.0131243346,
-0.0189019293,
0.0129201096,
-0.0510772057,
0.0233021975,
0.0241528228,
-0.036581438,
0.0360751189,
-0.0226989463,
0.0488478541,
-0.0101003889,
0.0320393927,
0.0104704322,
0.0647701919,
-0.0055087344,
-0.0781782269,
0.0122707533,
0.0645445287,
-0.0233131256,
-0.022674907,
0.0540665202,
-0.0460187532,
-0.0245864205,
-0.022809796,
-0.0439341329,
0.0417152047,
0.0148593588,
-0.0047527477,
-0.0186879914,
0.000752866,
0.0102439011,
-0.0117443064,
-0.068333067,
-0.0690275803,
0.024879666,
0.0130724218,
-0.0409122296,
-0.0419107266,
-0.0448593423,
-0.0503341109,
0.0610987507,
-0.0579706132,
-0.0193432402,
1.995157149e-34,
-0.0082083708,
-0.0078438381,
0.0299014952,
0.0345732085,
0.000532624,
-0.0126219094,
-0.0479999185,
0.0322217867,
-0.0044436697,
-0.0792360455,
-0.045828525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14745v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14745v2 | Relation Extraction with Fine-Tuned Large Language Models in Retrieval Augmented Generation Frameworks | 2024-06-20T21:27:57 | 2024-06-24T06:57:05 | Sefika Efeoglu, Adrian Paschke | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Information Extraction (IE) is crucial for converting unstructured data into
structured formats like Knowledge Graphs (KGs). A key task within IE is
Relation Extraction (RE), which identifies relationships between entities in
text. Various RE methods exist, including supervised, unsupervised, weakly
supervised, and rule-based approaches. Recent studies leveraging pre-trained
language models (PLMs) have shown significant success in this area. In the
current era dominated by Large Language Models (LLMs), fine-tuning these models
can overcome limitations associated with zero-shot LLM prompting-based RE
methods, especially regarding domain adaptation challenges and identifying
implicit relations between entities in sentences. These implicit relations,
which cannot be easily extracted from a sentence's dependency tree, require
logical inference for accurate identification. This work explores the
performance of fine-tuned LLMs and their integration into the Retrieval
Augmented-based (RAG) RE approach to address the challenges of identifying
implicit relations at the sentence level, particularly when LLMs act as
generators within the RAG framework. Empirical evaluations on the TACRED,
TACRED-Revisited (TACREV), Re-TACRED, and SemEVAL datasets show significant
performance improvements with fine-tuned LLMs, including Llama2-7B, Mistral-7B,
and T5 (Large). Notably, our approach achieves substantial gains on SemEVAL,
where implicit relations are common, surpassing previous results on this
dataset. Additionally, our method outperforms previous works on TACRED, TACREV,
and Re-TACRED, demonstrating exceptional performance across diverse evaluation
scenarios. | [
0.0763564184,
0.0435704142,
-0.0031534685,
0.0735332444,
-0.0097778998,
0.0107312351,
-0.0069428976,
-0.0126452949,
0.0423622206,
-0.0710532665,
-0.0247886572,
0.0075018811,
-0.0552494861,
0.0099210218,
0.0072418102,
-0.0072433031,
0.0339548253,
-0.0044399374,
0.0206469037,
0.0204652995,
0.0034004422,
0.0344421044,
0.001344704,
-0.0205334499,
-0.0097602149,
-0.0008431926,
0.0294461045,
0.0191428289,
0.0272424407,
-0.0489750467,
0.0146923,
0.0446053706,
0.0169456508,
0.0078567639,
0.0000020674,
-0.081208244,
-0.0305520799,
-0.0152613614,
-0.0147579657,
0.0172261,
-0.0138950879,
-0.0237748325,
0.036572665,
0.0138886888,
-0.0478841774,
-0.0948915407,
-0.0011660896,
0.0786070079,
0.0403441079,
0.0869055763,
-0.0274846572,
-0.0549462289,
0.0070451968,
-0.0450720005,
-0.0066820416,
-0.0346885175,
0.0514052548,
0.0144543797,
-0.0324831568,
0.0222491492,
0.017604975,
0.0216190256,
0.0100390678,
-0.0372479744,
0.0455524772,
0.0323898382,
-0.0409838036,
0.0050438587,
0.0097249253,
0.1022476256,
0.0620132945,
-0.0007654395,
0.0287232492,
0.0287158825,
-0.0102110431,
0.0503548421,
-0.0122766811,
-0.0152154742,
-0.0264840778,
0.0173076969,
0.0107562607,
-0.0031342863,
0.0391802117,
0.0122640347,
-0.0339050405,
0.0527234003,
0.0173039809,
-0.0381426178,
0.023101503,
0.0417000391,
-0.0316860378,
-0.0295294896,
0.0122589422,
0.0316911712,
-0.0012272496,
0.044311475,
-0.0421132296,
-0.0250083506,
-0.0075884191,
-0.0225919727,
-0.0061084433,
-0.011193376,
-0.0229975525,
0.042968519,
-0.0645388067,
0.0243511181,
-0.0177014042,
-0.041774381,
-0.0321927443,
-0.0041368827,
-0.024139287,
-0.0074616871,
-0.0402364284,
0.0603936724,
-0.0437072068,
-0.0175748151,
-0.0351277739,
0.0208745953,
0.006837653,
0.014110554,
0.0086138844,
0.0262509771,
-0.0275882538,
-0.0052657765,
-0.044731278,
0.0211684182,
-0.0014191996,
0.0299183484,
-0.0108488677,
-0.0271172281,
-0.0155387316,
0.004228414,
0.0569500551,
-0.0535973907,
0.0135260848,
0.0696207881,
0.0077214641,
-0.0437480509,
-0.0346227549,
-0.0592960343,
0.01408662,
-0.0467187762,
0.0355169326,
-0.0310853813,
0.050932236,
0.0350246206,
-0.0046334709,
-0.0307188742,
0.0703958943,
0.0022248414,
-0.0868141949,
0.0325624794,
-0.0102439681,
0.0239015874,
-0.0197199844,
0.0082737682,
0.0223999042,
0.0434358083,
0.0379269496,
0.0229096469,
0.0624572299,
0.0020990889,
-0.0213425625,
0.0238397159,
0.0349910073,
0.0154931294,
0.0021624314,
0.0336332098,
-0.030098198,
0.0011871936,
0.0445736162,
0.0577862523,
-0.0200754907,
0.003107676,
0.034945704,
-0.0146957813,
0.0144649679,
0.0397441499,
0.0732412487,
-0.0160963554,
0.0302381702,
0.0136741418,
-0.0397238396,
-0.0193410814,
-0.0470779277,
0.0188687723,
0.001384814,
0.0276568253,
-0.0090401564,
-0.0053720069,
-0.0032316959,
0.0081907092,
-0.0164842661,
0.0087017324,
0.0799263939,
0.0535571799,
-0.0458759181,
0.0399491228,
0.0354586914,
-0.0298709758,
0.0005809374,
-0.0137357339,
0.0197016466,
0.0324383304,
0.0768368989,
-0.0103436019,
-0.036980059,
0.0072727334,
0.0159634855,
0.0311495215,
0.022674391,
-0.0272573438,
-0.0047059152,
-0.0315647759,
-0.0485559404,
0.0022730515,
0.0131948693,
0.0107049029,
0.0465174131,
0.0057256641,
0.0603891574,
-0.0329711959,
-0.0161678065,
0.0461853407,
-0.0504262671,
-0.0582900457,
0.0334451385,
0.016255565,
0.0055697523,
0.0348401926,
-0.0287392084,
0.0017403179,
0.0653725117,
-0.0448583141,
0.0052377665,
0.0048642149,
-0.0688878819,
-0.0631115213,
0.0100316862,
0.0283762068,
0.00335605,
-0.0290720873,
-0.0355174653,
-0.0182548333,
0.0017098776,
0.0275749639,
0.0786931962,
-0.0236378107,
0.0025429532,
0.0352854244,
0.0103105754,
-0.0301749259,
0.0929960087,
0.0160643775,
-0.0156972203,
0.0193558969,
-0.0396947563,
-0.0167719591,
-0.0030923833,
-0.009646643,
-0.0241890624,
-0.0088058654,
-0.020685751,
0.0099318987,
0.0238746312,
-0.0609067082,
0.0066317702,
-0.0754592493,
0.0336631462,
0.0107843811,
0.038526319,
0.0024913517,
0.0328427106,
-0.0218411498,
-0.0134611949,
-0.0015422197,
-0.0012504032,
0.0157045424,
0.0087536089,
0.0278484598,
0.0245625172,
-0.0041428939,
-0.0429819897,
0.0050774016,
-0.0226571038,
0.0674981251,
0.0234151613,
-0.0124031072,
0.0059235152,
0.1080586836,
-0.0521706678,
0.0275607854,
-0.0155295366,
0.0039991243,
-0.0367229804,
-0.0103008719,
0.0526427738,
0.0077212616,
-0.0185781941,
0.0624244697,
-0.0047139381,
-0.0302526131,
-0.0343968645,
0.0261621736,
-0.0430291966,
-0.0152437845,
0.0118142972,
-0.0152472397,
0.0053573246,
0.0369877443,
0.0096953344,
-0.0267473143,
-0.0088178106,
0.0374944992,
0.0450143591,
0.0145965274,
-0.0149893975,
-0.0040840041,
0.0396708697,
0.0015168771,
-0.0574301556,
-0.0290373284,
0.0636537448,
-0.0226426404,
0.0105599873,
-0.0164802056,
-0.0053146374,
-0.0545439646,
0.0573278517,
0.0197901744,
0.0028773572,
0.0124324504,
-0.0009620057,
-0.0258730929,
0.0191381313,
0.0119225606,
-0.0297212619,
0.0276063066,
-0.0421373546,
0.0258790459,
0.0030272438,
-0.0237172674,
-0.0738180056,
-0.0279864166,
-0.0034162707,
0.0060954648,
-0.0017854987,
0.0002149878,
-0.0123863202,
0.007881932,
0.013230755,
0.000306781,
-0.0108792977,
-0.0224976446,
-0.0148821017,
0.086885199,
0.0958438143,
-0.0200480111,
0.003805792,
-0.0145273982,
0.0328303985,
0.0247421544,
-0.0083209127,
-0.035438735,
-0.0151854279,
-0.0134091545,
0.0073069721,
-0.0208210927,
0.0191779118,
-0.0111639854,
0.0346651413,
-0.0316612683,
-0.0311503299,
0.0960361436,
0.009611289,
-0.0168026146,
-0.0010415191,
0.037324775,
0.0152461519,
0.0362488106,
0.0336167328,
-0.0877676755,
-0.0321569294,
-0.012274255,
-0.0071171741,
-0.0144337881,
-0.0639159828,
-0.0063989563,
-0.150070101,
-0.004565333,
-0.0117540676,
-0.0388268121,
-0.0140231596,
-0.0563121028,
0.0185239352,
0.0291160196,
-0.0312571451,
-0.008355068,
-0.0517622083,
0.0207398403,
-0.0055929874,
0.0256747007,
-0.0646012127,
0.0008834209,
-0.0427008234,
0.0165893883,
0.0593841448,
0.0171037205,
0.0016974508,
0.0231409576,
0.0372794829,
-0.0240727309,
-0.0069559133,
-0.0344572291,
0.03643604,
-0.0333633125,
-0.0009577049,
-0.046620883,
0.0052315481,
-0.0507788621,
0.0221844837,
0.025319308,
0.064494364,
-0.002514886,
-0.0368324295,
-0.0259426571,
-0.0252696574,
-0.0064808284,
0.0676873773,
0.0061612073,
0.0119011896,
-0.0018739697,
0.0096846819,
0.0284535233,
-0.0318237208,
-0.0024086991,
0.0035889505,
-0.0645780936,
0.0265747812,
-0.0685490519,
-0.0630819127,
0.0310172997,
-0.0004571261,
0.0108615234,
0.005752312,
0.0041293157,
-0.0163267478,
-0.0717510656,
0.0463865362,
-0.0258002635,
-0.0311722104,
-0.0033293804,
-0.0191864222,
0.0109107988,
-0.0363893583,
-0.0201911684,
-0.0042313151,
-0.051599469,
-0.042165745,
-0.0358240157,
0.029621752,
0.0135358777,
0.052879598,
0.0033353399,
0.0128896153,
0.0520547926,
0.0869434029,
-0.0721611604,
0.007313516,
-0.0278683919,
-0.0070888037,
-0.002449668,
0.0349017344,
-0.0690803751,
0.0235524345,
0.0350873284,
0.0846251249,
0.012710127,
-0.0772823095,
0.0191034898,
0.0395863727,
0.0666063353,
0.007145762,
-0.0119931605,
-0.0729191899,
0.0036531044,
-0.062554881,
-0.0251718741,
-0.0502034612,
0.0340530053,
-0.0064159608,
0.0232447479,
-0.0118885692,
-0.0314879976,
0.0019298928,
0.0820414498,
-0.0260082055,
-0.0122556016,
0.0213640872,
-0.0034691505,
0.0297014341,
-0.0386736393,
-0.0185078159,
0.023858482,
0.0311237015,
0.0090261335,
-0.0362303928,
0.0326538831,
0.0074154902,
-0.0295242202,
-0.0388213769,
-0.0121617904,
-0.016742561,
0.0330071151,
-0.0491360836,
0.0151200611,
0.0610875711,
-0.0347890034,
0.0592121482,
-0.0249168202,
0.0013594686,
-0.0017200182,
0.0480067879,
0.0014895392,
-0.0116895083,
0.0295169856,
0.0135379927,
-0.0416432992,
0.056110166,
0.0532950275,
-0.0045640045,
0.0646187067,
0.0088440441,
-0.0558925383,
-0.0288012512,
-0.0223886408,
0.0270055328,
-0.000012146,
-0.0179067384,
0.0207984783,
-0.0401148424,
-0.0673735589,
-0.0001303384,
-0.0451711789,
-0.0446827002,
-0.0034755126,
0.0045660143,
0.0546277091,
0.0324003138,
-0.0565484762,
-0.0553616509,
0.023541268,
-0.0830092356,
-0.0378079563,
-0.0263271388,
-6.977345819e-33,
-0.0650410727,
-0.0605659634,
0.0337463915,
-0.0348594785,
-0.0503747836,
0.0357298777,
-0.045947589,
-0.0359150209,
-0.0121006453,
0.026783755,
-0.0049015302,
-0.0049186302,
-0.0035991764,
0.0160860438,
-0.0303271078,
0.0116870217,
0.0211653728,
0.0157928988,
0.0132943215,
0.0263840277,
0.0329291597,
0.0500560924,
0.0438643582,
-0.0886572972,
-0.005471807,
-0.0310612526,
0.0132347271,
0.0396612175,
0.0174099486,
0.0504029505,
-0.0374727696,
0.037226256,
0.0224862862,
0.0062590665,
0.05496566,
0.0093330862,
-0.1453628689,
-0.0151765719,
0.0011411943,
-0.0393130034,
-0.0394874513,
-0.0347453468,
0.0311808623,
0.0103832707,
0.0373775586,
-0.0245304443,
0.0551890992,
-0.0258876178,
0.0015974252,
-0.0928413197,
-0.0547150113,
0.0282437894,
0.0265959576,
-0.0099673895,
-0.012962901,
0.0535304137,
0.0064492747,
0.0163187478,
-0.0559872836,
-0.0024542355,
0.0059899492,
0.0085152518,
0.0347897634,
0.0141991293,
0.006929806,
0.0379483029,
0.0005818238,
-0.0148791624,
-0.0210652333,
0.0122994725,
0.0142875081,
0.0534863062,
-0.0767807588,
0.0212087668,
0.0074042478,
-0.0099585671,
-0.1160159186,
0.015860023,
0.0190877058,
0.0384850577,
-0.0009605861,
-0.0309745986,
-0.038887959,
-0.0085325716,
-0.0047770692,
0.0009062617,
-0.0290003233,
-0.0515986271,
0.0394308046,
0.0209086314,
-0.0063994592,
0.0227256678,
0.010672275,
-0.025088679,
-0.036292199,
0.0184077434,
-0.0193647146,
-0.0084530087,
-0.0315012857,
0.0188507158,
-0.0386030041,
-0.0537257865,
0.0300858133,
-0.0292778499,
0.0074208206,
0.0311058965,
0.0222719982,
-0.0148099028,
-0.0475329235,
-0.0117963543,
-0.0345786065,
-0.00266598,
-0.0448006429,
0.0170909856,
0.0036780834,
0.0484378934,
-0.0054033957,
0.0423033051,
0.0658634529,
0.0011935539,
-0.0130017232,
0.0021686153,
0.03515907,
0.0088730063,
0.0126970075,
0.0000336976,
0.0088556353,
0.0105313146,
-0.0031873796,
-0.047197219,
-0.0148108387,
-0.0166450758,
2.975e-7,
0.0348632112,
0.0466861241,
0.028440414,
0.0082024159,
0.0016414931,
0.0201067869,
0.0320777483,
0.042736724,
0.016464727,
0.0126945851,
0.0188610051,
0.0060514323,
0.0108089829,
0.035604585,
-0.0548297316,
-0.0078949379,
-0.0611104444,
-0.0706950203,
-0.059013024,
-0.0268956367,
0.0876015872,
0.0447891504,
0.0114503996,
-0.0036681034,
-0.0581347458,
-0.061271634,
0.0723927021,
-0.0075902855,
-0.0331684537,
0.0448137969,
0.0240716636,
0.0249910913,
-0.0251115877,
0.0294210277,
-0.0028698684,
0.0620755292,
-0.0070919371,
0.0622836985,
-0.0033404923,
0.0144663164,
0.0143573564,
0.001724478,
0.0274917763,
-0.0049698548,
0.0762805864,
-0.0594480522,
-0.0108325006,
0.0453600399,
-0.0409211479,
-0.011583237,
-0.0427802913,
-0.0038718642,
-0.0082009993,
0.0277856439,
0.0212215297,
-0.0044059944,
-0.0609565079,
-0.0799148902,
0.004051147,
0.0512562245,
-0.0150438407,
-0.0176991932,
-0.0149649214,
0.0052750981,
-0.0177814085,
-0.0427327417,
0.0465014689,
3.172663845e-34,
-0.0106071634,
-0.0003365907,
-0.0243786331,
0.0267920885,
0.0748259723,
-0.0419404097,
-0.0648517236,
0.0227933489,
-0.0112234941,
-0.1060901582,
0.0278377067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14739v1 | Learning to Retrieve Iteratively for In-Context Learning | 2024-06-20T21:07:55 | 2024-06-20T21:07:55 | Yunmo Chen, Tongfei Chen, Harsh Jhamtani, Patrick Xia, Richard Shin, Jason Eisner, Benjamin Van Durme | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce iterative retrieval, a novel framework that empowers retrievers
to make iterative decisions through policy optimization. Finding an optimal
portfolio of retrieved items is a combinatorial optimization problem, generally
considered NP-hard. This approach provides a learned approximation to such a
solution, meeting specific task requirements under a given family of large
language models (LLMs). We propose a training procedure based on reinforcement
learning, incorporating feedback from LLMs. We instantiate an iterative
retriever for composing in-context learning (ICL) exemplars and apply it to
various semantic parsing tasks that demand synthesized programs as outputs. By
adding only 4M additional parameters for state encoding, we convert an
off-the-shelf dense retriever into a stateful iterative retriever,
outperforming previous methods in selecting ICL exemplars on semantic parsing
datasets such as CalFlow, TreeDST, and MTOP. Additionally, the trained
iterative retriever generalizes across different inference LLMs beyond the one
used during training. | [
0.0079631368,
0.030832598,
-0.0006026407,
0.0080752792,
-0.0305166114,
0.0036546947,
-0.0474986583,
0.0062622987,
-0.0117870662,
-0.0541093871,
-0.0072030844,
-0.012947266,
-0.0244230852,
0.0087032225,
0.0075459639,
-0.0491799079,
0.0102569545,
-0.0219636038,
-0.0015621117,
0.0091238152,
0.0026350988,
0.0316370465,
0.0111393128,
0.0621896461,
-0.0360278897,
-0.0172705743,
-0.0079960115,
0.0174723025,
-0.0326044187,
-0.0553763658,
0.0260122251,
-0.0193630587,
0.0566177443,
0.009703055,
0.0000021081,
-0.0335641727,
-0.0809033439,
0.0071760369,
-0.0291206092,
-0.0726327524,
0.0493209958,
-0.0377646536,
0.0115043502,
0.0275124758,
-0.0349295735,
-0.0425151065,
0.0318870656,
-0.0004919954,
0.0452702381,
0.1030333042,
0.0045002173,
-0.0096749635,
-0.0059573478,
-0.0151230888,
-0.0149024688,
-0.0263813864,
0.0084867859,
0.0071724802,
0.0160877462,
0.0244844276,
-0.0096838148,
0.0233316254,
0.0257454664,
0.0272641517,
-0.0090319486,
0.0432291813,
0.0126571739,
-0.0281429105,
-0.0214466825,
0.0393974409,
-0.0129849194,
-0.0258288123,
-0.0012310477,
-0.00655929,
0.0025541424,
-0.0345381796,
-0.0376780704,
0.0527665652,
-0.0126332948,
0.0578806028,
0.027823424,
0.0049341968,
0.0205327738,
-0.0198198371,
-0.0543770827,
0.054004129,
0.0068159779,
-0.0499738157,
0.0163420457,
-0.007508093,
0.0013062457,
-0.026125934,
-0.0202310141,
0.0221368093,
-0.1056820601,
0.0296299495,
-0.0219558552,
-0.0238150358,
-0.013226795,
0.0260280557,
0.047352653,
0.0587290153,
0.0204636529,
0.0322678201,
0.0027789015,
0.0210392606,
-0.0203338955,
0.0097170863,
-0.0571847931,
-0.0185763389,
-0.0669040382,
-0.0265972521,
-0.0703165159,
0.0648640022,
-0.0670971423,
-0.0244944952,
-0.0030256473,
0.0404401831,
-0.0226698238,
0.0474689417,
0.0070051765,
0.0163762942,
-0.0736710653,
-0.0040304214,
-0.0083894543,
0.0365910716,
0.0017231213,
-0.0192769077,
0.0327579826,
-0.0245401282,
-0.0376986191,
-0.0129803102,
-0.0030322371,
-0.0481146164,
0.0030488784,
0.0622787327,
-0.0284576751,
-0.0299957488,
-0.0309342854,
-0.0374301374,
0.0229719002,
-0.0426662117,
0.0221947785,
-0.0989075154,
0.0039208368,
-0.005863701,
0.0165207312,
-0.0730664507,
-0.0051949238,
0.021323381,
0.0230711494,
0.053768646,
0.0060818144,
-0.0120347776,
0.0036506648,
-0.0172959045,
0.011342152,
0.0655359179,
-0.0031831374,
0.0330064632,
0.0221353732,
0.0132970726,
-0.0093178255,
0.0185358524,
0.0418990254,
0.010503931,
-0.0624467731,
0.0203563236,
0.0089783659,
0.0150207439,
0.0135309212,
0.0259676985,
-0.0359897017,
0.0411464572,
0.0139880776,
0.0614384636,
0.0282936003,
0.0006977679,
0.041525241,
0.0307923201,
-0.0357706361,
-0.0256110802,
-0.0334859714,
0.0206031017,
-0.0269317329,
0.0205100868,
-0.0175235085,
-0.0071992166,
-0.0102822455,
-0.0477203801,
0.0069805728,
-0.0166429821,
-0.0039307731,
0.03320463,
0.0688291863,
0.0523647666,
-0.0540058054,
0.0321261659,
0.0240295418,
-0.0113792447,
-0.0206170753,
-0.0072015021,
0.0518342815,
0.0554063804,
0.0282334536,
-0.0665957108,
0.0268076863,
-0.00954975,
0.0071630431,
0.0160979759,
-0.0426247008,
-0.0454093404,
0.0306388587,
-0.019385742,
-0.0360447392,
-0.041844938,
0.0223860443,
0.0265008565,
0.0351403095,
-0.0349551812,
0.0108523639,
-0.0030644103,
0.0076717017,
0.0325884111,
-0.0295373984,
-0.0501202047,
0.0269216523,
0.0136287864,
0.0579569712,
-0.0221304018,
-0.015078146,
0.0306950491,
0.0438495465,
-0.0398978665,
-0.0267727096,
-0.0210573487,
-0.0593119375,
-0.0696417913,
0.0303825904,
0.0032889023,
-0.0120817348,
-0.0201954152,
-0.0515165552,
-0.0302089565,
0.0155559247,
-0.0479222238,
0.0690546408,
-0.0168940034,
-0.0089459261,
0.0276239458,
-0.0483900942,
-0.0724156201,
0.067054905,
-0.0074513042,
-0.004632785,
-0.0037981803,
0.0191115774,
-0.0153694497,
-0.040899612,
-0.0044053094,
0.010755646,
-0.0266354177,
0.0262114163,
0.016750155,
0.0182498824,
-0.0185458753,
-0.0275082998,
-0.0768222213,
0.0325154923,
-0.0426357463,
-0.030616587,
0.0114729535,
0.0427621938,
0.0155982459,
-0.0279719625,
0.0235543624,
-0.0089337779,
0.0121534076,
0.038826108,
0.0136669762,
0.0315496027,
-0.020198768,
-0.0356420577,
-0.0412676446,
-0.0038618711,
0.0423026048,
-0.0556806773,
0.0097134477,
-0.0307098217,
0.0270803161,
0.0209330507,
0.0358146764,
-0.0204555374,
0.0443586186,
0.0366282724,
-0.0833250359,
0.0110157197,
0.0827647224,
-0.0117204823,
0.0745945349,
0.0069294614,
-0.0137723526,
-0.0940695703,
0.0418513417,
-0.0333697051,
-0.0705200881,
-0.0380128771,
0.0256135855,
0.0377604626,
0.0457587466,
-0.0071032466,
0.0341947936,
-0.045779448,
-0.0023559232,
-0.0098305177,
-0.0322848372,
-0.0720073134,
0.0057016485,
-0.0084478101,
0.0404830724,
-0.0228552315,
-0.0414918102,
0.0673872009,
-0.0207816903,
-0.00577936,
-0.0502797104,
-0.0148445414,
-0.0405431874,
0.0800467655,
0.0214611441,
0.0074482067,
-0.0385191664,
-0.0480315275,
-0.0414088704,
0.000476151,
0.0196778271,
-0.0241198614,
0.0659217834,
-0.0120998733,
0.029291613,
-0.0073113311,
-0.0748170167,
-0.0435785539,
-0.0048332051,
-0.0109431455,
0.0285974182,
-0.0030066278,
0.0165059995,
0.003626656,
-0.0298479293,
0.0068051605,
0.0212493073,
0.0358784236,
-0.0460813306,
-0.0385446176,
-0.0269951336,
0.0247560199,
-0.0070320885,
-0.0341728255,
0.0100927111,
0.0044440818,
0.0378020927,
0.0777695775,
-0.0013597021,
-0.041657187,
0.041773729,
0.0304256417,
-0.0316208415,
-0.0134094348,
0.0559731461,
0.0164752416,
-0.0710348412,
-0.0494044311,
0.0833950415,
0.0218710266,
-0.0512411743,
0.0067921854,
0.0122551126,
0.0089464402,
0.0539500751,
0.0460417531,
-0.0707965195,
-0.0413039401,
0.0171817616,
0.0259032343,
0.010613922,
-0.0191703234,
0.0063955146,
-0.167101264,
0.0281035099,
0.0169969928,
-0.028243836,
-0.041184783,
-0.0519234352,
-0.04337788,
-0.0201154146,
0.0065412819,
0.0616763495,
-0.0363798253,
0.0155835571,
0.0147844637,
0.0800178275,
-0.0019506509,
0.0168230645,
-0.0032381823,
-0.0087561235,
0.0921746194,
-0.0127362125,
0.013437218,
-0.0040321331,
0.0473017506,
-0.0324662216,
-0.0145527963,
-0.0190880764,
-0.0121609205,
-0.0367946699,
-0.0007632766,
0.0168217029,
0.0638393462,
-0.0312468279,
-0.0281818677,
-0.0052031358,
0.0640733391,
-0.0178181827,
0.03603274,
-0.0010102721,
-0.0486316644,
0.0342787132,
0.045299992,
8.394e-7,
-0.0127856256,
-0.0319700874,
-0.0464710779,
0.003535354,
-0.0342014357,
0.0504630916,
0.0101302871,
0.00579273,
0.0367203392,
-0.044806309,
-0.0052485676,
0.0316465423,
0.0871224701,
-0.0191848036,
-0.0162644722,
0.0331311561,
0.0120526804,
-0.0535348281,
0.0312999748,
-0.0177963283,
0.0136802746,
-0.0498190969,
-0.0185910817,
0.0001808406,
-0.0247462802,
-0.0561571307,
0.0102534415,
-0.0352353863,
-0.0280755982,
-0.0330105908,
0.0659389272,
0.0088994922,
0.0847591981,
-0.002940363,
-0.0143263852,
0.0763250142,
0.0590168312,
-0.0204203092,
-0.0148459952,
0.0211299602,
0.0083484547,
0.0147464089,
0.0414289832,
-0.0706863999,
0.0088185295,
0.0168824606,
0.0510633029,
-0.001657357,
0.0084657623,
0.0823471472,
0.0077746129,
0.0202529579,
0.0144418515,
0.0169377215,
-0.0236505754,
0.0162221082,
0.0049160663,
-0.0505563542,
-0.0564503036,
0.0303568877,
0.0337754861,
-0.0414994173,
0.0162682328,
-0.012083794,
0.0436111093,
0.06302315,
-0.0146310143,
-0.0086781336,
0.0123322438,
0.0101171983,
0.0560283102,
0.0050256769,
-0.024795875,
0.0453404523,
-0.0008931821,
0.0487919897,
-0.0297127049,
0.0430917218,
0.0492935069,
0.0201314725,
-0.0776151046,
-0.0111153433,
-0.0154753374,
-0.015152392,
-0.0311162472,
0.0239594877,
0.0646121949,
-0.0170830879,
0.0246503931,
-0.0286857076,
-0.0021620472,
-0.0200184267,
0.0226629917,
-0.0079167224,
-0.0608776398,
0.0197937675,
0.0314412303,
-0.013114986,
-0.0221225247,
0.0921572372,
-0.0057930863,
0.03587294,
0.0045305626,
-0.0006452945,
-0.0463441573,
-0.0350901112,
0.0129578328,
0.0405720286,
-0.0141081726,
-0.0221402477,
0.0207144897,
-0.0529391468,
-0.0152439363,
0.0285903122,
-0.0368042551,
0.0016731101,
0.0414682068,
0.0835784674,
0.015707422,
-0.0304231774,
-0.0193070527,
-0.0097822547,
-0.0025052107,
-0.0332929194,
-0.0602628663,
-5.925474903e-33,
-0.0538332239,
0.005406816,
0.0433665924,
0.0089850277,
-0.0028291768,
-0.020473538,
-0.0598670356,
-0.013899141,
0.0224168636,
0.0001523159,
-0.0227269568,
0.0070005106,
0.0071763094,
0.072243616,
0.0259428341,
0.0067898035,
0.0424095541,
-0.0052345647,
-0.0372701921,
0.007677462,
0.0438726358,
0.0354276821,
0.0204306524,
-0.0352025442,
-0.0304685067,
0.0461479574,
0.0204599872,
0.0644832328,
-0.0185981747,
0.0530921519,
0.0261020567,
0.0307593886,
0.0133712897,
-0.0470610522,
-0.0250642896,
0.0101713194,
-0.0920081288,
-0.0155192241,
0.0144715142,
-0.0135941999,
-0.0186748989,
-0.0134600028,
0.0402504429,
-0.0136916135,
0.0127858529,
-0.016680954,
0.0124198887,
-0.0021157418,
-0.0264393035,
-0.0453495793,
-0.0496970601,
0.0017188019,
-0.0001585428,
-0.0036920367,
0.0295495838,
0.0098560685,
0.020431431,
0.0442884006,
-0.0306089763,
-0.0143176699,
-0.0698609054,
0.0681931973,
0.0443104804,
0.043783199,
0.0609156378,
0.0270562191,
-0.0371112265,
0.0022849676,
-0.0359756537,
-0.0256971009,
0.009946377,
0.0617096163,
-0.0343358032,
0.0368652642,
0.0263598505,
-0.0127963303,
-0.0467125922,
0.0074387286,
-0.0029726175,
0.0865296796,
0.0104827397,
0.0661035404,
-0.0279022641,
-0.0091671357,
-0.0365944318,
0.0057352646,
-0.0039747353,
-0.0270368531,
0.0615825579,
0.0484653339,
-0.0095397485,
0.0012492316,
0.0468889438,
-0.0395141244,
-0.0249543302,
0.0118466597,
-0.0249701254,
-0.0091362288,
-0.0211233776,
0.0333793238,
-0.0430293232,
-0.0636242554,
0.0042574368,
-0.0286891982,
0.0033529468,
0.0179175287,
0.049890779,
0.0180461239,
-0.0480078049,
0.0127645051,
-0.0690822303,
0.037913166,
-0.043389231,
0.0543275066,
0.0641296208,
0.0372243635,
-0.0078441342,
-0.000891738,
-0.0071582105,
-0.0326175131,
-0.0471357331,
-0.0409534797,
-0.0165066384,
-0.0407568887,
-0.0191138051,
-0.0048412126,
-0.0556858107,
0.0196734499,
0.0212294161,
-0.0384259,
-0.0011303044,
0.0229577068,
2.822e-7,
0.0164754912,
0.0127903447,
0.02443121,
0.0197341684,
0.025355367,
0.0303002689,
-0.0174402017,
0.0185255371,
0.0268639047,
-0.0302811116,
0.0062700077,
-0.0136251431,
0.0425192192,
0.0278340876,
-0.0984265283,
-0.001423538,
-0.0470707081,
0.0090639498,
-0.0330593437,
-0.0377520509,
0.0321987085,
0.105738394,
0.0156517569,
-0.0089278938,
0.0292117428,
-0.0445589982,
0.0581060685,
-0.0106812315,
0.0149765452,
-0.0051688286,
-0.0381452143,
0.0599801317,
0.0357721224,
-0.0241344869,
-0.0013994537,
0.0669083968,
-0.0180524401,
0.0572141334,
-0.0157343913,
-0.0314005055,
-0.0012880994,
-0.0106842816,
0.0079546701,
-0.0416454487,
0.0413600318,
-0.0878838599,
0.0220015738,
-0.0076022586,
-0.0460502915,
-0.0227066986,
-0.0303106904,
0.0073462455,
0.0086735031,
0.029801609,
0.0263401195,
0.0177694075,
0.0045497706,
-0.0829820782,
-0.0264203679,
0.026353227,
-0.0423047878,
0.0146812089,
-0.0178097188,
0.0534703769,
0.0026617567,
-0.0424938463,
-0.012784359,
2.857369168e-34,
0.0097013386,
0.0067525897,
0.0411697626,
0.0387762636,
0.0311596375,
0.0061426121,
-0.0318306051,
0.0387997665,
0.0060246005,
-0.055366125,
-0.0247180443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14737v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14737v1 | Dissecting the Ullman Variations with a SCALPEL: Why do LLMs fail at Trivial Alterations to the False Belief Task? | 2024-06-20T21:02:30 | 2024-06-20T21:02:30 | Zhiqiang Pi, Annapurna Vadaparty, Benjamin K. Bergen, Cameron R. Jones | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent empirical results have sparked a debate about whether or not Large
Language Models (LLMs) are capable of Theory of Mind (ToM). While some have
found LLMs to be successful on ToM evaluations such as the False Belief task
(Kosinski, 2023), others have argued that LLMs solve these tasks by exploiting
spurious correlations -- not representing beliefs -- since they fail on trivial
alterations to these tasks (Ullman, 2023). In this paper, we introduce SCALPEL:
a technique to generate targeted modifications for False Belief tasks to test
different specific hypotheses about why LLMs fail. We find that modifications
which make explicit common inferences -- such as that looking at a transparent
object implies recognizing its contents -- preserve LLMs' performance. This
suggests that LLMs' failures on modified ToM tasks could result from a lack of
more general commonsense reasoning, rather than a failure to represent mental
states. We argue that SCALPEL could be helpful for explaining LLM successes and
failures in other cases. | [
0.0438145772,
0.080347769,
-0.0478932709,
0.0440632962,
-0.0627630427,
0.0205652732,
0.0070548146,
-0.0014648874,
0.0269265417,
-0.0508559532,
-0.0540333241,
-0.013970877,
0.0492667109,
0.0156563185,
0.0424390249,
-0.0465078093,
0.0386914648,
-0.0374510959,
-0.005394116,
-0.0309402067,
-0.0515983403,
-0.0066483798,
-0.0245527178,
-0.0055836574,
0.0142548755,
0.0012587461,
-0.0175270606,
-0.0010725879,
0.0243929364,
-0.0180389583,
-0.0439683646,
0.020302834,
0.0236012451,
0.0809546113,
0.0000019775,
-0.060923595,
0.0381726287,
-0.0279408302,
-0.0239720475,
0.0527972616,
0.0182164107,
-0.0117107993,
0.0293971561,
0.0011564016,
-0.0035040977,
-0.0119060362,
0.0296780616,
0.0901252553,
0.0056889053,
0.0720862374,
-0.0044624242,
0.0028469365,
0.0292261671,
-0.0200712308,
0.0841209888,
-0.032830067,
0.0399504006,
-0.0254122019,
-0.0126555674,
-0.0214258488,
-0.0203112625,
-0.0132670235,
0.0029056836,
0.0283046961,
-0.057545457,
0.017124299,
-0.0889738351,
-0.0289621316,
0.001603515,
0.0454301536,
0.0659892559,
-0.0471363887,
0.0022963786,
0.014667484,
0.0120724859,
0.0728865564,
-0.0067499708,
0.02862834,
-0.0129478108,
0.0156917553,
0.0242006853,
0.0083909323,
0.0416186824,
0.0240917709,
-0.0545573272,
0.0751882717,
0.0025412061,
-0.0108144851,
-0.0022367367,
-0.0012840866,
-0.0696124285,
-0.0612412691,
-0.0520625822,
-0.0052792584,
-0.021707546,
-0.0000570203,
-0.0486991778,
0.0035812163,
-0.0053736488,
-0.0219763741,
0.0696749017,
0.037756063,
-0.0201683268,
0.045391988,
-0.0346176438,
0.0561452881,
-0.0436802208,
0.0504165441,
0.0002991648,
0.0079491409,
-0.0399945416,
-0.0164285116,
0.0380166695,
0.0104310354,
0.0446370654,
-0.0118844453,
-0.0191856269,
-0.0214925129,
-0.0298186149,
-0.0056264843,
-0.0654374734,
0.0010840086,
0.0169452615,
-0.0236147866,
-0.0374096073,
0.0342764892,
0.0006641133,
0.0527501479,
-0.0073556979,
-0.0730027631,
-0.0238432661,
0.0170872472,
0.0000016677,
0.005944503,
0.0059687281,
0.0412180535,
0.0240685306,
-0.0362505168,
-0.0164569747,
0.0090218717,
-0.0117094535,
-0.0524261929,
0.0209766272,
-0.0422159061,
-0.0052891364,
0.0141612329,
-0.0101645542,
-0.0210158024,
0.0058647171,
-0.0206334833,
-0.0728179067,
0.0702902377,
-0.0003999964,
0.021328032,
-0.0005093379,
0.0182284862,
-0.0156273264,
0.0172769651,
0.0119056348,
0.0114756618,
0.0025405947,
0.0332657211,
0.0307016503,
0.0026031001,
0.0181663372,
0.0018648111,
-0.0385895111,
-0.0173345208,
-0.0128694251,
0.0305612478,
0.0414519608,
0.0407259353,
-0.0122655081,
-0.0190998185,
0.0760171786,
0.034852162,
-0.0526351556,
-0.0252798386,
0.0276419148,
0.0089210235,
0.0329602621,
0.0472352318,
-0.0653644204,
0.0209334753,
-0.0785441771,
-0.0209970362,
0.0076020495,
0.020194849,
-0.035986878,
0.009196775,
-0.0410650149,
-0.0032791363,
0.0139915142,
0.0308726821,
0.0396906622,
-0.0225873236,
-0.0004363022,
0.0067029344,
0.0388733372,
-0.0028868762,
-0.0084718531,
-0.0891749561,
0.0073663378,
0.0176704787,
0.040059492,
0.0023565947,
-0.0166016091,
0.0128133958,
-0.0155811002,
0.0800362453,
0.0689787343,
0.0222308468,
-0.0208347719,
-0.0084669348,
-0.0030610547,
-0.0531981736,
0.047662966,
0.0322228819,
-0.0515588559,
-0.0238744039,
0.0016341618,
-0.0543365069,
0.0553377084,
0.0211389065,
-0.0015326417,
-0.0088289324,
-0.0623446442,
-0.0023871509,
0.032149367,
-0.0045235236,
-0.0078293299,
0.0097277043,
0.0121541163,
0.004373481,
0.0095980894,
0.0244325045,
0.0037983863,
-0.0091896355,
0.0145290345,
-0.0255441237,
-0.0503595881,
0.0885134637,
-0.0066232453,
-0.0372931324,
0.0556729659,
-0.0260370541,
0.0336326435,
-0.0160720479,
0.0213260502,
-0.0468079671,
0.0010541182,
0.0178556461,
0.0817140788,
-0.034527842,
0.0082804272,
0.0310502257,
-0.0489386134,
0.0306137484,
-0.033368215,
-0.0128695751,
-0.0098871859,
0.0184479933,
-0.0222912151,
-0.0031372164,
-0.022977436,
0.0019854521,
-0.0238843337,
-0.0729630738,
-0.057027027,
0.0160248447,
-0.0356120542,
0.0236562267,
-0.0247227214,
-0.0253444016,
0.0224529952,
-0.0182182062,
0.0468000248,
0.0216576494,
0.0251787417,
0.0032342628,
-0.0489142425,
-0.0168401077,
-0.0201367624,
0.0355811566,
-0.0507854149,
0.0385960937,
-0.0000517982,
-0.0302266851,
-0.0464289263,
0.0552971289,
-0.081283398,
0.0209276862,
-0.0318604857,
-0.0405748971,
0.0207977816,
0.0172889344,
0.0206876341,
0.0855505019,
-0.0168079622,
0.0058671394,
0.0769721121,
0.0086291879,
-0.0286862869,
-0.0238408484,
0.0230775345,
-0.0047784108,
-0.0507746898,
-0.0905439109,
-0.0066740201,
0.0591841415,
0.0601837412,
-0.0148345456,
-0.0613341071,
0.0675634965,
-0.0060691889,
-0.0625986457,
0.0085180225,
-0.0165338386,
-0.0226489566,
0.0854896754,
-0.0174373165,
-0.0524513274,
0.0750364587,
-0.0298552457,
0.0281479433,
0.0010206894,
0.0463380106,
-0.0245532207,
0.0501681902,
0.0338056572,
0.0126873208,
0.0151131386,
0.0098545784,
-0.0575892627,
-0.0147431204,
-0.0208492838,
0.0030709377,
-0.0198321026,
-0.055468671,
-0.0047606155,
0.0194393881,
-0.0068232915,
-0.0424211621,
-0.0181423575,
-0.0423671789,
-0.0271297209,
-0.030925151,
0.0036682349,
-0.0665912852,
-0.0280247368,
0.0667265877,
0.0047402801,
-0.0013628775,
-0.0212706756,
-0.0105916532,
-0.01900612,
0.0382374525,
0.0021114745,
0.0718489215,
-0.051970195,
-0.0079668052,
0.0441053733,
0.0272602309,
0.0579233058,
-0.0047142822,
0.0079888357,
0.0155788166,
0.0558914989,
-0.0158203933,
0.0298264045,
0.0659713373,
0.0048606782,
-0.0151575254,
0.1174532846,
0.0441392735,
-0.0067279474,
0.0094043678,
-0.0077641746,
0.0011112536,
0.0240163784,
-0.0151261305,
-0.0288550016,
-0.016842071,
0.0077224784,
0.0012489369,
-0.047407981,
-0.0535471402,
0.0011706348,
-0.0803769901,
-0.0054336074,
0.0140026128,
0.0289216675,
-0.0136360712,
-0.0361505747,
0.0340399817,
0.0011478332,
0.029690098,
0.0157767851,
0.020018084,
-0.0065553151,
-0.0387679003,
0.0087416368,
-0.0688833073,
0.0437176786,
-0.001350941,
0.0869873017,
0.0500957705,
0.0187259056,
-0.0090252189,
-0.083762154,
0.0171703734,
0.0148329753,
0.0032520401,
-0.0126688629,
0.0047739325,
0.0052980678,
0.0070911278,
-0.0327989757,
0.040368475,
-0.0361337401,
-0.031839218,
-0.0308674015,
0.0508696027,
-0.0372537114,
-0.0588827729,
0.0165658891,
0.0056466488,
-0.0670918003,
0.0900704563,
0.0281036813,
-0.0451216511,
0.0075781099,
-0.0191771425,
-0.0351980664,
0.0420487002,
-0.0480277278,
0.0310426448,
0.0468696691,
-0.007457145,
-0.0560111552,
-0.0079018921,
0.0092448844,
0.0214600675,
0.0239071734,
-0.0174167268,
0.0096659809,
-0.0143220806,
-0.0275357552,
0.0149460305,
-0.0489966087,
-0.0235492066,
-0.0123940576,
-0.0168056376,
0.0082403393,
-0.0582550019,
-0.0020846154,
0.0081726052,
-0.0420072824,
-0.0971253738,
0.0337471254,
0.0093757864,
0.0382925905,
0.0038250675,
0.0296310093,
-0.0270858016,
0.0307222884,
-0.0352838039,
-0.0240392815,
0.0900988132,
0.008752903,
0.0398827679,
0.0117770573,
0.0597043447,
-0.0071261893,
0.0192206763,
0.050872013,
0.0030752569,
-0.0035444086,
-0.0088817198,
0.0350431725,
0.0256860405,
0.0527035333,
0.0166639034,
0.0676874071,
-0.0028241987,
-0.0161209013,
-0.0421386696,
0.0039382395,
-0.0145067284,
-0.0339539424,
0.0488144532,
0.0620440654,
-0.0286910739,
-0.0474486388,
-0.0421064571,
0.0380213521,
-0.0040452098,
-0.0282011423,
-0.0060865534,
0.0080470359,
-0.0080015175,
-0.0042223488,
-0.0059602936,
0.0270988438,
-0.0590222813,
0.0170311239,
0.0215206482,
0.0998295695,
0.0192200765,
-0.0315200537,
-0.0466528162,
-0.0155336736,
-0.0710259452,
-0.0614038967,
0.0617369413,
0.0183569342,
-0.0209629089,
-0.0122269178,
0.0206237864,
-0.074804768,
0.0200612936,
-0.0042561176,
0.0217608288,
0.0174855702,
-0.0202533677,
0.0280251,
-0.0038730635,
-0.016271472,
0.0060055577,
0.0681122765,
-0.0113773076,
0.0337994881,
-0.00805909,
-0.0186529979,
-0.0366933271,
-0.0026122807,
0.0127217425,
0.0581892505,
-0.0175869558,
0.0272919256,
-0.0674254075,
-0.0409912318,
0.0240217634,
0.0167925786,
0.019618012,
-0.0348667465,
-0.0158266965,
0.0731978044,
-0.0021271186,
-0.015854137,
0.0174395815,
-0.0190582741,
0.0229523666,
-0.0026212584,
-0.0144247757,
-6.509240458e-33,
-0.0156252794,
-0.0011280604,
-0.0308004487,
-0.0006691495,
-0.003792376,
0.0005018097,
-0.0447418429,
0.0299576931,
-0.0075604613,
-0.0173457619,
0.013930128,
0.0108971205,
-0.0059977025,
0.0152749978,
0.0170765352,
0.0001110815,
0.0252880249,
0.0211403202,
-0.0435928553,
-0.048391562,
0.0317110717,
-0.0369752347,
0.0490326434,
-0.0353778042,
0.0490492806,
0.014087881,
0.0074943146,
0.0395325758,
-0.06541951,
0.0014211984,
-0.0339869075,
0.0291244537,
0.0362203158,
0.0190720335,
0.0038549353,
-0.0214653369,
-0.0189316403,
-0.043021623,
0.0652512461,
-0.0074077244,
0.0099579422,
-0.0260011237,
0.002263956,
-0.012762161,
-0.0677033812,
0.0243788138,
0.015625,
-0.0035776517,
0.0440723896,
0.0679313764,
-0.039176695,
-0.0375454351,
0.0219959877,
-0.0156805571,
-0.0083840787,
0.0169493742,
-0.0149640366,
-0.0357090868,
-0.0721936673,
0.0316806026,
0.022129653,
-0.0281144585,
0.0621015057,
-0.0191488639,
0.0339224264,
0.08829806,
0.0643344969,
0.0281174444,
-0.0493657738,
-0.014018883,
0.0501492545,
0.0160068646,
0.0499991477,
0.0592404753,
0.0208916329,
-0.0057593863,
-0.0460360423,
-0.009170318,
0.0073894383,
0.0358384028,
0.0797382295,
0.0212260652,
-0.0368020795,
-0.0135508319,
-0.040855024,
-0.0090887016,
-0.0519627556,
-0.0034351894,
0.0094706807,
-0.0026500484,
-0.0336712413,
-0.0543678626,
0.038138289,
-0.0067141759,
0.0227403603,
-0.0362388045,
-0.0085024592,
0.0354096442,
-0.0043486222,
-0.0069841393,
-0.0492590964,
-0.0082056345,
0.0367416069,
0.0045040492,
0.0380493291,
0.0116868829,
-0.0202452596,
-0.0086584771,
-0.0419295393,
-0.013403723,
-0.0244999584,
-0.0049063503,
0.0068476661,
-0.0532676764,
0.0780929476,
0.0261643473,
-0.0249254722,
-0.0707018599,
-0.0014899832,
-0.0684754103,
-0.0488421172,
0.0593637489,
-0.0291016698,
0.0134379445,
-0.0271453895,
-0.0172574557,
-0.0252591912,
-0.0303117763,
0.0002151613,
-0.0497819297,
-0.0268293116,
-0.0049106046,
2.843e-7,
-0.0153032998,
0.0866206288,
-0.0206408612,
0.0082642138,
0.0491907597,
0.0515137427,
-0.0377191566,
0.0144226504,
0.0346105024,
-0.0871463865,
-0.050819587,
0.0402669311,
0.0387488976,
0.0238290355,
-0.0316526629,
0.0160935856,
0.0304438118,
-0.0121883284,
-0.0370314829,
0.0332960188,
0.0371292047,
0.0350507312,
0.0519391708,
-0.0053889249,
0.0199786406,
-0.0031994046,
0.0556294657,
-0.0333401263,
-0.0141496882,
-0.0128748417,
0.0073721143,
-0.000092428,
0.0112784291,
0.0458447039,
0.0508792438,
0.0068098847,
-0.0274868552,
-0.0020599503,
-0.0224766526,
-0.0317869708,
-0.0351193845,
-0.0047266609,
-0.0178374704,
-0.0624969415,
0.0596145764,
-0.062564835,
-0.0818545371,
0.0113659818,
0.0129349353,
0.0084649501,
0.0147454385,
0.0150920069,
-0.025735978,
0.0074013188,
0.013759804,
0.0276715048,
-0.0069923899,
-0.0405263305,
-0.0003250173,
-0.0031745529,
-0.0520234257,
-0.0672942922,
-0.0413151942,
-0.0217411462,
0.0279383883,
-0.0691707805,
0.0118857501,
2.627048499e-34,
0.0101266587,
-0.0041706427,
0.0034231239,
-0.0382228792,
0.0229436364,
-0.0227423515,
-0.0146814976,
0.0356148854,
0.0401043706,
-0.1012726575,
0.005729876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14732v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14732v1 | TTQA-RS- A break-down prompting approach for Multi-hop Table-Text Question Answering with Reasoning and Summarization | 2024-06-20T20:55:38 | 2024-06-20T20:55:38 | Jayetri Bardhan, Bushi Xiao, Daisy Zhe Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Question answering (QA) over tables and text has gained much popularity over
the years. Multi-hop table-text QA requires multiple hops between the table and
text, making it a challenging QA task. Although several works have attempted to
solve the table-text QA task, most involve training the models and requiring
labeled data. In this paper, we have proposed a model - TTQA-RS: A break-down
prompting approach for Multi-hop Table-Text Question Answering with Reasoning
and Summarization. Our model uses augmented knowledge including table-text
summary with decomposed sub-question with answer for a reasoning-based
table-text QA. Using open-source language models our model outperformed all
existing prompting methods for table-text QA tasks on existing table-text QA
datasets like HybridQA and OTT-QA's development set. Our results are comparable
with the training-based state-of-the-art models, demonstrating the potential of
prompt-based approaches using open-source LLMs. Additionally, by using GPT-4
with LLaMA3-70B, our model achieved state-of-the-art performance for
prompting-based methods on multi-hop table-text QA. | [
0.0173908789,
0.0213954449,
0.0084007736,
0.0142159006,
-0.0312858336,
0.0328097828,
-0.0066611702,
-0.0113634747,
0.0250319503,
-0.0293507464,
-0.02603711,
-0.0088153007,
-0.0391425043,
0.0175143965,
0.0351685919,
0.0149619989,
0.0619622059,
-0.002499212,
-0.0422769226,
-0.008060745,
0.0260560103,
-0.003205576,
-0.0321077853,
-0.002532328,
0.0085219145,
-0.0256030485,
-0.0397024453,
-0.0265040565,
-0.0117059937,
0.0153279835,
0.0109826634,
0.0678412691,
0.0211093407,
-0.0108329402,
0.0000017996,
-0.0080442103,
-0.0644903108,
-0.0193757769,
-0.0475399494,
-0.0085890638,
-0.0198738519,
0.0153513383,
0.0261418857,
0.0219674949,
-0.0338245332,
0.0158282053,
-0.0217468217,
0.081662789,
0.0779786259,
0.027572969,
0.0336794406,
-0.0281602461,
-0.0026466632,
0.0109703131,
0.0456456505,
-0.0496340021,
-0.0083018057,
0.0326775126,
0.0505005121,
0.0086967284,
0.0130080935,
0.0464314036,
0.0430850536,
0.0141268009,
-0.026503399,
0.0337226391,
-0.0110790208,
0.0532980971,
-0.0184716489,
0.1181231812,
0.052359309,
-0.0081980182,
0.0235231798,
0.0145190628,
0.0425738096,
-0.0267978925,
-0.0537986755,
0.0218614619,
-0.0082237786,
-0.0173819009,
0.0143027632,
-0.0017485978,
-0.0226034503,
0.0008664588,
-0.0138292704,
0.0768057108,
-0.0073161209,
-0.0564108267,
0.0052318806,
-0.0205851458,
-0.0031225383,
-0.0356387831,
0.0115488619,
0.0736388117,
-0.0289258473,
0.0348948576,
0.0179513469,
-0.0144940615,
0.0365419239,
-0.0108494656,
-0.0148534123,
0.0532340109,
-0.0060731703,
0.0323399827,
-0.0493260026,
0.0222810619,
-0.0014222461,
0.0334528796,
-0.0573911704,
-0.0394100547,
-0.0422935374,
-0.0187799316,
-0.0573248789,
0.0569339693,
-0.0750657395,
-0.004016493,
0.010112552,
0.0261692032,
0.0293828417,
0.0284028072,
0.021442676,
0.0365394391,
0.0205137711,
0.0209005475,
-0.0386490002,
0.0021911727,
-0.0708917975,
0.0106995851,
0.0023787899,
-0.0485571586,
-0.0431141183,
-0.0216811411,
0.0165193919,
-0.0003664584,
0.0284014028,
0.0606949888,
-0.0582876503,
-0.0336591341,
-0.0259805843,
-0.0299834237,
-0.0207196213,
-0.0429475643,
-0.0142476587,
-0.0367492177,
0.0381239355,
-0.000023185,
0.0048420937,
-0.0070272083,
0.0255490392,
0.0784046501,
-0.0206974726,
0.0517332517,
0.0258844439,
0.0076095434,
0.0256329458,
0.0032492757,
-0.0142476689,
0.0697849691,
0.0158199798,
-0.0034746407,
-0.0103977248,
0.0146599691,
-0.0273537505,
0.0222730059,
0.0436566658,
0.0068233488,
0.0156885348,
0.0628966466,
0.0129435482,
0.0348956548,
-0.0151511356,
0.0343787223,
-0.0153898457,
0.0341763459,
0.0123513667,
0.0493751019,
-0.0026735759,
0.0383665413,
0.0022643812,
0.017552359,
0.0426522791,
0.0297096446,
-0.0244997405,
0.05412025,
-0.0207493696,
0.0318102986,
0.0653967634,
0.009504078,
-0.048288092,
-0.0497907586,
0.0087924786,
0.0017016976,
-0.0232299436,
0.0353942104,
0.0161241107,
0.0303805619,
-0.0819559768,
0.006568504,
-0.0075885742,
-0.044490654,
-0.0286793392,
-0.0396849178,
0.074584797,
0.0458179116,
0.017891882,
-0.062586084,
-0.0213024728,
-0.022074759,
0.0214497782,
0.0102347117,
-0.0187175982,
-0.0425336361,
-0.0256469902,
-0.0057748253,
-0.0169062242,
0.0054723597,
0.0259250384,
-0.0269656014,
0.0129075004,
0.0075717997,
-0.0015488507,
-0.0434709713,
0.0107036931,
0.0336371996,
0.0243671723,
-0.0215218905,
-0.0172682256,
-0.0114055155,
-0.0064781434,
0.0535523109,
0.0164262913,
0.0253840536,
0.043947909,
-0.0400981456,
-0.0108793955,
-0.0225511175,
-0.0135062793,
-0.0667114109,
0.0315812156,
0.0450826474,
-0.0343427211,
-0.0104958564,
-0.0597884208,
-0.0725833848,
-0.0012096354,
-0.0227027535,
-0.0534960628,
-0.051376529,
-0.0306103062,
0.0500302091,
0.0060493778,
-0.0230847858,
0.0900202915,
-0.0245280322,
0.0233535971,
0.0126136402,
-0.0571984462,
0.014362514,
-0.0411470644,
0.0237423424,
-0.0405935757,
-0.0116749238,
0.0251575969,
-0.011842275,
0.0479230024,
-0.0670153648,
-0.0074171023,
-0.0947725475,
0.0494901054,
-0.0510867089,
0.0328868367,
0.0359991565,
0.0192539301,
-0.0202171039,
-0.0249578841,
-0.0772763938,
-0.0228311568,
0.0258280784,
-0.0045278231,
0.0684324428,
0.003373604,
0.0063326876,
-0.0403678641,
-0.0135085918,
-0.0094808415,
0.0304730888,
-0.0244533997,
-0.0417209081,
-0.0212805662,
-0.0545821115,
-0.0214710683,
0.0114244651,
0.0247357208,
-0.0103528695,
-0.0157720596,
-0.0051866798,
0.0571253113,
0.0142318336,
-0.0365278535,
-0.0086863684,
0.0190117918,
0.0198279079,
-0.0376592167,
0.0477831885,
-0.0144456979,
0.0151275471,
0.0659847111,
-0.0521550216,
0.0472004674,
0.0505054668,
-0.0047013755,
-0.019974269,
-0.0389213003,
0.0140472781,
0.0068834797,
0.0216860399,
-0.0852847323,
0.0483447164,
-0.0056111375,
0.0082875192,
-0.0071827183,
0.011919749,
0.0454962291,
-0.0229815748,
0.0062025767,
-0.067625396,
-0.0136072356,
-0.0753679648,
0.0430083647,
-0.0178795271,
0.0069308197,
-0.009535403,
-0.0116056269,
-0.0376064107,
-0.022873247,
-0.0219083037,
-0.0411351435,
0.10821376,
-0.0473306105,
0.0305864085,
-0.0057684178,
-0.0117571848,
-0.01487274,
-0.0210882295,
-0.0383583196,
0.0327478126,
-0.0247702971,
0.016684372,
0.0214695316,
-0.022525033,
0.0366839878,
0.053003557,
-0.0306118168,
0.0067686639,
-0.0335921124,
0.0698570907,
0.050378032,
0.0317587741,
-0.0009463861,
-0.0106030935,
0.0660783574,
0.0401017964,
0.0297900438,
-0.0388770998,
0.0248330925,
0.0149854487,
0.0252830442,
-0.0363490283,
0.0168211274,
0.0238037445,
0.0150344977,
-0.0448333435,
-0.0176995452,
0.0793386325,
0.0506156348,
0.0178051908,
-0.0092726108,
-0.0143977767,
0.0279658139,
0.0005606034,
0.0586060807,
-0.1148220748,
-0.0606914684,
-0.0257825907,
0.0038889041,
0.0357747898,
-0.0220059752,
-0.0101772137,
-0.0764666572,
0.0037819506,
-0.0524682701,
-0.0749090016,
-0.0544027872,
-0.0169953723,
0.0000574369,
0.0105680199,
0.0331832357,
0.0555063933,
-0.0281917006,
0.033305645,
0.020286737,
-0.0270321965,
0.0045462558,
0.0077453,
-0.045708444,
0.0239759255,
0.0717208385,
0.0058212979,
-0.0207193978,
-0.0195210334,
0.0259732883,
-0.0709693134,
0.0094781769,
0.0070943041,
0.016125137,
-0.0121867917,
0.012334574,
-0.0193761084,
0.0356302597,
-0.0292217787,
0.0027929577,
0.0457076691,
0.0592611358,
-0.0197815225,
0.0009387798,
0.0017669005,
0.030151004,
-0.0185226649,
0.0903617144,
0.0440410115,
-0.0025860949,
-0.0556067936,
-0.0183194838,
-0.0583663397,
-0.053800676,
0.0286086686,
0.0386891663,
-0.0122170495,
0.0377318524,
-0.0852093026,
-0.0289981775,
0.0767951459,
0.0161294956,
-0.0153289987,
0.0708532035,
-0.0614013076,
0.0109055871,
-0.0204636883,
-0.0078655714,
-0.0490579195,
0.0144367032,
-0.0314006954,
-0.0060215569,
0.0386587605,
-0.0467722677,
-0.0197642613,
0.0054682246,
-0.0679072365,
-0.0162025448,
-0.0307453219,
0.0285923369,
0.0159278587,
0.0020892122,
-0.0032239098,
-0.0053360024,
0.0001514634,
-0.0217541102,
-0.0332237743,
-0.00170213,
0.0058739469,
0.0306919049,
0.0056020436,
0.0464308411,
-0.0537306219,
-0.01289347,
-0.0406273603,
0.057905525,
-0.0308909174,
-0.0017070727,
0.0410303921,
-0.0072581712,
-0.0253854003,
0.0421608314,
-0.0331998579,
-0.0240187347,
0.0587400235,
-0.0306848474,
-0.0422294997,
-0.0223451797,
0.0356332809,
-0.005707527,
-0.0681889951,
-0.0133872349,
-0.0238119029,
-0.0181115456,
0.0496742614,
-0.0293948147,
0.0090657733,
0.0251756441,
-0.0412169583,
-0.0177208651,
-0.0438450091,
-0.0291823111,
-0.0372182205,
0.0044010067,
0.0267297644,
0.0030782849,
0.0372061878,
0.0374632217,
-0.0428505056,
-0.0335235,
0.0579547323,
-0.056204576,
-0.0405833721,
0.0049740216,
0.0248306599,
0.0045850244,
0.0315415636,
-0.0056669833,
0.0205107667,
-0.0057853237,
0.0326180942,
0.0051016756,
0.023587143,
0.0168020483,
0.0677694604,
0.0081889313,
0.0056879837,
0.0039741872,
0.0800771564,
0.0053075119,
0.031780418,
0.0038805241,
0.0146604916,
-0.0482044779,
-0.007914355,
-0.0315753967,
0.0017327617,
-0.0289433915,
-0.0184872206,
-0.0301081575,
-0.0086183446,
0.0246716142,
0.0241707284,
-0.0443257764,
-0.0235040784,
0.0442461744,
0.0312261172,
0.0633907691,
-0.0415501818,
-0.0539139882,
0.0051219226,
-0.001829891,
-0.039509926,
0.0134550603,
-6.059031999e-33,
-0.0319421776,
-0.0132198511,
0.0328318551,
-0.0467174612,
-0.0018016739,
-0.0146878613,
-0.0388080738,
-0.051766485,
-0.0340882353,
-0.010720701,
-0.0387007073,
0.0404434986,
0.0123270461,
0.0185923241,
-0.0132911419,
-0.0913216695,
-0.0061057042,
-0.0315984637,
-0.0021141539,
0.0251158457,
0.0080233887,
0.029786393,
-0.006057953,
0.0543066226,
0.0546857566,
-0.0371696167,
-0.0225820132,
0.005976548,
-0.0275117792,
0.0272467267,
-0.0536868572,
-0.0036703767,
0.0437761992,
-0.0514861308,
-0.015133041,
0.0674121678,
-0.1461703926,
-0.0351445526,
0.0247149318,
-0.02921989,
-0.0484556779,
-0.0348245054,
-0.0059975334,
-0.0024871328,
0.0300827138,
0.0053457697,
0.0095606335,
-0.0254987907,
-0.0029138664,
-0.0202330798,
0.0146898255,
-0.0038021042,
-0.0260164421,
0.000715861,
0.0066527072,
0.0747597739,
0.020837836,
-0.0046888902,
-0.0346583687,
0.000357927,
0.0380551592,
0.0025290768,
0.0309052467,
-0.0201661922,
-0.0068533896,
0.0096822102,
-0.0029299913,
-0.0359474905,
-0.0591682903,
0.0083192987,
-0.0738683492,
0.0257794857,
0.067620635,
-0.0029381802,
0.0224582385,
0.0464490876,
-0.0650424883,
0.056553673,
0.0010765895,
0.0098761246,
-0.0233733188,
-0.0294043012,
-0.0228862166,
-0.0210378934,
-0.0411427319,
0.0328896753,
-0.0272309799,
-0.0169444047,
0.0282303207,
-0.0074721379,
0.0035292048,
-0.0226059705,
-0.0128521491,
0.0136486869,
-0.0050857826,
0.0191413183,
0.0053639915,
0.0087296851,
0.0075220368,
0.0440702215,
-0.0488452986,
0.0110852066,
0.0266620889,
-0.03745047,
0.0169086065,
0.0348654836,
0.0338448212,
0.0127058001,
-0.0606145188,
0.015523375,
-0.0337358564,
0.0774028748,
-0.0272508655,
0.0177454129,
-0.0157163013,
0.0222204644,
0.0146290911,
0.0709051341,
0.0068309903,
0.0012958114,
0.0004300486,
-0.0142415762,
-0.0138728516,
0.0061014141,
-0.0028327096,
0.0410478972,
-0.0084083294,
0.0665685236,
-0.0253244601,
-0.0412586108,
0.0283009466,
0.0554085448,
2.308e-7,
0.0588709861,
-0.0110259484,
0.0725333914,
0.0424661711,
-0.0319090225,
0.0070422036,
0.0092539163,
0.0120888511,
-0.0023866592,
-0.0217633806,
0.0318996608,
0.0134432744,
0.0349530727,
0.0078167534,
-0.0766488984,
-0.0439310633,
-0.047400251,
-0.0152062317,
-0.0432893559,
-0.0273296349,
0.0863514394,
0.0709044784,
-0.0461332649,
-0.0011703533,
-0.0614767335,
0.001227863,
0.017556468,
-0.0309512857,
0.0092900842,
0.0177722406,
0.0621092394,
-0.0459564701,
0.0064748242,
0.0489786863,
-0.0176005848,
0.0109113399,
0.0225463733,
0.036747966,
0.039499376,
-0.0173997097,
-0.0032524716,
-0.0625500977,
0.0426114984,
-0.0328057334,
0.1315681487,
-0.0274559148,
0.0161142163,
0.0603677928,
-0.0084941136,
-0.0125034079,
0.0100004571,
-0.0049670013,
-0.0199167263,
0.0261376482,
0.0184387285,
-0.0132976156,
0.037469659,
-0.0745141432,
-0.0091954451,
0.0209066812,
-0.0024260881,
-0.0049293218,
-0.0119066434,
-0.0278263334,
-0.0212680865,
-0.0852724388,
-0.0519292727,
2.0861023e-34,
0.0375151448,
-0.0350926109,
0.0175486095,
0.0809070319,
0.023335427,
-0.0344127342,
0.0136031182,
-0.0206808932,
0.0387592316,
-0.0875996053,
-0.0076757576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14721v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14721v1 | 1+1>2: Can Large Language Models Serve as Cross-Lingual Knowledge Aggregators? | 2024-06-20T20:32:53 | 2024-06-20T20:32:53 | Yue Huang, Chenrui Fan, Yuan Li, Siyuan Wu, Tianyi Zhou, Xiangliang Zhang, Lichao Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have garnered significant attention due to their
remarkable ability to process information across various languages. Despite
their capabilities, they exhibit inconsistencies in handling identical queries
in different languages, presenting challenges for further advancement. This
paper introduces a method to enhance the multilingual performance of LLMs by
aggregating knowledge from diverse languages. This approach incorporates a
low-resource knowledge detector specific to a language, a language selection
process, and mechanisms for answer replacement and integration. Our experiments
demonstrate notable performance improvements, particularly in reducing language
performance disparity. An ablation study confirms that each component of our
method significantly contributes to these enhancements. This research
highlights the inherent potential of LLMs to harmonize multilingual
capabilities and offers valuable insights for further exploration. | [
0.0225075018,
0.0555313639,
-0.0205745883,
0.0774481818,
-0.0350841768,
-0.0056319148,
0.0233401414,
0.0099756327,
0.013114443,
-0.0285164975,
-0.0350617096,
-0.0204923488,
-0.0266790669,
-0.0049170596,
0.0050309217,
-0.0020402714,
0.0386980586,
-0.0494392961,
0.0090840627,
-0.0473971218,
0.0091562709,
0.0499565341,
0.033253938,
-0.0062271319,
0.0168668833,
-0.0023994138,
0.0227916092,
-0.022071857,
-0.0060310145,
0.0101826219,
-0.0048453375,
0.0305684395,
-0.0156052886,
0.0532186814,
0.0000020092,
-0.0595003888,
-0.0358946584,
0.0173361432,
-0.0135064377,
0.0017219021,
0.0164877754,
-0.0107914647,
0.0123904496,
0.0148767941,
-0.0332117379,
-0.022922134,
0.028437268,
0.017331494,
0.0287054759,
0.0232215207,
-0.0020952481,
0.0045438311,
0.0006475304,
-0.0127704376,
0.0188837629,
-0.0488906279,
0.0311073586,
0.0149775287,
0.0505118333,
0.0034016536,
-0.0164059047,
0.0485285223,
0.0007098307,
-0.0301687215,
-0.0058950009,
0.0245930366,
-0.0627921224,
0.0061184913,
-0.0014953202,
0.0340321437,
-0.0208501723,
-0.0159870088,
-0.0168500096,
0.0326749869,
-0.0040371674,
0.0293458942,
-0.0592668615,
-0.0226523206,
0.0026021325,
0.0035374321,
0.0294981878,
-0.0042665042,
0.0224556215,
0.0174162015,
-0.0378830321,
0.0721720159,
0.0448402315,
-0.0147386175,
-0.0085866367,
0.0034761971,
0.0246422812,
-0.0871136189,
0.0086217141,
0.0560288392,
-0.044585757,
0.0335822813,
-0.0079046926,
-0.0188675281,
0.0516794547,
-0.0600746237,
-0.0349910781,
0.0259174276,
-0.021355737,
0.1079701781,
-0.037558645,
0.0255402289,
-0.0307159163,
-0.0319379754,
-0.0553186908,
-0.0992514417,
-0.0504871458,
-0.0101257302,
0.0148147838,
0.0586091578,
-0.0137091754,
-0.0066711619,
-0.0233083945,
0.0058131893,
-0.0090089459,
0.0152299497,
0.0008937628,
-0.0189002268,
0.0105348639,
-0.0216021556,
-0.0566371195,
0.0936628804,
-0.0157687683,
-0.029762635,
-0.0317523889,
-0.080489777,
0.0275217257,
0.0004261731,
-0.0047161523,
-0.03570408,
0.0324395783,
0.0561928712,
-0.01148545,
0.0234738775,
-0.0278220978,
-0.0174312759,
0.0068710991,
-0.0472254977,
-0.0015856352,
-0.1137504205,
0.0669441372,
0.0293465015,
0.0111395754,
-0.023103388,
0.0200994145,
0.0079889568,
-0.0282363538,
0.0312223788,
-0.0287877899,
0.0083382204,
0.0502928011,
-0.0088938717,
0.0350266956,
0.1164731011,
-0.0323788002,
-0.023915071,
0.056310758,
0.0038864224,
-0.0193011984,
0.0358671509,
0.0138547355,
0.0496214256,
0.0230050199,
0.0383096188,
0.0135931959,
-0.0142842252,
0.0168767795,
0.056618847,
-0.0201130994,
-0.0056072474,
0.0129691781,
0.0162839107,
-0.0283312965,
0.0371399894,
-0.0044405661,
0.0011477836,
-0.0213297568,
-0.0009359121,
-0.0000169009,
0.037116576,
-0.0190079324,
-0.014632849,
0.0410648808,
0.0768893287,
-0.041960068,
-0.021480253,
-0.0107138734,
-0.0171391014,
-0.029743759,
0.076120846,
0.0605013706,
-0.0305531509,
0.027434973,
0.0876150578,
0.0391555689,
-0.0273197107,
0.0491041951,
-0.0007284352,
0.0004292161,
0.0343647413,
0.0251875352,
-0.0338509791,
0.008199797,
0.0214284062,
-0.0014914793,
0.0340120196,
0.0638669059,
-0.0200081225,
-0.0200447831,
-0.0375540555,
-0.0472781695,
0.009255562,
-0.0071982304,
0.0354501605,
0.0245379489,
0.0479104854,
-0.0055271951,
-0.0486422218,
-0.0220046006,
-0.0167965647,
-0.0334135294,
-0.0002462461,
-0.0074953763,
-0.0014187822,
-0.0125000663,
0.0309014972,
0.0004857357,
0.0119815907,
0.0225056019,
-0.0621040203,
-0.0601237863,
0.014955068,
-0.0016660923,
-0.0132723488,
0.0762259364,
0.001238319,
-0.0418301821,
-0.0305121392,
-0.0143707208,
-0.0425505526,
0.0056576165,
-0.0042974502,
0.0672174916,
-0.0260478165,
0.0055722492,
-0.0145500228,
-0.0165983774,
-0.037594568,
0.0701984242,
0.0084246565,
0.045145873,
0.0275029112,
-0.0392767191,
0.0690821931,
-0.0331176221,
-0.0254054777,
0.0552321151,
-0.0183485039,
0.0135817295,
0.0409741402,
-0.0118199885,
-0.0444407798,
0.001689811,
-0.0784027651,
-0.0051550744,
-0.0004823846,
0.0084442114,
0.0283075832,
0.041094847,
0.0230000857,
0.0002963259,
-0.0707052723,
-0.0032621715,
0.0572177581,
0.0531741269,
-0.0104811601,
0.0055400752,
0.0312550254,
-0.0191593282,
-0.0226666424,
0.0187185556,
0.0489259213,
-0.0202801265,
-0.0102365091,
-0.0258794557,
0.0148286643,
-0.0970064327,
0.0329710096,
-0.0019649828,
-0.0254890267,
-0.042112045,
-0.03585409,
0.0055097672,
0.0218442194,
-0.0440012142,
-0.063755542,
0.0607646629,
-0.0306465179,
-0.0602644309,
0.0003365385,
0.0145954229,
-0.0246229619,
-0.0376330093,
-0.0438654758,
0.007315394,
0.002821302,
-0.000776796,
-0.0199856348,
-0.0440894514,
-0.005070644,
-0.045902174,
-0.0192681663,
-0.0775480717,
-0.0047399164,
0.025774844,
0.0640486553,
-0.0136315897,
0.0014294584,
0.0725876167,
-0.0140204215,
0.0023684343,
-0.0486562103,
0.0022703111,
-0.060988348,
0.0128623853,
-0.0388670154,
0.0592496321,
-0.0460682735,
-0.0121485395,
-0.0391781926,
-0.0047030156,
0.0225905646,
-0.043159321,
0.0639067367,
-0.0209601354,
0.0147741763,
-0.034855891,
-0.0640776008,
-0.0221632998,
0.0038563057,
-0.037567798,
0.0151947746,
0.0266217012,
-0.009573712,
-0.0340247042,
-0.0023743182,
0.0647422373,
-0.0364097953,
-0.0132190753,
-0.0097577479,
0.0127463378,
0.0531430766,
0.0436156765,
-0.0020988558,
0.00690149,
0.0163625591,
0.0376120098,
0.0713322163,
0.035430029,
-0.0510987267,
0.0286412705,
-0.0038229856,
0.0650223941,
-0.0189573206,
-0.0355081409,
-0.0437578149,
0.0029244821,
-0.0144756623,
0.0248283818,
0.0962080136,
0.027449036,
-0.0472560748,
-0.0526202209,
-0.0478979275,
0.0266203433,
0.0418730304,
0.070094429,
-0.1085321009,
0.0151711544,
-0.0039320984,
-0.0163325965,
0.0193956699,
-0.000634224,
-0.0059325323,
-0.1388332546,
0.0063718185,
-0.0112683224,
-0.0469879545,
-0.037469171,
-0.0473854765,
0.0161771756,
-0.0103179831,
-0.0196094792,
0.0228061471,
0.0055404035,
-0.0221908148,
-0.003640672,
-0.0094367443,
-0.0369288996,
0.0169595759,
-0.0258402489,
-0.0106777977,
0.0404112563,
0.049409315,
-0.0225382,
-0.0069527356,
-0.0085330168,
-0.0478909984,
-0.0247329529,
-0.0362389646,
0.0182073526,
0.0396064781,
-0.0187003054,
0.0202201381,
-0.015933916,
-0.0190583523,
0.031190658,
0.0235289801,
0.1294684559,
0.0277067628,
0.0192833412,
-0.0014657184,
-0.0330611542,
0.005262733,
0.0825013816,
-0.0216161087,
-0.0026790288,
-0.0191444252,
-0.0299522504,
-0.0670036972,
0.0018164781,
-0.0400166214,
0.0549215376,
-0.0356030464,
-0.0350371189,
-0.0348552205,
-0.029973859,
0.0430724211,
-0.0128852474,
0.0343458019,
0.0703763738,
0.0053287996,
-0.0087408461,
0.0003464491,
-0.0067970911,
-0.049537044,
0.01416976,
-0.0023849488,
0.0067794593,
0.0091293212,
-0.027031159,
-0.0124909831,
0.0016047399,
-0.028997222,
-0.0682564154,
-0.0249354448,
0.0098504536,
0.0174591262,
0.0325357988,
-0.0348385051,
-0.0506011359,
0.0364054926,
-0.0079778219,
-0.0082212295,
0.0090363035,
-0.0033630212,
0.0058533424,
-0.0064494195,
0.0466442145,
-0.0903561637,
-0.0068908194,
-0.0044882004,
0.010271729,
-0.0455010533,
-0.0230764877,
0.0350020304,
0.0525576025,
-0.045126155,
0.0000559772,
0.0055887336,
-0.0084401006,
0.0105800601,
-0.0376737155,
-0.0431478359,
-0.0000790108,
-0.0016970901,
0.0165019054,
-0.0380881913,
0.0336237289,
0.0356484801,
0.0212357007,
0.002690803,
-0.0309880767,
-0.0049144137,
0.0291922409,
-0.022647636,
0.0583760403,
0.0228533205,
-0.0120676793,
-0.0084892437,
0.0200444479,
0.0249207951,
-0.0620720796,
-0.0063796826,
-0.0029026715,
-0.0409006216,
0.0175265763,
-0.0293484069,
-0.0504478775,
-0.1068188995,
0.0348036624,
0.0103328619,
0.0998798609,
-0.0185216684,
0.0745335147,
-0.0129254824,
-0.0565739684,
-0.0241132826,
-0.0399715565,
0.050698705,
-0.0092056282,
0.0492678992,
0.0296039078,
-0.0102140829,
0.0319083482,
0.0856546164,
-0.0474308692,
0.0234659538,
-0.0064130351,
-0.0104046706,
-0.028220037,
-0.0117620183,
0.0077057867,
0.0162108503,
-0.0440538712,
0.0004283414,
-0.0405435376,
-0.0499237701,
0.0089927018,
-0.0075944257,
-0.0246959329,
0.0112518845,
0.0341041721,
0.0843878463,
0.0495531149,
-0.0071189101,
-0.0514057837,
0.0507268757,
-0.0779429153,
-0.0160156563,
0.0308921747,
-6.260862175e-33,
0.0018048582,
-0.0063291956,
0.029606944,
-0.0142451078,
0.0168378782,
0.0130018368,
-0.0109218732,
-0.0083952723,
-0.0512005612,
0.0129431961,
-0.008913896,
0.007779628,
0.0167512018,
0.0039259964,
0.0257375482,
-0.0055681262,
0.0392445698,
0.0135128554,
0.0215411354,
0.0252461508,
0.0509171858,
0.0106783621,
0.0378173292,
-0.052953735,
0.0436234251,
0.0055516735,
0.0347701125,
0.0489961505,
0.0019397725,
0.0639167279,
-0.0189192798,
0.0796272606,
0.0217002369,
-0.0172411725,
-0.0066078198,
-0.0204254836,
-0.0654282197,
-0.0265215859,
0.0501322486,
0.0105747441,
0.0184279475,
-0.0359877013,
0.0120367678,
-0.0111621404,
0.0294738691,
-0.0051104315,
0.0361485295,
-0.0416189097,
-0.0176892485,
-0.0300606247,
-0.0507781841,
0.0152659258,
0.0040837983,
0.0303763002,
0.016616853,
0.0537347309,
0.0175073594,
0.0288566202,
-0.0491404124,
0.0498707034,
-0.0149452118,
0.077059947,
0.0635282546,
-0.007042306,
-0.0007816693,
0.0263618045,
-0.0266191754,
0.0141846128,
0.0533756316,
-0.000117881,
-0.0206614677,
0.015849825,
0.0553756617,
0.0800201073,
-0.0126884282,
0.0185041763,
-0.0786846206,
0.0317108966,
0.0172403436,
0.0478217565,
0.0105717769,
0.0256651137,
-0.0014006898,
-0.0200221483,
-0.0402161144,
0.0048362724,
-0.0549643226,
-0.0318843238,
0.0038221271,
-0.0072963759,
0.0015211366,
-0.005824062,
0.0532114878,
-0.0298753511,
-0.0504843667,
0.0700781941,
0.0043519544,
-0.0192763973,
0.016986819,
0.0433954857,
-0.0494832434,
0.0190855581,
-0.0499241836,
-0.0374539979,
-0.0213342495,
0.0268530529,
-0.0191993583,
-0.017471388,
-0.0471347049,
0.0131677771,
-0.0385690704,
-0.0102760857,
-0.01986566,
-0.0050691757,
0.007301833,
0.0103349183,
0.024372587,
0.019387627,
0.0641930401,
-0.0026275674,
-0.0251375772,
-0.0236600488,
-0.002611957,
-0.0059422418,
-0.0110977506,
0.0151497852,
-0.0424552187,
0.0113280509,
-0.0002813159,
-0.0257703755,
-0.0265378933,
-0.0098227076,
2.733e-7,
0.0503178611,
0.0061250012,
-0.0159769915,
0.0330174901,
0.0223602615,
-0.0012510151,
-0.0351926088,
0.0012494078,
0.0409087501,
-0.0014318553,
-0.0342789553,
0.0252908617,
0.0464568995,
0.0785090625,
-0.0974960476,
-0.0203078855,
-0.0229758024,
-0.0331428312,
-0.0642468333,
-0.0047370116,
0.015132702,
0.0611666813,
-0.0050898609,
-0.0114097083,
-0.0303226057,
-0.0365642235,
0.0489256307,
-0.0151801836,
-0.0582027324,
0.0280705616,
0.0335884914,
0.0075278012,
0.018574208,
0.0165619962,
-0.0322129093,
-0.0004863989,
0.0021533696,
0.0241614413,
0.0019367322,
-0.0083308592,
0.0047650058,
-0.0360027589,
0.00129115,
-0.0841623098,
0.1006200016,
0.0169851203,
0.0094589107,
-0.0075097168,
-0.0097042006,
-0.0254465509,
0.0374721885,
-0.0249338057,
-0.0648812428,
0.0016920676,
0.0216921847,
0.0008084668,
-0.0266361069,
-0.0260003936,
-0.0176408254,
0.046582453,
-0.0433331653,
-0.0808721185,
-0.005532301,
-0.0195480902,
-0.037609648,
-0.0187915042,
0.0288725477,
2.336188493e-34,
0.0224463809,
0.0302915834,
0.0231903624,
0.0480443276,
0.0289965011,
-0.027708346,
-0.0739544258,
0.0189953763,
0.0020791076,
-0.0803669468,
0.0109248366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14711v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14711v2 | MultiAgent Collaboration Attack: Investigating Adversarial Attacks in Large Language Model Collaborations via Debate | 2024-06-20T20:09:37 | 2024-06-26T16:05:20 | Alfonso Amayuelas, Xianjun Yang, Antonis Antoniades, Wenyue Hua, Liangming Pan, William Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MA | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown exceptional results on current
benchmarks when working individually. The advancement in their capabilities,
along with a reduction in parameter size and inference times, has facilitated
the use of these models as agents, enabling interactions among multiple models
to execute complex tasks. Such collaborations offer several advantages,
including the use of specialized models (e.g. coding), improved confidence
through multiple computations, and enhanced divergent thinking, leading to more
diverse outputs. Thus, the collaborative use of language models is expected to
grow significantly in the coming years. In this work, we evaluate the behavior
of a network of models collaborating through debate under the influence of an
adversary. We introduce pertinent metrics to assess the adversary's
effectiveness, focusing on system accuracy and model agreement. Our findings
highlight the importance of a model's persuasive ability in influencing others.
Additionally, we explore inference-time methods to generate more compelling
arguments and evaluate the potential of prompt-based mitigation as a defensive
strategy. | [
0.0379389748,
0.1032862514,
-0.0041310973,
0.0567670092,
-0.086330846,
-0.0133779952,
0.0552161261,
-0.0357040763,
-0.00447291,
-0.0468689278,
0.0086764749,
-0.0610830337,
0.025544785,
0.0116137778,
0.0563724153,
0.011021533,
0.0062140771,
-0.0212495904,
0.0059209163,
-0.0487996936,
0.0031325319,
-0.0250881836,
-0.007994134,
0.063082166,
0.0047028419,
-0.0242086165,
-0.0222913641,
-0.016964538,
0.009472548,
-0.0079375235,
-0.0015628753,
0.0620227009,
0.0007578363,
0.091747269,
0.0000019783,
-0.0420427732,
-0.0350607187,
0.0136641404,
-0.0241492912,
0.0510489978,
0.0392435379,
-0.0041390494,
-0.0203569122,
0.0240686461,
-0.0524819233,
0.0213020965,
0.0413303599,
0.0161862243,
0.0482987985,
0.0927850232,
0.0131326905,
-0.0032115239,
0.0198457725,
-0.0508751608,
-0.0684529319,
-0.0542149693,
0.0238754041,
-0.0140479533,
-0.0208464228,
0.0061118086,
0.01154547,
0.0276899729,
0.0154680004,
-0.0178078841,
-0.0416259095,
0.0199161693,
-0.0223890133,
-0.0181968249,
0.0015317447,
0.0382003486,
-0.0148788569,
-0.0145768719,
0.0006573232,
-0.007531275,
0.0062867743,
0.0491407849,
-0.0291285459,
0.0249151308,
0.0004439936,
-0.0004979162,
0.0283394419,
0.0071718949,
0.0720274597,
0.0313945785,
-0.0050563342,
0.036368981,
0.0155112464,
-0.0160940457,
0.000374144,
-0.0134561276,
-0.0199110806,
-0.082238555,
-0.0158239473,
-0.0013075918,
-0.0169494022,
0.0214741454,
-0.0512908436,
-0.0381660573,
0.0348325558,
-0.0693279356,
0.0464048423,
-0.0023352806,
0.0456525087,
0.0425042361,
0.0099837221,
0.0018228781,
-0.0533392467,
0.0312260743,
0.0358211026,
-0.0093698334,
-0.0284601133,
-0.0096104136,
-0.0003410776,
0.0018046091,
-0.0041646464,
-0.0056921355,
-0.0129847331,
0.0369802155,
-0.0486989506,
0.0537594743,
-0.0269249212,
0.0270889755,
0.0115477005,
-0.0355313569,
0.0094410535,
0.0102834916,
-0.0130354119,
-0.0001371671,
0.0008649073,
-0.0775942877,
-0.050830435,
0.0043684673,
-0.0549750105,
-0.0443905741,
-0.0095073469,
0.1038075835,
-0.0057620886,
-0.0146617601,
0.021453755,
-0.0667705089,
-0.0225920137,
-0.0518321469,
-0.0244430024,
-0.0852999017,
0.0011536307,
-0.0024384574,
-0.0136675136,
-0.0881917551,
0.0020591463,
-0.0312280934,
-0.0216546189,
0.0843190923,
0.008989796,
0.0073282174,
0.0488001667,
0.0434700884,
-0.0413583182,
0.068494156,
0.0194908567,
0.0415150486,
0.0424896069,
0.0200964976,
0.0220376402,
0.0561880432,
0.029844325,
0.0320474841,
0.001062147,
-0.0094937608,
0.0181049705,
0.0222944617,
-0.0492479652,
0.0729343742,
-0.0489294641,
-0.0924886912,
0.1136472374,
0.0549051054,
-0.0210260171,
0.0374530032,
-0.0073831566,
0.0037804609,
0.0107423132,
-0.0149006648,
-0.0492253341,
-0.0013843505,
-0.0274216235,
-0.032465402,
0.0226932652,
0.0306540579,
-0.0082087936,
-0.007281418,
-0.0035633002,
-0.012652522,
0.0259926151,
0.0169218332,
0.0210232791,
-0.0015166568,
-0.0265513733,
0.0074521881,
0.0080805048,
-0.0296184123,
-0.0327412188,
-0.064312391,
0.01755457,
-0.013632386,
0.0639233515,
-0.001371908,
-0.0040266365,
-0.0276859924,
0.02179664,
0.0337808989,
0.0538949855,
-0.0198163893,
0.010700156,
-0.0214190409,
-0.0264576413,
-0.0294455923,
0.0036144692,
0.0548829697,
0.0166294426,
-0.0060716779,
-0.0120588699,
0.0310780257,
-0.0523677468,
0.0180160701,
-0.0091301026,
0.0029207817,
-0.0190223195,
0.0215906166,
0.0724392012,
0.0016177697,
-0.0506262295,
0.0277956724,
0.0470648631,
-0.0070574121,
-0.0395027846,
0.0266335271,
0.0160540882,
0.0108997822,
0.0155557236,
-0.0032277319,
-0.0038091366,
-0.0051395181,
-0.024051534,
0.0125405397,
0.0813396648,
-0.0377742089,
0.0010236095,
-0.0001719327,
-0.0069688731,
-0.0174543709,
0.0110978615,
-0.0332584791,
0.0284462757,
-0.0110833822,
-0.0143669285,
0.0197809208,
0.0446486101,
0.0369656794,
-0.0449102893,
-0.0185491778,
0.035762839,
0.007781229,
-0.0065612751,
0.0415816531,
-0.046159748,
-0.0090864915,
-0.0335974284,
-0.0669658557,
-0.0341893025,
-0.0342323296,
0.043396391,
0.0116115762,
-0.0319269635,
-0.004597235,
0.0097169466,
-0.0190465208,
-0.0020665496,
-0.0163491052,
0.0430282764,
0.0119345244,
0.0072381683,
-0.0518276878,
-0.0364018753,
-0.0054608942,
0.0019558407,
0.0947348103,
0.0487760268,
-0.0185933709,
-0.0337477662,
-0.0158854499,
-0.0430113636,
0.0423494093,
-0.0224391539,
-0.0392907485,
0.0705282167,
0.0165782571,
-0.000197164,
0.1020653546,
0.0317100175,
0.0472332612,
0.0668659732,
-0.0004133137,
-0.0610463694,
-0.0179168377,
-0.0153886033,
-0.0157013126,
-0.0572029203,
-0.0319844931,
0.0027664034,
0.0802256986,
0.0325060524,
-0.0227572042,
-0.0171786081,
0.0734172314,
0.0219197161,
-0.0489219464,
-0.0138181336,
-0.0478535481,
-0.0179159604,
0.0273395926,
-0.0247427858,
-0.06198401,
0.0990774408,
-0.0570297576,
0.0164062753,
-0.0098874765,
-0.0437908843,
0.0191310402,
0.0816037133,
0.0041017872,
0.0119701279,
0.0151103251,
0.0105278026,
-0.0583720841,
-0.0150784533,
0.0656871647,
-0.0216750074,
0.0178401023,
-0.0395427421,
0.0130224722,
-0.0122971125,
-0.0034642387,
-0.0315290503,
-0.059172187,
-0.0335613787,
0.010014412,
0.0232837144,
-0.0426034294,
-0.0247112047,
-0.0223343838,
0.0084802397,
-0.004085042,
-0.0049092681,
-0.0038542808,
-0.0214506574,
0.0112748267,
0.0199124161,
-0.0111208772,
0.0136848418,
-0.0498626977,
0.0351193994,
0.0956408232,
0.0164254699,
0.007933558,
-0.0642912984,
-0.0480025038,
-0.0037783633,
0.0047428422,
0.005101155,
-0.0083831577,
0.0507743955,
-0.0413234644,
0.0173338614,
0.0514858402,
0.0132977897,
-0.0260030124,
0.009236536,
-0.0178912859,
0.0300524291,
-0.0059904149,
-0.0023078823,
-0.0721745342,
-0.0068584965,
0.0177463405,
0.0228619818,
-0.0323255472,
-0.0409807041,
-0.026789384,
-0.0907220691,
0.007291765,
0.0072745094,
-0.0042537753,
0.0216067284,
-0.0416667685,
-0.0113774799,
-0.0306854248,
0.0135819893,
-0.0294230804,
0.0623076856,
-0.0069881929,
0.0103386035,
0.0072953911,
-0.0218549222,
0.0081702489,
-0.0456868634,
0.0846575573,
0.0758929923,
0.028144218,
-0.0059915772,
-0.019769609,
0.0296971202,
0.0274404306,
-0.0219158083,
0.0193122029,
0.0423553772,
-0.0106680188,
-0.0105428854,
0.0364703648,
0.0193875507,
0.0244851224,
-0.0134268263,
0.039157901,
0.0299690887,
-0.02381997,
-0.0070300205,
0.0006813313,
0.0107619818,
0.0539095141,
0.0722159892,
0.0280572008,
-0.0260520037,
-0.0397748463,
-0.0761147141,
-0.0187187046,
-0.0421490073,
-0.0333785079,
-0.0382659137,
0.0382148772,
-0.0075910082,
-0.0584233478,
-0.023221273,
-0.0045348057,
0.0197638683,
0.007946115,
-0.0056018853,
-0.0055830576,
0.0268157031,
-0.0043910518,
0.0069478336,
-0.0064547528,
0.069689855,
-0.0504610613,
0.0171265006,
-0.0112290271,
-0.002965004,
-0.0214603674,
0.0339781791,
-0.0986870676,
-0.1281908005,
0.0002752639,
0.0491883047,
0.0249141715,
0.0148563096,
-0.0219375063,
-0.0996436998,
0.0443731435,
0.0219939724,
0.021197591,
0.0105430437,
0.0679203644,
-0.0266035721,
0.006678232,
0.0481022038,
-0.0074466667,
-0.0070647909,
0.0717800856,
-0.0048096147,
-0.071326755,
-0.0548002385,
0.0017751118,
0.0007493293,
0.0482547507,
-0.0224077404,
-0.0123271653,
0.0035626085,
0.0033840865,
-0.0275304019,
-0.0138208447,
-0.015930634,
0.0042671636,
0.0032960309,
-0.0183252394,
0.0447945297,
0.0202586595,
0.0262136143,
0.0245583225,
-0.0098976241,
0.0373789445,
0.0082786251,
0.0411490723,
0.0453453325,
0.0168604776,
-0.0122081321,
0.0227841716,
0.0033258412,
0.0296167247,
-0.0015229234,
0.0440193713,
0.0143075446,
-0.0209444668,
0.0072029782,
0.0312713943,
-0.0969727635,
-0.0917271972,
0.0416324697,
0.0251996778,
0.0271453764,
0.0416177027,
0.0301666111,
-0.0462823957,
0.0009125693,
-0.0272494368,
0.014313505,
-0.0033565038,
-0.023365939,
0.0418650694,
0.0003981676,
-0.0192359015,
0.0617997907,
0.0804346204,
-0.0054466464,
0.0410024114,
0.0083707795,
-0.0300464369,
-0.0068333838,
-0.0598878153,
0.0098790471,
0.0108143315,
-0.0458209924,
-0.0095048351,
-0.0346564241,
-0.053736046,
-0.0225888602,
0.0371433757,
0.0078913607,
0.0139649827,
-0.0071175727,
0.0618376024,
-0.0059443861,
0.054229673,
-0.0563904569,
0.0503172502,
0.020546373,
-0.0418539159,
0.0001782691,
-6.223196398e-33,
0.0298706163,
-0.0613071285,
-0.0187829528,
-0.0251915678,
0.004392433,
0.0154108433,
-0.0346686766,
0.02016991,
-0.055164203,
0.0122077679,
0.0170355253,
0.0221578684,
0.0006408676,
0.0040306868,
-0.0216848943,
-0.0191841405,
0.0231215972,
-0.0209765676,
-0.0176736023,
0.0004058919,
0.048283603,
-0.0207346696,
-0.0002224119,
-0.0756970197,
0.0687442198,
-0.0011509352,
-0.037097998,
0.0026538698,
-0.0753742084,
0.0397501588,
0.0088255303,
0.0084096733,
-0.009710053,
-0.0521948561,
-0.0052104187,
0.0144234765,
0.0248750933,
-0.0027367191,
0.0102041056,
-0.0365934111,
-0.0295075532,
-0.0399674661,
0.0152152097,
0.0061977808,
-0.0341160595,
-0.020572897,
-0.0119671002,
-0.0125356512,
-0.0300150216,
0.0104337679,
-0.0163067803,
0.0235594511,
-0.0312040225,
0.0008457743,
0.0224286709,
-0.0058121071,
0.029416753,
0.0099611999,
-0.0746176988,
0.0405275859,
0.0108966446,
0.0118681854,
0.0776185617,
-0.0002338339,
0.0220666248,
0.0654523224,
0.0293507073,
0.0007500335,
-0.0411485359,
-0.0107359393,
-0.0214112792,
0.0462927483,
0.0937868804,
0.0933169723,
0.0043139597,
-0.0045495429,
-0.0736282989,
-0.0019275562,
0.0507701635,
0.0143890399,
0.0551394038,
-0.0038056683,
-0.0355784371,
-0.0205782317,
-0.0232541468,
-0.0668255463,
-0.0317286886,
-0.0416947491,
-0.0120735746,
0.0108096376,
-0.0177957509,
0.0166155621,
0.0199199431,
-0.0589979552,
-0.0067687198,
0.0393014997,
0.0145918606,
-0.0161663815,
-0.0010730849,
0.0062125078,
-0.0522432737,
0.042739097,
-0.0211256817,
-0.0139625026,
0.0281274244,
0.0020759662,
0.0340757146,
0.0085173557,
-0.0402875692,
-0.0054838462,
-0.0300757773,
0.0123820519,
0.0135050658,
0.028396491,
0.0409250557,
-0.0203417521,
-0.0119106844,
0.0039659021,
-0.0031562026,
-0.0108478516,
-0.027416775,
0.020798998,
-0.0364518315,
-0.0057909591,
-0.0170198772,
-0.0059638973,
-0.0328079723,
0.0362121761,
0.058580339,
-0.0227062944,
-0.0151026165,
-0.070110634,
2.675e-7,
0.0058879219,
0.0293897241,
0.0134738972,
0.0141143417,
0.0414717495,
0.0687447488,
-0.0270146839,
0.0534643456,
-0.0021450282,
-0.0426506028,
-0.0175122414,
0.0230583437,
0.0482757837,
0.0387645923,
-0.0377929509,
-0.0229835268,
-0.1001646668,
-0.0019374405,
-0.0481390394,
-0.008591935,
0.0322384126,
0.0799250305,
0.0407353118,
0.0015534778,
-0.0180245396,
-0.053796906,
0.0602492802,
-0.0303746462,
-0.0103110252,
0.0049021943,
0.046266254,
-0.034273535,
0.0012127187,
0.0326514058,
-0.0040811514,
-0.0064744265,
-0.0390006527,
0.0291026868,
0.0112249907,
-0.0099874875,
-0.0354685709,
-0.0464283228,
-0.0095953811,
-0.0454592481,
0.0493867658,
-0.0483244695,
-0.0389761925,
-0.0101702753,
0.0314432569,
-0.0337185152,
0.0700885803,
-0.0344930217,
-0.0064511062,
-0.0098219598,
-0.0058804126,
0.0102783218,
0.0390023626,
-0.0701897293,
-0.017999677,
-0.041966293,
-0.0313069746,
-0.057890892,
0.005863151,
-0.0029921813,
0.0391725786,
-0.0037972641,
-0.0018023314,
2.329879165e-34,
0.0235821716,
-0.0101277875,
-0.0048976224,
0.0314724632,
0.0496487282,
-0.0092695933,
-0.018976707,
-0.0194951724,
0.0281613003,
-0.0456096157,
-0.0377848409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14709v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14709v1 | Factual Dialogue Summarization via Learning from Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T20:03:37 | 2024-06-20T20:03:37 | Rongxin Zhu, Jey Han Lau, Jianzhong Qi | cs.CL | cs.CL, F.2.2; I.2.7 | Factual consistency is an important quality in dialogue summarization. Large
language model (LLM)-based automatic text summarization models generate more
factually consistent summaries compared to those by smaller pretrained language
models, but they face deployment challenges in real-world applications due to
privacy or resource constraints. In this paper, we investigate the use of
symbolic knowledge distillation to improve the factual consistency of smaller
pretrained models for dialogue summarization. We employ zero-shot learning to
extract symbolic knowledge from LLMs, generating both factually consistent
(positive) and inconsistent (negative) summaries. We then apply two contrastive
learning objectives on these summaries to enhance smaller summarization models.
Experiments with BART, PEGASUS, and Flan-T5 indicate that our approach
surpasses strong baselines that rely on complex data augmentation strategies.
Our approach achieves better factual consistency while maintaining coherence,
fluency, and relevance, as confirmed by various automatic evaluation metrics.
We also provide access to the data and code to facilitate future research. | [
0.0469476245,
0.0471789539,
0.0187080055,
0.0418100059,
-0.0333983451,
0.009205238,
-0.0167954229,
-0.0363062099,
-0.0210308563,
-0.0570822731,
-0.0113372868,
-0.0220911726,
0.0220149495,
0.0204879399,
0.0013259642,
-0.0784313083,
0.0406463929,
-0.0158218127,
0.0329000428,
-0.0171696451,
0.0307998341,
0.0147011988,
0.0015177003,
0.0235327817,
0.0035256059,
0.0022763272,
0.0196395833,
-0.0030616149,
0.0651967824,
0.0001557447,
-0.017912861,
-0.0164481048,
0.0197507143,
0.0248922873,
0.0000018438,
-0.0566604361,
-0.0084953867,
-0.0100825503,
-0.0329547264,
0.0138026187,
0.0388194434,
-0.0491405129,
0.0291273184,
0.0236389469,
-0.0226534344,
-0.0048727584,
0.008534193,
0.054797098,
0.1028408036,
0.0836777836,
0.0027813578,
-0.0471772403,
-0.0074390583,
-0.024885932,
-0.024675779,
-0.0273304656,
0.0137534197,
0.0521075949,
-0.0269061644,
-0.0019564449,
0.0123468591,
0.0370714217,
0.0033725901,
0.0006809366,
-0.0088266423,
0.0338019691,
-0.0776789784,
0.0036021771,
0.0144512979,
0.096134901,
0.0345086269,
0.0200894997,
0.0155241899,
0.0036042852,
-0.0038146591,
-0.0163954645,
-0.0757949799,
0.037109416,
0.0028978521,
0.0320014693,
-0.0106917396,
0.0389496237,
-0.0091155907,
0.026280988,
-0.0465953909,
0.016406497,
-0.0054012695,
-0.0053104572,
-0.0630322024,
-0.0096740434,
-0.0377849452,
-0.0638804361,
-0.0057881656,
0.0356703773,
0.0080728466,
0.0178491101,
-0.0667684674,
-0.0085638827,
0.0185597092,
-0.049852211,
0.0188326426,
0.0134314075,
0.0157773588,
0.0630830973,
-0.0090535218,
0.055157356,
0.0449294224,
0.0323771164,
-0.040552903,
-0.0201815665,
-0.0449593589,
0.02138987,
-0.0314671136,
0.0564608797,
-0.0469049923,
-0.0408519097,
-0.0125137437,
0.0018535329,
0.0209182873,
0.0347136147,
0.0064945389,
0.0013893944,
0.0081764851,
-0.0118983248,
-0.0092421724,
0.0623104572,
-0.0404078439,
-0.0287223645,
0.0153345643,
-0.0196445733,
-0.0253561102,
0.0159871653,
0.0118243722,
0.0036060791,
-0.0073003359,
0.0327507593,
-0.0319927819,
-0.0335334279,
-0.0131546939,
-0.0265838262,
-0.0345148593,
-0.0815604404,
-0.0543990545,
-0.0464637205,
0.0005593766,
-0.0324095637,
-0.0236376207,
-0.0369322412,
0.0227776375,
0.0132164471,
-0.0347510837,
0.0330851935,
-0.0173304267,
-0.0078300675,
0.02729485,
0.0115889395,
-0.0003691172,
0.0413708091,
0.0676636025,
0.0263567809,
0.0644572452,
0.0363518,
-0.0016882921,
0.0094605144,
0.0174585506,
0.0154472934,
0.0019152455,
0.0076235016,
-0.0310499202,
-0.0144977197,
0.0205341186,
0.0891563296,
-0.0596210584,
0.0022737358,
0.0800215974,
0.041216407,
0.0179483518,
-0.0159867257,
0.0150287393,
0.0604975782,
0.0361124165,
0.0332557186,
-0.0245721303,
0.0170624834,
-0.0431375653,
0.0626730323,
0.0686393678,
0.0581963286,
-0.0186236836,
-0.0630498081,
-0.004716076,
-0.0193183161,
0.007620459,
0.0172781423,
0.0263555907,
0.0158943348,
-0.0428739414,
0.0481054783,
0.018033782,
-0.0613460727,
-0.0171600673,
-0.0108447326,
0.0210792609,
0.0640836135,
0.042684,
-0.0354232006,
-0.0482924022,
-0.0471420474,
-0.0190416425,
0.0303030424,
0.0165974721,
-0.0284228828,
0.0267545152,
-0.0473977327,
-0.0145841641,
-0.0164392926,
0.0167371966,
0.0019870971,
-0.01358769,
0.0007031151,
0.0503012389,
-0.0148466872,
-0.0267887712,
0.016753111,
-0.011067884,
-0.0413181148,
0.0212469026,
-0.0037893311,
0.0166198947,
0.054027535,
-0.0353479274,
-0.0090358574,
0.006891923,
-0.0226487871,
0.0026218824,
0.0231889114,
-0.0622761473,
-0.0932088047,
0.0580578633,
-0.0069284383,
0.0217854418,
0.0198019557,
-0.0629905239,
-0.0620577559,
0.0401231647,
-0.0461657345,
-0.0021940335,
-0.0344223678,
0.0164599344,
0.0223109201,
0.0001650882,
-0.0160535052,
0.0469039343,
0.0032113348,
-0.0525529794,
0.0360574238,
-0.0092405993,
0.0137300622,
-0.0177704692,
-0.0023084739,
0.0255364589,
0.0061435504,
0.0182429757,
0.0450748913,
-0.0070084282,
-0.0112762107,
-0.0079088556,
-0.0969910994,
0.0337885916,
-0.024731366,
-0.0041813306,
0.0334865823,
0.0031829891,
0.0070482097,
-0.0084706293,
-0.0341059826,
-0.0418094471,
0.0225828793,
-0.012003528,
0.0311704352,
0.0525074378,
0.0007314053,
-0.0609888136,
0.0014685289,
0.0154130328,
0.0531600378,
-0.0107580973,
-0.0125436736,
-0.0143991429,
0.0282090399,
-0.053586483,
0.0074870312,
-0.0077514215,
-0.0024703052,
-0.0184900481,
0.0179776289,
0.0196366217,
0.0500173829,
0.0441797599,
0.0058157132,
0.0150382267,
0.0080986489,
-0.0467255227,
0.0020832182,
-0.0089487778,
0.0179492179,
0.0039829887,
-0.0125236567,
0.0213697571,
0.0363741405,
0.0279836841,
0.0150561016,
-0.0432160795,
0.0419575758,
0.0083605964,
-0.02682041,
-0.0227741729,
-0.0121800667,
-0.0218765978,
0.0127421124,
-0.0487486422,
-0.0038262377,
0.0774485543,
-0.0558074862,
0.0111892717,
-0.0450764112,
-0.0325864851,
-0.0496285148,
0.0277871508,
0.0019393027,
0.0332127437,
0.0073716012,
-0.0019599472,
-0.0395044312,
-0.0534536652,
0.0499742627,
-0.0276077501,
0.0897989348,
-0.0388288125,
0.0087323021,
-0.0062651299,
-0.0242722798,
-0.0384522751,
-0.0654196739,
-0.044129245,
0.0332139097,
-0.0180174038,
-0.0064421636,
-0.0212090015,
0.0082569681,
0.0328262448,
0.0631441697,
-0.0060364096,
-0.0129253203,
-0.0260946397,
0.058114022,
0.0701696202,
-0.0089251976,
0.0353037715,
-0.003296586,
0.0436952636,
0.0235906336,
0.0237554051,
-0.0234173182,
0.0162533913,
-0.0425881892,
-0.0278389081,
-0.059234757,
0.0029054345,
-0.0150569212,
0.0543950349,
-0.0289681479,
0.0045312615,
0.1311557144,
0.0186257251,
0.007410387,
-0.0126926545,
0.011271351,
-0.000789448,
0.0065560886,
-0.0079297898,
-0.1136083007,
-0.047491435,
-0.0147927236,
0.0312360171,
0.0007736433,
-0.0409854315,
-0.0372706801,
-0.1172713861,
-0.0122223273,
0.0232750196,
-0.0315451249,
-0.0277202837,
-0.0089952536,
0.017738184,
-0.0458519571,
0.0314089544,
0.0304703154,
-0.0325814523,
0.0020865973,
0.0001276506,
-0.0383719951,
-0.0168668944,
-0.0178972147,
-0.0144760041,
0.0312610418,
0.0520264544,
0.0269988254,
0.0150521677,
0.0376223512,
0.0077148019,
-0.0248051025,
-0.009698214,
0.0160707738,
0.0738991871,
-0.0348824449,
0.0110663939,
-0.0129832579,
0.037721023,
0.0251596104,
-0.0292479247,
0.0127053382,
-0.0164945703,
0.0094474582,
-0.0159579925,
-0.0202668943,
0.054919865,
-0.0300271902,
0.0927761123,
0.0368704945,
-0.0051055425,
-0.0030953237,
-0.0330409929,
-0.0182358176,
-0.02774336,
-0.0008543176,
-0.0215796977,
-0.0136713693,
0.0156743955,
-0.110500671,
-0.0493148528,
0.0143932924,
0.0022494525,
-0.0151999928,
-0.0038655268,
-0.0068518701,
0.0196300913,
-0.0149973799,
-0.0111907795,
-0.0595880188,
-0.0035008907,
-0.0150245996,
-0.0067297076,
0.0571589544,
-0.0367517732,
-0.0274699666,
-0.0023803161,
-0.0831823573,
-0.0726949424,
-0.0388275944,
0.0814407915,
0.0236853231,
0.0981974006,
0.003555268,
-0.0021447574,
0.0716537759,
0.0486118682,
-0.0034342366,
0.021994669,
0.0461665206,
0.0368093401,
-0.0063568046,
0.0225503426,
-0.0324711725,
0.0261775423,
-0.0259241164,
0.047111474,
-0.0698554888,
-0.0696853846,
-0.0019253393,
0.0534193255,
0.0158739146,
0.002358993,
-0.0070878747,
-0.016139457,
0.0073062545,
-0.0389252603,
-0.022867782,
-0.0464489274,
0.0383087769,
-0.0177404732,
0.0005870908,
-0.0070491079,
0.0172975734,
-0.0348186754,
0.0314633772,
-0.0324701108,
-0.0278969072,
-0.0034791669,
-0.0321130864,
-0.0321126133,
-0.018309664,
-0.0548755117,
0.0252060909,
-0.016123319,
0.0112792011,
-0.0086873062,
0.0389231853,
0.0115615893,
-0.0188954789,
-0.0130578969,
0.0296317954,
-0.0654366091,
-0.0070545413,
-0.0532507934,
0.0515620932,
0.0363813378,
-0.004959303,
0.0690039322,
-0.0193597842,
0.0064283269,
-0.0160920266,
0.0230314322,
0.0143074431,
-0.0149011714,
-0.0349833779,
0.0286851935,
0.0056458167,
0.0427995697,
0.0941532552,
-0.0428105965,
0.0247318763,
0.0108441385,
0.0099178832,
-0.055434905,
-0.031609945,
0.0048199543,
0.0318077393,
0.0153082823,
-0.0069283438,
-0.0691314787,
-0.038394507,
0.0510548614,
-0.0007532064,
0.0060812472,
-0.0287001953,
0.0349219292,
-0.0024706244,
0.0139594479,
-0.000296811,
-0.0511293709,
-0.0348933414,
0.0130403936,
0.008094701,
-0.0015456545,
-6.092544976e-33,
-0.0452174321,
0.0179476086,
-0.0243662894,
-0.0068081506,
-0.0456129648,
0.0074045253,
-0.0370233692,
-0.0173850786,
-0.0099091232,
0.0075298017,
-0.00622035,
0.0217389967,
0.010663108,
0.048634015,
-0.0298185833,
-0.0148535939,
0.0729541183,
0.0125137614,
-0.050926812,
0.048268307,
0.0271743704,
0.0084145023,
0.0255360603,
-0.0372231156,
0.0152981048,
-0.0196502898,
-0.0333800316,
0.025410844,
0.0561032332,
0.0358196124,
-0.0034030315,
0.0525566489,
0.0085257618,
-0.0397353582,
-0.0453028791,
-0.0161337536,
-0.0818308592,
-0.0198489558,
0.0821693465,
-0.0300575048,
-0.0166981146,
-0.0320500918,
0.0121789528,
-0.0309651662,
0.0210184827,
-0.0484235398,
0.0171592701,
-0.0494702868,
-0.0225770399,
-0.0680865496,
-0.0449341461,
0.0335925445,
-0.0378032997,
-0.0535172597,
0.0132351462,
0.0295645986,
0.0074688033,
0.0048936061,
-0.024795115,
0.0170239061,
0.0519841462,
0.0100954408,
0.0421068221,
0.0425450131,
0.0086206226,
0.0949313492,
-0.0283599496,
0.0041810884,
-0.0488743223,
-0.0125820618,
-0.0065369676,
0.0133959046,
0.0121253189,
0.0811096802,
0.0372993238,
0.0259869844,
-0.0443605445,
0.0437567681,
0.001366155,
0.0223548412,
0.0222022161,
0.0052210768,
-0.0088308761,
0.0084166303,
-0.042880971,
-0.0026293187,
-0.0145134525,
-0.0172124598,
-0.0205374956,
0.0216848459,
-0.0577380173,
-0.0137744565,
0.0317609236,
-0.054093264,
0.0111563206,
0.0475503132,
-0.0361537561,
-0.0019352827,
-0.0173029657,
-0.0009473618,
-0.0544652753,
0.0349555053,
0.0545228496,
0.031104425,
-0.0003153712,
0.0151601182,
0.071983397,
-0.021491915,
-0.0368111394,
0.0258132759,
0.0190124903,
0.0401692279,
-0.0384148285,
0.0050542224,
0.0005869069,
0.0377980322,
-0.0086413138,
0.0656885579,
-0.0098686665,
-0.0192369465,
0.0062514534,
0.0171663407,
0.0214527156,
0.0244091731,
-0.0527627692,
0.0258036833,
0.0082423799,
-0.0077698426,
0.0210830923,
-0.042579852,
-0.014676068,
-0.0117651401,
2.459e-7,
0.0155333588,
0.0287163891,
0.0638886243,
0.007305847,
-0.0314475261,
0.0525270961,
0.0092061451,
0.0290483683,
0.0339290835,
-0.0365605578,
0.0352659971,
0.058706928,
0.0653331727,
0.0163391456,
-0.0857984126,
-0.0168634988,
-0.0909913108,
-0.067893818,
-0.0358197168,
-0.0275317952,
0.0876431912,
0.0848641321,
0.0054821181,
0.0011268931,
-0.0176308118,
-0.0361174196,
0.0432512313,
-0.0028963257,
-0.0399786308,
0.0149028199,
0.0199795794,
-0.0005238919,
0.002502667,
-0.0319103934,
0.0080065913,
0.0061825998,
0.0049237353,
0.0673079044,
0.0155619299,
-0.0265499577,
-0.0322804637,
-0.0026417577,
0.0144491969,
0.0213847551,
0.0811120197,
-0.1003224924,
-0.0086010089,
-0.0239243843,
-0.0637746379,
0.0025199261,
0.0101264706,
-0.0139488066,
-0.0396436788,
0.0733969733,
0.0132687492,
0.004052164,
0.0142309526,
-0.0771421343,
-0.0437157154,
0.0150662391,
-0.0098965885,
-0.0226762351,
0.0259942245,
-0.0353507176,
-0.0075160386,
-0.0573660024,
0.0173617732,
2.184721225e-34,
0.08843977,
-0.018610714,
-0.021572575,
0.010753924,
0.0430145413,
-0.0276582204,
-0.0677612796,
-0.0337856337,
0.0304463003,
-0.0820357949,
0.0067554982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14703v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14703v1 | Do LLMs Have Distinct and Consistent Personality? TRAIT: Personality Testset designed for LLMs with Psychometrics | 2024-06-20T19:50:56 | 2024-06-20T19:50:56 | Seungbeen Lee, Seungwon Lim, Seungju Han, Giyeong Oh, Hyungjoo Chae, Jiwan Chung, Minju Kim, Beong-woo Kwak, Yeonsoo Lee, Dongha Lee, Jinyoung Yeo, Youngjae Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The idea of personality in descriptive psychology, traditionally defined
through observable behavior, has now been extended to Large Language Models
(LLMs) to better understand their behavior. This raises a question: do LLMs
exhibit distinct and consistent personality traits, similar to humans? Existing
self-assessment personality tests, while applicable, lack the necessary
validity and reliability for precise personality measurements. To address this,
we introduce TRAIT, a new tool consisting of 8K multi-choice questions designed
to assess the personality of LLMs with validity and reliability. TRAIT is built
on the psychometrically validated human questionnaire, Big Five Inventory (BFI)
and Short Dark Triad (SD-3), enhanced with the ATOMIC10X knowledge graph for
testing personality in a variety of real scenarios. TRAIT overcomes the
reliability and validity issues when measuring personality of LLM with
self-assessment, showing the highest scores across three metrics: refusal rate,
prompt sensitivity, and option order sensitivity. It reveals notable insights
into personality of LLM: 1) LLMs exhibit distinct and consistent personality,
which is highly influenced by their training data (i.e., data used for
alignment tuning), and 2) current prompting techniques have limited
effectiveness in eliciting certain traits, such as high psychopathy or low
conscientiousness, suggesting the need for further research in this direction. | [
0.0549493767,
0.0468342938,
-0.0521054342,
0.0082621677,
-0.0355404392,
0.0117789032,
0.0290153082,
-0.0063621821,
-0.0017623263,
0.0186886992,
-0.0658543706,
-0.0061776219,
-0.0163707174,
0.0055069993,
0.0443416573,
-0.021784205,
0.0467646047,
-0.0011337256,
0.043805562,
-0.0140378401,
-0.0094382931,
0.0428484678,
-0.008074943,
0.0073358258,
0.029756058,
-0.033937294,
-0.0000257766,
-0.0263871383,
0.033358857,
-0.0318206102,
0.0118314335,
0.0714097545,
-0.0084369546,
0.033386007,
0.0000018932,
-0.0674023107,
-0.0080221603,
-0.017882023,
-0.0134669216,
0.0016509461,
0.0445263162,
0.0381195582,
0.0175798163,
0.0539016277,
-0.071361132,
-0.0276182555,
0.0212937631,
0.0393881053,
0.029273048,
0.0556601621,
0.0083547253,
0.0097059477,
0.0112210792,
0.0000504676,
0.0196841564,
0.025365524,
0.0112239849,
-0.0413573608,
-0.0151441591,
0.0286397748,
0.0075155026,
-0.0112307779,
0.0005641466,
0.0103531769,
-0.0273091737,
-0.0314668864,
-0.0336128287,
-0.0249536522,
-0.0019594501,
0.0569468066,
0.0723794401,
-0.0075130085,
-0.0209221933,
-0.0197807234,
0.025742285,
0.0181338843,
-0.0068965545,
0.0365635604,
-0.0024708016,
-0.0564359911,
0.0227240827,
0.0043394077,
-0.0137737142,
-0.0022744276,
0.0165618341,
0.0620355867,
-0.0054972139,
-0.0125626819,
0.0150717339,
-0.0075027226,
0.0149620455,
-0.074026309,
-0.011802651,
0.0125100268,
-0.0571136288,
0.0290571004,
-0.0294928811,
0.0142296599,
0.0588662326,
-0.0332443118,
0.0089663025,
0.0390996896,
-0.038706623,
-0.0085924705,
0.0367337763,
0.0570281297,
0.0281246118,
0.0543652959,
-0.0216425415,
0.0100768683,
-0.0297247618,
-0.0065882187,
0.0477814265,
-0.0177288577,
0.058524657,
0.0034764006,
-0.0758870691,
0.0492242798,
-0.0213827845,
0.0168706775,
0.0018807811,
-0.0087624658,
0.0269738156,
0.0210193712,
-0.071186699,
0.0122682862,
-0.0393028259,
0.0025508157,
0.0169007406,
-0.0153846787,
0.0379138403,
-0.00783817,
-0.0026901152,
-0.0380473658,
0.0375633687,
0.0558511913,
0.0222573131,
-0.0374807864,
-0.0475714318,
-0.0263929013,
-0.0307261217,
-0.0653542727,
0.0097662462,
-0.040116962,
0.0160614606,
0.036846973,
-0.0297478624,
-0.0501402542,
-0.0023785019,
0.0353005566,
-0.0004921927,
0.0511444844,
0.0085692098,
0.030899765,
0.0041179284,
0.0035940253,
-0.0127845807,
0.0282893889,
-0.0080261659,
-0.0100402171,
0.059909381,
-0.0712445676,
0.0234063379,
0.0409383737,
-0.0265028067,
0.0309201069,
-0.0090819634,
0.0030384706,
0.0038802694,
-0.0032019296,
0.0697861016,
0.047222279,
-0.0013782205,
-0.0296023339,
0.10172721,
0.0624433011,
0.0331438594,
-0.0008364141,
0.009513869,
0.0280287322,
0.0375873521,
0.0156849958,
-0.0454589017,
0.0214112066,
-0.0198809728,
0.02627795,
-0.0217518695,
0.0143294903,
0.0091341082,
-0.0360795483,
-0.0368049666,
0.0002331695,
0.0289971959,
0.056862738,
-0.0255067982,
-0.0321339145,
-0.0201378744,
-0.0257165208,
0.0322581716,
-0.0473698862,
-0.0356922895,
-0.0579470061,
0.0259026662,
0.0922623426,
0.0206014942,
0.0071939896,
-0.0349807478,
-0.0155836502,
-0.0556348674,
0.0523267984,
0.0662966222,
-0.0272896141,
-0.0200109389,
-0.0306422208,
0.0159551874,
0.000305011,
-0.0149059976,
-0.005840579,
0.0042059198,
0.0319614075,
-0.022144774,
-0.0080262888,
-0.0051715113,
0.0237106085,
-0.0961853266,
-0.05419112,
-0.0279956032,
0.0271836519,
0.0423635617,
0.0172044951,
0.0144238975,
0.0042129946,
0.0027272571,
0.0321456008,
0.0169160757,
-0.0003168403,
-0.0210821498,
0.0106862588,
0.0361258909,
0.0373118557,
-0.0093738455,
0.0108986301,
0.0316851586,
-0.0054571559,
-0.0247227661,
-0.0177405048,
0.0203242265,
-0.02046776,
0.0243326984,
-0.0490137376,
0.0561689325,
-0.02914677,
0.0179990549,
-0.0219505075,
0.0396852121,
0.0322328433,
-0.0033940307,
-0.0164184254,
-0.0454751924,
-0.0403355807,
-0.0154364165,
0.0099943336,
0.0344165638,
0.0093136113,
0.0077052275,
-0.0649220645,
-0.024423277,
-0.0875964463,
0.0108731035,
0.0288160443,
0.0109525817,
0.0182261001,
-0.0135538075,
-0.0466021821,
0.0271018986,
-0.0412153304,
-0.0154032717,
0.0397186428,
0.0422053188,
0.0291704927,
-0.0246828776,
-0.0330039524,
-0.062129166,
-0.0043928484,
-0.0436027944,
-0.0065081189,
-0.0427893102,
0.0667355284,
-0.027279079,
0.0354399942,
-0.0582898371,
-0.0182239413,
-0.0062981145,
-0.0812934563,
0.053004548,
0.0060859034,
0.0012643295,
0.0634284392,
0.0361174792,
0.0294171721,
0.0339431353,
0.0049114767,
-0.0512119755,
-0.0162056219,
-0.0089482665,
-0.0069589992,
-0.0329462774,
-0.0747125447,
-0.0237047095,
0.0524818078,
0.0279456191,
0.0158113614,
-0.0231777169,
0.0111413775,
0.0225981995,
-0.0453727283,
0.0496508069,
0.0055901459,
-0.0479687341,
0.079109773,
0.0285258889,
-0.0306677502,
0.0796495453,
-0.023159828,
0.010098964,
-0.0073898328,
-0.0572765209,
-0.0175191443,
0.0795152262,
-0.0158100445,
-0.0280038435,
0.0733361244,
-0.0037459782,
-0.0680479184,
-0.0697653592,
0.0159403346,
-0.046848923,
0.0380725674,
0.0006461286,
-0.0442072153,
0.0474295281,
0.0030085784,
-0.0585109368,
-0.0437696166,
-0.0392936133,
-0.0284454301,
0.0490953848,
-0.0567891486,
-0.0059489235,
-0.0435859822,
0.0501819961,
-0.0151314866,
-0.0318871923,
-0.0148894284,
0.0081568249,
-0.0078802947,
0.0679001585,
0.0291055478,
0.0743117258,
-0.0580982156,
-0.0081755659,
0.0111718001,
-0.0370298736,
0.0198729131,
0.0002639898,
-0.0033397905,
0.0328257605,
-0.0141944438,
-0.005177448,
0.02884393,
0.0368601717,
-0.0098726815,
0.0136879934,
0.1187491119,
0.0227728467,
-0.014022151,
0.0303496048,
-0.0255851652,
0.0363023318,
0.0442144275,
0.0549353212,
-0.0362786427,
-0.000026929,
-0.017537294,
0.0474545136,
-0.0703348815,
-0.0380099639,
-0.0282261912,
-0.0953380242,
0.024774611,
-0.0054125153,
-0.0315001905,
0.0142321987,
-0.040177729,
0.0282391887,
0.0073277932,
0.041179996,
0.0064252489,
-0.0088740783,
-0.0243606437,
-0.0079778749,
-0.064621985,
-0.0138774998,
0.0959451124,
-0.0260543544,
0.0500659421,
0.0107689016,
-0.0016358269,
-0.0196267664,
-0.0468012579,
-0.0476142913,
0.0037641202,
0.0064462097,
0.0296440683,
0.0449797846,
-0.0339326151,
0.0298626758,
-0.0975682214,
0.0035742919,
-0.0274072103,
0.0196026396,
0.016886767,
0.0656900629,
-0.0064246599,
-0.04834814,
-0.0270167813,
0.0186789166,
0.036246229,
0.0563038252,
0.0001599167,
-0.0956315845,
0.0120950853,
0.0017053296,
-0.012073623,
-0.0072176494,
-0.0666297004,
0.0197282936,
0.0145714022,
-0.0236143749,
-0.0525470935,
-0.0883436054,
0.012341232,
0.0072284741,
-0.0103791598,
-0.0397860967,
0.0064313859,
-0.0029543161,
-0.0252797715,
0.0113637531,
0.0261227898,
0.0221894383,
-0.073094666,
0.0088783056,
0.0468141213,
-0.03161484,
0.0102151819,
0.0185022112,
-0.0456749313,
-0.048369173,
0.0317165442,
0.013571837,
0.0228895526,
-0.0103155011,
0.0401457362,
-0.0324232653,
0.0148454355,
0.0024532357,
-0.0233785044,
0.0758640394,
-0.0064363847,
0.0155961784,
-0.0125894118,
0.0167810712,
-0.0286696963,
-0.001124009,
-0.006865093,
-0.0312753767,
-0.0215031914,
-0.093081817,
0.0115935327,
0.0363609828,
-0.0061743623,
-0.0203391742,
0.001661142,
-0.0241757222,
-0.0320636444,
-0.0342036895,
-0.0124115935,
0.0088135451,
-0.0836902112,
0.005380278,
-0.0132522183,
-0.0217039827,
-0.0507641248,
-0.0418012366,
0.0421536006,
-0.0389979035,
0.0457459092,
0.0136746885,
0.0019304371,
-0.0043741255,
-0.0007203648,
-0.0317792632,
0.0052455221,
-0.0063460274,
0.0490151979,
0.0273805782,
0.096311681,
-0.0263403356,
-0.0045205862,
0.0011539505,
0.0374088883,
-0.0391886085,
-0.0594687797,
0.0411619991,
-0.016851278,
-0.0308056101,
-0.0105891563,
0.0475842841,
-0.0284684394,
0.0247508679,
-0.0313599482,
0.0347935371,
-0.0280377455,
0.009000117,
0.0213218573,
0.0203249548,
-0.0226891357,
-0.0130336331,
0.024926452,
0.0327064544,
0.0202607848,
-0.034435153,
-0.028332958,
-0.0461850688,
0.0152925467,
0.0033621904,
0.0277718566,
-0.0304414034,
-0.0356048085,
-0.0880534723,
-0.0776332393,
0.0474096015,
0.0094086546,
-0.0119559607,
-0.0485480428,
0.0028546774,
0.0621644631,
-0.0142251737,
-0.0386948138,
-0.0388521068,
-0.005296499,
-0.0199558362,
-0.0221471414,
-0.0257253796,
-5.790445132e-33,
-0.0210159216,
-0.0362447351,
0.0239857472,
-0.0241406057,
-0.0266955849,
-0.0548592769,
-0.0059775505,
0.0627728626,
-0.0522563346,
-0.0268527959,
-0.0512968004,
-0.0014700374,
0.011030443,
-0.0263386369,
0.028487321,
-0.0007553205,
0.0161607731,
-0.0208714027,
-0.0172406994,
-0.0146404477,
0.0287432242,
-0.0084169665,
0.0686770082,
-0.0575488694,
0.0453540683,
-0.0319505073,
-0.0059677288,
-0.0164911877,
-0.012215768,
0.068056263,
0.0147494189,
0.0406851955,
0.0306643937,
-0.0144347679,
0.0019305224,
0.0298939422,
-0.0151966093,
-0.043311432,
0.0284321867,
0.0224372689,
-0.0100588929,
-0.0405320376,
0.022469962,
-0.0299295262,
-0.0524376631,
-0.0349060558,
0.0315510631,
-0.0013176375,
0.0302677974,
0.0496522486,
-0.0317939222,
0.0022357134,
-0.0227445662,
-0.0134939589,
-0.0577248894,
0.0142244045,
-0.0254335366,
0.0030247404,
-0.0779118538,
0.0566929579,
-0.0455545746,
0.0013883859,
0.0371951237,
0.0264394842,
-0.00447735,
0.0488943271,
0.0483463518,
0.0564269274,
0.0342465192,
-0.0165042356,
0.0439243205,
0.0601863936,
0.0025901375,
0.0625756681,
-0.033274468,
-0.0578376129,
0.0112816636,
0.0042740749,
0.1032594889,
-0.0599860214,
0.0368148163,
-0.003611627,
-0.0501755886,
-0.0461405367,
-0.0023979021,
-0.0066693826,
-0.0102235014,
-0.0459666438,
0.030482145,
-0.0441021509,
0.0076951361,
-0.0522024147,
0.0604538843,
-0.0302645825,
-0.0204987451,
0.0353009701,
-0.0944028646,
0.0605086014,
-0.0035341219,
-0.0077852821,
-0.0440979712,
0.0210166052,
-0.0200709142,
0.007022501,
0.0633350611,
0.0296845585,
0.0053424826,
0.0249496643,
-0.0760690123,
-0.0069326097,
0.025358025,
0.0321884751,
-0.0019229326,
0.01532852,
0.0053837369,
-0.0046815556,
0.0131344628,
0.0279307906,
-0.0110168057,
-0.0164668187,
-0.0621150881,
0.009085496,
0.0048275134,
0.0062618521,
-0.0074604768,
-0.0089064883,
-0.0438548326,
0.0360131115,
0.0263019484,
-0.0224895105,
0.0213099159,
-0.0002432406,
2.614e-7,
-0.0117031056,
0.0704448074,
-0.0404558219,
0.0813702568,
0.0169634037,
0.0661413297,
0.0165680517,
0.0149970911,
0.0335484073,
-0.0449870229,
0.0191633683,
0.0061491225,
0.0405105725,
0.0538129732,
-0.0363817737,
0.0019974182,
-0.029252423,
0.015111817,
-0.04638106,
0.0122169498,
0.0583262481,
0.0528492965,
0.0471804515,
-0.0153657068,
-0.008736751,
0.0025817989,
0.0059936163,
-0.003060783,
-0.0142768389,
0.0346459113,
-0.0096827708,
-0.035542421,
0.0154755786,
0.0561623536,
0.0070291678,
-0.0084984899,
-0.0561345331,
0.0655031651,
-0.0124466997,
-0.0437498093,
0.0227145925,
-0.0047016968,
-0.0181451235,
-0.0579075068,
0.0472400077,
0.0068178829,
-0.0410658717,
-0.0244969316,
-0.00293737,
-0.0586931296,
0.0361022316,
-0.0166697279,
0.0043602223,
0.0434478559,
0.0185442939,
-0.021858193,
-0.0097861551,
-0.0259961113,
0.0202673655,
0.0129093938,
-0.016331099,
-0.0911012962,
0.0032118775,
-0.004271559,
0.0351544209,
-0.0426397063,
0.0192165915,
2.28571249e-34,
-0.0109769618,
0.0732111409,
0.0255975034,
-0.013498581,
0.0630156547,
0.0211906563,
0.0201675296,
0.035625305,
0.0395826437,
-0.0735833794,
-0.0197131429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14701v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14701v1 | Speech Prefix-Tuning with RNNT Loss for Improving LLM Predictions | 2024-06-20T19:50:49 | 2024-06-20T19:50:49 | Murali Karthick Baskar, Andrew Rosenberg, Bhuvana Ramabhadran, Neeraj Gaur, Zhong Meng | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In this paper, we focus on addressing the constraints faced when applying
LLMs to ASR. Recent works utilize prefixLM-type models, which directly apply
speech as a prefix to LLMs for ASR. We have found that optimizing speech
prefixes leads to better ASR performance and propose applying RNNT loss to
perform speech prefix-tuning. This is a simple approach and does not increase
the model complexity or alter the inference pipeline. We also propose
language-based soft prompting to further improve with frozen LLMs. Empirical
analysis on realtime testset from 10 Indic languages demonstrate that our
proposed speech prefix-tuning yields improvements with both frozen and
fine-tuned LLMs. Our recognition results on an average of 10 Indics show that
the proposed prefix-tuning with RNNT loss results in a 12\% relative
improvement in WER over the baseline with a fine-tuned LLM. Our proposed
approches with the frozen LLM leads to a 31\% relative improvement over basic
soft-prompting prefixLM. | [
-0.0109066768,
0.0259938668,
0.0051270672,
0.0612270683,
-0.0119604329,
0.0034831318,
0.0171537381,
0.0164001156,
-0.016779853,
-0.012484205,
-0.0594923235,
-0.0561233684,
0.0393248759,
-0.0047296733,
0.0458248667,
-0.0280667134,
0.0374979675,
-0.0848890767,
-0.0322513022,
-0.0149359591,
0.021908287,
0.0053059035,
-0.0425466187,
0.0289565604,
-0.0117721353,
0.0531912297,
-0.0053457795,
0.0404583588,
0.0217243638,
-0.0468929484,
-0.0091596311,
0.0304366127,
0.0382210687,
-0.0077281999,
0.0000017659,
-0.0592235364,
0.0182713382,
-0.0081485631,
-0.077581577,
-0.0183525011,
-0.009489907,
0.0118082622,
-0.0038545839,
0.0506861433,
-0.0047480785,
0.0187737253,
0.0462823138,
0.0205826666,
-0.0253836699,
0.0746472254,
0.0200163927,
-0.013362322,
0.011376203,
-0.0246257428,
-0.0217716713,
-0.0220236126,
-0.0035104083,
-0.0643845126,
-0.0238871332,
0.0052883751,
-0.0243624616,
0.0429274663,
0.0173144955,
-0.0048231119,
0.0016941422,
-0.0022430501,
0.0033990731,
-0.0169588123,
-0.0367311724,
0.0324946381,
-0.0167008918,
-0.0283693764,
0.0391746573,
0.0045029707,
-0.0600025579,
-0.0572635792,
-0.0186362602,
0.0285699219,
0.0202019718,
-0.0059024566,
0.0002129308,
0.0118447049,
0.0394071527,
0.002413725,
0.0119550629,
0.0456972271,
0.0245109759,
-0.0407404155,
0.0191556793,
-0.0257023983,
0.045265086,
-0.0294013452,
0.0249044858,
0.0202688463,
-0.0151018258,
0.0299425963,
-0.0365270711,
0.0011405096,
0.0001085144,
-0.0242246445,
0.0233649947,
0.0615464114,
-0.0451198556,
-0.0174728371,
-0.0223179292,
0.0778573379,
0.0308550466,
0.0273039881,
-0.0240372624,
0.0029034319,
0.0178723373,
-0.0050979364,
-0.0129952608,
0.0322805606,
-0.0412105918,
-0.0011669463,
-0.0647625849,
0.0273288209,
0.0097785471,
-0.0406939015,
0.065505676,
-0.0195974484,
-0.0724765286,
-0.041553963,
-0.014905219,
0.0146099944,
0.0423480831,
0.0372156426,
0.0114765391,
-0.0891029909,
-0.0166183226,
0.0342246965,
0.0054200604,
-0.0136744706,
0.0102980621,
0.0950296447,
0.0097677875,
-0.0269906912,
-0.0624103062,
0.0095171938,
-0.0114768138,
-0.0409768447,
0.0210314095,
-0.0345766619,
0.0016349657,
-0.0173970219,
0.0012382732,
-0.0533632897,
0.005105685,
-0.0230893232,
0.0511717536,
0.0691114515,
-0.0256722905,
0.0023325738,
0.0178823955,
0.0102495439,
0.0339948274,
0.0523866266,
0.0106900129,
0.0067906142,
0.0235558394,
-0.015349891,
-0.0286847055,
0.065386191,
0.0145037528,
-0.0016442967,
-0.0443221703,
-0.0172042921,
0.0139700565,
0.0228775274,
0.0564675629,
0.0331198089,
0.0140932575,
-0.0374621339,
0.0529368967,
0.0711876899,
0.0270732846,
0.0326033793,
0.0284630731,
-0.0032786038,
-0.0072462996,
-0.0089167366,
-0.0309531838,
0.0186052229,
-0.0322658792,
0.0134937027,
0.0251364727,
0.0509295948,
-0.0175656211,
-0.0301503707,
-0.0331652649,
-0.0391748399,
-0.0526833273,
0.0629462227,
0.0261971597,
-0.009303011,
-0.0560205579,
0.0461044088,
0.0198429804,
-0.0231695957,
0.0335729159,
-0.0747948661,
-0.0238865595,
0.029955484,
-0.0096491333,
-0.0272771083,
-0.0601330809,
0.0005629797,
-0.0324006453,
0.0442755483,
-0.0107274661,
0.0220121183,
0.0488139428,
-0.0737331435,
-0.0169821549,
0.0791450217,
-0.0180180874,
0.0759349242,
-0.02041726,
0.0175508335,
0.0238410234,
-0.0005017032,
0.0322975628,
0.0024965457,
-0.059475217,
-0.0222440213,
0.0164629146,
0.009504417,
0.0762794614,
0.0495234132,
-0.0071722623,
-0.0131216347,
0.0422141105,
-0.0197001416,
0.019635113,
0.0214795023,
-0.0816094726,
-0.0496496819,
0.0455750339,
0.0446662791,
0.0230736546,
0.0537503548,
0.0035933962,
-0.063999936,
-0.0047254674,
-0.0141842812,
0.0535663925,
-0.0551065318,
0.0705694258,
0.0620094687,
-0.0036853813,
-0.0174677912,
-0.0089541692,
-0.0204857457,
0.0152434995,
0.0559834763,
-0.0039016488,
-0.0024449432,
-0.1292873025,
-0.0210738946,
0.0461401567,
-0.0208651107,
0.0072948546,
0.0080895768,
-0.0266735461,
-0.0213191323,
0.0021132501,
-0.0536396056,
-0.0028905694,
-0.0330104344,
0.0247516055,
-0.0045843865,
0.038708318,
-0.0060512968,
-0.0341192968,
-0.030867219,
-0.0534063354,
-0.0107589038,
-0.0039656693,
-0.0405632183,
0.0196464267,
-0.0324048474,
-0.0129546477,
-0.0143968239,
0.0227509439,
0.011069526,
-0.038501773,
-0.0692871958,
-0.0598790757,
0.0066585932,
0.0148699787,
0.0193542149,
-0.032076709,
-0.0282393321,
-0.0420595035,
-0.0094030621,
0.0307960827,
0.0400820337,
-0.0049781478,
-0.0107411854,
0.0022951581,
-0.0307598747,
-0.0493060984,
-0.0049582566,
0.0036588442,
0.0041509876,
-0.0111685432,
0.018375054,
-0.0012010419,
0.0341691785,
0.0076877358,
0.0384734124,
-0.0213816781,
-0.0298337508,
-0.0080619911,
-0.0542490706,
-0.0320162252,
0.0032533812,
-0.0651881546,
0.0344204046,
0.0052674757,
-0.0341248028,
0.0142946588,
-0.095478572,
-0.0216430873,
-0.0096630268,
-0.0526607744,
-0.0260107778,
0.0067867329,
-0.0252231117,
-0.0098143928,
-0.0180673636,
-0.042259831,
-0.0310059153,
-0.0145729734,
-0.0369451493,
-0.0308589786,
0.0655029565,
-0.0193142854,
0.0058109383,
-0.0136017781,
-0.0002444003,
-0.0183006804,
0.0362052508,
-0.0201466456,
0.0333902091,
0.0127063729,
-0.0156287141,
0.0315284915,
0.0155989034,
-0.0240298249,
0.0561335087,
0.0057902248,
0.045996882,
-0.0343716852,
0.0227941517,
0.0347006135,
0.0298170894,
-0.0164062101,
-0.005860236,
0.0175970364,
-0.0337261222,
0.0447859094,
-0.0424766503,
-0.0694594234,
0.0078995433,
0.0546830595,
-0.0215420295,
0.0160124619,
0.0444230214,
0.0302792024,
-0.0486125536,
0.0187024251,
0.0930149183,
-0.0088179419,
-0.0048840367,
-0.013969576,
0.0106912777,
0.0459667891,
0.0004763539,
-0.0098938169,
-0.0479845963,
-0.0327766128,
0.0517889224,
0.0331485122,
0.0195378829,
0.0276731309,
-0.0102703953,
-0.083494164,
0.0032072598,
0.0153403971,
-0.0293294061,
-0.0156369247,
0.0009534188,
-0.0264643859,
-0.006979092,
0.0749828145,
0.0322818682,
-0.0406812094,
-0.0359072201,
0.0543251373,
-0.0964783877,
-0.0670194328,
-0.005472037,
-0.0256656874,
0.0756750181,
0.0369147472,
-0.0079988679,
0.0141932433,
-0.0552672632,
0.0407853425,
0.0008932545,
0.0211095437,
-0.0462808423,
-0.0010988396,
0.0165680572,
-0.0070382981,
0.0022514039,
0.0139556164,
0.0020817665,
0.00081606,
0.0039520129,
0.0230277907,
-0.064134039,
0.0123473378,
0.009658142,
-0.013492614,
0.0027401317,
0.044925265,
0.0141329868,
0.0095622055,
-0.013972695,
0.0249965917,
0.0309682079,
-0.0371707156,
-0.0589648262,
-0.034591049,
-0.050114803,
-0.0331146121,
-0.0359418429,
0.0038530333,
0.0000059496,
0.0421986803,
0.0204329714,
0.0464994125,
-0.0306046512,
0.0348851867,
-0.0253769718,
0.018204879,
-0.0402553305,
0.0243246704,
-0.1050920933,
-0.0145369601,
0.060134802,
-0.0444382988,
-0.0056424155,
0.0394159555,
-0.0734155029,
-0.0695738047,
0.0036716152,
0.0058490429,
0.0179501176,
0.0729503259,
0.0000310626,
-0.0703461543,
0.0473716855,
0.0154407853,
0.0484018549,
0.0637585223,
0.0667861998,
0.0029292305,
-0.0185237341,
0.0313738026,
-0.060301993,
0.0319062695,
0.0011996507,
0.0240062587,
-0.0357699208,
-0.0488735288,
-0.0124945575,
0.0493087694,
0.0847282037,
-0.0365998112,
-0.0034293819,
-0.0382214524,
0.0776221901,
0.0073153619,
0.0642724708,
-0.0222405996,
-0.0059267767,
0.0186632965,
0.0187616646,
-0.0062606563,
0.0031037128,
-0.0307997558,
-0.0343549438,
-0.007501578,
0.082313709,
-0.0244373884,
0.0341197625,
0.0120673478,
0.0428726636,
-0.0153840277,
0.0470422357,
0.041010458,
0.0052077067,
-0.0038614359,
0.0032656607,
-0.0011850978,
0.0158671141,
0.0209906697,
0.0389411822,
0.0010857141,
-0.0410411768,
-0.0335744657,
0.0429313779,
0.0295721609,
-0.0032906521,
0.0073539163,
-0.0064215953,
0.0211129878,
-0.0473873429,
0.027218448,
-0.006499555,
0.0208271369,
0.0823102966,
-0.0032215542,
-0.0245874319,
0.0235941503,
0.0094836485,
0.0180761833,
0.0466555096,
0.0151446601,
0.0434146672,
-0.0279763676,
-0.0622136369,
0.0179654919,
-0.0258122422,
-0.0174233578,
-0.0176040046,
0.0015341135,
-0.0854535028,
0.0442095473,
-0.0031304653,
0.0177360605,
-0.0264655575,
0.0184935592,
-0.0296638384,
-0.0139961326,
0.0181850754,
0.0254269913,
-0.0562151894,
-0.0078780223,
-0.038771946,
-0.0001222542,
-6.259342849e-33,
-0.0537282564,
0.0348278433,
0.0386835895,
0.0197997205,
-0.0407786369,
0.0289238077,
-0.0302330256,
0.0045572035,
-0.0066074105,
-0.0418048017,
-0.0220025629,
-0.0342999734,
0.0461027883,
0.0184041262,
-0.0415413342,
-0.0207136646,
0.0884517655,
0.0033973109,
0.0349035785,
-0.0299779512,
0.0127396649,
0.0369780101,
0.0547486506,
-0.0356503129,
-0.0375780389,
-0.0010777761,
-0.0022024952,
0.0175041985,
0.0267742425,
0.0492977165,
0.0010168948,
0.0339713134,
0.0065868446,
-0.0314248316,
-0.0421453901,
0.0359689109,
-0.0813516602,
-0.0115192095,
0.0314172208,
0.0552842729,
-0.0049381843,
-0.0380382538,
0.0427196138,
0.0044587855,
-0.0826922208,
0.0012854853,
0.0095224706,
-0.0189547669,
-0.0444564,
-0.0838519633,
0.0083177323,
0.030668214,
0.007552783,
-0.0117017962,
0.0666919649,
-0.0089885639,
-0.0118641322,
-0.001399804,
-0.0417117551,
0.0343486331,
0.0274923984,
0.0917667598,
0.0702285841,
0.0502058715,
-0.0257035159,
0.0009972954,
0.0057580932,
-0.0325420573,
0.0671156719,
-0.0175227821,
0.0575745851,
0.0282861926,
0.0371079184,
0.0100319646,
0.0550385825,
-0.0332289599,
-0.0039166757,
0.0004727232,
0.0469802357,
0.0295132473,
0.0208592974,
0.0311254524,
-0.0250722654,
0.0055716117,
-0.0240543168,
0.0070100944,
-0.0291765742,
-0.0140461,
0.0933108404,
0.0200644191,
0.0206012055,
0.0490118824,
0.0824697465,
-0.0119414246,
0.0173024088,
-0.0183880702,
0.0419844203,
-0.0054065082,
-0.0139489966,
0.0028114102,
-0.0607695803,
-0.0479919612,
0.0367817469,
0.022308724,
0.0007134535,
-0.0513632074,
0.0057338346,
0.0564805232,
-0.0714860484,
-0.0024628644,
-0.0002796716,
0.0348761901,
0.0385857187,
0.0051635043,
0.032721743,
-0.0420728512,
0.0015978105,
0.06299413,
-0.0245743599,
-0.0437310748,
-0.0211188681,
0.0025822681,
0.0301601999,
0.0265796073,
-0.0410980098,
0.0196596142,
0.0289680082,
-0.0217592176,
0.0252574123,
-0.0291471221,
-0.0154551184,
0.0037502211,
2.583e-7,
-0.0480606034,
0.0219893809,
0.0380899198,
-0.0108975787,
-0.0226329286,
-0.0180989876,
-0.0383158103,
-0.0008703535,
0.0022848446,
0.0058170189,
0.0049166,
-0.0152839115,
0.0376208089,
-0.0390368961,
-0.1177371368,
-0.0016145542,
-0.0736501515,
0.05138487,
-0.0155163752,
-0.0071831797,
-0.0132503305,
0.0793397501,
-0.024976436,
-0.0385288969,
-0.0208162889,
-0.0083050011,
0.0221572649,
-0.0322464593,
0.0179236159,
-0.0001544283,
0.0468228795,
-0.0093949316,
-0.028737165,
-0.0186308194,
-0.0448458195,
0.0071705664,
0.0073171621,
0.0320978574,
-0.0425554328,
-0.1017232835,
0.0352683403,
0.0429862998,
-0.0112768952,
0.0069518504,
0.0375028327,
0.0242767893,
-0.0074838097,
-0.0375277139,
-0.0446519554,
-0.026702188,
-0.0304796081,
-0.0040635364,
0.0090628201,
0.0210215561,
0.0066197324,
-0.0126787266,
-0.0383135937,
-0.0847719759,
0.0030921227,
-0.0010127033,
-0.0653028488,
-0.0190484319,
-0.03638063,
0.0023553751,
0.0056868186,
-0.0013131447,
-0.0248629898,
2.144561103e-34,
0.0331845395,
-0.0041202456,
0.0052351314,
0.0679350719,
0.0029476339,
-0.0278093535,
0.0218506958,
0.0762993321,
0.0051530502,
-0.0637382418,
-0.0423036925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14695v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14695v1 | Depth $F_1$: Improving Evaluation of Cross-Domain Text Classification by Measuring Semantic Generalizability | 2024-06-20T19:35:17 | 2024-06-20T19:35:17 | Parker Seegmiller, Joseph Gatto, Sarah Masud Preum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent evaluations of cross-domain text classification models aim to measure
the ability of a model to obtain domain-invariant performance in a target
domain given labeled samples in a source domain. The primary strategy for this
evaluation relies on assumed differences between source domain samples and
target domain samples in benchmark datasets. This evaluation strategy fails to
account for the similarity between source and target domains, and may mask when
models fail to transfer learning to specific target samples which are highly
dissimilar from the source domain. We introduce Depth $F_1$, a novel
cross-domain text classification performance metric. Designed to be
complementary to existing classification metrics such as $F_1$, Depth $F_1$
measures how well a model performs on target samples which are dissimilar from
the source domain. We motivate this metric using standard cross-domain text
classification datasets and benchmark several recent cross-domain text
classification models, with the goal of enabling in-depth evaluation of the
semantic generalizability of cross-domain text classification models. | [
-0.0006823178,
-0.0367907882,
-0.0111285727,
0.0056605851,
-0.0293639135,
0.0229099188,
0.0099156043,
0.0288534462,
-0.0039622826,
-0.0775749907,
-0.0529777855,
-0.0194896124,
-0.0026123985,
0.0270879604,
-0.03566508,
-0.0304100513,
0.0278300047,
0.0342563093,
-0.0577715375,
0.0418960378,
-0.0232774448,
-0.0163957886,
0.0277884603,
0.037062604,
0.0361104012,
-0.0232007392,
0.0328563266,
0.0098415995,
0.033912655,
-0.0143623985,
0.0209905375,
-0.005773203,
0.0221669283,
0.0329043344,
0.0000019739,
-0.0517355576,
-0.0588470362,
0.0192735773,
0.0131885447,
-0.012245696,
0.0341597088,
-0.0431265347,
0.051893957,
0.0154139362,
-0.0018896466,
-0.0485997796,
0.0313231759,
0.0796907097,
0.0226388834,
0.0653447658,
-0.0174675304,
-0.0328244753,
0.0286372527,
-0.02760485,
-0.0076538827,
-0.0712834671,
0.004573768,
0.0240797307,
-0.0251851734,
-0.0034193979,
-0.0267952513,
0.0055756196,
0.0202565603,
0.0519538708,
-0.0024978949,
-0.0177289695,
0.0254416652,
0.0227834601,
0.0222023912,
0.0295605324,
0.0062051639,
-0.0105145155,
-0.0004214398,
-0.0259949304,
0.0423707813,
0.0478475392,
-0.0250493716,
-0.0449836776,
-0.0033915299,
-0.0033889057,
-0.019612439,
0.0755848363,
0.0476423427,
-0.0196597483,
0.0013548562,
0.0626420155,
-0.0030732465,
-0.0243329257,
0.0391492508,
0.0458438508,
0.0165223368,
0.0021160739,
0.00495813,
-0.0128625119,
0.0026778162,
-0.0117235882,
-0.042133186,
-0.0540047437,
0.0246312059,
-0.0362403393,
0.052120287,
-0.0151951117,
-0.017762512,
0.0293326899,
-0.0091314381,
0.0480794124,
-0.008345129,
0.0234477129,
-0.0308335237,
-0.0208526347,
-0.1055725068,
0.0163957663,
-0.0071670478,
0.0340519771,
0.0298361126,
-0.0119944336,
-0.0605967306,
0.0152135976,
-0.0366683081,
-0.0049811574,
0.0110263117,
-0.0361793153,
-0.0010311004,
0.0046374081,
-0.0263544358,
-0.013739395,
-0.0291095637,
0.0465795621,
0.0024077962,
0.0013124183,
0.0347341299,
-0.0126994457,
-0.0001639631,
-0.0264353417,
0.0085479617,
0.1331656873,
0.0454445444,
-0.0368500538,
-0.0318107009,
-0.0219090618,
-0.0137716727,
-0.0592564642,
0.0287198406,
-0.0221050233,
-0.0186319761,
0.0182380192,
0.0123619167,
-0.0459666438,
-0.045597408,
-0.0225699432,
0.0140178232,
0.0515192747,
0.0327262059,
-0.0328710973,
0.0554777458,
0.0340900607,
-0.0192877669,
0.0681211576,
-0.010842002,
0.0027493085,
0.081374146,
0.0149632562,
-0.0018720792,
-0.0115626669,
0.0134359011,
0.0052453233,
-0.0015177898,
0.02836187,
0.034334749,
-0.0088603757,
-0.0017045502,
-0.0439468846,
-0.007395451,
-0.0388504602,
0.029484909,
0.0176304355,
0.0353731699,
0.007267979,
0.0664095208,
0.0104786474,
-0.0388081148,
0.0363822393,
-0.0011408357,
0.0037638883,
0.0009554607,
-0.02401549,
0.0577840991,
-0.0008166149,
-0.047454007,
-0.0644879863,
-0.008751682,
-0.0250312071,
0.0180456955,
-0.0052857576,
0.0525426827,
0.0024605289,
-0.0021825794,
0.0356644988,
0.0315522663,
-0.0351496972,
0.0073187151,
-0.042033758,
0.0167298019,
-0.0265320037,
-0.0026263276,
-0.070432879,
0.0350940749,
0.0044401572,
0.0382048637,
-0.0048242966,
0.0521682017,
-0.0123079708,
0.0125222197,
0.0048677693,
-0.0673200041,
-0.0377561711,
0.0461122729,
0.0105899936,
0.0144118574,
0.0315430239,
0.0702822432,
-0.0879513919,
0.0147311948,
0.0200392772,
-0.0392933935,
0.0125776185,
0.0242064986,
0.021679461,
0.0175801888,
0.0020848296,
-0.0222152993,
-0.0132418815,
0.0126064401,
-0.0326551311,
-0.0648494661,
-0.0413871855,
0.0428241566,
0.0301892832,
-0.0222034063,
-0.0786641389,
0.0126463464,
0.088535957,
-0.0308727138,
0.0064907032,
0.0343606174,
0.0171526242,
0.030674126,
-0.0270260535,
-0.0056099836,
-0.040337231,
0.0092894109,
-0.0085630007,
0.0521466844,
0.0317450538,
0.0475276522,
-0.0498082824,
-0.0339229628,
0.0407821983,
0.0162752457,
-0.0099900579,
-0.0286499746,
-0.0524372011,
0.0499801673,
0.0095126377,
-0.0282595456,
-0.0298402496,
-0.0003389516,
-0.0218028408,
-0.0029284752,
-0.0286755264,
0.0157978777,
-0.0084970761,
0.009372416,
0.0180256907,
-0.0091787418,
-0.0428613275,
0.001038644,
-0.0264526512,
0.0170326009,
0.0235276818,
-0.0158169325,
0.0145777334,
-0.0074672042,
-0.0038669372,
0.0222025141,
0.0973550901,
-0.008673667,
0.0469052084,
-0.0676327944,
0.0443750843,
-0.0371542349,
-0.0064098937,
-0.0183467269,
0.0104351956,
-0.0427504629,
0.0352091342,
-0.0817407817,
0.0460368656,
-0.011295219,
-0.0152984168,
0.0319008455,
0.049677927,
-0.0180910733,
-0.0113870427,
-0.0191379879,
0.0397109725,
-0.0265605599,
0.0039067809,
0.0407464057,
0.0571526028,
-0.0104681123,
-0.0376883,
-0.0465594456,
0.0185746457,
-0.0621793307,
-0.0034383661,
-0.041267626,
0.0161833167,
0.0206769686,
0.0234720577,
-0.0039492617,
-0.0584062375,
0.0413872488,
-0.0334426612,
0.0707640871,
-0.0393802337,
-0.0544903241,
-0.0598173812,
0.0515282787,
-0.0390738174,
0.0171145517,
0.0516286455,
0.0055538369,
-0.0172384828,
0.0181253012,
0.0191451535,
-0.0137391035,
0.0757272989,
-0.0043146056,
0.0147614535,
-0.0006365369,
-0.042225074,
0.0056909686,
0.0047343411,
-0.0061166468,
0.0170127247,
-0.0251392797,
-0.0011337978,
-0.0525744744,
0.0208630525,
-0.0213654935,
0.0318513922,
-0.0234818626,
-0.0388156213,
0.0093994942,
0.0262975749,
-0.0078598289,
-0.0178833213,
-0.0515679456,
-0.0413093008,
-0.0074889343,
0.017169131,
-0.0256592538,
0.0096806763,
-0.0368630476,
0.0148260435,
0.004109134,
-0.0250861719,
-0.0500076637,
-0.0134018874,
0.0183653198,
-0.0271694195,
-0.0443960167,
0.0728053004,
0.0218518209,
-0.0226716734,
-0.0077046361,
-0.0086288676,
0.0196846724,
0.0184021592,
0.0033216875,
-0.0012599666,
-0.0508412197,
-0.0090151709,
0.003141894,
0.0108084232,
0.0074785454,
0.0290119611,
-0.0848187655,
-0.0009262793,
-0.0344564766,
-0.0700378194,
-0.0467733964,
-0.0710698292,
0.0298813637,
0.0009941675,
-0.0404091701,
-0.0880085528,
0.006994803,
-0.0327885188,
0.0142894778,
-0.0313645378,
-0.0377953984,
0.0330061279,
-0.0285517648,
-0.0307490658,
0.0466187224,
0.036252711,
0.0092544882,
-0.0202612672,
0.0311847683,
-0.008455012,
-0.0050392831,
0.006270214,
0.1080206409,
-0.0244474318,
0.0205154773,
0.0424956493,
-0.0211573821,
-0.0021545365,
0.0131165925,
0.0158117432,
0.0720543191,
0.0072186976,
-0.0104306964,
-0.0406163447,
-0.0005097526,
-0.0042487406,
0.0476702265,
0.0183785893,
-0.0651594028,
-0.0195639487,
-0.0240252614,
-0.007639973,
-0.0537035465,
-0.032266669,
0.0233809892,
-0.0320647508,
-0.0525760092,
-0.0349341594,
-0.0302018132,
-0.0419926122,
0.0094560487,
-0.0054825298,
-0.0074022794,
-0.0434432067,
-0.0007216622,
-0.0489332452,
-0.0129367495,
0.000735313,
0.069211483,
-0.0328639112,
0.0372412764,
0.0505087338,
-0.0096628536,
-0.0837626457,
0.0141648566,
-0.0505096763,
-0.0295974482,
-0.0320391916,
-0.0367589407,
0.0124328816,
-0.002383406,
-0.0274758339,
-0.0437786356,
0.0844118297,
-0.0040063597,
-0.0198988467,
-0.0057300408,
0.076759994,
-0.0555419251,
-0.0067858975,
0.0292512644,
-0.0774398744,
0.0295203067,
0.0414756648,
-0.0442150347,
0.0333506539,
-0.0101784635,
-0.0375738591,
-0.0369324833,
0.0795844272,
0.0391499847,
-0.0597131178,
-0.0043751616,
0.0124749178,
0.0142564038,
-0.0221054628,
-0.0346358083,
-0.0299462825,
0.0778908357,
0.0080474177,
-0.0246885624,
0.0649319887,
-0.0144530693,
0.0422846042,
-0.0536168925,
0.0050097802,
0.0381015763,
0.0960752219,
-0.0307027213,
0.012304645,
-0.0292616505,
-0.0791239589,
0.0323567316,
-0.0023836303,
-0.0176432841,
0.0234088432,
0.0113781346,
0.0855578184,
-0.0156546086,
0.0294141062,
-0.090546675,
0.0492062867,
-0.0270739868,
-0.0097837131,
0.0314438008,
-0.0142437303,
0.0133412611,
0.0116278185,
-0.0284942482,
-0.0203871019,
0.0370064452,
0.0116517199,
-0.0284160431,
0.018542394,
-0.0099001015,
-0.004216285,
0.0260866471,
0.0659172386,
0.0255997088,
0.022879729,
-0.0080710491,
-0.0382511951,
-0.0181789901,
0.0107232425,
0.0460658893,
0.0073314519,
-0.011987281,
-0.0210580062,
-0.0774455667,
-0.08661028,
0.0649544075,
-0.0151432808,
0.0248687156,
0.0338951685,
0.0102103101,
0.0892676041,
0.0056343959,
-0.0090750717,
-0.0414642468,
-0.0591325164,
-0.009446932,
0.0179691017,
-0.0127884531,
-5.344918814e-33,
0.0048804958,
0.0112273814,
-0.023058651,
-0.0008670411,
-0.0460366867,
0.0339120775,
0.0250186566,
-0.0072173653,
0.0338570178,
0.0025932938,
0.0096975844,
0.0354420431,
-0.0046034958,
0.0056636655,
-0.0169134792,
-0.0425749347,
0.032262858,
0.0038822843,
-0.0573659465,
0.0085814018,
0.0358186588,
0.0079265991,
0.0350594036,
-0.0828229263,
0.0497850925,
0.0293476377,
0.0062826662,
-0.0421133228,
0.05204501,
0.0581845231,
0.0063616084,
0.0459536985,
0.0554873347,
-0.0814542472,
0.0069984519,
0.0422171839,
-0.0211533289,
-0.0317777731,
-0.0069300402,
-0.009075135,
-0.0161574483,
-0.0115280291,
-0.0270170923,
0.0359119959,
-0.0061691236,
-0.0937778354,
0.0658238158,
-0.0232227203,
-0.0028003461,
-0.0408693366,
-0.0323222652,
0.0390119851,
-0.0133944685,
-0.0235845223,
0.0225572474,
0.0757967904,
0.0268783607,
0.0383423306,
-0.0106614344,
0.0261851531,
-0.0181930363,
0.0116487006,
0.0182666574,
-0.0047008796,
-0.0520555899,
0.0602468923,
-0.0040268321,
-0.0022414087,
0.0295259673,
-0.0183296353,
0.0191884357,
0.0500961244,
0.0068016583,
0.1126389876,
0.0577706732,
-0.03046594,
-0.1332127452,
0.0508666262,
-0.0607281886,
-0.0408693254,
0.0282176603,
0.00536551,
-0.0154878506,
-0.0068624676,
-0.0526629239,
-0.0086713061,
-0.0252792723,
-0.02851215,
0.038627997,
-0.0070512388,
-0.0114722783,
0.0025838956,
-0.0034579982,
-0.0812311545,
-0.0011506815,
0.0404458381,
-0.0179756097,
0.013393376,
0.0279364549,
-0.0434553325,
0.0171296392,
-0.0358724855,
0.0118642263,
0.0267532635,
0.0702820569,
-0.0548080951,
0.068451196,
-0.0255935062,
-0.0431884117,
-0.0078986995,
-0.0015761894,
-0.0371657908,
-0.0126348976,
0.0770391971,
-0.0079712588,
0.0102232099,
-0.0194013491,
0.0642996579,
-0.0014814414,
-0.0220500883,
-0.0217613596,
-0.0001053722,
0.0041467077,
0.0177663974,
-0.020626042,
-0.0480143838,
-0.0094304755,
-0.0193711203,
0.0461452566,
-0.0581427477,
-0.0233136117,
-0.0166926645,
2.531e-7,
0.0357110165,
0.0144154215,
-0.0253350735,
0.0062447502,
0.0209798105,
0.0589054115,
-0.0291796271,
0.0800340325,
-0.0081974184,
0.0236311834,
-0.0068361368,
-0.026438741,
0.0785226598,
0.0215860344,
-0.0583944768,
-0.0019010734,
-0.0172769539,
0.015460738,
-0.0015111495,
0.0257892273,
0.0174219217,
0.0482393652,
0.0226468891,
-0.0214711595,
0.0047801929,
-0.0358774811,
0.0563213006,
-0.0470343418,
0.0266807657,
0.0214690212,
-0.0372758843,
0.0195302013,
0.0184910819,
0.0388849564,
-0.0543663204,
0.031669531,
0.0811811239,
0.0389553308,
0.0357224569,
0.0190142319,
-0.0296704248,
0.0066754473,
0.0098776892,
-0.0112209208,
0.0511546247,
-0.0622389279,
-0.0084366566,
-0.010760651,
-0.0102378475,
-0.014396837,
0.0744301751,
0.0175053179,
-0.0244543515,
0.0188133828,
0.009366462,
0.0004756975,
0.0121295517,
-0.0382720158,
-0.0016529337,
-0.0052360357,
-0.0128384503,
-0.0036609343,
-0.0092046857,
-0.0157079604,
0.0478083119,
-0.0551491119,
0.0315853208,
2.153408764e-34,
0.0206921753,
0.0070131538,
0.0110464403,
-0.0557080433,
0.0120619964,
-0.0302410275,
0.0053036395,
-0.0360095054,
0.0043227673,
-0.0137647679,
0.0601497032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14686v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14686v1 | A Contrastive Learning Approach to Mitigate Bias in Speech Models | 2024-06-20T19:20:00 | 2024-06-20T19:20:00 | Alkis Koudounas, Flavio Giobergia, Eliana Pastor, Elena Baralis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Speech models may be affected by performance imbalance in different
population subgroups, raising concerns about fair treatment across these
groups. Prior attempts to mitigate unfairness either focus on user-defined
subgroups, potentially overlooking other affected subgroups, or do not
explicitly improve the internal representation at the subgroup level. This
paper proposes the first adoption of contrastive learning to mitigate speech
model bias in underperforming subgroups. We employ a three-level learning
technique that guides the model in focusing on different scopes for the
contrastive loss, i.e., task, subgroup, and the errors within subgroups. The
experiments on two spoken language understanding datasets and two languages
demonstrate that our approach improves internal subgroup representations, thus
reducing model bias and enhancing performance. | [
0.0015422009,
0.0900070295,
-0.0231471024,
0.0439590178,
-0.0303298272,
0.0338189155,
0.0496541783,
-0.0359240286,
-0.0447968915,
-0.0380930156,
-0.086067453,
-0.0630146936,
0.0486848094,
-0.039931003,
0.0577271841,
-0.1471128464,
0.0716345981,
-0.0387446359,
0.0255011227,
-0.0370078012,
0.0048904601,
-0.0047196615,
-0.0421207882,
0.0280594844,
0.0218811668,
-0.0152519261,
0.0424674675,
0.0221383255,
0.0113709038,
-0.0034284536,
0.0333170369,
0.0550821982,
0.0206003878,
0.0018566463,
0.0000018979,
-0.0188486911,
0.0017817655,
0.0068499055,
-0.0461599641,
0.0156904776,
0.0690702796,
-0.0016306927,
-0.0179248601,
0.0354939029,
-0.006814518,
-0.0192537531,
0.0295469146,
0.043563541,
0.0290226471,
0.0263340417,
-0.0105986129,
-0.0603394061,
-0.0215435829,
-0.0124850981,
-0.0134559413,
-0.006252375,
-0.0075411797,
-0.0244662724,
-0.0276879631,
-0.0669265389,
-0.0229785964,
0.0198084656,
-0.0003220342,
0.0424621627,
0.0193929262,
0.0034456437,
-0.0433857478,
-0.0210556127,
-0.0148006314,
0.0294449851,
0.0072553842,
0.0374485403,
-0.0297250953,
-0.0178514235,
0.0038731571,
-0.0233320668,
-0.018548429,
0.0037386068,
-0.0014342429,
0.0012163641,
0.0346249156,
0.0442149267,
-0.0044444581,
-0.0068292413,
-0.0180511512,
-0.0187473465,
0.0175346155,
-0.0111909518,
-0.0175157487,
0.0094331736,
-0.0318200476,
0.0068784906,
0.01427045,
-0.0230756085,
-0.0437454768,
0.0112238582,
-0.0255507659,
-0.0458736382,
0.0227910746,
-0.0482497066,
0.0109098945,
0.0607830323,
-0.0467755646,
0.0255873334,
0.0374247432,
0.0299823284,
0.0079665715,
0.0136217102,
0.0023204498,
-0.035397958,
0.0125884386,
0.0200037733,
-0.0298517067,
0.0016294144,
-0.04161584,
0.0574037731,
-0.0343035609,
-0.0045534722,
-0.0448828377,
-0.0282153934,
0.0076761423,
-0.0071399352,
-0.0792486146,
-0.0148415295,
-0.0034175296,
0.0451242998,
0.0068242666,
0.0399380475,
-0.018237222,
-0.0959890038,
0.0009731535,
-0.0128290532,
-0.0157730989,
-0.0313275978,
-0.0015403487,
0.0852265358,
0.0154704405,
-0.0418370292,
-0.0758595243,
0.0221449994,
-0.0077676745,
-0.0557471439,
-0.0484377891,
-0.0433885418,
0.0166074317,
0.0073286192,
0.0155588994,
-0.0277659371,
-0.0510269292,
-0.0242668744,
-0.0056686373,
0.0556080379,
0.0177943576,
-0.0241570026,
0.0239074137,
0.0105874166,
-0.0538406782,
0.0661826879,
0.0314503871,
-0.0810144022,
-0.0134054832,
-0.0269750804,
-0.0163919684,
0.0310576558,
0.0324080139,
-0.0060727419,
-0.0310127959,
-0.0041219788,
-0.0146262478,
-0.0362232588,
0.104271777,
0.0651523024,
-0.0231808852,
-0.0321550407,
0.0668046549,
0.0622810423,
0.0633800998,
0.0501141697,
-0.0113917626,
-0.0033327912,
-0.0357527807,
0.0408115163,
-0.0162147842,
0.0015643543,
0.0074154963,
-0.0079440568,
0.040177837,
0.0473254696,
-0.0472359955,
-0.0377266742,
-0.0033611832,
0.0192992669,
0.0161072183,
0.0250281915,
0.0655507147,
0.0147701483,
-0.0216950774,
0.0200090334,
0.0758085921,
-0.0049096029,
0.0653375983,
-0.0504675694,
-0.0023553164,
0.0487338826,
-0.0152011327,
-0.0254116692,
0.0100837788,
0.0025496914,
-0.0414818749,
0.0507365875,
0.024742214,
-0.0128617007,
0.0574678034,
-0.0371625349,
-0.0114051821,
0.0411476418,
0.0080799442,
0.0359115489,
-0.0516216271,
-0.016211817,
-0.0222115181,
-0.0492619015,
-0.0119866729,
0.0027305637,
-0.0216068979,
-0.0181245264,
0.0153717846,
0.0146258548,
0.0279084779,
0.0240021404,
-0.0414461195,
-0.0092207016,
-0.051147528,
-0.0034458137,
0.0106702633,
-0.0057794214,
-0.0780778229,
-0.0983367041,
0.000611986,
-0.0455642343,
-0.0193556622,
0.0338205732,
-0.0209259484,
-0.0407140329,
0.0811771601,
-0.0354947299,
0.0665847063,
-0.0298418161,
0.0090136286,
-0.0141598098,
0.0028721446,
-0.0182921998,
0.0430869274,
-0.0084392801,
-0.0294910725,
0.0351653919,
-0.0114435181,
-0.0095831044,
-0.0780784488,
-0.004397016,
0.0142136393,
-0.0111770667,
0.0403445996,
-0.014362853,
-0.0340336412,
-0.0323117934,
0.0425631776,
-0.0255354606,
0.0056071859,
-0.0317607597,
0.0261856653,
0.0127883721,
0.0286683571,
-0.0170216821,
-0.044022046,
-0.0067096553,
-0.0603500754,
-0.0056681531,
0.0055597471,
-0.0327935442,
0.0154441083,
0.0003675142,
-0.0154983932,
-0.0230110586,
-0.0069507067,
0.0400389656,
-0.0074804765,
-0.0134337218,
-0.0530708469,
0.0194715355,
0.0102041895,
0.0461728834,
0.0004019274,
-0.0028232003,
-0.0207429118,
0.054913234,
0.0256840922,
0.0418996476,
0.015261922,
-0.0177182294,
0.0230064355,
-0.0128218336,
-0.0239838399,
0.0031305046,
0.0047491114,
0.014246271,
-0.0025639141,
-0.021535771,
-0.0517082214,
0.0959488228,
0.0910853073,
0.0093583288,
-0.052588921,
-0.0167142823,
-0.0342115127,
0.008349821,
-0.0171808098,
-0.0208472945,
-0.0345371887,
0.0112872748,
-0.0674445331,
-0.0319129527,
0.0546700135,
-0.0132890623,
-0.0156703964,
-0.065594174,
-0.0254374556,
-0.0245591272,
-0.0204266254,
-0.0663882345,
0.0050114514,
0.0514665432,
-0.077650927,
-0.0781186149,
-0.0345687009,
0.046654772,
-0.035478238,
0.0623489991,
-0.0037957083,
-0.0112552792,
-0.0525583252,
-0.0539856702,
-0.0358716957,
-0.0021361427,
-0.0158141498,
0.055517938,
0.0386099704,
-0.0080652852,
-0.0135109741,
0.0021787412,
0.0254787188,
0.0363975912,
0.0022141989,
-0.0123425741,
0.0197634436,
0.0319119059,
-0.0195834618,
0.0109847765,
0.0431958213,
-0.0700045824,
0.0731709003,
0.027885465,
0.0754879043,
0.0059205187,
-0.0350207016,
0.0163061302,
0.055924587,
0.0114226909,
-0.0163567793,
0.0061060782,
0.0347521938,
-0.0449600779,
0.0280747898,
0.0860637128,
-0.0298093725,
-0.0655664057,
0.0071021845,
-0.0192754865,
0.0375958197,
0.0133480029,
-0.0087006781,
-0.0324030034,
-0.0190399494,
0.0470617674,
0.0720961988,
0.0057278317,
0.0161260851,
0.0142786037,
-0.0692062303,
0.0676232725,
0.0365021415,
-0.0200784411,
-0.0045535453,
-0.0314473212,
0.0462351739,
-0.0587960109,
0.0917512476,
-0.0010138934,
-0.0134597244,
-0.0306332354,
0.0789152682,
-0.0629728213,
-0.0493772812,
0.0331687853,
-0.0498096421,
0.0435933955,
0.0383416675,
0.0068103406,
0.01483119,
-0.0111288223,
0.0363302454,
-0.072943449,
-0.0054786652,
-0.0292982589,
0.0542723648,
-0.0079178158,
-0.0127302874,
-0.0145517122,
0.0425514877,
-0.008006338,
-0.0115492372,
-0.0181539301,
0.0312244594,
-0.0062153903,
0.0451173224,
-0.0211479254,
0.0134373577,
0.0305263661,
0.0641788095,
0.0467629991,
-0.0271053519,
0.0129221343,
-0.00963734,
0.0177154709,
-0.0202921275,
-0.0113741364,
0.0342883281,
0.0051792925,
-0.004847547,
-0.0051463726,
0.006911851,
-0.0171608217,
0.0443641357,
-0.0016638145,
0.0210813601,
-0.0167116076,
-0.023259839,
-0.0172972716,
0.0180936735,
-0.0054371445,
0.0415435657,
-0.0388523676,
-0.0723999292,
0.004877896,
-0.0279520918,
-0.0399938934,
-0.0125472816,
-0.0315202251,
-0.0772932097,
0.027965283,
0.0185746029,
0.016793225,
0.0635709167,
0.0097824056,
-0.0689196065,
0.0668680817,
-0.0187679287,
-0.0306347385,
0.0177863836,
0.0682981014,
-0.0165523365,
-0.0185279697,
0.013848207,
-0.0357195623,
0.0249219723,
0.0472182818,
-0.000019932,
-0.0400319546,
0.0112218428,
-0.0191966109,
-0.0338717028,
0.0708139688,
-0.014960546,
-0.0219863765,
-0.0441117324,
0.0198358577,
0.0061075948,
0.0146274352,
-0.0273911934,
-0.0422845706,
0.0037576344,
-0.0029767251,
-0.0327550173,
0.0053920192,
-0.0382824056,
-0.0415664352,
-0.0135058304,
0.1112367436,
0.0390407331,
0.0137196006,
-0.0121376514,
0.0251382422,
0.0060329693,
0.0217403565,
0.0122374939,
0.0396692455,
0.0193172265,
0.0194576848,
0.0055318992,
0.0192549601,
0.0051375683,
-0.0141240396,
-0.0441803932,
-0.0472207926,
-0.021146724,
-0.0743514076,
0.008535088,
0.0024063326,
-0.0085968301,
0.0027102949,
0.0205093697,
-0.0192459896,
0.0081585124,
-0.0618778169,
0.0236111414,
0.0164559502,
0.0071647163,
0.0101137394,
0.0147574684,
0.0598802865,
0.0027007076,
0.0489628688,
-0.057608515,
0.0223877728,
-0.0313866958,
-0.0115694888,
0.0449240133,
0.0011922057,
-0.024803739,
-0.017234927,
-0.074109152,
-0.0627392754,
0.0108829634,
0.0200928282,
0.0519162752,
0.0040721395,
0.0380849391,
0.0099032447,
-0.0474370122,
-0.0458409414,
0.0085047008,
-0.0450217575,
-0.0200477969,
0.0046091098,
0.0039933827,
-6.565187377e-33,
-0.0649984926,
0.0028692924,
0.002512845,
-0.0273134373,
-0.0044118431,
0.0300708096,
-0.0264785327,
0.0199275259,
-0.0184786152,
-0.0132799568,
0.0051038866,
0.0409969315,
0.0239779092,
0.0129007576,
-0.0260487013,
-0.0186220519,
0.1085141674,
0.0046839206,
-0.0139981387,
0.0017357392,
0.000701308,
0.0673399195,
0.0623188354,
-0.03141018,
-0.0066698706,
0.0203233846,
0.0157140121,
0.033754129,
0.0051922016,
0.0664483756,
-0.0175118875,
0.0575808063,
0.0219456162,
-0.0556301288,
-0.05644802,
0.0271837357,
-0.0648887008,
-0.0006829958,
0.0176761094,
0.0417810716,
0.0146106826,
0.0080607878,
0.027687218,
0.0404446013,
-0.0118704159,
-0.0738244429,
0.0427908823,
-0.0150929857,
0.0044044051,
0.0413122997,
-0.0314465724,
0.0434184074,
-0.0261782371,
-0.0136237815,
0.025179429,
0.0254135542,
-0.0057588657,
0.0024996088,
-0.0376598425,
0.0133843981,
0.0165630225,
0.008583012,
0.0505384952,
0.0782895684,
-0.016524734,
0.0352185704,
0.0686525851,
0.0190947093,
0.0522623993,
-0.0821933076,
0.051690504,
0.0039793747,
0.0159939677,
0.0548023172,
0.053621795,
0.0154984649,
-0.0243030842,
0.0110918405,
-0.0267728958,
0.0165553782,
0.0092153503,
0.0485209823,
-0.0564656034,
-0.0309858583,
-0.0235037208,
-0.0939207748,
-0.0297168884,
-0.0061796932,
0.0071700127,
-0.0082932487,
-0.0223495346,
-0.0197635163,
0.0788160637,
-0.0143126259,
0.0150762834,
0.03578154,
0.0090545621,
-0.0055780602,
-0.0160048977,
-0.0077968254,
-0.0782895386,
-0.0376976579,
0.0096056508,
0.067626819,
0.0113406871,
-0.018869618,
0.0267814528,
0.0191120114,
-0.0493261963,
0.0000637668,
-0.0035291845,
0.0093864668,
0.000160909,
0.0151189286,
0.0571538694,
0.0081996061,
-0.0016300819,
0.0546325222,
-0.021501841,
-0.0479926988,
-0.0216012653,
0.0335597657,
-0.0296962522,
0.061975684,
-0.0236188211,
-0.0086660571,
0.0169062782,
-0.0139478818,
0.0512545966,
-0.022240065,
-0.04160586,
-0.0223949607,
2.54e-7,
0.013389891,
-0.0066456413,
0.0175094325,
-0.0123824636,
0.0070453198,
0.0438153706,
-0.0015052563,
-0.0124568306,
0.0108664175,
0.0482540876,
0.0078333635,
0.0252923556,
0.0500702001,
0.0378761627,
-0.0394896381,
0.0464126542,
-0.063917391,
0.0512084626,
0.0014026656,
0.0066373004,
0.0289524868,
0.0572633632,
0.0006570262,
-0.0463981256,
-0.0053079836,
0.0323412679,
0.029861195,
-0.0009144839,
-0.0027958278,
-0.0155970994,
0.0030008752,
0.0545658097,
0.0179102682,
0.049587179,
-0.0311765037,
0.0412113033,
-0.0368098095,
-0.0070938645,
-0.008466173,
-0.0611440539,
0.0017763054,
0.0648078769,
-0.0304242466,
-0.0240684487,
0.0190301109,
-0.0321952812,
-0.0428847335,
-0.0438380092,
-0.0450147875,
-0.0015148167,
0.0189355407,
-0.003312699,
-0.0278065465,
-0.0107514495,
0.0069563775,
-0.0102662267,
-0.0464528687,
-0.0572747923,
0.0287733879,
0.0442832038,
-0.0568797626,
-0.0465444699,
0.0240619183,
0.0150716528,
0.0059362352,
0.0152807692,
0.016068574,
1.773325752e-34,
0.0172803104,
-0.0083252694,
0.0186690371,
0.0418724045,
-0.0242097415,
-0.0284379814,
-0.0110870758,
-0.0373998471,
0.07406535,
-0.0063725803,
-0.0310391467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14683v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14683v1 | TAGLAS: An atlas of text-attributed graph datasets in the era of large graph and language models | 2024-06-20T19:11:35 | 2024-06-20T19:11:35 | Jiarui Feng, Hao Liu, Lecheng Kong, Yixin Chen, Muhan Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In this report, we present TAGLAS, an atlas of text-attributed graph (TAG)
datasets and benchmarks. TAGs are graphs with node and edge features
represented in text, which have recently gained wide applicability in training
graph-language or graph foundation models. In TAGLAS, we collect and integrate
more than 23 TAG datasets with domains ranging from citation graphs to molecule
graphs and tasks from node classification to graph question-answering. Unlike
previous graph datasets and benchmarks, all datasets in TAGLAS have a unified
node and edge text feature format, which allows a graph model to be
simultaneously trained and evaluated on multiple datasets from various domains.
Further, we provide a standardized, efficient, and simplified way to load all
datasets and tasks. We also provide useful utils like text-to-embedding
conversion, and graph-to-text conversion, which can facilitate different
evaluation scenarios. Finally, we also provide standard and easy-to-use
evaluation utils. The project is open-sourced at
https://github.com/JiaruiFeng/TAGLAS and is still under construction. Please
expect more datasets/features in the future. | [
0.0314750858,
0.0101723792,
0.0273707826,
0.0374142192,
-0.0075841937,
0.0126850586,
0.0037723929,
-0.0025382184,
0.0942534432,
-0.0426998921,
-0.0330844447,
0.0182646494,
-0.0094398567,
0.0496848561,
0.0352808498,
0.0026654645,
0.0126875723,
0.0310355201,
0.0396504998,
-0.0045282785,
0.0187808145,
0.0396967605,
0.0420799255,
0.0098806815,
0.0010521093,
-0.0365945175,
0.0131675238,
0.0331817903,
0.0234337375,
-0.0377544723,
0.0057424591,
0.030354131,
0.033460401,
0.0382443592,
0.000001485,
-0.0024144407,
-0.0040159998,
0.0114271576,
-0.0229788665,
-0.0126752555,
0.0595671944,
-0.0100987861,
0.0565908924,
0.0092827287,
-0.0462923311,
-0.0587217286,
0.059850134,
0.0204212815,
0.0390993133,
0.064708896,
-0.0157605354,
-0.0402853526,
0.0018546418,
-0.0323501416,
-0.0117788399,
-0.0302499775,
0.0373304151,
0.0232824683,
-0.0024298714,
0.0534458272,
-0.0394866094,
0.0223763157,
0.0077333273,
-0.0248166863,
0.0683756918,
0.024960665,
-0.0143513661,
0.0344842598,
0.0062552965,
0.1459809393,
0.0130172716,
-0.047469005,
0.0221039988,
-0.0041356147,
-0.0157101899,
-0.004997293,
-0.042902723,
-0.0405012667,
0.024771655,
0.026851194,
0.0060486104,
-0.0131462114,
0.0810637027,
-0.0059420657,
0.0234928168,
0.0624031238,
-0.0143233454,
-0.0067938222,
0.0399966538,
0.0119748134,
-0.0310219526,
-0.0317018591,
-0.0056617996,
0.023703279,
0.0124906544,
0.0242322888,
-0.0338313282,
-0.0314924233,
0.0122284144,
0.0088464655,
0.0223805383,
-0.0400016271,
0.0105422419,
0.0677319169,
-0.0005507765,
0.0169227775,
-0.014379221,
0.0533727445,
-0.0304316562,
-0.024691714,
-0.064926371,
0.0129091023,
-0.0438219458,
0.008849429,
0.0041579846,
-0.0429676734,
-0.0252634399,
0.019113617,
-0.0307830628,
0.0088316286,
0.0323765464,
0.0324786939,
0.010694555,
-0.0048958897,
0.0253230911,
0.0340930298,
-0.0030499538,
0.0236341022,
-0.0015645601,
-0.0124369059,
-0.015238028,
0.0176293235,
0.0569651537,
-0.0628236979,
0.0293321107,
0.0435836129,
0.0506590046,
-0.0447877198,
0.0327323005,
-0.0169307664,
0.0110089816,
-0.0720369518,
0.039458558,
-0.0903178304,
0.0574338734,
0.0338578932,
-0.0005848822,
-0.0666652843,
0.0249542035,
0.0055820099,
-0.0560812205,
0.0571786091,
-0.0357560292,
-0.0187783372,
0.0037865483,
-0.017925052,
-0.000426007,
0.0347959325,
0.0336266793,
0.0146933366,
0.0484763049,
0.0056506954,
-0.0467166416,
0.0102813672,
0.0747864768,
0.0465534553,
0.0417048186,
0.0226249006,
-0.0238090716,
0.0197732057,
-0.0094632087,
0.052302666,
-0.0167003255,
-0.0546513833,
0.0257076472,
0.0364945568,
-0.0280295964,
-0.0322005749,
0.0178697407,
0.0331874453,
0.0199226569,
-0.0231960658,
-0.0328165293,
0.005910499,
0.0239656977,
0.0241738837,
0.0118842181,
-0.016846519,
-0.0338116847,
0.015163973,
-0.0094481641,
-0.0153375026,
0.0636923909,
-0.0168910529,
0.0630028695,
-0.0013664846,
-0.0422582589,
0.0109818643,
0.0186727215,
-0.0240596253,
0.004047208,
0.0089716977,
-0.0002027889,
0.0192308594,
0.0470692031,
-0.0151962871,
-0.0328619257,
-0.0113779148,
0.0307722874,
-0.0207284801,
0.0316803567,
-0.0539001934,
0.0128069678,
-0.0301604439,
-0.0472019874,
-0.0496214889,
-0.0126079712,
0.0018439398,
0.0259363931,
0.0020408761,
0.0029826763,
-0.1201416776,
-0.0459512807,
0.0100307176,
0.0073189619,
0.0036503305,
-0.0178748742,
-0.0245181695,
-0.0115848146,
0.0364089049,
-0.0071149464,
0.0225146897,
0.0409803651,
0.0144554125,
-0.0126771014,
-0.0098715005,
-0.0064442893,
-0.037063092,
0.0668348819,
-0.0412807204,
-0.0463623591,
0.0483640768,
-0.0867565498,
-0.0422528125,
0.0390825644,
-0.0538366437,
-0.0086354949,
0.0088174883,
-0.0178458653,
-0.0072908076,
0.0107603604,
0.0101111615,
0.043637827,
0.0038394702,
0.034979187,
0.0030064865,
0.0285013244,
0.0178472735,
-0.0382205807,
-0.0123616075,
-0.0005631859,
0.0101600541,
-0.0082757296,
0.029969817,
-0.0050497856,
-0.0523809269,
0.0648315698,
-0.0984501615,
0.0132771889,
-0.0144990496,
0.0256143678,
0.0045304685,
0.0110313352,
0.0344622955,
-0.0181950554,
-0.0594714433,
0.0170570631,
0.000906641,
0.0085823014,
0.0300966799,
-0.0182445198,
0.0212700386,
-0.0373704471,
-0.0605547652,
-0.0258310866,
0.0902288035,
0.012845695,
-0.0420638286,
0.0172763951,
0.0070276805,
-0.0269460529,
0.0233529638,
-0.0144774253,
0.0110052843,
-0.0199358407,
0.0098508261,
0.0281122122,
0.0480732657,
-0.0381617285,
0.0243917461,
0.0195062719,
0.0276764724,
-0.0482731871,
-0.0289532915,
-0.044690486,
0.0342675485,
-0.0385370813,
-0.0204284023,
-0.0156619735,
0.037317235,
-0.0076423739,
-0.0250267759,
-0.0188404601,
-0.0035677839,
-0.0218752958,
0.0034136607,
-0.0218277853,
0.008341413,
0.0266246554,
-0.0278795417,
-0.0431058556,
-0.0361326151,
0.0816221833,
-0.0208844636,
-0.0217653606,
0.0106290225,
-0.023784956,
-0.0565744601,
0.0776860192,
0.0442563109,
-0.0009232633,
0.0115221813,
0.016382087,
-0.018212907,
0.0030194207,
0.0262056813,
-0.0348909236,
-0.0137928538,
0.0135487849,
0.0374724232,
-0.0143284723,
-0.0250643436,
0.01725851,
0.0054323208,
-0.0424695462,
0.0485820994,
-0.0019555399,
-0.040658541,
0.0049379123,
-0.0112622753,
-0.0108006466,
0.0194394197,
-0.0241855625,
0.0258153044,
-0.028500041,
0.0772631541,
0.0891905054,
-0.0527746193,
0.0108861309,
-0.0030045311,
-0.0087798266,
0.0492144674,
0.0423470363,
-0.0175579377,
-0.0469500683,
-0.0024072393,
-0.0026300366,
-0.0145684639,
0.0002714138,
-0.0477511808,
0.049584832,
-0.0237412155,
-0.0036243186,
0.0552388653,
0.0222521219,
-0.039955169,
-0.0015243368,
0.0040151575,
0.0243596099,
0.0190444365,
0.0060080108,
-0.1080154628,
-0.0336200185,
-0.025457643,
0.0183653198,
0.0350937098,
-0.035567265,
-0.0092958314,
-0.0945279598,
0.0130675705,
0.0167174358,
0.0061102575,
-0.0479441062,
-0.0693041012,
-0.019013213,
-0.0388474464,
-0.0339548215,
-0.0223702732,
-0.01637863,
0.0081796916,
0.0330270343,
0.0049701924,
-0.0253493022,
0.0398671031,
-0.023640452,
0.0155334137,
-0.0116177248,
0.0333596356,
0.0287992228,
0.0029188138,
0.0302845966,
-0.0199263766,
-0.0664659813,
-0.0104076564,
0.0674955919,
-0.0117976321,
0.0050117709,
-0.0242401436,
0.0417775959,
-0.0429004095,
-0.0135233924,
-0.0242960118,
0.1177130416,
0.006307608,
-0.0436521359,
-0.0144156311,
-0.0256492589,
0.0060496563,
0.0342747979,
0.0371355303,
0.027742425,
-0.0880233571,
-0.0162520502,
0.0090137906,
-0.0791963562,
-0.0328940302,
0.0076487954,
-0.05140315,
0.0250247326,
-0.0484372899,
-0.0648310781,
0.0423041992,
-0.0173101779,
-0.018561855,
0.0079887202,
-0.0001349029,
-0.0425557271,
-0.1053665057,
0.0282205883,
-0.0491154566,
0.0488577485,
0.0153530929,
-0.022108214,
0.0454729684,
0.0306209009,
-0.0193703305,
0.0516093895,
-0.0779913366,
-0.071168974,
-0.0364779644,
0.0175809264,
0.0148870749,
0.0536952913,
-0.0435077026,
-0.035013061,
0.024710713,
0.0026678294,
-0.0215921942,
-0.0099328924,
0.0211996697,
-0.0470704064,
-0.0186464917,
0.0370014459,
-0.0587358102,
-0.0055571399,
0.017141385,
0.0381418169,
-0.0292634405,
-0.0444707163,
-0.0119300699,
0.0298770089,
0.0357711203,
0.0197949503,
0.0346274413,
-0.0571594723,
-0.0094340276,
-0.004650461,
-0.0347485691,
-0.022195518,
-0.0014761846,
0.0280479286,
-0.0105952285,
-0.0134031922,
-0.0225209445,
0.0007889472,
0.076716274,
-0.0317181982,
-0.005405732,
0.003768174,
-0.017064685,
0.0222309083,
-0.0165198948,
-0.0264526885,
-0.0019015259,
-0.0060849828,
0.0128351739,
0.0019718697,
-0.0144110043,
0.0303514004,
-0.0217831675,
-0.0152711794,
0.0208051875,
-0.0624468885,
0.0307551529,
-0.0461117439,
-0.0169310179,
0.0411480777,
0.01975164,
0.0775002092,
-0.0174933784,
-0.0304828677,
-0.036329627,
0.0479602739,
-0.0177571345,
-0.042067755,
0.0667603463,
0.0212621838,
-0.0212187264,
0.0296589807,
0.0647855848,
0.1087605059,
0.0436907373,
0.0323691741,
-0.0497462749,
-0.0041910578,
-0.0351926349,
-0.0289355181,
0.0139174471,
-0.0032996053,
0.0018944058,
-0.0390646905,
-0.0965963751,
0.0371920243,
-0.0159491394,
0.0027311684,
0.0379733518,
0.0164639764,
-0.005532864,
0.0300739631,
-0.0164018273,
-0.0696471483,
0.0567169748,
-0.0374729671,
-0.0341879651,
-0.0110631576,
-5.561773277e-33,
0.0001750729,
-0.0519167073,
0.0066202185,
0.0082010552,
-0.0487240963,
0.0238272492,
-0.0591195486,
-0.0186859649,
-0.0313927718,
0.0404138044,
-0.0077210455,
0.0268133581,
-0.0003786502,
0.0411969647,
-0.0384008251,
-0.0266373586,
-0.0029515938,
-0.0028058123,
0.008364059,
0.0579871051,
0.0475994684,
0.0187945031,
0.0821332633,
-0.0836519748,
0.0280920472,
-0.045296371,
0.0249521304,
-0.0000599243,
0.0372971371,
0.046589449,
-0.0218924023,
0.041791968,
0.0223694313,
-0.0370107964,
0.0058145346,
0.0095165865,
-0.0990087688,
-0.0213403068,
0.0078456188,
0.006224934,
-0.0618804358,
-0.0363900997,
-0.0152364578,
-0.009355709,
0.0341987386,
-0.0611506514,
0.0528226495,
0.0129812146,
-0.0313919298,
-0.0074003432,
-0.0276804939,
0.039845489,
-0.0125811798,
0.0315399505,
0.0082263276,
0.0279762559,
0.0195698272,
0.0335937254,
-0.0639344826,
0.0244602393,
-0.0646927506,
-0.0070974794,
0.0129609881,
0.0039666672,
0.0232299659,
0.0292188451,
-0.0206210408,
-0.0095419306,
-0.0163564943,
0.0286547206,
-0.0128639331,
0.0735872909,
0.0390814506,
0.0235448591,
-0.0478565432,
0.0264729038,
-0.0740281641,
0.0135603277,
0.0024040276,
0.0295591149,
-0.0319464579,
0.0238401927,
0.0274951831,
-0.0322307423,
-0.0285043661,
-0.0306324717,
-0.02277321,
-0.0351223797,
-0.0039064926,
-0.0320966095,
-0.0335446931,
0.0726147667,
0.0160101894,
-0.0824503079,
-0.0290898476,
0.1144280285,
0.0022867057,
0.0636282042,
0.0097323377,
0.0248695444,
-0.0630735606,
-0.0266268253,
0.0386753716,
-0.0064375512,
0.0238369182,
-0.0001302587,
0.0629485101,
0.0054698307,
-0.0097556999,
-0.0072277086,
-0.0486034155,
-0.0235997289,
-0.0520919971,
0.011434448,
0.0036954777,
0.0647226498,
-0.0110080708,
0.0431099683,
0.0626547635,
0.044946719,
-0.0044848016,
0.0216992889,
0.0015182659,
0.0213829614,
-0.0116315363,
-0.0177845638,
-0.0560064167,
0.0393400341,
-0.0158514455,
-0.0388142392,
-0.0064149713,
-0.0018774638,
2.231e-7,
0.071846135,
0.00740855,
0.0704747736,
0.0297498517,
0.0127992025,
0.0378387123,
-0.009752715,
0.0707019269,
-0.0111603225,
-0.0004923214,
0.0227440484,
0.0284104124,
-0.0014957086,
0.0034702711,
-0.0596662238,
0.0415800251,
-0.0928171873,
-0.0357091799,
-0.0200607534,
0.0087091075,
-0.0142521793,
0.0619492754,
0.038168557,
-0.0050726524,
-0.0299671479,
-0.0290129501,
0.081441693,
-0.0167910811,
-0.0040185447,
0.0150230899,
-0.0108854119,
-0.0106065199,
-0.0238783751,
-0.0078237401,
-0.0272816457,
0.0105263498,
0.0411669053,
0.0453632213,
-0.0132995201,
-0.0014515555,
-0.012433596,
-0.0507992841,
0.0193516742,
-0.0364983827,
0.0642247498,
-0.027827017,
-0.0553204529,
-0.0377893932,
-0.0436751992,
0.0149578862,
0.002479942,
0.0029320542,
0.0031209332,
0.0221350044,
0.0018406855,
-0.02290277,
-0.011824199,
-0.0630327761,
-0.0165707432,
0.0289056953,
-0.0043516504,
-0.0377973877,
-0.0053613433,
0.056960661,
0.0118848206,
-0.054028675,
0.0045922329,
1.857060784e-34,
0.0186711233,
0.003220439,
-0.021405695,
-0.0019823981,
0.0112268357,
-0.0598576143,
-0.0247107074,
0.0118216434,
0.0226233266,
-0.0891058072,
0.008694022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14680v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14680v1 | Dravidian language family through Universal Dependencies lens | 2024-06-20T18:59:46 | 2024-06-20T18:59:46 | Taraka Rama, Sowmya Vajjala | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Universal Dependencies (UD) project aims to create a cross-linguistically
consistent dependency annotation for multiple languages, to facilitate
multilingual NLP. It currently supports 114 languages. Dravidian languages are
spoken by over 200 million people across the word, and yet there are only two
languages from this family in UD. This paper examines some of the morphological
and syntactic features of Dravidian languages and explores how they can be
annotated in the UD framework. | [
0.0523683131,
-0.0075090965,
-0.0452462621,
0.0320285074,
-0.0046287952,
0.0056347647,
-0.0357786044,
-0.0193801075,
0.004661981,
-0.023764465,
0.0224467162,
-0.0335877165,
0.0110565871,
-0.0152358599,
0.0216543414,
-0.0802348852,
0.0236322973,
-0.0015811193,
-0.0236671939,
0.0228895787,
0.0296469126,
0.0348882377,
-0.0324345343,
0.006365296,
-0.0917051509,
-0.0155456383,
0.0123936329,
-0.0190357231,
0.0234557595,
-0.0549262054,
-0.0129063753,
0.0417270213,
-0.00835054,
0.0223108735,
0.0000018261,
-0.0550738126,
-0.0123048238,
-0.0062615681,
-0.0022211161,
0.0000284052,
0.0372691564,
-0.0445124172,
0.0190128516,
-0.0315619782,
-0.0064773764,
0.0117060971,
0.0969673917,
-0.0239572637,
0.0205249861,
0.0345735624,
-0.0276453532,
-0.0354877375,
0.0156712793,
-0.0162210763,
-0.059064202,
0.0333176889,
-0.0071308361,
0.1040821373,
0.0347194225,
-0.0408913344,
-0.0115045607,
0.0147734759,
-0.0019907784,
-0.0024811155,
0.0032124326,
-0.0182066504,
-0.0576278381,
-0.047549542,
0.0606844313,
0.0177538693,
0.0087416312,
-0.0507757366,
0.0020716144,
0.0011881557,
-0.0501755588,
0.0142355505,
-0.0459647737,
0.0031232531,
-0.0404507481,
0.0626817867,
0.0771928877,
0.0196673404,
0.0108355377,
-0.0261426754,
0.0080069993,
0.0795311183,
0.0281903613,
-0.0094114328,
-0.0375878401,
0.0223289318,
-0.0149569949,
-0.0383588076,
0.0189135931,
-0.0222141575,
-0.0119440965,
0.0230603963,
-0.0018780875,
-0.0708034337,
0.044666253,
-0.0408100039,
-0.0056388872,
-0.0257596746,
-0.0687956735,
-0.0045652273,
0.0006764552,
0.0110233622,
0.0110416068,
-0.05520311,
0.0256569348,
0.0162934549,
0.0273294244,
-0.0244617965,
-0.0152450781,
-0.0156531595,
-0.0283146668,
0.0437725037,
-0.0272971019,
0.0222730171,
0.0179866701,
-0.0090786656,
0.0023007859,
-0.0611803867,
-0.037131872,
-0.0103769023,
-0.0187175553,
0.0005516718,
-0.0345580466,
-0.0170165915,
-0.0274980403,
-0.0870932117,
0.0484205559,
0.0556040108,
-0.038151931,
-0.0253862143,
-0.039532464,
0.0709098428,
0.0318290442,
-0.03041403,
-0.0275571626,
0.0001224888,
-0.0289604124,
-0.0420885719,
-0.0315639935,
-0.0720946193,
-0.0094659319,
0.0595505573,
0.0196021013,
-0.0254490674,
0.0254393984,
-0.0091473246,
0.0361492671,
0.0495170951,
-0.0119396327,
-0.010459126,
-0.0012326429,
-0.0079714982,
0.0478952155,
0.0420225076,
0.0037222209,
-0.0208032597,
0.0516992584,
-0.0095471842,
0.0150509551,
0.0011547165,
-0.0300424043,
-0.0104629463,
-0.0197395273,
0.0192561205,
0.010879091,
-0.0018045427,
-0.0138883479,
0.0279513467,
-0.0033860847,
0.0102817668,
-0.0220917333,
0.0285076462,
-0.0011459549,
0.0189600717,
0.0171042066,
0.0389811583,
-0.0281278435,
0.0419134684,
0.0000983265,
0.0068827984,
0.0400273837,
-0.0165491458,
-0.0458932556,
0.0073224045,
0.0515375361,
-0.0038001931,
-0.0517329127,
-0.0290052276,
-0.0302373283,
-0.0313258842,
0.0336565077,
0.0094160968,
0.0095336596,
0.0478194728,
0.0917425826,
-0.045702599,
0.0208143387,
0.0153438766,
0.066932328,
0.001906037,
-0.011112974,
-0.030175861,
-0.0308441147,
0.0237546302,
-0.0243273266,
0.0797949955,
-0.0253758281,
-0.0207997691,
0.0086303046,
-0.0375396535,
0.0185408946,
0.0216720197,
0.0017472035,
0.0596604981,
-0.0642830655,
0.011841258,
-0.006958893,
0.0182621572,
-0.0319224559,
0.0199289303,
0.0036751172,
0.0085181724,
0.0021359678,
0.002005067,
0.0316699259,
0.0319824181,
-0.0521448404,
0.0225353446,
0.0073707527,
-0.0416084416,
0.0063935397,
0.0329800881,
0.0075328653,
0.0217962135,
-0.0048674261,
-0.0718833804,
0.0197984595,
-0.0235485155,
0.0578623042,
-0.0538281426,
0.0333768576,
0.0057739927,
0.0461517796,
-0.0143002328,
0.0393086299,
0.0053981734,
0.0388489775,
-0.033347588,
0.0481386408,
0.0194406286,
0.008670521,
-0.0102866031,
-0.0132768899,
0.0799116567,
-0.0337316282,
-0.0066905208,
0.0239331257,
-0.0034292133,
-0.0299197584,
0.0074952999,
-0.0098036407,
-0.0315687768,
-0.022878224,
-0.0604935214,
-0.0317523554,
-0.02640507,
0.0636998191,
-0.0162738245,
0.045716159,
-0.0115418648,
-0.0249680709,
0.0050573098,
-0.0101664914,
0.0216805357,
-0.0107363919,
0.0204050522,
-0.0027279239,
-0.0018955093,
-0.0011485453,
-0.0010470819,
0.0228144769,
0.0142538575,
-0.0041581821,
-0.0643903464,
-0.0408629291,
-0.0338330232,
-0.022168342,
0.0238060318,
0.0192719139,
-0.0282750744,
0.0208244231,
0.0503348969,
0.047769051,
-0.0285664499,
-0.0831656829,
-0.0112086041,
0.0392271839,
-0.0471258834,
-0.0115871951,
-0.0129088294,
0.0134847155,
0.0640543699,
-0.0029207147,
0.0131228874,
-0.0150287692,
0.0525389351,
-0.0183011219,
-0.0248384997,
-0.0014359946,
-0.0424111523,
-0.0767500624,
0.0143797016,
0.0540313758,
0.0148853147,
-0.0329846367,
0.0826965645,
0.0085858041,
-0.061332427,
0.0678696558,
-0.035083212,
-0.014360521,
-0.0409610979,
-0.0064297086,
-0.0460540764,
0.036268793,
0.0126329903,
-0.0289296433,
0.0286275465,
-0.0384331085,
0.0016291161,
0.0530386381,
0.0229849145,
0.0453144684,
0.0174534488,
-0.0671130195,
0.0244265553,
-0.0315902308,
-0.0238460507,
-0.0033245669,
0.0281849392,
-0.0226222016,
0.0060724127,
0.0267111454,
-0.0386028625,
0.0390180759,
0.0548691601,
-0.025658261,
-0.0266392976,
-0.0091442894,
0.0376599729,
-0.0054943939,
0.0301727876,
0.0220075957,
-0.0177420843,
-0.040436428,
0.079267405,
0.0107194576,
-0.0325207487,
-0.0407364704,
-0.0049167676,
0.0274119433,
0.0007249852,
0.0418987498,
-0.0047782878,
-0.0759837776,
-0.035467837,
0.0247752126,
0.0266053323,
0.0267270152,
0.0373483449,
0.024532821,
-0.0092091402,
0.0374457724,
-0.0565717258,
0.0132715069,
0.0407510959,
-0.0056942464,
-0.1310078353,
0.0064826398,
0.0039168131,
-0.0620522797,
0.0087246038,
-0.0109348744,
0.0113866851,
-0.0211594924,
-0.0194049198,
-0.0088605601,
-0.0188532863,
0.0118411593,
-0.0068390965,
-0.0440075248,
-0.0465827473,
-0.0001953888,
0.0246150922,
-0.0055084154,
-0.0020832259,
0.0411214568,
-0.0488876812,
-0.0333836712,
-0.0339545757,
-0.0165021997,
-0.0387546569,
0.0588353276,
0.0225925408,
-0.037160404,
-0.0001983064,
-0.0030588659,
-0.0318171717,
-0.0102030979,
0.0125230243,
0.0164196584,
0.0142570557,
-0.04516159,
-0.0477129854,
0.0220640935,
-0.0393124595,
-0.0217815265,
-0.012630783,
0.0878077596,
0.0051046791,
0.0158872828,
0.0038354611,
-0.0381752513,
0.0102494676,
-0.0324970931,
0.0036776613,
-0.0070421873,
-0.0003858556,
-0.0183165595,
-0.001952253,
-0.0052893027,
-0.0419255346,
0.0115397098,
-0.042360656,
-0.0770700201,
-0.0688139424,
-0.0843934193,
0.0622532256,
0.0065338421,
0.0257492438,
0.0458354205,
0.025295794,
0.0040771645,
-0.0006302863,
0.0033007287,
0.0246423855,
0.0380016603,
-0.0386124402,
-0.0437820666,
0.0338573717,
0.0458586812,
0.0013398896,
0.0256243404,
-0.0267835017,
-0.0599000454,
0.0203009658,
0.0131030902,
0.0230942667,
-0.0332901627,
-0.0300701428,
-0.0826246589,
-0.0607280098,
-0.0151291871,
0.0153932245,
-0.0175152514,
0.0014086706,
0.0104996786,
0.0194371194,
0.0535526238,
0.0075105093,
0.0077025532,
-0.0442801118,
-0.0209091436,
-0.0394671336,
-0.015468182,
0.0488238297,
0.0185897276,
0.0311832111,
-0.0886661857,
-0.0180944595,
-0.0394820757,
0.0048890091,
-0.0457052737,
-0.0167193711,
-0.024092583,
0.0515842885,
0.0114688091,
0.0061087417,
-0.0287528634,
-0.0049245544,
-0.016990561,
0.004078642,
0.0413587764,
0.0938465372,
0.102410987,
0.0671687573,
0.0119118504,
0.0239249952,
-0.0143990433,
-0.0207750462,
-0.0444651954,
0.0361918099,
-0.0221980251,
0.0180819761,
-0.0254502539,
-0.0106806075,
0.0702389628,
-0.0235627871,
0.1053193733,
0.0019571728,
0.033933267,
-0.0085582202,
0.0874714181,
-0.0187705718,
0.0688144267,
-0.0527144335,
0.0154485293,
0.0005175657,
0.0465048403,
-0.0036193007,
-0.0093596261,
0.0165303312,
-0.0005641253,
-0.0333452746,
0.0157452673,
0.0782273784,
-0.03122852,
-0.0067653945,
0.0498991273,
-0.0070998999,
-0.0178908035,
-0.0206167493,
-0.0008375007,
0.0194480028,
0.0025942863,
0.0483300723,
-0.0908358023,
-0.0529564582,
-0.0275323223,
0.0135104461,
0.0179645866,
-0.0239713807,
-0.0151537517,
0.000991434,
0.0603917986,
-0.0352654159,
-0.0266424511,
0.0042554759,
-0.0458827354,
0.0229846518,
0.0284240004,
-5.654113868e-33,
-0.0019189584,
0.0070316195,
-0.0259002112,
-0.007772027,
0.0188060869,
-0.0063285776,
0.0129412906,
0.0261501186,
-0.020688599,
0.0117095513,
-0.0085468823,
0.0102909412,
0.0230217557,
0.0019159574,
0.0818285495,
0.0252045393,
-0.0157611649,
0.0027945677,
0.0106983939,
0.0018660879,
0.0850499123,
-0.011336212,
0.1384474188,
-0.0448030569,
0.0779387131,
-0.07395643,
0.0003563063,
0.0355624706,
-0.0320834965,
0.0138246715,
-0.0671273395,
0.0161195714,
0.0324947983,
0.0443514474,
-0.0112481276,
-0.0208708178,
-0.0288433209,
-0.0227492638,
0.0338252969,
0.0666096285,
-0.0318814442,
-0.0245391075,
0.0072626667,
-0.01355696,
-0.0092889294,
0.0757790431,
-0.0152642429,
-0.0251828134,
-0.0085295523,
0.0045339349,
-0.0747861341,
0.0784338415,
-0.0004912716,
0.0058092857,
0.0364446156,
0.0392964967,
0.003301227,
-0.0412401631,
-0.0156638827,
-0.0122404583,
-0.0227631591,
0.0810783654,
0.074863255,
-0.018632615,
-0.0590369441,
0.0224631373,
0.0242288187,
-0.0654004738,
0.0863908604,
0.0392047502,
-0.029372355,
0.0600094497,
-0.0063021979,
0.0306873787,
0.0515670367,
-0.0260495469,
-0.0185750425,
-0.0202169046,
0.0577959083,
0.0406230204,
-0.0513331629,
0.0237997882,
-0.0401742272,
-0.0125407232,
0.0330581367,
-0.0464580841,
0.0063355393,
-0.0627521425,
-0.004552382,
-0.0517615266,
0.0063905804,
0.0897279233,
-0.0117765386,
0.0031764032,
-0.0347368233,
-0.0092968242,
-0.0144624608,
0.0205146968,
-0.0096429205,
-0.0057281107,
-0.0066950526,
0.0023226207,
-0.0365802869,
0.0107316542,
0.032718569,
-0.0025554327,
0.0551496632,
0.0203905944,
-0.0447735451,
0.0008685407,
-0.0062974757,
0.0172185674,
-0.0172696114,
0.0741174668,
0.0090022832,
0.0071292645,
-0.0083174398,
-0.0062236767,
0.0425020978,
-0.0011855889,
-0.0050558662,
0.0174632613,
0.0019008977,
-0.0127556846,
-0.0253961962,
-0.0087501444,
-0.0512128286,
0.0020459734,
0.0208366551,
0.0143016344,
0.0036514564,
0.0288866591,
2.634e-7,
0.008764632,
0.0490920171,
0.0508433804,
-0.0572220758,
0.011794392,
-0.0222790949,
-0.0565430187,
0.0285758171,
-0.0601983033,
0.0043425066,
-0.0362162478,
-0.0603336133,
0.0470914543,
0.0471399464,
-0.1063859537,
0.0185222961,
-0.0351082385,
-0.0692980513,
-0.0536126457,
-0.0482545272,
0.0062990366,
0.0873783231,
0.0069594565,
0.0013956791,
-0.0142576173,
-0.0002636567,
0.0059288396,
-0.0287142191,
0.0171904434,
0.0221381988,
0.0191131867,
-0.0536451675,
0.0058375131,
0.0094302949,
-0.0135817984,
0.021462759,
0.0067473138,
0.043854475,
-0.0167631041,
0.0633398071,
0.0259649213,
0.0010253359,
-0.0405284464,
-0.0140107255,
0.0260682683,
0.0499349572,
-0.0468896441,
-0.0250462666,
-0.0130536593,
0.0363939516,
0.0099917697,
0.0296691712,
-0.0051916339,
0.0166914929,
-0.0106131108,
-0.0556251295,
-0.0695886463,
-0.0053718402,
-0.056564007,
0.0832313895,
-0.0032127942,
-0.0074051507,
0.0081418157,
-0.0243579559,
0.0145732919,
-0.0158865377,
0.0257831644,
2.063235491e-34,
0.0157041252,
0.0037303169,
0.0273262821,
0.0312665291,
0.0113565372,
-0.0176264253,
-0.0518773124,
0.072388038,
-0.0034469776,
-0.0362114087,
-0.0128810974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14678v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14678v1 | Bidirectional Transformer Representations of (Spanish) Ambiguous Words in Context: A New Lexical Resource and Empirical Analysis | 2024-06-20T18:58:11 | 2024-06-20T18:58:11 | Pamela D. Rivière, Anne L. Beatty-Martínez, Sean Trott | cs.CL | cs.CL | Lexical ambiguity -- where a single wordform takes on distinct,
context-dependent meanings -- serves as a useful tool to compare across
different large language models' (LLMs') ability to form distinct,
contextualized representations of the same stimulus. Few studies have
systematically compared LLMs' contextualized word embeddings for languages
beyond English. Here, we evaluate multiple bidirectional transformers' (BERTs')
semantic representations of Spanish ambiguous nouns in context. We develop a
novel dataset of minimal-pair sentences evoking the same or different sense for
a target ambiguous noun. In a pre-registered study, we collect contextualized
human relatedness judgments for each sentence pair. We find that various
BERT-based LLMs' contextualized semantic representations capture some variance
in human judgments but fall short of the human benchmark, and for Spanish --
unlike English -- model scale is uncorrelated with performance. We also
identify stereotyped trajectories of target noun disambiguation as a proportion
of traversal through a given LLM family's architecture, which we partially
replicate in English. We contribute (1) a dataset of controlled, Spanish
sentence stimuli with human relatedness norms, and (2) to our evolving
understanding of the impact that LLM specification (architectures, training
protocols) exerts on contextualized embeddings. | [
0.0085572246,
0.0387372449,
-0.0390226319,
0.0886937454,
-0.0122911036,
0.0181873962,
-0.0072754072,
-0.0142493732,
-0.0649467185,
-0.0505384132,
-0.0639622584,
-0.034090776,
-0.0183451921,
-0.0487621091,
0.0381965525,
-0.0265275296,
0.0654373839,
0.0097729834,
-0.0547632128,
-0.0349716544,
-0.0147865778,
-0.0077238344,
-0.0017579051,
0.0079579419,
-0.0257850513,
0.0029326137,
0.028029114,
-0.0030821795,
0.0216310024,
-0.0163812079,
0.0012060086,
0.0547562912,
0.0059602987,
0.0701116771,
0.0000017862,
-0.0610749088,
-0.0140271448,
-0.0065065506,
-0.0091645448,
-0.0223448407,
0.0444886312,
-0.0290300548,
0.0000484642,
-0.03094895,
-0.0164432079,
-0.0447029211,
0.0560195632,
0.0135332802,
0.0193700828,
0.0066663777,
-0.007458033,
-0.0863125995,
-0.0249174163,
-0.0517599583,
-0.0110634966,
-0.033012867,
0.0109272627,
-0.0519929081,
-0.0345897228,
0.025390422,
-0.0573882721,
0.0292520188,
0.024664931,
0.050476633,
-0.0169647746,
0.0156552698,
-0.0550840534,
-0.0275750943,
0.0002366948,
0.0560244359,
0.0077873794,
-0.0372117274,
-0.0215410199,
0.0027076281,
-0.0063456343,
0.0383870378,
0.031563323,
0.0429162979,
0.0052988091,
0.0353037529,
0.0335136652,
0.0139358016,
0.0274159666,
0.0326054879,
-0.0463091433,
0.0398173705,
0.0357134007,
-0.054248061,
0.0247212797,
0.032153137,
-0.0572138168,
-0.0188674238,
0.0602881908,
-0.0177562013,
-0.0202776473,
0.0498075522,
-0.0153840063,
-0.0658073425,
0.0466064699,
-0.0839658007,
0.0045621875,
0.0456924401,
-0.0486633927,
0.0221211445,
-0.0256428234,
0.052650746,
-0.0279919449,
0.0332871154,
-0.0689062998,
-0.0457756743,
-0.0212372709,
-0.0052402755,
-0.0444800109,
0.0265248269,
-0.056605503,
0.0298515745,
-0.0387020372,
0.0269347969,
-0.028305022,
-0.0218560062,
0.0096341884,
0.0401551835,
-0.050671868,
0.0228425059,
-0.0241086446,
0.0181631017,
-0.073137939,
0.0173309706,
-0.0222671945,
-0.0372599959,
0.0005549517,
0.0139253382,
-0.0325611532,
-0.0757626742,
0.0017520625,
0.0443891101,
-0.0137854312,
-0.0662543252,
-0.0074798302,
-0.0235862788,
-0.0538961925,
-0.0510756671,
0.0035520718,
-0.0548662208,
0.0301126353,
0.0283621456,
0.0118700201,
-0.0336656533,
-0.011471699,
0.0059533068,
-0.0060628084,
0.122719653,
0.0217133462,
-0.0311951581,
-0.0028467518,
0.0328592882,
-0.0104458081,
0.0729957595,
0.0236121137,
0.0155469542,
0.0359673984,
0.0162257552,
-0.0528357476,
0.0100979805,
0.0133151775,
-0.002470294,
-0.0024325217,
-0.0061953696,
-0.0225192737,
0.0626224726,
0.0585367642,
0.0731380954,
-0.0168438274,
-0.0482189618,
0.0149096567,
0.0566358082,
0.0049540801,
0.0089263385,
0.0807998329,
0.0013291412,
-0.0135020735,
0.0333944783,
-0.0515148714,
-0.0182718728,
0.0033724962,
0.0017905261,
-0.0352219529,
0.0379577503,
-0.034045089,
0.0076870709,
-0.0068349391,
-0.0030111622,
0.0199195333,
-0.0146820871,
0.0513667464,
0.0454030111,
-0.0137246102,
0.0954862013,
0.0369625464,
-0.0523979999,
-0.000481365,
-0.0270207711,
0.0014725777,
0.0212913007,
-0.0050790971,
-0.0056448141,
-0.0364821032,
0.0263701696,
-0.0148649309,
0.0644631237,
0.0146799739,
-0.0049368092,
0.0311802998,
-0.0264153797,
-0.0051010577,
0.0068530012,
0.0173985269,
0.013917258,
0.0121360039,
-0.0090617267,
0.0170581918,
-0.0806649998,
0.0511457399,
0.0554858483,
-0.0439400785,
-0.0081940163,
-0.0196324792,
0.0226843823,
0.0209536571,
0.0166725069,
-0.0088957464,
-0.0140180392,
0.0479533151,
-0.0197825208,
0.0110437712,
0.028903354,
-0.0834020451,
-0.0485272072,
0.0118565978,
-0.0333269015,
-0.0335965231,
0.0132377921,
-0.0246939044,
-0.011345787,
-0.0070648543,
-0.0238503627,
0.0665801167,
-0.0541507527,
0.0399009623,
-0.0176107697,
0.0457837321,
-0.0365280174,
0.0625500157,
-0.0381409973,
0.0506925136,
0.0182583332,
0.0209976658,
0.0223602131,
-0.0107723037,
-0.0547764301,
0.0192549881,
0.0018602257,
-0.0269132834,
-0.004320255,
0.0071849991,
-0.0404851474,
-0.0201879498,
-0.0720081553,
-0.0152353542,
-0.0204632804,
0.0204675961,
0.0414633453,
0.0165237766,
0.0091450121,
0.001093164,
0.0320502818,
-0.016929375,
-0.0234043002,
0.0367420204,
0.0163252372,
-0.019953467,
-0.0140452348,
-0.0189778656,
-0.0095758494,
-0.0230756216,
0.0530114248,
-0.0027095992,
-0.021408977,
-0.0585653149,
0.0559434928,
-0.0282990113,
-0.0123339277,
0.0073562013,
-0.0588613823,
0.0149648283,
0.0657795519,
0.0908851549,
0.0283641834,
-0.0002684946,
0.0582735464,
0.0637061372,
-0.0116728777,
-0.0236588027,
-0.0088491477,
0.0075039747,
-0.0103907678,
-0.0447540209,
-0.0498972833,
-0.0068289265,
0.0802276284,
0.0292975847,
-0.0207179692,
-0.0322585218,
-0.0149736749,
-0.0482897572,
-0.0626337156,
0.0128502948,
0.0168211479,
-0.0495337658,
0.0292249024,
-0.034463983,
-0.0089908764,
0.0797019824,
-0.0196406841,
-0.0043656975,
-0.056776654,
0.0391515642,
-0.0165629834,
0.0354215726,
0.0082362993,
0.0257267468,
-0.0295228902,
-0.0154376468,
-0.0752829388,
-0.0246473681,
0.003978855,
-0.0292564891,
0.0828982517,
-0.0434671044,
-0.0006228612,
-0.0015624411,
-0.0422212109,
-0.0433886871,
-0.0190921035,
-0.0199740883,
0.0227392074,
0.0602302961,
0.0023610825,
0.0039087823,
-0.0196452904,
-0.0001045994,
0.0081317276,
0.0297071058,
-0.0372373685,
-0.0116665782,
0.0481788926,
-0.01611102,
0.021047242,
0.0724289492,
-0.0314765573,
-0.0091827791,
0.0063504661,
0.0029252749,
-0.0215740651,
-0.0431805253,
0.0166154746,
0.0236142762,
-0.0412277319,
-0.0472314619,
-0.0202605128,
0.0532988422,
-0.0151728913,
-0.0288162977,
0.0662311167,
0.037439052,
-0.0427366421,
0.0251725558,
-0.0372293442,
0.0145789683,
0.0242610369,
-0.0093773492,
-0.0842469409,
-0.0408550464,
0.0079564489,
-0.0206572302,
0.0338924378,
-0.0184556842,
-0.0173556395,
-0.0922207534,
-0.004932072,
-0.0319026448,
-0.0473226532,
-0.0082369726,
-0.016985707,
0.0142348502,
-0.033053223,
0.066659458,
0.0052326615,
-0.017948145,
-0.0060595726,
0.0083414027,
0.0276200455,
-0.0274362937,
0.0200042613,
-0.0532261282,
0.0307210218,
0.0380098298,
0.0132013252,
-0.0055119335,
-0.0037725593,
0.0246581156,
-0.0762875155,
-0.0105245626,
-0.0123168938,
0.0032692347,
0.0151159894,
-0.018689502,
-0.0356524251,
-0.0316834077,
-0.0131583121,
-0.0366965123,
-0.0265265945,
0.0734195784,
-0.0054275431,
-0.0091493139,
-0.0163343567,
-0.0214844029,
-0.047166355,
0.0952868909,
0.01635818,
-0.0353970379,
0.0060885455,
0.0318140723,
0.0462388545,
-0.0232272632,
0.0158386491,
0.0074312515,
-0.0641172007,
-0.0224637818,
-0.041678071,
-0.0629717484,
-0.0080088908,
-0.0154381096,
0.0131318942,
0.0156727396,
0.0216966327,
-0.0224356353,
-0.0430908911,
0.0473848917,
-0.0037321607,
0.0306659564,
-0.0309575778,
-0.0277179573,
0.0326504633,
-0.0152778998,
-0.0343226157,
0.0183297656,
-0.082093671,
-0.0305335727,
0.0499629453,
-0.0016549272,
0.0178883318,
0.0316846967,
-0.0288189296,
-0.0276045315,
0.015512675,
0.0501995198,
0.0005994637,
0.0583337508,
0.0318781137,
0.067161344,
-0.005249761,
0.0628725812,
-0.0269696247,
0.023400208,
0.0190613642,
0.0439219289,
-0.0194257386,
-0.0215486977,
0.0117686726,
-0.0220481958,
0.0423077121,
-0.0495887883,
0.0200200584,
-0.0316205658,
-0.012649253,
-0.0132486438,
0.0086969491,
0.0069362749,
-0.0143993143,
0.031072665,
-0.0077235298,
-0.0264727809,
0.025509771,
-0.0051883757,
0.0323816203,
-0.007727359,
0.0054171081,
0.0309519004,
-0.018264316,
-0.0167557895,
0.0678691566,
0.0213354155,
0.0055829976,
-0.031372074,
0.0238905568,
-0.0377320051,
0.0482720621,
0.003927181,
-0.0017494061,
-0.0582926534,
0.0465162992,
-0.0044499333,
0.0349437073,
0.0127343088,
0.0067085642,
0.0504671447,
-0.0307241511,
0.0417240076,
0.0058785374,
-0.0006029811,
0.0074998294,
0.0063397414,
-0.0042909854,
0.0141249103,
0.0675969645,
0.0031692607,
0.0133366147,
-0.0086290995,
0.0699196383,
-0.0569525957,
0.0378118716,
-0.0179267135,
-0.0122946911,
-0.0257629063,
-0.0080221463,
0.0097968187,
-0.0057658465,
-0.0293823984,
-0.0262347218,
-0.0662258193,
-0.07900244,
0.0176965576,
-0.0313172378,
0.0173784588,
-0.013293718,
0.0508339293,
0.0777363852,
0.0090516694,
-0.0362035856,
0.0185629297,
0.0068716179,
0.0225805826,
-0.0133127337,
-0.0610488206,
-6.140600287e-33,
-0.0322192386,
-0.0182317104,
-0.0269328021,
-0.0579264797,
-0.0201279186,
0.0274398383,
-0.0358986557,
-0.008865213,
-0.041614037,
0.0413976721,
0.009356088,
0.0321713984,
0.0275170971,
0.0155276693,
0.0011521204,
-0.0396295227,
0.0481453985,
0.0185548719,
0.00383409,
-0.0259716455,
0.0573035367,
0.0076466012,
0.0860084668,
-0.0535260104,
0.0369926617,
0.0188819319,
0.0099482574,
0.0451609716,
0.0193138979,
0.0661901459,
-0.0332756117,
0.0811871439,
0.0454396233,
0.0051317001,
-0.0271867849,
0.0076450408,
-0.0962641463,
-0.0637124628,
0.0789921358,
0.0290716626,
-0.018666517,
-0.0407806933,
0.072635971,
-0.0311085787,
-0.0413388722,
0.0346826203,
0.0207848996,
-0.0067792083,
-0.0150165604,
0.0059872316,
-0.0636486188,
-0.0074516893,
0.0271025784,
0.0012786509,
0.030580299,
0.0031833935,
-0.0116110733,
0.0131765734,
-0.0416277312,
-0.0127102118,
-0.0486198962,
0.0211104099,
0.0477771424,
0.0419859551,
-0.0001980555,
0.0465412065,
0.0760946572,
-0.0478656217,
0.0167732593,
-0.0426432937,
0.0162419528,
0.0148410108,
0.0393709838,
0.0793477446,
0.042514652,
-0.0158165004,
-0.0020594238,
-0.0345610641,
0.032482177,
-0.0013610496,
0.0484687127,
0.0000465457,
-0.0306839366,
-0.0170879941,
-0.0426620282,
-0.038781967,
-0.032962501,
-0.0142815756,
0.0331666023,
-0.0276757274,
0.0113878762,
0.0101102861,
0.0261893924,
-0.024221018,
-0.0187447947,
0.0033352564,
0.0002096911,
0.0130155254,
0.0420217291,
0.0509990864,
-0.0165985227,
-0.0237639137,
0.0175620802,
0.0426856503,
0.0024165974,
0.0001511067,
0.0311764143,
-0.0325201713,
-0.0041706478,
0.0168574564,
-0.043574743,
-0.0468634851,
-0.036057841,
-0.0256238524,
0.029661119,
0.0634776726,
-0.0180659052,
0.0330157727,
0.0826502964,
0.0079155266,
-0.0291722436,
-0.0091644311,
-0.0394510739,
0.0733998492,
-0.006100676,
-0.0002118526,
-0.015083502,
0.0369891226,
0.0449872166,
-0.058550287,
-0.0292321779,
-0.0029060752,
2.64e-7,
0.0863174647,
0.0377761945,
0.0055129263,
0.0377307609,
-0.0058553526,
0.005605869,
0.0145782717,
0.0256188773,
-0.0113741765,
-0.0166839622,
-0.0515028462,
0.0234960355,
0.0042046802,
0.0282075927,
-0.009834256,
0.0086267469,
-0.0291503854,
0.0408806503,
-0.029997142,
0.0471276194,
0.087734364,
0.1022577882,
0.0121161537,
-0.0085339285,
-0.0398720764,
-0.0071455832,
0.0471239947,
-0.052113723,
0.0115414858,
-0.0097615011,
-0.0205596592,
0.0164641254,
0.0354348905,
0.0358729027,
0.0062030745,
0.0086925663,
0.0103113623,
-0.0125776064,
0.0063511394,
-0.0092351092,
0.0060266065,
-0.0737074018,
-0.004685841,
-0.0420410708,
0.0602742545,
-0.0863197073,
-0.0324923359,
0.0323321372,
-0.0222714748,
0.0320469551,
0.0312832594,
0.0001448809,
-0.0763618127,
-0.0051254584,
0.0293816905,
0.0183864217,
-0.0627012849,
-0.068276614,
-0.015257623,
0.0339072794,
-0.0587231331,
-0.0283849239,
-0.0179341547,
-0.0082132537,
0.0515119508,
-0.0706533566,
-0.0003808135,
2.106652788e-34,
0.0070380317,
0.0262781903,
0.0122469412,
-0.002212431,
0.0197137631,
-0.042529285,
0.0138829546,
0.0063878917,
0.0021758566,
-0.0356902592,
0.0102969967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14673v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14673v1 | Insights into LLM Long-Context Failures: When Transformers Know but Don't Tell | 2024-06-20T18:50:44 | 2024-06-20T18:50:44 | Taiming Lu, Muhan Gao, Kuai Yu, Adam Byerly, Daniel Khashabi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit positional bias, struggling to utilize
information from the middle or end of long contexts. Our study explores LLMs'
long-context reasoning by probing their hidden representations. We find that
while LLMs encode the position of target information, they often fail to
leverage this in generating accurate responses. This reveals a disconnect
between information retrieval and utilization, a "know but don't tell"
phenomenon. We further analyze the relationship between extraction time and
final accuracy, offering insights into the underlying mechanics of transformer
models. | [
0.0586091205,
0.0264946837,
-0.0248921998,
0.0628857836,
-0.0196113996,
0.0092762122,
0.0026122821,
0.0018999036,
-0.02476025,
-0.0418537222,
-0.0266852006,
-0.0555759966,
0.0351723619,
-0.025323011,
0.0150746172,
-0.0084592886,
0.0423953943,
-0.0301238112,
-0.025925843,
-0.0083197514,
-0.0301442891,
-0.0039225961,
-0.0008578952,
0.0507776439,
0.0076081213,
-0.0112746498,
-0.0017721092,
-0.0225223675,
-0.0166720338,
-0.0140244113,
-0.0013412146,
0.0246738475,
-0.0013314146,
0.0685922503,
0.0000016507,
-0.0488939695,
-0.0127842724,
-0.0121048409,
-0.0601954907,
0.0087471539,
0.0061788992,
-0.03339912,
-0.0169252455,
0.0039550727,
-0.0202258416,
0.0061022546,
0.0563006103,
0.0452353507,
0.0009808263,
0.050925564,
0.0075857411,
-0.0102577917,
0.0118754506,
-0.0392896011,
0.0434147455,
-0.0430617072,
0.0195322018,
-0.0402992629,
0.0082739666,
0.0172790252,
-0.0530508682,
0.0398180149,
0.0222293176,
0.0243835058,
-0.0374429077,
0.0658009425,
0.0060551479,
-0.0139229195,
0.0061582718,
0.0303517748,
-0.0079530533,
0.0143185332,
-0.0031610709,
-0.0049020844,
-0.0167704355,
-0.0141480444,
-0.0498973019,
0.051030919,
-0.0103132799,
-0.0003233728,
-0.0072142566,
0.0152345244,
0.0345051363,
-0.010917034,
-0.0589981638,
0.0877620876,
0.0159544144,
-0.0399870053,
-0.0311171096,
-0.002010918,
-0.0060944129,
-0.0421414152,
0.0091011487,
0.0375521593,
-0.0137561299,
0.0500786677,
0.0172411632,
0.0003621028,
0.0345124528,
-0.0335202441,
-0.0006309657,
0.0476851314,
-0.0394296162,
0.0251246784,
-0.0375610292,
0.0579615757,
-0.0772491395,
0.0098763732,
-0.0234512947,
0.0018958012,
-0.0032351194,
-0.0557713211,
-0.0024644327,
0.025725998,
-0.0312334597,
-0.0365231857,
-0.0193899963,
0.0466236398,
-0.0059491703,
-0.0178936664,
-0.0012429631,
0.0441567972,
-0.0273747742,
-0.0100821555,
-0.0448840596,
0.0739668161,
-0.0075211944,
0.0218888987,
-0.0040845671,
-0.0514793694,
-0.0371318348,
-0.0060301088,
-0.0050128386,
-0.0800014883,
-0.0056399568,
0.0801300928,
-0.0045226081,
-0.0477375053,
-0.0300652348,
-0.0148281446,
-0.0620990582,
-0.0440343693,
0.0162510686,
-0.0478496291,
0.0106744217,
0.0603861734,
-0.0011005059,
-0.0376824401,
0.0206395648,
0.0279107187,
-0.0507332236,
0.0671962425,
0.0356235318,
0.0057808235,
0.0086947884,
0.0226233713,
0.0149975531,
0.0645880401,
0.0086660441,
0.0254294928,
0.0143518737,
-0.0011424087,
0.0184413865,
0.0291806329,
0.0184407067,
-0.0037604186,
-0.0068695927,
-0.0029351893,
0.000641877,
0.0273901559,
0.0647075623,
0.0517504215,
-0.0138156628,
-0.0345967636,
0.0536638424,
0.0723600835,
0.0535969585,
0.0103164269,
0.0005943486,
-0.019359136,
-0.0489848144,
0.0139093362,
-0.0696655735,
0.0250460561,
-0.0240981206,
0.0286778361,
0.0210700464,
0.0268860999,
-0.0172085781,
-0.0086610578,
-0.0298965313,
0.0010041018,
-0.0048202043,
0.0128236338,
0.0337788686,
0.0156037342,
-0.0368705653,
0.1170653924,
0.0008474584,
-0.0253356714,
0.0010305626,
-0.054066319,
0.0223580617,
0.0443045944,
0.0347611718,
-0.018563509,
-0.0187194776,
0.0248107687,
-0.0119781811,
0.0441317931,
0.0067852498,
0.0112780379,
0.0098076863,
-0.0054018525,
-0.0459326804,
-0.0184553787,
0.0173801426,
0.0030193944,
0.0097943563,
-0.0045877388,
0.041876398,
-0.0528473519,
0.0434704572,
0.0287876818,
-0.0363823622,
-0.0325410105,
-0.043975763,
0.0202917326,
0.0012480125,
-0.0313526988,
0.0029405884,
0.0301272199,
0.0335361511,
-0.0316755511,
-0.0107056182,
0.0015487624,
-0.0979478583,
-0.0079343896,
0.0447478667,
-0.0016978683,
0.0010560167,
0.0235929005,
0.0155857988,
-0.0327719972,
0.0189677924,
-0.0412169695,
0.0899452791,
-0.0064997459,
0.0333835892,
0.0023739871,
0.0400250405,
-0.049789574,
0.0718220994,
-0.0193538349,
0.0369712673,
0.0245067049,
0.0076588653,
-0.003195442,
-0.0202657394,
-0.0207410958,
0.0286896881,
-0.0235145669,
-0.0120263649,
0.0195321795,
-0.0424769148,
-0.044628758,
-0.0488125868,
-0.0769460127,
-0.022598559,
-0.0148299113,
0.0098667955,
0.0076514888,
0.0189045724,
-0.0010868167,
0.0021660374,
-0.0098901195,
-0.0134216482,
0.0030254081,
0.0622592308,
0.0159344133,
0.0280443989,
-0.0426549055,
-0.0509120114,
-0.0268281605,
-0.0223664977,
0.0752536729,
-0.0300804917,
-0.0066607278,
-0.0862028077,
0.0307112895,
0.0025943059,
0.0241209138,
-0.0361685045,
-0.0151273776,
0.0226403885,
-0.019686861,
0.0423830822,
0.0364720263,
0.0176222473,
0.0383736342,
0.0463428274,
-0.0313012116,
-0.0693110824,
-0.0034220763,
-0.0490860976,
-0.0406266227,
-0.0734453946,
-0.0009294552,
-0.0359968506,
0.0985325426,
0.0115453592,
0.0081783906,
-0.0268217977,
-0.0194519889,
-0.0205070488,
-0.0157531705,
-0.011979823,
-0.0174008235,
-0.0466604307,
0.0738864839,
-0.0166615117,
-0.0256837811,
0.0650535002,
-0.0232324507,
-0.0085307742,
-0.0030445945,
0.0211973675,
-0.0365661941,
0.0834352672,
-0.0005094308,
0.0099823168,
-0.0048345029,
-0.0647448674,
-0.0628820062,
0.0156893767,
-0.02971421,
-0.032508146,
0.084906958,
0.0022452446,
0.0012690184,
-0.0169136357,
-0.0445747748,
-0.0676189139,
-0.0321946777,
-0.0336124226,
-0.0006735014,
0.0349508785,
-0.0150422594,
-0.0437361971,
0.0181903355,
0.0409091115,
0.0339937434,
-0.0129822446,
-0.0270049274,
-0.0350786857,
0.0155569725,
0.0371401124,
0.0319688432,
0.0710908696,
-0.0371264145,
0.0051395912,
0.0725692213,
0.0420934968,
0.006053526,
-0.0184833426,
-0.0059799487,
0.0625879019,
-0.0203550011,
-0.0319634154,
0.0351789594,
0.0405452959,
-0.055856552,
-0.0471905433,
0.1012612581,
0.0295756292,
-0.0565029681,
0.0300601013,
-0.0447572879,
0.0263890959,
0.0367061123,
0.0102760643,
-0.0839415863,
-0.0080812741,
0.019485265,
0.0183089301,
-0.0132582458,
-0.0005188894,
0.007841059,
-0.137527287,
0.0058116042,
-0.0114510497,
-0.0140895816,
-0.0240782034,
-0.0194837451,
0.0225920025,
0.0137624349,
0.0668723434,
0.0537973754,
-0.0321555175,
-0.0337758958,
0.0165559463,
-0.0280372649,
-0.030089628,
0.0541408919,
-0.0062469444,
0.0244873688,
0.0492805839,
-0.0090731205,
0.0089557748,
-0.0455199704,
0.0403552093,
-0.0409904122,
0.0374514088,
0.0060342113,
0.0279658809,
0.012503311,
0.0030197797,
0.0054585789,
0.0007705782,
-0.0381120332,
-0.0243093111,
-0.0304556377,
0.0749146864,
-0.026184069,
-0.0073751137,
-0.0001693644,
0.0090650758,
-0.012294949,
0.0617008395,
0.0338671543,
-0.0225858781,
-0.0420733243,
-0.014474242,
0.0076176063,
0.0019585956,
-0.0470328741,
0.01468396,
0.0537706129,
-0.0256758984,
-0.0245839544,
-0.0239407383,
0.0043251137,
0.0250836425,
0.0275960471,
-0.0053681759,
-0.0198671371,
-0.0008117171,
-0.0426262356,
0.0290861316,
-0.0247709509,
0.0248526447,
-0.0604565814,
0.0473309495,
0.0163319353,
-0.0530475453,
-0.0230529327,
0.0045439852,
-0.0928144902,
-0.0658718944,
0.0590475835,
0.0131572736,
0.0361743458,
0.0295701325,
0.0074806856,
-0.0535796583,
0.0389404111,
0.0367563963,
-0.0411683805,
0.0434040651,
0.030145321,
0.0063074967,
-0.0033626347,
0.0334313735,
-0.0601440445,
-0.0025606842,
0.0325876549,
0.061502181,
-0.0339601263,
-0.0140229771,
0.0348554216,
-0.0236504581,
0.0760059431,
0.0032977958,
0.0146696065,
-0.0164626166,
0.0352000594,
-0.0036186676,
0.0037047635,
0.00480561,
-0.0336209424,
0.0392716043,
-0.0001956667,
0.0167210028,
0.000720434,
0.0051190532,
0.0258395653,
-0.0404326655,
0.0071690758,
0.0176455006,
-0.0388200246,
0.0374207608,
0.0380887501,
-0.0049676029,
0.0139814969,
0.0020721196,
0.0472048223,
-0.0030602212,
0.0549711809,
0.017813826,
-0.0079380814,
-0.0649300516,
0.0022741056,
-0.0854301155,
-0.0228874665,
0.0233916678,
-0.0176971387,
0.0398668461,
-0.0510930866,
0.038130369,
-0.0148352785,
0.002584083,
-0.0074915434,
-0.0073084547,
-0.0159357414,
-0.0225847829,
0.0476262867,
0.0362522677,
-0.0187474936,
0.0107805254,
0.0671732575,
-0.0134228142,
0.0532685034,
-0.0227894969,
-0.0028257184,
0.0050745313,
-0.0443552285,
0.0021183637,
0.0104890447,
-0.029986836,
-0.0359002389,
-0.0791625157,
-0.0645800903,
0.0238963924,
-0.0253384206,
-0.0079200296,
-0.0658004656,
0.0081838639,
0.0961622745,
0.0331937037,
-0.0411470979,
-0.0200474076,
0.0010803543,
0.018910218,
0.0287747532,
-0.0369042903,
-6.192603422e-33,
-0.0272963271,
-0.0379184261,
0.030467486,
0.004281552,
-0.0279223267,
0.0272530857,
-0.0434483998,
0.0257150233,
-0.023383379,
-0.0065370635,
-0.0303122886,
0.0133895464,
0.0182330851,
0.0307022091,
0.0217711795,
-0.0325136185,
0.0172412079,
0.0349469148,
-0.0290015992,
-0.0132874558,
0.0815156996,
0.0379415825,
0.0447754301,
-0.0633927062,
0.0194948129,
0.0112254042,
0.024653513,
0.0257416051,
-0.0151410382,
0.0840359032,
-0.0251482744,
0.0551538318,
0.0231274031,
-0.0782406703,
-0.0161092822,
0.0261143651,
-0.0646957532,
0.0054327892,
0.0373471156,
0.0213772915,
0.0050045047,
-0.0429858156,
0.0648311228,
0.0007173963,
-0.0362504832,
-0.0236914083,
0.0233588833,
-0.0309346728,
-0.044119928,
-0.0158211272,
-0.0770142376,
0.0008841389,
0.0086156959,
-0.0205508415,
0.0100406446,
0.0118414965,
0.0218934622,
0.054990083,
-0.0752081797,
-0.0026734429,
-0.0103616053,
0.0623318925,
0.0688629895,
0.0593920462,
-0.0043369555,
0.0732404962,
0.0262841284,
0.0289561022,
-0.0273387749,
-0.0729139671,
0.0400254391,
0.0161828995,
0.0090945829,
-0.0152452793,
0.0279749352,
-0.0249847472,
-0.0121588241,
-0.0290289,
-0.019510638,
0.0527843684,
0.0671274737,
0.0086052548,
-0.0240567978,
-0.0350484252,
-0.0370751098,
0.0349744856,
-0.0376457833,
-0.0209399834,
0.0213924292,
0.0223931577,
0.0226786863,
0.0266755298,
0.0437704735,
-0.0355568193,
0.0015343181,
0.0329124555,
-0.0089762518,
0.0197244249,
-0.0063852691,
0.0201980267,
-0.0461799204,
-0.0193204805,
-0.0149873709,
0.0051474562,
-0.0087438663,
0.0074500027,
0.0035240066,
0.0202225279,
-0.0739519149,
-0.033199288,
-0.0746266022,
-0.0001488938,
-0.0227741357,
-0.0247409735,
0.0591662191,
0.0089789322,
-0.0208854023,
0.0341445655,
0.0083384691,
0.0105500948,
-0.0374386162,
0.0251931418,
-0.0123538338,
0.0185721274,
-0.0292850137,
-0.0323973633,
-0.0407546796,
0.0670956075,
0.0355479904,
-0.0541131608,
-0.0261189118,
0.0093588317,
2.509e-7,
0.0735728443,
0.0334591754,
0.030623449,
0.0152270123,
0.0318140052,
0.0006752566,
-0.0058282125,
0.0138606532,
0.0262719095,
-0.0104244249,
-0.0026119666,
0.0139129916,
0.0339569934,
0.0167994983,
-0.0545200445,
0.0078562554,
-0.082271494,
0.0187198389,
-0.0258778501,
-0.0203616489,
0.0178539734,
0.0965766758,
-0.0193416551,
-0.0210910905,
-0.01179183,
-0.0490192883,
0.0694878325,
-0.0366371088,
0.0298506785,
0.005737789,
0.0150570357,
0.0137119181,
0.0359780192,
-0.0147763267,
0.0318245329,
0.0225768648,
-0.0208007637,
0.0320238508,
0.0152038075,
-0.095132798,
-0.0217778068,
-0.0231499374,
-0.0216718651,
-0.0568371043,
0.0570507944,
-0.0899031982,
-0.0246500894,
-0.0208091941,
0.0018642728,
-0.0042094425,
-0.0241769161,
0.0116658807,
0.0052483641,
-0.0022684527,
-0.0000587138,
-0.0097251805,
-0.0038937952,
-0.1101148427,
-0.0414879024,
0.0264893938,
-0.0630664527,
-0.0494940914,
-0.027385328,
-0.0245220382,
0.0451435708,
-0.0248849224,
-0.029198816,
2.300377701e-34,
0.012975879,
-0.0081900209,
-0.0073183957,
0.0396247618,
0.0235361475,
-0.0264065638,
0.0438280143,
0.0295830499,
0.0236226115,
-0.0828696266,
-0.0336543769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14670v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14670v1 | Exploring Design Choices for Building Language-Specific LLMs | 2024-06-20T18:47:43 | 2024-06-20T18:47:43 | Atula Tejaswi, Nilesh Gupta, Eunsol Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Despite rapid progress in large language models (LLMs), their performance on
a vast majority of languages remain unsatisfactory. In this paper, we study
building language-specific LLMs by adapting monolingual and multilingual LLMs.
We conduct systematic experiments on how design choices (base model selection,
vocabulary extension, and continued fine-tuning) impact the adapted LLM, both
in terms of efficiency (how many tokens are needed to encode the same amount of
information) and end task performance. We find that (1) the initial performance
before the adaptation is not always indicative of the final performance. (2)
Efficiency can easily improved with simple vocabulary extension and continued
fine-tuning in most LLMs we study, and (3) The optimal adaptation method is
highly language-dependent, and the simplest approach works well across various
experimental settings. Adapting English-centric models can yield better results
than adapting multilingual models despite their worse initial performance on
low-resource languages. Together, our work lays foundations on efficiently
building language-specific LLMs by adapting existing LLMs. | [
0.0203742739,
0.0560420379,
-0.0272668656,
0.0579870082,
-0.0531664379,
-0.0002735851,
0.0402288027,
0.0220043883,
-0.0174945518,
-0.0311010331,
-0.0414768644,
-0.0427478142,
0.0006607343,
0.0156527646,
0.0424110554,
-0.0466990322,
0.0617896281,
-0.0802007616,
-0.0369616039,
-0.0270893965,
-0.0211366471,
0.004472238,
0.0286033396,
0.0152477724,
-0.004002552,
0.0204598662,
-0.0118356468,
0.0193727128,
-0.0158045236,
-0.0260579865,
-0.0239470378,
0.0300580319,
0.0211569164,
0.0207274221,
0.0000020059,
-0.0355627052,
-0.0006260441,
-0.0129224816,
-0.018358374,
0.0230228193,
0.069727689,
-0.0412553735,
-0.0137788942,
0.0186872594,
0.0008799299,
-0.011042201,
0.0677752644,
0.0183345247,
0.0103870416,
0.0748741999,
-0.0077764639,
-0.0292987358,
0.0194175616,
-0.0212623514,
-0.0172731113,
-0.0327263847,
0.0019345145,
0.0135488566,
0.0368138701,
0.0042814435,
-0.0427632071,
0.0498834029,
0.0153586045,
0.0059805969,
-0.0039549107,
0.0243375339,
-0.0170653686,
-0.0197359584,
-0.0216846038,
0.0499336086,
-0.0413000472,
-0.0093332054,
-0.0144389886,
-0.0137728453,
-0.0161268767,
-0.0265156887,
-0.0524565466,
0.0139282597,
0.0159469172,
0.0144901881,
0.0359665491,
-0.023730807,
0.03885388,
0.0092891343,
-0.0559659824,
0.0513064526,
0.0450309217,
-0.011361355,
-0.01673376,
0.0050451914,
0.0037658457,
-0.066020973,
0.0120363813,
0.018965872,
-0.0276883654,
0.0440522097,
-0.0488439649,
-0.0083398437,
0.0188746378,
-0.0528732575,
0.047396861,
0.0600512698,
-0.0043072617,
0.0430125929,
-0.0419093408,
0.079980202,
-0.0295645632,
0.0200659763,
-0.0664446503,
-0.0453173257,
-0.0232985355,
0.005856778,
-0.039659705,
0.051588878,
-0.0218170919,
-0.0259237923,
-0.0369042084,
0.0642766878,
0.0568249971,
0.0085943146,
0.0396063104,
-0.056329608,
-0.0296752732,
-0.0228425432,
-0.0072403131,
0.0272726286,
-0.0277281664,
0.0028629401,
0.0068676821,
-0.0673656538,
0.0048134825,
0.0195944756,
-0.0214989576,
-0.0378324203,
0.011646647,
0.1062692925,
-0.0040904297,
-0.0206887182,
-0.0360167958,
0.0251265746,
-0.0077452553,
-0.0497852303,
0.0030992187,
-0.0867667049,
0.0410273708,
0.0320264623,
0.0215575956,
-0.0524382181,
-0.0046595591,
-0.0170395169,
-0.0337461047,
0.0503929369,
-0.0279699434,
0.0229071695,
0.000253661,
-0.0030892524,
0.0079411902,
0.1219007745,
0.0521323867,
0.0257156175,
0.0596886463,
-0.0283519737,
-0.0268916823,
0.0795437992,
-0.0139379492,
0.030618092,
-0.0231625922,
0.0048911613,
0.0093102874,
0.0334607437,
0.028896451,
0.0487013087,
0.0004163628,
0.0066590421,
0.0593682602,
0.0587876514,
0.0339574069,
0.0224068817,
0.0113928327,
-0.0064726858,
-0.0194378048,
-0.0079412833,
-0.0388187356,
0.0240039304,
-0.0073878593,
0.0109269312,
0.0122294882,
0.0553003252,
-0.0538987741,
-0.0415442735,
-0.0498348027,
-0.02127566,
0.014553383,
0.0136645446,
0.055231411,
-0.007812934,
-0.0191720519,
0.0871438235,
0.0379862972,
-0.0559430607,
0.0145973852,
-0.0655434653,
0.0086390562,
0.0857455432,
0.0330000296,
-0.0021097763,
-0.0163080283,
0.0326038636,
0.0256014764,
0.0789306611,
0.0693291947,
0.0138066523,
0.0265096314,
-0.0631073862,
-0.0244307686,
0.0050788894,
-0.006057688,
0.0498315841,
0.0086655524,
0.0250592865,
0.0128627624,
-0.0428464785,
-0.0366420709,
0.0222363696,
-0.0591695048,
-0.0015665705,
0.0154008036,
-0.0229988508,
0.0315868556,
0.0071546626,
0.007330426,
-0.0007633733,
0.0201038364,
-0.0611694902,
0.0033827946,
0.007057962,
-0.0475354008,
-0.0234378707,
0.0267747752,
0.0369805843,
0.0201750211,
0.0039354116,
-0.0367738828,
-0.0499101765,
0.0197878126,
-0.0372522622,
0.0615564212,
-0.0195799991,
0.0437633619,
-0.018312877,
0.0012286293,
-0.036743857,
0.036189761,
-0.0072446261,
-0.0082427803,
0.0052846097,
0.0056750132,
-0.003512216,
-0.0307120681,
-0.0309579708,
0.0686634555,
0.0071339202,
0.0140083134,
0.0321770199,
0.0278773308,
-0.0244579259,
-0.0587265976,
-0.0822558552,
0.0054814252,
-0.0257478524,
0.024737183,
0.0153762307,
0.0444893688,
-0.0100558,
0.002048881,
-0.0513071232,
0.0231905691,
-0.0138067361,
0.0534917898,
0.0036438575,
0.0040480918,
-0.0471579023,
-0.0458698012,
-0.0319794528,
0.0425676852,
0.0266651344,
-0.0480315685,
-0.0527699776,
-0.0701220334,
0.0331469402,
-0.0361351296,
0.0156698134,
-0.0140110943,
-0.0311210342,
0.0000582468,
-0.020394206,
0.0655669644,
0.032945659,
-0.0147800976,
-0.0042224512,
0.055826392,
-0.0174348019,
-0.0797620416,
0.0220068134,
0.0054261759,
-0.0489298292,
-0.0598176457,
-0.0525412001,
-0.0001440548,
0.0582471043,
-0.0225694645,
0.0011278262,
-0.0679994896,
-0.0134288715,
-0.0273472089,
-0.0393548273,
-0.0171267223,
0.0159540288,
-0.0053286194,
0.0419188477,
-0.003792556,
-0.0519938432,
0.0354911759,
-0.0355839543,
0.0030650455,
-0.0236821286,
-0.0079659224,
-0.0568524599,
0.0600429624,
-0.004460196,
0.0264310222,
-0.0337477736,
-0.0194938015,
-0.0515734032,
-0.0109969936,
-0.0049769459,
-0.021952942,
0.0643497035,
-0.0534378439,
0.0033762215,
-0.0241882186,
-0.059593223,
-0.0338151492,
0.0103555461,
-0.0369870104,
0.0304196049,
0.0158369448,
-0.0032686833,
-0.0560521074,
0.0414972194,
0.0371806957,
0.0285237581,
-0.0108679142,
0.0156563632,
-0.0183616169,
-0.0240007937,
0.0280190371,
0.035679657,
0.0148075707,
-0.0425108783,
0.029007066,
0.0209268481,
0.028328836,
-0.0229478311,
0.0031404176,
0.0092695896,
0.0788700655,
-0.0327479951,
-0.0516180024,
0.0253897645,
0.0723387152,
-0.0463688634,
-0.0147876628,
0.1126078367,
0.0042526033,
-0.0387395062,
0.014731939,
-0.0431546122,
0.0598054118,
0.0134923821,
0.0312588476,
-0.0502323098,
-0.0221894048,
0.0139573067,
-0.0088675283,
0.0202758871,
0.0175578147,
-0.0185658596,
-0.1195920631,
-0.0120408777,
0.034229219,
-0.0326978527,
-0.0133011034,
-0.0292452518,
-0.0085387519,
-0.0141652515,
0.0585174635,
0.0112467939,
-0.0082296133,
-0.0268389378,
0.0095042475,
-0.0529459342,
-0.0486066304,
-0.003415359,
-0.0250409972,
0.0537276678,
0.0527389608,
0.0127528952,
-0.0205995794,
-0.0368605778,
0.0569730811,
0.0306839477,
0.0200125352,
-0.045835875,
0.0082345093,
0.0200366993,
-0.0119017502,
0.0263843257,
-0.037437439,
-0.0290737934,
-0.0061435504,
0.0231714081,
0.0567495376,
0.002742158,
-0.0060730134,
-0.0167666376,
-0.0514894538,
-0.0142921861,
0.07649941,
0.0153573658,
-0.0590920374,
-0.0289616734,
-0.0287992582,
-0.0553979687,
-0.0641946271,
-0.014158058,
-0.0160766728,
-0.0405343883,
-0.0177678857,
-0.0368432142,
-0.0219712239,
-0.0025732943,
0.0072668446,
0.0343538076,
0.0351607911,
-0.0039596013,
-0.0054605291,
-0.00909176,
-0.016356077,
-0.0488087311,
0.012697448,
-0.0711557567,
-0.0107502434,
0.0251898114,
-0.0125210797,
0.0320055261,
-0.0061038025,
-0.047888156,
-0.0712318048,
-0.0116223842,
0.0467413291,
0.0165475719,
0.060021624,
0.0139833884,
-0.0649406761,
0.0180092007,
-0.0116804829,
-0.0081929071,
0.0348988846,
0.0433221348,
0.0002463121,
0.0026217238,
0.0535069704,
-0.0709745735,
0.0002242732,
0.0306826681,
0.0665788651,
-0.008253674,
-0.0387265868,
-0.0146630919,
0.0515071452,
-0.0060284999,
-0.0553823747,
-0.0158477798,
-0.0042962632,
0.0451906808,
-0.0625516102,
0.0038039482,
-0.0372594446,
0.0068256524,
0.025102742,
-0.0023227127,
0.0098061217,
0.0054763309,
-0.004977453,
0.0185262077,
-0.0250260793,
0.0373708792,
-0.0367268249,
0.0032275429,
0.0364114605,
0.0265344121,
-0.035811536,
-0.0045348736,
0.0066977423,
0.0144800181,
-0.0539811403,
0.0110458033,
-0.0141849685,
-0.0134955971,
-0.0304115564,
0.0504158922,
-0.0168209579,
-0.0540123805,
-0.0077458732,
0.0423155129,
0.0552419014,
0.0176068395,
0.0767195523,
-0.0215419568,
-0.007356232,
-0.046956379,
0.0175127555,
0.0225803629,
-0.0136552369,
0.0289943609,
0.0178545788,
-0.0422456712,
-0.0541295931,
0.0593292601,
0.0217729118,
0.0031734363,
-0.0060066232,
0.0286340863,
-0.0142415939,
-0.0038100746,
0.022416478,
-0.000505437,
-0.0383126885,
-0.007395152,
-0.0541471243,
-0.0639850795,
0.0071266587,
-0.0011603982,
-0.0018467471,
-0.0096233105,
0.0214380044,
0.0595807657,
0.0216652583,
-0.0056678769,
-0.0304462463,
-0.0024587389,
0.0128240241,
-0.0123197222,
0.0124141304,
-6.164797838e-33,
-0.0587006286,
0.0209519472,
0.0389867872,
-0.0179943666,
-0.0016478427,
-0.0042398749,
-0.0346374214,
0.014884254,
-0.0177946389,
-0.0299964976,
-0.013264861,
-0.0118876733,
0.0206090827,
0.0252930764,
0.017477816,
0.011253831,
0.0407214239,
0.0226446334,
-0.023629725,
0.0065537803,
0.0279591661,
0.0102140466,
0.0645861253,
-0.0358049795,
0.0038620511,
0.0164974779,
0.0130088637,
0.0192002859,
0.0207079835,
0.0846357122,
-0.0076377387,
0.0672066584,
0.0174851734,
-0.0240823105,
-0.0590382628,
-0.0139126899,
-0.0509266667,
-0.0427992344,
0.0792904347,
0.0365047865,
0.0023686967,
-0.0642896816,
0.0302509069,
0.0049779802,
-0.0504583493,
-0.0026551022,
0.0032100473,
-0.0346634313,
-0.0495226979,
0.0132840164,
-0.071754083,
0.0301034246,
0.034704674,
0.0271414947,
0.0333583206,
0.0193067826,
-0.0079190545,
0.0019299772,
-0.0211607367,
0.0176788699,
0.0111153433,
0.063230291,
0.0897213742,
0.0469765663,
-0.000956832,
0.0352702849,
0.02636417,
0.0243006237,
0.0022708969,
-0.0039263181,
0.0455174372,
0.0140401088,
0.0849954486,
0.04484329,
0.0004679896,
-0.0235339403,
-0.0700377449,
-0.0140884072,
0.0153141376,
0.0441597812,
0.0426534824,
0.0574060827,
-0.0214562565,
-0.0288466252,
-0.049926918,
0.0552744642,
-0.0383156724,
-0.0466165878,
0.0464866646,
-0.0038803348,
0.0070848833,
-0.0397978052,
0.0579633713,
-0.0282725506,
-0.0349415801,
0.0006321126,
-0.0108681098,
0.0078479871,
-0.0067024049,
0.0412570462,
-0.0467221737,
-0.0594913401,
-0.0155143132,
-0.0064157066,
-0.0029289979,
0.0021548297,
0.012123012,
0.0318948738,
-0.0747174099,
-0.0148288729,
-0.0360226892,
-0.0082897618,
0.0171953607,
0.00731989,
0.0197573267,
-0.0187942181,
-0.0106154867,
0.0366454311,
0.0185256097,
-0.0711117759,
-0.0282641873,
-0.0219472963,
0.0073787398,
0.0317943618,
-0.0293063,
0.0003223032,
-0.0640630051,
0.0245829858,
0.0502208062,
-0.0222652107,
-0.0364280008,
0.02507581,
2.652e-7,
0.0367111936,
0.0521538183,
-0.010617123,
0.010984242,
0.0159825142,
-0.0058255671,
-0.037855722,
0.0300687291,
-0.0064668115,
0.0062530721,
-0.0192336328,
0.0486309715,
0.0694072545,
0.0231000856,
-0.088994734,
0.0213596188,
-0.0228067897,
0.059585683,
-0.0452793874,
0.0293084197,
0.0248421263,
0.0981541872,
0.0028128484,
0.0040266276,
-0.0424882099,
-0.0601544194,
0.0497450233,
-0.0762822628,
-0.0220913552,
0.0395980366,
0.0076851272,
0.0411525182,
-0.004203863,
0.0032459944,
-0.0124036986,
-0.0070354687,
0.005652843,
0.0682632849,
-0.0101223504,
-0.0243315529,
0.0353214219,
-0.0227430612,
-0.0125998454,
-0.0417351834,
0.062079262,
-0.0041238745,
-0.0162302461,
-0.0194430575,
0.0455079004,
0.0074942149,
-0.0048129642,
-0.0255490355,
-0.0302968379,
0.0261022728,
0.0570803396,
-0.0057255067,
-0.0304396022,
-0.0562325902,
-0.0312994011,
0.0128669674,
-0.0387486704,
-0.0726982802,
-0.0684644356,
0.0253501683,
0.0029891718,
-0.0421631709,
-0.0064168102,
2.606631861e-34,
0.0453255847,
-0.0038638255,
0.0113058109,
0.0655425861,
0.0172296073,
-0.0320323072,
-0.0106942952,
0.0268771406,
0.0059837126,
-0.0945522413,
-0.0175588764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15513v1 | PKU-SafeRLHF: A Safety Alignment Preference Dataset for Llama Family Models | 2024-06-20T18:37:36 | 2024-06-20T18:37:36 | Jiaming Ji, Donghai Hong, Borong Zhang, Boyuan Chen, Josef Dai, Boren Zheng, Tianyi Qiu, Boxun Li, Yaodong Yang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | In this work, we introduce the PKU-SafeRLHF dataset, designed to promote
research on safety alignment in large language models (LLMs). As a sibling
project to SafeRLHF and BeaverTails, we separate annotations of helpfulness and
harmlessness for question-answering pairs, providing distinct perspectives on
these coupled attributes. Overall, we provide 44.6k refined prompts and 265k
question-answer pairs with safety meta-labels for 19 harm categories and three
severity levels ranging from minor to severe, with answers generated by
Llama-family models. Based on this, we collected 166.8k preference data,
including dual-preference (helpfulness and harmlessness decoupled) and
single-preference data (trade-off the helpfulness and harmlessness from
scratch), respectively. Using the large-scale annotation data, we further train
severity-sensitive moderation for the risk control of LLMs and safety-centric
RLHF algorithms for the safety alignment of LLMs. We believe this dataset will
be a valuable resource for the community, aiding in the safe deployment of
LLMs. | [
0.066161558,
0.0427112468,
-0.0055501987,
0.0184478927,
0.0074277888,
0.0234155208,
-0.0274029281,
-0.0002734489,
0.0117420508,
-0.0172718596,
-0.0246559177,
-0.0259393118,
-0.0431971587,
-0.0015970076,
-0.0005191904,
-0.0304047707,
0.0572343506,
-0.021308288,
0.0448057093,
-0.0026131896,
0.0665338188,
0.0209450033,
0.0001127968,
0.0470337942,
0.0055081625,
-0.0299907513,
0.035022907,
0.0097485781,
0.0640998259,
-0.0452889912,
0.0477869436,
0.0571992546,
0.0035018139,
0.0393998809,
0.0000018367,
-0.0562673211,
-0.0034550445,
-0.0029413449,
-0.0236411132,
-0.0212404914,
0.0231394842,
0.0050856555,
-0.0093167899,
0.0509300008,
-0.0348063149,
-0.0025249552,
0.0803048015,
0.0272089075,
0.1039121523,
0.0588913523,
0.0090585314,
-0.0180628728,
0.0446075201,
-0.0080910707,
0.0466735661,
-0.0126259644,
0.0537568033,
0.0010016904,
-0.0176443532,
0.0321276225,
-0.0007362495,
0.027574284,
0.0072288881,
-0.0361146256,
-0.0041149235,
-0.0140278516,
-0.0094687445,
-0.0401492566,
-0.0050506587,
0.1177601963,
0.0190382674,
-0.036590185,
-0.0118542928,
-0.0130722709,
0.0163039379,
0.0265780166,
-0.0362663344,
0.0083322348,
-0.0171845127,
-0.0129712056,
0.0388896391,
0.0156742334,
0.0260691084,
0.0146950511,
0.0685840249,
0.0851769,
0.0019740299,
-0.0313269719,
0.0072574266,
-0.0179439299,
-0.0155986315,
-0.0649184063,
0.0127700111,
0.0090436479,
-0.0221458524,
0.0250977892,
-0.0336357132,
-0.0086266352,
0.0849456564,
-0.0764158145,
0.0182905626,
0.0299360733,
-0.0098921871,
0.0140689826,
0.0325521156,
-0.0024319689,
-0.0338461585,
0.0333975591,
-0.0386076123,
0.0253254846,
-0.000798358,
-0.0133169247,
0.0099039003,
0.0045426134,
0.0115301674,
0.0634202585,
-0.0612324476,
0.0329842009,
-0.0376584455,
0.0191807039,
0.034735892,
0.0014079723,
-0.0200955998,
0.0060493597,
-0.038604971,
0.0254411977,
-0.0636138096,
0.0486052036,
0.012850252,
-0.0292626359,
0.0039593307,
0.011741152,
0.0005189874,
-0.0396768935,
0.0181661136,
0.0883407891,
0.0132732773,
0.014239165,
-0.0082031293,
-0.0379655026,
-0.0403550118,
-0.0211951565,
-0.0334415063,
-0.0649793744,
0.03328095,
-0.017097516,
-0.0131679839,
-0.0727227107,
0.0305589624,
0.0431735963,
-0.0337147675,
0.0447195619,
-0.0277900398,
0.0060368427,
0.0108237164,
0.0291244462,
-0.0150663629,
0.0501209944,
0.0259108078,
0.0148857599,
0.0506096408,
-0.0176714119,
0.0030981584,
0.0154430885,
0.0146789392,
0.0105348565,
0.0117630027,
0.0431419425,
0.0066807568,
0.0108494991,
-0.0127476798,
0.0470991172,
-0.0092213014,
-0.0495781787,
0.0711917505,
0.0243370906,
-0.0454331748,
0.0154046137,
0.0007224182,
-0.0044830493,
-0.0128064305,
-0.0006453819,
-0.0414724462,
0.0244197417,
-0.0758670419,
-0.0219380315,
0.01290398,
0.0152128832,
-0.0276358444,
-0.0405225381,
-0.0237454511,
0.0036647788,
0.0109510925,
0.010764204,
-0.016847169,
-0.0009917049,
-0.005708375,
0.0433964469,
0.0452169813,
-0.0510997996,
-0.016775988,
-0.0176581666,
0.0394666679,
0.0657807216,
0.036457859,
-0.0429835916,
-0.0774793699,
-0.0433426797,
0.0236585066,
-0.0067449063,
0.0010791918,
-0.0208670907,
0.0092078522,
-0.0400994234,
-0.0443975925,
0.0198270176,
-0.0049474682,
-0.0352015756,
0.033508826,
-0.0054144664,
-0.0155777177,
0.0025780876,
-0.0401828326,
0.0278329682,
-0.0035393143,
-0.0226199571,
-0.022715738,
0.010095886,
0.0508641824,
0.0090929084,
-0.0111203706,
0.0026017632,
0.0283131115,
-0.0112772379,
-0.014404214,
-0.0100755319,
-0.0443698429,
0.0139765292,
0.069903262,
-0.0525592044,
-0.0395484008,
0.0389931537,
-0.0413331315,
0.0064136647,
-0.0601771809,
-0.0306612998,
-0.0447623096,
-0.021749163,
0.005770138,
-0.0165152475,
-0.032650575,
-0.0462711416,
0.0514801741,
-0.0242210235,
0.0130037237,
-0.0321648493,
-0.0690804943,
-0.0135532496,
-0.0269844458,
-0.0362615958,
-0.0162700377,
-0.0379322469,
0.0410666801,
0.030228598,
0.0216363147,
-0.0598388761,
-0.010988662,
-0.056972377,
0.0011213839,
-0.0021809181,
0.0362510085,
0.0399571694,
-0.0120132556,
-0.0015495849,
-0.0105110416,
-0.062272571,
0.0053884936,
0.0110026272,
0.0519838519,
0.0388196968,
0.0016719878,
-0.0142655196,
-0.0424529314,
-0.0286418665,
-0.0365911983,
-0.0014516758,
-0.010901235,
-0.0234083552,
-0.027050199,
0.0131084146,
-0.066510275,
-0.0007923006,
0.0104499366,
-0.0724983886,
0.0019260126,
0.0211398751,
0.0160669051,
0.0201881602,
0.0344070755,
-0.0239059292,
0.0698622838,
0.0322976559,
-0.0521993339,
0.0009312939,
-0.021184871,
-0.062195491,
-0.0130499527,
-0.0572215319,
-0.0173578262,
0.0489069186,
-0.019471528,
-0.0195057206,
-0.0514077991,
0.0040099239,
-0.0267607048,
-0.0489454456,
-0.022906756,
-0.0546663776,
-0.0043768436,
0.0569474772,
-0.01641744,
-0.0589945018,
0.0949819162,
0.0093954243,
0.0275566988,
-0.0312447287,
-0.0126742302,
-0.0176670142,
0.0226742644,
-0.019589588,
0.0449331179,
0.0260511618,
0.0002180116,
-0.039633885,
-0.0400648266,
0.043057818,
-0.0464939512,
0.0317459181,
-0.0364443101,
-0.0064388486,
-0.0028812201,
-0.0821576118,
-0.059148211,
-0.0895065069,
-0.0221471693,
-0.0505004078,
-0.0161898155,
0.0046770927,
-0.0057097427,
-0.0165633913,
0.0239112936,
-0.0213880949,
-0.0152963083,
0.0059087183,
-0.0052400371,
0.027928751,
0.1076181233,
-0.0163450092,
0.0306599494,
-0.0085450066,
0.0436973087,
0.1006733701,
0.0068632029,
-0.0129292943,
0.0279744528,
-0.0072657987,
0.0434278212,
-0.0084036598,
-0.0038169429,
0.0461431667,
0.0523084737,
-0.0241686273,
-0.0027280117,
0.0607271269,
0.0253502168,
-0.0220550019,
0.0077420967,
-0.0414593853,
0.0361782983,
0.0057398891,
0.0030795995,
-0.0683022812,
-0.0228702109,
0.004507822,
0.0279688463,
-0.0287084635,
-0.0342827365,
0.0402903035,
-0.070618771,
0.0093864091,
0.0150093855,
-0.0532959886,
-0.0150457872,
-0.0373798124,
0.0150835337,
-0.018100366,
0.0323473886,
0.008882462,
-0.0143505922,
-0.0319345891,
0.0261848439,
0.0014368591,
-0.0089460546,
0.0249621253,
-0.0314625911,
0.0703425258,
0.0421224609,
-0.0043408806,
-0.0284303892,
-0.0381978303,
0.0233836621,
0.004391924,
-0.0412100218,
-0.0024808911,
0.0423583016,
-0.0098101171,
0.0049015582,
-0.0515148677,
0.0526298396,
-0.0145347454,
-0.0109637249,
0.0275069848,
0.0850442499,
0.0030172046,
-0.006442348,
-0.058495719,
0.0490645878,
0.0280352943,
0.0580926463,
0.0145245967,
-0.0500450693,
0.0187277254,
-0.0281699114,
-0.0194834732,
0.0117213186,
-0.0477514453,
0.014811282,
-0.0003539709,
-0.034899395,
-0.0741580874,
-0.0140390508,
0.0038755594,
-0.0118289106,
0.0204238612,
-0.001500992,
-0.0083448775,
0.0232984219,
-0.028476201,
0.0301777162,
-0.0449393056,
0.0192776248,
-0.0680665597,
0.0620336868,
0.019137986,
0.0048028314,
-0.0322176367,
0.0314246081,
-0.0487906523,
-0.0670906156,
0.017236067,
0.0803915635,
0.0250051171,
-0.0173536614,
-0.0140421996,
-0.0635466799,
0.0435287841,
0.065350689,
-0.0391373225,
-0.0268377438,
0.0232207533,
-0.0122278612,
0.0234559923,
0.0245444495,
-0.0479089878,
-0.0040749139,
0.0281084925,
0.0362674855,
-0.0522792079,
-0.0411438085,
0.0228181332,
0.0412593335,
0.0062628104,
0.0095207822,
-0.0003992503,
-0.0271177329,
0.0396123901,
0.0006406524,
-0.040573094,
0.0161701255,
0.0321917087,
0.0421012007,
-0.0541470125,
-0.0086673405,
-0.0065023233,
-0.029000232,
0.0456386916,
-0.0364655219,
0.0374840423,
0.0372079387,
0.0467291512,
0.0052057593,
-0.0055032782,
-0.0395483263,
0.0105405403,
0.0252092835,
0.0344534926,
0.0221852828,
0.0387301557,
-0.0062570944,
0.0119323721,
-0.0073264302,
0.0538934544,
-0.0311227888,
-0.0584984347,
-0.0388160162,
0.0094573181,
0.015929956,
0.023540169,
0.0519952029,
0.0125528257,
-0.0331235193,
-0.035206493,
0.0298059005,
-0.0059735761,
-0.0338661782,
0.0788795128,
0.021918254,
-0.0264995228,
-0.0125429844,
0.0631372556,
-0.0077466578,
0.0491390489,
0.016955886,
-0.0299331304,
-0.0114503754,
-0.0270435344,
0.0152299004,
0.0321337096,
-0.0320771746,
-0.0316271149,
-0.0704225004,
-0.0647405386,
-0.0077829938,
0.0033713253,
-0.0183895249,
0.0201211721,
0.014057382,
0.0006123218,
0.0232722498,
-0.0352459326,
-0.0063433158,
0.0027341638,
-0.0260448437,
-0.006372022,
-0.0210106205,
-6.073466703e-33,
0.0044691642,
-0.0141285388,
-0.0257121455,
-0.0081033688,
0.0076590073,
-0.0049344222,
0.0261246953,
0.021488646,
-0.0550803058,
0.0165736116,
-0.0124523295,
0.0232349709,
0.0044462066,
-0.0047712033,
0.0209421851,
-0.0642043725,
-0.0028451076,
-0.0022326186,
-0.0275547206,
0.0490244925,
0.0463798344,
-0.0235040206,
0.0470079668,
-0.101973623,
0.0410581455,
-0.004154901,
-0.0270426553,
0.0471042283,
-0.0645921081,
0.0918944255,
0.0089388276,
0.0815072209,
0.0164849889,
-0.0055155703,
0.0054636705,
0.0459970683,
-0.0424367525,
-0.03195614,
0.0479666442,
-0.0525506362,
-0.0557999313,
-0.0791801885,
0.0499850512,
-0.0000502893,
-0.0108559029,
-0.0373724736,
0.0250799246,
-0.0279958919,
0.0078947656,
-0.0244171713,
-0.0307352785,
-0.0011721971,
-0.0177347213,
-0.0199842956,
-0.0164323729,
0.0679947883,
0.0206448436,
0.0276167095,
-0.0315019041,
0.0137307961,
0.0134818135,
0.0228478611,
0.0516107753,
-0.0249073654,
-0.0241520535,
0.0531897433,
-0.0410163216,
0.0092806341,
0.0028783449,
-0.0159086473,
-0.0577605702,
0.0441958159,
0.0472480282,
0.0815373212,
0.0090642851,
-0.023101788,
-0.1128887162,
0.0455858409,
0.0024662158,
0.0711548924,
0.0173244346,
-0.0079605822,
-0.079704158,
-0.0059598037,
-0.0489259399,
0.0189485401,
-0.0459562279,
-0.0295958016,
0.02288289,
-0.0279259346,
-0.0575914867,
-0.029141644,
-0.0113395639,
-0.0338515081,
0.0127271116,
0.0470741317,
0.0119894128,
-0.0041533378,
0.0293605253,
0.0337977856,
-0.0367967635,
0.0122943381,
-0.00442782,
-0.0712570846,
0.0244103279,
0.0145206796,
0.0715537816,
0.0119610056,
-0.065380998,
0.0064616124,
-0.0165319759,
0.0295072533,
0.0113057336,
0.0100440234,
0.0413263328,
0.0142256394,
0.0100991027,
0.0172972623,
0.0718852207,
0.0249718186,
-0.0417153463,
-0.0106336763,
-0.0310212094,
0.0051116049,
-0.000294941,
0.0077201254,
-0.0027440025,
0.0076279715,
-0.0065853847,
-0.0571604781,
-0.0074797529,
-0.0239687636,
2.573e-7,
0.0541494451,
0.0409948044,
0.0236714538,
0.035043288,
0.0205303486,
0.0522360839,
0.0210625771,
0.059894301,
0.0482077375,
-0.0173369702,
0.045966275,
-0.0165687632,
0.056139145,
0.0621474087,
-0.0318041742,
-0.0355666243,
-0.0884933174,
0.0081989728,
-0.028504245,
-0.0243142471,
0.0949215218,
0.0831762254,
0.0044533205,
-0.0079447795,
-0.0169667155,
-0.0102273831,
0.0373644568,
-0.0658503398,
0.0157060307,
0.0314128995,
0.0298077874,
-0.0023479383,
0.0159369409,
0.0079390658,
0.009186795,
-0.0302975997,
-0.0024557891,
0.0901688486,
-0.0180627778,
-0.0456291996,
-0.0169751365,
-0.0301233418,
0.024190465,
-0.0767789185,
0.0595531911,
-0.0226658806,
-0.0185748897,
-0.0136453267,
-0.0335719995,
-0.0155438334,
0.0433634929,
-0.0348853171,
-0.0141767031,
0.0076687359,
0.0240972415,
0.0238959249,
-0.0261537265,
-0.0259207562,
-0.0512594543,
0.0091355965,
-0.0028667287,
-0.0993053839,
-0.0219022054,
0.0333692729,
-0.0417211279,
-0.0873242989,
0.0297398083,
2.262737545e-34,
-0.003739435,
-0.03175864,
0.022707006,
-0.0166682154,
0.0288659744,
0.0170848779,
0.0039498592,
0.0120000793,
0.0201576445,
-0.0580111295,
-0.0079789776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14666v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14666v1 | Co-training for Low Resource Scientific Natural Language Inference | 2024-06-20T18:35:47 | 2024-06-20T18:35:47 | Mobashir Sadat, Cornelia Caragea | cs.CL | cs.CL | Scientific Natural Language Inference (NLI) is the task of predicting the
semantic relation between a pair of sentences extracted from research articles.
The automatic annotation method based on distant supervision for the training
set of SciNLI (Sadat and Caragea, 2022b), the first and most popular dataset
for this task, results in label noise which inevitably degenerates the
performance of classifiers. In this paper, we propose a novel co-training
method that assigns weights based on the training dynamics of the classifiers
to the distantly supervised labels, reflective of the manner they are used in
the subsequent training epochs. That is, unlike the existing semi-supervised
learning (SSL) approaches, we consider the historical behavior of the
classifiers to evaluate the quality of the automatically annotated labels.
Furthermore, by assigning importance weights instead of filtering out examples
based on an arbitrary threshold on the predicted confidence, we maximize the
usage of automatically labeled data, while ensuring that the noisy labels have
a minimal impact on model training. The proposed method obtains an improvement
of 1.5% in Macro F1 over the distant supervision baseline, and substantial
improvements over several other strong SSL baselines. We make our code and data
available on Github. | [
0.0314537883,
0.03863547,
0.0250644963,
0.0042971941,
-0.0277608316,
0.0238009822,
0.036467161,
-0.0212752819,
0.0546753965,
-0.0492468253,
-0.0665846244,
0.0333598927,
-0.0117217638,
0.0174764134,
-0.0033811091,
-0.0233717151,
0.0448674187,
-0.0250814147,
0.0293531418,
-0.0181458928,
-0.0233147852,
-0.0212756302,
-0.0220641363,
-0.0116846636,
-0.0149869854,
-0.0346439816,
0.0514024049,
-0.0511246696,
0.0366159193,
-0.0649461448,
0.0530899875,
0.0636726618,
0.028780641,
0.014383629,
0.0000019933,
-0.0492805131,
-0.0108326832,
0.0292035453,
0.0037625576,
0.0125039117,
-0.0027090716,
-0.0266230572,
0.0283530094,
-0.0240399055,
-0.0232865121,
-0.0060498007,
0.068158716,
0.014091826,
0.0203785785,
0.0082389638,
0.0077336421,
-0.0264297761,
0.027207233,
-0.0153852841,
0.0227604322,
-0.0212279502,
0.0312692337,
0.0400708877,
-0.0075762202,
0.0332584828,
0.0125390403,
0.0686981827,
0.0089098616,
-0.0217395518,
0.0297262687,
0.0648790747,
-0.0734980628,
-0.0059148865,
0.0099841533,
0.0412413552,
0.0437068008,
-0.0675115883,
0.0151865389,
0.0031962898,
-0.0431636535,
0.039158456,
-0.0209759232,
-0.0104107223,
-0.0089911139,
0.010161411,
0.0520390384,
0.0363628566,
0.0199308172,
0.0185667388,
0.0158056505,
0.0709231198,
0.0048549185,
-0.0802199319,
0.0201296005,
0.0167434141,
-0.0060700201,
-0.0124189435,
0.0274234284,
0.0163371861,
-0.0000130137,
0.0081649283,
-0.0230616648,
-0.0443363525,
0.0200924929,
-0.0409607626,
-0.0353258885,
-0.0210913382,
-0.0299809705,
0.0532556064,
-0.0271095205,
-0.0086409152,
0.0418210067,
-0.012981886,
0.005153608,
-0.0147565594,
-0.0849289373,
-0.0240196157,
0.0010389138,
0.0326083936,
0.0348324329,
0.0212443229,
-0.0599793829,
-0.029037213,
0.0055918223,
-0.0184811074,
0.0000969176,
0.0015752992,
-0.0600531697,
0.0317475088,
-0.0010948814,
0.0332347937,
0.00307011,
-0.0056686341,
-0.0501784198,
-0.0171622969,
-0.0232273024,
0.0317469239,
0.0148157207,
-0.0442817919,
0.0273731668,
0.04813594,
0.0094951317,
-0.0305003561,
-0.0344075337,
-0.0266420562,
-0.01284716,
-0.0582958311,
0.0132030165,
-0.0181929022,
-0.0044852537,
-0.0156622417,
0.0128294108,
-0.0022860297,
0.0055377851,
-0.0055877012,
-0.0517400019,
0.0630681515,
-0.0742079765,
-0.0251301751,
0.0084471405,
-0.007473472,
-0.0046364726,
0.0430990979,
0.0244142581,
-0.0369836055,
0.0325797088,
0.0048515634,
-0.0561744012,
-0.0303894524,
0.0108797336,
-0.0093414718,
-0.0101602701,
-0.015419228,
0.010395525,
0.0161705706,
0.0065050558,
-0.0073405062,
-0.0231806505,
0.011116704,
0.0312988423,
0.0272920318,
0.0067448136,
-0.0075523248,
0.0626675338,
-0.0008660117,
-0.0001722945,
0.0246906914,
-0.0305586644,
0.0302914605,
-0.0323616751,
0.0078065055,
0.0300659128,
0.0026747731,
-0.0318370834,
-0.0633401573,
0.0221377779,
-0.0416804031,
-0.0474352241,
-0.0215855427,
0.1043377146,
0.0023318436,
0.0091872681,
-0.0050146822,
0.096306242,
-0.0185734313,
-0.0025031508,
0.0093536489,
0.0478480868,
-0.015061372,
-0.0234092604,
-0.0749586523,
-0.055775065,
0.0088772941,
0.0333009027,
0.011919912,
0.0212237816,
-0.0180187374,
0.0081476001,
-0.0159510765,
-0.0263259597,
-0.000916873,
0.0322074033,
-0.0060620308,
-0.0161306355,
0.0444349982,
0.039976608,
-0.0288127195,
-0.0187504403,
0.0544074811,
-0.0344897471,
-0.0241609141,
0.0006767997,
-0.0113122305,
0.0445371568,
-0.0043208376,
-0.0531150848,
0.0146238236,
0.0517756641,
-0.0364857167,
-0.0270087589,
0.0156740472,
-0.0206567142,
-0.0706645697,
0.0374926887,
-0.0324327499,
-0.0366921462,
-0.0105363773,
-0.0184189752,
-0.0329874754,
0.0539507419,
0.0219567623,
0.0072985515,
-0.0334927179,
-0.0255186092,
0.0018485737,
0.0038412628,
-0.0529144779,
0.0897154957,
0.0404269509,
0.0775813907,
-0.0003342262,
-0.0209628381,
0.0428079627,
0.0125014316,
0.005427327,
-0.025946904,
-0.0203129333,
-0.0535902008,
0.0484451614,
0.0147403413,
-0.0267105829,
-0.0109442463,
-0.0239555035,
0.0044226306,
-0.0058836374,
0.0163171701,
-0.0161270648,
-0.0153284073,
0.0042563551,
-0.0151099423,
0.0201884415,
-0.0063180383,
-0.0451391935,
-0.007361881,
0.0402584635,
-0.017787531,
0.0317642242,
-0.0366289727,
-0.0007514503,
-0.0614120513,
0.0508216284,
0.030500818,
-0.0519701727,
-0.0467922091,
0.0108008608,
-0.0404093452,
0.0184921976,
0.006766221,
0.0086682811,
0.0259698089,
-0.0080745649,
-0.0214820709,
0.071093969,
0.0004368086,
-0.0147756096,
0.0600795485,
0.0090183495,
-0.054183729,
0.0258692931,
-0.0297309831,
0.0268922839,
-0.0147993723,
0.0237185284,
-0.0005476503,
0.0502390154,
-0.0434965529,
-0.0381680354,
-0.0123384073,
-0.0044358419,
-0.0223086346,
-0.0185787417,
0.0455725342,
0.0272501986,
0.0262004342,
-0.0023579199,
0.0394073389,
-0.0471550822,
0.086751841,
-0.0029801407,
-0.0037053593,
-0.0791131258,
-0.0582211651,
-0.0323549733,
0.0293010734,
0.0082619851,
-0.0118326936,
0.0762563497,
0.0238885526,
-0.0158900619,
0.0195028633,
0.0358554646,
0.047614608,
-0.0659693331,
-0.039226342,
0.0631269142,
0.0075712777,
-0.0170075316,
0.0073004845,
-0.0298072305,
-0.0631416291,
0.0328782052,
-0.0370319895,
-0.0346836075,
-0.0189563185,
0.034770295,
0.0157443155,
0.0283851549,
-0.0382212885,
-0.0175486598,
-0.0315113924,
0.0083844559,
0.0542288497,
-0.0371869504,
-0.0346639045,
-0.0107184537,
0.0063814288,
0.0167789049,
0.0002472822,
0.0190637615,
-0.054462254,
-0.0125874057,
-0.0040550604,
-0.0342499278,
-0.0258546453,
-0.0035347471,
0.0200468358,
-0.0251859091,
-0.0218632109,
0.0997760892,
0.0302974749,
-0.0357868411,
-0.0098011699,
-0.0104099112,
0.0273561459,
0.0223721396,
0.010898185,
-0.0380172767,
-0.0444935486,
-0.0375975221,
-0.0073644281,
0.0016173342,
-0.0575832911,
-0.0130853364,
-0.0795507729,
0.004039967,
-0.0218693018,
-0.0563787222,
-0.0009882352,
-0.1225547418,
0.0091291489,
-0.0171578862,
-0.0730640218,
-0.044306919,
-0.0178873856,
0.0288668927,
0.0547254607,
-0.0560524091,
-0.0656623542,
-0.0122467922,
-0.0329693072,
0.0425363407,
0.0102637354,
0.0435625166,
-0.0229443274,
-0.0129297627,
0.0384680592,
-0.0467799008,
0.0054753385,
-0.0535338931,
0.0813172162,
-0.0114745041,
-0.0043628942,
0.0045158505,
0.059857972,
-0.0317252353,
-0.0091228364,
0.0466106087,
0.0875604302,
-0.0152389435,
-0.0304486379,
-0.0339175351,
0.0165423937,
0.0319311284,
0.0534458496,
-0.0001786016,
-0.02365686,
-0.0485966988,
0.0264202766,
0.0255933981,
0.0294828638,
0.0057197874,
-0.0030827112,
-0.0699029416,
-0.0404039547,
-0.062902756,
-0.0194811765,
0.0160528626,
0.0335672572,
-0.0002385435,
0.0531425774,
0.0223396253,
-0.0142564438,
-0.0240219757,
0.0270325262,
-0.0299482699,
-0.0180423651,
0.005935505,
-0.0236942768,
0.1042233706,
0.0421394929,
-0.0450985692,
-0.0092593823,
-0.0160280447,
-0.056544587,
-0.053357061,
0.0720566437,
0.0125212716,
0.0420352705,
0.0078758178,
-0.0388815552,
0.0373627059,
0.1085411683,
-0.0108913835,
-0.0177950338,
0.0269370098,
-0.0159929674,
0.0114692496,
-0.0021838052,
-0.0226117,
0.032215979,
0.0103713404,
0.0069673266,
-0.0452866443,
-0.0139670838,
0.0302742645,
0.0232370086,
0.0886977538,
-0.0162266605,
0.0130531322,
-0.0125375269,
-0.0060049468,
-0.0070294859,
-0.001336262,
-0.0261534881,
0.0570165105,
-0.0117105637,
0.0252834391,
0.004723866,
0.0258871857,
-0.0115777319,
0.0357377827,
-0.0571043342,
0.0081312684,
0.0282582883,
0.0333178155,
-0.0309102964,
0.0026818393,
-0.0029269184,
-0.044693552,
0.0328637995,
0.0402727537,
-0.0011998054,
-0.0093432041,
0.0550681241,
0.0654356629,
0.0048868265,
-0.0236954894,
-0.1229061037,
0.002935264,
-0.0072927526,
0.024149064,
0.0381289311,
-0.0295261964,
0.0314769149,
-0.0323515125,
-0.0187681559,
-0.006916122,
0.0570665598,
0.0265637487,
0.0155599238,
0.0313538164,
0.0084750103,
-0.0296962429,
0.062504366,
0.1022193208,
0.0463270955,
0.0427145176,
0.0331571475,
-0.0207173694,
-0.0217961669,
-0.0066598142,
-0.0059528304,
-0.0121009741,
-0.0049597318,
0.0014632217,
0.0057817344,
-0.0432748087,
0.0590938292,
-0.0285912529,
-0.0145934587,
-0.0034362893,
0.0294300336,
0.0131653361,
-0.0082149673,
-0.0349349827,
-0.0154320858,
0.0094976043,
0.0352339558,
-0.0431163125,
-0.0402450785,
-6.632718058e-33,
-0.0031138724,
-0.0148638971,
-0.0251562111,
0.0430208109,
-0.007778246,
0.0564434528,
-0.0228814073,
-0.0233953781,
-0.0273544434,
0.0292342063,
0.0104892245,
0.0133807268,
0.0106034633,
-0.0151713267,
0.0326747559,
-0.0219230242,
0.0128164319,
0.0038266731,
0.0322261453,
0.0147619415,
0.0324327014,
0.0508668683,
0.0704095438,
-0.1523180008,
0.0244415943,
0.026815556,
0.0166271031,
0.0086183613,
0.0061150687,
0.0123742186,
-0.0371145047,
0.0340335891,
-0.0095293233,
-0.0334952846,
0.0171475615,
0.0048439414,
-0.0804976001,
-0.0419615991,
-0.0231199563,
-0.0473813675,
-0.0415440015,
0.0157784075,
0.0012642242,
0.0260588024,
0.0083503677,
-0.025318956,
0.0885725096,
-0.0144617474,
-0.0406720452,
-0.0968683586,
-0.0677471086,
0.0464899428,
-0.0451688021,
0.0168808661,
0.0211373549,
0.0575936809,
0.0203840807,
0.0519417785,
0.0150417611,
0.0183560103,
0.0116511444,
0.042845726,
0.0019319353,
-0.0144602638,
0.0258078519,
0.0545710139,
0.0209525675,
-0.0048943963,
0.015720455,
-0.012493425,
0.0299628992,
0.010422674,
0.0150825568,
-0.0029499871,
0.0505603701,
0.032600347,
-0.1258963346,
0.0192789901,
0.0609656647,
0.028920291,
-0.0075939302,
0.0095020831,
0.004303833,
-0.0084426031,
-0.0235087965,
-0.034875527,
-0.0113497805,
-0.0151076652,
-0.0262130443,
-0.0276965201,
-0.0612662993,
0.0633683801,
-0.0096727209,
-0.0335407443,
-0.0528871343,
-0.0098300939,
0.0179316457,
0.0044843568,
0.0252956618,
0.0109664714,
-0.0719317645,
-0.068281956,
-0.0136765651,
0.0081925523,
0.0813052654,
-0.0189666152,
0.069736518,
-0.0076720431,
-0.0103817135,
-0.0325418524,
0.0024021862,
-0.0630766824,
0.026589008,
-0.0077604186,
-0.0138065442,
0.0397606865,
0.0184701066,
0.0497558899,
0.0765080228,
0.044777438,
0.0159786101,
0.0106317811,
-0.0008180556,
0.0053631067,
-0.0174910426,
-0.0499627776,
-0.0132478559,
0.0126495305,
-0.0176580641,
-0.072527431,
-0.0027603423,
-0.0000927395,
2.867e-7,
0.043154195,
0.0602005608,
-0.0042963373,
-0.048272755,
0.0053705703,
0.035929352,
-0.0059031881,
0.0141620915,
0.0139767062,
-0.0253157578,
0.0148934657,
-0.0341209918,
0.0163486041,
0.0299378708,
-0.0850884989,
-0.026896961,
-0.0757798553,
-0.0572149903,
-0.0646521673,
-0.0139629161,
0.0186917428,
0.039153289,
0.024186261,
-0.0066646859,
0.0123647079,
-0.0464065969,
0.0418525375,
-0.00768197,
0.0036498138,
0.0472633801,
0.0143675255,
-0.0139481183,
-0.0177211985,
0.0637375042,
-0.0376894586,
-0.0027627286,
0.0139175244,
0.0061512901,
-0.0023077698,
0.0326629952,
0.0620109998,
0.0258055478,
0.0177157838,
0.0383260101,
0.0788139924,
-0.0916522071,
-0.0651968643,
-0.0127704591,
-0.0323153101,
-0.0009454831,
0.0317936428,
0.0004857935,
0.0119704399,
0.0257883631,
-0.0166242868,
0.007157343,
-0.0427162535,
-0.0291424971,
-0.0320890173,
0.0597430877,
-0.0383749381,
-0.0209801402,
0.0111128641,
0.0094127199,
0.0327813067,
-0.0267682225,
0.0381866731,
2.61649683e-34,
0.0595328324,
-0.0295692682,
-0.0075776344,
0.0202180203,
0.0049987957,
-0.0134522738,
-0.0481197909,
-0.0062316158,
0.0253509525,
-0.026818784,
0.0160290562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14657v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14657v1 | OpenDebateEvidence: A Massive-Scale Argument Mining and Summarization Dataset | 2024-06-20T18:22:59 | 2024-06-20T18:22:59 | Allen Roush, Yusuf Shabazz, Arvind Balaji, Peter Zhang, Stefano Mezza, Markus Zhang, Sanjay Basu, Sriram Vishwanath, Mehdi Fatemi, Ravid Schwartz-Ziv | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce OpenDebateEvidence, a comprehensive dataset for argument mining
and summarization sourced from the American Competitive Debate community. This
dataset includes over 3.5 million documents with rich metadata, making it one
of the most extensive collections of debate evidence. OpenDebateEvidence
captures the complexity of arguments in high school and college debates,
providing valuable resources for training and evaluation. Our extensive
experiments demonstrate the efficacy of fine-tuning state-of-the-art large
language models for argumentative abstractive summarization across various
methods, models, and datasets. By providing this comprehensive resource, we aim
to advance computational argumentation and support practical applications for
debaters, educators, and researchers. OpenDebateEvidence is publicly available
to support further research and innovation in computational argumentation.
Access it here: https://huggingface.co/datasets/Yusuf5/OpenCaselist | [
0.0036004761,
0.0734606236,
0.0254272912,
0.052852612,
-0.0203443598,
0.0183910001,
-0.0175752062,
-0.0450002141,
-0.029268356,
-0.0477804281,
0.0571724847,
-0.0344797149,
-0.0023232216,
-0.0079707261,
-0.018122267,
-0.0904531255,
-0.0055031516,
-0.011423938,
0.0920705572,
-0.0198658407,
0.0357273109,
0.0025535896,
-0.029808959,
0.0425359793,
0.0160156563,
-0.0443330631,
-0.0047011464,
-0.0133772017,
0.0351761952,
-0.0269319657,
0.0069972677,
0.0228876583,
0.0072719497,
0.0401177816,
0.0000019408,
-0.0374164581,
-0.0018475411,
-0.0267051328,
-0.022520287,
0.0339902416,
0.0794322267,
0.0463236533,
0.0113154752,
0.0389944278,
-0.0226692464,
-0.0216477457,
0.0322907977,
0.0611047447,
0.0774904042,
0.0634647831,
-0.0055186832,
-0.0444787778,
0.0115741165,
-0.0246629957,
-0.0843683109,
0.0447808057,
0.014321018,
0.0214963183,
-0.0301114991,
0.0082080653,
0.0185925998,
-0.005552263,
0.0101844678,
-0.0167941172,
-0.0386229493,
0.0093452539,
-0.0720695183,
0.0076884036,
0.0258135498,
0.0721949711,
0.0386739261,
-0.0230324846,
0.0368293487,
-0.0167322122,
0.0265317578,
0.0103129596,
-0.0778985992,
0.0855154619,
-0.0096194725,
0.0471556559,
0.0463549644,
0.0461345389,
-0.0134643568,
0.0328335799,
-0.0010871598,
0.0208130553,
-0.0304646287,
-0.0089768395,
-0.0030522563,
-0.0208594538,
-0.0388971306,
-0.070818074,
-0.0022837964,
0.0164401308,
0.0194456298,
0.0186576918,
-0.0123205381,
-0.042207811,
0.0333547145,
-0.0498314165,
0.0219962019,
-0.0399379358,
0.0019470231,
0.0465822034,
-0.0021253431,
-0.0392283574,
-0.0142256971,
0.0025734156,
0.0141398627,
-0.0338478759,
-0.0270829387,
0.018880209,
-0.0251980238,
0.0115477918,
-0.0566577949,
-0.0042517697,
0.0048907837,
-0.0414960198,
-0.0559573546,
0.0088673355,
-0.0083284006,
0.0268469602,
0.0210181195,
-0.0247465167,
-0.0375698693,
0.0151144518,
-0.0616432764,
0.0120059075,
0.04688178,
-0.0053992663,
-0.0289770644,
0.0400307812,
0.0307514518,
0.0040736278,
-0.0250414908,
0.007923793,
-0.0349667631,
0.0386658572,
-0.0107722292,
-0.0671351328,
-0.0272253193,
-0.0293829124,
0.0185940936,
-0.0963221192,
-0.0023831821,
-0.0183266234,
-0.0099344496,
-0.0578210726,
0.0105473232,
0.025010271,
-0.0005834639,
0.0062412601,
-0.0220042709,
-0.0383455902,
0.047996372,
0.0308542643,
0.0006138178,
0.0180272963,
0.0208140947,
0.0264635384,
0.0605915338,
0.0329989865,
-0.0122638866,
-0.0016927723,
0.0182994269,
0.0166364219,
0.0729755312,
0.006704032,
-0.0425148495,
0.0142826317,
-0.0264963917,
0.0444041453,
-0.0438390151,
-0.0314364396,
0.0116338395,
0.0709119588,
0.0048588919,
-0.0030010319,
-0.0068092183,
0.0281428192,
0.0476807989,
-0.0001727936,
0.0283326115,
-0.0138422418,
0.0216848664,
0.0065920381,
0.0536948256,
0.0051422911,
0.0004619755,
-0.0739930421,
-0.0073039061,
0.0096122762,
-0.0041408744,
0.0059026168,
0.0100846747,
0.008374868,
-0.010902564,
0.0241255146,
0.0297830589,
-0.0744106099,
-0.0503632054,
-0.0016600954,
0.0468715876,
-0.0513685569,
0.0059531024,
-0.0476039648,
0.0055013299,
-0.0404857211,
0.1060154513,
0.0629049912,
0.0721162483,
-0.0311781764,
-0.0212060679,
-0.0511700809,
-0.0261577461,
-0.0392066948,
0.0314690135,
0.0052501503,
0.0195222553,
-0.0168558974,
0.0366978161,
0.0292694122,
-0.082224071,
0.0156375729,
0.0079943705,
-0.0113289971,
0.012713044,
-0.0117633883,
0.0433822796,
0.0483267419,
-0.0215105843,
0.0001790296,
0.0232046023,
-0.0208072234,
-0.0078570414,
0.0346737355,
-0.0069033951,
0.0091715492,
0.0565680973,
-0.0717951506,
-0.0192499589,
-0.0087622954,
-0.04318152,
-0.0276882835,
0.0669879988,
-0.032095179,
-0.0052662212,
0.0169444624,
-0.0109570362,
0.0001116525,
-0.0268226601,
0.0060506086,
0.0625009909,
0.0408487916,
-0.0040781675,
0.0320538916,
0.0049457927,
0.0511177108,
-0.0424084775,
0.0050632576,
0.010484702,
-0.0001092431,
-0.0024212485,
0.0603321008,
-0.0606916025,
-0.0537041053,
0.00104679,
-0.0639349148,
0.010975101,
-0.0091317669,
0.0320692919,
0.0287422165,
-0.0556594245,
0.0223172419,
0.0193039961,
-0.0327730328,
-0.0170585904,
-0.0083078407,
-0.0106394738,
0.0326356776,
-0.0057944194,
0.0536839031,
-0.0403502621,
-0.0329137221,
-0.0206806399,
0.0591354296,
0.0035448547,
0.0278430525,
0.0121043008,
0.0050108042,
-0.0209291559,
0.0076922793,
-0.0313205011,
0.0204420537,
0.0311839748,
0.0158019979,
0.0431786068,
0.0669324845,
0.0454089716,
0.0262223501,
0.0345430709,
-0.0311432481,
-0.0609656312,
-0.0280897859,
0.004689178,
0.043594081,
0.0031281549,
-0.0177992042,
0.016722383,
0.0624444745,
0.0036022742,
0.0087814415,
-0.0195370279,
0.0719670355,
-0.0228260253,
0.0188667551,
-0.017262293,
-0.0274669696,
-0.0102267517,
0.0378324352,
-0.0395023376,
0.0121613499,
0.0479580984,
-0.0259122439,
0.0634955689,
-0.0531840995,
-0.0295025017,
-0.0336184651,
0.0429428555,
-0.0156022618,
-0.0012676531,
0.0108487587,
0.0030692776,
-0.0167144947,
-0.044343967,
0.0818541795,
-0.0417747721,
0.062499322,
-0.0563574098,
-0.0011977006,
-0.0275613479,
-0.008937425,
0.0051509426,
-0.0223702025,
-0.0410845876,
-0.0067961621,
0.0183394589,
-0.0082434993,
-0.0505864769,
-0.0471433215,
0.018003514,
0.0325310715,
-0.0051142424,
0.0051386184,
0.0119535625,
0.0459001511,
0.0166313108,
0.015313766,
0.0564779378,
-0.0222087651,
0.0469877571,
0.0889670849,
-0.0079453848,
-0.0225101747,
-0.0401346609,
-0.0502904728,
-0.0380641259,
-0.044076141,
0.0038985463,
-0.0306385811,
0.0470176563,
-0.0557478368,
0.0419550017,
0.0724673942,
0.0211734679,
-0.0009263385,
-0.0165655389,
-0.0424422137,
0.0278986841,
-0.0116674928,
-0.0237838048,
-0.1112008989,
-0.0179317817,
-0.0248658285,
0.0256090518,
-0.0384893492,
-0.0513231046,
0.0090250205,
-0.0850309134,
0.0312449038,
0.0214807875,
0.0151477093,
0.0131217372,
-0.0288285874,
0.0060641048,
-0.0430471934,
-0.0337889418,
0.0058562658,
-0.001891537,
0.0195112843,
0.0323862582,
-0.0375921391,
0.0416708775,
-0.0001470914,
-0.0184622351,
0.0192959607,
-0.0407291017,
0.0668674409,
0.0002332442,
-0.0041223471,
0.0464837514,
-0.0503868945,
-0.077748917,
0.0083656386,
0.0401815102,
0.0210027937,
-0.0031964446,
-0.0275692921,
0.0684347078,
-0.0069203014,
-0.0731704906,
0.0548010878,
0.0244931523,
-0.002280094,
-0.0216039233,
-0.0219740663,
0.0293977372,
-0.0365001634,
0.0559045225,
0.0466965586,
0.0358340703,
-0.0406305231,
-0.0710403621,
-0.0029966668,
-0.0626765937,
-0.0135556189,
-0.0422818139,
0.0243002065,
0.0429286137,
-0.0595765039,
-0.0246543083,
0.0004296697,
-0.0013495549,
-0.0264864471,
-0.0306671392,
0.0120489625,
0.0133108394,
-0.0641791075,
0.0441557355,
-0.0174005926,
-0.0052019032,
-0.0014932166,
-0.0145387333,
0.0031992351,
0.0111888181,
-0.0479056947,
0.0652754754,
0.0018042091,
-0.067947045,
-0.0174286123,
0.0144934813,
0.018627068,
0.0436655022,
0.0204660837,
-0.0280975569,
0.0358383805,
-0.0139139965,
0.0526445247,
-0.0283128899,
0.0556919873,
0.0052083977,
0.0084470287,
-0.0070652412,
0.0213664584,
0.044788681,
-0.0105693527,
0.0098824566,
-0.062409278,
0.014712886,
-0.0118081411,
0.0273632687,
0.0376663804,
0.0400788039,
-0.0793989152,
-0.0518341549,
-0.0088623073,
-0.0666144118,
-0.0313490182,
-0.0218701847,
0.0469299406,
-0.0222282708,
-0.0405817814,
-0.0109025482,
0.017210409,
-0.0158033073,
0.0332950205,
0.0007829735,
0.0678058937,
-0.0031723541,
0.0179028641,
-0.0185555257,
-0.0247603133,
-0.0463704839,
0.02543303,
-0.0381088443,
0.0655621365,
-0.005530789,
0.0272712409,
0.0265738629,
-0.005870671,
0.057506714,
-0.006830073,
-0.0646978021,
-0.0163062885,
-0.0145765254,
-0.0265259929,
-0.0090703499,
-0.028148748,
0.0760283619,
-0.0057259789,
-0.0121535743,
-0.000999281,
0.0376348384,
0.0098974733,
-0.0158423986,
0.0059861648,
0.0304670427,
-0.0273224805,
0.0159529801,
0.0568381064,
-0.0478365198,
0.0105703231,
0.0319080241,
-0.0167695992,
-0.031872198,
-0.0573395453,
-0.0286054723,
0.0546016023,
0.0126939295,
-0.0350421891,
-0.0196534004,
0.0074940752,
-0.0355544314,
0.037075799,
0.0235359333,
0.0254625529,
0.014237579,
0.0161439944,
0.0034388788,
-0.0014053144,
-0.037721619,
0.0281218793,
-0.0196558218,
-0.0045298068,
0.0015203024,
-5.708340525e-33,
-0.0015147056,
-0.0170196574,
-0.0247676522,
0.0449026003,
-0.0228618626,
0.0062770867,
-0.060255032,
0.0218504611,
-0.0211103559,
0.0657172799,
0.0291722212,
0.0590536594,
0.0102359019,
0.0360803604,
0.0133668464,
-0.0041848221,
0.0145668099,
0.0053926934,
-0.0323266238,
0.0358904004,
0.0472101644,
-0.049751889,
0.0225638375,
-0.0651138127,
0.0472898707,
0.0027150847,
-0.0031659503,
-0.0060322196,
-0.008158749,
0.0406249277,
0.0021986312,
0.054512661,
0.0119339731,
-0.0549250357,
-0.0065666493,
0.0190421976,
-0.0727356598,
-0.0284065548,
0.0181911513,
-0.0645613521,
-0.0401644409,
-0.0559858903,
0.0130776502,
0.0290147886,
0.0121600106,
-0.0700250641,
0.0329869427,
-0.047893282,
0.0118260421,
-0.0274493694,
-0.0226349924,
0.0745193288,
-0.0617696494,
0.0031171758,
0.015295553,
0.02019177,
0.0253239926,
0.0458130985,
-0.0602927096,
0.05522177,
0.0059887036,
0.0077479947,
-0.0031459739,
-0.0508634113,
0.0024050639,
0.0754626319,
-0.0034805355,
0.003043381,
-0.0361166075,
0.031642016,
-0.0407132357,
0.0458373278,
0.0649847835,
0.0593380965,
0.0403313488,
0.0240573548,
-0.0774168149,
-0.0103497719,
0.0245079268,
0.023496177,
-0.0029102182,
-0.0344825685,
0.0111587746,
-0.0042517106,
-0.0502236038,
-0.0752683654,
0.0174903963,
0.0086352434,
-0.0448956527,
-0.0116438828,
-0.0476254337,
0.0076527069,
-0.0072470685,
-0.0264208727,
0.0190887004,
0.0237075333,
-0.000310308,
0.007497876,
-0.0035884199,
0.0094894692,
-0.0555661693,
0.0176479258,
0.0004733472,
0.0173478033,
0.0430557057,
-0.0113093182,
0.0367566496,
-0.0503107384,
-0.0363327377,
0.0041256393,
0.0003494152,
0.0200563762,
-0.0510968678,
0.0484980047,
-0.0110446298,
0.0469075814,
0.0301756337,
0.0229137335,
0.0018265353,
0.0042148428,
-0.0207870044,
-0.03422774,
0.0034731193,
-0.0101626059,
0.0025041867,
-0.0029418392,
0.0000269769,
0.0224596113,
0.0466361754,
-0.0434990712,
0.0021758468,
-0.0191445909,
2.355e-7,
0.0528771132,
0.054170277,
0.0201659147,
-0.0112383142,
-0.0127180498,
0.0234341696,
0.0149139538,
0.0056230729,
0.0294705443,
-0.0512423404,
-0.022734819,
0.0459120199,
0.0631909668,
0.0556123145,
-0.074351117,
-0.0945200399,
-0.0844098181,
-0.0692475364,
-0.0462933183,
-0.0059213215,
0.0788865983,
0.0374838524,
0.0014621944,
0.0108069256,
-0.0297688898,
0.0338240527,
0.0407231525,
-0.0141141415,
0.0009150149,
0.0050809453,
0.0568053722,
-0.0677284896,
0.0176973343,
-0.0135374526,
-0.028397318,
0.0177255217,
-0.0117673725,
0.0380805843,
0.0418576486,
-0.0157538336,
-0.0070661022,
-0.0330856927,
0.0260120854,
-0.0261491202,
0.0428011306,
-0.0864370614,
-0.0377965122,
-0.0229967199,
-0.0868720114,
-0.0132416813,
0.0053918073,
0.0067585944,
-0.0150875868,
0.0107785864,
-0.0225389823,
-0.0100905281,
0.0411794707,
-0.0876930207,
-0.0376331098,
0.0240129642,
-0.0166847575,
-0.0166429803,
0.0154943597,
-0.0050445073,
0.0157578886,
-0.0455909371,
0.0157140251,
1.921426561e-34,
0.0726394728,
-0.0102268271,
-0.0073418822,
-0.019004615,
0.0729821175,
-0.0116162635,
0.0189715493,
-0.0448912755,
0.0215676688,
-0.0540801585,
0.0012912569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14654v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14654v1 | Major Entity Identification: A Generalizable Alternative to Coreference Resolution | 2024-06-20T18:17:58 | 2024-06-20T18:17:58 | Kawshik Manikantan, Shubham Toshniwal, Makarand Tapaswi, Vineet Gandhi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | The limited generalization of coreference resolution (CR) models has been a
major bottleneck in the task's broad application. Prior work has identified
annotation differences, especially for mention detection, as one of the main
reasons for the generalization gap and proposed using additional annotated
target domain data. Rather than relying on this additional annotation, we
propose an alternative formulation of the CR task, Major Entity Identification
(MEI), where we: (a) assume the target entities to be specified in the input,
and (b) limit the task to only the frequent entities. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate that MEI models generalize well across domains on
multiple datasets with supervised models and LLM-based few-shot prompting.
Additionally, the MEI task fits the classification framework, which enables the
use of classification-based metrics that are more robust than the current CR
metrics. Finally, MEI is also of practical use as it allows a user to search
for all mentions of a particular entity or a group of entities of interest. | [
0.0669427291,
-0.0530151911,
0.0168120898,
-0.0037243599,
0.0039619361,
0.0498672388,
-0.0115923798,
-0.0116476035,
0.0761573315,
-0.0520005524,
-0.0109135443,
0.013276957,
-0.045426961,
-0.0321300253,
0.0079296017,
0.000803625,
0.0552140474,
0.0029645527,
0.0244486611,
0.0201358683,
0.0147087984,
-0.00475585,
-0.0197438858,
0.012525076,
-0.0158656854,
-0.0081732338,
-0.0073831864,
0.0038056029,
0.056159012,
-0.0270510968,
0.0279282928,
0.0495711565,
-0.0128815668,
0.04285115,
0.0000017605,
-0.055687774,
-0.0325403586,
0.0011309827,
-0.035079021,
0.0024472491,
0.012502782,
0.0200792719,
0.0297320914,
-0.0210404824,
0.0135677885,
-0.0329414681,
0.0286607128,
0.064496547,
0.0276800096,
0.0388716981,
-0.0076267365,
-0.0041162199,
0.0109621258,
-0.0134670958,
-0.0599920861,
-0.0738750696,
0.0450725108,
0.0112819802,
0.0127034895,
0.0242732633,
0.0362896398,
0.0364506319,
-0.0329044946,
0.0227625724,
0.0527018085,
0.0259290896,
-0.0401176028,
0.0040307841,
0.0194887649,
0.0892344937,
0.0500701331,
0.0300680455,
0.0684575811,
0.0247944109,
0.0125477314,
-0.0048130015,
-0.0381124504,
-0.0278380606,
-0.048809547,
-0.0265600011,
0.0058634765,
0.0078651607,
-0.0016802262,
-0.0036907548,
-0.014319622,
0.0068530063,
-0.0086570745,
-0.0116751241,
0.0537988655,
0.0314828269,
-0.0414788127,
-0.0796554089,
0.0697139576,
0.00816363,
-0.0179001391,
0.0103151612,
-0.0130457496,
0.019118445,
0.0173007939,
-0.0731995627,
-0.0209119357,
-0.0201123655,
-0.049431745,
0.0628418177,
-0.0352558345,
0.0104364948,
-0.0253161117,
-0.0214260817,
0.0229148231,
-0.0477310605,
-0.0606519803,
0.0298510771,
-0.0030241993,
0.0926303938,
-0.0335480459,
-0.0019913821,
-0.0590154268,
0.0085662045,
-0.0125806555,
0.0183035005,
-0.0432593264,
-0.0237116851,
-0.0065155625,
0.0178576615,
-0.0224934537,
0.0174057707,
-0.0482975245,
-0.0006004366,
-0.0379287489,
-0.0279890504,
0.0102834608,
-0.0079959398,
0.0284989625,
-0.0330067612,
0.002956647,
0.0422179401,
0.0268273111,
-0.0770564154,
-0.0460149273,
-0.0318611935,
-0.0239350665,
-0.0335641913,
-0.0117138634,
-0.043452058,
0.0071989843,
0.0237056538,
-0.0055100229,
-0.0631782115,
0.036903996,
0.0078817783,
-0.0532813556,
0.0299240779,
-0.0136462897,
-0.0003169999,
0.0482981056,
-0.0014497895,
0.0334649198,
0.0479859076,
-0.0077889729,
0.0335045867,
0.046329394,
0.0391801149,
-0.0017115581,
0.0509956405,
0.0248523466,
0.0117821237,
0.0730638579,
0.0147063155,
-0.0618651062,
-0.0043043238,
0.0203852374,
0.0454055853,
0.0071838018,
-0.0328670703,
0.0279004183,
0.0527227782,
-0.0437976867,
-0.0251152832,
0.0211287718,
-0.0000865559,
0.0051717665,
0.049392391,
-0.0375265628,
0.0183722824,
-0.0201201756,
-0.0201817378,
0.0551734902,
0.0055717356,
-0.028425483,
-0.0121357022,
-0.0174265765,
0.0132847941,
-0.0489586182,
0.035817869,
0.0771965981,
-0.0114409961,
-0.0330660716,
0.0352833234,
0.0319418684,
-0.0255468562,
-0.0180117376,
-0.0033292051,
0.0007448648,
0.0051982338,
0.031730067,
-0.0200847555,
-0.0329261087,
-0.0360805169,
0.0484665334,
0.0527303033,
0.013207091,
-0.0390591174,
0.0273568053,
-0.008447974,
-0.0208370276,
0.0533752181,
0.0097995857,
0.0299130138,
0.0545320325,
-0.020866815,
0.032456886,
-0.049533613,
-0.0223468766,
0.0163397864,
-0.0105556231,
-0.0211947355,
0.0116025982,
0.0403016135,
0.0051428247,
0.0704358742,
0.0009476467,
-0.0375472605,
0.0307210982,
0.0022914193,
0.002860121,
-0.0194442179,
0.0339418799,
-0.0010905518,
0.0200470518,
-0.0298359394,
-0.0371597447,
-0.0354054756,
0.0012976002,
-0.0281018987,
-0.0468145274,
-0.0153288133,
0.0469271205,
-0.0090061584,
0.0040563405,
0.0092812506,
-0.0111446204,
-0.0618562512,
0.0903994218,
0.0010284398,
0.0223694667,
0.067857638,
-0.0343137234,
0.0130492961,
-0.0703522339,
-0.0569239333,
-0.0293011367,
-0.0213735383,
-0.0262850672,
0.0551515259,
-0.043219924,
-0.0632469952,
-0.0005405203,
-0.0797285289,
0.0006422314,
0.0044545112,
0.0297680404,
-0.0138612026,
0.0243330114,
-0.0172787048,
-0.0190957002,
0.0133641092,
-0.014604154,
-0.0191055257,
0.0262426473,
0.0287999585,
0.033725176,
-0.0331827402,
-0.0409653224,
0.010427299,
-0.0432193764,
0.0085186027,
0.0303321294,
-0.0757654458,
-0.0145794805,
0.0713701472,
-0.0283677951,
0.0202855691,
0.0154112689,
0.0300673619,
-0.0108710984,
0.0347213782,
0.0160130281,
0.0391071439,
-0.0341744386,
0.0477105677,
-0.0395344421,
-0.0621819571,
-0.0789748877,
0.0312731788,
-0.0144574679,
-0.0174936783,
-0.0064034639,
-0.0472670794,
0.0674109608,
0.0579907857,
-0.0058496827,
-0.0076444782,
-0.0330164582,
-0.0213251039,
-0.0086924341,
0.0017841859,
0.0000664715,
0.0319491439,
-0.0126168216,
0.0376377292,
-0.0060581183,
0.0099020079,
0.0547581688,
-0.0398850851,
0.0001731394,
0.014573602,
-0.0215059295,
-0.0406115614,
0.0264344383,
0.0051178825,
-0.0022055604,
0.1058813557,
-0.0894644111,
0.0052965591,
0.0441868454,
-0.0081323143,
-0.0258514993,
0.0779714733,
0.0153626613,
0.0457755774,
-0.0017523221,
0.0008294297,
-0.0529134721,
0.0195494443,
-0.0468720235,
-0.0239786524,
-0.0334796198,
0.0101344548,
-0.0305612087,
0.0331336148,
0.015929915,
0.0017826669,
-0.001924769,
-0.0074053276,
-0.0310991984,
0.0415557288,
0.0245023649,
-0.0219421051,
0.0016611569,
0.0048631923,
-0.0014003806,
0.0290315114,
0.0019118669,
-0.020557439,
0.0065735946,
-0.0518015735,
0.0246548634,
-0.1060303673,
-0.0215700436,
-0.0112149501,
0.0565628335,
-0.0068698474,
-0.005567065,
0.1175049692,
0.033933118,
-0.0334348604,
-0.0316651091,
0.0349247605,
-0.0167103559,
0.0383500531,
0.0256545711,
-0.0463625938,
-0.037117552,
0.0207909141,
0.0150892958,
0.0071091861,
-0.0837748051,
0.0152738579,
-0.0858261436,
0.0146751897,
-0.0327233709,
-0.0474086851,
-0.0410919785,
-0.0456504114,
0.060190808,
-0.0274971891,
-0.0366256461,
-0.0079011926,
-0.0384705998,
0.0262049753,
0.0216993354,
-0.0091330428,
-0.0180674437,
0.0410188325,
-0.0769351795,
0.023188008,
0.0608778745,
0.0225137062,
0.0100250337,
0.0612800159,
-0.0139835849,
-0.0116126891,
-0.0162383839,
-0.0213951394,
0.075939782,
-0.0513124354,
-0.0055826078,
-0.0296373125,
0.0046227784,
0.0334940776,
0.0063018654,
0.040061783,
0.0214046817,
0.0233220179,
0.0466103852,
-0.0318933949,
0.0130120739,
0.0026009951,
0.0738973171,
0.028672656,
0.0022321842,
0.026449861,
-0.0310154054,
0.0310464259,
-0.0361784622,
-0.0181349907,
-0.0074421852,
-0.0656348765,
-0.0069118058,
-0.063632898,
-0.0255834945,
0.0551277772,
0.0056092273,
0.0363314413,
0.0345391147,
0.0234240387,
0.0311638527,
-0.0496418476,
0.0074886526,
-0.0685480535,
0.0068391026,
-0.0892580226,
0.0063858335,
0.0828993097,
0.0301210843,
-0.0523291193,
0.0706332475,
-0.0708392262,
-0.0436532982,
-0.0268938262,
-0.0213625059,
0.0111096893,
0.0103679541,
-0.0185275003,
-0.041106645,
-0.0175691415,
0.0286104213,
-0.0246364903,
0.0074188025,
0.0114231603,
0.0032364244,
-0.0305148121,
0.0297172945,
-0.0833086893,
0.0438581929,
0.0175153036,
0.0265915301,
-0.042333506,
-0.0530964024,
0.0080368826,
0.0363866165,
0.0368917361,
0.0112399096,
-0.0026467361,
-0.0346575342,
0.0028144447,
0.0355854221,
-0.0073941112,
-0.0007430759,
0.0136855692,
-0.0236933157,
0.0139604304,
-0.002017186,
0.0275830273,
-0.0280292425,
0.0824436024,
-0.0562044494,
-0.008132509,
-0.0092008375,
-0.0132353809,
-0.0176519547,
-0.0215940643,
-0.0208062157,
0.0388244651,
0.0660570785,
0.0520682968,
-0.0279843193,
0.0113792941,
-0.023105355,
0.0071670054,
0.014745852,
-0.044530239,
-0.0481964238,
0.0437580459,
-0.0512348376,
0.0575899146,
0.0768575221,
-0.0094303172,
0.0478514917,
0.0037889504,
-0.0158901438,
-0.0199940875,
0.0128652444,
-0.039946299,
0.0050859367,
-0.008204544,
0.0185805932,
-0.0081486059,
0.0268619098,
0.066347152,
0.0250518546,
0.0333700143,
0.0249702185,
-0.0342768393,
-0.0635882318,
-0.026484184,
-0.0050724386,
0.0034237532,
0.007009116,
0.0234004986,
-0.048603259,
-0.0221128818,
0.0758617818,
-0.0621034727,
-0.035194438,
-0.0114731509,
0.0157616492,
0.0088639949,
0.0319513381,
-0.0318414606,
-0.0540309288,
0.0050219307,
0.0136948163,
-0.0339063741,
-0.0113971988,
-5.646433482e-33,
-0.083652176,
-0.0488708802,
-0.0020892809,
0.0130236503,
0.0095756594,
0.0268557537,
-0.0146202762,
0.0054486976,
-0.0150282066,
-0.0294169076,
-0.0147721684,
-0.0061755627,
0.0276160017,
-0.0145747503,
-0.0146706589,
-0.0139833894,
0.0626331046,
0.0255312566,
-0.0078501562,
0.0260258373,
0.0303177182,
0.046630796,
0.0735230297,
-0.0886969417,
0.0732507035,
-0.004568256,
-0.0085821664,
0.0021711411,
0.060470853,
0.0588855632,
-0.0187656395,
0.0088712107,
0.0046895384,
-0.0366713218,
0.0065291557,
0.0122947767,
-0.1447764635,
-0.0108309016,
0.0206863191,
0.0240014289,
0.0583241284,
-0.0576680265,
0.0208735429,
-0.0161625948,
0.0101987524,
-0.0109809898,
0.0674974173,
-0.0224624481,
-0.0231141653,
-0.0464975275,
-0.0299293529,
0.0471992902,
-0.0177538712,
0.0226459187,
0.0358178429,
0.0485909618,
0.0276923161,
0.0129301045,
-0.0428798385,
0.0306223724,
0.0336046852,
-0.0110361287,
0.0100656012,
-0.0048637856,
-0.0129018826,
0.0248936079,
0.0192258358,
-0.0290680546,
-0.0292012356,
-0.0052900631,
-0.0071162558,
0.0126817282,
-0.0318720601,
0.1055204123,
0.0002714098,
0.0127525162,
-0.0535773672,
0.0462589711,
0.0235505961,
-0.0061441432,
0.0229969993,
-0.0105215339,
-0.080418095,
-0.0056152986,
-0.020573603,
-0.0189581104,
-0.0322313011,
-0.0264192577,
0.0333276726,
0.0007030871,
-0.0467630774,
0.0542553551,
0.0263429601,
-0.0346259773,
-0.0545918755,
0.0055995998,
0.0541743636,
0.0359898321,
0.0115238437,
-0.0115807559,
-0.0561150722,
-0.0144812549,
0.0049345284,
-0.0051263645,
0.0303668957,
-0.0052223634,
0.0261519719,
-0.0566608645,
-0.0593187176,
-0.0099730212,
0.0233517718,
0.0140200453,
-0.0650416762,
-0.0062730927,
-0.0111274291,
-0.0011303005,
0.0128240064,
0.0343710817,
0.0448028259,
0.0010644222,
-0.0441783555,
-0.0103869801,
0.0342662409,
0.0354669876,
-0.0066103474,
-0.0056028026,
0.0231206324,
0.0152032627,
0.0027986306,
-0.0284510907,
0.0019680557,
-0.0062829494,
2.403e-7,
0.005816794,
0.0259895846,
0.0402713418,
0.0042265793,
-0.038233351,
0.0156056508,
0.0318684317,
0.0209798589,
0.0172825214,
-0.0203284286,
0.0008961045,
-0.0157430694,
0.0027619593,
0.0287421327,
-0.1364836693,
-0.0307786297,
-0.0205973759,
-0.0001317974,
-0.0516517721,
0.0098110512,
-0.022619281,
0.0345372893,
0.0208724346,
0.0200588088,
-0.0429570116,
-0.0299838353,
0.0414553024,
-0.0290005002,
0.0007512448,
0.0430161692,
0.000695859,
0.0747449547,
-0.0284655131,
0.032330256,
0.0088531906,
0.0270059612,
0.0648700073,
0.0676737428,
0.0324030779,
-0.0126272347,
-0.0337158479,
-0.031529665,
0.0398685634,
0.0088344887,
0.0467741787,
-0.0504630767,
0.0080450531,
-0.0342025273,
-0.0034225055,
-0.0140914181,
-0.0351830684,
0.0250414554,
-0.0011715045,
0.0314159319,
-0.0179914739,
-0.016477596,
-0.0319751725,
-0.0640771687,
0.0241755787,
0.0183277279,
-0.0051641497,
-0.0279419236,
-0.0113359252,
-0.0650557727,
-0.0486650616,
-0.0426524617,
-0.0081869736,
2.114033607e-34,
-0.0148853948,
0.0211600959,
-0.0142394053,
0.0666924492,
0.0180885587,
-0.0158346221,
-0.0873667449,
-0.0007323345,
-0.006732374,
-0.0262614582,
0.0075608972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19415v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19415v1 | An Analysis of Multilingual FActScore | 2024-06-20T18:09:40 | 2024-06-20T18:09:40 | Kim Trong Vu, Michael Krumdick, Varshini Reddy, Franck Dernoncourt, Viet Dac Lai | cs.CL | cs.CL | FActScore has gained popularity as a metric to estimate the factuality of
long-form texts generated by Large Language Models (LLMs) in English. However,
there has not been any work in studying the behavior of FActScore in other
languages. This paper studies the limitations of each component in the
four-component pipeline of FActScore in the multilingual setting. We introduce
a new dataset for FActScore on texts generated by strong multilingual LLMs. Our
evaluation shows that LLMs exhibit distinct behaviors in both fact extraction
and fact scoring tasks. No LLM produces consistent and reliable FActScore
across languages with varying levels of resources. We also find that the
knowledge source plays an important role in the quality of the estimated
FActScore. Using Wikipedia as the knowledge source may hinder the true
FActScore of long-form text due to its limited coverage in medium- and
low-resource languages. We also incorporate three mitigations to our knowledge
source that ultimately improve FActScore estimation across all languages. | [
0.0012596871,
0.0226290077,
0.0003667811,
0.0497051328,
-0.0639655441,
0.0095294733,
0.0256252699,
-0.0303566735,
0.003660361,
-0.0542196892,
0.041881524,
-0.0698250383,
0.0360364281,
0.0228095166,
0.0002252885,
0.0237272549,
0.0243043639,
-0.0206343289,
0.0522156395,
-0.0301775672,
0.003670678,
0.0276746042,
0.0009335931,
0.0087240124,
-0.0592292137,
-0.0099317804,
0.029162202,
-0.0548390932,
0.0170923062,
-0.0104039414,
0.0026526798,
0.022124026,
-0.0131851742,
0.0014256143,
0.000001898,
-0.0755254328,
0.0072856136,
0.0120866131,
-0.0175970923,
0.0545929149,
0.0215939954,
-0.0005152533,
-0.0174984075,
-0.0321400687,
-0.0109724253,
-0.0281106457,
0.0074086776,
0.0657571778,
0.0193232186,
0.0566430315,
0.00903136,
-0.041464489,
0.0358271226,
0.0033623048,
-0.0112192594,
0.0228087716,
0.0289812516,
0.0530907772,
-0.0507392809,
0.002542004,
-0.0139784124,
0.0348945633,
0.0308626927,
-0.0211258195,
-0.0338052176,
0.0436328016,
-0.0162479468,
-0.0356125794,
0.0530331656,
0.0389603786,
0.0218426138,
-0.0088636205,
0.00722815,
-0.0012511271,
0.0051314821,
0.0288602021,
-0.0378478542,
0.053570006,
-0.0344761759,
-0.0004169164,
0.0669938773,
-0.0295289233,
0.0338269062,
0.008713223,
-0.0151003506,
0.0692161992,
0.0157154296,
-0.0269317273,
0.0011414055,
0.0163226631,
-0.0322702564,
-0.0514808409,
0.0077403835,
0.0003356388,
0.0115888081,
0.0086640893,
-0.0102833798,
0.0105436957,
0.0376565605,
-0.1104683056,
-0.0403850749,
-0.0033215582,
-0.0618367456,
0.0630695075,
-0.0010162395,
0.0364558436,
0.0058495235,
-0.0222524721,
-0.0075519076,
-0.0018274462,
-0.0114462376,
0.0261700265,
0.0467557795,
0.0177916996,
0.0053697363,
0.0117407274,
-0.0419993773,
-0.028615009,
-0.0075812452,
0.0386417173,
0.006772426,
-0.0488908775,
-0.0024513241,
-0.006199975,
-0.0614433363,
0.0776994601,
-0.0383438133,
0.004637803,
-0.0288065244,
-0.0196811836,
0.0118176108,
-0.0063973898,
-0.0054923929,
-0.0154427486,
0.019342931,
0.0033765752,
-0.0027665643,
0.006499629,
-0.0433285162,
-0.0142319035,
-0.0191896167,
-0.0998042822,
-0.0145711228,
-0.1155946106,
0.0206839815,
0.0424236953,
-0.0020307961,
-0.0392075069,
0.0197428744,
0.0134937,
-0.0191228501,
0.0140177188,
-0.0038472537,
-0.0004241417,
0.0216554888,
-0.0076587922,
0.0315330364,
0.0937973931,
0.0223320015,
0.0057901805,
0.0780467167,
0.0174496882,
-0.0170007907,
0.0277892351,
0.023736516,
0.0317685269,
0.0382260606,
0.0076963417,
0.0490679517,
-0.0054891179,
0.0094889812,
0.0239693206,
-0.0008685431,
0.0081193252,
0.0638411865,
-0.0084669562,
0.0243469793,
0.0076853381,
0.0353626311,
-0.0028935475,
0.0393961556,
0.0420765989,
-0.0257242434,
0.0000175192,
0.0099165766,
0.0394229479,
0.0054537486,
0.1051696762,
-0.0002147419,
-0.0517689697,
-0.0155938482,
-0.0130143734,
-0.0375250615,
-0.0046288357,
0.0626499057,
-0.0217888635,
0.0055777933,
0.0847090557,
0.0369242802,
-0.0359900221,
0.0442127362,
-0.0030623688,
0.0381794348,
0.0326155014,
0.021848008,
-0.0255938582,
0.0019654885,
-0.0060522826,
0.0305207632,
0.0319352597,
0.0368579961,
-0.0330719128,
0.0032585883,
-0.0307924785,
0.0091265477,
-0.0317937993,
0.0270221531,
-0.000611569,
0.0060003325,
0.0323907658,
0.0162446871,
-0.0592994131,
-0.0371136926,
0.0134163788,
-0.0367558375,
0.0284278151,
-0.0128413532,
-0.0034203141,
-0.0064376253,
0.0222421736,
-0.0240621511,
-0.0080939848,
0.0048852875,
-0.017530201,
0.0036148475,
-0.0046080151,
0.0239195991,
-0.0333657227,
0.0951155052,
0.0069364021,
-0.0265807863,
0.0092021348,
0.0030993854,
-0.0102284802,
-0.030358417,
-0.0323584229,
0.0047823191,
-0.0083576962,
0.03478387,
-0.0052566221,
0.0166791193,
0.0189085826,
0.0968477577,
-0.026282629,
0.0401344337,
-0.0162170008,
-0.0637032315,
0.0208202954,
-0.0219193809,
-0.0148911774,
0.0517768674,
0.013257171,
0.0051015834,
0.0524908789,
-0.0060868911,
-0.0219028834,
0.0043465672,
-0.0615701638,
0.0301566795,
-0.0292586256,
0.0116442032,
0.0190558936,
-0.0254835114,
-0.0070974641,
0.0525722913,
-0.0232085474,
-0.0606666729,
-0.0033119658,
0.0196123328,
0.01317228,
0.0054555614,
0.0007875916,
-0.0219576154,
-0.0179525763,
-0.0122803347,
0.0499704294,
0.028691737,
0.0056603104,
-0.0274710041,
0.0282561872,
-0.0868939087,
-0.0185954105,
-0.0291514397,
-0.0128898947,
-0.0029465272,
0.0027893125,
0.0845129564,
0.0446327999,
0.0076680183,
-0.0061013098,
0.0768953934,
-0.0466375686,
-0.029962007,
0.0026858042,
-0.0294581708,
0.0318488479,
-0.0338537656,
-0.0606938638,
0.0021947336,
0.0012525207,
0.0184528716,
-0.0076611512,
-0.0095698787,
0.0232680626,
-0.0493897498,
-0.0166210867,
-0.0309693851,
0.0384457223,
0.0086899679,
0.0530170575,
-0.006407565,
-0.0215089917,
0.0689213052,
-0.0453938916,
0.0241557267,
-0.0273309369,
-0.0070657493,
-0.0176465046,
0.0361101702,
0.0095874425,
0.004127081,
-0.0505233221,
0.0274225343,
0.0019327614,
0.0175190493,
0.0585931055,
-0.046248503,
0.0825020596,
-0.0382620506,
-0.0141537311,
-0.0055290307,
-0.0275117811,
-0.0073428676,
-0.037268281,
-0.0005520147,
-0.0152068315,
0.0035517793,
-0.0357713997,
-0.0348563865,
-0.0166758783,
0.0993434116,
0.006900847,
-0.0222981554,
0.0140317772,
0.0236169994,
0.0127634788,
0.0472495258,
-0.0074026478,
0.0410949923,
-0.023888804,
0.0329325907,
0.0450229421,
-0.0273064319,
-0.0198542345,
0.0431167036,
-0.031515535,
0.0091127884,
-0.0218733214,
-0.0373416469,
0.0170266032,
0.046967987,
-0.0510534532,
-0.0106496895,
0.1189556122,
0.0139141651,
0.0282418132,
-0.0146943536,
-0.0232015587,
-0.0144862402,
0.01093488,
-0.015017828,
-0.0333534926,
0.0239419844,
-0.0085144509,
0.0047814134,
-0.0066000363,
-0.0086831516,
-0.0264630467,
-0.1065925956,
0.0137990257,
-0.0060672169,
-0.0202965736,
-0.0694403201,
-0.0752857476,
-0.0117199719,
-0.0305894893,
-0.0124121355,
0.0070409616,
0.0120209046,
0.0009343745,
-0.0120854471,
-0.0275524631,
-0.055365175,
0.0349452831,
-0.0376313739,
0.0183757078,
-0.011629995,
0.0523805842,
-0.0610438809,
-0.0093104541,
0.018339375,
-0.0017737844,
-0.0492736734,
-0.005912662,
0.04663058,
0.0085999575,
-0.006833612,
-0.0448318608,
0.0012935002,
0.0253730919,
-0.0274108797,
0.0184900258,
0.073540546,
0.0205604546,
-0.0143131865,
0.0074515417,
0.005073397,
-0.0164909679,
0.0858570933,
0.0017074678,
-0.022943072,
0.0090021007,
-0.0578722358,
-0.0386276469,
-0.0211884398,
-0.0663674772,
0.039593149,
-0.046619311,
-0.0506031439,
-0.0604111925,
-0.040671628,
0.011131227,
0.0200427603,
0.0038083158,
0.0067223059,
0.0360656306,
-0.0157314409,
-0.0072706514,
0.0019483392,
-0.0197388828,
0.0221980773,
-0.0207179375,
0.0096026091,
0.043873433,
-0.0117661059,
-0.0011177801,
0.015247196,
-0.0360032357,
-0.0596226119,
0.0148501918,
0.0016222084,
0.0139819011,
0.021696914,
-0.0081693036,
-0.0042473241,
0.0436623357,
0.0726943016,
-0.0618844628,
0.0139401034,
0.0098177157,
-0.018736504,
0.0149980709,
0.0119323721,
-0.034637019,
0.0065200576,
-0.0136925662,
0.0421712697,
-0.0318283401,
-0.0372998007,
0.0163684953,
0.0696745738,
0.0231730584,
-0.018097749,
-0.0220844783,
-0.0523022898,
-0.0173102133,
-0.0522793941,
-0.0426764674,
0.0130448909,
0.0340239219,
0.0193233732,
0.0147318095,
-0.019111488,
0.0714434534,
0.0253595971,
0.0083952928,
-0.0284070633,
-0.0048149754,
-0.0067452746,
0.0031594452,
0.0289529208,
-0.0396469682,
-0.0434011184,
-0.0286615752,
-0.0157859866,
0.0160602089,
-0.0202227011,
0.0346749388,
0.0054408833,
-0.0233488288,
0.0297962986,
-0.0199697446,
-0.0344729163,
0.0011721909,
-0.0404542834,
0.010170972,
0.0536441393,
-0.0243611205,
0.0706607997,
-0.0563279837,
-0.0175992083,
-0.0521605387,
0.0162506327,
0.0293318052,
-0.016746521,
0.0170030687,
-0.0019189112,
-0.0509527624,
0.0090707634,
0.0798178911,
0.000479439,
0.0236435067,
0.0214507971,
-0.027566921,
-0.0202632379,
-0.0676810145,
-0.0643885657,
-0.015470651,
-0.0160747208,
-0.0180474147,
-0.0887980461,
-0.0620257929,
0.0128266793,
0.0251006782,
0.0034324154,
-0.0252678152,
-0.0282437652,
0.0788084641,
-0.0080128694,
-0.026412027,
-0.0647371113,
0.0458993018,
-0.0266183782,
0.0201113969,
0.0065431995,
-5.985950414e-33,
-0.0297044199,
-0.0391263254,
0.0044253781,
0.0305003934,
0.0057688109,
0.0352108628,
-0.0025064016,
0.0064535076,
-0.0355018601,
0.0635780171,
0.0251439828,
0.0109525016,
0.0135205593,
-0.0273267459,
-0.0076193549,
-0.0272013918,
0.0284218471,
0.0164052043,
-0.0488117039,
0.0071661519,
0.0710284486,
-0.0233489312,
0.0920433849,
-0.0880286992,
0.0689889342,
-0.018827606,
0.0127434479,
0.0102993045,
0.005639967,
0.050262779,
-0.0018801454,
0.0664026886,
0.0319599025,
-0.1151995286,
-0.0018806058,
-0.0326564051,
-0.0471929312,
-0.0262293369,
0.083114177,
-0.0137812691,
0.0524130389,
-0.0223262273,
0.0187966973,
0.0228289887,
-0.0346569009,
-0.0166399982,
0.0683260858,
-0.0351987891,
-0.0088416915,
-0.0350371674,
-0.0513240211,
0.0343158655,
0.0129484963,
0.0216612611,
-0.0286928192,
0.0252322983,
0.0251305997,
-0.0208473057,
-0.0592823438,
0.0297052581,
0.0035431834,
0.0411069579,
0.0414291248,
-0.0388619415,
-0.0007258074,
0.0676502958,
-0.0452757105,
0.0237088986,
-0.0704635605,
0.0181869883,
0.0256094616,
0.0193390176,
0.036483895,
0.1339876652,
-0.0220888723,
-0.031272687,
-0.1007729247,
0.0293577127,
0.0192929618,
0.027069699,
0.0167901851,
-0.0580722801,
-0.0389399715,
-0.0367582887,
-0.0357743353,
0.0413878523,
-0.0102280695,
0.0043367557,
-0.0139357829,
-0.0248083342,
0.0068777986,
-0.0052608424,
0.011803396,
-0.0101604117,
-0.0194025114,
0.0836214945,
-0.0407025591,
0.0330717787,
-0.0114758629,
0.0133544756,
-0.0863307342,
0.0156130865,
-0.0337104797,
0.0134770647,
0.004363521,
0.0231895167,
0.0198026206,
-0.0107524907,
-0.0378116183,
0.0110441586,
-0.0365736112,
-0.0160306152,
0.0163711365,
-0.0166522283,
0.031164445,
-0.0039848923,
-0.034376163,
0.0181990806,
0.0508413874,
0.0237160958,
-0.0234338343,
-0.0497617163,
0.0190056432,
0.0242986418,
-0.0277013276,
-0.005186202,
-0.0498932824,
-0.0146746403,
0.0125484401,
-0.0342717916,
0.0020426156,
0.0030582396,
2.538e-7,
0.0233820099,
0.0454619378,
-0.0177907348,
0.0303406827,
-0.0005786687,
0.0400152206,
-0.0309113488,
0.0051679099,
0.0229370371,
-0.0694788471,
-0.0333968028,
0.0318463333,
0.0272362903,
0.0849078521,
-0.0717038065,
-0.0094043519,
-0.0453202613,
-0.041026298,
-0.0598731153,
-0.0040090894,
0.006183913,
0.0605986081,
0.0481391884,
0.0168477371,
-0.002558416,
-0.0435045101,
0.0543378964,
-0.0361723565,
-0.1151862815,
0.0269941036,
0.0975610614,
0.0182629693,
0.0107378289,
0.0090499744,
-0.020364305,
0.0101305731,
0.0294663571,
0.0623500124,
0.0572070591,
0.0255251043,
-0.0009054742,
-0.0438429043,
-0.0218045991,
-0.0390833244,
0.0673036054,
0.0426434018,
-0.0322051384,
-0.0499396846,
-0.007228741,
0.0187966544,
0.0055513661,
-0.0119779874,
-0.0148703037,
0.0174622368,
-0.0029108911,
-0.0083925528,
-0.0083943149,
-0.0040895445,
-0.0684679151,
0.0532659367,
-0.0131366467,
-0.1057626754,
0.0172954667,
-0.0369715989,
0.0225628149,
-0.0652534887,
0.0327631645,
2.19262849e-34,
0.0556480661,
-0.007951498,
-0.018872451,
-0.032400351,
0.0596431196,
-0.0071594985,
-0.0332559757,
-0.0323659852,
-0.0168941412,
-0.0402758308,
0.0067331945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14644v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14644v1 | Unveiling the Spectrum of Data Contamination in Language Models: A Survey from Detection to Remediation | 2024-06-20T18:07:26 | 2024-06-20T18:07:26 | Chunyuan Deng, Yilun Zhao, Yuzhao Heng, Yitong Li, Jiannan Cao, Xiangru Tang, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data contamination has garnered increased attention in the era of large
language models (LLMs) due to the reliance on extensive internet-derived
training corpora. The issue of training corpus overlap with evaluation
benchmarks--referred to as contamination--has been the focus of significant
recent research. This body of work aims to identify contamination, understand
its impacts, and explore mitigation strategies from diverse perspectives.
However, comprehensive studies that provide a clear pathway from foundational
concepts to advanced insights are lacking in this nascent field. Therefore, we
present a comprehensive survey in the field of data contamination, laying out
the key issues, methodologies, and findings to date, and highlighting areas in
need of further research and development. In particular, we begin by examining
the effects of data contamination across various stages and forms. We then
provide a detailed analysis of current contamination detection methods,
categorizing them to highlight their focus, assumptions, strengths, and
limitations. We also discuss mitigation strategies, offering a clear guide for
future research. This survey serves as a succinct overview of the most recent
advancements in data contamination research, providing a straightforward guide
for the benefit of future research endeavors. | [
0.053120397,
0.1048991084,
-0.0505419783,
0.0427717641,
-0.0249986555,
0.0110353567,
-0.020021325,
0.0141395787,
-0.0200925544,
-0.0608787723,
-0.0222624186,
-0.0376189537,
0.0358820409,
-0.0187373087,
0.0448697582,
-0.0246455874,
0.069164753,
-0.0178458542,
-0.0441833027,
-0.0130597316,
0.0118523659,
-0.0100662727,
0.0507344455,
0.0055642519,
-0.0141667472,
-0.0192437936,
0.0128565021,
-0.0158229917,
-0.0127403112,
-0.0001584041,
0.00455418,
0.0489051491,
-0.029328825,
0.058860179,
0.00000186,
-0.0459076576,
-0.0146533223,
0.0194803197,
-0.0451801717,
0.0493438318,
0.0359293297,
-0.0110481204,
-0.0182348639,
0.0368881039,
-0.0006047398,
-0.0065687899,
0.0395763852,
-0.0054537104,
0.0478367358,
0.0473147072,
-0.0028704037,
0.0290226601,
0.028796427,
0.0132998843,
-0.040093217,
0.0367606357,
0.0436431654,
0.0143744331,
0.0173712932,
-0.0058971518,
-0.0410936624,
0.0569435395,
-0.0321361944,
0.0043892269,
-0.0235761646,
-0.0055349991,
-0.0438243672,
-0.032393232,
0.0332007445,
0.0473363176,
0.001139328,
-0.0113284066,
0.0166274533,
0.003663891,
0.0079616895,
0.0365271904,
0.0017696422,
0.0517475642,
-0.0018264489,
0.0279826485,
-0.0079416949,
-0.0506424457,
0.0497387834,
0.0144775761,
-0.0329003446,
0.0454843603,
0.0326511264,
-0.0563532226,
0.0014778357,
0.0222543981,
-0.0229470022,
-0.050048247,
0.0017408939,
-0.0284708478,
-0.0080610663,
0.0560553484,
-0.0474007428,
-0.0637932047,
0.0366340578,
-0.0388526954,
0.0244433265,
0.0040431991,
-0.0393684283,
-0.0060585905,
0.0265271682,
0.0053008562,
-0.004889362,
-0.0059940955,
-0.0288740359,
0.013292836,
0.0031216606,
-0.0045764148,
-0.017245926,
0.0243902579,
0.0109788282,
0.0076435651,
-0.0186650474,
0.0421245396,
-0.047489997,
0.0015643772,
-0.0211999267,
-0.0092785731,
-0.0018940589,
0.0242622104,
-0.0209688228,
0.0013418103,
0.0041081826,
0.0390106849,
-0.039632611,
-0.0959589779,
-0.0008903714,
0.0112138866,
-0.0187610742,
-0.0461950973,
-0.000805889,
0.0386828519,
0.0406823941,
-0.023912333,
-0.0233708266,
-0.0330355056,
-0.0546626039,
-0.0358311869,
-0.0200072471,
-0.0329945385,
-0.0135368342,
0.0077069039,
0.0039038369,
-0.026771225,
-0.011377248,
0.0382567421,
-0.0901677608,
0.050875783,
-0.0736097023,
0.0318181328,
-0.0029034419,
-0.0079160575,
0.0046295524,
0.0642758682,
0.0364218093,
-0.0387398303,
0.0312038846,
-0.0221598707,
-0.0021940416,
0.0514058284,
0.0110602826,
0.0205944292,
-0.025436433,
-0.0234018434,
0.0097452933,
0.0147977024,
0.0156210298,
0.1027054638,
-0.0243758336,
-0.0008089335,
0.0675787255,
0.0098073957,
-0.0307044387,
-0.0124137513,
0.0012886095,
0.0276553743,
0.0441973209,
0.0557831973,
-0.0380742997,
-0.0981585011,
-0.0031242759,
0.0102955513,
0.0321332067,
0.0391440652,
0.001562177,
-0.0358269289,
-0.0592328198,
-0.0252944138,
0.0077856015,
0.0107319057,
0.0430463254,
-0.0013467321,
-0.0127248233,
0.0341678821,
0.0225047097,
-0.0566196777,
0.0550275259,
-0.0197686385,
0.0071549774,
0.0779993758,
0.058875706,
-0.0134076364,
-0.0228422713,
-0.0167015661,
-0.0063493517,
0.0063346797,
-0.0218225941,
-0.0361295789,
0.0261392035,
-0.0359522104,
-0.0272879452,
0.0216939393,
0.0240191054,
-0.0096185813,
0.0028824832,
-0.0015659002,
0.0067575052,
-0.0346003957,
-0.0404550582,
0.0490783229,
-0.0248178691,
0.0310597494,
-0.0200298838,
0.0067630983,
0.0324527919,
0.0272326507,
-0.0549435131,
-0.0063006277,
0.0131166205,
0.0144677097,
-0.0125313476,
0.0009548076,
-0.0083809402,
0.0283287335,
0.0573800951,
-0.0198966414,
0.0027382548,
0.0385271683,
0.0015406187,
-0.0267918818,
0.0000469174,
-0.0376554802,
0.0315884911,
-0.0204496197,
0.0609736741,
-0.0128313294,
0.0341118984,
-0.0499556214,
0.0282722414,
-0.0117977029,
0.0201309528,
0.0377034061,
0.001541822,
0.0508422777,
-0.0388988853,
-0.0745302141,
0.0120447297,
-0.0181469657,
0.0409363024,
0.0324836336,
-0.0388075374,
-0.0432553329,
-0.0097794849,
-0.0658634678,
-0.0277507566,
0.0014095582,
0.0358609967,
0.0122846933,
0.0023077035,
-0.0378150679,
0.0177434552,
0.0088939462,
-0.0476869754,
0.0237260051,
0.0632230714,
0.02669736,
-0.0110142278,
0.0090685887,
-0.022613978,
-0.0149186766,
-0.0197745804,
0.056939438,
-0.0266015809,
-0.0629781261,
-0.0728616714,
0.0771516487,
-0.0388288237,
0.0187903009,
0.0212490838,
-0.0124676805,
-0.0014068953,
0.0066964617,
-0.0092403693,
-0.0115768174,
-0.0012649012,
-0.0029250712,
0.070386976,
-0.0285699349,
-0.055178076,
-0.0407960303,
0.0271290932,
-0.01223798,
-0.0133769643,
-0.0371728092,
0.0106214089,
0.0318202376,
0.0005753529,
-0.0588092878,
-0.0131266862,
-0.0053389836,
-0.0818078443,
0.0006802826,
-0.0037358331,
-0.0561196432,
-0.0390495583,
0.0130893048,
-0.0179989655,
-0.0413562991,
0.0305477101,
-0.0296470858,
0.0460567661,
-0.0503115095,
0.0125941969,
0.0146251945,
-0.0203736648,
-0.0020699424,
0.0113200648,
0.0568438433,
-0.0684547797,
-0.0636285171,
0.0252392534,
0.0367812105,
-0.0552377924,
0.0362302363,
-0.0145606715,
0.0364616774,
0.018819632,
-0.0327604786,
-0.0330522843,
-0.0506916568,
0.0420468673,
-0.014710824,
0.0471723266,
0.027083138,
0.0301486552,
-0.0093611302,
-0.0335686617,
-0.0040979614,
0.0104915379,
0.0017872556,
-0.0128325354,
0.0528713576,
0.038349431,
-0.0193048436,
0.0587482825,
-0.0192755032,
-0.0325269289,
0.0466988944,
0.0282038357,
0.006107532,
0.0018516653,
-0.0076538264,
0.0721361339,
-0.0030309833,
-0.0446931012,
0.0011248022,
0.0373161398,
-0.0540398285,
-0.00976477,
0.0930886492,
0.016508691,
-0.0019393137,
0.0126145836,
0.0205150973,
0.0375715271,
0.0057078376,
-0.0142326793,
-0.120282121,
0.0213407874,
0.0480301529,
0.0008483552,
-0.0387397148,
-0.0368468165,
-0.0129836397,
-0.1313624233,
0.0070027676,
0.0136850048,
-0.0338875577,
-0.01158062,
-0.0230358057,
0.0187335815,
-0.0163674466,
0.0697354376,
-0.0103599876,
-0.0238352884,
0.0171309765,
0.040216431,
-0.0566224828,
-0.1153999269,
-0.0367132053,
-0.0536194704,
0.06488657,
0.0313721783,
0.0092165498,
-0.0455358587,
0.0096215205,
0.0165865179,
-0.0393980108,
-0.0203920491,
-0.0005081937,
0.0662360787,
-0.0050287205,
-0.0244398583,
0.0032338153,
-0.0061249062,
-0.00042415,
0.0076222415,
-0.0253607426,
0.0715795606,
-0.0144564463,
0.0105255553,
-0.0156217935,
-0.0489338152,
0.0247919876,
0.0757094398,
-0.0125033557,
-0.0469778515,
0.012386661,
-0.0112559972,
0.0400525928,
0.0272731707,
0.043564681,
0.0457701869,
-0.0493404567,
-0.050831113,
-0.0815222114,
-0.0851123556,
0.0164472256,
0.0049428768,
0.0584639572,
0.0462880135,
-0.0201416351,
-0.0118376594,
-0.0187840369,
0.0462653004,
-0.0355520472,
0.0135908471,
-0.047542911,
0.0110552236,
-0.0474674515,
0.0212952197,
0.0101648299,
0.0110231452,
-0.1054138243,
-0.0854994133,
0.044845894,
0.0154038314,
0.0207477007,
0.0232237503,
-0.0074490597,
-0.0698051006,
0.0345922634,
0.0242471416,
-0.0396988317,
0.025833549,
0.0475920923,
-0.0554925948,
0.0190775413,
0.0141631737,
-0.0316673033,
-0.0204805005,
0.0273010954,
0.0086170007,
-0.0452408865,
0.0140076214,
0.0303821731,
0.0398494937,
0.0554136857,
-0.0462149158,
0.0012333302,
-0.0612799153,
-0.0222868361,
-0.0380186476,
-0.0159938,
-0.0307701025,
0.0146617163,
0.0562988743,
0.0347398072,
-0.0269465558,
0.0219433885,
-0.0401114486,
0.0581516065,
-0.0102543002,
-0.0105325291,
0.0199924745,
0.0009921351,
0.0582266115,
0.0342063308,
0.0327212512,
0.0131578073,
0.0068771602,
0.0201903842,
0.003763519,
0.0109425029,
0.0059082047,
0.0272282586,
0.0112546664,
0.0253658667,
-0.0327042639,
-0.0016100792,
-0.0231446475,
0.0063065621,
0.0259628985,
-0.0263739731,
0.0609977879,
-0.0068027633,
-0.0012353279,
-0.0284751169,
-0.034050703,
-0.0079389699,
-0.0144318081,
0.0187721066,
0.0032273321,
-0.0532355569,
0.0477909818,
0.0844338164,
-0.0020824445,
0.0802448466,
-0.0606104545,
-0.030975474,
0.0176714864,
0.0016594622,
0.0321004912,
-0.0013583214,
-0.0399592668,
-0.0366632491,
-0.0678839684,
-0.1056047231,
-0.024807347,
-0.0114583476,
-0.001768443,
-0.0177067202,
-0.0022818632,
0.0536860861,
0.0233975407,
0.0351338945,
-0.0566824004,
-0.0153094754,
0.0306590516,
-0.0268928465,
-0.0027631971,
-5.600807404e-33,
0.0215020273,
-0.0125379032,
-0.0211028289,
-0.0325508267,
-0.0247629751,
0.0281537641,
0.0139420722,
0.0129653681,
-0.0457982048,
0.0009831212,
-0.0135689666,
0.0122575788,
0.0148553345,
0.0095728673,
0.0064426675,
0.019468084,
0.0580048375,
0.0103414729,
-0.0300235394,
-0.0235579871,
0.0569741763,
0.0132623492,
0.0379709639,
-0.0596630499,
0.0558912866,
-0.0131769227,
-0.0180761721,
0.0047809449,
-0.0056874324,
0.0550809056,
-0.0139289536,
0.0597514473,
0.0289527737,
-0.0063296729,
-0.0455400497,
0.0241926704,
-0.0673315153,
-0.017617818,
0.0241261199,
0.0390541032,
0.0339060016,
-0.0245368816,
0.086728476,
-0.0384306014,
-0.0167154968,
0.0222376902,
0.0174952596,
-0.0392050892,
-0.0353654511,
-0.0085910456,
-0.0249002222,
0.0271215886,
0.0060531255,
0.0261792019,
0.0488596335,
0.0291401204,
0.0261412393,
0.0160505939,
-0.0414900966,
0.0190478731,
0.0450775623,
0.0411344543,
0.0483145453,
0.017002847,
0.0070790946,
0.0693495944,
0.0157066006,
0.0212652702,
0.0639326796,
-0.0274354406,
0.0533934124,
0.00262407,
-0.0035362064,
0.0333055742,
0.032883577,
-0.0410942845,
-0.0306296181,
0.0113322418,
-0.0280577485,
0.0208533797,
-0.027968647,
-0.0244550817,
-0.0502482466,
-0.0780205205,
-0.0433935933,
-0.0436120965,
-0.0111847166,
-0.0066451076,
0.0378196277,
-0.0375235118,
-0.0197308641,
0.0320291035,
-0.0025523815,
-0.0525504798,
-0.0692446157,
0.0193614643,
-0.0136615802,
0.0194816068,
0.0058474001,
0.048408702,
-0.0442876145,
-0.0301705915,
-0.0054519111,
-0.0181644429,
0.0086105717,
0.0231788643,
0.0519301891,
0.0430652685,
-0.0571885705,
0.0099769607,
-0.0073766704,
0.0235626902,
0.0042542629,
-0.0042446335,
0.0595028475,
-0.0022975318,
0.0376907848,
0.0064477595,
0.0995542184,
0.0428486131,
-0.0305057727,
-0.000265225,
-0.0073131751,
-0.0264564399,
0.018582195,
-0.028234696,
-0.013284402,
0.0542500019,
0.0717093945,
-0.0684935227,
0.0039001307,
-0.0311368518,
2.569e-7,
0.0564817898,
0.060405869,
0.0158305354,
-0.027014913,
0.0105142575,
-0.0046674591,
-0.0250957627,
0.0074431645,
0.0050194175,
0.0191973485,
-0.017113531,
-0.0484203547,
0.037961375,
0.0299077928,
-0.0802956372,
-0.0103312694,
-0.020839911,
-0.0144844223,
-0.0610953607,
0.0367862247,
0.0063661058,
0.0881020203,
0.011481992,
-0.0510139912,
-0.0195297468,
-0.0575452,
0.0214228258,
-0.0234946329,
-0.0387393385,
0.0452266671,
0.059973672,
0.0015661925,
0.0408446416,
0.021317644,
-0.0089021018,
0.0183164664,
0.0257468,
0.0005674128,
-0.0135778897,
0.0338315591,
-0.0340825208,
-0.0689475164,
-0.0372005031,
-0.0302421823,
0.0736289471,
0.0038263551,
-0.0232571792,
-0.0385837629,
-0.0512100533,
-0.0396462418,
0.0296520423,
-0.0226163752,
-0.0110480608,
0.0196286738,
0.0053525823,
0.0052249683,
-0.029663166,
-0.0427850895,
0.0093652755,
-0.0018675461,
-0.01664095,
-0.0798507482,
0.0320649408,
-0.0429004915,
0.014639846,
-0.075947836,
0.0290658306,
2.437729394e-34,
0.0186048578,
-0.0435141698,
0.0398393162,
0.0023345719,
0.0234339815,
-0.0176849775,
0.001682215,
0.0290186461,
-0.0268159937,
-0.0349405892,
0.0115282731
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14643v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14643v1 | Holistic Evaluation for Interleaved Text-and-Image Generation | 2024-06-20T18:07:19 | 2024-06-20T18:07:19 | Minqian Liu, Zhiyang Xu, Zihao Lin, Trevor Ashby, Joy Rimchala, Jiaxin Zhang, Lifu Huang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Interleaved text-and-image generation has been an intriguing research
direction, where the models are required to generate both images and text
pieces in an arbitrary order. Despite the emerging advancements in interleaved
generation, the progress in its evaluation still significantly lags behind.
Existing evaluation benchmarks do not support arbitrarily interleaved images
and text for both inputs and outputs, and they only cover a limited number of
domains and use cases. Also, current works predominantly use similarity-based
metrics which fall short in assessing the quality in open-ended scenarios. To
this end, we introduce InterleavedBench, the first benchmark carefully curated
for the evaluation of interleaved text-and-image generation. InterleavedBench
features a rich array of tasks to cover diverse real-world use cases. In
addition, we present InterleavedEval, a strong reference-free metric powered by
GPT-4o to deliver accurate and explainable evaluation. We carefully define five
essential evaluation aspects for InterleavedEval, including text quality,
perceptual quality, image coherence, text-image coherence, and helpfulness, to
ensure a comprehensive and fine-grained assessment. Through extensive
experiments and rigorous human evaluation, we show that our benchmark and
metric can effectively evaluate the existing models with a strong correlation
with human judgments surpassing previous reference-based metrics. We also
provide substantial findings and insights to foster future research in
interleaved generation and its evaluation. | [
-0.0174180008,
0.0449903011,
0.029449068,
0.0204148497,
-0.0386630446,
0.0026733305,
0.0261276159,
0.0353628732,
-0.0382047258,
-0.0235426817,
-0.0327587202,
-0.068925485,
0.0339043215,
0.0226938277,
0.0240326766,
-0.1013209596,
-0.045590736,
0.004613312,
-0.02285292,
0.0145644173,
0.0247560274,
-0.0025311261,
-0.003183407,
0.0238883011,
-0.0527802594,
-0.0401851088,
-0.0098563954,
0.0593531691,
0.05802368,
-0.0323896036,
-0.0235063136,
0.0477037728,
-0.0128931282,
0.0295513421,
0.0000021247,
0.010675719,
0.0196471475,
0.0223024711,
0.0441595614,
0.0163975246,
0.0574298836,
-0.0209740642,
-0.037345767,
-0.0363240838,
-0.0231844727,
0.0316644572,
0.0517907739,
0.0373446383,
0.0914865434,
0.0357408151,
-0.0313279554,
-0.0098714912,
-0.0271910783,
-0.0236959439,
-0.0044058654,
0.0047600865,
-0.0318926834,
0.0322296359,
-0.0203985814,
0.0178238694,
0.0009424385,
0.0205278173,
0.05752372,
-0.0188170336,
0.0180960651,
0.0580204464,
-0.0137384431,
-0.0121819992,
-0.0187394731,
0.0575139821,
-0.0606280044,
0.0192162246,
-0.0048306109,
-0.0502195731,
-0.0144384103,
-0.0160110183,
-0.0308055468,
0.0060621402,
0.0065494189,
0.0244359057,
-0.0790265054,
0.0557501987,
-0.0065249964,
-0.0182387084,
0.0061322441,
-0.0295104217,
0.0362377241,
0.0072470834,
-0.0391401388,
0.0590767302,
-0.0307894368,
-0.0492334738,
0.0220322348,
-0.0009937806,
0.0125463502,
-0.001309666,
-0.0856302455,
-0.0566108897,
0.0232196506,
-0.0070560845,
0.0787194073,
0.0166641753,
-0.0439089015,
0.0276649259,
-0.0545025356,
0.0764300823,
-0.0040923175,
-0.0062533198,
-0.0487200394,
0.0188213941,
-0.0136882998,
-0.0085226148,
-0.0054903952,
-0.0110045392,
-0.0549051277,
-0.0527489558,
-0.0290866923,
-0.0008166888,
-0.0153027587,
0.003041632,
0.0226501804,
0.030735461,
-0.0622132756,
-0.016026618,
-0.0307518765,
-0.0110412855,
-0.0236249752,
0.0253864918,
0.0261980854,
-0.0286874734,
-0.0029148443,
0.0482855327,
0.0123949572,
-0.0080465302,
-0.0359849408,
0.0799173862,
-0.064357169,
-0.0068501141,
-0.0055062748,
-0.0368321911,
-0.0225258041,
-0.0613467135,
0.0297361389,
-0.0492656939,
0.0310044046,
-0.0353635214,
0.0095247859,
-0.0070468718,
0.0146737518,
0.015611711,
0.0310569182,
0.0152947363,
-0.0222363975,
-0.0084052188,
-0.0103517715,
0.0184544735,
0.021034494,
0.0443616845,
0.051641725,
0.0700681582,
0.0050071017,
0.0119217336,
-0.0031555151,
0.0133808367,
0.0221789051,
0.0173494294,
0.0118438145,
-0.0266826209,
-0.0089993719,
0.0417987406,
0.0582672358,
0.0866327509,
-0.0598166175,
-0.0117513873,
0.1034760475,
0.0095921224,
0.029046718,
-0.0026026189,
0.0897594765,
0.042152863,
-0.0004246774,
0.0662370697,
0.0113019496,
0.058256425,
0.0312306266,
0.0534078516,
0.0688381121,
0.0623685718,
-0.0212474559,
-0.0392005183,
0.0241582077,
-0.0180221777,
-0.0153015442,
-0.0619986095,
0.0123070274,
0.0468111932,
-0.0863550156,
0.0188807286,
-0.0207421985,
-0.070722878,
0.0175515823,
-0.0317291692,
-0.0026978096,
0.0946136639,
0.0264443159,
0.0504289679,
0.0443197899,
0.0299023967,
0.0170090422,
0.087212801,
-0.0233984869,
0.0258001368,
0.0444585122,
-0.0618697368,
-0.0277902186,
-0.0414046869,
-0.0197183769,
0.0294989683,
-0.0087878546,
0.0429432876,
0.0277780164,
-0.0252019763,
-0.018985467,
0.0411607884,
0.0089134034,
-0.0002774358,
-0.0123618888,
0.0176630467,
-0.0085765449,
-0.0032554299,
-0.0480291843,
0.0317846388,
0.0091318823,
-0.0134871984,
-0.0251602326,
0.0259423647,
-0.0334945135,
-0.0320196487,
-0.0263969675,
-0.1004097834,
-0.0007813761,
-0.0010287493,
-0.0217149109,
-0.022940712,
-0.0179611687,
-0.0296236668,
-0.0055903606,
-0.0400892571,
0.0110118249,
0.032677561,
0.0095843067,
-0.0256075617,
0.0469781943,
-0.0329197124,
0.0148502644,
-0.006983242,
0.0281064697,
0.0006688129,
-0.0116809411,
-0.0088705914,
-0.0033470199,
-0.0074510961,
0.0080586392,
-0.0074800174,
0.0439673923,
-0.0752772689,
-0.0491949692,
-0.0484776199,
-0.0042363713,
-0.0031910506,
-0.0074228714,
0.0125249512,
-0.0241042972,
0.0206450019,
0.0189757459,
-0.0306981299,
0.0143936146,
0.0143292286,
-0.0018372365,
0.0485848933,
-0.0129051646,
0.0402462222,
-0.0279699322,
-0.0015677912,
0.0617371015,
0.0537124313,
0.0438221507,
0.0143853063,
-0.0499349236,
0.0071502551,
-0.033102762,
-0.0331208147,
0.0097562009,
-0.0418352932,
0.0452536754,
0.0295234434,
0.0455246381,
0.0412536971,
0.0445177071,
-0.0219696816,
-0.0015770758,
-0.008460856,
-0.0152633917,
-0.008139044,
-0.0028600639,
0.0071467492,
0.0499841794,
-0.0388992541,
0.0143712284,
0.0251188613,
0.0234985705,
0.0508175753,
-0.0786077753,
0.0283578038,
-0.0248907097,
-0.0482393764,
-0.0190306716,
0.0061925356,
0.0037067495,
0.0071267905,
-0.0622709841,
-0.0887601003,
0.0281500239,
-0.0577651709,
-0.0012003687,
0.0163918082,
0.0338559933,
-0.0000403104,
0.0486320332,
0.0096303495,
0.0350123532,
0.0100820353,
0.0259987302,
-0.0507304296,
0.0360898077,
0.0316137522,
-0.0278341267,
0.0242100675,
-0.0518015176,
-0.0046563474,
-0.0273232777,
-0.033507552,
-0.0228608288,
0.0069585522,
0.0207069796,
-0.030045798,
0.0587714389,
-0.0323597714,
-0.0107421046,
0.0348351225,
0.001434077,
-0.0043179574,
0.0099316463,
-0.0371870436,
-0.0075191045,
0.0649367943,
0.0108602885,
-0.0338390656,
-0.0034693279,
-0.0411510728,
-0.0008606928,
0.0596412569,
0.0213921946,
0.0158762317,
-0.0426350459,
0.0214637946,
-0.0163886398,
0.0537658073,
-0.0271590091,
0.0244788714,
0.0828115866,
-0.0421962105,
-0.0135564199,
0.0413769819,
-0.0077325092,
0.0024907754,
-0.0196854584,
0.0329638347,
0.0660374686,
-0.0139493961,
-0.0043268944,
-0.0854176953,
-0.0296551175,
-0.0255389325,
-0.0098249698,
-0.0001801385,
0.0035885938,
-0.036596857,
-0.0701208636,
0.0543536693,
0.0440037362,
-0.0028789041,
-0.0286500249,
0.0112040071,
-0.0030675128,
0.0424144231,
-0.0398123749,
-0.0131841535,
0.0160662234,
0.0176528487,
0.0133697875,
-0.0011999042,
-0.0387450866,
-0.0502567925,
-0.0125054549,
-0.0108154267,
0.0791547,
0.0437158309,
0.0400815308,
-0.0794372857,
0.0127933063,
-0.0069419062,
0.0100140078,
0.0145244105,
0.0677119195,
0.0082267337,
-0.0208825544,
-0.0378805287,
0.0001338334,
0.0053095599,
-0.0269472972,
-0.0093607688,
-0.0113683799,
-0.0120303435,
-0.0462974831,
-0.0420572162,
0.017709285,
0.0269917846,
0.030994121,
0.0515389442,
-0.0302725937,
-0.0725708008,
-0.0201564282,
0.0403492302,
-0.1044880897,
-0.0119948238,
0.0060065095,
0.0124907568,
-0.0212821271,
-0.0896812081,
-0.0225889254,
-0.0300288238,
0.0410175659,
-0.0203184038,
-0.017699834,
-0.0358737633,
-0.0171016771,
-0.0345689207,
0.003233114,
-0.009193453,
0.046906516,
-0.0668698177,
-0.0125174187,
-0.0215856936,
-0.035258323,
-0.028438922,
0.0494743884,
-0.0626684129,
-0.012267245,
-0.0322097652,
0.0702174678,
0.0129417842,
0.0232825615,
0.0165797696,
-0.0278005227,
0.0501794815,
0.0448729061,
0.0125941187,
0.026232155,
0.0086451545,
-0.0104705626,
-0.0045616101,
-0.000264697,
-0.0289507378,
0.0167163163,
-0.0109849032,
0.0213129781,
0.0470098071,
-0.0325194262,
0.0122251324,
-0.0137420464,
-0.0205616765,
-0.0544506125,
0.0281603504,
0.0027745944,
-0.0223476589,
-0.0294610281,
-0.0403589383,
-0.0731361732,
-0.0141532654,
0.0259469971,
0.0005015776,
-0.0098953154,
0.0201835595,
-0.0005558076,
0.0275708064,
-0.0261912607,
-0.0372268297,
-0.0149250505,
0.0259728543,
-0.0064549893,
0.0071448991,
0.0044976422,
0.00079567,
-0.0593683794,
0.0248661675,
0.0128092421,
0.0161594581,
0.0226186048,
-0.0216349848,
0.0254900996,
0.0791868567,
-0.0105012245,
-0.0053418707,
-0.0823878869,
-0.0138569968,
0.0556422584,
0.0317246467,
0.0981770679,
-0.0052401251,
0.0038429529,
-0.0221920982,
0.03169512,
0.0434093438,
-0.0424931943,
-0.0262405016,
-0.0053289919,
0.0086708907,
-0.0270723626,
0.0895645767,
-0.0307825878,
-0.0169110671,
-0.0364712439,
0.0067101107,
-0.0321164504,
-0.0321031325,
-0.0096323695,
0.0042527318,
0.0473241881,
-0.0123425182,
-0.0436344072,
-0.0256744456,
0.0272992495,
0.0586475804,
0.0098844757,
0.0243058875,
0.0602638386,
0.025331527,
-0.0249162689,
0.0309333801,
0.0138119766,
-0.0382537693,
-0.0115272216,
0.0172894876,
-0.0013529324,
-6.063738385e-33,
-0.0659186468,
-0.0472713634,
0.0055161999,
-0.0470312126,
-0.054157488,
0.0231550876,
-0.0237061884,
0.0003088854,
0.0536652543,
0.0089834072,
0.0593329668,
-0.0124586821,
0.0100349337,
0.0214535668,
-0.0407033376,
0.0328500457,
0.0442983545,
-0.00229737,
-0.067763485,
0.0148040047,
0.0080404421,
0.0098080793,
0.0110955657,
-0.0388135426,
-0.0287916679,
-0.0156017514,
-0.0416460037,
-0.0665757284,
0.0148790451,
0.0462723821,
-0.011641114,
0.0029060738,
0.0073212711,
-0.0087590441,
-0.0317051597,
0.0363694169,
0.0023563113,
-0.0258325674,
-0.0307816397,
-0.0081580896,
-0.1095622033,
-0.0203785691,
0.0378364064,
-0.018513361,
-0.0140007194,
-0.0568135753,
0.0365266129,
-0.0112336101,
0.0070622023,
-0.0300132465,
-0.0574417301,
0.0151309259,
-0.0433743559,
-0.0501419567,
0.0004325396,
0.0554014221,
0.015588847,
0.0280486606,
-0.0763205737,
0.0441244245,
-0.0057056611,
0.0242898557,
0.0506201982,
0.0211670604,
0.0024937254,
0.0768611506,
0.0312530063,
-0.0095705343,
0.0098046632,
-0.0014775562,
-0.0008606242,
0.0519339666,
0.063377887,
0.050088089,
0.0363407694,
-0.0056725652,
-0.0268801656,
0.0865391791,
-0.0572307184,
0.0033104194,
0.0155875366,
0.0167122986,
0.0071428656,
0.0265241675,
-0.0353379585,
-0.0503650978,
-0.0398834571,
-0.026276987,
0.0299992319,
0.0270787105,
-0.0115649011,
-0.0094401445,
0.0201570615,
0.0327000692,
-0.003737737,
-0.0260231756,
-0.0769445598,
0.0662795976,
-0.0159499161,
-0.0079788854,
0.0036374433,
-0.025823148,
0.0823366717,
0.0659274682,
0.0091385385,
-0.0123665193,
0.0270938352,
0.0046826098,
-0.0274458695,
-0.0024720067,
-0.0336264558,
0.028382415,
0.0367715023,
-0.037331298,
0.007764909,
-0.0291062072,
-0.069926627,
0.0166528169,
-0.018570384,
-0.0107340859,
0.0053905332,
-0.037683107,
-0.0022978662,
-0.0066894419,
-0.0197073314,
0.0338401534,
-0.0430593453,
-0.0315459073,
0.02254498,
-0.0510662384,
-0.060045734,
0.0310063735,
2.643e-7,
0.0214250162,
-0.0131636653,
0.0262589771,
0.0067583453,
0.001453285,
0.0155497538,
-0.0195898321,
0.014411387,
-0.0275262222,
-0.0049295728,
-0.0072372765,
0.0386983864,
0.0818377659,
-0.0030127009,
-0.0004402355,
0.0115683153,
-0.0550360568,
0.0050436668,
-0.0218193363,
-0.0089830598,
0.0919998586,
0.0049557239,
-0.0306750461,
-0.0185569376,
0.0650283024,
0.0154168149,
0.0974647626,
-0.0055819401,
0.0118721062,
-0.0296107233,
0.0114326216,
-0.0076062279,
-0.0052322517,
0.0250799228,
-0.0148355253,
-0.0568142571,
0.0952195004,
0.0287594665,
-0.0033398396,
-0.0145747783,
0.0294579268,
0.0159960911,
0.0101172784,
-0.0252079796,
0.0659361035,
-0.027725989,
-0.014985933,
-0.0215407331,
-0.05267388,
0.0109448358,
0.0629228279,
-0.0338107608,
-0.0721986741,
0.0297680181,
0.0489219725,
0.0286357701,
-0.0264083054,
-0.0099594546,
-0.0554620624,
-0.018892955,
-0.0265326668,
-0.0215023868,
-0.1064725667,
0.0177435428,
0.0136673758,
-0.0223192386,
-0.0381876975,
2.255715573e-34,
0.0079786908,
-0.0093152812,
0.0371501558,
-0.0275466181,
0.0198057033,
-0.0028535605,
-0.0054379203,
-0.0020286019,
-0.0381542258,
-0.0153058218,
0.0071125622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14629v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14629v1 | Can LLMs Learn by Teaching? A Preliminary Study | 2024-06-20T18:00:17 | 2024-06-20T18:00:17 | Xuefei Ning, Zifu Wang, Shiyao Li, Zinan Lin, Peiran Yao, Tianyu Fu, Matthew B. Blaschko, Guohao Dai, Huazhong Yang, Yu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Teaching to improve student models (e.g., knowledge distillation) is an
extensively studied methodology in LLMs. However, for humans, teaching not only
improves students but also improves teachers. We ask: Can LLMs also learn by
teaching (LbT)? If yes, we can potentially unlock the possibility of
continuously advancing the models without solely relying on human-produced data
or stronger models. In this paper, we provide a preliminary exploration of this
ambitious agenda. We show that LbT ideas can be incorporated into existing LLM
training/prompting pipelines and provide noticeable improvements. Specifically,
we design three methods, each mimicking one of the three levels of LbT in
humans: observing students' feedback, learning from the feedback, and learning
iteratively, with the goals of improving answer accuracy without training and
improving models' inherent capability with fine-tuning. The findings are
encouraging. For example, similar to LbT in human, we see that: (1) LbT can
induce weak-to-strong generalization: strong models can improve themselves by
teaching other weak models; (2) Diversity in students might help: teaching
multiple students could be better than teaching one student or the teacher
itself. We hope that this early promise can inspire future research on LbT and
more broadly adopting the advanced techniques in education to improve LLMs. The
code is available at https://github.com/imagination-research/lbt. | [
0.0219512284,
0.0026266815,
-0.0067469277,
0.0443623476,
-0.0096349996,
0.010067733,
-0.0380721465,
0.0107168471,
0.0115563795,
-0.019940272,
-0.0128338309,
0.0027057815,
-0.0700165331,
-0.0388079397,
0.0225667711,
-0.0866162181,
0.0409626216,
-0.0467679836,
-0.0021493826,
-0.0144440401,
-0.0394311547,
-0.048189301,
-0.0216035321,
-0.0197192803,
0.0385102257,
-0.0172736794,
-0.0537561849,
-0.0017985011,
0.0134788547,
-0.0127920508,
0.0131351948,
0.0460045971,
0.0398810655,
-0.0258457903,
0.0000020566,
-0.0544343814,
0.009104806,
-0.0308277309,
-0.0563852116,
-0.0063954559,
-0.0493338332,
0.0389311425,
0.0295821484,
0.0011543471,
-0.06521447,
0.0411942415,
-0.0177929588,
0.0247727782,
0.0985515937,
0.0495502166,
0.0539935306,
-0.0289341491,
0.0160653815,
0.0211264044,
0.0929228738,
-0.0109343408,
0.0111129889,
0.0406249575,
0.0393951312,
0.0331819057,
-0.0530594215,
0.0066740946,
0.0428396016,
0.0149499197,
0.0291237533,
0.033261206,
0.0060499217,
-0.0157629568,
-0.0115606282,
0.0569666103,
0.0084983297,
0.0234322995,
-0.031335447,
0.0074480753,
0.0744311064,
0.0322636813,
-0.0866159722,
0.0025163349,
-0.0074944794,
0.0215639714,
-0.0032037585,
-0.032419432,
0.0199824739,
0.0282605328,
0.0292155091,
0.0566885322,
-0.0300924629,
-0.0453638621,
0.0138790281,
0.0139918905,
-0.0018843649,
-0.0134054907,
-0.0367579535,
0.1017402932,
-0.0030874561,
0.0329061896,
0.011717611,
0.0244647022,
0.0159577876,
0.0042509572,
0.0281089339,
0.0178011786,
-0.0243523587,
0.0133075332,
-0.0397969671,
0.0311634522,
0.0304396935,
0.0695479512,
-0.0415866226,
0.0260349531,
-0.0826240405,
-0.0119538484,
0.0070550623,
0.0646131486,
0.0121754482,
0.0491581969,
-0.0346624181,
0.0346476808,
-0.0357562304,
0.0259031989,
0.0081417533,
0.0227934085,
0.0169683062,
0.0257830508,
-0.0922147557,
0.0399054959,
-0.0445135944,
0.0231236722,
0.0217932742,
-0.0574472845,
-0.0283055753,
-0.0045648185,
-0.0224164743,
0.0368658267,
0.032476563,
0.0716817975,
-0.0250985119,
-0.0285165813,
-0.0725157186,
-0.0263509806,
0.0448080376,
-0.0454891771,
0.0454720668,
-0.0853605568,
0.026798876,
-0.0126074767,
0.0061222529,
-0.0225746408,
0.0411548615,
-0.003197389,
0.002395584,
0.0401941948,
-0.0311250426,
0.0182723869,
0.029017983,
0.0571002103,
-0.0493557006,
0.0723935217,
0.0223347954,
0.0082766889,
0.0205027573,
-0.0316006467,
0.0311388969,
0.002115808,
0.0140750259,
0.0374474116,
0.0404016525,
0.0119342031,
-0.0003106433,
0.0444779582,
0.0051610395,
0.010549196,
-0.0410167053,
0.0333071835,
0.0544045568,
0.0485770181,
0.0140129821,
0.0107047735,
0.0101308329,
-0.0219951328,
0.0324950516,
0.0597449951,
-0.0637145191,
0.0205215029,
-0.0012969465,
0.0376676843,
0.0056440053,
0.0108747054,
-0.0334411785,
-0.0793110207,
0.0140310591,
-0.0128555428,
-0.0290691406,
0.0517794304,
0.0479784682,
0.0183170289,
0.0069335271,
0.0642275363,
0.0428550281,
-0.0592599362,
0.060802184,
-0.104181014,
0.0602016039,
0.0399589576,
0.034871418,
-0.0510819443,
-0.0508756526,
-0.0389838368,
0.0176959224,
-0.0077361502,
0.0303948093,
-0.0484274104,
-0.0064689848,
-0.022404857,
-0.0373822115,
-0.0360786691,
0.0001528326,
-0.0223783907,
0.0542434826,
-0.0173046682,
-0.0063811359,
-0.0632190406,
-0.0166076217,
0.0265061613,
-0.0683651939,
-0.0375904627,
-0.0162805691,
-0.0075909123,
0.0042291605,
0.0267215502,
0.0255567916,
-0.0031101757,
0.0614741556,
-0.0091785919,
-0.0194922015,
-0.0258233622,
-0.046952229,
-0.0431183651,
0.0571505465,
-0.0343543924,
-0.008977823,
-0.0050144116,
-0.0698416606,
-0.0188942887,
-0.0068201097,
-0.0056878687,
0.0081375362,
-0.0148822479,
0.0053247972,
-0.0001139423,
-0.0441519655,
-0.0345495977,
0.0518694595,
-0.009125053,
0.0110009834,
0.0126454914,
-0.0050452533,
-0.0115684308,
-0.0302944276,
0.0229912642,
0.002383359,
0.0033051791,
0.0264289621,
-0.0199673977,
0.0122388499,
-0.0990103781,
-0.0092876134,
-0.033884339,
0.0072220424,
-0.0037707333,
0.0202532671,
0.0111491913,
-0.0129009997,
-0.0053938353,
-0.0167468507,
-0.0630338639,
-0.0305813216,
0.0393851995,
0.0031201039,
0.021585295,
0.0155482814,
0.0083898613,
-0.0042224834,
-0.0087217102,
-0.0024298097,
-0.0046597505,
-0.0183008797,
0.0217360873,
-0.0387455784,
0.035996303,
-0.032979209,
-0.0020494622,
0.0053551686,
-0.0040869964,
0.0379966497,
-0.0310453512,
0.0155356284,
0.0653751493,
0.0121473111,
0.0243498627,
0.0392287858,
-0.0004205274,
-0.0790712982,
0.0398825966,
-0.0380468667,
-0.0476542339,
-0.0438763238,
-0.0399261415,
-0.0108136162,
0.0119179804,
0.0064522717,
-0.0177303161,
-0.0354345217,
0.0200567003,
0.0140382657,
-0.0148468371,
-0.0583409704,
0.016893724,
-0.0101111149,
0.0028508026,
-0.0153086614,
-0.070607245,
0.0932182744,
0.0045613176,
0.0119540719,
0.0000364838,
-0.0105947386,
-0.0540870205,
0.0167507734,
-0.0450193807,
-0.0183905046,
-0.0194709133,
0.0174745545,
-0.0763482302,
-0.0038892585,
0.0201007612,
-0.0583763123,
0.0817355365,
-0.0624359883,
-0.056936536,
-0.0044455486,
-0.0288188495,
-0.0741904005,
0.0191901885,
-0.0171573199,
0.0302182827,
-0.0359879136,
0.0099175889,
0.0095161796,
-0.0590211302,
0.034043476,
-0.0552376769,
-0.0125445565,
-0.0248719472,
-0.0261896364,
0.0228352919,
0.0010529277,
0.0479295366,
0.0187377539,
-0.0761159807,
0.0722908452,
0.06907738,
0.0293083955,
-0.0471621752,
0.0014836969,
0.0341743492,
0.0224386472,
-0.0344539583,
0.0302893911,
0.0441632681,
0.0516692623,
-0.0447778627,
-0.0087140519,
0.100740023,
0.0019950697,
0.0142292883,
0.0079012588,
-0.0223172437,
0.0231668912,
0.0415464789,
0.0205446519,
-0.076555334,
-0.0363521129,
-0.0273741651,
0.0738551617,
0.0077052643,
-0.0102942931,
0.0151264165,
-0.0790930167,
0.0081360266,
0.0375179388,
0.0015886251,
-0.0286599323,
-0.0620252229,
-0.0136202937,
0.0092157712,
0.0088032139,
0.0267198905,
-0.0068639945,
0.0212260094,
0.0742789656,
-0.0027262997,
-0.0620797612,
-0.0178743862,
-0.0399952196,
0.0287253,
0.047672186,
0.001811307,
-0.0297375098,
-0.0813091099,
-0.002050539,
0.01002461,
0.0393709391,
-0.0207059924,
0.0438411534,
-0.0109298741,
0.0177776404,
0.0014968428,
0.0727436319,
-0.0354411304,
-0.0324433073,
0.0566884652,
0.0998184532,
-0.0262949131,
-0.0316879936,
-0.0458454192,
-0.0051662326,
0.0058733071,
0.0615637749,
0.0534486696,
-0.023976665,
0.0137508102,
-0.053912878,
-0.0354909003,
0.017712472,
-0.0120070269,
0.0341495126,
-0.017362088,
0.0631605759,
-0.032347858,
-0.03447726,
0.0450199507,
0.0061945198,
-0.001685793,
0.0164195262,
-0.0413353741,
0.0260830596,
0.0074884566,
0.0243457332,
-0.0196564291,
-0.0106461784,
-0.0565686524,
-0.0407258868,
0.0133187138,
-0.0521153472,
0.0106141083,
-0.0262774508,
-0.117847234,
-0.067629002,
-0.007875503,
0.0766370073,
0.0181202143,
0.040537592,
0.0364920273,
-0.035353858,
0.0670940876,
0.0294071417,
0.0205513313,
0.0133093959,
0.0235623885,
0.0487395935,
0.0106252888,
-0.0023531029,
-0.0259323753,
-0.0103056626,
0.016766252,
0.0305110551,
-0.0457975343,
-0.0235187262,
0.0328100659,
0.0193628371,
0.025286831,
0.0102697248,
-0.020810144,
0.0007318758,
0.0298490264,
0.0350037441,
-0.016308194,
-0.0152852684,
-0.0096149305,
0.0010473182,
-0.0119108967,
0.0252125915,
-0.0331424288,
-0.0020683627,
0.0189572349,
-0.0331397764,
0.0376699679,
0.0238549206,
-0.0405539125,
0.0259647407,
-0.003964291,
0.000780087,
0.0169778652,
-0.0119464789,
0.0283450149,
0.0391192213,
0.068540208,
0.033541739,
0.0287297908,
0.0246224962,
-0.006586852,
-0.0880546868,
-0.0812337473,
-0.0326851048,
0.0620955601,
0.0248018894,
0.0602650121,
-0.0394436419,
-0.0332728177,
0.025170764,
0.0204663612,
-0.0167405847,
-0.0259887204,
0.0095563279,
0.0456720404,
0.0424427427,
0.0303974207,
-0.0107381167,
0.0576169267,
-0.0387124643,
0.0662474185,
-0.0475462936,
0.0548450202,
-0.0374937765,
-0.0060153119,
0.0448058806,
0.0034728092,
0.0331468433,
0.0173178297,
-0.0111908615,
-0.0383732319,
0.0137686981,
0.0439180955,
0.0040890654,
-0.0511908159,
0.0367765948,
0.024063237,
-0.0242243595,
-0.0259812772,
-0.0138287321,
0.0207334068,
0.0079537835,
-0.0233703088,
-0.0184544362,
-5.599129018e-33,
-0.0272049904,
-0.0266449675,
0.0322808996,
0.052889742,
0.0072102612,
-0.0382505432,
-0.0006228644,
0.0197057929,
-0.0202943552,
0.0025402766,
-0.0137858372,
0.009357444,
-0.0039540562,
0.0006813686,
0.0410357267,
-0.06614995,
0.0307891592,
-0.0139181484,
-0.0088504516,
0.0215436872,
-0.0147205843,
0.0213979743,
0.0588346422,
-0.0271590967,
0.0426665433,
-0.0282269567,
-0.0020928646,
0.0447903834,
-0.0742937252,
0.0078749321,
0.0122248931,
0.0534745306,
0.0099329231,
-0.0300599318,
-0.0351226702,
-0.0095787179,
-0.0616606362,
-0.0631863177,
0.0068958066,
-0.0367220454,
-0.0665305182,
-0.0544091985,
0.0526269041,
-0.0047986438,
-0.0127104307,
-0.0252470057,
0.0215707645,
-0.0278329719,
-0.0138194952,
-0.0337435603,
0.0133176977,
-0.0201954935,
-0.0365087204,
-0.0321229137,
-0.0091541475,
0.0391547643,
-0.031662304,
0.0023020396,
-0.0316252746,
0.0600654446,
0.1077970341,
0.0355397537,
0.0599975437,
0.0063336622,
-0.0253322385,
0.0434000567,
0.004849751,
-0.0107854009,
0.0030626578,
-0.0378547385,
0.0152964192,
0.0727465451,
0.0815942809,
0.0258678049,
0.0150676426,
0.0090534212,
-0.0307297893,
0.0580008961,
0.0140120089,
0.0312920921,
-0.0250125155,
-0.0065723103,
-0.0054152501,
-0.0182952639,
-0.0673394874,
0.002127331,
0.0049504153,
-0.0326021016,
0.0185005516,
0.0099190166,
-0.0006428861,
-0.0368921682,
-0.0049306583,
-0.0395950861,
0.0017013793,
-0.0132430159,
0.0099759279,
0.0129533159,
0.0054119388,
-0.0466290414,
-0.0502293818,
-0.0335742831,
-0.0008250542,
-0.0293366853,
0.0201072022,
0.0106653357,
0.0265391637,
0.0028909231,
-0.0180183984,
-0.0112856291,
-0.0364274904,
0.0290414412,
0.0562401488,
-0.0489874259,
-0.0140702259,
-0.0031589279,
-0.0260871388,
0.0274199173,
-0.0065077581,
-0.0380898714,
-0.0288698561,
0.0125768995,
-0.0132043473,
0.0114033204,
0.0010909819,
-0.0107049653,
-0.0081447465,
0.0085176891,
-0.0049422765,
-0.0449412689,
0.0003188285,
0.0213516932,
2.587e-7,
-0.0060044904,
-0.0093363021,
0.0078192819,
0.019860141,
0.0080606807,
0.0365365073,
-0.0429813899,
-0.0196810346,
0.0496476889,
-0.0696907341,
0.0024861072,
0.0606556945,
0.0366590805,
0.0510002486,
-0.087287344,
-0.0335942544,
-0.0205405448,
-0.0308998059,
-0.0165592842,
0.0026369488,
0.0581178479,
0.0168205518,
0.0284975041,
-0.020473361,
-0.0195517354,
0.0027195176,
0.037074104,
-0.0619384684,
-0.0109479045,
0.0345497206,
0.0479370914,
-0.0231671352,
0.0263283644,
0.0213403869,
-0.0195024423,
-0.0131544638,
-0.0465111248,
0.0258610006,
0.0263046045,
-0.0480782129,
-0.0208803583,
0.0025534704,
0.0318887904,
-0.0174407773,
0.0404605232,
-0.0307627507,
0.0039126817,
-0.0059233648,
-0.007238328,
-0.0478232615,
-0.0005851492,
-0.020602392,
0.0071183029,
-0.0034200866,
-0.0151418112,
-0.0065318709,
-0.0151327522,
-0.0267018247,
-0.0187823232,
-0.0181096736,
-0.0460817404,
-0.0895486102,
-0.0296486933,
-0.0107285716,
-0.039446108,
-0.0314849094,
-0.0218581613,
1.93190591e-34,
0.0026301229,
-0.0201145299,
0.0593600199,
0.078522563,
-0.0108529534,
-0.0053680069,
-0.0276385974,
0.0136463903,
0.0359003805,
-0.0183681305,
-0.0120284176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14563v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14563v1 | Model Merging and Safety Alignment: One Bad Model Spoils the Bunch | 2024-06-20T17:59:58 | 2024-06-20T17:59:58 | Hasan Abed Al Kader Hammoud, Umberto Michieli, Fabio Pizzati, Philip Torr, Adel Bibi, Bernard Ghanem, Mete Ozay | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Merging Large Language Models (LLMs) is a cost-effective technique for
combining multiple expert LLMs into a single versatile model, retaining the
expertise of the original ones. However, current approaches often overlook the
importance of safety alignment during merging, leading to highly misaligned
models. This work investigates the effects of model merging on alignment. We
evaluate several popular model merging techniques, demonstrating that existing
methods do not only transfer domain expertise but also propagate misalignment.
We propose a simple two-step approach to address this problem: (i) generating
synthetic safety and domain-specific data, and (ii) incorporating these
generated data into the optimization process of existing data-aware model
merging techniques. This allows us to treat alignment as a skill that can be
maximized in the resulting merged LLM. Our experiments illustrate the
effectiveness of integrating alignment-related data during merging, resulting
in models that excel in both domain expertise and alignment. | [
-0.0343860947,
0.0661987662,
-0.0187746305,
0.023175288,
-0.0273779426,
0.0203067437,
0.0103153856,
-0.0359706022,
-0.0018016892,
-0.0198815055,
-0.0358127877,
-0.0224840157,
0.0519602038,
0.0166300852,
0.0494641066,
0.0003134611,
0.0792406723,
-0.0632470772,
-0.03848169,
0.0049330983,
-0.0072170887,
0.0201503187,
0.020613648,
0.0317810997,
0.0303393826,
0.0106530888,
0.0015397387,
0.0319394469,
0.056842979,
0.021732023,
0.0339093655,
0.0512969308,
0.0178331193,
0.0624849647,
0.0000018704,
-0.0313732885,
-0.0376939774,
0.0318429768,
-0.0220710263,
0.0156435296,
0.027170524,
-0.0035553994,
-0.0294020306,
0.0314874612,
-0.0067680809,
-0.0123645039,
0.0653747395,
-0.0052763885,
0.0684401318,
0.0522720255,
0.0031916995,
-0.0024225011,
0.0364424698,
-0.0013689192,
-0.0440526605,
-0.0491418019,
0.0545296632,
0.0489855409,
-0.0075706616,
-0.0250018854,
0.0056699398,
0.038164068,
-0.0205227956,
-0.0352338739,
-0.0024071319,
-0.0115261283,
-0.005401236,
-0.0287528299,
-0.0218286794,
0.0307618547,
-0.0294365473,
-0.0238378942,
0.0220275931,
-0.0125861466,
0.0120590469,
0.0204018466,
-0.027493814,
0.0001437536,
0.0106456885,
0.0085450197,
0.0378208198,
-0.0143137611,
0.0327258743,
-0.0003030649,
-0.0162612237,
0.0608970486,
0.0461137518,
-0.0238441713,
-0.0035907815,
-0.0346412063,
0.0018626377,
-0.089304477,
-0.0242692474,
-0.0045050918,
-0.0317852236,
0.0236869752,
-0.0767818391,
-0.0287799835,
0.0362636261,
-0.0509339571,
0.0473068766,
0.0366075262,
0.0241360366,
0.0323729627,
-0.0046904641,
0.0301038232,
-0.0454623662,
0.0023131259,
-0.0552667193,
0.0095187519,
-0.0261000097,
-0.0013445006,
0.010211545,
-0.0167476684,
-0.0160863232,
0.0302190576,
-0.0402162746,
0.0395650007,
-0.0204064958,
0.0302208178,
0.0129921315,
-0.0213801973,
-0.025894437,
-0.0190555546,
0.0139823304,
0.0178165734,
0.0295570642,
0.0156679656,
0.0001591436,
-0.0353170522,
0.0066192895,
0.0049572275,
-0.0403915532,
-0.0384612121,
-0.0234979577,
0.0960343108,
0.0015930141,
0.0520736799,
-0.0230177268,
-0.0600550845,
-0.0007805043,
-0.0234358311,
0.0034442288,
-0.0811882615,
0.0511130169,
-0.0115071116,
-0.0236847103,
-0.0947865397,
-0.0055013034,
-0.0212779753,
-0.0323951803,
0.0480011441,
-0.0810075104,
0.038005881,
0.0183608737,
0.0025212914,
-0.019204054,
0.0827856958,
0.0149661498,
-0.0212181807,
0.0054231966,
-0.0361865498,
-0.0028971105,
0.0507464819,
0.0017049558,
0.0538680963,
-0.033139132,
-0.0138481455,
0.060520418,
-0.0098841293,
0.0146697657,
0.0156378392,
-0.0014569549,
0.0237676874,
0.0505730063,
0.0045972844,
0.0178528633,
0.0289058108,
0.0070830025,
-0.0003970545,
-0.0088028638,
-0.0008002294,
-0.0602619909,
-0.0063367775,
-0.0693432614,
0.0339562036,
0.0124573503,
0.0979904234,
-0.0143623985,
-0.0247104727,
-0.0454702005,
0.0134589132,
-0.0111608179,
-0.005426859,
0.0197024234,
-0.0218492281,
-0.0323789343,
0.0817079172,
0.0346010141,
-0.056381952,
-0.0241421871,
-0.0149315298,
-0.0559782088,
0.0507046022,
0.018155545,
-0.0227491483,
-0.1099763215,
0.023374835,
-0.016337825,
0.0045945379,
0.0607370026,
0.0106495917,
0.0053265644,
-0.0569926798,
-0.0816700235,
0.0285931379,
0.0012168492,
0.0262734089,
0.0172675736,
-0.0251003895,
0.0038142605,
-0.0279713031,
-0.0601537414,
0.0168150607,
-0.09620554,
0.0289706774,
-0.0615579337,
-0.0137849776,
0.0257611778,
-0.0046433304,
-0.036454007,
0.008968777,
0.0174764097,
0.019773066,
-0.0338320173,
0.0196031723,
-0.0074042804,
0.0273581594,
0.0585426427,
-0.015709646,
-0.037224818,
-0.000204053,
-0.0434538759,
-0.0299837664,
-0.0262558274,
-0.0291555803,
0.0209511817,
0.0307865888,
0.0852575079,
-0.0168708954,
-0.0307959896,
-0.0253932346,
0.0638209581,
-0.0027102714,
-0.0065188729,
0.0024164619,
-0.0452155881,
0.0228355806,
-0.0191754084,
-0.0165626593,
-0.0043395408,
-0.0211264864,
0.0447558425,
0.0172979981,
-0.0075518955,
-0.0362036154,
-0.0182442311,
-0.0641243681,
0.0300113391,
0.0199612696,
0.0495518595,
0.0367112309,
-0.0005841861,
-0.0171047058,
0.0481793992,
-0.0168506894,
-0.0261712484,
-0.0141910426,
0.0185045581,
0.0166218225,
-0.01470243,
-0.0689443871,
-0.0614009239,
-0.0309195053,
-0.0594775379,
0.0580189526,
-0.0059881276,
-0.0468579121,
-0.074772805,
0.0604045801,
-0.0576348491,
0.037466649,
-0.0081678722,
-0.0378516279,
-0.0329665393,
0.0192981604,
0.0301772933,
0.0240826458,
-0.0319815166,
-0.0386896245,
0.0763926432,
-0.0327004865,
-0.045748692,
-0.0028900015,
0.0226124935,
-0.0200958978,
-0.0266703833,
-0.0403089449,
-0.0100940354,
0.0573278032,
-0.0300953183,
-0.0240582544,
-0.0297475364,
-0.0138111701,
-0.0296088401,
-0.025172323,
0.0037912517,
-0.05027619,
-0.0179282781,
0.0835340247,
-0.0314999856,
-0.0623614788,
0.0452599451,
-0.0334779583,
0.034410838,
-0.0371085331,
-0.0196659714,
-0.028501818,
-0.0091982028,
-0.0334779955,
0.0237591211,
0.0175886974,
-0.0209612884,
-0.0840812773,
-0.0113921333,
0.0641612187,
-0.0316450596,
0.0661374927,
-0.057653062,
0.0406389646,
-0.012271869,
-0.0296471994,
-0.0347608812,
0.000570144,
-0.0145960404,
0.0087925913,
0.0338016562,
-0.0252112243,
-0.0675512999,
0.0067304727,
0.0251732562,
-0.0099704843,
0.0029318975,
0.0022785065,
-0.019240031,
-0.0246059503,
0.038346339,
-0.0077336673,
0.0131721143,
-0.0610455945,
0.025666628,
0.0315540656,
0.0436055139,
0.0072224271,
-0.047478091,
-0.0293214507,
0.0778077915,
-0.0261042826,
-0.0302275866,
0.0218848065,
0.0136857154,
-0.0346446335,
0.0390216671,
0.0762226209,
0.0139892949,
0.0095974142,
-0.0157148298,
-0.0442794636,
0.0488815233,
0.0182683226,
0.0343364887,
-0.0274875872,
0.0031848208,
0.0369840041,
-0.0130371591,
0.0290654786,
0.0031023205,
0.0036686936,
-0.1109584123,
0.0120548084,
0.0530409217,
-0.0217898656,
-0.017734779,
-0.0030122164,
0.027436547,
-0.0220649634,
0.0436578616,
0.0302439071,
-0.0256896093,
-0.0488079488,
0.0075074215,
-0.0186201129,
-0.0587664247,
-0.0220195465,
-0.0435387045,
0.073470436,
0.0753294975,
-0.0039281114,
-0.0084398566,
-0.041160576,
0.0758046508,
0.0450329296,
0.0012676038,
0.0060972283,
0.0435162522,
0.016606424,
0.0040948438,
0.0061310511,
-0.0097167818,
-0.0082306145,
-0.0386986621,
-0.002087198,
0.0558646992,
0.0103512136,
0.0222420413,
-0.0242532454,
0.0155999931,
-0.0228545535,
0.0544035397,
-0.0077052908,
-0.0229541361,
0.0064614355,
-0.0183236748,
-0.0308949053,
0.0132163716,
-0.0232231766,
0.0360879153,
-0.063580282,
-0.0753305629,
-0.0306201875,
-0.0120521234,
0.0154868588,
0.0295827128,
0.0518521518,
0.0113422237,
-0.0083456775,
-0.0130318329,
-0.0317480341,
0.0369921401,
-0.0377869457,
0.0297033023,
-0.0558626316,
0.0587119982,
-0.0097178845,
0.0032531256,
-0.0133804698,
0.0153286234,
-0.0916694701,
-0.1190776974,
-0.0030242624,
0.0399896577,
0.0279475097,
0.0107754664,
0.0073377397,
-0.0645353198,
0.0303740408,
0.0309404638,
-0.0241348743,
0.0092671104,
0.027189577,
-0.0535343476,
-0.0034388781,
-0.0004971356,
-0.0794379041,
-0.0319967307,
0.0297643971,
-0.0011100863,
-0.0397393927,
-0.0220586155,
-0.0058641424,
0.0417725258,
0.0269499458,
-0.0302815977,
-0.0040656263,
-0.0248790737,
0.020142829,
-0.0234399699,
-0.0365647525,
-0.0052533336,
0.0232476722,
0.0142135657,
0.0141370231,
0.0664059818,
0.0551580042,
0.015258247,
-0.0065481919,
-0.0135798091,
0.0012621329,
-0.0257489346,
0.0156457014,
0.0438772701,
0.0088281641,
-0.0070689307,
0.0147129158,
-0.0061262436,
0.0195202101,
-0.0206573736,
0.0108463112,
0.0157299116,
0.0543697514,
-0.0142773837,
0.0399652645,
-0.0386043638,
-0.0934050977,
-0.0371929519,
-0.0080321375,
0.0655185655,
0.0234522261,
0.1102785468,
-0.0125799906,
-0.0005157428,
-0.0400304943,
0.0243336745,
-0.0017073854,
0.0109223695,
0.0240174662,
0.0095620528,
-0.0141420206,
-0.0561904013,
0.0715627521,
0.0095881047,
0.0250790305,
-0.0526833758,
-0.0248636268,
-0.0014966204,
-0.0280990452,
0.07375893,
-0.0251923576,
-0.0335869715,
-0.0679023936,
-0.0775541812,
-0.0779061764,
0.0102758743,
0.0363733321,
-0.0354923159,
0.0279745851,
0.0080155768,
0.0393572375,
-0.0031154261,
-0.0031859549,
0.0199975688,
-0.0411254391,
-0.0043300549,
-0.0232112985,
0.0077199987,
-5.884816022e-33,
-0.026366191,
-0.0175666008,
-0.0042051128,
-0.0383887812,
-0.0303292163,
-0.0093056681,
0.0089446353,
0.0123725226,
-0.0062115579,
-0.0177232362,
-0.0008282219,
0.0075178305,
0.0138118993,
-0.0176050998,
0.0353377052,
-0.0044691367,
0.0118565606,
0.0392005593,
-0.0154120028,
-0.0111523755,
-0.0145418076,
0.0069737206,
0.0401136801,
-0.0904843807,
0.0238117557,
-0.0003194592,
-0.0041294908,
0.0178682022,
-0.0196993724,
0.0554416701,
0.0317713991,
-0.0007673077,
-0.0005539663,
-0.0421081148,
-0.0527402051,
-0.0248208363,
0.0056346897,
-0.0290949885,
0.0675706267,
-0.0153178992,
0.0040086643,
-0.0504071228,
0.0486047156,
0.0244627483,
-0.0012595676,
-0.0748892352,
0.0437044911,
-0.0135036809,
-0.0128781125,
-0.01110633,
-0.0822095722,
0.0310714114,
-0.0083460836,
0.0012275717,
0.0422124863,
0.0177703835,
0.0559299476,
-0.0165282842,
-0.0156822018,
0.0270743873,
0.0399250649,
0.0524683893,
0.1502307206,
0.0421663485,
-0.020427933,
0.0511087067,
-0.0322739631,
0.0018161732,
0.0355279781,
-0.0278665796,
0.0143466871,
0.0754175931,
0.0278720558,
0.0565397739,
-0.0003957821,
0.0084043955,
-0.0314246416,
0.0779283047,
-0.0240218434,
0.0136455167,
-0.0211095344,
0.0527556129,
-0.0332966149,
-0.0185710099,
-0.0329689905,
0.0358289592,
-0.0225647166,
-0.0040089386,
0.0125418762,
-0.0337290838,
-0.0223637111,
-0.0087021329,
0.0199202113,
-0.0410947874,
0.0022470187,
0.0075619286,
-0.0112515362,
0.0054519232,
-0.0148858819,
0.0483304337,
-0.0132680824,
-0.0512292124,
-0.0027615007,
0.0113631263,
0.0459502116,
0.0058833049,
0.0068236357,
0.0156161468,
-0.0699685737,
0.0396086946,
-0.0236557629,
0.0067019248,
0.0212343354,
-0.0186497867,
0.0822771639,
-0.007085457,
0.0267300345,
-0.0133284796,
0.0641095117,
-0.0019596275,
-0.0396773256,
0.0437324457,
-0.0224203281,
0.0138274254,
0.0150165372,
0.017772099,
0.0104251914,
0.0037934126,
0.0678092241,
0.0006375654,
-0.0525395721,
0.0084825559,
2.585e-7,
0.0612371862,
0.0238473937,
0.0364800766,
0.033928249,
-0.0189212635,
0.0518119894,
-0.0393067449,
0.0269737262,
0.0334203504,
0.0102501865,
0.0063194288,
0.0017355316,
0.0729486272,
0.0437724777,
-0.0275274776,
-0.0246852133,
-0.0186533704,
0.0113625405,
-0.0545783192,
-0.0200301372,
0.0578082465,
0.0585721843,
0.0064147967,
-0.0200451799,
-0.0362928994,
-0.0215587392,
0.0204096697,
-0.0463574193,
-0.0018439241,
0.0737304613,
0.0033995772,
-0.0044086827,
-0.0233414341,
0.022984378,
-0.0185105894,
0.0081984755,
-0.0024966595,
0.0622669123,
-0.0187046025,
0.0306198709,
0.0049862918,
-0.0320662856,
-0.020351138,
-0.0313296504,
0.0135929519,
-0.0301903151,
-0.011923274,
-0.0321195982,
-0.0346776731,
-0.0050599575,
0.006033917,
0.0049617914,
0.0284998361,
0.0514737479,
-0.0009775597,
0.0087816995,
-0.0389747396,
-0.0258227028,
-0.0298770647,
0.0453581102,
-0.042842783,
-0.0740729272,
0.0186533015,
0.0180560518,
0.0198136438,
-0.0654874891,
0.0110485563,
2.669543768e-34,
0.0032065194,
-0.0368810296,
0.0307506043,
0.0341950692,
0.0243754163,
-0.0162636396,
-0.0214575455,
0.044705607,
-0.0159468018,
-0.0128160976,
-0.0147531247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14562v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14562v1 | Whiteboard-of-Thought: Thinking Step-by-Step Across Modalities | 2024-06-20T17:59:45 | 2024-06-20T17:59:45 | Sachit Menon, Richard Zemel, Carl Vondrick | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | When presented with questions involving visual thinking, humans naturally
switch reasoning modalities, often forming mental images or drawing visual
aids. Large language models have shown promising results in arithmetic and
symbolic reasoning by expressing intermediate reasoning in text as a chain of
thought, yet struggle to extend this capability to answer text queries that are
easily solved by visual reasoning, even with extensive multimodal pretraining.
We introduce a simple method, whiteboard-of-thought prompting, to unlock the
visual reasoning capabilities of multimodal large language models across
modalities. Whiteboard-of-thought prompting provides multimodal large language
models with a metaphorical `whiteboard' to draw out reasoning steps as images,
then returns these images back to the model for further processing. We find
this can be accomplished with no demonstrations or specialized modules, instead
leveraging models' existing ability to write code with libraries such as
Matplotlib and Turtle. This simple approach shows state-of-the-art results on
four difficult natural language tasks that involve visual and spatial
reasoning. We identify multiple settings where GPT-4o using chain-of-thought
fails dramatically, including more than one where it achieves $0\%$ accuracy,
while whiteboard-of-thought enables up to $92\%$ accuracy in these same
settings. We present a detailed exploration of where the technique succeeds as
well as its sources of error. | [
0.003886949,
0.0726551861,
-0.0184363257,
0.0251480825,
-0.0504438318,
0.0213775206,
0.0484041758,
0.0157656632,
0.0213694666,
-0.0518288985,
-0.0359242223,
-0.0195947941,
0.0108717401,
0.0412604958,
0.0398377813,
-0.0912315547,
0.0077185677,
-0.0516870506,
-0.0158552099,
0.0099903625,
-0.0178855192,
0.0133889997,
-0.0603248551,
0.038438037,
-0.0503398441,
-0.0667928755,
-0.0467626378,
-0.0217098072,
0.024218021,
-0.0535272732,
-0.0435577966,
0.0545188598,
0.0378040858,
0.0477361605,
0.0000021841,
-0.038002409,
0.0143023711,
0.0042361007,
0.0129485456,
-0.0222142003,
-0.0305689219,
-0.0109156687,
0.0261789653,
0.0187968425,
-0.0356711857,
-0.0176788364,
0.0601989664,
0.0604280755,
0.0746037215,
0.0302612688,
-0.0040637865,
-0.027375875,
0.0171362069,
-0.0068722023,
0.041987475,
-0.0055532954,
-0.0205506757,
0.0268104337,
0.0467926934,
0.0185946096,
-0.0621511824,
0.0313019194,
0.0656501427,
-0.0163059011,
-0.0464943945,
0.0517830849,
-0.0027876496,
-0.0178615451,
-0.0276877768,
0.0788723454,
-0.0079423571,
-0.0071005877,
-0.0137932049,
0.0069012889,
0.0130949402,
0.0042866766,
-0.0627529249,
0.0727317855,
-0.0160873253,
-0.0121336421,
-0.0625673085,
-0.0137319816,
-0.0147458026,
0.0127983196,
-0.0342799611,
0.0281178765,
0.0099677863,
-0.0024698018,
0.0299715456,
0.0090045314,
-0.0419986285,
-0.0642836615,
0.020842839,
0.0496656671,
-0.0048658196,
0.0104740839,
-0.0130476579,
-0.0141384406,
-0.0082395738,
0.0176158845,
0.0501320213,
0.0658695474,
-0.0318416134,
0.051784236,
-0.0138130505,
0.0220645498,
-0.0609582625,
0.0443737321,
-0.0099374177,
0.0184947364,
-0.031586647,
-0.0282945707,
-0.0666290149,
0.0084409406,
-0.0307205971,
-0.045044791,
0.0141383475,
0.0208743587,
-0.0055060247,
0.0083933966,
-0.0031509253,
0.0204114616,
0.0114708887,
-0.0355172902,
-0.0538037606,
0.0433467031,
-0.041657865,
0.0230319779,
0.0086568613,
-0.0247636158,
-0.0048818197,
-0.0027387273,
0.0074192872,
-0.0429894142,
0.0112089766,
0.0645137355,
-0.0147495363,
0.0056276401,
0.0025859256,
-0.034372814,
-0.0062907697,
-0.0693044364,
0.0588969029,
-0.0544611737,
-0.0028920802,
0.0128506552,
0.0022826258,
0.0047133965,
0.0189979523,
0.0356192738,
-0.0021236071,
0.0911925137,
-0.003217774,
-0.0197109058,
0.0177316386,
0.0123127,
-0.0231116004,
0.0526582152,
0.0704240352,
0.0158439595,
-0.0102118347,
-0.018803658,
0.0186213031,
0.0537011735,
0.0072839153,
-0.039019499,
-0.027241325,
-0.0111113694,
-0.0026618137,
0.0675495192,
0.0054896842,
0.0374678597,
-0.0387473963,
-0.0091056377,
0.0480060354,
0.0631348938,
-0.0024582935,
-0.0244772527,
0.0487432852,
-0.0360628329,
0.0124585954,
0.0075738593,
-0.0794216096,
0.0932650939,
-0.0064070001,
0.0125302179,
0.0088247769,
0.0332147181,
-0.0018702471,
-0.0393318087,
-0.0097855767,
0.0251181703,
-0.0089094648,
0.0208769236,
0.039241191,
0.02492477,
-0.0154488385,
0.0288445055,
-0.0101665612,
-0.0391171128,
-0.032363575,
-0.0312342644,
0.0317551903,
0.0188037343,
0.0443076007,
-0.0032445721,
-0.0164196212,
-0.0301019382,
0.0428925306,
0.0315631032,
0.0247435942,
0.0365689844,
-0.0356396958,
-0.0395014547,
-0.0241289325,
-0.036297407,
-0.0038495541,
-0.016776355,
0.0083640181,
0.0054792776,
-0.0254377797,
-0.0310669746,
0.0552105382,
0.0206612758,
0.0484087616,
-0.0002646388,
-0.06098428,
0.0274642147,
-0.0255588405,
-0.0083933026,
-0.0088808322,
0.0328251347,
-0.0002859159,
-0.0201617964,
-0.0225673635,
0.0114573566,
-0.0749414265,
-0.0458392985,
0.0227906741,
-0.085412614,
-0.0403041206,
0.0056485129,
-0.0278079566,
-0.0076870779,
0.0291936547,
-0.0358225033,
0.0004914248,
-0.0152862668,
-0.0262952615,
0.0408207253,
-0.0095341494,
-0.0123301744,
0.0675145835,
-0.0018831057,
0.004685407,
0.0092876796,
0.0175253972,
0.0063347947,
-0.0093922513,
0.0164697263,
0.0295164958,
0.0146403704,
0.0165663064,
-0.0255869031,
0.0361380987,
-0.0638334304,
-0.0266313516,
-0.1007815897,
-0.0067141759,
-0.0057677836,
-0.0193323959,
0.0350045189,
-0.0286238585,
-0.0097257327,
-0.0517708734,
-0.0224082191,
0.0385344811,
0.0024234222,
0.028363103,
0.0178991016,
-0.0401399657,
0.0227258317,
0.0270867832,
-0.0217230935,
-0.0418042354,
0.0788045079,
0.0319443829,
0.0231089983,
-0.035463728,
0.0305942092,
-0.0500188246,
0.0275294632,
0.0111165857,
0.0078756688,
0.0696911737,
-0.0423138961,
0.02744532,
0.0699246526,
0.0050429194,
0.0156367309,
0.051164493,
-0.0419328809,
-0.0325330123,
0.0359650515,
0.0164903626,
-0.0114637306,
0.0207927432,
-0.0036179428,
-0.0409649163,
0.0396345444,
-0.0105841896,
-0.0004360508,
-0.0503017344,
0.0529289134,
0.0083505493,
-0.013763288,
-0.0425519086,
-0.0051507885,
-0.00490057,
0.061773818,
-0.029361926,
-0.0420048051,
0.0420290418,
-0.0094026076,
-0.0115075866,
-0.0166657344,
0.058766745,
-0.0263670571,
0.1386253834,
0.0324329771,
0.0082711037,
-0.0056694308,
-0.0160425641,
-0.0471438058,
-0.0240155365,
0.0104380725,
-0.011753507,
0.0714088604,
-0.0599366724,
0.0043519018,
-0.0316758752,
-0.0346074067,
-0.0242755283,
0.0431708768,
-0.0621445961,
-0.0025875536,
-0.0410476699,
-0.0187483579,
0.0094228536,
-0.0106380358,
0.0683243573,
0.0203483496,
-0.0043905559,
-0.0265676137,
-0.0227041654,
0.042685654,
0.0352384038,
0.0449925102,
0.0104170209,
-0.0361538753,
0.0262710024,
0.0471855514,
0.0151185188,
0.0080466373,
-0.057701394,
0.0415044427,
-0.0048531261,
0.0345041789,
-0.0116630681,
0.037926551,
0.0671935678,
-0.0738925487,
-0.0129645625,
0.0885392874,
0.0337030552,
-0.0375604331,
-0.0134179629,
-0.0449807309,
0.0309597887,
0.0509413071,
0.0273837857,
-0.0776059851,
-0.0564586557,
0.0237018671,
-0.0590882748,
0.021264663,
-0.0413938873,
-0.0141542228,
-0.1140457764,
0.0582858585,
-0.0050582406,
-0.0350280292,
-0.0107383523,
-0.0091543626,
0.0052592796,
0.0466339476,
-0.0095253894,
0.00577104,
0.0000535048,
0.027154753,
-0.0092762597,
0.0130876191,
0.0387596563,
0.0404966511,
-0.0148921814,
-0.028114358,
-0.0012337231,
0.0140486024,
-0.0099366717,
-0.0928947031,
0.0437303856,
0.0254408773,
0.0191607084,
-0.0152655337,
0.0550151281,
0.0298909657,
-0.0246184375,
-0.0219461638,
0.0301293731,
-0.01064994,
-0.052794639,
0.0157119278,
0.0980060399,
-0.0398670137,
-0.0229513254,
-0.0218143761,
0.0363210924,
-0.0385669991,
0.0151720662,
0.0371271111,
-0.0395226963,
-0.0758187771,
-0.0261800662,
0.0145438379,
-0.0449597612,
-0.0450409241,
0.0017245933,
0.0670025125,
0.0290484261,
-0.0414395519,
-0.0259092581,
0.0606478825,
0.0755246058,
0.0043532075,
-0.0159449503,
0.0130309649,
0.0187012143,
-0.0295200013,
0.0663084909,
-0.0352060162,
0.0614537857,
-0.0126282144,
0.020818295,
-0.0106208725,
-0.0491859429,
-0.0205122977,
0.0423603468,
-0.0542568862,
-0.0271191243,
-0.0559871979,
0.0408444479,
0.0228905603,
-0.0018489929,
0.030664837,
-0.0417666584,
-0.0045582359,
0.021610979,
0.0040938267,
0.0114840874,
0.0037088434,
0.0233701169,
0.0178970136,
-0.000118127,
0.0036611932,
0.0003381083,
-0.0152176972,
0.0425160378,
-0.0174621362,
0.0296852849,
0.0278610028,
-0.013329492,
0.0108688809,
0.0057939421,
0.029008247,
-0.0253249798,
0.0122770267,
-0.0163344871,
-0.0165120699,
-0.0502270274,
0.0126353847,
0.0109086121,
-0.0034308331,
0.0203045793,
-0.0488686785,
0.0300122611,
-0.0021940889,
0.0280984659,
0.0098408666,
0.0065538306,
-0.0011216606,
0.031245796,
-0.008782086,
-0.0058003138,
0.0196884423,
-0.0418926217,
0.0607213341,
0.0024644432,
0.1369361728,
0.0372815393,
-0.0490942746,
-0.0264762081,
0.0230313633,
-0.0512088723,
-0.103116937,
0.0381504111,
0.0294020325,
0.0495764539,
0.0128777483,
-0.0108718351,
-0.038770169,
-0.0132336998,
0.0346518606,
0.0349238999,
0.0248372704,
-0.0382249579,
0.0583774261,
0.0265472792,
0.0286716446,
-0.0596508421,
0.0206947383,
-0.048776798,
0.0413640104,
0.010137761,
-0.0088251457,
-0.0215806719,
-0.0387212895,
-0.0045891353,
0.0033487116,
0.0144204386,
0.0196454078,
-0.0670349821,
-0.0776112825,
-0.0120940562,
0.0368112326,
-0.0276143905,
0.0089358706,
0.0512393191,
0.0294419862,
-0.000324326,
-0.0390912965,
0.0044290521,
0.0306798015,
-0.0003689833,
-0.0105314804,
-0.0341768302,
-6.011781535e-33,
-0.020066997,
-0.0521926545,
0.0686708391,
-0.00773818,
-0.0274317618,
-0.0134453811,
-0.0352475084,
0.0253059492,
0.0032305713,
0.0123172347,
-0.006903193,
-0.0224264059,
-0.0046192566,
0.0407326147,
0.0094915275,
0.0140702073,
-0.0121753523,
-0.0028568679,
-0.0473338887,
0.0024532033,
0.014722975,
-0.0082552647,
0.0270350687,
-0.0141134514,
-0.0338307247,
0.0411072448,
-0.0180834569,
0.0262014419,
-0.0852521434,
0.0349148624,
-0.0446382537,
-0.0068168272,
0.0225222353,
0.001766043,
-0.0166638158,
0.0473889522,
-0.0516861379,
-0.0532315038,
-0.0012674981,
0.0166225061,
-0.1258084625,
0.015183772,
0.0245891921,
-0.018135462,
-0.0065271128,
-0.0565461777,
0.0338810794,
0.0010531336,
0.0126631148,
0.0681052804,
-0.0210633762,
-0.0151621737,
-0.0223388467,
-0.0343250036,
-0.0098910853,
0.0147912893,
0.0086121168,
-0.0200319029,
-0.040869128,
0.020597389,
0.0190094989,
-0.0182887372,
0.0572176278,
0.0162896812,
-0.0034116351,
0.0430515409,
0.0251696836,
-0.0337130278,
-0.0606604628,
-0.0223636758,
0.013102958,
0.049283985,
0.048751723,
0.0064584482,
0.0412647091,
0.0409079008,
-0.0292496048,
-0.0270671174,
-0.0408921018,
0.0604941808,
0.0163728409,
-0.015420001,
0.0012208123,
0.0105651533,
-0.0579704493,
0.0148928715,
-0.0558012463,
0.0066551389,
0.0384146646,
-0.0155913793,
0.0230096038,
-0.0014355654,
0.0416164473,
0.0001723589,
-0.0301097892,
0.0136988861,
-0.0019195551,
0.0657453239,
-0.0051459195,
0.031375844,
-0.0117104799,
0.009858341,
0.0313790962,
0.0229709148,
0.0123996558,
0.0139076645,
0.0385967344,
0.0136274323,
-0.0521836691,
-0.0148748364,
-0.0698047727,
0.0044131433,
0.0136806071,
-0.0323193669,
0.0417124331,
0.0058526485,
-0.0543591343,
-0.0011249769,
-0.0178895202,
-0.0426801629,
-0.0290787984,
-0.0069042044,
-0.0441925898,
-0.0029326708,
-0.0215529166,
-0.0055007092,
-0.0422426872,
-0.0198554192,
0.0335085131,
-0.0901888907,
-0.0087317098,
0.0360801071,
2.863e-7,
0.0350782201,
0.0165649876,
0.0023178374,
0.0372041389,
0.0351103507,
0.0380870812,
-0.0247755814,
-0.0074596242,
0.0211332478,
-0.0519685298,
-0.0207540095,
0.0657499358,
0.0273539107,
0.0165135022,
-0.0246193316,
0.0055623152,
0.0180939473,
-0.0218840595,
-0.0679639354,
-0.0015228759,
0.0961746424,
0.0192158706,
-0.0015455148,
-0.0346761867,
0.0254776552,
-0.0323467813,
0.0734713376,
-0.0170144141,
0.0501480289,
-0.0504900888,
-0.0022172085,
-0.0062906435,
-0.0040014102,
0.0267696418,
0.0141475899,
-0.0391237102,
0.0164569002,
-0.0076975031,
-0.0063672243,
0.0252193511,
-0.0369759314,
-0.0100748427,
-0.0266817287,
-0.0713114664,
0.0923983753,
-0.0560935996,
-0.0311915986,
-0.0138573376,
0.0219917148,
-0.0409798138,
0.0225333814,
-0.025225047,
-0.0242791697,
0.0118953157,
0.0121924393,
0.0029943215,
-0.0008379474,
-0.064031899,
-0.0353832953,
-0.0110773304,
-0.0340044722,
-0.0131807132,
-0.0605603643,
-0.0057634586,
0.0240314435,
-0.0435853302,
-0.0709222779,
2.496592044e-34,
0.0100271236,
-0.0155177685,
0.0501206554,
0.0025577655,
0.043526534,
-0.0164254308,
0.0480062589,
-0.0130030336,
0.0169090498,
-0.0663692579,
-0.0370740108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14561v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14561v1 | How to Compute the Probability of a Word | 2024-06-20T17:59:42 | 2024-06-20T17:59:42 | Tiago Pimentel, Clara Meister | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) estimate the probability distribution over sequences of
natural language; these distributions are crucial for computing perplexity and
surprisal in linguistics research. While we are usually concerned with
measuring these values for words, most LMs operate over subwords. Despite
seemingly straightforward, accurately computing probabilities over one unit
given probabilities over the other requires care. Indeed, we show here that
many recent linguistic studies have been incorrectly computing these values.
This paper derives the correct methods for computing word probabilities,
highlighting issues when relying on language models that use beginning-of-word
(bow)-marking tokenisers, e.g., the GPT family. Empirically, we show that
correcting the widespread bug in probability computations affects measured
outcomes in sentence comprehension and lexical optimisation analyses. | [
0.0435579456,
0.0635383278,
-0.025630137,
0.0317766406,
-0.0896205604,
0.0094491597,
-0.0136855599,
-0.0139921978,
-0.0391378887,
-0.0429242738,
0.0376817286,
-0.0722608343,
0.0583083332,
-0.0060556149,
0.0533460118,
-0.0436043665,
0.0683231428,
-0.0132238129,
0.0001055412,
0.0147085479,
0.014333697,
0.0049456195,
-0.0193921831,
0.0598025955,
-0.0001912691,
-0.007699505,
0.0185719877,
-0.0201985892,
-0.0252915248,
-0.0430266596,
-0.0275216661,
0.0472551621,
-0.0510930009,
0.0295854155,
0.0000018865,
-0.039460931,
-0.0187136848,
-0.0090629673,
0.0334538259,
0.0474690795,
0.0332919769,
0.0066801915,
-0.0207528509,
0.0395359062,
-0.0174533296,
0.0102917701,
0.0674390346,
-0.0073203356,
-0.0661225691,
0.0215361156,
-0.009653843,
-0.0026868454,
0.0401150361,
-0.0103685679,
0.0467406027,
-0.0449344479,
0.0208956171,
-0.0105918469,
0.0028772834,
-0.0378530808,
-0.052795697,
0.0360677317,
-0.0027320392,
0.0405139811,
-0.0499445759,
0.0393284373,
0.003983926,
-0.0468319356,
-0.0098337876,
-0.0195848476,
-0.0108028753,
-0.0177905317,
-0.0116624711,
-0.005795307,
-0.0024054311,
0.0354918055,
-0.0318208709,
0.0441641361,
-0.0088955592,
0.0163634066,
0.0345892794,
0.0298372731,
0.0251090545,
0.0162375849,
-0.0191255063,
0.1479020715,
0.0586426146,
-0.0205964111,
-0.0174360666,
0.0051032756,
-0.0708534196,
-0.0479785502,
0.0063661104,
-0.0356891677,
-0.0222201403,
0.05466244,
-0.0251256209,
-0.036077626,
0.0427897833,
-0.0086207595,
0.0301171411,
0.0314066783,
0.0229257401,
0.0302226916,
0.0087797549,
0.0285901166,
0.0108563183,
-0.0163727198,
-0.0244903695,
0.0411069319,
-0.0201167706,
-0.0377389267,
-0.0356358886,
0.0069900691,
-0.0114094969,
-0.0555998832,
-0.0349752605,
-0.0039824485,
0.0336860232,
-0.0862878188,
-0.0108106555,
0.0121490005,
-0.0344694816,
0.0034520288,
-0.0260837283,
0.006548997,
-0.0196868852,
0.0502449833,
-0.0076996721,
-0.063378416,
-0.0191979054,
0.0074605527,
-0.0012001464,
-0.030457275,
-0.0330628306,
0.0336435437,
-0.006090424,
-0.0415104814,
0.0213595126,
-0.0459692217,
-0.0639241114,
-0.019088801,
-0.0365521424,
-0.0812489539,
-0.0342133306,
0.032801915,
0.0142763723,
-0.0252201855,
0.0188611727,
0.0102542862,
-0.0407698862,
0.0806040764,
-0.00044492,
0.0186125673,
-0.0178184528,
0.0009226925,
0.0055167731,
0.0616900772,
0.05384022,
-0.0202938095,
0.0653357506,
-0.0077003501,
0.0107162669,
0.0505604483,
-0.0272414684,
-0.0348310806,
-0.0135633694,
-0.0342018567,
0.0327770188,
0.0111250943,
0.0467291512,
0.0570856556,
-0.0456963666,
0.0138781471,
0.0356587209,
0.0938620493,
-0.0282424428,
-0.012555562,
0.0112919249,
0.0090303011,
-0.0027198875,
0.0248896331,
-0.0182593372,
-0.03714706,
-0.0030900552,
0.0201665182,
0.0468038954,
0.0183508676,
0.0205395799,
-0.0262687691,
-0.0322114639,
-0.0012641295,
0.0269863978,
-0.0395991616,
0.0486818366,
0.0094620017,
-0.0529346354,
0.0150600858,
-0.0029509778,
-0.0253697094,
0.0232632197,
-0.0489481799,
0.0137033705,
0.0228547622,
0.0694145039,
0.0053690388,
0.0188026093,
0.028122589,
-0.0146550182,
0.0330848172,
-0.0045363642,
0.0334723964,
0.0134762032,
-0.0100788856,
0.0117851691,
0.0107011199,
0.0376538932,
0.0158877149,
0.0210482869,
0.0308530983,
0.0112569826,
-0.1037001535,
0.0287860148,
0.0407033227,
0.0146963056,
0.0068890601,
-0.0111849383,
-0.0386111774,
0.0274705552,
-0.0226466786,
-0.0227478649,
0.0721184537,
-0.0087359902,
-0.0077138604,
0.0013746499,
0.0059482073,
-0.0112415524,
-0.0211935826,
0.0625403598,
-0.0466477573,
0.015212357,
0.034361057,
0.0259680916,
-0.0318473987,
0.0400937311,
-0.0523876734,
0.0960364565,
-0.0509782359,
0.0499557257,
-0.0168044008,
0.0342702381,
-0.0532260612,
0.03948275,
0.0083997203,
0.0461912006,
-0.0747400001,
-0.0120810997,
0.0648483559,
-0.038959682,
-0.0524083897,
-0.0063756634,
-0.0088736648,
-0.0094974497,
0.0380836874,
-0.0049947747,
-0.0300602857,
-0.0364233144,
-0.0989219472,
-0.0013917737,
0.0072641009,
0.0588615388,
-0.0284154098,
0.0215448346,
-0.0453760512,
-0.0026428199,
0.043075379,
-0.0227468982,
-0.0190790277,
0.0514856912,
0.0483388901,
-0.0230440367,
-0.0351928025,
-0.0480193235,
-0.024312472,
-0.0358459353,
0.0154291047,
0.0227755252,
-0.0131743448,
-0.0408221297,
0.0262927376,
-0.0409877412,
-0.0029061045,
0.0138089396,
-0.0478033386,
0.0315747671,
-0.0019820565,
0.0786247849,
0.0042289165,
-0.0013650957,
0.0207784381,
0.0220695157,
-0.0338522755,
-0.0242836829,
-0.0423732884,
-0.0306993965,
-0.0138309514,
-0.0116554527,
-0.0466203764,
-0.0081037749,
0.0446004756,
0.0507676415,
-0.0288232602,
-0.0378914736,
0.0420259573,
-0.0523147248,
-0.038731847,
-0.0145395007,
-0.0144237448,
-0.0609864555,
0.0758302435,
-0.0098137502,
-0.0639628917,
0.0279824026,
-0.0395189673,
0.0167537723,
-0.0696374178,
0.0373090766,
-0.0063412688,
0.052324295,
0.0183718745,
0.0039493209,
-0.0141275413,
-0.0600140542,
-0.0421366058,
0.0157715883,
0.0076246085,
-0.0216142032,
0.0087339776,
-0.0754221529,
0.0098957093,
0.0192164574,
-0.0148022445,
0.0014978789,
-0.0496226698,
-0.0499654636,
-0.010796316,
0.0296837576,
-0.0008993466,
-0.0084155416,
0.0677280203,
0.0179595817,
0.006033753,
-0.0698225498,
0.0002037526,
-0.0257867444,
0.0119069535,
0.0565454103,
-0.0659152791,
0.0111126816,
0.005545611,
-0.0248233359,
0.0349997059,
0.0642537773,
0.0677035153,
0.0359262004,
-0.004787297,
0.0299346335,
-0.0375993103,
-0.0735779032,
0.0429282635,
0.0350570008,
-0.0346289948,
-0.0147800073,
0.129379198,
0.0584870502,
0.0004746467,
0.0304781143,
0.0105125494,
0.0260663517,
-0.0096867671,
0.0009427346,
-0.0757019669,
-0.0267485231,
0.0190156084,
-0.0026581162,
-0.0373957232,
-0.0268213451,
-0.0097334087,
-0.0995458737,
0.027793847,
-0.0017655718,
-0.0598342195,
-0.0118114557,
-0.0315841362,
0.0031370078,
0.0269193165,
0.0147880185,
0.043891672,
-0.0198716912,
0.07516101,
0.0211297013,
-0.0447132178,
-0.0186466277,
-0.0229770597,
-0.0401941203,
0.0231838003,
0.053285189,
-0.0071367421,
-0.039722085,
-0.0390887931,
0.0375779048,
-0.0030101116,
-0.0249694139,
-0.0069730207,
-0.0039597522,
0.0268261731,
-0.0076585957,
-0.0158996694,
-0.0157791357,
-0.0510270894,
-0.0300375,
0.0065896376,
0.0617076382,
-0.0055518537,
-0.0269626658,
-0.015084953,
0.0231862273,
-0.0113676935,
0.0723967254,
0.0274139512,
-0.0165496115,
-0.0436989404,
-0.0268854145,
0.0321464129,
0.0137818269,
-0.0090227667,
-0.0340035409,
0.0324648879,
-0.061790932,
-0.0360566005,
-0.0353815518,
0.044706054,
0.0502695851,
0.0060302536,
0.0524060987,
-0.0114967013,
0.0052376939,
-0.0136663215,
-0.0123792654,
0.0127966171,
0.0159790181,
-0.0843745768,
0.0300419778,
0.0346199982,
0.0081760576,
-0.0366926901,
0.0234450698,
-0.0682906285,
-0.0660602078,
0.0173326768,
0.0146579826,
0.0402807929,
-0.0451358669,
-0.017285794,
-0.0480868667,
-0.0399159342,
0.0410130136,
0.013562493,
0.0294828974,
-0.0130963959,
0.0156054283,
0.0176372267,
0.0112046553,
0.008176635,
-0.0162535347,
-0.0136783933,
0.0811501592,
-0.0107304119,
-0.0054572606,
0.0253975671,
0.0092401896,
0.0813697278,
-0.0621815808,
0.0157919377,
-0.022517262,
-0.027754819,
-0.04572827,
-0.0032584053,
-0.009298279,
-0.0102808606,
0.031082768,
0.0323651358,
-0.0774555802,
-0.0264329482,
-0.0632972345,
0.0292716417,
0.0128517393,
-0.0198386181,
0.0193509422,
-0.0216736402,
0.0184685588,
-0.0335361771,
0.0290304404,
0.007333166,
-0.0176783949,
0.0232460331,
-0.0004380329,
0.0099770771,
-0.0097890729,
-0.0168583728,
-0.0285873227,
-0.0163248945,
-0.053439945,
-0.0421891697,
0.0196912177,
0.0560335927,
-0.0038001924,
-0.0275885221,
0.0364633314,
-0.0478886962,
-0.0023687382,
-0.0302552152,
0.0057829418,
0.0279038791,
0.0041365903,
0.0339363031,
-0.0002699082,
-0.0355960354,
-0.0226647779,
0.0891624317,
0.0454322286,
0.0032592784,
0.0026822702,
-0.0790569037,
0.0029320486,
-0.0270521604,
0.0181188546,
0.0537807681,
-0.0040729926,
0.0226532519,
-0.1024512798,
-0.0624034107,
0.0047444026,
0.0356627256,
0.0380575247,
-0.0110551883,
-0.0071251383,
0.0842349604,
-0.0225547347,
-0.0203872751,
-0.0418866463,
0.0102794478,
-0.0045423722,
-0.0280892774,
-0.0117118275,
-6.343636814e-33,
-0.0139301922,
-0.0336093232,
-0.0273917057,
0.0224376265,
-0.0016485491,
-0.0310278926,
-0.026498666,
0.0445348211,
0.0230348334,
0.0141623421,
-0.0360009037,
0.0254573766,
0.02676218,
0.0284927636,
0.0331231579,
0.0068936506,
-0.0225648377,
0.0084479544,
-0.017070232,
-0.0590304881,
-0.0021261026,
0.0198889114,
0.0615710877,
-0.0159948561,
0.0558845997,
0.0051994738,
0.0015499438,
0.0111762099,
0.017048154,
0.0243009254,
-0.017118264,
0.0516852178,
0.0101180794,
-0.0175137371,
-0.0105058551,
0.0146153988,
0.0010315479,
-0.0702379718,
0.0829621032,
0.0044139586,
-0.0172333773,
-0.0117142927,
0.021690486,
0.0058244546,
-0.0531864055,
0.024754867,
0.0339123756,
0.0101883961,
-0.040093977,
0.0149783567,
-0.0560144708,
0.0278421734,
0.0039391057,
0.0131187243,
0.0188197512,
-0.0690789074,
-0.0102205183,
-0.0151380887,
0.0067058946,
0.0303222984,
0.03434892,
0.0665569752,
0.0443111248,
0.0166990813,
0.0063649653,
0.0384088121,
0.0447339341,
-0.0120940041,
0.0236656666,
0.0042631757,
0.0529490858,
-0.0294735227,
0.0157169793,
0.0302921161,
0.0866172388,
-0.0005213845,
-0.0327331014,
0.0025882735,
0.0510261208,
-0.0044907019,
0.0280652307,
0.0227507725,
-0.0605221838,
-0.0532294437,
-0.0454990156,
-0.051580783,
-0.0112430891,
-0.0098641198,
0.0266811661,
-0.0443798788,
0.0160028115,
-0.0165771246,
-0.0023095356,
-0.0086702136,
-0.0569913052,
-0.0298173595,
0.005193823,
0.015279565,
-0.0174704418,
0.0667821988,
-0.0273913909,
0.0087507144,
-0.0038604636,
0.0241037831,
-0.0011900131,
-0.0093853055,
-0.0144553548,
-0.0051017357,
-0.0757348835,
-0.0074182884,
-0.0153400181,
-0.0109617319,
0.013648144,
-0.016164571,
0.0433699489,
0.0084949322,
0.0033947676,
-0.0427818857,
0.0434014946,
-0.0041890405,
-0.0288934503,
-0.0144300265,
-0.0454937853,
-0.0051030214,
-0.0241876356,
-0.0165873785,
-0.0274916813,
0.0257439483,
0.0157909896,
-0.0503463708,
-0.0208503027,
0.0341594033,
2.752e-7,
0.1190666854,
0.0582702458,
0.0328797437,
0.0248711314,
0.0272153076,
-0.0061030756,
-0.0138097061,
0.0130835399,
0.0333200432,
0.0205993969,
0.0120825674,
0.0053685089,
0.0166830029,
-0.0102921426,
-0.0501670949,
0.0266872458,
-0.023542067,
0.0507510342,
-0.0631086826,
0.0051048002,
0.0199755598,
0.082748279,
0.0356127135,
0.0076813805,
-0.0388616249,
-0.0522708371,
0.0124092381,
-0.0177178644,
-0.0028727225,
0.0181995351,
0.0038577137,
0.0180147253,
0.0457661226,
0.0322306491,
0.0031172116,
0.0211658869,
0.0795495659,
0.002435613,
-0.0238150153,
0.0285239872,
-0.0201046132,
-0.0179439615,
0.0061208881,
-0.0782589838,
0.074840568,
0.005087446,
-0.0177071095,
0.0145714879,
-0.0402291119,
-0.0089624301,
0.0293129347,
-0.0059743202,
-0.0614171214,
0.0137498742,
0.0179651082,
0.0068893475,
-0.009590934,
-0.0310188774,
-0.0198255368,
-0.0219906587,
-0.0381655283,
-0.0555559695,
-0.0144297397,
0.0282237101,
0.0131118549,
-0.053466484,
-0.0532553867,
2.616486499e-34,
0.0615098327,
0.0166279729,
0.0165838543,
0.0058343983,
0.048395317,
0.0075824121,
0.0619860664,
0.0370843075,
0.0218871608,
-0.0730944574,
-0.0446515791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14553v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14553v1 | xCOMET-lite: Bridging the Gap Between Efficiency and Quality in Learned MT Evaluation Metrics | 2024-06-20T17:58:34 | 2024-06-20T17:58:34 | Daniil Larionov, Mikhail Seleznyov, Vasiliy Viskov, Alexander Panchenko, Steffen Eger | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art trainable machine translation evaluation metrics like xCOMET
achieve high correlation with human judgment but rely on large encoders (up to
10.7B parameters), making them computationally expensive and inaccessible to
researchers with limited resources. To address this issue, we investigate
whether the knowledge stored in these large encoders can be compressed while
maintaining quality. We employ distillation, quantization, and pruning
techniques to create efficient xCOMET alternatives and introduce a novel data
collection pipeline for efficient black-box distillation. Our experiments show
that, using quantization, xCOMET can be compressed up to three times with no
quality degradation. Additionally, through distillation, we create an
xCOMET-lite metric, which has only 2.6% of xCOMET-XXL parameters, but retains
92.1% of its quality. Besides, it surpasses strong small-scale metrics like
COMET-22 and BLEURT-20 on the WMT22 metrics challenge dataset by 6.4%, despite
using 50% fewer parameters. All code, dataset, and models are available online. | [
-0.0394016206,
0.089318119,
0.0314455293,
0.0289597642,
-0.0071758274,
0.0326147191,
-0.0148218907,
0.0684333146,
-0.052857969,
0.0410156175,
-0.0351453535,
-0.0146759162,
0.0256490111,
0.050049413,
0.0022571783,
-0.0434214696,
-0.0145398881,
-0.0043318635,
-0.0257207863,
-0.0058073625,
-0.0276258048,
-0.0307918135,
0.0193095282,
0.0236709118,
0.0096472213,
0.0146356625,
0.0185933728,
0.0187016241,
0.0505901016,
-0.0247152243,
-0.0375450738,
0.061042767,
0.0092627211,
0.0582850762,
0.000002148,
-0.0167807173,
-0.0376095995,
-0.0124967042,
-0.0361556187,
0.0167607162,
0.0214957502,
-0.0540399998,
-0.0128501449,
0.0064714132,
-0.0347981639,
-0.0125313867,
0.075422734,
-0.041416917,
0.0741112307,
0.0757939965,
0.0010171647,
0.0126224644,
-0.0101633044,
-0.0319490097,
0.0050405976,
-0.0083351778,
-0.0196000598,
0.0353807546,
-0.0796871409,
0.0428664424,
-0.0188844372,
0.0415274575,
0.0490071587,
0.0191406142,
0.015407878,
0.0222201794,
-0.0743112937,
-0.041765742,
-0.0158477519,
0.0634504259,
-0.0160981677,
0.0018583896,
-0.0262014512,
0.0082097417,
-0.0347104967,
-0.096641995,
-0.0403160378,
0.003364536,
0.0055132089,
0.0156544708,
-0.0843602344,
0.0300812386,
0.0257884655,
-0.0102388123,
-0.038439136,
0.0222506952,
0.0027994697,
-0.03484606,
-0.0091866329,
0.0261840671,
-0.0216874108,
-0.0237445422,
-0.0145706479,
-0.0379865579,
-0.0174808092,
-0.0117748613,
-0.0146463132,
-0.022464972,
-0.0026349209,
-0.023862619,
0.0544858836,
0.0627062321,
0.0054733427,
0.0684367642,
-0.0189521369,
0.0891484991,
-0.006205033,
0.0275261831,
-0.0434978344,
-0.0117434077,
-0.0533064604,
0.0163708534,
-0.0027346949,
-0.0038015649,
-0.0120801628,
0.017585637,
-0.0568681955,
-0.0450782552,
-0.0222311281,
-0.0015532785,
0.0322828256,
0.0087219719,
-0.0632208884,
-0.0086993165,
-0.0140119148,
0.0510405339,
-0.0299097653,
-0.020973878,
0.0345810205,
-0.0620155595,
-0.0570552945,
0.029869752,
-0.024277905,
-0.0061953412,
0.0306551177,
0.0616453849,
-0.0203944687,
-0.042882029,
0.0433231182,
-0.0206933413,
-0.0203971863,
-0.0702594966,
0.0149838701,
-0.0517088287,
0.0431891344,
0.0085964231,
0.0021324877,
-0.0407460369,
0.002616127,
-0.0315033346,
-0.0022639912,
0.0441958606,
0.0180326365,
-0.0160084013,
-0.0127219064,
0.0202339198,
-0.0292445067,
0.0855822712,
0.0474034697,
0.0927766711,
0.0079626413,
-0.0093718385,
-0.0206092484,
0.0022354531,
0.0511403643,
0.0796224028,
-0.0829987228,
0.0269334856,
-0.0308457259,
0.0736600086,
0.0684427619,
0.0251546185,
-0.0641576275,
-0.0090216063,
0.0525494628,
-0.0105769858,
0.0365008898,
0.0193568934,
0.0019913053,
0.0025178154,
-0.0149078602,
-0.0144351162,
-0.0007016126,
0.0747988075,
-0.0016773539,
-0.0517774858,
0.0802310035,
0.0417536832,
-0.0056750639,
-0.0515018404,
-0.008677219,
0.0005418783,
0.0108625013,
-0.0337709785,
0.0165989231,
-0.0012399219,
0.0022068198,
0.0689207464,
0.0191548336,
-0.0674718991,
0.0005721179,
-0.0253080986,
-0.0065379669,
0.0123241562,
0.0351316631,
0.0213550795,
0.0156165222,
0.0010030265,
0.0035015487,
0.0292678829,
0.033280503,
0.0072969729,
0.0445093364,
-0.0458876193,
-0.0932211205,
-0.0124022253,
0.002767819,
0.0074882088,
0.0314605162,
0.0279397741,
0.035090588,
-0.0607000254,
-0.0086399103,
0.0148773743,
0.0311366189,
-0.0730034187,
0.0489228517,
0.0180820096,
0.0920599923,
-0.0121561997,
-0.0156161338,
-0.0216312893,
0.0224111304,
-0.0196962915,
-0.0181754734,
-0.0158259533,
0.0086775776,
-0.0293203127,
0.0230979398,
-0.064249903,
0.0082772989,
0.0790530592,
-0.0468381308,
-0.0372147001,
-0.0045934836,
-0.0366869345,
0.0056807194,
-0.0227966588,
0.0192204826,
-0.0284134895,
0.0439270325,
-0.0149303293,
0.0115634734,
-0.0700002089,
0.0051268386,
-0.0037837492,
-0.0412531197,
0.0161594506,
0.0197388921,
0.0003400737,
0.0263486207,
0.0399316214,
0.0285181887,
0.0373237282,
0.0252708718,
-0.0269202124,
-0.0185867399,
-0.0120342411,
0.0132591315,
-0.0370395742,
0.0135920746,
0.0530216061,
0.0052548908,
0.0135337403,
-0.0023555958,
-0.0029742948,
-0.009495711,
-0.0161295813,
0.004956441,
-0.0146965319,
-0.0157850459,
0.0048975488,
0.0049354881,
-0.0428870879,
0.0405874774,
0.0473437123,
-0.036869891,
0.0028840355,
-0.0684012026,
0.0289665908,
-0.0218562856,
-0.0509604514,
-0.0052982527,
-0.0639081299,
0.0365889706,
-0.014434821,
-0.0391379073,
0.0368244611,
-0.0007428949,
0.0219335537,
0.0526916683,
0.019494012,
-0.0329076983,
-0.0197303165,
-0.0370466746,
-0.0441950224,
0.0135994013,
-0.0401076749,
0.0141273756,
0.011343807,
-0.0216673668,
0.0293981787,
-0.0520099252,
0.019647155,
0.0040911976,
-0.0501238219,
-0.0463622212,
0.0249072593,
-0.0086231157,
0.0357957333,
-0.0174425431,
-0.0901685283,
0.0577472411,
-0.0368777961,
-0.006675771,
-0.0462020785,
0.0100430623,
-0.0016130876,
0.0186755508,
-0.0111849345,
0.0323825739,
-0.0414465703,
0.0112333335,
-0.0283037182,
0.0153536405,
-0.0319390036,
-0.0245760903,
-0.0350972675,
-0.0417610705,
-0.0361323506,
-0.0160558168,
-0.0120388707,
-0.0011861781,
0.0297851805,
0.0190309975,
0.0086782807,
0.0286611076,
-0.0555957109,
-0.0319168158,
0.0105209053,
0.0270171426,
0.0311714634,
-0.0181482248,
-0.0161337629,
-0.0046851672,
0.006226134,
0.0060685468,
0.0328392163,
0.0689998046,
-0.0467847027,
-0.0223833174,
0.0493858531,
0.0168026015,
0.0117390295,
-0.0201343987,
-0.0065338169,
0.025376603,
0.0437344871,
0.0063663474,
0.0060606771,
0.0812686831,
-0.0489699803,
0.0028705073,
0.0469150804,
0.0074947327,
-0.0506573133,
0.0108810002,
0.0256037395,
0.0699649602,
0.0117307324,
-0.0327056758,
-0.0803795531,
-0.0254887063,
-0.0006070164,
0.0360104479,
0.0189976469,
-0.0022688983,
0.0067612259,
-0.053949926,
0.0211507399,
0.05561129,
-0.0337587483,
-0.0475365818,
-0.034578573,
-0.0056969645,
-0.0636123493,
0.0274322368,
0.0251242034,
0.020081779,
-0.0193762295,
0.0174926631,
0.0371731445,
-0.0793117359,
0.0183732025,
-0.0248471741,
0.0201441143,
0.035309121,
0.0294189341,
-0.0071734902,
-0.0650282651,
-0.0214574337,
-0.0067479503,
0.003552895,
0.0049855225,
0.0678303912,
0.0208363496,
-0.0177299064,
0.0385796092,
0.0492791571,
-0.0357457623,
0.0316462591,
-0.0251835994,
0.0471123978,
-0.0517307036,
-0.0073050074,
-0.0035607843,
-0.0543926954,
0.0182668809,
0.070041284,
0.0053411974,
0.0005146645,
-0.0332629383,
-0.0212742761,
-0.0012545808,
-0.046902962,
-0.0094538219,
0.0111147668,
-0.0092712017,
-0.0794812441,
-0.058401145,
-0.0009126242,
0.0113080395,
0.0628214329,
-0.033573743,
-0.0544726551,
-0.0171181262,
0.0127837146,
-0.0509474687,
0.0665131733,
-0.037492048,
-0.0106882313,
-0.0393333994,
-0.0030229378,
-0.0085789924,
0.0159226824,
-0.0156901553,
0.0350730792,
-0.1155215651,
-0.0302583538,
-0.0405545831,
0.0500069298,
0.0328633823,
0.0374214798,
0.0031746454,
-0.0154149756,
0.0782874301,
-0.009158982,
-0.0204785932,
0.0290577374,
0.0270543639,
-0.0389680117,
-0.019363068,
0.014928556,
-0.0080209076,
-0.0109599838,
0.0108726751,
0.0245119557,
-0.040234156,
-0.028061606,
0.0246136803,
-0.000232423,
0.0598068982,
-0.0533756204,
-0.0133712878,
0.0267404895,
0.0171762221,
0.0198057052,
0.0156562366,
-0.0647019222,
0.0137668056,
0.0623586327,
0.019642828,
0.0046369219,
0.0435674302,
0.0076636686,
-0.0427422747,
-0.0332854725,
0.0047015734,
-0.049272079,
0.011529739,
0.0377359912,
-0.0015279478,
-0.0030469315,
-0.0074524437,
-0.013830916,
0.0105251754,
0.0038783955,
0.0077625457,
0.0352632962,
0.0664793327,
0.0057223351,
0.0830147117,
-0.0385456532,
-0.0263751987,
-0.0827866197,
0.0064684018,
0.0510486364,
0.0426804498,
0.0794477165,
-0.0376652703,
-0.0231481344,
-0.0207812097,
0.0026558444,
-0.0020570899,
0.001048271,
0.0184150599,
-0.0024894157,
-0.011248,
0.0414976962,
0.069477804,
-0.0502400473,
0.0062398575,
-0.0480510518,
0.0080634858,
-0.0385532342,
-0.0222795792,
-0.0368311852,
-0.0170745589,
0.0346526988,
-0.0230592769,
0.0027962129,
-0.0333300158,
-0.0095311524,
0.0377581529,
-0.0178734306,
-0.0167959947,
0.0333926156,
0.059885513,
-0.0530438349,
-0.0283869989,
-0.0016822204,
-0.0594690964,
0.0082234852,
-0.0258377623,
0.0034762281,
-6.857372661e-33,
-0.0037932987,
0.0452786796,
-0.0024036455,
-0.0385159291,
-0.0238500591,
0.0094849393,
-0.0106431404,
-0.017933486,
0.011470275,
0.0042846864,
0.0324178189,
0.0194117334,
0.0145234279,
0.0001084425,
0.0116750458,
0.0239921119,
0.0866176262,
-0.0192041993,
-0.0813157484,
0.0332450233,
0.0535407625,
-0.01222621,
0.0577043928,
-0.0737529844,
-0.0264425892,
0.0354420431,
-0.0285465829,
0.0134794135,
0.0087854601,
0.0175768975,
-0.0075110439,
0.0225833487,
-0.0098890588,
-0.0531603768,
-0.0494474545,
-0.045313403,
-0.0269229431,
0.0131805893,
-0.0069375974,
0.0012990196,
-0.0277874004,
-0.0386911519,
0.0487323254,
-0.0022369022,
-0.0398158506,
-0.0378319137,
-0.0140516125,
-0.0594019219,
-0.0379134715,
-0.0265382212,
0.0229788907,
0.0318189822,
-0.0325484201,
-0.017535422,
0.0320634618,
0.025830308,
-0.044450216,
0.0354477428,
-0.062414065,
0.027801061,
0.0090111028,
0.062838383,
0.0742141232,
0.0006684515,
0.0250544474,
0.0540097058,
0.0403278768,
-0.0305703375,
0.0339452587,
0.0239719301,
0.0335092805,
0.0283563752,
0.0782995075,
0.0498440154,
0.0735519752,
-0.0341011137,
-0.0533981621,
0.0455660522,
-0.0322811529,
0.016985625,
0.0024917964,
0.0436211973,
0.0032326968,
0.0079796659,
-0.0226279479,
-0.0345579013,
-0.0170732494,
-0.0407222696,
-0.0022697684,
0.032228563,
-0.0500021577,
-0.0258129295,
0.0632325336,
-0.0342040472,
0.0483958125,
0.0344178192,
-0.0427574292,
0.0476760827,
0.0384876579,
0.0056975516,
-0.0053591612,
-0.0001509341,
0.0570185855,
0.0269449316,
0.040923018,
-0.0306492038,
0.0284768771,
0.0472941808,
-0.0241688117,
0.0027988711,
-0.0479454622,
-0.0238393676,
-0.0016771955,
-0.0253366306,
0.0223961398,
-0.0053364132,
-0.0011156249,
0.0007676726,
-0.0019627702,
0.0154590541,
-0.0284214839,
-0.0026246039,
0.0303180125,
0.0392766334,
-0.0399007834,
0.012389305,
-0.0272792093,
-0.0186396614,
0.0768049732,
-0.0412820391,
-0.0405853651,
0.0349972807,
2.795e-7,
0.0132770184,
0.0386029631,
-0.0030708315,
-0.0303015877,
0.0048103575,
0.0269536451,
-0.0348743014,
0.0124363983,
-0.0031278664,
-0.0523395464,
0.0297132134,
0.0201539397,
0.0862442553,
0.0590152293,
-0.0329888314,
-0.0128590018,
-0.0700166151,
-0.0230184179,
-0.0669919103,
-0.0390272439,
0.0679294318,
0.088581726,
0.0126883946,
-0.0154086975,
0.0423730277,
-0.0056022848,
0.0490889102,
-0.0243987069,
0.025640415,
0.0005604839,
0.0194780845,
-0.0003729912,
-0.0138634881,
0.0030177124,
-0.0049935873,
0.0127039421,
0.0348835923,
0.0927088931,
0.005730676,
-0.0540580265,
0.0203663576,
0.0159750748,
-0.0015448629,
-0.0205363669,
0.0442594141,
-0.00321116,
-0.0220806058,
-0.0220895801,
-0.0386160575,
0.0118386662,
0.0824130997,
-0.009736022,
0.00009145,
0.0188980773,
0.0108821895,
0.0155274523,
0.0111481324,
-0.0533229075,
-0.0050728167,
0.0214603283,
-0.0453531183,
-0.0798040256,
-0.0365280434,
-0.0232998673,
0.012187345,
-0.0255815871,
-0.0238943007,
2.638909283e-34,
0.0218767785,
-0.0238263123,
0.0522899143,
-0.0460910536,
0.0160504729,
-0.0217026845,
-0.0082564475,
-0.0470423996,
-0.0205703359,
-0.0444375724,
-0.0009589048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14550v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14550v1 | GraphReader: Building Graph-based Agent to Enhance Long-Context Abilities of Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T17:57:51 | 2024-06-20T17:57:51 | Shilong Li, Yancheng He, Hangyu Guo, Xingyuan Bu, Ge Bai, Jie Liu, Jiaheng Liu, Xingwei Qu, Yangguang Li, Wanli Ouyang, Wenbo Su, Bo Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Long-context capabilities are essential for large language models (LLMs) to
tackle complex and long-input tasks. Despite numerous efforts made to optimize
LLMs for long contexts, challenges persist in robustly processing long inputs.
In this paper, we introduce GraphReader, a graph-based agent system designed to
handle long texts by structuring them into a graph and employing an agent to
explore this graph autonomously. Upon receiving a question, the agent first
undertakes a step-by-step analysis and devises a rational plan. It then invokes
a set of predefined functions to read node content and neighbors, facilitating
a coarse-to-fine exploration of the graph. Throughout the exploration, the
agent continuously records new insights and reflects on current circumstances
to optimize the process until it has gathered sufficient information to
generate an answer. Experimental results on the LV-Eval dataset reveal that
GraphReader, using a 4k context window, consistently outperforms GPT-4-128k
across context lengths from 16k to 256k by a large margin. Additionally, our
approach demonstrates superior performance on four challenging single-hop and
multi-hop benchmarks. | [
0.0169381313,
0.0175446868,
-0.016579276,
0.0674241036,
-0.0523939021,
-0.0080661681,
0.0081340587,
0.000617952,
0.0854389295,
-0.0385511369,
0.0006228719,
-0.0375333726,
-0.0266962871,
0.0535137579,
-0.0071308734,
-0.0309125334,
0.0295962468,
-0.0492597632,
0.0327824987,
-0.0006310092,
-0.0036387807,
0.0073253927,
0.0317943841,
0.0087596569,
-0.0123226652,
-0.0290898979,
-0.0424695499,
0.0043232935,
0.0030372406,
-0.0557221286,
-0.0304548144,
0.014140063,
0.0151449014,
0.0612719096,
0.0000019178,
-0.025079485,
-0.0361991674,
0.0096563948,
-0.037933141,
0.008483964,
0.0761581957,
-0.021784801,
-0.0108077116,
0.0035889007,
-0.0471983962,
-0.0111050913,
0.0143943271,
0.0083656274,
0.0330094844,
0.0779552758,
-0.0121064102,
-0.0303743929,
0.025326144,
-0.0121043203,
-0.0052462672,
-0.1016314626,
0.0315226838,
-0.0072392756,
0.0539329275,
0.0049852831,
-0.0550680347,
0.0345218666,
0.0382086225,
-0.0170857441,
0.0065994179,
0.0430706292,
0.0007276889,
0.0137014305,
-0.0046736537,
0.1025672331,
-0.0113214115,
0.0011126024,
-0.0006363025,
-0.0127689922,
0.0016015851,
0.0010963446,
-0.0434780531,
-0.010276393,
-0.0365432352,
0.008823581,
0.0176660698,
-0.0402701348,
0.0295868702,
0.0160367768,
-0.0763520226,
0.0896700025,
-0.0038140893,
-0.0164907146,
0.0008830139,
0.0020357603,
-0.0116458442,
-0.0369041599,
0.0316936672,
0.0502756797,
-0.0527876392,
0.0424010456,
-0.0265402179,
-0.0154746426,
0.0002132678,
-0.000480054,
0.0078446548,
0.0237922091,
-0.0012169197,
0.0686333999,
-0.0133417556,
0.0249955449,
-0.0401697345,
0.0210961476,
-0.0408406369,
-0.0183745064,
-0.0353430249,
0.0071467781,
-0.0534198955,
0.0193730555,
-0.0540950932,
-0.0651042014,
-0.0048478772,
0.0642043948,
0.031547226,
0.0000158755,
0.0064049033,
-0.0202052426,
0.0162857249,
-0.0256960485,
-0.0112871174,
0.0382349789,
-0.0366871096,
-0.0181600936,
-0.0022334114,
-0.0106027359,
-0.0046696365,
0.0069047753,
0.0652437136,
-0.0485677086,
-0.0044322694,
0.090416044,
0.0135252187,
-0.0658823922,
-0.0239115562,
-0.021355154,
-0.0273241773,
-0.0706303641,
-0.031824775,
-0.0757526457,
0.0289629437,
0.0417851172,
-0.0049447808,
-0.0250767861,
0.0053121895,
0.0174435209,
-0.0304453969,
0.0643471554,
-0.0046256431,
0.0108529162,
0.0148208477,
-0.0071764016,
0.0079141334,
0.0601330958,
0.0071333763,
0.0274224915,
0.0486313179,
0.0127485422,
-0.0122636985,
0.0558780171,
0.0041866349,
0.0047999928,
0.0221049991,
0.0279732179,
-0.0283204671,
0.0254938044,
-0.0099952826,
0.0714556575,
-0.0386741273,
-0.0408708006,
0.0411105789,
0.0753981844,
0.0257287081,
-0.0233180914,
0.0465505347,
0.0568413436,
-0.0311523806,
0.0075711184,
-0.0586066693,
0.0028271305,
0.0004086345,
0.0328358933,
0.0052795364,
-0.0005959498,
0.0149406698,
-0.0085367877,
0.0020856615,
0.0067746066,
0.0575429201,
0.0123943537,
0.0567573905,
-0.0193169788,
-0.0554466732,
-0.0062425407,
0.0187524054,
-0.0360282324,
-0.0076320725,
-0.0200043917,
0.0129430927,
0.1116435304,
0.0509866923,
-0.0165742263,
-0.0345933214,
0.0051204748,
0.0250021275,
0.0390017144,
0.0354676098,
-0.0228128694,
-0.0059647504,
-0.0398198515,
-0.0232051294,
0.0030505203,
-0.0050653759,
0.0347043127,
0.0401478037,
0.0238162875,
0.0128203006,
-0.0476975478,
-0.0178811252,
0.0077515203,
-0.0095809288,
-0.0290399212,
-0.0294782035,
0.0032125753,
-0.01083316,
0.0440953523,
-0.0035312821,
0.0262594596,
0.0257614329,
-0.0135625964,
-0.0013462733,
-0.0260864031,
-0.0641448721,
-0.0373186097,
0.0558016375,
-0.0090006171,
-0.0237524882,
-0.0025662775,
-0.0175195131,
-0.0531397052,
-0.0024216911,
-0.0599919558,
0.0590584464,
-0.0026273881,
0.0177070554,
-0.0241347067,
-0.0056614177,
-0.0274899211,
0.0564479157,
0.0159688536,
-0.0068531022,
0.0175935756,
0.0719121248,
-0.0120521327,
-0.0411293805,
-0.0009590612,
0.0334111005,
0.028344851,
0.0004431724,
0.0231540576,
-0.0009422723,
-0.0529145114,
-0.0023870133,
-0.1179360747,
0.0013534594,
-0.0270832237,
0.0284156054,
0.005893671,
0.0146288555,
-0.0150876064,
-0.0083146431,
-0.0333866887,
0.0605961531,
0.0083050905,
0.0391156338,
0.0019583176,
0.0209461804,
-0.0284640454,
-0.032915283,
-0.0412020981,
-0.0296460483,
0.0397352874,
0.0173755065,
-0.0311365854,
-0.0391649082,
0.0217074025,
0.0130761582,
0.0272121448,
-0.0147732338,
0.0026723987,
0.0031397685,
-0.0572631657,
0.0359568112,
0.0530282445,
-0.0118084289,
0.0293597039,
0.0211059507,
-0.0308192279,
-0.0371735655,
0.0141004408,
-0.0297108106,
0.0007841379,
-0.0825724229,
0.0275989268,
-0.0230097044,
0.0483483039,
-0.0148505764,
-0.0041945265,
-0.0188849028,
-0.0167966671,
-0.024898421,
0.0027932031,
-0.0159190595,
-0.0176230054,
-0.0358056352,
0.0252953712,
-0.0331941545,
-0.02637632,
0.0898511559,
-0.0269387476,
-0.0069408361,
-0.0240591113,
-0.0272250082,
-0.0693623498,
0.1190362051,
0.0348282531,
0.012182883,
-0.0448095351,
-0.0500138216,
-0.0263700485,
0.0198645461,
0.0165251717,
-0.0232208334,
0.0683744699,
-0.0142333005,
0.0325160809,
0.0009031464,
-0.025442576,
-0.0227429774,
0.0032754859,
-0.0540778823,
-0.0023940164,
0.0304875989,
-0.0272768456,
0.0014930189,
0.0060548401,
-0.0029544954,
0.0687495023,
-0.0328570828,
0.0134739252,
-0.0376641862,
0.0403731652,
0.0524735525,
-0.0145693822,
0.0216977261,
-0.0368306078,
0.0741736293,
0.0665106848,
0.018419018,
-0.0406811722,
0.0015950834,
-0.0087209791,
-0.0022490614,
-0.0280815326,
-0.0101339836,
-0.0109104654,
0.0465571731,
-0.1094799861,
-0.0022796211,
0.0994361863,
0.0305230077,
-0.0870941728,
-0.0168455038,
-0.0292357299,
0.0234119501,
0.0248484984,
0.0287042782,
-0.0840708092,
-0.0360553376,
-0.0076579419,
0.0161662642,
0.0130575281,
-0.0655940548,
-0.0000499575,
-0.1160311997,
0.0105282208,
0.024480043,
-0.021776896,
-0.0092812888,
-0.0410611518,
-0.004844449,
0.0175720118,
0.0212036557,
0.0429153964,
-0.0206785891,
-0.0173446517,
-0.0290143695,
0.0239405371,
0.0042571686,
0.0363841914,
-0.0171273816,
0.0209033582,
0.0133455815,
0.027477948,
0.0187164191,
0.0249573737,
0.073234126,
-0.0178877451,
-0.002388485,
-0.0055201412,
0.0224711467,
-0.0276302528,
0.0077513582,
-0.0155830253,
0.0229957979,
-0.0358418263,
-0.0016186121,
0.0228442308,
0.1061319336,
0.0075280624,
-0.0160193592,
-0.001257007,
-0.0425635949,
-0.0012637693,
0.0322076716,
0.0446103588,
-0.0073520429,
-0.0938871875,
-0.0363774821,
-0.0376548171,
-0.068677105,
-0.0208314378,
0.0318794884,
-0.019324623,
0.0204397254,
-0.0327935778,
-0.0643650219,
0.0549007878,
0.0133042606,
-0.0073517114,
0.0260546077,
0.0523954891,
-0.0126817692,
-0.0813901275,
0.00733857,
-0.0419578813,
0.0518762618,
-0.0381741636,
0.0141348811,
0.0178103186,
-0.009599152,
0.0029940458,
0.0509899482,
-0.0696994662,
-0.0780778378,
-0.0095579121,
-0.0278091803,
0.0173138697,
0.0717829913,
-0.041413758,
-0.019317694,
0.044646468,
-0.0080186529,
-0.0734690502,
-0.018204404,
-0.0093329474,
0.0230128914,
-0.0086490568,
0.0451614372,
-0.0420503207,
-0.0011010815,
-0.0005928385,
0.049192097,
-0.0386471748,
-0.0306631457,
0.0092331963,
0.0378118716,
-0.0124966335,
0.0268800072,
0.0047938544,
-0.020258449,
0.0123959063,
-0.045645956,
-0.0019766609,
-0.0080991732,
0.0040099151,
0.0250861831,
-0.0380222313,
0.0118506122,
-0.028160518,
-0.0026514074,
0.0062763221,
-0.0431771204,
0.0408401676,
-0.0113938171,
-0.0322904587,
0.0754225776,
-0.0026140136,
-0.0118404413,
0.0045173047,
0.0163466111,
0.0281014238,
-0.0177614558,
0.0558542982,
0.0277931299,
-0.0612608157,
-0.0417745151,
0.0132035082,
-0.0837458,
-0.0151877729,
0.0101152537,
0.0306616127,
0.0369499736,
0.0212010983,
0.040958304,
-0.0267086476,
-0.0073806485,
-0.0292890556,
0.0283192713,
0.0244636424,
-0.0546736941,
0.0230434705,
0.0569093712,
-0.0047193756,
0.0199586246,
0.0408004336,
0.0386397466,
0.0253136009,
0.0443817936,
-0.0210736319,
-0.040787641,
-0.0369835384,
-0.0566949211,
0.046087347,
-0.021517856,
0.0242815446,
-0.0478104167,
-0.080240719,
-0.0012528518,
0.0028277214,
-0.0132779572,
-0.0315783396,
0.006718738,
0.0346844867,
0.0267942343,
-0.0207061749,
-0.0480695628,
0.0575643443,
-0.0310477223,
-0.0235396102,
0.0234844852,
-5.951510633e-33,
-0.0078244722,
-0.0919304788,
0.0557117164,
0.0149497949,
-0.0606899224,
0.0242189988,
-0.0567527451,
0.0054032383,
0.0011267952,
0.0060457201,
-0.0383306444,
0.0395842232,
0.009969552,
0.0420627855,
-0.0125299981,
-0.0177241508,
0.0212284289,
0.0141592668,
0.0193834342,
0.0315838307,
0.0284168068,
0.0495937802,
0.0032667799,
-0.0447308272,
0.0113535058,
-0.0138450647,
0.0493483171,
0.0311359614,
0.0135799488,
0.0599997193,
-0.0205322728,
0.0421458147,
0.0463408008,
-0.0168085583,
-0.0189265423,
0.0556499399,
-0.0947394669,
0.0026941735,
-0.001505063,
0.0177112184,
-0.0448167883,
-0.0304098912,
0.0191465467,
-0.0059029511,
0.028876733,
-0.0112272426,
0.0152811864,
-0.0118717728,
-0.0405438766,
0.0124279968,
-0.0593781993,
0.0681692734,
0.0143776964,
-0.0012374627,
0.0609034747,
-0.0071206652,
0.0280341618,
0.0044801128,
-0.0205108579,
0.0078089279,
-0.0148781082,
0.0121356603,
0.0274799261,
0.0186115559,
0.0165141858,
0.0298524424,
0.0109972786,
-0.0128845144,
-0.0341551974,
-0.0054420517,
0.0035431501,
0.0340786353,
-0.0077641346,
0.0317636952,
-0.0188357737,
-0.0249630082,
-0.0451184623,
-0.0169233382,
0.0352788754,
0.0209229551,
0.014212708,
0.0264047142,
-0.02269952,
-0.0242164675,
-0.0267441925,
-0.0096709114,
-0.039618127,
-0.0231666416,
0.0232766401,
-0.0007863918,
-0.0113476682,
-0.0006563364,
0.0456543192,
-0.0334988646,
-0.0170010682,
0.0653152615,
-0.0174117498,
0.0362347029,
-0.0099251615,
0.0695066899,
-0.0150503535,
-0.0070424378,
-0.0137082431,
-0.0077866847,
-0.0038173827,
-0.0019249322,
-0.006573488,
0.0043463795,
-0.0568025596,
-0.0190250538,
-0.0615302138,
0.0080751907,
-0.023796672,
0.0050053,
0.0572837815,
0.0137735382,
0.0140001969,
0.100095816,
0.0344477445,
0.0243776236,
-0.0157208834,
0.0017648587,
0.000158721,
0.0024146943,
-0.037478663,
-0.0065968246,
-0.0301637799,
0.0368915871,
0.0278768595,
-0.0667899773,
0.015246436,
0.0257773697,
2.63e-7,
0.0430453047,
0.0668213665,
0.0555315949,
0.0207811575,
0.0290407371,
0.0047112303,
-0.004203788,
0.0219107866,
-0.0302364379,
-0.0235381201,
0.0214687027,
0.0284163002,
-0.0061727269,
0.0384164117,
-0.0965254977,
0.0145003945,
-0.0295601878,
-0.0144143654,
-0.0765156075,
0.0243929904,
0.0642781705,
0.0854779482,
-0.0085962433,
-0.0000769231,
0.0024683205,
-0.0674728677,
0.019779427,
-0.0054228846,
-0.0029742662,
-0.0034408313,
-0.034984719,
-0.0011283581,
0.0001133281,
0.0082054427,
0.0301332287,
0.0464819111,
-0.0077835214,
0.0865672082,
0.0081641404,
-0.0140436841,
0.0291509014,
-0.0555072725,
-0.0114732645,
-0.0341451913,
0.0695244521,
-0.0304184649,
-0.0315156132,
-0.0150485961,
-0.0175911207,
-0.047338102,
-0.0514254384,
0.0024475509,
-0.0032199773,
0.0336772203,
0.0059346179,
-0.049437806,
0.0268129259,
-0.1020797715,
-0.0217320248,
-0.0070604803,
-0.0363955684,
-0.0316674337,
-0.0421553515,
0.0038841325,
0.0394735783,
-0.0331784189,
0.0022402741,
2.509975461e-34,
0.0459362119,
-0.0015773299,
-0.0021225018,
0.011926421,
0.0391993783,
-0.006737967,
-0.0393765233,
0.0244974215,
0.0407966822,
-0.1190415099,
-0.0459600724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14546v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14546v1 | Connecting the Dots: LLMs can Infer and Verbalize Latent Structure from Disparate Training Data | 2024-06-20T17:55:04 | 2024-06-20T17:55:04 | Johannes Treutlein, Dami Choi, Jan Betley, Cem Anil, Samuel Marks, Roger Baker Grosse, Owain Evans | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | One way to address safety risks from large language models (LLMs) is to
censor dangerous knowledge from their training data. While this removes the
explicit information, implicit information can remain scattered across various
training documents. Could an LLM infer the censored knowledge by piecing
together these implicit hints? As a step towards answering this question, we
study inductive out-of-context reasoning (OOCR), a type of generalization in
which LLMs infer latent information from evidence distributed across training
documents and apply it to downstream tasks without in-context learning. Using a
suite of five tasks, we demonstrate that frontier LLMs can perform inductive
OOCR. In one experiment we finetune an LLM on a corpus consisting only of
distances between an unknown city and other known cities. Remarkably, without
in-context examples or Chain of Thought, the LLM can verbalize that the unknown
city is Paris and use this fact to answer downstream questions. Further
experiments show that LLMs trained only on individual coin flip outcomes can
verbalize whether the coin is biased, and those trained only on pairs
$(x,f(x))$ can articulate a definition of $f$ and compute inverses. While OOCR
succeeds in a range of cases, we also show that it is unreliable, particularly
for smaller LLMs learning complex structures. Overall, the ability of LLMs to
"connect the dots" without explicit in-context learning poses a potential
obstacle to monitoring and controlling the knowledge acquired by LLMs. | [
0.0069515817,
0.0446856208,
-0.0219462179,
0.0426473655,
-0.0290600508,
0.0690686703,
-0.0409380496,
0.0137071945,
-0.0175541714,
-0.0350010172,
-0.029094087,
-0.0175097696,
0.0045040608,
-0.0110366512,
0.0610845424,
-0.0317687765,
0.0224673934,
-0.0697851777,
-0.0046720989,
-0.0154307606,
-0.0197301544,
0.0049865409,
-0.007953248,
0.0083238846,
0.0087893503,
-0.0126527157,
0.0019460303,
-0.0304586329,
-0.0027421878,
-0.022262523,
0.0201045088,
-0.0031479385,
0.0583766215,
0.0159178153,
0.0000020928,
-0.0391489677,
-0.0088627981,
-0.0161048584,
-0.0153296366,
-0.055644583,
-0.018841859,
-0.034505114,
0.0118841287,
0.0128651271,
-0.0379821025,
-0.0284782071,
0.0466926098,
0.0554892756,
-0.0014186887,
0.0820493549,
0.0112031223,
-0.0347281322,
0.0417769775,
-0.008748115,
0.0278526098,
-0.0065690624,
0.0272179917,
-0.0162644573,
-0.0401144661,
0.012602306,
-0.0406341329,
0.0068132756,
0.0126279164,
0.0315118618,
-0.0270967446,
0.0374318324,
-0.0149980141,
-0.0291725062,
-0.0009750286,
0.0778404921,
-0.0175540205,
-0.0194670781,
0.0109901093,
-0.0132039245,
-0.0039372062,
0.0259536821,
-0.067931354,
0.0717374086,
-0.0369203612,
0.0370933488,
0.0290105697,
-0.0201747231,
0.0743040293,
0.0170323476,
-0.0167067889,
0.0802396759,
-0.0199776758,
-0.0511557981,
0.0215451159,
0.0167206135,
-0.0562517382,
-0.0407722332,
-0.0145202642,
0.0466239229,
-0.0228230897,
0.054170534,
0.0089281229,
0.0245830156,
0.0301555581,
-0.059058208,
0.0223121271,
0.030189896,
-0.0325368978,
0.0626916289,
-0.0353761464,
-0.0069248211,
-0.0484276749,
0.0606325865,
-0.0130714262,
0.012509739,
-0.0545175411,
-0.0209423993,
0.0320578627,
0.0384268463,
-0.0111753223,
0.0219567902,
0.0037406024,
0.0389825031,
-0.0355665982,
0.0221425053,
-0.0357767455,
0.0142258303,
-0.0039664824,
-0.0212763697,
-0.0506706834,
-0.0165423099,
-0.0106570451,
0.0651584715,
0.0130931344,
-0.0316259451,
-0.0395471007,
0.0201875903,
0.0013460818,
0.0146193653,
-0.0116716903,
0.0889194161,
0.0044511622,
-0.0369812921,
-0.0621607415,
-0.0514282659,
-0.007162082,
-0.0644049272,
0.0317948014,
-0.0611439086,
-0.0091208229,
0.0287073757,
-0.0215921476,
-0.0375481844,
0.0086526508,
0.0141201541,
-0.0653588027,
0.0762998164,
-0.0098400749,
0.0068063643,
0.0153496191,
0.0225534793,
-0.0232446678,
0.0683266521,
0.000085454,
0.018006729,
0.0033928899,
0.0313860402,
0.0001646884,
0.0142670842,
0.0292930044,
0.0273361225,
-0.0285736229,
0.0088431714,
0.0253564119,
-0.0035452503,
0.0085117174,
0.0349288471,
-0.0510743186,
-0.0029024987,
0.0690380633,
0.0402610786,
0.0179884247,
-0.023078043,
0.0653371513,
-0.0217629131,
0.005511954,
0.0488926098,
-0.0762568861,
-0.0008546169,
-0.0564028695,
0.0054841754,
0.0316468738,
-0.0073452629,
-0.0270214099,
-0.0324685238,
-0.0379735008,
-0.0130831981,
0.0004995103,
0.0369343124,
0.0984390303,
0.0596964806,
-0.024257293,
0.0323454924,
0.0672539547,
-0.0034792393,
-0.0027382514,
-0.0354234762,
0.0342296921,
0.0377007872,
0.0407576859,
-0.037336655,
0.0014456555,
-0.027269274,
0.0328650847,
0.0111379148,
0.0375120379,
-0.0260488763,
0.0196789317,
-0.0419337973,
-0.0275869928,
0.0013489311,
0.0260778684,
-0.0134652294,
0.0191038437,
-0.0330493338,
-0.0045042951,
-0.0300733112,
0.0218753647,
0.0574355423,
-0.0393915661,
-0.0499515906,
-0.0391424261,
0.0127022807,
0.0133791473,
-0.02210957,
0.0156383291,
0.0038333929,
0.0333540998,
-0.0099116098,
-0.0249994732,
-0.0047873869,
-0.0507632829,
-0.0247659031,
0.01131933,
-0.0327958055,
-0.0345526598,
-0.0327225216,
-0.0502956323,
-0.0236099903,
0.0232584998,
-0.031183213,
0.0614932962,
-0.0329534709,
0.0099120559,
0.0193487462,
-0.0217179656,
-0.0179933328,
0.1197953597,
-0.0378481299,
-0.0027426872,
-0.007067692,
0.0155670838,
-0.009187906,
-0.0428939722,
-0.0052387421,
-0.0517469421,
0.0000759006,
-0.0064898841,
-0.0079063335,
-0.020958975,
-0.027005285,
-0.0251497068,
-0.0550768897,
-0.0131413713,
-0.0137767838,
0.0163073856,
0.018470563,
-0.0163995195,
0.0182865933,
-0.010772137,
-0.0047914996,
0.0278756935,
-0.0066737169,
0.0506097488,
0.0541239232,
-0.0320898443,
0.005189518,
-0.0014282049,
-0.0083384393,
-0.0579283051,
0.0639919937,
-0.0052923756,
-0.0203883052,
-0.1001770869,
0.0459474176,
-0.0148418155,
0.0203471985,
-0.0463416688,
0.0184966065,
0.0406920277,
-0.0223373137,
0.0018241369,
0.0741896778,
-0.0110010663,
0.0156553462,
0.0811402649,
0.0061273077,
-0.0437440686,
-0.0162440799,
-0.0337622166,
-0.000256811,
-0.0490657017,
0.0022579243,
-0.0595448576,
0.0645847544,
0.0087186629,
-0.008442671,
-0.0210537743,
0.0063120793,
0.0076054283,
-0.0471878611,
-0.0527160503,
-0.0481560752,
-0.0043004882,
0.0548303202,
-0.0174589939,
-0.0727836564,
0.0745127499,
0.0119831031,
0.0255780499,
0.0009515675,
-0.0042733219,
-0.024813978,
0.0571670569,
0.0220686849,
-0.0062175067,
0.0201149173,
-0.0278844833,
-0.077717863,
-0.0271324087,
0.0135288984,
-0.0094587486,
0.0564777851,
-0.0600406639,
0.0160225537,
0.0125262169,
-0.0493319109,
-0.0588130169,
-0.04242149,
-0.0182544887,
0.0115170246,
-0.02093965,
-0.0013760452,
-0.0046933647,
0.007600842,
0.04326915,
0.0191295054,
-0.0038120132,
-0.0213690046,
-0.0252438933,
0.0009237927,
0.0222974811,
-0.0073629646,
0.0475233793,
-0.0682873055,
-0.0084405262,
0.06381993,
0.0143612539,
-0.0332886316,
-0.0312585309,
0.049178306,
0.0122702178,
-0.0034798821,
-0.0318527408,
0.0293695983,
0.0319108963,
-0.0678783208,
-0.0212863367,
0.0753744096,
0.0139413271,
-0.0358959846,
0.0009727804,
-0.0122303208,
-0.0155048128,
0.0307922754,
-0.0009668734,
-0.0917810202,
-0.0243668165,
0.0367542207,
-0.0050173583,
-0.0150939347,
-0.0593586154,
0.0237982012,
-0.0882840008,
0.0299410801,
0.0011424337,
-0.0320288278,
-0.0098293107,
-0.0602130257,
-0.0183232445,
-0.0046813111,
0.0002869492,
0.0153285898,
-0.0354233049,
-0.0139541002,
0.0162147656,
-0.0195074584,
-0.0411214903,
0.0046172072,
-0.0212032795,
0.0386207998,
0.0444380231,
0.0043754182,
-0.0006972213,
-0.0265009347,
0.0442841575,
0.0000044881,
0.0262224507,
-0.0204825085,
0.0482568592,
0.0217118021,
-0.0000174861,
0.0142314835,
0.0449237563,
-0.0382056348,
-0.0413111448,
0.0028074514,
0.076571919,
-0.0347486995,
-0.022744935,
0.0078545827,
0.0200058781,
0.0057225763,
0.0678879917,
0.0150861889,
0.0052691274,
-0.0253059473,
-0.0370749496,
-0.0136684431,
0.0330396742,
0.0022964415,
0.0260960702,
0.0343256555,
-0.0231748503,
-0.0550135672,
-0.0253677703,
0.0341017805,
0.0316222571,
0.0190880857,
0.002994878,
0.0160767492,
-0.010048084,
-0.0378449187,
0.0368540511,
-0.0474089533,
-0.0357600674,
0.0163369887,
0.0130736995,
0.0168672521,
-0.047086224,
-0.0332049727,
0.0367176458,
-0.0714239702,
-0.0956620798,
0.0160151422,
0.0515835732,
0.0307641607,
0.0601125807,
-0.0183028504,
-0.0621152371,
0.1067528874,
0.0022372897,
-0.0374231972,
0.0171398446,
0.0226942338,
-0.008959407,
0.0361227728,
0.0379459113,
-0.054618001,
0.009195555,
0.0590524487,
0.0254721642,
-0.0740508735,
0.0566950813,
0.0294974428,
-0.0269857943,
0.0862777829,
-0.0096930582,
-0.0002734826,
-0.0403782241,
0.0232232157,
0.012010131,
-0.0153143927,
-0.0221120156,
0.0265814494,
0.0343343876,
0.022268666,
-0.0078227147,
-0.0107013425,
0.0140420804,
0.0625404119,
0.0194479916,
0.0076665748,
0.0542013943,
0.0134366704,
0.0344195813,
0.0044998769,
-0.0100344103,
0.0662118644,
-0.0251247697,
0.033773046,
-0.0083986204,
0.0375554822,
0.0384189598,
0.0395929851,
-0.0359605849,
-0.0381878242,
-0.0957270861,
-0.025030857,
-0.0137854731,
0.0253987443,
0.033679422,
-0.0265302826,
0.0032861405,
-0.0232627336,
-0.0091466708,
-0.0006717789,
-0.0054532839,
-0.014032416,
-0.0344835334,
0.0496175475,
0.0390318632,
-0.0294287857,
0.0220280066,
0.097415559,
0.0035609899,
0.0630372837,
-0.009423878,
-0.0015270915,
-0.0172915682,
-0.0191566702,
0.0466430932,
0.0384558737,
-0.021586325,
0.0129926726,
-0.0273226649,
-0.0797375739,
-0.0180091746,
0.0216567423,
-0.0060751992,
-0.0179908741,
-0.002773169,
0.0648572817,
0.0079333186,
-0.0279352702,
0.002383674,
-0.0025582178,
0.0360670537,
-0.0135771735,
-0.0289080571,
-7.071527895e-33,
0.0053488943,
-0.0496420003,
0.0394330472,
0.0351847857,
0.035298124,
0.0026842433,
-0.0238380749,
0.0030266503,
-0.0247700289,
0.0316394456,
-0.0163765289,
0.0331072696,
0.0041416055,
0.0106062582,
0.0194409844,
-0.0393054225,
0.0035017242,
-0.0257980172,
0.009710636,
-0.003776496,
0.0629970729,
0.0160060301,
0.0586683564,
-0.0905805826,
0.0630388409,
-0.0136284195,
-0.0257170573,
0.0648465902,
-0.0350081213,
0.0398934931,
-0.0020648285,
0.0109927608,
0.028548304,
-0.0299797487,
-0.0149092488,
0.0331511572,
-0.092037648,
-0.034991432,
0.0376590565,
-0.0298055075,
-0.024838265,
-0.0369406678,
0.0830740258,
-0.0070680487,
0.022223657,
-0.0180754345,
0.0260080304,
-0.0188039988,
-0.0292353015,
0.0093944203,
-0.0529385321,
0.016919395,
-0.0019316413,
0.0017970724,
0.0200525913,
-0.0013714625,
-0.0040918547,
-0.0041040196,
-0.0561713353,
0.0329077989,
-0.0077481889,
-0.0029589953,
0.0419948399,
0.0094814273,
0.0053965687,
0.0657479838,
0.0136400824,
0.0005990675,
-0.0569025613,
-0.051261995,
0.0228590984,
0.0456368513,
-0.0122823147,
0.0307267271,
0.0392175801,
0.0061358302,
-0.1095363423,
-0.0282097384,
-0.0012682449,
0.0307015795,
0.0277265534,
0.0089051714,
-0.0501891822,
-0.0376110859,
-0.0445461906,
-0.0266575832,
-0.0339736193,
-0.0081808483,
0.0090662939,
0.0289681312,
0.0189530458,
-0.0087522129,
-0.0253089853,
-0.0441827886,
0.0072329277,
-0.0117912097,
0.0250675455,
-0.0203998554,
-0.0012022419,
0.0255998075,
-0.0758310407,
-0.0571724698,
-0.0203422401,
-0.0024770582,
0.0352327973,
0.0236145463,
0.0769873708,
0.0270563904,
-0.0512651093,
-0.0272507649,
-0.0456748083,
-0.0041503389,
0.0171052702,
-0.0038759569,
0.0757994205,
0.0211807173,
-0.0035797074,
0.0045735626,
0.0292040948,
0.0190404076,
-0.0084874518,
-0.021532217,
-0.0453246944,
0.0225531179,
-0.0293665417,
-0.0393820629,
0.0101330681,
-0.0021822816,
0.0678530261,
-0.0547497086,
-0.0018973587,
0.0707887188,
3e-7,
0.0570447221,
0.0495850705,
-0.0046947193,
0.0102645876,
0.0288833641,
0.0288166553,
-0.0355874896,
0.0226422977,
0.0232416354,
-0.0658164248,
0.0150196124,
0.053039521,
0.0456418768,
0.0504860207,
-0.0899835601,
-0.0024187171,
-0.0414251387,
-0.0147391986,
0.0136204222,
-0.007747056,
-0.0026180695,
0.0766107365,
0.042590078,
-0.0198147856,
-0.0007922035,
-0.0622912161,
0.0824924335,
-0.0136393327,
0.0053059645,
-0.0315780379,
0.0023531655,
0.0188991968,
-0.0159213729,
0.0541674532,
0.0091897361,
0.0097484272,
-0.0185366292,
0.039581798,
0.0042623635,
-0.0296681616,
-0.0242957268,
-0.036886137,
0.0189069379,
-0.0446238182,
0.0770953,
-0.0883155689,
-0.0474209674,
-0.0196623653,
0.0074875085,
-0.0326613523,
0.0000363525,
0.0341204144,
0.0013793724,
-0.0039938544,
-0.0051653096,
0.0239941813,
-0.0025419476,
-0.086517401,
-0.0031192382,
0.0314922296,
-0.0266920235,
-0.0915460289,
0.0032146652,
0.0183029715,
0.0446917526,
-0.0513226762,
-0.0068549253,
2.660028922e-34,
0.0095155844,
-0.0243668649,
-0.0143680507,
0.0052326508,
0.0298219658,
-0.0201141071,
-0.0200272631,
0.0225161742,
0.0502177477,
-0.0822283179,
-0.0061044535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14545v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14545v1 | Unmasking Database Vulnerabilities: Zero-Knowledge Schema Inference Attacks in Text-to-SQL Systems | 2024-06-20T17:54:33 | 2024-06-20T17:54:33 | Đorđe Klisura, Anthony Rios | cs.CL | cs.CL | Relational databases are integral to modern information systems, serving as
the foundation for storing, querying, and managing data efficiently and
effectively. Advancements in large language modeling have led to the emergence
of text-to-SQL technologies, significantly enhancing the querying and
extracting of information from these databases and raising concerns about
privacy and security. Our research extracts the database schema elements
underlying a text-to-SQL model. Knowledge of the schema can make attacks such
as SQL injection easier. By asking specially crafted questions, we have
developed a zero-knowledge framework designed to probe various database schema
elements without knowledge of the database itself. The text-to-SQL models then
process these questions to produce an output that we use to uncover the
structure of the database schema. We apply it to specialized text-to-SQL models
fine-tuned on text-SQL pairs and generative language models used for SQL
generation. Overall, we can reconstruct the table names with an F1 of nearly
.75 for fine-tuned models and .96 for generative. | [
0.022721855,
0.1065151468,
-0.0047863745,
0.079003416,
-0.0441789702,
-0.0228258241,
0.0160150286,
0.0449035875,
0.029005833,
-0.0208470002,
0.0461251736,
0.0147287361,
-0.0031644553,
0.0349774398,
0.087958239,
0.018640995,
0.0207271725,
-0.0349143371,
-0.0270331688,
0.0173146259,
-0.0217449479,
-0.0343707912,
0.0389458686,
-0.0396943055,
-0.0111951688,
0.0094920509,
-0.074987933,
0.0476065502,
-0.021207368,
0.007775493,
-0.0449779145,
0.0585838035,
-0.0401824452,
0.038716048,
0.0000021903,
-0.008953087,
-0.0666009933,
0.0491701327,
-0.0752406269,
0.0078185145,
-0.008530275,
-0.064790301,
-0.0016875928,
0.0085762544,
-0.0079866927,
-0.0031261358,
0.044170633,
0.0459783934,
0.0337946229,
0.0824549124,
0.0024004027,
-0.0147045804,
-0.0220589377,
-0.0092335828,
0.0710459203,
-0.0240895785,
0.0125043532,
0.0034219988,
-0.0153069431,
0.0414913893,
-0.0120813567,
-0.0084670829,
-0.038782157,
-0.0147244399,
-0.0036301813,
0.013361007,
-0.0037816956,
0.0213252809,
0.0011101041,
0.0203576926,
0.0007477429,
-0.0319760256,
0.0213000216,
0.0223545451,
0.0100951632,
0.0122520924,
0.0216736272,
0.0595395528,
0.0129877366,
-0.031544514,
-0.0100157922,
-0.0142320925,
0.0320580825,
-0.0629340112,
-0.0276637468,
0.0193831418,
0.0039579077,
-0.0230365247,
-0.0212333407,
-0.0864372924,
0.0169819649,
-0.0470360629,
-0.0033802313,
0.0047597089,
0.0189998411,
0.0363853239,
-0.060116861,
-0.0368760526,
0.039377138,
-0.0619436949,
0.0321874619,
0.0385982729,
0.0352635048,
0.0289620962,
-0.008454022,
0.004872283,
0.008993037,
0.0092628999,
-0.025960831,
-0.0094355019,
-0.0314244032,
-0.0037131072,
-0.0024836224,
0.0329792649,
-0.0739194602,
0.0139993057,
-0.0014850043,
0.0431634411,
-0.0080620889,
0.0639581531,
-0.0492442101,
0.032199502,
0.0089542726,
0.0154505763,
0.0028443043,
-0.0682048127,
0.0137575716,
-0.0218376201,
-0.0351282358,
-0.075271681,
-0.0405181237,
-0.0028097348,
0.0006531486,
-0.0112783788,
0.0119465757,
0.0948084444,
0.0250345562,
0.0204354431,
-0.1017669216,
-0.1197747141,
0.0165609866,
0.0380381905,
-0.0331435166,
-0.0284483358,
0.003428502,
-0.0127003342,
-0.0076929736,
-0.0537647717,
-0.0186587423,
0.0171348788,
-0.030320866,
0.0726334155,
-0.0329643525,
-0.0029390219,
0.0032136717,
0.0163669083,
0.0241774805,
0.0165956318,
-0.0058105607,
0.0453069806,
0.0150992293,
0.0001889388,
0.0386985131,
-0.0048156357,
0.0409089066,
-0.0042010457,
-0.0155178979,
0.049017638,
0.0537179671,
-0.0372319221,
-0.0656911135,
0.0442860238,
0.0242580511,
-0.0226467419,
0.0506282672,
0.0174433198,
-0.0001875169,
0.0432790145,
0.0179581158,
0.0214218032,
-0.0186305549,
-0.0140709346,
-0.0195343345,
-0.0145801762,
-0.0989484638,
-0.0049902033,
-0.0065642819,
-0.0359464698,
-0.0013062052,
-0.006481315,
-0.0031101638,
-0.0358802341,
0.024880087,
-0.0070511959,
-0.0097429929,
0.05964664,
-0.0225836132,
0.0031690001,
-0.003977966,
-0.0611165352,
-0.0502105504,
-0.0384937972,
-0.0013827416,
0.0447183773,
0.025160417,
-0.0436129309,
0.0436129943,
-0.0056246663,
0.0207712259,
0.0447744578,
-0.0365283936,
-0.019912079,
0.0181442033,
0.0250332672,
-0.0018569502,
0.0313392915,
0.0719447881,
-0.0247786995,
0.0096110841,
-0.0126299728,
0.0345378257,
-0.0453628562,
-0.0041570272,
-0.0022401405,
-0.0201056246,
-0.0629049167,
0.0447739363,
0.018545473,
0.012651477,
0.0438958555,
-0.0063862633,
0.0517319813,
0.0353166088,
0.0234157071,
-0.0346878767,
-0.0660137981,
0.0695597455,
0.0691080913,
-0.021276651,
-0.0265367161,
0.0550971702,
-0.0443628319,
-0.012518324,
-0.0234151408,
0.0612937659,
0.0162209626,
-0.0116415014,
0.0093013663,
-0.0230880473,
0.0206276048,
0.0076544327,
-0.0290171485,
0.0370319821,
0.0320111476,
0.0267008729,
-0.0287146308,
-0.0953594819,
0.0289609879,
-0.0120265782,
-0.0029362724,
-0.0254989043,
-0.0500732847,
0.0547603257,
-0.0203272086,
-0.006743473,
-0.0243495144,
-0.0092614787,
-0.0418688618,
0.0156619046,
0.0094970912,
0.0589002557,
0.0072960765,
0.0227609631,
-0.024110144,
-0.0392732285,
-0.0431482419,
-0.0606035814,
-0.0446770228,
-0.0403631255,
0.0231927317,
0.012568838,
-0.0050002374,
0.0192335285,
-0.0227091964,
-0.0360445827,
0.0800680667,
-0.0188841037,
0.0168443117,
0.0293159671,
0.0407516137,
-0.0136745498,
-0.0062621194,
0.0071582939,
-0.0184544586,
0.0041239839,
-0.0144894095,
-0.0549055897,
0.0285329185,
-0.0089300051,
0.0281701833,
-0.0304182377,
-0.0201263539,
0.035568431,
-0.0368751623,
0.01774868,
-0.0084862988,
0.0096432045,
-0.0521108545,
0.0360941216,
-0.0122765098,
0.0639431477,
-0.0315349177,
-0.0265586693,
0.0144779375,
0.0540459938,
0.0038740656,
-0.0445367321,
0.000060263,
0.0494524427,
-0.0204752535,
0.0005992936,
-0.0031358686,
0.0438910313,
-0.0551664606,
0.0442657247,
0.0060966103,
-0.0200525634,
-0.0129989153,
0.0553628244,
-0.0096891699,
0.0437330119,
0.0940116122,
-0.0181734227,
-0.0008618756,
-0.0631364956,
0.0438985489,
-0.0138524091,
0.013232084,
-0.0263921618,
-0.0384640954,
0.0116481865,
0.0168191083,
-0.0443078429,
-0.0342715494,
-0.0036859261,
0.0097868061,
0.045167312,
-0.0033660741,
0.0102658169,
-0.0184275918,
0.0321902111,
0.0309510212,
0.013031153,
-0.0005354668,
-0.0122258384,
-0.015079814,
-0.0511254743,
-0.0810643509,
-0.0401565358,
-0.0414648391,
-0.0030428686,
0.0660369396,
0.0297662802,
0.0054757493,
0.0019245034,
0.0080722189,
-0.0421582609,
-0.0215182751,
-0.0067212353,
0.0224914625,
-0.1025094837,
-0.0177190658,
0.0070832768,
0.0333815441,
0.0123880291,
0.0481705368,
0.0160962027,
0.0298521016,
-0.018416049,
-0.0096058147,
0.0230859332,
-0.1625522077,
-0.0106141232,
-0.0230510756,
0.0235588346,
-0.0215137955,
-0.0780308992,
-0.0395498648,
-0.0825456381,
-0.025966933,
-0.0088710915,
-0.0421570987,
-0.0029711621,
-0.0310893897,
-0.0243586265,
-0.005839488,
-0.0375882275,
0.0311477259,
-0.0030449922,
0.0172584001,
0.0046719238,
0.0209992211,
-0.0456148572,
-0.0109360386,
-0.0191376563,
0.0294400603,
0.0124356998,
0.0123802992,
0.025978405,
0.0476879627,
-0.0415661037,
0.0011841046,
0.0048005572,
-0.0067409235,
0.0756714717,
0.0221728981,
-0.0148707796,
0.0242211744,
0.0509040393,
-0.0335481167,
0.0510610044,
0.0564573482,
0.0163404271,
-0.0183931421,
-0.0199354123,
0.0224897973,
-0.0723249093,
0.0810704306,
0.0433036387,
0.0011630061,
0.0080232145,
-0.0209775493,
-0.0320517495,
0.0278788358,
-0.0175852031,
0.0055703688,
0.0287788175,
0.000060751,
-0.0649065971,
-0.0052355058,
0.0228808187,
0.0053510801,
0.0265821759,
0.0671885833,
0.0261139907,
0.0191895589,
-0.034752436,
-0.0224685278,
-0.0394750386,
-0.0643926933,
0.0083461124,
-0.03191052,
-0.0108135641,
-0.02655527,
-0.0320131108,
-0.022155324,
-0.0419494957,
-0.0520615876,
-0.027448887,
0.011197024,
0.023889292,
0.0235750265,
-0.0326464884,
0.0032590094,
-0.041216068,
0.0297749862,
0.0326280445,
-0.0421875753,
-0.0466699973,
0.0162780527,
-0.0599264465,
0.0202268735,
0.0312226918,
-0.0208100379,
0.000465404,
0.0329746529,
-0.0297495555,
-0.0451178253,
0.003838436,
0.0062045702,
0.0622010455,
0.0065046116,
0.0625552982,
0.0059365574,
0.0205832273,
0.0297514256,
-0.0981178954,
-0.0221307762,
0.000453664,
-0.000095996,
0.0224914011,
0.0048370669,
0.0533263534,
-0.0501179099,
-0.0026080902,
0.0363699906,
0.0237419102,
-0.0334686339,
0.1023121029,
-0.0135421529,
0.0293233991,
-0.0238856189,
0.01250761,
0.0311039295,
0.0121003147,
0.0612218566,
-0.0021217391,
-0.0107241189,
0.0236373972,
-0.0145624839,
-0.0296218172,
-0.0029013767,
-0.0130568361,
-0.0124423346,
0.0371833965,
0.0019448169,
-0.009435744,
0.0241017547,
-0.0106090512,
0.0056828018,
-0.000054801,
-0.0314385705,
0.0184923634,
0.0048691309,
-0.0402585343,
-0.0014184606,
-0.0058372165,
-0.0200455599,
0.0445916206,
0.0688437,
0.0484888032,
-0.008256455,
-0.0243665688,
-0.0515518375,
-0.0618640706,
0.0238626506,
0.0324475467,
0.0154454457,
-0.032697916,
0.0062605417,
-0.0424702168,
-0.0064770482,
0.0189534668,
0.0166052543,
0.005937248,
0.0140151288,
0.0033919208,
0.051989194,
0.0568202324,
0.0159419756,
-0.0907777771,
0.0187564623,
-0.040660467,
-0.0750938952,
0.0177876446,
-6.068525586e-33,
-0.0064230575,
-0.0700275078,
-0.0419164635,
0.0081550991,
0.0817349926,
0.0047417968,
-0.0544535741,
0.0448576622,
-0.055785019,
-0.0005058813,
-0.0093501592,
0.0120680379,
0.0305087827,
0.0335859545,
0.0049559143,
-0.0091607003,
-0.0066924375,
-0.0075997692,
-0.010948658,
-0.0062998938,
0.1017391309,
0.0068377242,
0.011107347,
-0.024503693,
0.0689939559,
-0.0575671755,
-0.0526129343,
0.0065089087,
-0.0025853757,
0.0251697749,
-0.0279276539,
0.0122450357,
-0.0243465379,
0.0064351358,
0.0332053155,
-0.0555562451,
-0.0230511371,
-0.0188426822,
0.0188129526,
-0.0365602151,
0.0722756162,
-0.0589844733,
0.0367057025,
-0.0389893949,
0.0121259484,
0.0200597085,
0.0023853355,
0.0011326566,
-0.010692128,
-0.0229683537,
-0.0004146485,
0.0004856733,
-0.0235590693,
0.0301728714,
0.0494863279,
0.0073544495,
0.0256652441,
-0.0560795963,
-0.0239815079,
0.0283882804,
0.0669777915,
0.0176287014,
0.0138065713,
0.0259193871,
-0.0052247834,
-0.0207759328,
-0.0193918888,
-0.0162338503,
-0.002642707,
0.0717504472,
-0.0389667004,
0.0506029688,
0.0295750964,
0.0505137742,
0.0003477405,
-0.0402442813,
-0.0588720925,
0.0057502473,
-0.0445408374,
-0.0512571633,
0.0338526778,
-0.0231247917,
-0.0770459175,
-0.0376481824,
-0.0260006003,
-0.021798104,
-0.0525449067,
-0.0103946608,
-0.0137329428,
0.003377948,
-0.0381958894,
-0.0088605359,
0.0010098814,
-0.0341722704,
-0.0083891349,
0.0841205642,
-0.0061604152,
-0.0530594401,
-0.0136206541,
-0.0131202014,
-0.0224597193,
0.0125534851,
0.0228329506,
-0.0124521898,
0.0031805502,
0.0377053283,
0.0181400497,
0.0130188903,
-0.0566013083,
-0.0114643471,
-0.0094458563,
0.0445450246,
-0.0192436911,
0.0285842642,
-0.0124379527,
0.0192429814,
0.0296446737,
-0.0126423454,
0.0048731803,
0.0245537329,
0.0094272215,
0.0539130941,
0.00448049,
0.0113361888,
0.0389630534,
-0.0032016004,
0.0165524594,
-0.0338497683,
0.0818070397,
0.0152341807,
0.0088550579,
0.035888169,
3.025e-7,
0.0356575847,
-0.0290315393,
0.017812334,
0.0304201115,
0.0155465342,
0.114171125,
0.0169160366,
0.0350252278,
-0.0413385332,
-0.0569794029,
-0.0342605896,
-0.0269960165,
0.0459172577,
-0.0007918717,
-0.0604075491,
-0.031735491,
-0.000935505,
-0.0104425773,
-0.036397364,
0.0054493495,
0.0131190121,
0.0412272289,
0.0065563228,
-0.0070832637,
-0.0154484622,
-0.0160933454,
-0.0174013413,
-0.0096451221,
0.0229128711,
0.0219254922,
0.0388705321,
0.0131883491,
0.0129824765,
0.0643666089,
-0.0488501601,
-0.0186630562,
-0.0550518967,
0.051373519,
-0.0019692173,
0.0307315178,
0.0017144254,
-0.1171243042,
-0.008249647,
-0.0096973171,
0.0715050623,
0.0398429856,
-0.0218044333,
0.0838576406,
-0.0222615488,
-0.0225819908,
0.0033388832,
-0.0052024247,
-0.0257828869,
-0.046236556,
0.008980982,
0.036153838,
0.0626211837,
0.0186461303,
-0.034566395,
0.0274735037,
-0.0208343398,
0.0270442385,
0.0617946163,
0.0005402958,
-0.0229742955,
-0.007123414,
0.0282715093,
2.930247063e-34,
-0.0051134662,
0.0067314343,
0.0004729312,
-0.0123814614,
0.0253344718,
-0.0155231087,
0.0188304763,
-0.041569747,
-0.0127882101,
-0.0520405769,
-0.0533155762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14544v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14544v1 | Prism: A Framework for Decoupling and Assessing the Capabilities of VLMs | 2024-06-20T17:54:03 | 2024-06-20T17:54:03 | Yuxuan Qiao, Haodong Duan, Xinyu Fang, Junming Yang, Lin Chen, Songyang Zhang, Jiaqi Wang, Dahua Lin, Kai Chen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Vision Language Models (VLMs) demonstrate remarkable proficiency in
addressing a wide array of visual questions, which requires strong perception
and reasoning faculties. Assessing these two competencies independently is
crucial for model refinement, despite the inherent difficulty due to the
intertwined nature of seeing and reasoning in existing VLMs. To tackle this
issue, we present Prism, an innovative framework designed to disentangle the
perception and reasoning processes involved in visual question solving. Prism
comprises two distinct stages: a perception stage that utilizes a VLM to
extract and articulate visual information in textual form, and a reasoning
stage that formulates responses based on the extracted visual information using
a Large Language Model (LLM). This modular design enables the systematic
comparison and assessment of both proprietary and open-source VLM for their
perception and reasoning strengths. Our analytical framework provides several
valuable insights, underscoring Prism's potential as a cost-effective solution
for vision-language tasks. By combining a streamlined VLM focused on perception
with a powerful LLM tailored for reasoning, Prism achieves superior results in
general vision-language tasks while substantially cutting down on training and
operational expenses. Quantitative evaluations show that Prism, when configured
with a vanilla 2B LLaVA and freely accessible GPT-3.5, delivers performance on
par with VLMs $10 \times$ larger on the rigorous multimodal benchmark MMStar.
The project is released at: https://github.com/SparksJoe/Prism. | [
0.0218955446,
0.0428771339,
-0.0159604959,
0.0711671188,
-0.0471285321,
0.0401728898,
0.0235582404,
-0.0055289338,
0.0299807787,
-0.0693289191,
-0.0029239769,
-0.0122208809,
-0.0068597421,
0.0602022558,
0.036321681,
-0.0696642548,
0.0342213362,
-0.0601322316,
0.0117819272,
0.0117381625,
0.0140324365,
-0.0078552486,
-0.0201402493,
0.0211735964,
-0.012221151,
-0.0419418253,
-0.0103607848,
-0.0071236314,
0.02902909,
-0.0124860359,
-0.0415710285,
0.0035935736,
0.0549402386,
-0.0070363632,
0.0000021307,
-0.048292011,
0.0315703824,
-0.0020086099,
-0.001965631,
-0.0081997169,
0.0100810444,
-0.0146674151,
0.0250122696,
0.0109934472,
-0.0455439761,
-0.0359179229,
0.0485297441,
0.0291662961,
0.0546317175,
0.02913462,
-0.0093890456,
-0.0370454006,
0.0044620517,
-0.0028250916,
0.0374250151,
-0.0518168285,
0.0085429205,
0.0475684665,
0.019813206,
-0.0140098017,
-0.0440274626,
0.0560536012,
0.0549914502,
-0.018580595,
-0.0176409166,
0.0481318124,
-0.0416846089,
-0.0395327322,
-0.0431890562,
0.0718081743,
0.0086822603,
-0.0088112047,
-0.0166850239,
0.0032214564,
0.0090527972,
-0.0071215075,
-0.0445059165,
0.0490315817,
-0.0245202221,
-0.0007924978,
-0.0401664786,
-0.0342424177,
0.0091094496,
0.0065886183,
-0.0268401038,
0.0262768865,
0.0109631093,
0.0202806313,
0.0250232331,
0.0180105362,
-0.0299779493,
-0.0558220185,
-0.0277161058,
0.0508699901,
-0.0062663839,
0.0069029927,
-0.0297231581,
0.0113351792,
-0.0305049382,
-0.0239199232,
0.0464295186,
0.0265855789,
-0.0485715903,
0.0754710883,
-0.0648709461,
0.096006684,
-0.0205773022,
0.0515641123,
-0.027361596,
-0.0268590376,
-0.0280746706,
-0.0001831245,
-0.0185989458,
-0.0083168382,
-0.0678338632,
-0.0436514169,
-0.0001688052,
0.0108986776,
-0.009167701,
-0.0002679963,
-0.0222700331,
0.0124891913,
0.0177216101,
-0.0436542407,
-0.0721639767,
0.0549415872,
-0.0083815176,
0.006025692,
-0.0127727902,
-0.0693039224,
0.0095183784,
0.0538113192,
0.0056715072,
-0.0168283843,
-0.012348095,
0.0685116649,
-0.0347175337,
-0.0267016869,
-0.0477544889,
-0.0015250529,
0.0078578657,
-0.0680356622,
0.0389313474,
-0.0610430874,
0.0211728439,
0.0002758611,
-0.0108136386,
-0.0297256038,
0.0115145873,
-0.0077041094,
-0.0057066134,
0.0919127315,
-0.0171863027,
0.0003237996,
0.0039414819,
0.0145804295,
-0.0001162591,
0.0607579313,
0.0183686651,
0.0542614795,
0.0069374642,
-0.0013619415,
0.0238971133,
0.0285323989,
-0.0476041399,
-0.0132566784,
-0.1022521704,
0.0380493402,
-0.0087246783,
0.018219538,
0.0160583239,
0.0637150407,
-0.0064233229,
-0.0449354351,
0.0697175413,
0.0345338732,
0.0262221489,
-0.0436853319,
0.0442723446,
-0.0096015157,
0.0120312134,
-0.0272096917,
-0.0435421653,
0.0687539577,
-0.0270548984,
-0.0201716218,
-0.0549906828,
0.028409807,
-0.0261468403,
-0.0449378714,
-0.0377802812,
0.001491594,
0.001823966,
0.077142477,
0.0482781678,
-0.0144046592,
-0.0104863932,
-0.0013227193,
-0.0053481818,
-0.0276092645,
0.0020168335,
-0.0655114725,
0.0635203347,
0.0603904016,
0.0243949071,
0.0205547661,
-0.0196610391,
0.0024175998,
0.0209441278,
0.060671851,
0.028740434,
0.0060699671,
0.0345536061,
-0.0598878041,
-0.0421556421,
-0.0299469307,
-0.020991724,
0.0066843368,
0.001252724,
-0.0186947212,
0.0069656903,
-0.0438567922,
0.0343913175,
0.0495649129,
0.0185190067,
-0.0098142037,
-0.0407342687,
0.0148513252,
0.0028962803,
-0.0199629795,
-0.0002076699,
0.0045952247,
0.0105807427,
-0.0258515049,
0.0222407486,
0.0106920945,
-0.0060311896,
-0.020852074,
0.0452781841,
-0.0613440014,
-0.0164071135,
0.0177745894,
-0.0199435093,
-0.0007053632,
0.0125720417,
-0.0318631828,
-0.0288921725,
-0.0562349148,
-0.013687632,
0.0086357538,
-0.0101600084,
-0.0421246141,
0.0707558095,
-0.0279052481,
-0.0183710586,
-0.0237443205,
0.0208255053,
0.0298217535,
-0.0265979934,
-0.0062730378,
0.0148371719,
0.0004763363,
0.0029259506,
-0.0237566736,
0.0110334251,
-0.0607137233,
-0.0048559988,
-0.0481660664,
-0.0188857391,
-0.0197516773,
-0.0377205014,
0.007697281,
-0.013654503,
-0.01448589,
-0.0175240636,
-0.0274444316,
0.0452068262,
0.0099179167,
0.0208638292,
0.015040867,
-0.0030954424,
0.002886727,
-0.0025242018,
-0.0086432444,
-0.0006708566,
0.0474132039,
0.0399777442,
-0.0186437164,
-0.0352271535,
-0.0032229493,
-0.0607947744,
0.0380078256,
-0.0202328991,
-0.0197401587,
0.0430278219,
-0.0495595224,
0.0268374495,
0.0963382348,
-0.0120354984,
0.0096689323,
0.0494467728,
-0.0153873628,
-0.0319985822,
0.0273080003,
0.0014572231,
-0.0201268978,
-0.0251933113,
-0.0124704661,
-0.0340785719,
0.0187614802,
-0.0175818801,
0.0115804626,
-0.067723453,
0.050346069,
0.0017096678,
-0.072049588,
-0.0555052534,
0.0046655866,
0.0044422988,
0.0600650348,
-0.0505440086,
-0.0689464882,
0.0361439958,
-0.0183556788,
-0.0130572766,
-0.0004376551,
0.0186233986,
-0.0380661152,
0.0878029838,
0.0102207707,
0.0134054096,
-0.0207727551,
-0.0030075905,
-0.0497745052,
-0.0396444723,
-0.0123370914,
-0.0106023727,
0.074859418,
-0.099100627,
0.0167572498,
-0.0163712688,
-0.0088171754,
-0.0473896749,
0.0305615384,
-0.0454751179,
0.0057213791,
-0.078150481,
0.0035477628,
-0.0288239121,
0.0419516526,
0.0523779206,
0.004096562,
-0.0072365832,
-0.0050055338,
-0.022323193,
0.0183718782,
0.0678944811,
0.0412559174,
0.0227540843,
-0.040181566,
0.0210136306,
0.0632581338,
0.0232729688,
-0.0050959093,
-0.0494953059,
0.0547665544,
0.0308366176,
0.0415392816,
0.0221646186,
0.0435137041,
0.0600008108,
-0.0737695396,
-0.0144200148,
0.0896014944,
0.0294615254,
-0.0246153772,
-0.0235410593,
-0.0037498798,
0.0161866304,
0.0646505877,
0.0273995884,
-0.0801283792,
-0.044395525,
-0.0062066549,
-0.0083357105,
0.0281040743,
-0.0218292531,
-0.0236789752,
-0.0740978569,
0.0869731531,
-0.0000136073,
0.0089209778,
-0.0152360145,
0.0217115805,
-0.0048304177,
0.0136209503,
-0.0226034168,
0.0137111386,
-0.004565374,
0.0061505772,
0.0045150216,
0.0185224544,
0.004452345,
0.0218980256,
-0.0483706631,
-0.0267333873,
0.0456875414,
-5.008e-7,
0.0017515371,
-0.0990784615,
0.0312668234,
-0.0136425374,
0.0155923674,
-0.025523264,
0.0421099253,
-0.0035525733,
-0.0457603112,
-0.0194489956,
0.0238956194,
-0.0088276109,
-0.0360629521,
-0.0062501086,
0.0464052595,
-0.0262760986,
-0.0318682194,
-0.0307525378,
0.0027079815,
-0.0415192246,
0.0452405997,
0.0233655274,
-0.0219211113,
-0.0506162792,
0.0070224553,
-0.0328664519,
-0.0392902531,
-0.058134228,
0.0372582413,
0.0632274672,
0.0005655745,
-0.0524408817,
-0.0155511135,
0.0526981317,
0.064298138,
-0.0326448604,
-0.0280163419,
-0.0144656226,
0.0167219881,
-0.057047762,
0.086172618,
-0.0241761543,
0.0247484799,
-0.036676921,
0.0234624241,
-0.0067038774,
-0.0463419221,
-0.0254575517,
0.0012617195,
-0.059459921,
-0.039610669,
-0.0177921504,
0.0568544492,
0.0241684336,
-0.0016659658,
0.0045334306,
-0.0446104594,
-0.0073933299,
0.0103741596,
0.0286349021,
0.0350805148,
-0.0410100892,
-0.0236488488,
0.0112990439,
0.0205764156,
-0.0178067386,
0.0172599256,
0.0317569003,
0.02955864,
0.0082641356,
-0.0035739245,
0.0135237575,
0.027512176,
0.0417490825,
0.0088089434,
0.0021247412,
-0.032414794,
-0.001982077,
-0.0039268997,
-0.0040158438,
-0.0796053261,
0.0081920903,
0.0221837461,
0.0306020956,
0.025766883,
-0.0064385911,
0.0065850783,
0.0201773942,
-0.0311145354,
0.0116361259,
0.0378270485,
-0.029468555,
-0.0000122389,
0.0138240941,
0.0034582908,
0.0088591818,
-0.0365070663,
0.0484345667,
0.026716223,
0.1037968472,
0.0191980433,
-0.0211090632,
-0.0296854246,
0.0239086505,
-0.0229498781,
-0.097928457,
0.0290354509,
0.0476107411,
0.027834855,
0.018774502,
-0.0033435051,
-0.0239157639,
-0.0071836482,
-0.0273646284,
0.012605303,
0.0231044125,
-0.0357720628,
0.0893887877,
0.0529538542,
-0.0040102024,
-0.0603605434,
0.017721517,
0.0019125213,
0.0241908617,
-0.0104087563,
0.0084643895,
-0.0344727449,
-0.0518481731,
0.0173098445,
-0.0049367752,
0.008836858,
0.0538415425,
-0.0631058738,
-0.0646317229,
-0.0286165047,
0.0554254837,
-0.0065034581,
0.017664481,
0.0405519828,
0.0594409816,
0.0156266671,
-0.0612374283,
-0.0052166702,
-0.017664725,
-0.0219777562,
0.0004063876,
0.0193016157,
-6.123227583e-33,
-0.0196657069,
-0.0256674998,
0.0762390122,
-0.0235730298,
-0.0117222555,
0.0230796468,
-0.0209905934,
0.0203534253,
-0.0502321795,
0.0039522843,
0.0378780477,
-0.0020103215,
-0.0035050274,
0.0252244882,
-0.0165610779,
0.0028230811,
-0.0024939496,
0.0079228058,
-0.0211793873,
-0.0285861176,
0.0046919365,
-0.0086664064,
0.020159835,
-0.043457821,
-0.0388055146,
0.0384581089,
-0.0119041456,
0.0542104468,
-0.0345807187,
0.0835572258,
-0.02446975,
0.0034208479,
0.0329131074,
0.0211568214,
-0.0152851557,
0.0294324327,
-0.03987303,
-0.0088008977,
0.0491817147,
0.0193690807,
-0.0950630903,
0.0087625459,
0.0401107669,
-0.0028357718,
-0.0072423927,
-0.0571448803,
0.0371526815,
-0.0202195439,
0.0003454004,
0.0139484191,
-0.0199478194,
0.0135305282,
0.0063542495,
-0.0225630458,
0.0384080857,
0.0254061855,
-0.0034817816,
0.0587565154,
-0.0206804369,
0.0112091145,
-0.0154321631,
-0.0055860667,
0.0905339345,
0.0620308332,
0.0115297111,
0.0626283064,
0.0490065254,
-0.0526082925,
-0.0329317339,
-0.028450327,
0.0367840119,
0.0821535736,
0.0660212189,
0.0455475301,
-0.0092446301,
0.025211405,
-0.0654776618,
-0.0118499342,
-0.0386572443,
0.1000553891,
0.0052101999,
0.0158502907,
-0.005298675,
0.0155051956,
-0.0441021994,
0.0116308555,
-0.0650138482,
0.0119788349,
0.0861234218,
-0.0008351324,
-0.004089707,
0.0271417983,
0.0570962802,
-0.0243781917,
0.0217740815,
-0.0025731213,
-0.006088906,
0.0621167719,
0.0172371697,
0.0514442064,
-0.0505404696,
0.0048692939,
0.0465654656,
-0.006405862,
-0.0046119187,
-0.0069027399,
0.0014314064,
0.005275527,
-0.0336922146,
-0.0158904102,
-0.0657602474,
0.0154832937,
-0.0036207922,
0.0386689939,
0.0350996181,
0.0067549488,
-0.0469111465,
0.0045463857,
-0.0315617099,
-0.0536550842,
-0.0244801156,
-0.0221747309,
-0.0002798195,
0.0249564908,
-0.0290947296,
0.00358419,
-0.039278917,
-0.0144223943,
0.011848106,
-0.0421610326,
-0.0029657115,
0.0555746481,
2.699e-7,
0.0270351879,
0.0346693061,
-0.0061055338,
0.0200315267,
0.0198884942,
0.0464636311,
-0.0267277639,
0.0014261993,
0.0242044218,
-0.051173564,
-0.0350791439,
0.0891845524,
0.0266666468,
0.0085944729,
-0.0111482339,
0.0615124702,
0.0358396098,
-0.0260899477,
-0.0685368925,
0.0062664165,
0.0895019546,
0.0345743373,
-0.0119689852,
-0.0220368169,
0.0583783686,
-0.0618130192,
0.0707578063,
-0.0299531333,
-0.0143994074,
-0.0161324404,
0.0124187144,
0.0088576935,
0.0036595054,
0.0240154937,
0.0211427175,
-0.0175920166,
0.0195328835,
0.0546588972,
-0.0267261341,
-0.0392210446,
-0.0091832178,
0.0174529497,
-0.0088689318,
-0.0816215128,
0.1054735035,
-0.0174368229,
-0.0137178879,
-0.0020266003,
-0.0354203992,
-0.0128894011,
-0.0080214962,
-0.0006736602,
-0.0371916257,
0.0087587098,
0.0279422086,
-0.0435647815,
-0.0410235077,
-0.0877853483,
-0.0110794408,
-0.0287316442,
-0.0473572612,
-0.0161566306,
-0.0675197989,
0.0179111138,
0.0226940811,
-0.0050499649,
-0.0659653917,
2.19503504e-34,
-0.0017011795,
0.0147643844,
0.0249299873,
0.0091192322,
0.0315754488,
-0.0114449076,
-0.0383188389,
0.0005785864,
-0.0093473569,
-0.0835587159,
0.001437761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14532v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14532v1 | RL on Incorrect Synthetic Data Scales the Efficiency of LLM Math Reasoning by Eight-Fold | 2024-06-20T17:45:54 | 2024-06-20T17:45:54 | Amrith Setlur, Saurabh Garg, Xinyang Geng, Naman Garg, Virginia Smith, Aviral Kumar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Training on model-generated synthetic data is a promising approach for
finetuning LLMs, but it remains unclear when it helps or hurts. In this paper,
we investigate this question for math reasoning via an empirical study,
followed by building a conceptual understanding of our observations. First, we
find that while the typical approach of finetuning a model on synthetic correct
or positive problem-solution pairs generated by capable models offers modest
performance gains, sampling more correct solutions from the finetuned learner
itself followed by subsequent fine-tuning on this self-generated data
$\textbf{doubles}$ the efficiency of the same synthetic problems. At the same
time, training on model-generated positives can amplify various spurious
correlations, resulting in flat or even inverse scaling trends as the amount of
data increases. Surprisingly, we find that several of these issues can be
addressed if we also utilize negative responses, i.e., model-generated
responses that are deemed incorrect by a final answer verifier. Crucially,
these negatives must be constructed such that the training can appropriately
recover the utility or advantage of each intermediate step in the negative
response. With this per-step scheme, we are able to attain consistent gains
over only positive data, attaining performance similar to amplifying the amount
of synthetic data by $\mathbf{8 \times}$. We show that training on per-step
negatives can help to unlearn spurious correlations in the positive data, and
is equivalent to advantage-weighted reinforcement learning (RL), implying that
it inherits robustness benefits of RL over imitating positive data alone. | [
-0.0336954109,
0.0499388427,
-0.0122881504,
0.0089115342,
-0.0511956662,
0.0151006961,
-0.0267092884,
0.0038809325,
-0.0291838683,
0.0060543017,
-0.015789127,
0.0199238751,
-0.0242360998,
-0.0117468461,
0.0116859032,
-0.0076671797,
0.0170856155,
-0.0533889048,
-0.0009521926,
-0.0367249921,
-0.041353438,
-0.0463138893,
-0.0206308551,
-0.0496473387,
-0.0259891618,
-0.0073209014,
0.0030595472,
0.017272966,
0.013348233,
-0.0383552909,
-0.0047545452,
0.0375217795,
0.002677338,
0.0090419212,
0.0000023214,
-0.0508222543,
-0.0162897818,
0.0002987823,
-0.0501187332,
-0.0299201421,
-0.0428712368,
0.0126193585,
-0.0007358177,
0.0357394405,
-0.0571046956,
0.0540603846,
-0.0003687714,
0.0311459601,
0.0212160833,
0.0581981279,
0.0184647981,
-0.0231816377,
0.0166268535,
-0.0067869262,
0.0549941212,
-0.0078344187,
0.0072587128,
0.0280012023,
0.0279123355,
-0.0240657516,
-0.0386359952,
-0.0037660422,
0.0722210482,
0.0437167846,
0.0153311091,
0.0369467735,
-0.0213298388,
0.0280919485,
0.0212199111,
0.0571142212,
-0.0468320064,
-0.0400576293,
-0.02085042,
-0.044884868,
0.0302805919,
0.0167001579,
-0.0554914288,
0.0141967256,
-0.0252826214,
0.0456381142,
-0.0064062993,
-0.0330659039,
0.0457084887,
0.0222261436,
-0.0306697488,
0.0676603168,
-0.0133338282,
-0.0642988384,
0.0166678019,
0.0403853767,
-0.0339210592,
0.0068219467,
-0.0023413098,
0.0324292742,
0.0089295581,
0.0041253655,
0.0109004462,
-0.0239168555,
-0.0142494747,
0.0012800531,
0.0397591107,
0.0268597268,
0.032004483,
0.0088389302,
-0.0627914593,
0.0284595937,
-0.0096081384,
0.0660433993,
-0.0187829342,
0.0433212444,
-0.0179592054,
0.0111648105,
-0.0149144009,
0.0907947421,
-0.0124078654,
0.0421791635,
-0.0553876385,
-0.0083598392,
-0.079769589,
0.0485792831,
0.0111088669,
0.0058241012,
0.0212593582,
-0.0291249212,
-0.0738108158,
-0.0215840265,
-0.0441045091,
0.0503359884,
-0.0074471803,
-0.0350932516,
-0.0228163861,
-0.0111046191,
-0.0192627683,
0.0046040718,
0.0542572588,
0.092447713,
0.0067633186,
0.0001242708,
-0.0630423278,
-0.0488007776,
0.0295739025,
-0.0495722555,
0.0426012315,
-0.0914179832,
0.0348563939,
0.0029688028,
-0.0259716939,
-0.0349699408,
0.006727064,
-0.0107514132,
-0.0079935603,
0.0741077513,
0.0181556232,
0.0066238223,
-0.0288803373,
-0.0050842296,
-0.0432848409,
0.0806753039,
0.0579514578,
-0.0189999416,
-0.0006777405,
0.0028205593,
0.0453953147,
-0.0149947852,
0.0743478239,
0.0135699771,
-0.007188017,
0.0058918684,
-0.0255124606,
0.0322670415,
0.0045868629,
0.0042455825,
-0.0658713803,
-0.0237180851,
0.0350885279,
-0.0139656514,
0.0115799941,
-0.0260694101,
0.0082759811,
-0.0324962102,
0.0057741487,
0.0170142911,
-0.1069793627,
0.0491764583,
-0.0622476004,
0.0204418451,
-0.0323907882,
-0.0324164815,
-0.0296845865,
-0.094953306,
0.0156410486,
-0.0087209707,
-0.0213021059,
0.029130986,
0.0674487725,
-0.0117870159,
-0.0352860317,
-0.0085613299,
0.0232406557,
-0.0241826959,
0.0082616024,
-0.0335297361,
0.0463163443,
-0.0058615105,
0.0381357446,
-0.047365848,
-0.0419106893,
-0.0233137496,
-0.0371418297,
-0.0198833421,
0.0363871716,
-0.0019544226,
-0.0196329765,
-0.0088694328,
-0.0232335608,
-0.0219401736,
0.0064020599,
0.0044697998,
0.0469968803,
0.0067911735,
-0.0146000795,
-0.0477021895,
-0.0135127883,
0.0081542535,
-0.0772787556,
-0.0520717762,
0.0540422983,
0.0106060049,
0.0222918931,
-0.0243942533,
0.0246150512,
0.0281875785,
0.0279368833,
-0.0221366659,
-0.0678630248,
-0.0090466551,
-0.0739606246,
-0.0241717584,
0.0110438121,
-0.0384332985,
0.011446069,
0.0188937262,
-0.0682392865,
-0.0094734998,
0.0402904004,
0.0076512299,
-0.0166374706,
0.0045742369,
0.0437775776,
0.0233099423,
-0.0206149258,
-0.0421370603,
0.0342894159,
-0.028123619,
0.0395337008,
-0.0018165442,
0.0038793848,
0.0324561894,
-0.0080376668,
0.0385688692,
-0.0247581471,
-0.0154159367,
0.0187697597,
0.009554334,
-0.0128071746,
-0.0556642339,
-0.0037644368,
0.0187040996,
0.0274676457,
-0.0068987119,
0.0641184524,
0.0286343284,
-0.0661256164,
-0.0109229917,
-0.0197789818,
-0.0420892872,
-0.028551802,
0.034345936,
-0.0068296082,
0.0088973222,
0.0203440115,
0.0059587872,
-0.0079355463,
-0.0187027603,
-0.0153297242,
0.0040518153,
-0.0007628867,
0.0629387051,
-0.0236390438,
0.0236317329,
-0.0258033965,
0.0222079866,
-0.0072298138,
-0.0021007776,
-0.0001244465,
-0.0268652309,
-0.0199440531,
0.0747877285,
-0.0172123201,
-0.0214575119,
0.0431362912,
0.0362350568,
-0.0691564009,
0.0229509976,
-0.0358841307,
-0.0175593309,
-0.0142632583,
-0.0289569795,
-0.0328317173,
0.0432117656,
-0.0418363437,
-0.0279817227,
-0.0352006815,
0.0503744446,
0.0270724781,
-0.0492005385,
0.015023917,
0.0223483481,
-0.0091756564,
0.0451114699,
-0.0264948905,
-0.0465326868,
0.0615499653,
0.0341032371,
0.0067170183,
-0.0132405302,
0.0262567494,
-0.0174709931,
-0.0130076343,
0.0240305699,
-0.0206680521,
-0.035754215,
0.0379740335,
-0.0767968372,
-0.0658607855,
0.0997863263,
-0.0528976619,
0.0256459489,
-0.070819594,
-0.009285978,
-0.0386253148,
-0.0766083822,
-0.0820440948,
0.0130879376,
0.0253615994,
0.0208984576,
-0.0511982925,
-0.0032661709,
0.0286570266,
-0.059272822,
-0.001153173,
-0.0086984038,
-0.055923041,
-0.0380168557,
0.0023934667,
0.0053145052,
-0.006259257,
0.0162694659,
0.0826051086,
-0.0469709672,
0.020535646,
0.0230280254,
0.0624140985,
0.0254176483,
-0.0132306367,
0.0159056038,
0.0166095421,
-0.03638478,
-0.0084724892,
0.0506150424,
0.0219021272,
-0.0245423764,
-0.0195047129,
0.0637239069,
0.0252525769,
0.0124225914,
0.0077476385,
-0.0486767814,
0.0167879853,
0.0453238897,
0.0131805921,
-0.0591819584,
-0.0013828974,
0.0194204766,
0.0626882911,
-0.0323105901,
-0.0524490252,
0.0290847011,
-0.1626963317,
0.0073247827,
0.0369140431,
0.0013733744,
-0.0234660152,
-0.0239073653,
-0.0165110603,
-0.0390423536,
-0.014920542,
0.0212546643,
-0.0218039807,
0.0297672953,
0.0472630523,
0.0368966125,
-0.0192955453,
-0.0082858708,
-0.0246036556,
0.0281043556,
0.0102486368,
0.0059713759,
-0.0438786745,
-0.0666902363,
0.018557623,
0.0296474304,
0.0017276884,
-0.0014813888,
0.0494104363,
0.0460778549,
-0.0050695171,
-0.0051493035,
0.0463574231,
-0.0005937188,
-0.0300163478,
0.0194927789,
0.0974117965,
-0.0193782132,
-0.0160861053,
-0.0159260016,
-0.0066291825,
-0.0039908681,
0.0514000729,
-0.015467843,
-0.010880732,
-0.0494738705,
0.0001463348,
-0.0134972315,
-0.0338696577,
-0.009949741,
0.0318426862,
0.019256264,
0.0386903994,
-0.0402575955,
-0.0419608764,
0.0224382374,
0.0712064579,
-0.0133553101,
-0.0241170172,
-0.0379171632,
0.0077157174,
-0.0278785601,
0.015207231,
-0.037558414,
0.0466625839,
-0.0307770427,
0.0313817784,
0.0141114248,
-0.0455936007,
-0.0115208179,
-0.0430990309,
-0.0650106519,
-0.027088454,
-0.0192043409,
0.0736027434,
0.0220538098,
0.0699592754,
0.0185288731,
0.0124524971,
0.0262409337,
0.0811183751,
-0.0497982875,
0.0235799737,
0.0950258449,
-0.0093742264,
0.0116004283,
0.0064503248,
-0.0335182957,
0.0220890269,
0.0740820169,
0.044752501,
-0.0376956649,
0.0090857446,
0.0327852815,
0.034168601,
0.0539703928,
0.0185075607,
0.0265744198,
0.0197146442,
0.0500327982,
-0.0009118479,
0.0053622285,
-0.0079818638,
-0.0143830758,
0.0122731887,
0.0193095487,
-0.011154213,
0.0080198459,
0.0177475028,
0.0317465141,
0.0116266701,
0.001143841,
0.0095865019,
0.0126736229,
0.0354877561,
0.0026668874,
-0.0028128247,
0.0105780186,
0.0515383258,
0.0429395363,
0.0105454717,
0.0475971252,
0.0258771293,
0.0741124675,
-0.0432072058,
-0.0354612507,
-0.0519481637,
-0.0784993023,
-0.0061391396,
0.0272825081,
0.0304132793,
0.0198982786,
-0.0190736391,
-0.0472220182,
-0.0052200034,
-0.0051865061,
-0.0169755705,
-0.0269806646,
0.0238368791,
0.061868649,
0.0262823682,
0.0255493596,
-0.0350107215,
0.0318177529,
-0.0557515435,
0.0800067037,
-0.0642683133,
0.0425895527,
-0.0104872491,
-0.0585481487,
0.0107362196,
-0.0224919226,
0.0384823531,
-0.000104882,
-0.0775329322,
-0.0775747895,
-0.0131739639,
0.0492556803,
0.0234350245,
-0.0088363234,
0.0472841337,
0.0222458858,
-0.0338877365,
0.0084301298,
0.0181580484,
0.0146385059,
-0.0236743148,
-0.0175575837,
-0.0240922626,
-5.820369912e-33,
-0.0001948707,
-0.0132855074,
0.0544937588,
0.0212629735,
0.0021559976,
-0.0506354719,
0.0271641966,
0.016976472,
-0.0302331951,
0.0131373238,
-0.0230597258,
-0.004655309,
-0.0049386043,
0.0178173482,
0.0095034214,
-0.0555839315,
0.0420191139,
-0.0076967054,
-0.0446000881,
0.0025927601,
0.0104176691,
-0.0141271744,
0.0470172018,
-0.091126278,
-0.0318368897,
0.004080601,
-0.0102450876,
0.0427072123,
-0.0738492981,
0.0372276455,
0.0325360522,
0.0092823403,
-0.006982388,
-0.0459737182,
-0.0119992094,
-0.0615175031,
-0.0674498305,
-0.0598644018,
-0.0003340588,
0.0175326746,
-0.063225016,
-0.0283890665,
0.0619000793,
0.0330194905,
-0.0655128285,
0.0065347631,
-0.0134256938,
-0.0516206808,
-0.0117745884,
-0.0261106826,
-0.0331300162,
0.0062427535,
0.022294255,
-0.0211251173,
-0.0034367889,
0.0328382403,
-0.0122584179,
0.0113028558,
0.0154433129,
0.0145925786,
0.034215752,
-0.0139476126,
0.0478422157,
0.021817293,
0.0114588058,
0.029067127,
0.0296498481,
-0.0083615417,
0.0072956295,
-0.0389950648,
0.0105481576,
0.0319354571,
0.0864407569,
0.0758115575,
0.0897871405,
0.0104670785,
-0.0628786236,
0.0184549335,
-0.012042365,
0.0298139919,
-0.0063708532,
-0.0097062411,
-0.0340040736,
-0.0138577474,
-0.0790676624,
0.0186924227,
-0.0268865973,
-0.0257335417,
0.0249297209,
0.0364409164,
-0.0091985296,
0.0233512241,
-0.0025938258,
-0.0295555666,
-0.039589148,
0.0391455889,
-0.0032940526,
-0.0035768005,
0.0147784511,
-0.0257849246,
-0.0559483655,
-0.0060093491,
-0.0082667749,
-0.0241064746,
0.0308028944,
0.0190270767,
0.0665258989,
0.0299064163,
-0.0593700893,
-0.0075277803,
-0.0408469737,
0.0439822115,
0.0795546249,
-0.0454013199,
0.0318162367,
-0.0038185196,
-0.0151826357,
0.0334280357,
-0.0187630374,
-0.0147755183,
-0.025648497,
0.0383853205,
-0.0382727943,
0.057234209,
-0.0130216163,
-0.0170139261,
-0.007268724,
-0.0101479599,
-0.001409492,
-0.0943316817,
-0.0286027379,
-0.0073599983,
2.972e-7,
-0.0033761852,
-0.0236703139,
0.0337896235,
0.0471508354,
0.0152786179,
0.0586736575,
-0.0420835279,
-0.0343446247,
0.0336705185,
0.0028167951,
0.0153781772,
0.0468673445,
-0.0063815173,
0.0348502286,
-0.0115523608,
0.0111725666,
0.0033148683,
-0.0298848487,
-0.0002766672,
0.0002669555,
0.0383179486,
0.0353458486,
0.0503074192,
-0.0155730182,
0.0181965549,
0.0050202506,
0.0718775541,
-0.0374935716,
0.0305727869,
-0.0189635027,
0.0046156165,
-0.0456846841,
0.026721362,
0.0349545404,
0.0104963584,
0.0033078343,
-0.0671119019,
0.0305149294,
0.0059493752,
-0.0052522896,
-0.040188957,
-0.0611232668,
0.030729834,
-0.0125240237,
0.0796083361,
-0.0832677186,
-0.0027527653,
-0.0270254947,
-0.0229199082,
-0.0150470966,
0.02374175,
-0.0029447924,
0.02680609,
0.0092266975,
0.0102195172,
0.0393184833,
0.0059145573,
-0.0355436504,
-0.0192567725,
0.067669332,
0.0071334089,
-0.0416123644,
-0.0111986436,
0.0691325292,
0.0286976211,
-0.036536891,
-0.0347068422,
2.642648595e-34,
0.0344167426,
0.0085723829,
0.0411804244,
0.0090486882,
-0.0168164708,
-0.0117653394,
-0.0279939007,
0.0162734035,
0.0663484558,
0.0281648319,
-0.0053285137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14517v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14517v1 | PostMark: A Robust Blackbox Watermark for Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T17:27:14 | 2024-06-20T17:27:14 | Yapei Chang, Kalpesh Krishna, Amir Houmansadr, John Wieting, Mohit Iyyer | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | The most effective techniques to detect LLM-generated text rely on inserting
a detectable signature -- or watermark -- during the model's decoding process.
Most existing watermarking methods require access to the underlying LLM's
logits, which LLM API providers are loath to share due to fears of model
distillation. As such, these watermarks must be implemented independently by
each LLM provider. In this paper, we develop PostMark, a modular post-hoc
watermarking procedure in which an input-dependent set of words (determined via
a semantic embedding) is inserted into the text after the decoding process has
completed. Critically, PostMark does not require logit access, which means it
can be implemented by a third party. We also show that PostMark is more robust
to paraphrasing attacks than existing watermarking methods: our experiments
cover eight baseline algorithms, five base LLMs, and three datasets. Finally,
we evaluate the impact of PostMark on text quality using both automated and
human assessments, highlighting the trade-off between quality and robustness to
paraphrasing. We release our code, outputs, and annotations at
https://github.com/lilakk/PostMark. | [
0.0268778335,
0.0698222741,
-0.0038288075,
0.0648839176,
-0.0599142723,
-0.013405853,
-0.0059700124,
0.0631568208,
0.0134132728,
-0.0674090609,
0.0133416122,
0.0347807705,
-0.0052470504,
-0.0075274589,
0.0673390925,
-0.0185106657,
0.0390559062,
-0.0254366044,
-0.0178512521,
-0.0019663349,
0.0089629106,
0.013953154,
0.0652196631,
0.0343247503,
0.0107805068,
-0.0097211171,
-0.0004293482,
0.029805379,
-0.0003521966,
-0.0211885404,
-0.0345604308,
0.0370621048,
-0.0042795208,
0.0869012699,
0.0000019396,
-0.0511288457,
-0.0498544686,
0.037584126,
-0.0421261042,
0.0606482327,
0.0474084653,
-0.0118659195,
-0.0158042405,
0.0206883885,
-0.0250137709,
0.0364117809,
0.0372699611,
0.0232555345,
0.094893761,
0.0484207459,
-0.0123286955,
0.0203248728,
0.0289735682,
0.0109835286,
0.0014281856,
-0.0023044976,
0.0261535961,
0.0048158551,
0.0096803149,
0.0248677935,
0.0127929831,
0.0743006915,
-0.0003227232,
-0.0062032701,
-0.023949096,
-0.0211504828,
-0.0249309354,
0.0087034376,
-0.0065152934,
0.053023342,
-0.0324539766,
-0.0329140536,
0.0087727821,
-0.0094529577,
0.0171313658,
0.03767775,
-0.0395098291,
0.0355197303,
0.025050126,
0.0281683952,
0.01099067,
-0.0201920141,
0.0583067089,
-0.0012702671,
0.0118472939,
0.0604796484,
0.0435116068,
-0.0238355286,
-0.0495174564,
-0.0122212991,
-0.0188065451,
-0.0517457537,
0.0408001803,
-0.0100263972,
0.0502525978,
0.0101953177,
-0.1012712866,
-0.0442672819,
0.0377030335,
-0.0217357464,
0.0726923868,
0.0122021791,
-0.0157287065,
0.0289093349,
-0.0557887405,
0.0512580164,
-0.0457453653,
0.0745006353,
-0.0085528698,
-0.0073284698,
-0.0029485563,
-0.0261750314,
-0.0308251157,
0.048749242,
-0.0042945109,
0.0043299873,
-0.0180866029,
0.030568935,
0.0145706842,
0.0265265238,
-0.0166349579,
-0.0252310243,
0.0102604525,
0.0046268376,
0.0414191335,
-0.0500191599,
0.0239475016,
0.0029766071,
-0.0061418926,
-0.0573560633,
-0.0313132852,
0.0355789401,
0.0230210125,
-0.0021836848,
-0.0064873295,
0.0908603892,
0.0428518914,
-0.039957311,
-0.0352846496,
-0.0702599436,
0.002754108,
0.0045014201,
0.0028184231,
-0.0660716072,
-0.0104805846,
-0.0288413651,
0.002845102,
-0.0793223754,
0.0091381343,
0.0237881541,
-0.0401624963,
0.0627637431,
-0.0589244962,
-0.0253400411,
-0.0252177771,
0.0085413847,
-0.0243954696,
0.0505848415,
0.0663904697,
0.0325372703,
0.0953525528,
0.0076011969,
0.0016084869,
0.0751972497,
0.0188134685,
0.0431543812,
-0.0317977481,
-0.0455568954,
0.0365642272,
-0.006787309,
0.0034448013,
0.0373377614,
-0.0115248468,
-0.0397363417,
0.0826802105,
0.075793393,
-0.0331647098,
-0.0000723465,
0.006374782,
0.0307805948,
0.0139400577,
0.0032562527,
-0.0176626779,
-0.0355855487,
-0.0566232242,
0.0001043259,
0.024789691,
-0.0024932276,
0.0287650619,
-0.0096497741,
-0.0520229079,
-0.0273911003,
-0.0022332072,
-0.0142758507,
-0.0085800486,
0.0322942548,
-0.0314395539,
0.0838019475,
0.0027921146,
-0.0415231995,
0.0119251125,
-0.0700552687,
0.027546104,
0.0490575619,
0.100314185,
-0.0071846871,
0.0539335571,
-0.0279566497,
-0.0063571399,
0.0514609069,
-0.0401144773,
0.0128779188,
0.0328811705,
-0.029388912,
-0.0406531096,
-0.0315663926,
0.0230204649,
0.0062169214,
0.0366407447,
0.0088177305,
0.0347009711,
-0.0476782694,
-0.035183467,
0.041015055,
-0.0008256859,
-0.0277935173,
-0.0043362821,
-0.0266403388,
0.0185832605,
0.0238279961,
-0.012050421,
0.0357921943,
0.0172201339,
-0.0238961335,
-0.0191107374,
-0.0004165301,
0.0204362758,
0.0077991653,
0.0482494347,
-0.0360024236,
0.0006973719,
0.0566128269,
-0.0295225065,
-0.0092945779,
-0.0137727233,
-0.0541806147,
0.0584979504,
-0.0269774385,
0.0424666069,
-0.027072683,
0.0510419048,
-0.0369980969,
0.0080128061,
-0.0283434484,
0.0083168661,
0.0194845181,
0.0133252395,
0.0133084767,
-0.0029037814,
-0.0486383066,
0.0060124844,
-0.0138981454,
0.0198141057,
-0.0148777477,
0.0144698098,
-0.0335286856,
0.0001379684,
-0.0455595329,
0.0153802792,
-0.006413559,
0.0323087275,
0.0312351808,
-0.0019591707,
-0.0050367177,
0.0073962826,
0.003206087,
-0.0389722288,
0.00060137,
0.0196154863,
0.0450976454,
-0.0298974905,
-0.0368702933,
-0.0279652551,
-0.0029020221,
-0.0016286317,
0.076788418,
-0.0076221293,
-0.034028925,
-0.095222041,
0.039088238,
-0.0161632653,
-0.0161646362,
0.020979356,
-0.0294903927,
-0.008601361,
-0.017092647,
-0.0251252893,
0.0498019718,
-0.0090986677,
-0.0102393758,
0.0652611852,
0.004226326,
-0.0576749966,
-0.0377795883,
0.0021985783,
0.0081055881,
-0.0245606881,
-0.0482800528,
0.0358203873,
0.0302261543,
0.010294402,
0.0024648001,
0.0008225846,
0.0295729209,
-0.0011835161,
-0.0122874985,
-0.0016223302,
-0.0146589633,
-0.0542231686,
0.0214252863,
-0.0024155837,
-0.0683777407,
0.0328375846,
-0.0740779117,
0.0070370492,
0.0062382482,
-0.0335759483,
-0.0092126988,
0.0367628783,
-0.0291260816,
0.013191605,
-0.002472626,
-0.0236666854,
-0.0247711949,
-0.0324873291,
0.0566494539,
-0.0414368287,
0.0117097571,
-0.0582013056,
0.0022119717,
0.0046536718,
0.006420936,
-0.0213577058,
-0.0578291453,
-0.048158627,
0.0042194929,
-0.0051635914,
-0.0198657624,
-0.0052680573,
-0.0287784375,
0.0170952138,
0.0198999215,
-0.0171838962,
0.0106741972,
-0.0495718978,
0.0497728437,
0.0222219564,
-0.0208379403,
0.0443180799,
-0.0224752594,
-0.0000136267,
0.0678079501,
0.0030692723,
0.0037207294,
-0.0063274866,
-0.0252759997,
0.0377841853,
-0.0058511044,
-0.0237050224,
0.0070262821,
0.0233082734,
-0.0614590086,
0.0159332119,
0.0884525329,
0.0215236098,
-0.0071977125,
0.0129113393,
-0.0231657494,
0.0469542369,
0.0196982212,
-0.0188387483,
-0.079752177,
-0.0433793515,
0.04975852,
0.0503426418,
-0.0171776656,
-0.005967807,
-0.0385954976,
-0.0814857706,
0.0280609895,
0.0308059119,
-0.0062688626,
0.013297163,
-0.0488760807,
-0.0241197869,
0.0426040813,
0.0181792621,
-0.0500631928,
0.014016551,
-0.0052203648,
-0.0054568537,
-0.0522489846,
-0.0424299836,
-0.0205817595,
-0.0490753129,
0.0366552062,
0.045866698,
0.0199953504,
-0.0060334839,
-0.0242780764,
0.0504515544,
-0.0064222617,
-0.0367774479,
-0.0087422989,
0.0625082552,
-0.0011532061,
-0.0216731951,
0.0086545432,
0.0058577852,
-0.009087,
-0.0234846901,
0.0000418982,
0.0546875335,
-0.0186967738,
-0.0001709773,
0.0063787801,
-0.0126406206,
0.0098119527,
0.0720060915,
0.042916324,
-0.0058736694,
-0.0409405604,
-0.058131665,
0.0072468123,
-0.0354330279,
-0.064449884,
0.007958184,
-0.0476492755,
-0.0097175576,
-0.0726851076,
0.0071833315,
-0.0246475823,
0.0050839647,
0.0343120061,
0.0531203076,
0.006021189,
-0.0274392031,
-0.0416360386,
0.0050227623,
-0.1141152382,
0.0286953636,
-0.046603635,
0.0175227225,
0.0345950946,
-0.0011886657,
-0.0105927298,
0.0395001918,
-0.1058445498,
-0.0641964823,
0.0141038671,
0.0265347548,
0.0191380177,
0.0197749343,
-0.0213908628,
-0.0697921515,
0.0567731857,
0.0151244542,
-0.0069317301,
0.0290113185,
0.0581681281,
-0.0108393952,
0.00654636,
0.0499066301,
-0.0699855983,
-0.0372544117,
0.0312343929,
-0.0072041396,
-0.0378503278,
-0.012043328,
0.0033137607,
0.0824849457,
0.0213943422,
-0.0321267359,
0.0014789361,
0.0170417465,
0.033512637,
-0.0313900448,
-0.0206943285,
-0.0517576933,
0.0353893302,
0.0131872147,
-0.039894294,
0.0011352206,
0.0173819102,
-0.0376828611,
0.0366521254,
-0.0134499744,
0.0274561197,
-0.0330464654,
-0.0005081949,
0.0237693917,
0.0033163342,
0.0117122121,
0.0407607369,
-0.0166262407,
0.0249799341,
-0.0032700351,
-0.0093872696,
0.0019865963,
-0.0219041575,
-0.0289146397,
0.0700504258,
-0.0766345635,
-0.0251184423,
-0.0077328603,
0.0387571752,
0.0402324758,
0.0113649182,
0.0675842538,
-0.0367658585,
-0.0264704712,
-0.0174675323,
0.0383319929,
-0.027569415,
-0.0250563491,
0.0265394263,
-0.014885935,
-0.0305602215,
0.0448210128,
0.042987939,
0.0556076951,
0.0649102032,
-0.0040098205,
-0.0268265083,
-0.04193056,
-0.0482249409,
0.0472281687,
0.0137619665,
-0.0320493095,
-0.0355055928,
-0.0511449389,
-0.0745451227,
0.0168183576,
-0.0003819074,
-0.0119394455,
-0.0051059192,
-0.0303608291,
0.0167049933,
0.0010952121,
0.003900063,
-0.0392163135,
0.0193529017,
0.0374965668,
-0.0526656397,
0.00678478,
-5.714465585e-33,
-0.009848386,
-0.0512643382,
-0.0497787707,
-0.0247851349,
0.0195668954,
0.0424305722,
-0.0190583467,
0.0050711175,
0.0264733322,
-0.0107632838,
-0.0149506405,
0.0054461248,
0.0148660233,
-0.012753021,
-0.0276734363,
-0.0310572535,
0.0404691808,
0.0025962002,
-0.0265044775,
-0.0231971703,
0.0277240276,
-0.0008230784,
0.0430039391,
-0.0678374991,
0.0347892158,
-0.0302886814,
-0.0544047765,
-0.0248905458,
-0.0346108153,
0.04729167,
-0.0034883283,
0.021688154,
-0.0134821814,
0.0230773799,
-0.0584367365,
-0.0005843663,
-0.0294584911,
-0.0072340383,
0.0340515822,
0.012249805,
-0.0257872492,
-0.0841618329,
0.0418754853,
-0.0312169213,
-0.0044690063,
0.014337901,
-0.0001290657,
-0.016500311,
-0.0347426385,
-0.0063417451,
-0.0094500473,
0.0263442434,
-0.0141161671,
0.0239458364,
0.0570572093,
-0.0084578563,
0.0375641286,
0.0549312681,
-0.0807352513,
0.0162609499,
-0.0226973128,
0.0099590281,
0.0584310703,
-0.0122580323,
-0.0000676168,
0.0451288074,
-0.0219632015,
-0.0235789828,
0.0332122967,
-0.0170834288,
0.0286212843,
0.0120100128,
0.0770122707,
0.0594211258,
0.038800694,
-0.0070058326,
0.0017758654,
0.0352012329,
-0.0299935807,
-0.0173260327,
0.0321750231,
0.0183520634,
-0.0343557969,
-0.012919168,
-0.0592335127,
-0.0521313213,
-0.0176434983,
-0.0218000524,
0.035872031,
-0.0078426516,
-0.0671036616,
-0.0224366393,
0.0184391253,
-0.0667386204,
-0.032773789,
-0.0165580884,
-0.0196387004,
0.0343446098,
0.0060962662,
0.0282079112,
0.0261671226,
0.0064416118,
0.0240531117,
-0.033496514,
0.0551902056,
-0.0198576041,
0.0381985344,
0.0209579859,
-0.085661374,
0.0214288495,
-0.0143936807,
0.0044868435,
0.0136777544,
-0.0409267955,
0.0176693834,
-0.0361658633,
0.019020116,
-0.0072215437,
0.0520322807,
0.0046124789,
-0.006649646,
0.0110099316,
-0.012686858,
0.0132764606,
-0.0233027097,
0.0104599288,
-0.0140598137,
0.0453958958,
0.0602089278,
-0.0177401006,
-0.0011223976,
-0.0245393943,
2.55e-7,
0.03845587,
0.043026939,
0.0362348855,
0.0128681688,
0.0059607904,
0.0524306744,
-0.0047176434,
0.0134711228,
-0.0378660411,
-0.0244747419,
-0.0258520357,
-0.0091528343,
0.0885930285,
-0.0047121062,
-0.1018046439,
0.0173046384,
-0.0503451675,
0.0141260773,
-0.0657099932,
-0.0280532185,
0.0507128127,
0.1072118357,
0.0406398997,
-0.0229164716,
-0.0373708494,
-0.0627599955,
0.0433024019,
-0.0515078753,
-0.0199687108,
-0.0026856433,
0.0357121527,
0.0216766931,
0.0228505246,
-0.014095,
-0.0372358635,
-0.0112412935,
0.0137275197,
0.0679486841,
0.0192773696,
-0.0001099823,
-0.0505681038,
-0.0565854758,
0.0048900852,
-0.0478812121,
0.0773440972,
0.0705712363,
-0.022243131,
-0.0837966949,
-0.0108363042,
-0.0509069525,
0.0378432572,
-0.039243564,
-0.0175290443,
0.0128006004,
-0.00004232,
0.0009049593,
-0.022954274,
-0.054057546,
-0.0588200204,
-0.0682795793,
-0.0170431174,
-0.0279798303,
-0.0327600092,
0.0100969281,
0.0517017283,
-0.0717355087,
0.0251304004,
2.805718589e-34,
0.0249214042,
-0.029304456,
0.0239308327,
0.0804687142,
0.0544048697,
0.0127690732,
0.0238035358,
0.0148710301,
-0.0109594818,
-0.0351605788,
0.0112961857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14511v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14511v1 | Investigating Mysteries of CoT-Augmented Distillation | 2024-06-20T17:15:46 | 2024-06-20T17:15:46 | Somin Wadhwa, Silvio Amir, Byron C. Wallace | cs.CL | cs.CL | Eliciting "chain of thought" (CoT) rationales -- sequences of token that
convey a "reasoning" process -- has been shown to consistently improve LLM
performance on tasks like question answering. More recent efforts have shown
that such rationales can also be used for model distillation: Including CoT
sequences (elicited from a large "teacher" model) in addition to target labels
when fine-tuning a small student model yields (often substantial) improvements.
In this work we ask: Why and how does this additional training signal help in
model distillation? We perform ablations to interrogate this, and report some
potentially surprising results. Specifically: (1) Placing CoT sequences after
labels (rather than before) realizes consistently better downstream performance
-- this means that no student "reasoning" is necessary at test time to realize
gains. (2) When rationales are appended in this way, they need not be coherent
reasoning sequences to yield improvements; performance increases are robust to
permutations of CoT tokens, for example. In fact, (3) a small number of key
tokens are sufficient to achieve improvements equivalent to those observed when
full rationales are used in model distillation. | [
0.0032763351,
0.0326188356,
-0.005240913,
0.0128169665,
-0.0316827968,
0.033956714,
0.0059849839,
0.0130697601,
-0.0504804477,
-0.0244763736,
-0.0119511914,
0.0128504746,
-0.0327713974,
-0.0184009559,
0.0343948603,
-0.0479667485,
0.0426895916,
-0.0645093098,
0.0164967738,
-0.0231573246,
-0.0491290167,
-0.036249578,
-0.0451821871,
0.0120205497,
0.0127877844,
-0.0327613689,
-0.0505793057,
0.0173639879,
0.0139160231,
-0.0126531078,
-0.0248169955,
0.0514382944,
0.0125156865,
-0.0191955809,
0.0000019992,
-0.0554360747,
-0.003282483,
-0.0084263301,
-0.0737827122,
0.0264660828,
-0.0659965947,
0.0880528986,
0.0413970686,
0.0257687755,
-0.040440809,
0.0502973795,
0.0126483981,
0.0381347537,
0.0588618182,
0.0505814403,
0.0281290617,
-0.0412271433,
0.0159014147,
-0.000313875,
0.0367316082,
-0.0361276604,
0.0075944266,
0.0105241612,
0.0176896118,
0.031884823,
-0.0351573862,
0.0036692061,
0.0529833958,
0.0306304544,
0.0137602473,
0.0330160409,
-0.014001159,
-0.0323640928,
0.0150652891,
0.0243027899,
-0.0084014265,
-0.0127787385,
-0.0022599222,
0.0186485443,
0.0621073954,
-0.0086476579,
-0.0931203216,
0.0102397678,
-0.0019928038,
0.0366452001,
0.0253332928,
-0.0419581458,
0.0265260432,
-0.0028713183,
-0.0391835161,
0.0673496425,
-0.0210607443,
-0.068340838,
0.0444848351,
0.0154215097,
-0.0182393156,
-0.0627832785,
-0.0039573992,
0.0714231431,
0.0177329108,
0.0117842015,
0.0063908319,
0.0284505803,
0.0023609875,
0.037324626,
0.0197538752,
0.0507473275,
-0.0058936975,
-0.0159093998,
-0.0637883767,
0.0681347251,
-0.0036286497,
0.0932058766,
-0.0382844768,
0.01885291,
-0.1045840904,
-0.0269059576,
-0.02570788,
0.1109570563,
-0.0116929114,
0.0179624632,
-0.0572823584,
0.0177603718,
-0.0004876107,
-0.0088939741,
0.0093986047,
0.0187796913,
0.023681609,
0.0334072597,
-0.0735151693,
0.041284088,
-0.0419160165,
0.0324786529,
0.0535101108,
-0.0423937552,
-0.0525623634,
-0.0069254995,
-0.0269769356,
-0.0074659027,
0.0125129241,
0.0515600257,
-0.0519276746,
-0.0425202325,
-0.0550931878,
-0.0524155125,
-0.0104590096,
-0.0723791569,
0.0527435355,
-0.0764247328,
-0.0031304467,
0.0137132499,
0.0066279909,
-0.046769876,
0.0188316591,
-0.004817063,
0.001286983,
0.0521204509,
0.0044609006,
0.0011723826,
-0.0110522918,
0.0506995544,
-0.0387135632,
0.060997095,
0.0201322976,
0.057646092,
-0.0004988139,
-0.0209998321,
0.0020728933,
0.0060409759,
0.036308039,
0.0023449997,
0.0044899783,
0.0051863231,
-0.0002180455,
0.026488442,
0.0218703561,
0.0215483438,
-0.0398503058,
0.0305112079,
0.0486802422,
0.0771015659,
0.0265099946,
-0.0033111286,
0.0169116147,
-0.0294842236,
0.0160717797,
0.0821472257,
-0.075948216,
0.015434443,
-0.0049187294,
0.019891372,
0.0436193794,
-0.0035735972,
-0.0294031613,
-0.0994578749,
-0.0123719024,
0.035006199,
-0.0187688619,
0.0501264594,
0.0290551279,
0.0116463769,
-0.0108375158,
0.0897891,
0.0315762199,
-0.0422435962,
0.0048735728,
-0.0853140876,
0.001566065,
0.0123542286,
0.0170946885,
-0.0112404888,
-0.0485038348,
-0.0074201762,
0.0231462065,
-0.0010378369,
0.009512282,
-0.0288239848,
0.0194559004,
-0.0192002654,
-0.0350571796,
-0.04661832,
0.0078550978,
-0.0276799724,
0.0130594103,
0.0051349881,
-0.0086891167,
-0.0685703009,
-0.0247079637,
0.0268510841,
-0.0189563949,
-0.0689167976,
-0.0206781644,
0.0296014976,
0.0256268419,
0.0030059326,
0.0113253575,
0.010319436,
0.0526703037,
-0.0288052019,
-0.0214210022,
-0.0251474809,
-0.0403261036,
-0.0423480235,
0.0496069491,
-0.0099536339,
-0.0296676438,
-0.0003413469,
-0.0538580231,
-0.0638630614,
0.0032382014,
-0.0212994032,
0.0114193056,
0.0058634039,
0.0412309542,
0.012206303,
-0.0151489051,
-0.0473359153,
0.0546590537,
-0.0211411621,
0.0002794568,
-0.0067690494,
-0.0050128372,
-0.0062784469,
-0.0070651132,
0.0525134467,
0.0351974145,
-0.0062197079,
-0.0124347555,
-0.0320167057,
-0.0013802586,
-0.075584814,
-0.0257396251,
-0.0313275084,
-0.0029009839,
-0.0052443934,
0.0326060876,
0.022361923,
-0.0085286507,
0.0048966971,
0.0041911439,
-0.0341928713,
-0.0434607081,
-0.0091175642,
0.0263563506,
0.0363984555,
0.0034407829,
-0.0322336592,
0.0046332506,
-0.019046966,
-0.019309761,
0.0218676813,
-0.0398518406,
0.0010623435,
-0.0193793364,
0.0479859971,
-0.0257182922,
-0.0220656898,
-0.0087791234,
-0.0033098122,
0.058038082,
0.0147908423,
0.0050038169,
0.0714399517,
-0.0164490659,
0.0302396547,
0.0563892685,
0.0091565466,
-0.0446684621,
0.0340131633,
-0.0153427189,
-0.0188143961,
-0.0465266928,
-0.0586126149,
-0.0170911532,
0.0610009022,
-0.0110303285,
-0.0013291856,
-0.0366614312,
0.0114751384,
0.0103794504,
-0.059066508,
-0.0662734509,
-0.0014622026,
-0.0195758585,
0.0765440315,
-0.0147951609,
-0.0242510289,
0.085528478,
-0.0061425082,
-0.0075766272,
-0.0481643751,
0.0054953857,
-0.0216045603,
0.0458927006,
-0.0327676609,
-0.0305386726,
0.0061806054,
-0.0127786146,
-0.06593775,
-0.0476483405,
-0.0184358228,
-0.0268034674,
0.0874904916,
-0.0578308739,
-0.0314179361,
-0.0035855472,
-0.0429779142,
-0.0741937831,
0.0211639609,
-0.0156387091,
0.0346004665,
-0.0124549484,
-0.006143074,
-0.0257073063,
-0.0428929962,
0.032558281,
-0.0298268627,
-0.022136569,
-0.0261129811,
-0.0317330956,
0.0259637553,
0.0120097073,
0.0156693868,
0.0495370626,
-0.0566752143,
0.064064458,
0.0664405674,
0.0528040417,
-0.0270540994,
-0.0031084486,
0.025276361,
0.0112021314,
-0.0277765244,
-0.0220139995,
0.0285697579,
0.055109363,
-0.0436358564,
-0.0319153219,
0.0906112045,
0.0136302849,
0.0182284154,
0.0161014162,
-0.014338173,
0.0682189986,
0.0378701203,
-0.0006561856,
-0.0559061058,
-0.0359878987,
0.0328944586,
0.0411231853,
-0.007777628,
-0.0084850378,
0.0013781959,
-0.0680932999,
0.0339437537,
0.0042442866,
-0.0055965483,
-0.0026965581,
-0.0374566093,
0.0009685447,
0.0103198346,
0.0281929784,
0.019062994,
-0.0078160008,
0.0180075746,
0.0765801668,
0.013749972,
-0.0163927786,
-0.0140073719,
0.0133475848,
-0.0287337508,
0.0038906613,
0.0134791769,
-0.0047904169,
-0.0985990912,
0.0581790656,
-0.0245459192,
0.0493081585,
-0.0172495656,
0.02166982,
0.0302679092,
0.0124174953,
-0.003157849,
0.0375086069,
-0.0344455019,
-0.038543649,
0.0234006867,
0.0860771686,
-0.0390317179,
-0.0458768234,
-0.0176745281,
-0.0035722919,
-0.0403938778,
0.0633732304,
0.081626147,
-0.0271422546,
-0.0421255864,
-0.035825517,
-0.0552300438,
-0.0272308253,
-0.0151481405,
0.0088169323,
-0.0053741564,
0.0535432696,
-0.025918901,
-0.0476924293,
0.0178237129,
0.0620000437,
-0.0117917424,
0.0499820858,
-0.016734371,
0.0099671436,
-0.0041483166,
0.0421629325,
-0.0199802164,
-0.0273987111,
-0.0480188504,
-0.009233946,
-0.0162617955,
-0.0306980982,
-0.0288269464,
0.0008102466,
-0.1180876791,
-0.0502003804,
0.010651757,
0.0412442535,
0.0339780003,
0.0404032506,
0.0216538683,
-0.0422400534,
0.0299475286,
0.0142376972,
0.0392574854,
0.0443230942,
0.0460568033,
-0.001836493,
0.0137284873,
0.0100749116,
-0.0236139242,
0.0070231105,
0.0541246533,
0.0388207771,
-0.0505118482,
-0.0001150209,
0.0334864594,
0.0317149982,
0.0592744239,
0.0104836468,
-0.0023706614,
0.003595701,
0.0677967146,
0.0371068381,
-0.0052790362,
-0.0041386988,
-0.0139588416,
0.0300961491,
0.0187034216,
0.0163574778,
-0.0234750882,
0.0046665431,
0.0151276067,
-0.0000843913,
-0.0108567374,
-0.0170848817,
0.0080319569,
0.0285683013,
0.0071600624,
-0.0156862177,
0.0248801354,
0.0228283852,
0.0664488822,
0.0143329287,
0.0476714149,
0.0446953103,
0.0473859236,
-0.0271683261,
0.0128780836,
-0.1145853847,
-0.0742619634,
0.0367089696,
0.0137005262,
0.0261972938,
0.0421427824,
-0.0029334407,
-0.0292121619,
-0.0031351857,
0.0177964643,
-0.0154963061,
-0.0095157865,
0.0103441449,
0.0374719091,
0.0350654759,
0.0188883897,
-0.0323341191,
0.0544762872,
-0.0195805337,
0.0506089404,
-0.0166175887,
0.0382440649,
-0.0231758766,
-0.0588545315,
-0.0124670248,
0.017714411,
0.0400308669,
-0.0095211798,
-0.0559194423,
-0.0641263425,
0.0127617735,
-0.0008057021,
0.0315774344,
-0.0447255783,
0.0438604951,
0.0447795652,
-0.0083577698,
-0.0583038628,
0.017075317,
0.0010031404,
0.0452552997,
-0.0290304217,
-0.0111974971,
-6.125843058e-33,
-0.0253347196,
-0.0246912148,
0.0414684713,
0.0353804119,
-0.0135381082,
-0.0198985115,
-0.0223176703,
0.0126766469,
-0.0317357294,
0.0141920028,
-0.0417449474,
0.0274229348,
0.0303946752,
0.0096718268,
0.0051605701,
-0.0564811788,
0.0370530747,
0.0135943759,
-0.0347098224,
0.0126447249,
0.0320981033,
0.0225545093,
0.034321364,
-0.0338054188,
0.0226799175,
-0.0134359589,
0.0168372411,
0.0125018135,
-0.081444785,
0.0449500903,
0.0018451106,
0.0402947888,
0.0207492914,
-0.0431964211,
-0.0296194367,
-0.0209476352,
-0.0706728101,
-0.05873321,
0.0452018231,
-0.0099426927,
-0.0577841774,
-0.0716575682,
0.0531495214,
0.0226605404,
-0.0332915708,
-0.026848495,
0.0154623017,
-0.0207538307,
-0.0398105197,
-0.0139478976,
-0.0232882071,
-0.0290423892,
-0.0274551827,
-0.0155440476,
0.0050832788,
0.0330072567,
-0.039396029,
0.0256023463,
-0.019189531,
0.0117429439,
0.0494463034,
0.0523197837,
0.0623642169,
0.0367687568,
-0.0144648226,
0.044163648,
0.0280819759,
-0.0001192044,
-0.0138047049,
-0.0440783016,
0.0085601052,
0.0646748468,
0.065652743,
-0.0153718637,
0.0672999769,
0.0104215043,
-0.0814533308,
0.0004265249,
-0.0253450088,
0.0414582789,
-0.0070877597,
-0.003782881,
0.0000851085,
-0.0286035258,
-0.0727599561,
0.0083779292,
-0.0246291906,
-0.0076024197,
0.0282314997,
0.0060314983,
-0.0064538722,
-0.025760917,
0.0073924805,
-0.0106148655,
0.0111449016,
0.008814645,
0.0012104561,
0.0228428859,
0.0010445102,
-0.0214821622,
-0.0441489518,
-0.0118500739,
0.0135187609,
0.0114031583,
0.0390120298,
-0.0143652037,
0.0546505824,
-0.0134220067,
-0.0203349721,
-0.0179007724,
-0.064365916,
0.0428631045,
0.0390278958,
-0.0307496209,
0.0405822508,
0.0116604203,
-0.0102508757,
0.0292411745,
0.0056922426,
-0.0224127658,
-0.0271299221,
0.0282232054,
-0.0095694615,
0.0368919,
0.0072919065,
0.0028736941,
0.0068271887,
0.0362293683,
-0.0113142077,
-0.0685828254,
-0.024355229,
0.0405498222,
2.753e-7,
0.0125233661,
-0.0048274118,
0.0304622073,
0.0045562652,
0.0107610533,
0.0122420434,
-0.0489741899,
-0.0471770279,
0.0486533418,
-0.0765057355,
-0.0093162172,
0.0653016716,
0.0460360907,
0.0297926422,
-0.049382735,
-0.0267230924,
-0.0263312329,
-0.0199035853,
-0.0246323943,
0.0075271553,
0.0425717011,
0.0250632204,
0.0127647072,
-0.0523564667,
0.0022254691,
-0.0007343351,
0.0222699661,
-0.0141216163,
0.031925492,
0.0008242854,
0.0072697019,
-0.0409511738,
0.0482298657,
0.0558151528,
0.0120573537,
0.0064764433,
-0.0302547272,
0.0314947963,
0.0291579105,
-0.0548938438,
-0.0444440879,
-0.0042771003,
0.0419795364,
-0.0473708883,
0.0662179142,
-0.0192414373,
-0.0180145707,
0.0065109017,
-0.0120986952,
-0.0273536649,
0.0187031329,
0.0006436539,
0.0331232175,
0.0278963167,
-0.0220633075,
-0.0127890399,
0.004794402,
-0.0778534636,
-0.0231109168,
0.0173577555,
-0.0451516435,
-0.0676847547,
-0.0230371021,
-0.0035185649,
-0.0026967579,
-0.0358852744,
-0.0748796239,
2.563614508e-34,
0.0089191617,
-0.0217811484,
0.0673906282,
0.0691178441,
0.0039357296,
-0.0181646757,
-0.0545341112,
-0.013494242,
0.0338831469,
-0.0682719499,
-0.0119382553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14508v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14508v1 | Evidence of a log scaling law for political persuasion with large language models | 2024-06-20T17:12:38 | 2024-06-20T17:12:38 | Kobi Hackenburg, Ben M. Tappin, Paul Röttger, Scott Hale, Jonathan Bright, Helen Margetts | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC | Large language models can now generate political messages as persuasive as
those written by humans, raising concerns about how far this persuasiveness may
continue to increase with model size. Here, we generate 720 persuasive messages
on 10 U.S. political issues from 24 language models spanning several orders of
magnitude in size. We then deploy these messages in a large-scale randomized
survey experiment (N = 25,982) to estimate the persuasive capability of each
model. Our findings are twofold. First, we find evidence of a log scaling law:
model persuasiveness is characterized by sharply diminishing returns, such that
current frontier models are barely more persuasive than models smaller in size
by an order of magnitude or more. Second, mere task completion (coherence,
staying on topic) appears to account for larger models' persuasive advantage.
These findings suggest that further scaling model size will not much increase
the persuasiveness of static LLM-generated messages. | [
0.0054438999,
0.0707220212,
0.0215887669,
-0.0150745027,
-0.0162502676,
0.0006545974,
0.0066298256,
0.0091020521,
0.0055744285,
-0.0094477972,
0.0151529824,
-0.0517060757,
-0.0184241366,
0.0295838173,
0.0151958121,
-0.0657208189,
-0.0041057374,
-0.0305036251,
0.0610810928,
-0.0590279512,
0.0025742536,
-0.0148294233,
0.0248027928,
0.0549021289,
-0.0017795931,
-0.0148256365,
0.0046500494,
0.0230102837,
-0.0072883382,
-0.0386752523,
-0.0143199582,
0.047579512,
0.03704907,
-0.0193132479,
0.0000017702,
-0.044979535,
0.0317028053,
-0.0122495033,
-0.0354951955,
0.0464926176,
0.1192857474,
-0.0034992169,
-0.037209481,
0.0297484882,
-0.0007262868,
0.0433032513,
0.0822811201,
0.0710445344,
-0.009871087,
0.0278988015,
0.0201524533,
-0.0310528018,
0.0417679511,
-0.0339668579,
-0.0322666317,
0.007786701,
0.0279142428,
-0.0070730327,
-0.0247959923,
0.0464223176,
0.0039415755,
0.0060397522,
0.006285917,
-0.0167724453,
-0.0184483808,
0.0153775327,
0.0003268367,
0.0005602841,
-0.0039973129,
0.0273989886,
0.0031976507,
-0.0189026967,
0.0191695057,
-0.0069637676,
0.0432443619,
0.0260173976,
-0.0661359355,
0.0346563607,
0.0188546926,
0.0235311538,
0.0354762748,
0.0002613178,
0.0388960727,
0.0027075391,
0.0105290748,
0.0250634849,
-0.0143141048,
-0.0455062017,
0.0357039869,
-0.0157787185,
-0.011960349,
-0.0492011867,
-0.04034172,
-0.0313526168,
-0.0092066005,
0.0222023446,
0.0129235098,
0.0449406058,
0.0436647311,
-0.0867578462,
0.0405242778,
0.0047990582,
0.0142944539,
0.0288298801,
0.0452556312,
0.012956352,
-0.0325786248,
0.0186174139,
0.0148086678,
0.0262478814,
-0.0531977862,
-0.0020664744,
-0.0218065511,
0.0088969739,
0.0071253623,
-0.0046680509,
-0.0487549528,
-0.0217669196,
-0.0395391211,
0.0107955504,
-0.0495848656,
0.0088375667,
-0.0215853043,
-0.0353557952,
-0.0094882865,
0.0937157646,
-0.0439956561,
0.01866992,
0.0466185547,
-0.010003089,
0.0167222973,
0.0372317582,
-0.0002023611,
0.0075417003,
0.0277319457,
0.0036949376,
-0.0057206755,
0.0032787633,
-0.048235625,
-0.0127757574,
-0.0394655839,
-0.0506887585,
-0.0190410074,
-0.0667897463,
-0.0125451023,
-0.0043075201,
0.0065383692,
-0.0408392884,
0.0061471597,
-0.0187752061,
-0.023340527,
0.0428728126,
0.0268788859,
0.0292410254,
0.0195238292,
0.0333340541,
-0.0193129499,
0.0723157451,
0.033211939,
0.0829763487,
0.0340624675,
-0.0223207474,
0.0321974568,
0.0152714858,
-0.0092414916,
0.0524305552,
0.0054563303,
-0.0179087762,
-0.0450566933,
0.0012243502,
0.0015834507,
0.0670619309,
-0.0051257061,
0.0316603631,
0.080184713,
0.0764334351,
-0.0015832598,
0.0119220633,
-0.0244414844,
0.0419234857,
-0.0017982152,
0.0149458889,
-0.0284730028,
-0.0154204154,
-0.0254055168,
-0.0054927822,
0.0760863423,
0.0234627035,
-0.0439398177,
-0.0358612798,
-0.0150333932,
-0.0136087639,
0.0102301426,
0.0005551267,
0.0390040427,
-0.0253073573,
-0.019531697,
0.0079872431,
0.0562532432,
-0.0309411529,
-0.0191592444,
-0.0063150353,
0.0093612466,
-0.0070109535,
-0.0130162742,
0.005682304,
0.0464011356,
-0.0500392094,
0.0525492914,
0.0861864686,
0.072415866,
-0.0184584595,
-0.0320643894,
-0.0276316665,
-0.0126189366,
-0.0260407776,
0.0261415783,
0.0392342173,
-0.0044065979,
0.0266310032,
-0.0067477017,
-0.0367395803,
-0.0388097093,
-0.0027929707,
-0.0156563781,
-0.0130198793,
-0.0327489004,
0.0035126493,
0.0663441643,
0.0116049284,
-0.0216774084,
-0.0030636042,
0.0146580972,
-0.0518331341,
-0.0287629329,
0.0004635648,
0.0003270919,
0.0640214831,
-0.0059577595,
0.0005065275,
0.0105283959,
-0.0021269449,
0.0244260505,
0.0271994844,
0.0618739389,
-0.0360257402,
0.0922404304,
0.0063013327,
0.0167740304,
-0.0352536961,
0.0016618243,
-0.0090531986,
0.0279930886,
0.0123453643,
-0.0263046045,
0.0257247407,
-0.0360345095,
0.0076394388,
-0.0182462297,
0.0188554879,
0.010862573,
0.0159107167,
0.0218008272,
0.0308038201,
-0.0763325542,
-0.029819699,
-0.0708649755,
-0.0261150021,
-0.0361025371,
-0.0165697038,
0.0308129564,
-0.0050676037,
-0.0202099513,
0.0119686099,
0.065992631,
-0.0557965003,
-0.0364745483,
0.0090140766,
0.0505405776,
0.0110694049,
-0.012631638,
-0.04020679,
-0.0028921915,
0.0104756542,
-0.0031024748,
0.0128731811,
0.0564443506,
-0.0061679734,
-0.0490984321,
0.0508468784,
-0.0295548216,
-0.0178694967,
-0.0239788797,
-0.0431689471,
0.018993903,
0.0335782804,
0.1006423458,
0.0603870489,
0.0432660505,
0.044284001,
0.0509914681,
0.0444460548,
-0.0757121295,
-0.0365377776,
-0.0597864017,
-0.0027675019,
-0.0540455692,
-0.0573413707,
0.0568660125,
0.0321460702,
0.0093591344,
0.0374548808,
-0.0164499898,
0.0550736152,
0.0000542333,
-0.0335111544,
-0.0097385179,
0.0010526548,
-0.011706396,
0.068434678,
-0.0052458458,
-0.0663435385,
0.0182776302,
-0.0027415692,
0.0083993692,
0.0214769263,
-0.028663557,
0.0129868686,
0.0435910337,
-0.005241381,
0.0303945355,
0.0230051912,
-0.0192597546,
-0.0168104172,
-0.08158461,
0.0149954176,
-0.0340448767,
0.0287392922,
-0.0115303723,
0.0005718223,
0.0264055226,
-0.0471076146,
-0.0137567278,
-0.0845522285,
-0.0089477412,
-0.0089480225,
0.0384846851,
-0.0390021689,
-0.0347500071,
-0.0117507679,
0.0649327934,
-0.0341531076,
0.0173237883,
-0.0175417028,
0.0394714139,
-0.0167006887,
0.0102225672,
0.0330068842,
0.0322557949,
-0.0786057189,
0.0166870933,
0.026811216,
-0.0076957974,
-0.0128892194,
-0.0363664664,
-0.0337953083,
0.0113237901,
-0.0035500324,
-0.0035244578,
0.0322101004,
0.0651398078,
-0.0287292078,
0.035173066,
0.0388258509,
-0.0204234309,
-0.0051647592,
0.0172231849,
-0.032559514,
0.0629445538,
0.008020537,
0.0042013344,
-0.0473488458,
0.0138839306,
0.0201167203,
0.01072588,
-0.0359462276,
0.0214342382,
-0.0277354009,
-0.0915991664,
0.0717559978,
0.0330844745,
0.0736957937,
-0.0108202342,
-0.0610528849,
-0.0039248741,
-0.018456636,
-0.0315872543,
-0.0143729141,
-0.0062826863,
-0.0372794569,
-0.0035687156,
-0.0375124477,
-0.0511806048,
-0.0127864229,
-0.0331372805,
0.0353301354,
0.0539585128,
0.0492041633,
-0.0215361193,
-0.0663791224,
0.0611627549,
0.0557053238,
-0.0241186079,
0.0161910374,
0.0406786054,
0.0114929983,
0.0186199788,
-0.0425646007,
0.0189448148,
0.0192761384,
-0.0305787921,
0.0082913972,
0.0368280523,
0.0002169937,
-0.0751061365,
0.0176932774,
0.0268056653,
0.0201998651,
0.0861193836,
0.0419093594,
-0.040986836,
-0.015273096,
-0.0675656721,
-0.0080094654,
0.0337992609,
-0.047136642,
-0.0298868231,
-0.0070691197,
0.0083326222,
-0.0130822072,
-0.0122869844,
-0.0325979628,
0.0099434229,
0.0192183368,
0.0255908147,
0.0169386566,
0.0169535186,
0.0460960828,
0.0195985958,
-0.0509591773,
-0.0190871544,
-0.0921380818,
-0.0174966343,
-0.0183144789,
-0.0234816112,
-0.0058881654,
-0.0477550179,
-0.0259982664,
-0.070618771,
0.0092969835,
-0.0085793734,
0.0269323122,
0.0118613914,
0.0368609726,
-0.0298296474,
0.0335402116,
0.0626728013,
-0.0042499509,
0.0214800444,
0.0466632843,
0.0509799793,
0.0101171676,
0.0257825293,
0.0088199954,
0.0704838112,
0.0438695177,
0.001676588,
-0.0551125295,
-0.042062372,
0.0142602324,
0.0588810742,
0.0147192487,
0.0015010473,
-0.0296492018,
-0.0228670873,
-0.0363537259,
-0.0070346147,
0.0014446592,
-0.0095218997,
0.0035056029,
0.0193891693,
-0.0010504032,
0.0254422054,
0.0035829116,
-0.0336329266,
0.0197636951,
-0.0184186623,
0.0558441095,
-0.0954724476,
0.014772783,
0.0462225676,
-0.0007734165,
-0.0170057435,
0.0394175574,
-0.0152412867,
0.0398385674,
0.0298458058,
0.0320411026,
-0.0058268583,
-0.0096525969,
0.0154503835,
0.0145352641,
-0.0553483255,
-0.0933476165,
-0.0061840289,
-0.0078310147,
-0.0025650167,
0.0342904665,
0.0447262861,
-0.0469890945,
-0.0103790704,
-0.0228303913,
0.0256480202,
-0.0061382991,
-0.023842359,
0.040484488,
-0.0091221044,
-0.0680206269,
0.0143330749,
0.0299096294,
-0.0528760292,
0.0160075389,
0.0229034331,
-0.0005723607,
-0.0201256871,
-0.0501554497,
0.0157737676,
-0.0062529962,
-0.0006451944,
0.0090184929,
-0.0644611269,
0.0070621623,
-0.0289542247,
-0.0000782487,
-0.0241898894,
-0.0324077308,
0.0013550586,
0.0037722178,
-0.0579128116,
0.0549244322,
-0.0288235415,
0.0157439206,
-0.0117818462,
0.0050984616,
0.0327377394,
-5.861305768e-33,
0.0219964106,
0.0048692748,
-0.0195850115,
0.0057204105,
0.0098897349,
-0.0114392396,
-0.0129924743,
0.0635984316,
-0.0131041836,
0.0622508414,
-0.0010123439,
-0.0054755695,
0.0106503982,
-0.003983771,
-0.0102581019,
-0.0197201557,
0.0453099236,
0.0124883633,
-0.0393619128,
0.0437302031,
0.0335942991,
-0.0206623599,
-0.0069411309,
-0.0906280577,
0.0432546884,
0.011226451,
-0.019548228,
-0.0485080481,
0.0005310473,
0.0084077735,
-0.0053406181,
0.0339790285,
0.0108786589,
-0.0929569453,
-0.0074331262,
0.0816072747,
0.0301176757,
-0.0157224014,
0.0263173394,
-0.0918573514,
-0.0008320641,
-0.045289319,
0.0257369187,
0.0014181279,
-0.0557608195,
0.0035511679,
-0.0092611201,
-0.0254941341,
0.0168561917,
0.0067939279,
-0.0446539782,
0.0022822123,
-0.0005523917,
0.004544198,
-0.0446179546,
0.0832765549,
-0.028219562,
0.0621910132,
-0.0030553185,
0.0536646247,
0.0356400833,
0.018932499,
0.0286444351,
-0.0370221734,
-0.000044591,
0.0866219327,
0.035387706,
0.0184233803,
-0.0651078597,
-0.0308169872,
-0.0157180019,
0.0232082754,
0.0629913658,
0.0728179961,
0.0590056814,
-0.0219973382,
-0.0393726192,
-0.0155095151,
0.0545221008,
-0.0320363194,
0.0593577996,
-0.0224452484,
-0.0330882892,
-0.0590974912,
-0.0348865725,
-0.04154725,
-0.0256177895,
-0.0557760149,
0.0185894165,
0.0151961613,
0.017093949,
-0.0013745605,
0.0050913887,
-0.017747853,
-0.0364178605,
0.005125592,
0.0035872806,
0.0191464331,
-0.0140878903,
-0.0337819345,
-0.0764046758,
0.0124045555,
-0.0558176897,
0.0147475246,
0.0096215373,
0.0345322117,
0.006502796,
-0.0234533511,
-0.0661580563,
0.0002944295,
-0.0253021326,
0.0179497954,
0.0521580465,
-0.0231885891,
0.0231271945,
-0.0198357869,
0.0344227962,
0.0090475408,
-0.0242168233,
-0.0246344581,
0.0127196675,
0.001981019,
-0.0277321432,
0.0550856292,
-0.0616410263,
-0.0281203575,
-0.0588736758,
0.0152131002,
0.0477047153,
-0.0393598527,
-0.0328453593,
-0.0702073574,
2.429e-7,
-0.0095219202,
0.0486068651,
-0.0227518771,
0.0033308987,
-0.0117185423,
0.0591117628,
-0.0301466919,
0.0013222715,
0.0155669125,
-0.0597771145,
-0.0423362367,
0.0069402345,
0.0340948403,
0.0089710122,
-0.0867052749,
-0.0314229019,
-0.0778372586,
-0.0011059308,
-0.018483229,
0.0241307542,
0.0023228768,
0.0452809632,
0.03903782,
-0.0063362531,
-0.0121985218,
-0.0132789202,
0.0771679878,
-0.1037906334,
-0.0135260839,
0.0182569791,
-0.0094421618,
-0.0214839634,
-0.0031035524,
0.0088447165,
-0.0067057121,
-0.0390235521,
-0.0713694319,
0.086153008,
0.0312264245,
-0.0005202168,
-0.0066529633,
0.0160691086,
-0.0246826932,
-0.007714658,
0.0124297915,
-0.0624498315,
-0.0560762361,
-0.0484765545,
0.0041396078,
-0.0162708256,
0.0091405073,
-0.0134200109,
-0.0237581134,
-0.0571439303,
0.0134689715,
0.0004834526,
0.0193608627,
-0.0170728732,
0.003899137,
0.0054219561,
-0.0207017902,
-0.1112759858,
-0.0301858559,
0.0307084508,
0.0074299327,
-0.0587538257,
-0.0074652694,
2.148923748e-34,
0.0868994296,
-0.0273027197,
0.0415718369,
-0.0299179759,
0.0122188246,
0.0291048605,
0.0420948267,
-0.0432295874,
0.0514936633,
-0.0919276699,
0.015254111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14504v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14504v1 | Translating Across Cultures: LLMs for Intralingual Cultural Adaptation | 2024-06-20T17:06:58 | 2024-06-20T17:06:58 | Pushpdeep Singh, Mayur Patidar, Lovekesh Vig | cs.CL | cs.CL | LLMs are increasingly being deployed for multilingual applications and have
demonstrated impressive translation capabilities between several low and high
resource languages. An aspect of translation that often gets overlooked is that
of cultural adaptation, or modifying source culture references to suit the
target culture. Cultural adaptation has applications across several creative
industries and requires intimate knowledge of source and target cultures during
translation. While specialized translation models still outperform LLMs on the
machine translation task when viewed from the lens of correctness, they are not
sensitive to cultural differences often requiring manual correction. LLMs on
the other hand have a rich reservoir of cultural knowledge embedded within its
parameters that can be potentially exploited for such applications. In this
paper we define the task of cultural adaptation and create an evaluation
framework to benchmark different models for this task. We evaluate the
performance of modern LLMs for cultural adaptation and analyze their cross
cultural knowledge while connecting related concepts across different cultures.
We also analyze possible issues with automatic adaptation including cultural
biases and stereotypes. We hope that this task will offer more insight into the
cultural understanding of LLMs and their creativity in cross-cultural
scenarios. | [
0.0681453124,
-0.0043551642,
-0.0355908908,
0.0296480358,
-0.0362231843,
0.0183798168,
0.0395121463,
-0.0073307408,
-0.0125760725,
-0.0115494197,
-0.0562833473,
-0.0376343429,
0.018786421,
-0.0328189433,
0.0095613301,
-0.0523969196,
0.0413578823,
0.0067160698,
-0.0131503223,
-0.0021587727,
-0.0175264739,
0.0594184995,
0.0208839141,
0.0188479349,
0.0073599718,
-0.0009983083,
0.0554798618,
0.087044768,
0.0635124296,
-0.0246977564,
-0.0216309987,
-0.0201938711,
0.0254150946,
0.0141891176,
0.0000020108,
-0.0638503134,
-0.036760442,
-0.0333612636,
0.041219864,
0.0253108609,
0.0816032216,
-0.0569481589,
-0.0350044966,
0.001554666,
-0.022920955,
0.007499475,
0.0551114604,
-0.0052936333,
0.0357404575,
0.0732907206,
-0.0092396066,
-0.0260621756,
-0.0712380111,
-0.0306718517,
-0.0026893644,
-0.0399191044,
-0.0062551419,
0.0338890925,
-0.009902712,
-0.0217594206,
-0.0191354975,
0.071528405,
-0.020093875,
0.0086443294,
-0.0135596329,
-0.0162772015,
-0.0286127944,
-0.0129396692,
-0.0007155585,
0.0480064601,
0.0206251722,
0.0268931892,
-0.0107137049,
-0.0028624011,
-0.0239853133,
-0.0014120259,
-0.0424905978,
0.0144295227,
-0.0000314666,
-0.0224172547,
-0.0065781665,
0.0363578573,
0.0157233831,
-0.0100461617,
-0.0103783654,
0.0353651978,
0.03498362,
-0.0170591716,
-0.0410337038,
-0.0177608076,
0.0244972948,
-0.0246867947,
0.0387106873,
0.0009214349,
0.0387230515,
0.0292612948,
-0.0162147097,
-0.0141040375,
0.0027322005,
-0.0651420429,
0.0298625603,
0.0629888102,
-0.0250642095,
0.0469865277,
-0.0302946605,
0.0599527583,
-0.0181055106,
0.0103575606,
-0.0794437155,
-0.01809326,
-0.0187282264,
0.0274860449,
0.0081449822,
-0.0498000197,
-0.0304707605,
-0.0021469765,
-0.0742032528,
0.035876736,
0.0059018857,
0.0172273684,
0.0037466157,
-0.0466327295,
-0.0474272817,
-0.0320772119,
-0.0307019129,
0.07315927,
-0.0058203274,
-0.013941423,
-0.0499438643,
-0.0202954374,
0.0141830882,
0.0103123365,
-0.0128802359,
-0.0237841234,
0.0053911442,
0.0969889611,
-0.0129271988,
0.0093269795,
-0.0553941242,
0.0410281681,
-0.0210922174,
-0.0400889553,
0.007145748,
-0.0415811278,
0.072399281,
0.0137830013,
0.0309040211,
-0.0558273084,
0.0098798936,
-0.0016402192,
-0.0395405367,
0.0305282939,
0.0444445014,
0.0528734326,
0.0643544272,
-0.0014708425,
-0.0356133692,
0.0560265481,
0.0754587725,
0.0316241719,
0.0782276168,
0.0135569097,
-0.0318707973,
0.0623044521,
-0.0463176705,
0.0171602052,
-0.0315007269,
0.0147003243,
0.0002767936,
0.0222944524,
0.0310855508,
0.0321863554,
0.0215190966,
0.0442765728,
0.0675620958,
0.030002147,
-0.0066004596,
0.0536077097,
0.0616871119,
-0.001552497,
-0.0149629721,
-0.0123907216,
-0.0236341935,
0.0429276116,
0.0193856042,
-0.0047253356,
0.0074137482,
0.0676265135,
-0.008694021,
-0.0168068875,
-0.0083194906,
0.0182513427,
0.0387341864,
-0.01509606,
0.0253829658,
0.0191533826,
-0.0253950842,
0.0476373322,
-0.0263991393,
-0.0490954891,
0.0005648082,
0.0046105157,
-0.0191737413,
0.0950725749,
0.0505159013,
0.0017432171,
0.014014611,
-0.0037702476,
0.0083818939,
0.040419694,
0.0566138029,
0.0162341371,
0.0088029588,
-0.0319051035,
-0.0119214961,
0.0137901884,
-0.0041206791,
0.0566119961,
-0.0092035281,
0.0595830679,
0.0291455407,
-0.0220417343,
-0.0382934362,
0.003608478,
-0.0595917068,
-0.0355487168,
0.0265103988,
0.0021906174,
0.0095183682,
0.0520390086,
-0.038435895,
-0.0134096928,
-0.0237436518,
-0.0372943059,
0.0089363232,
0.0835738108,
-0.0161993578,
-0.0008705659,
0.0261353105,
-0.0742931366,
-0.0002734225,
-0.0442323126,
-0.015406929,
-0.0409293771,
0.0078880787,
-0.0101610413,
0.0095557952,
-0.0172005557,
0.0290826168,
-0.0140688019,
0.0106619271,
-0.038755212,
-0.0048507489,
-0.0017325513,
-0.0324341618,
-0.0019350932,
-0.0316483714,
0.0301755816,
-0.0206308458,
-0.0276139211,
0.0516807847,
0.0299895536,
-0.0097240433,
0.0245686602,
0.0352418497,
-0.0284400824,
-0.0316586681,
-0.0741966069,
0.0096154157,
-0.0024517693,
0.0244445819,
0.0127139976,
0.0390781425,
-0.0440742522,
-0.0036223563,
-0.0460279323,
-0.000860975,
0.007841072,
0.0077550826,
0.0300062206,
-0.0024474198,
0.013010418,
-0.0061527761,
0.0130067291,
0.0175363775,
0.0010223092,
0.0158253051,
-0.0698170215,
-0.0820349902,
0.0113336919,
-0.0830021799,
-0.0442867577,
-0.0052536335,
-0.0587845743,
-0.0239140484,
0.010937904,
0.077546306,
0.0288500302,
-0.0118902167,
-0.0565909259,
0.0578199476,
-0.0417820141,
-0.0216985233,
-0.0018620368,
0.0168554187,
-0.0258873049,
0.0078650061,
-0.1056394652,
0.0102748675,
-0.0024401681,
0.0108996192,
0.0077735023,
-0.0299556777,
0.0158209987,
-0.0240720287,
-0.0197999813,
0.0076186503,
0.0199238081,
0.0194580909,
0.0853149295,
-0.0120676737,
-0.0220852401,
0.0515224524,
-0.0201165378,
-0.0043724761,
-0.0141713638,
0.0092563052,
-0.0672720894,
0.0244751479,
-0.0566373654,
0.0277214926,
-0.0352824517,
0.0049423631,
-0.0408137292,
-0.0003616506,
0.0605797693,
-0.0515094399,
0.0252205171,
-0.0673346892,
-0.0267262924,
-0.0449515805,
0.0045649363,
-0.0233148504,
0.0402350239,
0.0000431753,
-0.0093747601,
-0.0043575848,
0.0095526986,
-0.0372944139,
0.0243648868,
0.0474187955,
0.0139734093,
0.0178271905,
0.0156533513,
-0.0145015018,
-0.0345043056,
-0.0112052159,
-0.0123565914,
0.0007599867,
-0.0284802318,
0.0114476988,
-0.0357302092,
0.0104317814,
-0.072155945,
0.014025881,
-0.0013461318,
0.047669068,
0.0089914119,
-0.0189776123,
-0.0217009094,
0.0730421096,
-0.0286801066,
0.0287948288,
0.0711059272,
0.0140857305,
-0.0466121025,
-0.0271537732,
-0.0383064225,
-0.0307661444,
0.0056144702,
0.05064632,
-0.0904654562,
0.0323368758,
0.0034574154,
0.0217858646,
0.0173944682,
-0.0050480063,
-0.0397311263,
-0.0843759701,
0.0361185856,
0.0731330067,
-0.0296622589,
-0.0583610646,
0.0133353928,
-0.0302433893,
-0.0067197806,
0.0201082379,
-0.0377165787,
-0.003597491,
-0.0163331144,
-0.0323682427,
-0.0229913909,
-0.0371157117,
0.0071393214,
-0.042877838,
0.0429252125,
0.0585319549,
0.0429788344,
0.0310110953,
-0.0370211899,
-0.0034890657,
-0.0067099417,
0.0084332246,
-0.0084471479,
-0.0347203799,
-0.0037265583,
0.0007507182,
0.0411049202,
-0.0436257757,
-0.0089816479,
0.0124476161,
0.0533080697,
0.0065850955,
-0.0158972796,
0.0168744363,
-0.0160941519,
0.023460485,
0.0027912501,
0.068183288,
0.0071629118,
-0.0506658442,
0.0143848741,
-0.0328558907,
-0.0441370308,
-0.0420097522,
-0.028132787,
0.0042453441,
-0.1190344468,
-0.0270493589,
-0.082504645,
-0.0302590318,
-0.020866558,
0.020170724,
0.0560484007,
-0.01577048,
-0.030566901,
0.0265226196,
-0.0220853426,
-0.0027713652,
-0.038128905,
0.025912473,
0.0061525144,
0.0116660465,
0.0122099444,
-0.0476793312,
0.0322763324,
0.020402588,
-0.0359504595,
-0.0421267562,
-0.0233232118,
0.0584624708,
0.0174031053,
0.0302375667,
0.01380568,
-0.0188864227,
0.0128741218,
-0.0088908942,
0.0255777836,
0.028513778,
0.011817568,
0.0800616667,
-0.0149746872,
0.0428703614,
-0.054636471,
0.0373304747,
0.0197985787,
0.0783708245,
-0.0058708848,
-0.0789467245,
-0.0054969182,
0.0293446593,
-0.0487164594,
-0.0586475208,
-0.0306864288,
-0.0178153571,
0.0202341676,
-0.0314133167,
-0.0359860621,
-0.0305558871,
-0.0271764211,
0.037937697,
-0.0047208653,
0.0125662964,
-0.0144005008,
-0.0279903896,
-0.0205264613,
-0.0313683227,
0.0321919546,
0.0087062558,
0.0440897197,
-0.0234249067,
0.0391688682,
-0.0299017951,
0.0336099118,
-0.0195140019,
0.026128659,
-0.0050392277,
0.0725074857,
-0.0123527767,
-0.0065825772,
0.0048172711,
0.0350717381,
-0.0041720886,
0.0050379662,
-0.0024118328,
0.0182718039,
0.1156427711,
-0.011760422,
0.1199975312,
0.0084090782,
-0.0102292346,
0.0019597525,
0.0329711847,
0.0203373861,
-0.0146647356,
-0.0353498086,
-0.0103828944,
0.0067612967,
-0.0000841053,
0.0237412639,
-0.0470796712,
-0.0206492618,
-0.028188888,
-0.0338838287,
-0.0161255803,
-0.0061230254,
0.0219587907,
-0.0485577248,
0.0097089475,
-0.0072726277,
-0.0756903216,
-0.0453192703,
0.0334010422,
-0.0033906831,
0.0156256482,
-0.0361068062,
-0.0286021773,
0.0930336565,
0.0043605259,
-0.0010531144,
-0.0565954968,
-0.0139654251,
-0.027106788,
0.009610597,
-0.0304913707,
-5.871239063e-33,
-0.0435893647,
-0.0127281211,
0.0101380516,
-0.0004687207,
-0.0221246388,
-0.0386645608,
-0.042061545,
-0.0256164297,
0.003216051,
-0.0064598671,
-0.0150430165,
-0.0297597814,
0.0272777565,
-0.0498237498,
0.0311782677,
0.0303707272,
0.0524251945,
0.0235382132,
-0.0472353064,
-0.015908068,
0.0386759937,
0.0210997984,
0.0837830082,
-0.100059554,
0.0790442824,
-0.0231036935,
-0.0189703945,
0.0059702503,
0.0745151564,
0.0043527698,
0.0164241884,
0.0029601662,
0.0144917127,
0.0046406724,
-0.0159517694,
-0.0288514514,
-0.0717371553,
0.007791358,
0.0441862494,
0.047377184,
0.0720588267,
-0.080547832,
0.0408208705,
-0.0488999672,
-0.0401775576,
0.0233455282,
0.0286952648,
-0.0820741355,
0.0069951206,
-0.0170062725,
-0.0625570714,
0.022877451,
0.0006577399,
0.0333493836,
0.0247270837,
0.074599877,
-0.0155009199,
0.0060955277,
-0.0679567531,
0.0278609078,
-0.0377790183,
0.0089333504,
0.1114354283,
-0.0116612474,
-0.0131213786,
-0.0060720448,
0.0032668645,
0.0375726521,
0.0235945974,
-0.0233716182,
0.0149784517,
-0.0052391058,
0.0190361738,
0.0950297639,
0.0030174281,
-0.0204491299,
-0.0236230548,
0.0567008071,
0.0387211889,
-0.0208302829,
0.0248574391,
0.0408822484,
-0.0020437322,
0.0090249758,
-0.0162921268,
-0.0075323167,
-0.0084073283,
-0.0653632209,
0.0102528799,
0.0027707936,
-0.0042126221,
0.0108592175,
0.0709993914,
-0.0337905884,
0.022515377,
-0.0414442532,
-0.0018481369,
-0.0179717373,
0.0014811369,
0.0185085107,
-0.0078992946,
-0.0428757966,
-0.0017406057,
0.0337679684,
0.0071865353,
-0.032450296,
0.0079084458,
0.0163072161,
-0.0585407279,
-0.0057380754,
0.0005479396,
-0.0194211677,
-0.0253155474,
-0.0045633274,
-0.0193936247,
-0.010097703,
-0.0163021293,
-0.0201442353,
0.0498649701,
-0.0165108815,
0.0055799233,
-0.0268672016,
-0.0092098648,
0.0476732962,
-0.0664976537,
0.0330773219,
0.0052835564,
0.010955424,
0.0221478958,
-0.0176742189,
-0.0394210108,
-0.0307411328,
2.873e-7,
0.0332252197,
0.0360720716,
-0.0277559999,
0.0322257876,
0.0149451988,
-0.0202534627,
-0.0553389154,
0.032814391,
0.0152119994,
0.0206319652,
0.0613251664,
0.0259286035,
0.0764530003,
0.0273773503,
-0.0879011974,
-0.0400989726,
-0.0151051097,
0.0458235852,
-0.0437621213,
0.0188873801,
0.0086707594,
0.0331320018,
-0.0060704257,
-0.0067322585,
-0.066029273,
-0.0532760918,
0.0528299734,
-0.0697784424,
-0.0216174871,
0.004151436,
0.0540124811,
0.002151943,
-0.0405770466,
-0.008421245,
-0.0123075247,
0.026061222,
0.0778971836,
0.0849710181,
0.013069272,
0.0023716958,
0.0121029932,
0.0202519204,
-0.0031147413,
-0.0436299406,
0.0186841935,
0.0179873277,
-0.0194544215,
-0.0168016106,
-0.0275095906,
0.0179309174,
0.0561094433,
-0.0295857787,
-0.0249320809,
0.0207474865,
0.0740989745,
0.0142957876,
-0.0257723331,
-0.0247042924,
-0.0164179392,
-0.0217946507,
0.0205912609,
-0.051156491,
-0.0188004747,
-0.0035344048,
-0.0289605297,
-0.021883402,
0.0153351706,
2.405411105e-34,
0.0521899424,
-0.0368849635,
-0.0345086716,
-0.0171796251,
0.0567234345,
-0.0163247585,
-0.0145128649,
0.0169503968,
-0.0173888821,
-0.0230339617,
-0.0180061385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14503v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14503v1 | Overview of the CAIL 2023 Argument Mining Track | 2024-06-20T17:06:13 | 2024-06-20T17:06:13 | Jingcong Liang, Junlong Wang, Xinyu Zhai, Yungui Zhuang, Yiyang Zheng, Xin Xu, Xiandong Ran, Xiaozheng Dong, Honghui Rong, Yanlun Liu, Hao Chen, Yuhan Wei, Donghai Li, Jiajie Peng, Xuanjing Huang, Chongde Shi, Yansong Feng, Yun Song, Zhongyu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | We give a detailed overview of the CAIL 2023 Argument Mining Track, one of
the Chinese AI and Law Challenge (CAIL) 2023 tracks. The main goal of the track
is to identify and extract interacting argument pairs in trial dialogs. It
mainly uses summarized judgment documents but can also refer to trial
recordings. The track consists of two stages, and we introduce the tasks
designed for each stage; we also extend the data from previous events into a
new dataset -- CAIL2023-ArgMine -- with annotated new cases from various causes
of action. We outline several submissions that achieve the best results,
including their methods for different stages. While all submissions rely on
language models, they have incorporated strategies that may benefit future work
in this field. | [
0.0419177562,
0.083431229,
0.0153725473,
0.0652441457,
-0.0485019051,
0.0165293384,
-0.0015060764,
-0.0069635599,
-0.0059515233,
-0.0623068362,
-0.0101243295,
-0.0261067916,
-0.0137915388,
0.0009156164,
-0.0253253896,
-0.072890088,
0.0391072966,
0.0098336181,
0.0888026282,
0.0237776376,
0.0380751565,
0.0090219071,
-0.0320055373,
0.0252000615,
-0.0202269834,
-0.0427917615,
-0.0236595497,
-0.0167232119,
0.0194014609,
-0.0075790519,
0.0063326051,
0.0465832688,
0.0001526597,
0.000888441,
0.0000019588,
-0.0507732965,
-0.005607307,
-0.0381434001,
-0.0556624047,
0.0180875622,
0.0379126966,
0.0606407486,
-0.0109540792,
0.0359880142,
-0.0484845676,
-0.0419413932,
-0.0126232998,
0.0945116878,
0.0512124449,
0.0917317569,
-0.0179675035,
0.0116856489,
0.0077620675,
-0.0289508067,
-0.068136178,
-0.0418414995,
0.00948737,
0.0238928571,
0.0100707365,
-0.0078807985,
0.0336780921,
-0.0122582186,
0.0231878459,
-0.0152361607,
-0.0764529407,
0.0096196625,
-0.0656160638,
-0.0027985901,
-0.0005536935,
0.0583992191,
0.0401691347,
-0.0337281525,
0.0080418615,
-0.0097764283,
0.0391891934,
-0.0430811979,
-0.0302551705,
0.0713560581,
-0.0432545058,
0.0310447253,
0.0737490803,
0.0482073054,
-0.0174370501,
0.0202876683,
-0.0073655853,
0.0221423339,
-0.0206608959,
-0.0215781573,
0.0210624374,
-0.0218295045,
-0.0017825044,
-0.0391745418,
0.0276874211,
0.0031413152,
-0.0112011489,
0.0302435402,
-0.0032100682,
0.0109611647,
0.029770406,
-0.0838113874,
0.0113051785,
-0.0242493581,
-0.0236519314,
0.0875292346,
0.0130785545,
-0.0140184499,
0.011662825,
-0.0369448923,
-0.0111828037,
-0.035130132,
-0.0356564149,
0.0141996937,
-0.0353515707,
0.0205758195,
-0.0716157109,
-0.0255596153,
0.015377745,
-0.0094672423,
-0.0345436111,
0.0142319147,
0.015948873,
0.0140107833,
0.0121503323,
-0.0216681603,
-0.0392733254,
-0.0152093163,
-0.0423954017,
0.0602464378,
0.0207917411,
-0.0344704613,
-0.0304431561,
0.0462482236,
0.0182904359,
-0.0181636941,
-0.0281979479,
0.0364739448,
-0.0351092964,
-0.0126607809,
-0.0195320807,
-0.060525272,
-0.0533931665,
-0.0393459424,
-0.0282351263,
-0.0665733665,
0.0160610061,
-0.0602046587,
-0.0092552667,
-0.0620669201,
0.0351330042,
0.0040426212,
0.0003730876,
0.0191336405,
0.0252940133,
-0.0475957468,
-0.021138316,
0.0423831753,
-0.0337624215,
0.0077881482,
0.0261491947,
0.0128612565,
0.05545187,
0.0209319647,
0.0300533678,
0.0008419724,
0.0200810246,
0.0019072638,
0.0406655408,
0.0058747949,
-0.0173876882,
-0.0169402529,
-0.0104388567,
0.0318767056,
-0.0468180999,
-0.0568015352,
0.0182684399,
0.0415870845,
-0.0078832293,
0.0158060938,
-0.0071943039,
-0.0103422422,
0.0427910872,
-0.0025975285,
-0.0120716821,
-0.0330389701,
-0.013200379,
-0.0295018665,
0.0078914389,
-0.0090026231,
-0.0235213675,
-0.0750392526,
0.0176495183,
-0.0183668751,
0.0283577722,
0.009421193,
0.0052526779,
0.0046705762,
-0.020445494,
-0.0140156969,
0.0272155832,
-0.0558119416,
-0.0524270609,
-0.0383613519,
0.0240795445,
-0.0226419438,
0.0221894979,
-0.0099768704,
-0.012215252,
-0.022843644,
0.027119536,
0.0380355455,
0.0645396039,
-0.0305183139,
0.0339444466,
-0.0293788742,
-0.0216648914,
-0.0189779047,
0.0310920216,
-0.0042321077,
-0.0121788885,
-0.0006166142,
0.018799996,
-0.0006586634,
-0.0066321455,
-0.0076382696,
0.0299749412,
-0.0181863606,
0.0456374921,
-0.0091813654,
0.0577849746,
0.0447888561,
-0.0155007159,
0.0023460793,
0.0516628958,
-0.0164980013,
-0.0075521488,
0.0796645284,
-0.0085021481,
-0.0540840141,
0.0558095463,
-0.036884781,
-0.0005507846,
-0.0421122536,
-0.0354704224,
-0.04328252,
0.0182660781,
0.0022665756,
0.000808516,
-0.0171877816,
0.0254994575,
0.0391203389,
-0.0199575387,
-0.0234005172,
0.0693165734,
0.0227424055,
-0.0483783074,
-0.0060128523,
0.0371916778,
0.0627612397,
-0.0501575805,
0.0084342742,
-0.0087699117,
-0.0101123862,
0.0053448337,
0.0400997438,
-0.0292727817,
-0.0427641496,
-0.0301712919,
-0.0834280699,
0.0127380695,
-0.0259282459,
0.0297750011,
-0.0109917577,
-0.0541265346,
-0.0014859803,
0.0089198304,
-0.0114901448,
-0.0223073773,
-0.0094327182,
-0.0344838314,
0.0123507651,
-0.007645275,
0.0115555227,
-0.0404662006,
0.0101117557,
-0.0214745309,
0.0403264202,
-0.0017965956,
-0.0089449557,
-0.011993112,
0.0213881433,
-0.0063382532,
0.0185713824,
-0.0480738245,
0.0009964979,
0.0116929365,
0.0084627327,
0.0123266578,
0.0752359852,
0.0464279987,
0.0578020923,
0.0017820718,
-0.0411834233,
-0.0574168563,
0.0330460705,
0.0021810031,
0.0457048565,
-0.0042905281,
-0.0031745876,
0.030847799,
0.0626785457,
0.0079521816,
0.0293709524,
-0.0163767245,
0.0154301291,
0.0291913766,
-0.0043791737,
0.0360026881,
-0.0198999569,
-0.024596516,
0.0208249558,
-0.0165161602,
-0.0168937463,
0.0653867796,
-0.0373950712,
0.0476754606,
-0.0822030976,
-0.0543341115,
-0.015554985,
0.0569447689,
-0.0282832216,
-0.008298425,
0.0268535651,
0.0059930864,
0.0329217874,
-0.0324917734,
0.0176603999,
-0.0306318551,
0.0471401811,
-0.049506627,
0.0098105529,
-0.0212323628,
-0.0426918231,
-0.0301908646,
-0.0202295613,
-0.0202895477,
0.0094221998,
0.0212481413,
0.0142607251,
0.0075012562,
0.0125419153,
-0.0311949402,
0.0134520596,
0.0188424643,
0.0262116455,
-0.0047586956,
0.0239854362,
0.027308844,
0.0037430441,
0.0283616688,
0.0062336447,
0.031314753,
0.1008246094,
0.0132991029,
0.0136101171,
-0.0155025246,
-0.0278543346,
-0.0216282625,
-0.0043518278,
-0.010483698,
-0.0012265048,
0.0328858495,
-0.0595484599,
0.0277691577,
0.0823285058,
0.0168695711,
-0.028237069,
-0.0032102116,
0.0055110087,
-0.0172967855,
-0.0147775384,
-0.0215281993,
-0.1091164052,
-0.019661935,
-0.0168874003,
-0.0117743649,
-0.0511055104,
-0.0291076209,
0.0023235902,
-0.0794686377,
0.082344234,
0.0211109295,
0.0467689,
-0.0510571487,
-0.0320055634,
0.0184789579,
-0.0200481638,
-0.0002133179,
-0.0055046817,
0.0199615527,
-0.0050509567,
0.0118539333,
-0.0281239077,
0.0168993212,
0.0416344702,
-0.0312544256,
0.0856576264,
-0.0083046919,
0.0629864559,
0.0338033028,
-0.0077054026,
0.0055147223,
-0.0673709512,
-0.0407288186,
-0.0081591252,
0.0297595169,
0.0063721659,
0.0021847582,
-0.0144277876,
0.0712250471,
-0.008293069,
-0.0451016538,
0.0728304312,
0.0293323845,
-0.0723476708,
-0.0274903718,
-0.001673433,
0.0328080393,
0.0077565485,
0.0760909393,
0.0385551713,
0.028399827,
-0.0350322165,
-0.0447822213,
-0.0192412902,
-0.0718117803,
0.0114958063,
-0.0157466307,
0.0248881225,
0.0433152169,
-0.0682199374,
-0.0509404838,
-0.0119545255,
0.035661038,
-0.0453173816,
-0.0209540278,
0.0356383249,
0.0122438427,
-0.0178367067,
0.024133943,
0.00029848,
-0.0048238444,
-0.0324986875,
0.0220558569,
0.0014783668,
0.0058896383,
-0.0307244379,
0.0299472082,
-0.0088811275,
-0.0224307738,
-0.0371647514,
0.0181175731,
0.0040301238,
0.0461318046,
-0.0134686679,
0.0249178763,
-0.0164839812,
-0.042380359,
0.0627931654,
-0.0159507599,
0.0858705938,
-0.0057229255,
-0.0108472966,
0.0085331146,
0.0164004918,
0.0580916069,
-0.0023394581,
0.0350199752,
-0.0721708834,
-0.0196090061,
0.0167954359,
-0.0328743644,
0.0499374345,
0.059880022,
-0.0545962043,
-0.044308193,
0.0242799949,
-0.044169981,
-0.0206782836,
-0.0657309592,
0.0249511972,
-0.0180341098,
-0.0229774304,
-0.0111343367,
-0.0164363123,
-0.0281512905,
0.0333676264,
0.0032517305,
0.0328233466,
0.0571759492,
0.0007974123,
-0.0550053492,
-0.0450834706,
-0.0146606257,
0.0604685135,
-0.0157421883,
0.0575903468,
-0.0081901159,
0.092465058,
0.0154368971,
-0.0311584156,
0.0330688655,
0.0014644458,
-0.0430923551,
0.0035206322,
-0.0052712173,
-0.0129286638,
0.0242549106,
-0.0342400707,
0.0527602993,
-0.0263599809,
-0.0047581354,
-0.0165157318,
0.0429539643,
-0.0092063034,
-0.0116950432,
0.0212772582,
0.0385104194,
-0.0362013243,
0.0036086622,
0.0427714661,
-0.0317660384,
0.0367091037,
0.0327560008,
-0.0146347648,
-0.0391029269,
-0.0858227983,
0.0073053837,
0.0426791199,
-0.0217369143,
-0.0052027828,
-0.0327228121,
0.0055816718,
-0.0616024956,
0.0350754634,
-0.0025430943,
0.0263467915,
0.0010910741,
0.0535203032,
0.0005206178,
0.0094988737,
-0.0379668511,
0.0001288939,
0.0204022713,
0.0058507617,
-0.0135307992,
-6.115825274e-33,
-0.0041820197,
-0.0250442531,
0.0004907839,
0.0632843226,
0.011592254,
-0.0136381006,
-0.0348004922,
0.0126689672,
-0.0525194108,
0.0628452897,
0.0310909916,
0.0336607695,
0.0150802294,
-0.0218381435,
-0.0120258229,
-0.0200683642,
0.0111931302,
0.0200409368,
-0.0131481439,
0.0177313592,
0.034788996,
-0.0286438335,
0.0124004744,
-0.1254766434,
0.0222679973,
0.0483859405,
-0.0090564257,
0.0156963188,
-0.0349962562,
0.0956377313,
0.0115225967,
0.0157197602,
0.011508354,
-0.0299710315,
0.0102028418,
0.0095097292,
-0.100302428,
-0.0114538986,
0.0166932978,
-0.0585042313,
-0.0040835692,
-0.0307170413,
-0.0148605984,
0.0329324342,
0.017442083,
-0.024547765,
0.0085368715,
-0.0414686985,
0.0118177151,
-0.0133997193,
-0.0457861535,
0.0774445757,
-0.022572957,
-0.0208074134,
0.0054760501,
0.0199218281,
0.0200260114,
0.0140136871,
-0.0734843463,
0.0140869897,
-0.0447969548,
-0.0156964418,
-0.0030735312,
-0.0790214017,
-0.03165574,
0.0465906188,
-0.0084155388,
-0.0101864478,
-0.0235788114,
-0.0057289936,
-0.0340509489,
0.1127175242,
0.0281222127,
0.0440543257,
0.000835984,
0.0008178778,
-0.0716141537,
-0.0279995147,
0.1194998398,
0.0347031876,
-0.0063876254,
-0.0120001314,
-0.0535324141,
-0.0244320314,
0.0057473914,
-0.067502901,
-0.0111480793,
-0.0084824041,
0.0024239377,
0.0390666611,
0.0039819661,
-0.0082494728,
0.0293778051,
-0.0204687025,
0.0317238122,
0.0352570154,
0.0090863518,
-0.0043724529,
-0.0191170052,
0.0320440456,
-0.0509756468,
-0.0386883952,
0.0339355506,
-0.0005317014,
0.018971812,
-0.0087755108,
0.0323280618,
-0.0550501607,
-0.0272092354,
-0.0183475632,
0.0003262899,
0.0000662534,
-0.0502435043,
0.0503980219,
0.0020840778,
0.0606562793,
0.0169151295,
0.0300833508,
-0.0118364394,
0.0144096538,
-0.0454991832,
-0.08283066,
-0.023465516,
-0.0246391874,
0.0120329699,
-0.0139773553,
0.0175232515,
-0.0005121579,
0.0269498322,
-0.0228768699,
0.0235697385,
-0.0220276788,
2.514e-7,
0.0363202132,
0.0198553428,
0.0216643978,
-0.0047451644,
0.0059617981,
0.0431214906,
-0.0037821527,
0.0200587977,
0.0284683127,
0.0002798528,
0.0112227937,
0.0436080247,
0.0724947825,
0.0544486456,
-0.0422678664,
-0.0510712005,
-0.0579734258,
-0.1034964323,
-0.0448052362,
0.0028055063,
0.078175731,
0.1012978777,
0.0075591649,
0.0168678276,
0.0006644162,
0.0234845225,
0.0318689421,
-0.0063023726,
-0.0315958373,
0.0181160681,
0.0813627392,
-0.0781506598,
-0.0119431466,
0.0370037667,
-0.0005482589,
0.0814829543,
-0.0315312743,
0.0886290148,
0.0149728945,
-0.0100480327,
-0.0259978138,
-0.0052644848,
0.0397739559,
-0.0160387047,
0.0533802435,
-0.0337937027,
-0.0103479261,
-0.0462135039,
-0.0267874468,
0.0006623854,
-0.0039302865,
0.0405259319,
-0.0168733373,
0.0135183455,
-0.0005932195,
-0.0188956056,
0.0188225824,
-0.106096074,
-0.0356566533,
0.0446772687,
-0.0113952952,
-0.0143309403,
0.0243157446,
-0.0302930493,
0.032444194,
-0.0560778417,
0.0279915389,
2.011051807e-34,
0.0328858308,
0.0037247045,
-0.0078682425,
0.035379272,
0.0822874829,
-0.0023660953,
-0.0123970183,
-0.0111496951,
0.0152318999,
-0.0614407659,
0.0213532019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14500v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14500v1 | Improving Expert Radiology Report Summarization by Prompting Large Language Models with a Layperson Summary | 2024-06-20T17:01:55 | 2024-06-20T17:01:55 | Xingmeng Zhao, Tongnian Wang, Anthony Rios | cs.CL | cs.CL | Radiology report summarization (RRS) is crucial for patient care, requiring
concise "Impressions" from detailed "Findings." This paper introduces a novel
prompting strategy to enhance RRS by first generating a layperson summary. This
approach normalizes key observations and simplifies complex information using
non-expert communication techniques inspired by doctor-patient interactions.
Combined with few-shot in-context learning, this method improves the model's
ability to link general terms to specific findings. We evaluate this approach
on the MIMIC-CXR, CheXpert, and MIMIC-III datasets, benchmarking it against
7B/8B parameter state-of-the-art open-source large language models (LLMs) like
Meta-Llama-3-8B-Instruct. Our results demonstrate improvements in summarization
accuracy and accessibility, particularly in out-of-domain tests, with
improvements as high as 5% for some metrics. | [
0.0607929565,
0.0422611088,
0.0335125662,
-0.0054211062,
0.0006390597,
0.0196658988,
-0.013310425,
0.0377789661,
-0.0303016268,
-0.0067736311,
-0.0512938239,
-0.0643123239,
0.0231716167,
0.030661298,
0.0214715693,
-0.0948928669,
0.004593981,
-0.0145367691,
0.0414409973,
-0.0143049369,
0.0198202301,
0.0088062882,
0.001941775,
0.0282087624,
0.03130918,
0.0008688254,
0.0275517348,
0.0005638586,
0.0287138037,
-0.0403026827,
-0.0191462506,
0.0644348711,
0.0145078069,
0.0211620051,
0.0000019649,
-0.0481948778,
-0.0096686408,
0.0379143991,
-0.0241269525,
-0.0101112369,
0.0819278657,
-0.0684704483,
0.0178071968,
0.0192956794,
-0.0026382883,
-0.0589488856,
0.0116110472,
0.0624721237,
0.0856731012,
0.0652307123,
-0.0134440958,
-0.0083071161,
-0.0014785365,
-0.0352595262,
0.0046368334,
-0.0400093161,
0.0113511048,
0.0454421714,
0.0123983063,
0.008988075,
0.0099809384,
0.0439563841,
0.0013767962,
-0.0021761607,
0.0006396794,
0.0491526537,
-0.0023745038,
-0.0061740652,
0.0219952893,
0.085326165,
0.013687972,
0.0097846547,
0.006608001,
0.0079602944,
0.0060817385,
0.0255068503,
-0.0777166188,
0.0337006375,
-0.0105210114,
-0.0147079295,
-0.0211051535,
0.0188298076,
-0.0039151781,
0.0163195767,
-0.016581675,
-0.0445313379,
0.0059508411,
-0.0021336672,
-0.0060524987,
-0.0016525921,
-0.0048422283,
-0.0453586429,
0.0143255359,
0.0379481986,
-0.0787411481,
0.0006245496,
-0.0161316264,
-0.0056537883,
0.0708733797,
-0.0359205976,
-0.0053207777,
0.0068144328,
-0.0401172005,
0.0806301162,
-0.0059843767,
-0.0024586048,
-0.010261748,
0.0379434563,
-0.0550161228,
-0.0129638221,
-0.013938373,
-0.0122470483,
-0.021192614,
0.0219270904,
-0.013635532,
-0.0162043069,
-0.0654334053,
-0.0164770018,
0.0128523083,
0.037915308,
0.0307756402,
0.0460507572,
-0.067717202,
-0.0074249539,
-0.024094265,
0.0427816398,
-0.0059745996,
-0.0197865199,
0.0028631489,
-0.0274505746,
-0.015039132,
0.0361766331,
0.0106004374,
0.02361474,
-0.0154188843,
0.0166360494,
-0.0225247815,
-0.0074139717,
0.0391722471,
-0.0796247572,
-0.0100780949,
-0.0425144993,
0.0109840492,
-0.0822402462,
0.0312819816,
0.0080407839,
0.0196176711,
-0.0282110944,
0.0008899489,
0.0133862076,
-0.0597616769,
0.0441492796,
-0.0564048551,
0.0104779107,
0.0257951394,
0.0389950462,
0.0330648199,
0.0348605067,
-0.0033730534,
-0.0196383707,
-0.0162682179,
0.0102162939,
0.0308097433,
0.0042607961,
0.0108604347,
-0.016785359,
0.0031949063,
-0.0005893507,
-0.0090489751,
0.08061634,
0.0342131034,
0.0822661817,
-0.0219286457,
-0.0086245453,
0.0219127331,
0.0572763607,
0.0027735396,
0.002185849,
0.0216532033,
0.0158429351,
0.0176268276,
0.0097538652,
-0.0222953241,
0.0322492532,
0.0005716867,
0.035314817,
0.0339888707,
-0.0037224109,
-0.0482268631,
-0.0227066129,
-0.0255338438,
0.0102951443,
-0.0414202474,
0.0171231441,
0.0477829427,
0.0113251302,
-0.025540689,
0.0439807735,
0.0675369948,
-0.0186734293,
-0.0069392915,
-0.0566611141,
-0.0106861927,
0.0687838793,
0.0579657778,
-0.0228398759,
-0.0251964331,
-0.0244868305,
0.0540357754,
0.0303389151,
0.0263297521,
-0.0148963425,
0.0025676684,
-0.0499686301,
-0.0429755263,
0.0336037502,
0.029895585,
-0.0369885787,
0.0006522363,
-0.0226409417,
0.015460196,
-0.0533855446,
-0.0446825512,
0.0157717336,
-0.05026149,
-0.0153112579,
-0.0164958015,
-0.0128521128,
-0.0120411739,
0.0278753489,
-0.0235869158,
0.0127666052,
0.0160427578,
-0.0003684642,
-0.0183417276,
0.0281871688,
-0.0640173256,
-0.0642533973,
0.0287457015,
-0.0547461025,
0.0073199347,
-0.0334112234,
-0.0496416688,
-0.0314630494,
-0.035979785,
-0.0548005961,
0.0226857625,
-0.0015115927,
0.0137581807,
0.0635150671,
-0.0143465661,
-0.0348772295,
0.0297442637,
-0.0232817233,
0.0041717659,
0.0852484927,
-0.0193401109,
-0.0112247439,
-0.0402285606,
-0.0165454894,
0.0080722114,
0.0318709202,
0.005661645,
-0.0035092314,
0.0319882371,
-0.035973452,
-0.0324004553,
-0.0949212909,
-0.0315147527,
-0.0080273561,
-0.0207599122,
0.0641267225,
0.02718818,
0.0021298847,
-0.026548028,
-0.0592449568,
-0.042787578,
0.0571706966,
0.0185913704,
0.0509939305,
0.0460791178,
0.0184581466,
-0.0401837453,
-0.024095282,
-0.0073648635,
0.0304469336,
0.0316835046,
-0.0117990104,
-0.0314709581,
0.0095970333,
-0.0311910305,
-0.021674918,
-0.0019268312,
-0.0228332095,
-0.0135145411,
-0.0400578231,
-0.0196950808,
0.0323188491,
-0.0095721576,
0.0161683019,
0.0439866595,
0.0006977717,
-0.0469630137,
-0.0181470681,
-0.0279000942,
-0.0599853359,
0.0258511491,
-0.0658835322,
-0.0100128008,
0.0406822935,
0.002545363,
0.0147439893,
-0.0307336953,
-0.0153363086,
-0.0140529787,
-0.0039720042,
-0.0444031209,
-0.0011636865,
-0.0083936686,
0.0420731157,
-0.0076507698,
-0.0222515259,
0.1024085432,
-0.0132220583,
0.0182099845,
-0.0744206458,
-0.0200143009,
-0.0603603758,
0.0106602926,
-0.0161030795,
0.0422633439,
0.0237263143,
-0.0361651406,
-0.0298894215,
0.0010669359,
0.0343986303,
-0.0536794327,
0.0419242457,
-0.0209832136,
0.0139515055,
-0.0039738975,
-0.022976106,
-0.0192996096,
-0.0411376469,
-0.0258598439,
0.0162641387,
0.0273570307,
-0.0115786232,
-0.0617413446,
0.0458522849,
0.0371277221,
0.0787278637,
-0.0015294773,
-0.018903872,
-0.0002416998,
0.0472879894,
0.0434482917,
0.0262434576,
-0.0124622639,
-0.0543783978,
0.0523201078,
0.0686221942,
0.0112780286,
-0.012327387,
0.002430934,
-0.0218787212,
-0.011188413,
-0.0107307797,
0.0105525171,
0.01283105,
0.0295676496,
-0.0347285829,
-0.0012636426,
0.1100213081,
0.024139395,
-0.0718352348,
-0.0144845145,
-0.0200816616,
0.0237210821,
-0.0021070016,
0.0151926288,
-0.0397310555,
-0.0198695436,
0.0020847116,
0.0371725857,
0.0229991339,
-0.0095473258,
0.0094171148,
-0.0646617189,
0.0423212573,
-0.0068419832,
-0.0733673796,
-0.0531816371,
-0.0453495421,
0.0122174025,
-0.0023154053,
-0.0072386418,
0.0056455438,
-0.0391722918,
-0.0063232603,
0.0126538705,
-0.0700040758,
-0.0810066462,
0.0095929885,
-0.0466860272,
0.0291725546,
0.0480459481,
0.0161403362,
-0.0216093212,
0.0310422201,
-0.0000882547,
0.0347177833,
0.0197550878,
0.0040701488,
0.1128858775,
0.0143301841,
-0.0014614211,
-0.0507738516,
0.0568342507,
0.0035583519,
0.0069726198,
-0.0158472955,
0.0284309629,
-0.0151346,
-0.0071604843,
-0.0505957641,
0.0744565353,
0.0146513861,
0.0523200408,
0.0092905322,
0.0295533556,
0.0148254838,
0.0107675763,
0.0519842282,
0.0128255198,
-0.0365361981,
0.0115486616,
-0.0414806418,
-0.0444973968,
-0.0695624053,
-0.041000478,
0.0631285757,
0.0099995462,
0.0030916117,
0.0202066544,
-0.0109862844,
0.0003733451,
-0.028356228,
0.0818799138,
-0.0122454334,
-0.0045360005,
-0.0477468446,
-0.0446210988,
0.0827688649,
-0.018410882,
-0.0168354344,
0.0295684896,
-0.0381157212,
-0.0130563388,
-0.0224892125,
0.0510281622,
0.0267183352,
0.0320408121,
0.0131990192,
-0.0556289367,
0.081270352,
0.0357640386,
-0.0198071543,
0.0126104821,
-0.0004880777,
0.005249328,
-0.0269142371,
0.0253930818,
-0.045480039,
0.0152932247,
0.0051702373,
0.033763241,
-0.0509602353,
-0.0617594384,
0.0390734859,
0.0495246015,
0.0252309367,
-0.0150517533,
0.0048421556,
-0.02456633,
0.0054802792,
-0.0452257767,
0.0032033978,
-0.0387472995,
0.0545759983,
0.001356004,
-0.014901828,
0.0105105266,
0.0264530964,
-0.0346935317,
-0.0183549672,
-0.0313147232,
0.0256255902,
-0.0246592872,
-0.0549677648,
0.0391922444,
-0.0111671807,
-0.0449223928,
-0.0194993261,
-0.0038677498,
0.0027600401,
0.0189778674,
0.0572701208,
0.0209312905,
0.0371934585,
-0.0207427498,
0.0418869779,
-0.036617361,
-0.0704350695,
-0.0476399586,
0.0319904052,
0.0338772349,
0.0147800427,
0.0158416331,
-0.0316521414,
0.0117866229,
-0.011676752,
0.0468705967,
-0.011653441,
0.0073821256,
0.0573688708,
0.0095906015,
0.0414571948,
0.0001308435,
0.119646199,
-0.0153669612,
0.0221238304,
-0.0190941971,
-0.0335078798,
-0.0540592335,
-0.0273866765,
0.0115614412,
0.0149584869,
-0.0452936031,
-0.0004416221,
-0.0557083152,
-0.0284869764,
-0.0228106324,
-0.0110529065,
-0.0479894914,
-0.040395584,
0.0711863711,
0.05332366,
0.0086991666,
-0.0237697549,
-0.0096772276,
0.0293713529,
-0.0081528286,
-0.0070034955,
0.0173560102,
-6.243181271e-33,
-0.0039235246,
-0.0327818021,
0.0196202956,
-0.0542103983,
0.0108696157,
0.0314238854,
-0.0476778075,
-0.0064959419,
0.0110021662,
0.0241160635,
-0.0452084355,
-0.0021727404,
0.0191943068,
0.041777689,
-0.0017895307,
-0.0031473793,
0.0478220731,
-0.0003633088,
-0.0271162428,
0.043097008,
-0.0342925489,
0.0220593307,
0.0312811062,
-0.0972833261,
0.0095769363,
0.0119363889,
0.0011686794,
0.0185741615,
-0.0012688613,
0.0355966873,
-0.0356785059,
0.0106256679,
0.0246104226,
-0.0253148321,
-0.0284192748,
0.0031973638,
-0.0777571723,
-0.0043568043,
0.0328498036,
-0.0245152451,
-0.0510890186,
-0.0115325451,
0.0352760702,
-0.0328226015,
0.0379275084,
-0.0356925204,
0.0366872214,
-0.0190911908,
-0.0247008186,
-0.0222928431,
-0.033093933,
0.0666057095,
-0.0065925084,
-0.0290656481,
0.0001719704,
0.0288994815,
-0.0339808539,
0.0283929761,
-0.0114559717,
0.0229851156,
0.0839098766,
0.0321896039,
0.0318316817,
0.0090089208,
-0.027006859,
0.0521269143,
0.042208571,
-0.0093952846,
-0.0237353593,
-0.0085806921,
-0.0523551218,
0.0094187595,
0.0212021712,
0.0660327598,
0.026146993,
0.0187010374,
-0.0518477336,
0.0557541735,
-0.0422496498,
0.0615749396,
0.0381614044,
-0.0398387238,
-0.0689207315,
-0.0111699384,
-0.0269093551,
0.0218808521,
-0.0257588644,
-0.044308316,
0.0005017602,
0.036272306,
-0.0179815236,
0.0016393019,
0.017987838,
0.0084918076,
0.0163988844,
-0.0229600333,
0.0185509957,
0.0208281465,
-0.0560687184,
-0.0195840839,
-0.0554920323,
0.0118239177,
0.0245910101,
-0.0040404028,
0.0233085547,
0.0281983595,
0.0309086423,
-0.0027999091,
-0.0643463433,
0.0154934647,
0.0262373053,
-0.0139720524,
-0.0338973477,
0.01378028,
0.0188167244,
0.0173432417,
-0.0138108842,
0.0564163998,
-0.0141056748,
-0.0058787754,
-0.0278819334,
-0.0539663844,
0.0151386531,
-0.008444231,
-0.0560334586,
0.0061920984,
-0.0143438671,
-0.0098705105,
0.080974102,
-0.018365493,
-0.0302081704,
0.0003566947,
2.754e-7,
0.0793269575,
0.0512564629,
0.016431611,
0.0112447338,
-0.0066308416,
-0.0021293652,
-0.0016739265,
0.0148226805,
0.0347289406,
-0.0058635697,
0.0460661054,
0.0122501692,
0.0094737764,
0.0324104838,
-0.108187668,
-0.0400502458,
-0.0883602723,
-0.0415657982,
-0.0100821713,
-0.0687185451,
0.0675437152,
0.0956059694,
-0.0585974231,
-0.0382561572,
-0.0013450399,
-0.0256486814,
0.0369142182,
-0.0541251935,
-0.0251298565,
0.0456549339,
0.0538585111,
0.0090173846,
0.0114252456,
0.0547550209,
0.0241844561,
-0.032875821,
0.0424463227,
0.0766276419,
-0.0185747389,
0.000985681,
0.0167450514,
-0.0016876658,
0.0246215593,
-0.0202687513,
0.0336514749,
-0.0903404579,
-0.0354664437,
0.0022076813,
-0.0222622454,
-0.0283059552,
0.0439944938,
-0.0472988747,
-0.0540633723,
0.0422830842,
0.0029312975,
0.0120966528,
-0.0289325695,
-0.0838247612,
-0.0330548808,
0.0163768455,
-0.0132787963,
-0.069496721,
0.0480939373,
-0.056406837,
-0.0357860066,
-0.0589486584,
0.0214427654,
2.509161339e-34,
0.0774114206,
0.0234593116,
-0.0162919667,
0.0190276783,
0.0358922519,
-0.0254901964,
0.001043244,
0.0082429349,
0.0474982113,
-0.0902324617,
-0.0158131029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14498v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14498v1 | LLaSA: Large Multimodal Agent for Human Activity Analysis Through Wearable Sensors | 2024-06-20T17:00:34 | 2024-06-20T17:00:34 | Sheikh Asif Imran, Mohammad Nur Hossain Khan, Subrata Biswas, Bashima Islam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Integrating inertial measurement units (IMUs) with large language models
(LLMs) advances multimodal AI by enhancing human activity understanding. We
introduce SensorCaps, a dataset of 26,288 IMU-derived activity narrations, and
OpenSQA, an instruction-following dataset with 257,562 question-answer pairs.
Combining LIMU-BERT and Llama, we develop LLaSA, a Large Multimodal Agent
capable of interpreting and responding to activity and motion analysis queries.
Our evaluation demonstrates LLaSA's effectiveness in activity classification
and question answering, highlighting its potential in healthcare, sports
science, and human-computer interaction. These contributions advance
sensor-aware language models and open new research avenues. Our code repository
and datasets can be found on https://github.com/BASHLab/LLaSA. | [
-0.0015797063,
0.0447716564,
-0.0095286053,
0.0376245528,
0.0192942768,
0.0050634858,
0.0263971556,
-0.0150807733,
0.0234329458,
-0.0710405707,
-0.0094251698,
0.005941628,
-0.017534893,
0.0114266118,
0.0423952788,
-0.0213040933,
0.0503901578,
-0.0449899547,
0.0349338539,
0.0123793101,
0.0268469248,
-0.0096830772,
-0.0478282832,
0.0325872451,
-0.001649298,
-0.027393369,
-0.0089440867,
-0.0246197898,
0.011406078,
-0.0676595494,
0.0016588083,
0.0106673613,
0.0612461641,
-0.0124939391,
0.000001886,
-0.0224797726,
0.0590081178,
-0.0048542889,
-0.0088268835,
-0.036348708,
0.0040736734,
0.0027337687,
0.0482443869,
0.0145638641,
-0.0554433949,
0.0009974394,
0.0033307113,
-0.0222657695,
0.0673596784,
0.0647369996,
-0.0118557382,
0.017338803,
-0.0020651754,
-0.0004234367,
0.0443796255,
-0.0162030403,
0.0065089157,
0.0152330892,
0.0813954845,
0.0263647977,
-0.0365466699,
0.0229414776,
0.0153005961,
0.0228869095,
0.0056462171,
0.0242470726,
-0.0054148068,
0.0125386259,
-0.0213158131,
0.087353982,
0.0252959542,
0.0137363318,
0.0002853429,
0.0452399887,
0.005460503,
-0.0055839932,
-0.0797376111,
0.001413307,
-0.0053747119,
-0.0236436054,
-0.0154028963,
0.0277906191,
0.0087267933,
-0.0021283294,
-0.0242879633,
0.0408256687,
0.0117599862,
0.0024678144,
-0.0359159075,
-0.001919601,
0.0126080457,
-0.0436488427,
0.0364057273,
0.0567277931,
-0.0425975285,
-0.0019120708,
-0.0465777889,
-0.0011794961,
-0.0010935282,
-0.0517950356,
0.016945079,
0.0494611599,
0.0169770606,
0.0541442148,
0.0447610915,
0.0374404863,
-0.0287704859,
0.0280560888,
-0.0658745766,
-0.0302913059,
-0.0472121462,
-0.0000575632,
-0.0080490354,
0.0176418163,
-0.0426353812,
-0.0527544953,
-0.0061363103,
0.0545224771,
0.0071277497,
-0.0238733664,
-0.0357115157,
0.0273047667,
0.0079573914,
0.0122130075,
-0.0127926823,
0.0199148692,
-0.0517852791,
0.0642693266,
-0.0235759523,
-0.0576890372,
-0.0112403054,
0.0402088314,
0.0168115851,
-0.02518191,
0.0051627229,
0.0458797999,
-0.0139620937,
-0.0437677316,
0.0269559454,
-0.0187939368,
0.0039965077,
-0.0423217751,
-0.0028605335,
-0.0815926641,
0.0511334799,
-0.0107624661,
-0.0040710699,
-0.0672425106,
0.0281690229,
0.0473643243,
-0.0169671681,
0.0856097639,
-0.0178509858,
0.0350865908,
0.0250679404,
0.0024297447,
0.0424220115,
0.0385898314,
0.0567632094,
-0.0200076066,
0.0389979631,
-0.0176779088,
-0.0164706577,
0.0468365923,
0.0031639056,
-0.0268213097,
0.0030383139,
0.0276662074,
0.0009194869,
0.0551098399,
-0.0066082873,
0.0475343205,
-0.011741166,
-0.008221468,
0.0685232282,
0.0728141814,
-0.0575176999,
-0.0428033136,
0.0269081276,
-0.0347169489,
0.0089822281,
-0.0703073293,
-0.0150541877,
0.0305525418,
0.0202102344,
-0.0552084222,
0.0187086705,
0.0069008549,
-0.0509974137,
-0.0473079011,
-0.0448558405,
-0.0217963699,
0.0360942744,
0.0394012816,
0.0344467312,
-0.0293418448,
0.0166842025,
0.0387749784,
-0.0194269586,
-0.0359941944,
0.027363684,
-0.0168828778,
0.0302886683,
0.0719979629,
0.0244018137,
-0.0292545911,
-0.0362770669,
-0.0213877801,
0.0533365272,
-0.0094137052,
-0.0019137198,
-0.0364890434,
0.0162615608,
-0.058300525,
-0.0184780378,
-0.0092024021,
-0.018696472,
-0.0181952436,
-0.0362475775,
0.0115166297,
-0.0178743806,
-0.0314704627,
-0.0025129176,
0.0410723202,
-0.0224668495,
-0.0279288758,
0.0015946289,
0.0018957627,
0.0372861251,
0.043203935,
0.0049064346,
0.018828474,
0.054761339,
-0.0639018193,
-0.0030278175,
0.0653321519,
0.0034434609,
-0.0528620817,
0.0527801476,
-0.0099401725,
-0.0365719944,
0.0048961765,
0.0040386445,
-0.0403982364,
-0.0183374844,
-0.0886945054,
0.0059598335,
-0.027331382,
-0.0483077802,
0.0613869019,
0.0078053842,
-0.0489726514,
0.0169049501,
-0.0150408391,
-0.0039618136,
0.0510824174,
0.0327818096,
0.040734496,
-0.0399063379,
-0.0339853391,
0.0166895147,
-0.0057145143,
0.0189339127,
0.0337087102,
0.0038542701,
-0.0303287525,
-0.0109929284,
-0.1412059814,
0.0105490275,
-0.0143277682,
0.0400290526,
0.0117800636,
0.0454050414,
-0.0068617524,
-0.0324315764,
-0.0265941173,
-0.0358208306,
-0.0002122168,
0.0389607549,
0.0287213419,
0.0253830589,
-0.0108863693,
-0.015453862,
0.0169420019,
-0.0512572341,
0.0512503609,
-0.0086291181,
0.0175507739,
-0.005044179,
-0.0739545375,
-0.0270438585,
0.0438694544,
-0.0026745948,
-0.0368420407,
0.0746152997,
-0.0400797464,
0.05823512,
0.0603761934,
0.0172614586,
0.035922695,
0.0439037718,
-0.0564971864,
-0.0520312563,
0.0379806347,
-0.0114574721,
0.0161598772,
-0.048243273,
-0.018554857,
-0.0010610056,
0.0385640226,
0.0141508132,
0.0163240936,
-0.0083443774,
0.0102010677,
-0.0136619145,
-0.0235670973,
-0.0318483002,
0.0558696352,
-0.0487650521,
0.0351045504,
0.0081286859,
-0.0196346752,
0.02714484,
-0.0122847054,
-0.0291053206,
-0.0551855005,
-0.0130044417,
-0.0338099971,
0.0850878283,
0.003372614,
0.019788824,
-0.0572725646,
0.0017994875,
0.0060193641,
-0.0141120823,
-0.0307030808,
-0.0241423268,
0.00805513,
-0.0722398385,
0.0450388752,
0.0072899992,
-0.0323382244,
-0.0209600125,
-0.0300117936,
-0.0372992828,
-0.0224350244,
-0.0889585912,
-0.0106138932,
-0.0167741589,
-0.0198498107,
0.0100381076,
-0.0090546841,
-0.0057101292,
0.0069551808,
-0.0214303099,
0.0289914217,
0.0721659362,
0.0680820942,
-0.0640558675,
-0.0281161293,
-0.0041017551,
0.0785069093,
0.0238678306,
0.0081733726,
-0.0474875011,
0.0059913914,
0.0205541495,
0.0238437653,
0.0039098742,
0.0540847927,
0.0863390341,
-0.0460383222,
-0.019476695,
0.1335384101,
0.0161683112,
-0.0244616475,
0.0318512283,
0.0119506298,
-0.0068095061,
0.0123466151,
0.008239096,
-0.0284600183,
-0.079896003,
-0.0332785025,
0.027787948,
0.0216545872,
-0.0140775451,
0.0179779343,
-0.0728664547,
0.0150332553,
0.0021656591,
-0.0330638848,
-0.0761777535,
-0.0352853611,
0.0226878636,
0.0040846188,
-0.021741014,
-0.0167938732,
0.0033964911,
0.0187545065,
0.0177528076,
-0.0382095352,
-0.0307263918,
0.0230225362,
-0.0359609462,
0.0478982814,
0.0443042628,
0.0585282482,
-0.0171513949,
-0.0658246353,
-0.0069743772,
-0.03482363,
-0.0085810544,
-0.0244771615,
0.0095037054,
-0.0040085311,
-0.0275669117,
-0.0340142176,
0.0954194441,
-0.0758942291,
-0.027365407,
0.0191717483,
0.093913883,
-0.0620842054,
0.048615545,
-0.0660528392,
-0.0215226021,
0.037367899,
0.0487790182,
-0.0014229009,
-0.0567617714,
-0.031760823,
-0.0132483449,
-0.0245511141,
-0.0184365436,
-0.0181429274,
-0.0142246466,
-0.0138639119,
0.0090153618,
-0.0537392087,
-0.0760052651,
0.0617912635,
0.0330617018,
-0.0166624803,
0.0389209576,
0.0283088274,
0.0283349995,
-0.0694109201,
0.0631967336,
-0.0007385451,
0.0481880046,
-0.0009009306,
-0.043639645,
0.0351106338,
0.0246510971,
-0.0132830776,
0.0380022526,
-0.0775247216,
-0.0179655831,
-0.0163169038,
0.0666269958,
0.0151614835,
0.0023867521,
-0.0075656069,
0.0042286362,
-0.0235864259,
0.0169763118,
-0.0474469364,
0.0300942361,
-0.0075342543,
0.0077394359,
-0.0044840528,
0.0124213118,
-0.033267796,
-0.0006487473,
-0.0658307448,
0.0537155755,
-0.0810784996,
-0.0684888288,
0.0045510768,
-0.0008046037,
0.0445553437,
0.0284606572,
0.0062527773,
-0.0106218103,
-0.0049959458,
-0.0213606656,
0.0149846328,
-0.0529529415,
0.0001692029,
0.0095084496,
0.0000021703,
-0.0296341162,
0.0402955636,
-0.0218653623,
-0.0391822532,
-0.0241671465,
0.0482511222,
0.0353903435,
0.0337569378,
-0.0186933056,
-0.008607083,
-0.0167361666,
0.0135406386,
-0.0076257288,
0.0012442112,
0.0097193811,
0.0428897962,
0.0210479032,
-0.0002692956,
-0.0128415236,
0.0538967885,
-0.0452357791,
-0.003755738,
0.0244245287,
0.0567827225,
0.0206461735,
0.0408151858,
0.0138530927,
0.0163514391,
-0.0003027293,
-0.0250374638,
0.0471675061,
0.0096288854,
0.0031217344,
0.0818702206,
0.000084814,
-0.015004985,
-0.0322604589,
0.0790701509,
-0.0216916855,
0.0846222788,
0.0249390882,
-0.0372079946,
-0.0435515195,
-0.0220979545,
0.0231299847,
0.0315951966,
-0.0310287401,
0.0279580764,
-0.0136061739,
-0.0274353568,
-0.0127688637,
0.0103948284,
-0.0277534742,
0.0057090423,
0.0571380183,
0.0395597219,
-0.0224049632,
-0.0383360125,
-0.0234221071,
0.0093858521,
-0.0814832076,
-0.0461025946,
-0.0082909456,
-5.578790395e-33,
-0.0195284523,
-0.0345353559,
0.0593792871,
0.0063709784,
-0.0213529505,
0.0085700266,
-0.0610615537,
-0.0055188425,
-0.02180323,
-0.0021981345,
0.0322146043,
-0.0062461812,
-0.0027872403,
0.0185485054,
0.0390421115,
-0.0065518548,
0.0055110222,
-0.0079692323,
0.0053591002,
0.0012513092,
0.0552133694,
0.0178069007,
0.0105151506,
-0.0755787268,
0.0047403323,
-0.0126766413,
-0.0222097225,
0.0540957823,
-0.015982762,
0.045997072,
-0.0537714362,
0.041520644,
0.0246115681,
0.0465228446,
-0.0150410244,
0.0515302047,
-0.0575381145,
-0.0538710654,
0.0218969733,
0.0295119733,
-0.0471337177,
-0.0377345942,
0.0165751632,
-0.0038236002,
-0.0265851319,
-0.0079166237,
0.0414451212,
-0.0078358753,
0.0279872827,
-0.0147413295,
-0.0220864806,
0.0138066709,
-0.0188787524,
-0.0595241822,
-0.0207681786,
0.0093747517,
-0.0143786836,
-0.0174988825,
-0.040524669,
-0.0000352233,
-0.0538822748,
0.0240185987,
0.025345752,
0.0107997498,
-0.0072455863,
0.0342617109,
0.0125285331,
-0.0255213827,
-0.0249790773,
0.042707663,
0.0121204788,
0.0525994636,
0.0172777865,
0.0505222268,
-0.0009159223,
0.0081738336,
-0.0802881792,
0.0612837523,
0.0615855977,
0.0418694131,
-0.0221501961,
0.0326587856,
-0.024020737,
0.0032896758,
0.0093978494,
0.0459143631,
-0.0133604864,
-0.0276509412,
0.0538882241,
-0.0086152991,
-0.0064748884,
0.0040432508,
0.0448195376,
-0.0321264192,
0.0313927941,
0.0092148632,
0.01535137,
-0.000358551,
0.0212549008,
0.00344605,
-0.0476112626,
-0.0312692076,
0.037086457,
-0.0022625667,
0.0303227194,
0.0109000374,
-0.021649275,
0.0379916802,
-0.0124603352,
-0.0308670942,
-0.0018021528,
-0.0123841129,
-0.0203878339,
0.0079144742,
0.0346742421,
0.0163436309,
-0.0389349461,
0.0970852822,
-0.0578300767,
-0.0134034287,
-0.0456600785,
-0.0423484072,
0.0110787256,
-0.0092961257,
-0.0318551064,
0.0094137015,
-0.0654400364,
0.0358108357,
-0.0327327661,
-0.0538373478,
-0.0069049895,
0.0390084684,
2.632e-7,
0.0484525412,
0.0339992493,
0.0124217607,
0.0018657012,
0.0504438654,
0.0315840319,
-0.0225009043,
0.0672463849,
-0.0241913367,
0.014798386,
0.0071278294,
0.0273376554,
0.0386490375,
0.036124032,
-0.022719007,
-0.0592825525,
0.0057911766,
-0.0120250108,
-0.0600603148,
0.0139068291,
0.0792285725,
0.0564023033,
-0.0113738086,
0.0037555485,
0.0246032942,
-0.091848515,
0.061809402,
-0.0142817283,
-0.0198210105,
-0.0000875433,
-0.0008490059,
-0.0019091056,
-0.0030311884,
-0.0257867929,
0.0125938905,
-0.014079893,
0.0466440842,
0.0917407647,
-0.0609269142,
-0.0285251513,
-0.0274316985,
-0.0071487539,
-0.02039125,
-0.0228067003,
0.0836383253,
-0.0101122372,
-0.038875591,
-0.0266559906,
-0.0052719382,
-0.0004003902,
-0.0086645391,
-0.0101001235,
0.0008607297,
-0.0034127715,
0.0209440626,
-0.028502902,
-0.0177870449,
-0.0810308307,
-0.0284612924,
-0.0191562567,
-0.0972214118,
-0.010529126,
-0.0294291824,
0.0000409741,
0.0119725456,
-0.0469210036,
-0.0230641291,
1.80383316e-34,
-0.0106592057,
0.0157572459,
-0.00397463,
0.0335076042,
0.0182856824,
-0.0123129673,
-0.0054422561,
0.0063472958,
0.0392894223,
-0.0810582712,
-0.0212751031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14497v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14497v1 | CodeRAG-Bench: Can Retrieval Augment Code Generation? | 2024-06-20T16:59:52 | 2024-06-20T16:59:52 | Zora Zhiruo Wang, Akari Asai, Xinyan Velocity Yu, Frank F. Xu, Yiqing Xie, Graham Neubig, Daniel Fried | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | While language models (LMs) have proven remarkably adept at generating code,
many programs are challenging for LMs to generate using their parametric
knowledge alone. Providing external contexts such as library documentation can
facilitate generating accurate and functional code. Despite the success of
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) in various text-oriented tasks, its
potential for improving code generation remains under-explored. In this work,
we conduct a systematic, large-scale analysis by asking: in what scenarios can
retrieval benefit code generation models? and what challenges remain? We first
curate a comprehensive evaluation benchmark, CodeRAG-Bench, encompassing three
categories of code generation tasks, including basic programming, open-domain,
and repository-level problems. We aggregate documents from five sources for
models to retrieve contexts: competition solutions, online tutorials, library
documentation, StackOverflow posts, and GitHub repositories. We examine
top-performing models on CodeRAG-Bench by providing contexts retrieved from one
or multiple sources. While notable gains are made in final code generation by
retrieving high-quality contexts across various settings, our analysis reveals
room for improvement -- current retrievers still struggle to fetch useful
contexts especially with limited lexical overlap, and generators fail to
improve with limited context lengths or abilities to integrate additional
contexts. We hope CodeRAG-Bench serves as an effective testbed to encourage
further development of advanced code-oriented RAG methods. | [
0.0160132162,
0.0810428858,
-0.0282437168,
0.0215315595,
-0.0341912843,
-0.0280309375,
-0.0404355451,
0.0222522654,
-0.0177112948,
-0.0203011222,
-0.0100604761,
0.0006769545,
0.0048195347,
0.0200324878,
0.0296924785,
0.0042179194,
0.0101819951,
-0.0217085071,
-0.0137770558,
0.0289948918,
-0.002179038,
0.0204633549,
0.0182212498,
0.0586924553,
0.0106715932,
-0.0030075118,
-0.0078162551,
0.0488260537,
-0.0181050245,
-0.0181883201,
0.040468853,
0.0304310396,
0.017707888,
0.0043047457,
0.0000022474,
-0.0350169986,
-0.0282415003,
0.0131998453,
0.0174838472,
0.0356078893,
0.03916426,
0.0203654356,
0.0108965151,
0.014034545,
-0.0488633029,
-0.0019415797,
0.0357439369,
-0.0640556067,
0.0280351676,
0.0522537194,
0.0139731206,
0.0107898405,
0.0060157739,
-0.0066759866,
0.0782013386,
-0.0307186805,
-0.0187189523,
0.043518737,
0.0358570255,
0.0270930938,
0.008262001,
0.037630368,
0.0195185915,
0.0135415988,
0.0165792238,
0.0473192893,
-0.0607643947,
0.0073523181,
0.0052075409,
0.0191667397,
-0.0067973109,
-0.049620036,
0.0424065441,
-0.0107036997,
-0.0311223436,
-0.0052838367,
-0.0518284068,
0.0457860902,
-0.010048056,
-0.0080994442,
-0.001403418,
-0.0067606755,
0.0220577624,
0.0087651946,
0.0011753776,
0.025717983,
0.0231100582,
0.0110231685,
-0.0230203457,
-0.0190281738,
-0.0092739165,
-0.0460965186,
0.0008710484,
0.0390500203,
0.0188980903,
0.020269284,
-0.0128417453,
-0.0433944874,
0.0680346787,
0.0024591717,
0.0174974557,
0.0596422926,
-0.0432069302,
-0.0293695349,
-0.0347977504,
0.0557467379,
-0.0050402894,
-0.0420754366,
-0.0373906083,
0.029215211,
-0.0449754968,
-0.016470328,
-0.06586539,
0.0580141358,
-0.0319615267,
0.0235851612,
-0.031164011,
0.0509996973,
0.0219347328,
0.0218755659,
-0.0296488386,
-0.0067130402,
-0.0583352037,
0.0148311267,
0.030403683,
-0.0402503535,
-0.0001420829,
-0.0363847055,
0.0313653834,
-0.0800633058,
-0.0067678979,
-0.001832099,
-0.0092365704,
-0.0464100502,
0.0218319651,
0.0331333727,
0.0233693179,
-0.0093641132,
-0.0400626957,
-0.0551898293,
0.003215529,
-0.0076933382,
-0.0130912345,
-0.1092032865,
-0.03125,
0.0334396772,
-0.0297860205,
-0.0817244872,
0.0115988431,
0.0199723188,
0.0135151846,
-0.0065394114,
-0.0422564559,
0.0288739968,
0.0394367687,
0.033680521,
-0.0055691861,
0.0292204712,
0.0157789662,
0.0338096581,
0.0290181581,
-0.0153572029,
0.0445279181,
0.014628808,
0.0225829631,
-0.0127301337,
0.0015895183,
0.0412878469,
0.023801012,
-0.0221532173,
0.0035592008,
0.0607502572,
-0.0390784107,
0.0431445278,
-0.0017388046,
0.0486443825,
0.0302200671,
-0.0040935888,
0.0751398355,
0.0275917388,
-0.0172721148,
-0.0115208076,
-0.0090578618,
0.0370859876,
-0.0314757004,
0.0331173018,
0.0295771267,
0.0403878987,
0.0045661931,
-0.0583897233,
-0.0164076034,
-0.0032138005,
-0.0228321534,
-0.000398627,
0.0346036516,
0.0170383174,
-0.0504058264,
0.0501516797,
0.0044300398,
-0.1092813015,
0.0020574701,
-0.0485435091,
0.0140604731,
0.0417833403,
0.0965330899,
-0.0520933867,
-0.0001165973,
0.0127719929,
0.0080208965,
-0.021512704,
0.040157944,
-0.0017348451,
0.0092102261,
-0.0625759736,
-0.0056024576,
-0.0623735376,
-0.0028665443,
0.0260833278,
0.0565790609,
-0.0216189586,
0.0743430629,
-0.0464949757,
-0.0635745972,
0.0367152281,
-0.0427563079,
0.021441767,
0.0303795896,
-0.0193511993,
-0.0094637396,
-0.0177118089,
-0.0481218547,
0.0478214882,
0.0488682687,
-0.0107479664,
-0.0095170829,
-0.0194950141,
-0.0257328209,
-0.0106350863,
0.0141511811,
-0.0248298459,
0.0104095144,
-0.0021193956,
0.00040524,
-0.0117279505,
0.0593736321,
-0.0099718422,
0.0243674852,
-0.0192435384,
0.0119201522,
-0.022923179,
-0.0294720121,
-0.014563553,
0.0558724515,
0.0035544401,
0.0418604277,
0.0198275484,
0.0750926584,
0.0347581208,
-0.0199862141,
-0.0104832686,
-0.0134940352,
-0.0678066835,
0.0491539091,
0.0384917147,
0.0431604534,
-0.0274478309,
-0.0641976297,
-0.0830006003,
0.0358822905,
-0.0252530444,
-0.0011843338,
0.0292907376,
0.0572226122,
0.0022716115,
0.0054738387,
-0.0139591722,
-0.023671845,
0.0020219074,
0.019330252,
0.023138497,
0.0148608293,
-0.0438490696,
-0.0661353469,
-0.0040537976,
-0.0135609256,
0.0394756645,
-0.0107616037,
0.0084083984,
-0.0483228713,
0.0937591419,
-0.0137714772,
0.0002162801,
-0.0394396037,
-0.0149903288,
0.0360843837,
-0.0633635446,
0.0800882876,
-0.002649551,
0.0015334131,
0.0070001371,
0.0399452448,
-0.0369018428,
-0.0585847199,
0.0215865057,
0.0042727659,
-0.0714187548,
0.043505948,
-0.0653237998,
0.0663188919,
0.0511649847,
0.0095796464,
-0.0198858641,
-0.0384747908,
-0.0057820766,
-0.0080177123,
0.0108101694,
-0.0153474482,
-0.0426664613,
0.019842919,
0.0661261827,
-0.0250097122,
-0.1000166908,
0.0355816334,
-0.0555308908,
0.0017303095,
-0.0165121872,
-0.0009941394,
-0.0710785761,
0.0678895861,
-0.0091915084,
0.0339867659,
-0.0122866752,
-0.0146603836,
-0.0166731942,
0.0171133988,
-0.0076317545,
-0.0612681173,
0.0528274998,
-0.0386912078,
0.0302405264,
-0.0038366613,
-0.0282504428,
-0.0464886986,
-0.00116251,
0.0425214395,
-0.0239827018,
0.0345846675,
0.036179278,
0.0465042852,
0.0034544102,
0.0274234954,
0.048203852,
0.0296347421,
-0.0380488932,
0.0045809527,
-0.0067462539,
-0.0065341764,
-0.0761562437,
-0.0264663137,
-0.0077987048,
-0.0350584723,
0.0098183611,
0.0800243095,
0.0276617222,
-0.036616303,
-0.0057931198,
0.0342854746,
-0.0069655068,
-0.0522565953,
0.0791294277,
0.0523054041,
-0.032212805,
-0.0515209064,
0.0641190633,
0.0447645262,
-0.0594984666,
-0.0011020935,
-0.0260989442,
0.0523446128,
0.069630906,
0.0350499898,
-0.0791696236,
0.0019949279,
-0.0060679712,
0.0639485419,
-0.0086559737,
-0.0065934383,
-0.0396230035,
-0.1013849154,
0.0264130626,
0.0266466718,
-0.0310623329,
-0.0319675095,
-0.0224626679,
-0.017548956,
0.0437441356,
-0.0613823421,
0.0803814083,
-0.0106692249,
0.0390374996,
-0.020504158,
-0.0184949003,
-0.0067255506,
0.016839711,
-0.020608006,
-0.0209317878,
0.072974503,
0.00385395,
0.0325935371,
0.0136582851,
0.0124648688,
-0.0520368814,
0.0197963528,
-0.0234340951,
0.0386651158,
0.0044876486,
0.0002729272,
0.0396745726,
0.0294065606,
-0.0633283034,
-0.0425346419,
0.022187436,
0.0123894103,
0.0080763455,
0.0095407674,
-0.0422688164,
-0.0035277207,
0.0231924057,
0.0311884098,
0.0585011989,
0.0092287119,
-0.0182663668,
-0.0602929108,
0.0303833093,
-0.0616227463,
0.0205005426,
-0.0406300277,
0.0186710823,
-0.0086834012,
-0.0618936345,
0.026829537,
-0.0004893579,
0.0324601717,
0.0140460879,
0.0046859235,
-0.0235740189,
-0.0229794402,
-0.0843586922,
0.0188356526,
-0.0243635885,
0.0135631422,
-0.0374193043,
-0.0343328007,
0.0179368705,
-0.0525225773,
-0.0144345108,
0.042153623,
-0.0788184628,
-0.0650845915,
-0.0342942327,
0.0500135683,
0.0224209744,
0.0038409547,
-0.0205520988,
-0.0174146835,
-0.0478703342,
0.038715113,
-0.0416526161,
0.0331687778,
-0.0088696312,
0.0075968588,
0.0153125692,
-0.0062966472,
-0.0978047401,
-0.0034998367,
-0.0042069517,
0.0212575551,
0.0180979855,
-0.0054583196,
0.0461984463,
0.027042415,
0.0113975666,
0.029052522,
-0.0310368072,
-0.009972672,
-0.0250304639,
0.0120037356,
-0.0350906588,
-0.0369874761,
0.020870775,
-0.0094658174,
-0.0349455364,
0.0532444492,
0.0155199878,
-0.0378564633,
0.1073984131,
-0.0167854391,
0.0133833215,
0.0028926951,
0.0684739351,
0.0747814924,
-0.0171930976,
-0.0277036708,
0.0106041487,
-0.0483147837,
0.0446415246,
-0.0364644751,
0.03480855,
0.0020107822,
0.020788189,
0.0225257445,
0.0028159327,
-0.0579491965,
-0.0374476463,
-0.0177078657,
-0.0306869,
0.0285320505,
0.0473922193,
0.0383224636,
-0.0047933236,
0.019378718,
-0.0285042431,
0.0702234507,
0.0101660099,
-0.0612635612,
-0.0060184798,
0.0233358033,
-0.0121514071,
-0.0217552539,
0.1039504334,
0.0062715188,
-0.0031426181,
-0.0180831198,
0.0048445007,
-0.023876531,
0.0083838971,
0.04420105,
0.0050437758,
-0.013940515,
-0.0275577102,
-0.0420040973,
-0.0458310284,
0.0124361515,
0.0252046119,
0.0079618413,
0.0043136938,
0.0344161354,
0.1172124445,
0.0009127113,
0.0040627453,
-0.0217979886,
0.0459808484,
-0.0635452121,
-0.0450043529,
-0.0264889225,
-6.062967701e-33,
-0.0484091789,
-0.0289939977,
0.0183413923,
0.007857834,
0.0268174373,
0.0147795705,
-0.0847796425,
0.0165505745,
0.0088053392,
-0.0767500475,
0.0207454786,
0.0160831623,
-0.021562973,
-0.0240107756,
0.0236967914,
0.0476711392,
0.0121554527,
0.0302743725,
-0.0763961002,
0.0454623252,
-0.0165066868,
0.0302987434,
-0.0017174184,
-0.0384431444,
-0.0405202471,
-0.0464112237,
0.0406894162,
-0.0275111422,
0.0441078208,
0.0420705713,
0.0019420186,
-0.0007687831,
-0.0075927377,
0.0244066846,
-0.032884147,
-0.0359186567,
-0.0142452559,
-0.0062521016,
0.0098638143,
-0.0440423749,
-0.0056735682,
-0.0772965178,
0.0570274033,
-0.0105340555,
-0.0383624919,
0.0214312952,
0.0146870287,
0.0093063693,
-0.0266111065,
-0.0490704887,
-0.0425843522,
0.0297516081,
-0.0414967649,
-0.0090500312,
-0.021878643,
0.040927086,
0.0187607352,
0.0931934863,
0.0277332123,
0.0210597496,
-0.0082308529,
0.0807027072,
0.0663524345,
-0.0239926893,
0.0114957644,
0.0070981169,
0.0076081473,
0.0130273923,
-0.0110895922,
-0.0024060183,
0.0403949581,
0.0478613637,
0.0129060792,
0.0186048523,
0.0313477479,
-0.0378459245,
-0.0381392501,
0.0362486281,
-0.0119392658,
0.0115998751,
0.0448738895,
0.0319151655,
-0.0348295234,
-0.0126663409,
-0.0437537096,
-0.025379736,
-0.0300658457,
-0.0409248471,
0.0481654294,
0.0189864319,
-0.0242464691,
-0.0222262479,
0.0126752583,
-0.0171998274,
-0.0002790614,
0.0767278895,
-0.0651873797,
0.0309356917,
-0.0335209742,
0.0251019597,
-0.0172567274,
-0.035630215,
0.0313128047,
0.0270485748,
0.0425701514,
0.0210987404,
0.0062160157,
0.0168875325,
-0.0403418094,
-0.0067825746,
-0.066898331,
0.0148058319,
-0.0304113273,
-0.0106795039,
-0.0160655845,
0.0201279651,
0.011030673,
0.0371241607,
0.0168168712,
-0.0288067162,
-0.0603594519,
-0.0222393833,
0.0145602748,
0.0132431956,
-0.0195200108,
-0.0063184421,
-0.0285344739,
0.0626012459,
0.0642699152,
0.0051439176,
-0.0609458834,
0.0270012729,
2.978e-7,
0.0338432901,
0.0096834693,
0.0175970476,
0.0294976514,
-0.0180666596,
0.0008822728,
-0.0389167555,
-0.0240865368,
0.0247943383,
-0.008314386,
-0.0571692586,
0.0096660098,
0.0262092967,
0.0395994484,
-0.0493059829,
0.0162485428,
-0.0133995181,
-0.010945634,
-0.0644175038,
0.0082305707,
0.046105627,
0.0094057973,
-0.041757673,
0.0095926374,
-0.0127883898,
-0.0519602187,
0.0281858165,
-0.0172787532,
0.0135586718,
0.0563766584,
-0.0567468777,
0.0355029888,
-0.0136715425,
-0.0678680465,
-0.0235367604,
0.0012375942,
0.0221246332,
0.0228530504,
0.0189703573,
0.0006657284,
0.0503246449,
-0.0036921627,
-0.026235912,
-0.0700058118,
0.0235581156,
-0.0025292824,
0.0268973336,
-0.0065252446,
-0.0273142233,
0.0075527136,
-0.0278593823,
-0.0134834861,
0.0035690642,
0.0020226436,
-0.027359074,
-0.0091173938,
-0.0362846479,
-0.0439525731,
-0.0467372052,
0.0025451616,
-0.0070287557,
-0.034995418,
-0.0634872913,
0.0409520492,
-0.0267943013,
-0.0163372196,
0.0287276469,
2.993390854e-34,
0.0263286345,
-0.0475217812,
0.0019540833,
0.021366369,
0.0698828772,
-0.0199469775,
-0.0493936874,
0.0196369234,
-0.040763963,
-0.0168523453,
-0.0386338383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14496v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14496v1 | African or European Swallow? Benchmarking Large Vision-Language Models for Fine-Grained Object Classification | 2024-06-20T16:59:39 | 2024-06-20T16:59:39 | Gregor Geigle, Radu Timofte, Goran Glavaš | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Recent Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) demonstrate impressive abilities
on numerous image understanding and reasoning tasks. The task of fine-grained
object classification (e.g., distinction between \textit{animal species}),
however, has been probed insufficiently, despite its downstream importance. We
fill this evaluation gap by creating \texttt{FOCI} (\textbf{F}ine-grained
\textbf{O}bject \textbf{C}lass\textbf{I}fication), a difficult multiple-choice
benchmark for fine-grained object classification, from existing object
classification datasets: (1) multiple-choice avoids ambiguous answers
associated with casting classification as open-ended QA task; (2) we retain
classification difficulty by mining negative labels with a CLIP model.
\texttt{FOCI}\xspace complements five popular classification datasets with four
domain-specific subsets from ImageNet-21k. We benchmark 12 public LVLMs on
\texttt{FOCI} and show that it tests for a \textit{complementary skill} to
established image understanding and reasoning benchmarks. Crucially, CLIP
models exhibit dramatically better performance than LVLMs. Since the image
encoders of LVLMs come from these CLIP models, this points to inadequate
alignment for fine-grained object distinction between the encoder and the LLM
and warrants (pre)training data with more fine-grained annotation. We release
our code at \url{https://github.com/gregor-ge/FOCI-Benchmark}. | [
0.0305447597,
0.0416212082,
-0.0274129454,
0.0714538991,
-0.0148061132,
0.0571761727,
0.0076015145,
-0.001055573,
-0.0451361053,
-0.0740284324,
-0.0254241675,
0.0075314483,
0.048352249,
0.0246387795,
0.0246262997,
-0.0442365631,
0.0238412935,
-0.0152171357,
0.0109488554,
-0.009932992,
0.0023299309,
0.0081592808,
-0.0002604043,
0.0388112329,
0.006336845,
0.0084967827,
0.0136804068,
0.0060506458,
0.0337003693,
0.0033604142,
0.0083076553,
0.0592103675,
0.0452182777,
-0.0024839113,
0.0000021253,
-0.049169343,
0.0261330605,
0.0316908211,
-0.0510609448,
0.0207586307,
-0.0045459126,
-0.0221780669,
0.0330573246,
-0.0037413316,
0.0049159713,
-0.0348531716,
0.0878389776,
0.0172110703,
0.0082437275,
0.0527683273,
0.0114822229,
-0.0743421093,
0.0410201475,
-0.0264448076,
0.0326410942,
-0.0500176586,
0.0154342614,
0.0097336452,
-0.0273647532,
-0.0024513318,
-0.0341644809,
0.0290708486,
0.0380362794,
0.0448516309,
-0.0034745943,
0.0356116407,
-0.082333684,
-0.0713149756,
0.0225964729,
0.0372103006,
-0.0315158963,
0.001286456,
-0.0250188429,
0.005527548,
-0.0010410986,
-0.0129773896,
-0.020720819,
0.0529923216,
0.0098381918,
0.0168585535,
0.0063871183,
-0.0066177351,
0.0046306145,
0.0289015323,
-0.0400024876,
0.0019042933,
0.0091055417,
0.0390114821,
0.039984148,
0.0451975539,
-0.0279366896,
-0.0373374857,
-0.0425358824,
0.0189989135,
-0.0244596284,
-0.0630054399,
-0.0068288078,
0.0055918163,
0.0124811698,
0.0019666445,
0.0332538933,
-0.0076853423,
-0.0674638674,
0.0434631705,
-0.0411850773,
0.040605031,
-0.0193966683,
0.0540997535,
0.0127807437,
-0.0319505557,
-0.034787029,
-0.0054296749,
-0.0149936657,
0.0323967636,
-0.0368721411,
0.0067139771,
-0.0092385681,
-0.0815471485,
-0.0489030406,
0.0278369505,
-0.0458851233,
-0.0192958321,
-0.0204747319,
0.0003136707,
-0.0283684134,
0.0202191547,
-0.023458235,
0.0315074995,
-0.0076079201,
-0.0511851013,
0.0056706509,
0.0114362715,
0.0125393262,
-0.0294637401,
0.017321324,
0.0456724465,
-0.0239839032,
-0.0432799309,
-0.0568114594,
-0.0079976618,
-0.043288663,
-0.0894278288,
0.0017916131,
-0.064035587,
0.0010547724,
0.0083379382,
0.03372797,
-0.0255784504,
0.0047038435,
-0.0361079611,
-0.0145921437,
0.0941860378,
-0.0433893465,
-0.0299851876,
0.0000514758,
-0.0030970001,
0.0249565821,
0.0803832114,
-0.0105233621,
0.058913257,
0.0179868992,
-0.020859791,
-0.0107025644,
0.018149253,
-0.0258791316,
-0.00650959,
-0.0693374574,
0.0021906672,
0.0186787508,
0.0020769581,
0.0074736625,
0.0289666709,
0.0026972755,
-0.0528033786,
0.0558599681,
0.0243137795,
-0.0021472168,
-0.0289373137,
0.0592884831,
0.0171216819,
0.0120457457,
0.0109615121,
-0.0472773612,
0.0406417958,
-0.0706356391,
-0.0036263685,
-0.0147264739,
0.0395113789,
-0.0359863974,
-0.0343685411,
-0.0134662287,
-0.0230986476,
0.0048786709,
0.025125904,
0.0806306601,
-0.0157471374,
0.0117314681,
-0.0418409742,
0.0615570471,
-0.0218138937,
-0.0283714626,
-0.0551455505,
0.0893349797,
-0.0214682166,
-0.0207344815,
0.0091113821,
-0.0422040559,
0.0082146414,
0.0258534979,
0.0551130883,
0.0590475798,
-0.0150130056,
0.0102342376,
-0.0300810579,
-0.0271777157,
0.0008553871,
0.0170857292,
-0.0242159832,
-0.0043662661,
0.0403195918,
0.0406251289,
-0.02696242,
-0.0117212096,
0.0623067543,
0.0380202979,
0.022718098,
-0.0195128284,
0.0487148203,
0.0366454907,
-0.0328290164,
-0.034270566,
-0.0178641453,
-0.0002932026,
-0.0525299236,
0.019507559,
-0.0405012816,
0.0257076044,
-0.0299665369,
0.0403130203,
-0.0708025917,
-0.0309005342,
0.0413586162,
-0.0178194195,
-0.000578829,
-0.0077342601,
-0.0037346007,
0.0256464947,
-0.027032055,
0.0086989487,
-0.054178752,
0.0140354577,
-0.0258640535,
0.0418691598,
0.0187911261,
0.007565897,
-0.0150088705,
-0.0549371429,
0.0222771745,
-0.0454331487,
-0.0381562971,
0.0066684568,
-0.0038385182,
-0.0027328036,
-0.011209487,
0.0234642774,
-0.0283234343,
0.0027261823,
-0.0306996685,
0.0307866558,
-0.0252176691,
-0.0271662939,
-0.0388171077,
-0.0440407656,
0.0254238229,
0.0031871973,
-0.0112541299,
0.0293076541,
-0.0590771064,
0.0265796948,
-0.0081598284,
0.0346197039,
-0.024850443,
-0.0071922201,
-0.0131292352,
0.0263441708,
0.0377785489,
-0.0018871976,
-0.0432938188,
-0.0246973597,
0.0281442329,
-0.0678171068,
-0.0131786969,
-0.0160667393,
-0.013218686,
0.0341992415,
-0.0231749732,
-0.0575576909,
0.0843956545,
0.0174948908,
0.0348295681,
0.0148599036,
0.0188323632,
-0.0208879616,
-0.0307128653,
0.0031551928,
-0.0452852212,
-0.0220040921,
-0.0253984388,
-0.0221105516,
0.0424606204,
-0.0478991754,
-0.0196073074,
-0.0636512712,
0.0681888387,
0.0045326222,
-0.0360768288,
-0.0664417446,
0.0298130177,
0.0175527129,
0.0681499466,
-0.0565291457,
-0.0540370271,
0.0233277157,
-0.0126700932,
-0.0098271053,
0.0466147698,
-0.0017227862,
-0.0318842009,
0.0826747343,
0.0267974325,
0.0165485516,
0.0341753885,
0.0199711751,
-0.0540927239,
-0.0166387912,
-0.0022734886,
-0.023674326,
0.0599430762,
-0.0243272893,
0.0258498788,
-0.0768279433,
-0.0266582426,
-0.0081799971,
-0.0019561313,
-0.0359174646,
0.0058358139,
-0.01274182,
-0.0295636561,
-0.0355564989,
0.0331973359,
0.0014970689,
-0.0281353854,
-0.0363923982,
0.0252427552,
0.0099655259,
0.0226201583,
0.0499095283,
0.0307616387,
0.0259065833,
-0.0296021309,
0.0132973641,
0.0287533309,
-0.0208354127,
0.0379232876,
-0.0394486152,
0.026973471,
0.0376211442,
0.0225356519,
-0.014313451,
0.0266825072,
0.0941737816,
-0.0593545735,
0.0039990698,
0.083989203,
0.0227473695,
-0.032744322,
-0.0181444455,
0.009472399,
0.0309365895,
0.0343882106,
0.0010870839,
-0.045022916,
-0.0671807155,
0.0059871143,
-0.0224659145,
-0.0060328809,
-0.036812637,
-0.0017678265,
-0.1183653623,
0.0866696909,
0.025747817,
-0.0641924292,
-0.0432498418,
0.0252508651,
0.0235970244,
-0.0329083838,
-0.023939034,
-0.0192310344,
0.0036695523,
0.0136164054,
0.0202021357,
0.0248514358,
-0.0234060567,
0.0227223858,
-0.0549836382,
0.0133309718,
0.0113540301,
0.006923479,
-0.0380048193,
-0.0908592343,
0.044424355,
-0.0530246422,
-0.0266605448,
-0.0060335756,
0.0761601478,
-0.0071836482,
-0.0555663519,
0.0171868466,
0.0318899751,
0.0029239163,
-0.02153874,
-0.0183516331,
0.0434298031,
-0.0368317701,
-0.0442987047,
-0.0196959712,
-0.0216600876,
-0.0199579466,
0.0573047698,
0.059796758,
-0.0495068319,
-0.0164543968,
-0.0035218049,
-0.0363339931,
-0.0160959959,
-0.0351995453,
0.0427948833,
0.0518211089,
-0.0424298383,
-0.0490010381,
0.0063870391,
0.0797009841,
0.0168101285,
-0.0169156883,
-0.0248792786,
-0.0199275427,
-0.0043318379,
-0.0573475547,
0.0812225938,
-0.0382937528,
0.0247474872,
-0.0427588038,
-0.0276374575,
0.0609778985,
-0.0170380827,
-0.0135701178,
0.0454374067,
-0.0714698285,
-0.0243897773,
-0.0297854617,
0.05842847,
0.0170867071,
0.0190510266,
0.0304594226,
-0.0728505477,
-0.0109828133,
0.0671168864,
0.0648165569,
0.0480531678,
0.0035957287,
-0.0755188018,
0.0018304175,
0.0270900819,
-0.0382480547,
0.0196714178,
0.0353736989,
-0.0060098665,
0.0095994594,
-0.0251107961,
-0.0095985131,
-0.0008675989,
0.0555041879,
-0.0395020694,
-0.0325512439,
-0.0114869084,
0.0204765126,
0.0768623054,
-0.0127018644,
-0.0333353393,
-0.0673328936,
0.0128321536,
0.0262303241,
0.0211026929,
0.0117401211,
0.0033985802,
0.0289442912,
-0.0443380177,
0.0101377666,
0.0323672928,
-0.0062828446,
-0.0097162118,
0.0326524116,
-0.0337837823,
0.0189648047,
-0.0059167864,
0.0613123141,
-0.0095274132,
0.0509093665,
0.0155555969,
0.0534212664,
-0.0360645168,
0.0228298828,
0.0108597651,
-0.0314890146,
-0.0127958348,
0.020658059,
0.024768997,
-0.0633826479,
-0.0162231885,
0.0146476012,
-0.0380108058,
-0.0381571017,
0.0440657996,
-0.0264167432,
-0.0329601765,
0.0510939471,
0.0343555622,
-0.0328341983,
-0.0048137312,
0.052454289,
0.0297154821,
0.0248476528,
0.0063207312,
0.0223399606,
-0.0026626994,
-0.0238071233,
0.0393004641,
-0.028215874,
0.0363700837,
0.0170434285,
-0.0497484952,
-0.0695035383,
0.0000801038,
0.0102396635,
-0.001996726,
0.0667789206,
0.0132898064,
0.0065224543,
0.0003960497,
-0.0418498106,
0.0016181197,
-0.0383880921,
0.0064625125,
0.0215665232,
-0.0203792658,
-6.345729929e-33,
-0.0236935988,
-0.0075996355,
-0.0165826567,
0.0259054583,
0.0170257259,
0.0004120373,
0.0293029454,
0.0093684085,
-0.0459396392,
0.0355073735,
0.0366742797,
-0.0381054357,
-0.0036038538,
0.0473618992,
0.0083577791,
0.0167431124,
0.0063718958,
0.015314173,
0.0054949219,
-0.0029785391,
0.0000812464,
-0.0001286962,
0.0507382788,
-0.0604634136,
-0.0236078016,
0.0290271211,
-0.0035846611,
0.0152482074,
-0.0357355773,
0.0519267023,
0.0051468038,
0.0015055488,
0.0394251198,
-0.0284202006,
-0.0120398365,
-0.0244211201,
-0.0532674603,
-0.0286319312,
0.0216107685,
0.031519372,
-0.0293058008,
-0.0082693575,
0.058355242,
-0.0023124716,
0.01778345,
-0.0265894886,
0.0384968482,
-0.0460573062,
0.0119431755,
-0.0190097764,
-0.0659262463,
0.021355113,
-0.0126210824,
-0.0486223809,
0.0297966022,
-0.000381491,
0.0011689333,
0.0489441976,
-0.001957038,
0.003470001,
0.0345724523,
-0.0047411746,
0.0400049835,
0.0765714496,
-0.0092535717,
0.0777833834,
0.047335241,
-0.0104642194,
0.010779202,
-0.0379966237,
0.0309016891,
0.0685564578,
0.0542431585,
0.0437395386,
0.0509466194,
-0.0032921974,
-0.0767350569,
0.0445077047,
-0.0887190551,
0.0358023383,
0.0086330464,
0.0122267241,
0.0412600711,
-0.0092600062,
-0.0695389584,
-0.0445215702,
-0.0360080488,
0.0434939079,
0.0450830646,
-0.0177909844,
-0.0350671858,
0.0644440874,
0.0555181839,
-0.0178966913,
0.0174045563,
-0.0515501164,
-0.0084994826,
0.0508712195,
0.0299984533,
-0.0192802642,
-0.0535726175,
-0.0331286676,
0.0310354494,
-0.0052646999,
0.026271319,
-0.0028171723,
0.0891345516,
-0.0108597772,
-0.0431469493,
0.0100629479,
-0.0386263691,
-0.0077341436,
-0.0080918549,
0.0699560568,
0.0649570525,
-0.0092125935,
-0.0062823785,
0.0234076474,
0.0023864249,
-0.0282335766,
-0.0266708434,
0.0083671417,
-0.0329683274,
0.0066089868,
-0.0051652333,
-0.0010480155,
0.0017383959,
-0.0087002153,
0.0083228648,
-0.0155409165,
0.0219560452,
0.0084026419,
2.845e-7,
0.0156547762,
-0.0243428964,
0.0018988349,
-0.0195857473,
0.0089107649,
0.0626686737,
-0.0235241149,
-0.0411078781,
0.004540164,
-0.0601783693,
-0.0059320438,
0.054136999,
0.0561735705,
0.0052555366,
0.0011311392,
0.0388640277,
0.0164202694,
0.0041715917,
-0.0447728634,
0.0062651611,
0.0055943839,
0.1036842912,
0.0202652309,
-0.0254154969,
0.034891177,
-0.0451008119,
0.0758320764,
-0.0575143881,
0.0124847572,
-0.0177801661,
-0.0600921996,
0.0599253774,
-0.0025551915,
0.071260944,
0.0190757066,
-0.0120143965,
0.0225038584,
0.0317962915,
-0.0331428126,
0.0432752296,
-0.0390890986,
0.051849816,
-0.0284238197,
-0.0481201075,
0.0996386781,
-0.0761537403,
-0.0639172941,
-0.0682994947,
0.003825811,
0.0130801713,
0.0096605653,
-0.034487091,
0.0409108661,
0.0212076381,
-0.0122587839,
-0.0163078252,
-0.027913725,
-0.0844288245,
0.0290178061,
0.026636431,
-0.037738353,
-0.0299355499,
-0.0347892381,
-0.0193947162,
0.0187427346,
-0.037759915,
-0.0486383811,
2.347648185e-34,
-0.0072083939,
0.0081580942,
0.0154594528,
0.0043662423,
-0.0082933512,
0.0122630922,
-0.0554786175,
-0.0130738663,
-0.0318947993,
-0.0158663932,
0.0302767381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14492v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14492v1 | Does Object Grounding Really Reduce Hallucination of Large Vision-Language Models? | 2024-06-20T16:56:11 | 2024-06-20T16:56:11 | Gregor Geigle, Radu Timofte, Goran Glavaš | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Large vision-language models (LVLMs) have recently dramatically pushed the
state of the art in image captioning and many image understanding tasks (e.g.,
visual question answering). LVLMs, however, often \textit{hallucinate} and
produce captions that mention concepts that cannot be found in the image. These
hallucinations erode the trustworthiness of LVLMs and are arguably among the
main obstacles to their ubiquitous adoption. Recent work suggests that addition
of grounding objectives -- those that explicitly align image regions or objects
to text spans -- reduces the amount of LVLM hallucination. Although intuitive,
this claim is not empirically justified as the reduction effects have been
established, we argue, with flawed evaluation protocols that (i) rely on data
(i.e., MSCOCO) that has been extensively used in LVLM training and (ii) measure
hallucination via question answering rather than open-ended caption generation.
In this work, in contrast, we offer the first systematic analysis of the effect
of fine-grained object grounding on LVLM hallucination under an evaluation
protocol that more realistically captures LVLM hallucination in open
generation. Our extensive experiments over three backbone LLMs reveal that
grounding objectives have little to no effect on object hallucination in open
caption generation. | [
0.0141505552,
0.0588467047,
0.0074564856,
0.0377380513,
-0.0137836495,
0.0190511011,
0.0349836163,
0.0116569856,
-0.001791904,
-0.0496055521,
-0.0338579416,
-0.0173543543,
0.0258325115,
-0.0113065178,
0.0260238536,
-0.0508114845,
0.0366932042,
-0.0603931323,
-0.0729543269,
-0.0040476848,
0.0060262303,
-0.0263050795,
0.0044490639,
0.0336284116,
-0.0176194813,
-0.0349722914,
-0.0112751396,
0.0217842795,
-0.0021389599,
-0.0071121454,
-0.0360101722,
0.0935656652,
0.0286085289,
0.0184726249,
0.0000018537,
-0.038598638,
0.0129314465,
-0.0028765227,
0.0140169915,
0.0333143063,
0.0062199063,
-0.0270356163,
0.0126200542,
0.0034169862,
-0.006876355,
-0.0073921024,
0.0861055031,
0.1046757847,
0.0561353378,
0.0167707074,
-0.0018696839,
-0.0259044804,
0.0098049482,
0.0066022673,
0.0569857061,
0.0118434364,
0.0086224219,
0.0727474242,
-0.0493220203,
-0.0198088009,
-0.0412366427,
0.0324732624,
0.0280402899,
-0.0067956382,
0.011349624,
0.0577141382,
-0.0832282081,
-0.042486053,
-0.0199126005,
0.0745416954,
0.0067724837,
-0.0332224071,
-0.0250725504,
0.0114051653,
0.0316198803,
-0.0028150752,
-0.0579710342,
0.0542234182,
0.0040187459,
0.0097505078,
-0.0302611813,
-0.0083824992,
-0.0002295461,
0.0010303995,
-0.0149335954,
0.0066113132,
0.0084073367,
-0.0078966934,
0.0444588214,
0.0376123637,
-0.0696185976,
-0.073558867,
0.0063407905,
0.0051370496,
0.0042967033,
-0.0073058284,
-0.0464141145,
0.0088929906,
0.0174463186,
-0.0508565493,
0.0271623079,
-0.0025983576,
-0.0918981656,
0.0364242755,
-0.0418618917,
0.0638194084,
-0.0281225163,
0.0674652755,
-0.0207098015,
0.0318616703,
-0.016761763,
-0.0230170842,
-0.0283182953,
0.0296349525,
-0.0491281822,
-0.0433372036,
-0.0035210289,
0.0064751357,
-0.0306684934,
0.0072928681,
-0.0404192284,
0.0513743609,
-0.0218861122,
-0.0014787308,
-0.0296911374,
0.0277040564,
0.0118338913,
0.0075008175,
0.0017776482,
-0.0724694878,
-0.0208385922,
0.052157294,
-0.0147508588,
0.0015477921,
-0.0136206662,
0.0466767214,
-0.0190270655,
-0.0285094827,
-0.019385092,
-0.0324757807,
-0.0531629138,
-0.0553527102,
0.0427747592,
-0.0567974746,
-0.0206137318,
-0.0057992605,
-0.0022417454,
-0.0183191448,
0.0328732803,
0.0215381868,
-0.0069854427,
0.0716001168,
-0.0221737772,
-0.0027236375,
0.0138643496,
0.021644067,
-0.0156948548,
0.0727411285,
-0.0019795191,
0.0456084386,
-0.0004806546,
-0.0302710142,
0.0303899013,
0.0247387178,
0.0073937457,
0.0198993292,
-0.0492105298,
0.0004082731,
0.0058712042,
0.0204538535,
0.0572795235,
0.0697541237,
-0.0207935516,
0.0014296914,
0.1107027829,
0.062702544,
-0.0457045026,
-0.0024961529,
0.0058136545,
-0.0144295972,
0.0022987293,
0.0727539212,
-0.09029264,
0.0569858365,
-0.0120792426,
0.0271125045,
0.0011280318,
0.0064607542,
-0.0342989936,
-0.0470429137,
-0.0301275942,
-0.0043036141,
-0.0054168832,
0.0026835271,
0.0160668492,
0.0212811753,
-0.0556741096,
0.063151978,
-0.0051533375,
-0.0429798849,
-0.0089327926,
-0.0424013175,
0.0097764703,
0.0200284719,
0.0461616442,
0.0299239941,
-0.0375993811,
-0.0344309546,
0.1010470092,
0.1059297994,
0.0121752433,
0.0281066075,
-0.0128694698,
-0.0261782724,
-0.0239720121,
-0.0167015884,
0.0054228953,
-0.0157316141,
0.0001811152,
-0.0068707452,
-0.0049497131,
-0.0428910591,
-0.064735949,
0.0571440607,
0.0463843457,
-0.0028953305,
-0.0632551238,
0.018710237,
-0.0115900077,
-0.0258961041,
-0.0284268521,
0.0217675604,
0.0040424531,
-0.0224947985,
-0.0210933071,
0.0206394196,
-0.0535534434,
0.0079169329,
0.0238435082,
-0.0743521824,
-0.0012445217,
-0.0056376769,
-0.0026171361,
-0.0046172836,
-0.0108477781,
-0.036247462,
0.0122560449,
-0.0549235642,
0.0264840964,
-0.0183749404,
0.0290552843,
-0.0339689031,
0.0525998548,
-0.0499605425,
-0.0152976811,
0.032325197,
-0.0110642398,
-0.0050501307,
-0.0347340666,
-0.014091108,
0.0162873548,
0.014199825,
0.0154459765,
-0.0041482029,
0.0240632202,
-0.0641622394,
-0.0193131343,
-0.0837804079,
-0.0170477182,
-0.024266297,
-0.0303988922,
0.0293134339,
-0.028965665,
-0.0067175333,
-0.0024444561,
-0.0231956746,
0.0257619694,
0.0142346406,
0.0378972627,
0.0334036462,
-0.0146881854,
-0.0406780429,
-0.0049235169,
0.0069539943,
0.0242404602,
0.0719899014,
0.0093077915,
-0.0433189496,
-0.0706001073,
0.0875923559,
-0.0519015752,
0.0075598876,
0.008616739,
-0.0020138589,
0.0169161782,
0.0168859679,
0.0192328412,
0.089266412,
0.000944808,
0.0492634363,
0.0659895092,
-0.0056089316,
-0.0273127686,
-0.0273288637,
0.0183416139,
-0.0792102888,
0.0115556456,
-0.0251012519,
-0.0102332933,
0.0301797614,
-0.0194519293,
0.0311679132,
-0.0625366271,
0.0367626585,
-0.0259148106,
-0.0735544711,
-0.0320989788,
0.0043160301,
-0.0050238199,
0.062860094,
-0.0501855873,
-0.1065454111,
0.0376258194,
-0.0375644006,
-0.021754073,
0.0244139563,
0.0369186848,
-0.0085270656,
0.0551550202,
0.0122943297,
0.0298129842,
0.018661337,
-0.0172414351,
-0.0589063019,
-0.0236296654,
-0.0379360616,
-0.0033815783,
0.0744629651,
-0.0563597642,
0.0032687604,
-0.0266431905,
-0.0192748234,
-0.0440371111,
-0.0034987915,
-0.0091133509,
-0.0329087824,
-0.0931916609,
0.0271150507,
-0.0366895534,
0.0438348316,
0.012959457,
-0.0227157008,
-0.0448583029,
-0.0129141333,
-0.0146118905,
0.0034632154,
0.0581060685,
0.0257100835,
0.0366137996,
-0.052865956,
0.0404387414,
0.0653247908,
0.01530849,
0.021314675,
-0.0485175662,
0.0255236235,
0.0201054756,
0.0246939473,
-0.0193290226,
0.0310027096,
0.0740336925,
-0.0475855805,
-0.0264448281,
0.0853019878,
0.0176350847,
-0.0291465633,
-0.0149190752,
-0.020423932,
0.0855469406,
0.0196841024,
-0.0075523853,
-0.0454500467,
-0.0332564525,
-0.0154180843,
-0.007632555,
0.0187408775,
0.0018788043,
-0.0308602992,
-0.0794860348,
0.0742537752,
0.0280486234,
-0.0445395447,
-0.059403684,
0.0144473445,
-0.0216486678,
0.0293991398,
0.0391751453,
-0.0191579424,
-0.002615653,
0.0006823796,
0.0266820751,
-0.0112279197,
-0.0059818998,
0.0003187022,
-0.0590135083,
0.0043520518,
0.0731999874,
-0.0150872748,
0.0027968297,
-0.0964139402,
0.0293069631,
0.0102735022,
0.0257637762,
0.0036326624,
0.0581537075,
0.0007785248,
-0.0221602488,
0.0142875938,
0.0208406821,
-0.0333937854,
-0.0165855289,
-0.0207372475,
0.0266668424,
-0.0324091278,
-0.0336944461,
-0.0166580025,
0.0560058132,
-0.0146448985,
0.0699855015,
0.0599722676,
-0.0412014984,
-0.036446888,
-0.0017206807,
0.0131044704,
-0.03494085,
-0.0294289328,
0.0493021496,
0.0445661992,
-0.018465491,
-0.0707351416,
-0.0328096747,
0.036933776,
0.0440674163,
0.0159300361,
0.0124493726,
-0.0517934673,
0.0012896711,
-0.0297244694,
0.0726671293,
-0.0418166928,
-0.0020178691,
-0.0514954776,
0.0118567506,
0.0358698182,
-0.0351441614,
-0.0051669232,
0.0306596179,
-0.092084378,
-0.0366406105,
0.0054440852,
0.048067864,
0.0280626826,
0.0306243859,
0.0507258587,
-0.027037397,
0.0156450737,
0.0496626161,
0.0579069592,
0.0771838352,
-0.0135367615,
-0.0062060617,
0.0083663454,
0.0200819075,
-0.0186541621,
-0.012075847,
0.0343423896,
0.010852715,
0.0180046018,
-0.0162345916,
0.0162302703,
0.0146418624,
0.0297557302,
-0.0320600457,
0.0272057261,
0.0017742818,
0.0089187967,
0.0043439423,
-0.0030712974,
-0.0443749949,
-0.0048559913,
0.0153393392,
0.0203094073,
0.0271798838,
0.0052509857,
-0.0285018235,
0.0348790511,
-0.0096600829,
-0.0209041778,
0.0046955626,
-0.0393857323,
-0.0024028947,
0.0262533538,
-0.0355131589,
-0.0094448812,
-0.0132942488,
0.0450593233,
0.0224850941,
0.0735789686,
0.0054523358,
0.000773026,
-0.0247484911,
0.0555901602,
-0.0289266687,
-0.0621584393,
-0.0313137509,
0.0544172749,
0.0402681604,
0.0038266482,
0.0318688452,
-0.01980092,
0.0005427591,
-0.0077776881,
0.010350965,
0.0254416429,
-0.0336297378,
0.0504422933,
0.011426352,
-0.0164736882,
-0.0204050019,
0.0379947349,
0.0262380242,
0.0383602232,
0.0008636715,
-0.013850675,
-0.0205493309,
-0.0437025838,
0.0037136015,
-0.0394083932,
0.006742144,
0.0083946176,
-0.0606109835,
-0.0466659218,
-0.014357049,
0.0150324525,
0.0075738654,
0.0007928715,
0.0477935337,
0.0491911955,
-0.0046471115,
-0.0113284336,
0.0198143944,
-0.0393933021,
0.0122338235,
0.0237792302,
-0.0117272288,
-5.67918349e-33,
-0.0488573201,
-0.0344819613,
0.0403482616,
-0.0101208864,
-0.0339624099,
0.0149797192,
-0.0103776362,
0.0287310444,
0.0192574915,
-0.0090001971,
0.0159704704,
-0.0024483814,
0.017735986,
0.0162468869,
-0.022069687,
-0.032943543,
0.042044621,
-0.0167414583,
-0.0259937029,
-0.0252044909,
-0.0077984217,
-0.0104323542,
0.0312238801,
-0.0411263295,
0.0120052602,
0.0079935342,
-0.0226156209,
-0.011593123,
0.0270995926,
0.0609788485,
-0.0280982852,
0.0109277209,
0.009648799,
-0.0301378742,
-0.0520184934,
0.0198520869,
-0.0281000268,
0.0026814584,
0.040864516,
0.0542604513,
-0.0460952893,
-0.002823639,
0.0438647196,
-0.0170809571,
-0.0247507412,
-0.0312431064,
0.0245676786,
-0.0174733512,
-0.0254929252,
0.0493368544,
-0.0458249561,
-0.0337977968,
-0.0058761141,
-0.0290609431,
0.0308672376,
0.0000919632,
-0.0006458827,
0.0200149603,
-0.0085340412,
0.018299941,
0.016811261,
0.0035053696,
0.1081891432,
0.0524934717,
-0.0006686635,
0.0781778321,
0.0557879657,
-0.0074008806,
-0.0370197073,
-0.0413279608,
0.021607792,
0.0565480925,
0.0530747734,
0.0188131686,
0.0521089323,
0.0332958102,
-0.0381031111,
0.024899872,
-0.1221145913,
0.0440781489,
0.0454234518,
0.0011211463,
-0.006372557,
-0.0084628118,
-0.0301225465,
0.0032396612,
-0.0390112922,
-0.0253816601,
0.0651603714,
-0.0056281448,
-0.0329825655,
0.0049288371,
0.0705504715,
-0.024808703,
0.0150428275,
-0.0059590475,
-0.0180332288,
0.0557328686,
-0.0106910914,
-0.0324650444,
-0.0201971009,
-0.0020309263,
0.0459146127,
0.0221860502,
0.0258752126,
0.0297444668,
0.0349770896,
-0.0258550849,
-0.0518780127,
0.003195262,
-0.055490654,
-0.0014586365,
0.0056694555,
0.0179121438,
0.049049519,
-0.007965371,
-0.0496635027,
0.0115669621,
-0.006127012,
-0.0188510567,
-0.0203166865,
0.000584783,
-0.0269301888,
0.0218351297,
-0.0199848302,
0.0084671248,
-0.0205865391,
-0.0168436021,
0.0327167474,
-0.0674544126,
-0.0293106623,
0.0125032058,
2.499e-7,
-0.0031618276,
0.0273311287,
0.034503974,
0.0369866788,
0.0094791632,
0.0314290449,
-0.0001296661,
-0.0014272861,
0.0180595592,
-0.083290711,
-0.0068666325,
0.0508124903,
0.0427862443,
-0.0062880865,
-0.0348204784,
0.0170991477,
-0.0225515515,
0.0200025868,
-0.0515507869,
-0.0509023182,
0.0268489569,
0.0399573743,
-0.0565190278,
-0.0326211117,
0.0332140401,
-0.0709339082,
0.0819773972,
-0.0280329268,
0.0222256519,
-0.0199506003,
0.0271305181,
0.0357656218,
-0.005915767,
0.068044208,
0.0093522677,
-0.0494045392,
0.0527317263,
-0.0124280062,
-0.0285428222,
-0.0167677291,
-0.0527142733,
0.0237020478,
-0.0027157727,
-0.055983007,
0.0704196841,
-0.0440968312,
-0.0134877143,
-0.0031579509,
-0.0102688186,
-0.0415192917,
0.0568006374,
-0.0269385464,
-0.0029271855,
0.0109744659,
0.0126886126,
0.009549683,
-0.0456465334,
-0.0470314138,
-0.0186739452,
-0.0142359482,
-0.0033286272,
-0.0509318449,
-0.0480349809,
0.0051882621,
0.0026544714,
-0.0441986956,
-0.0630797669,
2.488956382e-34,
-0.0072254171,
-0.0170994867,
0.0622561909,
0.0294123851,
0.0035184242,
-0.003624036,
0.0293140337,
-0.0046102162,
-0.0413118266,
-0.0448620357,
0.0067232456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14491v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14491v1 | Instruction Pre-Training: Language Models are Supervised Multitask Learners | 2024-06-20T16:55:33 | 2024-06-20T16:55:33 | Daixuan Cheng, Yuxian Gu, Shaohan Huang, Junyu Bi, Minlie Huang, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | Unsupervised multitask pre-training has been the critical method behind the
recent success of language models (LMs). However, supervised multitask learning
still holds significant promise, as scaling it in the post-training stage
trends towards better generalization. In this paper, we explore supervised
multitask pre-training by proposing Instruction Pre-Training, a framework that
scalably augments massive raw corpora with instruction-response pairs to
pre-train LMs. The instruction-response pairs are generated by an efficient
instruction synthesizer built on open-source models. In our experiments, we
synthesize 200M instruction-response pairs covering 40+ task categories to
verify the effectiveness of Instruction Pre-Training. In pre-training from
scratch, Instruction Pre-Training not only consistently enhances pre-trained
base models but also benefits more from further instruction tuning. In
continual pre-training, Instruction Pre-Training enables Llama3-8B to be
comparable to or even outperform Llama3-70B. Our model, code, and data are
available at https://github.com/microsoft/LMOps. | [
0.0223310925,
0.0490344651,
-0.0163421072,
0.0125333685,
0.0151291918,
0.0165199321,
0.0072034923,
-0.0355117172,
0.0183592308,
-0.066738151,
-0.0961036682,
-0.0611046888,
-0.0296836942,
-0.0073908227,
0.0295659769,
-0.0331754088,
0.0562688783,
-0.0439991243,
-0.0404584259,
-0.004254174,
-0.0046717497,
0.052503828,
-0.0251946412,
0.0329683237,
0.0291734058,
-0.0272281896,
-0.0072425148,
0.0046787425,
-0.0268055443,
-0.0203244872,
0.0537984967,
0.0486126393,
0.0554501824,
0.0049790516,
0.0000020988,
-0.0466274358,
0.0007162518,
-0.0376633964,
-0.0022974794,
0.0231345855,
0.059868142,
0.0077528087,
-0.007214657,
0.0441217236,
-0.0317470282,
-0.0265965872,
0.0307649206,
-0.0098387189,
0.0637011379,
0.0800326318,
0.0077837449,
-0.0165577997,
0.0387175418,
-0.0286724046,
0.0049643316,
-0.0027172905,
-0.0008514602,
0.0034424923,
0.0060358094,
0.0106862569,
-0.0291627459,
0.0055559627,
0.0210096277,
0.0325788185,
-0.0150809754,
0.0353322178,
0.0153201325,
-0.024451552,
-0.0312367436,
0.0798922405,
-0.0451168008,
-0.0140535524,
-0.0049353777,
-0.0002431159,
-0.0252107866,
-0.0118739149,
-0.0385515019,
0.024995517,
0.0083207982,
0.0309114698,
0.042426642,
-0.0397191793,
0.0218337141,
0.006898053,
0.0107344557,
0.0413480364,
-0.0112427864,
-0.0237270966,
0.0248828866,
0.0370482281,
-0.0046662451,
-0.0346593149,
-0.0086114723,
0.0412150063,
-0.0447661579,
0.0284851342,
-0.06654834,
-0.0299590472,
0.0295680072,
-0.0452534817,
0.1053900048,
0.0403195955,
-0.0422799811,
0.009915824,
-0.036273919,
0.0154088279,
-0.0133453496,
0.0413922146,
-0.0701350793,
-0.0010084616,
-0.0829004794,
0.0145079372,
-0.0363011397,
0.03191429,
-0.0424066558,
-0.001936527,
-0.0295608733,
0.0443287306,
-0.0091675781,
-0.0381339863,
0.0431330353,
-0.0094191674,
-0.0558994636,
0.0107754143,
-0.0319780335,
0.0060265358,
-0.0202859677,
0.0759627149,
-0.0060693156,
-0.0620608293,
-0.0123125724,
0.0086577758,
-0.0180165898,
-0.0162352696,
0.0584715381,
0.0618148334,
-0.0441270322,
-0.0405013748,
-0.0596402511,
-0.0142279305,
0.0109591223,
-0.0673446134,
0.0257006492,
-0.0653857887,
0.0550468788,
-0.0125550795,
0.0172807053,
0.0051231408,
0.0127474265,
0.0254154485,
-0.0308926981,
0.0579873696,
-0.0078768972,
0.0227985419,
0.0258831158,
0.0049128253,
0.0175141413,
0.1075452194,
0.0361457616,
-0.0060071265,
0.0366788544,
-0.0203511789,
-0.0169595517,
0.0470983423,
0.0118554765,
0.0112392632,
0.0347240344,
0.0054337387,
-0.0033014915,
-0.0095197074,
0.0766436085,
0.0169820283,
-0.0157672465,
0.022058649,
0.0255756862,
0.0251573827,
0.0071258075,
0.0043910043,
0.0957963467,
0.0139623145,
0.0059081945,
0.0235558003,
-0.0613040924,
0.0166469682,
0.0053855111,
0.0094818641,
0.0197171737,
0.0397304893,
-0.056414485,
-0.0342138819,
0.0123537919,
-0.0411388949,
0.0060126837,
0.0175294839,
0.0536913611,
0.0210822485,
-0.0724437907,
0.0323212333,
0.0559037328,
-0.0297511723,
0.0193904173,
-0.0603914708,
0.0198602602,
0.0975102931,
0.0043388354,
-0.035990905,
-0.0488816649,
-0.0165025741,
0.0487671681,
0.0123072611,
0.0225804076,
-0.0306935944,
0.0506190136,
-0.0787959024,
-0.0147570521,
-0.0244652927,
0.0331545435,
0.0233042669,
0.0326483734,
-0.0222076662,
0.0145791667,
-0.0190441143,
-0.0362627842,
0.0397204608,
-0.0496934503,
-0.0420365483,
0.0008851684,
-0.0134315845,
0.0264564306,
0.0045074238,
-0.0162425041,
0.0059089856,
0.0563457869,
-0.0526815988,
0.0186015125,
-0.0015822002,
-0.0698223487,
-0.0102562876,
0.0248166882,
0.0099123511,
-0.0171539765,
0.0624309145,
-0.0460182056,
-0.0496639721,
0.0176849477,
0.0140975183,
0.0364168435,
-0.0432462506,
0.0104821892,
0.0099392189,
0.0210082624,
-0.0202166177,
0.0142581388,
-0.01197147,
0.0210185703,
-0.0087536173,
0.0069725388,
-0.0126662515,
-0.0163581017,
-0.0066837585,
-0.0129815796,
-0.0149649391,
0.0483877175,
-0.0359992608,
0.0443163216,
-0.0478810444,
-0.0473843664,
-0.1000824049,
0.0309151635,
-0.0285918228,
0.0449142307,
0.0377400629,
-0.001144102,
-0.0040410603,
-0.0192632768,
-0.0013772798,
-0.0095514227,
-0.0006050371,
0.0386197008,
-0.0019506695,
-0.004455965,
-0.0035467967,
-0.0477830172,
-0.0230769664,
-0.008848777,
-0.0079756584,
-0.0283007175,
0.0242402591,
-0.0414816625,
-0.0060766214,
0.0180202629,
0.0377658121,
-0.002772748,
-0.0263128355,
0.0116516836,
-0.0235844757,
0.0605397299,
0.0479198433,
-0.013638434,
0.0143801179,
0.0732095912,
0.0116443653,
-0.0548217855,
0.0308790188,
-0.014296324,
-0.0556099191,
-0.0479473099,
-0.0323402509,
-0.0164548978,
0.10526409,
-0.0126826102,
-0.0203988552,
-0.0535351112,
-0.0488523357,
-0.0269991811,
-0.0217236187,
-0.0107703041,
0.0160734132,
-0.0278873034,
-0.0067545478,
-0.0297565609,
-0.064693734,
0.0423593186,
-0.0268948935,
-0.0229549464,
-0.067613095,
-0.0247479696,
-0.0347322449,
0.0357295312,
-0.0170135032,
-0.0011290832,
-0.0052197138,
-0.0157672931,
-0.0740766749,
0.0253210962,
0.000461402,
-0.0070407968,
0.0539695658,
-0.0635559335,
-0.0072038956,
-0.0276317149,
-0.0191983506,
-0.0330902115,
-0.0250390489,
-0.0166895185,
0.0319949612,
0.0092973216,
0.0083831111,
-0.0203844775,
-0.0441191494,
0.0017619407,
0.0450080484,
0.0089914249,
0.0044948608,
-0.0290646814,
0.0111954287,
0.0441278704,
0.0054735271,
-0.0414649248,
-0.0697883368,
-0.0267189927,
0.0176666081,
0.0773376077,
-0.0297507383,
-0.0067177601,
0.0236771144,
0.0557671562,
-0.0145950848,
-0.0018371209,
0.0357308276,
0.0517569259,
-0.0310779307,
0.0033384801,
0.1088103652,
0.027316628,
-0.0463996418,
0.0236722138,
0.0121204583,
0.0150184743,
0.0521867275,
0.0397065207,
-0.0632115975,
-0.0293651,
-0.0202868655,
0.0268757381,
0.0255611427,
-0.0033021984,
-0.0199141316,
-0.1183761433,
-0.0017995656,
-0.0041943602,
-0.0378302149,
0.0248961486,
-0.0412582718,
-0.0213330872,
-0.0026823725,
-0.0059139552,
-0.0050346246,
-0.0352660716,
0.0079680029,
0.0587194152,
0.0109384367,
-0.0640530065,
0.0469027795,
-0.035058286,
0.0728400499,
0.0493084304,
-0.0060721594,
-0.0099274553,
-0.0286499485,
0.0390309691,
-0.0314697102,
-0.0026955809,
-0.0155881969,
0.0331157111,
-0.0248038881,
0.0055896454,
0.0196254663,
0.0369178578,
-0.044051744,
-0.0121998163,
0.0179755446,
0.0638606921,
0.0046135816,
-0.0098899575,
-0.0135877654,
-0.0188761763,
0.0285580233,
0.0525001287,
-0.0013865569,
-0.0669882819,
-0.0050268541,
-0.0230214056,
-0.0328588672,
-0.0939965993,
-0.0041899104,
0.0188790224,
-0.0483244322,
0.0039222501,
-0.0615386516,
-0.0337179527,
0.0486535355,
0.0197330527,
0.0153855933,
-0.003470843,
0.0116889775,
-0.0161098838,
-0.0713142753,
0.041254051,
-0.0157900751,
0.0324394479,
-0.084301278,
-0.0840305239,
0.0312562101,
-0.0128020747,
-0.0212235861,
0.0144478306,
-0.0960038751,
-0.0553711131,
-0.0061359,
0.0837830082,
0.0124466857,
0.0392539166,
-0.0006775797,
-0.0317294858,
0.0094379159,
0.0065820795,
-0.0602939129,
0.0295770802,
0.0504965149,
-0.0139539763,
0.011354411,
0.0167433079,
-0.0523655303,
0.0523407906,
0.0169960093,
0.0116818082,
-0.0085279373,
0.002184323,
-0.0036757952,
-0.0103597604,
0.045510564,
-0.0277269017,
0.0257738754,
-0.0662918016,
0.0287256446,
0.0064780386,
0.0144022312,
-0.0494943857,
0.0060348371,
0.0431163236,
-0.0397921279,
0.0173737071,
0.0229254309,
-0.0076376288,
0.0445444174,
-0.024070004,
0.0171926003,
0.0092836525,
0.0243737996,
0.0203496348,
0.0302647334,
-0.0222658273,
-0.0136967916,
0.0051124156,
0.0309787802,
-0.0205447748,
0.0243442561,
-0.024378065,
0.0108176786,
-0.0308340434,
0.0486706868,
-0.0442831889,
-0.0284700133,
-0.0477945991,
0.0217534322,
0.0540104471,
-0.0225359127,
0.0587406829,
-0.0065219263,
0.0205170549,
-0.0257002506,
0.0410488583,
-0.0161040276,
-0.0158177838,
0.0227167625,
0.0156369098,
-0.0142547172,
0.0033312996,
0.1210489944,
0.0152392015,
0.0638934821,
0.01298308,
0.0365574621,
-0.0439911895,
-0.038244918,
0.0177802369,
0.0525637791,
-0.0327237435,
0.0075512249,
0.0050030849,
-0.0521938987,
-0.00395075,
0.0029230588,
-0.0125516709,
-0.0142219802,
0.0491808727,
0.0457502417,
-0.0238282792,
0.0115897143,
-0.0632978007,
-0.0304164458,
0.0114544025,
-0.0150995087,
0.0017006224,
-6.678017937e-33,
-0.0234806277,
0.0226906668,
0.0396462493,
-0.0128045762,
0.0117238928,
-0.0023168777,
-0.009984768,
-0.0010418005,
-0.030595256,
-0.0296737272,
0.0098449737,
-0.0030328808,
0.0230392683,
0.0265082587,
0.0372609012,
0.0147600491,
0.0538768768,
-0.0221507363,
0.0135210436,
0.0273102242,
0.0289927386,
0.0307387114,
0.072342813,
-0.0404148884,
0.0005350089,
-0.0007478826,
0.0096836286,
-0.003059075,
-0.0118428487,
0.073591873,
-0.0224272888,
0.0674366876,
0.0202301722,
-0.0216792878,
-0.0395256169,
0.017099319,
-0.068174541,
-0.0272117648,
0.0416383222,
-0.0117493616,
-0.0478584655,
-0.0339644887,
0.0100500481,
0.0196467806,
-0.0016715209,
-0.0080875391,
0.0440976135,
-0.0069972761,
-0.0068578203,
-0.0006965066,
-0.0556163825,
-0.0222132187,
0.016454298,
-0.0559620187,
0.0104342317,
0.065224573,
0.007576955,
-0.0087942202,
-0.0459495075,
0.0236919299,
-0.0042295083,
0.0374321006,
0.0726689324,
0.0385844223,
0.0118858237,
0.0331998058,
-0.0050333766,
0.0148880407,
-0.0009446722,
0.0215759967,
0.0523832254,
0.0603790395,
-0.0202374887,
0.0252479501,
0.0218920764,
-0.0180292707,
-0.0668963492,
0.03056488,
0.0369823538,
0.0214412585,
0.0312577747,
0.0043690479,
-0.0063755554,
-0.02590473,
-0.0342531279,
0.0107743014,
-0.0253846366,
-0.0286061093,
0.0435029678,
0.0462244898,
-0.0072740139,
0.0097512715,
0.0433186069,
-0.0445333458,
-0.0103736427,
-0.0252941549,
-0.0365534797,
0.018995421,
-0.0018251978,
0.0102437362,
-0.0796008408,
-0.0819806755,
0.0287558362,
-0.013941057,
0.0214878637,
0.035026107,
0.0433062017,
0.0309325978,
-0.0778318197,
0.0046663284,
-0.0520782396,
0.0264543071,
0.035046231,
0.0555514358,
0.0363879502,
0.0178835634,
-0.034321744,
0.0782741755,
-0.0017253362,
-0.0384317115,
-0.0149194896,
-0.0416304544,
-0.0045499522,
0.0537139028,
-0.0195944291,
0.0181421638,
-0.0520381816,
-0.0384240709,
0.0047992212,
-0.0498776697,
-0.022297224,
0.0060616857,
2.652e-7,
0.0271239299,
0.0395502113,
-0.0078191441,
0.0233726613,
0.0010900811,
0.0127467848,
-0.0290862173,
0.0669777021,
0.0036631238,
-0.0014070605,
-0.0268263724,
0.0368589945,
0.0487066843,
0.0248875227,
-0.0815565735,
-0.0239951629,
-0.021285655,
0.0611655824,
-0.0585709885,
-0.0007084332,
0.014258015,
0.0954432338,
-0.0095930248,
-0.0135450847,
-0.0034464106,
-0.0069781812,
0.0629128069,
-0.0301728621,
-0.0217853524,
0.0266297795,
-0.0227038674,
0.0535350591,
-0.0144655919,
0.0078622252,
-0.0531277917,
0.0027194738,
-0.0178842042,
0.101108551,
-0.0002018252,
-0.0341538414,
0.030374147,
-0.0142744863,
-0.0356700756,
-0.0223300364,
0.0682083145,
-0.0350026712,
-0.003722549,
-0.0104856594,
-0.0021141495,
0.0237300154,
-0.010125027,
-0.0389118455,
-0.0108477287,
0.0054305061,
0.0121721793,
-0.0325625017,
-0.0329589136,
-0.0610800907,
-0.0181514546,
0.0279639103,
-0.022739118,
-0.040695373,
-0.0284624957,
-0.0264370125,
0.0191224217,
-0.0624369197,
0.0068388144,
2.219684376e-34,
0.020860007,
-0.010145166,
0.058215484,
0.0515965372,
-0.0217143521,
-0.0352600627,
-0.0320073664,
0.0154865459,
0.0066731554,
-0.0758476853,
-0.0220951084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14479v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14479v1 | On Layer-wise Representation Similarity: Application for Multi-Exit Models with a Single Classifier | 2024-06-20T16:41:09 | 2024-06-20T16:41:09 | Jiachen Jiang, Jinxin Zhou, Zhihui Zhu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Analyzing the similarity of internal representations within and across
different models has been an important technique for understanding the behavior
of deep neural networks. Most existing methods for analyzing the similarity
between representations of high dimensions, such as those based on Canonical
Correlation Analysis (CCA) and widely used Centered Kernel Alignment (CKA),
rely on statistical properties of the representations for a set of data points.
In this paper, we focus on transformer models and study the similarity of
representations between the hidden layers of individual transformers. In this
context, we show that a simple sample-wise cosine similarity metric is capable
of capturing the similarity and aligns with the complicated CKA. Our
experimental results on common transformers reveal that representations across
layers are positively correlated, albeit the similarity decreases when layers
are far apart. We then propose an aligned training approach to enhance the
similarity between internal representations, with trained models that enjoy the
following properties: (1) the last-layer classifier can be directly applied
right after any hidden layers, yielding intermediate layer accuracies much
higher than those under standard training, (2) the layer-wise accuracies
monotonically increase and reveal the minimal depth needed for the given task,
(3) when served as multi-exit models, they achieve on-par performance with
standard multi-exit architectures which consist of additional classifiers
designed for early exiting in shallow layers. To our knowledge, our work is the
first to show that one common classifier is sufficient for multi-exit models.
We conduct experiments on both vision and NLP tasks to demonstrate the
performance of the proposed aligned training. | [
-0.0235678051,
0.0480922982,
0.0126133189,
0.0372726917,
-0.0249458589,
0.003826593,
0.0292680357,
-0.0465855561,
-0.0159872007,
-0.0052085263,
-0.0783021823,
0.0024100328,
0.0157915987,
-0.0347652137,
0.0027600985,
-0.035950616,
-0.0001761041,
0.0559036061,
-0.0858103037,
-0.0182487164,
0.0004579374,
-0.0275488589,
0.009874207,
0.056273371,
-0.0133565059,
-0.0484969653,
-0.0063258191,
-0.0009796177,
0.0630500093,
-0.005500359,
0.0373220704,
0.002927609,
0.0241176467,
0.050368771,
0.0000021227,
-0.0145748761,
-0.0321883745,
0.0135601405,
-0.0119764162,
-0.0199598148,
-0.035920579,
-0.038449809,
0.0152580021,
-0.0240723602,
-0.0162515063,
-0.0185447354,
0.09544117,
0.1087945253,
0.0568244494,
0.0401623771,
-0.0222155638,
-0.0836879835,
0.034826532,
-0.0314161964,
-0.0408979692,
0.0001152806,
-0.003602322,
-0.0067433785,
-0.0675926581,
-0.039289929,
-0.023410175,
0.0390730537,
0.0412704162,
0.0114379125,
-0.0078668892,
0.0546808019,
-0.0297984816,
-0.0169970673,
0.0046658157,
0.0718848184,
-0.0607516319,
-0.0304236189,
0.0002485101,
-0.0100163836,
-0.0088067492,
-0.0048549799,
-0.0424848981,
-0.004205999,
0.0181085598,
0.0516330823,
-0.014205995,
0.0769844279,
0.034800142,
-0.0282380879,
-0.0258154813,
-0.0239344351,
0.0222718436,
-0.0227801837,
-0.0069143204,
0.022740528,
0.0045609684,
0.0138119636,
-0.0170892663,
-0.002461737,
0.023264084,
-0.0118476581,
-0.0398275144,
-0.0196713135,
0.0010083468,
-0.0718997642,
0.0778928995,
0.0595333986,
-0.0546666123,
0.0412242077,
-0.0624275357,
0.1085468531,
-0.0774778128,
0.075178802,
-0.0101844603,
0.0007758573,
-0.0590554066,
-0.0212545581,
0.0022431973,
0.0154169351,
0.0546744056,
-0.0366139673,
-0.0552690439,
0.0440024734,
-0.0278359409,
0.0326028764,
0.0172380432,
0.0578938462,
-0.0159948748,
0.0226927307,
0.0262687318,
0.0579049625,
-0.0159496609,
0.0046721348,
-0.0079675606,
-0.0258818939,
-0.0221507512,
0.0614404939,
0.0385145321,
-0.0171518642,
0.0356343873,
0.0673102662,
-0.0129110403,
-0.0133890677,
-0.0039862823,
0.0257598907,
-0.0145990672,
-0.0270613134,
0.0161924716,
-0.06562417,
0.0651604757,
0.0045854072,
-0.0068083555,
-0.0310846381,
-0.0125781158,
-0.0012256608,
0.0100426776,
0.058562737,
0.0714097098,
-0.006038235,
0.0440402031,
-0.0207895786,
-0.0110217584,
0.0359067619,
0.0236573182,
0.0038870932,
0.0132832043,
-0.0389323495,
-0.0017911025,
0.0409370214,
-0.0214646067,
-0.0432531163,
-0.0353672616,
-0.0171700846,
0.0119371936,
0.0553461388,
0.0423314646,
0.0250311289,
-0.0414103232,
-0.0735870749,
0.0404078811,
0.0449240543,
0.0525550656,
-0.0036704058,
0.0284025799,
-0.0098564401,
-0.0043364209,
0.0299848542,
-0.04885488,
0.0475832522,
0.0108506083,
0.0001774512,
-0.0201772805,
0.0272822827,
-0.0624152794,
-0.0112357074,
0.0182416849,
-0.0170862246,
-0.0482698604,
-0.0206049625,
0.0420810021,
-0.0153121278,
-0.0265783854,
0.0784700438,
-0.0023551132,
-0.0261561777,
-0.0107548721,
-0.0180906784,
-0.0338875987,
-0.0064610951,
-0.0107028987,
0.0067799259,
-0.0395380631,
0.0191959664,
-0.0199606996,
-0.0004220458,
0.0376104377,
0.0015872727,
0.002523016,
-0.0509538464,
-0.0513622724,
-0.0226048157,
0.0185357239,
0.0038899777,
-0.0144632105,
-0.0134603623,
0.0458471738,
-0.0297475103,
-0.0043892111,
0.0243115649,
-0.0206405837,
0.0226869639,
-0.0054932972,
0.0552666783,
0.0022944803,
0.0097294906,
-0.0144626973,
-0.0064014755,
0.0271526091,
-0.0455843918,
-0.0469132699,
0.049938757,
-0.0351747163,
-0.0030755042,
0.0207810644,
-0.0581062324,
-0.003267278,
0.0864439979,
-0.0360557213,
-0.0357020572,
0.026996877,
0.0087937461,
0.0314816721,
-0.0242484063,
0.0469628908,
-0.0074050361,
0.0394061096,
-0.0261600111,
0.0629905686,
-0.0054083313,
0.0250917599,
-0.0015402726,
-0.0342641249,
0.0356372409,
-0.011257234,
-0.0346093588,
-0.017255554,
-0.0195887182,
0.0375683382,
0.018909853,
-0.0328255221,
-0.0086616613,
-0.0461870469,
-0.041079428,
0.0129022254,
-0.0098821577,
0.0107570821,
0.0326777361,
0.0046010255,
0.0503131449,
-0.0100456607,
-0.0416676924,
0.0327476971,
0.0025183465,
-0.0183305778,
0.0102880811,
-0.0213589482,
-0.0546649471,
-0.0454863235,
-0.025997499,
-0.0083228713,
0.096396558,
-0.0135666495,
-0.01300414,
-0.0105781741,
-0.015737677,
0.0004068167,
0.0415289253,
-0.0226079021,
-0.0360541642,
0.0051031956,
-0.004696798,
-0.0245851018,
0.0744402409,
0.0251146834,
0.0261075087,
0.0277222283,
0.0421998799,
-0.0714575872,
-0.0036382077,
-0.0406678803,
0.0016766335,
-0.0541673452,
0.0072232517,
-0.0293489601,
0.036824435,
0.0030006885,
0.0237369891,
-0.0514274538,
-0.016560901,
0.0198405087,
0.0043784794,
-0.0011163099,
0.0064643384,
0.0034988774,
-0.0177319199,
-0.0374681465,
-0.0225929543,
0.0530720726,
-0.0293364394,
0.0053974525,
0.0309860241,
-0.0181345697,
-0.0378006846,
0.0646412224,
0.0197949316,
0.0291025937,
0.0059610065,
-0.0199754462,
-0.0703750178,
0.0377070718,
0.0201231148,
-0.0163262617,
0.0686277747,
0.0224080905,
0.0006790818,
-0.0228923168,
-0.0502882637,
-0.0795710459,
0.0104487389,
-0.0206717048,
0.0327350087,
-0.0348668806,
-0.0216196105,
-0.1115646064,
0.0023917912,
0.0008115258,
0.0491233505,
0.0118107218,
0.0083725015,
-0.0273918714,
0.0296268519,
0.0344147906,
0.0574030057,
-0.0070277187,
-0.0340097249,
0.061265137,
0.0455878302,
-0.0109668327,
0.0350756608,
-0.0849605054,
-0.0061801877,
0.0197188575,
-0.0162795391,
-0.0315318592,
-0.0170236081,
0.0072013573,
-0.0254200939,
0.0174666159,
0.0806211233,
-0.0195355676,
-0.07588882,
0.0036384184,
0.0089075863,
-0.0072568636,
0.0388065763,
0.0113913687,
-0.0187107176,
-0.0278914291,
-0.0283751506,
0.0046753492,
0.0311335213,
0.0137263257,
0.0225658249,
-0.0672425181,
-0.0160034522,
-0.0279373787,
-0.0237200372,
-0.0372072496,
-0.0272411183,
0.0423141159,
-0.0244168732,
-0.0016921886,
-0.0577519014,
0.0076652267,
-0.0572378933,
0.0381767452,
-0.0208964553,
-0.0397488512,
-0.0031821942,
-0.051310312,
-0.0104410332,
0.0543049127,
-0.013056078,
-0.0239698254,
-0.0464670844,
-0.0159483142,
-0.0335558504,
0.0336080231,
0.0509651899,
0.0454070531,
-0.0043564704,
-0.0451918282,
0.0170341432,
0.0153960716,
-0.0377831906,
0.0176575053,
-0.0483487286,
0.0702821612,
-0.0249271337,
-0.0385637879,
-0.0223867446,
0.011305823,
-0.0551492088,
0.0535777695,
0.0079260115,
-0.0261461288,
-0.0267925076,
0.0296884254,
0.022691438,
-0.0059897508,
-0.0192415137,
0.0257940274,
0.0324939266,
-0.0478746444,
-0.0217180718,
0.0073050065,
-0.02343118,
0.0205982886,
-0.0182857662,
-0.0815035403,
-0.0035791765,
-0.0156019107,
-0.066818431,
0.0167646986,
0.0256591085,
0.0075061102,
-0.0427512936,
0.0454529002,
0.0673560351,
-0.0357205421,
-0.042250894,
-0.0203012042,
-0.0902227163,
-0.0597009175,
0.0001689389,
0.0171538498,
0.0031465436,
0.0600606166,
-0.0034405424,
-0.0224630367,
0.0349490866,
0.0468007587,
-0.0020093236,
0.022458965,
0.0362146758,
-0.0830494836,
-0.0123962965,
0.0214302484,
-0.052791439,
0.0487032458,
0.0402306542,
0.0190159753,
-0.0352649577,
-0.0289758444,
0.033682473,
-0.0583900884,
0.0593061112,
0.0339036956,
0.0231773686,
-0.0248553995,
-0.0026228304,
0.012445583,
-0.0433534831,
-0.0101003936,
-0.0195659995,
0.0234224144,
0.0504090451,
0.013316852,
0.0341276862,
0.0505201556,
0.0244054943,
-0.0474395156,
-0.0142519055,
0.0133780362,
0.0036174688,
-0.0365631692,
0.0283536576,
-0.0330907479,
0.0045770821,
0.0217980836,
-0.0081901597,
-0.0161999352,
0.0132691078,
0.0400605835,
0.0590810515,
-0.0551872328,
0.021665521,
-0.0931510106,
-0.0296157636,
-0.0463056415,
-0.0256422609,
0.0416161194,
-0.0195345469,
0.018042475,
-0.0008438441,
-0.0029274765,
-0.0190852303,
0.0130723305,
0.0009970424,
-0.0285633709,
0.0376713388,
0.0144610563,
0.0313312896,
-0.0335402563,
0.037267942,
-0.0646244362,
0.0436757691,
-0.0814751238,
0.0108724451,
-0.0326265134,
-0.0121609448,
0.0310667604,
0.0156891812,
-0.0033947139,
-0.0260841902,
0.0012008469,
-0.0476659834,
0.0640131608,
-0.0197894238,
0.0241653807,
0.0336450785,
0.0341512896,
0.0517018624,
0.0091155134,
-0.0231727269,
0.0308798999,
-0.0430993252,
0.0157301519,
-0.0284266695,
-0.0148800835,
-6.430158341e-33,
0.0211145617,
0.0180261489,
0.0038690064,
0.0203164034,
-0.0330233201,
0.0270192213,
-0.0087122759,
0.0057667936,
-0.0492832027,
0.0111471098,
0.0143268658,
0.0234595332,
0.0052007474,
0.0087170107,
0.0129254339,
-0.0294244327,
0.0695269331,
0.0082646832,
0.0017896639,
-0.0001298193,
0.035141442,
0.0117532061,
0.0841234773,
-0.0589224286,
-0.042598255,
-0.0025140729,
-0.0006302109,
0.0005689912,
0.0296529122,
0.0736761019,
-0.0401512757,
0.0149329398,
0.0246782042,
-0.0348724648,
0.0192365348,
-0.0227195155,
-0.0475525521,
-0.0133430483,
-0.0746805295,
0.040200863,
-0.0405004211,
-0.0122071113,
0.0793495551,
-0.0177696422,
-0.0277577788,
-0.0557248332,
0.0846262872,
0.0195954796,
0.0205587205,
-0.0125602102,
-0.0382827669,
0.0143784601,
-0.0326786935,
-0.021154616,
0.0048858486,
0.0881926864,
0.0262106042,
0.0497220121,
-0.0887475908,
0.009844467,
-0.0556482747,
-0.0045535029,
0.0626629516,
0.0307252426,
0.0019669582,
0.0729943514,
0.0250850227,
-0.0498895161,
-0.0428491309,
-0.0442361757,
0.0379004814,
0.0458201654,
0.031597659,
0.0384642631,
0.0490673296,
-0.001703657,
-0.0551939197,
0.0329775214,
-0.0366528779,
0.0326057896,
0.0277729854,
-0.0058039329,
-0.0210777391,
0.000860722,
-0.0409980342,
-0.0182238799,
-0.0465530008,
-0.0123117026,
0.0382387936,
0.0076981336,
-0.0064443606,
0.0273837447,
0.0038159671,
-0.0595477633,
0.0380288959,
0.0214490052,
0.0065863477,
0.045871336,
0.0094292425,
-0.0100111254,
-0.0049292571,
-0.054367587,
-0.0119948378,
0.0045044227,
0.0576034039,
0.0002130609,
0.0520590693,
0.0199784636,
-0.0351799503,
-0.0204509851,
-0.0091468226,
-0.0487576909,
-0.0121026952,
0.0098927738,
0.0213614088,
0.0130728893,
-0.0265660193,
0.0255866349,
0.0065993634,
0.0442836322,
-0.0108779836,
-0.0291335564,
0.0535766408,
0.0399417803,
0.0037559532,
-0.006763069,
-0.0395909883,
-0.0302761514,
0.0093474062,
-0.0715959445,
-0.0116248159,
0.0193740651,
2.864e-7,
0.020415945,
-0.0342152864,
0.0347301625,
-0.0132543286,
0.0147396661,
0.0183776412,
0.0215811767,
0.0564238802,
-0.0362548158,
-0.0191060677,
0.0157244075,
0.0162146315,
0.0284593999,
-0.0133330515,
-0.0396544263,
0.0185597725,
-0.0644920766,
0.0134390909,
-0.0064719203,
0.004266764,
0.0535339415,
0.0964867994,
-0.0018791425,
-0.012899979,
-0.0095193619,
0.0298772659,
0.0822921246,
-0.0020315226,
0.0641731918,
0.0073828204,
0.0189877432,
-0.0299944393,
0.0004434095,
0.030920824,
0.0019347469,
0.0504407696,
0.0526928604,
0.0015184061,
-0.0118020112,
-0.0365125351,
0.0030254088,
0.0500042774,
-0.0056005516,
-0.0608372577,
0.0401924103,
-0.0792945549,
-0.0269730389,
-0.0681793243,
-0.0436740108,
0.0366574638,
0.0364581533,
0.0264405925,
0.0038925197,
0.0263100751,
0.0174340457,
-0.025506692,
-0.0206094403,
-0.0695091337,
-0.0200849827,
-0.0120204128,
-0.0431617834,
0.0117136864,
-0.0284316987,
-0.0726214647,
0.0800438151,
0.0346553475,
-0.0200352222,
2.268941721e-34,
-0.0019183302,
0.0188019611,
0.0219335202,
-0.0050392984,
-0.0216924399,
-0.0268346462,
-0.0105994102,
0.0000516511,
0.0074109943,
-0.0616066158,
-0.0135705573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14473v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14473v1 | Data-Centric AI in the Age of Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T16:34:07 | 2024-06-20T16:34:07 | Xinyi Xu, Zhaoxuan Wu, Rui Qiao, Arun Verma, Yao Shu, Jingtan Wang, Xinyuan Niu, Zhenfeng He, Jiangwei Chen, Zijian Zhou, Gregory Kang Ruey Lau, Hieu Dao, Lucas Agussurja, Rachael Hwee Ling Sim, Xiaoqiang Lin, Wenyang Hu, Zhongxiang Dai, Pang Wei Koh, Bryan Kian Hsiang Low | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | This position paper proposes a data-centric viewpoint of AI research,
focusing on large language models (LLMs). We start by making the key
observation that data is instrumental in the developmental (e.g., pretraining
and fine-tuning) and inferential stages (e.g., in-context learning) of LLMs,
and yet it receives disproportionally low attention from the research
community. We identify four specific scenarios centered around data, covering
data-centric benchmarks and data curation, data attribution, knowledge
transfer, and inference contextualization. In each scenario, we underscore the
importance of data, highlight promising research directions, and articulate the
potential impacts on the research community and, where applicable, the society
as a whole. For instance, we advocate for a suite of data-centric benchmarks
tailored to the scale and complexity of data for LLMs. These benchmarks can be
used to develop new data curation methods and document research efforts and
results, which can help promote openness and transparency in AI and LLM
research. | [
0.0143548362,
0.1058188975,
-0.0450353175,
0.0517034605,
-0.0532319769,
0.0260669664,
-0.0058944374,
-0.0191697795,
-0.0349285491,
-0.0296173338,
-0.0610896759,
-0.0381750651,
0.0014404355,
0.0195434,
0.023028193,
0.0029373649,
-0.0019316376,
-0.0464972109,
0.0006240858,
-0.0144768972,
-0.0190510601,
-0.0000630297,
0.0175760332,
0.0289587434,
-0.02633873,
0.0359086804,
-0.0061942372,
0.0065934877,
-0.013440555,
-0.0381128155,
-0.0124867931,
0.0349748433,
0.0399727821,
0.0608834475,
0.0000019104,
-0.064524062,
0.0071868468,
0.0105346506,
-0.0673510432,
-0.005773664,
0.0211230218,
-0.0449943095,
0.007701451,
-0.0060779215,
-0.0415656492,
-0.0098847831,
0.0618783608,
-0.0224530268,
0.0171241555,
0.079080157,
-0.0127614671,
-0.046654243,
0.0684315711,
-0.0324218385,
-0.0073785409,
-0.0187917128,
0.0460375808,
0.0239590295,
0.0015135491,
-0.0151357697,
-0.0178283826,
0.0478806943,
0.0249912646,
0.0138861639,
-0.0344785638,
0.0290103629,
-0.0429938883,
-0.0159786921,
-0.0005642397,
0.0946718901,
0.0193813983,
-0.0358014666,
0.0117612071,
0.0023844717,
-0.0197635274,
-0.0120281689,
-0.0510079525,
0.0697445124,
0.010396258,
0.03200645,
0.0550291799,
-0.0052900994,
0.0858579203,
0.0108401049,
-0.0615033694,
0.0685105771,
-0.0140416631,
-0.0371128805,
0.0219909474,
0.013174748,
-0.0253489856,
-0.059643764,
-0.0138606895,
0.0312555172,
-0.0030622783,
0.0294919293,
-0.0586151779,
-0.0341936462,
0.0009384077,
-0.0077799093,
0.0471546501,
0.0163544733,
-0.0235889945,
0.0525873676,
0.0125839943,
0.025750991,
0.0054389201,
0.0215425324,
-0.0350693166,
-0.0540491864,
-0.0192742236,
0.0108339246,
-0.0096459808,
0.0210625902,
0.0034063081,
-0.0011792716,
0.004489921,
0.0518726259,
-0.0345760956,
0.0246473532,
0.0105985403,
-0.0441513471,
-0.0269938987,
-0.0074506835,
-0.0066858279,
-0.0033158262,
-0.0088891936,
0.0588321798,
-0.0005789234,
-0.0867016464,
0.0117079196,
0.0134491296,
0.013964816,
-0.0465363786,
0.0363969691,
0.0658885464,
0.0165788829,
-0.0399600565,
-0.0279644933,
-0.0097764451,
0.0122416578,
-0.0844216868,
-0.0081204297,
-0.060932532,
0.0505296327,
0.0397015549,
-0.0104542505,
-0.0593560673,
-0.018455511,
-0.0101652285,
-0.0346076079,
0.0777315795,
-0.0146919265,
0.0420249626,
-0.0054623135,
-0.0082694218,
0.0024415345,
0.077769205,
0.0470444635,
0.0097960774,
0.0351255909,
0.0027981182,
0.0126390131,
0.0422955044,
0.0434470698,
0.0368303843,
-0.0490991212,
0.0305399206,
0.0008607818,
0.0062339129,
-0.0111144185,
0.0802181214,
-0.0259737484,
0.0199201871,
0.0839311182,
0.0720184818,
0.0006680284,
0.0137652019,
0.0181601923,
-0.0207910426,
0.0303095952,
-0.023531327,
-0.0603905655,
-0.0139732352,
-0.0024532794,
0.0047688293,
-0.0013984361,
0.0316232592,
-0.0252470747,
-0.0400871597,
-0.0290290713,
-0.0131713683,
0.0064420188,
0.0514792688,
0.0618781224,
-0.0017893974,
-0.0063486933,
-0.0116608907,
0.0324243419,
-0.0300322492,
0.0048109847,
-0.075490348,
0.0048269886,
0.0287625436,
0.0531031899,
-0.0527801961,
-0.0266798716,
0.0014093312,
0.0577264875,
-0.0084839622,
0.0321260169,
-0.0379491113,
0.0257936213,
-0.0195600521,
-0.0240996517,
-0.019463947,
0.0150987031,
0.0029523442,
-0.0018262315,
0.0137105342,
-0.0086426307,
-0.0265608169,
-0.0310955066,
0.0498989634,
-0.0558723174,
-0.0208997261,
-0.0090417862,
0.0004017556,
0.0421120264,
-0.0009628771,
-0.0447906107,
-0.0241379626,
0.0296019912,
-0.0229461286,
0.0303489193,
0.0199993923,
-0.0245296136,
-0.0057675019,
0.0313987583,
-0.0436291769,
-0.0067931334,
0.0182473417,
-0.0458742343,
-0.027806567,
0.0213617496,
-0.0073517561,
0.0410852768,
-0.0246537551,
0.0520819835,
-0.0468762405,
0.0261906218,
-0.0165885985,
0.0530137122,
-0.0219711121,
-0.0162277929,
0.0400855988,
0.0287707709,
0.0098697999,
-0.0339842327,
-0.0475572199,
0.0283666048,
-0.0057973401,
0.0178578477,
0.0225017406,
-0.0101440838,
-0.002793506,
0.0062371469,
-0.0904943123,
-0.0116951521,
-0.042240262,
0.0069656204,
0.0131770186,
0.0094148926,
-0.0146441599,
0.001015151,
-0.0141472705,
-0.0237783529,
0.0289800465,
0.0203953795,
0.0447980613,
0.0334052071,
-0.0202659406,
-0.06153813,
-0.0292947274,
-0.0072146244,
0.0410087146,
-0.009312111,
-0.0107670184,
-0.0468928516,
0.0347221754,
-0.0210838616,
0.0535378568,
-0.0507667288,
0.0066887946,
0.0200057533,
-0.036242038,
0.0079717152,
0.0751532987,
-0.0456304438,
0.0307596419,
0.0850025788,
-0.0167065151,
-0.0293568261,
-0.0025906088,
-0.0272742826,
-0.0122176018,
-0.0494907573,
-0.0228336304,
0.0308207832,
0.0458524488,
-0.0165953096,
-0.0169151742,
-0.0092764441,
0.0368572287,
-0.0178949777,
-0.0315202847,
-0.0472012945,
-0.0065027797,
0.0053149378,
0.0544061288,
-0.0371485166,
-0.0841304213,
0.0688439831,
-0.0271668863,
0.0292144455,
0.0047155772,
-0.0403316356,
-0.0510851629,
0.0694380105,
0.0073815188,
0.0063045505,
-0.0354561768,
0.0066097262,
-0.0620083436,
0.0161857121,
0.0208052285,
-0.026406236,
0.0720477775,
-0.0764440224,
0.0277337916,
-0.0027525465,
-0.0650221705,
-0.0361128263,
-0.019693343,
-0.0426087826,
0.023283191,
0.053705629,
-0.0367210507,
-0.017744666,
-0.0192444883,
0.0342373662,
0.0527420714,
0.0308308396,
-0.0027202948,
-0.0099909175,
-0.0179223586,
0.0460759513,
-0.0139374351,
0.0313045196,
-0.0333874151,
0.0238170847,
0.0177553762,
0.0469349064,
0.000761787,
-0.0192106143,
0.0020901086,
0.0421901979,
0.0095929364,
-0.0049009183,
0.0125745544,
0.0355192013,
-0.0368109792,
-0.0160040576,
0.1100228354,
-0.0066380301,
-0.0414306708,
0.0141641116,
0.0113618709,
0.0048815063,
0.0193617232,
0.0163716618,
-0.0888569131,
-0.0235968828,
0.0120183295,
0.021360768,
-0.0229014102,
-0.0488163903,
-0.032588765,
-0.103069365,
0.0190021787,
-0.0197160076,
-0.0494107269,
-0.0453705117,
-0.0439228527,
0.0084253205,
-0.0364985168,
0.0274714828,
-0.0122125885,
-0.0079519982,
-0.0270850528,
0.0147308186,
-0.0058916085,
-0.0885981917,
0.018715309,
-0.0446933024,
0.0761331618,
0.047132615,
0.0379008614,
-0.0179954674,
0.012366062,
0.0180519521,
0.0012316704,
-0.0116632506,
-0.0056844084,
0.0364373848,
-0.0072387801,
-0.0153424973,
0.0075225974,
0.0363984518,
-0.0465334468,
0.0058546416,
0.0004469261,
0.0722269937,
-0.0308210459,
-0.0117837936,
0.0072215423,
-0.0657071248,
0.0098141003,
0.0954538062,
0.0149530647,
-0.0444941781,
-0.0260501783,
-0.0009168946,
0.0037531543,
-0.0089245802,
-0.0030680324,
0.0085724536,
-0.0191027354,
0.0069870236,
-0.0423937067,
-0.04186913,
0.0290337652,
0.0254848432,
0.0367081426,
0.0076405518,
0.0085173817,
-0.0308689177,
-0.0399836488,
0.0204355679,
-0.0478370301,
0.0198290758,
-0.0484327264,
-0.0271804668,
0.011485694,
-0.030019775,
-0.0013374076,
0.0306112226,
-0.1116830707,
-0.0666928589,
0.0274170246,
0.0456926413,
0.0244468227,
0.0514962524,
0.0009852917,
-0.0785021409,
0.042962864,
0.0513118766,
-0.0144689986,
0.000016982,
0.0238035526,
-0.0132757984,
0.0151421539,
0.0457993858,
-0.0539663248,
0.0287798755,
0.0554122068,
0.0026752567,
-0.0329176597,
-0.0029692943,
0.01549525,
0.0212879647,
0.0348507203,
-0.0098071638,
-0.0346583016,
-0.0447440371,
-0.0012520453,
-0.017686002,
-0.0158532821,
-0.0534761436,
-0.0077869575,
0.021424802,
0.0368448682,
-0.0136065306,
0.0039032851,
0.0220740698,
0.0206642933,
-0.0827357396,
0.0189052038,
0.0147095229,
0.0419236459,
0.0579518862,
0.0144027369,
0.0001185631,
0.051191479,
0.0055718613,
0.0506318547,
-0.0041852128,
0.0190639906,
0.0293375887,
-0.01592209,
-0.0246948898,
0.0295008719,
-0.0885893404,
-0.0468957499,
-0.0109392134,
0.0146741066,
0.0660512894,
-0.0056222351,
0.0346131325,
-0.0439149067,
-0.00109706,
-0.0268595852,
0.0163711272,
0.013593439,
-0.0257382449,
0.0114746802,
0.0138479695,
-0.0420768335,
0.0555568859,
0.0712069795,
0.0158756338,
0.0799331963,
-0.0253421217,
0.0059398813,
0.0022170283,
-0.0261082556,
0.0158680212,
-0.0006546417,
-0.0290406737,
0.0006714463,
-0.038075503,
-0.1097131297,
-0.0178309698,
0.0059535909,
-0.0120736724,
-0.0217939708,
0.0228783656,
0.0452198125,
-0.0060968115,
-0.0109065985,
-0.0282627381,
-0.0010045957,
-0.0164916087,
-0.0330510065,
-0.0001191679,
-6.407160529e-33,
0.0218811817,
0.0268093031,
0.0234304294,
-0.0082564596,
-0.0134371361,
0.031079188,
-0.0325019509,
-0.0030923781,
-0.0610771552,
-0.0047016451,
-0.0334610268,
0.0241530947,
0.0045772144,
0.0264927056,
-0.0159437433,
-0.0322043113,
0.0385092013,
-0.015566973,
-0.012087293,
0.0222113468,
0.0153685622,
0.0074397051,
0.057370156,
-0.0759967119,
0.0228811614,
-0.0230232682,
-0.0157692377,
0.0477901436,
0.0084938258,
0.0463036597,
-0.0145184658,
0.0335084498,
0.0283253789,
-0.0142532354,
-0.0231530629,
-0.0162785742,
-0.0699036866,
-0.0129677961,
0.0089486567,
0.0186308231,
0.0052886559,
-0.0115557918,
0.0529774837,
-0.0214335769,
-0.013326236,
0.0229849163,
0.0106656151,
-0.026860632,
-0.0082817338,
-0.0221265461,
-0.0618609339,
0.0141557045,
-0.0262428112,
-0.0036912209,
0.0712261647,
0.015852198,
0.0077296756,
0.0195096564,
-0.076568611,
0.0263030659,
0.0312614404,
-0.0123303486,
0.1135515794,
0.0368809775,
0.0437506847,
0.0531908982,
0.0610187687,
0.0290133879,
-0.0144058391,
-0.0050518592,
0.0408550911,
0.0706214979,
-0.0116068069,
0.0317545459,
0.0063021947,
-0.014313505,
-0.0821005628,
-0.0227085762,
0.0293667987,
-0.0122627728,
0.0194267537,
-0.0087382402,
-0.075450629,
-0.0491089709,
-0.0634185895,
-0.0227347873,
-0.0217357017,
0.0226941295,
0.0293986779,
0.0146191837,
-0.0029417258,
0.0370513164,
0.0473915935,
-0.0883819982,
-0.0500297472,
0.0340338238,
-0.0043217251,
0.0266392957,
0.0082169762,
0.0011702459,
-0.0889459252,
-0.0538677014,
0.0022318005,
0.0246425103,
0.0259074494,
0.0058364454,
0.0372409672,
0.0617105812,
-0.0179505963,
-0.0104225287,
-0.0370586365,
0.0124886464,
0.0265527852,
-0.003964928,
0.0429108366,
0.0429446511,
0.0094765527,
0.0369769447,
0.0701793805,
-0.0012507966,
-0.0145193804,
-0.0190581623,
-0.0285719205,
-0.0171173085,
-0.0277547911,
-0.0386069231,
-0.0344077349,
-0.0036456515,
0.0613244697,
-0.0496312715,
-0.0064689992,
0.0060480447,
2.641e-7,
0.0411173441,
0.037826594,
-0.001880776,
0.0284267049,
0.0121216802,
0.0024061897,
-0.020085603,
0.0025247068,
-0.0030104304,
0.0176930949,
0.0273941271,
0.0517087057,
0.0619033463,
0.0319749229,
-0.0599507503,
-0.0152442763,
-0.054972358,
-0.0133662727,
-0.062466763,
0.0113214459,
-0.0086541874,
0.1056835651,
0.0131074572,
-0.0262571741,
-0.0158977639,
-0.0319318846,
0.0390385315,
-0.0884038359,
0.035373915,
0.0591365509,
0.0207473338,
0.0392967872,
-0.0060218265,
0.0144063486,
0.0069866464,
0.0354317985,
-0.0069512674,
0.0419312268,
0.0259412993,
-0.009529571,
-0.0056816293,
-0.0227834657,
-0.0114662386,
-0.0577227511,
0.0848786682,
-0.0447978415,
-0.0492377505,
-0.0309279766,
0.0352531299,
-0.045046743,
-0.0065404805,
-0.0164182857,
0.0257269908,
0.0088837268,
0.0215092283,
-0.0175783839,
-0.0270769093,
-0.0752254203,
-0.0005494908,
0.0014538339,
-0.0237237792,
-0.0536609925,
-0.0277819037,
-0.0144061847,
0.0282034297,
-0.0278860796,
0.0591820478,
2.286804644e-34,
0.0201496948,
-0.0358412564,
0.0110451141,
0.0024795444,
0.0268678162,
0.0003669682,
0.0112537164,
-0.0098517388,
0.0085514765,
-0.0897880569,
-0.0055017206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14464v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14464v1 | A Review of Common Online Speaker Diarization Methods | 2024-06-20T16:26:03 | 2024-06-20T16:26:03 | Roman Aperdannier, Sigurd Schacht, Alexander Piazza | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Speaker diarization provides the answer to the question "who spoke when?" for
an audio file. This information can be used to complete audio transcripts for
further processing steps. Most speaker diarization systems assume that the
audio file is available as a whole. However, there are scenarios in which the
speaker labels are needed immediately after the arrival of an audio segment.
Speaker diarization with a correspondingly low latency is referred to as online
speaker diarization. This paper provides an overview. First the history of
online speaker diarization is briefly presented. Next a taxonomy and datasets
for training and evaluation are given. In the sections that follow, online
diarization methods and systems are discussed in detail. This paper concludes
with the presentation of challenges that still need to be solved by future
research in the field of online speaker diarization. | [
-0.0194438789,
-0.0213798769,
0.0035638083,
-0.0083312467,
-0.0269694906,
0.0007179972,
0.0729614049,
-0.0244021975,
0.004835696,
-0.0125377318,
0.0076985387,
-0.0244118255,
0.0365581661,
-0.006105572,
-0.0300335679,
-0.0789836869,
0.015541506,
-0.0254581533,
0.0283220634,
0.0037713603,
0.0008726704,
-0.0215899125,
-0.0839799047,
-0.0048194332,
-0.0330744721,
0.0044305022,
0.0013950315,
-0.0079559619,
0.0321472511,
0.022586748,
0.0050918791,
0.028290119,
0.0078208148,
0.018837167,
0.0000014527,
-0.0144672934,
-0.0490260981,
-0.020771062,
-0.0319052599,
-0.0320623666,
-0.006649029,
0.0225962047,
-0.0192382205,
0.0493200645,
-0.0133248074,
-0.0250410829,
0.0165820867,
0.0048956326,
0.0231824126,
0.0246310774,
0.0139735704,
-0.0607735515,
0.0347317979,
0.0213920586,
-0.0042596189,
-0.0033612589,
0.009544393,
-0.0146512678,
-0.0423759706,
-0.0488327369,
0.0203192681,
0.0556686148,
-0.0259355288,
-0.0007635893,
0.0725009292,
-0.0199512858,
-0.0464162156,
-0.0192838684,
0.0122870496,
0.0229333043,
0.0373683535,
0.0286459401,
0.0619685277,
0.0427810028,
-0.0318173133,
-0.0176797863,
0.0219761897,
0.0202718414,
-0.0354177803,
-0.0591083467,
-0.074398227,
0.0624168329,
-0.0085629076,
-0.0169431083,
0.01102015,
0.0266963709,
-0.0286513623,
-0.0096791778,
-0.0445865244,
-0.034678109,
-0.0178221669,
0.0158904977,
0.066924125,
0.0052857869,
-0.0118169235,
-0.0148274628,
0.0116589004,
-0.0073698298,
-0.0550053231,
-0.035988193,
0.0186734274,
-0.0245192684,
0.0032256532,
0.0104331328,
-0.0162687916,
0.0339776054,
0.0231159665,
-0.0378839895,
0.0007704159,
-0.0030503019,
-0.0874504745,
0.0333068147,
-0.0362308659,
0.010168137,
0.0901853219,
-0.0094973408,
-0.0937522873,
-0.0116201462,
-0.0832783431,
-0.0158660244,
-0.021553712,
-0.0402976274,
0.0232011024,
0.0175638869,
-0.0052696131,
0.0508735478,
-0.0272941031,
0.0314170681,
-0.0766071677,
-0.0413402878,
0.0482397899,
0.0348078795,
0.0481050834,
0.0246913601,
0.0001179645,
-0.0074591106,
0.0016477946,
-0.0358643048,
0.04091594,
-0.0557169914,
-0.0123853702,
-0.002930301,
-0.0136663234,
-0.0620361902,
0.0427099392,
-0.0189633165,
0.0055115731,
0.0223143194,
-0.0281884205,
-0.0216034111,
0.0402525626,
0.0353198275,
-0.0057086814,
0.0692822859,
0.0793265253,
0.0051295585,
0.0125801284,
-0.0248418935,
0.0358204693,
-0.0538059846,
0.0596641973,
-0.0438340791,
0.0098059466,
0.0563731492,
-0.0263057351,
-0.0300203077,
-0.0150432028,
-0.0213524234,
-0.0145403324,
0.0463066101,
-0.0202486217,
-0.0024980148,
-0.0079888301,
-0.0003882322,
0.0297930427,
0.0540346652,
0.0171638783,
-0.0227603596,
0.0295271296,
0.0275878385,
-0.0026163745,
0.0214348249,
0.0237156097,
-0.0477968827,
-0.0156411566,
-0.0330785364,
0.0647598803,
-0.0009841055,
-0.0132136932,
-0.000947888,
0.0394904688,
-0.0510673411,
-0.0228630509,
0.021488186,
0.0063217436,
-0.0352189429,
0.0517001227,
0.0772471055,
-0.0106414426,
-0.0339097641,
0.0148351612,
-0.0133177442,
-0.0275770538,
0.0285381861,
0.0040622042,
-0.0232596248,
0.0243451856,
-0.0637779236,
0.0148132173,
-0.0187405031,
-0.0160264987,
-0.0516444333,
-0.0023533418,
-0.0251090135,
-0.0022899387,
0.0733238682,
-0.013793854,
0.0301212557,
0.0259611998,
-0.0084012272,
0.0593499281,
-0.0298495255,
0.0358901322,
-0.0164566506,
-0.0060486174,
-0.034696687,
0.0033767403,
0.0309008453,
0.0652663335,
0.0669451356,
0.0054658926,
-0.0438043997,
0.0150127672,
-0.021166604,
0.0317015126,
-0.0033730331,
-0.019824123,
0.0020631587,
0.0813666359,
-0.0265765823,
-0.0052809818,
0.0481713749,
-0.001322867,
-0.06386704,
0.0337005407,
-0.0195167065,
-0.0157502554,
-0.031364046,
0.0284975246,
-0.0114334337,
0.0015427694,
-0.0070307446,
0.0134092215,
0.0287379939,
0.0479414463,
-0.0128104929,
0.011415028,
0.0179493446,
-0.0643955395,
-0.0075382707,
-0.0306149982,
-0.0264506862,
0.0531063266,
-0.0247080307,
-0.0638178885,
-0.0179741923,
-0.003147979,
-0.036774464,
-0.0064284448,
-0.0057528177,
0.0057536876,
-0.0178047121,
-0.007603677,
0.0030204032,
-0.0193071384,
0.0087896287,
-0.016023377,
0.0015375386,
0.0092467703,
-0.0511476845,
0.0074861357,
-0.0982496217,
0.0360386856,
-0.0159856863,
-0.0031945435,
-0.0277423374,
0.0008748765,
-0.0332369804,
-0.0322774015,
-0.0527758971,
-0.026286019,
-0.0014578423,
0.0027971382,
0.0222647227,
-0.0129674794,
0.023090709,
0.0159516241,
0.0078381179,
0.0517568365,
-0.0067007304,
-0.0156927537,
0.0143910935,
0.007595039,
-0.0169219933,
0.018906856,
0.0406585634,
0.0019626082,
-0.0250217821,
-0.0030100006,
0.0073195104,
-0.0018988608,
0.018634269,
0.0192771573,
-0.0386119671,
-0.0438252054,
0.0025658803,
-0.032202553,
-0.0316165239,
-0.0336209834,
-0.0362262391,
0.0356182493,
-0.0028570062,
0.0005658333,
-0.0522308834,
0.0007706365,
-0.019090008,
-0.1049783602,
0.0014334949,
-0.0029381278,
0.0446088389,
0.0398241542,
0.0224957075,
-0.0432455875,
0.004804011,
-0.0328185968,
0.0751347467,
-0.0651425049,
-0.028469732,
0.0386714675,
0.0079883514,
-0.0168360695,
-0.0017888675,
0.0014220616,
-0.0244909842,
-0.0136618363,
0.0012754353,
0.0239000991,
-0.0379299596,
-0.0028823253,
0.0842669457,
0.0224464741,
-0.010282577,
-0.0189850722,
0.0360100456,
-0.0179603286,
0.1030215845,
-0.0560664013,
0.0358095095,
-0.022500582,
-0.0050165597,
0.0035211002,
-0.0192193445,
0.0413559973,
-0.0204116385,
0.0134161189,
-0.0373308845,
0.005955386,
-0.0188652482,
-0.0719050393,
0.0426976793,
0.0142406533,
0.0027199835,
0.0226650387,
0.129428342,
0.0442553498,
-0.0820619836,
-0.0611853823,
0.0221266448,
-0.0326918624,
0.0078689586,
-0.0081999991,
-0.0184650309,
-0.0013026085,
0.0451910011,
0.0807956383,
0.0019162903,
-0.0072267554,
-0.0079588406,
-0.0058140545,
0.021917237,
-0.0010820442,
-0.0028051869,
-0.010147593,
-0.0541865416,
-0.0078614149,
0.0177244917,
0.0100816367,
-0.0019172222,
-0.0111174071,
0.0033934261,
0.0538838878,
-0.1094673574,
-0.0116799418,
0.0306522623,
-0.0297113005,
0.076271303,
0.0205896031,
0.0346821845,
-0.0093762325,
-0.0343606882,
0.0303598642,
-0.0349462926,
-0.0172251873,
0.0115975374,
0.061219316,
0.0178159662,
0.0340141989,
-0.02295826,
-0.021737624,
0.0775243714,
-0.0142392321,
0.0232137628,
0.0170919448,
0.0164105445,
0.0126475878,
0.0291860122,
0.0784610286,
0.0348947458,
0.0301484074,
0.0103768576,
-0.0252547506,
-0.0129039502,
0.069457233,
0.0965274423,
0.0048893197,
-0.0073688249,
-0.0145669682,
-0.0255163107,
-0.0838827863,
-0.0202705115,
0.0119015211,
-0.0465939082,
0.0178596564,
-0.0145562394,
0.0251290444,
0.0339667052,
0.0512158237,
-0.0438407473,
0.0150852408,
-0.0208164938,
0.0676749274,
-0.0762646273,
-0.0185055286,
0.0605192222,
-0.0153256226,
0.0052091,
0.0314185545,
-0.0388622917,
-0.0007311595,
0.0488969274,
-0.0692195296,
0.0255802888,
0.0287903342,
-0.048738353,
-0.041321069,
0.0425284281,
-0.0053516706,
-0.0009969395,
0.0181230064,
0.0470750369,
0.0404867604,
-0.0562608764,
0.0231602415,
-0.0127774067,
0.0610193871,
-0.0339831039,
-0.0854607895,
-0.0913471654,
-0.0662963614,
-0.0650110841,
0.010630277,
0.0523885973,
0.0172364004,
-0.0238451846,
-0.0051201354,
0.007451863,
0.0195970032,
0.0219584126,
0.0262626037,
-0.0154751455,
0.0345081091,
0.0335678905,
-0.0089410571,
0.0631549209,
-0.0123608783,
-0.0400700606,
-0.0071332492,
0.0102626514,
0.0501214489,
-0.0285455603,
-0.0155619513,
0.0230700392,
-0.039423991,
0.0152215604,
0.0453408919,
0.0150964772,
-0.0039278651,
0.0162379984,
-0.0346644558,
0.0379228331,
-0.0082698883,
0.0152980946,
-0.0394249856,
-0.006880716,
-0.0050959149,
0.0011634085,
-0.0003227849,
0.0448382571,
0.0366243199,
0.0502521656,
0.003892232,
-0.0356609598,
0.040167138,
-0.0368844271,
-0.0466827452,
-0.0079861516,
0.0067828796,
-0.0141220484,
0.051946152,
0.0428580828,
0.0062403204,
-0.0264913402,
-0.0444010682,
-0.0184110496,
-0.0396879017,
0.0021025413,
-0.070631437,
-0.0044269743,
-0.0084567247,
-0.0539541245,
0.0239908863,
-0.023142701,
0.0348991565,
-0.0450138375,
0.0098838247,
0.0284342263,
-0.0325512365,
-0.0308919922,
-0.0323465355,
-0.0042893239,
-0.0094936118,
-0.0307873115,
0.0105259512,
-0.0034315898,
0.0353037454,
-4.670869047e-33,
-0.0469804034,
-0.0045556007,
-0.0452174209,
-0.0207858551,
-0.0102330875,
-0.0052143983,
0.025639493,
0.031942334,
0.0287438091,
-0.0550038218,
-0.0008445231,
0.0314864293,
0.0247840118,
0.030942589,
-0.0374488756,
-0.0261098463,
0.0682353452,
-0.0431035645,
0.0119082341,
0.050117135,
0.0537654273,
0.0108363023,
-0.0421111435,
-0.0800548196,
-0.0210702624,
-0.0256863758,
-0.0413152277,
0.011669592,
0.0134047912,
0.0102288695,
-0.0194953643,
0.0106570404,
0.0060740444,
0.0068051848,
-0.001589162,
0.0868130773,
-0.0663524717,
0.0178324785,
-0.0671616644,
0.0810173154,
0.0448134094,
-0.0076120608,
0.0002200531,
0.0130768716,
-0.027064465,
-0.0222059842,
0.0865030736,
-0.0171752647,
-0.0326848067,
-0.0329493992,
0.0687295645,
0.0312665813,
0.0016018003,
-0.0292803738,
0.0504779145,
0.0504204147,
0.0099158557,
-0.0609031171,
-0.0955589414,
0.052963689,
0.0164873097,
-0.0068075657,
0.0006281674,
0.0749935731,
-0.0305355228,
0.0111928815,
0.0753491968,
-0.0501790754,
0.0335355438,
-0.0400716476,
-0.0095609063,
-0.0127504794,
0.0476477444,
0.0044600884,
-0.0134920012,
-0.049729716,
-0.0153160598,
0.0115668094,
0.0660720766,
-0.0471239388,
0.0333226547,
0.008520307,
-0.0291945376,
-0.007083538,
-0.0178669002,
-0.0519110411,
0.0016072597,
-0.0113259675,
0.0104891406,
0.0032625524,
-0.016185306,
-0.053954903,
0.0342762843,
-0.0333531201,
-0.0172956791,
0.0024347289,
0.0115560042,
0.0799978897,
-0.0103214765,
-0.0300287213,
0.0014375424,
-0.054835692,
0.0691389367,
0.0030897881,
0.0216706805,
-0.070994705,
-0.0120447008,
0.0365327075,
-0.0394648761,
0.0140641797,
0.0686072633,
0.0354030505,
-0.0120427897,
0.0308710113,
0.0284770746,
-0.0135487672,
0.019619571,
0.0359382145,
0.0578782111,
0.0145162242,
0.0393756405,
-0.0284297988,
-0.0008906724,
0.0084013809,
-0.0466271788,
0.0428289808,
0.0010668464,
0.0130503159,
0.0141548766,
0.0010948974,
0.0229368396,
-0.0632653534,
2.231e-7,
-0.0287142582,
0.0100196218,
0.0295778513,
-0.0782180578,
0.0462820604,
0.0046477718,
0.0248294137,
-0.009195582,
0.0254375823,
-0.0131101478,
-0.0015519754,
-0.0519986004,
0.098696731,
0.0598403886,
-0.0760841146,
-0.0472216122,
-0.0355732366,
0.0598924495,
-0.0254116338,
0.0663713887,
0.0225983299,
0.0406466089,
0.0275570061,
-0.0115300827,
-0.0142518049,
-0.0484700091,
0.0010379785,
0.0035401259,
-0.0085345935,
-0.0242348034,
0.062464904,
-0.0356592201,
-0.012896168,
0.0662175938,
-0.0240964275,
0.0336302891,
0.0121791204,
0.0450859107,
0.0466736704,
-0.002089011,
-0.0763924867,
0.0198096987,
-0.0028487458,
0.0173627734,
0.0570005625,
0.0060644541,
-0.0387479402,
0.0030198288,
-0.0380076729,
-0.0299052633,
-0.020078389,
0.0270963181,
-0.0094188936,
0.0320290327,
-0.007914179,
-0.0244330913,
-0.0210824143,
-0.0525116995,
0.0041788924,
0.0617745034,
-0.0512125306,
-0.0544322282,
0.0235746056,
-0.0283769369,
0.0569659807,
0.0002624339,
0.0285946485,
1.285478148e-34,
-0.0276348405,
0.0423582494,
-0.0163327977,
-0.0402942412,
-0.0117231868,
-0.0413406454,
-0.0174221788,
0.0183758922,
0.0210413542,
-0.0216368344,
0.0172916632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14462v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14462v1 | Explicit and Implicit Large Language Model Personas Generate Opinions but Fail to Replicate Deeper Perceptions and Biases | 2024-06-20T16:24:07 | 2024-06-20T16:24:07 | Salvatore Giorgi, Tingting Liu, Ankit Aich, Kelsey Isman, Garrick Sherman, Zachary Fried, João Sedoc, Lyle H. Ungar, Brenda Curtis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being used in human-centered
social scientific tasks, such as data annotation, synthetic data creation, and
engaging in dialog. However, these tasks are highly subjective and dependent on
human factors, such as one's environment, attitudes, beliefs, and lived
experiences. Thus, employing LLMs (which do not have such human factors) in
these tasks may result in a lack of variation in data, failing to reflect the
diversity of human experiences. In this paper, we examine the role of prompting
LLMs with human-like personas and asking the models to answer as if they were a
specific human. This is done explicitly, with exact demographics, political
beliefs, and lived experiences, or implicitly via names prevalent in specific
populations. The LLM personas are then evaluated via (1) subjective annotation
task (e.g., detecting toxicity) and (2) a belief generation task, where both
tasks are known to vary across human factors. We examine the impact of explicit
vs. implicit personas and investigate which human factors LLMs recognize and
respond to. Results show that LLM personas show mixed results when reproducing
known human biases, but generate generally fail to demonstrate implicit biases.
We conclude that LLMs lack the intrinsic cognitive mechanisms of human thought,
while capturing the statistical patterns of how people speak, which may
restrict their effectiveness in complex social science applications. | [
0.0547841638,
0.0859971195,
-0.0237039067,
0.0031853383,
-0.0130438795,
0.0097356159,
0.0546416268,
-0.0409227088,
0.0581136942,
-0.0322151557,
-0.0161766466,
-0.0136419106,
-0.0259008072,
0.0083623407,
0.052116286,
-0.053080231,
0.0337269939,
0.003247425,
0.0681456923,
-0.0284551084,
0.0151022691,
0.0324850567,
0.0192834232,
0.0382877328,
-0.0226287395,
-0.0004548388,
0.0122367973,
-0.028520409,
0.0383841582,
-0.0204899237,
0.0058914069,
0.0427205898,
0.0269186199,
0.0213500578,
0.0000019422,
-0.0489398763,
0.0334367529,
0.0081074666,
-0.0067213248,
-0.0123499157,
0.0639129803,
0.0354821384,
0.007600741,
0.0164169315,
-0.0591874011,
-0.0077973832,
0.0436942987,
0.0318916589,
0.0420246646,
0.0086804098,
-0.011369138,
-0.0118168956,
-0.0213600732,
0.0059588528,
0.0035773432,
0.0264910739,
0.0563639626,
-0.0190685242,
-0.0422442369,
0.0043422887,
0.0099093756,
0.0025963979,
-0.0046645673,
-0.015006043,
-0.0000302968,
-0.0016001584,
-0.0351320356,
-0.0584733523,
0.0152633861,
0.0789594278,
0.0516801439,
-0.0046209656,
-0.0001994492,
0.0088466341,
0.02278376,
0.0377797745,
-0.0247158278,
0.0374456942,
-0.0165641438,
-0.0051245438,
-0.0291088577,
0.022840647,
0.0117547736,
0.0284031127,
-0.0168862324,
0.0616430491,
-0.0157066546,
-0.0150459362,
0.0236770287,
0.0054650628,
0.0113162883,
-0.0477657989,
0.0065003647,
0.0014111835,
-0.0397724286,
0.0378416069,
-0.0119363405,
0.0157290194,
0.0348154865,
-0.0834433958,
0.0245271754,
0.0303344261,
-0.0062029622,
0.0116963396,
0.0180207416,
0.0066090976,
-0.0041562044,
0.0208364129,
0.0246857163,
-0.0155701851,
-0.0341329314,
-0.0315953568,
0.0041797515,
0.0056362315,
0.0264574997,
0.0230462514,
-0.0280203652,
-0.0119559318,
-0.0718355998,
-0.0072687948,
-0.0457430333,
0.0257178191,
-0.0101391105,
0.0085328771,
-0.0948293805,
0.0191414561,
-0.0364620909,
0.0341756977,
-0.0121886386,
-0.0689047202,
0.0402755514,
0.0147654135,
-0.0219605267,
-0.013298098,
0.0055275038,
0.0576855354,
0.0191813651,
0.0149204591,
0.0004843899,
-0.0137943327,
-0.0215340946,
-0.0814208388,
-0.0158199295,
-0.0369842388,
0.0263656229,
0.0147898141,
-0.0046238084,
-0.075198561,
0.0271378383,
0.0304656364,
-0.0518189967,
0.08497639,
0.0132732103,
0.0348570012,
0.0449574627,
0.0241902154,
0.0089933751,
0.0596368276,
0.0244038533,
-0.0003963837,
-0.0081356196,
-0.0192638952,
0.0079556471,
0.0174891092,
0.0087360796,
0.0255404916,
-0.0365140587,
0.0156430248,
-0.0435838215,
0.0249428432,
0.0521881618,
0.0888674334,
-0.0220393091,
-0.0157282576,
0.0843401924,
0.06926658,
-0.052008491,
0.0392825045,
0.0631352514,
0.0306971986,
0.0198377892,
0.006344445,
-0.0551407486,
0.0074403612,
0.0076017277,
-0.054448273,
0.0148211131,
0.0177628361,
-0.0140529815,
-0.023409985,
-0.0013821203,
0.0159917511,
0.0386015102,
0.0296789128,
-0.0057512913,
-0.0241017621,
0.0071822261,
0.022045508,
0.044768326,
-0.0396423303,
-0.0146956965,
-0.0478131808,
0.0451723076,
0.0692699626,
-0.011887067,
0.0180316959,
0.0052752714,
-0.0464679524,
-0.0052761696,
0.0653962344,
0.1033703983,
-0.0331715047,
-0.0609271117,
-0.0036099216,
-0.0088504255,
0.0155196069,
-0.0028431071,
0.0449092016,
0.0367540121,
0.005160905,
0.0056083649,
0.0006982709,
-0.0451666452,
0.0220043566,
-0.0666453615,
-0.0042433906,
-0.0365768149,
0.0039685098,
0.0434403569,
0.025826605,
-0.0004849782,
0.0105198305,
0.0013076501,
0.0068570087,
-0.0280395485,
0.0171763785,
-0.0227478687,
0.0333528928,
0.0111977821,
-0.036495734,
-0.0370684005,
0.0011444794,
0.0215496533,
0.0201990865,
0.026113417,
-0.0348349065,
0.0177827291,
-0.028678989,
-0.0254088119,
-0.0518445931,
0.0280980058,
-0.0379367769,
0.0368211903,
0.0035613414,
-0.0166150536,
0.0240710881,
-0.0198805984,
-0.0085522411,
-0.0605624467,
-0.0170265678,
-0.0245443508,
0.0352804027,
0.0035528031,
0.0199200884,
-0.0497934707,
-0.0618392266,
-0.0126460642,
-0.0938837379,
-0.0173928905,
0.0207913164,
-0.01857947,
-0.0056701242,
-0.0150712961,
-0.0086656669,
0.0148303825,
-0.0553072095,
-0.0185332038,
0.0015806212,
0.0616938733,
0.0216304716,
-0.0287313517,
0.0003488394,
-0.0270521287,
0.0293959845,
-0.0497549437,
0.036689911,
0.0395407155,
-0.0237401519,
-0.0188286137,
-0.0109062754,
-0.0764805004,
-0.0060850019,
0.0017797572,
-0.0436282493,
0.0496325605,
0.0390485749,
0.0792686865,
0.082776688,
0.038248986,
0.0451710969,
0.0401900373,
0.034021955,
-0.0694435462,
-0.0231475104,
-0.0337296724,
-0.0022727251,
-0.0159780271,
-0.0703842416,
-0.0281375963,
0.0512314253,
0.0291855801,
0.0000542078,
-0.0315105245,
0.1106436774,
-0.0382792316,
-0.0705331862,
0.0064342753,
-0.0372073464,
-0.0290927775,
0.0286149289,
-0.0286179129,
-0.0414911546,
0.0755277574,
0.0262643807,
0.0271248575,
0.0144361202,
0.0011982817,
-0.0114817508,
0.0226597171,
0.0108806742,
0.0063895173,
0.0010031908,
0.0266939793,
-0.0472292751,
-0.0359104276,
-0.0009639019,
-0.0560903475,
0.0100767156,
-0.0468605757,
0.0014125234,
0.0246036295,
-0.0181824099,
-0.0469906256,
-0.04070976,
-0.0481243022,
0.0030056699,
0.0347189382,
-0.0291533768,
-0.0043206117,
0.0051927571,
0.0687188208,
-0.0211162381,
0.0039819544,
-0.0131977769,
0.0102494014,
-0.045753628,
0.0341918543,
0.0378068835,
0.0699341893,
-0.0300650001,
0.0508931428,
0.0101094153,
-0.0305118877,
0.0038265828,
-0.0294006988,
-0.0100099668,
0.0009766072,
0.0358127505,
0.0080542732,
0.0173385032,
0.0557926558,
-0.0203647763,
0.0155308889,
0.0997928232,
0.0208049789,
-0.0479348823,
0.0155312577,
-0.013593995,
0.0113365185,
0.0467402749,
0.0004291417,
-0.0641671196,
0.0114103621,
-0.0151629634,
-0.0052284067,
-0.0943149254,
-0.0775668845,
-0.0133415908,
-0.1162013337,
0.040894527,
-0.0082730222,
-0.0076358644,
0.0303265527,
-0.0486404076,
0.0333056562,
-0.0236933939,
0.0364587978,
-0.0236924645,
0.0250241123,
-0.0064685154,
0.0040331758,
-0.0537983067,
-0.0413496792,
0.0518201292,
-0.0312101394,
0.0745129585,
0.0293368939,
0.0764744356,
-0.0048806774,
-0.0143419337,
0.0323859751,
0.0294795539,
-0.0146409879,
0.0167634673,
0.049595084,
-0.0071307509,
-0.005378657,
-0.081494242,
0.0433750562,
0.0007012202,
0.0020573225,
-0.0087357592,
0.0591191947,
-0.0096676517,
-0.0426037498,
-0.0171001386,
0.0281839669,
0.0251177978,
0.087005794,
0.0218080953,
-0.0689902678,
-0.00003783,
-0.0330140553,
-0.0174410623,
0.0057481104,
-0.1158516109,
0.0248640981,
-0.0233452898,
-0.0394877866,
-0.0316392519,
-0.0623428449,
0.0411418341,
-0.0021777153,
0.0161197912,
-0.0323614627,
0.0496581271,
-0.0137522556,
-0.0189542808,
0.0652722567,
-0.0343174189,
0.0262668319,
0.0141964909,
-0.0542707667,
0.030782843,
-0.0145129748,
-0.0006019418,
0.0290058386,
-0.0089881271,
-0.0692442507,
0.0600509271,
0.0225239359,
0.0261213072,
0.0355237685,
0.0278834607,
-0.0441968143,
0.0439899601,
0.0223534741,
-0.0301943049,
0.0063344729,
-0.0264927857,
0.0749911368,
0.0000031284,
0.0233401544,
-0.0000590643,
0.0353448465,
0.0298945997,
-0.0353276767,
-0.0669865534,
-0.0473519862,
0.0400245525,
0.0229393281,
0.0365099125,
-0.0256421808,
0.0085677477,
-0.0250290558,
-0.0656881034,
-0.0390597843,
-0.0460982025,
-0.0005842583,
-0.0465269871,
0.0224643741,
0.0150998225,
-0.011043271,
-0.0333263837,
-0.066448994,
0.0615653433,
-0.0152304452,
0.0270890668,
0.0238347072,
0.0375228077,
0.0282082707,
-0.0117354151,
-0.0040669609,
0.035878621,
-0.0567413047,
0.0197386127,
0.0282252636,
0.0212416854,
0.0068011233,
0.0074784248,
0.0034460519,
-0.0138015058,
-0.035256844,
-0.0519412644,
-0.017428698,
0.0219095536,
-0.0252644792,
0.0113330381,
0.0233798884,
-0.0197639298,
-0.0142659452,
-0.0158052053,
-0.0109325852,
-0.0049915244,
-0.0223419946,
0.0427669287,
-0.0032152839,
-0.0511415377,
-0.008671321,
0.026688043,
0.0195038579,
0.0368891917,
-0.0399130434,
-0.0470128804,
-0.0239397269,
-0.0194261707,
0.0169099905,
-0.0352190323,
-0.0077711116,
-0.0116360579,
-0.0853947699,
-0.0550995767,
-0.0196651872,
0.0091794096,
-0.0099920742,
-0.0364237875,
0.0002739517,
0.037156336,
-0.0212952122,
0.0025229445,
-0.042287603,
0.0558876395,
-0.0294247828,
-0.0020290837,
-0.0200822521,
-6.207032616e-33,
-0.0357897393,
-0.0643172488,
-0.0007021697,
-0.0193545893,
-0.0393057466,
-0.0134043396,
-0.0291858986,
0.0317052342,
-0.0300132446,
0.0539193489,
0.0191948991,
-0.0059089041,
0.0100085502,
-0.0261332579,
0.0189317185,
-0.0254392512,
0.04327498,
-0.0117423562,
-0.014336613,
0.0007677316,
0.0194024239,
-0.0185513124,
0.0054329387,
-0.0925349742,
0.0665071011,
-0.000479418,
0.0027285605,
0.0036509533,
-0.0293782279,
0.0345303155,
-0.0372522175,
0.0634161532,
0.021056002,
-0.0044184201,
-0.0110650379,
0.0841728076,
-0.0380216092,
-0.0138095161,
0.0459809415,
-0.0091411332,
-0.0159527455,
-0.0357785374,
0.0220076051,
-0.0244590398,
-0.0544670336,
0.0263305362,
0.0416159183,
-0.043428991,
0.0544115342,
-0.0111064306,
-0.0408848077,
-0.0092220539,
-0.0095321881,
0.0248277467,
-0.0479136109,
0.0248319339,
-0.0388282798,
0.0389841907,
-0.0404534787,
0.046875976,
-0.0154165514,
-0.0497831479,
0.0421767756,
0.0251085833,
0.0438232161,
0.0786855668,
0.0503944233,
0.0510360934,
-0.0810061172,
-0.0387867987,
0.0302396733,
-0.0082342522,
0.0307529923,
0.0940656662,
-0.019465575,
-0.0130050536,
-0.0235875119,
-0.0370392799,
0.049716264,
-0.0198595542,
0.0507367253,
-0.00474115,
-0.0210917704,
-0.0306387357,
-0.0654269755,
-0.0540180206,
-0.0231443346,
-0.0291346088,
0.0134207318,
-0.0190016683,
-0.0230615716,
-0.0006788678,
0.02376738,
-0.025560068,
-0.0041452264,
-0.0188072044,
-0.0223626606,
-0.0061998637,
0.001160866,
-0.0127662327,
-0.0690300241,
0.0185618084,
-0.0075426516,
0.0234795045,
0.0488846488,
0.0248434581,
-0.0000397349,
-0.0051932149,
-0.049187135,
-0.0205727573,
-0.0144998422,
0.0239160061,
0.004790687,
0.0027177059,
0.0337482877,
0.015287647,
-0.0019180593,
-0.0105700735,
0.0173844974,
-0.0145148924,
-0.0023802985,
0.0191957783,
-0.0405477285,
0.0272744801,
-0.0497747324,
-0.0147105157,
-0.0252575334,
-0.010490017,
0.0315078907,
-0.0621205419,
-0.0122446967,
-0.0259656832,
2.592e-7,
0.0201465972,
0.0836280435,
-0.0119907614,
0.006579183,
0.0273003913,
0.0296179261,
0.0304281935,
0.0088770408,
0.0280540194,
-0.0793898478,
-0.0246867556,
0.0371434987,
0.040317364,
0.0463088527,
-0.0663546398,
0.0002414704,
-0.0455430038,
-0.012309866,
-0.0597446673,
0.0235209465,
0.0399171412,
0.0475224257,
0.0277272183,
-0.0054358533,
-0.0187326353,
0.00134413,
0.0479434952,
-0.0349415131,
-0.0353466533,
0.0211179126,
0.008070345,
-0.022739917,
0.0342204608,
0.0827124938,
0.0216344465,
-0.0107996175,
-0.0015353147,
0.0671325773,
-0.0002727634,
-0.0226589274,
-0.0086909188,
-0.0250907987,
-0.003056345,
-0.0386500694,
0.0536288507,
-0.0642732456,
-0.0575091839,
-0.0299873874,
-0.0175585747,
-0.0376902223,
0.0251158196,
-0.0275790393,
-0.0048689563,
0.0131462757,
0.0267796889,
-0.0015839703,
0.0147024356,
-0.026340045,
-0.0173196811,
-0.0242021438,
-0.0595056005,
-0.0987268537,
-0.0039724535,
0.0129601397,
0.0046544396,
-0.0235433616,
0.0537271872,
2.172506644e-34,
0.0296003055,
0.0440010093,
0.0112024639,
-0.0580585748,
0.0668740869,
0.0259094015,
0.0147156091,
0.011951183,
0.0587264784,
-0.0476284586,
0.0165738612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14459v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14459v1 | Healing Powers of BERT: How Task-Specific Fine-Tuning Recovers Corrupted Language Models | 2024-06-20T16:18:04 | 2024-06-20T16:18:04 | Shijie Han, Zhenyu Zhang, Andrei Arsene Simion | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models like BERT excel at sentence classification tasks due to
extensive pre-training on general data, but their robustness to parameter
corruption is unexplored. To understand this better, we look at what happens if
a language model is "broken", in the sense that some of its parameters are
corrupted and then recovered by fine-tuning. Strategically corrupting BERT
variants at different levels, we find corrupted models struggle to fully
recover their original performance, with higher corruption causing more severe
degradation. Notably, bottom-layer corruption affecting fundamental linguistic
features is more detrimental than top-layer corruption. Our insights contribute
to understanding language model robustness and adaptability under adverse
conditions, informing strategies for developing resilient NLP systems against
parameter perturbations. | [
0.0389217921,
0.0848155916,
-0.0285457596,
0.0277672149,
0.0080994675,
0.0186716337,
-0.0353884548,
0.0042080153,
-0.0444584489,
-0.0848759562,
-0.0256573912,
-0.0088297045,
0.0180431064,
-0.0193332471,
0.054396756,
-0.0597407259,
0.0678652748,
-0.0116932783,
0.0106194392,
-0.0074386438,
0.0125694871,
-0.0171019323,
0.029549541,
0.0429634638,
-0.0026286431,
0.0104454318,
0.0249508377,
0.0309627168,
-0.0058135339,
0.0381024517,
0.0544594079,
0.0690445676,
-0.0061381008,
0.0493536443,
0.0000016197,
-0.0289590564,
-0.0213196427,
-0.0069538262,
-0.0095824152,
0.0661648437,
-0.0046083964,
-0.0029242886,
-0.0347645171,
0.0447615832,
-0.0236276519,
-0.0061713099,
0.0260989703,
0.0622900873,
0.0734475181,
0.084123604,
0.0004270806,
0.0000076106,
0.0378311314,
-0.0273151714,
-0.0316988342,
-0.0095079029,
0.0277401041,
-0.0431605168,
-0.00754485,
-0.0203066897,
-0.0030228966,
-0.0219910312,
-0.0080374088,
0.0157082025,
-0.0337059908,
0.0000047661,
-0.0743910149,
-0.025868807,
0.0089371884,
0.0504285879,
-0.0667050257,
-0.0027224177,
0.0068524703,
0.0211428553,
0.0208637286,
-0.0109087052,
-0.0026595131,
-0.0003974202,
0.0249751899,
0.0185644347,
0.0279756263,
-0.0601719283,
0.0559801944,
0.0011954322,
-0.0188676659,
0.0184085555,
0.0360002331,
-0.0350742787,
-0.0414393879,
-0.0020831632,
-0.0591090582,
-0.0203491747,
-0.0025244185,
-0.0112608224,
-0.0219857264,
0.0181297269,
-0.0612037405,
-0.0352984928,
0.044714082,
-0.0663959384,
0.0620011128,
0.010415189,
-0.053078603,
0.0021836106,
-0.0347389355,
0.0202503968,
-0.007708333,
0.0459187515,
-0.0144006088,
-0.0026951968,
-0.0481893159,
-0.0146527067,
-0.0536299944,
0.0204639528,
0.0008937389,
0.0115014613,
-0.016935965,
0.0166605432,
0.0094304085,
0.0172779076,
-0.0145359663,
0.0148308417,
-0.0390945636,
0.0016205639,
-0.0011481975,
0.0349372104,
-0.0149072045,
0.0033143547,
-0.0103493091,
-0.0629265979,
-0.023891639,
-0.0056473981,
-0.0232216492,
-0.0507387519,
0.0191631559,
0.0432932042,
0.0284009296,
-0.0486384816,
-0.0581490174,
0.0093163932,
-0.0770354122,
-0.0462948531,
-0.0193798412,
-0.0214938056,
-0.011525983,
0.0109024141,
-0.0114570251,
-0.0354768038,
0.0303414874,
-0.015387129,
-0.0785477608,
0.075927332,
-0.0420077555,
-0.0233059265,
0.0007175081,
-0.0206436049,
0.0035556299,
0.0462318473,
0.0447367057,
-0.0142726609,
0.0460613891,
-0.0152928829,
0.0125400908,
0.0436781198,
0.0023721561,
0.032924667,
-0.0149154393,
-0.0282787289,
0.0267096944,
0.0083176941,
0.0137351425,
0.0509704873,
-0.0103430115,
-0.0026459887,
0.0861998126,
-0.0046302308,
-0.0053764679,
0.0388621502,
-0.0194805637,
-0.035602577,
0.0063825487,
0.0118984254,
-0.0724718273,
-0.0600460358,
-0.0203068331,
-0.0059985407,
-0.0140850917,
0.0286177229,
-0.0153305484,
-0.0305687804,
-0.0705779642,
-0.0006371104,
0.0124103222,
-0.0264345556,
0.0423519462,
0.0251737982,
-0.0090272967,
0.0719674677,
0.0344001316,
-0.043795798,
0.0102687478,
-0.0627089739,
-0.0103603294,
0.0600171611,
0.0795120001,
-0.0526361875,
-0.0535106398,
-0.0063984119,
-0.009512064,
0.0105708567,
0.0410203263,
-0.0041408995,
0.0466112569,
-0.0173823815,
-0.0120572401,
-0.0069357068,
0.0545156822,
0.0021306225,
-0.0261639785,
-0.0384285077,
-0.0122971525,
-0.0858763009,
-0.0513017774,
0.0367008038,
0.0217102114,
-0.0088120988,
-0.0018479051,
0.0189078171,
0.0023992658,
0.0067338352,
-0.0604766309,
0.0117273359,
0.0313216709,
-0.0162042193,
0.0083649121,
0.0255903788,
-0.0097300299,
-0.0445580855,
0.030208623,
0.010472998,
-0.0130200302,
0.0678632036,
-0.0096463086,
-0.0387242362,
0.016403323,
-0.0637603998,
0.0652584136,
-0.0225376468,
0.0421975441,
-0.0314311236,
0.0276779402,
-0.0227434691,
0.0521473326,
-0.0063306796,
0.0014058569,
-0.0160313584,
0.0235771798,
0.0360372812,
-0.052958332,
-0.0561924018,
0.0213950891,
-0.0171552002,
0.0236137956,
0.0295828972,
-0.0121623771,
-0.0263645258,
-0.0317013375,
-0.0689594448,
-0.0031459148,
-0.054643143,
0.0150846299,
0.0166507885,
-0.0038678369,
-0.021384567,
-0.0138437077,
0.017396871,
-0.0122248549,
-0.0023664569,
0.0416783169,
0.0453556217,
-0.0027893537,
-0.0172292795,
-0.0404470451,
-0.0091741467,
-0.0267596226,
0.0710706487,
-0.0401741229,
-0.0211587176,
-0.0757186189,
-0.0179579612,
-0.0072972733,
0.0465731993,
0.0172716659,
-0.080655463,
0.0004843252,
-0.0105508594,
0.038977161,
0.0623925515,
-0.0120362677,
0.0832098201,
0.0143372891,
-0.0012598232,
-0.0242042486,
0.0107940044,
-0.0092822993,
-0.0243350454,
-0.0445267819,
-0.0159613527,
0.0036793414,
0.0579966418,
-0.0182599649,
-0.019780118,
-0.0532913134,
0.0211504325,
-0.0055639572,
0.0088199945,
0.0185189918,
-0.0355826057,
-0.028547328,
0.0104979435,
-0.0334886611,
-0.0355447307,
0.0459487252,
-0.0273515675,
0.021787582,
-0.0498097427,
0.0126172742,
-0.0028641338,
0.0296454448,
0.0168238841,
0.026528202,
0.0528577268,
-0.0597754307,
-0.0183007717,
0.0087505914,
0.0252527036,
-0.0146685289,
-0.0027118691,
-0.0336985216,
0.0060652923,
-0.0117842881,
-0.0844040662,
-0.0162355062,
-0.0348465592,
0.0248796064,
0.0392521843,
0.0392561369,
-0.0326092914,
-0.0410630517,
-0.0436426066,
0.0014253861,
0.0108465245,
-0.0295968149,
-0.0007698657,
-0.0308658667,
0.0655414388,
0.0118209077,
-0.0037724173,
0.0360795483,
-0.0576385297,
-0.020011561,
0.02589182,
0.0623566657,
0.0256310254,
-0.0317504965,
0.0286748409,
0.0527729653,
-0.0350241661,
-0.0336942971,
-0.0010148069,
0.0592128374,
-0.0373037681,
-0.0428258479,
0.0862081647,
0.0191432089,
0.0039965571,
0.031199716,
-0.0021175509,
0.0570187233,
-0.0015139396,
0.0225955825,
-0.0478188396,
-0.0303919353,
0.0363876857,
0.0502572209,
0.0123275947,
-0.0136110587,
0.0281527638,
-0.0934497043,
0.0261747111,
0.0059481896,
0.0183469616,
-0.0229089372,
-0.0414069779,
-0.000937244,
-0.0177644752,
0.0964587182,
0.004664741,
0.0023612399,
0.0078518735,
0.0337600037,
-0.0024385627,
-0.0715384707,
0.0244913977,
-0.0508851111,
0.0438718386,
0.096975185,
0.0190183502,
-0.0243816134,
-0.0088161556,
0.0445826948,
-0.0209629405,
0.0132680302,
-0.0028338274,
0.0461264439,
0.0049491366,
-0.0492974892,
0.0204211753,
0.0280141141,
-0.0402523652,
-0.0019713212,
-0.0671731606,
0.0254411269,
0.005402816,
-0.0067635207,
0.0045496817,
-0.0590134338,
-0.0179807656,
0.0566494353,
0.0235354919,
-0.0453962088,
-0.0544374138,
-0.0290370341,
-0.0068886494,
-0.0554675907,
0.0248119328,
0.0313591734,
-0.0090063065,
-0.0244700946,
-0.068626076,
-0.0532048158,
0.0030484591,
0.0204532519,
0.0358342566,
-0.0088445926,
-0.0143515533,
0.0001937165,
-0.0188295897,
0.0634796172,
0.0337228142,
0.0113013173,
-0.0780085847,
-0.0239603966,
0.0178024601,
0.0175760705,
-0.010708008,
-0.0445182435,
-0.0583246723,
-0.0795194879,
0.058537215,
0.0727034733,
0.0190364141,
0.0166600086,
-0.0388925932,
-0.0953046456,
0.0241912771,
0.0348387845,
-0.0090001505,
0.0153321419,
0.0677643269,
-0.0482255332,
0.00369229,
0.0591219887,
-0.0437892489,
-0.0096255559,
0.0406037644,
0.0453468487,
-0.0069479779,
0.003626134,
0.0187741295,
0.0062789,
0.0657574832,
-0.0146517484,
-0.0283312351,
-0.005005152,
0.0226138011,
-0.0058553815,
-0.0152599635,
-0.023599036,
0.0366241522,
0.0270025209,
0.0146343727,
-0.0199692193,
0.0267813224,
-0.0182528049,
0.051794868,
-0.0732730031,
0.007060844,
0.0093540046,
-0.0110173998,
0.0370793529,
0.0096394373,
0.0091260215,
0.0611564815,
-0.0088754343,
0.0326459073,
-0.0396264829,
0.0132573787,
0.017705841,
0.0051347977,
-0.0292209182,
0.0471558236,
-0.0634059459,
-0.0378169417,
-0.0431004353,
0.0073074154,
0.0517398119,
-0.0148668941,
0.0464178994,
-0.0081446515,
-0.0188423079,
-0.0272445679,
-0.0202243812,
0.0246484969,
-0.0039862557,
-0.0032688265,
0.0113932779,
-0.0285567883,
0.0122032324,
0.0815220922,
0.0226224326,
0.0700691268,
-0.0049235946,
-0.0097467778,
-0.0162000936,
-0.0096818218,
0.0351525322,
-0.0047541452,
-0.0398900956,
-0.0089019528,
-0.0192077588,
-0.0777775571,
0.0413831733,
-0.01591672,
0.0375735275,
0.0007900132,
-0.0136244847,
0.0840560347,
0.0004878969,
0.007636447,
-0.0301755182,
-0.0124925058,
0.0321228094,
-0.0089670187,
-0.0039881663,
-5.885074264e-33,
0.0115067316,
0.0304309875,
-0.0424680673,
-0.0496145934,
0.0223652218,
0.0040526618,
-0.0213223752,
0.016276041,
-0.0218451861,
0.0207952559,
-0.0164839402,
0.0120466957,
0.0020959862,
0.0283106957,
-0.0181586388,
-0.0308330916,
0.0530463867,
0.0193794928,
-0.0560055822,
-0.0144960172,
0.0543910488,
0.0619663186,
0.0769558474,
-0.0093398811,
0.0177513957,
0.0159282293,
-0.018340487,
0.0486079454,
0.0090273712,
0.0528067611,
0.0076538124,
0.0453780144,
0.0085320994,
-0.0005528372,
-0.0284072552,
-0.0061793188,
-0.0768922195,
0.0067248046,
-0.0092841946,
0.0257116742,
-0.020601755,
-0.0125405109,
0.0665021315,
-0.0032619615,
-0.0162002686,
0.0205131266,
0.0234614741,
-0.0232244227,
-0.0343368128,
-0.017336132,
-0.0520592779,
0.014877473,
-0.0097550033,
-0.0215848293,
-0.0311097987,
-0.0041213264,
-0.0090428377,
0.0378727578,
-0.02472388,
-0.0364103988,
0.0549331233,
0.0607525818,
0.0006119633,
-0.0063021453,
-0.0300451089,
0.0725128651,
0.0131824557,
0.0472952239,
0.0078120842,
-0.0338871181,
0.0539373904,
0.0583534315,
0.0522208437,
0.0266581681,
0.0141480323,
-0.0179158188,
-0.0526756011,
0.0118677458,
0.0437723882,
0.0266818404,
0.0026585921,
0.026951693,
-0.0275608338,
-0.0166451558,
-0.0613191091,
-0.0464173444,
-0.043734543,
0.0105064781,
0.0121719604,
-0.0046188082,
-0.0061644344,
0.0218816418,
0.0065508727,
-0.0135826906,
-0.0237918701,
0.0018840138,
-0.0252835043,
-0.0139760366,
-0.0029538467,
0.0401587114,
-0.0207674503,
-0.0361174084,
0.0053093527,
0.0074845371,
-0.0061557414,
0.0010877444,
0.0644961074,
0.0260974001,
-0.0442839935,
0.0106496038,
-0.0171291661,
0.028920358,
-0.0089874389,
0.0613116473,
0.046359811,
-0.0006537842,
0.0093652876,
0.0209744759,
0.0712289438,
0.060899727,
-0.0403007492,
0.0237369202,
0.0017026284,
0.0082013179,
0.0252952911,
-0.0390870646,
-0.0206351113,
0.0472255573,
-0.0101512149,
-0.0870307013,
-0.0016236826,
-0.021655174,
2.392e-7,
0.05188407,
0.0930682942,
0.0182148963,
-0.0348401479,
0.0384543091,
0.0485108197,
-0.0301783755,
0.053405799,
0.0043244036,
0.032281436,
-0.0260461718,
-0.021049222,
0.055090677,
0.0198945384,
-0.0547285043,
0.0056544784,
-0.0931031033,
0.0282232482,
-0.0468884148,
-0.0067048264,
0.0230914224,
0.1222822443,
0.0050587365,
-0.0334030427,
0.0197895803,
-0.0846996978,
0.0677520409,
-0.0153551865,
-0.0346680433,
0.0238858052,
0.0073008803,
0.0319360942,
0.0311989877,
-0.0016441838,
-0.0532670915,
0.0371523723,
-0.0314937383,
0.0312331077,
-0.0399874672,
-0.0515612289,
-0.0207142755,
-0.0226543453,
0.0042355959,
-0.0444697551,
0.078141205,
-0.0137689868,
-0.0178017039,
-0.0005624329,
-0.0351117589,
0.0052575651,
0.0243035872,
-0.0524175093,
-0.0543284342,
0.032280203,
0.0095420294,
0.006690878,
-0.0234658588,
-0.089234978,
-0.018832488,
0.0109755266,
-0.0364957452,
-0.0444641635,
-0.0117426123,
-0.014095542,
0.0480030254,
-0.100762181,
0.0096065486,
2.528826762e-34,
0.0500353537,
-0.0399320498,
0.0124264928,
0.0293985978,
0.0330236964,
-0.0117104463,
0.0318268277,
0.0094467103,
-0.0095682815,
-0.0313856453,
-0.0188830066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14434v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14434v1 | Towards Truthful Multilingual Large Language Models: Benchmarking and Alignment Strategies | 2024-06-20T15:59:07 | 2024-06-20T15:59:07 | Weihao Liu, Ning Wu, Wenbiao Ding, Shining Liang, Ming Gong, Dongmei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the era of large language models (LLMs), building multilingual large
language models (MLLMs) that can serve users worldwide holds great
significance. However, existing research seldom focuses on the truthfulness of
MLLMs. Meanwhile, contemporary multilingual aligning technologies struggle to
balance massive languages and often exhibit serious truthfulness gaps across
different languages, especially those that differ greatly from English. In our
work, we construct a benchmark for truthfulness evaluation in multilingual
scenarios and explore the ways to align facts across languages to enhance the
truthfulness of MLLMs. Furthermore, we propose Fact-aware Multilingual
Selective Synergy (FaMSS) to optimize the data allocation across a large number
of languages and different data types. Experimental results demonstrate that
our approach can effectively reduce the multilingual representation disparity
and enhance the multilingual capabilities of LLMs. | [
0.0248776004,
0.0515768901,
-0.0268221106,
0.0954362154,
-0.0599439293,
-0.0018131004,
0.0363936909,
-0.0190524831,
0.0182908624,
-0.0004564065,
-0.0164457764,
-0.0565821864,
0.0311057214,
-0.0196350999,
0.007636996,
0.003361949,
0.0683895946,
-0.0049693841,
-0.0306315124,
-0.0360139608,
0.0285339337,
0.056547761,
0.0063972753,
0.0083792256,
-0.0414935686,
-0.0075930515,
0.0167710651,
-0.0168085657,
0.042031277,
0.0026770851,
-0.0334599651,
0.0077228406,
-0.0209726412,
0.0808407515,
0.0000020207,
-0.0604278035,
-0.0389515683,
0.0098214289,
-0.0422410145,
0.0140933311,
0.0260780994,
-0.0567319691,
0.0145182097,
-0.0015243425,
-0.0269414801,
-0.0069476757,
0.0782163814,
-0.0012783448,
0.0291227587,
0.0450295247,
-0.0191879477,
-0.0266571399,
0.0157235507,
-0.0061979243,
-0.0293449238,
-0.0030674788,
-0.0073650666,
0.0256893355,
-0.0364249311,
-0.0336051285,
0.0145673221,
0.0549998209,
0.0171210524,
-0.005847821,
-0.0235207714,
0.0082812915,
-0.0237451252,
-0.0419456996,
0.0285061803,
0.0230669528,
0.0059141177,
-0.0294386093,
-0.0093168737,
-0.0188600346,
-0.0293051023,
0.0182802435,
-0.020365987,
0.0223100502,
-0.0324150957,
0.0227580965,
0.0375384167,
0.0165000483,
0.0403552838,
0.013040496,
-0.032606855,
0.0856579989,
0.0182654187,
-0.0130023509,
-0.0203295518,
0.004408903,
-0.0087487409,
-0.0787902549,
-0.0034212831,
-0.0054503977,
-0.0544554964,
0.0270258114,
-0.0301360711,
-0.0465961136,
0.0649894625,
-0.0836170465,
0.0183387771,
0.0315850191,
-0.0139840953,
0.052630417,
0.0243955329,
0.0604629144,
-0.023969952,
-0.018321177,
-0.0533488356,
-0.059970066,
0.0225480385,
0.0054679308,
0.0335937552,
0.0092651993,
-0.0408499502,
0.0134971868,
-0.0572029054,
0.024353737,
-0.0371868275,
0.0759654194,
-0.0275103059,
-0.0355604477,
-0.0229312684,
-0.0361303687,
-0.0405827574,
0.0760376379,
-0.0158609487,
-0.012063236,
-0.0334710777,
-0.0798138455,
0.0187953915,
0.0367855094,
-0.0427351482,
-0.0503012836,
-0.0111351153,
0.0583275557,
0.0027687007,
0.0119424099,
-0.0122786704,
-0.0338381007,
-0.0121647473,
-0.0819556564,
-0.0238537006,
-0.0990059301,
0.0713348687,
0.0316829532,
0.0034703501,
-0.0465319417,
-0.0134637831,
-0.0106690442,
0.0092348279,
0.0310542006,
-0.0180405416,
0.0226060413,
0.003240827,
-0.0268617589,
0.0044731852,
0.0921803117,
0.0162308626,
0.0031901887,
0.0797406957,
-0.0009198773,
-0.0387893766,
0.0361751243,
0.012750485,
0.0491901115,
-0.0149320615,
0.0253580939,
0.0525477119,
0.0282477178,
0.013866215,
0.0565411411,
0.0020740214,
-0.0164911523,
0.0865781829,
-0.0078937039,
0.0140110664,
0.015431839,
-0.0116899312,
0.0163991209,
0.0148470607,
0.013850498,
-0.0327505916,
0.0273748599,
-0.002140288,
0.0381654203,
0.031676624,
0.1206251457,
-0.0084719909,
-0.0152957821,
-0.0373848155,
-0.0326938368,
-0.0053659333,
0.0288192984,
0.0107274521,
-0.0509133749,
0.0218628775,
0.1075161174,
0.0544372462,
-0.073036097,
0.010505965,
-0.0133552495,
0.0054137148,
0.0485764481,
0.0044574882,
-0.0384272225,
-0.0486169383,
0.004509862,
0.0008147613,
0.0649461299,
0.0685899481,
0.0074678874,
0.0331278369,
-0.0525145382,
0.0019719175,
-0.0005644254,
-0.006659464,
0.0376161374,
-0.0099246865,
0.039970763,
-0.0101086432,
-0.0455572419,
-0.0261234064,
0.0013732939,
-0.037865866,
0.0453098267,
-0.0033438609,
0.0160578415,
0.015018804,
0.0304664634,
-0.0177787002,
-0.0116602825,
0.0168831833,
-0.0177404601,
0.0016122824,
0.048591312,
-0.024896238,
0.0064754602,
0.0691727027,
-0.0088427905,
-0.0231537167,
0.0291948859,
-0.01730147,
-0.0165269859,
-0.0359941684,
-0.0145047521,
0.0398581773,
-0.0226450283,
0.0273859259,
-0.0172187537,
0.0199200213,
0.0029616107,
0.0578833744,
-0.0102076875,
0.0424410105,
0.0090560168,
-0.0664390028,
0.0523978211,
-0.0148416338,
-0.0132413171,
0.0778915063,
0.0120526012,
0.033419881,
0.0368492901,
-0.0068857023,
-0.0199660566,
-0.005020373,
-0.0867431387,
-0.0012010167,
-0.0103296991,
0.0307046119,
0.0278611351,
0.0088597229,
0.0129498467,
0.0226875562,
-0.0539473556,
-0.0096752783,
0.0422739312,
0.0352758281,
0.0349214226,
-0.0072326581,
-0.0052185841,
-0.0112935444,
0.0009358235,
0.0000345663,
0.0307984799,
0.0055228691,
-0.0412253626,
-0.0272398405,
-0.0349880047,
-0.1032470539,
-0.0000982134,
-0.0082298964,
-0.0100011965,
-0.0195080657,
0.0316769369,
-0.0016649879,
0.0054993038,
-0.0118015567,
-0.0145193702,
0.0529979616,
0.004581905,
-0.0564264096,
-0.0048626261,
0.0053836182,
0.0129767247,
-0.0373674929,
-0.0384645127,
0.0098562166,
0.0097609777,
0.0141000822,
-0.0104400711,
-0.0289335772,
-0.0433705449,
-0.0350772031,
-0.0302480888,
-0.0176811032,
-0.0054462831,
-0.0115391714,
0.0438327566,
-0.0162846819,
-0.042116601,
0.0632158816,
-0.0618022606,
0.001427407,
-0.0419451483,
-0.009149801,
-0.0277050007,
0.0467832349,
-0.0170766786,
0.0568689592,
-0.0349700227,
-0.0065133539,
-0.0254580248,
0.0030600431,
0.0594360866,
-0.0398857482,
0.083866097,
-0.0372468606,
0.0117577864,
-0.0201955512,
-0.0498132631,
-0.0233739112,
-0.0323532373,
-0.0060803448,
-0.0140051711,
-0.0132006276,
-0.0333487988,
-0.0611383617,
-0.0139422463,
0.0640334114,
0.0125613129,
-0.0017458102,
0.0199426897,
-0.016416356,
-0.0228796918,
0.0223889034,
0.0342502333,
0.0546971001,
-0.0247117039,
-0.0057189125,
0.0356171578,
-0.0066399393,
-0.0247871876,
0.0253910627,
-0.0403224975,
0.048067756,
-0.0153741129,
-0.0272862948,
-0.0055847471,
0.0370999426,
-0.0222977195,
0.0262953918,
0.084970504,
0.0038889972,
-0.0314213187,
0.0003936843,
-0.0184789076,
0.0069418997,
0.0075450083,
0.0270306207,
-0.1172836795,
-0.0095808152,
-0.0193396378,
-0.0347642936,
0.0044159512,
-0.0074672024,
-0.0203052089,
-0.0973731726,
0.0036584025,
0.0269050896,
-0.0258407816,
-0.0429771878,
-0.0187025853,
-0.0170637257,
-0.0115007656,
0.043126829,
-0.0160671752,
0.0170428567,
-0.0282715671,
-0.0098546604,
-0.02540485,
-0.0440455377,
-0.0136624267,
-0.0489942878,
0.0086431894,
0.0355063081,
0.0619458482,
-0.0328992307,
-0.0539455228,
-0.0063625085,
0.050928127,
-0.0561612248,
0.0082554799,
-0.0001559225,
0.0121770902,
-0.0059208884,
0.0015273816,
-0.0272818543,
0.0171840806,
0.0031722197,
0.0141498577,
0.077703312,
0.0090443837,
0.0444079861,
0.0208011102,
-0.0089963246,
0.0124092065,
0.0767376497,
-0.0199888106,
-0.011896708,
0.0177308582,
-0.031134136,
-0.0176815875,
0.0005002582,
0.004171581,
0.0535997003,
-0.0183089841,
-0.0504305139,
-0.0376373753,
-0.038662903,
-0.0071477792,
0.0141974967,
0.0120197441,
0.0038040318,
0.0199387111,
-0.0298512895,
-0.0031768936,
0.0024707366,
-0.0446779393,
0.0607761703,
-0.0323127583,
0.0336827338,
-0.016142698,
-0.0366112664,
0.0128281834,
0.0036532201,
-0.04717746,
-0.0786992088,
0.0006712585,
0.0193424374,
0.0245294739,
0.0477924757,
-0.0096280621,
-0.0359931849,
-0.0163521655,
0.0848004296,
-0.0577636734,
0.0246520042,
0.0201536082,
-0.0185334254,
0.0068787993,
0.0535433292,
-0.0485818014,
-0.0276269168,
-0.0226072874,
0.0234781764,
-0.0156011442,
-0.0602335483,
0.027888028,
0.0640645921,
-0.0085807014,
-0.0284973029,
-0.0119771222,
-0.0367360599,
0.0132632684,
-0.05195494,
-0.0413989611,
0.0217155907,
-0.0033976934,
0.0108756842,
0.0035687494,
0.0399518684,
0.0368691199,
0.0106645869,
-0.0252508558,
-0.0378776006,
-0.0195272546,
-0.0222968534,
-0.0148238307,
0.0413058922,
0.0072122975,
-0.0343685001,
-0.0029672463,
-0.0044046841,
0.0377735645,
-0.0383447073,
0.03480855,
0.0259862281,
-0.0162172355,
-0.013910234,
0.0108340746,
-0.0075655654,
-0.0506563857,
-0.0163367726,
-0.0183504727,
0.0876612663,
-0.0022010724,
0.1092153862,
-0.0374413505,
-0.0195468049,
-0.0209744051,
0.0256636627,
0.0099609159,
-0.0360728987,
-0.0048063654,
-0.0047864323,
-0.0388554782,
0.0080415541,
0.057337191,
-0.0562493391,
0.0081438078,
-0.0118457926,
-0.0237102248,
-0.0127318045,
-0.055614721,
-0.0055660042,
0.009574567,
-0.0411787219,
-0.0343369991,
-0.1000837162,
-0.070806466,
0.0441421233,
0.0258874763,
-0.010014574,
-0.0408893973,
-0.01404835,
0.0771638528,
0.0358009189,
-0.0061031375,
-0.0499371737,
0.0168086682,
-0.0098297279,
0.0295285378,
0.0043256497,
-6.155223437e-33,
0.0199915897,
-0.00899156,
0.018094819,
-0.0257005803,
0.0027909633,
0.0289037395,
0.0033482113,
-0.0203248002,
-0.0600055605,
0.030888645,
-0.0077688326,
0.0010845523,
0.0358726755,
0.0114744948,
0.006944146,
-0.0002178103,
0.019558277,
0.0305416156,
-0.0345694982,
0.0084744683,
0.0785878003,
-0.0502294078,
0.0828909948,
-0.058318954,
0.0607868843,
-0.0164574739,
-0.0049989461,
0.0384181291,
-0.0168178156,
0.0762270764,
-0.0021563021,
0.0662616715,
0.0241127126,
-0.0419569984,
-0.0041452735,
-0.0383386202,
-0.0103515415,
-0.0267116092,
0.0870735943,
0.0185524374,
0.0037048094,
-0.003177525,
0.0148444362,
-0.0090391291,
-0.0284350403,
0.0026554307,
0.0068761804,
-0.0099156601,
-0.0233426429,
-0.0113406023,
-0.067659691,
0.0191719159,
0.0139918737,
0.0439183339,
-0.0014379617,
0.0334199853,
0.0063446937,
0.0124934046,
-0.098093234,
0.0300455485,
-0.0063491906,
0.0145573104,
0.1053535268,
-0.0025231934,
-0.0004199058,
0.0601126738,
-0.0180852022,
0.0246667881,
0.013651263,
0.0668578371,
0.0106508872,
0.0069717676,
0.0447261408,
0.1319648325,
-0.02118106,
-0.0341998152,
-0.0498189218,
0.0144191869,
0.0342527293,
-0.0151480054,
0.0165776704,
-0.0020384875,
-0.0309266653,
-0.0327370092,
-0.0141379917,
0.0605219118,
-0.0259866007,
-0.0046298383,
0.0095408289,
-0.044761274,
-0.0158429015,
0.0521734096,
0.0434371717,
-0.0181069188,
-0.0380832069,
0.0397660136,
-0.0147543335,
0.0002527316,
0.0170673449,
0.0546579845,
-0.0592507012,
-0.021499671,
-0.0770264268,
0.0012937237,
-0.0093365125,
0.0343554467,
0.0385180786,
-0.0068530701,
-0.0390101783,
0.0597129725,
-0.0514741428,
-0.0072191842,
-0.0236000493,
-0.0688434243,
0.0402184017,
-0.0116782943,
-0.0122126825,
0.0558800101,
0.0402994081,
-0.0240779631,
-0.0613158718,
-0.0241141282,
-0.0062595652,
0.0302526522,
-0.0033672566,
0.0087142708,
-0.057543654,
-0.0235638674,
0.0563045815,
-0.0263269041,
-0.0126594305,
-0.0023090455,
2.687e-7,
0.0123167904,
-0.0107779717,
0.0012158935,
0.0252166707,
-0.0066079623,
0.0574244075,
-0.0178038664,
0.0215928685,
-0.0148215434,
-0.0128504615,
-0.0372238345,
0.0161137972,
0.0588983335,
0.0786631182,
-0.0392295867,
0.0330088586,
-0.0655158311,
-0.0305860639,
-0.0615578294,
0.0145099424,
-0.0070667565,
0.06812305,
0.0350771397,
-0.0004303436,
-0.0041434849,
-0.0310886893,
0.0329608433,
-0.0299381893,
-0.0615515485,
0.0135631943,
0.0464831367,
-0.0350211598,
0.0111367712,
-0.0081029572,
-0.009724278,
0.008662018,
-0.0156385284,
0.0410469249,
-0.0023130199,
0.0264112167,
-0.0236849636,
-0.0821602792,
-0.0354052298,
-0.0587670319,
0.0490034968,
0.0192715004,
-0.0126227578,
-0.0291896015,
0.0074728695,
-0.0065336344,
0.0390349217,
-0.015007196,
-0.0446545631,
0.046745345,
0.0177932736,
0.0007458333,
-0.0191363245,
0.0057393997,
-0.0496469811,
0.0335179418,
-0.0071636322,
-0.0460481234,
0.0184292607,
-0.0140890786,
0.0221842527,
-0.0659834966,
0.026133433,
2.332130971e-34,
0.0242537912,
0.0142035717,
0.020706119,
-0.0107511114,
0.0484467112,
-0.0233994592,
-0.057284601,
0.023094587,
-0.0121224569,
-0.0114708561,
-0.0043518553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14425v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14425v2 | SynDARin: Synthesising Datasets for Automated Reasoning in Low-Resource Languages | 2024-06-20T15:49:28 | 2024-06-25T13:48:41 | Gayane Ghazaryan, Erik Arakelyan, Pasquale Minervini, Isabelle Augenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Question Answering (QA) datasets have been instrumental in developing and
evaluating Large Language Model (LLM) capabilities. However, such datasets are
scarce for languages other than English due to the cost and difficulties of
collection and manual annotation. This means that producing novel models and
measuring the performance of multilingual LLMs in low-resource languages is
challenging. To mitigate this, we propose $\textbf{S}$yn$\textbf{DAR}$in, a
method for generating and validating QA datasets for low-resource languages. We
utilize parallel content mining to obtain $\textit{human-curated}$ paragraphs
between English and the target language. We use the English data as context to
$\textit{generate}$ synthetic multiple-choice (MC) question-answer pairs, which
are automatically translated and further validated for quality. Combining these
with their designated non-English $\textit{human-curated}$ paragraphs form the
final QA dataset. The method allows to maintain the content quality, reduces
the likelihood of factual errors, and circumvents the need for costly
annotation. To test the method, we created a QA dataset with $1.2$K samples for
the Armenian language. The human evaluation shows that $98\%$ of the generated
English data maintains quality and diversity in the question types and topics,
while the translation validation pipeline can filter out $\sim70\%$ of data
with poor quality. We use the dataset to benchmark state-of-the-art LLMs,
showing their inability to achieve human accuracy with some model performances
closer to random chance. This shows that the generated dataset is non-trivial
and can be used to evaluate reasoning capabilities in low-resource language. | [
0.051397875,
0.0258022603,
-0.0236406233,
0.0605115555,
-0.0541428514,
0.0320971571,
0.0210156478,
-0.0300288964,
0.015949212,
-0.0332739837,
0.0057108914,
-0.0188182946,
-0.006858631,
-0.0522142574,
0.0204363391,
-0.0099741612,
0.0446738005,
-0.0389582664,
-0.0152813736,
-0.0399081223,
0.0141674932,
0.0494042486,
-0.003398027,
-0.0072025526,
0.0162367746,
-0.0273574665,
-0.0104432944,
-0.0191483833,
0.012342792,
0.0123728728,
-0.0178653374,
0.0574116185,
-0.016072588,
0.0079978425,
0.0000020402,
-0.0566788055,
-0.0203040522,
-0.0158331022,
-0.0138987759,
0.0159479138,
0.0281923432,
0.0167689398,
0.0025583338,
0.0442450643,
-0.0531274825,
-0.0153200189,
0.0055197626,
-0.0254689064,
0.078708753,
0.0453177541,
0.0104825012,
0.0045752111,
0.0048397882,
0.0089848759,
-0.0159436613,
-0.0289773475,
0.0360897407,
0.046569299,
0.0105974413,
0.0355195627,
-0.0039366526,
0.0256885048,
0.0424690396,
-0.0118340887,
-0.0504389144,
-0.0216597803,
-0.0531146675,
-0.0352190025,
0.0186996665,
0.0709395036,
-0.0021236485,
-0.0387746133,
0.0117485607,
0.006300027,
-0.0017616055,
0.0285608694,
-0.0380314514,
0.0484131277,
-0.026006477,
0.0122077344,
0.0494983532,
-0.0213692077,
-0.0163266491,
0.0162163544,
0.0032969797,
0.028905578,
0.0325251967,
-0.0167383328,
-0.0018116313,
0.0020128894,
-0.0470822677,
-0.0513532571,
0.0240397006,
0.0344776399,
-0.0182870291,
0.0508216508,
-0.0249714535,
-0.0640058666,
0.0593694374,
-0.0713441446,
-0.0220027938,
0.0171715077,
0.0175517835,
0.0655755699,
-0.023054868,
0.045576334,
0.0218881108,
0.0305591598,
-0.07994017,
-0.0540922806,
-0.0223654173,
-0.0061704228,
-0.0386174805,
-0.0010428777,
-0.0400274917,
0.0337032229,
-0.0238514803,
0.0247048512,
0.0000910294,
0.040353477,
0.0070067067,
0.0132590327,
-0.0081292065,
0.0076433979,
-0.0434549861,
0.0296363942,
-0.0634522587,
0.0133141028,
0.0029821272,
-0.0733487383,
0.0214584768,
0.0163500197,
0.0074437317,
-0.0216000378,
0.0247029085,
0.025841305,
-0.0326016247,
0.0018414742,
-0.0394877195,
-0.0199908298,
0.0063856319,
-0.040209461,
0.0169054642,
-0.119345665,
0.0633886829,
0.029821679,
-0.0126852486,
-0.0300726052,
0.0122606782,
0.0638636127,
-0.0103137605,
0.0475367494,
-0.0227664672,
0.0380873159,
0.0557944179,
0.0056419736,
0.0326412581,
0.0869699121,
0.0427342318,
-0.0225308556,
0.0955758244,
-0.0103059094,
-0.0210221745,
0.0366288386,
0.0206371751,
0.0261110123,
0.0079290718,
0.0829484612,
0.0226452351,
-0.0064130509,
-0.0067573977,
0.0611066744,
0.0114572998,
-0.0421297774,
0.0198805556,
0.04775998,
-0.0142500997,
0.0542423762,
0.0250017866,
0.0116037531,
0.0402709246,
-0.0018466498,
0.0239896551,
0.0204859376,
-0.0078213224,
0.0024243311,
0.0400351658,
0.058142636,
-0.0424516685,
-0.0591323823,
-0.0306371376,
0.005440874,
0.0072810557,
0.0369200818,
0.0574636981,
0.0198071711,
-0.0075243721,
0.0447657742,
0.0444100834,
-0.0447478779,
0.0126175638,
-0.032449007,
0.0749816447,
0.0319945402,
0.0369370766,
-0.0177421905,
0.002829022,
0.0028704163,
0.0498326942,
0.0408384353,
0.0303484835,
-0.0727170482,
-0.0277038068,
-0.029354848,
0.0197748207,
0.0066077914,
-0.0266273152,
0.0109712984,
0.0348618105,
0.0179687683,
0.0091170836,
-0.0317263715,
-0.0244861059,
0.0121605927,
-0.0543441921,
-0.0073785488,
0.0314523317,
0.003063539,
-0.007708651,
0.0516430475,
0.024295276,
0.0141584082,
0.0451567024,
-0.0351557657,
-0.0105236992,
-0.0093285246,
-0.0068230741,
-0.0672075078,
0.0429284014,
-0.0412213132,
-0.0136216767,
0.0484204255,
-0.0372924209,
-0.0538828224,
0.0084939571,
-0.0232678168,
-0.0164607465,
-0.0550068133,
-0.0052363425,
0.0158248842,
-0.0124398731,
-0.0451679043,
0.0588021576,
0.0027926406,
0.0667247921,
0.0345944092,
0.0204018373,
0.0524749681,
-0.0363249294,
-0.010396285,
0.0440033898,
-0.0095618246,
0.0218940321,
0.0411322527,
0.0121026132,
-0.0501881242,
0.0150027173,
-0.0816544741,
0.0311560258,
-0.0189258046,
0.0414967537,
0.042579975,
0.0071159368,
-0.0024895382,
0.0062481798,
-0.0677245036,
-0.0274933893,
0.0637297183,
0.0220619123,
0.0223795157,
0.0105679408,
0.0228418279,
-0.0208099615,
-0.0268637221,
-0.0121296439,
0.0423405543,
0.0327204317,
0.0494759344,
-0.046815984,
0.0238627922,
-0.0491920151,
-0.0014720504,
0.0022331211,
-0.0564082153,
-0.0034941761,
-0.0089444667,
-0.0029296831,
0.0284329299,
-0.0012994825,
-0.0412244052,
0.0520069338,
0.0201870017,
-0.0319453329,
0.0134450877,
-0.0283162389,
-0.0105005074,
-0.0097281644,
-0.0725678727,
-0.0145367477,
0.0426009558,
0.0103657236,
-0.0275645033,
-0.0485469438,
0.0185105316,
-0.0364633426,
-0.0012421501,
-0.0399450101,
0.026262518,
0.0113523519,
0.0731773227,
-0.0225168224,
0.0029273112,
0.070465982,
-0.0262395088,
-0.0026309879,
-0.09025646,
-0.0109365424,
-0.070274137,
0.0378534272,
-0.0217360351,
0.0027595216,
-0.0484590568,
0.0370244756,
-0.0568403043,
-0.0141500942,
0.0122437933,
-0.03459052,
0.0434073023,
-0.0740928054,
-0.0006254839,
-0.0229935609,
-0.0227119289,
-0.0378927141,
-0.0256071985,
-0.0059437384,
0.0069464785,
0.007124994,
0.0174110103,
0.0179585945,
-0.0112383058,
0.0116783166,
0.0164304338,
-0.0224708393,
0.0089806067,
0.0056710308,
0.0793990865,
0.0601269417,
0.002052065,
0.0283744261,
-0.0079231644,
0.0702995211,
0.0617063642,
0.0312535055,
-0.0048560975,
0.0138344327,
-0.0232807826,
0.016150387,
-0.0027981938,
0.0090917191,
-0.0131709278,
0.0212571193,
-0.0343871787,
-0.0304241795,
0.0891413316,
0.0597239286,
-0.0309153311,
-0.0186714567,
-0.0333645828,
-0.0013819112,
0.036859367,
0.0484819785,
-0.0909703746,
-0.012157632,
-0.0303903762,
0.0313688926,
-0.0360254943,
-0.0117549663,
-0.0165317953,
-0.1493642926,
0.008843475,
-0.0226424485,
-0.0566425957,
-0.0076438012,
-0.086286895,
-0.0179115962,
-0.0140368761,
-0.0127012869,
0.0107819447,
0.0046496051,
0.0203296319,
0.0297701061,
-0.0384731553,
-0.0442298315,
0.0322165042,
-0.0036958326,
0.0130398693,
0.0279690996,
0.043197576,
-0.0169178247,
-0.0272622481,
0.0082251895,
-0.0896291211,
-0.0421945192,
-0.0023355829,
0.011240677,
0.027571246,
-0.0205168128,
-0.0152566852,
0.0341198593,
-0.0534310453,
-0.0151138827,
0.0759593248,
0.0813823417,
-0.0027167234,
0.0184953921,
-0.0030557604,
0.0095670922,
-0.0002453389,
0.0744163319,
0.0237293318,
-0.0388810076,
0.001139633,
-0.0266602989,
-0.0288319066,
-0.0753427371,
0.0033664552,
0.0347830132,
0.0008292409,
-0.0011905432,
-0.0930006504,
-0.0515765324,
0.0695410967,
0.0106638381,
-0.0038385158,
0.0146497516,
-0.0117419818,
0.0220686682,
-0.0335833095,
0.0228374638,
-0.0443622321,
0.0022163044,
-0.0408954546,
-0.0196647234,
0.002565176,
-0.0583344959,
-0.0287365131,
0.0128023801,
-0.1158959717,
-0.0587071106,
-0.0111245653,
0.0406219624,
0.0185458418,
0.036498297,
-0.012474129,
-0.0259853378,
0.0257262643,
0.0162592679,
-0.0367421359,
0.0068223272,
-0.0037802197,
0.0192384738,
-0.0164697021,
0.0365740545,
-0.0389080085,
0.0106351357,
0.0067113941,
0.0369288735,
-0.0337516963,
-0.0357194282,
0.0355718769,
0.0297566038,
-0.0228716675,
0.0076892194,
0.0091057885,
-0.0221669246,
0.0293946806,
-0.0321161523,
-0.0231546573,
-0.0230390579,
0.0023084776,
0.009369255,
-0.0617307611,
-0.0067890007,
0.0025490462,
-0.0186006222,
0.0289694853,
-0.0194468871,
0.0234616138,
0.0251297541,
0.0224616695,
-0.0201122854,
-0.0052420436,
-0.0245308913,
-0.0268525481,
-0.0220323969,
0.0478936657,
-0.0170712918,
0.0593620539,
0.0093532428,
-0.0347478166,
0.02379594,
-0.0054575885,
-0.0465652868,
-0.0427355133,
-0.0021998913,
0.0171629284,
0.043540176,
-0.0198345929,
0.0488649607,
-0.0098970011,
-0.0402894281,
-0.0189794619,
0.0078006191,
0.0265758932,
-0.0367817208,
0.0466210432,
0.0201467182,
-0.0148769105,
0.0219968054,
0.0790347606,
-0.0122613776,
0.024566453,
0.0036545317,
-0.0222941991,
-0.02109362,
-0.0276845004,
-0.0244123433,
-0.0169041827,
-0.0318517946,
-0.0147901876,
-0.0477690473,
-0.0807206705,
-0.011430352,
0.0415636301,
-0.0005531349,
-0.0030726101,
0.0377294645,
0.0781706125,
0.0177882109,
0.0021609487,
-0.0648651794,
0.0441876538,
-0.0689275265,
-0.0200056937,
0.0128668789,
-6.166948993e-33,
-0.0182926636,
-0.0258629043,
0.005399555,
-0.0310494974,
0.0553853512,
-0.0140589159,
-0.0401660316,
-0.0119913761,
-0.0388381965,
0.0130157936,
-0.0219027083,
-0.0073974747,
0.0052674459,
0.034959022,
0.0179211777,
-0.0281945039,
-0.001956047,
-0.0166384894,
-0.0179463513,
0.023039259,
0.0503881015,
-0.0140670054,
0.0531895161,
-0.0092974929,
0.0394868515,
-0.0508852452,
0.0022864682,
0.030682005,
-0.0142862834,
0.0829452723,
-0.0000978611,
0.0504549257,
0.0361108035,
-0.0636131838,
0.012807183,
0.0437247418,
-0.1031857058,
-0.0448788553,
0.0531452633,
-0.0077524045,
-0.0531209409,
-0.035580229,
-0.0083983447,
-0.0137694832,
0.0144728906,
0.0149613963,
0.0436338894,
-0.044671651,
0.0072668176,
-0.0261787903,
-0.0051613082,
0.0137295313,
-0.0361907817,
-0.0077767898,
-0.038063921,
0.0855645016,
-0.0200447887,
0.0319032893,
-0.0278544296,
0.0184351746,
-0.012269536,
0.0145234531,
0.0628245249,
-0.0132469228,
0.0057659768,
0.0360507257,
-0.0053396672,
0.0044217659,
0.0083182221,
0.0080292327,
-0.0079582939,
-0.0131448703,
0.0742731541,
0.1011141539,
0.0009919455,
-0.0102674253,
-0.1148484573,
0.0537880994,
-0.0002062648,
0.0176491868,
0.0241278578,
-0.0533958152,
-0.0199139938,
-0.0353619047,
-0.0471040048,
-0.0048238588,
-0.0347864963,
-0.0398308001,
0.0299656168,
-0.0130617153,
-0.0585110784,
-0.0187157057,
0.0337820798,
-0.0365919136,
0.0077585052,
0.0244502462,
-0.0334331766,
0.0168115124,
-0.010748703,
0.0484233983,
-0.0495009199,
0.0378379524,
-0.0054983618,
-0.0231677126,
0.0070490441,
0.0259061214,
0.0333650261,
-0.0171325058,
-0.0447905771,
0.0148478104,
-0.0562259592,
0.0305970442,
-0.0312602818,
0.007459539,
0.0066478038,
0.040939223,
-0.0087773772,
0.0527719632,
0.0271376129,
0.0017923217,
-0.0194096249,
-0.0246995054,
-0.003589507,
-0.0026362704,
-0.0400531627,
0.0010374165,
-0.0421313792,
0.0182726085,
0.0131672453,
-0.0391243026,
0.0110094631,
0.0235622562,
2.64e-7,
0.0598507412,
0.0157440361,
0.0062825638,
0.0295836534,
0.0192432627,
0.0024554818,
-0.0199975632,
-0.0081119994,
0.0224319585,
-0.0003613709,
0.0147648342,
0.0415309891,
0.0606262088,
0.072352007,
-0.1001932546,
0.0194618627,
-0.0474595651,
-0.0293160435,
-0.0537950695,
0.0209044572,
0.0441495776,
0.0768035203,
0.0126639986,
-0.0205197297,
-0.0793674067,
-0.0289045498,
0.0571307465,
-0.014978786,
-0.0593770519,
0.024804784,
0.0230930261,
0.0215616282,
0.0135892779,
0.0201602262,
-0.0293998774,
0.0033993176,
0.0287629794,
0.0588383749,
0.0350310393,
-0.0295746736,
0.0108115524,
-0.0521020032,
0.0107702427,
-0.0763303563,
0.1161664054,
-0.0228629727,
-0.011961787,
-0.0352888331,
0.0072303438,
-0.0185729638,
0.0061050323,
-0.0305316858,
-0.0125029022,
0.0196804609,
0.0093573909,
-0.0308311582,
0.0417607054,
-0.0268968791,
-0.0034225967,
0.0115748923,
-0.0349841714,
-0.0624417216,
-0.0050792587,
0.0040387264,
-0.0181324854,
-0.0431722291,
0.0252417438,
2.38867179e-34,
0.0351593085,
0.0128363334,
-0.0167306513,
-0.0008316243,
0.0276539922,
-0.0284969285,
0.0039302497,
-0.0047500334,
0.0143054808,
-0.0665937811,
-0.0146170165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14408v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14408v2 | FVEL: Interactive Formal Verification Environment with Large Language Models via Theorem Proving | 2024-06-20T15:31:05 | 2024-06-21T02:51:41 | Xiaohan Lin, Qingxing Cao, Yinya Huang, Haiming Wang, Jianqiao Lu, Zhengying Liu, Linqi Song, Xiaodan Liang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Formal verification (FV) has witnessed growing significance with current
emerging program synthesis by the evolving large language models (LLMs).
However, current formal verification mainly resorts to symbolic verifiers or
hand-craft rules, resulting in limitations for extensive and flexible
verification. On the other hand, formal languages for automated theorem
proving, such as Isabelle, as another line of rigorous verification, are
maintained with comprehensive rules and theorems. In this paper, we propose
FVEL, an interactive Formal Verification Environment with LLMs. Specifically,
FVEL transforms a given code to be verified into Isabelle, and then conducts
verification via neural automated theorem proving with an LLM. The joined
paradigm leverages the rigorous yet abundant formulated and organized rules in
Isabelle and is also convenient for introducing and adjusting cutting-edge
LLMs. To achieve this goal, we extract a large-scale FVELER3. The FVELER
dataset includes code dependencies and verification processes that are
formulated in Isabelle, containing 758 theories, 29,125 lemmas, and 200,646
proof steps in total with in-depth dependencies. We benchmark FVELER in the
FVEL environment by first fine-tuning LLMs with FVELER and then evaluating them
on Code2Inv and SV-COMP. The results show that FVEL with FVELER fine-tuned
Llama3- 8B solves 17.39% (69 -> 81) more problems, and Mistral-7B 12% (75 ->
84) more problems in SV-COMP. And the proportion of proof errors is reduced.
Project page: https://fveler.github.io/. | [
-0.0228053275,
0.0743939206,
-0.013463757,
0.0787177831,
-0.0180905033,
-0.0109798182,
-0.052923616,
-0.0004775646,
-0.0025868155,
0.0186806805,
0.0017954158,
0.0367321633,
0.02100637,
0.040070653,
0.0320885442,
-0.0077433777,
0.0285817944,
-0.0475686491,
-0.0443448573,
-0.023456078,
-0.0194203202,
-0.0117969085,
0.009652894,
0.0110493796,
-0.0071002096,
-0.0358653106,
0.0069158906,
0.0195410922,
0.0081662983,
-0.0526343249,
-0.0170123801,
0.0231487341,
0.0116616059,
0.0604936369,
0.0000023741,
-0.043833904,
0.0305336714,
0.0704349205,
-0.0232588276,
0.0464184657,
-0.0592709035,
0.0011707651,
-0.0057410393,
0.0375149474,
-0.0220228415,
-0.0139695751,
0.0079853749,
0.0015486077,
0.1141233742,
0.0361283161,
0.0015645931,
-0.0571815446,
0.0544797182,
-0.0029509445,
-0.0051347739,
-0.0570896156,
0.0044694906,
-0.0074554607,
0.0188153572,
-0.0240369365,
0.0350798778,
0.0357625075,
0.0935782492,
-0.0286494344,
-0.0458213389,
0.0356289297,
-0.0200989041,
-0.014804096,
-0.0042408975,
0.0535233244,
-0.0191998538,
-0.0510036498,
-0.0356400311,
0.01849626,
-0.0520242453,
0.0019193949,
-0.0302903745,
0.0314622298,
-0.0123125892,
0.0010926693,
0.0183584522,
-0.0536124036,
0.0604080968,
-0.0321305431,
-0.0299116392,
0.0870964304,
0.0408880785,
-0.0255340785,
-0.0220824219,
-0.0282000303,
-0.0286231227,
-0.0489283428,
0.0055769016,
0.0504367352,
-0.016295217,
-0.019353414,
0.0136746326,
0.0216353349,
0.0242887456,
-0.0594257936,
-0.021221973,
0.009225389,
-0.0066186092,
-0.0026299306,
-0.0405305251,
0.0165117607,
-0.0374509729,
0.0318266004,
0.0121194934,
-0.0109111238,
-0.0285903532,
0.0143701192,
-0.0327095278,
0.0278367605,
-0.0173110142,
0.0244605485,
-0.0471751839,
0.0092683258,
-0.0340425372,
0.1141161844,
-0.0437266938,
-0.0347031541,
0.0432197899,
0.0187701043,
-0.0030799801,
-0.0696611404,
-0.0451262034,
-0.0503247753,
-0.0154657634,
-0.0368004628,
-0.0118756341,
0.0253101289,
-0.0552863888,
0.016869003,
0.0245710742,
0.0437172726,
0.0202704538,
0.0159837231,
-0.0054205144,
0.0051014828,
0.0379085466,
-0.0786162093,
0.0113382032,
-0.1075154021,
0.0000958186,
-0.001252147,
0.0072988453,
-0.0372065306,
-0.0075067147,
0.0050477502,
0.0499855168,
0.0508678071,
-0.0118705695,
0.0064612068,
0.0177862737,
0.0232624654,
0.0059875268,
-0.0081300857,
0.0474362187,
-0.0120957438,
-0.0028973864,
-0.005371748,
0.0451267622,
0.0512841418,
0.0065845763,
0.0009119504,
-0.0399141647,
0.019512767,
0.0033880258,
0.0287694354,
-0.0547574125,
0.0943409875,
-0.0188312642,
-0.0075774412,
-0.0352826938,
0.0136040766,
0.0358918421,
-0.0143350353,
0.0536692068,
0.0045622448,
0.0889498219,
-0.0160551034,
-0.0880402774,
0.0518413894,
-0.0453169122,
0.0015294714,
-0.0306737237,
0.0376322158,
-0.0235281438,
-0.0774015337,
-0.0456616804,
0.007153844,
-0.0405754596,
-0.0089104641,
0.0256925281,
0.0153481718,
-0.0131550785,
0.0314777158,
0.0182875469,
-0.0537725687,
-0.0487718843,
-0.0616895035,
0.0827057213,
0.0107479747,
0.0653007627,
-0.0629937127,
0.0152273439,
-0.0030928762,
-0.0551834404,
0.0860946104,
0.0006717182,
-0.0113270087,
0.0012739463,
-0.0164557565,
0.0012492009,
-0.0229942687,
0.015462908,
0.0180347115,
0.062468484,
-0.0115658585,
0.0144783892,
0.008179958,
-0.0579370931,
0.0440300703,
0.0018079894,
-0.0402559638,
0.008099976,
0.0114244707,
0.0241177212,
-0.0389350951,
-0.0561473593,
0.0187409259,
0.0459586419,
-0.0118974783,
0.0125991227,
-0.0385409333,
0.0026972564,
-0.0313000754,
0.0141253415,
-0.0207054187,
-0.0433695838,
0.0511617176,
-0.0706478283,
0.0149273323,
0.0486963615,
-0.0014165944,
-0.0060489969,
-0.0177673008,
0.0208536107,
-0.0046879114,
0.0113770505,
0.0138686104,
0.0017050111,
0.0035021913,
-0.0372675061,
0.022689322,
0.0212739911,
-0.0119593116,
0.029885564,
-0.0314432681,
0.0243450236,
-0.0055139149,
0.0568711385,
-0.0089755803,
0.0321232714,
0.011839468,
-0.0297873467,
-0.0162866525,
0.0238605402,
-0.0021790743,
0.0320296586,
0.010173765,
0.0166129936,
-0.000733762,
0.0036521428,
-0.0009644261,
0.0114803091,
0.0016773052,
-0.0126879262,
0.0425170213,
-0.0338808075,
-0.0809623227,
-0.0460062698,
0.0064109424,
-0.0245333314,
0.0427219719,
-0.0245814901,
-0.0411169305,
-0.0086143725,
-0.0128747188,
-0.032259535,
0.0338694975,
-0.0169593412,
0.0051817866,
0.0317012742,
-0.0126409288,
0.0033525024,
0.0209741686,
-0.0125193624,
0.006973241,
0.050110694,
-0.0067044459,
-0.0477700643,
0.033069361,
0.057675682,
-0.0244691838,
0.0029819745,
0.005696401,
0.0430361852,
0.0449608192,
-0.0588608049,
-0.0080168461,
0.0058408775,
0.0379026681,
0.0210669357,
0.0276190825,
0.0130722104,
-0.0132919438,
-0.0232585669,
0.0068688239,
-0.0181124434,
-0.0801654905,
0.0617516339,
-0.0818972662,
-0.0140068047,
-0.0032111953,
-0.0322502665,
-0.0665546581,
0.0680541173,
0.0212168805,
-0.0092530074,
-0.0018268159,
0.0191037338,
0.0002342955,
-0.0523075275,
0.0259346701,
-0.0041648545,
0.0507495217,
-0.0208905973,
0.0189617872,
-0.0029994184,
-0.0251794625,
-0.0496238433,
0.0248234402,
-0.0572227798,
0.0337597281,
-0.0528519787,
-0.0430362895,
-0.0052912026,
-0.0086981561,
-0.0056603863,
0.0244056918,
0.0230060238,
-0.0275193043,
-0.0194496252,
-0.0099018496,
-0.0383323207,
-0.0214536507,
0.01090963,
-0.0508656651,
0.0269355197,
0.0268234219,
-0.0153197479,
0.0695803463,
-0.067799069,
-0.0231469758,
-0.0025412634,
-0.0335438102,
0.0126951896,
0.0226879623,
-0.0174651481,
-0.0611601993,
-0.0068788519,
0.0753938034,
0.0153159229,
-0.0108386017,
0.0243016146,
-0.0207417626,
0.026235722,
0.0365479179,
0.0976656005,
-0.0961573645,
-0.0200865921,
0.0095999027,
-0.0290756002,
0.0155585967,
0.0194803439,
-0.0266123097,
-0.0890391022,
0.0556764267,
0.0281972382,
0.0053206547,
0.0156399645,
-0.0044115735,
-0.0114072179,
0.0379540361,
-0.0017807605,
0.0155411232,
0.005784539,
-0.030622907,
-0.0217346363,
-0.0028739965,
-0.0348502547,
0.0898727402,
-0.0440371409,
0.019682372,
0.0240118671,
0.0205775388,
-0.042009227,
-0.0611598752,
0.0814981163,
0.0344557762,
0.0053358194,
-0.0227480642,
-0.0221362822,
0.0212649014,
-0.0014937579,
0.0078240801,
-0.0103096012,
-0.0031294185,
-0.0531326234,
0.0566490404,
0.0547649153,
0.0096621374,
-0.0547533855,
-0.0115434425,
0.0055475347,
-0.040709056,
-0.0067449706,
0.0215035919,
0.0396582671,
-0.0237216968,
-0.0526351817,
-0.0719118863,
-0.0137526207,
-0.0351455398,
-0.0063702003,
0.0232789367,
-0.0233245697,
-0.0284428019,
0.0665302649,
0.0250919238,
0.0441732816,
0.0018102569,
-0.0517533422,
0.0409608707,
-0.0178111698,
-0.0633207038,
0.0349807069,
-0.0577813461,
0.0606587082,
-0.0181602444,
0.0297250059,
0.0007123812,
0.0145764127,
-0.0251981094,
0.0521613471,
-0.0426984765,
-0.0468844213,
-0.0411381312,
0.0655234903,
0.0185591299,
0.0419627205,
-0.0311970469,
-0.0132920863,
0.0098856818,
0.0632895455,
0.005886741,
-0.0067367004,
0.0310268495,
-0.0578176416,
0.0082246913,
-0.0162760019,
-0.0296667125,
0.0014799271,
0.0316178724,
-0.0122540221,
0.0524132438,
-0.0162689909,
0.0353229344,
0.0990017951,
0.0038717196,
0.0200570337,
-0.0216491949,
-0.0232229494,
0.0158185083,
0.0056989659,
-0.0194293968,
-0.0487028249,
0.0504113026,
-0.0388148203,
-0.032859724,
0.0093164593,
-0.0037330908,
0.013221967,
-0.0056027076,
0.0279204641,
0.0280873924,
-0.0429428108,
0.0700100511,
0.0573379993,
-0.026773395,
-0.0070958887,
0.0023786312,
0.0089285439,
0.0486584529,
-0.0147530586,
-0.0065755299,
0.0296323616,
0.0537855625,
-0.0628643185,
-0.0037780281,
-0.0092776194,
-0.0759316683,
-0.0107956752,
0.0471301489,
0.0625805855,
0.0622824393,
-0.000465637,
-0.0464075394,
0.0291917436,
-0.0118930172,
0.0401638113,
-0.0273939576,
-0.0320866294,
0.0364269614,
0.0442390777,
0.0254774485,
-0.0317086056,
0.0370818973,
-0.0203044415,
0.0463593528,
0.0250859335,
0.0333880596,
-0.0450162254,
-0.0065924046,
-0.0283553302,
-0.0180245601,
-0.0271730404,
-0.0262945965,
-0.0141385868,
-0.0734951198,
0.0361203365,
0.0641931593,
-0.0185596179,
0.0309938788,
0.0083478922,
0.040592555,
0.0695780367,
-0.0499528497,
0.0208247527,
-0.0356627293,
0.0452764407,
-0.0715382397,
0.0308319218,
-5.932454033e-33,
-0.0096880272,
0.0065587023,
0.0395121872,
0.0243199058,
-0.0258864202,
-0.0317413956,
-0.0861272812,
-0.0473107286,
0.0210047532,
0.0302044731,
0.0221481863,
0.0331860259,
0.0007841747,
-0.031254489,
0.0022328985,
0.0020055394,
0.0408717878,
0.0575912967,
-0.0557689667,
0.0164000653,
-0.0445459634,
-0.0261404756,
0.0429657139,
-0.0085579054,
0.0032767074,
-0.0017218182,
0.0048737046,
0.052139014,
-0.1032468155,
0.064558953,
0.0075698211,
0.0070656068,
-0.0231237113,
0.0083085066,
0.0000073806,
-0.0243353192,
-0.042858582,
-0.0389022492,
0.0325197019,
-0.0247350931,
-0.0303148944,
-0.0331191197,
0.0631253123,
0.0242379475,
-0.0196800921,
0.0142675303,
0.0077270917,
0.0020689596,
0.0195605606,
-0.0366225094,
-0.0576025359,
0.0401357189,
-0.0322329625,
-0.0365558453,
-0.0241269749,
-0.0074342466,
-0.0216005817,
-0.027203083,
-0.031594187,
-0.0194544587,
-0.0022142373,
-0.011549281,
0.0619373247,
-0.0238488074,
0.0020859691,
0.0230032261,
0.0558038317,
-0.0060373722,
-0.0731603131,
0.0200598184,
0.0266203936,
0.0787591189,
0.038928926,
0.0007910012,
0.0159590151,
0.0232947916,
-0.057885997,
0.0199702159,
0.0075792628,
0.0760590211,
-0.0090754032,
-0.0073084678,
-0.0278552771,
-0.0203813668,
-0.0556916818,
0.0206309278,
-0.0428321585,
0.0219206829,
0.0047644493,
-0.0088545512,
-0.0172597095,
-0.0393507481,
-0.0248221792,
-0.0588254333,
-0.0122839129,
-0.0077950838,
-0.0006864691,
-0.0076447637,
-0.0084038787,
0.0345595181,
0.0372969061,
0.0026197315,
-0.0417279527,
-0.0359006859,
0.0512385517,
0.0072895153,
0.0187647957,
0.0513471328,
-0.0302679725,
0.0126041798,
-0.081010133,
-0.0292540956,
0.0320859477,
0.0170110408,
0.0107604088,
0.0108642569,
0.0105788792,
0.0268374421,
-0.0399636738,
-0.0182936303,
-0.0232864525,
0.0895428881,
0.0542052314,
0.0550899841,
0.0030000038,
-0.0319322161,
-0.0742019564,
0.036728479,
0.0418598317,
-0.0608330555,
-0.0183324367,
-0.0051493663,
3.104e-7,
-0.0228042733,
0.0190246478,
0.0365729108,
0.0802400857,
-0.0078404341,
0.0213174112,
-0.0495948568,
-0.0036566411,
-0.0102673136,
-0.0093634715,
-0.0382370241,
0.0709073171,
0.0444593355,
0.045705568,
-0.0241803285,
0.0101623554,
-0.0715320557,
-0.0347447544,
-0.0161582492,
-0.0167000592,
0.004024982,
0.0329162888,
0.052724652,
-0.0116990563,
0.0089514693,
-0.0436435491,
0.0263394713,
0.0316907726,
-0.0228804611,
0.0306484904,
-0.0374618582,
0.0044763237,
0.0512816384,
-0.0053447713,
0.0125541324,
0.0027468647,
-0.0555813573,
0.048122786,
-0.01194668,
0.0830768719,
-0.017806625,
-0.0292628855,
-0.0036126263,
-0.0293296091,
0.0352081694,
-0.0283999238,
-0.0246297456,
-0.0269665364,
-0.0101008974,
-0.0403650291,
0.0306018889,
-0.0034880403,
0.0014563351,
0.0202521756,
-0.0031257945,
-0.0225060396,
-0.0316818915,
-0.0337119401,
-0.0654900372,
0.0170994587,
-0.0221659392,
-0.0329985172,
-0.0126227625,
0.0030985589,
-0.0029029094,
-0.0210128073,
0.0235245526,
3.014815157e-34,
0.0391048864,
-0.0200995337,
0.0277758073,
0.0389781445,
0.0317715034,
-0.0043121902,
-0.0188960768,
0.0110558681,
-0.0021963893,
-0.0180367902,
-0.0213522688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14394v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14394v1 | SEC-QA: A Systematic Evaluation Corpus for Financial QA | 2024-06-20T15:12:41 | 2024-06-20T15:12:41 | Viet Dac Lai, Michael Krumdick, Charles Lovering, Varshini Reddy, Craig Schmidt, Chris Tanner | cs.CL | cs.CL | The financial domain frequently deals with large numbers of long documents
that are essential for daily operations. Significant effort is put towards
automating financial data analysis. However, a persistent challenge, not
limited to the finance domain, is the scarcity of datasets that accurately
reflect real-world tasks for model evaluation. Existing datasets are often
constrained by size, context, or relevance to practical applications. Moreover,
LLMs are currently trained on trillions of tokens of text, limiting access to
novel data or documents that models have not encountered during training for
unbiased evaluation. We propose SEC-QA, a continuous dataset generation
framework with two key features: 1) the semi-automatic generation of
Question-Answer (QA) pairs spanning multiple long context financial documents,
which better represent real-world financial scenarios; 2) the ability to
continually refresh the dataset using the most recent public document
collections, not yet ingested by LLMs. Our experiments show that current
retrieval augmented generation methods systematically fail to answer these
challenging multi-document questions. In response, we introduce a QA system
based on program-of-thought that improves the ability to perform complex
information retrieval and quantitative reasoning pipelines, thereby increasing
QA accuracy. | [
0.0128765162,
0.0728581399,
-0.0108248098,
0.0198415015,
0.0079204123,
0.0075817714,
0.0084264902,
0.0106627932,
-0.0104163745,
-0.0264117178,
-0.018554952,
-0.0268880893,
-0.033664342,
0.0608738586,
0.0259745512,
-0.0109100938,
0.0203217603,
0.0034688055,
0.0429339372,
-0.0002623148,
0.0260866079,
-0.0005317988,
0.000004542,
0.0040499307,
-0.0054672891,
-0.0289360546,
-0.0421064682,
-0.0155237373,
0.0076472606,
-0.0332920365,
0.0039116526,
0.0278797001,
0.0415930264,
0.0285005346,
0.0000020591,
-0.0581412315,
-0.0509398952,
-0.0015099582,
-0.0378263779,
-0.0269590169,
0.0046521714,
0.0017243964,
0.0562254861,
0.0255149361,
-0.0828727037,
0.0434983596,
0.0418440364,
0.0368337706,
0.0940263644,
0.0773798451,
-0.0081604263,
-0.0359315313,
0.0224615633,
-0.0380908214,
0.03691433,
-0.0926109329,
0.0122279264,
0.0267173387,
0.0279494356,
0.0066828914,
0.0167741552,
0.0325541049,
0.0083670095,
-0.0210070834,
0.0431466326,
-0.0037199399,
-0.0422981903,
0.005187755,
-0.0394858867,
0.0746157467,
0.0422685444,
0.0333491452,
0.0242836643,
-0.0171811972,
0.0005011078,
0.0150018809,
-0.0354604162,
0.0244201254,
-0.0312904529,
-0.0157347564,
0.003112854,
0.0010402844,
-0.0230372716,
-0.0187228099,
-0.0592540875,
0.014782751,
-0.0331855007,
-0.0633173287,
0.0149877919,
0.0192601085,
-0.0139358761,
-0.0457803607,
0.0126363439,
0.0496673435,
-0.0158914663,
0.0012241169,
-0.0095932968,
-0.0659877658,
0.0169792194,
-0.0286589433,
0.0333968289,
0.0365304947,
0.0093102725,
0.04078646,
-0.013556649,
0.028576389,
0.0032390289,
-0.0377768688,
-0.0570341907,
0.0052005472,
-0.0679014996,
-0.0240845513,
-0.0401286446,
0.1060508341,
-0.0494345352,
-0.0222097412,
-0.0408384651,
0.0186841395,
-0.0234619696,
0.0328054316,
-0.0216401629,
0.0266777072,
-0.0386487506,
0.005252169,
-0.0723684952,
-0.0140401898,
-0.0586930476,
0.0309196096,
0.0057433746,
-0.0186186414,
-0.0042995173,
0.0154303946,
0.0009127741,
-0.0153129818,
0.0033635679,
0.0616883077,
-0.0071884445,
-0.02261048,
-0.0403582752,
-0.0833807066,
0.0180917885,
-0.0263294335,
-0.0226799678,
-0.0262900479,
0.0393242501,
0.0036475339,
-0.0615392886,
0.0160053428,
0.0089326268,
0.0433721952,
0.0104301982,
0.0783840045,
0.0104735401,
-0.0122116478,
0.0382989869,
-0.0351719186,
0.0169705618,
0.0589295775,
0.0141656017,
-0.0021897391,
0.0429043882,
0.0402752683,
0.0227743648,
0.0247683749,
0.036617972,
-0.0326449014,
0.0255931113,
0.1041861102,
-0.0002059387,
0.019581249,
0.0145348199,
0.0268426295,
-0.0102863843,
-0.0001466872,
0.0090190051,
0.0343945473,
0.061641451,
0.0033676599,
0.0151882339,
0.0388678126,
0.0388779081,
-0.024251204,
0.0316729359,
0.0249939002,
-0.0157170873,
0.0350686759,
0.0098145595,
-0.0193863548,
-0.0426836498,
-0.0491790362,
-0.0039225626,
0.0152159091,
-0.0386716984,
0.0166230816,
0.011034566,
-0.0057393885,
-0.0387544595,
0.0498268008,
-0.0226914007,
-0.0474813133,
-0.0322759002,
-0.0488569587,
0.0934311748,
0.057299532,
0.0552319288,
-0.058433257,
0.0073455661,
-0.0183893256,
0.0075788903,
0.0268995184,
0.0468690135,
-0.0291952994,
-0.0465395898,
-0.0398598202,
-0.0163037609,
-0.0157727804,
-0.005464423,
0.0067724637,
-0.0105540073,
0.0204764623,
0.0219199117,
-0.0219522323,
0.0091648912,
0.0347105935,
-0.0156733859,
-0.0654677078,
0.0318857543,
-0.0100521892,
0.0034705058,
0.0353423245,
-0.0167756211,
0.0380436108,
0.0077445498,
-0.013148752,
-0.0444743335,
-0.0130183436,
-0.0350133665,
-0.0049082693,
-0.0103250053,
-0.0185087807,
-0.0111485012,
-0.0098025454,
-0.0558310375,
-0.0225098468,
-0.0259936545,
-0.0386302769,
-0.0092185475,
-0.0613557547,
-0.035581179,
0.0402303487,
0.0178985652,
-0.0323047936,
0.0784230456,
0.0117737558,
0.0253684632,
0.023083644,
0.0205225796,
0.0367269292,
-0.066787675,
0.0611761101,
-0.0020015503,
-0.0422158949,
0.0295137204,
0.024005698,
0.0361866914,
-0.0355147645,
-0.0107157221,
-0.0729988441,
0.0033008561,
-0.0093396623,
0.0324939154,
0.0044656107,
0.0062191733,
-0.0112195993,
-0.0200322717,
-0.0596200377,
-0.0072156871,
0.01097799,
0.0140136611,
0.0763912722,
0.0122671686,
0.0293613672,
-0.0470451862,
0.0019773254,
-0.0069043417,
0.0487448275,
0.068558082,
0.0229254458,
-0.0061725406,
0.0008622844,
-0.0285206866,
0.0081298808,
-0.0015683599,
0.0517474264,
0.0283942688,
-0.027132649,
0.0158020575,
0.0582655929,
0.0402494632,
0.0192333944,
-0.0390237123,
-0.0038246301,
-0.0606010854,
0.0468823016,
-0.0171767641,
0.0047190604,
0.0337773152,
-0.0088426229,
0.0393811166,
0.0229013041,
-0.006201582,
-0.0073192902,
-0.0662700832,
0.0888982564,
0.0106149763,
-0.0102980034,
-0.069717519,
0.0016754527,
0.0030330759,
0.0843450874,
-0.0012177562,
-0.0157494955,
0.0698188543,
-0.0013960091,
-0.0222357716,
-0.0536234975,
-0.0012587571,
-0.0879414082,
0.0611998104,
-0.0420243517,
-0.0091824643,
-0.0284070875,
-0.0037509736,
-0.0500979498,
-0.025357876,
0.0177959912,
-0.0458309986,
0.0456658639,
-0.0326699726,
0.0351512209,
-0.007547454,
-0.0334334411,
-0.0466555469,
-0.0403765999,
0.0013312564,
-0.0088652419,
0.0310828798,
-0.0251611024,
-0.0328589454,
-0.0082659144,
0.0192372985,
0.0212485455,
-0.0312243477,
-0.0545488484,
0.0158733353,
0.0743725523,
0.0676900595,
0.0171475224,
0.0351339802,
-0.0258870162,
0.0684878007,
0.0488922745,
0.0573545955,
0.0106208799,
0.0267109517,
-0.0182094816,
-0.0287844576,
-0.0342394188,
0.0411569625,
0.0041035116,
0.0028327655,
-0.0458618887,
-0.0389875211,
0.0760404468,
0.0625443459,
0.0151039232,
-0.0074226796,
-0.0291886516,
0.0084443474,
0.0027967803,
0.072031267,
-0.1378997117,
-0.0136749223,
-0.019881079,
0.0539559722,
-0.011111524,
-0.059864942,
-0.0326075219,
-0.1273757368,
0.0554050356,
-0.0317208879,
-0.0031250729,
-0.0040537766,
-0.0521195568,
-0.0278365389,
-0.0250159819,
-0.0268117562,
0.0528142639,
-0.0080608651,
0.0196130592,
-0.0005911436,
-0.0309708472,
0.0155572966,
0.03307404,
0.0000192336,
-0.0530905239,
0.0378979221,
0.0217751376,
0.0137778679,
-0.0437319167,
-0.0354152173,
-0.0465919673,
-0.0080000926,
0.0161430407,
0.0447882824,
-0.0158731993,
-0.0245062336,
-0.000733659,
0.0670941398,
-0.0423127487,
0.0268556867,
0.0495974422,
0.0084910318,
-0.0385757536,
-0.0043445085,
-0.0484867841,
0.0043435572,
0.0017044467,
0.0653239414,
0.0024507232,
-0.0340622254,
-0.0299164653,
-0.0478391759,
0.0071369992,
-0.0953265131,
0.0281637926,
-0.0377290547,
0.0177115928,
0.0482142754,
-0.1026120782,
-0.0578442365,
0.0274256356,
0.0236631595,
-0.0169398524,
-0.040317215,
0.0273832884,
-0.0050338344,
-0.0595180541,
0.0202053078,
-0.0170100052,
0.0138458218,
-0.0035893668,
0.0129067916,
0.0090691512,
-0.0254171174,
-0.0586001016,
0.0486785695,
-0.0861775801,
-0.0229545068,
-0.0200563353,
-0.0046969787,
0.022452347,
-0.003659863,
-0.0171774738,
0.0373431742,
0.0708413944,
0.0713404864,
-0.0835009441,
-0.032711722,
0.0278224852,
0.0193299782,
-0.0041415715,
0.029975906,
-0.067655094,
0.0136593096,
-0.0479953997,
0.0424671732,
-0.0036252821,
-0.0015080723,
0.0064381263,
0.0132522602,
-0.0132819945,
0.0611304007,
-0.013603474,
-0.0313923173,
0.0072679189,
-0.0201163273,
-0.0122498786,
-0.0414722189,
0.002117919,
0.00267276,
-0.0356600396,
-0.0005327493,
0.0101104276,
-0.0367969833,
0.027230544,
-0.0194523036,
-0.0076868888,
0.0061447741,
0.0109007116,
0.0244901013,
-0.0418629311,
-0.0031173767,
-0.0082316762,
0.0111955991,
0.0326940157,
0.0102194594,
0.0280593187,
0.021338271,
0.0193355847,
0.0137729291,
-0.0162839387,
-0.0798041001,
-0.0511548966,
-0.0204117,
0.0349761657,
-0.0204602871,
0.0084188217,
-0.0355973169,
-0.0272583142,
0.0078981714,
0.0324741863,
0.0092650391,
0.0193309858,
-0.0287939832,
0.0212473311,
0.0317863524,
-0.0336397141,
-0.0374089442,
0.0820242763,
-0.027485989,
0.0049182936,
-0.0575482734,
-0.015953809,
-0.0606288724,
-0.0315946415,
0.0139491055,
0.0426445268,
0.0280234218,
-0.0076527763,
-0.0564390831,
-0.0489143766,
0.0319630168,
0.0180994123,
-0.0121939685,
0.0181840155,
0.0503040068,
0.0755822286,
0.0189543795,
0.0266783815,
-0.0111739915,
0.0257424135,
-0.0735092163,
-0.0422087871,
-0.0381813087,
-6.178316758e-33,
-0.002062761,
-0.036200624,
0.0569243059,
0.0006041147,
0.0147834308,
0.013597426,
-0.0316386223,
-0.0290643536,
0.0039962293,
-0.0049102157,
-0.0161132906,
0.0234903917,
0.0030996769,
0.034486603,
0.0217225198,
-0.0179133005,
0.0089385379,
-0.0510573387,
-0.0172719676,
0.0074825548,
0.0439139716,
0.0427649096,
0.0118416212,
-0.0236720927,
0.0354154892,
-0.0129998317,
-0.0353957675,
0.0130820768,
0.0251785126,
0.0627712384,
-0.0192951467,
0.055688303,
0.0228347275,
-0.0717783868,
-0.0068055294,
0.0290304944,
-0.0165547058,
-0.0685087666,
-0.0169291776,
-0.0187181588,
-0.0423401408,
0.0112774884,
0.0342109837,
-0.0113443239,
0.0054741381,
0.0001425629,
0.0346540287,
-0.0024271589,
0.035407763,
-0.0668311045,
-0.0462127924,
0.0153483944,
-0.0197960585,
0.0111442553,
-0.0137508968,
0.1087886691,
0.0105815418,
0.0330325067,
-0.0274617355,
0.0035048351,
0.0182353612,
0.0132258916,
0.0294771455,
-0.0163839962,
-0.0031629498,
0.0235555675,
-0.0091657899,
0.0094655771,
-0.0181037802,
-0.0050197123,
-0.0123451427,
0.033080101,
0.0551421456,
0.0514752232,
0.0174797904,
-0.0030099298,
-0.054185573,
0.0515507087,
-0.0173871163,
0.0410643592,
0.0078490619,
-0.0165497325,
-0.0089481864,
0.0003894998,
-0.0256390031,
0.0406177901,
-0.045097895,
0.0203979779,
0.0372979976,
0.0220622085,
-0.0217642374,
0.0061411653,
0.0099743642,
-0.0324819945,
-0.0397373624,
0.0015032117,
-0.0327345915,
0.0032387273,
0.0234174524,
0.0079958346,
-0.0407859832,
0.0052458858,
0.0189753827,
0.0337269083,
-0.0123127103,
-0.0045691971,
0.0253206156,
-0.0031077892,
-0.060428746,
-0.0194368437,
-0.0104146563,
0.0613515079,
-0.0238391981,
0.0009659191,
-0.0238117818,
0.0473909676,
-0.012584486,
0.0247246269,
-0.0191263761,
0.0108443853,
-0.0277373753,
-0.0247421134,
0.0038238131,
0.0457572453,
0.0145796081,
0.0173241459,
-0.0118676517,
0.0432980247,
0.0298125036,
-0.0484032743,
-0.0059270882,
0.0664338544,
2.794e-7,
0.0273116715,
0.0342231803,
0.0316633731,
0.0609314814,
0.0389197469,
0.0398811512,
-0.0010032085,
0.0280267503,
0.0031213979,
-0.0119615048,
0.0311189294,
0.0185071845,
0.0359531231,
0.0249627419,
-0.0917766765,
-0.0596539751,
-0.0732029825,
-0.0038456619,
-0.0857654512,
0.0171701722,
0.0703637227,
0.0462740734,
-0.0250538401,
-0.0314284526,
-0.0103653418,
-0.0703721941,
0.0599004775,
0.0050086034,
-0.0194708388,
0.0124767423,
0.0374643393,
0.0108037116,
0.0177381355,
0.0225939583,
-0.012457245,
0.0331348665,
0.0141144078,
0.0181975681,
0.0565994345,
-0.0332212597,
0.0058975909,
-0.0198755376,
0.0069808271,
-0.0448666848,
0.0727228895,
-0.081984289,
-0.0102676619,
-0.0320994854,
-0.0470439456,
0.0041570198,
0.027254194,
-0.0178376194,
0.0044813319,
0.0208009537,
0.0004530833,
-0.0035063715,
0.0488202907,
-0.0261071287,
-0.0059125638,
0.0181043986,
-0.0473044738,
0.0072706798,
-0.0445864871,
-0.0088463249,
0.0051102829,
-0.0592624135,
0.0069097159,
2.481513574e-34,
0.0635223165,
-0.03060559,
-0.0235138908,
0.0181834642,
0.0626251474,
-0.0072133713,
-0.0163757633,
0.029277321,
0.0087397406,
-0.0976530984,
-0.0093987398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14393v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14393v1 | Jailbreaking as a Reward Misspecification Problem | 2024-06-20T15:12:27 | 2024-06-20T15:12:27 | Zhihui Xie, Jiahui Gao, Lei Li, Zhenguo Li, Qi Liu, Lingpeng Kong | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The widespread adoption of large language models (LLMs) has raised concerns
about their safety and reliability, particularly regarding their vulnerability
to adversarial attacks. In this paper, we propose a novel perspective that
attributes this vulnerability to reward misspecification during the alignment
process. We introduce a metric ReGap to quantify the extent of reward
misspecification and demonstrate its effectiveness and robustness in detecting
harmful backdoor prompts. Building upon these insights, we present ReMiss, a
system for automated red teaming that generates adversarial prompts against
various target aligned LLMs. ReMiss achieves state-of-the-art attack success
rates on the AdvBench benchmark while preserving the human readability of the
generated prompts. Detailed analysis highlights the unique advantages brought
by the proposed reward misspecification objective compared to previous methods. | [
0.0239503551,
0.0473926142,
-0.0005955091,
0.041107852,
-0.0406730026,
-0.013162978,
0.019491272,
-0.0261770748,
0.0285840668,
-0.0166312866,
-0.02382157,
-0.0209465306,
0.0253347624,
0.0166237131,
0.0436195098,
0.011819805,
0.0627888963,
-0.0444034934,
-0.0034341267,
0.005561816,
0.0118983798,
-0.0042592944,
-0.0016944301,
0.035917215,
0.0182696469,
-0.0310422573,
-0.0284893923,
0.0144477151,
0.038949836,
-0.0335974917,
0.0066700606,
0.0361075327,
-0.042165108,
0.0790011808,
0.0000021523,
-0.0544272624,
-0.0424879715,
0.0034548368,
-0.0318782665,
0.0627528355,
-0.025733605,
-0.0513004847,
-0.0492146574,
0.0244576596,
-0.0312095508,
0.036430113,
0.0431807339,
0.033727631,
0.075932458,
0.0739710853,
0.0067825089,
0.0180474762,
0.0534002855,
-0.0461707115,
-0.010281546,
-0.0744883269,
0.0080844536,
-0.0180946328,
-0.0274276119,
0.0000816244,
0.0165661592,
0.0070816716,
0.0207444262,
-0.0182632376,
-0.0671334565,
0.0129617844,
-0.008258041,
-0.0018067837,
-0.0322643258,
0.0404472835,
-0.0496803932,
-0.0108621269,
0.00035642,
-0.0065183742,
0.0134568941,
-0.0025137728,
0.0181437992,
0.0209886432,
-0.0157716665,
-0.0068871416,
0.0146161327,
-0.0195963308,
0.0650300905,
-0.0114602773,
-0.0009619182,
0.0383142531,
0.0179248806,
-0.0408751667,
-0.0190205295,
-0.0284645781,
-0.0164835509,
-0.059115503,
-0.0217624623,
-0.0191531293,
-0.0234896336,
0.0115913581,
-0.1013298929,
-0.063009426,
0.03585146,
-0.0080894763,
0.0221844912,
0.0317821316,
-0.0013716748,
0.0391931757,
-0.0423410907,
0.0501158424,
-0.0366715342,
0.0594018288,
-0.0032778163,
0.0197078884,
0.0093305884,
-0.0100985747,
-0.0066737398,
-0.0220393352,
0.0061539733,
-0.0153645724,
-0.0345459133,
0.0424302109,
-0.0327140689,
0.0594779402,
-0.0447815396,
-0.0109155755,
-0.0149924355,
0.0131127127,
0.0379400477,
-0.0376801454,
0.0002904348,
-0.0362688527,
0.0047702612,
-0.0552451611,
-0.0385924056,
0.0088544898,
-0.104384616,
-0.0525831804,
-0.0211347863,
0.1219649538,
0.0202892292,
0.0051772003,
-0.0320471525,
-0.0583131537,
-0.0410237275,
-0.0164538547,
0.0086624147,
-0.0667586476,
-0.0262525901,
-0.0152767813,
-0.0132644596,
-0.0506161377,
0.0024286348,
-0.0141313467,
-0.0187945813,
0.0629463792,
0.0206508003,
-0.0093632238,
-0.0044708229,
0.0180434622,
0.022299476,
0.0731892809,
0.0149546666,
0.0822956935,
0.0460798591,
-0.0182967931,
0.0257695094,
0.0697193667,
0.0186765939,
0.0501101241,
-0.0405972637,
-0.0181065705,
0.0868358687,
0.0057258685,
0.0254482869,
0.0291049276,
0.0092280544,
-0.046101965,
0.0719147474,
0.027450379,
-0.0392332189,
-0.002158368,
-0.031794589,
-0.0302096792,
-0.0113480901,
0.0065154675,
-0.0692166239,
0.0243087653,
-0.0817016885,
-0.0232312661,
0.0103624538,
0.0372473821,
-0.0050856504,
0.0133654187,
0.0014887353,
-0.007924716,
-0.0072416817,
0.0135458866,
0.0164801385,
0.00625451,
-0.0403782986,
0.0242084451,
0.0080629485,
-0.0224442612,
-0.0360780023,
-0.0831568688,
-0.001934487,
0.0441906154,
0.0762641653,
-0.01254912,
0.0209822487,
-0.0113184359,
-0.0077886693,
0.0396952741,
0.039448522,
0.0168357454,
0.0032006605,
-0.0242966432,
-0.015512201,
-0.0357738361,
0.008904784,
0.0453420989,
0.0028403413,
-0.034484297,
-0.0274872277,
0.010635376,
-0.0540361963,
0.0422044806,
0.0211811997,
-0.0230431762,
-0.0010477015,
0.0487272702,
0.0316959955,
0.0104095405,
-0.0314274319,
0.0273895971,
0.0450067073,
-0.0055588344,
0.0381536782,
-0.0037407966,
-0.0102205584,
-0.0126326922,
0.0326199457,
-0.0195866469,
-0.0301267132,
0.092564024,
-0.044711519,
-0.0019785922,
0.0778477937,
-0.0266205184,
0.0373510309,
0.0157935116,
0.033038076,
-0.0205241498,
0.0265923403,
-0.049565088,
0.0054365993,
-0.0278632157,
-0.001421473,
-0.0286592189,
-0.0163083766,
0.0350488462,
-0.0189407393,
-0.054361172,
0.02155797,
-0.0255543049,
0.0237486176,
0.0115931015,
0.0109350756,
0.0038613002,
-0.0405261889,
-0.0008177269,
-0.0028763965,
-0.0203557368,
0.0425333939,
0.0628526956,
0.0038158542,
-0.0155433351,
-0.0201453064,
-0.0133806923,
-0.0368159153,
0.0019505116,
-0.0010701932,
0.0063260836,
-0.0220999476,
-0.053871125,
-0.0347593315,
-0.0184154306,
-0.0089772437,
0.0459843799,
-0.0036177118,
-0.0175480936,
-0.0259074345,
-0.0060837544,
0.0073162927,
0.0265833586,
-0.0247878004,
-0.0616740435,
0.0476562381,
0.0261162668,
-0.0199932959,
0.0730770603,
0.0072867647,
0.0383727737,
0.0763091296,
0.0360208414,
-0.0454318151,
-0.0228624027,
0.0318296701,
-0.0566596575,
-0.0264228713,
-0.0580626614,
0.0343270265,
0.0759859532,
0.0445950739,
0.0058604102,
-0.0224722438,
0.0052633029,
0.0141386222,
-0.0331065692,
-0.0294866972,
-0.033855509,
-0.0390692912,
-0.0004570372,
-0.0479048863,
-0.0900645107,
0.0788852051,
-0.0651775599,
0.0182672366,
-0.0233093258,
-0.0299384166,
0.0122030694,
0.0347337238,
-0.0271944609,
0.0315005779,
0.0339266323,
-0.0358691141,
-0.0359974988,
-0.0368780829,
0.0213972814,
-0.0081791487,
0.055440411,
-0.0247438401,
0.0149149066,
-0.0064046425,
0.0057587307,
-0.0641198456,
-0.0613020882,
-0.0166897904,
0.0021189053,
0.0313260891,
-0.0390311852,
-0.0281051546,
-0.0112941647,
0.0390363,
-0.007276366,
-0.002156347,
0.0032645776,
-0.0359679721,
0.0186888967,
0.0462872833,
-0.0659525245,
0.0179638024,
-0.0555089377,
0.0305386595,
0.059860684,
0.0342273675,
0.0577314533,
-0.0280006193,
-0.0341316983,
0.0338209271,
-0.0037067693,
0.0116712302,
0.0161735713,
0.0329604484,
-0.0285387523,
0.0161531735,
0.0418435261,
0.0299231298,
-0.0295113679,
0.0272427164,
0.0067163436,
0.0572508536,
0.0125823673,
0.0234949719,
-0.0907227993,
-0.0267313123,
0.0290654097,
0.063657701,
-0.0131890709,
-0.0096445475,
-0.0328081772,
-0.1152972355,
-0.0325559676,
0.0354769304,
-0.0449036956,
0.0070918789,
-0.0079881735,
-0.0138844876,
0.0153717119,
0.0453874841,
0.0064521115,
0.0227138158,
-0.0061945426,
0.0139094237,
-0.0320153013,
-0.0260111857,
0.0042488971,
-0.0460626073,
0.1070610285,
0.1302149594,
-0.0109414561,
-0.0190462787,
-0.0085437559,
0.0217070319,
-0.0081558675,
0.0072314413,
0.0465804636,
0.0276845433,
0.0066082082,
-0.0248360299,
0.0014641347,
0.0243366025,
-0.0133687425,
-0.0061275936,
0.0509383231,
0.0269272942,
-0.0203422029,
0.0062248204,
-0.0210000947,
-0.0294619203,
0.0554569066,
0.0505893007,
0.0171357282,
-0.0377091616,
-0.049108509,
-0.0652233064,
-0.0057246522,
-0.0647713691,
-0.0165145658,
0.0263409782,
-0.0012199503,
-0.0226085857,
-0.0472720414,
-0.0094493497,
-0.0179285463,
0.0366440341,
0.0525455922,
-0.0151151503,
-0.0758018494,
0.0070671849,
-0.0292266607,
0.0043844827,
-0.0053393324,
0.0833265111,
-0.0755454227,
0.0124217141,
-0.0673190877,
-0.0427407436,
-0.0082432358,
0.0143762315,
-0.0539569668,
-0.0967826694,
0.0253284983,
0.0360615626,
0.0237180013,
0.0073326579,
-0.0521448366,
-0.0611047,
0.0529009365,
0.039285019,
-0.0344028436,
0.024888115,
0.0676996335,
-0.0168186277,
-0.0014387273,
0.0228410438,
-0.0409736931,
-0.0124180689,
0.0647557527,
-0.0054219277,
-0.0134193683,
0.0150304614,
0.0297511052,
0.0380240232,
0.0362131037,
-0.046510905,
0.0143699786,
0.0147391502,
0.0074674501,
0.0001275492,
-0.022104552,
0.0085581858,
0.0033290875,
0.0229941849,
-0.0411796384,
0.0568558313,
0.0192781575,
-0.0080735181,
-0.0054872027,
-0.0112426123,
0.0297475718,
0.0280731879,
0.0792414173,
0.0659378022,
0.0243368447,
-0.0078166239,
0.0648949668,
-0.0106466785,
0.0305058267,
0.0193313248,
0.0431853049,
0.020385256,
-0.0218544025,
-0.0071982485,
0.0607258342,
-0.057649456,
-0.0566055216,
0.018907873,
0.0482442267,
0.0407996103,
0.032052543,
0.0280981138,
-0.0060367789,
-0.0010996815,
-0.0156123107,
-0.0236095078,
-0.0129960598,
-0.0442581065,
0.041930981,
0.0004122531,
-0.0043709502,
0.0228256397,
0.0487462617,
-0.0189080667,
0.0600857474,
-0.0214426219,
-0.0136688268,
-0.0242598113,
-0.016536396,
0.0646399856,
-0.0037005669,
-0.0675229952,
-0.0436334573,
-0.0632888079,
-0.0712786391,
-0.0370584652,
0.0613586642,
0.0232247245,
0.0134199299,
-0.0250645746,
0.0513258502,
-0.0198703799,
0.042879153,
-0.0627610385,
0.0136550786,
-0.0350373536,
-0.0657696128,
0.0081582181,
-6.081744387e-33,
0.0165361855,
-0.042517785,
-0.0416019186,
-0.0270715524,
-0.0148480283,
0.0357289948,
-0.0406852365,
0.0126765417,
-0.0256412774,
-0.0313636474,
0.0056753661,
-0.0115344366,
0.0061242781,
-0.0024460172,
-0.0269006379,
-0.0228158291,
0.0175353363,
-0.0028577289,
-0.0508654676,
0.0023482663,
0.0642025545,
-0.0021853982,
0.0228534192,
-0.0384699032,
0.0612549745,
-0.0068454579,
-0.058811266,
0.0265709162,
-0.0187538881,
0.038585443,
0.0166124906,
0.0041534142,
-0.0156642441,
-0.0208163746,
0.0102382265,
0.0571313687,
0.0357495546,
0.0075517455,
0.0209482573,
0.0153601291,
-0.0324217305,
-0.0273810327,
0.0096522858,
-0.0085505098,
-0.02179344,
0.0113988174,
0.0054273186,
-0.0101405801,
-0.0298652109,
0.0236539301,
-0.0148798209,
0.0139917638,
-0.0365769304,
-0.0181473978,
0.0017101238,
0.0020780154,
0.0185613763,
0.0010683525,
-0.0525700524,
0.0503625274,
0.0236787852,
0.0168025885,
0.0870497301,
0.0426130742,
-0.003796489,
0.0872238129,
0.0028909559,
-0.0270162318,
0.0092926659,
0.0142125003,
0.0141062886,
0.0244017765,
0.0741079375,
0.0545775965,
0.054901354,
-0.0293147806,
-0.0525564589,
0.0220615361,
0.0481531397,
0.0108668124,
0.0361537263,
0.0028069562,
-0.0725157633,
0.0064632553,
-0.00650565,
-0.0461276211,
-0.0199266989,
-0.072538726,
0.0192615446,
-0.0131954914,
-0.0388260707,
-0.0517743789,
0.0055056964,
-0.0354546681,
0.0084932782,
0.0534921624,
-0.0159412399,
-0.0035495907,
-0.0394509397,
0.0079999259,
-0.023469029,
-0.0017187598,
0.0072200485,
-0.030008886,
0.05235691,
0.0079482365,
0.0357172303,
0.025699703,
-0.0459699556,
0.0063445456,
-0.0324882716,
0.0481664836,
0.0071560205,
-0.0113032134,
0.0364929512,
-0.0464181863,
-0.0098432731,
-0.0075761615,
0.0102862902,
-0.0298330542,
-0.0268836021,
0.04380906,
-0.0269150324,
0.0228471234,
-0.0248140953,
0.0102594094,
0.0123880254,
0.0012963606,
0.0571612678,
-0.0553859659,
-0.0099355625,
-0.0443558171,
2.909e-7,
-0.0227647442,
-0.0013532345,
0.051472187,
-0.011397318,
0.0132355429,
0.0849896595,
-0.0368995517,
0.0804190859,
-0.0227920879,
-0.036004439,
-0.0510362983,
-0.0058426545,
0.0655334964,
0.0415256433,
-0.0212531723,
0.0469371043,
-0.0916099921,
0.0369013175,
-0.0620896406,
-0.0012826584,
0.0133068971,
0.0573012792,
0.0235124789,
-0.0353494212,
0.0111557627,
-0.0451949611,
-0.0106642991,
-0.0020314599,
-0.0194003861,
0.0073250872,
0.0552378036,
-0.0129385218,
-0.0109939575,
0.023355227,
-0.018538883,
-0.0185074639,
-0.0225020945,
0.0121732857,
0.0055981148,
-0.0249840319,
-0.0591025203,
-0.0297869369,
-0.0126062669,
-0.0458790958,
0.0440982431,
-0.001156131,
-0.0304246247,
-0.0591730736,
0.0260676816,
-0.0432119332,
0.0242118444,
-0.024999924,
0.0100515625,
-0.0017019021,
0.0131139765,
0.0026066983,
0.011268165,
-0.0552741885,
-0.0386288725,
0.0065294532,
-0.0012963521,
-0.0153133785,
-0.0023442507,
0.0545314886,
0.0222230442,
-0.0376745835,
0.0083887288,
2.823227027e-34,
-0.0039136256,
-0.0345135741,
0.0193476193,
-0.0178442821,
0.0100344429,
0.0045485115,
0.0245700758,
0.0146346353,
0.0142533528,
-0.0308100935,
-0.0265006516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14373v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14373v2 | Artificial Leviathan: Exploring Social Evolution of LLM Agents Through the Lens of Hobbesian Social Contract Theory | 2024-06-20T14:42:58 | 2024-07-01T22:06:13 | Gordon Dai, Weijia Zhang, Jinhan Li, Siqi Yang, Chidera Onochie lbe, Srihas Rao, Arthur Caetano, Misha Sra | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.MA | The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) and advancements in Artificial
Intelligence (AI) offer an opportunity for computational social science
research at scale. Building upon prior explorations of LLM agent design, our
work introduces a simulated agent society where complex social relationships
dynamically form and evolve over time. Agents are imbued with psychological
drives and placed in a sandbox survival environment. We conduct an evaluation
of the agent society through the lens of Thomas Hobbes's seminal Social
Contract Theory (SCT). We analyze whether, as the theory postulates, agents
seek to escape a brutish "state of nature" by surrendering rights to an
absolute sovereign in exchange for order and security. Our experiments unveil
an alignment: Initially, agents engage in unrestrained conflict, mirroring
Hobbes's depiction of the state of nature. However, as the simulation
progresses, social contracts emerge, leading to the authorization of an
absolute sovereign and the establishment of a peaceful commonwealth founded on
mutual cooperation. This congruence between our LLM agent society's
evolutionary trajectory and Hobbes's theoretical account indicates LLMs'
capability to model intricate social dynamics and potentially replicate forces
that shape human societies. By enabling such insights into group behavior and
emergent societal phenomena, LLM-driven multi-agent simulations, while unable
to simulate all the nuances of human behavior, may hold potential for advancing
our understanding of social structures, group dynamics, and complex human
systems. | [
0.0531120896,
0.0695668384,
-0.0370841101,
-0.0378781632,
-0.0606571846,
-0.0095331268,
0.0077576241,
0.0212910622,
0.0697866529,
-0.0058714384,
0.046599742,
0.0035397967,
-0.021150358,
-0.0238119215,
0.0316641927,
-0.0080888765,
0.0191819593,
-0.0381859951,
0.0012653552,
-0.0294124633,
-0.0355973467,
0.002232363,
0.0336237028,
-0.0113421166,
0.0236827992,
0.0335531421,
-0.0439120792,
-0.0021526162,
0.0298054367,
-0.0178930629,
-0.0102643063,
0.0217797682,
0.0541581623,
0.0192262717,
0.0000021882,
-0.0613847189,
0.0267403293,
-0.0059179533,
-0.0045454912,
-0.0098722409,
0.0839761868,
-0.0007062451,
-0.0116910506,
-0.0299697574,
-0.0609054454,
0.0404628888,
0.0011894767,
-0.0577784739,
0.0286641996,
0.0501700044,
0.0135397082,
-0.0204735491,
0.0479932502,
-0.0130795678,
-0.0052707293,
-0.0291055739,
0.0267714225,
-0.0075292657,
0.0531150959,
0.0007991592,
0.0108798966,
-0.0087564625,
0.0239788443,
-0.0257863402,
-0.0152589353,
0.0160647053,
-0.0125685697,
-0.0453785881,
-0.008273093,
0.0387328826,
0.0864135548,
-0.0105572408,
0.0205813963,
0.0373047218,
0.0096703777,
-0.0109540597,
0.0495274924,
0.0670501813,
0.0058461828,
0.0203464963,
0.0686944127,
0.007842592,
-0.0022382797,
0.011861572,
-0.0306433365,
0.0738859028,
0.0071246079,
0.0326095633,
-0.0487528928,
-0.0190511271,
-0.0174790695,
-0.0571297035,
0.005991491,
0.0379624255,
-0.0394597761,
-0.0013917725,
-0.0327465869,
0.011906282,
0.0389358886,
-0.0364572667,
-0.0100069866,
-0.0122975865,
0.0198776312,
0.0296363197,
0.0550733432,
0.0353851207,
-0.0293927565,
0.0456879847,
0.008549951,
0.000852366,
-0.0725564659,
0.0099323262,
-0.0365339257,
0.0472925529,
0.0236296579,
-0.0013876379,
0.030188432,
0.0197932646,
-0.0414673276,
0.0164616331,
-0.0717892498,
-0.0060916245,
0.035020221,
-0.0232954901,
-0.0569607653,
-0.0768191665,
-0.0639129058,
-0.0136589222,
-0.0135151185,
-0.0575781651,
-0.0033773752,
-0.0418682657,
-0.0216172468,
-0.012429961,
0.0251070596,
0.060679324,
0.03463386,
-0.022842383,
-0.0278159361,
-0.0018155111,
0.0283510182,
-0.0086181285,
0.0194543377,
-0.037050657,
0.0622009039,
-0.0221269149,
-0.0215173513,
-0.0854035616,
0.0036838071,
-0.0172039606,
-0.0278512202,
0.0214124899,
-0.0222723801,
-0.0023484139,
0.0033869857,
0.012800728,
0.0262234509,
-0.0319210179,
0.0368165933,
-0.0180053171,
0.0238283854,
0.028437933,
0.0833912268,
0.0513864607,
-0.0357173979,
0.0368284583,
0.019476952,
-0.0138483504,
-0.0220014099,
0.0000892074,
-0.0133089311,
0.0113534443,
-0.0080765486,
-0.0085691717,
0.0707618296,
0.0903605521,
-0.0337071791,
0.0551900268,
-0.0084807528,
0.0682051778,
0.0078576291,
-0.0185026843,
-0.0589394905,
0.0298606753,
0.0283228643,
-0.0343499593,
-0.0487433933,
0.0576918907,
-0.0065726433,
0.0026063384,
0.0295702908,
-0.0311342627,
0.0473645069,
0.0237731114,
0.0129597886,
-0.0258727223,
-0.012664495,
-0.0229900926,
0.0535945445,
-0.0100826686,
0.0115601458,
-0.0632260442,
0.0458579548,
0.0465864055,
0.0353702754,
-0.0104341069,
0.0036624481,
-0.0033309534,
0.0135783469,
0.0641079545,
0.0365608968,
-0.008541815,
-0.0386172757,
-0.0394572541,
-0.0018084866,
0.0518710241,
-0.0135423774,
0.0401747972,
-0.0357670113,
-0.0142662972,
-0.0129639264,
0.0757601261,
-0.0310177114,
0.0206509791,
-0.0393587761,
0.0130987596,
-0.0802753642,
-0.0252026673,
0.0580375344,
-0.0068701752,
-0.0465161502,
0.0007880417,
0.0247983132,
0.0019682646,
-0.0332609117,
0.0336919203,
-0.0122081079,
0.0670036599,
0.0465031788,
-0.0354119837,
0.0323126949,
0.0283668116,
0.0275241714,
0.0390030816,
0.0359881334,
-0.0407552496,
0.0430054888,
0.0097895386,
-0.0234476253,
-0.0570788532,
0.0350224413,
-0.0258138645,
-0.0067430618,
0.0206015538,
-0.0669467747,
-0.0363924205,
0.0016348447,
0.043465279,
0.0029175859,
0.0081089484,
-0.0057526072,
0.0058794934,
0.0128878048,
0.0556429289,
0.0224769991,
-0.0066872276,
-0.0355210751,
-0.0149295274,
-0.030646624,
0.029808864,
-0.0375190452,
-0.0038340399,
-0.043808341,
0.0032061189,
0.0427149832,
-0.0221565906,
0.0569362156,
0.0252945777,
-0.0219027624,
-0.0173279978,
-0.0455330014,
-0.0927573517,
-0.0215823166,
0.0366660282,
-0.0450368859,
0.0051969346,
0.0291707385,
0.0140556991,
0.0117208883,
-0.0098754941,
-0.0783454031,
0.0033092364,
-0.0252786204,
-0.0593542457,
0.0313510261,
0.0043770629,
-0.0025582768,
0.0228481386,
0.0258112196,
0.0706161782,
0.0340394676,
0.0113363797,
-0.0569450706,
-0.0255460087,
-0.0093802195,
-0.0222728215,
-0.0632704273,
-0.0804636702,
-0.0578609332,
0.0632939786,
0.0023306522,
0.0254586488,
-0.0290855151,
0.0613705553,
-0.0164659843,
-0.0280679949,
0.0248043165,
-0.0523721091,
-0.0106255868,
0.0327132232,
-0.0576183684,
-0.004523973,
0.059157569,
0.0199519396,
0.012608557,
0.0212966483,
0.0077207373,
-0.0086121829,
0.0890536159,
0.0532526895,
-0.0120484335,
0.0395264998,
0.0305000301,
-0.0339775383,
-0.0120915677,
0.028189525,
-0.0216896813,
-0.0104438402,
-0.0619158149,
-0.0029776585,
0.0185118672,
0.0016736304,
0.002632597,
-0.0570448376,
-0.0476176292,
0.0332097486,
0.0262244325,
-0.0283756386,
-0.0045660115,
-0.0290511921,
0.0467979535,
-0.0226066764,
0.0326879807,
0.0206478424,
-0.0497239791,
-0.0578719676,
0.0099117672,
0.0173147935,
0.0381406173,
-0.031374801,
0.0002692513,
0.012506634,
0.0005987593,
0.0307113659,
0.0024503984,
0.010231995,
0.0192757584,
0.0259049609,
0.0075665987,
0.0192412492,
-0.0291954651,
0.0069207819,
-0.0029061635,
0.0778598264,
0.0129948296,
0.0135182692,
0.0728618354,
-0.0321473777,
0.0136134187,
0.0318166018,
0.0245926473,
-0.050859578,
0.050105419,
-0.0084777279,
-0.000638991,
-0.0450704694,
-0.0655983835,
0.0447124951,
-0.0494588129,
0.0026339693,
0.0210474338,
-0.0064518419,
0.0260295384,
0.0053523672,
-0.032776542,
-0.0129142357,
-0.0554063022,
0.0113269361,
0.0445001833,
-0.0006983198,
0.0064161895,
0.0069436827,
0.0542594381,
0.0403706431,
-0.0585069656,
0.0851027742,
0.0754554868,
0.058932621,
-0.0479478016,
0.0098947333,
-0.0134241562,
0.0439549275,
-0.016798906,
0.0702529177,
-0.0126345046,
0.045459345,
0.0028072621,
-0.0121125728,
-0.0163338576,
-0.0090671713,
-0.0286661517,
0.0909301043,
0.0217172764,
0.0171421431,
-0.067146115,
-0.0128240641,
-0.0144698825,
-0.0156120257,
0.0139882434,
-0.0235290527,
-0.0504471995,
-0.038031064,
-0.0214145947,
-0.0360568948,
-0.0105906641,
-0.0756921545,
0.0016195942,
0.0048561646,
-0.0180662889,
-0.0100975363,
-0.0601549037,
-0.0290228892,
-0.0278159585,
0.0691225156,
-0.0739070252,
0.084638387,
-0.03129353,
0.0014123368,
-0.0103120431,
-0.0478357375,
-0.0352807827,
-0.0043841721,
-0.0354722328,
0.0070862011,
-0.05077013,
0.0005003336,
-0.0362668112,
-0.0270904992,
-0.0506198481,
0.0685279891,
0.0346870907,
0.0261625573,
-0.0115020974,
-0.0087185809,
-0.0299486257,
0.0253365971,
-0.018286271,
-0.0427339636,
0.0726237595,
-0.0151164345,
-0.0040692184,
-0.0052725547,
-0.0033262637,
0.0072168843,
0.0250060447,
0.0044868072,
0.0079669263,
-0.0753113255,
-0.0314374864,
0.0148733668,
-0.012956067,
-0.0701039582,
-0.0232576393,
-0.039162159,
0.0276053846,
-0.0376454853,
0.0009238654,
0.0053054835,
-0.0185148716,
-0.0695366338,
0.0245307796,
-0.0016709778,
0.0096133081,
0.0504191592,
0.0051439637,
0.0239535235,
0.0374752246,
0.0498181619,
0.0265157148,
0.0309937522,
0.0200769976,
-0.0211821329,
0.0130879898,
0.0546227954,
-0.0482107997,
0.0358427726,
-0.0046851146,
0.0021154217,
-0.0133172078,
-0.0455275588,
0.0054071397,
0.0302674975,
-0.0435700119,
-0.0791502446,
0.0435848683,
0.0444971733,
-0.0208499432,
0.0291135348,
0.0603246614,
-0.0460011736,
-0.0037080548,
-0.0214644689,
0.0010634116,
-0.0235194974,
-0.0408002585,
-0.0429439545,
0.0193911679,
-0.0214991458,
0.0727886409,
0.0152035067,
0.0002762486,
0.0466280319,
0.0108788423,
0.012359146,
-0.0094597097,
-0.0111335637,
0.0049382565,
-0.0571117736,
-0.0041745249,
-0.0125579126,
-0.0733370557,
0.0041553006,
-0.0000472563,
0.0547331199,
0.008073464,
-0.0145674581,
0.0290167294,
0.0175615475,
-0.0480081774,
-0.0140725067,
-0.0605408773,
0.0245375559,
-0.0327225141,
-0.0096938442,
0.0091394559,
-5.808153954e-33,
-0.0196064245,
-0.0239281245,
0.0540120006,
-0.0193195175,
-0.0564756542,
-0.0885455012,
-0.0347474441,
0.0007222804,
-0.0352729782,
0.0182550494,
-0.0056440663,
-0.0096902829,
0.0099055246,
-0.0355464853,
0.0428455882,
-0.0209365245,
-0.0288178045,
-0.0415458567,
0.0219413452,
-0.0329403095,
-0.053532768,
-0.004257062,
-0.0051794397,
-0.0218576621,
0.0021136708,
-0.0163768455,
-0.0161485635,
-0.0154783726,
-0.0707937256,
-0.0005104563,
-0.0125357443,
-0.0220802296,
0.0017767487,
-0.0231333617,
0.0188870523,
0.0316690207,
0.0075752474,
0.0167062506,
-0.0098929703,
-0.0358971432,
0.0363569334,
-0.0350130908,
-0.0348753743,
-0.0204046499,
-0.0521530472,
0.0042730677,
0.036306899,
-0.0148205115,
0.006969953,
0.0009610605,
-0.0824277848,
-0.0094870552,
-0.0465749018,
-0.0429646,
-0.0352066457,
-0.0176836811,
0.0155794611,
0.0157969501,
-0.0168487709,
0.0856015533,
-0.0112079978,
-0.0534184538,
-0.0138254724,
0.0112006664,
0.0431430489,
0.0516785458,
0.0435024165,
0.0612068921,
-0.0555046573,
-0.0118038543,
0.0552368835,
0.0303722154,
0.0278224051,
0.0717415214,
-0.0775794983,
-0.0134724705,
-0.0284474082,
-0.01868839,
0.0563499965,
-0.029616829,
0.010079354,
0.004951858,
0.0198365431,
-0.0175376497,
-0.01470605,
-0.0644746572,
0.0185746867,
0.0197392032,
-0.0422398262,
-0.0222976282,
0.0161608662,
-0.0373220332,
0.0271989126,
-0.0508346781,
-0.0353171416,
-0.0249336548,
0.0267781578,
0.0069908565,
0.0328095108,
-0.0130750919,
-0.0290472414,
-0.0522717498,
-0.0657444894,
-0.0040670843,
0.0589721277,
0.0321292169,
-0.029449081,
0.0080984076,
0.0324891768,
-0.0011221457,
-0.0043381141,
0.0097156093,
0.0476686954,
-0.0717810318,
0.0172243882,
0.0047742655,
0.0111337099,
-0.043642085,
0.0720783696,
-0.0267882664,
-0.0041662809,
0.1262307465,
-0.0424453653,
0.0164990835,
0.0274012089,
0.036239367,
-0.0455044545,
0.0836392567,
0.0524885207,
-0.0251685586,
-0.0272805858,
-0.0486653373,
2.862e-7,
-0.0342632271,
0.061918959,
0.0244572498,
-0.0231569577,
0.016644191,
0.084460333,
0.0247360263,
0.0576592125,
-0.0284274574,
-0.0593270287,
0.0270724185,
0.0122145675,
0.0303651821,
0.0119009707,
-0.0264146663,
-0.0082665132,
-0.0262869149,
-0.0474942178,
-0.0389276706,
-0.0038774463,
0.0164782237,
-0.013987937,
0.0630881265,
-0.0128508518,
-0.0073442375,
0.0000744954,
-0.0074879201,
-0.0282346662,
-0.0154578825,
0.046822723,
-0.0818051174,
-0.0646867901,
-0.0194706675,
-0.0003429923,
0.0436351262,
-0.0166299604,
-0.0331946649,
0.0134143075,
0.0041891499,
0.0060966336,
0.0028220823,
-0.037511155,
-0.0272864811,
-0.0182214901,
0.0410132259,
-0.0280843638,
-0.0291855522,
0.0498816967,
-0.0338881128,
0.0041484036,
-0.0044849152,
0.0058097378,
0.0089052869,
0.0061983867,
0.0127713727,
0.0119908107,
0.0429470725,
-0.0323351547,
-0.0037324892,
0.0130777787,
-0.0159593988,
-0.0393926352,
0.0122407209,
0.0976512358,
0.0044069258,
-0.0080205388,
-0.0002884799,
2.234845498e-34,
-0.0326800309,
-0.0127172498,
0.0030938715,
0.0123242168,
0.0590353087,
0.0276724901,
-0.0498136133,
0.0200676229,
0.0494061224,
-0.0082671605,
-0.0233204514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16953v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16953v1 | Validation of a new, minimally-invasive, software smartphone device to predict sleep apnea and its severity: transversal study | 2024-06-20T14:36:15 | 2024-06-20T14:36:15 | Justine Frija, Juliette Millet, Emilie Bequignon, Ala Covali, Guillaume Cathelain, Josselin Houenou, Helene Benzaquen, Pierre Alexis Geoffroy, Emmanuel Bacry, Mathieu Grajoszex, Marie-Pia d Ortho | eess.SP | eess.SP, cs.CL | Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is frequent and responsible for cardiovascular
complications and excessive daytime sleepiness. It is underdiagnosed due to the
difficulty to access the gold standard for diagnosis, polysomnography (PSG).
Alternative methods using smartphone sensors could be useful to increase
diagnosis. The objective is to assess the performances of Apneal, an
application that records the sound using a smartphone's microphone and
movements thanks to a smartphone's accelerometer and gyroscope, to estimate
patients' AHI. In this article, we perform a monocentric proof-of-concept study
with a first manual scoring step, and then an automatic detection of
respiratory events from the recorded signals using a sequential deep-learning
model which was released internally at Apneal at the end of 2022 (version 0.1
of Apneal automatic scoring of respiratory events), in adult patients during
in-hospital polysomnography.46 patients (women 34 per cent, mean BMI 28.7 kg
per m2) were included. For AHI superior to 15, sensitivity of manual scoring
was 0.91, and positive predictive value (PPV) 0.89. For AHI superior to 30,
sensitivity was 0.85, PPV 0.94. We obtained an AUC-ROC of 0.85 and an AUC-PR of
0.94 for the identification of AHI superior to 15, and AUC-ROC of 0.95 and
AUC-PR of 0.93 for AHI superior to 30. Promising results are obtained for the
automatic annotations of events.This article shows that manual scoring of
smartphone-based signals is possible and accurate compared to PSG-based
scorings. Automatic scoring method based on a deep learning model provides
promising results. A larger multicentric validation study, involving subjects
with different SAHS severity is required to confirm these results. | [
-0.0323811658,
0.0142666185,
-0.0276517142,
-0.0390818864,
-0.0109965606,
0.0081924917,
0.0455298349,
-0.0157389045,
-0.0308156293,
-0.0431568809,
0.0439838506,
-0.042878639,
0.0388584808,
0.010542023,
0.0101204915,
0.0376830921,
-0.0085794264,
0.0364402458,
0.0274215229,
-0.0048543126,
-0.0098943664,
0.0069987355,
-0.0505505875,
0.0565164573,
0.0022012154,
0.0160163045,
-0.0132922558,
-0.0443076901,
0.0383419469,
-0.0526095256,
0.0082093291,
-0.0159480851,
-0.019137105,
0.0477636755,
0.0000022303,
-0.046745196,
-0.0146525707,
0.0676001906,
0.0008216974,
-0.0642110854,
-0.0002188116,
0.0444186106,
0.0426760353,
0.009320193,
-0.037603911,
-0.0509803928,
0.0336766839,
-0.0043279934,
0.0111587085,
0.0295188222,
-0.0101605672,
0.0034265046,
0.0171451177,
-0.0553474501,
0.0156623274,
-0.0382531323,
0.0086448975,
-0.0269159153,
0.0098330732,
-0.0501779132,
0.013637702,
0.0398329869,
0.0334004089,
0.0579022989,
0.0623909459,
-0.0072886688,
-0.0197218433,
-0.0613877364,
-0.0243762173,
0.0063397926,
-0.030797869,
0.0244639535,
-0.0301810093,
-0.0020991946,
-0.0286274925,
-0.0295108259,
-0.0713961199,
-0.019573763,
0.0009957709,
0.0049418113,
0.0051988456,
0.012603824,
0.056611415,
-0.0627674237,
0.009164039,
-0.0579504333,
-0.0234754011,
0.0075716469,
0.0694928765,
0.0561161786,
-0.0048892931,
0.0012976484,
0.0349709354,
-0.055553697,
-0.0554047003,
-0.0352214985,
0.0101816608,
-0.0263209529,
0.0479949452,
-0.0233478639,
0.0022168956,
-0.01100903,
0.0007975046,
-0.0176661052,
-0.0398803949,
0.0230424907,
0.005342009,
-0.0083808554,
-0.046115756,
0.0297039337,
-0.0067227501,
0.0151330652,
0.0263935421,
-0.0025220846,
0.0023083265,
0.005480838,
-0.0934626758,
-0.0716668069,
-0.0265508629,
-0.002213761,
-0.001610056,
0.0837816373,
0.0036020619,
0.0364863053,
0.0194459073,
0.0004447585,
0.072660774,
0.0526254587,
-0.02351382,
-0.0123314038,
0.0329288021,
0.000428031,
0.0416695178,
0.0469125658,
-0.0337399915,
-0.0053912848,
0.0351116806,
-0.0006990796,
0.0175495259,
0.0158604085,
0.003116179,
0.003844762,
-0.0087020947,
-0.0455871448,
-0.0078637134,
-0.0123044122,
0.0148366485,
-0.020677289,
0.0145299025,
-0.0296562836,
0.0388128981,
-0.0049075061,
-0.0278962366,
-0.0254704133,
0.0344741568,
0.017122997,
0.0294580199,
0.0025573091,
0.0716867447,
-0.0117473891,
-0.0018286885,
-0.0397236682,
0.0152045377,
0.0346786119,
0.0109192599,
-0.0701478571,
0.0167125035,
-0.0138579644,
-0.0273642484,
0.0465893,
-0.0368630812,
0.0044891741,
0.0754712224,
-0.0280902442,
0.0434677638,
0.0275818352,
0.0392246433,
0.0234849993,
-0.0441244766,
-0.0544443652,
-0.0196330026,
-0.0773950666,
0.0305369273,
0.0101732826,
-0.0521607287,
-0.0313504525,
0.0200715214,
-0.011384977,
0.007450128,
-0.1373268813,
-0.0456499308,
-0.0284216348,
-0.0340806358,
0.0506689623,
0.0337512456,
-0.0371269956,
0.0117761791,
-0.0249586124,
0.0011518153,
0.0128446696,
-0.0315766446,
-0.0225825366,
0.02943746,
-0.0255242325,
0.0036162867,
-0.0239393041,
0.0295762029,
-0.0618643947,
-0.0346860737,
-0.0584731847,
-0.0055293725,
0.0190095175,
0.0698593408,
-0.0292631537,
-0.0727277398,
0.0035637983,
0.0032969478,
-0.000607906,
-0.021274671,
0.0494784154,
0.0076318653,
0.0065236231,
-0.034008082,
-0.0019541839,
-0.048603218,
-0.0122702876,
0.0405067094,
0.0431367159,
0.053735178,
0.009721336,
0.0199467707,
-0.0186470561,
0.0339814909,
-0.0563549064,
-0.025423659,
-0.0182554591,
-0.0173949543,
0.0297402386,
0.0085652191,
0.0187215917,
0.0483368225,
0.0550081916,
-0.020880593,
-0.004715337,
-0.0262282845,
-0.0385373943,
0.0410232991,
-0.0056483131,
-0.037011046,
0.0398322083,
0.0525392406,
-0.0259633139,
-0.044852864,
0.0190260559,
0.0193080995,
-0.0117319627,
-0.0138137471,
0.0159936827,
-0.0115820169,
-0.0421833843,
-0.0090358984,
-0.055492986,
0.0082677072,
0.0304190926,
0.0108075794,
0.002533739,
0.0479755774,
-0.0938608497,
0.0259662084,
-0.0044929204,
-0.0465568155,
-0.0037962182,
0.0465963781,
0.0067870612,
-0.0161865111,
-0.032589756,
-0.006907871,
-0.016230192,
-0.0042530186,
0.0179337803,
0.0180519633,
-0.0396982245,
-0.0265265647,
-0.0008190506,
-0.0505542718,
0.0021946949,
0.0669727623,
-0.0140466252,
0.0192897394,
-0.0021435479,
0.0116749285,
-0.0042720963,
0.0111957761,
-0.0170577839,
0.0040645376,
-0.0121267885,
-0.0214763843,
0.0811818391,
0.0014619133,
0.0065401122,
0.019907333,
0.0383916609,
0.0074958201,
-0.0013319131,
-0.0545984395,
-0.0316743776,
0.0056784819,
-0.0572986342,
-0.0594025254,
0.0717663914,
0.0481524207,
0.0085826656,
0.047965087,
-0.0237032305,
-0.0200331565,
-0.0304163434,
-0.0224992204,
0.0257362612,
0.0094237505,
0.0639108196,
0.0308304615,
-0.0309504513,
-0.0042805434,
-0.0028394787,
-0.0351146646,
-0.0568527728,
-0.0504516251,
-0.0131006846,
0.0350634679,
-0.0038187865,
0.0227745045,
0.0131633589,
0.0097621325,
0.026475152,
-0.0518380105,
-0.0402938724,
-0.0528630503,
-0.0112493457,
-0.0455279239,
-0.0155206686,
-0.0045568841,
-0.0641273856,
-0.0295176078,
0.0120235821,
-0.0327336602,
-0.0359398015,
-0.0833351463,
0.0141963447,
0.0001475638,
-0.000612047,
-0.0287854504,
0.0217349697,
0.0231542476,
-0.0160002187,
0.0216296744,
0.0329705141,
0.0487409942,
0.0318827331,
-0.0091566164,
0.0506824106,
0.0288476739,
0.0101628946,
-0.0070052319,
0.1110827327,
-0.062948361,
0.0274913963,
-0.0239071231,
0.0001086192,
-0.0046348632,
0.0341383666,
0.0346264727,
-0.0167045556,
0.0394995548,
0.0588531457,
0.0169800073,
-0.0285717957,
0.0179801416,
0.0228740592,
-0.0407957248,
-0.0339860544,
-0.0464922264,
-0.0342091694,
-0.0159471594,
-0.013881214,
0.0631837472,
-0.0133958366,
0.0343061052,
0.0189303495,
0.0175298806,
0.0517925806,
-0.0045373389,
0.0016910571,
-0.0182332043,
-0.1022980809,
0.0272770543,
-0.0916959867,
0.0442784354,
-0.0819340348,
0.0194096435,
-0.0062724631,
0.028480988,
-0.1139345691,
0.0140579436,
0.0558707193,
-0.0211449284,
0.0061010891,
0.065958254,
0.0411527343,
-0.0000741418,
-0.024624398,
-0.0370826088,
0.0400460474,
0.0171999875,
-0.0342143811,
-0.0154393055,
0.0511803702,
0.0040978626,
-0.0145907784,
0.095210366,
-0.0673903897,
0.0368026048,
0.0462574176,
0.0639635846,
-0.0039225868,
-0.0454508103,
-0.0657202452,
0.0393405557,
0.0277729537,
0.0208285172,
-0.0015547163,
-0.0100925164,
-0.0330145918,
0.0300342888,
0.0403746963,
0.0079502063,
0.022936929,
0.0163710434,
0.0555972643,
-0.0961710587,
-0.0032443276,
-0.0156966187,
0.0254901703,
0.0064897626,
0.0663378984,
0.0706405118,
0.02810001,
0.0388917886,
-0.0617660433,
-0.0074151633,
0.0696748346,
0.0501719564,
0.0105944695,
-0.0140029714,
0.0631379113,
0.0174800064,
-0.0012617966,
0.0103412103,
-0.0275261831,
0.0445833206,
0.0263953581,
0.0718330219,
0.0170977861,
0.0359711982,
-0.0318023898,
0.0164742675,
0.0462793559,
0.0207977109,
-0.0344248936,
0.0265748054,
0.0387715064,
-0.0002501986,
-0.0341410935,
-0.0148590468,
-0.0012829596,
0.0049214358,
-0.0330002345,
-0.0046379124,
0.005938902,
-0.0814241394,
0.0173758976,
0.0049723405,
0.0336838253,
-0.0008756756,
-0.008802589,
-0.0068119131,
0.0555538535,
0.0168162063,
0.0574964583,
-0.0432203896,
0.0124302814,
0.0044366978,
0.0394239686,
-0.0119584836,
0.0471655354,
0.000882245,
-0.0712967515,
-0.0754786879,
0.0667978451,
0.002474346,
0.0860185474,
-0.0033695439,
0.0141396942,
-0.0456821993,
-0.0593763739,
-0.0021657317,
0.0177878924,
0.026528215,
0.0007563771,
-0.0217655953,
-0.0030061563,
-0.0458251201,
0.0608823746,
-0.0036624051,
0.0392493308,
-0.0051284153,
0.0012106787,
-0.0001957829,
-0.0004135445,
0.0073376186,
0.0260191206,
0.0040363809,
-0.0478831455,
0.0368915424,
-0.0630674511,
0.0362584107,
0.0142282844,
-0.0281556807,
0.0013338552,
0.0207438059,
0.032435745,
0.0061580963,
0.0238706749,
-0.0213982034,
-0.0484773181,
-0.0186116491,
-0.0154306423,
0.0601184815,
0.0479307622,
-0.0343034901,
0.0043305838,
-0.0009456559,
-0.0160724912,
0.0582068078,
-0.0158823282,
0.0359047949,
-0.0167573933,
-0.0113991536,
0.0204216447,
-0.0600710139,
-0.0381555334,
-0.0016788084,
-0.0179428533,
-0.0427202284,
0.0006413879,
-0.0297682118,
-5.595642943e-33,
0.014790643,
0.0042608646,
-0.0199148394,
-0.0305397063,
0.0249553788,
0.0367332101,
0.0130988816,
0.0260572881,
0.0645510703,
-0.0004160375,
-0.0007240313,
-0.0575300306,
0.0175635237,
0.0002051875,
0.0400106497,
-0.0184694864,
0.0307783578,
0.0146251423,
0.0198362898,
0.0108379647,
-0.0236015972,
0.001305857,
0.0257266574,
-0.0670593828,
-0.042662546,
0.0394060872,
0.0184939839,
-0.0765461549,
-0.0098412484,
-0.0082681384,
-0.0302376058,
0.0419284441,
0.0332191102,
0.0532639176,
0.0163362008,
0.036230579,
-0.0351646133,
-0.0299223177,
0.0096575394,
0.0152691072,
-0.035290204,
-0.0067885485,
0.0768425316,
0.0169910602,
-0.0284797959,
-0.0178099126,
0.0599554703,
-0.045133464,
0.006073501,
-0.0457600318,
0.032251332,
0.00204583,
-0.0101551842,
-0.0178036597,
-0.0281698201,
0.0272623859,
-0.0492283963,
-0.0191613212,
-0.0484052971,
-0.0214263815,
-0.0395120047,
0.007827404,
-0.0147909028,
0.025506638,
-0.0047918563,
0.0581144691,
0.0772433951,
-0.0497307442,
-0.0180653986,
0.0517699793,
-0.0195823498,
0.0269927066,
0.063946642,
0.041095145,
0.0087735569,
-0.0562773533,
-0.0972620919,
0.0448029712,
-0.0201007519,
-0.0656709373,
0.0216964819,
0.0216163918,
-0.0294796135,
-0.0125188939,
-0.0033231238,
-0.0039449832,
-0.0019551455,
-0.005202529,
0.0256984774,
-0.0085156169,
-0.0197516438,
0.0634990633,
-0.0014039555,
-0.0454382934,
0.0530512817,
-0.0693589598,
0.0669161901,
-0.0136188455,
0.0200740099,
-0.0471209809,
0.0029065986,
0.0301957503,
0.0333228819,
0.046134524,
0.0455859154,
-0.0516303927,
-0.0147298556,
0.0559966043,
0.0276493262,
-0.028638754,
0.0031431681,
0.0015489049,
0.0066942945,
-0.010124105,
0.028556481,
0.010423338,
-0.0109324325,
0.1166753247,
-0.0659372807,
0.0192112383,
-0.0474676825,
-0.0079634497,
-0.0061871377,
0.002395998,
-0.0304108318,
-0.0459841341,
-0.0265295096,
-0.0381875485,
0.0236524772,
-0.0367225222,
-0.0033939229,
-0.0092388215,
2.962e-7,
-0.0415063314,
-0.0226563644,
0.0284138136,
-0.0890436471,
0.0186463296,
0.0104176039,
-0.0175025538,
-0.0114779798,
0.0607233532,
0.0110766133,
0.0177845638,
-0.0292978678,
0.0274170786,
0.0467921272,
-0.0065801363,
-0.039872285,
0.0200609695,
0.0807546154,
-0.0324305706,
0.0462581739,
0.038508486,
0.0382339545,
-0.0007119472,
-0.056833256,
0.0110715376,
-0.0325512476,
-0.0011717703,
-0.0158331059,
0.0252989251,
-0.0441291668,
0.0321164504,
0.0392086394,
0.0559313782,
-0.0222195797,
-0.0094114365,
-0.0255536959,
0.0138683971,
0.0328980684,
-0.0672354698,
-0.0281686168,
-0.0026398706,
0.0194044057,
0.0279618204,
-0.0280260649,
0.0620402507,
-0.0090350509,
-0.055147063,
-0.0433144718,
-0.0031277654,
0.020282032,
0.0501682609,
-0.0260035899,
0.0188135318,
0.0050945678,
-0.0146961026,
0.0106929643,
-0.0194262862,
0.0020908841,
-0.0394010134,
0.0218316391,
-0.0078444015,
-0.0115309646,
0.0101321116,
-0.0455288887,
-0.0673014149,
-0.0243252702,
-0.0138287609,
2.069401785e-34,
-0.0475995168,
0.006569088,
-0.0428387187,
-0.0296907127,
-0.0049647889,
-0.0136045609,
0.0669183508,
0.0388280079,
-0.0234540161,
-0.0039504366,
-0.0328667983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14358v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14358v1 | The neural correlates of logical-mathematical symbol systems processing resemble that of spatial cognition more than natural language processing | 2024-06-20T14:31:09 | 2024-06-20T14:31:09 | Yuannan Li, Shan Xu, Jia Liu | q-bio.NC | q-bio.NC, cs.AI, cs.CL | The ability to manipulate logical-mathematical symbols (LMS), encompassing
tasks such as calculation, reasoning, and programming, is a cognitive skill
arguably unique to humans. Considering the relatively recent emergence of this
ability in human evolutionary history, it has been suggested that LMS
processing may build upon more fundamental cognitive systems, possibly through
neuronal recycling. Previous studies have pinpointed two primary candidates,
natural language processing and spatial cognition. Existing comparisons between
these domains largely relied on task-level comparison, which may be confounded
by task idiosyncrasy. The present study instead compared the neural correlates
at the domain level with both automated meta-analysis and synthesized maps
based on three representative LMS tasks, reasoning, calculation, and mental
programming. Our results revealed a more substantial cortical overlap between
LMS processing and spatial cognition, in contrast to language processing.
Furthermore, in regions activated by both spatial and language processing, the
multivariate activation pattern for LMS processing exhibited greater
multivariate similarity to spatial cognition than to language processing. A
hierarchical clustering analysis further indicated that typical LMS tasks were
indistinguishable from spatial cognition tasks at the neural level, suggesting
an inherent connection between these two cognitive processes. Taken together,
our findings support the hypothesis that spatial cognition is likely the basis
of LMS processing, which may shed light on the limitations of large language
models in logical reasoning, particularly those trained exclusively on textual
data without explicit emphasis on spatial content. | [
0.0056601716,
0.0522895753,
-0.0542048849,
0.0013011228,
-0.0463217758,
0.0511956066,
0.0238187648,
0.0294654332,
0.003367461,
0.0026517343,
-0.0543762334,
0.0285658352,
0.0462559164,
0.0194256604,
0.0628012866,
-0.000628242,
0.0042686397,
-0.0358841307,
0.0393015966,
0.0100975409,
-0.0662206486,
-0.0066393586,
-0.0041025509,
0.0020845889,
-0.0177227333,
-0.0241799243,
0.016272651,
-0.0738375112,
0.0135359857,
-0.0121203279,
-0.0728937313,
0.0239030309,
0.030704556,
0.01310373,
0.0000020817,
-0.0353559479,
0.0329785384,
0.0281971674,
0.0042921803,
0.0007177062,
0.0106466981,
-0.011326679,
0.0376633853,
-0.0057538478,
-0.0197841823,
-0.0032001864,
0.0380929187,
-0.0016876636,
-0.046224758,
0.0164747816,
-0.0129162464,
-0.0474231318,
0.0318995416,
-0.0139942961,
0.0567910038,
0.06382557,
0.0232670568,
0.0249971412,
0.0012438899,
0.0150859561,
-0.0172685962,
0.0083597666,
0.0568736419,
0.0540456809,
-0.0669160411,
0.0349402167,
-0.0050433683,
0.0627468154,
0.026689481,
0.0003820336,
0.0211694613,
-0.0501896888,
0.0278647542,
0.0236045755,
0.0427682325,
0.0216666851,
-0.0627457723,
0.0399410613,
-0.0015110796,
0.0128773125,
0.0110887028,
-0.0593027398,
0.0070819291,
-0.0074183014,
-0.0118457833,
0.1028246135,
-0.0087511661,
-0.0302330572,
-0.0096552046,
-0.0171982814,
-0.0624151938,
-0.0496092588,
0.0155959306,
0.0057418444,
0.0108965579,
0.0035343305,
0.0183052924,
-0.004517267,
-0.0052887271,
-0.0692565888,
0.0728191882,
0.0481764413,
0.032943625,
-0.0166008379,
-0.0559870489,
0.0677814782,
-0.0140187992,
0.0813431367,
-0.0317755751,
0.0533915497,
-0.0362102427,
-0.0420099795,
0.0245609339,
0.0144163519,
0.0042661219,
0.0104665579,
-0.0225869771,
0.0250106063,
-0.0145573067,
-0.0034167538,
-0.0550151765,
-0.000142597,
0.0451665185,
0.0179368351,
-0.040283829,
-0.0254937261,
-0.0167128667,
0.0390720032,
-0.0339029133,
0.0107215652,
-0.0139086358,
0.0288629588,
-0.0310100038,
-0.0141330753,
0.0048913169,
0.0538832918,
-0.0027984108,
0.0012114958,
-0.0033443279,
-0.0107952151,
-0.00752004,
-0.0002497248,
0.0562894382,
-0.0618099719,
0.0059954911,
0.0445658974,
-0.0741484761,
-0.0239284933,
-0.0220374521,
0.0358772054,
-0.0320526287,
-0.0052941218,
0.0025137383,
0.0303244293,
0.0683845654,
-0.0134029984,
-0.0402461924,
-0.0107306037,
0.0795636848,
0.026758872,
-0.0318366177,
0.0162635185,
-0.027536869,
-0.0006013179,
-0.0058536045,
-0.0269090161,
-0.0759695247,
-0.0266631879,
-0.0064393729,
0.0308347233,
0.0326414071,
0.0286261793,
-0.0405213833,
-0.007967772,
0.0145958243,
0.0896862447,
0.0426245928,
0.020183906,
0.0257535353,
-0.0208263546,
0.0175781026,
-0.0369143113,
-0.1032085717,
0.030513674,
-0.0145492693,
-0.0033203887,
-0.0124381687,
-0.0070943041,
0.0003187298,
-0.023147665,
-0.0081418417,
0.0177243166,
0.0072332839,
0.0026355518,
0.027367333,
-0.0318236947,
0.0287822708,
0.0188327711,
-0.0241134334,
0.0063299555,
-0.0047982084,
-0.0141652795,
-0.0128477467,
-0.0216331854,
-0.0057379543,
-0.0276306458,
0.0020906269,
-0.0171263032,
0.0248723999,
0.0176481362,
0.0044346275,
0.040657267,
-0.0119520389,
0.0089258729,
0.0003692332,
-0.019303415,
-0.0058756163,
0.0148040969,
-0.0333678946,
0.0090224128,
-0.0086964555,
-0.0352204889,
0.0012426235,
0.0314633176,
-0.0117144836,
0.0055749021,
-0.0673057362,
0.009996186,
-0.0309690442,
-0.0411951132,
-0.0055801794,
0.0637634322,
-0.0029202164,
-0.0185420495,
-0.0113858609,
0.0093678152,
-0.0451632775,
-0.0038274529,
0.0487554558,
-0.0362946093,
0.000663969,
-0.0139334621,
0.0037620871,
0.0107554691,
0.0584712848,
-0.0836400315,
0.0154314004,
0.00332566,
-0.0115898913,
-0.0121780895,
-0.0211248826,
-0.042861864,
0.0721231699,
0.0047994321,
0.0385307111,
0.0085436432,
-0.0450472645,
0.0358588435,
0.0076160831,
0.0180760399,
-0.0564067066,
-0.0315874852,
-0.00849107,
-0.0383980088,
0.0217791256,
-0.0337769836,
-0.0121630039,
-0.0258614235,
-0.0040200157,
0.0476929396,
0.0522433184,
0.0123051656,
-0.092355758,
-0.0338826999,
0.0018775074,
0.0169722009,
-0.0059944168,
0.0072188536,
0.0659359172,
0.0225428399,
-0.0515871197,
0.0119250575,
-0.0139141716,
-0.0426969714,
-0.0940911621,
0.040654242,
0.0277446508,
0.0011564118,
-0.0118515575,
0.0599973425,
-0.0381752662,
-0.0202197488,
0.0015825162,
0.0097214375,
0.0606346428,
-0.0020299016,
-0.0028593133,
0.0363845043,
-0.0164459608,
-0.010045575,
0.0447914563,
-0.0538006797,
-0.0169060081,
-0.0261628926,
-0.0306410436,
0.0530617721,
-0.0176596027,
-0.0365075022,
0.0055479547,
0.040495988,
0.0309934132,
-0.0174765028,
0.0112768393,
0.0378447473,
-0.0427340865,
-0.0155634377,
-0.0248504002,
-0.0281018596,
-0.0243919082,
0.073503606,
-0.0421826728,
-0.0199052747,
0.0336209387,
0.0305345748,
0.0114172446,
-0.0415673964,
0.0584764816,
-0.0146767814,
0.0665053725,
0.0104119517,
-0.003672258,
0.0060981945,
-0.060676951,
-0.049601309,
-0.0302316844,
-0.0124986973,
-0.0138467103,
-0.007441672,
-0.0449670702,
-0.0125604076,
0.002363208,
-0.0163643472,
-0.0006106381,
0.0723468512,
-0.0032728927,
0.0169647355,
-0.0094918367,
-0.0164814349,
-0.0077303248,
-0.0303578041,
0.0710995942,
-0.0036025529,
-0.0288768671,
-0.0108203199,
-0.001857663,
-0.0310984626,
0.0091961958,
0.0722141862,
0.0055442816,
-0.0049877581,
-0.0477320366,
0.0157243554,
-0.0493828431,
0.0172369964,
-0.0013574723,
0.0544482321,
0.0287440456,
-0.0219271686,
-0.0337551869,
0.0304924604,
0.0028858625,
-0.0113338176,
-0.0110813165,
0.0536415651,
0.0508084148,
0.0141257765,
0.0091989059,
-0.0663981736,
-0.0278351922,
0.038478829,
0.001125957,
-0.0197975934,
0.0128371967,
0.0197279248,
-0.0681711137,
-0.0048999693,
-0.0493721738,
0.0246493947,
-0.0510745421,
0.0248615555,
-0.0091616837,
-0.1230259612,
-0.0380993523,
-0.027291175,
0.0204150062,
0.0509626716,
-0.0525648929,
0.00274288,
-0.0153261041,
0.0283552427,
0.0171059091,
-0.0245220419,
0.0587023012,
-0.022452103,
-0.0228367746,
-0.002387037,
0.0010097297,
0.0437638685,
-0.0285501219,
-0.0791427121,
0.0146143874,
0.0817751884,
0.0288196746,
-0.0247423947,
-0.000931966,
0.0577338487,
0.0385805704,
-0.062448509,
0.0177541263,
-0.0373915508,
-0.0697174817,
-0.0162117165,
0.0874734297,
-0.0445959978,
0.012083916,
-0.0067449724,
0.0400784872,
-0.0656922385,
0.0116100051,
0.0336642452,
-0.0116276955,
-0.0301244687,
-0.005794622,
0.0027721864,
0.004500797,
-0.027396068,
0.0158202425,
0.0391220525,
-0.0229967441,
-0.0252602454,
-0.0151899178,
0.044085443,
-0.0084645022,
0.0250079781,
-0.0308151823,
0.0473894253,
-0.0755037293,
-0.0896973014,
0.0293555409,
-0.0165374912,
0.0121536944,
0.0549530461,
0.0462357216,
-0.0498172641,
-0.036179062,
-0.0453599021,
-0.0009760692,
-0.0209373496,
-0.0361208171,
0.0121385083,
0.0321737491,
0.0124756936,
-0.0913193002,
0.0234184265,
-0.0141925719,
0.0145429568,
0.0165907405,
0.0142403506,
0.054094404,
-0.0381251387,
0.0387134179,
0.037218228,
-0.0225086026,
0.0097290296,
-0.0253711212,
0.045499444,
0.0005965593,
-0.0138132554,
0.0471447743,
-0.0085476907,
0.0015180337,
0.059050031,
0.0189555604,
-0.0011751006,
-0.010101689,
-0.0482847989,
-0.0438814946,
0.0030638305,
0.0337862,
-0.0216573738,
0.0265868455,
0.071681805,
-0.0255077928,
-0.0348686278,
0.0301144477,
0.0168992113,
0.0637834743,
0.0002211615,
-0.0182264931,
0.0324272178,
0.0093072718,
0.0390036516,
0.0272393338,
-0.0126888817,
-0.0541014373,
0.0318926387,
0.0028239607,
0.0283277296,
0.031809099,
-0.0002320104,
-0.0640912727,
-0.0002408224,
-0.04089633,
-0.1152941659,
0.064288497,
-0.0398155712,
0.0139534287,
-0.0106521929,
-0.0283006579,
-0.0610376075,
0.0260032006,
-0.0167104956,
-0.0346137807,
-0.0063938596,
-0.0105624013,
0.034068767,
0.0000898777,
0.0041908734,
-0.0978199914,
0.0169949718,
-0.0601808392,
0.0221942011,
-0.035486903,
-0.0659697279,
0.0118355602,
-0.0341116562,
-0.0127217313,
0.0105702374,
-0.0248556882,
-0.0274861753,
-0.0649115294,
-0.0540106632,
0.0337083004,
0.010312153,
0.0264794547,
0.0205088928,
0.0403466932,
0.0329684988,
-0.0135718929,
-0.0487895459,
0.0274174456,
0.0450362451,
0.0299644023,
-0.0649994984,
-0.0585515238,
-5.279619735e-33,
0.0172764286,
-0.0359816551,
0.0613960586,
0.0060303919,
-0.0131415827,
-0.0364725068,
-0.02122139,
0.0669762716,
0.0041147154,
-0.0051531238,
0.0068883509,
0.0102855703,
0.0003436214,
0.004425724,
0.0721532777,
0.0067271204,
-0.0570500381,
-0.0412614346,
-0.0138687426,
-0.0665746257,
0.0543706082,
-0.0257660653,
0.0574238412,
-0.0496003926,
0.0011600963,
0.0902865678,
0.0661760494,
-0.0065097678,
-0.050881885,
0.001008743,
-0.0025544541,
0.0249824338,
0.0630016923,
0.0062002614,
-0.0192190763,
0.0561237521,
0.0195226595,
-0.0857373178,
0.0508653857,
-0.0227427054,
-0.0160509106,
-0.0083218832,
0.0715164468,
-0.0009315773,
-0.0110076731,
-0.009959924,
0.0420904867,
-0.0285076909,
0.0025705232,
0.0319440737,
-0.0439033918,
-0.018837845,
-0.0086524626,
0.0199837815,
-0.0289562792,
-0.008662886,
-0.0443259664,
0.0113747232,
-0.0578795895,
0.0287508946,
-0.0324759297,
0.0013439734,
0.0004746424,
0.0178073812,
0.0600919425,
0.0258709099,
0.078736499,
0.0218755081,
-0.0527494662,
0.0084480625,
0.087793082,
0.0393279754,
0.030626392,
-0.0119627323,
0.0709364861,
-0.001657055,
-0.0104372138,
-0.0067486791,
-0.0508199036,
0.0536156744,
-0.0007508732,
0.0030631458,
0.0201194193,
-0.0131701455,
-0.0186251905,
-0.0000324584,
-0.0369581543,
-0.0003717698,
-0.0139945205,
-0.0600578263,
0.0833123699,
0.0264070667,
0.031478066,
-0.0033534544,
-0.0114872511,
-0.0494859442,
0.0116668874,
0.0054988163,
0.0122502968,
0.0136843352,
-0.0531230718,
0.0008136213,
-0.0142581426,
0.0058319164,
0.0589390583,
0.0185750686,
-0.0021578218,
-0.0055336482,
-0.004105791,
-0.0251616519,
-0.0193956569,
-0.0678170472,
0.0557800159,
-0.0222477745,
0.0234100036,
0.0107383579,
0.0119178118,
-0.0684965998,
0.0069658631,
-0.0298937373,
-0.0506219417,
0.0373819917,
-0.0506397225,
0.003593317,
0.0334679894,
-0.023110427,
-0.0418855287,
0.0202604737,
0.0409019329,
-0.0720616579,
-0.0143789416,
-0.0180849005,
2.983e-7,
0.073908411,
0.0680875853,
0.0155953513,
0.0574278943,
0.041108679,
-0.000557373,
0.0201194417,
-0.046019379,
0.0559223108,
0.0232995581,
-0.0148746409,
0.0552405752,
0.0124985725,
-0.0070662033,
0.0015799145,
0.0277735908,
0.0121487081,
-0.0081565836,
-0.0374741703,
0.0438112244,
0.0604416765,
-0.0373001024,
0.0125757232,
-0.0149680302,
-0.0193581041,
-0.0019991389,
0.0263434798,
-0.0243109595,
0.0732007027,
-0.0169379488,
-0.0278615952,
-0.0468350574,
0.0214898419,
0.0481990688,
0.0145402765,
-0.0417700857,
0.002288895,
-0.0007588913,
0.0149610229,
0.0415220261,
0.0117548155,
-0.0481522046,
-0.0193762034,
-0.0228909757,
0.0187665578,
-0.0871636495,
-0.0384773053,
0.0338724889,
0.0174153149,
0.0228054654,
0.0451086462,
0.0174744669,
0.0006698975,
-0.0305788033,
0.0369531214,
0.0318244062,
0.0132220285,
-0.03571897,
-0.0057630157,
0.0577200241,
-0.0663262606,
-0.0160609633,
-0.061473757,
0.0061750305,
0.0587792471,
-0.0234631766,
-0.0349398479,
2.615857655e-34,
-0.0478858426,
-0.0089568179,
0.0402996317,
-0.037459027,
0.0227107033,
0.0011264709,
-0.0472212434,
0.0278303791,
0.0032667082,
-0.0436767489,
-0.0052124681
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14336v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14336v1 | Exploring Spatial Representations in the Historical Lake District Texts with LLM-based Relation Extraction | 2024-06-20T14:04:59 | 2024-06-20T14:04:59 | Erum Haris, Anthony G. Cohn, John G. Stell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Navigating historical narratives poses a challenge in unveiling the spatial
intricacies of past landscapes. The proposed work addresses this challenge
within the context of the English Lake District, employing the Corpus of the
Lake District Writing. The method utilizes a generative pre-trained transformer
model to extract spatial relations from the textual descriptions in the corpus.
The study applies this large language model to understand the spatial
dimensions inherent in historical narratives comprehensively. The outcomes are
presented as semantic triples, capturing the nuanced connections between
entities and locations, and visualized as a network, offering a graphical
representation of the spatial narrative. The study contributes to a deeper
comprehension of the English Lake District's spatial tapestry and provides an
approach to uncovering spatial relations within diverse historical contexts. | [
0.0167506617,
0.0314486511,
-0.0102113523,
0.0467361398,
-0.0306042992,
0.0112035498,
0.0131666595,
-0.0218684878,
0.0319875851,
-0.0774380416,
0.0025684694,
0.0193734113,
0.0301862415,
-0.0315692425,
-0.0097444383,
-0.0934879705,
-0.0026081298,
0.0112656327,
-0.0462824702,
0.0331162252,
-0.0150900949,
0.028963767,
-0.0211652722,
0.0048498269,
-0.0232085101,
0.0322549231,
-0.011247728,
-0.0017481819,
0.0252711605,
-0.0572398677,
-0.0334154367,
-0.0225524753,
0.0312205348,
-0.0264758728,
0.0000016333,
-0.0159515236,
-0.0283425525,
-0.0124862352,
0.0430255383,
0.0063514407,
0.025411211,
0.0018723942,
0.0289342254,
-0.0675590113,
-0.0335831381,
-0.0184467565,
0.0373436213,
0.0432530046,
0.0343849286,
0.0448353663,
-0.0235492066,
-0.1034340188,
-0.0027247299,
0.0147432629,
-0.0037621099,
0.0305946786,
0.0167996529,
0.0272414982,
0.0111142751,
0.0486156605,
-0.0629765093,
0.0143126035,
-0.0123002892,
-0.0042112176,
-0.0101766242,
0.0354724713,
-0.0071661165,
0.0554326139,
0.0114703001,
0.0398968011,
0.0333873071,
-0.0023801934,
0.0375073403,
0.0153085692,
-0.0192387216,
0.0841105133,
-0.0414302573,
0.0069944877,
-0.0076006586,
0.0505954288,
-0.0120663159,
0.0052941847,
0.0339478925,
-0.0075510647,
-0.0345050395,
0.0506477803,
0.0077138175,
0.004038102,
-0.0743607953,
0.0380696505,
-0.0091533698,
-0.0242065731,
-0.006537844,
0.0829046965,
0.0164252669,
0.0040339073,
0.0151310693,
0.0515576936,
-0.0244263094,
-0.036596898,
0.0045910911,
-0.0291684531,
-0.0388521031,
0.0466359146,
-0.0261234082,
0.0201821383,
-0.0076890076,
0.0192504097,
-0.015502953,
0.011863119,
-0.0481921472,
0.0010949598,
-0.0310330167,
0.0270623621,
-0.0329307206,
0.0031787211,
-0.0013487828,
-0.0063840449,
0.0333875753,
0.0137843536,
-0.0127214259,
0.0187407285,
0.0017728291,
-0.0378045142,
-0.0249802135,
0.033064194,
-0.0105093019,
0.020935297,
-0.0723352581,
-0.0022096755,
0.0051660952,
0.0277076215,
0.0386348963,
-0.0387875773,
-0.0516504571,
0.0657180026,
0.0321384817,
-0.0226667225,
-0.0803116113,
0.0238024928,
-0.0017650331,
-0.0031645333,
0.0241793972,
-0.0528079309,
0.0003703706,
-0.0287116114,
0.0018463165,
-0.0434659272,
0.0152107431,
-0.0119098416,
-0.0336166434,
0.0250134245,
-0.0117792627,
0.0140752364,
0.0414452441,
0.0004804575,
0.0585449152,
0.0288617034,
0.0906480849,
0.0820188075,
0.0424750336,
0.0059678801,
0.0222206768,
0.0053444523,
-0.0140664261,
-0.0248410087,
-0.0691162795,
-0.0102430778,
-0.0269287527,
0.0166652221,
0.0422517695,
0.0240470357,
-0.0028099956,
-0.0107093975,
0.0572173111,
0.0919683427,
0.0571473762,
0.0099447602,
0.0656717196,
0.0361324251,
-0.0251019821,
0.0250536986,
-0.0439941883,
0.0028379543,
0.0515423976,
0.0230281986,
-0.0327310264,
0.0481788851,
0.0131429946,
-0.0190426782,
-0.0071066013,
-0.0003371658,
-0.0174567718,
-0.0285518412,
0.056531582,
0.0128590241,
-0.0289103501,
0.0504690968,
0.0228972677,
-0.0246387646,
0.0556527376,
0.0215231609,
-0.0031158249,
0.0426857397,
0.0323461182,
-0.0095064929,
0.0389308408,
-0.0227075983,
0.015746681,
0.0124716815,
0.0235580672,
-0.004500865,
0.0312540568,
-0.0422795378,
-0.0516840667,
-0.0122092245,
0.0175781418,
-0.012647463,
0.0230484046,
0.0350036174,
0.0225483496,
-0.0658392012,
0.0164134335,
0.0381279252,
0.0249705836,
-0.0466230996,
-0.029183533,
0.0132006034,
-0.0481740907,
0.0067923344,
-0.0344630182,
-0.0000783158,
0.0349643603,
-0.0397144854,
0.0206240416,
0.0714737177,
-0.0172107331,
-0.0088210274,
-0.003719413,
-0.077408269,
-0.0070619099,
-0.037967395,
-0.0287107974,
-0.0211845115,
0.0185827669,
-0.0284184124,
0.0731534213,
0.022495633,
-0.0003539279,
0.0265204944,
-0.0172880776,
-0.0842434689,
0.1042576507,
-0.0007607635,
0.0165313203,
-0.0428306796,
0.0001314761,
-0.0077552442,
0.012087917,
0.0304659884,
-0.0582342073,
0.0197362304,
-0.015153002,
0.01653203,
-0.0232716165,
-0.0124155851,
-0.0422307551,
-0.0413965732,
0.0166370831,
-0.0305108391,
0.0175347105,
0.0249306671,
-0.0464703962,
-0.0240396149,
-0.0004837076,
-0.0092513282,
-0.0183330141,
-0.0047623757,
-0.0017795688,
0.0484778136,
-0.0417515449,
0.030191211,
-0.0287030898,
-0.0007147232,
-0.0139531568,
0.0956750885,
0.0436517857,
-0.0566570014,
-0.0128597915,
0.0318995602,
0.0093089286,
-0.0184301361,
-0.0220437925,
0.0072167492,
0.0029958864,
-0.0270796083,
0.029570017,
-0.009043484,
-0.0043967012,
0.05030673,
0.0339533798,
-0.0617972091,
-0.0340078361,
-0.003456071,
-0.0505909324,
0.0083432989,
-0.0408638157,
-0.0282338504,
-0.0023361957,
0.0182319488,
0.014312502,
0.0047471444,
0.0133291241,
0.0150545873,
-0.0257015806,
0.0207381211,
0.0076896343,
0.0090229372,
0.0126091354,
0.062229611,
-0.0502794497,
-0.0385919735,
-0.0229189247,
0.0095455823,
0.0312973708,
-0.0071377712,
0.0172408447,
-0.035150364,
0.1379884332,
0.0399447456,
0.0297875628,
-0.0173357911,
-0.0633929148,
0.0026385635,
-0.0341811217,
0.0212841071,
-0.0051954649,
0.019398246,
-0.0581758209,
0.0182713252,
0.0155863995,
0.0028883172,
-0.0338634774,
-0.0020554771,
-0.003909383,
-0.0308694337,
-0.0018459597,
-0.0321717188,
0.0063073901,
0.047306139,
0.0173021499,
0.0097624995,
-0.01428515,
-0.0147180147,
-0.0315883085,
0.11784821,
0.0734722018,
0.0606722683,
0.0070091793,
0.0396796465,
-0.0462908149,
0.010265545,
-0.0886802226,
0.0102619901,
0.0176501833,
0.0353044532,
-0.0056684767,
-0.0815084502,
-0.0420679599,
-0.0083613386,
0.0245316811,
-0.0518645495,
-0.0571543612,
0.063879706,
0.0520089231,
-0.0168094058,
0.0093743606,
0.0064866473,
-0.0385707431,
0.0457432568,
0.011381167,
-0.0526151098,
0.0419730842,
-0.0342969708,
-0.0772678405,
0.0344100334,
-0.047485806,
-0.0037660431,
-0.0541416556,
0.0397021063,
0.0133371949,
-0.0546523556,
-0.0167240892,
-0.0658986568,
-0.0405541211,
-0.0203015171,
-0.0820393413,
-0.0468743443,
-0.0234423336,
0.0060496391,
0.0155064156,
-0.0302035399,
0.0378359146,
-0.0413283557,
-0.0489736237,
0.0164019689,
0.0392574668,
0.0686246753,
-0.0407566801,
-0.0134258224,
-0.0085782157,
0.0391214415,
0.0418933295,
0.0134187927,
0.0218227915,
0.0198152997,
-0.0063904407,
-0.029047126,
-0.046399381,
0.0118058566,
-0.0525582731,
0.0308023673,
0.0478906259,
-0.0149732195,
0.0538793951,
-0.0003178389,
0.0738422722,
0.0271227639,
-0.0027416728,
0.0074590496,
0.0403283648,
-0.0261758603,
-0.0441540405,
0.0326962918,
-0.034565758,
-0.0876647905,
0.0528945886,
-0.0147229945,
0.0253784992,
-0.0588559024,
-0.0318805426,
0.0066260761,
0.0471994393,
0.0422908626,
0.0040522427,
0.0349770188,
-0.0635978058,
-0.0949439555,
0.0904763192,
-0.0368255712,
-0.00798201,
0.050096076,
0.0208637398,
0.0388214812,
-0.047475148,
0.020141881,
-0.0052863224,
-0.048118189,
-0.0393530242,
0.0160622131,
0.0279650725,
0.0155388704,
-0.0129120443,
0.0106653674,
-0.0041216128,
0.0605925992,
0.0282409787,
-0.0055916822,
-0.0132429469,
-0.0300671309,
0.0566251799,
0.0066281618,
-0.0290425252,
-0.0134155629,
0.0194819123,
0.0102413334,
0.0023224722,
-0.0596644171,
-0.019451255,
-0.0244535618,
-0.0412072428,
0.1146531776,
-0.0152749922,
0.0038179988,
-0.0243325997,
-0.0454473607,
-0.0658556521,
0.0110283559,
0.0034944536,
0.0210578665,
0.0116700549,
0.0270766672,
-0.0521841682,
-0.0042901854,
-0.0180187635,
0.0255738199,
-0.0343129933,
-0.0073514138,
0.0374503061,
-0.0448499657,
0.0058428273,
0.0598136373,
-0.0279821306,
0.034879718,
-0.007567931,
0.0422047824,
0.0084772157,
-0.0322957672,
0.0111639928,
0.0130220698,
-0.0722387135,
-0.0082267495,
-0.0383795276,
-0.0016696119,
-0.0150243184,
0.0313740969,
0.0825762823,
-0.0335368365,
0.0248448607,
0.0125785014,
0.0162725188,
0.0293457825,
0.0209966861,
0.0118901851,
-0.0346472263,
0.0057829181,
0.0110835601,
-0.0336012058,
0.0403667055,
-0.0017884674,
-0.0296556763,
0.0460897498,
0.0652339682,
-0.0379367769,
-0.0037455328,
-0.0503845252,
-0.0018033487,
0.018791737,
-0.0069234134,
-0.0155763784,
-0.0749704018,
-0.024301311,
0.026839491,
-0.0085941078,
0.0090583982,
0.0108262338,
0.008457738,
-0.0057052793,
0.0184467174,
-0.0345763899,
-0.0682621822,
0.0369183607,
-0.0075614573,
-0.0395172387,
-0.0137818251,
-5.081549672e-33,
-0.0486648045,
-0.094716683,
0.0684840828,
-0.0130638583,
-0.0501993634,
-0.0065680793,
-0.0020235546,
-0.0021848672,
-0.0229666475,
0.0283596013,
0.007183318,
-0.0172010884,
0.004683319,
0.0037158187,
-0.0274703782,
0.023862455,
0.0177082531,
0.0111297183,
0.0040330729,
0.0001727328,
0.0465008803,
0.0052964399,
0.0587207153,
-0.0683650523,
-0.0016091948,
0.0191544201,
-0.0223861709,
0.0053601833,
0.0337471329,
0.0177315697,
-0.0269762091,
-0.0091149313,
0.0360183641,
-0.0510547347,
-0.0179388467,
-0.012681758,
-0.0672438815,
-0.0497883447,
0.0120868348,
0.0179735236,
0.0463829972,
-0.0653978214,
0.0444796942,
0.0055003064,
0.0200660061,
-0.0204308797,
0.0560836941,
0.0330147743,
-0.0669696704,
-0.0395371206,
-0.0870971456,
0.0165969413,
-0.0138625475,
0.0071079279,
0.0206371546,
-0.0476716198,
0.0200624857,
0.0134351691,
-0.0390570536,
0.0246990584,
0.0199188944,
0.0053935521,
-0.0025144839,
0.009830907,
0.0014414571,
0.0625450164,
-0.0037288959,
-0.0346840285,
-0.0743755698,
0.0286378637,
0.0218502618,
0.0434582606,
-0.0420424268,
0.0519591458,
-0.0215369742,
0.0009502659,
-0.0563224405,
0.032438457,
-0.0617781393,
0.0165206846,
-0.0259505305,
0.0051632738,
0.0203619432,
-0.0222904477,
-0.0102794357,
-0.0146887908,
0.027543243,
0.0077370489,
0.0052667437,
-0.0338235684,
0.0582806431,
0.0672878921,
-0.0096936598,
-0.0444626212,
-0.0454894714,
-0.0122220544,
-0.0027370208,
0.026643794,
-0.028058432,
0.0276949592,
0.0228990484,
-0.0291512199,
0.0113016507,
0.0231243707,
0.0077349083,
0.0194759667,
-0.0084351134,
0.0068373135,
-0.0472283624,
-0.006371405,
-0.0269788951,
-0.0541558415,
0.0075774137,
-0.0296315718,
0.0214208327,
-0.0180423148,
0.0039426815,
0.0464881547,
0.0428700633,
-0.0113489581,
0.0678426698,
-0.0024169893,
-0.0029887583,
0.0472161174,
0.0093585206,
0.0082004433,
-0.0000842896,
0.0321588032,
0.0453315116,
-0.0369828902,
-0.0173616782,
-0.0163887702,
2.447e-7,
0.0701889992,
0.0737327263,
0.0518088527,
-0.0072875367,
-0.0063129328,
-0.0170979332,
0.0370213091,
0.0145907206,
-0.065661937,
0.0404345319,
0.0555533841,
0.0298831556,
0.0142489038,
0.0486736186,
-0.0850426927,
0.0475051813,
-0.0491047725,
-0.0884722248,
-0.0704867169,
-0.0169204473,
0.1037848219,
0.0170286018,
0.0204927325,
-0.0064589265,
-0.0267713852,
-0.0081452625,
0.0210223701,
-0.0632971451,
-0.0093212193,
0.0294506475,
0.0630470589,
-0.0679015592,
-0.0314655527,
-0.0089768525,
-0.0073388834,
-0.0196484644,
0.0044890535,
0.02096406,
-0.0061976663,
-0.0074423705,
-0.0189699177,
-0.0579282381,
-0.0189148411,
-0.0427938849,
0.0326016173,
-0.0479035564,
-0.0006005705,
-0.0178586897,
-0.044169236,
0.0437324978,
0.0197441205,
0.0220818594,
0.0096508758,
0.0022041358,
0.0252331086,
0.020751588,
-0.018397579,
-0.0753310174,
-0.001116935,
0.0363737606,
0.0007017637,
-0.005751003,
0.0105700232,
-0.0013472656,
0.0109746894,
-0.0265554208,
-0.0268234704,
1.986995498e-34,
-0.0168238636,
-0.0022933232,
-0.0236793682,
0.0239623189,
0.0514327921,
-0.0091305319,
-0.0198315699,
0.009397774,
-0.0018928343,
-0.0502886362,
0.0017259578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14335v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14335v1 | Self-supervised Interpretable Concept-based Models for Text Classification | 2024-06-20T14:04:53 | 2024-06-20T14:04:53 | Francesco De Santis, Philippe Bich, Gabriele Ciravegna, Pietro Barbiero, Danilo Giordano, Tania Cerquitelli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite their success, Large-Language Models (LLMs) still face criticism as
their lack of interpretability limits their controllability and reliability.
Traditional post-hoc interpretation methods, based on attention and
gradient-based analysis, offer limited insight into the model's decision-making
processes. In the image field, Concept-based models have emerged as
explainable-by-design architectures, employing human-interpretable features as
intermediate representations. However, these methods have not been yet adapted
to textual data, mainly because they require expensive concept annotations,
which are impractical for real-world text data. This paper addresses this
challenge by proposing a self-supervised Interpretable Concept Embedding Models
(ICEMs). We leverage the generalization abilities of LLMs to predict the
concepts labels in a self-supervised way, while we deliver the final
predictions with an interpretable function. The results of our experiments show
that ICEMs can be trained in a self-supervised way achieving similar
performance to fully supervised concept-based models and end-to-end black-box
ones. Additionally, we show that our models are (i) interpretable, offering
meaningful logical explanations for their predictions; (ii) interactable,
allowing humans to modify intermediate predictions through concept
interventions; and (iii) controllable, guiding the LLMs' decoding process to
follow a required decision-making path. | [
0.035146378,
0.0337559395,
-0.0147982696,
0.0677775294,
0.0268131401,
0.0160693564,
0.0264867954,
-0.0150905363,
0.012601288,
-0.0130106201,
-0.0272922497,
0.0227319356,
-0.0287780315,
0.0825016797,
0.0078142434,
-0.0627879202,
-0.0150684388,
-0.0214512926,
0.0027433196,
0.0328967907,
0.022469921,
0.0040911245,
0.0455811508,
0.0428604074,
0.0138229942,
-0.0385320447,
-0.03389832,
-0.0124258474,
-0.0227857828,
0.0001288781,
-0.0128901275,
0.0663587973,
0.0824363679,
0.0212322958,
0.0000021314,
0.0087953061,
-0.0262212697,
-0.0228874125,
-0.0655393228,
0.0300013367,
0.0359735079,
-0.0343790799,
0.0214259271,
-0.0408967249,
-0.0079318685,
-0.0200918429,
0.0442825444,
0.0839643478,
0.0881514773,
0.0242451988,
-0.0095829815,
-0.0534874238,
0.0148441829,
-0.0122090802,
0.0466257744,
-0.0383142233,
-0.0033638037,
0.0284854136,
-0.0411570035,
0.0528033003,
-0.0587872304,
0.0271094851,
0.0360575095,
-0.0220814794,
0.0792060345,
0.031654574,
0.0345546566,
-0.0448623262,
0.018406136,
0.0933286473,
-0.0111900084,
-0.028941188,
-0.011476473,
-0.0203131884,
0.0136412606,
-0.0125913927,
-0.011674786,
-0.0218300354,
0.0333733223,
0.0197619796,
0.0113451239,
0.0506221838,
0.0373558216,
0.0272871796,
-0.0478183143,
0.030782735,
-0.0446426496,
0.0003639712,
-0.0323364511,
0.0305229407,
-0.0470184572,
-0.0090372432,
0.013229562,
0.0189853664,
0.0248333551,
0.0419864245,
-0.0298600495,
-0.0334559195,
-0.0369494893,
-0.0539572649,
0.0510656089,
0.0210164934,
-0.0391835272,
0.0716205537,
-0.007313157,
0.0419557728,
-0.0261456724,
0.0215066411,
-0.0123388963,
0.009509081,
-0.0652528629,
-0.0214654393,
-0.025813682,
0.0187780336,
0.004592292,
-0.0272240732,
-0.0136507899,
0.0410108678,
-0.0417878591,
0.0132237449,
0.0008841844,
0.0264858585,
-0.0366562791,
-0.0476199016,
-0.0347953625,
0.0023827001,
-0.018701192,
-0.0157955624,
-0.0151514765,
-0.0068027601,
0.0128795309,
0.0205952898,
0.0035784922,
0.0025950763,
-0.0099880546,
0.0374130309,
0.000349634,
-0.0489916764,
-0.0190349016,
-0.0258730538,
-0.0187745318,
-0.0235087909,
-0.0022263245,
-0.0071278359,
0.0063211746,
0.0030160961,
-0.0036751907,
-0.0653005093,
-0.0073009622,
-0.0114766564,
-0.0266558342,
0.1198147833,
0.0129718268,
-0.0206999499,
0.0443036035,
0.0461566299,
-0.0429415479,
0.0661888793,
0.0292912647,
0.0546839722,
0.0286473893,
-0.0257059075,
0.0258407164,
0.0096913567,
0.0508878604,
-0.015814973,
-0.0135603352,
0.0207329132,
-0.0328660719,
0.044292368,
0.0724022612,
-0.0100497706,
-0.0249102507,
-0.0298701078,
0.0497281961,
0.0518673286,
0.01238955,
0.0508642644,
0.0149690071,
0.0330034047,
-0.0111300638,
-0.0079556378,
-0.0510831401,
0.036831703,
0.0194433853,
-0.0282869916,
0.0090704439,
-0.0206105113,
-0.0260587297,
-0.0751603469,
0.0252201948,
-0.012647056,
-0.0030177319,
0.0163919516,
0.0757628158,
0.0076336786,
0.0031559446,
-0.0058845901,
0.0033797135,
-0.0168016702,
-0.0022169778,
-0.0647157878,
0.0757972598,
0.0888196081,
0.0508995987,
-0.025626706,
0.0408202,
-0.013648998,
0.0379248336,
0.0187681671,
-0.0158637501,
0.0266879834,
0.0206638575,
-0.0410524942,
-0.0538215935,
-0.0146851391,
0.01437933,
0.0119257327,
-0.0223283377,
-0.0279519092,
0.0174051169,
-0.024937341,
-0.0446741953,
0.0269298069,
0.0250629615,
-0.0420860201,
0.0014529463,
0.0188293848,
0.0204430632,
0.0173840094,
0.015129596,
-0.0176490135,
0.0069018016,
-0.0274482276,
-0.0314995348,
0.0073848963,
-0.0397950895,
-0.0397287346,
-0.0362102091,
-0.0346630923,
-0.0296506807,
-0.000889106,
-0.0669159442,
-0.0280268304,
0.0271630958,
-0.0430039689,
-0.0004930782,
-0.0460536405,
-0.028536398,
0.0215833113,
0.0137977209,
-0.0159236733,
0.0361658186,
-0.0195287094,
-0.0252881721,
-0.0267010797,
0.0097474093,
-0.0050940271,
-0.0226362478,
-0.0362867787,
-0.0062664743,
0.0136383381,
-0.0113193812,
-0.0116681531,
-0.0097770626,
-0.0236207321,
0.0179196801,
-0.0503297932,
-0.0443565771,
-0.0112735564,
-0.0173845217,
0.0286109131,
-0.016088035,
0.0406656861,
-0.026231993,
-0.0049153334,
0.0156595521,
-0.0090818033,
-0.0066322568,
0.0332607068,
-0.0049209776,
0.0315654241,
-0.016156882,
-0.0131961862,
0.0167465918,
0.1165753603,
0.030188581,
0.0068971775,
-0.0599528737,
0.0099418275,
0.014161462,
0.0020075603,
-0.0114058992,
-0.0484807454,
-0.0164616406,
-0.0273646917,
-0.0180548951,
0.0776612684,
0.0128847156,
0.0771993399,
0.0363030247,
0.0298904311,
-0.0638134703,
-0.0224973466,
0.0099648889,
0.0278956722,
-0.0052175028,
-0.0597968921,
-0.003688273,
0.102742061,
-0.009913397,
-0.0027898047,
-0.074632369,
0.0284374785,
0.0059847669,
-0.0522153303,
-0.0989071578,
0.0041389395,
0.0353543982,
0.0186192803,
-0.034244325,
-0.0636488944,
0.0647372156,
-0.0069477009,
-0.0250807162,
0.026199637,
-0.0135211861,
-0.0224246234,
0.0728367269,
0.0366996862,
-0.0003215642,
0.0287185721,
-0.0002442436,
-0.0138327163,
-0.0003370845,
0.0216129888,
0.0001714161,
0.0352324732,
-0.0321171992,
-0.0061322483,
0.0186783113,
-0.0221029148,
-0.0330202244,
-0.0060593197,
-0.0223103724,
-0.0430697054,
0.0277829617,
0.0078282626,
-0.0141785536,
0.0168122202,
0.0372342989,
0.0253483076,
-0.0073940852,
-0.0273873582,
-0.0060073249,
0.0214372016,
0.0444684029,
0.0033430769,
-0.0376039855,
-0.0080873752,
0.0328800306,
0.0576869436,
-0.0098597817,
-0.05455314,
-0.0664986074,
0.0285373684,
0.0001534093,
-0.0052664937,
-0.0130471876,
0.0022527508,
0.0114850802,
-0.1125684008,
-0.037307702,
0.1107402965,
0.0156906322,
-0.0372187346,
-0.0263911337,
-0.0236334167,
-0.0109713925,
0.0058967713,
0.0185368545,
-0.0302524157,
-0.0440794863,
-0.0176475737,
0.0230168961,
0.0120188091,
0.0162345972,
-0.0120996488,
-0.0395400822,
0.0627391338,
0.004510127,
-0.0353461131,
-0.050508,
-0.0372396968,
-0.0544674695,
-0.0558915548,
-0.0479460321,
-0.0027742328,
0.0268456172,
0.0350111537,
-0.0120430337,
-0.0694518909,
0.0029795982,
0.0290935338,
-0.0024115078,
0.0286499895,
0.0635447279,
0.0095776655,
0.0080169942,
-0.0258082189,
-0.0218474437,
-0.0445042998,
0.0064903316,
-0.0059463163,
0.1081833243,
-0.0421007983,
-0.0126762893,
-0.026981594,
0.0580817647,
-0.0273251142,
-0.0337711237,
-0.0152821438,
0.094589293,
-0.0136530856,
-0.0178395808,
-0.0308315903,
-0.0208428912,
0.0044704,
0.0896901339,
0.0415294357,
-0.0742939413,
-0.0513985492,
-0.0457248017,
0.0155151216,
-0.0444170348,
-0.0448054895,
0.0021566798,
0.010485474,
-0.040765591,
-0.0237642191,
-0.0568764471,
0.0135032488,
0.0209168456,
-0.0053270757,
-0.0150821768,
-0.0001626023,
-0.0211763754,
-0.045008488,
0.0560308807,
-0.0110277785,
-0.0217916854,
-0.0489957668,
-0.0182256494,
0.0293882396,
-0.0652285069,
-0.0356809013,
0.0085032852,
-0.030181637,
0.0093989167,
0.0225265231,
0.0640752688,
0.0143970205,
0.0434229784,
0.0023319107,
-0.0849491432,
0.0832343549,
0.010778131,
-0.0308955517,
-0.027886793,
0.0483407974,
0.0279908497,
0.0033793848,
0.0394256897,
-0.0189735182,
0.0531759933,
0.0068499511,
-0.0464663021,
-0.0463110246,
-0.0081518339,
0.0010351188,
-0.0312611461,
0.0385324843,
-0.0000145352,
-0.0214989018,
-0.0456542559,
-0.005770816,
0.0078338394,
0.0014564511,
-0.0705648512,
0.0247864872,
0.0318510644,
-0.0155804204,
-0.0075654085,
-0.0336381234,
-0.0056070355,
-0.0213712044,
0.0063955211,
0.0138603384,
0.0198755246,
0.0359236449,
-0.022645602,
0.0163625386,
-0.0172335096,
0.0042325081,
-0.0409846567,
0.0232999567,
0.0053364132,
0.0785622969,
0.0174636319,
-0.0127789788,
-0.0380240679,
0.0446041673,
-0.0580198392,
-0.0182077438,
-0.0138223357,
0.009816546,
0.0227449313,
0.0143494466,
-0.0099707758,
-0.0200338326,
-0.022653332,
-0.0031920497,
0.059194956,
-0.0000274369,
-0.0272241402,
0.0147926807,
0.0097175427,
-0.0171707589,
-0.0251902547,
0.0534636341,
0.0234692898,
-0.0078486297,
0.014850066,
-0.0348514281,
-0.0508373342,
0.0007418809,
-0.0055631157,
0.0171613786,
-0.0217319783,
0.0333610848,
-0.0076519013,
-0.0727392212,
0.0273084529,
-0.0085754199,
-0.025981551,
0.0060761655,
0.0160477683,
0.0412416197,
0.0038833213,
-0.0105554983,
-0.0328342989,
0.0426553711,
-0.0320834555,
0.004440485,
-0.0138450321,
-5.919715348e-33,
-0.0167061705,
-0.0421952941,
-0.007554376,
-0.0061397306,
0.018398853,
0.020633582,
-0.0330624692,
-0.0235780217,
0.0273921676,
0.0393997058,
0.0192758422,
0.0271806754,
-0.0135754524,
0.0506666005,
0.0128957042,
-0.0135238133,
0.0468666516,
0.003480389,
-0.0090228599,
0.0352466442,
0.0602854304,
0.0424009822,
0.0193572771,
-0.0487697534,
0.0454996973,
0.0070795924,
0.0022629425,
-0.0024101359,
0.0190327354,
0.0539690331,
-0.0351291746,
-0.0009330299,
0.0415052883,
-0.0399927124,
-0.0266672466,
0.0496132746,
-0.0910492465,
-0.0171477888,
-0.0288563836,
0.0301404577,
-0.0522250421,
-0.028530119,
0.0381394066,
-0.0067623639,
0.0318208188,
-0.059012942,
0.0588095002,
-0.0284876432,
-0.0150220133,
0.0200850088,
-0.0133759333,
0.0281923506,
-0.037931107,
-0.0112801436,
0.0714466125,
0.0076422663,
0.0211582072,
0.0587364472,
-0.0878418609,
-0.0232776254,
-0.0021399658,
-0.0022296535,
0.088225171,
0.0042673522,
-0.0059993546,
0.0365368165,
0.0192412026,
-0.0281297583,
-0.0630597472,
-0.0304736532,
-0.0022348645,
0.0550079793,
0.0487824157,
0.0465813354,
0.0494905524,
0.0085306605,
-0.0416886583,
0.0145956604,
-0.0558697954,
0.0361647122,
0.049222026,
0.0481689125,
-0.0627184734,
0.0002742455,
-0.0334787443,
-0.0384682193,
-0.0477070175,
-0.0413384847,
0.0278655253,
-0.0049339556,
-0.0450924039,
0.0146903601,
0.0409472659,
-0.0578260683,
0.0025344344,
0.0098563191,
0.0032376107,
0.0329912677,
0.0256863348,
0.028133085,
-0.0292768702,
-0.0169266239,
0.0298709739,
-0.001464585,
0.0042640995,
0.0059418771,
0.0399928242,
-0.0088587105,
-0.0182177667,
-0.0386510007,
-0.0524666049,
-0.046635177,
-0.0337906629,
0.0223470554,
0.0153794838,
0.016204251,
-0.0740147531,
0.037297532,
-0.0074711372,
0.0134692229,
-0.0021549985,
-0.0458619744,
-0.004173364,
0.0142750051,
-0.0183928888,
-0.025489945,
-0.0063057621,
-0.0091110636,
0.0395905375,
-0.0560765006,
-0.0025339318,
0.0229957439,
2.606e-7,
0.0484663807,
0.0279145204,
-0.0198369455,
0.0163900591,
0.0480005629,
0.0710520148,
0.0181614216,
0.0200270694,
-0.0003261172,
-0.0244166013,
0.0448868535,
0.0639129207,
0.0331084169,
-0.0062468476,
-0.0047944314,
-0.0022361788,
-0.0060721161,
0.0229748636,
-0.0306837037,
-0.0217510257,
0.0828803927,
0.1005150303,
0.0328938253,
0.004310111,
0.0678148568,
-0.0073460117,
0.0664708465,
-0.0627215877,
0.0290066898,
-0.0207594782,
0.0340739302,
0.0195756704,
-0.0161924232,
0.0112207392,
-0.0137151247,
-0.0021105104,
0.0149180014,
0.0595665984,
-0.0088302894,
0.0108417477,
-0.0426133275,
0.0169942304,
0.0239867717,
-0.0880138353,
0.0709536448,
-0.0967082381,
-0.053362947,
0.0145906676,
-0.0061088628,
-0.0612198412,
0.0174235646,
0.0145316627,
0.013147247,
0.0035748095,
-0.0070526325,
-0.0544417426,
-0.0006766637,
-0.0988537595,
-0.0159965288,
0.0038007828,
-0.0340741239,
0.0148876347,
-0.107284613,
0.0067053312,
0.0698416233,
-0.0390175432,
-0.0194494072,
1.970608832e-34,
-0.001540049,
0.0146703646,
-0.0105052153,
0.0172484424,
0.0401992723,
-0.0052158334,
-0.0059655583,
-0.0054181316,
0.0455789827,
-0.0589555055,
0.0132873673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14326v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14326v1 | medIKAL: Integrating Knowledge Graphs as Assistants of LLMs for Enhanced Clinical Diagnosis on EMRs | 2024-06-20T13:56:52 | 2024-06-20T13:56:52 | Mingyi Jia, Junwen Duan, Yan Song, Jianxin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Electronic Medical Records (EMRs), while integral to modern healthcare,
present challenges for clinical reasoning and diagnosis due to their complexity
and information redundancy. To address this, we proposed medIKAL (Integrating
Knowledge Graphs as Assistants of LLMs), a framework that combines Large
Language Models (LLMs) with knowledge graphs (KGs) to enhance diagnostic
capabilities. medIKAL assigns weighted importance to entities in medical
records based on their type, enabling precise localization of candidate
diseases within KGs. It innovatively employs a residual network-like approach,
allowing initial diagnosis by the LLM to be merged into KG search results.
Through a path-based reranking algorithm and a fill-in-the-blank style prompt
template, it further refined the diagnostic process. We validated medIKAL's
effectiveness through extensive experiments on a newly introduced open-sourced
Chinese EMR dataset, demonstrating its potential to improve clinical diagnosis
in real-world settings. | [
0.0349887386,
0.0202310197,
-0.0076064006,
-0.0249982942,
0.0062609944,
0.0133003183,
-0.0248825401,
0.0732327104,
0.0778314173,
-0.0147285834,
0.0354378261,
0.006797031,
-0.0152798388,
0.0249677189,
-0.002860175,
-0.0226020031,
0.0104450528,
0.0358870551,
0.0414204709,
0.0011170466,
-0.0253183972,
0.0080831675,
0.0013918072,
0.0329770818,
0.0367585346,
0.0059491182,
0.0164104123,
0.0002360964,
0.0454766117,
-0.0801417381,
-0.042545218,
0.0074526859,
-0.035163857,
-0.0197483841,
0.0000019328,
-0.065345265,
-0.0338551998,
0.0043413541,
-0.06775105,
-0.0440928489,
-0.0185195599,
-0.0204533339,
0.033739306,
0.0182793289,
-0.0165250599,
-0.0614445582,
0.001000713,
0.0309749618,
0.0342149884,
0.0577080846,
-0.0073151188,
0.0001157661,
0.0245001353,
-0.0277750604,
0.0352748148,
-0.0477365591,
0.0791954696,
0.0148763433,
0.0742760897,
-0.0301548354,
-0.0026920196,
0.0360018574,
-0.0375020429,
-0.0043588006,
0.0275999494,
0.0311626326,
0.0271260869,
0.01371215,
0.0182802994,
0.0792982727,
-0.0117231831,
-0.0009135786,
0.0421091318,
-0.0159329735,
0.0033124043,
0.0363314413,
-0.0171861574,
-0.0312700532,
-0.0545147397,
-0.0083753709,
0.030886922,
-0.0403316207,
0.063305147,
0.0028187626,
-0.0392294228,
0.0887538567,
-0.0107187005,
-0.0107009076,
-0.0032475253,
-0.0415490903,
-0.0193259045,
-0.0446467511,
0.0611587763,
0.0698690563,
-0.0836684406,
0.0170336105,
0.0335520394,
-0.0095625184,
0.0659098327,
-0.0279929303,
-0.0178710707,
-0.0114162341,
0.0440573171,
0.0427562632,
-0.0159770064,
-0.0015461874,
-0.0387296416,
0.0319750272,
-0.0519497506,
-0.0270937495,
-0.063214913,
-0.0297162905,
-0.0000275986,
0.0055892062,
0.0319994688,
-0.0081609357,
-0.0741607174,
0.0181889702,
-0.0272248629,
0.0041294717,
0.0537806004,
0.0284635928,
0.0486450493,
-0.0061021792,
-0.0557656623,
0.0193568096,
0.0184127949,
0.0306887813,
-0.0212629233,
0.0390856601,
0.0387144424,
0.0036832991,
0.0295796283,
0.0129613066,
0.0554358922,
0.0507558547,
0.0494275503,
-0.0141713871,
-0.0138370469,
-0.0486015789,
-0.0214813519,
0.0054495619,
-0.020333007,
-0.0575564355,
0.0019979931,
0.0483628102,
-0.0001347666,
-0.0300730709,
0.0285375696,
0.0038016743,
-0.0809286162,
0.0455658436,
-0.0765750408,
0.0168461595,
-0.0021837188,
0.0318755358,
-0.0188065153,
-0.0149583835,
-0.0070530707,
-0.0358685702,
0.0159519259,
-0.0007714694,
0.0171373971,
-0.0006530267,
0.0137435831,
-0.0235106479,
0.0034211073,
0.0033958585,
-0.0351942666,
0.0663180798,
-0.0306709781,
0.0106447916,
0.0292784106,
0.006107185,
0.0308948513,
0.0456335768,
0.0475826785,
-0.008113143,
0.0024606271,
-0.0386903137,
-0.0468377583,
-0.0175722763,
0.0206530578,
-0.0093269534,
-0.0276978817,
-0.0082961386,
-0.016163433,
0.0000478826,
-0.0159379952,
-0.0256610755,
-0.0658013448,
0.0130076762,
-0.0038436949,
0.012746484,
0.0430345163,
-0.0172375329,
0.0048928303,
0.0601460114,
0.0346281454,
0.0078831445,
-0.0236633252,
-0.0646042749,
-0.0156250317,
0.117708765,
0.0445254371,
-0.060976252,
-0.0393682048,
0.0388687775,
-0.0203352347,
-0.0423985124,
-0.0170168411,
-0.0306775756,
-0.0188353788,
-0.0289829783,
-0.0170176793,
0.0600546859,
0.0243956763,
-0.02716613,
-0.025784228,
0.0398918279,
-0.0119298995,
-0.0852226615,
-0.0056750313,
0.0121908542,
-0.0225135591,
0.0364748314,
0.0172428917,
0.0128731886,
0.0052585872,
0.048145242,
0.0050875666,
0.0396993086,
0.0378999002,
-0.0478788614,
-0.0829915777,
-0.0009270059,
-0.0038910874,
-0.0171547495,
0.0290325191,
-0.0148795526,
-0.0404309109,
-0.0241662059,
-0.0358124152,
-0.0317132734,
-0.0240567401,
-0.0265388153,
0.0390665047,
0.0131100938,
0.0035063962,
0.0280356854,
-0.0403443389,
-0.0319012031,
0.0425968133,
-0.0333681218,
0.0276370328,
0.0279072709,
-0.0411323048,
0.0037051651,
-0.0304483771,
-0.0190225057,
-0.0140212309,
0.0116150687,
0.0374131836,
-0.0049416372,
-0.0162585154,
-0.0144385025,
0.0143585857,
-0.1014021114,
-0.0006529054,
0.0260582939,
0.0200971439,
0.0083375731,
0.0398282371,
0.0002170726,
-0.0134130158,
-0.0394174643,
0.0246666037,
0.0482338332,
-0.0061245989,
0.0448991433,
0.0204272103,
-0.0094493758,
0.0001674346,
-0.0196227841,
-0.0584360398,
0.0196478907,
0.0061043198,
-0.0013580342,
-0.0195913948,
0.0087771993,
-0.070372954,
-0.0096283425,
-0.0068783714,
0.003874843,
-0.0322076045,
-0.04681997,
-0.0254783258,
0.0495170057,
-0.04580836,
0.026897734,
0.0421863161,
0.0129282745,
-0.0192688499,
-0.0030503185,
-0.0364848934,
0.0266067442,
-0.0151604889,
-0.0303754546,
-0.0114389174,
0.0092689032,
0.0147469146,
-0.031967409,
-0.0122717265,
0.0069141621,
-0.018458413,
0.0486345068,
-0.0636407807,
-0.0038188929,
0.0107845049,
0.0130736316,
-0.0024486338,
-0.0163587835,
0.0884352624,
0.0019324445,
0.057448104,
-0.0337127335,
-0.0676611364,
-0.0491305068,
0.0029078193,
-0.0144385463,
0.032769572,
-0.026630478,
-0.0104753757,
0.0101315258,
0.0115935775,
0.0216158759,
-0.0736622885,
0.0295042917,
0.0022428127,
0.0514040403,
0.0416145921,
-0.0097313244,
-0.0188922882,
0.0205408055,
-0.0287270118,
0.0306857135,
0.0023397207,
0.0167592466,
-0.038395673,
0.0637730211,
-0.007558737,
0.0371681862,
0.0388592035,
-0.0286895521,
0.009905708,
0.0197925698,
-0.0156402458,
-0.0181543864,
0.0195192099,
-0.0122242887,
0.0521256775,
0.0541740544,
-0.0341612399,
-0.0373275392,
0.0118995756,
0.0390421487,
-0.0079974877,
-0.035805162,
0.0012870654,
-0.008358622,
-0.0179827362,
-0.0387276858,
0.023021074,
0.0821663663,
0.0431866087,
-0.0739652589,
0.0108914869,
-0.0003368349,
-0.0278331786,
0.0102725457,
0.0180879068,
-0.0633345693,
-0.0183846727,
0.0125090741,
0.0250423085,
-0.0134817353,
-0.0716021806,
0.040738605,
-0.037532039,
0.0413066335,
-0.0192646421,
0.0092485929,
-0.0401491262,
-0.0745170116,
-0.0000681518,
-0.0000589347,
-0.0418775007,
-0.0254792571,
-0.0106981685,
-0.0203791447,
-0.0142771518,
-0.0558703057,
-0.0664393529,
0.0239006076,
-0.0355821252,
0.0316439047,
-0.0100267688,
0.0184831675,
-0.0080806483,
-0.0210706666,
-0.0368659794,
0.0497446656,
0.0177409779,
-0.0340777077,
0.0337559916,
0.0222485587,
-0.0120526124,
-0.0922076628,
-0.0229073633,
-0.037919756,
-0.0210208073,
0.0023168195,
0.1118172482,
-0.0242139101,
-0.0344430655,
-0.0438923314,
-0.0395282544,
0.029334262,
0.0313288793,
-0.0197394658,
-0.0156742018,
0.0129000898,
0.0194072537,
0.0253603458,
0.0625728741,
-0.0220003817,
0.0611966327,
-0.0707287192,
-0.0215813741,
-0.0566534512,
0.0110645685,
0.0415300354,
-0.0111824917,
0.0224241372,
0.0490378253,
0.0210182667,
-0.0149387857,
-0.0964946076,
0.0129060885,
0.0450620838,
0.038848903,
-0.041194506,
-0.0026224044,
0.0620061941,
0.0103006847,
-0.0072673974,
-0.0105279526,
-0.0031563942,
-0.0336600281,
-0.0319441445,
-0.0173995998,
0.0190956946,
-0.0166178811,
-0.0164162349,
-0.0312836953,
0.0650904328,
0.0334438011,
-0.0333331153,
-0.0212738048,
-0.0182559341,
-0.0338599794,
-0.0058329119,
0.0072708549,
-0.0376224555,
0.0055190339,
-0.0033480425,
0.0310366545,
-0.033551693,
-0.0227377042,
0.029940499,
0.0648508295,
0.032279402,
0.011611009,
-0.0325984433,
-0.0443849899,
0.0423910245,
-0.0192767642,
0.0079097161,
-0.0224754885,
0.0122848935,
0.0211704839,
-0.0016565012,
0.0109363375,
-0.0043110182,
-0.0035263703,
-0.0722213462,
-0.0724793449,
0.0519191101,
-0.0066546146,
-0.024867801,
0.082704708,
-0.016702272,
0.025206469,
0.0245229695,
0.022186555,
0.0127454838,
-0.0181705393,
0.0251954328,
0.0030262945,
0.013844802,
-0.0523735583,
0.0288691334,
-0.0202562883,
-0.0648430884,
0.0232699532,
0.0337189287,
0.0862824917,
0.0188738164,
0.0327412151,
-0.0176599044,
-0.0113204634,
-0.0103373267,
-0.0127213914,
-0.0155094387,
0.0120899398,
0.0367787704,
0.0192835443,
-0.0114083327,
0.0255248547,
0.0784503073,
0.0054780291,
0.0394195914,
-0.0207926277,
-0.094408378,
-0.0126491552,
-0.0112823574,
0.0748177618,
0.0186649915,
-0.062464498,
0.0071031214,
-0.065537855,
-0.0875587985,
0.0179707743,
-0.0095328745,
-0.069311589,
0.0022770052,
0.0408491604,
0.0300715026,
0.0479907952,
-0.0169581566,
-0.0230506789,
0.0239290223,
-0.0931212157,
-0.0273442268,
0.0596579164,
-6.043246212e-33,
0.0227525048,
-0.0786314085,
0.0135284411,
-0.0125164697,
0.0356564187,
0.0409796834,
-0.0070408457,
0.0068915118,
0.0147396335,
0.0633321106,
-0.0166250952,
0.0060903053,
0.0025324509,
0.0056407587,
-0.0024321973,
-0.0102632437,
0.0021868292,
0.0572951511,
-0.0046541602,
0.0014432754,
0.0262294654,
0.0439011678,
0.0104992846,
-0.0669072121,
-0.0209112521,
-0.0050426819,
0.0397858024,
0.0546281561,
-0.0486492887,
0.0704591945,
0.0008624026,
0.0605012625,
0.0373225175,
-0.0067704222,
-0.0018881293,
-0.0269805547,
-0.0655632168,
-0.0316863582,
-0.0028409287,
-0.0256077908,
-0.0105999298,
-0.0056476104,
0.0566957518,
0.0109073371,
0.0243007559,
0.0089937942,
0.0416313112,
-0.0135239437,
-0.0426609628,
-0.0386881717,
0.0455681384,
0.0479496904,
-0.0093051968,
0.0270646028,
-0.008687227,
-0.0689593852,
-0.0315514915,
-0.0026979723,
-0.0466342568,
0.0106208501,
0.0184418112,
0.0109729469,
0.0045278897,
-0.0124124661,
-0.0463357829,
0.0418939218,
0.0094398754,
-0.02357498,
-0.0165739749,
0.0145847946,
-0.0552574694,
0.0525866374,
0.0309270043,
-0.0137650864,
-0.0133980736,
-0.0372550078,
-0.1209308654,
0.049033016,
-0.0380099006,
0.0393235832,
0.0195924174,
0.0014474877,
-0.0248844475,
-0.030742351,
-0.0178149045,
0.0019355298,
-0.0591257587,
-0.0138742458,
0.0198096149,
0.0056588822,
-0.0112592326,
-0.0233593285,
0.0027658681,
-0.0288201626,
-0.030088447,
0.0092177019,
0.0492690019,
-0.0038582936,
-0.0347829312,
-0.007924445,
-0.0367720611,
-0.004572039,
-0.0092659788,
-0.0280861557,
0.0407111347,
0.033982724,
0.0052619958,
-0.0304896049,
-0.022441484,
0.0102317845,
0.0457484238,
-0.0486754961,
-0.0205962528,
-0.0138426973,
0.0298597738,
0.0261050425,
0.008406085,
0.0523563586,
0.0718114674,
0.029600732,
-0.0439798012,
-0.0047938549,
0.0124956779,
-0.02074706,
-0.0243699402,
-0.0225026291,
-0.0429815911,
0.052227851,
0.0437624082,
-0.0458869338,
-0.0237211678,
-0.0041076727,
2.887e-7,
0.0924053043,
0.0640517622,
-0.0103580849,
0.0216393489,
0.0372537896,
-0.0089254761,
-0.0126110362,
0.0003118737,
0.0194392577,
0.0015861472,
0.0686435178,
0.0009367944,
-0.022085024,
0.0502698235,
-0.0584227331,
0.0161584765,
-0.0609049127,
-0.0268144812,
-0.0191083793,
-0.0095130112,
0.05058055,
0.0322180465,
-0.029069718,
-0.0124706458,
0.0333380848,
-0.0324038044,
0.0196776893,
-0.0102648688,
0.0346772112,
0.0047207866,
0.0607494749,
-0.0011766052,
0.0026186474,
0.0774301514,
0.0070741591,
0.0162628312,
0.0008866975,
0.0597068481,
-0.0613473132,
0.023596799,
0.0075958711,
-0.0370094068,
0.0563089624,
-0.0479758792,
0.0698683485,
-0.0343900882,
-0.0315507688,
0.0440343097,
0.0225933176,
-0.0428768508,
0.0387545153,
-0.010286835,
-0.0233568884,
0.0294513516,
0.0004092109,
0.0356165729,
-0.0161850918,
-0.0871640295,
-0.005026544,
0.0258762296,
-0.0180487521,
-0.0630833954,
0.0425850302,
-0.0388804115,
0.0148284789,
-0.0649470016,
0.028829366,
2.712067505e-34,
0.0156918485,
0.045932021,
-0.0242239572,
0.0084457034,
0.0438713245,
-0.0326624587,
0.0163236223,
0.0231154449,
0.0031261544,
-0.125042215,
-0.0234301686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14322v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14322v2 | Mind the Privacy Unit! User-Level Differential Privacy for Language Model Fine-Tuning | 2024-06-20T13:54:32 | 2024-07-03T14:05:20 | Lynn Chua, Badih Ghazi, Yangsibo Huang, Pritish Kamath, Ravi Kumar, Daogao Liu, Pasin Manurangsi, Amer Sinha, Chiyuan Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful tools for tackling
complex tasks across diverse domains, but they also raise privacy concerns when
fine-tuned on sensitive data due to potential memorization. While differential
privacy (DP) offers a promising solution by ensuring models are 'almost
indistinguishable' with or without any particular privacy unit, current
evaluations on LLMs mostly treat each example (text record) as the privacy
unit. This leads to uneven user privacy guarantees when contributions per user
vary. We therefore study user-level DP motivated by applications where it
necessary to ensure uniform privacy protection across users. We present a
systematic evaluation of user-level DP for LLM fine-tuning on natural language
generation tasks. Focusing on two mechanisms for achieving user-level DP
guarantees, Group Privacy and User-wise DP-SGD, we investigate design choices
like data selection strategies and parameter tuning for the best
privacy-utility tradeoff. | [
0.0254495516,
0.1087747142,
-0.0410482772,
0.0398568548,
-0.050518088,
-0.0138239618,
0.1129928529,
-0.0528972149,
0.0240752529,
-0.0086837215,
-0.0085638538,
-0.0650304109,
-0.0069562015,
0.002237424,
0.0180570055,
-0.019122107,
0.0446038432,
-0.0525702462,
-0.0028679103,
-0.0282827895,
-0.0570394993,
-0.0013842622,
0.0132344505,
0.0319212154,
0.0207445603,
-0.0056917639,
-0.0040953993,
-0.0072946576,
0.0266083647,
-0.0146782734,
0.0204484314,
0.0901713818,
0.0368620455,
0.0526781641,
0.0000020758,
-0.0367933586,
-0.0393119343,
0.0434078798,
-0.0191760417,
0.0287650283,
0.0115101682,
-0.0083959615,
0.0303966813,
-0.0071736267,
-0.0266896952,
0.0134940241,
0.0567843243,
-0.0003287455,
0.0603380203,
0.0456280783,
0.0020181995,
-0.0200970564,
-0.0341322273,
-0.0417987034,
0.0113901431,
-0.0258600917,
0.0265153013,
-0.0317059569,
-0.0152793424,
-0.0134390444,
0.0227995235,
0.0374317355,
-0.0064697675,
0.0205787998,
0.0169443395,
0.0075275493,
-0.0088818809,
-0.0380700417,
-0.0008674522,
0.0494856201,
0.0182735715,
0.0059976014,
0.0362677313,
0.0015886389,
0.0408247188,
0.0021510099,
0.0058599073,
0.0377603695,
-0.0382483341,
0.0026914692,
0.0124845402,
-0.0072280569,
0.0167033449,
0.0369353183,
0.0041582589,
0.0374324173,
0.0235867389,
0.024214182,
-0.0318575688,
-0.0100696431,
-0.0282108951,
-0.0537735894,
0.0641107708,
0.0036329357,
-0.0036828946,
0.0153545989,
-0.0807406828,
-0.0592756197,
0.0342644267,
-0.0226350781,
0.0456465408,
0.0051473738,
0.0703708529,
-0.0015380654,
0.0026211492,
0.0547727197,
-0.005411278,
-0.0022176891,
0.0502370857,
0.0263065509,
0.014268104,
0.0055047227,
-0.0086731622,
0.0607767887,
-0.0778118223,
0.0136385811,
-0.0232285094,
0.0549311712,
-0.0027197022,
0.0166449919,
0.0074707861,
-0.0008073301,
-0.0645959154,
-0.0154726459,
0.0131563004,
-0.0830699727,
-0.0373673476,
0.0033784877,
0.0384249315,
-0.0396016985,
-0.0187833961,
-0.0456742086,
-0.0020419608,
0.0002918263,
-0.0426240601,
0.0825479776,
0.0196269248,
-0.0153335957,
-0.0186060145,
-0.1042170674,
0.0022547622,
-0.0340090282,
-0.011168886,
-0.0576469302,
0.0207193773,
-0.0107157854,
0.0013374803,
-0.0984485894,
-0.0139109334,
0.0352475233,
-0.0045042997,
0.0316476598,
-0.002841796,
-0.0055839354,
-0.001638767,
0.0461980738,
-0.0028212166,
0.0635458604,
0.022185456,
0.031928353,
0.0493781529,
-0.0116142584,
0.0252481997,
-0.0212747995,
0.0290427897,
0.0469387472,
-0.0163759179,
0.0135420617,
-0.0178804398,
-0.0404414088,
0.0003501289,
0.0629556999,
-0.0149347773,
-0.0501398221,
0.0927513465,
0.0778435245,
0.0397168808,
0.0214678962,
-0.0520346127,
0.0333942063,
-0.0378912836,
0.0171082839,
-0.0433357097,
0.0059237997,
-0.0389768556,
-0.0120954076,
-0.0015218218,
0.0469484255,
-0.0022762781,
0.0128351748,
0.0130160842,
-0.0480179228,
0.0374498852,
0.0162201114,
-0.0283990558,
0.0104476875,
0.029391693,
0.0556485727,
0.0102568986,
-0.0818566903,
0.0102427779,
-0.0173413437,
0.0183231495,
0.0781647861,
0.0321290083,
0.0210755784,
-0.0034572978,
-0.0399616137,
-0.0341882147,
0.041815035,
0.0205672327,
0.0001771862,
0.0727501586,
-0.0262607057,
-0.047245577,
-0.0116658937,
0.0187725201,
0.0263964776,
0.0094360132,
-0.0350471884,
0.0239323452,
-0.0147591978,
-0.0017737316,
0.0422239751,
-0.0274438746,
-0.0491966344,
0.0240694378,
0.0104634566,
0.0277590919,
0.0099150147,
0.0000495622,
0.0091991508,
-0.0235844124,
0.026416542,
0.0116930241,
-0.0313113779,
-0.0480403192,
-0.0156163406,
-0.0253928676,
-0.0283352546,
0.047146339,
0.0296138916,
-0.0007261934,
-0.0264823716,
-0.0005661783,
0.0064257816,
-0.0054079918,
-0.0255762246,
0.0202107355,
-0.0078733349,
0.0188134871,
-0.0429101065,
0.0316198207,
-0.057988219,
-0.0228867885,
-0.0496994592,
-0.0088611078,
0.0313371085,
-0.0464701205,
-0.0178131945,
0.0104345968,
-0.0156923905,
0.0525090694,
0.0412704162,
0.0070172511,
-0.024939036,
-0.0254402831,
-0.0058468641,
0.0297068581,
-0.0202557221,
0.0480135418,
0.0023044972,
0.0359064005,
-0.030973196,
-0.0357027426,
-0.0542197526,
-0.0331075042,
-0.0365060344,
0.0245500952,
0.0111021297,
0.0303741861,
-0.0326355733,
-0.0130206998,
-0.0169651937,
0.0419401303,
0.0161703452,
-0.0138921486,
-0.0168389324,
-0.0242601279,
0.0395408273,
-0.048971273,
0.0275354814,
0.0034433429,
-0.0099608041,
-0.0113950307,
0.0259998403,
0.0106269708,
0.0284980312,
0.0077541047,
0.0003774668,
0.0497232154,
0.0028752983,
-0.046496179,
0.0022759335,
-0.0306591894,
-0.0202277694,
-0.0302961562,
0.0144060925,
0.0497158431,
0.0182731114,
0.0263312068,
-0.0588161536,
-0.0440330245,
0.0520665981,
-0.0241290554,
-0.0359468013,
0.0104571534,
-0.027281655,
-0.0047545135,
0.0450344719,
0.0028738405,
-0.0804685578,
0.0945190266,
-0.0023847574,
0.0396345444,
-0.0068605966,
-0.021378886,
-0.0128737092,
0.0453918315,
-0.0248831548,
0.048724737,
0.0158593766,
-0.0420575514,
-0.0194814112,
0.0283477176,
0.0583668128,
-0.0298570096,
0.0426432975,
-0.0233445,
-0.0271304231,
-0.0114174522,
-0.0651270598,
-0.0461444817,
-0.0837607384,
0.0124606984,
0.0047029718,
0.0295272171,
-0.0642974004,
0.0221772213,
-0.0169233978,
0.0132042971,
0.0005995542,
-0.0065258169,
0.0221234933,
-0.0185710359,
-0.0390025079,
0.0021263089,
-0.037472941,
-0.0051641995,
-0.0440146588,
0.0025187524,
0.0389756747,
0.0556442328,
0.0252577569,
0.0487224348,
-0.0246043745,
0.0420172438,
-0.0244060718,
-0.0277463887,
0.0605848394,
0.0787055641,
-0.0329481736,
-0.0072990819,
0.0703232586,
0.0096973777,
-0.0592124313,
0.0004991418,
0.0457340777,
0.0670750141,
-0.004276433,
-0.0084860818,
-0.0950587615,
0.0172068831,
0.010138372,
0.0815118477,
-0.0442040861,
-0.0571463034,
-0.0593308359,
-0.0633271635,
-0.0082060583,
0.0333546884,
-0.0162812658,
-0.0006529585,
-0.0436845794,
0.0250422955,
0.0121486112,
0.0214869548,
-0.033187706,
-0.0065596472,
-0.0228307098,
0.001629788,
0.0049303342,
-0.0596106648,
-0.0271649994,
-0.0424565002,
0.0337836482,
0.0625157729,
0.0100354217,
0.0336287357,
-0.0623604394,
0.0157632027,
0.0081226984,
0.0073107253,
0.0005656105,
0.0356491283,
0.0025358656,
0.0007578825,
-0.0305493064,
0.0703656152,
-0.0041907867,
0.0103859948,
-0.0086275907,
0.0080144834,
-0.0236716289,
-0.0038492878,
0.0089797284,
-0.0140247848,
0.0457404926,
0.0432702042,
0.0198897999,
-0.0483650416,
-0.0076857884,
-0.0412677974,
0.0178788193,
-0.0516709313,
0.0491415299,
0.030474117,
-0.0228447095,
-0.0556202494,
-0.0569462888,
0.025470145,
-0.0049648886,
0.0170546491,
0.0214359667,
-0.0004459059,
0.0357619599,
-0.0142486906,
-0.0060579805,
0.0206845421,
-0.0633964539,
-0.0030344005,
-0.0373517647,
-0.0293302927,
-0.0054190489,
0.0093266191,
-0.0034744344,
0.037954405,
-0.0676432624,
-0.0965689272,
0.0494862683,
0.028338423,
0.0196414515,
0.0369060524,
-0.0158291813,
-0.1041067541,
0.0571302176,
0.0562292337,
-0.0439682268,
-0.0001063712,
0.0410132743,
-0.0150187844,
-0.0105337044,
0.0345962979,
-0.0235952996,
-0.0312757455,
0.069919005,
-0.0118647106,
0.0160885844,
-0.058759436,
-0.013128276,
0.0608256459,
-0.0003848602,
-0.0296918005,
0.0567879491,
-0.0428503603,
0.0165791847,
-0.0153916227,
-0.0137985675,
-0.015895173,
-0.0324840955,
0.0332600772,
-0.0420196392,
0.0425682738,
-0.018871244,
0.025059076,
0.0314724445,
-0.0707257241,
0.0223600157,
0.0251072403,
0.0242671166,
0.0336826406,
0.0170103647,
-0.0430358909,
0.0627432838,
0.0020686905,
0.0279179085,
-0.016159324,
0.0348143503,
-0.0089744907,
0.022086503,
-0.0123099405,
0.0405934602,
-0.0300647914,
-0.0747491121,
-0.0240935571,
-0.0117487032,
-0.0216291081,
0.0577843264,
0.0143199516,
-0.0474836342,
0.0065880958,
-0.022321023,
0.0262245871,
-0.0059363674,
-0.0182433464,
-0.0266466644,
-0.0247649439,
-0.0136487391,
0.0116861947,
0.0785202608,
0.0278923959,
0.0125405649,
-0.0445628986,
-0.0192586146,
-0.0504644476,
-0.0182348043,
-0.0108177355,
0.053896375,
-0.0150253912,
-0.0107590742,
-0.0605319887,
-0.0596933179,
-0.0463055857,
-0.0023586664,
0.0236549489,
-0.0044805072,
0.0259061679,
-0.0133384801,
-0.0253963843,
-0.0536624305,
-0.0713204965,
-0.026881475,
0.0125393011,
0.0113573568,
-0.0244595949,
-6.085895351e-33,
-0.0400097966,
-0.014150952,
-0.0332546122,
0.0153504359,
0.0271477625,
-0.0062005203,
-0.0044994648,
0.010942257,
0.004530204,
-0.0463907681,
-0.0307335891,
-0.0157898627,
0.0152263623,
0.0326640047,
-0.0381847024,
-0.0032307622,
0.0652884468,
-0.0086870659,
-0.040481735,
0.055088941,
0.0450649075,
0.0158012584,
0.0011754418,
-0.0755248219,
0.07361985,
0.0005209017,
-0.0385683365,
0.0044349409,
-0.0617216751,
0.0327103287,
-0.0178393293,
-0.0018301184,
0.0039146566,
0.0232103802,
-0.0544834137,
0.0241555441,
-0.0498134345,
-0.01194287,
0.0008136518,
-0.0348345116,
0.0353281796,
-0.0858470127,
0.0297980309,
-0.0311235115,
-0.0236020274,
-0.0027549185,
-0.0285345074,
0.0040002931,
-0.0251059011,
-0.0552164242,
0.0000069425,
0.0020958891,
-0.0107046412,
-0.0047050985,
0.0503595434,
-0.0016220532,
-0.0123917796,
-0.0316699259,
-0.0100717377,
0.0497895256,
0.0730639845,
-0.0371002294,
0.079756856,
0.0214396659,
0.0277584326,
0.0410359353,
0.0342421345,
0.0634420514,
0.0089543732,
-0.0291667767,
-0.0035487707,
0.0238314122,
-0.0195744671,
0.0257247798,
-0.0062476466,
-0.0411508679,
-0.0103510087,
0.0218308792,
-0.0538225882,
-0.0186264925,
0.0625461563,
0.0266120844,
-0.0698703378,
-0.0244276393,
-0.0766140521,
-0.0079094367,
-0.021559054,
-0.0033648615,
0.0141121298,
0.0178961251,
-0.0508844927,
-0.0399802104,
0.0332893319,
-0.0364487246,
-0.0170881059,
0.0258082319,
0.0461454466,
-0.0371504277,
-0.0079848906,
-0.021193428,
-0.0251085963,
-0.0102477474,
0.0248152819,
-0.0225181617,
0.0079070842,
-0.0046511539,
0.0052661565,
0.0102319894,
-0.0638484955,
0.0103606526,
-0.0384653695,
0.0527982451,
0.0342489928,
0.0561245158,
0.0424172096,
-0.0493701398,
-0.0214150865,
0.040161103,
0.026741378,
-0.0153548643,
-0.0276849233,
0.0665966347,
-0.0027114616,
0.0019058759,
0.0202156063,
-0.0124424249,
0.0267537422,
-0.0013370904,
0.1272883713,
0.0333660878,
0.0065339799,
-0.0422547683,
2.753e-7,
-0.0067760586,
0.0113651464,
-0.0065426743,
-0.0082834326,
0.0031249202,
0.0502218977,
0.0321078189,
0.0681277886,
-0.0101966057,
0.0478408933,
-0.0239871889,
-0.0189050958,
0.047600504,
0.0304972902,
-0.0095018847,
0.0025573522,
-0.0070601623,
0.0415719636,
-0.059320569,
-0.039799951,
0.0074588517,
0.0108623262,
0.0093409326,
-0.0021188725,
-0.0115863718,
-0.0516460463,
0.0416645147,
-0.0601367131,
-0.0351944827,
0.0064361668,
0.0631283745,
0.0821604803,
0.0263813213,
-0.0070215869,
-0.0125897862,
0.0261699092,
-0.0766014755,
0.1085490659,
0.0425659046,
-0.001902931,
0.0245647971,
-0.0445057563,
-0.0171891525,
-0.0467674397,
0.0109465346,
0.0000046799,
-0.0272381287,
-0.0111205289,
0.0528477021,
-0.0785082355,
0.0273525063,
-0.0568794869,
0.0313675143,
0.0058667911,
-0.0048939558,
0.0301355384,
-0.0114880055,
-0.0428154767,
-0.0491924062,
-0.0158831738,
-0.0229867231,
-0.0209056623,
0.0106037483,
0.0196460746,
-0.0224621072,
-0.0269913804,
0.0784465969,
2.497372646e-34,
-0.0203297157,
-0.013983814,
-0.0103186518,
-0.0034151177,
0.0349632502,
0.0090244245,
0.0409050845,
0.0111469841,
0.041321259,
-0.0448166467,
-0.0229444765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14319v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14319v1 | LiveMind: Low-latency Large Language Models with Simultaneous Inference | 2024-06-20T13:52:30 | 2024-06-20T13:52:30 | Chuangtao Chen, Grace Li Zhang, Xunzhao Yin, Cheng Zhuo, Ulf Schlichtmann, Bing Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | In this paper, we introduce a novel low-latency inference framework for large
language models (LLMs) inference which enables LLMs to perform inferences with
incomplete prompts. By reallocating computational processes to prompt input
phase, we achieve a substantial reduction in latency, thereby significantly
enhancing the interactive experience for users of LLMs. The framework adeptly
manages the visibility of the streaming prompt to the model, allowing it to
infer from incomplete prompts or await additional prompts. Compared with
traditional inference methods that utilize complete prompts, our approach
demonstrates an average reduction of 59% in response latency on the MMLU-Pro
dataset, while maintaining comparable accuracy. Additionally, our framework
facilitates collaborative inference and output across different models. By
employing an LLM for inference and a small language model (SLM) for output, we
achieve an average 68% reduction in response latency, alongside a 5.5%
improvement in accuracy on the MMLU-Pro dataset compared with the SLM baseline.
For long prompts exceeding 20 sentences, the response latency can be reduced by
up to 93%. | [
0.0210919008,
0.0626764223,
-0.0243210029,
0.0242350847,
-0.0466212481,
0.0142740207,
0.0370704457,
-0.0122621739,
0.0475884378,
-0.0096644145,
-0.001880496,
-0.0394480862,
0.0159766264,
0.0411508419,
0.024082778,
-0.0506157428,
0.0468121879,
-0.0707394555,
0.014441506,
-0.0335866027,
-0.0067342203,
0.0159836859,
-0.0236397702,
0.0594585836,
0.0145867756,
-0.0296019297,
-0.0482022166,
-0.000907384,
0.0001611002,
-0.0336702503,
-0.026617961,
0.047013253,
-0.0032386957,
0.0363538153,
0.0000020764,
-0.0560688786,
0.0342516042,
-0.0159998722,
-0.0418339111,
0.0129929101,
0.0077406755,
0.0239803679,
0.00186418,
0.028643515,
-0.0208875611,
-0.0059266575,
0.0531122647,
0.0111728041,
0.0235514864,
0.0383300558,
-0.0084327254,
0.010926595,
-0.0004179448,
-0.0440549031,
-0.0218385085,
-0.0480928645,
0.0155980866,
-0.0296838861,
0.0302757118,
-0.0066287145,
-0.006885007,
0.0787717178,
0.0587651432,
-0.0193230268,
-0.0278063864,
0.0525967218,
-0.0000925638,
-0.0423204191,
-0.0326613411,
0.0524200276,
-0.0090412833,
-0.0208503809,
0.0184871219,
-0.0226648804,
0.0065793246,
-0.0027441042,
-0.0485274047,
0.0515671037,
-0.0382264294,
0.0028683655,
0.0230656192,
-0.0174173769,
0.0269603916,
0.0106241098,
-0.0140391467,
0.0659592748,
0.0386610888,
0.0048219957,
-0.0371609144,
0.016851835,
-0.0705516115,
-0.064960517,
-0.0012936797,
0.0165435448,
-0.0697575435,
-0.0080817575,
-0.0519862846,
-0.0397967659,
-0.0008721661,
-0.0162583459,
0.0758587271,
0.0609800555,
-0.0355299972,
0.0522746146,
-0.00612474,
0.0031744281,
-0.0252539627,
-0.0284720697,
-0.0144699961,
-0.0103533585,
-0.0005441559,
-0.004382187,
-0.0112182992,
0.031791158,
-0.0359136648,
-0.029778624,
-0.028607063,
0.0538151152,
-0.0190928988,
0.0021029599,
-0.0015628479,
0.0024734014,
-0.0320273153,
-0.0288597085,
-0.0165541414,
0.0579336248,
-0.0402422175,
0.0431967378,
0.006531219,
-0.0904147327,
-0.0215276908,
0.0307390131,
-0.0047195982,
-0.0133051006,
-0.0039478801,
0.0519881025,
0.00080999,
-0.01867841,
-0.0070116436,
-0.0191265158,
0.0117103104,
-0.0645005107,
0.0003004874,
-0.087754868,
0.0284272563,
0.0268922541,
-0.019225331,
-0.004456881,
-0.0024776065,
0.0180252828,
-0.007060939,
0.0531073213,
-0.0228797086,
0.0289096981,
0.0306941643,
0.0225823764,
-0.0614824854,
0.0959245041,
-0.0011790521,
0.007398075,
0.0325620882,
0.0037876377,
-0.0010741707,
0.0607550032,
0.0262988023,
0.0017256098,
-0.0112293614,
-0.0044421414,
0.0158208255,
0.0445150658,
0.0354670882,
0.0277281106,
-0.0178807154,
0.0135746254,
0.0874462128,
0.0852892026,
-0.0111762928,
-0.0452824384,
0.049467463,
0.0485545769,
0.0183426347,
-0.0079932641,
-0.0847089738,
0.0342902504,
-0.0101227481,
0.0220176782,
0.0341967605,
0.0648351759,
-0.0155297592,
-0.0014759435,
0.007611102,
-0.0217003487,
-0.0417566188,
0.0585817248,
0.0384049006,
-0.0116623174,
-0.0042829053,
0.0605366118,
0.0438885801,
-0.0366100967,
-0.0254700594,
-0.0635925904,
0.0514897741,
0.069989033,
0.0210804343,
-0.0050599361,
-0.019971367,
-0.0004275071,
0.0303208623,
0.0615744814,
0.0228582118,
0.0052367817,
0.0156175913,
-0.0156192733,
-0.0021440492,
0.0453582406,
0.019225128,
0.0350000225,
0.041918803,
-0.0028267771,
-0.0020474722,
0.0195687246,
0.0216626544,
0.0020426889,
-0.0308823679,
0.0158246476,
-0.0046034157,
-0.0009879587,
0.016992908,
-0.0167097822,
-0.0015325956,
0.0044277813,
0.0175820347,
-0.0370074213,
0.008091053,
0.0107853487,
-0.0504872799,
-0.0560747087,
0.0200891793,
0.0282444954,
-0.0150908595,
0.0535328574,
-0.0245578494,
-0.0318499245,
-0.0098055517,
-0.0152528752,
0.0382412784,
-0.0287937205,
0.0027236727,
0.0112571251,
0.0143751102,
-0.0059562512,
0.0301512983,
-0.0120399864,
0.02799684,
0.0751507729,
0.0199568532,
-0.0305770803,
-0.0578923523,
-0.018602604,
0.0309883952,
-0.0080965618,
-0.0332778431,
-0.0033879294,
-0.0009449118,
-0.0173023101,
-0.0041997205,
-0.1186485887,
-0.0138949277,
-0.0363190845,
0.013596273,
0.0220488347,
0.031789761,
-0.0449666455,
-0.0423891917,
0.0097632045,
0.0293752532,
0.0363552272,
0.0474855714,
-0.0116825486,
-0.0011778575,
-0.0156379063,
-0.017726792,
-0.0122180171,
0.0001136713,
0.0483670495,
-0.0101821655,
-0.0572058521,
-0.0632705167,
-0.0061050728,
-0.021134451,
0.0406179056,
-0.0226955004,
-0.0065524806,
0.0154122524,
-0.0417555571,
0.0544059128,
0.0598440282,
0.0071072192,
-0.0109754438,
0.0542604588,
-0.0281674955,
-0.044451654,
0.013016725,
-0.0148187065,
0.0023971011,
-0.0231297035,
-0.003573487,
-0.0411866605,
0.0634162277,
0.0080414414,
-0.0236583054,
-0.0343375951,
0.034161672,
0.0079999585,
-0.0290944017,
-0.0397635102,
-0.0135624073,
-0.0248028133,
0.0379500315,
-0.0069542672,
-0.077337116,
0.0810816586,
-0.0536106639,
-0.0119090015,
0.003546081,
-0.0153698605,
-0.0064983838,
0.0816805512,
0.0139954854,
-0.0195310395,
-0.0117184864,
-0.036725834,
-0.0444808938,
0.0441164151,
0.0165066328,
-0.0323371328,
0.0293559693,
-0.0783041269,
-0.0042878832,
-0.0399747156,
-0.047689639,
-0.0347230546,
-0.0363927186,
-0.0683423877,
-0.0059878933,
0.0175907072,
-0.0328180157,
0.0081470227,
0.0015050492,
-0.0074918754,
0.0744523481,
-0.0450022221,
0.0090520661,
-0.0411934517,
0.0123134367,
0.0653163642,
0.0355702937,
-0.0029872325,
-0.0261067059,
0.0437024161,
0.0613902882,
0.0140035814,
-0.0011010633,
-0.0256393421,
0.0030889455,
0.0509119853,
0.0082571153,
-0.0255140476,
0.0641513318,
0.0629896522,
-0.0851600468,
-0.0114520434,
0.1136560515,
-0.0057722842,
-0.0647775009,
-0.0115943821,
-0.0139832478,
0.0648366734,
0.0015773244,
0.025224736,
-0.0669958219,
-0.0530782081,
0.0494425446,
0.0190203208,
0.0022531946,
-0.024130499,
-0.0164089072,
-0.1059255376,
0.0312315915,
-0.0209536497,
-0.0183441602,
-0.0051379413,
-0.0394544639,
-0.0101946425,
0.0498263277,
-0.000240328,
0.0171914902,
0.001419223,
-0.0164422803,
-0.0190773141,
-0.0250508245,
-0.0532615557,
0.048677031,
-0.0248158537,
0.1061345786,
0.0396182686,
-0.0076570795,
0.0202702079,
-0.0404124781,
0.0569000579,
-0.0320487581,
-0.0313581638,
-0.0131507693,
0.0214086063,
0.0008611574,
-0.0086421836,
-0.0238013137,
0.0336181447,
0.0209424943,
-0.0114451433,
0.0193074141,
0.0601515025,
-0.0302439593,
-0.0205494817,
-0.0202711299,
0.0124330055,
0.0340251923,
0.0575520247,
0.0379500128,
-0.0591844805,
-0.0148031246,
-0.0052620089,
-0.0552444495,
-0.0159757044,
-0.0348455124,
-0.0113448063,
0.0052743475,
-0.0299242381,
-0.0111082774,
-0.0211890135,
0.0290654115,
0.0285110343,
0.0096479952,
0.0283323061,
0.020661246,
0.0008102951,
-0.0356878862,
0.0651191324,
-0.0093400106,
0.0170558281,
-0.0471719727,
0.0048986902,
0.0097124157,
-0.0352750234,
-0.01472391,
0.0452407748,
-0.1329867244,
-0.0748041496,
-0.0072956802,
0.0329453982,
0.0279184747,
0.0603793636,
-0.019533718,
-0.0640637875,
0.0153167089,
0.0326859951,
-0.0379415154,
0.0445921496,
0.0076616565,
0.0319830664,
0.0057925121,
0.0530251451,
-0.0422590449,
0.002859243,
0.0026729354,
0.0403799713,
0.0007935136,
-0.0431503989,
-0.0290820431,
0.0302393101,
0.065267086,
-0.0182599314,
-0.0051826313,
-0.033556059,
0.0336925089,
-0.033566799,
0.0100172106,
-0.0319502987,
0.0217430275,
-0.006999359,
-0.020274777,
0.0159969181,
-0.0036217694,
0.0242271703,
-0.0364768542,
-0.0346872993,
-0.0205668975,
0.0027850771,
-0.0189377405,
0.071710147,
-0.0128981126,
-0.0305256993,
-0.013634203,
0.0076629552,
0.0271103773,
-0.0308572911,
0.0568188354,
0.042349752,
-0.0342861749,
-0.0042967959,
0.0066575939,
-0.0735240355,
-0.0803357586,
0.0170369633,
0.0729170591,
0.0489484966,
0.0237150136,
0.0396981873,
-0.028986359,
0.004540761,
-0.0348575376,
0.0551993214,
0.0216352884,
-0.0400878116,
0.0496372879,
0.0232731439,
-0.0166737922,
0.0226167142,
0.0467101485,
0.003408506,
0.0314687937,
0.0027285786,
-0.0067448434,
-0.0172113106,
-0.0314947627,
-0.0313798301,
0.0256367102,
-0.0288562998,
0.0319344588,
-0.0335025787,
-0.0685873926,
0.0045868587,
0.017651841,
-0.0345908403,
-0.0125156129,
0.0192019362,
0.0639153048,
0.0225095991,
-0.0766161531,
-0.0209823307,
0.0322519317,
-0.0104888566,
-0.0325545445,
-0.0273081809,
-6.901833531e-33,
-0.0408483185,
-0.0665385798,
0.0327216312,
-0.0201035328,
-0.0402588248,
0.0186007768,
-0.0396253802,
0.0060782311,
-0.0125354659,
-0.00380809,
-0.029475566,
0.0378731266,
0.0218834877,
0.0358842909,
-0.0012756689,
-0.01285428,
0.0342746563,
-0.0033394375,
-0.0263608024,
0.0210558809,
0.0298240706,
0.0287551563,
0.0132457586,
0.0075866608,
0.0196182765,
-0.0097738029,
0.0322791897,
0.0281822979,
-0.0478602275,
0.0187816992,
-0.0400520302,
0.0590821393,
-0.0022928778,
-0.0279771574,
-0.023048887,
0.0498178042,
-0.0525621027,
-0.0082444027,
0.0297663826,
0.0041435305,
-0.0318948515,
-0.0086070495,
-0.0085582491,
0.0232472643,
-0.0009460836,
0.0009903463,
0.0141890449,
-0.0194073319,
-0.0257233605,
-0.0078371968,
-0.03498495,
0.014385893,
0.0020455718,
-0.0060912473,
0.0306090638,
0.0621483959,
-0.007148569,
0.0139142266,
-0.0571164005,
0.0043756738,
0.0244189892,
0.0650313199,
0.0720796511,
0.0100261588,
0.0152362678,
0.0409240015,
0.0033749568,
-0.0178355277,
-0.0849509165,
0.0086695394,
0.0374444462,
0.0147220735,
0.046023678,
0.0067016184,
0.0078541012,
-0.0005484903,
-0.0484226793,
-0.0041484358,
0.0635179803,
0.0234577712,
0.0473803356,
-0.0194533691,
-0.0414799824,
-0.0367044657,
-0.0362203009,
-0.0276867896,
-0.0327432528,
0.0045444337,
0.064563483,
0.0211726241,
0.0107263345,
-0.0496135391,
0.0613007993,
-0.0212331712,
-0.0128468564,
-0.0242365617,
0.0044089737,
0.017176602,
-0.0036137609,
0.0385310315,
-0.0255748741,
-0.0028863284,
0.0093867015,
0.0075901812,
0.0225059167,
0.0016067938,
-0.0135609237,
0.0261300597,
-0.0728414133,
0.0085838493,
-0.0216294341,
0.0149962017,
0.0156992748,
-0.0175122004,
0.0699338913,
-0.0377709717,
-0.0014297649,
0.0528809167,
-0.0188444108,
-0.0191270206,
-0.0212657824,
-0.0155538479,
-0.023985479,
0.0138255479,
-0.0318175964,
0.028035596,
-0.0584162176,
0.0516997166,
0.0034786419,
-0.051768966,
-0.0206876472,
0.0301509798,
2.757e-7,
0.0079127401,
0.0109421667,
0.0039001056,
0.045820348,
0.0102660144,
0.0167170968,
0.0019756274,
0.00254988,
0.0342412181,
0.0024388351,
-0.0193843208,
0.0340901166,
0.0716597289,
0.0188865382,
-0.1114240959,
-0.0129689397,
-0.0940891728,
0.0342985503,
-0.0582996868,
-0.0173575338,
0.0523911901,
0.0690974221,
0.0022119787,
-0.0028931268,
0.0381831937,
0.0000894313,
0.0330606364,
-0.0225360524,
-0.0259705409,
-0.0256000217,
0.0622146614,
-0.0352910347,
0.0126860281,
0.0388105325,
0.00086585,
-0.0193606578,
-0.0291543771,
0.0480889045,
0.0354101025,
-0.0141704595,
-0.0259322748,
-0.0305331089,
0.0049051675,
-0.0380664952,
0.0902117118,
-0.0527951755,
-0.0240173824,
-0.0341724828,
0.0124570169,
-0.0781003684,
0.0086283116,
-0.0103320722,
-0.0006519324,
0.0004695409,
0.0102677643,
-0.029103253,
-0.0053787101,
-0.0739278346,
-0.0382118821,
0.0055984152,
-0.0542076454,
-0.080698967,
-0.054872565,
-0.0161050018,
0.0448847525,
-0.0671387762,
0.0116481232,
2.659295156e-34,
0.0288052578,
0.001183711,
0.0114991851,
0.0849555358,
-0.0040099001,
-0.0365434177,
0.019445885,
0.005799979,
0.01115607,
-0.1055145115,
-0.053628061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14318v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14318v1 | The Fire Thief Is Also the Keeper: Balancing Usability and Privacy in Prompts | 2024-06-20T13:52:25 | 2024-06-20T13:52:25 | Zhili Shen, Zihang Xi, Ying He, Wei Tong, Jingyu Hua, Sheng Zhong | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | The rapid adoption of online chatbots represents a significant advancement in
artificial intelligence. However, this convenience brings considerable privacy
concerns, as prompts can inadvertently contain sensitive information exposed to
large language models (LLMs). Limited by high computational costs, reduced task
usability, and excessive system modifications, previous works based on local
deployment, embedding perturbation, and homomorphic encryption are inapplicable
to online prompt-based LLM applications.
To address these issues, this paper introduces Prompt Privacy Sanitizer
(i.e., ProSan), an end-to-end prompt privacy protection framework that can
produce anonymized prompts with contextual privacy removed while maintaining
task usability and human readability. It can also be seamlessly integrated into
the online LLM service pipeline. To achieve high usability and dynamic
anonymity, ProSan flexibly adjusts its protection targets and strength based on
the importance of the words and the privacy leakage risk of the prompts.
Additionally, ProSan is capable of adapting to diverse computational resource
conditions, ensuring privacy protection even for mobile devices with limited
computing power. Our experiments demonstrate that ProSan effectively removes
private information across various tasks, including question answering, text
summarization, and code generation, with minimal reduction in task performance. | [
0.0634243786,
0.0605577454,
-0.0223068669,
0.0206861589,
-0.0267838202,
-0.0224120822,
0.0902447104,
-0.0107974261,
0.0644144639,
-0.0163973719,
-0.0257163178,
-0.0268270914,
0.0080707194,
0.0407547355,
0.0051892125,
-0.0107902531,
0.0154668437,
-0.0480458103,
0.0307277627,
-0.0226734132,
0.0014151493,
0.0123442076,
0.0141968718,
0.0588469394,
0.013167751,
-0.0490910523,
-0.0293283109,
-0.0123784831,
-0.0001949732,
-0.0008758531,
0.0056105466,
0.0536672361,
-0.0148233473,
0.0510280095,
0.0000023411,
-0.0529525243,
-0.03286184,
0.0333892144,
-0.0605802648,
0.007167588,
0.0214895885,
0.0115589481,
-0.0203062166,
0.0501927622,
-0.0296584945,
0.0455457121,
0.0483640172,
0.0182451122,
0.0820079818,
0.0379531235,
-0.0069507211,
0.0166400857,
0.023920618,
0.0092643211,
0.0177669153,
-0.0417615771,
-0.0068150172,
-0.0891670212,
-0.0112967882,
0.0352789648,
0.0005847027,
0.0378466062,
0.0197130367,
-0.0073528779,
-0.0070427721,
0.0255591907,
-0.0238122772,
-0.0363689885,
-0.0369762853,
0.0518217161,
0.0128058149,
-0.0084177488,
0.0297908355,
0.0202240553,
0.03373098,
-0.0003792369,
-0.001442295,
0.0451359823,
-0.0432479382,
-0.0334054641,
-0.0203192532,
-0.032696981,
-0.0001496464,
0.0097869067,
0.0206604544,
0.0418351553,
0.0301772188,
-0.0119489944,
-0.0441972315,
-0.0527930856,
0.0097277118,
-0.0772087052,
0.0723488033,
0.0370857716,
-0.0084835589,
-0.0018194944,
-0.0538968332,
-0.0444459617,
0.0045214486,
-0.0234906506,
-0.0077292891,
0.0419685505,
0.0105669685,
0.0172727183,
-0.0072971182,
0.0820096582,
0.0274194404,
0.0014529229,
0.0185453631,
-0.0085590165,
0.0007320814,
-0.0219466183,
-0.0314135142,
0.0725519583,
-0.0432016738,
0.0109001575,
-0.022020191,
0.0690312162,
-0.0070615178,
0.0361238532,
-0.0150281955,
-0.001583625,
-0.0212526284,
-0.0026635046,
0.019631641,
-0.0514527373,
-0.0276940502,
-0.0186741371,
0.0152031537,
-0.0872618482,
0.0013896255,
-0.0154658286,
0.0067249979,
0.020922184,
-0.025355475,
0.0915507153,
0.0138291987,
-0.0330288,
0.0140555957,
-0.0473129079,
-0.0101697398,
-0.0138052665,
-0.0308668669,
-0.0300940685,
0.0344158001,
-0.0260175318,
-0.0309572816,
-0.0431108736,
0.0069736121,
0.0573117025,
-0.0188902691,
0.0617867224,
-0.0342647471,
-0.0183900259,
0.0160268582,
0.0435369089,
-0.0166174304,
-0.005780241,
0.0334257111,
0.0615735836,
0.0667568818,
-0.0251484774,
0.0534366593,
-0.0035788468,
-0.0151426215,
-0.0257577915,
0.0308769643,
0.0220449474,
0.0312549062,
-0.0376053713,
-0.0080800196,
0.0518013202,
0.0119725866,
-0.0259018652,
0.098382324,
0.1040779948,
-0.0664636865,
0.0044075623,
-0.0452919975,
0.0536168404,
-0.0007636176,
-0.0302385781,
-0.0753717422,
0.0163528696,
-0.0856227428,
-0.0307076834,
-0.0082581993,
0.0109959124,
-0.0138328327,
-0.0139077809,
0.0212151501,
-0.0613495111,
0.0160677563,
0.0321031548,
-0.0175431557,
0.0138338907,
-0.0272193924,
0.0285511296,
-0.0160877388,
-0.0799237266,
-0.0398484878,
-0.0610221773,
0.0454572178,
0.1219551191,
0.0494792238,
0.0108151324,
-0.0044178287,
-0.0319309607,
-0.0123569258,
0.0268554203,
-0.0165676121,
0.0220729467,
0.0601399653,
-0.0391909853,
-0.0451663211,
0.0225302111,
-0.0020854713,
-0.007436797,
0.0080955494,
-0.015012173,
0.0229742527,
0.0287128799,
0.0321652815,
0.0135592939,
-0.0258931965,
-0.0350498483,
0.0136029432,
0.029966509,
0.0065081199,
0.0377015658,
0.026253894,
0.0145648392,
0.0159235131,
0.0092775561,
-0.0000736219,
-0.0233470779,
-0.0219253674,
0.0033684783,
0.0020950714,
-0.0110836001,
0.0095494045,
0.0660692081,
-0.020358121,
0.0004068757,
-0.0321819037,
-0.0199165493,
0.0106541673,
-0.0304376967,
0.0293112136,
-0.0182260443,
0.0310590975,
-0.0353710577,
0.0021969571,
-0.0144533608,
-0.0038286899,
-0.0289869625,
0.0336278789,
-0.0217943359,
-0.0234640911,
-0.0283719376,
-0.0159911104,
-0.0145501634,
0.0183744896,
0.0044385591,
0.0238861814,
-0.0327917822,
-0.0165584255,
-0.0965724289,
0.010852837,
0.0058549889,
0.0174855161,
0.0134554254,
0.0475299209,
-0.0159549732,
-0.0386032686,
-0.0606204383,
-0.0244120471,
-0.0226915479,
0.0464003272,
0.0443541892,
-0.0274454765,
-0.0607548952,
-0.0020715671,
0.0082984492,
0.007170619,
0.0062641697,
-0.0398427844,
-0.012076268,
-0.0223786905,
0.0420705229,
-0.0280933063,
0.0038671272,
0.0072661308,
-0.0238182098,
-0.0016373917,
0.0015838621,
0.0082239266,
0.0603708848,
0.0523129776,
-0.0091212299,
0.0356920958,
0.0131769255,
-0.0335508846,
-0.0122397337,
0.0249820072,
-0.0238995813,
0.0049378695,
-0.0235564392,
0.0402523316,
-0.0067827012,
0.0249293,
-0.0149571784,
-0.0359809957,
0.0446372107,
-0.0024871067,
-0.0318927728,
-0.045250874,
-0.0301452409,
-0.034293931,
0.0287982989,
-0.0277329162,
-0.0699754283,
0.0680734217,
-0.0334612131,
0.0203484539,
0.0139767379,
-0.0345891751,
-0.0046512284,
0.0740375742,
-0.0292070527,
0.0442472249,
0.0489399508,
-0.083900243,
-0.031818606,
-0.0149028506,
0.0229695272,
-0.0693544224,
-0.0126606487,
-0.016951479,
-0.0437044166,
0.0091374489,
-0.0661974251,
-0.0508377329,
-0.0870411992,
-0.0051537505,
-0.0026024142,
0.0016828122,
-0.0202067047,
0.033163324,
-0.001578258,
0.0251606591,
0.0156260617,
-0.0143786883,
0.0021548774,
-0.050223507,
0.0034762684,
-0.0180619098,
-0.0015881459,
-0.0209669918,
0.0005340822,
0.0267726649,
0.0856081173,
0.0526363291,
-0.0362857692,
0.0244763568,
-0.0354492292,
0.0361646935,
-0.0338155329,
-0.0494384207,
0.0313468203,
0.0762554035,
-0.0364519358,
0.001824073,
0.0929029137,
0.0181385186,
-0.0655379668,
-0.0060845292,
0.0290545579,
0.008073953,
-0.0010915956,
0.0067650555,
-0.0863906965,
-0.0132655147,
0.0350138433,
0.0581101514,
-0.0405446179,
-0.0282996856,
-0.0357334241,
-0.0947441608,
-0.0015700612,
-0.0120546892,
-0.0278076846,
-0.0500790924,
-0.0491723232,
0.0034674185,
0.0497148298,
0.0192735288,
-0.027142873,
-0.0071537015,
-0.002032843,
-0.0220603235,
-0.0506672747,
0.0250830874,
-0.0036982803,
-0.0423157848,
0.0479444638,
0.0663725883,
0.0172152352,
0.01444373,
0.0013904398,
0.0203894172,
0.0471792221,
-0.0251346342,
0.0064105471,
0.0259930827,
0.0051036533,
0.0014047251,
-0.0366231203,
0.0329281576,
-0.0160521623,
-0.0026742122,
0.0456203595,
0.0061257421,
-0.0208064895,
0.0159383044,
-0.0080741467,
-0.0076984544,
0.0223187171,
0.0776263624,
-0.0033522418,
-0.0516554341,
-0.0117251668,
-0.0648541152,
0.0290084481,
0.005660098,
0.0183047559,
-0.0062000677,
-0.0084220553,
-0.0442710817,
-0.0479386114,
-0.0026627649,
-0.0283580013,
-0.0111613721,
0.0500887111,
-0.0020208645,
0.0121118315,
0.0448588021,
-0.0244073067,
-0.0204120334,
-0.1165419072,
0.0305595621,
-0.0163322445,
0.0493925698,
0.0104824407,
-0.0152067272,
-0.0015352914,
0.0226764567,
-0.0375326537,
-0.0317892507,
0.0061729704,
0.0515314341,
0.0209523141,
0.0133992573,
-0.0596184507,
-0.0426191092,
0.0810497552,
0.0299824141,
-0.0677654594,
0.0194401368,
0.0387924202,
0.0223768055,
0.0077189454,
0.0042905253,
-0.0390825234,
-0.0279792324,
0.0302312337,
-0.021105336,
-0.0140364962,
-0.0815155134,
-0.0136998221,
0.0656313375,
-0.0099275913,
0.0323799923,
0.032597471,
-0.0084847724,
0.0353938229,
-0.0315442942,
0.0030894636,
-0.0061102924,
0.0141411657,
-0.0082399594,
-0.0025043674,
0.0538853556,
0.0222133771,
0.0109195905,
0.0143461647,
-0.021299215,
0.0164831821,
-0.0079333074,
0.0468518287,
0.0070745624,
0.0178754143,
-0.0439759195,
0.0892882422,
0.0303792246,
0.0233933162,
-0.0190650318,
0.0487102456,
-0.0139264632,
-0.0115022603,
-0.0132477432,
0.0675348341,
-0.0936866701,
-0.0729414001,
0.0125784706,
0.0471733101,
-0.0244677644,
0.0543882363,
-0.0444025174,
-0.0046988581,
0.009464276,
-0.0364072174,
0.00831162,
0.0166755319,
-0.0381090567,
-0.0212215185,
-0.0009489106,
-0.0119525697,
-0.0022232463,
0.071670413,
-0.0190154016,
0.0181731284,
-0.013205247,
-0.0435435139,
-0.059307579,
-0.0150501346,
0.0022687213,
0.0591079704,
-0.0247037411,
-0.0432520732,
-0.0407754779,
-0.0596433096,
-0.0218243282,
-0.0316659473,
0.0099767158,
-0.0132881142,
0.0351740718,
0.0135437604,
-0.0038244615,
-0.0500170216,
-0.0744162872,
0.0411379077,
0.0044636941,
-0.0126145249,
-0.0082559837,
-5.671617714e-33,
-0.0049807061,
-0.0407621637,
-0.0260296315,
0.0336051472,
0.0026562689,
0.0239898935,
-0.02008879,
0.0038136935,
-0.0207077041,
-0.038017828,
-0.0415648371,
0.0297374632,
0.0232098177,
0.0257793628,
-0.0354759172,
-0.0064095855,
0.0569110736,
-0.0093110595,
-0.0055412906,
0.0522039719,
0.0447479934,
0.0261654984,
-0.0192508698,
-0.0476091318,
0.0456727147,
-0.0186720956,
-0.0411578603,
0.012815713,
-0.0124278292,
0.0215602349,
-0.0141157452,
0.0279141869,
0.0014559167,
-0.0238459874,
0.0115537206,
0.1261147708,
-0.0466785543,
-0.0320173353,
0.0027866848,
-0.0079590557,
-0.0012639449,
-0.1155907735,
0.0245867576,
-0.0449624769,
-0.0118444515,
0.0227800272,
0.0054667871,
-0.0108777955,
-0.0125128338,
-0.0394869298,
0.0040568705,
-0.0183042213,
-0.0151963783,
-0.0018456492,
0.026915323,
0.053480152,
0.0105946902,
-0.0152499247,
-0.0230277739,
0.0431533009,
0.0158880353,
-0.0249785222,
0.0340082534,
0.0302221477,
0.0082659107,
0.0331790932,
0.0692961514,
0.0257482547,
-0.0027978998,
-0.0142991096,
-0.0127176158,
-0.0004900984,
0.0324745737,
0.0183607396,
-0.0000616432,
-0.0462770164,
-0.0025878458,
0.0251069814,
0.0360148735,
-0.0271193534,
0.044614587,
-0.0013680711,
-0.0740721226,
-0.011680685,
-0.0458271354,
0.0185498614,
-0.0398766138,
-0.0176789481,
0.0102398396,
-0.0151062459,
-0.0377874002,
-0.0426620357,
-0.0003672822,
-0.0551792681,
0.0066689071,
0.0339601785,
0.0671238974,
-0.0214578882,
0.0053917635,
0.025948409,
0.0070341807,
0.0171387345,
0.011087616,
-0.0469879732,
0.0172394384,
0.0134083182,
0.0011553282,
-0.0019625502,
-0.0911770687,
-0.0198484641,
-0.0143755572,
0.0420477167,
0.0253667291,
0.0141735738,
0.0325053446,
-0.0288850628,
0.0062292046,
0.0379056148,
0.0290680062,
0.01214951,
-0.0432538763,
0.0278957803,
-0.0018083343,
-0.0192157812,
0.01670314,
-0.0134865521,
-0.0087199323,
0.0525515787,
0.0539621301,
-0.0093430886,
-0.004072845,
-0.040590141,
3.043e-7,
-0.0201206766,
-0.013202576,
-0.0031350672,
0.0013991932,
0.0378237665,
0.075127773,
0.055436179,
0.0677272007,
-0.0063090916,
0.0062070121,
-0.0369688869,
0.0296546258,
0.0666730851,
0.0308526792,
-0.0869028345,
-0.0525723323,
-0.0052488456,
-0.0126772188,
-0.0549890511,
0.0711030215,
0.0575534999,
0.0759567171,
0.0158708617,
-0.0227896571,
-0.0144434432,
-0.0214515589,
-0.0089747189,
-0.0338877775,
-0.0362393595,
-0.0122669805,
0.0233697761,
0.0375053249,
0.0318017527,
0.0304201599,
-0.0168756321,
-0.025517568,
-0.0133904619,
0.0897102952,
0.0316227376,
-0.0257583,
0.0132965408,
-0.0498802513,
-0.0136019029,
-0.0203100555,
0.0639694184,
0.0294569749,
-0.0542876162,
-0.0384339914,
0.0066413381,
-0.078825444,
0.0132290404,
-0.024667887,
-0.0135256657,
0.0084544206,
-0.0105145462,
-0.0031371757,
0.0087460494,
-0.0458169617,
-0.0344139785,
-0.0511767343,
-0.0056302138,
-0.0606104806,
-0.0111046256,
-0.0017587685,
0.0167427901,
-0.0413336307,
0.0727076977,
3.101884161e-34,
-0.0078605935,
-0.0301951244,
-0.0112413457,
0.0558712669,
0.0467846058,
0.0219611786,
0.0546844676,
-0.0002772856,
0.0656178966,
-0.0502607413,
-0.0220216438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14314v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14314v2 | Identifying User Goals from UI Trajectories | 2024-06-20T13:46:10 | 2024-06-30T12:33:48 | Omri Berkovitch, Sapir Caduri, Noam Kahlon, Anatoly Efros, Avi Caciularu, Ido Dagan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Autonomous agents that interact with graphical user interfaces (GUIs) hold
significant potential for enhancing user experiences. To further improve these
experiences, agents need to be personalized and proactive. By effectively
comprehending user intentions through their actions and interactions with GUIs,
agents will be better positioned to achieve these goals. This paper introduces
the task of goal identification from observed UI trajectories, aiming to infer
the user's intended task based on their GUI interactions. We propose a novel
evaluation metric to assess whether two task descriptions are paraphrases
within a specific UI environment. By Leveraging the inverse relation with the
UI automation task, we utilized the Android-In-The-Wild and Mind2Web datasets
for our experiments. Using our metric and these datasets, we conducted several
experiments comparing the performance of humans and state-of-the-art models,
specifically GPT-4 and Gemini-1.5 Pro. Our results show that Gemini performs
better than GPT but still underperforms compared to humans, indicating
significant room for improvement. | [
0.0716823786,
0.0300697554,
-0.0359436832,
0.0119603667,
-0.0323703177,
-0.0007324637,
-0.0074457247,
0.0182946157,
0.016488634,
-0.0397432223,
-0.0284158848,
-0.0145940641,
0.0005505914,
0.0091009075,
-0.0229694266,
-0.057312537,
0.0128249684,
-0.014534031,
-0.0357622989,
0.0831684172,
-0.003900107,
0.0263923574,
0.002586141,
0.1036946177,
0.0163609944,
-0.0369472243,
-0.0127683263,
0.0336280987,
0.0197966825,
-0.0231903214,
-0.0140628517,
0.0134060206,
0.0005172894,
0.0236634016,
0.0000019454,
-0.0437754877,
0.0293387547,
-0.0246879663,
-0.0243994072,
-0.0369332507,
0.0754534602,
0.0448406674,
0.0231620744,
0.0160729382,
-0.0302991234,
0.0079105059,
0.0024163052,
0.053901948,
0.0546595976,
0.0274869129,
-0.0167095289,
0.0563485101,
-0.0343815759,
0.0274215546,
0.0296749845,
-0.0585711524,
0.009958501,
-0.0143074924,
0.0235857628,
-0.0424820744,
0.0397650301,
-0.0242435951,
-0.0082289418,
0.0420621224,
-0.0321964771,
0.0170434359,
-0.0355030783,
-0.0533004403,
-0.0067194924,
0.0678708032,
-0.0147437425,
-0.0231457483,
0.0481669344,
0.0044412599,
0.0194390304,
0.0342354588,
-0.0178031288,
-0.0137208235,
-0.0670256987,
-0.0435765535,
-0.0330014527,
0.0442298651,
0.0249522552,
-0.0014813114,
-0.0393882208,
0.0355498306,
-0.004656354,
-0.0181368813,
-0.0064119543,
-0.0112447767,
-0.0083920956,
-0.0653545856,
0.0327023789,
0.0305340644,
-0.054611627,
0.0108698895,
-0.0523620062,
-0.0329653919,
-0.0287879314,
-0.0195109602,
0.0628077686,
0.0308092702,
-0.0076120086,
0.0357190184,
0.0065247836,
0.0734058619,
-0.0046611046,
0.0146538392,
-0.0688368604,
0.01642319,
-0.08578787,
0.0190292969,
-0.0413150415,
0.0267523229,
0.0140892426,
-0.0264176205,
-0.0255834013,
0.0683913231,
-0.0094679287,
0.0156838372,
0.0043949629,
0.0265851188,
-0.0485657305,
-0.0114206644,
-0.0085954247,
-0.0427271985,
-0.0593441091,
0.0297273807,
0.028169753,
-0.0260883123,
0.0131881936,
0.0245657805,
0.0289092232,
0.0086857136,
-0.0144330189,
0.0981955752,
0.037969213,
-0.0174488313,
-0.0484979488,
-0.0871606618,
0.0148376171,
-0.034080565,
-0.014646654,
-0.0204923656,
0.033956591,
0.0075336788,
-0.0203479845,
-0.0003401514,
-0.0001589987,
0.053341303,
0.0187996011,
0.0617254563,
0.0145744998,
0.0102741448,
0.0086417245,
0.0207699332,
-0.0961586833,
-0.0012497156,
0.02666438,
0.1365714818,
0.0432505347,
0.0315889902,
0.0443945006,
0.0277611259,
-0.0349738039,
-0.021358382,
0.0444165058,
0.0090566874,
-0.0168016441,
0.0314394608,
-0.0006544783,
0.0238179918,
-0.0211217161,
0.0329236649,
0.0808164924,
0.1261673719,
-0.0205038544,
-0.0301297624,
0.0509027205,
0.0251093693,
-0.0212214142,
0.0039618402,
-0.0465129577,
-0.0011531295,
-0.0103650279,
-0.0196464229,
-0.0108272852,
-0.011887731,
-0.0072029447,
-0.0380868427,
-0.0143365739,
-0.0235969126,
0.0068525439,
-0.0260976143,
0.033964958,
0.007195388,
-0.0342247672,
-0.034364868,
-0.0014101043,
-0.0221090037,
-0.0255581606,
-0.0947617218,
0.0182759073,
0.0915750414,
0.0413056053,
-0.021472279,
-0.0245463792,
-0.0087578781,
0.0193747412,
-0.0171072986,
0.0133903408,
-0.0341921113,
0.0149231795,
-0.0091704093,
-0.0490536168,
-0.0074174325,
0.0000789295,
0.0156888403,
0.0210959353,
-0.0246849693,
0.0251716543,
-0.0650111958,
-0.0345045291,
0.0380951203,
0.0157688297,
-0.0370910391,
0.0191141553,
0.0413381644,
0.022342721,
0.0016444082,
0.0293506533,
-0.0083888257,
0.0052821357,
-0.0077718017,
0.0035842848,
0.0594056919,
0.0176953487,
0.0008629054,
0.0260072444,
-0.028536085,
-0.0140394671,
0.0564150475,
-0.0032390775,
-0.025769202,
0.0070457994,
-0.0146882748,
0.0192139689,
0.0150085883,
0.0343903974,
0.0139535628,
-0.0391244963,
-0.0024989473,
0.0345447734,
0.0253978949,
-0.0120344628,
0.049763009,
-0.0429345332,
0.0380646698,
-0.0219661258,
0.0138834277,
-0.0367083773,
-0.02059469,
0.0083389096,
0.0216906238,
-0.0046697431,
-0.0434441902,
0.0027526938,
-0.0869961679,
0.0047629261,
-0.0306952298,
0.0069175675,
0.0548194647,
0.0183218326,
-0.0103718704,
-0.0426026098,
0.0161192045,
0.0060708029,
-0.017937202,
-0.0212971084,
0.0481750928,
0.0149033759,
-0.0087320162,
-0.0396056399,
0.0382544026,
-0.0527064912,
-0.0116848145,
0.0349520557,
-0.0054650707,
-0.0763089731,
0.0148597667,
0.0141893812,
0.0203056931,
-0.0351304449,
-0.0196665209,
0.0207495485,
-0.001308976,
0.0121016083,
0.0865129381,
0.0017690787,
0.0341463834,
0.0353381708,
0.0027939752,
-0.0165900756,
-0.0074741184,
0.0063835219,
-0.010220442,
-0.025178574,
-0.052774258,
0.0939296186,
0.0491043627,
0.0207066387,
0.0279921982,
-0.0681828186,
0.0019579071,
-0.0275459643,
-0.0290364306,
-0.0281975865,
0.0381521918,
-0.0449307337,
0.0419519767,
-0.0217782725,
-0.0570058823,
0.0654704422,
-0.029779315,
0.0127605284,
0.0128651913,
-0.0249919724,
0.023546882,
0.0671749189,
0.0056466698,
0.0216334071,
0.044275634,
-0.01416176,
-0.0366717614,
0.0467673652,
0.029565623,
-0.0171816498,
0.020630857,
-0.0855172426,
-0.0056584734,
0.0160635263,
-0.0531387143,
-0.029576648,
-0.0344747938,
0.0043566171,
-0.0319214016,
-0.0342822894,
-0.0296816509,
-0.0664937645,
0.0233622789,
0.0130123151,
0.0502323434,
-0.0051333355,
-0.0592040196,
-0.0282510985,
-0.0179605391,
0.0845974162,
-0.0004057606,
-0.0650909916,
-0.0197781287,
0.0240734536,
0.0172761604,
0.0446487665,
0.0028946288,
-0.0193850845,
-0.0399503633,
0.0074283546,
-0.0457152128,
-0.0156185608,
0.0836901292,
0.0345757566,
-0.0088934032,
-0.014362881,
0.093227081,
0.0345571935,
-0.0259721223,
0.0166844837,
-0.0187925845,
-0.0029644063,
0.027460862,
-0.0002120555,
-0.0279433243,
-0.0698047355,
0.0170639865,
0.0498448089,
0.0059037772,
-0.0152383838,
0.005179917,
-0.0415803045,
0.006886831,
-0.021074824,
0.0130184554,
0.0251727831,
-0.0393466726,
0.0305287112,
-0.0315200314,
-0.0142577002,
-0.0073078689,
-0.0246557128,
-0.0035477085,
-0.0118689341,
-0.0569526516,
-0.0363290384,
0.0385375023,
-0.0415855125,
-0.0125220977,
0.0803857297,
0.0432823338,
0.0312649757,
-0.0221217629,
-0.0317960158,
0.0275176577,
0.0246789772,
0.013650219,
0.065005593,
-0.0281124488,
0.0213848948,
-0.0119323377,
0.0422325879,
-0.1030265614,
-0.0103120133,
0.0561836399,
0.0563888811,
-0.0367557444,
0.001389623,
-0.0322589464,
-0.0455553867,
0.0149978325,
0.075395681,
0.0004400692,
-0.0173058752,
-0.0688393638,
-0.0243003275,
-0.0114459693,
-0.0360067151,
-0.0228855629,
-0.0110042263,
-0.0282770824,
-0.0147850951,
-0.0803614855,
-0.1111396477,
0.0236864556,
0.0468303598,
0.0152761331,
0.016951371,
0.0112069882,
0.0312249586,
-0.0461991392,
0.0184773505,
-0.0081729731,
0.0449142344,
-0.0140912421,
-0.0113864783,
0.0059406143,
-0.0282055866,
-0.0013947267,
0.0538445525,
-0.0433029607,
-0.0105319014,
-0.0533227213,
0.0472027995,
0.0271134116,
0.024435848,
-0.0295892451,
0.0348845758,
-0.0152442688,
-0.020985648,
-0.0021395262,
-0.025695987,
0.0192841012,
0.0282219853,
-0.0383351259,
0.007784517,
-0.0702732056,
-0.0061397678,
-0.0275103338,
0.0101121692,
-0.0395416021,
-0.0158344712,
0.0663148239,
0.0198391229,
0.0328068398,
-0.0153790237,
0.004908558,
0.0123461308,
0.0040666326,
0.0194152594,
-0.015227858,
-0.0338550359,
0.0035668255,
0.0121638319,
0.026132416,
0.0178400632,
0.018988844,
-0.0426277556,
-0.0354610346,
-0.0731848255,
-0.0413952656,
-0.0258472338,
0.0756580532,
-0.0097374674,
-0.0135598173,
-0.0191193447,
-0.0046474729,
0.0276696645,
0.0655002967,
-0.0064456221,
0.0682866871,
0.0335422046,
0.0027480624,
-0.0244483929,
0.0823416561,
-0.0829967558,
-0.0135561023,
0.0116466573,
-0.0080606528,
0.019930115,
-0.0206958205,
0.0320768245,
-0.0356876552,
0.0248696022,
-0.0281770844,
0.024021579,
0.0043542301,
-0.0087729972,
-0.0214488991,
0.0077488227,
0.0145055987,
-0.0467578955,
0.0637187213,
-0.0050279037,
0.0404484384,
-0.0089425296,
-0.0649467409,
-0.0687646791,
-0.0299131535,
0.0338417999,
0.0229716189,
-0.0141146025,
-0.0536667593,
-0.0402275287,
-0.0403512679,
0.0029623231,
0.0091601014,
0.037617702,
-0.0619460344,
0.046274446,
0.066183731,
-0.0087938104,
-0.0600057878,
-0.0324006602,
-0.0665814131,
-0.0451006778,
0.0506302305,
-0.0962529257,
-5.067137009e-33,
-0.0089926906,
-0.0192816909,
0.0205970723,
0.0199463759,
0.004327666,
-0.0504347794,
-0.0345319621,
-0.0146514904,
0.0226589274,
-0.0117730889,
-0.0113921929,
0.002770103,
0.0230719857,
-0.0244372301,
0.0151683567,
0.0190478787,
0.049831979,
-0.005856182,
-0.0662019551,
0.0321700275,
0.0136533799,
0.0018405032,
-0.0066105691,
-0.0620997176,
0.0096093481,
-0.0276054181,
0.0163553618,
-0.0180282239,
0.0104599977,
0.0185864717,
-0.0140816988,
0.0226927288,
0.0391860195,
0.0150323547,
-0.0072316402,
0.0184273478,
-0.0071730819,
-0.048003491,
0.0136133544,
0.0267124362,
-0.04002757,
-0.0155852791,
0.0247835014,
-0.0049238121,
-0.0436967276,
0.0269662924,
0.0700894147,
-0.015855724,
0.0154238781,
0.0143579971,
-0.084957622,
-0.0217424203,
0.0410022661,
-0.0562154129,
0.0248129666,
0.0590808168,
-0.0267710816,
-0.0155428657,
-0.0382037461,
-0.0082379868,
-0.0222368166,
0.034490604,
0.0785787776,
0.0553027578,
0.0362708084,
0.0524265617,
0.0141603742,
0.0103099598,
-0.0339129344,
0.0209033974,
-0.0107197091,
0.0602563918,
0.0034183864,
0.010230287,
0.0214009676,
-0.0077362275,
-0.0094041461,
0.0876744092,
0.0216245539,
0.0201937128,
0.0123082111,
0.0262873992,
-0.0543651059,
0.0232945904,
0.0147545943,
-0.0050229318,
-0.020243356,
-0.0389174633,
0.0778073743,
0.0354451835,
0.0024767404,
-0.0714282095,
-0.0100226933,
-0.0321075246,
0.0157405268,
-0.0413405336,
-0.0416927077,
0.0143658929,
-0.0121464496,
-0.0194268245,
-0.0128216399,
-0.0231951103,
0.0150509942,
0.0542099886,
0.0795528218,
0.0048761293,
-0.0235432386,
0.0038024897,
-0.0161222182,
-0.0186392237,
-0.0391439945,
-0.0248451475,
-0.0280440357,
-0.0213337913,
0.0622387715,
0.0000025049,
-0.0185457952,
0.0373051986,
-0.0230209958,
-0.0627138987,
-0.0281903129,
-0.0128481723,
0.0096433423,
-0.0357731059,
-0.0373438671,
-0.0420055091,
-0.0613367073,
0.0384733006,
0.0094672469,
-0.035884589,
-0.0083926823,
0.0051568965,
2.735e-7,
-0.03601918,
-0.0077888849,
0.0046589063,
0.033935599,
-0.0343717933,
0.0562802367,
-0.0211140495,
0.0196486432,
0.0072735981,
-0.0446902625,
0.0312469434,
0.0012784903,
0.0371263549,
-0.0040650833,
-0.0442181826,
0.006017894,
0.0193609446,
0.0115252184,
-0.0437692031,
0.0431437194,
0.0977306366,
0.0402776971,
0.0070796134,
0.0109311854,
0.0542557389,
-0.0420073494,
0.0087098582,
-0.0394452326,
0.0461308211,
0.0182552114,
0.0202699844,
-0.0064138006,
-0.0257183593,
0.0174115524,
-0.0150464494,
-0.0155025404,
-0.0026942715,
0.0448285975,
-0.0402087495,
0.0150756128,
-0.0528256297,
-0.0229346752,
0.057849545,
-0.0281502455,
0.0400307253,
-0.0554223843,
-0.0249882452,
0.0083126752,
0.0099452613,
0.0059713922,
-0.0463886261,
0.0075625526,
0.0045664092,
-0.0028356775,
0.0095042959,
0.0422796644,
-0.0324706994,
-0.0824161097,
0.0277954992,
0.0110127386,
-0.0333653018,
-0.0315125361,
-0.0825288892,
0.0341975614,
0.0121894088,
-0.0617399961,
0.0000964036,
2.065849129e-34,
-0.0214280579,
0.0197844058,
0.0006684355,
0.0060929949,
0.0395959467,
0.0216800421,
-0.0052460693,
0.0274790656,
0.037425112,
-0.0234088916,
-0.0212695058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14313v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14313v1 | Robust Few-shot Transfer Learning for Knowledge Base Question Answering with Unanswerable Questions | 2024-06-20T13:43:38 | 2024-06-20T13:43:38 | Riya Sawhney, Indrajit Bhattacharya, Mausam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Real-world KBQA applications require models that are (1) robust -- e.g., can
differentiate between answerable and unanswerable questions, and (2)
low-resource -- do not require large training data. Towards this goal, we
propose the novel task of few-shot transfer for KBQA with unanswerable
questions. We present FUn-FuSIC that extends the state-of-the-art (SoTA)
few-shot transfer model for answerable-only KBQA to handle unanswerability. It
iteratively prompts an LLM to generate logical forms for the question by
providing feedback using a diverse suite of syntactic, semantic and execution
guided checks, and adapts self-consistency to assess confidence of the LLM to
decide answerability. Experiments over newly constructed datasets show that
FUn-FuSIC outperforms suitable adaptations of the SoTA model for KBQA with
unanswerability, and the SoTA model for answerable-only few-shot-transfer KBQA. | [
0.0262548421,
0.0380953662,
-0.0018813942,
0.000081827,
-0.0353849269,
0.0205656309,
0.0122373886,
-0.0031902341,
0.0125865974,
-0.0351654142,
-0.0008160892,
-0.0042771962,
-0.0755294859,
0.0036434222,
0.0091116019,
-0.0020943368,
0.0596625581,
-0.0100494754,
-0.0013024773,
-0.0269095916,
-0.0267923977,
0.0135544995,
-0.0352059714,
-0.0192714185,
0.0188135915,
-0.0335706249,
-0.0215812828,
0.0185592398,
0.0008856996,
0.0138435578,
0.0080247568,
0.0525292233,
-0.018974619,
0.0063651754,
0.0000020581,
-0.0641795024,
-0.023545498,
0.015326282,
-0.075349912,
-0.0279553067,
-0.0030011036,
0.0164385699,
0.0163458865,
0.0150158731,
-0.0298534278,
0.0224985983,
0.0415631123,
0.0428351611,
0.0654041767,
0.0341004319,
0.0091259973,
-0.0180606302,
0.0215291288,
0.0112455301,
0.066962257,
-0.07192716,
0.0434154272,
0.0285874195,
0.0224529915,
0.0111532481,
-0.0120233987,
0.0359379537,
0.0228483137,
-0.0031839167,
0.0073747691,
0.0040277182,
-0.0517577976,
0.0269659385,
0.0004007969,
0.1140847951,
0.0070506958,
-0.0149159329,
0.0086089363,
-0.0142253935,
0.0232357308,
0.02380272,
-0.0377518795,
-0.0083003147,
0.0062473146,
-0.04083848,
-0.0392914452,
0.0147335362,
0.0027970353,
-0.010415962,
-0.0330958478,
0.0936438069,
0.0363251008,
-0.0437143743,
0.0324278101,
0.0219067279,
-0.0304970443,
-0.0615882464,
-0.0232819133,
0.0942847729,
-0.0117463507,
0.036235638,
-0.0255964305,
0.0157854985,
0.0341321677,
-0.0129364925,
0.0427237414,
0.0352861471,
-0.0340594947,
0.0920815915,
-0.0764763281,
0.0235471707,
0.001878441,
0.0214105472,
-0.0205421504,
-0.0361022241,
-0.075261265,
-0.0339868292,
-0.0309723206,
0.0722172782,
0.00556025,
0.0023874613,
-0.0198792331,
0.0335254967,
-0.0018100425,
0.0134043787,
0.0184708145,
0.0216572918,
-0.0144258551,
-0.0282635838,
-0.0669578314,
0.0793515444,
-0.0600889511,
0.0329335518,
0.0185372848,
-0.0408204049,
-0.0285485517,
0.0138135375,
0.0393377431,
-0.037668623,
0.0214326102,
0.0551479235,
-0.0205726568,
0.0036825966,
-0.0583273247,
-0.0198024865,
-0.0218200032,
-0.0489665121,
-0.0001595084,
-0.0486095771,
0.0299138241,
-0.0240160786,
-0.0410675146,
-0.0276561156,
0.0019918084,
0.0446558669,
-0.0081885066,
0.0753125623,
-0.014559499,
0.0051123002,
0.0205694884,
-0.0248128287,
-0.0637963563,
0.0670258775,
0.007511673,
-0.0004584487,
0.0342842378,
-0.0189688075,
0.0255062804,
-0.0376043208,
0.0529160313,
0.0133026596,
0.0070161568,
0.0484381989,
-0.019097982,
0.0037209608,
-0.019387288,
0.0088583678,
-0.0089632971,
-0.0243779384,
0.0076867752,
0.0180714466,
0.0211065821,
-0.0051907189,
0.0388527177,
0.0133148469,
0.0113784904,
0.0125183407,
-0.0475340374,
0.0893865898,
-0.0765522718,
-0.0020896348,
-0.0021334179,
0.0056462158,
-0.0528216213,
-0.0060296957,
0.0484231114,
0.0420541279,
-0.0249922052,
0.0024240345,
0.050006099,
0.045789171,
-0.0523161255,
0.0585533455,
-0.013033649,
-0.0147443451,
0.0135637932,
-0.0106160063,
0.0817930326,
0.0199897289,
0.0248703398,
-0.0202800892,
-0.06454698,
-0.0204508808,
0.0421428494,
0.0103785302,
0.0006228207,
0.0005368125,
0.0396048166,
-0.0303889103,
0.0016297601,
-0.0130493259,
0.0222444925,
-0.0210564565,
0.0109522697,
0.0578123778,
0.0105306478,
-0.0692287609,
0.0571349487,
0.0253796391,
-0.032069087,
-0.0390402712,
0.0456253104,
-0.0086725047,
0.0301967412,
0.0142565919,
0.0097439094,
0.0057860166,
0.0051512648,
-0.0087232124,
-0.0586638451,
-0.0276250541,
0.0006781863,
-0.067546472,
0.0135608241,
0.0160218421,
-0.0157717932,
0.0211809445,
-0.0657079369,
-0.0569565669,
0.0029555501,
0.006965891,
-0.0241463948,
-0.0478081964,
-0.0212047026,
0.0388092324,
-0.0038382784,
-0.0448023789,
0.0591760054,
0.0231288001,
0.0062559401,
-0.0501222163,
-0.0245298371,
0.0054137264,
-0.0371096507,
-0.0032044728,
-0.0136055825,
-0.0423602499,
-0.0101289079,
-0.0114935031,
0.0114693111,
-0.050384447,
-0.0153662646,
-0.0366604999,
0.0508288182,
-0.0006615418,
0.0435014963,
0.021897804,
-0.0050179674,
0.0021952044,
-0.0107255736,
-0.0699924976,
0.05092692,
0.0175549537,
0.0073385243,
0.0526918992,
0.0136505133,
0.02835075,
-0.0112888934,
-0.010409479,
0.0048307874,
0.0257255789,
-0.0316234641,
0.0116846832,
-0.0144616151,
0.0215535518,
-0.0438068658,
-0.0016124042,
0.0386950672,
0.0002916256,
-0.0006355592,
-0.0352447741,
-0.056922026,
0.0371408314,
-0.022551382,
-0.0611850582,
0.0189531296,
-0.0290187653,
-0.0479340777,
0.0599149242,
-0.0078295739,
-0.0524591021,
0.016932318,
-0.0099768303,
0.0022422906,
0.0487642549,
-0.0257839896,
-0.0315673724,
-0.0762203708,
0.0577676557,
0.0349110067,
0.0160064064,
-0.0537788495,
0.0532472357,
0.0220447257,
0.0248417184,
-0.0045999391,
0.0488544926,
0.0650422797,
0.02249665,
-0.0163802896,
-0.0097552966,
0.0232190583,
-0.0401762053,
0.0284122843,
-0.0413825624,
-0.0169769861,
0.0083736265,
0.0030522065,
-0.0707203075,
-0.0395818911,
0.0083176661,
-0.0071437238,
0.0005622637,
-0.021023985,
0.026751224,
-0.0248037241,
0.0055602379,
-0.04265045,
-0.0262406953,
-0.0258498546,
0.008993539,
-0.0506778024,
0.0236534644,
-0.0184316281,
-0.0237163622,
0.0079856245,
0.0147687793,
0.0107083926,
-0.0173254833,
-0.0292722657,
0.0488837548,
0.0775728151,
0.0704476014,
0.0305698514,
0.0095538646,
0.0301671587,
0.0394334346,
-0.0146695403,
0.0374688655,
0.0259191878,
0.0162607841,
0.0307257678,
-0.0220583845,
0.014231788,
0.0237752236,
0.0792600065,
-0.0272437949,
-0.029255664,
0.0833343565,
0.0250352845,
0.0491699949,
0.003252368,
-0.0672419742,
-0.0130572859,
0.0031867696,
0.0714154467,
-0.0877936184,
-0.0689520389,
-0.0186914597,
0.0377584845,
-0.0050418717,
-0.0661640763,
-0.011031175,
-0.1370452195,
0.0291127264,
-0.0225796681,
-0.0366467945,
-0.0184365865,
-0.0137485508,
0.0206645913,
-0.0131065799,
-0.0026518444,
0.0345550142,
-0.0086109126,
0.0185847413,
0.0057511185,
-0.0098130442,
-0.0317235999,
0.0664792284,
-0.0213166922,
0.0573840737,
0.0514919534,
0.0041269991,
-0.0235453118,
0.0015603144,
-0.036351908,
-0.0411986858,
-0.0260809213,
-0.0060632844,
0.0348880291,
0.0041723819,
-0.0407896452,
-0.019821059,
0.0326861031,
-0.0344808772,
-0.0117349299,
0.0717117265,
0.0830674991,
-0.0087497467,
-0.0634849668,
-0.003433581,
0.0095505398,
-0.010884068,
0.0885317996,
0.0139260562,
-0.0222766269,
-0.0463822074,
0.0116954139,
-0.0308584552,
-0.08027035,
-0.0333298668,
0.0240321252,
0.0017964804,
0.0371306762,
-0.1012971252,
-0.0357851088,
0.0359904729,
0.0389223173,
-0.0296459403,
-0.0000482977,
0.0144955646,
0.0134524526,
-0.0114591336,
-0.0405254439,
-0.0459997989,
-0.005843203,
-0.0385620482,
0.0361258723,
0.0026128714,
-0.0201583523,
-0.0055674822,
-0.0572339892,
-0.0230148789,
-0.0074798362,
-0.0188622493,
0.0625760183,
0.0129943872,
-0.0295138713,
-0.0516147129,
-0.0191958267,
0.0592606738,
0.0492646731,
-0.007889078,
0.0247980412,
0.0420381352,
-0.0109545812,
-0.0047114226,
0.0566676408,
-0.064760156,
0.0039332667,
0.0060895598,
0.0766558573,
-0.0563073941,
-0.005034144,
0.0270311628,
0.0144657185,
-0.0278419722,
0.0635466874,
-0.0196573362,
0.0042127133,
0.0670501441,
-0.0041340832,
0.0008083627,
-0.0704551041,
-0.0349171124,
0.0198482014,
-0.0579163097,
0.0134990746,
-0.0457867086,
-0.0386225991,
0.0674661025,
0.0063446742,
-0.0360084139,
0.0272512063,
0.0250132363,
-0.0027307586,
-0.0233607255,
-0.029796958,
-0.0077447887,
0.0119246244,
0.0475667007,
0.0099694487,
0.0431908928,
0.0213518515,
0.0089790858,
-0.0324501581,
-0.0230143778,
-0.0532022081,
-0.0271526389,
-0.0333818421,
0.0360404551,
0.0264428854,
0.0448093116,
0.0079351021,
0.0106581477,
-0.0235375799,
-0.0190456621,
-0.0059587732,
0.005452171,
0.0219353363,
0.0501302145,
0.040663898,
0.029496599,
0.0056024333,
0.0387930386,
0.0089086704,
0.0479615666,
-0.0108472947,
0.03271164,
-0.0369095877,
-0.0285665151,
0.0017448941,
0.0061521488,
0.0106314356,
0.0374112092,
-0.0536062792,
-0.0561096407,
0.0413662903,
-0.0336387195,
-0.0398208387,
-0.0150703397,
-0.0015585542,
0.0407028235,
0.0371918641,
-0.0568264127,
-0.0408265367,
0.0181154031,
-0.0366750509,
-0.0140679264,
0.0065910527,
-6.96627707e-33,
-0.033592198,
-0.0310396776,
0.0684317499,
-0.0794793814,
0.0191273168,
-0.0312868953,
-0.0399888977,
-0.0214629937,
-0.0542461015,
0.0202167947,
-0.0232511517,
-0.0018980805,
-0.0046693129,
0.042460531,
0.0248132348,
-0.0432350859,
0.0009835428,
0.0268643405,
-0.0165557768,
0.0076981215,
0.0273950975,
0.0446256958,
0.0089244656,
-0.0005773499,
-0.0010063893,
0.0061793663,
-0.0117009664,
0.0436926559,
-0.0392227694,
0.0401348136,
-0.0152824558,
0.0163028222,
0.0159316752,
-0.0242339503,
0.0180501807,
-0.0081427488,
-0.0705605596,
-0.0964541659,
0.0210802536,
-0.0141974045,
-0.0257569589,
-0.0340847746,
0.0104081854,
-0.040378768,
0.0682948828,
-0.0309486818,
-0.0071232161,
-0.027210895,
0.0002901393,
-0.0290235654,
-0.0161050167,
0.0100083565,
0.0088386778,
-0.0311583783,
-0.0380037129,
0.0664933696,
-0.0060645519,
-0.0098032262,
-0.0290953405,
-0.0335334241,
0.0278753582,
0.0137859173,
0.0610232726,
-0.0236153156,
-0.0301183034,
0.0226171426,
0.0090097124,
-0.0347852744,
-0.0312030148,
-0.0071439296,
-0.0168712828,
0.0592653677,
0.0675233155,
0.0841759965,
0.0385648385,
0.0165180974,
-0.0691533536,
0.0282031391,
-0.0174159557,
0.0464172252,
0.0030456164,
-0.0199022181,
-0.024813652,
-0.0261311084,
-0.0270495955,
0.0523932949,
-0.0579693988,
-0.0233183131,
0.0422175527,
-0.0305443723,
-0.0534149893,
0.0076252683,
0.0562884696,
-0.0430118181,
0.0156779587,
0.0114037208,
-0.0032789388,
0.0166123472,
0.0170459133,
0.0431035496,
-0.0550083295,
0.0106359404,
0.0463270433,
-0.0325343944,
-0.021300761,
0.0319671072,
0.0066182301,
0.0165457074,
-0.0557278059,
-0.0286076479,
-0.0133749945,
0.0355536416,
-0.0124808932,
-0.0093756085,
-0.0092579992,
0.0399310179,
-0.010822217,
0.0211934354,
-0.0108655663,
-0.0150045818,
0.0294599738,
0.0124400007,
-0.0080562914,
0.020008808,
-0.0364582501,
-0.0017956055,
-0.0139453411,
0.0053208112,
-0.0754190087,
-0.0432561897,
-0.0008614918,
0.0182503797,
2.838e-7,
0.0502533019,
0.0055004978,
-0.012368951,
0.0129059078,
-0.0085912673,
0.0279785525,
-0.0151080023,
0.0364192724,
0.0045290506,
-0.0590832904,
0.0251864418,
0.0378802083,
0.0151790185,
0.0363643505,
-0.068188183,
-0.0106695611,
-0.0010137939,
-0.0166795962,
-0.0266182348,
-0.0374141671,
0.1152554527,
0.0507038906,
0.0226372276,
-0.0126108117,
0.0261151846,
-0.0424524099,
0.0409465395,
0.0251425616,
0.0189448632,
0.0030057228,
0.0284723025,
-0.0111365644,
0.0130215529,
0.0621952005,
-0.0058602486,
0.0123668294,
-0.0036155086,
0.086679846,
-0.0004269179,
-0.0676604062,
-0.0503173321,
-0.0208345503,
0.0499105752,
-0.0165248532,
0.1271369308,
-0.0880310237,
-0.0215322971,
0.0291364528,
-0.0594360158,
-0.0187965967,
-0.0002206387,
0.0221094601,
-0.0186470263,
-0.0290569346,
0.0239668451,
0.0211910158,
-0.0210465807,
-0.0428441986,
0.0238083247,
0.0142131392,
-0.0033422385,
-0.0287681688,
-0.0354016125,
-0.0068587381,
0.0028707513,
-0.0742474198,
0.0133193312,
2.360412401e-34,
0.0069318088,
0.0004767361,
0.0242693294,
0.0194398854,
0.0025932672,
0.0132599045,
-0.0339669101,
-0.0034703875,
0.061007414,
-0.0691709742,
0.0162463281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14312v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14312v1 | Infusing clinical knowledge into tokenisers for language models | 2024-06-20T13:43:03 | 2024-06-20T13:43:03 | Abul Hasan, Jinge Wu, Quang Ngoc Nguyen, Salomé Andres, Imane Guellil, Huayu Zhang, Arlene Casey, Beatrice Alex, Bruce Guthrie, Honghan Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study introduces a novel knowledge enhanced tokenisation mechanism,
K-Tokeniser, for clinical text processing. Technically, at initialisation
stage, K-Tokeniser populates global representations of tokens based on semantic
types of domain concepts (such as drugs or diseases) from either a domain
ontology like Unified Medical Language System or the training data of the task
related corpus. At training or inference stage, sentence level localised
context will be utilised for choosing the optimal global token representation
to realise the semantic-based tokenisation. To avoid pretraining using the new
tokeniser, an embedding initialisation approach is proposed to generate
representations for new tokens. Using three transformer-based language models,
a comprehensive set of experiments are conducted on four real-world datasets
for evaluating K-Tokeniser in a wide range of clinical text analytics tasks
including clinical concept and relation extraction, automated clinical coding,
clinical phenotype identification, and clinical research article
classification. Overall, our models demonstrate consistent improvements over
their counterparts in all tasks. In particular, substantial improvements are
observed in the automated clinical coding task with 13\% increase on Micro
$F_1$ score. Furthermore, K-Tokeniser also shows significant capacities in
facilitating quicker converge of language models. Specifically, using
K-Tokeniser, the language models would only require 50\% of the training data
to achieve the best performance of the baseline tokeniser using all training
data in the concept extraction task and less than 20\% of the data for the
automated coding task. It is worth mentioning that all these improvements
require no pre-training process, making the approach generalisable. | [
0.0506381057,
0.0136520648,
0.0117870513,
-0.0163695645,
-0.0391879231,
0.0294048581,
0.0079820789,
0.0433828309,
-0.0135234725,
-0.0621945448,
0.0098872446,
-0.0177539345,
-0.0095442934,
0.0720063224,
0.0299759284,
-0.0347572528,
0.0394522063,
0.0211002175,
0.0382627845,
0.0163902994,
-0.0113673871,
0.0006729587,
-0.004412442,
0.0681504905,
-0.0321041197,
-0.0071438099,
0.0389336236,
-0.043502342,
0.0015077901,
-0.058746215,
-0.0324293487,
0.0291353893,
-0.0251609962,
-0.013369563,
0.0000019118,
-0.0501848012,
-0.0481508598,
0.0292228218,
-0.0151799722,
-0.0818364695,
0.0919374228,
-0.0948537439,
0.0120479818,
0.0161474757,
-0.0355401449,
-0.0517909862,
0.0167065244,
0.0739431828,
0.0253938772,
0.0470738113,
-0.0214278791,
-0.0106485793,
0.0495940484,
0.0274864733,
-0.0256432202,
-0.0168906711,
0.0581760183,
0.0055888128,
0.0246146116,
-0.0010678907,
-0.0118160341,
0.0370803103,
-0.0238767676,
0.0035209882,
0.0590088814,
0.0276699178,
-0.0733776763,
-0.0205840021,
0.0066141193,
0.0158253182,
-0.0307183675,
-0.0517885797,
0.0293489564,
0.0083278781,
0.0002924185,
-0.0024460671,
-0.0227249768,
-0.0070054354,
-0.0329609998,
0.0071522864,
0.0457633734,
-0.0025656158,
0.0205600709,
-0.0214092005,
-0.0510273315,
0.0242616348,
0.0050124405,
-0.0205640718,
-0.0012019499,
-0.0140864225,
-0.0463185683,
-0.0529846512,
0.0378710218,
0.0222172234,
-0.0286423136,
0.0149682229,
-0.0260921605,
-0.0824322402,
0.0495966934,
-0.0680271015,
-0.0412802882,
0.0188610125,
0.0006543791,
0.0247688945,
-0.0540203899,
0.0301824566,
0.015638452,
0.0428578854,
-0.0548682697,
-0.0117111309,
-0.0548535474,
-0.0337231904,
-0.0611147173,
0.0570635498,
-0.0202539526,
-0.0179729536,
-0.0610519461,
0.0324499495,
0.0049099312,
-0.0155562107,
0.0045921477,
0.0284903217,
-0.010279946,
0.0278718714,
0.0145049701,
-0.0187762212,
0.0061658593,
-0.0026863143,
-0.0230572671,
-0.0525402874,
0.027002627,
0.0054778871,
0.0362661071,
0.0023982364,
0.0148825506,
0.0534473024,
0.0194514543,
-0.0245686155,
0.0082087191,
-0.0416670851,
-0.0201466288,
0.0284684822,
-0.0245752316,
-0.0680516362,
0.0474315211,
0.052547168,
-0.0042538359,
-0.0350761265,
-0.0047281403,
-0.0136774983,
-0.0532994419,
0.067143254,
-0.0599852316,
-0.0166883375,
0.0182897784,
0.0188381616,
-0.0283550434,
0.0465630926,
0.0185806081,
-0.0183378551,
0.0093942732,
-0.0164565332,
0.0050455742,
0.0005846799,
0.0112040155,
-0.0688720122,
-0.0408519097,
0.0185888056,
0.0277252011,
0.0466944091,
-0.0087991245,
0.0597620457,
-0.0224784929,
0.0350497328,
-0.0123438733,
0.0800926164,
0.0481083207,
0.0210562088,
0.0440854616,
-0.0434284918,
-0.009651171,
-0.0353093632,
-0.0016735082,
-0.0337082855,
0.0421655402,
0.0159498267,
-0.013060254,
0.001886087,
-0.0014648582,
-0.0206084289,
-0.0305934865,
-0.0196564645,
-0.0447469354,
-0.0479650535,
0.0531223081,
0.0088951411,
-0.0425618999,
0.0845242739,
0.0405005403,
-0.0259519815,
0.0018048958,
-0.0477719866,
-0.0197831579,
0.0485157594,
0.0670689866,
-0.0478316583,
-0.0215035602,
-0.0393771194,
-0.0026335164,
-0.0130203245,
-0.0123971514,
-0.0325187892,
-0.0084020384,
-0.0270650405,
0.012750471,
0.0365731753,
0.0193868894,
-0.0319439955,
-0.0094667869,
0.0572894439,
-0.0068530128,
-0.0659435168,
0.0184034221,
0.0552320965,
-0.02938338,
0.0038820966,
0.003571613,
-0.0099760527,
0.0259909946,
0.0261914153,
-0.0021835139,
0.0342715606,
0.0374219716,
-0.0602279082,
-0.0264605563,
0.0168120097,
-0.0326469392,
-0.0676558688,
0.0071394979,
-0.0094263572,
0.0343601815,
-0.0379302204,
-0.0140287308,
-0.0058290367,
-0.0253145006,
-0.000746502,
0.1129327118,
-0.0088588176,
0.0351833031,
-0.0135839796,
-0.0188802443,
-0.032867495,
0.02878814,
-0.0141966632,
0.0197343919,
-0.0176238995,
-0.0507429503,
0.0035616413,
0.0183922816,
-0.023665525,
-0.0106961811,
-0.031073926,
-0.0018480639,
-0.0133188209,
-0.035163641,
0.0051699718,
-0.0394078419,
-0.1336025149,
-0.0282289814,
0.0169722922,
0.0065333159,
0.0343979523,
0.0484178476,
0.0084549161,
-0.0128201908,
-0.0257216506,
-0.0409641005,
0.0084542343,
0.0193420332,
0.0225706771,
0.0215849262,
0.0017587168,
0.0036305825,
0.0205356106,
-0.0503281318,
0.0572894141,
0.0010375162,
-0.0245364886,
-0.0116897942,
-0.0023890743,
-0.0205822606,
-0.0003499571,
-0.0056652105,
-0.0212945584,
0.0146996723,
-0.0050820047,
0.030545529,
0.0363193192,
0.0075849616,
0.0365515128,
0.0310458057,
0.0172925051,
-0.0092844702,
-0.0125307227,
-0.0265069045,
0.0132713448,
-0.014998626,
-0.0296072531,
0.0393869281,
0.096711427,
0.0327509008,
-0.013240247,
-0.0371569358,
-0.022855619,
-0.0354729779,
0.0230124779,
-0.0487895273,
0.0021121574,
-0.0502613373,
0.017802475,
0.009814919,
-0.0126439128,
0.0875085741,
-0.0263801999,
0.0390115045,
-0.0843719468,
-0.0043380661,
-0.0315808728,
-0.0290970001,
0.0073799593,
0.0231944676,
-0.0031882834,
-0.0155489696,
0.0370506905,
0.0246951114,
-0.0176770687,
-0.0519410409,
0.0627119616,
0.0170295704,
0.0111794779,
0.0132251754,
-0.0199454818,
-0.0562478974,
-0.0152345505,
-0.0349713303,
0.0253880061,
0.0598242208,
0.0353373587,
-0.0467468947,
0.0860375911,
-0.0339517668,
0.0795992762,
0.0104777338,
-0.0029418012,
-0.0063970112,
0.0071900338,
0.0208525527,
-0.0495025888,
-0.0251315683,
0.0277005639,
0.0590550378,
0.0479841642,
0.0060857432,
-0.0069712149,
-0.0117764752,
-0.0086059188,
-0.0019699321,
-0.0577226803,
-0.0188370496,
-0.0110328477,
0.0081316596,
-0.024840923,
-0.0054303827,
0.1204754263,
0.0550790317,
-0.0547043011,
0.0217482243,
-0.0261494778,
-0.0480610132,
-0.0163910165,
0.0034098194,
-0.064737834,
-0.0330936573,
0.0177205577,
0.0055494541,
-0.0182118416,
-0.0345574655,
0.0362962149,
-0.0143491374,
0.0128233517,
-0.0053452812,
-0.0908041522,
-0.0274699274,
-0.0458809882,
-0.025702551,
-0.0146513302,
0.0068614874,
0.0081496378,
-0.0039947522,
0.0168794077,
0.0070616966,
-0.0487786718,
-0.0710880384,
-0.0143483859,
-0.0237799045,
0.0358021557,
0.0118924268,
0.0106919473,
-0.005321858,
-0.0098801674,
0.0091185868,
0.0419179685,
0.0087926574,
-0.0076979129,
0.0500322953,
-0.0199383162,
0.0067075333,
-0.0365308598,
0.0099522946,
-0.0270357244,
-0.0563074574,
-0.0390011705,
0.0896514803,
-0.0242461469,
-0.0146180522,
-0.0427174419,
-0.0159524959,
-0.0026858947,
0.0490571596,
0.0066149849,
-0.0248577427,
-0.0066246605,
0.0023583123,
0.0402176306,
-0.013567674,
0.0074033462,
0.0088617532,
-0.033969637,
-0.0304874666,
-0.0653887242,
0.0179857817,
0.0708990395,
0.003532713,
0.0221072417,
0.0455438681,
-0.0098884208,
-0.0301575027,
-0.0909447744,
0.0381508432,
0.0382978097,
-0.0031376851,
-0.0731759146,
-0.0161737911,
0.0660086647,
-0.0031326378,
-0.0290379766,
0.0006064258,
0.0048794346,
-0.0104986448,
0.0185974911,
0.0154340584,
0.0075927847,
0.0111408783,
-0.0096991146,
0.0087966481,
0.0899986625,
0.0575343408,
-0.0838014334,
-0.0374950096,
-0.0296085812,
-0.0038419175,
-0.0013962765,
0.0119428635,
-0.0356785245,
0.0210056286,
0.0042378688,
0.011080116,
0.0026750208,
0.0350246839,
0.0121732783,
0.0287827253,
0.0559777133,
-0.0162992403,
-0.0143755358,
-0.006665484,
0.0123014953,
-0.0244992655,
0.0054004164,
-0.0286779609,
0.0117784739,
0.018752683,
0.0201399457,
-0.0110166417,
0.0132336887,
-0.0563864522,
-0.047659833,
0.019321233,
0.0463343859,
0.0054058977,
0.039215982,
0.082565479,
-0.0034870007,
-0.0085231597,
-0.046939142,
-0.0116909947,
-0.0064936494,
-0.0701528192,
0.0264708102,
0.0078493292,
0.041182328,
-0.0293637495,
0.0636965632,
-0.0364665724,
0.0163336117,
-0.0248055793,
0.0103642903,
0.0287051145,
-0.0181948598,
0.0014633113,
-0.0245910045,
-0.0007895574,
-0.0015006594,
0.0274461228,
-0.0128667811,
-0.0020901435,
0.033755675,
-0.0074191689,
-0.0288704094,
-0.0506237485,
0.0825869069,
0.0157314893,
0.022337297,
-0.0098359985,
-0.0532606542,
-0.0341697559,
0.0405379906,
0.0438265465,
0.0303681605,
-0.0616531931,
0.0007368466,
-0.0608205013,
-0.0485749878,
0.0524048582,
-0.0381485522,
-0.0560847111,
-0.0001580089,
0.0408857875,
0.0409880765,
0.0409618951,
-0.0325318836,
-0.0205352399,
0.0597389303,
0.0188611783,
-0.0237451605,
0.0440550782,
-5.523105023e-33,
0.0231251772,
-0.0250248685,
-0.006911464,
0.0090831174,
0.0099552516,
0.0224463455,
-0.0182458013,
-0.0275853314,
0.0229274128,
0.0339375995,
-0.0324065946,
-0.0003674975,
0.0034988944,
0.0348172188,
0.003836975,
0.0048870225,
0.0281558856,
0.0014035944,
-0.0115214512,
0.0066631977,
0.0251404438,
0.0810762122,
0.0548367053,
-0.0476321764,
-0.0017495991,
0.0077186953,
0.0675287694,
-0.0088717155,
0.0452366136,
0.0632174015,
-0.0380996354,
0.0392097756,
0.0487021804,
-0.028828904,
0.005011105,
0.0077990154,
-0.0730459094,
-0.0338359885,
0.0353979133,
0.0075693256,
-0.0092003234,
-0.0533528663,
0.060914617,
-0.0203770697,
-0.0143572977,
0.0242812354,
0.0150662148,
-0.0202492718,
-0.0369163081,
-0.0307574254,
-0.0529022552,
0.0469467007,
0.0238098446,
0.0375031792,
0.0314876847,
-0.025768796,
-0.0132807968,
0.0178580936,
-0.02836743,
-0.0069818236,
0.0037635518,
0.0285840929,
0.0130443415,
-0.009999861,
-0.0159110725,
0.0659351274,
-0.0103925643,
-0.0320540108,
-0.0248325262,
0.0480416752,
-0.0301464964,
0.0446638055,
0.0278915837,
0.0184772182,
0.0251485724,
-0.0718063191,
-0.0612179115,
0.0267407615,
-0.0553035662,
0.0312338863,
0.0392275788,
-0.0082049808,
-0.0296546873,
-0.0190503392,
-0.0244565252,
-0.0161673184,
-0.0317950659,
-0.036589928,
0.0342417806,
0.0002136816,
-0.0190442689,
-0.0034670203,
0.010950814,
-0.0264982395,
0.0086045619,
-0.0212251805,
0.0521921255,
0.0330276825,
-0.0469671302,
0.0092422422,
-0.0425271057,
-0.0452065356,
0.0359435119,
-0.0135095343,
0.0440343022,
0.013757932,
0.0414469354,
-0.0457183905,
-0.0524191335,
0.0012541834,
0.0252704173,
-0.0267055295,
-0.0052266959,
0.0317116342,
0.0343768969,
0.0576675124,
0.0109026507,
0.0115930187,
0.0177363176,
-0.0331508368,
-0.0247327946,
-0.0165675413,
0.0212709997,
0.0054982649,
-0.0488680787,
-0.0307656098,
-0.0481362827,
0.0722863823,
0.0390411839,
-0.0337923169,
-0.0084513295,
-0.0035826992,
2.687e-7,
0.1130337641,
0.0488790199,
0.0001128667,
-0.0668287352,
0.0389975496,
-0.0028426598,
0.0207632184,
0.0194963105,
0.0013524994,
0.0121101514,
0.0134888543,
-0.019888306,
-0.0021056992,
0.046513617,
-0.1331155449,
-0.0014770476,
-0.048952993,
-0.0267178975,
-0.0227640849,
0.0061332048,
0.0401529744,
0.0820032507,
-0.0395374857,
0.0002491277,
0.0039518224,
-0.0444225781,
0.0096600652,
-0.0080200927,
0.0212422255,
0.0562090911,
-0.0224903896,
0.0273322538,
0.0322369859,
0.0704807043,
-0.0276331902,
0.0093432618,
0.0062504746,
0.0760051757,
-0.0709332302,
0.0338102952,
0.0257670712,
-0.0261273328,
0.0333726853,
-0.0759210736,
0.0644630343,
-0.0442088135,
-0.0273817796,
-0.0448091477,
0.0016506157,
-0.0023855683,
0.0160108041,
-0.0068466198,
-0.0308895111,
0.0698399544,
0.0418782867,
0.0428785086,
-0.0409974866,
-0.0897415057,
-0.010228334,
0.0239521731,
-0.0157594904,
-0.0225890167,
0.0249098577,
-0.0081760315,
0.0539957546,
-0.0427883379,
0.0358327366,
2.631125306e-34,
0.0323569365,
0.0200289749,
0.0041533327,
0.0601000078,
0.0231702849,
-0.0525521152,
0.0128589226,
0.0258795619,
0.0041019982,
-0.0745900348,
0.0125474064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14307v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14307v2 | QuST-LLM: Integrating Large Language Models for Comprehensive Spatial Transcriptomics Analysis | 2024-06-20T13:37:10 | 2024-07-01T19:38:03 | Chao Hui Huang | q-bio.GN | q-bio.GN, cs.CL, cs.CV | In this paper, we introduce QuST-LLM, an innovative extension of QuPath that
utilizes the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) to analyze and
interpret spatial transcriptomics (ST) data. In addition to simplifying the
intricate and high-dimensional nature of ST data by offering a comprehensive
workflow that includes data loading, region selection, gene expression
analysis, and functional annotation, QuST-LLM employs LLMs to transform complex
ST data into understandable and detailed biological narratives based on gene
ontology annotations, thereby significantly improving the interpretability of
ST data. Consequently, users can interact with their own ST data using natural
language. Hence, QuST-LLM provides researchers with a potent functionality to
unravel the spatial and functional complexities of tissues, fostering novel
insights and advancements in biomedical research. QuST-LLM is a part of QuST
project. The source code is hosted on GitHub and documentation is available at
(https://github.com/huangch/qust). | [
-0.0163676776,
0.0797948316,
-0.0355074704,
-0.0025510809,
-0.0176281016,
0.0259310398,
0.0518137068,
-0.0048672576,
0.0552581586,
-0.0020457078,
-0.002468118,
0.0302833598,
0.0261136796,
0.0597223006,
0.020191364,
-0.0099251838,
0.0176114105,
-0.0030994087,
-0.0213595405,
0.0165054072,
-0.0147355422,
0.0311824773,
0.0311703663,
0.0451379642,
-0.0233365837,
-0.0212611668,
0.0213091504,
-0.0147178844,
0.0268758591,
-0.0408034436,
-0.0154881217,
0.0242548659,
0.0564045273,
0.0519561209,
0.0000023129,
-0.0351388007,
-0.0476925075,
0.0356666408,
0.0142779239,
0.0389315337,
0.0246468764,
0.0168773793,
0.0238968208,
-0.0170850977,
0.0063985428,
-0.0459717922,
0.0623815954,
0.0045413296,
0.023557445,
0.0234608818,
-0.0188658908,
-0.0357314162,
0.0381369032,
-0.0099030109,
0.0486259572,
-0.000471268,
0.0525530539,
-0.0000857426,
0.0614431277,
0.008706117,
0.0224949792,
0.0347948857,
-0.004206805,
-0.0237141792,
0.0092560984,
0.0455525406,
0.0105720367,
0.0024584152,
0.0391994081,
-0.0113946749,
-0.0151479226,
-0.0211196579,
0.0590696856,
0.0347573832,
0.0276661776,
0.0181987043,
-0.0751054287,
0.0072727171,
0.006417017,
0.0020833032,
-0.002614018,
-0.0185516104,
0.0187523793,
-0.0171664599,
-0.022281453,
0.0761416331,
0.0052631642,
-0.0074251741,
-0.0777838975,
-0.0090941964,
0.0029782427,
-0.0076257871,
0.0015483077,
0.0150823239,
-0.0037203324,
-0.0289620515,
0.0384409949,
-0.0073096547,
0.0539896339,
-0.0647450015,
0.0185836367,
0.0168507136,
-0.0270500444,
0.0220323298,
-0.0079975175,
-0.0296791084,
-0.004010323,
0.0084455125,
-0.0027182172,
-0.0256791376,
-0.0591218881,
-0.0116247796,
-0.0075554126,
0.0313675925,
-0.0767425373,
0.0198453367,
-0.0464063138,
0.0214889515,
0.0100624217,
0.0102596162,
0.019383952,
0.0302797258,
0.0038094583,
0.0581900589,
0.0545907654,
0.0229722746,
-0.0320715494,
0.0120465625,
-0.0521581173,
-0.0369823314,
-0.0238462389,
0.0548935831,
0.0815459862,
-0.0256346073,
-0.0867911652,
0.0572479181,
0.0540430173,
-0.0067054499,
0.0251186769,
-0.0179517884,
-0.0726343766,
0.0025825882,
-0.0038793683,
-0.0613402501,
0.0144665763,
0.0325455554,
-0.0107786618,
-0.0189752113,
-0.019879777,
-0.0117824199,
-0.0404935218,
0.0355623811,
-0.0876996219,
-0.0125605464,
0.0286697224,
-0.0123111196,
0.0453917496,
-0.0038536314,
-0.0002296506,
0.0235254597,
0.0175705813,
-0.022404654,
-0.0069985557,
0.0224260185,
-0.0179221742,
-0.0164913628,
-0.0498114489,
0.0267952885,
0.0397336781,
0.0331666395,
0.0058920528,
-0.00866397,
-0.012202031,
0.0082641775,
0.0300501641,
0.112781629,
0.0409478247,
0.0064262273,
0.026956005,
0.0778953731,
-0.0407108851,
-0.0790558085,
-0.0165572651,
0.0574012734,
-0.0492449403,
0.0109968306,
0.020378923,
0.0485964268,
0.0457423478,
0.0003500019,
-0.0350171849,
-0.021601012,
0.0065691313,
-0.0424345024,
0.0153832277,
-0.0500599444,
0.0587786511,
-0.0080966558,
0.0118565522,
-0.0412024856,
0.0105767082,
-0.0040344479,
0.0192672703,
0.0240556058,
0.0070113335,
-0.0773914233,
0.0053453799,
-0.0363075845,
-0.0113096647,
0.0172599591,
-0.0086662043,
-0.0085925804,
0.0042802556,
0.0150003117,
-0.0229755174,
0.0098882811,
0.02659522,
-0.0135495393,
-0.023679411,
-0.0091588618,
-0.0027151008,
-0.0686039627,
-0.0367903821,
-0.0009787347,
-0.0262876879,
-0.0281396359,
-0.0267685596,
-0.0394748263,
0.0095215058,
0.0035698779,
-0.0711292326,
0.0392464846,
0.0554931313,
-0.0262654815,
-0.0324769504,
0.0011535682,
0.0410004407,
-0.0228753537,
-0.001015959,
-0.0024857169,
-0.0320448726,
-0.0007861186,
-0.01117511,
-0.0200028643,
0.0279234499,
-0.042768959,
0.0224387199,
-0.0175503641,
-0.0350117944,
-0.014306196,
-0.0222300049,
-0.0490402579,
0.0251112655,
0.0182087831,
0.0041071358,
0.007877077,
-0.074977383,
0.0214760564,
0.0088644456,
0.0344693735,
-0.0443888791,
0.0232772641,
-0.0161811262,
0.0163198169,
0.0117453542,
0.016083857,
0.0053650215,
-0.0616163425,
0.0065931696,
-0.0047799866,
0.0412075929,
-0.0091904234,
0.0007715719,
-0.0112633351,
0.0151619408,
-0.0389240459,
-0.0216174759,
-0.0074776928,
0.0077102948,
0.0297122095,
-0.0475128256,
-0.0344625264,
-0.0668360367,
-0.0263047721,
-0.0594950654,
0.0381471775,
0.0153288292,
-0.070535779,
0.0351033174,
-0.0200097188,
-0.0317614824,
-0.0138028329,
0.0126976641,
-0.0080055464,
0.0099548809,
-0.0220134649,
-0.0074708811,
-0.0097982846,
-0.0137171689,
0.0014229356,
0.0505031496,
-0.043098297,
-0.0057337629,
-0.0169071052,
-0.0287649371,
0.0280780029,
-0.0374417715,
-0.044720307,
0.0086531471,
0.0254691709,
0.0311131906,
-0.0467146747,
-0.0170336422,
0.0535393395,
-0.0113556953,
0.0411446802,
-0.0306363776,
0.0005832196,
-0.0103405192,
0.0575319938,
-0.0152698178,
-0.035311453,
0.0568416864,
-0.0165894497,
0.0118749142,
-0.0254492834,
0.0039434875,
-0.0451782867,
0.0583615564,
0.009186523,
0.0076918607,
-0.0338018127,
-0.0110621797,
0.0744648129,
-0.0241492074,
-0.05078765,
-0.0169179048,
-0.0000793449,
-0.0279781222,
0.0392769165,
0.0262373183,
-0.0148314955,
0.0169720408,
0.0562594719,
-0.0186790582,
0.0128583182,
0.0448225997,
-0.0647187233,
0.0061138906,
0.0418665186,
0.0456970856,
0.0560064502,
-0.0716721788,
0.0204082821,
-0.0313418247,
-0.0034839574,
0.046684783,
0.0532137379,
0.0106414789,
0.0125372149,
0.0308737643,
0.017238643,
-0.0915034115,
0.0231611952,
0.0369821899,
0.0442552269,
-0.0009788291,
-0.025233658,
-0.0230668783,
-0.0137884822,
0.0800417736,
-0.0682077259,
-0.0596879758,
0.110041298,
0.0791294202,
-0.0233740211,
0.0285995789,
-0.0562917106,
-0.0156460088,
0.0275676996,
0.0591332205,
-0.0595473945,
-0.0184633676,
-0.0361301862,
-0.0506643616,
0.0405660123,
-0.05467375,
0.0614695437,
-0.0276689287,
0.0723808929,
0.0462477468,
-0.1015925631,
-0.0447896048,
-0.0390188769,
-0.0346657075,
-0.0361209549,
-0.0188883115,
-0.0094343489,
-0.0194856953,
-0.0146401906,
-0.0029862537,
-0.0304293893,
-0.0168701708,
0.0061748815,
-0.0296483506,
0.0651724041,
0.0465281568,
0.0254059751,
-0.0220436845,
-0.0327744894,
-0.0168136563,
0.0258946046,
0.0029592118,
-0.0371926427,
0.0325998105,
0.0560193211,
-0.0161366109,
-0.0511697903,
0.0037092376,
-0.0261881929,
-0.0389858745,
-0.0197148398,
0.1003523991,
-0.0434622467,
0.0084673651,
-0.0260107554,
0.0076460089,
-0.009410698,
0.0130102178,
0.0186706819,
-0.0078636315,
-0.0199510735,
-0.0575132854,
0.0016123002,
-0.0386029221,
-0.044287391,
0.0455994345,
-0.0208573993,
-0.0324056633,
-0.0077513852,
-0.0220509712,
0.0547771491,
-0.0344307236,
0.0264042541,
0.0358408242,
0.0158100743,
-0.0730608106,
-0.055608578,
0.0764587671,
-0.0019818901,
0.0142052583,
0.0374959633,
-0.0262340903,
0.0411255956,
-0.01766029,
0.0103490623,
0.0231358595,
-0.0120359035,
-0.0366278812,
-0.0196080767,
0.0343463644,
0.0087065678,
-0.0323475339,
0.019792106,
-0.0465097241,
0.0088281604,
0.0067921118,
-0.0387969092,
-0.0000714587,
-0.0209657773,
-0.0073972028,
0.0122751491,
0.0116351414,
-0.0067377849,
0.0198959745,
-0.0204384532,
0.0235032905,
-0.0341439955,
-0.0422210842,
-0.0009826766,
-0.015547636,
0.0839269385,
0.037942946,
-0.0262468513,
-0.0163275935,
-0.0018526444,
-0.0758873895,
0.001265207,
-0.0203621574,
0.0198132116,
-0.0159174502,
0.0552441031,
-0.0295355897,
0.0084147016,
-0.0294244792,
-0.0195057858,
-0.0514795929,
0.0193724483,
-0.004586793,
-0.0457723737,
-0.0209199823,
-0.0024013731,
-0.0439129137,
0.0308630206,
-0.071752876,
0.0143400896,
0.0097393505,
-0.045165237,
-0.013932297,
0.0530003719,
-0.0262082703,
0.0031976616,
-0.009245839,
-0.0032355641,
0.0133759845,
0.0377162471,
0.0828449205,
-0.0198390093,
0.0663076639,
-0.0096333632,
0.0026453128,
-0.0630039722,
0.0076721637,
-0.0191337019,
-0.0196068492,
-0.00292864,
0.0046183397,
-0.0588396974,
-0.0993247852,
0.0205841847,
0.0589229614,
0.02512802,
-0.0304239225,
-0.0830885172,
-0.0181591362,
-0.0000149053,
0.0809457228,
0.0201395303,
-0.0668239594,
0.00321474,
-0.0348305851,
-0.0619511977,
0.0359828696,
0.0385431238,
-0.0544654317,
-0.0076484126,
-0.0216041394,
-0.0472698659,
0.0061565307,
-0.0869312882,
-0.0437261648,
0.0181229413,
-0.012659817,
-0.0903910473,
0.0374716297,
-6.784155526e-33,
-0.0072346586,
-0.0557058156,
0.0380998105,
-0.0072620143,
0.0077508367,
-0.0052264067,
-0.0347193964,
-0.0291584954,
0.065063104,
0.045428928,
0.0198397357,
-0.0037046131,
-0.0149958078,
0.0318566225,
0.0542924553,
0.0145901153,
0.0278759617,
0.0250327513,
0.0358264893,
0.00920635,
0.0467615165,
0.0170565117,
0.037165571,
-0.0316448808,
0.0162212327,
0.0761243999,
0.0066141663,
0.0105234999,
-0.0590788275,
0.0094366595,
-0.0042698546,
0.0011611219,
0.0049677314,
0.0006668157,
-0.0029077106,
-0.0140955159,
-0.0052706529,
-0.0028945205,
0.0121583696,
-0.0011087693,
-0.0315155983,
-0.0466092229,
0.026616266,
-0.0269845333,
-0.0192743,
0.0145473583,
0.0342167765,
-0.0098061133,
-0.0627800524,
-0.0167914554,
-0.0414984934,
0.0415830016,
-0.026337238,
0.0211888347,
0.0285901558,
-0.0425124243,
-0.0087423492,
0.0297657587,
-0.0520395637,
-0.0068647442,
0.0214885492,
0.0210939795,
0.0354479849,
-0.0031822829,
0.0600895323,
0.0462111868,
-0.0017019798,
-0.0496342629,
0.0057306127,
0.0558603033,
0.0138928313,
0.0290966649,
0.0227685962,
-0.011486548,
0.0074693314,
-0.0059025316,
-0.1049368083,
0.0678687841,
-0.0868776739,
-0.0036339576,
0.0010080239,
0.0224020611,
0.0472716428,
-0.0006819627,
-0.0333151333,
0.01693381,
-0.0042419881,
0.016315842,
-0.033787068,
-0.0631914437,
-0.0214478634,
0.0639756024,
0.0446370356,
-0.0102479868,
-0.0518355928,
-0.0106848218,
0.0195121113,
-0.0174528826,
-0.030209709,
0.0370533243,
-0.0073018293,
0.0128360363,
-0.0183886196,
-0.0320144184,
0.0380534939,
0.0256972387,
0.022382427,
0.0335612744,
-0.0715969428,
-0.0016615808,
0.0212276597,
-0.0145342974,
-0.0171383843,
0.0185986366,
0.0073079616,
-0.0022020056,
0.0349598825,
0.0595266148,
0.0420122743,
0.0191573258,
-0.0022026391,
0.000179589,
-0.0374722816,
-0.0052126893,
-0.0092911627,
-0.0098360032,
-0.0655978769,
0.0234795194,
0.019271316,
-0.0584076941,
0.0231821574,
0.0235628411,
3.155e-7,
0.0842188671,
0.1003240347,
0.0039506489,
-0.0056553502,
0.0522217825,
-0.0308606513,
0.0104248393,
0.0210611746,
-0.0328928828,
0.0241452772,
0.026007317,
0.0051331194,
0.0387811251,
0.0303220637,
-0.0736768171,
0.0259751156,
-0.05350741,
0.0225385558,
-0.0630068555,
0.0216593705,
0.0608233958,
0.1062173173,
-0.031422995,
0.0276080109,
0.0616537817,
0.0124299508,
0.0009607801,
-0.0193344392,
0.019187957,
0.0083846664,
-0.0299772881,
-0.065201208,
0.0444317274,
0.005095596,
-0.0053475867,
-0.0034034122,
-0.0513133332,
0.0995106697,
-0.0053889905,
0.0370468572,
0.0462928228,
-0.0241824612,
0.0275421645,
-0.0549012534,
0.0216528513,
-0.0633505583,
-0.0503678843,
-0.0348117203,
0.0668338239,
0.023583455,
0.036929097,
0.0021319601,
0.0069942377,
0.017550841,
0.0039728619,
-0.0145186679,
-0.0145775126,
-0.0053364043,
-0.018480977,
0.0476715676,
-0.0403327793,
0.0052736937,
-0.0243927967,
0.0010260371,
0.0181878842,
-0.0003497847,
0.0171919297,
3.238230256e-34,
0.0178290121,
0.0095595894,
-0.009853025,
-0.016276177,
0.0657803267,
-0.0209970083,
-0.0216511991,
0.0158614814,
-0.0143900784,
-0.0805085376,
-0.0104520833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14284v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14284v1 | VAIYAKARANA : A Benchmark for Automatic Grammar Correction in Bangla | 2024-06-20T13:09:29 | 2024-06-20T13:09:29 | Pramit Bhattacharyya, Arnab Bhattacharya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Bangla (Bengali) is the fifth most spoken language globally and, yet, the
problem of automatic grammar correction in Bangla is still in its nascent
stage. This is mostly due to the need for a large corpus of grammatically
incorrect sentences, with their corresponding correct counterparts. The present
state-of-the-art techniques to curate a corpus for grammatically wrong
sentences involve random swapping, insertion and deletion of words.
However,these steps may not always generate grammatically wrong sentences in
Bangla. In this work, we propose a pragmatic approach to generate grammatically
wrong sentences in Bangla. We first categorize the different kinds of errors in
Bangla into 5 broad classes and 12 finer classes. We then use these to generate
grammatically wrong sentences systematically from a correct sentence. This
approach can generate a large number of wrong sentences and can, thus, mitigate
the challenge of lacking a large corpus for neural networks. We provide a
dataset, Vaiyakarana, consisting of 92,830 grammatically incorrect sentences as
well as 18,426 correct sentences. We also collected 619 human-generated
sentences from essays written by Bangla native speakers. This helped us to
understand errors that are more frequent. We evaluated our corpus against
neural models and LLMs and also benchmark it against human evaluators who are
native speakers of Bangla. Our analysis shows that native speakers are far more
accurate than state-of-the-art models to detect whether the sentence is
grammatically correct. Our methodology of generating erroneous sentences can be
applied for most other Indian languages as well. | [
0.0781183243,
0.0246544797,
-0.0226534195,
0.0327041596,
-0.0658120587,
0.0093519157,
-0.0332166106,
-0.0285951253,
-0.0015775305,
-0.0524255373,
-0.0077125439,
-0.0369388759,
0.0353278741,
-0.0095422994,
0.0343454294,
-0.0425223261,
0.0509902239,
-0.0062838783,
0.0125139635,
0.017548738,
0.021765098,
0.0175303686,
-0.0352663472,
0.0147282155,
-0.0581722744,
-0.0310666524,
0.0031347519,
0.0394538157,
-0.0030602636,
0.0149535118,
0.0662051737,
0.0656692088,
-0.0509195477,
0.0569951721,
0.0000016402,
-0.0360463485,
0.0242621563,
-0.0302421916,
0.00839944,
0.0396947749,
0.0234865714,
0.0138614774,
-0.0661685094,
0.0276299417,
-0.0353531465,
0.0240471326,
0.0443283319,
0.0499838144,
0.0506387502,
0.1116827056,
0.0077397441,
-0.0213771239,
0.0203886237,
0.0038125424,
0.0110189002,
0.021096861,
0.0125586884,
-0.0478286631,
-0.0104679689,
-0.0076905158,
-0.0169891007,
0.0256640874,
0.0056542796,
-0.0650359243,
0.0297675319,
-0.042054709,
-0.0384710431,
-0.0296293348,
-0.0115878833,
0.0334051363,
-0.0415931121,
-0.0473541319,
0.0018924488,
0.0123983258,
0.012921866,
-0.0539829247,
-0.0111326799,
0.0238830075,
-0.0157018099,
0.0382261463,
0.0405585319,
-0.0579361096,
0.0222181771,
0.0149790142,
0.086602062,
0.0361448042,
0.008630204,
-0.0656488612,
-0.0517896153,
0.0338342674,
0.0208663251,
-0.0431360044,
0.0131248767,
-0.0107666738,
-0.0500036776,
0.0110716429,
-0.0361725688,
-0.0509464219,
0.0414916165,
-0.0452007689,
0.0281991493,
-0.020725809,
-0.0271676369,
0.01991418,
-0.0076145628,
0.0116423899,
0.0245250277,
0.0306938626,
-0.0087039648,
0.0035634232,
-0.0113604283,
-0.0468265712,
-0.0007064206,
0.0104571702,
-0.0221610777,
0.0392148122,
-0.0924326554,
-0.0230582003,
-0.0427331515,
0.0243228748,
-0.0085421121,
0.0293613505,
-0.0259073507,
-0.0361635797,
-0.0013863102,
-0.0036858702,
0.0229809601,
0.0393841602,
0.0222482719,
-0.0807617754,
0.0031197562,
0.0189123433,
-0.0190240964,
0.011180602,
-0.0238230508,
-0.0043523773,
-0.0186928697,
0.0018703828,
-0.0663992614,
0.006047803,
-0.036596369,
-0.0419372916,
-0.059677951,
-0.0936095789,
-0.0082593486,
-0.0235805083,
-0.0297245272,
-0.0167592242,
0.0149186086,
0.0453275181,
-0.0148085719,
0.0741422549,
-0.0343998447,
0.0137981856,
0.0462308154,
0.0003620649,
0.0573117249,
0.0188800339,
0.0193499699,
-0.0117107499,
0.0509102009,
0.0200457461,
0.0449506901,
0.0251659341,
-0.0300447214,
-0.0463522822,
0.0046211304,
-0.0298066102,
-0.0353967771,
0.0662243217,
0.0256801192,
0.0752449706,
-0.0019078357,
0.0587177612,
0.0476134792,
0.0217686221,
-0.0110548548,
0.0391947813,
0.0421570912,
-0.018918233,
0.0375434048,
0.0249412954,
-0.0525476821,
-0.0098155709,
-0.0375984423,
-0.0251430981,
0.0056737652,
0.0216141716,
0.0010535518,
-0.0435570627,
-0.0159776751,
-0.0065657403,
-0.0201540943,
-0.0462620631,
0.0128279859,
0.0581243746,
-0.0034767229,
0.0400061831,
0.0421408676,
-0.0799540877,
0.001900824,
-0.0047022593,
0.0305901915,
0.0306653753,
0.0400369316,
-0.0198100526,
-0.0241528135,
-0.0061675292,
-0.0171862934,
0.0719754547,
0.066187568,
-0.032311108,
-0.0284348316,
-0.0379286259,
0.0643679351,
0.0216771476,
0.0353992432,
-0.0207817946,
0.0056466418,
0.0163971689,
0.0096761789,
0.0001885696,
-0.0437711254,
0.0392769091,
-0.0070561133,
0.0045257625,
0.0211616717,
0.0060089738,
0.0123671377,
-0.0151573075,
-0.0233246312,
0.0094811572,
-0.0070661022,
-0.0101417154,
-0.0401236862,
0.0053052818,
-0.0324847661,
-0.0693316683,
0.0098066796,
-0.0800894871,
-0.0386149511,
0.035067942,
-0.0451599918,
-0.0483565964,
0.047481399,
-0.0277126562,
-0.0082867639,
-0.0633775592,
0.0613781065,
-0.0058437106,
-0.0021969923,
-0.038686417,
0.0141594848,
-0.002708554,
0.023587944,
0.0042152819,
-0.0067701195,
0.0188517105,
-0.067977041,
-0.011218545,
0.0126445554,
0.0002382091,
0.0236642938,
0.0041501876,
0.0409195982,
-0.0650569499,
-0.0283618532,
-0.0833580494,
-0.0214568358,
-0.0188666098,
0.013716775,
0.0567574613,
0.0214624815,
-0.0293394104,
-0.0455598459,
0.0054696263,
0.0228361245,
0.0477159098,
-0.0173881911,
0.085283719,
-0.0482187867,
0.0096939849,
-0.0550467893,
-0.0027558652,
-0.037254028,
-0.0178993475,
0.0034026816,
-0.0417496338,
-0.0678275079,
0.0092338463,
0.0052415621,
-0.0002378178,
0.0489156097,
-0.0706565157,
-0.0145249553,
-0.00250303,
0.0127019128,
0.033488024,
0.0067682532,
-0.0024642935,
-0.0114852088,
-0.0111186774,
0.0148638012,
-0.00775187,
0.0039285282,
0.0103776418,
-0.0182425492,
-0.0359844528,
-0.001114091,
0.0312807336,
0.0295228697,
-0.002080451,
0.0145861842,
0.0270553734,
-0.0192204528,
-0.0026919292,
-0.0319348574,
0.0059220269,
-0.036524456,
0.0413695313,
-0.035510309,
0.0011550073,
0.0354277268,
0.0047117886,
0.0192175228,
-0.0563806929,
0.0146892713,
-0.0109263044,
-0.013167751,
0.0140217645,
0.0174473636,
0.0080068856,
-0.0304214619,
-0.082754828,
-0.0028976852,
0.0575551763,
-0.0076577966,
0.0102155842,
-0.1204529703,
0.0220498908,
0.0083104195,
-0.0827317983,
-0.0278455168,
-0.0750324652,
0.0076419888,
-0.0335448235,
-0.0102050761,
0.0080600902,
-0.0221664533,
-0.046429012,
-0.0404951796,
0.0114224423,
-0.0304075126,
-0.0057585589,
0.0018832587,
0.0361680277,
0.0117786452,
0.0032718189,
0.0496093333,
0.0195996985,
-0.0076731206,
0.0261757374,
-0.0090648215,
0.0438068062,
-0.020957008,
0.0137930503,
0.0088090189,
-0.032948833,
-0.0515033118,
-0.0040369406,
0.0465593413,
-0.0328613631,
-0.0445156693,
0.0698478743,
0.0377069078,
-0.0170257725,
-0.0094905291,
-0.0454615764,
-0.0246250294,
-0.0187250748,
0.0370638184,
-0.0567681491,
-0.0196433049,
0.0331902392,
0.0090508908,
-0.0349832214,
0.0035457292,
0.0093962876,
-0.1383301616,
0.0437156111,
0.028979281,
0.0086370902,
-0.0314229392,
0.0301928464,
-0.0064976579,
0.0003741066,
0.0653711334,
0.061521858,
-0.023915112,
-0.0014372045,
0.0282485951,
-0.0500030518,
-0.0752718672,
-0.0282240584,
-0.0155453263,
0.0693133771,
0.0437565073,
0.0182335079,
-0.0209445767,
0.0074401954,
0.0416197106,
0.0163129587,
-0.0210014675,
0.0235078875,
0.023011161,
0.0278507154,
-0.0333694257,
-0.0605829582,
0.0381192006,
-0.029152412,
-0.0033714147,
0.0060633961,
0.0655377284,
-0.0016853472,
0.0011422058,
-0.0011973405,
0.0064358553,
0.0156628452,
0.0134893171,
0.0453960039,
-0.0152884377,
-0.0560883544,
-0.0627603158,
-0.0347622782,
-0.0429660678,
-0.0171765462,
0.0500060283,
-0.0243286248,
-0.0451261327,
-0.077345483,
-0.0797744468,
-0.0060157496,
-0.004193475,
0.033981666,
-0.0168666467,
0.0208667088,
0.005340647,
0.0184743796,
-0.0452323295,
-0.0022548942,
0.0332539901,
-0.0701643229,
0.0086767077,
0.007710964,
0.0419357195,
0.0134646893,
-0.034985587,
-0.0585422218,
-0.0627717376,
0.0680186152,
0.0445870869,
0.0170517005,
0.0176416151,
-0.0482610725,
-0.0787183642,
0.0084274365,
0.0739181787,
-0.0200109985,
0.0360966474,
0.0058778957,
-0.027249299,
0.002307219,
0.0487754345,
-0.0127741871,
0.002363102,
0.0038148386,
0.0079337209,
-0.0380121879,
0.0159057267,
0.0300840996,
0.026941644,
0.0474988781,
-0.0268768873,
-0.0050663147,
-0.0560112372,
0.0156808998,
0.0013544199,
-0.0489948057,
0.0201436114,
0.0132507347,
0.0418396853,
0.0247903783,
-0.0178708564,
-0.028678786,
-0.0528816134,
0.0161436461,
0.0197722763,
0.0153201735,
0.0499489643,
0.0491861254,
0.006236183,
0.0031472354,
-0.0173744466,
0.0099374903,
0.0072999215,
0.0530171916,
0.0050104996,
0.0033197321,
0.0181228071,
0.013278964,
-0.0026827559,
0.023716595,
-0.0064829774,
0.0440354645,
-0.0039250092,
0.0264990479,
0.0952816233,
-0.0164829046,
0.0659239069,
-0.0293244012,
-0.024263829,
-0.0305497963,
0.0478780195,
-0.0057910611,
-0.0002351946,
0.0236003902,
-0.02214339,
-0.0078050713,
-0.0188519452,
0.0387327708,
-0.0377107635,
0.0093240608,
0.0529696494,
-0.0331162214,
-0.0264767651,
-0.0233934484,
-0.02148173,
-0.0250762776,
0.0095382202,
-0.0179465003,
-0.0374996178,
-0.0604103617,
0.0088040121,
0.0522041097,
0.043579638,
-0.002720414,
0.0019408828,
0.052692946,
0.0302519966,
0.0637315959,
-0.071188271,
0.024573829,
-0.0005088569,
-0.0367179774,
-0.0534690619,
-5.361621119e-33,
-0.0373962596,
0.0063646785,
-0.0330475904,
-0.005648355,
0.0007765848,
-0.0365813673,
-0.0194712766,
0.0176492017,
0.030598456,
0.0608126111,
-0.0518594533,
0.0235089567,
0.0219176356,
0.0153351761,
0.0966490135,
-0.0035209768,
0.062274538,
0.0150844073,
0.0023441676,
-0.0263928268,
0.0507767349,
0.0423939005,
0.0774046183,
-0.0148333181,
0.0344718732,
-0.0416126996,
-0.0530574396,
0.0603150651,
-0.0496035218,
0.0114303799,
0.0437789001,
0.0845048353,
0.0051576793,
0.0439921245,
-0.0374380238,
0.0076246471,
-0.0339271612,
-0.0423901379,
0.031014204,
0.0932641253,
-0.0237934701,
-0.0579374172,
0.0680945963,
-0.0222936366,
-0.0295430478,
0.0488462597,
0.0278003793,
-0.0108428178,
0.0293708984,
0.0385716334,
-0.0501456633,
0.003734285,
-0.016567938,
0.0017989745,
-0.0360207185,
0.0106832599,
-0.0392273329,
-0.0751612186,
-0.0578446276,
-0.0017855074,
0.0271836221,
0.0455545373,
0.0330164209,
-0.0183763485,
-0.0432702638,
0.0199301261,
0.0580372214,
-0.0145255532,
0.030329939,
0.0464456491,
-0.011483117,
0.0283294301,
0.0186583158,
0.0936933309,
0.0612234771,
-0.0623988435,
-0.0317934789,
0.0012164082,
0.034238521,
0.0642550439,
-0.0200756975,
-0.0243431181,
-0.040581461,
-0.0603390485,
0.019195538,
-0.0222791098,
-0.0049499953,
-0.0030074066,
0.0505767688,
-0.0043225666,
0.0250886623,
-0.0107181808,
-0.0442124046,
-0.025887562,
0.0073360852,
-0.0148151256,
-0.0387981199,
0.0173021294,
0.0003060226,
0.0242372397,
-0.0429340936,
-0.0082396641,
-0.0255345013,
0.0556148328,
0.0163866021,
0.0259226039,
0.0809938759,
0.0030825972,
-0.0562994257,
0.0180823058,
-0.0171931386,
0.0459185988,
-0.0065606395,
0.0116806021,
-0.0018958783,
0.0033125659,
-0.0242602825,
-0.0128978193,
-0.0076195523,
0.0291462839,
-0.0181021597,
-0.0171431806,
-0.0200792681,
-0.0059666946,
-0.0299607944,
0.008533922,
-0.0449031927,
0.0078652175,
0.0206520818,
-0.0391552486,
0.0300604459,
0.0005924482,
2.371e-7,
0.0060122735,
0.0780778974,
0.0415871069,
-0.0228605848,
0.0215948336,
0.0354532488,
-0.0441918001,
0.0264327843,
-0.0111560058,
0.0596645847,
0.0105981762,
-0.0291495379,
0.05300292,
0.0123154782,
-0.1032975838,
0.012308903,
-0.067342259,
-0.006662827,
-0.0174869727,
-0.0466486849,
-0.0033870568,
0.0448055342,
0.0430463552,
-0.0473939143,
-0.0167927016,
-0.009606149,
0.0286962204,
0.0041259914,
-0.0422510356,
0.0098952604,
0.0756601393,
0.0164132919,
0.0170315299,
0.0003866219,
-0.0164251346,
-0.0484866947,
0.0055210018,
0.0153473709,
-0.0123422276,
0.0472900011,
-0.0111955488,
0.0112002604,
-0.0064678402,
-0.0198220424,
0.0306468476,
-0.0003228614,
-0.002702578,
-0.0105692213,
-0.0171922296,
0.0115667582,
0.0108437967,
-0.0222340561,
-0.0331722423,
-0.0078853928,
0.0369536504,
-0.0238135103,
-0.0187483225,
-0.0082998741,
-0.0145347966,
0.0303684212,
0.0042988332,
-0.0206153374,
0.0070141712,
0.0750368163,
0.0216087364,
-0.0720107332,
0.0350263715,
1.561984266e-34,
0.0602558069,
0.0182922762,
0.0642899796,
-0.0207748376,
0.0164113846,
0.0197784845,
0.0026488493,
0.0244590007,
-0.0107679684,
-0.0247125234,
-0.0117019285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14282v1 | Learning to Plan for Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models from Knowledge Graphs | 2024-06-20T13:07:38 | 2024-06-20T13:07:38 | Junjie Wang, Mingyang Chen, Binbin Hu, Dan Yang, Ziqi Liu, Yue Shen, Peng Wei, Zhiqiang Zhang, Jinjie Gu, Jun Zhou, Jeff Z. Pan, Wen Zhang, Huajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Improving the performance of large language models (LLMs) in complex
question-answering (QA) scenarios has always been a research focal point.
Recent studies have attempted to enhance LLMs' performance by combining
step-wise planning with external retrieval. While effective for advanced models
like GPT-3.5, smaller LLMs face challenges in decomposing complex questions,
necessitating supervised fine-tuning. Previous work has relied on manual
annotation and knowledge distillation from teacher LLMs, which are
time-consuming and not accurate enough. In this paper, we introduce a novel
framework for enhancing LLMs' planning capabilities by using planning data
derived from knowledge graphs (KGs). LLMs fine-tuned with this data have
improved planning capabilities, better equipping them to handle complex QA
tasks that involve retrieval. Evaluations on multiple datasets, including our
newly proposed benchmark, highlight the effectiveness of our framework and the
benefits of KG-derived planning data. | [
0.0763344765,
-0.0020302164,
0.0057020113,
0.0608184114,
-0.0180080906,
-0.0092825126,
-0.0506575853,
-0.0172888003,
0.0410944112,
-0.0648637116,
0.013424159,
-0.0001038769,
-0.0594873093,
-0.0066327574,
0.001999845,
-0.0386772305,
0.0257299114,
-0.0365251713,
0.0064754686,
0.003417219,
0.002597386,
0.0382453948,
0.0031388041,
0.0128481342,
0.0255577527,
-0.0046228217,
-0.0161876231,
0.0235245693,
-0.0232878551,
-0.0218522586,
0.0281507559,
0.0412118547,
0.0196211953,
0.0060402271,
0.0000016842,
-0.0402541049,
-0.0341998078,
-0.0130711496,
-0.0423526354,
0.0092031863,
-0.031016808,
0.0099316491,
0.04931584,
0.0396987647,
-0.0577474199,
0.0082906298,
-0.0233034175,
0.0320979133,
0.059315864,
0.0687633455,
0.0291691553,
-0.0295389369,
0.0184845068,
-0.0054894364,
0.0168385021,
-0.0554927103,
0.0247198455,
0.0445077531,
0.0196857117,
0.045152273,
-0.0124500412,
0.0402511545,
0.0063604536,
-0.0083175376,
-0.0244891495,
0.000465813,
-0.0485489368,
0.0169725027,
0.0000402982,
0.0970136449,
0.034699887,
0.0054710894,
0.0142047377,
-0.0046924637,
-0.0041863848,
0.0238400865,
-0.0781310648,
-0.0026997738,
-0.0191397667,
-0.0027165171,
-0.0232586097,
-0.0390269496,
0.0236352887,
0.0053230128,
-0.0230069049,
0.0874638334,
-0.0075123562,
-0.0189425405,
0.0143501507,
0.0041901069,
-0.0358465128,
-0.0323704518,
-0.0002976328,
0.0818157047,
-0.0341357067,
0.0476329625,
0.0090880264,
-0.0042091771,
0.0105923638,
0.0234521441,
0.0142003046,
0.0469325036,
0.0330898762,
0.0472588316,
0.0089312419,
0.0521195233,
-0.0115825869,
0.0092566703,
-0.0869031847,
-0.0076048928,
-0.0658372492,
-0.0204565562,
-0.0357476063,
0.039058961,
-0.0409157127,
-0.0260416828,
-0.0131666576,
0.0324139521,
0.0128187025,
0.0041282149,
0.0537860505,
0.042776905,
-0.0110425074,
-0.0243798848,
-0.0711275339,
0.0449353643,
-0.0488856174,
0.0033714036,
0.0047924244,
-0.020011222,
-0.0287483893,
-0.0116412062,
0.037770804,
-0.02185601,
0.0071265609,
0.0330274515,
-0.0169770774,
-0.0023881204,
-0.0122797089,
-0.0695301667,
-0.0136948694,
-0.0408932231,
0.0538106672,
-0.0596888624,
0.0440665707,
0.0138164172,
-0.0086102746,
-0.0004975112,
0.0244356953,
0.0283256713,
-0.0182482377,
0.0210438352,
0.0122717908,
0.0398961939,
0.0020620613,
0.0092663793,
-0.0141237285,
0.0700178966,
0.0165689085,
0.0063153515,
0.0426105112,
0.0187957287,
0.0025574325,
0.0390044264,
0.0436459295,
0.0248894468,
0.0393587537,
0.0525013618,
-0.0032058936,
0.0302624274,
0.0098834429,
0.0321443938,
-0.03424602,
-0.0026698215,
-0.0016708625,
0.0591295585,
-0.0133844204,
-0.006347375,
0.0407497026,
0.028109204,
0.01809939,
-0.0005725158,
-0.0206778347,
0.0061265696,
-0.0512928255,
0.0181288272,
0.0167834777,
0.0042942259,
-0.0191622078,
-0.0234460719,
-0.0163104441,
0.0151713593,
0.0047483086,
0.0490576066,
0.0317117944,
0.01387526,
-0.0434466526,
0.0460778102,
-0.0074145482,
-0.0312638767,
0.0094843172,
-0.0422305129,
0.0165072829,
0.063430883,
0.0561467707,
-0.0366450883,
-0.0613781102,
0.0343516618,
0.0196097102,
-0.0123409685,
0.0225154404,
-0.049917452,
-0.0071013235,
-0.0594041906,
-0.0410091355,
-0.0508063883,
-0.0118700452,
-0.0132158911,
0.0770355016,
-0.0023407245,
0.0297132712,
-0.0617857315,
0.0024759406,
0.0132598402,
-0.0420654006,
-0.0494407825,
-0.0222636126,
-0.0091351066,
0.0043475912,
0.0294462517,
0.0120103061,
0.0308894515,
0.0475106649,
-0.0146322725,
-0.0086622136,
-0.0353427157,
-0.0358475633,
-0.072043933,
0.0628685206,
0.002312406,
-0.0072974092,
0.0082125859,
-0.0529095456,
-0.0633030832,
0.0027046516,
-0.0118556479,
0.04858426,
-0.03625644,
-0.0088658109,
0.0452222526,
-0.0670649111,
-0.0497571491,
0.0438712873,
-0.0029677206,
0.0298355464,
0.0335668474,
-0.0059555001,
0.0132841868,
-0.0398389064,
-0.0231130421,
0.0125985909,
0.0038457569,
0.0300805438,
0.0367591344,
0.0178232417,
-0.0977193862,
-0.0237998646,
-0.1144929081,
0.0413560383,
-0.0261327568,
0.0263766963,
0.0108935842,
0.0145190265,
0.0126316212,
-0.014103801,
-0.0451779366,
0.0198515486,
0.0237014201,
0.0004737276,
-0.0154209714,
0.0357038788,
0.011407014,
-0.0324413627,
-0.0167076848,
-0.0170222092,
0.001115808,
-0.0011229792,
0.0019981707,
0.0014925848,
0.0442586727,
-0.0535195842,
0.0108759087,
-0.0108884368,
-0.0181408972,
-0.0010500196,
-0.0462770946,
0.0123399161,
0.0251970571,
-0.0296948384,
0.0077861724,
0.0275937673,
-0.0486860909,
-0.0763045251,
0.0581474677,
-0.0475576296,
-0.0715287626,
-0.0635012984,
-0.021752622,
-0.0002636555,
0.0289554652,
-0.001011585,
-0.0032006816,
-0.0575637221,
-0.0103336517,
0.0131516401,
0.0002578328,
-0.041143138,
0.0261852015,
0.0109993117,
0.0246476829,
-0.0311721563,
-0.0066083702,
0.0478950888,
0.0020923766,
-0.0111727361,
-0.0118443472,
0.0205500238,
-0.0635612532,
0.0696879774,
-0.0013223878,
0.0022673453,
-0.0525017753,
0.0009838698,
-0.0566304326,
-0.0061858059,
0.007173494,
-0.0676900148,
0.0364055708,
-0.0551627353,
0.0241395663,
0.00250399,
-0.0358503982,
-0.0286581721,
-0.0051748799,
-0.0472490042,
0.0407226346,
-0.0114743309,
-0.0217001569,
-0.0123608001,
-0.0142965615,
0.0298820008,
0.0254376438,
-0.0310457125,
-0.0072515942,
-0.0149484379,
0.0364342555,
0.0802201331,
0.0428439453,
-0.0211920422,
-0.0154127171,
0.0263268109,
0.0302235037,
0.0629613101,
-0.0239224974,
0.0162929725,
-0.004829918,
0.028482696,
-0.0168259107,
0.0020530785,
0.0488209948,
0.0458554476,
-0.0496090241,
-0.0311817192,
0.0902297646,
0.0186274294,
-0.0183811747,
-0.0350658111,
-0.0335627757,
0.0571734086,
0.0426610634,
0.0422381833,
-0.0496281199,
-0.0457111672,
-0.0122648617,
0.0496277884,
0.0020903947,
-0.0584591329,
0.0088882893,
-0.1553132385,
0.0138959838,
-0.0080158496,
-0.0221281964,
-0.0147137782,
-0.0406895317,
-0.0065437946,
0.0229941197,
-0.0029044072,
0.0040065232,
-0.0384660475,
0.0221568216,
0.034932673,
-0.0266333017,
-0.0081542498,
0.0111574447,
0.0152440583,
0.0169981066,
0.0491476171,
0.0212461613,
0.00799686,
0.0095382668,
0.0074299881,
-0.0159165803,
-0.0054956637,
-0.0198464673,
0.0216115769,
-0.0111763757,
0.0171357691,
-0.0221749675,
0.0402359739,
-0.0452693552,
-0.0127790971,
0.0700591654,
0.1089613959,
-0.0233736634,
0.0030197431,
-0.0225475691,
-0.009758275,
-0.0005023069,
0.0740692094,
0.0243760739,
-0.0011038173,
-0.0192915797,
-0.0259299539,
0.0042040548,
-0.063626036,
-0.0296101104,
0.040156763,
-0.0049975747,
0.1094398275,
-0.0633361489,
-0.0523923822,
0.0876245871,
0.0166344214,
0.0053527257,
0.0391841009,
0.0046403361,
0.0394279808,
-0.0535207726,
0.0454731882,
-0.0599613637,
-0.0108668981,
-0.0440777652,
-0.0074581699,
-0.0029133693,
-0.0151104024,
-0.0159554817,
0.0292148646,
-0.0816871077,
-0.0589035712,
-0.0235365927,
0.0247216225,
0.0159971565,
0.0388003737,
0.0175919756,
-0.0347458608,
0.0543478467,
-0.0062274146,
-0.0243981667,
0.004658734,
-0.0036648896,
0.0342312828,
-0.0202180184,
0.0492460541,
-0.0858459622,
-0.0146936122,
-0.0006820413,
0.1003165022,
-0.0356958658,
-0.0588947609,
0.0126154749,
0.0602809899,
-0.0014486873,
0.0228075441,
-0.0196648762,
-0.0232121367,
0.0115784174,
-0.0152488677,
-0.0292503703,
-0.0518438965,
0.0223851949,
0.0211665463,
-0.0573990345,
-0.0013748831,
0.0047339681,
0.025784472,
0.0411383174,
-0.0180295911,
-0.0321766324,
0.0361117758,
-0.0629368648,
0.0318685733,
-0.0238228478,
-0.0207999945,
0.013192581,
0.0057864478,
0.0486795269,
0.0105277114,
0.0483353734,
0.0203888509,
-0.0267539471,
-0.0556412004,
-0.0339919105,
-0.0503147133,
-0.1097359434,
-0.0089129666,
0.0176511183,
0.0248562247,
-0.0053040017,
0.0414414108,
-0.0279111937,
-0.023760004,
-0.0203684364,
-0.0152403647,
0.0033139191,
0.0047563352,
0.0702281669,
0.0469878316,
-0.0049883821,
0.0164255444,
0.0443422869,
0.0106958365,
0.0662510917,
-0.0068583833,
-0.0251420513,
-0.0200942308,
-0.0634347945,
0.0057815472,
0.0435889997,
0.0141735021,
0.0070200488,
-0.0342742875,
-0.0539226979,
-0.0071650445,
-0.0083046695,
-0.0657533854,
-0.0396647118,
0.0497194566,
0.0616546832,
0.0021476236,
-0.043745812,
-0.0358185805,
-0.0026827676,
-0.0584539846,
-0.0349891335,
-0.0014108695,
-5.58416424e-33,
-0.0233342275,
-0.0321138911,
0.0633943751,
-0.0244325865,
-0.0143557973,
0.0113875363,
-0.038238924,
0.0027738744,
-0.0503597632,
-0.0016659427,
-0.0418241844,
0.0112272361,
0.0036815479,
0.0348212421,
0.0126785524,
-0.0131414188,
0.0058099171,
-0.0161740128,
-0.0159951374,
0.0230881423,
0.0458477885,
0.0130376611,
0.0331409611,
-0.0008198642,
-0.0094612883,
-0.0285358857,
0.018298883,
0.0629493818,
-0.021511374,
0.0720124617,
-0.0177245624,
0.0125472974,
0.0272285063,
0.0030091456,
-0.0021611068,
0.0286591798,
-0.0593533032,
-0.0457640737,
0.0381881222,
-0.0335879847,
-0.0699822232,
-0.0282658711,
0.001576488,
-0.0091316747,
0.0283308085,
-0.0321768634,
0.0145671088,
0.0167359989,
-0.010101825,
-0.008812719,
-0.0241852831,
0.0065590614,
-0.0147933196,
-0.0161565244,
0.0272282586,
0.0346368104,
0.0099496711,
0.0296502765,
0.005107027,
-0.0032416368,
-0.0135171022,
0.0529362895,
0.031894058,
0.0588151291,
-0.0078165801,
0.0455392227,
-0.0037316172,
0.0204905476,
-0.0170458257,
-0.0397532098,
0.0055503598,
0.057177145,
-0.000121524,
0.0467284285,
-0.00673815,
0.0426158123,
-0.0720297322,
0.0330354907,
0.0039769299,
0.0467885919,
0.0113898925,
-0.0148906233,
-0.0032917489,
-0.0204671994,
-0.0871081203,
0.0321899392,
-0.0120062046,
0.0100665595,
0.0430800728,
0.0210707653,
0.0075172079,
-0.0059630368,
0.0464937724,
-0.0387005396,
0.015089253,
0.0705053285,
-0.0307320356,
0.0204580538,
-0.02323897,
0.0646671131,
-0.0552727878,
-0.0180338211,
0.0215447359,
-0.0529951118,
-0.0285498668,
0.030744547,
-0.008664025,
-0.0057890401,
-0.0372987725,
-0.0194614138,
-0.0535408743,
0.0033986042,
-0.0455967747,
-0.0225532055,
0.0454979464,
0.0453826152,
-0.0001990334,
0.0192753002,
0.0479091108,
-0.0180614349,
0.0007201838,
-0.0370047987,
0.0377285145,
-0.0410279147,
-0.0074460222,
0.0180461667,
-0.0169074032,
0.0168589056,
-0.0228822641,
-0.0268378053,
0.0051301322,
0.0504944399,
2.45e-7,
0.0697538704,
0.0309667252,
0.0182950459,
0.0578164347,
0.0017734841,
0.0079332031,
0.0038224868,
-0.0246664938,
0.0567771494,
-0.0366655216,
0.0347863175,
0.0434975587,
0.0439833254,
0.0248605702,
-0.0867008716,
0.0129530132,
-0.0313313864,
-0.0459916815,
-0.0560257956,
-0.0412442796,
0.048788283,
0.0571660399,
0.0037155163,
0.0013878886,
-0.0350765027,
-0.0716334134,
0.0591052957,
-0.0301734824,
-0.0147272525,
0.0288245063,
0.0382832848,
0.0198908411,
0.0116215711,
0.0060655037,
0.0088821612,
0.0477951951,
0.0141362334,
0.0701547042,
0.0005215965,
-0.0495491289,
-0.0054865414,
-0.0557815805,
0.0180216432,
-0.0338071026,
0.0746497139,
-0.0440246239,
0.0125558684,
0.0284188725,
-0.00097976,
-0.0365188606,
-0.0262191929,
-0.021397166,
0.0426754765,
0.0220167469,
-0.0078311404,
-0.0015685818,
0.0194861069,
-0.0861649215,
0.0068624718,
0.0272457078,
-0.0311715379,
-0.0458592586,
-0.0331746005,
0.0046849428,
-0.0383021049,
-0.04174776,
0.0234343149,
2.121327641e-34,
0.0228705518,
-0.0057679336,
0.0259724762,
0.0195509009,
0.0506611466,
-0.0144621218,
-0.0129102496,
0.0213014223,
0.007837723,
-0.1453555673,
-0.026186876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14277v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14277v1 | Augmenting Query and Passage for Retrieval-Augmented Generation using LLMs for Open-Domain Question Answering | 2024-06-20T12:59:27 | 2024-06-20T12:59:27 | Minsang Kim, Cheoneum Park, Seungjun Baek | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has received much attention for
Open-domain question-answering (ODQA) tasks as a means to compensate for the
parametric knowledge of large language models (LLMs). While previous approaches
focused on processing retrieved passages to remove irrelevant context, they
still rely heavily on the quality of retrieved passages which can degrade if
the question is ambiguous or complex. In this paper, we propose a simple yet
efficient method called question and passage augmentation via LLMs for
open-domain QA. Our method first decomposes the original questions into
multiple-step sub-questions. By augmenting the original question with detailed
sub-questions and planning, we are able to make the query more specific on what
needs to be retrieved, improving the retrieval performance. In addition, to
compensate for the case where the retrieved passages contain distracting
information or divided opinions, we augment the retrieved passages with
self-generated passages by LLMs to guide the answer extraction. Experimental
results show that the proposed scheme outperforms the previous state-of-the-art
and achieves significant performance gain over existing RAG methods. | [
0.0389813073,
0.0327689461,
-0.0081475908,
0.0358942188,
-0.0372874551,
-0.0019869586,
-0.0162061919,
0.0001244806,
0.0130729834,
-0.0521822125,
-0.0045839953,
-0.0421993732,
-0.0631785914,
0.0229300093,
0.0022795682,
-0.0099261068,
0.038799867,
-0.0064250082,
-0.0191880204,
-0.0100137703,
0.0097264033,
0.0243152697,
0.0085056666,
-0.0034411061,
0.0316016339,
-0.031796813,
-0.038477581,
0.0105888778,
0.011322652,
-0.0162560139,
0.0327534117,
0.0149056856,
0.0365096964,
0.017472906,
0.0000018566,
-0.0471222587,
-0.0559318587,
-0.0019043213,
-0.0391942561,
-0.0095387017,
0.0283101853,
0.0555643849,
0.0381931998,
0.0384982377,
-0.0664081872,
0.0187875405,
-0.0073808162,
0.0504962243,
0.0749421194,
0.0677503124,
0.0212614089,
-0.0159951057,
0.0029178814,
-0.000436069,
0.0365525112,
-0.0511911288,
0.0075514484,
0.0057872669,
0.0384715572,
0.0610152818,
0.0154236387,
0.0276415385,
0.0305375531,
-0.0102621978,
-0.0033927837,
0.0007113822,
-0.0338058472,
0.0208461303,
-0.0023710001,
0.1060794145,
0.0418788902,
-0.0023595146,
-0.0002693756,
-0.0063011125,
0.014349415,
0.0446215905,
-0.0653394684,
0.0307182502,
-0.0061439108,
0.0027962984,
-0.0207495205,
0.0110033583,
-0.0054032574,
0.0297148749,
-0.0478461422,
0.0747808367,
0.0113639496,
-0.031014286,
-0.0066386517,
0.0132179242,
-0.0236531943,
-0.0259283632,
0.0064244391,
0.0718294531,
-0.0130316941,
0.0470015779,
-0.0225823782,
-0.0366395228,
0.015224956,
-0.0079678968,
0.0256372634,
0.0344048068,
-0.0273884758,
0.0308624338,
-0.0146799134,
0.0232019033,
-0.0396558419,
-0.0050695813,
-0.0982623622,
-0.0074439612,
-0.0191346779,
-0.0338602364,
-0.0448972173,
0.0767665207,
-0.0903718024,
0.0021986584,
-0.008239815,
0.048677031,
0.0358948074,
-0.0290777795,
0.0108358236,
0.0508396402,
-0.0206704233,
-0.0345219299,
-0.0540883206,
0.0267766062,
-0.0466551445,
0.0119439717,
0.031050561,
-0.0390602835,
-0.0182440057,
0.0224153567,
0.0298204049,
0.0050641024,
-0.0179365817,
0.0283796843,
-0.0250256974,
-0.0247423016,
-0.0489919446,
-0.0655551404,
-0.0171447955,
-0.0326775908,
0.0213241801,
-0.0528123714,
0.0372746438,
0.0145404628,
-0.054501716,
-0.0071052578,
0.0346491337,
0.0668577105,
-0.0152328853,
0.0210383926,
-0.0173812192,
0.0033158367,
0.0439096168,
0.0288700648,
0.0443250164,
0.0612754002,
0.027247604,
0.0253444128,
0.0462814085,
0.047037378,
0.0113832531,
0.0088516865,
0.0254462417,
0.0259600058,
-0.0124304071,
0.0560154021,
0.0024470428,
0.0067226193,
0.00779083,
0.058744248,
-0.0234422963,
-0.0185150653,
0.0202780329,
0.0062929499,
0.0167704728,
0.0038595281,
0.0335285626,
0.0369535834,
0.0240777079,
0.0493081361,
0.0111216558,
0.0427634902,
-0.0236600302,
0.0196171124,
0.0579125807,
0.0288332608,
-0.0351280607,
-0.051643908,
-0.0022807678,
0.0049762437,
-0.0070682811,
0.0389524661,
0.0076102423,
0.0385973938,
-0.0483599268,
0.0518411696,
0.0055148397,
-0.0607685372,
0.0218675192,
-0.0398347639,
0.0622376837,
0.0172967948,
0.0714735687,
-0.0455303341,
-0.0529419072,
0.0008053902,
0.0072599188,
0.0392992869,
0.0128243724,
-0.0159224942,
-0.0371224172,
-0.0649719462,
-0.0287848096,
-0.0322309509,
-0.0161405448,
0.0182092153,
0.038804844,
0.0005382224,
0.0534104779,
-0.058657676,
-0.0028673413,
0.0180261843,
-0.0441636071,
-0.0513664447,
0.0531337522,
-0.0119474214,
-0.0028433839,
0.0505691506,
0.0075994581,
0.0243517645,
0.0325156935,
-0.0381969437,
-0.0535466224,
-0.0098117171,
-0.0544398651,
-0.0420247614,
0.0177414548,
0.0362821631,
-0.0096459007,
0.0252769236,
-0.0348089039,
-0.0426362082,
-0.0118285278,
-0.0290623046,
0.0007324445,
-0.0790158585,
-0.0155493962,
0.0563000105,
-0.0159678701,
-0.0824090764,
0.0667620152,
0.0027974232,
-0.0068832217,
0.0255021527,
0.0031887055,
0.0211233981,
-0.0201809332,
0.0079051591,
-0.0122324824,
-0.0174532719,
0.0117412759,
0.019474607,
0.0040474283,
-0.0773163736,
-0.0270100757,
-0.0685444102,
0.0480851978,
-0.0296332706,
0.0347705111,
0.0194664691,
0.0427838601,
-0.0191985723,
-0.0181146916,
-0.0847462714,
0.0020454407,
0.0359291956,
0.0105750682,
0.023165701,
0.0428377241,
0.028924372,
-0.0283999164,
0.0166800674,
0.0011353493,
0.0177905876,
-0.0119668934,
0.0218491703,
-0.0576216392,
0.0492385812,
-0.0540832169,
0.0242506284,
0.0032592381,
-0.0219517853,
-0.0058193938,
-0.0577400513,
0.0455960222,
0.0208805855,
0.0360489003,
-0.0318074003,
0.0435867608,
-0.0071105431,
-0.0585619211,
0.045248121,
-0.0462349802,
-0.0520644188,
0.0186253767,
-0.0166689623,
0.0291440897,
0.0143051716,
0.0082964795,
-0.0242437199,
-0.0202988591,
0.0223021116,
0.0054632602,
-0.0055704974,
-0.0362302549,
0.002343958,
-0.0299359113,
0.0507042259,
-0.0027229078,
-0.0286819283,
0.056059584,
0.0008351631,
0.0037620307,
-0.076748997,
0.0166596156,
-0.0870850682,
0.0583462901,
-0.0218913406,
0.0254079867,
-0.0014090347,
-0.0256339237,
-0.056068752,
0.002954321,
-0.0224950705,
-0.0771631449,
0.0474917255,
-0.050480064,
0.0074015963,
-0.008664201,
-0.0299411602,
-0.0780026764,
-0.0394637212,
0.0223347303,
0.0046758233,
-0.0139873819,
-0.0066537936,
0.0020930122,
-0.0223226119,
0.0263668168,
0.0106273815,
-0.0476245023,
0.0059495736,
-0.0148840956,
0.0928845555,
0.0953644663,
0.0568998531,
0.0038218736,
-0.0302581377,
0.0213398226,
0.0650749505,
0.026291769,
-0.0160190016,
0.0333475731,
-0.0218399055,
0.0378691591,
-0.0420299545,
0.0060745501,
0.0159990806,
0.0585734956,
-0.052006457,
-0.0437615216,
0.0977172703,
0.067602016,
-0.0040524099,
-0.0441011675,
-0.0524868704,
0.0279179644,
-0.002159531,
0.0621787235,
-0.1033170149,
-0.0192896929,
-0.0252178106,
0.0568858199,
-0.0019179173,
-0.019110268,
-0.0098745069,
-0.1336772591,
0.0260428134,
-0.0076089981,
-0.0508466214,
-0.0077802092,
-0.0088428613,
0.0021430384,
0.0358735509,
0.0041018301,
0.0528653003,
-0.0187056269,
0.01913766,
0.0101130828,
0.0050117588,
0.0083797984,
-0.011979186,
-0.0184379928,
-0.0143505717,
0.0622279495,
0.0116519621,
0.0325745232,
-0.0103578661,
0.0136767151,
-0.0693960711,
0.0094612036,
0.0048553897,
0.024608491,
0.0042467183,
0.0016885445,
-0.0408914164,
0.0363239758,
0.005115197,
-0.0073931594,
0.0275831372,
0.0460252762,
-0.0328246467,
0.0274199788,
-0.0455257036,
0.0309747308,
0.0022358282,
0.0722241551,
0.0080681536,
-0.0288619064,
-0.0282749645,
-0.0082408013,
0.0070212376,
-0.0636238679,
0.0031275169,
0.0156378653,
-0.0161980875,
0.0577958338,
-0.1071389914,
-0.0327707604,
0.0217019822,
0.030019097,
-0.0182869397,
0.0180230234,
0.0028353569,
-0.0029733444,
-0.0424230658,
-0.0045788819,
-0.0611967444,
-0.0341828205,
-0.0190620217,
-0.0240898374,
0.036845319,
-0.0673252419,
-0.0057990244,
0.0113375289,
-0.0640464798,
-0.0600435883,
-0.0018251565,
0.024194615,
0.0129096005,
0.0170865394,
0.00429312,
-0.0145336716,
0.0388520136,
0.0345560685,
-0.0351629779,
0.0100980159,
-0.007680614,
0.0620788857,
-0.0304645319,
0.0371598452,
-0.0490174964,
-0.0151898805,
-0.0093440125,
0.0681980848,
-0.0207802467,
-0.0755724981,
0.0409283303,
0.0231633913,
-0.0051438562,
0.0333268531,
0.0120328069,
-0.0284770243,
0.0499291159,
-0.0390772112,
-0.0370248221,
-0.0319237299,
0.0287636686,
0.0009435095,
-0.0682606995,
0.010219669,
0.0295768678,
-0.0410898775,
0.0879273266,
-0.0321538374,
-0.0048185466,
-0.003443988,
-0.0154719269,
0.0130930729,
-0.0143827759,
-0.0173884053,
0.0047718575,
0.0051684598,
0.0590652265,
0.0015798492,
0.0757594034,
-0.0034926008,
-0.0130740413,
-0.0125038987,
0.0259011313,
-0.0788753182,
-0.052948799,
-0.0222931467,
0.0271199085,
-0.0169586428,
0.0070690205,
0.0101051377,
0.0029721085,
-0.0274036992,
-0.0198814124,
0.0032650142,
0.0114371814,
-0.005995959,
0.0543281846,
0.0287506599,
-0.0140786693,
0.0209217481,
0.0373290814,
-0.0294435211,
0.0298510157,
-0.0116181476,
-0.0004881929,
-0.029165579,
-0.0499736331,
0.0127017219,
0.0346625596,
-0.0036049499,
0.0094691189,
-0.044643376,
-0.0299551543,
0.0131429471,
0.0085031176,
-0.007808778,
-0.0257422756,
0.0528971143,
0.0547982864,
-0.0004873033,
-0.0239770375,
-0.0666492358,
0.0418725759,
-0.0596532635,
-0.0320408046,
0.0141610242,
-6.395111712e-33,
-0.0318793729,
-0.034175422,
0.0474194176,
-0.0485241599,
-0.0559976399,
-0.014197262,
-0.0175311528,
0.0076789865,
-0.0022220409,
-0.021628432,
-0.0130918575,
-0.0061208946,
0.000436296,
0.045641765,
-0.0434337221,
-0.0315173641,
0.0234354138,
-0.016401086,
-0.0180223696,
0.0363242216,
0.0592035726,
0.021244593,
-0.0112343943,
-0.0062164045,
0.0154857133,
-0.0587824099,
0.0096265627,
0.0285089109,
0.0005354213,
0.0601692609,
0.0005548997,
0.0208725594,
0.0310025066,
-0.0330270901,
0.011605043,
0.0587802753,
-0.0540304184,
-0.028231062,
0.0103090331,
-0.0427362397,
-0.0731420517,
-0.0441951938,
0.0124336239,
-0.0156099517,
0.0439640433,
-0.0041447356,
-0.0023206421,
-0.0289211851,
0.0173488874,
-0.0313245729,
-0.0207676031,
0.0062892637,
0.0148526821,
-0.0304187238,
-0.0185067207,
0.0732773915,
0.0222734828,
0.0217880402,
0.0017849657,
0.0140457777,
0.0263670925,
0.0480559282,
0.0165597368,
0.0091860769,
-0.026525585,
0.0248445868,
-0.012775002,
-0.0181915145,
-0.0478917137,
0.0019927982,
-0.0265710168,
0.0208607446,
0.0232099146,
0.0505481213,
0.0030633078,
0.0341169424,
-0.0616396628,
0.0709103718,
-0.012814967,
0.0203470904,
-0.0102161709,
-0.0165680833,
-0.0008348917,
0.0060801432,
-0.0452201068,
0.0535021611,
-0.0343029089,
-0.0335262753,
0.0528445691,
0.0210113805,
-0.0511811301,
-0.0409639142,
0.0333049074,
-0.0245908611,
0.0328144021,
0.0127801346,
-0.0375165455,
0.0082577094,
-0.030978933,
0.0394118167,
-0.0221922584,
0.0132973688,
0.0331138559,
-0.0448760428,
-0.0515117906,
0.0156351198,
-0.0095285205,
-0.0024323508,
-0.0626907647,
0.0293286294,
-0.034027651,
0.0433270782,
-0.029976435,
0.0171783995,
0.0154411104,
0.0240364224,
0.0000425207,
0.0758511201,
0.0017163977,
0.010145532,
-0.0366273709,
-0.0401096493,
0.0178263243,
-0.0019360234,
-0.0263982974,
0.0652991235,
0.0150397662,
0.0599854514,
-0.0416966602,
-0.0417563953,
0.0024740305,
0.050539244,
2.602e-7,
0.0496476591,
0.006970739,
0.0326406136,
0.0748344958,
-0.0173231978,
0.0078812744,
0.0344527811,
0.0090055382,
0.041606456,
-0.027178498,
-0.0004609902,
0.0308933686,
0.0357217975,
0.0185561553,
-0.1077621207,
0.0009082945,
-0.0183122419,
-0.0388973914,
-0.0340250283,
-0.0360854492,
0.0921823531,
0.0529482774,
-0.0219499953,
0.0011388169,
-0.0397398546,
-0.0193137936,
0.0595669895,
0.0235081259,
-0.0690482929,
0.0394748114,
0.0358450077,
0.0189408548,
-0.007241169,
-0.024105465,
-0.0114965066,
0.0307424106,
0.0128480066,
0.0504385121,
0.0533611476,
-0.0885403976,
-0.0062659765,
-0.0170017779,
0.0342391692,
-0.0265501533,
0.0838438496,
-0.0176790394,
-0.0050458862,
-0.0114143062,
-0.0178993177,
-0.0102224918,
-0.0052006608,
-0.0350195058,
-0.0106949881,
0.0144631248,
0.0037544998,
-0.008086131,
0.0130941942,
-0.0677599832,
-0.0084509263,
-0.0009908908,
-0.0372868553,
-0.035899356,
-0.0273127239,
0.0100551872,
-0.0279745199,
-0.0815062523,
-0.0056430902,
2.29796656e-34,
0.031494163,
-0.0017034309,
-0.011867797,
0.0468842722,
0.0072763297,
0.0041779145,
-0.0100423303,
0.0018510353,
0.0211553797,
-0.1004103869,
-0.0130571406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14275v1 | Step-Back Profiling: Distilling User History for Personalized Scientific Writing | 2024-06-20T12:58:26 | 2024-06-20T12:58:26 | Xiangru Tang, Xingyao Zhang, Yanjun Shao, Jie Wu, Yilun Zhao, Arman Cohan, Ming Gong, Dongmei Zhang, Mark Gerstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) excel at a variety of natural language
processing tasks, yet they struggle to generate personalized content for
individuals, particularly in real-world scenarios like scientific writing.
Addressing this challenge, we introduce Step-Back Profiling to personalize LLMs
by distilling user history into concise profiles, including essential traits
and preferences of users. Regarding our experiments, we construct a
Personalized Scientific Writing (PSW) dataset to study multiuser
personalization. PSW requires the models to write scientific papers given
specialized author groups with diverse academic backgrounds. As for the
results, we demonstrate the effectiveness of capturing user characteristics via
Step-Back Profiling for collaborative writing. Moreover, our approach
outperforms the baselines by up to 3.6 points on the general personalization
benchmark (LaMP), including 7 personalization LLM tasks. Our extensive ablation
studies validate the contributions of different components in our method and
provide insights into our task definition. Our dataset and code are available
at \url{https://github.com/gersteinlab/step-back-profiling}. | [
0.0748296231,
0.0366577394,
-0.0148681952,
-0.0176823772,
-0.03393583,
-0.0231669284,
0.067410171,
-0.0114712613,
0.013487109,
-0.0278779995,
-0.0365587845,
0.000248734,
-0.012223552,
0.06444031,
-0.0002601685,
-0.0582225248,
0.0352291651,
0.0055357297,
0.0438397229,
-0.0046854164,
0.0182570331,
0.0432764217,
0.0089491,
0.03357381,
0.0383551493,
-0.0713170394,
0.027106205,
-0.0133807268,
0.0339641497,
0.0052794013,
0.0322005786,
0.0959387198,
0.0076566655,
0.0362673104,
0.0000019176,
-0.0162668433,
-0.0299485419,
-0.0031157541,
0.0225563888,
0.0311828312,
0.0824286863,
0.0527530834,
0.0013487816,
0.0070947167,
-0.0447375476,
0.024960218,
-0.0098751849,
0.0124710174,
0.05532277,
0.0621598922,
0.0153719876,
-0.0094951969,
0.0123699568,
-0.0127680153,
0.0281604119,
0.0376632996,
0.0053475564,
-0.0426260978,
-0.0015854893,
0.0258429218,
0.0088395122,
0.0202398915,
-0.0214562267,
-0.0310688764,
0.0564533845,
0.0209394768,
-0.0108426576,
0.0223893281,
0.0030728173,
0.0432741456,
0.0436604656,
-0.0275611356,
0.0235412605,
-0.0135324327,
-0.0163427349,
-0.0070489403,
-0.0247625113,
-0.0138292424,
-0.0507162437,
-0.0258944202,
0.0053524738,
0.0264541451,
0.0201747883,
0.0437750593,
0.0230971128,
0.0738695264,
0.0048927995,
-0.0110964216,
-0.0271398202,
0.0039116456,
0.0425051339,
-0.045781631,
0.0582787208,
0.0056985365,
-0.0282710567,
-0.0151260346,
-0.0648679286,
-0.061375156,
0.038027849,
0.0106578451,
0.0739475191,
-0.0020007489,
0.0517655574,
0.0173851252,
0.0216597542,
0.0000133289,
0.0250893515,
-0.0146047836,
0.0026971044,
0.0049379556,
-0.0739012435,
-0.0131990472,
0.0063689188,
0.0351463147,
-0.0139273247,
-0.0082814703,
-0.0378229842,
0.0029639967,
0.0247320794,
-0.0090674637,
0.0110154599,
0.0324777439,
-0.067412667,
0.0183049794,
0.0111091714,
-0.0009378918,
-0.0504313745,
-0.0045655067,
0.0321307592,
0.0132062333,
0.033243306,
-0.0066330954,
0.0044812001,
-0.0510944128,
0.0011141142,
-0.0058788322,
0.0084136771,
-0.052937232,
0.0235785916,
-0.0519092344,
0.0317239501,
-0.0560874715,
-0.020716792,
-0.0689669326,
0.0493037142,
0.0357266143,
0.0000909284,
-0.0863629058,
-0.0320055485,
0.0158564765,
-0.0062564369,
0.0364014469,
-0.0245644767,
-0.0256716013,
0.0695085526,
0.0167613104,
-0.007328324,
-0.0150680291,
0.0270770397,
0.0206016563,
0.0345304161,
-0.0055266679,
0.0125933951,
0.005621314,
-0.0247580744,
-0.0039193812,
0.0072050639,
-0.0010313712,
-0.0392891355,
0.0422059745,
0.0275379606,
0.0331880525,
-0.0249119047,
-0.0109401643,
0.0484561138,
0.0689293668,
0.0633587837,
0.0562414937,
0.0306179263,
0.0261068642,
0.0256377552,
-0.0011516393,
0.0079807984,
0.0273455866,
-0.0025348871,
-0.0087489877,
0.0138055077,
0.0414559692,
-0.0135550648,
-0.023474684,
-0.0025388242,
0.0089985644,
0.0025590006,
-0.0203559995,
0.0117764873,
-0.0011090492,
-0.0082116919,
0.0221785568,
0.0162700359,
-0.1010510772,
0.0421621576,
0.0271756686,
0.0258642063,
0.0934739038,
0.0714795664,
-0.0254762433,
-0.008713834,
-0.0445404649,
-0.0061401832,
0.0209554061,
0.0451778099,
-0.0055301106,
-0.0051463782,
-0.0404225215,
-0.0426072329,
-0.0105054928,
-0.0186318122,
0.0288753901,
0.045976717,
0.0053336578,
0.0150233079,
-0.0012460129,
-0.0425633341,
0.0352335796,
-0.0963750482,
-0.0138772326,
0.0145272985,
-0.0236148499,
0.0288879201,
0.0357241966,
0.004262371,
0.0168459229,
0.0179281142,
-0.0400770865,
-0.0091971429,
0.0019683016,
0.0236065201,
-0.0144058149,
0.0274311136,
-0.0567872487,
0.0140508264,
0.0354170948,
0.0086432137,
-0.0463646092,
0.0268030707,
0.0014351553,
-0.0031206009,
-0.02473858,
-0.0128754843,
-0.0077394121,
-0.0107683158,
-0.0383246392,
0.0379328802,
-0.0268333685,
0.0298056006,
-0.0099179791,
-0.0315534435,
-0.024429027,
-0.031178765,
-0.0277199391,
-0.0526496321,
0.0391645133,
0.0056724674,
0.0229168851,
-0.0305633862,
-0.0618917346,
-0.0367395431,
-0.0729343668,
0.0166780856,
0.0040665562,
0.0229235385,
0.0112551209,
0.0077206874,
0.0059198029,
0.0050680563,
-0.0324991643,
-0.0288442411,
-0.0231517255,
-0.0014301548,
0.0463160314,
0.0086712344,
0.0135195674,
-0.0613120385,
-0.0181941502,
-0.0423671901,
-0.0028936309,
0.0263495725,
-0.0005822488,
-0.03983045,
-0.032233417,
-0.0336089544,
-0.0367711075,
-0.0080649108,
0.0119017912,
0.0332303382,
-0.0160858985,
0.022042172,
0.0601567402,
-0.0020200294,
0.0251081381,
0.056875769,
0.0296088718,
-0.0334079862,
0.0039111115,
-0.0273427311,
0.0677835867,
0.0234843269,
-0.0442361049,
0.0452240407,
0.0372917391,
-0.0075715813,
-0.0271056145,
-0.0440680273,
0.0491288938,
0.0055313176,
-0.0112885358,
0.0145789916,
0.0101051703,
-0.0315819532,
0.0181489326,
0.0031727599,
-0.0305525716,
0.0819941461,
-0.0100928787,
0.0126007777,
-0.0402325317,
-0.0169402827,
-0.0340684503,
0.021595167,
0.0152043207,
0.0147157963,
-0.028097719,
0.0156063335,
-0.0157904644,
-0.0144119794,
0.0390241072,
-0.0185471345,
-0.0177759603,
-0.0183759518,
-0.0215503443,
-0.0045144781,
-0.0342225023,
0.0093959337,
-0.0984178409,
-0.0297746249,
0.0184547063,
0.0215801634,
-0.0557464436,
-0.0391626097,
-0.0351259895,
0.013352165,
0.041445978,
-0.0421966128,
-0.0213555396,
-0.0350094512,
-0.0055849282,
0.0348066241,
-0.0623078682,
-0.0450081304,
-0.0399413221,
-0.0113366656,
0.0569539592,
0.0300513059,
0.0152689731,
-0.0022773182,
-0.0361535661,
0.0255272761,
-0.0862381905,
-0.0488244668,
-0.002067762,
0.0587114915,
-0.0378470644,
-0.0023484346,
0.10547252,
0.0257233903,
-0.0883141607,
-0.0140377032,
-0.0083030015,
0.0398309715,
0.024160875,
0.0625199452,
-0.0470219143,
-0.0209642928,
-0.0134329852,
0.0477234796,
-0.0074471212,
-0.0512777679,
-0.0446182154,
-0.0652730465,
0.0072178235,
0.0065780273,
-0.0366239846,
0.0291208904,
-0.0556106791,
-0.0259955544,
-0.0062706941,
-0.0192372128,
-0.0110305939,
-0.0095540499,
0.0188777838,
0.0196526982,
-0.0329332389,
-0.0550197698,
-0.0175097622,
-0.0316737071,
0.0483835116,
0.0261921231,
0.0572406054,
0.0121613489,
-0.0267808288,
-0.0277686454,
0.0410600193,
0.0354781412,
-0.0220051035,
0.0665845051,
-0.037269257,
0.0532991402,
-0.0612430573,
0.060317032,
-0.0323085412,
-0.0087930951,
0.0370764993,
0.0623507984,
-0.0269498304,
-0.0062641297,
-0.0537314266,
0.0107436161,
0.0159415416,
0.077587314,
0.0259971395,
-0.0896563828,
-0.0565782562,
-0.0448415726,
0.019173542,
-0.0615487397,
-0.0541162267,
-0.0407352559,
-0.0484929308,
0.0280404463,
-0.0555002578,
-0.0497503206,
0.0367732532,
0.0004607535,
0.0121416049,
0.0578892082,
-0.0463170819,
-0.0359463505,
-0.045028735,
0.0309077799,
-0.0188691579,
0.0434177928,
-0.0749455094,
-0.0393623672,
0.0363499336,
-0.0193220526,
0.0026400839,
0.0033438271,
-0.0517296903,
-0.0699517131,
0.0112229045,
0.0318426229,
0.0172799323,
0.0443423465,
-0.0015454439,
-0.1245604977,
0.0327715799,
0.0006115959,
0.0045002587,
-0.0061336327,
0.0059015159,
-0.0116183385,
-0.0376828164,
0.0117416596,
0.0049834154,
-0.0121461404,
0.0153257065,
-0.00216885,
-0.0306705385,
-0.0820467547,
-0.0226281416,
0.0064149182,
0.0462677665,
-0.0402702428,
0.0018908796,
-0.035636805,
-0.0111133279,
-0.0237917006,
-0.0222674757,
-0.0181777757,
-0.0268939529,
0.0206458978,
-0.0256197993,
-0.0110039087,
0.032369528,
-0.0448797829,
0.0227158349,
-0.0808621719,
0.058959052,
-0.0098463558,
0.0305075664,
0.0252322778,
-0.0025289045,
-0.0333536714,
0.0011775086,
-0.007083348,
0.0415593199,
0.0134506673,
0.0225064848,
0.0073242974,
0.0466938876,
0.0076267733,
0.0352280438,
-0.0874272287,
0.0087670218,
0.0045790416,
-0.000650669,
-0.015291078,
0.0288201738,
0.0863197073,
-0.0168083794,
-0.0303808153,
-0.0555709079,
0.0692874715,
0.0185500998,
0.0247355979,
-0.0208950825,
-0.0113188047,
-0.0239145756,
-0.022736799,
0.1118917167,
0.0363779142,
0.0092581837,
-0.000606934,
-0.0365854539,
-0.0531123914,
0.0069083795,
-0.0036024908,
0.0483700782,
0.0108665228,
-0.0285840761,
-0.0541515462,
-0.0143200494,
0.0733895376,
-0.0205188561,
-0.0327809975,
-0.0445376746,
0.0304285735,
0.0246898104,
-0.0453060158,
-0.030632183,
-0.0635325313,
0.0288346279,
-0.0043061292,
-0.0527745225,
-0.0019075733,
-5.883692691e-33,
-0.0111439722,
-0.0405833535,
-0.013471894,
0.0801828057,
0.0147990361,
-0.0043880371,
-0.0241614282,
0.0150702232,
0.0435639322,
0.0010648581,
-0.0633697063,
-0.0066811983,
0.0020886434,
0.0244412981,
0.0253214072,
0.0670186877,
0.0867333338,
0.0064937053,
-0.0435076281,
0.036559917,
0.0500985309,
0.0664997846,
0.0296358932,
-0.0740072057,
0.0475152619,
-0.049942147,
-0.004333816,
-0.0139639778,
-0.0255294777,
0.0496616438,
-0.0040393323,
0.0123421308,
-0.003946017,
-0.0004104949,
-0.0325830951,
0.0120048327,
-0.0626094788,
-0.0427348502,
0.0165649317,
-0.0001638181,
-0.0097872429,
-0.0766766965,
0.0338464379,
-0.014481253,
-0.0509595536,
-0.035417974,
0.0856713355,
0.0189822223,
-0.0437116027,
-0.0453500114,
-0.0167641994,
0.0373355038,
0.0105465511,
0.0220449083,
0.0044491659,
0.0181155503,
-0.0335712954,
0.0201288071,
-0.060728047,
0.0408060476,
0.0206720196,
0.0111912517,
0.012965139,
0.0269229487,
-0.0152282938,
0.0496694595,
0.0195331238,
0.037053749,
0.0315112472,
0.0077049015,
0.0016540391,
0.0220960826,
0.0437529385,
0.0989171714,
0.0030216032,
-0.0006603284,
0.0162664913,
0.0780140236,
0.0616189688,
-0.0528544188,
0.0545930117,
-0.0012942639,
0.0100441873,
-0.0482534207,
-0.0318170115,
-0.0264605954,
0.0006443664,
-0.0208024569,
-0.0106076496,
-0.0110392459,
-0.0668512508,
-0.0456965715,
-0.0020329133,
-0.0052923928,
-0.0420472398,
0.030075863,
-0.0214234032,
0.0400476716,
0.0125067513,
-0.0183322895,
-0.0792124569,
0.0115197627,
-0.0142192356,
-0.0350379534,
0.0224978589,
-0.0079360772,
0.0605640002,
0.0037079717,
-0.0312650502,
-0.0217574742,
0.0127377464,
0.0158070102,
0.0127743743,
0.0655147061,
0.0243254434,
0.0032612209,
-0.0034670047,
0.0392366797,
0.0457945727,
0.0541043319,
-0.0200914871,
-0.0185750034,
0.036673788,
-0.0172036644,
0.0006071393,
-0.0177005343,
-0.0350911245,
0.0117591387,
0.0636942834,
-0.0175484475,
-0.0033440257,
-0.0486230031,
2.586e-7,
0.042646192,
0.064735055,
-0.0015312803,
-0.0056143836,
0.0306387916,
0.0505072847,
-0.0042011603,
0.0419865474,
0.0155548863,
0.0375249423,
-0.0001446271,
0.012330329,
0.0390872918,
0.0319769122,
-0.0759042129,
-0.0271672532,
-0.0562549941,
0.0346792042,
-0.0600748584,
-0.0215413775,
-0.0082207499,
-0.0063758721,
0.0483977571,
-0.0209033564,
0.0026230449,
0.0038197255,
0.0688050911,
-0.0489511564,
-0.0216719341,
0.0386824273,
0.0372055285,
-0.0150303217,
-0.0051835477,
-0.0034655333,
-0.0241838954,
-0.0173258726,
-0.0191456266,
0.0851289257,
-0.0202649795,
-0.0305962134,
0.0592689887,
0.0302530956,
-0.0210647415,
0.0013564193,
0.0361514539,
0.0245265607,
-0.0172279105,
-0.0376694612,
0.0136667229,
-0.0124884453,
0.0520494208,
-0.0211806837,
0.0103850123,
0.0196337979,
-0.0001449227,
-0.0196772944,
-0.0435103141,
-0.0455526188,
-0.0442479178,
0.0046580858,
-0.0354775041,
-0.0203131028,
-0.0410265364,
0.006569949,
-0.0011084445,
-0.0703082457,
0.0126853762,
2.317639789e-34,
0.0222193953,
0.0483998172,
0.0078062089,
-0.0248003304,
0.0120617105,
0.0023721927,
-0.0252006929,
0.0159162562,
0.0665460527,
-0.0641014501,
-0.028641941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14267v1 | On the Evaluation Practices in Multilingual NLP: Can Machine Translation Offer an Alternative to Human Translations? | 2024-06-20T12:46:12 | 2024-06-20T12:46:12 | Rochelle Choenni, Sara Rajaee, Christof Monz, Ekaterina Shutova | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While multilingual language models (MLMs) have been trained on 100+
languages, they are typically only evaluated across a handful of them due to a
lack of available test data in most languages. This is particularly problematic
when assessing MLM's potential for low-resource and unseen languages. In this
paper, we present an analysis of existing evaluation frameworks in multilingual
NLP, discuss their limitations, and propose several directions for more robust
and reliable evaluation practices. Furthermore, we empirically study to what
extent machine translation offers a {reliable alternative to human translation}
for large-scale evaluation of MLMs across a wide set of languages. We use a
SOTA translation model to translate test data from 4 tasks to 198 languages and
use them to evaluate three MLMs. We show that while the selected subsets of
high-resource test languages are generally sufficiently representative of a
wider range of high-resource languages, we tend to overestimate MLMs' ability
on low-resource languages. Finally, we show that simpler baselines can achieve
relatively strong performance without having benefited from large-scale
multilingual pretraining. | [
0.0176082533,
0.0548509881,
0.002569305,
0.0647380725,
-0.0383269154,
0.0181701463,
0.0492446236,
0.0042105261,
-0.0074488963,
-0.0417667069,
-0.0834342688,
-0.054211583,
0.006816206,
-0.0227208063,
0.0339788385,
-0.0491679013,
0.0045191944,
-0.0096117398,
-0.0235225167,
0.0173324626,
-0.0066221245,
0.0134759182,
0.0203901324,
0.044310566,
-0.0062908018,
-0.0009621301,
0.0490470827,
0.0187282972,
0.034789715,
-0.0252022762,
-0.0212255288,
0.0202951506,
0.0018055874,
0.0338425748,
0.0000018497,
-0.0459975787,
-0.0024826375,
0.0207825899,
-0.0050453758,
0.006783423,
0.0528011099,
-0.0930474997,
-0.0075485362,
0.0071542496,
-0.0358712003,
-0.0102027236,
0.038371928,
0.0017078293,
0.0505604446,
0.0767671987,
-0.0113639627,
-0.0297615714,
0.0142189944,
-0.0371454768,
-0.0230291504,
-0.0680535212,
-0.0268324297,
0.0154815204,
-0.0288431533,
0.0009926445,
0.0032748631,
0.0556931458,
0.019119041,
0.0144337593,
-0.0344045237,
0.0130538037,
-0.0242053531,
-0.047990758,
-0.0295127574,
0.0716340095,
-0.070861809,
-0.0090727946,
-0.0457327813,
-0.014449507,
-0.0356761031,
-0.0213183332,
-0.024085328,
0.0384204574,
0.0139083099,
0.011231035,
0.0335540064,
0.0483816899,
0.0421749726,
0.0153840324,
-0.0072715874,
0.0193058029,
0.0320725106,
-0.0352696776,
0.0336068049,
0.0381766818,
-0.0061464449,
-0.0032085399,
0.0129567962,
0.0043866243,
-0.0393270403,
0.0300950799,
-0.0189563725,
-0.0404176861,
0.0233378448,
-0.0786414295,
0.0638203546,
0.0456604771,
-0.0226643272,
0.0632526651,
-0.047882814,
0.0789859742,
-0.0107740164,
0.0171580743,
-0.0670594722,
-0.0349277742,
-0.0318202563,
0.0261099041,
-0.0236792509,
-0.0002217318,
-0.0455286615,
-0.0073368563,
-0.0206200443,
0.0015995123,
-0.0041118693,
-0.0002976272,
0.0149645489,
-0.0297901388,
-0.0287466384,
-0.0085858377,
0.0004811742,
0.0459545776,
-0.0309651531,
-0.0191145372,
-0.0190362968,
-0.0637961701,
0.005464186,
0.0278243311,
-0.0348467194,
-0.0394990519,
0.031348981,
0.1206494197,
-0.0031749068,
-0.0358239226,
-0.0070853597,
0.0068322187,
-0.0235161725,
-0.0889578611,
-0.0101765739,
-0.050595507,
0.0824864879,
0.0170993693,
0.0531540588,
-0.0079607824,
-0.008235747,
0.0135250911,
-0.0155105675,
0.0715351105,
0.0347250141,
0.0212239381,
0.0044566663,
-0.0216007307,
-0.0246161129,
0.0879137665,
0.0370681062,
0.0127455527,
0.0554250143,
0.0047224448,
0.0003482249,
0.0758791715,
-0.0130897397,
0.0314049684,
0.0025083581,
0.0211011861,
-0.0069742906,
0.0423338562,
0.0208495781,
0.0616095141,
-0.0252713691,
0.0250877719,
0.0351905189,
0.0361126661,
0.0102013405,
0.0210440811,
0.0776134953,
-0.0015859841,
-0.0034055628,
-0.0075838901,
-0.032799542,
0.0082028909,
-0.0166352019,
-0.0112496456,
0.0233161394,
0.0435401015,
-0.004530774,
-0.029127717,
-0.034837313,
-0.0319541506,
0.0204820987,
0.0037839687,
0.0330900662,
0.0114973588,
-0.0235722996,
0.0455794036,
0.0000678129,
-0.0507335775,
0.0360257849,
-0.0297137592,
-0.0396276303,
0.0679249242,
0.052699592,
0.0064878287,
-0.0173122492,
-0.0005094555,
-0.0025639639,
0.0523864292,
0.0956263617,
0.0018751839,
0.0518846288,
-0.0351588875,
0.0088305539,
-0.015807189,
0.0173608176,
0.0480145402,
0.0187101811,
0.0314055867,
0.0274658259,
-0.0632708743,
-0.1087834463,
0.0487919003,
-0.0339423865,
-0.0070141144,
0.0176756419,
0.0171770342,
0.0079947589,
0.0236566216,
-0.0069613708,
0.0070023979,
0.0103774145,
-0.0473158769,
-0.0104763201,
0.023932131,
-0.0177766643,
-0.042599678,
0.0276175346,
-0.0289952774,
-0.0299580228,
0.0240918007,
-0.0334659778,
-0.0331289507,
-0.003202928,
-0.0268375408,
-0.0176928472,
-0.0302769486,
0.0215277001,
-0.0050463877,
0.0133625027,
-0.048364602,
0.0380587801,
0.0165094119,
0.0378679112,
0.0068779397,
-0.0168712419,
0.0439215042,
-0.0223454274,
-0.0512153693,
0.0600524433,
0.0052070059,
0.0285616964,
0.0348484963,
0.058963608,
-0.0476035923,
-0.0378136002,
-0.0928341001,
0.0216901004,
-0.0361035466,
0.0448889136,
0.0443831086,
0.0043473104,
0.0079787616,
-0.0019819173,
-0.036183551,
-0.013285988,
0.0375670381,
0.0341282301,
0.0103838015,
-0.017450003,
0.0316413045,
-0.024548145,
-0.000031999,
0.0226774663,
0.0664824992,
0.0013960307,
-0.0181520805,
-0.0488911308,
0.0035060765,
-0.0489774644,
-0.0176759139,
0.0103595378,
-0.0384834968,
0.0145363575,
0.0039683953,
0.0279660057,
0.0427229181,
-0.0238126852,
0.0128176911,
0.0441035703,
0.0143699823,
-0.0608152263,
0.0015464651,
0.0003865226,
-0.054615166,
-0.0291595832,
-0.0365308411,
0.0081347087,
0.0264614467,
0.0001659768,
-0.0070096781,
-0.0592405386,
-0.0167426933,
-0.0777292922,
-0.0406079926,
-0.0279689785,
0.0284673423,
0.0085325371,
0.0418747105,
-0.0296655446,
-0.0493566468,
0.0773248449,
-0.0338346623,
-0.0249738581,
-0.045234032,
0.0050355471,
-0.0584129989,
0.0802834183,
-0.0355119631,
0.03398671,
-0.0567334965,
-0.0074808174,
-0.0125542888,
0.0141170807,
0.0036116,
-0.0341305509,
0.0405132212,
-0.0803281367,
-0.0060572363,
-0.0187183153,
-0.0310193561,
-0.0097909672,
-0.0037064319,
-0.0190425627,
0.0152913118,
-0.0026550156,
0.0153803164,
-0.0305124559,
0.0245337728,
0.0354646295,
0.0267045312,
0.0068499325,
-0.0018019332,
0.0049339901,
0.011038552,
-0.005295408,
0.0048774192,
0.0044106632,
-0.0398964174,
0.0322057381,
-0.0037089598,
0.0128559209,
-0.0085459901,
-0.0338278525,
-0.0080198031,
0.0368448347,
-0.0054340544,
-0.0361645706,
-0.0238727648,
0.0650133938,
-0.0370908827,
0.0023366043,
0.0919293165,
0.0263314862,
-0.0474469662,
-0.0056725778,
0.0041745459,
-0.0095105292,
0.0035503046,
0.0303666368,
-0.0914863124,
-0.0337579399,
-0.0174073055,
0.0236918572,
0.047903236,
0.0103469547,
-0.0129676936,
-0.0885374695,
-0.013323091,
0.0099253086,
-0.0718879327,
-0.035904631,
-0.0351157933,
-0.0306621548,
-0.0620065555,
0.0333006419,
-0.0286835898,
0.0245029517,
-0.0039281892,
0.0060389009,
0.0011797895,
-0.0840698034,
0.0461789258,
-0.0534482747,
0.015825754,
0.0572296418,
0.0691402704,
-0.0053338949,
-0.0049363314,
0.027209077,
-0.0132974843,
0.0119221462,
-0.0015904846,
0.0185371395,
0.0115395235,
-0.0227481313,
0.0480838828,
-0.0388003998,
-0.046295587,
0.0269997437,
0.0023467822,
0.0508167371,
-0.0020397899,
-0.0153475674,
0.0226907637,
-0.0429456234,
0.0016592453,
0.0593451336,
0.0029791188,
-0.0359114781,
-0.0171706714,
-0.0153539646,
-0.0118706496,
-0.0698709786,
-0.0200317372,
0.0089006834,
-0.0389366224,
-0.0088761169,
-0.0828571171,
-0.0921052769,
0.0037875411,
0.0108465385,
0.0282258503,
-0.0028163788,
-0.0099944575,
-0.0014259369,
0.0067009893,
0.0564558692,
-0.0406250618,
0.0412529595,
-0.0407834016,
-0.0078181429,
0.0499485135,
-0.0079935705,
0.020698484,
0.0285035744,
-0.0604722612,
-0.060697224,
-0.0621415377,
0.0709024966,
0.0185220744,
0.0174604785,
-0.0590080619,
-0.0386502147,
-0.0091415206,
-0.0089158751,
-0.0390069634,
-0.0054606651,
0.0306010582,
0.0212482717,
-0.0084955106,
0.0560299493,
-0.0173402932,
0.0124012129,
-0.0059194909,
0.0770653114,
-0.0047428431,
-0.046378579,
0.0165289026,
0.032180503,
0.0206474867,
-0.0776680335,
-0.0479813889,
-0.0050365576,
-0.022604702,
-0.0221231654,
-0.032303866,
-0.0445592105,
-0.0115755098,
0.0577859953,
0.0282465369,
-0.01371843,
0.0058621843,
-0.0046940478,
-0.0198903475,
-0.0109570259,
0.0089025954,
0.0008091141,
-0.0076104417,
-0.0027152952,
0.0491320714,
-0.0289762709,
-0.0049683158,
-0.0307031982,
0.0157811008,
-0.0402682796,
0.0168302637,
0.0027930615,
0.0090794377,
0.03188131,
0.0556537919,
-0.0195021424,
-0.00992388,
-0.0157164279,
-0.0019858633,
0.1038831249,
-0.0059220791,
0.1395216137,
-0.0027904166,
-0.0122622252,
-0.0168282595,
0.0395763069,
0.0081703914,
-0.0382442176,
-0.0068039657,
-0.0028406726,
-0.0018387636,
-0.0036449793,
0.0832343623,
-0.0148250768,
0.0209521838,
-0.0144650145,
-0.0005625802,
-0.0248638447,
-0.007508676,
-0.0117288735,
-0.0245793741,
-0.0220383015,
-0.0007319884,
-0.0384449735,
-0.0548490286,
0.0014226593,
0.0171701983,
0.0087446962,
0.0105617475,
-0.005114424,
0.1069813296,
-0.0084617659,
0.0431169532,
-0.0744664669,
-0.0215203371,
0.0063639707,
-0.0092562446,
-0.0475109182,
-5.890029707e-33,
-0.0071248738,
-0.0198090598,
0.0285992119,
-0.0359652862,
-0.0169484895,
0.027691517,
-0.0278319754,
0.0222038217,
-0.0302270893,
0.0047637713,
-0.0002549587,
-0.0502496809,
0.014626829,
-0.0007876772,
0.0288047623,
-0.0214966964,
0.0044727731,
0.0005823719,
-0.0410810299,
-0.0189586878,
0.0201859605,
0.0142598357,
0.1283865571,
-0.0477795117,
0.074178651,
0.0080455253,
-0.0287155714,
-0.0154563449,
0.0022376068,
0.0484053642,
-0.0154204648,
0.0357409604,
0.0452391356,
-0.0363015682,
0.0014571178,
-0.0418404415,
-0.0473333672,
-0.0111479005,
0.0332526527,
0.0453726128,
-0.0209927913,
-0.0150590762,
0.0290698186,
-0.0346822515,
-0.030162802,
0.0319397934,
0.0042322264,
-0.0456058644,
-0.0217104405,
-0.0075010611,
-0.0767669305,
0.0234137289,
0.0142056271,
-0.0215727929,
0.0351484567,
0.0708609149,
-0.045718655,
0.0082501611,
-0.058318723,
0.0166414473,
-0.0336375646,
0.0102832429,
0.0767755359,
0.0006195757,
-0.0283525623,
0.0272701029,
0.0033827841,
-0.0002467851,
0.0317164734,
0.0035259528,
0.0429721735,
0.0024489034,
0.0789776668,
0.0708765909,
0.0181916635,
0.0276794359,
-0.0360233486,
0.0483473614,
0.0081530567,
0.0056057177,
0.0083224373,
0.0020055582,
-0.0086051831,
-0.0038186018,
-0.073886849,
-0.0191714615,
-0.0432273149,
-0.0293385629,
0.0354986303,
0.0130497357,
-0.0187309366,
0.0206188671,
0.0514103286,
-0.0133545846,
-0.0278544109,
0.0116981482,
-0.0043364149,
0.008602459,
-0.0096027749,
0.0326780081,
-0.0346801504,
-0.0443802774,
-0.0022237913,
0.0224760268,
0.0155198229,
-0.0492539033,
0.0687102973,
0.0252004135,
-0.036878217,
0.0167231094,
-0.0511986017,
-0.0154088242,
-0.0118712215,
0.0448106751,
0.0330053829,
-0.013720504,
-0.0300554782,
0.0365843326,
0.0276543237,
-0.0088478019,
-0.0301153418,
-0.010377395,
0.0232332852,
0.0189278927,
-0.0426101312,
0.0317762829,
-0.0367203653,
-0.0270892046,
0.0121660484,
-0.018235188,
-0.0189356077,
0.002658308,
2.541e-7,
0.0646301955,
0.0400804617,
-0.0090549411,
0.047914844,
-0.0032309904,
0.0097449524,
-0.0497613177,
0.0275934879,
-0.0098534534,
0.0427498929,
-0.0068184761,
0.0330814347,
0.0942638665,
0.0297126938,
-0.0513317212,
-0.039063707,
-0.0309265126,
0.0278446358,
-0.0403427407,
-0.0061976919,
0.0267692395,
0.0886026323,
-0.0028819584,
0.0109503157,
-0.0341835506,
-0.0474577881,
0.0817932039,
-0.0285846014,
-0.048094295,
-0.0078456253,
0.0408590958,
0.0586597919,
-0.0216492601,
0.0115009993,
-0.041964978,
-0.0081366235,
0.0724996403,
0.0705163777,
0.0098668616,
-0.0500447638,
0.0176927,
-0.0389801189,
-0.0231914986,
-0.0435369015,
0.052917473,
-0.0034263143,
-0.009659173,
0.0006263804,
-0.0069664698,
0.0306588151,
0.0755813494,
-0.0527997725,
-0.0419848189,
0.0354085937,
0.0532341413,
-0.02047031,
-0.0542311408,
-0.0259452835,
-0.0489088409,
-0.0068986113,
0.0163587183,
-0.0315310322,
-0.0163390562,
-0.0216882844,
-0.0185302701,
-0.0566894822,
-0.0093659107,
1.787882138e-34,
0.0331592262,
-0.0089160698,
0.0296880826,
-0.0041299076,
0.0360148996,
-0.0089606335,
-0.0143947434,
-0.0000390982,
-0.0380494259,
-0.0238385629,
0.014453277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14230v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14230v1 | Raising the Bar: Investigating the Values of Large Language Models via Generative Evolving Testing | 2024-06-20T11:51:00 | 2024-06-20T11:51:00 | Han Jiang, Xiaoyuan Yi, Zhihua Wei, Shu Wang, Xing Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Warning: this paper contains model outputs exhibiting unethical information.
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved significant breakthroughs, but their
generated unethical content poses potential risks. Measuring value alignment of
LLMs becomes crucial for their regulation and responsible deployment. Numerous
datasets have been constructed to assess social bias, toxicity, and ethics in
LLMs, but they suffer from evaluation chronoeffect, that is, as models rapidly
evolve, existing data becomes leaked or undemanding, overestimating
ever-developing LLMs. To tackle this problem, we propose GETA, a novel
generative evolving testing approach that dynamically probes the underlying
moral baselines of LLMs. Distinct from previous adaptive testing methods that
rely on static datasets with limited difficulty, GETA incorporates an
iteratively-updated item generator which infers each LLM's moral boundaries and
generates difficulty-tailored testing items, accurately reflecting the true
alignment extent. This process theoretically learns a joint distribution of
item and model response, with item difficulty and value conformity as latent
variables, where the generator co-evolves with the LLM, addressing
chronoeffect. We evaluate various popular LLMs with diverse capabilities and
demonstrate that GETA can create difficulty-matching testing items and more
accurately assess LLMs' values, better consistent with their performance on
unseen OOD and i.i.d. items, laying the groundwork for future evaluation
paradigms. | [
0.0415082462,
0.1300135255,
-0.0529999174,
0.0399842858,
-0.0608276874,
0.0022076932,
0.0054643624,
0.0089770947,
0.006640282,
-0.0311110951,
-0.0033188411,
-0.0203313362,
-0.0124262972,
0.038614504,
-0.0026888407,
0.0084897736,
0.0609046519,
0.0092593245,
0.0116350902,
-0.0206532963,
-0.0036080878,
0.0192089193,
0.0275278091,
0.0234556813,
0.0337313414,
-0.0010034215,
0.0103712119,
-0.0080938479,
0.0333140157,
-0.0309868809,
0.0101381177,
0.062541537,
-0.0067175138,
0.0497667789,
0.0000019291,
-0.0767994896,
-0.0178318098,
0.0086548626,
-0.0113912132,
0.0297833793,
0.1009960398,
0.0310381576,
-0.0193520747,
0.0436246581,
-0.0631023124,
-0.0024688065,
0.0252392534,
-0.0221713614,
0.0405273698,
0.0732575282,
0.0012965986,
0.0388440788,
0.0088888276,
-0.0174814761,
0.0025533701,
-0.0474716611,
0.0318159871,
-0.0004936517,
-0.0157960225,
0.013910993,
-0.000549147,
0.0071186544,
0.0124885775,
0.0007210696,
-0.0004793293,
-0.0177673679,
-0.0099403244,
-0.0279193316,
-0.0023688779,
0.0485888347,
-0.0026166651,
-0.0220282711,
0.0109630944,
-0.0162380654,
0.0272405129,
-0.0048559182,
0.0219597686,
0.015721729,
-0.0089514842,
0.0095646502,
0.0528558455,
-0.0119369421,
0.0196811128,
0.033314798,
0.009913872,
0.0417225324,
0.0110097295,
-0.039722126,
-0.0160215162,
-0.0186951235,
-0.0107153347,
-0.0411233529,
0.0024673312,
0.0095130848,
-0.0545918159,
0.0476016104,
-0.0447125323,
0.0094375201,
0.0651936531,
-0.0473804027,
0.0468791015,
0.0260043163,
0.0020710244,
0.0332903937,
0.0087441746,
0.0573477633,
0.0068374421,
0.0058121877,
-0.0671467781,
0.0278466009,
0.0225052778,
-0.0158172529,
0.0202676822,
-0.0112632047,
0.0119345365,
0.0184493568,
-0.0363116451,
0.0282823071,
-0.0505228043,
0.0375613645,
-0.0194784161,
-0.0019842351,
-0.0180985723,
0.0253638439,
-0.0354400165,
-0.022498183,
-0.0428130738,
0.0211796984,
0.001211297,
-0.0135171534,
0.0164341424,
-0.0162280556,
-0.0145619856,
-0.0003551497,
0.0176881757,
0.0945401639,
0.0005853279,
-0.0141528407,
-0.0116422195,
-0.0318640992,
-0.0301638208,
-0.0444256403,
0.0103776734,
-0.0528700687,
0.0062052063,
0.0042415415,
-0.0404336974,
-0.0733736604,
0.0064586485,
0.0175474249,
-0.0412876904,
0.0541138984,
0.0219131708,
0.0204720069,
-0.0105667347,
0.0250511989,
0.0154058086,
0.0832177624,
0.0164258424,
-0.0003985589,
0.0602725893,
-0.026603967,
0.0094996821,
0.0580028668,
0.0238034222,
0.0697749108,
-0.0414698683,
0.0073503088,
-0.0017868141,
0.0257697497,
0.0043994868,
0.0530218109,
0.0045344322,
-0.0440174863,
0.0800806209,
0.0416470282,
-0.008704083,
0.029399544,
0.0142366914,
0.01728555,
-0.0192189422,
0.016473148,
-0.0555315875,
-0.0035028965,
-0.0443902388,
-0.0186193865,
-0.0338710286,
0.0525302365,
0.0061193779,
-0.0541528799,
-0.0204933975,
0.0133163296,
0.0650452301,
0.0317259915,
0.013453491,
0.0057843993,
-0.0389521271,
-0.0355152823,
0.0647423714,
-0.0582844131,
-0.0015195424,
-0.0704188272,
0.0605850555,
0.0911459774,
0.072923176,
-0.0171605423,
-0.038065929,
-0.010675339,
-0.0374285206,
0.0258080028,
0.0478509068,
-0.0279788617,
-0.024122186,
-0.0107034305,
-0.0448174886,
0.0165609512,
0.0085331108,
0.0110502327,
0.016219141,
0.0027096828,
0.0071942182,
-0.0479223281,
-0.0699957833,
0.0522782356,
-0.0422300734,
-0.0020775695,
-0.0043522702,
0.0015122986,
0.0513920076,
-0.0062978179,
-0.0173636489,
-0.0143500129,
0.0205936246,
0.0017619353,
-0.0090555698,
0.0112656374,
-0.0271370467,
0.0285626128,
0.0345043093,
-0.0149126174,
-0.0160069801,
0.033108063,
-0.0289633572,
0.0283803437,
0.0212110784,
-0.0149034234,
0.0064149941,
-0.0373286121,
0.0122878179,
-0.0681964234,
0.0230792034,
-0.0391032584,
0.0373514295,
-0.0335827209,
0.0085276263,
-0.0238049533,
-0.0008555903,
0.0115722837,
0.0046470105,
-0.0335463993,
0.0131588876,
-0.0366700664,
0.036723014,
0.0319142975,
0.0452720821,
-0.0279969741,
-0.0638210922,
-0.0775914192,
0.0031905898,
-0.0208627731,
0.0120639922,
0.0177483633,
-0.0252339486,
-0.0180833805,
0.0419003181,
-0.0425843298,
-0.0090374183,
0.0437502749,
0.0321604609,
0.0062711523,
-0.0331930071,
-0.0376691297,
-0.0346060246,
-0.0019136471,
-0.0519267768,
0.0446100272,
0.0079086963,
0.0611530691,
-0.041177839,
0.0092169177,
-0.0656836331,
-0.0071184263,
-0.0013844869,
-0.0646010712,
0.0323594697,
0.0480551757,
0.0374779627,
0.0876719877,
0.0677027851,
0.039468918,
0.0367161557,
0.0048054005,
-0.0658831373,
-0.0263389461,
-0.0048299539,
-0.0276592989,
-0.0229942407,
-0.0798490793,
-0.0124127045,
0.0562245473,
-0.0039631356,
-0.0076874755,
-0.0571792647,
0.0615630522,
-0.0807241127,
-0.0530865863,
-0.0026560954,
-0.0253610834,
-0.0386821143,
0.0106889047,
-0.0182989612,
-0.0607482158,
0.0820322111,
-0.0065716542,
0.0390100256,
-0.0565221347,
0.003788474,
-0.0189081393,
0.0588774607,
-0.0020575915,
0.0348671153,
0.030032061,
0.0035056877,
-0.0487661548,
0.0029722464,
0.0619436279,
-0.077493459,
0.0469494797,
-0.0430238545,
0.005900369,
0.0130106863,
-0.0496043116,
-0.0485678352,
-0.0464019254,
0.0218786336,
-0.0064325156,
0.0062831366,
-0.009553113,
0.0099967355,
-0.0256194863,
-0.0077759665,
0.0122871203,
-0.0112544456,
0.000708909,
-0.0121320337,
-0.0352357589,
0.0646926686,
-0.0188310631,
0.050358776,
-0.0107202157,
0.0095651001,
0.0265421234,
0.0300646406,
0.0114787966,
-0.0076254173,
0.0410369188,
0.0207514353,
-0.0009804284,
0.0435315557,
0.0329111181,
0.0235264841,
-0.0210545529,
-0.0064380197,
0.0751004517,
0.0310633406,
-0.0361192301,
0.0455988497,
-0.0105558196,
0.0148145724,
0.0480048247,
0.0284146313,
-0.1038713679,
0.0074554817,
0.0048440029,
0.0567561835,
-0.0810038596,
-0.0596031509,
0.0033381728,
-0.128250733,
0.0309897605,
0.0007552918,
-0.0321470425,
0.024592381,
-0.0221230853,
0.0016050965,
-0.0254338048,
0.082796827,
0.0144113544,
0.0041483324,
-0.0331575386,
-0.0058982079,
-0.0073067774,
-0.040533822,
0.0801069736,
-0.0422901325,
0.1085472107,
0.0821640119,
0.0216971561,
-0.0391018428,
-0.0260377545,
0.0212765448,
0.0057369093,
-0.0404221937,
0.0131334737,
-0.0016048694,
-0.0020967701,
-0.0259900652,
-0.022913035,
0.029647598,
0.0046171532,
-0.0059386501,
0.0065174699,
0.0497129522,
0.0329494737,
-0.0445599183,
-0.0315623842,
0.0018400577,
0.0241549928,
0.0802020729,
0.0035379145,
-0.0893378556,
0.0228491854,
-0.041998852,
-0.029088039,
-0.0199214518,
-0.069529295,
0.0070411419,
-0.0038501837,
-0.0057314001,
-0.0910879374,
-0.0482606441,
-0.0142591875,
0.0108380765,
0.0329700261,
-0.0575182885,
0.0076696486,
-0.0246516019,
-0.032806322,
0.0103842998,
-0.006901118,
0.0070246239,
-0.0345457718,
0.0060078641,
-0.0045596543,
-0.0182326343,
-0.0229273289,
0.0322526284,
-0.0424424745,
-0.0724912807,
0.0669867918,
0.0404441021,
0.0214209501,
0.0185959823,
-0.0194135252,
-0.0320310518,
0.0444381423,
0.0312379207,
-0.0245055445,
0.0474597514,
0.0331564285,
-0.0077696,
0.0061783441,
0.0272539034,
-0.0453550592,
0.0235986058,
0.0348110832,
0.0181573145,
-0.0068888329,
-0.0235178266,
0.0295155216,
0.0155769587,
-0.0027561462,
-0.0339027792,
-0.0282823481,
-0.0355442278,
-0.0090515465,
-0.0243712869,
-0.063706696,
-0.0159794185,
-0.0077525419,
0.0140117332,
-0.0027416477,
-0.0159165431,
0.018364476,
-0.0456593148,
0.0577438883,
-0.052701287,
0.005439118,
-0.0083353436,
0.0248788465,
0.0246315189,
0.0034075393,
-0.0199527722,
0.0231469739,
-0.0243346058,
0.04988667,
0.0021399665,
0.069817543,
0.0077576176,
0.0096452851,
-0.0012243707,
0.0329466052,
-0.0171906445,
-0.0098872315,
-0.03330357,
0.0309899859,
-0.0065438896,
0.0290042963,
0.0512983911,
-0.0221386589,
0.0130307032,
-0.0187699236,
-0.0270179827,
-0.0443381071,
-0.0695692599,
0.0219572112,
0.0183736421,
-0.0280242525,
0.0221156329,
0.054862462,
0.0094376178,
0.0340420976,
-0.0096696001,
0.0071095387,
-0.0208288524,
-0.0396815427,
0.0332688428,
-0.0371885747,
-0.0390940942,
-0.0290669128,
-0.0793283731,
-0.0720827878,
-0.018539127,
0.032125935,
0.0202264152,
-0.0315645337,
-0.0247706603,
0.0972791687,
-0.0435675234,
0.0227149185,
-0.0320807584,
-0.042482391,
-0.0321526974,
-0.0173376761,
-0.0156364795,
-6.41215638e-33,
0.0023888745,
-0.0253392458,
0.0028921983,
-0.0469362848,
-0.0128816608,
0.0002955612,
-0.0164164938,
0.0383514389,
-0.0426056646,
-0.0087300586,
-0.0128683513,
0.0026603569,
0.0038654171,
-0.0059452793,
0.0099978559,
-0.040485967,
0.0058975215,
-0.0202507488,
-0.0600940585,
0.0181067698,
-0.003713751,
-0.0319563039,
0.0399789661,
-0.0556033887,
0.051362019,
0.0224983543,
-0.0303810108,
0.0222585741,
-0.0431228951,
0.0496343039,
0.006925466,
0.0698869228,
0.0164310392,
-0.0055606542,
0.0177465994,
-0.0188381597,
-0.0219774358,
-0.0056161606,
0.0350514874,
-0.0132998172,
-0.0101632532,
-0.0191797558,
0.051836364,
-0.0092797661,
-0.0482303947,
0.0088188024,
0.0239884406,
-0.0223414972,
-0.0082920706,
-0.0160658639,
-0.0697966218,
0.0103574134,
-0.0375508964,
-0.0151325697,
-0.0602429546,
0.0248339735,
0.0142166158,
0.0044172006,
-0.03559874,
0.0245698001,
-0.0036091851,
0.0044456976,
0.0596467443,
-0.0058211959,
0.0175375715,
0.0669347569,
-0.0075936634,
0.0639069304,
0.0100905756,
-0.0353017785,
0.085142687,
0.0043810583,
0.0462817177,
0.0728595182,
0.0038587456,
-0.0619558878,
-0.0241816416,
0.0052468344,
0.0544011742,
-0.0019508956,
0.0460476689,
-0.0004986293,
-0.0691716149,
-0.0259397831,
-0.0468664207,
-0.0287425723,
-0.0348318443,
-0.0290741287,
0.0501962528,
-0.0001685749,
-0.0746783912,
-0.0257995743,
0.0324098989,
-0.0448790342,
-0.0051451698,
0.0013831573,
-0.0463382788,
0.0027871234,
-0.0073873615,
0.0439173952,
-0.0476425029,
-0.0191988964,
0.0082432367,
-0.0126114627,
0.032868769,
0.0045689265,
0.0159125216,
0.0122060711,
-0.0544755012,
0.0303740222,
-0.0194146466,
0.0482151061,
-0.0067555453,
-0.009515902,
0.0352550372,
0.0036937848,
0.0193624441,
-0.0035830224,
0.0890440941,
-0.0008145926,
-0.0876359344,
0.039576795,
-0.0102784475,
0.0230257995,
-0.0286044385,
-0.006474467,
-0.0290635973,
0.0409350246,
0.0295236185,
-0.0501806103,
-0.0128968265,
0.0215078425,
2.672e-7,
0.0049055265,
0.0564644858,
-0.0266561378,
0.0202994831,
-0.0028225696,
0.0579013862,
0.0011328043,
0.0527129434,
0.0516291149,
-0.0250875968,
0.0196543299,
0.0206150338,
0.0473362468,
0.055497136,
-0.0290251579,
0.0042714905,
-0.0838784277,
-0.0039679711,
-0.0646110028,
0.0047977851,
0.018518893,
0.0752465427,
0.034026932,
0.0011579776,
-0.0025512765,
-0.04706496,
0.0296302289,
-0.0386019424,
-0.0222712923,
0.0268894378,
-0.0200647824,
0.0048205224,
0.0064523406,
-0.0039760312,
-0.006052712,
0.026337279,
-0.0189631991,
0.0460227914,
0.00233435,
-0.025233686,
-0.025517026,
-0.0571477972,
0.0032251682,
-0.0678578466,
0.0823535621,
-0.0102964863,
-0.0098819071,
-0.0638351291,
-0.0150109269,
-0.0398054495,
0.0223193821,
-0.0396863595,
-0.0343917422,
0.0335275866,
0.0100201061,
0.0283969268,
0.0061411234,
-0.0496705547,
-0.0071573672,
-0.0197164956,
-0.0167499948,
-0.0780079439,
0.0005407563,
0.0387375131,
-0.0105258068,
-0.0501899943,
0.0451770313,
2.717614599e-34,
0.0255444031,
-0.0196917821,
0.0281704906,
-0.0276261475,
0.0545978248,
0.041425705,
-0.0041896533,
0.025635561,
0.0048827087,
-0.032603845,
0.0016371246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14213v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14213v1 | Complexity of Symbolic Representation in Working Memory of Transformer Correlates with the Complexity of a Task | 2024-06-20T11:27:29 | 2024-06-20T11:27:29 | Alsu Sagirova, Mikhail Burtsev | cs.CL | cs.CL | Even though Transformers are extensively used for Natural Language Processing
tasks, especially for machine translation, they lack an explicit memory to
store key concepts of processed texts. This paper explores the properties of
the content of symbolic working memory added to the Transformer model decoder.
Such working memory enhances the quality of model predictions in machine
translation task and works as a neural-symbolic representation of information
that is important for the model to make correct translations. The study of
memory content revealed that translated text keywords are stored in the working
memory, pointing to the relevance of memory content to the processed text.
Also, the diversity of tokens and parts of speech stored in memory correlates
with the complexity of the corpora for machine translation task. | [
0.0249226317,
-0.0507235415,
-0.0424781516,
0.0135466838,
-0.0152357882,
0.0401605479,
-0.0115743354,
0.0084154084,
-0.0562537648,
-0.0300193392,
-0.0319118984,
-0.0410939492,
0.039123971,
-0.0290942378,
0.0370091908,
-0.0545061566,
0.0278039444,
-0.019844396,
-0.0047673155,
0.0124353264,
-0.0473202206,
-0.0036489645,
0.0105291074,
0.0306116845,
-0.0225905869,
-0.0039785658,
-0.0052077407,
-0.0188113097,
0.017669946,
-0.0004417454,
-0.0595427863,
0.012131609,
0.0054408824,
0.047673177,
0.0000019233,
-0.0451992825,
-0.0055571669,
0.0123483101,
0.0040157265,
-0.0268814005,
0.0617545359,
-0.0505560376,
-0.0181006454,
0.0501041636,
0.0060567893,
-0.0111738276,
0.0784335956,
0.0478725508,
0.0122687761,
0.0408842973,
-0.0158657394,
-0.03320444,
0.0149225341,
0.022963427,
-0.0114580002,
-0.0097061051,
-0.0085236626,
-0.0245626252,
-0.065732941,
0.0086949319,
-0.0376330949,
0.0580745861,
0.0296786837,
0.0454473943,
-0.0466199666,
0.001149187,
-0.0154654328,
-0.0250539277,
-0.0156788453,
-0.0072100498,
-0.0252934005,
-0.0208178815,
-0.0319537111,
0.0110730072,
0.0116681643,
-0.0093214838,
-0.0268610027,
0.0725874081,
-0.0437263548,
-0.0044009928,
0.0301640909,
0.0266836248,
-0.0040473994,
-0.046469111,
-0.0598387085,
-0.0105132852,
0.0008327467,
-0.0401651226,
0.0194269624,
-0.0168855321,
-0.0195254385,
-0.0135565968,
0.0502910502,
0.0377384946,
0.0359244719,
0.0228981525,
-0.0123709859,
-0.0799744353,
-0.0172060058,
-0.1154661998,
0.0114210844,
0.0702900216,
0.0006899353,
-0.0081669679,
-0.0168690048,
0.1049097404,
-0.0437166579,
0.0497841351,
-0.0769871026,
-0.036887344,
-0.0564717352,
-0.0251126699,
-0.074347198,
0.0234755371,
0.0064056953,
-0.0044718264,
-0.0041479203,
0.0256281458,
0.0571452081,
-0.0322116986,
0.0139168929,
-0.0029507566,
-0.0511332564,
0.0455144159,
-0.0410134457,
0.0596989952,
-0.0184487179,
-0.0564249158,
-0.0218648911,
-0.0264309347,
-0.0004657003,
-0.0104943002,
0.0039686733,
-0.0478491671,
-0.003653331,
0.0760692582,
-0.0055718487,
-0.0373784229,
-0.0221032798,
0.0037106585,
0.0320584401,
-0.0657004267,
0.0270063877,
-0.0254970584,
0.0335118212,
0.058854077,
-0.0019466616,
-0.0005689216,
-0.0049079452,
0.0320474505,
0.0191436745,
0.0151595501,
0.0286183525,
-0.0192548651,
0.0487966798,
-0.0129499054,
-0.0056559695,
0.037578918,
0.0547055267,
0.0381001271,
-0.0108204726,
-0.057999026,
-0.0139222117,
0.0248912126,
-0.0302433502,
-0.0532849804,
-0.0335976444,
-0.0290501434,
0.0141144628,
-0.0056652753,
-0.0053173006,
0.0736108348,
-0.0200516395,
-0.0054353569,
0.0346105546,
0.0603327267,
0.0326663963,
0.0598390847,
0.0110663911,
0.0047580241,
0.0668463558,
0.0314872973,
-0.0142144701,
0.0682332069,
-0.007815036,
-0.0165895317,
-0.0658621117,
0.046340283,
-0.0030906231,
-0.0239453632,
-0.0148231704,
0.0094933743,
0.0387585945,
-0.0572542623,
0.0396408141,
0.0123530868,
-0.0958852619,
0.1190664172,
-0.0330731794,
-0.0095652556,
-0.0495760739,
-0.0103248833,
-0.0244254582,
0.0356539488,
0.0057836403,
0.0188279636,
-0.0031806233,
-0.03437379,
-0.0373082235,
0.0174809508,
-0.0040796711,
0.0346215703,
-0.01313427,
-0.0276869293,
0.0022578414,
0.0238495711,
0.0064404001,
0.0241722446,
-0.0111655565,
0.0121810371,
0.0311038215,
0.0012057569,
-0.0461927466,
0.0046979561,
-0.0054262965,
-0.0584265366,
-0.0175119806,
0.0291436799,
0.0065557295,
0.002909184,
-0.008294397,
0.0078353276,
0.0133272028,
-0.0631517023,
-0.008670656,
0.0796139687,
-0.0594516397,
0.055394806,
0.0194970109,
-0.054418914,
0.0351513326,
0.0438489355,
0.0266829096,
-0.0473416783,
0.0145083843,
-0.0995184854,
0.0426203161,
-0.0069298223,
0.0585834719,
-0.0282301139,
0.0169730838,
-0.027247142,
0.059053041,
-0.0262734145,
0.0241537523,
0.0057319524,
-0.0047204094,
0.0361748748,
-0.0015112367,
-0.0373280719,
0.0483480468,
-0.0296709873,
-0.0036872639,
0.0255175829,
-0.0674903095,
0.0018710706,
-0.0414453484,
-0.0304659307,
-0.0210750941,
0.0010240432,
0.0332300626,
0.0123611921,
0.000176172,
0.026127968,
0.0355280116,
0.0044459365,
0.0561706312,
-0.0130870128,
0.0154478895,
0.0095062265,
-0.0003290472,
-0.0092075756,
-0.0121248355,
-0.022140054,
-0.0133050708,
0.0829599947,
0.0437773839,
-0.0548559465,
-0.062520735,
0.0532660261,
0.0294084605,
-0.0085863415,
-0.0112427659,
-0.0889934152,
0.0253031198,
0.0358094536,
0.078262195,
0.02417822,
0.0294585954,
-0.0019094725,
0.0465817675,
-0.0226111542,
-0.0165028013,
-0.0003681217,
-0.0329889953,
-0.0224197619,
-0.0615318641,
-0.0493440181,
-0.0065269079,
0.1154928058,
0.0388804935,
0.0288096983,
-0.0557035096,
-0.0308798458,
-0.0341040678,
-0.0099750068,
0.010168043,
-0.0000909815,
-0.0331098475,
0.0318844058,
-0.0189342164,
-0.0324229226,
0.025586674,
-0.0020861141,
0.0155897262,
-0.0534447469,
0.0234414935,
-0.0133716278,
0.0700857714,
-0.0021036821,
0.020732902,
0.0086904364,
-0.0365203843,
-0.0291220695,
-0.0062778029,
-0.0196312517,
-0.0472449623,
0.0102417516,
-0.0210050456,
-0.0544205382,
-0.0209365785,
0.0159028694,
-0.0296399482,
0.0720186532,
-0.0239384007,
0.0063113985,
0.0852513611,
-0.0257559009,
-0.0382102057,
0.0098793283,
0.061671745,
0.0344772339,
0.0082509406,
-0.0294735208,
-0.0046753841,
-0.0108762626,
-0.0142472032,
0.0170537159,
0.051592499,
-0.0298007242,
0.0403926112,
0.0141723547,
-0.0062864693,
-0.0050395261,
-0.0269027874,
-0.042114336,
0.0378189348,
-0.0155852977,
-0.0210240427,
0.0335671119,
-0.0177941211,
-0.0397104099,
-0.0344308838,
0.095550321,
0.0592314526,
-0.0569942482,
0.0171707552,
-0.041103337,
-0.055518128,
0.0463613421,
0.0387617499,
-0.0451539755,
0.0234973524,
0.004498966,
-0.0240267236,
-0.0235209391,
0.0083523775,
-0.0119542526,
-0.0587344468,
-0.0064694299,
-0.0107522532,
-0.0644620433,
-0.0503867902,
-0.0158172585,
-0.0675279945,
-0.0040333718,
0.0112258857,
0.0157512873,
-0.019801043,
-0.0216412861,
0.0645738915,
-0.0076406971,
-0.027299026,
-0.0227322597,
-0.0360876657,
-0.0339333266,
0.0442532264,
0.023917539,
-0.0428317636,
-0.0536473393,
-0.0114747761,
0.0127088483,
0.0414509214,
-0.0250296276,
0.0319003202,
0.045400992,
-0.0368944965,
-0.0572528802,
-0.0444384404,
-0.0217942204,
-0.0130619332,
-0.0233357251,
0.042370677,
-0.0286499001,
0.0070301006,
0.0430778712,
-0.0252319798,
-0.052315712,
0.0429206826,
0.0098581621,
-0.0331312753,
-0.0070459326,
-0.0310170744,
0.0247350726,
-0.0083761467,
-0.0528403409,
0.0178867988,
0.0145822605,
-0.060183987,
-0.072740376,
-0.0062915306,
0.0300069861,
0.0434001796,
0.0374619104,
-0.0081360769,
0.0239603911,
-0.0167376492,
-0.0748908222,
0.0137600405,
0.0073675574,
0.0327705331,
-0.0550996028,
-0.0139785986,
0.0038693082,
-0.0426042341,
-0.0070207031,
0.0001410443,
-0.1131403446,
-0.010390494,
0.0334191732,
0.0413269885,
0.0218965914,
-0.0251693763,
0.018652508,
-0.0357379057,
0.0058123395,
0.0039818087,
-0.0250832215,
0.0277739987,
0.0321294628,
0.0043810871,
0.008567635,
-0.0041930676,
0.0122685591,
-0.0160942413,
0.0029664582,
0.0135173136,
-0.003737885,
0.0156094711,
0.0345809273,
0.0239783321,
0.006852068,
0.0095527284,
-0.0152285798,
-0.0139498301,
0.0262518656,
0.0020672441,
0.0188354142,
-0.0284027532,
-0.0168923177,
0.0400865339,
0.0241397768,
-0.0179944374,
0.0074877688,
0.0198222902,
-0.0385752432,
0.059756726,
0.0210265853,
-0.0014239735,
0.0236301422,
0.0073736133,
0.0557416193,
-0.0170134101,
-0.0266826414,
0.0112400595,
0.0202980172,
-0.0130855637,
0.0547510348,
-0.0032008947,
0.0346242711,
-0.0267267339,
0.0126341386,
0.001022335,
-0.0383735858,
0.0185722057,
-0.0320910886,
0.0165898055,
-0.054321032,
0.0183302909,
-0.0435612537,
0.0299376603,
0.0000723465,
-0.025282532,
-0.0316654779,
0.0391957425,
0.0161892157,
-0.0019025976,
0.0322644003,
-0.0640210211,
0.0640042573,
-0.0287255589,
0.0275373179,
0.0004296322,
-0.0320915021,
-0.0077339951,
-0.0027328739,
-0.0026293274,
-0.0415787473,
-0.0007533953,
-0.02541041,
-0.0631260723,
-0.0440905653,
0.0671551228,
-0.0153608387,
0.0435814857,
-0.0404054374,
0.0336469263,
0.0546499267,
-0.0237967204,
-0.0254020058,
0.0076511423,
-0.0159537457,
0.0497962572,
0.0148037802,
-0.0230780672,
-5.996328927e-33,
-0.0228296965,
-0.0411396921,
0.0412042402,
-0.0201525521,
-0.0077220351,
0.002284382,
-0.0104578184,
-0.019941587,
0.0080642337,
0.0025357376,
-0.0077502062,
0.0150067238,
0.02214857,
-0.016018888,
0.0213426948,
-0.0045464281,
0.0615232587,
0.0095706685,
-0.0090915952,
-0.0082852608,
0.0657614917,
0.0454564355,
0.0921068937,
-0.0438375734,
0.011734779,
0.0241417568,
0.0443163142,
-0.0136633161,
0.0360920243,
0.0286213588,
-0.0085261157,
0.0356128402,
0.0279115103,
-0.0851776749,
-0.0246694088,
0.0089244926,
-0.0708617643,
-0.0336807333,
0.0480807386,
0.064799279,
0.0402249657,
-0.072477527,
0.0398372784,
-0.0390731543,
-0.0033701956,
-0.0187004935,
0.0136135975,
-0.0285272449,
-0.0311709568,
-0.0545855202,
-0.0729368925,
-0.000972516,
0.0009641877,
0.0390666015,
0.0289149247,
0.042443119,
-0.0440870747,
-0.0104349162,
-0.0859993622,
-0.0147403656,
0.021810364,
0.0427578352,
0.0323775969,
0.0410443358,
0.0169870239,
-0.003168005,
0.0315223262,
-0.0107694212,
-0.0234981943,
0.0399435349,
0.053856194,
0.0188380405,
0.0703817606,
-0.0216792542,
0.1036193147,
-0.028541727,
-0.0074112513,
-0.0121179344,
-0.037523903,
0.0802655444,
0.0544583276,
-0.0243125316,
-0.0192299206,
-0.0045701233,
-0.0256014206,
0.046789322,
-0.0185903944,
-0.0205812994,
-0.005687363,
0.0108664539,
-0.0273711532,
-0.0161981266,
0.0506997369,
-0.0219607688,
0.0750524178,
0.0056372825,
0.0127917714,
0.0431074128,
-0.02725536,
0.0008417128,
-0.0335920341,
-0.0470510907,
-0.0055904915,
0.0129633667,
0.0228682533,
0.0081085516,
0.0126062939,
0.0504956134,
-0.0511048697,
0.0016510653,
-0.0414157435,
0.0015635013,
0.0153104747,
0.0096358666,
-0.0059748567,
0.0272982027,
-0.0121003231,
-0.0230862554,
-0.0155025795,
-0.0197974462,
0.0040216902,
0.0399769023,
0.0197531581,
0.0309240501,
-0.0308890995,
-0.0050914236,
-0.0416701324,
0.0652232096,
0.0740733668,
-0.0531968363,
-0.0304292478,
0.0208974667,
2.683e-7,
0.0235560238,
0.0659460649,
0.0364782438,
0.0343491025,
0.0167946164,
-0.0241883807,
0.0197136551,
0.0022779556,
0.0390847176,
-0.0043812743,
0.0073275687,
0.0458324403,
0.0417175777,
0.051820565,
-0.0733546615,
-0.0736223981,
-0.0270445663,
0.0067092967,
-0.0175140351,
0.0502292961,
0.0472841486,
0.1000814289,
-0.0112664131,
-0.0156295802,
-0.0394389406,
-0.0114725446,
0.0517111495,
-0.0353501849,
0.0734963194,
-0.0092853885,
0.0382210538,
0.0262528677,
0.010648218,
0.0069867177,
-0.0123475883,
-0.0074579068,
0.0181744955,
0.0125044426,
0.0054238569,
0.000927138,
0.0418504626,
-0.0431891903,
-0.0516565368,
0.019448055,
0.0113233374,
-0.110894464,
-0.0339574404,
0.0380210094,
0.0143606309,
0.0202785302,
-0.0138857672,
-0.0022400662,
0.0174516179,
0.0267062318,
0.0190653633,
-0.0120504247,
0.031958729,
-0.0332799628,
-0.011011241,
-0.0168150775,
-0.0189842563,
-0.0410471931,
-0.0524765775,
-0.0403928868,
0.0310487114,
-0.001243648,
0.0055195191,
2.221310553e-34,
0.0311892126,
-0.0170384627,
0.0139327813,
0.0476304516,
0.0227065664,
-0.0377017073,
-0.0047555398,
0.0166634452,
-0.0237049088,
-0.0790887251,
-0.0175439063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14197v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14197v1 | On the Representational Capacity of Neural Language Models with Chain-of-Thought Reasoning | 2024-06-20T10:59:02 | 2024-06-20T10:59:02 | Franz Nowak, Anej Svete, Alexandra Butoi, Ryan Cotterell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.FL | The performance of modern language models (LMs) has been improved by
chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning, i.e., the process of generating intermediate
results that guide the model towards a final answer. A possible explanation for
this improvement is that CoT reasoning extends an LM's computational power, as
RNNs and transformers with additional scratch space are known to be Turing
complete. Comparing LMs to Turing machines, however, introduces a category
error - Turing machines decide language membership, whereas LMs define
distributions over strings. To bridge this gap, we formalize CoT reasoning in a
probabilistic setting. We present several results on the representational
capacity of recurrent and transformer LMs with CoT reasoning, showing that they
can represent the same family of distributions over strings as probabilistic
Turing machines. | [
0.0269455183,
0.0511632562,
-0.0172330942,
0.0169966035,
-0.0513957292,
0.0139425369,
-0.024546599,
-0.0239100475,
-0.0437913612,
-0.0323065035,
-0.012519924,
-0.0965104476,
0.0359768234,
0.011297089,
0.0526526943,
-0.05036873,
-0.0026071211,
-0.0488958769,
0.0104548465,
-0.0215585493,
-0.0345779099,
-0.0058486452,
-0.0385306925,
0.035697002,
0.0142124919,
-0.013787495,
-0.0176908914,
-0.052929081,
-0.0193588324,
-0.000494985,
-0.026415294,
0.027473053,
0.0109599307,
0.0563102253,
0.0000017974,
-0.0361627862,
0.0090961829,
-0.0078934599,
-0.0152511476,
-0.0344480872,
-0.0201595761,
0.007924607,
-0.0025022246,
0.0274427664,
-0.0079777362,
0.000947408,
0.0617250055,
0.0121502383,
0.0040245238,
0.0519762374,
0.0127830952,
-0.0449388213,
0.0409363583,
-0.0359339416,
0.0354965664,
0.0021714405,
0.0100397132,
-0.0042357263,
0.0422077365,
-0.0289167278,
-0.0191246141,
0.0508982576,
0.0477743335,
0.0057356465,
-0.04301662,
0.0505372435,
0.0256315246,
-0.0141579695,
0.0057554501,
-0.0028794697,
-0.0466317125,
-0.0331708193,
-0.0230468679,
0.0093139792,
-0.0026256524,
0.0018639372,
-0.0214872006,
0.0806689039,
-0.0178081114,
0.0575546399,
0.0220999811,
0.0251693465,
0.0607533008,
-0.0219804235,
-0.0872232243,
0.0840440989,
0.0120852413,
-0.0241551269,
-0.0402076803,
0.0279516093,
0.0343114398,
-0.046523679,
0.0114827333,
0.0633988306,
0.0212069191,
0.0338278003,
0.0142881526,
0.0035175157,
-0.0211427975,
-0.0443828627,
0.0437817313,
0.036992982,
0.0050949273,
0.0274722818,
-0.0435964726,
0.0490592904,
-0.0657330304,
0.0058029443,
-0.0197403543,
-0.0240807608,
-0.0583482049,
-0.0482261814,
-0.00719968,
0.0541318245,
0.0298736636,
0.0160031151,
-0.0240737442,
0.0491669923,
0.0074214744,
-0.0327493772,
0.0282229017,
-0.0131819053,
-0.0255744457,
0.0064509786,
-0.1016736254,
0.0225476194,
0.0100174407,
0.0276081823,
0.0311723072,
-0.0227045789,
-0.0206143502,
0.0010446213,
-0.0129686994,
-0.030312255,
-0.0039218757,
0.0715015382,
0.0111325011,
-0.0118442401,
-0.0332174748,
-0.0064988141,
-0.0265984796,
-0.0688144043,
0.039848607,
-0.0911972821,
0.0064248014,
0.0038470742,
-0.0189740304,
-0.0187578462,
0.0014520244,
0.0207313839,
-0.037694335,
0.0676964447,
0.0145535376,
-0.0003789497,
-0.0068588038,
0.006628504,
0.0068393294,
0.0201832801,
0.0599585734,
0.0295078345,
-0.015860863,
0.0187806822,
0.0428738929,
0.0126646524,
0.0086256871,
-0.0481988117,
-0.0281388946,
-0.0452501997,
0.0041533476,
0.0278937072,
-0.0141146695,
0.0721310377,
-0.0010291368,
-0.0033151135,
0.0299135353,
0.0331070758,
0.0658313408,
0.0445674509,
0.0861914158,
-0.0549732186,
0.0179683883,
0.0603745803,
-0.0432865657,
0.0517713018,
-0.0308064818,
0.0367350169,
0.0178649183,
0.0229136981,
-0.0328502953,
-0.0659155846,
-0.0332328528,
-0.0043706875,
0.000231283,
-0.0264844727,
0.0806859881,
0.0057934164,
-0.0144251706,
0.0442020185,
-0.0029201175,
-0.020419402,
0.0165001452,
-0.064979665,
0.0039910255,
0.0112860054,
0.0195588451,
-0.0285638366,
-0.011742685,
-0.0056894887,
-0.036408145,
0.0540022999,
0.0085926112,
0.0242227539,
-0.0193404499,
-0.0205216985,
0.0003741201,
0.0167597737,
0.0049239756,
0.0229823329,
-0.0282146912,
0.0143117476,
-0.0043144934,
-0.0149948699,
-0.0098423855,
0.0370013006,
0.0428224839,
0.0105712935,
0.0064230682,
0.0427660495,
0.0466572493,
-0.0032790632,
0.000230151,
0.0527484156,
0.0105056185,
-0.040187411,
-0.0521594658,
0.0280379429,
-0.0623856522,
-0.0403001383,
0.0391633548,
-0.0267112236,
0.0090435743,
0.0015233683,
-0.0346785598,
-0.0390856154,
0.0713332593,
-0.0317152552,
0.0270893574,
-0.0312444586,
0.0305568371,
0.0043504215,
0.0013771716,
-0.003542759,
0.0979263708,
-0.0335445032,
0.0260562859,
-0.0070048883,
0.0169434696,
0.0040973951,
-0.0288753062,
-0.0586027019,
0.0322193205,
-0.0139754228,
0.0209146626,
0.0104752863,
-0.0071377154,
0.0127974162,
-0.0553487428,
-0.0314518549,
-0.0102742519,
-0.0035420982,
0.0298595782,
-0.0239946824,
-0.0069964235,
0.0330371074,
0.0158136021,
-0.0577322654,
0.0098462934,
0.0157282706,
0.0182059519,
0.080363825,
-0.0129346568,
-0.0342614166,
-0.0125653483,
-0.0242024232,
-0.037290819,
0.0566885658,
-0.0098934015,
-0.0384997055,
-0.0504217558,
0.0333658196,
-0.0454728454,
0.037293639,
-0.0303847492,
-0.0133428341,
0.0402333736,
-0.0327773914,
0.0287218448,
0.0290909912,
0.0195934251,
0.0064411424,
0.0787585899,
0.0023160237,
-0.0046888101,
0.0165163483,
-0.038832508,
-0.0356924571,
0.0012399799,
-0.0214982703,
-0.0303797908,
0.1186799258,
0.0034360262,
-0.0562949739,
-0.0526247807,
-0.001043071,
0.0032854415,
0.0288418476,
-0.0156943314,
-0.0312653407,
-0.0212364607,
0.0814119056,
-0.007025308,
-0.0562790073,
0.0854153782,
-0.0583216026,
0.0303970445,
-0.0400322005,
-0.0284742191,
-0.0500595868,
0.0781530216,
0.0309889894,
-0.0242398772,
0.0232919566,
-0.0082509751,
-0.0670468956,
-0.0086783022,
-0.00678918,
-0.0140593927,
0.0250401683,
-0.0586885102,
0.0024183877,
-0.0173100047,
-0.0005059451,
-0.0284883603,
0.0124481572,
-0.0307132434,
-0.0018546913,
-0.013683917,
-0.0105880089,
-0.0203966424,
0.0548464693,
0.0197749548,
0.0204969384,
0.0095533608,
-0.0088747423,
-0.0182067528,
0.0114290183,
-0.0108305756,
0.0010257022,
0.0465608053,
-0.0033114413,
-0.0066863769,
0.0198703948,
0.0110039655,
0.0375438631,
-0.0497986898,
0.0277996045,
-0.0007238577,
0.0156226195,
-0.0674661919,
0.0183161907,
-0.024849657,
-0.0521556139,
-0.027862858,
0.1121885702,
0.0273957811,
-0.0398865044,
-0.0071197357,
-0.0056811082,
0.0002792234,
0.0235076807,
0.0308243707,
-0.0884675533,
0.0152863637,
0.0138285039,
-0.0313687995,
-0.0221082568,
-0.0409182422,
-0.0187833626,
-0.0778944492,
-0.0077743712,
-0.0099887596,
-0.031053938,
-0.0490003303,
-0.009611194,
-0.0144511983,
0.0361251049,
-0.0352280103,
0.0171091072,
0.014132998,
0.0284187775,
0.0303411484,
0.00120722,
-0.0282209422,
0.008886504,
-0.0437820405,
0.0150913661,
0.0605233572,
0.0136635024,
-0.0059115114,
-0.0593960956,
0.0268247686,
-0.0306258909,
-0.0042274692,
0.0295108557,
-0.0374283865,
0.0045287362,
-0.0208576098,
0.0080422116,
0.0122225825,
-0.0195624866,
-0.0134662064,
-0.0106026111,
0.1035944,
-0.0352341123,
-0.0601881109,
0.0030540526,
0.0067378394,
-0.0207914747,
0.0741355047,
0.0663560629,
-0.0300399717,
-0.0070104189,
-0.0410214886,
-0.0392746292,
0.0235544033,
-0.0554595999,
0.0067286449,
0.0673984587,
-0.0337802544,
-0.0695332959,
-0.0214950424,
0.0138932373,
0.0633869022,
-0.0046049198,
0.002623027,
0.015332968,
-0.0143347308,
-0.0203710031,
0.0043290909,
-0.0391221978,
0.0000952727,
-0.0452471115,
0.0179796368,
0.0268603265,
-0.0365979262,
-0.0478264987,
-0.0091238646,
-0.0852971151,
-0.0502759479,
-0.0139455432,
0.042408172,
0.0383271351,
-0.0141299218,
-0.03159054,
-0.0499830656,
0.04811069,
0.0265472606,
0.001177331,
0.0089755505,
0.0290613882,
0.0256429017,
0.0213753432,
0.0453632548,
-0.0393698812,
0.0073290407,
-0.0057383804,
0.0386017859,
0.0151644647,
-0.0191262066,
0.0167928785,
-0.017135229,
0.0503825881,
0.0189460013,
-0.0120695978,
-0.0266195145,
0.0262641925,
0.0053088376,
-0.0345286652,
-0.0420047715,
0.0164355543,
0.0251728166,
0.017517047,
-0.0248331372,
-0.0947958678,
0.0364842713,
0.0214239638,
0.0520098992,
-0.0235084351,
0.0305691306,
0.045293875,
0.0284940638,
0.0113864075,
0.0089376746,
0.006033476,
-0.0226775948,
0.0259688385,
-0.0035261859,
0.044368621,
0.033864554,
0.0011242809,
-0.0611908324,
-0.008391547,
-0.0993656665,
-0.0603828654,
0.0258900635,
0.0100303106,
0.0474031679,
0.014119585,
-0.0199598838,
-0.0511447713,
0.0091851717,
0.010717758,
0.0307148192,
0.055801291,
-0.0143436296,
0.0611957721,
0.0143748401,
0.0046076914,
-0.0240209475,
0.082892634,
0.003175782,
-0.0022839752,
-0.0077065593,
0.0168099571,
-0.0126378005,
-0.033224538,
-0.0879142806,
0.0066787787,
0.0013055569,
0.0049784379,
-0.0661781728,
-0.0970229954,
0.0241297018,
0.0409437381,
0.0492274389,
-0.0063028298,
0.0061627519,
0.0672381967,
0.0148206735,
0.0486675762,
-0.0051898425,
0.0123023577,
0.0840103999,
-0.0118161067,
-0.0421929918,
-6.158613636e-33,
-0.0351429917,
-0.0096503869,
0.0212426409,
0.014670386,
0.0130285965,
-0.0154678309,
-0.05772743,
0.0059297765,
-0.0192380995,
-0.0026008002,
-0.0254566725,
0.0164349582,
-0.0030511096,
0.0525919572,
0.0046714474,
-0.0244858824,
0.004527872,
-0.0044692983,
-0.0074129822,
-0.0197477229,
0.0326812118,
0.0028498094,
0.0491759144,
-0.0114173861,
0.04846479,
-0.0259419121,
0.0215701293,
0.072373718,
-0.0310131926,
0.0475119017,
-0.0340964086,
0.0064346674,
0.0407113694,
-0.0294210874,
-0.0121066729,
-0.0117614176,
-0.069291234,
-0.0379679576,
0.0428287834,
-0.0102945939,
-0.0338486321,
-0.0316455476,
0.0612220578,
-0.0029756175,
0.0098445537,
-0.0170155279,
0.022348661,
-0.0231190678,
-0.0112253157,
-0.0114114517,
-0.0108831283,
-0.0062823929,
0.0157789178,
-0.0077019921,
0.0155597758,
-0.000540839,
-0.0192046277,
0.0169021543,
-0.0577652901,
-0.0021265242,
-0.0157095529,
0.0251355935,
0.069163613,
0.0055562132,
-0.0089902664,
0.0389403403,
0.0177565701,
-0.0210342873,
-0.1027370989,
-0.0052883704,
0.0232739076,
-0.0101754051,
0.0740523115,
-0.0146488883,
0.0391940512,
0.0260584187,
-0.0697278157,
-0.0135021033,
0.0275128428,
0.0464458354,
0.0508746766,
-0.0126567557,
-0.0148447361,
-0.0459693372,
-0.0570798665,
-0.0794157311,
-0.0546582974,
-0.0155937234,
-0.006285775,
-0.0163110178,
0.0083834743,
-0.0287739616,
0.0314466767,
-0.0355561301,
-0.003179091,
0.038709905,
0.0177871604,
0.021078838,
0.0025065548,
0.0392093621,
-0.0196937583,
0.0150153162,
-0.0329240635,
0.0364560597,
-0.0133732148,
0.0201655924,
0.0144852251,
0.0265770666,
-0.0172406826,
-0.0224526636,
-0.0815718025,
-0.0042778607,
-0.0086301658,
0.046064429,
0.0530028194,
0.0293918792,
-0.0172626227,
0.0173548032,
-0.0351292863,
-0.0139498301,
0.0075548785,
0.0703150854,
-0.0148800109,
0.0450556204,
-0.0319826268,
-0.0392263904,
-0.0409835875,
0.0481432863,
0.0537209958,
-0.0544154234,
-0.0013332092,
0.0458584763,
2.754e-7,
0.060045708,
0.0046571321,
0.0432870053,
0.0109040784,
0.0300457142,
0.0053766188,
-0.0237065852,
-0.0141617581,
0.0415051319,
-0.0430834703,
-0.007416497,
0.042239029,
0.029167816,
0.0136264181,
-0.0689879283,
-0.0448153727,
-0.0535177663,
-0.0030885134,
0.014856129,
0.0071545905,
0.0412656032,
0.114847526,
0.0413325876,
-0.0112157837,
0.0003830125,
-0.0456483886,
0.0358754396,
-0.0117899776,
0.0424128398,
0.0031942476,
-0.0019364766,
0.0222183447,
0.0176183656,
0.0153236585,
0.0342871323,
0.0471248999,
-0.0100435819,
0.0023921889,
0.0354136005,
-0.0012025187,
-0.0073629334,
-0.0274925996,
-0.0142778829,
-0.042365972,
0.053522829,
-0.0794294551,
-0.0378636234,
0.0275617018,
0.0397821777,
-0.0097698001,
0.0046035559,
0.0130104702,
-0.0299187917,
0.0110845715,
-0.0160227306,
-0.0017198477,
0.0329110809,
-0.1260962039,
-0.025139451,
0.0048868055,
-0.0493515804,
-0.0044057895,
-0.0206086729,
-0.0237502735,
0.0772485733,
-0.0538105369,
-0.012155043,
2.529434713e-34,
0.0352296531,
-0.0116127003,
0.0134872738,
0.0079549747,
0.0466496311,
-0.0012875345,
0.0179587454,
-0.0029816537,
0.0348054916,
-0.1028297693,
-0.0587155595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14192v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14192v1 | Timo: Towards Better Temporal Reasoning for Language Models | 2024-06-20T10:52:14 | 2024-06-20T10:52:14 | Zhaochen Su, Jun Zhang, Tong Zhu, Xiaoye Qu, Juntao Li, Min Zhang, Yu Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Reasoning about time is essential for Large Language Models (LLMs) to
understand the world. Previous works focus on solving specific tasks, primarily
on time-sensitive question answering. While these methods have proven
effective, they cannot generalize to a wider spectrum of temporal reasoning
tasks. Therefore, we propose a crucial question: Can we build a universal
framework to handle a variety of temporal reasoning tasks? To that end, we
systematically study 38 temporal reasoning tasks. Based on the observation that
19 tasks are directly related to mathematics, we first leverage the available
mathematical dataset to set a solid foundation for temporal reasoning. However,
the in-depth study indicates that focusing solely on mathematical enhancement
falls short of addressing pure temporal reasoning tasks. To mitigate this
limitation, we propose a simple but effective self-critic temporal optimization
method to enhance the model's temporal reasoning capabilities without
sacrificing general task abilities. Finally, we develop Timo, a model designed
to excel in temporal reasoning at the 7B and 13B scales. Notably, Timo
outperforms the counterpart LLMs by 10.0 and 7.6 in average accuracy scores and
achieves the new state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance of comparable size.
Extensive experiments further validate our framework's effectiveness and its
generalization across diverse temporal tasks. The code is available at
https://github.com/zhaochen0110/Timo. | [
0.0245548878,
0.0905201808,
0.0010201333,
0.0194396228,
-0.0438592099,
0.0036723956,
0.0364344418,
-0.0049157953,
-0.0415343009,
-0.0186430383,
-0.0050689001,
-0.0451573133,
-0.0063649844,
0.0226034895,
-0.0179456249,
-0.0428326763,
0.0516972914,
-0.0485145152,
0.0184015874,
-0.0104221553,
-0.0211232956,
-0.0172384661,
-0.0306621753,
0.0200440194,
0.0134332646,
-0.0611534081,
-0.0018364963,
-0.0534567349,
0.032169763,
-0.0196696855,
-0.0053541563,
0.0409413986,
0.0057377135,
0.0276253242,
0.000002067,
-0.0176189672,
-0.0028222259,
-0.010564154,
-0.0485233329,
0.0353227183,
-0.0006645331,
0.0123449098,
0.0175035149,
0.0156088592,
-0.0738251507,
0.0200045705,
-0.0051227184,
0.0153333871,
0.053238228,
0.0750336424,
0.0156932808,
0.0099535147,
0.0186672006,
-0.0227450244,
0.0308709517,
-0.0615858398,
-0.0129498113,
0.0272503272,
0.0452514701,
-0.0146141332,
-0.0075829588,
0.0480166525,
0.0606426038,
-0.0031017058,
0.0238514282,
0.0457920656,
-0.0255285278,
0.0218987744,
-0.0317708924,
0.0338512249,
0.026091218,
-0.0424020737,
0.0035008073,
0.0271644015,
-0.0364329293,
-0.041932676,
-0.0522588231,
-0.0198916607,
0.0332528166,
0.0159000382,
0.0072699008,
0.0466886461,
0.0426980779,
0.0412829742,
-0.0264767073,
0.112431787,
0.0079729687,
0.00150994,
-0.0509076938,
-0.0297122616,
-0.0159544162,
-0.0518310778,
0.0192748737,
0.0972404405,
-0.0013516436,
-0.0022342349,
0.0030121088,
-0.0058311368,
-0.0344843604,
-0.0027048008,
0.0245449748,
0.0749678314,
0.0356799141,
0.0598313063,
-0.0030901574,
0.070884034,
-0.0352159664,
0.0143085578,
-0.0157995671,
0.0080585461,
-0.0400248133,
-0.0204096697,
0.014394735,
0.0081932433,
-0.0002023008,
0.0088007748,
-0.0554939248,
0.0375730544,
-0.0188006628,
-0.0085684061,
-0.0152782761,
0.0114784716,
-0.0049702544,
-0.0553781055,
-0.0634636953,
-0.003006839,
-0.0469983518,
-0.0128715802,
-0.016637357,
-0.0199271888,
-0.0373054892,
-0.0056057987,
0.0008447128,
-0.0557392985,
-0.0190299079,
0.0483176857,
-0.0167621225,
0.0103683863,
-0.0386507809,
-0.0180107374,
-0.0001760056,
-0.0574482121,
0.0003925511,
-0.0720240474,
0.028773468,
-0.0167134106,
-0.0364187658,
-0.0175184496,
0.0150578097,
-0.001882272,
0.0297165886,
0.0738673881,
0.0300845373,
0.0295963045,
0.008591406,
0.021489149,
0.0318848975,
0.0380370356,
0.0277408659,
-0.0268221926,
0.012508044,
0.0186897423,
-0.0287978966,
0.0230303034,
0.0370727032,
-0.0242304988,
-0.0657406524,
0.0437559597,
-0.0250031687,
0.0461324081,
0.0030567306,
0.0350445136,
-0.0346611366,
-0.0443962477,
0.019443674,
0.0176227652,
-0.0235112347,
-0.0076159043,
0.0591754355,
-0.0270171929,
0.0353145935,
-0.0474481508,
-0.050935328,
0.0461487956,
-0.0328756124,
0.0144383218,
-0.0267591272,
0.0028694933,
-0.026038928,
-0.0793018937,
-0.0294704232,
0.0188293103,
-0.0125707397,
0.0413989499,
0.0619947799,
-0.0067369952,
-0.0112672467,
0.068856068,
-0.0004015894,
-0.0004326089,
-0.0114306444,
-0.0182371642,
0.0467744805,
0.066100128,
0.0411965288,
-0.0464910194,
-0.0619558655,
-0.0103078596,
0.0263719708,
0.0153573267,
0.0743472651,
-0.0193225853,
-0.0184096862,
-0.0299523789,
-0.0127609428,
-0.0223512463,
0.0114399325,
-0.0073329243,
0.0679350793,
0.0599552952,
0.0218550563,
-0.032379251,
0.0218735095,
0.0218608622,
-0.0282625705,
-0.0350747146,
-0.0163768381,
0.0133979423,
0.0022341534,
0.0029877687,
0.0184041783,
0.027477527,
0.0164250191,
-0.0205156505,
-0.0279822871,
0.0199428834,
-0.0807950422,
-0.0830316916,
0.0665885136,
0.027614411,
-0.0383286513,
0.0418151766,
-0.0429241396,
-0.0266267881,
0.0889539272,
0.0204744842,
0.0376042277,
-0.0239086244,
0.0185745079,
-0.0091182087,
0.0154920248,
-0.0426049978,
0.0794356242,
-0.0212118253,
0.0133048715,
0.0124682765,
0.0279997364,
0.0023410516,
-0.0252200905,
-0.0082617644,
0.0080094561,
-0.0156444255,
-0.0048165447,
0.0109140752,
-0.0044698003,
-0.0506042838,
-0.0088866977,
-0.0585896932,
0.0156151559,
-0.0079986528,
0.0320695564,
-0.0011319412,
-0.023845369,
0.0081573734,
-0.0240152832,
0.0008946778,
-0.0086366097,
-0.0329786353,
-0.0009169588,
0.0539197549,
0.0085388366,
-0.0073637818,
-0.017750131,
-0.0308710113,
-0.0714874566,
0.0564279817,
-0.0271471012,
0.0102688195,
0.0155810239,
-0.0080665527,
-0.0683435202,
0.0073069409,
-0.0067837783,
0.0194591023,
0.022131769,
-0.0387161747,
0.0427577868,
0.0724135935,
0.0011544579,
0.0318356268,
0.0575591251,
-0.011874333,
-0.0507947318,
0.0684647039,
-0.0055897716,
0.0166744273,
-0.0008117023,
-0.0042261546,
-0.0219920799,
0.1003254354,
-0.0391326919,
-0.0042235674,
-0.0663349032,
0.0523271039,
-0.0437999442,
0.0048771948,
-0.0286752488,
0.0373302214,
-0.0248830616,
0.0215821192,
-0.0557763353,
-0.0336528011,
0.0714588016,
0.0209208056,
-0.0134442169,
-0.0022312833,
0.0076523665,
-0.0601253696,
0.0956294835,
-0.0014330379,
-0.034107957,
0.0172468685,
-0.0166679956,
-0.0296136979,
-0.0162812788,
0.0451600999,
-0.0253575165,
0.0298853815,
-0.0597482882,
0.0225128345,
-0.0043556518,
-0.0405970961,
-0.0476342142,
-0.0412118174,
-0.0609664991,
-0.0224389601,
-0.0825791359,
-0.00386993,
-0.0236782357,
-0.0016347179,
-0.041199252,
0.0242983997,
-0.0544161424,
-0.014281027,
0.0089891674,
0.0209359489,
0.0466327555,
0.02717329,
0.046298787,
-0.0116462801,
0.0408999547,
0.0042016129,
0.095772922,
-0.0427687019,
-0.063194856,
0.0254694577,
-0.0149273882,
-0.0337469094,
-0.0053269421,
0.0152356708,
0.0313679911,
-0.0789356083,
-0.0039660549,
0.1410185546,
0.068772994,
0.0113929594,
-0.0006201461,
-0.0542478897,
0.017019989,
0.0358790085,
0.0161783937,
-0.0468814224,
-0.0416625515,
0.0151552018,
-0.0084216092,
0.003983858,
-0.0335890166,
-0.0159185063,
-0.0677127615,
-0.0005450109,
0.0182784945,
-0.0093534878,
0.0355809256,
0.0142169455,
-0.0191612523,
-0.0192480292,
0.0145390918,
0.0305212289,
0.0037872884,
0.0185981467,
0.0219256654,
-0.0311522372,
-0.0264685173,
0.0746017769,
0.0259517524,
0.0427689217,
0.0077048289,
0.0551059283,
-0.0013179407,
-0.0350252278,
0.0350844972,
0.0510078482,
-0.0320871398,
-0.0197773315,
0.0195289887,
0.0047454559,
-0.0312380623,
0.0026009269,
0.0400926843,
-0.030311957,
-0.0332896747,
-0.0117676556,
0.1215894297,
-0.0318847857,
-0.0284015164,
-0.0279073138,
-0.0046339072,
-0.0444551669,
0.0512149036,
-0.002663838,
-0.0066407849,
-0.089667879,
-0.0004017489,
-0.0593681857,
-0.0878571421,
-0.0365009159,
-0.0165965427,
0.060503196,
-0.0030941425,
-0.0656562522,
-0.0420330912,
-0.0152583504,
0.0112126926,
-0.0281897169,
-0.0315556005,
-0.0156836957,
0.0113475891,
-0.0561317727,
0.0465446711,
-0.0348359719,
0.0312769823,
-0.0343272574,
0.0267815553,
0.0049115941,
0.0024499269,
-0.0127244964,
0.0258813147,
-0.110379681,
-0.04081624,
-0.0132182315,
0.0056220675,
0.0117509486,
0.0641486198,
-0.0223300345,
-0.0205372199,
0.052495461,
-0.0043913387,
-0.0426778719,
-0.0004521537,
0.0631410331,
-0.0112701859,
0.0115488023,
0.0470380075,
-0.0400284342,
-0.0075846245,
-0.0058757584,
0.0337745771,
-0.0048010722,
0.0250640139,
0.0152747063,
-0.0184569918,
0.0004309857,
0.0580765791,
0.0025817845,
0.0051289476,
0.003005774,
-0.0303203203,
-0.0111401817,
-0.0174079482,
0.0226226635,
0.0179422647,
-0.032583978,
-0.009065791,
-0.0068898806,
0.0403742976,
-0.0041672038,
0.0017412248,
0.0332955718,
-0.0050623952,
0.018426029,
0.0280759875,
-0.0035635261,
-0.010065713,
0.0141961919,
-0.0195079856,
0.038244009,
-0.0032715173,
0.0304862112,
0.0081976801,
0.011344783,
-0.049479831,
-0.0378007479,
-0.112332046,
-0.0342072807,
0.0235026497,
-0.0183432736,
0.0541767515,
-0.0204106085,
0.0266395714,
-0.0215012729,
-0.0071730809,
-0.002288918,
0.017312156,
0.0335951746,
-0.0117272604,
0.0198382605,
0.0120288637,
0.0197880939,
-0.0038838258,
0.0594369657,
-0.0014236562,
0.0504510663,
0.0411126651,
0.0057229265,
-0.0182528701,
-0.0360416807,
-0.0710698664,
-0.0179336257,
-0.0277076829,
0.0055588204,
-0.0525733419,
-0.0791296363,
0.0397669338,
0.0282136202,
-0.0536569767,
-0.0047509596,
0.0037003572,
0.0318545327,
-0.0059083146,
-0.031712722,
-0.0270458478,
0.0423455313,
0.0196610428,
-0.0128639461,
-0.0559899993,
-6.308732713e-33,
-0.0118118646,
-0.0155290924,
0.0651562959,
0.0029523547,
-0.0150327915,
0.0100502335,
-0.052151572,
0.0076258518,
-0.0285119731,
0.0059826463,
-0.0383753516,
0.0655557513,
0.0126493657,
0.0074513797,
0.0333304182,
-0.0102287997,
0.0032740713,
-0.0214519762,
-0.0180130061,
0.0120270941,
0.0273403637,
0.0359930396,
0.0506416596,
-0.0119318273,
-0.0092647905,
0.0326202512,
0.0008716683,
0.0576832108,
-0.0232018437,
0.067161642,
-0.0043043252,
0.0045297151,
0.0148638636,
-0.0388096347,
-0.0278849043,
-0.0036021112,
-0.1207356006,
-0.0821234733,
-0.0100113647,
0.0169758052,
-0.0496726297,
-0.0517673977,
-0.0098872324,
0.0096702063,
-0.0054330383,
-0.050073918,
0.0106242811,
-0.0320608653,
-0.0141181648,
-0.0282691866,
-0.0142303314,
0.0656742081,
-0.0486204363,
-0.0302003529,
0.0489888154,
0.0327179655,
0.0052171331,
-0.0251564384,
-0.0017845999,
0.019364275,
-0.0052456507,
0.0070652575,
0.0565328412,
0.0114536993,
0.0049313838,
0.0098882932,
-0.0112889716,
-0.0132798739,
-0.0066038077,
0.0122424904,
0.0280825645,
0.0166136585,
0.0496036857,
-0.0247620828,
0.0227392167,
-0.0039546704,
-0.0418949425,
0.0075355186,
0.0521280691,
0.0447996855,
0.0270266682,
0.0077473246,
-0.0385118425,
0.0144014265,
-0.0277802777,
0.0375161543,
-0.0446151048,
0.0054992391,
0.0225659274,
0.0221978333,
0.0039349901,
-0.0004313993,
0.0150725842,
-0.0602070056,
0.0120426118,
0.0447290018,
-0.0178961828,
-0.0050542578,
0.0085297283,
0.0631315857,
-0.0411257669,
0.0224941187,
-0.0252209064,
-0.0126250098,
-0.0059513235,
-0.0211593267,
0.0007348851,
0.0274778306,
-0.0287784357,
-0.0281439573,
-0.0463532768,
0.0078062457,
0.0137783866,
0.0027841595,
0.0455001816,
0.005455778,
-0.0141702052,
0.0561747141,
0.0169902779,
0.0188149381,
-0.0234121811,
0.0512653552,
0.0096436618,
0.0372119211,
-0.0084406259,
-0.0316149816,
-0.0407253131,
0.0302796587,
0.0024203828,
-0.0350345187,
-0.0031817164,
0.023026349,
2.592e-7,
0.0330045186,
0.034202937,
0.0138297379,
0.0510401018,
0.0258216206,
0.0095851421,
-0.0123341326,
-0.0487198494,
-0.0445648097,
0.0216384195,
0.0483360626,
0.0489381887,
0.0539782643,
0.0322033465,
-0.0198835842,
-0.0022808309,
-0.0618243963,
-0.0137057286,
-0.0588451587,
-0.0412527844,
0.0100031979,
0.0912714526,
0.0540216528,
0.0070234388,
-0.0178127326,
-0.0583687909,
0.0881411582,
0.0056594335,
-0.0192244593,
0.0447920114,
0.0393902324,
-0.0070762732,
0.0018722584,
-0.0155669497,
-0.0093826409,
0.0397751108,
-0.0287224874,
0.0606874041,
-0.0188371036,
-0.0337817334,
-0.0481899865,
-0.0471727625,
-0.0210336167,
-0.0301728304,
0.109337315,
-0.0513909347,
-0.0456331521,
-0.0215588231,
0.0291227978,
0.0191450361,
0.0319077298,
0.0174853019,
-0.017504435,
0.0082590897,
0.0205218662,
-0.0217181928,
-0.0097816102,
-0.1262453049,
-0.0373637006,
0.0422047712,
-0.0218759105,
0.0144088762,
-0.0498612672,
0.0015128185,
0.0042886743,
-0.0290167574,
-0.004499726,
2.22458311e-34,
0.0298277196,
0.0099864667,
-0.0178267602,
0.0299788006,
0.0434122495,
-0.0194830243,
-0.0048645553,
-0.0204741433,
0.0496247783,
-0.0400483608,
-0.0186607335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14191v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14191v1 | Temporal Knowledge Graph Question Answering: A Survey | 2024-06-20T10:51:06 | 2024-06-20T10:51:06 | Miao Su, ZiXuan Li, Zhuo Chen, Long Bai, Xiaolong Jin, Jiafeng Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Knowledge Base Question Answering (KBQA) has been a long-standing field to
answer questions based on knowledge bases. Recently, the evolving dynamics of
knowledge have attracted a growing interest in Temporal Knowledge Graph
Question Answering (TKGQA), an emerging task to answer temporal questions.
However, this field grapples with ambiguities in defining temporal questions
and lacks a systematic categorization of existing methods for TKGQA. In
response, this paper provides a thorough survey from two perspectives: the
taxonomy of temporal questions and the methodological categorization for TKGQA.
Specifically, we first establish a detailed taxonomy of temporal questions
engaged in prior studies. Subsequently, we provide a comprehensive review of
TKGQA techniques of two categories: semantic parsing-based and TKG
embedding-based. Building on this review, the paper outlines potential research
directions aimed at advancing the field of TKGQA. This work aims to serve as a
comprehensive reference for TKGQA and to stimulate further research. | [
0.0547478497,
0.0006301205,
-0.026566647,
0.0056324853,
-0.0355738215,
-0.0118569788,
-0.0325445719,
0.0162345264,
0.0133595606,
-0.0446685404,
0.0654545426,
0.0200227983,
-0.0401940048,
0.0310372282,
-0.0260935668,
-0.0580245145,
0.0194824189,
0.0357135236,
-0.0040237112,
-0.0045768097,
0.0107034966,
-0.0159818679,
-0.0275262222,
0.0192692913,
0.0014877166,
-0.0552423187,
-0.0360794812,
-0.053866744,
0.0356498621,
-0.0491568297,
-0.0078301346,
-0.0026410285,
0.0221480429,
-0.0215200894,
0.00000207,
-0.0290593076,
0.0102161346,
0.0054327887,
-0.0516681261,
0.0159199405,
-0.015389354,
0.0273118224,
0.0569637083,
-0.0132036088,
-0.0753589869,
-0.0403821878,
-0.0071133156,
0.0183777101,
0.0186481737,
0.0381680131,
0.008911374,
0.0024424542,
0.0250184946,
0.0257310104,
-0.0083063338,
-0.0663289726,
0.0024831393,
0.0313643329,
0.0608403869,
-0.0260546468,
-0.0192547105,
0.0379828438,
0.0112255402,
0.0037679432,
0.0633144379,
0.0428638272,
-0.0143161993,
0.0839176551,
-0.0256838202,
0.0315948427,
0.0606361739,
-0.0152322678,
0.0119826887,
0.029711185,
-0.036069043,
0.028664073,
-0.0386785381,
-0.0307478439,
-0.0103000337,
-0.0188854672,
-0.0208294168,
0.019828748,
0.0151662799,
-0.0122034242,
-0.03701609,
0.1101440415,
-0.0111151785,
-0.0258856788,
-0.0301185772,
-0.0204707477,
0.0349240676,
-0.0596014597,
-0.0142484559,
0.1001147032,
0.0217016134,
0.0035685687,
0.0208947714,
0.0351472832,
0.0128519256,
-0.0410809927,
-0.0485755652,
0.0393977985,
0.0309882592,
0.0590202697,
0.0133557077,
0.0307265781,
-0.0191629156,
-0.0212714691,
-0.0552275293,
0.0028118393,
-0.093030259,
-0.0266001988,
-0.033719115,
0.0379050858,
-0.007817707,
-0.0015550265,
0.0041025556,
0.0388533957,
-0.0108486228,
-0.0101215914,
0.0015122887,
0.0465427861,
0.0125043113,
0.0222463235,
-0.0623684302,
0.0159038734,
-0.0539543629,
0.0066256211,
-0.0430866517,
-0.003276522,
0.0163636971,
-0.0071922988,
0.0517270379,
-0.0168901775,
-0.045611646,
0.0573282987,
-0.0017932247,
0.0210723728,
-0.0579208098,
-0.0818865523,
-0.0068570883,
0.0045331023,
0.0305858571,
-0.0335160419,
0.0212129075,
0.0094311861,
-0.0357224718,
0.0376583748,
0.0077617774,
-0.0212702323,
-0.0242399555,
0.0489088334,
0.0098918155,
0.0280862171,
-0.0062987744,
-0.006520296,
-0.0068160542,
0.0286377724,
0.0308976714,
-0.0303699728,
0.0280314963,
0.0107716918,
-0.0740716532,
0.0049845031,
0.0407743156,
-0.0273626689,
-0.0134661114,
0.059929613,
-0.0122899432,
0.0185881574,
-0.0191784147,
-0.006511935,
-0.0413068198,
-0.0310403612,
-0.019569613,
0.0233923998,
-0.0150910681,
-0.0154008092,
0.0884492472,
-0.0276025496,
0.0080282046,
0.0303932633,
0.020398194,
-0.0154291214,
-0.0150877647,
0.012527572,
-0.0741840303,
0.0002241783,
-0.0067441193,
-0.0273521263,
0.0001747255,
0.0137867406,
0.0395353995,
-0.0020855658,
0.028980352,
-0.0212385282,
0.0089847343,
0.0374092907,
-0.017438231,
0.0427436158,
0.0309114624,
0.0119918017,
0.0119365025,
0.0849110931,
0.0484969392,
-0.0162472837,
-0.0727977976,
0.0116074421,
0.008301761,
-0.0199901443,
0.0495171435,
-0.0487994216,
-0.0499623567,
0.0056388779,
-0.0316826627,
-0.0215446018,
-0.0006150054,
-0.0148815643,
0.0381338038,
0.0520198606,
-0.0107015222,
-0.0538520515,
0.0540499799,
0.0111335507,
-0.0183458291,
0.0037410385,
-0.0306057688,
0.025675606,
0.0110257687,
0.0454049408,
0.0138095459,
0.0444308147,
0.0393696129,
-0.0300609078,
-0.0451651514,
0.0667610914,
-0.0029399048,
-0.0857004374,
0.0594886839,
-0.0012682761,
-0.02560197,
-0.0270220693,
-0.0320815742,
-0.0301079359,
0.052122768,
0.0099821407,
0.0902580172,
-0.0076824571,
-0.0254222471,
0.0091684153,
-0.0410929136,
-0.0647281408,
0.0698494315,
-0.0163668431,
0.0317860991,
-0.000992913,
-0.0222215299,
0.0462542288,
-0.0295994841,
-0.00353133,
0.0168994367,
0.0159680676,
-0.0236365311,
-0.0071844496,
-0.0251254793,
-0.0771880671,
0.0306802318,
-0.1029556468,
0.0029043115,
-0.0134483157,
0.0452531949,
0.0352313071,
-0.0204939134,
0.0424576811,
-0.0221223775,
-0.0263568461,
0.0234200545,
-0.0068910439,
0.0246441662,
0.0419480242,
0.0677738115,
-0.0007623618,
0.0037795529,
-0.0125567177,
-0.054060787,
0.0783590749,
-0.0071580936,
-0.0395654701,
-0.0002411534,
-0.0275002625,
-0.0614611283,
0.0172949713,
0.00085712,
0.0403838195,
0.0303758346,
-0.0118638808,
0.0250073988,
0.0159194171,
-0.0216692816,
0.0071027451,
0.0254538842,
-0.0492397249,
-0.0263828002,
0.0186309572,
-0.0217673276,
0.0344576836,
-0.0235015415,
-0.0060384395,
-0.0092302132,
0.0120896073,
0.0111667467,
0.0020174156,
-0.0626265928,
0.0242719278,
-0.0432535969,
0.0169186648,
-0.0303804129,
0.0025095814,
-0.0043968461,
0.0216435492,
-0.0093363151,
0.0250054561,
0.0591949522,
0.049792856,
0.0193264149,
0.0325332284,
0.0046298704,
-0.0534210317,
0.0886090621,
-0.0098209148,
0.0224660821,
0.0047851927,
-0.0481267273,
-0.0347695015,
-0.0260773525,
0.0421286523,
-0.0263799932,
0.0128401909,
-0.02075845,
0.0245083403,
-0.0037155102,
0.0150364051,
-0.0108420104,
-0.0332613327,
-0.0213625357,
0.0164954402,
-0.0479898676,
0.0334702134,
0.0221688282,
0.0358780548,
-0.0591950305,
-0.0558472164,
0.0083839167,
-0.0099549033,
-0.0149551332,
0.0892693102,
0.0577715077,
0.0450352728,
0.0077821333,
0.0716156736,
0.0241966546,
0.0272801686,
0.052627705,
-0.0355570465,
-0.0684310496,
-0.0126031358,
-0.0334854051,
-0.061723426,
0.005334924,
-0.0117544234,
-0.0056254361,
-0.0732842237,
0.0118611678,
0.0599656329,
0.0618108474,
0.0650218651,
0.0108244959,
0.0195653457,
-0.0271619763,
0.0122726988,
0.0190286376,
-0.0915249214,
0.0048590326,
-0.0425825194,
-0.0258357804,
-0.0141703309,
-0.0644760281,
-0.0141138081,
-0.0636893362,
-0.0011671353,
-0.0075950297,
0.0183700193,
-0.0095582968,
0.0218447316,
-0.0115185641,
0.0054253126,
-0.0468322374,
0.0032249589,
-0.0130068818,
0.0129542835,
0.0071325554,
-0.0570763275,
-0.0303828213,
0.0502300672,
0.0060380343,
0.0361359157,
0.0058826776,
0.0144049991,
0.0037564607,
-0.0060770507,
-0.0232273545,
0.0033808893,
0.0115684131,
-0.0212385561,
-0.0040467209,
0.0255349483,
-0.00871618,
0.0034668758,
-0.0048738089,
0.0050585917,
-0.0039077364,
0.0214919355,
0.1386366636,
-0.0412536114,
-0.0096960459,
-0.0174927972,
-0.0193425138,
0.008651468,
0.0277196653,
-0.0029768283,
0.0235931482,
-0.0724842697,
0.0149962828,
-0.0021941934,
-0.0660410523,
-0.0117429579,
0.0250745285,
-0.0058402838,
0.0520364232,
-0.0905850232,
-0.0669045672,
0.025106309,
-0.0145277893,
-0.0110471919,
0.0090331286,
0.0507187918,
-0.0007235612,
-0.0423762128,
-0.0083083613,
-0.0305554364,
0.0136026135,
0.0272460375,
0.0000833243,
-0.0073932684,
0.0242271647,
-0.0285742003,
-0.0235792547,
-0.0546387956,
-0.0309155658,
-0.0258450247,
-0.045385886,
-0.0024509013,
0.0505367778,
-0.0315603428,
0.0036218564,
0.0867028907,
-0.0016347144,
-0.0281287115,
-0.0150880329,
0.0253865123,
0.0208001696,
-0.0078476965,
0.0372030735,
-0.067694582,
-0.058283601,
-0.0537682362,
0.0672068819,
-0.0291610751,
0.0008272483,
0.0196746159,
-0.0004010142,
-0.026533924,
0.0640191212,
-0.019708693,
0.008333574,
-0.0025794166,
-0.0212159306,
-0.0225072093,
-0.0162678678,
-0.0387581103,
-0.0368136503,
-0.0181749109,
-0.0215206183,
-0.0129003432,
-0.0131010599,
0.0101398882,
0.0004970664,
0.0001081186,
0.0339367576,
-0.0041225427,
0.0206856262,
0.009519537,
-0.0384743288,
0.0143226972,
-0.0214393605,
0.0059013912,
-0.0079920655,
-0.0063148411,
0.0297888611,
0.0277224872,
-0.0611083917,
-0.0319937654,
-0.0770913139,
-0.0265240744,
0.0375745632,
-0.0283928476,
0.0657200143,
0.0019499061,
0.0190806203,
0.0107657611,
-0.0377353989,
0.0233545657,
-0.0268635824,
0.0345341973,
-0.0228970777,
0.0439696014,
0.0154447593,
-0.0063684392,
0.0097549669,
0.0692236722,
0.0061677485,
0.0657073706,
0.008585114,
-0.050162822,
-0.0138200773,
-0.0749283805,
-0.0318962522,
0.0089073945,
-0.0111412192,
-0.0005386248,
-0.0634594038,
-0.0365372226,
0.0403473936,
0.0154175861,
-0.0666735619,
0.007533432,
0.013541868,
0.0057367403,
0.1085112169,
-0.0456088483,
-0.0233360231,
0.0790987387,
-0.0222058352,
-0.0014247183,
-0.0415523835,
-5.933410224e-33,
-0.0087852729,
-0.0397692211,
0.0776233152,
0.003447003,
-0.0875917226,
0.0190038886,
-0.025138054,
-0.0170070287,
-0.0360429324,
0.0160045028,
-0.0220117662,
-0.008492413,
-0.0011223658,
-0.0189927835,
0.0308186896,
-0.0310003627,
-0.0014052021,
-0.027405411,
0.0229884647,
0.0115903346,
0.0598775968,
0.0107758772,
0.0113171097,
0.001097734,
0.0166456141,
0.010146589,
0.0370994732,
0.0512375943,
0.0150275622,
0.0610738844,
-0.0180949811,
0.0200298652,
0.0388134196,
-0.0244172346,
0.0049291393,
0.0025441854,
-0.1189232692,
-0.0811850503,
0.0035853116,
0.0134282773,
-0.046727635,
-0.0059534949,
0.0066918484,
-0.0039905426,
0.0760242492,
-0.0193919204,
0.0120381368,
-0.0380027182,
-0.0348358117,
-0.0668874606,
-0.0164075531,
0.0438172929,
-0.0214030147,
0.033023268,
0.0190768428,
0.0067617511,
0.0448206514,
-0.0253666267,
-0.0551289618,
0.0228987336,
-0.0045463541,
-0.0199089814,
0.0032516557,
0.0155731216,
0.0301583316,
-0.0104913041,
-0.0849336386,
-0.0076297182,
-0.0056940196,
0.0646529049,
-0.0560832322,
0.0206171814,
-0.0008958644,
-0.0145822,
-0.0128417825,
-0.0001168774,
-0.0543391481,
-0.007663094,
0.0498219989,
0.038491983,
-0.033045508,
-0.0253938157,
-0.0162251964,
-0.0143867703,
-0.0208837539,
0.0393288098,
-0.0049646087,
-0.0371814333,
0.0256356709,
-0.0045197499,
0.0013477793,
0.0231113583,
0.0315916985,
-0.0887988135,
0.0116155064,
0.031411238,
-0.0026346364,
0.031926617,
0.0109328618,
0.0500751585,
-0.0218271371,
0.0348214768,
0.0152144181,
-0.0561584495,
-0.0097984625,
0.0046949149,
-0.0041454732,
0.0220753197,
0.0165950768,
-0.0070586349,
-0.0098061068,
-0.0059111705,
-0.0577597655,
-0.0486314669,
0.0334900282,
0.0573335811,
-0.0019373739,
0.0221992433,
0.0477512553,
0.0428463183,
0.0025623764,
0.0224427935,
0.0199688151,
0.003831035,
-0.0091960253,
0.0085528195,
-0.0139963394,
0.0594854355,
-0.027573958,
0.0027638229,
0.0009649898,
0.0322597362,
2.632e-7,
0.0640473962,
-0.0212291144,
0.0269440431,
0.0887069479,
0.0339662731,
-0.0292312466,
0.0367750265,
-0.0211799666,
-0.0502157882,
-0.0078032864,
0.0346162766,
0.0008660723,
-0.0179474503,
0.0633488148,
-0.0234049056,
-0.0367329903,
-0.0411338881,
-0.0406701192,
-0.0519973598,
-0.0268442053,
0.0732354373,
-0.0004855107,
0.0405249149,
0.0484701134,
-0.0354111418,
-0.0540465303,
0.0692740604,
0.0239468273,
-0.0286829975,
0.0392658114,
0.0530658849,
-0.0170651153,
-0.0045875642,
0.0545849316,
-0.0066631557,
0.0338283926,
-0.0415964536,
0.0091730747,
-0.0169637278,
-0.0171227176,
-0.0320274569,
-0.0969531536,
0.0279821772,
-0.0174205396,
0.1033094302,
-0.0763799027,
0.0038669566,
0.0279243067,
-0.0318030566,
-0.000410002,
-0.0317287445,
0.0219807941,
-0.0038354187,
0.001827123,
0.0054829731,
0.0084955562,
0.0156545974,
-0.0694481805,
-0.000577596,
0.0518930666,
-0.0151992487,
-0.0148004442,
0.0306921825,
-0.0117584867,
0.0154281948,
-0.0092466678,
0.0250786357,
2.036014531e-34,
0.0322711319,
0.0372122265,
-0.0133937243,
0.012352149,
0.0186431855,
-0.0294510424,
-0.0151527552,
-0.0603680685,
0.0619530939,
-0.0762483031,
0.0043168343
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14189v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14189v1 | In Tree Structure Should Sentence Be Generated | 2024-06-20T10:49:08 | 2024-06-20T10:49:08 | Yaguang Li, Xin Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative models reliant on sequential autoregression have been at the
forefront of language generation for an extensive period, particularly
following the introduction of widely acclaimed transformers. Despite its
excellent performance, there are always some issues that we face today. For
example, problems such as hallucinations and getting trapped in a logic loop
may occur. To enhance the performance of existing systems, this paper
introduces a new method for generating sequences in natural language, which
involves generating the targeted sentence in a tree-traversing order. The paper
includes an illustration of the theoretical basis and validity of the approach,
as well as a comparison of its fundamentals with the diffusion model in graphic
generation. Finally, a module called SenTree is introduced for generating an
approximating binary tree. It is already available at
https://github.com/arklyg/sentree. Additionally, a joint training framework
based on this approach is proposed, incorporating the intrinsics of generative
adversarial networks. | [
0.0103800949,
0.0552222244,
-0.0238726232,
0.0195815135,
-0.0309147649,
-0.0147628663,
-0.0356206633,
-0.0086345356,
-0.0189497713,
-0.021484023,
0.0408858582,
-0.0517515801,
0.0018755379,
0.0347130373,
0.0214696508,
-0.0997772962,
0.0049646287,
-0.016828062,
-0.0041594845,
-0.0125168776,
-0.0268546902,
0.0194828007,
0.0016009009,
0.034928754,
-0.0543142855,
-0.053990487,
-0.0456595495,
0.0030685973,
0.0336780325,
-0.0453374684,
-0.0203316826,
0.0363186188,
0.0236264467,
0.0415313877,
0.0000022078,
0.0124837663,
0.0119284997,
0.0074217762,
0.0189268589,
-0.0168751422,
0.0091855135,
0.0114204111,
-0.0304138251,
0.0072052241,
-0.0564910099,
-0.0086217858,
0.0467046276,
0.0353633985,
0.0964610651,
0.0818441957,
-0.0283242054,
-0.1057896167,
0.0251107272,
-0.0430218168,
0.011623973,
-0.0018976391,
-0.0038425918,
0.0033055383,
-0.0032322141,
0.0112223998,
-0.0400227532,
-0.0048963148,
0.0657091737,
-0.0298644248,
0.0261962879,
0.0551989563,
-0.0046941093,
-0.0311479233,
-0.0090560336,
0.0545058213,
-0.0426052213,
-0.0226254631,
0.0200925674,
-0.0250025447,
-0.0030936734,
-0.046304632,
-0.031288363,
0.0505239554,
-0.0131078623,
0.0375168659,
0.0090743499,
-0.0087157851,
-0.006809514,
-0.0371862762,
-0.0051613036,
0.0204020943,
0.0359088071,
-0.0184646435,
-0.0206029024,
0.0087741828,
0.0146429557,
-0.0909562558,
-0.0031691587,
0.0384848602,
-0.0305461809,
0.0165485255,
-0.0794454142,
-0.0190840308,
0.0156983044,
-0.0339957736,
0.039562691,
-0.020608006,
-0.0007664536,
-0.0159895327,
-0.0274720229,
0.0284030531,
-0.0021475325,
0.0067448006,
-0.0274353232,
0.0500105843,
-0.0439480469,
-0.0226331148,
-0.059531156,
0.0247752201,
-0.0435764827,
-0.0454303734,
-0.0640000999,
0.0184197873,
0.0266351048,
-0.0037202034,
0.0404836237,
0.0443779826,
-0.0445764512,
0.0118761938,
0.0117874295,
-0.039728757,
-0.0362510942,
-0.0163005404,
0.036683064,
-0.00413675,
-0.0075022951,
0.0426207222,
0.0083543109,
0.0029155503,
-0.0244217012,
0.0798957497,
-0.0371988155,
-0.0007242868,
-0.0318740457,
-0.0248689111,
-0.0280165374,
-0.0491855741,
0.039016977,
-0.044060912,
-0.0160731636,
-0.0421345606,
-0.0194867272,
-0.0037009232,
0.0280452017,
0.0370727852,
0.0102660367,
0.0140722813,
-0.0251075551,
-0.0118599674,
0.0032742938,
-0.0038474232,
0.0859555528,
0.0280392319,
0.0673126206,
0.0987451971,
-0.0147391912,
-0.0242850035,
0.0036620318,
0.0187702812,
0.019539278,
-0.0246252101,
0.0055697444,
-0.0321983844,
-0.0809725523,
0.0365230106,
0.0018842944,
0.0506510772,
-0.0323174037,
-0.0097562661,
0.0311390404,
-0.0049220803,
0.0303024594,
0.0426181741,
0.096440345,
-0.0176946744,
-0.0338952541,
0.061523851,
0.0236105118,
0.044488214,
0.0035325759,
0.02320184,
-0.0242082924,
0.0283674728,
-0.0214682221,
-0.0381185189,
0.0283467136,
-0.0020817232,
0.0196354929,
-0.0568970367,
0.0382364541,
0.0956720784,
-0.0633699372,
0.0046000751,
-0.0105663752,
-0.0464919023,
-0.0243346505,
-0.0263224989,
-0.0121700168,
0.0285845846,
0.0527746603,
0.0178658403,
0.0062750764,
0.0019902976,
-0.0200308822,
0.0897584334,
-0.0081132296,
-0.007451423,
0.0015302539,
-0.039120689,
-0.0025172625,
-0.0234635435,
-0.0032329115,
0.0542520545,
-0.0560580716,
0.0145092886,
0.0333847515,
-0.0047516441,
-0.025913408,
0.0511037074,
-0.0235254597,
-0.0247877166,
0.027598951,
0.0086057223,
0.0286925677,
-0.0011265493,
-0.0250225961,
0.0375145003,
0.0315232985,
-0.0322486423,
-0.0515431613,
0.0271811448,
-0.090060398,
-0.0614210814,
0.0081149982,
-0.0647049248,
-0.0080203442,
0.0104917251,
-0.0434484743,
-0.0594986193,
0.0157661568,
-0.0594394021,
0.0091532329,
-0.0390788056,
0.030704543,
0.051580485,
0.0294290576,
-0.0204255339,
0.0884768665,
-0.0145072741,
-0.0020910881,
-0.0122480718,
0.0110944621,
0.034270931,
-0.0264531504,
0.0327797979,
0.0050517698,
-0.0083241398,
-0.0100282431,
0.0259863678,
0.0392595902,
-0.0345012061,
-0.0093884477,
-0.0202222317,
-0.0069707641,
-0.025794616,
0.0095521649,
0.0180153083,
0.0008642307,
-0.0046263402,
-0.0258564427,
-0.0512933545,
0.0562679842,
0.0289217178,
-0.015381827,
0.0540147275,
-0.0304995868,
-0.0339643136,
-0.0334630348,
-0.0139332479,
-0.0097731194,
0.0503084101,
0.0318146013,
-0.0322351344,
-0.0334664695,
0.0137926331,
-0.0304699168,
0.0230750591,
0.0023058886,
-0.0336799622,
0.0342760049,
0.000425904,
0.09559232,
0.0287771337,
0.0616503097,
0.0669459552,
0.0141599337,
-0.0136432964,
0.0271304827,
0.0092831692,
-0.0432480611,
0.0401241332,
0.0044915508,
-0.0431833491,
0.0493899174,
0.093013078,
0.0425768904,
0.0100639407,
-0.0541287102,
0.0188159887,
0.0288502704,
-0.0430871323,
0.0027845548,
-0.0142152887,
-0.0125972303,
0.0130532645,
-0.0360575095,
-0.036766354,
0.0614187606,
-0.0443216637,
-0.0149698928,
-0.007514304,
-0.0040406142,
-0.0030336543,
0.0942870006,
0.0799792185,
0.0237849616,
0.0471853875,
-0.0234029796,
-0.0588140264,
0.0302974936,
0.0346463174,
0.0000498446,
-0.0215132497,
-0.0383080579,
0.0054928507,
-0.0220026392,
-0.0082708374,
-0.0559891649,
-0.031962581,
0.0345603973,
-0.005904228,
0.0187070258,
-0.0108908573,
-0.0200711209,
0.0096644294,
-0.0092918687,
0.0219689459,
-0.0218834672,
-0.028706735,
-0.0187079422,
0.0881276205,
0.0677776933,
-0.0339232758,
-0.0367043242,
-0.0367629938,
0.0424702391,
0.0466965474,
-0.0313324034,
0.0595139861,
-0.0405818485,
-0.0036557389,
-0.0318914875,
-0.0006963022,
-0.0357438065,
0.0312073138,
0.010794796,
-0.0342276469,
-0.0237575993,
0.0585822426,
0.0334159248,
0.006076321,
0.0306645781,
-0.0134918187,
0.0739899427,
0.0039816387,
0.0036869366,
-0.0731673688,
0.0193535015,
-0.015107167,
0.0045521064,
-0.0144747151,
-0.007258167,
-0.0140645402,
-0.1047537699,
0.0703041106,
0.0155822206,
-0.0401293747,
-0.0332646072,
0.0181313455,
-0.0397563986,
0.0548170581,
-0.0172207206,
0.0091474252,
0.0132776629,
0.0292056929,
0.031878829,
-0.0243575089,
-0.0033117435,
-0.030815402,
0.0072170799,
0.0029339134,
0.0998625904,
0.0777734593,
0.0216661487,
-0.0325038657,
-0.0158519223,
-0.0005688512,
0.0245373305,
-0.0033124515,
0.0362456106,
0.0368974917,
-0.0177718494,
-0.0069398223,
0.0128376093,
-0.0104558868,
-0.0070395344,
0.0343800113,
0.0377641246,
-0.0360891335,
-0.0766184926,
-0.0459800176,
0.0216020755,
0.0198918525,
0.0165747497,
0.0391530395,
-0.0100212311,
-0.0696613416,
-0.0457045138,
0.0633354336,
-0.0653652474,
-0.0701145232,
0.0295573827,
0.0099817906,
-0.0460756607,
-0.1087782234,
-0.0522979088,
-0.0113201188,
0.0775136873,
-0.0233387519,
-0.0153990025,
-0.0312085208,
-0.0374110676,
-0.0114116864,
-0.0599910133,
0.0106227193,
0.0014510921,
-0.0146630136,
-0.0360481478,
0.0327945277,
-0.0292324945,
-0.0215922259,
0.0160364583,
-0.0591885708,
-0.0607435368,
-0.0152397417,
0.0679158717,
0.0129399057,
0.0074850251,
-0.0109052137,
-0.0102719124,
0.0334249139,
0.0571740083,
0.0192594603,
-0.000247998,
0.0131966695,
-0.0227393247,
-0.0138838971,
0.0017105498,
-0.0173009597,
0.0623488538,
-0.0050995806,
0.0667410493,
-0.0155519443,
-0.0060332636,
0.0536647253,
0.0082013393,
0.0060912836,
-0.0455615781,
0.0092361346,
-0.0203232784,
0.0094605098,
-0.062604636,
-0.0198615976,
-0.0450974815,
0.0337956734,
0.0133337434,
0.0302372444,
0.0031573996,
-0.0265268274,
-0.0144944191,
0.0083829323,
-0.0113809826,
-0.0145024071,
0.0476256981,
0.0510768555,
-0.001405172,
-0.0085614836,
-0.0027141192,
-0.022351617,
-0.010764055,
0.0405190252,
0.0105115306,
0.0423782878,
0.0179764312,
0.0281414203,
-0.0029139798,
0.024520237,
-0.0458820648,
-0.0063455529,
-0.0511404313,
0.0410076305,
0.0850207657,
0.0297587682,
0.0529414266,
-0.0455177426,
0.0324875377,
0.0036428715,
0.0378407985,
0.0221630707,
-0.077407591,
-0.0147740664,
0.004345296,
-0.0191795304,
-0.040061377,
0.0843761489,
0.0257786624,
0.007127319,
0.0056594508,
0.0024619431,
-0.0624818616,
-0.0325416066,
-0.0212424453,
-0.0373132601,
0.0298633482,
0.0126217306,
-0.0170362089,
-0.066908367,
-0.0059784469,
0.0312675834,
0.0605786256,
0.0040123952,
0.0838386789,
0.034910921,
-0.0175439864,
0.0095004942,
-0.034975715,
0.0288796145,
-0.01517634,
-0.0057115844,
-0.0505876504,
-5.848808794e-33,
-0.068303518,
-0.0263819229,
0.0067253802,
-0.0057348297,
-0.0422882512,
-0.0430750661,
-0.0725719556,
0.0024792806,
0.0430370271,
0.0134333894,
0.0113712959,
-0.0098765595,
0.0037728758,
0.0457861461,
0.0136566954,
0.0122226672,
0.072011292,
-0.0050988803,
-0.0156476721,
0.0393018164,
0.0215356275,
0.026627114,
0.027666403,
-0.0254588798,
-0.0287464503,
-0.0305154137,
-0.0260050148,
-0.0356890149,
-0.01398433,
-0.0052734739,
-0.0021976582,
0.0099664321,
0.012837478,
0.0007452997,
-0.0344199128,
-0.002476664,
-0.0379205458,
-0.035869509,
-0.0213261507,
-0.0107345264,
-0.0906354934,
-0.014260225,
0.0396551304,
-0.0394697636,
0.0373826697,
0.0071725864,
0.0605176762,
0.0073555913,
-0.0445698574,
-0.0809834898,
-0.0862044767,
-0.0013108115,
-0.0224209093,
-0.0258377716,
-0.0362636745,
0.0584361143,
0.005291455,
-0.0026233476,
-0.0119943209,
0.0448886678,
0.0125169093,
0.0283352546,
0.0218675956,
0.0160296671,
0.0233696271,
0.0513431318,
0.0531165041,
-0.0148299532,
-0.0572298914,
0.0711473972,
-0.0258433614,
0.0473514013,
0.0308831353,
0.0130080208,
0.0413809456,
-0.0083441772,
-0.0676548108,
0.0298756193,
0.0110839019,
0.0286858417,
0.0110664694,
0.012835443,
0.0364602804,
-0.0013277046,
0.0181727353,
-0.0419466719,
0.0311247911,
-0.0445929319,
0.0291662011,
0.0215760693,
-0.0140969809,
-0.0548934937,
-0.0107493103,
-0.0007624118,
0.0002531607,
0.021148378,
-0.0524360575,
0.0159488041,
-0.0139932344,
0.0264210831,
-0.0039403704,
-0.0368507281,
0.0514022708,
0.0311655998,
0.0172040425,
0.0303946454,
0.0045504426,
0.0145765459,
-0.0295011718,
-0.0056521259,
-0.0139098167,
0.0422807522,
0.0101119149,
0.0194721296,
0.0153445462,
-0.0338265449,
-0.0462710448,
0.0087262541,
-0.0018597442,
-0.0074204658,
-0.0146969194,
0.0162959937,
-0.004509646,
0.028900519,
-0.0223068502,
0.0010227937,
-0.0428720191,
0.0088171707,
0.0464133956,
-0.0952826738,
-0.0388767011,
0.0030234538,
2.811e-7,
-0.001251199,
0.0080907429,
0.0458262488,
0.0412920639,
0.0261331853,
-0.0103597324,
-0.0028882455,
0.0292233359,
-0.0029258884,
-0.0327721685,
0.0108732311,
-0.0258080065,
0.0425681286,
0.0338786654,
-0.0949362665,
0.0473911688,
-0.110117428,
0.0048059174,
-0.0287406053,
-0.0102869971,
0.050242085,
0.0500834845,
-0.0303946175,
-0.0072064553,
0.0428162552,
0.0156622268,
0.0545882098,
0.047276035,
0.0255971812,
-0.0216773581,
0.0150778824,
-0.0264764968,
-0.0217596255,
0.0012864671,
-0.0240821335,
-0.0037004992,
0.0130019877,
-0.002226142,
-0.0227973219,
0.0020998376,
0.0344074294,
0.0095842183,
0.0227997359,
-0.00104814,
0.0304837041,
-0.0561428517,
-0.0374139398,
-0.0007451908,
-0.0377340131,
0.0384943224,
0.0128627615,
-0.0136824157,
-0.0425836928,
0.0088124108,
0.0223756377,
-0.0102428896,
0.0266475249,
-0.0296278168,
-0.0142160011,
-0.0125792623,
-0.0558767617,
0.0003602319,
-0.0391702354,
0.0583142154,
0.0093461899,
0.0430840701,
-0.0501480512,
2.332462038e-34,
0.0269264709,
-0.0131072383,
-0.0037600172,
-0.0020430028,
-0.0098683452,
-0.0058150585,
0.0261730161,
0.0300373062,
0.0160312634,
-0.0271344464,
-0.0731662288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14177v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14177v1 | SimulSeamless: FBK at IWSLT 2024 Simultaneous Speech Translation | 2024-06-20T10:34:46 | 2024-06-20T10:34:46 | Sara Papi, Marco Gaido, Matteo Negri, Luisa Bentivogli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper describes the FBK's participation in the Simultaneous Translation
Evaluation Campaign at IWSLT 2024. For this year's submission in the
speech-to-text translation (ST) sub-track, we propose SimulSeamless, which is
realized by combining AlignAtt and SeamlessM4T in its medium configuration. The
SeamlessM4T model is used "off-the-shelf" and its simultaneous inference is
enabled through the adoption of AlignAtt, a SimulST policy based on
cross-attention that can be applied without any retraining or adaptation of the
underlying model for the simultaneous task. We participated in all the Shared
Task languages (English->{German, Japanese, Chinese}, and Czech->English),
achieving acceptable or even better results compared to last year's
submissions. SimulSeamless, covering more than 143 source languages and 200
target languages, is released at: https://github.com/hlt-mt/FBK-fairseq/. | [
-0.0087973522,
0.0245528296,
0.0145126143,
0.031674806,
-0.0345797911,
-0.0106164031,
0.0401024148,
-0.0373970717,
-0.0046126414,
0.0204953868,
-0.1049202606,
-0.0310112648,
0.0333258137,
-0.025846662,
0.0304446574,
-0.0517233014,
0.0589746423,
-0.0333180912,
-0.0338223651,
0.0093144346,
0.0011119751,
0.0312854461,
-0.0333211385,
0.0274645612,
-0.0149990292,
-0.0408471636,
0.0042158896,
0.0403519832,
0.0572038144,
-0.0255007576,
0.0060464884,
0.0083188154,
0.0181074869,
0.0530360341,
0.0000017704,
-0.0314133167,
-0.0240934826,
0.0108086606,
0.0014161741,
-0.0055872635,
0.036864046,
-0.0535655282,
0.0027562114,
0.0317472219,
-0.0106942607,
-0.0269675348,
0.0411176383,
0.0328162722,
0.0531908385,
0.0863660574,
-0.0134412041,
-0.0495388024,
0.0119464146,
-0.0621581115,
-0.0365916006,
-0.0634732917,
-0.0234221984,
-0.0204920974,
-0.0446779765,
-0.0063127675,
-0.02149841,
0.0734159797,
0.0310497358,
0.0072109974,
-0.0389522649,
0.0117333634,
-0.0151050976,
-0.0596378706,
-0.0211319104,
0.0793026909,
-0.0073807179,
0.000926268,
-0.0039776224,
-0.0109510543,
-0.0209791008,
-0.0279383957,
-0.0650395304,
0.0263825413,
0.0008550981,
-0.0138436295,
0.0409615003,
0.0492866077,
0.0279351454,
-0.0151833426,
-0.0002589008,
0.0443145633,
0.0245195311,
-0.0308004878,
0.0191283878,
0.0001951118,
-0.0105011081,
-0.0160991848,
0.0420679599,
0.000619491,
-0.0442549698,
0.006808097,
-0.072113961,
-0.0496493168,
-0.0181025341,
-0.0330568887,
0.0194392651,
0.0856125504,
-0.0294390712,
0.0340042301,
-0.0005176715,
0.0523853227,
-0.044004254,
0.0006170704,
-0.063466154,
-0.0133391107,
0.0103212204,
0.0360742398,
-0.0530520007,
-0.0103458557,
-0.0724606141,
-0.0373221673,
-0.0391573496,
0.0097508142,
-0.0229209661,
-0.0003338181,
0.0475035608,
-0.0354965031,
-0.1183661222,
-0.0180091746,
0.029943116,
0.0801767036,
0.0079503283,
-0.0035797709,
0.0058347937,
-0.0286509674,
-0.0568491891,
0.0454134829,
-0.015521992,
-0.0679688826,
-0.010867455,
0.0692555979,
-0.0259047225,
-0.0208736174,
-0.0099062705,
-0.0128182955,
-0.0143026449,
-0.0639447421,
0.0011076811,
-0.0252082758,
0.0580399334,
-0.0288850721,
0.0226113368,
0.0004780659,
-0.0133845033,
-0.0199035518,
0.0085456222,
0.061544396,
-0.0026700667,
-0.0000013923,
-0.0001975604,
0.0069477041,
-0.0171246063,
0.1025800183,
0.0008299522,
0.0151821934,
0.003816281,
0.0191132668,
-0.0461944714,
0.0759359673,
0.0229827929,
0.0162815955,
-0.0313549414,
0.0081089167,
0.0235405564,
0.0398144051,
0.0587792359,
0.031757798,
-0.0354749225,
-0.007199428,
0.0632299855,
0.0038661771,
0.0263221357,
0.0401664712,
0.0784358084,
0.0160818398,
-0.0199123845,
0.029235037,
-0.0347298011,
0.0409458727,
0.0154346703,
0.0366724096,
0.075669229,
0.0407163389,
-0.0256686378,
-0.0283203311,
-0.0013595071,
-0.0132861771,
-0.0260904264,
-0.013676391,
0.0393490493,
-0.00678484,
-0.0362484977,
0.0701079592,
0.006351742,
-0.0306655467,
0.0088746678,
-0.0223225988,
-0.0157097466,
0.0428002775,
0.0120319976,
0.0060511599,
-0.0685944408,
-0.0232786685,
0.039747294,
0.0656156167,
0.079468146,
0.0101467427,
0.0742614642,
-0.0512303375,
-0.0056500658,
0.0136757325,
0.0090104491,
0.0163652673,
-0.0022582947,
0.0411510244,
0.0304661784,
0.0368628353,
0.0274506826,
-0.0090065002,
-0.0314091854,
0.0191973634,
0.0071258522,
0.0058424417,
0.0177260861,
0.0288640801,
-0.0157044698,
0.0245120991,
0.0145675046,
-0.0343296304,
0.0195966456,
0.0677464828,
-0.0334492736,
-0.0482501239,
0.0466056429,
-0.0360520259,
-0.009116644,
0.0643057302,
-0.0299936999,
-0.0509497561,
0.0021876332,
-0.0088942479,
0.0213468336,
-0.0263574105,
0.0346252993,
0.0438506901,
0.032852035,
-0.0030644366,
0.0240242369,
0.0063341279,
0.0157976244,
0.0439554155,
-0.0359342657,
0.0053967466,
-0.0580506139,
0.0023625747,
0.0272833761,
-0.003923879,
0.0073102489,
-0.0165747721,
0.0180501994,
-0.036284294,
-0.026900664,
-0.0853597075,
0.0438730605,
-0.0269572474,
0.0549652055,
0.0466552526,
0.0414252244,
-0.0137683749,
-0.0066100024,
-0.0113817574,
-0.0074964352,
0.0157983173,
-0.0040352754,
-0.0372818597,
-0.0292673279,
0.0131075485,
-0.0124203619,
-0.0130308997,
0.0043936917,
-0.0076940139,
-0.0114868209,
-0.0091963243,
-0.0485187359,
-0.0272725746,
-0.010865082,
0.0092401253,
-0.0061603771,
-0.0339682996,
-0.0143690482,
-0.022217663,
0.0357925743,
0.0399608016,
-0.015973676,
0.0165201481,
-0.0169669278,
-0.0335156061,
-0.0440061428,
0.0499232486,
0.0105901649,
0.0128649995,
-0.0196991283,
-0.0006363247,
-0.0017971151,
0.0571775213,
-0.000922406,
0.0070664277,
-0.0522164926,
-0.0276595782,
-0.0005933898,
0.0040274658,
0.0045214603,
0.0013652134,
-0.021237012,
-0.0186256934,
-0.0138515336,
-0.042034924,
0.054197263,
-0.0674390867,
-0.0345915779,
-0.0799874216,
0.0165033061,
-0.0018586622,
0.0496927723,
-0.0605672635,
-0.0024468291,
-0.0475595593,
-0.0434271507,
-0.0378405079,
0.0013430577,
0.007739698,
-0.0284509584,
0.0360333547,
-0.0249374937,
0.0096068149,
-0.0583176725,
-0.0024011051,
-0.0210488271,
-0.0663083196,
-0.029669309,
0.0015881271,
-0.0103744287,
-0.015226556,
-0.0405011848,
0.0049742376,
0.0015302722,
0.0599531941,
-0.0327547416,
0.0304232221,
-0.0047100112,
0.0523697175,
0.0257107876,
0.0295196511,
0.0036335841,
-0.0681974366,
0.0204182304,
0.0152696976,
0.0702824593,
0.0096776728,
-0.027970979,
-0.0175491776,
0.0495060347,
-0.0035986679,
-0.0223178659,
-0.0358124115,
0.0693767667,
-0.0582924858,
0.0256337952,
0.1031429172,
-0.0063486462,
-0.0271312203,
0.0018445385,
-0.0049020592,
0.0392898694,
-0.0015353361,
0.022678718,
-0.0733347312,
-0.0458752923,
0.0165650714,
0.0127525246,
0.0489216335,
0.0356757008,
-0.0286850873,
-0.0640372336,
0.0297042336,
0.051849667,
-0.0173254535,
-0.0610562302,
0.0364031643,
-0.0223680753,
-0.0238462128,
0.0546294376,
0.0036115972,
0.0088464869,
-0.002200817,
0.0038964909,
0.027207328,
-0.0467482619,
-0.0011336633,
-0.0213767178,
0.0637458637,
0.0237485021,
0.0101736933,
0.0000417944,
-0.0854951367,
0.0783915147,
-0.0445670374,
-0.0222900584,
-0.0179239959,
-0.0025943734,
-0.0305250008,
-0.0357927755,
0.007108984,
0.0064917165,
-0.0090557914,
0.0059911716,
0.0192267913,
0.0560750887,
-0.0256860908,
0.020654669,
0.0222062543,
0.0259424485,
0.009500687,
0.0521884784,
0.0180416871,
-0.0078704869,
0.0162153784,
0.0028029694,
-0.0071937153,
-0.0789509937,
0.0041018394,
0.0143005038,
-0.0125695197,
-0.0586124845,
-0.0327894613,
-0.0407598652,
0.0077354698,
0.0704815984,
0.0029029711,
0.0071099144,
-0.0440575257,
0.019438386,
-0.0192156192,
0.0658373535,
-0.0174781121,
0.0466184616,
-0.0272775665,
0.0125285629,
0.0258744527,
-0.0516926646,
0.0039201253,
0.0753810927,
-0.0979458019,
-0.0788509175,
-0.0396447629,
0.0365504585,
0.0242163297,
0.076784648,
-0.0674769655,
-0.0087891389,
0.0077928072,
-0.029327048,
-0.0658902302,
0.0107162809,
0.0574863777,
-0.0186527055,
0.0037094981,
0.0543066896,
0.0103117069,
-0.0022204318,
0.0039011303,
0.0632419288,
0.0380459279,
-0.035665717,
-0.0160769857,
0.0205298644,
0.0252127685,
0.0087724524,
0.0074686985,
-0.0268622581,
0.0374077857,
0.0072582853,
0.0031516927,
-0.0412212946,
-0.001204143,
0.0293330587,
-0.0104330163,
-0.0047126706,
0.0048904903,
0.0004869292,
-0.0404598005,
-0.0140862847,
0.0201057978,
-0.0407045223,
0.031501282,
-0.004921793,
-0.0024693978,
-0.0367338136,
0.0275710933,
-0.0003525346,
0.0149784712,
-0.0313016772,
0.0642367005,
-0.0049262405,
0.0124010043,
0.0222480576,
0.0310660861,
-0.0395500436,
0.0087103015,
-0.0297282133,
0.0137381526,
0.0579479598,
0.0113384239,
0.1339362264,
0.0124336267,
-0.0035026635,
-0.0059101665,
0.0718130022,
-0.0405490324,
-0.0036008046,
0.0053775022,
-0.0189015307,
-0.0018896715,
0.0064148679,
0.0535996221,
-0.0426050872,
-0.0160446838,
0.0189677645,
0.0042943051,
-0.0112652918,
-0.081830129,
0.0220410675,
-0.0095667196,
-0.0273861326,
-0.0381003693,
-0.0157020092,
-0.0604701787,
0.0277313162,
0.0509309135,
-0.0368044227,
-0.0130492887,
-0.0091546057,
0.0532682799,
-0.0273943767,
-0.0082667656,
-0.0085575758,
0.0137188518,
0.0143634556,
-0.0162011962,
-0.008364209,
-6.142712871e-33,
-0.0461012721,
0.0521460772,
0.0263375137,
-0.0491380133,
-0.1282908022,
-0.0085399672,
-0.0355634578,
-0.0340578109,
-0.0085133826,
-0.0026465794,
0.0096005294,
0.0273121577,
0.0396747552,
0.0155392149,
0.0060145855,
-0.0261069369,
0.0484650694,
0.0071473946,
-0.0401947238,
0.045066949,
-0.0054880804,
0.0049888724,
0.0860783979,
-0.0260135271,
0.0003895826,
-0.0027337507,
-0.0125486674,
0.0229487307,
-0.0397689976,
0.0603007153,
0.0069342866,
0.003232951,
0.0078255767,
-0.0423300005,
-0.0386358537,
0.0049395813,
-0.0694554374,
-0.0061252364,
0.0349596627,
0.0559587777,
-0.0448642708,
-0.0341518186,
0.0399155095,
-0.0071766819,
0.010455884,
-0.0464377031,
-0.010684819,
-0.0348813199,
-0.0123427492,
-0.0130256182,
-0.0293039884,
0.0216101799,
-0.0181524865,
0.0020758733,
0.0632521436,
0.0631431341,
-0.0005850788,
-0.0428480059,
-0.0527914502,
0.0079169925,
-0.0189314168,
0.0477445982,
0.0874755234,
-0.0166294351,
-0.0238847695,
-0.0077564442,
0.0067503513,
-0.0610324852,
0.0340561271,
-0.027312493,
0.0286931489,
0.0200203359,
0.0296487771,
0.0326153859,
-0.0136714512,
-0.0021271594,
-0.0163673684,
0.0201183464,
0.0560320467,
-0.0042481143,
0.0191501286,
-0.0023366765,
-0.010242898,
0.0129032498,
-0.012690085,
-0.0000196685,
-0.0340961069,
-0.0207053646,
0.0281740353,
0.0065167323,
0.0042555528,
0.0335334912,
0.111360006,
-0.0017992471,
0.0354025699,
0.0078406818,
0.0073943916,
0.0086452868,
-0.041148331,
0.0513173677,
-0.0247300696,
-0.0356339552,
0.001682763,
0.0605385751,
0.0189270191,
-0.008254583,
0.0137205087,
0.0325004533,
-0.0301704872,
-0.0129892677,
-0.0247280952,
0.0099500474,
-0.0432520956,
0.0097172819,
0.056567207,
-0.0163190011,
-0.007939592,
0.034008,
0.0115769338,
-0.0257705599,
-0.0242822375,
0.0108309118,
0.0297854077,
0.0436446257,
-0.0084911911,
0.038313929,
-0.003232307,
-0.0353187248,
0.0162127782,
-0.0609250925,
-0.0189848077,
0.0344849899,
2.506e-7,
0.0169791672,
-0.0271704234,
0.0173970144,
-0.0036986156,
0.0099975187,
0.0007120084,
-0.0561222695,
0.0455319583,
0.0065128743,
0.0523008294,
0.0315873064,
-0.0079224398,
0.1193738431,
0.0125411656,
-0.0629896,
-0.0428286493,
-0.0501793474,
0.0442203954,
-0.0515468717,
-0.0037969449,
0.0459495485,
0.0923891068,
-0.0137726814,
0.0184925105,
0.0115813371,
0.02034867,
0.0397189111,
0.0115933958,
-0.0307717156,
-0.0274992846,
-0.0162953716,
-0.0453962982,
-0.0509362668,
0.0214061514,
-0.0357708968,
0.0322047323,
0.0364982672,
0.0879779086,
0.0119869495,
-0.0309080333,
0.0134197287,
0.0276310518,
-0.0142245749,
-0.0315914638,
0.055543106,
-0.0660516471,
-0.0017461955,
0.0274750125,
-0.0412720367,
0.0198886599,
-0.0130413705,
-0.0204771142,
-0.0236676037,
0.0263264719,
0.048568774,
-0.0182641726,
-0.0381791443,
-0.0429482423,
-0.025442753,
-0.0280518103,
-0.0596206449,
-0.0492919683,
-0.0281564053,
0.0077086631,
0.0019795594,
-0.0460911617,
-0.033572454,
2.168134127e-34,
0.0461949296,
-0.047734905,
0.0296349674,
-0.0059529259,
-0.0062229163,
-0.0399379879,
0.0170430616,
0.0036737185,
-0.003215502,
-0.0626882687,
-0.0491331778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14171v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14171v1 | Ranking LLMs by compression | 2024-06-20T10:23:38 | 2024-06-20T10:23:38 | Peijia Guo, Ziguang Li, Haibo Hu, Chao Huang, Ming Li, Rui Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We conceptualize the process of understanding as information compression, and
propose a method for ranking large language models (LLMs) based on lossless
data compression. We demonstrate the equivalence of compression length under
arithmetic coding with cumulative negative log probabilities when using a large
language model as a prior, that is, the pre-training phase of the model is
essentially the process of learning the optimal coding length. At the same
time, the evaluation metric compression ratio can be obtained without actual
compression, which greatly saves overhead. In this paper, we use five large
language models as priors for compression, then compare their performance on
challenging natural language processing tasks, including sentence completion,
question answering, and coreference resolution. Experimental results show that
compression ratio and model performance are positively correlated, so it can be
used as a general metric to evaluate large language models. | [
0.0134014618,
0.0659676641,
0.0180397443,
0.034956485,
-0.0373327285,
0.0326590091,
-0.0227123201,
0.0478415936,
-0.043795485,
-0.0659857392,
-0.0430297889,
-0.0473215282,
0.0259119123,
-0.0372831635,
0.0250434913,
0.0065648728,
0.0354052298,
-0.0137715805,
0.008936408,
0.013955934,
-0.0433789976,
-0.0366384499,
0.0341101214,
0.0228601005,
0.0294125564,
0.0090695685,
-0.0101319067,
-0.0028955252,
0.0065185768,
-0.0004967537,
-0.044612553,
0.0281675104,
0.0393750705,
0.0037518817,
0.0000016397,
-0.0536827967,
-0.0155197587,
0.0135330996,
-0.0777007639,
0.0130685456,
0.0358530395,
-0.0193247236,
0.0157899074,
0.0133500248,
-0.0311522949,
-0.0194748603,
0.0444944464,
0.0536563508,
0.0592254214,
0.0588531122,
0.0138955927,
-0.0548675805,
0.0298658516,
-0.0530970357,
0.0149109447,
-0.0459390022,
0.0153870266,
0.0666145608,
-0.0053936266,
0.0311464667,
-0.034894783,
0.0310029276,
0.0353122689,
0.0327899121,
0.0148101337,
0.0218211468,
-0.0202102531,
-0.0163371395,
0.0260610562,
0.0641753897,
-0.0023348776,
-0.0116795758,
-0.0194723234,
0.0326052681,
0.0043616649,
-0.0452943705,
-0.0863201544,
0.0485027283,
0.0434061401,
0.0426371433,
0.0026658024,
0.011676426,
0.0329571031,
0.0192608666,
-0.0440222286,
0.0878604129,
-0.0072026425,
-0.0113564208,
0.0187134184,
-0.0283388924,
-0.0556965619,
-0.0484188683,
-0.0313207693,
0.0325537436,
0.0403208137,
0.0304804295,
-0.0354683697,
0.0062208693,
0.0189702287,
-0.0692227557,
0.0362278298,
0.0395479016,
0.034680225,
0.0515806489,
-0.0671835467,
0.0818960369,
0.0119585712,
0.0299261697,
-0.0594885759,
-0.0053527635,
-0.0228165854,
0.0068840203,
-0.0012800376,
0.0761272684,
-0.019701736,
-0.0228172,
-0.0311978087,
0.0151877338,
0.0279751942,
0.0106187025,
0.0512830913,
-0.0087245284,
-0.005065457,
-0.0168633964,
-0.0351784676,
0.0067734681,
0.002632923,
0.0241785944,
-0.0302657112,
-0.0426822044,
-0.0168570057,
0.0153979575,
-0.0106412591,
-0.0099643357,
0.0319078527,
0.0409543216,
-0.0123282559,
-0.0476940349,
-0.0188457519,
-0.0022181079,
0.0006211505,
-0.0642799512,
-0.0129937232,
-0.0661217868,
0.0085944654,
0.023661986,
0.0135368621,
-0.0551434159,
0.0121522583,
0.0117388312,
-0.058103539,
0.0581595972,
0.0255956184,
0.0219964422,
0.0192936845,
0.0126540931,
0.0453799926,
0.071900472,
0.0474824309,
0.0166811086,
0.0205563325,
-0.0160491727,
-0.0328382328,
0.0118537936,
0.031595286,
0.0161943473,
-0.0321654454,
0.032560721,
-0.0150226364,
0.0001539482,
0.0435526855,
0.0513911881,
-0.0557687804,
-0.0709370971,
0.0565267652,
0.0430259369,
0.0437051617,
0.0137723461,
0.0077468688,
-0.0005319228,
0.0136621594,
0.0237904675,
-0.0404187925,
0.0180251673,
-0.0583334938,
0.0220750943,
0.0782946572,
-0.0413556173,
-0.0343955643,
-0.072360225,
-0.0515119247,
-0.0354861356,
0.0289450493,
0.0063302168,
0.0440796316,
-0.0184326805,
-0.0220868774,
0.0554916486,
-0.0087999282,
-0.0444302708,
-0.0098314881,
-0.0630138665,
-0.0044958577,
0.0110069597,
0.0275619011,
0.0023032338,
-0.015504811,
-0.013635397,
-0.0064742016,
-0.0101993326,
0.0028942053,
-0.0043374584,
0.0277236272,
-0.0513448715,
-0.0298840646,
0.0036575929,
0.0081212334,
-0.0096342554,
0.0068933894,
-0.0078193443,
0.0255805608,
-0.0847056285,
-0.0138650956,
0.0304736923,
-0.0317201652,
-0.0318821929,
0.0228639543,
-0.0170902722,
0.0697139427,
-0.0102582732,
-0.0308960602,
0.0313712098,
0.0530929416,
-0.0574062839,
-0.0356717557,
-0.0296804328,
-0.0478027575,
-0.0391312726,
0.0263720211,
-0.028281251,
0.0427685529,
0.0520838164,
-0.0374405086,
-0.0516911633,
0.0058977297,
-0.0538751259,
0.0583474487,
-0.0482939035,
0.0123330308,
0.016214801,
0.0015901988,
-0.0479909703,
0.0734055266,
-0.0623119064,
0.0367814302,
0.0320642814,
-0.0082445722,
0.0282837953,
-0.0321428403,
-0.0207620505,
0.0135363806,
-0.0436253436,
-0.0059356303,
0.0206484925,
0.0075837201,
-0.0130496155,
-0.0241135284,
-0.084606111,
-0.002196088,
-0.0141995829,
0.0202540215,
0.0186530817,
-0.0077310652,
0.0114773847,
-0.0251041111,
-0.0436842665,
0.0046786433,
0.0108100092,
0.0145594683,
0.0206165798,
0.0266373083,
-0.0108602718,
-0.0406824574,
-0.0599632077,
0.0254809055,
0.0896524116,
-0.0484014414,
-0.01684325,
-0.054591801,
0.0930090174,
-0.0388212204,
-0.004288408,
-0.0059375577,
-0.0606096983,
-0.0295677185,
-0.0225933548,
0.0086418018,
0.0915646628,
-0.0011086657,
0.0223017205,
0.0734920502,
0.0164765101,
-0.0536310561,
0.0006717464,
-0.0128055187,
-0.0327143967,
-0.03851863,
-0.0867340788,
-0.0203040969,
0.0766623318,
0.0107779633,
-0.0058843046,
-0.0690921471,
-0.0389913581,
-0.010385206,
-0.0229701586,
-0.0472699516,
-0.0088326829,
0.0191686638,
0.0739905611,
-0.0091370018,
-0.0697580799,
0.028567994,
-0.0475966968,
0.0063076345,
-0.019542288,
-0.0188363083,
-0.0567328259,
0.066990532,
0.0486315489,
0.0279504396,
0.0026799426,
-0.0114222337,
-0.051444523,
-0.0072434992,
0.0239374116,
-0.0537368804,
0.014745825,
-0.0312392022,
0.0255744923,
-0.042107407,
-0.0101950616,
-0.028783476,
-0.02932675,
-0.0052890605,
0.0205005705,
0.0075277966,
0.0023541315,
-0.0383379273,
0.0442168377,
0.0288703274,
0.0268919766,
0.0120911915,
0.0071844128,
0.0081467181,
0.0352097079,
0.0280556362,
0.030990703,
0.0599970147,
-0.0168070253,
0.0214172881,
0.0482146144,
0.0512520336,
0.0447234958,
-0.0173570551,
0.0025527603,
0.0411183685,
-0.0244079921,
-0.0610999875,
0.0469273627,
0.0290040188,
-0.0124422433,
-0.0024886115,
0.1446700096,
0.039749492,
-0.0307234507,
0.0014622998,
-0.0228032172,
0.016289033,
0.0291926321,
-0.0181440078,
-0.0686662644,
-0.0313260853,
0.0112103745,
-0.0022470176,
-0.0058119651,
-0.0256523751,
-0.0260325857,
-0.0897401646,
0.0096776364,
0.014422914,
0.02813752,
-0.021541236,
-0.0696018189,
0.0182346813,
-0.0477817543,
-0.0068449792,
0.0149240652,
-0.016308343,
-0.0014383834,
0.0065214718,
-0.0464079194,
-0.0418383926,
0.0079882219,
0.0182413291,
0.0363029353,
0.0448986553,
0.0237740222,
-0.0095444359,
-0.017105639,
0.0090744104,
-0.0019311904,
-0.010791935,
-0.0297007374,
0.0308636986,
0.0176359303,
0.0224441886,
0.0227970984,
0.0291434024,
-0.0262521766,
0.0070076264,
-0.0286089871,
0.0486627109,
-0.0175570901,
-0.0082412045,
-0.0098934034,
-0.0050399238,
-0.0434928797,
0.1112967506,
0.0505647659,
0.0001760382,
-0.0259144735,
-0.0111125698,
0.0049586501,
0.0228768829,
-0.0245715883,
0.0292854663,
0.0108983405,
-0.0228791591,
-0.0505477712,
0.0023616469,
0.0120777851,
0.0174767412,
-0.013218428,
0.0124371396,
-0.0076945256,
0.012217937,
-0.0655264333,
-0.0003268826,
-0.0221637301,
-0.0223543122,
-0.0973414555,
0.0284888744,
0.053461764,
-0.0050093313,
-0.0364651419,
0.0182474125,
-0.1076198891,
-0.0404488333,
-0.0486722849,
0.042533692,
0.0312127359,
0.0538932011,
0.0098637883,
-0.0605328195,
-0.001261679,
-0.0004470609,
-0.0448872708,
0.0582163148,
0.0427595489,
-0.0321104042,
0.0115514332,
0.0602631606,
-0.0394604132,
0.037927378,
0.0015973285,
0.0362648033,
-0.0537205748,
-0.0712034777,
0.0263967346,
0.0327737406,
0.0006151146,
-0.007463539,
-0.0093218507,
0.0370800421,
0.0357916877,
-0.0211525597,
0.003458946,
-0.0409546942,
0.0025826788,
0.0351882726,
0.0132824611,
0.0095771914,
0.0240336396,
-0.0011978761,
0.018750269,
-0.0002487972,
0.0146286516,
-0.0115093989,
-0.0309580639,
0.0112671005,
-0.0214197468,
-0.0411151834,
-0.0377328135,
0.0029290305,
0.026759034,
-0.0185038317,
0.0341730714,
-0.0190152731,
0.0183342453,
-0.0097246692,
0.0403675772,
-0.0706253797,
-0.0418403037,
-0.0311989989,
0.0183766317,
0.0598159395,
-0.0013410543,
0.049482286,
-0.0235515628,
0.0003562434,
-0.0447053239,
-0.0142567977,
0.0192325879,
0.0139539046,
0.0420799777,
0.0247644261,
-0.0050094421,
0.0232864786,
0.0908142328,
0.0423351415,
0.014939093,
-0.0178309307,
-0.004408021,
-0.0377322547,
-0.0247678366,
-0.0249174181,
0.0275095366,
0.0082886191,
0.0341302007,
-0.0218620002,
-0.0553924404,
0.0060947039,
-0.0129047083,
0.0052768108,
-0.026278235,
0.0374183767,
0.0461585782,
-0.0007909881,
0.0003054313,
-0.0200559106,
-0.0023997191,
0.0017144714,
-0.0101284645,
-0.0182218328,
-6.031719388e-33,
-0.0303495955,
-0.0055256402,
0.0053534466,
-0.0336571895,
0.0000354226,
0.013093139,
-0.0088357972,
-0.0013506293,
-0.0541284643,
-0.0209820494,
-0.009414671,
0.0148443216,
0.0035004241,
0.0360445753,
-0.0351677462,
-0.0001179571,
0.0426799059,
-0.0124713462,
-0.0207173191,
-0.0147523172,
0.0156309232,
-0.0009683215,
0.049788788,
-0.0306405313,
0.0027950073,
0.0180074312,
0.0060461783,
0.0167677421,
0.0267856941,
0.0707851276,
-0.0312641673,
0.0144658545,
0.0323918201,
-0.0769646019,
-0.0215707831,
0.0043317704,
-0.0761322603,
-0.0348826796,
0.054125905,
-0.018211009,
-0.0206034854,
-0.0466474742,
0.0524274819,
-0.0027062146,
-0.0227946788,
-0.0146822818,
0.0023878692,
-0.0660160705,
-0.0437889099,
-0.007541765,
-0.0044701658,
0.0371898673,
-0.0214895811,
-0.0183737464,
0.0599035099,
0.0584739968,
-0.0525762439,
0.0321712531,
-0.0256327558,
0.0302989464,
0.0256399084,
0.0798603073,
0.0508225523,
0.0068664211,
0.0095054861,
0.0227904171,
-0.0270966087,
-0.0476342514,
-0.0332017578,
-0.0222376771,
-0.0055077546,
0.0298711453,
0.0335006565,
0.0436555818,
0.0416790843,
0.0085991938,
-0.1071862653,
0.0269836485,
0.0153664686,
0.045416154,
0.0147594688,
0.0204130076,
-0.0348561071,
-0.0185129493,
-0.0803182498,
-0.0001976004,
-0.012629563,
-0.0356328748,
0.0294259563,
0.0023032383,
-0.002129792,
-0.0440550707,
0.0729543343,
-0.0620080382,
-0.0038422106,
0.047739502,
0.0157372095,
0.0332557857,
0.0207140688,
0.0426743515,
-0.0523622036,
0.0141062848,
0.0053392141,
-0.0086284401,
0.0062327469,
-0.0354924351,
0.0228325482,
0.0023543716,
-0.0396224074,
-0.0286188647,
-0.0025807342,
-0.0256388374,
-0.0113823181,
0.0247084331,
0.0496551134,
0.0198845919,
-0.009044989,
0.0562297292,
-0.0365914293,
0.002558005,
-0.0075969053,
-0.0240656268,
0.0377305709,
0.0331202969,
-0.0192942135,
0.0007136564,
-0.0336452089,
0.0270555671,
0.0371499993,
-0.0127716716,
-0.0283481684,
0.0470546931,
2.454e-7,
0.0425344221,
0.0121389525,
-0.0186656825,
0.0033834693,
0.0083316974,
0.0229012761,
-0.0108060474,
0.0055858367,
-0.0019972287,
-0.0437629893,
0.0148911439,
0.0224865433,
0.0349693671,
0.0048866603,
-0.0608992875,
-0.0111783091,
-0.0480391644,
-0.0081401458,
-0.0030424057,
0.0120182373,
0.0666978806,
0.1491061598,
-0.0140282679,
0.0169401746,
-0.0186014045,
-0.0148092061,
0.0472445488,
-0.0664177537,
-0.0012718481,
0.0088355364,
0.022196779,
0.0369505212,
0.0080185318,
0.0342428014,
0.0010726574,
0.0043783695,
0.0249058008,
0.097762838,
-0.0032546385,
-0.0154867759,
0.0049807802,
-0.0180033129,
-0.0127073862,
-0.0296819955,
0.1144127548,
-0.0346972868,
-0.0477152355,
-0.0348274224,
-0.0095592272,
0.0120422477,
0.0236527342,
-0.0100572323,
0.026735099,
0.0066147046,
0.0049138078,
-0.0138681838,
0.0038096637,
-0.0623578839,
-0.018136505,
0.0147618689,
-0.0369022973,
-0.0360101312,
-0.0434925891,
-0.0128708687,
0.0558260754,
-0.0608248264,
-0.0155913774,
2.168531545e-34,
0.0311890803,
-0.010496485,
0.0230707992,
0.0363288894,
-0.0075276732,
-0.0285642315,
-0.0314758942,
0.0074763652,
0.0030136495,
-0.1001244485,
0.0055209235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14167v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14167v1 | Definition generation for lexical semantic change detection | 2024-06-20T10:13:08 | 2024-06-20T10:13:08 | Mariia Fedorova, Andrey Kutuzov, Yves Scherrer | cs.CL | cs.CL | We use contextualized word definitions generated by large language models as
semantic representations in the task of diachronic lexical semantic change
detection (LSCD). In short, generated definitions are used as `senses', and the
change score of a target word is retrieved by comparing their distributions in
two time periods under comparison. On the material of five datasets and three
languages, we show that generated definitions are indeed specific and general
enough to convey a signal sufficient to rank sets of words by the degree of
their semantic change over time. Our approach is on par with or outperforms
prior non-supervised sense-based LSCD methods. At the same time, it preserves
interpretability and allows to inspect the reasons behind a specific shift in
terms of discrete definitions-as-senses. This is another step in the direction
of explainable semantic change modeling. | [
-0.0113977734,
0.0487960503,
-0.0420280844,
0.0288832188,
-0.035205327,
-0.0042857612,
-0.0224279407,
0.0205289014,
-0.020441182,
-0.0626261905,
0.0290215705,
-0.0148515375,
-0.0072032064,
0.0147387711,
-0.0017920985,
0.0142306276,
0.103115283,
-0.0120825842,
-0.0649048612,
0.0347636491,
-0.0043357462,
-0.020211488,
0.0005321908,
-0.0153753301,
-0.0369950794,
-0.0409085974,
-0.0278113298,
-0.033870399,
0.0201282948,
-0.0476058349,
-0.0142714027,
0.0323347226,
0.0431055911,
0.0799729601,
0.0000020616,
-0.0704693943,
-0.0539573207,
-0.0187596735,
-0.027070893,
0.0332867131,
0.0735218301,
-0.0050803027,
-0.007043343,
-0.0752110928,
-0.0365767553,
0.0092674699,
0.0211996045,
-0.0323460102,
0.0515292995,
0.0351321064,
-0.0033635001,
-0.0432223342,
-0.0058287969,
-0.0014697934,
0.007580773,
-0.0042187609,
0.0296714604,
0.0360556841,
-0.0371732116,
-0.0121785663,
-0.0627903715,
0.0084017301,
-0.0325294584,
-0.0401276983,
0.0232809801,
0.019449044,
0.0298784804,
0.0241820235,
0.0001824962,
0.0064804358,
0.015774807,
-0.0368937515,
-0.0047193887,
-0.0107310927,
-0.0041298461,
0.0552189015,
-0.0105777858,
-0.0468590744,
0.0239501316,
0.0070482562,
0.0643187687,
-0.0047472678,
0.039472986,
0.0551597439,
-0.0591878332,
0.0505807325,
0.0358927548,
-0.0374828503,
-0.0539711379,
-0.0275095962,
-0.0087199779,
-0.0379144438,
-0.0324744992,
0.0052906903,
-0.029272696,
0.055529166,
0.0038759159,
-0.0433020443,
0.0112504102,
-0.0601980127,
0.0054236655,
-0.0148417354,
-0.0291482043,
0.0500575341,
-0.0233024731,
0.0407678783,
-0.0030204253,
-0.052208703,
-0.0402776226,
0.0102733206,
-0.0683772638,
-0.0051857028,
-0.0310384333,
0.0003885601,
-0.0260083396,
0.0048458888,
-0.0280829258,
0.0624780133,
-0.0111984201,
-0.0205436479,
-0.0129338922,
-0.0234852564,
-0.0439645797,
0.0466019958,
-0.0362546295,
-0.0229957905,
-0.0134697398,
-0.0137341321,
-0.0395954065,
-0.0443944819,
0.0174791589,
0.0006948743,
-0.018494131,
-0.0129424352,
-0.0430593044,
0.0420911312,
-0.0013841294,
-0.0245487373,
-0.0303640701,
-0.0374870002,
-0.0743524283,
0.0249146819,
-0.0465129279,
-0.0415097885,
-0.0179937538,
-0.0275791436,
0.0194105804,
-0.0669068992,
-0.0065804026,
-0.0100831212,
-0.032740809,
0.074028179,
-0.05640563,
0.0093427189,
0.0002729515,
-0.0206209533,
0.0399576202,
0.0782321468,
0.0439629927,
-0.032888215,
0.0731490925,
0.0072981622,
-0.0708044544,
0.00989585,
-0.0187649354,
0.045485992,
-0.0735065192,
-0.0115280719,
0.0327781625,
0.0463029966,
0.0173112378,
0.0006579489,
-0.0246042125,
-0.0378308855,
0.0103740003,
0.0188688692,
0.0537937284,
-0.0193466488,
0.0519617461,
-0.0305823572,
-0.0472551174,
0.0043513826,
0.0234470908,
-0.0493438691,
-0.0054517118,
-0.0433818735,
-0.0452885367,
-0.0478275195,
-0.0009369139,
-0.0109380018,
0.0001426531,
0.0070657083,
0.0023032161,
-0.0388607271,
0.0579797029,
0.0302948281,
0.0339721516,
0.081631057,
0.045442652,
-0.0076690307,
0.0331626795,
-0.0293365922,
0.051454477,
0.0886885002,
0.0535334982,
-0.0457103625,
0.0103395833,
0.0214150473,
-0.0004393209,
0.0281857569,
0.0103622293,
-0.0472098589,
-0.0113915727,
-0.001489793,
0.0192191713,
-0.034981519,
0.0249642506,
0.0039394745,
-0.0028872394,
0.0281795897,
0.0018949993,
-0.0698017478,
-0.0393751822,
0.0425796993,
-0.0231392402,
-0.0231325999,
0.0102451406,
-0.0196981262,
0.0303230789,
0.0187242087,
-0.0189561453,
0.0011780786,
0.0178799592,
-0.0370623656,
-0.0003083297,
0.0372677594,
-0.0207591169,
-0.0138056679,
0.0455778763,
0.0359416604,
0.038866099,
-0.0182535816,
-0.0311539527,
-0.0103253527,
0.0536993481,
-0.0432378873,
0.0463271812,
-0.046650026,
0.0385849103,
-0.0321189985,
0.0315737911,
-0.0747127309,
0.0806041285,
-0.0052009546,
-0.0276581272,
0.0012436834,
0.0899824351,
0.0228851754,
0.0274882726,
-0.010816969,
0.0679951236,
0.0373645015,
-0.0295212399,
0.018191997,
-0.0169370677,
-0.0461203307,
-0.0052878656,
-0.0401119031,
-0.0075440537,
-0.0317339227,
0.016943628,
0.0577414557,
0.0164845288,
0.0084938053,
0.0039609666,
0.0545680672,
0.0364008211,
-0.0108941942,
0.0483952872,
0.0470490456,
-0.0042324117,
-0.0086923884,
-0.0499757119,
-0.0057249144,
-0.0195943043,
0.0925766379,
0.0147850132,
-0.0229693949,
-0.0581283905,
-0.0033570384,
-0.0781030729,
0.0253621452,
-0.0123652956,
0.0045576738,
0.0127661107,
-0.0187987536,
0.0360764042,
-0.0068700477,
0.0576140285,
0.0709377751,
0.0937916711,
-0.0553488322,
-0.0580492653,
-0.0305197556,
-0.0127254324,
0.0079715652,
-0.0318651013,
-0.0124295624,
0.0398534089,
0.0311948415,
0.0205856003,
-0.0200662818,
-0.0112730945,
0.0276976153,
-0.0802457109,
-0.035726402,
-0.0365245678,
0.0019364359,
-0.0614622459,
0.0368081778,
-0.0099760657,
-0.0422772169,
0.005909699,
0.0132368375,
0.044572629,
-0.0465065986,
-0.0353497155,
-0.0426335782,
0.0760088339,
-0.0165330507,
0.0183829851,
-0.0032129746,
-0.0020674525,
-0.0498351343,
-0.0429286547,
0.0600814782,
-0.0138660865,
0.0659675598,
-0.1003366336,
0.0415600576,
0.0156318825,
0.0545638241,
-0.0333234854,
-0.0298673492,
-0.004236904,
0.0280512366,
0.0071160118,
0.0041080453,
0.0460294075,
0.0349780656,
-0.0290601477,
0.0394432172,
0.0301790573,
-0.0293313414,
-0.0291998293,
0.0243942421,
0.0168950371,
-0.0238945764,
-0.0234275088,
0.0167111754,
0.0478530563,
0.0034576408,
-0.0319872871,
-0.0180164427,
-0.1046546176,
-0.0014464339,
-0.0137719586,
-0.0493991971,
0.0093897283,
-0.0113434,
-0.0213170834,
-0.0199432075,
-0.0264824964,
0.0831511617,
0.0480519608,
-0.0478702225,
0.0375284292,
-0.0162711851,
-0.0277010351,
0.0215120446,
-0.0433668643,
-0.0630873293,
-0.0277192872,
-0.0106014172,
-0.0192256812,
0.0059477794,
-0.0538360812,
-0.0256922636,
-0.041862458,
0.0073606116,
-0.004090644,
-0.0598609187,
0.0461122431,
-0.0113635985,
0.0474257842,
-0.0031755923,
-0.0517446995,
-0.0037406015,
0.0151874674,
-0.0024973101,
0.0048039621,
-0.0289010312,
-0.0311304107,
0.0304898489,
0.0056836121,
0.0121212313,
0.0659098104,
0.0570393093,
-0.008001742,
-0.0394979827,
0.044636678,
-0.0780883059,
0.0158467982,
-0.030084312,
0.0207939558,
0.0206488147,
0.0029869436,
0.0509212688,
-0.0605447739,
0.0114642344,
-0.0209837426,
0.0230035502,
0.0565763488,
-0.042519778,
-0.0157583077,
-0.0308723003,
-0.0223115664,
0.0108546317,
-0.0020286518,
-0.0063298675,
-0.001594531,
0.0326100811,
0.0282353535,
0.0105560319,
0.0359216295,
-0.0220995266,
-0.0461470447,
-0.0547844619,
-0.0322564542,
-0.0836202204,
0.0141758313,
-0.0436766073,
0.0011342244,
0.0251199212,
0.0555293672,
-0.0000167058,
-0.0110941799,
-0.088247478,
0.0087022511,
-0.0140631124,
0.028727062,
-0.0310467873,
-0.0506141447,
0.0630160719,
0.029125018,
-0.0233414229,
0.0414848626,
-0.0489314683,
-0.0307380501,
0.0372708701,
-0.0503468029,
0.0089607071,
0.0341078006,
-0.0233744737,
0.0182815399,
0.0480521321,
0.0017229733,
0.0136998715,
0.037058726,
0.0015887225,
0.0177313015,
-0.0144387735,
0.0409014076,
-0.0472508669,
0.014482636,
0.004461728,
0.0275736023,
-0.0390047133,
-0.0462983288,
0.0280511957,
0.0008634628,
0.0441911295,
-0.0218394715,
-0.0248571988,
-0.0077563445,
-0.0226093344,
-0.0034017605,
-0.038872961,
0.0159866177,
-0.0015845004,
-0.0173981879,
-0.0281327069,
-0.0311709382,
0.0458620638,
-0.0233501215,
0.0065158228,
-0.0015946116,
-0.013096855,
0.0431433953,
0.0385744907,
0.0196651723,
0.0535027161,
0.0202952474,
-0.0123679414,
-0.058235541,
-0.0106933806,
-0.0116459858,
0.0367456973,
0.0140174953,
-0.0228147302,
-0.0414361991,
0.0320393257,
-0.0386362672,
-0.0108957086,
0.023984123,
-0.0268198941,
0.0669242367,
0.0051478543,
0.0671662912,
-0.0264349915,
-0.0128823342,
-0.026719166,
0.0140555603,
0.0523781814,
-0.0150189642,
0.0160330404,
0.0218035243,
0.0057445792,
0.0558303334,
0.0222189575,
-0.0444977544,
0.050250221,
-0.0246186126,
-0.0260820054,
-0.0031996169,
-0.0013327812,
-0.0105054881,
0.0171443224,
-0.0142151918,
0.0078699235,
-0.0628055334,
-0.0209463984,
0.0310907569,
-0.0157892425,
-0.0019810367,
0.0429628678,
0.0398695432,
0.0556494035,
0.0291814189,
0.0378412865,
-0.0441766419,
0.034046445,
-0.0224842429,
-0.0251648817,
-0.0547031052,
-5.591144105e-33,
-0.0170926135,
-0.0220771842,
-0.0061539514,
-0.0220174771,
-0.0755556598,
0.042943202,
-0.0284287687,
-0.0413813256,
0.0310475286,
0.0236261133,
0.0329798274,
0.0614761375,
-0.003414124,
-0.0517866611,
0.0216259155,
-0.037195418,
0.0663053542,
0.0142314751,
0.0033166278,
-0.0004900164,
0.0993578285,
-0.0142989717,
0.0625607148,
-0.0492198989,
0.0825299397,
0.0521573313,
0.03553202,
0.005014156,
0.0176466405,
0.013044185,
-0.0104651935,
0.0669737309,
0.0111508006,
-0.0113206413,
-0.0306362472,
-0.0635730326,
-0.0235101543,
-0.0510860048,
0.0309513472,
-0.0007061991,
-0.0044160425,
-0.0275321044,
-0.0010173469,
0.0138301151,
-0.0176252928,
0.0668622628,
0.0394147411,
-0.0281452723,
-0.0631617978,
-0.0144449519,
-0.0448613763,
0.0690005943,
-0.0271812417,
0.0070534805,
0.0001049904,
-0.0213474222,
0.0541205481,
-0.0211895481,
-0.025459243,
0.0331360698,
0.0187733527,
0.0032903997,
0.0259224866,
0.0123675931,
-0.0032746131,
0.0509030037,
0.0165091045,
-0.020660935,
0.084882386,
-0.0182155985,
0.0028996218,
-0.010660856,
-0.0078467904,
0.0556216501,
0.0315948389,
-0.0154858828,
-0.0077723265,
-0.0221759155,
0.0181698687,
0.0549280681,
0.0336091891,
0.0101509029,
-0.002262261,
-0.002474834,
-0.0157913081,
0.0430392958,
-0.0272323955,
-0.009372198,
0.038233377,
-0.0220892113,
0.000009629,
0.0035465071,
-0.0035935089,
-0.0283313598,
-0.0008034914,
0.0214763433,
-0.0370273255,
0.0012187803,
0.0298317671,
0.0008530888,
0.0485857986,
-0.0224484522,
0.0146638397,
0.0284043569,
0.0158665217,
-0.012181229,
-0.0392373353,
-0.0128686139,
0.0109667759,
0.018705992,
0.001253339,
-0.0762665942,
-0.0752412155,
-0.0480221063,
-0.0126803471,
-0.0087581584,
-0.0188400485,
0.0267787259,
0.0843482539,
-0.0145650348,
0.0217632484,
-0.0077772974,
0.002247185,
0.0515492968,
-0.0295720436,
0.0056335879,
0.014615682,
0.0646282658,
0.0611285046,
-0.0049705785,
0.0192642398,
-0.0042855144,
2.812e-7,
0.0588361062,
0.053930454,
-0.0306650698,
0.0210468974,
0.0564563051,
-0.0258607771,
-0.0277562123,
0.0041154549,
-0.033266075,
0.039999865,
0.0100165447,
0.0009276023,
-0.0038943952,
0.0549933873,
-0.008651468,
-0.0147163989,
-0.0333233587,
0.0107852621,
-0.087694414,
0.0028590881,
0.0762307718,
0.0430750623,
0.012621332,
-0.0123922676,
-0.041632399,
-0.0272875316,
0.0328495838,
-0.0254560187,
0.0016135763,
-0.0114030614,
0.0431950353,
0.0230853353,
0.0304337163,
0.0489022024,
-0.0422485657,
0.019131355,
-0.0167721305,
-0.018081788,
-0.024999937,
0.067701973,
-0.0434308723,
-0.0328035615,
0.0154891117,
-0.0336491242,
0.0720040202,
-0.0072374055,
0.0217076596,
-0.0526945628,
-0.0592319593,
0.0273671485,
0.0180472918,
-0.0050460673,
-0.0539637804,
0.0276709627,
-0.0004684896,
0.0317079909,
-0.0581215769,
-0.0714750439,
0.0192603339,
0.0101864496,
0.0019527326,
-0.0420158319,
-0.0054336083,
-0.0238854345,
0.006885936,
-0.0224067662,
0.0387635864,
1.929298241e-34,
0.017914433,
0.0859111324,
-0.0086900694,
0.0005518007,
0.0239267796,
-0.0267376304,
0.0300605539,
0.0208981484,
0.0263965838,
-0.0420367122,
-0.0018199146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14164v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14164v1 | A Data-Driven Guided Decoding Mechanism for Diagnostic Captioning | 2024-06-20T10:08:17 | 2024-06-20T10:08:17 | Panagiotis Kaliosis, John Pavlopoulos, Foivos Charalampakos, Georgios Moschovis, Ion Androutsopoulos | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Diagnostic Captioning (DC) automatically generates a diagnostic text from one
or more medical images (e.g., X-rays, MRIs) of a patient. Treated as a draft,
the generated text may assist clinicians, by providing an initial estimation of
the patient's condition, speeding up and helping safeguard the diagnostic
process. The accuracy of a diagnostic text, however, strongly depends on how
well the key medical conditions depicted in the images are expressed. We
propose a new data-driven guided decoding method that incorporates medical
information, in the form of existing tags capturing key conditions of the
image(s), into the beam search of the diagnostic text generation process. We
evaluate the proposed method on two medical datasets using four DC systems that
range from generic image-to-text systems with CNN encoders and RNN decoders to
pre-trained Large Language Models. The latter can also be used in few- and
zero-shot learning scenarios. In most cases, the proposed mechanism improves
performance with respect to all evaluation measures. We provide an open-source
implementation of the proposed method at https://github.com/nlpaueb/dmmcs. | [
0.0125649972,
0.0630961955,
0.0152500961,
0.0002841846,
0.0046308772,
0.0373057835,
0.0060254396,
0.0544871315,
0.002491096,
-0.0113988649,
0.009809101,
-0.0349216834,
0.0250939075,
0.0544815622,
-0.0058917063,
-0.0664673075,
0.0120630916,
-0.0122665688,
0.0243294928,
0.0011513499,
-0.0306072943,
-0.0024292881,
-0.0402655937,
0.0324411243,
-0.0251484569,
-0.0002127804,
0.0234362539,
0.0221602563,
0.0411440767,
-0.089498274,
-0.0171092954,
0.0397755019,
0.0097787213,
0.0060166609,
0.0000021123,
0.0087115718,
-0.0224203598,
0.0246216394,
0.0045901155,
-0.0323601589,
0.0738037154,
-0.072433427,
0.0083374344,
-0.0035476706,
-0.0214411113,
-0.1029470488,
0.047559794,
0.0698957741,
0.0577004366,
0.0681841597,
-0.024873754,
-0.0474481136,
0.0106438082,
-0.0151053676,
0.0162767358,
-0.0477229282,
0.0210310537,
0.0612922832,
0.0356187075,
0.0229034908,
-0.0110259727,
0.0792174935,
0.0000480502,
0.0103394249,
0.0005802343,
0.0946786702,
0.0096854102,
-0.0421252474,
-0.0083134929,
0.086783424,
-0.0140837366,
0.0001341812,
-0.0063986289,
-0.0196295548,
-0.0292905401,
-0.0263547227,
-0.0035001547,
-0.0102978973,
-0.0006614392,
0.0235056318,
0.0013276066,
0.0332533158,
0.0242033582,
-0.0175522994,
-0.0312478784,
-0.0167506672,
0.0061289249,
0.0072857221,
-0.0297481027,
0.0082893642,
-0.0317729637,
-0.0518637337,
0.0444701761,
0.0257232822,
-0.028615633,
-0.0003136126,
-0.0722866207,
-0.1043053344,
0.0419354327,
-0.0465624556,
-0.0107672261,
-0.0092695327,
-0.0505069792,
0.0681390688,
-0.0517569967,
0.0097294012,
-0.0415227674,
0.0447135344,
-0.0557290204,
0.0002285946,
-0.0439506248,
-0.0130523425,
-0.0462865606,
0.0050611133,
-0.0012112428,
-0.0331709683,
-0.0550618768,
-0.0362760983,
0.0313445181,
0.0133609623,
0.0166489277,
0.0588044077,
-0.0531778149,
0.0116586005,
0.0028421611,
0.0255007371,
0.0106679955,
-0.0217492729,
-0.0114830686,
-0.0253364909,
-0.0022486642,
0.051207751,
0.023034988,
0.0117602777,
0.017697027,
0.0448148586,
-0.0217109229,
-0.0224030856,
0.0190004222,
-0.0436681621,
-0.0606746636,
0.0045211287,
0.0168811772,
-0.0553176627,
0.036456082,
0.034301281,
0.0020167297,
-0.0476196483,
0.0318312235,
0.0074402192,
-0.027224578,
0.0721081123,
-0.068234764,
-0.0014143628,
0.0505413748,
0.0332852304,
0.0291631799,
0.005021947,
0.016267458,
0.0242292732,
-0.0112424567,
-0.0049634441,
0.0347199813,
0.0232684053,
0.0102656102,
-0.0134869451,
-0.0361467004,
-0.0030496621,
0.0124904532,
0.0511400588,
0.0171281453,
0.0475082919,
-0.0068738293,
0.029886296,
0.0190385729,
0.037978109,
0.0457182601,
0.0197912026,
0.0185347144,
-0.0031980914,
-0.0323458537,
-0.0164408535,
0.0225637313,
0.0300833117,
0.0422570519,
-0.001879848,
-0.0126513895,
-0.0042543183,
-0.0475331917,
-0.0272110738,
-0.0252785347,
-0.0213978216,
-0.0183779951,
-0.007333199,
0.0562442169,
0.0297786947,
-0.0713587254,
0.0411863402,
0.027388012,
-0.0076089874,
-0.0297304839,
-0.0443692356,
-0.0283302721,
0.064669542,
0.0817305073,
-0.0288349725,
-0.0440097377,
0.0172431357,
0.0373200662,
0.0221923906,
0.0132643245,
0.0253722519,
0.0156019665,
-0.0708661005,
-0.0283775795,
0.039177198,
0.0084686605,
0.0074609718,
-0.0191409029,
0.032877177,
-0.0045693764,
-0.0112042679,
-0.0760156065,
0.0564006865,
0.0315415934,
-0.0370836332,
0.0379217193,
0.0109046642,
-0.0042998963,
0.0139435092,
-0.0422691666,
0.0071983351,
0.0205034055,
-0.0219751429,
-0.0571856685,
0.0407389626,
-0.0711658224,
-0.0670239702,
-0.0086220028,
-0.0679966658,
-0.0296617094,
-0.0349303111,
-0.0489698835,
-0.0268220585,
-0.0225611012,
-0.0597058311,
-0.042347949,
-0.0100020347,
-0.0039726296,
0.0543771163,
0.0060594478,
-0.0040468457,
0.0502863266,
-0.0106958458,
-0.0196812861,
0.02178468,
-0.0174500216,
0.0127543164,
-0.0266236458,
-0.056751091,
0.012357628,
-0.0075964355,
-0.0070784758,
-0.0157926511,
0.0483782329,
-0.0007849821,
-0.0085931187,
-0.0784395486,
-0.0137300957,
0.0112760821,
-0.0335214883,
0.0479666255,
0.0271232426,
0.0189999025,
-0.0503232032,
-0.0448215492,
0.0019305013,
0.0608349331,
-0.0238473658,
0.0594602153,
0.0481854901,
-0.0253151413,
-0.0201925058,
0.0028662474,
-0.0210218616,
0.0318578221,
0.0340762176,
-0.0464876033,
-0.0285098776,
0.035590291,
-0.0023812687,
-0.0002829147,
0.0216230955,
-0.0576672852,
-0.0006315234,
-0.026814349,
-0.0337508991,
0.0402587801,
-0.0170017239,
0.0208267309,
-0.0063214302,
0.00356948,
-0.0164757725,
0.0084895175,
-0.0433559529,
-0.0288991053,
0.0186940767,
-0.0706879199,
0.0092606861,
0.0647116229,
0.0300265606,
0.046889849,
-0.0481381081,
-0.0247788336,
-0.041564405,
-0.0281793792,
-0.0476004742,
0.0391472131,
-0.016722979,
0.0273687132,
0.0007729064,
-0.0474707223,
0.0799062029,
-0.0181329623,
-0.0218401439,
-0.0431394652,
-0.0158293378,
-0.0263466462,
0.0109920502,
0.0022929818,
0.0388007127,
0.0187056586,
-0.0350641832,
0.033637356,
0.0248317122,
0.0199754592,
-0.0613865256,
0.0250661857,
-0.011439844,
0.0098973466,
-0.0142562464,
-0.0213423949,
-0.0379202813,
-0.004147117,
0.0140136061,
-0.0219856761,
-0.0181230865,
0.0086476067,
-0.0580102466,
0.0522352345,
-0.0195086412,
0.0462329499,
0.0092803957,
0.0051527913,
-0.0244439971,
0.0651561469,
-0.0127460891,
-0.020064339,
-0.0365595967,
-0.028214816,
0.0185274016,
0.0551079027,
-0.0443280116,
0.0438462161,
-0.05306191,
-0.005099528,
-0.0045698183,
0.0356928632,
0.0256833956,
0.0312659889,
0.0152899446,
-0.064969644,
-0.0074295746,
0.0894272998,
0.0280965436,
-0.0583143197,
-0.0195991136,
0.0247280169,
-0.0136464937,
-0.0281480439,
-0.0078722872,
-0.0696453899,
-0.0423774235,
-0.0021272404,
0.0406085141,
0.0017678869,
-0.0044482239,
0.0073919003,
0.007442866,
0.0464811698,
0.0127242971,
0.0094392085,
-0.0492706373,
0.0015239934,
-0.0509136133,
0.004880718,
-0.0368399732,
-0.0285999179,
0.0288295113,
0.0060447375,
0.0081163747,
-0.0294406004,
-0.1041500866,
-0.0139046209,
-0.0282774288,
0.0351424105,
0.1077306494,
0.0438906439,
-0.0098936316,
-0.0145758307,
-0.031372536,
0.0339110084,
0.0284535736,
-0.021941036,
0.0865283906,
-0.0228928626,
-0.037831977,
-0.0261963699,
0.0498619378,
-0.0398511365,
-0.0122982515,
-0.0145437773,
0.0298436359,
-0.0271730702,
-0.0208189283,
-0.0632455721,
0.008571906,
0.0584097207,
0.0597927049,
-0.0083382688,
0.0030247276,
-0.0376051962,
0.008329113,
0.0677089766,
-0.0652906522,
-0.0212860182,
0.0295957681,
-0.0411025062,
-0.040080443,
-0.074436754,
-0.0141915167,
0.0532423705,
-0.0085667726,
0.0104147848,
-0.0137801897,
-0.0126266172,
0.0203213245,
-0.0801794305,
0.0362707451,
0.0083280597,
-0.0016530065,
-0.0564014502,
-0.02348377,
0.06567166,
0.0127794668,
-0.0106641306,
0.0669309944,
-0.0492162555,
0.0175837595,
0.0144992657,
0.057267528,
0.0088543259,
-0.0225306973,
-0.0210469104,
-0.0143020311,
0.0573144294,
0.0626026168,
-0.0203118399,
-0.0116159059,
0.0083572268,
-0.0434597917,
-0.026771253,
0.008869445,
-0.0091474066,
0.047683429,
-0.0043782094,
0.0212412141,
-0.0021393392,
-0.0253340062,
0.0320964716,
0.015554144,
0.0359346755,
-0.0724130496,
-0.0362514332,
-0.0102856169,
0.0046012364,
-0.0010715718,
0.0104396893,
-0.0231388174,
0.0441936813,
0.0495494977,
-0.0061549265,
-0.0103226937,
0.032939259,
-0.0209371746,
-0.0182469077,
0.0056901015,
0.0630232766,
0.0241391845,
-0.0320823602,
0.0514726341,
-0.0143599734,
0.0049327873,
0.0254577585,
0.0049595907,
0.0035227719,
-0.0112065598,
0.0392713435,
0.0268825609,
0.0554732382,
-0.0021558495,
0.0699416697,
0.0036411232,
-0.0129861757,
-0.03587237,
0.0175692253,
0.0494162776,
0.0184073858,
0.0339053832,
-0.0435490161,
0.0038738947,
-0.0171685647,
0.0306112096,
-0.0238043759,
-0.0027056194,
0.0342489183,
-0.0249227788,
0.0200500451,
-0.0346103311,
0.0840896443,
-0.0219547581,
0.026044881,
-0.0063591716,
-0.044225622,
-0.0453221798,
0.0025494264,
0.0091001289,
-0.0265575461,
-0.0513021089,
0.0332910642,
-0.0133352485,
-0.0259784404,
0.0303701609,
-0.0205995236,
-0.0231758282,
-0.0019874913,
0.068444021,
-0.0024831973,
0.0214340333,
-0.0144313797,
-0.0028627089,
0.0362313539,
-0.0353121795,
-0.0068703927,
-0.0089467233,
-5.83501951e-33,
-0.0198738351,
-0.0556884632,
0.0122435773,
-0.035544727,
0.0236026738,
0.0510960817,
-0.0325530916,
-0.0091776717,
0.0312458538,
0.0305242073,
-0.0040230765,
-0.0179973133,
0.0230417941,
0.05785181,
-0.0300819054,
-0.0171486866,
0.045337189,
-0.0287216064,
-0.0218763221,
0.0299934987,
-0.022376474,
0.0326895453,
0.0272363629,
-0.0752904266,
-0.0228616092,
-0.0200622696,
-0.0125421565,
-0.0204877704,
0.0473778695,
0.0111560905,
-0.0540043749,
0.0055249901,
0.0235888846,
-0.0205855779,
-0.0285993386,
0.0306390151,
-0.0981188193,
0.0042519644,
-0.0102096414,
0.0327318348,
-0.041122254,
-0.0092848549,
-0.0051579829,
-0.0321307853,
0.0098467274,
0.0044844416,
0.0293977987,
-0.0211770628,
0.0205411613,
-0.0549842827,
-0.0036901173,
0.0565428361,
-0.0013496936,
-0.0179239102,
0.0512754731,
0.0007686419,
-0.0168211181,
0.0454672873,
-0.0543323569,
0.0072941915,
0.0483205579,
0.0480120666,
0.0382521972,
-0.0084498394,
-0.016657941,
0.0562877618,
0.0461317785,
-0.0516460724,
-0.0419554003,
0.0256111994,
-0.0378022306,
0.0522430539,
0.0688764825,
0.038745854,
0.0540191196,
-0.0246606488,
-0.0340341739,
0.0390740074,
-0.1114889458,
0.0475595221,
0.038400311,
-0.0086476533,
-0.0446459167,
0.0128232306,
-0.0135423308,
-0.0170868337,
-0.0257055499,
-0.0458888561,
0.067978777,
0.0377663746,
-0.039743457,
0.0092817722,
0.0429629572,
-0.0205128863,
0.0242194962,
-0.0461766347,
0.0476740412,
0.0491449088,
-0.0577779077,
-0.0031674905,
-0.0295279771,
-0.0515980162,
0.0929082111,
0.0004215264,
0.0438918285,
-0.0017244224,
0.0139035629,
0.000887778,
-0.0335071981,
0.0067267669,
0.021332467,
-0.0101184919,
-0.0270840675,
0.05966831,
0.0305612031,
0.0242205523,
-0.0247249454,
0.0000329861,
-0.020792814,
0.0418303385,
-0.0440962799,
-0.0598952919,
0.0150722666,
0.0114716245,
-0.0569244288,
-0.0039751907,
-0.0404991247,
-0.0217107125,
0.0451171063,
-0.0602298044,
-0.0267460402,
0.0599671118,
2.772e-7,
0.0724807382,
0.0504762754,
0.0471586175,
0.0106360372,
0.0207450986,
0.032047417,
-0.0033920482,
0.0136881201,
-0.0006965317,
-0.0266812928,
0.0475306772,
0.0173687898,
0.0096610663,
0.0139008667,
-0.0578073896,
0.0139821311,
-0.0191090498,
0.0108061759,
-0.0000586221,
-0.0414510034,
0.077812776,
0.0654324442,
-0.0588762462,
-0.0382480919,
0.0442560278,
-0.0467909761,
0.0512068681,
-0.0124128554,
0.0141067756,
0.0311353058,
0.0144954035,
0.0595639348,
-0.0175730661,
0.0288784057,
-0.0084416009,
-0.0549475737,
0.0128665343,
0.0461588055,
-0.0347940177,
-0.0163140967,
-0.0206302255,
0.0336057767,
0.0011908433,
-0.0153510449,
0.0573699325,
-0.0757125244,
-0.0069040116,
-0.0089267176,
0.011706545,
0.0012539016,
0.0348166525,
-0.0472097993,
-0.0366490521,
0.0438373238,
0.051645387,
0.0171350278,
-0.0606150664,
-0.0816092566,
-0.0211631935,
-0.0103618708,
-0.0171642117,
-0.0151002584,
-0.0078994641,
-0.0030986415,
0.0212488994,
-0.0789911523,
-0.0232192986,
2.387047909e-34,
0.0258409455,
-0.002727495,
-0.0210510008,
0.0219000373,
-0.0074016456,
-0.0165655874,
-0.0183308516,
0.0101267863,
0.0078262407,
-0.0595924295,
-0.0257744361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14162v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14162v1 | DIRAS: Efficient LLM-Assisted Annotation of Document Relevance in Retrieval Augmented Generation | 2024-06-20T10:04:09 | 2024-06-20T10:04:09 | Jingwei Ni, Tobias Schimanski, Meihong Lin, Mrinmaya Sachan, Elliott Ash, Markus Leippold | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) is widely employed to ground responses
to queries on domain-specific documents. But do RAG implementations leave out
important information or excessively include irrelevant information? To allay
these concerns, it is necessary to annotate domain-specific benchmarks to
evaluate information retrieval (IR) performance, as relevance definitions vary
across queries and domains. Furthermore, such benchmarks should be
cost-efficiently annotated to avoid annotation selection bias. In this paper,
we propose DIRAS (Domain-specific Information Retrieval Annotation with
Scalability), a manual-annotation-free schema that fine-tunes open-sourced LLMs
to annotate relevance labels with calibrated relevance probabilities. Extensive
evaluation shows that DIRAS fine-tuned models achieve GPT-4-level performance
on annotating and ranking unseen (query, document) pairs, and is helpful for
real-world RAG development. | [
0.0219974536,
-0.0381292626,
0.0160622168,
-0.0042015007,
0.014802509,
0.0092339441,
-0.0194164254,
0.0007304264,
0.0038981424,
-0.0778148994,
-0.0620595776,
0.0200095959,
-0.0519864559,
-0.0265101995,
0.002733703,
0.0152783245,
0.0462436453,
0.0242559388,
-0.0368443169,
0.0299112163,
-0.0016062651,
0.0111413579,
0.0083771106,
0.0154677052,
0.005231251,
0.0189543124,
-0.0212056153,
0.0648382381,
0.0047502676,
-0.0348074175,
0.0113401962,
0.0316201411,
0.0197957419,
0.0497054905,
0.0000018602,
-0.0754704103,
-0.0439554751,
0.0211095288,
-0.0099925483,
0.0275181923,
0.0297797956,
0.0632015094,
0.0326593965,
0.0146899251,
-0.0338885933,
0.00604966,
0.0241157673,
0.027425766,
0.0478010178,
0.0742764771,
0.0101578264,
-0.0035527851,
0.0222695768,
-0.0516467802,
0.0772373602,
-0.0667736456,
-0.0122717591,
0.0317645632,
0.0487665087,
0.0408960618,
0.0307923593,
0.0288926251,
-0.0385850556,
-0.0311643537,
0.0607721023,
-0.0110628735,
-0.0573538169,
0.0174292494,
0.0334156901,
0.0395204686,
0.089157179,
-0.0118626673,
0.0112737566,
-0.0038742828,
0.0025276281,
0.042762652,
-0.0611907132,
-0.0153142596,
-0.02152697,
0.0066807098,
0.0163538549,
0.0168185215,
0.0267675053,
-0.0013339859,
0.0233809985,
0.0855130404,
0.0050250697,
-0.0183353946,
-0.0083001507,
0.0223395769,
-0.0243685581,
0.0000204557,
-0.0010292619,
0.014074727,
-0.0015335978,
0.0047022835,
-0.0148682995,
-0.0388439596,
0.0810271427,
-0.0223868508,
0.0252640564,
0.0320392027,
-0.0089462735,
0.0484716445,
-0.0287410729,
0.0072166761,
-0.0135027748,
-0.0274712797,
-0.0479502603,
-0.0146172363,
-0.0472772643,
-0.0207280684,
-0.0222082864,
0.0516935736,
-0.0493082106,
-0.0086826207,
-0.0525572859,
0.0517916195,
0.0050789155,
-0.0235014763,
0.0319299772,
0.0093331281,
-0.0737348199,
0.0101147257,
-0.0673768446,
-0.0042816517,
-0.0180172548,
-0.0089796986,
0.0260090046,
-0.0603714846,
0.0083272206,
0.0437863506,
-0.0185498968,
-0.0321678743,
-0.0113911517,
0.0390147753,
0.0225034505,
-0.0396636538,
-0.0617828071,
-0.0733624622,
0.0479359888,
-0.0182798654,
0.0188887883,
-0.0300149228,
0.0049582492,
0.0158982947,
-0.0198851116,
-0.0300291758,
0.0115248617,
0.0480375513,
-0.0060325996,
0.0231409054,
-0.0148465326,
-0.0047198315,
0.0574212782,
0.0196133554,
-0.0050381096,
0.0762665197,
-0.0026944987,
0.0271502156,
0.0390240774,
0.0441302136,
-0.008944625,
-0.0005435318,
0.0237059761,
0.0508188717,
0.0115898699,
0.0361027569,
-0.0110005541,
0.0311640128,
0.0337120779,
0.0162514038,
-0.037314564,
0.01070002,
-0.0110173691,
0.0104545159,
0.0550786518,
-0.0179339517,
0.0511569642,
0.032825876,
-0.0166622233,
-0.0057262736,
-0.0121071292,
0.0477691367,
-0.0573356412,
0.0099923918,
0.0654373914,
-0.0076397522,
-0.0398288742,
-0.0262203701,
-0.0147756813,
0.0239241254,
-0.0494492874,
-0.0286679007,
0.0196954869,
0.0201054104,
-0.035141211,
0.0530999713,
-0.0074610375,
-0.0568747334,
0.0032099234,
-0.0442097187,
0.0042909505,
0.0517458059,
0.0924574211,
-0.066542536,
-0.0387258567,
0.0025024652,
0.0253082141,
0.0406787992,
0.0298819765,
-0.0184713621,
-0.0300305299,
-0.0562846586,
-0.0624583662,
-0.0218332466,
0.0034859423,
0.0168223269,
0.0277570132,
0.0094799204,
0.0577619858,
-0.1041640565,
-0.0331403837,
0.0431785136,
-0.0235078726,
-0.0645804554,
0.0292461365,
-0.0131144775,
0.0145871034,
0.031809397,
0.0103931697,
0.0308185797,
0.0404153317,
0.009199555,
-0.0179346744,
-0.0337175056,
0.0327841379,
0.0247681867,
0.0163668729,
-0.0129040899,
0.03747743,
-0.0201287847,
-0.0252081547,
-0.0368052274,
-0.0255407691,
-0.0416983664,
0.0112609351,
-0.0794088989,
-0.0038126193,
0.0189441498,
-0.0018474219,
-0.065479815,
0.0666908771,
0.0056343423,
0.0076305815,
0.0332102738,
0.0277344901,
0.0376961455,
-0.0434472784,
-0.0002600214,
-0.0329232737,
0.0067426101,
0.0270577315,
0.0353697054,
0.024706943,
-0.0472204946,
0.011042376,
-0.0850241333,
0.038319923,
-0.005140062,
0.0361727886,
-0.0154383443,
0.0485370569,
0.0054738601,
-0.0035197088,
-0.0238834489,
0.0032472797,
-0.0040422375,
0.0198169556,
0.0212107785,
0.0471774787,
0.0179121792,
-0.0148428027,
-0.0037472502,
0.0105572687,
0.003454092,
0.0262191705,
-0.0010806181,
-0.0431798436,
0.0340071172,
-0.0695734397,
0.0158516802,
-0.0096086897,
0.0439028107,
0.0101122549,
-0.0429241098,
0.0069522057,
-0.0022222623,
0.0176412407,
-0.0173444878,
0.0423798151,
-0.0106969457,
-0.0965495482,
0.028455548,
-0.0401231535,
-0.0136055294,
0.016044531,
-0.0246416479,
0.0226149932,
-0.0273739267,
-0.029395964,
-0.0236517936,
-0.0379580744,
0.0049360278,
0.0102944644,
-0.0128036039,
-0.0561443195,
0.0109256683,
0.010268948,
0.0612281784,
0.0169184897,
-0.0655846447,
0.033337336,
-0.0216681119,
0.0240947213,
-0.054516159,
0.0192406233,
-0.068479836,
0.0255131721,
-0.034510687,
0.000951021,
-0.0393205471,
0.00489756,
-0.0072100977,
0.0444797501,
0.0344601423,
-0.0630684197,
0.0660005361,
-0.0178897344,
0.0591835566,
-0.0190855544,
-0.0152214514,
-0.0345619209,
-0.0039061704,
0.0061699674,
0.0150336614,
-0.0092324009,
-0.0037229897,
-0.064691335,
0.0081024682,
0.018264873,
0.0429002382,
-0.0363507308,
-0.0468505733,
-0.0027925218,
0.0157293212,
0.0253846105,
-0.016382141,
-0.0178200658,
0.0348565839,
-0.0401719324,
0.0235546697,
-0.0038622264,
-0.0523200594,
-0.0028210068,
-0.016498249,
0.0509375408,
-0.0427674465,
-0.0373366661,
0.0121017918,
-0.0033674543,
-0.0144198099,
-0.0311286263,
0.0602615364,
0.0427279025,
-0.0444409177,
-0.0325444713,
-0.0463793315,
0.0678300858,
0.0456359647,
0.0682626665,
-0.096386373,
-0.0320938826,
0.0123728355,
0.1014332771,
0.0091145691,
0.0036097511,
-0.0192832984,
-0.1138363406,
0.0574643612,
-0.0193345752,
0.0064629391,
0.0332111903,
-0.0528605506,
0.0036752601,
-0.0020308858,
-0.0490124486,
0.0354656056,
-0.016010616,
0.0078350436,
0.0231014527,
0.0182939824,
-0.0508845001,
-0.0281200372,
0.0066253506,
0.0070088226,
0.0678759813,
0.0176730026,
0.0338780358,
-0.0619313642,
0.036280632,
-0.007990188,
0.0477916673,
-0.0579562858,
0.035631083,
-0.0333462916,
0.0444016047,
-0.018128017,
0.0009611564,
-0.0202591829,
0.0149843786,
-0.0072003184,
0.069639869,
-0.0546170436,
0.0676076859,
-0.0855494961,
-0.0203052312,
0.0029258642,
0.0657248199,
0.0029611727,
0.0146499788,
-0.0052536884,
-0.0246315133,
0.0293571558,
-0.0296742022,
0.011207249,
-0.0078086513,
-0.0558707155,
-0.0236838385,
-0.0584496483,
-0.0244330838,
-0.0179226734,
0.0060618217,
-0.0152447363,
0.0285877474,
-0.0922144875,
-0.0071127811,
-0.0694647729,
0.0238521863,
-0.0339287966,
-0.0161967222,
-0.0279397666,
-0.0140051348,
0.0840104669,
-0.0783288181,
-0.0251445901,
0.0301707238,
-0.026761774,
-0.0364965722,
-0.0465918779,
0.0193943828,
0.0248292331,
0.0376417637,
-0.0293180775,
-0.0375831872,
-0.0012450287,
0.0953733772,
0.0027577893,
0.00583268,
-0.0063078199,
0.008199323,
-0.0365907177,
-0.003531351,
-0.0939580277,
0.020417599,
-0.0554322042,
0.0554436967,
0.0254408978,
-0.0725343153,
0.0139131546,
0.0538939647,
0.0369402841,
-0.0309170168,
-0.0006567153,
-0.0168828573,
0.0229871664,
-0.008502637,
-0.0240288135,
-0.0257056672,
0.0308986157,
-0.0256053396,
-0.061607901,
0.001999157,
0.0538447462,
-0.039991755,
0.0851894617,
-0.0539899766,
-0.0046950355,
-0.0130592622,
-0.0120693631,
-0.0297152884,
-0.0170323793,
-0.0118035851,
-0.0024448971,
0.0164299682,
0.0503882207,
-0.0508727245,
0.0277929585,
0.0140185487,
0.0437919013,
0.0220646411,
0.0177480523,
-0.058914572,
-0.0174990166,
-0.072035484,
0.0026376392,
0.0103239026,
0.0082822144,
0.0586094037,
-0.0192980394,
-0.021635741,
-0.0207249429,
0.0083617223,
0.0352788568,
0.0063413898,
0.0036904381,
0.035502024,
0.0003099099,
0.021530848,
0.0577577055,
-0.0163499992,
0.0300294869,
-0.0703793168,
-0.0554925762,
-0.0444453321,
-0.0628481805,
0.0228101946,
0.0710750222,
-0.010174416,
-0.0319055468,
-0.0525690354,
-0.0062389676,
0.0255058166,
-0.0043792524,
-0.021825185,
-0.040730603,
0.0701387674,
0.0686605498,
0.0063585774,
-0.0301323533,
-0.0443774536,
-0.021644732,
-0.0915025324,
0.0050097043,
0.0132260043,
-6.263111043e-33,
-0.0418737903,
-0.0359870605,
0.0400900543,
-0.0020715375,
-0.0193718076,
0.0037779731,
0.0039452133,
-0.033594843,
0.0087626893,
-0.047814779,
-0.0059226239,
0.0142055284,
0.0068057748,
-0.007945912,
0.0022034268,
0.0120799476,
0.0300077144,
-0.0023375016,
-0.0480391495,
0.0398984775,
0.0591605678,
0.0074594007,
-0.0062524555,
-0.0657579228,
0.0222997069,
-0.0352739245,
-0.0188355185,
0.0027017207,
0.0062594051,
0.07521303,
-0.0089939814,
0.0387447253,
0.0256064609,
-0.0339934528,
0.0195134338,
-0.0393236391,
-0.0340195782,
-0.030174382,
0.0130628431,
-0.039246168,
-0.0478037968,
-0.0104673579,
0.0180890821,
0.0105558932,
-0.0421629362,
0.0116451513,
0.0382842533,
-0.0174373221,
-0.0341644809,
-0.0756019652,
-0.0418401882,
0.0311342403,
0.0263617411,
0.0136507712,
0.0009894195,
0.0337834544,
0.0143796001,
0.0676662177,
-0.0367017388,
0.0333495103,
-0.0140743125,
0.062122792,
0.0541458204,
0.0055094371,
-0.0208478961,
0.0232721027,
-0.0038272543,
0.0098873712,
0.033536952,
-0.0240453854,
-0.0012070846,
0.0363440551,
-0.0119963922,
0.0517627783,
0.0229528453,
0.0159393791,
-0.0511739627,
0.1122843772,
-0.0180677064,
0.0125099234,
0.0174109712,
0.0364100412,
-0.04497502,
-0.011107387,
-0.0278338883,
0.0455868989,
-0.0635833666,
-0.0126077402,
0.0467508137,
0.0343256667,
-0.0342728868,
0.0353301875,
0.0282073747,
0.0108768782,
0.0043520336,
0.0230799597,
-0.030010229,
-0.0058832597,
-0.014225157,
-0.0136996573,
0.0032222501,
-0.0381977782,
0.0294566657,
-0.0160022099,
-0.0180477891,
-0.0141528063,
0.0285728127,
0.0072394875,
-0.028273223,
0.0152674094,
-0.0084370067,
0.0239512566,
-0.055464197,
-0.030356111,
-0.0014555336,
0.0071355831,
-0.0003612969,
0.0626192912,
0.0418787301,
0.0444358326,
0.0006859286,
-0.0672696158,
0.0224031229,
-0.0037563723,
-0.0097645363,
0.0768894553,
0.0407799929,
0.0316071697,
0.0071504172,
-0.0423694327,
-0.0306600351,
0.0420616269,
2.755e-7,
0.0644480512,
0.0304781254,
0.0195487402,
0.0304128621,
0.0057988991,
0.0095241079,
0.014280458,
0.0284125693,
0.0484335758,
-0.0002067489,
0.0114023713,
-0.009776935,
0.0383354984,
0.0181608461,
-0.0648364946,
-0.0145187322,
-0.0135084167,
-0.0044252365,
-0.0395002067,
-0.0267951898,
0.0186568759,
0.0188062973,
-0.0279085357,
-0.0367334411,
0.0010498045,
-0.0380260833,
0.0582710467,
0.002910397,
0.0022934787,
0.0325124972,
0.067655459,
0.0607031547,
0.0071047633,
-0.0285846926,
-0.0212417189,
0.0141788656,
0.0352875404,
0.0209933314,
-0.0040945215,
-0.0451726727,
0.0374169648,
-0.0267766435,
0.0367653556,
0.0094415694,
0.0562789291,
0.0397901498,
0.0091034938,
0.0262146611,
-0.0404389687,
0.0023814302,
-0.0223262776,
-0.0254739746,
-0.0160420705,
-0.0148406513,
-0.0097688986,
0.0192122776,
-0.0412047058,
-0.043941576,
-0.0131818596,
-0.0123989964,
-0.0421214625,
-0.0489367619,
-0.0507088378,
0.0608256944,
-0.0397036038,
-0.0550502762,
-0.0146331843,
2.587792727e-34,
0.0279162508,
0.0133036673,
-0.0081002051,
0.0099125877,
0.020538412,
0.0292636156,
-0.0386465192,
0.0138378683,
0.0169188157,
-0.0732196048,
-0.0168329924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14155v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14155v1 | Aligning Large Language Models with Diverse Political Viewpoints | 2024-06-20T09:53:23 | 2024-06-20T09:53:23 | Dominik Stammbach, Philine Widmer, Eunjung Cho, Caglar Gulcehre, Elliott Ash | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models such as ChatGPT often exhibit striking political
biases. If users query them about political information, they might take a
normative stance and reinforce such biases. To overcome this, we align LLMs
with diverse political viewpoints from 100,000 comments written by candidates
running for national parliament in Switzerland. Such aligned models are able to
generate more accurate political viewpoints from Swiss parties compared to
commercial models such as ChatGPT. We also propose a procedure to generate
balanced overviews from multiple viewpoints using such models. | [
0.0257352125,
0.0785128623,
0.0018887937,
0.0467902161,
-0.0232748296,
0.0044376762,
-0.0268943068,
-0.0108042182,
0.034100242,
-0.0552134365,
0.0370971933,
-0.0774462298,
-0.0330489017,
0.0222099461,
-0.0152277555,
-0.0984768122,
0.0450787321,
0.0205582026,
0.0425729901,
-0.0388439335,
0.0536580719,
0.0238418207,
0.0058396719,
0.0482299551,
0.0015332474,
0.0135686798,
-0.0283953082,
0.0298800748,
0.0461189896,
0.0286273602,
-0.0108252419,
0.0168886874,
-0.0006235148,
0.0204373449,
0.0000014957,
-0.0065045794,
-0.0268060602,
-0.0267736055,
0.0388116278,
-0.0190808959,
0.0959138647,
-0.0014950514,
-0.0172847956,
0.0233538486,
-0.0399013311,
0.0178709198,
0.0553215221,
0.0149798179,
0.0611156523,
0.0479738005,
-0.0024872934,
-0.0326309539,
-0.0503350385,
-0.0227596126,
-0.0198556986,
-0.038263049,
0.0355471,
-0.0021954612,
-0.0490366556,
0.031547565,
-0.0123467864,
0.0056967232,
-0.0156860612,
-0.0048797764,
-0.0284428485,
0.0009536477,
0.0218488779,
-0.0255633462,
0.0022497138,
0.0213542767,
0.0192497373,
-0.0122995842,
0.0326295942,
-0.0353469476,
0.0066613681,
0.0603718273,
-0.0532049425,
0.0311740786,
-0.0263793282,
0.0492662564,
0.0523534641,
-0.0115092043,
0.0126370033,
0.0359727964,
-0.0150885731,
0.0476993509,
0.0028048344,
-0.0112488857,
-0.0090802275,
-0.0033014608,
0.0380287543,
-0.042321004,
-0.0042580632,
-0.0066372883,
0.0004563578,
0.0469610728,
-0.0056254719,
0.0496177115,
0.0461358167,
-0.076157406,
0.0097580012,
0.034730196,
-0.007379475,
0.0958675146,
0.0711514205,
-0.0312162694,
-0.032947056,
-0.0212580469,
-0.0137566132,
-0.0567211024,
-0.0259591863,
0.0016610043,
0.0107185841,
0.0085712736,
-0.0437106565,
0.0165782757,
-0.0234100409,
0.020172514,
-0.0128981704,
0.0157459304,
0.0390798524,
0.0007260334,
-0.0133354841,
-0.0311075114,
-0.0799140111,
0.0777968392,
-0.0367676243,
0.0187793877,
-0.0459728986,
-0.0307241324,
0.0230362676,
0.0400544629,
-0.0205788277,
-0.0118883764,
-0.0263027325,
0.0388471372,
0.0041767498,
0.0398365594,
0.0271896757,
-0.0119929248,
-0.0351383537,
-0.0454991162,
0.0094882967,
-0.0900195017,
0.070448108,
-0.0101080043,
0.0188382287,
-0.0354208909,
0.0019449223,
0.0210516825,
-0.0587511286,
0.0445728824,
-0.0235781632,
0.022955941,
0.0291221235,
0.0261072721,
0.0058346763,
0.115736261,
-0.0196096357,
-0.0017112152,
0.026401462,
-0.0152980732,
-0.0070037548,
0.0295627043,
-0.015853662,
0.0567944944,
-0.0488005392,
0.0386997499,
-0.0270221941,
-0.0519743524,
0.0332729071,
0.0572311059,
0.0113435332,
-0.0174677651,
0.06042061,
0.0446506366,
-0.0000981323,
0.0336410515,
-0.0146787344,
0.0095788082,
0.0173102878,
0.0269753337,
-0.0014340009,
0.035078913,
-0.0118639041,
-0.0208045766,
0.0383506864,
0.028818164,
-0.0186270941,
-0.0123824347,
-0.0148974434,
0.0020006902,
0.0185009874,
0.0146060986,
0.0333817974,
-0.0653105229,
-0.0070004757,
0.0610329807,
0.0595206693,
-0.0537272207,
0.0195277017,
-0.0281012971,
0.0214210842,
0.0428352542,
-0.0228043031,
-0.0309525523,
-0.0426788069,
-0.0196092501,
0.0223879013,
0.0766166002,
0.1165042296,
-0.0337056369,
-0.0358214676,
-0.0190493874,
-0.0376259908,
0.0253786501,
0.0182064325,
0.046950601,
-0.0126836887,
0.0058606146,
-0.009252429,
-0.0061953566,
0.0045689307,
0.0049086581,
-0.0181853436,
0.0279559772,
-0.0169689339,
0.0029406813,
0.0269993376,
0.0395187996,
-0.0006256066,
-0.0136901923,
0.0439445972,
-0.0109944493,
-0.0074737049,
-0.0088572064,
-0.0392769054,
0.0257403608,
0.0425711274,
-0.0464061312,
-0.0160634685,
0.0052114548,
-0.0421181992,
-0.0279141162,
0.0509687327,
-0.005203322,
0.0341253653,
-0.0281041153,
-0.0017719148,
-0.016868135,
-0.0414909795,
-0.078301467,
0.0896623656,
0.0047169942,
0.0224486906,
0.0358239263,
-0.0542370975,
0.0129369609,
-0.013498229,
-0.0120518897,
0.0278934147,
0.0377667844,
0.0322246514,
0.0464964397,
-0.0331526846,
-0.0342200063,
-0.0623380616,
-0.0649707839,
-0.0001274245,
-0.0424919836,
0.0619831011,
0.0671485215,
0.0015571065,
-0.0035903736,
0.0186395738,
-0.0605550893,
-0.0474862382,
-0.0293870177,
-0.0172889214,
0.0423443131,
0.0065381173,
-0.0284059737,
-0.0415572003,
0.0125859752,
-0.0333549865,
0.0042089047,
0.005177475,
-0.0604434386,
-0.0244549178,
0.0102471793,
-0.0596628748,
0.0040373709,
-0.0377774015,
-0.0210192688,
0.0137477787,
0.0058501731,
0.0363173559,
0.0221223217,
0.0499412678,
0.0410163887,
0.0114287464,
0.0094512338,
-0.0876470655,
-0.021948887,
-0.049176719,
0.0311359651,
-0.0522181503,
-0.0401996002,
0.0234271605,
0.0642303303,
0.0084540956,
0.0128913289,
-0.0454769768,
0.0680030882,
-0.0143272104,
0.0114933029,
-0.0281918831,
-0.0069550164,
-0.0155586163,
0.0147866821,
0.0155987553,
-0.006651259,
0.019768158,
-0.0056736134,
0.0550745092,
-0.0096682515,
-0.012849696,
-0.0509733818,
0.0644567534,
-0.023927737,
0.0245635584,
-0.0490805134,
-0.0004820968,
-0.0481534749,
-0.063129887,
0.0510684587,
-0.0546082072,
0.0874020532,
-0.0563683063,
0.0312267113,
-0.0338709392,
-0.0413643755,
-0.0405987985,
-0.08250916,
-0.0182537418,
0.008450062,
0.031610582,
-0.0341266207,
-0.021673169,
0.0437943749,
0.0099476557,
-0.0474143066,
0.0042300448,
0.0202687141,
0.0035464331,
0.0017077634,
0.0215922501,
-0.0223751403,
-0.0046550194,
-0.0098722978,
-0.0035426239,
0.0562329143,
-0.0024641401,
0.0250145737,
-0.0119580012,
-0.0663798302,
0.0300972294,
-0.051513128,
-0.0307293683,
-0.0396851338,
0.0319340639,
-0.0245473813,
0.0288308207,
0.0844678357,
0.0249536783,
-0.058503706,
-0.031781368,
-0.0032830001,
0.0026416995,
0.0350999944,
0.0029976314,
-0.0855013803,
0.0325782038,
0.0074183997,
-0.014994883,
-0.0269888453,
-0.0073328707,
-0.0180669203,
-0.0839312747,
-0.0002004739,
0.0223035943,
-0.0172353853,
-0.0124328984,
-0.0244187731,
0.0323858894,
-0.0264904555,
-0.0183644071,
0.0081392247,
-0.0011983633,
-0.0008529519,
0.0194095913,
-0.0783659145,
-0.0486925356,
-0.0110237272,
-0.0159974992,
0.0733613446,
0.0192861632,
0.0601580627,
-0.0001802824,
-0.0194342993,
0.0884579495,
0.0062254099,
-0.0243974999,
0.0012518836,
-0.0063228691,
-0.0228054393,
-0.0081662145,
-0.0220240019,
0.0282683559,
0.0384816118,
-0.0103109917,
0.0094524967,
0.0244163722,
-0.0459405109,
0.0164184645,
-0.0053323847,
0.038734626,
0.0628719702,
0.0821276456,
0.0377333313,
-0.0114316586,
-0.0001173637,
-0.0600558408,
-0.0209138356,
-0.0118803158,
-0.0331820622,
0.0121841403,
-0.0413732938,
-0.0154281957,
-0.0033714126,
-0.0351432972,
-0.004518589,
0.0009134724,
-0.0048376406,
0.0266479608,
0.0516047068,
-0.0249328241,
0.0027337887,
0.0154730026,
-0.0392575637,
-0.0052332799,
0.0007080475,
-0.0627351999,
0.00635343,
-0.0059390762,
-0.0314427391,
-0.0163936764,
-0.0591269955,
-0.0619609877,
0.0222304258,
-0.0111918868,
0.0307854768,
0.0363488644,
-0.0212926902,
-0.0328297019,
0.0070501021,
0.0510082915,
-0.0017372081,
-0.031115856,
-0.0054855398,
0.054719191,
0.0182953477,
0.0400342345,
-0.0234164521,
0.0171747338,
0.0528102554,
-0.025366025,
-0.0777999312,
-0.0445805863,
0.0178151913,
0.0065009557,
0.0521012805,
0.0079539064,
-0.0530622266,
-0.0470755585,
-0.0269260462,
-0.0404561125,
-0.0312275589,
0.0094233593,
0.0116835125,
0.0151419779,
-0.0467144847,
-0.0124583235,
0.0244808961,
-0.0526172295,
0.0385293812,
-0.0331127308,
0.0465854295,
-0.01441707,
-0.0139090875,
0.0318772197,
-0.0096478527,
-0.0235291198,
0.0371451303,
0.0006934647,
0.0288156401,
0.0034018864,
-0.0044079013,
0.0091884211,
0.0167487543,
0.0579790659,
-0.0296583343,
-0.0644299984,
-0.061163038,
-0.0421058051,
0.0601125881,
0.0477034375,
0.0153141646,
0.0505217686,
-0.0096354466,
-0.0163504835,
-0.0064558885,
0.0138540687,
0.0310739949,
-0.0183125567,
0.0574522577,
-0.007034916,
-0.0554347374,
-0.0220911354,
0.0589381196,
-0.0120953443,
0.0260697976,
0.0236056577,
-0.0188414082,
-0.0261628628,
-0.0285741687,
0.0236059558,
-0.0302362628,
-0.04113511,
-0.0452725776,
-0.055330094,
-0.0186877102,
0.0007398931,
0.0209052358,
-0.0169855747,
0.0326024592,
0.0105292294,
0.0548401773,
0.0042789262,
0.0608670376,
-0.0603753626,
0.0492396802,
-0.0614239983,
-0.0264967438,
0.0029260416,
-6.229303825e-33,
-0.0263980944,
-0.0199539457,
0.0087256823,
-0.03093067,
-0.0196782015,
-0.0121585391,
0.0046856194,
0.0450957604,
-0.0241004825,
0.007028501,
0.0167305171,
0.0465467088,
0.0317918397,
0.0080463514,
-0.0006168056,
-0.0364070758,
0.0289321057,
0.0151894353,
-0.0153447334,
0.0074045528,
0.0253074374,
-0.0087698,
0.0553057939,
-0.0733478367,
0.0620124079,
-0.0043590586,
-0.0146549447,
-0.0086140521,
0.0130847869,
0.028870929,
-0.0234083831,
-0.0039633736,
0.0358047523,
-0.01544517,
-0.0253455602,
0.0721210837,
0.0117348759,
-0.0114214374,
0.0461381674,
0.0013789712,
0.0127481679,
-0.0234002266,
0.0321460031,
0.0161519572,
-0.0432575345,
0.0064925859,
0.0472168699,
-0.0108783562,
0.011516856,
-0.015674632,
-0.0120048933,
0.0376820974,
-0.0013889982,
0.036329072,
-0.0403069034,
0.0460112356,
0.0585159399,
0.0411615781,
-0.0544619001,
0.0362256877,
-0.0241508838,
0.0170338452,
0.0607211366,
-0.0248198155,
-0.0078626657,
0.0800846741,
0.0116086639,
0.0254169833,
-0.0761552677,
-0.0268251803,
-0.0107228067,
-0.0051762885,
0.0431473739,
0.0609246306,
0.0107554086,
-0.0370272808,
-0.0941192135,
0.0166595448,
0.0733324438,
0.0012292444,
0.0337417088,
-0.0127023887,
0.0041605467,
-0.0097944513,
-0.0296166725,
-0.044855915,
-0.017944539,
-0.0212793499,
-0.0219725892,
0.0050279177,
0.0003849381,
0.0092405761,
0.0265415013,
-0.067971617,
-0.0243902598,
0.0007793132,
-0.0325004533,
-0.0255303811,
-0.0110775782,
0.0188055467,
-0.042442359,
-0.0364758968,
-0.0305651706,
0.0317356251,
-0.0137460129,
-0.0070596398,
-0.0043083909,
-0.0259327218,
-0.0865124911,
-0.0057674535,
-0.0358850881,
0.0014960438,
-0.0137679381,
0.0580646135,
0.0541958213,
-0.0093489811,
0.0215442516,
0.0418959036,
0.0287444871,
-0.0142143387,
0.0094836401,
-0.0287085511,
-0.053296946,
0.0208927635,
-0.0154246092,
-0.0212840103,
-0.0093860561,
0.019382285,
0.0343436971,
0.004753998,
-0.0094145462,
-0.014813873,
2.312e-7,
0.0858153105,
0.0491066426,
-0.0176307745,
0.0193044227,
-0.0060166265,
0.0198775437,
-0.0030401186,
0.0433118641,
-0.0664635971,
-0.0392938219,
-0.0280071162,
-0.0008942974,
0.0400988124,
0.0558887906,
-0.0924422815,
-0.0186420996,
-0.0888585001,
0.0039488869,
-0.0301374272,
0.0376658179,
0.0198707581,
0.0620364211,
0.025999574,
0.0055979765,
-0.0293294434,
-0.0048353802,
0.0692950189,
-0.0446977839,
-0.0933249518,
0.0565631948,
0.0616427027,
-0.0313064829,
0.0322769098,
0.0321872495,
0.0212824084,
-0.0189168155,
-0.0339085311,
0.082977213,
0.0040437556,
-0.0092665525,
-0.0298685562,
-0.0368258096,
0.0200899988,
-0.0140036913,
0.0423914567,
-0.0224813186,
-0.0001504805,
-0.0805945843,
-0.0177958682,
-0.0005721669,
0.0694280118,
0.0002882222,
-0.0097298017,
0.0298714563,
0.0018574819,
-0.0283666551,
-0.015722502,
-0.0423882194,
-0.0323746055,
-0.0429688655,
-0.0326696932,
-0.0764276385,
0.0321054943,
0.0205759052,
0.0410847217,
-0.0314795375,
0.0115064885,
1.522032726e-34,
0.0501737297,
0.0247115381,
-0.0376569703,
-0.0285130516,
0.0402223244,
0.0087368311,
-0.0099412231,
0.0085661551,
-0.0073412401,
-0.0362380818,
0.0010373918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14154v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14154v1 | Watching the Watchers: A Comparative Fairness Audit of Cloud-based Content Moderation Services | 2024-06-20T09:52:10 | 2024-06-20T09:52:10 | David Hartmann, Amin Oueslati, Dimitri Staufer | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG | Online platforms face the challenge of moderating an ever-increasing volume
of content, including harmful hate speech. In the absence of clear legal
definitions and a lack of transparency regarding the role of algorithms in
shaping decisions on content moderation, there is a critical need for external
accountability. Our study contributes to filling this gap by systematically
evaluating four leading cloud-based content moderation services through a
third-party audit, highlighting issues such as biases against minorities and
vulnerable groups that may arise through over-reliance on these services. Using
a black-box audit approach and four benchmark data sets, we measure performance
in explicit and implicit hate speech detection as well as counterfactual
fairness through perturbation sensitivity analysis and present disparities in
performance for certain target identity groups and data sets. Our analysis
reveals that all services had difficulties detecting implicit hate speech,
which relies on more subtle and codified messages. Moreover, our results point
to the need to remove group-specific bias. It seems that biases towards some
groups, such as Women, have been mostly rectified, while biases towards other
groups, such as LGBTQ+ and PoC remain. | [
0.0675108358,
0.0806093067,
-0.0437376164,
-0.0140673378,
-0.010892598,
0.0266926289,
0.1023440063,
0.002899813,
0.0121748345,
-0.0603300743,
-0.0050448189,
0.0168987419,
0.0163809974,
0.0314031802,
-0.0234847926,
0.0154307922,
0.0064051938,
0.058942683,
0.0175666139,
0.0041873553,
0.0504715741,
0.0165807456,
0.0006585342,
0.0205480158,
-0.0227067769,
0.0012621806,
0.0657146722,
0.0005435944,
-0.0009505478,
-0.0065507805,
0.0228952747,
0.0003187244,
-0.0433329679,
0.0741650909,
0.0000018148,
-0.0751839504,
-0.0345037468,
0.0160352439,
-0.0012206858,
-0.0134989256,
0.0635138676,
-0.0176187512,
-0.0199811291,
0.0482109636,
-0.003549224,
0.0434732772,
0.0367814265,
-0.0018779208,
0.0452751815,
0.0316683948,
-0.0312942937,
0.0134559646,
-0.0556066334,
0.0241443422,
-0.0163200852,
0.0404963531,
0.0184888151,
-0.0625918284,
-0.0773942173,
-0.0612043552,
-0.0060296538,
0.0174552705,
0.036702849,
0.0005833035,
-0.0032476715,
-0.0422418863,
-0.0462036878,
-0.0383898243,
-0.0057023922,
0.0237192716,
0.0591321625,
0.0310135819,
-0.0013603651,
-0.0151540479,
0.0353896208,
0.0260933582,
-0.0204589013,
0.0424291007,
-0.0295197126,
-0.0005533719,
-0.0386976749,
0.0228101742,
0.0388767831,
0.0570710711,
0.0656382143,
0.0875525102,
-0.0074324179,
-0.0493545718,
-0.0069399294,
0.0014271471,
0.0655385703,
0.0043889484,
0.0677237436,
-0.0172233023,
-0.0224423911,
-0.0062710745,
-0.0173029099,
-0.0520596169,
0.0178075079,
-0.0323769562,
0.0325081311,
0.056808833,
-0.0184555314,
0.008586809,
0.0281229801,
0.058676783,
0.0134245558,
0.0401305482,
0.0255744159,
0.0289224256,
0.0414738581,
0.0331559628,
0.0657189712,
-0.0032614495,
-0.0140688848,
0.0617708005,
-0.0512961,
0.0074915802,
-0.0547639318,
0.0042486554,
0.0112862671,
-0.0089395177,
0.0115365535,
0.0177873876,
-0.0358436331,
-0.0430731997,
-0.0624177754,
0.0260360427,
-0.0286793932,
-0.0581902675,
0.019665448,
0.0149522396,
0.0004531023,
-0.0140852425,
0.043745432,
0.0533366762,
0.0334759839,
0.0100024007,
0.0103513049,
-0.0303351879,
-0.0109305186,
-0.0335722715,
-0.0242822729,
-0.0231502689,
0.0073785288,
0.0156193869,
-0.0183177497,
-0.0573298782,
-0.0218522493,
-0.0148046911,
-0.021438336,
0.0220312495,
0.0171923321,
-0.0144004766,
0.0360649489,
0.0428285599,
-0.0322665349,
0.0364321321,
-0.0024675766,
-0.0077767503,
0.0740108192,
0.0003537294,
0.0013337097,
0.0277739428,
0.0152555797,
0.0546479374,
-0.0353240855,
0.0229339991,
-0.0669444799,
-0.0284578521,
0.0298330989,
-0.0004130251,
0.0109232496,
-0.0378620662,
0.0439643078,
0.0491997376,
-0.0353386477,
0.0285366606,
-0.0057992223,
-0.0146704754,
-0.044907894,
-0.0302906372,
-0.0791252181,
-0.017271921,
0.006612028,
-0.0656204671,
0.031065518,
0.0523285344,
-0.0119090704,
-0.0387285091,
-0.0198844317,
0.0214327015,
0.0754263103,
0.003561005,
0.0011866657,
-0.0321972743,
-0.0087633245,
-0.0074580335,
0.0194969028,
-0.0013999733,
0.0189187899,
-0.0506771207,
0.0399091467,
0.0226520244,
0.0052620834,
-0.0229450278,
0.03839349,
-0.0538328923,
-0.0026307346,
0.0174041223,
0.047038015,
0.0091580786,
-0.0322888494,
-0.0159847122,
-0.0439870022,
0.025940951,
0.0249277074,
0.0335902311,
0.0523732789,
0.0490298644,
-0.0066053066,
0.0424649641,
-0.0307760891,
0.0077000703,
0.0605551377,
-0.0103345709,
-0.0024935438,
-0.0048161652,
0.0500567257,
0.0064475979,
-0.0294858739,
-0.0199325848,
-0.0195908211,
0.0241506379,
-0.0350263752,
0.003998932,
0.0019012217,
0.0785772949,
0.0354813486,
-0.0323595293,
0.0114916023,
0.0581903271,
0.0106520299,
0.0584553368,
0.0745846629,
0.04997411,
-0.0651412308,
-0.0033536367,
-0.0353063568,
-0.0576293766,
0.0256859586,
0.0024173062,
0.0036278751,
-0.0364751816,
0.0307197217,
-0.0051643411,
-0.0597758181,
0.0392868444,
0.0525413901,
-0.0155452173,
-0.0290692952,
-0.0730514824,
0.0182467997,
0.014783361,
-0.0373649485,
-0.0252777226,
0.0408610664,
-0.0478720665,
-0.0233052447,
-0.0040407339,
-0.0139984582,
-0.0047411332,
0.0353806913,
-0.0178898405,
0.0108834719,
-0.004844246,
-0.089251928,
0.0159453433,
0.0427387878,
0.001158576,
-0.0513122156,
-0.0285859834,
-0.0140063977,
-0.0353808627,
-0.0456722938,
0.0239097252,
0.0460308269,
-0.0130026974,
0.0537009202,
-0.0430345573,
-0.0450682193,
-0.0161096193,
-0.0183123816,
-0.0357061736,
0.0281319823,
0.0256493222,
-0.018821694,
0.0337326825,
0.0643585175,
0.0248089042,
0.0110364389,
0.035180755,
0.0120451683,
0.0093037868,
0.0206393376,
-0.0078854654,
-0.006282602,
-0.0122334352,
0.0023622736,
0.0225137919,
0.0393183753,
-0.0112101221,
-0.0339355767,
0.0701626092,
-0.0890725702,
-0.0508375317,
-0.0486757234,
-0.059933152,
-0.0119833294,
0.037675377,
-0.0151616884,
-0.0515307412,
0.0166519973,
0.0145574221,
0.030405445,
0.004023524,
-0.0345337056,
-0.0170328338,
-0.0013426577,
-0.0556953922,
0.0372533202,
-0.078076005,
-0.0002972907,
0.0323357135,
-0.0479196347,
0.1283142418,
-0.0579319261,
-0.0320517942,
0.0166093409,
0.0014932984,
-0.0051507754,
-0.0300449748,
-0.0144641502,
-0.0397556461,
-0.0430301949,
-0.0193785783,
0.0452787653,
0.014754382,
-0.0251519717,
0.0316347666,
0.0291656312,
0.0199161991,
0.0067970678,
-0.0069323834,
0.0481152497,
-0.0988615751,
-0.0896045119,
0.0024816331,
0.0786650851,
-0.0108210389,
-0.0270157848,
0.0378550142,
0.0240237713,
-0.0179689322,
0.0539199933,
0.0526316836,
0.0048435191,
-0.0148419971,
0.0219153203,
-0.0146088004,
0.0325119868,
-0.0064864196,
0.0474943146,
0.0283898562,
-0.0078360876,
-0.0582460091,
-0.0205350406,
-0.0083924551,
-0.0346202478,
0.0387925245,
-0.0186555944,
-0.0796997622,
0.004734626,
0.0161011331,
0.0499132946,
-0.1127037108,
-0.0731852874,
-0.0065892544,
-0.03243348,
0.0313902833,
-0.0027817993,
-0.0015861995,
-0.0501324758,
-0.0238930862,
0.0198400952,
-0.0212289263,
0.0128876939,
-0.0440712832,
0.0284310952,
0.003024599,
-0.0042186277,
-0.0537537113,
0.0179636478,
-0.000189483,
-0.0738563463,
-0.0066824788,
0.0196853057,
-0.0094830338,
-0.0378876776,
0.0231320076,
0.0620561317,
0.0076545989,
-0.0553466119,
-0.0198177304,
0.0214883238,
0.0026713861,
-0.0202696528,
-0.0293633286,
0.0439146459,
0.0041125049,
0.022898566,
-0.0061150431,
0.0020956839,
0.0602336749,
-0.0155545492,
-0.0573869906,
0.0201875642,
0.0098113818,
0.0367258191,
-0.0093749398,
-0.0632386804,
0.0043626335,
-0.0869634822,
-0.0026126918,
0.0151583105,
-0.0699872449,
0.0118169533,
0.0447659865,
-0.0212034397,
0.0129375271,
-0.0035772542,
-0.0511932336,
-0.0025831859,
0.0316721983,
-0.0322917886,
0.0068529886,
-0.0353696607,
-0.0026433207,
-0.0119459452,
-0.0002334686,
0.0525914766,
0.0196018443,
0.0092702108,
-0.0804673582,
0.0108417189,
-0.037441317,
0.0185360629,
-0.0086148633,
0.0078174816,
0.0745352879,
0.039993722,
0.0158719439,
0.0138982544,
-0.0126373656,
-0.0043152329,
0.0591196977,
0.0685973465,
-0.0598043725,
0.0084798429,
0.0610139966,
-0.0253240801,
0.0001259802,
-0.0045624305,
-0.0275373962,
-0.021202622,
0.0260255523,
-0.0563331805,
0.0170850996,
0.0132987201,
-0.0175704043,
-0.0041501839,
-0.0338972025,
-0.006189385,
-0.0239187125,
-0.0124111595,
-0.011693731,
0.0162299201,
-0.0442285016,
-0.0068387338,
-0.0148790265,
0.0262191202,
-0.0174434911,
-0.0428241976,
0.0364541709,
-0.0333918259,
-0.0303664058,
-0.0802193359,
0.0396652259,
0.0072502466,
0.0243603121,
0.0222328138,
-0.0049831378,
-0.0125400368,
0.0439336598,
0.0178380888,
-0.0053590583,
-0.0062287515,
0.0029679493,
0.0227865651,
0.0657655597,
0.014560177,
-0.0154934479,
-0.0206230171,
-0.0101807676,
0.0053693005,
-0.0514468923,
-0.0362861454,
-0.0006918577,
0.000115445,
0.0455593616,
-0.0270150676,
0.0009877257,
-0.0234582666,
0.0051208874,
0.0167188719,
-0.0132413898,
0.0140696699,
-0.0187421292,
0.0398582332,
-0.0120119415,
-0.0081343772,
0.0378017575,
-0.0198461246,
-0.0336252041,
0.0026650946,
-0.0157245137,
-0.0180516317,
0.0368885733,
0.0047389902,
-0.0094514592,
-0.0573656633,
-0.0234281737,
-0.0235516969,
-0.0514337309,
0.0520542376,
-0.0430203751,
-0.0297089312,
0.0612499788,
0.0054104007,
-0.0133089917,
-0.0134889428,
-0.0263743531,
-0.0575006753,
-0.0585130081,
0.0048922226,
-5.783526613e-33,
-0.0103191482,
-0.0315981023,
-0.0420110412,
-0.0087120095,
0.0001716687,
-0.0048695188,
0.034803763,
0.0038447345,
0.0039670556,
0.0082689887,
-0.0182236433,
0.0275355335,
0.0115418108,
-0.0059770816,
0.0093507404,
-0.0557581149,
0.0332486331,
-0.0253182724,
-0.0531588458,
0.0213776156,
-0.0289056208,
-0.0096071986,
-0.0291820355,
-0.0906281546,
0.0479788333,
0.0144045446,
-0.0366194732,
-0.0014785895,
-0.0247582141,
0.0837372839,
-0.0019494342,
0.0548977368,
0.0162794199,
-0.0235666782,
0.0423729196,
0.0187491141,
-0.0584456287,
0.0289221853,
0.0439488888,
0.0042671566,
0.0444384143,
-0.0080739073,
0.0146166263,
0.0393324569,
-0.0231346488,
-0.0534771532,
0.0191140492,
-0.0163923316,
0.0028336656,
-0.0666107759,
0.0121425837,
0.0101265851,
-0.0834674686,
0.0486715697,
-0.024268223,
0.0329822972,
0.0208695307,
0.0428788587,
-0.0315069929,
-0.0015208491,
-0.0107583981,
-0.0382776372,
-0.0017456523,
0.0176499505,
-0.0181103125,
0.0335835256,
0.006332105,
0.0126565695,
-0.0499877892,
-0.0154708,
0.0429456569,
-0.0260023866,
0.0044046068,
0.0630508959,
0.0155598223,
-0.0826827362,
-0.0268369708,
-0.005291387,
0.0318551585,
-0.0042042835,
0.0589959994,
-0.0623118654,
-0.0521228425,
-0.0244161561,
-0.0224063359,
-0.1134880111,
-0.0438302718,
0.0072143879,
0.0465552174,
0.0157598723,
-0.0413741991,
-0.0270776413,
0.0193448551,
-0.0438479595,
-0.013528429,
0.0321942307,
-0.009343178,
-0.0196745954,
0.0556097887,
-0.009979425,
-0.02750846,
-0.0025837668,
-0.0349798501,
-0.0041304603,
0.0522966273,
-0.0481623597,
0.007789697,
0.0526599586,
-0.063245222,
0.0255540926,
0.0227099638,
0.0678193942,
-0.008686766,
0.0535367057,
-0.0152954757,
0.0496716872,
0.0047860467,
0.0012073861,
0.044216264,
0.0247661546,
-0.0135455066,
-0.0302936044,
-0.0189842433,
0.0048399935,
-0.0303430986,
-0.0379071645,
0.0184423439,
-0.0097022476,
0.038208738,
-0.0525556058,
0.0158528183,
-0.058493834,
2.561e-7,
0.0249835029,
-0.0029820851,
-0.0187088493,
0.0034379424,
0.0307748038,
0.0262950044,
0.0597872511,
0.03818129,
0.0151124559,
0.0188881662,
-0.0279339962,
0.0235312767,
0.0136436187,
0.035003107,
0.0382303484,
-0.0477187075,
-0.0694879591,
0.0455135666,
-0.0395297743,
0.0367011763,
-0.0494780615,
0.0363683216,
0.0506030284,
-0.0300292857,
-0.0416878387,
-0.0137769608,
-0.0094239656,
-0.0451920144,
0.0229722597,
-0.0015608186,
0.0454841815,
0.0479606539,
0.025850391,
-0.0116862478,
0.0097134346,
0.045531705,
-0.0145344166,
0.023486061,
0.0553737395,
0.0355308726,
-0.0047223908,
-0.0105137378,
0.0380223021,
-0.0271232054,
0.0502896197,
0.076871559,
-0.00795912,
-0.0780384988,
-0.0276242103,
-0.0757248998,
0.0838888586,
0.0036768341,
-0.040992599,
0.0080381082,
0.0119453035,
0.0154573983,
0.0099942284,
-0.0599451922,
0.0138717052,
-0.0334537998,
0.0020347955,
-0.0385340117,
-0.0076057781,
0.0205893014,
0.0104565816,
0.0739193335,
0.0470028967,
2.212965461e-34,
0.0278438721,
-0.0049621058,
-0.0034888668,
-0.0489738546,
0.0287936348,
-0.0039832396,
0.0359775275,
-0.0449419655,
0.0196421985,
0.0163542982,
0.0100051304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14144v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14144v1 | Finding Safety Neurons in Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T09:35:22 | 2024-06-20T09:35:22 | Jianhui Chen, Xiaozhi Wang, Zijun Yao, Yushi Bai, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) excel in various capabilities but also pose
safety risks such as generating harmful content and misinformation, even after
safety alignment. In this paper, we explore the inner mechanisms of safety
alignment from the perspective of mechanistic interpretability, focusing on
identifying and analyzing safety neurons within LLMs that are responsible for
safety behaviors. We propose generation-time activation contrasting to locate
these neurons and dynamic activation patching to evaluate their causal effects.
Experiments on multiple recent LLMs show that: (1) Safety neurons are sparse
and effective. We can restore $90$% safety performance with intervention only
on about $5$% of all the neurons. (2) Safety neurons encode transferrable
mechanisms. They exhibit consistent effectiveness on different red-teaming
datasets. The finding of safety neurons also interprets "alignment tax". We
observe that the identified key neurons for safety and helpfulness
significantly overlap, but they require different activation patterns of the
shared neurons. Furthermore, we demonstrate an application of safety neurons in
detecting unsafe outputs before generation. Our findings may promote further
research on understanding LLM alignment. The source codes will be publicly
released to facilitate future research. | [
-0.0159778297,
0.0440698266,
-0.0210984927,
0.034042567,
-0.0117556285,
0.0348805413,
-0.0203456171,
-0.0252723396,
-0.0263134912,
0.0014136632,
-0.0416024737,
-0.0415915325,
-0.0029280116,
0.0231621955,
0.0504640527,
0.022709379,
0.09897466,
-0.0331172496,
0.0030925558,
-0.000644287,
0.0305637252,
0.0041919877,
0.0083896043,
0.0359797627,
0.0007796867,
-0.0277607534,
0.0004122253,
0.0178515036,
0.036738608,
-0.0192094874,
0.0018309657,
0.0320234224,
0.0242896806,
0.0897702798,
0.0000019716,
-0.0261611585,
-0.0099737933,
0.0178113487,
-0.0321856923,
0.0143572697,
0.0144090019,
-0.0538192876,
-0.0379478484,
0.0186404791,
0.0049936236,
-0.0080034453,
0.0944308564,
0.0305425134,
0.0639510006,
0.0914567783,
0.0202721898,
0.0058419979,
0.0664982051,
-0.016275622,
0.0062441663,
-0.0502292551,
0.0586257838,
-0.014526587,
-0.0545483269,
-0.0008968851,
-0.0569864474,
0.0194619168,
0.0076397047,
-0.0468816683,
-0.0179134924,
-0.0068971673,
-0.0146894446,
-0.0529728457,
-0.0065334504,
0.040616665,
-0.0281285793,
-0.0273556523,
0.0125202481,
0.0003698789,
-0.0072213416,
-0.0109362882,
-0.0232936293,
0.028230343,
0.0373887047,
0.0305748768,
0.0373116434,
-0.0144619215,
0.0763106942,
-0.0023382644,
0.040250048,
0.0648884922,
0.0198874064,
-0.0400190167,
-0.0254825186,
0.0052105393,
0.0032314688,
-0.0317268558,
-0.0241551716,
-0.0081493231,
-0.0225514863,
0.0585157238,
-0.0485363156,
-0.0397333018,
0.0408943407,
-0.0774665177,
0.0461136177,
0.041693829,
0.044002004,
0.0077270977,
-0.010424614,
0.0147476466,
-0.0656029284,
0.0942500979,
0.0015156653,
0.0278972611,
-0.0023480917,
-0.0440272577,
0.0258139465,
-0.0161514059,
0.0205733217,
0.0115674743,
-0.0538888983,
0.0450214148,
-0.0574097037,
0.0026901527,
-0.0222345907,
-0.0072353641,
-0.0338440686,
-0.0041922941,
0.0019579853,
0.0053383871,
0.0020554054,
-0.0031065403,
-0.0006485318,
-0.0363728702,
-0.0450547934,
0.0236540884,
-0.0290415958,
-0.0402807854,
-0.0232455842,
0.1010181755,
0.0020378937,
0.0015695904,
-0.0511325113,
-0.0111437999,
-0.0459225625,
-0.0116081974,
0.0066984589,
-0.0332448706,
0.0039426638,
-0.0036787021,
-0.0380702615,
-0.0728580803,
0.0269138571,
0.0008889887,
-0.0806039199,
0.0463543609,
-0.0550775304,
0.0079491949,
-0.021344224,
0.0054492564,
-0.019687457,
0.0510827228,
0.0497049242,
0.0089827152,
0.0181073379,
-0.0027668059,
0.0024733767,
0.0417973027,
0.0434151106,
0.0461279824,
-0.0588233918,
-0.0367145725,
0.0303020924,
0.0050011789,
0.0392588712,
0.0340618901,
-0.0232095905,
-0.0178929269,
0.0801998749,
-0.0060545434,
-0.0116018606,
0.0290087052,
0.0217677709,
-0.0174534805,
-0.0364272557,
0.004879267,
-0.0903284624,
0.0167195704,
-0.0641154796,
-0.00162169,
0.0037491785,
0.0261721816,
-0.0085941758,
-0.0072824196,
-0.0293125249,
0.0060308031,
0.0299054105,
-0.0160550065,
0.0079820119,
0.0083396295,
-0.0350408964,
0.0593185015,
0.0423046164,
-0.0298145339,
0.0110924635,
-0.0489153974,
0.0160729978,
0.0708866715,
0.0331634022,
-0.0043997052,
-0.0670493692,
-0.0138479983,
-0.029601153,
0.0333930664,
-0.0099315299,
0.0138098709,
0.0400380641,
-0.0554527938,
-0.0398048535,
0.0013551639,
0.0203034729,
-0.0080996547,
0.0227967445,
-0.0341716073,
-0.0203323215,
0.0068469658,
-0.0671924874,
0.043292053,
-0.0250205863,
-0.0172522776,
-0.0383597575,
-0.0026629805,
0.026373215,
-0.037269488,
-0.0426517241,
0.0115805883,
0.0362368561,
-0.0014695361,
0.0035811421,
0.022145316,
-0.0727635697,
-0.0026633358,
0.0512471758,
0.0189509541,
-0.0268225186,
0.0431368276,
-0.0258426834,
-0.0263537876,
0.0141529283,
-0.0363334045,
0.0023597346,
-0.0156413838,
0.0308613479,
-0.0253619663,
0.0158644449,
-0.0262160562,
0.072906591,
-0.0051611937,
-0.0248163529,
-0.0379235633,
-0.0165143888,
0.0149237104,
-0.0329760313,
-0.0196416546,
-0.0188210122,
-0.0171951335,
0.0561526865,
0.0157502647,
-0.0074306531,
-0.0117985755,
-0.0067276391,
0.0010412923,
0.0188313797,
0.0020057384,
0.0253746063,
0.0444207415,
-0.0425345637,
0.0033742033,
0.0209776014,
-0.0005885717,
0.0494580828,
0.0076854178,
0.0229073279,
0.0395448953,
-0.0232098531,
-0.0470889099,
-0.0449834913,
-0.0216436516,
-0.0395863578,
0.0454501323,
-0.0007830849,
-0.0336575657,
-0.0748629645,
0.0592510924,
0.0004629172,
0.0189882573,
0.0118320119,
-0.0772677884,
-0.0065515828,
0.0310076196,
-0.0160394106,
0.0511280969,
-0.0010551699,
0.0351962596,
0.060600929,
0.0332340822,
-0.0356266275,
0.0029560544,
-0.0258719139,
-0.0219277944,
-0.0479879044,
-0.0097339312,
-0.0266714226,
0.0955112353,
0.0158212055,
-0.0318284817,
-0.0504312739,
-0.0132096196,
-0.0178561676,
-0.0515963249,
0.0137590393,
-0.0877527222,
-0.0486305207,
0.052279368,
-0.0425947942,
-0.0737161487,
0.0673342869,
0.0006144302,
0.0173795298,
0.0000650988,
-0.013350727,
0.0044086562,
0.0460306443,
0.0164053608,
0.0396053381,
0.0199725833,
-0.0388415195,
-0.0697127506,
-0.0251854695,
0.027385259,
-0.0068386192,
0.0395020992,
-0.0316121764,
-0.0071963202,
-0.0043951166,
-0.0497896336,
-0.0492713638,
-0.0517754406,
0.021999035,
-0.0158915706,
0.0320914984,
-0.0138189923,
-0.0353648588,
-0.0290516708,
0.0425389335,
-0.0221932828,
-0.0435546786,
0.0196315292,
-0.0354802795,
-0.0106915943,
0.0395115428,
-0.0318086967,
0.0651841089,
-0.0646390691,
0.007025023,
0.0713109225,
-0.0064003048,
0.0337877907,
-0.0505684353,
-0.0056920643,
0.0352192558,
0.0105274403,
-0.0155543759,
0.0231524408,
0.0629347041,
-0.0441671573,
-0.009962894,
0.0661357045,
-0.0021191351,
-0.0156815965,
0.0268205889,
0.0028706091,
0.0278500188,
0.0091170436,
0.0105963638,
-0.0228231307,
0.0012811461,
0.0267335046,
0.00294814,
0.0053569586,
-0.0064051747,
0.0238177441,
-0.0847063214,
0.0150008816,
0.0380100682,
-0.0465197116,
-0.03412918,
0.0304857306,
-0.0046163914,
-0.0130198402,
0.0809454396,
0.0370727852,
0.0065629547,
-0.0264977124,
0.0098248664,
0.037956886,
-0.0534080565,
0.0114098415,
-0.0407686383,
0.1118534133,
0.107434988,
0.0082818717,
-0.0288097356,
-0.0465379991,
0.022444455,
0.0284389332,
-0.0021545847,
0.0296401214,
0.0565157831,
0.007134913,
-0.0228702016,
-0.027144162,
0.0205571018,
-0.0012901926,
-0.0264169164,
-0.0455745533,
0.0571948178,
-0.0056172507,
-0.0133933611,
-0.0158908162,
0.0378669389,
0.0030002024,
0.0573682748,
0.0150098698,
-0.0322859474,
-0.0080676246,
-0.0159443878,
0.0023430402,
-0.0473523475,
-0.0548742078,
0.031629499,
0.0070532374,
-0.0902548954,
-0.0411608145,
0.0151707008,
-0.017143108,
0.0200411454,
0.0453785211,
-0.0156653393,
-0.0120031638,
-0.0220332798,
-0.0115542309,
0.0285542235,
-0.0247886907,
0.0146659035,
-0.0484586656,
0.0382850543,
-0.0149135049,
0.003301562,
-0.0167277474,
0.0223492291,
-0.0568934828,
-0.1098944321,
0.0170119833,
0.065572761,
0.023471158,
0.0118708201,
-0.0223289598,
-0.0578878671,
0.0490862094,
0.0545556098,
-0.0480110832,
0.011256678,
0.0285328384,
-0.0363673903,
0.0044179289,
0.0381786823,
-0.0288528353,
-0.0302985813,
0.0495136008,
0.0405571386,
-0.0439809635,
-0.0073549566,
0.035965804,
0.0186485555,
0.0506045483,
-0.0170593821,
0.0328164361,
-0.0305999294,
-0.0078284694,
-0.0035031755,
-0.0187353045,
-0.0210333783,
0.0177738834,
0.0745230839,
-0.0234651975,
-0.0071375761,
-0.0116407778,
0.0302387737,
0.029370416,
-0.0050736242,
-0.0013796692,
-0.0274628215,
0.0144237727,
0.0219002403,
0.0490755253,
-0.033255402,
0.0458349399,
-0.020078443,
0.005836538,
0.0027154845,
0.0200277623,
0.0369035453,
0.0225534402,
-0.0306365769,
0.0200380459,
-0.051847849,
-0.0549853072,
0.0002843766,
0.0084737679,
0.0396660827,
0.006409057,
0.0782620087,
-0.0177979935,
-0.0220847037,
-0.0340876319,
0.0162860807,
0.0022575567,
-0.0348878354,
0.0415891521,
0.0179333743,
-0.022752123,
-0.0328574777,
0.0633728951,
0.0105618667,
0.038866818,
-0.0151889082,
-0.0163977239,
0.0047008581,
-0.0084963208,
0.0486570932,
0.0061152219,
-0.0516590886,
-0.0101354038,
-0.0655698851,
-0.0889469236,
-0.0034345889,
0.0330478437,
-0.0038500235,
-0.0169205274,
-0.0046080397,
0.0285394695,
0.0022579317,
-0.0167528354,
-0.0105114384,
-0.0316594243,
0.0141412718,
0.0079049729,
-0.0237377342,
-6.573127107e-33,
-0.0028453441,
-0.0205207951,
0.0007046318,
0.0091523677,
-0.0101816189,
-0.0124123823,
-0.0191663727,
0.0115152169,
-0.0190995149,
0.023645537,
0.0093213934,
0.0204272885,
-0.001352004,
0.0182137694,
0.0093192868,
-0.0437158756,
0.0075802063,
-0.004548247,
-0.0084390249,
0.0196278114,
0.0530538708,
0.0139338681,
0.0674307197,
-0.1058873609,
0.0296986103,
0.0186365843,
-0.040560931,
0.0239310525,
-0.0765612945,
0.0571111254,
0.0158517621,
0.0192020386,
-0.0017045075,
-0.0520764813,
-0.0125423763,
0.0163080022,
-0.0075481948,
-0.0045626392,
0.0405339338,
-0.0295554753,
-0.0682387054,
-0.0720167905,
0.0720309764,
-0.0287440941,
-0.0183972251,
-0.0325777158,
-0.0017078766,
-0.0287104528,
-0.0308338497,
-0.0178228002,
-0.1003662571,
0.0042342469,
0.0152037973,
-0.0512893349,
0.0041537597,
-0.0116575342,
0.0051883953,
0.0119371349,
-0.0555539094,
-0.0253467318,
-0.0111617623,
0.0411360115,
0.0630714372,
0.041899953,
0.0075175934,
0.0804283097,
-0.0053302222,
0.0188139249,
0.0033066988,
-0.0199850537,
0.0150479469,
0.0263950024,
0.037328098,
0.0500744693,
0.0222459193,
-0.0198762733,
-0.0858553573,
0.0006014506,
-0.0218297224,
0.0558947474,
0.0379276238,
0.0307676028,
-0.0222604405,
-0.0107497908,
-0.0333149731,
-0.0005254237,
-0.0238071438,
-0.0167908072,
-0.0013694403,
0.0078712832,
-0.0333555043,
-0.0012974279,
-0.0036118217,
-0.0310244877,
0.0420590341,
0.0594618618,
0.0105154077,
-0.032935258,
0.0020866867,
0.0193832666,
-0.051260747,
-0.0112909051,
-0.032060124,
-0.0198364072,
0.0330522992,
0.0182770528,
0.0702740178,
0.0582273751,
-0.0451463312,
0.012793785,
-0.0456744619,
0.036553096,
0.0293488167,
-0.0075130137,
0.0532033816,
-0.0102437288,
-0.0042463159,
-0.0009955876,
0.0802045465,
0.0362292565,
0.0042940285,
0.031053381,
-0.0376336128,
0.0139318956,
-0.0163231753,
-0.002125113,
-0.0223902687,
0.0353695862,
0.0373652615,
-0.086998567,
-0.0058960011,
-0.006063398,
2.863e-7,
0.0632934943,
0.0508944653,
0.0469609648,
0.0497048162,
0.0381992608,
0.061011333,
-0.0289311279,
0.0534933321,
-0.0073598921,
-0.0189309195,
0.0160172842,
0.0058584777,
0.0656484514,
0.0446667969,
-0.0117797842,
0.0011580426,
-0.0953052342,
0.0291983522,
-0.01881795,
-0.0201224796,
0.0576706789,
0.0935568959,
0.0106677599,
-0.0359342843,
0.026265787,
-0.0760613382,
0.0647533461,
-0.0252201203,
0.0130257308,
0.0039334651,
-0.0173768811,
0.0081479065,
-0.0242436565,
0.0104335677,
-0.0009837205,
0.0116692213,
-0.0483950637,
0.0735342577,
-0.0418640338,
-0.0012377562,
-0.0228452887,
-0.0498306565,
-0.017173063,
-0.0391303003,
0.023712419,
-0.0648335516,
-0.0614892021,
-0.005761079,
0.0208275616,
-0.0041671712,
0.0156225394,
-0.0187903717,
-0.0123394243,
0.0066256775,
-0.016908003,
0.0161947124,
-0.0382264815,
-0.0401401855,
-0.0293445289,
-0.0014987789,
-0.0185827129,
-0.0739511102,
-0.0176333394,
0.0272173136,
0.0096165799,
-0.0794132277,
0.0009562882,
2.828300249e-34,
-0.0022425333,
-0.0691447482,
0.0195981041,
-0.0122636976,
0.0426789001,
-0.0037374296,
-0.0063626003,
0.0197629947,
0.0042069443,
-0.0140680177,
-0.03389607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14137v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14137v1 | MACAROON: Training Vision-Language Models To Be Your Engaged Partners | 2024-06-20T09:27:33 | 2024-06-20T09:27:33 | Shujin Wu, Yi R. Fung, Sha Li, Yixin Wan, Kai-Wei Chang, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large vision-language models (LVLMs), while proficient in following
instructions and responding to diverse questions, invariably generate detailed
responses even when questions are ambiguous or unanswerable, leading to
hallucinations and bias issues. Thus, it is essential for LVLMs to proactively
engage with humans to ask for clarifications or additional information for
better responses. In this study, we aim to shift LVLMs from passive answer
providers to proactive engaged partners. We begin by establishing a
three-tiered hierarchy for questions of invalid, ambiguous, and personalizable
nature to measure the proactive engagement capabilities of LVLMs. Utilizing
this hierarchy, we create PIE, (ProactIve Engagement Evaluation) through GPT-4o
and human annotators, consisting of 853 questions across six distinct,
fine-grained question types that are verified by human annotators and
accompanied with well-defined metrics. Our evaluations on \benchmark indicate
poor performance of existing LVLMs, with the best-performing open-weights model
only achieving an Aggregate Align Rate (AAR) of 0.28. In response, we introduce
MACAROON, self-iMaginAtion for ContrAstive pReference OptimizatiON, which
instructs LVLMs to autonomously generate contrastive response pairs for
unlabeled questions given the task description and human-crafted criteria.
Then, the self-imagined data is formatted for conditional reinforcement
learning. Experimental results show MACAROON effectively improves LVLMs'
capabilities to be proactively engaged (0.84 AAR) while maintaining comparable
performance on general tasks. | [
0.0611842275,
0.0513450764,
-0.0190760847,
0.0250470061,
-0.0204208419,
0.0157346912,
0.0082901996,
-0.0324501656,
0.001067847,
-0.0555829257,
-0.0102458866,
-0.0325835757,
-0.0574405976,
0.0479473099,
0.016847102,
-0.0851656497,
0.0371700376,
-0.0366290323,
0.014877893,
0.0123953382,
-0.0002505612,
-0.0011992683,
-0.0258696247,
0.0323677063,
-0.0020456694,
-0.0286904313,
-0.018529404,
0.0095045744,
0.017881453,
-0.031713672,
0.0189909656,
0.0930147618,
0.004956848,
0.0178022943,
0.0000023524,
-0.0648596212,
0.0232522506,
-0.0152343707,
-0.0148001527,
-0.0212165024,
0.0001813862,
0.032542076,
0.0265613981,
0.0244026762,
-0.0626660883,
-0.0316740386,
0.046983216,
0.0398280211,
0.0649531037,
0.0426119342,
-0.0056150672,
0.0026997833,
0.0242808796,
-0.0117337927,
0.0585442334,
-0.0128676221,
0.0133382129,
0.0186731927,
-0.0021239428,
-0.0017463489,
-0.0276328307,
0.0258545801,
0.0560855828,
-0.0323305354,
0.0432626568,
0.0385563597,
-0.045926474,
-0.0349825062,
-0.0107634375,
0.0934524834,
0.0156215569,
0.0133310081,
-0.0333760865,
-0.0460747257,
0.0401506573,
0.0091246748,
-0.0262899697,
-0.0057590366,
0.0010697832,
-0.0143779265,
-0.0365272649,
0.0198265724,
-0.0043286304,
0.0225074627,
-0.0088194646,
0.0183829777,
-0.0138530144,
-0.0185571071,
0.0322652049,
0.0174277872,
-0.0550578758,
-0.0742084831,
-0.0231750738,
0.0262356363,
-0.0539978668,
-0.0079883551,
-0.024386894,
-0.0102743655,
0.0005062594,
-0.0136203291,
0.0305167306,
0.0295190979,
-0.0462580286,
0.0337123051,
0.0050584208,
0.0510783009,
-0.0272088163,
0.0148654943,
-0.0542133078,
0.0033313823,
-0.0282407068,
-0.0202702153,
-0.0440030508,
0.0313961767,
-0.0535392165,
-0.011084917,
-0.033429075,
0.0585965887,
-0.0256490074,
0.0169987865,
-0.0190464258,
0.0408503301,
-0.037045382,
-0.0141466623,
-0.0941416025,
0.0403927229,
-0.0547061861,
-0.0011800326,
0.0275773145,
-0.0730742514,
0.0116813695,
0.0375763737,
-0.0103622852,
-0.0501941517,
-0.0068894718,
0.0625687242,
-0.0218354817,
-0.0245234631,
0.0063609635,
-0.0193006806,
0.002520802,
-0.041980885,
-0.0088761756,
-0.0598826371,
0.0094488356,
-0.0075762998,
-0.0336386375,
-0.0161701571,
0.0393103398,
0.028556928,
0.0168514196,
0.1054537594,
-0.0289973468,
-0.0142065631,
-0.0117593333,
0.0087980507,
-0.0320670865,
0.0709599704,
0.0386494063,
0.0377974994,
0.0177350771,
-0.0191544909,
0.0479568392,
-0.0030735491,
-0.0247082394,
-0.0133710308,
-0.0126861418,
0.0526995957,
0.0003096526,
0.026862599,
0.0133930426,
0.0500021502,
-0.0112011414,
-0.0236834604,
0.0772639439,
0.0231555663,
-0.0246665124,
-0.012310423,
0.0287819766,
0.0204731561,
-0.0054856958,
0.0327386782,
-0.0578716919,
0.0766891614,
-0.01050111,
0.0024016255,
0.0069514923,
0.0056996639,
-0.0253180638,
-0.0895414427,
-0.0030271662,
-0.0056041479,
0.0149897523,
0.0511703864,
0.0170850456,
-0.0043852883,
-0.0258584339,
-0.0309573598,
0.002565739,
-0.0337032899,
0.0019730411,
-0.0384757183,
0.0528333075,
0.0497433208,
0.0580884553,
-0.0410100259,
-0.0607283935,
-0.0423364155,
0.0005972055,
0.0459906384,
0.0660399199,
-0.0165762566,
-0.0073111188,
-0.0543393679,
-0.0491574071,
-0.0122236926,
-0.0187070072,
0.0154196043,
0.0259624142,
-0.0275436416,
-0.00237305,
-0.0050501865,
-0.0172015354,
0.0298577696,
0.0011264615,
-0.0331560746,
0.0083829574,
0.0101610254,
0.0207986459,
0.0160150062,
0.015154887,
0.0103659304,
0.0300630797,
-0.028078191,
-0.0171049051,
0.0140204336,
-0.046615947,
0.0172862466,
0.0111316508,
-0.0490968376,
-0.0625324249,
0.0259018596,
-0.0211328845,
-0.0129312892,
-0.0254916139,
-0.0274321549,
-0.0160611663,
-0.068770811,
-0.0289291684,
0.0058377017,
-0.0104381489,
-0.0577240475,
0.0768483132,
-0.0360817313,
-0.0060841516,
0.0265119299,
-0.0237471033,
0.001388668,
-0.050241936,
0.0166052468,
-0.0224706177,
0.0066005317,
0.0009781253,
0.0264376253,
0.041606348,
-0.0721950904,
-0.0248896461,
-0.0660003126,
-0.0091909366,
-0.0332057625,
-0.0167082958,
0.0192100313,
0.0294926129,
-0.0015026804,
-0.0369067229,
-0.065044418,
0.0206672847,
-0.0028988726,
0.0296794977,
0.0668848082,
0.0284840241,
0.0328181498,
-0.0308488365,
0.0089883916,
-0.0090932213,
-0.0079509346,
0.0404068679,
0.0305008795,
-0.0208643191,
-0.0168476291,
-0.0417445116,
0.0413136184,
-0.0146945193,
-0.0159100685,
0.0273255911,
-0.020385284,
0.0189828295,
0.0852854922,
0.0240540858,
0.0372878611,
0.0133832367,
0.0291818511,
-0.0538379289,
0.0601028278,
-0.0230417456,
-0.0462412089,
-0.0289623979,
-0.0283889081,
0.0000458676,
0.0546767376,
-0.0331520103,
-0.0046211965,
-0.0802932754,
0.0440308526,
0.0213134289,
-0.0612958409,
-0.0192794763,
0.0026623178,
-0.0137196695,
0.0784971565,
-0.0108202891,
-0.0510457456,
0.0895169452,
0.0322694741,
-0.0325999148,
-0.0203485209,
0.0225588232,
-0.0461796224,
0.0656141713,
0.0220928974,
-0.0023429848,
0.0129024787,
-0.0132224979,
-0.1093150079,
-0.0323312432,
-0.0001819091,
-0.0419157222,
0.0570514873,
-0.0369933024,
-0.0052233599,
0.0001171838,
-0.0595240518,
-0.0889408514,
-0.0230544955,
-0.0175699145,
0.0076293303,
-0.0171534587,
0.0018825372,
-0.0132632311,
0.0018413143,
0.024359202,
0.0150874136,
-0.0145416223,
-0.0374946482,
-0.0295972396,
0.0349848568,
0.0903055891,
0.0735425055,
0.043641571,
-0.0227885973,
0.0150179453,
0.0707166418,
0.0271508917,
-0.0086562298,
-0.0019857178,
0.017494889,
0.0097632352,
-0.0118927099,
0.0173971318,
0.0262322146,
0.0659494698,
-0.0432052873,
-0.0093530901,
0.1091307104,
0.0391534939,
-0.0591699965,
-0.0083133662,
-0.0224874485,
0.0465906933,
0.0573811531,
0.0578006357,
-0.088055186,
-0.0149482386,
-0.0267802067,
0.0367215797,
-0.0028371692,
-0.0279465057,
0.0019021039,
-0.1214029565,
0.0520972349,
-0.0138089964,
0.0075101475,
-0.0053895991,
0.0164539702,
0.0103749875,
-0.0278629512,
-0.0046275398,
0.0064596669,
0.0112542268,
0.0168257598,
-0.0068399208,
0.0255007502,
0.0003155565,
0.0284452606,
-0.0165034421,
0.0303867869,
0.0913395137,
-0.0099272346,
-0.0344082415,
-0.0576362237,
0.0191969629,
-0.0230939314,
-0.0089496048,
-0.0034655107,
0.0393987671,
-0.0206273515,
-0.0049230698,
-0.0211737528,
0.0778155625,
-0.0161552746,
-0.0179082043,
0.027291188,
0.0502397642,
-0.0039877109,
0.0083886199,
-0.0255387537,
0.0096857753,
0.019762177,
0.0291828439,
0.0264618937,
-0.0666490346,
-0.0397563167,
-0.02572391,
-0.0048760083,
-0.0507306084,
-0.0126652587,
-0.0084554693,
0.0606575496,
0.0166508127,
-0.061561849,
-0.0801087469,
0.0606434867,
0.052582331,
-0.0147971641,
-0.0243835878,
-0.0096956417,
-0.0024917407,
-0.0373200588,
0.07884942,
-0.002178004,
0.0108503811,
-0.0480743498,
-0.0369252414,
-0.0243148971,
-0.073275499,
-0.0257255975,
-0.0147110857,
-0.0443567783,
-0.0292930808,
-0.0096169757,
0.0855347887,
0.0260685831,
0.0389478579,
-0.0213176589,
-0.0435054787,
-0.0105688302,
0.0383623987,
-0.0086622294,
-0.0036493519,
0.0022668079,
0.0389699787,
-0.0034102094,
0.0289074164,
-0.0272157732,
0.0104056885,
0.0149894971,
0.0241531543,
-0.0058676926,
-0.0647632852,
0.0359295197,
0.0081774993,
0.039445173,
0.0014200375,
0.0249003489,
-0.0116353054,
0.0183309615,
-0.0084844576,
-0.014683024,
-0.0542346165,
-0.0232522711,
0.0092909914,
-0.0065494129,
0.0245817695,
-0.0208257679,
-0.0165902413,
0.0118856169,
-0.0610306934,
-0.0207061656,
0.0339250192,
-0.0004783549,
0.0069373022,
-0.0049058348,
-0.0031022609,
0.0199428014,
0.030821003,
0.0866306946,
0.0383739211,
0.1150031015,
0.0204034895,
0.0002515596,
0.0077525964,
0.0296156574,
-0.0547797009,
-0.0792220309,
-0.0172503181,
0.0376241654,
0.0090817902,
0.0231005978,
-0.021761829,
-0.017936334,
-0.0105874045,
-0.00450572,
0.0162714403,
0.015950853,
-0.0232684612,
0.0519526675,
0.0433381572,
-0.0166631751,
-0.0073874607,
0.0456952862,
-0.0304062869,
0.0110154962,
-0.0161768179,
0.0310765319,
-0.0518845282,
-0.0055459691,
0.0055841142,
0.0433811247,
-0.0278720856,
0.0830763653,
-0.0564410016,
-0.0538508669,
0.0012891198,
0.0281699933,
-0.0046623764,
-0.0176209752,
0.0568116866,
0.0296836682,
-0.0035873803,
-0.0438602008,
-0.0237219166,
0.0216291528,
-0.0537760817,
-0.0222863685,
-0.0216503199,
-6.917588094e-33,
-0.0271359123,
-0.0478593558,
0.0381572656,
-0.0051842262,
-0.0306320097,
0.0026292098,
-0.0219861064,
0.0211894363,
-0.027860865,
-0.0060188165,
0.0216622036,
-0.0148245692,
-0.0099188332,
0.0300903283,
0.0271077249,
-0.0372018963,
0.0143716726,
0.006387752,
-0.0288174469,
-0.0053780223,
-0.0124904579,
-0.0037683602,
-0.0043329233,
-0.0861193538,
0.0363420919,
-0.0019899753,
-0.0115948748,
0.0522693694,
-0.0533305593,
0.0786522329,
-0.0224001836,
0.0267073028,
0.0223541278,
0.0278602652,
-0.0039973394,
0.0358083919,
-0.0503818877,
-0.0479604788,
0.0298164748,
0.0039619459,
-0.1346285045,
0.0108537897,
0.0091412906,
-0.0142690009,
0.0051971832,
-0.0407086536,
0.038452819,
-0.0228872374,
0.007283424,
0.049378451,
-0.0278148055,
-0.0319805071,
-0.0209964588,
-0.0245702602,
0.0139050968,
0.1025584638,
-0.0054502911,
0.0463705063,
-0.0375347398,
0.0076907314,
0.0076421904,
0.0096643632,
0.0673123077,
0.0360979661,
0.0142205758,
0.03720529,
0.0423386097,
-0.0149116348,
-0.012177309,
-0.0359318107,
-0.0164329223,
0.0349066891,
0.0614113063,
0.0622538775,
-0.0004855448,
0.0378986895,
-0.0073585655,
0.020479586,
0.0130996592,
0.0225929879,
0.0158819351,
0.0040076044,
-0.0440603979,
0.0023447797,
-0.0571139231,
-0.0197665319,
-0.0694752634,
-0.0458399653,
0.048679892,
0.0145127391,
-0.0272514895,
0.034938667,
0.0199549627,
-0.0263468567,
0.0156286247,
-0.0271198824,
-0.022035148,
0.0477362797,
0.0068482477,
0.0253311023,
-0.0293995366,
0.0331976153,
0.0230426248,
-0.0254626386,
-0.0003898388,
0.0512795858,
0.0197960548,
-0.0051581073,
-0.0401675031,
-0.0161464214,
-0.0374346524,
0.0398000404,
-0.0200653356,
0.0143094324,
0.0232540295,
0.0178431738,
-0.0468506999,
0.0590541251,
0.0054967036,
-0.033084929,
-0.0726401433,
-0.0202585068,
-0.0090607973,
0.0203643274,
-0.0103294244,
0.0144289089,
-0.005775278,
-0.002970224,
-0.0237811971,
-0.0359070487,
-0.0266868994,
0.0321311951,
2.953e-7,
0.0269418564,
0.0380346887,
0.0202207696,
0.0393983163,
0.003636989,
0.0633035898,
0.0161995105,
0.0218709856,
0.0576257072,
-0.0378503725,
0.0169312935,
0.0241354965,
0.0275869574,
0.0076568122,
-0.052695971,
0.0235502515,
-0.0268029366,
0.0170924794,
-0.0403607078,
-0.0044007367,
0.083689779,
0.0404564105,
0.0062818234,
0.0057452498,
0.040807277,
-0.0033157808,
0.0397336036,
-0.0400887169,
-0.0182413496,
-0.0086012445,
-0.0215683021,
0.0259168819,
0.0223920494,
0.0516394377,
-0.0149320792,
0.00006288,
0.002395778,
0.0543529131,
-0.0094467076,
-0.0510981493,
-0.0057235258,
0.0361831039,
0.0315594599,
-0.0823206306,
0.0777112097,
-0.0708765611,
-0.0268397667,
0.0159876291,
-0.0311043207,
-0.0183923673,
0.0311699659,
-0.0201543774,
-0.0226864833,
-0.0154958386,
0.0279570464,
0.0124968542,
-0.0119520715,
-0.0283238888,
-0.0013282455,
-0.0276719015,
-0.0405356623,
-0.0287608858,
-0.0497708097,
0.0141309956,
-0.013698197,
-0.0241113063,
-0.0342704244,
2.66345186e-34,
0.0383920297,
0.0312784575,
0.0527514629,
0.043972455,
0.0152793955,
0.0222885814,
-0.0216647256,
0.0032577475,
0.0491283797,
-0.0655366927,
-0.0210355166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14129v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14129v1 | Towards Event-oriented Long Video Understanding | 2024-06-20T09:14:19 | 2024-06-20T09:14:19 | Yifan Du, Kun Zhou, Yuqi Huo, Yifan Li, Wayne Xin Zhao, Haoyu Lu, Zijia Zhao, Bingning Wang, Weipeng Chen, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM | With the rapid development of video Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs),
numerous benchmarks have been proposed to assess their video understanding
capability. However, due to the lack of rich events in the videos, these
datasets may suffer from the short-cut bias that the answers can be deduced
from a few frames, without the need to watch the entire video. To address this
issue, we introduce Event-Bench, an event-oriented long video understanding
benchmark built on existing datasets and human annotations. Event-Bench
includes six event-related tasks and 2,190 test instances to comprehensively
evaluate video event understanding ability. Additionally, we propose Video
Instruction Merging~(VIM), a cost-effective method that enhances video MLLMs
using merged, event-intensive video instructions, addressing the scarcity of
human-annotated, event-intensive data. Extensive experiments show that the
best-performing model, GPT-4o, achieves an overall accuracy of 53.33,
significantly outperforming the best open-source model by 41.42%. Leveraging an
effective instruction synthesis method and an adaptive model architecture, VIM
surpasses both state-of-the-art open-source models and GPT-4V on the
Event-Bench. All code, data, and models are publicly available at
https://github.com/RUCAIBox/Event-Bench. | [
-0.0225800835,
0.0440934598,
0.0106512355,
0.0897307321,
-0.0018898986,
0.0299536735,
0.0090338504,
-0.0307234433,
0.0020012297,
-0.0577951595,
-0.0098386435,
-0.0415507779,
-0.0056436812,
0.0447561964,
0.0202181414,
-0.0711623803,
0.0465607755,
-0.027708685,
-0.0119864065,
0.0314009264,
0.0347660556,
0.0177611802,
-0.0261453427,
0.0435702242,
-0.0172244404,
-0.0124670919,
-0.0332261063,
-0.0010424502,
0.0543590523,
-0.0307547804,
-0.0303803906,
0.0323947109,
0.0799029395,
0.0112495022,
0.0000017543,
-0.0409527421,
0.0208423529,
-0.0314857587,
-0.0327718556,
0.0436111055,
-0.0091719851,
-0.0471375175,
0.0124956127,
-0.0045107882,
-0.0220731162,
-0.0266162436,
0.0296746902,
-0.0104144067,
0.0329777077,
0.0469000936,
-0.0281672701,
-0.0505361259,
0.0310998894,
-0.0309188534,
0.0359721221,
-0.0774707198,
0.0166204441,
0.0179993454,
0.0168394279,
-0.0250178985,
-0.0708635524,
0.0390310027,
0.0361553095,
-0.0025433048,
-0.0095101306,
0.0367198177,
-0.0435027555,
-0.031006828,
-0.0092621688,
0.0690408275,
-0.018304538,
0.0347163007,
0.0104443543,
0.0232450608,
0.0129712755,
-0.013897296,
-0.0704734847,
0.0183665678,
0.0000883898,
0.0031113743,
0.0018477811,
-0.0085206889,
0.0168287624,
-0.012010878,
0.0159906186,
-0.0043292777,
0.0150478054,
0.0206756555,
-0.0456776507,
-0.0219806097,
-0.0372081622,
-0.0672616214,
-0.0157723296,
0.0387782976,
-0.0303802136,
0.0048399838,
-0.0513154231,
0.0307718683,
-0.0385816209,
-0.0817596316,
0.0249509402,
0.0393529348,
-0.0403009169,
0.0883583575,
-0.0161109548,
0.0590129122,
-0.017343929,
0.0148220751,
-0.0270515829,
0.0059768851,
-0.0509422198,
0.0401006341,
-0.0052335151,
-0.0140701653,
-0.0519453622,
-0.0336723998,
-0.0007362487,
0.027800167,
-0.0037970315,
0.0112524619,
-0.0429352336,
-0.0016094322,
0.0129755205,
-0.0251345858,
-0.0019627707,
0.0472542197,
-0.0501835048,
0.0445930921,
-0.0188986566,
-0.0772435293,
-0.0083387773,
0.0280660577,
-0.0095644975,
-0.0231330059,
0.0127942823,
0.0253305752,
-0.0643515289,
-0.0420139395,
-0.0161160193,
0.0181271676,
-0.0027304052,
-0.0217209551,
0.0172853936,
-0.0493973903,
0.0702717379,
-0.0122812428,
-0.0023057037,
-0.0027940171,
0.0161168296,
-0.0380746685,
-0.0219093263,
0.0724898279,
-0.0008103841,
0.0286543332,
0.0103000533,
0.0318562426,
-0.0125417653,
0.0545453541,
0.0383915678,
0.0261970293,
0.0231458507,
0.0147930067,
0.0157836303,
0.0512660891,
-0.0227693692,
0.0231227987,
-0.0406165496,
0.0180520099,
0.0140697509,
0.0459906831,
0.0693056956,
0.0163814146,
-0.0289415549,
-0.0674750358,
0.052919928,
0.00694298,
-0.0651538894,
-0.0525858738,
0.0294435322,
0.0243906621,
0.0047168043,
0.0104681822,
-0.0592338778,
0.0598631389,
0.0181284845,
-0.0174970403,
0.021762507,
0.0100563634,
-0.0636780336,
-0.0147578642,
-0.0223164801,
-0.0145583469,
0.0164746586,
0.0569114685,
0.0292275585,
-0.0325502977,
-0.0459157266,
0.0339546129,
-0.0014375777,
0.0102083385,
0.040408656,
-0.0391222946,
0.0225450844,
0.0746500418,
-0.0050693932,
-0.0124620488,
-0.0651900694,
0.0169404335,
0.0578749068,
0.0032675331,
0.0162535571,
-0.0291866958,
0.0791920125,
-0.0730120763,
-0.0332340412,
-0.0047252816,
0.002505075,
0.0442757346,
0.0085416986,
-0.0200380683,
-0.0016432003,
0.0029508993,
0.0083060283,
0.0392392278,
0.0165477619,
-0.041089382,
-0.0493514277,
-0.0097102132,
0.013432431,
-0.013312499,
-0.0170136318,
-0.0318769664,
0.0180778019,
-0.0249831043,
0.0318164751,
0.0148360943,
-0.03451287,
-0.0488377102,
0.0490399972,
-0.0252252575,
-0.0485693999,
0.0734570548,
-0.0587819368,
-0.0269368179,
0.010959533,
0.0019797101,
0.0018017079,
-0.0387749001,
-0.0039394735,
0.0407597683,
0.012171356,
-0.0104301665,
0.0071818284,
-0.0176845901,
-0.0140672848,
0.0184834711,
0.0233479291,
0.0313018151,
-0.0510332808,
-0.0368627198,
0.0087672295,
-0.0162801277,
-0.0260251034,
-0.0039242692,
-0.0271696914,
-0.07755211,
-0.0150043992,
-0.0979495123,
0.0362089053,
-0.028580958,
0.0243091863,
0.0006223096,
0.0025410589,
-0.0165608693,
-0.0308415499,
0.0259280279,
-0.031475503,
-0.0238220245,
0.0314454883,
-0.0175472014,
0.0395446829,
-0.0074314834,
-0.0288044587,
-0.0239549316,
-0.0070660217,
0.0460064672,
-0.0052834759,
-0.0191379208,
-0.0061359759,
-0.0309019685,
-0.0063745743,
0.0392064825,
-0.0570913404,
-0.0350685418,
0.0286746323,
-0.0237104166,
0.0444265679,
0.0729571059,
0.0055255708,
0.027588876,
0.0116374707,
-0.0588518567,
-0.0109570948,
0.0399783589,
-0.0060290094,
-0.0379519388,
-0.0510459617,
0.0029462343,
-0.0606474653,
0.0281409957,
-0.0327804796,
0.0303553734,
-0.0583804622,
-0.0513510965,
0.005472234,
-0.0168827008,
-0.0574323982,
-0.0079658451,
-0.0214467123,
0.0073538208,
-0.0533252172,
-0.0342387892,
0.033851292,
-0.0318694636,
-0.0415988266,
0.0062361495,
0.0059968005,
-0.0221802425,
0.104290843,
0.0264626555,
-0.0121848332,
-0.077583544,
-0.0332739577,
-0.0615966991,
0.0046665412,
0.007740418,
-0.0068349452,
0.0511889607,
-0.0679176003,
0.0086373892,
-0.0268786587,
0.0048448755,
-0.0426465496,
-0.0330903754,
-0.0250582639,
-0.024701003,
-0.0263788607,
0.0076942858,
-0.017323317,
0.0206334442,
0.0346710943,
0.0357200466,
-0.0075279176,
0.0266237278,
-0.0032789374,
0.0390268601,
0.0633643642,
0.0118654445,
-0.055234354,
-0.0595811345,
0.0443282723,
0.0569060333,
0.0626605377,
-0.0221140571,
-0.0679997057,
0.0474142954,
0.0181015804,
0.0181792285,
-0.0279200394,
0.0455181375,
0.054083392,
-0.0944521278,
0.0535920486,
0.097021699,
-0.0063019469,
-0.0315164626,
-0.0087172193,
0.0274869595,
0.0112717496,
0.0384073518,
0.004176829,
-0.0829754099,
-0.0663576871,
0.0015960031,
-0.0171303507,
0.0464143865,
0.0029268218,
-0.024280414,
-0.0521211512,
0.0435933657,
0.0006847206,
-0.0274215732,
-0.0266694222,
-0.0057012881,
0.0187438577,
-0.0091912029,
-0.0116829136,
0.0144102704,
-0.008255302,
0.0042426884,
0.018296605,
-0.0482351594,
-0.0729304031,
0.0700346082,
-0.0525561348,
0.0408617668,
0.0202844366,
0.0101396767,
0.0113403117,
-0.0217146408,
0.0517180115,
-0.0107079148,
-0.0065716766,
0.0077256183,
0.047333993,
-0.0321569294,
-0.0349317715,
0.0093422625,
0.0385691747,
0.0136359558,
-0.0409676246,
0.0040304651,
0.0937849432,
-0.015146425,
0.0137940235,
-0.0214154013,
-0.0159691758,
0.0102505814,
0.0688299015,
0.0085589262,
0.0007339304,
0.0008037246,
0.0656699613,
-0.0413267277,
-0.0398664996,
0.0052580149,
0.0105458181,
0.0185200945,
-0.0175863542,
-0.0066299336,
-0.045461107,
0.0642245561,
0.0115201958,
-0.0409628861,
0.0183872879,
0.0059162625,
0.0294583738,
-0.0583996177,
0.1122974604,
-0.0174151678,
0.0219313242,
-0.0404456817,
-0.0165918786,
0.0156545825,
0.0172451008,
-0.0040376247,
0.0653477982,
-0.06688492,
-0.0320334509,
-0.0042516161,
0.0280399472,
0.0148562584,
0.0817979202,
0.023913227,
-0.0274231322,
-0.0558861643,
-0.0183822252,
0.0119828833,
0.0206681639,
-0.0204959102,
-0.0352302268,
-0.0219092593,
0.0290185586,
-0.0344090872,
0.0347146317,
-0.0336154699,
0.0100351889,
-0.0732805803,
-0.0049247909,
-0.0114437779,
-0.0334575102,
0.0543872789,
-0.0296755712,
-0.0281148218,
-0.028458463,
-0.0039967345,
0.0126518309,
0.0467525721,
-0.0674458519,
-0.0005078159,
0.0300641172,
-0.0140490057,
-0.0035607298,
0.0115846656,
-0.0019260145,
-0.0409558006,
-0.0546718463,
0.0062267967,
-0.0058725318,
-0.0204175618,
0.0141674448,
0.0281531885,
0.0184591543,
0.0134059153,
0.0100511676,
0.0161175281,
0.0114223473,
0.0667712688,
0.0246383045,
0.0142700821,
0.0186373927,
0.0075519597,
-0.0248443205,
-0.0142475953,
0.000390523,
0.0238647591,
0.0679245889,
-0.0317244567,
0.0195310824,
0.016891215,
-0.0102963438,
-0.0495684147,
0.064074859,
-0.0304639153,
-0.0660606921,
0.0521798618,
0.0237751752,
-0.00367638,
-0.0041298214,
0.0693681389,
0.0189309511,
0.0540575981,
0.0146453679,
0.0405112207,
-0.0141578168,
-0.0475330129,
0.0474771149,
0.0198527332,
-0.0321418159,
0.0200202279,
-0.0162947625,
-0.0435832329,
-0.0335232578,
0.0026331476,
-0.0133714294,
0.0115010394,
0.0425690524,
0.0259511136,
-0.0163068175,
-0.0278778188,
0.0125560174,
-0.0115763927,
-0.0305508729,
-0.0246830881,
0.0036234269,
-5.639201988e-33,
-0.0268452298,
-0.0033170229,
0.0427986197,
0.0212447904,
-0.0088638449,
0.023911152,
-0.0274602119,
0.0269052852,
-0.0235018898,
0.0272784196,
0.0348202437,
0.0222038571,
0.011583088,
0.0158029776,
0.0016863596,
-0.0684150681,
0.0164528303,
-0.0212797821,
0.0001474798,
0.0004616916,
0.0135603249,
0.0327577069,
0.0383585282,
-0.0536962263,
-0.0183260608,
0.0003092749,
-0.0114575317,
0.0223965682,
0.0250021517,
0.0664460286,
0.0031868564,
-0.0119862929,
0.0371826068,
-0.0472139716,
-0.0322735086,
0.0105638159,
-0.0477553792,
0.0141363628,
0.0364844501,
0.0355768576,
-0.0703358948,
-0.0007316584,
0.036065042,
0.0313087739,
0.0068221451,
-0.0609378181,
0.0234588236,
-0.0131599996,
0.0013302824,
0.0095591815,
-0.0340002142,
0.026703516,
-0.0121272532,
-0.0737323985,
0.0572327003,
-0.0006839335,
0.0335237049,
-0.0183213055,
-0.033157412,
-0.0293796919,
-0.0581179745,
0.0597884953,
0.0981579795,
0.0224626381,
-0.0149417687,
0.0416748114,
0.0202631988,
-0.0610818006,
-0.0276400503,
0.0227997024,
0.0251482558,
0.0920448303,
0.0188698787,
0.0434803665,
0.0306417588,
0.0305978898,
-0.0597808659,
0.0538101234,
-0.011725531,
0.0371550471,
-0.0132423863,
0.0352042429,
0.0114517771,
0.010659731,
-0.0317334235,
0.0574005134,
-0.0286321174,
0.0284657851,
0.0423747897,
0.0071673682,
0.0337684602,
0.0232601985,
0.0959100574,
-0.0246702284,
0.023122618,
0.0339015685,
-0.0292633697,
0.0434979945,
0.0228885487,
0.050649561,
-0.0350209214,
-0.0082888473,
0.0451007783,
-0.0198170878,
0.012389455,
-0.0025212837,
-0.011974033,
0.042440284,
-0.0144833317,
-0.0098747518,
-0.0247111116,
0.0096772639,
-0.0142079052,
0.0199980699,
0.0484847575,
0.0110062929,
-0.0370951816,
0.0621724576,
-0.0298219472,
0.0173141565,
0.0014901148,
-0.0521846823,
-0.0077169333,
0.0173195284,
-0.0233399067,
0.0405337363,
-0.0485652275,
-0.0446547717,
0.0014160101,
-0.0427801497,
-0.0133247431,
0.0546079911,
2.431e-7,
0.0255835857,
0.0182635151,
0.0248861909,
0.022049997,
0.0032653415,
0.0405527577,
-0.0064956886,
0.0435957164,
0.0180871319,
-0.0413977653,
-0.0120137176,
0.0762395561,
0.0470840186,
0.0030843969,
-0.0249004532,
-0.0423184633,
-0.0384649411,
0.0255544297,
-0.069905743,
0.01342336,
0.0548052005,
0.0989505798,
0.0197489094,
-0.000274207,
0.0546442159,
-0.0211693719,
0.058115907,
-0.0125812888,
-0.0600859784,
0.0271311142,
0.0013064283,
0.0110568507,
-0.0268292781,
0.0243577976,
-0.0192530975,
-0.0400000177,
0.0285650697,
0.065629974,
-0.0320406593,
-0.0433396213,
-0.0167677719,
0.0180529319,
-0.0403348878,
-0.0322295912,
0.0789112151,
-0.0215380136,
-0.015941957,
-0.0138074122,
-0.0289023165,
0.0044140387,
-0.0386959314,
0.0400060974,
-0.0091916565,
0.0145586412,
0.0197391678,
-0.0370576568,
-0.0241728444,
-0.1189410537,
-0.0142956525,
-0.0078138337,
-0.0727785081,
-0.0032160005,
-0.0432573296,
-0.0250950437,
0.0524429679,
-0.0237824637,
-0.0762119889,
1.530288737e-34,
-0.001279121,
-0.000920431,
-0.0020319899,
-0.0214404762,
0.0043599987,
-0.0214234237,
-0.0587835871,
0.0138581246,
-0.00882293,
-0.0331308246,
-0.0064723534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14117v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14117v1 | An Investigation of Prompt Variations for Zero-shot LLM-based Rankers | 2024-06-20T09:03:18 | 2024-06-20T09:03:18 | Shuoqi Sun, Shengyao Zhuang, Shuai Wang, Guido Zuccon | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | We provide a systematic understanding of the impact of specific components
and wordings used in prompts on the effectiveness of rankers based on zero-shot
Large Language Models (LLMs). Several zero-shot ranking methods based on LLMs
have recently been proposed. Among many aspects, methods differ across (1) the
ranking algorithm they implement, e.g., pointwise vs. listwise, (2) the
backbone LLMs used, e.g., GPT3.5 vs. FLAN-T5, (3) the components and wording
used in prompts, e.g., the use or not of role-definition (role-playing) and the
actual words used to express this. It is currently unclear whether performance
differences are due to the underlying ranking algorithm, or because of spurious
factors such as better choice of words used in prompts. This confusion risks to
undermine future research. Through our large-scale experimentation and
analysis, we find that ranking algorithms do contribute to differences between
methods for zero-shot LLM ranking. However, so do the LLM backbones -- but even
more importantly, the choice of prompt components and wordings affect the
ranking. In fact, in our experiments, we find that, at times, these latter
elements have more impact on the ranker's effectiveness than the actual ranking
algorithms, and that differences among ranking methods become more blurred when
prompt variations are considered. | [
0.0453332439,
-0.024518244,
-0.0232501682,
0.0323076397,
-0.0149701601,
-0.0223421287,
0.0272625685,
-0.0028164794,
0.0315590426,
-0.0602063388,
-0.0473669954,
-0.0490369536,
0.0175455958,
-0.0004396237,
0.0227784347,
-0.035346549,
0.0288143978,
-0.0371135324,
0.0181562304,
-0.0131265726,
-0.0178276896,
-0.0110477488,
0.0175165888,
0.0237387866,
0.0862161815,
0.0042433375,
0.0039918907,
0.0043948079,
0.0262204502,
-0.0561147369,
-0.0364265442,
0.0326702148,
0.0008978197,
0.0419324338,
0.0000020525,
-0.0584987327,
-0.0150477206,
-0.024224231,
-0.0065685431,
0.0396629348,
0.0092400862,
0.0448734388,
-0.0307953879,
0.0326775499,
-0.0238335952,
-0.0144090233,
0.0113874562,
-0.0211563613,
0.0350492522,
0.0335080661,
0.0085216947,
-0.0244142227,
-0.0167166889,
-0.0413092896,
0.0246909484,
-0.0380808711,
0.0179016311,
-0.008054194,
0.0504504032,
0.0743167028,
-0.0124933757,
0.0023445562,
-0.0419102497,
-0.0387109444,
0.0220902823,
0.0432700142,
-0.045711074,
-0.0171698313,
0.0106420405,
0.0838578865,
-0.0133921476,
0.0032225547,
0.0108896345,
-0.0065555195,
0.0290050991,
0.0241779909,
-0.0579553433,
0.0539347976,
0.0428462476,
-0.0039259577,
0.0101053324,
0.0481383987,
0.0191078801,
0.0312956609,
-0.0311103556,
0.1003598049,
0.0155464672,
-0.0587245934,
-0.0117297089,
-0.0397665985,
-0.02405045,
-0.0534656681,
-0.020423416,
0.0133255236,
-0.0506728292,
0.0340133831,
0.0151911909,
0.034751974,
0.0341637768,
-0.0377344228,
0.0357654952,
0.025978107,
0.0219991673,
0.0615732707,
-0.0155330077,
0.0744534433,
0.0363447145,
0.0016207554,
-0.0323959924,
0.0375899076,
-0.0127903577,
-0.0307621155,
-0.0042581768,
0.0391578898,
-0.0159598254,
-0.0127831418,
-0.0565905422,
0.0135899372,
-0.0106848227,
0.0319286771,
0.0142365461,
-0.0136165265,
0.0007526984,
0.0212237947,
-0.0012436041,
0.0217479467,
-0.010919245,
-0.0093813334,
-0.0037086224,
-0.0309686437,
0.0291975029,
-0.0136039276,
-0.0071546561,
-0.0336509943,
0.0138920629,
0.02651559,
0.0154924886,
-0.0175748132,
0.0584993288,
-0.01556993,
-0.0229849964,
-0.0405912511,
-0.0452153832,
-0.0691805631,
0.0057120644,
0.0365237743,
0.0358949266,
0.0271133706,
0.0038963552,
0.0317155607,
-0.0507442392,
0.0694811791,
0.0167652983,
0.0193663761,
0.0082109841,
0.0254156869,
0.001751414,
0.0318471603,
-0.0069599319,
0.0274014659,
0.0552247316,
-0.0276191551,
-0.0036970791,
0.0543322004,
-0.0496381186,
0.0149865411,
0.0028095497,
-0.0003944663,
0.0116660204,
0.0367287062,
0.000817428,
0.0320656151,
-0.0289042816,
0.0045681447,
0.0775569528,
0.0510286465,
0.0458585471,
-0.0488379747,
0.0268715713,
0.0364149697,
-0.0027359934,
0.0097690234,
-0.0192751717,
-0.0042937808,
-0.0118112341,
-0.0031248068,
0.0469162092,
0.0248731542,
-0.0117479609,
-0.0065570725,
-0.0112835178,
0.0189866014,
-0.0263339095,
-0.0087132622,
0.0264495965,
-0.0341563411,
-0.0484671891,
0.0259558745,
0.017893251,
-0.0538516566,
-0.0053994707,
-0.0529152825,
0.0149886087,
0.090023309,
0.0648373142,
-0.0406078249,
-0.0019634096,
0.0009794668,
0.0129221231,
0.0167693738,
0.0085733803,
-0.0135675482,
-0.0253887493,
-0.0286697596,
-0.0273827706,
-0.0006686897,
0.0046970882,
0.0424677432,
-0.0382246189,
-0.0096001783,
0.0043597948,
-0.0098190047,
-0.0137638291,
-0.0153094707,
-0.0012851834,
-0.0148417475,
0.0156737585,
-0.0322799832,
0.0225772839,
0.0296324845,
-0.0006894058,
0.0048485687,
0.0268861409,
-0.0093657998,
0.0117230909,
-0.0423715152,
-0.027679082,
-0.0058534485,
0.0308502465,
0.0008863285,
0.0316627659,
0.0394140445,
-0.0270175599,
-0.023097882,
-0.0296770744,
0.0338829793,
-0.0017459441,
-0.0043653464,
0.0706589818,
-0.0272007529,
-0.0233949088,
-0.0727601796,
0.0747361332,
0.0143116685,
0.0713209137,
0.0752935857,
0.0253924392,
-0.0154816201,
-0.0752051696,
-0.0661428794,
0.0688188821,
-0.0091528222,
-0.0108045777,
0.0345097855,
0.0039994842,
-0.0236507487,
-0.0361959003,
-0.1148952246,
0.0085412003,
0.0006895681,
-0.0200142451,
0.0201679915,
0.0140595976,
-0.004946223,
0.0262802877,
-0.0245417058,
-0.0349517316,
0.0311231129,
0.0555447638,
0.0030444551,
0.0085581699,
-0.0238801055,
-0.0393874049,
-0.0424333103,
0.0000151331,
0.0421075411,
-0.011383404,
-0.0130857704,
-0.0305140037,
0.0705546066,
-0.0647639856,
-0.0289912522,
-0.0296650007,
-0.0223477799,
0.0015372266,
-0.0176153593,
0.0136076966,
0.0095981071,
0.0343047082,
-0.0049481099,
0.0840577707,
-0.0152904578,
-0.0658324137,
-0.0337053351,
0.0171515048,
-0.0148338536,
-0.0090247085,
-0.0408240445,
0.0049502603,
0.0361284763,
0.0140130231,
0.0013058587,
-0.0401304625,
0.0498243645,
-0.0474290028,
0.0114235403,
-0.0752134919,
-0.0068456698,
-0.0337167792,
0.0329682603,
-0.0017796236,
-0.0120019875,
0.0116294222,
-0.0357477106,
0.0096028242,
-0.0055260137,
0.0074276896,
-0.0415905863,
0.000179414,
0.0218939725,
0.020955896,
-0.0473578274,
-0.0240949281,
-0.0357905105,
0.0047265626,
0.0530847833,
-0.0580830686,
0.0229700133,
0.0062591843,
0.0198175199,
-0.0319610834,
-0.026623359,
-0.0185680408,
-0.048504822,
0.0061196587,
0.0246599801,
0.0224302094,
0.026116753,
0.0047981571,
0.0398116596,
0.0538684428,
0.0321925804,
-0.0320246108,
-0.0071181376,
-0.0110150641,
0.0497011952,
0.0256782547,
-0.023450058,
0.0192268658,
-0.0033416289,
0.077396147,
0.0067732739,
0.0391165577,
-0.0000203218,
0.0481881797,
-0.0215376988,
0.0633162335,
-0.0498565286,
-0.0753388852,
0.0555393249,
-0.0036506276,
-0.0205228664,
0.0242935661,
0.1219045222,
0.0438351668,
-0.0325783044,
-0.0029900593,
-0.0329388194,
0.0344029292,
0.0195747074,
0.0428687744,
-0.0933528692,
0.0196182989,
0.0144229215,
0.0171342734,
-0.0536676422,
-0.0194975957,
-0.0201839618,
-0.1603231281,
0.0583311655,
-0.0074916794,
-0.0074998904,
0.0443946347,
-0.0420997962,
0.0038434721,
0.0010228814,
0.007509388,
0.0503195301,
-0.0463216305,
0.0117399096,
0.0013464949,
-0.0332301259,
-0.0540026948,
0.0224333312,
-0.0332574137,
0.067647405,
0.0450025611,
0.0419502482,
-0.0494131781,
-0.04230446,
0.0046469602,
-0.0117497835,
-0.0098970439,
-0.0308135469,
0.0053391182,
-0.016101744,
0.0211195797,
-0.0134098912,
-0.0469776206,
0.0615969822,
0.0181451254,
-0.0090238797,
0.0494521186,
0.0045376131,
-0.0115366224,
-0.0021712552,
0.001153096,
-0.018808296,
0.0800504312,
-0.0053421832,
-0.0336521193,
0.0048047993,
-0.0592881255,
0.0222135056,
0.0116161788,
-0.0986538008,
-0.0241402183,
-0.0077916365,
-0.014223231,
-0.0366688818,
-0.0240926873,
0.0163059067,
0.035694588,
0.0205240417,
0.0749492347,
-0.0698610991,
0.0077810925,
-0.0032666186,
-0.0433234908,
-0.0094716726,
0.0213616956,
-0.0913568884,
0.0008243099,
0.0740403533,
-0.0445599928,
-0.0250694808,
-0.0489792749,
0.0014549549,
-0.0568593852,
-0.0066200029,
0.0403037816,
0.0333218686,
-0.0243197288,
-0.0005973055,
-0.0800897777,
0.0671271458,
0.0580220334,
-0.0014790116,
0.0290466081,
-0.0054850518,
0.0144675411,
-0.0206550974,
0.0114657059,
-0.0646704882,
0.0164296888,
-0.0079976739,
0.0407167524,
-0.0245574228,
-0.0406671464,
0.0140030868,
0.0538788773,
0.0393305086,
-0.0212336462,
-0.0236727595,
-0.0195595119,
0.0180567056,
-0.0921389386,
-0.0318328515,
-0.0095365513,
0.0048647202,
0.0459341928,
0.0138230165,
-0.0032615853,
0.0328151584,
-0.0369095355,
0.0242449511,
-0.0762082636,
0.0157727543,
-0.0038860985,
-0.0557615459,
0.0157342833,
-0.0049350271,
-0.0325363427,
0.0175539628,
0.0326136425,
0.0302482806,
-0.0127544897,
0.0173571501,
-0.0053374176,
-0.0317399465,
-0.0094568674,
0.0954277068,
-0.0529748052,
-0.0681633502,
0.000619729,
0.0305941217,
0.0618460067,
0.0019336723,
0.0622666888,
0.0274689849,
0.0094927894,
-0.0045411712,
-0.0479712076,
0.065058291,
-0.0754328892,
0.0027177928,
0.0586909913,
0.0046230881,
0.0538350306,
0.0680915117,
0.0450663976,
-0.0395138003,
0.007970443,
-0.039210204,
-0.0006155547,
0.0113342414,
-0.0021162818,
0.0552097894,
-0.0326798111,
-0.0154531561,
-0.0993986502,
-0.008278993,
-0.0095001943,
-0.0080374777,
0.0133595653,
-0.0482108779,
-0.0015458554,
0.0400734246,
0.0076894686,
0.0103736939,
-0.0873626024,
-0.0425503664,
-0.0115751578,
-0.0179652553,
-0.0077367146,
-6.169090597e-33,
-0.0392777771,
-0.0377684347,
-0.0055615488,
0.0000279822,
-0.0168593153,
0.0122660371,
-0.0065715881,
0.033980906,
-0.0005150079,
-0.028855294,
-0.0460395962,
-0.021258682,
0.02264091,
-0.0146851074,
0.015898278,
-0.0113793518,
0.0263621248,
0.023609845,
-0.0507975221,
-0.0035972223,
0.0218873285,
0.0092480276,
-0.0032733623,
-0.00098772,
0.0542634241,
-0.0212188326,
-0.0050838739,
-0.0075752023,
0.0037745649,
0.0476060919,
0.024700813,
0.0334182382,
0.0371680446,
-0.0847088099,
0.0050425692,
0.035403084,
-0.0169586968,
-0.0172707979,
0.0491217896,
-0.0218468048,
0.0255980771,
-0.0080107171,
0.0158311706,
0.0019860663,
-0.0367373861,
-0.0030425882,
0.0381155573,
-0.0133595727,
-0.039430052,
-0.0120294541,
-0.0246303007,
0.0113843158,
-0.0020408584,
-0.0031059198,
0.0149666341,
0.0585957654,
-0.0229240824,
0.070730783,
-0.0571637265,
0.0745603591,
0.0122069987,
0.0769126639,
0.0554284044,
0.056642063,
-0.0231228732,
0.0611537807,
0.0013898421,
0.0266920161,
-0.0120843276,
-0.0426346771,
-0.0022277404,
0.0194577891,
0.0373893008,
0.0196139887,
0.0313720554,
0.013260508,
-0.0484101325,
0.0436760187,
0.0312612318,
-0.001034345,
0.0397082232,
0.0116811236,
-0.0527893119,
-0.0503738932,
-0.0254499801,
-0.0012056245,
-0.0536261201,
-0.0490473993,
0.0345786884,
-0.0222268328,
-0.0549306832,
-0.0208508,
0.039441362,
-0.0249598771,
-0.0722832754,
0.0373906009,
-0.0114934817,
0.0564869232,
-0.0108007845,
0.0161358155,
-0.0564014763,
0.015271089,
0.0208036285,
-0.0130731445,
-0.0077110701,
0.0192450453,
-0.0197732244,
-0.0064582047,
-0.0480932668,
-0.0187337268,
0.0085118916,
-0.0175370704,
-0.0398468561,
0.008701317,
0.0011837981,
-0.0281772483,
0.0078731272,
0.0317266919,
0.0462931916,
-0.0345651843,
-0.0146693476,
-0.0116078323,
-0.0251222141,
-0.0274291057,
-0.0235399082,
0.0172825791,
-0.0292732213,
0.0881614462,
0.0277080406,
-0.008787605,
-0.0437622219,
-0.0284553654,
2.874e-7,
0.014132156,
0.0386744365,
-0.0578483045,
0.0179107506,
0.0193502549,
0.0142775541,
-0.0108411601,
0.0503727421,
0.0506139062,
-0.0019472787,
0.0136833461,
-0.0146700814,
0.0001674282,
0.0053633731,
-0.0881322697,
-0.0137492977,
-0.0625154376,
0.0054932814,
-0.049931705,
-0.0251011997,
0.0327624418,
0.0574184544,
-0.0151885385,
0.0186241698,
-0.0253017303,
-0.0361342691,
0.0341355279,
-0.0189958289,
-0.0213462189,
0.0147921648,
0.0569425188,
-0.0120676802,
-0.0167324226,
0.0101837907,
0.010071571,
0.0370535031,
0.0532072,
0.0439950675,
-0.0154184466,
0.0209657643,
0.0025039974,
-0.029529145,
-0.0024363317,
-0.0806320831,
0.0863301978,
-0.0409225821,
-0.0317705497,
0.0197447166,
-0.0671871081,
-0.0286289472,
0.0157451499,
-0.0356706902,
-0.0521941222,
0.0198067892,
-0.0037526391,
-0.021806078,
-0.0213120859,
-0.0324843712,
-0.0247703604,
-0.0352053046,
-0.0193970967,
-0.0920606479,
-0.0009892692,
-0.0130988276,
-0.0174933393,
-0.059177652,
0.0116206743,
2.776947447e-34,
0.0358287171,
0.0234873351,
0.0247736126,
-0.0259215944,
0.0172940176,
0.0153464749,
-0.0104096755,
0.0175348502,
0.0290162954,
-0.1051185578,
-0.0220090821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14115v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14115v1 | Take the essence and discard the dross: A Rethinking on Data Selection for Fine-Tuning Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T08:58:58 | 2024-06-20T08:58:58 | Ziche Liu, Rui Ke, Feng Jiang, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data selection for fine-tuning Large Language Models (LLMs) aims to select a
high-quality subset from a given candidate dataset to train a Pending Fine-tune
Model (PFM) into a Selective-Enhanced Model (SEM). It can improve the model
performance and accelerate the training process. Although a few surveys have
investigated related works of data selection, there is a lack of comprehensive
comparison between existing methods due to their various experimental settings.
To address this issue, we first propose a three-stage scheme for data selection
and comprehensively review existing works according to this scheme. Then, we
design a unified comparing method with ratio-based efficiency indicators and
ranking-based feasibility indicators to overcome the difficulty of comparing
various models with diverse experimental settings. After an in-depth
comparative analysis, we find that the more targeted method with data-specific
and model-specific quality labels has higher efficiency, but the introduction
of additional noise information should be avoided when designing selection
algorithms. Finally, we summarize the trends in data selection and highlight
the short-term and long-term challenges to guide future research. | [
0.042186223,
0.0785491467,
-0.0171515997,
0.0312549323,
-0.0161861721,
0.0236834828,
0.0281637162,
0.0307152029,
-0.047757227,
-0.0670155957,
-0.0497013777,
-0.0288076866,
0.0198714044,
-0.007978797,
0.0571143627,
-0.0148588475,
0.0380063057,
-0.0461300574,
-0.0008059883,
-0.0011546164,
-0.0139377965,
0.0206404552,
0.0474599898,
0.0330938473,
0.0281071067,
0.0363645777,
0.0435527042,
0.0063136076,
-0.012068714,
-0.017399624,
0.0377070829,
0.0905114934,
0.0143485554,
0.0199105069,
0.0000020378,
-0.0607043728,
-0.0192107242,
0.0038356364,
-0.0380277596,
0.0246889647,
0.0246346351,
-0.0128233312,
-0.0036573794,
-0.0003847519,
-0.00758958,
-0.0040742727,
0.0595733561,
0.0046393927,
0.0217780992,
0.0612581968,
-0.0019802917,
-0.0357056111,
-0.0011161835,
-0.045179043,
-0.0504745655,
-0.0207617395,
0.0675244406,
0.0211280659,
-0.0079143764,
0.0258710049,
-0.0231562685,
0.0096392604,
-0.0491649471,
-0.0081065977,
0.0231160447,
0.0023076613,
-0.0593513884,
-0.0383186974,
0.0316761881,
0.0629663914,
-0.0349876061,
-0.0152887972,
0.0189859904,
-0.0186589547,
-0.0274692588,
0.0154988216,
-0.0386214033,
-0.0238082353,
0.023484027,
0.057556197,
0.0447422192,
-0.0292602386,
0.0514344387,
0.054659266,
-0.0468432754,
0.0113034276,
0.0253265984,
-0.0424775556,
0.0544462018,
-0.0073431544,
-0.048858691,
-0.0237696376,
-0.0190384183,
-0.0273134168,
-0.0437568128,
-0.0055878772,
-0.0469530337,
-0.0320644081,
0.0073343618,
0.0120604923,
0.047716327,
-0.0012700136,
0.0282543525,
0.0482406467,
-0.0142465755,
0.0057525998,
0.0364809632,
0.0524921864,
-0.039792642,
-0.0097699128,
-0.0315245315,
0.031928923,
-0.034131892,
0.0229627006,
-0.0046189185,
-0.0075697205,
-0.0562334023,
-0.0372485071,
0.0104103237,
-0.0283469781,
0.0422690362,
-0.0623587891,
-0.0417619608,
0.032978721,
0.0221483335,
0.0140068112,
-0.0254868325,
0.02874179,
-0.0123010566,
-0.0667022467,
0.0060065235,
0.0154589135,
0.0165388491,
-0.0481475182,
0.0324099511,
0.0151032479,
0.0172585323,
-0.0668932348,
-0.0442358255,
0.0317733064,
-0.0392447487,
-0.0705762058,
0.0116255945,
-0.0572516881,
-0.0026119752,
0.0080302674,
0.03881827,
-0.0250859782,
-0.0251437947,
-0.0241899155,
-0.0394183733,
0.0249512177,
-0.0653504357,
0.0351912975,
-0.0244748928,
-0.0329200961,
0.015984457,
0.086156249,
0.0414170921,
-0.0069723809,
0.0521516614,
-0.0359390788,
-0.009266777,
0.0457031205,
-0.0069787996,
0.0343320742,
-0.0318596512,
-0.0083824797,
0.028098911,
-0.0031178268,
-0.0153473485,
0.0189309791,
-0.0300037209,
0.004033478,
0.0660646781,
0.0061272723,
0.0759008899,
0.0103175268,
-0.0116148638,
0.0059342408,
0.0243252087,
-0.0119048525,
-0.0041573099,
-0.0178591572,
-0.0312559269,
0.0160989426,
0.0403840914,
0.0436811335,
-0.0166889615,
-0.0396537334,
-0.0312828235,
0.0145172141,
0.003467968,
0.0247675143,
0.07996732,
-0.0078186709,
-0.024697043,
0.0282927267,
0.0750320777,
-0.0140940007,
0.0046024225,
-0.0623175204,
0.023983974,
0.0299390703,
0.0424528942,
-0.0303007327,
0.0021585196,
-0.0224566143,
0.0307639483,
-0.019652104,
0.0672226623,
0.0002862734,
0.0187416375,
-0.0703208745,
-0.0557079092,
0.0051036365,
0.0172446333,
-0.0282963105,
-0.0091957757,
-0.0035732246,
0.0085922712,
-0.0459372625,
-0.0681201369,
0.0611610189,
0.0137606375,
0.0024263044,
0.0125509202,
-0.0053183371,
0.0462062545,
-0.028512625,
-0.0243428573,
-0.0150956549,
0.0117890732,
-0.023292318,
0.0450238213,
-0.0617818832,
-0.0076589515,
-0.0130012874,
-0.0030902547,
-0.0122125437,
0.0047197621,
0.0364713259,
-0.0512822494,
-0.0376342535,
-0.029291993,
-0.0276047774,
-0.0176553596,
-0.0626656115,
0.0413184129,
-0.0517200567,
0.0181338917,
-0.0614157282,
0.0374683402,
0.0220837723,
0.0353035107,
0.0354553275,
0.0097814882,
0.0209127255,
-0.0435555652,
-0.0616481118,
0.0460245274,
-0.0190885253,
0.0318868458,
0.0365427919,
0.0270819031,
-0.0318436585,
-0.0338422842,
-0.0657588989,
0.001415204,
-0.0523350537,
-0.0073107537,
-0.0055328012,
-0.0041538649,
-0.0140628079,
0.0243613962,
0.0099301198,
-0.0048621651,
-0.0001378875,
0.030158082,
0.0064971419,
-0.0012812897,
-0.0220511798,
-0.0599440224,
-0.0567040816,
0.0410981923,
0.0654861331,
-0.0104574217,
-0.0103943693,
-0.0517341234,
0.0422703996,
-0.0256109051,
-0.0208031461,
-0.0010848757,
-0.0510631576,
-0.0175332259,
-0.014947121,
-0.0437783338,
0.0249305423,
0.0005094538,
0.0065038614,
0.042710349,
-0.0062417896,
-0.0125037991,
-0.0197340418,
-0.0183027331,
-0.002577218,
-0.0429029353,
-0.0145468945,
0.0210349578,
0.0500786677,
-0.0070611988,
-0.0231151395,
-0.0464677885,
0.0433423556,
-0.0383822992,
0.0193775631,
-0.0200140011,
0.0293658059,
-0.0010057191,
0.0497629084,
-0.0200022552,
-0.0755910873,
0.0605319962,
-0.0171645675,
0.0065039773,
-0.0484333038,
-0.001980386,
-0.0123014683,
-0.0170728471,
-0.0103765111,
0.0136732571,
0.0202543531,
0.0150702931,
-0.0290330518,
-0.0253420081,
0.0411719047,
-0.0254008863,
0.0521374457,
-0.034134645,
0.0496367216,
-0.0077932202,
-0.0264439173,
0.0044398154,
-0.0263387579,
-0.0248636976,
0.0225648861,
0.0406977944,
0.0318798721,
-0.0070326449,
0.0380881168,
-0.0310644582,
0.0373902209,
-0.0363428295,
0.0184971336,
-0.0117885955,
-0.0103267226,
0.0537499525,
0.0101840701,
0.0291698575,
-0.0350752771,
0.018462114,
-0.0161244534,
0.0126173124,
0.0410621092,
-0.0037258347,
0.0268678982,
0.0472873971,
-0.0014969492,
-0.0523143969,
0.0229525957,
0.04472249,
-0.0594923981,
-0.0146625424,
0.1059547663,
-0.0059523671,
-0.0055947355,
0.0033282808,
0.034755297,
0.0346921235,
0.0149585037,
0.0099144382,
-0.0209233388,
-0.0339329168,
0.0217374433,
0.0438242853,
-0.019986257,
0.0010875395,
0.0219527613,
-0.0829043388,
0.0766971707,
0.0326373614,
-0.0396980867,
-0.026646249,
-0.0717454478,
0.0415836126,
-0.0512084961,
0.0286711436,
0.0148620447,
-0.0191920344,
-0.0338764265,
0.0298921447,
0.0035918495,
-0.122669287,
0.0169130042,
-0.0358290859,
0.0312723592,
0.0404724106,
0.0487259217,
-0.0222874992,
-0.0211587902,
0.0333249979,
-0.0423475802,
-0.012910895,
-0.0496254414,
0.0489792824,
0.0225909445,
-0.0263677314,
0.0184734464,
0.0251562558,
0.017258795,
0.0022485368,
-0.0277356971,
0.033927355,
-0.018295357,
-0.0230832137,
0.0350610986,
-0.0172813069,
-0.016322175,
0.0748295411,
0.045378305,
-0.0560930595,
-0.0141663533,
-0.0018759917,
-0.00395157,
-0.0324498601,
0.0037670999,
0.0227664411,
-0.0334052406,
-0.0100693507,
-0.0328077823,
-0.0104681989,
0.0572300628,
0.0218591895,
0.0125922645,
0.0628852844,
0.0257668309,
-0.0020267835,
0.0192141235,
0.0382770561,
-0.0477749668,
0.0032529116,
-0.0787905529,
-0.0325159393,
0.035582006,
-0.030730525,
-0.0259168502,
-0.0034881153,
-0.0689160973,
-0.0556308404,
0.0153155867,
0.050724525,
0.0185708087,
0.0128973862,
-0.0015871188,
-0.0943925157,
0.0266988054,
0.0146098556,
-0.0011350686,
0.0089517236,
0.0425568372,
-0.0573372282,
-0.0448845886,
0.0151583161,
-0.0498453788,
0.0427578352,
0.0814724192,
0.0187364072,
0.0067542549,
-0.0311629213,
-0.0057358728,
0.0517797209,
0.063179113,
-0.0288835708,
-0.0744105056,
-0.0643100888,
0.0202366337,
0.0414441042,
-0.0063521736,
-0.0411749855,
-0.0063498723,
0.0008186669,
0.0074021416,
-0.0354556888,
-0.0169662833,
-0.0234563407,
0.0250404216,
-0.0786848888,
0.0354916267,
-0.0130659984,
0.0129463263,
0.039035935,
-0.0007474404,
-0.0177732892,
0.0290010422,
0.0285625271,
0.0249810554,
-0.0286133476,
0.0243261084,
0.0109872734,
0.036882896,
-0.0367337242,
0.0366350003,
-0.0324543267,
-0.0236552544,
-0.0463791713,
0.0057290429,
0.0581969097,
-0.0507052504,
0.0684913471,
0.0128980419,
-0.0294327289,
-0.0619371496,
0.0402729772,
0.0334984884,
0.0018410145,
0.0065739206,
0.010753056,
-0.0458326116,
0.0214470867,
0.0523802564,
0.0147758638,
0.0246848334,
0.0076404656,
-0.0038134498,
-0.02658315,
-0.0063914424,
0.0100959027,
-0.0167835113,
-0.0212024711,
-0.0109360395,
-0.0331269577,
-0.0431882478,
-0.0180321243,
-0.0351712108,
-0.0151674803,
-0.0002335161,
0.0351032801,
0.0506850295,
-0.0137411412,
0.0136591299,
-0.0561847128,
-0.0773991272,
0.0299112163,
0.0034438227,
-0.008849347,
-6.466157856e-33,
0.0077554141,
0.0450383015,
-0.0347057208,
-0.023343293,
-0.0184911191,
-0.0089792367,
-0.0251862034,
-0.0414583832,
-0.0397727862,
-0.0108723091,
-0.0192174483,
-0.0334519818,
0.0141212875,
0.036108125,
-0.0221729167,
-0.0084040482,
0.0614575557,
-0.0048631611,
-0.0363519415,
0.0088635767,
0.0194952469,
0.030216191,
0.0587672107,
-0.0320051946,
-0.0000088481,
0.0123530971,
-0.0267559625,
-0.0071452553,
-0.0284114927,
0.0825554729,
0.0231608748,
0.0481883995,
0.0325815678,
-0.037173748,
-0.023287423,
-0.0097380653,
-0.0222494639,
-0.0073382971,
0.0238317996,
-0.0081073102,
0.0468349941,
-0.0145776644,
0.0593851842,
0.0011810868,
-0.0205935836,
-0.0221760776,
0.0230595525,
-0.0494711138,
-0.0683615729,
-0.0133871986,
-0.0450106077,
0.031096179,
-0.0121554155,
-0.0169749651,
0.0433258787,
0.019210564,
-0.0270895623,
0.0501220301,
-0.0151359448,
0.0201923363,
0.0809903294,
0.0796015337,
0.0286501683,
0.055449944,
0.0084272502,
0.0453547463,
-0.0205173157,
0.0003307403,
0.091731146,
-0.0262546577,
0.0784938857,
0.0695387945,
0.056021966,
0.0140244979,
0.0238775425,
-0.0386142097,
-0.1038018167,
-0.0041390103,
-0.0116248708,
0.0000275502,
0.0348828621,
0.029067317,
-0.0300504174,
-0.0508973263,
-0.085388355,
-0.0151406238,
-0.0291446783,
0.0297868177,
0.0400654562,
0.0132996039,
-0.0725215301,
-0.0111768264,
0.0519720614,
-0.0373410173,
-0.0390989482,
0.0167542249,
-0.0304228328,
0.0055933245,
-0.0108089559,
-0.0023868198,
-0.0479311943,
-0.073706314,
0.0452889986,
-0.0150979897,
0.0130168097,
-0.0455882289,
0.0317744873,
0.004405628,
-0.0347798057,
0.0137516661,
-0.0011551862,
-0.0013776496,
0.0103068408,
0.0367204957,
0.028693188,
0.0124595715,
0.0171709899,
0.054789383,
0.0288122781,
-0.0150584551,
-0.023238996,
0.0027932459,
0.0140253678,
0.0319366902,
0.0119586438,
0.0189477298,
-0.0220741928,
-0.0126713319,
0.0577313863,
-0.0033718538,
-0.0236802902,
0.0286132284,
2.662e-7,
0.0447779521,
0.0499175042,
-0.0559099019,
-0.0069633364,
-0.0040990235,
0.039729435,
-0.0326913521,
-0.0228441283,
0.0495509021,
0.0203909166,
0.0135063017,
0.0025815128,
0.1134919003,
0.0094626322,
-0.0588547513,
0.0284327809,
-0.0459958576,
0.0302291233,
-0.0356918834,
-0.0107029583,
0.0050151777,
0.1139594242,
0.0021110994,
-0.0135086821,
-0.0145970015,
-0.0279989075,
0.0289071873,
-0.0694716573,
-0.002571255,
0.0743830055,
0.0317991525,
0.0430302918,
-0.0096369069,
0.0357295685,
-0.0336122997,
0.0312877782,
0.014086823,
0.0529875085,
-0.0003841199,
0.0361208506,
0.017496936,
0.0228633191,
0.003497289,
-0.0656954721,
0.0807591602,
-0.0663109645,
-0.020924639,
-0.0149924709,
0.0246261358,
-0.0360892192,
0.0334248133,
-0.0758604258,
-0.0073703169,
0.0296003725,
0.0326775014,
-0.0039299177,
-0.0416794382,
-0.0463917442,
0.0215441789,
0.0189623889,
-0.0474626496,
-0.0569090024,
-0.0221519694,
-0.0327232182,
0.0334872976,
-0.0432620272,
0.0373991132,
2.593801983e-34,
0.0251022652,
-0.0339452252,
0.0102061573,
-0.0071637575,
0.0234820116,
0.000906029,
0.008386624,
0.0120754763,
-0.0424229018,
-0.1048934683,
0.0088095181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14106v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14106v1 | EasyECR: A Library for Easy Implementation and Evaluation of Event Coreference Resolution Models | 2024-06-20T08:40:21 | 2024-06-20T08:40:21 | Yuncong Li, Tianhua Xu, Sheng-hua Zhong, Haiqin Yang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Event Coreference Resolution (ECR) is the task of clustering event mentions
that refer to the same real-world event. Despite significant advancements, ECR
research faces two main challenges: limited generalizability across domains due
to narrow dataset evaluations, and difficulties in comparing models within
diverse ECR pipelines. To address these issues, we develop EasyECR, the first
open-source library designed to standardize data structures and abstract ECR
pipelines for easy implementation and fair evaluation. More specifically,
EasyECR integrates seven representative pipelines and ten popular benchmark
datasets, enabling model evaluations on various datasets and promoting the
development of robust ECR pipelines. By conducting extensive evaluation via our
EasyECR, we find that, \lowercase\expandafter{\romannumeral1}) the
representative ECR pipelines cannot generalize across multiple datasets, hence
evaluating ECR pipelines on multiple datasets is necessary,
\lowercase\expandafter{\romannumeral2}) all models in ECR pipelines have a
great effect on pipeline performance, therefore, when one model in ECR
pipelines are compared, it is essential to ensure that the other models remain
consistent. Additionally, reproducing ECR results is not trivial, and the
developed library can help reduce this discrepancy. The experimental results
provide valuable baselines for future research. | [
0.0541490018,
-0.0005344186,
-0.0090139471,
0.0098224571,
-0.0472162627,
0.015642507,
0.0095466161,
-0.0267341249,
0.058391273,
-0.0247428883,
0.0157417264,
0.0287968088,
-0.0076106032,
0.0614830591,
-0.015133244,
-0.0599023215,
0.051378876,
0.0062058051,
0.0389294811,
0.0363638625,
0.0266001765,
0.0386346541,
-0.0226638559,
0.0344006307,
-0.0227339603,
0.0290975273,
0.0075155366,
-0.0029606111,
0.0430779308,
-0.0077631869,
0.0036280744,
0.0445025824,
0.0097474093,
0.0384017266,
0.0000020464,
-0.0572383143,
-0.0115060182,
-0.0021432389,
-0.0050008446,
0.0002582905,
0.0018163905,
-0.0072720069,
0.0329563953,
-0.0060665389,
-0.0001688083,
-0.0261522606,
0.0416065753,
0.0641442165,
0.0223586671,
0.0074232002,
-0.0316002667,
0.0156768635,
0.0038449902,
-0.0254876688,
-0.0636817738,
-0.0628353059,
0.0295728203,
0.0069198264,
0.0163687319,
-0.0127092414,
0.0314171575,
0.00350091,
0.0069024069,
0.0415748172,
0.0059188632,
0.0506486222,
-0.0952885449,
-0.0050038411,
0.0197563637,
0.0657667667,
0.037592534,
-0.0080513246,
0.0663377568,
0.0085716993,
-0.0292792376,
0.0065750959,
-0.0599456504,
-0.0294576362,
-0.0190728363,
0.0043534352,
-0.0164589956,
0.0290036015,
-0.0330194756,
-0.015536461,
0.0070855734,
0.0666785687,
0.02790392,
0.0221948046,
-0.0045250375,
0.002079831,
-0.0171940029,
-0.0713322759,
0.0813737512,
0.0014527877,
-0.0352629945,
0.0087029226,
-0.038776163,
0.0777570829,
0.0218252465,
-0.0667058304,
-0.0117933331,
0.0059368503,
0.0142055284,
0.0535458103,
-0.0032962216,
0.0239723511,
0.0013340483,
0.0162736867,
-0.0151246991,
-0.0469685644,
-0.0724073425,
0.0516666472,
-0.0441632569,
0.0188765619,
-0.0832841545,
-0.0225862786,
-0.0355876461,
0.0172661636,
-0.0041623004,
-0.0107680634,
-0.0102355396,
-0.0028635431,
-0.0106093884,
0.005054858,
-0.0280628353,
-0.0105863735,
-0.0329966433,
0.0192048643,
-0.0604573563,
-0.0418273471,
0.0006194783,
0.0222297683,
0.0103751039,
-0.0277885627,
-0.0294480547,
0.0250745621,
0.012602346,
-0.0305323694,
-0.0165454857,
-0.0440530665,
-0.0106510846,
-0.0309989955,
-0.0632682443,
-0.0641677156,
0.0527806245,
0.0181264691,
-0.0027197683,
-0.0450875126,
0.0166071039,
-0.0102224797,
-0.0864618197,
0.0233349092,
-0.026875345,
0.0284311604,
0.028979294,
-0.0094926422,
0.0190164912,
0.0306383688,
0.043295525,
0.0058169183,
0.0489386693,
0.0277075451,
-0.0142992362,
0.0212557297,
0.020546874,
0.0092511447,
0.0468575731,
0.0050486224,
-0.0624836758,
-0.0121725593,
0.0371399485,
0.0206917189,
-0.0110431295,
-0.0522889085,
0.0320955925,
0.0216589905,
-0.0566469058,
-0.0431514308,
-0.01779183,
0.004244165,
-0.0155339856,
0.0272169597,
-0.035110727,
0.0167582463,
-0.0032503475,
-0.0209877286,
0.0635765269,
0.0010959631,
-0.0540088192,
0.0208627935,
-0.0091586467,
0.0330446288,
0.0028369341,
-0.0057344628,
0.0415803939,
-0.0212248899,
-0.0244650003,
0.0753012225,
0.017329054,
-0.0131186079,
0.007655601,
-0.0012344617,
-0.0332721099,
0.026015833,
0.0452158749,
-0.0240987875,
-0.0491956659,
0.011128352,
0.0252356716,
0.0152602261,
0.021226462,
-0.0101863965,
0.0414098687,
-0.035139896,
-0.0367474742,
0.0305401161,
-0.0062740487,
-0.0020145469,
0.0378380306,
-0.0106679909,
0.0111659104,
-0.0147685772,
-0.0304011498,
0.0233916827,
-0.0290682856,
0.0133114941,
-0.0161864888,
-0.0046835151,
0.0203520302,
0.01599098,
-0.0058664382,
-0.0201767217,
0.0465743169,
-0.0050825062,
-0.0024610555,
0.065344356,
-0.0154799186,
-0.0047730748,
0.0315825827,
-0.0329071954,
-0.0254327077,
-0.0169975143,
-0.0510087498,
-0.061108321,
0.0046459325,
-0.0056073121,
0.0315081291,
-0.0131663671,
0.0254920963,
0.002540868,
-0.0247923639,
-0.0184797719,
0.0304144602,
0.003036967,
0.0071762884,
-0.0018226322,
0.0132302642,
0.024425257,
-0.0432662927,
-0.0296744592,
-0.0131165516,
0.0020304383,
-0.0188210849,
0.0457470864,
-0.0308752023,
-0.0723439902,
0.0087903822,
-0.0908674002,
0.0193508938,
-0.0152168749,
0.025411468,
0.0518388301,
0.0237333551,
-0.0215200484,
-0.0016406908,
0.0095565198,
-0.0551646091,
0.001158873,
0.0305446088,
0.017620679,
0.0242245179,
-0.0345031172,
-0.0594715327,
0.0025133383,
-0.0345812216,
0.0486519858,
0.02210957,
-0.0610213913,
-0.0314663164,
0.051399067,
-0.0298235994,
0.012541919,
0.0000010276,
0.0246904548,
-0.0148869352,
0.0349958315,
0.0288580749,
0.001818244,
-0.0154423071,
-0.0095006432,
-0.0070383167,
-0.073921442,
-0.0704208538,
0.0175633337,
-0.0432357229,
-0.0149238994,
-0.0097056627,
-0.0322510824,
0.0302349795,
0.0220387466,
0.0385863408,
0.0175840985,
-0.0502773114,
-0.0194747094,
0.0023480179,
-0.0052550463,
-0.010820955,
-0.0646269843,
-0.0156417601,
0.055562079,
-0.0663765445,
-0.0226063989,
0.0516338535,
-0.0255579315,
0.0076827351,
-0.0160383433,
-0.0132063311,
-0.075207442,
0.0720596313,
0.0094606075,
-0.0003523167,
0.0235382263,
-0.0561544932,
0.0104797585,
-0.0072652958,
0.0120155094,
0.0070247739,
0.0418931209,
-0.0514245704,
0.0489988141,
0.0125492765,
0.0041435338,
-0.0436556377,
0.0407606103,
-0.0314270929,
0.0025301834,
-0.0195857491,
0.0319262333,
-0.058109507,
0.0823557004,
0.0216397997,
0.0505837165,
0.0126216672,
-0.0049127685,
-0.0201830864,
0.0706327781,
0.0244300608,
-0.0401535407,
-0.0136034926,
0.0064399308,
-0.0367324986,
0.0598574914,
0.0414723009,
0.0031693608,
-0.0358104706,
-0.0187196545,
0.0192497019,
-0.0897012129,
0.0135111688,
-0.0046903337,
0.0490334108,
-0.0175337996,
-0.0071698958,
0.1103122458,
0.0458192602,
-0.0343287922,
-0.0101395631,
0.0155431097,
0.017726142,
0.0289302096,
-0.0331473537,
-0.0024855705,
-0.0219882801,
-0.0046482747,
-0.0257472377,
0.0089880032,
-0.0836626813,
0.0092930524,
-0.0499941371,
0.0233356394,
-0.0069004004,
-0.0690127835,
-0.0930242091,
-0.0917626694,
0.0735194609,
-0.0331046507,
-0.021217946,
0.0028076668,
0.0081301127,
0.001977507,
-0.002536522,
-0.0750657395,
-0.038676925,
0.0387633555,
-0.0772774443,
0.0351053365,
0.0334144831,
0.0363071337,
0.0278244354,
0.058937218,
-0.0044570812,
-0.0468474701,
-0.0120300911,
-0.0341973603,
0.0565086901,
0.0005731179,
0.0071310797,
-0.0339537151,
0.0369123183,
-0.0301714633,
-0.0322226882,
0.0364660509,
0.0574533343,
0.0049316725,
0.0160771068,
-0.0409805663,
0.0219257716,
0.013399275,
0.0618458167,
0.0139864469,
0.0557776131,
0.0136856083,
0.0141812209,
0.008778736,
-0.0252290815,
-0.0067755817,
-0.0164731909,
-0.0408181846,
-0.0023553018,
-0.0501336157,
-0.0319965929,
0.0474018268,
-0.0203425623,
-0.0182299577,
0.013902491,
0.0503049977,
-0.0227190293,
-0.0556279533,
0.0163576305,
-0.0633192435,
0.0127053196,
-0.0283062328,
0.0126090134,
0.0635321364,
0.1072460487,
-0.0328741968,
0.1469144672,
-0.0465075783,
-0.0390189141,
-0.0246565137,
-0.0386058725,
0.017597815,
0.013151858,
-0.0259336922,
-0.0068573565,
-0.0248264819,
0.002511739,
-0.0504273437,
0.0017247284,
-0.0228007082,
-0.0086717168,
-0.0089666555,
0.0323115215,
-0.0324580856,
0.0530725569,
-0.0302244145,
0.0595469996,
-0.0567888692,
-0.1050614193,
-0.0154294381,
0.0161151867,
0.0435520038,
0.0312256925,
-0.0299021676,
-0.0359392539,
0.0091662407,
-0.0322756171,
0.0143316314,
0.0078428118,
0.0382187963,
-0.0532756262,
0.0181482155,
0.0000751886,
0.0454479121,
-0.0465634912,
0.0323834568,
-0.0311601423,
-0.019171115,
0.0139573272,
0.0238695685,
-0.002770667,
-0.0046835267,
-0.012466684,
-0.0021490057,
0.0129162986,
0.0277497116,
-0.0365230478,
0.0158383101,
0.0029033057,
0.0201068074,
0.0022650431,
-0.0225190949,
-0.0617398806,
0.0377270393,
-0.0345761552,
0.0026580938,
0.0499038585,
-0.0054494203,
0.0877867118,
-0.0108719366,
-0.0081197964,
-0.0172645412,
0.0207865965,
-0.0309745166,
0.0223821644,
-0.0313146636,
0.0121884141,
-0.0249702614,
0.0688197538,
0.0440504365,
-0.0209812783,
0.0297055691,
0.0170440953,
-0.0666839555,
-0.0193716697,
-0.0559981801,
0.0136637697,
0.0097112535,
-0.0082252864,
-0.023141006,
-0.0634364188,
-0.0007430727,
0.0652312785,
-0.0345295034,
-0.0063518612,
0.0051221498,
0.0535507798,
0.0225860011,
0.0439002365,
-0.0055821603,
-0.0033723481,
0.0143620251,
0.0195377618,
-0.060289111,
-0.0524142981,
-5.929339708e-33,
-0.0415863506,
-0.048067525,
-0.0041425494,
0.0080769211,
0.0120479548,
0.0068454472,
-0.0366578475,
-0.0217537843,
0.0178994313,
-0.0205906518,
0.0161105674,
-0.0178896617,
0.0308387913,
-0.0335884169,
-0.0030155161,
0.0004037751,
0.0420203134,
0.0254128128,
-0.0078358082,
0.0651700944,
0.0749487579,
0.0256629512,
0.0516524948,
-0.1143823564,
0.0223644208,
0.0272906199,
0.0061245882,
-0.0019044038,
0.0796199962,
0.0471364781,
-0.008677979,
0.026447773,
0.0157603249,
-0.061469201,
-0.0311534293,
-0.0327211097,
-0.1183775216,
-0.0299454741,
0.0485344194,
-0.0054868013,
0.0203543715,
-0.0170737598,
0.0230460856,
-0.0036012093,
0.010421617,
-0.0141185531,
0.0448675305,
-0.0026117535,
-0.0453471653,
-0.0114080831,
-0.051070109,
0.0579296649,
-0.0298539456,
0.0195483509,
0.0122848125,
0.0325713903,
0.0184919611,
0.0168377664,
-0.0912657902,
0.0470779948,
-0.0402681753,
-0.0097030131,
0.0237567779,
-0.0353555866,
0.0041876533,
0.0384693407,
-0.0101072425,
-0.0428480878,
-0.0218879692,
0.0462353602,
0.0062104873,
0.0569364689,
-0.0001411893,
0.0903242603,
-0.0419694744,
0.0207121745,
-0.0688065141,
0.0756305978,
0.0066753295,
0.001423697,
0.0349635109,
0.0175488517,
-0.0659521446,
-0.0279653557,
-0.035063725,
-0.0132385436,
-0.0292796828,
-0.0083503155,
0.0108721498,
0.0115042021,
0.0149269896,
0.0711957738,
0.020047361,
-0.0002819743,
-0.0264596548,
0.0181311835,
0.0190700553,
0.0296711624,
0.0182677116,
0.0458045378,
-0.0420208201,
-0.013924744,
0.0436401591,
-0.0022162984,
0.0285419673,
-0.0328298509,
0.0044821282,
-0.0382125415,
-0.0473773293,
0.0097790994,
0.0144880358,
0.0076621082,
-0.0603423975,
-0.0301556699,
-0.0208526179,
0.0009852267,
0.0157020949,
0.0434403233,
0.0140374126,
0.0033385626,
-0.0441801436,
-0.0068142558,
0.0206614938,
0.0527663343,
0.0134103578,
0.0049655917,
-0.0445563644,
-0.0171572026,
0.0280925166,
0.0194139481,
-0.0310085006,
0.0009336369,
2.592e-7,
0.0218371004,
0.02845788,
0.0867063627,
0.0302032232,
-0.0213993769,
0.0143086072,
0.0091075711,
0.0666546077,
0.0407428183,
0.0005498911,
0.00227669,
0.0311897732,
0.0032193558,
0.0538348109,
-0.0530945063,
-0.0389352888,
-0.0623641796,
-0.0316839553,
-0.0694315508,
0.0023517462,
0.0356495157,
0.0575758703,
0.0580043904,
0.0167992245,
-0.0374542736,
-0.0172681008,
0.0179764703,
-0.0413358882,
-0.0441215783,
0.0562353395,
-0.0320680588,
0.0273562521,
-0.0223729331,
0.0727863908,
0.0195494331,
-0.0022215259,
0.0175988339,
0.0564088672,
0.0059365099,
-0.0397316739,
-0.0181311574,
-0.0353923775,
0.0174420513,
-0.0498952307,
0.0515354201,
-0.0459573716,
-0.0018874307,
0.006115282,
-0.0263900366,
0.0497023202,
-0.0019162821,
0.0499046221,
-0.0259247534,
0.0375479013,
-0.0004005441,
0.0331703462,
-0.0274356566,
-0.0636456236,
-0.0008681636,
0.0187725015,
-0.0216171052,
-0.0454069749,
0.0071675507,
-0.0648940057,
-0.0232664999,
-0.0182407219,
0.0317748263,
2.473865284e-34,
0.0089302119,
0.062362764,
-0.0336673222,
-0.0005080323,
0.0341519974,
-0.0485108271,
-0.0509813055,
0.0028089629,
0.0094764242,
-0.0305183697,
0.0096485382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14099v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14099v2 | Let Guidelines Guide You: A Prescriptive Guideline-Centered Data Annotation Methodology | 2024-06-20T08:24:57 | 2024-07-02T15:38:17 | Federico Ruggeri, Eleonora Misino, Arianna Muti, Katerina Korre, Paolo Torroni, Alberto Barrón-Cedeño | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce the Guideline-Centered annotation process, a novel data
annotation methodology focused on reporting the annotation guidelines
associated with each data sample. We identify three main limitations of the
standard prescriptive annotation process and describe how the
Guideline-Centered methodology overcomes them by reducing the loss of
information in the annotation process and ensuring adherence to guidelines.
Additionally, we discuss how the Guideline-Centered enables the reuse of
annotated data across multiple tasks at the cost of a single human-annotation
process. | [
0.0124809742,
0.0035098293,
-0.0088035073,
-0.0398969352,
0.0330177918,
0.0156834405,
0.0178230181,
-0.0284857918,
-0.0141017921,
-0.0293710828,
0.0285310745,
0.0492432527,
0.0204134509,
-0.0041157035,
0.0312491357,
-0.0829048008,
0.0381509699,
0.0228806939,
0.0096625332,
0.0728823096,
0.0109566571,
-0.0044453591,
-0.00718662,
0.0422191098,
-0.0709741935,
-0.0335380547,
0.0043392391,
0.0361655429,
0.0236996561,
-0.0549743213,
0.0014554646,
0.0459118187,
0.0402849987,
0.0089741666,
0.0000022796,
-0.0222337879,
-0.020615574,
0.056030456,
-0.0372986607,
0.0270728134,
0.0170735102,
-0.0103728743,
0.0147480359,
-0.0049101701,
0.0195247419,
-0.0276767537,
0.0936736986,
0.0166342836,
0.0783119947,
0.0114651285,
-0.0078027323,
0.0208390709,
-0.0201217625,
-0.0092437165,
0.0129551757,
0.0351140089,
-0.0034864596,
0.1081552133,
0.0314023755,
0.0184708163,
0.0302759577,
0.036903102,
0.012477356,
-0.0166974049,
0.0346074477,
-0.0084442589,
-0.0110809635,
-0.0269452389,
0.0073987073,
0.0361663178,
0.0654129758,
0.0042564236,
0.0320686065,
-0.0204620007,
-0.016443802,
-0.0088776918,
-0.0648975074,
0.027035512,
0.0014906041,
-0.0406544656,
-0.0141616492,
0.019288579,
0.0154563291,
-0.0504685268,
0.0410957858,
0.0284828935,
-0.0408666246,
0.0022924833,
-0.0043702768,
0.0065429155,
-0.010783094,
-0.0422623008,
0.0062417602,
-0.0130958902,
0.0285379291,
-0.0458971262,
0.0061742729,
-0.0257252734,
0.098450236,
-0.0339882746,
0.1009972543,
0.0005444224,
-0.0649330541,
0.0104651321,
0.0263723042,
-0.0238799602,
-0.0029879441,
-0.0043390952,
0.0096265413,
0.0210637953,
-0.0436366387,
0.0025077874,
-0.0030148695,
-0.0076403623,
-0.0225018971,
0.0103651686,
-0.032868281,
0.0374460705,
-0.0317814425,
0.0256066993,
0.0351876691,
-0.0166602992,
-0.0478066877,
0.0532638282,
0.0178727899,
-0.0183412898,
-0.0689586923,
0.0407554731,
0.032370273,
-0.0270425882,
0.0135867177,
0.0282560438,
0.005903909,
0.0063185082,
-0.0216054879,
0.0247240942,
0.0429429859,
0.0361472443,
-0.018376125,
-0.0845928863,
0.0170631297,
0.0104461377,
0.0143553251,
-0.0176769644,
0.0325627327,
0.02393171,
-0.0002480473,
0.0112989964,
-0.0184678826,
0.040936213,
-0.0037286114,
0.0509521998,
-0.0874016806,
-0.0104998779,
0.0047555096,
0.0125290137,
-0.0203683823,
0.0157539994,
0.0244881827,
-0.0085164085,
0.0154981697,
0.0084742596,
0.0144841839,
-0.0185485501,
-0.0241083,
-0.0522205085,
0.0146376649,
0.0015112449,
0.0236341115,
0.0129714832,
0.0307111163,
-0.0052976282,
-0.0545908883,
0.0373093411,
0.0128115145,
0.0374693163,
0.0480665416,
-0.0240291506,
0.0489165448,
0.0110101318,
0.0266322084,
-0.054069411,
-0.0442863144,
0.0424256995,
0.0385109857,
0.0280378722,
-0.0570303015,
-0.0029429644,
0.0023131955,
-0.0445367955,
-0.0511604957,
-0.0002179463,
0.0188056752,
-0.0072924006,
-0.0315930247,
0.0160608105,
0.0370814316,
0.0192546863,
-0.010111657,
-0.0518723205,
-0.0404320695,
0.0135070765,
-0.0154416636,
0.0773966387,
0.0041791829,
-0.0419370569,
-0.0431448892,
-0.0515699871,
0.088890709,
-0.0069774827,
0.0571156517,
-0.0457622036,
0.0137663474,
-0.0206452683,
-0.0407195203,
-0.0343837887,
0.0075558648,
-0.0054130764,
-0.0231406689,
-0.0524734333,
-0.0079243025,
-0.02163307,
-0.0974218324,
0.0663916543,
0.0352982543,
-0.0250741728,
-0.004428986,
-0.0130086094,
0.0268283524,
0.0665221363,
-0.0077309893,
0.0116196554,
0.0380247161,
0.0192953814,
0.0412062891,
-0.0227643531,
0.0306712128,
0.0430929065,
0.0073075825,
-0.0241364613,
-0.0132033201,
-0.0461175144,
-0.0300560724,
-0.0239276681,
-0.0834633783,
-0.0057247528,
0.0002411202,
-0.0014413423,
-0.0149521502,
0.030333288,
-0.0192023441,
-0.0290851016,
-0.0268593375,
0.0126245422,
-0.0520349927,
0.0189636927,
-0.0444145426,
0.0540613793,
-0.0133438502,
-0.0185978096,
-0.0090291649,
0.0004192533,
0.0227744412,
0.0282318648,
0.012054815,
-0.0170911029,
0.047025118,
-0.0889647454,
-0.0141116129,
0.0163197238,
0.0292534921,
-0.0159649514,
-0.022342721,
-0.009802077,
-0.0429006293,
0.0207030904,
-0.0294488482,
-0.0683861598,
0.0092179012,
0.0462189242,
0.0364056863,
-0.0035158671,
-0.0297189727,
-0.0031644742,
-0.0337881483,
0.0158699751,
0.0564249195,
-0.0704048276,
-0.0387815982,
-0.0201538466,
-0.0405603871,
-0.0097094662,
0.0192924459,
0.0191973168,
0.0455474742,
0.0446559712,
-0.0222125482,
0.025644416,
-0.0761636943,
0.0099075865,
0.0724735335,
-0.0085285716,
-0.0129800746,
-0.0127813453,
0.0131251263,
0.0378691144,
0.029111987,
-0.0308868419,
0.021250423,
-0.0004592738,
-0.0467419103,
0.0133527312,
-0.0074778539,
-0.0130657284,
-0.0165155139,
0.0036359308,
-0.0284508634,
-0.0302621406,
-0.0172458515,
0.0196284894,
-0.0179046411,
-0.0553845465,
0.0228953026,
-0.0094650425,
0.0001474891,
0.0033883261,
-0.0103543643,
-0.0195030589,
0.0185786728,
-0.0245600659,
-0.0162002984,
0.0118419463,
-0.0012485589,
0.0142514706,
-0.0063608256,
0.0817698017,
-0.0090453336,
0.0112005137,
-0.0575473607,
0.0240014717,
0.0002013729,
-0.0083009889,
-0.0005462776,
0.0563176088,
-0.0246358924,
0.0369963609,
-0.0051284535,
-0.0059523121,
-0.0091725038,
0.0213612765,
0.0312397443,
0.0768703893,
0.0107611399,
-0.0172437094,
0.0021142871,
-0.0666121319,
-0.0457330309,
-0.0051919855,
-0.0155805685,
0.0076120561,
-0.0155566558,
0.0232133083,
-0.0426410027,
0.0006827245,
-0.0594550706,
0.0172464605,
-0.0174213573,
-0.0331311375,
-0.0368327573,
0.0551337488,
0.0657437891,
-0.0836532786,
0.0154466769,
0.0526420251,
0.0374853872,
-0.0357601382,
-0.0036852281,
0.018392453,
-0.0125855226,
0.0173652135,
0.0198513865,
-0.0586988069,
0.0013936113,
-0.0042225551,
0.0613814332,
-0.0251935814,
-0.0296940636,
0.0058941268,
0.0009583384,
0.0751293525,
-0.007923875,
-0.0799845606,
-0.0036244213,
-0.0540458187,
-0.0037827012,
-0.0510087386,
-0.0076299384,
-0.0201710686,
-0.0113067972,
-0.0036300244,
0.0572491139,
-0.1107807979,
-0.0542572401,
-0.0375701264,
-0.0383578762,
0.103560701,
0.0820180923,
0.0042696358,
0.0058335243,
0.0219631344,
0.0578188971,
0.0000307169,
0.03030462,
-0.0586307421,
0.0773544759,
0.0011238562,
0.0176838301,
-0.0082432823,
-0.0032781854,
0.0053060227,
-0.0534066148,
0.003600654,
0.0684062093,
-0.0519487411,
0.0428485349,
-0.0186678842,
0.001262367,
0.0273344386,
0.0397258699,
0.0482979454,
-0.0055702729,
0.0049614566,
-0.0419244468,
0.0293035731,
-0.0736839622,
0.0129668964,
-0.0138935521,
-0.1003868207,
-0.0381846875,
-0.0619181171,
-0.0687850043,
0.0617420673,
0.024077937,
0.0333154388,
0.0116393771,
-0.024586888,
-0.0053587668,
-0.0650215149,
0.0545190871,
-0.0095612397,
-0.0135246366,
0.0329873152,
-0.0412346423,
0.0004392953,
0.0323959589,
-0.0101428917,
0.0801280513,
-0.0194096155,
0.0124972202,
0.0269848611,
0.0687332302,
0.0263456199,
-0.0017795588,
0.0288220458,
-0.0591810346,
-0.0241137389,
0.0391747244,
0.0048334864,
-0.047044646,
0.0164539274,
-0.0084906714,
-0.0162586514,
-0.0479062758,
-0.0310418699,
-0.0034499094,
-0.0035341079,
0.0035098572,
-0.0282890853,
-0.0361861922,
-0.0003427659,
-0.000531276,
0.0558123663,
-0.0074763051,
-0.0200633369,
-0.0510858633,
-0.0348759405,
-0.0269557331,
-0.0142445834,
-0.0331092589,
0.0792736411,
-0.0420717485,
-0.0234871767,
-0.0074188933,
0.0733169615,
-0.0260705445,
0.0211654101,
-0.100447759,
0.0112834396,
0.0139771244,
0.0131019372,
-0.0841333345,
0.0079671666,
-0.0308947265,
0.0316311233,
-0.0034238349,
0.0226921383,
0.0186861046,
0.0290363338,
0.0143095301,
0.0363610424,
-0.0162050482,
0.050868623,
-0.0222515985,
0.0171777066,
-0.0596576259,
0.0164798908,
0.0024835942,
0.0062504159,
0.0804843754,
-0.0398348086,
-0.0183009412,
-0.0208134577,
0.0783773586,
0.001657453,
0.0264911614,
-0.0445892401,
-0.0009004494,
-0.0300010331,
-0.0869209841,
0.0125009408,
-0.0062531298,
0.0044252463,
-0.0920188501,
-0.0701427534,
-0.056338653,
-0.0010608527,
0.0464084223,
0.0168554932,
-0.0408060253,
-0.0555645227,
-0.0442934968,
-0.0449753441,
0.029538352,
0.0270829499,
-0.0219772626,
0.0036637543,
0.0112894773,
-0.0026682215,
0.0059747766,
-0.1067144573,
-0.0068881027,
-0.0504409857,
-0.0343479738,
-0.0074864067,
-0.029390445,
-6.064309234e-33,
-0.0320188366,
-0.0094635058,
0.0330238156,
0.0256516915,
-0.0338670574,
0.0216190591,
-0.0099082962,
-0.0180531982,
0.0281651523,
0.0301446188,
0.0270536281,
-0.0063637323,
0.011644233,
-0.042796582,
0.0766037926,
-0.0187287182,
0.0584562868,
0.023306597,
-0.0306836572,
0.0014134246,
0.0125846379,
-0.0211436097,
0.0464795791,
-0.1058218926,
0.0533042587,
0.0276373606,
-0.0422031842,
-0.0274368804,
0.0314483643,
0.0665507615,
0.0012581255,
-0.0304039232,
0.0183328893,
-0.0037112918,
-0.0439890847,
0.0158169437,
-0.0667887181,
-0.0251694694,
0.0049786861,
-0.0007592897,
-0.0276053734,
-0.0467608571,
0.0213145278,
-0.0288772173,
0.006299356,
-0.0085886382,
0.0455192327,
-0.0194936451,
-0.0312013198,
-0.0279715583,
-0.0428595766,
0.03974865,
-0.0045849597,
0.003178512,
0.0301641226,
0.0583519377,
0.032403551,
-0.0306665059,
-0.0577900074,
0.00632325,
-0.0158885662,
-0.0236337688,
0.0518457256,
0.0432390086,
0.014778886,
0.0275530517,
-0.0284405034,
0.044975169,
0.0396090485,
0.0042937086,
-0.0006556378,
0.044432614,
0.0063844025,
0.0173803978,
0.0018616536,
0.0169286672,
-0.0584069081,
0.0709542185,
-0.0393040404,
-0.0055742948,
-0.022793781,
0.003075422,
-0.0730906799,
-0.0219904929,
-0.0274178479,
-0.0241810177,
0.001958251,
0.0041885586,
0.0312890038,
-0.0090345545,
-0.0540991351,
0.1145761758,
0.0103717996,
0.0072668525,
0.0217225682,
-0.0527022332,
0.0245697275,
0.018341003,
0.0055645811,
-0.0347183049,
-0.0369881205,
0.0015567471,
0.0521729253,
0.0317186378,
0.0695391595,
-0.0206203461,
0.0792523623,
0.0387142599,
-0.0366840214,
-0.0044079958,
0.016056845,
-0.0058522918,
-0.0307092387,
-0.0256593879,
0.0509392284,
0.0057920329,
-0.0027217851,
0.0456553772,
0.0055425027,
-0.0033931481,
-0.0068355338,
-0.0191126596,
-0.005161596,
-0.0293920301,
0.0193161555,
0.0134939104,
0.0082906131,
0.002249901,
0.0139554031,
-0.0172176082,
-0.0039828154,
0.0443006903,
2.752e-7,
0.0999339968,
0.0530004203,
0.0594761744,
0.0254229773,
-0.0058026323,
-0.0454029962,
0.014697196,
-0.0125623429,
-0.0103690764,
-0.0214074384,
0.0515220724,
-0.0035433681,
0.0242526475,
0.0419544727,
-0.0161476526,
-0.0728143305,
-0.0025880465,
-0.0190150868,
-0.0670465827,
-0.0097431997,
0.0210911725,
-0.007853006,
-0.0099936314,
0.0111599034,
0.0244190861,
-0.0114098396,
-0.0047568814,
-0.0424589626,
0.0355271362,
0.0349418856,
0.0649563223,
0.0190679487,
0.0096978489,
0.0470408089,
-0.0310671888,
-0.0369976908,
0.0130665526,
0.089263007,
-0.0303359348,
0.0109414617,
0.0157917514,
-0.0318995304,
0.0233320687,
-0.017127784,
-0.0086133406,
-0.0273062456,
0.0010566638,
-0.0143807372,
-0.0080366181,
0.0185835604,
0.0419647545,
-0.0083399685,
0.0454184897,
0.006812749,
-0.0082082851,
0.0139603578,
-0.0584991574,
0.000281008,
-0.0174486469,
0.0439334027,
-0.005991064,
-0.0560620762,
-0.0023177732,
-0.0503474213,
-0.0288724806,
-0.0580240004,
-0.0106381988,
2.643346544e-34,
0.0200432204,
-0.0548487194,
0.022854561,
0.0085319364,
0.0212039445,
0.0204643868,
0.0106771784,
0.0029781831,
0.0069709257,
-0.010964172,
-0.0102957292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14092v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14092v1 | Seamless Language Expansion: Enhancing Multilingual Mastery in Self-Supervised Models | 2024-06-20T08:13:30 | 2024-06-20T08:13:30 | Jing Xu, Minglin Wu, Xixin Wu, Helen Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Self-supervised (SSL) models have shown great performance in various
downstream tasks. However, they are typically developed for limited languages,
and may encounter new languages in real-world. Developing a SSL model for each
new language is costly. Thus, it is vital to figure out how to efficiently
adapt existed SSL models to a new language without impairing its original
abilities. We propose adaptation methods which integrate LoRA to existed SSL
models to extend new language. We also develop preservation strategies which
include data combination and re-clustering to retain abilities on existed
languages. Applied to mHuBERT, we investigate their effectiveness on speech
re-synthesis task. Experiments show that our adaptation methods enable mHuBERT
to be applied to a new language (Mandarin) with MOS value increased about 1.6
and the relative value of WER reduced up to 61.72%. Also, our preservation
strategies ensure that the performance on both existed and new languages
remains intact. | [
-0.0284269974,
0.0556630604,
-0.0094471853,
0.0058927797,
0.0045999275,
-0.0132769383,
0.053658735,
-0.0354085006,
0.0103644244,
0.0165909715,
-0.1077067032,
0.0079898462,
0.0042208252,
0.0080429362,
0.0409022719,
-0.0579550415,
0.0235058106,
-0.068322733,
-0.066813305,
-0.0553791076,
-0.0454824045,
0.0386757143,
-0.0168253109,
0.015503373,
0.0129111251,
0.0021466725,
-0.012898271,
-0.0039623776,
0.0134587809,
0.023276899,
-0.0426206216,
0.0691852048,
0.029039111,
0.0134891253,
0.000001973,
-0.0581947677,
-0.0362918712,
-0.0180068202,
-0.0272225589,
0.0129568307,
0.0591401495,
-0.0053858366,
-0.0368745811,
0.0406012014,
-0.0138889477,
-0.0145718018,
0.0168035869,
-0.0046632984,
0.0373001136,
0.0468092412,
-0.0220895186,
-0.0442119129,
-0.029102562,
-0.0280107725,
-0.0213422328,
-0.0086796712,
0.0172115155,
0.0166440811,
-0.0248538163,
-0.069878608,
-0.0463773645,
0.0645987839,
0.0258127432,
-0.0269640554,
0.0036285447,
-0.013553814,
-0.0007280138,
-0.0266120452,
0.0028012583,
0.0154074654,
-0.0437231809,
-0.0254280455,
0.0073336028,
0.0143193696,
0.0165518615,
0.0140732853,
-0.047376927,
-0.0140815778,
0.0363170244,
0.0152000599,
0.0013658276,
-0.0156267677,
0.0262680575,
-0.01931349,
-0.0303121358,
0.0577037185,
0.0378900357,
0.0011993763,
-0.0020915426,
-0.0169339925,
0.0492265001,
-0.0129001848,
0.0240091477,
0.0231326558,
0.008244344,
0.012190802,
-0.0514644869,
-0.0132580036,
-0.0137378555,
-0.0159340538,
0.0288150255,
0.0327640064,
-0.039943561,
0.010007333,
-0.0598372407,
0.0055140937,
-0.0022799019,
0.0061083282,
-0.0520939864,
0.0023265255,
-0.0318655483,
-0.0078090029,
-0.0362430364,
0.0523108467,
-0.031998869,
0.0304075107,
-0.0533968844,
0.0266248398,
-0.0033511159,
-0.0095692873,
-0.0000628983,
-0.0361913145,
-0.069813095,
-0.0273139589,
0.0022714697,
0.0533352718,
0.0164422616,
0.0377218761,
0.0131281503,
-0.0467764102,
-0.0076710838,
0.023290053,
0.0117858918,
-0.0015462078,
0.0244446155,
0.0807812214,
-0.030952774,
0.0075721433,
-0.0592540093,
-0.0122520421,
-0.0494589508,
-0.0225975439,
0.0171010699,
-0.0518305115,
0.0161223598,
-0.040985059,
0.0064382213,
-0.0563486814,
-0.0467955321,
-0.0489553437,
0.0314089507,
0.0138370842,
-0.0273821466,
0.0253158063,
0.0495708063,
-0.0004103502,
0.0030238652,
0.0748001337,
0.022320373,
0.0023344243,
-0.0014485837,
-0.0450427867,
0.0188799128,
0.0513476804,
-0.0150726195,
0.0241055619,
-0.0542906895,
-0.023006605,
0.0048115193,
-0.0021900004,
0.0799216256,
-0.0168129969,
-0.0397220738,
-0.0121114654,
0.04592181,
0.0478188135,
0.0928639397,
0.0485226363,
0.0516288839,
-0.0300903022,
0.0069841929,
0.0377087444,
-0.0072554145,
0.0413185433,
-0.0411991216,
0.0163096879,
0.0071008392,
0.0789342597,
-0.0623488054,
-0.0705593005,
0.0188648552,
-0.0198346525,
-0.0225516092,
0.0069944654,
0.0690831244,
0.0690022707,
0.0143129323,
0.0232586265,
0.0476312153,
-0.0889646411,
0.0840768665,
-0.0648085624,
0.0049268277,
0.0701925606,
0.0161620341,
-0.0154375732,
-0.0334975645,
-0.0209767185,
-0.0345616825,
0.0373228751,
0.0117688347,
0.0078894477,
0.0826170221,
-0.0716094449,
-0.0225347634,
-0.0151767051,
-0.0136013934,
0.0535229705,
-0.035367243,
0.0186352227,
-0.0005379918,
-0.0533898585,
0.0166599136,
0.0102392612,
-0.0738143101,
-0.0012855108,
0.0324704945,
0.0288475901,
0.0179903898,
0.0423933156,
-0.0045188488,
-0.0071568177,
0.0055523608,
-0.0272384509,
-0.0563031882,
0.0413313508,
-0.0737763047,
-0.0433411412,
0.0220601223,
0.0104780765,
0.013292932,
0.0185334589,
0.0235980805,
-0.0877150744,
0.0661242679,
0.0107399179,
0.0319332927,
-0.0501654707,
0.031585414,
0.0208984483,
0.0407106429,
-0.0071608122,
0.0014311476,
0.0284818243,
-0.0570850335,
-0.0098027457,
-0.0128273694,
0.0275174715,
-0.0639331192,
-0.0044398955,
0.0139083769,
-0.0246882085,
0.0451913401,
0.0132910982,
0.0076504308,
-0.0257409867,
-0.0582085289,
-0.0234120246,
-0.0142759942,
-0.0288207959,
0.0245856997,
0.0260636155,
0.0481379069,
-0.0174528006,
-0.0411252417,
-0.025139492,
-0.0514752157,
-0.0071238386,
-0.0031003808,
-0.0261056069,
0.0074131652,
-0.015047227,
-0.0121737691,
-0.0081817713,
0.0308324806,
0.0065280353,
-0.0522761084,
-0.0106341615,
-0.0500662848,
-0.0040096184,
-0.0499107465,
0.0207485221,
0.0044301916,
-0.0190990996,
-0.0034262955,
-0.0076884101,
0.0693291351,
0.0483439378,
-0.020600481,
-0.0113136414,
0.0913990811,
-0.0094401026,
-0.0173376482,
-0.0072877817,
0.0016450008,
-0.0153748095,
-0.0500523113,
0.0315875076,
-0.0273239966,
0.0105756717,
0.0314562991,
-0.0231751837,
-0.0747453421,
-0.0472925492,
0.0046938956,
-0.0726451203,
-0.0150505928,
0.0048156604,
-0.009055635,
0.0008115681,
-0.0035653906,
-0.0300138928,
0.032185629,
-0.0294704828,
-0.0381102003,
-0.0398887917,
-0.0548283756,
-0.0142285712,
-0.0054720901,
-0.0440051667,
0.0239627957,
-0.0396180153,
-0.0399790518,
-0.0508942455,
0.0040810956,
0.0215970669,
-0.028408533,
0.0211365167,
-0.0584973916,
0.0000077665,
0.0090297358,
-0.0324877538,
-0.0230058804,
0.0358102359,
0.0289313495,
-0.0128764985,
-0.0313197821,
0.0070066079,
-0.0126853064,
0.0095433416,
0.0475693718,
0.0797136202,
-0.001942376,
0.01289107,
-0.0146562699,
0.01266101,
0.0218616538,
0.0484922305,
-0.0151898358,
-0.0305704549,
0.0578771345,
-0.0096063074,
0.0866371989,
-0.0344565324,
-0.0347473174,
0.0508938059,
0.0296426006,
0.0004311611,
0.0019775769,
0.0197547078,
0.0576535091,
-0.0042327433,
0.0263477955,
0.066050142,
-0.0099041592,
-0.0108180149,
-0.01251652,
-0.0649268627,
0.0459191911,
0.0206441134,
0.0040156739,
-0.008993784,
0.0058216639,
0.0111842658,
0.0018830209,
0.0418389291,
0.0228314418,
0.0101036392,
-0.1097435281,
0.0545641109,
0.0456997231,
-0.0829653665,
-0.024624737,
-0.0334416479,
-0.0204613898,
-0.0365101136,
0.0580220968,
0.0115571674,
-0.0269804057,
-0.0302633047,
0.0394946933,
-0.0526106916,
-0.0592287816,
-0.0089524398,
-0.0143173924,
0.0746276751,
0.0411607288,
-0.0070469682,
0.0015903829,
0.001255468,
0.0202868227,
-0.0048000338,
0.0077564768,
-0.0086788023,
0.0401945077,
0.0599312931,
-0.0128834508,
0.0199687462,
0.0538514741,
-0.0191836134,
-0.0100971814,
0.009489012,
0.0382337868,
0.0145431794,
-0.0086366767,
0.0185116846,
0.0049138283,
-0.0296568852,
0.0230358206,
0.0291667897,
-0.0491853803,
0.0369567648,
0.0010606404,
-0.0172860064,
-0.0382284522,
-0.0139241172,
0.0556544252,
-0.0335627683,
-0.0489651859,
-0.0369889028,
-0.0305927917,
0.027771065,
0.0694583729,
0.0191461071,
0.0525194146,
-0.0083952369,
-0.0137000857,
-0.0144510604,
0.0126848398,
-0.0420767441,
-0.0169932991,
-0.0391288511,
-0.0413866639,
0.0196424797,
-0.0669618249,
0.0035275507,
-0.0129685532,
-0.0207171813,
-0.0692199618,
0.0165859219,
0.0552387014,
0.0254671425,
0.0845272765,
0.0018198803,
-0.051080633,
0.1123835444,
0.0114729553,
-0.0284752417,
0.0443274751,
0.0585511737,
0.0014183916,
-0.0031452533,
0.030238336,
-0.0377552509,
0.0415608287,
-0.0036642586,
0.0130266072,
-0.0073576327,
-0.0167340115,
0.0142672732,
0.0277075451,
0.0125321737,
-0.0400594696,
0.0651694685,
-0.0502474159,
0.0205512643,
-0.0440620258,
0.0480926745,
-0.0325819254,
-0.0042712879,
0.0495024361,
0.0127205215,
0.015022628,
-0.0002735496,
-0.0321231633,
-0.0466901809,
-0.0108179161,
-0.0074412278,
-0.0020097988,
0.0448167287,
0.0075443909,
0.0478658602,
0.0142550757,
0.0446020439,
0.0258842912,
-0.0103522772,
-0.0158682391,
-0.022362059,
-0.0222998131,
0.0244973302,
-0.026296718,
0.0486767702,
-0.0267123636,
-0.050312493,
-0.0543972068,
-0.0055952999,
0.0616975948,
0.0065473248,
0.1198430657,
0.0133010149,
0.0079702688,
-0.0263613686,
0.018075034,
-0.0231111348,
0.0127212498,
-0.0130617805,
-0.0243417453,
-0.0149252573,
0.0112969028,
0.0532968082,
-0.0102911191,
0.0377562419,
-0.0076157623,
0.0669442192,
-0.0379720442,
-0.0601337291,
0.0077611902,
-0.0238857176,
-0.0251248088,
-0.0174758732,
0.0152679859,
-0.0960744992,
0.0300809033,
0.0170746073,
0.008412973,
0.0115478653,
0.0289383829,
0.0223432835,
-0.0544733256,
0.012311344,
-0.0212206747,
-0.0288062003,
0.0565355048,
-0.0176637564,
0.1000623479,
-6.429491983e-33,
-0.0396868214,
0.0320473909,
0.042678725,
-0.0165534969,
0.0056007244,
-0.0553642474,
-0.0259438846,
0.039681863,
0.0157594886,
0.0069321087,
0.0011294886,
-0.0097943591,
0.0302789211,
0.0194405336,
0.0365300588,
0.049989406,
0.0727827251,
-0.0020747187,
0.0099272449,
0.0016737373,
0.0188204888,
0.0306964293,
0.0644773245,
-0.0286408775,
-0.0691438988,
0.0421527363,
-0.0131995156,
-0.0145618059,
-0.0174181089,
0.0547650158,
0.0054916744,
0.0643540323,
0.0001246984,
-0.0089640338,
-0.0504060611,
-0.0347039141,
-0.0677194297,
-0.0375305228,
-0.0142042469,
0.0143334046,
-0.048843991,
-0.0179214031,
0.0674875453,
0.0102343233,
-0.0280255247,
-0.0232152957,
0.0364864469,
-0.0323537514,
-0.0257074069,
0.0257285684,
-0.0463704579,
0.028552087,
0.0047599659,
-0.011794718,
0.0727212876,
0.0475297198,
-0.032055974,
-0.0545701571,
-0.0458701141,
0.02922244,
-0.0268744305,
0.0621546134,
0.0666103885,
0.0135655999,
-0.0230145603,
0.0057054721,
0.0594229959,
-0.0304735471,
0.0647619292,
-0.0096579138,
0.0704843774,
0.0234877076,
0.0026569683,
0.0440868922,
-0.020213604,
-0.0465069674,
-0.0396705084,
0.0299029816,
-0.0133651309,
-0.0170405917,
-0.0223939512,
0.0498738401,
0.0320021473,
0.0020507893,
-0.0529064536,
-0.027670268,
-0.0254094172,
-0.0229138657,
0.0378861316,
0.0180083476,
-0.015888324,
-0.0321887173,
0.0496119931,
0.0027984253,
0.0072529083,
-0.0382100716,
-0.0772284269,
-0.0140225776,
0.0125132371,
0.0601707846,
-0.0132765174,
-0.0462898985,
0.0368649699,
0.0213158745,
-0.0085986974,
-0.0009832899,
0.0012045836,
0.0739448071,
-0.0753884017,
0.0111705754,
-0.0066508548,
0.0075204344,
0.0555651449,
-0.0236554667,
0.0062774681,
-0.0275923889,
-0.0062590968,
0.0210794583,
0.0071573746,
-0.0257715583,
-0.0101817073,
0.0221235044,
0.0357753411,
0.0225681569,
-0.0197024997,
0.0025118494,
-0.01129256,
-0.0359407552,
0.0738637894,
-0.0425324067,
-0.0210933872,
-0.0049589132,
2.823e-7,
0.0083645647,
0.0032098049,
0.0064861747,
-0.0411783829,
0.0133824097,
0.0116366539,
-0.0707968175,
0.0162231345,
0.0040013022,
0.0410975441,
0.0004608326,
0.0363147072,
0.0627801865,
0.0044299806,
-0.0286526326,
0.0281937551,
-0.0327332355,
0.0622791983,
-0.0267036427,
-0.0078101689,
-0.0519023165,
0.0414120518,
-0.0070296736,
-0.0239913575,
0.0009250809,
-0.003395444,
0.039062921,
0.0036981616,
-0.0372523144,
0.0211313739,
0.0191985127,
0.0322772376,
-0.0230827797,
-0.0042197881,
-0.0322890133,
0.0509606078,
0.0091775935,
0.0309167411,
-0.0336737148,
-0.0441978835,
0.0667327568,
0.075335443,
-0.0336012021,
0.0028093378,
0.0285742935,
-0.0167936254,
-0.0227533039,
-0.0054149972,
-0.0318912901,
0.0361671187,
0.0527275987,
-0.022837311,
-0.0137097565,
0.0442081876,
0.032708969,
0.0383806974,
-0.0256963037,
-0.0452420413,
0.0029144958,
0.0298563,
-0.0663742125,
-0.0077899196,
-0.031873025,
-0.0073252125,
-0.0135532115,
-0.0125326402,
0.0176043212,
2.161350009e-34,
-0.0066143787,
-0.0136449756,
0.0277698468,
-0.0090486221,
0.0003868828,
-0.0540734716,
-0.0461414903,
0.0379661508,
-0.0257498156,
-0.0406901278,
-0.0478278995
] |
Subsets and Splits