id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15796v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15796v1 | Rethinking Entity-level Unlearning for Large Language Models | 2024-06-22T09:40:07 | 2024-06-22T09:40:07 | Weitao Ma, Xiaocheng Feng, Weihong Zhong, Lei Huang, Yangfan Ye, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language model unlearning has gained increasing attention due to its
potential to mitigate security and privacy concerns. Current research
predominantly focuses on Instance-level unlearning, specifically aiming at
forgetting predefined instances of sensitive content. However, a notable gap
still exists in exploring the deletion of complete entity-related information,
which is crucial in many real-world scenarios, such as copyright protection. To
this end, we propose a novel task of Entity-level unlearning, where the
entity-related knowledge within the target model is supposed to be entirely
erased. Given the challenge of practically accessing all entity-related
knowledge within a model, we begin by simulating entity-level unlearning
scenarios through fine-tuning models to introduce pseudo entities. Following
this, we develop baseline methods inspired by trending unlearning techniques
and conduct a detailed comparison of their effectiveness in this task.
Extensive experiments reveal that current unlearning algorithms struggle to
achieve effective entity-level unlearning. Additionally, our analyses further
indicate that entity-related knowledge injected through fine-tuning is more
susceptible than original entities from pre-training during unlearning,
highlighting the necessity for more thorough pseudo-entity injection methods to
make them closer to pre-trained knowledge. | [
0.0313618518,
0.1051269174,
-0.0064273989,
0.0770784616,
-0.0416627824,
0.0123695405,
0.0478566028,
0.0231707525,
0.0151826572,
-0.0299243052,
-0.0157906674,
0.0094765229,
-0.031576436,
0.0043361168,
0.018187793,
0.0199049339,
0.0263141692,
-0.0090548918,
0.0050700158,
-0.0353836454,
-0.0064113261,
0.0029987751,
0.0258976948,
-0.0237058382,
0.0066681905,
-0.0201365445,
-0.0385694429,
0.0067977277,
0.0026474567,
0.0372372121,
0.0004116164,
0.0406453423,
0.0306095257,
0.0626351833,
0.0000019994,
-0.0412012264,
-0.0754916742,
0.0363815762,
-0.0581821427,
0.0782210827,
-0.0024287947,
-0.0271524619,
-0.0275468249,
-0.0099805389,
0.0036967194,
-0.0045189052,
0.0327850096,
0.0443688706,
0.0625285804,
0.0865410268,
-0.0198695716,
-0.0181724168,
0.0076756561,
-0.0283537786,
-0.0163184814,
-0.0582049005,
0.0601755381,
-0.0415449142,
-0.0493046343,
-0.006195826,
-0.0008697743,
0.0389961675,
0.0177826229,
0.0239378754,
-0.0078819254,
0.0108463401,
-0.0286422055,
0.0279006306,
0.0032698181,
0.0224373955,
-0.0111404061,
-0.0329076499,
0.0462553725,
0.0125174774,
0.0229954887,
0.0119221555,
0.003619934,
0.0045656445,
-0.0002573577,
0.017104039,
-0.009709565,
-0.0562545545,
0.0659278929,
0.0009890599,
-0.0107588861,
0.0227597822,
0.035145551,
-0.0309742764,
-0.0063693523,
-0.0586055107,
0.0091974176,
-0.0516639613,
0.0256840866,
0.013510786,
0.0041658119,
0.0240866933,
-0.0401500575,
0.0229929201,
0.0149205504,
-0.0347151384,
0.0439199954,
-0.0069964351,
0.0185762718,
0.0878379121,
-0.0054165213,
0.0297242571,
-0.0119817974,
0.035163708,
0.0281631071,
0.0025655604,
-0.0353865027,
-0.0266412776,
0.0011256152,
0.0824516788,
0.0138647547,
0.0307568237,
-0.0100663062,
-0.0040460979,
-0.0295225699,
0.0541560948,
-0.0378132612,
-0.0151328202,
-0.0010438975,
-0.0214541461,
-0.0090462044,
-0.0029016072,
-0.020740388,
0.0000412662,
-0.0145368492,
-0.0506157875,
-0.0140304165,
-0.0471488833,
-0.0044988394,
-0.0225105602,
0.0255169738,
0.0958658606,
0.0229805782,
-0.0292226523,
-0.0754202157,
-0.0577360243,
0.0170124322,
-0.0537695996,
-0.0157304574,
-0.0546807237,
-0.0001160853,
-0.0247152261,
-0.0252669305,
-0.1038282588,
-0.0214953367,
-0.028830491,
-0.0858089849,
0.0424371548,
-0.0342641473,
-0.0055701705,
-0.0053101089,
0.012641957,
0.0117465304,
0.0417244546,
-0.0359465443,
0.0267125778,
0.0445163734,
-0.0314896703,
0.0409809947,
0.0525113121,
0.0274607241,
0.0240473058,
-0.0398810059,
-0.008577208,
0.0331032388,
-0.059061788,
-0.0039511975,
0.0485836975,
-0.0162359811,
-0.0354870893,
0.0571635216,
-0.0206360929,
-0.0331804045,
0.0466682352,
-0.0102572059,
0.0097817499,
-0.0001248681,
0.0342401862,
-0.0715162307,
-0.0077455728,
-0.0559275933,
-0.0212068968,
-0.0175106712,
0.0376310535,
-0.0314777792,
-0.0114391996,
0.028172316,
-0.0352106094,
0.013111772,
0.0291634984,
0.0409139656,
0.0741244331,
0.0018542364,
0.0781438351,
0.0454620719,
-0.0525792129,
0.0169163141,
-0.0216620285,
-0.0171211045,
0.0587921999,
0.0703497902,
-0.0579505228,
-0.0050791474,
-0.0006167064,
-0.0108180428,
-0.0081364205,
0.0089256437,
-0.0213890169,
0.0586946905,
-0.0309240445,
-0.0454466492,
0.01178673,
0.0475191325,
0.0023028837,
0.021154549,
-0.0448433422,
0.0205450654,
-0.0515234284,
-0.0043187868,
0.0130558526,
-0.0551700592,
-0.0445769429,
-0.0091482792,
0.0231433082,
-0.0205695797,
0.038041193,
-0.0270759892,
-0.0122138076,
0.0268838573,
0.0360311829,
-0.0207068417,
-0.0604370907,
0.0137988674,
0.027460156,
0.0360175446,
0.0079125166,
0.011674515,
0.02974228,
0.0017452126,
0.0104839783,
0.0088738762,
0.0128523428,
0.0836342424,
-0.0101369005,
0.0474854559,
-0.0600647703,
-0.0159498528,
-0.0064185159,
0.0437412858,
-0.0043831267,
-0.0127187381,
0.0052302396,
-0.0494193695,
-0.0027451133,
-0.0154736787,
-0.0572099946,
0.0059802746,
-0.0235421173,
0.0289413556,
0.024735976,
-0.03727258,
-0.0350407809,
-0.024099756,
-0.0406424925,
0.0018818976,
0.0007540637,
0.026834907,
0.0094045559,
0.0253929961,
-0.0182607193,
-0.034718655,
-0.0144063467,
-0.03213441,
-0.0693142414,
0.0452729575,
0.0037193631,
-0.0151819633,
-0.0550770722,
0.0154349431,
-0.014013188,
-0.0072802585,
0.0638311431,
-0.0422532149,
-0.005951643,
0.0164627209,
0.0927930921,
-0.0442049652,
0.0254193749,
0.0124350134,
-0.0294974986,
-0.0251079835,
0.0001627638,
-0.0335293375,
0.0379739255,
-0.0286850594,
0.0539548248,
0.0359365717,
-0.0192718506,
-0.0186325572,
-0.0054139681,
-0.0267242417,
-0.0329914615,
-0.0454265252,
0.0312913358,
0.0063777515,
0.0275233183,
0.0063960883,
-0.0241414923,
-0.0298547056,
0.0568604134,
-0.0128027191,
-0.0379008912,
-0.0250068475,
-0.0091605624,
0.011724229,
0.0137336934,
-0.0172765069,
-0.04334905,
0.041639246,
0.0040526488,
0.0552255176,
0.0090406854,
-0.0020046802,
-0.0093625234,
0.0418495275,
0.0060938955,
0.0517261662,
0.0474541821,
-0.0384185277,
-0.0465490706,
0.0178931486,
0.0441340506,
-0.0350788608,
-0.0026769242,
-0.0228895359,
-0.0287355203,
0.0290434882,
-0.0481792241,
-0.0154352849,
-0.0256080236,
0.0048282309,
0.0125965653,
-0.0120419255,
-0.0287677888,
0.0003224393,
-0.0572896898,
0.0196524151,
-0.0038301754,
0.0243763365,
0.0111029502,
-0.0199276824,
0.0267483294,
-0.0041477098,
-0.0502956696,
-0.02268105,
-0.0157456007,
0.0173838474,
0.0887867957,
0.0302792136,
-0.0196387079,
0.02662999,
0.0213307571,
0.0035391501,
-0.0362636447,
-0.012391408,
0.0238496009,
0.0072001289,
-0.0422718711,
-0.0139140273,
0.0857898742,
0.0240298063,
-0.0134706758,
-0.0081851659,
0.0624663346,
0.0005825416,
0.0189250596,
0.0049200878,
-0.1042103842,
-0.0016531056,
0.012797026,
0.0090525812,
0.0068292776,
-0.0562801063,
0.0096238386,
-0.0977557972,
0.0001602849,
0.0371228158,
-0.0317642018,
-0.0279467311,
-0.0396138579,
0.0131486095,
-0.0340931453,
-0.0143214427,
-0.0241813939,
0.0048437039,
0.0017008726,
-0.0100148544,
0.0074001262,
-0.0441257395,
0.0188699253,
-0.0651616752,
0.0435008742,
0.0456486493,
0.0146170314,
-0.0263676178,
-0.0014452646,
-0.0037915455,
-0.0016773236,
-0.0196240991,
0.0198640246,
0.0675873011,
-0.0031302962,
-0.0133358818,
0.0010966886,
0.0636164322,
0.0165510159,
-0.0453228988,
0.0075078658,
0.0636686981,
0.0276407916,
-0.0086358944,
0.0145981405,
-0.0724053606,
0.0157066863,
0.0687169954,
0.0086058872,
-0.0443508476,
-0.0050451695,
-0.027628446,
0.0222282838,
0.0259884149,
0.0089730741,
0.0052862512,
-0.0396021232,
-0.0281612556,
-0.0414209217,
0.0022819105,
0.0030490577,
0.0060579008,
0.0691007823,
0.0252326969,
0.0653760508,
-0.0208461322,
-0.0583337918,
-0.0618743077,
-0.0859923512,
0.0118840653,
-0.0059271744,
-0.0199582465,
0.0023689899,
0.022276273,
-0.0141220242,
-0.0139986677,
-0.0683077872,
-0.0947490111,
0.0433770604,
0.0087650232,
0.0227782819,
0.05176723,
-0.0238628965,
-0.0551111437,
0.0887923911,
0.0443727151,
-0.0620876178,
0.0099596381,
0.0413098,
-0.0307750367,
-0.0005895685,
0.0526120439,
-0.043719653,
-0.0063853106,
0.1032189652,
-0.0260567646,
-0.0355427526,
-0.0130987531,
0.0117746759,
0.0482072271,
0.0130203972,
0.0362644605,
0.018780563,
-0.0051959432,
0.0407355838,
0.0073894449,
-0.0391982682,
-0.0014418372,
-0.0124666989,
0.0445376784,
0.0484067872,
0.0200167224,
0.027668532,
0.0515677556,
0.033721216,
-0.0131420568,
-0.0457622372,
0.0408547185,
-0.0013729752,
0.0573161617,
-0.0071632508,
0.0168447047,
0.0532181822,
0.0202237163,
0.0398205146,
-0.0353047214,
0.0420107879,
0.0118134664,
0.0256225392,
-0.0434034504,
0.0000780025,
-0.0023731303,
-0.0209444501,
-0.0239266455,
0.0482358746,
0.0285503697,
-0.0283555519,
-0.0102111138,
-0.0217591133,
-0.0289084036,
-0.0281137694,
-0.0097035123,
0.0026578309,
-0.0408446826,
-0.0115557062,
0.0194062982,
-0.0334749855,
0.0674271435,
0.0650363564,
-0.013378432,
0.089111656,
-0.0071481848,
-0.0044353707,
-0.0701102018,
-0.0180201065,
0.0279145446,
-0.0081191631,
-0.0127964383,
-0.0128468312,
-0.0630020201,
-0.0615010038,
-0.0117766662,
-0.0108861849,
0.0087015862,
-0.0044326219,
-0.0019588894,
0.0605494045,
0.0135760233,
-0.0018427767,
-0.083779864,
-0.02487332,
0.0043839323,
-0.044611834,
0.0298789013,
-5.701055031e-33,
0.0191167779,
0.0026933372,
-0.0402747467,
0.0380541272,
0.0248682741,
0.0147730969,
0.0015096196,
-0.0205298793,
-0.0209512338,
0.0003857153,
-0.0326931402,
0.0078698453,
-0.0009633523,
0.0129707865,
-0.0389959849,
-0.0095426617,
0.0507694632,
-0.0138291474,
-0.0275072269,
0.0455944575,
0.0525511689,
0.0435463637,
0.0450811833,
-0.0863623098,
0.0011544663,
-0.0062884628,
-0.0482826307,
0.0378178209,
-0.018616084,
0.0463279709,
-0.0346371531,
0.0003656988,
-0.0068074446,
-0.0561680757,
0.0014843972,
-0.0070587941,
-0.0810377523,
0.0227170736,
-0.0275955535,
0.0063461168,
0.0329777822,
-0.0777740255,
0.0172083229,
-0.0295263585,
0.0085689584,
-0.0160942432,
0.0006862026,
-0.0071281302,
-0.0094111804,
-0.0507710688,
-0.0300126374,
0.0030840221,
-0.0395223573,
-0.0048756036,
0.06937626,
-0.0639075711,
0.025105428,
-0.0294975042,
-0.066490218,
0.0233054738,
0.0590679124,
0.0157728288,
0.0388929844,
-0.004347859,
-0.0011192738,
0.0776040927,
0.0432148501,
0.0369850285,
0.030424336,
0.028309837,
0.0237017516,
0.0424612425,
-0.006298271,
0.0520802625,
0.0437379591,
-0.0361203663,
-0.0364111662,
0.0110873086,
-0.0579330698,
0.0208373461,
0.0174850412,
0.0434338748,
-0.028652614,
-0.0191587117,
-0.0641047359,
-0.0111752339,
-0.0558394045,
-0.0205723979,
0.0086669168,
-0.0142226843,
-0.0683936179,
0.0155050466,
-0.0018608927,
-0.0593905263,
-0.0509608649,
0.067360118,
0.0142781464,
0.0015136473,
-0.0117168864,
-0.0054159155,
-0.054872185,
-0.0292963963,
0.0134650795,
-0.0476765335,
0.0188583452,
-0.0008799917,
0.0702904314,
0.0621364005,
-0.066299364,
0.000653571,
-0.0281421747,
0.0331121385,
0.0510466918,
0.0225630179,
-0.0108951572,
0.0123420972,
0.0189054776,
-0.0277099647,
0.0856922343,
-0.0031273435,
-0.0523677431,
0.0735360682,
0.008168363,
-0.0088180667,
0.0261034742,
-0.0310892276,
0.0014413748,
0.005679707,
0.0603444912,
-0.02385737,
-0.0013923001,
-0.0076376395,
2.695e-7,
0.0023301556,
-0.0050941906,
0.0393610261,
-0.0133894421,
0.0261330791,
0.0776080564,
-0.0125161558,
0.0484911799,
-0.0133458981,
-0.0298191048,
-0.0026686299,
0.0037344499,
0.0401609279,
0.0074738516,
-0.102396749,
0.0030497238,
-0.0120838257,
-0.0247503761,
-0.0596868657,
0.0000961599,
-0.0081053525,
0.100367859,
0.0535517409,
-0.0467607677,
-0.0065094917,
-0.0281208344,
0.0293101668,
-0.0318373181,
-0.0218787435,
0.014642084,
-0.0174534637,
0.0575039014,
0.0042509777,
0.0161479488,
-0.038128797,
0.0242449269,
-0.0078732623,
0.0714331791,
0.055208154,
0.0112071671,
-0.0275335871,
-0.0377392955,
-0.0096043106,
-0.0130435312,
0.0755490139,
0.0130084204,
-0.0508023202,
-0.0018562694,
-0.0247069206,
-0.0537897013,
0.0206111278,
-0.0021975411,
-0.0271128416,
0.0182306636,
-0.0110891359,
0.0166894756,
-0.012882106,
-0.058397539,
-0.0213421881,
-0.0191496648,
-0.0298789553,
-0.0253144894,
0.0344353616,
-0.0178974234,
-0.0096568819,
-0.0994516015,
0.072166793,
2.416383151e-34,
-0.0255385637,
-0.0380131081,
0.0069951359,
0.0207558814,
0.024317259,
-0.03101632,
-0.0083973976,
0.0148413191,
-0.0134139359,
-0.0343372673,
0.0209620427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15786v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15786v1 | What Matters in Transformers? Not All Attention is Needed | 2024-06-22T08:41:48 | 2024-06-22T08:41:48 | Shwai He, Guoheng Sun, Zheyu Shen, Ang Li | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Scaling Transformer-based large language models (LLMs) has demonstrated
promising performance across various tasks. However, this scaling also
introduces redundant structures, posing challenges for real-world deployment.
Despite some recognition of redundancy in LLMs, the variability of redundancy
across different structures, such as MLP and Attention layers, is
under-explored. In this work, we investigate the varying redundancy across
different modules within Transformers, including Blocks, MLP, and Attention
layers, using a similarity-based metric. This metric operates on the premise
that redundant structures produce outputs highly similar to their inputs.
Surprisingly, while attention layers are essential for transformers and
distinguish them from other mainstream architectures, we found that a large
proportion of attention layers exhibit excessively high similarity and can be
safely pruned without degrading performance, leading to reduced memory and
computation costs. Additionally, we further propose a method that jointly drops
Attention and MLP layers, achieving improved performance and dropping ratios.
Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our methods, e.g.,
Llama-3-70B maintains comparable performance even after pruning half of the
attention layers. Our findings provide valuable insights for future network
architecture design. The code will be released at:
\url{https://github.com/Shwai-He/LLM-Drop}. | [
0.022310378,
0.0381807759,
-0.0017226423,
0.047472734,
-0.019802371,
-0.0088293264,
0.0294673014,
-0.0114339693,
-0.0045945342,
-0.0164897442,
-0.0486702397,
-0.0275605526,
0.0073750969,
0.0023276936,
0.0222752187,
-0.0294751339,
0.0217977986,
-0.0179843586,
-0.0597892515,
-0.0090600243,
-0.0039879419,
-0.0151832057,
0.0260026045,
0.0545995198,
0.0195573512,
-0.0099937115,
-0.0100312233,
-0.0016029762,
0.0097138584,
-0.0085723754,
0.012531627,
0.0130162258,
-0.0152427191,
0.0301886499,
0.0000020754,
-0.0111112623,
0.0107803177,
-0.0098154582,
-0.0122517366,
0.04016589,
0.0344768092,
-0.0074875192,
-0.0316058174,
0.0379333124,
0.012824893,
-0.0459649824,
0.0877125189,
0.0610421412,
0.0648014173,
0.0504728146,
-0.0120108603,
-0.0419243425,
0.0143722845,
-0.0336367637,
-0.0249309931,
-0.0127456533,
0.0111795207,
-0.0053537246,
-0.0076669683,
-0.004412075,
-0.0209951699,
0.0446247943,
0.0264818072,
0.0020983678,
-0.0013929029,
0.0463626571,
-0.039730452,
-0.0205108412,
-0.0158895757,
0.0428138673,
-0.0626619235,
-0.0360463858,
0.023750389,
-0.0154795498,
-0.0453224257,
-0.0052698501,
-0.0432045721,
0.0347506367,
0.023385467,
0.0251289681,
-0.00983126,
0.0152271856,
0.0512462929,
-0.0178456027,
-0.0411548875,
0.0297287088,
0.0405373946,
0.0041763671,
-0.0327417366,
0.0013784067,
0.0088482201,
-0.0526015982,
0.0249588173,
0.0431415625,
0.0020304588,
0.0018771477,
-0.0540736094,
-0.0395444706,
-0.0020094453,
-0.0480750166,
0.0615121014,
0.0486491881,
-0.0180745348,
0.0428782515,
-0.0367062315,
0.0636860281,
-0.0827675983,
0.0216541551,
-0.0605174638,
-0.0122913616,
0.0141488388,
-0.0167548638,
-0.0336088613,
0.036144875,
-0.0070149736,
-0.0620197356,
-0.0172250867,
0.0483401343,
0.0148655912,
-0.021171771,
0.0165581331,
-0.0005124983,
-0.0122977225,
-0.0024458137,
0.0212280564,
0.0606233813,
0.0102392333,
-0.0119181341,
-0.0010933331,
-0.0711206347,
-0.0189228896,
0.037954811,
-0.0165651683,
-0.0130146006,
0.0142969601,
0.0857717544,
-0.0005657866,
-0.0408324376,
-0.0265626647,
0.02787745,
0.0079457192,
-0.036692664,
0.0065951715,
-0.0531042926,
0.0133094443,
0.0034038064,
0.0134505285,
-0.0076906756,
0.0000625196,
0.0322743878,
-0.0277107656,
0.025686115,
0.0268705077,
0.0287495349,
0.0235368945,
0.0046198564,
0.026577495,
0.0419692248,
0.0388236977,
0.0082319342,
0.0086470982,
-0.0233124122,
0.0148676364,
0.0698930323,
0.0017855255,
0.006658962,
-0.0154629052,
-0.0270618238,
-0.0212666541,
0.0056966371,
0.0495147929,
0.0810118169,
-0.0353985801,
-0.0187969673,
0.0717841089,
0.0469854437,
0.036378473,
0.0492035747,
-0.0014893224,
0.01948075,
-0.0061547677,
-0.0069318777,
-0.0732740685,
0.0784791708,
0.033362437,
-0.0012368434,
0.0210534856,
0.0657813028,
-0.0517089888,
0.014609579,
-0.0169463269,
-0.0176177397,
-0.018987244,
0.002187134,
0.028423341,
0.0242332499,
-0.0486026518,
0.133521378,
0.0019263758,
-0.0586311892,
-0.0361756124,
-0.0622700192,
-0.0092949942,
0.029647341,
0.041281078,
0.0066538816,
-0.0277385674,
0.0331113972,
-0.0102217197,
0.0348952934,
0.02877439,
0.0180868562,
0.0017185755,
-0.0598962381,
0.0035681601,
0.0305188168,
0.0144253448,
-0.0243041124,
0.0427594371,
-0.01406499,
0.0212672148,
-0.0185120497,
-0.0091717187,
0.02497706,
-0.0150090139,
0.0334605873,
0.0094886534,
-0.0060692895,
0.0308354124,
-0.0144734643,
-0.013878338,
0.005570719,
0.0437958054,
-0.0364708938,
-0.0047567845,
0.0099756652,
-0.055598639,
0.023997698,
0.0208494663,
-0.0224927701,
0.0513712429,
0.091105178,
-0.0320066921,
-0.0450216047,
0.0354191288,
-0.0844426975,
0.0538637675,
-0.0135030346,
0.0354846381,
-0.0227367729,
0.0494164228,
-0.0278029535,
0.0079111969,
-0.004822996,
0.0111080958,
0.0047036195,
0.0178493652,
0.0183446575,
-0.0079079075,
-0.0600969158,
0.0056397826,
-0.0223858915,
0.0418704115,
-0.0001028745,
-0.0239789337,
0.0062997583,
-0.0400904045,
-0.0455713347,
0.0031781341,
-0.0230791029,
0.0480805859,
0.0417233743,
0.0627287105,
0.0302056801,
-0.007708421,
0.0150298923,
0.0265056435,
-0.001064581,
0.0296801515,
0.0054934742,
-0.0435189791,
-0.0823974609,
-0.0430601202,
-0.0580554716,
0.0307728108,
0.0806959793,
-0.0292123184,
-0.0332501233,
-0.04926157,
0.0118363984,
0.014487219,
0.0506457165,
-0.0287560616,
-0.0610136688,
0.0010797759,
-0.0035440009,
0.0454470515,
0.0452533178,
-0.0010973978,
-0.0139066679,
0.0566774383,
0.0113398656,
-0.0331186093,
-0.006991012,
-0.0306440052,
-0.0119584883,
-0.0438312702,
0.0039925221,
-0.0072429175,
0.0947745144,
-0.0208593551,
-0.0095225545,
-0.0343054831,
-0.0556454659,
-0.0007276136,
0.0004036545,
0.0193495937,
-0.0230941344,
-0.0374883115,
0.026328072,
-0.0001635479,
-0.0639361367,
0.0159622412,
-0.0403844342,
-0.0215918031,
-0.0094696349,
-0.016170226,
-0.027789304,
0.0592400767,
0.0262880549,
0.0241062194,
-0.0244138278,
-0.0350363776,
-0.033481326,
0.0374239124,
-0.0336459242,
-0.0281259157,
0.0996475443,
-0.0234906301,
0.0298335943,
-0.0397191718,
-0.0434626415,
-0.0379378498,
0.0312182251,
-0.041267857,
0.0063792593,
0.044589866,
-0.043386098,
-0.0810866058,
0.0554885194,
0.024202181,
0.0657428131,
0.0132268136,
-0.0042442973,
-0.0163384676,
0.0410464853,
0.0036270299,
0.0423950367,
0.0759031549,
-0.0169916917,
0.0084766941,
0.0542583577,
0.044380229,
0.0293756686,
-0.0709954947,
-0.0288428962,
0.0523126759,
-0.0200993177,
-0.019953521,
0.0207833853,
0.048152037,
-0.0456912965,
-0.032014627,
0.0935038105,
-0.0077279592,
-0.0695607215,
0.0166611727,
0.0099823717,
0.0502447858,
0.0272437781,
0.0465877466,
-0.0548378862,
-0.014625526,
0.0150309615,
0.005737137,
0.0147650158,
-0.0008899721,
-0.0046728211,
-0.0936426446,
0.0007572017,
-0.0050922004,
-0.0135832028,
-0.035775993,
-0.0598858222,
-0.0054818699,
-0.0139849745,
0.0058652596,
0.0235428475,
-0.0194646735,
-0.0512907393,
0.0098150577,
-0.0210925043,
-0.0336536318,
0.0294562485,
-0.0310454741,
0.0484314971,
0.047147043,
-0.0227169581,
-0.0061382037,
-0.0432592146,
0.0532912239,
-0.0296347775,
-0.0051428163,
0.0069205081,
0.0151129495,
0.0283021182,
-0.0306758285,
-0.0517403893,
-0.0313564874,
-0.0456537642,
-0.0040313792,
-0.0486735664,
0.0794738382,
-0.0207029842,
-0.0427529328,
-0.0253256243,
-0.0059954696,
-0.0384642519,
0.0562980138,
0.0509926304,
-0.0308661312,
-0.0563548841,
-0.0072980225,
-0.0101539949,
-0.044872947,
-0.0474446677,
0.0372635275,
0.0050492422,
-0.048556719,
-0.0048452043,
0.0369357429,
-0.0226766746,
-0.0062834322,
0.0357816629,
-0.063054733,
0.0797702298,
-0.0100602759,
-0.0407949463,
0.0018253673,
-0.0478343666,
0.0111205215,
-0.0767891333,
0.032935448,
0.047239393,
-0.0200094823,
-0.0313054174,
-0.0084594442,
-0.1386380792,
-0.0542438217,
0.0229763053,
0.0298256204,
0.0237751752,
-0.0005020264,
-0.0003188911,
-0.0727667361,
0.0009205414,
0.0353604816,
-0.0364178196,
0.056321349,
0.0067068269,
-0.0537308306,
0.0065898686,
0.0337366425,
-0.0372267775,
0.0440818407,
0.020398939,
0.023040358,
0.010586014,
-0.037101917,
-0.0153679624,
0.0125255119,
0.0184249524,
0.0115784695,
0.0551893748,
-0.0043076905,
0.0381786041,
0.0344816372,
0.0263934154,
-0.0501026846,
-0.013939051,
0.0152143631,
0.0081984187,
0.0188901816,
0.0201498903,
0.0457253605,
0.0111676473,
-0.0020633063,
0.0129539734,
-0.0336129218,
-0.0306971911,
0.0558757111,
-0.0096014589,
-0.0219968297,
-0.0208717473,
0.0231205393,
0.0125508429,
-0.0320560224,
-0.0022792534,
0.0202286504,
-0.0001364136,
-0.0654511899,
0.0362046324,
-0.0398913473,
-0.0796283185,
-0.0212263912,
-0.0085740564,
0.0567170903,
0.0036010582,
0.0636147633,
-0.0199709889,
0.0130343512,
-0.0326514468,
0.0115006827,
-0.0137066096,
-0.0136910761,
0.0401400849,
0.0107508786,
0.0089093698,
-0.0123399263,
0.0439642407,
-0.0160220228,
0.020150777,
-0.0140498653,
0.0045191171,
-0.0085092122,
-0.046161484,
-0.0492388867,
0.0118314913,
-0.0340660587,
-0.0419657044,
-0.0307131559,
-0.0511542223,
0.000669642,
-0.0151417702,
0.025466824,
-0.0430864505,
0.0117833856,
0.0502003804,
0.0247768313,
-0.0116653321,
-0.0022805417,
-0.0128317941,
0.0096396245,
-0.0060104923,
0.0232814997,
-6.721921916e-33,
-0.001231098,
-0.0149172274,
0.0341751687,
-0.0034017267,
-0.0505265072,
0.0336140655,
-0.0530314408,
-0.0209432803,
-0.048291266,
-0.0199063215,
-0.0256887656,
0.0110571124,
0.010921631,
0.0481043532,
0.0189954322,
-0.0048799966,
0.0522449873,
0.013950455,
-0.0255873669,
0.0471534096,
0.0023881742,
0.0036148319,
0.047788512,
-0.0281782281,
-0.069416225,
-0.0273899734,
0.0258513,
-0.0098660169,
-0.0073191174,
0.0519999266,
-0.0417112522,
0.038459383,
0.021192817,
-0.0690464079,
-0.0254353061,
0.025079852,
-0.0582561456,
0.000673021,
0.0020917684,
0.0345312878,
-0.0087313084,
-0.0204349589,
0.0599251054,
0.0410019569,
-0.02362491,
-0.0505734533,
0.0090152416,
0.0139778927,
-0.0493242107,
0.0147231231,
-0.0333092585,
0.0140131274,
0.0132316574,
0.0020678598,
0.021175677,
0.0223748516,
-0.0406119563,
0.0691316277,
-0.0795983225,
0.0187229421,
-0.0128793977,
0.0776854232,
0.0702847466,
0.0397987366,
0.007282435,
0.0403261185,
0.0244171228,
-0.023268396,
-0.0316006541,
-0.0165917221,
0.0450886562,
0.0212763846,
0.0342303403,
-0.0280440524,
0.0056305011,
-0.0165926572,
-0.0558545031,
-0.0431367494,
-0.0028425637,
0.0467242114,
0.062733829,
0.0344834179,
-0.007577138,
-0.0258274917,
-0.0018046333,
0.0223452095,
-0.0381798223,
-0.0061092582,
0.0172988847,
0.0194390472,
-0.0298048556,
0.0134643996,
0.0367219336,
-0.0414945744,
0.008342295,
0.0281006508,
0.0030582214,
0.0490187816,
-0.0062528974,
0.0180619955,
-0.0576462224,
-0.0456113443,
-0.0237690266,
-0.0302722678,
0.008068881,
-0.0145626003,
0.0011293364,
0.0459287763,
-0.0841160193,
-0.0236473456,
-0.0515402704,
0.0019351109,
0.0124883493,
0.0688040182,
0.019682657,
0.0005855369,
0.0106795682,
0.0271432996,
-0.0115335807,
-0.0329449065,
-0.004070119,
0.0370493904,
0.0282727964,
0.0156799462,
-0.0439383164,
0.017468974,
-0.1037004888,
0.0505835898,
0.0403032191,
-0.0781214312,
-0.0566499904,
0.0423830375,
2.865e-7,
0.0340784378,
0.0354624875,
0.0291828513,
0.0254263487,
0.038216617,
0.022546418,
0.0211783629,
0.0378016829,
0.0034157226,
0.0447884426,
-0.0165033657,
0.0100536682,
0.0214370694,
-0.0088448031,
-0.0806672871,
0.0189467072,
-0.1160065234,
0.0049504964,
-0.0142142549,
-0.0381381363,
-0.0225378349,
0.1083550751,
0.0053640874,
-0.0193553828,
-0.0022298251,
-0.0086640064,
0.0198751483,
-0.0030877474,
0.0362791456,
0.0384900682,
0.0240815151,
0.009191107,
-0.0370650925,
0.0047140918,
0.008845116,
0.0115764523,
-0.0054898141,
0.0645079762,
0.0196322054,
-0.0145072257,
0.0377928801,
-0.0305118822,
-0.0333948545,
-0.0706780106,
0.0331102647,
-0.0549675897,
-0.0239585992,
-0.0358405225,
0.0015026648,
-0.0147661474,
-0.0109445099,
0.0055391304,
0.0200937763,
0.0244241543,
0.0299720857,
-0.0475740992,
-0.0104528219,
-0.068326503,
-0.0292300619,
-0.0181125067,
-0.0571923181,
-0.0420863628,
-0.0757905915,
-0.0426208042,
0.0497639775,
-0.004128539,
-0.0197197944,
2.62703128e-34,
0.0043145181,
-0.0007663024,
0.0088521084,
0.0592923015,
-0.0082348958,
-0.0295608044,
0.0112365922,
0.0168381874,
-0.0416714773,
-0.0918728188,
-0.034047991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15781v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15781v1 | DABL: Detecting Semantic Anomalies in Business Processes Using Large Language Models | 2024-06-22T08:20:19 | 2024-06-22T08:20:19 | Wei Guan, Jian Cao, Jianqi Gao, Haiyan Zhao, Shiyou Qian | cs.CL | cs.CL | Detecting anomalies in business processes is crucial for ensuring operational
success. While many existing methods rely on statistical frequency to detect
anomalies, it's important to note that infrequent behavior doesn't necessarily
imply undesirability. To address this challenge, detecting anomalies from a
semantic viewpoint proves to be a more effective approach. However, current
semantic anomaly detection methods treat a trace (i.e., process instance) as
multiple event pairs, disrupting long-distance dependencies. In this paper, we
introduce DABL, a novel approach for detecting semantic anomalies in business
processes using large language models (LLMs). We collect 143,137 real-world
process models from various domains. By generating normal traces through the
playout of these process models and simulating both ordering and exclusion
anomalies, we fine-tune Llama 2 using the resulting log. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate that DABL surpasses existing state-of-the-art
semantic anomaly detection methods in terms of both generalization ability and
learning of given processes. Users can directly apply DABL to detect semantic
anomalies in their own datasets without the need for additional training.
Furthermore, DABL offers the capability to interpret the causes of anomalies in
natural language, providing valuable insights into the detected anomalies. | [
0.0478430577,
0.0299755856,
-0.019832259,
0.0673594326,
-0.0314734355,
-0.0066512665,
-0.0028653825,
0.0210624225,
-0.014568951,
-0.0228374302,
0.0313425884,
-0.0191708766,
-0.0372653455,
0.0727443546,
-0.0314736664,
-0.0183208827,
0.0343210213,
-0.0272274315,
0.0470108613,
0.0371833779,
-0.0220648069,
0.0274842922,
-0.0045852656,
0.0216816179,
-0.0074608354,
-0.0131048067,
-0.0151292561,
-0.0061009913,
0.0284300186,
-0.0458555631,
0.0019415253,
0.0036115649,
0.0063152951,
0.0899273828,
0.0000018727,
-0.0794901401,
0.0005968074,
-0.0046588825,
-0.0039172424,
0.0415941291,
-0.0144559229,
-0.0222724434,
-0.0031200142,
0.0268003121,
-0.0237268955,
-0.010601378,
0.0090833958,
0.0958343223,
0.0341703296,
0.0565783381,
-0.0299759228,
0.0128216352,
-0.0163703859,
-0.0274988562,
0.0006606528,
-0.070090577,
0.0568064749,
-0.0363911651,
-0.0114403618,
-0.0071942089,
-0.0015306133,
-0.0373402163,
-0.0154943885,
-0.0209791381,
-0.0456942357,
0.0382291265,
0.0321732722,
0.0017102807,
0.0203608405,
0.0695206225,
-0.04289582,
0.0328666642,
0.0385577604,
-0.0082929041,
0.0193505157,
-0.019768009,
-0.038200628,
0.0433785319,
-0.020082701,
0.0047839112,
0.048884403,
0.0128671099,
0.041131895,
0.0054644113,
0.003502188,
0.0561405867,
0.005503735,
-0.0331881568,
-0.0734861791,
0.0137672275,
0.0169531852,
-0.0399081856,
0.0042436854,
0.0309689287,
-0.0778831393,
0.0080935676,
0.0107301949,
0.0442429855,
0.0439288467,
-0.0453751236,
0.0429885946,
-0.0042724111,
-0.0139818294,
0.0400060788,
0.0001557377,
0.0326141231,
0.0060487506,
0.014841917,
-0.0128988465,
0.0000890149,
-0.0430242307,
-0.0087780626,
-0.023801785,
-0.0061977603,
-0.0675479099,
-0.0353491753,
-0.0153111201,
0.0514564402,
-0.0470184051,
0.0399653204,
0.0173948109,
-0.0122945439,
-0.0083879242,
-0.0356140174,
-0.0573407151,
-0.0254569687,
-0.0108276941,
0.0476769805,
-0.0427998826,
-0.0141347498,
-0.0494979247,
-0.002825628,
-0.0095731523,
-0.0040110424,
-0.0236486178,
0.0575130731,
0.0549349599,
0.002771338,
-0.0764966533,
-0.0493158884,
0.0020183339,
-0.0178100504,
-0.0603041761,
-0.0202481113,
-0.0278993417,
-0.0322548524,
-0.0134589868,
0.0077903606,
0.0128442422,
0.0009494029,
-0.0410574414,
0.0380248278,
-0.0292875636,
0.008692137,
-0.0115174036,
0.0226268955,
0.0389054082,
0.0465571173,
-0.0015501804,
-0.0281060822,
0.0398875065,
-0.0112046376,
0.0577215813,
-0.00078985,
-0.0156801119,
0.0191122126,
0.0105817122,
-0.0069268979,
-0.0227473956,
-0.0036665697,
0.0873534754,
-0.0023749559,
0.0113390544,
-0.0406423137,
0.024444785,
0.008345494,
-0.0863817185,
-0.0230689533,
0.0502826199,
-0.0022982829,
-0.058198709,
0.0058370996,
-0.0070265732,
-0.0297051854,
-0.02270188,
-0.0446103439,
-0.042266123,
-0.0100123463,
-0.0332985297,
-0.0305642132,
-0.0151014319,
0.0014815215,
-0.0077426168,
-0.0427107327,
0.0243694838,
0.0264235139,
-0.0388908088,
0.0089560514,
0.0089599006,
0.0058083045,
-0.0142468149,
-0.0306549016,
0.0293600466,
0.1092486903,
0.0557922907,
-0.0629796162,
-0.0057899863,
-0.0327621587,
-0.0316645689,
0.0431414396,
0.0123738572,
-0.0180065203,
0.0298575759,
-0.0019733084,
-0.0076515651,
-0.0065607191,
0.0490561314,
-0.0228290092,
-0.0477405898,
0.0117887622,
0.003129506,
-0.0378029533,
-0.0363469794,
0.0518305786,
-0.0028207784,
-0.0416843556,
0.0297390651,
-0.0187366568,
0.015241446,
-0.0165569633,
0.0218677334,
0.0159033537,
0.0331953727,
-0.0541370809,
-0.0533210747,
0.0304912087,
0.0051915459,
-0.0002474252,
0.0309021529,
0.0026136506,
-0.0180867668,
0.0017561947,
-0.0642682835,
-0.0534892976,
0.0294004977,
-0.0188134573,
0.0286926348,
-0.0176874939,
0.0218241587,
0.0183229465,
0.0320509262,
-0.0208198596,
0.0491185896,
-0.027974451,
0.0246240348,
-0.0327882506,
-0.0044991281,
0.0158938095,
0.0061331932,
0.0150201572,
0.0677078739,
-0.0119281746,
0.0133668482,
0.0020518813,
-0.0277228169,
0.0131782284,
0.0126182698,
-0.0282565486,
0.0032970638,
-0.0051650903,
0.0323530175,
0.0287644863,
0.0240420755,
-0.029688403,
-0.0372816883,
0.0155751491,
0.0003794479,
0.031555526,
0.0314985029,
0.059965793,
0.0089321658,
-0.057959497,
-0.0203931835,
0.0046376139,
-0.0366430432,
0.0544528402,
0.0116925659,
0.0294842962,
-0.1051880941,
0.0435190387,
-0.017213745,
0.0184085052,
-0.0031466428,
0.0028161095,
-0.016165683,
-0.0178294647,
0.0190836061,
0.023932945,
-0.0286979098,
0.0466170646,
0.0266282,
-0.0329672061,
-0.0159771759,
-0.0160731487,
-0.0380432457,
0.0311204847,
-0.0157206468,
-0.0222465023,
0.0188542958,
0.0726839304,
0.0137930065,
-0.0320371762,
0.002900559,
-0.0002367867,
-0.0224889442,
0.0124186836,
-0.0105009498,
-0.0901299641,
-0.0092578912,
0.0622712076,
-0.0026775675,
-0.0080080098,
0.0397488214,
-0.014711705,
0.011785944,
-0.0197931118,
-0.0348838978,
-0.0276776273,
0.0773043633,
0.0087264674,
0.026829401,
-0.0350635834,
-0.071845226,
-0.0252455268,
-0.0071101417,
0.0514155962,
0.0151755149,
0.0274629463,
-0.0667715967,
0.0157368127,
0.0185108446,
-0.0252937134,
-0.0692458078,
-0.0470576994,
-0.0115235867,
0.0145255132,
-0.0223866589,
-0.0239020884,
-0.0489820018,
0.0069422964,
-0.0548663102,
0.0554676354,
0.0393916704,
-0.0339696929,
-0.0276017133,
0.013667414,
0.0234040972,
-0.0761389881,
0.0190465078,
-0.0221419111,
0.0260944273,
0.0424049869,
-0.0321823545,
-0.0051825424,
-0.0084667122,
-0.0154506695,
-0.0405869223,
-0.0333997756,
0.0220542271,
0.0060745832,
0.0087004574,
-0.0780729353,
-0.0446362831,
0.105337292,
0.0477371588,
0.0257925596,
0.0448292457,
0.0001124355,
0.0332783125,
0.0256625675,
-0.0037107307,
-0.0353711359,
0.0091115264,
0.0087099839,
0.0014586597,
-0.0058981869,
-0.0576555952,
0.0268520452,
-0.1182428226,
0.0206469558,
-0.0129209477,
-0.0091464696,
-0.0572185926,
-0.0611130334,
0.0041930126,
-0.0364585705,
0.04864081,
-0.0178484246,
0.0114382394,
-0.0285577755,
0.023663545,
-0.0739615932,
-0.0793607906,
0.0565948971,
0.0007536284,
0.0048337285,
0.0333291553,
0.0087103117,
-0.0293536503,
0.0197349098,
0.031573575,
0.0136339162,
-0.0060273497,
0.0123730507,
0.0369510464,
0.0510741211,
-0.0200060625,
-0.0276535898,
0.0294973068,
-0.10199745,
-0.0098823402,
0.0086937752,
0.1067614481,
-0.0296015274,
-0.0525510237,
-0.0010493163,
-0.0051272945,
0.0496944524,
0.0728970915,
-0.0435939133,
-0.031494543,
-0.0181718096,
0.0063742483,
-0.015326106,
0.0289103873,
0.0111220228,
0.04391855,
0.0358351022,
-0.0566202253,
-0.0607792698,
-0.0803070441,
0.0029372226,
0.0067959316,
0.0070362086,
0.0049354979,
-0.0116660558,
-0.0121890567,
-0.0246423874,
-0.0198596269,
-0.0068635205,
0.0729294345,
0.0325983614,
0.0722900778,
0.0000201035,
0.1002599746,
-0.0473623425,
0.0370508805,
-0.1011695787,
-0.0326963291,
0.0066679241,
-0.0261908267,
0.011632097,
0.0450234339,
-0.0483732782,
0.0101779988,
-0.0219416562,
0.0225264449,
-0.0189535972,
-0.0235565975,
0.0109774722,
-0.0532089993,
0.0290637612,
0.0252365042,
-0.0210598633,
0.0380236916,
-0.0097604217,
0.034043815,
-0.0931705013,
-0.0471271388,
0.0214059837,
-0.0263611637,
0.0325863585,
0.025428772,
-0.0133305052,
-0.0708880201,
0.0140878875,
-0.0339814536,
-0.0144272698,
-0.0029389698,
0.0449594334,
0.0217945762,
-0.0373624861,
0.0125796953,
-0.0163919665,
-0.0678618699,
-0.0052276738,
-0.002644903,
-0.0020133296,
0.0350181796,
0.0250471849,
0.0261400472,
0.0100831911,
0.014371736,
-0.0036375734,
0.01327316,
0.0547057092,
0.0233118366,
0.0266493056,
0.0202262178,
0.0301830545,
-0.0242676362,
-0.0569416285,
-0.0230624378,
0.0308810342,
0.0398462564,
-0.0011762864,
0.0707362816,
-0.0485560223,
0.0056162504,
-0.0258033685,
0.0347107165,
0.0083868681,
0.0270305946,
0.0105511155,
0.0069517926,
0.0014366518,
0.02250758,
-0.0402347967,
0.0053458703,
0.092259571,
-0.0066608647,
0.0756984279,
-0.0039952812,
-0.0164677761,
-0.0330935381,
-0.0390423797,
0.0430080965,
0.0518201888,
-0.0058564763,
0.0097497022,
-0.0835310444,
-0.0393504538,
-0.0253557395,
-0.006209597,
-0.0170121174,
0.0075479387,
-0.0086172074,
0.0757538229,
0.0124113308,
0.0171039738,
-0.031341482,
-0.0450480469,
0.0090146186,
-0.0446344092,
-0.067719996,
-5.139205466e-33,
-0.0085617602,
-0.0723844245,
-0.0014470401,
0.013165297,
0.0316454396,
-0.0211271532,
-0.0197388381,
-0.0188366715,
0.045475062,
0.0837023109,
0.0034199809,
0.0325950198,
0.0059321807,
-0.0084908875,
0.0182612222,
0.003213641,
0.07420744,
0.0357519202,
0.0273478478,
0.0332752503,
0.0840975866,
0.020081304,
0.0411184654,
-0.0773936883,
0.055799257,
-0.0076949769,
-0.0261856616,
0.0461864769,
0.0277855229,
0.0332208164,
-0.0065594735,
0.061068859,
0.0158649925,
0.0054622744,
-0.0220516473,
-0.0603170805,
0.0055686673,
-0.0288990662,
-0.0173822157,
0.0008379157,
-0.0002396799,
-0.0235956758,
0.0241735708,
-0.0091800084,
0.0044605578,
0.0319592059,
0.0364927128,
-0.0210376978,
-0.0084104175,
0.0468229279,
-0.0778648481,
0.0117060719,
-0.0349712372,
0.0216675047,
-0.0177021045,
-0.0386493579,
0.0432533994,
-0.0642770678,
-0.0510357693,
0.0100379679,
-0.0090846615,
-0.0233239885,
0.0163622871,
0.0035005086,
-0.0266058724,
0.0299208984,
-0.0143765798,
0.0290090535,
0.021929644,
0.0504432507,
-0.0348278694,
0.0859180838,
0.0033213533,
0.006866409,
-0.0043755793,
0.0098985201,
-0.0719790086,
0.044783283,
-0.0181996822,
0.049004443,
0.0607867539,
-0.0383432284,
-0.0672051907,
-0.0162675735,
0.0110451067,
0.0248842873,
-0.0163193252,
0.0363053642,
0.0197405517,
0.0294444133,
0.0163435694,
0.0020796261,
0.0163557045,
-0.0335594453,
-0.0606522001,
0.014218892,
-0.036006961,
-0.0714214817,
0.0121252062,
-0.006666197,
0.0037602738,
-0.0590285622,
0.0042939615,
0.0020478738,
0.0351464301,
0.00118533,
0.0250849165,
-0.0129970275,
-0.0857316777,
0.0191495586,
-0.0434387065,
0.0374462791,
-0.0509796739,
0.0336197317,
0.0018072302,
-0.0317098312,
-0.0315574519,
0.0420972444,
0.0142419646,
0.0009190863,
0.0068966453,
0.0482551418,
-0.0540248677,
-0.0001257617,
-0.0175951459,
-0.0389675833,
-0.0017437699,
-0.0220146272,
0.0914606228,
-0.0257748533,
-0.001642562,
-0.0230745636,
2.515e-7,
0.0107631376,
0.0287060328,
-0.0065675243,
0.0624118075,
0.069358781,
0.0434519947,
-0.0080380933,
0.0335965119,
-0.0452434793,
-0.0044003576,
0.0392413065,
-0.0280232541,
-0.0080074547,
0.0460063778,
-0.034721002,
-0.0465908311,
-0.0498278961,
-0.0223971233,
-0.1012653857,
-0.036498569,
0.0299133491,
0.0923750177,
0.0483082943,
-0.0455434434,
0.037366692,
-0.0707353055,
0.0255754925,
-0.0093497317,
-0.0128254723,
0.0195408072,
0.0266832728,
0.0288807694,
0.0573732853,
0.0275318902,
-0.0286211912,
-0.0018790206,
-0.0264413413,
0.0573897026,
-0.0273597129,
0.0332689956,
-0.0400650315,
-0.0380354784,
0.0188676212,
-0.0296447165,
0.0306488797,
-0.0185518712,
-0.0270842351,
0.0159803964,
0.0076731616,
-0.011584783,
0.0147698596,
0.0243767444,
-0.0197528303,
0.0322270319,
-0.007306749,
-0.0116726933,
0.0389421359,
-0.0204863437,
0.011680658,
-0.0042218072,
-0.0303812344,
-0.0188982002,
0.0525526442,
0.0014610066,
0.0127446661,
0.0260704551,
0.0472118929,
2.479540948e-34,
0.0455611907,
0.0260837637,
-0.0091679459,
-0.0129688922,
0.011561784,
0.0245510004,
-0.0392037816,
0.0289460886,
0.0192156993,
-0.0278137587,
0.0204229411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15765v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15765v1 | Unveiling and Harnessing Hidden Attention Sinks: Enhancing Large Language Models without Training through Attention Calibration | 2024-06-22T07:00:43 | 2024-06-22T07:00:43 | Zhongzhi Yu, Zheng Wang, Yonggan Fu, Huihong Shi, Khalid Shaikh, Yingyan Celine Lin | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Attention is a fundamental component behind the remarkable achievements of
large language models (LLMs). However, our current understanding of the
attention mechanism, especially regarding how attention distributions are
established, remains limited. Inspired by recent studies that explore the
presence of attention sink in the initial token, which receives
disproportionately large attention scores despite their lack of semantic
importance, this work delves deeper into this phenomenon. We aim to provide a
more profound understanding of the existence of attention sinks within LLMs and
to uncover ways to enhance the achievable accuracy of LLMs by directly
optimizing the attention distributions, without the need for weight finetuning.
Specifically, this work begins with comprehensive visualizations of the
attention distributions in LLMs during inference across various inputs and
tasks. Based on these visualizations, to the best of our knowledge, we are the
first to discover that (1) attention sinks occur not only at the start of
sequences but also within later tokens of the input, and (2) not all attention
sinks have a positive impact on the achievable accuracy of LLMs. Building upon
our findings, we propose a training-free Attention Calibration Technique (ACT)
that automatically optimizes the attention distributions on the fly during
inference in an input-adaptive manner. Extensive experiments validate that ACT
consistently enhances the accuracy of various LLMs across different
applications. Specifically, ACT achieves an average improvement of up to 7.30%
in accuracy across different datasets when applied to Llama-30B. Our code is
available at https://github.com/GATECH-EIC/ACT. | [
0.0175875332,
0.0538125858,
-0.0189678408,
0.055903662,
-0.0013421178,
-0.0055127307,
-0.0136832278,
-0.0138195669,
-0.0322321281,
-0.0177495778,
-0.0533735007,
-0.0447311997,
0.038147442,
0.017466642,
0.062514171,
-0.0304849986,
0.0243065953,
-0.0404907987,
-0.0049328115,
0.0261318814,
0.0205320902,
-0.0009015684,
0.0070453468,
0.0530241877,
-0.005627146,
-0.0228230674,
-0.0032083406,
0.0257869083,
0.0021186431,
-0.0244149864,
-0.0114102131,
0.0366709493,
-0.0025258674,
0.0485465042,
0.0000020204,
-0.0355213434,
0.0397300497,
-0.0339733586,
-0.0376649685,
0.0666179657,
0.0307887774,
-0.0132879131,
-0.0049663521,
0.0246457402,
-0.012997238,
0.0215108078,
0.0789618939,
0.0052621318,
0.0307613928,
0.0643860325,
0.0006344499,
0.0039578541,
0.0073250765,
-0.0712164715,
-0.0020776016,
-0.068832688,
0.0163976941,
-0.0168584473,
-0.0190266818,
-0.0030691612,
-0.0506684668,
0.0361632928,
0.0355381668,
-0.0057182028,
0.0238201395,
0.0580722988,
-0.0318175964,
-0.0405664705,
-0.0239079613,
0.0882936418,
-0.0638635084,
-0.0501028858,
-0.0205628406,
-0.0323362052,
0.0144736618,
-0.0444199294,
-0.0589201562,
0.0370074995,
0.0250310693,
0.0448615998,
0.0523473471,
-0.0068205176,
0.053162504,
-0.0154420016,
-0.0372104794,
0.047947567,
0.0001784298,
-0.0184316225,
-0.0329167768,
0.0185324494,
-0.0261872746,
-0.0653298199,
0.0177070815,
0.0413620472,
0.0076887063,
0.0239777826,
-0.0453240536,
-0.0573275425,
0.0133204553,
-0.039411597,
0.0610332675,
0.0580761172,
-0.0512578897,
0.0436828472,
-0.0127406111,
0.0586038344,
-0.0357920751,
0.0144544998,
-0.043906033,
0.017952526,
0.0290444922,
0.008152443,
-0.0184296146,
-0.0124909868,
-0.055973649,
-0.0397067927,
-0.0175827574,
0.0312401522,
0.0153683666,
-0.0478811525,
0.0166986007,
0.0138232084,
-0.0216725152,
0.0102950539,
0.0053691999,
0.0554212295,
-0.0474559255,
0.042070929,
-0.000975995,
-0.0604357868,
-0.0683329627,
0.0440165922,
0.0029449558,
-0.02092457,
-0.0057071629,
0.0574321896,
0.0048467042,
-0.0430133529,
-0.0212264713,
0.0166822355,
-0.017848853,
-0.056968946,
0.0149116553,
-0.0360847674,
0.0365111157,
0.0097431606,
-0.0016558159,
-0.0259706024,
0.0187997986,
0.0275587924,
-0.0364043191,
0.0429603383,
0.0102186883,
0.0168028399,
-0.0245772265,
-0.0117042055,
-0.0186113417,
0.0810990259,
0.0550671779,
0.0304127336,
-0.0015378055,
-0.0093377717,
-0.0314165056,
0.0468992218,
0.0316208191,
0.0026381027,
-0.0150638586,
-0.0074305409,
-0.0304008257,
0.0321746208,
0.0990124941,
0.0256037023,
-0.0250433367,
-0.008294791,
0.0652000457,
0.0622424558,
-0.0029736564,
0.0168559831,
0.0309005771,
-0.0102022523,
0.0056762933,
0.0152698308,
-0.0915216953,
0.0593613647,
-0.0009885365,
0.0133696813,
0.0686853901,
0.0157078598,
-0.0166037492,
-0.0355475023,
-0.0227613561,
0.0045123403,
-0.0078545855,
0.0208606105,
0.0329902172,
0.0065832827,
-0.0427729338,
0.0773625672,
0.0410158224,
-0.0359660871,
-0.0038142186,
-0.0446434021,
0.0355123244,
0.0410318933,
0.0119163515,
-0.0031485106,
-0.0161496177,
0.0290278345,
0.0423709489,
0.0650876537,
0.0228821002,
0.0365433171,
0.0143742179,
-0.0418023616,
0.0048628915,
-0.0251059216,
0.0266964808,
0.0197525062,
0.0075859814,
0.0051929122,
0.0128386142,
-0.0542223752,
-0.0298976377,
0.0409131348,
-0.0110635534,
-0.0198553484,
-0.0033353821,
-0.000420105,
0.037421789,
-0.0033839545,
0.007722131,
0.0424670242,
0.0396971889,
-0.0414706916,
0.0387782492,
-0.0084146773,
-0.0412680991,
-0.0243705548,
0.0447584167,
-0.0102694696,
-0.0263867397,
0.0313410684,
-0.0252342205,
-0.0458417423,
0.0484628156,
-0.055460345,
0.0548856482,
-0.0130674867,
0.0299387351,
-0.0044352761,
0.0872182399,
-0.034024328,
0.0478123203,
-0.0223325901,
0.0299452655,
-0.0014765291,
0.0197011493,
0.0037419146,
-0.0282030832,
0.0061573833,
-0.0228862837,
-0.0031907409,
-0.007210664,
-0.0341535956,
-0.001760409,
-0.0174677577,
-0.0179558061,
-0.0559759475,
0.0259302557,
-0.0359907299,
0.0516041405,
0.0390392095,
0.0061281025,
-0.0149365049,
-0.0269875415,
-0.0213803872,
0.0058853133,
-0.0237303283,
0.0071253474,
0.0218037553,
-0.029223064,
-0.0074672489,
-0.0757044554,
-0.0116044739,
-0.0148887886,
0.0317076035,
0.0061228443,
-0.0296133477,
-0.0574400425,
-0.0006132348,
-0.0025626712,
0.0105318297,
-0.014395833,
-0.059903916,
0.0166835077,
0.0063977167,
0.0542987026,
0.0989272669,
-0.0114531657,
0.0239796396,
0.0770321339,
0.0047185975,
-0.0377600603,
0.0229206234,
-0.000084536,
0.0157548953,
-0.0236715451,
-0.0339835808,
0.0033665653,
0.1243286803,
-0.0084850593,
0.0124255037,
-0.061072059,
-0.0036853361,
0.0051530087,
-0.004312953,
-0.0055023073,
0.0171919055,
-0.0582089089,
0.0076178759,
-0.0559216999,
-0.0606093593,
0.0753367618,
-0.0681042224,
-0.0221839231,
-0.0304378662,
0.0055744685,
-0.0526495017,
0.0324658118,
0.0130729415,
0.0026473415,
-0.0027423627,
-0.0286702048,
-0.0310532507,
0.019152822,
-0.0204826109,
-0.0221569277,
0.0774197057,
-0.0114122042,
-0.0097076437,
-0.0402029827,
0.0000454151,
-0.0300971102,
-0.0280896481,
-0.0672321171,
-0.0041723126,
0.0166519247,
-0.020573454,
-0.0533504933,
0.0033409416,
0.0325756818,
0.0420848578,
-0.0276483707,
0.039515648,
-0.0272394717,
0.0249353573,
0.0660317615,
0.0176996998,
0.0425065979,
-0.0517933778,
-0.0249945279,
0.0562410653,
0.0261217225,
0.0491824858,
-0.0192993414,
-0.0058197645,
0.0394618213,
-0.0065721031,
0.0118943937,
0.0194377042,
0.0613105632,
-0.0577529445,
-0.002612056,
0.1056170464,
0.013396617,
-0.0587813556,
0.0374537669,
-0.0271497257,
0.0357105061,
0.0384422727,
0.0012732216,
-0.0676321387,
-0.057050813,
0.0119467238,
0.0190877523,
0.0236248504,
0.0012200522,
-0.0138338534,
-0.1004816815,
-0.0021527938,
0.010182674,
-0.0494621284,
-0.0312428344,
-0.0497886501,
0.033269465,
0.0091031594,
0.0295308959,
0.0269177444,
-0.0091482475,
-0.0022238467,
0.0272842683,
0.0043249121,
-0.0344117731,
0.0262159035,
-0.0275779385,
0.051592119,
0.0403672941,
0.0125687076,
-0.0059325127,
-0.03873289,
0.0479202718,
-0.0336062498,
-0.0051027085,
0.0059325937,
0.0412399359,
0.0006353999,
-0.0180784166,
-0.0171106793,
0.0093188984,
-0.0359087214,
0.0003899114,
-0.0050278082,
0.0890348256,
0.0042990698,
-0.0398117341,
-0.0332365967,
-0.0158596672,
-0.0225646179,
0.0698370188,
0.0944761038,
-0.0511872582,
-0.0415930524,
-0.0317249,
-0.0134776207,
-0.0477575846,
-0.0201273691,
0.0375551507,
0.0189544167,
-0.0680200458,
-0.0423071533,
-0.0234326888,
0.0248554219,
-0.0042411205,
0.0098184561,
-0.000912193,
0.0021161477,
-0.0467694253,
-0.032839641,
0.076909937,
-0.0545761175,
0.0344452411,
-0.0515505411,
-0.0039515649,
0.0119507667,
-0.0120249204,
-0.0012743808,
0.0412791446,
-0.1114679277,
-0.0720729381,
-0.0238216538,
0.0270976946,
0.019516794,
0.0109649897,
-0.0347701386,
-0.0715776607,
0.0164106805,
-0.0038620166,
-0.0137970978,
0.0461032875,
0.0058435732,
-0.0351731665,
0.0167659465,
0.059741389,
-0.0326470174,
-0.0011861933,
0.0148136076,
0.0682660416,
-0.0197267849,
-0.0379690938,
-0.0046006432,
-0.0084521845,
0.051714465,
-0.0042567807,
0.0028968782,
-0.0115720881,
0.0305179041,
0.0117379678,
0.0038826989,
-0.0405768603,
-0.0254034083,
0.0270805452,
-0.013650571,
0.0034532594,
-0.0204012133,
-0.0274648983,
0.0151627464,
-0.0357527956,
0.0481590778,
0.0009696385,
0.0025369225,
0.0297715496,
-0.0118116811,
-0.0240253005,
-0.0166607201,
-0.0371907279,
0.0301716849,
-0.0035308644,
0.0028738326,
-0.0016158383,
-0.0199270137,
-0.045916114,
0.0220057871,
-0.0535510667,
0.0097442772,
0.0090883803,
0.041730769,
0.0872985795,
-0.0288548414,
0.0649670959,
0.0253036804,
-0.0061505493,
-0.01810118,
0.008265201,
-0.033415556,
-0.0279932804,
0.0435033403,
0.0235958043,
-0.0016421253,
0.0023099841,
0.0723442286,
0.031590879,
0.0225314144,
-0.0041328208,
0.0000600087,
-0.0034621209,
-0.0259875301,
-0.0079647508,
0.0196519326,
-0.038229093,
0.0075868536,
-0.0465897582,
-0.1062677652,
0.0044238134,
0.0023385985,
-0.030241387,
-0.0330975503,
0.0165580772,
0.0306767449,
-0.008333643,
-0.0223945826,
-0.0115276594,
0.0201054774,
-0.0155951865,
-0.034271758,
-0.0241805427,
-6.768581695e-33,
-0.0111890789,
-0.0184777807,
-0.0040543191,
-0.0174215641,
-0.0450046696,
0.0166912042,
-0.090233691,
0.0075164242,
-0.0430037677,
-0.0035633005,
-0.0093198121,
0.0172732957,
0.0153859053,
0.0127697336,
-0.012894555,
-0.0279898178,
0.0190571342,
0.0105953012,
-0.0315922685,
0.0102131171,
-0.0001881519,
0.009054401,
0.0701001212,
0.005814495,
0.0113989795,
-0.0106055951,
0.0081932377,
0.0120037803,
-0.0182196815,
0.0716156289,
-0.0279062837,
0.0621238537,
0.0171165429,
-0.0029264889,
-0.0295586977,
0.0251662061,
-0.0536032878,
-0.0279179346,
0.0619879514,
0.0042664981,
-0.0304688346,
-0.0424354449,
0.0794161484,
0.0276337881,
0.0097399782,
-0.0147480462,
0.0244924873,
-0.0276661403,
-0.047505185,
0.0277168062,
-0.0492020659,
0.0156271197,
-0.0145468656,
-0.0190231688,
0.0049488763,
0.0111329388,
0.0088384375,
0.0239880551,
-0.0368675068,
0.0019502487,
0.0317520462,
0.0573210306,
0.0671281144,
0.039398659,
0.0231996626,
0.0295636058,
0.0055523044,
-0.0093915202,
-0.0370508693,
-0.020561859,
0.0396414325,
0.0058105811,
0.0324071385,
-0.0121867554,
0.0234516859,
-0.0056447159,
-0.0802741721,
-0.0343411863,
0.0172017496,
0.0678312257,
0.0425984971,
0.0093726702,
-0.0404991359,
-0.0116009945,
-0.0215789229,
-0.0303692371,
-0.0570949353,
-0.0037618496,
0.0371037014,
0.020302603,
-0.0041462705,
-0.0156025402,
0.0292937998,
-0.0239352975,
0.0091187917,
0.0346146114,
0.007799712,
0.0166736003,
0.0163040999,
0.0298387278,
-0.0605501942,
-0.0051304824,
0.0024103457,
0.0015136985,
0.01954199,
0.0076704421,
0.0313807949,
-0.0016466638,
-0.0346753262,
-0.0103602009,
-0.0614674799,
-0.0140229994,
-0.0169112179,
0.0424759611,
0.0668486506,
-0.0169498418,
-0.0079378197,
0.0301929563,
0.0112299295,
0.0196666364,
-0.0250046458,
0.0103436066,
-0.0094708549,
0.0474939868,
-0.0747430995,
-0.0063642454,
-0.0497155525,
0.0372388773,
0.0309720039,
-0.092050001,
-0.0424728319,
0.0321664736,
2.665e-7,
0.0530743971,
0.0271088444,
0.0161253177,
0.0321415178,
0.0258590095,
0.0104843872,
-0.0209791213,
0.0317860395,
0.0289740711,
-0.027223587,
-0.0338762477,
0.0284989942,
0.0436727442,
-0.0009612903,
-0.1107954979,
-0.0098452875,
-0.0649590194,
0.0293226093,
-0.0279026758,
-0.0296851154,
-0.0015650373,
0.137267828,
0.0033935106,
-0.0062238597,
0.0104830312,
-0.0399155095,
0.0397641733,
0.0136977546,
-0.0011602525,
0.0067872782,
0.0154834362,
-0.0065712589,
-0.0103869801,
-0.0101679331,
-0.003886109,
0.0383182466,
-0.0067748413,
0.0849135891,
-0.0335406289,
-0.0494174436,
-0.0167678073,
-0.0239413902,
0.0186094195,
-0.0748560205,
0.0644622073,
-0.0375672579,
-0.0168056637,
-0.040847294,
0.011129545,
0.0047735116,
0.0182794742,
-0.0100942301,
-0.0052754492,
0.0096576642,
0.0309401155,
-0.0380473472,
-0.0332383998,
-0.0797428563,
-0.0782546699,
-0.0072555183,
-0.0414271913,
-0.0226357877,
-0.0823431686,
-0.0202946123,
0.0431069881,
-0.0460822135,
0.0005286466,
2.46192093e-34,
0.0300228354,
-0.0586761311,
0.0433448255,
0.0355509557,
0.0136289662,
-0.0225032084,
-0.0046681194,
-0.0018272974,
0.0239677727,
-0.0923315585,
-0.0330561511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15754v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15754v1 | Multimodal Segmentation for Vocal Tract Modeling | 2024-06-22T06:44:38 | 2024-06-22T06:44:38 | Rishi Jain, Bohan Yu, Peter Wu, Tejas Prabhune, Gopala Anumanchipalli | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Accurate modeling of the vocal tract is necessary to construct articulatory
representations for interpretable speech processing and linguistics. However,
vocal tract modeling is challenging because many internal articulators are
occluded from external motion capture technologies. Real-time magnetic
resonance imaging (RT-MRI) allows measuring precise movements of internal
articulators during speech, but annotated datasets of MRI are limited in size
due to time-consuming and computationally expensive labeling methods. We first
present a deep labeling strategy for the RT-MRI video using a vision-only
segmentation approach. We then introduce a multimodal algorithm using audio to
improve segmentation of vocal articulators. Together, we set a new benchmark
for vocal tract modeling in MRI video segmentation and use this to release
labels for a 75-speaker RT-MRI dataset, increasing the amount of labeled public
RT-MRI data of the vocal tract by over a factor of 9. The code and dataset
labels can be found at \url{rishiraij.github.io/multimodal-mri-avatar/}. | [
-0.029148059,
0.0806522295,
-0.0013108365,
0.0183721986,
0.0016058759,
-0.0072062914,
0.0563476905,
-0.004815401,
-0.0642697215,
0.0209219772,
-0.0466490686,
-0.0356345214,
0.0173379947,
-0.0121443868,
0.054161869,
-0.0880171135,
-0.0263019186,
-0.0668120682,
0.0192668885,
-0.0247580223,
-0.0071462649,
0.0065981396,
-0.1042758822,
0.0045233266,
-0.0638602823,
0.0022137021,
-0.0280264206,
-0.0019954254,
0.0655977055,
-0.025956329,
-0.0509705953,
0.0026813047,
0.0050751888,
0.039187897,
0.0000018588,
-0.0181322116,
-0.0239273589,
0.0691662431,
-0.0377779938,
0.0195322521,
0.0398850031,
0.0412097201,
-0.0249171797,
0.0056628538,
0.0061240741,
0.0018575848,
0.043197874,
-0.0037884086,
0.0833476409,
-0.0023529944,
-0.0301496759,
-0.0346030146,
0.0204782784,
-0.0265040454,
0.0084066521,
-0.0318797193,
0.0033611276,
0.0053674183,
0.0060251579,
-0.0055761002,
-0.0412866212,
0.1040961817,
-0.0185339116,
-0.0052738511,
0.0156613793,
0.0384661034,
-0.0225156918,
-0.0905752927,
0.0061524655,
0.0737225339,
0.0535632595,
0.0810558796,
0.0343221985,
0.0332543552,
-0.0243920963,
-0.0147934239,
-0.0067260414,
0.0458550118,
0.0184446592,
-0.0086792856,
-0.0880512074,
0.0257293507,
0.0336858779,
-0.0550265238,
0.0186762325,
-0.0189059284,
0.0202272739,
0.0130350888,
0.0299508404,
-0.0355619751,
-0.0089436742,
-0.0513252281,
0.0519879051,
0.0214467999,
0.0062546199,
-0.0088319089,
-0.0267059058,
-0.0668369681,
-0.0126111703,
0.0217996873,
-0.0235030577,
-0.0149444994,
-0.0608690493,
0.0458024703,
0.0016846777,
0.0007140454,
-0.0697024316,
0.0511386432,
0.0194044095,
-0.0407059677,
-0.0160410851,
-0.0315104611,
-0.0320293643,
-0.0227711387,
0.0087477118,
-0.0011185745,
-0.028222682,
-0.0236909222,
-0.0658871308,
0.0077900817,
-0.0096869413,
0.0364334732,
-0.0178598668,
-0.005140217,
-0.0070854612,
0.0318136998,
-0.0259224642,
0.0532608405,
-0.0174728241,
-0.0278368294,
0.0101378299,
0.0147427786,
0.0211220328,
-0.0075107873,
0.0155546945,
0.0345819816,
-0.0090931254,
0.0197788719,
0.0547177903,
-0.0256255288,
-0.031011574,
-0.0168558694,
0.034607064,
-0.0738642812,
0.0433353111,
-0.0461658239,
0.0112901377,
0.0097182021,
-0.029020736,
-0.0206836015,
0.0276894178,
0.0512504354,
0.0129212597,
0.028767189,
0.0667206794,
0.0221506655,
0.0121572549,
-0.0339482687,
0.0608180277,
-0.0085383467,
-0.0072722733,
-0.0071072308,
0.0093525825,
0.069894135,
0.0242360923,
-0.0373902842,
-0.0534662046,
-0.0656360239,
-0.0171048064,
0.0690252706,
0.0297825411,
0.0235444345,
-0.0115592144,
-0.0512435548,
0.0285661798,
0.04128379,
0.013141769,
-0.0279787648,
-0.0241290685,
0.0068625626,
0.00559298,
-0.0603891239,
0.0332877636,
0.0704911426,
0.0579923429,
-0.0212150253,
0.0608918369,
0.0320377015,
-0.040684741,
0.0181652438,
-0.0247220285,
-0.0157190841,
-0.0252125897,
0.0393972732,
0.0553968251,
0.0060148956,
-0.0164426286,
0.044935707,
-0.0319702104,
-0.0045421682,
-0.0020329163,
-0.0348484144,
-0.0415242277,
-0.0104590403,
-0.0308081768,
-0.0714960322,
-0.0172048137,
-0.0316635445,
0.0558461659,
0.0508744195,
-0.0089670522,
-0.0210670847,
0.0844191015,
-0.0460512042,
-0.0061808936,
0.0290245935,
0.0103146723,
-0.0105044721,
-0.0048574428,
-0.0024811872,
-0.0273396056,
-0.0558839776,
0.1074640229,
0.0330568217,
-0.0174241681,
0.0137816407,
-0.0198255926,
0.0233222768,
0.0502458625,
0.0039451923,
-0.0437250026,
-0.0236262251,
-0.0234974604,
0.008765582,
0.0183082819,
0.0198276471,
-0.0221465174,
-0.019231081,
0.0403609276,
-0.0601889119,
-0.03685138,
0.0121476548,
-0.0012886872,
-0.0477652624,
0.0042402493,
-0.0396192893,
-0.0105856946,
-0.04267703,
-0.0212994441,
0.0173375066,
-0.0300006289,
-0.0047081932,
-0.0303526558,
0.0112263765,
-0.0197302848,
0.0485208593,
-0.011310041,
-0.0396198258,
-0.048546169,
-0.0600518547,
0.0344640836,
0.0003597323,
0.0070876074,
-0.0390568078,
-0.0513362549,
-0.0061837346,
-0.033010684,
-0.0400176086,
0.0186132491,
0.0304393303,
-0.0208728388,
-0.0107873837,
-0.0099081388,
0.0079306643,
-0.0180042163,
-0.0148485219,
0.0089003779,
-0.0082255099,
-0.0113779549,
-0.0073831882,
0.0047006677,
-0.0288237091,
-0.0275037047,
0.016861923,
0.0100259362,
-0.026681846,
-0.0052961805,
-0.0239569023,
0.0253131613,
-0.0436517522,
-0.0081162015,
0.0107810311,
-0.0214432124,
0.0074326121,
-0.0032465656,
-0.0032390999,
-0.0109335147,
0.0118116103,
-0.024739692,
0.012602549,
0.0244251285,
-0.0158746392,
0.0164351612,
-0.0084475018,
0.0218047705,
0.0450026244,
-0.0540022813,
-0.0130946301,
-0.0251210518,
0.0492891297,
0.0371478759,
0.0508653261,
-0.0046915757,
-0.0223754887,
-0.0325226448,
-0.0232211296,
-0.0055274451,
0.0518128388,
-0.0451408401,
0.0174120534,
-0.0386164822,
-0.0137536032,
0.0600174218,
-0.0458722711,
-0.1067684218,
0.0327450186,
-0.0366137326,
0.0071362914,
0.0243724231,
-0.0086610718,
0.0222964026,
-0.0198350362,
-0.0436911769,
-0.0555469804,
0.0141740609,
0.0257449783,
-0.0364531055,
-0.0031932634,
-0.023944281,
-0.003503846,
-0.0169520006,
0.0340615585,
-0.0190632213,
0.0460683219,
-0.0192330405,
0.0242671631,
-0.0232950374,
-0.0173293985,
0.007245,
0.0035061599,
0.0694009811,
0.0414531603,
0.0193044953,
0.0186770298,
0.001900784,
0.0525632352,
0.0020755555,
0.0375189669,
-0.1086041629,
-0.0555258505,
0.0295048971,
-0.0088882428,
0.0102971615,
0.0236460064,
-0.0623788647,
0.0081943646,
-0.0155906612,
0.0253878459,
-0.0108605158,
0.0046379282,
0.032652311,
-0.0057063927,
0.0093370322,
0.0638507381,
-0.0151944058,
0.0160615668,
-0.0101199187,
0.0767405406,
0.0133059109,
0.0243029445,
-0.0090400521,
-0.0233473033,
-0.0161971934,
0.0673601925,
0.0179265831,
0.0484911203,
0.0374540947,
-0.0176587906,
-0.0034028948,
0.0717414469,
-0.0172616765,
-0.0613441877,
0.0401394889,
0.0207680389,
0.0362480171,
-0.0407275148,
-0.0149465837,
-0.0220478922,
0.0260489807,
-0.0229782704,
0.0716221854,
-0.068957381,
-0.0354075804,
0.0235180575,
-0.0503515862,
0.0433449522,
0.0188533459,
0.0333988406,
-0.0396985449,
-0.0335290879,
0.0493540354,
0.0879432857,
-0.0445301272,
-0.0016522238,
0.0759941414,
0.0252217688,
-0.0046329722,
0.0045676171,
0.046637468,
0.0043369089,
-0.002972116,
-0.0051235082,
0.0690260231,
-0.0140544763,
0.0480542593,
-0.016804507,
0.0463588275,
-0.012672523,
0.0187030546,
-0.0184188634,
-0.02757564,
0.016989544,
0.0411120728,
0.0851676986,
-0.0249936935,
-0.021860173,
0.026224561,
-0.006863228,
-0.0625287965,
0.0000165897,
0.0393129848,
0.0601489209,
0.027463885,
0.0271031037,
-0.0068081026,
0.0198362619,
0.0093674725,
-0.046090588,
0.0193488635,
-0.0343680605,
0.0468751118,
0.01128125,
-0.0591107495,
0.0363106132,
0.0076501458,
-0.0074419798,
0.0446180068,
-0.0752129927,
-0.0369938016,
0.0067705135,
0.0136174131,
0.0173394065,
0.0553155728,
-0.0176422,
-0.0442095958,
0.0500318184,
-0.026799107,
0.0325060636,
0.0514576398,
0.0644508079,
-0.0201416779,
-0.0259200092,
-0.0029592414,
-0.0480987057,
0.0218022913,
-0.0464795604,
-0.01390306,
-0.0359548293,
-0.0475623868,
-0.0358655043,
-0.0016229202,
0.0374100208,
-0.0044220537,
0.0225685928,
-0.0909023061,
0.0016067943,
0.018512534,
0.0429056548,
-0.0505130067,
-0.0159127358,
0.0527715348,
0.0303759407,
-0.0067143124,
-0.0037032212,
0.0157899745,
0.0015192142,
0.0269899555,
0.0716983303,
0.0082538994,
0.0077697192,
-0.0290037561,
0.0536417812,
0.0471817777,
0.0360909216,
-0.0040844884,
0.0126190148,
0.0390024334,
0.0163136106,
0.0066303057,
-0.0212880392,
0.0108881015,
0.0249481536,
0.0077042165,
-0.0152121363,
0.0008756075,
0.0306039024,
-0.0020376204,
0.0053495043,
0.0303384904,
0.018509062,
-0.0077581764,
-0.0032221789,
0.0601219609,
-0.0287721697,
-0.0214827936,
0.0552673079,
-0.0061032274,
0.0195804965,
-0.0005514691,
0.0197055433,
0.0065017585,
0.0026616801,
-0.0285054985,
0.0187921226,
-0.0470395349,
-0.0024570534,
-0.0279908068,
-0.0155566465,
-0.0175749753,
-0.0284032077,
0.0133883953,
-0.0591950603,
0.0093852561,
-0.0351922661,
-0.0253652483,
-0.0271207113,
0.0391376093,
-0.0029531491,
-0.007531222,
-0.0081911702,
0.008492291,
-0.0535442792,
0.0032662188,
-0.0156703275,
0.0256977454,
-5.40837053e-33,
-0.0398718901,
0.0094015589,
0.0268752854,
-0.0239302535,
-0.0492297225,
0.034177199,
-0.0455841348,
0.0117217954,
0.002902613,
0.0327667408,
0.0476528555,
-0.0177813713,
0.0284061916,
-0.0036097888,
-0.0119077777,
-0.015195976,
0.0579516329,
-0.0530916601,
0.0055208532,
-0.0096655581,
-0.0062580113,
0.0354875959,
0.0630406961,
-0.0566668697,
-0.0345251076,
0.0395419337,
-0.0221701954,
0.0227859896,
-0.0054665832,
0.0210690498,
-0.0589286536,
-0.010257585,
-0.0025918032,
-0.0635271966,
0.0005159305,
-0.0204218365,
-0.0714994445,
0.0143706724,
-0.026151713,
0.0604153164,
-0.0462217107,
0.0194858722,
0.0260012187,
-0.0160661619,
0.0358648486,
-0.042667985,
0.0753932968,
-0.0346156359,
0.0144460835,
-0.0335088484,
0.0202582665,
0.015308708,
-0.0139328148,
-0.0876792967,
0.0662420392,
0.0187113285,
0.0087429183,
0.0288308747,
-0.0593869574,
-0.0035630083,
-0.0030643533,
0.0246258061,
0.0673362985,
0.0627315044,
0.0040857405,
0.064530924,
0.0715933591,
-0.0809056237,
0.0350223742,
0.0537478551,
0.0219389144,
0.0881899372,
-0.0051841876,
-0.0028596416,
0.0040621497,
0.0017995783,
-0.0142897479,
-0.016586978,
-0.062577419,
-0.0173435379,
0.0099974275,
0.0499643609,
-0.0033901115,
0.0123037267,
-0.0301129036,
-0.0540075079,
-0.0128243463,
0.0561062507,
0.0297416616,
0.0083994893,
-0.0166606717,
0.0200806838,
0.0516160987,
0.0311843343,
0.0040391795,
-0.0586939752,
-0.0009971808,
0.0176638756,
0.0024344809,
-0.0069580977,
0.0098668896,
-0.0242060926,
0.0568213426,
0.0399267264,
0.0866788998,
-0.040872585,
-0.041684892,
0.0279838238,
-0.0399676189,
-0.0017805499,
-0.0154626388,
0.0095292218,
-0.0167055447,
0.0638492852,
0.0388475172,
-0.0239169467,
-0.0429924056,
0.040713761,
-0.0144120539,
0.034004733,
-0.020690605,
-0.0109118968,
-0.0596597232,
-0.0089676958,
-0.0340332724,
0.0123237316,
0.0340003036,
-0.0829064026,
0.0644988194,
-0.0576700717,
-0.0282742754,
-0.0016812721,
2.66e-7,
0.0073102568,
-0.0073333634,
0.0669344589,
-0.016980879,
0.0253014769,
0.027092522,
-0.0553260893,
0.0063850773,
-0.0186915826,
-0.0922704414,
0.0123046348,
0.0224427823,
0.087420851,
0.0569307916,
-0.0298081804,
-0.0298684333,
-0.0471917391,
0.0235060118,
-0.0200171322,
0.0029834385,
-0.004821023,
0.063363634,
0.0183244627,
-0.0659473762,
0.028717868,
-0.0258148424,
0.0142554529,
-0.0088524362,
0.01586584,
-0.0342334956,
0.020331135,
0.0248891972,
-0.0059413286,
-0.012480909,
-0.0113613028,
-0.0414868854,
0.0364735052,
0.0419294834,
-0.0436686762,
-0.0720543936,
0.0242687054,
0.072303243,
-0.0539891943,
0.0615418665,
0.0341017917,
-0.0127574028,
-0.0217621699,
-0.0507993475,
0.0073366393,
0.0076615261,
0.0238874946,
-0.014538168,
0.0095276907,
0.0131472927,
0.0079908697,
-0.0330309682,
-0.0354374908,
-0.0327978581,
-0.0161424801,
-0.0373280235,
-0.111653626,
-0.02076062,
0.0190490037,
-0.025792148,
-0.0467002317,
-0.0184268206,
-0.0446819887,
1.621154909e-34,
-0.0052802451,
-0.0284317322,
0.0007812596,
0.0368275531,
-0.019760225,
0.0121521354,
0.0172417387,
0.0178983081,
-0.0305097569,
0.0016974873,
-0.0658315495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15752v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15752v1 | TacoLM: GaTed Attention Equipped Codec Language Model are Efficient Zero-Shot Text to Speech Synthesizers | 2024-06-22T06:39:52 | 2024-06-22T06:39:52 | Yakun Song, Zhuo Chen, Xiaofei Wang, Ziyang Ma, Guanrou Yang, Xie Chen | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL | Neural codec language model (LM) has demonstrated strong capability in
zero-shot text-to-speech (TTS) synthesis. However, the codec LM often suffers
from limitations in inference speed and stability, due to its auto-regressive
nature and implicit alignment between text and audio. In this work, to handle
these challenges, we introduce a new variant of neural codec LM, namely TacoLM.
Specifically, TacoLM introduces a gated attention mechanism to improve the
training and inference efficiency and reduce the model size. Meanwhile, an
additional gated cross-attention layer is included for each decoder layer,
which improves the efficiency and content accuracy of the synthesized speech.
In the evaluation of the Librispeech corpus, the proposed TacoLM achieves a
better word error rate, speaker similarity, and mean opinion score, with 90%
fewer parameters and 5.2 times speed up, compared with VALL-E. Demo and code is
available at https://ereboas.github.io/TacoLM/. | [
-0.0197796095,
0.0202009082,
0.046079848,
0.0281983204,
0.0143833905,
-0.0311659016,
0.027356036,
-0.0249309223,
-0.0607796535,
-0.0186269302,
-0.0630179718,
-0.0452653728,
0.0284673218,
0.0682354793,
0.0448512696,
-0.0376560502,
0.0199932735,
-0.0175463073,
0.0076883999,
-0.0050794366,
0.0014203474,
0.0122726243,
-0.0403762572,
0.0222700872,
0.0015381509,
-0.0076215155,
-0.0264583621,
0.0289830286,
0.0196377281,
-0.0227383096,
-0.0341830514,
0.0132621676,
0.0067609153,
0.0332096741,
0.0000022598,
-0.0056904452,
0.0004863889,
-0.0172417071,
-0.003038673,
0.0070669106,
0.0434983484,
0.0026195492,
-0.0422470942,
0.0151026323,
0.0024507933,
-0.0350113623,
0.0485048704,
0.0504156351,
0.0460942723,
0.1038408875,
-0.0021761185,
-0.0504029989,
0.0320198685,
-0.0116581479,
0.0106382398,
0.0086201839,
-0.0499917679,
-0.0437993929,
0.0168490857,
0.0087523926,
-0.0483388267,
0.0440485701,
0.0239141323,
-0.0338890254,
0.0275288671,
0.0250446703,
-0.0454861708,
-0.0409794673,
0.0064615081,
0.1011718661,
-0.014189153,
-0.0165775344,
0.0040519089,
0.01941346,
-0.0133578228,
-0.0424779207,
-0.0152558647,
0.0225364771,
0.0338429995,
0.0233736131,
-0.0183551554,
0.0329467282,
-0.0047849878,
-0.0502115898,
-0.0035563337,
0.0129397186,
-0.0022507675,
-0.0243485011,
-0.01405886,
0.0013880846,
0.0185119119,
-0.0321986228,
0.0115485042,
0.0421290435,
-0.0042769988,
-0.0322553255,
-0.0727436617,
-0.0461222902,
-0.0399753079,
-0.0522199497,
0.0298260581,
0.0557209812,
-0.0490102991,
0.0059713325,
-0.0535483249,
0.0611865744,
-0.0049916953,
-0.0035420202,
-0.0166124441,
-0.0218267031,
-0.0076122549,
0.02710348,
-0.0271447487,
0.0384929441,
-0.0124312667,
-0.0478384756,
-0.032091219,
-0.01044505,
-0.0341839567,
0.0079499511,
0.0187617056,
0.0385875851,
-0.0257440917,
-0.0302305911,
0.013721914,
0.0397690162,
0.0074131782,
0.0164920464,
-0.02290277,
-0.0460437536,
-0.0348459929,
0.0449155606,
0.0183025561,
0.0247245319,
0.0244206134,
0.0268670134,
0.0128676444,
-0.030498635,
-0.0522962771,
-0.0192930177,
-0.0105711296,
-0.0614880212,
0.0024985685,
-0.0783041269,
0.0283628665,
-0.0182205327,
-0.0098877624,
-0.0264264066,
-0.0056560915,
0.0180125684,
0.0011961071,
0.0362276249,
-0.0251842774,
0.0089125969,
0.0092126159,
-0.0178314541,
0.0226942599,
0.0585839674,
0.0570746362,
-0.0062317909,
-0.0434723757,
-0.0100092515,
-0.0053345421,
0.0101628276,
0.0355171934,
-0.0081631159,
-0.0624571927,
0.0048586936,
-0.0312373303,
0.0314483196,
0.1265165955,
0.0436474495,
-0.020180257,
-0.0073418552,
0.0999365821,
0.023237776,
0.0546491072,
0.0304835178,
0.0628709793,
0.0280253161,
-0.0045935288,
-0.0095713241,
-0.0085476376,
0.0928408876,
0.0087360423,
0.048814401,
0.0822324604,
0.016869938,
-0.0642902255,
-0.0140991686,
0.0140992943,
-0.0331039205,
0.0010406313,
-0.0294877347,
0.0046254392,
0.0250274669,
-0.0690040141,
0.0547773764,
0.0089475941,
-0.0728310049,
-0.0057675838,
-0.0074663465,
0.0152697833,
0.0708172843,
-0.0053978129,
0.0259415545,
-0.0249974988,
-0.0775521472,
0.0004669121,
0.0873031691,
0.018898163,
0.015591166,
0.0131460056,
-0.0716625899,
-0.0037143582,
-0.0178990774,
-0.0203332193,
0.0352835506,
-0.0367643312,
0.0634067208,
0.0027549821,
0.0205288008,
0.0440610908,
-0.0091274064,
0.0042217188,
-0.0391874462,
-0.0107308663,
0.0116242515,
0.0568934381,
0.0574206337,
-0.0530975796,
0.0229420066,
-0.004968165,
-0.0510245599,
-0.0201992858,
-0.0018508255,
-0.0821837485,
-0.0654115826,
0.0349376313,
-0.0675896928,
0.0192019623,
0.0514708199,
0.0300950278,
-0.0808164552,
0.08692763,
-0.0243143179,
0.0429204516,
-0.0211994685,
0.0422996208,
0.02278951,
0.0195551645,
0.0326264836,
0.0090008546,
-0.0078349728,
-0.0039864932,
0.0506147705,
0.0291298497,
-0.0086793005,
-0.0562018827,
-0.0359043218,
0.0045406315,
-0.0171605758,
0.0162198581,
-0.0356628373,
0.0278546736,
0.0090915449,
0.0058791316,
-0.0621012188,
0.0060742027,
-0.0155650973,
-0.0004173807,
-0.0148153324,
0.0120894639,
0.0016291431,
0.0003108471,
-0.0251979399,
-0.0147706531,
-0.0064394413,
-0.0430861302,
-0.0118881231,
-0.0395321399,
-0.0198938679,
-0.0248427987,
0.0071042283,
0.0311601199,
0.0041335905,
-0.0286575388,
-0.0138400849,
-0.0105362562,
0.0154189616,
0.0044354601,
0.0234706309,
0.0483936705,
-0.0262590069,
-0.007949804,
0.0273764338,
0.0202559866,
0.0346322209,
-0.0147466054,
-0.031336993,
-0.0054701869,
0.0107202008,
-0.0402398705,
0.0218815543,
0.0204673838,
0.0209219418,
-0.0007921073,
-0.0138793718,
-0.004717458,
0.0831305012,
0.0137062203,
0.0186815616,
-0.0841946527,
-0.0092929993,
0.010484728,
0.0068403212,
0.0492311791,
-0.012959837,
-0.0387629122,
-0.0143768582,
-0.0283847023,
-0.0287502892,
0.0457597002,
-0.0726596862,
-0.0506062023,
-0.0311822109,
0.0118596591,
-0.0204329211,
-0.0235505141,
-0.0016639946,
0.0369894803,
0.0195542481,
-0.0138052674,
-0.0120485006,
0.0060065663,
-0.0260452442,
-0.0276213344,
0.0502220541,
0.0217890888,
0.0213893969,
-0.0223457441,
-0.0006462858,
0.0087878695,
0.0106582586,
-0.0379646383,
0.0567197092,
0.00998904,
-0.0288813282,
-0.0135177355,
0.0414104089,
0.0241971351,
0.0368722491,
-0.0022219045,
0.0219695363,
-0.0264274627,
0.0315475948,
0.0379711129,
-0.0229076296,
-0.0169451274,
0.013083511,
0.0449525528,
0.0130879609,
0.0070817298,
0.080634959,
-0.0695803463,
-0.0088617848,
0.028724717,
0.0217773914,
-0.0118833072,
0.0082046045,
0.0347878039,
-0.0305860341,
0.0091537097,
0.124404408,
-0.0288939029,
-0.0458859727,
0.0000549328,
0.010949702,
0.0303964783,
0.007904388,
-0.0028603736,
-0.0631622672,
-0.0451553017,
0.0201669149,
0.040647693,
0.0170460455,
0.0122720506,
-0.0319997519,
-0.1436577588,
0.0248761624,
0.0300162397,
-0.0163663551,
-0.0618996285,
-0.0238667056,
-0.0263548736,
-0.0017505556,
-0.0026343763,
0.061455518,
-0.007848965,
-0.0288416222,
0.02356687,
-0.0248547215,
-0.0437465571,
-0.0133830821,
-0.0708044767,
0.1357943863,
0.0591458492,
0.0381519087,
0.0179376695,
-0.0190784931,
0.0050856699,
0.0046114684,
-0.0020526475,
-0.0032095802,
0.041101411,
-0.0359310731,
-0.0073501277,
0.0292486381,
0.0612449721,
-0.0240180865,
0.0549642928,
-0.0342078917,
0.0498082936,
0.0121918377,
-0.0020193362,
-0.0435600765,
0.0558455735,
-0.0018634549,
0.0715902597,
0.0435592867,
-0.0698250011,
-0.0251225494,
-0.0149325747,
-0.0154723264,
-0.1167398766,
-0.0477816798,
0.0123606585,
-0.0059365672,
-0.0623076819,
-0.0115674138,
-0.0446760133,
-0.0148704788,
0.0146839246,
-0.0117843514,
-0.0334219038,
-0.0043988558,
-0.0166593827,
-0.0319392867,
0.0043994877,
-0.0037298498,
0.0190040767,
-0.0654119328,
-0.0182110127,
0.0051056291,
-0.0330887139,
0.0130087752,
0.0335400291,
-0.0828750357,
-0.0473518111,
-0.0364570543,
0.0295609031,
0.0106583182,
0.0412583761,
-0.0009440767,
-0.0361537039,
0.0656612143,
-0.0134878103,
-0.0314406715,
0.0588303357,
0.0488054492,
0.0294717234,
0.0020760973,
0.0348238945,
-0.0363346115,
0.0450491942,
0.028129071,
0.0402464457,
0.0018657292,
-0.0322629251,
-0.0118637979,
-0.0239951946,
0.0047871708,
-0.0024051084,
0.0703222677,
-0.0279120505,
0.0189053416,
-0.0284607261,
0.0530135669,
-0.0685437843,
-0.0119110569,
0.0256088097,
-0.011182175,
-0.006633189,
-0.0074890349,
-0.0571539104,
0.0038070867,
0.0030492528,
0.0490114167,
0.0060311486,
0.0012055152,
0.0185476206,
-0.0307721961,
-0.0336080901,
0.0137453396,
-0.0215615593,
-0.0014099751,
-0.0014470203,
0.0063404194,
0.0026106222,
0.0306963343,
-0.0009113582,
0.0205685683,
-0.0071893986,
0.0147937126,
-0.0392287746,
0.0028496464,
0.0443002731,
0.0294916406,
0.1026433185,
0.0230268538,
0.0223757457,
-0.0073891729,
0.0209234823,
-0.0324056074,
-0.0119032227,
0.0070117605,
-0.0033397381,
0.0039243097,
-0.0104103712,
0.0517664365,
0.0250453819,
-0.0310456548,
-0.0154833207,
0.0465219729,
-0.0169826914,
0.0042167045,
-0.0111327656,
-0.0054652086,
-0.010565809,
0.0085870894,
-0.0265399646,
-0.0362706184,
0.0700509176,
-0.0155932261,
0.002755732,
-0.0366470404,
0.0502329543,
-0.0421604179,
-0.0113161337,
0.0076757283,
0.0002935393,
-0.0316193439,
0.0020742565,
-0.0499254987,
-0.0414004661,
-6.440003106e-33,
-0.0530146137,
0.0262149554,
0.0079235742,
-0.0096069193,
-0.045923695,
0.0031465855,
-0.0468066819,
0.00354424,
-0.035138391,
-0.0078665977,
0.0048095505,
0.0207105298,
0.0039905752,
0.0722073391,
-0.0148048839,
0.0131510962,
0.0615347214,
-0.0386357345,
-0.0167080443,
0.0397473797,
0.0315894075,
0.0368752405,
0.0275419522,
-0.0346025489,
-0.0032869906,
-0.024137212,
0.0094672777,
-0.045252461,
0.0495371781,
0.0348806717,
0.0046654888,
0.0537773483,
-0.0070965681,
-0.053598091,
-0.0351434425,
0.0306180418,
-0.0524887592,
-0.022477122,
0.0054235109,
0.0088288197,
0.0086637856,
-0.0366177373,
0.0499188825,
0.0298986863,
-0.0523484796,
-0.0703277364,
0.0094016129,
-0.0224642847,
-0.0389092751,
-0.0799574926,
-0.049628906,
0.0283087809,
-0.0196057037,
-0.0549513176,
0.0318966694,
0.0915645361,
-0.0408292785,
0.0242923927,
-0.087536104,
0.0326923616,
0.0021165176,
0.0400986075,
0.0625911728,
0.0100843068,
-0.0141164856,
0.0343195237,
0.0282752682,
-0.061388351,
-0.0472956263,
0.000515337,
0.0309537202,
0.0134124737,
0.0548942909,
0.0047962707,
0.0264350101,
-0.0124372113,
-0.0104708597,
-0.0073832567,
-0.0106215803,
0.0246095639,
0.048661992,
0.0191157386,
-0.0166307818,
-0.0092794672,
-0.0203903653,
-0.0597867891,
-0.0371861979,
-0.0433284193,
0.0431701764,
0.0043381243,
0.0125111425,
-0.0462948345,
0.0792593658,
-0.0190552194,
0.0585519858,
0.0077890572,
-0.0152059542,
0.0321708471,
0.0120621826,
0.0277859122,
-0.0769389644,
0.0211141333,
0.0378007963,
0.030412741,
0.0026218712,
0.0101164412,
0.0236852076,
0.0500236824,
-0.0544235632,
-0.0352191292,
-0.0018159106,
0.0219167937,
-0.0098862126,
0.0617634989,
0.0154535845,
-0.0008756432,
0.0093485517,
0.060308408,
-0.0322742574,
-0.0006468539,
0.0232203789,
-0.0154587021,
0.0086603193,
0.0163420551,
-0.0485316627,
0.0410482958,
-0.02710489,
0.043380253,
0.0050918404,
-0.0559462868,
-0.030807294,
0.0310741533,
2.957e-7,
-0.0245696623,
-0.0303273909,
0.0012344121,
-0.0263659023,
0.0111425007,
0.0161020625,
0.0078134583,
0.0630949736,
-0.0167980809,
0.0016053284,
-0.0203635357,
0.024528861,
0.0692264438,
0.0000243677,
-0.1025093421,
-0.0109121259,
-0.0667117462,
0.0334854573,
-0.025373837,
-0.0015462899,
0.0224061105,
0.0844146684,
-0.0271648075,
-0.020481633,
0.0420478992,
0.0131978253,
0.0245059505,
0.0229042638,
-0.0183045361,
-0.0359926708,
0.0445880406,
-0.0113825202,
-0.0753662586,
-0.0305351969,
-0.0243301187,
0.0215973277,
-0.0102287121,
0.047289215,
-0.0111930501,
-0.0797239468,
0.0253424495,
-0.0124992849,
-0.0553218164,
0.0080216583,
0.0548037216,
-0.0123307658,
-0.0198523272,
0.0105431434,
-0.0279295817,
0.0433764234,
0.0020088647,
-0.0416066423,
0.0095189521,
-0.0279566571,
0.0576413423,
-0.0280188341,
-0.0343825668,
-0.0415345803,
-0.0235413536,
-0.0046148114,
-0.0148586147,
-0.0116797853,
-0.0292570405,
-0.0140545061,
0.0662584156,
-0.0174327511,
-0.0156591553,
2.466345105e-34,
0.0454793163,
-0.0435486138,
0.0433583595,
-0.0251780599,
-0.0187134519,
-0.0195840355,
-0.0087788822,
-0.007711906,
0.01322468,
-0.0494425371,
-0.0465905368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15741v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15741v1 | Ladder: A Model-Agnostic Framework Boosting LLM-based Machine Translation to the Next Level | 2024-06-22T05:33:35 | 2024-06-22T05:33:35 | Zhaopeng Feng, Ruizhe Chen, Yan Zhang, Zijie Meng, Zuozhu Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | General-purpose Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4 have achieved
remarkable advancements in machine translation (MT) by leveraging extensive web
content. On the other hand, translation-specific LLMs are built by pre-training
on domain-specific monolingual corpora and fine-tuning with human-annotated
translation data. Despite the superior performance, these methods either demand
an unprecedented scale of computing and data or substantial human editing and
annotation efforts. In this paper, we develop Ladder, a novel model-agnostic
and cost-effective tool to refine the performance of general LLMs for MT.
Ladder is trained on pseudo-refinement triplets which can be easily obtained
from existing LLMs without additional human cost. During training, we propose a
hierarchical fine-tuning strategy with an easy-to-hard schema, improving
Ladder's refining performance progressively. The trained Ladder can be
seamlessly integrated with any general-purpose LLMs to boost their translation
performance. By utilizing Gemma-2B/7B as the backbone, Ladder-2B can elevate
raw translations to the level of top-tier open-source models (e.g., refining
BigTranslate-13B with +6.91 BLEU and +3.52 COMET for XX-En), and Ladder-7B can
further enhance model performance to be on par with the state-of-the-art GPT-4.
Extensive ablation and analysis corroborate the effectiveness of Ladder in
diverse settings. Our code is available at https://github.com/fzp0424/Ladder | [
0.0472110808,
0.0636693686,
0.0071078152,
0.0443910733,
-0.0093548391,
0.0212694053,
-0.0080347173,
0.0011431392,
-0.0050627906,
-0.039280843,
-0.0558285266,
-0.0252069589,
0.0137301479,
0.0178033151,
0.0425301306,
-0.0386034958,
0.0326021463,
-0.0239874423,
-0.0388230197,
0.0089025153,
-0.0101660127,
0.0186432395,
0.0364601277,
0.0189869143,
0.0124539714,
0.009739521,
0.0065972065,
0.0901457965,
0.0352511778,
-0.01148789,
0.0211280826,
0.0525766872,
0.038134627,
0.0897277296,
0.0000024173,
-0.024927564,
-0.0497413985,
0.019230796,
0.0026494965,
0.042436529,
0.0267137792,
-0.0518533401,
-0.0255516395,
0.0292422455,
-0.0258795209,
-0.008356858,
0.0464496166,
-0.006280249,
0.072781533,
0.0915732756,
-0.0107708639,
-0.0426716506,
0.0290151145,
-0.0752157792,
-0.0196077116,
-0.0699429587,
-0.0065319417,
0.0307084695,
-0.0307333637,
0.0525884293,
0.0071213758,
0.027440913,
0.0041384422,
-0.0068555693,
-0.020513406,
-0.0152968131,
-0.0154840881,
-0.0399001725,
-0.0127189877,
0.0796005949,
-0.0454641916,
-0.0170306712,
-0.0151561731,
0.0087642493,
-0.0151850265,
-0.0334445909,
-0.0262904,
0.0148659525,
0.0076266951,
0.009663051,
0.0099693015,
-0.0070620594,
0.0509966351,
0.0139594106,
-0.0474297404,
0.008482377,
0.0416160263,
-0.0028138247,
-0.0050855679,
0.0221118797,
-0.0306027476,
-0.0112984506,
0.037193574,
-0.0166044291,
0.0148133487,
-0.0006987342,
-0.0256988332,
-0.0034548473,
0.0153783392,
-0.0317578614,
0.0478147604,
0.0809133872,
-0.0000976766,
0.0550069846,
-0.0267488547,
0.0366051234,
-0.0409790277,
0.0190173797,
-0.0822244734,
-0.0014770664,
-0.0147761516,
0.0437613241,
-0.040150214,
-0.0222759247,
-0.0522133559,
0.0132733155,
-0.032837294,
0.0172916669,
0.0293168053,
-0.0083335377,
0.0403429419,
-0.0271088146,
-0.0498453043,
-0.0396067463,
0.0181163121,
0.0454490073,
-0.0039225034,
-0.0265257582,
0.0128119718,
-0.0706617683,
-0.0263171848,
0.0119295707,
-0.010468537,
-0.023155598,
0.0135626327,
0.0752117261,
-0.013361834,
-0.0360908359,
-0.0068359012,
0.0084175179,
-0.0073684496,
-0.0878720656,
-0.018613236,
-0.0600722432,
0.0414806083,
0.0101089971,
0.0200989861,
-0.0609262809,
0.0161440969,
-0.0021724906,
-0.0234096479,
0.0534094684,
-0.032744769,
-0.0036190299,
0.029860517,
0.0030961905,
-0.0393121466,
0.062765725,
0.052260831,
0.052018635,
0.0239531118,
-0.0060882536,
-0.0078169946,
0.0781045109,
-0.0018463935,
0.0541903824,
-0.0051523265,
-0.0034918198,
0.0024088416,
0.0468660556,
0.0530630313,
0.0277240667,
-0.0177993719,
0.0100881159,
0.0936295018,
0.0010174265,
0.0011214148,
0.0682412684,
0.0426798686,
0.0184745211,
0.0146992933,
-0.0233311821,
-0.0465644225,
0.003615221,
-0.0187234487,
-0.0028302209,
0.0268819276,
0.0547734909,
0.0004909593,
-0.0222423244,
-0.0068252631,
-0.0014997115,
0.0136794532,
0.0008886301,
0.0309349466,
-0.0144058568,
-0.0690051392,
0.0431066342,
0.0151449665,
-0.0677301884,
0.0195455719,
-0.0392116494,
-0.0275433566,
0.0796979219,
0.0567994677,
0.0121139036,
-0.0652157441,
-0.0141290613,
0.0188591722,
0.0594781749,
0.0529057011,
0.0241069086,
0.0011350806,
-0.0590370521,
-0.0302276351,
0.0068887225,
0.0155113982,
0.0341474041,
0.036720898,
0.0112326387,
0.0519694835,
-0.044357501,
-0.0693668202,
0.0240404215,
-0.0246037096,
-0.0133852791,
0.0105738807,
-0.0118301911,
0.0182255134,
0.0128468294,
-0.0121132825,
-0.0157527495,
0.0296892971,
-0.0326109044,
-0.0099441586,
-0.007736397,
0.0014287865,
-0.0209199041,
0.0477519445,
0.0136302821,
-0.0081379395,
0.0293619987,
-0.0697909892,
-0.0379485823,
-0.0246791802,
-0.0218943544,
0.0070057632,
-0.0490894318,
0.0495968796,
-0.0014438808,
0.0121792518,
-0.0485362075,
0.0141809648,
-0.0067047114,
-0.0382903665,
-0.0003282541,
-0.0320518129,
0.002339981,
-0.0066568833,
-0.0190346148,
0.0359310098,
0.0305328108,
0.0602548197,
0.0249400735,
0.0473981239,
-0.0379429013,
-0.0358187892,
-0.1011819541,
0.0299834106,
-0.024632439,
0.053108409,
0.0313000306,
0.0539897569,
-0.0302109029,
0.0116205104,
-0.0026502891,
-0.0023122081,
-0.016411975,
0.0045926757,
-0.0049357032,
-0.0176644493,
0.0038865127,
-0.0372123942,
-0.0092354566,
0.0313667916,
0.012859825,
-0.0009829464,
-0.0376003012,
-0.0558814108,
0.0063106348,
-0.0395893529,
0.0072196047,
-0.0005131898,
-0.0769229382,
-0.026389068,
-0.030471867,
0.035914477,
0.025842879,
0.0016626007,
-0.013107012,
0.0177713595,
0.0055452799,
-0.0544421636,
0.0147215463,
-0.010696156,
-0.0814141184,
-0.0261358339,
-0.0326448306,
-0.0015591759,
0.0556853786,
-0.0169662684,
0.0020413348,
-0.0619400479,
-0.015446174,
-0.0020858787,
-0.0156962611,
-0.0017398346,
0.0538627803,
-0.0044354056,
0.0363233872,
-0.0286760274,
-0.0600220673,
0.0473333746,
-0.0540702045,
0.0025195305,
-0.0406044424,
0.0034199888,
-0.0532734953,
0.0378007703,
-0.0150295356,
0.0186570454,
-0.0316308364,
0.000981545,
-0.0197528582,
0.0290175211,
0.0223166496,
-0.0357280746,
0.0318319164,
-0.0650096238,
0.0180926956,
-0.0408483408,
-0.0197345763,
-0.0078972662,
0.0119051663,
-0.0078063183,
-0.0110818688,
0.0121095832,
-0.0455496423,
-0.0160621647,
0.0140586179,
-0.0165770352,
0.0873064399,
-0.0386062376,
-0.0017835917,
-0.0233321972,
0.0274080187,
-0.0023382346,
0.0086927414,
0.0171257127,
-0.0481681265,
0.0010111311,
0.0301297847,
-0.0114259757,
-0.0251578018,
-0.0261848196,
-0.0107308915,
0.0615034923,
-0.0172313582,
-0.0244739708,
-0.0083959857,
0.0513180792,
-0.0705820024,
0.004479371,
0.1139836758,
0.0155626694,
-0.0605430491,
-0.0051022083,
-0.0126146628,
0.0592513755,
0.0188156832,
0.0313680172,
-0.094921276,
-0.0442422442,
0.0155718848,
0.0430968776,
0.047708299,
0.0204719976,
-0.0260362048,
-0.0778222457,
0.0462725945,
0.0527017526,
-0.0361933596,
-0.013630148,
-0.0059366864,
-0.0150243789,
-0.0265431106,
0.0119182374,
0.0131320236,
0.0070324568,
0.0030104362,
-0.0033565431,
0.0054874299,
-0.0781023726,
0.0075844545,
-0.0499569662,
0.0048706308,
0.0328348391,
0.0453131385,
0.012177567,
0.0163465273,
0.0828818455,
-0.0199532211,
0.0027176565,
-0.0330531038,
0.00976652,
-0.0065096384,
-0.0109755835,
0.0241694339,
0.0142394025,
-0.0331652202,
0.0257510412,
0.0213877577,
0.0573246963,
0.0001544572,
0.0029640938,
0.0035131567,
-0.0434985459,
-0.0166969802,
0.0465335585,
0.0052767647,
-0.0371199474,
-0.0131006418,
-0.0329348296,
-0.0179499593,
-0.0257001761,
-0.017024396,
-0.0024458743,
-0.0452919677,
-0.0402248651,
-0.0843046233,
-0.0191356391,
0.0022634887,
0.0258369055,
0.0079354066,
0.0125151891,
-0.0128462976,
0.0006757024,
-0.0460414402,
0.0649253651,
-0.0529874824,
0.0104302922,
-0.0767903626,
-0.0001183059,
0.0406533666,
-0.0241619926,
-0.0004962669,
0.0372493565,
-0.0973373204,
-0.0671526864,
-0.0558565035,
0.0579023398,
0.0229013786,
0.0560527295,
-0.0336310454,
-0.0243762396,
0.0140197799,
0.0114621259,
-0.03468927,
-0.0002052305,
0.0363263153,
-0.0102596264,
-0.0284818709,
0.0390029214,
-0.0177864488,
-0.0037308447,
-0.0119753014,
0.0724294186,
0.010365637,
-0.0646993145,
0.0222601537,
0.006351776,
0.0210423749,
-0.0460907817,
-0.0411149524,
-0.0145695014,
0.0364307798,
-0.0154422475,
-0.0121934833,
-0.0597096607,
-0.00205179,
0.0651663616,
-0.0226466823,
-0.0101169618,
0.0283171125,
0.0079048062,
0.004825355,
-0.0339310579,
-0.0069256062,
-0.0752400532,
0.012836583,
0.0166969523,
-0.0030658627,
-0.0192078371,
0.0083803916,
-0.0101080118,
0.0107813245,
-0.0457624868,
0.0489219129,
0.0027212028,
0.0138097377,
-0.0050026686,
0.0736516193,
-0.0155982645,
-0.0440789722,
-0.0626320094,
0.0309706628,
0.1055239066,
0.0318825208,
0.1415589303,
-0.0015601325,
-0.0400804803,
-0.0268206727,
0.0309187137,
-0.0055367905,
-0.0056283469,
-0.0095674014,
-0.0085206171,
-0.0175028536,
0.0279798005,
0.0648396462,
0.0284932666,
0.0302229151,
-0.0053808698,
-0.0133993775,
-0.0133375991,
-0.0514383502,
-0.0125957429,
-0.0144979414,
-0.0165644065,
-0.0143960183,
-0.0248093382,
-0.0545060039,
-0.0250729732,
-0.0032716941,
-0.0238159858,
-0.0193421263,
0.0125714261,
0.0820328146,
-0.048543077,
-0.0056928978,
-0.0610551611,
-0.0280122105,
0.0278837886,
-0.028841272,
-0.014199663,
-7.021146208e-33,
-0.0193238482,
-0.0030690567,
0.0136613362,
-0.0013219971,
-0.0456843823,
-0.0085326592,
-0.0331835486,
-0.0277340207,
0.0085568689,
-0.0109347934,
-0.0053181648,
-0.0041104173,
0.0220379792,
0.0022205513,
0.006134795,
0.0259706173,
0.0614704117,
0.0227140691,
-0.0487245806,
0.0273937136,
0.0015209395,
0.0248677954,
0.0893605128,
-0.0374321528,
0.0213820469,
-0.0176575743,
-0.04645757,
0.0157314911,
0.007656978,
0.0062999637,
0.0027373049,
-0.0005091278,
0.0174402855,
-0.0113700004,
-0.0196755789,
-0.0565325506,
-0.0961032957,
0.0390200205,
0.0193942301,
0.0299319196,
-0.0152748618,
-0.0424340591,
0.0530392714,
-0.0243481938,
-0.0154653648,
-0.0288266502,
-0.008162884,
-0.0565028414,
-0.0237843469,
-0.0384509936,
-0.0635849461,
0.0370873213,
-0.0043603345,
-0.0246401485,
0.0179641526,
0.048499573,
-0.0179405436,
0.0030252142,
-0.0346840583,
0.011599876,
0.0069589969,
0.0550389849,
0.0925454497,
-0.0076223053,
-0.0031207218,
-0.0044967481,
-0.007155112,
-0.0018437457,
0.0075471052,
0.0156211946,
0.0321860164,
0.0262453053,
0.0581380501,
0.0268901903,
0.0260043759,
-0.003826593,
-0.0609446578,
0.0607432723,
-0.0023806451,
0.014476941,
-0.0107274121,
0.0360733382,
-0.0181455892,
-0.0016256924,
-0.0473726951,
-0.0144981174,
-0.0281830356,
-0.040906731,
0.0195800997,
0.0138401967,
-0.0402137935,
-0.0104981828,
0.0555455908,
-0.0221755691,
0.0007776663,
0.0244824309,
-0.0359560363,
0.0142741576,
-0.0171257034,
0.0489856303,
0.0102088051,
-0.0408625156,
0.0145510258,
-0.021621583,
-0.000596997,
-0.0269312356,
0.0310874712,
0.0341724679,
-0.0497025661,
0.0191980843,
-0.0543682538,
0.0025213757,
-0.015353119,
0.0339465775,
0.0183013082,
-0.0233971123,
-0.003689022,
0.06922777,
0.0448446944,
0.0514983013,
-0.0351939239,
0.0432502106,
0.0222502165,
0.0434734412,
-0.0261472501,
0.0341708884,
-0.0119074369,
-0.0059685213,
0.0272914879,
-0.0569110587,
-0.0416174866,
0.005728587,
3.061e-7,
0.052430544,
0.0965741351,
0.005450035,
0.0141757969,
0.0142157068,
0.0279081464,
-0.0167798251,
0.0130654015,
0.0173425246,
0.0255915914,
0.0427828878,
0.0380667448,
0.0947201103,
-0.0025987059,
-0.0554180034,
0.001586559,
-0.030985523,
0.0295318309,
-0.0656149909,
-0.0330684185,
0.0268971343,
0.1058781296,
0.0074677248,
-0.0158543028,
-0.0045607677,
-0.0283277072,
0.0869618505,
-0.0400299467,
-0.0535981506,
0.0399926007,
0.0276703965,
0.0511102863,
-0.0477881767,
-0.0403982438,
-0.0316868573,
0.0094281361,
0.0436362103,
0.1061762869,
-0.0033339418,
0.042230092,
0.0213454831,
-0.0308823995,
0.0092603685,
-0.0415299311,
0.0576396398,
-0.0065072365,
-0.0027815816,
-0.0078523187,
-0.0187219512,
-0.0123678083,
0.0295656435,
-0.0740364045,
-0.0407193862,
0.0519028641,
0.0459136106,
-0.0120244734,
-0.0412227139,
-0.0323675238,
-0.0417664684,
-0.0023257115,
-0.0318170153,
-0.0304001924,
-0.0257600937,
0.0075353314,
-0.0127707152,
-0.0380699076,
0.0013772587,
3.200733594e-34,
0.0497583933,
-0.0321558863,
0.0109426258,
-0.0097191669,
0.0472596064,
-0.0046050604,
-0.0028100696,
-0.002171963,
-0.0284404363,
-0.0523724928,
-0.019296864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15736v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15736v1 | Evaluating Large Vision-and-Language Models on Children's Mathematical Olympiads | 2024-06-22T05:04:39 | 2024-06-22T05:04:39 | Anoop Cherian, Kuan-Chuan Peng, Suhas Lohit, Joanna Matthiesen, Kevin Smith, Joshua B. Tenenbaum | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Recent years have seen a significant progress in the general-purpose problem
solving abilities of large vision and language models (LVLMs), such as ChatGPT,
Gemini, etc.; some of these breakthroughs even seem to enable AI models to
outperform human abilities in varied tasks that demand higher-order cognitive
skills. Are the current large AI models indeed capable of generalized problem
solving as humans do? A systematic analysis of AI capabilities for joint vision
and text reasoning, however, is missing in the current scientific literature.
In this paper, we make an effort towards filling this gap, by evaluating
state-of-the-art LVLMs on their mathematical and algorithmic reasoning
abilities using visuo-linguistic problems from children's Olympiads.
Specifically, we consider problems from the Mathematical Kangaroo (MK)
Olympiad, which is a popular international competition targeted at children
from grades 1-12, that tests children's deeper mathematical abilities using
puzzles that are appropriately gauged to their age and skills. Using the
puzzles from MK, we created a dataset, dubbed SMART-840, consisting of 840
problems from years 2020-2024. With our dataset, we analyze LVLMs power on
mathematical reasoning; their responses on our puzzles offer a direct way to
compare against that of children. Our results show that modern LVLMs do
demonstrate increasingly powerful reasoning skills in solving problems for
higher grades, but lack the foundations to correctly answer problems designed
for younger children. Further analysis shows that there is no significant
correlation between the reasoning capabilities of AI models and that of young
children, and their capabilities appear to be based on a different type of
reasoning than the cumulative knowledge that underlies children's mathematics
and logic skills. | [
-0.005012651,
0.0654119849,
-0.0320658423,
0.0520172417,
-0.0524491668,
0.0210412554,
0.0360944681,
0.0008906203,
-0.002848339,
-0.0220766086,
0.0201141462,
-0.0102437157,
0.0049542775,
0.0443325862,
-0.0105603868,
-0.0498329364,
-0.0085671274,
-0.090031974,
0.0467312783,
-0.019522503,
-0.0714174882,
-0.0357243791,
-0.031495668,
0.0204862561,
-0.0428500175,
-0.0473333038,
0.0142852599,
-0.0506030284,
-0.0082145911,
-0.02414627,
-0.0449746996,
0.0024918129,
0.0211779494,
0.0381119922,
0.0000021517,
-0.0512558892,
0.01413076,
0.0015579197,
-0.0252362695,
0.0256335475,
-0.0127589637,
0.0060576182,
-0.0092869988,
0.018090101,
-0.0595316663,
0.0298676174,
0.044702746,
0.0149972606,
0.0307345539,
0.0265237913,
0.0033696168,
0.0156265795,
0.074232839,
0.0002786269,
0.0743372962,
-0.0644496605,
-0.0022735421,
0.05732264,
0.0546337627,
-0.0063586053,
-0.0371890776,
0.0565215945,
0.0671003759,
-0.0064925193,
-0.0364667699,
0.012513632,
-0.0389341153,
-0.0045273639,
-0.0123891095,
0.0353748091,
-0.0020121536,
0.003506819,
-0.0153372381,
0.0289369002,
0.0097821821,
0.0245417543,
-0.0915712789,
0.0623981804,
0.0125072561,
-0.020956615,
-0.0048921029,
-0.0130050769,
0.0003983199,
0.0220325273,
-0.0261383876,
0.0996730253,
-0.0078534223,
0.0072889272,
-0.0090981051,
0.010286714,
-0.0603039414,
-0.0414008647,
0.0058277245,
0.0264190193,
0.0194249582,
-0.0023230524,
-0.0176936314,
-0.0222183745,
-0.0512950532,
0.012505739,
0.0394765958,
0.048060447,
0.0337698013,
0.0470062532,
-0.0240320787,
0.1155320033,
-0.0104423901,
0.082030803,
-0.0166778192,
-0.006640262,
-0.0314430408,
-0.0049107885,
-0.0088569783,
0.0253638402,
-0.0083433473,
-0.0271901023,
-0.0226611588,
-0.000765654,
-0.0293977335,
0.0120259086,
-0.0155100198,
0.0185313262,
0.0245439615,
-0.0495090783,
-0.0605839826,
0.0081099644,
-0.0381464995,
0.0075452463,
-0.0107620172,
-0.0296252035,
-0.012662868,
0.0083501358,
0.0165588632,
-0.0292699002,
0.0232760496,
0.0585133657,
0.0014737443,
-0.0078807892,
0.0122659402,
0.0030084597,
0.0284398645,
-0.0961711928,
0.0633523688,
-0.0821270049,
0.0354216956,
0.0047772243,
-0.0065511246,
-0.0287523642,
0.0140408827,
0.0182770416,
0.0095866267,
0.0433114655,
0.0120893251,
0.005254,
-0.0039007538,
0.0058175307,
-0.0235760212,
0.0439139307,
0.0766903535,
0.0088571887,
0.0222682077,
-0.0095692202,
-0.0067767948,
0.0345763639,
-0.0113970432,
-0.0075682197,
-0.0142712621,
0.0033254579,
-0.0062145991,
0.0466211289,
-0.0432767086,
0.0451147594,
-0.0006723932,
-0.0176964197,
0.0710105747,
0.0627126619,
-0.0108885821,
-0.0151312975,
0.0075095869,
-0.0580880046,
0.0831966698,
-0.0266170744,
-0.0897489116,
0.0690379739,
-0.004870839,
-0.0039994409,
-0.0434243083,
0.0293336902,
-0.0132431025,
-0.0790867954,
-0.0117390156,
0.0125172902,
0.0004749322,
0.0504596159,
0.0739196017,
-0.0162745025,
0.00622947,
-0.0623053052,
-0.0184143092,
-0.009468738,
-0.0061119613,
-0.0856712013,
0.03921213,
0.0020108684,
0.0592429079,
-0.0295943692,
-0.0208845288,
0.0098697217,
0.0236366,
0.006759984,
0.0228431169,
0.0230205115,
-0.0201301817,
-0.0071233418,
-0.0041101621,
-0.0305683427,
0.0170838572,
-0.0246689655,
0.0237707216,
0.0045972764,
-0.0132315783,
-0.0276570506,
0.0116641847,
0.0219230372,
-0.0689299926,
-0.0006126236,
-0.0249115303,
0.0061445571,
-0.0111310268,
-0.0236311052,
0.0196616873,
0.0166222565,
0.0042404919,
-0.0306306444,
-0.0041359351,
0.0101286666,
-0.0470011905,
0.0052552912,
0.0447128527,
-0.1058236137,
-0.0166686028,
0.0610916428,
-0.009948669,
0.0234485865,
0.0768999755,
-0.0329737812,
-0.0060053007,
0.0158753321,
0.0373342894,
-0.0314170197,
-0.0519550107,
-0.0089725079,
0.076243639,
0.0100082764,
-0.0156365205,
0.0033124096,
-0.007071225,
0.0221255701,
-0.027676871,
0.0054232646,
-0.0029964277,
-0.0203726646,
0.0272564199,
-0.0327044912,
0.0041415482,
-0.0317850597,
0.0016799092,
-0.0319943242,
0.0044204663,
0.0123320539,
0.0271520857,
-0.0047444352,
-0.0539436936,
-0.0141882002,
0.0121786082,
-0.0001891879,
0.033269871,
-0.0170874521,
0.0118124234,
0.0264518354,
0.0050953119,
-0.0257880036,
-0.0014238387,
-0.0343938284,
-0.063652657,
0.0541370399,
0.0643909872,
0.0243266989,
0.0115572615,
0.0381155722,
-0.0595272593,
0.0186343659,
-0.0238834601,
0.0283912998,
0.0353296138,
-0.0145399747,
0.0216128323,
0.1299705356,
-0.0117282877,
0.0348022282,
0.0305088125,
-0.0392172821,
-0.0265008882,
0.0202732459,
0.0159398299,
-0.0053457385,
-0.0091419555,
-0.0276047848,
-0.0209312495,
0.0381238312,
-0.0366194807,
-0.0135643855,
-0.0276446454,
0.1089073643,
-0.0081907697,
-0.0464834869,
-0.0681206882,
-0.0197120626,
0.0230039451,
0.0604302958,
-0.0292660631,
-0.0490480848,
0.0228411853,
0.015640026,
0.0050237663,
-0.0363000631,
0.0269745272,
-0.0425166115,
0.0864096656,
0.0204940364,
-0.001276532,
-0.0536294207,
0.003052288,
-0.0923392996,
0.0167447627,
0.0176153593,
-0.0200285632,
0.0605842881,
-0.0577360094,
-0.0037892025,
-0.0130188074,
-0.0630332753,
-0.0247353129,
0.0436930023,
-0.0337191671,
0.0317184851,
-0.0167185124,
-0.060588032,
-0.0610939376,
0.0009499887,
0.055238612,
-0.0171957649,
-0.0394191295,
-0.011736745,
-0.0014191783,
0.0098043289,
0.0486208498,
0.0317295119,
0.0544080026,
-0.084013544,
0.015960658,
0.0376939178,
0.0617765523,
-0.0014630893,
-0.0144892139,
0.0346975997,
-0.0052142623,
0.0374515504,
-0.0241549648,
0.0287213419,
0.0301009249,
-0.0808729306,
0.0192912351,
0.0594914071,
0.0510643162,
0.011812333,
0.0019660459,
-0.0385914408,
-0.0044546202,
0.0104815699,
-0.007409147,
-0.0664361343,
-0.0154055916,
0.0449321158,
-0.0177057646,
-0.0038926727,
-0.0447403751,
-0.0099979592,
-0.0955474004,
0.0391875692,
0.0150277233,
-0.019186886,
-0.0445850566,
0.0037717244,
-0.0062452722,
0.0297587011,
-0.0116477227,
-0.0170224719,
-0.0142878927,
0.0248512365,
-0.0209221058,
0.0071269455,
0.027676275,
0.0339005403,
-0.0302246101,
0.0027293742,
0.0055058482,
0.0169309229,
-0.0410565361,
-0.0610773265,
0.0005350577,
0.0397945605,
-0.0241125245,
0.0281490963,
0.0128172152,
-0.0055404711,
-0.026926687,
-0.0247668456,
0.0362536348,
-0.0133151626,
-0.0416580178,
0.0453030318,
0.0819590539,
-0.0015517017,
-0.0483218879,
-0.0112801678,
-0.0015088202,
-0.0695918128,
0.0398403406,
0.0119370446,
-0.0177802499,
-0.0532091074,
-0.0385007448,
-0.0253159273,
-0.0454742908,
-0.0538706109,
0.0498979874,
0.1055314317,
-0.0127540957,
-0.048162017,
0.002645833,
0.0544978902,
0.0289604049,
0.0022168469,
-0.0638284981,
0.0199072901,
0.0204706974,
-0.0420049839,
0.0616460778,
-0.0133024929,
0.0304502062,
-0.0464710817,
0.0279682726,
-0.0410732292,
-0.0571724363,
-0.0428230911,
0.0188300423,
-0.1012972817,
-0.0069400622,
-0.0045699533,
0.0352946483,
0.0255257636,
-0.0560865812,
0.0240879413,
-0.0111099677,
0.0055189477,
0.0287129227,
0.0078292405,
0.0206156466,
-0.0148753794,
-0.0042773508,
0.03537561,
-0.0049271421,
0.0041218945,
0.0016123943,
0.0181555618,
0.0334041603,
-0.008642165,
0.0149695594,
0.0007239624,
0.0294943657,
-0.003395536,
0.045081608,
-0.0324247554,
-0.0207422692,
0.0046329303,
-0.0371279083,
0.0110784741,
-0.0268785469,
-0.0315461978,
0.0042209974,
0.0303960592,
0.0366249792,
0.0117931413,
0.0385672227,
0.0066098436,
-0.0203712247,
0.0597495474,
-0.0049455366,
0.0235917233,
0.0094749657,
0.0194718931,
0.0392137319,
0.0071303304,
-0.0342334434,
0.0813482702,
0.0223050825,
0.0442414396,
0.0009557744,
-0.0241202489,
-0.0324467681,
-0.0008741,
-0.0754478127,
-0.1034966782,
0.0450170934,
0.0219596326,
0.0592321828,
0.0189077556,
-0.0395363867,
-0.0579502322,
0.0016535022,
-0.0324212462,
-0.0101414379,
0.0463712141,
-0.0184251238,
0.0227330197,
0.0265743025,
0.0293527339,
-0.0415045097,
0.0188291129,
0.0025684743,
0.0166014135,
0.0009143118,
0.0320915505,
0.0056496751,
-0.0401372686,
0.0130559728,
0.0162268635,
0.0100877769,
0.0345941782,
-0.0617129691,
-0.0566879176,
-0.0114706904,
0.0093387291,
-0.0172735769,
0.0182587039,
0.0204061382,
0.0385324433,
-0.0357177109,
-0.0448761024,
0.0212218203,
0.0159884598,
-0.0459380448,
-0.0337937474,
-0.0156748947,
-5.54800383e-33,
-0.0012589846,
-0.0554969162,
0.0465298779,
0.0285567604,
0.0378830843,
0.0107361386,
-0.0089989919,
0.0359190591,
-0.0514978394,
0.0016685566,
0.0013549111,
-0.0031522787,
-0.0053922813,
0.0028666668,
-0.0055236681,
0.0005499932,
-0.0370247439,
-0.0158638172,
-0.0337468684,
-0.0344619192,
0.0006198873,
-0.0410038866,
0.0390166566,
-0.0570328385,
-0.0173526444,
0.0175566506,
0.0075472272,
0.0229121931,
-0.0520798899,
0.0586476065,
0.0017035472,
0.0128790475,
0.0451899804,
0.0129714776,
-0.0056473357,
0.0340747051,
-0.0298951212,
-0.0094681848,
-0.0058617033,
0.0006569937,
-0.0906795561,
-0.0272595137,
0.0142620066,
0.0276204757,
-0.0208432246,
-0.0628650114,
0.0323386565,
-0.0380355306,
0.0300783534,
0.0290260501,
-0.0189470593,
0.0097151268,
-0.0342286117,
-0.0242999829,
0.0398310386,
0.0386083201,
-0.0053448598,
0.0190991648,
-0.0183072593,
0.060210187,
0.0043515703,
-0.0047900365,
0.0569662005,
-0.0182789993,
0.0261372253,
0.0446394831,
0.0594591573,
-0.0267613344,
-0.0322936401,
-0.0471098498,
0.0472096242,
0.067482844,
0.0936853364,
-0.0031321165,
0.0330831707,
0.0412676297,
-0.0880681127,
-0.0144214015,
-0.0023566834,
0.0715806037,
0.0014322512,
-0.0118520157,
-0.0509876385,
0.0221319217,
-0.0349003114,
0.0181113463,
-0.0510763377,
0.0063906927,
0.0403510593,
-0.0419124365,
0.0179168824,
0.0153244669,
0.013324677,
-0.0392503291,
0.0161638614,
0.0025384163,
0.0408135094,
0.0497644357,
0.0089817001,
0.0468991026,
-0.0523686036,
-0.0291295778,
0.0193329137,
0.0156155881,
0.0293924119,
-0.0010555448,
0.005375592,
0.0187623892,
-0.0391587168,
-0.0224994682,
-0.040095374,
-0.0125761591,
0.0658040345,
-0.0159242526,
0.0233348217,
-0.0020497863,
-0.0129319401,
-0.0137957586,
-0.0192583222,
-0.0214684512,
-0.0433101431,
0.0073459321,
-0.0217166133,
-0.0243814178,
0.0121341227,
-0.0190110616,
-0.0666857883,
-0.0094923098,
-0.0152016887,
-0.0443830825,
-0.0011333307,
-0.0042815665,
2.779e-7,
0.011443723,
0.09185078,
0.0043448107,
0.0321449153,
0.0321972929,
0.0286707766,
-0.0328422599,
-0.0512700193,
0.0285274312,
0.0073454515,
-0.0172002576,
0.0819532722,
0.0320754088,
0.0190980677,
-0.0306777041,
0.0250533968,
-0.0090346243,
-0.0287604071,
-0.0795549899,
0.0173644219,
0.0593364947,
0.0349862538,
0.017064577,
-0.0104963072,
0.0141987633,
-0.0851095915,
0.0211014897,
-0.0030347561,
-0.0062039918,
-0.022323763,
-0.0545721054,
-0.0083780354,
0.0240365714,
0.0499558933,
-0.0053883391,
0.0304457024,
0.034585122,
0.0322229527,
-0.0103972126,
0.0214681551,
-0.028392924,
0.00223681,
-0.0355217531,
-0.0502015688,
0.0990187973,
-0.0405475423,
-0.0661035106,
0.0186294578,
0.0028213428,
-0.0117959725,
-0.0053651179,
-0.0043129898,
0.012341802,
0.0070151505,
0.0208905451,
-0.0269405767,
0.0033789398,
-0.036002472,
0.01425156,
-0.0459979326,
-0.0402064472,
-0.0583748184,
-0.0725661591,
0.0175056346,
0.0257966164,
0.0144728776,
-0.0152661521,
2.347485866e-34,
0.0285731591,
-0.0030531476,
0.026041029,
-0.0317728221,
0.0388250984,
-0.0104111489,
-0.0015204111,
-0.016721651,
0.0305984598,
-0.042792391,
0.0005092073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15734v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15734v1 | RankAdaptor: Hierarchical Dynamic Low-Rank Adaptation for Structural Pruned LLMs | 2024-06-22T04:52:58 | 2024-06-22T04:52:58 | Changhai Zhou, Shijie Han, Shiyang Zhang, Shichao Weng, Zekai Liu, Cheng Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The efficient compression of large language models (LLMs) is becoming
increasingly popular. However, recovering the accuracy of compressed LLMs is
still a major challenge. Structural pruning with standard Low-Rank Adaptation
(LoRA) is a common technique in current LLM compression. In structural pruning,
the model architecture is modified unevenly, resulting in suboptimal
performance in various downstream tasks via standard LoRA with fixed rank. To
address this problem, we introduce RankAdaptor, an efficient fine-tuning method
with hierarchical dynamic rank scheduling for pruned LLMs. An end-to-end
automatic optimization flow is developed that utilizes a lightweight
performance model to determine the different ranks during fine-tuning.
Comprehensive experiments on popular benchmarks show that RankAdaptor
consistently outperforms standard LoRA with structural pruning over different
pruning settings. Without increasing the trainable parameters, RankAdaptor
further reduces the accuracy performance gap between the recovery of the pruned
model and the original model compared to standard LoRA. | [
-0.0058659823,
0.0732230544,
-0.0221528262,
0.0551580042,
0.0084594944,
0.0164954271,
-0.0376051627,
0.0457308404,
-0.0271995738,
-0.0227449741,
-0.0637235567,
-0.0122776749,
0.0227551665,
-0.0111172143,
0.0259261765,
-0.0219014939,
0.0305734221,
-0.0456470139,
0.015654536,
-0.0049242908,
-0.0209016539,
0.007494499,
0.0230362993,
0.0049638897,
0.0854352415,
-0.0084828399,
-0.0115325861,
0.0189952962,
0.0093540587,
0.0229546484,
0.0076134186,
0.0623824187,
0.0362875983,
0.0214443002,
0.0000021198,
-0.0192202069,
-0.0172449835,
0.0050091976,
-0.0481191799,
0.0356476754,
0.0315671302,
-0.0163545869,
-0.0315016061,
0.0124767255,
-0.0002462377,
0.009655091,
0.0185895748,
-0.0248309094,
0.0520680733,
0.0621572062,
0.0044214153,
-0.0164840054,
-0.0187013932,
-0.0464473628,
-0.0659736991,
-0.0240533967,
0.0085094972,
-0.0201370995,
-0.0445358232,
0.0030929609,
-0.035678979,
0.0045631006,
-0.0090428228,
0.016640516,
-0.0101815416,
-0.0135676609,
-0.0576214194,
-0.0141900238,
0.0175709166,
0.056157548,
-0.0733587667,
-0.0339816697,
0.0364282541,
-0.0161236823,
0.0004909791,
-0.0796169117,
-0.0440324619,
0.0390932374,
0.0356963351,
0.0296693463,
-0.0017495127,
-0.0240463112,
0.023993941,
-0.0062533263,
-0.0328731798,
0.0338299833,
0.0406648666,
-0.0082631567,
-0.0255353991,
-0.0279427804,
0.0214441251,
-0.0200733114,
0.009618544,
0.0153351948,
-0.0345737338,
0.0059229666,
-0.0574312396,
-0.0413207784,
0.0150202438,
-0.0263178442,
0.0568030737,
0.0683232248,
0.046563901,
0.0080863638,
-0.0439164713,
0.0693741217,
0.0097028678,
0.0137508651,
-0.0465822667,
0.0100333262,
-0.0044999351,
0.0195994023,
-0.0076499227,
0.0276923385,
-0.0603138767,
0.0205859542,
-0.053476166,
0.0181554295,
0.0225522704,
-0.0094729466,
0.0287325904,
-0.015985271,
-0.0529121123,
-0.0117488448,
0.0232508145,
0.0243355557,
0.0286345091,
0.0236155521,
-0.0237306282,
-0.012841424,
-0.0251771752,
0.0311537422,
0.0022531317,
-0.0175841097,
0.0215140935,
0.0453828871,
-0.050262019,
-0.0309182163,
-0.0273159258,
0.0065166685,
0.0191631857,
-0.0472300984,
0.006927812,
-0.0340118855,
0.0405440964,
-0.0525708459,
0.0261284169,
-0.0175292864,
-0.0113600632,
0.0185485445,
-0.0564561263,
0.0249328241,
0.0144643625,
0.0102282651,
0.0003318043,
0.0010657064,
0.0480350144,
0.0646658987,
0.0461325124,
0.0407024063,
-0.0089226905,
-0.0194989387,
-0.0796292871,
0.0662907958,
0.035641931,
0.0232325476,
-0.0537333488,
-0.0075065405,
-0.0210763402,
0.0055233212,
0.0828926489,
0.0454593115,
-0.0263006967,
-0.0236264486,
0.0525072329,
0.0448707119,
0.0837487206,
0.0782216936,
-0.005081031,
-0.0243497044,
-0.0141412755,
0.0012801305,
-0.0303664412,
0.0097964816,
-0.0444461219,
0.009662509,
0.0181831997,
0.0848196,
-0.0154975019,
-0.0028509556,
-0.0377250388,
0.0015444359,
0.0005664281,
0.0233129356,
0.0216958914,
0.0088495594,
-0.0317355171,
0.0789587647,
0.0171322338,
-0.0505082607,
-0.0246527344,
-0.0725548491,
-0.0214042105,
0.0348750763,
0.0278727226,
0.0012263109,
-0.0209406912,
0.0184133891,
-0.0075071002,
-0.0159540307,
-0.0184896216,
-0.0156790763,
0.0354600362,
-0.0511846207,
-0.0103621352,
0.0271308962,
0.0162763968,
0.0158559866,
0.0062512313,
0.0046626376,
0.0208654124,
-0.0609534569,
-0.0323078036,
0.0349861793,
-0.0385465547,
0.0073257284,
0.0340999961,
-0.0093044816,
0.0195874684,
-0.0132502839,
-0.0161397364,
-0.0319501795,
0.057831075,
-0.048301734,
0.0428252332,
-0.0562741905,
-0.0277281292,
-0.048561208,
0.0486995615,
0.0178399999,
0.0306124445,
0.115714252,
-0.0542500354,
-0.0401718803,
0.0097458148,
-0.0423980393,
0.0038177092,
-0.0428925231,
0.0340772979,
-0.0235983711,
0.0714244246,
-0.0126186786,
0.0517854579,
-0.0294960253,
-0.0034243162,
0.0937572494,
-0.0105355922,
-0.0157379825,
-0.0683156252,
-0.0290147364,
0.0472010896,
-0.0179582164,
0.021814758,
0.000916953,
0.0388352387,
-0.0069614681,
-0.0221296977,
-0.0543073379,
0.0348338298,
-0.0314032882,
0.0487253219,
0.0354536399,
0.0077769575,
0.0175066851,
-0.0208241157,
0.0046402849,
0.0238783639,
-0.013343079,
0.0076245912,
0.0012062184,
0.0010594979,
-0.0197513234,
-0.0329236053,
-0.0330678783,
0.0364198424,
0.0264858063,
-0.0584662445,
-0.0418319143,
-0.0543028675,
0.0700363517,
-0.0228176974,
0.0238028876,
-0.0212904233,
-0.0487304777,
-0.0585521124,
0.007467459,
0.040675994,
0.055850815,
-0.0005306316,
0.0030749959,
0.0927581638,
0.0233980827,
-0.0321908034,
0.0008702399,
0.0032347792,
-0.0111010037,
-0.0354695357,
-0.0449242629,
-0.0244757514,
0.0707290843,
-0.006686891,
0.011467373,
-0.0527746119,
-0.0466226637,
0.0091422694,
-0.0070701484,
-0.0418747589,
0.0121968053,
-0.0442356877,
0.016057197,
-0.0014236381,
-0.0339071341,
0.0278581623,
-0.0486972071,
-0.0196092017,
-0.003725996,
-0.0480396599,
-0.0520115159,
0.0241179857,
0.0247398987,
0.00745684,
-0.030460868,
-0.0065608607,
-0.0561243966,
0.0363151431,
0.0166191626,
-0.041409526,
0.0122886728,
-0.0271136574,
0.0142026665,
-0.0591582358,
-0.045615375,
0.0115960492,
-0.012002035,
0.0008162947,
0.0460482165,
0.0414047502,
-0.0333613008,
-0.0116093503,
0.0235884096,
-0.0008730714,
0.0687025413,
0.0047319559,
0.0305019487,
-0.0283338502,
0.0381258391,
0.0667781457,
0.0584844165,
0.0357331522,
-0.0042712921,
0.0295093562,
0.0270608515,
0.0520869009,
-0.0042484365,
-0.0279360767,
0.0152693912,
0.0503308326,
0.0264464151,
-0.0356629603,
0.0362088196,
-0.0050732451,
-0.0420446321,
-0.0077633061,
0.0551217906,
0.0049432749,
-0.063922137,
0.0110180825,
-0.0283369925,
0.0944700986,
0.0252919979,
0.0509145297,
-0.0509396456,
-0.0046727117,
0.0359417498,
0.0398623198,
0.0185044445,
-0.0071484284,
-0.0040580099,
-0.1074462384,
0.0424188823,
0.0173496585,
0.009342174,
0.027293019,
-0.0245225932,
0.0117652752,
-0.0094051808,
0.0208076034,
0.0264098197,
-0.0277557503,
-0.0129693598,
0.0163842291,
-0.0625246763,
-0.0533860363,
0.0161597077,
0.0338425748,
0.064350076,
0.0397924073,
0.0446108878,
0.0251691584,
-0.0389876775,
0.0576482378,
-0.0126882633,
-0.0194727853,
-0.0553569458,
-0.0145280585,
0.0232640617,
0.0100839958,
0.0168622229,
0.0242624711,
-0.0059544006,
-0.0105325682,
-0.0170195699,
0.093577534,
-0.0008466411,
-0.0071484325,
-0.0045278538,
-0.0245555118,
-0.0429051965,
0.0303978603,
0.0245918799,
0.0249979291,
-0.0227737222,
0.0016627026,
-0.0131797884,
-0.0433330238,
-0.0401570946,
0.0278443731,
-0.035973046,
0.0160262771,
-0.0174032357,
0.0505108871,
0.0020204498,
0.0017456344,
-0.0309912097,
0.0071362639,
-0.0531339645,
0.0257181991,
-0.0478718989,
-0.015223301,
-0.0374464318,
-0.0090550194,
-0.0324043967,
0.0097344695,
0.0153583018,
-0.0088188807,
-0.017849775,
-0.0191272516,
-0.0838403031,
-0.0494076982,
-0.0383531637,
0.0562077276,
0.0181438029,
0.0745842904,
0.0148566039,
-0.0816367418,
0.0164247192,
-0.0008425065,
0.0003520175,
0.0879869759,
0.0131016141,
-0.056070894,
-0.0232383721,
0.0615923703,
-0.0862986445,
0.0029387479,
0.0105744405,
0.0320945978,
0.0081165126,
-0.0306413602,
-0.0215344131,
0.0534984544,
0.0022849455,
-0.0056717223,
-0.0554482602,
0.0016457102,
0.0769415125,
-0.0127626779,
0.0104890978,
-0.0389949344,
0.0317364298,
0.0025333066,
-0.0129092354,
0.0016362409,
0.0224301964,
0.0354593135,
0.0178438816,
-0.0656305701,
0.011347685,
-0.0122647537,
-0.0419145785,
0.048824694,
0.0190224648,
-0.0099009899,
0.0202928148,
0.0400122702,
0.035561014,
-0.0456082933,
-0.0416769311,
-0.0005761357,
0.0401542857,
-0.0843240917,
0.0401288159,
-0.0101041123,
-0.0732249245,
-0.062609531,
-0.0075857085,
0.0416553095,
0.0272021387,
0.0617640279,
0.0218412653,
-0.0036585713,
-0.0202571023,
-0.0195647292,
0.0045037721,
-0.0035258676,
0.0163503271,
-0.0014109811,
-0.0084547317,
0.0257633757,
0.074521333,
0.0591352694,
0.0360794589,
-0.0252469778,
-0.0077419085,
-0.0432809144,
-0.042602174,
-0.0320374407,
0.0239088405,
-0.0122525552,
-0.050059136,
-0.0014338524,
-0.0565133169,
0.0095224669,
-0.0014123496,
0.0196892228,
-0.0509112887,
0.0082688155,
0.0339573137,
-0.0048860088,
0.0053512617,
-0.0066287811,
-0.0716213286,
0.0278128479,
-0.0133096119,
0.0152583811,
-6.335835205e-33,
-0.042930793,
0.0105472896,
0.0187920872,
-0.0202901494,
-0.0432190821,
-0.0046888883,
-0.0375179835,
-0.0185310692,
0.0076401792,
-0.020352805,
-0.0277651772,
0.0033452795,
0.0114475004,
0.011638823,
0.0004063562,
0.0359675363,
0.0461689606,
-0.0280306768,
-0.0386829041,
0.018785391,
0.0091580525,
0.0375254974,
0.0273263939,
0.0194754526,
-0.0660519078,
0.0129439272,
-0.0226185564,
0.0062431376,
-0.0142567856,
0.0325130224,
-0.0295955408,
0.0140296556,
0.0193181038,
-0.0334066525,
-0.0249423198,
0.0425953455,
-0.0835677385,
0.0009270295,
0.0469986536,
-0.0091564078,
-0.0271420926,
-0.0381838307,
0.0265274998,
0.0416209251,
-0.0270298757,
-0.0365957618,
-0.007161248,
-0.0611451156,
-0.0391643196,
-0.0756596401,
-0.0414159447,
0.0191382915,
-0.0015000651,
-0.0059623499,
0.0628255829,
0.031935405,
-0.0232094582,
0.0466289893,
-0.0471137986,
-0.0015452697,
-0.0013681685,
0.1023976952,
0.0808364376,
0.0257674456,
-0.0343894921,
0.0326895155,
-0.0061970414,
0.0009422397,
0.039432954,
0.0010226467,
0.0479239337,
0.0247761048,
0.0300695878,
0.0328934304,
0.0017444817,
-0.0147970468,
-0.0754694268,
-0.011898376,
0.0250937343,
0.0146436263,
0.0229647253,
0.0714142621,
0.0369879566,
-0.0236527752,
-0.0363306627,
0.0003642344,
-0.0446473286,
0.0019937325,
0.0110380016,
0.0499948449,
-0.0272195283,
-0.0076834229,
0.0370522924,
-0.0360812992,
0.0195446946,
-0.0020349815,
-0.0292318612,
0.0124234976,
0.0256881062,
0.0439446755,
-0.0379564874,
-0.0385437198,
0.0298406761,
-0.0351001918,
0.0274934676,
-0.0418760031,
0.0095926151,
0.0423866138,
-0.0363248624,
-0.0053007081,
-0.0036800003,
0.0038813339,
0.004097105,
0.0714505911,
-0.0007571438,
-0.0127170673,
0.0192275569,
0.0675198063,
0.0296951048,
0.0265702773,
-0.0181417651,
0.0123531027,
0.0457130708,
0.0319050662,
-0.0277449787,
0.0101487171,
-0.0226728711,
0.021433603,
0.0296519026,
-0.0441953577,
-0.0260780826,
0.0234978385,
2.799e-7,
0.0119726732,
0.034486495,
-0.019493727,
-0.0660150498,
0.0181352273,
-0.0106051853,
-0.0263869371,
0.0162550453,
0.0189559255,
-0.00211873,
0.0265996177,
-0.012031896,
0.0667625144,
-0.0060887258,
-0.0478244014,
0.0172376577,
-0.0868706107,
-0.0132178375,
-0.0403686836,
-0.0689930469,
-0.0301191956,
0.104169406,
-0.0267075356,
-0.0449410751,
-0.0210860372,
0.0084424531,
0.0170980748,
-0.0121709872,
-0.0068640704,
-0.0061027673,
0.0366277546,
-0.0111402432,
-0.0604780801,
-0.0248524845,
-0.0176031291,
0.0499165803,
-0.0302742291,
0.0878435895,
-0.0210163817,
0.0070210458,
0.0587988198,
0.0117140869,
-0.0237878952,
-0.035619285,
0.0527681522,
-0.0213323105,
0.0018603288,
-0.0304010734,
-0.0052546975,
-0.012229112,
-0.0255445465,
-0.0323862359,
0.0222431235,
0.0318827555,
0.0206524804,
0.0095412927,
-0.0356072597,
-0.0896889642,
-0.0001193742,
-0.0040153028,
-0.0837664455,
-0.046175357,
-0.0364444926,
-0.026973173,
0.0198402852,
-0.0740697905,
-0.0038600245,
2.9833002e-34,
0.0234460905,
0.0075602238,
-0.0115743037,
0.0631565377,
0.0273416974,
-0.0300234407,
-0.0022469189,
0.0498906374,
-0.0232981034,
-0.1052232385,
-0.0407853164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15723v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15723v1 | Acoustic Feature Mixup for Balanced Multi-aspect Pronunciation Assessment | 2024-06-22T03:56:29 | 2024-06-22T03:56:29 | Heejin Do, Wonjun Lee, Gary Geunbae Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | In automated pronunciation assessment, recent emphasis progressively lies on
evaluating multiple aspects to provide enriched feedback. However, acquiring
multi-aspect-score labeled data for non-native language learners' speech poses
challenges; moreover, it often leads to score-imbalanced distributions. In this
paper, we propose two Acoustic Feature Mixup strategies, linearly and
non-linearly interpolating with the in-batch averaged feature, to address data
scarcity and score-label imbalances. Primarily using goodness-of-pronunciation
as an acoustic feature, we tailor mixup designs to suit pronunciation
assessment. Further, we integrate fine-grained error-rate features by comparing
speech recognition results with the original answer phonemes, giving direct
hints for mispronunciation. Effective mixing of the acoustic features notably
enhances overall scoring performances on the speechocean762 dataset, and
detailed analysis highlights our potential to predict unseen distortions. | [
-0.0284518227,
0.0522071794,
0.0182118118,
-0.024238361,
-0.0244269464,
-0.0079274308,
0.0337572955,
-0.0228228085,
-0.0193310343,
-0.0214502122,
-0.0524833314,
-0.0109919691,
0.0892983302,
0.0434764326,
0.0009953225,
-0.0353264362,
-0.0297011491,
-0.0426891111,
0.0491809323,
-0.0530856401,
0.0210943613,
0.0270856675,
-0.0825141519,
0.042742271,
-0.0497153364,
0.035399124,
0.012306151,
0.0149129853,
0.0228740219,
0.0125463055,
-0.002645687,
0.0609211251,
-0.0453708805,
0.0147618167,
0.0000019861,
-0.0459017903,
-0.0055334852,
0.0159285478,
-0.0181920845,
0.0317467041,
0.0127021428,
0.0623091534,
-0.0252240356,
0.0130323218,
0.0136043159,
-0.0419700332,
0.0593701303,
0.0007412257,
0.0003808665,
0.0119193979,
0.0008821869,
-0.0356307887,
-0.0257929061,
0.0142362081,
0.0082405163,
0.0294167157,
-0.0210880022,
-0.0127545064,
-0.0200162288,
-0.0653400645,
-0.0345614441,
0.0488395728,
-0.0111228973,
0.0098259095,
0.0248280261,
0.0138889933,
-0.0196952652,
-0.0294303074,
-0.0411366075,
0.0440519117,
-0.0184154641,
0.0128824459,
-0.0090707373,
-0.0435449965,
-0.0274358578,
-0.0203611236,
0.0140806381,
-0.0136863943,
-0.0062967855,
-0.0103045981,
0.0098921051,
0.010218191,
-0.0091496008,
-0.026952127,
0.0095729837,
-0.0102994461,
0.0177192241,
-0.0286863763,
-0.0000504458,
0.0387734212,
-0.0052319546,
0.0072630476,
0.0500437208,
0.0215077177,
-0.0451724455,
-0.0341926999,
0.02551011,
-0.0315792412,
0.022459479,
0.0321528465,
0.0209771246,
0.0292608235,
-0.0749959946,
-0.0122376215,
0.0143494438,
0.0619989224,
0.0480401851,
0.0076951748,
-0.0381203294,
-0.0095163221,
-0.0172290783,
0.0105013009,
0.0398129262,
0.0239409711,
0.0127934599,
0.0647695586,
-0.0747821033,
-0.0499819405,
-0.0640455484,
0.0136553571,
0.0792909563,
0.0258425437,
-0.0261846874,
0.0160750151,
-0.0097610168,
0.0460842326,
-0.0047137938,
0.0400458314,
-0.0039639329,
-0.0265653189,
0.0260170493,
0.0110972701,
0.0106371753,
0.0201670546,
0.0691987053,
0.0476160198,
0.0255002379,
-0.0251781922,
0.0137662636,
-0.0172379073,
-0.0560745411,
-0.0284040682,
-0.0469223633,
-0.0736823305,
0.0155784683,
-0.0255927239,
0.0238462854,
-0.0060971454,
-0.0523134992,
-0.0227700919,
0.0199060254,
0.0220723767,
0.0443477929,
0.0391355194,
0.0253172405,
-0.0230999589,
0.0397015177,
0.0380714051,
0.0439453274,
-0.060901247,
0.0018944903,
-0.0154868374,
0.0055622193,
0.0390181616,
0.0558374636,
0.0183042455,
0.0301065352,
-0.0477254316,
-0.0105025517,
0.0173173584,
0.0452119596,
0.0490942709,
0.0006534503,
-0.0155152464,
0.0440781303,
0.0239614714,
0.0478121042,
-0.0231723785,
0.0328840613,
0.0095286388,
-0.0113312481,
0.0353684984,
-0.0107445624,
-0.0223585106,
-0.0365136452,
0.0235193465,
0.0906789005,
0.1042911187,
-0.0332318433,
-0.0390353464,
-0.0261179581,
-0.0101270797,
-0.0405994505,
0.055857785,
0.0250308104,
0.0064821932,
0.0045212586,
0.0042220331,
0.0074140416,
-0.0334468521,
0.0341884531,
-0.0258453675,
0.0079661105,
0.0569430329,
-0.0143956114,
-0.0220244378,
-0.0094751678,
0.0093415575,
-0.0820311382,
-0.0048619844,
0.0001252691,
-0.0293707494,
0.0576148666,
-0.0389045812,
-0.0161662325,
0.0748889372,
-0.0013319881,
0.020722853,
-0.0419155434,
0.0524802506,
0.0026794658,
-0.0677360818,
-0.0147149898,
-0.0343600251,
0.0315281637,
-0.019379992,
0.0364338048,
0.0209699664,
0.0200159792,
0.0735247359,
-0.0115102911,
-0.0151089495,
0.031512145,
0.0119505161,
0.0164015703,
-0.0107133016,
-0.0383289792,
-0.0492654853,
0.0746130273,
-0.0262137204,
-0.0118580284,
-0.0291741285,
-0.0039956765,
-0.0735547915,
0.022308344,
-0.0036644528,
0.0034711016,
-0.0498771071,
0.0450171307,
0.0063986466,
-0.0088883527,
-0.0238329563,
-0.0170156695,
-0.0169942174,
0.0320199914,
-0.0431531556,
-0.0379556641,
-0.010486722,
-0.0703646541,
-0.0454069898,
0.0110006267,
-0.0228172112,
0.0452488959,
-0.0318267643,
0.0508842133,
-0.0371021666,
-0.0207778551,
-0.1030430868,
0.0080133704,
-0.0152245229,
0.0216211248,
0.003416375,
0.0145657901,
0.0048832358,
-0.0149223609,
-0.0528780669,
-0.0624094568,
0.0246568341,
0.0043446333,
-0.0466185845,
-0.0029382776,
-0.0217632148,
0.0049256906,
-0.009856822,
-0.0209436417,
-0.0149224736,
0.0136609869,
0.0351945683,
-0.0351768509,
-0.0136340838,
0.0005972128,
-0.0438141376,
0.07459867,
0.0077929096,
-0.0244499743,
0.0195472408,
0.0102558937,
-0.007491332,
-0.056103386,
-0.0271571148,
0.0498627499,
-0.0662636831,
-0.037266627,
-0.0229733232,
0.0185706187,
0.0097292485,
0.0047078137,
-0.0122954333,
-0.0636420101,
0.0005232497,
0.0454231985,
0.0174149033,
-0.0383379087,
-0.0045319316,
-0.0444137529,
-0.0367479771,
-0.0223334748,
-0.0450438224,
-0.0152185569,
-0.0095681772,
0.0088324314,
-0.0001066615,
0.0763715655,
-0.0831769854,
-0.0266048815,
-0.0687361509,
-0.0155424234,
-0.0057610525,
-0.0014372017,
-0.0478985868,
-0.0066547352,
-0.0025210602,
-0.025386272,
-0.0060923924,
-0.0078791603,
0.0482588373,
-0.0739072487,
0.0384880453,
-0.0244909227,
-0.0153236659,
0.0171120092,
-0.004410909,
0.0164053924,
-0.031035753,
-0.0186056476,
0.0133888861,
-0.0084280651,
-0.0610464625,
0.0614528656,
-0.0011893347,
-0.014244644,
0.0052547017,
-0.0107887145,
0.0153426761,
0.0408855081,
0.0428314097,
0.0186425466,
0.0739012286,
-0.0452665575,
-0.0156899877,
-0.0179115385,
-0.0344418548,
0.0637617186,
0.0249454323,
0.029036073,
0.0491181426,
0.0596547499,
0.0350226127,
0.0135916434,
0.0116557088,
0.0582888536,
-0.0182406269,
0.0221986696,
0.0644975305,
0.0213171169,
-0.0212121196,
0.0142872715,
0.0317247175,
0.0886763781,
-0.0143633038,
0.0037428858,
-0.0207141358,
-0.0074992962,
0.0393927582,
0.041153308,
-0.0401766971,
0.0373540036,
0.0022994974,
-0.0781306624,
0.0140099144,
0.0165389981,
-0.050210204,
-0.0421957709,
-0.0372440852,
-0.0132411066,
-0.0370851681,
0.0273980461,
-0.0008599671,
0.033054661,
-0.0185642578,
0.0489491187,
-0.0119867846,
-0.0824616328,
0.0520885289,
-0.0495244823,
0.0676693991,
0.0341817513,
-0.0231089164,
-0.0259686038,
-0.0695714355,
-0.0046146531,
0.0173994359,
-0.0218455698,
-0.0352697559,
0.0199586712,
0.0123563288,
-0.0262328144,
-0.0089470688,
0.0385591872,
-0.0055152806,
0.0253803078,
0.0087884394,
0.0678196624,
0.0132947704,
0.0495441556,
-0.0114805801,
0.0147376023,
0.0382789187,
0.0479430445,
0.0318919457,
-0.0826699436,
0.0364994816,
-0.0073669022,
-0.0208702497,
-0.0052967588,
-0.0442462638,
0.0606651492,
0.02730079,
-0.0800131559,
-0.0580775104,
-0.0272492785,
0.0307435263,
0.0465413108,
0.0240371935,
-0.0214816723,
-0.0704866424,
0.0103058545,
-0.007705146,
0.0139133753,
0.0109621147,
0.0844330341,
-0.0319785401,
0.0017378819,
0.0000511404,
-0.0130406264,
-0.039421767,
0.0302896667,
-0.0253061671,
-0.0570843779,
0.0551894754,
0.0061957641,
0.0148848398,
0.0316977315,
-0.0460398458,
-0.0454972386,
0.0773928538,
0.0308154821,
-0.0201252345,
0.027557414,
0.0441320576,
-0.0618923157,
0.0182211921,
-0.0015507489,
-0.054447487,
-0.0067159506,
-0.0381836481,
0.0062526618,
0.0153534235,
-0.0997286513,
0.0017873402,
0.0600721873,
0.0591847934,
-0.0300669242,
0.0155139379,
-0.0145108933,
0.0447357818,
0.0595297739,
0.0278123263,
0.0005631119,
-0.0240904558,
0.0253276564,
-0.0168727431,
-0.0298886057,
0.0342172198,
-0.0176239368,
-0.0142004779,
0.0191177651,
0.0517180599,
0.0007167265,
-0.0056929328,
-0.0341656953,
0.0146656344,
-0.013558913,
-0.0104468679,
0.0227516331,
0.0452989638,
0.0134856394,
-0.0356497467,
-0.0237314627,
-0.012342155,
0.0337582119,
0.0134568708,
0.00094657,
0.0458618924,
-0.0518208668,
-0.0643819347,
0.0142761255,
-0.0241247769,
0.0377888046,
0.0315925181,
0.0473654903,
-0.0570482127,
-0.0413268916,
-0.0308561921,
0.0351767503,
0.0096933031,
-0.0067550763,
0.0108739361,
0.0131765315,
0.0204643924,
-0.0163184926,
0.0143806823,
-0.0585881807,
0.0524693392,
-0.0082078455,
-0.0094554406,
-0.0585313365,
0.0240958724,
-0.0336012691,
-0.0439243428,
-0.0700164959,
-0.0439678095,
0.0354749188,
0.0468976982,
0.0560547113,
0.0252691191,
-0.0223582387,
-0.0038522738,
-0.0710689723,
0.0527353957,
0.0247752182,
-0.0823285207,
-0.0031709888,
-0.0186134595,
0.0285960343,
-6.426822876e-33,
-0.0445507281,
-0.0403365493,
0.0042037861,
-0.015925156,
0.0181641467,
0.0175770838,
0.0337462872,
0.0330550633,
-0.0390112884,
-0.0060832486,
-0.0048057749,
-0.0350028984,
0.0283703376,
-0.0153744426,
0.0166422669,
0.0132596781,
0.0560721606,
0.0211547837,
-0.0026175766,
-0.0045426143,
0.0156971514,
0.0122274682,
0.0700095743,
-0.0827713609,
0.017964378,
0.0429840349,
-0.0258764271,
-0.0053103822,
-0.0496975444,
0.0570068173,
0.012979744,
0.1081200838,
-0.0064264596,
-0.0008767197,
-0.0209944192,
-0.0488518514,
-0.0382393561,
-0.025033351,
0.0243756138,
0.066684626,
0.0581786446,
0.007906531,
0.0007170497,
0.0268971547,
-0.0517729297,
-0.0432426035,
0.0402995721,
-0.0208808742,
0.0353994705,
-0.0240000375,
0.0406444259,
0.0288934335,
0.0065927999,
-0.0483187251,
0.0268825684,
0.0307246912,
-0.0241500456,
-0.0426773503,
-0.0366170667,
0.0447739661,
0.0332704484,
0.0540368073,
0.0588284321,
0.0309576504,
-0.0281891357,
0.0333196186,
0.044208698,
-0.0553993694,
0.0235658195,
-0.041339051,
0.0419146568,
-0.0483835973,
0.038699232,
0.0299412198,
0.0252968483,
-0.0302018933,
-0.0032909461,
0.0299538448,
0.0074099475,
-0.0425637141,
-0.0071620527,
0.0212539006,
-0.0463463701,
-0.0210643113,
-0.070867829,
-0.043332275,
-0.0688659549,
0.0022736441,
0.0288900621,
-0.0164245963,
-0.0052687572,
0.0489244722,
0.018786503,
0.0002341916,
-0.0098256869,
-0.0230838507,
-0.0004102424,
-0.0026420371,
-0.010022752,
-0.0156623311,
-0.019005103,
0.0103470348,
0.0433535241,
0.0467697233,
0.0142709585,
-0.0329605751,
-0.0062744985,
0.0528085493,
-0.0597320832,
0.0099022035,
0.0043257615,
0.0095620705,
-0.0336532518,
-0.0257669147,
0.0232557617,
0.0349653177,
-0.0361923017,
0.0618930496,
-0.0020217102,
0.0052745771,
-0.0152266072,
-0.0032818271,
-0.0242116116,
0.0354515202,
0.007774841,
-0.0039356449,
0.0576689094,
-0.0883929506,
-0.0101731978,
0.007561801,
-0.013176837,
0.019604519,
2.743e-7,
-0.0241574049,
0.0178278517,
0.011816198,
-0.0686145723,
-0.016090652,
0.0277730823,
-0.0342706405,
-0.0176242255,
0.0197535753,
-0.0162760932,
-0.0067147054,
-0.0262976121,
0.0334388763,
0.0488815531,
-0.0611056983,
0.0297384635,
-0.0461334102,
0.0321550891,
-0.0073185232,
0.0061931401,
0.0442384742,
0.0449488498,
-0.0121095227,
-0.0762753859,
0.0264944863,
0.0247356407,
-0.0400515012,
0.0240615346,
-0.0438975506,
-0.0530612879,
0.0392806865,
-0.023888208,
0.0567164533,
0.0626845732,
-0.0242083594,
0.0034400921,
0.0128435334,
-0.0148111722,
-0.0283437539,
-0.0760128275,
-0.023445718,
0.0518500209,
-0.0524751656,
0.0379423089,
0.0436103418,
0.0911218226,
-0.0033720883,
-0.0293083396,
-0.0452163219,
0.007582556,
0.057937853,
-0.0138320187,
-0.0058847363,
0.0353057534,
-0.0026029411,
-0.0092173107,
-0.0116482126,
0.0134738861,
-0.0011791488,
0.0807776973,
0.0004616623,
-0.0420292169,
0.0069812117,
-0.0056814016,
-0.013217696,
-0.0503973737,
-0.0361507274,
1.966427791e-34,
0.0179359689,
-0.0297489986,
0.0717835501,
0.0018991145,
-0.0263120197,
-0.0027583938,
0.0469208583,
-0.020771727,
0.0140648689,
0.0222424436,
-0.0413430184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15720v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15720v1 | Scaling Laws for Fact Memorization of Large Language Models | 2024-06-22T03:32:09 | 2024-06-22T03:32:09 | Xingyu Lu, Xiaonan Li, Qinyuan Cheng, Kai Ding, Xuanjing Huang, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fact knowledge memorization is crucial for Large Language Models (LLM) to
generate factual and reliable responses. However, the behaviors of LLM fact
memorization remain under-explored. In this paper, we analyze the scaling laws
for LLM's fact knowledge and LLMs' behaviors of memorizing different types of
facts. We find that LLMs' fact knowledge capacity has a linear and negative
exponential law relationship with model size and training epochs, respectively.
Estimated by the built scaling law, memorizing the whole Wikidata's facts
requires training an LLM with 1000B non-embed parameters for 100 epochs,
suggesting that using LLMs to memorize all public facts is almost implausible
for a general pre-training setting. Meanwhile, we find that LLMs can generalize
on unseen fact knowledge and its scaling law is similar to general
pre-training. Additionally, we analyze the compatibility and preference of
LLMs' fact memorization. For compatibility, we find LLMs struggle with
memorizing redundant facts in a unified way. Only when correlated facts have
the same direction and structure, the LLM can compatibly memorize them. This
shows the inefficiency of LLM memorization for redundant facts. For preference,
the LLM pays more attention to memorizing more frequent and difficult facts,
and the subsequent facts can overwrite prior facts' memorization, which
significantly hinders low-frequency facts memorization. Our findings reveal the
capacity and characteristics of LLMs' fact knowledge learning, which provide
directions for LLMs' fact knowledge augmentation. | [
0.0033209617,
0.0023919332,
-0.0097857509,
0.0228847079,
-0.017908223,
0.0276666526,
-0.0088895112,
0.0023919491,
-0.00580703,
-0.0448289923,
0.0038402409,
-0.0640422627,
0.006354182,
-0.0056580678,
0.0009632505,
-0.0286412314,
0.0349783488,
-0.0493761227,
0.0179999992,
-0.0450529121,
-0.0220227987,
-0.038373936,
-0.0123825027,
-0.0253063012,
-0.0407854021,
-0.0107823405,
-0.0103041725,
-0.0389611274,
0.0067037591,
-0.0293177105,
-0.0164828654,
0.0427372083,
0.0467203185,
0.0048436052,
0.0000020457,
-0.0596256182,
0.0097216461,
-0.0379568189,
-0.068650201,
0.0566902794,
-0.0189229473,
-0.0113920169,
-0.0084894625,
-0.0153039247,
-0.0258388743,
-0.0415638573,
0.045934964,
0.0724062771,
0.0238566715,
0.0711779818,
0.024612952,
-0.0328720957,
0.0659037679,
0.0007287995,
0.0010673819,
-0.0121438894,
0.0544621684,
0.0538066328,
-0.0575783215,
0.030298207,
-0.0519819111,
0.0172365103,
0.014088884,
0.064261727,
0.0262202844,
0.0781006292,
0.0376760848,
-0.0062754028,
0.0077096731,
0.0561077073,
0.046046827,
-0.0342583433,
-0.0058384538,
0.0084093772,
0.0136341285,
0.0508652516,
-0.0665307567,
0.0302223638,
-0.018010851,
0.016206773,
-0.0097004939,
-0.0139518892,
0.0450700782,
0.0073605082,
-0.0097824,
0.0358405299,
-0.0097221099,
-0.0482066348,
-0.0231693406,
-0.0221662167,
-0.0199949592,
-0.0596747436,
-0.0213323347,
0.0465652123,
0.013550383,
0.043921452,
-0.0231980439,
-0.0039604995,
0.050991144,
-0.0744616762,
0.0098210303,
0.0083333282,
-0.02379594,
0.0691294968,
-0.0458020829,
0.0627193674,
-0.0116418162,
0.00908799,
-0.0233072955,
0.0172466598,
-0.0575205311,
-0.0041884179,
-0.0085680727,
0.0537704565,
0.0632100105,
0.0005936786,
-0.0134068336,
0.0013640671,
0.0173295308,
0.0390824974,
0.0029405572,
-0.0219495818,
-0.0188831314,
-0.0283403508,
-0.0528701916,
0.0451110378,
-0.037717592,
0.0142088337,
-0.0165961608,
-0.0022703167,
-0.0081328331,
-0.0298062172,
0.0102376509,
0.0184721556,
0.0189153552,
0.0323309116,
0.0019798111,
-0.0171042047,
-0.0923957452,
-0.0086124726,
0.0302629061,
-0.0722493306,
-0.0110333208,
-0.0759789869,
0.0110415379,
0.0316575356,
-0.0123985521,
-0.0255682562,
0.0117616644,
0.017558651,
-0.0612254106,
0.0462120734,
0.0170508288,
0.0312303789,
0.0281818882,
0.0171866044,
0.0184667781,
0.0914984941,
0.0086976103,
0.0101671433,
0.0353038684,
-0.0143723395,
-0.0094896667,
-0.001800888,
0.0433179624,
0.023382239,
0.028053565,
0.0085400585,
0.0755527392,
0.029969791,
0.0566593707,
0.0394691117,
-0.0271604806,
-0.0737598464,
0.0775801167,
0.0022792991,
0.006336099,
0.0398560874,
0.0168752298,
-0.0090673221,
0.0621353723,
0.0834894031,
-0.057136558,
0.0346631035,
-0.0133196237,
0.0300226659,
-0.0052891122,
0.0568021201,
-0.0620130971,
-0.019152578,
-0.0330877341,
0.0016708357,
-0.0277534164,
-0.003160255,
0.0625026599,
-0.0102744699,
-0.030510664,
0.1061634794,
0.0606194623,
-0.0065767867,
0.0210547056,
-0.0145578403,
0.0182926506,
0.0249678101,
-0.0024085324,
-0.0294461083,
-0.0296444874,
0.0186729487,
0.0341430083,
-0.0155974189,
0.0587076582,
-0.0139090754,
-0.0165314022,
-0.0691874772,
0.0022616703,
-0.0140586104,
0.0294920634,
0.0253068879,
0.0172365922,
0.0175799131,
0.0081407242,
-0.0395892672,
-0.0253418963,
0.0224940237,
-0.0461811684,
-0.0682559237,
-0.05287214,
-0.0044183396,
0.0068864617,
0.0080192564,
-0.004849127,
-0.0053470456,
0.0269578975,
-0.0152917691,
-0.001771076,
0.0011326688,
-0.0582407862,
-0.0209535733,
0.0390022285,
0.023479538,
0.0175310075,
-0.0019605006,
-0.0091120154,
-0.042615626,
0.0134630073,
-0.0081814202,
0.0905919895,
-0.0133921038,
0.032733839,
-0.0016183958,
-0.0029046491,
-0.0078257024,
0.0742155015,
-0.0434483439,
-0.0035099743,
0.0123628145,
-0.0147638712,
0.0074765012,
-0.0367949009,
-0.0099757034,
0.0106222592,
0.0030792009,
0.0379836485,
-0.0146011654,
-0.0713437274,
-0.0577938706,
0.0002868777,
-0.0716048405,
0.0030970126,
-0.0172788501,
0.0124056088,
0.0204359479,
-0.0111810509,
-0.0057872375,
-0.0040946258,
-0.0414159335,
0.036974974,
-0.0338250175,
0.0546664335,
0.0025493836,
0.0095867962,
-0.0200660061,
-0.0202990975,
-0.0065316805,
-0.0188832022,
0.0182228368,
0.0066005071,
0.0235772021,
-0.0403710976,
0.0501194671,
-0.0355632156,
0.0173472147,
-0.0352846943,
-0.0225678328,
-0.0090681184,
-0.0113348821,
0.0580390058,
0.083279565,
0.0419567376,
0.0141564207,
0.0737459362,
-0.008687445,
-0.0550805442,
0.0115124891,
-0.0448381715,
-0.0241524577,
-0.0415233783,
-0.021695083,
-0.0037330477,
0.0543387495,
0.0063906587,
-0.0028023575,
-0.0362697281,
0.0106021902,
-0.0217681117,
-0.0123509914,
-0.038091097,
-0.0000331949,
-0.019782234,
0.0235285796,
0.0096727842,
-0.0382541679,
0.0467797965,
-0.0274007525,
0.0170236249,
-0.000104597,
0.007578244,
0.0030803096,
0.0639319792,
0.0232981611,
0.0278166737,
-0.0028584965,
-0.0046710856,
-0.0616605133,
-0.0204149075,
0.0493022092,
-0.0327226594,
0.0444958769,
-0.0330373831,
0.0074104811,
0.0055078254,
-0.0242746491,
-0.0726267025,
-0.0210796446,
-0.0191258863,
-0.019411182,
-0.0461037047,
-0.034811534,
-0.0321982391,
-0.0197919793,
0.0726825669,
-0.007537886,
0.0089650601,
-0.0087392079,
0.0150032481,
0.020290209,
0.0445967056,
0.0345065743,
0.0429559574,
-0.0312763676,
0.0061887428,
0.0543337204,
0.0291177761,
-0.0257616695,
-0.0059454469,
-0.01749474,
0.0071803411,
-0.0523630679,
-0.0126078604,
0.0381491445,
0.0369379073,
-0.0513607077,
0.0316197388,
0.0902910158,
0.0017861087,
-0.0165886544,
0.0110011548,
-0.0075273616,
0.0227747522,
0.0067578251,
-0.0224083532,
-0.055065874,
0.0140522122,
-0.0013290469,
-0.0117405877,
-0.0022069977,
-0.0228443034,
-0.02786199,
-0.0972953439,
-0.0308854599,
0.0208718944,
0.013420023,
-0.0202765223,
-0.0600871481,
0.004832543,
-0.0223136991,
0.0106201051,
0.0397046208,
-0.0359851122,
-0.0026500879,
0.0213298593,
0.0013908985,
-0.0391391255,
0.0399175361,
-0.0344774053,
0.0898325071,
-0.0248884428,
0.0220254119,
-0.0216453541,
-0.0439883396,
0.014736779,
0.0025924104,
0.0102475444,
0.0086749941,
0.0595522188,
0.0030080224,
0.0123816123,
-0.0272345003,
0.0156478453,
0.009548001,
-0.0356111899,
0.011065973,
0.0654270574,
0.004236809,
-0.035360463,
0.0020273514,
0.0019946056,
-0.028167991,
0.1110591441,
0.0364454277,
0.0139249302,
0.0245303195,
-0.0058677457,
0.0101069231,
-0.0096988762,
-0.055748567,
0.0258069132,
-0.0135713806,
-0.0219307393,
-0.0873374715,
0.0003111457,
-0.0135706719,
0.0460667722,
0.0033460332,
0.0203970987,
0.0531545877,
-0.0023836596,
-0.0171520282,
0.0051075616,
-0.0584948286,
-0.0386639759,
-0.0506402403,
-0.0474187955,
0.0443205498,
-0.0484017432,
0.004866702,
-0.0264131967,
-0.0718150735,
-0.0584001914,
0.0441970304,
0.0276948158,
0.0263669491,
0.0651086345,
0.0223371647,
-0.0300847907,
0.0693742856,
0.0278227888,
-0.0627828613,
0.0376302451,
0.0253179744,
-0.0080309249,
0.0005956358,
0.0330195054,
-0.0279939659,
0.0033214921,
0.0002541431,
0.0096726073,
-0.0520657599,
-0.0158589073,
0.0234999657,
0.0253392812,
0.0120630693,
0.0096224248,
-0.0193307102,
-0.0170168262,
0.0081844553,
0.0130892545,
0.0236701891,
0.0191192459,
0.0171294045,
0.0081677167,
0.0098487847,
0.0036600479,
-0.0581288971,
0.0251262803,
0.0183148514,
0.023373194,
-0.0383187123,
-0.012770175,
-0.012411857,
0.0595812723,
-0.0045271958,
-0.0546712391,
0.0206187814,
-0.0132834408,
0.023487322,
0.0065434957,
0.0504068658,
0.0023145378,
-0.0165875182,
-0.0604455024,
-0.01700476,
-0.0860664845,
-0.054045476,
-0.0166306179,
0.0243218411,
0.0583288185,
-0.0468463562,
0.0201380122,
-0.0683277398,
0.010066851,
-0.0260969885,
-0.0327966698,
-0.0030914124,
0.0236144885,
0.0359391607,
0.0346349031,
-0.0131216431,
0.0411604345,
0.1150269359,
-0.0006104958,
0.0770361423,
-0.0014499176,
0.013405011,
-0.0124556562,
-0.0469518639,
-0.0283020847,
0.0072711133,
-0.0295724794,
0.0042888648,
-0.0863083601,
-0.0640436336,
-0.0163409971,
0.0012010981,
0.0020355091,
-0.0450171754,
0.0197742656,
0.0623215027,
-0.0152938953,
-0.0059388583,
-0.0128313331,
0.0503859669,
0.0062875114,
0.0152409291,
-0.0047996007,
-6.725926679e-33,
-0.019590402,
0.022026943,
0.0387718156,
0.016884122,
0.0130422907,
0.0401687324,
0.0126616824,
0.0015528057,
-0.061512731,
-0.0036203733,
-0.0052215811,
-0.0140826087,
0.0098048234,
0.000699245,
0.0076736812,
-0.0379599854,
0.0628894717,
-0.0041134055,
-0.0247132685,
0.0331828371,
0.0785189644,
0.0059404462,
0.0511301756,
-0.0738966912,
0.0074537373,
-0.0157766119,
0.0268247854,
0.0263062622,
-0.0046825637,
0.0613467023,
-0.0398129635,
0.0451974235,
0.0286182947,
-0.0670710057,
-0.0344082862,
-0.03014745,
-0.0809452683,
-0.0374910943,
0.061397355,
-0.0049338243,
0.0413237326,
-0.0190311428,
0.0410101451,
-0.0199656617,
-0.0098285917,
-0.0313398354,
0.0238951705,
-0.0223324075,
-0.0528027602,
0.004202161,
-0.032457158,
0.0092121335,
0.0265797079,
-0.0090756034,
-0.0153147718,
-0.0374866463,
0.011478913,
-0.016604254,
-0.0956919342,
0.0351680592,
0.0429524332,
0.0386263616,
0.0342377983,
0.0205925088,
0.0237319302,
0.0807934329,
-0.0142549276,
0.0241443273,
-0.0379280932,
0.0008286325,
0.0205603093,
0.0193945318,
-0.0084110638,
0.0568194762,
0.0412749685,
-0.0236457307,
-0.0514029898,
0.0045674467,
0.030829804,
0.0490891263,
0.0189979076,
0.0146334805,
-0.0501927547,
-0.0360363498,
-0.0491975099,
0.0687028468,
-0.0314688645,
-0.0219258666,
-0.0035061683,
0.0179280061,
0.0027727501,
-0.0349502973,
0.0161925014,
-0.0092091365,
-0.0159683023,
0.0362421758,
-0.0006982022,
0.0110084685,
-0.0270088743,
-0.006300942,
-0.1038886011,
-0.0055778008,
-0.012066545,
-0.0055476534,
-0.0070142373,
0.0616331249,
0.0323162898,
0.0180813018,
-0.0315013267,
-0.0157208778,
-0.0183612034,
-0.0457203947,
0.0489027314,
-0.0402233377,
0.0383949541,
0.0208143387,
-0.0104773575,
0.0254847929,
0.0226626787,
-0.0145285632,
-0.0406585746,
-0.0119898887,
-0.0123880748,
0.0536901131,
-0.0421625748,
-0.0126704043,
-0.0366331041,
-0.0233037136,
0.031063471,
-0.0331256948,
0.0098756831,
0.0207704622,
2.751e-7,
-0.0272604767,
0.0290340763,
-0.012621182,
-0.0161192045,
0.005151818,
0.0518568382,
-0.0250962321,
0.0223887842,
0.0315619335,
-0.0809738114,
-0.0030520791,
0.0858487636,
-0.0011195136,
0.0229869485,
-0.0759737417,
-0.0334776416,
-0.0509051494,
-0.0319957994,
-0.0379837081,
-0.0108746858,
-0.0050824797,
0.0621607974,
0.0487189963,
0.0006664498,
0.0214651618,
-0.0328299403,
0.089616172,
-0.0412229896,
-0.0254973304,
0.0044583799,
0.0445805974,
0.0291832611,
-0.0090324925,
0.0580773801,
-0.0055127162,
-0.000623633,
-0.0274609905,
0.0560823344,
0.0543109849,
0.0136608342,
-0.0217709634,
-0.0502242818,
-0.0256078225,
-0.053146489,
0.0727206841,
-0.0482978411,
-0.0419118777,
0.0037293115,
0.0089472765,
0.0027594711,
0.0003906642,
0.0030968015,
-0.0121839065,
0.0091132671,
-0.0363228396,
0.00261911,
0.0217403583,
-0.0478674434,
-0.0189671014,
0.0428513251,
-0.0502289981,
-0.1117629409,
-0.0252522156,
-0.054678496,
0.0500487201,
-0.0710054263,
0.0257457662,
2.21531622e-34,
0.0323464461,
-0.0218670778,
0.0012006176,
0.0059478972,
-0.0143160513,
-0.0431814417,
-0.0159825906,
-0.0005447437,
0.0231164806,
-0.1088459939,
0.0047274018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15718v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15718v1 | Beyond the Turn-Based Game: Enabling Real-Time Conversations with Duplex Models | 2024-06-22T03:20:10 | 2024-06-22T03:20:10 | Xinrong Zhang, Yingfa Chen, Shengding Hu, Xu Han, Zihang Xu, Yuanwei Xu, Weilin Zhao, Maosong Sun, Zhiyuan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) increasingly permeate daily lives, there is a
growing demand for real-time interactions that mirror human conversations.
Traditional turn-based chat systems driven by LLMs prevent users from verbally
interacting with the system while it is generating responses. To overcome these
limitations, we adapt existing LLMs to \textit{duplex models} so that these
LLMs can listen for users while generating output and dynamically adjust
themselves to provide users with instant feedback. % such as in response to
interruptions. Specifically, we divide the queries and responses of
conversations into several time slices and then adopt a
time-division-multiplexing (TDM) encoding-decoding strategy to
pseudo-simultaneously process these slices. Furthermore, to make LLMs
proficient enough to handle real-time conversations, we build a fine-tuning
dataset consisting of alternating time slices of queries and responses as well
as covering typical feedback types in instantaneous interactions. Our
experiments show that although the queries and responses of conversations are
segmented into incomplete slices for processing, LLMs can preserve their
original performance on standard benchmarks with a few fine-tuning steps on our
dataset. Automatic and human evaluation indicate that duplex models make
user-AI interactions more natural and human-like, and greatly improve user
satisfaction compared to vanilla LLMs. Our duplex model and dataset will be
released. | [
0.0105627645,
0.0273692179,
-0.0260255672,
0.027747957,
-0.0283936206,
0.0261784196,
0.0037375921,
0.0001737117,
-0.0156954378,
-0.0395041183,
-0.0356492661,
-0.0318523981,
0.0024988803,
0.0565903373,
-0.0051613287,
-0.0472207181,
0.0399218909,
-0.0381976888,
0.0191391688,
0.0006180613,
0.012350779,
-0.0137597546,
-0.0506486967,
0.0689683482,
-0.0091761658,
-0.0192564689,
-0.0669380948,
0.0208162908,
-0.0382542461,
-0.015588942,
0.0021739954,
0.0709294453,
0.0327397808,
0.0267128181,
0.0000021555,
0.0143846609,
0.0230571721,
-0.0391967334,
-0.027759878,
0.0146403238,
0.0306779556,
0.0288865361,
0.0207751039,
0.0337351635,
-0.0679018497,
0.0063213054,
0.0337996744,
0.0339240767,
0.0903198346,
0.0436269343,
-0.0073087527,
0.0001914221,
0.0030952715,
-0.0117261568,
0.0177715868,
-0.044760067,
-0.0156446714,
0.022242561,
0.0465553701,
0.0290806126,
0.0240595173,
0.0259591751,
0.0166753959,
-0.0377693996,
-0.0192379802,
0.0237269476,
-0.0247365665,
0.0012630151,
-0.0214121472,
0.0740604475,
-0.0147556877,
0.00818469,
0.0172668621,
0.0194427278,
0.0141947186,
-0.0366066247,
-0.0591682419,
-0.0361718833,
-0.0118846698,
-0.0058463095,
-0.0497424789,
0.0252617095,
0.0071588331,
-0.0170469079,
0.00076323,
0.0536283106,
-0.0042889197,
-0.013354443,
-0.0562266335,
0.0125754513,
0.0553421862,
-0.0639097095,
0.02255705,
0.0324643292,
-0.0839672014,
0.0114604542,
-0.0720726252,
0.0158124678,
-0.0066627557,
-0.0669292361,
0.0206306502,
0.0662622526,
0.0045528491,
0.0489260219,
0.0338560902,
0.0207585767,
-0.0217004213,
-0.0123241786,
-0.032145936,
-0.0115359034,
-0.0175083652,
-0.029906569,
-0.0493789054,
0.0493771136,
-0.0477441102,
-0.0521265902,
-0.0291302484,
0.0656920671,
0.0151362261,
0.0235591251,
0.0209681951,
0.0076726796,
-0.014597795,
0.0016409145,
0.0057839588,
0.0312758982,
-0.0133050149,
0.0027034748,
0.0318911597,
-0.1585300267,
-0.0200647544,
-0.0186547823,
-0.002205187,
-0.0345815495,
-0.0387384109,
0.0627299845,
-0.0285599101,
-0.0315546989,
0.0479185544,
-0.0258719344,
-0.0127511211,
-0.0252924655,
-0.0039298474,
-0.0438297763,
0.0593571998,
-0.0083622327,
0.0179074984,
0.0067730276,
0.0302909743,
0.019297611,
-0.016114777,
0.0714953691,
0.0202105325,
0.0799517781,
0.0527272373,
0.000523654,
0.020912027,
0.0565398037,
0.0630282313,
-0.0226448923,
0.0420533903,
-0.0261724461,
0.0541588254,
0.0786364749,
-0.011279474,
-0.0315558836,
-0.0246013179,
-0.00228506,
-0.034554936,
0.0539093725,
-0.0137443328,
0.041784972,
-0.0406970754,
-0.0219927914,
0.1180091426,
0.0178930834,
-0.0023492544,
0.0005724126,
0.0324936807,
0.0356983766,
0.003576966,
0.0079911705,
-0.0237779208,
0.058844164,
0.0170188751,
0.007742851,
0.0489205718,
-0.0058240341,
-0.0570881888,
-0.036649704,
0.0239968821,
-0.0104367454,
0.0214351807,
0.0342241079,
0.0588081963,
-0.0035548192,
-0.0622727796,
0.0282287505,
-0.0029103714,
-0.0342147686,
-0.010210433,
-0.0516654179,
-0.0085238246,
0.1218300834,
0.0661918744,
-0.0055927108,
-0.0155990701,
-0.0017797657,
-0.0223676618,
0.0259180479,
0.0542232543,
-0.0078055868,
0.0144278416,
0.0004735305,
-0.0060600936,
0.0281339213,
-0.000978838,
0.0265427642,
-0.0051894807,
0.0086469436,
-0.0416174568,
0.0081393635,
0.0159301683,
0.0069345809,
-0.0120066032,
-0.023946071,
-0.0006107515,
-0.0076367334,
0.0025230346,
0.0424516313,
-0.0385498628,
0.0147023536,
0.0339809284,
-0.0154477134,
-0.0074694827,
0.0582858026,
-0.0712645501,
-0.0342861973,
0.0442704856,
0.0078142611,
-0.0329621173,
0.0862195939,
-0.0020500687,
-0.0073576337,
0.0168981906,
-0.0247852113,
0.0553246662,
-0.0123989843,
0.033574868,
0.0003533821,
0.0339474492,
0.0073344721,
-0.0165461488,
-0.0266083498,
-0.0178221837,
-0.014463203,
-0.0490417071,
-0.0198139101,
-0.0818288252,
-0.0026429908,
0.0487354659,
-0.0204948429,
-0.0084843254,
-0.0184461921,
0.0110368822,
-0.0416376032,
-0.0345823057,
-0.092483297,
-0.0268400032,
-0.0173096526,
-0.0032196848,
0.0072869388,
0.0164164267,
-0.0112249972,
-0.0295375455,
-0.0329769999,
-0.0317313969,
0.0581452362,
0.0004727679,
0.0170339309,
-0.0124561321,
-0.0134831956,
-0.0458871536,
-0.0182858724,
0.0010205049,
0.0328525268,
-0.0426487327,
-0.044369299,
-0.013507749,
-0.021042252,
0.0159794558,
0.0351476595,
-0.0104969433,
-0.0510209613,
0.0392805152,
-0.0198238306,
0.0309493076,
0.0441135839,
0.0217927173,
0.0304166041,
0.0219296683,
-0.0506750606,
-0.0394837335,
0.0379621908,
-0.0197000224,
-0.0137619069,
-0.0553775318,
-0.0282964632,
0.0347745121,
0.0650197566,
0.0073085106,
0.017818721,
-0.0435674153,
-0.0241110213,
-0.0113983387,
-0.065191865,
-0.0382120609,
-0.0249317475,
-0.0369542576,
0.0013814787,
-0.0126225101,
-0.0274320059,
0.0424541347,
-0.0341624543,
-0.0490569212,
0.0201261826,
-0.0148776462,
-0.0134402281,
0.0638841987,
-0.0269523747,
-0.0009247144,
-0.0661296695,
-0.0433872715,
0.0198238324,
-0.0000996831,
-0.0014869921,
-0.0727567598,
0.0423877537,
-0.0666637495,
-0.0117179183,
-0.0120921843,
-0.0172335226,
-0.0248776264,
0.0088084759,
-0.0394159481,
-0.0009235957,
0.0298368149,
-0.0348779261,
-0.0541396141,
0.0264031012,
0.0051710159,
0.0426630601,
-0.0352440774,
-0.0251252279,
-0.0367221013,
0.0191259887,
0.0589551106,
0.0327484533,
-0.059211012,
-0.0227646735,
0.0812866911,
0.0545829795,
0.0563899763,
-0.0031617128,
-0.0098482268,
-0.011233245,
0.0613358878,
0.0122629805,
0.004468237,
0.030950509,
0.0145154558,
-0.0417797454,
-0.017151447,
0.1213232875,
0.0298822876,
-0.0713498071,
0.0027409527,
-0.0510733239,
-0.0201999564,
-0.0012062532,
0.0130753908,
-0.0738672763,
-0.0229725782,
0.0190408137,
0.0051871696,
0.0335250571,
-0.0209466126,
0.0018305457,
-0.1156549305,
-0.0129920933,
0.0021581901,
-0.0231810734,
-0.0521990843,
0.0112852976,
-0.0168461502,
0.0060384837,
0.0677517951,
0.0036107812,
0.0349790603,
-0.0066039455,
0.0115372902,
-0.041563265,
-0.0012162649,
0.0396374576,
-0.0203674678,
0.0983035788,
0.0382238179,
0.0782743618,
0.0203932803,
-0.0172684789,
0.0064905677,
0.0162643827,
-0.0022460592,
-0.0055844709,
0.0149754146,
-0.0313409418,
-0.0025834423,
0.0081072133,
0.0017986264,
-0.0189609285,
0.0068896869,
0.0164128337,
0.0172589608,
-0.0489644222,
-0.0023663733,
-0.0316708311,
0.0117041357,
0.0551139116,
0.0481347889,
-0.0010805489,
-0.065527536,
-0.0223815572,
-0.0082137659,
0.0065608774,
-0.0659530237,
-0.0706177801,
0.002339558,
0.0442303605,
-0.0115291607,
-0.0549687222,
-0.0286104511,
-0.0008019066,
-0.0040282854,
-0.0158927795,
0.0314872041,
0.0461992361,
0.0185969956,
0.0079668397,
-0.0493136607,
-0.0099541554,
0.0188369974,
-0.0366519988,
-0.0139272111,
-0.0103975227,
-0.0379743055,
0.0096883681,
0.0449740998,
-0.0681906566,
-0.0476030633,
0.0298176929,
0.0496292934,
0.0201094411,
0.0136101684,
-0.0231332537,
-0.0402417108,
-0.0454545021,
-0.0103469817,
-0.043617066,
0.0152232638,
0.0163193829,
0.0440478437,
0.0014854397,
0.0292120464,
-0.0644535869,
0.0145565365,
-0.0416282304,
0.0326643959,
-0.0744235739,
-0.0598834082,
0.0165003724,
0.0079446938,
0.0607590564,
0.0408350676,
0.0520397983,
0.0384979434,
0.0396661907,
-0.0815368965,
0.0231658462,
-0.0723435581,
0.0012242558,
-0.0169884935,
-0.0146020185,
0.0132361921,
-0.0050418582,
-0.0393087678,
-0.0174923372,
-0.003298068,
-0.0387192219,
-0.0070670624,
-0.0219193492,
0.0018654033,
0.0159941856,
0.0151268356,
0.0269687101,
-0.0050355252,
-0.0024695359,
0.0079823919,
0.0177253038,
0.0002240042,
-0.0480839759,
0.0042691133,
0.035432864,
-0.0304372478,
-0.0337336212,
0.0414563492,
0.0245140083,
0.0428577736,
0.029868219,
0.0314908288,
-0.0095029548,
0.0315657258,
-0.0356250145,
0.0564684197,
0.0047169817,
-0.0446127243,
0.0041433163,
0.0199258197,
-0.0356944986,
-0.013985524,
0.0531973802,
-0.0183818731,
0.0102632092,
0.0018611251,
-0.0318044797,
-0.0383930542,
-0.0127812726,
0.0019796474,
0.0114098545,
-0.0445164926,
-0.01965384,
-0.0411916003,
-0.0119208489,
-0.0440368876,
0.0617039092,
0.0235903487,
-0.0552618057,
0.0268750433,
0.0396980941,
0.0173003022,
-0.0382856503,
-0.0609958619,
0.017995391,
-0.0199073032,
-0.0132046789,
0.0010603986,
-6.266827809e-33,
-0.0167567097,
-0.052077882,
0.0295886248,
-0.0000840068,
-0.0570203848,
-0.0240086596,
-0.0319811627,
0.027448792,
-0.0384284183,
-0.0200661272,
-0.0523900464,
0.0676083937,
0.0176523756,
0.0155526781,
0.0045110546,
-0.0142644141,
0.0558277555,
-0.0479104295,
0.0047192206,
0.0534562729,
0.0050594527,
-0.0033250023,
0.0243286528,
-0.0528340451,
0.0198738966,
-0.0235302337,
-0.0063050888,
0.0328175016,
-0.020187512,
0.0114005525,
-0.0378624387,
0.0090893935,
0.002502579,
-0.0543208383,
-0.0275420155,
0.0525458008,
-0.0492022485,
0.0077228309,
-0.0110844448,
0.0427668095,
-0.0313420445,
0.0096551934,
-0.019133186,
0.0593530908,
-0.0260176472,
-0.0180817656,
0.0140314633,
-0.0041952603,
-0.0535039641,
0.0016330631,
-0.0011267571,
0.0111773983,
-0.0222789273,
-0.0486779101,
0.0402713194,
0.0882098675,
0.0110149356,
-0.0130062746,
-0.0577468574,
0.0565576516,
0.0119187701,
-0.0062446482,
0.0466913022,
-0.0360439643,
0.0535108559,
0.0399481803,
0.0114778159,
0.024466468,
-0.0510154068,
-0.0149645545,
0.0223269742,
0.0458606333,
0.0111620687,
0.0266072843,
0.0263221003,
-0.0260980558,
-0.0083900709,
0.0287714209,
0.0563180037,
0.0333449952,
0.0469558872,
0.0286184624,
-0.043483343,
0.036012169,
0.0017039176,
0.0366562419,
-0.0218695924,
-0.0608679466,
0.0212291684,
0.0265307445,
0.0356028639,
-0.0504007898,
0.0593342148,
-0.0062869056,
-0.0126997856,
-0.0052129761,
-0.0109035335,
0.0355170555,
-0.0231521875,
-0.0041720741,
0.0267929435,
-0.0113864839,
0.0472739339,
0.0054113227,
0.0143632349,
0.0139504345,
-0.0287209805,
0.0470459275,
-0.038925264,
-0.005806976,
-0.0135014616,
0.0556492321,
0.0155055691,
-0.00550004,
0.0460089855,
-0.0375364348,
-0.0289070699,
0.0427502841,
-0.0189993829,
-0.0520215258,
-0.0651936233,
-0.0079992926,
0.0124100624,
0.0060686911,
-0.0410978645,
0.0084896851,
-0.0723334774,
-0.003669108,
0.0500607342,
-0.0122895269,
-0.0438310057,
-0.0302567817,
2.884e-7,
-0.0207201894,
0.062326096,
0.0326289982,
0.0568736307,
0.0290602352,
0.0474020429,
-0.0151286907,
0.0678169578,
-0.0039166547,
0.0252759401,
0.0602170974,
0.047686737,
0.0750786364,
0.0040681697,
-0.081044443,
-0.0697229728,
-0.0952350944,
0.0145786144,
-0.0219678562,
-0.0111536803,
0.0514288582,
0.0378785767,
0.0228332039,
0.0262674838,
0.040177118,
0.0046606795,
0.0166691113,
-0.0354403369,
-0.0134058557,
0.0061536995,
0.0257190447,
-0.0249951389,
-0.0286719333,
-0.023096228,
-0.0007798867,
-0.0026819068,
0.0255335942,
0.0712113827,
-0.0239738654,
-0.0387879536,
-0.012899884,
0.0081182895,
-0.0184823181,
-0.0516625345,
0.0305920877,
-0.0331593603,
-0.015146629,
-0.0253794901,
0.0212064926,
0.0065675704,
-0.0099180015,
0.0154636679,
-0.0015446703,
0.0034645149,
0.0040142406,
0.0227030143,
0.0440756194,
-0.0511814728,
-0.0092141395,
0.0042286762,
-0.0862454176,
-0.032347966,
-0.0524199158,
-0.0117512858,
0.0032288672,
0.0141928708,
-0.0006680517,
2.309305259e-34,
0.0013564378,
0.0150759751,
-0.0044765412,
0.0911017209,
0.0188857354,
-0.0090070879,
0.0251043756,
0.0231096074,
0.0516123995,
-0.0566274114,
-0.0333761051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15708v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15708v1 | Teach Better or Show Smarter? On Instructions and Exemplars in Automatic Prompt Optimization | 2024-06-22T02:07:10 | 2024-06-22T02:07:10 | Xingchen Wan, Ruoxi Sun, Hootan Nakhost, Sercan O. Arik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models have demonstrated remarkable capabilities, but their
performance is heavily reliant on effective prompt engineering. Automatic
prompt optimization (APO) methods are designed to automate this and can be
broadly categorized into those targeting instructions (instruction
optimization, IO) vs. those targeting exemplars (exemplar selection, ES).
Despite their shared objective, these have evolved rather independently, with
IO recently receiving more research attention. This paper seeks to bridge this
gap by comprehensively comparing the performance of representative IO and ES
techniques, both isolation and combination, on a diverse set of challenging
tasks. Our findings reveal that intelligently reusing model-generated
input-output pairs obtained from evaluating prompts on the validation set as
exemplars consistently improves performance over IO methods but is currently
under-investigated. We also find that despite the recent focus on IO, how we
select exemplars can outweigh how we optimize instructions, with ES strategies
as simple as random search outperforming state-of-the-art IO methods with seed
instructions without any optimization. Moreover, we observe synergy between ES
and IO, with optimal combinations surpassing individual contributions. We
conclude that studying exemplar selection as a standalone method and its
optimal combination with instruction optimization remains a crucial aspect of
APO and deserves greater consideration in future research, even in the era of
highly capable instruction-following models. | [
0.0207189005,
0.0170753021,
-0.0374294557,
0.0199722759,
-0.0510639027,
0.0093957148,
0.0090955663,
-0.008697859,
-0.0118938275,
-0.028480662,
-0.037863411,
-0.0088852225,
-0.0048546251,
-0.0047116382,
0.0251030084,
-0.0633852184,
0.0834805369,
-0.0679372102,
-0.019975571,
-0.0074346685,
-0.0348089077,
-0.0186720453,
-0.0054126405,
0.041254662,
0.0185674205,
-0.0103548244,
-0.0290947165,
0.0242662877,
-0.0037506453,
-0.0166989528,
-0.0038767313,
0.0546741597,
-0.0026787752,
-0.0003087865,
0.0000023099,
-0.0621039681,
-0.0256899614,
-0.0223170873,
-0.0584496856,
0.0596397929,
-0.001451893,
0.0469383411,
-0.0308329314,
0.0197590459,
0.0046605347,
0.0019897623,
0.0528733768,
-0.0188436508,
0.0553089082,
0.0657480508,
0.0268791616,
0.0254113469,
-0.0056159017,
-0.0098206205,
0.0245051607,
0.0122119021,
0.0230689924,
-0.0702640042,
0.0711746812,
0.042615436,
-0.0301242694,
0.0303354077,
0.0213335529,
-0.0256552342,
-0.0060344758,
0.0334462337,
0.0108955223,
-0.0169532895,
-0.0721651167,
0.0618536621,
-0.0439517982,
-0.0155243585,
0.0073085749,
-0.0392904729,
0.0280592591,
0.0023285539,
-0.0196907017,
0.0348385349,
-0.0116685033,
0.0152151389,
0.0309310202,
0.003338072,
-0.0101438668,
0.0008347874,
0.0008373697,
0.0612887628,
0.0286284946,
-0.0391909182,
0.0224395003,
-0.001513629,
-0.0450059101,
-0.0584729016,
-0.019725373,
0.0475000851,
-0.067321144,
0.0266822595,
-0.0347430743,
-0.0049040141,
-0.0034580366,
0.0383781046,
0.0893984586,
0.0809381157,
-0.018964706,
0.0079812808,
-0.0102773942,
0.0814708173,
0.0189973805,
0.0441414341,
-0.0141481599,
0.0720423684,
-0.0406399444,
0.0151587501,
-0.069021374,
0.0374720953,
-0.0254675522,
-0.0194611698,
-0.0079325903,
0.0407011397,
-0.0177530386,
0.0108183911,
-0.0135102468,
-0.0248890538,
-0.0283634495,
0.0234698225,
-0.0055061788,
0.0046040588,
-0.0415679812,
-0.0136516169,
0.0095783332,
-0.0608389489,
-0.0234524664,
0.0204371307,
-0.0278338864,
-0.0165349729,
-0.0117350891,
0.0723381788,
-0.0141615272,
-0.0432320908,
0.0013147932,
-0.0265373625,
0.0016451451,
-0.0240071304,
0.0047970433,
-0.0606734864,
0.0006946828,
-0.006714432,
0.0003272508,
-0.015495915,
0.016899379,
0.0196445584,
0.032062877,
0.0126755787,
0.0324553512,
0.0311425701,
0.0118377851,
0.0031706658,
-0.0168089252,
0.0646250173,
0.0236503091,
0.016166186,
0.0310627222,
-0.0206582714,
0.0249032136,
0.0712344348,
0.013334739,
0.0119369468,
0.0082067549,
0.012003744,
0.0684792697,
0.0170805603,
0.0003180243,
0.0469361842,
-0.0133377025,
0.007663318,
0.0377881229,
0.0043866015,
-0.0344720483,
-0.034672685,
0.1017097011,
0.014953359,
0.0353128091,
0.0325816721,
-0.0303887781,
0.0203684568,
-0.008528485,
0.0175598562,
0.022142306,
0.0256856736,
-0.0235321447,
-0.0320835561,
-0.0015916481,
0.011626834,
-0.0311943647,
0.035277769,
0.0141696418,
0.007058579,
-0.1035094932,
0.0200199932,
0.0269497577,
-0.0195885412,
-0.0170472208,
-0.0891154781,
0.0476072431,
0.039281711,
0.0507663488,
-0.0209376831,
-0.0175964329,
0.0044539669,
0.025472315,
0.0133852074,
0.0646472275,
-0.0308878329,
0.0144551909,
-0.0396355167,
-0.0514587574,
-0.0106596518,
-0.0000598084,
0.034970127,
0.0430933684,
-0.0213293955,
0.0057515139,
0.027990004,
-0.0536200926,
0.0458055027,
-0.0388190486,
-0.0599427894,
-0.0062094894,
0.0382026732,
-0.0014614211,
-0.017021291,
-0.0071017658,
0.0290710814,
0.0268072877,
0.0049289516,
0.0244924985,
-0.0364940092,
-0.0785989761,
-0.0423026942,
-0.0033162294,
-0.0226585194,
-0.014541449,
0.0044700671,
-0.0406774469,
-0.0306727961,
-0.0124467127,
-0.0576156788,
0.0268481206,
0.0065646982,
0.0520242415,
-0.0277251583,
-0.0281987935,
-0.0489179306,
0.0499613285,
0.0088946931,
-0.0010660092,
0.088846311,
0.0406538732,
0.0235009436,
-0.0637559369,
-0.0076091993,
-0.0087948786,
-0.0239613559,
-0.000796497,
0.0440098271,
0.0297076274,
-0.0383046046,
-0.0520374067,
-0.0719509125,
0.0251815356,
-0.0239982195,
0.004753598,
0.0306106135,
0.0024154875,
-0.028017249,
0.0021253612,
0.0192775652,
-0.0233929567,
-0.0239795092,
0.0174755342,
0.0180072058,
0.0193537977,
-0.0594687946,
-0.0225198809,
-0.0235096887,
-0.0213018302,
0.0081727225,
-0.0104546137,
0.0183746833,
-0.0577864982,
0.047695335,
0.0107358703,
0.017197635,
0.0005888595,
-0.0026099838,
0.0339398459,
-0.0181957744,
0.0362746008,
0.0648743659,
0.0022339798,
0.0277010594,
0.0238283947,
-0.0144096278,
-0.0871327817,
0.0277037024,
-0.0223672614,
-0.0323855579,
0.0040993756,
-0.0412818789,
0.0281386189,
0.0672426298,
0.0187108982,
-0.0074472521,
-0.0597913377,
0.0149961999,
-0.0060537318,
-0.0140145151,
-0.047779277,
-0.0686444491,
-0.0288471542,
0.0218515061,
-0.0434398316,
-0.0781672448,
0.0917111039,
-0.0284396019,
0.0086785499,
-0.0590371452,
0.0551410392,
-0.0154182594,
0.0001131016,
-0.0110592339,
-0.0073638498,
0.0358210132,
-0.0383926407,
-0.0551957749,
0.0286200866,
0.0073958724,
-0.0114774937,
0.0321669206,
-0.0399455987,
-0.0252953898,
0.0304076839,
-0.0418516807,
-0.0600655079,
-0.0414262526,
0.0396344624,
0.0015688051,
0.0231664795,
-0.0050304472,
-0.0147144748,
-0.021277979,
0.0276248213,
0.0488468558,
-0.0391555727,
-0.0046209265,
-0.0434454456,
-0.0081243161,
0.0428417511,
-0.0287220143,
-0.0001075593,
-0.0521618016,
0.0599403046,
-0.0140805161,
0.0639068112,
-0.026635332,
0.0069442308,
0.0344292857,
0.0482345708,
-0.0625535473,
-0.0329343155,
0.0843928158,
0.090822272,
-0.0523182973,
-0.0360138975,
0.0874973834,
0.0463801809,
-0.0102118142,
0.0182835795,
0.0021164028,
0.0541331656,
0.0286196396,
0.0565339848,
-0.0608526245,
-0.0248268098,
0.0072066933,
0.0504248478,
-0.045318123,
-0.0023461436,
-0.0078645637,
-0.1447854936,
0.0435309038,
-0.0047161472,
-0.0289324522,
-0.0082190791,
-0.0478131399,
0.0145860268,
0.0146966996,
0.0184758119,
0.0347997434,
-0.0530317053,
0.0273873955,
0.0402200967,
0.0071115904,
-0.0346227288,
0.0470271818,
-0.0029372845,
0.0175922308,
0.1023220047,
-0.0232454818,
0.0205747709,
-0.0363773443,
0.0420302413,
-0.0316578113,
0.0328166261,
-0.0257736035,
0.0339060165,
0.0089105191,
-0.0179127883,
0.0063450737,
0.0390601978,
0.0155977672,
0.0030505436,
0.0125360927,
0.0695118755,
-0.01586858,
-0.0114756543,
-0.0175021384,
-0.0088916477,
0.0687172487,
0.0641020536,
0.0601043031,
-0.0431669019,
-0.0235659946,
-0.0538477525,
-0.0057725399,
-0.0725520998,
-0.0064921328,
0.0152618522,
-0.0069243438,
-0.0416016318,
-0.0514986292,
-0.0547865629,
0.0304088686,
0.0403628796,
0.0348281786,
-0.0342889875,
-0.0365425982,
-0.010079572,
0.01754242,
0.0307072941,
-0.0237075873,
0.0141191548,
-0.0891530141,
-0.0267397948,
-0.0306950305,
-0.032590799,
-0.0126687791,
0.0155031979,
-0.0464696847,
-0.0756533667,
-0.0054646698,
0.0839121714,
0.0194486212,
0.016579356,
0.0000163476,
-0.0112500535,
0.0596520565,
0.0112536354,
0.0204896443,
0.0014796319,
0.0276051853,
-0.0437204055,
-0.0215216987,
-0.002134575,
-0.0256378148,
0.0423097424,
0.0586079732,
0.0375781134,
0.0149463089,
-0.0323954336,
0.0399291888,
0.0329073593,
0.0423711576,
-0.0414031371,
-0.0355369449,
-0.0252265334,
0.0209847149,
-0.0125381825,
0.0037657495,
-0.034902852,
0.0393241607,
-0.0155233936,
-0.005409881,
0.0283547342,
-0.0414568484,
-0.0170853417,
0.0406019576,
-0.0353994407,
0.0534996204,
-0.0066751363,
0.0362371057,
0.0297010634,
0.0080447216,
-0.0102634542,
0.0553215072,
0.0233794097,
0.0437563024,
-0.0107704839,
0.0902496427,
0.028349407,
0.0343875103,
0.0042988816,
0.0158303287,
-0.048065301,
-0.0563746542,
-0.0455102883,
0.0158544648,
0.0149222016,
-0.021086501,
-0.0046734633,
-0.0135641433,
0.0032107905,
-0.0200587194,
0.016077593,
0.009073073,
-0.0483061261,
0.0019009706,
0.04276428,
0.0297338925,
-0.0515253954,
0.040781796,
-0.0496980548,
0.061742451,
-0.0154199898,
0.0366542265,
-0.0549329817,
0.0057071573,
0.0411888473,
-0.0033984189,
-0.0288994145,
0.0027138828,
-0.0307953432,
-0.0084953746,
-0.0309574474,
0.0414545052,
-0.0084814075,
-0.0011963514,
0.069599919,
0.0388737693,
-0.0340233222,
-0.0036457938,
-0.0121107697,
-0.0137720304,
-0.0093188351,
-0.0465718433,
-0.0282312296,
-6.182710168e-33,
-0.0477850102,
0.0057028695,
0.0141257914,
-0.022923965,
0.0147005785,
-0.0001666574,
-0.0712183714,
0.007809204,
0.0026315341,
-0.0188846029,
-0.0172795393,
-0.0394695923,
0.0175168328,
-0.0178578869,
0.0255662054,
0.0119506298,
0.0350253247,
-0.024303196,
-0.0917930678,
0.031640999,
0.0010595593,
0.0052892095,
-0.0015751194,
0.0207082555,
0.0268225055,
-0.0004957441,
-0.0024681827,
0.0112956986,
-0.0325934514,
0.063994877,
0.0092969257,
0.018593533,
-0.0105665661,
-0.0826371312,
-0.0535933971,
0.0423238277,
-0.0267587714,
-0.0865567774,
0.0175998248,
-0.0149077233,
-0.0524051115,
-0.0741434246,
-0.0027644341,
-0.025035521,
-0.0375195853,
0.0117371306,
0.0171345659,
0.0290651508,
-0.0028028633,
0.0354914814,
-0.0695258826,
-0.0064987745,
-0.0220081601,
-0.0469179675,
0.0256864838,
0.0563536286,
0.0043660863,
-0.0235549025,
0.0091555733,
0.0688509196,
0.0555110089,
0.0615079887,
0.0632106662,
0.0186149776,
-0.0032471863,
0.0211930629,
0.016446149,
0.0036708396,
0.0437872447,
-0.0161044225,
0.0337242186,
0.0204958525,
0.0150725124,
-0.0327893645,
0.0118593192,
-0.0088683637,
-0.0406848714,
0.024596978,
0.0573861599,
-0.0224535726,
0.0176289305,
-0.0282361526,
-0.0695789382,
-0.0195950959,
-0.0533263013,
0.0082045048,
-0.0141760809,
-0.0194602199,
0.0568684265,
0.0048820782,
-0.0405428857,
-0.0097224349,
0.0668712929,
0.0059830253,
-0.0168653186,
-0.0041888165,
-0.0364358574,
0.0267471373,
-0.0062464378,
0.018786367,
-0.0428206325,
-0.0826412737,
0.0473132394,
-0.020018626,
0.0401553065,
0.0275518689,
0.0035150845,
0.040373724,
-0.0684942603,
0.0136779984,
-0.0531269424,
0.0250114575,
0.0124286832,
-0.0314298533,
0.0159886852,
0.01960955,
-0.0010292013,
0.0317229182,
0.0191092212,
-0.0631506443,
-0.0451835953,
0.0094477516,
-0.0053471276,
0.0301005039,
-0.0177758951,
0.0160012078,
-0.0341649316,
0.0334325917,
-0.029222209,
-0.0130697573,
-0.041902218,
0.0141513515,
2.93e-7,
0.0181719083,
0.0298275091,
0.0410111248,
0.041759681,
0.0014669423,
0.0202997513,
-0.0251735449,
-0.0105065173,
0.0228311159,
-0.0309224874,
-0.0007712764,
0.0219139419,
0.0202734116,
-0.0085220402,
-0.0670812055,
0.0155162895,
-0.0350021757,
0.0475748219,
-0.0720120668,
0.007744825,
0.0469598211,
0.0469736271,
-0.0266938675,
0.0131820664,
-0.0387584642,
0.0262311157,
0.0071186032,
-0.0085295774,
0.0310549978,
0.0554773472,
-0.0135881416,
-0.0331904776,
-0.0114495689,
0.0283667725,
-0.0271418169,
0.0190736819,
-0.0176174399,
0.0612109788,
0.0062913117,
-0.0298207384,
0.0344580673,
0.0104038334,
-0.0184386056,
-0.0626832694,
0.0536724441,
-0.0395920128,
0.0346404277,
-0.0207770392,
0.0019656799,
-0.0108154481,
-0.0070518656,
-0.0387356915,
0.0132418498,
0.0383134894,
-0.006835693,
0.0020749962,
0.00791049,
-0.0237739105,
-0.0064290878,
-0.0046887426,
-0.0352438726,
-0.0607298054,
-0.0752416998,
0.0072288387,
-0.0240275003,
-0.0592829846,
-0.0216637496,
3.137796662e-34,
0.0148268603,
-0.0524899438,
0.04623539,
0.0275799539,
0.0064281137,
-0.0181748159,
-0.0361361168,
0.0341992751,
0.0359522775,
-0.0581342615,
-0.0633892119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16962v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16962v1 | MetaGreen: Meta-Learning Inspired Transformer Selection for Green Semantic Communication | 2024-06-22T00:49:40 | 2024-06-22T00:49:40 | Shubhabrata Mukherjee, Cory Beard, Sejun Song | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Semantic Communication can transform the way we transmit information,
prioritizing meaningful and effective content over individual symbols or bits.
This evolution promises significant benefits, including reduced latency, lower
bandwidth usage, and higher throughput compared to traditional communication.
However, the development of Semantic Communication faces a crucial challenge:
the need for universal metrics to benchmark the joint effects of semantic
information loss and energy consumption. This research introduces an innovative
solution: the ``Energy-Optimized Semantic Loss'' (EOSL) function, a novel
multi-objective loss function that effectively balances semantic information
loss and energy consumption. Through comprehensive experiments on transformer
models, including energy benchmarking, we demonstrate the remarkable
effectiveness of EOSL-based model selection. We have established that
EOSL-based transformer model selection achieves up to 83\% better
similarity-to-power ratio (SPR) compared to BLEU score-based selection and 67\%
better SPR compared to solely lowest power usage-based selection. Furthermore,
we extend the applicability of EOSL to diverse and varying contexts, inspired
by the principles of Meta-Learning. By cumulatively applying EOSL, we enable
the model selection system to adapt to this change, leveraging historical EOSL
values to guide the learning process. This work lays the foundation for
energy-efficient model selection and the development of green semantic
communication. | [
0.0254770871,
0.0372701026,
0.0302941948,
0.0201693699,
-0.0454704426,
-0.0194139369,
-0.046733886,
0.0221381038,
-0.1041139886,
-0.0514238924,
0.0071696765,
0.0635299608,
0.0200962517,
-0.0194567237,
-0.0255621877,
-0.0307399854,
0.0719040036,
0.033019539,
-0.0272436049,
-0.0067439871,
0.0020257151,
-0.0191865079,
0.058979515,
0.0157900471,
-0.0433489382,
0.0203545671,
-0.0203136113,
0.0681371391,
0.0016393306,
-0.0228799172,
-0.0176386125,
0.0177825298,
-0.0242422111,
0.0316022784,
0.0000023511,
-0.0315850228,
-0.055160746,
0.0000654167,
-0.0095383134,
-0.0152928866,
0.0823539943,
-0.0075835604,
-0.0062083774,
0.0215505399,
0.0317004286,
-0.0291763321,
0.1462112963,
0.0136807961,
0.0356571972,
0.0184337441,
-0.0166608244,
0.0324616097,
0.0347265191,
-0.0176783148,
0.0447853915,
0.0312171653,
0.0147647848,
0.019189395,
-0.0710022897,
-0.0244890843,
-0.0359421521,
0.046218507,
-0.0068557356,
0.0027225425,
0.0010338351,
-0.0106131546,
-0.0291068703,
0.0144752078,
-0.0385070071,
0.0154835973,
-0.0217218511,
-0.0047644316,
-0.0064551542,
-0.023735486,
-0.0785821527,
0.0163016915,
-0.0341512337,
-0.0445487574,
0.0138948122,
0.0119920457,
-0.0496840663,
0.0524766333,
0.019924948,
0.0346602388,
-0.0332280099,
0.0662713796,
0.0042259842,
-0.0286729839,
0.0366963632,
-0.0018756922,
-0.0266256612,
-0.0017650187,
-0.0009118462,
-0.0462395921,
0.032964997,
0.0153920995,
-0.0355230086,
-0.002542682,
-0.0082112439,
-0.0269675162,
0.0729735568,
0.033279296,
0.0741148293,
0.0127046145,
0.0196482912,
-0.0153939473,
-0.0004775667,
-0.0064986181,
-0.0306182727,
-0.0374870524,
-0.0222802814,
-0.0196365453,
-0.0202961359,
0.0530112609,
-0.0278641582,
-0.0180290397,
-0.0211342946,
0.0061924611,
-0.0216297936,
-0.0186226554,
0.0335405208,
-0.0139391525,
-0.0244327448,
-0.0035805514,
0.0030247248,
0.0301928669,
0.0218412876,
-0.0315539129,
-0.0002842645,
-0.0668882653,
0.03982234,
0.0148217278,
-0.0261612497,
-0.0103169251,
-0.0050583612,
0.1320596188,
0.024311861,
-0.0610967353,
0.0025448382,
-0.0249165781,
0.0333905146,
0.0219480433,
-0.0040906467,
-0.0339363702,
-0.0185153577,
-0.0296729617,
0.0278294478,
-0.0253117159,
0.014159766,
0.0071261604,
-0.0013119011,
0.0451084375,
-0.0714026093,
-0.0101333223,
0.0143132834,
-0.0020605053,
-0.0193470418,
0.1230979934,
0.0660300553,
-0.0118740024,
0.0329288319,
-0.0144639323,
-0.0691227689,
-0.0093393298,
0.0377084911,
-0.0026864242,
0.0122382762,
-0.0700538233,
0.017574219,
0.0079314364,
-0.0064985063,
0.0604381375,
-0.0263210796,
-0.034931343,
0.0461337641,
0.0193060897,
0.0224771611,
-0.0107800374,
-0.0218580272,
0.0573775768,
-0.0588817671,
-0.0418078862,
-0.0187054072,
0.0656195581,
-0.0394209623,
-0.03616767,
0.025245266,
0.0320778079,
-0.0153596839,
-0.045903556,
0.009068843,
-0.037371587,
-0.003166945,
-0.0156268086,
0.0114817098,
0.0217059441,
-0.0233812891,
0.1190636232,
0.0403460562,
-0.0675939843,
-0.0617856197,
-0.0495333709,
-0.0164104626,
0.0241807997,
0.0539352745,
0.0150557375,
0.0129384696,
-0.0123701114,
-0.0188849214,
0.0098934965,
0.0127126854,
0.0099863671,
0.0210091993,
-0.0682619736,
-0.0224643946,
0.0238819774,
-0.0209786594,
-0.0240998436,
-0.0270133503,
0.0165130794,
0.0269147083,
-0.0323268212,
-0.0066275029,
0.0363400243,
0.0503458045,
0.0327984355,
0.0395708978,
0.0087242527,
0.0435782857,
-0.0340940394,
0.0012556792,
0.0075857253,
0.0286046527,
-0.022277249,
-0.0517910533,
0.0199668482,
-0.0698546842,
0.0467134379,
-0.0067087677,
-0.0452974699,
0.0493280739,
0.0773781762,
-0.017836526,
-0.0157863423,
-0.010962368,
-0.0794195682,
0.0698165223,
-0.0195871238,
0.026603533,
-0.0214657728,
0.0090042278,
-0.0072615473,
0.0120235551,
-0.0196328163,
0.0081856893,
-0.0304149054,
-0.0303116348,
0.0463379286,
0.0034734581,
0.020728806,
0.0285850298,
-0.0412404798,
0.0344691537,
0.0523247197,
0.0098923258,
0.0149609596,
0.009689304,
-0.0516769178,
-0.0047107055,
-0.0223454256,
0.0207165424,
0.0043079336,
0.0165461209,
0.0360367261,
0.0449971296,
0.0247343071,
0.0563284494,
-0.0518398993,
0.0215776972,
-0.0133992592,
-0.026000062,
-0.0235411953,
0.0003729896,
-0.0556220785,
0.009491303,
0.110912241,
0.0180559382,
-0.0208959114,
-0.0003377208,
-0.0086873639,
0.0025333504,
-0.0428358242,
-0.0134561546,
-0.0237967111,
-0.0397783518,
0.0167472623,
-0.0097312201,
0.0015358946,
0.0331850536,
-0.0023114206,
0.0277302302,
0.0023856207,
-0.0835078657,
0.0053245532,
-0.0241697077,
0.005245592,
0.0049743224,
-0.0029247284,
0.0628667548,
0.0589677282,
-0.0562376939,
0.0253534913,
0.0147450194,
0.0190954823,
0.0101997498,
-0.0695030615,
-0.0319245756,
0.0323589705,
0.0185260773,
0.021076588,
-0.0008259636,
-0.0378023349,
0.0342694819,
-0.0037592771,
0.0078810323,
-0.0300202779,
-0.0002156574,
0.0105846599,
0.0036726776,
-0.0394006707,
0.0611953214,
-0.0218393039,
0.018819103,
-0.032715641,
-0.0463611148,
0.0483317934,
0.0032310584,
0.0331697911,
-0.0237982832,
-0.0015142383,
-0.005422052,
-0.0524290465,
0.023168942,
0.049709063,
-0.0183614902,
0.0102340514,
0.0160398278,
-0.0080671413,
-0.06789992,
0.0276567526,
-0.0011537153,
-0.0050439015,
0.0180506967,
-0.0681741387,
0.0011767974,
0.0063970066,
-0.0315110683,
-0.0319692604,
0.0220381413,
0.0213511195,
0.0114780702,
0.0728751943,
-0.0181801785,
-0.0015465054,
-0.0046278373,
0.0071061887,
0.0536843389,
0.0010587744,
-0.0391244441,
0.0221149027,
0.0047801868,
-0.0399677493,
0.0212650336,
0.0460688882,
0.0126897786,
-0.0282973535,
0.0059506414,
-0.0330043435,
0.0422886498,
-0.0188630037,
-0.0009054263,
-0.0333020017,
-0.0587519258,
0.0110959411,
0.0250331182,
-0.0307243764,
0.0085128443,
-0.0221596751,
-0.0272133444,
-0.024589695,
-0.0104535986,
-0.0002200458,
0.0129076466,
-0.0725238249,
-0.0351983011,
-0.0391899459,
-0.022608608,
-0.0269306134,
-0.0087022698,
-0.0580298193,
0.0329108015,
-0.0278863069,
-0.0228636526,
-0.003044893,
0.0072124638,
-0.0084391544,
0.0787003115,
0.0225807428,
-0.0330093466,
-0.0859156549,
0.0438954756,
-0.008616481,
-0.013146515,
-0.0543418862,
0.0023783029,
-0.0055419067,
0.0076300669,
-0.0081690149,
-0.0425150171,
0.0219805092,
-0.0133786034,
-0.0292999484,
0.0579993799,
0.0113211712,
-0.0271406882,
-0.0142472982,
-0.0061016199,
0.0268059094,
0.0552781932,
-0.0053131524,
-0.0202538837,
-0.0868951306,
-0.0519155189,
0.0043018488,
-0.0157787167,
-0.0100166257,
0.001269908,
0.0038884026,
-0.1150032282,
-0.0143278614,
0.0557723343,
-0.0172389168,
0.0281733219,
-0.0000768137,
-0.0170519073,
0.0410255603,
0.0202820227,
-0.0924600214,
-0.0404738076,
-0.0235847291,
0.0140646137,
-0.0668128952,
-0.0012960433,
0.0915913209,
0.0263547599,
-0.0098360507,
0.0083823921,
-0.0795817748,
-0.0491337515,
0.0130276773,
0.0612555556,
0.0249718502,
0.0138480766,
0.0746947452,
-0.0330126993,
0.0139859281,
0.1324373782,
-0.0088966303,
0.016062662,
0.0822451785,
0.0140168183,
-0.0084380731,
0.0247702207,
-0.0184253566,
0.0371670611,
0.014546996,
0.0343008414,
-0.0039639408,
-0.0172213186,
0.025663903,
0.0390969813,
0.0383775868,
-0.0081647281,
-0.0513550192,
0.0475174859,
0.0265274588,
0.0123537211,
0.0376397185,
-0.0679828376,
-0.0092174988,
-0.0183383953,
0.0243517887,
0.0347889215,
0.0552019849,
0.0357096121,
-0.0712698773,
0.0192192364,
0.0170016959,
-0.0306363348,
0.0450993888,
0.0096234865,
0.0153886927,
-0.0142525351,
-0.0719227046,
0.0575948134,
0.0044576824,
-0.0550856143,
0.0061648902,
0.0465054251,
0.0209883861,
-0.0475951098,
0.0448116288,
-0.0067409347,
-0.0315552019,
-0.0035130461,
-0.0154908597,
0.0076871039,
0.0911431834,
0.0009860893,
-0.0611969866,
-0.0046015056,
-0.0375289582,
0.024660131,
-0.0253002457,
0.0038633123,
0.0403447337,
0.00526221,
-0.0269350521,
-0.0108086187,
0.0089469021,
-0.0400060378,
0.0052122725,
-0.0396150015,
0.0133373505,
-0.0162582882,
0.0089193135,
-0.0229834821,
0.0067528239,
0.018390635,
-0.0176049788,
-0.0647521466,
0.0055989549,
0.0478414968,
-0.0030394895,
0.0759160221,
0.0035883046,
0.0947525278,
0.0543979742,
0.0109315654,
-0.0433294773,
0.0180020332,
-0.0749678686,
-0.0664698109,
0.0104663707,
0.0130861131,
-7.226951024e-33,
0.0219252575,
-0.0192986801,
0.0117461141,
0.0487679094,
0.0027159823,
0.0169600993,
-0.017763637,
-0.0289109796,
-0.0398712531,
0.0052308552,
0.0154923433,
-0.03485718,
0.0176017974,
0.0424553752,
-0.0001370762,
0.0125404391,
0.0289238542,
0.0295714624,
-0.0533344969,
0.0045067244,
0.0578366145,
0.0063161384,
-0.0228085779,
-0.0415920913,
-0.0828838199,
0.0529471412,
-0.0089676296,
-0.0341999643,
0.0065705841,
0.0217268821,
-0.0017187834,
0.0700436458,
0.0014471884,
-0.003304485,
-0.0269402154,
0.0191855263,
-0.0436281599,
-0.0575045384,
-0.0075712209,
-0.0259931833,
-0.0198262855,
-0.0343296714,
-0.020669803,
0.0474503338,
-0.0548597313,
-0.0303803831,
-0.0053377212,
0.0120744891,
-0.088054657,
-0.0142353429,
-0.0221019629,
0.0038452127,
-0.0038086686,
0.0337515324,
0.0057086539,
-0.0103404475,
-0.0139218317,
0.0182346739,
-0.0289003197,
0.0533453189,
-0.0179726742,
0.0417986363,
0.0368139185,
0.0182070788,
0.0039134002,
0.0520822704,
0.0262669027,
-0.0034348902,
0.0358487368,
0.0381409377,
0.0584826842,
0.0255729109,
0.0317306742,
0.0301744305,
0.0477558337,
-0.0686957687,
-0.0454947613,
0.0170034021,
0.0049454188,
0.0198431816,
0.0071588615,
0.022978507,
0.00468399,
-0.0429796167,
-0.0442498289,
0.0551286675,
-0.0185515285,
-0.0480611958,
0.0192467608,
0.0003595182,
-0.0533958338,
0.0325849354,
0.0241108555,
-0.0250598267,
0.0387957469,
0.0294848755,
0.0089278212,
0.0371877179,
0.0144419046,
-0.0124113811,
-0.0322501659,
-0.0543153323,
-0.0040838113,
0.0238875281,
0.0072904709,
-0.0387008563,
0.0066774609,
0.0354355946,
-0.0461496897,
0.005813437,
-0.0337816365,
-0.0470640697,
0.0228615794,
-0.113930136,
-0.0140524348,
0.0206768457,
0.0043644668,
0.0114400517,
-0.0336787477,
-0.0418863222,
-0.0271022487,
-0.0165317785,
-0.0197050869,
0.0535650328,
-0.0233431142,
0.0202366132,
-0.0932057202,
-0.0320876203,
0.0519503281,
-0.0226904657,
-0.0705060437,
0.0320142582,
3.156e-7,
0.0243480448,
0.0261628069,
-0.0202126075,
0.0009233031,
-0.0383804403,
0.0141006233,
0.0484018065,
0.014997826,
-0.0144343898,
0.0136105185,
-0.0114518162,
-0.0334411711,
0.0514602289,
-0.0063378643,
-0.0349862836,
-0.0029643148,
-0.0681788325,
0.0155632105,
0.0034310012,
-0.0273784958,
0.0406538472,
0.0326793604,
0.0153998174,
-0.0007821361,
-0.0022914775,
0.0243617836,
0.0440001488,
-0.0783526152,
0.0563209504,
0.0126777375,
-0.0167660154,
-0.0355633907,
0.0225071572,
0.0064681722,
0.0048821759,
-0.0369366556,
0.0047233491,
0.03409262,
-0.0057800077,
-0.0321531147,
0.0199191105,
0.0240408871,
-0.0252902992,
0.0345679894,
0.0241445228,
-0.0261417069,
-0.0423991382,
0.0185647309,
-0.0269133244,
0.0228380337,
-0.0058464529,
-0.0081298463,
-0.0478634275,
-0.0130562587,
-0.0339006707,
0.0284208097,
0.0017177821,
-0.0033197172,
0.0533713065,
-0.0313209146,
0.0203656703,
-0.0698787048,
-0.0521475114,
0.0023753501,
0.0748580322,
0.019518612,
0.0151705481,
2.757997422e-34,
0.0258946121,
-0.0277389959,
0.0078330049,
0.0167554412,
-0.0241064988,
0.0091252541,
0.0196521394,
-0.00257571,
-0.0328657366,
-0.02198774,
0.0022933451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15695v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15695v1 | SS-Bench: A Benchmark for Social Story Generation and Evaluation | 2024-06-22T00:14:48 | 2024-06-22T00:14:48 | Yi Feng, Mingyang Song, Jiaqi Wang, Mao Zheng, Liping Jing, Jian Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) often misunderstand social
situations and struggle to participate in daily routines. Psychology experts
write Social Stories under strict constraints of structural clarity,
descriptive orientation, and situational safety to enhance their abilities in
these regimes. However, Social Stories are costly in creation and often limited
in diversity and timeliness. As Large Language Models (LLMs) become
increasingly powerful, there is a growing need for more automated, affordable,
and accessible methods to generate Social Stories in real-time with broad
coverage. Adapting LLMs to meet the unique and strict constraints of Social
Stories is a challenging issue. To this end, we propose \textbf{SS-Bench}, a
\textbf{S}ocial \textbf{S}tory \textbf{Bench}mark for generating and evaluating
Social Stories. Specifically, we develop a constraint-driven strategy named
\textbf{\textsc{StarSow}} to hierarchically prompt LLMs to generate Social
Stories and build a benchmark, which has been validated through experiments to
fine-tune smaller models for generating qualified Social Stories. Additionally,
we introduce \textbf{Quality Assessment Criteria}, employed in human and GPT
evaluations, to verify the effectiveness of the generated stories. We hope this
work benefits the autism community and catalyzes future research focusing on
particular groups. | [
0.0348979682,
0.0331359692,
-0.035107594,
0.028636314,
-0.0364499018,
0.0005784169,
0.0122612491,
-0.0404440314,
-0.0330800489,
-0.0396970399,
0.0302400775,
-0.0769452825,
0.0227915328,
0.1187854782,
-0.0092542861,
-0.0701573566,
0.0307679474,
0.0154418098,
0.0172131639,
0.0059284205,
0.0055385279,
0.0430430844,
-0.01048976,
0.0598632656,
-0.0229140166,
0.0014772009,
0.0106309475,
0.0015709946,
0.042882055,
-0.0542107522,
0.0028807223,
0.0491056666,
0.0311554223,
0.0241162553,
0.000002169,
-0.0461774692,
0.0105732651,
-0.0243401919,
0.0509117916,
-0.0206620749,
0.0031343906,
-0.0201886054,
0.0113680353,
0.0371025652,
-0.0453418195,
-0.0106125455,
0.0280227661,
0.0400529057,
0.0217944011,
0.0446811654,
-0.0260330252,
0.01680094,
-0.0035260795,
-0.0271515846,
0.0375231765,
-0.0333764516,
-0.0108860424,
-0.0086216833,
0.0662465692,
-0.0502525605,
-0.0098855151,
0.0196468905,
0.010934921,
-0.0217749178,
0.047171697,
0.0188249554,
-0.0098021189,
-0.024010567,
-0.004852321,
0.0926074535,
0.0731504112,
0.0113414247,
0.0385435186,
-0.0135334786,
0.0041198148,
0.0239361208,
-0.0584191196,
0.0518044867,
0.0017510677,
0.0279540382,
-0.0060111624,
0.0417717211,
-0.0094770938,
0.0075532305,
0.0671892241,
0.0284438077,
-0.026541492,
0.011751838,
-0.0349228308,
-0.0010069028,
0.0171905719,
-0.0987458229,
0.0399173163,
0.0330057219,
-0.0394579582,
0.0139471013,
-0.058667019,
0.0307111703,
0.0072196205,
-0.0036854169,
0.0324136242,
0.0228199959,
0.0306909606,
0.0069230776,
0.04183897,
0.0576292016,
0.0217215195,
-0.0219019335,
-0.0392670818,
0.0519681424,
-0.0620693862,
0.0065744137,
-0.0376960933,
0.0223010387,
-0.0307377242,
-0.0612791218,
-0.0256848522,
0.0349773392,
0.0160328504,
0.0099095367,
-0.0002060232,
0.0521205291,
-0.0250140484,
0.0249316581,
0.0023820405,
-0.0175947454,
-0.0779492632,
-0.0004990829,
0.028837176,
-0.017352242,
-0.0161467195,
0.0002906633,
0.0370356441,
0.0109278187,
-0.0219850242,
-0.0028802108,
0.0009149942,
-0.0325521491,
-0.0354774669,
-0.0521748215,
-0.0367917307,
-0.0594881848,
0.0038033726,
-0.0525883883,
0.039375104,
0.0237233378,
0.0182473492,
-0.0646636859,
0.007885213,
0.0142718386,
-0.0084567303,
-0.0007355136,
-0.0210243501,
0.0234316047,
-0.0229829177,
0.0405289829,
0.035340365,
0.0655707121,
0.0803805366,
0.0173813812,
0.0369446054,
-0.0130416285,
0.0456718989,
0.0041104248,
-0.0132534839,
-0.0027252315,
-0.0191121418,
0.0009295166,
0.0105963405,
0.0661053509,
-0.0055695991,
0.0468193628,
-0.0223150272,
0.0470763296,
0.0889325291,
0.0744387135,
-0.0135637531,
0.0294752605,
0.0512116365,
0.0174987353,
0.0092993826,
0.0129944049,
-0.0172677319,
0.025828911,
-0.0071545672,
-0.0147209875,
-0.0026505294,
0.0544915833,
-0.0281869266,
-0.0136624482,
-0.0158833116,
-0.0125378808,
0.0269127693,
0.0011138589,
-0.0130190309,
0.0087405629,
-0.0459769219,
-0.0126087638,
-0.000449605,
-0.0874368027,
0.0229411311,
-0.0227032136,
-0.003556065,
0.0683325902,
0.089685373,
-0.0109962039,
-0.011265222,
-0.0281742401,
-0.0327256359,
0.0407196693,
0.0232012272,
-0.0020199711,
-0.011534268,
-0.0092876488,
0.0047106533,
-0.0169798639,
0.0212019961,
-0.0171083026,
0.0429805815,
0.015547323,
0.0021165393,
-0.0213941094,
-0.0118392147,
0.0534624308,
-0.0665329248,
0.0019261936,
-0.0085127,
-0.0418851115,
0.0102683315,
0.0315980315,
-0.0179618038,
0.0081663923,
0.0100168204,
0.0081495065,
-0.0387801193,
0.0472918116,
-0.0880466923,
-0.0491420366,
-0.0056978185,
-0.0623276643,
-0.0266895685,
0.0617163293,
0.0074760043,
-0.021887999,
0.0714131668,
-0.0555942059,
0.0243020225,
0.0043213428,
0.0235045198,
-0.0164198726,
-0.0024099168,
-0.0029360119,
0.0519514456,
0.0060605532,
-0.0024851533,
-0.0834758952,
-0.0226182379,
-0.0122118331,
-0.0308578704,
0.0145167978,
0.0116554676,
-0.0242702272,
0.0116880154,
0.0244667549,
-0.011915681,
-0.0406812467,
-0.0313878022,
-0.1127244756,
0.0100534204,
-0.000968348,
-0.0181823093,
-0.0011687106,
-0.0079466384,
-0.0156486388,
0.0232559219,
-0.0375663713,
0.0278996676,
0.0364043564,
0.0015266213,
0.0061425124,
0.0259617157,
-0.061018195,
-0.0476956032,
0.0289984941,
-0.0225896556,
0.0693228617,
0.0345215909,
-0.0328407809,
-0.0148193408,
0.041690018,
-0.0790522918,
0.0060984553,
-0.0223540738,
0.0008691166,
0.0521330126,
0.0555981696,
0.0579479374,
0.0250119288,
0.0247579738,
0.0363330282,
0.0414077118,
-0.0388212688,
-0.0334959924,
-0.0150547912,
-0.0103661325,
0.0330352522,
-0.0412682667,
-0.0985011384,
0.0234176014,
0.0700248554,
0.050194256,
0.0137276528,
-0.06476973,
0.0256109312,
0.0034545227,
-0.0258162916,
-0.0188453104,
-0.1017796919,
-0.0333180465,
0.0197780058,
-0.0042069154,
-0.0561860129,
0.0572061352,
-0.0374944657,
0.0018471592,
0.0071424032,
-0.0033580307,
-0.0339568108,
0.1145641878,
-0.0070701735,
0.0533729047,
-0.024954088,
0.0149590382,
-0.0102412337,
-0.026327204,
0.0113176284,
-0.0285957884,
-0.0068444666,
-0.0827667117,
0.0086288396,
0.0114951087,
-0.0082588429,
-0.0340659134,
-0.0172975268,
-0.0345303565,
0.0037451091,
0.0237535462,
-0.0759296268,
-0.0288368315,
-0.0109919952,
0.0292942151,
0.0660237074,
-0.0313053839,
-0.0167594496,
-0.0156027945,
-0.0194707476,
0.0693824589,
-0.0532136597,
0.040097896,
-0.0437303782,
0.0158476569,
0.0482656993,
0.0407693088,
0.0256974306,
0.0182298124,
0.00361536,
0.0131310988,
0.024086779,
-0.0008860327,
0.035567563,
0.0522257835,
-0.0072619701,
-0.0308950879,
0.0836432725,
0.034332443,
-0.0303589851,
0.0588739999,
-0.0005893024,
-0.0006876637,
-0.0068029501,
-0.0051290491,
-0.0551025383,
0.0042738463,
0.0412433147,
0.0364853516,
-0.0432180651,
-0.0733517781,
-0.054408446,
-0.0427153446,
0.0398702547,
0.0108032934,
-0.0433908962,
-0.0253570732,
-0.0156007893,
-0.0224414989,
0.0558247864,
0.0171487704,
0.0016231377,
-0.0367353745,
0.0038724842,
-0.0219112262,
-0.0380183831,
-0.0691031218,
0.0552503318,
-0.0087504443,
0.0974014625,
0.017237084,
0.0356420204,
0.0265332852,
-0.023669688,
-0.0438296124,
0.0383341089,
0.0003751885,
-0.0129791703,
0.0105888769,
-0.0172829311,
0.008832396,
-0.0359487124,
0.0611342564,
-0.0440870672,
-0.02984423,
0.0017890229,
0.0611191764,
-0.0266034529,
-0.0742810369,
-0.0153577011,
0.0418770909,
0.019368086,
0.1000694036,
0.0423519053,
-0.0208621006,
0.0032937226,
0.0143467588,
-0.0013428088,
-0.0739691108,
-0.0283100046,
-0.0023825513,
0.0025739337,
-0.0083601531,
-0.0615221113,
-0.0359785631,
0.0301314648,
0.0505473614,
-0.0207414366,
-0.0367818959,
0.0069599799,
0.0009166494,
-0.0287109427,
0.0652754977,
-0.0061299382,
0.0190546792,
-0.0120155551,
0.0195356477,
-0.0256998055,
-0.0574852116,
-0.0081538036,
0.0203416497,
-0.0218308158,
-0.0546979867,
0.0558761396,
-0.0416289717,
0.0284264311,
-0.0023537725,
0.0448892005,
-0.0632772893,
-0.0186068527,
0.0219015386,
-0.000730582,
0.0485287383,
-0.0527256392,
-0.0381727293,
0.0076410831,
-0.0085463934,
0.0025122357,
0.0410676114,
-0.0297478512,
0.0498125963,
0.0115123456,
-0.003589896,
0.0187461097,
0.005666961,
-0.0055657825,
-0.0384757295,
-0.0690216497,
-0.0608495586,
-0.0505229943,
-0.0626026019,
-0.0027296995,
-0.0710346624,
-0.0110777626,
0.0247377604,
0.0177610032,
0.002200187,
-0.0110659497,
-0.0944118276,
0.0355079994,
-0.0513329543,
0.003988496,
-0.0348783135,
-0.0003780156,
0.0049089785,
-0.0181215387,
-0.0148939556,
0.0168032441,
-0.0535308272,
0.0405602232,
-0.0243493263,
0.0483028032,
0.0181134194,
-0.0110601969,
0.0224088356,
0.0137077132,
-0.0188568886,
-0.0281376764,
-0.0779887363,
0.0099612493,
-0.0139851989,
0.0272034444,
0.0584064983,
-0.0299256798,
0.0382424816,
-0.0022137456,
0.0077531179,
-0.0163373183,
-0.029393198,
-0.0000250875,
0.0159329213,
-0.0071266424,
0.0151822362,
0.0376363099,
-0.0114426678,
0.0224011354,
-0.0103906756,
-0.0296138972,
-0.0160515122,
-0.0209022965,
0.0405527577,
0.0089690294,
-0.0025253126,
-0.0160874948,
-0.0898353085,
-0.0161424186,
-0.0110892663,
0.0236475896,
-0.004624574,
-0.0330708772,
0.0287386049,
0.0458191931,
-0.0124650728,
-0.0240658838,
-0.0289970506,
0.0015534168,
-0.0269118901,
-0.0268864278,
0.004641891,
-6.631120855e-33,
-0.0263243821,
-0.065728493,
0.0240782909,
0.0007406506,
-0.0644940138,
0.0340000913,
-0.0662197173,
0.0377728716,
0.0187397972,
0.0351517163,
0.0015349657,
-0.0078734327,
0.0040915082,
-0.0014347925,
-0.0338512398,
0.0429517962,
0.0092305886,
-0.0082074087,
-0.0606422313,
0.0310845226,
-0.0071745985,
-0.0097612897,
0.0430570804,
-0.0472606458,
0.0385142453,
-0.0372795239,
-0.0399517454,
0.007040821,
0.0475158617,
-0.0008139528,
-0.0087718749,
0.0047448934,
0.0446230806,
0.0380528271,
-0.0066398061,
0.0416804627,
-0.0300768651,
-0.0195799768,
0.0248712096,
-0.057064876,
-0.0904814079,
0.0122513967,
0.0037417784,
-0.0184328407,
-0.0529641099,
-0.0013947694,
0.0051095504,
0.0038733408,
0.0164560154,
0.0048235166,
-0.0919105783,
0.013064106,
0.0055004591,
-0.0402869135,
-0.0351944864,
0.0631370172,
-0.0007683862,
0.0104319118,
-0.000034703,
0.0441187881,
0.0059915185,
0.0351510197,
0.026049858,
-0.0212472081,
0.0043680444,
0.0697834268,
-0.0005627961,
0.0501908138,
-0.0417702831,
0.0074405191,
0.0391196199,
0.0258157328,
0.0602731295,
0.0416961014,
-0.0343999527,
0.0067212251,
-0.0423967391,
0.0431214534,
0.0288075767,
-0.0144063272,
0.0201775134,
-0.0147458967,
-0.0585047454,
-0.0234750547,
-0.052770365,
0.0476177596,
0.0061715692,
-0.0119907139,
0.0274375509,
0.0314225815,
-0.0505882837,
0.0233052634,
-0.0143556641,
0.0117992656,
-0.0012111666,
-0.0164896771,
0.0035563312,
0.0339976847,
0.0134535423,
0.0132231433,
-0.0194590241,
-0.0382542424,
0.0469830297,
0.049420841,
0.0606199503,
0.0003681478,
0.0062476229,
0.0254085474,
-0.0291900467,
0.0300997552,
-0.0269504897,
0.0616855063,
0.0039693019,
-0.0590568557,
-0.0126293823,
-0.0273637231,
-0.0465936884,
0.0299320724,
0.0294970497,
0.0022162602,
-0.058418531,
-0.015278616,
-0.0122941202,
0.0336234458,
-0.0122573599,
0.0031090409,
-0.0279895831,
-0.0149962548,
0.0945323184,
0.0032421383,
-0.0003832318,
-0.029233139,
2.88e-7,
-0.0128734233,
0.0567614995,
0.0155559015,
0.0314494371,
0.013307835,
0.0475877076,
0.0182135217,
0.0383376889,
-0.0032304002,
-0.009492401,
0.0049653486,
0.0503653325,
0.0280866604,
0.0640590116,
0.0055562318,
0.0150144519,
-0.0874017999,
-0.0259164106,
-0.0325448364,
-0.0485606194,
0.0286114402,
-0.0123093529,
0.0213451721,
-0.015599777,
0.0178509057,
-0.0720168427,
0.0345157497,
-0.0041314079,
-0.0266109314,
0.0516028926,
-0.0471599512,
-0.0314938612,
0.0145654194,
-0.0467647798,
0.0070474306,
0.0282861143,
-0.0330741964,
0.0248413142,
-0.0558767729,
0.0281229112,
0.0324171558,
0.0064848126,
-0.0238469411,
-0.0690843984,
0.0344835408,
-0.0486533716,
0.004228889,
-0.0087558655,
0.0016242964,
-0.0006771492,
0.0145391114,
0.0036755812,
0.0153551102,
0.0273428485,
0.000310268,
0.0081015574,
0.0039252201,
-0.0501881428,
-0.006999996,
0.0060148113,
-0.0375355184,
-0.0295397192,
-0.0122098774,
0.0153547497,
-0.0654520914,
-0.0408097766,
0.0202121884,
2.653310007e-34,
0.0306443274,
0.0321897678,
0.0091291433,
-0.0461081937,
0.0772719607,
0.0155398995,
-0.0643359348,
-0.0059903311,
0.0235731155,
-0.0347265564,
-0.0280006956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15673v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15673v1 | Large Language Models have Intrinsic Self-Correction Ability | 2024-06-21T22:29:40 | 2024-06-21T22:29:40 | Dancheng Liu, Amir Nassereldine, Ziming Yang, Chenhui Xu, Yuting Hu, Jiajie Li, Utkarsh Kumar, Changjae Lee, Jinjun Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have attracted significant attention for their
remarkable abilities in various natural language processing tasks, but they
suffer from hallucinations that will cause performance degradation. One
promising solution to improve the LLMs' performance is to ask LLMs to revise
their answer after generation, a technique known as self-correction. Among the
two types of self-correction, intrinsic self-correction is considered a
promising direction because it does not utilize external knowledge. However,
recent works doubt the validity of LLM's ability to conduct intrinsic
self-correction. In this paper, we present a novel perspective on the intrinsic
self-correction capabilities of LLMs through theoretical analyses and empirical
experiments. In addition, we identify two critical factors for successful
self-correction: zero temperature and fair prompts. Leveraging these factors,
we demonstrate that intrinsic self-correction ability is exhibited across
multiple existing LLMs. Our findings offer insights into the fundamental
theories underlying the self-correction behavior of LLMs and remark on the
importance of unbiased prompts and zero temperature settings in harnessing
their full potential. | [
0.0288350992,
0.0203066096,
-0.0377949476,
0.0408788174,
-0.0598090403,
0.0022838891,
-0.0158966463,
0.0013644572,
0.0237516128,
-0.0440556407,
-0.0383537263,
-0.0431285277,
0.0096000601,
-0.0037308696,
0.0228622723,
-0.0153002404,
0.0590622015,
-0.0657386705,
0.0039871321,
-0.0349720828,
-0.014009105,
-0.028632557,
-0.0067548715,
-0.003267243,
0.0064722076,
-0.028041359,
-0.0040627164,
0.0036171158,
-0.0552727655,
-0.0163776223,
-0.0248738062,
0.0724888518,
-0.0172968749,
0.0623816252,
0.000001883,
-0.0726389885,
0.0146995131,
-0.0248985719,
-0.0404439606,
0.0445124507,
0.0300481264,
-0.0243779104,
-0.0316317268,
0.0307561588,
-0.0310764462,
0.011384408,
0.0484360456,
0.0526592173,
0.0472607128,
0.0646118447,
0.0122776525,
-0.0090372218,
0.0036604104,
0.0036657092,
0.0024168817,
-0.0122636538,
0.0425114408,
0.0020343163,
-0.0225196332,
-0.0026565837,
-0.0399873629,
0.0378265381,
0.0190287866,
-0.0137424124,
-0.0116258999,
0.0301788878,
-0.0381586105,
-0.0372752175,
-0.0247007385,
0.0297513325,
0.0139177097,
-0.0320763476,
-0.008948531,
0.0087692654,
0.0162326694,
-0.0063202968,
-0.0403346084,
0.0338421725,
0.0228848197,
0.0276135467,
0.0032286402,
-0.0010285629,
0.0509920754,
-0.0099282796,
-0.0352062359,
0.1167897657,
0.0191817079,
-0.063689895,
-0.0385861248,
0.0215095747,
0.0016813785,
-0.1039338633,
-0.0030062136,
0.0423742682,
-0.0310453679,
0.0210406296,
-0.0568438359,
0.0049622082,
0.029735608,
-0.0595818311,
0.0284757465,
0.0314635821,
-0.0270808227,
0.0217265058,
-0.047547061,
0.0311036464,
-0.0251659919,
0.0417996831,
-0.0319590345,
0.0102334321,
-0.0030724653,
-0.0280742943,
-0.0318698809,
0.0294789709,
-0.0051300153,
-0.0107120313,
-0.0467272624,
0.033719629,
-0.0024722568,
0.0075729433,
-0.0233343728,
0.0299964584,
-0.0154318335,
-0.0415921174,
-0.0492497757,
0.0208725501,
-0.0206754878,
-0.0157868508,
0.0152705414,
-0.0660820007,
-0.027657507,
-0.013688433,
0.0025927024,
-0.008517907,
0.0052880584,
0.0677615851,
0.0044228318,
-0.0238210335,
-0.0402350649,
-0.0321587883,
-0.060653653,
-0.0809501708,
-0.0152232042,
-0.0436280817,
-0.0112923896,
0.0245869271,
-0.010906552,
-0.0236736704,
0.037735939,
0.0102646854,
-0.0448039994,
0.0947908536,
-0.0068377955,
0.0358143374,
0.0288294759,
0.0027317081,
0.0493840203,
0.0696111023,
0.0345568135,
-0.0070613665,
0.0396309607,
-0.0162904225,
0.0568431579,
0.0398619026,
0.0026579481,
0.0031713839,
-0.0525114238,
-0.0060079503,
0.0182440989,
0.0661557242,
0.0304860938,
0.0709958151,
-0.0039474294,
-0.0201962087,
0.0868796408,
0.0294259451,
0.0100750122,
0.0367858633,
0.020368848,
-0.0314373858,
0.0059174332,
0.0732483938,
-0.070813939,
0.0418902151,
-0.0351068154,
0.0224757567,
0.0716128945,
-0.016075084,
-0.0251994114,
-0.0482485667,
-0.0326697119,
0.016474843,
-0.0075592711,
-0.0056424877,
0.0301423203,
0.0287250839,
-0.0035321803,
0.0225226413,
0.0114886472,
-0.0285191629,
-0.0018994086,
-0.0728643313,
0.010044721,
0.0917573795,
0.0583548322,
0.0059350263,
-0.0152071435,
-0.0032052798,
-0.0139672374,
0.0598695017,
0.0828697011,
0.0340680107,
-0.0433054343,
-0.0467292368,
-0.0011805478,
-0.0293143019,
0.0285898373,
0.0097400444,
-0.0075345109,
0.0033344445,
-0.0043904227,
0.0006768573,
-0.0129202073,
0.0272593256,
-0.0441111811,
-0.0418470278,
0.0115152877,
-0.027684845,
0.0041916468,
-0.0062857307,
-0.0337025598,
0.0569972955,
0.0106747691,
-0.0143815987,
-0.0576701388,
0.021230692,
-0.0848591775,
-0.0144475838,
0.0548059642,
0.0219766758,
0.0079550985,
-0.006809745,
0.025919497,
-0.0581687242,
0.0594931915,
-0.0319657512,
0.0405887887,
-0.0419924445,
0.0611261204,
-0.0183373746,
0.0489270687,
-0.004648699,
0.0347903706,
-0.0074753226,
0.0134551181,
0.0101507027,
0.0339482129,
-0.0168182701,
-0.0447101407,
-0.0215267874,
-0.0032718147,
0.0033483391,
0.0187189486,
0.0105664013,
-0.0654139146,
-0.0301015563,
-0.0375492647,
-0.0501967408,
0.0015293867,
-0.0222271569,
-0.0211376324,
0.0252924804,
-0.0059757633,
-0.0292416085,
-0.0171023142,
-0.0095342873,
-0.0107571585,
0.0474709943,
0.0441020504,
0.0395269543,
-0.0198439024,
-0.0219292361,
-0.0250333436,
-0.0048228856,
-0.0168833397,
0.0146068828,
0.0116587682,
0.0018653042,
-0.0916092247,
0.0493313,
-0.0601885878,
0.0394468419,
0.008668459,
-0.0349361859,
0.0134644993,
0.0027390555,
0.0522995628,
0.0480154268,
0.0256272685,
-0.0019595171,
0.0743285939,
-0.0288915914,
-0.0307128411,
0.0038169473,
-0.0157497078,
-0.0299507361,
-0.0096814651,
-0.0387117602,
-0.0072526219,
0.0923737958,
0.0308460984,
-0.0142680984,
-0.0268612057,
0.0464848541,
-0.0271386635,
-0.080344215,
-0.0141954143,
-0.0171812437,
-0.0348904319,
0.0530881025,
-0.0265979767,
-0.0834749416,
0.0829323158,
-0.0424213298,
0.0182926096,
-0.0127908168,
0.014454877,
-0.0192116275,
0.058899235,
0.0081461864,
0.0154618016,
0.0234075338,
-0.0136918342,
-0.0328219347,
-0.0462932773,
0.0298683904,
-0.0509135686,
0.03783831,
-0.034616854,
0.0130221797,
0.0208167098,
-0.0467821956,
-0.0498674177,
-0.0549099222,
-0.0187696926,
0.0018981947,
0.0019119928,
-0.0075537702,
-0.0162347257,
0.0023094197,
0.0448302664,
0.0275363196,
-0.0286640152,
-0.0136263082,
-0.0216159057,
-0.0118487151,
0.0648585483,
0.0426142067,
0.0696987882,
-0.0207991563,
0.0433066078,
0.0427461714,
0.0395895988,
0.0324303769,
-0.0121018374,
0.0075015915,
0.0124565717,
-0.02391918,
-0.0190249588,
0.0206712428,
0.0444005616,
-0.0487595238,
-0.0334669687,
0.1075411439,
0.0346444063,
-0.0199037381,
0.0079573328,
-0.0601377003,
-0.0002283126,
0.0356648602,
0.0065867049,
-0.0594200566,
-0.0018713365,
0.0243537445,
-0.0047254837,
-0.0519753061,
-0.0485585593,
-0.0218476485,
-0.1249691844,
0.037851654,
0.0296460949,
0.003602617,
-0.0184862372,
-0.0043261079,
0.0026284265,
0.0350215584,
0.0636322573,
0.0391414091,
-0.0085321516,
-0.0199795719,
0.0149478642,
-0.0302997548,
-0.0295210574,
0.0225835107,
-0.0365927517,
0.0942093879,
0.0941116735,
-0.003258104,
0.00077422,
-0.0374868438,
0.0337606221,
-0.0105427699,
0.0228058323,
0.0004153948,
0.0124901449,
0.025041569,
-0.0121684773,
-0.0158574935,
0.0136396838,
-0.0086525064,
-0.0090900715,
-0.0170189533,
0.0556789674,
-0.0351567902,
-0.0483773053,
-0.0138216652,
0.0058022528,
-0.0191922653,
0.0696293637,
0.0250675324,
-0.0263576563,
-0.057955496,
-0.0414204113,
0.018484395,
-0.0296844393,
-0.0480015948,
0.0182255544,
0.0338306129,
-0.0058911368,
-0.0648050681,
-0.0178665202,
-0.0154828476,
0.0195042174,
0.0183845256,
0.0221956614,
-0.0130054224,
-0.0142835677,
-0.0038624585,
-0.0149798663,
-0.0723489299,
0.0009817518,
-0.0510505177,
0.0075632236,
0.0282949023,
-0.0326929167,
0.0267349705,
0.013108273,
-0.0338046812,
-0.0801429078,
0.0475428924,
0.0335106067,
0.0311912354,
0.0471652299,
-0.0215707123,
-0.0774651542,
0.0302888267,
0.0432765447,
-0.0432960354,
0.0608345643,
-0.0105793159,
0.0238451511,
0.006580669,
0.0485117175,
0.0099903904,
0.0204001348,
0.0319115482,
0.0500197075,
0.0257027838,
-0.0680570677,
0.0525162145,
0.0251610819,
0.0195268244,
0.0095467474,
0.0507992283,
-0.0090167634,
0.0245536733,
-0.0154617503,
-0.0284443758,
-0.0005191897,
0.0017976004,
0.0461275764,
-0.011561254,
-0.0116493031,
-0.035342481,
-0.0591169074,
0.0077719702,
-0.0026553231,
-0.0492845215,
-0.014305504,
-0.006026322,
0.0426719524,
0.0017696166,
-0.0028470738,
0.0573209673,
0.0103476774,
0.0427070744,
0.0073130727,
0.0509857424,
0.0059427568,
-0.0046903561,
-0.0787813514,
-0.0028319117,
-0.0809474736,
-0.0542677157,
-0.0077530467,
0.0450654849,
0.0473763347,
0.015127033,
0.0307019409,
-0.0291878693,
-0.0011784988,
-0.0121193426,
-0.0060795359,
0.0381081179,
-0.0080496632,
0.0085300747,
0.0078251772,
-0.0331671685,
0.0132569838,
0.042909544,
-0.0311120506,
0.0621243007,
-0.0069922358,
-0.0203282461,
-0.0139608178,
-0.0374346338,
-0.045320224,
-0.0430160686,
-0.0356165059,
-0.0257149227,
-0.0527346507,
-0.0769238248,
-0.0116555775,
0.0411884598,
0.0204894431,
-0.0540795662,
-0.0134257451,
0.0782405511,
-0.0081950407,
-0.0210766643,
-0.0209130552,
0.038976036,
0.0262379944,
0.0067931735,
-0.0116309328,
-6.505367204e-33,
-0.0178785045,
0.0010966009,
0.0430025049,
-0.034687534,
0.0107839387,
-0.0531626344,
-0.0217261426,
0.0425698906,
0.007730891,
0.0011500646,
-0.0526284054,
0.0244738702,
0.0263145883,
-0.0017406354,
0.0520919375,
-0.0232676473,
0.0689699575,
-0.0224226322,
-0.0337502249,
-0.0109969983,
0.039862331,
-0.0043475414,
0.0423066057,
-0.0399497673,
0.0390672609,
-0.0047631194,
-0.0118185785,
0.0315121263,
-0.0323854983,
0.0361328498,
-0.0401351936,
0.0395322777,
0.0335702635,
-0.0271267202,
-0.0392227881,
0.0155347278,
-0.0255946834,
-0.0181225426,
0.0091921473,
0.0006423955,
-0.0246274583,
-0.0294961538,
0.0721892864,
-0.0082457419,
-0.0460198149,
0.0376358256,
-0.0074639665,
-0.0263744593,
-0.0065775127,
0.0600975081,
-0.0386610888,
0.0048543056,
0.020930754,
-0.0250968449,
-0.0142523665,
-0.0102777835,
-0.0157063995,
-0.0238890145,
-0.0710335374,
0.0157876201,
0.0511498414,
0.05366835,
0.0652852356,
0.0089173475,
0.0121737281,
0.0433324464,
0.0676606521,
0.0463870466,
-0.0411314704,
-0.044079341,
0.030823946,
0.0131984251,
0.0422515385,
0.0455527157,
0.0338184088,
-0.0314720012,
-0.011526362,
-0.0150443325,
-0.0121407108,
0.0196440965,
0.0504255407,
-0.016808439,
-0.027231358,
-0.039908953,
-0.0519398451,
0.0093520526,
-0.0570583828,
-0.030409554,
0.034633819,
0.034213867,
0.0084317168,
-0.0243810099,
0.0098320385,
-0.0415768176,
-0.0242917575,
-0.0324766003,
-0.005266929,
0.0233356189,
-0.0077022007,
0.0141767142,
-0.0377991907,
-0.0124850692,
-0.0356907398,
0.0376107097,
-0.0210022666,
0.0216560327,
-0.0105684968,
0.0154023869,
-0.0777747929,
0.0122896899,
-0.0356538072,
0.0308201183,
0.0193130728,
-0.0556406043,
0.0420989022,
0.0036285054,
-0.0184766594,
0.0045973747,
0.0178435296,
0.0018196926,
-0.0319136605,
0.0458522998,
0.0034657822,
0.0178222489,
-0.0001172668,
-0.0011304566,
-0.0460080765,
0.0250510313,
0.0318205468,
-0.0502354726,
0.0018581384,
-0.0115281725,
2.716e-7,
0.0062503135,
0.0563807786,
0.0166471526,
-0.0138612092,
0.0445611812,
0.0431595258,
-0.0391864069,
0.0224808231,
0.0268525183,
-0.034607444,
-0.0202152301,
0.0237907954,
0.0219737068,
0.0339475013,
-0.0456164703,
-0.0157936979,
-0.0678833947,
0.0537444018,
-0.0401339643,
-0.0442516506,
-0.0072923228,
0.0655898377,
0.0256507546,
-0.0124624828,
0.004586719,
-0.0674859881,
0.0745693669,
-0.0163369533,
-0.0040553077,
0.0374513716,
0.0329231136,
0.0462517068,
0.0192576591,
0.0076152007,
0.002109176,
0.0084899347,
-0.0298239272,
0.0407239757,
0.0126103507,
-0.0108158868,
-0.0237423573,
-0.0101382574,
-0.0063433405,
-0.0681554005,
0.0706157163,
-0.0746888667,
-0.0245164074,
-0.050297752,
0.026649721,
-0.0124217924,
0.0465749502,
-0.016282592,
-0.0237660296,
0.0377460867,
0.0163511503,
0.0586128123,
-0.0133541357,
-0.0842212215,
-0.033310011,
-0.0110627878,
-0.0473564751,
-0.0122926291,
-0.051566232,
0.0227669049,
0.0361894369,
-0.0742777959,
0.0296672396,
2.366913895e-34,
0.0310930368,
-0.0059750862,
0.0264247414,
0.0017331871,
0.0113664605,
-0.005258698,
0.0250026528,
0.035216514,
0.0066735498,
-0.0668219775,
-0.0442690104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15668v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15668v1 | PI-Whisper: An Adaptive and Incremental ASR Framework for Diverse and Evolving Speaker Characteristics | 2024-06-21T21:58:37 | 2024-06-21T21:58:37 | Amir Nassereldine, Dancheng Liu, Chenhui Xu, Jinjun Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | As edge-based automatic speech recognition (ASR) technologies become
increasingly prevalent for the development of intelligent and personalized
assistants, three important challenges must be addressed for these
resource-constrained ASR models, i.e., adaptivity, incrementality, and
inclusivity. We propose a novel ASR framework, PI-Whisper, in this work and
show how it can improve an ASR's recognition capabilities adaptively by
identifying different speakers' characteristics in real-time, how such an
adaption can be performed incrementally without repetitive retraining, and how
it can improve the equity and fairness for diverse speaker groups. More
impressively, our proposed PI-Whisper framework attains all of these nice
properties while still achieving state-of-the-art accuracy with up to 13.7%
reduction of the word error rate (WER) with linear scalability with respect to
computing resources. | [
-0.0324377492,
0.0826466978,
-0.0061936495,
0.0090950904,
-0.0359899029,
-0.0320906788,
0.0541003272,
-0.0259086993,
-0.0234825984,
-0.0140645606,
-0.008523806,
0.0298352446,
0.0282024685,
0.0566799678,
-0.010341539,
-0.0782741308,
0.0314040482,
-0.0253459271,
0.0576386191,
-0.0576632954,
0.0130376117,
0.0096319849,
-0.0304098465,
0.0346027501,
-0.007019409,
0.0031561153,
-0.0007713362,
-0.0067176949,
0.0238181986,
0.0279936418,
-0.0046576015,
0.0458029993,
0.0230400804,
0.0231146794,
0.0000018523,
-0.0386932194,
-0.0242711566,
0.0321686491,
-0.0503883623,
-0.0341247693,
0.0293988623,
0.0530944429,
-0.0304345135,
0.044608824,
-0.0092060883,
0.0139003312,
0.0209987592,
0.0283443332,
0.0214861687,
0.0030363195,
-0.0062174322,
-0.022593949,
0.0182687063,
0.0029078214,
-0.0138864294,
-0.0656750426,
-0.0175915845,
-0.1270381212,
-0.0285551809,
-0.0418761857,
0.010072507,
0.0416944437,
0.031148348,
0.0048279669,
0.0679527596,
-0.0034618191,
-0.0547390617,
-0.0197045524,
-0.0532696433,
0.0388759039,
0.0015098639,
0.002020187,
0.0168335382,
0.017125655,
-0.0235641506,
-0.0453520007,
-0.0125294318,
-0.0256636199,
-0.0208780821,
-0.0158950947,
-0.0389874168,
0.0405866057,
0.0188816693,
0.0049150167,
-0.007736207,
0.053297434,
0.0026485792,
-0.0265463628,
-0.0136979306,
-0.0366362892,
0.0304749981,
0.0033952503,
0.0919091105,
0.0285126083,
-0.0337629914,
0.0008457047,
-0.030348327,
-0.025953833,
0.0052687572,
-0.0156247253,
0.031569995,
0.0541547798,
-0.0493585318,
0.004352177,
0.0430969335,
0.0394355953,
0.0291239638,
-0.0080504604,
-0.0047839074,
-0.0120049203,
0.0041838433,
-0.0036035974,
-0.0458421223,
0.0208824463,
-0.0298475903,
-0.0427150801,
-0.0350947939,
0.0403409004,
-0.0294619463,
0.0108548487,
0.0179526955,
-0.0047867959,
-0.0549445041,
-0.0043504122,
0.0500532761,
0.0449626856,
0.010769261,
0.0255511254,
0.0044219969,
-0.0476425327,
0.014243301,
0.0149832033,
0.0419338942,
0.0339096524,
-0.0035377601,
0.014924828,
-0.0067909393,
-0.0449650101,
-0.0044418471,
0.0235504992,
-0.0155368606,
-0.0091611976,
-0.0012718519,
-0.018513713,
0.0473594666,
0.006584282,
-0.0027220929,
-0.0416459329,
-0.0177188199,
-0.0158164538,
-0.0109347515,
0.0501056276,
-0.0153227858,
0.0202236939,
0.0912206471,
0.0018025357,
0.0099319806,
0.0327974893,
0.0738304332,
-0.0595900714,
0.026348928,
-0.0316815153,
-0.0352924354,
0.0637387857,
0.0168210957,
0.0216677897,
0.0087972591,
-0.0025876404,
-0.012269157,
0.0135835242,
0.0174827557,
0.0294780638,
0.0100782122,
-0.0761027932,
0.0200155247,
0.0765590221,
0.0307210516,
0.0474676862,
-0.0088634435,
0.0131710228,
-0.0141604319,
-0.0221265182,
-0.0541442484,
-0.0198424067,
0.0005935989,
-0.0189014003,
0.0494084284,
0.0513615832,
-0.0537984222,
-0.0147397937,
-0.0021648607,
-0.0209091008,
0.0289833378,
0.0576939993,
0.0168377515,
-0.0026143927,
0.0075887134,
0.030737428,
0.0364516824,
-0.0619622245,
-0.0088026263,
-0.0668469593,
0.0105450451,
0.0814378634,
0.0229232106,
-0.03168137,
0.0077258642,
-0.0100479722,
-0.0420150459,
0.0273782704,
0.0019781208,
-0.0017188111,
0.0494900383,
-0.0554961599,
-0.0047635525,
0.0757113546,
-0.0189969353,
0.0590558983,
0.0035032628,
0.0136534814,
0.0247116145,
-0.0349036939,
-0.0011084493,
-0.006965749,
0.0024337925,
-0.0073120911,
0.0570340976,
0.007456142,
0.0300884377,
0.0637616143,
-0.005939804,
-0.0443970226,
0.0076474841,
-0.0122851897,
0.0006132859,
0.051299125,
-0.0644199625,
0.048368562,
0.0793775395,
0.0230049975,
0.030431563,
0.009547499,
0.0102792643,
-0.0625331625,
0.0708314851,
-0.018323794,
0.026275605,
-0.0206322297,
0.0390078425,
0.0019080223,
0.040055491,
0.0350482166,
-0.0318014026,
0.0013103232,
-0.0295396391,
-0.0230769068,
0.0157213807,
-0.0202711169,
-0.1068001688,
-0.0007992658,
0.0053960979,
-0.0089652101,
0.0433193073,
-0.022279935,
0.0192471631,
-0.0195703786,
0.0060999179,
-0.0828769132,
-0.0214139801,
-0.0452673919,
-0.0094289491,
-0.0273974128,
0.0604597181,
-0.0169573929,
-0.0702206641,
-0.0188467484,
-0.0262990799,
0.0021188587,
0.003547074,
-0.0437767021,
-0.0335928164,
-0.0091982437,
0.0011542311,
-0.0089351237,
0.0103282519,
0.0022363777,
0.0040854374,
0.0080569107,
-0.0598041378,
-0.0527170263,
0.0001459801,
0.0484660715,
-0.0062568989,
0.0173800699,
0.0031355869,
0.042228099,
0.0460334755,
0.0345267653,
0.0320368186,
0.0109557174,
-0.0274380427,
-0.0007785198,
-0.0425733626,
0.0286650881,
0.0000069502,
0.0458747707,
0.0148612037,
-0.0048630089,
-0.030385837,
0.022090951,
-0.011388015,
0.0255679619,
-0.0480592437,
-0.0001479231,
-0.0201348495,
-0.0475935228,
0.0075085214,
-0.0397612862,
-0.020908501,
-0.031156132,
-0.0096509522,
-0.0378613882,
0.020464031,
-0.0720401257,
-0.0209249333,
-0.0621934012,
-0.060715504,
-0.0403061211,
0.0150120193,
-0.0307606682,
0.0138212433,
-0.0289613996,
-0.0318047665,
-0.0013018794,
-0.0263644066,
0.0100785075,
-0.0588107444,
0.0399967879,
-0.0271259379,
0.0290069953,
0.013086658,
-0.0532848351,
-0.027895404,
0.0184807535,
-0.019931756,
0.0519726686,
-0.024058735,
-0.0611169934,
0.0002500574,
0.0379676335,
0.0277267732,
0.0597071163,
0.0015680633,
0.0259087346,
-0.015926417,
-0.0126413144,
0.0176119376,
0.0579989515,
-0.0144082503,
0.0239398442,
0.0471414775,
0.0153507944,
0.1286671162,
-0.0318783633,
-0.024987001,
0.0024619666,
0.0412113704,
-0.0304341149,
0.0042024986,
0.0079859756,
0.0639026314,
-0.0170825571,
0.0106669515,
0.0829209611,
-0.0021301752,
-0.0876493379,
-0.011062663,
-0.0208084881,
0.0166881997,
0.00914435,
-0.0066018207,
-0.0270010121,
-0.0073789502,
0.0563928895,
0.0966362208,
-0.0029683395,
0.0078515001,
-0.0353486836,
-0.0408226214,
0.0265219957,
0.0251628719,
-0.069702372,
-0.0271480866,
-0.0571165308,
0.0107349288,
-0.004494227,
0.0703477636,
0.0125461388,
0.0061915289,
-0.0481523164,
0.0328324735,
-0.0924858823,
-0.0150902299,
0.0397895612,
-0.0160629507,
0.0448512584,
0.061401464,
-0.008130732,
0.0087244241,
-0.0457642861,
0.0026261655,
-0.0054321978,
-0.0117624579,
-0.0712374225,
-0.009669777,
0.0104835825,
0.0040520807,
-0.015802132,
0.0516940728,
-0.0037860477,
-0.0158460978,
0.0460013375,
0.0274984278,
-0.0169187952,
0.0045368196,
-0.0297463648,
-0.0024711946,
0.0236162487,
0.0326852091,
-0.0007230328,
-0.0392711833,
0.0057438524,
-0.0028920437,
0.0100249946,
-0.0138432933,
-0.0052715861,
0.0145117287,
-0.03390228,
-0.0471120514,
-0.0040612151,
-0.0016950137,
-0.0109255444,
0.0253529176,
0.0162861273,
-0.0101287039,
0.0143381096,
0.020092994,
-0.0582383089,
-0.0379762016,
-0.0273278784,
0.0345822088,
-0.0312138889,
-0.0441311523,
0.019852588,
-0.0569475703,
-0.0147433272,
0.0033792905,
-0.0385508686,
-0.0535061955,
0.0656584278,
-0.0089825261,
0.0242385548,
0.0712903515,
-0.0655497983,
-0.0608457699,
0.0925810784,
0.0149536747,
-0.0178797562,
0.0416508988,
0.085592024,
0.0143610938,
-0.0253298767,
0.0206807777,
-0.050741531,
0.0043707909,
-0.0277756695,
-0.0106566474,
-0.0455028899,
-0.1247405186,
-0.0492209457,
0.0315504037,
0.0071577816,
0.0100608366,
0.0122682797,
-0.0033759612,
0.0423853584,
0.0266033988,
0.0388130061,
-0.0192387197,
-0.0215268694,
-0.0602254979,
-0.0030586172,
0.0002276946,
-0.0408497415,
-0.0234047174,
-0.0520198643,
-0.0531861037,
0.0509166047,
-0.033586897,
-0.00006762,
0.0264839772,
0.0025870048,
0.0007557137,
0.0432042889,
0.0294553954,
0.0176379737,
0.0139061483,
-0.0002744859,
-0.0011396254,
-0.004994472,
-0.0286225751,
0.0281921737,
-0.0406965055,
-0.0450234674,
-0.0032455251,
0.0662808716,
0.0038820782,
0.0665562749,
0.0409692004,
0.0115464693,
0.0382507406,
-0.0418773219,
-0.0113049764,
-0.0131314751,
-0.0208627172,
0.011819791,
-0.0047181761,
-0.0048654187,
0.0414711498,
0.0361639783,
-0.0118406257,
0.021267863,
-0.0495169051,
0.0320829339,
-0.0506944247,
-0.0546644963,
-0.0283932667,
0.0164438039,
-0.0194720253,
-0.003960514,
-0.0112555176,
-0.0458448231,
0.0537093878,
-0.0016609463,
0.0534256846,
-0.0123624234,
0.0053672092,
0.0129884966,
-0.062449418,
-0.0298631787,
0.0000108575,
-0.0389028899,
-0.0185056385,
-0.0234143548,
0.0917313471,
-6.222168575e-33,
-0.0383931473,
0.0077001541,
0.010769044,
0.0223192088,
-0.0064608953,
-0.0045606019,
0.0071216179,
-0.0080910232,
0.0082417484,
-0.0457707867,
-0.053491585,
0.0128281973,
0.0497544333,
0.0247438475,
-0.018974768,
-0.0168692507,
0.1027676612,
-0.0019728423,
0.0064985515,
0.0210218355,
0.0081759244,
0.0432482921,
0.0098612169,
-0.0674146563,
-0.0052085523,
0.0079868641,
-0.0181940347,
-0.0042145606,
0.0024504601,
0.0089142248,
0.0002717951,
0.062606521,
-0.0054440866,
0.0061885528,
-0.0166458469,
0.0076302337,
-0.0958966464,
0.0153436344,
-0.0387094133,
0.0688451529,
-0.0042661522,
-0.0115643544,
0.0287602134,
0.0366188809,
-0.0594350137,
-0.0101794153,
0.0321941152,
-0.0142419506,
-0.0095680878,
0.0050246469,
0.0521178804,
0.0513654314,
-0.0057887668,
-0.0224739686,
0.0182280466,
-0.0104361121,
-0.0186646935,
-0.0652792603,
-0.131274417,
0.042859599,
0.0088761607,
-0.0144610154,
0.0203834344,
0.0294473581,
-0.0025671232,
-0.0133306962,
0.0823723599,
-0.071362637,
0.0427406617,
-0.0410405658,
0.0354934894,
0.0024855505,
0.0114126494,
-0.0362153761,
-0.0041794903,
-0.0565680712,
-0.0018869938,
-0.0219441336,
0.1099682972,
-0.0034827148,
0.0210778769,
0.0287116617,
-0.0708996728,
-0.0022815757,
-0.0386862718,
-0.0695243254,
-0.0253181234,
-0.0116823167,
0.0478597395,
0.0355843939,
-0.0159665216,
0.0180173591,
0.0327989608,
-0.0125178732,
-0.0015699668,
-0.0137125123,
0.0078187957,
0.0056968415,
0.00149074,
0.0231949445,
-0.0358474404,
-0.0137132453,
0.0161892381,
0.0387623236,
-0.0068544019,
-0.0308429375,
-0.0133475997,
0.0826454833,
-0.0580780655,
-0.0023382411,
0.0193626471,
0.0680657327,
0.0256659538,
-0.0118182544,
0.0122062266,
-0.0127937282,
-0.0080870958,
0.0477727838,
0.0359391309,
0.0069125155,
-0.0320597328,
0.020580003,
0.0137177696,
0.0284830257,
-0.0523413457,
0.0053412262,
0.0281033851,
-0.0121522136,
-0.0125276763,
-0.0182534624,
-0.0052551334,
-0.0130717559,
2.717e-7,
-0.0862616822,
0.0177264158,
0.033620432,
-0.0528337136,
0.0296761859,
0.0340821259,
0.0149029195,
0.0228802189,
-0.0137400571,
0.0808325782,
-0.0002897142,
0.0485295504,
0.0619395822,
0.0380136967,
-0.0738398209,
-0.0496844426,
-0.0679523274,
0.0294498801,
-0.0106893117,
0.081209071,
-0.0087029617,
0.027343927,
0.0305947978,
-0.0478736162,
0.0009009943,
-0.0365717821,
-0.0099866465,
0.0054358877,
0.027190255,
0.0001197304,
0.009963261,
0.0243167747,
-0.0012221768,
0.0255001187,
-0.0149806263,
0.0729554892,
-0.0348513387,
0.0158273783,
-0.0395583585,
-0.0535762347,
-0.0075693638,
0.046256274,
-0.0125378221,
-0.012555737,
0.0690850839,
0.036840152,
-0.0403224565,
-0.0403379649,
-0.0014787766,
-0.0220605861,
0.0120580141,
0.0195393264,
-0.0107547315,
0.0356372036,
-0.0133889941,
-0.0287232492,
-0.0455707535,
-0.0809111297,
0.0219834317,
-0.0111819711,
-0.0550482497,
-0.0184952654,
-0.0553813986,
0.0234205816,
0.0079423385,
0.0184563808,
0.0203032009,
1.696183591e-34,
0.0049886387,
0.0244654007,
-0.0099184895,
0.030652402,
-0.0424907766,
-0.0405270234,
0.058612261,
0.0187560488,
0.0331372619,
-0.0210898072,
-0.0364891365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15627v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15627v1 | Benchmarking Uncertainty Quantification Methods for Large Language Models with LM-Polygraph | 2024-06-21T20:06:31 | 2024-06-21T20:06:31 | Roman Vashurin, Ekaterina Fadeeva, Artem Vazhentsev, Akim Tsvigun, Daniil Vasilev, Rui Xing, Abdelrahman Boda Sadallah, Lyudmila Rvanova, Sergey Petrakov, Alexander Panchenko, Timothy Baldwin, Preslav Nakov, Maxim Panov, Artem Shelmanov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Uncertainty quantification (UQ) is becoming increasingly recognized as a
critical component of applications that rely on machine learning (ML). The
rapid proliferation of large language models (LLMs) has stimulated researchers
to seek efficient and effective approaches to UQ in text generation tasks, as
in addition to their emerging capabilities, these models have introduced new
challenges for building safe applications. As with other ML models, LLMs are
prone to make incorrect predictions, ``hallucinate'' by fabricating claims, or
simply generate low-quality output for a given input. UQ is a key element in
dealing with these challenges. However research to date on UQ methods for LLMs
has been fragmented, with disparate evaluation methods. In this work, we tackle
this issue by introducing a novel benchmark that implements a collection of
state-of-the-art UQ baselines, and provides an environment for controllable and
consistent evaluation of novel techniques by researchers in various text
generation tasks. Our benchmark also supports the assessment of confidence
normalization methods in terms of their ability to provide interpretable
scores. Using our benchmark, we conduct a large-scale empirical investigation
of UQ and normalization techniques across nine tasks and shed light on the most
promising approaches. | [
-0.0124011971,
0.1083879694,
0.0231249426,
0.0040261457,
-0.0548631586,
-0.0164083708,
0.019750677,
-0.012525226,
-0.024546966,
-0.0496386997,
0.0134928161,
-0.1064741611,
0.0304246433,
0.0261605587,
0.0289149079,
-0.009070972,
0.0011555626,
-0.0261602215,
0.0124830464,
0.0098391632,
0.0117377359,
-0.0002769821,
0.018303765,
0.0480554588,
-0.0366129428,
-0.0036974107,
0.0070609134,
0.0519914627,
0.034278933,
-0.0357530899,
-0.0215650238,
0.083533451,
0.0098935571,
0.0551954135,
0.000001852,
-0.0533488803,
-0.0222355407,
0.0035903563,
-0.0048238887,
0.0294362362,
0.0384942181,
-0.0123874079,
-0.0125295985,
0.0556139946,
-0.0008296064,
0.0072784489,
0.0586284995,
-0.014263547,
0.0024695734,
0.0751434043,
-0.0045159068,
0.0013071612,
0.005582368,
-0.0169181898,
-0.0244352873,
-0.0189386159,
0.0214047972,
0.0118448194,
-0.0209125038,
-0.0229256637,
0.0014586197,
0.0254657064,
0.0137791242,
-0.0061192573,
-0.0434626713,
0.0139008593,
-0.0245060287,
-0.0254634079,
0.0155093372,
0.0319431238,
-0.028990522,
-0.025902776,
-0.0047467886,
-0.0135805188,
-0.0250967257,
0.0204726905,
-0.0267885346,
0.0703497678,
-0.0175041594,
0.0192468204,
0.0056591984,
0.036513418,
0.0462671146,
0.0102475574,
-0.0090120863,
0.0569123626,
0.0324088782,
-0.0019021637,
0.0110290768,
0.0103924656,
-0.0563355312,
-0.0410978422,
0.0203770082,
0.0211238954,
-0.0330438837,
0.0165662728,
-0.0838690102,
-0.0149100525,
0.0300245881,
-0.0144541049,
0.0403103903,
0.0210616905,
0.0277258642,
-0.0151151344,
-0.0016211532,
0.0616460033,
0.0230700355,
-0.0110113174,
-0.0396330394,
0.0094199125,
0.0126731498,
0.0012339208,
-0.0175860114,
0.0080310833,
-0.0065824585,
-0.018067237,
-0.0769632012,
0.0079922918,
-0.0103835035,
0.03512723,
0.0129713481,
0.0025720147,
-0.0205184519,
-0.0103498986,
0.0133221867,
0.0230667684,
0.0041310466,
0.0061168717,
0.0238675084,
-0.064926289,
0.0094695501,
0.0498301126,
-0.0179444868,
-0.0122069744,
-0.0037276044,
0.0424485877,
-0.0003074793,
-0.0460639074,
-0.0203231368,
-0.0466710627,
-0.0570684746,
-0.0785865635,
-0.0289787408,
-0.0957043767,
-0.0126708467,
0.0051329196,
-0.0056281528,
-0.0540489182,
0.0282758698,
0.0153287863,
0.0066111069,
0.0478636511,
-0.0163702723,
0.01887553,
0.0130726863,
0.0185246114,
0.0163796619,
0.0585512258,
0.0767007321,
0.0440645181,
0.033300139,
0.0230181962,
0.0330781005,
0.050499808,
0.0115180146,
-0.0095489584,
-0.0422968753,
-0.0550551787,
-0.019823838,
0.0586443581,
0.0086276382,
0.1158766001,
-0.0232211165,
0.0026278603,
0.0881953835,
0.0032690386,
-0.0218657795,
-0.0457267463,
0.0524119698,
0.005605361,
0.040088281,
0.0228988044,
-0.0236049481,
-0.016569959,
-0.0355665907,
0.0529996753,
0.0500591956,
0.0552886613,
0.0017641931,
-0.0603110082,
-0.0557521693,
-0.013924202,
-0.0053269602,
0.0020773564,
0.0450032093,
-0.0185036212,
-0.0525626279,
0.0152262524,
0.000272994,
-0.0614434928,
0.0309709646,
-0.0349540003,
0.0130297905,
0.0370426401,
0.0793761462,
-0.0167995449,
-0.0224730801,
-0.0015444945,
-0.0278314445,
0.0468053557,
0.0144507661,
0.0005030381,
0.006898867,
-0.0553833172,
-0.0100878216,
0.0106811896,
0.0281776302,
-0.0079618869,
0.0269207209,
0.0107014198,
0.0485735349,
-0.0641681179,
-0.04964488,
0.02981361,
-0.0278873295,
-0.0312420763,
0.0165077206,
-0.010794796,
0.0153182214,
0.0378083177,
-0.0491274819,
0.0430230275,
0.0345407873,
-0.0242872443,
-0.0036476289,
-0.0052294945,
-0.0141032692,
-0.0194928031,
0.0632861182,
-0.0276315492,
-0.0127529046,
0.0174216442,
-0.0239723511,
-0.0447778441,
-0.0157392956,
-0.0201501623,
-0.0454022139,
-0.0509067886,
0.0351338387,
0.0026762821,
0.0097932601,
-0.0690413862,
0.0337981395,
-0.0162096489,
0.0208658464,
0.0254828557,
0.0136735607,
0.0092752865,
-0.0119296471,
-0.0273630302,
0.0104811136,
-0.0156638324,
0.0366356485,
0.0305286832,
0.0100868046,
0.0044526663,
-0.0344646499,
-0.0823066756,
0.0196894947,
-0.0360439904,
0.0311592799,
0.0315486863,
-0.0040368726,
-0.0043906886,
0.0290298238,
-0.0573063157,
-0.0331596024,
0.0404656306,
0.0038947694,
0.051519841,
-0.0238773264,
-0.019918913,
-0.0398112275,
-0.0060692984,
-0.0155445021,
0.0560980812,
0.0106820101,
0.0067046569,
-0.0604677536,
0.0512680784,
-0.0364687741,
-0.0302071497,
0.0142095983,
-0.025628686,
0.0027784181,
0.0215486456,
0.033839047,
0.0186103191,
0.0216264669,
0.0260664839,
0.0659526661,
-0.0068940339,
-0.010563409,
-0.011674027,
-0.0278514177,
-0.0248617213,
-0.0103141507,
-0.0888440609,
0.0211037342,
0.0539838634,
0.0072398898,
-0.011951982,
-0.042334266,
0.0349646211,
-0.0443321355,
-0.0338878334,
-0.0186127927,
-0.0161115769,
-0.0213631503,
0.0625636503,
-0.0034396676,
-0.0707406774,
0.0304366406,
-0.0841292217,
0.0395430587,
-0.0052456553,
-0.0116424868,
-0.0127296289,
0.0467765704,
0.0277733896,
0.0389019884,
0.0144544374,
0.0067236102,
-0.0630149469,
0.0024130326,
0.0456376188,
-0.0480783023,
0.0119618997,
-0.0783483759,
0.0133675365,
-0.0016797415,
0.0130638629,
-0.037345726,
-0.0307327211,
-0.01766425,
0.0350231268,
0.0461693592,
-0.0461621284,
0.0119131738,
0.0479340553,
-0.0123521034,
0.007072269,
-0.0383407138,
-0.0006134989,
-0.0102123674,
0.0482830778,
0.0573811568,
-0.0093255863,
0.0767827332,
-0.0526421592,
-0.0257786512,
0.0332915075,
0.0008856946,
0.0485802591,
-0.0190428123,
-0.0368094184,
0.013221777,
-0.0355433598,
-0.0170970988,
0.0523098186,
0.0975640938,
-0.0250614155,
-0.0212007966,
0.1410605013,
0.0251583699,
0.0186554771,
0.0182112828,
0.0231550466,
0.0954712033,
-0.0122088809,
0.0066881506,
-0.0844767019,
-0.0187209323,
0.0226225145,
0.0408773981,
-0.026801778,
-0.0214074738,
-0.0158872437,
-0.1015672907,
0.0393884704,
0.0266331173,
-0.0521942079,
-0.0473544933,
-0.0318591781,
-0.0033026452,
-0.0201422703,
0.0528246909,
0.0071974057,
-0.0142372074,
0.016444359,
0.0540904999,
-0.0646473989,
-0.0806770921,
-0.0487153344,
-0.0595788695,
0.058771167,
0.0188152865,
0.0203984696,
0.0041794786,
0.0213237032,
0.0014252275,
0.0052859685,
-0.0234533604,
0.0196683612,
0.0345277898,
0.0150187779,
-0.0007607505,
-0.0075639291,
0.0076860809,
-0.0414827503,
-0.0140110366,
-0.0168420598,
0.0256259367,
-0.0054530106,
-0.0388017036,
-0.0072274157,
0.0157361254,
0.0088913962,
0.0836804658,
0.0291851778,
-0.0116397217,
-0.0709604099,
-0.0482738428,
0.0318206549,
-0.0391566865,
-0.004490538,
0.0291651897,
-0.0185764804,
-0.0397904627,
-0.0744955093,
-0.0325672515,
0.0183154717,
0.022081472,
-0.016029695,
-0.0200936925,
0.0427853502,
-0.0175441168,
-0.0631690025,
-0.0064785169,
-0.0147645418,
0.0453796163,
-0.0516234785,
0.0523669906,
-0.0192329325,
0.005440508,
-0.000056474,
0.0610103793,
-0.1200648546,
-0.0812841356,
-0.0062932442,
0.0210616346,
0.0256141424,
0.0061101876,
-0.007535784,
-0.0589150339,
0.0504743233,
0.052276805,
0.0058013801,
0.0148049863,
0.0112124206,
0.0048534051,
-0.0360860415,
0.022908831,
-0.0022340128,
-0.0126307886,
-0.0317505151,
0.048756741,
-0.0103410464,
-0.0982640386,
0.0082809674,
0.0465766974,
0.0030872121,
-0.0669970289,
0.0168297887,
-0.0133218588,
-0.0233310107,
-0.0403160341,
-0.0266200546,
-0.0466457903,
0.0060724821,
0.0448324718,
0.0065634539,
-0.0311979651,
-0.0065289289,
-0.0038803704,
0.042767182,
-0.008572923,
-0.0199142508,
-0.0464432463,
0.0228261501,
0.0338304192,
-0.0456013344,
-0.0254371278,
0.0187510233,
-0.0118915029,
0.0247762557,
0.0206873491,
0.0049020816,
-0.0004892459,
0.0175227001,
0.0093460698,
0.0134858573,
-0.031746015,
-0.0520956144,
-0.0548594259,
0.0303812139,
0.060614977,
0.0178059805,
0.0859259889,
-0.04259599,
-0.0010052635,
-0.0608812831,
0.048091758,
0.0188024715,
0.0117128398,
0.031148145,
-0.0124002527,
-0.0358790047,
0.0000996284,
0.095357798,
0.0341513976,
0.0321588032,
-0.0092608724,
-0.0653489605,
-0.024975583,
-0.0515775941,
-0.0205158889,
0.0157240611,
-0.0283529796,
-0.0249121785,
-0.0729186386,
-0.0658830479,
0.0220607948,
0.0386084691,
0.0258480962,
-0.0158633497,
-0.0076749045,
0.0332078151,
-0.0121003576,
0.0252611954,
-0.0367040001,
-0.0008214919,
-0.0207918547,
0.0140030095,
-0.0087335398,
-5.943793513e-33,
-0.0297100246,
-0.0622623824,
-0.0142333265,
-0.0590120442,
-0.0211902354,
0.0086499844,
-0.0104702199,
0.0323359109,
0.0387242809,
0.0244928002,
0.0057854862,
-0.021794321,
0.0194562897,
0.0270461645,
-0.0134883961,
-0.0002631797,
0.056383878,
-0.0036629641,
-0.0535169318,
0.0047258916,
0.0206758305,
0.0016274542,
0.0581898242,
-0.0658175275,
0.0258560963,
0.0031380854,
-0.0571583174,
0.0198953077,
-0.0123159839,
0.0372758619,
-0.0079234382,
0.0305086989,
0.0021201822,
-0.0060318601,
-0.0158544593,
-0.0168801546,
-0.0320128389,
-0.008074793,
0.0081860423,
0.027191883,
-0.0422888324,
-0.0215535704,
0.0251274705,
-0.0130713386,
-0.0511585101,
0.0008727952,
-0.0008615794,
-0.007501299,
-0.0359961241,
-0.0783809051,
-0.041691646,
0.0685896799,
0.0098015172,
-0.0220967252,
-0.0015986302,
0.050430838,
-0.0376096405,
-0.0140018687,
-0.0255246498,
-0.0125268893,
0.0239100643,
0.0563692078,
0.077791065,
0.035624098,
-0.0289704502,
0.0464050658,
-0.0015968641,
-0.0042270613,
-0.025578035,
0.0140578384,
0.0182460267,
0.0090488503,
0.0374740884,
0.0719687268,
0.0334614515,
0.0096977325,
-0.0747659802,
0.0458229631,
0.0173385069,
-0.0037192965,
0.0456680208,
-0.0183841437,
-0.0222113058,
-0.0401055403,
-0.072004348,
-0.0163017195,
-0.0063617178,
-0.0070662564,
0.0136825731,
0.0165519454,
-0.0430544317,
-0.0153676709,
0.0282911938,
-0.0284037162,
-0.0399908349,
0.0150573952,
-0.0345879681,
0.0169557016,
-0.0076348251,
0.0465449765,
-0.0407652408,
-0.0089918226,
0.0238647033,
0.0074104755,
-0.003207729,
0.0055309371,
0.0254469514,
0.0238405764,
-0.0667763352,
0.0343126208,
-0.039379824,
0.030333424,
0.0158164818,
0.0046319342,
0.0360086523,
-0.0514941886,
-0.0139240036,
0.0295903478,
0.0197289158,
0.0374255627,
-0.0082603218,
0.0185501017,
0.0198113509,
0.0135336639,
-0.0267017987,
0.0176473334,
-0.0207825247,
-0.0129208304,
0.0395141505,
-0.0213358123,
-0.0244575683,
-0.0211305507,
2.468e-7,
0.0731091723,
0.0528735518,
0.0339274108,
0.0665223226,
-0.0134118423,
0.0158377644,
0.0159775633,
0.0011715421,
-0.0131985424,
-0.0022493256,
0.009637258,
0.004411845,
0.0606594905,
0.0387695059,
-0.0335234217,
-0.0267635491,
-0.0508877859,
0.0129398415,
-0.0343452506,
-0.0089115109,
0.0612436049,
0.0749043375,
-0.0258542113,
0.0053578392,
0.0186504591,
-0.0317453817,
0.0725093633,
-0.0286894217,
-0.0543743074,
0.0400099754,
0.0879602879,
-0.00666735,
0.011845584,
-0.0046526678,
0.0045719203,
-0.0286435392,
0.0172697976,
0.0735456571,
0.0337319709,
0.0116748409,
0.0054668998,
-0.0018732423,
0.0140199242,
-0.0560617149,
0.0540931635,
-0.0384317748,
-0.0303059611,
-0.0761977807,
-0.0095047699,
-0.0253453981,
0.0674532726,
-0.019601794,
-0.0092421221,
0.0257161837,
0.0096802386,
0.0240695346,
-0.0197180603,
-0.0016602296,
-0.065997079,
0.0057343077,
-0.0137323691,
-0.0405959859,
-0.0177009273,
-0.0108565362,
0.0052707922,
-0.0635717884,
0.0084681753,
2.685606944e-34,
0.0572505295,
-0.0033970866,
-0.0153510934,
0.0053914771,
0.0437170491,
-0.0135802785,
-0.0040305126,
0.0133203445,
-0.0295929071,
-0.0649494901,
0.0104156546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15625v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15625v1 | Shortcomings of LLMs for Low-Resource Translation: Retrieval and Understanding are Both the Problem | 2024-06-21T20:02:22 | 2024-06-21T20:02:22 | Sara Court, Micha Elsner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This work investigates the in-context learning abilities of pretrained large
language models (LLMs) when instructed to translate text from a low-resource
language into a high-resource language as part of an automated machine
translation pipeline. We conduct a set of experiments translating Southern
Quechua to Spanish and examine the informativity of various types of
information retrieved from a constrained database of digitized pedagogical
materials (dictionaries and grammar lessons) and parallel corpora. Using both
automatic and human evaluation of model output, we conduct ablation studies
that manipulate (1) context type (morpheme translations, grammar descriptions,
and corpus examples), (2) retrieval methods (automated vs. manual), and (3)
model type. Our results suggest that even relatively small LLMs are capable of
utilizing prompt context for zero-shot low-resource translation when provided a
minimally sufficient amount of relevant linguistic information. However, the
variable effects of prompt type, retrieval method, model type, and
language-specific factors highlight the limitations of using even the best LLMs
as translation systems for the majority of the world's 7,000+ languages and
their speakers. | [
0.0094356313,
-0.0135067077,
-0.0341197401,
0.0305651259,
-0.0186223257,
0.015627794,
0.0235552732,
0.0047558178,
-0.0564655885,
-0.0693890452,
-0.0789400041,
-0.0085506495,
0.0350224003,
-0.0618521087,
0.0134982243,
-0.0578080155,
0.0325131603,
-0.0269772019,
-0.0354890749,
0.0019547441,
-0.0108510684,
0.000032263,
0.0192017388,
0.0248244479,
0.0084156981,
0.0205095336,
-0.001560405,
0.0578608923,
-0.0092249038,
-0.0169675369,
-0.0108476384,
0.0392188951,
0.0200922024,
0.0469796509,
0.0000021815,
-0.0712430775,
-0.0344355181,
-0.0107887452,
-0.0325058922,
0.0310680419,
0.0895278379,
-0.0402795263,
-0.0240163803,
0.0290325433,
-0.0209200718,
-0.016328685,
0.0429795943,
-0.0465209037,
0.0235832222,
0.0514264219,
-0.0046525965,
-0.0360796452,
0.0025882211,
-0.0128041422,
0.0194732901,
-0.0342511348,
0.0234945696,
-0.0052003884,
0.0029815047,
0.0501196496,
-0.0014365476,
0.062902838,
0.0018932779,
0.0008325659,
-0.032429114,
-0.0093146078,
-0.0107699558,
-0.0661952645,
-0.0026679975,
0.047902137,
-0.0163796954,
-0.0391906016,
-0.0297686979,
0.0101656793,
-0.0075413077,
-0.0145011982,
-0.0653889775,
0.0450715236,
0.0176474024,
0.0074896449,
0.0444905199,
0.0368241258,
0.0373211466,
0.0138311386,
-0.055410549,
-0.0385611728,
0.0102544762,
-0.0421184935,
0.0124430573,
0.0178869069,
0.0081712035,
-0.0089099705,
0.0019739431,
0.0400575735,
-0.0049470025,
0.0500322953,
0.006256381,
-0.0546815805,
0.0397349596,
-0.043153286,
0.0014550993,
0.0571344867,
-0.0230462942,
0.028842086,
-0.0042311754,
0.055741325,
-0.0038248615,
0.0162975118,
-0.0845685154,
-0.0070046121,
-0.0208853595,
0.0103815394,
-0.0656620264,
0.0040367497,
-0.0329956822,
0.0209977739,
-0.0043850131,
0.0138084562,
0.0333691537,
0.004706135,
-0.0200266615,
-0.0252955165,
-0.0799659267,
-0.0109876748,
-0.0229323562,
0.0741799846,
0.0053687785,
0.0049244245,
0.0082713645,
-0.082621254,
0.0075445035,
-0.0006910915,
-0.0153579786,
-0.0418675505,
0.0111501897,
0.0531302653,
-0.0303405467,
-0.0740153641,
-0.044747524,
-0.0219004266,
-0.0144765358,
-0.0706644207,
-0.0020752153,
-0.0661839768,
0.0231483839,
0.0529814474,
0.0547020547,
0.0052306158,
0.0098883677,
0.0001646067,
-0.0130502572,
0.0491545238,
0.0192730837,
0.0183855332,
0.0601926818,
0.0007318905,
-0.0003536667,
0.0893088058,
0.0229581334,
0.040942058,
0.0410426073,
-0.0167180523,
-0.0503013358,
0.0527068935,
0.0187312476,
0.052060999,
-0.0324420109,
-0.0019481794,
0.0094425594,
0.0264890175,
0.0244137999,
0.0564268157,
-0.0112060318,
0.0717711747,
0.0716099367,
0.0774105936,
0.0006337835,
0.0134956725,
0.062201824,
0.0211913828,
0.0176815223,
0.0024247814,
-0.0312129278,
-0.0283944719,
-0.0426470041,
0.0194364358,
0.0305137411,
0.039467182,
-0.0289058667,
-0.0560426861,
-0.0153831281,
-0.0194381699,
-0.0114751114,
0.0131228464,
0.0683064535,
0.0198093615,
-0.0402911417,
0.0256503932,
0.0010424814,
-0.0379848666,
0.0179845374,
-0.0214664098,
-0.0131042926,
0.0537842698,
0.0509367175,
-0.0183210857,
0.0108603314,
0.0205566138,
0.034007445,
0.0342875719,
0.0344384871,
-0.0047171852,
-0.00906129,
-0.0412213504,
0.0034339477,
0.0200118348,
0.0353869274,
0.0081349472,
0.0064761401,
0.0440117382,
0.0389228389,
-0.026047634,
-0.0703562573,
0.0248145554,
-0.086540699,
-0.0762516409,
-0.0355578698,
0.0257821344,
-0.0064376323,
0.023517698,
-0.0112673268,
-0.0161438156,
0.0466689244,
-0.0136423586,
0.0292505901,
0.0209740587,
-0.0678474903,
-0.0147314146,
0.0004311663,
0.0111273769,
0.0058128894,
-0.0336096063,
0.011138021,
-0.0527599826,
-0.0178134833,
0.0093126791,
0.0443050042,
-0.0689427257,
0.0535081774,
-0.0458670072,
-0.0116790086,
-0.0730990022,
0.0188574232,
0.0230603646,
0.0234081671,
0.0499240346,
-0.0129464949,
0.0320207067,
-0.057656046,
-0.0400170274,
0.0267243031,
0.0159029067,
0.0100987935,
0.0169261396,
0.030641418,
-0.0271177012,
-0.0121658556,
-0.0786319003,
0.0202232506,
-0.0215850454,
-0.0120517537,
0.0581851713,
0.041179467,
-0.0013506524,
0.0046947044,
0.0332195535,
0.0232347436,
0.0195721313,
0.0351632498,
-0.0032997001,
0.0233083703,
0.0135127287,
-0.0363660082,
0.0047568385,
0.0296257474,
0.0354223102,
0.0290536806,
-0.0391592756,
-0.0365656912,
0.0854349509,
0.0094250124,
-0.0137869855,
0.0169988386,
-0.0763065144,
0.0122086899,
-0.0221815296,
0.0473775677,
0.0585234426,
-0.0326099321,
0.0373734348,
0.0559238195,
-0.0056625716,
-0.0743332952,
-0.0173549112,
-0.0045901602,
-0.0878519639,
-0.0467892773,
-0.0407968313,
0.0003334734,
0.050077267,
0.0243476462,
-0.0060233041,
-0.0546502061,
-0.0227876399,
-0.0485287718,
-0.0213841088,
-0.0495790951,
0.0285100434,
-0.0092433356,
0.0570330024,
-0.0192173366,
-0.0573961101,
0.0539408103,
-0.0278101619,
-0.0163747855,
-0.0250227638,
0.0011440606,
-0.0304242764,
0.0150209107,
-0.0240132008,
-0.0033958466,
-0.0419001989,
-0.0321211964,
-0.0489380993,
0.0280282069,
0.0090532219,
-0.047878392,
0.0272943359,
-0.0660605207,
-0.0041645127,
-0.0390672982,
-0.0166940149,
-0.0300666001,
0.0131859472,
-0.000268666,
-0.0124050211,
0.0184731297,
0.0142067811,
-0.0207603555,
0.0064828177,
0.0430586338,
0.0482812785,
-0.0056156628,
-0.0159331243,
-0.012698818,
0.0037010245,
-0.0484407991,
-0.01604628,
0.0094223889,
-0.0733575225,
0.0753330737,
0.000209895,
0.017211806,
-0.0333626382,
-0.007425779,
-0.034411706,
0.0422112532,
0.0045297495,
-0.0416558497,
0.0137299541,
0.0378942601,
-0.0478386059,
-0.0154238222,
0.1067580581,
0.0260992739,
-0.0643950105,
-0.0336740538,
-0.0386497304,
-0.0068466193,
0.0230447296,
0.0194421895,
-0.1189984232,
-0.0061071431,
0.0279149283,
0.0382045843,
0.0241463631,
0.0274147596,
-0.0308182016,
-0.1200196147,
0.0036580707,
0.0301071666,
-0.0296816379,
-0.0184976086,
-0.0169585552,
-0.0150611736,
-0.016206434,
0.0318091363,
0.0211737659,
-0.0152363321,
-0.0016180349,
0.03021699,
0.0440388061,
-0.0574930124,
-0.017504923,
-0.0045894533,
-0.0215562005,
0.053294871,
0.0242582578,
-0.0184669755,
-0.0115872473,
0.0644201338,
-0.0321157202,
0.006306909,
-0.023415802,
0.0021520101,
0.0319501199,
0.0146679524,
0.0073246984,
-0.0020424495,
0.004534523,
-0.0021519915,
0.0281503499,
0.0779596791,
-0.0140667306,
0.0130994236,
0.0066808849,
-0.0605221502,
0.0093577839,
0.0822158754,
0.0338908434,
-0.0470156707,
0.0174346082,
0.0023966979,
-0.0213256329,
-0.0180809163,
-0.0271238908,
0.0333757736,
-0.0913152695,
-0.0257651079,
-0.0809922963,
-0.0354890414,
0.0098922458,
0.0383131318,
0.0525827371,
0.0321948454,
0.0150275892,
0.0078461012,
0.0182909202,
0.0349995121,
-0.0409528948,
-0.0060407897,
-0.1119039729,
-0.0193866175,
-0.0001743782,
-0.0577908158,
0.0200687405,
0.0137491794,
-0.0652554706,
-0.0610962063,
0.0132984873,
0.0206846185,
0.029652603,
0.0280458163,
-0.0019577737,
-0.0339962691,
0.0745837763,
0.0142123103,
-0.008675063,
0.0378555879,
0.0150402188,
0.0492813438,
-0.0210145246,
0.0308670383,
-0.0274314266,
0.0085367318,
-0.0021071336,
0.0177281294,
-0.0428509191,
-0.0684445649,
0.0216713622,
0.0308452491,
0.0477507785,
-0.0454204008,
-0.038225852,
-0.036514353,
0.018304633,
-0.017492285,
0.0003734749,
-0.0116023915,
-0.0332350917,
0.0642317608,
-0.0006916726,
0.018335551,
-0.015473892,
0.0063339616,
0.0364221595,
-0.0029568516,
-0.0093104551,
-0.0277439971,
0.0428822637,
0.028709637,
0.0516072698,
-0.0073794918,
0.0461844727,
-0.0295296237,
0.0379256606,
-0.0438862592,
0.0459049679,
-0.0097873742,
0.016347941,
0.0117268572,
0.0103474185,
0.0043115895,
-0.0303818937,
0.0008172354,
0.0098432852,
0.0658096969,
-0.0211256761,
0.0609156862,
-0.0066003497,
-0.0061950251,
-0.0476410389,
0.0090753641,
0.0320279151,
-0.0298891626,
0.0116822952,
-0.0160251185,
0.0159484241,
0.0380995348,
0.0696865842,
0.001954939,
0.0215079896,
0.0036588707,
0.0008452924,
0.0008920014,
0.0127208177,
0.0260446426,
-0.002547564,
-0.0200765934,
-0.0276215207,
-0.0611480586,
-0.0396637917,
-0.0131716216,
-0.0006338541,
-0.0312629491,
-0.0345658734,
0.0162026267,
0.0816215575,
-0.0437167324,
0.0067192055,
-0.045931641,
0.0313169137,
-0.0187828932,
-0.0211687926,
-0.0041920487,
-6.599755727e-33,
-0.0428370386,
-0.0369500816,
0.0310558341,
-0.0335770659,
0.0177302863,
0.0290137306,
-0.0292967409,
-0.0049681249,
-0.0087780757,
-0.0035727993,
-0.0258332361,
-0.0119014531,
0.0186108928,
-0.0136891278,
0.0136521095,
0.0381474122,
0.0459744856,
-0.0009347823,
0.0048343455,
0.0073541496,
0.0555663593,
0.0236627143,
0.0705473423,
-0.0352835506,
0.0499080941,
-0.0431372263,
0.0023949228,
0.0103951329,
0.0056871288,
0.0239453278,
0.0008551315,
0.0506936051,
0.0188992228,
-0.0246295519,
-0.0229140539,
0.0392880589,
-0.0914473012,
-0.0218840297,
0.0475225635,
0.0379403867,
0.026597742,
-0.0762472004,
0.0368642844,
-0.037253201,
-0.0381100737,
-0.0014599443,
0.0245187189,
-0.0435962453,
-0.017838046,
-0.0056867828,
-0.0667285174,
-0.0137599241,
0.0050577046,
-0.0194098447,
0.0252101179,
0.0936004817,
-0.0378153734,
0.0138398642,
-0.0630664676,
0.0407086052,
0.0110007618,
0.0484279096,
0.0556267612,
0.0427872203,
0.0047961501,
-0.0114871105,
0.0154692829,
0.0188647993,
0.0529416129,
-0.0072725075,
0.0860758722,
-0.014381323,
0.0159261152,
0.0898347348,
0.03648993,
-0.04565835,
-0.0588483587,
0.0308240838,
-0.0114375986,
0.0291386805,
0.0287286229,
-0.0014468419,
-0.009831748,
-0.0162927955,
-0.067561999,
-0.0130631877,
0.0062256991,
-0.0235976968,
0.0126740849,
0.0216240194,
-0.0060683545,
-0.0191507787,
0.0996817574,
-0.0174705815,
-0.0191794578,
0.0292240325,
-0.0293502007,
-0.0018790754,
-0.0347477198,
0.0224771611,
-0.0605960637,
-0.0384476893,
0.0239089131,
0.0077515403,
-0.0058852532,
-0.0114994124,
0.0157631245,
0.0219751559,
-0.0353870615,
0.0066077826,
-0.046940431,
0.0010265459,
0.0079534035,
-0.0058009815,
0.0307289883,
0.0278829448,
-0.0021412806,
0.0381391793,
0.0278563704,
-0.0262751263,
-0.0283231977,
-0.0196854211,
-0.0279315878,
0.0098166624,
-0.0647301823,
0.0143678077,
-0.0334070288,
0.0412919745,
0.0534471758,
-0.0394509062,
-0.0208170321,
0.0023781953,
3.036e-7,
0.052191969,
0.0566022322,
0.0010658491,
0.0009585141,
0.0178932473,
0.015773017,
-0.0494981483,
-0.0091918437,
0.0363762081,
0.0114228455,
0.0343051851,
0.0448944718,
0.0728582218,
0.0196273476,
-0.1085551679,
-0.0625517517,
0.0025058268,
0.0364252664,
-0.0601337403,
0.0173699912,
0.0054403138,
0.0512016304,
-0.0209585074,
0.00193395,
-0.0178215019,
-0.0509007983,
0.0544696935,
-0.0326117538,
-0.0203586761,
-0.0001975,
0.0332196169,
0.0352059528,
-0.0200192574,
-0.0263259076,
-0.0090313405,
0.0084639555,
-0.016921347,
0.0601656586,
0.0142813474,
-0.0203514062,
0.0353357494,
-0.040812429,
-0.0246786494,
-0.0649685189,
0.0386472419,
-0.0225863177,
0.0336422101,
0.0319776535,
0.0035869733,
-0.0165806711,
-0.0017388288,
-0.0283986218,
-0.0347741432,
0.0094934944,
0.0272118002,
-0.0247287564,
-0.0202653408,
-0.0218317974,
-0.0081649898,
0.0333788954,
-0.0124201225,
-0.1011951268,
-0.0226479452,
0.0077332617,
-0.0120034227,
-0.0469056293,
0.0104284724,
2.585555156e-34,
0.0143559827,
-0.0326927043,
0.0410656147,
-0.013094998,
0.0177899245,
-0.0152498521,
-0.0083701005,
0.0174769815,
0.0071322131,
-0.0550909638,
0.0025557929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00075v1 | Logicbreaks: A Framework for Understanding Subversion of Rule-based Inference | 2024-06-21T19:18:16 | 2024-06-21T19:18:16 | Anton Xue, Avishree Khare, Rajeev Alur, Surbhi Goel, Eric Wong | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | We study how to subvert language models from following the rules. We model
rule-following as inference in propositional Horn logic, a mathematical system
in which rules have the form "if $P$ and $Q$, then $R$" for some propositions
$P$, $Q$, and $R$. We prove that although transformers can faithfully abide by
such rules, maliciously crafted prompts can nevertheless mislead even
theoretically constructed models. Empirically, we find that attacks on our
theoretical models mirror popular attacks on large language models. Our work
suggests that studying smaller theoretical models can help understand the
behavior of large language models in rule-based settings like logical reasoning
and jailbreak attacks. | [
0.0464909263,
0.0293239895,
-0.0145093249,
0.0442454703,
-0.0768923014,
-0.0320119746,
-0.0201389454,
-0.0276434571,
0.0328491591,
-0.0109115476,
-0.0010280312,
0.0160559844,
0.0291658528,
-0.0096750148,
0.043597322,
-0.0155172711,
0.0636301041,
-0.0322671942,
-0.0029919033,
0.0032524164,
0.0069982274,
-0.0073059038,
0.0135737704,
0.0273325685,
0.0081397817,
-0.0204278901,
-0.0364388488,
0.0269399174,
-0.0085994452,
0.0149216373,
-0.026010355,
-0.0015772549,
-0.0572208427,
0.0458723716,
0.0000021597,
-0.0154241668,
-0.0192073919,
0.0521229543,
-0.032132607,
0.0691361502,
-0.022161141,
-0.0466977209,
-0.0237059649,
0.0243927632,
0.0085887872,
0.0146233598,
0.0324039347,
0.0884532407,
0.0851450488,
0.0789522156,
0.0018692992,
-0.0085525,
0.055974707,
-0.0069921343,
0.0002498795,
-0.0526636988,
0.0252366439,
-0.0274058804,
0.0036372035,
0.0079313759,
0.0192192663,
-0.052480448,
0.0339916758,
-0.0033451312,
-0.1148030385,
0.0174099151,
-0.0210100655,
-0.0164849889,
0.0026207997,
0.0049910997,
-0.0454903953,
-0.0419923477,
-0.0072729518,
0.0398673378,
0.0000255878,
0.0484513678,
0.0328307524,
0.0314729363,
-0.0238680523,
-0.0258703325,
0.0542757213,
-0.0045514544,
0.0707037225,
-0.0331554525,
-0.0310817081,
0.0752439648,
0.0352514721,
-0.0242304653,
-0.0592044741,
-0.0472895391,
-0.0289258249,
-0.0477707349,
-0.0286433455,
-0.0199424755,
-0.0072093969,
0.0238742009,
-0.0733487383,
0.0055398257,
0.0434257612,
-0.029830629,
-0.0259021819,
0.0452208556,
0.0101681342,
0.0161170159,
0.0130526135,
-0.0378866717,
-0.0394337773,
0.0444373488,
0.0018284806,
0.0104102949,
0.0216659252,
-0.0503822565,
-0.0019350771,
0.026540285,
0.0023032031,
0.0212503802,
0.0004990385,
0.0212602392,
-0.0315066613,
0.0344200954,
-0.0509266704,
-0.009888703,
-0.0032722575,
0.0121464962,
0.0515966304,
-0.0004734841,
-0.0115080839,
-0.0007127613,
0.0054211896,
-0.08267124,
-0.0293430798,
-0.0482667536,
-0.1031381711,
0.0023743126,
-0.0195515379,
0.1439445317,
0.0302236583,
-0.0019119043,
-0.0580117367,
-0.0944497138,
-0.0244696494,
-0.0265671667,
-0.0340226069,
-0.0756533965,
-0.034048792,
0.0099597266,
-0.0044546979,
-0.0493540019,
-0.0102666104,
-0.0116155688,
-0.041165255,
0.0447764099,
0.0094052888,
-0.0220035575,
-0.0532492474,
0.0315145515,
-0.0369785465,
0.02067592,
-0.019905977,
0.0196370538,
0.033283677,
0.0208511911,
0.0580390729,
0.0276817922,
0.008773827,
0.0144725824,
-0.0108228521,
-0.0004592772,
0.050526727,
-0.0323499888,
-0.0706651583,
0.0753991529,
-0.0385097936,
-0.0290183481,
0.0506183319,
0.0213285144,
0.0090550873,
0.0419640504,
-0.0179238413,
-0.0478591435,
0.0060221092,
0.0405534059,
-0.0751526579,
-0.0345612355,
-0.0793234631,
-0.0159251932,
-0.0812314227,
0.0183801409,
0.0071813753,
-0.009176176,
-0.011537537,
0.0223123617,
-0.0485015959,
-0.0219433997,
0.0071035307,
0.0559154488,
0.0609540828,
0.1007127389,
0.0396047048,
-0.0355724245,
-0.0155854505,
-0.090419963,
0.0045526018,
0.016317945,
0.0599797741,
-0.0084643085,
0.0469565243,
-0.0028012493,
-0.0075499858,
-0.0029786942,
0.0065903729,
0.0351907015,
-0.0026124455,
0.0363766886,
0.0386396907,
-0.0061911722,
0.074580729,
-0.0082251355,
-0.03197309,
-0.0357201695,
-0.0166973062,
-0.0473667011,
0.0266318694,
0.0057667191,
0.0110831931,
0.0048901378,
-0.0137195522,
0.0078926403,
-0.026561277,
-0.0013109045,
-0.0477750264,
0.0424042046,
0.0538249947,
0.0172219314,
0.0266289338,
0.0206050817,
-0.0281987526,
-0.0082918527,
0.0290298108,
-0.0764650032,
0.0134034511,
0.055168815,
-0.0078515206,
0.0148242814,
0.0650227219,
-0.0827023908,
0.0911829695,
0.0085375337,
0.0238236934,
0.0019214457,
-0.0265523437,
-0.0069648856,
-0.0059636026,
-0.0081151547,
0.0117354346,
0.0045037931,
-0.0315780491,
0.028184209,
0.0270889699,
-0.0272991825,
0.0293962918,
-0.0456213653,
0.0202580839,
-0.0049990318,
-0.0149725359,
0.0158869382,
-0.0739399642,
0.0369156897,
-0.0241808146,
0.0036407597,
0.0280242357,
0.0114472248,
0.0338268802,
-0.0228539407,
-0.0192653257,
0.0442762785,
-0.0709987953,
-0.0014070647,
0.0237402692,
0.0029309809,
-0.0188995041,
-0.0423409604,
0.0213945527,
-0.0115399016,
-0.0291103162,
0.0716706663,
-0.029302083,
0.0486290902,
-0.0327666476,
-0.0225569308,
-0.0408523269,
0.0032425832,
-0.0296284743,
-0.011699345,
0.0343156122,
0.0014424683,
-0.0077436143,
0.0262862351,
0.0175041147,
0.0613143109,
0.0134007959,
-0.0121486746,
-0.020295158,
-0.0591938086,
0.029500166,
-0.0152547602,
-0.0407570265,
-0.0616321415,
-0.0128926635,
0.0349750333,
0.0316157974,
-0.0078952601,
-0.0421315245,
0.0706102774,
-0.0080758203,
-0.0203361474,
0.032990735,
-0.0255880207,
-0.0262589753,
-0.0117703713,
-0.009293641,
-0.0390694663,
0.0558043048,
-0.0415281951,
0.032535769,
-0.0342369303,
-0.0024577572,
-0.0271007326,
0.0464301705,
0.006876742,
0.0126171773,
0.1234923825,
-0.0016237027,
-0.0098003363,
0.0007135035,
0.0603412688,
-0.0160709769,
0.0489155464,
-0.0542896166,
-0.0140024247,
-0.01434898,
-0.0577598959,
-0.0522849634,
-0.0516645126,
-0.0000146122,
-0.0346399471,
-0.0140122483,
-0.014982095,
-0.0087525323,
-0.0063209347,
0.0167975649,
-0.0292707309,
0.0116844587,
-0.0317976885,
-0.034698084,
0.0181117393,
0.0043011941,
-0.0717802495,
-0.0102547351,
-0.0062562167,
-0.0026452336,
0.0769747049,
0.0196191706,
0.0150138931,
0.0022890014,
0.0051687681,
-0.0024971184,
0.0016159492,
0.0076932246,
0.0069817128,
0.0076329098,
-0.0195085388,
-0.0102170296,
0.0094774347,
0.0077920831,
0.035050761,
0.0535545573,
-0.0197070092,
0.0420134552,
-0.0059538423,
0.0026188486,
-0.0904645994,
-0.0105828661,
0.0477025025,
0.0319428295,
-0.024486253,
-0.0214302912,
-0.0241306443,
-0.0645100474,
0.0019257559,
0.0201891232,
0.0046201916,
0.0143650649,
-0.0370396562,
-0.0035524296,
-0.0179964118,
-0.007624683,
-0.0081388857,
-0.026729092,
0.0263005141,
0.0114562903,
-0.0011290807,
0.0358029567,
0.0188357588,
-0.012344351,
0.0280489009,
0.0838194788,
-0.0093629546,
-0.0448621847,
-0.0102193076,
0.0110207917,
-0.0094744293,
-0.0310665742,
-0.0019698343,
-0.0325038135,
0.0154879652,
-0.0218268931,
-0.0047178329,
0.0350109525,
0.0397450179,
-0.0473520905,
0.0164713375,
0.0461170375,
0.014244305,
-0.0739592388,
-0.0247868355,
-0.0344916359,
-0.0103175603,
0.0479940027,
0.0004675031,
0.0108066211,
-0.0383217596,
-0.0948392302,
-0.0413734131,
0.0274301767,
-0.0778030753,
-0.0171272717,
0.080101043,
-0.0747469068,
0.0025233743,
0.0450231172,
-0.0327674374,
0.015137502,
0.0455455706,
0.002681389,
0.0361000374,
0.0187454689,
-0.000323887,
-0.0048960797,
-0.0344147235,
0.0455100015,
-0.0212691519,
0.0544334166,
-0.0089816572,
-0.0087884255,
-0.0210302565,
-0.0375411175,
-0.00311045,
-0.0651603788,
0.0453991741,
0.0531277657,
0.0311995465,
-0.0012430639,
-0.0283582043,
0.0096062981,
-0.0078269951,
0.0792665929,
-0.0356081128,
0.0209418274,
0.0940642878,
-0.0635289028,
0.0255157072,
0.0014994973,
-0.0014173373,
0.0147640323,
0.0544106252,
0.0082996842,
-0.0749783814,
-0.0141871842,
0.0434013866,
0.0291027054,
0.0132257473,
0.0622977987,
0.0077169556,
0.041122362,
0.0251868572,
-0.0101456214,
0.0054238155,
-0.001315509,
-0.0047901259,
-0.0094319265,
0.0087274574,
0.0180788469,
0.0226348881,
0.0285583474,
-0.0034300487,
0.0369711407,
0.018733805,
0.047539521,
0.0344088152,
0.0676159412,
-0.0173056293,
-0.0112423142,
0.0321999602,
-0.029557433,
0.0388422906,
-0.0113310693,
0.0210995432,
0.0278568324,
-0.016738195,
-0.0280101411,
0.0148347961,
-0.0790440217,
-0.0421100184,
0.0676656663,
0.0670059174,
-0.0363226496,
0.0073232413,
-0.0265090838,
0.0035598152,
0.0065123155,
-0.0333335623,
0.0111260079,
0.005765839,
-0.0459559187,
0.0343056694,
-0.0024783961,
0.0081184432,
0.0312582441,
0.0303133987,
-0.0368052721,
0.075428158,
-0.0004242696,
0.0122765647,
-0.0307579916,
-0.030509714,
0.0055450164,
-0.0131574487,
-0.0150066111,
-0.0576283783,
-0.1044072136,
-0.07408645,
-0.00717603,
0.0079695228,
0.0677126125,
-0.0206484236,
-0.0525867753,
0.0776139721,
0.0405239016,
-0.0325564966,
-0.059975192,
0.0412796326,
-0.0022031649,
-0.0342983939,
0.0240639374,
-5.476264145e-33,
0.0186818521,
0.0031676162,
-0.0425329246,
0.0152562354,
0.0220068656,
-0.0234632306,
-0.0295028482,
-0.0034890994,
-0.0356849432,
-0.0135090686,
-0.0242098458,
0.0132902283,
0.0139716091,
0.000983544,
-0.0526539125,
-0.0403780192,
0.0283772722,
0.0322479866,
-0.0174098704,
-0.0116456496,
0.0262610018,
-0.0140027348,
-0.0080580553,
-0.0065875463,
0.0547225103,
-0.0434937626,
-0.0305450987,
0.0398056656,
-0.0843345821,
0.0391595215,
0.0193561241,
-0.021272473,
-0.0248358119,
-0.0229311306,
0.0002431041,
0.0579643361,
0.0005932929,
0.0059418501,
0.0439401045,
-0.0372283347,
0.0174591802,
-0.0163096543,
0.0009049995,
0.0189486425,
-0.0057726842,
-0.0048513417,
-0.0096381549,
0.0090328185,
0.0115147317,
0.021986967,
-0.0293143615,
0.0024896944,
-0.017249953,
-0.0341374837,
-0.0264715217,
0.0155293951,
0.0113860434,
-0.0351860262,
-0.0269959029,
0.0512138195,
0.0782966092,
-0.0155588705,
0.000742471,
-0.0101750782,
-0.0393326357,
0.0207874514,
0.0156896971,
-0.0052514784,
-0.0103012221,
0.0114875128,
-0.0158943255,
0.0799709409,
0.0725324675,
0.0470001139,
0.0200989041,
0.0222479086,
-0.0386474282,
-0.0141317891,
0.0424982049,
0.0359417126,
0.0227602627,
-0.0244775191,
-0.0513254628,
0.0056719757,
-0.0232748818,
-0.014978149,
-0.0285588875,
-0.0222363323,
-0.0149132051,
0.0284391809,
-0.0169874001,
-0.0393529385,
-0.0149655156,
-0.0700937584,
-0.0026085116,
-0.0106436219,
0.0103968307,
-0.031413164,
-0.0279961396,
0.0224552024,
0.0046500517,
0.0098361317,
0.0011260611,
-0.0390688777,
0.0187225435,
0.0024988689,
0.0287339333,
0.0312957503,
-0.0190639663,
-0.0376695469,
-0.002631034,
0.0016824853,
-0.0186303891,
0.0234332792,
0.0604962818,
0.0276516061,
-0.0078522377,
-0.0581169948,
-0.0104469154,
0.019764604,
-0.0564140268,
0.0785961002,
-0.0027982239,
0.0415182859,
0.0250508487,
-0.0217606612,
-0.0347817801,
0.0254973844,
0.0258822162,
-0.0435001552,
-0.0133301159,
-0.0154461535,
3.013e-7,
0.0122551136,
-0.0491687059,
0.0298704337,
0.0662233755,
0.0257832631,
0.0916599631,
-0.0172551256,
0.0566450506,
0.0164183695,
-0.0125213517,
-0.0566201732,
-0.0219309833,
0.0239530914,
-0.0012088321,
-0.0643437952,
0.0061962865,
-0.0572981313,
-0.0360651501,
0.0049455613,
0.0275206733,
0.0434752814,
0.0658171847,
0.0407762006,
-0.0243832786,
-0.0211941134,
-0.0142757371,
0.0031227646,
0.0216178857,
-0.0083084302,
-0.0105834669,
0.0392838456,
-0.0004285944,
0.0482879393,
0.0223989412,
-0.0198377557,
-0.032948371,
-0.0790656358,
0.0299380347,
0.0174957942,
0.0153761394,
-0.0894231647,
-0.0695147216,
-0.0145759583,
-0.0184091609,
0.0771280006,
0.009455136,
-0.0005803232,
-0.0194576886,
-0.0071387254,
-0.0326454006,
-0.0067688799,
0.0065234439,
-0.0344332494,
-0.0066696173,
0.018138228,
0.0236143228,
0.0258407667,
-0.0390945561,
-0.0220753253,
0.0061771632,
-0.0128948977,
-0.0392971858,
0.0402701758,
0.0313098691,
0.0240148772,
-0.0312296301,
-0.0116948811,
2.873125614e-34,
0.0137236575,
-0.0389516279,
0.0164668672,
0.0157486387,
0.0113321049,
-0.0347580798,
0.0501227416,
0.01446178,
0.0078337528,
-0.0236245934,
-0.0254913829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15593v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15593v1 | News Deja Vu: Connecting Past and Present with Semantic Search | 2024-06-21T18:50:57 | 2024-06-21T18:50:57 | Brevin Franklin, Emily Silcock, Abhishek Arora, Tom Bryan, Melissa Dell | cs.CL | cs.CL, econ.GN, q-fin.EC | Social scientists and the general public often analyze contemporary events by
drawing parallels with the past, a process complicated by the vast, noisy, and
unstructured nature of historical texts. For example, hundreds of millions of
page scans from historical newspapers have been noisily transcribed.
Traditional sparse methods for searching for relevant material in these vast
corpora, e.g., with keywords, can be brittle given complex vocabularies and OCR
noise. This study introduces News Deja Vu, a novel semantic search tool that
leverages transformer large language models and a bi-encoder approach to
identify historical news articles that are most similar to modern news queries.
News Deja Vu first recognizes and masks entities, in order to focus on broader
parallels rather than the specific named entities being discussed. Then, a
contrastively trained, lightweight bi-encoder retrieves historical articles
that are most similar semantically to a modern query, illustrating how
phenomena that might seem unique to the present have varied historical
precedents. Aimed at social scientists, the user-friendly News Deja Vu package
is designed to be accessible for those who lack extensive familiarity with deep
learning. It works with large text datasets, and we show how it can be deployed
to a massive scale corpus of historical, open-source news articles. While human
expertise remains important for drawing deeper insights, News Deja Vu provides
a powerful tool for exploring parallels in how people have perceived past and
present. | [
0.0191848706,
0.1110255048,
0.0096366685,
0.0029647811,
-0.0375012495,
0.0149459476,
-0.0282627419,
0.031280756,
0.003100202,
-0.038411025,
0.0180307664,
0.0206580888,
-0.0160002448,
-0.0072947652,
-0.0528277792,
-0.0441974774,
0.0529570431,
0.054561872,
-0.0157733727,
0.013696027,
-0.0070178355,
0.0449086018,
0.0095712915,
0.0170207601,
0.0033862276,
0.0100903222,
-0.018697707,
0.0211228468,
0.0305324923,
-0.0407327861,
-0.0188333541,
0.0160317849,
0.0724846572,
0.0754038468,
0.0000020117,
-0.0270049684,
-0.0271993373,
-0.0219758134,
0.009594027,
-0.002729188,
0.0525736436,
-0.0201708544,
-0.0089240642,
-0.0182805173,
-0.0468314625,
-0.0925116315,
0.0337298065,
0.0411355682,
0.0355553627,
0.068345122,
-0.0148972748,
-0.023550272,
0.0228014775,
-0.0016378418,
0.0181678254,
-0.0222124867,
0.0412097462,
-0.03689586,
-0.0131057054,
0.0191296488,
0.0193165708,
0.0399560854,
0.0072438372,
0.0031559598,
-0.0341915935,
0.0267416369,
-0.0077724569,
0.0184004344,
0.0037596431,
0.022689363,
-0.0251563061,
-0.056099318,
0.0341594741,
0.0226651393,
-0.0440764278,
0.0606495589,
-0.0532057658,
-0.0152187329,
-0.014255669,
0.0357637741,
0.0460837819,
-0.0080576986,
0.0380648114,
0.0320041999,
-0.0398769639,
0.0462562032,
0.0306869093,
-0.0193573572,
-0.0029552693,
0.0005502656,
0.0367537104,
-0.035516005,
0.0366864577,
0.0306383837,
-0.0017503871,
0.0015724904,
-0.0243411642,
-0.0441135056,
-0.0018106702,
-0.0591808446,
-0.0305908732,
0.008988264,
-0.0388742536,
0.0718570501,
-0.008663578,
0.0122507764,
-0.0221608859,
0.0038497099,
-0.0110452082,
-0.0453407094,
-0.0530234389,
-0.0037220614,
-0.0414839387,
-0.0027639517,
-0.022144651,
-0.0316578746,
0.0152077051,
-0.0043199048,
-0.0051128888,
0.0057862294,
-0.0466213115,
0.0093124211,
-0.0044709845,
-0.0216603186,
-0.021722436,
0.0334952325,
-0.0323803946,
-0.0021099397,
-0.0230493471,
-0.0500137992,
0.0009693542,
0.0009228307,
0.0190982819,
-0.0380091183,
0.0017903991,
0.0160333887,
-0.0243662894,
0.0226441436,
-0.0686980933,
-0.0259395931,
0.0376456976,
0.010883701,
0.0220991783,
-0.0673340112,
0.0105565209,
-0.0194159765,
0.0095623871,
-0.0530582257,
0.0024910052,
0.0429848507,
-0.0528101511,
0.0626865774,
0.0441482849,
-0.0107868239,
0.0532313809,
0.0262323655,
0.0931551531,
0.0580466762,
0.0328564048,
0.0270158798,
0.0648729578,
0.0280987881,
0.0053953142,
0.0133358864,
0.0010909014,
0.0165649783,
-0.0641180798,
0.0039987098,
-0.0003430024,
0.0685669556,
0.0366341956,
0.0355161466,
-0.0179238375,
-0.0442906171,
0.0208630506,
0.0475668423,
-0.0173325147,
0.0462570898,
0.036669828,
0.0105600618,
-0.0256111287,
-0.0004173857,
0.0021304737,
0.0395699367,
-0.0052886424,
-0.0358979926,
0.0079301372,
0.0369882248,
-0.0345973261,
0.0241837725,
0.0135910753,
0.0258731339,
0.0098938495,
-0.0048975619,
0.0404955707,
0.0112721659,
-0.0847887397,
0.0479889214,
0.0388843864,
-0.0290722214,
0.0269384384,
-0.0334448926,
-0.0119128805,
0.0513854884,
0.0829901397,
-0.0331748202,
0.0440052934,
-0.016633749,
-0.0170465186,
0.0282826293,
0.0564813651,
0.0053149867,
-0.0308329258,
-0.047014147,
-0.0294604283,
-0.0054254215,
0.0393974073,
0.0029772043,
0.0160831232,
0.0767960399,
0.0068344865,
-0.0218234751,
0.0154721085,
0.048292622,
-0.0308884345,
-0.021660462,
-0.0052874186,
0.0203379914,
-0.0038102129,
0.0306003261,
0.0158277713,
0.0121462131,
0.0400727913,
-0.0336896554,
-0.0288311094,
0.0131683126,
-0.0058707916,
0.0062408573,
-0.0119135808,
-0.0919120312,
0.0007340051,
0.0971077457,
-0.0229457617,
-0.0295475051,
0.0389212258,
-0.0213671606,
0.0405399539,
-0.0291363336,
0.0113155842,
-0.053272374,
0.0141390022,
-0.0567906946,
0.0785478503,
0.0071054315,
-0.009272946,
-0.0040359716,
-0.0493362807,
0.0134317018,
-0.0076440196,
-0.047998324,
0.017120149,
-0.0013336064,
-0.0034228864,
0.0399536453,
-0.0440553278,
-0.0331824757,
-0.0210928563,
-0.0625332296,
0.0286861155,
-0.0270841029,
-0.012657322,
0.0506649651,
0.0145811671,
-0.0014940482,
0.0035615782,
-0.0181251206,
0.0137681263,
-0.0220479835,
0.0205878876,
0.0340650491,
-0.0097064842,
0.0116579328,
-0.0506455414,
-0.0212437063,
-0.0399966352,
0.0793347508,
0.0277477242,
-0.0125680221,
0.0077102082,
0.0322870053,
-0.0174260624,
0.0208381694,
-0.0270612892,
0.0185225587,
0.0127429394,
-0.0242567491,
0.0166919492,
0.0790946856,
0.0448365882,
0.0679125935,
0.0336213298,
-0.0103686582,
-0.07284493,
-0.0074275676,
-0.0659195408,
-0.0232378971,
-0.0110470355,
-0.0266913809,
0.0178375337,
0.0001913878,
0.0089293271,
0.0279799998,
-0.0116717322,
-0.0003372564,
-0.0124684134,
-0.0135720735,
-0.0315233953,
-0.0206807237,
0.0148400832,
0.0582230128,
-0.0090740304,
0.0140739819,
0.0300684664,
0.0359085687,
0.0609306209,
-0.0062708054,
-0.009120645,
-0.0435653478,
0.0803435221,
-0.0470790267,
0.006343578,
-0.0198623892,
-0.0493816733,
-0.048099529,
-0.0131909391,
0.004195652,
-0.0411781706,
0.0581259802,
-0.015572249,
0.0137044769,
0.0263815392,
-0.0331127495,
-0.0184963401,
-0.0741966069,
-0.0436886512,
-0.0053791632,
-0.0167369507,
-0.0261999331,
-0.0871242508,
0.0204505678,
0.0136330482,
0.0428686328,
0.0080153001,
-0.0235070419,
-0.0054435106,
0.0610989295,
0.055835478,
-0.0331499986,
0.0149303619,
0.0140202241,
-0.0485870987,
0.0157554038,
0.0242401101,
0.0181826018,
-0.0165971965,
-0.0151127623,
0.0499341749,
-0.0702890158,
-0.0080682412,
-0.0401374064,
-0.018830955,
-0.071463801,
-0.0133742057,
0.093464762,
0.034683682,
-0.0852007195,
-0.0039870413,
-0.0233184099,
-0.0310240909,
0.0137343798,
0.0135566499,
-0.1107369661,
-0.0037858598,
-0.0031620965,
-0.0285010431,
-0.0078483708,
-0.055468291,
0.0106475782,
-0.1098914966,
-0.0149683645,
-0.0066028065,
-0.0010595701,
-0.0185612645,
-0.0833905265,
0.0092974324,
-0.0514070541,
-0.0385316201,
0.0022767915,
-0.0089019611,
-0.0177532956,
-0.0359555595,
0.0262750443,
-0.0456249677,
0.0164079219,
-0.0476977564,
0.0045003314,
0.0335147046,
0.0745660514,
-0.0065102219,
-0.0202875715,
-0.0138510456,
-0.0337656513,
-0.0182513967,
-0.0027364166,
0.0650839955,
-0.0130059849,
-0.0120495986,
-0.0387493409,
0.0225820225,
-0.0080032367,
-0.0037861264,
-0.0067605255,
0.053655792,
-0.0412828848,
-0.0198193286,
-0.0231539309,
-0.02125757,
0.039442718,
0.0644676089,
-0.0084471786,
0.0072624898,
-0.0188855138,
-0.0133975949,
0.0796071291,
-0.0335682258,
-0.0656899586,
0.0049750777,
-0.0187423863,
-0.040413972,
-0.0551731884,
-0.0222553518,
-0.0167912189,
0.0059475624,
0.0109462393,
-0.0154843144,
0.0526892096,
-0.0410421081,
-0.1094501987,
0.0166720189,
-0.043797452,
0.006806049,
0.0104857292,
-0.0042024902,
0.0292641204,
0.0283596274,
-0.0223072693,
0.0105302297,
-0.0943845809,
-0.0001082768,
0.0226989277,
-0.0547642298,
0.0189014003,
0.0436624512,
-0.026094038,
-0.0211955011,
0.0403702296,
0.0505372807,
-0.0130604524,
-0.0398252271,
-0.0368931666,
-0.0086775506,
0.000151596,
0.0369909592,
-0.0325342342,
-0.01369223,
-0.028835278,
-0.0173967928,
-0.0525732487,
-0.0406906083,
0.0188327804,
-0.0401911661,
0.0733984336,
-0.0069315974,
-0.0192071777,
-0.0408335291,
-0.0325443931,
-0.0203571599,
0.0127740614,
0.0121788532,
-0.0043905838,
0.0215912294,
0.0040075975,
-0.0416035354,
0.0538661107,
0.0086153056,
0.0596715771,
-0.0914546251,
0.0212275479,
0.0179400649,
0.0402621217,
-0.0051565119,
0.0065991785,
-0.0110916393,
0.0555865206,
-0.0012227574,
0.0462203026,
-0.0345417149,
-0.0078437226,
0.0252810102,
0.0104641607,
0.0150981406,
-0.0088773146,
-0.0958866924,
-0.0502096936,
-0.0090608941,
-0.0046698824,
0.0869219676,
-0.0280217025,
0.0380919613,
0.0200746953,
-0.0193502847,
0.0162910968,
-0.0131088868,
0.0061623193,
-0.0271794032,
-0.0103531042,
0.0340259783,
0.002398276,
0.0636451766,
0.0551281497,
-0.0600336492,
0.0742209107,
0.0558999963,
-0.0477749258,
0.0002831653,
-0.0231805593,
0.0581257641,
0.0222475212,
-0.0115983272,
-0.0243486594,
-0.0386468843,
0.0140248127,
0.0280803107,
-0.0079572918,
-0.0226888545,
0.0093490938,
0.0327023752,
0.0492505915,
0.0021078382,
0.0241894051,
-0.0362294167,
0.0643100441,
-0.0530488789,
-0.0733006299,
-0.014285502,
-6.623386103e-33,
0.0058423616,
-0.0079001011,
0.0087480191,
-0.0491403155,
-0.0743427351,
0.005711583,
-0.0466585942,
-0.036483027,
-0.0750495866,
0.0228568558,
0.0004794213,
0.0241177585,
0.0089119868,
-0.007671739,
0.0295565538,
-0.0309683625,
0.0552674718,
0.0326983631,
0.0001384142,
0.0251745302,
0.0738087296,
0.0227381196,
0.0329273604,
-0.0707733035,
0.0006900868,
0.0065402994,
-0.0121384943,
0.0010489309,
0.0678443536,
0.0462383442,
-0.0067122872,
0.0020026448,
0.0141638964,
-0.0620857216,
0.0084790671,
0.0533569492,
-0.0807761401,
-0.0184583906,
0.0020431068,
0.0137591315,
0.0124871433,
-0.0273851585,
0.0197408926,
0.0047891699,
-0.0236111339,
-0.001712926,
0.0546938442,
-0.0062280255,
-0.0026964345,
-0.0449905768,
-0.0433249623,
0.0172142629,
-0.0328436978,
0.0176637117,
-0.0017744151,
0.0372556858,
0.0194833446,
0.0498359166,
-0.0887263268,
0.0435274541,
-0.0424952656,
0.0282142125,
0.0353979468,
-0.0212366506,
0.0058910185,
0.0802614093,
0.0127469487,
-0.020802306,
-0.0240967423,
0.0591568463,
0.0371856727,
0.0069154277,
-0.0007286274,
0.0884834751,
0.0663152784,
-0.0402064919,
-0.0563789606,
0.0445391648,
-0.0001649388,
0.0434979573,
0.0387460962,
0.0243974179,
0.021049032,
0.0148058394,
-0.0277495198,
-0.0060885539,
-0.0473099165,
0.0013071082,
-0.0116210151,
0.0070881136,
-0.0002283279,
0.0607942045,
0.018619895,
-0.0391087309,
-0.0145352175,
0.0447387695,
-0.0154098999,
0.0006887733,
-0.0064090011,
0.0252793115,
-0.0286793672,
-0.0009498745,
0.0314306542,
0.0175843351,
0.020814376,
0.0089663267,
0.0076899785,
-0.0100616403,
-0.0561516434,
-0.0138754733,
-0.0094409119,
-0.0317556448,
-0.0312117748,
-0.0389963016,
0.0046789842,
0.0275837872,
0.0130859036,
-0.0025873983,
0.0599928051,
0.0261679552,
0.0208168663,
-0.03357777,
0.0059843883,
0.0060652853,
0.004421589,
-0.0041441047,
-0.0412141532,
-0.0001716502,
0.0319743492,
-0.0679558665,
-0.016134467,
0.0106131891,
2.803e-7,
0.0322462618,
0.0405364931,
0.0289549585,
0.0271526612,
-0.0079509532,
0.017970724,
0.0399869047,
0.0655538887,
-0.0152895693,
-0.01314859,
0.023970183,
0.0037551622,
0.0302626155,
0.0197534747,
-0.0909171849,
-0.0306937173,
-0.0880648792,
-0.04155536,
-0.0737219825,
-0.0098832119,
0.0595693737,
0.0637383014,
0.0422997959,
-0.018682912,
-0.0174783524,
-0.0274520423,
0.0282550473,
-0.028955223,
-0.0488279015,
-0.003602643,
0.0040094121,
0.0142941726,
-0.0011412355,
0.0031343265,
-0.0189012792,
0.0077205254,
0.0275885239,
0.03129014,
0.0145697314,
-0.0323354118,
-0.0020622576,
-0.0128732286,
-0.030805992,
-0.069249481,
0.0827726349,
-0.0248767734,
-0.0147656128,
-0.0346767157,
-0.0644076765,
0.0489288419,
0.0567713678,
0.0067418413,
-0.0443250388,
0.0129823387,
0.0093536107,
0.0543042012,
0.0124989785,
-0.0442193933,
0.0198625028,
0.0155905485,
-0.0387827903,
0.0088848779,
-0.0113241524,
-0.0284305401,
-0.0005365381,
-0.0030823429,
0.0303194057,
2.419102171e-34,
0.0280190539,
0.0475331284,
-0.0318677388,
-0.0098763732,
0.0298041273,
0.0215008575,
-0.0431683548,
0.0024845724,
0.007010228,
-0.0659297258,
0.0046729124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15586v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15586v1 | TinyStyler: Efficient Few-Shot Text Style Transfer with Authorship Embeddings | 2024-06-21T18:41:22 | 2024-06-21T18:41:22 | Zachary Horvitz, Ajay Patel, Kanishk Singh, Chris Callison-Burch, Kathleen McKeown, Zhou Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The goal of text style transfer is to transform the style of texts while
preserving their original meaning, often with only a few examples of the target
style. Existing style transfer methods generally rely on the few-shot
capabilities of large language models or on complex controllable text
generation approaches that are inefficient and underperform on fluency metrics.
We introduce TinyStyler, a lightweight but effective approach, which leverages
a small language model (800M params) and pre-trained authorship embeddings to
perform efficient, few-shot text style transfer. We evaluate on the challenging
task of authorship style transfer and find TinyStyler outperforms strong
approaches such as GPT-4. We also evaluate TinyStyler's ability to perform text
attribute style transfer (formal $\leftrightarrow$ informal) with automatic and
human evaluations and find that the approach outperforms recent controllable
text generation methods. Our model has been made publicly available at
https://huggingface.co/tinystyler/tinystyler . | [
-0.0086592101,
0.0883503631,
-0.0001812966,
0.0129166925,
-0.0321243331,
-0.0139895743,
0.0533233844,
0.0250971206,
-0.0428626798,
-0.0054414468,
-0.0158898793,
-0.0228262246,
0.0206955578,
0.0103613082,
0.0576124564,
-0.0392467938,
-0.0220627002,
-0.0023682187,
0.0396178365,
-0.0295020081,
0.0664391294,
0.0104876012,
0.0315605141,
0.0192962233,
0.0120529924,
-0.0475649312,
0.0204740576,
0.0482687838,
0.0455039702,
0.0643477291,
0.011273494,
0.0428564996,
0.0168852545,
0.0451422073,
0.0000016927,
0.0105521912,
-0.0109148808,
-0.0026891362,
0.0795864537,
0.0242465064,
0.0910602361,
0.0187275764,
-0.0412971675,
0.0001132844,
-0.0115273111,
-0.0209631119,
0.0432532169,
0.0609433278,
0.0648075715,
0.0798282698,
-0.03748006,
-0.0555341803,
-0.0054472499,
-0.0272119269,
0.0407383181,
-0.0138831083,
0.0029845096,
-0.0328169651,
-0.0256046131,
0.0328009315,
-0.0104802176,
0.0287383497,
-0.0279246289,
-0.0201774202,
0.0299509373,
0.0077276677,
-0.0346228518,
0.0576706603,
0.0245076008,
0.0476748832,
-0.0152087575,
-0.039331995,
0.0226952471,
0.0080148689,
0.0118087744,
0.0186067373,
-0.0573014393,
-0.013853021,
0.0001761492,
-0.0045240195,
-0.0326770581,
0.0190203413,
0.0068064327,
-0.0159396715,
0.0119300392,
-0.0410154834,
0.0473014675,
-0.0143049723,
-0.0579478554,
-0.0042961063,
-0.0083814152,
-0.0456914417,
0.0258292872,
0.0007150072,
0.0463814028,
-0.0157799143,
-0.1017565876,
-0.0540277883,
-0.0171940718,
0.0002908169,
0.0792033672,
-0.0005441183,
0.0318660028,
0.0091506625,
-0.0530296154,
0.0320852473,
-0.0066694836,
0.0073221959,
0.0138604334,
-0.005429368,
-0.0600281246,
-0.011465068,
-0.0413117036,
-0.0314192437,
0.0308995508,
-0.0071143117,
-0.0014495049,
-0.0148709258,
0.0010362837,
-0.0070084198,
-0.0043863789,
0.0195236169,
-0.0404639319,
-0.0255278535,
0.0523848385,
0.0269998144,
-0.0006713254,
0.019922737,
0.0335512981,
0.0200362522,
-0.0175570045,
0.0202659499,
0.0725624189,
-0.0223723762,
-0.002161321,
-0.0124152852,
-0.0310766287,
-0.0100955926,
-0.0111749908,
-0.0144124515,
0.0113869281,
-0.0167997554,
-0.0408069864,
-0.0720050558,
-0.0039312774,
-0.0163740013,
0.0107765337,
-0.0837989748,
-0.0192461386,
0.0378558487,
-0.0440678075,
0.0369960368,
0.0041028666,
-0.0027205497,
0.023066245,
-0.0094604408,
0.0061806655,
0.0039819386,
0.0744134858,
0.0629097596,
0.0067681731,
-0.0315174945,
0.0154219884,
0.0299955867,
0.0407014191,
0.0567569062,
-0.0094213318,
-0.0717337355,
0.0182580184,
0.0567807406,
0.0683913827,
0.0591473766,
-0.0181909129,
-0.0148808975,
0.109829165,
-0.0023667887,
0.0612080619,
0.0286112018,
0.0607591756,
0.0341885313,
0.006619581,
-0.0297844745,
0.0005323336,
0.0260023046,
-0.0156824589,
-0.0090054274,
0.0131221153,
0.0451853462,
-0.0380461514,
0.0452147909,
0.0531446263,
-0.007092827,
-0.0134917619,
-0.0282460339,
0.0011912595,
0.0616806559,
-0.0400984138,
-0.0207824148,
-0.0006707722,
-0.0816854313,
0.0146576902,
0.0004146156,
-0.0003564698,
0.0894570574,
0.0436856262,
0.0373215042,
0.007699158,
-0.0198671855,
0.0272977222,
0.0214078818,
0.0088317543,
-0.004101899,
0.030163072,
-0.0544543937,
0.0143930474,
-0.0310342256,
-0.004273924,
0.0276052598,
-0.0160485115,
0.0566854104,
0.0305291247,
-0.0307298936,
-0.0227543004,
0.0299408343,
-0.0395187289,
-0.0426394381,
0.0299586412,
0.0061888127,
-0.0250773393,
-0.0183065701,
-0.0529860966,
0.0098825451,
-0.056090232,
-0.0573107153,
-0.0238039102,
0.0421196632,
-0.0205323733,
-0.0631250069,
-0.0087242424,
-0.0136334188,
0.0146116363,
0.0033919944,
-0.0563766547,
-0.0615692772,
0.0298892539,
-0.0141474558,
-0.0006217631,
-0.0226590727,
0.0002989514,
-0.0018853672,
0.0242362786,
-0.0296718311,
0.0121903354,
0.0449629351,
-0.0224547852,
-0.0214758273,
0.0282490402,
0.019959284,
-0.0005420473,
0.0007336451,
-0.0569372848,
0.0210787598,
0.0282192696,
0.0103305653,
0.0194180198,
0.0012462015,
-0.0608202815,
-0.0457259417,
0.0007231173,
0.0094065825,
0.01083575,
0.0028755316,
0.0220450126,
0.0071615921,
0.0183159504,
-0.0831341445,
0.0294573382,
-0.0601846613,
0.011963604,
0.04929398,
-0.0220718216,
-0.0135644749,
-0.0320562683,
-0.0042814594,
0.0183217209,
0.0356453992,
0.049269896,
0.0301513989,
-0.0278411414,
0.0018540107,
-0.0172793306,
-0.02413317,
0.0323199369,
-0.0572097562,
-0.0073567932,
-0.0378910936,
0.0442567021,
0.0433795899,
0.0352787413,
-0.0100312885,
-0.0065158634,
-0.0163629372,
-0.0280118622,
-0.0180625562,
0.007926017,
0.0109653147,
-0.0002590539,
-0.0444388203,
0.0259606168,
0.026809901,
0.0326328985,
-0.0118864803,
-0.1065575778,
0.0448240414,
0.0444464386,
-0.0265733004,
0.0441780947,
0.038391199,
-0.0095413513,
-0.0220325924,
-0.0350166969,
-0.0038894252,
0.0295707714,
-0.0403872207,
-0.0112119736,
0.0280486476,
0.0081976568,
-0.0250539389,
0.017792806,
0.0100408131,
0.0372036956,
0.0052324277,
-0.0091250176,
-0.065871574,
0.0310554784,
0.079811953,
-0.0078216679,
-0.0172995012,
-0.0107937856,
0.023670204,
-0.0290356036,
-0.0370678976,
0.0098661287,
-0.0693929419,
-0.0040849498,
-0.0115978383,
0.0187055543,
-0.0586475618,
-0.0082791587,
-0.0123402504,
0.0149681773,
0.0561089888,
-0.0443342812,
-0.0232108627,
-0.0068953009,
0.0386683978,
0.0342132971,
-0.037410561,
-0.0498551913,
-0.0307066031,
0.0070991772,
0.0359771103,
0.0177159477,
0.0159507543,
-0.0448592231,
-0.0076092524,
0.0087035429,
-0.0126110297,
-0.0569656938,
-0.0118675316,
0.1034805253,
-0.0540249012,
-0.0212328322,
0.1112716496,
0.002653383,
-0.0336924717,
-0.0315248296,
-0.0017048941,
0.0423636958,
-0.010505694,
0.0266248509,
-0.0822157264,
-0.0467042439,
-0.0076363636,
0.0292986389,
0.0063569364,
-0.0419261418,
-0.0214022901,
-0.0603049174,
0.0069702743,
0.0407082066,
-0.0629730746,
0.0269482881,
0.0021026365,
0.0047547771,
0.0010837993,
-0.0404734723,
-0.0093313977,
-0.0164084267,
0.0113426223,
-0.0127273668,
-0.0159949549,
-0.0212068725,
0.0283821747,
-0.0345882736,
0.0774540752,
0.0601233095,
0.0626009777,
-0.0208403151,
-0.0400239453,
-0.0342541225,
-0.0278265402,
-0.0264318902,
-0.0035728395,
0.0679313615,
-0.0218908209,
-0.0039533526,
-0.0113774771,
0.0413846672,
-0.0053547821,
0.0150678037,
0.0385622941,
0.0134013994,
0.0087241661,
-0.0571007617,
-0.0091485539,
0.0011047613,
0.0187551714,
0.0356340408,
0.0612800531,
-0.0834107101,
-0.0619716533,
-0.0469730347,
0.0147504881,
-0.0799760893,
-0.0525678135,
-0.0311091673,
-0.0173502583,
-0.047523085,
-0.1105121225,
0.0032329385,
0.0095245959,
0.0549572296,
0.017333664,
0.0099241342,
-0.0158682819,
-0.0187877119,
-0.0400160588,
-0.0490922742,
-0.0481623001,
0.0423039868,
-0.0237447377,
-0.0161566008,
0.0264059547,
-0.0377461575,
0.0299793053,
-0.007259517,
-0.0701079294,
-0.0441674851,
-0.0074333083,
0.0455824509,
0.0044777687,
0.0126164677,
-0.0386802852,
-0.1123973057,
0.0620069876,
0.056424506,
0.0033387153,
0.0335537121,
0.0448000394,
-0.0084981611,
-0.0104991999,
0.0519568212,
-0.0207342487,
0.035661988,
0.0278630257,
0.0134044001,
-0.0018274119,
0.0091363071,
-0.0091518089,
0.0120790927,
-0.0276795756,
-0.0311416294,
0.0239898842,
-0.0012413623,
-0.0131678628,
-0.0383248217,
-0.0051005315,
-0.0745030046,
-0.0288140923,
0.0289786905,
0.0348013788,
-0.0086242799,
-0.0059466562,
0.0269188862,
0.0489217304,
-0.0408474691,
-0.0077172453,
-0.0048942049,
0.0732739419,
0.00937251,
0.0181180909,
-0.0175653584,
-0.0031045608,
-0.0054323524,
0.0205954425,
-0.032181114,
0.000790898,
0.0486404262,
0.0291293468,
-0.009224508,
0.0235553123,
-0.0616395399,
0.0106008723,
-0.0164252575,
-0.0107760355,
0.0089418292,
0.0218251925,
0.1097661555,
-0.000233923,
0.0019126238,
-0.0217683259,
0.0619876757,
-0.0045666965,
-0.0077336207,
-0.031288296,
-0.0093747228,
0.0068411757,
-0.0093764029,
0.0819011256,
0.0192797855,
0.013964464,
-0.0087222951,
0.005945222,
-0.0038547097,
0.0031987075,
0.0375648439,
-0.0089552021,
0.0542824902,
-0.012743081,
-0.0298609622,
-0.0293876342,
0.0445732549,
-0.0443988368,
-0.0007036401,
0.0061956821,
0.0117583517,
0.0231420696,
-0.0299529359,
0.0147603285,
-0.0519572943,
0.021914782,
0.0291517768,
-0.0358979218,
0.0344292484,
-5.341192864e-33,
-0.028964784,
-0.0027688527,
-0.0142822955,
0.0433869883,
-0.0327385701,
-0.0185049046,
-0.0681830198,
-0.0503300875,
0.0191579685,
0.0367266797,
-0.0298930984,
-0.0074628689,
-0.0065506217,
0.051985871,
0.0403324664,
0.0556646548,
0.0786024332,
0.0081854174,
-0.0412693955,
0.079457216,
0.0622780845,
0.0049170377,
0.0387926623,
-0.0531691946,
-0.0447215065,
-0.0124827838,
-0.0483484305,
-0.0372686945,
0.0356163159,
-0.0179564022,
0.0199406371,
0.0132108992,
-0.0072873058,
-0.0077787172,
-0.0252711512,
-0.0048316433,
-0.0624100193,
-0.0501587614,
-0.0143138273,
0.0075068409,
-0.0041060383,
-0.0476914719,
0.0440275818,
-0.0381862,
0.0472736135,
-0.0307629965,
0.0565326326,
-0.0060624806,
-0.0209060162,
-0.0831671283,
-0.0688221306,
0.0235219933,
-0.0089545269,
-0.0210801288,
0.0271308161,
-0.0097186463,
-0.0062309061,
-0.004983813,
-0.0558668636,
0.0078382054,
-0.0245631076,
0.0071036532,
-0.0309294593,
0.041414611,
0.0215614121,
0.0439744331,
-0.0164315291,
0.0528357662,
-0.0312044006,
0.0413527228,
0.0458828472,
0.0356409363,
0.02205454,
0.0964579284,
0.001361647,
-0.0333557464,
-0.0038658162,
0.0429924391,
0.0316084772,
-0.0164583512,
0.0100938845,
0.0540225431,
-0.0010207141,
-0.0246749744,
-0.0343618318,
-0.0431287698,
-0.0127426265,
-0.0170096513,
-0.0065410081,
0.0003529632,
-0.0458044298,
-0.0089423005,
0.0326775126,
-0.036395207,
-0.043858327,
-0.0165810138,
-0.0713467151,
0.0539488271,
-0.0302948207,
-0.0089385575,
-0.0350857154,
-0.0207515489,
0.0591574237,
0.018523721,
0.0005072902,
0.0142437061,
0.0841891691,
0.0386278778,
-0.0746457502,
-0.0447797664,
-0.0071100714,
0.0153962858,
0.0149648739,
-0.0352303348,
-0.0184749626,
0.006743391,
-0.0152951526,
0.0079048658,
0.0366030522,
-0.0131403524,
0.0111267576,
-0.0199516602,
0.0153522035,
-0.0171547253,
-0.0689339787,
-0.0151238088,
-0.0299959555,
-0.0438097455,
0.0145344418,
-0.0514222868,
-0.0249958765,
-0.0429245383,
2.408e-7,
0.0194620676,
0.0110502895,
0.0105056558,
-0.0078397011,
0.0128601054,
0.0499384962,
0.0213524792,
0.0644226745,
-0.0048220768,
0.0248560384,
0.0291657783,
0.0297710318,
0.0942264125,
-0.0101938071,
-0.0681829229,
0.0172736831,
-0.0276591778,
0.0188381933,
-0.0212568697,
-0.0299898926,
0.0522066168,
0.0089675803,
0.0578139834,
-0.0162614267,
0.0470038801,
-0.0354246981,
0.1077501625,
0.0147476057,
0.0210927073,
0.024663968,
0.0342539363,
-0.0576001815,
-0.0352726206,
-0.02081999,
-0.0147369597,
-0.0169357583,
0.024110904,
0.0644811019,
-0.0101619139,
0.0481767803,
-0.0153826596,
-0.0254681148,
0.0103061385,
-0.0323191322,
0.0509440452,
-0.0074910927,
-0.0295133498,
-0.0254850239,
-0.0606967658,
-0.0000884587,
0.0083552655,
-0.005238594,
-0.0489950143,
0.0134251509,
0.0253036283,
0.0081325695,
-0.0416667536,
-0.0645884722,
-0.0140310517,
-0.0149056967,
-0.0189571157,
-0.0095845023,
-0.0347192436,
0.0126064979,
0.0182307698,
-0.0496351682,
0.0245236009,
2.052991241e-34,
0.0313661471,
-0.0382329188,
0.0138158528,
0.0030634224,
0.0181408282,
0.0029395237,
0.0292428751,
0.0197372176,
0.0289610904,
-0.0705752745,
-0.0116909808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15583v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15583v1 | Detecting AI-Generated Text: Factors Influencing Detectability with Current Methods | 2024-06-21T18:31:49 | 2024-06-21T18:31:49 | Kathleen C. Fraser, Hillary Dawkins, Svetlana Kiritchenko | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Large language models (LLMs) have advanced to a point that even humans have
difficulty discerning whether a text was generated by another human, or by a
computer. However, knowing whether a text was produced by human or artificial
intelligence (AI) is important to determining its trustworthiness, and has
applications in many domains including detecting fraud and academic dishonesty,
as well as combating the spread of misinformation and political propaganda. The
task of AI-generated text (AIGT) detection is therefore both very challenging,
and highly critical. In this survey, we summarize state-of-the art approaches
to AIGT detection, including watermarking, statistical and stylistic analysis,
and machine learning classification. We also provide information about existing
datasets for this task. Synthesizing the research findings, we aim to provide
insight into the salient factors that combine to determine how "detectable"
AIGT text is under different scenarios, and to make practical recommendations
for future work towards this significant technical and societal challenge. | [
0.07120803,
0.0498548076,
-0.0353716053,
0.0460120142,
-0.0618922487,
0.0120125385,
0.0354045667,
0.0393895544,
0.0324912556,
-0.0202845708,
-0.009746802,
0.0081011076,
0.0214920826,
0.0439765453,
0.0255296621,
0.0373336822,
0.009184191,
0.0147929313,
0.0601010956,
0.0090325736,
0.0248307809,
0.0328057371,
0.0241214223,
0.0326660611,
-0.0434392989,
-0.0311207753,
0.0070343991,
0.0152812283,
0.0055615203,
-0.0025937103,
-0.0111813918,
0.0522328541,
-0.0112086516,
0.1127424687,
0.0000017414,
-0.0248311199,
-0.0263765156,
0.0000284692,
-0.0444093235,
0.0287670903,
0.0762385726,
-0.0095043723,
-0.0267453939,
0.0157614443,
-0.0594411418,
0.0683246478,
0.0179635752,
0.0359059945,
0.0437749326,
0.0834441632,
-0.0436291955,
0.0129179182,
0.0634271353,
0.0208558682,
0.0022619546,
-0.0067091794,
0.0331385657,
-0.0174469836,
-0.0408656783,
0.0303685442,
0.0246212818,
0.0390703343,
-0.0001320783,
-0.0544812083,
-0.0269028861,
-0.001494403,
-0.0200341064,
-0.0188796893,
-0.0210385248,
0.0053985128,
-0.0357895531,
-0.0574202053,
0.0386198536,
-0.0137756821,
0.0137746828,
0.0324186943,
0.0208693482,
0.0477167964,
-0.0285076518,
0.0112170251,
0.0259839632,
-0.0068652863,
0.0202131495,
0.0480633043,
0.0219360869,
0.0465092771,
0.002076383,
-0.0406961963,
-0.0461839959,
-0.0124380412,
0.0052696955,
-0.0333632641,
0.0605405457,
0.0104966164,
0.041536063,
-0.0050464668,
-0.0968860835,
-0.0857498646,
0.0225647595,
-0.039347861,
0.0489180945,
-0.0150958989,
-0.0078216111,
0.041041214,
-0.0370081142,
0.0757353753,
-0.0205676761,
0.0290125757,
0.0118167344,
0.0183420591,
-0.0008291369,
-0.0345805436,
-0.0232825205,
-0.0103407633,
-0.006091231,
-0.0229358245,
-0.0331321433,
0.0129785025,
-0.0212901141,
0.0358982608,
-0.0394529402,
-0.0378352739,
-0.0117019881,
-0.0044695628,
0.0215827525,
-0.0365765616,
0.028535774,
0.0487495176,
-0.0114699937,
-0.0328076184,
0.006227491,
0.0777935907,
0.0132777672,
0.0129438266,
0.0068481602,
0.0504496545,
-0.0039648148,
-0.0416837856,
-0.0325746909,
-0.0528839864,
-0.0471304953,
-0.0346234366,
0.0209104531,
-0.0314510576,
-0.0332476161,
-0.0383609496,
-0.0191025846,
-0.0655013174,
-0.0115476418,
0.0311810356,
-0.0108834086,
0.0385889821,
-0.0149536477,
-0.0037842146,
0.051521495,
-0.0131407483,
-0.0065434375,
0.0203999355,
0.0549208708,
0.0879568234,
0.0835213736,
0.0229514297,
0.0442013852,
0.0546744093,
0.0257191323,
0.0151565252,
0.0046133311,
-0.0409374759,
-0.0242982805,
-0.0197968613,
0.0200426579,
0.0454509631,
0.0166710857,
-0.0649325252,
0.0820795223,
0.0704266354,
-0.0246560853,
-0.0089120502,
0.0391376913,
0.0427036658,
0.0380779244,
0.0272351298,
0.0128215021,
-0.0276980307,
-0.0376434773,
-0.0496283285,
-0.009440056,
0.0084039681,
0.0039332416,
-0.0485402271,
-0.0137836691,
-0.0394476131,
0.0135823321,
-0.0408638008,
0.0441658422,
0.014268185,
-0.0381672196,
-0.0896289349,
-0.0243889317,
-0.0312987939,
0.0035105473,
-0.0892829672,
0.0792197064,
0.0743707493,
0.0574749522,
-0.0264334548,
0.0997262076,
-0.0253202822,
-0.0066459738,
0.0515393987,
-0.0291157812,
-0.0130540896,
-0.0268254001,
-0.0112735052,
-0.0082648993,
-0.015655987,
0.0120360125,
0.0229937416,
0.0305282567,
0.0254555475,
0.0138539206,
-0.0093410341,
-0.0538790636,
0.0410363488,
-0.0041448497,
-0.0107106157,
0.0111647658,
0.0098851128,
0.0160375796,
0.0202603787,
-0.0335018523,
0.0072465814,
0.0331158489,
-0.0311056953,
-0.0512237102,
-0.0298905279,
0.0325780064,
0.0189899951,
0.0053266301,
-0.0377701372,
-0.0219959412,
0.0452775173,
-0.0116824368,
0.0075053084,
0.0129753416,
-0.0622671135,
-0.0160650648,
-0.0714857206,
0.0204743724,
-0.0175583102,
0.0395045988,
-0.0199766327,
0.0488435403,
-0.0273846686,
-0.0400962383,
-0.010016026,
0.0021380575,
0.0433360934,
-0.0116040381,
0.0115364445,
-0.013734946,
-0.0372918956,
0.0263466835,
0.014171157,
0.0034878289,
-0.0000647235,
-0.0190864727,
-0.0385458097,
-0.0293906201,
-0.0272543598,
0.0185124725,
0.0116928928,
-0.0502683297,
0.0001851923,
0.0182324871,
-0.0094585801,
-0.0242079981,
0.0334143713,
0.0022953125,
0.046952527,
-0.0439331792,
0.0132135954,
-0.0300880484,
0.0064928136,
-0.012575807,
0.0455855392,
0.0697551072,
-0.0565471649,
-0.0533535033,
0.0290971473,
0.0006415127,
-0.023391895,
-0.0148969581,
-0.0245711282,
-0.0167841502,
-0.0058598961,
-0.0060759564,
0.0917677358,
0.0322275907,
0.0325089321,
0.0138116097,
0.0713674501,
0.004532903,
-0.0367347524,
-0.0127376597,
0.0428049602,
0.0006176907,
-0.0523304828,
0.0576958507,
0.0220986195,
0.0053969319,
0.0086529059,
0.0194181111,
0.056967251,
-0.0195750091,
-0.0324583128,
0.0071607684,
-0.0498104244,
-0.0172327887,
0.0438673981,
-0.032221429,
-0.0786768198,
0.0180776417,
-0.0530817956,
0.0421955101,
-0.0215581637,
-0.0249616206,
-0.0010228887,
0.0021819016,
0.0163359698,
0.0358237512,
-0.0035587691,
0.0064215674,
0.0003459801,
0.0161756538,
0.0507136881,
-0.0248003732,
-0.0094936909,
-0.0127114933,
0.0085009467,
0.0213188343,
0.0139979385,
-0.0431022346,
-0.0661389977,
0.0019988122,
-0.0150931366,
0.0439549685,
-0.0638812035,
-0.0203939434,
-0.0269070473,
0.0376542099,
0.0590485483,
-0.024690615,
-0.0016950177,
-0.027925035,
0.0922765583,
0.0208248459,
-0.0599043556,
0.0205774456,
-0.0287301168,
-0.0230563506,
0.0576695763,
-0.0080076419,
0.0340650789,
0.0081254663,
-0.0288875941,
-0.0047849151,
0.0233145636,
-0.0048641404,
0.0071910606,
-0.0023014823,
-0.0371908471,
0.0090585742,
0.0821142346,
0.0324979275,
-0.0261782538,
-0.0110357255,
-0.0074114157,
-0.022416003,
-0.0034715559,
-0.0083602397,
-0.0757377446,
-0.0012575526,
0.0172209162,
-0.0021855021,
-0.0724130198,
0.009856442,
-0.0199548136,
-0.0540944561,
0.0534680821,
-0.0006953339,
-0.0004418484,
-0.0311176013,
-0.0591733381,
-0.0288197864,
0.0371112227,
-0.0147000039,
-0.0789998844,
0.0205932539,
-0.0205091871,
-0.0098087396,
-0.0611090735,
-0.0324950144,
-0.0205806885,
0.0008160691,
0.0249601491,
0.0836192295,
0.0722637028,
-0.0409125313,
-0.0541534275,
-0.002806054,
0.0202959888,
-0.0153159183,
-0.0117737697,
0.0921266824,
-0.0169695895,
-0.0073110908,
-0.0098302551,
0.0524346009,
0.0019651379,
0.0006113024,
0.0272776037,
0.0389081128,
-0.0175175983,
-0.042473942,
-0.035355188,
-0.0150026875,
0.0418813564,
0.0506115481,
0.0125921918,
-0.0616960451,
-0.0484551303,
-0.0436851531,
0.0521025918,
-0.0459984131,
-0.0256368369,
0.0183808822,
-0.006492612,
-0.0421768501,
-0.0884971544,
-0.0100263441,
-0.0531418286,
-0.016813511,
0.0191617757,
0.0095369127,
0.0220612586,
-0.0241900347,
-0.0598168001,
-0.0398808792,
-0.0523276217,
0.0496271811,
-0.0365107991,
-0.0140742129,
-0.0411328226,
-0.0542331263,
-0.0102627324,
0.0317085236,
-0.0500109121,
-0.0178726427,
0.0212120414,
-0.0167693589,
0.0195296779,
-0.0041712774,
-0.0274575148,
-0.0238476992,
0.0775776505,
0.0326101184,
-0.0241839755,
0.0103364233,
0.0366895758,
-0.0200017933,
-0.0185560156,
0.0065090684,
-0.0160315111,
0.0413579196,
0.0372090004,
-0.0707063302,
-0.0398436934,
0.0033200304,
0.0151308337,
0.0378387272,
0.011365396,
-0.0102569563,
0.0144159971,
-0.0324164331,
-0.0418248959,
-0.0192054417,
-0.0175342076,
-0.0286361016,
-0.0097510489,
0.0347050279,
0.0052313367,
0.0007696408,
0.0154390996,
-0.0342880674,
0.0018447917,
-0.012866579,
-0.0097530661,
-0.0098227495,
0.10140118,
-0.022539895,
0.0160829388,
0.0214435104,
0.0792618096,
-0.0227735862,
0.0124796517,
0.0239800401,
0.0323940516,
0.0129303271,
-0.0224940106,
0.0086153513,
0.0490826517,
-0.064449802,
0.024752697,
-0.032395523,
0.0179279093,
0.0248910561,
-0.0155640822,
0.0248072278,
-0.0365111306,
-0.003191886,
-0.0321556292,
0.027648842,
0.0269283671,
-0.0245018806,
-0.0651639849,
-0.0106979962,
-0.0425790101,
0.0461012125,
0.0597190298,
0.0369666032,
0.0222387388,
-0.0010378187,
-0.0516117364,
-0.0271124076,
-0.0315802731,
0.0316667072,
-0.0087947818,
0.0029664398,
0.0091565177,
-0.0451333337,
-0.0513705723,
0.0374077596,
0.0059722485,
0.0343818367,
-0.0100929551,
-0.0440833941,
0.0754684135,
-0.0222529694,
0.0258537903,
-0.0589584634,
-0.0034204319,
-0.0112616206,
-0.0194240622,
-0.019730147,
-4.640983205e-33,
0.0278359186,
-0.1058330461,
-0.0325035527,
0.0317208394,
0.0292794704,
0.0753362775,
-0.005157623,
-0.0393803194,
-0.0126748933,
0.0323161595,
-0.0104799904,
0.0329866484,
-0.007716604,
0.0072685853,
-0.0380368717,
0.0133996606,
0.0293428022,
-0.0281589925,
-0.0454543792,
0.0205816701,
0.0352208652,
-0.0315049887,
-0.0039281691,
-0.0834769905,
0.0303331781,
-0.0304962024,
-0.0560949445,
-0.0171166174,
-0.0502414219,
0.0550301895,
-0.0288945474,
0.0201804005,
0.0315725245,
0.0148879057,
-0.0210998859,
0.0525106154,
-0.0067652231,
-0.0111511489,
-0.0500872619,
0.02054126,
-0.0273703989,
-0.0663980842,
0.022473393,
-0.0268393494,
-0.0225903336,
0.0190950651,
0.0575395674,
-0.0202600975,
0.0024295186,
-0.0372315645,
-0.0523095988,
0.0287644118,
-0.0041276142,
0.0156519599,
0.0390558466,
0.043155212,
0.0315304399,
0.0335476808,
-0.0816047713,
0.0288040955,
-0.0199482813,
-0.0365086086,
0.0229396541,
-0.0320889316,
-0.0180706549,
0.0329747014,
0.0293360408,
0.027388528,
-0.0156646334,
-0.0275553633,
0.0124679664,
0.0022362093,
0.0977167711,
0.0688451007,
0.0164126679,
-0.0455458537,
-0.0326212943,
0.0290139094,
0.0033634882,
-0.0340131223,
0.0283793285,
-0.0372433476,
-0.0654084533,
0.0071667959,
-0.01659826,
-0.0866625533,
-0.0204621553,
0.0087890048,
0.0125465663,
0.0161749348,
-0.0306708869,
-0.0109387161,
0.0034306394,
-0.0621436909,
0.0095543144,
0.0120871812,
-0.0382877626,
0.036556188,
0.0208893437,
0.0549153462,
-0.0196424965,
0.0006826377,
0.035301622,
0.0022155549,
0.0328651145,
-0.0199079886,
0.0722292662,
0.0268798042,
-0.0442025624,
0.0131104533,
0.0096967174,
0.0253459848,
0.0329361483,
0.0034877614,
-0.0065990514,
-0.0285062604,
0.0084903054,
-0.0085269772,
0.0176547971,
0.0111189224,
-0.0168515202,
-0.0288813934,
-0.0456125513,
0.0053065317,
-0.0277301669,
-0.0228357296,
-0.0312723294,
0.0225809813,
0.0183201898,
-0.0530800335,
0.0194442198,
-0.0389314964,
2.283e-7,
0.0182737205,
0.0444738902,
0.0324567109,
-0.001528666,
0.047608301,
0.0418183804,
0.0342719108,
0.0000359647,
-0.0434683897,
0.0003706802,
-0.0155292107,
0.0123059424,
0.068889536,
-0.0183692724,
-0.0320494473,
0.02773639,
-0.0576312169,
0.0211128443,
-0.06246363,
0.0224035289,
0.0552859493,
0.0559327193,
0.039333079,
-0.0635752082,
-0.010450094,
-0.07564459,
0.0230277926,
0.0016309688,
0.0222397782,
0.0012202086,
0.0384364985,
-0.0031136558,
0.0151160527,
0.0435521565,
-0.0320009179,
-0.0001854052,
0.0127014248,
0.070210807,
0.0016727679,
0.0510345139,
-0.0175491963,
-0.0112574464,
-0.0015119456,
-0.0446704477,
0.0625201017,
0.0394805372,
-0.0177655257,
-0.0556120537,
-0.0126592452,
-0.0571236424,
0.0346080139,
-0.0259976853,
0.0021136543,
0.0256913453,
0.009692925,
0.0195859969,
0.0074661006,
-0.0371919572,
0.0054787709,
-0.0567992106,
-0.0231180415,
0.0240909234,
-0.0618719757,
0.0133502875,
0.0612828024,
-0.0523903631,
0.0507680364,
2.248298939e-34,
0.0173088703,
-0.0517741293,
-0.0070184912,
0.0124306744,
0.0440289304,
0.0236426778,
-0.0090996344,
0.0079146223,
0.0066146292,
-0.0329236686,
0.0370743461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15576v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15576v1 | Contrastive Entity Coreference and Disambiguation for Historical Texts | 2024-06-21T18:22:14 | 2024-06-21T18:22:14 | Abhishek Arora, Emily Silcock, Leander Heldring, Melissa Dell | cs.CL | cs.CL, econ.GN, q-fin.EC | Massive-scale historical document collections are crucial for social science
research. Despite increasing digitization, these documents typically lack
unique cross-document identifiers for individuals mentioned within the texts,
as well as individual identifiers from external knowledgebases like
Wikipedia/Wikidata. Existing entity disambiguation methods often fall short in
accuracy for historical documents, which are replete with individuals not
remembered in contemporary knowledgebases. This study makes three key
contributions to improve cross-document coreference resolution and
disambiguation in historical texts: a massive-scale training dataset replete
with hard negatives - that sources over 190 million entity pairs from Wikipedia
contexts and disambiguation pages - high-quality evaluation data from
hand-labeled historical newswire articles, and trained models evaluated on this
historical benchmark. We contrastively train bi-encoder models for
coreferencing and disambiguating individuals in historical texts, achieving
accurate, scalable performance that identifies out-of-knowledgebase
individuals. Our approach significantly surpasses other entity disambiguation
models on our historical newswire benchmark. Our models also demonstrate
competitive performance on modern entity disambiguation benchmarks,
particularly certain news disambiguation datasets. | [
0.0110921431,
0.0295846332,
0.0118013583,
0.0296582971,
-0.0007458918,
0.0579630882,
0.001459677,
-0.0131113771,
0.0340427235,
-0.029351376,
0.0102259172,
0.0177211426,
0.008866014,
-0.0825293213,
-0.0000846385,
-0.0331966691,
0.0506464355,
0.030847393,
-0.0052327998,
-0.0172697548,
-0.0174491554,
0.0268468354,
-0.0277869012,
-0.0369735695,
-0.0176435374,
-0.025609998,
-0.006126726,
0.0227668397,
0.0658723488,
-0.0023376455,
0.0133777102,
0.0434054807,
0.0093036657,
0.0431561768,
0.0000017054,
-0.0418508798,
-0.0176849272,
0.0169008039,
-0.0461276509,
0.0239888355,
-0.0166652147,
-0.047736764,
0.0046737101,
-0.0267577507,
0.0182386972,
-0.031507574,
0.0152993342,
0.0365145281,
0.0529630557,
0.0549947545,
-0.0057443441,
-0.0502541959,
0.0274696071,
-0.018668782,
-0.0322965235,
-0.029533891,
0.0306979083,
-0.0034298541,
-0.0730747059,
-0.0007315766,
-0.0016270803,
0.0531397946,
0.0102696298,
0.0445146114,
0.0094894879,
0.0095037976,
-0.0407372899,
0.0136743775,
0.0362539776,
0.0429839753,
0.0338456035,
-0.0086979773,
0.0707703754,
0.0226442944,
-0.0413224623,
0.0386486314,
-0.0000488638,
-0.0144051863,
-0.0390772633,
-0.0003746852,
0.0109224468,
-0.0372862779,
0.0243824795,
0.0226087924,
-0.0330507196,
0.013706102,
0.0278475918,
-0.015862111,
0.0404496901,
0.0376525335,
-0.0184053835,
-0.0121195978,
0.0528223477,
-0.0053017251,
-0.0164031889,
0.0036042146,
-0.04123744,
-0.0170640461,
-0.0212623253,
-0.0781371817,
-0.0647606179,
-0.0097315134,
-0.0010850881,
0.0677772462,
-0.0136582088,
0.0291490778,
-0.0183305442,
0.0213050228,
0.0307816863,
-0.0568245612,
-0.0748752952,
0.0398386195,
-0.0329310521,
0.0319410414,
-0.0139768422,
0.0100947917,
-0.0404628105,
-0.051313974,
-0.0148472078,
0.035577666,
0.0095588611,
-0.0282228608,
-0.0338208303,
-0.0069789775,
-0.0344483629,
0.0323140845,
-0.0522833839,
-0.0127876149,
-0.052166298,
-0.0080840252,
-0.0037560121,
-0.0041014948,
0.0150429448,
-0.0871163681,
0.0191055033,
-0.0013088644,
-0.0015872507,
-0.0141481757,
-0.0519882888,
-0.0351023898,
0.0123941246,
-0.0384606943,
-0.0249934904,
-0.0603324026,
0.0311907232,
0.0154656721,
0.0005159416,
-0.1112579554,
0.0022249692,
-0.019703038,
-0.0735232979,
0.0592470802,
-0.0146995829,
-0.0084142135,
0.0495351069,
-0.005922005,
0.0351907387,
0.0558194853,
0.0728975013,
-0.0120721525,
0.056317538,
0.0450744629,
-0.0370541774,
0.0235446878,
0.0438961796,
-0.0013513931,
0.0287116077,
-0.0129440874,
-0.0195063259,
0.0287277028,
0.0550311171,
0.0627443492,
-0.0230160896,
-0.0287626944,
0.0140076466,
-0.0016563595,
-0.0202113204,
0.0069281207,
0.0196854714,
0.0178089682,
0.0162833016,
-0.0015805999,
-0.0408520252,
0.0053409678,
0.0298774373,
-0.0058418931,
0.0417289957,
0.0296782907,
-0.0278457198,
0.0306245089,
0.0265099164,
-0.0184120405,
0.0241363365,
0.002907027,
0.0695292354,
-0.004735704,
-0.0445734486,
0.0902435258,
0.0311941411,
-0.0687636957,
0.0319621377,
0.0162336603,
-0.0501437597,
0.0554359518,
0.0396810845,
0.0034655223,
-0.0026850333,
-0.0254515074,
0.0090804817,
0.0339339077,
0.0244449154,
-0.0561762527,
0.0623892136,
-0.0331459269,
-0.0381801389,
0.0088250935,
0.0038165501,
0.0011264042,
0.0761905313,
0.0649352893,
0.0499932058,
-0.0576743707,
0.0208781324,
0.0404203646,
-0.0719326288,
-0.0191729721,
-0.0333805941,
0.0516392812,
-0.0252422597,
0.0628644004,
-0.0052262163,
-0.0589816682,
0.0153362695,
-0.0184255354,
0.0254041124,
-0.0219036657,
0.0226394106,
-0.0298151113,
0.0138289863,
-0.0358280726,
-0.029345125,
0.0421767943,
-0.0193050466,
-0.0450764969,
0.0155508453,
-0.0215728413,
0.0230704322,
0.0003727784,
0.0148665598,
-0.0147575513,
0.0012984041,
-0.0151465554,
0.0737587065,
0.0001522746,
-0.0055462709,
0.0116898734,
-0.0073586083,
0.0068929996,
-0.023463415,
-0.0500358045,
-0.0157704856,
0.0231329557,
-0.0006912213,
0.0244541317,
-0.0388787463,
-0.0613991208,
-0.0242712703,
-0.0401706062,
0.0306672975,
-0.0357990488,
0.0285507385,
0.0004087051,
0.0219445322,
0.0191566143,
0.0076929536,
0.0328811482,
-0.0247928631,
-0.0314428471,
0.0190808512,
0.0329941884,
0.018622458,
-0.0090595931,
-0.0129762599,
-0.0133697046,
-0.0161148366,
0.0337852612,
0.00368884,
-0.0610051304,
-0.0037587087,
0.0547289103,
-0.0447356142,
0.0213509146,
-0.01165195,
0.0233872253,
0.0116214762,
0.017671179,
0.0093515366,
0.0502551347,
-0.0367796756,
0.0335283168,
-0.031229848,
-0.0566740744,
-0.0494000837,
0.0214024745,
-0.0011580639,
0.0091024693,
-0.0280432869,
-0.0215523727,
-0.0270253029,
0.0338322744,
-0.0109091904,
0.0035655147,
-0.0182116795,
-0.0002871458,
0.0029306496,
-0.0026491042,
0.028226262,
-0.0113837263,
0.0090480307,
0.0475166067,
-0.0370710716,
0.0350495316,
0.0400708057,
0.0038547609,
0.0446905531,
-0.0023205772,
0.0077669546,
-0.0235866904,
0.0546939075,
-0.0183149185,
0.0062318291,
0.0311862547,
-0.0577052794,
-0.0256762579,
-0.0049510216,
0.0458088405,
-0.0268965717,
0.0689720884,
-0.030981496,
0.0498158075,
0.0045005782,
-0.0154935075,
-0.0332528129,
0.0036881769,
-0.0147904521,
-0.0042876024,
0.0152000645,
0.0095556043,
-0.0318810716,
0.0172921401,
0.0258616935,
0.0205293316,
0.0224244334,
0.0005783115,
-0.0279125255,
0.0459836572,
0.0141019756,
-0.0129546346,
0.0198181197,
-0.0232630372,
-0.0059112529,
0.0051059644,
0.0209674854,
-0.0288355593,
0.0178040452,
-0.0157265533,
0.0146202641,
-0.0841715634,
-0.0421724543,
-0.0462491922,
0.0522644967,
-0.0371498987,
-0.0233343635,
0.1040102765,
0.0342284031,
-0.0685092062,
-0.0223732516,
0.0353639275,
-0.0395833813,
0.0051021655,
-0.0136635145,
-0.0518273376,
0.0004647042,
0.000481626,
0.0013424184,
0.0242755022,
-0.0926607549,
0.0105090039,
-0.1111055911,
-0.0265515018,
0.0017938153,
-0.0263256188,
-0.0488816127,
-0.0680132136,
0.0137873692,
-0.0724974051,
-0.0103121456,
0.0115483087,
0.0077427817,
0.02542831,
-0.0192113221,
0.0152296238,
-0.0415746979,
-0.0130972685,
-0.0929628909,
0.016669035,
0.0182679538,
0.0583774038,
0.0151908826,
0.0405395813,
-0.0109501276,
-0.083862029,
-0.0629983842,
-0.0069013662,
0.1123424545,
-0.033708673,
-0.0165706929,
-0.0282374974,
0.0111104362,
0.0225347355,
-0.0112107489,
0.0152165154,
0.008094877,
0.0258109644,
0.03145108,
0.0268356167,
-0.0181487557,
0.0375170931,
0.0403251983,
-0.0077521582,
0.0075408476,
-0.0258417614,
-0.0126300864,
0.0635463446,
-0.0407334045,
-0.013130324,
-0.0069909962,
-0.0612715222,
-0.0166569278,
-0.0598440766,
-0.0678737015,
0.0222730711,
0.0166705921,
0.0141933933,
0.0103876386,
0.0499542505,
-0.0047639739,
-0.0689721555,
0.0137931798,
-0.0704778433,
0.0144290533,
-0.0078363474,
-0.0207415204,
0.0454084948,
0.057798937,
-0.0111569539,
0.0562456883,
-0.0706582963,
-0.0353385881,
0.015006558,
-0.0377797596,
0.019241007,
0.0946266353,
-0.0378974155,
-0.0204102807,
0.0187456664,
0.0260853264,
-0.0520999506,
0.0091099599,
-0.0165213607,
0.028808333,
-0.0212763697,
0.046416413,
-0.0607514903,
0.01852322,
-0.0007838246,
0.0062126722,
-0.0560563393,
-0.0375964642,
-0.0414134189,
0.0204411596,
0.0295304395,
-0.0097144041,
0.019562209,
-0.0176367238,
0.0093327696,
-0.0371249281,
0.0092000365,
0.0320663564,
0.001493825,
-0.0002925431,
0.0062817568,
-0.0120736482,
0.0881440938,
0.0291772,
0.0313156098,
-0.0646299645,
-0.0276912283,
0.0221892875,
0.041784402,
-0.0334298164,
-0.022328157,
-0.0009350764,
0.0177060608,
0.0781085491,
0.0744620934,
-0.0328726247,
-0.0086252009,
-0.0231487732,
0.0291481484,
-0.0147694778,
-0.0401370898,
-0.0692680478,
0.0027297332,
-0.0310272705,
0.0041529322,
0.046026919,
0.0078712162,
0.1142358556,
0.0294061676,
-0.0355287567,
0.0207698811,
0.0181097407,
-0.0121194171,
0.0348998234,
-0.0249207634,
0.0096959937,
0.0021942034,
0.0747278854,
0.0427029692,
-0.0033539576,
0.0456867516,
0.0145298438,
-0.0318967775,
-0.0361396857,
-0.0385815315,
-0.0484992266,
-0.0433014743,
0.0143040763,
-0.0213455688,
-0.0605282262,
-0.0097584464,
0.0545009747,
-0.0174567308,
-0.0093029961,
0.0045802449,
0.0144075602,
-0.0039605647,
0.0175340381,
-0.0202748291,
-0.0394180976,
0.017261304,
-0.0201336946,
-0.0556768216,
-0.0180337727,
-5.411727301e-33,
-0.0599232204,
0.0219948944,
0.0126261655,
-0.0606308915,
-0.0650076345,
-0.0014896187,
-0.0182389766,
-0.0379341915,
-0.0449166857,
-0.0143614849,
-0.0139199598,
0.0313053951,
0.0281737261,
-0.0027175327,
-0.016789224,
-0.0247301944,
0.0708986223,
0.0221512672,
-0.0274156388,
0.0593761057,
0.058330819,
0.0208884757,
0.0544025488,
-0.0924312994,
0.0575202815,
-0.0102124214,
-0.0193020608,
-0.0035522201,
0.0669192597,
0.0437082201,
-0.0007280362,
0.0045960271,
-0.008952057,
-0.0372810923,
-0.0003887739,
-0.0064337212,
-0.1425363868,
-0.0046736235,
-0.0127483048,
0.053512089,
0.0539932363,
-0.0521179549,
0.0521090776,
0.0095928423,
0.0099240653,
-0.0270535164,
0.0646736249,
0.0121944668,
-0.0005457946,
-0.0244438797,
-0.0312480945,
0.0320750922,
-0.0252184272,
0.0187034942,
0.0185281578,
0.0151757086,
0.0156455915,
0.0179469679,
-0.1086954027,
0.002535217,
0.0094081238,
-0.0017727754,
-0.0005864209,
-0.013762854,
-0.0191078335,
0.0375512391,
0.0142083513,
0.0006526462,
0.0157384071,
0.0286664441,
0.0160700008,
0.020679906,
-0.0163242668,
0.1280686706,
0.0182097591,
-0.0291732568,
-0.0847710297,
0.0343265086,
0.0202845577,
0.008042125,
-0.0206457507,
-0.0268653855,
-0.0219651237,
-0.0359558314,
-0.0481615551,
-0.0556103326,
-0.0105814124,
-0.0216730349,
-0.0087499972,
-0.0144935055,
-0.0374303386,
0.0541595034,
0.0057589845,
-0.048856765,
-0.0446542613,
0.0442057475,
-0.0024000385,
0.061354585,
0.0070693744,
-0.010959506,
-0.0225991551,
-0.0101182116,
0.0250458997,
0.0457945466,
0.0219292026,
-0.0088390987,
0.025399141,
-0.0275600012,
-0.0362761468,
0.0116748605,
0.0213561282,
-0.000663202,
-0.0369672999,
-0.0106339604,
-0.0060741957,
0.0248626154,
0.0289631262,
-0.0050506056,
0.0653196201,
-0.0027035398,
0.0088654878,
-0.0532162413,
0.0521033965,
0.0415688977,
0.0177827775,
0.0062885638,
-0.0022150544,
0.0079212142,
-0.0003781437,
-0.0507583842,
-0.0103933448,
-0.0244796239,
2.356e-7,
0.0347659774,
0.0243601911,
0.0630241483,
0.0071034338,
-0.0287659261,
-0.0098160412,
0.022504257,
0.0340980329,
-0.0246083271,
-0.0630127788,
0.0215131436,
0.0373214856,
0.0355441049,
0.0405229665,
-0.0593668595,
-0.0398275033,
-0.0287503917,
0.0089362562,
-0.0598115288,
0.0108351503,
0.0031219365,
0.0419306867,
0.0540121868,
-0.0146766063,
-0.0319931768,
0.0088677434,
0.0454395749,
-0.0096674878,
-0.0381360315,
0.0205865391,
-0.0068556061,
0.0195824225,
0.0000570577,
0.0531641096,
-0.0169623215,
0.0231316593,
0.0435210466,
0.0571054704,
0.0332932398,
-0.0009662417,
-0.0331821479,
-0.0414947793,
0.00259504,
0.00319155,
0.0878316835,
0.0016667905,
0.0005495517,
0.0137252156,
-0.0792026594,
0.0271199718,
0.0037319064,
0.0170316957,
-0.0187030118,
0.0267701112,
-0.0018344284,
0.0302056819,
-0.0108723603,
-0.0598133206,
0.0153842075,
0.0416689329,
-0.0057284944,
-0.0491413474,
0.063227497,
-0.0506057329,
-0.0172492173,
-0.0232080165,
0.0279341713,
1.727981517e-34,
0.020763509,
0.02806063,
-0.0069685318,
-0.0028855661,
0.0262862276,
-0.0319458321,
-0.0959542617,
-0.0317534618,
0.0024615854,
-0.0219017621,
0.027498655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15570v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15570v1 | DEM: Distribution Edited Model for Training with Mixed Data Distributions | 2024-06-21T18:07:46 | 2024-06-21T18:07:46 | Dhananjay Ram, Aditya Rawal, Momchil Hardalov, Nikolaos Pappas, Sheng Zha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50, F.2.2; I.2.7 | Training with mixed data distributions is a common and important part of
creating multi-task and instruction-following models. The diversity of the data
distributions and cost of joint training makes the optimization procedure
extremely challenging. Data mixing methods partially address this problem,
albeit having a sub-optimal performance across data sources and require
multiple expensive training runs. In this paper, we propose a simple and
efficient alternative for better optimization of the data sources by combining
models individually trained on each data source with the base model using basic
element-wise vector operations. The resulting model, namely Distribution Edited
Model (DEM), is 11x cheaper than standard data mixing and outperforms strong
baselines on a variety of benchmarks, yielding up to 6.2% improvement on MMLU,
11.5% on BBH, 16.1% on DROP, and 9.3% on HELM with models of size 3B to 13B.
Notably, DEM does not require full re-training when modifying a single
data-source, thus making it very flexible and scalable for training with
diverse data sources. | [
0.0076840427,
0.063578628,
0.0197711736,
-0.014286641,
0.0267101098,
0.0220691748,
0.0195844397,
-0.0343241058,
-0.0430472866,
-0.0390045643,
-0.0459976532,
-0.0121150101,
0.0070523042,
-0.0056744711,
0.0472076982,
-0.0774406046,
0.0315414891,
-0.000142154,
-0.0412375629,
0.0150977597,
-0.0083258059,
-0.014825156,
0.0039046956,
-0.0098304609,
0.0090606753,
0.019029811,
-0.0322390236,
0.0677492619,
0.0353476703,
-0.0271910783,
0.049964603,
0.0315219797,
0.0691580996,
-0.0065040542,
0.0000022599,
0.0192217883,
-0.0102300178,
-0.0019597826,
-0.0237024706,
-0.013705885,
0.0525652394,
0.0088934861,
-0.0122861937,
0.0289601553,
0.0111574922,
0.0002583704,
0.0467714481,
0.0463761352,
0.0885035321,
0.062542513,
-0.0102702249,
-0.0176003519,
0.0081167584,
-0.0443542376,
0.0199750252,
-0.0000774297,
0.0343862772,
0.0633767769,
-0.007312886,
0.0094260713,
-0.0248912442,
0.019457845,
0.0110696172,
0.0691580325,
0.0193882957,
0.0235527139,
-0.0036356528,
0.0087551009,
-0.0398922376,
0.0405742936,
-0.0773418844,
0.0210893881,
0.0238245577,
-0.0147278495,
-0.0041716374,
-0.0005207342,
-0.0292836633,
-0.0167444851,
-0.0230868254,
0.0058835582,
-0.0445557684,
-0.0067849206,
0.0168495923,
-0.0129158944,
-0.0430039465,
0.0504400395,
-0.0070580975,
-0.0215392355,
-0.0090792952,
-0.0362773873,
0.0004762938,
-0.0215863585,
-0.0208120942,
0.0146072563,
-0.0153439464,
-0.0146616129,
-0.0871225595,
-0.0960113853,
-0.0087847104,
-0.0050643124,
0.0831159055,
0.0458305329,
-0.0602490604,
0.0280726869,
-0.0039666803,
0.0057388768,
-0.0271042604,
0.0418930724,
-0.0385416336,
0.0570751429,
-0.0548229702,
0.0239823349,
0.0084684035,
0.0324554853,
-0.0471252874,
0.0125868721,
-0.0669603646,
0.0440513194,
-0.0353747793,
-0.0484398194,
0.0719044358,
0.0367231593,
-0.0706678554,
0.0616297387,
-0.0049948832,
-0.0165399518,
0.0011633962,
0.0343039446,
0.0452537797,
-0.0036914975,
0.0076120696,
-0.0012276114,
-0.039220985,
-0.02813394,
0.050324861,
0.0626900941,
-0.0264684614,
0.0073357411,
-0.081922017,
0.0353720337,
0.0269659311,
-0.049318593,
0.0323007703,
-0.04178885,
0.0720325038,
-0.0586259849,
0.0096387714,
-0.0087211132,
0.0119752781,
0.0057182768,
-0.0408782922,
0.1035452336,
0.0329137407,
0.0070906566,
0.0601825826,
-0.0169660598,
-0.0466477573,
0.0959758684,
0.0161968302,
-0.0126333693,
-0.0216038451,
0.0022022191,
-0.0099698128,
0.032196831,
-0.0121504078,
0.0185783021,
0.0013428899,
-0.0185209196,
-0.018108258,
0.0017109123,
0.0649298877,
-0.0071694818,
-0.0454072505,
0.0036538567,
0.0609832294,
-0.0324183255,
0.0513368957,
-0.0434287637,
0.0424964949,
0.014455623,
0.0109327557,
-0.0109522436,
-0.059863884,
0.0208096188,
-0.0104954084,
-0.0002888806,
-0.018114306,
0.0816013291,
-0.0546527691,
-0.0397200361,
0.0231502242,
-0.0286868382,
-0.0212328639,
-0.0042037051,
0.0555371456,
-0.0396491475,
-0.0604246892,
0.0178096388,
0.0669726804,
-0.0242155194,
-0.0249859709,
-0.0268643573,
-0.0472049378,
0.0222559944,
0.0232342053,
-0.0496571958,
-0.0402281731,
-0.0392063856,
0.0159775894,
-0.0150559666,
-0.0032551475,
0.0026311823,
0.0324168243,
-0.0493040942,
-0.0611530542,
-0.0114538437,
0.004524101,
0.0695352927,
-0.0067580673,
-0.0298690051,
0.0116485916,
-0.0122257872,
-0.0518531762,
0.0338366851,
-0.0159000121,
0.0101010129,
0.0225394946,
0.0052919807,
0.0416541286,
-0.0212269761,
-0.0069925948,
0.0002706313,
0.0125247026,
-0.0231120046,
-0.0289759543,
-0.0143709043,
-0.0246160775,
-0.0051674247,
0.0323641337,
0.015984429,
0.0479989089,
0.0268133674,
-0.0397542976,
-0.0626098961,
-0.0256377645,
-0.0002604662,
0.0115460539,
-0.007408136,
0.0592738762,
0.0339478813,
-0.0246105026,
-0.0571553409,
0.0636574104,
-0.0397770256,
-0.0375209451,
-0.0123566473,
0.012803263,
0.0164201297,
-0.0457616597,
0.003959409,
-0.0068430114,
-0.0120171346,
0.0313605964,
0.010188181,
-0.006461597,
-0.0164090097,
-0.0193435103,
-0.022763595,
0.0481920727,
-0.00791544,
0.0423747078,
0.0280276276,
0.007744655,
-0.0181780774,
0.0125162154,
-0.0166985393,
0.0011623165,
-0.0213597659,
0.0015023751,
-0.0285364743,
0.0453534462,
0.0045542428,
-0.0328413472,
-0.0229054578,
-0.0329932123,
0.0119395293,
-0.0477280691,
-0.0113228625,
-0.0227880757,
0.040644899,
-0.0359269567,
0.0589968041,
-0.0500491299,
-0.037515901,
-0.0174208805,
0.0030477382,
0.0890573487,
0.0947561413,
0.006888899,
-0.0217971727,
0.0370409861,
-0.0247159321,
-0.0303306524,
0.0456136502,
-0.0161451381,
-0.0107247764,
-0.0173595138,
-0.016101798,
-0.0150694074,
0.0572610758,
-0.0047735088,
0.0168229863,
-0.0470659956,
-0.010002682,
0.0067378827,
-0.0350663178,
-0.0460495912,
0.0236779917,
-0.0282388851,
-0.044183556,
-0.058415845,
-0.0437414683,
0.0508285053,
-0.0011048472,
0.0021245701,
-0.0404121503,
-0.0564354733,
-0.0249128826,
-0.0475099273,
0.0059619681,
0.0017801499,
-0.0470200554,
0.0087707443,
-0.0604412332,
0.0306039676,
0.0378765538,
-0.0159857683,
0.0033663195,
-0.0048449398,
-0.0124403303,
-0.0028154962,
-0.0249634087,
-0.0369163007,
-0.0172518194,
0.0225904174,
0.0105090747,
-0.0139306057,
-0.0385446511,
-0.0740846768,
0.0105335275,
0.0466054007,
0.0720519647,
-0.0519078746,
-0.0063418453,
-0.0233200006,
-0.0035786524,
0.0295869093,
-0.0468457043,
-0.0670772269,
-0.0446735136,
-0.0407941751,
0.0109119499,
0.1007641405,
-0.0504910052,
-0.0277618133,
0.0219200198,
0.0066066543,
0.0189359747,
-0.0257294327,
0.0216070414,
0.0317112617,
-0.0383810438,
0.0289064404,
0.0512103587,
0.0100879995,
-0.0438903533,
-0.0190355089,
-0.0149493273,
0.0660086125,
0.0436611399,
0.0458403453,
-0.0434473194,
-0.0110737234,
0.0097236438,
0.0615789965,
-0.0076873563,
-0.0163628757,
0.0128278742,
-0.0755659565,
0.0157623254,
0.025002664,
-0.0597929396,
-0.0290136933,
-0.0516932681,
0.013872453,
-0.040122848,
-0.0442036688,
0.0113893682,
-0.017477775,
0.0042528617,
0.0619865209,
-0.0056084371,
-0.087361522,
-0.0050759893,
-0.0365604535,
0.0014494767,
0.076152809,
-0.0121010123,
-0.0091760363,
-0.0292008128,
-0.0004552949,
0.0096540954,
-0.0121546546,
0.0128574744,
0.0852322727,
-0.0514976829,
0.0207726844,
-0.0022922284,
0.0529636741,
0.0032232057,
-0.0080424473,
0.0137055023,
0.0670833588,
-0.0340839922,
0.0467949994,
-0.0431193411,
-0.0524367318,
0.0747043043,
0.0308203753,
-0.0319857299,
-0.0382592939,
0.0192190874,
-0.0105091184,
-0.0282706618,
-0.0028921687,
0.0159171168,
0.0461456887,
-0.0619903877,
-0.0752293691,
-0.0591090582,
-0.0315077901,
-0.0106108235,
0.0773567557,
0.028643135,
-0.0209793895,
-0.0276916437,
0.0148510663,
-0.0672660396,
0.036852248,
0.0206543356,
0.0503769703,
-0.0785928592,
-0.068755731,
0.0008972636,
-0.0157580823,
-0.0355232246,
0.0160301421,
-0.1092422456,
-0.0497028194,
0.0119998893,
0.0902555212,
0.0205281489,
0.0654518679,
0.0039933673,
0.0036651122,
0.0522389673,
0.0203956757,
-0.0182865486,
0.0371283814,
0.0557315908,
-0.0599105917,
0.0147400154,
-0.043383386,
-0.0510785989,
0.0190067757,
0.0178332701,
-0.0276098121,
-0.0387370177,
-0.0242072884,
-0.0100524817,
-0.0107908128,
0.0279202014,
0.0015893119,
-0.0280630942,
-0.0478666686,
0.0257921088,
-0.0296590328,
0.0045961402,
-0.0421391204,
0.0015625762,
0.0160328206,
0.0142136645,
0.0268350523,
0.0266623553,
0.0515186898,
0.0061868783,
-0.0556453802,
0.0014935036,
0.0213616081,
-0.0067907814,
-0.0036290986,
0.0175786,
0.0402215123,
-0.0096197482,
0.0135689341,
0.0191153493,
0.0070306817,
0.0255591627,
0.0079193264,
-0.0002349473,
-0.023889618,
0.0300827194,
-0.0852217749,
-0.0222392399,
-0.0604751296,
-0.0045340778,
0.0372570157,
-0.0281336736,
0.0310538094,
0.0123490039,
0.0000020117,
-0.0396237299,
0.0001214983,
-0.0061285305,
0.0340677686,
0.0312191099,
0.0407734215,
0.0170253161,
0.002288461,
0.0675237477,
0.0291056335,
0.1044122279,
-0.0630815849,
0.0043941704,
-0.0392241813,
0.0209762007,
0.0670451373,
0.0689704716,
-0.0121149011,
-0.0143010048,
-0.0310592037,
-0.0277878214,
0.022237109,
0.021849867,
0.0199164413,
-0.0172798745,
0.0647648871,
0.0226005726,
-0.0659785941,
0.0000217467,
-0.0433098301,
-0.0620794967,
0.0180913545,
0.0262269918,
0.0434033759,
-6.061796615e-33,
0.0042327121,
0.0542696379,
0.022524368,
-0.0316158012,
-0.0410513021,
0.030568473,
0.0005860009,
-0.0106730275,
0.0093939826,
-0.0357198715,
-0.0180986226,
0.0183617119,
0.0158336945,
-0.0321691409,
0.0227544867,
0.0481059887,
0.0531154834,
-0.0081086,
-0.0104472758,
-0.0072086402,
0.0407637991,
0.0497020371,
0.0258704256,
-0.0546403416,
-0.019898206,
0.0350622721,
-0.0153708635,
-0.0126742022,
-0.0120359622,
0.0226140115,
0.0001257674,
-0.0101051759,
-0.0074053765,
-0.0243148301,
-0.0585545674,
-0.0078518279,
-0.0382836796,
0.0129369451,
0.0040851948,
-0.0113116698,
-0.0280576851,
-0.0077119139,
0.0127191907,
0.010881382,
-0.0058037341,
-0.0302758887,
0.0432203226,
-0.0397695042,
-0.00878416,
-0.0303690471,
-0.0227108542,
0.033788085,
0.0157272946,
-0.036163982,
0.039352186,
0.034022674,
0.0200076941,
0.0105063589,
-0.0456843637,
0.0368894115,
0.0248832051,
0.0377207324,
0.0358889624,
0.0905709788,
0.0143267065,
0.0296465456,
0.0035613817,
0.0087593673,
-0.0037550656,
-0.0017953484,
0.0250784587,
0.0834418312,
-0.0190211274,
0.023605004,
0.0200690012,
0.0024131539,
-0.0522283576,
0.0928260982,
0.0034034802,
0.0067076576,
-0.0395588726,
0.0522892401,
-0.0184249692,
0.0107160825,
0.0065217856,
0.0123826358,
-0.0022578819,
-0.0127781155,
0.0398147702,
0.0443371683,
-0.0108610336,
0.0100018727,
0.0453929305,
-0.0046080467,
0.038921129,
0.0329756327,
-0.0049271574,
-0.0073924307,
0.0073046554,
0.0028325364,
-0.043264851,
-0.0542289764,
0.0614464879,
0.0013390396,
0.0239267685,
0.0210601874,
0.0433602706,
0.0215534959,
-0.0361245014,
-0.0212044846,
-0.0245429911,
0.008285786,
0.0054109222,
0.0851423964,
0.0496572554,
0.0046140105,
-0.0076665962,
0.0305749793,
0.0043850052,
-0.0474258699,
-0.0337045416,
0.0231072716,
-0.007944297,
0.0312435199,
-0.0069547202,
0.0120938579,
-0.0511491261,
-0.0310715735,
-0.0171072055,
-0.0465740561,
-0.0136607178,
-0.0041112565,
2.869e-7,
0.008580572,
-0.0180198811,
-0.0071048848,
-0.0014449948,
-0.0245149843,
0.0059857084,
-0.0499252342,
0.0131635563,
0.0031996085,
-0.0487447269,
0.0409247391,
0.0385326073,
0.0138647435,
-0.0208728369,
-0.0307889748,
-0.0537520312,
0.0206953567,
0.0230330508,
-0.0561495088,
-0.0247566029,
-0.0106975092,
0.0818405375,
0.0364067219,
-0.0282865576,
0.0354138426,
0.0352038257,
0.0294443741,
0.020569995,
-0.0133193973,
-0.0038389182,
0.0378620438,
0.009505013,
-0.0181586314,
0.0440415069,
-0.0397681445,
0.0010479179,
0.0177754983,
0.0623156428,
-0.0714303628,
0.0256416537,
0.0414206795,
0.0555267669,
-0.075619176,
-0.0126395095,
0.0467021689,
-0.0242527332,
-0.00165879,
-0.0199291799,
-0.0667144284,
0.0289620832,
0.0201615728,
0.0014825495,
-0.000882595,
-0.0067198128,
0.0077482755,
-0.0072906995,
-0.0101732742,
-0.0485370569,
0.0012508815,
0.0635318533,
-0.0506301001,
-0.0581964999,
-0.0376374424,
0.005607733,
0.0405265726,
-0.0546354912,
-0.0378577448,
2.882676735e-34,
0.0105710719,
0.0170288812,
0.0400939509,
0.0166331716,
-0.0292889364,
-0.0232107379,
-0.0475806668,
0.0126991589,
-0.0272565559,
-0.0411626883,
-0.0413279496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15567v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15567v1 | SAIL: Self-Improving Efficient Online Alignment of Large Language Models | 2024-06-21T18:05:35 | 2024-06-21T18:05:35 | Mucong Ding, Souradip Chakraborty, Vibhu Agrawal, Zora Che, Alec Koppel, Mengdi Wang, Amrit Bedi, Furong Huang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML | Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) is a key method for
aligning large language models (LLMs) with human preferences. However, current
offline alignment approaches like DPO, IPO, and SLiC rely heavily on fixed
preference datasets, which can lead to sub-optimal performance. On the other
hand, recent literature has focused on designing online RLHF methods but still
lacks a unified conceptual formulation and suffers from distribution shift
issues. To address this, we establish that online LLM alignment is underpinned
by bilevel optimization. By reducing this formulation to an efficient
single-level first-order method (using the reward-policy equivalence), our
approach generates new samples and iteratively refines model alignment by
exploring responses and regulating preference labels. In doing so, we permit
alignment methods to operate in an online and self-improving manner, as well as
generalize prior online RLHF methods as special cases. Compared to
state-of-the-art iterative RLHF methods, our approach significantly improves
alignment performance on open-sourced datasets with minimal computational
overhead. | [
0.0166213084,
0.0930432305,
-0.000103387,
0.0141209606,
-0.0242469627,
0.0099363979,
-0.0272297766,
-0.0241751187,
-0.0031036008,
0.0125279855,
-0.0556905083,
-0.029781023,
0.0268039927,
0.0131175853,
-0.005425211,
-0.0262298845,
0.0446535945,
-0.0441720672,
-0.0245635007,
-0.0300016031,
0.0293818731,
0.0204426721,
-0.0385854952,
0.0279574543,
0.0573127903,
-0.0284773484,
0.0002641361,
0.0140099227,
0.0360732377,
-0.0213232916,
0.0282378253,
0.0542008281,
0.0309997182,
0.0601255186,
0.0000019482,
-0.051082138,
-0.0314203203,
-0.0141772572,
-0.0265823137,
-0.0181898642,
0.0319637842,
0.0060389196,
-0.02719515,
0.0172314215,
-0.0064648204,
0.0094874855,
0.0803710893,
-0.0245033968,
0.0439097509,
0.0672229528,
0.0115451878,
-0.0041691847,
0.0081604505,
-0.020973824,
-0.0285201203,
0.0037559213,
0.0240165256,
-0.009454418,
-0.026741039,
-0.0418414846,
-0.0296812747,
0.0281660389,
-0.0208903719,
0.000274497,
0.027101893,
0.0285015106,
-0.0342807509,
-0.0159493145,
-0.0225846656,
0.0735089555,
-0.0168671738,
-0.0336813591,
0.0121840583,
-0.0115632163,
-0.0191828012,
0.0091009839,
-0.0148724234,
-0.0040776334,
-0.0121853547,
0.0435307659,
0.0319417827,
-0.0417842641,
0.0203905161,
0.0146305906,
0.0050740805,
0.1046136618,
0.0200925656,
-0.041128736,
0.0210032687,
0.0070375446,
-0.0341985673,
-0.041511938,
-0.0044570989,
0.0061846082,
-0.0803172663,
0.0270600021,
-0.0511165559,
0.0050653368,
-0.0194955468,
-0.031719882,
0.0870492905,
0.0507746004,
0.0188109837,
0.0283518992,
0.0252057742,
0.0836212263,
-0.0324322097,
0.0199114438,
-0.0268199593,
0.04179582,
-0.0329271406,
-0.0222891513,
0.0025675648,
0.0083248122,
-0.0232435856,
-0.0156812817,
-0.0486162044,
0.0370972902,
-0.0242671873,
0.0530372895,
0.0410525948,
-0.0203572381,
-0.0445472412,
0.000745301,
-0.056745287,
0.0605395511,
0.0015723282,
-0.0157848168,
-0.008778383,
-0.0028510741,
0.0077985832,
0.0153970551,
-0.0042114872,
-0.0471514873,
-0.0104597304,
0.0830669329,
-0.0220165178,
0.0061814729,
0.0184853859,
-0.0028689976,
-0.032816153,
-0.0555037111,
-0.0371024124,
-0.059140753,
0.0438852757,
-0.0201806705,
-0.0195081476,
-0.044460129,
-0.0064781778,
0.00935777,
-0.0274188109,
0.0670982748,
0.002251344,
0.0349762961,
-0.0049411072,
-0.0716619566,
0.0031019163,
0.0622585975,
0.0274064951,
0.0066327029,
0.0216039587,
-0.0152598321,
-0.0151786767,
0.0655725747,
0.0323888585,
0.0472955629,
-0.0487563647,
0.005485008,
0.0063863178,
0.0789925754,
0.0822857693,
0.0195891988,
-0.0018274477,
0.0185428858,
0.0868529528,
0.0230215956,
0.0246763565,
-0.0196225047,
-0.0016991379,
0.0414860807,
-0.029021116,
-0.0141498297,
-0.0440934151,
0.0330984332,
-0.0189737063,
0.0398954153,
0.0268336516,
0.0430963226,
-0.0038021344,
-0.0281325188,
-0.0230402444,
0.0261747651,
-0.0080092996,
0.0445513092,
0.0449818075,
-0.0178763606,
-0.0492028147,
0.0136312544,
0.0498161837,
-0.0235992447,
0.0144937523,
-0.0318303593,
0.0632018968,
0.0953865498,
0.0552151613,
-0.0099065257,
-0.0355471894,
-0.0209903866,
-0.0247135013,
0.0680889115,
0.0119693093,
-0.0296772476,
-0.0190625973,
-0.0288326684,
-0.0479978547,
0.0392508171,
-0.0170637779,
0.0310826693,
0.0372870974,
-0.0190868247,
-0.0443253145,
-0.0142830713,
-0.0497638956,
0.0328377746,
-0.0229426343,
-0.0292472038,
-0.0159450192,
0.0365215354,
0.0346184932,
-0.0028963394,
0.0058377264,
-0.0130846715,
-0.0066620815,
0.0066258833,
0.0019065771,
-0.0155321369,
-0.0097898142,
-0.0430422649,
0.067497924,
-0.0126817273,
-0.0389728695,
0.0479279086,
-0.0404810123,
-0.0169084892,
-0.0348386876,
-0.0050985878,
0.0266583394,
-0.005661109,
0.0468382388,
-0.0200372599,
-0.0136711253,
-0.0591915548,
0.0320828706,
-0.010560655,
0.0357751921,
-0.0090010921,
-0.0131504303,
-0.0189660341,
-0.0516165942,
-0.0179480016,
0.0163393728,
-0.00877041,
0.0287132151,
0.0370734185,
0.027906958,
-0.0259745363,
-0.0166017953,
-0.0568919033,
0.0211099517,
-0.0107276142,
0.0204874184,
0.0254166331,
-0.0084627867,
-0.0230731796,
-0.0083395438,
-0.0336286351,
-0.020030411,
-0.0196811948,
0.0330438763,
0.0345932543,
-0.0184527189,
-0.0331528895,
-0.0778146237,
-0.0216227509,
-0.0164031889,
-0.0249252003,
-0.0461504571,
0.0175602324,
-0.0610593557,
0.0046026781,
-0.0673032254,
0.0208348669,
-0.0105479127,
-0.0294148587,
0.0021251629,
-0.0043461537,
0.0542707071,
0.0981260166,
0.0132600265,
0.0265501142,
0.0579944327,
0.0073048859,
-0.0842035115,
0.0004317114,
-0.0516946949,
-0.0666782185,
-0.043153502,
0.0076387515,
0.0137501797,
0.1051736698,
-0.0108496509,
0.0139913661,
-0.0717204064,
-0.0085969782,
-0.0063641011,
-0.0075002047,
-0.0543540455,
0.0186868683,
-0.0573299751,
0.0197400507,
-0.0396842696,
-0.0831776261,
0.0993064269,
-0.0139612183,
0.0162712671,
-0.0362958014,
-0.0258747339,
-0.0172866993,
0.0111586507,
0.0184471291,
0.0225000698,
-0.0208310112,
-0.0168368332,
-0.0709760934,
-0.0306446087,
0.0806774795,
-0.0548172705,
0.0550928749,
-0.0284757502,
0.0173489731,
-0.0162237305,
-0.0693895072,
-0.0345020331,
-0.0319833979,
-0.0215610284,
-0.0322942883,
0.0108253025,
-0.0566380136,
-0.0132917175,
0.0122343926,
0.0287593007,
0.033358302,
-0.0262888726,
-0.0023603381,
-0.0381641202,
0.0169018079,
0.0968301445,
0.0173753817,
-0.0057066451,
-0.0267819297,
-0.0093839644,
-0.0086664567,
0.0600862168,
0.0093465913,
0.0117292637,
-0.000275432,
0.0739325881,
-0.0341108665,
0.0182175357,
0.0309472922,
0.0424535573,
-0.0027903821,
-0.0197042692,
0.0860303938,
0.0194924884,
-0.0633781329,
-0.0017953719,
-0.0231054816,
0.09926451,
0.0126630487,
0.03691715,
-0.0468388572,
-0.0243763216,
0.0158431437,
0.0593831651,
0.0115559241,
-0.0074859327,
-0.0147375679,
-0.1378028542,
-0.0153278625,
0.0303522572,
-0.0565427393,
-0.0219693743,
-0.0219393875,
0.0281454138,
-0.06085556,
0.0440980271,
0.0327608138,
-0.0025082685,
0.0096689286,
0.0062271403,
-0.0043518282,
-0.0187423602,
-0.011525183,
-0.034607619,
0.0583406053,
0.0922567174,
0.0268387869,
0.0109933913,
-0.0412544757,
0.0286640897,
0.0270513557,
-0.0407410562,
0.0035980591,
-0.0077076266,
-0.0329710431,
0.0117610004,
-0.0310863964,
0.0735627189,
-0.0323672965,
0.002013278,
0.00009103,
0.0606153645,
0.0182394851,
0.024764413,
0.0033125039,
-0.0129031129,
0.0378315151,
0.0635117292,
-0.0223916713,
-0.0843470544,
-0.0113350265,
-0.0201025438,
-0.034787111,
-0.0206811484,
-0.018696323,
0.0085166059,
-0.0251671132,
0.0099139651,
-0.047407452,
0.0084365644,
-0.0206922125,
0.0284607299,
-0.0005281954,
-0.0042416998,
0.0124917598,
-0.0152380271,
-0.0280167144,
0.0426224433,
-0.0459638387,
0.0184974112,
-0.0845616907,
-0.0137587143,
0.0081361718,
-0.0269750934,
-0.0139601296,
0.0122296484,
-0.0616934262,
-0.08307717,
0.0007154673,
0.0270476062,
0.0117428713,
0.0769799948,
0.0035908027,
-0.0246633533,
0.0384883583,
0.0392797291,
-0.0046552592,
0.0200680066,
-0.0104128364,
0.0259532798,
-0.0097385077,
0.0384364836,
-0.0312506035,
-0.0231453143,
0.0351789854,
0.0526210815,
0.0035612429,
-0.015481987,
0.0289124884,
0.0008627685,
0.073417075,
-0.0480852947,
-0.0427307338,
-0.0454703718,
0.000512646,
0.0317103714,
-0.0321339741,
-0.0014230607,
-0.0171272103,
0.0386474915,
-0.0222522933,
-0.0157299805,
0.0193088744,
0.0250257086,
0.0146579705,
-0.0234639794,
-0.0224433113,
0.0079320464,
0.019097738,
0.058350604,
0.0259420779,
0.0066492623,
0.0555377901,
0.0017860149,
0.0617570728,
0.0187133458,
0.0436806977,
0.0462737828,
0.0328387134,
0.0073229158,
-0.002808037,
-0.0013022472,
-0.0734478682,
-0.0584494174,
-0.0436649546,
0.0696445554,
-0.0012913734,
0.0682080314,
-0.0059685153,
-0.026441697,
-0.0176647361,
0.0337585919,
-0.0523336157,
-0.00444018,
0.0437031984,
0.0161554813,
-0.0243073516,
0.0109537039,
0.0448616855,
0.0140345907,
0.0155496458,
-0.053880889,
0.0116962139,
-0.0339662805,
-0.0273351017,
0.0055862195,
0.0124137038,
-0.0317699388,
-0.0315300822,
-0.0142036956,
-0.0555927865,
-0.0177327245,
0.0384392478,
-0.0409952216,
-0.004160617,
0.0465076789,
0.0186323933,
-0.0528445281,
-0.0104504414,
-0.0469802506,
-0.0026765496,
-0.0112479022,
-0.0412037075,
-0.0123999352,
-6.292713664e-33,
-0.0436340086,
-0.0208412707,
0.0175284296,
-0.0235867538,
-0.0591929555,
-0.0357927904,
0.0083145639,
0.0208397396,
0.0184097942,
-0.0206479989,
-0.0052802409,
-0.0042677461,
0.0127821257,
0.0093805147,
0.0302765649,
-0.0205849037,
0.0129495692,
-0.0070827692,
-0.0745392889,
-0.0134579772,
0.0398934595,
0.0012424212,
0.0277321413,
-0.0342772156,
0.0354420133,
0.016854018,
-0.0293868426,
0.0421085022,
-0.0103603043,
0.0881495997,
0.0023838864,
0.0134258987,
-0.0132459272,
-0.0209520962,
0.0039123478,
0.0198204946,
-0.0484868512,
0.0009834126,
0.0151444096,
0.0218458604,
-0.0276132915,
-0.0186830647,
0.0337990709,
0.0076896851,
-0.0574028902,
-0.0150013091,
0.0341008715,
-0.0131879281,
-0.0438586585,
-0.0009833691,
-0.0788905248,
0.0210281517,
-0.0094999485,
-0.0086226249,
0.0335807279,
0.0419813618,
0.0061798166,
0.0138385762,
-0.029285349,
0.0468593016,
-0.0166906305,
0.0435901731,
0.117744498,
0.0568069033,
0.0308667626,
0.0280042123,
0.0104185482,
-0.0437923633,
0.02967388,
-0.0033496183,
0.0348576792,
-0.0158313848,
0.0007238915,
0.0451909788,
0.0087090386,
0.0097842487,
-0.0031177613,
0.015106895,
0.0057343603,
-0.0136768622,
0.0308076628,
0.0554449819,
-0.0470658951,
-0.0103564635,
-0.0568682253,
-0.0460755564,
-0.027630033,
-0.0406207517,
0.0331588276,
0.0018210771,
-0.0173185915,
-0.0532142073,
0.0287166853,
-0.0335626788,
-0.0437369496,
0.0053742728,
-0.0237743147,
0.0179585926,
-0.0036175183,
0.0225865692,
-0.07168708,
-0.0448317379,
-0.0470805243,
-0.0119290976,
0.0016688601,
0.0276370943,
0.0156194745,
0.0099353166,
-0.0845312253,
0.0370928682,
-0.0124722663,
0.0010848788,
-0.0028896842,
0.0350408368,
0.085991621,
-0.046446573,
0.0231567174,
0.0638815686,
0.0274747442,
-0.0207155608,
-0.0277092215,
-0.0219304897,
-0.0400997736,
0.0063490937,
-0.0001397851,
0.0342940874,
-0.03437851,
0.0059126276,
-0.0258283764,
-0.0340009145,
-0.010281804,
0.0059149787,
2.619e-7,
0.0156232687,
0.0464336947,
0.0129226968,
0.0205160864,
-0.006268004,
0.0131935067,
-0.0104510915,
0.0102814864,
-0.0082223443,
-0.0137854693,
0.036367707,
0.0192800481,
0.0672699064,
-0.0215554647,
-0.0587752946,
0.003220859,
-0.0824568719,
0.0607949123,
-0.0505117811,
-0.0161156487,
-0.0032389716,
0.0835635066,
0.0238946844,
0.0076437257,
0.0108317295,
0.0329747945,
0.0585437454,
-0.0266372524,
-0.0144727435,
0.0306254923,
-0.0341424085,
-0.0110661145,
-0.0422223508,
-0.0394020192,
0.0118231475,
0.0306687728,
-0.0203582663,
0.0805158541,
0.0042003989,
-0.0296245683,
-0.0303752907,
0.0157821588,
0.0125411721,
-0.062100701,
0.0340696275,
-0.0481945872,
-0.0015690014,
-0.0362957381,
0.0141943973,
-0.0312960036,
0.0326740257,
-0.0404407531,
-0.0105954716,
0.0283409841,
0.0485985279,
0.0228723697,
-0.0342017896,
-0.0387673937,
-0.0193017852,
0.0508027934,
-0.0376069732,
-0.0462849885,
-0.0229900666,
0.0556370318,
-0.0001691939,
-0.0459902063,
-0.0020303074,
2.325483688e-34,
0.0045436318,
-0.0146068437,
0.0255110096,
0.0011950427,
0.0225740802,
-0.0088421907,
0.0323562324,
0.0192715954,
0.0527669862,
-0.0712688193,
-0.0040094433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15352v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15352v1 | A SMART Mnemonic Sounds like "Glue Tonic": Mixing LLMs with Student Feedback to Make Mnemonic Learning Stick | 2024-06-21T17:59:51 | 2024-06-21T17:59:51 | Nishant Balepur, Matthew Shu, Alexander Hoyle, Alison Robey, Shi Feng, Seraphina Goldfarb-Tarrant, Jordan Boyd-Graber | cs.CL | cs.CL | Keyword mnemonics are memorable explanations that link new terms to simpler
keywords. Prior works generate mnemonics for students, but they do not guide
models toward mnemonics students prefer and aid learning. We build SMART, a
mnemonic generator trained on feedback from real students learning new terms.
To train SMART, we first fine-tune LLaMA-2 on a curated set of user-written
mnemonics. We then use LLM alignment to enhance SMART: we deploy mnemonics
generated by SMART in a flashcard app to find preferences on mnemonics students
favor. We gather 2684 preferences from 45 students across two types: expressed
(inferred from ratings) and observed (inferred from student learning), yielding
three key findings. First, expressed and observed preferences disagree; what
students think is helpful does not fully capture what is truly helpful. Second,
Bayesian models can synthesize complementary data from multiple preference
types into a single effectiveness signal. SMART is tuned via Direct Preference
Optimization on this signal, which we show resolves ties and missing labels in
the typical method of pairwise comparisons, augmenting data for LLM output
quality gains. Third, mnemonic experts assess SMART as matching GPT-4, at much
lower deployment costs, showing the utility of capturing diverse student
feedback to align LLMs in education. | [
0.0156747624,
-0.0104793971,
-0.0163214356,
0.0227580778,
-0.0117985392,
-0.0083634416,
-0.0252615791,
-0.0022948261,
0.0060182391,
-0.0560124889,
-0.0318266228,
0.0311731976,
-0.0293467101,
-0.026243221,
0.0428123996,
-0.0613630861,
0.0251604822,
-0.0004977624,
-0.0243932921,
0.0066421842,
-0.0078493524,
0.0046038195,
-0.033000309,
0.0132291103,
0.0372260846,
-0.017541958,
-0.0072434265,
-0.0129735013,
0.0029456725,
-0.0562472157,
0.0069006463,
0.0290033538,
-0.0266403928,
0.0016726621,
0.0000019815,
-0.0900523439,
-0.0103119016,
-0.0292915422,
-0.043166589,
0.0256523937,
-0.0076572658,
0.0839572996,
0.0012685809,
-0.0236762632,
-0.0219397582,
0.0431939662,
0.0355643518,
0.000920938,
-0.0121680014,
0.0186952744,
0.0219862685,
-0.0239421017,
0.0131192803,
0.0133505967,
0.114026852,
-0.0153584136,
-0.01574222,
-0.0202502813,
0.0108011309,
0.0296773333,
-0.0183441993,
0.0098303901,
-0.0192280468,
0.0239820685,
0.0974048972,
0.0173057429,
0.0336549915,
0.0286604222,
-0.0141017344,
0.0595085882,
0.0411989577,
0.0007597144,
0.0102602774,
-0.0349606313,
0.0483781993,
0.0705552027,
-0.0870758221,
-0.0249280147,
-0.0119560119,
0.0059004887,
0.0339400806,
-0.0375851505,
0.0436013862,
0.0510417372,
0.0395582691,
0.0491366684,
0.0056699486,
-0.0246405359,
0.0215118285,
0.0091552921,
0.0063724243,
-0.0145837907,
0.0233385786,
0.0424372926,
0.0008001028,
0.0474694557,
0.0096847629,
0.0013894641,
0.0470421985,
-0.034391094,
0.0492074713,
0.03122719,
-0.017118765,
0.0026932075,
-0.0426147394,
0.0255699679,
0.0025444294,
0.0515710078,
-0.0140240397,
0.0282090306,
-0.0588976778,
-0.0092868423,
0.033058431,
0.094273679,
0.055392541,
-0.0034886259,
-0.0714188069,
0.0272137169,
0.0059270975,
0.0373334847,
-0.0138355335,
0.0185212959,
0.0129338773,
0.0142806703,
-0.08533144,
0.0227907598,
-0.0581027269,
0.0248379484,
0.0334506854,
0.0348329954,
0.0179985687,
0.0138068013,
-0.0133446474,
0.0146814128,
0.035498824,
0.0990665704,
-0.0027192859,
-0.0322817005,
-0.0630162954,
-0.0398362242,
0.0185733289,
-0.0222793799,
0.012791669,
-0.0622990951,
-0.0409699418,
0.010417508,
0.0029547445,
-0.0562965944,
-0.0000724325,
0.0293909218,
-0.0074518276,
0.0396533944,
-0.011991349,
-0.0377988592,
0.0077199028,
0.0359736346,
-0.0216282848,
0.029207442,
0.0400571041,
0.0351437107,
0.0566883236,
-0.0525739007,
-0.0110025434,
0.0036152462,
0.0031883954,
-0.0060806419,
-0.0294720698,
-0.0156051926,
0.0112561742,
0.0613068864,
-0.0370600484,
-0.013943891,
-0.0000417945,
0.041458521,
0.0563983358,
0.0749680623,
0.0503296331,
0.0285722818,
-0.0344551392,
-0.0154107045,
0.0197544303,
0.039565742,
-0.0426139235,
0.0594341159,
-0.0784436911,
0.0327536762,
0.0384926014,
0.009788217,
-0.0016093985,
-0.0746170878,
-0.0305842757,
-0.0109695233,
-0.0507652909,
0.0235570278,
0.0422335044,
-0.0145387668,
-0.037819542,
0.0530608855,
0.0018265363,
-0.0635994971,
0.0195242204,
-0.0758631974,
0.0759389922,
0.1133055389,
0.0588190891,
-0.0376931652,
-0.0649533272,
0.0015742008,
-0.0530967824,
-0.0044535524,
0.0065110205,
-0.027040001,
-0.0172004215,
-0.0772311464,
-0.0312463026,
-0.0134724351,
0.003656483,
0.0082382029,
0.0030126616,
0.0343966484,
0.001989729,
-0.0411673561,
-0.0330259725,
0.0178281032,
0.0079825353,
-0.0774816275,
-0.0136652533,
-0.0247944575,
0.0275602117,
0.0318548977,
0.0364452563,
-0.006612814,
0.0326633379,
0.0231762584,
0.0138006676,
-0.0487265028,
-0.0700869784,
0.0378998294,
0.0431917608,
-0.023744233,
0.0159057677,
-0.012148004,
-0.0233636908,
-0.0268503949,
0.0060756193,
0.001954241,
0.0508398712,
-0.0058425958,
0.0142440246,
-0.0058958628,
-0.0412443914,
-0.0156980902,
0.0327169262,
-0.019947648,
0.0051294384,
-0.0082987696,
-0.0038336238,
-0.0198744182,
-0.0064656283,
0.0248541012,
0.0146420198,
0.0095723579,
0.0256503224,
-0.0080183316,
0.0094838981,
-0.0904739872,
-0.0252776071,
-0.0085065681,
0.0243668836,
0.013091784,
0.0230555572,
-9.18e-7,
-0.0151614277,
-0.0003492526,
0.0236711726,
-0.0357504338,
0.0114818048,
-0.0258243158,
-0.0048452071,
0.0065127672,
0.0172267165,
-0.0091268737,
-0.0644617826,
0.0046104747,
-0.0282391366,
-0.0203040615,
0.0504985675,
-0.0051360745,
-0.0278211907,
0.0205477439,
-0.032356333,
-0.0520250201,
-0.0012443558,
-0.0023631079,
0.0529757775,
0.0002428114,
0.0443835668,
0.0671874285,
-0.0029844772,
0.0011922275,
0.057490401,
-0.0358315408,
-0.0753128752,
-0.0193786267,
-0.0205537546,
-0.0318047218,
-0.0237470809,
-0.0235688258,
-0.004440228,
0.0356428288,
0.0056408197,
-0.0148221916,
0.002077918,
0.0229461864,
0.0206723604,
0.014616861,
-0.0484496132,
-0.0131643023,
-0.0388704911,
0.0201728754,
0.0537090339,
-0.0520800017,
0.0615607314,
0.0013268973,
0.0368146338,
-0.0365847684,
-0.0075239027,
-0.0234304015,
-0.0039393934,
-0.0760857761,
-0.0008267885,
-0.0008789041,
0.0013282722,
-0.0450359546,
-0.0533157662,
0.0591259003,
-0.0727976859,
0.064836137,
-0.0735965744,
-0.0525771715,
0.0257824641,
0.0306843016,
-0.0390707925,
0.0320089646,
-0.032934241,
-0.0243217237,
0.0174227692,
-0.0288678259,
-0.0160239935,
-0.0368369445,
0.025235869,
-0.00582055,
0.0219894871,
-0.026954772,
0.015504363,
-0.0101178233,
0.0234646983,
-0.0026113729,
0.0225371718,
-0.0384722464,
0.0084201396,
0.0407682769,
0.0383389182,
-0.0812904388,
0.023279123,
-0.0047796271,
0.0475268997,
-0.0647034571,
-0.0115485564,
0.0580070242,
0.015037423,
-0.0501104891,
0.0396556035,
0.0791082084,
0.0136555368,
-0.0706004649,
-0.003353155,
-0.0287285484,
0.018351391,
0.0072090058,
-0.0003542988,
-0.0375079177,
-0.0470129177,
-0.0079562599,
0.0663770884,
-0.0097345402,
-0.0185423214,
-0.0159837343,
-0.0573691987,
-0.015609663,
0.0290820505,
-0.0260425638,
0.0375665613,
-0.0293291733,
-0.0145204403,
-0.0090929819,
0.0166798271,
-0.0118859345,
-0.0314897522,
0.0377722494,
0.0259130038,
-0.011571005,
-0.0168907978,
0.0086460263,
-0.0201589055,
0.0349796899,
0.0612329505,
0.0113543076,
-0.0120526226,
-0.0944679603,
0.0170498118,
0.0105481241,
0.0126321213,
-0.0306207649,
0.0165130608,
-0.029736178,
0.0486165546,
-0.0371818468,
0.0525804497,
-0.017389195,
-0.0109203523,
0.0759180263,
0.0680684373,
0.0009818706,
0.0194404572,
-0.048466742,
0.0141753862,
-0.0327938758,
0.0542434454,
0.0513582155,
-0.0302297529,
0.0482268631,
-0.034638904,
0.0026179329,
-0.0098157683,
-0.0510096475,
-0.0110353818,
-0.0462006405,
0.0542306863,
-0.0320169218,
-0.0566770621,
0.0399906933,
0.0395305343,
0.0244621001,
0.0516799092,
-0.0381019041,
-0.0227641985,
-0.031231476,
0.007203042,
-0.0035606376,
-0.0317895934,
-0.086857453,
-0.0650943071,
0.0285010338,
-0.025876252,
0.01170839,
0.0196642131,
-0.0128293345,
-0.0441124327,
-0.000358612,
0.0828420669,
0.0242857877,
0.0050058095,
0.0659773648,
-0.0199753866,
0.0275855064,
0.0603012368,
0.019665394,
-0.0083227819,
0.0122115305,
0.0116034094,
0.0138660064,
-0.0141690802,
-0.0497225262,
-0.0331493951,
0.0080260849,
0.0377768166,
-0.0294582527,
-0.0269494392,
0.0213766545,
0.0085946051,
0.0706586093,
-0.0722677186,
-0.0175795723,
-0.0042946609,
0.0260071065,
0.0092695169,
-0.006786176,
0.026441969,
-0.0132824769,
0.0237456523,
-0.0012221185,
-0.0125006232,
-0.0151694827,
-0.0437690951,
0.0117828175,
-0.0262757577,
0.0443449505,
-0.034880206,
-0.0000311349,
0.0026669535,
0.0096285697,
-0.0279924404,
0.0037930915,
0.032157518,
0.0613992922,
0.0187451765,
0.0778478384,
0.0098457308,
-0.0057626902,
0.0214292761,
0.0228880178,
-0.0186275523,
-0.062514469,
-0.0325011835,
0.0301058516,
0.0205947775,
-0.0150403166,
0.000730441,
-0.0278477203,
0.0277785454,
-0.0016373371,
0.0119053619,
-0.0331763104,
-0.0059144874,
0.0203933977,
0.0157924909,
0.0237354264,
-0.009179187,
0.0419524834,
-0.0562167764,
0.0143057099,
-0.0377715789,
-0.0015024825,
-0.0372743867,
-0.0126446541,
0.051896628,
0.0760764182,
0.0023220016,
-0.0485258251,
-0.086937204,
-0.0242394395,
0.0302563943,
0.0067965384,
0.01478724,
-0.0347512141,
0.0510190986,
0.0265303012,
-0.0490500815,
0.003231995,
0.0044629495,
0.0100042028,
-0.0700869635,
-0.025848994,
0.0189647954,
-5.928741675e-33,
-0.0403813012,
-0.0539910495,
0.0143302837,
0.0371790119,
0.0115522193,
-0.0160944164,
-0.0093477247,
0.0255504064,
0.008381865,
-0.0269415528,
-0.0090250643,
-0.0275991056,
0.0003651386,
0.0011306321,
0.0503036976,
-0.0183323827,
0.0224238932,
0.0349496789,
-0.028881235,
0.0250916686,
0.0435839333,
-0.0007956597,
0.08799465,
-0.0477656014,
0.0576702021,
-0.011792724,
0.0192016996,
-0.0351587832,
-0.0775878429,
0.0524739958,
-0.0164672006,
0.0648149624,
-0.0236370154,
-0.0162350815,
-0.0123173743,
-0.0231538266,
-0.0036097099,
-0.0696931332,
0.0457012467,
-0.0263867397,
-0.0080154035,
-0.0760146081,
0.0511175208,
-0.0036633222,
-0.0795351416,
0.0002412242,
0.0709948614,
-0.0038464468,
-0.0433885083,
0.0127116162,
-0.0257573687,
-0.0051509249,
-0.0198902357,
0.0036361266,
-0.016811654,
-0.0225686319,
0.009921506,
0.038148772,
-0.0526555553,
0.0529932119,
0.0609369278,
0.0315447263,
0.1015188247,
0.0370999761,
-0.0220254231,
0.0729282945,
0.0386121087,
-0.0140041383,
0.0199628454,
-0.0084374482,
0.0173652116,
0.0188126396,
0.0941524431,
0.0558207333,
0.0756711438,
0.0004141399,
0.0020544862,
0.0586438775,
0.0075507723,
0.0036258351,
-0.0069915699,
0.0131947445,
-0.0329397321,
-0.0102653066,
-0.0357450098,
0.0123538831,
-0.0077890777,
-0.0545305759,
0.0243813042,
-0.0474490784,
-0.0291451756,
-0.012016952,
-0.030053962,
0.0166572854,
-0.0225634724,
-0.021065155,
0.0168384034,
-0.0015771987,
-0.0109420642,
-0.0514559522,
-0.0631005242,
0.017141005,
-0.019722905,
-0.027661141,
0.0329601541,
0.0287186429,
-0.0103170434,
0.0205587223,
-0.0468986221,
-0.0074102632,
-0.018614471,
-0.0464709029,
0.0462681502,
-0.1415568441,
0.0255553387,
0.0039857044,
-0.0107367421,
0.0796861574,
0.0149541991,
-0.0353720933,
-0.0044697314,
-0.0326308571,
-0.0407345816,
-0.006031231,
-0.0040565738,
-0.0014386079,
-0.0034730837,
-0.0123391403,
0.0044535305,
-0.0172330365,
0.0138693312,
0.0136695774,
2.702e-7,
0.0185068268,
0.0446300991,
-0.0127593735,
-0.058295656,
-0.0468324572,
0.0515229441,
-0.0197635237,
-0.0430161767,
0.0305089261,
-0.0234579146,
0.0204688404,
0.0192888174,
-0.0077549322,
0.0284369513,
-0.0749012157,
-0.0206735712,
0.002892019,
0.0018611712,
-0.0349735394,
0.0302084051,
0.0675840229,
-0.0176785346,
0.0496747904,
-0.0138484193,
-0.0362291001,
-0.0229470488,
0.0177738275,
-0.0909848437,
0.0197156873,
0.0087471772,
0.0289743394,
0.0102525642,
0.0006422778,
0.0036485293,
-0.0097950082,
-0.0384165905,
-0.0128069501,
0.0252011083,
0.0249389764,
-0.0575698614,
-0.0135660795,
-0.0007833308,
0.0125955287,
-0.0226719566,
0.0069476068,
-0.0056122993,
0.0143202469,
0.0331326947,
-0.0415104926,
-0.0222178362,
0.0216918178,
-0.0175762754,
0.0152384657,
-0.0178695582,
-0.0527526699,
0.0143952956,
-0.0233288314,
-0.0455364101,
0.0056175645,
0.0544519424,
0.0248511564,
-0.0400256589,
-0.0491398387,
-0.0255262088,
-0.0137660224,
-0.0391993932,
-0.036285989,
1.943084585e-34,
-0.0033381856,
-0.0313129947,
0.0599210113,
0.0479573123,
-0.0046703508,
0.0103602605,
0.0082843089,
0.0361515433,
0.0549757704,
-0.0327060558,
-0.0119662583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15334v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15334v1 | Multimodal Task Vectors Enable Many-Shot Multimodal In-Context Learning | 2024-06-21T17:50:02 | 2024-06-21T17:50:02 | Brandon Huang, Chancharik Mitra, Assaf Arbelle, Leonid Karlinsky, Trevor Darrell, Roei Herzig | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The recent success of interleaved Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) in few-shot
learning suggests that in-context learning (ICL) with many examples can be
promising for learning new tasks. However, this many-shot multimodal ICL
setting has one crucial problem: it is fundamentally limited by the model's
context length set at pretraining. The problem is especially prominent in the
multimodal domain, which processes both text and images, requiring additional
tokens. This motivates the need for a multimodal method to compress many shots
into fewer tokens without finetuning. In this work, we enable LMMs to perform
multimodal, many-shot in-context learning by leveraging Multimodal Task Vectors
(MTV)--compact implicit representations of in-context examples compressed in
the model's attention heads. Specifically, we first demonstrate the existence
of such MTV in LMMs and then leverage these extracted MTV to enable many-shot
in-context learning for various vision-and-language tasks. Our experiments
suggest that MTV can scale in performance with the number of compressed shots
and generalize to similar out-of-domain tasks without additional context length
for inference. | [
-0.0249858815,
0.0190036017,
0.0067463326,
0.0388964564,
-0.0230262149,
-0.0038685198,
0.0619096793,
-0.0064524016,
-0.055918362,
-0.0832372159,
-0.0567571595,
-0.0294465553,
-0.0033691539,
-0.0137257222,
0.0724109337,
-0.042585548,
0.0363621339,
-0.0126742003,
0.0063766893,
0.0182830915,
0.0446619652,
0.0087393131,
-0.0098255081,
0.0585590228,
-0.0288406946,
-0.0713209212,
-0.0283744279,
0.0288236178,
0.0266624205,
-0.0304190423,
0.0082511855,
0.0211594403,
0.0445453413,
-0.0024889275,
0.0000019953,
-0.0115031563,
0.0123286797,
-0.0104603861,
-0.0059045893,
-0.0067637227,
0.0186198056,
-0.0286420286,
0.0274143796,
-0.0318707004,
-0.0091652889,
-0.0269070733,
0.0540550984,
0.0214631893,
0.0690526664,
0.0547542609,
-0.0329317749,
-0.0141020231,
-0.033785142,
-0.0433047302,
0.039515458,
-0.0429875813,
-0.016572265,
-0.0287839379,
-0.0196923483,
0.0178222544,
-0.057944987,
0.0319634117,
0.0233835615,
0.0219660476,
0.0329308957,
0.0500761606,
-0.017437445,
-0.0267712474,
-0.0192168783,
0.0859490037,
-0.0571281314,
0.0041503212,
-0.0235877503,
-0.0290067364,
0.0207273196,
-0.0193169285,
-0.0812871531,
0.0136903338,
-0.0187269729,
0.0217233542,
-0.0546930432,
0.0279543884,
0.0155170495,
-0.0225085225,
-0.0086667035,
-0.0448595956,
-0.0203693751,
0.0236490145,
-0.0109489746,
-0.0111922938,
-0.0737516731,
-0.0279416982,
-0.032211978,
0.0252316836,
-0.0445394963,
-0.0064015933,
-0.0636093915,
-0.058352638,
0.0075006932,
-0.0052965125,
0.0973559991,
0.0152370483,
-0.0501893982,
0.0719148442,
-0.0223693307,
0.0124499025,
-0.0429558717,
0.0217330307,
-0.0208031684,
-0.0223134607,
-0.045767691,
0.0083029056,
-0.0302761458,
0.0067617069,
-0.0063438504,
-0.0310383011,
-0.0110253105,
0.0405073985,
-0.0217541717,
-0.0096194595,
-0.0258635879,
-0.0035193786,
-0.0416883752,
-0.0144436797,
0.00792454,
0.0499772243,
-0.0350273214,
0.0394446477,
0.0023708388,
-0.0029391339,
-0.0336886942,
0.0333955586,
0.0390468389,
-0.067341283,
-0.0116295256,
0.0755903795,
-0.0353408344,
-0.0775737688,
-0.0103299646,
-0.0469706841,
-0.0287510008,
-0.0599512644,
0.0343185253,
-0.0335720181,
0.046937082,
-0.0216089133,
0.0275620148,
-0.0056544458,
-0.0017732212,
0.0282157175,
-0.0170693286,
0.0702438205,
0.06299261,
-0.0047339639,
0.0095969066,
0.0026320363,
-0.0159771126,
0.0767304897,
-0.0062685814,
0.0199491214,
0.0143504003,
0.0087276064,
0.0149183935,
0.0288298074,
0.0506605804,
0.0184482075,
-0.0204205103,
-0.0080152638,
0.0398933925,
0.0207076184,
0.0668958127,
0.0165836029,
-0.0525437221,
-0.0222635455,
0.0729936361,
0.0278592501,
0.0123583712,
-0.0268404037,
0.0563222319,
-0.0201379526,
-0.003054658,
-0.0015617228,
-0.0614580363,
0.0874044448,
0.0078166351,
-0.002171681,
0.0583215281,
0.034379743,
-0.0468962751,
-0.007545318,
0.0196915194,
-0.019450618,
-0.0089736385,
0.0200542491,
0.0484110601,
0.0268862229,
-0.0550981574,
0.0008348854,
0.0247528609,
-0.0017051409,
-0.0353037454,
-0.0098110465,
-0.0037171491,
0.0327805728,
0.0227857418,
-0.0273582619,
-0.0397974961,
-0.025527671,
0.0771087036,
0.0320118926,
-0.0242670309,
-0.0036772052,
0.0639459714,
-0.0383408256,
-0.0303072166,
-0.0490682647,
0.0017204725,
-0.0213466212,
-0.0074611967,
0.0132884961,
0.0015006571,
-0.0245443825,
0.0588780381,
0.0400421619,
-0.0032809505,
-0.015502708,
-0.0182217509,
0.0259096902,
0.0240677316,
-0.0223350376,
-0.004067054,
-0.0033271287,
0.0123947728,
-0.0665664822,
0.0094858864,
0.0066348389,
-0.0638188869,
-0.0779898241,
0.0030887148,
-0.0519149564,
0.0095150974,
-0.0248400364,
-0.0431154259,
0.0254325327,
-0.0026770942,
-0.0236706622,
0.0138054751,
-0.0273076259,
-0.0130552193,
0.0263609737,
0.048219379,
-0.0031268594,
0.016510617,
-0.0373980477,
-0.0169489644,
0.0266770013,
0.0081664799,
-0.0006298505,
0.0083197281,
-0.0230803937,
-0.0199606828,
-0.0044909189,
0.0006106867,
-0.0012576673,
0.0040447619,
-0.0327787101,
0.0402730145,
-0.1054099575,
-0.0077070566,
-0.012871705,
-0.0219593514,
-0.0214523077,
0.0032096228,
0.0264627934,
-0.0484458618,
0.0060513895,
0.0266826637,
-0.0166635532,
0.0398671068,
0.0249170251,
0.0140169905,
0.0273773335,
-0.0071989708,
-0.0054942123,
0.0185400452,
0.09858118,
-0.0597295091,
-0.0207424648,
-0.0211818181,
-0.0096178418,
-0.0067371703,
0.0179218799,
-0.0283026453,
0.0016036008,
0.0225265417,
-0.02958644,
0.0696175247,
0.0994367972,
0.0044394252,
0.0291886441,
0.0246552769,
-0.0207117796,
-0.0295174327,
0.0233079921,
0.0118781608,
-0.0024809712,
-0.0104570873,
0.0236907061,
0.0071332278,
0.0439846441,
-0.022700198,
-0.0073765251,
-0.0475871786,
0.0239437371,
0.0125890896,
-0.0459899083,
-0.0577395186,
0.0320368744,
-0.0055548097,
-0.0079085696,
-0.0383696854,
-0.0329864845,
0.0369973555,
-0.0094548734,
-0.0286043491,
0.0063472865,
0.0123705165,
-0.0049079997,
0.0701629147,
0.0092653958,
0.0230263304,
0.0326496251,
0.0074372585,
-0.0592047162,
0.0167040341,
0.0109910108,
0.0365405753,
0.0550444089,
0.0135137867,
-0.0065982593,
-0.0311219897,
-0.0355198272,
-0.0060191862,
-0.0661819726,
-0.0060828058,
-0.0090879351,
-0.0558220483,
0.0417852439,
-0.0305870324,
-0.001974531,
0.0533540361,
0.049755998,
0.0041452437,
-0.0283236653,
-0.0066276267,
0.0463717543,
0.0219937712,
0.0261493456,
-0.051425606,
-0.0523051098,
0.0120124565,
0.0531380251,
0.0275842082,
-0.01251713,
-0.0256031826,
0.014935378,
0.0025377206,
0.040283028,
-0.0127939936,
0.0486434661,
0.0729873553,
-0.0619462244,
0.0012936125,
0.0394229293,
-0.0053996854,
-0.0665490329,
0.0071562631,
0.0274079442,
-0.0197820179,
0.0499811508,
0.0088087451,
-0.0818543658,
-0.0891563892,
-0.0060232528,
-0.035556756,
0.0324441232,
0.0078113843,
-0.0261338148,
-0.0921277031,
0.026306849,
0.014027697,
-0.0444224514,
-0.0107121961,
-0.0103323925,
0.005776172,
0.0230794698,
-0.0021045113,
0.0157755576,
-0.0020356888,
-0.0199419148,
-0.0032858648,
0.0626031086,
-0.0630251095,
0.033281792,
-0.0418509692,
0.0041514081,
0.0271207392,
0.0104209613,
0.0156759266,
-0.0254468378,
0.0222050138,
0.0184375215,
0.0151827987,
0.0115590189,
0.0559084788,
-0.0564698577,
-0.0339003392,
0.0107938442,
0.035167072,
-0.0006533198,
-0.0457198992,
-0.0157333557,
0.0862306431,
-0.0049915011,
0.0001291256,
-0.0474878997,
-0.0422006845,
0.0084297182,
0.0185884703,
0.0239811372,
-0.0616888963,
-0.0098999841,
0.0096050883,
-0.0296381954,
-0.0264157541,
0.0149216792,
0.0246407744,
-0.014542181,
-0.0053201821,
-0.0448059514,
-0.0196180101,
0.0432628319,
0.0642513111,
-0.0388170034,
-0.018763002,
-0.025986338,
0.0427818671,
-0.0635380894,
0.0417382009,
-0.01812803,
0.0353246629,
-0.0325138308,
0.0249305442,
0.0328769833,
-0.0117878914,
-0.0101745017,
0.0632559285,
-0.1136762202,
-0.0166136287,
-0.0371734202,
0.050180532,
-0.0023331211,
0.0516349934,
0.0289428178,
-0.0200912766,
0.0685897768,
0.0216489192,
-0.0204286035,
0.0538904406,
0.0345100276,
-0.0048218602,
0.0072579859,
0.0429871194,
-0.0530207902,
0.0226417258,
-0.00288455,
0.0125834355,
-0.0069181691,
0.0341168046,
0.0194638111,
-0.0462921448,
0.070310086,
-0.0355263464,
0.0097259972,
0.007730105,
0.013843799,
0.0091691716,
-0.0179363489,
-0.0564405769,
-0.009869691,
-0.0119501641,
-0.0071599972,
0.0118486192,
0.0229928847,
0.0539831966,
0.0386055335,
-0.0409965776,
0.0061690696,
0.0009571728,
-0.0282577369,
0.0027526526,
0.0530482531,
-0.0011364153,
-0.0158673581,
-0.0335604921,
-0.0091795614,
-0.0426159129,
0.0624733344,
0.0400379412,
-0.004638934,
-0.0649564937,
0.0355344675,
-0.0141197462,
0.0584462136,
-0.0520722866,
0.0212666448,
0.0526455753,
0.0102653019,
0.0010856114,
0.0251900814,
-0.0256541185,
-0.0312333405,
0.0573039576,
-0.0164297726,
-0.0309444256,
0.0184695274,
0.022174228,
0.0220755618,
-0.0201192778,
0.1043335795,
-0.005911239,
0.0260722507,
0.0038293072,
0.0290546883,
-0.0543089211,
-0.0079977624,
0.0392348059,
0.0496144891,
0.0268538203,
0.015275646,
-0.0096101444,
-0.0542134345,
0.006422563,
-0.013810087,
-0.0376983136,
0.0120032085,
0.0340534896,
0.037264999,
0.0348260924,
-0.0332548656,
0.0033566591,
-0.0197853222,
0.0181182865,
0.001413677,
0.0231579132,
-6.148517609e-33,
-0.0278262496,
-0.0278104506,
0.0284503661,
-0.043263223,
-0.0336466134,
0.0198898204,
-0.0269842222,
-0.0080838166,
0.0039262031,
-0.0074956324,
-0.0001126429,
-0.0122260014,
-0.007589391,
0.0321994573,
0.036265526,
0.0030686453,
0.0329015553,
-0.0185431484,
0.0122384261,
0.0161777548,
0.0274636038,
0.0239738282,
0.0691214725,
0.0214517377,
-0.0062966938,
0.0117430901,
-0.0456987992,
0.0017461337,
0.0094704591,
0.0571866632,
-0.0340071507,
0.0086888466,
0.0231035817,
-0.0470589958,
-0.0472944789,
0.0436465479,
-0.0865337104,
-0.0158297233,
-0.0066622407,
0.0139965713,
-0.0718060061,
-0.0294140689,
0.0525036529,
-0.0096730795,
0.0352022052,
-0.0322631188,
0.0251741037,
-0.0077416878,
-0.0009297109,
-0.0227011256,
-0.0565467514,
-0.0113586979,
-0.0247978624,
-0.0374770612,
0.0331942923,
0.0511450581,
0.0101928031,
0.0402889289,
-0.0419084243,
-0.014061817,
-0.0885475129,
0.0098953843,
0.0494843759,
0.0381136425,
0.0194560532,
0.0537819378,
0.0015918057,
-0.0122900298,
-0.0207741018,
0.0035099415,
0.0441880859,
0.035796158,
-0.0067523434,
0.0856111795,
0.062307898,
0.0249926355,
-0.0610307343,
-0.0100613264,
-0.0024380134,
0.0480306186,
0.0419594049,
0.0267453231,
0.0216386933,
-0.0058223289,
-0.0004158672,
-0.0212677121,
-0.0375629477,
-0.0110685527,
0.0476648211,
0.0307834614,
0.016043324,
0.0441407971,
0.1106579378,
-0.0259550195,
-0.0248499382,
0.0232300721,
-0.0174888931,
0.0569442064,
0.0121328989,
-0.0068599479,
-0.0425882451,
-0.018531736,
0.0549319908,
-0.0004216146,
0.0313787945,
0.0041474705,
0.082581006,
0.0481733829,
-0.0457461216,
-0.0320162363,
-0.0238638204,
-0.0100392979,
-0.0027670688,
0.0477734581,
0.0382007509,
0.0133081861,
-0.0598535612,
0.0308961254,
-0.0007056178,
-0.0638040528,
-0.0073114615,
-0.0281435698,
-0.014083026,
0.0207005907,
0.0024322271,
0.0017489484,
-0.0463175774,
-0.0547940321,
0.0423816703,
-0.0675881207,
-0.0214767568,
0.040454641,
2.659e-7,
0.0074278833,
0.0251163226,
-0.0231549907,
-0.0126608787,
0.0327271037,
0.0496732667,
-0.0193930641,
0.064343974,
-0.0157943033,
-0.0362490863,
0.0110460678,
0.0400598645,
0.0162382759,
0.0182944778,
-0.0542829037,
0.0091551663,
-0.025911171,
-0.0081624184,
-0.0429584198,
-0.0179705545,
0.0137378452,
0.1028008983,
0.0194315128,
-0.0076483227,
0.0313623883,
-0.0423383266,
0.0835390389,
-0.0048700129,
0.0010713002,
-0.0473524407,
-0.0472392291,
0.0031248906,
-0.0113591794,
0.024686439,
0.0020637857,
-0.0127498433,
0.0546142496,
0.0490517393,
-0.0292114597,
-0.0535516366,
-0.0211842097,
0.0282511264,
-0.0322366655,
-0.0186366905,
0.0790605769,
-0.0984900296,
-0.0309535172,
-0.0575449392,
-0.0310386848,
0.0097571453,
0.0118336556,
0.0020563358,
-0.0263495259,
0.0070599373,
0.0350289643,
0.0047419784,
-0.0350249633,
-0.1018452719,
-0.0525903739,
0.0531309955,
-0.0511297025,
-0.0048514265,
-0.0550893135,
-0.0448769219,
0.0518678389,
-0.0473097637,
-0.0596678555,
1.88676199e-34,
0.0157316197,
-0.0136705032,
0.0265464354,
0.0246983171,
-0.0304708239,
-0.0389253609,
-0.0633674189,
-0.0118739363,
0.0248016529,
-0.0274665747,
-0.0266180467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15330v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15330v1 | Gradient-Mask Tuning Elevates the Upper Limits of LLM Performance | 2024-06-21T17:42:52 | 2024-06-21T17:42:52 | Haoling Li, Xin Zhang, Xiao Liu, Yeyun Gong, Yifan Wang, Yujiu Yang, Qi Chen, Peng Cheng | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized lots of fields of research.
Although it is well-known that fine-tuning is essential for enhancing the
capabilities of LLMs, existing research suggests that there is potential
redundancy in the fine-tuning process and therefore proposes to update only a
subset of parameters. However, these methods fail to leverage the task-specific
information to identify important parameters during training. Based on the
insight that gradients inherently contain information on task-specific data, we
propose Gradient-Mask Tuning (GMT), a method that selectively updates
parameters during training based on their gradient information. Specifically,
we compute the absolute values of the gradients and apply masking to those with
relatively smaller magnitudes. Our empirical results across various tasks
demonstrate that GMT not only outperforms traditional fine-tuning methods but
also elevates the upper limits of LLM performance. Further analysis indicates
that GMT exhibits insensitivity to mask ratio and possesses computational
efficiency comparable to vanilla SFT. | [
0.013263165,
0.0413640104,
-0.0074367058,
0.0519672371,
-0.009693238,
0.0092630927,
-0.000094199,
0.0152271837,
-0.0223355647,
-0.0372543223,
-0.0763127655,
-0.05136168,
0.0217569638,
-0.007847935,
0.058188118,
-0.052837614,
0.0427466817,
-0.0540398024,
-0.045389656,
0.0028567212,
-0.0199019685,
0.0079450021,
0.004853962,
0.0368667506,
0.0360474773,
-0.0152269471,
0.0328609906,
0.0369183943,
0.0360415988,
0.0146011412,
0.0435481146,
0.029494619,
0.0221279096,
0.0120060891,
0.0000020458,
-0.029527897,
0.0168092325,
-0.0088501396,
-0.028447099,
0.043394614,
0.0347708836,
-0.0198502596,
-0.0300380867,
0.034668576,
-0.0390904471,
-0.0072673662,
0.037373662,
0.0193770397,
0.036289122,
0.0895774737,
-0.0088199098,
-0.0347684585,
0.0191119816,
-0.0611488298,
-0.0077967094,
-0.0384190008,
0.0198047403,
-0.0128205493,
-0.0503909476,
-0.0116567714,
-0.0442022532,
0.0396072417,
0.0008399756,
0.009798144,
0.0286528841,
0.0464409366,
-0.0165165253,
0.0067436695,
-0.0061960397,
0.0498279706,
-0.0853620768,
-0.006072165,
0.0186866093,
-0.0166559126,
-0.0353732854,
-0.038893681,
-0.0368139632,
0.0034037922,
0.0308436938,
0.0390186384,
-0.0022162863,
-0.0242424738,
0.0578859933,
0.0214227121,
-0.0271960814,
0.0246378575,
0.0063050399,
-0.004468956,
-0.028041251,
-0.0207770616,
-0.0526631363,
-0.055945687,
0.0240152609,
0.0366414748,
-0.0251403749,
0.0098418212,
-0.0662009493,
-0.0516521968,
-0.0053262203,
-0.0011995414,
0.0754152983,
0.0589140542,
-0.0028666141,
0.0600572303,
-0.0405127257,
0.0452803969,
-0.0311234668,
0.0197959151,
-0.0350799002,
-0.0051121134,
-0.0018051054,
-0.0221735965,
-0.0135241523,
-0.0010448029,
-0.0490708761,
-0.0055336445,
-0.0059663891,
0.0093259159,
0.0087374859,
-0.007065108,
0.0349660702,
-0.0383254178,
-0.0499076322,
-0.0195644312,
0.0095366305,
-0.0136822434,
-0.0103942128,
0.017353097,
0.005345827,
-0.0245661512,
-0.0275254864,
0.0156965554,
0.0181719419,
-0.0322976671,
0.0167329907,
0.0860837549,
-0.0276964847,
-0.013621469,
-0.0537652075,
0.0130031276,
0.0136640416,
-0.0629988909,
0.0102233086,
-0.0362013876,
0.0005743547,
0.0033067651,
0.0284991134,
-0.0402564779,
-0.0039077057,
0.0164109692,
-0.006897381,
0.0676178932,
0.0120352069,
0.0078291111,
0.0398257561,
0.0117592989,
-0.0141094774,
0.0837710947,
0.0423696302,
0.0288195089,
0.0134726427,
-0.0121396016,
-0.0205579791,
0.0508520417,
0.0124401432,
0.0196981113,
-0.0211325679,
-0.0294842497,
0.0190813802,
0.0065033305,
0.077976808,
0.056992352,
-0.051456593,
-0.042294804,
0.0905900374,
0.0356964096,
0.049706161,
0.028846249,
0.026788095,
-0.0029452897,
0.0047737854,
0.0131217791,
-0.0412471071,
0.0049195979,
0.0038830149,
0.0024314495,
0.003056013,
0.0578184687,
-0.0384603031,
-0.0344689824,
-0.0292653441,
-0.0090170735,
0.0134477066,
0.022744013,
0.0384638347,
0.0079718074,
-0.0375818498,
0.0391583629,
0.0093153501,
-0.0203961786,
0.0120006669,
-0.0487149917,
-0.0021081546,
0.049792394,
0.0378657654,
-0.0245530438,
-0.0374923609,
-0.0023676243,
0.0287848692,
0.0421651825,
0.029686043,
0.0112750921,
0.0574026294,
-0.0936335921,
0.0077151568,
-0.019334225,
0.0120138582,
0.0273339897,
0.0246161073,
-0.0009518188,
0.0404362716,
-0.0125278663,
-0.0141391382,
0.039073199,
-0.053604126,
-0.0425592028,
0.0235293917,
-0.0196129009,
0.0130701577,
-0.0209851116,
-0.0096144052,
-0.0135467155,
0.0012223294,
-0.060242407,
0.0043383776,
-0.027352063,
-0.0578267463,
-0.0183711108,
0.0211239252,
-0.0095990626,
0.0066210069,
0.0916274861,
-0.0409239344,
-0.0524147041,
-0.0002255516,
-0.0304731429,
0.0169948265,
-0.0349930339,
0.013876142,
-0.0069429833,
0.0372742899,
-0.0351062045,
0.0134260077,
-0.0095110247,
-0.0267486814,
0.04192679,
0.0176842175,
-0.0069905091,
-0.0332937166,
-0.020070171,
0.0062809912,
0.0125933141,
0.0122826956,
-0.0252519529,
0.0239341538,
-0.0277414173,
-0.0287781022,
-0.0894971117,
0.0210259128,
-0.0446754284,
0.0348851532,
0.0385274515,
0.0023839825,
-0.0113903424,
-0.0119490298,
-0.0225338843,
-0.0069298921,
-0.0469543338,
0.004593994,
0.0155596379,
0.0081640203,
-0.0157903321,
-0.0522229411,
-0.0290087871,
0.0200814735,
0.0240502041,
-0.0419344641,
-0.0370789096,
-0.0621447638,
0.0533208326,
-0.0015940488,
0.0478533022,
-0.027598314,
-0.0389264449,
-0.0155051192,
-0.0088962493,
0.0847961679,
0.1022098809,
0.0062894104,
0.0034316101,
0.0480700098,
-0.012163531,
-0.029191222,
0.0242509637,
-0.0224102587,
-0.0229682978,
-0.0473016314,
-0.03553693,
-0.0001630301,
0.0865135714,
0.0047341012,
0.0102985278,
-0.0669889823,
0.0019417856,
-0.0439922251,
-0.0209849402,
-0.0347851291,
0.0268532615,
-0.0477968715,
0.0118567972,
-0.0250260718,
-0.0596774518,
0.0358417779,
-0.0447075143,
-0.0229157656,
-0.0175142083,
-0.0191951487,
-0.0635779053,
0.0296619236,
0.0024341817,
0.0036140224,
0.0126449857,
-0.0422629118,
-0.0500011966,
-0.0105577391,
0.0200055763,
-0.0280557033,
0.0364648923,
-0.0444502831,
0.0062172851,
-0.0344171003,
-0.0467601568,
-0.0132660354,
-0.0414679572,
0.0021908705,
0.0290630385,
0.033694461,
-0.0411502123,
0.0003669722,
0.0229890682,
0.0091943359,
0.0826160833,
-0.0336599983,
0.0098057846,
-0.0354585275,
0.004862837,
0.0653835088,
0.0282116886,
0.0217949785,
-0.047397539,
0.000664321,
0.021268243,
0.0619030446,
0.0197050739,
-0.0435614251,
0.0107477475,
0.0541173257,
-0.0002383596,
-0.0262290612,
-0.0055549415,
0.0856627002,
-0.0751042888,
0.0102894092,
0.1100505143,
0.001143685,
-0.0573243275,
-0.0108687244,
0.009679622,
0.049282819,
0.0282998588,
0.0160958637,
-0.054490082,
-0.0320897624,
0.0132465577,
0.0393990017,
-0.0098793367,
0.0016893699,
-0.0237065982,
-0.075471729,
0.0342147872,
0.0328121074,
0.0011053846,
-0.0075348443,
-0.0326048993,
0.0170361195,
-0.0234247856,
0.0622684173,
0.0048633302,
-0.0232976805,
-0.0299246907,
0.0268835984,
-0.0323015004,
-0.0792385042,
0.0255058948,
-0.0129844937,
0.0229698196,
0.0528015718,
0.0010461608,
-0.0001102412,
-0.0251092501,
0.0746921599,
-0.0188479405,
0.0254816916,
-0.0516987629,
0.0362281203,
-0.0209366754,
-0.027350083,
0.0105362944,
0.0278868973,
-0.0255045574,
-0.0030324089,
-0.0072600697,
0.0356787965,
-0.0072006779,
0.0118584344,
0.0089346031,
-0.0467202626,
-0.00511635,
0.056267824,
0.0518232435,
-0.0634860024,
-0.0126116658,
-0.025840126,
-0.0098021002,
-0.0539970025,
-0.0161504783,
-0.0151143093,
-0.0151998643,
-0.0143367397,
-0.0440810025,
0.0062895739,
0.0156086646,
0.0043935822,
-0.0032476296,
0.0068776184,
0.0159512777,
-0.0150331603,
-0.0559403598,
0.0487555489,
-0.0577176772,
0.0270743873,
-0.0534966849,
-0.0214945953,
0.052762311,
-0.0145075973,
-0.0042391629,
0.0166911501,
-0.1309655756,
-0.0814873129,
-0.0155764045,
0.0370348617,
0.0222742204,
0.0485414565,
-0.0037623055,
-0.1046236157,
0.0222999025,
-0.0040753777,
-0.0062199831,
0.0800204724,
0.0454671644,
-0.0379028395,
-0.0025392487,
0.0385761745,
-0.0309721045,
0.0132465186,
0.0508160256,
0.0428030528,
-0.007413581,
0.0360157266,
-0.0209549125,
-0.0277129412,
0.0598371588,
-0.0058119623,
-0.0053854724,
-0.0363244824,
0.0349955894,
0.0125081511,
0.0121500986,
-0.0508483276,
-0.0066315075,
0.0338988118,
0.0128959632,
-0.0273462385,
0.0452479571,
0.0193761028,
0.0271103997,
-0.0725995079,
0.0247249566,
-0.053739544,
-0.0018195657,
0.0378510021,
0.013121957,
-0.0365945585,
0.0233256351,
0.0133153545,
-0.0019243336,
0.0114918035,
0.0300015807,
0.0238814298,
-0.0013458703,
-0.0471165814,
0.0456989743,
-0.0653828382,
-0.0599691235,
-0.0335244648,
0.0107672643,
0.081301868,
0.0049382164,
0.0693815351,
-0.0108680213,
-0.0197627284,
-0.0339835025,
-0.0060516004,
0.0057442337,
0.0156494789,
0.0260529853,
0.017270118,
-0.020872388,
0.0210934803,
0.0750959367,
0.0280322004,
0.0282625332,
-0.0141792689,
0.0122815631,
-0.0187766943,
-0.0106575256,
0.018820852,
0.0270307455,
-0.0098970477,
-0.0047769663,
-0.0076875929,
-0.0652593747,
0.0126423426,
-0.0052516032,
0.0003454799,
-0.0252838191,
0.027899174,
0.0399155766,
-0.0161900297,
-0.0208196733,
-0.0409615859,
-0.0278351735,
-0.0001734767,
-0.0018597352,
0.0015776401,
-6.81973921e-33,
-0.0390403643,
-0.0042612869,
0.0108128628,
0.0465416834,
-0.0428214408,
0.0125574162,
-0.0372354537,
-0.0003099749,
-0.0261547584,
-0.0188774541,
-0.0201749727,
0.0117672859,
0.0294102803,
0.0290593877,
-0.0379797667,
-0.0039670714,
0.0630029365,
-0.0015531739,
-0.0260335431,
-0.0008636166,
-0.0004168816,
0.0435712561,
0.0678647906,
-0.0447369665,
-0.0361060277,
0.0078571653,
-0.0264489073,
0.0095133279,
-0.0031627703,
0.0675561801,
-0.0288188569,
0.0508443303,
0.0232241377,
-0.0485908203,
-0.0534525253,
0.0050878646,
-0.0734988004,
-0.0131418342,
0.0272986107,
0.0282669514,
-0.0460084192,
-0.0307833347,
0.066972129,
0.0108189126,
-0.0252610892,
-0.0257826392,
0.0120198624,
-0.0371940397,
-0.0335934311,
-0.0395126604,
-0.0303268321,
0.0454158112,
0.0276086442,
-0.0247599874,
0.0629135594,
-0.0137465009,
-0.0183323678,
0.0044180094,
-0.0564079955,
-0.0313437954,
0.0440520793,
0.0914255604,
0.0513613634,
0.0887327343,
0.0241048858,
0.0329118781,
0.045352187,
0.0390104838,
0.0116804829,
-0.0148594016,
0.0659587234,
-0.0023731149,
0.021323977,
-0.0056210109,
0.014201194,
-0.0193168689,
-0.0618877597,
-0.0280784592,
-0.0125152562,
0.0288419742,
0.0434022099,
0.0626416802,
0.0079408372,
-0.0176582765,
-0.0706650242,
0.0085477084,
-0.0347686857,
0.0157986693,
0.0338957049,
0.0486217365,
-0.0128154112,
0.0129066957,
0.0298364162,
-0.0130748888,
0.022570217,
-0.0133046973,
0.0032571845,
0.040193893,
0.010290361,
0.016884191,
-0.0637704208,
-0.0407675542,
0.0156907588,
0.0079524191,
0.0174773969,
-0.0147486823,
0.015211246,
0.0484054051,
-0.057957869,
-0.025161488,
-0.0345592313,
0.0291403811,
-0.0013446237,
0.0716040879,
0.0260694828,
-0.021899676,
-0.0016393554,
0.0977406576,
0.0133342799,
-0.0087523265,
-0.0271391496,
0.0043127686,
0.0165576916,
0.0404931568,
-0.0321340673,
0.0033517496,
-0.0074530556,
0.0000801471,
0.0497165322,
-0.0272475183,
-0.0278228745,
0.0204387438,
2.627e-7,
0.0109445974,
0.0307441503,
-0.0130863283,
0.0488484651,
0.0393996388,
0.0245324597,
0.0035389401,
0.0011206639,
0.0145313134,
-0.0131002162,
-0.0011918624,
0.0514938794,
0.0752623901,
0.0048962063,
-0.0722893178,
0.0120319277,
-0.0370591916,
0.0110035306,
-0.0270987302,
-0.007922614,
-0.0157493278,
0.0953038186,
0.0273010414,
-0.0072010295,
0.0300847068,
-0.0242524724,
0.0811355188,
-0.0615232363,
-0.0028280003,
0.0276204776,
0.0254871175,
0.0366481952,
-0.0227162298,
-0.0033024182,
-0.0199937392,
0.0288220197,
-0.01451011,
0.1068462804,
-0.0174874701,
-0.014274722,
0.0108542917,
0.017736664,
-0.011559926,
-0.0622648597,
0.0702177584,
-0.0410382934,
-0.0028294642,
-0.057570722,
0.0241781045,
-0.0149873393,
0.0186581202,
-0.0520114005,
-0.0388360359,
0.011221596,
0.039045807,
-0.0037998222,
-0.0500123203,
-0.1040788963,
-0.0304131601,
0.0148636336,
-0.0638362691,
-0.0520485677,
-0.0627479702,
-0.0136871357,
0.0155772045,
-0.0611295477,
-0.0167420153,
2.698116546e-34,
0.0374284424,
-0.0466618054,
0.012779356,
0.0437512994,
0.0174806379,
0.0214106161,
-0.0487239584,
0.0177799072,
0.0128868306,
-0.0937255397,
-0.0333024673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15319v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15319v2 | LongRAG: Enhancing Retrieval-Augmented Generation with Long-context LLMs | 2024-06-21T17:23:21 | 2024-06-30T15:01:36 | Ziyan Jiang, Xueguang Ma, Wenhu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In traditional RAG framework, the basic retrieval units are normally short.
The common retrievers like DPR normally work with 100-word Wikipedia
paragraphs. Such a design forces the retriever to search over a large corpus to
find the `needle' unit. In contrast, the readers only need to extract answers
from the short retrieved units. Such an imbalanced `heavy' retriever and
`light' reader design can lead to sub-optimal performance. In order to
alleviate the imbalance, we propose a new framework LongRAG, consisting of a
`long retriever' and a `long reader'. LongRAG processes the entire Wikipedia
into 4K-token units, which is 30x longer than before. By increasing the unit
size, we significantly reduce the total units from 22M to 700K. This
significantly lowers the burden of retriever, which leads to a remarkable
retrieval score: answer recall@1=71% on NQ (previously 52%) and answer
recall@2=72% (previously 47%) on HotpotQA (full-wiki). Then we feed the top-k
retrieved units ($\approx$ 30K tokens) to an existing long-context LLM to
perform zero-shot answer extraction. Without requiring any training, LongRAG
achieves an EM of 62.7% on NQ, which is the best known result. LongRAG also
achieves 64.3% on HotpotQA (full-wiki), which is on par of the SoTA model. Our
study offers insights into the future roadmap for combining RAG with
long-context LLMs. | [
0.054519102,
0.0009621201,
0.0096640019,
0.0397526436,
-0.0256684367,
0.0126877585,
-0.008586077,
0.029197054,
0.0126386769,
-0.0595760904,
0.00075798,
-0.0246096626,
-0.0424058735,
-0.0131930206,
0.0221243557,
0.0105902208,
0.0329957269,
-0.015731398,
0.0083204787,
-0.0198252387,
-0.0168920141,
0.0064423201,
-0.0223501287,
-0.0066030556,
0.0045845639,
0.0034363721,
-0.0379457697,
0.0159980468,
0.0152258361,
-0.0422144569,
0.0419760384,
0.0233213529,
0.0142482826,
0.0194082558,
0.0000018464,
-0.0692464411,
-0.0147858206,
0.0060945093,
-0.0504179783,
0.0008715641,
0.0068894811,
0.0191257838,
0.0308957417,
0.0029927911,
-0.0307520237,
0.0272118933,
-0.0091482047,
0.0604493842,
0.0405894443,
0.0743462443,
0.0167356618,
-0.0603032224,
0.0577443838,
-0.0289046094,
0.098642014,
-0.0208462086,
0.0174105223,
-0.0233427901,
0.0299420841,
0.0222932678,
-0.0067033111,
0.0306571797,
0.0266486183,
0.0047564008,
0.034055721,
0.0349873006,
-0.0603305884,
0.0044630002,
0.0046191295,
0.0771126971,
0.0614013411,
0.0026860384,
0.0336366929,
0.0317792036,
0.0140023781,
0.0229322445,
-0.0469149426,
0.0285908002,
-0.0169230867,
-0.0117908139,
0.0141349481,
-0.0116743241,
-0.0018042745,
0.0168272667,
-0.0368168689,
0.0697826669,
0.048538778,
-0.0326821096,
-0.0014214971,
0.0127280373,
0.0110577429,
-0.0186482854,
-0.0005335157,
0.0658022761,
-0.0140285566,
0.0164114144,
0.0025610074,
-0.0254674535,
0.0814455003,
-0.0101941628,
-0.0299832802,
0.0321204141,
-0.003789366,
0.0384667031,
-0.0566420481,
0.000840381,
-0.0268055666,
-0.0036987143,
-0.0306185707,
-0.0235939026,
-0.0377008803,
-0.0360165946,
-0.0220346693,
0.0750837848,
-0.0493518375,
-0.0177066531,
-0.0399745703,
0.0169211384,
0.0358209312,
-0.0154390568,
0.0097910194,
0.017300358,
-0.0545177497,
0.0384460837,
-0.0483405851,
0.0434520356,
-0.036192894,
0.009139671,
0.0468397513,
-0.0374038033,
-0.0072446871,
0.0060719247,
0.0364572741,
-0.0449313335,
0.0351076722,
0.0538005643,
-0.0057450891,
-0.0241736025,
-0.0473064743,
-0.0735367313,
-0.0178325158,
-0.0599891692,
0.0164380297,
-0.0947835594,
0.0337596796,
0.0334968753,
-0.0143982405,
0.0074257934,
0.0191677045,
0.0526009165,
-0.0205825865,
0.0179573912,
-0.0076286001,
-0.0047327001,
0.0424174033,
0.0280306581,
0.0305576753,
0.048251614,
-0.0080450159,
0.032757096,
0.0596295558,
0.0314558111,
-0.0136663113,
0.0016637493,
0.0496097803,
0.0182975549,
0.0321035124,
0.0360496119,
-0.0087852497,
0.0153961601,
0.0241163578,
0.054988604,
-0.0296992455,
-0.0118820416,
0.0132293934,
0.0365272388,
0.0537251346,
0.0097483937,
0.0450216904,
-0.0158427786,
0.0102787428,
0.0189444814,
-0.0219205357,
0.0291523412,
-0.0313831083,
0.0460415483,
0.0476841219,
0.0122676864,
-0.0326066278,
-0.0022405914,
0.0052133542,
0.0057374802,
-0.0560132079,
0.0241090581,
0.0397743769,
0.0042642653,
-0.0255459808,
0.0822764114,
0.0232888404,
-0.0696192682,
0.0416738912,
-0.0517291985,
0.064377591,
0.0499776304,
0.072037518,
-0.0272371657,
-0.0319709517,
0.0082674967,
-0.0015173291,
0.0425698273,
0.0181930792,
-0.0323587209,
0.0007401588,
-0.0299080275,
-0.0200938489,
-0.0125590041,
-0.0061803628,
-0.0056849075,
0.0490998216,
0.047228571,
0.0460414775,
-0.0585095808,
0.0124713387,
0.0287261605,
-0.039099291,
-0.0450751185,
-0.0162802003,
0.0098591726,
-0.0022423661,
0.0487901568,
-0.0174022764,
0.024360707,
0.0525347106,
-0.0510961972,
-0.0178929325,
-0.0512299947,
-0.0355121344,
-0.0590380467,
0.0485057421,
-0.0173932575,
0.002390312,
0.0140150553,
-0.0153140798,
-0.0314178653,
-0.0279251263,
-0.0200076103,
0.0161113422,
-0.0570879728,
-0.009658833,
0.0365182832,
0.0125677194,
-0.0766479671,
0.0675598234,
0.0188653301,
0.0182545017,
0.0448148996,
-0.0030598484,
-0.0002356754,
-0.0701628625,
-0.03597565,
0.0223700497,
-0.0143680405,
0.0050926819,
0.0218063742,
0.0014981101,
-0.1008380726,
-0.0198138338,
-0.094605431,
0.0320158899,
-0.0175678171,
0.025513133,
0.0116825029,
0.0248617902,
-0.0076065068,
-0.0032529337,
-0.0745768845,
-0.0073609897,
0.0245272089,
0.0341630057,
0.0306001212,
0.0419183597,
0.0235720575,
-0.0227404535,
-0.0387996919,
-0.0045366427,
0.0134092178,
0.012594033,
0.010605284,
-0.0401137583,
0.0474987961,
-0.051318828,
-0.0286760926,
0.0026229965,
-0.0068757432,
0.0051246863,
-0.0506503396,
0.0434473753,
0.0397134908,
0.0414231159,
-0.0162857845,
-0.0048223399,
-0.0281640235,
-0.0627504885,
0.0236806795,
-0.0349426717,
-0.0304633677,
0.0119897043,
-0.0018656021,
0.0279178638,
0.0128853042,
-0.0030159971,
-0.0203109588,
-0.0013438597,
-0.0004283006,
0.0190084837,
-0.0173994508,
-0.0407097787,
0.0221293885,
0.0015245287,
0.0317823924,
-0.0111381635,
0.004125115,
0.0702481866,
-0.0116231265,
0.0081616659,
-0.0394111872,
0.0221614819,
-0.0616529174,
0.0348721333,
-0.033888828,
-0.0000015115,
-0.0584740788,
-0.0088190921,
-0.036869362,
0.0001487491,
-0.0198459588,
-0.0600951351,
0.0738546476,
0.0100411698,
0.0290810373,
-0.054614637,
-0.01467783,
-0.0594386905,
-0.0275101028,
0.0329333916,
0.0145128826,
-0.0397844799,
0.0104971062,
0.0109891864,
-0.0222939868,
0.0491843596,
0.0015668004,
-0.0379366763,
-0.0123722758,
-0.0158702135,
0.0893790945,
0.0979665965,
-0.0054915701,
0.0233901236,
-0.002974991,
0.0325431302,
0.0716842487,
0.0566851534,
-0.0121544143,
0.0413354971,
-0.0172625259,
0.0352512524,
-0.0813432634,
0.0089932857,
0.0080163851,
0.0526480526,
-0.0616198033,
-0.035231065,
0.0813530236,
0.0258385148,
-0.0420269184,
-0.0228946619,
-0.0330495723,
0.0513196178,
0.012717355,
0.0455314182,
-0.0735602975,
-0.0175987612,
-0.005818639,
0.064904511,
-0.0144319385,
-0.0381328762,
0.0216095056,
-0.1340649575,
0.020290155,
0.0010689638,
-0.032621,
-0.0190649386,
-0.040611241,
-0.014248278,
0.0370638929,
0.0178248249,
0.0814501569,
-0.01825024,
0.0229808278,
0.0133222491,
0.0402310602,
0.0022623881,
0.0170658156,
-0.0276404005,
0.002352274,
0.0185958706,
0.0054668267,
-0.0023365023,
-0.0243606996,
0.0083784843,
-0.0650304258,
0.0025118082,
-0.0144775687,
0.0803832859,
-0.0312706158,
0.0018605104,
-0.0522892289,
0.036763262,
-0.0300391782,
-0.0135867298,
0.0400957875,
0.0498370863,
-0.0081674764,
0.0186027456,
-0.0476083122,
-0.0259853024,
0.0062720776,
0.0663043186,
0.0309485923,
-0.0017602105,
-0.0536661893,
-0.0170623697,
-0.0175407659,
-0.0658273548,
-0.0221130345,
0.0059834826,
-0.0230302662,
0.0068104933,
-0.0783971921,
-0.053417556,
0.0019123123,
0.0608985759,
-0.0074894652,
0.0374172814,
-0.0566923544,
0.0069865794,
-0.0910411105,
-0.0123105794,
-0.0564992689,
-0.0108840819,
-0.0490028337,
0.0004258797,
0.0492523089,
-0.037012957,
0.0145347835,
-0.0065271021,
-0.0589637086,
-0.0723542944,
0.0010230459,
0.0489203297,
0.0211363435,
0.0222956482,
0.0090467921,
-0.0140221659,
0.1082238927,
0.0577022135,
-0.0597204044,
0.0261121355,
-0.0298121683,
0.0304091573,
-0.0107371258,
0.0242810156,
-0.0823461562,
-0.0077721211,
-0.0036658228,
0.0757165998,
0.0198692344,
0.0041605034,
0.0012026726,
0.0704605058,
0.003682181,
0.001906218,
0.015744606,
-0.0240674373,
0.0414361097,
-0.0341741145,
-0.0084925173,
0.012659939,
0.0065964991,
-0.0107265608,
-0.0494920872,
0.0121675581,
0.0036201042,
0.0027933437,
0.0719920546,
-0.0498817898,
0.0129873864,
-0.0104113268,
-0.0028610553,
0.0261766352,
-0.0239857361,
-0.043553412,
-0.03444371,
-0.0073392307,
0.0616953559,
-0.0211858433,
0.0335779898,
0.0053394767,
-0.0310788844,
0.0002594262,
0.0196187645,
-0.0788969323,
-0.0174009446,
0.0016618181,
0.0180392098,
0.0187991615,
0.0052625979,
0.0362097919,
0.0093150223,
-0.0310826991,
-0.0281283949,
0.0112279523,
0.0026320147,
-0.0037140127,
0.0332726203,
0.042542927,
-0.0090277661,
0.0131236808,
0.0329743773,
-0.0100872945,
0.032978598,
0.006917316,
-0.0102206515,
-0.0272349399,
-0.0451495126,
-0.0118937772,
0.0026360049,
-0.0191797391,
-0.0341902636,
-0.0472849011,
-0.071429573,
0.0090753175,
0.0078950413,
-0.0112179108,
-0.009725851,
0.0188045297,
0.0598619841,
0.0303622503,
-0.0408074223,
-0.0633528754,
0.0719681382,
-0.0661605224,
-0.0167146362,
0.0169882569,
-6.284790832e-33,
-0.0307316612,
-0.0354041792,
0.0426607989,
-0.0121855335,
-0.0420451909,
0.0068880115,
-0.0334664769,
-0.0083657159,
-0.0252029169,
-0.0226947404,
-0.0252942853,
-0.0041890852,
0.0062650163,
0.0276086908,
-0.0007713705,
-0.0417089202,
0.0174600277,
0.0251725093,
-0.0319525488,
0.0288218036,
0.0610160157,
0.0418429747,
0.0272664074,
0.0005681642,
0.0031341834,
-0.0263976362,
0.0476505086,
0.0036485554,
-0.0058397423,
0.0657701045,
-0.0085808402,
0.0546927638,
0.0379713066,
-0.0210643224,
0.0124833537,
0.0232515559,
-0.1220751926,
-0.025733199,
-0.0172371659,
-0.0248388294,
-0.0280232094,
-0.0567309819,
0.0403924175,
-0.0237859264,
0.0186943524,
-0.0190534815,
0.0239101984,
-0.0142675415,
-0.0266709328,
-0.0396238044,
-0.0276481453,
0.0034776158,
0.0326648094,
0.0139200436,
-0.0321666785,
0.0440598726,
0.0201962553,
0.0517831258,
-0.0616401434,
0.0076904781,
-0.0188624635,
0.0646532476,
0.0357901677,
0.0050527132,
-0.0042799572,
0.0560808517,
0.0169872157,
-0.0153271155,
-0.0232707355,
-0.0231363587,
-0.0058052382,
0.0330601521,
0.015157951,
0.051145114,
0.0553299561,
-0.0083092395,
-0.1017231569,
0.0566566624,
0.0031906872,
0.0738464445,
0.0149861388,
-0.0208620466,
-0.031494271,
0.0078740148,
-0.0150783798,
0.0131768994,
-0.04479637,
-0.0342829339,
0.0646969751,
0.0177403521,
-0.0414806716,
-0.0042338977,
0.0442191325,
-0.0125798043,
0.0047513107,
0.0620441325,
-0.0250049718,
-0.0030592701,
-0.0362964049,
-0.0182043239,
-0.0267262962,
0.001288346,
0.022623647,
-0.0055868807,
-0.0247133784,
0.0001174856,
0.0181501079,
0.0183461942,
-0.0528884269,
-0.0143405329,
-0.0401182026,
0.0305465739,
0.007375191,
-0.0064318669,
0.0044383598,
0.0005215209,
0.0090197772,
0.0273134001,
0.0188182183,
-0.018474564,
-0.0350813605,
-0.0383598022,
0.0276873298,
0.0009788973,
-0.0267489888,
0.0365521982,
0.00163232,
0.0772661939,
-0.0202404652,
-0.0392513461,
0.0111410283,
0.0065417131,
2.607e-7,
0.0202343091,
-0.0151790008,
0.0567190833,
0.0101982979,
0.0039710677,
-0.0105081433,
0.0133791389,
0.0409232788,
0.0114490809,
-0.0189793464,
-0.0198062025,
0.0360925756,
0.0176014882,
0.0123228645,
-0.1014260352,
-0.0125231659,
-0.0123129608,
-0.0089027509,
-0.0526820645,
-0.0244919099,
0.0713088587,
0.0313795656,
-0.0129462332,
-0.0383235924,
-0.0120862806,
-0.0466550104,
0.0545619838,
0.0170166809,
-0.0181288496,
0.0405035391,
0.0477572456,
0.0124792336,
0.0267269891,
-0.0082471482,
-0.017299382,
0.0248099547,
-0.0100608952,
0.0498867743,
0.0101208007,
-0.1055897176,
0.0003246819,
-0.0359359756,
0.0261191539,
-0.0355817564,
0.072797671,
-0.0017277158,
-0.0194381718,
-0.0033747426,
-0.0380445346,
-0.0268814042,
-0.0206334237,
-0.0320036337,
-0.0205348916,
0.0273988619,
-0.016284151,
-0.0006980516,
-0.0017363835,
-0.0743886083,
-0.0222335737,
-0.0126437023,
-0.0453065336,
-0.074925907,
-0.034714587,
-0.0064995643,
-0.0317156054,
-0.0740454346,
-0.015224915,
2.40445946e-34,
0.0115488563,
-0.0022671043,
-0.0097877476,
0.0569775887,
0.0089686736,
-0.0149675198,
-0.0384531207,
0.0013277937,
0.0218262319,
-0.0845040902,
-0.035756696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15313v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15313v1 | STARD: A Chinese Statute Retrieval Dataset with Real Queries Issued by Non-professionals | 2024-06-21T17:10:09 | 2024-06-21T17:10:09 | Weihang Su, Yiran Hu, Anzhe Xie, Qingyao Ai, Zibing Que, Ning Zheng, Yun Liu, Weixing Shen, Yiqun Liu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Statute retrieval aims to find relevant statutory articles for specific
queries. This process is the basis of a wide range of legal applications such
as legal advice, automated judicial decisions, legal document drafting, etc.
Existing statute retrieval benchmarks focus on formal and professional queries
from sources like bar exams and legal case documents, thereby neglecting
non-professional queries from the general public, which often lack precise
legal terminology and references. To address this gap, we introduce the STAtute
Retrieval Dataset (STARD), a Chinese dataset comprising 1,543 query cases
collected from real-world legal consultations and 55,348 candidate statutory
articles. Unlike existing statute retrieval datasets, which primarily focus on
professional legal queries, STARD captures the complexity and diversity of real
queries from the general public. Through a comprehensive evaluation of various
retrieval baselines, we reveal that existing retrieval approaches all fall
short of these real queries issued by non-professional users. The best method
only achieves a Recall@100 of 0.907, suggesting the necessity for further
exploration and additional research in this area.
All the codes and datasets are available at:
https://github.com/oneal2000/STARD/tree/main | [
0.0816476718,
0.0204264373,
-0.0106133027,
-0.0175511185,
-0.0445695855,
0.0031715271,
0.0079716062,
0.0628430918,
0.0034515497,
-0.0241968893,
-0.0250876993,
-0.0112763848,
-0.0261952356,
-0.0122010773,
-0.0325692073,
-0.0523727611,
0.032567665,
0.0818502158,
0.061373625,
-0.0016615642,
0.0312368274,
0.012039151,
0.0279455408,
0.0320351385,
0.0010993278,
0.0164804999,
-0.0203319229,
0.0219631288,
0.0034415366,
-0.0118350824,
0.0197946541,
0.0503931195,
0.0210619476,
0.0116466228,
0.0000015154,
-0.0330999903,
-0.0197400413,
-0.0110163586,
-0.0217665974,
0.0387742706,
0.0607859902,
-0.016338598,
0.001522826,
0.011383716,
-0.056430392,
0.0247540101,
-0.0117588341,
-0.0147797512,
0.0296497624,
0.0919214413,
0.0032894756,
-0.0488926768,
-0.0006451576,
-0.0438125022,
0.0241725817,
-0.0644210726,
0.0106109157,
-0.0090166656,
0.0079240585,
-0.0052711545,
0.0289571844,
-0.0060047563,
0.0091000693,
-0.0391304828,
-0.0200891867,
-0.0041488474,
-0.0581319444,
0.0266785119,
0.0273125004,
0.0460457653,
0.0750072896,
-0.0487940498,
0.0275397543,
0.0129125649,
0.0403168648,
0.0528960004,
-0.0358384103,
0.0638414174,
-0.0510585792,
-0.0131616369,
0.0036241887,
0.007674214,
-0.0079770274,
0.0231533758,
-0.0133616552,
0.0193311218,
-0.0006118831,
-0.0417665653,
0.0144069819,
-0.0305397101,
0.034770146,
-0.0216641463,
0.0481668524,
0.026601756,
-0.025846146,
0.0152939176,
0.0119714299,
-0.0227860846,
0.0786710307,
-0.0417881086,
-0.0202434044,
-0.0012576522,
-0.0159193762,
0.1039189175,
-0.0411301851,
-0.0091125676,
0.0224535856,
0.0289620217,
-0.0208133012,
-0.0346792005,
-0.0497210138,
-0.0069803908,
-0.0610225238,
0.0674443021,
-0.0841798335,
0.0165640526,
-0.0014601189,
0.0025742145,
-0.0218148325,
0.0099169193,
0.0118602961,
0.0162622668,
-0.0232416652,
-0.036925558,
-0.0667864233,
-0.0407399014,
-0.0550716296,
0.029323861,
-0.018354129,
-0.0015201912,
0.0198286902,
0.0054729818,
0.0474997684,
0.0119338818,
0.0088765025,
0.0223013945,
-0.0029596125,
-0.0386051349,
-0.0423221402,
-0.0696201771,
0.0147357564,
-0.0179821048,
-0.0367029384,
-0.0306584407,
0.0032122543,
-0.0496169142,
-0.0285310373,
-0.0469102338,
0.010242898,
0.0739054158,
0.0113111073,
0.0284874272,
-0.0218958333,
-0.0124813244,
-0.0253347121,
0.0504640751,
0.040788129,
0.0043568392,
-0.0242695175,
0.0504201576,
0.066447407,
0.0190564021,
0.0227511507,
-0.0289180912,
0.0075641298,
0.020289341,
0.0123572228,
0.0661047921,
-0.0529597029,
0.0043275803,
-0.0002090037,
0.0196475405,
-0.0071416018,
-0.0364970528,
-0.022082407,
0.0421007648,
0.0063346261,
0.0223102458,
-0.0302418824,
0.0054445895,
0.015635822,
-0.0047748857,
-0.0185746755,
0.0264223255,
-0.0244341716,
0.0030014571,
-0.036557395,
-0.0436983481,
-0.0298205391,
-0.0655016154,
0.0118210679,
0.0429334156,
-0.0405809246,
0.0188957173,
0.0315269195,
0.0021096093,
-0.0202647373,
0.0331473798,
0.0019273089,
-0.0541488789,
-0.0220257193,
-0.0151146101,
0.0011201618,
0.029088201,
0.040923465,
-0.0734534189,
-0.0234015677,
0.0391428508,
0.0139642507,
0.0348048545,
0.0146865547,
-0.0339101329,
-0.0373559408,
-0.0477209352,
-0.0541263781,
0.0419350937,
0.0111666508,
-0.0132880257,
0.0332279168,
0.0215541665,
0.0423984155,
-0.0562897511,
0.0001444846,
0.0338028558,
-0.0091151251,
-0.0230328105,
0.0164109319,
0.0111022396,
0.0252618864,
0.0282979421,
-0.008268402,
-0.0109079173,
0.0501411706,
0.022750251,
-0.0173586942,
-0.0226578508,
0.024751801,
0.0164384618,
0.0199576337,
-0.0686615705,
-0.0063732043,
0.0089101,
-0.0485278815,
-0.0358223803,
-0.0491537713,
0.0161404926,
0.0286417007,
-0.0768567622,
-0.027347574,
-0.0144675616,
-0.0480435304,
-0.0233940464,
0.0344573185,
0.0016175725,
0.0006660609,
0.0145776244,
-0.0010899222,
0.0495606512,
-0.0241713636,
-0.0328282379,
-0.0495016798,
-0.0430746414,
0.0288827419,
0.0363866799,
-0.003395587,
-0.0596910939,
-0.0093027698,
-0.0469761193,
0.0322039314,
-0.0464783944,
0.0005645223,
0.0017618418,
-0.0340102836,
-0.0004111229,
-0.0441706739,
-0.0517729856,
-0.0036521389,
-0.0452443697,
-0.0224411041,
0.0163917672,
-0.0002229354,
-0.0042337817,
-0.0056514614,
-0.0205506869,
-0.01052038,
-0.022699764,
0.0193759743,
-0.0026476588,
0.0309775509,
0.0650314018,
-0.0192942396,
-0.0242851172,
-0.0494692512,
-0.002822587,
-0.0009526007,
-0.0205698982,
-0.0592239574,
0.023786569,
0.045955386,
0.0003587345,
0.0238856412,
0.0231868271,
-0.0515217297,
0.0183656458,
0.0077259112,
0.0211829972,
-0.0049314327,
-0.0020390379,
0.0614844225,
-0.0446741879,
0.0071482463,
0.0084813554,
-0.0414238274,
-0.0022396478,
0.0230302773,
0.0173486527,
-0.05533785,
0.0468818583,
-0.013328163,
0.0519256815,
-0.0014765017,
-0.0552011281,
0.0230673254,
0.0395680144,
0.0495383702,
-0.0291470531,
0.0215298682,
-0.0402160138,
0.1292650998,
-0.0195138361,
0.019299645,
-0.0390591808,
-0.0529448092,
0.0247013085,
0.0334472768,
0.0739679933,
-0.0707988441,
0.0561526679,
0.0182240345,
0.0567488223,
-0.04043632,
-0.050640177,
-0.0098756673,
-0.0430209748,
0.026560571,
0.0300190616,
-0.0234358758,
0.0032963841,
-0.028065281,
0.010273464,
-0.0534819104,
0.0312375054,
0.0197247081,
-0.0326039717,
-0.0162333343,
-0.0023537208,
0.0098248096,
-0.0161016025,
-0.0097255502,
0.0324281529,
-0.0088170366,
0.038896095,
0.0038519127,
0.0104997037,
0.0616600029,
-0.0081565566,
0.017346479,
-0.0905520767,
0.0097106313,
0.0292519256,
-0.0418879353,
-0.0694542453,
0.0203159042,
0.0666229725,
0.0567010194,
-0.041028928,
-0.0485916808,
-0.022310257,
-0.0186199509,
0.066688031,
0.0034420635,
-0.1223294586,
0.0194331203,
0.0319403,
0.0236732066,
-0.0375794806,
-0.0274103731,
0.0001924771,
-0.097198464,
0.1106623784,
0.0005246176,
0.0094557386,
-0.0558867417,
-0.0379952826,
0.021473892,
0.0068052169,
0.0090058437,
0.0362884291,
-0.037972521,
-0.0221800953,
0.006566349,
-0.0540785082,
-0.007523051,
0.0332696699,
-0.0467512012,
0.0157579388,
0.016173685,
0.0485305078,
-0.0048417272,
-0.0054786,
-0.012053513,
-0.0115693603,
-0.0202545617,
-0.0155059872,
0.0321364366,
0.0193830896,
0.0115671158,
-0.0550182052,
0.0389641225,
-0.0231151413,
0.008549531,
0.0627191216,
0.0028703383,
-0.0371303149,
0.0157392062,
-0.0366765521,
-0.0215807036,
-0.0327442959,
0.0682735369,
-0.0002542051,
0.044354897,
-0.0283432491,
-0.01990702,
-0.0131464032,
-0.0329551585,
-0.0230272636,
0.0266793855,
-0.025086103,
0.0141347731,
-0.0516454205,
-0.0221598838,
0.0119340597,
0.0610431172,
0.003149665,
0.0416954458,
0.0410506204,
-0.0195334572,
-0.0540105365,
-0.0040205531,
-0.0543048792,
-0.0189889036,
-0.0370145254,
0.0053125634,
-0.0047706505,
0.0252218843,
-0.0258225165,
-0.0520457029,
0.0395218432,
0.0022744939,
0.0008863591,
-0.0394073129,
0.0114729768,
-0.0057062698,
-0.054270044,
-0.0256814435,
0.0558741502,
0.0630452037,
-0.0076413816,
-0.0514030941,
0.0515886247,
-0.0515194349,
-0.0570718907,
0.0199403577,
-0.0386572666,
0.0062141269,
0.0039732349,
0.0375678167,
0.0051874453,
0.0415307358,
0.0454477668,
0.0758347884,
0.0277250502,
0.0388018377,
-0.0299308896,
-0.0359615237,
0.0209828746,
-0.0055367178,
-0.0288754255,
0.0054299724,
-0.0166052319,
0.0290930085,
-0.02178392,
-0.0224391874,
0.0853961185,
0.0003183952,
0.0183551032,
-0.081701383,
0.0251702294,
0.0328155197,
0.0485271066,
-0.0074470048,
-0.0439596474,
-0.002962539,
0.0299752485,
-0.0095545063,
0.0652404279,
-0.0203956608,
0.0189050324,
0.0205281544,
0.0149424551,
-0.0002808991,
-0.0161196068,
-0.0515671447,
-0.0524103679,
-0.0199136212,
0.0216572527,
0.0551690198,
-0.0018759685,
-0.0325031951,
-0.030352952,
-0.0063723293,
-0.0048524803,
-0.0175316371,
0.0030632738,
-0.0216471031,
0.0366772898,
0.0172424261,
-0.0062483591,
0.0314713903,
0.060202539,
-0.0045998739,
0.0288561042,
0.0101760058,
-0.0294271633,
0.0097552836,
-0.0358826555,
0.0155713679,
0.0329569876,
-0.0340200588,
-0.0734138116,
-0.0646503791,
0.0073196585,
-0.0239616595,
0.0112406705,
-0.0107410736,
0.0325312279,
0.0145594524,
0.0606435202,
0.0307564326,
-0.0229958538,
-0.0429589674,
-0.0011956136,
-0.0496342145,
0.0048211804,
-0.0053048097,
-5.537022876e-33,
-0.0196495354,
-0.033437904,
0.0238594059,
0.0213650651,
0.021184219,
-0.0113222254,
-0.0242877118,
-0.0314282291,
-0.0426827781,
0.0195326265,
-0.0388788246,
0.0579089709,
0.0314405821,
-0.0027002275,
0.0384643972,
-0.0249756891,
0.0247597899,
0.015670808,
0.0051221289,
0.015589945,
0.0196206644,
0.027614858,
-0.0042511211,
-0.0584908575,
0.0406291932,
0.0514306277,
0.004350306,
-0.0128976218,
-0.0524708629,
0.0678144321,
0.0360302627,
0.0571832582,
0.038207259,
-0.0048920666,
0.0178239048,
0.0235978253,
-0.1338931769,
-0.0030810025,
-0.0120498482,
-0.0214443151,
0.0207703542,
0.0035407802,
0.0372730792,
-0.0103491126,
-0.0058977306,
0.0021932034,
0.0307977386,
-0.0248787142,
-0.0621651933,
-0.0913359374,
-0.0258389488,
0.0418037772,
0.0058901929,
0.0545627996,
-0.0070723402,
0.0194965564,
0.0284191724,
0.0680200458,
-0.0788270682,
-0.0004849968,
-0.0546073951,
0.0295605995,
-0.0106838085,
-0.0594298393,
0.0128447432,
0.0177652836,
0.0054255812,
0.0104360804,
-0.0205778126,
-0.0188446306,
0.0257275496,
0.0779265687,
0.0173077285,
0.0470474623,
0.0697062016,
-0.0498447791,
-0.0596391782,
0.0063425479,
0.0470511988,
0.0619995594,
0.0294955838,
-0.0260104518,
-0.0491149984,
0.0113588488,
-0.0297275335,
-0.0300691854,
-0.0083999541,
0.0152465859,
0.0350869074,
0.0485042334,
0.0376637913,
-0.0378205068,
-0.0234705508,
-0.0291072968,
0.0172468387,
0.0298141744,
0.0197989624,
0.00356647,
-0.0198388565,
0.0369395874,
-0.0548827648,
-0.0443645716,
0.0163340066,
-0.0382809713,
-0.0428983383,
-0.0248736553,
0.0168170836,
-0.0372029655,
-0.0575411245,
-0.0053577018,
0.0377466567,
-0.016664898,
0.0168555677,
0.0197361466,
0.0255863741,
0.0361302309,
0.0506793223,
0.0164211839,
0.0132741444,
0.0080108158,
-0.0605009571,
-0.0395385697,
-0.0176491961,
-0.0505825467,
0.0274035577,
0.0284417383,
0.0006486813,
-0.0093682054,
0.0275708865,
0.0322924443,
0.0112564526,
0.071989879,
2.298e-7,
0.0723608658,
0.0127806412,
-0.0332276598,
0.0447513387,
-0.0397769995,
-0.0119426642,
0.0106502501,
0.0442879796,
-0.0179262348,
-0.0286126826,
0.0656493008,
-0.0218237974,
0.0441863835,
0.0396895409,
-0.1074884012,
-0.0363802761,
-0.0380570404,
-0.0473797657,
-0.0258681308,
0.0337242708,
0.0104913916,
0.0645084456,
-0.0151227443,
-0.0282146763,
0.0095918188,
-0.045955874,
0.0358294025,
-0.0009702363,
-0.0001541195,
0.0080360929,
0.0935948268,
0.0076897042,
-0.018530909,
-0.0017447495,
-0.0053136614,
0.0521397814,
-0.032493934,
0.0888228938,
0.0136840744,
0.0223959219,
-0.0243351478,
-0.0528808571,
0.0423223712,
0.0082788039,
0.0511543453,
0.0428602286,
0.0274839476,
0.0202211421,
-0.0323792063,
-0.0086705172,
0.0049713701,
0.0371472538,
-0.0296051931,
-0.0243087653,
0.0243815519,
-0.0096748592,
0.0360076986,
-0.115879178,
0.027138399,
0.020541897,
-0.0055294773,
0.0183265675,
0.020082837,
0.0072274529,
0.0002841089,
-0.0547384396,
0.0105771609,
1.88535817e-34,
0.0379714444,
-0.0070861136,
-0.0081999814,
0.0220364109,
0.033378277,
0.0206266884,
-0.0485249758,
-0.0053107571,
-0.0240820292,
-0.0618208833,
0.0211397447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15294v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15294v1 | NLP-KG: A System for Exploratory Search of Scientific Literature in Natural Language Processing | 2024-06-21T16:38:22 | 2024-06-21T16:38:22 | Tim Schopf, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL | Scientific literature searches are often exploratory, whereby users are not
yet familiar with a particular field or concept but are interested in learning
more about it. However, existing systems for scientific literature search are
typically tailored to keyword-based lookup searches, limiting the possibilities
for exploration. We propose NLP-KG, a feature-rich system designed to support
the exploration of research literature in unfamiliar natural language
processing (NLP) fields. In addition to a semantic search, NLP-KG allows users
to easily find survey papers that provide a quick introduction to a field of
interest. Further, a Fields of Study hierarchy graph enables users to
familiarize themselves with a field and its related areas. Finally, a chat
interface allows users to ask questions about unfamiliar concepts or specific
articles in NLP and obtain answers grounded in knowledge retrieved from
scientific publications. Our system provides users with comprehensive
exploration possibilities, supporting them in investigating the relationships
between different fields, understanding unfamiliar concepts in NLP, and finding
relevant research literature. Demo, video, and code are available at:
https://github.com/NLP-Knowledge-Graph/NLP-KG-WebApp. | [
0.0805608258,
-0.0138990944,
-0.0246930327,
-0.0138700753,
-0.030207647,
0.0008064039,
0.0025534637,
0.0208840296,
0.0495496839,
-0.0653824508,
0.0018558006,
0.0326765291,
0.0204249416,
0.0763070509,
-0.0072627333,
-0.0537533723,
0.0443329141,
0.0238356125,
0.0740127042,
0.0367803723,
0.0177521836,
0.010169629,
-0.0348131545,
0.047622025,
0.0285939332,
-0.0119925216,
-0.0133654224,
-0.0188657846,
-0.0106916362,
-0.0847073719,
0.0155316405,
0.0215289537,
0.0145758493,
0.0546604767,
0.0000019511,
-0.0597725809,
-0.0553063415,
0.0312093943,
0.0053574028,
-0.0307498612,
0.1152807921,
0.008925369,
0.0137430895,
-0.0085517224,
-0.0084250905,
-0.008989525,
0.0780513585,
0.0482857786,
-0.0039413278,
0.0332347825,
-0.0029180578,
-0.0568951555,
-0.015498952,
0.0420825928,
0.0368891433,
0.0031989121,
0.0290165097,
-0.0213788562,
0.0891998187,
0.0369201526,
0.0146793528,
0.0121349376,
-0.0706691146,
-0.0310488362,
0.076266259,
0.0338268653,
-0.0149006229,
-0.0521461628,
-0.0188509785,
0.0132018048,
-0.0036405865,
-0.0235205963,
0.0403370932,
-0.0224848222,
-0.0407444537,
0.0584543906,
-0.0507396646,
0.0041461969,
-0.0183466431,
-0.0419436581,
0.0081493296,
-0.0004695098,
0.0243378896,
0.0142104644,
0.0358374678,
0.0697850883,
0.0143123558,
-0.0399054065,
0.018060958,
-0.0092381798,
0.0195007753,
-0.0309379008,
0.0487036966,
0.0186650474,
-0.0351487659,
0.0292158462,
0.0212287735,
-0.0391597077,
0.0804165602,
-0.020868754,
-0.0133072296,
-0.0054301289,
0.0074999761,
0.0283862706,
0.0443778969,
-0.0232131649,
0.0148896445,
-0.0510911755,
0.0141500765,
-0.0145753156,
-0.0789303854,
-0.0557924621,
-0.0045967163,
0.0006853074,
-0.0346901789,
-0.0323731489,
-0.0158141758,
0.0057541858,
0.0006280302,
-0.0102896104,
-0.0123474682,
0.0499027148,
-0.0263911691,
0.0439908467,
-0.0523640774,
0.050443992,
-0.0420695581,
0.0068282266,
-0.0164942872,
-0.0021675366,
0.027991794,
-0.0080864243,
0.0320951603,
-0.00031945,
0.0178630129,
0.0141882673,
0.0584374294,
-0.0689093545,
-0.0161883757,
-0.0246341862,
0.0236182008,
-0.0164411962,
0.0283420533,
-0.0577817187,
0.032322187,
0.0062920991,
0.0066480218,
0.006100921,
0.0217632335,
0.0652868599,
-0.0245796647,
0.0667466372,
-0.0773195326,
-0.0223501269,
0.0385204926,
-0.0039429488,
0.0222362224,
0.0459508933,
-0.0139870085,
-0.0358936824,
0.0863734484,
-0.0151067302,
0.0163634103,
-0.0461156555,
-0.0266271066,
-0.0689178631,
0.0372910723,
0.0055883811,
-0.0730096474,
0.0500690937,
-0.0479729362,
0.0137201138,
0.0022573518,
0.0114765866,
-0.0464940332,
0.1307788938,
0.0161548126,
0.0049961265,
0.0076826056,
0.0553373471,
0.011140774,
-0.0431107357,
0.0178992189,
0.0201181117,
-0.0385814123,
-0.0130137792,
-0.0347977579,
0.0397088379,
0.0367094763,
-0.0039066756,
-0.0374291837,
0.065781638,
0.0324550867,
-0.0390557274,
0.0486332215,
0.0193709973,
0.0208205245,
-0.0266985558,
0.0365874246,
-0.0117398929,
-0.0114639634,
0.0063990215,
-0.0057080756,
0.0797810033,
0.0670274869,
-0.0569278076,
0.0018071589,
-0.0073501407,
-0.0519176908,
0.0397293791,
-0.0084500676,
-0.0148265874,
-0.0133997463,
-0.0035992824,
-0.0180330463,
0.0105089433,
-0.0080898181,
-0.0419039056,
0.0111145265,
0.0290386137,
-0.025993729,
-0.0440662317,
-0.0337469801,
0.0565203093,
-0.0185956918,
-0.0050966283,
-0.0083080158,
-0.0262385756,
0.0048878375,
0.0574535243,
0.0194453765,
0.0405388065,
0.0708035007,
-0.003300091,
-0.0383267626,
0.0065307682,
0.0681535453,
-0.0100130429,
0.0266565029,
-0.0785612687,
-0.0194264986,
-0.0103276093,
-0.000579826,
-0.0160133466,
0.0299191121,
-0.0379778519,
0.057048291,
0.0051429747,
-0.0017088972,
-0.0258864481,
-0.0104255294,
-0.0511465259,
0.0746770799,
0.0359626561,
0.0579698719,
-0.0135618998,
-0.047034014,
-0.0127941733,
-0.0094224904,
-0.0367391072,
0.0180482753,
-0.0089421887,
-0.0129807293,
0.0737400502,
-0.0186736248,
-0.0755285248,
0.0294188689,
-0.0836164504,
0.031820979,
0.028508164,
0.010298836,
-0.0018725391,
0.023079956,
-0.0152738346,
-0.0310167111,
0.0044270409,
0.0106978808,
0.0264474843,
-0.0118032023,
0.0500238314,
0.0069708521,
0.0242664162,
-0.0488399193,
-0.0217750538,
-0.0500195809,
0.0389273055,
0.040691115,
-0.0264635906,
-0.0266231447,
0.0092420503,
-0.0084448159,
0.003069028,
0.0017644226,
0.0148173822,
0.0225464869,
0.0031390926,
-0.0074049113,
0.0416630879,
0.0171044022,
0.0696013346,
0.0526333787,
-0.0298129003,
-0.0396458432,
0.0151561191,
-0.03395788,
0.0342408121,
-0.0027727573,
-0.0082980525,
0.0647832528,
0.0130859585,
-0.0272582136,
-0.0068317889,
0.0149611812,
0.0150276227,
-0.0199661795,
0.0056654466,
-0.0423801392,
0.0058195717,
0.0178508665,
0.0504419319,
0.0160792973,
0.0224990193,
0.0715914965,
0.0023068774,
-0.0077437847,
-0.1386996955,
-0.0194486156,
-0.0215440467,
0.0677179173,
-0.0012645404,
0.0121398289,
0.053692393,
-0.015548626,
0.0211876053,
0.0141592128,
-0.0041622655,
-0.0213794634,
-0.0217738654,
-0.0123432074,
-0.0036538679,
0.0188581664,
0.0215811264,
-0.0097155357,
-0.0189832002,
-0.0460304283,
0.0016184861,
0.0487350114,
-0.0563161708,
-0.0608330034,
-0.0185466632,
0.0596150346,
-0.001592811,
0.015816154,
-0.0524794012,
-0.0223403797,
0.0070216944,
0.0520717204,
-0.0275032967,
0.0473567247,
0.0552748814,
0.0052040182,
0.0626189485,
-0.0292631648,
-0.0158257242,
-0.0180359427,
-0.0279218648,
0.0229371451,
-0.1138684377,
-0.0102151064,
-0.0062215053,
-0.0125892954,
-0.0541114584,
0.0235575642,
0.0713791624,
0.0619159453,
-0.0527943037,
-0.0075780898,
-0.0458943434,
0.0068419594,
0.0535265282,
0.0419351421,
-0.0748805404,
-0.0054509221,
-0.0069956579,
0.0016024266,
-0.0479259975,
-0.0557648875,
-0.0099870181,
-0.0746090636,
0.019772673,
-0.0514448993,
-0.0067491019,
-0.0206673108,
-0.1074467897,
0.0086022513,
-0.0124317976,
-0.0337487347,
-0.0080591235,
-0.0764727294,
-0.006444437,
0.0007943262,
-0.0315769017,
-0.0772837028,
0.0328206904,
-0.0415108167,
0.0346850827,
0.0091557149,
0.0661645234,
-0.0155678224,
0.0199020244,
-0.0653487518,
0.0059986548,
0.0125257559,
-0.0271315761,
0.0120743997,
-0.0103083719,
0.0268654227,
-0.0677522719,
0.0122349868,
-0.0293113254,
-0.0172486026,
0.0275239293,
0.0752688497,
-0.024510026,
0.0162157472,
-0.0940403044,
-0.0046802573,
0.0112922527,
0.0439956114,
-0.0272668097,
-0.003061157,
-0.0306562781,
-0.0440509468,
0.0288642067,
0.0172663517,
-0.0745899975,
0.0250505973,
-0.0347780325,
-0.0109107578,
-0.047954116,
0.004272298,
0.0451771207,
-0.0194096677,
0.0147185996,
0.0345896818,
0.029122578,
0.0135554783,
-0.0737870857,
0.0193693526,
0.0302229691,
0.0224825628,
0.0091874255,
-0.0188252758,
0.0630339235,
0.016335465,
-0.0158373937,
0.0053388914,
-0.0033698052,
-0.0444995202,
-0.020499019,
-0.0108234836,
0.0135617005,
0.0028106796,
-0.0332703106,
-0.0430654362,
0.0045851455,
0.0290108342,
-0.0638724267,
-0.0409386493,
-0.0439098477,
0.0090808412,
-0.0044999439,
-0.0352928862,
-0.0274570119,
-0.0025681346,
-0.0724401847,
0.0147406291,
-0.0198334642,
-0.0278538968,
0.0283808392,
0.0333204232,
0.0420981795,
-0.0251989812,
0.013671577,
-0.0177579839,
-0.0385501757,
-0.0069875391,
-0.010737638,
-0.013426003,
-0.0037246277,
-0.0249250457,
-0.0125320395,
0.0124931224,
0.0415264405,
-0.0316349342,
0.0322256722,
-0.0020583582,
0.0820201859,
0.0391120613,
0.0008956143,
0.0195198972,
-0.0057697543,
-0.008264631,
-0.0203420036,
-0.0440565385,
0.0298418738,
-0.0158595052,
0.0094517702,
0.018140452,
-0.0503675155,
-0.0118406285,
0.0250752401,
-0.0757167339,
-0.0482430533,
0.0225838795,
-0.0036853005,
0.0102667129,
-0.0135994274,
-0.0011156477,
-0.0786198601,
-0.0018844574,
0.0176818278,
0.005008887,
-0.0201720018,
-0.0191828683,
0.0266026855,
0.026652379,
-0.0221375115,
-0.0314367563,
0.0538027994,
0.0376812518,
0.0161027908,
0.0232689381,
-0.0670334101,
-0.0107320761,
-0.0009363371,
0.0011834753,
0.0860572681,
-0.0191585366,
0.0246925633,
-0.0318601727,
0.0024761683,
0.0069491598,
-0.0303211939,
-0.0046739406,
-0.0381252281,
0.0817268565,
0.0492906943,
0.0190088507,
-0.0330708474,
-0.0387115814,
0.0422293693,
-0.0375090167,
-0.0360147133,
-0.0127927084,
-6.254914174e-33,
-0.0023184561,
-0.0792344883,
0.0106152222,
-0.0040021227,
0.0158453993,
-0.0135398712,
-0.0067222943,
-0.0029219927,
-0.0127807204,
0.0151428841,
-0.0289288256,
0.0210433174,
-0.0027754384,
-0.0026653917,
0.0315396115,
0.0409845971,
0.0327140801,
0.0069308924,
0.0218256079,
-0.0053996765,
0.0654814541,
0.0382775106,
0.0537426025,
-0.0922565758,
0.0419358835,
0.012487716,
0.0254054219,
0.0215696264,
0.0148677099,
0.0514912978,
-0.0418375805,
0.0404831059,
0.0082094381,
-0.0421104319,
0.0050025606,
0.004116809,
-0.0494716279,
-0.044876799,
0.0115229189,
0.0166284908,
-0.0170334373,
0.0147953508,
0.0522963479,
-0.0135489814,
0.0028958423,
0.0349023193,
0.0733897611,
-0.0145147191,
-0.0301812887,
-0.0097654378,
-0.0689339787,
0.0105511164,
-0.0346419811,
0.0404685624,
0.0367638692,
0.0286226273,
-0.0056198086,
0.0269279089,
-0.0219883379,
0.0281071458,
0.0170727726,
0.0303617995,
0.0017291586,
-0.0315373577,
0.0273892879,
0.0617300607,
-0.0401471928,
-0.0296487268,
0.0218559261,
-0.0115041109,
0.0114924051,
0.0367373489,
0.0039369748,
0.0325582139,
0.0475054085,
-0.0167534593,
-0.0131613174,
0.0118749253,
0.0490036011,
0.0304639004,
-0.0088178422,
0.0367204621,
0.0132422205,
-0.0053633526,
0.0132473977,
0.0048913336,
-0.028076956,
-0.0446277559,
-0.0248881318,
-0.0075565572,
-0.0019694006,
-0.0013897368,
-0.0390025862,
-0.0223588739,
-0.0128947068,
0.0372026451,
0.0357518531,
0.0183259696,
-0.0001651214,
-0.0103933522,
-0.0831080452,
-0.0017953848,
-0.0266358387,
-0.0089148683,
0.00722872,
-0.0085193878,
-0.0342719965,
-0.0200887192,
-0.0295084808,
0.0033683053,
0.0433554389,
0.0022747593,
-0.0173971485,
0.0038457834,
-0.0061597964,
0.0331366397,
-0.0009735882,
0.0536102802,
0.0693055093,
0.0485588834,
-0.0106004514,
-0.0206027031,
-0.0202899147,
0.0042158035,
-0.0082872435,
-0.0213598721,
-0.0474424511,
0.0114344275,
0.0252409335,
-0.0469759665,
0.0091236951,
-0.0276413057,
2.857e-7,
0.0460404865,
0.0856461301,
-0.0055297837,
0.0030540114,
0.0427413993,
0.005076115,
0.0375058018,
0.0321408249,
-0.025277378,
-0.0136992894,
-0.0153692886,
-0.038950555,
-0.0423505567,
0.0336965509,
-0.1077348441,
-0.0611597858,
-0.0512889735,
-0.041234903,
-0.0745197907,
0.0259630848,
0.0208747629,
0.0475491174,
-0.0086963801,
0.0335609019,
-0.0542564094,
-0.0201485232,
-0.0051956368,
0.001324487,
0.0469820872,
0.0267930925,
0.0209846534,
0.0292551089,
0.0204610117,
0.0101018539,
-0.0350384079,
0.0250305645,
-0.0133240391,
-0.0228935592,
-0.0378657505,
0.0009555062,
0.0511704981,
-0.0232458916,
0.0034636799,
-0.0512121916,
0.0320642516,
-0.035192728,
-0.0332581662,
-0.0317032635,
0.0004818024,
-0.0182929765,
0.0211398806,
-0.0544289835,
-0.0276944321,
0.0128340693,
-0.0281198956,
-0.0046141744,
-0.0383942202,
-0.0683892518,
0.018391788,
0.0349493213,
-0.0008676972,
0.002938916,
-0.0396797881,
-0.0383808278,
0.0103438012,
-0.0363149717,
0.0057552895,
2.504464412e-34,
0.0113243451,
0.0244513992,
-0.0354833938,
0.0406096168,
0.0350133255,
0.008247436,
-0.0288146921,
0.0303426534,
0.0166519955,
-0.0579484403,
0.0040002447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15284v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15284v1 | The Greek podcast corpus: Competitive speech models for low-resourced languages with weakly supervised data | 2024-06-21T16:28:47 | 2024-06-21T16:28:47 | Georgios Paraskevopoulos, Chara Tsoukala, Athanasios Katsamanis, Vassilis Katsouros | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | The development of speech technologies for languages with limited digital
representation poses significant challenges, primarily due to the scarcity of
available data. This issue is exacerbated in the era of large, data-intensive
models. Recent research has underscored the potential of leveraging weak
supervision to augment the pool of available data. In this study, we compile an
800-hour corpus of Modern Greek from podcasts and employ Whisper large-v3 to
generate silver transcriptions. This corpus is utilized to fine-tune our
models, aiming to assess the efficacy of this approach in enhancing ASR
performance. Our analysis spans 16 distinct podcast domains, alongside
evaluations on established datasets for Modern Greek. The findings indicate
consistent WER improvements, correlating with increases in both data volume and
model size. Our study confirms that assembling large, weakly supervised corpora
serves as a cost-effective strategy for advancing speech technologies in
under-resourced languages. | [
-0.0251231957,
0.0502534844,
-0.0103665618,
0.0119184107,
-0.0059016035,
-0.0086281439,
0.0493899696,
0.0155963749,
-0.0200153738,
0.0047870683,
-0.0710480362,
-0.0108620105,
0.0365767404,
0.0210883133,
0.0385044999,
-0.0145267807,
0.0179184098,
-0.0886143669,
-0.0118430639,
-0.0391550586,
0.0099131465,
0.0144828316,
-0.0443951823,
0.0112358946,
0.0046849861,
0.0486773923,
0.0145652816,
0.0002195077,
0.0147997029,
0.0169538688,
-0.049306605,
-0.0111230621,
0.0358312801,
0.0925292373,
0.0000017231,
-0.0420169644,
-0.0088517228,
0.040977709,
-0.0599601232,
0.006730278,
0.039000228,
-0.0049608639,
-0.0316671133,
0.0208361447,
-0.0163369905,
-0.0566878952,
0.0274126418,
-0.0023441524,
0.0025820166,
0.0702818781,
-0.0187960844,
-0.0177665148,
0.0214653686,
-0.0393122993,
-0.0151479933,
-0.0279384758,
-0.0243358836,
-0.0150739709,
-0.0227641445,
-0.0135617182,
0.0144938985,
0.0778548867,
0.0038144325,
-0.0381394699,
-0.027064085,
-0.0033830004,
-0.0746015012,
-0.0431591645,
-0.014406899,
0.0087103723,
0.0559161715,
-0.003088638,
0.0257706288,
0.0284053423,
-0.0247703418,
-0.0187636018,
-0.0417605899,
0.0165148638,
-0.0112740351,
0.0097374832,
0.0163183082,
0.0258826539,
0.0084729502,
-0.0204316955,
0.0162317324,
0.0409486331,
0.0287131052,
-0.0222832188,
0.0269784834,
0.0360723026,
-0.0284874775,
0.0106886756,
0.0437041931,
-0.017905267,
-0.0320816897,
-0.0204831827,
-0.0079963068,
-0.0577811524,
-0.0069800732,
0.028027406,
0.0363724232,
0.0448751673,
-0.0332208052,
0.0161911845,
-0.0220219549,
0.0464116409,
0.0433057807,
-0.0232493412,
-0.0040611452,
0.0054263314,
0.0008333986,
0.0089967931,
-0.0521079376,
0.0117186494,
-0.038434241,
-0.0284388363,
-0.0403147414,
-0.0112784253,
0.0170249306,
0.012816729,
0.0328071453,
-0.0570156127,
-0.0585039519,
0.003486654,
0.0404721685,
0.0422282182,
0.0064745047,
0.057300102,
0.0081570204,
-0.0642667934,
0.0233230367,
-0.0014092843,
0.0493738651,
-0.0013150071,
0.0030545492,
0.0480794981,
-0.0001393504,
-0.0318368226,
-0.0282558091,
-0.012164454,
-0.0565445423,
-0.0821754709,
-0.0276940335,
-0.0328033604,
0.03772071,
-0.0021601545,
0.0153681673,
0.0010381417,
-0.0213324614,
-0.0180140212,
0.0419636108,
0.0421682186,
-0.0421217903,
0.0269373022,
0.013859502,
-0.0229579322,
-0.0053568389,
0.0445607863,
0.0419320948,
-0.0304281022,
0.0335851684,
-0.0324868001,
-0.0580240637,
0.0745670572,
-0.0038633053,
0.033469487,
0.0057377424,
-0.0279326867,
0.0256271269,
0.0177556891,
0.0335082747,
0.0672662258,
-0.0206261836,
0.0168328676,
0.0965799168,
0.0423536599,
-0.0123724015,
0.0152047677,
0.0399202704,
-0.0036171221,
-0.0009155748,
-0.0020865179,
0.0134790568,
-0.0380899869,
0.025725523,
0.0426743403,
0.0536055118,
0.0565879606,
-0.0190010611,
-0.0232789796,
-0.0124134459,
-0.033514142,
-0.0282493979,
0.0623567551,
0.0660204217,
0.0175707452,
-0.0279360954,
0.0360709243,
0.0510471873,
-0.0834859237,
0.0138032651,
-0.0403790399,
0.0349869281,
0.0212296844,
0.0300324764,
-0.0283082295,
0.0019919481,
-0.0525362939,
0.0412186347,
0.0795183629,
0.0061587067,
0.0126786577,
0.0683073997,
-0.0618585236,
0.0028589831,
0.0291233547,
0.0240650419,
0.048559621,
-0.0172648318,
0.0272994787,
0.0123553071,
-0.0624290742,
-0.026026981,
-0.0146528399,
-0.0237817094,
-0.000854739,
-0.0013698168,
-0.0069593056,
0.043100331,
0.0370889194,
-0.0300612859,
-0.0032208203,
0.0254492052,
-0.0728326589,
0.0196419768,
0.0153719885,
-0.0687295347,
-0.0276470687,
0.0509848185,
-0.0226853918,
-0.0057131601,
0.0168938059,
0.0304973684,
-0.0614003502,
0.0473671854,
-0.0685850605,
0.0763841048,
-0.0176479965,
0.0422111899,
0.0383735634,
0.0179657396,
0.0281666592,
-0.0183172878,
0.0524935909,
0.0194260795,
0.0287871789,
-0.0259685442,
0.0115457401,
-0.0835873485,
0.0066519924,
0.013829452,
-0.0657842159,
-0.0082919747,
0.0260892119,
-0.0122418245,
0.00837381,
-0.021357242,
-0.0484463051,
-0.0112966606,
-0.0390489362,
0.0224468242,
-0.0234812312,
0.0315056033,
-0.0046346011,
0.0099129332,
-0.0166656319,
-0.0117353117,
-0.0046925028,
0.0178539306,
-0.0482661463,
0.0100732911,
-0.0295718946,
-0.0473550819,
-0.0065973499,
0.0278139524,
0.0024497602,
0.0406838395,
0.0088298451,
-0.0446795337,
0.0276898332,
0.0032936721,
0.0046979561,
-0.0098290518,
-0.0020420188,
0.0074172206,
0.0040828483,
0.0863114744,
-0.014784988,
-0.0611423254,
-0.0036536304,
-0.0033173026,
-0.0145263448,
-0.0589917377,
-0.0095884334,
0.0227938481,
-0.0388016291,
-0.081373103,
0.0177929401,
-0.0302969534,
0.0344475806,
0.0236268695,
0.0242630523,
-0.0405322872,
-0.0085922591,
-0.0338323936,
-0.0247395802,
0.023041578,
-0.0175358318,
-0.0279724281,
0.0248411931,
-0.0052264729,
-0.0154001219,
0.0276314896,
-0.0844412968,
-0.0435944162,
-0.0485414341,
-0.0745307431,
-0.0556762442,
-0.0014521264,
-0.0051076477,
0.0240733735,
0.0211494248,
-0.0387349539,
-0.0191860627,
0.0308165457,
0.0294468906,
-0.022114126,
0.0302002244,
-0.0101342592,
0.0289453585,
-0.0179390516,
-0.0565214977,
0.0283964016,
0.0114130005,
-0.0273263827,
0.0356822088,
0.044609338,
-0.0108194947,
-0.0508358292,
0.0424476564,
-0.0107662091,
0.0713430867,
-0.0067517664,
-0.0007944617,
-0.0182506628,
0.0510018505,
0.0267521106,
0.0019436892,
-0.0253119711,
-0.0104682129,
0.0389468782,
-0.0181179531,
0.0991427228,
0.0049188654,
-0.0455164276,
-0.0031347324,
0.0396261513,
-0.0059306771,
-0.0043788906,
0.0039934758,
0.0489643402,
-0.0154600656,
-0.0043334053,
0.0962006077,
-0.0216421857,
-0.046756044,
-0.001169843,
0.0200748425,
0.0660664514,
0.0178057849,
-0.0091264201,
-0.0427071452,
-0.0188658163,
0.0571993887,
0.0773626342,
0.0298884511,
0.0159933995,
-0.0004269495,
-0.0918552056,
0.0194289349,
0.0184750557,
-0.0525927767,
-0.0223328918,
-0.0727905035,
-0.0200595297,
-0.0536607057,
0.0334886163,
-0.0011992636,
-0.0295591485,
-0.0051233126,
0.0471257493,
-0.0655098632,
-0.0783374012,
-0.0135878073,
-0.0415019393,
0.0802786201,
0.0595734455,
0.0242950395,
-0.0322590694,
-0.0141603947,
0.0114793442,
0.0205463469,
-0.0052937786,
-0.030017443,
0.0316305868,
0.0227916632,
-0.0139052141,
0.0204714239,
0.0623212121,
-0.0064130146,
0.0021812215,
-0.0003266452,
0.0356102251,
-0.0129764816,
-0.0182960946,
0.0421263203,
-0.0005959927,
0.0175752398,
0.0446424596,
0.0223166142,
-0.014120236,
0.0209172815,
0.0209064912,
0.0623161867,
-0.0308971424,
-0.0093690287,
-0.0025495067,
0.0342722461,
-0.063075006,
-0.0342899784,
-0.0086729461,
0.0189246647,
0.0220646299,
0.0151803913,
-0.0026617576,
-0.0330948383,
0.0193413347,
-0.0250902772,
0.0138098076,
-0.022852581,
0.029924931,
-0.0454659872,
-0.0488699265,
0.0280191898,
-0.0097707426,
-0.0153678721,
0.0444407538,
-0.0843821838,
-0.0861384422,
0.0398199819,
0.01043233,
0.0238747448,
0.0368179977,
-0.0004946363,
-0.026530521,
0.0607216209,
0.0153962057,
-0.0509298891,
0.0318822153,
0.0411523543,
-0.0114031369,
-0.0131963361,
0.0510812365,
-0.0408450589,
0.0103875846,
0.0113290371,
0.0427512936,
-0.0119570559,
-0.0498507246,
0.0039006989,
0.0284810271,
0.0619700886,
-0.0407394618,
0.0172404367,
-0.0316593461,
-0.0006024967,
-0.0211760309,
0.0752240866,
-0.0231874418,
0.0069834096,
0.0223726481,
0.0383710004,
-0.0069570169,
0.0314372703,
-0.0304672234,
0.0029652487,
-0.0521629788,
0.0526226014,
0.0347192995,
-0.0795367137,
0.0269748326,
0.0391784124,
-0.0185150858,
0.065100871,
0.016570244,
0.0054647992,
-0.0193862934,
-0.0144853462,
-0.0121417828,
0.0210925825,
0.0486034639,
0.0044901134,
-0.0240763221,
-0.0378203616,
0.0078795077,
0.0184532348,
0.0637596548,
0.0056624962,
0.0944040716,
0.0000476492,
0.0086306063,
-0.0521375202,
0.0167919286,
-0.0275052413,
0.0179893747,
-0.0021497332,
0.0158638973,
-0.0272361413,
0.0702287033,
0.057217475,
0.0058124326,
0.0374192558,
0.0013980989,
0.0458618738,
-0.0306281988,
-0.0497817621,
-0.0451565497,
-0.0110366289,
-0.0404427014,
-0.0649577528,
-0.0031225202,
-0.0904324204,
-0.0151417339,
-0.0130099179,
-0.0246304572,
-0.0228748489,
0.0100516798,
-0.0059296112,
-0.0322896428,
0.0243131965,
0.0227008034,
-0.0517446138,
-0.0511097163,
-0.0275332369,
0.0203728136,
-5.917319911e-33,
-0.0185135528,
0.0634905249,
0.0067067132,
-0.0001957351,
-0.0296958387,
0.0353745967,
-0.0606277175,
0.0150297387,
0.0145871872,
0.003297349,
-0.0238682646,
-0.0101570096,
0.0397778414,
0.0294592325,
0.0024780754,
0.0071151615,
0.1011015698,
-0.0006565552,
0.001401386,
0.0073531531,
0.0118125137,
0.0529714301,
0.0274515618,
-0.0413976759,
-0.016236024,
0.020793546,
-0.0066694487,
-0.0303786583,
0.0220977496,
0.0742609054,
0.00965886,
0.0911519974,
-0.0350788049,
-0.0472848266,
-0.0238607749,
0.0374799781,
-0.0603265688,
0.0107981432,
-0.0045330152,
0.0815271735,
0.0404606164,
-0.0181786306,
-0.0278852899,
-0.0081737675,
-0.03719569,
-0.0197440051,
0.0287058223,
-0.0024524047,
-0.0360216498,
-0.0877482668,
-0.0045621558,
0.0298715457,
-0.0258677416,
-0.0221410692,
0.083407864,
0.0377567485,
-0.0002461428,
-0.0426645391,
-0.0442253053,
0.0479603969,
-0.0150944609,
0.0673686489,
0.0457560569,
-0.0109366989,
-0.0263111163,
0.0016174512,
0.0333358087,
-0.0564513206,
0.0506745838,
-0.0139124999,
0.0401927568,
0.0159701165,
0.033760827,
-0.0165528469,
0.0063050236,
-0.0243193936,
-0.0330152996,
-0.0538832173,
0.0447444655,
0.0159152579,
-0.007133143,
0.0300693158,
-0.0454449095,
-0.0060984828,
-0.0697372332,
-0.0685401484,
-0.0012473806,
-0.0079288865,
0.0421454012,
0.0051652351,
0.0079631526,
0.0267781187,
0.0471411794,
-0.0359997153,
-0.0254893415,
-0.0019926182,
-0.0109035494,
-0.0029142387,
-0.0406622663,
0.0082137175,
-0.0631853491,
-0.0073997704,
0.0320433117,
0.0365050808,
0.0175673496,
-0.0443480872,
0.007590231,
0.0666316822,
-0.076951392,
-0.0005091678,
0.001025878,
0.0300733857,
-0.0087323803,
0.012068606,
0.0337735079,
-0.016616581,
-0.0071872473,
0.0545701757,
-0.0023064252,
0.0281293821,
-0.0090675801,
0.0083857505,
0.0003819849,
0.0044709877,
-0.0404197387,
-0.0091528874,
-0.0041102106,
0.0104875416,
0.0618631914,
0.0080050891,
-0.0227353517,
-0.0064456584,
2.559e-7,
-0.0291246753,
0.010246723,
0.0040786406,
-0.0306901839,
0.0105946343,
0.0165652409,
-0.0213185195,
-0.0348528996,
-0.0145169646,
0.02440078,
-0.0214616582,
0.0020806913,
0.1255378574,
0.0413908958,
-0.112629056,
-0.0563367717,
-0.1064004153,
0.0199244283,
-0.057092011,
-0.0042386367,
-0.0037367991,
0.1019600481,
-0.0109085236,
-0.0628912896,
-0.0159436259,
-0.0530240349,
0.0029612845,
-0.0052860761,
-0.0082870182,
0.006858224,
0.0054595759,
0.0088679167,
-0.0203095842,
-0.0092454478,
-0.042553477,
0.0301012676,
-0.0066448976,
0.0310420617,
0.0141157489,
-0.0318910442,
0.0087413397,
0.0659096986,
-0.0436573327,
0.0145813711,
0.0311981812,
-0.0276953932,
-0.0245269239,
-0.0236126035,
-0.0446252562,
-0.030445585,
-0.0330019668,
-0.0230068546,
0.0047801691,
0.0072083492,
0.0270135254,
-0.0179024655,
-0.0397706963,
-0.0168775935,
0.0256421193,
0.0248645842,
-0.0626199394,
-0.0357615352,
-0.0294672623,
0.0276157018,
-0.0063924938,
0.0050254609,
-0.0003898295,
2.023209908e-34,
0.037995249,
-0.0187863503,
0.026799418,
0.0304930676,
-0.0101285642,
-0.043409463,
0.0267744102,
0.0113209048,
-0.0264677498,
-0.0498401783,
-0.0298876036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15279v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15279v1 | Cross-Modality Safety Alignment | 2024-06-21T16:14:15 | 2024-06-21T16:14:15 | Siyin Wang, Xingsong Ye, Qinyuan Cheng, Junwen Duan, Shimin Li, Jinlan Fu, Xipeng Qiu, Xuanjing Huang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | As Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) becomes increasingly integrated into
various facets of human life, ensuring the safety and ethical alignment of such
systems is paramount. Previous studies primarily focus on single-modality
threats, which may not suffice given the integrated and complex nature of
cross-modality interactions. We introduce a novel safety alignment challenge
called Safe Inputs but Unsafe Output (SIUO) to evaluate cross-modality safety
alignment. Specifically, it considers cases where single modalities are safe
independently but could potentially lead to unsafe or unethical outputs when
combined. To empirically investigate this problem, we developed the SIUO, a
cross-modality benchmark encompassing 9 critical safety domains, such as
self-harm, illegal activities, and privacy violations. Our findings reveal
substantial safety vulnerabilities in both closed- and open-source LVLMs, such
as GPT-4V and LLaVA, underscoring the inadequacy of current models to reliably
interpret and respond to complex, real-world scenarios. | [
-0.0292936582,
0.0536402762,
-0.0151177244,
0.0109235188,
-0.0572337583,
-0.0044158255,
0.0350642838,
-0.0267006941,
0.0450917222,
-0.0024354616,
-0.0079715047,
0.0092257252,
-0.0219196025,
0.0446979664,
0.0347145796,
0.0410743579,
0.0824566931,
-0.0382521637,
-0.0193711519,
0.0076916022,
-0.0034061212,
-0.0033148099,
-0.0065901694,
0.0270044859,
-0.0379282422,
-0.0121116936,
-0.0111768348,
0.0143599072,
0.0866479501,
-0.0064041107,
-0.0105305174,
-0.0009901067,
0.01254154,
0.0597720779,
0.0000018972,
-0.0576061495,
-0.0189321917,
0.0339704193,
0.0191289224,
-0.0658056736,
0.005744935,
-0.0194547717,
-0.0193825234,
0.0303816404,
-0.0308801569,
0.0196727496,
0.06563586,
0.050504826,
0.0091974847,
0.0696804225,
-0.0137579758,
0.0393412933,
0.0648982823,
0.016466232,
-0.0181975402,
-0.0629222915,
0.0224086251,
-0.0103998557,
-0.0242961496,
-0.0529943816,
0.0159740578,
0.0093704248,
0.0104041426,
0.0035986225,
-0.0196398981,
0.0061298227,
-0.000598146,
-0.0390891694,
-0.037612956,
0.0411710329,
0.0026737601,
0.0029226253,
0.0146670239,
0.0081309443,
0.0245992076,
-0.0425813384,
0.0206169821,
-0.0054883803,
-0.0324183218,
-0.0101013286,
0.0105352383,
0.049252931,
0.0490135364,
0.0072103939,
0.0297183376,
0.0599065907,
0.0208998937,
-0.0210173037,
0.0338367634,
0.012674314,
0.0092275031,
-0.0086241746,
-0.035531573,
-0.0040389774,
-0.0750581995,
-0.0188255422,
-0.0390726514,
0.0103655225,
0.0404228866,
-0.0155977244,
0.0617693439,
0.0179275963,
0.028738033,
0.0004747695,
0.0410945639,
0.02254791,
-0.0643900633,
0.0494057052,
-0.0215263981,
0.03040828,
0.0122496616,
0.0075741592,
0.0284735523,
0.0065012425,
-0.0202869084,
0.0243516564,
-0.0190929808,
0.0230060034,
-0.1067181528,
0.026105566,
-0.0294215195,
0.0161380526,
0.0093785403,
-0.0062216655,
0.0058091711,
-0.044105541,
-0.0308046192,
0.0309590101,
0.0012004816,
-0.0201224014,
-0.0051576588,
0.0086970506,
-0.0503590778,
-0.0624208897,
-0.0137719074,
0.1619295627,
0.0091932733,
0.0085081626,
-0.0613888428,
-0.0523695089,
-0.0200657863,
-0.0547459386,
0.0274149124,
-0.0085212188,
0.0006795728,
-0.0407794751,
-0.0385421775,
-0.0524745844,
-0.0026861429,
-0.0114452131,
-0.0287855472,
0.0683308095,
0.0127092991,
-0.0123188272,
-0.0011126345,
0.0315413699,
-0.037531089,
0.032643389,
0.0186558813,
0.0111619774,
0.0196506847,
-0.031941101,
0.04177358,
0.0178442299,
-0.0113639291,
0.03322386,
-0.0102750994,
0.0150083778,
-0.0124582481,
0.053875532,
0.0001901026,
0.0569813401,
0.0100416914,
-0.0223658364,
0.0683612749,
0.0583305135,
0.0116729094,
0.037504103,
0.0091954032,
-0.0253925379,
-0.0336258933,
-0.0233820789,
-0.0929277837,
0.0066027003,
-0.1081470028,
-0.0195359848,
-0.0466935448,
0.0651657358,
-0.0495084412,
-0.0125704389,
-0.013926412,
-0.0321630239,
0.0588180162,
0.0073409406,
-0.0023797902,
-0.0460551679,
-0.0091918493,
-0.071189478,
-0.0031649231,
-0.0522762053,
-0.0307767037,
-0.077357091,
0.0011559277,
0.0699725077,
0.0195076261,
-0.0297508948,
-0.0575377643,
-0.0444842614,
-0.0328456722,
-0.0274486002,
0.0190327968,
0.0085875737,
0.041248437,
-0.0129521005,
-0.0314422771,
0.0175984353,
0.0070222886,
0.0212300941,
-0.0072949384,
0.0055087693,
-0.0372427404,
-0.0159441642,
0.0078488467,
0.0216207635,
-0.0382098854,
-0.0095896777,
-0.034782894,
0.0199298151,
0.0621779338,
0.0088561811,
-0.0239774454,
0.0055221352,
0.0326619968,
0.0300723258,
-0.0343207158,
0.0119798621,
0.0042395266,
0.1073060855,
0.0184757449,
-0.0920039043,
-0.0209085755,
0.0933978558,
-0.0126712741,
0.0109042311,
-0.0230317153,
-0.0069549149,
-0.0355710648,
-0.0071871849,
0.0039563053,
-0.0065860115,
-0.0236010514,
-0.0093279453,
0.0383970663,
0.0044423616,
-0.0492445938,
-0.0452088863,
-0.0120233363,
0.0534572937,
-0.022854086,
-0.0202046335,
-0.0079541327,
-0.0476992242,
0.0519564115,
0.0278442744,
0.007030007,
-0.0377237424,
-0.0044370992,
-0.0891066417,
0.0169120189,
0.0131738642,
0.0105921794,
-0.0122558791,
-0.0283528287,
-0.0184419584,
-0.0130430358,
-0.004141585,
0.0404279977,
0.00109501,
0.0304499585,
0.0265307501,
-0.0047008889,
-0.0209187176,
-0.0200340617,
0.0190642532,
-0.0503070019,
0.0060901358,
0.0174957532,
0.0264304783,
-0.0348037817,
0.0230804831,
-0.0334473364,
0.0255135875,
0.0102616018,
-0.0299372058,
0.0051927962,
0.0619723871,
-0.0082203103,
0.0724099353,
0.0379398353,
0.0225491449,
0.067624487,
0.0190111678,
-0.0085491054,
0.01181514,
0.0231806748,
-0.0545397922,
-0.0196222421,
0.0075117955,
-0.0301146619,
0.0226305984,
-0.0161943045,
-0.0029291492,
-0.0303335395,
0.0289377477,
-0.006342655,
-0.1116777286,
0.0127420826,
-0.0473255515,
-0.0227996893,
0.0385234617,
-0.0199842211,
-0.0602507778,
0.0494042039,
0.0317431092,
0.0538156442,
0.0393324643,
-0.0242866389,
0.000464802,
0.024542043,
-0.0124907773,
0.0347430184,
0.0041901716,
-0.0194170699,
-0.0599966794,
0.019914154,
0.0046327757,
-0.0306565929,
0.0413543284,
-0.041378051,
-0.0057874792,
-0.0286903977,
-0.1001801118,
-0.0339471698,
-0.033313591,
0.0151273329,
-0.0106223049,
-0.0193100944,
-0.0149053307,
-0.01082695,
-0.0323632583,
0.028922515,
-0.0412783735,
-0.0138765927,
-0.012094982,
-0.0191045217,
-0.0314952731,
0.0544220991,
-0.0360126048,
0.0340823941,
0.0207858905,
0.0216060262,
0.0546104796,
0.0262751225,
0.0124586718,
-0.0541667491,
0.0210971702,
0.01185425,
-0.0107156243,
0.0052567134,
0.0387071148,
0.0614787713,
0.0112137385,
0.0219194517,
0.014066752,
-0.0311400928,
-0.0359218717,
0.0280684177,
-0.009723248,
-0.0272702891,
-0.0108963083,
0.0238821208,
-0.0524873361,
0.0010531894,
0.0024232967,
0.0324324891,
-0.047806032,
-0.0570544228,
0.0578314476,
-0.0685182512,
0.0462999791,
0.0360768698,
-0.0377166234,
-0.0643370152,
-0.0040600779,
0.0160310175,
-0.0622578971,
0.0492784604,
-0.0197630282,
-0.0050003277,
-0.0550445803,
-0.0123241162,
0.0006242397,
-0.0096238051,
0.0103823729,
-0.0430813991,
0.0664595291,
0.0671508312,
0.0110721132,
-0.0575723723,
-0.0192194767,
0.010166266,
0.0300796293,
0.0110057062,
0.0301925819,
0.0468006358,
-0.0090942895,
0.0261049215,
-0.0386984311,
0.038857799,
-0.0086093331,
-0.0226871464,
0.0420012213,
0.0587437525,
-0.0214844383,
-0.0337249376,
-0.0472072661,
-0.0097955558,
0.028372068,
0.0518085063,
-0.023747541,
-0.0382326096,
-0.0539882071,
-0.0089861006,
0.0010199633,
-0.0098412167,
-0.038645763,
0.0115664182,
0.0145235742,
-0.0508711711,
0.0000758484,
-0.0465190448,
-0.0552191027,
0.0171446633,
0.0534066334,
-0.0505983047,
-0.0296514854,
0.0302625224,
-0.0195675939,
0.0074668606,
0.0234153923,
0.0263349582,
0.0028885901,
0.0725799203,
-0.0235142466,
-0.0118975276,
-0.0091756079,
0.054022152,
-0.0003513853,
-0.0549333207,
0.0326112211,
0.0761500821,
0.0350534767,
0.0075641782,
-0.042365741,
0.0234812479,
0.0687950924,
0.0343268141,
-0.0234925039,
0.0187938809,
0.0514721237,
-0.0280988272,
-0.0000538214,
-0.0016212977,
-0.0315651968,
-0.0220403522,
0.0439695716,
-0.0092069451,
-0.0513817817,
-0.0095082587,
0.0047973548,
0.0341221206,
0.0220841933,
-0.0454753898,
0.024748126,
0.0039537824,
-0.0113498243,
0.0178896915,
0.0124158626,
-0.0094761644,
-0.0223988928,
0.048364494,
-0.0080546523,
0.0233912393,
0.0304284655,
0.0246742424,
-0.0039735921,
-0.067640081,
-0.0216538794,
0.0248745494,
0.0798319727,
-0.0066450029,
0.0241087079,
-0.0218934566,
0.0264462121,
0.0040041707,
0.0213182569,
0.0034709177,
0.0331341513,
-0.0055209589,
0.0450539775,
-0.0047891727,
0.090897277,
-0.0690155253,
-0.0490479991,
-0.0157741252,
0.0014604055,
0.0209381711,
0.0397889465,
0.0111683831,
-0.0080128144,
0.0079717152,
-0.0449904874,
0.0292844195,
-0.0229857229,
0.0014379864,
-0.0240678526,
0.0176389962,
-0.0176689811,
-0.009139915,
0.0452203602,
-0.0052456153,
0.0470440798,
-0.0326863639,
-0.003798157,
-0.0110236285,
-0.0417136028,
0.0654538944,
-0.0006669307,
-0.009172746,
-0.0730619207,
-0.0876015574,
-0.0606921241,
0.0020783914,
0.026893599,
0.0051505007,
0.0200312734,
-0.0017280208,
0.0093966573,
-0.0138177117,
-0.0082095452,
0.0072582024,
-0.0812075362,
-0.0209828764,
0.007724179,
-0.0184177496,
-5.576376958e-33,
0.0084417732,
-0.0185245592,
-0.0055741356,
0.0145184584,
-0.0495893806,
0.0052564517,
0.0272789709,
0.0169662461,
-0.0236221235,
-0.005866461,
0.0110847754,
0.0124219004,
-0.0075598992,
-0.0250615887,
0.0336529352,
-0.0574117713,
-0.0332611352,
-0.0162249878,
-0.0059508169,
0.0324481837,
0.0044740732,
0.0044770436,
-0.0081131207,
-0.1244906411,
0.0399874523,
0.0315011665,
-0.0358202197,
-0.0011391871,
-0.0548933931,
0.0458343551,
0.0118895695,
0.0399779491,
0.01125436,
0.0127585046,
0.018557813,
0.0648434609,
0.0061890981,
-0.0107173976,
-0.0160842035,
-0.0616531298,
-0.0637351871,
-0.078495726,
0.0136092575,
-0.0039437995,
-0.0446621068,
-0.0338077992,
0.0226479452,
-0.0054088375,
0.0216265228,
-0.0287483055,
-0.0700180829,
-0.0168170016,
-0.0350880586,
-0.00663736,
0.0062610842,
0.0422602519,
0.0210419074,
-0.0098753721,
-0.0138475532,
0.0040936153,
-0.0433786511,
-0.0744224489,
0.0780512542,
-0.0152799236,
-0.002911764,
0.063300468,
-0.0178490393,
-0.0328797698,
-0.0554821342,
-0.042132061,
-0.0235680398,
0.1026783958,
0.0227322206,
0.0596110262,
-0.0212834403,
-0.0232343394,
-0.0725422353,
0.0444854498,
-0.0186355822,
0.0229302011,
-0.0099822991,
-0.0089282636,
-0.0743655935,
0.0290242936,
0.0035806305,
-0.0344156362,
-0.0256891511,
-0.0216586888,
0.0238246974,
-0.0299214181,
-0.0101951789,
-0.008649054,
-0.0024278967,
-0.0368735641,
0.07860367,
0.009364807,
0.0710277185,
-0.0176995769,
-0.0011039824,
0.0354167372,
-0.003446782,
-0.0632040203,
-0.0011198116,
0.001996638,
0.0730590969,
0.0029337623,
0.0351426378,
0.0371745974,
-0.0172534585,
-0.0006744025,
-0.0306824092,
0.041817531,
0.0410129987,
-0.0158693399,
0.0419249125,
-0.0211454052,
0.0307980105,
0.0091128191,
0.0408984907,
0.0451387465,
-0.0235995594,
0.0205532126,
-0.0402794108,
-0.014575758,
0.0435993671,
0.0068900799,
-0.0108695719,
0.0364465378,
0.0128793148,
-0.0431080498,
-0.0031864697,
0.0257143471,
2.761e-7,
-0.000706915,
-0.0296192486,
0.0420789346,
0.0129538141,
0.0027826189,
0.0845719948,
-0.0159980152,
0.1061898321,
-0.011283569,
-0.0046345135,
0.0597627386,
0.0029944384,
0.0506234579,
0.0375623442,
0.0576842539,
-0.0106902961,
0.0050616879,
0.0213925987,
-0.0500346124,
0.0348058455,
0.0483195372,
-0.0091400556,
0.0252397116,
-0.0256640054,
0.0275090225,
-0.0520371795,
0.0080927974,
-0.0626512989,
0.019222388,
-0.0329475999,
0.013919428,
0.05336041,
-0.0022084198,
0.047376316,
0.010103656,
-0.0111916438,
-0.0183558464,
0.0438503213,
-0.0484061502,
-0.0605935529,
-0.0300088078,
-0.0387074128,
0.0109760808,
-0.009585036,
0.0394913815,
-0.001990003,
-0.0109603936,
-0.0103905667,
-0.0005368614,
-0.0309975483,
0.044862885,
-0.001928863,
0.0285164732,
-0.0018515748,
-0.0042201201,
0.0228694249,
0.009713836,
-0.0083582122,
0.0333048441,
0.0010304961,
0.0076670377,
-0.0947608575,
0.0167342816,
0.0883952156,
0.0283260588,
-0.0532721616,
-0.015235316,
2.34352546e-34,
-0.0372908339,
-0.0538058765,
0.0167925265,
-0.0151712056,
0.0509016924,
0.0192687791,
-0.0612298287,
-0.0137912268,
-0.0186814778,
0.0031158151,
-0.0030839886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15275v1 | Cognitive Map for Language Models: Optimal Planning via Verbally Representing the World Model | 2024-06-21T16:10:05 | 2024-06-21T16:10:05 | Doyoung Kim, Jongwon Lee, Jinho Park, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models have demonstrated impressive capabilities across various
natural language processing tasks, yet they struggle with planning tasks
requiring multi-step simulations. Inspired by human cognitive processes, this
paper investigates the optimal planning power of language models that can
construct a cognitive map of a given environment. Our experiments demonstrate
that cognitive map significantly enhances the performance of both optimal and
reachable planning generation ability in the Gridworld path planning task. We
observe that our method showcases two key characteristics similar to human
cognition: \textbf{generalization of its planning ability to extrapolated
environments and rapid adaptation with limited training data.} We hope our
findings in the Gridworld task provide insights into modeling human cognitive
processes in language models, potentially leading to the development of more
advanced and robust systems that better resemble human cognition. | [
0.063795425,
0.0067941472,
-0.0341166854,
0.0034504686,
-0.0325073712,
-0.0025492534,
-0.0256714877,
-0.0112487115,
0.0649150163,
-0.0192162748,
-0.0083162552,
-0.0193714611,
0.007564832,
0.012538109,
0.0237974022,
-0.089907743,
0.0364890285,
-0.0858550072,
-0.0197298136,
0.0155549552,
-0.0655836537,
-0.0182834044,
-0.0471851118,
0.0484941192,
-0.0027312492,
0.0212313067,
-0.0536241271,
-0.0274878256,
0.0243688021,
-0.0714837387,
-0.052632872,
0.0006292582,
0.0434523486,
0.0033487985,
0.0000017188,
-0.0449309163,
0.000812401,
-0.0395571068,
0.0281681642,
-0.0294098724,
0.0279198065,
0.010466638,
-0.007403282,
0.0052785091,
-0.0490914471,
0.0308377314,
0.0440481044,
0.0332118869,
0.0456550121,
0.0362577103,
-0.0176535267,
-0.0038254014,
-0.0174363256,
0.0306049511,
0.0050468831,
-0.051441092,
0.0128849344,
0.0297865532,
0.0335695669,
-0.0090373177,
-0.0149406753,
-0.0226337519,
0.009045599,
0.0083059622,
-0.0422683768,
0.0590639338,
0.0244514775,
0.0161382332,
-0.017046066,
0.0641038865,
-0.026104046,
-0.0271486416,
0.0287937988,
0.000264181,
-0.016547801,
0.0043598674,
-0.0401564166,
0.016800778,
0.0012892538,
0.0239836052,
-0.0164481476,
-0.0044493522,
0.0121558597,
0.0233308338,
-0.0295170043,
0.1453845799,
-0.0028815551,
-0.0176617894,
0.0001863568,
-0.0186698828,
-0.0392648429,
-0.0572125353,
0.0332779251,
0.0740873367,
-0.0422193073,
0.021720048,
-0.0268765464,
0.0020719003,
-0.001055803,
-0.0449948944,
0.0845557451,
0.0628870055,
0.0571127199,
0.0215870086,
-0.0044185575,
0.0747570843,
-0.0227177814,
0.0372369923,
-0.0366322696,
0.0034283937,
-0.0462809354,
0.0147436131,
-0.0632653162,
0.0140026156,
-0.0457401313,
-0.0450550392,
0.0082693016,
0.0410958789,
0.0095011946,
-0.0211037528,
0.00466388,
0.0180811174,
-0.0124661373,
-0.0044406415,
-0.0512612872,
-0.0890671164,
-0.0785474181,
0.0138796233,
-0.0087637566,
0.0111911055,
0.0185536072,
0.0160931572,
-0.0066935713,
-0.0039187735,
-0.02901664,
0.1028249636,
0.0092620254,
0.0025284963,
-0.0711012185,
-0.0228547044,
-0.0113131758,
-0.0386006124,
0.0562340617,
-0.0680503696,
0.0272756163,
0.0194068626,
-0.0284199305,
-0.0000561312,
0.0051344461,
-0.0116010001,
-0.0190742929,
0.0472501405,
-0.0020349848,
0.0283960924,
0.0587036163,
-0.0093477694,
0.0057686479,
0.0479555726,
0.0735079423,
0.0528706685,
-0.0208699927,
0.0741931796,
0.0087831868,
0.0653762296,
-0.0155314011,
-0.002739158,
-0.0214152634,
-0.0040084859,
0.017223537,
0.0441994779,
0.0296548773,
0.0497161821,
-0.040049307,
0.0261594374,
0.0200237352,
0.1010407582,
-0.0198041555,
-0.0037018927,
0.0670300499,
0.0050223707,
-0.0167503338,
-0.0103366086,
-0.0444638804,
0.0110832136,
0.0066303303,
0.0003268149,
-0.0263722632,
0.0168026816,
0.0211525261,
-0.022056289,
-0.0311878249,
0.0174801424,
0.0433984697,
-0.0619030856,
0.0052565285,
0.0198089313,
-0.036599841,
0.0501248688,
-0.0136847636,
-0.0241850577,
-0.0269399881,
-0.0055562528,
-0.0211974494,
0.0434471481,
0.0037256768,
-0.0171597116,
-0.0122383637,
0.0241686758,
0.0042174393,
0.0518629737,
0.0571398102,
-0.0003029335,
-0.0144525394,
-0.0213396158,
-0.0245975722,
0.0139524741,
-0.0004334718,
0.0284358505,
0.0456429869,
0.0014557331,
-0.0133896461,
-0.0396611728,
-0.0278329477,
0.0540257841,
-0.0138010206,
-0.0035588269,
-0.0721396878,
-0.0002908061,
0.0175367743,
-0.0192646757,
-0.0141291209,
0.0307932291,
0.0247176476,
-0.0083383806,
-0.0193970911,
0.035646826,
-0.0552537888,
-0.0136056822,
0.0435773358,
-0.0208613314,
-0.0039679487,
0.0209247377,
-0.0014669684,
-0.0283097457,
0.0193210933,
-0.0362542532,
0.0389400423,
0.0258507486,
0.0318866335,
0.021190783,
-0.043786969,
-0.0147899585,
0.0802312717,
-0.0099631883,
0.0073882015,
0.0386681929,
0.0131844794,
0.0220161546,
-0.0169946328,
0.0079658013,
0.0245255493,
-0.0002784378,
-0.0184406061,
0.0017345792,
0.010439002,
-0.0482920632,
-0.0227748118,
-0.0900593027,
-0.0330966674,
0.0031790237,
0.0090378225,
0.0291635655,
-0.0613408536,
-0.0143391313,
0.0053748093,
-0.0102521293,
0.049717892,
0.0048501161,
-0.0086995754,
0.0182700269,
-0.0006567867,
-0.0035167646,
-0.0505211055,
0.0282607824,
-0.0381057933,
0.0033658149,
0.031387791,
-0.0560832471,
-0.0317363143,
0.0243260246,
-0.0186829157,
0.0525192656,
-0.0124950772,
-0.0441734232,
0.0304854866,
-0.0322532952,
0.0582512878,
0.0056932941,
0.0085362447,
-0.0136675006,
0.0724913701,
-0.0290523265,
-0.038075082,
0.0453381836,
-0.0416294672,
0.0021767088,
-0.0697741136,
-0.0402416475,
0.0223881844,
0.0497392267,
0.0012679065,
0.0287323389,
-0.0230844356,
0.0132939285,
-0.0362200774,
-0.0428752229,
-0.0276807994,
0.0224500913,
-0.0334593244,
0.0727746785,
-0.0480487868,
-0.0223538969,
0.0347993672,
-0.0283795018,
0.0158636272,
-0.0138170347,
0.029510878,
-0.0067643397,
0.0682714358,
0.0250763521,
0.0503128842,
-0.0016722959,
0.0095058708,
-0.0089383172,
-0.0467606895,
-0.0391399972,
0.0062022037,
0.0110993497,
-0.0966149122,
0.0252179243,
0.0036843717,
-0.034862902,
-0.0311426148,
0.0497907735,
-0.0205800366,
0.0304154567,
0.0304937959,
-0.0549893118,
-0.0312084183,
0.028160641,
0.0372843333,
0.0695837066,
-0.0107674897,
-0.0324884467,
-0.0138169322,
-0.0146507937,
0.0745622739,
0.0844558254,
0.0165032223,
0.0091489051,
0.0038791043,
0.0282182824,
0.0371681154,
0.0094362264,
0.003371987,
0.0517292023,
0.0048373383,
-0.0187467318,
-0.0111653907,
0.0837045312,
0.0497700199,
-0.0247099549,
-0.0501999222,
0.0835906118,
0.0669123083,
0.0036824257,
0.0283614434,
-0.0602093562,
0.0205361657,
0.0584658757,
0.0463306904,
0.0289858989,
0.0056997412,
0.0269183498,
-0.0314085856,
-0.014834391,
-0.0589110106,
0.0087153101,
-0.1048849896,
0.0412585363,
0.003409286,
-0.0624070019,
0.0251338817,
-0.0378895514,
-0.0132460399,
0.0395148098,
-0.0497462377,
-0.0475591831,
0.0327011086,
-0.0071192598,
0.0030553148,
-0.037920028,
0.000351498,
0.0056276298,
-0.0339152217,
0.0551547222,
0.0382039249,
0.0619143099,
0.0102210101,
-0.0430577211,
0.0084883748,
0.0747046694,
0.05465189,
-0.0203993805,
0.012663519,
0.0366144851,
0.018646555,
0.0269237719,
-0.0066342414,
-0.0593868718,
-0.0713863596,
0.0156149566,
0.0733266026,
-0.0241270196,
0.0253248569,
-0.0317818858,
0.0301599186,
0.0274352022,
0.0525676906,
0.0180753134,
-0.0192051306,
-0.075363636,
-0.0675425306,
-0.0354140624,
-0.0615371205,
-0.0925898105,
-0.0051888311,
0.0214063469,
-0.0020164123,
-0.0721575171,
-0.0303786229,
0.048941724,
0.0654198527,
0.0231615249,
-0.0281405039,
0.0273826011,
-0.0305771194,
-0.0125472797,
-0.0109318681,
-0.0270348098,
0.0381257832,
-0.0128535433,
-0.02276651,
-0.0095513975,
-0.0251112878,
-0.0204931498,
0.0521571711,
-0.028173808,
-0.0715487227,
0.0297587067,
0.0457138978,
0.0252739266,
-0.0256043617,
-0.0057687913,
-0.0001063617,
-0.0104618659,
-0.0132120335,
-0.0250555072,
0.0379604623,
0.0087255063,
0.0805835649,
0.0230529364,
0.0102387322,
-0.0084658284,
0.0225856826,
0.0105983503,
0.0698504224,
-0.0111653078,
0.0040508979,
0.0157307964,
-0.0192248132,
0.050096225,
-0.0084499279,
-0.0174476914,
-0.0119057177,
-0.0455057099,
-0.0263413321,
-0.0265356917,
-0.0125463316,
0.0046843681,
0.0023352981,
0.0285295323,
0.031945128,
-0.0186737105,
-0.0042015687,
-0.0142003633,
0.0320574008,
-0.032645002,
0.0236673728,
-0.031825494,
0.0138269765,
0.014138137,
-0.001975832,
-0.0098637026,
-0.0313562788,
0.0061135283,
0.0075475047,
0.0124926018,
0.0099075017,
-0.0280030239,
-0.0614261962,
-0.0311530214,
-0.0726789683,
-0.1095318198,
0.0008144039,
0.0765024051,
0.0586031526,
-0.0144060226,
0.0161886811,
-0.0783362165,
0.016804222,
0.0219036732,
-0.0615771338,
0.0399180576,
-0.0349454246,
0.0441428423,
0.0301627722,
-0.0159811676,
-0.0357624553,
0.0159099549,
0.0309948567,
0.0882889926,
-0.0060553909,
-0.0221600048,
-0.0509163514,
-0.022514239,
-0.0164868217,
0.0257083215,
-0.0096315015,
0.0293140821,
-0.0614323169,
-0.0604655333,
0.0158168469,
0.0681632012,
0.0050053056,
-0.0229740702,
0.0672718138,
0.0187227689,
-0.0195131786,
-0.0383725204,
-0.0249475595,
-0.0172680058,
-0.0088149421,
-0.04250158,
-0.0658728182,
-5.201714949e-33,
-0.0386926904,
-0.0482448228,
0.0683370084,
-0.0276219379,
0.0149816461,
-0.0665776804,
-0.0578720421,
0.0464926213,
-0.0364032723,
0.0044597266,
-0.0207022391,
-0.0089691915,
0.0200290494,
0.0082250684,
-0.0146857025,
0.0484712236,
0.0242425799,
-0.0187157821,
-0.0471017398,
-0.0419018641,
0.0244956464,
-0.0125304041,
0.020060759,
-0.0484748371,
-0.0274119712,
-0.0024439767,
-0.0294930469,
0.0298480745,
0.0088797817,
0.0552976429,
-0.0476223566,
0.0033445947,
0.026203528,
-0.0315805115,
-0.0392248519,
0.0154695474,
-0.041713547,
-0.0452544764,
0.0199040174,
-0.0165110156,
-0.0373276733,
-0.0166633073,
-0.0010915797,
0.0005074703,
-0.0366263166,
0.0399813466,
0.0359277911,
-0.0134143243,
-0.0266206134,
0.0461129397,
-0.0644861683,
0.0032356554,
-0.0033561527,
0.0072952025,
0.0347227417,
0.0360444672,
-0.0150797497,
0.0029652172,
-0.0271173436,
0.0321513154,
0.0324110091,
0.0174333267,
0.0430288576,
0.0381433852,
0.0365500487,
0.0735744387,
0.0299611278,
-0.0081974687,
-0.0295654666,
-0.0268859696,
0.0387387909,
0.0462390333,
-0.0200255439,
0.0272481665,
0.0136265187,
-0.0062171211,
0.0020943605,
0.0137992594,
-0.0280172992,
0.0336973295,
0.034241911,
0.0052768239,
-0.0165405627,
-0.008758815,
-0.0638653263,
-0.0008764836,
-0.0095764166,
0.009921086,
0.0312638059,
-0.0073476578,
0.0245863684,
-0.0181363896,
0.0110816807,
-0.0136967432,
-0.0148617737,
0.0145961018,
-0.0164642185,
0.0413843021,
0.0132482219,
0.0313872509,
-0.064672336,
-0.0604044609,
-0.0181723963,
0.0358264558,
0.0051403898,
0.0161170252,
-0.0164379291,
0.0325406902,
-0.0427855961,
-0.0067637209,
-0.0560170561,
-0.0066130972,
0.031895671,
0.0068060076,
0.0482508764,
-0.0552336685,
-0.030321328,
-0.013132588,
0.0065279016,
-0.0792910606,
0.0427532233,
-0.004950183,
-0.0238423161,
0.038746886,
-0.0209909137,
-0.0090671778,
-0.0512212366,
0.043936424,
0.0119061675,
-0.0467519313,
-0.0112290177,
0.0732830614,
2.508e-7,
0.0248735342,
0.0513783209,
0.0019057147,
0.0302535761,
0.0307833701,
0.009728252,
-0.0021900923,
-0.0033009069,
-0.0385724939,
-0.036316935,
0.0085282912,
0.0557706244,
0.0075642257,
0.0180300176,
-0.0700792298,
-0.0001434898,
-0.0233972222,
-0.0179255288,
-0.0503882281,
0.0101621831,
0.0445484184,
0.0356342457,
-0.0135307107,
0.0309015438,
-0.0245265514,
-0.0275421217,
0.02234165,
-0.0594278425,
0.0721364617,
-0.0095189372,
-0.0189227015,
0.010752405,
-0.0165720638,
-0.016988853,
0.0035265996,
0.0162633769,
0.0016617926,
0.0459415279,
-0.0152183026,
-0.0253745448,
0.0055489722,
-0.0431711823,
0.0216682255,
-0.0678688511,
0.0192346349,
-0.0589334331,
-0.0037872721,
0.0192127004,
0.0512539484,
0.0265937336,
-0.0330469608,
-0.0171883348,
-0.0045189997,
-0.0321580395,
0.0066003157,
0.01804059,
0.0103903152,
-0.0517476238,
-0.0105558317,
0.0023883318,
-0.0440961383,
-0.0158221684,
-0.0689329803,
-0.001637992,
0.0077639516,
-0.0492277779,
-0.0211832598,
1.962834498e-34,
-0.009027537,
0.0074144863,
0.0032429539,
-0.0134671088,
0.0474969745,
0.0076036197,
0.040232148,
0.031517338,
-0.0072545647,
-0.0644153655,
-0.0510664135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15267v1 | Evaluating Diversity in Automatic Poetry Generation | 2024-06-21T16:03:21 | 2024-06-21T16:03:21 | Yanran Chen, Hannes Gröner, Sina Zarrieß, Steffen Eger | cs.CL | cs.CL | Natural Language Generation (NLG), and more generally generative AI, are
among the currently most impactful research fields. Creative NLG, such as
automatic poetry generation, is a fascinating niche in this area. While most
previous research has focused on forms of the Turing test when evaluating
automatic poetry generation - can humans distinguish between automatic and
human generated poetry - we evaluate the diversity of automatically generated
poetry, by comparing distributions of generated poetry to distributions of
human poetry along structural, lexical, semantic and stylistic dimensions,
assessing different model types (word vs. character-level, general purpose LLMs
vs. poetry-specific models), including the very recent LLaMA3, and types of
fine-tuning (conditioned vs. unconditioned). We find that current automatic
poetry systems are considerably underdiverse along multiple dimensions - they
often do not rhyme sufficiently, are semantically too uniform and even do not
match the length distribution of human poetry. Our experiments reveal, however,
that style-conditioning and character-level modeling clearly increases
diversity across virtually all dimensions we explore. Our identified
limitations may serve as the basis for more genuinely diverse future poetry
generation models. | [
0.051175341,
0.0481642075,
-0.0355680548,
0.0051130811,
-0.0327563174,
-0.0206545964,
0.0265542269,
-0.0004922564,
-0.0230777301,
-0.034560658,
-0.0179483667,
-0.0509360433,
0.014390205,
0.0128299855,
0.0150890639,
-0.0396009497,
-0.0309104938,
-0.0329929292,
0.0365977585,
-0.007261808,
-0.0095196413,
0.0139713027,
0.0034850712,
0.0558048338,
0.0303251147,
0.0013244504,
-0.0300949849,
0.0379255861,
0.0167164765,
-0.0234823562,
-0.0333312266,
0.0539695062,
-0.0370089598,
0.0094231237,
0.0000015105,
-0.0778449178,
0.0149504365,
-0.031958621,
0.0627471283,
0.0028588199,
-0.0077633453,
-0.0208678748,
-0.0047571533,
0.0084599406,
0.0098348157,
0.0513843745,
0.0369791687,
0.0099924318,
0.0718583092,
0.0930089131,
0.017589815,
-0.0594383441,
0.0164159499,
-0.0464260019,
0.0247952957,
0.0232543778,
0.0079280222,
-0.0203385744,
0.0252540186,
-0.0239503998,
-0.0519876778,
-0.0011753379,
-0.0044916752,
0.0346841998,
0.0163717438,
0.0409364663,
0.0009998172,
0.0128990887,
0.0075104693,
0.0256723333,
0.0014419812,
-0.0038936031,
0.0282484498,
-0.0066447644,
0.0084561286,
-0.0111798318,
-0.0299106482,
0.0597447753,
0.0086043477,
0.0208323933,
0.0081777172,
0.0111815808,
-0.0307771061,
0.0101605495,
0.0228967108,
-0.006419363,
0.0371567607,
-0.0353718586,
-0.0160301402,
0.0195890926,
0.0344312452,
-0.0747293755,
-0.0073564663,
0.0130837681,
-0.0120168431,
-0.0040626219,
-0.0270429812,
-0.0672317594,
0.0398670435,
0.035756547,
0.1302411705,
0.0519956574,
0.0279817358,
-0.0084026149,
-0.0121592591,
0.0234551225,
0.0043353382,
0.0051347623,
-0.059741687,
0.0387317836,
0.0075403233,
-0.0032060689,
-0.036091879,
-0.0235598814,
-0.0010155629,
-0.0193020925,
-0.0321585201,
0.0093642175,
0.0245946329,
-0.0324943401,
0.0169576202,
0.0410558991,
-0.0456170626,
0.0072256732,
0.0003349315,
-0.0108900275,
-0.0224966705,
0.0302035268,
0.0171158798,
-0.0133681605,
0.0009323573,
0.0066299653,
0.0318496153,
-0.0214708038,
0.0272001512,
0.049739819,
0.0238164086,
-0.0532320216,
-0.0252347179,
-0.0148645313,
-0.0144866388,
-0.0515114591,
0.0298085306,
-0.0725077093,
-0.0062715877,
-0.0085026976,
0.0119978823,
-0.0302018188,
0.0175405089,
0.0183729157,
-0.0382769629,
-0.0085495496,
-0.0097655468,
0.0298854038,
-0.0164153576,
-0.0065763569,
0.0231212638,
0.0419888385,
0.0722250417,
0.0459895842,
-0.01079344,
0.00619506,
0.0269018337,
-0.0092935916,
-0.0324251726,
-0.0070883231,
-0.0186911933,
-0.0519049242,
-0.0397309884,
0.0666965991,
0.0366755761,
0.0607955121,
0.0104700308,
-0.0416813791,
0.0654842034,
0.0303012542,
0.0379066318,
0.0520231202,
0.0935539976,
-0.0041582417,
0.0576834679,
0.054419104,
-0.014348533,
0.0315247923,
0.0540515035,
0.0577447377,
0.0614318438,
0.067743361,
0.0048363707,
-0.0214111861,
-0.0476574227,
-0.002885235,
-0.0064555211,
-0.0585860312,
0.0005692504,
0.0344850011,
-0.0198426731,
-0.0255609285,
0.0125720436,
-0.0638434514,
-0.0017300261,
-0.0076552583,
0.053814657,
0.1166611314,
0.0501849018,
0.0141638769,
0.0392824039,
0.017655788,
-0.0283280183,
0.0551640242,
-0.004412144,
0.0373739451,
0.0054345154,
-0.0061572068,
0.0257790387,
-0.0379618891,
0.025414519,
0.048696965,
-0.0325994864,
0.0291712489,
-0.0071461909,
-0.0116427569,
-0.04344723,
0.0457710214,
-0.030119583,
-0.0159086119,
0.0314512067,
0.0159880016,
0.0030841327,
0.0044524497,
-0.082274884,
0.0498114638,
-0.0084219892,
-0.0366741903,
-0.0248730462,
0.0451040864,
-0.0507938042,
-0.0371415652,
0.0294803716,
-0.0986251011,
0.0436734781,
0.0236012172,
0.0202618185,
-0.0325540006,
0.0851966664,
-0.0311299879,
-0.0027168291,
-0.0299889892,
0.0014083782,
0.0062025068,
0.0248512309,
-0.0137338359,
0.0171854235,
-0.0010646515,
0.0256032143,
-0.0311472509,
0.0095565468,
0.0199537165,
-0.0289033018,
-0.0282044951,
0.0021351574,
0.0136930635,
0.016690243,
-0.0094114337,
0.0220719185,
-0.0365005247,
-0.0726327524,
-0.0631929561,
0.0028003068,
-0.0043702098,
-0.0175151564,
0.0355662107,
-0.0063570119,
-0.0625661239,
0.0377624668,
-0.037482433,
0.0073747141,
0.0426087305,
0.0422488488,
0.0313457698,
-0.0242723376,
-0.0472867787,
-0.022228878,
-0.0125536621,
-0.0122452183,
0.0272522736,
0.0298845042,
0.0285983477,
-0.0203147754,
0.019621985,
-0.040215943,
-0.0635109469,
0.0118285483,
-0.0410961621,
0.0170585923,
-0.0394769944,
0.0678025484,
0.048126176,
0.0165618602,
-0.01447351,
0.0901620761,
0.0062704589,
0.0440907925,
-0.0132178981,
0.0130746942,
0.0543799922,
0.0404945761,
-0.0534739122,
0.0043872623,
0.0489053503,
0.047354497,
-0.036168091,
-0.0183491372,
0.0614702031,
0.017194476,
-0.0209802613,
0.000378877,
-0.0050821253,
-0.0143887093,
0.0339725539,
-0.0152456602,
-0.0398713648,
0.0462861247,
-0.0363997146,
0.0060095345,
-0.0125108883,
0.0049646869,
-0.0586956181,
0.0496370085,
0.0174721535,
0.0405211486,
-0.0041766614,
0.0206865482,
-0.0374481305,
0.0428713039,
0.0174450185,
-0.0285095163,
0.0555692278,
-0.0186975952,
-0.0183534715,
-0.0197325833,
-0.0064240904,
-0.0376646668,
0.0072239079,
-0.0094721979,
-0.0155399041,
0.0692773685,
-0.0271609221,
0.044297345,
-0.0155749703,
-0.0356606543,
0.0284661707,
-0.0240910146,
-0.0187180638,
-0.0239656195,
0.0429080613,
0.0062781773,
-0.0066914395,
-0.0047161668,
-0.0030034136,
-0.0146645037,
-0.0402558446,
-0.0414736941,
0.0251360778,
-0.0257422253,
0.0352061689,
-0.0189914182,
-0.0057542012,
0.0478013568,
0.040758241,
0.0331000462,
-0.0241905525,
-0.0401138701,
0.0563282855,
0.0193874855,
0.0012575524,
0.0074128481,
-0.0069445493,
0.0332249254,
0.0123237632,
0.0122816116,
-0.0239837412,
-0.0026572691,
0.0119445184,
0.0512199402,
-0.0008086794,
-0.0228933133,
-0.0547185615,
-0.0693051964,
0.0083134286,
0.0074652201,
-0.0358605012,
0.0087688155,
0.0213977899,
-0.019908255,
0.0074454723,
-0.0361209288,
0.0066550518,
-0.0301036872,
0.0444551036,
-0.0163767766,
-0.0129945967,
-0.0305046849,
-0.0522401072,
-0.0634933189,
0.0505124144,
0.0471825898,
0.0239266269,
-0.012029822,
-0.0372526161,
-0.0319634005,
-0.0155478986,
0.0264932141,
0.0234474279,
0.0006714513,
0.0545104258,
-0.0072833351,
-0.0297434293,
0.017351795,
-0.0025117442,
-0.0029950971,
0.0047758957,
-0.0078402553,
-0.0308452528,
-0.0441782139,
-0.0452181771,
0.0525591262,
-0.0171522982,
0.081027925,
0.0644839033,
-0.0506740808,
-0.0540018305,
-0.0532047637,
-0.0158088896,
-0.123267673,
-0.0354146697,
-0.0125515154,
0.0049142092,
-0.0267100055,
-0.1034754887,
-0.0214505158,
-0.0371941887,
0.0153717073,
0.0355048217,
-0.0151594905,
-0.0280282423,
-0.0314693004,
-0.0305790305,
-0.0165603869,
-0.000486591,
0.0149050439,
-0.0294974539,
-0.0583569705,
-0.0311789103,
-0.0979881883,
0.0012462727,
0.0140693039,
-0.0997742787,
-0.0473415852,
0.0452423468,
0.0152670406,
0.0220516715,
-0.0224914774,
0.0053026271,
-0.0101828985,
0.0075363154,
0.0702454224,
0.0685200244,
0.0757124871,
-0.0221088249,
0.0331306718,
0.0045874915,
0.0153683163,
-0.0171599444,
0.0154184196,
0.0405096635,
0.044629667,
0.0897198245,
-0.0549473315,
0.0338823721,
0.0153298378,
-0.0309183765,
-0.0501097441,
0.007198242,
-0.0334946439,
-0.0746123791,
-0.0401938483,
0.0026941672,
-0.0227861106,
-0.0310270544,
0.0305808894,
0.0215624552,
-0.0226528794,
-0.0153988414,
-0.0014819138,
0.0080994219,
-0.0461911634,
-0.0129486341,
0.0050166268,
-0.0206983611,
-0.0291844904,
-0.0160709005,
0.0029494367,
0.0257033017,
-0.0787216052,
0.0310393963,
0.021441577,
-0.0210800823,
0.0079630017,
-0.0212858357,
-0.0481315926,
0.0545136295,
-0.0682890788,
0.0046542236,
-0.0145237381,
-0.0013455489,
0.0657953471,
-0.0175860859,
0.0529789925,
-0.0520977154,
0.0411765873,
-0.0092997281,
0.0213747174,
0.0181038063,
-0.0080496073,
-0.0448159315,
-0.0039807698,
0.00330816,
-0.067497164,
0.0849532783,
-0.0147269722,
0.0034354627,
-0.0097604003,
-0.0054373024,
0.0003706098,
-0.0105760656,
-0.0409671441,
-0.0050011077,
0.0185854994,
-0.0059599546,
-0.0642805248,
-0.0357851572,
0.0520697869,
0.008562603,
0.0734085143,
-0.0071293735,
0.0125482045,
0.0298466068,
-0.0182765685,
0.0360655896,
-0.0358283333,
-0.013279696,
-0.0350516252,
-0.0130971596,
-0.0194169264,
-5.487765989e-33,
-0.0504044257,
0.0071259472,
-0.0373411067,
-0.0507820733,
-0.0104353419,
-0.026844386,
-0.0807316378,
0.0195558835,
0.0121375397,
-0.0108571043,
-0.0195506196,
-0.0267299172,
-0.0129213613,
-0.0076923375,
0.0653391331,
0.0223209597,
0.0321212374,
-0.012959348,
-0.055817198,
-0.0264656711,
0.0331290215,
-0.0077394093,
-0.0302334875,
-0.0214947052,
0.0145853888,
-0.0520100519,
-0.0112136863,
-0.0463264138,
-0.0052518998,
0.0188122019,
-0.0284947865,
0.0325508192,
0.0579258054,
0.0004396936,
-0.0314065479,
-0.0073942239,
0.0005554523,
-0.0485304892,
-0.0129297161,
-0.0257095471,
0.0118704597,
-0.0718847886,
0.04820529,
-0.0196824037,
-0.0347538069,
-0.0015813265,
0.0172083098,
-0.0274461322,
0.0251132026,
-0.1002673954,
-0.0440923981,
-0.0169594865,
-0.0275175907,
-0.0517695136,
-0.0531073958,
-0.0386610106,
0.025067294,
0.0327618793,
-0.0017469783,
0.0507641658,
-0.0180122275,
0.0065515228,
0.0130516393,
-0.0027022352,
-0.0215904173,
0.0573272705,
-0.0094466032,
0.0189664476,
-0.0528710112,
0.0599332824,
0.0090376046,
0.0102527505,
0.0482290909,
0.0483302176,
0.0611036159,
-0.0226016268,
-0.0168351792,
0.0607824586,
-0.0085178996,
-0.0385157578,
0.0271223187,
0.0034705945,
-0.0194786396,
-0.0052729673,
0.0357694775,
-0.0660039857,
0.0000703757,
0.0042025335,
0.0380373597,
0.0237026252,
-0.0238745715,
-0.0190841407,
-0.0095936526,
-0.0316275395,
0.0045436854,
0.0387963764,
-0.0762628242,
0.0361021124,
-0.0134574194,
-0.0235121138,
0.0087271892,
-0.0248295385,
0.1002670079,
0.0313352421,
0.0129757514,
0.0067924745,
0.0371620618,
0.0245504659,
-0.0640937239,
0.0168243255,
-0.0367359482,
0.0332930647,
0.0489421077,
-0.004252207,
0.0136865713,
-0.0212509166,
0.0051524364,
0.0291534308,
0.0480805263,
0.0222807173,
-0.0330147408,
0.002449336,
-0.0198734682,
0.0146620832,
0.0081350477,
0.0420123637,
-0.0254167486,
-0.0282481965,
0.0118686669,
0.0024017703,
-0.0266300607,
-0.0238223691,
2.411e-7,
0.013001156,
0.0252976567,
0.0525807552,
0.0468111448,
0.0412340797,
0.0082078697,
-0.0737059787,
0.0487783141,
-0.0313300379,
0.0318728276,
0.0200744271,
0.0236336328,
0.0434763171,
0.0222637355,
-0.0832336918,
0.063925907,
-0.0597076751,
0.0233946424,
-0.0906701162,
-0.0368354246,
0.0731048882,
0.0089484556,
-0.0119497059,
-0.0156361721,
0.0189729147,
-0.0596755482,
0.0211531576,
0.0039653094,
0.0391656533,
-0.019779738,
0.0469495282,
-0.0250204112,
0.0147694228,
-0.0344353281,
0.0010589429,
0.0409421101,
0.0225174669,
-0.0021675967,
0.0204782113,
0.0338048004,
0.0726417825,
-0.0001429321,
0.0163599197,
-0.0171164144,
0.0319297947,
0.0839171112,
-0.0215982962,
-0.0022097502,
0.0182992779,
-0.0039451453,
0.0450123698,
-0.0424276032,
-0.0299258269,
-0.0111090699,
0.014604493,
-0.0218923334,
0.0450006686,
-0.0132510606,
-0.0432034284,
-0.0406067371,
-0.0501973368,
-0.0151003366,
-0.0344880261,
0.0299355052,
0.0038145941,
-0.1018941551,
-0.0222672969,
1.970993163e-34,
0.0632377043,
-0.0349624865,
0.005818984,
-0.0152978711,
0.0445113219,
0.0037089542,
0.0198863279,
0.0117097739,
-0.0329591893,
-0.0652474388,
-0.0405314974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15265v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15265v1 | Perception of Phonological Assimilation by Neural Speech Recognition Models | 2024-06-21T15:58:22 | 2024-06-21T15:58:22 | Charlotte Pouw, Marianne de Heer Kloots, Afra Alishahi, Willem Zuidema | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human listeners effortlessly compensate for phonological changes during
speech perception, often unconsciously inferring the intended sounds. For
example, listeners infer the underlying /n/ when hearing an utterance such as
"clea[m] pan", where [m] arises from place assimilation to the following labial
[p]. This article explores how the neural speech recognition model Wav2Vec2
perceives assimilated sounds, and identifies the linguistic knowledge that is
implemented by the model to compensate for assimilation during Automatic Speech
Recognition (ASR). Using psycholinguistic stimuli, we systematically analyze
how various linguistic context cues influence compensation patterns in the
model's output. Complementing these behavioral experiments, our probing
experiments indicate that the model shifts its interpretation of assimilated
sounds from their acoustic form to their underlying form in its final layers.
Finally, our causal intervention experiments suggest that the model relies on
minimal phonological context cues to accomplish this shift. These findings
represent a step towards better understanding the similarities and differences
in phonological processing between neural ASR models and humans. | [
0.0005260796,
0.05172126,
0.0041767354,
-0.0001184468,
-0.0136968046,
-0.0122567378,
0.0123561239,
-0.0110433521,
0.0091588432,
0.0196500942,
-0.0503786206,
0.0010159553,
0.0738069192,
-0.016266102,
0.0524854027,
0.0171164498,
0.052857291,
-0.0577564389,
-0.0042319205,
-0.031483423,
0.0011717801,
0.0069321371,
-0.0292136874,
0.0083101233,
0.0398099646,
0.0049958695,
-0.0058312481,
0.0327236466,
-0.0467944294,
0.0144815724,
0.0084646363,
0.0248588063,
0.0029605939,
0.0044150269,
0.0000016002,
-0.0459200293,
0.0277009774,
-0.008449587,
-0.0638224706,
0.0487650111,
-0.034707848,
0.0005540417,
-0.0300964992,
0.0019244058,
0.0307358559,
-0.0003071998,
0.0618427992,
0.0090287244,
-0.0445122495,
-0.0302562546,
-0.0056299563,
-0.035881564,
-0.0187378991,
-0.0006689953,
-0.0374750607,
-0.0047150352,
0.060367845,
-0.0659567118,
-0.0425591655,
-0.0638061613,
-0.0233955551,
-0.002136504,
-0.0149585549,
0.0363691449,
0.0066846488,
0.0498353876,
0.0091771465,
-0.0772702694,
-0.0779132321,
0.002961738,
-0.0005144188,
-0.082115002,
0.0078440327,
0.0228745528,
0.0048086178,
-0.0353699997,
0.0139963273,
-0.0119246412,
-0.005468653,
-0.0041995011,
-0.0094876504,
-0.0066070696,
0.0005524725,
-0.0244707968,
0.0119822398,
0.05330538,
0.016803164,
-0.051311262,
-0.0185629707,
0.0148121091,
0.0221214741,
-0.0084181847,
0.0802525207,
0.0066071474,
0.0038154479,
-0.0073025734,
0.0341085456,
0.0031870774,
0.0085317791,
-0.0590897501,
0.0171469525,
0.0321463309,
-0.0642113015,
-0.0329517275,
-0.0678877383,
0.0516771264,
-0.0381294377,
-0.0178089142,
-0.0309726335,
0.0207932796,
0.0188774765,
-0.0234795213,
-0.0060364036,
-0.0060099522,
0.0040518073,
0.0096717114,
0.0181155875,
0.0107403463,
-0.0228290353,
-0.0160716809,
-0.0125567457,
0.0313840471,
-0.0551278889,
-0.0016567329,
0.0047703981,
0.0716806874,
0.0041492824,
0.0613591298,
-0.0211589299,
-0.0344163328,
-0.0305512194,
0.0030655758,
0.0352245532,
0.010320656,
0.0051097143,
0.0579920001,
-0.0004148344,
0.0108558899,
-0.0106882472,
0.0222308841,
-0.0186594278,
0.0129160536,
-0.0177609567,
-0.0102987289,
-0.0102007492,
-0.0156749673,
-0.0189945009,
-0.0512882508,
-0.0354208499,
-0.0321893021,
-0.0451629683,
0.0550098009,
0.0091466075,
0.0190134607,
0.0868225321,
0.0130624007,
0.0063859089,
0.0068946788,
0.0156100094,
-0.0222316068,
-0.0219749343,
-0.0674168468,
-0.0111229783,
0.0378937125,
0.022205906,
-0.0115885939,
-0.0354382545,
-0.024225235,
-0.0147038521,
0.0228866134,
0.0884608105,
0.0103112608,
-0.0240634549,
-0.0667808726,
0.0553555898,
0.0820956826,
0.0304636601,
0.0218737852,
0.0117420023,
-0.0268401783,
-0.0077201189,
0.0344717503,
-0.0710047185,
0.0113883875,
-0.0626740679,
0.0289344639,
0.022697974,
0.049036026,
-0.0135572786,
-0.0073118694,
-0.0171150602,
0.0102510154,
0.0203341581,
-0.0011523506,
0.0040966617,
0.021181507,
-0.034234833,
-0.0113467863,
0.0203567091,
0.0036476923,
0.0600192249,
-0.0061631007,
0.044026047,
-0.0072013019,
-0.0147554176,
-0.0014653323,
0.0089091482,
0.0064276005,
-0.0515866615,
0.0436217561,
0.0286218021,
0.0214876849,
0.0331492089,
0.0001045032,
-0.0222263448,
0.1014987528,
-0.0072795199,
0.0785987154,
-0.0145743135,
-0.0218571033,
-0.0291751698,
0.0089702299,
-0.0002662451,
0.0158033613,
-0.0347055234,
-0.0403649062,
-0.0245077629,
-0.0237482265,
0.0186745767,
0.0209174585,
-0.0028083913,
0.0327678621,
0.025818415,
0.0380624086,
0.0167092383,
0.0623171814,
-0.0309753604,
-0.0118124299,
0.0424340665,
0.0084102154,
0.0295253135,
-0.0054839761,
0.0854464322,
-0.0668762773,
0.0362225994,
-0.0122604147,
0.0755518675,
-0.0247780848,
0.0052825706,
-0.0028088542,
0.055103261,
0.0200315975,
-0.037899185,
-0.0158726685,
-0.0518483371,
0.004495048,
0.0006113661,
-0.0204812661,
-0.0499010086,
-0.0219002776,
0.0293180961,
-0.0387373529,
0.0139488503,
-0.000783744,
-0.0638243556,
-0.0641844124,
0.0264245197,
-0.0555574,
0.0191327445,
0.043959029,
0.0139452573,
0.0222846288,
0.0074876649,
0.0093406364,
-0.0413001962,
-0.0117262574,
-0.0416081473,
-0.0238481835,
0.0753748566,
-0.0532127991,
-0.0298043322,
-0.0245383829,
-0.0576340333,
-0.0092668841,
-0.0203087311,
0.0049516372,
-0.0313032381,
-0.0294180345,
-0.0974205658,
-0.0378099047,
0.0088361921,
-0.0084087001,
0.0262112599,
-0.0380222797,
0.0020239917,
0.018231893,
0.0324572027,
0.0536427908,
-0.0221609361,
0.0227129534,
0.0487223975,
-0.0113624064,
-0.0285437647,
-0.0232043192,
-0.0274367817,
0.0231371298,
0.0229689609,
-0.0151552455,
-0.0652504936,
0.073787801,
0.0499096885,
0.0063347179,
-0.0521561392,
-0.0025697986,
-0.0135666821,
-0.0715481788,
-0.0182333905,
-0.0744479522,
-0.0753865764,
0.0420211405,
-0.0393022783,
-0.0128150946,
0.0552346185,
-0.0686944127,
-0.0569411516,
-0.0274951905,
-0.0110937087,
0.039839942,
-0.0689623058,
0.0266716257,
-0.00577247,
0.0359918959,
-0.0537464954,
-0.0247260425,
-0.0026568091,
-0.019335296,
-0.0383983701,
0.0096650776,
-0.0018292584,
-0.0266002472,
0.0391709618,
0.024133103,
-0.0429771543,
0.0180927571,
-0.0316982716,
0.0544894226,
-0.0459885299,
-0.0008739707,
0.0681752041,
0.009117228,
0.0566176362,
0.0556785353,
-0.0119303716,
0.0083895447,
-0.0419617668,
0.0199294202,
0.0243166015,
0.0675627217,
0.0118844444,
0.0011328418,
0.0174084548,
-0.0414560586,
0.049941577,
0.0532209426,
-0.0147536285,
0.0763326362,
0.0491697602,
0.0069381869,
0.0236287117,
0.042169448,
0.0221120119,
-0.0072733262,
-0.0087565538,
0.0374664664,
0.0125268325,
-0.0557812266,
0.0192483123,
-0.0224067103,
0.0052384166,
0.0075627919,
-0.0032010449,
0.0089051826,
0.0406244174,
0.0441218168,
0.0050812219,
0.0105897747,
0.0424060374,
0.0011828525,
-0.03622403,
0.0382951945,
0.0342873819,
0.0016979474,
0.0134406062,
-0.0281254742,
0.0533936433,
0.0042951377,
0.0573048219,
0.0532953851,
-0.0220646914,
-0.0354095511,
0.0537975244,
-0.0265192278,
-0.0214111321,
-0.0095437216,
-0.0108798705,
0.1031977758,
0.0605176166,
-0.0236947313,
-0.043450214,
-0.0594576299,
0.0572565347,
-0.0229862258,
0.014052229,
-0.0221934039,
0.011840581,
0.0845099986,
-0.0150367776,
-0.0028854343,
0.04527729,
-0.0165778231,
-0.0454730578,
-0.0001380269,
0.0543928035,
0.0361252762,
0.0075204624,
0.0275071766,
0.0585624985,
-0.0467723049,
0.0529016629,
0.0886510983,
-0.0634977221,
0.01438912,
0.0009500818,
0.018030582,
0.0323820002,
-0.0511797331,
0.0315570496,
-0.0131770121,
-0.0534813739,
-0.0260486249,
0.0092918947,
-0.0214092787,
0.0016398379,
0.0638600141,
0.0166782495,
0.0147990854,
-0.0279816817,
-0.006752199,
0.0214695614,
0.001148099,
0.0334187858,
-0.003915824,
0.0083498154,
-0.0036377276,
-0.0814695656,
-0.0269348919,
-0.0030927511,
0.0252764989,
-0.074384667,
0.0417853333,
-0.0362670273,
0.0329431668,
0.088072218,
-0.0427179821,
-0.0347462371,
0.026664272,
-0.0350412503,
-0.0008795598,
0.05253613,
0.020884946,
0.0119932871,
0.0032405455,
0.0036547098,
-0.0166877881,
0.0104745766,
-0.0148098227,
-0.0118504325,
0.0085107451,
-0.0454843566,
0.0280012209,
-0.0324758403,
0.0668528527,
-0.0506068505,
0.0095207533,
-0.01461046,
0.0208292417,
0.0383620784,
0.0523530617,
0.0339281671,
-0.0561250113,
0.0285530146,
0.0468121991,
-0.0105567547,
-0.0456814095,
-0.0406335369,
0.0205100719,
0.0109198913,
0.0245461129,
0.0012160353,
0.0551652461,
0.0058321166,
0.0303307325,
-0.0157332737,
0.0296997037,
-0.0395323969,
0.0353550278,
0.001945489,
-0.0079298206,
-0.0038590531,
-0.0063743195,
-0.043474976,
0.0083323941,
-0.0282944795,
-0.0231358707,
0.0231071487,
0.004047235,
0.0322673731,
-0.041967012,
0.0370824002,
0.0188695639,
0.0492022485,
-0.0219314005,
-0.0581812374,
-0.0575408787,
0.0240845457,
0.0298673138,
0.0154162114,
0.0046126377,
0.0120750573,
0.0131312367,
-0.0285240728,
0.0375568308,
-0.058421351,
0.0488227457,
0.0017880261,
-0.0174678117,
-0.0223171804,
0.0212449674,
-0.0982203558,
-0.0206522532,
-0.0127827898,
-0.0581865422,
-0.0009836296,
0.0077406294,
0.0636277124,
-0.0273144711,
-0.0442493781,
-0.0376246311,
-0.0314275101,
-0.0331398919,
0.0681614503,
-0.0057010278,
-0.0086141182,
-0.0056178467,
0.0198967364,
-6.093786592e-33,
-0.019388387,
0.0026711312,
0.0028205451,
0.0194696095,
-0.0185654666,
0.0022095467,
-0.0638662726,
0.0074084159,
-0.0026837783,
-0.0171458218,
-0.0062708845,
-0.0271302387,
0.0402509384,
-0.050428018,
0.0500092655,
0.0276449751,
0.0401280001,
-0.0309735723,
0.0134548917,
-0.0567754693,
0.0075482633,
0.0274797473,
0.0399159566,
-0.0534380414,
0.0189468432,
0.0452904887,
-0.023066109,
-0.0184322335,
-0.0041870419,
0.0463238023,
-0.0479119569,
0.0388974287,
0.0204015505,
-0.0009053781,
-0.024883857,
0.0468457267,
-0.0656430274,
0.0045511336,
0.0541463792,
0.0555697493,
0.0002326479,
-0.0151478043,
0.0799347684,
-0.0316843837,
-0.0277680922,
0.0335908122,
0.0010098673,
-0.0242730305,
-0.0094346916,
0.055614613,
-0.0526022129,
-0.0478696711,
-0.0179266874,
-0.0108094309,
0.0466197655,
-0.0054653119,
-0.0417941287,
-0.0356636867,
-0.062714994,
0.0077042235,
0.0021423078,
0.0315875225,
0.0101463366,
0.0400557332,
-0.0102062551,
-0.0338062048,
0.1446229666,
-0.0234291181,
0.0262680575,
-0.0558427386,
0.0720388591,
-0.0283176284,
0.0386743955,
-0.0148518598,
0.0319108292,
-0.0378263667,
0.0510816947,
-0.0530725792,
0.0080721267,
-0.0129906079,
0.0052349307,
0.0255210921,
-0.0058120578,
-0.0119502265,
-0.0280657243,
-0.0863922015,
-0.0760420486,
-0.0093247136,
0.0449146032,
-0.0515723526,
0.0403218754,
-0.007770678,
0.0595406964,
-0.0428583398,
0.0292425547,
-0.0350967944,
0.0051425453,
-0.0209167786,
0.0081758453,
0.0482797176,
-0.0318423472,
0.0015349106,
0.0077150674,
0.0203410275,
-0.0040899254,
0.0050869896,
-0.0341023281,
0.0150491279,
0.0076770033,
-0.0223204028,
-0.0686271191,
-0.0599622168,
0.0809350684,
-0.0121159954,
0.0303075239,
0.0413983092,
-0.0200570561,
-0.0425650962,
0.0133364396,
0.0189546272,
-0.0292792935,
0.0422070026,
-0.0329256319,
0.0838431492,
-0.0420381352,
-0.0025490562,
0.0321614631,
0.020125933,
0.0300179869,
0.0191802997,
-0.0140380654,
0.0252165981,
2.654e-7,
-0.0347029902,
0.0332555324,
0.0382825844,
-0.0332809761,
0.0708310604,
-0.0204792414,
-0.0456992574,
0.0064451788,
0.0676549599,
-0.0089483121,
-0.0070866565,
-0.0142654395,
0.070219852,
-0.0199602004,
-0.0093498388,
-0.0296190195,
-0.0325256139,
0.059255179,
-0.0179743096,
0.0146839945,
-0.0199209638,
-0.0312819853,
-0.0107942764,
-0.0594773628,
-0.0471152104,
0.0045022881,
-0.005349847,
-0.0275703818,
0.0591097027,
-0.0457371287,
0.025692489,
-0.0303553995,
0.0178924315,
0.0280633699,
-0.0241177734,
0.0419664234,
-0.0130509073,
-0.0133445747,
-0.0303513929,
-0.0256321877,
0.0045261839,
0.0364401564,
-0.0439358689,
-0.0511026233,
0.0137706418,
-0.0098624863,
0.0083848322,
-0.0115468213,
-0.0338606127,
-0.0245473962,
0.0062978817,
0.0089207431,
-0.0021526699,
0.0217159223,
-0.0287856124,
0.0264591817,
-0.0454028733,
0.0104271751,
-0.0303930435,
0.0537692793,
-0.0586799271,
0.0113547994,
-0.0215188414,
-0.0108967228,
0.0200023465,
-0.0429076217,
-0.0009718171,
1.457209837e-34,
-0.0120715071,
-0.0208065193,
0.0940096229,
0.0498419143,
-0.0259029176,
-0.0363904275,
0.0131471539,
0.0449230932,
0.0323134027,
-0.0546173304,
-0.0534495562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15264v1 | Towards Fine-Grained Citation Evaluation in Generated Text: A Comparative Analysis of Faithfulness Metrics | 2024-06-21T15:57:24 | 2024-06-21T15:57:24 | Weijia Zhang, Mohammad Aliannejadi, Yifei Yuan, Jiahuan Pei, Jia-Hong Huang, Evangelos Kanoulas | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) often produce unsupported or unverifiable
information, known as "hallucinations." To mitigate this, retrieval-augmented
LLMs incorporate citations, grounding the content in verifiable sources.
Despite such developments, manually assessing how well a citation supports the
associated statement remains a major challenge. Previous studies use
faithfulness metrics to estimate citation support automatically but are limited
to binary classification, overlooking fine-grained citation support in
practical scenarios. To investigate the effectiveness of faithfulness metrics
in fine-grained scenarios, we propose a comparative evaluation framework that
assesses the metric effectiveness in distinguishinging citations between
three-category support levels: full, partial, and no support. Our framework
employs correlation analysis, classification evaluation, and retrieval
evaluation to measure the alignment between metric scores and human judgments
comprehensively. Our results show no single metric consistently excels across
all evaluations, revealing the complexity of assessing fine-grained support.
Based on the findings, we provide practical recommendations for developing more
effective metrics. | [
0.073906824,
0.0101261316,
-0.004657825,
0.0104350122,
-0.0448737256,
0.019775968,
-0.0073712389,
0.0228833687,
0.041100014,
-0.0811959356,
0.0133001124,
0.0293810572,
0.0234601311,
-0.0536077879,
0.0156213725,
0.0065057692,
0.0321390554,
0.037519116,
0.0646285266,
0.0273699854,
-0.0020210911,
0.0339718685,
0.0401114896,
0.0492259115,
0.0213352498,
0.0018370284,
0.0579457358,
0.0071886801,
0.0432204008,
-0.0159561019,
0.0217401795,
0.0511441045,
-0.0237611327,
0.0391048789,
0.0000019045,
-0.059418872,
0.0008558404,
0.035624478,
0.0119695356,
0.0240213443,
0.0338218249,
-0.0037481822,
0.0127302604,
-0.0087418118,
0.0043295482,
0.0094258506,
0.0044750241,
0.0463303961,
0.0376356281,
0.0141586475,
-0.0075023128,
-0.046533417,
0.0501450971,
0.0283875354,
0.0070390007,
0.0116886031,
0.0245281328,
0.0723674297,
0.0215337444,
0.0631107017,
0.051022809,
0.0253660083,
-0.0261174496,
-0.0102600651,
0.0416959412,
-0.0280029494,
-0.0602207668,
-0.0016269787,
0.0722253248,
0.0075196717,
-0.0021393856,
-0.0701293126,
0.0267138146,
-0.0198290292,
-0.0012875863,
0.0724687353,
-0.028030403,
-0.0087192412,
-0.0075365701,
-0.0115278047,
0.0262135845,
0.0113704633,
0.0348070338,
0.0243056621,
-0.0026510758,
0.0585989207,
0.0103542442,
-0.0378644727,
0.0105962027,
0.0091826068,
-0.0095368354,
-0.033158008,
-0.0013331658,
0.0103660207,
0.0350740589,
-0.02695073,
-0.0019544296,
-0.0084793614,
0.0793707222,
-0.0536382906,
0.0005474381,
-0.0119896261,
-0.040639434,
0.0515000559,
-0.0640431568,
0.0321882665,
-0.0243795905,
-0.0359635651,
0.0083979182,
-0.002006718,
-0.0596619956,
0.0112105832,
-0.0086454302,
0.000985846,
-0.0107289199,
-0.0139359394,
-0.0488115549,
0.004537066,
-0.0435765237,
0.0416407399,
-0.0054822466,
-0.0308504272,
0.0312193464,
-0.001847358,
-0.0232060719,
-0.0029886593,
-0.0226358734,
0.0554242991,
-0.0381492674,
-0.044182092,
0.0208796524,
0.0393679403,
0.0116211986,
-0.0502713174,
0.0323020555,
0.029561663,
0.0439156666,
-0.0174939334,
-0.0544750728,
-0.0452024192,
-0.0238520745,
-0.0540885776,
-0.0153117357,
-0.0730768144,
0.01095693,
0.0573798344,
0.0087867593,
-0.041398976,
0.0027442896,
0.0233512837,
-0.0736916289,
0.0032126112,
-0.0284030661,
-0.0008753979,
0.0106037268,
-0.0060516959,
0.0388202742,
0.0110005932,
0.026849594,
0.0126329781,
0.041800715,
0.0100591956,
0.0044628177,
-0.0261620376,
-0.0072777113,
0.0280743726,
-0.0172433332,
-0.0037249874,
-0.0223099515,
-0.0026104276,
-0.0069569605,
0.0449342318,
-0.0349489227,
0.0166361835,
0.0613062046,
0.0063712397,
0.0179315228,
0.0048140949,
0.0668234006,
0.0142091047,
0.0265868735,
0.0127786137,
-0.0195536017,
-0.0127357719,
-0.0283434484,
0.0216931682,
0.0539767779,
0.0183386765,
0.002956107,
-0.0327820852,
-0.0325984024,
0.0094438959,
-0.0137384785,
-0.0259991623,
0.025579799,
-0.0181072541,
-0.0354449898,
0.0504100621,
0.0120381825,
-0.0558222234,
0.0404617898,
-0.005676969,
0.033667855,
0.0421072505,
0.0668000504,
-0.0075764921,
0.0411142521,
0.003618811,
-0.0027901405,
0.0061621009,
-0.0077336347,
0.0014036095,
-0.0044645062,
-0.0371615216,
-0.0213629697,
-0.0044398606,
0.0277516712,
-0.0419192053,
0.0149100376,
-0.0111951409,
0.024001725,
-0.0819506273,
-0.0588874295,
0.0396544524,
0.0173849631,
-0.0165350512,
-0.0377866775,
-0.0021359583,
0.0128770359,
0.0215008501,
-0.0345655866,
0.0206070319,
0.0199127309,
-0.0204684976,
0.0156727284,
0.0121986382,
0.0410244204,
0.0688633844,
0.0328988917,
0.0014513067,
0.0101149324,
-0.0062101497,
0.0037297145,
-0.0219312701,
0.0194732454,
-0.0228421725,
-0.0047628842,
-0.0346655175,
0.0435136333,
-0.0570007972,
0.0189605393,
-0.0594899058,
0.0625235438,
0.0263124891,
0.096359022,
0.0148050375,
-0.0388598517,
0.0675408766,
0.0113023333,
-0.0651126355,
-0.0266191028,
-0.0231262017,
0.0139004681,
0.0745226592,
-0.0311444402,
-0.0340962745,
-0.0462634526,
-0.0400015563,
-0.011088253,
0.000052753,
0.0329536758,
0.0065280041,
-0.0295337345,
0.007775608,
0.0223236438,
0.0114603834,
-0.0278905053,
-0.0127829257,
-0.0014887649,
0.0355817378,
0.0107841212,
-0.0055011236,
-0.0451375581,
0.0029216281,
-0.0063510919,
0.0495706722,
0.0567518137,
0.0106889056,
-0.0838320255,
0.0232548937,
-0.0417075455,
-0.0242611151,
0.0121814599,
0.0072023994,
-0.002662241,
0.0228869859,
0.0306612458,
0.0083943093,
0.0130041596,
-0.0259701759,
0.0337489098,
0.0080178548,
-0.0645987391,
-0.0523229353,
-0.0162137225,
-0.0377654433,
-0.0182633549,
-0.0641148239,
0.0323034152,
0.0198805761,
-0.0016656518,
-0.0081381239,
-0.0491266288,
-0.007864939,
-0.0122795636,
0.0144597162,
-0.0036080012,
-0.0302778445,
0.0015006388,
0.0459539294,
0.0037450008,
-0.0347185619,
0.0097771809,
-0.0732410103,
0.0300687365,
0.0002164898,
-0.0051209014,
-0.0006568691,
0.0163421147,
0.0212739706,
-0.0097156651,
0.0233568791,
0.0108405044,
-0.0171484463,
0.0146067645,
0.0378239229,
-0.0350430645,
0.0198854208,
-0.0135463178,
0.0286891758,
0.0064810812,
0.0426924452,
-0.0181100499,
-0.0047463137,
-0.0300123449,
0.0276128035,
0.0191384871,
-0.0023409517,
-0.0363911726,
0.0015885718,
0.0660861582,
-0.0138601428,
-0.0208655037,
-0.0370790288,
-0.0331177115,
0.0363458022,
0.0306821913,
-0.004981251,
0.0435241014,
-0.0040565841,
-0.0564863384,
0.0230365098,
-0.0127878673,
0.0468037985,
-0.0521880724,
-0.0691741928,
0.0250334498,
-0.0506459437,
-0.0272975694,
0.0209166221,
0.0371673517,
-0.0457042903,
-0.020061221,
0.0969301611,
0.0295190737,
-0.0384362563,
-0.0423444435,
-0.067304343,
0.0127749974,
0.0285189543,
0.0004822062,
-0.0712667108,
0.0048162569,
0.0090877237,
0.0160330962,
-0.0385555439,
-0.0200448222,
0.027617136,
-0.08184129,
0.0381660573,
0.0040314826,
0.0336552002,
-0.0391995236,
-0.0753475279,
0.0500400774,
0.0120224245,
-0.027242817,
0.0180837046,
-0.0049541919,
-0.0047416887,
0.0021480443,
-0.0215475243,
-0.0609778389,
0.0096958736,
-0.0543545187,
0.0149203027,
0.0481007807,
0.0501096435,
-0.0124354139,
-0.0472562611,
0.0084686494,
-0.0850428715,
-0.0282985829,
0.0197790246,
0.0234321821,
0.0147399129,
0.0383223146,
-0.0013937398,
-0.0225327164,
0.0271507595,
-0.0342241749,
0.00615812,
0.0786198378,
-0.0127025694,
0.0078897895,
-0.0386251472,
0.0246294439,
-0.0038799844,
0.0811054558,
0.0578328371,
0.003138612,
-0.0153126828,
0.0178641863,
0.0611225292,
-0.0148255127,
-0.0419610664,
0.0196353495,
-0.0320046805,
0.0258452054,
-0.0841162279,
-0.0104904827,
-0.0367944092,
-0.0281110015,
0.0165689141,
0.0589289442,
0.0141532104,
-0.0322549529,
-0.0492229052,
0.0261072721,
-0.042615708,
0.025197139,
-0.0229168963,
0.0304819886,
-0.0102312919,
-0.0005919862,
-0.0178236645,
-0.0088344449,
0.0287328809,
-0.0082459627,
-0.0029134096,
0.0002427647,
0.0211897269,
-0.0243067481,
-0.0292034186,
-0.0409272276,
0.0086729266,
0.0783152804,
-0.0371741764,
0.0149742989,
0.0014958131,
-0.0351716988,
-0.0206013899,
-0.0043294146,
-0.0723864138,
0.0294899214,
-0.0120170545,
0.0098878555,
0.0295065176,
-0.0532477275,
0.0108459527,
0.02368588,
0.0496891253,
-0.0257761572,
0.032554891,
0.0062873843,
-0.0390940607,
-0.0116740465,
-0.0291915238,
-0.012713423,
0.0008877787,
0.0109809041,
0.0254104529,
-0.0220598821,
0.0460701846,
-0.0353357345,
0.0817855448,
-0.0525597781,
-0.0076737353,
-0.0454392061,
0.0730995536,
-0.0335375369,
-0.0333086252,
-0.0513039492,
-0.0454011336,
-0.0313258469,
0.0316790119,
-0.0132599287,
0.0302633476,
0.0093148164,
0.0065474636,
0.0032945098,
0.0190732218,
-0.0781860054,
0.0075481599,
-0.0296642352,
-0.057729166,
0.0245380178,
-0.0387188457,
0.0934604183,
-0.0226675328,
-0.0457698405,
-0.0166051891,
0.0390286557,
0.0163671896,
0.0240511224,
-0.0150550492,
0.0228323825,
-0.0425811037,
0.0427087061,
0.0169639178,
0.015990356,
0.0109647894,
-0.0457420573,
-0.0442621112,
0.0087095229,
-0.0616157763,
-0.0720990226,
0.0252929647,
-0.0129936021,
-0.034662284,
-0.0870411247,
-0.0269566849,
0.0227334462,
0.0430516526,
0.0072687161,
-0.031347625,
-0.0147335185,
0.0471229926,
0.0061542727,
-0.0051022065,
-0.0527816899,
0.0155143691,
-0.0081495875,
0.0052549513,
-0.0412448049,
-6.196778631e-33,
-0.0110779181,
-0.0416135453,
-0.0268666036,
-0.0357890613,
-0.0293459408,
-0.0000069786,
-0.0426019728,
-0.0222875215,
-0.0578130297,
0.0246270951,
0.0011498692,
-0.0083498573,
0.0041280906,
-0.0254634805,
0.0381592624,
0.0485404953,
0.0289781597,
0.0376520492,
-0.0473632067,
0.022165129,
0.0612610951,
-0.0404978879,
0.0234217066,
-0.1522999704,
0.0959241539,
-0.0469187796,
-0.0219893996,
-0.0322925001,
0.0420188233,
0.057854116,
0.0029821694,
0.0164099373,
0.0455707125,
-0.0263708141,
0.0146706849,
0.0030675954,
-0.0697569698,
0.0152938366,
0.042312853,
-0.0394094177,
-0.0115372445,
-0.0196809433,
0.0531650558,
-0.0087686703,
-0.0418337025,
-0.0003412694,
0.0990987942,
-0.0706086382,
-0.0059704832,
-0.0805072412,
-0.0668132007,
0.0354857631,
0.0387192704,
0.0561936945,
-0.0091662584,
0.084351182,
-0.0002063413,
0.1292874366,
-0.0324052349,
-0.0041254694,
-0.0513231494,
0.0348614492,
-0.0008698867,
-0.0380374119,
0.0053729448,
0.05527284,
-0.0188202094,
-0.0331178382,
-0.0079322848,
-0.0436015092,
0.0280613117,
0.0278542545,
0.0703044087,
0.116999492,
0.0324091762,
-0.01393048,
-0.0509369075,
0.0227105562,
-0.0207335465,
0.0416229814,
0.027834747,
-0.0153634241,
-0.0288298633,
-0.0076615419,
-0.0303902794,
-0.0438005216,
-0.0447176173,
-0.0240070075,
0.0000874624,
-0.0202064216,
-0.0267239287,
0.0173100121,
0.0393537097,
-0.0201729294,
-0.0024910735,
0.0809675083,
-0.0556879602,
0.0399384238,
0.0230225641,
0.0147844916,
-0.0479988791,
-0.0462393239,
0.0019912361,
-0.0058248127,
0.0339634269,
0.0033521364,
0.0445897356,
-0.0190320518,
-0.0593977869,
-0.0057983855,
0.0074599693,
-0.0095034577,
-0.0476727448,
-0.0547521077,
0.0182872359,
0.0250402112,
0.0369614772,
0.0013140865,
0.0391931124,
0.0216453932,
0.0083744656,
0.0068985727,
-0.0049793292,
0.0136563852,
-0.0030775145,
-0.0141850272,
-0.0256056469,
0.0444507971,
-0.0218123831,
-0.0219589323,
0.0154080335,
-0.0013148749,
2.702e-7,
0.0406034552,
0.0319001265,
-0.0288662761,
-0.0557753034,
-0.0137945106,
0.0183890983,
0.014105116,
-0.0058298046,
0.0212164018,
-0.0015078635,
-0.0084562171,
-0.0381809361,
0.0371537469,
-0.0001762518,
-0.0364152864,
-0.0182486884,
-0.0630522817,
-0.0328854397,
-0.0145957582,
-0.0044414434,
0.0140834758,
0.0114943283,
0.0110256393,
0.0144545455,
-0.0231085401,
-0.0716844723,
0.0615363009,
-0.0323525146,
0.0047143432,
0.0456797406,
0.0660071075,
0.0236471165,
0.0239461157,
0.0090866014,
-0.0116158864,
0.0274835993,
0.0140790669,
0.0374533236,
0.0216223393,
0.0234254431,
-0.0207144935,
-0.0395924412,
0.0472972393,
-0.0833572894,
0.0309982393,
-0.0285370238,
0.0016583463,
-0.0585038923,
-0.1049492806,
0.0126470793,
0.0025039203,
0.0202913024,
-0.0289081763,
0.019378718,
-0.0138385687,
0.042025689,
-0.0536649749,
-0.0477738343,
-0.028834559,
0.0589261241,
-0.0126652326,
-0.074185513,
0.0104695475,
-0.0422788821,
0.016801158,
-0.0651028603,
0.0460331514,
2.28891158e-34,
0.0361507088,
-0.010744757,
0.0256192926,
-0.0238540657,
0.0314518213,
0.0182281826,
-0.0421604924,
0.0523177199,
-0.004203348,
-0.0323924422,
0.0373057686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15245v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15245v1 | Unsupervised Morphological Tree Tokenizer | 2024-06-21T15:35:49 | 2024-06-21T15:35:49 | Qingyang Zhu, Xiang Hu, Pengyu Ji, Wei Wu, Kewei Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | As a cornerstone in language modeling, tokenization involves segmenting text
inputs into pre-defined atomic units. Conventional statistical tokenizers often
disrupt constituent boundaries within words, thereby corrupting semantic
information. To address this drawback, we introduce morphological structure
guidance to tokenization and propose a deep model to induce character-level
structures of words. Specifically, the deep model jointly encodes internal
structures and representations of words with a mechanism named
$\textit{MorphOverriding}$ to ensure the indecomposability of morphemes. By
training the model with self-supervised objectives, our method is capable of
inducing character-level structures that align with morphological rules without
annotated training data. Based on the induced structures, our algorithm
tokenizes words through vocabulary matching in a top-down manner. Empirical
results indicate that the proposed method effectively retains complete
morphemes and outperforms widely adopted methods such as BPE and WordPiece on
both morphological segmentation tasks and language modeling tasks. The code
will be released later. | [
-0.0066819019,
0.0946313441,
0.0032900991,
0.0417431854,
-0.0536408834,
-0.0113090454,
0.0020506708,
0.0100435317,
-0.0877390951,
-0.0004551872,
-0.0291352086,
-0.0460215583,
0.0113553256,
0.0386027768,
0.0430580489,
-0.0351431891,
0.0671518147,
-0.0462219864,
-0.0372984,
-0.0009915357,
0.0448264256,
0.0354712196,
0.0135055771,
0.0196969975,
-0.0946717858,
-0.0000056344,
-0.0091644907,
0.0157795176,
-0.0408681855,
-0.0148288142,
-0.0041505778,
0.0262252633,
-0.021206988,
0.0339336656,
0.0000018084,
-0.0320109762,
-0.047843758,
-0.013347079,
-0.0013278737,
0.0108089549,
0.0734352469,
-0.0678440034,
-0.0274725351,
-0.0085956389,
0.0065493505,
0.006634234,
0.0600655302,
0.0252081882,
0.0285655595,
0.0454144739,
-0.0342140011,
-0.0787106901,
0.0544187352,
-0.0113138147,
-0.0447387733,
0.045601055,
0.006553709,
-0.0441220328,
-0.0587725565,
-0.0133815752,
-0.0307271611,
0.0080483733,
-0.0080840373,
-0.0163369011,
0.0165630355,
0.0299961772,
-0.0233736634,
-0.0462697409,
0.0319509804,
0.05633609,
-0.0653776303,
-0.0426770709,
0.0306887925,
-0.0129313031,
-0.0029515196,
-0.0208164398,
-0.0171570536,
0.0141403591,
0.0252318028,
0.0663010478,
0.0592994392,
-0.0110564353,
0.0461195707,
-0.0054065199,
-0.0481047258,
0.0674694553,
0.0623942539,
-0.022571072,
-0.0393165238,
-0.0130885411,
0.0017931031,
-0.035672348,
0.0449033119,
-0.0071573067,
-0.0311488844,
0.0306640361,
-0.0086078271,
-0.0255728289,
0.0254241116,
0.0033685912,
-0.0029487843,
-0.0095320195,
-0.0301645696,
0.0000521004,
-0.0891271904,
-0.0271874089,
0.0025998272,
0.0278939344,
-0.023497114,
-0.0292480439,
-0.0181303136,
-0.031203026,
-0.0589158125,
0.0204270724,
-0.0131447352,
0.0028346609,
-0.0014033621,
-0.0073539885,
0.0180977657,
-0.0239409022,
0.0085539641,
0.019041989,
-0.0684043989,
-0.0131189255,
0.005321559,
0.0004893204,
-0.0529611744,
-0.0026596719,
-0.0123294145,
-0.0141514335,
0.0030133431,
0.0283926558,
0.040131487,
-0.0038584643,
0.0311867092,
0.0882245749,
-0.0244795736,
-0.0592873842,
-0.0039950777,
-0.0382871479,
-0.0466327555,
0.0115815457,
-0.000687742,
-0.0687153339,
0.016960714,
-0.0531627946,
-0.0323698297,
0.0142117636,
-0.0034179606,
-0.0017866291,
0.0020034155,
0.0906981975,
-0.0126029458,
-0.0253236555,
0.0257688519,
-0.0131100575,
0.0612380356,
0.0083986344,
0.0422721021,
0.0419906974,
0.0157023445,
-0.0282558855,
-0.0070539038,
0.0510182455,
-0.0053017419,
-0.036084041,
-0.0663367584,
-0.0433688797,
-0.0283347182,
0.034370847,
0.076036334,
0.0820628181,
-0.0025835529,
-0.02169469,
-0.0116899945,
0.1005143598,
0.0004493653,
0.0562681742,
0.0409864336,
0.0002094242,
-0.0368295349,
0.0193133354,
-0.0239753388,
-0.0179897137,
0.0014980186,
0.0465248562,
-0.0398559198,
0.0349278301,
-0.0033047723,
-0.0130088748,
0.0079941517,
-0.0397770368,
-0.0019343074,
-0.0537923425,
0.074452579,
0.0485336445,
-0.0436500423,
0.0251770597,
0.0372356996,
-0.0429469943,
0.0463280603,
-0.0185677409,
0.0109292846,
0.0537232719,
0.0474995933,
-0.0201548766,
-0.0301968288,
0.020896662,
-0.0175972786,
0.0801362172,
-0.0162808578,
-0.0344030112,
-0.00172723,
-0.0686626062,
0.0171395075,
0.0226798225,
0.0194285512,
0.0374992788,
-0.0259853955,
-0.0110879289,
-0.0005266226,
-0.023604624,
-0.0184501503,
0.0684842914,
0.0008931066,
-0.0282742847,
-0.0135070039,
0.0066733318,
0.0062459917,
-0.0006386539,
-0.0409457311,
0.0171065293,
0.0203309711,
-0.0405453257,
-0.0014977419,
-0.0066045672,
-0.1079306528,
-0.0196627937,
0.0484765396,
-0.0273641404,
-0.0053882836,
-0.043106433,
0.0272530634,
-0.072417371,
0.0497174561,
-0.0314634964,
0.0742387176,
-0.0854152292,
0.0442549214,
0.0007976895,
0.0247369856,
-0.0244965926,
0.0403302759,
0.0169738717,
-0.0192704983,
0.0127929933,
-0.0141202342,
0.0023904741,
-0.0115475981,
-0.0143574513,
0.0017472991,
-0.0210502967,
-0.0236723199,
-0.0035010646,
-0.0049766009,
-0.0160438083,
-0.0366167612,
-0.1042465717,
-0.0200103652,
-0.0217327196,
0.0308369771,
0.0209692065,
0.0331904776,
-0.0065518194,
-0.0179681499,
-0.0289529618,
0.0100230332,
0.0137175834,
0.0045908159,
0.0547052808,
-0.0512548275,
-0.0240346137,
-0.0493805073,
-0.0262959022,
-0.0443584882,
0.0210882556,
0.0044814721,
-0.0455592535,
-0.0261962973,
-0.0556318499,
-0.0138243213,
0.0331657231,
0.022228593,
-0.0568056628,
0.0336694792,
-0.0592468381,
0.1035100967,
0.0454524085,
0.0072167465,
-0.0133756651,
0.0635385066,
-0.0221192911,
-0.0263943821,
-0.043448519,
-0.012669906,
0.0496661812,
-0.0132029457,
-0.02056765,
0.0023181473,
0.1175228357,
-0.020351911,
0.031913273,
-0.0072780102,
0.0176761765,
-0.025295658,
-0.0040775794,
0.0261957534,
0.0128841642,
-0.0531477481,
0.0084667532,
-0.0420466438,
-0.0272990111,
0.0633516163,
-0.0744507164,
-0.0358354338,
-0.030095933,
0.0018238508,
-0.0325742103,
0.0241413638,
0.0247024205,
0.0291384589,
0.0487515479,
-0.0694205612,
-0.0301478766,
0.0455575213,
-0.0075523378,
-0.0028261228,
0.003567039,
-0.0189280715,
-0.0041816165,
0.0102758966,
0.0071683666,
-0.0075345803,
-0.0025989253,
-0.0011884486,
0.0542654842,
0.0586346425,
-0.0300069433,
0.0209598746,
0.0358279869,
-0.0350106806,
0.0540972054,
-0.0017352526,
0.0279532131,
-0.0378662981,
0.0614526495,
0.0335851274,
-0.0230078697,
-0.0232923813,
0.0104081975,
-0.0015922093,
0.0083358521,
0.0101412609,
0.0021261831,
-0.025075119,
0.002300377,
0.0065527852,
-0.0487545878,
-0.0083964374,
-0.0442902297,
0.0269191246,
-0.0206154957,
-0.0399787277,
0.1001673266,
0.0438827835,
-0.0085730692,
0.0164101291,
0.0028305121,
0.0378218889,
-0.0092624454,
-0.0262886062,
-0.0254840795,
-0.0256720297,
0.0449547842,
-0.0154500538,
0.0352535583,
-0.0242140163,
0.0344926342,
-0.0690163299,
0.0072312932,
0.0061803907,
-0.0487241484,
0.0202086233,
-0.0195117816,
0.0021549421,
-0.0177239254,
0.0216540508,
0.0086483983,
-0.0018745869,
-0.00907824,
0.0303685796,
-0.0660048053,
0.005014305,
-0.0244356655,
-0.0688017532,
0.0165166892,
0.0674409196,
0.0327106565,
-0.0266519114,
0.0060609113,
0.0841288567,
-0.0094475253,
0.0005570616,
-0.0024732156,
0.0091489553,
-0.0026426918,
-0.0248843413,
0.0010548491,
0.0192743037,
-0.0214094482,
0.0054380447,
-0.0255891867,
0.050696373,
0.039732229,
-0.0184321105,
-0.0204948317,
-0.0247048605,
-0.0431084335,
0.0310682785,
0.0280884895,
-0.0459814593,
-0.0481338724,
-0.0282866582,
0.0250094943,
-0.0401701443,
-0.0260394476,
-0.0179583672,
0.0158512574,
0.0193607435,
-0.1024511456,
-0.0365477689,
0.0392527655,
0.0167054534,
0.0048222523,
-0.0178491827,
-0.0414223969,
-0.0497400761,
-0.0534854457,
0.008427524,
-0.0179832671,
-0.003765394,
-0.0694281757,
-0.0084930127,
0.0565745868,
0.0235451031,
0.0024023731,
0.0018153709,
0.0200278163,
-0.0371315889,
0.025603354,
0.0148349656,
0.0090566399,
0.0158799086,
-0.0430407003,
-0.0251155104,
0.0671982542,
0.0139548043,
-0.0292967092,
-0.0072796592,
0.0128246583,
0.0049207718,
-0.0160895661,
0.0129961967,
-0.0139640719,
0.0375692472,
0.0082369288,
0.0384808332,
-0.0072892015,
0.0053177271,
0.0345379785,
0.0017409016,
0.0372243635,
-0.0495780744,
0.0773195103,
-0.0475662574,
-0.022429049,
-0.0117650367,
0.0082299812,
-0.0105287936,
0.0302026141,
0.0613112636,
0.0224661026,
0.0090889474,
0.0041451678,
-0.025443295,
-0.0081524523,
0.0343459956,
0.0004621854,
0.048476439,
0.0163702909,
-0.013739571,
0.0153302783,
0.0191444941,
0.0047201086,
-0.0458216183,
0.0094619915,
-0.0855044872,
-0.0283356588,
-0.0163028091,
-0.0023404101,
-0.0765877068,
0.0403948985,
0.0143389897,
0.0337832011,
-0.0859154314,
0.0444760509,
0.0432562865,
-0.0413517803,
0.0024016679,
-0.0356045179,
0.0072091916,
-0.0064971405,
0.0044476581,
-0.0219573248,
-0.0153406532,
-0.0022159244,
0.0355900191,
-0.0508423634,
-0.047306262,
0.0454202443,
0.0720407441,
0.0245611835,
-0.0031837381,
0.0369677916,
-0.0201197974,
0.013459295,
-0.0025301008,
0.0368269272,
-0.0592616536,
-0.0169283804,
-0.0033674506,
-0.0584078059,
-0.0014015322,
0.0134615349,
0.0220785439,
0.0343743525,
0.0378047526,
0.0212272014,
-0.0167233534,
0.0111445747,
0.0120732719,
0.0066837026,
0.0674026683,
-0.028176032,
-0.0038802789,
-5.98131419e-33,
0.0117461421,
-0.0087706419,
-0.0357676782,
-0.0217617378,
0.0145423291,
-0.0063539036,
-0.029595647,
0.0143579962,
0.0372646898,
0.0114861559,
-0.0109698856,
0.0167258754,
0.0186434835,
0.0161649417,
0.0529855788,
0.0138771329,
0.0584956743,
-0.0408982188,
-0.0017899495,
-0.0032977853,
0.0078346897,
0.0569955148,
0.0747506917,
-0.0095731793,
0.0072731278,
0.0198919177,
0.0066785249,
0.0114322286,
0.0046527842,
0.0490421206,
-0.0356499813,
0.0324982405,
0.0154766459,
0.0113313636,
-0.0296854265,
0.0433626734,
-0.1043962762,
0.0008181778,
0.0006661024,
-0.0152886109,
-0.046453312,
-0.0368350446,
0.0614354573,
-0.0308831595,
0.0306810532,
0.0191368721,
0.020255683,
-0.0062124333,
0.0082439724,
-0.0090166405,
-0.0950326622,
0.0199298635,
0.0124560166,
0.0055318414,
0.0866095275,
-0.049069453,
0.0336713158,
-0.0134941535,
0.0188317671,
0.0131099001,
-0.0043390077,
0.0606592335,
0.0611061193,
0.0546205603,
-0.0370148607,
0.0584684983,
0.0850375295,
-0.0413888209,
0.0300679263,
0.011338288,
0.0719603375,
0.0372518897,
0.0478865616,
-0.0120924013,
0.0337059163,
-0.0113094579,
-0.0271006711,
-0.0016574478,
0.0383566469,
0.023007622,
-0.0288922638,
0.0492049977,
0.0020234149,
-0.0250429884,
0.0024696863,
-0.0758245364,
-0.032531973,
-0.0091956351,
0.0136109991,
0.0092898617,
-0.0491582826,
0.0526531525,
0.0150413606,
0.008656933,
-0.0247990973,
-0.0222684573,
0.0283826422,
0.015540055,
-0.0055565927,
0.0392837226,
-0.0288958699,
-0.0708598793,
0.0197657589,
-0.0015866947,
0.0073179747,
0.0058667939,
0.0039498406,
-0.0055572186,
-0.0510633066,
0.009813373,
-0.0116024436,
-0.0263556354,
-0.0090112481,
0.0446651131,
0.0413680524,
0.012961721,
0.0084750364,
-0.001714024,
0.0615422502,
0.0043368395,
-0.0400316417,
0.0218629576,
-0.0464580059,
0.0433315486,
-0.0243025254,
0.0055138264,
-0.0219053905,
-0.0004659984,
0.0567249581,
-0.0295563769,
-0.0059101419,
-0.0064532491,
2.548e-7,
0.0415622778,
0.0690339804,
0.0789538249,
-0.0470110364,
0.0470141359,
0.0039099306,
-0.0115810661,
0.0145470174,
-0.0479364581,
-0.0280137323,
0.014181111,
-0.0258993488,
0.0117124161,
0.0245928708,
-0.1121290475,
0.0356668122,
-0.0599032827,
0.0277387854,
-0.0589868762,
-0.0153610138,
0.0022589157,
0.1056850106,
-0.038119562,
-0.0243399143,
-0.023355186,
-0.0226416215,
0.0165669825,
-0.004419514,
0.0002071572,
0.0273151919,
0.0168978199,
-0.0095654111,
-0.0105717825,
0.0075992844,
-0.0032815572,
0.0174986757,
0.0544955246,
0.0388309956,
-0.0502152406,
0.0075396239,
0.0253619123,
-0.0345996432,
-0.0064421478,
-0.0246725641,
0.0456947945,
-0.017272057,
0.0214805566,
-0.0509433821,
-0.0260352083,
0.0627522171,
-0.0346297882,
-0.0063886512,
-0.051483199,
0.05572211,
0.0517552234,
0.0005431676,
-0.0383402705,
-0.0684832335,
-0.0034084886,
0.0050170552,
-0.0298059694,
0.0120565267,
-0.0427596495,
0.0371880643,
-0.0018222383,
-0.0085586719,
-0.0199329015,
2.380417846e-34,
-0.0018088153,
0.0039569722,
0.0253619067,
0.0556676239,
-0.0078145806,
-0.0442435518,
0.0300772861,
0.0555839129,
-0.026821835,
-0.0134891756,
-0.0343534835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15231v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15231v1 | Detecting Synthetic Lyrics with Few-Shot Inference | 2024-06-21T15:19:21 | 2024-06-21T15:19:21 | Yanis Labrak, Gabriel Meseguer-Brocal, Elena V. Epure | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In recent years, generated content in music has gained significant
popularity, with large language models being effectively utilized to produce
human-like lyrics in various styles, themes, and linguistic structures. This
technological advancement supports artists in their creative processes but also
raises issues of authorship infringement, consumer satisfaction and content
spamming. To address these challenges, methods for detecting generated lyrics
are necessary. However, existing works have not yet focused on this specific
modality or on creative text in general regarding machine-generated content
detection methods and datasets. In response, we have curated the first dataset
of high-quality synthetic lyrics and conducted a comprehensive quantitative
evaluation of various few-shot content detection approaches, testing their
generalization capabilities and complementing this with a human evaluation. Our
best few-shot detector, based on LLM2Vec, surpasses stylistic and statistical
methods, which are shown competitive in other domains at distinguishing
human-written from machine-generated content. It also shows good generalization
capabilities to new artists and models, and effectively detects post-generation
paraphrasing. This study emphasizes the need for further research on creative
content detection, particularly in terms of generalization and scalability with
larger song catalogs. All datasets, pre-processing scripts, and code are
available publicly on GitHub and Hugging Face under the Apache 2.0 license. | [
0.050578665,
0.0431413017,
-0.0072479458,
0.0616916008,
-0.0506602526,
-0.0005854153,
0.0250256713,
0.0187890008,
-0.0253418982,
0.0047726855,
-0.0067327889,
-0.0027499141,
0.0000668033,
-0.0066580963,
0.0325623713,
0.0251185056,
-0.0183338448,
-0.0091111138,
0.0563600808,
0.0270240214,
-0.0297938343,
0.029075224,
-0.024062153,
0.0409425385,
-0.0285198577,
-0.012405389,
0.0040921592,
0.0872399062,
0.0055279885,
-0.0237157978,
-0.0415438227,
0.0544710755,
-0.0289636478,
0.0550881512,
0.0000016245,
-0.0249202177,
-0.0104700336,
-0.0183241796,
-0.014374448,
-0.0274686143,
0.035728544,
-0.027023606,
-0.0356460847,
0.0074327141,
-0.0229733698,
0.008291034,
0.0318279713,
0.002563905,
0.0729997829,
0.07980901,
-0.0091852685,
-0.0504698269,
-0.006568478,
-0.019506393,
0.0492861792,
-0.0216047093,
0.0267544277,
0.0090281991,
0.0298754741,
-0.0042383275,
-0.0152000906,
0.057893388,
-0.0146630304,
-0.0172248576,
0.0223243907,
0.0399648473,
-0.0897792578,
-0.0359626934,
0.0329748839,
0.0239279829,
-0.0182730649,
-0.0282924119,
0.0070136315,
-0.0023522084,
0.0006198169,
-0.0103827156,
-0.0179173648,
0.0048393128,
0.0068799285,
0.0282914452,
-0.0394600332,
-0.0133158071,
-0.0012332343,
-0.0094222147,
0.0196052101,
-0.0251959842,
0.0373956636,
-0.0495877489,
0.0102059888,
-0.0057909088,
0.0028941254,
-0.0490983836,
-0.0022957618,
-0.0089323092,
0.0172406901,
-0.0123326397,
-0.0697384179,
-0.0729557797,
0.0048650345,
-0.0337294489,
0.1101296544,
-0.0124113308,
0.0014624333,
0.0786821097,
-0.0501060858,
-0.0127066802,
-0.0164446142,
0.0301019978,
-0.0039594681,
0.0143050291,
0.0001316188,
-0.0222571213,
-0.0355968401,
-0.0291057155,
0.0243060552,
-0.0188571028,
-0.025200827,
0.0039058258,
0.0434503928,
0.0345868357,
-0.0064833434,
-0.0276476629,
-0.0092955856,
-0.0080174366,
0.0451377779,
-0.0102168899,
0.0046676155,
0.0538335852,
-0.036215134,
-0.0326880403,
-0.0296025015,
0.0346210636,
0.0651338995,
0.0162349697,
0.0676975623,
0.0587335899,
0.0464232005,
-0.0882223323,
-0.0530165248,
-0.0460197441,
-0.0369845517,
-0.0486965105,
-0.0130951591,
-0.0772238448,
0.0229801796,
-0.0363707729,
-0.0301021524,
-0.0154945916,
0.0040725111,
0.0367980562,
-0.062559627,
0.0239010081,
-0.0199520215,
0.0428702049,
-0.0198045578,
-0.004172463,
-0.0000061139,
0.0169637296,
0.0646745265,
0.062951304,
0.0437750928,
-0.016030902,
0.0386903286,
0.0348833799,
0.0081478721,
0.0211672261,
-0.0381735899,
-0.04577896,
-0.0255738404,
0.0445690192,
0.016962342,
0.0221038964,
0.0133498609,
-0.0399984755,
0.0905597061,
0.040544156,
0.0288468786,
0.02595382,
0.0739267692,
0.0433568023,
0.035963174,
0.0032885801,
0.0086028231,
0.0396322235,
0.0126459403,
0.0153197097,
0.0816177949,
0.0048869373,
0.0185618363,
0.0309063494,
-0.0325851589,
-0.0076017505,
-0.0468966365,
-0.0430014469,
0.0023099168,
0.0404512361,
-0.0360726304,
-0.0056259413,
-0.0101532973,
-0.0410790183,
-0.0309954192,
-0.0194998626,
0.0876772404,
0.0618516803,
0.064544484,
0.0224667247,
0.0544992834,
-0.0235010646,
0.001594189,
0.0948891789,
-0.0466615558,
-0.0137771722,
0.0177419856,
0.0228920113,
0.0086435648,
-0.0577713475,
0.0010206777,
0.0041684536,
-0.0279993601,
0.0169164669,
-0.0064975782,
-0.0388391651,
0.0136589138,
0.010733678,
0.0094952341,
-0.0283874441,
0.0442401618,
0.0314400271,
0.0247401036,
0.0347882174,
-0.0659727603,
0.0216879416,
0.0097203432,
-0.0192117728,
0.0003264401,
0.0162445493,
0.0184253603,
-0.0889386609,
0.0586731136,
-0.0530577339,
0.0144494073,
0.0132495575,
-0.016387485,
-0.0171910115,
0.053470999,
-0.0129256453,
0.0035199821,
-0.0228780024,
0.0054560052,
-0.0288150106,
0.0423364379,
0.0475470796,
0.0062635969,
0.0221855212,
0.028220281,
0.0037702909,
-0.0280045178,
0.0597564541,
0.0382949822,
-0.0183938518,
0.0151509987,
0.0091237724,
-0.0184158869,
-0.0463136286,
0.0126026049,
-0.021790674,
-0.0469743833,
-0.0508381352,
0.0170377102,
-0.0176230483,
-0.0178041495,
0.0172747001,
-0.0337758474,
-0.0426124744,
-0.0093051996,
-0.0102785015,
-0.0489964969,
0.0053857849,
0.0225645658,
-0.0168945547,
-0.0083347466,
-0.0525496081,
-0.001089232,
0.0202786513,
-0.0078842267,
-0.0010126982,
-0.0138742467,
0.0232798718,
-0.0026796232,
0.0163308103,
-0.0465625115,
-0.0576192886,
0.0304347407,
-0.0240219608,
-0.0114986515,
-0.0514504574,
0.0328799598,
0.04258582,
0.0094689829,
-0.008530044,
0.0449127071,
0.0037044375,
0.0566794686,
-0.0202158894,
0.022184955,
0.0137180565,
-0.0129947336,
-0.0597519577,
0.0153231202,
0.0465803742,
0.0702702999,
0.0172977541,
0.005987992,
0.0689104497,
-0.0075105475,
0.0261135977,
0.0179741159,
0.0311099198,
-0.0322001949,
0.0174360722,
-0.026162602,
-0.0158801116,
0.0494791195,
-0.0479038954,
-0.0424272381,
0.013779562,
-0.0631897599,
-0.0379911289,
-0.0104404399,
-0.0186970886,
0.0246028826,
0.0016815662,
-0.007561692,
-0.0296871029,
0.0334805697,
0.0463030823,
-0.0340753458,
-0.0186460447,
-0.0090266801,
0.0083230482,
-0.0145343989,
-0.0092745433,
0.0013533636,
-0.0992183909,
0.0014784401,
-0.0303147584,
-0.0128331361,
-0.0297043286,
0.0384713709,
-0.0154265054,
-0.0073172385,
0.0367396027,
-0.0230840482,
-0.0184612069,
-0.0247865506,
0.0789564997,
0.0548688546,
-0.0511570498,
-0.0341018178,
-0.0127467969,
0.0450899526,
0.0323063247,
-0.0196037106,
0.0464457013,
-0.003328565,
0.0035402561,
-0.0069607147,
0.032702595,
0.0283980779,
0.012816566,
0.0149781527,
-0.0243206974,
0.0131019475,
0.0699320287,
0.0025825545,
0.0065356288,
-0.0146271791,
0.0163012706,
-0.0272454284,
0.0298664831,
-0.0267704073,
-0.0791182443,
-0.0215788074,
0.006492177,
0.0379872695,
-0.0084522711,
-0.0111595942,
-0.044690866,
-0.0806078687,
0.049694974,
-0.0040855487,
-0.0380982533,
0.0040621362,
-0.0089071924,
-0.0047061141,
0.0323984101,
-0.0507928804,
-0.031255953,
-0.0075688562,
0.0199850276,
-0.0564698577,
0.013121319,
-0.0437966399,
-0.0086650224,
-0.0631766543,
0.0517851301,
0.0437316746,
0.0705219284,
-0.0167257767,
-0.0170502253,
-0.0307554062,
-0.0423313081,
-0.0122417668,
0.0370786339,
0.0495516807,
-0.004858824,
-0.0141465021,
0.0168150924,
0.043239288,
-0.0122408606,
-0.0132331727,
0.0032961522,
0.0334804319,
-0.0049975347,
-0.0614952445,
-0.0064450023,
0.0838127211,
0.014470919,
0.0991290659,
0.1054771766,
-0.0225216895,
-0.0058964877,
-0.0011751862,
-0.0061115329,
-0.0765967816,
-0.0480241217,
-0.0192148313,
-0.0078716436,
-0.0115983728,
-0.0296609849,
0.0105781322,
0.0100387549,
0.0048323157,
0.0037432585,
0.0185013562,
-0.0459180214,
-0.0410773642,
-0.0642884374,
-0.0364947617,
-0.0299191047,
0.0671687797,
0.003172932,
-0.0372883901,
-0.0064733187,
-0.0192408636,
-0.0099622244,
-0.0154292192,
-0.1440218687,
-0.0296135619,
0.0000609486,
0.012479159,
0.0103862435,
0.0150942272,
-0.0231256913,
-0.0444705598,
0.0418254621,
0.0454904251,
-0.003036337,
0.0524284244,
0.0245594699,
0.0297217779,
0.0031221451,
0.015336277,
-0.0558402352,
0.0539795905,
0.0593700074,
0.0072452961,
0.0160927363,
-0.0310726836,
0.0282155368,
-0.018382065,
0.002665933,
-0.0254189447,
-0.0073373327,
-0.0278067011,
-0.0300584678,
-0.042061504,
-0.0018495615,
-0.03100379,
-0.0051438357,
0.0628567412,
0.0203631707,
-0.036234878,
0.0019288029,
-0.0233779866,
0.0170120094,
-0.0315584019,
-0.0018583381,
0.0242501721,
-0.0281807184,
0.0244145133,
0.0030215222,
0.0128548844,
0.0310133249,
0.0091234427,
0.0072092689,
0.0373911373,
0.0265271682,
0.0145889781,
-0.0479321256,
0.0003726194,
0.0497836806,
-0.0567647219,
-0.020253893,
-0.0278534796,
0.0597659461,
0.0695351139,
-0.0090568317,
0.0317747109,
-0.0007359335,
-0.0230052266,
0.0150409397,
0.0610290579,
-0.0390084423,
-0.0648474544,
-0.0264311321,
0.0086708292,
-0.0232074428,
-0.0092927702,
0.0639021099,
0.0147741921,
0.001255153,
0.0001059846,
-0.0031468952,
-0.0132184289,
0.0303253718,
-0.017730033,
-0.0087765753,
0.0297573265,
0.0464415438,
-0.0674463958,
-0.0629890561,
0.0447792523,
-0.0049655139,
0.0283882506,
0.0154448664,
-0.0439875014,
0.0340659209,
0.015754085,
0.0159421246,
-0.0164807737,
-0.0284615532,
-0.005112113,
-0.0179716274,
-0.0001436367,
-5.247533882e-33,
-0.0055801459,
-0.0190329105,
-0.0712356269,
0.012982172,
-0.0272179116,
-0.0399220102,
-0.069492586,
-0.0042553609,
0.0162170138,
-0.0122934543,
0.0069860197,
0.0500016063,
-0.0084996456,
-0.0214660186,
0.0293192659,
-0.0018665809,
0.0779912323,
-0.022258468,
-0.056406837,
0.0174327549,
0.0274693239,
0.0273207575,
0.0191601701,
-0.0429200046,
-0.0018177326,
-0.0408015177,
-0.0046948195,
-0.0022710075,
0.017440116,
0.0398050696,
-0.0098996861,
0.0094643608,
0.0377924778,
0.003299695,
-0.0148038967,
-0.010238097,
-0.0160788801,
-0.0022963835,
-0.013473317,
0.0065341312,
0.0021568232,
-0.0406751446,
0.038115155,
-0.0095767509,
-0.0094685415,
0.0128647136,
0.0428462774,
-0.0666801929,
0.0115930811,
-0.1006778553,
-0.0469914973,
-0.0048051686,
-0.0463694595,
-0.0329543054,
0.0206226073,
0.0240685381,
0.0168056637,
0.073280625,
-0.031604182,
0.0210038722,
-0.0620582774,
-0.0094773313,
-0.0042668171,
-0.0190787036,
-0.0003809264,
0.0552849509,
-0.0006637721,
-0.0217764042,
-0.0288494471,
0.0500984341,
0.0216771029,
0.0286503453,
0.0281914435,
0.0691453442,
0.0787507668,
-0.0132055972,
0.0040018312,
0.0287099015,
0.0004377629,
-0.0323826708,
0.0123142507,
0.0429699123,
-0.0256269779,
-0.0140965059,
0.0180472936,
-0.1017394587,
-0.0390259027,
-0.0392989032,
0.0316311903,
-0.0042868252,
-0.0506730154,
-0.0034061226,
0.0156436395,
-0.0526195057,
0.0004178661,
-0.0090444498,
-0.0800604001,
0.0288757961,
0.0084218774,
0.0008338733,
-0.0295223314,
0.0182831604,
0.1094918251,
0.0043736487,
0.0499314852,
-0.0144562554,
0.0645986795,
0.0484944396,
-0.0791563019,
0.0016613029,
-0.0101786908,
-0.0202909075,
0.0233068168,
-0.0049187504,
0.0351449735,
0.0040974081,
-0.006626701,
0.0083090859,
0.0170044918,
0.0374118164,
0.0035056949,
-0.0103921127,
-0.0320842341,
-0.0051962952,
0.0088611124,
0.0201029759,
0.0044024196,
-0.0288258959,
0.013393824,
-0.0595411882,
-0.0203808248,
-0.0197048057,
2.446e-7,
0.0101577127,
-0.0151990857,
0.0272709634,
0.0055681141,
0.0387544744,
0.0238348078,
-0.0810639784,
-0.0146136219,
-0.036506854,
-0.0075103245,
0.0360514186,
-0.020457413,
0.1123827621,
0.0119549613,
-0.1156622991,
0.0686102659,
-0.0694449097,
-0.0148998406,
-0.1222598702,
-0.0456908345,
0.0641025975,
0.0587674081,
0.0296940692,
-0.0375696011,
0.0133114662,
-0.0549904443,
0.0274263266,
0.0021648102,
0.0158529505,
-0.0614831075,
0.0241204295,
-0.0100043751,
0.0028955587,
-0.0325309187,
-0.0370653719,
0.0343854204,
0.0172910951,
0.0356951505,
0.0417409092,
0.0311839301,
-0.0005912298,
-0.0035344139,
0.0067506977,
0.0001090216,
0.0635143071,
0.0186361019,
-0.0434503108,
-0.0427700169,
-0.0218346342,
-0.0100504551,
0.0048174025,
-0.0430889428,
-0.0301433112,
-0.0372770913,
0.0299870167,
-0.0049709692,
0.0280389283,
-0.0516450778,
0.0083888657,
0.007189048,
-0.0279172584,
0.0043909801,
-0.0044430005,
0.0123034986,
0.0457794555,
-0.0660173297,
-0.000988118,
2.159885233e-34,
0.0607358888,
-0.061062254,
0.0041207252,
0.0140593071,
0.0062907897,
0.0203094278,
-0.0089009451,
-0.0131231491,
-0.0432039313,
-0.0625980496,
-0.001233715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15227v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15227v1 | A LLM-Based Ranking Method for the Evaluation of Automatic Counter-Narrative Generation | 2024-06-21T15:11:33 | 2024-06-21T15:11:33 | Irune Zubiaga, Aitor Soroa, Rodrigo Agerri | cs.CL | cs.CL | The proliferation of misinformation and harmful narratives in online
discourse has underscored the critical need for effective Counter Narrative
(CN) generation techniques. However, existing automatic evaluation methods
often lack interpretability and fail to capture the nuanced relationship
between generated CNs and human perception. Aiming to achieve a higher
correlation with human judgments, this paper proposes a novel approach to asses
generated CNs that consists on the use of a Large Language Model (LLM) as a
evaluator. By comparing generated CNs pairwise in a tournament-style format, we
establish a model ranking pipeline that achieves a correlation of $0.88$ with
human preference. As an additional contribution, we leverage LLMs as zero-shot
(ZS) CN generators and conduct a comparative analysis of chat, instruct, and
base models, exploring their respective strengths and limitations. Through
meticulous evaluation, including fine-tuning experiments, we elucidate the
differences in performance and responsiveness to domain-specific data. We
conclude that chat-aligned models in ZS are the best option for carrying out
the task, provided they do not refuse to generate an answer due to security
concerns. | [
0.0714781582,
0.0147826411,
-0.0191852748,
0.0392229967,
-0.0736891627,
0.0006297106,
0.0362803228,
-0.0292173456,
0.0416113064,
-0.0762408748,
0.001829747,
-0.0603085272,
0.0015807983,
0.0647921935,
0.0225847587,
0.0075201457,
0.004867401,
0.0056737056,
0.0888914466,
-0.0286550336,
-0.0031009673,
0.0195272136,
-0.0230701659,
0.0393616743,
0.0156506058,
-0.010313591,
0.0309323817,
0.0126796924,
0.0350178406,
-0.0317527875,
0.0002452283,
0.0299368668,
0.0140468339,
0.0392702371,
0.000002066,
-0.0550852679,
0.002790519,
-0.0001976956,
-0.0475430936,
0.0113825556,
0.0395518504,
0.0446948707,
-0.015615548,
0.0229004733,
-0.0398307517,
0.0491420217,
0.0145799946,
0.0276812334,
0.0986084342,
0.0883029029,
-0.0085992347,
-0.0522560589,
-0.0036986307,
-0.0116113583,
-0.0296164379,
-0.0408597253,
0.0158584137,
0.028477855,
-0.0283234753,
0.0337750539,
0.0259487797,
0.0047970251,
-0.006528744,
-0.0232994463,
0.0089268247,
0.0167671833,
-0.0375621095,
-0.0179923028,
-0.0179652274,
0.0748472735,
0.0194651596,
-0.0272847582,
0.009892934,
-0.0220164079,
0.0421427339,
0.0204544291,
-0.058655493,
0.0720819458,
-0.0193929579,
0.0043745055,
-0.0013528601,
0.0363620371,
0.0161667056,
0.0377622694,
0.0395463966,
0.0186973028,
-0.0035660486,
-0.0212287065,
-0.0279007405,
-0.0292138401,
-0.0025578779,
-0.0716890544,
0.0112818405,
0.0263690427,
-0.0417035148,
0.0224443842,
-0.0104964115,
0.000552877,
0.0365897529,
-0.1340064555,
0.0332206674,
0.0259444062,
0.0332057439,
0.0383393727,
-0.028139947,
0.0552637391,
-0.0002861838,
0.004576243,
-0.0014561412,
0.0084224641,
-0.0332015082,
0.0068234131,
0.0021148948,
0.0324188843,
-0.0336255394,
0.0035277293,
-0.0488584302,
-0.016726546,
-0.0505607389,
0.0284616537,
0.0062150117,
0.0385249145,
-0.0025859778,
-0.0109530855,
-0.0266737901,
0.0312746055,
-0.0440250598,
0.0163708068,
-0.0098262494,
-0.0530286655,
0.0040613143,
0.0255908053,
-0.0212348811,
-0.0093654832,
0.0104328888,
0.0987940133,
-0.0024781586,
0.0118670901,
0.0160968862,
-0.0410868749,
-0.0290678609,
-0.0645067096,
-0.0067171315,
-0.0612072982,
0.0257519539,
0.0105682183,
-0.006931657,
-0.0263325684,
0.0307170916,
0.0376195833,
-0.0546815917,
0.0118317669,
0.0301340539,
0.002531389,
0.0568532459,
0.0322550423,
-0.0098292446,
0.0404661819,
0.0232839826,
0.0685449988,
0.0474649481,
0.0239926148,
0.0131465644,
-0.0055636992,
0.0151114827,
0.0016651446,
-0.0179375838,
0.023525266,
-0.0156030916,
0.013827025,
-0.0299552623,
0.0483405776,
-0.0462131351,
-0.0610515885,
0.0782535374,
0.0057293172,
-0.0169741008,
0.0039638644,
0.0590670928,
0.0187521316,
0.0049665011,
0.0351527222,
-0.0035385024,
0.0242704786,
-0.0720138475,
-0.0321214721,
0.0344612524,
0.0562701784,
-0.0091493204,
-0.0365789793,
-0.0077883331,
0.0063003902,
0.0110634398,
0.0075228787,
-0.0009626112,
0.0137213459,
-0.0580583215,
-0.0079355948,
0.0289558172,
-0.0339362286,
-0.0156423375,
-0.0617634617,
0.0031355328,
0.074577488,
0.0402034223,
0.0332461037,
-0.036130812,
-0.0451101921,
0.0081805289,
0.052222047,
0.0359675251,
-0.012520005,
-0.0281965118,
-0.0304096583,
-0.0258244388,
-0.0596615635,
0.0109120468,
0.0409067832,
0.0109416572,
-0.0087492317,
0.0168888438,
0.0041329777,
-0.0470244475,
0.008610365,
-0.0138458796,
-0.010610695,
0.0117544439,
-0.0058600768,
0.0414203443,
0.0373389907,
-0.012868694,
0.0080117239,
0.0315993577,
-0.0038233048,
-0.0500267968,
-0.0008667465,
-0.0222825017,
-0.0271863714,
0.0095152361,
-0.0472307652,
-0.0105125979,
0.0071525364,
-0.022195233,
0.0060817264,
0.0492438711,
-0.0217916463,
0.0166743789,
-0.0270844176,
-0.0013740452,
-0.015673561,
-0.0320194513,
-0.03098673,
0.0904607177,
-0.0041522863,
0.0266419649,
0.0165798068,
-0.0172273219,
0.000265274,
-0.0390420184,
0.0023130542,
0.0174693409,
-0.0049022627,
0.0054479325,
0.0368960463,
-0.0123006543,
-0.0283937063,
-0.0240755361,
-0.0843426809,
0.0039331792,
-0.0056554563,
-0.0012703703,
0.0382277779,
-0.0363445953,
-0.0022985106,
0.02216761,
-0.0435374714,
-0.0336898416,
0.0217675362,
0.0304341875,
0.0096968692,
0.0113780657,
-0.0152463624,
-0.0310171358,
0.0065959012,
-0.0229019672,
0.0860433504,
0.0416626707,
-0.0165424459,
-0.0129185328,
0.0299589988,
-0.065723896,
-0.0083291847,
-0.0417137928,
-0.0504478253,
0.0302386712,
0.0441872962,
-0.0056565693,
0.0347683243,
0.081615895,
0.0294855684,
0.0442434289,
-0.0073729581,
-0.0546748303,
-0.0271504559,
-0.020864239,
-0.0061253803,
-0.0196688958,
-0.0804390535,
-0.0055915187,
0.0517849289,
0.0545273721,
0.0199542772,
-0.0606882945,
0.0580961108,
-0.0025894046,
-0.0211994871,
-0.0253839921,
-0.0693930686,
-0.0008340773,
0.0264845826,
-0.0209653806,
-0.033734981,
0.0926445797,
-0.0236228313,
0.0543516278,
-0.0213992242,
-0.0220741108,
-0.0243602004,
0.0231355987,
-0.0091492971,
0.0525094718,
0.0229877718,
0.0189238712,
-0.0300751198,
-0.0575613491,
0.068305485,
-0.0499835052,
-0.0696241185,
-0.0433530249,
-0.0068932758,
0.0446812436,
-0.0135491602,
-0.0626787245,
-0.0906452239,
-0.0160770603,
-0.0109418975,
0.0165945012,
0.0029651634,
-0.0384771153,
0.001456436,
0.0350198559,
-0.0258749165,
-0.0145761678,
-0.0017339386,
0.0236647315,
0.0204934478,
0.037985757,
-0.016706761,
0.0423448868,
-0.0163077228,
0.0448641852,
0.0731997713,
-0.0129480734,
-0.0204273481,
0.0196049642,
-0.0489700399,
-0.0084419986,
-0.0045342124,
-0.0220235437,
0.0071038175,
0.0154262846,
-0.0236494355,
0.0020932299,
0.1070447341,
0.0340269953,
0.0006291862,
-0.0034751734,
0.0019337521,
-0.0110252844,
0.0208948422,
-0.018979542,
-0.0831222758,
0.0046221814,
-0.0141821308,
0.0238535143,
-0.0803829059,
-0.0476086177,
-0.0423079431,
-0.1289360523,
0.0269996654,
0.0149902105,
0.0165896378,
0.0048154695,
-0.03793405,
-0.0136884982,
0.0022167289,
-0.0158995204,
0.0139124272,
0.0249675568,
-0.0077646347,
-0.017329568,
-0.024131773,
-0.032009352,
0.0317501426,
-0.0052766069,
0.0559573621,
0.0403641164,
0.0595578589,
-0.0015566807,
-0.0160266105,
0.0207776744,
0.0077989222,
-0.0070502358,
-0.0059415596,
0.0592922568,
-0.0378058739,
0.0208303928,
-0.0429487266,
0.0265263822,
0.0500093214,
-0.0404370427,
0.0058348561,
0.0355084576,
0.0008043969,
-0.0162744634,
-0.013885254,
0.0372049659,
0.0464896485,
0.1093098149,
0.0187553018,
-0.0305559989,
0.0055993856,
-0.0581382215,
0.0045489976,
-0.0236211624,
-0.0504527725,
-0.0147820786,
0.0335102715,
-0.0003327042,
-0.0754784793,
-0.024042977,
-0.0418474041,
0.0152734565,
-0.0078892531,
0.0008489826,
0.0001746208,
0.0126460334,
-0.015686363,
-0.0306132734,
-0.0393270962,
0.0418870971,
-0.014612494,
0.0071832389,
0.0319949649,
-0.050799571,
-0.0220210645,
0.0448226966,
-0.0399569459,
-0.06979049,
-0.0172026139,
0.0383528285,
0.0261708423,
0.0129863704,
0.0002471272,
-0.031378407,
0.0518025607,
0.0392122827,
-0.0344028436,
0.007058369,
0.0273581222,
0.0324231125,
0.0146335224,
-0.0014184377,
-0.0081495261,
0.022745518,
0.0211376678,
0.0324728675,
-0.0402559713,
-0.0471825339,
0.0351824947,
0.0113326563,
0.0234098248,
-0.0242383834,
-0.0383783504,
-0.0158216655,
0.0124461725,
-0.0873822644,
-0.046384953,
0.0069942209,
0.0013671527,
0.006615987,
-0.0208228044,
0.0033697677,
-0.003211963,
-0.0804297104,
0.0411489792,
-0.0538655706,
0.0036413216,
0.0209936164,
-0.0051424913,
0.0043036048,
-0.0302589498,
-0.0227917489,
0.0046298103,
0.0161149763,
0.0405420586,
0.0007152731,
0.025931282,
0.0057140472,
-0.0275925566,
0.0312966406,
0.0150309373,
-0.0612433963,
-0.0247939564,
-0.0413584858,
0.0425609946,
0.0383035801,
0.024529824,
0.045528952,
0.0124953995,
-0.0094309011,
0.0048730504,
0.0029874474,
-0.0039996239,
-0.0536276512,
-0.0032508718,
0.0180043224,
-0.0354008712,
0.0542457514,
0.0627676323,
0.0046991976,
0.0317804813,
0.0150161702,
-0.0682647005,
-0.0315786228,
-0.0549532697,
-0.0213993024,
0.0557936281,
0.0270234589,
-0.0155115947,
-0.1209373996,
-0.0306673739,
0.0050462307,
0.0114695746,
0.0364986919,
-0.0005894008,
-0.0008009656,
0.0582736582,
0.0092896679,
0.0030670443,
-0.064749971,
0.0335960053,
-0.0097749578,
-0.0030261984,
-0.0286255926,
-6.539184707e-33,
-0.0187496524,
-0.0945857465,
-0.0089136623,
-0.0017286841,
-0.0010140114,
-0.002895619,
-0.0136806797,
0.0067524067,
-0.0272016432,
0.0326641984,
0.0357146338,
0.0029454527,
0.0058584907,
-0.0027962709,
-0.0499740131,
-0.0098949866,
0.0378285386,
-0.0152180297,
-0.0576624162,
0.0298324041,
0.0484796613,
-0.0162762832,
0.019337954,
-0.0833015516,
0.0521194562,
-0.022773942,
-0.0281833354,
0.0003305321,
-0.0220304113,
0.0442524403,
0.0065245088,
0.0504662357,
0.0335497484,
-0.0261748414,
0.0065790089,
-0.0000194415,
0.0218321718,
-0.0013577341,
0.0554510206,
-0.0532563739,
0.0343936905,
-0.0188119877,
0.0109430691,
-0.0105627514,
-0.0472066998,
-0.0011335369,
0.0297373962,
-0.0319866128,
0.0133744068,
-0.0247664992,
-0.0491475351,
0.0139042931,
-0.0271403417,
-0.0332269147,
-0.054503087,
0.0795916617,
0.0137747405,
0.023285564,
-0.0615349188,
0.0766616687,
-0.0066190059,
-0.024926709,
0.0483151935,
-0.0208140444,
-0.0218485743,
0.0707209259,
0.0131952558,
0.0501616634,
-0.0653889999,
-0.0123808654,
-0.027199233,
0.0347244591,
0.0683923066,
0.1081194058,
-0.0012307951,
-0.0355233811,
-0.1185270026,
0.0303782579,
0.0126690287,
0.0269075204,
0.049171906,
-0.0087423967,
-0.0443938822,
-0.0252313465,
-0.0415382758,
-0.0599329174,
-0.034321297,
-0.024062125,
0.009729974,
0.0053569372,
-0.0663887486,
-0.0107867019,
0.0168374293,
-0.0329212099,
0.011888613,
0.0657037571,
-0.0229742024,
0.0048497021,
0.0181298256,
0.0251511727,
-0.0474459827,
0.0488147438,
0.0408808254,
0.0202434435,
0.0147218229,
-0.0110920519,
0.0319169797,
-0.0128726726,
-0.0240389183,
0.0188274756,
-0.028699398,
0.0146422684,
-0.0318530016,
-0.0210177489,
-0.0037938498,
0.0205708239,
-0.0377321467,
0.0040913322,
0.0013352408,
-0.0073932433,
-0.0192413386,
-0.0081857936,
-0.0012825681,
0.0257476307,
-0.0313079469,
0.0314775333,
0.0076562734,
0.0491870046,
0.020147793,
-0.0308894552,
-0.0206829645,
-0.026496876,
2.833e-7,
0.002081241,
0.0573058836,
-0.015575625,
0.0186122749,
0.0258516949,
0.0610970594,
0.02106921,
0.0074979495,
0.0338151343,
-0.0707728863,
-0.0157933943,
0.0409301817,
0.0335863791,
0.0511177406,
-0.031298425,
0.0007955636,
-0.0812991634,
-0.0342342146,
-0.0499879979,
-0.0113657881,
0.0987758189,
0.0182529539,
0.0224201232,
-0.0035178873,
-0.0510135181,
-0.0023769485,
0.067984052,
-0.0079802852,
-0.0647804961,
0.0108305709,
0.0143329268,
-0.0185552295,
-0.0078622587,
0.0176889636,
-0.0116061922,
0.0035124889,
-0.0104232598,
0.0569497459,
0.0063784416,
-0.0384172276,
-0.0154009908,
-0.011247837,
0.0058609899,
-0.0536174811,
0.0544875525,
-0.0456066541,
-0.034816321,
-0.0407515615,
-0.0485444032,
0.0201658271,
0.0333418697,
-0.0437059365,
-0.0434818193,
0.0101373242,
0.0026776113,
0.0180766899,
0.0192374568,
-0.0192403477,
-0.0222014841,
0.0189270452,
-0.0518569201,
-0.0693492666,
-0.0023675158,
-0.0241141226,
0.0201089513,
-0.0215734262,
0.0640048981,
2.638850508e-34,
0.0482975468,
0.0144197475,
0.0067052152,
-0.0209191404,
0.0572830625,
0.0606523603,
-0.0172099657,
-0.008583691,
0.0365577266,
-0.038797088,
-0.0066760867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15214v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15214v1 | Unsupervised Extraction of Dialogue Policies from Conversations | 2024-06-21T14:57:25 | 2024-06-21T14:57:25 | Makesh Narsimhan Sreedhar, Traian Rebedea, Christopher Parisien | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue policies play a crucial role in developing task-oriented dialogue
systems, yet their development and maintenance are challenging and typically
require substantial effort from experts in dialogue modeling. While in many
situations, large amounts of conversational data are available for the task at
hand, people lack an effective solution able to extract dialogue policies from
this data. In this paper, we address this gap by first illustrating how Large
Language Models (LLMs) can be instrumental in extracting dialogue policies from
datasets, through the conversion of conversations into a unified intermediate
representation consisting of canonical forms. We then propose a novel method
for generating dialogue policies utilizing a controllable and interpretable
graph-based methodology. By combining canonical forms across conversations into
a flow network, we find that running graph traversal algorithms helps in
extracting dialogue flows. These flows are a better representation of the
underlying interactions than flows extracted by prompting LLMs. Our technique
focuses on giving conversation designers greater control, offering a
productivity tool to improve the process of developing dialogue policies. | [
0.0677660555,
0.0455119349,
-0.0184928607,
0.0570515878,
-0.0551470853,
-0.0018301411,
0.0073563866,
-0.0205667,
0.045683682,
-0.0182500184,
-0.0044599082,
-0.0203513503,
-0.0035377019,
0.0922440812,
-0.0250268113,
-0.0746997148,
-0.0042965966,
-0.040690273,
0.0134832151,
0.0106618451,
0.0278275739,
0.0308927298,
-0.0144870952,
0.0534271672,
0.0037800667,
-0.0196551699,
-0.0506728478,
0.0003586432,
-0.0130474223,
0.0123605262,
-0.0183566436,
0.0388907231,
0.033611387,
0.0083461357,
0.0000018767,
-0.0491933189,
0.0054771933,
-0.0393204205,
-0.000610303,
-0.0106535684,
0.0436178707,
-0.0057334197,
-0.0058875936,
0.0181561653,
-0.0520839579,
0.0071485788,
0.0383158661,
0.0388769694,
0.0915258527,
0.071569711,
-0.0275515672,
-0.0381324925,
-0.0261031687,
-0.0039050959,
-0.0222524107,
-0.0759802237,
0.0108770821,
0.0353589132,
0.0146106342,
-0.0046487506,
-0.0190214124,
0.0208103135,
0.0030028629,
-0.0746784732,
-0.0316477083,
0.0056814896,
-0.0119653819,
-0.0352031961,
-0.0273735989,
0.1294476986,
0.0464723483,
0.009423052,
0.052364964,
-0.0252581052,
-0.0102146016,
0.0200442839,
-0.0704187304,
-0.0046299235,
-0.0090355147,
0.0055583697,
-0.0264954586,
-0.021092739,
0.0123819169,
-0.0227094293,
-0.0499299988,
0.0435633287,
-0.0183033384,
-0.0034723433,
-0.0047402405,
-0.0246303286,
0.0216991883,
-0.0634146631,
0.0402699411,
0.0178202558,
-0.084178932,
0.0332979597,
-0.018825002,
0.0310981423,
-0.0120694963,
-0.015814852,
0.0238002427,
0.0117100906,
0.0227182359,
0.0389147736,
0.0417185314,
0.0476591326,
-0.0373623371,
0.018426124,
-0.0226656571,
0.0060057743,
-0.0805403441,
-0.0087335799,
-0.0564920381,
0.0006294597,
-0.0470731817,
-0.0560252815,
0.0004859493,
0.0776629746,
-0.0122593855,
0.0464072973,
0.0373941623,
0.0142553458,
0.00146851,
-0.0110276155,
-0.0156309307,
0.0089756735,
-0.0103431372,
-0.011471563,
0.0203189868,
-0.0140808923,
0.0044833166,
0.0227342825,
0.0291748922,
0.0077515109,
-0.0436686911,
0.0759109333,
0.0143975168,
0.0216576122,
0.0371793881,
-0.0616558678,
-0.0239863917,
-0.0227906927,
-0.0216936357,
-0.0474033765,
0.0449921153,
-0.0016292819,
-0.0140329786,
-0.048089467,
0.0160589404,
0.0039102505,
-0.0530152358,
0.0131728025,
0.0093064019,
0.0563431531,
0.0038221101,
0.0090858359,
0.0055654277,
0.0306207426,
0.0655434132,
0.0179255065,
0.0666266233,
-0.0103381556,
0.0184701644,
0.0481297895,
0.0054218238,
0.0032441921,
0.0320292786,
0.0326682143,
-0.022327261,
-0.0054210732,
0.0017615655,
0.0390413702,
-0.0345666595,
-0.0251607522,
0.0358827263,
0.0537287891,
-0.0234590042,
0.0062514287,
0.0492414273,
0.0594127364,
-0.0135873547,
0.0374750681,
-0.0149074178,
-0.0194948241,
0.047692135,
-0.0116801392,
0.0446714722,
-0.0253516454,
-0.0112547837,
-0.0353678204,
0.0438131131,
0.0123713017,
0.0416486338,
0.0118969483,
0.0248898752,
0.0330042355,
-0.0635334104,
0.0392040722,
-0.0145974094,
-0.0395724028,
-0.0623762831,
-0.0106075723,
-0.008430155,
0.1006151959,
0.0549074933,
-0.0028527509,
-0.028942382,
-0.0026768555,
0.044044625,
0.0295103956,
0.0498829409,
-0.0371278413,
0.0335161947,
-0.0393409505,
-0.0289931502,
0.002451644,
-0.0074167582,
0.0215666145,
-0.0184381325,
-0.0491886176,
0.0013938653,
0.0086554522,
-0.0552858487,
-0.011400749,
-0.0090087391,
0.0080853719,
0.0590067655,
0.0039017966,
0.0313268192,
0.055854395,
-0.0016747927,
0.0041135154,
0.0098922821,
-0.0126418527,
0.0095774839,
0.0552997179,
-0.0688174814,
-0.0335895345,
0.0072871447,
-0.0029960342,
-0.0479103252,
-0.01505257,
-0.0524218157,
-0.058131367,
0.0310200229,
-0.040494632,
0.0265234597,
-0.0131748747,
-0.0040717139,
0.0156599004,
-0.0303534456,
-0.0161710791,
0.0076501206,
0.0081495456,
-0.0096875187,
0.0422947258,
0.0062665334,
0.0190731026,
-0.0649643838,
0.035765525,
0.049857419,
-0.0140582239,
-0.0073314346,
0.0426039025,
0.0252829473,
-0.0382761247,
-0.0042511672,
-0.0882850662,
0.0062116254,
-0.0109880231,
0.0262352657,
0.0131275887,
0.0376549251,
-0.0018084779,
-0.0206459388,
-0.0424723402,
0.0289709475,
0.0675390735,
-0.0106468555,
0.0357959121,
0.0274981204,
-0.0657614619,
-0.0538095422,
0.0033399195,
-0.0095167467,
0.03642001,
-0.004167357,
-0.034809459,
-0.0354394056,
0.0535790995,
-0.0103121391,
0.0185783561,
-0.0209419094,
-0.0202921312,
0.0253415592,
-0.0184540935,
0.0195043944,
0.0376823731,
0.0162628144,
0.0253672041,
0.0050270464,
-0.0618949831,
-0.0664859563,
0.0207016952,
-0.043168921,
-0.005498956,
-0.0655874908,
-0.0162990261,
0.0455041453,
0.0364749692,
0.0223661773,
0.0451031066,
-0.0463298522,
-0.0120743606,
0.0332908854,
-0.004122999,
0.0042627081,
-0.0137575297,
-0.0296588968,
0.0436583608,
-0.0001112553,
-0.0302955359,
0.0564970039,
-0.017932808,
-0.015772853,
0.0025627748,
-0.0381363407,
-0.0547683388,
0.0776429847,
0.0168600474,
0.0122430138,
0.0023572748,
-0.0661917105,
-0.0293021798,
-0.0101270117,
0.0558341704,
-0.0306551494,
0.0277790315,
-0.0626595467,
0.007887288,
0.0218461752,
-0.0343836881,
-0.0397220477,
-0.0254321788,
-0.023978319,
0.0045780386,
0.0180988498,
-0.0423366688,
-0.0108875055,
0.0268504601,
-0.017777741,
0.0267148074,
0.018003419,
0.0057061487,
-0.0438851155,
0.0302359778,
0.0441292338,
-0.0000942459,
-0.0545600355,
-0.0027252755,
0.0707838014,
0.047604844,
0.0029898428,
0.0014205688,
-0.0130335968,
-0.012242889,
-0.0030958108,
0.0031855768,
0.0028399283,
0.023271136,
0.0563533977,
-0.0364985131,
-0.036797028,
0.0959822983,
0.0295470487,
-0.0382873677,
-0.0095844278,
0.0213579964,
0.0486157052,
0.0022646773,
0.0239216294,
-0.0815988183,
-0.0141459107,
-0.0107593043,
0.0396794751,
-0.0199801065,
-0.0608673133,
-0.013898504,
-0.0514234789,
0.0191983413,
0.0111956513,
-0.0110176364,
-0.0060682609,
-0.0269499458,
-0.008711122,
-0.0021009443,
-0.000877112,
-0.030243827,
0.0034759389,
-0.0262537599,
-0.0119917411,
-0.0288846064,
-0.0101461774,
0.0073822974,
0.0263822377,
0.0321511962,
0.0511988103,
0.0443751849,
0.0481210276,
0.0318705067,
0.0540346503,
0.0292910412,
-0.0185138509,
-0.0105280811,
0.0146895433,
0.0129166367,
-0.0081330827,
-0.0326502882,
0.0332457013,
-0.0473534688,
-0.0477580391,
0.0430971384,
0.0416981801,
-0.0581789985,
-0.0294336472,
0.0043336893,
0.0323170684,
0.0611209013,
0.0600991063,
0.062955074,
-0.0274733659,
-0.0403035171,
-0.0699108839,
-0.0121267354,
-0.0824407786,
-0.0497233942,
-0.026471179,
0.0000615152,
0.0426596999,
-0.0576176904,
-0.0273198411,
0.0066120774,
0.007829112,
-0.0087467935,
-0.0413946882,
0.0543406233,
0.0087245898,
0.0005435964,
-0.0299471896,
-0.0363651551,
0.016788166,
-0.0389263406,
-0.0332740732,
0.0108869737,
0.0326483697,
-0.0200694893,
0.0566396266,
-0.0481066182,
-0.0806590244,
-0.0428374521,
0.0178212523,
0.01837736,
0.0405148491,
-0.0017163808,
-0.0059065637,
0.0038064115,
0.0266600735,
-0.0128098447,
-0.0514759086,
0.0470429547,
0.0396382026,
-0.0081119128,
0.0456954651,
-0.0358027183,
0.0051841703,
-0.0301545262,
0.0628957525,
-0.0764486268,
-0.0997760072,
0.0152253993,
-0.001901421,
-0.0144806989,
0.0650805384,
-0.0117556714,
-0.0362924747,
0.0226450358,
-0.0384357981,
-0.0423391536,
-0.0509156957,
0.0461832322,
-0.0122796698,
-0.0642336681,
0.0320126936,
0.0224890318,
-0.04345911,
0.0525158532,
-0.0136721674,
-0.0065884097,
0.0164449941,
-0.0106983008,
0.0227435865,
-0.0256366618,
-0.0117675588,
0.0323820151,
0.0281550903,
0.0265429057,
0.0175269153,
0.087104626,
0.0279612765,
-0.0385330468,
-0.0000475978,
0.0263505578,
-0.0857288167,
-0.0507278852,
0.0176378042,
0.022302065,
0.0287273824,
0.0127042253,
0.0585393719,
-0.0501038656,
0.0181787554,
-0.0217033662,
0.0796929821,
0.0127771776,
-0.047462441,
0.016787935,
0.0182808209,
-0.0239938423,
-0.0144837834,
0.0706290454,
0.023284832,
0.0044343127,
0.0102256825,
-0.0362268761,
-0.0700987428,
-0.0622211844,
-0.0100348406,
0.0514005423,
0.0032557363,
-0.0101590054,
-0.0354282558,
-0.0352984853,
-0.0313022248,
0.0049830973,
0.0028707746,
-0.0112100895,
0.0251082033,
0.0268882401,
0.0269389208,
0.0101556303,
-0.0559065156,
0.0377898812,
-0.0490236357,
-0.036736086,
-0.0602509342,
-5.472140363e-33,
-0.0134719126,
-0.0767778307,
0.0345251709,
0.0573891364,
-0.0349440649,
-0.0423116535,
-0.0693754628,
0.0018622036,
-0.0005492655,
0.0279611759,
0.0004480721,
0.0264904536,
0.0144648449,
0.0188545492,
-0.0080953008,
0.0056725317,
0.0408188365,
0.0014973521,
-0.0203997456,
0.0705849528,
0.0626098886,
-0.0080050481,
0.0037705526,
-0.1074216887,
0.02226137,
-0.0162284467,
0.0113224648,
0.039642036,
0.0361080468,
0.0535412543,
0.0009278911,
0.03706415,
0.0132437134,
-0.0353905931,
-0.0338908993,
0.0667442158,
-0.0293639489,
-0.0082974872,
0.0293437969,
-0.0020330928,
-0.0314529352,
-0.0332177356,
0.0046506086,
-0.0054844455,
0.017463902,
0.0003332431,
0.0050140414,
0.001074689,
-0.0255315136,
0.0088838497,
-0.0438131839,
0.0261613391,
-0.0574211739,
-0.0352134183,
0.0415449105,
0.0222115293,
0.0221110154,
-0.0395121872,
0.0162713174,
0.0494329408,
-0.0297100153,
-0.0085031688,
0.041456826,
0.0178933069,
0.0486317649,
0.0418845788,
-0.0116480114,
0.040640451,
-0.002975994,
-0.0036388193,
-0.0313605592,
0.0699914172,
-0.0581032708,
0.0407412574,
-0.0685756654,
-0.0026747216,
-0.0434071347,
0.0055454909,
0.0147511438,
0.0317102708,
-0.0044500399,
0.0091136526,
-0.0189465061,
-0.0359671712,
-0.0154623035,
-0.0213933457,
0.0042521837,
-0.0194639806,
0.0237653963,
0.0039539975,
-0.0113936318,
-0.0008582387,
0.0307629555,
-0.0512756109,
-0.0413085893,
0.0551716946,
-0.0375748463,
-0.0043649566,
-0.009926999,
-0.0043037534,
-0.0320629328,
-0.0544164367,
0.0296363272,
-0.0103671653,
0.0335611179,
0.0158780683,
-0.0100099472,
-0.012827212,
-0.0266019125,
-0.0094728572,
-0.0496477224,
0.0214100629,
-0.0813813731,
0.0331641883,
0.0132945543,
0.0145299174,
-0.0255280696,
0.0774049461,
-0.007312329,
-0.0246275384,
-0.0255209599,
-0.0117855584,
0.0210902393,
0.0186062418,
-0.0448491722,
-0.0361178517,
-0.0234878808,
0.0220728293,
0.0496267565,
0.0031195891,
-0.0122510623,
-0.0193468742,
2.488e-7,
-0.0062853391,
0.0455439948,
0.0412360951,
0.0596763231,
0.0480797105,
0.0455287248,
-0.0029056596,
0.0175329484,
0.018343335,
-0.0658425242,
0.0443392731,
0.0201761834,
0.0424731672,
0.0231599305,
-0.0956226587,
-0.0205885805,
-0.0540546812,
-0.0590942204,
-0.0572997779,
-0.0050289943,
0.0968418792,
0.0252289269,
-0.0104920994,
0.0292536002,
-0.0083872192,
-0.0249747057,
0.0342084952,
-0.0407529138,
-0.0066670487,
0.0080834301,
-0.0030053586,
-0.0442800075,
0.0027843302,
-0.0215178523,
-0.001645722,
0.0442053452,
-0.0192319266,
0.1084788516,
0.0205233712,
-0.0376928002,
-0.0338946432,
-0.0451390035,
0.0276395269,
-0.0131488573,
0.0128264679,
-0.0519100726,
-0.0195914786,
-0.0182328448,
0.0200983323,
-0.0423764214,
-0.0168206245,
0.0138626527,
0.0075521166,
0.0315511301,
0.0014594329,
-0.0156964101,
0.0531448685,
-0.0545169972,
0.027979156,
-0.0268061757,
-0.043398086,
-0.0278694443,
-0.0292732213,
0.0188601632,
-0.029578587,
0.0287407357,
0.0202013738,
2.089922197e-34,
0.0217157248,
0.0162807852,
0.0197522026,
0.0230517536,
0.0500388183,
-0.0151199671,
0.0057743061,
0.0343359932,
0.0483462848,
-0.1008724719,
-0.0264334958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15211v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15211v1 | How Effective is GPT-4 Turbo in Generating School-Level Questions from Textbooks Based on Bloom's Revised Taxonomy? | 2024-06-21T14:52:37 | 2024-06-21T14:52:37 | Subhankar Maity, Aniket Deroy, Sudeshna Sarkar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We evaluate the effectiveness of GPT-4 Turbo in generating educational
questions from NCERT textbooks in zero-shot mode. Our study highlights GPT-4
Turbo's ability to generate questions that require higher-order thinking
skills, especially at the "understanding" level according to Bloom's Revised
Taxonomy. While we find a notable consistency between questions generated by
GPT-4 Turbo and those assessed by humans in terms of complexity, there are
occasional differences. Our evaluation also uncovers variations in how humans
and machines evaluate question quality, with a trend inversely related to
Bloom's Revised Taxonomy levels. These findings suggest that while GPT-4 Turbo
is a promising tool for educational question generation, its efficacy varies
across different cognitive levels, indicating a need for further refinement to
fully meet educational standards. | [
0.0008417291,
-0.0304779653,
-0.0307297539,
0.003007065,
-0.0378315039,
0.0024306485,
0.0163488761,
0.0083135543,
-0.0104750348,
-0.0419160873,
0.0049746921,
-0.023128584,
-0.0103117917,
0.0242213551,
0.0420226417,
-0.0507975332,
0.0261685625,
0.0113229472,
-0.0310170576,
0.0299448166,
-0.0243257806,
-0.0093313847,
-0.0209915061,
0.0161526501,
-0.0002491832,
-0.0236378834,
-0.0638733134,
0.0030395503,
0.0313744918,
-0.0314507708,
-0.0150656607,
0.0642172769,
0.0080373613,
0.0272279941,
0.0000019164,
-0.0556398146,
-0.0199066401,
0.0016725981,
-0.0005448057,
0.0174287297,
0.0446592085,
0.0392252542,
0.0116380649,
0.0258808602,
-0.0508055091,
-0.0017227662,
0.0160121471,
0.0152799217,
0.042234011,
0.0363656841,
0.0076465989,
-0.0085328221,
0.0433345996,
0.0032863319,
0.0834431723,
-0.0021237084,
-0.0243611429,
0.0036819356,
0.0534292273,
0.0313522965,
-0.0368519127,
-0.0016452287,
0.0598981567,
0.0015221586,
-0.0032937969,
0.0498012006,
-0.0172719955,
0.0229028352,
0.0230069514,
0.0508890897,
0.0263046455,
0.0246316306,
-0.0175648872,
0.0102632158,
0.0397075936,
0.015412895,
-0.0760195404,
0.0191482026,
-0.0259396322,
-0.0338815041,
0.0051989011,
-0.0095436685,
-0.0198763814,
-0.0093083493,
0.0243629571,
-0.0065729972,
0.0094900802,
-0.0453727804,
0.0038891302,
0.0279787779,
-0.0250513107,
-0.0507276766,
0.0032834946,
0.0299862176,
0.0014516219,
0.0086682122,
-0.034999948,
0.0146280201,
0.0336075127,
0.0373826735,
0.0070200111,
0.0578127727,
0.0042583458,
0.0142943282,
-0.0327489972,
0.0500745773,
0.0256611444,
-0.002509512,
-0.0364423506,
0.0449320078,
-0.0786660686,
-0.0214395709,
-0.0367222913,
0.0497721694,
0.0030464665,
-0.006771008,
-0.0687498972,
0.0063095037,
0.0340593718,
-0.0035455555,
-0.0248704366,
0.005487802,
-0.0246766582,
0.0133464318,
-0.0561219789,
0.0171331689,
-0.0653572753,
-0.0225811955,
0.0364498459,
-0.0439613089,
-0.0072782808,
0.013674357,
0.0199402217,
-0.0094723273,
0.0183250662,
0.0104152635,
-0.0193072911,
0.0020680968,
-0.0211606044,
-0.0650308579,
0.0230527241,
-0.0332686789,
0.0248773154,
-0.057163991,
0.0106958188,
0.0289733466,
-0.0224592462,
0.0376042724,
0.0004836411,
0.0636310801,
0.0174167734,
0.0298120212,
0.0044017471,
-0.0067717372,
0.0415747724,
0.0205441304,
-0.0302549992,
0.0260416195,
-0.0009173921,
-0.0098085431,
0.0183139015,
-0.015347017,
0.0400368087,
0.0070040314,
-0.00637752,
-0.0198581666,
0.0046803239,
0.0163624287,
-0.012053553,
0.0518907122,
-0.0127598559,
0.0506997667,
-0.0246183313,
0.0373081341,
0.0383606106,
0.0573879592,
-0.0096519226,
0.0473318361,
0.0526683554,
-0.0021878749,
0.0410064384,
0.0955480188,
-0.0372048616,
0.0470138229,
-0.0523546189,
0.0197475459,
0.0304169264,
0.0209936425,
0.014404906,
-0.0563772246,
-0.0064106453,
0.0442287587,
0.0174814966,
0.0134370206,
0.0090536764,
-0.0264647696,
-0.0262952559,
-0.01332088,
-0.0346887968,
-0.0460458361,
0.0312096551,
-0.0449021086,
0.0296701342,
-0.0049038948,
0.0859051347,
-0.0202716012,
-0.0707445145,
-0.0140998401,
0.0104887113,
0.0600448288,
0.0554410554,
-0.0180004537,
-0.0392839015,
-0.0543069355,
-0.0058026747,
-0.0446526222,
-0.0120797157,
-0.026807446,
0.006427024,
0.017767204,
0.0237379409,
-0.0422346182,
-0.035850402,
0.0397945084,
-0.0164444856,
-0.0528537668,
-0.0489404127,
0.0190817025,
-0.023406079,
0.0110847605,
0.0095328204,
0.0196503084,
0.0095865326,
-0.0170241669,
0.0001943209,
-0.0300804228,
-0.0422704592,
-0.0133609669,
0.0456694067,
-0.0607265197,
-0.0308609381,
0.0223127585,
-0.0106267193,
-0.0395766683,
0.0102281943,
-0.0214500595,
0.0185092762,
-0.0376569182,
-0.0145206274,
-0.0066802786,
-0.0310556646,
-0.034749411,
0.0866347626,
0.0503724478,
0.0463905632,
0.0307328124,
-0.0162738841,
0.0404780954,
-0.0013891634,
-0.0080258939,
0.0215427857,
-0.0194909945,
-0.0067227082,
-0.002038551,
0.0187697411,
-0.1002027541,
-0.0008798154,
-0.0521885604,
0.0265145507,
-0.0161053929,
0.0238792878,
0.036925368,
-0.034773197,
-0.0154413218,
0.026948005,
-0.1011118144,
0.0194176771,
0.0084353723,
0.0095958775,
0.0450272299,
0.0043246699,
0.0371665843,
0.0176742245,
0.0021808194,
-0.0622689724,
-0.0169759952,
0.0712132603,
0.0640908927,
-0.004760961,
0.0255014766,
-0.0484582856,
-0.0385793671,
0.0274543352,
-0.0112570329,
0.0451641344,
-0.0476938598,
0.0544585735,
0.0482457019,
0.0122897942,
-0.011498143,
0.019856995,
-0.0214434266,
-0.0141898673,
0.0299340114,
-0.0173469614,
-0.0153146125,
0.0208947621,
-0.0632367134,
-0.00913308,
0.0083183739,
0.0124959974,
-0.0216835327,
-0.0246716272,
0.0969799459,
-0.0472094528,
0.0162477475,
-0.0739898533,
0.0004695791,
-0.0131861102,
0.0506114066,
-0.0120567074,
-0.0020003892,
0.0775845274,
0.0037447175,
-0.0220080055,
-0.1080101654,
0.0715013221,
-0.0099320402,
0.0586974844,
0.0019131029,
0.0035822585,
0.0369932204,
-0.0123193115,
-0.1140827313,
0.0506905168,
0.0322829783,
-0.0241713785,
0.0222500153,
-0.0384185128,
-0.0497567058,
-0.0316868089,
-0.013625307,
-0.0253172051,
0.0123373345,
0.0303553697,
0.009450363,
0.0172988139,
-0.0232650191,
-0.0102000907,
-0.0189126879,
0.0476037599,
0.0016968,
-0.0518255308,
-0.0545273833,
0.0087606953,
0.089788422,
0.06506522,
0.0055992063,
0.0448970124,
-0.0321290754,
0.0164330937,
0.0699664876,
-0.0001909604,
0.0232223533,
0.0325497426,
0.0094966991,
-0.0062275701,
-0.0390235037,
-0.0080893664,
0.0298784357,
0.0213216785,
-0.0892767236,
-0.0305533875,
0.0841118842,
0.0550398231,
-0.0209878143,
-0.020874761,
-0.0554162823,
0.0053687803,
-0.0063664117,
0.0411684625,
-0.0527048223,
-0.0134425117,
-0.0060588145,
0.0420320332,
-0.0524807498,
-0.0515663102,
0.0127349505,
-0.1281266212,
0.0432090163,
-0.0215563886,
-0.0746848658,
0.0182540994,
-0.0095393145,
-0.0118882852,
0.0419373214,
0.0152174626,
0.01547499,
0.004541859,
0.036010474,
0.0048701102,
0.0463403426,
-0.0116105936,
0.0124298185,
0.0056417664,
-0.0014434904,
0.0360060632,
0.0308743399,
-0.0294794776,
-0.0340610854,
0.0454610139,
-0.0456414968,
-0.0170468222,
0.0112561872,
0.0140681276,
0.0070032403,
0.0245897397,
-0.0612039119,
0.0574339367,
0.0131963464,
0.0037382124,
0.0430064984,
0.0849772021,
0.0065278364,
-0.0556106791,
-0.0397187844,
0.0235993695,
-0.038774129,
0.0743830279,
0.0656490549,
-0.0225397833,
-0.00361611,
-0.051812984,
0.0245023984,
-0.1004506797,
-0.0433711298,
-0.0034979873,
0.0210465603,
0.0326577164,
-0.066048488,
-0.0773477554,
0.0655277446,
0.034222655,
0.0050300388,
-0.0115161194,
0.003425258,
0.0000762684,
-0.0317919627,
0.0001161301,
0.0192201491,
-0.0419118479,
-0.0763523355,
-0.0246207621,
0.0078603718,
-0.0221184306,
-0.0264084041,
0.0415100716,
0.0078941137,
-0.0289908536,
0.0063039036,
0.0269332398,
0.025776498,
-0.0645450056,
0.0156850331,
-0.0046862182,
0.0237470716,
0.0508723557,
-0.0085103661,
0.017346181,
-0.0525125787,
-0.01765568,
-0.006880844,
-0.0056866971,
-0.0162031427,
0.0152433636,
-0.032179039,
0.0390119702,
0.0120571433,
0.0227423683,
0.0498047993,
0.0511847772,
0.0119184833,
-0.0230220947,
0.0020069093,
-0.0030132392,
-0.0113694239,
-0.0480207056,
-0.0206043683,
-0.0080430759,
-0.0125051113,
0.0049395529,
-0.007844097,
-0.0010341665,
0.0096590798,
-0.0422384255,
0.0561518334,
-0.0000456013,
0.0058152913,
0.0088929394,
0.0282641985,
0.0141407382,
-0.0277240649,
-0.0211030338,
-0.0474820063,
-0.0059663346,
0.0837906748,
-0.0128212804,
0.0993276387,
0.0280821528,
0.0068961312,
0.0199182834,
0.0206143297,
-0.0611852929,
-0.0297426637,
-0.0226100478,
0.003853088,
-0.0212132353,
0.0330519117,
-0.0215204302,
-0.0341016538,
-0.025780445,
0.0006552106,
-0.0073789111,
0.0360746831,
-0.0139567377,
0.0172704235,
0.0316856503,
0.0180674791,
-0.0186653025,
0.0538952723,
-0.0374097824,
0.001205992,
0.0308310445,
-0.0253204592,
-0.0352815203,
-0.0078146243,
-0.0203573853,
0.0481855348,
0.035570655,
0.0347953923,
-0.0877208412,
-0.0315032452,
-0.0030054459,
0.0449294746,
0.030031383,
-0.0139364786,
0.0316061601,
0.0506262556,
-0.035997618,
-0.0179486386,
-0.0042091855,
0.0834375918,
-0.0985000134,
-0.0384623297,
-0.0059144823,
-6.089660607e-33,
-0.0269207656,
-0.0569964349,
0.0248578377,
-0.0120298592,
-0.0147688184,
-0.0035182002,
-0.0558897145,
0.0396213606,
0.0057572359,
-0.0067230426,
-0.0127981007,
-0.0264727604,
-0.0132459076,
0.0081250444,
0.0322366357,
-0.0369607471,
0.0111537306,
-0.0153228855,
-0.0617872365,
0.0460982956,
0.0239619799,
-0.0041157561,
0.0299589038,
0.0286561009,
0.0215105806,
-0.0485376604,
0.0114307869,
-0.0202446543,
-0.0179511402,
0.0341639556,
-0.0277310237,
0.0391283408,
0.0444325767,
-0.0435389355,
0.007427549,
0.0211776868,
-0.0157011636,
-0.0577002242,
-0.0043964968,
-0.0522599146,
-0.0550481528,
-0.0482059233,
0.0252745412,
-0.0141583979,
-0.001660575,
-0.0387915745,
0.0395841673,
-0.0042093256,
0.0106805759,
0.0016409865,
-0.0658647791,
0.0006864458,
-0.0225914288,
0.011814177,
-0.0545607954,
0.1081906632,
0.0232588015,
0.0233187415,
-0.0238691326,
0.0262867231,
0.0409135036,
0.0247261487,
0.0196490474,
-0.005446122,
-0.0005357225,
0.0314421766,
0.0495395549,
-0.0107837208,
-0.0495126247,
0.0065831826,
0.0185972266,
0.0037143205,
0.1017664149,
0.096758239,
0.0695086867,
0.0361883193,
-0.0403928459,
0.0717435703,
0.029463172,
-0.0221555736,
-0.0223137438,
-0.0750364587,
-0.0318667553,
-0.0029264223,
-0.0164682101,
0.0077134226,
-0.0508046336,
-0.0413090698,
0.0553968996,
-0.0516613349,
-0.0263370201,
-0.0064617316,
0.0245747417,
0.0231894813,
0.0333107673,
-0.0309592225,
-0.0250991434,
0.0594479814,
-0.0161535479,
0.0051808716,
-0.0224881098,
0.0412566997,
0.013399763,
0.0000255838,
0.0417807437,
0.0306091141,
0.0090296045,
-0.0013418976,
-0.0018685786,
-0.0077125044,
-0.0294803344,
0.0391431116,
0.0122990077,
-0.0279731881,
-0.0012726368,
0.0244392194,
0.0168463588,
-0.0282082148,
0.0177406482,
0.0082888184,
-0.0612538122,
-0.0195012353,
-0.0028181507,
-0.008430534,
-0.0062223594,
-0.0017523486,
-0.0103010638,
0.0136056608,
0.0089051882,
-0.0602223687,
-0.0153282192,
0.0003589716,
2.54e-7,
0.0511417203,
0.0297514349,
0.0165356025,
-0.0088478941,
-0.0114983497,
0.0176485647,
-0.0073807426,
-0.0350369774,
0.0536850616,
0.0124033373,
0.0155479936,
0.0227869265,
0.0186730698,
0.0458586626,
-0.107668981,
-0.0651393607,
0.0043948293,
-0.0063388511,
-0.0508186817,
0.0147078959,
0.1075341329,
-0.0104531543,
-0.0231966246,
-0.036981266,
-0.0012550016,
-0.0229874067,
0.025414519,
0.0180574339,
0.0081638861,
0.0287510268,
-0.003264223,
0.0275082309,
0.0126871234,
0.0249594152,
-0.0182460137,
-0.0257534999,
0.0168481488,
0.0102960616,
0.0412519127,
-0.0496750735,
0.013534857,
0.0047065965,
0.0227997825,
-0.1084880307,
0.068942979,
-0.0328082368,
0.0104500977,
0.0775489137,
-0.0638180971,
-0.0312371012,
-0.0136195868,
-0.0221016183,
-0.034094356,
0.0238864776,
-0.0208137892,
-0.0049799066,
0.0363548659,
-0.0159090329,
-0.0039625415,
-0.0110823615,
-0.0343880132,
-0.0574199073,
-0.0671009421,
-0.0161306746,
0.0010812241,
-0.0322858058,
-0.0282865055,
2.314447817e-34,
0.0262687169,
-0.0230152123,
0.0743764117,
-0.0500254333,
0.0039633238,
0.0011221437,
0.0180819742,
-0.0178714059,
0.0056301453,
-0.0603477955,
-0.0264667198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15193v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15193v3 | Reward Steering with Evolutionary Heuristics for Decoding-time Alignment | 2024-06-21T14:35:16 | 2024-06-25T16:55:03 | Chia-Yu Hung, Navonil Majumder, Ambuj Mehrish, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL | The widespread applicability and increasing omnipresence of LLMs have
instigated a need to align LLM responses to user and stakeholder preferences.
Many preference optimization approaches have been proposed that fine-tune LLM
parameters to achieve good alignment. However, such parameter tuning is known
to interfere with model performance on many tasks. Moreover, keeping up with
shifting user preferences is tricky in such a situation. Decoding-time
alignment with reward model guidance solves these issues at the cost of
increased inference time. However, most of such methods fail to strike the
right balance between exploration and exploitation of reward -- often due to
the conflated formulation of these two aspects - to give well-aligned
responses. To remedy this we decouple these two aspects and implement them in
an evolutionary fashion: exploration is enforced by decoding from mutated
instructions and exploitation is represented as the periodic replacement of
poorly-rewarded generations with well-rewarded ones. Empirical evidences
indicate that this strategy outperforms many preference optimization and
decode-time alignment approaches on two widely accepted alignment benchmarks
AlpacaEval 2 and MT-Bench. Our implementation will be available at:
https://darwin-alignment.github.io. | [
-0.0057661985,
0.0558110885,
0.0028875615,
0.0087167807,
-0.0276569854,
0.007787121,
-0.065250963,
-0.0015882857,
-0.0679750964,
0.0147726303,
-0.0266569909,
0.0375824235,
0.0015435884,
-0.0073047495,
-0.0144188832,
-0.0257346425,
0.0757483914,
-0.0027365601,
0.0064625004,
0.021997489,
-0.0107319131,
-0.0088364044,
0.0085187834,
0.0235730633,
0.0531420074,
-0.0404697917,
-0.0347304307,
0.0503391139,
0.0807183832,
-0.0212211329,
0.0009535193,
-0.0064036292,
0.0107497042,
0.0843532458,
0.0000021974,
-0.0628553033,
-0.0392674729,
-0.0043553784,
-0.0621164069,
0.0421431176,
0.0374277085,
0.0389203466,
-0.028145615,
0.0025178094,
-0.0075625214,
0.0461436845,
0.0710073858,
-0.0098577542,
0.0011154698,
0.0803529546,
0.0173038002,
0.0252562109,
0.0065206434,
-0.0175512824,
0.0282706656,
-0.0579435378,
-0.008149256,
-0.0090427417,
0.0201018937,
-0.0051787384,
-0.0165945534,
0.0268373787,
-0.0096472353,
0.0188541859,
0.0397048257,
0.0135097951,
0.0278720148,
-0.0303678438,
-0.0597867928,
0.0187781323,
0.0039875442,
-0.0063896244,
0.0263789762,
-0.0309470501,
0.0109526757,
-0.0476430282,
0.0119556896,
0.002610385,
-0.024242267,
0.0349652544,
0.0624618679,
0.0177047178,
0.0284670405,
-0.0220054761,
-0.0089354357,
0.1052033007,
-0.0007520716,
-0.0275604222,
-0.0229744278,
-0.0008474161,
0.0268257596,
-0.0406237021,
-0.0505651273,
0.0207950454,
-0.0261215009,
-0.0112860287,
-0.0401938856,
0.026161544,
-0.02233156,
-0.0018229116,
0.0515410602,
0.0634395629,
0.0051145367,
0.0042226631,
-0.0213433988,
0.0575690642,
-0.0725616664,
0.0265765898,
-0.0241196938,
0.0498869494,
0.003256344,
0.0086076558,
0.0559959374,
-0.0096826758,
-0.0444999747,
0.0065989378,
-0.0406279899,
0.0724765286,
0.0123002734,
0.0492861308,
0.0003001681,
0.0034913314,
-0.032417696,
0.0326845422,
-0.0559433922,
0.0374293402,
-0.0215080082,
-0.0158797093,
0.0087882662,
0.0167395324,
-0.009590161,
0.0040706005,
-0.0391309783,
-0.0291987192,
-0.0108462982,
0.1177117079,
-0.0248259008,
0.0058450401,
-0.0521470606,
-0.0455758497,
-0.0126506044,
-0.0067762975,
0.0154224606,
-0.019114567,
0.0233751703,
-0.0090537509,
-0.0285186972,
0.0061798836,
-0.005805674,
-0.0414451919,
0.0045006094,
0.0545198321,
-0.0049681501,
0.003384663,
-0.011760911,
-0.0020909733,
0.0031330362,
0.0733753666,
0.0431080461,
0.0543773472,
0.0136388205,
0.0096299099,
-0.042373158,
0.0300939064,
-0.0124351298,
-0.0116290152,
0.0501502566,
0.0061155041,
0.037469063,
0.041545786,
0.0882816017,
-0.0357690379,
0.0162027795,
0.0116789872,
0.05323001,
0.0078148665,
0.0535753407,
-0.0368261151,
-0.0221879184,
-0.019801937,
-0.0536988005,
-0.0011846973,
-0.0542481132,
0.0642617866,
-0.025392333,
0.0393765345,
-0.0019272302,
0.061220441,
0.0091751106,
-0.0411886312,
-0.0157866813,
0.0130596068,
-0.0136634773,
0.042944815,
-0.005155188,
-0.0464080088,
-0.0607370622,
0.0092981094,
0.0147971008,
-0.0125749232,
-0.0221052729,
-0.0581176393,
0.0593409874,
0.0858848244,
0.0471303426,
-0.0166705865,
-0.0583267473,
0.0055621625,
-0.0330421403,
0.0214117095,
0.0357793979,
-0.0170543417,
0.0075628604,
-0.0223405231,
-0.0704996064,
-0.0163781568,
-0.0233442597,
0.042121619,
0.017568361,
-0.0197296347,
-0.008176472,
-0.0016839318,
-0.0285942312,
0.0375150666,
0.0157787316,
-0.0484285727,
-0.026158588,
0.0045769075,
0.049163837,
0.0102706524,
-0.0076075322,
-0.0028518215,
0.0274824873,
-0.0015147257,
0.0205861945,
0.0359769538,
-0.0484247617,
-0.0252256356,
0.0479574092,
-0.0356405266,
-0.0175256841,
0.0217728261,
-0.0509748533,
-0.0172341671,
0.020237565,
0.0000971193,
0.06300392,
0.0236548483,
0.0651169866,
-0.0319208391,
-0.0347203203,
-0.0550610311,
0.0443858281,
0.002918232,
-0.0351674818,
-0.0221076831,
0.0093632089,
-0.0019816349,
-0.0606328994,
0.0030946159,
0.0289906617,
0.0234335847,
-0.0234892908,
0.0503590368,
0.0248290896,
-0.0292060934,
-0.0267896447,
-0.04290656,
0.0468571894,
0.0023042394,
0.0872443765,
0.0256873164,
-0.0011757686,
-0.0028012798,
0.0227223877,
-0.0215400606,
0.0085311057,
-0.0134516582,
-0.0119085917,
0.0485429838,
-0.0055655721,
-0.042337995,
-0.0376185812,
0.0202702042,
-0.0362310223,
-0.0130315823,
-0.0070188055,
-0.0297761783,
-0.0918711349,
0.0288244989,
-0.0234881006,
0.0039911428,
-0.0207530614,
0.016974695,
0.033159405,
0.0509396791,
0.0256137364,
0.0962141976,
-0.0074417987,
0.0304160696,
0.0209496375,
0.0009522342,
-0.0856805369,
0.0064301705,
-0.0065750256,
-0.0494103283,
-0.0386866145,
-0.0245067589,
0.0281046536,
0.0903692618,
-0.0303630978,
0.0159721076,
-0.0542339198,
-0.0014652613,
0.019895155,
-0.0591576211,
0.0303627755,
-0.0106726,
-0.0357881561,
0.0411261618,
-0.0559893139,
-0.0738084987,
0.0670694262,
-0.0089095095,
0.0021918449,
-0.0131051978,
-0.001776279,
-0.0522204451,
0.030299915,
-0.0362110436,
0.0143669983,
0.0092993341,
-0.0428866968,
-0.054642953,
0.0067712064,
0.0353817903,
-0.0366588905,
0.0447677746,
-0.0104559502,
-0.0276692808,
-0.0389700457,
-0.0585938916,
-0.0178395044,
0.0231959037,
0.0107233888,
-0.025116533,
0.0110733937,
-0.0307151452,
-0.0519308299,
-0.0227040313,
0.0185803249,
-0.0278405957,
-0.019059306,
-0.0030054115,
-0.0377657413,
-0.0432251468,
0.0410462208,
0.0206907894,
0.0293705985,
-0.0317195468,
-0.0134876175,
0.0364794135,
0.0502391309,
-0.0265644602,
-0.0412149057,
0.0135318451,
0.0446304679,
-0.0384334177,
0.0100193536,
0.0380592085,
0.0780447274,
-0.0274270773,
0.0095441826,
0.0532386526,
0.0200447999,
-0.0202829726,
0.0178492479,
-0.0532498322,
0.0408241637,
0.0076973983,
0.0456039459,
-0.0885618776,
-0.0330779552,
0.0108847488,
0.0736422986,
-0.0300049055,
-0.0008471355,
0.0132624842,
-0.0506238043,
-0.0055669961,
0.0436144024,
-0.0271152668,
-0.0096659185,
-0.0013249472,
-0.0158274341,
-0.039127361,
0.0087803146,
0.0528722554,
0.0205748733,
-0.0000873613,
0.0262011643,
0.0295512844,
-0.0125253126,
0.0005725354,
-0.0403719358,
0.0530382246,
0.1487120539,
0.0010341306,
0.0367191397,
-0.0530534871,
-0.0082954429,
0.028523,
0.0152189573,
0.00029476,
-0.0135713397,
-0.0315878019,
0.0164623428,
-0.0305726267,
0.0326822586,
0.0007655686,
-0.0032284071,
0.0110974768,
0.0630379543,
-0.0265923887,
-0.0056339828,
-0.033911176,
-0.036404267,
-0.0084194653,
0.0497029349,
-0.0131591102,
-0.0193715449,
-0.0524058677,
-0.0308922417,
-0.0440833941,
-0.0876931176,
-0.0155520821,
0.0156341717,
-0.0071796249,
-0.0195498224,
-0.0388925709,
-0.0293800756,
-0.0362636037,
0.0268028621,
0.0236380473,
-0.0350943319,
-0.0349514447,
-0.0244519692,
-0.0676536858,
0.0140453996,
0.0048446399,
0.0057606082,
-0.0704424232,
-0.0002911389,
-0.0172903389,
-0.01714186,
0.0170227438,
0.033139091,
-0.0611434616,
-0.0819237456,
-0.036219798,
0.0548213087,
0.0289390292,
0.0660400987,
0.0198173299,
0.0226500072,
0.0382056125,
0.0493549258,
0.0314137302,
0.0355280377,
-0.0012620459,
0.032278724,
-0.0381538384,
0.0044957898,
-0.0649562031,
-0.0196221471,
0.0658502206,
0.0412577949,
0.0198036376,
0.0120580653,
0.0091429809,
0.0187659971,
0.0184204467,
-0.0306930114,
-0.0535931364,
0.0082608927,
0.0053271293,
0.0009899682,
0.0039491011,
-0.0109547023,
-0.0338602215,
0.0055082706,
-0.0165905319,
0.0304253697,
0.0029703779,
0.0197868496,
-0.0182078239,
-0.0763838217,
0.0534593947,
-0.0066527654,
0.0230142139,
-0.0030286764,
0.0241800807,
-0.0080504892,
0.0533459522,
-0.0058943285,
0.0476186201,
0.0110587878,
0.0258497968,
0.0295750406,
0.0597154312,
-0.0140614631,
0.030510053,
-0.0310950708,
-0.0128523596,
-0.0224969052,
-0.0362607166,
0.06250076,
0.0083022397,
0.0601819903,
-0.0011714781,
0.0075952699,
-0.0093710348,
0.0271164719,
-0.0379705913,
0.0012862607,
0.0189718306,
0.0084628817,
-0.0398088917,
-0.0872645006,
0.019075416,
-0.009336248,
0.0533015095,
-0.0724344179,
-0.0093136076,
-0.0217841528,
-0.0417591706,
0.0370658673,
-0.0375206284,
-0.0278756917,
-0.0494964346,
-0.0457471982,
-0.0042745234,
0.0033072478,
0.0461845957,
0.020119952,
-0.0163821951,
0.010785955,
0.0181652009,
-0.0234085843,
-0.1066368148,
0.0083318027,
-0.0382027328,
-0.0109329,
-0.0189460758,
-0.0588891879,
-6.446741628e-33,
-0.0359241031,
0.0037797703,
0.0261573792,
0.0109239239,
-0.0477562025,
-0.0198506881,
-0.0111090913,
-0.0064924075,
0.0019573586,
-0.0576374978,
-0.0093738781,
-0.0313579515,
0.0097415345,
-0.0398544669,
0.0476454347,
-0.0085059293,
0.0249216668,
-0.005935872,
-0.0822221264,
-0.0280748606,
0.0342450589,
0.0078332257,
0.0645932779,
-0.0171082504,
0.0256898254,
0.0515978336,
0.0004369203,
-0.0164484121,
-0.0162921157,
0.0419777893,
0.0239301864,
-0.0281875599,
-0.0128371464,
-0.0443419255,
-0.0293564219,
-0.0104873991,
-0.0344772488,
-0.0204288065,
0.0308731031,
0.0228112936,
-0.0286962036,
-0.0778132081,
0.0367887393,
0.0373047926,
-0.0785525367,
-0.0170556754,
0.0068392409,
-0.0094034439,
-0.0198091492,
-0.014932476,
-0.0774123296,
0.0214806329,
-0.0134055056,
0.0214168765,
0.0486279801,
0.0276132189,
0.0091408454,
0.0225051288,
-0.0335242413,
0.0413109325,
0.0161988325,
0.0123891886,
0.1268568784,
0.0776732564,
0.0207592081,
0.0225163866,
-0.0334692933,
-0.0068343491,
0.0003948885,
-0.0026583539,
0.0004851822,
0.0345782526,
-0.0005865906,
-0.0283125173,
0.0049553257,
0.0106952712,
-0.0173346363,
0.0762534812,
0.0366760679,
0.0045032124,
0.0162245948,
0.0776028261,
-0.0431727134,
0.0066171591,
0.0065732729,
0.015893003,
-0.0138177378,
-0.0468116775,
0.038875483,
0.0032136289,
-0.0227893554,
0.0050524576,
0.033741463,
-0.0222514216,
0.020124618,
-0.0380789451,
-0.0066053816,
0.0073662056,
-0.0082466891,
-0.0048731901,
-0.0588151477,
-0.0586859919,
0.0092760008,
-0.016332712,
0.0650896057,
0.0009623727,
-0.0213248041,
0.0052016368,
-0.0539857671,
0.0262646824,
-0.0427370146,
-0.0081071155,
0.017114209,
-0.0479502864,
0.0521214642,
-0.0352015868,
0.0065766047,
-0.0090934718,
0.0211254861,
0.0044518071,
-0.0561062619,
0.0136976121,
-0.0063757407,
0.023756329,
-0.0168761443,
0.0285904016,
0.0058157588,
0.0458416529,
-0.0716635734,
-0.0371704809,
-0.0472752973,
0.0329838395,
2.893e-7,
0.0371797234,
0.0320893861,
0.0492204838,
0.0275071189,
0.0046603056,
0.0355109349,
-0.0019923735,
0.0460919328,
-0.0245216172,
-0.0220118538,
0.0413166694,
-0.0012698272,
0.0467739701,
-0.0171541031,
-0.004147409,
-0.0272405986,
-0.0162590742,
0.0631594434,
-0.0441998392,
-0.0099306591,
0.0151137412,
0.0338190645,
0.003664837,
0.0333267488,
0.0368530564,
0.0228230618,
0.0224093422,
-0.0208179709,
0.0026589877,
0.0172651913,
-0.0383846462,
-0.0302417967,
-0.0554548725,
-0.0367135443,
-0.0010344484,
0.0121016959,
-0.0496250838,
0.0461243093,
-0.0229753517,
-0.0598509721,
-0.0230280794,
0.0353941843,
0.0026963043,
-0.0239514261,
0.0348774977,
-0.0107204542,
-0.0519232117,
-0.0242042672,
-0.0037054769,
0.0030822859,
-0.0359226316,
0.0347472019,
0.0380004123,
0.0063273455,
-0.0175941829,
0.0133208176,
-0.0574231856,
-0.0487996414,
-0.0160633549,
0.0393475816,
-0.0338784233,
-0.0757989958,
-0.0519971363,
0.112496607,
0.0199405774,
-0.0605031662,
-0.0389095098,
2.988330948e-34,
-0.021835221,
-0.0462274738,
0.0165253822,
0.0482502207,
0.0210314523,
0.0048574018,
-0.0134992385,
0.018106604,
0.0546850674,
-0.0150285633,
-0.0333374888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15178v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15178v1 | Hybrid Alignment Training for Large Language Models | 2024-06-21T14:23:57 | 2024-06-21T14:23:57 | Chenglong Wang, Hang Zhou, Kaiyan Chang, Bei Li, Yongyu Mu, Tong Xiao, Tongran Liu, Jingbo Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Alignment training is crucial for enabling large language models (LLMs) to
cater to human intentions and preferences. It is typically performed based on
two stages with different objectives: instruction-following alignment and
human-preference alignment. However, aligning LLMs with these objectives in
sequence suffers from an inherent problem: the objectives may conflict, and the
LLMs cannot guarantee to simultaneously align with the instructions and human
preferences well. To response to these, in this work, we propose a Hybrid
Alignment Training (Hbat) approach, based on alternating alignment and modified
elastic weight consolidation methods. The basic idea is to alternate between
different objectives during alignment training, so that better collaboration
can be achieved between the two alignment tasks.We experiment with Hbat on
summarization and dialogue tasks. Experimental results show that the proposed
\textsc{Hbat} can significantly outperform all baselines. Notably, Hbat yields
consistent performance gains over the traditional two-stage alignment training
when using both proximal policy optimization and direct preference
optimization. | [
0.0482696369,
0.0537177324,
0.0301779062,
0.0100759612,
-0.0190330613,
-0.0030937914,
-0.042474553,
-0.0505448878,
-0.0156382713,
0.0052446718,
-0.0547302067,
-0.0627814084,
0.0327250622,
-0.0348197483,
0.022292044,
-0.0828979909,
0.0543628298,
0.0027877421,
-0.0022034841,
0.001501632,
0.0703018606,
0.0072871069,
-0.0091960952,
0.0052311812,
0.0117526371,
-0.0099933119,
-0.0255201701,
0.0272862576,
0.0584585294,
-0.0077749887,
0.0231524147,
0.0371474102,
0.0296919942,
0.0232373253,
0.0000018476,
-0.0438933857,
-0.0028989189,
-0.0238574576,
-0.0230086744,
0.0161854438,
0.0456211977,
-0.0422638841,
-0.0042057205,
0.0200976543,
-0.0079031941,
0.0121960817,
0.0723049641,
0.0561938025,
0.0830038413,
0.0857464075,
-0.0085431505,
-0.0461809337,
-0.0000361602,
-0.0410463437,
-0.032844115,
-0.0313921347,
-0.0004224787,
0.0018332631,
-0.0331752449,
-0.0261856336,
0.0017688292,
0.0160702541,
-0.0029041057,
0.0038020751,
-0.0064766929,
0.0382831283,
-0.0471101888,
-0.0228704531,
-0.0258616675,
0.0751012787,
0.0101997834,
-0.0024188776,
-0.0002806076,
-0.0062121321,
0.0005782801,
-0.031648986,
-0.0322615355,
0.0014197699,
0.017827265,
0.0470330864,
0.005035799,
-0.0214450974,
0.0159558896,
0.0060284142,
-0.0309735797,
0.0295176953,
0.0231455341,
-0.05126426,
0.005844017,
-0.0127294045,
-0.0274285842,
-0.0488173626,
0.0080602029,
0.0299590323,
-0.0800226256,
0.0287984814,
-0.0819564983,
-0.0303430445,
0.0057273833,
-0.0258279406,
0.0408714898,
0.067760326,
0.0352766663,
0.0335649028,
0.0028918316,
0.1019240767,
-0.0072427313,
0.0002902212,
-0.0817908198,
0.0285149235,
-0.029623514,
-0.014936287,
-0.0297477227,
0.0170926228,
-0.0250856038,
-0.0460661352,
-0.0554377288,
0.0324923247,
-0.0010553141,
0.0266589597,
0.0255646743,
0.013104667,
-0.0608956665,
-0.0189434737,
-0.0191371106,
0.0713206157,
-0.0160460845,
0.0071995333,
0.0342256762,
0.0281944033,
-0.0360231586,
0.0501766391,
-0.0160608646,
-0.0286257565,
-0.0366897248,
0.062061049,
-0.0836348459,
0.0142071964,
0.0009508337,
0.0122352801,
-0.022198949,
-0.0659546331,
-0.0377658084,
-0.0391486622,
0.0508540869,
-0.0332398824,
-0.0117871556,
-0.0269286484,
0.0053125382,
-0.0119354408,
-0.0071767834,
0.0469642729,
0.0062555624,
0.0277446546,
0.0030681007,
-0.0325207487,
0.0048051155,
0.0806512535,
0.0458308309,
0.0306349322,
-0.0096149184,
0.0205543246,
-0.0523021258,
0.052465599,
0.0061756196,
0.0241975635,
-0.0152323898,
-0.0031639687,
0.0158253238,
0.0654160753,
0.0664143413,
0.0695215464,
-0.0448325798,
0.0138202924,
0.0747114047,
0.022912411,
0.0010532335,
-0.0130789801,
0.0055220462,
0.0412927717,
0.0007148978,
0.0580033474,
-0.0505603515,
0.0220651459,
-0.0308122765,
0.0635863766,
0.0527576953,
0.0389684178,
-0.0180857945,
-0.0352940112,
-0.0044539659,
-0.0183439422,
0.0178118031,
-0.0228776559,
0.0200790223,
-0.0111625018,
-0.0628873482,
0.0746528506,
0.0255953651,
-0.0353265442,
0.004518352,
0.0057929899,
0.0011140777,
0.0724977776,
0.0162176024,
-0.0165321268,
-0.0876314193,
0.0036310263,
-0.001894812,
0.0594798177,
0.0646350607,
-0.017512938,
-0.007297738,
-0.0812124759,
-0.035706155,
0.0080978014,
-0.0198924746,
0.002120153,
0.0229572747,
-0.0247521177,
0.0149089908,
0.0182216372,
-0.0616227463,
0.0378573351,
-0.0131781185,
-0.0048876684,
-0.0049098097,
0.0364646427,
0.0301707219,
0.0075508421,
-0.0070121796,
-0.0026280256,
0.0047810059,
-0.0193471182,
0.0001882715,
0.0254299641,
-0.0554567426,
-0.0522211827,
0.0706212521,
0.0023938979,
-0.0306722689,
0.0175667536,
-0.0226986948,
-0.0795291141,
-0.030398231,
-0.0229979586,
0.034235388,
-0.0259731803,
0.052478604,
0.0227580182,
-0.0386285074,
-0.0711730644,
0.0364507101,
0.0007945544,
-0.0051467968,
0.0362243578,
-0.0178278629,
-0.0095945895,
-0.0449386314,
-0.011180847,
0.0131030744,
0.0127656497,
0.0275188647,
0.0319446251,
0.0304400045,
-0.0468027182,
-0.0597674176,
-0.1005129367,
0.0465909541,
-0.0292265136,
0.0432491861,
0.0488241911,
0.0060289237,
-0.0074036098,
0.0029137607,
-0.0483023748,
-0.0004872342,
-0.0232472606,
0.0067885802,
0.027663365,
0.0175847784,
-0.0070961509,
-0.0577670038,
0.0097430553,
0.0056184335,
-0.0118937492,
-0.0168911014,
0.0185871888,
-0.0516281277,
0.0280342009,
-0.0336106159,
0.0173765514,
-0.0053656171,
-0.0501362495,
-0.0060509988,
0.0146291107,
0.0767655298,
0.0691372529,
0.0357174091,
0.0091978759,
0.0249628667,
0.0251736511,
-0.0512072891,
0.0263415538,
-0.0228985604,
-0.0114757745,
-0.0651095435,
-0.0169918891,
0.0030452039,
0.0648746192,
-0.0044279117,
0.0245241001,
-0.0766272843,
-0.0447991155,
0.0110103851,
-0.016661441,
-0.0087828571,
-0.0118389828,
-0.0657099262,
-0.0229544304,
-0.0642178953,
-0.0355485417,
0.0958196148,
-0.0325196572,
-0.0179426763,
-0.0597864799,
-0.0363229923,
-0.0403890908,
-0.0004886621,
0.0132128149,
0.0349993668,
-0.0193780512,
-0.0340819135,
-0.0880938768,
-0.0103959944,
0.0432426259,
-0.0034752009,
0.0593566187,
-0.0351789705,
0.0181249492,
-0.0366340019,
-0.0622992963,
-0.0432145223,
-0.0455519073,
-0.0030158167,
0.021002369,
0.0250263829,
-0.0297152624,
-0.0414551459,
0.0171271879,
0.0443780459,
0.0377900489,
-0.0294170901,
0.0171120688,
-0.0347758047,
0.012469219,
0.0830750689,
0.039937906,
-0.0159266852,
-0.0627169311,
-0.0076991338,
0.0237390678,
0.071281679,
-0.040843267,
-0.0206765532,
-0.0108157732,
0.0391720198,
-0.0696232244,
0.0104321819,
0.0083796792,
0.0788652748,
-0.0165489744,
0.0254957117,
0.1163885295,
0.0179514792,
-0.0435205773,
-0.0124120107,
0.0137239108,
0.0984051153,
0.0246686377,
0.0164912026,
-0.0399113707,
-0.0401579849,
0.0058259824,
0.019326197,
0.0314325206,
0.0199839938,
-0.0076000947,
-0.1083657369,
-0.0359121822,
0.0458431095,
-0.0625489876,
-0.0150665194,
-0.0061459518,
0.033969108,
-0.0498196073,
0.072787337,
0.0150187379,
-0.0242934339,
0.0042779106,
0.0335431956,
-0.0115475422,
-0.0296241771,
-0.0515806414,
-0.0440442003,
0.0467512682,
0.074926585,
0.0097613381,
0.0013424137,
-0.0027150295,
0.051596038,
0.0282325298,
0.0006547543,
0.0129122455,
0.00912234,
-0.0271104351,
0.0007401219,
-0.0111568794,
0.046296142,
0.0048540849,
-0.0130573306,
0.0105552291,
0.0516184755,
0.0100001805,
0.0199427996,
0.0216463041,
0.0030422867,
0.0167663991,
0.0571524501,
-0.0006309692,
-0.052941341,
-0.0135849295,
-0.0211884286,
-0.0257481299,
-0.0394453928,
0.00208716,
0.0062550129,
-0.0527263619,
0.0145533802,
-0.0518228076,
-0.0486117117,
0.0098395413,
0.0444768332,
0.0201534443,
-0.0146340765,
0.0114581902,
-0.0268295947,
-0.0251317564,
0.0131813185,
-0.0187742431,
0.001960515,
-0.0526612997,
-0.0199053511,
0.0077325995,
-0.0001065658,
0.0058876681,
-0.0165265761,
-0.0424476154,
-0.1013074368,
-0.0359622687,
0.0489896722,
0.0148869073,
0.1000737399,
0.0108467462,
-0.0363697559,
0.0213737637,
0.0261722021,
-0.023298379,
0.0124348793,
0.0344394781,
-0.009926673,
-0.0090638436,
0.0421213955,
-0.028981356,
-0.0289129075,
0.0011259409,
0.0720168129,
-0.0226911604,
-0.0679111034,
0.026578011,
0.0156724807,
0.0027944397,
-0.0209807605,
0.0070811398,
-0.045052629,
0.0242173746,
-0.0091658393,
-0.0361338258,
-0.0090654613,
-0.0160660408,
0.0149416374,
0.0041128439,
0.0322648697,
0.0351418406,
0.0213418268,
0.0156130008,
-0.026776161,
-0.0137175173,
-0.0420825928,
0.007660599,
0.0290045682,
0.0243036076,
-0.0394344293,
0.0223615337,
0.0031993047,
0.0177549738,
0.004044997,
0.0504499301,
0.049554754,
0.0243683774,
-0.0138543816,
0.0231949631,
-0.0332650952,
0.0012879294,
-0.0316312313,
-0.0211268328,
0.0485386178,
-0.0274123084,
0.0857154801,
-0.0057375538,
-0.0195421912,
-0.0217360444,
0.0422163419,
-0.0523057021,
-0.0049192747,
0.0070804036,
0.0258712061,
-0.0127351815,
0.0131316269,
0.0728220567,
-0.0325725749,
0.0061874026,
-0.0436247811,
0.024462698,
-0.053039819,
-0.0611729845,
0.0268895682,
0.0207449496,
-0.0398532376,
-0.0442984849,
-0.0197934955,
-0.0354341976,
0.0026433822,
0.0153297167,
-0.0323331244,
-0.0186138712,
0.0552269556,
0.0365415104,
-0.0481542014,
-0.0105391517,
-0.0043302584,
-0.0390161574,
-0.0075680502,
0.0070072408,
-0.0402742289,
-6.030258836e-33,
-0.0372757055,
0.012607865,
0.0413129665,
-0.0258631576,
-0.0939402133,
-0.0080835866,
-0.0148406336,
0.0150835738,
0.0069285422,
0.0062308433,
-0.0049231006,
-0.0166338924,
0.0134797012,
0.0252041053,
0.0062619084,
0.0177113321,
0.0529278703,
-0.0060157608,
-0.0541282594,
-0.0055139465,
0.0072014905,
0.0153118195,
0.027849758,
-0.0201684274,
0.0044312542,
0.0254399739,
-0.0171894338,
0.030854119,
0.0025799598,
0.0675897375,
-0.0005161602,
0.0069478741,
0.0013924511,
-0.0419925191,
-0.0548673607,
0.0211850479,
-0.0427588038,
-0.0157810077,
0.0592546687,
0.0029315755,
-0.0563997664,
-0.0444574952,
0.0317394882,
-0.0315756388,
-0.004866052,
-0.0322529525,
0.029214358,
-0.0236724224,
-0.0261446368,
0.0057150405,
-0.0646655932,
0.0090690749,
-0.0305480454,
0.002121696,
0.0149058662,
0.0074148676,
0.003463519,
-0.023200335,
-0.0290108565,
0.0006026663,
-0.0021542259,
0.053655982,
0.0703572035,
0.0683358908,
0.0030578023,
0.0573730059,
-0.017194232,
-0.0239271875,
-0.0044607222,
-0.0054372973,
0.0197203662,
0.0080499258,
-0.0048156613,
0.0373325162,
-0.0017873853,
0.0236652475,
-0.032555446,
0.0451980866,
0.0145644369,
0.0477298535,
0.0105532045,
0.059852317,
-0.0073142564,
-0.0160654783,
-0.0299230665,
0.0186989754,
-0.0216370206,
-0.0291972086,
-0.0042511742,
0.040155232,
-0.0195424818,
0.0004431692,
0.0242526326,
-0.0144533068,
0.0126255071,
0.0267370902,
-0.0291491654,
0.0165171139,
-0.0211369041,
0.0211740676,
-0.0890118778,
-0.0523573011,
0.0101527898,
0.0072720675,
0.0090327831,
0.0169393104,
0.0534395054,
0.0127031049,
-0.0423329957,
0.0166843832,
-0.0176227521,
0.0099462038,
-0.0200483929,
0.0055983393,
0.0496474728,
-0.0127552487,
-0.0007627615,
0.0577107705,
0.0004133023,
-0.0237379577,
-0.0387372226,
-0.0152878305,
0.0178270228,
0.0344097503,
-0.0188276302,
0.0454125851,
-0.0069690063,
-0.0048572235,
-0.024280848,
-0.0433638021,
-0.0195440445,
0.0126686757,
2.561e-7,
0.0077453298,
0.0148650082,
0.0736988708,
0.0258366317,
-0.0187823921,
0.0266979225,
-0.0103001809,
0.0320383757,
0.0122904088,
-0.0007360812,
0.055395171,
0.0431082137,
0.0544520654,
-0.0127662895,
-0.1104363725,
-0.0100024324,
-0.0674071983,
0.0020195756,
-0.0449189395,
0.0127551453,
0.0511106141,
0.1009528264,
-0.008907292,
0.0190072078,
-0.0009030493,
0.0057010716,
0.0584888943,
-0.0222992394,
-0.0170604847,
0.0404404737,
-0.0031848273,
0.0045091179,
-0.0390183628,
-0.0097671933,
-0.0096725337,
0.0191526618,
-0.0022997402,
0.099696368,
-0.0177019071,
-0.0199215226,
0.0210330915,
0.0260902103,
-0.0081732357,
0.0050624548,
0.0593582429,
-0.0579603948,
-0.005628047,
-0.014359259,
-0.0319246948,
0.0002879679,
-0.0098154005,
-0.0169093236,
-0.0082192179,
0.0381405167,
0.0315349251,
0.0151884947,
-0.0387813002,
-0.0564955622,
-0.0375122167,
0.0337232649,
-0.0303091481,
-0.0357745253,
-0.0020050944,
0.0156507865,
-0.0083255833,
-0.0681280866,
-0.005104444,
2.491018777e-34,
0.0159629937,
-0.0217078999,
0.0361309797,
0.0342558399,
0.0164825916,
-0.0303203594,
-0.0250734743,
0.0200367216,
0.042348206,
-0.0962241888,
-0.023968799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15175v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15175v1 | Enhancing Idiomatic Representation in Multiple Languages via an Adaptive Contrastive Triplet Loss | 2024-06-21T14:21:41 | 2024-06-21T14:21:41 | Wei He, Marco Idiart, Carolina Scarton, Aline Villavicencio | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Accurately modeling idiomatic or non-compositional language has been a
longstanding challenge in Natural Language Processing (NLP). This is partly
because these expressions do not derive their meanings solely from their
constituent words, but also due to the scarcity of relevant data resources, and
their impact on the performance of downstream tasks such as machine translation
and simplification. In this paper we propose an approach to model idiomaticity
effectively using a triplet loss that incorporates the asymmetric contribution
of components words to an idiomatic meaning for training language models by
using adaptive contrastive learning and resampling miners to build an
idiomatic-aware learning objective. Our proposed method is evaluated on a
SemEval challenge and outperforms previous alternatives significantly in many
metrics. | [
0.0277922135,
0.0258002318,
-0.0028265719,
0.0492120981,
-0.0558723137,
0.0151503189,
-0.0301596411,
0.0340941884,
-0.0095948549,
-0.0302829146,
-0.050803557,
-0.0166981779,
0.0057636211,
-0.0303740483,
0.0475701019,
-0.0353419445,
0.0478292629,
0.0307749342,
0.0042503895,
-0.0212612431,
0.0145096323,
0.0387256853,
0.0246575717,
0.0148701556,
-0.0124769956,
-0.0252460614,
0.0344800241,
0.0339084342,
-0.0234450884,
-0.029426273,
0.0630433783,
0.0194932036,
-0.0015139119,
0.0085854884,
0.0000021036,
-0.0591454916,
-0.0283924285,
-0.0332253501,
0.0211537648,
0.0136997905,
0.0929409489,
-0.0197718926,
0.0041400506,
0.0045042462,
-0.0491567813,
0.0598145872,
0.0514304377,
0.0489297025,
0.0139542622,
0.0165433008,
0.0017897766,
-0.0604931898,
-0.0284089968,
-0.0382944047,
-0.0073553976,
-0.0413690321,
0.0086818924,
-0.0068250662,
-0.0874690413,
-0.0161223169,
-0.0360840932,
0.0401482619,
0.0363168679,
0.039683491,
0.0058635897,
0.0274034608,
-0.0413450748,
0.0218352061,
-0.0305864327,
0.0639114529,
-0.0482311025,
0.0072311326,
-0.0459611639,
-0.041896686,
0.0021273599,
-0.0801249295,
-0.0335657075,
-0.0241793077,
-0.0061089369,
0.0361650772,
0.0415782519,
0.0155809941,
0.0086088134,
0.0601074249,
-0.0191799365,
-0.0192152094,
0.0218361486,
0.0039145905,
0.0079950206,
-0.0208124481,
-0.0368078277,
0.037204504,
0.0174829196,
-0.020832656,
-0.0085152816,
0.0233149976,
-0.0032186988,
-0.0362990201,
0.0328789093,
-0.0858579725,
0.0516572297,
0.0250407085,
0.0093448088,
0.0486611538,
-0.0178173184,
0.0129495086,
0.028462166,
0.0757876933,
-0.0222426299,
-0.0123488642,
-0.0580095127,
-0.0222585257,
-0.0341460891,
0.0567480065,
-0.0082761524,
0.012608204,
-0.0350695141,
-0.0140906451,
-0.0340149067,
-0.0543206409,
0.031092409,
0.0387415104,
-0.0970301852,
-0.0343209058,
-0.022612242,
0.0805587173,
-0.010659798,
0.0479253344,
-0.0286839083,
-0.0656573176,
-0.0223134365,
0.0144919232,
-0.0198875107,
-0.0476340465,
0.0367052145,
0.0662262589,
-0.005257966,
-0.0829176009,
-0.0808896646,
-0.0138081778,
-0.0224321187,
-0.0198187232,
-0.0079367654,
-0.0792216286,
0.0425572768,
-0.0276093371,
0.0217250623,
-0.1246130764,
0.0111006638,
-0.0143020283,
-0.0317086205,
0.0755045488,
-0.0156937316,
-0.030165419,
-0.0378760993,
0.0148564745,
0.0180801712,
0.093960546,
0.060258422,
-0.0270727929,
0.0381170101,
-0.0048765731,
-0.052409865,
0.0179123785,
0.0289930683,
0.0256916732,
-0.0506375134,
-0.0101195909,
-0.0121562174,
0.0246665366,
0.0565669797,
0.0574722551,
0.0024178557,
-0.0139762908,
0.0308050122,
0.0001261572,
0.0221906602,
0.0447561778,
0.0532615408,
0.0409547314,
-0.0392708555,
0.0188833214,
-0.0022070864,
-0.0111898053,
-0.0081412699,
-0.0031855893,
0.0408812724,
0.0524226129,
-0.0226664171,
-0.0326810181,
0.0277159512,
-0.0285923034,
0.0321737155,
-0.0256598406,
0.0309646036,
0.048163496,
-0.0257703941,
0.0680510402,
0.0492883772,
-0.0332224332,
0.0045869066,
-0.0312917195,
-0.0653853565,
0.0306143984,
0.009817862,
-0.0120769525,
0.019227406,
-0.0175276827,
0.0243176185,
0.0277410075,
0.0153585244,
0.0060118223,
0.076887466,
-0.047749009,
-0.0115838367,
-0.0094285207,
0.0043248981,
0.0171883795,
0.0098454785,
0.026331462,
0.0083864396,
-0.0409482121,
-0.0428802185,
0.0050345068,
-0.039416872,
-0.0734148026,
0.069283776,
-0.007658449,
0.0211375672,
0.0145586906,
-0.0189277846,
0.0174687505,
0.0051805088,
-0.0384493768,
-0.0435675979,
0.0385785997,
-0.0324383341,
-0.0777581483,
0.0588574857,
-0.0396908037,
-0.0128715858,
-0.0168049019,
-0.0640163496,
-0.0175064802,
0.0630675778,
-0.0543360673,
0.0232018381,
-0.0317405276,
0.0017286293,
-0.0055498448,
0.0527582541,
-0.0207299571,
0.0745762363,
-0.0158454012,
0.0183606464,
-0.0446967892,
0.0029366058,
0.0178971048,
0.0126149599,
0.0213949475,
0.0151102543,
-0.0385163799,
0.0242933016,
0.0199741442,
0.0293317214,
-0.0482408591,
-0.0198048782,
-0.0421121344,
0.0086553898,
0.0030188055,
0.0380741395,
0.0289608836,
0.0361313224,
0.0001773556,
-0.0346196257,
0.0009229431,
-0.0532631874,
-0.0300489906,
0.0280164089,
0.0223574694,
0.0057873284,
-0.0287805498,
0.0134999882,
-0.0133727668,
-0.0364741832,
0.0358291566,
-0.0166756287,
0.0239265841,
0.01798396,
0.0109989149,
-0.0226083212,
-0.0164234079,
0.0132179093,
-0.0373067595,
-0.0380261205,
0.0037588996,
0.0200571865,
0.0529123023,
0.0200340953,
0.0283156727,
0.0163217057,
-0.0334585458,
-0.034755256,
0.0005134869,
-0.0280860662,
-0.0235590171,
-0.0010467931,
-0.0664097592,
-0.0099920714,
0.0613008663,
0.048791565,
0.0090077138,
-0.0496729612,
0.036742121,
0.0160617866,
-0.0106945168,
-0.0362497084,
0.03797438,
-0.0328518674,
-0.0103940833,
-0.0171375144,
-0.004348204,
0.0777175426,
0.0074854833,
-0.0049027493,
-0.0664284602,
-0.0169837363,
-0.0225784127,
0.0530813746,
-0.0683455095,
0.0360839851,
0.031436719,
-0.0348324887,
-0.0470415056,
-0.0686901584,
0.0156571362,
-0.0462135188,
0.0190648325,
-0.030885594,
-0.020092763,
0.0106518893,
-0.0510075726,
0.0256685987,
-0.0413201228,
-0.0109746838,
0.0349057876,
0.0261473432,
0.0391173586,
0.0115949241,
-0.0185023975,
0.0298639499,
-0.0052908906,
-0.0006909989,
-0.0329724401,
-0.0012089717,
0.0254429653,
0.0102597456,
0.0141662508,
-0.0004019896,
0.0122474777,
0.0349445418,
0.0227187444,
0.0210624617,
-0.0084796669,
-0.0097538754,
0.0414131768,
0.0101931784,
-0.0224559121,
-0.0139693776,
-0.0158137735,
-0.0036268975,
-0.0438753255,
-0.0186273251,
0.0600381754,
0.0240458585,
-0.0562508143,
0.0346993618,
0.0003258801,
0.0326340646,
0.0395764746,
-0.004789961,
-0.0525106639,
-0.0699763224,
-0.0169421379,
0.0003131084,
-0.0055768196,
-0.0182516705,
-0.0440627895,
-0.1058244333,
-0.0103245554,
0.0186468307,
-0.0538675338,
-0.0402460881,
-0.0119021246,
-0.0363180041,
-0.0330785587,
0.0137274796,
-0.0130534684,
-0.0215803757,
-0.0001883551,
0.0096700657,
-0.0176889803,
-0.0642646179,
0.0316846557,
-0.0247235056,
-0.0061802785,
0.0363840014,
0.0684817582,
-0.015009678,
-0.0545087121,
-0.0119411089,
-0.071453087,
-0.0304847434,
-0.0275063906,
0.0213210769,
-0.0132605704,
-0.0158665814,
0.0232097581,
-0.008551117,
-0.0494972505,
0.0002455442,
-0.0132280188,
0.0118463393,
0.0028217654,
0.0320066996,
0.003132347,
-0.0150629412,
0.0144523829,
0.0702220201,
0.0245972928,
-0.0355975926,
0.026422672,
-0.0089603048,
0.0079406584,
-0.054184068,
-0.0357971527,
0.002080759,
-0.0390324779,
0.0115639791,
-0.0336615294,
-0.036785908,
0.0052992464,
0.0385846682,
-0.0026042019,
0.0377401747,
-0.1008011922,
-0.0031593356,
-0.0634969175,
0.0263309721,
-0.0263319202,
0.0385759287,
-0.0147354947,
0.0203170888,
0.0306273419,
-0.018186288,
-0.0272536185,
0.0451297015,
-0.012471281,
-0.0677241534,
-0.0266922228,
0.0483333692,
0.0125920819,
0.0431232117,
-0.0227075294,
-0.0103716515,
0.0011177036,
0.0641867369,
0.0413303375,
0.0064878045,
0.0706794187,
0.0150733003,
0.0225720722,
0.0611532703,
-0.0218976773,
0.019252114,
0.0059514255,
0.0947692692,
0.0229167417,
-0.038201984,
0.038394466,
0.0110178236,
0.0218995996,
-0.057432048,
-0.0332846455,
0.0210265163,
0.0079976916,
0.0071218014,
-0.0370712765,
-0.0318540968,
0.0211277641,
0.0306064598,
-0.0142849945,
-0.0400270298,
0.0130319577,
-0.016314581,
-0.0376568958,
0.028059952,
-0.0148368413,
0.0203632433,
-0.0307447743,
-0.0348556265,
0.0390303321,
-0.0081893345,
-0.0177180655,
0.0161592998,
0.0169503428,
-0.0071388003,
0.0396344736,
0.0147098294,
0.0017522381,
-0.0106190322,
0.0188642442,
0.0119670276,
0.0157323591,
-0.0314733274,
-0.0240568221,
0.0381985158,
-0.0283888392,
0.0347371101,
-0.013502893,
0.0006662068,
-0.0276462138,
0.0314792469,
-0.0157386251,
-0.0607530437,
0.0512769744,
0.002544303,
-0.0279943552,
-0.0104651563,
0.0616008453,
-0.0627928898,
0.0535088219,
-0.0029285355,
-0.0088365115,
-0.0113762775,
-0.0060493499,
0.0448388681,
0.0346207879,
0.0239419285,
0.0326304063,
-0.0685156509,
-0.0674548447,
0.0185339339,
-0.000528901,
0.0191575121,
-0.0131768538,
0.0506331436,
0.0649977103,
0.004650102,
0.0090541607,
-0.0228370633,
-0.0222232211,
-0.0894595608,
-0.021138642,
-0.0336487293,
-6.688354941e-33,
-0.0476073511,
-0.0181681104,
-0.0160250943,
-0.0379059836,
-0.0268824603,
0.0363393985,
-0.0528028458,
0.0025660298,
-0.0293229464,
0.0160875171,
0.01207228,
0.0308445469,
0.0062962323,
0.0186550077,
-0.0018684092,
0.0351635963,
0.0015127682,
0.0218397155,
-0.0201970842,
0.0160689037,
0.0403120928,
0.0202595536,
0.1064419448,
-0.0523357205,
-0.0119802877,
0.0682843253,
-0.0502520241,
0.0290893484,
0.0367318243,
0.0320024677,
-0.0053874366,
0.1019076928,
0.0234020818,
-0.0173586961,
0.0023050243,
-0.0341627151,
-0.0564989857,
-0.0401093997,
0.0407758839,
-0.0016534866,
-0.0030526859,
-0.0448573902,
0.077837117,
-0.0296839569,
-0.0093806516,
-0.0067551844,
0.0235486068,
-0.0085034287,
-0.0271931384,
-0.0044625453,
-0.0666192099,
0.0276205409,
-0.0018138329,
-0.0266981088,
-0.0039292569,
-0.0240362491,
0.0103632128,
0.0229012091,
-0.0313885324,
-0.0004763397,
-0.011950938,
0.0364725292,
0.0198358186,
-0.0170532353,
0.0096697062,
0.0656052306,
0.0063916803,
-0.0224012062,
0.079894051,
-0.022350613,
0.0464736819,
0.0283237416,
0.0581105947,
0.0706289709,
0.0266225375,
0.0041339593,
0.0025666251,
-0.0012964911,
0.0280631352,
0.0206382368,
0.0202089082,
0.0168452114,
-0.0279839523,
-0.0229806956,
-0.018191928,
-0.0360296778,
-0.0242789816,
-0.0559872054,
0.0196593553,
-0.0107202418,
-0.0180711579,
0.0438313708,
0.0169296917,
-0.0347721875,
-0.0541001335,
0.0173460003,
-0.015449944,
-0.0090564555,
0.0170699172,
0.0218018442,
-0.0142343594,
-0.0330924019,
-0.0281709619,
0.0490784682,
0.0188912898,
-0.0147971269,
0.0571952797,
0.0205249172,
-0.0366650485,
-0.0140062617,
-0.0348689109,
-0.0251917299,
-0.0394237749,
-0.0070469114,
0.0293943565,
0.0466291606,
-0.0317679495,
-0.002219975,
0.0674278289,
-0.0324451327,
-0.0102793202,
-0.0508525409,
-0.0296427887,
0.1033608317,
-0.0329466015,
-0.0090545118,
-0.0011042111,
-0.037963938,
0.0339255966,
-0.0243533645,
-0.0403897651,
-0.0183701441,
2.941e-7,
0.0639005825,
0.0342316963,
-0.0040761754,
-0.0080600707,
-0.0310958698,
0.050407026,
-0.0052377195,
0.0375473425,
-0.0574533083,
0.0336948149,
-0.0012386362,
0.0301537998,
0.0361203849,
-0.0068322164,
-0.0771140829,
0.0661429539,
-0.067465499,
0.0678896382,
-0.0299290605,
0.0070187696,
0.0523188263,
0.1152900159,
0.0325416662,
-0.032801874,
-0.0081342757,
-0.0838697627,
0.0514415652,
-0.014353876,
0.0482326709,
-0.0091445595,
0.0168921091,
0.0327214673,
0.0211228747,
0.0254338514,
-0.0272886325,
-0.002159209,
0.0124107813,
0.0407968499,
-0.0308452062,
-0.0050527342,
-0.0032377266,
-0.0244167056,
-0.0080190878,
-0.0341238193,
0.0508474074,
-0.0489466675,
-0.0550507158,
-0.0268501975,
-0.0061469451,
0.0369820334,
0.083810173,
-0.0267127641,
-0.0481500328,
-0.0151618281,
0.0088199312,
0.0128801744,
-0.0462797508,
-0.0647120476,
-0.0076583466,
0.0486093573,
0.0261401515,
0.0084981006,
-0.0094219232,
0.041636914,
-0.002628769,
-0.0486302041,
0.0156928971,
2.283906316e-34,
0.0505814143,
-0.0157926604,
0.0268553086,
0.057295002,
0.0426923595,
0.0030886531,
0.0334972702,
0.0126727102,
0.0086392928,
-0.0058089294,
0.0078256112
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15534v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15534v1 | Geneverse: A collection of Open-source Multimodal Large Language Models for Genomic and Proteomic Research | 2024-06-21T14:19:10 | 2024-06-21T14:19:10 | Tianyu Liu, Yijia Xiao, Xiao Luo, Hua Xu, W. Jim Zheng, Hongyu Zhao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, q-bio.QM | The applications of large language models (LLMs) are promising for biomedical
and healthcare research. Despite the availability of open-source LLMs trained
using a wide range of biomedical data, current research on the applications of
LLMs to genomics and proteomics is still limited. To fill this gap, we propose
a collection of finetuned LLMs and multimodal LLMs (MLLMs), known as Geneverse,
for three novel tasks in genomic and proteomic research. The models in
Geneverse are trained and evaluated based on domain-specific datasets, and we
use advanced parameter-efficient finetuning techniques to achieve the model
adaptation for tasks including the generation of descriptions for gene
functions, protein function inference from its structure, and marker gene
selection from spatial transcriptomic data. We demonstrate that adapted LLMs
and MLLMs perform well for these tasks and may outperform closed-source
large-scale models based on our evaluations focusing on both truthfulness and
structural correctness. All of the training strategies and base models we used
are freely accessible. | [
0.0175896529,
0.0962965339,
-0.0064864955,
0.0229718219,
-0.0182642974,
0.0248399451,
0.0700657219,
0.0147250639,
0.0120939277,
-0.007345078,
-0.0213735476,
-0.0153755546,
0.0177496336,
0.0392637923,
0.0364446044,
0.0246996172,
0.0145237474,
-0.0042072074,
-0.0167957041,
-0.0299250074,
-0.0087907678,
0.0317436941,
0.0483921766,
0.0320844129,
0.0119588859,
-0.0344042554,
0.0327738263,
0.0002535973,
0.0339424349,
-0.0026541809,
0.0064994828,
0.0499487855,
0.0386807285,
0.0225085635,
0.0000019325,
-0.0422770157,
-0.0296386052,
0.0129464697,
0.0060728914,
0.0203021262,
0.0229232423,
-0.0207535066,
0.0227248389,
-0.0242584422,
0.0074765668,
-0.0257467683,
0.0910757259,
0.0263463277,
0.0269572102,
0.0447702445,
-0.0047419849,
-0.0547526106,
0.0288456623,
-0.0347327031,
0.0313858278,
0.0022820111,
0.0893434957,
0.0070793591,
0.0041529718,
-0.0129166907,
0.0001170019,
0.048186563,
-0.0295310728,
0.0064135385,
0.0115296086,
0.0278373174,
0.0055057504,
-0.0462864898,
0.0467899702,
0.0589489341,
-0.0177376214,
-0.0316502526,
0.0123274997,
0.0097081428,
0.0100357169,
0.0297134239,
-0.0476340763,
0.0311583355,
-0.0517629087,
0.0316322744,
-0.0050346684,
-0.061568886,
0.0638974458,
0.0043560588,
0.0195242669,
0.0320263319,
0.0127411131,
-0.0142700467,
-0.0555163994,
-0.0210396443,
-0.0546922125,
0.0082885204,
0.0021598572,
-0.0122717731,
0.0093424134,
-0.0303602535,
0.000294087,
-0.0463282727,
0.0550056659,
-0.0432572179,
0.0724256411,
-0.0114509063,
-0.0360591449,
0.0435401574,
-0.0372114033,
-0.0398923568,
-0.0478646494,
0.0274094194,
-0.0312177539,
-0.0096277073,
-0.0558207519,
0.0294394903,
0.0119616492,
0.0264798868,
-0.0273777004,
0.0289669409,
-0.0470901504,
-0.00272221,
-0.0084016388,
0.0028918267,
0.018562153,
0.0117450813,
-0.0273814704,
0.0301715899,
0.0226738323,
0.0594631061,
-0.0160470121,
0.0267255679,
-0.0341944173,
-0.0721140355,
-0.0212785322,
0.0409622341,
0.0354103968,
-0.0582988784,
-0.002626593,
0.0958561078,
0.0220382046,
-0.0369576104,
-0.0081947921,
-0.0214861967,
-0.0747713223,
-0.0470362008,
0.0135077368,
-0.0856507197,
0.0649896413,
0.043448247,
0.0134763205,
-0.0156606082,
-0.003236189,
-0.0327953286,
-0.0701169297,
0.0666037798,
-0.0375832617,
-0.0138120726,
0.0332169384,
-0.0224847998,
0.0026775214,
-0.002788875,
0.0275325011,
0.0103539564,
0.0078532575,
-0.0305842906,
-0.0272040498,
0.0508618839,
0.0021836183,
0.0006984761,
-0.0334373005,
0.0286244377,
0.079037495,
0.0550233424,
0.0149721326,
0.0048597353,
-0.012068552,
-0.040919438,
0.078445673,
0.0459344238,
0.0514455773,
0.0275439098,
0.034341,
0.0254429244,
-0.0083422186,
-0.0461327992,
-0.0052723377,
0.0087252166,
-0.0568956546,
0.0263949968,
0.0478285737,
0.0411760658,
0.0078715431,
0.0034437375,
-0.0313335136,
-0.0110378535,
-0.0037372068,
-0.0243816022,
0.052190952,
-0.0419462584,
-0.0256179366,
-0.0004237752,
0.0766656846,
-0.0281902794,
0.0113972956,
-0.0449550413,
0.0522566848,
0.0341584608,
0.0277744308,
-0.0565295592,
0.0007452908,
-0.0445858575,
0.0366888978,
0.0078776488,
0.004374119,
0.0036804571,
0.0208529271,
0.0037700718,
-0.0141159911,
-0.001339526,
0.0257833134,
-0.0062246132,
-0.0357881486,
-0.0054739979,
0.0034911586,
-0.0433975086,
-0.0339033641,
0.01934666,
-0.0391680002,
-0.0202189535,
0.0089058382,
-0.0376868956,
0.0106012393,
-0.016703127,
-0.0756971911,
0.0058511556,
0.0349571966,
-0.0360948928,
-0.0041474365,
-0.0426718667,
0.0204126891,
-0.0600340404,
0.0240125302,
-0.0140657341,
-0.0352335162,
0.0146145131,
-0.0518498868,
-0.0186762493,
0.0101821143,
-0.0394886434,
0.011833014,
-0.0450998433,
-0.0231287722,
-0.020470541,
0.0286591928,
-0.0534966923,
0.0250206944,
-0.0117283193,
0.0044870148,
-0.0031203676,
-0.0424428135,
0.0240445249,
-0.0296749678,
-0.0383083634,
0.0047701569,
0.0137637649,
0.0351789556,
0.0055699814,
0.0008882853,
0.0079674115,
-0.0069666407,
-0.0947403759,
0.0156724621,
0.0107613401,
0.0102762552,
-0.0503287688,
-0.0041104238,
-0.0035960195,
0.005721183,
-0.0192736257,
0.0246030986,
-0.008250447,
0.0143205859,
0.0307330191,
-0.0218092464,
-0.0431132913,
-0.0593141392,
-0.02886758,
-0.0435450301,
0.0714053363,
0.0010428741,
-0.0313419029,
-0.0226698462,
0.0049579912,
-0.0422313102,
-0.0000888223,
-0.0007410113,
-0.0307732671,
0.0027046704,
-0.0210120268,
0.0160775762,
0.014256686,
-0.0127469292,
-0.0113280602,
0.0719676912,
0.0042009572,
0.0119334981,
-0.0197244044,
-0.0495389663,
-0.0279237311,
-0.0156380478,
-0.0152981533,
-0.0262645241,
0.0446930528,
0.0260913242,
-0.0235110708,
-0.0398850851,
0.0295382533,
0.0293613672,
0.0168863293,
-0.028011743,
0.034280654,
-0.0245163497,
0.0230637118,
-0.0001185632,
-0.0669626892,
0.0830397755,
-0.0331399143,
0.0165034849,
-0.0001872897,
-0.0038155061,
-0.0206826758,
-0.0044384683,
0.020414982,
0.0323474146,
0.0275131911,
0.0183815602,
0.0259455144,
0.0219863411,
0.0104935849,
-0.0435456522,
0.0376247354,
-0.035678234,
0.032394696,
0.0116443895,
-0.0312104747,
0.0180013459,
-0.0119499993,
-0.0218938235,
0.0191864818,
0.0259318873,
-0.0339319408,
-0.0443565026,
0.0363655835,
0.0255614985,
0.0297989044,
-0.0446025245,
0.0137200002,
-0.0234504398,
-0.0053451424,
0.0471465737,
0.014855138,
-0.0152397342,
-0.0467598252,
0.006357972,
0.0323297307,
-0.0448530018,
0.030556716,
-0.0109229628,
0.0180831868,
0.007588583,
0.0211385787,
-0.0069504078,
-0.0074647618,
0.0475545451,
-0.0346488617,
-0.0095336214,
0.0969980285,
0.0238857549,
-0.0771444589,
0.0045879767,
-0.0045531439,
0.000440266,
-0.0202010982,
0.0371182188,
-0.1035006419,
-0.0626754314,
-0.0086267237,
0.0035080777,
0.0211316086,
-0.0485483035,
0.0487163104,
-0.0547382459,
0.0645830259,
0.0475238003,
-0.0450966768,
-0.0526850745,
-0.069127433,
-0.0275761168,
-0.0440640301,
-0.0059852833,
0.003275428,
-0.0133005064,
-0.003444002,
0.0209031031,
0.0173877869,
-0.1016785577,
0.0280992109,
-0.0454833806,
0.0536945723,
0.0647597462,
-0.0074850079,
-0.0009060078,
-0.0167944208,
0.0048696715,
0.0114768744,
-0.0009967677,
-0.0458974689,
0.0476475395,
0.0174500328,
-0.0469778813,
-0.0415907465,
0.0244090967,
-0.031600967,
-0.0048260703,
-0.0287873689,
0.1017756239,
-0.0167591758,
-0.036064636,
-0.0172856152,
-0.0156673267,
-0.0088893669,
0.0619396567,
0.0174578745,
-0.0373604074,
-0.0124155534,
-0.0193263143,
0.0012318119,
-0.0127806468,
-0.0210023094,
0.0275310595,
-0.0417800359,
0.0057895686,
-0.0370540917,
0.0081571201,
0.0508992635,
-0.0114128003,
0.0156230815,
0.0174614545,
0.013798031,
-0.0426315665,
-0.0584813021,
0.0796498805,
0.0044512413,
0.0462767072,
-0.0430832766,
-0.0357046686,
0.0688282922,
-0.031662304,
0.0089376606,
0.067071408,
-0.0808799192,
-0.0852909833,
-0.0492247455,
0.0562307276,
0.0137722176,
-0.012619976,
0.0283194501,
-0.0872314572,
0.0264293645,
0.0560867675,
-0.0226443131,
-0.0147954337,
-0.011360676,
-0.0266780257,
-0.0108614024,
0.03426826,
-0.029059669,
0.0133443046,
0.0078265313,
0.0414160788,
0.0197018012,
-0.0224220958,
0.02017924,
0.0252341256,
0.0766941756,
-0.0014910074,
-0.0497330241,
-0.0488891564,
0.0241611451,
-0.0049184654,
-0.0368799418,
-0.0113405166,
0.0141074331,
0.0300120767,
0.0056333072,
-0.0239359941,
-0.0077489694,
0.0007872282,
0.0209036488,
-0.0821996927,
0.0332606211,
0.0104944902,
-0.0585007146,
0.057641007,
-0.0019718227,
-0.0105777103,
0.0572043024,
-0.0550958663,
0.0038634045,
0.0063258456,
0.0072170906,
-0.0008044379,
0.0346962661,
-0.0421461314,
-0.0040644812,
0.0070521152,
-0.0155171007,
-0.025865363,
0.013027749,
0.0817484185,
-0.0221699849,
0.0690856427,
0.005760781,
-0.0213359036,
-0.0844722912,
0.0398816019,
-0.0316953845,
0.0040263589,
0.0470885858,
0.0101470519,
-0.0540120266,
-0.0509046093,
0.0755667016,
0.074101612,
0.0666457936,
-0.0457671918,
-0.0527467206,
-0.0221564099,
-0.0171259288,
0.0216538794,
0.0043413313,
-0.0640593767,
-0.0235300716,
-0.0216561537,
-0.0786038861,
-0.0051697595,
0.0023855669,
-0.0151569331,
0.0259359833,
-0.0114771938,
0.0254873019,
0.0205905512,
-0.0489479676,
-0.0396173224,
0.0288612619,
0.0016262199,
-0.048059985,
0.0127266757,
-6.548999351e-33,
0.0109273903,
-0.0059785373,
-0.0026484844,
0.0225871112,
-0.00670896,
-0.0059388378,
-0.0186830107,
-0.0006981093,
0.030662667,
0.0490425266,
0.0143203391,
-0.0039424156,
-0.0180058498,
0.0077941804,
0.013261117,
-0.0001687019,
0.0342273749,
0.0051988619,
0.0159436632,
0.0052217441,
0.0316491611,
0.041183576,
0.0432551652,
-0.0409866013,
0.0185840428,
0.0430707037,
-0.0085191689,
-0.001803179,
-0.0550043434,
0.0263476763,
-0.0209015384,
0.0352324173,
0.0030948475,
0.0077091553,
-0.0060783015,
-0.0215303116,
-0.0417764522,
0.0573167726,
0.0102688204,
-0.0049967589,
-0.0212306231,
-0.0409799255,
0.0522307344,
-0.01548752,
-0.0264159534,
-0.0069500008,
0.0382162482,
-0.0456903204,
-0.0529711172,
-0.0093060015,
-0.0475178212,
0.0415421873,
0.009342338,
0.0099555263,
0.0341024511,
-0.0039351378,
0.0104377605,
0.0458697267,
-0.0192342959,
0.0046304339,
0.0441547558,
0.0283315666,
0.0744435042,
0.0080607403,
0.0312750377,
0.0746848509,
0.0089741182,
-0.0180784892,
-0.0008483332,
0.0237574466,
0.0097116865,
0.0674975067,
0.0398264341,
0.0348164551,
-0.0033457761,
0.0113062011,
-0.1206703931,
0.0276807286,
-0.0447702669,
0.0028330921,
0.0296759624,
0.0136797065,
0.0299147051,
-0.0000227526,
-0.0662636533,
0.0047420384,
-0.0284462851,
0.0031610711,
-0.0206158143,
-0.0508226976,
-0.0267153587,
0.0323711298,
0.0597721301,
-0.0345484056,
-0.0572747663,
0.0299840942,
0.0028264879,
0.0028223593,
-0.0164517723,
0.0213371273,
-0.0224105325,
-0.0408789143,
0.0268146917,
-0.0598075017,
0.0549752861,
-0.0078420192,
0.0192257445,
0.0016300787,
-0.052307386,
0.0022205145,
-0.0393123552,
-0.0295674633,
0.0163609926,
0.0596527047,
0.0191973448,
0.0143355392,
0.0038817918,
0.0685304627,
0.0483604632,
0.0293365791,
0.0120975953,
-0.0354308188,
-0.0083483551,
-0.004070627,
-0.0322440304,
-0.0055302796,
-0.0267635938,
0.0064976737,
0.0337963887,
-0.0503603145,
-0.0108455243,
0.030652009,
2.828e-7,
0.0590286404,
0.0717377439,
-0.0145604452,
-0.0082239369,
0.0216548163,
0.0320304707,
-0.0365587249,
0.0448930748,
-0.0224755555,
-0.0196420681,
0.0045246221,
-0.0088358745,
0.07801871,
0.0182849914,
-0.0371364802,
0.0121738436,
-0.0526768751,
0.0340343118,
-0.0502019189,
0.0073148287,
0.0185281783,
0.1236142069,
-0.01333996,
-0.0163661465,
0.079768829,
-0.0424057245,
0.0544709228,
-0.0372889191,
-0.0254421998,
0.0225655809,
-0.0279378034,
-0.0306004137,
0.014539035,
0.0207924098,
0.0025739286,
-0.0312374122,
-0.0002166223,
0.0881625712,
-0.0041834288,
0.0261741113,
0.0580497682,
0.0049599591,
0.0191151388,
-0.0458730236,
0.037837971,
-0.0524513423,
-0.0350577757,
-0.0330049172,
0.0365761928,
-0.0060515543,
0.0538421273,
-0.0590768345,
0.0064925016,
0.0427504256,
0.0054027685,
-0.0001009498,
-0.0311102401,
-0.0256205872,
-0.0191544238,
0.037866924,
-0.0769706517,
-0.0192747265,
-0.0146853123,
-0.0204962436,
0.0189266875,
-0.0489465818,
0.0318440497,
2.640576097e-34,
0.044112388,
-0.0223803893,
-0.0247066468,
-0.0097794365,
0.0707370266,
-0.0394420847,
-0.0236652028,
0.0311751198,
-0.0409276374,
-0.1295582652,
0.0043460359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15163v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15163v1 | A Syntax-Injected Approach for Faster and More Accurate Sentiment Analysis | 2024-06-21T14:08:25 | 2024-06-21T14:08:25 | Muhammad Imran, Olga Kellert, Carlos Gómez-Rodríguez | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment Analysis (SA) is a crucial aspect of Natural Language Processing
(NLP), addressing subjective assessments in textual content. Syntactic parsing
is useful in SA because explicit syntactic information can improve accuracy
while providing explainability, but it tends to be a computational bottleneck
in practice due to the slowness of parsing algorithms. This paper addresses
said bottleneck by using a SEquence Labeling Syntactic Parser (SELSP) to inject
syntax into SA. By treating dependency parsing as a sequence labeling problem,
we greatly enhance the speed of syntax-based SA. SELSP is trained and evaluated
on a ternary polarity classification task, demonstrating its faster performance
and better accuracy in polarity prediction tasks compared to conventional
parsers like Stanza and to heuristic approaches that use shallow syntactic
rules for SA like VADER. This increased speed and improved accuracy make SELSP
particularly appealing to SA practitioners in both research and industry. In
addition, we test several sentiment dictionaries on our SELSP to see which one
improves the performance in polarity prediction tasks. Moreover, we compare the
SELSP with Transformer-based models trained on a 5-label classification task.
The results show that dictionaries that capture polarity judgment variation
provide better results than dictionaries that ignore polarity judgment
variation. Moreover, we show that SELSP is considerably faster than
Transformer-based models in polarity prediction tasks. | [
0.0417419188,
0.0462571681,
-0.0084973117,
0.0094906427,
-0.047515206,
0.021227764,
-0.0239238422,
-0.0287323613,
0.0033200514,
-0.0817213356,
0.0091909515,
0.0031772959,
-0.0293133762,
0.0454992652,
-0.0538189746,
-0.0477917194,
0.0315924138,
0.0654067248,
0.059805911,
0.0240894929,
0.0081430115,
0.021777058,
-0.0037133216,
0.0038980339,
-0.0142954597,
0.0206312574,
-0.0090298802,
-0.0226951931,
0.0023397543,
-0.0476888008,
0.0376958847,
0.0337077044,
-0.0324789472,
-0.0228449795,
0.0000021103,
-0.0247274507,
-0.0229065567,
-0.003201907,
0.0173697658,
-0.0265467949,
0.0776854977,
-0.0252496228,
0.011528966,
0.0297591034,
-0.0644681007,
-0.0284939725,
0.0476653017,
0.0419921093,
0.0767909959,
0.0585792474,
-0.0300083943,
-0.0657577738,
-0.0399543159,
0.0317179784,
-0.0304532386,
0.0117974645,
-0.000666698,
-0.0076563968,
-0.0450571142,
-0.0171617288,
-0.0143843992,
-0.0237077121,
0.0105541106,
0.0186572839,
0.0321342014,
0.0059831534,
-0.0099352403,
-0.0162845347,
-0.0139862001,
0.0161354095,
0.0034489706,
-0.04398885,
-0.0027801145,
-0.0074258712,
-0.0258180685,
-0.0410603024,
0.0103611667,
0.0372678675,
-0.0177287646,
0.0431667976,
0.0534831062,
0.0359078497,
-0.0243125688,
0.002865473,
-0.0161672886,
0.0882719904,
-0.0166546013,
-0.0395723842,
0.0223746039,
0.055055961,
-0.0044471542,
-0.0277242772,
0.013062546,
-0.0381059311,
0.0155083109,
0.0051515857,
0.0067850766,
-0.0320394151,
-0.0034145801,
-0.0689400509,
0.0090262638,
0.0158587992,
-0.0067069945,
0.0194492619,
0.0041673658,
-0.0150323762,
0.0379308574,
-0.0088672535,
-0.0336496159,
0.0068184594,
-0.0604712218,
0.0147679551,
-0.0044445246,
0.0378414989,
-0.0038832284,
0.0064859963,
-0.0374395028,
-0.0196137093,
-0.0251275469,
-0.007846483,
0.0181418769,
0.012070884,
0.0088716345,
0.0290995706,
-0.0546503067,
0.0575480498,
-0.0384351239,
0.0146169346,
-0.0473444983,
-0.0111807091,
0.008143927,
0.0577185452,
0.0200976245,
-0.0208789706,
0.0109788291,
0.0321520828,
0.028225312,
-0.0325040035,
-0.0516838655,
-0.0481452793,
-0.026609119,
-0.0316231512,
-0.0043696864,
-0.048387222,
-0.0193620939,
0.0378293619,
-0.0176531579,
-0.0124186631,
0.0134538859,
0.005270829,
0.0080024758,
0.0623365976,
-0.0186075419,
-0.0741600245,
-0.0487455912,
-0.0327149071,
-0.0224904399,
0.0300433822,
-0.0071421065,
0.0439769626,
0.0132219773,
-0.0372559205,
0.0014316173,
-0.0453934148,
-0.0131380577,
-0.0325920172,
-0.0708530396,
0.0134606287,
-0.0371820293,
-0.0584891662,
0.023228813,
0.0607762262,
0.0275297053,
-0.0286999457,
0.0137528265,
-0.0347800404,
-0.0420941934,
0.0170040485,
0.0164455865,
0.0344975702,
-0.0318465531,
0.0061226198,
-0.0460547432,
0.0425869972,
0.0038078879,
0.0137183713,
-0.0033760674,
0.023257751,
0.0259110592,
-0.0936802328,
-0.0561518967,
-0.035755679,
0.0640054718,
-0.0068192207,
0.0185764674,
0.0065343585,
-0.0626288652,
0.0326349735,
0.0644325018,
-0.0761578009,
-0.036872074,
-0.0162129179,
0.0028459849,
0.0862092823,
-0.0190700721,
0.0074801445,
-0.0548907891,
-0.0498820543,
-0.0208619274,
0.0130185327,
0.0358382724,
0.0222857948,
-0.0060514705,
-0.0442742445,
-0.0067217541,
-0.0121943895,
0.0150127588,
0.0376018696,
-0.0010322891,
0.0052637891,
0.0162093472,
0.0250300504,
-0.0216182731,
0.0111241387,
0.0605237186,
-0.0243791062,
0.0348743387,
0.0178677998,
0.0767762363,
0.0386951976,
-0.0094620278,
-0.0042328183,
0.0240074843,
-0.0200482141,
-0.0542896353,
0.021626601,
-0.0334921591,
-0.0525551215,
0.0130177224,
-0.0312199071,
-0.0282811783,
0.0328098312,
-0.0205780696,
-0.0203283131,
0.0092874635,
-0.0541450828,
0.021790497,
0.0044710538,
-0.0096885972,
-0.0003741468,
0.0165645089,
-0.0326775163,
0.0676430911,
-0.0059516383,
0.0190580953,
-0.0855181888,
-0.0307282787,
0.0170023665,
0.0493702814,
-0.0339638069,
-0.0130263278,
0.0159639344,
-0.0171556622,
0.0241822433,
0.0002320174,
-0.0107129933,
-0.04170423,
-0.0696509853,
-0.0041325721,
-0.0164330229,
0.0422683507,
-0.0019005073,
-0.0068379026,
0.0233046003,
0.0191885028,
-0.017841028,
0.0008857985,
-0.0179866944,
0.0135092968,
0.049767144,
0.0133965835,
-0.049792137,
-0.0313113965,
0.0126041472,
-0.0624800287,
-0.0101247691,
0.0231856927,
-0.0128929187,
-0.0038367377,
0.0505527481,
-0.0110645648,
0.0198642723,
0.0121714417,
-0.0714800134,
0.0258051865,
-0.0310627725,
0.0213680547,
0.0398248285,
0.0072528711,
-0.0031112661,
0.0550303683,
-0.0229040477,
-0.0162395444,
0.0203173012,
-0.0457067452,
0.0506785028,
-0.0100660603,
-0.0367017053,
-0.0075090979,
0.0827464163,
0.02337832,
-0.0079875551,
-0.0568620712,
0.0025475277,
-0.0317487232,
0.0173404384,
0.0721908584,
0.0137305921,
0.0015859534,
0.0155290775,
0.0258046445,
-0.0207887664,
0.0847359002,
0.0053353705,
-0.0211005732,
-0.1004424691,
-0.0195386931,
-0.0527424216,
0.0591431856,
0.0137403104,
-0.0099812457,
-0.002191457,
-0.0082241688,
0.0359480195,
-0.0438725948,
0.0269018523,
0.0097521916,
0.0402721278,
-0.0358739346,
-0.0185538381,
-0.0048381342,
-0.0580726713,
0.00851316,
-0.0391525887,
-0.0495157167,
-0.0278351493,
0.0513418093,
-0.0125223259,
0.0266782176,
0.0135251405,
-0.0343610533,
-0.0283759031,
-0.0003256439,
-0.0074198982,
0.014828885,
-0.0324690342,
0.0062376047,
-0.024344679,
0.0360548571,
0.0731043592,
-0.0129308421,
0.0242132507,
0.0036483684,
0.0394539498,
-0.0490520187,
-0.0239388142,
0.0012162786,
-0.0308582708,
-0.0475053042,
-0.0269060954,
0.0136255352,
-0.0380158983,
0.0144968675,
0.1167678982,
0.0719464198,
-0.0208819993,
-0.0096714944,
0.0071975803,
-0.0158865061,
0.0431926474,
0.0014351257,
-0.0238428432,
-0.033047609,
-0.0004000724,
0.0164005812,
-0.0244904198,
-0.0120291216,
-0.0014167428,
-0.1105170175,
0.0041327365,
-0.0296510328,
0.0363082439,
-0.0309004299,
-0.0572142787,
-0.0299349166,
-0.0480118357,
-0.038094122,
-0.0210410822,
-0.0018304044,
0.0422127247,
0.0372958034,
-0.0634282008,
0.0013294255,
0.0259376969,
-0.0058725183,
-0.0016765696,
0.0215736181,
0.0401312448,
-0.0340026952,
-0.0320454799,
0.0171922278,
-0.0114620375,
-0.0081760464,
-0.0478520133,
0.0564769804,
-0.0162353013,
-0.0128415721,
-0.0366686583,
-0.0068083042,
-0.0314564593,
0.0383258462,
-0.0243986584,
0.0398871079,
-0.0325982794,
0.0067385109,
0.012961532,
0.0495469645,
0.0151165184,
0.0670228451,
-0.0058843726,
-0.035626106,
-0.0347871892,
-0.0433081053,
-0.0010212681,
-0.0780162737,
-0.0100503089,
-0.0185570698,
0.0284572523,
-0.0534948297,
-0.0731832013,
-0.0667959377,
0.0202821773,
0.0033855168,
-0.0237290226,
-0.0150483111,
0.0170115251,
-0.0066943667,
-0.0377570093,
-0.0136837177,
0.0727177039,
-0.0019562761,
-0.0256350096,
-0.0477485992,
0.0697171763,
0.0262936652,
-0.0321049467,
-0.0285452567,
-0.0049080164,
-0.0232608989,
0.0423084684,
0.0630399808,
-0.0002749065,
-0.0098022325,
-0.0096139666,
0.0073122298,
-0.0679552183,
0.1305177361,
-0.0521805063,
-0.0100679463,
0.0542705096,
0.0809718519,
0.040889848,
0.0020558543,
0.0167424083,
0.0170413461,
-0.0132475039,
-0.0205310378,
-0.0346879028,
-0.0165598523,
0.0384085029,
0.0132834855,
0.1034139693,
0.0194568243,
-0.0077266139,
0.0123315733,
0.0058454825,
-0.0478615202,
-0.0477197878,
-0.0215916373,
-0.024684824,
-0.0121774962,
0.0306880847,
-0.0702645779,
0.054705102,
-0.0370338969,
0.0174892917,
0.0151048824,
0.1059546396,
0.0557839684,
-0.0021397134,
-0.0006511565,
0.0043769595,
-0.0234110113,
-0.0433266871,
0.0431170277,
-0.0004387506,
-0.0015140793,
0.0165225733,
0.0089693191,
-0.0021279892,
-0.0237751529,
-0.0182452109,
-0.021238545,
0.0360461585,
0.0150937317,
-0.0158992559,
0.0026114862,
-0.0197900552,
0.0662707537,
-0.0347018167,
0.007206311,
0.0323246196,
0.0207272731,
0.0090530021,
-0.0120407743,
0.0552958213,
-0.000494754,
-0.0369613506,
-0.0477991402,
0.042380929,
0.0010103525,
0.0080570215,
0.0435336195,
-0.0415702015,
-0.0505088829,
-0.0319996439,
0.0234731007,
0.0006385435,
0.0254101008,
0.0194185004,
-0.0405896083,
-0.0252153669,
0.0657364354,
-0.0297464672,
0.0568966269,
-0.0224322528,
0.0450606719,
0.0612966269,
0.0254747476,
-0.0418987945,
-0.0574371479,
0.0251764357,
-0.0015877053,
-0.0114361979,
-0.0236332063,
-6.74113831e-33,
-0.0067863455,
-0.0209775046,
-0.0317814052,
0.0542331226,
0.0128960973,
-0.0218818672,
-0.0122348918,
0.0503946804,
0.0216221176,
0.0425397679,
0.0105330991,
0.0359793007,
0.0206441376,
0.0282381233,
0.0645717457,
-0.0057466729,
0.060907945,
-0.004599758,
0.0235385653,
-0.0241098274,
0.0405569002,
0.0307626408,
0.0546061695,
-0.0914861709,
0.0272826664,
0.0138159301,
-0.0059634228,
-0.0219213665,
0.0128345871,
0.0275361668,
0.0194728561,
0.0305081736,
0.0186122786,
-0.027776055,
0.0210206099,
0.0285068043,
-0.0145833176,
-0.036502663,
0.0079075377,
0.0481117293,
0.0012102446,
-0.0181350932,
0.0311072059,
0.0059646992,
-0.031351205,
0.0329720266,
0.0168395266,
-0.0064908336,
0.0255227219,
-0.0542059839,
-0.0295301471,
0.0425991006,
0.0036063346,
-0.0037433261,
0.0448694974,
0.0397851542,
0.0103457524,
0.0416650251,
-0.0609153621,
-0.0033709458,
-0.0786408558,
0.0496742055,
-0.0069305254,
-0.0347654261,
-0.0069660107,
0.0394210778,
0.0187453292,
-0.0050212373,
-0.0227371212,
0.0647992566,
-0.0122746136,
-0.0021573899,
0.0493821539,
0.0207099542,
0.051769115,
-0.0327532478,
-0.0247954745,
0.0126771228,
0.0755858421,
0.0421862192,
0.0296015739,
0.0086406646,
-0.0724488869,
-0.0147010498,
0.0218734853,
-0.0328557864,
-0.0154272979,
-0.0167880189,
0.0054401108,
-0.0325630233,
-0.0252951551,
0.0063442201,
0.0045333644,
-0.0351096764,
-0.0048279911,
0.0367589667,
-0.0461062007,
0.0450637527,
-0.0135973599,
-0.0116812643,
-0.0262413044,
0.0046107569,
-0.0165130738,
0.0184824765,
0.0218623709,
-0.0267662741,
0.063177906,
0.0066537331,
-0.0994372666,
-0.0004498882,
-0.0244120676,
0.0410712138,
-0.0101055084,
0.0753279328,
0.0134660406,
0.0383336768,
-0.0075949393,
0.063059926,
0.0212306865,
0.0594508946,
-0.0273702387,
-0.0104209566,
-0.0168175828,
-0.0020752368,
-0.0198121164,
-0.0535549,
0.0063769356,
-0.0014476961,
-0.0702075064,
-0.0378735289,
-0.0292355493,
0.0147497114,
2.985e-7,
0.051429119,
0.1002906635,
-0.00526798,
0.0159877744,
0.015497013,
0.0571521297,
0.0334351324,
-0.0044925371,
-0.0255396366,
-0.0164822992,
-0.0227540992,
-0.0077820984,
-0.0071248617,
0.0607447773,
-0.0935554951,
-0.0214684103,
-0.0040941737,
-0.0261894092,
-0.0067531005,
0.0380400158,
0.1219205931,
0.0880828798,
0.0415843837,
0.0149869984,
-0.0089228479,
0.0076109455,
0.0032868402,
-0.0074630259,
-0.0206982773,
0.0062788269,
-0.016811382,
-0.0310991202,
-0.0408583246,
0.0031194128,
-0.0190521982,
0.0019916615,
-0.0536048897,
0.0616051741,
0.026500782,
-0.0148008149,
0.0304058678,
0.0295956992,
-0.0129289571,
-0.0085943323,
0.0621097647,
-0.0568872392,
-0.0532807223,
-0.0489280112,
-0.0575723164,
0.0238372069,
0.019526504,
0.0156993847,
-0.039327383,
-0.0077900654,
-0.0172041245,
-0.0626102686,
-0.060451027,
-0.0493766889,
-0.0474034958,
0.0221406892,
0.0158768613,
-0.0037673339,
0.0062282286,
0.059747424,
0.036145594,
0.0257746615,
0.0027883588,
2.880985584e-34,
0.0675535351,
-0.0339541622,
0.0186826419,
-0.0163994599,
0.0484231636,
0.0547277518,
-0.075609386,
0.0182595495,
0.0270950645,
-0.0218566023,
0.0111712748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15130v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15130v1 | Assessing Good, Bad and Ugly Arguments Generated by ChatGPT: a New Dataset, its Methodology and Associated Tasks | 2024-06-21T13:27:10 | 2024-06-21T13:27:10 | Victor Hugo Nascimento Rocha, Igor Cataneo Silveira, Paulo Pirozelli, Denis Deratani Mauá, Fabio Gagliardi Cozman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The recent success of Large Language Models (LLMs) has sparked concerns about
their potential to spread misinformation. As a result, there is a pressing need
for tools to identify ``fake arguments'' generated by such models. To create
these tools, examples of texts generated by LLMs are needed. This paper
introduces a methodology to obtain good, bad and ugly arguments from
argumentative essays produced by ChatGPT, OpenAI's LLM. We then describe a
novel dataset containing a set of diverse arguments, ArGPT. We assess the
effectiveness of our dataset and establish baselines for several
argumentation-related tasks. Finally, we show that the artificially generated
data relates well to human argumentation and thus is useful as a tool to train
and test systems for the defined tasks. | [
0.0405962057,
0.0413768142,
0.0063976878,
0.0610726848,
-0.0434598438,
0.0214237235,
0.0118815163,
-0.0048927702,
0.0183962341,
-0.0715393424,
0.0073845261,
-0.0282051042,
0.002106138,
-0.019156849,
0.0055090059,
-0.0602218285,
0.0054924977,
0.0103337299,
0.0925206691,
-0.0103641963,
0.0186749101,
0.0124979047,
-0.0185220148,
0.062855944,
-0.0101713883,
-0.0755469278,
-0.0024074868,
-0.0079041198,
0.0374954455,
-0.0207167845,
0.0213381145,
0.0181137156,
-0.0242783818,
0.0406635292,
0.0000017131,
-0.0329512283,
0.0248066504,
-0.0139473816,
-0.0252292678,
0.0454332158,
0.1039341539,
0.0450483859,
-0.0331992842,
0.0392929055,
-0.0331181437,
0.0018574474,
0.0277566127,
0.1203467324,
0.0814988315,
0.1157203019,
-0.0015981027,
-0.0261552148,
0.022011634,
0.0048389514,
-0.0351221487,
0.0250220094,
0.0491186045,
0.0231254268,
-0.0187735502,
0.027390914,
0.0301462188,
0.002501125,
0.0190594252,
-0.0263900571,
-0.0468528382,
-0.0067464747,
-0.0708487406,
-0.0170823019,
0.0038505963,
0.050387539,
-0.0098089399,
-0.0608312711,
-0.0067680958,
-0.0385291688,
0.0188925862,
0.0078610862,
-0.0331671387,
0.0587895587,
-0.0395164862,
0.0600198358,
0.0666458085,
0.0286326967,
0.0237641446,
0.0344057456,
0.023887828,
0.014810686,
-0.0279921796,
-0.0464439169,
0.0529943258,
-0.0212681461,
-0.0339833088,
-0.0652685687,
-0.0075011253,
0.0160141271,
0.0265145749,
0.0482229143,
-0.021226706,
0.0037863788,
0.0560109019,
-0.1197943911,
0.024292957,
-0.0105431154,
-0.018760005,
0.0262092091,
-0.012149767,
0.0004836797,
-0.0233018361,
0.0144335246,
0.0157149397,
-0.0306810029,
-0.0542875305,
-0.0247032642,
-0.0288019646,
0.0115327155,
-0.0098840222,
-0.001477388,
-0.0204514693,
-0.0207854155,
-0.0662973523,
0.0121426024,
0.0490575768,
0.004384493,
0.0184742678,
-0.0197051521,
-0.0535614118,
0.0072713397,
-0.0355367139,
0.0286017731,
0.0139905857,
-0.0655385926,
-0.0037779917,
0.0583562627,
-0.0179581586,
-0.0192205571,
-0.0183732323,
0.0319856852,
0.0018336333,
0.0268241111,
-0.0509236641,
-0.0409492366,
-0.0364113152,
-0.0470515564,
0.0079564592,
-0.0651224479,
-0.0137533499,
-0.0461001433,
-0.0160953384,
-0.0639659017,
0.0143566206,
0.0484152213,
-0.0227509607,
0.0230776239,
-0.0101891439,
-0.0221377593,
0.0581840687,
0.0168772154,
-0.0417730361,
0.0560299717,
0.0167844184,
0.0262477621,
0.0511041544,
0.0193812922,
0.0217791088,
0.0154014966,
0.0380715095,
0.0071207341,
0.0466888063,
0.0086564776,
-0.0666021481,
0.0226207953,
-0.0306504015,
0.0529757589,
-0.024998283,
-0.0488881469,
0.043241255,
0.0195665583,
0.0180971082,
0.0136664156,
0.0271268338,
0.0077416124,
0.0480533652,
0.0154638495,
0.011548657,
-0.0229705423,
-0.011473598,
-0.0166941695,
-0.0026430588,
-0.0056379777,
-0.002705117,
-0.0574949868,
-0.0212847497,
-0.0290061422,
-0.0064544063,
-0.0281536728,
0.015172163,
0.0310666319,
-0.0275411326,
-0.0220190641,
0.044036869,
-0.0510287546,
-0.0659980178,
-0.0338692777,
0.0386626609,
-0.0233894736,
0.0117598148,
-0.0079307985,
0.0074701551,
-0.0244193189,
0.0729855075,
0.0790593475,
0.078218855,
-0.0300264619,
-0.0188835468,
-0.0338353626,
0.0104549574,
-0.0506478436,
0.0295309797,
-0.0022244835,
0.0159335434,
0.0040158667,
0.0293631051,
-0.0188210346,
-0.069406487,
0.0347360857,
-0.002353301,
-0.0012923341,
0.0146252168,
0.0139930965,
0.0524165295,
0.0230125934,
-0.025488114,
0.0074035362,
0.0364189409,
-0.024651587,
-0.0160566811,
0.0281545576,
-0.0164445173,
0.012781499,
0.0216614436,
-0.0622859187,
-0.0131507767,
-0.0027455864,
-0.0269461982,
-0.0015172721,
0.0176613014,
-0.0014404601,
0.0132947713,
-0.0133123314,
-0.0015233349,
-0.0029699816,
0.0164815355,
-0.0100030825,
0.0774002895,
0.0405667052,
0.0196977537,
0.0007567672,
0.0259848721,
0.0346073061,
-0.0503684133,
0.0008337285,
0.0087861689,
0.0096774586,
0.0142909354,
0.0270111132,
-0.0356453434,
-0.0290398803,
-0.0247944687,
-0.1064638197,
-0.0050622709,
-0.0142196678,
0.0310009532,
0.0295911469,
-0.0745952949,
0.0043871067,
0.0405403897,
-0.0352209732,
-0.0174854379,
-0.0138384867,
-0.0124018565,
0.0316449068,
-0.02881556,
0.0246042795,
-0.0288296062,
0.0193754099,
-0.030621592,
0.0414515436,
0.0078706183,
-0.0026712506,
-0.0403760485,
0.0275042187,
-0.0229797009,
0.0038143082,
-0.0238995422,
-0.0482430942,
0.0450132713,
0.0359277353,
0.0095741544,
0.0873400718,
0.0399142243,
0.0468244515,
0.0157782063,
0.0042761518,
-0.0379870236,
-0.023362264,
0.0003938867,
0.0475173704,
-0.025216572,
-0.0475054458,
0.025575459,
0.055222936,
0.0025644517,
0.0315529965,
-0.0692543164,
0.0535388887,
-0.0197836831,
0.0037004978,
0.031950634,
-0.0365622006,
-0.0305499956,
0.0276464764,
-0.0218455717,
0.0048559103,
0.0442820899,
-0.0567231625,
0.0260830484,
-0.0219817385,
-0.0291395485,
-0.0196478777,
0.0396278985,
-0.0158334337,
0.0044967011,
0.0409958065,
0.0452131778,
-0.0017781761,
-0.0375370272,
0.0484016985,
-0.0292077586,
0.0070438362,
-0.0384327881,
0.0085080862,
0.0020863344,
-0.0188967474,
-0.0462942235,
-0.0575633869,
-0.0344287604,
-0.0368744358,
-0.0011778792,
-0.0023027277,
-0.0079368996,
-0.0219325256,
-0.020700587,
-0.0062402999,
-0.0154473437,
0.0068792473,
0.009935556,
0.0053235712,
0.0194510836,
0.0096743284,
0.0395059213,
0.0098590162,
0.0540793389,
0.0804481357,
-0.0465874299,
-0.0077583934,
-0.0549082719,
-0.0583229586,
-0.0412409157,
-0.0174443051,
-0.0215981472,
-0.0172480475,
0.0428624824,
-0.0531089157,
-0.0016889333,
0.0658512339,
0.021438757,
0.0003173347,
-0.0052317865,
-0.0331137031,
0.0130891483,
-0.0159550048,
-0.0213258974,
-0.0790159404,
-0.0223152265,
-0.024790829,
0.0191232935,
-0.0830269903,
-0.0155671304,
-0.0087926714,
-0.1355949938,
0.0328423344,
0.0153537858,
0.015051825,
0.0141760176,
-0.0255656578,
-0.0182901639,
-0.0234796666,
-0.0050670542,
0.0055954624,
0.0081686713,
-0.0053512584,
0.0235517137,
-0.0203792565,
-0.0106923785,
0.0179011058,
-0.0082594426,
0.0872485787,
-0.0081415949,
0.0832188427,
0.008222376,
-0.0441731252,
0.0502253547,
-0.0189160779,
-0.042685017,
-0.0018180159,
0.0351458639,
0.0023960257,
-0.0063741477,
-0.0267727003,
0.0454302654,
-0.0107966792,
-0.0475033298,
0.0445325561,
0.0574454032,
-0.0257081073,
-0.0311051961,
-0.0026027046,
0.0397763513,
0.00754523,
0.0855762884,
0.0323256403,
0.0091634328,
-0.0310333576,
-0.0716906339,
-0.0139644556,
-0.0681455955,
-0.0323712267,
0.0450324453,
0.0050912476,
0.0312477108,
-0.0838109776,
-0.0600483231,
-0.0196825601,
0.0241854768,
0.0104423594,
-0.0029689753,
0.020428963,
0.0118014151,
-0.0004705676,
-0.0004261285,
-0.0296945833,
-0.0054145963,
-0.0148510095,
0.0155501608,
0.0023983829,
-0.0094237272,
-0.0093334196,
0.0183156207,
-0.0268204678,
-0.0800106227,
0.0045437682,
0.0473326743,
0.0274464376,
0.0278616864,
0.0021102994,
-0.0326783545,
0.0246662647,
0.0060949288,
0.0312957503,
-0.0121495211,
0.0554546304,
0.0037641304,
0.0324274562,
0.0155786695,
0.0015294729,
0.0284092985,
-0.0155177321,
0.0014496015,
-0.0609574094,
0.015984714,
0.0245658625,
0.0171152782,
0.0408769771,
0.0286076795,
-0.0481932871,
-0.029881712,
0.0224612094,
-0.0772543177,
-0.0180808343,
-0.0178306419,
0.0323651768,
-0.0042574424,
-0.0265952535,
-0.0087534869,
-0.0171998795,
-0.0599269904,
0.043882329,
0.004132844,
0.0187370721,
0.0086886808,
0.0429859124,
-0.021100631,
-0.0174395181,
-0.0463455431,
0.0475482941,
-0.0225399025,
0.0529763699,
-0.0005657024,
0.0563819371,
0.036609713,
0.0099417735,
0.0583886281,
0.0012044837,
-0.0303996745,
-0.039868705,
-0.0137256961,
-0.0022177531,
0.0237056725,
-0.0305466391,
0.0797582939,
-0.0346674696,
-0.0127593242,
-0.0064630359,
0.0297277234,
0.0046072383,
-0.0150724249,
0.0312737077,
0.0072869551,
-0.0568860956,
-0.0082248282,
0.0624479726,
-0.0318584554,
0.0282442495,
0.0376777947,
-0.0148320207,
-0.0362620614,
-0.0582514741,
-0.0182143953,
0.0010309562,
0.0201757345,
-0.0255440008,
-0.0476433858,
-0.0214679968,
-0.0615132749,
0.0337998196,
0.0164556913,
0.0008716805,
-0.0020458405,
0.035716027,
-0.0021618223,
0.0500262864,
-0.0607877709,
0.0129125575,
-0.0170528293,
-0.0078080022,
-0.007997185,
-5.557184074e-33,
0.0057478962,
-0.0448777117,
-0.0113993101,
0.0777791291,
0.0075945952,
-0.0119254161,
-0.0196086876,
0.0239074733,
-0.0360677578,
0.0794655383,
0.0251413304,
0.0216156729,
0.0137252063,
0.0063833632,
-0.0437210388,
-0.004045248,
0.0170684587,
-0.0008236044,
-0.0296932459,
-0.0038170363,
0.0552281179,
-0.0457812957,
0.0258695204,
-0.0764755532,
0.0685656816,
-0.0283369068,
-0.0335502215,
0.0007991208,
-0.0387669988,
0.0767008588,
0.0104309293,
0.0622857325,
0.021814758,
-0.0196078308,
0.0256056786,
0.0195324924,
-0.0224461611,
-0.0211753044,
0.0458852462,
-0.0349840038,
-0.0311804898,
-0.0581203774,
0.0261334293,
0.0178717133,
-0.0219010357,
0.0068844724,
0.0244471915,
-0.0433840007,
0.0054831598,
-0.0123050436,
-0.0669063628,
0.0457080789,
-0.0165756661,
-0.017213501,
-0.0277097654,
0.036375083,
-0.0051846988,
0.0602086,
-0.0574779026,
0.0095631443,
-0.0159266721,
-0.0070270756,
-0.0067171254,
-0.072493121,
0.0022041134,
0.0697795004,
-0.006739432,
0.0219117198,
-0.0461921096,
0.0077026458,
-0.0252508726,
0.0237006973,
0.080275692,
0.0856923312,
0.0213250611,
-0.0271682851,
-0.0710532516,
-0.0214712974,
0.0387355164,
0.0377983488,
0.0014442207,
-0.0379696786,
-0.0143114887,
0.00728655,
-0.0141718751,
-0.0779316202,
-0.0066938093,
-0.0346533358,
0.0084738564,
-0.0015664054,
-0.0114182699,
-0.0056983703,
-0.0011662034,
-0.0181322247,
0.0283462089,
0.0158543084,
-0.0409639999,
-0.001551143,
0.0081491675,
0.0047092205,
-0.0547576547,
-0.0064631766,
0.0267925952,
0.0179301649,
0.0745898038,
0.0002171028,
0.0580499656,
-0.0528963283,
-0.0470181294,
0.0024115073,
-0.0273934435,
0.0398639403,
-0.020222947,
0.0389680937,
0.0184381902,
0.0261862911,
0.0018836632,
0.0302020703,
0.0015796142,
-0.0111409901,
-0.051900804,
-0.0410480089,
-0.0132089844,
-0.0197239239,
-0.0433892198,
-0.0065129837,
0.0078097014,
0.0145230489,
0.0412832908,
-0.0692195222,
0.0093441419,
0.0004047609,
2.308e-7,
0.0424946435,
0.0702451691,
0.023356162,
0.0108686145,
0.0273696985,
0.0520484857,
-0.0246060919,
0.0012723301,
-0.0023684776,
-0.0399175286,
-0.0326080583,
-0.0020906553,
0.0775641352,
0.0608695224,
-0.0765595287,
-0.0456167571,
-0.0996344909,
-0.0439688005,
-0.0444477983,
0.0042081461,
0.0904042944,
0.0979644582,
0.0187284127,
-0.0002752472,
-0.0183825977,
-0.0030384331,
0.0741015077,
-0.0091987019,
-0.0248164125,
0.0038921733,
0.0729324594,
-0.0433784835,
-0.0024185665,
0.018366253,
-0.0039078626,
-0.011373125,
-0.0308966078,
0.058087714,
0.0039607529,
-0.0312585682,
-0.0029131004,
-0.0361935869,
0.0181260165,
-0.0714955702,
0.0484613329,
-0.0600022897,
-0.0426562317,
-0.0337283276,
-0.0358618386,
0.0103086103,
0.0244090483,
-0.007850728,
-0.0064320569,
0.0004457854,
-0.0077307206,
-0.0014078676,
0.0197677203,
-0.0502693132,
-0.0474913158,
0.0096918065,
-0.0224612914,
-0.0333365835,
0.0091168797,
-0.0142383166,
0.0410312079,
-0.0420606956,
0.0188957639,
1.631038475e-34,
0.0325282738,
-0.0296919029,
0.0104699638,
0.0071366266,
0.0560583584,
0.0264184456,
0.0206392687,
0.0081460336,
-0.0125123886,
-0.0183721725,
0.0014918115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15111v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15111v2 | Investigating the impact of 2D gesture representation on co-speech gesture generation | 2024-06-21T12:59:20 | 2024-06-24T08:19:00 | Teo Guichoux, Laure Soulier, Nicolas Obin, Catherine Pelachaud | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Co-speech gestures play a crucial role in the interactions between humans and
embodied conversational agents (ECA). Recent deep learning methods enable the
generation of realistic, natural co-speech gestures synchronized with speech,
but such approaches require large amounts of training data. "In-the-wild"
datasets, which compile videos from sources such as YouTube through human pose
detection models, offer a solution by providing 2D skeleton sequences that are
paired with speech. Concurrently, innovative lifting models have emerged,
capable of transforming these 2D pose sequences into their 3D counterparts,
leading to large and diverse datasets of 3D gestures. However, the derived 3D
pose estimation is essentially a pseudo-ground truth, with the actual ground
truth being the 2D motion data. This distinction raises questions about the
impact of gesture representation dimensionality on the quality of generated
motions, a topic that, to our knowledge, remains largely unexplored. In this
work, we evaluate the impact of the dimensionality of the training data, 2D or
3D joint coordinates, on the performance of a multimodal speech-to-gesture deep
generative model. We use a lifting model to convert 2D-generated sequences of
body pose to 3D. Then, we compare the sequence of gestures generated directly
in 3D to the gestures generated in 2D and lifted to 3D as post-processing. | [
-0.0163662154,
0.0814540088,
0.0054773195,
0.0483309403,
-0.0087216506,
0.0308109336,
0.0045430344,
0.0042546899,
-0.0185753852,
-0.0760010928,
-0.0660796314,
-0.0669214725,
0.0298488885,
0.0432780087,
0.0329487883,
-0.0656305328,
0.0108923204,
-0.0615873523,
-0.0392496586,
-0.0145974541,
0.0052880435,
0.018112598,
-0.0459586196,
0.0133441482,
-0.1018196493,
0.0102467882,
-0.0526120774,
0.0266489908,
-0.0079030991,
-0.0417298973,
-0.0193374716,
0.0042414158,
0.0809906125,
0.0347136483,
0.000001987,
0.019017309,
0.0361230336,
0.0143075474,
-0.0038994909,
0.0357386097,
-0.0082299747,
-0.022040464,
-0.0262722075,
0.002556659,
-0.0393621251,
-0.0145847499,
0.0026661223,
0.0381014645,
0.065246135,
0.0259170495,
-0.0061609079,
-0.0260869227,
0.01560291,
-0.0353926234,
0.0152709996,
0.0222420041,
-0.011201378,
0.0091439951,
0.0363440961,
0.0418746248,
-0.0529675335,
0.0029544055,
0.0202510916,
-0.0095421076,
-0.041473899,
0.017447032,
-0.0203548577,
-0.0445504785,
-0.0095092217,
0.0771168023,
0.0090678707,
0.0534433238,
0.0262511242,
-0.0001430166,
0.0481066555,
0.0062611229,
0.0056358385,
0.0363675654,
0.0212555584,
0.003248997,
-0.0547356606,
0.0314382277,
-0.0180088673,
-0.0751303285,
0.0417960733,
-0.0014027377,
0.014899849,
0.0420833454,
-0.0374265425,
-0.0145526566,
0.0231693089,
-0.0296235457,
0.024215905,
-0.0139295878,
0.0163620654,
-0.0212680418,
-0.0415239073,
-0.0101815993,
-0.0166028962,
-0.0005009644,
0.036077667,
0.0381152295,
-0.0191982109,
-0.0167070813,
-0.003562222,
0.0165309627,
-0.0436002798,
-0.0125835938,
-0.0081799254,
0.0164358839,
0.0325500965,
-0.0387947969,
-0.0252165888,
-0.0083179045,
-0.0590269528,
-0.0440185629,
-0.0016484656,
0.0012294524,
-0.0120662078,
-0.0368065014,
-0.0085858637,
0.1007665247,
0.0012480945,
0.0162441451,
0.0145752588,
0.0033683879,
0.0064553018,
0.0809410885,
-0.0004007687,
-0.0655212849,
-0.0338622592,
0.0078472653,
0.0459193215,
0.0075037954,
0.0093383286,
0.0547021441,
-0.0308870301,
-0.0347243957,
0.0697771609,
-0.0295031853,
-0.0428834222,
-0.0246079862,
0.0306996275,
-0.0499810167,
0.0258198287,
-0.0471120812,
-0.0172212757,
-0.0212740209,
0.0089718215,
-0.0464107692,
0.0237098895,
-0.004416334,
0.0132360067,
0.0230420008,
0.0635784417,
-0.005324617,
0.0095996698,
0.0003749223,
0.0760984942,
0.0049543614,
-0.033004351,
0.0089818053,
0.0045577567,
0.0423448756,
-0.0077584498,
0.0023871632,
0.0242866613,
-0.0583775342,
0.0122904889,
0.0792646483,
0.0645279586,
0.0073217507,
-0.0636952668,
-0.0319291763,
0.0256572533,
0.0825003609,
-0.0295189321,
-0.008645297,
0.0764683783,
-0.0219924413,
-0.007447903,
-0.0359231569,
-0.015077197,
0.0099181859,
0.0568628982,
-0.0440775342,
-0.0039397273,
0.0353403427,
-0.0554617979,
-0.0308497306,
0.0237321667,
-0.0291160569,
0.0265663248,
-0.0379765481,
0.0370843075,
0.0104262438,
-0.031036675,
-0.0196910426,
-0.0274665393,
-0.0528433062,
0.0011855962,
0.0304422211,
-0.0087030521,
-0.0088178115,
-0.0776473433,
0.0361729264,
-0.0362495705,
-0.004758996,
0.0350474343,
0.0277479365,
-0.0155033646,
-0.0054346477,
0.0910551548,
0.0119704194,
-0.038179718,
-0.033451438,
0.0601342581,
0.0460265726,
-0.008697791,
0.0145917153,
0.0074180812,
-0.0318949781,
0.0544315614,
0.0097053787,
-0.0766033158,
0.0540119037,
-0.0128251091,
0.0189203992,
0.031924434,
0.0293777194,
-0.022987796,
-0.0117246322,
0.0171803571,
-0.0426316075,
-0.002245663,
0.039498724,
-0.052902706,
-0.0190059729,
-0.0040217624,
-0.0369393155,
-0.003510047,
0.0089299101,
0.0031771897,
-0.0630452186,
0.0827142224,
-0.0235616397,
0.0089556109,
-0.0002076934,
-0.0338521563,
0.0663039535,
0.008285068,
0.0018280474,
0.0003022713,
-0.0147921881,
-0.0086783227,
0.0410651825,
-0.0058350582,
0.0244657416,
-0.0543226637,
0.0121199992,
0.018053323,
-0.017249139,
0.0064438442,
0.0277849678,
0.0011505316,
-0.0173012745,
0.0292105358,
-0.0440573767,
-0.0143163372,
0.0078175068,
0.0227229055,
-0.0243058689,
-0.000809932,
-0.0278658513,
-0.008907374,
-0.0670262352,
0.0024226282,
0.0315505564,
-0.0275648292,
0.0040220292,
-0.0077120964,
0.0090347379,
-0.0380955599,
0.0314829312,
0.0211213268,
0.0335199349,
0.0346824639,
-0.0379516706,
0.0280551165,
-0.0159910712,
-0.0059117507,
0.0449109189,
-0.0247111432,
-0.0184887201,
0.0486410409,
-0.0230649579,
-0.0044743242,
0.0191672929,
-0.0150599917,
0.0043021017,
0.0046561519,
0.0094691785,
-0.0588563792,
0.0091699092,
-0.0167240351,
0.0400958285,
-0.0491202064,
-0.0154849337,
0.0145929959,
0.0475651436,
0.0330025554,
0.0531619787,
-0.048497986,
-0.0420781747,
0.0593016334,
-0.0602177307,
0.0356807485,
0.009019508,
-0.0128144175,
-0.0050818417,
-0.0252631102,
-0.0218747687,
-0.0249305815,
-0.0316219255,
-0.0393869653,
0.072748743,
0.0335798897,
-0.0206589419,
0.0796519071,
0.0383443907,
0.0399050117,
-0.0267477036,
-0.0211923849,
-0.0115729738,
0.0525841154,
0.038427759,
-0.0101964464,
-0.0747082531,
-0.0519187339,
0.0069037364,
-0.0436517075,
-0.0315165296,
0.0162857696,
0.0233116057,
-0.0384550244,
0.0029129521,
-0.0435602181,
-0.0432517342,
0.0349698924,
-0.0174545608,
-0.0054828422,
0.0653477162,
0.0139127905,
0.0122230509,
-0.015688967,
-0.0103099653,
0.0004304311,
0.0798283368,
-0.0712376162,
-0.0022663311,
0.0019735028,
0.0485468656,
-0.01157453,
0.0341364332,
-0.0800304189,
0.0391550995,
0.0240067672,
0.0514688529,
-0.0532971993,
0.0142727233,
0.0312013738,
0.0055148574,
0.0188445151,
0.029043451,
-0.0012977998,
0.0211285315,
0.047896374,
0.0240224991,
0.0223111399,
-0.018052401,
-0.0512181222,
-0.0794339404,
-0.0630179346,
-0.0127048511,
-0.0184447989,
0.0553637967,
-0.0370562002,
0.0124960253,
-0.1129797474,
0.0564313792,
-0.0033941236,
0.0013797247,
-0.0522263758,
-0.0397525057,
0.0511248969,
-0.0000836288,
-0.0377638377,
-0.0065288218,
0.0019699282,
0.0431372114,
0.0563727282,
-0.0227460694,
-0.0654506087,
-0.0059446814,
-0.0117024463,
0.006349307,
0.0099730529,
0.0446172021,
0.0023983289,
-0.024091566,
0.0246706773,
-0.0197332427,
0.0292783435,
-0.0044505396,
0.0258103944,
-0.011400844,
0.0076620388,
0.0243382808,
0.1163083315,
-0.0617795922,
-0.0215892661,
-0.0316027664,
0.0331641026,
-0.0621473528,
-0.0168467332,
-0.0364546031,
-0.0039259228,
0.0041654278,
0.0247005206,
0.0035556108,
-0.0415767767,
-0.0284986347,
-0.0066416664,
0.0310425498,
0.0528605841,
-0.018939361,
-0.021303229,
0.0247040465,
-0.034554027,
-0.0626894385,
-0.0095282411,
0.0416484103,
0.0281250048,
-0.0470668562,
0.0143356733,
-0.0278468411,
0.0207352359,
-0.0247914232,
0.0260499567,
0.0337380432,
0.0508866571,
-0.0241027009,
-0.0072430419,
0.0302254688,
-0.0018125701,
-0.0005383958,
-0.0358557701,
-0.0489859842,
-0.03820052,
-0.0349263959,
0.0444859564,
0.0097875493,
0.0533226058,
0.0187329818,
0.0040744678,
0.0089463443,
0.0723361298,
-0.0279305149,
0.0448674262,
0.0396198854,
0.0056695947,
-0.0547986962,
0.0159550253,
-0.0243812893,
0.0039864788,
-0.0309811905,
-0.0112705091,
-0.0607679114,
-0.0615037121,
-0.025374867,
-0.0326394923,
0.0381044857,
-0.0225372855,
0.0357386619,
-0.0558493398,
-0.0291726682,
-0.0097386679,
0.0312135275,
-0.1340319216,
0.0084831156,
0.0457678661,
0.005487965,
-0.0024591149,
0.0408897363,
0.0138616953,
0.0288806614,
-0.0235136766,
0.0280480534,
0.0524275526,
0.008981715,
-0.0333513245,
0.0108237416,
0.0327503458,
0.0831113085,
-0.0748741254,
-0.0082764551,
-0.0117398445,
-0.0011938813,
0.0235208701,
0.0048445994,
0.0421577841,
0.0493629426,
-0.0186057575,
-0.0705049783,
-0.0345721953,
0.010390725,
0.0089607844,
-0.0017073744,
0.061693795,
-0.0493687354,
0.0048423456,
0.0147757819,
0.0972718298,
0.0117453542,
-0.0608618297,
0.0669604838,
-0.0248620417,
-0.0295099728,
0.0035840992,
0.0477104448,
-0.0102130948,
0.0299114734,
0.0138906091,
-0.0092906989,
-0.0006702816,
-0.0540046431,
0.0465439633,
-0.0279153474,
-0.0101622762,
0.0127488496,
0.0141647058,
-0.0275044255,
-0.0458669625,
0.0218138043,
0.0007708055,
-0.0305269863,
0.0842904598,
0.0083153509,
-0.0201044083,
0.0456333831,
-0.0140182888,
-0.0369920768,
-0.006699638,
-0.029678192,
-0.05048123,
-5.263973171e-33,
-0.0168559048,
0.0141385784,
0.00003592,
0.0101708071,
-0.0226560906,
-0.0124383792,
-0.0477796607,
0.0561125018,
0.0041879029,
0.0138314171,
0.0203679353,
0.0046762032,
-0.0090321777,
0.0163729098,
0.0166945662,
-0.0002039892,
0.0055273673,
-0.0433040746,
-0.0249228962,
0.0264251642,
0.0264541935,
0.0137916468,
0.0514733009,
-0.0558569022,
-0.0271080527,
-0.0179921817,
-0.0369033776,
-0.015061751,
0.0066806185,
0.0028128363,
-0.0415868796,
-0.0224378668,
0.0028403064,
0.0009380726,
0.0123893386,
0.0142462291,
-0.0583459809,
-0.0048216926,
-0.0464198478,
0.0169278309,
-0.0778462216,
0.040185377,
-0.0298924129,
0.0275227111,
-0.049046237,
-0.0104679633,
0.0254606921,
-0.0289507508,
0.0109929815,
-0.0666861534,
0.0108938748,
0.0353879184,
-0.0630946979,
-0.0616287626,
0.0145791145,
0.0843520015,
0.0060324199,
-0.0448126197,
0.0086409934,
0.0368913859,
-0.0091922749,
0.019085817,
0.0529802516,
-0.0139186857,
0.010177399,
0.066742368,
0.0101818098,
-0.0506731868,
0.0126857469,
0.0334377177,
0.0388097838,
0.0849660859,
-0.0165803283,
0.092017509,
0.0730121359,
0.0107135233,
-0.0180979706,
0.0789727718,
-0.0123530962,
0.0010437041,
-0.0400443226,
0.0070173824,
0.0481486097,
-0.0316324644,
-0.0376604237,
-0.0342061147,
0.0201956891,
-0.0027710132,
0.0028030341,
0.0229788106,
0.0342949517,
-0.01145487,
0.0693885237,
0.0167503096,
-0.0538842417,
0.0173867829,
-0.0344469696,
0.0335719213,
0.0224382561,
-0.0145687591,
0.0213109422,
-0.0357706062,
0.0345163867,
0.0179090351,
0.0442021787,
0.0140241859,
-0.0191209875,
0.0333308987,
0.0238826051,
-0.0398715511,
-0.0064091985,
0.0238420963,
-0.0036064964,
0.0361632854,
0.0575278252,
-0.0333642103,
-0.025058385,
0.0356770456,
-0.0652946532,
0.0561573915,
-0.0336798802,
-0.0009302086,
-0.0274312794,
0.0028401031,
-0.0451750606,
0.0032253924,
-0.025077248,
-0.0467382632,
0.0682129562,
-0.0735155568,
-0.0171830505,
0.0203835741,
2.7e-7,
0.0074832072,
-0.0430809632,
0.0260310527,
-0.014035685,
0.023149278,
0.0583683439,
0.0146281933,
0.0780067444,
-0.0017843846,
-0.0471775718,
0.0016844479,
0.0178828947,
0.0190562047,
0.0149201797,
-0.0255001001,
0.014036905,
-0.0246950705,
-0.0026329195,
-0.0200694352,
0.0036613364,
-0.0010219271,
0.023243241,
-0.0436362587,
-0.0157014616,
0.013443497,
0.0254930425,
0.0691686273,
-0.0691940114,
0.0345669501,
-0.0172808319,
0.0512147211,
-0.0078997007,
0.0067514749,
-0.0216126945,
-0.0238599628,
0.0103810886,
0.0582623407,
0.0263625327,
-0.0373190567,
-0.0048441994,
-0.0200992506,
0.0117433621,
-0.0458085723,
0.0413037129,
0.0376488976,
-0.0712550804,
-0.0260483772,
-0.0311130118,
-0.0414607711,
0.0198513176,
-0.0063042785,
0.0019891819,
0.0265688077,
0.02802114,
0.0194390211,
-0.068361558,
0.0118302936,
-0.0422829352,
-0.0295839421,
-0.049692858,
-0.0830490366,
-0.0022809112,
-0.0199826881,
-0.0259099677,
0.0055369842,
0.0168842226,
-0.0441327132,
1.686221277e-34,
-0.0154989492,
0.045087751,
0.0340449847,
-0.0216107592,
0.002404758,
-0.0157976132,
0.0469182432,
0.0474265367,
-0.007108042,
-0.0092277946,
-0.0278413445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15109v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15109v1 | Brain-Like Language Processing via a Shallow Untrained Multihead Attention Network | 2024-06-21T12:54:03 | 2024-06-21T12:54:03 | Badr AlKhamissi, Greta Tuckute, Antoine Bosselut, Martin Schrimpf | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have been shown to be effective models of the
human language system, with some models predicting most explainable variance of
brain activity in current datasets. Even in untrained models, the
representations induced by architectural priors can exhibit reasonable
alignment to brain data. In this work, we investigate the key architectural
components driving the surprising alignment of untrained models. To estimate
LLM-to-brain similarity, we first select language-selective units within an
LLM, similar to how neuroscientists identify the language network in the human
brain. We then benchmark the brain alignment of these LLM units across five
different brain recording datasets. By isolating critical components of the
Transformer architecture, we identify tokenization strategy and multihead
attention as the two major components driving brain alignment. A simple form of
recurrence further improves alignment. We further demonstrate this quantitative
brain alignment of our model by reproducing landmark studies in the language
neuroscience field, showing that localized model units -- just like language
voxels measured empirically in the human brain -- discriminate more reliably
between lexical than syntactic differences, and exhibit similar response
profiles under the same experimental conditions. Finally, we demonstrate the
utility of our model's representations for language modeling, achieving
improved sample and parameter efficiency over comparable architectures. Our
model's estimates of surprisal sets a new state-of-the-art in the behavioral
alignment to human reading times. Taken together, we propose a highly brain-
and behaviorally-aligned model that conceptualizes the human language system as
an untrained shallow feature encoder, with structural priors, combined with a
trained decoder to achieve efficient and performant language processing. | [
-0.0081354221,
0.0592559204,
-0.0201535877,
0.0253491886,
-0.0071633067,
0.0462922603,
0.0460219868,
-0.0130996248,
-0.0230719913,
0.002961325,
-0.0613786764,
-0.046600204,
0.0709956884,
0.022844797,
0.0509648621,
-0.0112189986,
0.0261990149,
-0.0200022068,
0.0106955711,
-0.003626246,
0.0199927278,
0.0121090785,
-0.0244099647,
0.0428771935,
0.0084554506,
-0.0414260514,
-0.0288273226,
-0.0109628038,
0.0004448961,
0.0080573075,
-0.0219752342,
0.0736089125,
0.0105510652,
0.0395563729,
0.0000019728,
-0.0242510922,
0.0207870509,
-0.0129567077,
0.0008262881,
0.0049686106,
0.0227727052,
-0.0350942947,
-0.0099320505,
-0.0290397294,
-0.0016988136,
-0.0276039522,
0.0774614438,
0.059426412,
0.0085454825,
0.0549823232,
-0.0210786033,
-0.0352834016,
0.0491110533,
-0.0389782116,
0.0002562441,
-0.0297170728,
0.022640897,
-0.0404740795,
-0.0374348983,
-0.0052151647,
-0.0710579902,
0.0278409999,
0.0068515926,
0.0318254307,
0.0349692777,
0.0573413186,
-0.0152226957,
-0.014381038,
-0.0153124863,
0.0686978698,
-0.0238071922,
-0.0573323667,
0.0190311689,
-0.0036356275,
-0.0250729118,
-0.0055365609,
-0.0315895043,
0.0185598601,
0.0121000865,
0.0377499126,
0.038868688,
-0.033481285,
0.0370610803,
-0.0186990518,
-0.0114782564,
0.0411716774,
0.0210193321,
-0.0328476503,
-0.0117398389,
0.0491112471,
-0.0060950909,
-0.0300826002,
0.0194334164,
-0.0137160784,
-0.0194563344,
-0.00532598,
-0.0442439653,
-0.0814662948,
-0.0092453668,
-0.0326815099,
0.0260252263,
0.0503736138,
-0.02385558,
0.0148018589,
-0.0415617898,
0.0719528571,
-0.0685537532,
0.064877972,
-0.0377554037,
-0.0178213567,
-0.0217944887,
-0.0102103408,
0.0170928389,
-0.0144171882,
-0.0145206749,
-0.045875892,
-0.0458147563,
0.009738626,
-0.0076000816,
-0.0527881905,
0.0133987125,
0.0212841816,
-0.0138668269,
0.0108316373,
-0.0037720497,
0.0307408087,
-0.0221476797,
0.0271602459,
0.0045221359,
-0.0434760042,
-0.0287641231,
0.0614267476,
-0.0056407554,
-0.0476965271,
-0.0207812954,
0.0516176149,
-0.0458505526,
-0.0105231097,
-0.015259888,
0.0121628661,
-0.0208532326,
0.0049722334,
0.029819157,
-0.0772219226,
0.0835557505,
0.040640492,
-0.0315906927,
-0.0706784576,
-0.0323067158,
-0.0050193286,
-0.0572887659,
0.0335419215,
-0.0201476831,
0.0302422494,
0.045454815,
-0.0207608398,
0.0112385759,
0.021972524,
0.0632288978,
-0.0094269132,
-0.0147717455,
-0.0273308419,
-0.0561861955,
0.0489066541,
0.0059024459,
-0.0333335549,
-0.0530414432,
-0.0355608091,
-0.0083701322,
0.0486572608,
0.0947448835,
0.0393827856,
-0.0227117278,
-0.0398692079,
0.0607914664,
0.093944177,
-0.0133467475,
0.0523460694,
0.0065343715,
0.0010208861,
-0.0154600888,
0.0087926295,
-0.0502436273,
0.0594523959,
0.0117508136,
0.0040251189,
0.0375143178,
-0.001336256,
-0.0304134488,
0.0050453981,
0.0173013527,
-0.0082471846,
0.0013506559,
0.0130281318,
0.0497824773,
-0.0223942213,
-0.0289804675,
0.0836093649,
0.0362018608,
-0.0029481959,
-0.000640469,
-0.0165199414,
0.0029137589,
0.0371912383,
-0.0043906788,
0.0044774776,
-0.0046019219,
0.0163641721,
-0.0060366578,
0.0840899795,
0.0263819601,
0.0338271484,
0.0310514569,
-0.0317598619,
-0.012803873,
0.0155459233,
-0.0037644908,
0.0118693113,
-0.0146736614,
-0.0113848103,
-0.0131831756,
-0.0310834106,
-0.0140075851,
0.0525422692,
-0.0484034233,
-0.0015956205,
-0.0318455026,
-0.0057809963,
0.0393296331,
-0.026499046,
-0.0086715417,
0.0294226669,
-0.0003310225,
-0.0154917976,
0.0283964146,
-0.0074591869,
-0.0466237403,
0.0083834613,
0.0228558294,
-0.0063671749,
-0.0258844364,
0.0637579411,
0.009076925,
-0.0407939218,
0.0048656822,
-0.0379192531,
0.0302029196,
-0.0216698609,
0.0288025327,
-0.0349105969,
0.0545491241,
-0.0522459373,
0.0254651271,
-0.0184912588,
0.0179086048,
-0.0023019053,
-0.0503468178,
0.0028233742,
-0.028430216,
-0.0399100073,
0.0191897936,
-0.0074763214,
-0.0216460284,
-0.013557368,
-0.0155868474,
-0.0261714645,
-0.0090154372,
-0.1050975919,
-0.0023478926,
0.0026250486,
0.0078517366,
0.037392918,
-0.0006414095,
0.0129855732,
0.0089135543,
-0.0502512008,
0.0245459694,
0.014399359,
0.0120605463,
0.014201425,
-0.051140707,
-0.0355381481,
-0.0413774997,
-0.0362765156,
-0.0465763323,
0.059590593,
-0.0213154349,
-0.0400370099,
-0.0811109692,
0.0345982239,
-0.0043881373,
0.0095535656,
0.0065298486,
-0.0115082394,
0.0544617325,
0.0096927322,
0.0504849628,
0.0968126655,
0.0308383983,
0.0001622079,
0.0710562319,
0.0047160159,
-0.0243246797,
-0.0246132724,
-0.0367771722,
0.0214730836,
-0.0763130486,
-0.0463218763,
-0.0059343576,
0.0990870073,
0.0594904125,
0.0275917724,
-0.0462508835,
-0.0019226938,
0.0266356692,
-0.0396277308,
-0.0220288616,
0.0117867664,
-0.0451220609,
0.0467247106,
-0.0496291183,
-0.0323953852,
0.063692376,
-0.0266129561,
0.0069595501,
0.0009808072,
0.0202124827,
-0.0122210328,
0.0214545839,
0.0408831425,
0.0280770324,
-0.0397548713,
-0.0375359617,
-0.053599488,
0.0279440582,
-0.0308463201,
-0.0241094492,
0.0621286221,
-0.0219764262,
-0.0039661555,
-0.0007164777,
0.0105305817,
-0.0271521378,
-0.0053902259,
-0.0261370521,
-0.004884968,
0.030291466,
0.006025359,
-0.0929884166,
-0.0157536454,
0.0493000709,
0.0709257349,
-0.0307846237,
0.0012168692,
-0.0281217638,
0.0423367359,
0.045108255,
0.0374450795,
0.0364919901,
-0.0441796556,
-0.0152879693,
0.0595336445,
0.0088001424,
0.058908131,
-0.0439007394,
0.0047669369,
0.0395910703,
-0.0194422081,
0.0153497001,
0.0234109797,
0.0537652634,
-0.0198709127,
-0.0244847573,
0.1324317753,
0.0177400634,
-0.0555411614,
0.0130787585,
-0.0160927754,
0.0492126606,
-0.0076037189,
0.0110685779,
-0.0048929709,
-0.0261727795,
0.0000220945,
0.0041819094,
0.022399744,
-0.0221640151,
0.0098463101,
-0.0566123016,
-0.028789347,
0.009072667,
-0.059183199,
-0.0047887173,
-0.0279721357,
0.0039987057,
-0.0112995841,
0.0377863683,
0.0103800548,
0.0195201151,
-0.0192039292,
0.0172767211,
-0.0088486485,
-0.0201404747,
0.0283114482,
-0.0342745185,
0.0813686475,
0.0485121459,
0.0170213785,
-0.0083983764,
-0.0280008987,
-0.0096108597,
0.0117188087,
0.0090980334,
0.0309186429,
0.0271356888,
0.0206108987,
-0.003748117,
-0.0297806226,
0.0288170632,
-0.0592900515,
-0.0298320632,
-0.0404256359,
0.0778995007,
-0.0058292807,
-0.0083582271,
-0.0112261688,
0.005562257,
-0.0292655099,
0.054181084,
0.0445062071,
-0.0792609379,
-0.0339575671,
0.008875588,
0.0153623391,
-0.0327680074,
-0.0749088004,
0.012479133,
0.0084581906,
-0.0127922734,
-0.0346499458,
0.0030617812,
-0.0118550807,
-0.0225531254,
0.031755358,
-0.0158056449,
0.062522471,
-0.0730262399,
-0.0387711562,
0.056615632,
-0.0023056467,
-0.0107188178,
-0.0912835151,
-0.0243396778,
-0.0094667794,
-0.0209924541,
-0.0220074728,
0.0540817268,
-0.100321047,
-0.0638626516,
0.0501173884,
-0.0198298283,
0.0137975728,
0.0326830633,
0.0183463767,
-0.0480058864,
0.0139360987,
0.0116514489,
-0.0366892293,
0.0591612235,
-0.0547173396,
-0.0414106622,
-0.0061735432,
0.011373708,
-0.0214296766,
0.028176574,
0.0538751259,
0.0170643516,
-0.0014721751,
-0.0043840678,
0.0047312989,
0.0015629025,
0.1050321236,
-0.0011591528,
0.0196216293,
-0.0332642347,
-0.0412382931,
0.0159383565,
0.0448651277,
-0.0057947487,
-0.0796491131,
0.0562833138,
0.0097336555,
-0.0152040748,
0.0023515979,
-0.004285709,
-0.0047235317,
-0.0178939793,
-0.0174326953,
-0.0581780374,
-0.015139061,
-0.0087567307,
0.0417973548,
0.0037366892,
0.022294974,
-0.0299614463,
0.029505996,
-0.0073845042,
0.038116321,
0.0102132121,
0.0237592179,
-0.0346228182,
0.0010528016,
-0.0455989502,
-0.0277102403,
0.0035415948,
-0.0321717598,
-0.0041324501,
-0.0489944331,
0.0713927075,
0.0107006337,
0.027081348,
-0.0452327654,
0.032599695,
-0.0336761177,
-0.006898182,
0.0104157785,
0.0185301676,
0.0042814319,
-0.0377302878,
0.0539841689,
0.0168941393,
-0.0442798734,
-0.0048546619,
-0.02696684,
-0.0216927845,
-0.0291125625,
0.0101367654,
0.0100677246,
-0.0534845069,
-0.023287449,
-0.0192444101,
-0.0448910035,
0.015838949,
-0.0155528262,
0.0439161286,
-0.0167047195,
0.014571052,
0.0344099402,
-0.0372415297,
-0.0203406028,
0.0019336073,
-0.0036215072,
-0.0173083041,
-0.0593557656,
-0.0593191683,
-6.233216018e-33,
-0.0216636118,
-0.0209667962,
-0.0003950817,
-0.0265502967,
-0.0293939486,
0.0053898478,
-0.0405226313,
0.0352833793,
-0.0144084385,
-0.0131990565,
-0.0035886697,
0.0144114392,
0.0119438646,
0.0399286039,
0.0227158833,
0.0221762042,
-0.000445274,
-0.0402340069,
-0.0192269273,
-0.0011744851,
0.0710111484,
0.0108352685,
0.0900943279,
-0.0535638891,
0.0008606947,
-0.014690496,
0.0308638718,
0.0038113268,
0.020918062,
0.0285348743,
-0.0465407521,
0.0515823588,
0.0421475656,
-0.0213667806,
-0.0151217114,
0.038847629,
-0.0592062548,
0.0023062031,
0.0402726829,
0.0293055307,
-0.0229331497,
-0.0245276708,
0.0849755704,
-0.0215059035,
-0.0088794231,
-0.0458330438,
0.0604248457,
-0.016286524,
-0.0174528603,
0.0441508181,
-0.0830575079,
-0.0135768447,
-0.0395852402,
0.028002657,
0.0134753771,
0.0165137034,
-0.0321941786,
0.0630092323,
-0.1046975628,
0.012943767,
-0.0076705134,
0.0516411066,
0.0663672388,
0.0285619572,
0.0478941612,
0.0886285156,
0.1021376327,
0.0192887764,
-0.0357127562,
0.0123239653,
0.0606734641,
0.0204035062,
0.0185306761,
-0.0027016343,
0.0634631887,
-0.0116235586,
-0.0596777014,
-0.0154493544,
-0.0191157833,
-0.0007917739,
0.0598807447,
-0.014717306,
-0.0129874544,
-0.0282650907,
-0.0191735793,
-0.0026224537,
-0.0502599962,
-0.0183798503,
0.0298046824,
-0.0492838733,
0.0388687365,
-0.0186610818,
0.0397308543,
-0.0238273665,
0.053982757,
0.0236524064,
-0.0094233761,
0.041283872,
0.0220626649,
0.0023681098,
-0.0498390496,
-0.0266125277,
0.0036137556,
-0.0022989823,
0.0524680912,
0.0134912441,
0.0062821456,
-0.0028123274,
-0.0277598016,
-0.0155738704,
-0.0299454108,
-0.0530893952,
0.0025786438,
0.013390786,
0.0296501834,
-0.0044690496,
-0.0216648374,
-0.0156611465,
-0.0187309608,
-0.0196534004,
-0.0229769256,
-0.0103801377,
-0.0150859877,
0.0429133736,
-0.0026576661,
0.0180748552,
-0.0293354876,
-0.0018966094,
0.0762054697,
-0.0645414069,
-0.0202794783,
0.0449528061,
2.771e-7,
0.0315262936,
0.0524389334,
0.0289643761,
0.0197960995,
0.0527692549,
0.0043954523,
0.0174415894,
0.0382784531,
0.0047805621,
-0.0607480966,
-0.0137103209,
0.0459199287,
0.03762196,
-0.0167265348,
-0.0651615337,
-0.0055042808,
-0.0719498545,
0.0673384368,
-0.0412901603,
0.011733762,
0.0132062435,
0.043523591,
-0.0117950393,
-0.0327493139,
0.0189851057,
0.0329169706,
0.0784928873,
-0.03826911,
0.016474463,
0.015902251,
-0.026181262,
-0.0436941087,
0.0156770851,
0.0382031575,
0.0184522755,
0.0122909741,
0.0195480231,
0.0323880985,
-0.023913322,
-0.0029527715,
0.0051985616,
-0.0082432246,
-0.0206293836,
-0.0371666662,
0.0303710699,
-0.0533605516,
-0.0668729842,
-0.0098974658,
-0.02839428,
0.0514796898,
0.013971868,
0.0039355648,
0.0221859552,
-0.003796485,
0.042379044,
-0.0098340185,
0.0012622307,
-0.0291846227,
-0.0507722013,
0.050079409,
-0.0855348259,
-0.0061615054,
-0.0550567694,
-0.0447114334,
0.0595612563,
-0.0460086912,
0.0085024275,
2.279715632e-34,
-0.0364166722,
0.0222008135,
0.0396621265,
0.0116238277,
0.0096799582,
-0.04695867,
0.0266394429,
-0.0041016275,
-0.0117037129,
-0.0754573122,
-0.0212944783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15085v1 | A Unified Framework for Input Feature Attribution Analysis | 2024-06-21T12:01:03 | 2024-06-21T12:01:03 | Jingyi Sun, Pepa Atanasova, Isabelle Augenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | Explaining the decision-making process of machine learning models is crucial
for ensuring their reliability and fairness. One popular explanation form
highlights key input features, such as i) tokens (e.g., Shapley Values and
Integrated Gradients), ii) interactions between tokens (e.g., Bivariate Shapley
and Attention-based methods), or iii) interactions between spans of the input
(e.g., Louvain Span Interactions). However, these explanation types have only
been studied in isolation, making it difficult to judge their respective
applicability. To bridge this gap, we propose a unified framework that
facilitates a direct comparison between highlight and interactive explanations
comprised of four diagnostic properties. Through extensive analysis across
these three types of input feature explanations--each utilizing three different
explanation techniques--across two datasets and two models, we reveal that each
explanation type excels in terms of different diagnostic properties. In our
experiments, highlight explanations are the most faithful to a model's
prediction, and interactive explanations provide better utility for learning to
simulate a model's predictions. These insights further highlight the need for
future research to develop combined methods that enhance all diagnostic
properties. | [
-0.0055036326,
0.0308238771,
-0.0158580132,
0.0264418125,
-0.0039072414,
0.0155466478,
0.0657400042,
-0.0189152341,
-0.0436334498,
-0.0128928246,
0.0191148967,
0.0086701959,
0.0193973724,
0.0585536249,
0.0444420315,
-0.0604559332,
0.0046967501,
0.0055075479,
0.0087772151,
-0.0061732265,
0.0284827892,
-0.0089603737,
0.0382518023,
0.0645051301,
-0.027971616,
-0.0117256502,
0.0057067173,
0.0112205455,
0.0185717307,
0.0257982723,
-0.0154171502,
0.0314572267,
-0.0196000319,
-0.0212989971,
0.0000021286,
-0.037139561,
0.0100573655,
0.0211889762,
-0.0419357717,
0.0304897111,
-0.0043290546,
-0.0108714662,
0.0644289553,
0.0179631449,
0.030404577,
0.0358323678,
0.059708856,
0.0737602189,
0.0146550154,
-0.0056821927,
-0.0073670396,
0.0173072889,
-0.0227509011,
-0.027827397,
0.030290788,
-0.0069090473,
-0.0042563989,
-0.0548518635,
-0.0806861147,
-0.0462355055,
-0.008917653,
0.0187498648,
0.0530470088,
-0.019379653,
0.0917909443,
0.0132161658,
-0.0019205569,
-0.0344890319,
-0.011739661,
0.0615255907,
-0.0270697419,
-0.0062626856,
-0.0024577696,
-0.0419999734,
0.0343741365,
0.0232220106,
-0.035705898,
-0.0414229184,
0.021032434,
-0.0027593491,
-0.0303868838,
0.0372138806,
0.0758809298,
0.010087586,
-0.011845313,
0.0139714619,
-0.0344820842,
-0.0134096714,
-0.0255974904,
0.0048900587,
-0.0187697466,
-0.0342215896,
0.0126006994,
0.0197036341,
-0.0157508738,
-0.035780862,
0.0255506188,
-0.0012283383,
0.0166131649,
0.0106196702,
0.0895614773,
-0.0147203384,
-0.0528366342,
0.0128242476,
-0.0310950726,
0.0669891462,
-0.0087563042,
0.0261121262,
-0.0164867137,
0.0218960475,
-0.0051058456,
-0.0224838424,
0.041344393,
-0.014301762,
0.0129524013,
0.0229616519,
-0.0003492313,
-0.0009154874,
-0.0663998723,
0.0107300077,
0.0061592157,
0.0478965379,
-0.0112399003,
0.0222665295,
-0.0345402136,
-0.0036246241,
-0.0806782916,
0.0187584199,
0.036679592,
-0.0460118279,
-0.0534843318,
0.0477429964,
-0.0331617445,
-0.0178900771,
0.0043049273,
0.0718994588,
0.0440337695,
0.0178865083,
0.0083151292,
-0.0620995387,
-0.004538036,
-0.0416176915,
-0.0098254746,
-0.0117813312,
-0.0048545958,
0.0264582448,
0.0053185471,
-0.0251413547,
-0.0341636688,
-0.0221938659,
-0.0321250111,
0.0782510191,
0.0366941653,
-0.0033597967,
-0.0254316479,
-0.0028861458,
-0.0488939509,
0.0216555577,
0.0397171527,
0.0503470786,
-0.0017561082,
-0.0389227197,
0.0641061962,
-0.0384976082,
0.065749824,
0.0011485647,
-0.0437325612,
0.0101071922,
-0.0509536043,
0.0231963005,
0.0585407279,
-0.000554946,
-0.0041160085,
-0.0059038778,
0.0493034981,
0.0324878879,
0.0381791815,
0.0390259102,
0.0276912786,
-0.0212132949,
-0.0316367745,
0.0257468149,
-0.0833604708,
0.0431501903,
-0.0133589543,
-0.0071818181,
-0.0168140903,
0.0075128158,
-0.0209891833,
-0.0720620975,
-0.0250534602,
0.0105339931,
0.0102239009,
0.0449749753,
0.0351005793,
-0.0132946391,
0.0179954004,
0.0346924663,
0.014874422,
-0.0133480504,
-0.0252049603,
-0.0870106965,
0.0281363633,
0.0535561591,
0.0005791135,
-0.0239454042,
0.0553998984,
-0.0477273278,
-0.0129423821,
-0.0259251501,
0.0394762568,
0.0013254519,
-0.0074924058,
-0.0194395669,
-0.0473746099,
-0.0556036793,
0.0329122953,
0.0373482555,
-0.0223327223,
-0.0381485596,
0.0160091259,
-0.0542297401,
-0.0603567213,
0.0214687623,
0.0356036201,
-0.019503776,
0.0191422105,
0.0189152732,
0.0382129028,
0.0068856799,
0.0171755776,
0.0147298798,
-0.0187597964,
0.0157263614,
-0.012757794,
0.0214354172,
-0.0028728417,
0.0346255861,
-0.0174009856,
-0.0350979641,
-0.0081056077,
0.0339855775,
-0.0417851768,
-0.0229195394,
0.0298946388,
-0.0222186111,
-0.0175860934,
-0.0196889434,
0.0121954838,
-0.0263564289,
0.0250429139,
-0.0225062296,
0.039485909,
-0.0274030901,
-0.0090117948,
-0.010814731,
-0.0289455894,
0.0349083543,
-0.0255566016,
0.0156360436,
0.0030837716,
-0.0304960404,
-0.0085175075,
-0.0023406073,
-0.0465560593,
-0.0139152193,
0.0421355106,
-0.0135307852,
-0.0238687675,
-0.0352584459,
-0.0172163248,
-0.0039949063,
-0.0104757147,
0.0111490656,
-0.0246407557,
-0.0123948343,
-0.0292270128,
-0.0199023131,
0.0108402167,
0.0279408693,
0.0080172671,
-0.0186095275,
-0.0271403231,
-0.0287538078,
-0.0271540601,
0.074765712,
0.0627752244,
0.0520146862,
-0.0380471982,
-0.0291393716,
0.010679964,
-0.0442890637,
-0.0153872287,
-0.0247520953,
-0.0010920621,
0.0174444076,
-0.0459116735,
0.0864365548,
-0.0007263473,
0.1115396395,
0.057209719,
0.0372193679,
-0.038036067,
-0.0093199452,
-0.0309624728,
0.0235619191,
-0.002164294,
-0.0423960984,
-0.010319246,
0.0462262891,
-0.0098854527,
-0.0055078138,
-0.0450692661,
0.0456689596,
0.0219345633,
-0.043995522,
-0.0391838141,
-0.0172922909,
-0.0045907609,
0.0416855887,
-0.044256337,
-0.1148250178,
0.0789323449,
-0.0171067975,
0.0331861116,
0.0201175418,
-0.0069535258,
-0.0193305463,
0.0249189343,
-0.0311141592,
0.0022950009,
-0.0085369665,
-0.0214848388,
-0.007853223,
-0.0148305465,
0.0962197334,
-0.0063814376,
0.0149784088,
-0.0172611643,
-0.0404579453,
0.0115894796,
-0.0175080132,
-0.0196755473,
-0.0625029653,
0.0020246108,
0.0248837322,
0.0113970367,
-0.0527495705,
-0.0128926281,
0.0182030834,
0.0127601065,
-0.0170436837,
-0.027267877,
-0.0011082094,
0.023150079,
-0.0464403592,
-0.0239513814,
0.0542501584,
0.0397870317,
-0.0550090671,
-0.0115126995,
-0.0159709137,
0.0378294811,
0.0384560302,
-0.0327958241,
0.0272893049,
-0.0099040503,
-0.0187904388,
0.0141408369,
0.0189288501,
0.0455883481,
-0.0766810849,
0.0324849524,
0.0485354513,
0.0122883264,
-0.0643936917,
0.0314069241,
-0.0276029706,
0.0390520133,
0.0109738633,
-0.0155816805,
-0.0408252068,
-0.0234659761,
-0.0035541805,
0.0683548972,
-0.0178482607,
0.0059650643,
0.0477093086,
-0.0255340859,
0.0567817166,
-0.0038808456,
-0.0188426431,
-0.0517114736,
-0.0411862656,
-0.0139132198,
-0.0586571619,
0.0019255824,
-0.0362623557,
0.0130902305,
0.0367318206,
0.0397851281,
-0.0083332816,
-0.0353972241,
0.0153183211,
-0.0396177769,
0.0070726927,
0.0953685269,
0.007235446,
-0.0159038492,
-0.0096799908,
-0.0324677303,
0.0225950405,
0.0547362566,
-0.0121810697,
0.0973409042,
0.0094723832,
-0.0080654668,
-0.0555042699,
0.0665864572,
0.0165641308,
-0.0032712719,
-0.0244062301,
0.0505523011,
-0.0094038583,
-0.0401704721,
-0.0344045535,
-0.0460988767,
0.0232998151,
0.0773930103,
0.0757493973,
-0.0192912892,
-0.0811618119,
-0.041873049,
-0.0302112848,
-0.0154164322,
-0.0671598762,
0.0335263945,
0.0436919928,
-0.0783618912,
-0.0073349369,
-0.0416007377,
-0.0003683412,
-0.0122320373,
0.0041352808,
-0.0261971746,
-0.058730524,
-0.0233483668,
-0.0423228331,
0.0917546749,
0.0587591529,
0.024061989,
0.0196621921,
-0.0068703769,
-0.0093991458,
-0.0635039657,
-0.0396191068,
0.0206485093,
-0.005252284,
-0.0037196558,
0.0048793852,
0.0322616249,
0.0268104896,
0.0596114807,
-0.0523816235,
-0.0732095167,
0.0694742203,
0.026211055,
0.0104564251,
-0.0184780024,
0.049603235,
-0.0523738153,
0.0042837267,
0.0218054708,
-0.0019895888,
-0.020950418,
0.0144049628,
-0.0215283856,
-0.0230034254,
0.0185862556,
0.0093385866,
-0.0086269611,
0.0964968279,
-0.0273184143,
-0.0620216876,
0.0071143904,
0.0076136119,
0.0375528224,
-0.0114576779,
-0.0285078287,
0.0056553865,
0.0210163947,
-0.0030881725,
0.0072495737,
-0.0153399864,
-0.0109370099,
-0.0236616507,
-0.0684703141,
0.0702966973,
-0.0138616739,
0.0067675556,
-0.0016962634,
0.042605672,
-0.0103791337,
0.0189068895,
-0.0107102655,
0.0211932883,
0.0533414781,
0.0310109537,
0.0131140919,
0.0266329125,
-0.0052867234,
0.0081029702,
-0.0769297481,
-0.0347337499,
-0.0175449513,
-0.0226175189,
-0.0039213519,
-0.0362395942,
0.034713164,
0.0082463752,
-0.0084410664,
-0.0048972862,
0.0629459843,
0.0188089274,
-0.0077188145,
0.0126765864,
0.0245183334,
-0.0392630622,
-0.0616601929,
0.0445280261,
0.0239486042,
0.0117787626,
-0.0789057985,
-0.0393092632,
0.011139296,
-0.0314536579,
0.0507360883,
0.0209085029,
-0.0092961174,
-0.0021109662,
-0.0917470828,
-0.0672742203,
-0.0391989127,
-0.0075949915,
0.0266036429,
-0.0254182257,
-0.0110059977,
0.0789922774,
-0.0265320931,
-0.0434228517,
-0.0207356308,
-0.0045613763,
-0.0330259055,
-0.0008073365,
-0.029499134,
-6.275361898e-33,
0.0249538738,
-0.0594954453,
-0.0344799459,
-0.0008658458,
0.0072955587,
-0.0015618656,
-0.032952264,
-0.0152288191,
-0.0225523021,
0.04931283,
0.0122431731,
0.0446340553,
-0.000298349,
-0.0130389631,
0.037761081,
-0.0628750771,
0.0365442522,
0.0358821303,
-0.0286440756,
0.048501499,
0.0234740097,
0.0009489322,
0.0319697,
-0.0820579305,
0.0605154149,
0.0014184921,
-0.0422981791,
-0.0153770242,
-0.0677560195,
0.0643476844,
-0.0094026951,
0.0380258076,
0.0070635262,
-0.032571584,
0.0013261064,
0.031040052,
-0.0231340434,
-0.0065664095,
0.014255031,
0.0123306569,
-0.0478752516,
-0.0608333163,
0.0461318381,
0.0325437151,
0.0012552497,
-0.0703574046,
0.0577428117,
-0.0011558662,
-0.0046958686,
-0.0050638397,
-0.0077826348,
0.0193556007,
-0.0674125478,
-0.0076688691,
0.0234235972,
0.0382485092,
-0.000416005,
0.0179451276,
-0.0123837562,
-0.0034043731,
0.0235456526,
-0.0347462259,
0.078908205,
0.0413484201,
0.0045713326,
0.0468785353,
0.0181606691,
-0.0275575612,
-0.0578055456,
-0.0284511019,
0.001019308,
0.0742463022,
0.1153902411,
0.0403999723,
0.0414772928,
0.0228556097,
-0.063626267,
0.0244443379,
-0.0143795768,
0.0430736169,
0.0301052053,
-0.007410964,
-0.0547744334,
-0.0184325874,
-0.0604905151,
-0.0626934841,
-0.0421455763,
-0.0490583703,
0.0396662131,
-0.0244623292,
-0.0598602854,
0.0568423383,
0.0036613045,
-0.0234022383,
0.0052844407,
-0.0009732241,
0.017537294,
0.0271302778,
0.0304066837,
-0.0403501168,
0.0073981993,
0.0130913705,
-0.0097206216,
-0.0068807672,
0.0766733289,
0.0238852669,
0.0456214137,
0.0029001574,
0.0167107917,
-0.0166043323,
-0.0401413105,
-0.0214987807,
-0.0418746471,
-0.0096397707,
0.0113194538,
0.0069684861,
-0.0305158794,
0.0014679636,
-0.0195052549,
0.0687076077,
-0.0457975194,
0.0052299565,
-0.0502226055,
0.0317775719,
-0.0227981117,
-0.0275468156,
-0.0302094929,
-0.0565876067,
0.0570964701,
-0.0357959904,
-0.0349900462,
-0.0106212813,
2.729e-7,
0.0311332159,
0.0099933445,
0.0254745502,
0.0031924983,
0.0132038994,
0.0503409505,
0.0032311927,
0.0222157463,
0.0168171246,
-0.0357898399,
0.0207264666,
0.033140894,
0.0604180694,
0.0001126319,
0.0086236969,
-0.0301374663,
-0.0314672217,
0.0044118054,
-0.0257599913,
0.018890053,
0.0283345692,
0.0151056638,
0.0253597125,
0.0096568614,
0.0608029887,
0.0079626655,
0.0211037509,
-0.0561843403,
0.0459298976,
0.0011670138,
0.0564188436,
-0.0276617631,
0.0287768077,
0.0436123684,
-0.031610813,
-0.0051944847,
-0.0210307352,
0.0417053439,
-0.0201937687,
-0.0476890728,
-0.0723806173,
-0.020795323,
0.0678540915,
-0.091820769,
0.052514635,
0.0022984287,
-0.0384807102,
-0.0301371552,
0.0061133453,
-0.0137937777,
0.0373727828,
-0.001993014,
0.0364280418,
0.0145342369,
-0.029421391,
-0.0116949631,
0.0106815426,
-0.0773473382,
-0.0651702136,
-0.0005651757,
-0.0237786677,
-0.0128500359,
-0.0351693481,
-0.0131379003,
0.0773607865,
-0.0429261401,
-0.0360579267,
2.75362743e-34,
0.0303614177,
0.033660274,
0.028501926,
0.0347426087,
0.032948453,
0.0224078614,
-0.0191333983,
-0.0015364179,
0.0805059001,
-0.0211777594,
-0.0159357898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15066v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15066v1 | Cross-lingual paraphrase identification | 2024-06-21T11:37:24 | 2024-06-21T11:37:24 | Inessa Fedorova, Aleksei Musatow | cs.CL | cs.CL | The paraphrase identification task involves measuring semantic similarity
between two short sentences. It is a tricky task, and multilingual paraphrase
identification is even more challenging. In this work, we train a bi-encoder
model in a contrastive manner to detect hard paraphrases across multiple
languages. This approach allows us to use model-produced embeddings for various
tasks, such as semantic search. We evaluate our model on downstream tasks and
also assess embedding space quality. Our performance is comparable to
state-of-the-art cross-encoders, with only a minimal relative drop of 7-10% on
the chosen dataset, while keeping decent quality of embeddings. | [
0.0211522523,
0.0272856131,
-0.0078875627,
0.0859625861,
-0.0331068039,
0.0091249757,
-0.008519955,
-0.0081418827,
-0.024004994,
-0.0164101999,
-0.0241858661,
-0.0030103717,
-0.012015406,
-0.0439215116,
0.0176690649,
-0.0423338227,
0.0358590484,
0.0211369377,
-0.0047151502,
-0.0108140297,
-0.0133451587,
0.0331882685,
0.0180357844,
0.0634308755,
0.0570623726,
-0.0150354812,
0.032640826,
0.0159820896,
0.0478407182,
-0.00763625,
0.0117846392,
-0.0273820926,
0.0475015789,
0.0452324003,
0.0000015954,
-0.0172960516,
-0.0230596289,
-0.0177335124,
-0.0075175208,
0.0324625745,
0.0436529443,
-0.0610039793,
0.0313250944,
-0.0100602312,
-0.0014080328,
-0.0270544142,
0.0330642015,
0.0165220145,
0.0585298054,
0.0073439945,
-0.0144064967,
-0.0731738135,
-0.0054846834,
-0.0168186184,
-0.0096999649,
-0.0096000144,
-0.004628655,
-0.0081253834,
-0.0257063415,
-0.001417149,
-0.0339950584,
0.0739314854,
0.0121825049,
0.0655752569,
-0.0207096711,
0.0051660668,
0.0000230362,
-0.0132323187,
0.0065479223,
0.0693691894,
-0.0714446977,
-0.019919984,
-0.0155247515,
-0.0179848913,
-0.0140903872,
0.036283236,
-0.0340359211,
0.011289889,
0.0132289398,
0.0329368375,
0.0048235469,
0.0276965611,
0.0187240858,
-0.0005766366,
-0.0006794253,
-0.00536827,
0.0440588482,
-0.0207536742,
-0.02811924,
0.0206368957,
-0.0249622334,
0.0497938246,
0.0052717514,
-0.0315524898,
0.0025181901,
-0.0084066,
-0.0446567945,
-0.0604575947,
0.0299467407,
-0.0585840642,
0.0424753949,
0.0234349128,
-0.0238319654,
0.0478066579,
-0.0841334313,
0.0496145152,
-0.0525075495,
0.0817643255,
-0.0338778123,
-0.0698328689,
-0.0256842058,
0.0108587565,
-0.0407466665,
0.0024057429,
-0.0055202269,
-0.0474592336,
-0.0332816504,
-0.024713302,
0.0056799017,
0.0297382548,
0.0147363069,
0.0045282021,
-0.0210169666,
0.0200550724,
0.0100230239,
0.0286050681,
-0.0386891812,
0.0206571575,
-0.032640662,
-0.0567041747,
-0.0463224165,
0.03694975,
0.0488406345,
-0.0759074092,
0.0282300916,
0.0430186875,
0.0019128701,
-0.0390603691,
-0.0208844636,
-0.023118129,
-0.0046069324,
-0.0415947735,
0.0098940358,
-0.0524275638,
0.0769758448,
-0.0175048634,
0.0171922781,
-0.0406727083,
0.0047536334,
0.0155572183,
-0.0338338129,
0.0699492693,
0.0222914759,
-0.0413201265,
-0.0141615141,
-0.0099513577,
0.0031609677,
0.0491877608,
0.0261760429,
0.0035205001,
0.0886350125,
0.0083758729,
-0.0308315977,
-0.0050486415,
0.0172558911,
0.0127660269,
-0.0171870068,
0.0291565061,
0.0431331806,
0.0373185985,
0.0404397622,
0.0317346826,
-0.0403898545,
-0.0560146458,
0.0375601649,
0.0436184593,
-0.0068339189,
0.0439539924,
0.0957217664,
0.0337815918,
-0.0384011045,
0.0207330082,
0.0239748377,
0.0378371626,
0.0195120946,
0.0347912461,
0.0430498421,
0.0565533154,
-0.035524562,
0.0003990724,
-0.0017200881,
-0.0236599147,
0.0124806473,
-0.0085413111,
0.0247575659,
-0.0038661943,
-0.0547639653,
0.0825640783,
-0.0076892851,
-0.0692450255,
-0.0055822525,
-0.0053626783,
-0.0054894965,
0.0651276633,
0.0314036757,
0.0289099142,
0.0232467391,
-0.0212894417,
0.0027358904,
0.0248628091,
0.0401121005,
0.006936694,
0.0801449195,
-0.0503878258,
-0.0322015248,
-0.0703115314,
0.0161668584,
0.0032276935,
0.0037259958,
0.0435226969,
0.0473491289,
-0.0294464789,
-0.0235340595,
0.0256499592,
-0.0453255475,
-0.0000074492,
-0.0046554902,
0.0443083346,
0.0028097001,
0.0135737462,
-0.0085741449,
0.009641028,
0.0232962649,
-0.0716798082,
0.0005448019,
0.0419365726,
0.007776639,
-0.0808527693,
0.0151604787,
-0.091400288,
-0.0074337847,
0.0519094095,
-0.0192858391,
-0.0170413684,
0.0353000611,
-0.0661312118,
0.0398403518,
-0.0567753091,
-0.0024190436,
-0.0708686709,
0.0443876088,
0.0064934082,
0.04416449,
0.0017505874,
0.0334442481,
-0.0004666267,
-0.0355188176,
0.0772475824,
0.0011209225,
-0.0576337688,
-0.0041790083,
0.0478819087,
-0.0021315163,
0.0230091959,
-0.0023955014,
-0.0185115226,
-0.0120249735,
-0.0507315248,
0.0108227646,
-0.0184419658,
-0.0142702712,
0.0304579157,
0.0155118266,
0.00454192,
-0.0302011967,
0.0095541533,
-0.000875418,
0.0041705859,
0.0235138871,
0.0466854721,
0.0199984219,
-0.0257822499,
-0.0428300351,
0.0040504057,
0.0048315991,
0.0577970631,
-0.0234307051,
0.0063928613,
-0.0113176918,
0.0063477955,
-0.0348703265,
-0.0159574188,
0.0081266891,
-0.0448123775,
-0.0131126521,
0.0032027934,
0.0090538906,
0.0746336207,
-0.0163489208,
-0.0179153904,
0.0709040835,
0.0216972977,
-0.0539391153,
-0.0025003704,
0.0121830842,
-0.0321682319,
0.0028130517,
-0.036569383,
-0.0169992093,
0.040326491,
0.0154620893,
-0.0102527421,
-0.0673573241,
-0.0014216114,
0.0311555993,
0.0156355947,
-0.0122047067,
0.0081419088,
0.0059285159,
0.02203013,
-0.0337236151,
-0.0100302529,
0.0833647028,
-0.0433524214,
-0.0167973675,
-0.0487016812,
-0.0354378261,
-0.0358850956,
0.0242036078,
-0.0416057259,
0.0396525487,
-0.0031314006,
0.0122219995,
-0.0375286229,
-0.0161236003,
0.0451818109,
-0.0154210953,
0.0165047627,
-0.0030579185,
-0.0149278743,
-0.0058202557,
-0.0467548631,
-0.0093829064,
-0.0595195182,
-0.0350563973,
-0.0030600368,
-0.0069476408,
-0.0034992029,
-0.0391045175,
-0.0250359736,
0.0149882967,
0.0304261092,
-0.0118473899,
0.0015776652,
-0.029642107,
0.0469389074,
0.0676515326,
0.0181224272,
0.005263946,
-0.0469979011,
0.0046318136,
-0.0053487616,
-0.0026753289,
0.0113796666,
-0.0244945176,
-0.0303537585,
-0.0003141273,
0.0057396889,
-0.0200987589,
-0.0442888513,
0.0263775643,
-0.0162174255,
-0.0263893232,
0.0677495897,
-0.0091703944,
-0.0520781837,
-0.0092454897,
-0.0562261082,
0.0275798924,
0.0244700275,
-0.0010317309,
-0.0335734151,
-0.0679383874,
-0.0267939456,
-0.0275097527,
0.0327149332,
0.0076445821,
-0.011297917,
-0.0813833848,
-0.0070463945,
0.0032050214,
-0.0142464982,
-0.0971082225,
-0.006060624,
-0.0060827043,
-0.0051883766,
0.0144339763,
-0.0361314863,
-0.0188012104,
0.0082268072,
-0.0370674431,
0.027416572,
-0.0531435497,
0.0066312659,
-0.0929054767,
-0.0321677551,
0.0142494459,
0.0558538213,
0.017882036,
-0.0478915349,
-0.0258928332,
-0.0783227012,
-0.0403310508,
0.006384552,
0.0575628616,
-0.0300930217,
-0.0149983438,
0.0279523749,
-0.0186876412,
-0.0377582274,
0.0306012034,
0.0352382958,
0.0789690688,
0.0266462062,
-0.0005270707,
-0.0130311595,
0.0271305051,
-0.0101455785,
0.0862704292,
0.046814505,
0.0001857263,
-0.0223232303,
0.0026456721,
-0.0051137647,
-0.0622600988,
-0.0540882461,
-0.0008757124,
-0.0090505136,
0.0480242521,
-0.0398250483,
-0.0339631364,
-0.0092337495,
0.008847625,
-0.009449427,
0.0427166931,
-0.0426476523,
0.0045087347,
-0.0601995699,
0.0018487053,
-0.0552086681,
0.0325177796,
0.0426678658,
0.0361426771,
0.0476844609,
0.0069021257,
-0.0284605194,
0.0169105381,
-0.078170225,
-0.0236838609,
-0.0550390743,
0.0161624253,
0.007019395,
0.0479668193,
-0.0041828407,
0.0394875444,
0.0352530032,
-0.0209741089,
-0.053290084,
0.0226772595,
0.0431589931,
0.0093031367,
0.0034073403,
0.0642774776,
-0.0290599763,
-0.0548733436,
0.0145476703,
0.0382337943,
-0.001725796,
-0.0551224686,
0.0186520293,
-0.0231488012,
0.0199784059,
-0.0086745368,
0.0058399485,
-0.0194613449,
0.019785149,
-0.0063339001,
0.0038709666,
-0.0335148424,
0.000934121,
0.0478752106,
-0.0134615274,
-0.0027036206,
0.0412519388,
0.0149943102,
0.0122542381,
-0.0303197224,
0.0062519307,
0.0051677753,
0.0209212713,
-0.0478045158,
0.0228881724,
-0.0330698006,
-0.0108289374,
-0.0349241607,
0.0092146499,
-0.0280161276,
0.010346612,
0.0014506544,
-0.0386800058,
-0.0289226044,
0.0429240726,
-0.030479433,
-0.0294569228,
0.0088931154,
0.0005500509,
0.0791216716,
-0.0431016423,
0.0821042806,
0.0167469215,
-0.0352747664,
0.0066403891,
0.050916072,
-0.0477090031,
-0.0037595695,
0.0097909877,
-0.018400114,
-0.0055427351,
-0.0047433814,
0.065412052,
0.0290872678,
0.0454789363,
-0.0310457945,
-0.0253495798,
-0.0261068642,
-0.0373554751,
0.0386733301,
0.0170856882,
0.0037867443,
0.0146172484,
-0.0139931682,
-0.0446751118,
-0.0090816673,
0.0111514749,
-0.0359724946,
0.0305904076,
0.0446698666,
0.0700060129,
-0.0011830139,
-0.0331618041,
-0.0452434085,
0.0236998815,
0.0153981987,
-0.0109336106,
-0.0457720272,
-5.163166449e-33,
-0.0028431104,
0.0428854041,
-0.0301744789,
-0.0460849404,
-0.008254461,
-0.0184827615,
-0.0300078634,
-0.0305564553,
-0.0713560209,
0.017195249,
0.0451712497,
0.0206842758,
0.0146305654,
0.0079136258,
0.0358648971,
-0.0404406227,
0.0533015169,
0.0118183931,
-0.0017539918,
-0.0116119478,
0.04158663,
0.0215597749,
0.0682216138,
-0.0559028164,
-0.0135813719,
-0.0118056824,
0.0207745153,
-0.0101157241,
0.0418765061,
0.0814566016,
-0.0049935477,
0.0541666113,
-0.0030167126,
-0.0077691437,
-0.0255901869,
-0.0247212984,
-0.0701413229,
-0.0061237775,
0.0085361898,
0.0061529493,
-0.077855505,
-0.0780978054,
0.0405073017,
-0.0439960621,
0.0002733495,
-0.0030163494,
0.0631743148,
-0.0387523659,
0.0049769031,
0.0197227784,
-0.0425801016,
-0.0124418791,
0.0055012186,
0.0125281969,
0.0379560553,
0.1028762087,
0.0274717547,
0.0697888061,
-0.0595813319,
0.0160292387,
-0.0715321898,
0.0127187176,
0.008897962,
-0.0449786037,
0.0274020862,
0.0575773083,
-0.0148237869,
-0.0623222776,
0.0631649569,
0.0092311986,
0.0123569025,
0.0007677611,
0.0506123453,
0.0984975919,
0.0406084955,
0.0134447981,
-0.0546512753,
0.0272993762,
0.0114263864,
0.0255129188,
0.0519147031,
-0.0042778091,
-0.003074521,
-0.0015638092,
-0.0224137027,
-0.0507085435,
-0.0173706729,
-0.055373095,
0.0244776458,
0.0045406227,
-0.0235990267,
0.0053119194,
0.0696945041,
-0.0396289416,
-0.0009003628,
0.0439011231,
-0.0289516263,
-0.0042262119,
0.048451148,
0.0392336547,
-0.0011868698,
-0.0313231759,
0.0011007624,
0.0150872646,
0.0386820883,
-0.0188521761,
0.0537254028,
-0.0257166661,
-0.0505467169,
0.0149440765,
-0.0351185761,
-0.0715919808,
-0.0741025731,
-0.0211435966,
-0.0142907621,
0.0388404839,
-0.0048027197,
0.0289640054,
0.008221209,
-0.0182640497,
0.0007616198,
-0.0519709662,
0.0349737555,
0.0615283661,
0.0029824807,
0.0095923012,
-0.051681798,
0.004328094,
-0.0024021929,
-0.0573930629,
0.0042740614,
-0.0160117615,
2.245e-7,
0.0346936956,
-0.0046250713,
0.0227039736,
-0.016521167,
-0.0102840308,
0.0250084158,
0.0052896314,
0.0436746366,
-0.0349502303,
-0.0261012204,
0.0142607549,
0.0425249748,
0.0347444899,
-0.0304696374,
-0.1025962457,
0.0117864236,
-0.0828072876,
-0.0011091356,
-0.037832588,
-0.0098756263,
0.0660459623,
0.1151437983,
0.0172196254,
0.0129129654,
-0.0273559801,
-0.0321708396,
0.086969018,
-0.0544834621,
-0.0086776428,
-0.0188206155,
-0.0337079838,
0.0312475357,
-0.0088689839,
0.0012298245,
0.0081767673,
0.0534707047,
0.0762895271,
0.0432061143,
0.0306563247,
-0.0397307798,
-0.0037597166,
-0.0127043109,
-0.0256261099,
-0.0637466013,
0.0647773296,
-0.0488290899,
-0.0020519602,
-0.0041823387,
-0.0148974946,
0.0752691701,
0.0986830667,
-0.0120466277,
-0.0551484711,
-0.0087663336,
0.036565695,
0.0125576248,
-0.0016553592,
-0.039279189,
-0.0028389751,
0.034913484,
-0.040241506,
0.0152317919,
-0.0194729678,
-0.0325215273,
0.0470551103,
-0.052434165,
0.0263235644,
1.672441361e-34,
0.0340380967,
-0.0123161124,
0.0243813843,
-0.0120509118,
0.0188749917,
-0.0465573184,
-0.029331848,
-0.0244695842,
0.0193084627,
0.0082898177,
-0.0073480271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15053v1 | PARIKSHA : A Large-Scale Investigation of Human-LLM Evaluator Agreement on Multilingual and Multi-Cultural Data | 2024-06-21T11:00:38 | 2024-06-21T11:00:38 | Ishaan Watts, Varun Gumma, Aditya Yadavalli, Vivek Seshadri, Manohar Swaminathan, Sunayana Sitaram | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluation of multilingual Large Language Models (LLMs) is challenging due to
a variety of factors -- the lack of benchmarks with sufficient linguistic
diversity, contamination of popular benchmarks into LLM pre-training data and
the lack of local, cultural nuances in translated benchmarks. In this work, we
study human and LLM-based evaluation in a multilingual, multi-cultural setting.
We evaluate 30 models across 10 Indic languages by conducting 90K human
evaluations and 30K LLM-based evaluations and find that models such as GPT-4o
and Llama-3 70B consistently perform best for most Indic languages. We build
leaderboards for two evaluation settings - pairwise comparison and direct
assessment and analyse the agreement between humans and LLMs. We find that
humans and LLMs agree fairly well in the pairwise setting but the agreement
drops for direct assessment evaluation especially for languages such as Bengali
and Odia. We also check for various biases in human and LLM-based evaluation
and find evidence of self-bias in the GPT-based evaluator. Our work presents a
significant step towards scaling up multilingual evaluation of LLMs. | [
0.0235988796,
0.0361644216,
-0.0088903112,
0.0347266272,
-0.0368011519,
0.0387041159,
0.0294443276,
-0.0036615664,
0.001579269,
-0.0197724365,
-0.0974373966,
-0.0803332403,
0.0515380427,
-0.0135022355,
0.0498855896,
-0.0551119894,
0.0262185205,
-0.0533412658,
-0.0103505123,
0.0008199351,
-0.0063848873,
-0.0079216957,
-0.0099420324,
0.0393569954,
0.0118359979,
0.0076083592,
0.0360826068,
-0.0129212262,
0.0179534443,
-0.056887392,
-0.0082451049,
0.0505516306,
-0.005910981,
0.0314451642,
0.0000020603,
-0.0624512397,
0.0234399084,
-0.0025640819,
0.0065771667,
0.0822099745,
0.0639726669,
-0.0095201507,
-0.0187752508,
0.0091936514,
-0.0232767854,
0.0084744282,
0.0457482189,
0.0145306345,
0.0291367657,
0.0682466403,
0.0003082896,
-0.050044328,
0.0120556103,
-0.0311327912,
-0.0414989181,
-0.0272459704,
0.0043466804,
0.0168385319,
0.0007400278,
-0.0278923381,
-0.0271229837,
0.0167497192,
0.0164327137,
0.0031800976,
-0.0186920594,
0.0042638909,
-0.0149170598,
-0.0594880804,
0.0093888966,
0.0594019927,
-0.0192001034,
-0.0231381897,
-0.0070776925,
-0.0100753037,
-0.0401213206,
-0.0116689494,
-0.0305209421,
0.0365655087,
0.0206903033,
0.0237463806,
0.0273634475,
0.0292509291,
0.0265794285,
0.0138664506,
0.012684281,
0.0507625714,
0.0379008912,
-0.0451244451,
0.0348920934,
0.0179210417,
-0.0108393356,
-0.0232079457,
-0.0059143575,
-0.0139813488,
-0.0347778462,
0.0269182194,
0.0119516524,
-0.0132464971,
0.0480971262,
-0.0751167983,
0.0439969078,
0.0452786051,
-0.0258225966,
0.0258719362,
-0.0113530252,
0.0794236884,
-0.0190238897,
0.027069388,
-0.0548499599,
-0.0041966648,
-0.019859083,
-0.0030558081,
0.0267325975,
0.001575349,
-0.0131251765,
0.0075198188,
-0.1167208254,
-0.0152717503,
-0.0130492924,
-0.02042743,
0.0317150317,
-0.0300827343,
-0.002741135,
-0.0128624495,
-0.0048908172,
0.0462703668,
-0.0446332023,
0.0096386382,
-0.0234469026,
-0.0740245134,
0.0430225134,
0.0506333411,
-0.0599679425,
-0.0287476126,
0.0028519435,
0.0516502783,
-0.020441819,
-0.0227847807,
-0.0338772349,
0.0303503536,
-0.0283546858,
-0.1098195612,
-0.017291978,
-0.0668096691,
0.0379460976,
0.0172217507,
0.0142956944,
-0.0209153015,
-0.0064611174,
0.0042677168,
0.0083529241,
0.0302530695,
0.0221907515,
0.0409106761,
0.0540371165,
0.0283148829,
0.006180183,
0.0896373987,
0.034596093,
0.0113620274,
0.0334974937,
-0.0326500088,
-0.0166101195,
0.0842546001,
-0.0115919132,
0.0221140143,
-0.018477628,
0.0206493046,
0.005581351,
0.0431401655,
0.0366578028,
0.0658044145,
-0.0206261221,
0.0298680123,
0.0575425439,
0.0604731515,
0.0136725567,
0.0277781785,
0.0417083502,
0.0125149144,
0.0405380838,
0.0164964274,
-0.0301623661,
-0.000799456,
-0.0150058577,
0.0028132044,
0.0386444367,
0.0532334633,
-0.0028138382,
-0.0168821998,
-0.0319236107,
-0.0185849462,
0.0163877364,
-0.0082939938,
0.0592191704,
-0.0451179557,
-0.021117704,
0.0425477996,
0.0422398336,
-0.0619743839,
0.0076665455,
-0.0634893551,
0.0196014158,
0.0360835344,
-0.0018283849,
0.0243559647,
0.0107020373,
0.033597663,
0.0219516866,
0.0546758063,
0.072264351,
0.0053744167,
0.0051092622,
-0.0565368161,
-0.0034034667,
0.0166535806,
-0.0079195527,
0.0454761125,
0.0028419648,
0.0477665514,
0.0116049387,
-0.0376703627,
-0.0685298666,
0.0307471696,
-0.0486995578,
0.0006059543,
-0.0207782052,
-0.0049004336,
0.0386078246,
0.021615874,
-0.0152851688,
-0.0021119255,
0.0089773303,
-0.0073787142,
0.0109469742,
0.0262986254,
-0.0446598977,
0.0159162339,
0.0339602083,
-0.0296398383,
-0.0136908107,
0.0114495885,
-0.0023594261,
-0.054942891,
0.0179144498,
-0.0125634987,
0.0066535654,
-0.0350310504,
0.0297848526,
-0.0429476835,
-0.0128825624,
-0.0193375461,
0.0449215733,
0.0030797224,
0.0184293147,
0.0267265253,
-0.0007690109,
0.0613725707,
-0.0438524671,
-0.0664085001,
0.0684218481,
0.0261637624,
0.0206351224,
0.0144216167,
0.0521251038,
-0.0669007003,
-0.0529725589,
-0.1178519949,
-0.0142201651,
-0.0161350984,
0.0235962681,
-0.0036376028,
-0.0086982558,
-0.0195314102,
0.0138362022,
-0.0384137258,
-0.0399450473,
0.0389706381,
0.0335713588,
-0.0053388197,
-0.0181495473,
-0.0059361653,
-0.0388525799,
-0.0163712464,
0.0131899873,
0.0476563349,
0.0205407571,
-0.0265537295,
-0.025868414,
0.0184371006,
-0.0447295122,
-0.0225796346,
-0.0052838558,
-0.0779091343,
0.0224077199,
0.0122962482,
0.0189823378,
0.0202301387,
-0.0033576605,
-0.0298030712,
0.0369370878,
-0.0175394062,
-0.0419885777,
-0.037587814,
0.0318442136,
-0.0244362317,
-0.0326733515,
-0.0388966277,
-0.0127584869,
0.0663946867,
0.0056104823,
0.0116649829,
-0.0406177677,
-0.0348801576,
-0.0873706564,
-0.0356623791,
-0.031412255,
0.0014181883,
-0.033564996,
0.0707672015,
-0.0026761391,
-0.0577546395,
0.0575517826,
-0.044571802,
-0.0126876282,
-0.0288517866,
0.0065382728,
-0.0573921576,
0.0252402499,
-0.0243908353,
0.0100431005,
-0.0509533994,
-0.0092739919,
-0.0425851345,
0.0013145965,
0.0163468011,
-0.0485116057,
0.0453065112,
-0.0857550874,
0.0123524722,
-0.0160714854,
-0.0400731638,
0.002579768,
-0.0064626713,
-0.0091577359,
0.0029041271,
0.0170912482,
0.0010321769,
0.0075577507,
0.0363537334,
0.0265295058,
-0.0166411437,
-0.0115675367,
0.0318096466,
0.0308066159,
-0.0213529356,
0.0269002318,
0.0180329215,
0.0257677902,
-0.0437222421,
0.0200536139,
0.0008681898,
0.0394126587,
-0.0053252652,
-0.0298988037,
0.0082085859,
0.0441830046,
-0.0134010576,
-0.0454167351,
0.0086710388,
0.0456428193,
-0.0165908765,
0.0268900469,
0.0909744725,
0.0167373959,
-0.0544965342,
-0.0105292061,
-0.0494305417,
0.017338967,
-0.0150256436,
0.0073792026,
-0.0704692602,
-0.0096546393,
-0.0010345818,
0.014476059,
0.0112682665,
0.0168988127,
0.0098318374,
-0.1326517612,
-0.0002705833,
0.0125337793,
-0.0239880476,
-0.0029815258,
-0.0340997949,
-0.0313286297,
-0.0402028747,
0.0529156998,
0.0304742344,
-0.027027674,
0.0006087846,
0.0417552367,
-0.0623341575,
-0.0807823911,
0.0409004278,
-0.0456123091,
0.0375725925,
0.0490585305,
0.0040418427,
-0.0379398689,
-0.0548675805,
0.0405749045,
-0.009143088,
-0.0265822913,
0.0076152743,
0.0078222193,
0.0189066269,
-0.0181799456,
-0.02570883,
-0.0224458538,
-0.0067393701,
0.0206042212,
0.0136459442,
0.0352040008,
0.008563811,
0.005401548,
0.0237442311,
-0.0014114636,
-0.0160341728,
0.0556046404,
0.0267952494,
-0.064138338,
-0.0178057924,
-0.0023854196,
-0.0162210427,
-0.0244638026,
-0.0493629538,
0.0399990343,
-0.0342705734,
-0.0335890241,
-0.0468715094,
-0.0638848692,
0.0015252355,
0.0014448374,
0.0382203199,
0.0263408925,
-0.0177507382,
0.0044206046,
0.0276177041,
0.0271793921,
-0.0103196157,
0.0419627242,
-0.1008874699,
0.0033063588,
0.0550361201,
-0.0024308315,
-0.0011263018,
0.0211593322,
-0.0487844869,
-0.0596906617,
0.0118282847,
0.0603759848,
0.0237349477,
-0.0108084735,
-0.0066955783,
-0.0761396065,
0.0289902762,
-0.0085004102,
-0.0288540106,
0.0366543308,
0.0177764669,
0.022926731,
-0.0009365936,
0.0297772679,
-0.0367537253,
0.0054188902,
0.0050455807,
0.0319847837,
-0.0040499014,
-0.0340378173,
-0.0010219206,
0.0449198484,
0.0231794734,
-0.0930659473,
-0.0360190086,
-0.0210513603,
-0.0092247436,
-0.0155523447,
-0.0018282686,
-0.0266607758,
-0.0275103338,
0.0564578064,
0.0323818102,
-0.0040863189,
-0.0045819608,
-0.0011441894,
-0.0045933039,
-0.0448814519,
0.0657793209,
0.0008743069,
0.0089761354,
0.0002850629,
0.0241761841,
-0.0198638737,
-0.0123825958,
-0.019906329,
0.0270549245,
-0.0088817375,
0.0738750994,
-0.012693611,
0.0015703627,
0.0578178838,
0.0559792519,
0.0263647288,
-0.0089608319,
-0.009606,
0.0132914754,
0.0873921365,
0.0126041602,
0.1071723625,
0.0082373936,
0.0108076073,
-0.0348838158,
0.0139124161,
-0.0447328724,
0.0030614072,
0.0361119807,
-0.0031964986,
-0.034253858,
0.0028003245,
0.065750517,
0.0195283834,
-0.0136317629,
-0.004910579,
0.0018332504,
-0.0056119869,
-0.0482270867,
-0.0148820588,
-0.021808397,
-0.0299823899,
-0.0279976856,
-0.0851084441,
-0.0581187867,
-0.0284342635,
0.0250412673,
0.0064485269,
-0.0222169906,
0.0124337347,
0.0767584592,
-0.0176410172,
0.0101120323,
-0.0629602522,
-0.0323982462,
0.0058169467,
-0.0013471148,
-0.0050734822,
-6.36940512e-33,
-0.03828777,
0.0078969402,
0.0241706036,
-0.0285155438,
-0.0351941176,
-0.0077617457,
-0.0113401478,
0.0276152082,
-0.0059763384,
-0.0036207044,
-0.008626366,
-0.0166269746,
0.0169710442,
-0.0118690589,
0.0527559929,
-0.0077697025,
0.0016278629,
0.0051926114,
-0.0199652091,
-0.0168204531,
0.0104678115,
-0.0091342237,
0.104856953,
-0.0417284779,
0.063724786,
-0.0174137913,
-0.0189163424,
-0.0190791264,
-0.0320913009,
0.0907655209,
-0.0309499819,
0.0319426209,
0.0302636623,
-0.0340249166,
-0.0125052389,
-0.0330679603,
-0.0242960118,
-0.0090359943,
0.0663732067,
0.0527683385,
-0.0006394388,
-0.0079717701,
0.06218886,
-0.0154128112,
-0.0812058598,
0.033284992,
0.0003351122,
-0.0173272658,
-0.003099761,
0.0146370688,
-0.051951848,
0.0518804155,
0.0006691564,
0.0140676759,
0.0178062562,
0.0351112112,
-0.048530478,
0.0102982447,
-0.0761957839,
0.012827917,
0.0295069255,
0.036017511,
0.0900271237,
0.0209745243,
-0.0208743848,
0.042244833,
0.0453298613,
-0.0210727844,
0.0286653992,
-0.0433469862,
0.0406101309,
0.0170451924,
0.0376550443,
0.0781678557,
0.0260914192,
-0.0420213118,
-0.0634547845,
0.0327685364,
0.0302062239,
0.0402124226,
0.0155646047,
0.017792156,
-0.0365702659,
-0.0409054086,
-0.0165254381,
-0.0158594325,
-0.0288747046,
-0.0440533683,
0.0644593909,
-0.0325441658,
0.0140510583,
0.0082962802,
0.0610629991,
-0.0190644152,
-0.0054262811,
-0.0100714834,
-0.0309728738,
0.0404193029,
0.0035039724,
0.0386560559,
-0.071953252,
-0.0214803964,
-0.043315772,
0.051452104,
0.0215965658,
-0.0314373709,
0.0145185348,
-0.0043558506,
-0.0661561862,
0.0239182319,
-0.0292560067,
-0.0158619042,
0.0137844402,
0.0167199895,
0.0374904722,
-0.0332312211,
-0.0219606478,
0.0314436704,
0.0000431181,
-0.0026990487,
-0.026112942,
-0.0310910866,
0.0052628592,
0.0174815264,
-0.0325625651,
0.0329698808,
-0.0140511887,
-0.0009205954,
0.0353599936,
-0.0037012519,
-0.0000329056,
0.0371108577,
2.759e-7,
0.0294310171,
0.0483009666,
-0.002392137,
-0.0153897386,
-0.004664849,
0.0159256067,
-0.0756742135,
-0.0083251428,
0.011273833,
0.029488625,
0.0012754592,
0.0098277219,
0.0910009295,
0.0343138464,
-0.0663080886,
-0.0102485092,
-0.0829482377,
0.0182060059,
-0.0374987088,
0.0045673163,
-0.0240762755,
0.0694752559,
-0.0026163042,
-0.0113775237,
-0.0476339497,
-0.0432341471,
0.0764075518,
-0.0454338789,
-0.040184021,
0.0236909334,
0.0487200804,
0.0148835266,
-0.0037798376,
0.0013269541,
-0.0123040583,
0.0062937229,
0.0697695762,
0.0944776088,
0.009998071,
0.012152208,
0.0377728119,
-0.000433623,
-0.0216896553,
-0.0936321467,
0.0607327856,
0.0048006917,
-0.0451114736,
-0.0247765519,
-0.0117391609,
-0.0360062495,
0.0667860359,
-0.0470421724,
-0.0169054605,
0.0359625742,
0.0327310786,
-0.0574838296,
-0.0361913443,
-0.000158241,
-0.0323469117,
0.0058582942,
-0.0158746541,
-0.0774095953,
-0.0214608982,
0.0045071039,
-0.0168653149,
-0.0502609983,
0.0006174635,
2.060356218e-34,
0.0611544922,
-0.011152273,
0.0301699042,
-0.0160430409,
0.0395988971,
0.0150658982,
-0.0146569004,
0.0088693853,
-0.0202609804,
-0.072476007,
0.0135656158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15050v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15050v1 | Tri-VQA: Triangular Reasoning Medical Visual Question Answering for Multi-Attribute Analysis | 2024-06-21T10:50:55 | 2024-06-21T10:50:55 | Lin Fan, Xun Gong, Cenyang Zheng, Yafei Ou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, I.2.7; I.2.10; J.3 | The intersection of medical Visual Question Answering (Med-VQA) is a
challenging research topic with advantages including patient engagement and
clinical expert involvement for second opinions. However, existing Med-VQA
methods based on joint embedding fail to explain whether their provided results
are based on correct reasoning or coincidental answers, which undermines the
credibility of VQA answers. In this paper, we investigate the construction of a
more cohesive and stable Med-VQA structure. Motivated by causal effect, we
propose a novel Triangular Reasoning VQA (Tri-VQA) framework, which constructs
reverse causal questions from the perspective of "Why this answer?" to
elucidate the source of the answer and stimulate more reasonable forward
reasoning processes. We evaluate our method on the Endoscopic Ultrasound (EUS)
multi-attribute annotated dataset from five centers, and test it on medical VQA
datasets. Experimental results demonstrate the superiority of our approach over
existing methods. Our codes and pre-trained models are available at
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/Tri_VQA. | [
0.0346351601,
0.0447974131,
-0.0088774227,
-0.0019169755,
0.0055093574,
0.0397503711,
0.0098806666,
0.0292672534,
-0.0005490357,
0.0050908141,
-0.0043210932,
0.0074082604,
-0.0016718775,
0.0249274746,
0.0299341697,
-0.0520447455,
0.0048918691,
0.0306692924,
0.0500423424,
-0.0192421712,
0.0162494741,
-0.016049426,
-0.0171890557,
0.0476194657,
-0.0188886784,
-0.0049072201,
0.0254453234,
-0.0127512887,
0.0166034102,
-0.0409016497,
-0.0263899304,
0.0219848752,
0.0010551296,
-0.0582070425,
0.0000022153,
-0.0157528911,
-0.0193140414,
0.0160810445,
-0.0221582875,
-0.0402419157,
-0.0383808464,
-0.0030750234,
0.063701123,
0.0280097667,
-0.0390227884,
-0.0064023035,
0.0342817903,
0.0536399968,
0.0803549662,
0.0193510819,
-0.0170659367,
-0.0271695089,
-0.0077339108,
0.0048049088,
0.018967554,
-0.0283569861,
-0.0006198674,
0.0379709825,
0.0005790545,
0.0036872821,
0.0017956728,
0.0263123997,
0.0256557353,
0.0311839264,
0.0126261292,
0.0391689204,
0.0161011145,
-0.0224362817,
0.0195038598,
0.0884783044,
0.0317120254,
0.0271425899,
0.0014340803,
0.0082423184,
0.0078732204,
0.0528015718,
-0.0626140162,
-0.0099199396,
-0.0196583718,
-0.025467135,
-0.0184339713,
0.0498351976,
0.0026288305,
-0.0040532751,
-0.0082972487,
-0.0440525003,
0.0021402279,
0.0119573623,
-0.0139405131,
0.0295175314,
-0.0249735154,
-0.0170924161,
-0.0117116068,
0.0542786233,
-0.0492366776,
-0.0018195641,
0.0698877722,
-0.0009668238,
0.0404431932,
-0.0201145839,
0.0266688876,
0.0287700724,
-0.0549856238,
0.0498163179,
-0.0435981937,
0.0126461247,
-0.0659984127,
0.0695051104,
-0.0251365714,
-0.0091339648,
-0.0435884669,
-0.0307238884,
-0.0042347652,
-0.0036109316,
0.0085658953,
0.0042451378,
-0.0263060983,
-0.0080401311,
-0.0470898338,
-0.0005499299,
0.0020296404,
0.0811958686,
0.0153733147,
0.0220613275,
-0.041858092,
0.0534444451,
-0.0630285367,
0.0383773632,
-0.0238063727,
0.0129692405,
0.0038171445,
0.0307752546,
0.0171806347,
0.0094614914,
0.0176958814,
0.0403646864,
0.0034783015,
0.008076339,
-0.0150160762,
-0.0728165805,
-0.0012443322,
-0.0305177663,
0.0343002304,
-0.0428432859,
0.0285287797,
0.0096067619,
-0.0146913007,
-0.0148815857,
0.0048507312,
0.0248220023,
-0.0519521907,
0.0968061462,
-0.0377138667,
0.0047963592,
0.0131845959,
0.0423679389,
0.0002103665,
0.0236807652,
0.0072129848,
0.004875469,
0.0026983449,
-0.0290441494,
0.0305098761,
-0.0530954227,
0.0376772508,
-0.0208319053,
-0.0032992794,
0.0336586908,
-0.0376433916,
0.0760104954,
-0.06147407,
0.0348333046,
-0.0354738049,
-0.0482314974,
-0.0045374795,
0.0337869935,
-0.0080013396,
-0.0503371134,
0.015535471,
-0.0721660778,
-0.0286382381,
0.0153158531,
-0.0086090332,
0.0741586387,
0.0203588773,
-0.0024239451,
-0.0114896921,
-0.0025588013,
-0.0522253886,
-0.0830419138,
-0.0446274318,
-0.0001127169,
-0.0252059493,
0.035252139,
0.026829835,
0.0070461105,
-0.0119338259,
-0.0272582788,
0.0264165048,
-0.0159368683,
-0.0392743833,
-0.0525937974,
0.0479599349,
0.0473568439,
0.0311744437,
-0.0143595254,
-0.0556234792,
-0.0289369933,
0.0444523804,
-0.0424977168,
0.0155503722,
-0.0360721499,
0.0093584629,
-0.0354860872,
-0.0334956162,
-0.0054217675,
0.0041342848,
-0.010060587,
0.0013340221,
-0.0050139334,
-0.0420129076,
-0.0250464063,
0.0545148104,
0.0329953097,
-0.0013273509,
0.0173114501,
-0.0164312515,
0.0386871696,
-0.0070221936,
0.0326859951,
0.0053050825,
0.0237915572,
0.0267524384,
-0.0331049748,
-0.0231443346,
0.0224011187,
-0.0334247127,
-0.0187700428,
0.0100537566,
-0.0840087086,
-0.0381073914,
-0.0120340856,
-0.0577704087,
-0.0390260145,
-0.0112398211,
-0.0155231673,
-0.0353773087,
-0.0100372853,
-0.0512844361,
0.0537535958,
-0.0100947348,
-0.0527158007,
0.0467401184,
-0.0355683081,
0.0036888462,
-0.0115299607,
-0.0210999604,
0.0421529114,
0.0005922891,
0.0125361597,
0.0114625432,
0.0123641836,
-0.0005634498,
-0.004784856,
0.0118187508,
-0.0354559906,
-0.0043772859,
-0.0782550126,
-0.0282093193,
-0.0103774294,
-0.0364323109,
0.0003665539,
-0.0107804257,
0.0187299252,
-0.0708232522,
-0.0599356629,
0.0113101415,
0.0071424902,
0.0394494757,
0.0900156051,
0.0237665772,
0.0285186097,
-0.0082912156,
-0.0056135175,
-0.0400625765,
0.0531677604,
0.0635858551,
0.0187997706,
-0.0135862557,
-0.075769864,
-0.0680600926,
-0.017006265,
0.0147455763,
-0.0047141602,
0.0294534042,
-0.0093310066,
-0.0551180504,
0.056154009,
-0.0356432647,
0.0181558486,
0.0097812973,
0.0310585033,
-0.0396467037,
0.0154279228,
-0.0466886051,
0.004758785,
0.0455573536,
-0.0677477792,
-0.047178302,
0.0504599437,
-0.0176492631,
-0.0332716666,
-0.0667926446,
0.0365242548,
0.028612541,
0.0009443123,
-0.0832299665,
-0.0088553494,
0.0075752167,
0.0871290863,
0.004065183,
-0.0412417985,
0.1042372957,
0.0174844339,
0.0171684548,
-0.013480546,
0.0007968142,
-0.0839835331,
0.0438845232,
-0.0122463172,
0.0249652509,
0.0192236379,
-0.0074678347,
-0.0463500991,
-0.0003124797,
0.0452704206,
-0.0280280802,
0.0329026654,
-0.0105123557,
-0.0064965147,
-0.0029927504,
-0.0381597728,
-0.0458103977,
-0.023295857,
-0.0175358504,
-0.0074341646,
-0.0692420006,
0.02214236,
-0.0264101829,
0.0255209468,
0.0105741993,
0.0010988305,
-0.0033085395,
-0.0142383771,
-0.0144854262,
0.0447209179,
0.0377272516,
0.0281635895,
-0.0062592318,
-0.0126034357,
0.0173415039,
0.0748217478,
0.0111626144,
0.0084276097,
-0.0221301578,
0.020570226,
-0.031741675,
0.0243513454,
0.0141532151,
-0.0275203567,
-0.004786009,
-0.042501878,
0.05241739,
0.0442419127,
0.0283522978,
-0.0030439387,
0.0012984362,
-0.0102765169,
-0.0073655359,
0.031897977,
0.0251871701,
-0.1095073745,
-0.0200267509,
-0.0145287076,
0.0211051181,
0.008120087,
-0.0033149987,
0.0123816375,
-0.0312163737,
0.0742732435,
-0.0417890437,
0.016299108,
-0.0528906956,
-0.0230768826,
0.0115606794,
-0.0212869998,
-0.0468175001,
-0.0288198888,
0.0314200856,
0.0010063733,
0.0183398966,
-0.0191834904,
-0.01779777,
0.0454690419,
-0.0135134347,
-0.0193449575,
0.007601127,
0.0404827893,
-0.0128254611,
-0.0794593915,
-0.0498352721,
-0.0097657964,
0.0174099486,
-0.011663639,
0.0882942677,
0.0052988897,
-0.019794995,
-0.0195205063,
0.0563770458,
-0.0109798759,
-0.0227673203,
-0.0088704601,
0.1024226919,
-0.035490606,
-0.0096974149,
-0.0586669408,
0.0333102271,
0.002117597,
0.0279567428,
0.0190929212,
0.0112625677,
-0.0468055867,
0.0165802594,
0.0188205689,
0.0114900125,
-0.0534447618,
0.0247518066,
0.043000944,
-0.0084018465,
-0.0605249442,
-0.0194356889,
0.05227511,
0.0384892449,
-0.0047799107,
0.013692419,
-0.0378260352,
0.0036592034,
-0.0472381562,
0.0529132821,
0.0221787021,
0.0265034735,
0.0363761857,
0.0092026656,
0.038795989,
-0.0363189541,
-0.0270198435,
-0.0317144208,
0.0356647857,
0.0023787592,
-0.0492164269,
0.0665438846,
0.0162865184,
0.0395113491,
-0.0139341857,
-0.0204338152,
0.0131497514,
-0.0037505354,
-0.0194703136,
-0.0365315638,
0.0237727631,
-0.0045612897,
-0.0155568542,
-0.0035164012,
0.0186003335,
-0.0023061896,
0.002009094,
0.0048008612,
-0.0541291498,
-0.0037614089,
0.0211955551,
0.0265826788,
0.0564464517,
0.0050800461,
0.0229560435,
-0.0172656979,
0.0222096927,
-0.0148293693,
0.004208128,
-0.0166859198,
0.0242460612,
-0.0021663574,
-0.0293657258,
-0.0104903877,
-0.0499268994,
-0.0218277257,
-0.0249461401,
-0.0197973084,
0.0468489528,
0.0211073551,
0.0015788373,
-0.0050324276,
0.0150460582,
-0.0000701592,
0.0069603967,
0.0023354546,
0.0632718801,
0.0119842943,
0.0693247989,
0.0327121094,
0.0124693969,
-0.0251219943,
0.0085660564,
-0.0555216521,
-0.0630509704,
0.0187360253,
0.0221667364,
0.0118151363,
0.0317861475,
-0.0264470335,
0.0180058554,
-0.0012314989,
0.0441975296,
0.0258113537,
-0.0041100592,
0.004071251,
0.0995651037,
0.0160988197,
0.0003134235,
-0.0284506772,
0.0745582283,
-0.0071257008,
0.019554114,
-0.0646954626,
-0.0335809663,
-0.0449952967,
-0.0561586805,
0.0350040682,
0.0195819493,
-0.0235846303,
0.0346996151,
-0.0892872214,
-0.0449715443,
-0.0281461477,
-0.0140886726,
-0.0219556801,
0.0032318085,
0.031122392,
0.0346689485,
0.0448345318,
-0.0258871187,
-0.0152680166,
0.016545726,
-0.0599170178,
-0.0179656986,
0.0547241382,
-6.626700262e-33,
0.0015592666,
-0.0376666225,
0.0648545027,
-0.0297435075,
0.0165126808,
0.0379971787,
-0.0237950832,
-0.0206334386,
-0.0353277773,
0.0351319648,
0.0005909138,
-0.00964172,
0.0062979679,
0.026323773,
0.0240359083,
-0.0321145318,
-0.0081481477,
0.0152316326,
0.0025773183,
0.0266818367,
0.0006325234,
0.0007996258,
0.0292849503,
-0.12968795,
-0.0019321312,
0.0253479276,
-0.0068454091,
0.0454247445,
-0.0618055202,
0.063946031,
-0.0093464954,
-0.0210301001,
0.0283196233,
-0.0420015231,
0.0067556798,
0.0057083652,
-0.0756554902,
-0.0490293391,
0.0145969465,
-0.0037575725,
-0.1426458061,
-0.0005917607,
-0.0086323721,
-0.0262017082,
0.0483459011,
-0.0463687405,
0.0371148065,
-0.0272355247,
0.0055892244,
-0.0192165915,
-0.0108075831,
0.0376752242,
-0.0378515683,
-0.0134402066,
-0.0027049759,
0.040471375,
0.0047471435,
0.0270155799,
-0.0392294154,
0.0151981181,
-0.0084861629,
-0.0609813593,
0.02458998,
-0.0142375417,
-0.0073542972,
0.04468989,
0.0442550108,
-0.0377889499,
-0.0690358952,
-0.0236158725,
-0.0827154443,
0.0801364183,
0.119045496,
0.0511102118,
0.0001536509,
-0.0022968675,
-0.0946587548,
0.0064220778,
-0.0696719438,
0.0795331225,
0.016164761,
-0.035721764,
-0.0587380789,
0.0014769498,
-0.045998551,
-0.0174891856,
-0.0418246128,
-0.0268879067,
0.033475168,
0.0329847895,
-0.0214095898,
0.0682967901,
0.0174557064,
-0.0435131192,
0.0489141457,
0.01588176,
0.0060204472,
0.0184689965,
0.0037864957,
0.0218096524,
-0.0274511278,
0.0460854135,
0.0175228808,
-0.0514903367,
0.0474959388,
0.0163710173,
0.0683807433,
-0.0506717712,
-0.0328180455,
-0.0210700221,
-0.011134753,
-0.0205207411,
-0.0374181233,
-0.0388722531,
0.0261584446,
0.0656019971,
-0.045363076,
0.0554150417,
0.0133216232,
0.0635446534,
-0.0262685195,
-0.0808358639,
-0.0249931067,
0.0138892885,
-0.0295518935,
-0.0003625323,
-0.0118377218,
-0.0549259745,
-0.0176843088,
-0.0483691469,
-0.0162811931,
0.035986688,
2.898e-7,
0.0736420974,
0.0206749998,
0.0215899851,
0.0052396916,
0.0153479706,
0.0245633647,
-0.0057588946,
-0.0185220707,
0.023577068,
-0.0241482425,
0.0346972197,
0.0386264324,
-0.0008144445,
0.0657614172,
0.0024051808,
-0.0047761067,
-0.0313205346,
-0.0266188495,
-0.0185039639,
-0.0217080805,
0.0972036645,
0.0215912163,
-0.023684334,
-0.0348986089,
0.0141132912,
0.0078481454,
0.0632448867,
-0.0098226769,
0.0167973954,
-0.0038593996,
0.0252994914,
-0.0251065139,
0.0186183937,
0.0571689755,
0.0142288329,
-0.0406532809,
0.0203812402,
0.0295598879,
-0.0288317744,
-0.0385179259,
0.0023081345,
0.0063890852,
0.0382180959,
-0.0528205074,
0.0963561311,
-0.042807214,
-0.0557607338,
0.0098279603,
-0.0157758687,
0.0009987907,
0.0949512124,
0.0091152219,
-0.0248376802,
0.0144228144,
0.0242713224,
-0.005619532,
-0.0114732543,
-0.0839573219,
-0.0067192791,
0.0245535113,
-0.0029651446,
-0.0167833734,
0.051753059,
-0.0214113221,
0.0303318072,
-0.0360084064,
-0.0583680309,
2.366592471e-34,
0.0357272625,
0.0226916932,
0.0395288244,
0.0227613226,
0.0351399556,
-0.0189711656,
-0.0169814229,
-0.0290285349,
0.0738864988,
-0.0188218728,
-0.0114707574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15045v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15045v1 | Harnessing Knowledge Retrieval with Large Language Models for Clinical Report Error Correction | 2024-06-21T10:48:21 | 2024-06-21T10:48:21 | Jinge Wu, Zhaolong Wu, Abul Hasan, Yunsoo Kim, Jason P. Y. Cheung, Teng Zhang, Honghan Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study proposes an approach for error correction in clinical radiology
reports, leveraging large language models (LLMs) and retrieval-augmented
generation (RAG) techniques. The proposed framework employs internal and
external retrieval mechanisms to extract relevant medical entities and
relations from the report and external knowledge sources. A three-stage
inference process is introduced, decomposing the task into error detection,
localization, and correction subtasks, which enhances the explainability and
performance of the system. The effectiveness of the approach is evaluated using
a benchmark dataset created by corrupting real-world radiology reports with
realistic errors, guided by domain experts. Experimental results demonstrate
the benefits of the proposed methods, with the combination of internal and
external retrieval significantly improving the accuracy of error detection,
localization, and correction across various state-of-the-art LLMs. The findings
contribute to the development of more robust and reliable error correction
systems for clinical documentation. | [
0.0785059556,
0.0579341576,
0.0217094366,
0.0018607507,
0.0101252403,
0.0391164012,
-0.0259432085,
0.0535430759,
0.0096591506,
-0.0110478075,
0.0103193233,
-0.0601596646,
0.017469652,
-0.0119864438,
0.0330123492,
-0.0383990146,
0.0300819576,
0.0187313985,
0.0218744315,
0.0169906914,
-0.0222835839,
0.0155266896,
-0.0015595888,
0.0341392867,
-0.0033299369,
0.019292973,
0.0310555156,
0.0226927716,
0.0134073999,
-0.0479502492,
-0.0260000173,
0.0068579419,
0.0124648232,
0.0397218019,
0.0000018083,
-0.0534783937,
-0.0369073413,
0.0386572033,
-0.0181525014,
-0.0246319398,
0.0489593111,
-0.0743837133,
-0.034259785,
0.0072673112,
0.0286206584,
-0.0686001405,
0.038442187,
0.0385652445,
0.0534889176,
0.0849035531,
-0.0191050284,
0.0229179338,
0.0011536062,
-0.0053396341,
0.0156515744,
-0.0322978236,
0.0549779236,
0.0661883205,
0.0008429621,
-0.0051789982,
0.0231697727,
0.0386317149,
-0.0353100337,
-0.0288498122,
-0.0046693506,
0.0134149725,
-0.0028601037,
-0.0058935261,
0.0068010478,
0.0133212823,
0.0327456631,
-0.0141205378,
0.0120960288,
0.0143268481,
0.0073597971,
0.0329903811,
-0.0295504145,
0.006343673,
-0.031055171,
-0.0115623157,
0.001271692,
-0.0576354451,
0.0232018847,
0.0205246154,
-0.0579813682,
-0.0182772055,
0.0069476897,
-0.0316542499,
-0.0174299795,
0.0278993249,
-0.0121652605,
-0.0280225426,
0.0376320481,
0.0507446118,
-0.0449210405,
0.0213078354,
-0.0343781151,
-0.0591270141,
0.0749305561,
-0.0581273809,
-0.0313293226,
-0.0231255181,
-0.0346340723,
0.055278711,
-0.0095888963,
0.0388755649,
-0.0227636993,
0.0150444685,
-0.0311490744,
-0.011099739,
-0.0106039643,
-0.0335154049,
-0.021756433,
-0.0041950773,
-0.0136138452,
0.0099643441,
-0.0705977157,
0.0015334628,
-0.0235539172,
0.0557916239,
0.0141022187,
0.0268106032,
-0.0741329193,
-0.026912123,
-0.043868117,
0.0331398547,
0.0527746752,
0.0029050056,
-0.00566713,
-0.0337671898,
0.0122292656,
0.0487424992,
0.009233105,
0.0228458308,
0.005159888,
0.0191776175,
0.0148295499,
0.0086783068,
-0.0057954779,
-0.0856562108,
-0.0302222725,
-0.0042514177,
-0.0132095721,
-0.0541465804,
0.0052723559,
0.0223127659,
0.0117103048,
-0.0401844494,
0.0292501058,
0.0118043134,
-0.069108285,
0.0479818098,
-0.0877988264,
0.0217470359,
0.0259074401,
0.0125380186,
0.0407310463,
-0.0125244884,
0.0088172741,
-0.0480616167,
0.0038931093,
0.0137854274,
0.0368157029,
-0.0179047361,
-0.0047350335,
-0.0390385129,
-0.0227251891,
0.0062454427,
-0.0025899888,
0.0593504943,
0.0203379206,
0.0634261221,
-0.0193699412,
0.0344197229,
0.007582258,
0.0250915419,
0.0492280871,
0.005571045,
0.0389771163,
-0.0539433174,
-0.0052397852,
-0.021987278,
-0.0117395632,
-0.0134517374,
0.0079278443,
0.0056501674,
0.0055081197,
0.0000897026,
-0.0172485784,
-0.0176798254,
-0.0594545566,
0.0154461628,
-0.0450964011,
-0.00523336,
0.0881647244,
0.0079358388,
-0.0411157422,
0.0590261444,
0.0369078219,
-0.0300432071,
0.0039456128,
-0.0595350377,
-0.0101659391,
0.0986616313,
0.110222131,
-0.0462053604,
-0.0229537543,
0.0116977347,
0.0018808127,
0.026200667,
0.0303168893,
-0.0254749972,
-0.0298631042,
-0.0370953605,
-0.0112815108,
0.0618867278,
0.023223402,
-0.0137620419,
0.0255461819,
0.0114751747,
0.0078746639,
-0.0546612702,
-0.0592591986,
0.0171917528,
-0.0386836156,
-0.0141586354,
-0.0152990995,
-0.0004545111,
-0.0054478487,
0.0148423137,
-0.0458140373,
0.0292586647,
0.015895661,
0.0129375998,
-0.0382124707,
0.0030314524,
-0.0196432378,
-0.0202933438,
0.0370156169,
-0.0266236737,
-0.0079130242,
-0.0530287549,
-0.0339365527,
-0.0067413719,
-0.0282342527,
-0.0612409674,
0.0203848518,
-0.0423571393,
0.0478562005,
0.0572039746,
-0.022753885,
-0.0284141283,
0.0454784483,
-0.0059262444,
0.0226637274,
0.0329449363,
-0.0246591028,
0.0012016525,
-0.040761888,
-0.0109509956,
0.0147112589,
0.0028371178,
0.0272550471,
0.0214220658,
-0.0203897618,
-0.0159253981,
-0.0402612574,
-0.0742830858,
-0.0113962907,
0.0041504507,
-0.0013950773,
0.0357055105,
0.0182306711,
0.0048442809,
-0.031802889,
0.0081196334,
-0.0225046296,
0.0726805776,
0.0086946478,
0.0620177127,
0.0346710794,
-0.0121415956,
-0.0394033082,
0.0040543261,
-0.0322546512,
0.0134986434,
0.0436598398,
-0.055800315,
-0.0903356969,
0.0733339638,
-0.0611855462,
0.0037045488,
0.0119125843,
-0.0311505161,
0.0005908532,
-0.0553307496,
0.0009800798,
0.0146482317,
-0.01672896,
0.0382139236,
0.0315029658,
-0.0485044941,
-0.0221815556,
0.0033452257,
-0.0299707074,
-0.0688986927,
0.011222776,
-0.0443987846,
-0.0169450045,
0.0187605098,
-0.000330148,
-0.0173709076,
-0.0078793373,
-0.0034862377,
-0.0359559245,
0.0102453548,
-0.011156843,
-0.0330739655,
0.0143626034,
0.0536011197,
-0.0164527185,
-0.0251582488,
0.0829603672,
-0.0090955822,
0.0451895595,
-0.0426355973,
-0.0018685112,
-0.0218355954,
0.0006174408,
-0.0213141721,
0.033382535,
0.001185937,
-0.0457021147,
-0.0079653328,
0.0002961981,
0.0560573973,
-0.0732437819,
0.0601835251,
-0.0399479233,
0.0365843587,
0.0144178513,
-0.0084762191,
-0.0454862341,
-0.0222650636,
0.0321821608,
-0.0417738594,
-0.0019675957,
-0.003856255,
-0.0947378352,
0.0449788421,
0.0374235474,
0.0241992045,
0.0285017956,
-0.0293336026,
0.0131501583,
0.0073378761,
-0.0029865853,
0.0013112201,
0.0038308862,
-0.0401975587,
0.0134120751,
0.0637168139,
-0.0100578722,
0.0322356559,
-0.009024879,
-0.0086616213,
-0.0109402565,
-0.0090918625,
-0.0245413724,
-0.0121246139,
0.0192898773,
-0.0588783845,
-0.0461883731,
0.0801554322,
0.032281056,
-0.049035389,
-0.0339956507,
-0.0116383517,
-0.0706377774,
-0.0003152635,
0.0294047426,
-0.0231108498,
0.0309091583,
0.0276967622,
0.0381869748,
-0.0077556442,
-0.0254285894,
0.0357875898,
-0.0725271255,
0.0727829039,
0.0405398533,
-0.0391848348,
-0.105989337,
-0.0363343321,
0.001932229,
0.0337451436,
-0.0140885105,
0.0580049045,
-0.0101566976,
-0.0267542023,
0.0197619386,
-0.0477007516,
-0.1281281263,
-0.0323774815,
-0.0290465262,
0.0189450197,
0.071580559,
0.0270414427,
-0.0056618927,
0.0094266357,
-0.0199306179,
0.0300264694,
0.0014359038,
0.0114283348,
0.091770716,
0.0414027646,
-0.0137370247,
-0.0626678914,
0.0043696747,
-0.0055145416,
-0.0080967974,
-0.0597643964,
0.0606365129,
-0.0335633643,
0.0236378144,
-0.0070705642,
0.0166393854,
0.0272465944,
0.0191606991,
-0.0038486235,
0.0549600869,
-0.0136475861,
0.002903393,
0.0483251922,
-0.0026177331,
0.0212382246,
0.0558718406,
-0.0704383403,
-0.0614036657,
-0.0518687479,
-0.0273367539,
0.0230327006,
0.0209591184,
0.0192919597,
0.0093564186,
-0.0111780092,
-0.0189408306,
-0.042106349,
0.0302423704,
0.0077024512,
0.0058074249,
0.0087841069,
0.0070591788,
0.0326790437,
0.0099546863,
0.0032803377,
0.0215359982,
-0.0002950763,
-0.0115644,
-0.0209722631,
0.0173554607,
0.0260907821,
-0.009328695,
-0.0079179294,
-0.0169378631,
0.0231856015,
0.0903526619,
-0.0304417554,
0.0063916803,
-0.0555158556,
-0.0492286533,
-0.0269476548,
-0.0091992188,
-0.0575034916,
-0.015426076,
0.0042916574,
0.0414032191,
-0.0107953018,
-0.0397048071,
0.0542276166,
0.0629069507,
0.0249432195,
-0.0098273885,
0.0058767791,
-0.0412591472,
-0.0008407019,
-0.0429718718,
-0.02690465,
-0.0042769699,
0.0462094881,
0.0284701344,
-0.0338813439,
0.0064728907,
0.0078050941,
-0.0459086932,
-0.011036627,
-0.0119138556,
0.0179901253,
0.0194792468,
0.0103598069,
0.0767486319,
-0.0169429593,
-0.0126440162,
-0.0377614982,
0.0240930133,
0.0304002073,
-0.0144608412,
0.0390286632,
0.0096745193,
0.0339874886,
-0.0368349329,
-0.0299079884,
-0.0192918014,
-0.0345710851,
-0.045750916,
-0.0025037434,
0.0697987601,
0.0288898405,
0.0401099622,
-0.0533955023,
-0.0156524684,
-0.0257716086,
0.0454914272,
0.0188028775,
-0.0002166263,
0.0144353053,
0.010665833,
0.0260007009,
-0.0259059407,
0.0706578121,
-0.0148174074,
0.0458054058,
-0.060198836,
-0.1107960567,
-0.0172120892,
-0.0277272519,
0.0025324577,
-0.0507103764,
-0.0531583726,
-0.011585691,
-0.0450899303,
-0.0652491301,
0.0068999608,
0.0248794816,
-0.0329227559,
-0.0063321376,
-0.0006395784,
0.0869844556,
0.0366514213,
-0.0088136131,
-0.0352267288,
0.0502112806,
-0.0437344164,
-0.0099904928,
0.0234647542,
-5.414985991e-33,
-0.0271470454,
-0.0706282258,
0.0289376304,
-0.0863405988,
-0.0136649134,
0.024669148,
-0.0569732375,
-0.0246082861,
0.0545969978,
0.0370862149,
-0.0163662173,
0.0220702328,
0.0104890363,
0.0082570752,
0.0200296361,
0.0332647339,
0.0348497815,
0.0385697894,
-0.0037669553,
-0.0108854044,
0.0262892768,
0.0454355776,
0.0476202294,
-0.1095060855,
0.0136169139,
0.0283424854,
0.0135422591,
0.0196299125,
0.0235791802,
0.0654756129,
0.0119702006,
0.016541265,
0.0013474663,
-0.0021193442,
-0.0091912597,
-0.0316951014,
-0.0966406241,
0.0090940194,
-0.0071186451,
-0.0021651208,
-0.0148442145,
-0.0004432649,
0.054878097,
-0.0305800792,
0.0089574251,
-0.0010361302,
0.0192428883,
-0.0439440869,
-0.0105995303,
-0.0232135337,
-0.0392990895,
0.0541255102,
0.0225720238,
0.020376537,
-0.0302227717,
-0.0041720117,
-0.0188878048,
0.0273266658,
-0.0332895778,
-0.0050482247,
0.0400290675,
0.035852652,
0.0155929551,
-0.0183801129,
-0.0432878844,
0.0483285151,
0.0061528729,
0.0091286879,
-0.0184678752,
-0.0166172218,
-0.04826409,
0.0221547298,
0.0269740168,
0.0692342669,
0.0301247295,
-0.0415652543,
-0.0966032445,
0.0532989539,
-0.0782410428,
0.0952039883,
0.0210248847,
-0.0295195654,
-0.0542785227,
0.0206811391,
-0.0036851251,
0.0128114475,
-0.0249970518,
-0.0476440042,
0.0343256555,
0.0413584039,
-0.0024415629,
0.0415691845,
0.009995522,
-0.008435823,
-0.0108988797,
-0.0457320884,
0.0273727421,
-0.0024740016,
-0.0827434659,
-0.020618733,
-0.0180218313,
-0.022546174,
0.0165857542,
0.024947416,
0.0093025761,
0.031718377,
0.0057010073,
0.0036058389,
-0.0656928718,
0.0325836986,
0.0228817519,
-0.0076998011,
-0.0431514308,
-0.0093145538,
0.0438355505,
0.0238493253,
0.0081498818,
0.0218878277,
0.0041405368,
0.0052936804,
-0.0066495626,
-0.0468926579,
-0.0046781059,
-0.0019328378,
-0.02162591,
-0.0230068881,
-0.0239208378,
0.0171101224,
0.0434310026,
-0.0088247517,
0.0010408929,
0.0105437534,
2.689e-7,
0.0871385261,
0.0455679819,
0.0430269428,
0.0309398435,
0.0200910065,
-0.042625621,
-0.0192654375,
-0.0131968623,
0.0001316111,
0.0116374008,
0.0588485412,
-0.0147282109,
0.0319473371,
0.0526816696,
-0.0628629103,
-0.0299253613,
-0.0367658995,
-0.0312682427,
-0.001145052,
-0.0549848713,
0.0519585386,
0.020823285,
-0.0457469299,
-0.0300014876,
-0.0058744778,
-0.0625060275,
0.0519052818,
-0.0094847921,
-0.0130265448,
0.03753924,
0.0762436911,
0.0396960936,
0.0358913168,
0.0501602963,
-0.0078050573,
-0.0321869403,
0.013307686,
0.030729698,
-0.032593932,
0.0593854226,
0.0015366968,
0.0063554845,
0.0409008786,
-0.0276128985,
-0.0050901747,
-0.0394084826,
0.0189766828,
0.0178753063,
-0.023601165,
-0.024641972,
0.0258045141,
-0.0318097547,
-0.0312007871,
0.0326719917,
0.0027781746,
0.0651207939,
-0.0250422116,
-0.0734654218,
0.0368707143,
0.0396360308,
-0.012153564,
-0.0502773784,
0.0711886212,
-0.0007433022,
-0.016210746,
-0.0566723011,
0.0274755042,
2.453443825e-34,
0.0528986715,
0.0220308006,
-0.0177543592,
0.0013765442,
0.0759344548,
-0.0197261758,
-0.027137382,
0.038433034,
-0.0016336858,
-0.0432812236,
-0.0050711902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15038v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15038v1 | Online detection and infographic explanation of spam reviews with data drift adaptation | 2024-06-21T10:35:46 | 2024-06-21T10:35:46 | Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, Silvia García-Méndez, Fátima Leal, Benedita Malheiro, J. C. Burguillo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SI | Spam reviews are a pervasive problem on online platforms due to its
significant impact on reputation. However, research into spam detection in data
streams is scarce. Another concern lies in their need for transparency.
Consequently, this paper addresses those problems by proposing an online
solution for identifying and explaining spam reviews, incorporating data drift
adaptation. It integrates (i) incremental profiling, (ii) data drift detection
& adaptation, and (iii) identification of spam reviews employing Machine
Learning. The explainable mechanism displays a visual and textual prediction
explanation in a dashboard. The best results obtained reached up to 87 % spam
F-measure. | [
0.0671582669,
0.0325636044,
-0.0596156083,
0.0220227372,
-0.0170869268,
0.0057181558,
0.0101193339,
0.0416062661,
0.0005695497,
-0.0386464372,
0.0214479081,
0.0268257745,
0.0264698137,
0.1142648384,
-0.0173262767,
-0.0939662084,
-0.0179939289,
-0.0300425384,
0.0366481841,
0.034562733,
0.0478600971,
-0.0089951204,
-0.0178554039,
-0.0145130623,
-0.0197117291,
-0.0166411977,
0.0223209634,
-0.0182093158,
0.0198513027,
-0.056546703,
-0.0340743586,
-0.0019714169,
0.0037154327,
0.0070416755,
0.0000020167,
-0.053975068,
0.0102862567,
-0.0181407873,
-0.0539084449,
-0.0033428436,
0.0539769232,
-0.0410565883,
0.0354299918,
0.0442855954,
-0.0217979457,
0.0297523793,
0.0325417928,
0.0758571029,
0.0827206373,
0.0379997604,
-0.0087961117,
-0.0044690589,
-0.0251783282,
0.0124558527,
0.0143666612,
0.0088620232,
0.0295664556,
-0.0344532095,
-0.0508454069,
0.0173943099,
-0.0324285477,
-0.009178008,
-0.0432547778,
-0.0474809743,
0.0629483387,
-0.0120517183,
0.017131947,
0.0060962937,
-0.0510507673,
0.0143596604,
-0.018701084,
-0.0414945073,
-0.0031608078,
-0.0108287428,
0.024290273,
0.0075273751,
-0.0804835111,
0.0109887505,
0.013171765,
0.0158955846,
-0.0385597423,
0.0153261414,
0.0293819141,
0.0443700664,
0.0053043086,
-0.0014107164,
-0.0391705669,
-0.0155938575,
-0.0300771259,
0.0090740174,
0.0794258863,
-0.0319261551,
0.0031686232,
0.0237613637,
-0.028298391,
0.0089457473,
0.0123551413,
-0.0549144968,
-0.0026180374,
-0.0713066235,
0.0308083333,
-0.0221614949,
0.023623893,
0.0567318946,
0.01314322,
0.0102797588,
0.025234187,
-0.0037565213,
0.0012470422,
0.0458673686,
-0.048666887,
-0.0064976104,
-0.01438885,
0.0115266768,
0.030470971,
0.040447887,
-0.0571987107,
0.0367086977,
-0.0211473033,
0.0339814946,
-0.0004890742,
-0.0095119458,
0.0218163766,
0.0009044,
-0.0672627985,
-0.0000266337,
-0.0371283256,
0.0361198746,
-0.0378416516,
-0.0065430105,
-0.0217878427,
0.0371122807,
0.0181935709,
-0.008872305,
0.0350512676,
0.034375459,
0.0842527077,
-0.0066380468,
-0.0315063521,
-0.0408213139,
-0.0198223647,
0.0186148193,
-0.0617639422,
-0.0064310445,
-0.0381558277,
-0.0027441736,
-0.0020125038,
-0.0012373923,
-0.0477334224,
0.0177373048,
-0.0314501263,
0.047822658,
-0.0525523089,
0.0096651604,
0.0157568511,
-0.014734433,
-0.0499806032,
0.0045217797,
-0.035467077,
0.0408273079,
0.0606601313,
-0.0701102912,
0.0474039391,
-0.0047603361,
0.0359201357,
-0.0077439197,
0.0002707871,
0.0129054999,
-0.0886646062,
-0.0413831398,
0.0171778407,
-0.0350779295,
0.0043966393,
-0.0028970509,
0.0907013714,
-0.025078034,
-0.0126338536,
0.0196650866,
-0.039899379,
0.0279449802,
-0.0301237926,
-0.0247391425,
-0.0295236669,
0.0444893129,
-0.02348857,
-0.0171100572,
-0.0496242791,
0.0392403081,
-0.0135763828,
-0.0408450775,
-0.0250304919,
0.0172065832,
0.0231794976,
0.0098117385,
0.043203637,
0.051924333,
-0.0069260928,
0.0058308169,
0.0305435471,
0.0307996497,
-0.0179837663,
-0.0099981474,
0.0478265025,
0.0754942819,
0.0147373127,
0.0197353661,
0.0064398088,
-0.0715542734,
0.0197848473,
0.0055276267,
0.0473601185,
0.0048946589,
-0.0401913188,
0.0022718397,
-0.0461628623,
-0.0024927617,
-0.0267813057,
-0.05329087,
-0.0106949974,
0.0163280424,
0.0084157502,
-0.0227495842,
-0.0490459502,
0.0424976647,
0.0894847289,
0.019974906,
0.0362734236,
-0.0003685354,
0.0773345307,
0.0343553238,
0.0465372615,
-0.0061694016,
0.0402114317,
0.0105650993,
-0.0148611423,
-0.0030310366,
0.0584395863,
0.0409610495,
0.0419346169,
-0.0254335888,
-0.0043242672,
0.0051867473,
-0.0538546406,
0.0161563866,
0.0494900867,
0.0131285451,
0.0014080788,
-0.0247025732,
-0.0157197062,
-0.0147294523,
0.0533893108,
-0.0053785937,
0.062392626,
0.017984489,
-0.0063676448,
-0.0237523578,
-0.0193668343,
-0.0195482783,
0.0278596003,
0.0637279302,
-0.0058180923,
-0.0577866733,
-0.0073761228,
0.003994545,
-0.032683,
-0.0243331585,
0.0351691954,
-0.030907277,
-0.0600184388,
-0.0099412687,
0.0300905332,
0.0340921022,
0.0014154016,
0.006286371,
-0.0147307832,
-0.0650417954,
0.013878407,
0.0282675717,
0.0000906652,
0.0599828847,
-0.0197756942,
-0.0441329256,
-0.0227556173,
0.0291818548,
0.005747465,
0.0018278324,
0.0636544824,
-0.0518862456,
-0.0683204904,
-0.0332125388,
-0.0237464309,
-0.0444260947,
-0.0008716297,
-0.0018921844,
-0.0381117426,
0.0143378172,
-0.0422983021,
-0.0065709385,
0.0370978862,
0.0786546841,
0.0227233917,
0.0621483624,
-0.0148695912,
0.0053435885,
-0.0268281605,
0.0697929561,
-0.0279376414,
0.0098302718,
0.088810347,
-0.0008701156,
0.0038298988,
-0.0019421271,
0.0209153574,
0.0610923953,
0.004718706,
0.038343586,
-0.0465287901,
-0.0595890358,
-0.0145343328,
-0.0118992198,
-0.0027435052,
-0.0606507659,
0.0686177313,
-0.0030153503,
0.0420102254,
-0.050704848,
-0.0464739799,
0.0169029031,
0.0113721378,
-0.0092153698,
0.0099313147,
-0.0413584895,
0.0307374448,
0.0504291728,
-0.0233706497,
0.076799646,
0.0416520163,
-0.0284211691,
0.0127654364,
-0.0038083557,
0.0431419238,
0.0193541031,
-0.0305690672,
-0.1059330925,
-0.0317841209,
-0.0491765514,
0.0200002156,
-0.0400247723,
-0.0234669503,
0.0410961695,
0.0242424291,
0.0207169205,
0.0213834979,
-0.0638291836,
0.027486816,
-0.0352783799,
-0.0100593204,
-0.0050640129,
0.0000955051,
-0.0643537864,
0.0175749008,
0.0513888523,
0.0278975219,
-0.0304221511,
-0.0146913892,
-0.0355899408,
0.0026488833,
-0.0712343901,
0.0175630152,
-0.0199480429,
-0.031801898,
-0.0273561794,
0.017227428,
0.0392150767,
0.0126477657,
-0.04712658,
0.028024869,
0.0007889842,
0.0462232642,
-0.0150791872,
0.018015828,
-0.0362457521,
-0.0195928011,
0.0001800857,
0.0406469032,
-0.0235495549,
-0.0335190333,
0.0022187568,
-0.0452166051,
0.0145338802,
-0.0159267634,
-0.0514012277,
-0.091407761,
-0.084712103,
-0.0323683582,
0.0042132796,
0.0066232583,
-0.0187686421,
-0.0036285445,
0.0429304987,
0.0059822947,
-0.0666153729,
-0.0237860586,
-0.0237811729,
-0.0133654643,
0.0150187444,
0.0495573543,
0.0234462824,
-0.0511965118,
0.0184624065,
0.0288086832,
-0.0191310551,
0.0177299976,
-0.0206634719,
0.1234583557,
0.0180123262,
0.0118577164,
-0.0320854522,
0.0054469756,
-0.0337620564,
0.0412701666,
0.0387785137,
0.044093024,
0.0008920293,
-0.0381600112,
-0.0317419805,
-0.0265058335,
0.0092011075,
0.054880444,
0.0185286365,
-0.0361270942,
0.0184785016,
-0.0371960923,
-0.0043525975,
0.0256689768,
0.0414141864,
0.0237197634,
-0.0139686204,
-0.0499718152,
-0.0890586451,
0.0280055553,
-0.0191126671,
0.0476983376,
0.0625838861,
0.0263371933,
-0.0385518409,
0.0055660848,
-0.0348344222,
0.0170822851,
0.0191225801,
0.0630542338,
0.0071621453,
0.0003101702,
0.0198169146,
-0.0218990128,
-0.0007174932,
0.0199245065,
-0.0776389167,
0.0036108431,
-0.0270604324,
0.0408577956,
0.0290424693,
0.0481465347,
-0.0364420861,
-0.0510603562,
0.0393219553,
-0.0248620361,
-0.0123034269,
-0.0572453551,
-0.0234843027,
-0.014949521,
0.0223247912,
-0.010976064,
-0.0177046508,
-0.0007175935,
0.0213260707,
-0.0813305825,
-0.0419092923,
0.0239942428,
0.0135634262,
0.0127934162,
0.0235049184,
0.0312906653,
-0.0147596914,
0.0032865198,
-0.0060058585,
-0.0276783351,
-0.0349125974,
0.0077024982,
0.0111307446,
0.039929986,
-0.0265882313,
-0.0068643694,
0.0511859953,
0.0237770081,
-0.0456122905,
-0.0303439908,
-0.0037391044,
0.0153045002,
0.0270004086,
0.0024082288,
0.0256512873,
0.025568109,
0.0069489828,
0.0214791223,
0.0089071561,
0.0165917184,
-0.0016490882,
0.0135890553,
-0.0286145397,
0.0219857264,
0.0027515118,
-0.0435338877,
0.0084477123,
-0.0008903958,
-0.0003260514,
-0.0276541803,
0.0041189608,
0.0576994978,
-0.0067986357,
-0.0003173351,
0.0172927715,
0.0072440398,
0.0053704418,
0.0171170104,
0.0009073575,
0.010541535,
-0.0455601998,
-0.0071693431,
0.032337781,
-0.0270513799,
-0.0219962485,
-0.0110683767,
-0.0822913572,
-0.0136844041,
0.0498243533,
-0.0083665596,
0.0452781282,
0.0158145428,
-0.0226083603,
-0.0096699903,
-0.0588999614,
0.0133007457,
-0.0212356001,
0.0581316985,
-0.021949565,
0.0133787487,
0.0473907068,
0.0217446107,
0.0189270061,
-0.0495201983,
0.0125562046,
0.0359629951,
-0.0214562695,
-0.019386787,
-6.153151628e-33,
0.0245409589,
-0.099270992,
-0.0694112182,
0.024870405,
0.0043588756,
-0.0351663418,
-0.007015829,
-0.0179182831,
0.0109038325,
0.0356507376,
0.0180026442,
0.0302013736,
0.0016168884,
0.023384098,
-0.0131885987,
-0.01819041,
0.0526674576,
-0.0053791567,
-0.0016945341,
0.0450883657,
0.0477672368,
0.0230868794,
-0.0212003961,
-0.0420073979,
0.0592463724,
0.0036785579,
-0.0785885453,
0.0346911475,
-0.000756846,
0.065829508,
0.0061413706,
0.0448919758,
0.0341519192,
0.0202719662,
-0.0078024175,
-0.0300338399,
-0.0414477997,
-0.0159729533,
0.0189330913,
0.0476550721,
0.0387298465,
0.0082703419,
0.0731095299,
-0.0084268181,
-0.026147943,
0.040130768,
0.0681742355,
-0.0513142347,
-0.0377466939,
-0.0251269322,
0.0147350766,
0.0144254314,
-0.0423932113,
0.0508868359,
0.0258907769,
0.0716428012,
0.0377806053,
0.0104020638,
-0.0793132409,
0.0236562546,
0.0007983584,
-0.0292285625,
0.0170175787,
-0.0080065578,
-0.0210348312,
0.0325945467,
-0.0205058083,
0.0335733183,
-0.0248103626,
0.036824692,
-0.0286252927,
0.0022331616,
0.0532531999,
0.0376274288,
0.0200312994,
-0.0731991306,
-0.061114762,
0.0260745101,
0.0336884819,
0.0058287275,
0.0364453346,
-0.0399832502,
-0.0409287214,
-0.0192377008,
0.016652083,
-0.0345679484,
-0.0291777216,
-0.0308463667,
0.0059622684,
0.0236478895,
-0.0244990587,
-0.0455470756,
-0.0596896969,
-0.0643453598,
-0.0587827228,
0.0173232798,
0.0040740138,
0.0047171735,
0.0483280271,
-0.059413787,
0.0503717437,
-0.0134969465,
-0.0476134047,
-0.0164103266,
0.0099064307,
-0.0373102464,
0.0794986859,
-0.0180177279,
-0.0647513568,
0.0266028624,
0.0144719528,
0.0272563528,
-0.0260775294,
0.0315748006,
-0.0297360197,
-0.0088165905,
-0.003542417,
0.0539799258,
0.0454330817,
0.0457733348,
-0.0054868115,
0.0323142037,
-0.0351040214,
-0.0021444259,
-0.009995399,
-0.0851581022,
0.0068465592,
-0.0480241403,
0.0347865149,
-0.1172176301,
-0.0154880155,
-0.0375726372,
2.686e-7,
0.0292217322,
0.0677583963,
-0.0115448469,
-0.065364264,
0.0660318062,
0.0483922102,
-0.009644066,
0.0131723136,
-0.0112686893,
-0.0120068723,
0.0074811564,
-0.0213886574,
0.005056663,
0.0183124281,
-0.0313863419,
-0.0348692834,
-0.0473376848,
0.0054229717,
-0.0543489046,
0.0506750457,
0.04680188,
0.0337795056,
0.0257715825,
-0.0010497465,
0.0140631497,
-0.0262632687,
-0.0319670066,
-0.0195082407,
-0.0061920849,
-0.0027591896,
0.1119908318,
-0.0663789138,
-0.0104851797,
0.0115460716,
-0.0510907657,
0.011726344,
-0.0542045683,
-0.013286991,
-0.0022009395,
0.0151048554,
-0.0083488338,
-0.0093082311,
0.0693742707,
-0.0559325628,
0.042729564,
0.0020979319,
-0.0416063406,
-0.0724997148,
-0.0135913482,
-0.0319985263,
0.0352868326,
-0.0006901759,
-0.0265140627,
0.0319548175,
-0.0038501595,
-0.019476084,
-0.0128143337,
-0.0412015542,
0.0230860431,
-0.0243103541,
0.0123475883,
0.0111152241,
0.0018622773,
-0.0412618443,
0.061686527,
0.0433566794,
0.0252590813,
2.349631603e-34,
0.0621106289,
-0.0344129093,
-0.0194546804,
-0.031726446,
0.0271607693,
0.0117355436,
-0.0062044966,
0.0101774456,
0.0493548363,
-0.0568659082,
0.0218704399
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15032v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15032v1 | GiusBERTo: A Legal Language Model for Personal Data De-identification in Italian Court of Auditors Decisions | 2024-06-21T10:25:26 | 2024-06-21T10:25:26 | Giulio Salierno, Rosamaria Bertè, Luca Attias, Carla Morrone, Dario Pettazzoni, Daniela Battisti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advances in Natural Language Processing have demonstrated the
effectiveness of pretrained language models like BERT for a variety of
downstream tasks. We present GiusBERTo, the first BERT-based model specialized
for anonymizing personal data in Italian legal documents. GiusBERTo is trained
on a large dataset of Court of Auditors decisions to recognize entities to
anonymize, including names, dates, locations, while retaining contextual
relevance. We evaluate GiusBERTo on a held-out test set and achieve 97%
token-level accuracy. GiusBERTo provides the Italian legal community with an
accurate and tailored BERT model for de-identification, balancing privacy and
data protection. | [
0.0484813116,
0.0832510665,
-0.0098658474,
0.0287561044,
-0.0332015008,
-0.0027069529,
0.0537103675,
0.0417994596,
0.0163811632,
-0.0315840803,
-0.040737614,
0.0419391915,
-0.0189625733,
0.0154610286,
-0.0185027607,
-0.0511289574,
0.0417086743,
0.0326430053,
0.0548525602,
0.0134900259,
0.0115607772,
0.005123511,
0.027743645,
0.0239615347,
-0.0048436611,
-0.0043963855,
0.0196724534,
-0.0006579095,
0.012031937,
0.0028965436,
0.0015814462,
0.0832958147,
0.0313342884,
0.0448935032,
0.0000015741,
-0.0423607789,
-0.0329125561,
0.0140839973,
-0.0262674205,
0.0048586908,
-0.0130676571,
0.0050171698,
-0.026980266,
-0.0215882845,
-0.0197836217,
0.0070350757,
0.0118276849,
0.0390478,
0.0564116165,
0.0929593071,
-0.0152526358,
-0.0467084162,
0.0071326336,
-0.0216093231,
0.0009010887,
-0.0135566071,
0.0354553685,
-0.0840244144,
-0.0279374514,
0.0038840203,
0.0478707291,
0.0377066098,
-0.0123536419,
0.0000867402,
-0.0170432106,
0.0279252008,
-0.0610537566,
0.0188464206,
0.014273393,
0.0381059647,
0.0135206841,
-0.0452371277,
0.0235148072,
0.0219619628,
0.0388649777,
0.0329534672,
-0.0073611755,
0.0185258444,
-0.0331891738,
-0.0004557734,
-0.0056523881,
0.021772746,
0.0091999406,
0.0250537787,
-0.0020978774,
0.0063494989,
0.0284256656,
-0.034296345,
-0.0025624868,
-0.0265321862,
-0.0168035682,
-0.0823110417,
0.0794135556,
0.0333260633,
0.0578990802,
0.0074054934,
-0.0634358153,
-0.0411677249,
0.0310049858,
-0.0606639497,
0.0031298266,
-0.0268594176,
-0.0281957667,
0.0568257943,
-0.0399388634,
0.0596508048,
-0.0010887287,
0.0335941575,
-0.0009683126,
-0.0332445316,
-0.0263762586,
-0.0184273329,
-0.0592733398,
0.0568057597,
-0.0882803202,
0.0189646389,
-0.0085740825,
0.0150952972,
-0.0236975476,
0.0273643918,
-0.0273086727,
-0.0144427251,
0.0082362574,
-0.028980229,
-0.0370590873,
-0.030799292,
-0.0366957076,
0.0042957999,
-0.0193980355,
-0.0001103923,
0.0246147104,
-0.024386622,
0.0543937087,
-0.035340853,
0.018537527,
0.0366481058,
0.0213505514,
-0.0609416813,
-0.0592623651,
-0.0376044177,
0.0123933535,
-0.0333446972,
-0.0108520603,
-0.0165561922,
0.0177251492,
-0.0649594739,
-0.0261180121,
-0.0653139651,
-0.0016943497,
0.0302554835,
-0.0267076045,
0.0764493868,
-0.0560447164,
-0.0349092595,
0.0381746925,
0.0091715911,
0.0650079548,
-0.02858104,
0.0133504597,
0.0296141561,
0.0231592059,
-0.0000458272,
0.0520464033,
0.0313500315,
0.0320595056,
-0.0246487819,
-0.0061128917,
0.0287600178,
-0.0289838985,
-0.0196072403,
0.0111080669,
0.0455312692,
-0.0100532183,
-0.0234004632,
0.0557338223,
0.0546718091,
-0.0341602825,
0.0476499647,
-0.0415348485,
0.0023251134,
0.0153688099,
-0.0240860227,
-0.0551662706,
-0.0100766569,
-0.0165723301,
-0.0184587333,
-0.0839144662,
-0.0005364073,
-0.0350893587,
-0.0154925045,
0.0186047498,
-0.0522949137,
0.007393247,
-0.0014149192,
0.017773401,
0.0366080254,
-0.038987264,
0.024092745,
-0.0102827903,
-0.0756012201,
0.0036489875,
-0.0452022962,
0.0341666043,
0.0848502889,
0.0565537736,
-0.0407945029,
-0.0110499756,
-0.0360668711,
-0.0220631771,
0.0188294277,
-0.0111966096,
0.0000935731,
0.036491368,
-0.0413447358,
-0.0622491352,
0.0585483201,
0.0020498766,
0.0407298543,
0.0206077788,
0.0004458306,
0.0405923203,
-0.0637449697,
0.0250695273,
0.0425426885,
0.0018849571,
-0.07624235,
0.0238337517,
0.0372519568,
-0.0037336848,
0.0217164811,
0.0028188345,
-0.0209612995,
0.0352530666,
0.0227781627,
0.0265481398,
-0.0155372117,
0.0209811963,
-0.0071127019,
-0.017717313,
-0.0161768533,
0.0063769924,
0.015644066,
-0.0266517363,
-0.0213066805,
-0.022518754,
-0.0084834108,
0.018653946,
-0.0392611921,
-0.0036836409,
-0.0071153678,
0.0346726887,
-0.0221668016,
0.0513211638,
-0.0170770921,
-0.0014763349,
-0.0270620603,
0.0195144974,
0.030100137,
-0.0372235142,
-0.0378874689,
-0.0540677533,
-0.0184548888,
0.0121995723,
0.0418633111,
0.0088122208,
-0.0076024798,
-0.050319314,
-0.0996267945,
0.0080805505,
0.0075565046,
0.0260074101,
-0.0047222977,
0.0169807859,
-0.0307943672,
-0.0176105779,
-0.0202284344,
-0.0810377598,
-0.0270039458,
-0.0097591244,
0.0618398264,
0.0057533868,
-0.0523437299,
-0.0038331237,
-0.0216249786,
-0.0002583576,
0.0283042733,
0.011263309,
-0.0651784986,
-0.0025669958,
-0.0008102746,
-0.0360118672,
0.0678275824,
-0.0114146052,
-0.0033224195,
-0.0263427403,
0.054444693,
0.0193306804,
0.0315421075,
0.0033154741,
0.0217037071,
-0.0218121205,
-0.0082454327,
-0.0266220868,
0.0032139705,
-0.0055293511,
0.0435755998,
-0.0206032321,
-0.0660455227,
0.0857459977,
-0.0208104737,
-0.0043123201,
-0.007940623,
-0.0126600778,
0.005005186,
0.0175238606,
-0.0169021394,
-0.0132972226,
-0.0522321463,
-0.0011612077,
0.0316157937,
-0.0102273505,
-0.0014150718,
0.0481551439,
-0.0089111123,
0.0718366951,
-0.0047303215,
0.0228355583,
0.0065738913,
0.0853328481,
0.0272632334,
0.0411031581,
0.0231229458,
-0.0749176145,
0.0290185474,
-0.0377911627,
0.0207037888,
-0.0394047536,
0.0096705081,
-0.0233771242,
0.0201481879,
0.0400204733,
-0.0323694497,
-0.0221921336,
-0.0666876659,
0.0261171497,
0.0403378457,
0.0052371495,
-0.0179732181,
-0.0735780895,
-0.0114530977,
0.0059334827,
0.0358354226,
-0.0023020497,
0.0111337611,
-0.0410493799,
0.0430144407,
-0.0295283608,
-0.05387621,
0.0112930769,
-0.0087097157,
-0.0580223724,
0.0090603363,
0.0490518324,
0.0190772414,
0.0085456446,
-0.0186903626,
-0.0153237712,
-0.0848574862,
-0.0539145954,
-0.0168108996,
0.0000897203,
-0.0350968391,
-0.017604243,
0.1146083549,
0.0125521077,
-0.0230113789,
-0.0338881277,
0.0654319152,
-0.0002927567,
-0.0002303227,
0.0291791055,
-0.0757723376,
0.0154137257,
0.0053913668,
0.0145812305,
-0.0571638718,
-0.0508771166,
-0.018270582,
-0.0516323745,
0.0313936584,
-0.0144437142,
0.0106378663,
-0.0375850722,
-0.0612723455,
-0.0019954005,
-0.0010486466,
-0.016479766,
-0.0205100756,
-0.0178342126,
-0.0161482487,
0.0317611396,
-0.0505853593,
-0.0253047273,
-0.0201860666,
-0.0500308648,
0.0432151631,
0.0466681607,
0.0686494187,
-0.0555865057,
-0.0097848177,
0.0114503801,
0.0124551253,
-0.0224018879,
-0.0051415474,
0.0883757994,
-0.0068400768,
-0.0017484634,
-0.0530662835,
0.0138460025,
0.0315090828,
-0.0271945652,
0.012309486,
-0.0011329229,
-0.0308287218,
0.0108398935,
0.0165866036,
-0.0524146743,
0.0081304247,
0.0518666245,
-0.0052537662,
-0.0065322919,
-0.0033620126,
-0.0000102704,
0.0526916608,
-0.0080982288,
0.0665631294,
-0.0089154504,
-0.0729006678,
-0.0517337769,
-0.0463363491,
-0.0164921768,
0.0020224082,
0.0031871065,
0.0568024814,
-0.0041108774,
0.0376287624,
-0.0071554547,
-0.0597520024,
0.0491708107,
-0.0730748698,
0.0284060873,
-0.0533374064,
0.0347144008,
-0.0008405184,
0.031671755,
-0.0497682057,
0.0296075121,
-0.0149355149,
-0.0165820736,
-0.0002433184,
-0.0061686342,
0.0211852007,
0.0408119299,
-0.0323889405,
-0.076744169,
0.0495028235,
0.0149593903,
0.0150217824,
-0.0374425724,
0.0355374888,
-0.0186473764,
-0.0046772906,
-0.012607594,
-0.0178381056,
0.0218410306,
0.0587110445,
-0.0499276221,
-0.0470573828,
-0.0187140405,
0.0067497524,
0.0405897349,
0.0432060957,
0.0240305588,
0.0357833989,
-0.0761745051,
-0.0051369299,
-0.0169795379,
0.0289910659,
0.0121360663,
-0.0223005135,
0.0532598905,
0.0326897763,
0.0110202953,
0.0306959972,
-0.0289433617,
0.0142221404,
-0.0684541985,
-0.0211917777,
0.0238506719,
0.0368526503,
-0.0156648438,
-0.023179885,
-0.0018102766,
0.0569105782,
0.0395042561,
0.0522946604,
-0.0545179695,
0.0172904506,
0.0027966427,
-0.0017902482,
-0.0168840494,
0.0251840651,
-0.0314246006,
0.0390689336,
-0.0616259836,
0.0736597031,
-0.0025750555,
0.0090995505,
-0.0174544118,
-0.0203245934,
0.0071857427,
0.0106569221,
0.0101535711,
-0.0025745553,
-0.0077566914,
-0.0105446642,
-0.0005807226,
-0.0312393922,
0.0278800465,
0.0402144529,
0.0366656259,
0.0318761133,
-0.0362080447,
-0.0471481234,
-0.0520354696,
-0.0070631155,
0.0163527355,
0.0261972845,
-0.0453664996,
-0.0377779379,
-0.0171886627,
-0.0128693478,
0.0105377333,
0.0129457032,
-0.0076291617,
0.0114742396,
0.0342730284,
0.0181915052,
0.0038618385,
-0.0413225293,
-0.0374162793,
0.0266042724,
0.0415482931,
-0.0375202894,
-0.0358578302,
-4.772019969e-33,
-0.030260032,
-0.0103542898,
0.0190013237,
0.0109835528,
0.0076882211,
0.0280608293,
0.0068423655,
-0.0442570783,
-0.0332319364,
-0.0051314849,
-0.0426914096,
0.0100054834,
0.0204924978,
0.0124624763,
-0.0448846631,
0.0102715464,
0.0624854378,
0.0215869918,
-0.000686885,
0.0188708846,
0.0222622585,
0.0475629568,
0.0539833456,
-0.0986489132,
0.0587758757,
0.006139941,
-0.0711683109,
0.0084448829,
0.0081621883,
0.0269426443,
-0.0157094356,
-0.0454280488,
0.0208576582,
0.0334120244,
0.0073837042,
0.0806659311,
-0.1191993728,
-0.0226543881,
-0.006066293,
0.0520149134,
0.0562560931,
-0.0416627154,
0.0557093397,
-0.0599175468,
-0.0376287028,
0.0599008054,
0.0468829721,
-0.0051678475,
-0.041519437,
-0.0417438336,
-0.0176507663,
0.0286139548,
0.0080420496,
0.013427644,
0.042393595,
0.0126312729,
-0.0018521022,
-0.0264700539,
-0.0628264993,
-0.0291679986,
0.036394272,
-0.0370652862,
-0.0005299324,
-0.009284853,
-0.0026567751,
0.0514076464,
0.0744835585,
-0.0000623417,
-0.0057945373,
-0.0215960685,
0.0400781631,
0.0426001102,
0.032896664,
-0.0032348002,
-0.0129303699,
-0.0482411273,
-0.0779208466,
0.0358863622,
-0.0050611855,
-0.0272343718,
0.0431888625,
-0.0337974541,
-0.0576405264,
-0.0009076712,
-0.0371782817,
-0.0601883307,
-0.0010332504,
0.030199023,
0.0010061215,
-0.0331786424,
0.0068967384,
0.0213760473,
-0.0105432142,
-0.0144559778,
-0.0307997949,
0.0306267049,
0.03943488,
0.0254536364,
-0.0004544389,
0.0290565118,
-0.0281430054,
-0.0531794541,
0.0221302938,
-0.0135782547,
-0.0237392616,
-0.0125016989,
0.0964000672,
-0.0409427024,
-0.0684834793,
-0.0012928519,
0.0141318329,
0.0336640403,
0.0378299057,
0.0458368249,
0.0022465379,
0.0219448376,
0.0252858847,
-0.0187148806,
0.0502121598,
0.0271348618,
-0.0292681828,
0.0246517472,
0.0052929949,
0.0222069025,
0.0324642062,
-0.0200625937,
0.0052165817,
0.0662148744,
0.0385592952,
-0.0009842842,
0.0137586789,
0.0250940993,
2.238e-7,
0.0618261918,
0.0010429608,
0.0033253655,
-0.0224449262,
-0.0112432074,
0.0356138311,
0.053871531,
0.0639541,
0.0064414027,
0.0340842158,
0.0215026326,
-0.0232066046,
0.0200598929,
0.0288784523,
-0.0675145462,
-0.0430826731,
-0.0239416994,
-0.0242578909,
-0.0901484564,
0.0576000735,
-0.0068703652,
0.087271072,
0.0822532102,
-0.052206777,
-0.0376848951,
-0.0510038324,
0.050033737,
-0.0286936034,
-0.0410592817,
0.0268310141,
0.0643981472,
0.043953862,
0.0088587496,
0.0279753711,
-0.0134655591,
0.0473744571,
-0.017167028,
0.0755174905,
-0.0043799435,
0.0339404382,
0.0168087203,
-0.0757792443,
-0.0319138914,
-0.0294886604,
0.0504595973,
0.0146963578,
0.0036942461,
0.018379217,
-0.0538106561,
-0.0367159285,
0.022600852,
0.0124349631,
-0.0510797314,
0.0152748441,
0.0314287208,
-0.0163551383,
-0.0034225818,
-0.0601162128,
0.0292772986,
-0.0111362357,
-0.0275185406,
0.0222471543,
0.0152442958,
-0.0201435424,
0.0192438047,
-0.0482690111,
0.0723135769,
2.001683438e-34,
-0.0083919484,
-0.0010050603,
-0.0444639474,
0.035836488,
0.0518161617,
0.01487449,
0.007726796,
0.0213746484,
-0.0129278274,
-0.0476813875,
0.0122455433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15019v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15019v1 | MedOdyssey: A Medical Domain Benchmark for Long Context Evaluation Up to 200K Tokens | 2024-06-21T09:46:57 | 2024-06-21T09:46:57 | Yongqi Fan, Hongli Sun, Kui Xue, Xiaofan Zhang, Shaoting Zhang, Tong Ruan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Numerous advanced Large Language Models (LLMs) now support context lengths up
to 128K, and some extend to 200K. Some benchmarks in the generic domain have
also followed up on evaluating long-context capabilities. In the medical
domain, tasks are distinctive due to the unique contexts and need for domain
expertise, necessitating further evaluation. However, despite the frequent
presence of long texts in medical scenarios, evaluation benchmarks of
long-context capabilities for LLMs in this field are still rare. In this paper,
we propose MedOdyssey, the first medical long-context benchmark with seven
length levels ranging from 4K to 200K tokens. MedOdyssey consists of two
primary components: the medical-context "needles in a haystack" task and a
series of tasks specific to medical applications, together comprising 10
datasets. The first component includes challenges such as counter-intuitive
reasoning and novel (unknown) facts injection to mitigate knowledge leakage and
data contamination of LLMs. The second component confronts the challenge of
requiring professional medical expertise. Especially, we design the ``Maximum
Identical Context'' principle to improve fairness by guaranteeing that
different LLMs observe as many identical contexts as possible. Our experiment
evaluates advanced proprietary and open-source LLMs tailored for processing
long contexts and presents detailed performance analyses. This highlights that
LLMs still face challenges and need for further research in this area. Our code
and data are released in the repository:
\url{https://github.com/JOHNNY-fans/MedOdyssey.} | [
0.0251371507,
0.0604371652,
0.0072743921,
0.0327625759,
-0.0641355962,
0.0140544632,
0.0349941589,
0.0220316257,
-0.0212044809,
-0.0248564035,
-0.0154581135,
-0.0821089372,
0.0203382801,
0.0316004977,
0.0095583936,
-0.0261505786,
0.0292339344,
-0.013385592,
0.0249231122,
-0.0053469744,
-0.0332907923,
-0.0260701776,
-0.0119197313,
0.0473860167,
-0.0107719516,
-0.016883174,
0.0305588525,
-0.0172605366,
0.0053753057,
-0.066082105,
-0.0124564227,
0.0380617268,
-0.0012537907,
0.027224971,
0.0000019141,
-0.0675933436,
-0.021768555,
0.0322769545,
-0.0387869552,
0.0045277537,
0.0455055684,
-0.0357210524,
-0.0055255173,
-0.0017372487,
-0.0230802838,
-0.0257233139,
0.0139118703,
0.0393693522,
0.0259317085,
0.0611105002,
-0.018326208,
-0.015616402,
0.0158361662,
-0.0518224798,
0.0136122294,
-0.0882779732,
0.0584044047,
-0.028798217,
0.0499685034,
0.0015595822,
-0.0260250121,
0.0357591249,
0.0289474167,
0.037143413,
-0.0065604313,
0.0451190211,
-0.0347007252,
0.0153088616,
0.0131158866,
0.0662667379,
0.0189341716,
0.0110864509,
0.0240793899,
0.0162204038,
-0.0278716423,
-0.0422386825,
-0.0353957973,
0.0190142449,
-0.026049573,
-0.0010006253,
0.0394256748,
0.0240184031,
0.0485230908,
-0.0029659667,
-0.0675431788,
0.0394618064,
0.0287474878,
-0.0413649306,
-0.0113011207,
-0.0175074171,
-0.027744852,
-0.0465634987,
0.023165945,
0.0244039595,
-0.0610627979,
0.0145026743,
-0.0289075039,
-0.0270938538,
0.0687921643,
-0.0406373143,
-0.0226236042,
0.014698402,
-0.0396152064,
0.0871639922,
-0.0005996046,
0.0077754166,
-0.0489766747,
-0.0072912979,
-0.0333118886,
-0.0236188509,
-0.0223088488,
0.0163387824,
0.0037306708,
0.0031971897,
-0.0573263057,
-0.022151567,
-0.0725778341,
-0.008084802,
-0.0170098096,
0.0341678038,
0.0034332557,
0.0144887837,
-0.033472158,
0.0013277738,
0.0074991221,
-0.0050465255,
-0.0291262846,
0.0119957048,
-0.0256762095,
-0.0380539298,
0.0015040649,
0.0279570725,
-0.0067478833,
-0.0459227078,
0.0207838994,
0.0849333182,
0.0363281406,
-0.0173522439,
0.0019101861,
-0.0412532985,
-0.0635339022,
-0.0519072525,
-0.0210121982,
-0.0771150589,
0.0165298786,
0.0296788774,
0.0063765217,
-0.0533627681,
-0.006396661,
0.0010283728,
-0.0441923179,
0.0739672557,
-0.0061447928,
-0.0030142507,
0.0078477981,
0.0526604541,
0.0070193158,
0.069185324,
0.002138363,
-0.0327315293,
0.0329152718,
0.0028603449,
-0.0096209645,
0.0181128196,
0.0254536495,
-0.0017991038,
-0.0119711859,
0.0489187427,
0.0407606103,
0.0879543647,
-0.0270295963,
0.0777734816,
0.000301629,
-0.0480093099,
0.0087830052,
0.0682574585,
0.0362545364,
-0.0128407395,
0.0293729696,
-0.0485585555,
-0.0062567871,
-0.0021611494,
-0.0376674905,
-0.0306871068,
0.025051184,
0.0141216638,
0.0143169658,
0.0082233613,
-0.0207834765,
-0.0017606399,
-0.0481262431,
-0.0435937867,
-0.0346576273,
-0.0106691616,
0.0524688847,
-0.0271651093,
-0.0135147925,
0.0644010231,
0.0435127281,
-0.030427495,
0.0025696787,
-0.0420260765,
-0.0123419808,
0.0633214191,
0.0585835651,
-0.0676277429,
-0.018077556,
-0.0156028103,
0.0346898548,
0.0279130824,
0.0103242965,
-0.0033022517,
0.0539327599,
-0.0371585079,
-0.0277425591,
0.0092316335,
0.0199510846,
-0.0216647312,
0.0323188268,
0.0396683998,
0.0082823848,
-0.0501014218,
0.0386104174,
0.0385634378,
-0.0826082304,
-0.0117848897,
-0.0030643893,
0.0012104281,
0.0522935465,
0.0274889916,
-0.0282473657,
0.0361579172,
0.041716937,
-0.070008792,
0.0015286499,
-0.0031707347,
-0.0886116326,
-0.0255768932,
0.0331917107,
-0.0324577801,
-0.0132152252,
-0.0147166532,
-0.0154997855,
-0.0316590033,
-0.037658222,
-0.0247336812,
0.063276954,
0.0176697522,
0.0353470705,
-0.0043656277,
0.0084656915,
-0.0381111056,
0.0498629585,
-0.0258966796,
0.0155932363,
0.0272885133,
0.0044258167,
0.0046380716,
-0.0354725681,
-0.0493357144,
0.0074263923,
0.0017908708,
0.0072258324,
-0.0130145522,
-0.0090742707,
-0.0404864065,
-0.0277534556,
-0.1376718134,
0.005648057,
-0.0239621345,
0.0253324192,
0.0154700466,
0.0345111303,
-0.0019819529,
0.0171657894,
-0.0420292988,
-0.0377204902,
-0.0053357999,
0.0462381057,
0.017141629,
0.0406297296,
-0.0092466865,
-0.016444955,
-0.0212589949,
-0.0388161577,
0.0645695031,
-0.0115681477,
0.0075209439,
-0.0128717804,
0.0127311684,
-0.012612639,
0.0008912593,
-0.0232555252,
0.0059317085,
0.0126085393,
-0.0170415137,
0.0518253371,
0.0295688026,
0.0228774324,
0.0155558418,
0.0121555729,
-0.0046066367,
0.0017832327,
-0.0095514851,
-0.0141634727,
-0.0109720174,
-0.039391093,
0.0024651461,
-0.0047680028,
0.0722684711,
-0.0062490688,
-0.0063188495,
-0.0166320167,
-0.0104755862,
-0.0461486988,
0.0130190346,
-0.0173747297,
0.0206004716,
-0.037739493,
0.0452686101,
-0.0063734525,
-0.031556461,
0.0953963846,
-0.0419673957,
0.0311138593,
-0.0549116693,
-0.0153435357,
-0.0697630048,
0.0704053566,
-0.0252834093,
0.0132637015,
-0.0157230143,
-0.0167335346,
0.0184627585,
0.014740319,
-0.0238157976,
-0.0547225215,
0.0914841294,
-0.0114733949,
0.033843983,
-0.0056817685,
-0.0617400184,
-0.0394857824,
-0.0338052362,
-0.0328936353,
0.0098756896,
0.0429072343,
0.0082516903,
-0.0394555703,
0.0296494104,
-0.0015044758,
0.0846203417,
0.0271147285,
0.0194979049,
0.0024506559,
0.0142463483,
0.0155805955,
-0.0014592388,
0.009562036,
-0.0226939861,
0.0422010273,
0.0682186335,
0.032743603,
0.0253806282,
-0.014204503,
0.001668399,
-0.0144081609,
-0.0280312076,
-0.0190752447,
0.017746428,
0.0552261584,
-0.0700555667,
-0.0146115422,
0.1162665412,
0.0083322432,
-0.0846415162,
0.0275189877,
-0.0123121282,
-0.0086473403,
-0.0011652656,
-0.0143119926,
-0.0918174312,
-0.0456866845,
0.0156970136,
0.0139495749,
-0.0066975849,
-0.0589930639,
0.0279355384,
-0.0714815855,
-0.000859695,
0.0034345789,
-0.0686512738,
-0.0153027922,
-0.0437015109,
0.0099322973,
-0.0151772443,
0.0264233593,
0.0234296974,
-0.0101886597,
-0.0267536081,
-0.0246096738,
-0.0173521508,
-0.0949598327,
0.0709209442,
-0.0405416973,
0.0694442093,
0.0291890129,
-0.0040547722,
-0.005096931,
-0.0033330554,
0.0342554487,
-0.0194760393,
-0.0083940551,
-0.0047022835,
0.0512759909,
-0.0022268121,
-0.0154819973,
-0.0197948925,
0.0247899983,
-0.0471681841,
-0.0236792155,
0.0223318823,
0.0799757838,
-0.0102523528,
0.0044901799,
-0.0426441841,
0.0103644086,
0.0232938938,
0.0848261788,
0.0168442465,
-0.0206017625,
-0.038772624,
0.0157622714,
0.0044962633,
-0.0108923791,
0.0006804297,
0.026544407,
-0.0206075553,
-0.0116952378,
-0.0439404659,
-0.0014618034,
0.0380690508,
0.0434180386,
0.0035877398,
0.0598549843,
-0.004401464,
-0.0080006132,
-0.0859300569,
0.0363780148,
-0.0058880537,
0.0617253929,
-0.0780358762,
0.0122836409,
0.0537723787,
0.0068678502,
-0.011566068,
0.0484642833,
-0.0560607761,
-0.044175677,
0.0140124215,
0.0013231602,
0.025870841,
0.0253960826,
-0.0051654065,
-0.0248882715,
0.0505695418,
0.0293704681,
-0.05707445,
0.0254714377,
0.0102000013,
0.0010320552,
-0.0039299768,
0.0304125771,
-0.0292839929,
0.0102586737,
0.0096546449,
0.0383285433,
0.0010672988,
-0.0083659636,
-0.0143462736,
0.0171123073,
0.017951319,
-0.0131077347,
-0.01207003,
0.0204465427,
0.0236815773,
-0.0409066938,
0.0074546388,
-0.0080806995,
0.0092304749,
0.0254728142,
-0.0062181437,
0.0046263398,
0.015913574,
-0.0179539081,
-0.0174448807,
-0.0287601668,
0.0710835978,
-0.0025998703,
-0.0100898677,
0.0801676288,
-0.0133120045,
-0.0088536656,
-0.0116303368,
-0.0213503093,
0.0254537743,
-0.036905583,
0.0419458784,
0.0114931054,
0.0240606293,
-0.0190975387,
0.0483121835,
-0.0536525622,
0.0053177993,
0.0204917602,
0.0308682527,
0.0500900894,
-0.0039089443,
0.0209355839,
-0.0101625994,
0.010165995,
-0.0485756509,
0.0301471371,
-0.0312287621,
0.0146395871,
0.0216303952,
0.0398212634,
-0.0094096242,
0.0364999436,
0.1050589755,
0.0283598863,
0.0527251884,
0.0281405449,
-0.0165640563,
-0.0451636016,
-0.0252345186,
-0.0017459824,
0.0398996174,
-0.0564902723,
-0.0093697514,
-0.078130655,
-0.0693088472,
0.0239745993,
-0.0268617515,
-0.0291425157,
-0.0042848438,
0.0274107624,
0.0522816256,
0.0187580567,
-0.0052816332,
-0.0099904574,
0.0647701398,
-0.002214974,
-0.032626193,
0.0242505223,
-5.988817885e-33,
0.0273746364,
-0.0333196484,
0.0318063833,
-0.0375632867,
-0.043534454,
0.0719977617,
-0.0345408507,
-0.0068805101,
0.0165462065,
0.0074610021,
-0.0296333507,
0.0043718736,
0.0059741153,
0.038505882,
-0.0197304618,
-0.032299187,
0.0194003973,
0.021441251,
0.0072697839,
0.0390926152,
-0.0004148958,
0.045200251,
0.0083106486,
-0.0738701597,
-0.0009172373,
0.0051275617,
0.0434537083,
0.024116274,
-0.0227608811,
0.0913818628,
-0.0332197472,
0.0278084707,
0.0590198301,
-0.0455168225,
-0.0047567012,
0.0096666384,
-0.0735230371,
0.0212002825,
0.0136497561,
-0.0344807021,
-0.0275977179,
-0.0375642329,
0.0538536459,
0.0047637383,
-0.0397068448,
-0.0218005776,
-0.0090368548,
-0.0445397794,
-0.0370040126,
-0.0265387148,
-0.0241597816,
0.0599449873,
0.018973643,
0.0029003671,
0.0099974014,
-0.0532276854,
-0.0144414939,
0.0652214289,
-0.0330941565,
-0.0130737228,
-0.011797348,
0.0257013086,
0.0258094482,
-0.0278166309,
0.0003517548,
0.0597646423,
0.0224047489,
0.0143411765,
-0.0395564847,
-0.0167806596,
-0.0322970487,
0.0509055294,
0.0376113728,
0.0394942947,
0.0338425897,
-0.0408208668,
-0.0989623442,
0.0038840158,
-0.036721807,
0.033918187,
0.0330954492,
-0.0027403657,
-0.0581013598,
-0.013986351,
-0.0325055867,
0.0265596323,
-0.0276827142,
0.0002421641,
0.0332330577,
-0.0031114265,
-0.0064701834,
0.0271540359,
0.0312176477,
-0.0434544683,
-0.0005911591,
0.0192172769,
0.0338830985,
0.0106170224,
-0.0233573671,
0.0361206084,
-0.0353483967,
-0.0152727105,
0.0147607923,
0.011313471,
0.0397135131,
-0.0196925178,
0.0247571636,
-0.0230393875,
-0.0699922815,
-0.0258729719,
-0.0158862956,
-0.0141872261,
-0.0164192803,
0.0346020162,
0.0533636846,
0.0191364624,
0.0136397667,
0.0683336481,
0.0253265984,
-0.0046025873,
-0.0390584357,
-0.0343975127,
0.003918313,
-0.006407334,
-0.0311865956,
-0.0152713032,
-0.0235407129,
0.0379801728,
0.06032959,
-0.0366313383,
-0.0092374319,
-0.0084803393,
2.592e-7,
0.0634604394,
0.0445608199,
0.0310479347,
-0.0486886762,
0.060557019,
0.0102708833,
-0.0101946173,
0.0243388508,
-0.0582457334,
-0.0065770028,
-0.0112110991,
0.0006147908,
0.0607844032,
0.036002852,
-0.0675136372,
0.0070069707,
-0.0736278594,
-0.0216106772,
-0.0556466617,
-0.0020837476,
0.0369260386,
0.0964406282,
-0.0271349419,
-0.0347404666,
0.0291231591,
-0.0515531935,
0.0348878652,
-0.0467022918,
-0.0106489696,
0.0229776204,
-0.0105058616,
0.0201271717,
0.0420572944,
0.0081666019,
0.0028289454,
0.0043794746,
-0.0039146254,
0.1182267293,
-0.0096580731,
-0.0016623914,
0.0191588774,
-0.0275922567,
-0.0183947962,
-0.036622256,
0.0760649592,
-0.0389999934,
-0.0421401933,
-0.0671847761,
0.0178818963,
-0.0245994907,
0.0469052382,
0.0265674237,
-0.0127199069,
0.0161437187,
0.0257661771,
-0.0017847625,
-0.039566569,
-0.093796894,
-0.0350352228,
0.021399701,
-0.0740573555,
-0.0362543538,
-0.0048414664,
-0.0092945416,
0.0317541063,
-0.0961518511,
0.0085616689,
2.688252265e-34,
0.0497435443,
-0.0150419986,
-0.0083264895,
0.0086629437,
0.0197868738,
-0.0381549969,
-0.0221286956,
0.0096231624,
0.0063355938,
-0.0726778731,
0.0010337837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15015v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15015v1 | GraLMatch: Matching Groups of Entities with Graphs and Language Models | 2024-06-21T09:44:16 | 2024-06-21T09:44:16 | Fernando De Meer Pardo, Claude Lehmann, Dennis Gehrig, Andrea Nagy, Stefano Nicoli, Branka Hadji Misheva, Martin Braschler, Kurt Stockinger | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL | In this paper, we present an end-to-end multi-source Entity Matching problem,
which we call entity group matching, where the goal is to assign to the same
group, records originating from multiple data sources but representing the same
real-world entity. We focus on the effects of transitively matched records,
i.e. the records connected by paths in the graph G = (V,E) whose nodes and
edges represent the records and whether they are a match or not. We present a
real-world instance of this problem, where the challenge is to match records of
companies and financial securities originating from different data providers.
We also introduce two new multi-source benchmark datasets that present similar
matching challenges as real-world records. A distinctive characteristic of
these records is that they are regularly updated following real-world events,
but updates are not applied uniformly across data sources. This phenomenon
makes the matching of certain groups of records only possible through the use
of transitive information.
In our experiments, we illustrate how considering transitively matched
records is challenging since a limited amount of false positive pairwise match
predictions can throw off the group assignment of large quantities of records.
Thus, we propose GraLMatch, a method that can partially detect and remove false
positive pairwise predictions through graph-based properties. Finally, we
showcase how fine-tuning a Transformer-based model (DistilBERT) on a reduced
number of labeled samples yields a better final entity group matching than
training on more samples and/or incorporating fine-tuning optimizations,
illustrating how precision becomes the deciding factor in the entity group
matching of large volumes of records. | [
0.0212535225,
0.0854791477,
0.0041620093,
0.0119406842,
-0.0381687917,
0.0085972371,
0.0041420371,
0.0380027965,
0.0213071574,
-0.0471862033,
-0.0045940094,
-0.0273511391,
0.0147492001,
0.029715525,
0.0262639355,
-0.0012330974,
0.0624391735,
0.0177337341,
-0.0360020623,
-0.0263529494,
0.0197974965,
0.0395320617,
0.0063244719,
-0.0110323466,
-0.0159945395,
0.0200197585,
0.0292147771,
0.0125751998,
0.0288202632,
-0.0001900598,
0.0021788899,
0.0231681708,
-0.0299563371,
0.0403837971,
0.000001891,
-0.0675155222,
-0.0560268462,
-0.00015776,
0.0024565498,
-0.0407976471,
-0.0240278151,
-0.0738584548,
0.0317676589,
0.0130276531,
-0.0318392664,
-0.0530730709,
0.0529213883,
0.0369758382,
0.0449683927,
0.082290031,
-0.0560625792,
-0.0358780771,
0.0082118269,
-0.0417677015,
0.0106525868,
-0.0663580969,
0.0689671636,
-0.0023835441,
0.0026195925,
-0.0410026982,
-0.0205870811,
0.02367994,
-0.0347951539,
0.0090119755,
0.0174573436,
0.0297766086,
-0.0322066285,
0.0447736047,
-0.0182467494,
0.0941492915,
-0.0062413663,
-0.0279762223,
0.0455707312,
-0.0183625184,
0.0068572965,
0.0322926864,
0.0097085396,
-0.0311724897,
-0.0438249856,
0.0197739266,
-0.0387019627,
-0.0075877132,
0.0254507903,
-0.0128020542,
-0.0461707786,
0.0066772015,
0.0029706664,
0.0157232899,
-0.0187032651,
0.0240044761,
-0.0442483313,
-0.0641020387,
0.020217834,
0.0211609658,
-0.0219433326,
-0.0147282341,
-0.0851029158,
-0.0121354088,
-0.006265908,
-0.0219805129,
0.0059085432,
0.0136502748,
-0.0018946144,
0.0625849366,
-0.0408573672,
0.0419809967,
-0.0197793916,
0.030743666,
-0.0266932957,
-0.0621100478,
-0.0600148551,
0.0552833974,
-0.0464332104,
0.0453111865,
-0.0109900227,
0.0021369378,
-0.0254466254,
-0.0120167285,
-0.0603532903,
0.0468666144,
-0.0173332449,
-0.0128779756,
0.0253755935,
-0.0397499166,
-0.040355511,
-0.0085452273,
-0.0244399793,
0.0138652679,
-0.0560790524,
-0.0235922355,
0.0401666798,
-0.006804633,
0.0360729285,
-0.0368410423,
0.0447438918,
0.0482430235,
0.0437567793,
-0.0128833465,
-0.0516434126,
-0.0085999304,
0.0168266464,
-0.0255284403,
0.0023608368,
-0.0223077498,
0.0706485063,
0.0292648375,
-0.0078165373,
-0.0619608238,
-0.0188562255,
-0.0392781049,
-0.0797495842,
0.0900297388,
0.0212937258,
0.0356755964,
-0.008818144,
-0.060187459,
-0.0363385491,
-0.0054845023,
0.0169026349,
-0.0323882662,
0.0385259055,
-0.0158085097,
0.0111135375,
0.0546198636,
0.0530808158,
-0.0204825699,
0.0195122361,
0.0668760613,
0.0211365484,
-0.0195701905,
0.058920987,
0.054911375,
-0.0094611505,
-0.0578952022,
0.0504364558,
0.0034184768,
0.0206652991,
0.0188724045,
-0.0426818021,
0.0144477077,
-0.0465037413,
-0.0038118458,
-0.0442755111,
0.0157561433,
-0.027107263,
-0.010207097,
-0.0075634629,
0.0483346619,
-0.0389962196,
0.0445078798,
0.0032372449,
-0.005599278,
0.0229942799,
0.0092900172,
0.0255079325,
-0.0050406838,
-0.0371844843,
0.0716427937,
0.0041530463,
0.0330272429,
-0.0324870832,
-0.0159850437,
-0.0172935072,
0.054461576,
0.0556823127,
0.0086774612,
-0.0160390865,
-0.0187461711,
-0.0195658263,
-0.0046705143,
0.0483411439,
-0.0078619439,
-0.0127166705,
-0.0256098025,
-0.0322912708,
0.0663791746,
-0.0430165045,
0.051535666,
0.0279048793,
0.0431956351,
0.0044356184,
-0.0381299257,
-0.0041801236,
0.0184168182,
-0.0140849138,
0.0035945217,
0.0083273593,
0.0358260013,
-0.0165302306,
0.0115655242,
0.0062962654,
-0.0201179609,
-0.0027969074,
0.0075273057,
-0.0317738615,
-0.0054137646,
0.0008345737,
0.0084696291,
0.019774016,
-0.0461526439,
-0.042350933,
0.0182284378,
-0.0269530434,
-0.0251387972,
-0.0158279333,
-0.02706342,
0.0128561985,
-0.0081962515,
0.0170119647,
-0.0199419931,
0.0276449621,
-0.0167243201,
0.0361566022,
0.0073789884,
0.0195326768,
-0.0495292842,
-0.0038002802,
0.0468767285,
-0.039383065,
-0.0033808269,
0.0243433695,
-0.0159030315,
0.054333549,
0.0235852972,
-0.0563803352,
-0.0151063269,
-0.0085801389,
-0.0271834675,
0.0024258483,
0.0272171441,
0.0330491476,
0.0042190407,
0.0253938194,
-0.0045122849,
-0.0187059604,
-0.039796412,
0.0024656306,
0.0532454774,
-0.0019204615,
0.050178539,
-0.0070389095,
-0.0450483747,
-0.0124374041,
-0.0122088641,
-0.0489389226,
0.0583651029,
0.0213065147,
-0.0670481399,
-0.0610644929,
0.0203421433,
-0.0419712774,
0.0334003903,
0.0086590089,
0.0487375744,
-0.0207603294,
0.0482243113,
0.0073287459,
0.0165487994,
-0.0214976855,
-0.0590558238,
-0.0023219867,
0.010129747,
-0.0620646775,
0.0004425235,
-0.0045278156,
0.0184502173,
0.0100018186,
-0.0170212872,
-0.0010130524,
-0.0013780836,
0.001993747,
-0.0386450104,
-0.0535030216,
0.0213155262,
0.0254664458,
0.053487774,
-0.0301388577,
-0.0264870692,
0.041153837,
-0.0036042528,
-0.037840344,
-0.0164483953,
0.0564994998,
-0.011993954,
0.0212406199,
0.0174222477,
-0.0205355491,
-0.0637785122,
0.0380371176,
0.009900419,
0.0214233864,
0.00498403,
0.0034037011,
-0.022659475,
-0.0016037694,
0.0684717596,
-0.0295536239,
0.0886484087,
0.0261588302,
0.0698930919,
0.0045491862,
-0.0572899915,
-0.0416502021,
-0.0081991572,
0.0324270055,
0.0115868915,
0.0137067335,
-0.0293102246,
-0.1044839323,
0.0605412796,
-0.0305684507,
0.0130970702,
0.009586988,
-0.0343122222,
-0.0185502432,
0.020426577,
0.0387529507,
-0.0324637517,
0.0363908671,
-0.0196584463,
-0.0054502585,
0.0011429577,
0.0596886501,
0.0210684799,
-0.0164518859,
-0.0136351883,
0.006185771,
-0.0478063188,
0.0088848956,
-0.028995607,
-0.0095913187,
0.0083992174,
0.0524904057,
0.0709757134,
-0.0004596902,
-0.020633705,
-0.0151847471,
0.0469807759,
-0.0099355504,
0.0143546043,
0.0571235083,
-0.0875862837,
0.0130062867,
-0.0142647633,
0.0085338205,
0.0517689474,
-0.0766348243,
-0.0217392966,
-0.0996713638,
0.008872767,
0.0078637404,
-0.0244882647,
-0.0529555082,
-0.0443555377,
0.0283193924,
-0.0546216555,
-0.0151802786,
-0.0260197073,
-0.0312525779,
-0.0401460826,
0.0016114758,
-0.0144399088,
-0.0005673701,
0.0169724952,
-0.0915926099,
-0.0065102009,
0.0113894986,
0.0301149283,
0.0162535477,
-0.0168614555,
-0.0309267677,
-0.0122976955,
-0.0577344038,
0.033475861,
0.0919381082,
-0.0219830684,
-0.0096392948,
0.0106778201,
-0.0008833146,
-0.030826306,
-0.0064792843,
-0.0225798469,
0.0256530046,
0.0089448011,
-0.0193274822,
0.009224318,
-0.0241934936,
0.0078284042,
0.0672912598,
-0.0288168713,
-0.0209871754,
0.0027966623,
-0.0143874595,
0.0540577769,
-0.0138632422,
0.0092088049,
0.0516276844,
-0.0603312925,
0.0107770963,
-0.0500969552,
-0.0320386551,
0.0283001121,
0.0358800106,
-0.0021597319,
0.0076368749,
0.0289145708,
-0.0634509549,
-0.0429858156,
0.0146447504,
-0.05617062,
0.0843967795,
-0.0577066876,
0.007088352,
0.0122167263,
0.016650686,
-0.0661143586,
0.0140477233,
-0.0843319967,
-0.0702413842,
-0.0222840551,
-0.0575363338,
0.021094095,
0.0674393475,
-0.0296540521,
0.0180589743,
0.0013361658,
0.0442176722,
-0.0157649163,
-0.0096363826,
-0.0074623334,
-0.0479826219,
-0.0240736343,
0.020387603,
-0.0539940186,
0.0400720723,
0.0274701025,
0.0044039339,
-0.019384129,
-0.0584601499,
0.0121878125,
0.061627809,
0.0320313536,
0.0484121367,
0.0095579633,
-0.0505831279,
-0.002695241,
0.0515737645,
0.0148222251,
0.0045661274,
-0.0508925989,
0.0426385216,
-0.0140034668,
-0.0032804536,
-0.0063298312,
0.0072510978,
0.0125524877,
-0.0914508849,
-0.0173843671,
-0.0385060571,
0.0156287011,
0.0220723189,
-0.0240243524,
0.0264951158,
0.0332004204,
0.0784733519,
0.0462175831,
-0.057003554,
-0.0389997549,
0.0468200967,
0.0436679348,
-0.0257424694,
-0.0404136516,
-0.0389678441,
0.004003807,
-0.0385634527,
-0.0052318871,
0.0595195889,
0.0125156213,
0.0182998441,
-0.004938622,
-0.0053483439,
-0.0120349787,
-0.0044912407,
-0.0044269133,
-0.002569702,
0.0079204151,
0.0159980543,
-0.0110842008,
0.0369564258,
0.0768663511,
0.038891796,
0.0710644722,
-0.0515591912,
-0.0367066003,
-0.0349872634,
-0.0249339286,
0.0243371148,
-0.0425528549,
-0.0049547483,
-0.0180686992,
-0.0472233035,
-0.0579816736,
0.0385290869,
-0.0154342279,
-0.018542232,
0.0062749707,
0.0179412141,
0.0166560784,
0.0358949378,
-0.0067662266,
-0.0051526534,
-0.0114485566,
0.0130641814,
-0.0229458231,
-0.0160048567,
-5.479583447e-33,
-0.0182474665,
-0.0519462153,
0.026583191,
0.0204002615,
0.0017486367,
0.0212151352,
0.0200922787,
-0.0780193061,
-0.0398562141,
-0.029911045,
0.0012192497,
0.0208342411,
0.0215625893,
-0.0179569181,
-0.016851319,
-0.020800788,
0.038417194,
0.0083523327,
-0.0250788797,
0.0036395753,
0.0187352244,
0.0429098681,
0.0134624429,
-0.1043574437,
0.0070089689,
-0.0454399921,
-0.0480293892,
-0.0113006122,
0.0536760092,
0.0645918921,
0.0009437476,
0.007464183,
0.007816405,
-0.0509991683,
-0.0144021017,
-0.0268892534,
-0.0967310965,
-0.0178761836,
-0.0362425074,
0.0148167508,
0.0648087785,
0.0165932085,
0.0364421494,
-0.0159874279,
0.0068029733,
-0.0143088931,
0.029913513,
0.0150454426,
-0.0085279448,
-0.0225586556,
-0.039877031,
0.0401902646,
0.0295801125,
0.0489513427,
0.0381585509,
0.0234773476,
0.0249259714,
0.0104266312,
-0.0721683875,
0.033270359,
-0.0126095172,
-0.0111546181,
0.0176755469,
0.0033527634,
-0.01053173,
0.0448924936,
0.0177371055,
-0.005508271,
0.04925799,
-0.0063368008,
0.0041639786,
0.0487337559,
-0.0084387185,
0.0537210219,
0.0148781314,
-0.0447369888,
-0.0703274384,
0.0770800337,
-0.0420692414,
-0.0354491509,
-0.0224425308,
0.0067543932,
-0.0175796207,
-0.048734583,
-0.0054117069,
0.0054892977,
-0.0415351279,
0.0035207502,
0.0296840798,
0.0178295914,
-0.0126998015,
0.0623863116,
0.003241638,
-0.0669241697,
-0.0961012468,
0.0290944241,
-0.014710038,
0.025140075,
0.0149774365,
0.0138397859,
-0.0213168338,
-0.0762631297,
0.0415110625,
-0.0150335124,
0.0479894951,
0.0281211864,
0.0723301321,
-0.0053645144,
-0.0699049011,
0.029787289,
0.0090803038,
-0.001335657,
-0.0625105277,
-0.0942503586,
0.0224699564,
0.0566299893,
0.0353786498,
0.0037967667,
0.0752863288,
-0.0121688759,
0.0099306535,
0.0153618837,
0.0041934219,
0.0649351925,
-0.0041670101,
0.0022373991,
-0.006305337,
-0.0010674748,
0.0577451997,
-0.0314617492,
-0.0208738986,
0.0069018505,
2.758e-7,
0.050848037,
0.0435592793,
0.0515591912,
0.0416306593,
0.0042609936,
0.0309058037,
-0.0128572183,
0.0571832843,
-0.0192336049,
0.0149352504,
0.0284084827,
0.0103357555,
0.0458476432,
0.0620097481,
-0.042194277,
0.0349894054,
-0.0581736453,
0.0126270391,
-0.0840800479,
0.0263627451,
0.0060482039,
0.0396452993,
0.0209092461,
-0.0189321581,
-0.0054675364,
-0.0437199287,
0.0487929322,
-0.0285214391,
-0.0187879838,
0.033091832,
0.031170262,
-0.0173617005,
-0.0063408213,
0.0875539631,
-0.0202301275,
0.0523934625,
0.041802153,
-0.0074396199,
-0.0288892519,
0.0540959276,
-0.0582843833,
-0.0620737597,
-0.0125943553,
-0.0348248668,
0.0526593067,
-0.0270890985,
0.0156487245,
-0.0030240342,
-0.0437217392,
-0.0073029166,
0.0041294876,
0.057057105,
-0.0336889736,
0.026911173,
0.0358665399,
0.0123195993,
-0.0024604723,
-0.0392160639,
0.0460955389,
0.0314218402,
0.0133906845,
0.015195556,
-0.0073876819,
0.0127801271,
0.0713121518,
-0.0165800024,
0.0044794995,
2.60075416e-34,
0.0098255547,
-0.0008613866,
-0.0226786695,
-0.0209350381,
0.0702918246,
-0.0412104167,
-0.0463734791,
0.0478366315,
-0.0253418591,
-0.0515690222,
-0.002340117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15000v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15000v1 | Unveiling the Impact of Multi-Modal Interactions on User Engagement: A Comprehensive Evaluation in AI-driven Conversations | 2024-06-21T09:26:55 | 2024-06-21T09:26:55 | Lichao Zhang, Jia Yu, Shuai Zhang, Long Li, Yangyang Zhong, Guanbao Liang, Yuming Yan, Qing Ma, Fangsheng Weng, Fayu Pan, Jing Li, Renjun Xu, Zhenzhong Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly advanced user-bot
interactions, enabling more complex and coherent dialogues. However, the
prevalent text-only modality might not fully exploit the potential for
effective user engagement. This paper explores the impact of multi-modal
interactions, which incorporate images and audio alongside text, on user
engagement in chatbot conversations. We conduct a comprehensive analysis using
a diverse set of chatbots and real-user interaction data, employing metrics
such as retention rate and conversation length to evaluate user engagement. Our
findings reveal a significant enhancement in user engagement with multi-modal
interactions compared to text-only dialogues. Notably, the incorporation of a
third modality significantly amplifies engagement beyond the benefits observed
with just two modalities. These results suggest that multi-modal interactions
optimize cognitive processing and facilitate richer information comprehension.
This study underscores the importance of multi-modality in chatbot design,
offering valuable insights for creating more engaging and immersive AI
communication experiences and informing the broader AI community about the
benefits of multi-modal interactions in enhancing user engagement. | [
0.0367388092,
-0.0064774938,
-0.0472981445,
-0.0171262808,
-0.0167347062,
-0.0021448806,
0.0371570885,
-0.0122982748,
0.0569922067,
-0.0260395184,
-0.0509527437,
-0.0013066632,
0.0222214349,
0.0789874271,
-0.0039874963,
-0.0662265345,
0.0038854999,
-0.0333084501,
0.0184213333,
0.0338142179,
0.0403658822,
0.0035565062,
-0.0576158613,
0.0808036625,
-0.0567730069,
-0.0298725851,
-0.057673499,
0.0285582598,
0.0023727964,
-0.0367471427,
-0.0124188205,
0.0395652838,
0.0412219018,
0.0435822681,
0.0000018328,
-0.0133838095,
0.0223385803,
-0.0156544875,
-0.0526704602,
-0.0226861108,
0.0571706668,
0.0470816977,
0.0057886573,
0.0247170217,
-0.0176089834,
0.0533867814,
0.0803929642,
0.0564084761,
0.082200259,
0.0105281742,
-0.0322456621,
0.0186747219,
0.0165504813,
0.020379005,
0.0442789942,
-0.0459610187,
-0.0080496119,
0.0322915576,
0.050044138,
-0.0082698381,
-0.0150791993,
0.0276909936,
0.0192061421,
-0.0620220825,
0.0142763369,
0.0625805482,
-0.0165562257,
-0.0696593001,
-0.0260454156,
0.0929357782,
0.0365196764,
0.0252863187,
-0.0200516749,
0.0195122268,
0.0502995066,
-0.0043014493,
-0.0883840248,
-0.0304433238,
0.0069252774,
-0.0143601783,
-0.05363084,
0.0020305158,
-0.0010102842,
0.0069297696,
0.0060128202,
-0.0254958402,
0.0141596133,
-0.0161157269,
-0.0209898353,
-0.0033263743,
0.0042160461,
-0.0623752326,
-0.0189026203,
0.0327818468,
-0.0437685549,
0.0365183763,
-0.0356152467,
-0.0005074132,
-0.0097548272,
-0.0369183756,
-0.0340294614,
0.0627883896,
-0.0623980314,
0.0745275691,
0.0385083593,
0.019700544,
0.026066998,
-0.0257898085,
0.0111328159,
-0.0001829319,
-0.0315843448,
-0.0558492877,
-0.0120715024,
0.0339731388,
-0.0143588893,
-0.0912757516,
-0.0184913334,
0.0810897723,
0.0166470688,
0.0292853471,
-0.0127844261,
-0.0012262149,
-0.0247468483,
0.0396522321,
-0.0300140493,
0.0303582735,
-0.0350763649,
0.0075907544,
0.0383597985,
-0.1004864797,
0.0109792352,
0.0229607802,
-0.0000688274,
-0.0152810803,
-0.0144452704,
0.0534961782,
0.0022937558,
-0.0497623868,
0.0189931244,
-0.0381945334,
-0.0071885213,
-0.0539500751,
-0.0114416238,
-0.0129259257,
0.038601689,
0.0111403288,
0.0077794441,
-0.0088744611,
0.0116731981,
0.0195158701,
-0.0064234487,
0.0523647033,
-0.0304031409,
0.0155129051,
0.0453561209,
0.0495204106,
-0.0115521047,
0.0687677786,
0.0460968204,
0.0233494136,
0.0463286638,
-0.0223659612,
0.0223440323,
0.0350544751,
-0.0666303262,
-0.0238204375,
0.0328211524,
-0.019482214,
-0.0137845799,
0.0288892817,
-0.0172740463,
0.0307686385,
-0.0404144973,
0.0184893031,
0.107107006,
0.0601462014,
-0.031273786,
0.005738894,
0.0078923814,
0.0207253732,
0.0575022325,
0.0315523595,
-0.0136349341,
0.0625268668,
0.0075895861,
-0.0278523713,
0.0489093289,
0.0120233465,
-0.0471599922,
-0.0528233871,
0.02284077,
-0.0365377925,
0.0679661408,
0.0166056566,
0.035895098,
-0.0196979661,
-0.0252586361,
-0.0109210201,
0.0061317296,
-0.0543438718,
-0.0241890438,
-0.005961325,
0.0042732195,
0.0971470103,
0.0434379429,
-0.0078187333,
-0.0244856495,
-0.0180959366,
0.0070381104,
0.0671093389,
0.026214283,
0.0290542506,
0.0243815687,
-0.0121459896,
-0.0134602869,
-0.0500801541,
-0.0133383274,
0.0031159273,
-0.0066612996,
0.0259397812,
-0.0330663174,
0.0220846348,
0.0101143355,
0.0065282192,
-0.0073410119,
0.0235823225,
-0.0807436481,
0.0328470282,
0.0112160593,
0.022323776,
0.0011285371,
-0.0191743821,
0.0209742505,
0.0257071517,
0.0008896729,
0.0909021795,
-0.0146761434,
0.0114936475,
0.0597562715,
-0.0219521374,
-0.0211875048,
-0.0012844317,
0.0352823399,
0.0018063515,
0.0210786592,
-0.0698269531,
0.0709096342,
-0.0058953301,
0.0259178746,
-0.012237831,
0.0332104191,
-0.0052256668,
-0.0051234248,
-0.0019053805,
-0.0369792357,
0.0344679505,
-0.0096770488,
-0.0004521447,
-0.0152124176,
-0.0039184634,
0.038808614,
-0.0114159556,
-0.00848528,
0.0258124042,
-0.0390595347,
-0.0990394726,
-0.0116024846,
-0.1547768563,
-0.0270729866,
0.0143236266,
-0.0370272063,
0.0184770282,
0.051592242,
-0.0179275945,
-0.0132581396,
-0.0229769796,
0.0049997717,
0.0154728675,
0.0376393236,
0.0318436362,
-0.0170551799,
-0.0196328945,
-0.0502459817,
0.034767475,
0.0264558718,
0.0323659964,
0.0502003841,
-0.0321566612,
-0.0008396801,
-0.0173590854,
-0.0515146255,
-0.0063522873,
-0.0434932746,
-0.0641274899,
0.0485135615,
0.0245436616,
0.0498628132,
0.0488096252,
0.0342856832,
0.0592303388,
-0.0033373989,
-0.0187966544,
-0.0525053665,
0.016133653,
0.0352104753,
0.0048703481,
-0.0317790732,
-0.0322078057,
0.0171200354,
0.0231485832,
-0.0153746968,
0.0618533045,
-0.0329428166,
0.013789501,
0.0160406735,
-0.066129081,
-0.0006950693,
-0.0200515315,
-0.037870314,
0.0247306582,
-0.0094625531,
-0.055203937,
0.0480448306,
-0.0280188192,
-0.0469821766,
0.0090694726,
0.0014119981,
-0.0103292149,
0.0401611701,
-0.0321259573,
0.0302697271,
0.0075526414,
-0.0145218968,
-0.0091934428,
-0.0038890843,
0.0054771109,
-0.0565901436,
0.0104545932,
-0.0112437736,
-0.0172869731,
0.0358842351,
-0.0270332042,
-0.0324432701,
-0.0298048705,
-0.0518516041,
-0.038072791,
0.0391529985,
-0.044377774,
-0.0613320544,
0.0166641977,
0.0523886755,
-0.0173903704,
0.0070817764,
-0.0346175954,
-0.0111582316,
0.0051905024,
0.0384035856,
0.0389642343,
-0.0261786431,
-0.0249504969,
0.081325464,
0.0392821208,
-0.0163934156,
-0.018129427,
-0.0144236414,
-0.024628602,
0.0173188653,
0.0090309307,
-0.0267550629,
0.0123861404,
0.0621336997,
-0.0224092137,
0.0134602897,
0.100028038,
0.0056923209,
-0.0400235727,
0.00060849,
-0.0477011949,
0.0311187189,
-0.0019709242,
0.0093081938,
-0.060190659,
-0.0261192154,
0.0326229334,
-0.0306668244,
-0.0228543449,
0.00237883,
-0.0087381229,
-0.0803383514,
0.0060741333,
-0.0197999198,
-0.004747258,
-0.0229697581,
-0.023485031,
0.0296098646,
0.0336085297,
0.0281819832,
-0.0097666569,
-0.008126149,
-0.027449999,
-0.0019576261,
-0.0427080207,
0.0078325691,
0.0120120477,
-0.0119186165,
0.063093394,
0.0364271663,
0.0651340634,
-0.0150060626,
-0.0047169081,
0.0128468191,
0.0770437643,
0.0137278903,
0.0163897276,
0.0704100281,
-0.0095524527,
0.0080977222,
-0.0439360514,
-0.0079264622,
0.030193001,
-0.019471541,
0.0089877583,
0.0157555807,
-0.010069361,
0.0192247536,
-0.035058111,
0.0453605764,
0.0124966102,
0.0148921488,
0.0289923362,
-0.0730966106,
-0.0270194765,
-0.0426781178,
-0.003274004,
-0.0084854616,
-0.0345254466,
-0.02671762,
-0.0189331826,
-0.003697535,
-0.0488983914,
-0.0613370053,
0.0297318064,
0.0012187045,
-0.0074913772,
0.0447681546,
-0.0218337197,
0.0372146145,
0.0369207524,
0.0248105563,
-0.0403740816,
0.0205649175,
-0.0220486,
-0.0059513529,
-0.0126423622,
-0.0868568942,
0.0228304379,
-0.0088788439,
-0.0564470291,
-0.024475852,
-0.0355243832,
0.0162597988,
0.0163728464,
0.0134328241,
0.0118281459,
-0.0396232195,
-0.0193065964,
-0.0127146635,
-0.0303388126,
-0.013935307,
0.0088741183,
0.0640482754,
0.0129559543,
-0.0183040779,
-0.0316623561,
-0.0454690196,
-0.0326290913,
-0.004749679,
-0.0392897502,
-0.075338684,
0.0223813597,
0.0300112776,
-0.0071096257,
-0.0055345171,
0.0074880407,
0.0238397829,
-0.0085948864,
-0.0381205603,
-0.00339621,
-0.0382014476,
-0.0144939562,
-0.0273157414,
0.0037623555,
0.0016320209,
0.0233192537,
-0.0313556083,
0.0113892602,
-0.0116046425,
-0.0052225632,
0.0006683146,
-0.0328732654,
-0.020648187,
-0.000256664,
0.0028841465,
-0.0067122173,
0.0150249042,
0.0135789774,
0.0219987035,
0.0811207667,
-0.0183788929,
-0.0538285114,
0.0047150739,
0.0542879663,
-0.0390740037,
-0.0293986239,
0.0322582945,
0.0283348579,
0.0542334914,
0.0445084348,
0.013874338,
-0.0283990558,
0.0195413604,
-0.0162446145,
0.0337069072,
0.0000097149,
-0.0089103617,
-0.0245337263,
0.0171723869,
-0.0248503536,
0.0074909246,
0.0319421776,
-0.0327023193,
0.0326395035,
-0.0201814491,
-0.0228091814,
-0.0355102718,
0.006804822,
0.0324327126,
0.0680210814,
0.000734847,
0.0042455699,
-0.0285581909,
-0.0585549027,
-0.0142150922,
-0.0139547158,
0.0040151081,
-0.0271054264,
0.0370237976,
0.0324048735,
-0.0090394868,
-0.0075581963,
-0.043349985,
-0.010519769,
-0.0335311927,
0.0089141829,
-0.0293872468,
-5.379302391e-33,
0.0024862157,
-0.0635042489,
0.0244913455,
0.0193504095,
-0.0821444914,
0.0087048616,
-0.0480990298,
0.0429510586,
-0.0160072949,
-0.0161135197,
-0.0123547502,
0.012942248,
0.0047335797,
-0.0108662266,
-0.004689456,
-0.0132379588,
0.0433659069,
0.0046108146,
-0.0340125859,
0.0280377101,
0.0032440098,
-0.0058759958,
-0.0164373983,
-0.0875386,
0.0292009711,
0.0199764036,
-0.0212241001,
-0.0220030788,
0.0421868004,
0.0631319731,
-0.0103150094,
0.0450351052,
0.014952817,
0.0264352392,
-0.0051710224,
0.0660493076,
-0.0316988565,
-0.0114933308,
0.031235639,
0.0527508408,
-0.0427172966,
-0.0313651115,
0.0067790938,
-0.0271727704,
0.0065159947,
0.0019729156,
0.0405377373,
-0.0116045522,
0.0007275228,
0.0333911888,
-0.0804978609,
0.0017751533,
-0.0676494017,
-0.0621446185,
0.0101157641,
0.0850342885,
0.0502997115,
0.0325754657,
-0.0362108275,
0.0632100776,
-0.0555400364,
-0.0338771082,
0.0554517545,
0.0087981848,
0.0492670536,
0.0713199601,
0.0349597894,
0.030396942,
-0.045104757,
-0.0271077342,
0.0201917812,
0.049365662,
-0.0032175416,
0.0370551683,
-0.0035980642,
-0.0386181772,
-0.0166415107,
0.0352092348,
0.0603218935,
0.0373866595,
0.0240204465,
0.0486747399,
-0.0846500099,
0.0336141624,
-0.0317758657,
0.0278748665,
-0.0442530029,
-0.0774286613,
0.0179277863,
0.0062737633,
0.0032643981,
-0.0637702048,
0.0525530912,
-0.0407347642,
0.0032768592,
0.0105404025,
-0.0281264577,
0.0478737801,
-0.0100246454,
-0.0310583133,
0.0386714712,
-0.0103000309,
0.0403472483,
-0.0033004705,
0.0399555601,
0.0087015452,
-0.0038480374,
0.0231982078,
-0.0181216672,
-0.0240481906,
-0.0150940819,
0.0137611283,
0.0168262012,
-0.003549271,
0.0443935059,
-0.0125526525,
-0.0653102174,
0.0176680852,
0.0180772431,
0.0274879951,
-0.0410924852,
-0.0555608086,
-0.0490831397,
-0.0364268534,
-0.0340446346,
-0.0051530376,
-0.0506503843,
-0.0401486978,
0.0106059927,
-0.0595370121,
-0.0428450331,
-0.0246983506,
2.608e-7,
-0.0390641429,
0.0293888431,
-0.0159694366,
0.0256501287,
0.0504571237,
0.0489374362,
0.0039572306,
0.0011103982,
0.0332491994,
-0.0177019555,
0.0197473392,
0.0404603072,
0.05861485,
0.0023085936,
-0.0734189972,
-0.0320201702,
-0.03977051,
-0.0028680093,
-0.0444701687,
0.0366091691,
0.0754566863,
0.0264449231,
0.0018911733,
-0.0046138377,
0.0175935812,
-0.0241686013,
0.0384207256,
-0.0412474535,
-0.0241241474,
0.0066931923,
0.0080613075,
0.0267657004,
0.0210519489,
0.0005974274,
-0.0049032769,
0.003738424,
0.05625958,
0.0406077206,
0.0141675053,
-0.0472615138,
0.0126698753,
0.0427917093,
-0.0049902895,
-0.0417481735,
0.0583383664,
-0.0375502519,
-0.069671683,
-0.0545537472,
-0.0196968298,
-0.054554712,
0.0552176796,
-0.0338577032,
-0.0463674739,
0.0039470149,
-0.018327225,
-0.0210841838,
-0.0248813163,
-0.02930969,
0.0092340223,
-0.0221880935,
-0.0886338353,
-0.0575255491,
-0.0704443678,
-0.0343094468,
0.028154131,
-0.0131322071,
0.018015461,
1.541364672e-34,
-0.0057643144,
-0.039110221,
0.0381734185,
0.0900956318,
0.0408639088,
0.0304316804,
0.030910233,
0.0120179458,
0.0389143601,
-0.0664911866,
0.0063197659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14993v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14993v1 | Disability Representations: Finding Biases in Automatic Image Generation | 2024-06-21T09:12:31 | 2024-06-21T09:12:31 | Yannis Tevissen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Recent advancements in image generation technology have enabled widespread
access to AI-generated imagery, prominently used in advertising, entertainment,
and progressively in every form of visual content. However, these technologies
often perpetuate societal biases. This study investigates the representation
biases in popular image generation models towards people with disabilities
(PWD). Through a comprehensive experiment involving several popular
text-to-image models, we analyzed the depiction of disability. The results
indicate a significant bias, with most generated images portraying disabled
individuals as old, sad, and predominantly using manual wheelchairs. These
findings highlight the urgent need for more inclusive AI development, ensuring
diverse and accurate representation of PWD in generated images. This research
underscores the importance of addressing and mitigating biases in AI models to
foster equitable and realistic representations. | [
0.0068484042,
0.0637078807,
-0.0331386328,
0.0006233801,
0.0113083096,
0.0288678091,
0.0827271864,
-0.0236948375,
0.0559519827,
-0.0609427392,
0.0425163805,
0.004139612,
0.022740772,
0.0064282063,
0.0002634191,
-0.1293349266,
-0.0122824339,
0.0700755343,
-0.0131131699,
-0.0308165532,
-0.0087681254,
0.046338886,
0.0150508834,
0.0538475625,
-0.0473552346,
-0.0509284437,
0.0773553029,
0.0466604568,
0.0000931671,
-0.0310878642,
-0.0097788805,
0.0283140168,
0.0537719317,
-0.0156682245,
0.0000018528,
-0.0429409966,
0.050335031,
0.0092132585,
0.0180517156,
-0.0235554203,
0.0268300939,
-0.0332249813,
0.0041243392,
0.0071766754,
0.0019035663,
0.0362749808,
0.0981201604,
0.0604055487,
0.0246855076,
-0.0112248519,
-0.0115048885,
0.0019535446,
-0.0379592739,
0.0144149382,
0.0265805274,
0.0289435424,
0.0018977941,
-0.0273408964,
-0.0110155372,
-0.0589655563,
-0.0137329716,
0.0471805856,
-0.0095894318,
0.0475075245,
0.0304940902,
0.0395097472,
0.0198423378,
-0.0826664045,
0.0006023748,
0.0699736327,
0.02378048,
0.0378683582,
-0.0307876375,
-0.0188105516,
0.0255189929,
0.0454391576,
-0.0109355776,
0.0547284298,
0.0035252513,
0.0043087192,
-0.0897589326,
0.0268449485,
0.0021880239,
-0.0147231203,
0.0123268282,
-0.0399293378,
0.0368776694,
0.0095379502,
-0.0329395272,
-0.0032771784,
0.0270133782,
-0.0286321938,
0.0474432558,
-0.006747582,
0.0344399214,
0.0058892905,
-0.0632181019,
-0.0140946079,
0.0000147933,
-0.0419891961,
0.0793339387,
0.048063688,
-0.0486360081,
-0.0140125416,
0.0339561738,
0.060074091,
-0.0131367752,
-0.0044569522,
-0.0060797939,
0.0783741623,
0.0010620225,
-0.0149832144,
0.0070100767,
-0.0367023461,
-0.0120011168,
-0.0170189533,
-0.051780045,
0.0120283933,
-0.0683447793,
-0.0216440223,
-0.0137259318,
0.0893118456,
-0.0569239855,
0.0311688054,
-0.0559125505,
0.0244302228,
-0.0370162874,
0.0524667129,
-0.0366642028,
-0.0349051021,
0.0394903794,
0.0252715647,
0.0135823125,
-0.0499568693,
0.0024444221,
0.042579446,
0.0053919768,
-0.0173764061,
-0.0344485119,
-0.0110575072,
-0.0162248611,
-0.002730764,
0.0239766538,
-0.0135273794,
0.0138157839,
-0.0103831477,
0.0267137364,
-0.0816835091,
-0.00052331,
0.0171001647,
-0.0488194749,
0.06674622,
-0.0092708291,
0.0124627817,
0.0813079327,
0.0247600563,
-0.0149807623,
0.0429207385,
0.0295650493,
0.0441377088,
0.0391679928,
-0.0338972174,
0.0185079444,
0.0110366857,
-0.0066492325,
0.004887098,
-0.0542738996,
0.0380294472,
-0.0593044199,
0.027952956,
0.0358349383,
0.0360411815,
0.0063902903,
0.0311116073,
0.0607527792,
0.0441277102,
0.017284533,
0.0377170518,
0.0144996559,
-0.0308974925,
0.0047085802,
0.0079782028,
-0.0220181197,
0.0312819183,
0.0563231073,
-0.0127712972,
-0.0323229767,
0.0954594016,
-0.0351356864,
-0.006153231,
0.0019983726,
-0.009312368,
0.0636394098,
-0.0046569891,
-0.0057485695,
0.0185119584,
-0.0334901176,
-0.0298415907,
-0.0328858271,
-0.0486721396,
-0.018875435,
-0.062848635,
-0.0434360728,
0.0715474561,
0.0150861917,
0.0182974078,
0.027933538,
-0.0209202785,
-0.0043932712,
0.037739031,
-0.0263154414,
0.0297576953,
-0.0305807088,
0.0124275526,
-0.0150497798,
0.0067799045,
0.0340981819,
0.0314075239,
-0.0143926293,
0.0506760478,
0.0157488063,
0.011473407,
-0.0223126728,
0.0353663526,
0.0329853483,
-0.0169976484,
-0.0105965566,
0.034870673,
0.0040530744,
0.0134029407,
-0.0612718761,
0.0098920558,
-0.0212867744,
0.0120099084,
-0.0271763317,
0.068572022,
-0.0409329794,
0.0253142733,
-0.0042885183,
-0.1395055205,
-0.0264455806,
0.0373425335,
0.036405243,
0.0107839024,
0.032066565,
-0.0345814265,
-0.034963686,
-0.0546062253,
0.0048336345,
-0.0036045457,
0.0027253716,
-0.0082243588,
0.0528019741,
-0.0229226463,
-0.0536235981,
0.0016987432,
-0.0421938263,
0.0010970874,
-0.039721258,
-0.0176437628,
0.0047505689,
-0.0230964441,
0.0565271787,
0.0087683564,
-0.0027634099,
-0.0190823358,
0.0628790185,
-0.0787308067,
-0.040977262,
0.0011181539,
-0.0514545478,
-0.0329826027,
-0.0181695111,
-0.0170988962,
-0.0175455101,
-0.0277952291,
-0.0094738016,
-0.0332708098,
0.0444741249,
-0.01061296,
-0.0302765872,
0.0027336008,
-0.0392244272,
-0.0204800684,
-0.0224012956,
0.0555418059,
0.0798128322,
-0.003622226,
-0.0079130679,
-0.0237896834,
-0.0302457847,
0.0177735314,
0.0138462167,
0.015418441,
0.0404091291,
0.0567840375,
-0.0184267946,
0.0058581163,
0.0435143337,
0.0364242718,
0.0299780779,
0.0446937308,
0.0155584533,
-0.0169550404,
-0.0012290034,
0.0489326082,
0.0271106306,
-0.0993448198,
0.0080284625,
-0.0168463606,
0.0298400577,
-0.0020260722,
-0.0514592193,
0.0421296954,
-0.0322059542,
-0.0484124534,
-0.0301782675,
-0.026999373,
-0.0460238717,
0.0323789269,
-0.0004763441,
-0.0781084374,
0.0149328141,
0.0102740256,
0.0141465971,
0.0382658727,
0.0444093645,
0.0195378531,
0.0196428169,
0.0115721943,
0.0575549975,
-0.0200519245,
0.0254413337,
-0.0479529686,
-0.0095346561,
0.0231729504,
-0.0307343453,
0.034825258,
-0.0180828571,
0.0053632334,
-0.0003350387,
-0.0272326767,
-0.0354064666,
-0.0279039238,
0.0069008395,
-0.0254404973,
-0.0163561795,
-0.0278616529,
-0.0001846614,
-0.0264085289,
-0.0101266168,
0.0547906421,
0.0002281111,
0.0060280613,
0.0190997217,
-0.0184676815,
0.0237529296,
-0.0231492296,
-0.0110976864,
-0.0138094751,
0.0025927303,
-0.0059490427,
-0.0106733385,
0.0042177904,
-0.023426529,
0.0327366814,
0.0132726692,
0.0335691459,
0.017941637,
0.0232123509,
0.0661070496,
0.0252593812,
0.0478761643,
0.055344671,
-0.0086063556,
-0.0783758387,
0.0335866362,
0.0131509425,
-0.0569814779,
-0.0008953026,
-0.0107792728,
-0.0842789188,
0.0044577713,
-0.0119930217,
0.052404508,
-0.0754329637,
-0.0227388963,
0.0123816095,
-0.0415109619,
0.0525333919,
-0.0025958954,
0.0341871865,
-0.0466034561,
0.0220069401,
0.0044514467,
0.0453235656,
0.0288343746,
0.0005465345,
-0.02913424,
0.0063450621,
-0.0258516856,
-0.047967203,
-0.0352832377,
-0.0060058208,
-0.0141959246,
0.0338145457,
0.064204514,
0.0516170748,
0.0080934297,
-0.0297821127,
-0.0239258092,
-0.0018650912,
0.02899177,
-0.0280083362,
0.0372830443,
-0.0397012979,
-0.0173371434,
-0.0463365987,
0.0384767912,
0.0180921145,
0.0153359035,
0.0125748534,
-0.0192725398,
-0.0347402357,
-0.0491086207,
-0.0933277532,
-0.0300861634,
0.0253764912,
0.0342604108,
0.0441919826,
-0.0274752043,
-0.0134600373,
-0.0344890989,
0.0525192842,
-0.0050492226,
-0.0489077829,
0.0114195077,
-0.0531249046,
-0.0302490797,
-0.0412873924,
-0.0177753903,
0.0239297412,
-0.0063394317,
-0.0202974267,
-0.074713096,
-0.0320241004,
0.0336744487,
-0.0548841581,
0.0204936452,
0.0295192115,
0.0185908172,
0.0568680167,
-0.0248474684,
-0.0457422361,
-0.0118806949,
-0.0157427229,
-0.0321812108,
0.0296570212,
0.0039716484,
0.0567137189,
0.0379255414,
0.0188014694,
-0.0411395766,
0.056033235,
-0.0423321575,
0.0450965278,
0.0955992863,
0.0375054292,
0.0052938117,
-0.0303556956,
-0.0101680718,
-0.0139016286,
0.0081463344,
-0.0008943782,
0.0491050072,
-0.0278769303,
-0.0223053694,
-0.025946036,
0.0021281214,
-0.0322421789,
0.0043966565,
-0.0079285037,
-0.058583308,
0.0052512693,
-0.0264578965,
-0.0519015975,
-0.0480859317,
-0.0203977861,
-0.0298684835,
-0.0069170659,
0.0148512153,
0.0180178247,
-0.0190614797,
-0.0147030791,
-0.0723390877,
0.0125806322,
-0.0700325966,
0.0390126184,
0.0051866574,
0.0326442197,
-0.0300816055,
-0.0109626651,
0.0236352645,
0.0510406606,
-0.0386204049,
0.0162753984,
0.0433414355,
0.049394004,
0.0101401629,
0.0211612936,
-0.0226234663,
0.0261157602,
0.0272947066,
-0.0499468073,
-0.0277331937,
0.0424530208,
0.0286750365,
0.0005635041,
0.0035797858,
0.0225058906,
-0.006016844,
0.0258605704,
-0.0314076506,
0.0371804461,
0.0197129883,
0.0478704013,
-0.0321882553,
-0.0013196275,
-0.0315178782,
0.0242908094,
-0.0021998733,
0.0234443285,
-0.0379521884,
-0.0503183603,
0.0105574494,
-0.0461633019,
0.0175405797,
-0.0418192968,
-0.0091804136,
0.0192725789,
-0.0552922525,
-0.0526610464,
0.0008080025,
-0.0218850709,
0.0080838054,
0.003299732,
0.0094837444,
-0.0041412069,
-0.017606115,
-0.0300869849,
0.0304745436,
-0.0177128129,
-0.1155278385,
-0.0101217488,
-0.0005638973,
-5.676893847e-33,
-0.0201661885,
-0.0435221456,
-0.0212107003,
-0.0689114556,
-0.0315283984,
0.0075142183,
-0.0091690291,
0.0103450613,
-0.0198700465,
0.033298526,
0.0118058445,
-0.0139827598,
0.0140485084,
0.0152869411,
0.0014381884,
0.0048564868,
0.0672940239,
-0.0052054576,
-0.0531441458,
0.0119445724,
-0.0296678245,
-0.0160113573,
-0.0058728443,
-0.0839446485,
0.0676682144,
-0.0283017419,
-0.040303193,
-0.0528068319,
0.0908431411,
-0.0058651967,
-0.011132434,
0.0260595046,
0.0421592183,
0.0227352027,
-0.0004449551,
0.1237476766,
0.0077199894,
0.0048799249,
-0.0162164383,
0.0072012795,
-0.0437601991,
-0.015728116,
-0.006910299,
0.0022710434,
-0.0574479513,
-0.0283875521,
0.0773270354,
-0.0215938669,
0.0606743172,
0.025384305,
-0.0328623131,
-0.0169625729,
-0.0484872386,
0.0166686606,
-0.0183792263,
0.0353405848,
0.0189866982,
0.0603785366,
-0.0275743455,
0.0104485583,
-0.0496095866,
-0.0663067922,
0.0512973852,
0.0024952702,
0.040870931,
0.0407240763,
0.0470507294,
-0.0075720074,
-0.07987874,
-0.0592765547,
0.0125450054,
0.0098073632,
0.0226851273,
0.0566786714,
0.0449129343,
-0.0409070253,
0.0054683872,
0.0291804057,
-0.0207735766,
0.0456840508,
0.0446191691,
-0.0227290895,
-0.0557588637,
0.0027010534,
-0.0229844823,
-0.0263687465,
-0.0260830224,
-0.0324037001,
0.0200857893,
-0.03194426,
-0.0027476207,
0.061372757,
0.0146156102,
-0.0446973518,
-0.0258333068,
-0.0306783654,
0.010210854,
0.0108694239,
-0.0009329999,
-0.0139204795,
0.0125155011,
-0.0108681889,
0.0368204154,
0.061172951,
0.0327595547,
0.0048429132,
-0.0085563185,
-0.0488212481,
-0.0374633186,
-0.0097662434,
0.0102479924,
-0.0298101567,
0.0214563627,
0.0322263986,
0.0092747053,
-0.0046191853,
-0.0215588808,
-0.0258910023,
0.0013274095,
0.0128407748,
-0.0550747029,
-0.0445804335,
-0.0395050049,
0.0387325212,
-0.0601046272,
-0.0165113024,
-0.0468094386,
0.0008648618,
0.0508971438,
-0.0826578513,
-0.0198122114,
-0.0607174188,
2.455e-7,
0.020828668,
0.0447980911,
-0.0202535875,
0.030579593,
0.0343876816,
0.0490376912,
0.0327960141,
0.0552093461,
0.0205551274,
0.0340429842,
0.0298857465,
0.0411587209,
-0.0236800201,
-0.0068026837,
0.0337873027,
0.0502006002,
-0.0340175517,
0.0404489227,
-0.0266740676,
0.0512867756,
0.0394400731,
-0.000920545,
-0.0342925265,
-0.030180322,
0.0041831378,
-0.0498082079,
0.0251084119,
-0.0307073072,
0.0557166152,
-0.051327087,
0.0016562166,
0.0374831706,
0.0032150019,
-0.0149318101,
-0.0063503706,
0.0208452828,
0.0294342525,
0.0064810496,
-0.0650997162,
0.0166725609,
0.0196932964,
0.0450098775,
-0.0238553546,
-0.0199681781,
0.0513043739,
-0.0034130053,
-0.0110189607,
-0.069521822,
-0.0285955332,
-0.0036418433,
0.0781496912,
-0.0291633699,
-0.0221726708,
-0.0010638069,
0.0137770297,
0.0032259817,
-0.0010691098,
-0.0560264327,
-0.0050271326,
-0.0312404297,
-0.0310528483,
-0.0320907496,
-0.0355299115,
0.0244805589,
0.0219889376,
-0.0146001959,
0.0005049938,
1.795081237e-34,
0.0316257663,
0.055320438,
0.014273745,
-0.0443955883,
0.0033550307,
-0.0053325933,
0.0471386574,
-0.0382134393,
0.0029986638,
-0.0161636658,
-0.0185591727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14991v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14991v1 | SpreadsheetBench: Towards Challenging Real World Spreadsheet Manipulation | 2024-06-21T09:06:45 | 2024-06-21T09:06:45 | Zeyao Ma, Bohan Zhang, Jing Zhang, Jifan Yu, Xiaokang Zhang, Xiaohan Zhang, Sijia Luo, Xi Wang, Jie Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | We introduce SpreadsheetBench, a challenging spreadsheet manipulation
benchmark exclusively derived from real-world scenarios, designed to immerse
current large language models (LLMs) in the actual workflow of spreadsheet
users. Unlike existing benchmarks that rely on synthesized queries and
simplified spreadsheet files, SpreadsheetBench is built from 912 real questions
gathered from online Excel forums, which reflect the intricate needs of users.
The associated spreadsheets from the forums contain a variety of tabular data
such as multiple tables, non-standard relational tables, and abundant
non-textual elements. Furthermore, we propose a more reliable evaluation metric
akin to online judge platforms, where multiple spreadsheet files are created as
test cases for each instruction, ensuring the evaluation of robust solutions
capable of handling spreadsheets with varying values. Our comprehensive
evaluation of various LLMs under both single-round and multi-round inference
settings reveals a substantial gap between the state-of-the-art (SOTA) models
and human performance, highlighting the benchmark's difficulty. | [
0.0155409314,
0.0698755383,
-0.0123949703,
0.0179105829,
-0.0403487049,
0.0237824731,
-0.013955934,
0.0415730178,
0.0085984189,
-0.0040359762,
-0.0311481263,
-0.0741281137,
0.0087634502,
-0.0010631611,
0.0327910334,
-0.0261649471,
0.0074866023,
-0.0222766325,
-0.0454644598,
0.0179245993,
0.0014946626,
-0.0124283209,
-0.0254868995,
0.026624728,
0.0059272754,
0.0027959973,
-0.0117083061,
0.000062618,
-0.0266021378,
0.0242799576,
-0.0229079407,
0.0884504244,
-0.0076976041,
0.0599816591,
0.0000021214,
-0.0364146344,
-0.026095802,
-0.0062785121,
-0.0505843163,
0.0273138564,
0.0460039377,
-0.0299475621,
-0.0192960333,
0.0228928383,
-0.04049436,
-0.0266140718,
0.0285818614,
-0.0384854823,
0.0802311078,
0.0626259893,
-0.009403565,
0.0174498297,
0.0007617422,
-0.040456485,
0.0750118047,
-0.1094070524,
0.018894691,
0.0301464219,
0.0707656965,
-0.0850885436,
0.0059464015,
0.0261601843,
0.0271076802,
-0.0521331839,
-0.0067095687,
0.0110649941,
-0.0596092306,
0.0012887672,
0.0085818479,
0.084667027,
-0.034788534,
0.0188196283,
-0.0053638052,
-0.019043684,
0.0188253317,
0.0211192761,
-0.0753081217,
-0.0153261172,
-0.0189446062,
-0.0383852087,
-0.0036740992,
-0.0115207415,
0.0234783627,
0.018598821,
-0.0274762791,
0.0040365076,
-0.0219122544,
-0.050078135,
0.025696367,
0.0052885758,
0.0002619443,
-0.0558913723,
0.0479222201,
0.0438252799,
-0.0462300181,
0.0147107458,
-0.0274978168,
-0.06496571,
0.0347638987,
-0.0883106515,
0.0616849884,
0.0202110354,
0.0222990327,
0.0591889843,
0.0010940406,
0.0483213961,
-0.0204278622,
-0.0308407098,
-0.0086532403,
-0.0059243189,
-0.030704163,
0.0091944272,
-0.0183003191,
0.0064127971,
-0.0709424689,
0.0191581324,
-0.0092566842,
0.0326029919,
-0.0345213823,
0.0906790644,
0.0307807624,
-0.0194988195,
-0.0104246465,
-0.0473678187,
-0.0440041535,
-0.0202554651,
-0.0261603575,
-0.0167495795,
-0.0046742456,
-0.0913026035,
-0.0027799159,
0.0145408493,
0.01554213,
-0.0344067849,
0.0235084388,
0.0793223754,
-0.0066287136,
0.0375871882,
-0.0137605304,
-0.0510545671,
-0.0051585268,
-0.0493346937,
-0.0389057361,
-0.078634873,
0.0456794463,
0.0244034864,
-0.0446105488,
-0.0525468625,
0.0056741205,
0.0345530622,
-0.0217527077,
0.0723230466,
-0.0038768749,
0.0070216362,
0.0153918685,
0.0096300244,
-0.0411387309,
0.0433620438,
0.0051377234,
0.0301102027,
0.0028461707,
-0.0312636234,
0.0782988891,
0.076338999,
-0.0179083012,
-0.0164772999,
-0.0000576013,
0.0839148536,
0.0086019225,
0.0589612871,
-0.0311849006,
0.0427397899,
-0.0174801182,
0.0210205298,
0.0575452782,
0.0664212555,
0.0215525888,
0.0322873406,
0.0136482744,
0.0081762904,
0.0346629992,
-0.0216304548,
-0.0414686464,
0.0353999324,
0.0185371451,
0.0084834462,
-0.0002253925,
0.0163397789,
0.0030156944,
-0.0506161712,
0.0008262987,
-0.0040863985,
-0.0465593226,
-0.0027272971,
0.0271621346,
-0.0256719869,
-0.0347654074,
0.0146071622,
-0.0182815567,
-0.0720847249,
-0.0261972155,
-0.0127929887,
-0.0120791877,
0.0859406516,
0.0572257563,
-0.0527074449,
-0.0358773954,
-0.0481287949,
0.001818954,
0.0249189828,
0.0672086924,
-0.0299405456,
-0.0196553804,
-0.0468720719,
0.0171811264,
0.0513110422,
0.0123924986,
-0.012518812,
0.0359271131,
-0.0288525093,
0.0113912076,
-0.0739444047,
-0.0362216756,
0.0071478086,
-0.0238477718,
-0.0655813813,
0.0219242014,
0.024033634,
0.0151847815,
0.0020069974,
-0.0064218813,
0.0214609783,
0.0148031022,
-0.0044587092,
0.0040076701,
-0.0235507693,
-0.0255083423,
0.0220363066,
0.0056067226,
0.0344310962,
-0.0637141764,
-0.0038516622,
-0.0286166631,
0.0045136949,
-0.0097388858,
0.0094841635,
-0.0294422172,
-0.0170552488,
0.0417148247,
-0.0013726621,
-0.0284134857,
-0.0118693681,
0.0459170453,
-0.0046200147,
0.0487799197,
0.0204474069,
-0.0117242336,
0.0112075778,
-0.0256363321,
0.0155371381,
0.0365825072,
-0.0279279761,
0.0244332161,
-0.0214360934,
-0.0001301374,
-0.041521851,
-0.0484716929,
-0.0528670885,
0.0041433042,
-0.0060430234,
0.053788811,
0.0226807017,
0.0086244838,
-0.0291752946,
-0.0273169558,
-0.0536178648,
-0.0222058129,
0.0038383133,
0.0108516859,
0.0309302732,
0.0056197289,
0.0064932136,
-0.0494464822,
-0.0037970091,
-0.0239002854,
0.0324299596,
0.0114728659,
-0.00474932,
-0.0017956709,
0.002606557,
-0.0104762428,
0.0078198453,
0.0139272241,
0.0359894224,
-0.0098754028,
-0.0380884111,
0.0523978733,
0.1058593467,
-0.0152825229,
0.0180402435,
0.0187770985,
-0.0389003344,
-0.0347201303,
0.0013641304,
0.0375954881,
-0.0150740696,
-0.0214909445,
-0.0356863774,
0.0030515313,
0.0556928702,
-0.0076950192,
0.0172482487,
-0.0328999646,
0.0512702316,
-0.0099388035,
0.006191636,
-0.035416685,
0.02860309,
-0.0193916913,
0.024751965,
-0.0401627421,
-0.0348903388,
0.033266969,
-0.0198406279,
-0.0041980017,
0.0022008622,
-0.0164139625,
-0.0058418643,
0.0744418129,
0.0017541893,
-0.020927839,
-0.0523136258,
-0.0121100005,
-0.0300024413,
0.0043467167,
0.0310681202,
-0.059946686,
0.109208174,
-0.0686438084,
0.0230062604,
-0.0362512581,
-0.0818277523,
-0.0022079633,
-0.0334500074,
-0.0307594948,
0.0148206837,
0.0561652854,
-0.0390893668,
-0.0252433904,
-0.0231897999,
0.0476407446,
0.0666016936,
-0.0046024234,
-0.0485758856,
-0.0063055847,
0.0189124923,
-0.0011495362,
-0.0101067871,
-0.0385225527,
-0.0625612736,
0.0216025468,
0.0423526354,
0.0222884305,
0.0051113628,
0.0259941071,
-0.0070661516,
-0.0109031396,
-0.0579475909,
-0.0408195555,
0.0368495211,
-0.0161817167,
-0.0685247034,
-0.0039321021,
0.0824206695,
0.0328033268,
0.0039186641,
-0.0143505065,
-0.0280256737,
0.0085652415,
0.0188795011,
0.0927973166,
-0.1072579548,
-0.0022935132,
-0.0001134258,
0.0131520564,
0.0256041922,
-0.0715395808,
-0.0065470319,
-0.1328711808,
0.0663167238,
-0.0163013265,
-0.0070588607,
-0.0244090017,
-0.031654276,
0.0165600162,
-0.0399024263,
0.0082624611,
0.0573666878,
0.0059757708,
0.0004675026,
0.0115425587,
-0.0620507039,
-0.0053400928,
0.0251333918,
-0.0537931323,
-0.011169604,
0.0382802002,
0.0129640903,
-0.0013215475,
-0.0261925533,
0.0009259898,
0.0318725482,
-0.0084278733,
-0.0101117883,
0.0654313564,
0.033324562,
-0.0049155229,
-0.0096582193,
0.0046913982,
-0.0601738654,
0.0235175267,
0.0445185229,
0.0834258124,
-0.0140700312,
-0.0082923984,
0.0359067209,
-0.038239941,
-0.0178365316,
0.0496132672,
0.0338916071,
-0.0513025373,
-0.0515536629,
-0.0729030669,
-0.0147281624,
-0.0899918675,
0.0101228049,
-0.0181528777,
0.0217980091,
-0.0223427787,
-0.0469333194,
-0.0478117466,
0.0822334811,
0.0534860343,
-0.0103220642,
0.0393668227,
0.0089809084,
-0.0175725929,
-0.0245688707,
-0.0286644138,
-0.0290128905,
0.0635607317,
-0.0207943786,
-0.0036396501,
0.0112418868,
0.0139325354,
-0.0154253235,
0.0116473874,
-0.0626121834,
-0.0486551002,
0.0031047752,
0.0092009762,
0.029558979,
-0.0080408296,
-0.0213524234,
-0.0311135221,
-0.0386813246,
0.0452567078,
-0.0407663286,
-0.0127784461,
0.001524265,
-0.038902007,
0.0042539765,
0.036696665,
-0.0287924558,
-0.0188450869,
0.0050533833,
0.0191703103,
-0.0464994237,
-0.0114287948,
0.0196700152,
0.0379138067,
-0.028763013,
0.0526233986,
-0.0453522094,
0.0019450973,
0.0321378149,
-0.0117369732,
-0.0291775521,
0.0008886721,
-0.0396925211,
0.0297553055,
0.0139924698,
0.0107677346,
0.0966620892,
0.0146454647,
0.005958939,
-0.0422464535,
0.0154959699,
0.0134756714,
0.0250810478,
0.0525264218,
-0.0314233676,
0.003013832,
-0.0076723965,
0.0138639724,
0.051597964,
0.0022776218,
0.0330920182,
0.0043880921,
-0.0074669947,
0.0278671961,
0.0141540226,
-0.0272990912,
-0.072901316,
-0.0095897857,
0.0159726217,
0.0279277451,
-0.0252705831,
-0.0044491543,
-0.0178858768,
-0.0248631667,
-0.0022053681,
0.001010294,
0.0316147394,
-0.0200314224,
0.0109969918,
0.0292884186,
0.0053782896,
-0.0258769542,
0.0952482596,
0.0013810642,
0.0125265652,
-0.010859414,
-0.0243979413,
-0.0596669391,
-0.0132793952,
0.0234631076,
-0.0247797165,
-0.0287053678,
-0.0132869063,
-0.0663187578,
-0.0544475466,
0.0285486821,
0.0450598858,
-0.0109362919,
0.003001346,
0.0211227778,
0.095765464,
0.0327904969,
0.0237848628,
-0.0215302985,
0.0431008339,
-0.0354750194,
-0.0422698073,
-0.0376599766,
-6.068711828e-33,
0.0000359734,
-0.0198161472,
0.03007151,
0.0008622368,
0.0231999177,
-0.0386933982,
-0.0185956024,
0.0160000864,
-0.0162401889,
-0.0275719911,
-0.0440991297,
0.0207437202,
0.0241008215,
-0.0196036473,
0.0136289382,
-0.0181011613,
0.0188301168,
0.0010677917,
-0.0374533162,
-0.0167062785,
-0.0154711278,
0.0269494746,
0.0283819418,
-0.0564370044,
0.0117825912,
-0.0041237734,
-0.0033800274,
0.0196392275,
-0.0142302662,
0.0250320751,
-0.0030752355,
0.0156912319,
0.0290268399,
-0.0257020406,
-0.0181997232,
0.0242066272,
-0.0557794385,
-0.0075053195,
-0.0140981711,
0.0178010352,
-0.0018406747,
-0.0147120822,
0.0801924393,
0.0079564024,
-0.025507547,
0.0062055984,
0.0144621776,
-0.0464582555,
-0.0075303065,
0.0136597222,
-0.0344082154,
0.0459107459,
0.0248332098,
0.0043212604,
0.0182250012,
0.0533140935,
-0.0013329245,
-0.0116642369,
-0.045288492,
-0.0182017311,
0.0454497412,
0.0459790081,
0.0785676539,
0.0075048893,
0.0269266218,
0.0113034621,
0.0165976211,
0.0363158621,
-0.0518632978,
-0.012599485,
0.007545027,
0.0528109968,
0.0446633957,
0.0594303869,
0.0472228974,
0.0039939801,
-0.0357730947,
0.0806846172,
0.0045704544,
0.0100334613,
-0.006167172,
0.0156741962,
-0.036788512,
-0.0067451121,
-0.0258355662,
0.0508662648,
-0.0419704467,
-0.0090609053,
0.0264315028,
-0.0125713153,
0.0397488847,
0.0216808803,
0.0044940277,
0.0040111993,
-0.0444029085,
-0.0240972172,
0.0094958143,
0.0316583477,
0.0009061177,
-0.0104845511,
-0.0465493575,
0.009868158,
-0.0502720624,
0.0293305218,
0.0342083499,
0.0415781587,
0.0163596384,
0.0011751686,
-0.0892931744,
-0.0180889238,
-0.0259585585,
0.0489830934,
0.0142958779,
0.0109230988,
0.0241590291,
0.0074683838,
0.0191929191,
0.0450848825,
0.0114845848,
-0.0374380015,
-0.0363458693,
-0.0319001973,
-0.0060988027,
-0.0048531666,
-0.009715694,
-0.0127879726,
-0.0237171184,
0.0330132283,
0.042177666,
-0.0211432818,
0.012742592,
0.0098361801,
2.669e-7,
0.0809899196,
0.0351594761,
0.0300998911,
0.0296447929,
-0.0048916764,
0.0072434889,
-0.0356419198,
-0.0116294259,
-0.0219591521,
-0.0111419344,
0.0307010226,
-0.0096486788,
0.0913808942,
0.0463306084,
-0.0701203644,
-0.0586091727,
-0.069607161,
0.0304166693,
-0.0670851693,
-0.0091738617,
0.0294421483,
0.0740719587,
-0.019881513,
0.0002701648,
0.0329994708,
-0.0448181443,
0.0539013594,
-0.0371255837,
0.0260915142,
0.0258539505,
0.0005886719,
-0.0389516503,
-0.007045859,
0.0386373214,
-0.0297418144,
-0.0245881453,
0.0170632154,
0.0964716449,
-0.0042002634,
0.0721573457,
-0.0026718979,
-0.1004719585,
0.0068817311,
-0.0647546798,
0.0447074883,
-0.0447156206,
-0.0034958306,
0.0531651564,
-0.0222865362,
-0.000713742,
0.0259408355,
0.0037371363,
-0.0233330019,
-0.0042467057,
0.0141706923,
-0.0039522955,
0.0064979899,
-0.0036010095,
-0.0447648726,
0.0228764657,
-0.0189707577,
-0.0120034153,
-0.0520303994,
-0.0129525336,
-0.0196122658,
0.012299885,
0.0089462604,
2.623762166e-34,
0.0211119056,
0.0229935609,
0.0490618758,
0.0128407599,
0.0803332925,
0.0058224569,
0.0288384967,
0.0547241122,
0.0174209476,
-0.0730723217,
-0.0039634765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14986v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14986v2 | Do Large Language Models Exhibit Cognitive Dissonance? Studying the Difference Between Revealed Beliefs and Stated Answers | 2024-06-21T08:56:35 | 2024-07-02T14:02:04 | Manuel Mondal, Ljiljana Dolamic, Gérôme Bovet, Philippe Cudré-Mauroux, Julien Audiffren | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Prompting and Multiple Choices Questions (MCQ) have become the preferred
approach to assess the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs), due to
their ease of manipulation and evaluation. Such experimental appraisals have
pointed toward the LLMs' apparent ability to perform causal reasoning or to
grasp uncertainty. In this paper, we investigate whether these abilities are
measurable outside of tailored prompting and MCQ by reformulating these issues
as direct text completion - the foundation of LLMs. To achieve this goal, we
define scenarios with multiple possible outcomes and we compare the prediction
made by the LLM through prompting (their Stated Answer) to the probability
distributions they compute over these outcomes during next token prediction
(their Revealed Belief). Our findings suggest that the Revealed Belief of LLMs
significantly differs from their Stated Answer and hint at multiple biases and
misrepresentations that their beliefs may yield in many scenarios and outcomes.
As text completion is at the core of LLMs, these results suggest that common
evaluation methods may only provide a partial picture and that more research is
needed to assess the extent and nature of their capabilities. | [
0.0544937886,
0.0603463501,
-0.0390913188,
0.0023975496,
-0.0678680614,
0.0146967266,
0.0140375346,
-0.0037396841,
0.0374916308,
-0.0388540812,
0.0138635663,
-0.0398117043,
0.0047425083,
-0.012611378,
0.028120786,
-0.0154816667,
0.0094849998,
-0.023348175,
0.0595003851,
-0.059628021,
-0.0246922318,
0.002036093,
0.0130765615,
0.0305621978,
0.0479965732,
-0.008963027,
-0.0086671375,
-0.0203514677,
-0.0257191509,
-0.0482954085,
-0.0208477676,
0.05228623,
0.0178622082,
0.0309840124,
0.0000021007,
-0.0720329508,
0.0300518107,
-0.0448109731,
-0.0380988382,
0.0261076614,
0.0171300005,
0.0389581397,
0.038489271,
0.0045132232,
-0.0093998201,
-0.0032115362,
0.0214616153,
0.0397184826,
-0.017468201,
0.0026011609,
0.0151482653,
-0.0203379635,
-0.0049463427,
-0.0146929892,
0.0147662107,
0.0092990818,
0.0565730259,
0.0229406804,
-0.0186436567,
0.0107884975,
-0.011908656,
0.0192619972,
0.0147784678,
0.0290042032,
-0.0575094149,
0.0227018781,
-0.0184732173,
-0.0715502948,
0.0140575673,
0.0291221328,
0.0428247638,
-0.0220875423,
-0.023033211,
-0.0241226945,
0.0323273875,
0.0473125614,
-0.0494144373,
0.0317416862,
-0.0087566208,
0.0087840687,
0.0070191268,
0.0215979926,
0.018591905,
0.0168375559,
-0.0198514182,
0.1182674915,
0.0059003816,
-0.0272606704,
-0.0012324898,
0.0242214352,
-0.0213501453,
-0.0951010287,
-0.0383493677,
0.0092778448,
-0.0204113983,
0.0486721508,
-0.0012374407,
0.0206982046,
0.0350389704,
-0.0549548045,
0.0363012031,
0.0441393629,
-0.0191811398,
0.0263204351,
-0.0030061812,
0.0351422019,
-0.0198252406,
0.0000025301,
-0.0327877887,
0.0333678164,
-0.0020674467,
-0.0287108105,
0.0276252683,
0.0276443511,
-0.0060671302,
-0.0166879706,
-0.0424027219,
-0.0099715842,
-0.0085455347,
0.012214574,
-0.0365237258,
0.009624104,
-0.0110328402,
-0.0194243919,
-0.1042384207,
0.0320272297,
-0.0284971707,
0.0545484237,
-0.009993773,
-0.0581798069,
0.0160673223,
0.0228362586,
-0.0200434849,
-0.0325549431,
0.022641262,
0.0505372994,
-0.017158905,
-0.013617944,
-0.002977716,
-0.0143576413,
-0.0663458556,
-0.0766442046,
-0.0190201141,
-0.0584794469,
-0.00353487,
0.0536317602,
-0.0237491876,
-0.026940655,
0.0271554608,
0.0015507691,
-0.0410880335,
0.0695877373,
0.0385547541,
0.0536189079,
0.0390256383,
0.0231726151,
-0.0259785801,
0.0567487143,
0.0170918573,
0.0463032201,
0.0091615915,
0.0114695476,
0.0197981894,
0.019002622,
-0.0055848844,
0.0270069148,
-0.0661972389,
0.02736241,
0.0014860049,
0.0009873447,
0.0215504672,
0.0637934878,
-0.0187644158,
0.0031444083,
0.1043244749,
0.0500889719,
-0.0181483328,
-0.0109521989,
0.0181201007,
0.0126529569,
0.0342618413,
0.0599415451,
-0.0280566011,
0.0126700737,
-0.0270181913,
0.0077101891,
0.0493095815,
-0.0054177907,
-0.0042009349,
-0.0385429636,
-0.0193149764,
0.0028826192,
0.03352575,
0.0707490593,
0.0404354632,
-0.0428233258,
-0.0373409614,
-0.0074616489,
0.014978461,
-0.0178811997,
-0.0170350019,
-0.0665893331,
0.0608955547,
0.0332740247,
0.0246039852,
0.0106462119,
-0.00511713,
0.006392173,
0.0116423098,
0.0493524224,
0.0743535906,
0.0238475241,
-0.0193397906,
-0.013016711,
-0.0036976987,
-0.0241964236,
0.0100732166,
0.0203204416,
-0.0048634834,
-0.0028103727,
-0.0233430285,
-0.0225474257,
-0.0094541693,
0.0274976771,
-0.0173814502,
-0.0294083543,
-0.0562020205,
-0.0047224732,
0.0367915593,
-0.0151896747,
-0.0049145739,
0.0278870873,
0.0165901706,
0.0037921884,
-0.0419412516,
0.0156821404,
-0.0455575585,
0.0137259113,
0.02547797,
0.021368593,
-0.0131464116,
-0.0046289074,
0.0335885994,
-0.0186467618,
0.0105490591,
-0.0093397908,
0.0222689565,
-0.0127031915,
0.0461701751,
-0.0531177483,
-0.0001081682,
-0.0423708148,
0.0719336197,
-0.0122380741,
0.0533206575,
0.0135968179,
-0.0078464933,
0.020772038,
-0.0170512144,
-0.0449223444,
0.0224333052,
0.0254989378,
-0.0127318073,
0.0497212596,
-0.0675971806,
-0.0472300798,
-0.0435018912,
-0.0644080564,
-0.0260220189,
0.0123209609,
0.0009074251,
0.0019170608,
-0.048191119,
-0.0273955688,
0.0101190535,
-0.0227154102,
-0.0266015753,
0.0269465446,
0.0646104217,
0.0199295171,
-0.011026538,
-0.0108137121,
-0.033399906,
0.0020270401,
-0.0182263069,
0.0392623022,
0.0323998854,
-0.0076185772,
-0.0309026111,
0.0235034656,
-0.0635429993,
0.0091438917,
-0.0314348042,
-0.0260989796,
0.0441457704,
0.0067491722,
0.0596055277,
0.046373792,
0.0246052723,
0.0169206634,
0.0813444182,
-0.0230674949,
-0.061710421,
-0.0085613895,
-0.0321784578,
-0.0395177379,
-0.0341460034,
-0.0760734007,
-0.0385622904,
0.0563106313,
0.0586412512,
0.0076893466,
-0.0546488874,
0.0417181142,
-0.0219116677,
-0.0607090555,
-0.0307836663,
-0.061381571,
-0.0216992442,
0.0990311429,
-0.0039840885,
-0.0827951655,
0.0885438398,
-0.0104802754,
0.0051506208,
-0.0258120988,
0.0013751012,
0.00615595,
0.0769362673,
0.0129405167,
-0.0069724508,
0.0427110754,
-0.0133592272,
-0.0824572146,
-0.0513805747,
-0.0131160971,
-0.0435431749,
0.0347411446,
-0.0531407446,
-0.0201610941,
0.0186258722,
-0.0038903849,
-0.0338220485,
-0.0447983816,
-0.0499653481,
-0.0271752272,
0.0284082741,
0.0039248266,
-0.0246148296,
-0.003532338,
0.0646337494,
-0.0438443236,
-0.0076172971,
-0.003546081,
-0.0053104428,
-0.0283269081,
0.043683894,
0.0158639885,
0.0638085231,
-0.0588735715,
0.0274271276,
0.0252162069,
0.0073917992,
0.035202235,
-0.010428844,
-0.0185692664,
0.0345708169,
0.0097600184,
-0.0351969264,
0.054433465,
0.0629533753,
-0.0228204224,
0.0411316082,
0.1044045463,
0.0339461789,
0.0106678875,
-0.0098247398,
-0.0457601547,
0.0131913824,
0.0405892581,
-0.0025247086,
-0.0687830448,
0.0052674995,
0.0134292068,
-0.0166181009,
-0.0508343168,
-0.0264963433,
-0.0264319275,
-0.0966646671,
0.01566099,
-0.0194956958,
0.0241510011,
0.0261004176,
-0.0182553586,
0.0117437616,
0.0407493226,
-0.0080728075,
0.0288587492,
0.0090555726,
0.0003150082,
-0.0121465325,
-0.04292183,
-0.0200899728,
0.0194461178,
-0.004692215,
0.0336979628,
0.0280043669,
0.0016585521,
-0.0390208662,
-0.0342101716,
0.0150301149,
-0.0294706766,
-0.0203473642,
0.0132919457,
0.0171637554,
0.0111940792,
0.01830074,
-0.0469039939,
0.000364468,
0.0290349629,
-0.0238251798,
0.0174003616,
0.0446651727,
-0.0163535997,
-0.0785766095,
-0.0055016004,
0.0309681464,
-0.0018763861,
0.1068108305,
0.0314578302,
-0.0498250686,
-0.0077067688,
-0.0267778914,
-0.0158098973,
0.0360789597,
-0.0225756429,
-0.0027659149,
0.0401805975,
0.031546548,
-0.0359252878,
-0.045781251,
0.0270786732,
-0.0360350534,
-0.0040427605,
0.0174066946,
-0.0017102779,
-0.0092591308,
0.0009991601,
0.0140166376,
-0.0025249105,
0.0127936946,
-0.0214701183,
0.0271556787,
0.0028257435,
-0.0484679863,
-0.0112702893,
-0.0137391612,
-0.052252464,
-0.0830101371,
0.0086382627,
0.0170471985,
0.0332714356,
-0.0263772123,
0.0140888942,
-0.0497569554,
0.0289376639,
0.0085096164,
-0.0227591041,
0.0573814064,
0.0071702325,
0.070425272,
0.0053299721,
0.0400122441,
0.0059413477,
0.044569727,
0.0103396419,
0.0255663488,
-0.0226034317,
-0.0757724196,
0.0348020829,
0.0239826795,
0.0377436504,
-0.0022174527,
0.0164324399,
-0.0165705811,
-0.0140134292,
-0.0353836231,
-0.0444424637,
0.0182687938,
-0.0576830991,
0.0406965613,
-0.006418054,
-0.0068124919,
-0.041206114,
-0.0358274654,
0.0416352786,
-0.0172741003,
0.0216055121,
0.0109311156,
0.0026243213,
0.055897288,
-0.0105259661,
-0.0165987164,
0.0014323952,
-0.0401550457,
0.0340297557,
0.0329918936,
0.0725711882,
0.01513045,
-0.0154452827,
-0.0001442492,
-0.0385066532,
-0.0567832105,
-0.0870416462,
0.04293143,
0.0300400946,
-0.0106032453,
0.0006477428,
0.0270357039,
-0.030831648,
-0.0027416418,
-0.0249306653,
-0.0213926677,
0.0077743246,
-0.0284124967,
0.0790468752,
0.0010444751,
-0.0584560186,
0.0165160783,
0.0581889898,
-0.0081781754,
0.0392278284,
-0.0144415544,
-0.0097619416,
-0.0222612042,
-0.0634710565,
0.0059605031,
0.0400579348,
-0.033178553,
0.0283280183,
-0.0897799507,
-0.0539589301,
0.0000517187,
0.0089886859,
0.0055971672,
-0.0791230202,
-0.0355620198,
0.0660545379,
-0.00450991,
-0.0112818722,
-0.0196823925,
0.03254354,
-0.0049481061,
0.0215381067,
-0.0499880463,
-6.639416907e-33,
-0.0092978962,
-0.0352825522,
0.0025765782,
-0.0416901633,
0.0153092854,
-0.0164926834,
-0.0311071239,
0.0499989875,
-0.0451795906,
0.0005522578,
-0.0053226179,
-0.0007988799,
0.0097016254,
-0.0075506861,
0.0315824561,
-0.0202100854,
0.0285622738,
-0.0009715455,
-0.0485364087,
-0.0502249226,
0.0239080675,
-0.0238081831,
0.0163454078,
-0.0494369641,
0.0857393518,
-0.0360686518,
0.0004738481,
-0.0043207938,
-0.0395401679,
0.0298274923,
-0.0276757665,
0.0374516398,
0.0207877979,
-0.0260580499,
-0.0043071471,
0.0769476071,
0.0264569223,
-0.0377231836,
0.0764124691,
-0.0166823287,
-0.0177474618,
-0.0069685248,
0.0141010452,
0.0063360971,
-0.0579657517,
0.0273113959,
0.0085368501,
-0.0365059376,
0.004352021,
0.0241200067,
-0.0400486216,
0.0046719625,
0.0134611251,
0.0047812113,
-0.021199692,
0.0627731085,
-0.0092183892,
0.0365387872,
-0.045723591,
0.0264215469,
0.0240001474,
0.0075247474,
0.0557458773,
0.0015748149,
0.0300844554,
0.0690237284,
0.0292693898,
0.0375860296,
-0.0595573932,
-0.0182611067,
0.0180048048,
0.0084437402,
0.0426846594,
0.0599790737,
0.0130779054,
-0.0344903097,
-0.0245210771,
-0.0166808087,
0.0289586615,
0.0176304784,
0.0905121416,
0.0213119499,
-0.0316513367,
-0.0727472231,
-0.0857460499,
-0.0004924565,
-0.0515024215,
-0.0350717083,
0.0395369567,
-0.0061356085,
-0.0051766057,
-0.0471287929,
0.0381371491,
-0.0217489023,
-0.0340393148,
0.0005414096,
-0.0426558368,
0.030561354,
0.0102827316,
0.0517331474,
-0.0495853573,
0.0228833426,
-0.0096203433,
0.0126345325,
-0.0146848857,
0.0293382667,
-0.0277908351,
-0.0123338299,
-0.0601646379,
0.0031891239,
-0.0150368921,
-0.01606475,
0.0258644894,
-0.0481404588,
0.0734625012,
0.0168869421,
-0.012249101,
-0.0305839572,
0.0048219645,
-0.0375085548,
-0.0333868749,
-0.0111963917,
-0.0179786514,
0.0184350796,
-0.0309012644,
-0.0101450244,
-0.0317406356,
0.0132889571,
0.023192808,
-0.0045620683,
-0.0254083164,
0.0197344534,
2.769e-7,
0.0442524888,
0.0765790269,
-0.0456892587,
0.0499437414,
0.0088168336,
0.0338706747,
-0.0143784583,
-0.0244600624,
0.0979917794,
-0.0506537482,
-0.0227758158,
-0.0004082117,
0.0377246998,
0.0295256432,
-0.0486427657,
-0.0033046354,
-0.0513228625,
0.040086586,
-0.0277365521,
0.0365469493,
0.0613314882,
0.0470354483,
0.0313161053,
0.0258364659,
-0.0498303026,
-0.0211110543,
0.0623623356,
-0.053527724,
-0.0082554454,
0.0184069965,
0.0015737521,
0.0022056622,
0.0159570258,
0.0520856939,
0.0479357913,
0.0006525684,
-0.0114932191,
0.0540061593,
0.0458167046,
0.0070812949,
-0.0248242877,
-0.0191403553,
-0.0086019104,
-0.0893732235,
0.0652588084,
-0.0872803628,
-0.0450320356,
-0.029517753,
-0.0012169649,
-0.0436806418,
0.0575932004,
-0.0111850323,
-0.0250228625,
0.0011384588,
0.0042710034,
0.0336997025,
0.0203546528,
-0.0355762951,
-0.0343808383,
0.0189255122,
-0.0472606048,
-0.0906591341,
-0.0393195115,
-0.0080299145,
0.0098608453,
-0.0756206959,
0.0200255718,
2.474360048e-34,
0.0320382118,
0.0225102007,
-0.009961742,
-0.0263431352,
0.0492218025,
0.0013970876,
-0.0082191797,
0.034798272,
0.0474215299,
-0.0926092193,
-0.0138728134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00072v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00072v2 | Pistis-RAG: A Scalable Cascading Framework Towards Content-Centric Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-21T08:52:11 | 2024-07-03T06:54:16 | Yu Bai, Yukai Miao, Li Chen, Dan Li, Yanyu Ren, Hongtao Xie, Ce Yang, Xuhui Cai | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | In Greek mythology, Pistis symbolized good faith, trust, and reliability.
Drawing inspiration from these principles, Pistis-RAG is a scalable multi-stage
framework designed to address the challenges of large-scale retrieval-augmented
generation (RAG) systems. This framework consists of distinct stages: matching,
pre-ranking, ranking, reasoning, and aggregating. Each stage contributes to
narrowing the search space, prioritizing semantically relevant documents,
aligning with the large language model's (LLM) preferences, supporting complex
chain-of-thought (CoT) methods, and combining information from multiple
sources.
Our ranking stage introduces a significant innovation by recognizing that
semantic relevance alone may not lead to improved generation quality, due to
the sensitivity of the few-shot prompt order, as noted in previous research.
This critical aspect is often overlooked in current RAG frameworks.
We argue that the alignment issue between LLMs and external knowledge ranking
methods is tied to the model-centric paradigm dominant in RAG systems. We
propose a content-centric approach, emphasizing seamless integration between
LLMs and external information sources to optimize content transformation for
specific tasks.
Our novel ranking stage is designed specifically for RAG systems,
incorporating principles of information retrieval while considering the unique
business scenarios reflected in LLM preferences and user feedback. We simulated
feedback signals on the MMLU benchmark, resulting in a 9.3% performance
improvement. Our model and code will be open-sourced on GitHub. Additionally,
experiments on real-world, large-scale data validate the scalability of our
framework. | [
0.0636835173,
0.0242122505,
0.0008057805,
0.0120431865,
-0.0200553183,
-0.0025892493,
-0.0189610496,
-0.0009953209,
0.0093187802,
-0.0493989922,
-0.0356519856,
0.0042219888,
-0.0016480574,
-0.006717925,
0.0070151044,
-0.0062887836,
0.0234402828,
0.0132966265,
-0.0128263747,
-0.0024265351,
-0.0083270995,
0.0484238602,
0.0135747688,
-0.0002204083,
0.0029155996,
0.007427433,
-0.0089858212,
0.0358506031,
0.0445895828,
-0.0434294157,
-0.0261240248,
0.0228387564,
0.0138355233,
0.0590123013,
0.0000022454,
-0.0803015456,
-0.0406475104,
0.0046924516,
0.0295798145,
-0.0053941752,
0.0429788902,
0.0518848933,
0.0107070068,
0.0127419028,
-0.0336825289,
0.0282598641,
0.0103697348,
0.0050289631,
0.0526520945,
0.0642208904,
-0.0056610405,
-0.0188978035,
0.012009549,
-0.0359070413,
0.0113401953,
-0.0428126641,
-0.0090626422,
0.0329524577,
0.0466380641,
0.0410826169,
0.0289768204,
0.0465933345,
-0.0205488671,
-0.0343821384,
0.0386240855,
0.0273840297,
-0.0299761407,
-0.0156945791,
-0.0004927741,
0.0545345992,
0.034184169,
-0.0249981042,
0.0241820198,
-0.0011586484,
0.0121445591,
0.0315338746,
-0.0543087721,
0.0329055265,
-0.0410414115,
0.0015469758,
0.0020235435,
-0.006006571,
0.0092915883,
0.038143985,
-0.0365166776,
0.0437563322,
0.0403809622,
-0.0172639824,
-0.012026865,
0.0204494148,
-0.0049909442,
-0.0334516354,
0.0394004509,
0.0312350076,
-0.0636692122,
0.0012618948,
0.0031195935,
-0.0184559599,
0.0388367251,
-0.016185414,
-0.008464383,
0.0129259033,
0.0239681285,
0.0425004251,
-0.018882826,
0.0126727941,
-0.0243910439,
-0.0265022684,
-0.0546150915,
0.0021976205,
-0.0481030047,
-0.0263181794,
-0.0195950847,
0.0297105107,
-0.0546475947,
-0.0160719045,
-0.0408813953,
0.0390589908,
0.0102111353,
0.0108063333,
0.0161244068,
0.0392579548,
-0.0274163894,
-0.0116547858,
-0.0282383971,
0.0497349203,
0.00751444,
-0.0070017497,
0.0541529357,
-0.0069740736,
0.018384235,
0.0065816906,
0.0085180784,
-0.0014837183,
0.0040531182,
0.0262804888,
-0.0274832472,
-0.0168927368,
-0.0438395999,
-0.0545768216,
-0.005641554,
-0.0358998477,
-0.0340137295,
-0.0656221882,
0.0096952077,
0.02986007,
-0.0088886982,
-0.011433728,
0.0106081432,
0.0615458265,
-0.0511574671,
0.011548168,
0.0059131305,
0.0126290806,
0.0320732556,
0.0307894498,
0.0119335605,
0.0238405652,
0.0063692662,
0.072147876,
0.0538537875,
0.0357330143,
-0.0179435872,
0.0108080255,
0.0190945677,
0.0359074846,
-0.0041017025,
0.0365236662,
-0.022257302,
0.0246021375,
0.0337078758,
0.0528676286,
-0.0400548317,
0.0400036983,
0.0532907993,
-0.0071462579,
0.0029726343,
0.0040633054,
0.0561843514,
0.0493991934,
-0.0206397716,
-0.002681951,
0.0091278581,
0.0255312901,
-0.0344792269,
0.0068855993,
0.0734025761,
0.0741102248,
-0.0162426289,
-0.0155576048,
0.0015387076,
0.0082896855,
-0.0616544597,
0.0223492254,
0.0199111793,
0.0369145423,
-0.0429364815,
0.031233659,
0.0063283634,
-0.0681788623,
0.0355660729,
-0.035504844,
0.0407701917,
0.090849936,
0.1221546382,
-0.0054604709,
-0.0017060795,
0.0338357277,
0.0007771557,
0.0376770124,
0.0100032492,
-0.0247486662,
-0.0446189418,
-0.0716225952,
-0.0576261804,
0.0144867813,
-0.0171793066,
0.022853544,
-0.0044385572,
0.0162498262,
0.0591677427,
0.0030054685,
-0.0346047319,
0.0101592904,
-0.015536706,
0.0109420726,
0.0005862987,
-0.0008310611,
0.006498883,
0.0284110773,
0.0054934635,
0.0278622005,
0.0254810285,
0.0022025278,
-0.0336437672,
-0.0246725362,
-0.0219996199,
-0.0022762401,
0.0155914212,
-0.0281847846,
0.0186642781,
0.0093614683,
-0.0277083386,
-0.0408674851,
-0.0138853416,
-0.0307221934,
0.0058810073,
-0.0349162556,
0.0366927385,
0.0317147486,
-0.0086304247,
-0.0716578588,
0.0905140713,
0.0010888008,
0.0239897352,
0.0682414696,
0.0299329013,
0.0139338896,
-0.0418380126,
-0.0207276661,
0.0066781421,
-0.013331702,
0.0012395752,
0.0815870911,
0.0146706663,
-0.0540447608,
-0.0245029069,
-0.0775342211,
0.0082905078,
0.0139324116,
0.0052435263,
0.017966168,
0.0336821154,
-0.0048340638,
0.007180437,
-0.0359016359,
0.0214010719,
0.0420226194,
0.03535714,
0.0277198236,
0.0065709054,
0.0039526322,
-0.0175018515,
-0.0115438802,
0.0237344392,
0.0417230986,
0.0313087404,
0.0388548113,
-0.071186237,
0.0523480996,
-0.0931984708,
-0.029449245,
0.0017344684,
0.0234386697,
0.0085625453,
-0.0312865712,
0.065478839,
-0.0204395596,
0.0313500687,
-0.0328068621,
0.043784868,
-0.0337693691,
-0.0676432922,
-0.0106993085,
-0.0312281735,
-0.0260682795,
-0.0009662794,
-0.0196813308,
0.0146086477,
-0.0092506325,
-0.0001573203,
-0.0256950706,
-0.0305384304,
0.0263222195,
-0.0113280406,
-0.0164098386,
-0.0299780704,
-0.0465001538,
0.0106625604,
0.0421191342,
-0.0102537172,
-0.0369219519,
0.0437294543,
-0.0252319332,
0.0282646548,
-0.0762670487,
0.0369258188,
-0.0487902835,
0.0404412784,
0.0073252851,
0.0252227671,
-0.0654283687,
0.0152771054,
-0.0654607341,
0.0408638902,
0.0602706335,
-0.0653453022,
0.0056268233,
-0.0160721894,
0.0094935428,
-0.0118714627,
-0.0395655818,
-0.0457570814,
0.0086776465,
0.0224990193,
-0.0108215893,
0.0292689539,
-0.009169993,
-0.0489215069,
-0.0314018615,
0.0510156304,
0.011567927,
-0.009046535,
-0.0538988598,
-0.0023463445,
0.0865169019,
0.0548447967,
-0.0303784367,
0.0501889549,
0.029589396,
-0.0150498627,
0.0642270967,
0.0631090701,
-0.066306442,
0.030778883,
-0.041186627,
0.0561434478,
-0.0267160684,
-0.0343921445,
0.0088759987,
-0.0158041231,
-0.0012416545,
-0.0269721989,
0.0815059841,
0.0612683967,
-0.0769519657,
-0.0224166103,
-0.0167220607,
0.0501435623,
0.0246087201,
0.0655987933,
-0.0605398826,
0.0224901102,
-0.0028513351,
0.0505409874,
-0.003653886,
-0.0153021049,
-0.0358389802,
-0.1141921505,
0.0734726489,
-0.0025483831,
0.0114133852,
0.0044998475,
-0.056198664,
-0.008746163,
0.0178302918,
-0.0595159642,
0.0720147192,
-0.034599632,
0.015399524,
-0.0079938369,
0.061790131,
-0.0256671421,
-0.0234271623,
-0.0170144774,
-0.0306271221,
0.0413321294,
0.0279472359,
0.0282324627,
-0.0474615991,
-0.0045651072,
-0.0038990029,
-0.0076630665,
-0.0264614634,
0.0016664605,
0.0075265379,
0.0343235023,
-0.0518029109,
-0.0009144718,
0.0041365456,
-0.0207744148,
0.0002938691,
0.0553195179,
-0.0039460482,
0.0152509417,
-0.0427117944,
-0.0081643136,
0.0145658217,
0.0659659803,
0.0077312323,
-0.0101516554,
0.0064452938,
-0.0014923868,
0.0125724683,
-0.0104799988,
-0.0277693626,
0.0241694059,
-0.018492071,
-0.0168952458,
-0.1135065332,
-0.0132645201,
-0.0510315113,
0.0590676777,
0.0054209386,
-0.0017817558,
-0.0265363343,
-0.0228155181,
-0.065574795,
-0.0070427139,
-0.0234836936,
-0.0126151098,
-0.0294248741,
0.0197487753,
0.0613244921,
-0.0860848799,
-0.0191598386,
0.0206320826,
-0.0301368888,
-0.0517303348,
-0.0240449719,
0.0267068781,
0.0243559275,
0.037657842,
-0.008766586,
-0.0453096256,
0.0956095383,
0.0639383271,
-0.0567257181,
0.010037004,
-0.0349377766,
0.0133421449,
-0.0348558612,
0.0165275,
-0.0890614018,
0.0298553146,
-0.0458874591,
0.0461940654,
0.0454924442,
-0.0197720211,
0.0315072574,
0.0662036538,
-0.0042127762,
-0.0574761592,
0.0312767103,
-0.0420338064,
0.0195027851,
-0.0438468568,
-0.0445138738,
-0.0215168633,
0.0515442416,
0.0178516768,
-0.0198874176,
0.0184476003,
-0.0004599351,
0.0196452402,
0.0590528212,
-0.0595044792,
-0.0490351468,
-0.0207060613,
-0.0043271771,
0.0288065597,
-0.0240955018,
-0.0301488154,
0.0183015168,
-0.0184391867,
0.0560523756,
-0.0497208275,
0.0613185056,
0.0231098011,
-0.0421486273,
0.0074919742,
0.047388047,
-0.0898639783,
-0.05313069,
-0.0520463549,
-0.0149799176,
0.024599677,
0.0293786954,
0.0915964022,
-0.0386384428,
-0.0190382861,
-0.0015319362,
0.0005310219,
0.0276216753,
-0.0555765927,
-0.0507999621,
0.0264351126,
0.0075574918,
0.0234054159,
0.0530149974,
-0.0516125038,
-0.0135838715,
-0.0553893261,
-0.0698927864,
-0.0249196272,
-0.0602769256,
-0.0358570889,
0.0452127345,
-0.0140888784,
-0.0140237389,
-0.0640431494,
-0.0330211744,
-0.0122081647,
0.0263312813,
0.0053440863,
-0.0208196919,
0.0729775131,
0.0839963853,
0.0069913198,
0.0194375273,
-0.0411286689,
0.0249205865,
-0.0841516033,
-0.0305303335,
-0.0079803215,
-6.984130625e-33,
-0.0219167676,
-0.033893045,
0.0526572764,
-0.0127543323,
-0.0208814144,
-0.0007422263,
-0.0151687451,
-0.0332252644,
0.0280633196,
-0.0145059349,
-0.0095221261,
-0.0012870487,
0.0013505347,
0.0262468681,
0.0132853929,
0.0449912697,
0.0392899327,
0.0107063893,
-0.0553684831,
0.0637817755,
0.0984292403,
0.0017204504,
-0.0017071059,
-0.0413931124,
-0.0066261636,
-0.0188583825,
-0.0036682277,
0.0113580143,
0.001347946,
0.0492871292,
0.0127248606,
0.0274028964,
0.0206609238,
-0.0216482095,
0.0276826322,
-0.0313118286,
-0.046744328,
-0.0026034452,
0.0112617072,
-0.0316621214,
-0.0348842517,
-0.008903305,
0.0042849365,
-0.0235144645,
0.0079907849,
-0.0060396926,
0.0204614364,
-0.0189986993,
-0.0362171866,
-0.0867646411,
-0.0508823022,
0.0246453807,
-0.0005609103,
-0.0017605512,
-0.0264904164,
0.072932668,
0.0055339923,
0.0644067526,
-0.0341785178,
0.0592435822,
-0.060817562,
0.0549612828,
0.0794293955,
0.0063013067,
-0.0296847094,
0.0412678495,
-0.0149974497,
-0.0019188711,
0.0048789317,
-0.0124399485,
-0.0340743922,
0.0449863039,
0.011669674,
0.0598027781,
-0.0222986918,
-0.0156164328,
-0.0787927732,
0.0736926943,
0.0043353434,
0.0137611832,
0.0191592481,
0.0045412513,
-0.0523330867,
-0.0168672372,
-0.0150666786,
-0.0140919359,
-0.0429365411,
-0.0096564656,
0.0302975737,
0.0391444191,
-0.0471652932,
0.0155822076,
0.0211254675,
-0.0091006272,
-0.0270785131,
0.0679523572,
-0.0438179448,
-0.0092818215,
-0.0137948757,
0.0119042685,
-0.0443210714,
-0.0095906099,
0.039896857,
-0.0092649106,
-0.0306529328,
0.0187098868,
0.0137647865,
0.0086060269,
-0.0391768813,
0.0335439295,
-0.0206279904,
0.0258795135,
-0.0324845538,
-0.063385047,
0.0035583379,
0.0184475966,
-0.0168740172,
0.0287823454,
0.0509806648,
0.0141370585,
-0.0078642871,
-0.0157716032,
0.0260972138,
0.0021230436,
0.0062528769,
0.0365404338,
-0.0166752376,
0.045062121,
0.0353397802,
-0.0573757403,
-0.0377662107,
0.0182221923,
3.219e-7,
0.0102858301,
0.0140749384,
0.0016531381,
0.0170373637,
0.0060055363,
-0.0114522753,
0.0261613093,
0.0579444431,
0.0253886543,
-0.0019813315,
0.0196312405,
0.0011515045,
0.0253165886,
0.0424274318,
-0.0814883187,
-0.0282771271,
-0.0870859623,
-0.0476878546,
-0.0559043437,
-0.0400271006,
0.0429417416,
0.0227788445,
-0.01285253,
-0.0434640199,
-0.0126957586,
-0.0165515766,
0.0604603514,
0.0300335679,
-0.0103349416,
0.023217896,
0.055468116,
-0.0322925709,
-0.0148390839,
-0.0182354916,
-0.0366976261,
0.0297051854,
0.0123579921,
-0.0152101554,
0.0232864618,
-0.0105557237,
0.0190969892,
-0.0122176809,
0.0203513615,
-0.0657631755,
0.0389578417,
-0.0266914014,
0.0117955757,
-0.0056377053,
-0.0701595768,
-0.0049795923,
-0.0224757269,
-0.0134618273,
-0.0288887061,
0.0180829111,
-0.02761098,
0.0245726053,
-0.0006332665,
-0.0738610476,
-0.0242931116,
-0.0112583255,
-0.0273894127,
-0.0718078092,
-0.0371045582,
-0.0113199614,
-0.0013601495,
-0.0431785956,
0.0134317847,
3.125462925e-34,
0.0352090932,
-0.0114784641,
-0.0153541043,
-0.0458660163,
0.0436806567,
-0.0070302924,
-0.0466969572,
0.0200498961,
0.019544322,
-0.0755940303,
-0.0190106109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14979v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14979v1 | Retrieve-Plan-Generation: An Iterative Planning and Answering Framework for Knowledge-Intensive LLM Generation | 2024-06-21T08:45:52 | 2024-06-21T08:45:52 | Yuanjie Lyu, Zihan Niu, Zheyong Xie, Chao Zhang, Tong Xu, Yang Wang, Enhong Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the significant progress of large language models (LLMs) in various
tasks, they often produce factual errors due to their limited internal
knowledge. Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG), which enhances LLMs with
external knowledge sources, offers a promising solution. However, these methods
can be misled by irrelevant paragraphs in retrieved documents. Due to the
inherent uncertainty in LLM generation, inputting the entire document may
introduce off-topic information, causing the model to deviate from the central
topic and affecting the relevance of the generated content. To address these
issues, we propose the Retrieve-Plan-Generation (RPG) framework. RPG generates
plan tokens to guide subsequent generation in the plan stage. In the answer
stage, the model selects relevant fine-grained paragraphs based on the plan and
uses them for further answer generation. This plan-answer process is repeated
iteratively until completion, enhancing generation relevance by focusing on
specific topics. To implement this framework efficiently, we utilize a simple
but effective multi-task prompt-tuning method, enabling the existing LLMs to
handle both planning and answering. We comprehensively compare RPG with
baselines across 5 knowledge-intensive generation tasks, demonstrating the
effectiveness of our approach. | [
0.0626441464,
0.0132120103,
-0.0008024512,
0.0083143944,
-0.0434525497,
-0.0300869141,
-0.0353992544,
-0.0114866886,
-0.0041603204,
-0.0606103353,
0.0073289108,
-0.0022185328,
-0.0332669616,
0.0175637193,
0.0209155809,
-0.0327016152,
0.0401571505,
-0.030426085,
0.0119633526,
-0.011579561,
0.0063307378,
0.0348267853,
0.0003302527,
0.0365290865,
-0.0185830165,
-0.0087282676,
-0.0345844179,
0.0120364102,
-0.0026394485,
-0.0383467861,
0.0294202436,
0.0207485352,
0.020569196,
0.0081110829,
0.0000019522,
-0.0600212216,
-0.0497194231,
-0.0041200262,
-0.025962336,
-0.0359827802,
0.0066731428,
0.0059737237,
0.0162391216,
0.0281241667,
-0.0326760896,
0.0347265266,
-0.012114522,
0.0501085483,
0.0427786373,
0.0880593956,
0.0124812135,
-0.0111137526,
0.0089197056,
-0.006794197,
0.0348056778,
-0.0276678745,
-0.0126337158,
0.0017242342,
0.0418683104,
0.0456305444,
0.0268559679,
0.0285341032,
0.0134759508,
-0.0525701605,
0.0094786026,
0.0109025426,
-0.0157545451,
-0.0281882659,
-0.022558691,
0.0560988933,
0.0179093275,
-0.0187995285,
0.0369280167,
-0.0186111722,
0.0181029439,
0.0231556911,
-0.0858218372,
0.0576959364,
-0.0035804883,
-0.00806191,
0.0137186386,
-0.0349990353,
0.0104524139,
-0.0026612477,
-0.0155751379,
0.0751980171,
0.021383157,
-0.0274298191,
-0.0182940811,
0.009636079,
-0.010345892,
-0.0773949698,
0.0136504807,
0.098337777,
-0.055424016,
0.034940958,
-0.0363519602,
-0.0258302204,
0.0526123345,
0.0020206582,
0.0362602174,
0.0301176142,
-0.0005579297,
0.0280752275,
-0.0148393773,
0.0455564819,
-0.0008199025,
-0.0224617906,
-0.0654128119,
0.0146299591,
-0.0443086885,
-0.0327218212,
-0.0556892753,
0.0575596802,
-0.0453067198,
-0.0255402066,
0.0100927977,
0.0588190854,
0.0201732516,
0.0399995744,
0.0298417509,
0.0156518202,
-0.0528820753,
-0.0435831472,
-0.0459362417,
0.0058207838,
-0.0309236236,
0.0101623703,
0.040654704,
-0.0295247845,
-0.0110826492,
0.0340940021,
0.0087057753,
0.003612041,
-0.0041896007,
0.0585038625,
-0.0420539789,
0.0068932525,
-0.0573339909,
-0.0942188501,
-0.0195131544,
-0.0572553016,
0.0165330674,
-0.0768245012,
0.0226704143,
0.0208819956,
-0.0475001223,
-0.003804497,
0.0353094302,
0.0493982621,
-0.0087925009,
-0.0031320606,
-0.0117840879,
0.0415091999,
0.0535564423,
0.0180072021,
-0.0056990692,
0.0570930392,
0.0319093093,
0.0512091294,
0.0413135849,
0.0407865867,
-0.0071585015,
0.0255711842,
0.0280508045,
-0.0117325056,
0.0226637963,
0.027481474,
0.0035085769,
0.0134931216,
0.0296893567,
0.0335548669,
-0.0150222918,
0.05308735,
0.0416462757,
0.0205957741,
0.0047989166,
0.0110258609,
0.0476033054,
0.0345937088,
-0.0126415016,
0.0305984598,
-0.019473685,
0.0424502827,
-0.0353354216,
0.0321708843,
0.022608269,
0.0128329666,
-0.022121178,
-0.0307270624,
-0.0078389514,
0.0106163807,
-0.0271942262,
0.0118027749,
0.0503731743,
0.0376848578,
-0.0716185942,
0.0670884028,
-0.0128302425,
-0.0528144911,
0.0270480029,
-0.0221246071,
0.081272237,
0.070171088,
0.0664640963,
-0.0205364618,
-0.0478205271,
0.0155375432,
0.0224331561,
0.0446004756,
0.043929372,
-0.0332167484,
-0.0442711934,
-0.0467347801,
-0.0260202177,
-0.0604767688,
-0.0123932371,
-0.0001416507,
0.0496994779,
-0.0131994067,
0.0494661815,
-0.028603388,
0.0026384052,
0.0223481636,
-0.05798072,
-0.0207460187,
0.0071697985,
-0.0111157941,
0.0145690404,
0.0242519081,
-0.0024765222,
0.0483407825,
0.0469648093,
-0.0396741219,
-0.0072226641,
-0.0146881891,
-0.0327587463,
-0.0308065414,
0.0285470858,
0.0026774851,
-0.0066236975,
-0.0359018967,
-0.0251170695,
-0.0661610365,
-0.0236611236,
-0.0433939248,
0.0284864958,
-0.0538179912,
0.0048349467,
0.0532042943,
-0.0258828606,
-0.0588464402,
0.0598034635,
0.0193324927,
-0.0036323066,
0.0630629361,
0.0066470732,
0.0069387569,
-0.0672772229,
0.0037018426,
-0.0015102915,
-0.0082909986,
0.0036579934,
0.0595953204,
0.0404558405,
-0.0540424809,
-0.069129087,
-0.0967103243,
0.0302297007,
-0.0366816632,
0.0179642309,
0.0175887309,
0.0166755076,
-0.0163010173,
-0.0181749351,
-0.0604360066,
0.0187170208,
0.044197619,
0.0000648278,
0.0166919678,
0.0284806769,
0.0163027644,
-0.037927378,
0.0155662112,
0.0099895308,
-0.0095347473,
0.0320143625,
-0.0001833628,
-0.0770277455,
0.0656774119,
-0.033279445,
-0.0004647552,
-0.0008492864,
0.0085239932,
0.0139803682,
-0.036370445,
0.0671824217,
0.006222324,
0.0182062555,
0.0012852534,
0.0335049704,
-0.0562429763,
-0.0864708349,
0.0356822535,
-0.0358641818,
-0.0362260565,
-0.0144128213,
-0.0306959022,
0.0291700587,
0.0241288878,
0.015568478,
-0.002520289,
-0.0380942933,
-0.0009631616,
0.0060375058,
-0.0233392194,
-0.0190954115,
-0.016409466,
-0.0123557188,
0.0508410186,
-0.00899004,
-0.0374942087,
0.0513600558,
-0.0281246919,
0.0089365141,
-0.0312944576,
0.020091271,
-0.0318822078,
0.0659125298,
0.0029085565,
0.0261421129,
-0.0168159865,
0.0007623379,
-0.0629779547,
0.0003657849,
-0.0026087363,
-0.0492756478,
0.0576146506,
-0.0812334567,
0.0175873153,
-0.0203463212,
-0.0326133408,
-0.0560438745,
-0.0258726962,
0.0161289107,
0.0097949132,
-0.0023662029,
-0.0091877142,
-0.01211935,
-0.0269839019,
0.0459319502,
0.0227177814,
-0.0252753887,
-0.0183659829,
-0.0204971898,
0.0410086475,
0.090648219,
0.033136338,
0.0071932012,
-0.041544266,
0.0224193744,
0.0472628586,
0.0288343392,
0.0081775552,
0.0246533528,
-0.0114270905,
0.0326142535,
-0.0445798784,
-0.0181118157,
0.0467362776,
0.0554478802,
-0.0577040091,
-0.044683475,
0.1005901471,
0.0395320542,
-0.0156380329,
-0.0137341386,
-0.0650726482,
0.0510269143,
0.0047933739,
0.0662241876,
-0.0516628437,
0.0048559648,
0.0129784625,
0.0394851044,
-0.0233010184,
-0.019270936,
-0.0344915204,
-0.1154749095,
0.0624571145,
0.0017847426,
0.0099412231,
0.0060349801,
-0.0338571072,
-0.014158099,
0.0507354401,
0.015574065,
0.0492802076,
-0.0287509188,
0.0180649124,
0.0100774011,
-0.0250668656,
-0.0040965676,
-0.0062819915,
0.0179305542,
0.0128452387,
0.0683954209,
0.0106400615,
0.014041665,
0.0038125224,
0.0260636732,
-0.0046213036,
0.0224068779,
-0.0189558491,
0.0045266612,
0.0073907054,
0.020798821,
-0.023630118,
0.0335251838,
-0.0272108614,
-0.0521180741,
0.0514928214,
0.0582669452,
-0.0459728912,
0.0040028263,
-0.0359130241,
0.0133508947,
0.0221647732,
0.0786789879,
0.0247874055,
-0.0260648523,
-0.0379293859,
-0.0180983506,
0.0075737801,
-0.0849713832,
0.024831716,
0.0127131101,
-0.0201595984,
0.0626384392,
-0.087353684,
-0.038666781,
0.0486022495,
0.0374008231,
0.0136114638,
0.0072111981,
0.0010661612,
-0.0165445581,
-0.0472372398,
0.0075153019,
-0.0231422633,
-0.0088893343,
-0.051052738,
-0.0302926265,
0.0049574152,
-0.0624493062,
0.0111274961,
0.0263369791,
-0.0714338794,
-0.0501892529,
-0.0213042591,
0.0409220271,
0.0175908152,
0.0485418476,
0.0145740723,
-0.0303629022,
0.0739594847,
0.0329491161,
-0.0649635047,
0.0187305678,
-0.0135292839,
0.0548149161,
-0.0231307559,
0.038089633,
-0.0959800556,
-0.0067527439,
-0.015071094,
0.0879237354,
0.000179394,
-0.0574061573,
0.0234456323,
0.0628627241,
-0.0300240032,
-0.0212296285,
0.005909605,
-0.0384989157,
0.0220391713,
-0.031390205,
-0.0329491161,
-0.050671149,
0.0385411866,
-0.009951829,
-0.0539084747,
0.0306473617,
0.017783219,
-0.0136050675,
0.0533460602,
-0.0158700105,
-0.0190975368,
-0.0205417909,
0.0000520793,
0.0440026857,
-0.0223336443,
-0.0228215363,
0.0017728114,
-0.014241687,
0.0385527983,
-0.0059936889,
0.0701876283,
0.0115069887,
-0.0075945184,
-0.0106887557,
-0.002639035,
-0.0486162975,
-0.0723318681,
-0.0241684709,
0.0271923374,
0.021465918,
0.0105170906,
0.0560130328,
-0.0519010127,
-0.0117736505,
-0.0302708186,
0.0101238806,
0.0215823501,
-0.032546781,
0.0324552096,
0.0167959034,
-0.0239964854,
-0.0129528427,
0.0788045675,
-0.0076757767,
0.0138361305,
-0.0106391739,
0.0018818206,
-0.0587766245,
-0.0481815115,
0.0113553479,
0.0192361549,
-0.0126087368,
-0.0218211394,
-0.034405414,
-0.0262786932,
0.0141103501,
0.0249904823,
-0.0245532859,
-0.0033225808,
0.0421228893,
0.0804700404,
-0.0086881053,
-0.0388679989,
-0.0683288276,
0.0433579609,
-0.0347509123,
-0.0328760594,
-0.0115297697,
-5.95725329e-33,
-0.0634653941,
-0.0740330517,
0.0684287399,
-0.0049925996,
-0.0123089664,
-0.0018993452,
-0.0628844872,
-0.0073746764,
0.0246134643,
-0.0008162672,
-0.0279402211,
-0.0285237245,
0.0105216792,
0.0393027104,
0.0142417364,
-0.0017845769,
0.042039603,
-0.0052033351,
-0.0321161412,
0.0546092428,
0.0631765202,
0.0168639198,
0.0035148405,
-0.0063436483,
0.0146500692,
-0.0082920138,
-0.0015829363,
0.0257723406,
-0.0080095632,
0.0575051606,
0.0096865091,
0.025406355,
0.017803371,
-0.0117709562,
-0.0534390099,
0.0528324507,
-0.0424485169,
-0.061178375,
0.0247116145,
-0.0340764336,
-0.0502402745,
-0.0622186251,
0.0200572088,
-0.0285773333,
0.0118867178,
-0.0087618046,
0.0283302888,
-0.0014868753,
-0.022227494,
-0.030475473,
-0.0695203766,
0.0104416618,
0.0141463401,
-0.0207607634,
-0.00000539,
0.0533753745,
0.0231521111,
0.0056396131,
-0.008482459,
0.0265944786,
-0.0217364598,
0.0533900112,
0.051291395,
0.0088773919,
-0.0136786308,
0.0409063064,
-0.0155365774,
0.0091952085,
-0.0253822543,
-0.0124640642,
-0.0213191062,
0.0628320053,
-0.0103803724,
0.0509765036,
-0.0258595068,
0.0255290233,
-0.0515046008,
0.0593858697,
0.0094860476,
0.0431441478,
0.0433032513,
-0.0152163552,
0.0086784558,
-0.0034315607,
-0.0386556238,
0.0340171829,
-0.0101621402,
-0.0178063791,
0.0516833775,
0.041150175,
0.0057177432,
-0.0304551497,
0.0349677727,
-0.0168513153,
0.0101367319,
0.0262021553,
-0.0469249636,
0.0106997006,
-0.017408438,
0.0392324589,
-0.0600508302,
-0.016585011,
0.0379081406,
-0.0218929686,
-0.0202100147,
0.0527442992,
-0.0090946723,
0.0256326832,
-0.0404147729,
0.0229006279,
-0.0600755475,
0.045411285,
-0.01819144,
-0.0374636166,
0.0207058527,
-0.014909327,
-0.0087666186,
0.0219403785,
0.0094191255,
-0.036590308,
-0.0195993297,
-0.0378988981,
0.025751546,
0.0126844188,
-0.0227916483,
0.0477510616,
-0.0058147223,
0.019825073,
-0.0031997124,
-0.0190065466,
0.0012126007,
0.0479311794,
2.647e-7,
0.0286190119,
0.0309670698,
0.0183567051,
0.0447374545,
0.0046626865,
-0.0101947095,
-0.004813836,
0.0130447736,
0.0178128947,
-0.0096857995,
0.0198984016,
0.0072721895,
0.041973792,
0.0418840833,
-0.1125602052,
0.0313259363,
-0.0598766431,
-0.016017599,
-0.0606191978,
-0.0273835827,
0.0615350306,
0.0262717083,
-0.0314886458,
-0.0161490105,
-0.0174332038,
-0.0221164692,
0.0758055449,
-0.0126749445,
-0.0413330272,
0.0461851619,
0.0708911642,
-0.0140658719,
0.0016082476,
-0.0044411542,
-0.0336883329,
0.0159202311,
-0.0062452047,
0.0499435812,
0.0263428763,
-0.0511407256,
-0.0050407518,
-0.0469502807,
0.0320307054,
-0.068496339,
0.0391140468,
-0.0140152723,
0.0193332564,
-0.0331220068,
-0.0166495312,
-0.0166860726,
-0.0483410917,
-0.020011073,
0.009149407,
0.0362575278,
0.0152177457,
0.0085784364,
-0.0055443598,
-0.0718196481,
-0.0202679932,
0.0222523902,
-0.0597019754,
-0.0490554459,
-0.0505342036,
-0.0034759613,
-0.0323467925,
-0.0781690329,
-0.0162773207,
2.592956867e-34,
0.0125418017,
-0.0024933091,
-0.0257875938,
0.0185422562,
0.0307084415,
0.0115545513,
-0.0249625165,
0.0369331948,
-0.0046520997,
-0.0982819572,
-0.0522695966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14972v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14972v1 | A Tale of Trust and Accuracy: Base vs. Instruct LLMs in RAG Systems | 2024-06-21T08:31:02 | 2024-06-21T08:31:02 | Florin Cuconasu, Giovanni Trappolini, Nicola Tonellotto, Fabrizio Silvestri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) represents a significant advancement in
artificial intelligence combining a retrieval phase with a generative phase,
with the latter typically being powered by large language models (LLMs). The
current common practices in RAG involve using "instructed" LLMs, which are
fine-tuned with supervised training to enhance their ability to follow
instructions and are aligned with human preferences using state-of-the-art
techniques. Contrary to popular belief, our study demonstrates that base models
outperform their instructed counterparts in RAG tasks by 20% on average under
our experimental settings. This finding challenges the prevailing assumptions
about the superiority of instructed LLMs in RAG applications. Further
investigations reveal a more nuanced situation, questioning fundamental aspects
of RAG and suggesting the need for broader discussions on the topic; or, as
Fromm would have it, "Seldom is a glance at the statistics enough to understand
the meaning of the figures". | [
0.0680724904,
0.0446483083,
-0.0077781882,
-0.0088068144,
-0.0304378215,
-0.0071269614,
0.020493621,
-0.0118823731,
-0.0059228325,
-0.0364603773,
-0.0587898158,
-0.0517569594,
-0.0151081681,
-0.0147624668,
0.0282161273,
-0.0129271885,
0.0355356671,
-0.0100907367,
-0.0281078462,
-0.0008413296,
-0.0160790477,
0.0190169029,
-0.001222365,
0.0385227203,
-0.0203713533,
0.0442859754,
0.0075612194,
0.0292489771,
0.0063197175,
-0.0047179111,
-0.0086070467,
0.0243359897,
0.0500433929,
0.0660062358,
0.0000018079,
-0.0653458014,
-0.0025372161,
-0.0179087278,
-0.0444003344,
0.0421492606,
0.0386078022,
0.0503813513,
-0.0173594337,
0.0349527672,
-0.0416565202,
-0.0063169915,
0.0383356474,
0.0261574462,
0.0324587934,
0.0693630502,
0.0068238708,
-0.0162145272,
0.0387636796,
-0.0484078191,
0.0574443117,
-0.0159046184,
0.0066089034,
0.0090266094,
0.0220945757,
0.0321594812,
0.0220983941,
0.0454901457,
0.0272004586,
-0.0116766784,
0.0150505416,
0.0474724993,
-0.0375185199,
-0.0036416599,
-0.030213207,
0.0309913997,
0.0291189943,
-0.001895366,
-0.0096184667,
0.0176376048,
0.0083601382,
0.0496019609,
-0.0509046093,
0.0277842693,
-0.0120697087,
0.0274207182,
-0.0139095364,
-0.0063688522,
0.0200223867,
0.0355038121,
-0.0201674756,
0.0478677601,
0.0182011239,
-0.041375462,
0.0197938718,
0.0317881368,
-0.0257302932,
-0.0396085903,
0.0142865824,
0.031780526,
-0.0091521433,
0.0368317962,
-0.0202048197,
0.0110946279,
0.0261118207,
0.0333931223,
0.0453536138,
0.0346123166,
-0.0489479862,
0.0110332761,
-0.0528960451,
0.0614629723,
-0.0145436004,
0.0065507162,
-0.0293286722,
0.0302421767,
-0.0609940961,
-0.027482979,
-0.0403098986,
0.047539074,
-0.0392567031,
-0.0388216004,
-0.0529852845,
0.0141699044,
0.0243295617,
0.014874626,
0.0187582374,
0.0478728041,
-0.0620393045,
0.0109537356,
-0.0448173434,
0.0193146132,
-0.0005642753,
0.0425612368,
0.0528607555,
-0.0868141502,
0.0071449443,
0.0199000556,
-0.0104404604,
-0.0087016253,
0.0242788158,
0.0403377675,
-0.0333239883,
-0.0476697199,
-0.0589472055,
-0.0352574959,
-0.0464813523,
-0.0637317598,
0.0056441133,
-0.0715547651,
0.011246155,
0.0040969457,
-0.0116835274,
-0.0275269635,
0.0194776617,
0.0270668902,
-0.0278175306,
0.0167633593,
0.0085904561,
0.0191361178,
0.0435171574,
0.020015832,
0.0045456667,
-0.0038153525,
0.033594057,
0.0827208906,
0.0065198545,
0.0127501842,
0.03494386,
0.0307227857,
0.0006428052,
0.0252789669,
-0.0444034636,
-0.0146253519,
-0.0426130332,
0.0187989082,
0.0467723347,
0.0885556862,
-0.0553777628,
-0.0009563614,
0.0715727508,
0.0475019701,
0.0252935011,
0.0490372665,
0.0694550052,
0.0134729743,
0.0138661405,
0.0244703926,
-0.0279466882,
0.0048812293,
-0.0418521352,
0.0404739156,
0.0442636013,
0.0178291947,
-0.0380738378,
-0.0431107469,
-0.0292368233,
-0.0091956444,
-0.0127981296,
-0.0001335533,
0.0533479676,
0.0085845096,
-0.0432393029,
-0.0005694811,
-0.0023603681,
-0.0784823522,
0.0180150233,
-0.0743990242,
0.0390271768,
0.0852467343,
0.0837178156,
0.0179676507,
0.0041538985,
0.0057189409,
-0.0057455692,
0.0472568162,
0.0260568373,
0.0083025238,
-0.0088242674,
-0.0669270381,
-0.0127385901,
-0.0061163339,
-0.0067323833,
0.0574581735,
0.0238117892,
-0.0183786452,
0.0186830908,
0.0066788602,
-0.0596345402,
0.0264347997,
-0.0390112288,
-0.0368091352,
-0.0038910273,
-0.0130779408,
-0.0021023899,
0.0335763171,
-0.0329588167,
0.0354425572,
0.0493212305,
-0.0181693044,
-0.0117415572,
-0.0063499119,
-0.0528482944,
-0.0043601147,
0.0011530417,
0.0191693846,
0.0229229648,
0.0053310497,
0.0012917515,
-0.0358713865,
0.0156969652,
-0.0575880408,
0.0425005555,
-0.0757760853,
0.0308522973,
0.0362814628,
-0.0129844202,
-0.0648462921,
0.0515861809,
-0.0345573127,
-0.0134745594,
0.0458601266,
0.042571418,
0.0128510287,
-0.0733553097,
-0.0016679979,
0.0189464819,
0.005478594,
0.0197339114,
0.0395640135,
0.0017130709,
-0.0502325185,
-0.0283250324,
-0.0902478546,
0.0003648636,
-0.0183745939,
-0.0004201266,
-0.0113847693,
-0.0028290213,
-0.0163024534,
-0.0171167217,
-0.047032807,
0.0006258201,
0.04244541,
0.0215329081,
-0.00002623,
0.0372347087,
-0.0136562735,
-0.0623059832,
-0.013023667,
0.0183357578,
0.0030713002,
0.0190255791,
0.0087761329,
-0.072108686,
0.0508535095,
-0.0547099747,
-0.0054947231,
-0.003618605,
-0.0504072271,
0.0414305106,
-0.0473209359,
0.0466027111,
0.0477594994,
0.0190589968,
0.0278311856,
0.0512048528,
0.0083942041,
-0.0920892507,
0.0000711884,
-0.041132383,
-0.0674918741,
-0.0070136567,
-0.0028425225,
-0.0143483384,
0.0304176081,
0.0347738527,
0.0095392093,
-0.0211117715,
0.0090719592,
0.0337734781,
-0.0501001365,
-0.0208174493,
-0.0436977856,
-0.0280641504,
0.0438725464,
-0.0302526094,
-0.0907831043,
0.0486628823,
-0.0463432409,
-0.0155919194,
-0.0434352048,
-0.0041290415,
-0.0063666995,
0.0257028751,
-0.0200599525,
0.0367578194,
-0.0523493178,
-0.0409096479,
-0.0377758034,
-0.0070417742,
-0.0197708644,
-0.0648230836,
0.0173941441,
-0.038297534,
0.012692811,
0.0051086764,
-0.027668504,
-0.0849449113,
-0.0113928551,
0.008220504,
0.017766865,
-0.0086673032,
-0.0229379386,
-0.0310583413,
-0.0194500294,
0.0756940767,
0.0166258067,
-0.0019369149,
-0.0320678391,
-0.0130667752,
0.0212810747,
0.0497717634,
-0.0007429565,
0.0133337863,
-0.0084675029,
-0.0244643912,
0.0340575576,
0.0563734658,
0.0125458576,
-0.033530578,
0.0068704318,
0.0445343144,
-0.0030042741,
-0.0115046408,
0.0331711322,
0.016242357,
-0.0447790921,
-0.0350895487,
0.0831486955,
0.0335666649,
-0.0089485496,
-0.0231299493,
-0.0062772692,
0.0452739447,
0.0183858722,
0.0355431437,
-0.0635355562,
-0.0109928343,
0.0072110565,
0.0672500804,
-0.0188394673,
0.0078150593,
-0.0167311337,
-0.1395960152,
0.0435748287,
0.0316265896,
-0.0243783575,
0.0074564172,
-0.024989536,
-0.0105472449,
0.0139937242,
0.0308475997,
0.0512522049,
-0.0178982206,
0.0018549801,
0.0447302125,
0.0170677062,
-0.0499581285,
-0.0165683776,
-0.0481482483,
0.032336954,
0.1273342669,
0.0053561786,
0.0038061379,
-0.0803989768,
0.0278443061,
0.0260140821,
0.0622472279,
-0.0140227908,
0.0339013673,
-0.0156849306,
0.0124646807,
-0.0278047025,
0.0203944184,
0.0087822378,
0.0134360204,
-0.0275440253,
0.0261904411,
-0.0471134037,
0.0181049705,
-0.0241006557,
-0.0009539661,
0.0117053865,
0.0667450204,
0.0254176259,
-0.0242645703,
-0.0145166032,
-0.0109022865,
0.0235625543,
-0.042563837,
-0.0287926514,
0.045216158,
-0.0385781005,
-0.0380482115,
-0.1015437916,
-0.0478439741,
-0.0099522015,
0.057677757,
0.005327411,
-0.0141729647,
-0.0315858983,
0.0002995574,
-0.0318541601,
0.0168697219,
-0.0325524658,
-0.0173250251,
-0.0634570792,
-0.0535329431,
0.0251575708,
-0.0919723436,
0.0045937165,
-0.0164659079,
-0.0300561488,
-0.0727270767,
0.0304818563,
0.0614447109,
0.0386369936,
0.0266356915,
0.0298156701,
-0.0506448597,
0.0557423458,
0.0327650867,
-0.0307672303,
0.0228752401,
-0.0013585985,
0.0149166277,
-0.0140806949,
0.0007684669,
-0.051350642,
0.0413206145,
0.0165677574,
0.0450231396,
0.0034060241,
-0.0181359779,
0.0291682463,
0.0145264231,
0.0451600328,
-0.0326503254,
0.0167320464,
-0.0314334892,
0.0187208578,
-0.0053416686,
0.0197204873,
-0.0286148787,
-0.0158704035,
0.045651339,
0.0108369794,
0.0148757743,
-0.0104172966,
-0.0340272486,
0.0919359401,
-0.0342639424,
-0.0195474047,
-0.0009909383,
0.0305825751,
0.0120122787,
0.0147102019,
-0.0461496077,
0.0365272872,
-0.0136824977,
0.0476837456,
0.0086803753,
0.0592975728,
-0.0089700976,
-0.0379820839,
-0.0104527334,
0.0432257354,
-0.0676063225,
-0.054903768,
-0.0342209227,
0.0242570695,
0.0326908417,
0.0031850096,
0.0508227386,
-0.0375619419,
0.0216335077,
-0.0358584821,
-0.0104736574,
-0.0011148079,
-0.0223384015,
0.0042839451,
0.0212538186,
-0.0223283768,
0.0301221348,
0.0378412865,
-0.0076033096,
0.049541723,
-0.0768480748,
-0.0326310955,
-0.0195395704,
-0.0471754931,
0.0195145197,
0.0258920286,
-0.0199923813,
-0.0259524845,
-0.0514182411,
-0.0407488905,
-0.0020176207,
0.0244498346,
0.014925817,
-0.0295985378,
0.0459302105,
0.0620960742,
-0.0157289617,
0.0163415633,
-0.0390922464,
-0.0114213051,
-0.0653961226,
-0.0163769796,
-0.0299873669,
-6.11899617e-33,
-0.0283889621,
-0.014762599,
0.0618218258,
-0.0688769147,
-0.0362706184,
-0.0087641869,
-0.0341120586,
0.0081562717,
-0.0005622656,
-0.0441942625,
-0.0206233673,
-0.0228332821,
0.0217591505,
0.0214997027,
0.0150234094,
0.0285576805,
0.0615161359,
0.0025994494,
-0.033178363,
0.0149471015,
0.0820663869,
0.041862838,
0.0327850915,
-0.0518817827,
0.0047575356,
-0.013547522,
-0.0025991146,
-0.0059688725,
-0.0232563484,
0.0880052298,
-0.015783973,
0.0186968409,
0.0041324482,
-0.0168336295,
-0.0204330292,
0.0375755243,
-0.0357994176,
0.000192184,
0.0069473009,
-0.0267778654,
-0.0379411019,
-0.0279555097,
0.0521183722,
-0.0430058129,
-0.0541432537,
0.0525503047,
0.0132478271,
-0.04581609,
-0.027848484,
-0.018700067,
-0.0375518985,
-0.0182043314,
0.0396904051,
-0.0129755158,
-0.0010886629,
0.0392034203,
-0.0164426863,
0.019621823,
-0.0526792072,
0.0468475409,
0.0069647897,
0.0580569133,
0.0784672573,
0.0235529058,
0.0028892797,
0.0548447445,
0.0403823219,
-0.046898067,
-0.0123314075,
-0.0407302044,
0.042168431,
0.0578228869,
0.0149080381,
0.0570197366,
0.0506016053,
-0.0140245073,
-0.0313750543,
0.0448423401,
0.0358297862,
0.0473424532,
0.0372883044,
0.0170847122,
-0.0566187873,
0.0092966082,
-0.0219993275,
0.0091426205,
-0.0324037932,
-0.0834195539,
0.0678577125,
0.0572913401,
-0.0218011644,
0.008094239,
0.0559700951,
0.0094386209,
-0.0113404654,
-0.0069065024,
-0.048289299,
0.0034288841,
-0.0362833887,
-0.0118845794,
-0.0598849691,
-0.0268212315,
0.0680410862,
0.0055107251,
-0.0413652547,
0.0225230046,
0.0239425432,
0.0294356681,
-0.0500163138,
0.0312256459,
-0.0511672273,
0.0244136937,
0.01212213,
-0.034715116,
0.0461949892,
0.0030936177,
-0.0179527402,
0.0408900045,
-0.0056746602,
-0.028529793,
-0.0427487455,
-0.0462617874,
0.0101146195,
-0.0047894879,
-0.0346792415,
0.0435132124,
0.0085469903,
0.0281486493,
0.0031263197,
0.0047474373,
-0.0091483332,
0.0255293772,
2.656e-7,
-0.0002808682,
0.0209700242,
0.0674170256,
-0.0269359443,
-0.0070347195,
-0.0157803968,
-0.020374978,
0.0040055048,
0.0287801381,
0.0026005551,
0.0027756889,
0.0259853415,
0.0542343259,
-0.0092718862,
-0.0462214053,
-0.032308355,
-0.0542180948,
0.0033299078,
-0.0649036691,
-0.0094016585,
0.0700551048,
0.0408888273,
0.0015127265,
-0.044428166,
0.0071128388,
-0.0114147663,
0.0635248572,
-0.0064592632,
-0.0064396216,
-0.0072985752,
0.0383616649,
0.0585800037,
-0.022528952,
-0.0287427474,
0.0061190282,
0.0154168224,
-0.0091896309,
0.0497254021,
-0.006127628,
-0.068143934,
0.0124959089,
0.0259554945,
0.0077085141,
-0.0252708569,
0.0280975066,
-0.0159326456,
0.0283500105,
0.0045363419,
-0.0233209673,
-0.0141370948,
-0.0105800936,
-0.0415172502,
-0.001215046,
0.0014606648,
-0.0141035235,
0.0187750254,
-0.0060399729,
-0.0768312216,
0.0078894058,
0.0024165106,
-0.04648697,
-0.0736772716,
-0.0440111533,
0.0375586897,
-0.0359898917,
-0.0680266544,
-0.0300660711,
2.448530167e-34,
0.0095582223,
0.0036637457,
0.0262167901,
0.0355529115,
0.0162726771,
0.020491682,
-0.0427321903,
0.033779718,
0.01421538,
-0.0788508356,
-0.0383495577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14971v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14971v1 | Domain Adaptation of Llama3-70B-Instruct through Continual Pre-Training and Model Merging: A Comprehensive Evaluation | 2024-06-21T08:29:31 | 2024-06-21T08:29:31 | Shamane Siriwardhana, Mark McQuade, Thomas Gauthier, Lucas Atkins, Fernando Fernandes Neto, Luke Meyers, Anneketh Vij, Tyler Odenthal, Charles Goddard, Mary MacCarthy, Jacob Solawetz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We conducted extensive experiments on domain adaptation of the
Meta-Llama-3-70B-Instruct model on SEC data, exploring its performance on both
general and domain-specific benchmarks. Our focus included continual
pre-training (CPT) and model merging, aiming to enhance the model's
domain-specific capabilities while mitigating catastrophic forgetting. Through
this study, we evaluated the impact of integrating financial regulatory data
into a robust language model and examined the effectiveness of our model
merging techniques in preserving and improving the model's instructive
abilities. The model is accessible at hugging face:
https://huggingface.co/arcee-ai/Llama-3-SEC-Base, arcee-ai/Llama-3-SEC-Base.
This is an intermediate checkpoint of our final model, which has seen 20B
tokens so far. The full model is still in the process of training. This is a
preprint technical report with thorough evaluations to understand the entire
process. | [
0.0052301409,
0.0527638495,
-0.0195693374,
0.0094899526,
0.0255537052,
0.0370747857,
0.0270056874,
0.020822864,
0.0018913306,
-0.0499736406,
-0.0774039701,
-0.03550018,
-0.0170356967,
0.0813293606,
0.0317594111,
-0.0353570953,
0.0671001598,
-0.0399823934,
0.0203673374,
-0.0210740175,
0.0181645062,
-0.0255033076,
0.0226563159,
-0.0048474362,
0.0335456021,
0.0084362542,
0.018613413,
-0.0331718773,
-0.0071032424,
-0.001471398,
0.0218216591,
0.0245022979,
0.0353408866,
0.0463035628,
0.0000022708,
-0.0752702206,
-0.0577008165,
-0.0070329909,
-0.0525631383,
0.0345302112,
0.0359334089,
-0.0268175956,
-0.0106368819,
0.0398042388,
-0.0595416948,
0.0159656052,
0.0479976982,
0.0320509374,
0.0890464485,
0.078623496,
-0.0130999712,
-0.0646018982,
0.028806895,
-0.058458522,
-0.039835982,
-0.0654848963,
0.0696865022,
-0.0023778696,
-0.0208545532,
-0.0128344893,
-0.0256045517,
0.0394690521,
0.0256258287,
-0.020650696,
0.0189639814,
0.0109605547,
-0.012247758,
-0.0071050716,
-0.0475356132,
0.0460115671,
0.0294005722,
0.0120068155,
0.0122413123,
-0.0187382195,
0.0150827356,
0.0100933323,
-0.061443381,
-0.0098685883,
0.0210533272,
0.011004921,
0.0295201745,
-0.0163823236,
0.0257539563,
0.0108546074,
-0.0490163229,
0.0177501515,
-0.0029875843,
-0.0469855294,
0.0254187193,
-0.0126483319,
0.0023030918,
-0.0360675827,
0.0230032764,
0.024211254,
0.0023618997,
0.0286096185,
-0.0602146648,
-0.0065619186,
-0.00294629,
-0.0576741397,
0.0196947828,
0.0574380904,
-0.0495048948,
0.0472681634,
-0.0487382449,
0.0650098771,
-0.001222057,
0.0328397192,
-0.0293410979,
0.0201387722,
-0.059404958,
-0.0114956163,
-0.0340756923,
0.0754655674,
-0.0518356487,
-0.0101955123,
-0.090723455,
0.0014733692,
-0.01338505,
0.0083323112,
0.0176273622,
-0.0563403256,
-0.0148046883,
-0.0141433803,
-0.0486997962,
0.0070847203,
-0.0258790925,
0.0547932014,
0.0182655398,
-0.0218490046,
0.0088841785,
0.0000978266,
-0.0435237996,
-0.0208595786,
0.0163542666,
0.0956832096,
0.011762321,
-0.0293303542,
-0.0849093571,
-0.0304726996,
0.0049510198,
-0.0352038853,
0.0518253781,
-0.0200150069,
0.0407120474,
-0.0331476443,
0.0145645915,
-0.0781892985,
-0.0125082303,
-0.0363846831,
-0.0012066616,
0.0733089149,
-0.0344594978,
-0.0342631154,
-0.0076957522,
0.0012708589,
-0.0174489133,
0.0851698443,
-0.0112789776,
0.0019656629,
0.0148672005,
-0.0054738582,
-0.010817905,
0.0542619415,
0.0285039749,
-0.0123942653,
0.0105370181,
0.0071187117,
0.0059909681,
-0.0233014394,
0.0511360019,
0.021580616,
-0.0125134308,
-0.0204436257,
0.0496348105,
0.0228002984,
0.0572795495,
0.0049749888,
-0.0035002632,
-0.0085880719,
0.0412909091,
0.0080680493,
-0.0538896285,
-0.0067393575,
-0.0440542661,
0.0333013311,
-0.0174816083,
0.0508784652,
-0.0403359942,
-0.0590446219,
-0.0022611951,
-0.0207307078,
-0.0560220182,
0.004820223,
0.0618006624,
0.0108619183,
-0.0447051711,
0.0494816117,
0.0530211926,
-0.0109651089,
-0.001426355,
-0.0513624176,
0.0280720368,
0.0644348562,
0.0195724908,
-0.041473221,
-0.027575247,
-0.0126679866,
0.0286938772,
0.0636031032,
0.0367074274,
-0.0145591479,
-0.0074555906,
-0.0805064663,
-0.0477846451,
0.0231908001,
0.0330544487,
0.0489530228,
-0.0160394814,
-0.0110024586,
0.0034245413,
0.0025582602,
0.0151289329,
0.0414000303,
-0.0716944262,
-0.0355308354,
-0.0321621746,
-0.0148478718,
0.0168752782,
0.031483084,
-0.0085682524,
-0.0038335992,
0.0393319279,
-0.0136540039,
-0.0192890875,
-0.0008962283,
-0.0617529601,
0.015729323,
0.0423946008,
0.0054810094,
0.0039885826,
-0.0144914025,
-0.0433172472,
-0.0435137562,
-0.0201376509,
-0.004395585,
0.03984062,
-0.0467440411,
0.0405930988,
-0.0101812724,
0.0266802702,
-0.0090490887,
0.0638971254,
-0.0200128891,
-0.0421265736,
0.0139257396,
-0.0273927245,
0.0077699907,
-0.0223589316,
0.0135058155,
0.0077429474,
-0.0484293774,
0.0114775319,
-0.0011617962,
0.0046160659,
-0.0315398313,
-0.0136599196,
-0.0083276937,
-0.0156918485,
-0.0128740473,
0.0633215457,
0.0179382619,
0.0140938871,
-0.0307730418,
-0.0116990143,
-0.0133910282,
-0.0168455988,
-0.024500899,
0.0242423378,
0.025309246,
-0.0052031367,
-0.058887478,
-0.059074983,
-0.0137918321,
-0.0202914663,
0.0216986164,
-0.0064442386,
-0.0694391355,
-0.0353308581,
0.0259940978,
-0.0184562467,
0.0240117162,
-0.0250598118,
0.00793608,
-0.0036413539,
0.008848317,
0.0365751795,
-0.0028506774,
-0.0513793118,
0.0330249369,
0.029847892,
-0.0094423387,
-0.0423116423,
-0.0004112275,
0.0293691214,
-0.0120335072,
-0.0548233762,
0.0205358118,
0.0223238245,
0.0686310828,
-0.0596988685,
-0.0065781856,
-0.0633235648,
0.013980967,
-0.0292775575,
-0.0230387244,
-0.0353468247,
-0.0049972399,
-0.0217478089,
0.0544058606,
0.0023275823,
-0.0439995676,
0.0541361533,
-0.0003196517,
-0.0042804196,
-0.0387207642,
-0.0069678091,
-0.0495602265,
0.0183087811,
-0.0471414216,
-0.0108650336,
0.0549207479,
-0.0590766706,
-0.050600037,
-0.0460522771,
0.0287335981,
-0.0132575529,
0.0522839688,
-0.0516851321,
0.0455518141,
0.0004468067,
-0.0238412209,
-0.0357590131,
-0.0257853027,
-0.0112098791,
0.0370824449,
0.010029505,
-0.0161840729,
-0.0620412566,
-0.0159161985,
-0.0213702619,
-0.0076363538,
0.0105299372,
-0.0281354301,
0.002018379,
0.0052087931,
0.0445664898,
0.0272318069,
0.0390320197,
-0.0601028651,
0.0649363697,
-0.0048355376,
0.0196237564,
-0.0383140855,
-0.0166680776,
0.0145641174,
0.0196831655,
-0.0458990932,
-0.0038863944,
0.0287140626,
-0.0069236476,
-0.0484498143,
0.0078153005,
0.0821243003,
0.0202405695,
0.0170898326,
-0.005678216,
-0.0274479259,
0.0288473703,
0.0218287893,
0.0455571264,
-0.0835830942,
-0.0111841839,
0.0339563787,
0.0112296967,
0.0228968132,
-0.0102746086,
-0.0126986234,
-0.0919399038,
0.0444303639,
0.0101686493,
-0.0333847217,
-0.0332641415,
-0.037725959,
-0.0128448727,
-0.019551767,
0.040924143,
-0.0037712273,
-0.0452247113,
-0.0232145842,
0.0423372425,
-0.0345878862,
-0.0400832742,
-0.0250258707,
-0.0221537333,
0.0443826653,
0.0583566576,
-0.0108006196,
-0.0123104779,
-0.0331462845,
0.0407363586,
0.009607994,
-0.020492956,
-0.0109924506,
0.0357559919,
0.0249208026,
-0.0071142274,
0.0389547832,
0.037845578,
-0.0335977785,
-0.0080294451,
0.0099270884,
0.0447391495,
-0.0032814415,
0.0020152908,
-0.0190743841,
0.0098841479,
-0.0456661582,
0.0627450868,
0.0215137806,
-0.0106785633,
0.0076951464,
-0.0380038023,
-0.0374630988,
-0.0388933532,
0.0191898197,
0.0238966662,
-0.0423191041,
-0.0221312642,
-0.080592446,
-0.0537876934,
0.0120805232,
0.0522976965,
0.0394004732,
0.0286630057,
0.0431844406,
-0.0317592695,
-0.0036533845,
0.0083706817,
-0.0927348658,
0.0289942939,
-0.0769387335,
0.0369448215,
0.0134275295,
-0.0141951256,
-0.0471733697,
0.0252682716,
-0.0549886711,
-0.058801204,
0.0530955233,
0.0246209223,
0.0331144519,
0.0046281936,
-0.0219090562,
-0.0136324428,
0.078195557,
0.0510900244,
-0.0490611792,
0.0088693881,
0.0769156143,
-0.0317211375,
-0.0264153276,
0.010695925,
-0.0619335584,
0.0103759151,
-0.0002400607,
-0.0085180756,
-0.0044074161,
0.0285697486,
0.0116040679,
0.0380936228,
0.0098788701,
0.0048269695,
-0.0593478531,
-0.0467980392,
0.0279058013,
0.0010525,
0.021530319,
-0.0166033562,
-0.0352116227,
0.0599324442,
0.0052833487,
0.0106483623,
0.0225934777,
-0.0097412206,
0.007802445,
-0.0241304357,
0.021029057,
-0.0134556442,
0.0666557699,
0.0008581249,
-0.0286097415,
0.0200543981,
0.0244509652,
0.0367859341,
0.0217148438,
-0.0231665522,
0.0414701402,
-0.0033753598,
0.0292839315,
-0.0311952755,
0.0184212867,
-0.0349045619,
-0.0045831087,
-0.0110127199,
0.0544364154,
0.0616538115,
-0.0045627602,
0.0255960301,
-0.0244936906,
0.0080599971,
-0.0016777116,
0.0206290446,
0.0048871045,
-0.0217251033,
0.0791486725,
-0.0050588585,
-0.0189387519,
-0.0143059064,
0.0773528442,
0.0315086916,
0.0581226125,
-0.0211182013,
0.0439922996,
-0.0294363853,
-0.0489218272,
0.0762868151,
0.0087729609,
-0.0410825796,
-0.0484883077,
-0.0665530115,
-0.0466635898,
0.0221496746,
-0.0126109477,
-0.0337057523,
0.0086733503,
0.0317296274,
0.0413072966,
0.0006414788,
0.0011328945,
0.0084630344,
-0.0250560474,
0.0131293293,
-0.0251267906,
-0.0154581061,
-6.752396608e-33,
-0.0601921007,
0.0013448603,
0.0629651099,
0.0115449699,
-0.0254795551,
-0.0111017693,
-0.0070618307,
-0.0242713429,
-0.0120060248,
-0.0100264493,
-0.0165264923,
0.0274217371,
0.0379946679,
0.0078024054,
-0.0046167024,
-0.0319005623,
0.0377420373,
-0.0093207089,
0.0129579194,
-0.0055815289,
-0.0035450205,
0.0711462125,
0.0494819358,
-0.0900750682,
0.058860898,
0.0453684144,
-0.0390146747,
-0.0113035683,
-0.0010253945,
0.0924271196,
-0.0233822782,
0.0316584557,
0.0028385725,
-0.0670237094,
-0.0480852798,
-0.0003566428,
-0.0747266784,
-0.0487040281,
0.0370336995,
0.0222342145,
0.0482137799,
-0.0529230237,
0.0525462069,
-0.0061635398,
-0.0130145764,
-0.0341130495,
0.0221439339,
-0.0200179163,
-0.0274027195,
-0.010695138,
-0.1147734448,
0.0217911825,
0.0143623427,
0.0314685404,
0.0427322164,
0.0490586981,
0.0331162959,
-0.011512382,
-0.0312625468,
0.0435044505,
0.0193593446,
0.0159732867,
0.0585403293,
0.0228414312,
-0.0322475582,
0.0493735932,
-0.0262834728,
0.0004847178,
0.0451734774,
-0.0200158786,
0.0466246381,
0.0511090346,
0.006719674,
0.037426997,
-0.0006049229,
-0.0347813964,
-0.0614806525,
0.0579944216,
0.0105976211,
0.0301961042,
-0.0146732433,
0.0495622791,
-0.024538707,
-0.0210545752,
-0.0150118591,
0.0540558547,
-0.0133901285,
-0.0139453793,
0.0350185223,
-0.0136833368,
-0.0050963843,
0.0087093841,
0.0161574073,
-0.0713209212,
-0.0451384149,
-0.016995728,
0.0076720505,
0.0167419929,
0.0046959221,
0.0263533648,
-0.0520390943,
-0.0705258399,
0.0176418144,
0.0046152216,
0.0136837196,
-0.0291040856,
0.0399583243,
0.0330799259,
-0.0773755014,
0.0096239299,
-0.0012437515,
0.0133706024,
0.0711283833,
0.0394883864,
0.012097056,
0.0328734033,
0.005879546,
-0.0051537585,
0.0253028236,
-0.0261377003,
-0.0120808426,
0.0139374677,
0.0003634836,
0.0606673509,
-0.0187016763,
0.0026353661,
-0.0172116235,
0.0467986949,
0.0647929907,
-0.0468158461,
-0.0318595096,
0.0234000012,
2.935e-7,
0.0604226477,
0.0564547405,
0.0201994162,
0.0011896834,
-0.0181200877,
0.0219218284,
-0.0612753406,
0.0264357254,
0.009624037,
0.0304719135,
0.0070038503,
-0.0038504384,
0.0615773797,
0.0028451784,
-0.0764384195,
-0.0347206704,
-0.0283655934,
0.0129480306,
-0.0616413467,
0.0276911445,
0.0327686667,
0.1045411527,
0.0087526785,
-0.0503557511,
-0.004217017,
-0.0630400404,
0.0511070788,
-0.0336540602,
-0.0224853177,
0.0209073722,
0.0194709003,
0.0457895175,
-0.021570297,
0.0137245376,
-0.028689228,
0.0392797887,
-0.0146387089,
0.070647791,
0.0274100583,
0.0276233666,
0.0090531129,
0.0120876571,
-0.0123971179,
-0.0130208507,
0.0330926292,
-0.0427227803,
-0.0336137339,
-0.0243315753,
-0.0476288535,
0.0005096644,
0.0192857701,
-0.0010100107,
0.0232188422,
0.0050678905,
0.0179124512,
-0.0154427681,
-0.027727196,
-0.0260181464,
0.0171463042,
-0.0087418957,
-0.0257663354,
0.0011569265,
-0.0591271035,
0.023290962,
0.0145718269,
-0.0951202586,
0.0287284162,
2.915118313e-34,
0.0375737809,
-0.0610296801,
0.0195532497,
0.0719081983,
0.0198276248,
-0.0069295852,
0.0008085623,
0.057824973,
-0.002739564,
-0.0764747709,
0.0334652178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14956v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14956v1 | Unlocking the Global Synergies in Low-Rank Adapters | 2024-06-21T08:10:03 | 2024-06-21T08:10:03 | Zixi Zhang, Cheng Zhang, Xitong Gao, Robert D. Mullins, George A. Constantinides, Yiren Zhao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Low-rank Adaption (LoRA) has been the de-facto parameter-efficient
fine-tuning technique for large language models. We present HeteroLoRA, a
light-weight search algorithm that leverages zero-cost proxies to allocate the
limited LoRA trainable parameters across the model for better fine-tuned
performance. In addition to the allocation for the standard LoRA-adapted
models, we also demonstrate the efficacy of HeteroLoRA by performing the
allocation in a more challenging search space that includes LoRA modules and
LoRA-adapted shortcut connections. Experiments show that HeteroLoRA enables
improvements in model performance given the same parameter budge. For example,
on MRPC, we see an improvement of 1.6% in accuracy with similar training
parameter budget. We will open-source our algorithm once the paper is accepted. | [
0.0406449288,
0.0703797042,
-0.004903886,
0.0578095391,
0.0284727197,
0.0062716282,
0.0041341968,
-0.0072984472,
0.0133133326,
-0.0211263634,
-0.0710644051,
-0.0155471265,
0.0298980866,
0.0016011094,
0.0316284448,
-0.0291557796,
0.0381562971,
-0.0255152006,
-0.0523601398,
0.0012444564,
-0.0210177787,
0.0331910104,
0.0012915481,
0.0436565317,
0.0534056798,
0.007991829,
-0.0098201018,
0.0434184037,
0.0380589291,
0.0163505282,
0.003671953,
0.0442361757,
-0.0101263234,
0.0808372274,
0.0000020768,
-0.02103265,
-0.0282689258,
-0.0158087872,
-0.0304718595,
0.0191364232,
0.0155012906,
0.0119573381,
-0.0183422938,
0.0340071172,
-0.0083098803,
-0.0028179667,
0.076841794,
0.0045228791,
0.0257969312,
0.089987047,
-0.0208017547,
-0.0052200845,
0.0015202675,
-0.0507576577,
-0.0384084508,
-0.054302182,
0.0236836672,
-0.0147638498,
0.0083347708,
-0.0228824541,
-0.0456762612,
0.0394046344,
-0.0118542556,
0.0062783854,
0.0179699846,
0.0130454358,
-0.0596857965,
-0.0278941747,
0.0019041998,
0.0813960284,
-0.0799193159,
-0.0428165048,
0.0066458895,
-0.012074641,
-0.02394161,
-0.0016391993,
-0.0043524685,
-0.009460181,
0.0229876712,
0.0164859444,
0.0039966027,
-0.0459053405,
0.0443485416,
0.000891738,
-0.0655232668,
0.0221383218,
0.0402201191,
-0.0018478503,
0.0242901724,
-0.0194524247,
-0.0340884291,
-0.0371604674,
-0.0029885613,
-0.0009250673,
-0.0235663615,
-0.0091830399,
-0.0496490747,
-0.0438457578,
-0.0021976919,
-0.01194527,
0.0794347674,
0.0727301538,
0.0228865929,
0.0392866321,
-0.1024089903,
0.0275953431,
-0.056344606,
0.021478653,
-0.0626435876,
-0.0277129188,
-0.0217317436,
0.0004035652,
-0.0261485949,
-0.0005573956,
-0.0779146999,
-0.0296046883,
-0.015670469,
0.0446051136,
0.0171200745,
-0.0165344495,
0.002343178,
-0.0141760129,
-0.0413996279,
-0.0141341332,
0.0092459284,
0.0749236271,
0.0153014129,
0.0098471837,
-0.0339704379,
-0.0400570035,
-0.0173197929,
0.0152615625,
0.0379479751,
-0.0564524494,
0.0459949151,
0.0541448668,
-0.0241537914,
-0.0494323596,
0.0141177867,
0.0308801513,
-0.0036310796,
-0.0573686361,
0.0052481452,
-0.0107466709,
0.0123337163,
-0.0005625551,
0.0397247337,
-0.0134939356,
-0.0183169376,
-0.0057365936,
-0.0721496046,
0.058930669,
0.001853223,
0.0121342437,
-0.0144955041,
-0.0267667696,
0.0374417156,
0.0842755735,
0.0205056425,
0.0294485148,
-0.0081658969,
-0.0275936555,
-0.0476162247,
0.0484012254,
0.0185776781,
-0.002330807,
-0.0022393698,
0.0117961187,
0.0556652024,
0.0243517011,
0.0438833944,
0.0041752784,
-0.0275748149,
-0.0246156882,
0.0494685955,
0.0099547254,
0.1098034531,
0.0297150519,
0.0080416007,
-0.0441348068,
-0.014701277,
-0.0422645956,
-0.0556788966,
0.0471432917,
-0.0586673282,
0.002892303,
0.0179324429,
0.0931531712,
-0.026631467,
0.0035072959,
-0.0216061305,
0.0232596584,
-0.0464639291,
0.0275049247,
0.0221722424,
-0.0234403219,
-0.0248832051,
0.019863382,
0.0396904424,
-0.0505060777,
-0.0171075352,
-0.0658543333,
0.0134354113,
0.04556638,
0.0278416071,
-0.0028951582,
-0.0190010704,
0.006681975,
0.0096600633,
0.0181220006,
0.0334735885,
0.01860095,
0.0447204821,
-0.0560114346,
-0.025218308,
0.0431380831,
0.0081379814,
0.0441592596,
-0.0168092325,
0.0137184141,
0.0037079316,
-0.0235363729,
-0.0221866947,
0.02404394,
-0.0032788604,
0.0208002832,
0.0274149869,
0.0326683857,
0.0289360229,
-0.0024321384,
-0.0192562602,
-0.0334826075,
0.0112106251,
-0.0328889936,
0.0337079689,
-0.0056757415,
-0.0161011368,
-0.0221869443,
0.0023448195,
-0.0170072727,
0.0347714722,
0.0877277181,
0.0063601779,
-0.0556284785,
0.025250392,
0.0122785484,
0.0696548373,
-0.0265837256,
0.0384426899,
-0.0293471776,
0.0650467128,
-0.0197335239,
0.0259982143,
0.0371278413,
0.0169567447,
0.0611434802,
0.0142702721,
0.034406133,
-0.0317467749,
-0.0555674583,
0.0113605838,
-0.0021387818,
0.0235517044,
0.0140057262,
0.0167321414,
0.0064177304,
-0.0735931173,
-0.0798511133,
0.0373161957,
-0.0330278538,
0.0178335812,
0.0378273539,
0.0284287632,
0.005764842,
-0.0323869586,
0.0185105912,
0.0242343824,
-0.0297929347,
0.0490691774,
-0.0261317343,
0.0354386158,
-0.0237301495,
-0.0576815791,
-0.0284216478,
0.0173269007,
0.0530454069,
-0.0296474639,
-0.0121445991,
-0.0585663393,
-0.0070770239,
-0.0123597998,
0.0128323846,
-0.0139489044,
-0.0698415115,
-0.0253979582,
-0.0222923327,
0.0172604788,
0.0752373561,
-0.0111427298,
-0.0166622717,
0.0660596266,
0.0271034203,
-0.0528725833,
0.0126183303,
0.0190968458,
-0.0405718945,
-0.0485349521,
0.0082062455,
-0.020899402,
0.0636844188,
-0.0434744544,
-0.0186238457,
-0.068325147,
-0.0044494956,
0.0189418234,
-0.0262335371,
-0.0421754383,
0.0288350694,
0.014813792,
-0.0035273274,
-0.0138989668,
-0.0294505693,
0.0182072502,
-0.0385773666,
-0.0353972279,
-0.0241064485,
-0.038278807,
-0.0382305942,
0.0061524394,
0.0292486064,
0.0408769287,
-0.024592407,
-0.0118249934,
-0.0534915179,
0.01070558,
0.0157355778,
0.0001913342,
0.0643218085,
-0.012648507,
0.0458233431,
-0.0651327372,
-0.0508673303,
0.0129509354,
-0.0327491984,
-0.0016048376,
0.0259568021,
0.0154625271,
-0.0547910705,
-0.0507697463,
0.0470824465,
0.0043872818,
0.069468677,
-0.0246904176,
-0.0092507768,
-0.0345836803,
0.0178089887,
0.0863186195,
0.0573638715,
0.0225457624,
0.0171036497,
0.0312220547,
-0.0113785639,
0.0564392619,
0.0079747643,
-0.037225984,
0.0304950345,
0.0351682119,
0.013917001,
-0.0189152118,
0.0097261388,
0.0251616593,
-0.0442730188,
-0.0029501631,
0.0791696087,
-0.0066685448,
-0.0718304366,
-0.0172504783,
-0.0114165433,
0.0894146115,
0.0299402326,
0.0488332696,
-0.0199690033,
-0.0230825618,
0.0095723579,
0.0134380367,
0.0115276752,
-0.012108501,
0.0065271193,
-0.0836890936,
0.0022057469,
0.0071814777,
-0.0490388758,
-0.0532853976,
-0.0257000346,
0.0129360585,
-0.0340268239,
0.0391731188,
0.0244478974,
-0.0321912244,
-0.0385774821,
0.0155305862,
-0.0234348718,
-0.0410018153,
-0.0096041793,
-0.0201690923,
0.0814468563,
0.0248336047,
0.0297202282,
0.0110582309,
-0.001888153,
-0.0063695754,
-0.0508981161,
-0.0027200233,
-0.0355144329,
0.0105848117,
0.0077278013,
-0.0491721146,
0.0212370977,
-0.0005558183,
-0.0178890284,
0.0118119447,
-0.0270839836,
0.0646029636,
0.0082759652,
0.0234421659,
0.0013490462,
-0.0263306759,
-0.0181262773,
0.0592092127,
0.0109420018,
-0.036287263,
-0.0091326917,
-0.0020132773,
-0.0220031794,
-0.0370684005,
-0.0219733343,
0.0012653493,
-0.0360670052,
0.0213573184,
-0.015957335,
0.0070060613,
0.0471944958,
0.0721046403,
0.0049795797,
0.0158300791,
-0.0503918454,
0.0071061524,
-0.0091898767,
0.0315443315,
-0.0614738725,
0.0015166679,
-0.0306738522,
-0.0115179028,
0.0234629996,
-0.0305466186,
-0.0179256909,
-0.0070749158,
-0.0450983681,
-0.0534130186,
-0.0233254898,
0.0435522236,
0.0248233937,
0.0610774234,
-0.0149277197,
-0.0636206269,
0.0209465139,
0.0145133426,
0.0230305158,
0.0818425119,
0.0220432505,
-0.0415687263,
-0.0303550977,
0.0469452366,
-0.0695769638,
-0.0297725908,
0.0502485894,
0.0541108139,
-0.0003930284,
-0.047076799,
-0.0155290766,
-0.0054192473,
0.0074932519,
-0.0016618919,
-0.0379694663,
-0.0425667986,
0.0811646134,
-0.0281700231,
0.0186372381,
-0.0300554782,
-0.0115041472,
0.0457546189,
0.0187184289,
-0.0171614271,
-0.0204879865,
0.0331876278,
0.0565753058,
-0.0433557257,
0.0056713913,
0.0001303192,
-0.0193305723,
0.0469858237,
0.0220833197,
-0.0155025702,
0.011309905,
0.0502865165,
0.034698654,
-0.071187757,
-0.0037016508,
0.0255706478,
-0.0289320964,
-0.0282898024,
0.0643867776,
-0.0393119864,
-0.0832578838,
-0.041556336,
0.0164804328,
0.0728415996,
-0.0076535088,
0.0805872455,
0.0087973149,
0.0030440907,
-0.0152580319,
-0.0190024599,
-0.0054411585,
0.0053057359,
0.0234523024,
0.0063836616,
-0.0114522791,
0.0292458162,
0.0382845886,
0.0100349793,
0.0796668679,
-0.0205118731,
0.0078178681,
-0.0251827203,
-0.0307462662,
0.0150993103,
0.0164145902,
-0.0336940065,
-0.0077249934,
-0.0062043262,
-0.0505271479,
-0.0073564379,
-0.0218280628,
-0.0263738241,
-0.0097101927,
-0.0240876619,
0.0276395474,
-0.0098998845,
-0.0201757103,
-0.0211435426,
-0.0564694777,
0.0046079876,
0.0163027849,
0.0129295876,
-6.917284669e-33,
-0.0456641316,
0.0188382287,
-0.0035866522,
-0.0272763371,
-0.0087709362,
-0.0034787282,
-0.0122754835,
-0.003933352,
-0.0670545325,
-0.0291004553,
-0.0181567594,
-0.0031980225,
0.0179934148,
0.0252320562,
-0.0027141888,
0.0240763575,
0.0525181554,
0.0246666018,
-0.0186094213,
-0.0025238944,
0.0185902137,
0.0347898379,
0.0299154799,
0.0016967638,
-0.0711677745,
0.0119830929,
-0.0175648574,
0.023007853,
-0.0002022752,
0.0666161329,
-0.0093861688,
0.0468770117,
0.020521611,
0.020591788,
-0.0035619999,
0.0145426886,
-0.0817358792,
0.0072974111,
0.028125992,
0.0124523453,
0.0192028694,
-0.0185820088,
0.0380482823,
0.0120449727,
0.0115827424,
-0.0320310555,
0.0128763486,
-0.0275050942,
-0.0511305183,
0.0319979303,
-0.0587675348,
-0.0031638194,
0.006758329,
-0.000311617,
0.0190948881,
0.02210637,
0.0036408817,
0.0131513914,
-0.0494916476,
-0.0158514194,
-0.0145195201,
0.0914287791,
0.0289133564,
0.0587820783,
-0.0033365861,
0.0410982072,
-0.0008333169,
-0.0319915898,
0.07228861,
-0.0130400006,
0.0600374714,
0.02509683,
0.0362650603,
0.040545661,
0.0030232877,
-0.0184577499,
-0.0475226976,
-0.0189117957,
0.0288990643,
0.0071723228,
0.0272592138,
0.0406159461,
-0.0418698303,
0.0131003093,
-0.0318145938,
-0.0044583185,
-0.0757400095,
-0.0332498513,
0.039757669,
0.0373240709,
-0.0227884594,
0.0278372709,
0.0687583536,
-0.0352979451,
0.0109617198,
0.0027009053,
0.0054583494,
-0.0002362855,
0.0062842267,
0.0380713269,
-0.0503549613,
-0.0635196865,
0.0397677608,
-0.0363198705,
0.0087557612,
-0.018641863,
0.011291136,
0.0468562022,
-0.0889383629,
-0.0304770116,
-0.029782081,
0.0121133514,
-0.0194100253,
0.0573653653,
-0.0023060001,
-0.0071960636,
0.0053721713,
0.0465219542,
-0.0012232059,
0.01724682,
-0.0123705082,
-0.0330228843,
0.0268283766,
0.0082870927,
-0.0282105263,
0.0207134187,
-0.0384154916,
0.0268300101,
0.0436614454,
-0.0652901307,
-0.0078477208,
0.0330043212,
2.905e-7,
0.0211915579,
0.018451374,
-0.051519312,
-0.0528714806,
0.0135915279,
-0.000329365,
-0.0161415488,
0.0143589238,
0.0300691687,
0.0349935926,
0.0029224127,
-0.0073638032,
0.0565653406,
-0.0200202931,
-0.0577798001,
0.0290428326,
-0.0698856041,
-0.0155432876,
-0.03924568,
-0.0552645884,
-0.0240159761,
0.1338837296,
-0.0027672565,
-0.0203437246,
-0.0043776198,
-0.0369005576,
0.0416736491,
-0.0403548852,
-0.0126509657,
0.0245921388,
0.0457408987,
0.0152329318,
-0.0382930264,
0.0097973142,
0.0085981963,
0.0649089962,
-0.0081187207,
0.036406137,
-0.0357866324,
-0.0437585525,
0.0231548771,
-0.0101188309,
-0.0103795864,
-0.0721261427,
0.0729459301,
-0.0327820554,
0.0133608095,
-0.0292934664,
0.0090259733,
0.0091293473,
-0.0012925123,
-0.0335660279,
-0.0050413478,
0.0330922753,
0.0284395572,
-0.0282570664,
-0.0146873025,
-0.0926847085,
-0.008280972,
0.0169327054,
-0.0407674052,
-0.065626353,
-0.0440306813,
-0.0564388819,
0.0859865621,
-0.0620225742,
-0.0251903553,
2.740591151e-34,
0.0030489534,
-0.0230774544,
0.0280649811,
0.0429185331,
0.0216311328,
-0.0110746706,
-0.0063254312,
0.0150884613,
-0.0104668979,
-0.1465839297,
-0.0352937877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14955v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14955v1 | ICLEval: Evaluating In-Context Learning Ability of Large Language Models | 2024-06-21T08:06:10 | 2024-06-21T08:06:10 | Wentong Chen, Yankai Lin, ZhenHao Zhou, HongYun Huang, Yantao Jia, Zhao Cao, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-Context Learning (ICL) is a critical capability of Large Language Models
(LLMs) as it empowers them to comprehend and reason across interconnected
inputs. Evaluating the ICL ability of LLMs can enhance their utilization and
deepen our understanding of how this ability is acquired at the training stage.
However, existing evaluation frameworks primarily focus on language abilities
and knowledge, often overlooking the assessment of ICL ability. In this work,
we introduce the ICLEval benchmark to evaluate the ICL abilities of LLMs, which
encompasses two key sub-abilities: exact copying and rule learning. Through the
ICLEval benchmark, we demonstrate that ICL ability is universally present in
different LLMs, and model size is not the sole determinant of ICL efficacy.
Surprisingly, we observe that ICL abilities, particularly copying, develop
early in the pretraining process and stabilize afterward. Our source codes and
benchmark are released at https://github.com/yiye3/ICLEval. | [
-0.015169411,
0.056019295,
-0.0037952715,
0.0859661177,
-0.0515092462,
0.055617854,
0.0138162207,
0.0148429759,
-0.036602743,
-0.0292773806,
-0.0654106066,
-0.0485165045,
-0.0294266045,
-0.0002435478,
0.0168404207,
-0.018646501,
0.0332525708,
-0.0442890525,
-0.0326063149,
0.0049810479,
-0.0133174909,
-0.0090589998,
0.0115831206,
0.0310860164,
-0.0043537323,
-0.0194980334,
0.0017627985,
0.0045660599,
0.0012539855,
-0.034005709,
0.0226295516,
0.0250147209,
0.0407484919,
0.0666579083,
0.0000022018,
-0.0575450324,
-0.0102574956,
-0.01031549,
-0.035726659,
0.0173758809,
0.0408763587,
-0.0178552624,
-0.0126230977,
-0.0089758458,
-0.0416416749,
0.0030882687,
0.0356924236,
0.0585879609,
0.0457649343,
0.1023958549,
-0.0049862619,
-0.0371116251,
0.024085097,
-0.0420163237,
-0.001928067,
-0.0779744536,
0.0300518274,
0.0497831441,
-0.0217909683,
-0.0239112545,
0.0017856671,
0.0473560393,
0.0463666394,
-0.0063267439,
-0.0151882069,
0.0368853919,
-0.007394854,
-0.0056795315,
0.0100544747,
0.0741006434,
-0.0453655757,
-0.0332046188,
-0.0287108589,
-0.0131972153,
0.0025615969,
-0.0153549109,
-0.0528879687,
0.0253226683,
0.0080979038,
0.0479588583,
0.0134179313,
0.0121561689,
0.0762314126,
-0.0105569782,
-0.0339190625,
0.0423679464,
0.0098868217,
-0.0347070731,
0.0254951753,
-0.010657195,
-0.0129279429,
-0.0545216464,
-0.0367064402,
0.0316177122,
-0.0559131168,
0.0172550194,
-0.0468126796,
0.0160845388,
0.0203038882,
-0.0296413358,
0.0520804971,
0.0355841257,
-0.0071133114,
0.0676846951,
-0.0513893887,
0.0453639664,
-0.0278495476,
0.0611246116,
-0.0530736968,
-0.0288238972,
-0.0526740216,
0.0159071013,
-0.019202169,
-0.0083092265,
-0.0088070771,
-0.0282173697,
-0.0193760619,
0.0280875396,
-0.0235421024,
0.0144944219,
-0.0161248818,
-0.0389366411,
-0.0017979834,
-0.0215298478,
0.0207624659,
0.0056881588,
-0.0131167322,
0.0226304401,
0.0242463611,
-0.0320227332,
-0.022261966,
0.000820549,
-0.0097363628,
-0.0081406711,
0.0235465914,
0.083499603,
-0.0163672417,
-0.0476706177,
-0.0286602043,
-0.0047673318,
0.0200107414,
-0.0990580469,
-0.0122418273,
-0.0677999482,
0.002654192,
0.0033473254,
0.0132721458,
-0.0605803505,
0.0060014054,
0.0125134736,
0.0048064301,
0.0556127317,
0.0105229625,
0.0167996697,
-0.0358524993,
0.0051183617,
-0.0295090713,
0.060117729,
-0.0034153461,
-0.0017538257,
0.0287479647,
-0.0051610409,
0.0007591912,
0.040588595,
0.0403822549,
0.0510561913,
-0.0505400486,
-0.000973511,
0.0364790633,
0.0339074135,
0.0540788844,
0.0379494354,
-0.0330043882,
0.0036557468,
0.0868056417,
0.0401044078,
0.0336261988,
0.0182999205,
0.0666797608,
-0.0040741065,
0.0177899022,
-0.0206865035,
-0.0854057148,
0.0108391326,
-0.0058452915,
0.0140209924,
-0.0057748808,
0.0047190157,
-0.0103263119,
-0.0170020778,
-0.0286654457,
-0.0056605181,
-0.0493954979,
0.0022417374,
0.0362731554,
0.031600792,
-0.0239521749,
0.03152683,
0.0388209559,
-0.0310395677,
-0.0276102256,
-0.0475845672,
0.0471444316,
0.031157393,
0.0185467992,
-0.0246792231,
-0.0232563205,
-0.0012476967,
0.0438056625,
0.0201812834,
0.0231530201,
-0.017591767,
0.0444553979,
-0.0413849913,
-0.0224259011,
-0.0435990691,
0.029052021,
0.0058471491,
0.0285776462,
0.0074319136,
-0.002246283,
-0.0508252792,
-0.0367782153,
0.0557295457,
-0.0521475188,
-0.026476888,
-0.02249608,
0.0012237261,
0.0430439152,
-0.0289741307,
-0.0386440195,
0.0055296607,
0.0246178526,
-0.0459328704,
-0.0294461567,
0.022167189,
-0.0941520184,
-0.0354634114,
0.040935453,
-0.02495021,
-0.0415878259,
-0.0184179097,
-0.050936196,
0.0055371574,
-0.0156699363,
-0.0025244718,
0.0629106835,
-0.035732884,
0.0269148387,
-0.0116613638,
0.0177903399,
-0.0288127568,
0.0840301588,
-0.0210218914,
-0.0110912193,
0.0731188655,
0.0196015779,
0.0095038349,
0.0057740672,
0.0121195996,
0.0022085006,
-0.0243997946,
-0.0048398962,
-0.0439317785,
0.0355684757,
-0.0520725586,
-0.0252134576,
-0.0600760318,
0.0098320106,
-0.0407948568,
-0.0012830284,
0.0347706899,
-0.0111103831,
-0.0144585464,
-0.018999109,
-0.0143803535,
-0.004533899,
0.0037845362,
0.010939219,
0.0131661417,
0.0057066004,
-0.0293853283,
-0.0409243219,
0.0004930528,
-0.0022260847,
0.071138747,
-0.0279000998,
0.0006884196,
-0.0530350134,
0.0475251935,
0.0173153244,
0.0090637272,
-0.0303215012,
-0.0102325706,
0.0111274775,
-0.035878066,
0.0075720879,
0.0723433048,
-0.0118691428,
0.0009481533,
0.0590142198,
-0.0112896152,
-0.0561518408,
0.0127011286,
-0.0073907454,
-0.0294976737,
-0.0799062401,
0.0042288597,
0.0097822873,
0.0552379154,
-0.0375264287,
0.0002003021,
-0.020480141,
0.0328680053,
-0.0126444045,
-0.0307303742,
-0.0723981708,
0.0000609261,
-0.0293236673,
0.0485801287,
-0.0306580011,
-0.0830242634,
0.0295886733,
-0.0381115302,
-0.0134246685,
-0.037827123,
-0.029905811,
-0.0572249666,
0.0841193423,
-0.0092835268,
0.029047709,
-0.0238409676,
-0.0030821925,
-0.0480260663,
0.00690703,
0.0243640635,
0.0097995214,
0.0608642921,
-0.0499848016,
0.0176838227,
0.0061469157,
-0.0430844501,
-0.0498838536,
-0.0247616898,
-0.0281773657,
0.024816798,
-0.0223230869,
-0.0210663881,
0.0064484398,
-0.0234786235,
0.0420345925,
0.0321897119,
0.0180840679,
-0.0212939736,
-0.013765879,
0.0174380131,
0.0158341639,
0.0183391813,
0.0249641202,
-0.047268562,
0.0352264829,
0.0503821522,
0.0496366881,
0.0094927261,
-0.0325177088,
0.0397038385,
0.0278473888,
-0.0100753112,
-0.0064700069,
0.0288316458,
0.062314041,
-0.0704441592,
-0.0106934011,
0.095563516,
-0.0019212882,
-0.0798134208,
0.0260136463,
-0.0292396676,
0.0216628443,
0.0439164937,
0.0030553294,
-0.0631107688,
-0.0515108816,
0.0370395966,
-0.0004013152,
0.019030571,
-0.0224417355,
-0.0132590728,
-0.1078116968,
0.0168412905,
0.0059186914,
-0.095011875,
-0.0661807284,
-0.0370178111,
0.0035964085,
0.002629431,
0.0326692834,
0.0205330662,
-0.0333837233,
-0.0265091676,
0.0009321621,
-0.0267571229,
-0.0681916475,
0.0706785023,
-0.0493775606,
0.0538290851,
0.0592323504,
0.0289372839,
0.0218716916,
-0.0410209782,
0.0789203942,
-0.0284091216,
-0.0048053144,
-0.0106029063,
0.0463125333,
0.0004988032,
-0.0108308904,
0.0222967956,
0.0515999496,
-0.0173410345,
-0.0168855302,
0.0119905099,
0.0572299771,
0.0054608611,
-0.0324702673,
0.0101320427,
-0.0239711422,
0.0233592838,
0.0793082267,
0.0575460233,
-0.0065135453,
-0.0303303655,
-0.0086428374,
-0.0326597765,
-0.0413962975,
-0.0261084605,
0.0405047946,
-0.0104789771,
-0.020361485,
-0.0529065207,
-0.0128875813,
-0.0087844655,
0.0333084948,
0.0106100766,
0.0074763517,
-0.0105642155,
-0.0091960886,
-0.0147797596,
0.0443085358,
-0.056606479,
0.0339658074,
-0.0582211539,
-0.0076558189,
0.0196259059,
-0.0023694367,
-0.0319939442,
0.0142092519,
-0.0669951215,
-0.0473820344,
0.0104840361,
0.045032151,
0.0179969687,
0.0787409917,
-0.0161542837,
-0.0246677548,
0.0637979805,
-0.0182651524,
0.0182296131,
0.0184928123,
0.0550660081,
-0.0281694867,
0.0256026201,
0.0691106766,
-0.0352073796,
0.0132438624,
0.0424457975,
0.0143238027,
-0.0211927723,
0.009926809,
0.0269252639,
-0.0138146114,
-0.0038806663,
-0.0024872441,
-0.0363143533,
-0.023244625,
0.0411186218,
-0.0072541521,
-0.0012252408,
-0.0510039255,
-0.0158280581,
0.0457523167,
0.0216780957,
0.0159418937,
-0.0061151143,
0.0383143909,
0.0094707943,
0.0144640515,
0.0125454636,
0.008717062,
0.0334094875,
0.0540264063,
0.0069960342,
-0.0239073541,
0.0247126613,
-0.0245932844,
0.037392471,
-0.0253671091,
0.059611395,
0.0357656032,
-0.0101918299,
-0.0385643467,
0.0353167541,
-0.0812404528,
-0.0275267847,
-0.0099529522,
0.0066748192,
0.0999796689,
-0.0329206511,
0.0673390999,
-0.0367828012,
-0.0016451037,
-0.0147127789,
0.0243777763,
-0.0232502818,
-0.0300563592,
0.0172753502,
0.0063281702,
-0.0047416384,
0.0402564146,
0.0728991851,
-0.0055328743,
0.0772490278,
-0.022034511,
0.0232127253,
-0.0299372785,
-0.0029834707,
0.0475312695,
0.0192263965,
-0.0112693636,
0.0028050833,
-0.045068901,
-0.0675796121,
-0.0150417667,
0.0269768462,
-0.0398117453,
-0.0071155294,
0.02195579,
0.0767505988,
-0.0018221795,
-0.0131811164,
-0.0131057156,
-0.0222615972,
0.0234084744,
-0.0036430242,
-0.0187177453,
-6.596173408e-33,
-0.0083984155,
0.0096690478,
0.0325521082,
0.0184356961,
-0.0351585113,
0.0202486105,
-0.0610052086,
0.0032175768,
-0.009965119,
0.0193625428,
-0.0080386866,
-0.0003980236,
0.0039388034,
0.0170745514,
0.0025207547,
-0.0298549403,
0.0382667594,
0.0051909368,
-0.0195683986,
0.0337958634,
0.0230106041,
0.0241975281,
0.0697603598,
-0.0704160109,
-0.0108233234,
0.007360776,
0.0046722647,
0.0414201915,
-0.0587115623,
0.0353562199,
-0.0219319128,
0.0079276534,
0.029394716,
-0.0373909958,
-0.0358235687,
-0.020150343,
-0.0606062002,
-0.0134165958,
0.018441515,
-0.0085640727,
-0.0211422723,
-0.0336455964,
0.0613835454,
0.0102237118,
0.001165772,
-0.0298608709,
0.008220098,
-0.022264149,
-0.0189094264,
-0.0150041198,
-0.0991384387,
0.031824328,
0.0009276196,
-0.0119009782,
-0.0009040516,
-0.0031274455,
0.004327809,
0.014565384,
-0.067083545,
0.0021946775,
-0.0424172021,
0.0362811834,
0.0624841563,
0.0049222694,
-0.0016537181,
0.0753360987,
0.0364203751,
-0.0184494313,
0.0062218271,
-0.0429859757,
0.0554361083,
0.0732086599,
0.0252562817,
0.0678174645,
0.029082546,
0.02897227,
-0.0700528771,
0.0095183952,
0.0225190222,
0.0594140142,
0.0100424169,
0.0239130426,
-0.0130056031,
0.0099756718,
-0.0509495288,
-0.0098261368,
-0.0164026674,
-0.0063770767,
0.0579793528,
0.0142251858,
0.0118743237,
-0.0229895059,
0.0402541012,
-0.0340286084,
-0.0229924545,
0.0317287892,
-0.0125505272,
0.011506875,
-0.0017411552,
0.024584204,
-0.0819578245,
-0.0379673764,
-0.0123867197,
-0.0026229466,
0.0386585332,
-0.0216968842,
0.0905128121,
0.0272231624,
-0.0563291945,
-0.0067170272,
-0.050350219,
0.0126309171,
0.0046110321,
0.0369928256,
0.0481766425,
0.0054278621,
-0.0182316545,
-0.0047685457,
0.0089563271,
-0.0197528452,
-0.0093822898,
-0.0253873784,
0.0040507033,
0.0066591441,
-0.0305431876,
-0.0228339154,
-0.0782044902,
0.0247552767,
0.0437709391,
-0.0419515185,
-0.0127088539,
0.0072277063,
2.829e-7,
0.0432461761,
0.0263159554,
0.0048129014,
0.0029312961,
0.042623464,
0.0487090461,
-0.0823290497,
-0.0116474088,
0.0228723139,
0.0274941977,
0.0087468782,
0.0558949411,
0.0736497343,
0.0160728619,
-0.0843841806,
-0.0150572201,
-0.0617911443,
-0.0240536109,
-0.0266804639,
0.0006009105,
0.0017794363,
0.1010904461,
0.0181033928,
-0.0412121676,
0.0335482843,
-0.0691625327,
0.0506174304,
-0.0542943031,
0.0207601748,
0.0141140986,
0.0037025746,
0.0203495286,
0.0197263509,
0.0068094498,
0.0025222136,
0.0256945435,
-0.0334898941,
0.0576651134,
0.0092608277,
-0.0110788858,
-0.0203161091,
0.0041505671,
0.0021300693,
-0.0953993052,
0.0766196251,
-0.0715661347,
-0.0104904072,
-0.0627500862,
-0.0111992387,
-0.0277446304,
0.0044536772,
0.0062784059,
-0.0229846165,
0.0348184481,
0.0192951486,
-0.0055466271,
-0.0399966463,
-0.0640308112,
-0.0331377685,
0.0001150789,
-0.0272797905,
-0.0622927025,
-0.0642270446,
0.0037085277,
0.0370311253,
-0.0401827879,
0.010971738,
2.705656929e-34,
0.0197594315,
-0.0247981548,
0.0426465981,
0.0440895818,
0.016618073,
-0.0049361857,
-0.000001187,
0.0042471024,
-0.0302305073,
-0.0509389862,
0.0205910597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14952v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14952v2 | ESC-Eval: Evaluating Emotion Support Conversations in Large Language Models | 2024-06-21T08:03:33 | 2024-06-24T12:24:52 | Haiquan Zhao, Lingyu Li, Shisong Chen, Shuqi Kong, Jiaan Wang, Kexin Huang, Tianle Gu, Yixu Wang, Dandan Liang, Zhixu Li, Yan Teng, Yanghua Xiao, Yingchun Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotion Support Conversation (ESC) is a crucial application, which aims to
reduce human stress, offer emotional guidance, and ultimately enhance human
mental and physical well-being. With the advancement of Large Language Models
(LLMs), many researchers have employed LLMs as the ESC models. However, the
evaluation of these LLM-based ESCs remains uncertain. Inspired by the awesome
development of role-playing agents, we propose an ESC Evaluation framework
(ESC-Eval), which uses a role-playing agent to interact with ESC models,
followed by a manual evaluation of the interactive dialogues. In detail, we
first re-organize 2,801 role-playing cards from seven existing datasets to
define the roles of the role-playing agent. Second, we train a specific
role-playing model called ESC-Role which behaves more like a confused person
than GPT-4. Third, through ESC-Role and organized role cards, we systematically
conduct experiments using 14 LLMs as the ESC models, including general
AI-assistant LLMs (ChatGPT) and ESC-oriented LLMs (ExTES-Llama). We conduct
comprehensive human annotations on interactive multi-turn dialogues of
different ESC models. The results show that ESC-oriented LLMs exhibit superior
ESC abilities compared to general AI-assistant LLMs, but there is still a gap
behind human performance. Moreover, to automate the scoring process for future
ESC models, we developed ESC-RANK, which trained on the annotated data,
achieving a scoring performance surpassing 35 points of GPT-4. Our data and
code are available at https://github.com/haidequanbu/ESC-Eval. | [
0.0699272677,
-0.0201291144,
-0.0415137671,
0.0501408428,
-0.0029937937,
0.0307964981,
-0.0122792488,
-0.0251933932,
0.0470752344,
-0.0244602431,
-0.0360226743,
-0.0255313907,
-0.0181762986,
0.024415832,
0.0021003529,
-0.0991373733,
0.0208777487,
0.013139355,
0.0994077399,
0.022700524,
-0.0014396991,
0.0116388053,
-0.0350666977,
0.0477031916,
-0.0295236837,
-0.0036564395,
-0.0240527578,
0.0203272849,
0.0741730481,
-0.053118404,
0.0372598544,
0.0188705027,
0.0186073743,
-0.0208040979,
0.0000021972,
-0.0331671759,
0.0235448498,
-0.0220276322,
-0.0113976384,
-0.0101985047,
0.0524635315,
0.0097801499,
-0.0206316728,
0.0110232327,
-0.0400976241,
-0.0265922677,
0.0264451578,
0.0621719882,
0.1087518185,
0.0881583467,
-0.0202959403,
-0.0097447149,
-0.0162737351,
-0.0173680671,
0.0152326999,
-0.0374760851,
0.0091293193,
0.0258415584,
0.0404697284,
-0.0308981147,
0.0106629627,
0.0152692143,
0.0124119995,
-0.0355268717,
-0.0053367838,
0.028287312,
-0.0254600309,
-0.01428222,
0.004892136,
0.0841133818,
-0.0034375023,
0.0312821195,
-0.0066836402,
-0.0034041938,
0.0534986965,
0.021029966,
-0.0257733036,
0.0002335039,
0.0380935371,
-0.0212909356,
0.0213793479,
0.0499853939,
-0.0174107142,
0.0121728424,
0.0365599059,
0.0264988355,
-0.0298639014,
-0.0505789556,
0.0252026785,
0.0003864336,
-0.0418773331,
-0.0475555584,
-0.0220054835,
0.0329987556,
-0.0578227937,
0.0306075104,
-0.0171641205,
0.0250216909,
-0.0099521596,
-0.059413597,
0.0142648797,
0.0407985523,
-0.0120429192,
0.0352585614,
0.0202594511,
0.0619117692,
0.0402895175,
0.0027922534,
-0.0255313534,
0.0171103254,
-0.0483309887,
-0.013980601,
-0.0457276627,
0.0277669281,
-0.0522148795,
-0.0371754505,
-0.060113214,
0.0116135031,
-0.0415990874,
0.0418509319,
0.037831042,
0.004382493,
0.025105238,
0.0205347072,
-0.0230793227,
0.0167045631,
-0.0439092629,
0.0131374653,
0.0182751268,
-0.081506744,
0.0070961122,
0.0176383834,
-0.0246644337,
-0.0162402149,
0.0184211023,
0.0349503681,
0.0099924495,
-0.0523420833,
-0.0037962894,
0.0005306006,
-0.0268735643,
-0.1061905175,
-0.0173601843,
-0.0122357262,
0.0439904109,
-0.0205148794,
0.0337636694,
0.0128230797,
0.0325219408,
-0.0117591284,
0.0023436598,
0.0710279942,
0.0141396737,
0.0083727399,
0.0387579016,
0.0451960303,
-0.0092019169,
0.0510733351,
0.034959957,
-0.0018096499,
0.0238134041,
-0.0325048268,
0.0402478799,
0.0354734994,
-0.0422839485,
-0.0419598147,
0.0396757387,
-0.0003393941,
-0.0258127749,
0.0655409023,
0.0049068863,
0.0327485465,
-0.0525504239,
-0.0271852408,
0.0648518354,
0.0452893078,
-0.0482533872,
0.0396064408,
0.0182985291,
0.0400522575,
0.0564670712,
0.0062214676,
-0.0592643805,
0.0475636348,
-0.0162995216,
-0.0387751684,
-0.0267232768,
-0.0448810942,
-0.0424426869,
-0.0612961389,
-0.0098532569,
-0.0399246216,
0.0135838045,
0.0075630434,
-0.0077885939,
-0.0289997812,
-0.0324978046,
0.0244159363,
0.0160328913,
-0.0781527981,
-0.038220875,
-0.0555173345,
0.0096517988,
0.1082862169,
0.0344892591,
-0.0537943803,
-0.0586036034,
-0.0106035396,
-0.0418090709,
0.0398872048,
0.0453164205,
-0.0217938535,
0.0149409827,
-0.0374938101,
0.0217754357,
-0.019479109,
0.0000396538,
0.0201163404,
-0.0264150202,
0.0000758909,
-0.0195889287,
-0.0007118224,
-0.0161216557,
0.0086166672,
-0.0053945361,
-0.0334910601,
-0.0238424856,
0.0135795474,
0.0564546362,
0.0252492931,
-0.0320569165,
-0.0305402335,
0.0302852839,
-0.0113207204,
-0.0186010841,
0.0451612733,
-0.05464077,
-0.0381068997,
0.0376878195,
-0.0166754872,
-0.0407728404,
0.0768143386,
-0.0286289956,
-0.0330836475,
-0.0089386683,
-0.0564046316,
0.0270580556,
-0.0213405937,
0.0527980588,
-0.0096511822,
0.0319300555,
0.011985857,
0.0441702306,
0.0006460638,
0.0074116951,
0.0046877423,
0.0172875319,
-0.0063909399,
-0.0735882148,
-0.024085043,
0.0142407082,
0.0110107074,
-0.0159008447,
-0.0003080151,
0.0158383306,
-0.0626028478,
-0.0579016432,
-0.1253186464,
-0.0026604424,
0.0003028401,
-0.0211326852,
0.0146911638,
-0.031170262,
-0.0382702686,
0.0046708365,
-0.0490674451,
-0.0026990811,
0.0402949601,
-0.0054561328,
0.0058132778,
0.0021315448,
-0.0245848484,
-0.0609037429,
0.0324803516,
-0.0153457113,
0.013693993,
-0.0056384299,
-0.0090000127,
-0.0277677085,
0.0202651005,
-0.0250500757,
0.0213963203,
-0.0304097496,
-0.077270098,
0.0098850476,
0.0137312114,
-0.0010262607,
0.069462277,
0.0221695323,
0.0701093823,
-0.0011117939,
-0.0116430447,
-0.0557077415,
0.040230643,
0.0320276245,
0.0177020784,
-0.0698675513,
-0.0147642251,
-0.00392333,
0.0636280254,
0.0005457674,
0.0556226708,
-0.0727841556,
-0.020838147,
0.0173614006,
-0.0589567535,
0.0011793246,
-0.0307386816,
-0.0404806733,
-0.0208416991,
0.0023209513,
-0.0109815784,
0.0487475209,
-0.0179443397,
-0.0618972071,
-0.0511464067,
-0.0144000957,
-0.0255176779,
0.0677860901,
-0.0231832508,
0.0055838954,
-0.0203560311,
0.0006998113,
-0.0203464553,
-0.0504238643,
0.0013210702,
-0.0621575229,
-0.0082876645,
-0.063515529,
-0.0114117265,
0.0148518942,
-0.0249721538,
-0.0224181656,
-0.0230837185,
-0.054739818,
0.0151199,
0.0406617261,
-0.022335263,
-0.0416938178,
-0.0045057014,
0.0411629863,
-0.0018628245,
-0.0057246247,
-0.0148550831,
0.0003627915,
0.004982674,
0.0781424716,
0.0330696218,
0.0076923957,
-0.0030485513,
0.107911393,
0.0536426008,
-0.0178815927,
-0.0000191239,
-0.0076946523,
0.0156549532,
0.0144477487,
-0.0133602694,
-0.0070368908,
0.0005650822,
0.0256674103,
-0.0360823646,
0.0136791449,
0.1581332386,
0.0337330177,
-0.0454923473,
0.0038765883,
-0.0481089391,
-0.0015770873,
0.0098265382,
0.0105475979,
-0.0549426638,
0.0057536433,
-0.0041234368,
0.0225205868,
-0.0307291057,
-0.0397626944,
0.0207558647,
-0.126179412,
0.0729969367,
-0.0199262649,
-0.032564979,
0.0035335899,
-0.0050004977,
0.0343183503,
-0.0298436936,
0.0091823395,
-0.0385251716,
0.0241798647,
-0.0379585288,
0.0065364065,
-0.0296982694,
-0.0135797076,
0.0645417348,
-0.0245367065,
0.1024640054,
0.0483672172,
0.1113781855,
0.0262421053,
-0.0191866979,
0.0023877458,
0.0440153591,
-0.0038434088,
-0.0084960992,
0.0617238991,
-0.03518508,
-0.0115190577,
0.0057799052,
0.046541255,
0.0030674099,
0.0117188077,
0.0130097251,
0.0638100803,
-0.0281632282,
-0.0130516151,
0.0079656569,
0.0249717478,
0.0474178083,
0.073899053,
0.0094214221,
-0.0533938929,
-0.0059966445,
0.0013141352,
0.0333741195,
-0.0001136848,
-0.0721990988,
-0.0037408967,
0.0194889829,
0.0153504591,
-0.0501885265,
-0.0893848762,
0.0308294203,
-0.0034542533,
-0.0405744687,
-0.0060452744,
-0.0020999378,
0.0255285408,
0.0186034571,
-0.0031124824,
-0.0268148351,
0.0408569314,
-0.0178726651,
-0.0271393266,
0.0292411093,
-0.039562352,
0.0034331796,
0.0024799523,
0.0213920884,
-0.0454559252,
0.0339664444,
0.0799192488,
0.0202893708,
0.008925071,
0.0036533263,
-0.0710848346,
0.0072132736,
0.0024474717,
-0.0675049424,
0.0100389617,
0.0113522857,
0.0587617233,
-0.0127396183,
0.0301653389,
-0.0206397232,
0.0496712513,
-0.0197704975,
0.0322028399,
-0.0321227573,
-0.0922238156,
0.0027986325,
0.0217969641,
0.0375058055,
-0.0018835606,
-0.0209655464,
0.0013769639,
0.017775856,
-0.0665851533,
0.0042783176,
-0.0472319163,
-0.0142945796,
0.0023304133,
0.0041642678,
-0.0019565839,
-0.0354542919,
-0.0392039679,
-0.0316449665,
-0.0062187831,
0.0151754702,
0.0206167847,
-0.021332439,
-0.0192788932,
0.022002086,
0.0043799155,
-0.0012525637,
0.0072131851,
0.0236311592,
0.0226411112,
0.0827656761,
0.0120902685,
-0.0420238338,
0.0406182148,
0.0634814501,
-0.0228385311,
-0.0293185282,
-0.0016592162,
0.030945573,
0.0475621894,
0.0018003414,
0.057125587,
-0.0493563898,
0.0271443985,
-0.0016085769,
-0.0077847969,
0.0071025235,
-0.0368276909,
0.0346961804,
0.0194428824,
-0.029220216,
0.0043991306,
0.0173661988,
-0.0121294614,
0.041707769,
-0.0175805148,
-0.0219527371,
-0.0611663572,
-0.0195982419,
0.00999997,
-0.0354644768,
-0.0350952223,
0.0170795582,
-0.0750592053,
-0.0439142585,
-0.0045908075,
0.0054820357,
-0.0150186671,
-0.0475589149,
0.0266910512,
0.0223215278,
-0.0120453024,
-0.0017548918,
-0.0446767174,
-0.0070514102,
-0.0510931537,
-0.0095095802,
-0.0340611823,
-6.103964904e-33,
-0.0194839407,
-0.010033736,
0.0030106197,
0.0321965367,
-0.0278909765,
0.014422968,
-0.0383302346,
0.0398408212,
-0.0084991036,
0.0467594899,
-0.0078361575,
0.0409778208,
0.0126126967,
-0.0058205994,
-0.0033200392,
-0.0276455078,
0.0214802027,
-0.0103899529,
-0.021411974,
0.0211199727,
0.0127176102,
-0.002177858,
0.0335160084,
-0.1515243053,
0.0357269607,
-0.0035473446,
-0.0143381357,
0.016639173,
0.0100444993,
0.0450808257,
-0.0052894917,
0.0212826114,
0.0183744617,
-0.0312397033,
0.0262967292,
0.0446931981,
-0.0230312794,
-0.0214938745,
0.040462561,
0.0052759699,
-0.058542937,
-0.0241035428,
-0.0338738896,
0.025671564,
-0.0108055957,
-0.0091844238,
0.0114519764,
-0.0181464646,
0.0213149693,
-0.0111944079,
-0.0481496044,
0.0072968346,
-0.0366517901,
-0.0508270934,
-0.0110212192,
0.0667175725,
-0.0101585472,
-0.0132919447,
-0.0263814516,
0.0052217911,
-0.0276184119,
-0.0142161753,
0.0176350996,
-0.0106555326,
-0.0119623849,
0.0583633445,
-0.0053331666,
0.0343763903,
-0.0449152514,
-0.007333213,
-0.012838752,
0.0776130334,
0.0561547466,
0.0353730321,
-0.047875654,
-0.0010642554,
-0.0089800842,
0.0423597842,
0.0497682914,
0.0560542978,
0.0255384408,
0.0089869034,
-0.0440750457,
0.0242214538,
-0.0232398771,
0.0219995342,
-0.0069398796,
-0.0503310226,
0.0356555022,
-0.0034445033,
-0.0068878112,
-0.0331508853,
0.0048494004,
-0.0380735956,
0.0252709184,
0.0196514335,
-0.013335729,
0.0506956428,
-0.0102556841,
-0.0132329091,
-0.0259955507,
-0.0174915809,
0.0488900729,
0.0064277942,
0.0538640209,
-0.0120743373,
0.0047375178,
0.0371895172,
-0.0190911442,
0.001708169,
-0.0077163903,
0.0656565502,
-0.0309361722,
0.017605545,
-0.0307897646,
-0.0081075178,
-0.0304753315,
-0.002087035,
-0.0123247011,
0.0258113537,
-0.0242920667,
-0.0197071154,
-0.0011075531,
-0.0047886018,
-0.0413821526,
0.0085723512,
-0.040606685,
-0.0127970101,
0.0140659641,
-0.0042284536,
0.0138229011,
-0.0095642591,
2.994e-7,
-0.0282417741,
0.0366178975,
-0.0016008937,
0.0205013007,
0.0131100481,
0.0367957056,
-0.0131880995,
0.0242556836,
0.0501541831,
-0.0348730944,
0.0540192798,
0.040175695,
0.0818434879,
0.0161209721,
-0.0656474978,
-0.0508014634,
-0.0465796925,
-0.0295686461,
-0.0043060235,
0.0294977445,
0.0950716585,
0.071424827,
0.0368498228,
0.0051138569,
-0.0118114278,
0.0090960898,
0.0295232888,
-0.0616947562,
-0.0277923439,
0.0246283934,
0.0311868191,
0.0008427774,
-0.0182214119,
0.0117398156,
0.0166042075,
0.0449128002,
-0.0052339355,
0.0862834677,
-0.0132585615,
-0.0134501439,
0.0211141389,
0.0321334228,
-0.0182401352,
-0.0495747142,
0.0475269072,
-0.0787923187,
-0.0301744863,
-0.0038317426,
-0.0470409319,
-0.0110960938,
0.0326349735,
-0.0169858765,
-0.0402259268,
0.0341358818,
-0.001720257,
-0.0404597111,
0.0015226018,
-0.0559891202,
-0.0146421185,
-0.0069527458,
-0.0397880934,
-0.0369611755,
-0.0178919584,
-0.0072051226,
-0.0167857241,
-0.0345983543,
0.010930541,
2.07194471e-34,
0.0002165778,
0.0031981859,
0.0098533249,
0.0446590409,
0.0604443736,
0.0266617239,
-0.0277037565,
0.0278512407,
0.0228675622,
-0.0649330914,
0.0157393683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14938v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14938v1 | Towards Retrieval Augmented Generation over Large Video Libraries | 2024-06-21T07:52:01 | 2024-06-21T07:52:01 | Yannis Tevissen, Khalil Guetari, Frédéric Petitpont | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Video content creators need efficient tools to repurpose content, a task that
often requires complex manual or automated searches. Crafting a new video from
large video libraries remains a challenge. In this paper we introduce the task
of Video Library Question Answering (VLQA) through an interoperable
architecture that applies Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) to video
libraries. We propose a system that uses large language models (LLMs) to
generate search queries, retrieving relevant video moments indexed by speech
and visual metadata. An answer generation module then integrates user queries
with this metadata to produce responses with specific video timestamps. This
approach shows promise in multimedia content retrieval, and AI-assisted video
content creation. | [
0.0391681641,
0.0366512053,
0.0025016747,
0.0326506607,
-0.0187594034,
-0.0223658662,
-0.0029669779,
0.0038099755,
-0.0228575747,
-0.0636583492,
0.0152802952,
-0.0346935354,
-0.0609927103,
0.0255316962,
0.0019509257,
-0.0587131605,
0.0329749286,
-0.0158120412,
0.0031999985,
0.0041576643,
0.013637362,
0.0210285559,
0.0102984468,
-0.0036155405,
-0.0566337332,
0.0030231404,
-0.0237976927,
-0.0029524181,
0.012482957,
-0.0176241696,
-0.0192483161,
0.0103545589,
0.0751021504,
0.0311135147,
0.0000015943,
-0.0558650717,
-0.0064447094,
-0.0057071815,
-0.0246476475,
0.0122714797,
0.0243714582,
0.0408323072,
0.0207792949,
0.0307237133,
-0.063162148,
0.009173682,
0.0495029576,
-0.0343392156,
0.0551443845,
0.0202699024,
-0.0368437655,
-0.0486510471,
0.0087677194,
0.0202941913,
0.0764089972,
-0.0215172172,
-0.0147810793,
0.0425000265,
0.1051648706,
0.0110789947,
-0.0021967369,
0.0759230331,
0.0148215909,
-0.0471317507,
0.0165543035,
0.0166000184,
-0.0631179586,
-0.0116444416,
-0.0104728136,
0.0430297144,
0.0539628491,
0.0166180003,
0.0104447082,
0.0246679392,
0.0145911761,
0.0328340717,
-0.0751422718,
0.0295027718,
0.0036323951,
-0.0178904906,
-0.0327653177,
-0.0095847044,
0.0159257315,
0.0027881067,
0.0234036501,
0.0465877056,
0.0753734559,
0.011068373,
-0.0787112266,
-0.0469431579,
-0.0000529729,
-0.0388268754,
0.0120754959,
0.0834366977,
-0.0003781023,
0.0053817425,
-0.0204140618,
-0.0179190598,
-0.0035637617,
-0.0353701375,
0.0205138978,
0.0154809952,
-0.048280172,
0.0649230927,
-0.0275048222,
0.0509530008,
-0.0349901021,
-0.0477133505,
-0.0539445952,
-0.050288301,
-0.0516569912,
-0.0381492674,
-0.0304404628,
0.0338748991,
-0.0585025772,
-0.0152896866,
0.0009459955,
0.0543418452,
-0.0212228186,
0.0014788415,
-0.050394848,
0.0470593162,
0.0100114793,
-0.0440414213,
-0.0555937067,
0.0258072261,
-0.0339935645,
0.0179673824,
0.0109804673,
-0.0718508884,
0.0135445399,
0.0112814819,
0.0187049322,
-0.0195816401,
0.0407925993,
0.0431496389,
-0.0501011647,
0.0043689758,
-0.0304460712,
-0.0340103507,
-0.0000995146,
0.004701654,
0.008899481,
-0.0957159325,
0.0508484915,
0.0026698411,
-0.0647995621,
0.0096323164,
0.0051651173,
0.0099524502,
-0.0287233759,
0.0363340229,
-0.0000952561,
0.0580932461,
0.0890497267,
0.0178564638,
0.0453217775,
0.0227511525,
0.0080771884,
0.0326705389,
0.0724067688,
0.0334752724,
0.0723464713,
0.0496566519,
-0.0217984002,
0.0191054717,
-0.0643486902,
0.0550713241,
0.0123911304,
0.0338315293,
0.0026177922,
0.0692685172,
-0.010777371,
-0.0447053276,
0.0324054025,
0.043431472,
-0.0238580238,
-0.0307025146,
0.0767048299,
0.0270389952,
0.0081920018,
-0.0050863628,
0.0213794429,
0.1059753075,
-0.003861164,
-0.001802051,
0.0348253287,
0.0354725085,
-0.0777185038,
-0.0054062535,
-0.0071517895,
-0.0157198887,
-0.0075430907,
0.0489103347,
0.0216368027,
0.0030929332,
-0.0389727987,
0.0331355967,
-0.0295416247,
-0.0453913137,
0.0730605498,
-0.055649735,
0.0589793883,
0.0899607092,
0.0493591987,
-0.0136036165,
0.0030929206,
0.0219929796,
0.0295337886,
0.0202203486,
0.0130293919,
-0.0415451787,
-0.0245196298,
-0.0478846058,
-0.0040235729,
-0.0069394242,
0.0020668062,
0.0289331246,
-0.0001437751,
0.0109735234,
0.0318815932,
-0.0369942561,
-0.0325650759,
0.0230627358,
0.0116988318,
-0.0267476644,
0.0095962323,
0.0180507656,
-0.000221903,
0.0407768153,
-0.0396025926,
0.0097753089,
0.0290964246,
-0.015980443,
-0.0268114619,
0.0211975761,
0.0006449899,
0.0208470095,
0.0509385578,
-0.0630606264,
0.0254552253,
0.0187973753,
-0.0159355756,
-0.0665001124,
0.0247508045,
-0.01978237,
0.0197117645,
-0.0851555541,
0.0035091152,
0.0355598629,
0.0032929869,
-0.0525518693,
0.027442487,
0.0404154733,
0.0051927124,
0.0242585409,
0.0227215085,
0.0410129912,
-0.0627666637,
-0.0229280517,
0.0256202687,
-0.0212528296,
0.0260332543,
0.0483580008,
-0.0145181222,
-0.0452018715,
-0.0249645282,
-0.095983386,
0.0159826837,
0.0057472223,
0.0031828312,
0.0023801774,
0.0506954454,
-0.018163478,
-0.0323081762,
-0.0422933474,
-0.0130933011,
0.0495128669,
0.0245017372,
0.0057050497,
0.059374325,
-0.0181944594,
-0.0217585694,
-0.0252246894,
0.0158944502,
0.0423566587,
0.0006164478,
-0.0028390007,
0.004815571,
-0.0575393699,
-0.049837295,
0.0402736142,
-0.0004028086,
-0.0177433454,
-0.003929493,
-0.0424228236,
0.0088681858,
0.0399686769,
0.0403859876,
-0.0153501937,
0.0037859706,
-0.0194566436,
-0.0554984994,
0.0284732617,
-0.0047842595,
-0.0730332807,
0.0095134238,
-0.0152826598,
0.00404137,
-0.0377311595,
-0.0068762107,
0.0198090002,
-0.0356353037,
0.018365046,
0.0411062725,
0.0071879309,
-0.0417800955,
-0.0212048441,
-0.0159444604,
0.0522127859,
0.0006677825,
-0.0464915,
0.0396132506,
-0.0231764652,
-0.0261175521,
0.0045728725,
-0.0127977608,
-0.0401281752,
0.0906609148,
0.0134671293,
0.0402569212,
-0.0564360954,
-0.0182914771,
-0.0848897323,
-0.0019021076,
0.0264675561,
-0.0533354655,
0.0185753517,
-0.0412355512,
0.0260945223,
-0.0172786918,
-0.0131680369,
-0.043091584,
-0.0063294847,
-0.0207874384,
-0.0161436927,
-0.0444300137,
-0.019291034,
-0.0260597039,
0.0094926618,
0.0379467942,
-0.0027339046,
-0.0247365907,
0.0150396591,
0.0014653894,
0.0723994002,
0.0970264301,
0.0309154857,
-0.0424415022,
0.0045120455,
0.0459938459,
0.0207176842,
0.0417411365,
-0.0144368913,
-0.0299409851,
0.00271422,
0.0553343147,
-0.0023548321,
-0.0108386101,
0.040984109,
0.019403832,
-0.0217597913,
0.0074759447,
0.0906599611,
0.0391266309,
-0.0328207463,
-0.0390330963,
-0.0269916151,
-0.0116019398,
0.0495305359,
0.0867801756,
-0.1189518869,
-0.0173396394,
-0.0247967541,
0.0206066072,
0.0117409974,
0.0173278973,
-0.0304745566,
-0.1001326665,
0.086048007,
0.0029384072,
0.0181465242,
-0.0098961014,
-0.0170636345,
-0.0135686947,
0.0176770668,
-0.0317200609,
0.0225146189,
-0.0352642089,
0.0295169689,
-0.0049517369,
0.0260679629,
-0.0249981079,
0.0332646705,
-0.034698166,
0.0444883853,
0.0733470619,
0.0206499137,
-0.0056510293,
-0.0442136191,
-0.0124869235,
-0.0105265435,
-0.0047843424,
0.0159882661,
0.0103711355,
0.0080489693,
-0.0138990022,
-0.0195641797,
0.0209541805,
0.0301037524,
-0.0347097889,
0.005528857,
0.0796326101,
-0.0369652286,
0.0183897167,
-0.0695964843,
0.00600826,
0.015590366,
0.0841876566,
-0.0003317445,
-0.0238298625,
-0.0089628967,
0.0247241817,
-0.063006185,
-0.0511641614,
-0.0354245938,
0.0060050171,
0.0086823301,
0.0471793599,
-0.0678589642,
0.0067622918,
0.0271226149,
0.0050053671,
-0.0198541787,
0.017263094,
-0.0094818734,
0.0363001935,
-0.094930619,
0.0151831191,
0.015253922,
-0.0085373176,
-0.0579102784,
-0.0125925094,
0.0558707789,
-0.0766888782,
-0.0037432106,
0.0134931961,
-0.0215771291,
-0.0414206497,
-0.0173185635,
0.0618341565,
0.0242358744,
0.0271784179,
0.0109038632,
-0.0279605556,
0.0305089504,
0.0689443722,
-0.0305220373,
-0.0080712819,
-0.0467012823,
-0.0044964277,
-0.0258551389,
0.026441196,
-0.1001252532,
0.0145450067,
-0.0267807413,
0.0356200337,
-0.0149479052,
-0.051119335,
0.0192774255,
0.0171138197,
-0.0411628075,
-0.0274400003,
-0.0246219579,
-0.0042638006,
-0.0120236091,
-0.0071181837,
-0.0091622146,
-0.042745322,
0.0170668289,
0.0048527895,
-0.0153225437,
0.012034853,
0.0438200086,
-0.005471319,
0.0257776137,
-0.0117724305,
-0.032138031,
-0.0325554833,
-0.029035503,
0.0101943696,
0.013031045,
0.02452855,
0.0422702432,
-0.0175315961,
0.0552090555,
0.0069105378,
0.0611735992,
-0.0111169377,
-0.0044861115,
-0.0057122926,
0.0297882631,
-0.0661681443,
-0.0835654587,
-0.0122256167,
0.0192096066,
0.0516427793,
-0.0370577201,
-0.0258329716,
-0.0184515808,
-0.0233212877,
-0.0524678975,
0.0244152639,
0.0069298781,
-0.0696343556,
0.0261621401,
0.0234290585,
-0.0212157313,
0.0212201923,
0.0702323541,
-0.0187587589,
0.0224687774,
-0.0045001679,
-0.0082954168,
0.0020558501,
-0.0432551354,
-0.0132719958,
-0.0088982247,
-0.0509480499,
0.0247072522,
-0.0207901858,
-0.0452153943,
-0.0294596273,
0.0082613649,
-0.0155688496,
0.0231058653,
0.0517831929,
0.0568556562,
0.0200864207,
-0.0197322164,
-0.0266504847,
0.0201326404,
-0.0917631164,
-0.0421852842,
0.0067836968,
-5.747425712e-33,
-0.0248122159,
-0.0204395894,
0.0616130568,
0.0182785951,
-0.0134089142,
-0.005541292,
-0.0009957242,
0.0170620382,
-0.0414250419,
-0.0281778052,
0.0049860775,
0.0176500287,
-0.0036234437,
0.0541589633,
0.0150632998,
-0.0345071256,
0.0168004837,
-0.0387700833,
-0.0191186368,
0.0135814641,
0.0496247821,
0.022174608,
-0.0256088395,
-0.0511004403,
-0.0630890131,
-0.0173966084,
0.0004770417,
0.044839289,
0.0114083532,
0.0799637362,
0.005711291,
0.0083138365,
0.0110268276,
-0.0286882408,
0.000061867,
0.0034072225,
-0.0371579602,
0.0250997227,
0.0241938848,
-0.0080763428,
-0.0368967466,
-0.0333224162,
0.0004438334,
-0.0226418059,
-0.0081805466,
0.0043261098,
0.0386171341,
-0.016578028,
0.025526287,
-0.0237840451,
-0.0322451778,
-0.0154676996,
-0.0197633263,
-0.0386725664,
0.0256643817,
0.0115668867,
0.0277105346,
0.0046747192,
-0.0210940987,
0.0424745791,
-0.033355508,
0.0614482164,
0.0751751289,
0.0280638915,
-0.0160429515,
0.0401102267,
0.0149508063,
-0.0831287429,
-0.005125958,
-0.0086893635,
-0.0317344256,
0.0506572947,
0.0110405916,
0.0334298387,
0.0089794751,
0.0021306854,
-0.0255376212,
0.0462649278,
-0.027989313,
0.0480742343,
0.0120862043,
0.027552899,
0.0380272418,
0.0206557624,
-0.0287410002,
0.0378510468,
-0.05036439,
-0.0432382636,
0.0205897111,
0.0037633597,
0.0196696687,
-0.0234759692,
0.082640022,
-0.0312967449,
0.0266562402,
0.0289552454,
-0.0445149653,
0.0206880439,
0.0291744433,
0.0507780164,
0.0082383305,
0.0385441259,
0.0427904204,
-0.0154708317,
-0.0475788787,
0.0396189541,
-0.0299864784,
0.0568235554,
-0.0334017687,
0.0178724211,
0.0001242904,
-0.0022532484,
-0.0444666445,
0.003647452,
-0.0018096962,
0.0491463579,
-0.0309736636,
0.0207578894,
-0.02884515,
0.0258389451,
-0.0108630406,
-0.0882337019,
0.0066210357,
0.0114834867,
-0.0351425298,
0.0664012209,
-0.0552623533,
0.0150912181,
-0.0065793484,
-0.0432124101,
-0.018271843,
0.0409801155,
2.518e-7,
-0.004417446,
-0.0099701928,
-0.0036097055,
0.040585231,
0.0171905234,
0.0107893078,
0.012832934,
0.0227832645,
0.0490084402,
-0.0225076117,
-0.0034653211,
0.0328038745,
0.0300386157,
-0.0118679553,
-0.0563285314,
0.0125982538,
-0.0489174761,
-0.04442003,
-0.0724437088,
-0.0337623358,
0.0369449034,
0.0685716346,
-0.0061167954,
0.0010323166,
-0.0043241326,
-0.0718369484,
0.0667719766,
0.0221377648,
-0.0543169305,
0.0177652501,
0.0394030958,
0.0269039832,
-0.0014613608,
-0.0235508718,
-0.0168905724,
0.0050163022,
0.0265904926,
0.0199621096,
-0.0097364224,
-0.0620489642,
-0.0370485485,
0.0105991028,
-0.0080648391,
-0.0137806507,
0.0620240867,
0.0135845877,
0.0100532183,
-0.031635996,
-0.0345859788,
0.0009017026,
-0.0544413514,
-0.0344984792,
0.0066697695,
0.0188324265,
0.0271648858,
-0.0159058105,
-0.0003272923,
-0.085534744,
-0.0007636131,
-0.0074198344,
-0.0488901436,
0.0035620786,
-0.0364311226,
0.011648613,
-0.0005635534,
-0.0162495784,
-0.0219563078,
1.765091438e-34,
0.0154785467,
0.0509569868,
-0.0073209256,
0.0027821106,
0.0035435299,
0.006108216,
-0.0515258312,
0.02781846,
0.0013365084,
-0.0479473807,
-0.0170112215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15527v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15527v1 | Data Efficient Evaluation of Large Language Models and Text-to-Image Models via Adaptive Sampling | 2024-06-21T07:38:55 | 2024-06-21T07:38:55 | Cong Xu, Gayathri Saranathan, Mahammad Parwez Alam, Arpit Shah, James Lim, Soon Yee Wong, Foltin Martin, Suparna Bhattacharya | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Evaluating LLMs and text-to-image models is a computationally intensive task
often overlooked. Efficient evaluation is crucial for understanding the diverse
capabilities of these models and enabling comparisons across a growing number
of new models and benchmarks. To address this, we introduce SubLIME, a
data-efficient evaluation framework that employs adaptive sampling techniques,
such as clustering and quality-based methods, to create representative subsets
of benchmarks. Our approach ensures statistically aligned model rankings
compared to full datasets, evidenced by high Pearson correlation coefficients.
Empirical analysis across six NLP benchmarks reveals that: (1) quality-based
sampling consistently achieves strong correlations (0.85 to 0.95) with full
datasets at a 10\% sampling rate such as Quality SE and Quality CPD (2)
clustering methods excel in specific benchmarks such as MMLU (3) no single
method universally outperforms others across all metrics. Extending this
framework, we leverage the HEIM leaderboard to cover 25 text-to-image models on
17 different benchmarks. SubLIME dynamically selects the optimal technique for
each benchmark, significantly reducing evaluation costs while preserving
ranking integrity and score distribution. Notably, a minimal sampling rate of
1% proves effective for benchmarks like MMLU. Additionally, we demonstrate that
employing difficulty-based sampling to target more challenging benchmark
segments enhances model differentiation with broader score distributions. We
also combine semantic search, tool use, and GPT-4 review to identify redundancy
across benchmarks within specific LLM categories, such as coding benchmarks.
This allows us to further reduce the number of samples needed to maintain
targeted rank preservation. Overall, SubLIME offers a versatile and
cost-effective solution for the robust evaluation of LLMs and text-to-image
models. | [
0.0124958428,
0.0819623768,
0.0031498291,
0.0535794385,
-0.03058655,
-0.0000154847,
-0.0094227418,
0.039794229,
-0.010352469,
-0.0733867511,
-0.0629668012,
-0.0164556243,
0.0232606977,
-0.0012456898,
0.0383454114,
-0.0599612184,
0.0190471262,
-0.027759254,
-0.0314172506,
0.0205787979,
0.0176043846,
0.0230013169,
0.0292028319,
0.0362631492,
-0.0047855019,
-0.0086583244,
0.0171336643,
0.0491557196,
0.0190616939,
-0.0314243101,
-0.0300791841,
0.0671119913,
0.0282516107,
0.0202629808,
0.0000021328,
-0.0182386022,
-0.0335980244,
0.0224930625,
-0.0006406226,
0.0182240624,
0.0764974728,
-0.0359217823,
0.006739879,
-0.0223133434,
-0.0169149227,
0.0321496241,
0.0473848656,
0.0333885178,
0.0641062185,
0.0371693633,
-0.0275301076,
0.0133078881,
0.0184621178,
-0.0361254886,
-0.0170931052,
-0.0399705283,
0.0134703768,
0.0434325077,
-0.0045963302,
0.0264735091,
-0.0184445586,
0.0588803142,
-0.0046224925,
0.0054171886,
0.0103317518,
0.0386549793,
-0.0309781916,
-0.0107811792,
-0.0244886409,
0.0645805523,
-0.049355343,
0.0020938034,
0.0055188555,
-0.0050374935,
-0.0336171351,
0.0151385106,
-0.0795872062,
0.0408835746,
0.0347824208,
0.0416916795,
-0.0197739191,
0.0326563455,
0.0360984951,
0.0118562179,
-0.0073426589,
0.0292610377,
0.0263298862,
-0.0130297914,
-0.0047185747,
0.0193237253,
-0.0633965135,
-0.0193318147,
0.0082368758,
-0.0176490676,
0.0270124096,
0.0185069889,
-0.0401043966,
-0.0482301824,
0.0087497504,
-0.0328284316,
0.067615889,
0.0181943662,
0.0066059013,
0.0910393298,
-0.0285366941,
0.0701738968,
0.0139459157,
0.0421960615,
-0.0199911594,
0.0034470749,
-0.0234251283,
0.0079712039,
-0.0137720937,
0.030705994,
-0.0400499888,
-0.0510036647,
-0.0210486036,
0.000170025,
-0.0105689373,
-0.0059579667,
0.0467496403,
0.0103348745,
-0.0280630328,
0.0236750264,
-0.0197071303,
-0.015198227,
0.0123963524,
-0.0129344147,
-0.0162254814,
-0.0278523955,
0.0178203434,
0.0268970691,
-0.0188991912,
-0.028787015,
0.0004254638,
0.0859074369,
-0.01960418,
-0.0473799929,
-0.0052652834,
0.0147861671,
-0.0414441787,
-0.0503864251,
0.0153095806,
-0.0994271114,
0.0478026457,
0.0043132715,
0.0253248122,
-0.0436584987,
0.000645231,
0.0122644026,
-0.0347694568,
0.0812516138,
0.0068194717,
0.0081576072,
-0.004071068,
0.0155857326,
-0.0111234803,
0.1009261236,
0.0341350734,
0.0382025577,
0.0641253516,
0.0117531978,
0.000109895,
0.0807898715,
-0.0005366422,
0.0198280327,
-0.0229657274,
0.00694911,
0.0152912568,
0.0170810744,
0.0496403761,
0.0772883222,
-0.0580571815,
-0.0217797495,
0.0795741379,
0.0760116205,
0.0331103243,
-0.0103016449,
0.0062291697,
-0.0133338599,
0.0155431423,
-0.0265095998,
-0.0448827967,
0.0257282872,
0.0040699677,
0.0145527851,
0.0582634173,
0.0501978397,
0.0003445372,
-0.0274329688,
-0.0243881717,
0.0145735303,
0.0061774743,
-0.0052760812,
0.0328363068,
-0.0047081332,
-0.0254696812,
0.0544112362,
-0.0043095872,
-0.0525169335,
0.0027525369,
-0.028584417,
0.0132056903,
0.0624632798,
0.0699379221,
0.002373094,
0.0315735713,
0.0279907342,
-0.0127451783,
0.0394850709,
-0.0284134075,
-0.0034057032,
0.0343116373,
-0.0404380634,
-0.0510511398,
-0.0020370227,
-0.000516594,
0.0051406911,
0.0397724062,
-0.0044565513,
0.0029245894,
-0.0951496661,
-0.0527720898,
0.04080889,
-0.0024040453,
0.0095775612,
-0.0136383101,
-0.0122739784,
0.0334255844,
-0.0107898815,
-0.0312571153,
0.0094096744,
0.0287062321,
-0.0280014873,
0.0052046068,
-0.0399279147,
-0.0180189759,
-0.0694084913,
0.0079766819,
-0.0641165748,
-0.0153847719,
0.0604635999,
-0.0599256083,
-0.0249801259,
-0.0083829025,
-0.0161094703,
0.0145759964,
-0.0534973815,
0.0251469519,
0.009879875,
0.0207092557,
-0.0596460737,
0.0584153011,
-0.0335572138,
0.0051901015,
0.0397296548,
0.0193691198,
0.0040196478,
-0.0377313793,
-0.0384944379,
0.0174637847,
-0.0040914426,
0.0353585519,
0.0009402024,
0.0541692227,
-0.0498613343,
-0.0293434877,
-0.0904837102,
0.0135918809,
-0.0291305985,
-0.0211751498,
0.0286877286,
-0.0152479401,
0.0228059161,
0.0143961385,
-0.0254664887,
-0.031201018,
0.0007206711,
0.0099965911,
0.0355958082,
0.0074756215,
0.0184660256,
-0.0541342944,
-0.0461064316,
0.0317202657,
0.0878770202,
-0.0352733657,
-0.0197428819,
-0.0029669746,
0.0469836295,
-0.0448560007,
0.0003918567,
-0.0128127979,
-0.0287494007,
0.008989892,
-0.0407452956,
0.032956697,
0.0607999489,
0.0079458104,
-0.0050770715,
0.0055977558,
0.0175822321,
-0.0596778914,
-0.032095328,
-0.0053821378,
0.0106865428,
0.030636536,
-0.0765373409,
0.0176733304,
0.0541027784,
0.0127366642,
0.028682325,
-0.0550101735,
0.0072144256,
-0.029112801,
-0.0397860035,
-0.0710428208,
0.0356260315,
0.0238466132,
0.0469153225,
-0.0693593621,
-0.0695424899,
0.0227685515,
-0.070620589,
0.0016586821,
0.0026271683,
0.0105047626,
-0.0357242748,
0.047356233,
0.0196043868,
0.0126684913,
-0.0272664726,
0.0173137356,
-0.0446424074,
-0.0193454754,
0.0208292156,
-0.0489341542,
0.0518907346,
-0.0471820533,
0.034123417,
-0.0232643485,
-0.0289048292,
-0.0160215292,
-0.0085091507,
0.0025624258,
0.0245452318,
0.0204149392,
-0.0071451245,
0.0125991944,
0.0627659187,
-0.0173581317,
0.013570399,
-0.024219621,
-0.0141691482,
-0.0217016768,
0.0765022114,
0.0611994788,
-0.0364155881,
-0.0020462463,
-0.0385565124,
0.0156505872,
0.0655443296,
0.0461544134,
0.039039135,
-0.0519263111,
0.0382038206,
0.0295051727,
0.0320436656,
-0.0104575427,
0.0081681022,
0.037482217,
-0.0196951479,
-0.014346418,
0.0950981528,
0.028546799,
-0.027499659,
-0.0321592763,
0.0181167461,
0.0568242818,
0.0170040149,
-0.012614022,
-0.0347686708,
-0.0376255065,
-0.0098666754,
0.0222826526,
-0.0041075898,
-0.0125603061,
0.015413749,
-0.1065533012,
0.0466150194,
0.0101301856,
-0.0172030199,
0.0064853602,
-0.0305507574,
0.0057132458,
-0.03889044,
0.0079653198,
-0.0030370301,
0.0148308156,
0.0118599068,
-0.0020231667,
-0.0174210053,
-0.0398991928,
0.0274921544,
-0.0405096747,
0.0116985459,
0.0663524419,
0.0622693077,
0.0030540153,
-0.0185734872,
0.030989632,
-0.0032058426,
-0.0155031634,
-0.0268313065,
0.0595302097,
-0.0142006977,
-0.0218778607,
0.0054623359,
0.014183009,
0.0094530042,
-0.0061365752,
-0.0232064463,
0.0510063991,
0.0053795772,
-0.0036756259,
-0.0469755642,
-0.0000249284,
-0.0188253336,
0.0647360757,
0.0310050882,
-0.0182163268,
-0.0391456448,
-0.0358043425,
0.0190652683,
-0.059090931,
-0.0330875814,
0.0262494963,
-0.0263025034,
0.0069176937,
-0.0947963968,
0.007174314,
0.0358679593,
0.0269908234,
-0.018049201,
0.0011972595,
-0.0325551555,
-0.0098880902,
-0.0601871498,
0.0398527868,
-0.0404665358,
0.0089587569,
-0.0610280745,
0.0123531176,
0.0254784375,
-0.0065972325,
-0.0259415656,
0.0299541093,
-0.1006224304,
-0.0286314413,
-0.0428204425,
0.0683962554,
0.0113341603,
0.0224208217,
-0.0091331555,
-0.0562414676,
0.0294695944,
0.0327671655,
0.0173982829,
0.007274834,
-0.0042244378,
0.0030076192,
-0.0210054237,
0.0132704694,
-0.0516556241,
0.0275530312,
0.008540608,
0.0546747148,
-0.0136596337,
-0.0505462401,
-0.00255252,
0.0221259966,
0.0344862975,
-0.0418539792,
-0.0176961459,
0.0139879882,
-0.0277226605,
-0.035534814,
-0.0302564092,
-0.0669980124,
0.023588974,
0.0330116414,
0.029324688,
-0.0273877513,
0.0448473021,
0.0008568643,
0.0278287418,
-0.0859890133,
-0.0036074016,
0.0089627355,
-0.0279441047,
-0.0244673751,
0.0073710969,
-0.0141559355,
-0.0123233367,
-0.0341398381,
0.0085875876,
-0.0272381343,
0.0323162787,
0.0206795484,
0.0012344472,
0.0030694539,
0.0674078241,
-0.0504405834,
-0.0117739132,
-0.0721404403,
0.0277348757,
0.0622634143,
0.0032387259,
0.0778135583,
-0.0319145583,
-0.0203337371,
-0.036198128,
0.0110832648,
0.0303801317,
-0.0306336805,
0.0472664386,
0.0196725056,
0.0154781062,
0.0129061928,
0.0488296859,
0.0036941597,
-0.0089833373,
0.0050891959,
-0.0317418016,
-0.0276942011,
-0.0138814524,
0.0204860754,
-0.0279910937,
0.0080525167,
-0.0100402506,
-0.0273291934,
-0.0632931814,
0.014461359,
0.0358378738,
-0.0225581322,
-0.0152106071,
0.0505030602,
0.0482607856,
0.0179725718,
0.0311473627,
-0.0366769098,
-0.0293643475,
-0.019331634,
-0.0224699583,
-0.0163864084,
-6.653494186e-33,
-0.0198136866,
-0.0387670398,
-0.0113414703,
-0.048200693,
-0.0166327935,
0.0182612278,
-0.0048184157,
-0.0143350838,
0.0085573681,
-0.0124997208,
-0.001486416,
-0.0136154164,
0.0033841396,
0.0482016914,
-0.0336646624,
0.015690688,
0.0321524218,
-0.0342246927,
-0.0604671203,
-0.0007920111,
-0.0029354987,
0.0105122607,
0.0202366374,
-0.0214647371,
-0.0278199911,
0.0304235592,
-0.0178302098,
-0.0262928214,
0.0314997621,
0.0697468445,
-0.0202075001,
0.0165404063,
0.0226098523,
-0.036465358,
-0.0406513922,
-0.0201162603,
-0.0679510906,
0.0069250395,
0.032874532,
-0.0110052517,
-0.0667954087,
0.0157755446,
0.0437659584,
-0.0182891935,
-0.0191665255,
-0.0449273027,
0.0335020684,
-0.0406139232,
-0.0558570512,
-0.0294198282,
-0.0198017471,
0.0276265517,
-0.0151751898,
-0.0214073285,
0.0572555438,
0.0328391492,
-0.0193280745,
0.0933658555,
-0.0484657772,
-0.0010444832,
0.0131231658,
0.0627227351,
0.0837095156,
0.0591603108,
0.0092805102,
0.0491159856,
-0.0284071602,
-0.0273837093,
0.0208357442,
0.0066676848,
0.0412181281,
0.0844883993,
0.0742600784,
0.0671192631,
0.0073465863,
0.043863982,
-0.0293847509,
0.0462651961,
-0.0197178219,
-0.0082930112,
0.046025198,
0.0241799597,
-0.0107874088,
-0.0189986192,
-0.0827234238,
-0.0255922023,
-0.0413084403,
-0.0167247914,
0.0601703785,
0.0158106387,
-0.0404739939,
0.0049177646,
0.0654966384,
-0.0450094901,
-0.0281901658,
-0.024229167,
-0.0300448518,
0.0626145452,
0.0020521889,
0.0328760184,
-0.0357935503,
-0.0083169211,
0.0515633635,
0.0413025543,
0.0214850977,
-0.0250351634,
0.0096411528,
-0.0206981096,
-0.0377117284,
-0.0068348399,
-0.0243223626,
0.0003386284,
-0.0388764367,
-0.0000063436,
0.0113190264,
-0.0309909433,
-0.0283568967,
0.0288093854,
-0.0011621213,
0.0016718114,
-0.0263875518,
-0.0219434034,
-0.0014392465,
0.005416302,
-0.035011109,
0.03500925,
-0.0558833331,
-0.0095997155,
0.0456612445,
-0.0542877056,
-0.0359222926,
0.0514118411,
2.687e-7,
0.0642810911,
0.0347278714,
0.0014433343,
0.0008062527,
0.0279295817,
0.0245188773,
-0.053600803,
0.0145599181,
0.0013846596,
-0.0197847746,
-0.0075761452,
0.0281615872,
0.0705004036,
0.0073072622,
-0.0309804343,
0.0279490035,
-0.0775199309,
-0.0010756627,
-0.0496620536,
-0.0325621217,
0.0506440401,
0.0983952135,
-0.0365443006,
-0.0099847922,
-0.0093733519,
-0.0419606194,
0.0947439149,
-0.0494978242,
-0.009428882,
0.0004983013,
-0.0041827415,
0.0246474091,
-0.0060549434,
-0.0225028284,
-0.0037597932,
-0.0227738898,
0.0882100835,
0.0594836734,
-0.0061800103,
-0.0423320308,
0.001471948,
-0.0021356763,
-0.0033733605,
-0.0843686312,
0.08309111,
-0.0410348326,
-0.0180161968,
-0.0170423537,
-0.0178760067,
0.020265175,
0.0290241279,
-0.0153256515,
-0.0419331938,
0.041620288,
0.0490013398,
0.0038452048,
-0.0377788469,
-0.0497465506,
-0.0225076638,
-0.0188450497,
-0.0151445605,
-0.0533753335,
-0.0539650209,
-0.0116581991,
0.0061613685,
-0.0742124021,
-0.0376645513,
2.760110327e-34,
0.0362825878,
-0.0141090956,
0.0190200452,
0.008685871,
0.0192207042,
-0.0106427958,
-0.0370884389,
-0.0084078796,
-0.0513037369,
-0.0871018395,
0.003044781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14928v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14928v1 | Autonomous Agents for Collaborative Task under Information Asymmetry | 2024-06-21T07:37:19 | 2024-06-21T07:37:19 | Wei Liu, Chenxi Wang, Yifei Wang, Zihao Xie, Rennai Qiu, Yufan Dang, Zhuoyun Du, Weize Chen, Cheng Yang, Chen Qian | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.MA, cs.SI | Large Language Model Multi-Agent Systems (LLM-MAS) have achieved great
progress in solving complex tasks. It performs communication among agents
within the system to collaboratively solve tasks, under the premise of shared
information. However, when agents' communication is leveraged to enhance human
cooperation, a new challenge arises due to information asymmetry, since each
agent can only access the information of its human user. Previous MAS struggle
to complete tasks under this condition. To address this, we propose a new MAS
paradigm termed iAgents, which denotes Informative Multi-Agent Systems. In
iAgents, the human social network is mirrored in the agent network, where
agents proactively exchange human information necessary for task resolution,
thereby overcoming information asymmetry. iAgents employs a novel agent
reasoning mechanism, InfoNav, to navigate agents' communication towards
effective information exchange. Together with InfoNav, iAgents organizes human
information in a mixed memory to provide agents with accurate and comprehensive
information for exchange. Additionally, we introduce InformativeBench, the
first benchmark tailored for evaluating LLM agents' task-solving ability under
information asymmetry. Experimental results show that iAgents can collaborate
within a social network of 140 individuals and 588 relationships, autonomously
communicate over 30 turns, and retrieve information from nearly 70,000 messages
to complete tasks within 3 minutes. | [
0.0513284653,
-0.0169116687,
-0.0288447533,
0.0259121098,
-0.0651434734,
-0.0167564545,
-0.0042752684,
0.0209542383,
0.0198021084,
-0.0238028243,
-0.0246250946,
-0.0062767705,
-0.0182424448,
-0.031928353,
-0.0083932253,
0.0035972686,
0.0092534693,
-0.0202800799,
0.0397172533,
-0.0171633605,
-0.0070808805,
-0.0120810159,
0.0075378716,
0.0099106301,
-0.0122150127,
0.0067025735,
-0.0417837054,
-0.0102484794,
0.0257861819,
-0.0247877426,
-0.0179189574,
0.026688017,
0.0190138351,
0.0019349189,
0.0000023705,
-0.0428172462,
0.0056642126,
-0.0040977648,
-0.0654361919,
-0.0260672048,
-0.0027409096,
0.011323465,
0.000879188,
0.012618647,
-0.0824424848,
0.0330722407,
-0.0036741677,
0.0576262623,
0.0225308593,
0.0500376932,
-0.0032484713,
0.0002712916,
-0.0121095739,
-0.0107894428,
0.0042873211,
-0.0606574304,
0.0275971964,
0.0111050345,
0.0466699786,
0.0163966138,
0.0123390919,
0.0266320147,
0.040354576,
0.0091048814,
0.0217277035,
0.0360073298,
0.0201037601,
-0.0536303855,
-0.0090101287,
0.0687160343,
0.0365867652,
0.0115549332,
0.0047055334,
-0.009753556,
-0.0136298304,
0.0442433693,
-0.0160247292,
0.0308779441,
-0.0482261479,
-0.0072001498,
-0.0060599223,
0.0265825875,
0.0313191526,
-0.0019561201,
-0.0138491783,
0.103368707,
-0.0394101925,
0.0052963309,
-0.0164070185,
-0.0382223167,
0.0283996314,
-0.0523232743,
0.0449080877,
0.0591649674,
-0.0426233597,
-0.0027951768,
0.0061483029,
-0.0082913479,
0.0250036567,
-0.0863470808,
0.0036891997,
-0.0110401167,
0.0346136279,
0.0318893343,
0.013733997,
0.0106030488,
-0.0106443651,
0.0131939147,
-0.0167847201,
-0.0402957425,
-0.0867588148,
-0.0053249667,
-0.0352663808,
0.0587354898,
0.0009798751,
-0.0074761766,
0.0115422849,
0.0437973067,
-0.064852275,
0.0004761204,
-0.0110449893,
0.0281370059,
0.0182678029,
-0.0135606835,
-0.0645980239,
0.0023750269,
-0.0387126729,
0.0127010467,
0.0109002385,
-0.0174955614,
0.0255069751,
-0.0262742545,
-0.0165202692,
-0.0237485673,
-0.0021897496,
0.1049507409,
-0.0123047074,
-0.0213401075,
-0.0168905556,
-0.053538207,
0.0483262986,
-0.091822885,
-0.0044189468,
-0.0323878005,
0.041077666,
0.0612654984,
-0.0491560325,
-0.0129159335,
0.0373881534,
-0.029026892,
-0.0409170948,
0.0786782205,
0.0138438689,
0.0380086303,
0.0252663419,
0.0497199371,
0.0120029273,
0.0213287305,
0.0340128168,
0.0392564982,
0.0464377925,
0.0637968928,
0.0078510754,
-0.0044831312,
0.0418300405,
-0.0047460734,
0.0956028476,
0.0011054436,
-0.0183680411,
0.0263509676,
-0.0368522368,
0.0697137564,
-0.0118781291,
-0.0343219042,
0.0776092112,
0.0341234356,
-0.0199086405,
0.0183805469,
-0.0012535454,
0.0655094758,
-0.0204343311,
-0.0485406779,
-0.0526589006,
0.0840781331,
-0.03307385,
-0.0227105618,
-0.0001630214,
0.0193848349,
-0.0421355031,
-0.0231157802,
0.004842069,
-0.0202974882,
0.0516334958,
0.0299482439,
0.0417369679,
-0.0232056174,
-0.0273776893,
0.0196868051,
-0.007956136,
-0.0149719343,
-0.0132375211,
-0.0511413291,
0.021042645,
0.0892037451,
0.0647366345,
-0.0205328595,
-0.0291557033,
0.0252865665,
0.0003093327,
-0.0259022769,
0.0001749621,
-0.0182482209,
-0.0264404789,
-0.0348035693,
-0.0301648583,
0.0459959023,
-0.0211737119,
0.0353187509,
0.0113211498,
0.0060675805,
-0.0198660139,
0.0446162522,
-0.0086103333,
-0.0238879099,
-0.0319300964,
0.0710015222,
-0.0414167792,
0.0262320489,
0.0485611446,
0.0400597081,
-0.026262369,
-0.0019079624,
0.053857144,
-0.0181670319,
-0.0913068503,
0.0358399861,
-0.0111237271,
0.0186286271,
0.00322928,
-0.0295672826,
0.0355491862,
0.0351686664,
0.0299955253,
-0.0437553823,
0.0463213399,
0.0020762223,
0.0273571555,
0.0062249657,
0.0068456731,
0.0422565565,
0.0089262985,
0.0147249205,
0.0297039077,
-0.0037426269,
-0.0570338666,
-0.0355658159,
0.0173126459,
0.0219348241,
-0.0250336938,
0.0459135771,
0.0678282231,
0.0260533914,
-0.0159806833,
0.0229078848,
-0.0311191231,
-0.0026264545,
-0.0162776522,
-0.1060336083,
-0.0139125297,
-0.0064631812,
0.00892343,
-0.0125271147,
0.0064778668,
0.0381403789,
0.0002234555,
-0.0356796347,
0.0796507001,
0.0100862244,
0.0181908403,
0.0144854495,
0.0638095513,
-0.0628440455,
-0.033388447,
-0.0001024235,
-0.0190983694,
-0.0204733573,
0.0533494316,
-0.0649265498,
-0.0365784131,
0.0113917487,
-0.0728708953,
0.0412131175,
-0.0467003547,
-0.0286816452,
0.0345931761,
-0.0036791589,
-0.0082651526,
0.0228724666,
0.0011267258,
0.0394673273,
0.0003589476,
-0.0403344445,
-0.0489817113,
0.0220922548,
-0.0338521712,
0.0367165729,
-0.0384650342,
-0.0593763292,
-0.0388435647,
0.0046638334,
-0.0036997208,
-0.0178726614,
-0.0071983915,
-0.0465343148,
0.0358090885,
-0.025963746,
-0.032244686,
-0.054334648,
0.0229175054,
0.0069069988,
-0.0530608334,
0.010389789,
0.068164058,
-0.0028140156,
0.0000062808,
0.0230194908,
-0.0408902615,
-0.054517597,
0.1075017154,
0.0133104883,
0.01089276,
-0.00136406,
0.0063281553,
-0.0259063169,
-0.0050601936,
0.0289754234,
-0.0068383263,
0.0244884249,
-0.0458062105,
0.0260027237,
0.0020562683,
-0.0574514978,
-0.0007589808,
-0.0389333554,
-0.0022510833,
0.0439106785,
0.0171435084,
-0.0624048933,
0.0141085032,
0.0070914342,
0.0661933869,
-0.0197282862,
0.0117985578,
-0.0006474984,
-0.0447153822,
-0.0491757765,
-0.0242747478,
0.0054514646,
0.0178772993,
-0.0194749143,
0.0258845016,
0.0675515085,
0.0663979277,
-0.0441597402,
0.0363952927,
-0.0154812746,
0.0076923729,
0.0193260107,
-0.0296192616,
-0.0217014495,
0.0433158278,
-0.0324428529,
-0.0086595304,
0.0588971339,
0.0373385288,
-0.0332275555,
0.0003331476,
-0.0350400321,
-0.0269195102,
0.007593208,
0.0448872335,
-0.0603956804,
-0.0147032812,
0.0234407131,
-0.0260603651,
-0.00111667,
-0.0750282183,
-0.0019439594,
-0.0469248705,
-0.0002316239,
0.0113208862,
-0.0204435065,
-0.0293354336,
-0.04650883,
-0.014023141,
0.0176876318,
-0.0377497226,
-0.0059255762,
0.0469000861,
-0.0313964151,
-0.0153338257,
0.0171509292,
0.0286556091,
0.0371070504,
-0.045113638,
0.0853753909,
0.0607949644,
0.0569087379,
0.0195705704,
-0.0261515528,
-0.0076734531,
0.0428275466,
0.0281144511,
-0.0175012425,
0.0247293152,
-0.0061342968,
0.0299565997,
0.0102731483,
-0.0001348736,
-0.0487585627,
-0.0039769998,
0.0022448231,
0.0712582991,
-0.0398904048,
-0.0220845658,
-0.0075886208,
-0.0018121459,
0.0487168916,
0.0812394023,
-0.0283209253,
-0.0072745006,
-0.0389643349,
0.007191739,
-0.0054075392,
-0.0075384416,
0.003743794,
-0.0002262518,
-0.0268338788,
-0.0532389544,
-0.0615378991,
-0.0671148822,
0.0207552928,
-0.0017111052,
0.0023289425,
0.0132987062,
0.0645624921,
-0.021835316,
-0.0243499558,
-0.0538655408,
-0.0145676546,
0.0288797822,
-0.0092973234,
-0.024925841,
0.0000062281,
-0.0690996125,
-0.0011852819,
0.0107421679,
-0.0574552789,
-0.0569861531,
0.0276854299,
0.0210325737,
0.0224224553,
0.023181254,
-0.0297733732,
-0.0298108105,
0.0208066851,
0.0222378261,
-0.0616747364,
0.0400875583,
-0.0191020109,
0.002153364,
0.037964467,
0.0585758574,
-0.0462033153,
0.0226837527,
0.0121290097,
0.0143856257,
-0.0656947494,
-0.0434816517,
-0.0145668928,
0.0454789363,
-0.0077567417,
0.042062711,
-0.0392170139,
-0.0071380106,
0.0137132062,
-0.036466632,
-0.0008437486,
-0.0376095846,
0.0114810411,
-0.0412903316,
0.0012058124,
0.0403662436,
0.0223403405,
0.0382416584,
-0.0212771948,
0.0421776734,
-0.0177971814,
-0.0416598879,
0.0400281511,
0.0202774331,
0.0447470471,
0.0451750644,
0.0194446351,
0.0377388932,
0.0404152498,
0.0051700068,
0.0740347654,
0.0263219159,
-0.0501278974,
-0.0518267043,
0.0409777686,
-0.08901719,
-0.0657991096,
0.0786746219,
0.0658237636,
0.0526130162,
0.0767541006,
-0.0152800716,
-0.0786768422,
0.0518495776,
-0.0189230014,
0.0290178396,
-0.0052827648,
-0.0322629772,
0.0206892788,
0.0195399839,
-0.0084833028,
0.066144675,
0.0365008302,
-0.057349693,
0.0367061757,
-0.0621480234,
-0.0454208478,
-0.0045924983,
-0.0061016888,
0.0113533605,
0.0348125696,
-0.011271311,
-0.0028555449,
-0.0404815041,
-0.0256276932,
-0.0162297282,
0.0604516529,
-0.0079939365,
-0.041356571,
0.0097442111,
0.0211745054,
0.0135098565,
-0.0763963386,
-0.0459231921,
-0.016707899,
-0.0537492149,
0.0276662149,
-0.0006141743,
-6.943289543e-33,
-0.024165798,
-0.0409082621,
0.0589822717,
0.0337133482,
-0.0053385403,
-0.0327583067,
-0.0335642546,
-0.0016940042,
-0.035903614,
0.0265103672,
-0.0371503606,
0.0566154942,
0.0256424695,
-0.027658537,
0.0114800697,
-0.0073787854,
0.0077821324,
-0.0125122806,
0.0175495725,
0.0172459241,
0.0609339066,
0.0063462839,
0.0014157803,
-0.0778872222,
0.0061462955,
-0.0225183479,
-0.0120529775,
0.0660991147,
-0.0448901951,
-0.0231090747,
0.0187022407,
0.005380298,
0.0240783226,
-0.0091885161,
0.005941805,
0.0048068478,
-0.0470478646,
-0.0234275125,
0.0094954055,
-0.0135580143,
-0.0392884165,
-0.0190461352,
0.0146129606,
-0.0041295318,
-0.0109581202,
0.0455258749,
0.022134712,
0.0060338331,
0.0092224199,
0.025309395,
-0.010640041,
-0.0081809266,
0.0054960931,
-0.0120189376,
0.0017404621,
-0.0077555366,
-0.019053217,
-0.0447827429,
-0.0683142319,
0.0038183932,
-0.0494194292,
-0.0222121496,
0.0108982148,
0.0082993135,
0.0144117177,
0.0429387838,
0.0914113075,
0.0514486432,
-0.0384781323,
-0.0069550066,
-0.0276511628,
0.0834182799,
0.0222847424,
0.0239003673,
-0.0601111539,
-0.0081963679,
-0.0511588715,
0.0234366413,
0.0391855352,
0.0305971596,
0.0285517611,
0.0529838651,
-0.0673429891,
-0.0275399741,
-0.0041664615,
0.0003804017,
-0.0233413111,
-0.055426009,
0.0049345451,
0.014610243,
0.0204160549,
0.0027431024,
0.0145590538,
-0.044516135,
-0.018780347,
0.0290132985,
0.0255535077,
0.0343808755,
-0.0098096374,
-0.02659069,
-0.0932839736,
0.0002965982,
-0.0230529141,
0.0294856448,
0.000604843,
0.0350677259,
0.009372198,
0.0232511591,
0.0277614202,
-0.0376279242,
-0.0483436808,
0.0154234366,
0.0433432162,
-0.1001551002,
0.019723976,
0.0168881249,
-0.0155688683,
0.0107206255,
0.0008909899,
-0.0252215136,
-0.0130476682,
0.0074458597,
-0.0148729095,
-0.0147775887,
0.0052084532,
0.007952665,
-0.0741174668,
0.0083475308,
0.0241495781,
-0.00828485,
-0.0192102753,
-0.0091456575,
3.271e-7,
-0.0503981747,
0.0188668463,
0.0191940386,
0.022642348,
0.0123402253,
0.0590134561,
-0.0143444557,
0.0238205604,
-0.0233438704,
0.01124945,
0.0452786125,
0.081933625,
-0.0213121902,
0.0413402542,
-0.031159712,
-0.0648673251,
-0.0036009676,
-0.0604734682,
-0.0275444612,
-0.0173962899,
0.0178265963,
0.003019036,
0.0909306332,
0.0070296978,
0.0210062061,
-0.0653935596,
0.0174069982,
-0.0653293654,
-0.0002006151,
0.0149735454,
0.0148763638,
-0.042610392,
-0.0207016282,
0.0549712107,
0.0343909003,
-0.022664031,
-0.0570393018,
0.020683974,
-0.0362667367,
-0.0422622934,
-0.0421087369,
-0.0424258597,
-0.0259667058,
0.0126553494,
0.0326477475,
-0.0294420645,
-0.0395769775,
0.0497722588,
0.0116147716,
-0.0415817536,
-0.0592120588,
0.0348924547,
0.0076352931,
0.0054970603,
-0.0255878121,
-0.0233531222,
-0.005141872,
-0.0919110924,
0.0440125167,
0.0120111099,
-0.0476686209,
-0.0444338284,
-0.0144449715,
0.0144545361,
0.019000506,
-0.0050714128,
-0.0007629322,
2.383801984e-34,
0.0040182997,
0.0195099041,
-0.0307335034,
0.0362396389,
0.0474200696,
0.0003803965,
-0.105812788,
0.0177746303,
0.0316510536,
-0.0395212062,
-0.0375493988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14917v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14917v1 | LLM2FEA: Discover Novel Designs with Generative Evolutionary Multitasking | 2024-06-21T07:20:51 | 2024-06-21T07:20:51 | Melvin Wong, Jiao Liu, Thiago Rios, Stefan Menzel, Yew Soon Ong | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.NE | The rapid research and development of generative artificial intelligence has
enabled the generation of high-quality images, text, and 3D models from text
prompts. This advancement impels an inquiry into whether these models can be
leveraged to create digital artifacts for both creative and engineering
applications. Drawing on innovative designs from other domains may be one
answer to this question, much like the historical practice of ``bionics", where
humans have sought inspiration from nature's exemplary designs. This raises the
intriguing possibility of using generative models to simultaneously tackle
design tasks across multiple domains, facilitating cross-domain learning and
resulting in a series of innovative design solutions. In this paper, we propose
LLM2FEA as the first attempt to discover novel designs in generative models by
transferring knowledge across multiple domains. By utilizing a multi-factorial
evolutionary algorithm (MFEA) to drive a large language model, LLM2FEA
integrates knowledge from various fields to generate prompts that guide the
generative model in discovering novel and practical objects. Experimental
results in the context of 3D aerodynamic design verify the discovery
capabilities of the proposed LLM2FEA. The designs generated by LLM2FEA not only
satisfy practicality requirements to a certain degree but also feature novel
and aesthetically pleasing shapes, demonstrating the potential applications of
LLM2FEA in discovery tasks. | [
0.0208305474,
0.0425521508,
-0.03857252,
0.0568702929,
-0.040390186,
-0.0153532093,
0.0270784665,
-0.0029087525,
-0.0509660728,
0.0303125586,
-0.0309308227,
-0.0443913117,
-0.049353607,
0.0770328715,
0.0324557126,
0.0055388743,
-0.0326882601,
-0.0439282134,
-0.0025096799,
-0.0199488681,
-0.0274834391,
0.0087145995,
-0.011714641,
0.046533078,
-0.0056965146,
0.008377458,
-0.0419472195,
-0.0008657405,
0.0183877554,
-0.0347346365,
-0.0223550498,
0.0523917601,
0.0308021568,
0.0676990375,
0.0000022291,
-0.0170028396,
0.0133131286,
-0.0192496013,
0.0252598953,
-0.0103022838,
0.0808622986,
0.0369272754,
-0.0487441681,
-0.0543341935,
-0.0281477589,
0.0186697301,
0.0037770204,
0.0198871084,
0.0047445996,
-0.0257686581,
-0.0046598259,
-0.0506895706,
0.0521353148,
-0.0117309,
0.0475874096,
0.0276623238,
-0.0110690817,
-0.0240250621,
0.0672478229,
-0.0044344985,
-0.0103710759,
0.018686641,
0.0190220997,
0.0008845936,
0.0290068127,
0.0266850479,
0.0430132821,
-0.0376783907,
0.0069141388,
0.0487075262,
-0.0519347228,
0.0170956403,
0.0126794092,
-0.0398265421,
-0.0110735754,
0.0494986437,
-0.0151124308,
-0.0222321544,
-0.0331255831,
-0.016437903,
0.0152545618,
-0.0696223453,
-0.0238016136,
-0.0713485107,
-0.0081559364,
0.0393571742,
0.0289108194,
0.0282694418,
-0.0155458655,
-0.0093448516,
-0.008787076,
-0.0160229113,
-0.0087835463,
-0.0126697151,
-0.0010023395,
-0.0166818928,
0.0095982505,
-0.0423804447,
0.005664581,
-0.0006043146,
0.0992128029,
-0.0112612909,
0.010201348,
0.0069036628,
-0.0709151626,
-0.0220748987,
-0.0555027127,
-0.0210583992,
-0.0933605134,
0.0303560793,
-0.0247273892,
-0.0254625492,
-0.001335753,
0.0401123874,
-0.0800160766,
-0.012189555,
0.0059677842,
0.0516890362,
-0.0057343715,
-0.0231793318,
0.022594396,
0.0367979892,
0.0381319039,
-0.00501954,
-0.0561374202,
-0.051568348,
0.0010773701,
0.0710057765,
-0.0170816574,
0.0076722489,
0.0221881829,
0.0227298699,
0.0089121722,
0.0140090957,
-0.0199465081,
0.1049000546,
-0.0476499759,
0.0248095524,
-0.0324371085,
-0.0299180727,
0.0486222319,
0.00170635,
0.0817075148,
-0.0065073632,
0.0126577253,
-0.0291178226,
-0.0063159754,
-0.0238874331,
0.0029194742,
-0.0477984026,
0.0128032258,
0.0345595293,
-0.0131429527,
0.0466389656,
0.0069749518,
-0.0426279791,
-0.0305832587,
0.03770395,
0.0013425101,
0.0028874092,
-0.0244015492,
-0.0269955099,
0.0193979647,
0.0107877627,
0.0167867262,
0.0024561293,
0.014788474,
-0.0536642671,
0.0094820447,
0.0313636921,
0.001791873,
-0.0380688272,
-0.0324510448,
0.0802887157,
0.0475580096,
-0.0028671841,
0.0533219762,
0.1055344045,
0.0725348219,
-0.01160804,
-0.0398987159,
-0.0127301542,
0.07140176,
0.0411702432,
-0.0235920418,
-0.0232841987,
-0.0292233042,
0.0450975597,
-0.0398542322,
-0.0374528542,
0.0618625544,
-0.001319612,
-0.0119396271,
-0.0036806699,
0.0127824331,
0.0339444466,
-0.005541889,
-0.0220689066,
-0.038886968,
-0.0116379559,
-0.0340202041,
-0.0204767622,
0.0552386455,
0.083227165,
0.0023983656,
-0.00294078,
-0.0344455205,
0.019463256,
-0.0032656924,
0.0185028613,
0.0175231528,
-0.0165966544,
-0.0044225557,
0.0412320122,
-0.0137333376,
-0.0248551965,
0.0289083701,
0.0560511239,
-0.0564690419,
0.0019735449,
-0.0129803186,
0.0197254289,
-0.0001180813,
0.0277436282,
-0.0520777367,
0.0361659564,
0.0806358382,
-0.0029486748,
0.0106858676,
-0.0084205773,
-0.0007679993,
-0.0120065957,
0.0390067548,
-0.0709539279,
-0.0425736122,
0.0064417776,
0.036583513,
0.0353283063,
-0.0197106134,
-0.0565715171,
0.0248519164,
-0.0197615083,
0.0146019636,
-0.0095225275,
0.0199928768,
-0.0048785699,
0.0692256466,
-0.0030753806,
-0.014930455,
-0.013835161,
-0.0094987452,
-0.0164757185,
0.0412469357,
-0.0169560574,
-0.0209800266,
-0.0222926065,
-0.0138927344,
0.021368077,
0.00435333,
-0.027864553,
0.027327545,
0.0136916963,
0.0087048449,
0.0257726908,
0.0120970327,
-0.0250871629,
-0.0240924805,
0.0226754099,
-0.0106893247,
0.0414042845,
0.0183116905,
-0.0093495054,
-0.0289342646,
-0.0082405945,
0.0574520715,
0.0190681275,
0.0307177939,
-0.0157447383,
-0.0446366593,
0.0566347539,
-0.0049811839,
-0.0463638268,
0.0009669182,
-0.0096018733,
-0.0471354984,
0.0335648917,
0.0917907283,
0.0031579263,
-0.0822288468,
0.0648504868,
-0.0580567867,
-0.0147489263,
0.0053473641,
0.0147320386,
0.0216137338,
-0.0383756943,
0.0581942089,
0.0317772143,
-0.0063326713,
-0.0109592918,
0.0117387567,
0.0028111665,
-0.0355678089,
0.0224190857,
-0.033073958,
0.01610405,
0.0550713614,
0.0304530188,
0.0504880697,
-0.0448869206,
-0.0314900205,
-0.0322257765,
-0.0242405571,
0.1084205955,
0.0628259405,
-0.0593748838,
0.0012226149,
-0.0120837633,
0.0192452576,
0.0869296268,
-0.0121297007,
0.0046631875,
0.0392905511,
0.0455075577,
0.0170662589,
0.0179837197,
0.0113095893,
-0.0252997819,
0.0687513053,
-0.0023557716,
0.0126799187,
0.0568625368,
0.0319149084,
0.0154819349,
0.0586886778,
0.0189318694,
-0.0205477793,
-0.0158027131,
-0.0461509265,
-0.0207894035,
-0.0064709727,
-0.0804953873,
-0.0613917001,
0.0340396464,
0.0041839192,
-0.0085557215,
-0.0038533944,
0.001813592,
-0.037722934,
0.0001708514,
0.003466151,
-0.0065600965,
-0.006632328,
0.0307055041,
-0.0225332454,
0.0404454172,
0.0320580453,
0.0273921881,
-0.0037016366,
0.0059586265,
-0.0234012157,
-0.0114574367,
-0.0383359045,
0.0002070288,
-0.0345973298,
0.0310955327,
0.0349311121,
0.0438965075,
-0.0340974405,
-0.014536595,
-0.0005335679,
-0.0135727366,
0.0035662993,
0.0064004669,
0.0045837201,
-0.0064148158,
0.0292604826,
0.014952464,
0.0335179977,
-0.0032105797,
0.0244825631,
-0.045138184,
0.0074509084,
-0.0538670793,
-0.0192099623,
-0.0499130711,
-0.0328447968,
0.0232484415,
-0.0913365632,
0.0590133183,
-0.0136885792,
-0.0298259612,
0.0235135108,
0.0101960823,
-0.0058799149,
0.0177231804,
-0.08658728,
0.002933058,
0.0028391131,
0.0023213057,
-0.0015018213,
0.0145889306,
-0.0694374293,
-0.0114822751,
0.0271181166,
-0.0393023081,
0.0300257038,
0.0172949471,
-0.0135935787,
-0.1264723539,
0.0243566334,
0.0339733213,
0.0262887366,
-0.0386040173,
-0.0208245814,
0.0446559153,
0.0018029298,
-0.0425101928,
0.0422402434,
-0.012944079,
-0.0208985209,
0.0165218208,
0.0628889278,
0.0064501339,
-0.0113175781,
-0.100267075,
-0.0550352149,
0.0175368246,
-0.0218872521,
-0.0065213991,
-0.0741307139,
-0.00284006,
-0.0688850731,
-0.0171959884,
-0.0724477395,
-0.0683415905,
-0.0490467548,
0.0524733216,
-0.0008459747,
-0.0480916686,
0.0794481784,
-0.0020663873,
0.0227285661,
0.0269351956,
-0.0109635154,
-0.0809668303,
-0.0019652562,
-0.034530025,
-0.0448674671,
0.0233493168,
-0.0157605428,
-0.0003805199,
-0.0032721802,
0.0701030716,
-0.0747799203,
-0.0410463959,
0.0395154953,
-0.0249890238,
-0.0088318614,
-0.0072076302,
0.0302929748,
0.0053479183,
-0.0488849618,
0.0056102234,
-0.026373582,
0.0597738177,
0.0383157469,
0.0413754992,
-0.0275594071,
-0.0101994844,
0.0125684049,
0.0039726486,
-0.0398086347,
0.0059775882,
0.0209991615,
0.0147217792,
-0.0065317675,
0.0380589776,
-0.0288736708,
0.0011921094,
0.0342248641,
-0.0082911728,
-0.0121591166,
0.0340338498,
-0.0455124155,
0.0510497391,
0.063187696,
-0.0108506978,
-0.0188213158,
0.0045304871,
0.0026896575,
-0.0350365825,
0.0020834056,
-0.0190996584,
0.0457461365,
0.0646642074,
-0.0699916855,
0.0691433176,
0.0377779752,
0.0413990729,
-0.0192614254,
0.0086006029,
0.0419043303,
0.0303561538,
-0.0412684903,
0.0371293761,
-0.0135024311,
-0.0083954977,
-0.003800953,
-0.0068460261,
-0.0165648144,
0.0816647783,
-0.0287781656,
-0.04466106,
-0.0714498088,
0.0428593867,
0.0627797619,
0.0659249127,
-0.009818946,
-0.0267366394,
-0.0142646069,
-0.0119313477,
0.0100626713,
-0.0273530893,
-0.0441379175,
0.0106704067,
0.0137964422,
0.0227609947,
-0.1017694175,
0.0214153305,
-0.0462383404,
0.0034643018,
-0.0259649679,
0.0175018869,
-0.0472956225,
0.0125890356,
0.0269842632,
0.0064400309,
0.0122661367,
0.0151353227,
-0.0718750656,
-0.0061754626,
0.0175938383,
0.0540485606,
0.0041332273,
0.0087885093,
0.0459648594,
0.0650889203,
-0.0420431271,
-0.0550349988,
0.0246419329,
-0.0261902176,
-0.0467557795,
-0.0029072633,
-0.019828191,
-5.878140317e-33,
0.0039735148,
-0.0029197764,
0.0200235453,
0.0448099636,
-0.0094622448,
-0.0331108719,
-0.0243584421,
-0.0023411762,
0.0187866762,
-0.0342897102,
-0.0185098574,
-0.0921994373,
-0.0510163493,
-0.0229083952,
0.0745226815,
-0.0067708581,
0.0400853828,
0.0192297585,
-0.0437859744,
0.0142723927,
-0.040071331,
0.0112946527,
-0.0140704643,
-0.0276645459,
-0.0398732126,
-0.0181675702,
-0.0144830504,
-0.0118188299,
-0.0209198613,
0.0492560156,
-0.0300081745,
0.0256915633,
-0.0170730557,
-0.0473631546,
-0.0195065495,
-0.0475782007,
-0.0334705152,
-0.049537912,
0.0166987944,
-0.0483760945,
0.007992818,
-0.0695131049,
0.0004686691,
0.0446572043,
-0.0398539007,
0.0010478674,
0.0431018397,
-0.0220246036,
0.009593986,
-0.0433672443,
-0.0686128661,
-0.017761305,
-0.0099643925,
-0.0159077011,
0.0496124849,
-0.0247502178,
0.0325931646,
0.0123068867,
0.0175499152,
0.1004105061,
-0.0035842226,
-0.0357632153,
0.0241412856,
-0.0033377197,
0.0345469788,
0.0225047655,
0.0344199836,
0.030804893,
-0.0104298852,
-0.0053578028,
0.0335274078,
0.0792860538,
0.0124591524,
0.0447049141,
0.0011144738,
-0.0033719875,
-0.0161653478,
0.0471760109,
-0.064771302,
-0.0082174605,
0.0372044779,
0.0440138094,
0.0558656417,
-0.0305391885,
0.0126890289,
-0.0150681669,
-0.0159590859,
0.0154501833,
-0.0107063539,
0.00905813,
0.003841178,
-0.0345876142,
0.0042647072,
-0.0496160015,
0.048986394,
-0.0249580275,
-0.0449573956,
0.0167609192,
-0.0052835718,
-0.0137355132,
-0.0179350637,
-0.0579522774,
-0.0071881944,
0.0314235128,
-0.0034713254,
-0.0264386777,
-0.0384402201,
0.0270315148,
0.0182574727,
0.0075419946,
-0.0286624897,
-0.0215016026,
0.049240455,
-0.0158729292,
0.0325126797,
0.0068373787,
-0.0133485775,
-0.0925448239,
0.0274320766,
0.0125642642,
-0.0746322796,
0.0393077545,
-0.0734568164,
0.017139744,
-0.0462234132,
-0.0172083378,
0.0048672389,
0.0102968393,
0.0528098308,
-0.0897715762,
-0.0313046277,
0.0264400691,
3.06e-7,
-0.0066242316,
0.0188690107,
-0.0278310031,
0.0070386003,
0.0316062868,
0.02273014,
-0.042642884,
0.0244189352,
0.0159570742,
0.0388437696,
0.0088393753,
0.0236376822,
-0.0036340742,
-0.0202239864,
-0.0799839422,
0.0263200067,
0.0381099917,
0.0634678602,
-0.0551056042,
0.0461124107,
0.0278671179,
0.034729179,
0.0002500308,
-0.0217833016,
0.008714471,
0.0461056381,
0.0011469761,
-0.0167075936,
0.0463808924,
0.0061691604,
-0.0536209568,
0.03275121,
-0.0350791477,
-0.014048188,
0.0072947815,
0.0112942876,
0.0201498885,
-0.0141196195,
0.0606510751,
0.0180442072,
0.0520564653,
0.080199331,
0.0200361069,
-0.0089926589,
0.0161066875,
-0.0030905039,
0.0224077813,
0.0065734177,
0.0305552632,
0.0258815717,
-0.0212984867,
-0.0361278243,
0.03344981,
-0.0302611049,
-0.0452197976,
0.0207681488,
0.0284556448,
-0.0095025916,
0.0169813372,
0.031305816,
-0.0835967734,
-0.0242414251,
-0.0252326075,
-0.0145122726,
0.0400225855,
-0.0011726909,
0.0283293463,
2.126540224e-34,
-0.0115052834,
-0.015340359,
0.0023042313,
0.0644403026,
-0.0070203124,
0.0410621539,
0.0389505178,
-0.0237360708,
0.031528227,
-0.0227590259,
-0.0368800499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14909v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14909v1 | MoA: Mixture of Sparse Attention for Automatic Large Language Model Compression | 2024-06-21T06:58:37 | 2024-06-21T06:58:37 | Tianyu Fu, Haofeng Huang, Xuefei Ning, Genghan Zhang, Boju Chen, Tianqi Wu, Hongyi Wang, Zixiao Huang, Shiyao Li, Shengen Yan, Guohao Dai, Huazhong Yang, Yu Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7 | Sparse attention can effectively mitigate the significant memory and
throughput demands of Large Language Models (LLMs) in long contexts. Existing
methods typically employ a uniform sparse attention mask, applying the same
sparse pattern across different attention heads and input lengths. However,
this uniform approach fails to capture the diverse attention patterns inherent
in LLMs, ignoring their distinct accuracy-latency trade-offs. To address this
challenge, we propose the Mixture of Attention (MoA), which automatically
tailors distinct sparse attention configurations to different heads and layers.
MoA constructs and navigates a search space of various attention patterns and
their scaling rules relative to input sequence lengths. It profiles the model,
evaluates potential configurations, and pinpoints the optimal sparse attention
compression plan. MoA adapts to varying input sizes, revealing that some
attention heads expand their focus to accommodate longer sequences, while other
heads consistently concentrate on fixed-length local contexts. Experiments show
that MoA increases the effective context length by $3.9\times$ with the same
average attention span, boosting retrieval accuracy by $1.5-7.1\times$ over the
uniform-attention baseline across Vicuna-7B, Vicuna-13B, and Llama3-8B models.
Moreover, MoA narrows the capability gaps between sparse and dense models,
reducing the maximum relative performance drop from $9\%-36\%$ to within $5\%$
across two long-context understanding benchmarks. MoA achieves a
$1.2-1.4\times$ GPU memory reduction and boosts decode throughput by $5.5-6.7
\times$ for 7B and 13B dense models on a single GPU, with minimal impact on
performance. | [
0.0125565408,
0.0517063141,
0.0037510609,
0.0456193089,
-0.0190462805,
-0.0038483057,
-0.0064031356,
-0.0031665845,
-0.062039014,
-0.0357512385,
-0.0000693776,
-0.0759419128,
0.0331409127,
0.0225898828,
0.0253484882,
-0.0471888818,
0.0243835561,
-0.0465762727,
0.0076983585,
0.021289954,
-0.004940975,
-0.0139907114,
0.0629652888,
0.0394369289,
0.0184588805,
-0.0145346923,
-0.0369434357,
-0.0095574725,
-0.010816115,
-0.0122897867,
-0.0142713068,
0.0719628483,
0.0430051275,
0.0413290486,
0.0000024183,
-0.0196337551,
-0.0125026628,
-0.0116778454,
-0.0280962531,
0.0556467399,
0.0428386033,
-0.0201471113,
-0.0041734995,
-0.0067975274,
0.0036781286,
-0.0254244413,
0.065352574,
0.0081141144,
0.0450607836,
0.0453303196,
-0.003978298,
-0.0305831321,
0.0251030978,
-0.0669010133,
0.0187362954,
-0.0586905703,
0.0269538462,
-0.0212015361,
0.0017940575,
0.0121018775,
-0.0375141688,
0.0432682447,
0.0240091644,
0.0132296355,
0.0052004438,
0.026609404,
-0.0235835519,
-0.0357816629,
0.007650611,
0.0665803328,
-0.0508927479,
-0.0402532518,
-0.0196433421,
0.0174202248,
-0.0050470172,
-0.057135798,
-0.0653540492,
0.0356152803,
-0.001497158,
0.0116512943,
0.0430573523,
0.022116242,
0.0348913334,
-0.0053086388,
-0.0843307823,
-0.0121617597,
0.0190871712,
-0.0213069431,
-0.0424091145,
-0.0145011162,
-0.0248835478,
-0.0452324226,
0.0114515265,
0.0365941636,
-0.0053986884,
0.0101142768,
-0.0601000488,
-0.0508691967,
0.0262674317,
-0.0276052896,
0.0496034324,
0.0847454593,
-0.0432711951,
0.0543408915,
-0.0167418513,
0.0436823331,
-0.0299130511,
-0.0305546131,
-0.0427930616,
0.0061290427,
0.0098120803,
0.0214434285,
-0.0230037309,
0.0211390927,
-0.0595576614,
-0.0296732429,
0.0023798454,
0.0265781097,
0.0010271161,
-0.0059530884,
0.0115046334,
0.0213426203,
-0.0250327773,
-0.0015127936,
0.0373686589,
0.04913323,
-0.0222762991,
-0.0147058051,
0.0159131382,
-0.0638513565,
-0.0449304841,
0.0405071862,
0.001756637,
-0.0311717633,
-0.0006283719,
0.0607541874,
-0.0007926983,
-0.0494525433,
-0.0242789593,
0.0107737286,
-0.001817357,
-0.0491946936,
0.0029065807,
-0.0632816479,
0.0335604809,
-0.0128386086,
0.0054798666,
-0.0235819723,
0.0178938489,
0.0259887557,
-0.0514074527,
0.0361801498,
0.0142734572,
0.009922877,
0.0241164993,
0.0221615974,
0.0312896073,
0.0707425177,
0.0024448256,
0.0428643525,
-0.0004404931,
-0.0087422375,
-0.0300009809,
0.0152834821,
0.0528802462,
0.0342015252,
-0.0325331986,
0.0256051868,
-0.0022523385,
0.0098733883,
0.0931506604,
0.0798738301,
-0.0404726416,
-0.061918892,
0.0355448648,
0.0718850791,
-0.0042304303,
0.0405377783,
0.0366513506,
0.0175598525,
-0.0216633305,
0.0116910515,
-0.0344359092,
0.0449131131,
-0.0321064778,
0.0360549986,
0.1044508144,
0.0438658744,
-0.0238905735,
-0.0084399842,
-0.0200658441,
-0.0014342795,
-0.0022940312,
0.0313357078,
0.0198457204,
-0.0298963767,
-0.0631855577,
0.0571687073,
0.0376556665,
-0.0604719222,
-0.0414536335,
-0.0466756709,
0.0291936547,
0.0491205491,
0.0159671959,
0.0100507876,
-0.0415165126,
-0.0033596135,
0.0070185168,
0.0181397106,
-0.0173399467,
0.022845272,
0.0116322152,
-0.073230058,
0.0149506908,
-0.0251705069,
0.0210638121,
0.0221793633,
0.0297865216,
0.0061323089,
0.0177061073,
-0.007942535,
0.0006032687,
0.0141684385,
-0.0064931773,
-0.0264736619,
-0.0357866175,
0.010171717,
0.0397400297,
0.0007981829,
-0.0048253862,
0.0220275894,
0.0598482229,
-0.0609963574,
0.0481947288,
-0.0369666815,
-0.0764760748,
-0.0127355112,
0.037839815,
0.0225484446,
0.0261916853,
0.0186185297,
-0.0102338502,
-0.0395077355,
0.0310078319,
-0.0543199629,
0.0681082085,
-0.036591962,
0.0096890498,
-0.0015118582,
0.0654313043,
-0.0534153692,
0.0719950572,
-0.0551967956,
0.013663115,
0.0593186505,
0.0036829067,
0.0145106241,
-0.0409463644,
-0.0160895288,
0.0121332975,
-0.0124761257,
-0.0044097072,
-0.0090177078,
-0.0024232247,
-0.0119887618,
-0.010647295,
-0.0684795603,
0.0144144194,
-0.0436708927,
0.012721411,
0.0282712467,
0.0466494709,
-0.0023857539,
0.0099500399,
0.0024074796,
0.0068096635,
-0.0026654461,
0.0191471316,
-0.0387586728,
0.005742453,
-0.0101148915,
-0.0498942509,
-0.0466638096,
0.0171600804,
0.0728753209,
-0.0405011475,
-0.06355533,
-0.036997769,
0.0374711156,
0.0030409356,
0.0128443334,
-0.0147502134,
-0.039514415,
-0.0205733143,
-0.0449678041,
0.0517968982,
0.0900619924,
0.0076549822,
0.0407398976,
0.0850281343,
-0.0145401405,
-0.0176286306,
0.0242492147,
0.0038293041,
-0.028111266,
-0.0182986502,
-0.0309510026,
-0.0135410838,
0.1080453917,
-0.0234439317,
-0.0029958831,
-0.0710324645,
-0.0445574895,
0.0079721408,
-0.0184973944,
-0.0127683971,
0.0037082545,
-0.0261100959,
0.0438570678,
-0.044929374,
-0.0505287834,
0.0428921841,
-0.0616215989,
0.0022377898,
-0.0155619141,
-0.0020667624,
-0.0529797748,
0.0566492341,
-0.0031649522,
0.0241209045,
-0.0345593095,
-0.0260394309,
-0.0049127415,
0.0351615846,
-0.0408080742,
-0.0183010101,
0.0580521971,
-0.0156991277,
0.0183856077,
-0.0420761667,
-0.0024347559,
0.0026327088,
-0.0019872163,
-0.0269324742,
0.0234780032,
0.0502990782,
-0.0057025887,
-0.0441804715,
0.0471775196,
0.0175335165,
0.0545546263,
-0.0119148865,
0.0322237574,
0.0018064409,
0.0249586757,
0.0363955349,
0.0395663641,
0.010060925,
-0.0316308886,
-0.0094289053,
0.0564273298,
0.0303353034,
-0.0085310591,
-0.0294647627,
-0.0098205255,
0.0495037697,
0.0192862134,
-0.0290460698,
0.0386612937,
0.0364842936,
-0.1000228226,
-0.0103250537,
0.0910214186,
0.0073097758,
-0.0946864411,
-0.0064384323,
-0.0382399112,
0.055895716,
0.0205769613,
0.0318744145,
-0.0644426569,
-0.0382947922,
0.0151604405,
0.0109930979,
0.035026703,
-0.0020130803,
-0.0060889153,
-0.0829828158,
0.0189608801,
0.0310803335,
-0.0323477946,
-0.0366865955,
-0.0626890138,
0.0156783015,
0.0089100767,
0.0056456579,
0.0201308969,
-0.0042543453,
-0.0169024654,
0.0045832163,
0.0291898455,
-0.0453118607,
0.0235873237,
0.0219075251,
0.0539271571,
0.0346610211,
-0.0045986758,
0.0353427306,
-0.0291919149,
-0.000763105,
-0.0093222605,
0.0009914865,
-0.0184014104,
0.0205296706,
-0.012016749,
0.0023711275,
0.0003370409,
0.017598087,
-0.0280106757,
-0.0112192379,
-0.0102145728,
0.0981613472,
0.0040426585,
-0.0099990088,
-0.0362873077,
-0.0300993398,
-0.0046524825,
0.080400914,
0.0681830496,
-0.0041492353,
-0.0395474285,
-0.0222476218,
-0.0053579626,
-0.0385737568,
-0.0177164357,
0.0147267813,
0.020151671,
-0.0644494742,
-0.0068744705,
-0.0169043336,
-0.0010887436,
0.0237120837,
-0.0182990655,
0.0208776221,
0.0067815566,
0.005215277,
-0.0895809606,
0.0531079583,
-0.0442198925,
-0.0047335685,
-0.0854752064,
0.0015485053,
-0.0209533703,
-0.0193230473,
0.0080767628,
0.0303993542,
-0.1091487259,
-0.0468376391,
-0.0069868127,
0.0250717178,
0.013804825,
0.0599770918,
-0.0035969082,
-0.062735036,
0.025155168,
-0.0244149398,
-0.0491272472,
0.0635527521,
-0.0023307367,
-0.0438960455,
0.0001215697,
0.0521881655,
-0.0264608525,
-0.0106118647,
-0.0114530716,
0.0498709977,
-0.0103058573,
-0.0330133587,
0.0035867807,
-0.0131396623,
0.0160295125,
-0.0055278181,
0.0062599396,
0.0118548805,
0.0379220657,
0.009695448,
0.0196603797,
-0.0159163158,
-0.0119103035,
0.0324606001,
-0.0146474754,
0.0307320319,
-0.0059677209,
0.0169855356,
0.0025640992,
-0.0380742326,
0.0593919866,
-0.029539302,
-0.0256359763,
0.032549046,
0.0033665313,
-0.036559891,
-0.0434435271,
-0.0335730575,
0.0318965167,
-0.0578790419,
0.0196547303,
-0.0071085771,
-0.0057350569,
-0.0301490817,
0.0445361771,
-0.0364314951,
-0.0313188061,
-0.0169514399,
-0.001144669,
0.0647486672,
-0.0423681252,
0.0429049209,
0.0220299829,
-0.0085422089,
-0.0390777998,
0.0052800621,
-0.0083856732,
-0.0308588184,
0.0073696766,
0.0410693139,
0.0008309749,
0.0235164706,
0.0861239657,
0.0317625962,
0.0203461368,
0.0241179671,
-0.0011225606,
-0.016467575,
-0.0234036334,
-0.0142765464,
0.0639817789,
-0.033683192,
0.0064096125,
-0.0233315192,
-0.0595206618,
-0.0118255476,
-0.0304854307,
-0.0387428179,
-0.0068507805,
0.0157696195,
0.0445812754,
0.0019161685,
-0.0060288412,
-0.0064690239,
0.032731466,
-0.0098805213,
-0.0208301954,
0.0116185993,
-7.392111654e-33,
-0.0162679013,
0.0082155596,
0.0179487877,
-0.0693773627,
-0.0369423106,
0.0207630619,
-0.0640846416,
-0.0093476214,
-0.018936852,
-0.0189174134,
-0.0381277874,
0.0010763778,
-0.0007164324,
0.0371515676,
-0.0048798313,
0.0116031049,
0.0360491946,
0.0235503092,
-0.0132353129,
0.0441847779,
0.0146626439,
0.0336807221,
0.0272977464,
-0.0203268044,
-0.0251035038,
0.0110996142,
0.0421542935,
-0.0039710044,
-0.0018211593,
0.0612388924,
-0.0460971706,
0.0209609773,
0.0230797995,
-0.0302761532,
-0.0372262113,
0.0249861199,
-0.0728935003,
-0.0056965523,
0.0455885567,
-0.0359296165,
-0.015946487,
-0.0786592066,
0.0161218867,
0.0371314213,
0.0484886169,
-0.0467534475,
-0.0164421909,
-0.0315262824,
-0.0761505291,
0.0070467251,
-0.0571274571,
0.0282465853,
-0.014071377,
0.0075735212,
0.0627558604,
0.0034031733,
-0.0207690708,
0.0467036851,
-0.0357922949,
0.0017538456,
0.0031671941,
0.0851036534,
0.0857288018,
0.0294698142,
0.0173241664,
0.0230214633,
-0.0123528214,
0.0026298983,
-0.0550860651,
-0.0024372227,
0.0207463074,
0.0183477122,
-0.0022402965,
-0.0043281117,
0.0425761044,
-0.0255120937,
-0.0623080432,
-0.0256288834,
0.0049109776,
0.0785745606,
0.0697231516,
0.0453158319,
-0.0219216887,
-0.0299090501,
-0.0192700922,
0.0093041165,
-0.048685316,
-0.0108741429,
0.0330087915,
0.031289801,
-0.0219180267,
-0.0261028074,
0.0661943927,
-0.0260204058,
0.035601154,
0.0475792401,
0.0060288571,
0.0085231736,
0.0205055438,
0.0420277156,
-0.0577537492,
0.0114102438,
0.0147174103,
-0.038827952,
-0.0082597611,
-0.006333346,
0.0074974331,
0.022303788,
-0.0450849123,
-0.0319127403,
-0.0472662374,
-0.0223635882,
0.0011757564,
0.0339401551,
0.045151785,
0.0194145646,
0.0152563369,
0.0678763539,
-0.0142998593,
0.0201019328,
-0.0140831312,
-0.0245624781,
0.0070999088,
0.0193084516,
-0.0429177359,
0.0110005271,
-0.0742873102,
0.0443327837,
0.0479327291,
-0.0381942764,
-0.0332949422,
0.0588469096,
2.986e-7,
0.0099101216,
0.0409832373,
-0.0123104602,
-0.0221129339,
0.0022579152,
0.0005296477,
0.0103010023,
0.0023742542,
-0.0004581767,
-0.0342067741,
-0.0155960387,
0.0346437171,
0.0266424455,
-0.0089973798,
-0.0859998241,
-0.0174255669,
-0.019544933,
-0.0122555541,
-0.0402942784,
-0.0290610231,
0.0172994677,
0.1580627561,
-0.0201849826,
0.0072616939,
0.0424780659,
0.0099615734,
0.0271422993,
-0.0214573741,
-0.0091026714,
0.0062599326,
0.0198879372,
0.0051668487,
-0.0272429641,
-0.0299042929,
0.0107480939,
0.0192792602,
-0.0236454848,
0.0875052586,
-0.0160602052,
-0.0300628748,
0.0301919952,
-0.0134404683,
-0.034301661,
-0.0675031692,
0.0474522188,
-0.001529682,
-0.0267876945,
-0.0373932421,
0.0026674431,
0.0143869231,
-0.0261927992,
0.0017771827,
0.0428695641,
0.0037043041,
0.0066898963,
-0.0357346088,
-0.0075023696,
-0.0824907944,
-0.0283724219,
-0.0117040155,
-0.0502145253,
-0.0010311574,
-0.0881260335,
-0.0226400476,
0.056134969,
-0.0380625501,
0.0126428353,
3.266541533e-34,
0.0349830575,
-0.0123412963,
0.0179216452,
0.0269929599,
0.0072984262,
-0.0599082895,
-0.0252533946,
0.0376778319,
-0.0201787818,
-0.1171924025,
-0.0317703336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14898v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14898v2 | Safely Learning with Private Data: A Federated Learning Framework for Large Language Model | 2024-06-21T06:43:15 | 2024-06-26T04:28:38 | JiaYing Zheng, HaiNan Zhang, LingXiang Wang, WangJie Qiu, HongWei Zheng, ZhiMing Zheng | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | Private data, being larger and quality-higher than public data, can greatly
improve large language models (LLM). However, due to privacy concerns, this
data is often dispersed in multiple silos, making its secure utilization for
LLM training a challenge. Federated learning (FL) is an ideal solution for
training models with distributed private data, but traditional frameworks like
FedAvg are unsuitable for LLM due to their high computational demands on
clients. An alternative, split learning, offloads most training parameters to
the server while training embedding and output layers locally, making it more
suitable for LLM. Nonetheless, it faces significant challenges in security and
efficiency. Firstly, the gradients of embeddings are prone to attacks, leading
to potential reverse engineering of private data. Furthermore, the server's
limitation of handle only one client's training request at a time hinders
parallel training, severely impacting training efficiency. In this paper, we
propose a Federated Learning framework for LLM, named FL-GLM, which prevents
data leakage caused by both server-side and peer-client attacks while improving
training efficiency. Specifically, we first place the input block and output
block on local client to prevent embedding gradient attacks from server.
Secondly, we employ key-encryption during client-server communication to
prevent reverse engineering attacks from peer-clients. Lastly, we employ
optimization methods like client-batching or server-hierarchical, adopting
different acceleration methods based on the actual computational capabilities
of the server. Experimental results on NLU and generation tasks demonstrate
that FL-GLM achieves comparable metrics to centralized chatGLM model,
validating the effectiveness of our federated learning framework. | [
0.0324679725,
0.0953148976,
-0.0043245843,
0.0717038289,
-0.0601363145,
-0.0220936444,
0.1055789739,
-0.0229927022,
0.0308279693,
-0.0237816181,
-0.0411673859,
-0.0515630096,
0.0037502067,
0.0176053513,
0.0402428992,
0.002323901,
0.0361920148,
-0.0291721299,
-0.0162315518,
-0.0509643219,
-0.0332742631,
0.0004239019,
0.0329359621,
0.0075575346,
0.0306585822,
-0.0509682409,
-0.0304903742,
-0.0005631321,
0.0029566144,
0.002971214,
0.0137257772,
0.0339244045,
0.0196778867,
0.093750529,
0.0000021861,
0.0068253614,
-0.0730814859,
0.0342816189,
-0.0456832387,
0.0846993029,
0.0039397716,
-0.0135969734,
-0.0008657446,
0.0383084118,
-0.0438397974,
-0.0177850705,
0.015526507,
0.0315979533,
0.0803050846,
0.0924526975,
0.0149901928,
-0.0531731956,
-0.0031709932,
-0.0425596237,
-0.1039548591,
-0.0497574173,
0.0060678422,
-0.0478602499,
-0.0350768082,
0.029199414,
-0.0285170842,
0.023612991,
0.0283688977,
0.0295263436,
0.0008362817,
0.0128796473,
-0.0377520248,
-0.032234069,
-0.0474903248,
0.0324185193,
-0.0155108999,
0.0059502996,
0.0041421545,
-0.0048843408,
-0.0023088537,
0.0123095391,
-0.0048374189,
0.059173122,
0.0033065225,
0.015646508,
0.0054419744,
-0.0263239723,
0.0346863605,
-0.0050725038,
0.0556558184,
0.0625045747,
0.0030612494,
0.003089936,
-0.056484215,
-0.0379436985,
-0.0152355991,
-0.0459079891,
0.0550355986,
0.0062821466,
0.0246324483,
0.0078067309,
-0.0714649186,
-0.0634820312,
0.0190979578,
-0.0177432671,
0.0223974325,
-0.0435250066,
0.0261775777,
0.0201571416,
-0.0089894477,
0.0096547194,
-0.0160316136,
0.0348950773,
0.0227662176,
0.0281566791,
-0.0297738742,
-0.0041061747,
-0.005862562,
0.0669240579,
-0.0620120876,
-0.0086336229,
-0.0188803561,
0.0202565677,
-0.0306596272,
0.0369576514,
0.0134802787,
0.0135210231,
-0.0013311009,
-0.0148646394,
0.0534220934,
-0.0144685954,
-0.0117641166,
-0.0051950021,
0.0285974927,
-0.0722296014,
0.0022964887,
-0.0141645884,
-0.0071476074,
0.0213722251,
-0.0215570461,
0.0459902659,
0.0143336644,
-0.0012747756,
-0.026073467,
-0.0996060073,
0.0378465168,
-0.0456841253,
0.0107705081,
-0.0623364449,
-0.0020193604,
-0.0287665073,
-0.0055317944,
-0.0443022735,
-0.0017148126,
0.0079432772,
-0.0352424271,
0.0505718403,
-0.0252543949,
-0.019248439,
0.0155921504,
0.0353787616,
-0.0347102024,
0.0480784103,
0.0007120114,
0.0284304805,
0.0801802874,
-0.016477285,
0.0179563351,
0.0046762084,
0.069549337,
0.0139939319,
-0.021287322,
0.0077409702,
-0.0085491957,
0.0043285647,
-0.034467496,
0.0579918735,
-0.0073614144,
-0.0691195652,
0.0732170865,
0.0711264983,
0.014166004,
0.0326972306,
-0.0530033298,
0.0595428571,
0.0025344857,
0.0040309541,
-0.0274492111,
-0.0064582173,
-0.0228633136,
-0.0264641251,
0.0057273386,
0.0769081637,
-0.0036890723,
0.0023570159,
0.0121814376,
-0.0730117634,
-0.0083838096,
0.0125066927,
0.0137148472,
0.0058800597,
-0.0118489601,
0.0304970928,
0.0109614739,
-0.0389443673,
-0.0099938791,
-0.0347333215,
-0.0107931448,
0.0564813539,
0.0609069876,
0.0356276892,
-0.0061712973,
-0.0483175516,
-0.0028772063,
0.0341699123,
-0.0170873795,
0.0187880546,
0.0656542182,
-0.0456237942,
-0.0483623929,
0.0333812833,
0.005160037,
0.0034509446,
-0.0054664151,
-0.0000168609,
0.0107548516,
0.0090814121,
-0.0044763177,
0.022372568,
-0.0143485377,
-0.0189696923,
0.0303058047,
0.0187064335,
0.0380799957,
0.0065759015,
-0.0126746474,
0.0136759663,
0.0171177015,
0.0155319907,
-0.0392955728,
-0.0345634408,
0.0072747972,
-0.0258839224,
-0.0150142815,
-0.0005813382,
0.0253276043,
0.0555402711,
-0.0433470458,
-0.0070483484,
0.016091289,
-0.0174609683,
0.0566304401,
-0.0230473261,
0.0118706208,
-0.004181481,
0.0318116397,
-0.0224818792,
0.0087723434,
-0.0491767041,
-0.0353858285,
-0.0641812086,
-0.0057349731,
0.0278083272,
-0.031243572,
0.0248491317,
0.0109461695,
0.0087360879,
0.014269813,
-0.0137153659,
0.0084787793,
-0.0144707495,
0.0366038308,
-0.0086302981,
0.0028933682,
-0.0348402821,
0.048708491,
0.005232607,
-0.0013249527,
-0.0222691335,
-0.0568366535,
-0.028356377,
0.0269202739,
-0.0580614991,
0.0193487946,
-0.0041704648,
-0.0030474537,
-0.042009294,
0.0198998377,
-0.0242041294,
0.0306788534,
0.0579085648,
-0.0491617061,
0.0054713511,
-0.0322508924,
0.0065966952,
-0.0359875858,
0.0357004441,
0.0191997625,
-0.0311549827,
-0.0073778275,
0.0327433385,
-0.0259532686,
0.0600275658,
0.0246072151,
-0.0079058819,
0.0361218825,
-0.0041623428,
-0.0295736548,
-0.0079242811,
-0.0231857542,
-0.0152578019,
-0.032376606,
0.036954537,
0.0211840253,
0.0291220676,
0.0136585673,
-0.0536954366,
-0.0119872242,
0.0384001471,
-0.0105115734,
-0.0317036696,
-0.0563403517,
0.0056285784,
-0.0027372497,
0.0063445331,
0.0177787859,
-0.0717138499,
0.0648594499,
-0.0370794386,
0.0121796699,
-0.032655634,
-0.0651065186,
-0.0335566513,
0.0530711003,
-0.0224878453,
0.0565081947,
-0.0087772803,
-0.0463144518,
-0.0058246651,
0.0380586199,
0.0352656953,
-0.0343855284,
-0.0299455971,
0.0100918273,
-0.0371292233,
-0.0014144066,
-0.0474532396,
-0.0307159889,
-0.0744098723,
-0.0300366767,
-0.0044659832,
-0.0174607951,
-0.0235903747,
0.023184821,
-0.0007537428,
-0.0025867161,
0.0066788411,
-0.0264803059,
0.035970863,
-0.0202191435,
-0.0010162808,
0.0035911775,
-0.0727305412,
-0.0113152657,
-0.0270374604,
0.0064986413,
0.090975672,
0.0690287799,
-0.0123801026,
0.0108072208,
-0.0465803184,
0.0088825291,
-0.0152661614,
-0.0221226476,
-0.0079254033,
0.0326928459,
-0.054055512,
0.0089804642,
0.0626683086,
0.0028913664,
-0.0430848449,
-0.0125370873,
0.0010746903,
0.0411511064,
-0.0220471807,
0.0075978828,
-0.0647686273,
-0.0018541312,
0.0388620384,
0.0519020259,
0.0108274091,
-0.0103627695,
-0.0344184525,
-0.1170473471,
0.0228368007,
0.0245816894,
0.0166902915,
-0.0331688374,
-0.0675623789,
-0.0256322175,
0.0407312214,
0.0060621169,
-0.0169656407,
0.0189693905,
-0.0060023433,
0.0180994403,
-0.0215674266,
-0.0509134941,
-0.0228110254,
-0.0463059731,
0.0623703748,
0.0059642107,
-0.0011892895,
0.0051567145,
-0.0583118312,
0.0135827111,
0.0783648416,
-0.0362692699,
-0.0033392934,
0.0143639417,
-0.0176100358,
-0.0182172544,
0.0154480916,
0.0315956026,
0.016334394,
-0.0074441796,
0.0451127216,
0.060553126,
-0.0144565264,
0.0013418086,
0.0007642632,
0.0069300197,
0.0440531,
0.0532839783,
0.0117215421,
-0.0225345772,
-0.0111700213,
-0.0062086061,
0.0240011383,
0.0126701361,
0.014194198,
0.0481116511,
0.0029717523,
-0.0010249958,
-0.0368076675,
0.016238505,
-0.0286677144,
0.0303743426,
0.0179018565,
0.0401706025,
0.0448265672,
-0.001228102,
-0.0447804928,
-0.0071808351,
-0.0614308901,
0.0276197456,
-0.0520847701,
-0.0273384582,
0.0131304413,
0.0019496949,
-0.0394949839,
0.0253007095,
-0.088775821,
-0.0730807558,
0.0114232767,
0.030056417,
0.0125883762,
0.0145117594,
-0.0170387682,
-0.0589363798,
0.0916597024,
0.0413354002,
-0.0972690284,
0.0164738074,
0.0557441749,
-0.0820937008,
0.0263915062,
0.0542133227,
-0.0272411276,
-0.0252107661,
0.0446767099,
-0.0287030339,
0.0034195867,
-0.0244981758,
-0.0508795679,
0.0459244326,
0.0479564667,
-0.0050808112,
0.0170001257,
-0.0371390805,
0.0633135363,
-0.0459283479,
0.0074955625,
-0.0277683213,
-0.0044360948,
0.0288744066,
-0.0143090598,
0.0224977583,
-0.0106435437,
0.0837049112,
-0.0131178433,
-0.016661888,
0.0371907875,
0.0081396438,
-0.0342634916,
0.0368144028,
0.0215003137,
-0.0133376885,
0.0174237862,
0.0286873281,
0.0282602441,
-0.0152351754,
0.0235699173,
-0.0138513045,
0.0115950396,
-0.0250596516,
0.049373962,
-0.0576099455,
-0.1099808812,
-0.0078216624,
0.0333234333,
0.0171578359,
0.0438130237,
-0.0040886095,
-0.0275247451,
-0.0074894684,
-0.0326015018,
-0.001346849,
-0.0558566824,
-0.070128642,
0.0096279467,
-0.0117309755,
-0.0117078889,
0.0698708072,
0.0999241918,
0.0538142547,
0.0150445327,
-0.0131059084,
-0.0111387558,
-0.0633513629,
-0.0035927186,
0.0363483168,
0.0388375558,
-0.037903592,
0.005277276,
0.0006310423,
-0.0838868842,
-0.0249621719,
-0.0127896983,
0.0101521108,
0.0209784862,
0.0091411835,
0.0181922764,
0.004440845,
-0.0160503853,
-0.1152533889,
0.0515047833,
0.0231538583,
-0.0080881771,
0.0147049483,
-6.02861792e-33,
0.0108690411,
-0.023872992,
-0.0118400306,
0.0555103458,
0.0168472063,
0.0642892122,
0.00700614,
-0.0141038289,
0.0338074528,
-0.0099232038,
-0.042598363,
0.0256916266,
0.0209784433,
0.0668573752,
-0.0242181197,
-0.0269948188,
0.028206626,
-0.0499323271,
-0.0045841159,
0.0378991365,
0.0547136031,
0.0503423698,
0.0429276116,
-0.065384984,
-0.0018392563,
-0.0319627188,
-0.0264127851,
0.0133409742,
-0.0530531928,
0.0313681103,
-0.0297209378,
-0.004290781,
-0.0041321912,
-0.0453173257,
-0.022369992,
0.0029025264,
-0.0050311596,
0.0089085819,
-0.0389790721,
0.0216844361,
-0.047585763,
-0.0320425071,
0.0418119095,
-0.0206445958,
0.0178553276,
-0.0089280652,
-0.0196942277,
0.0213431455,
-0.0366900265,
-0.0227444209,
0.0189384036,
0.0092140576,
0.0212158747,
0.0073115211,
0.0617124103,
0.0014181274,
-0.0006879505,
-0.0452069379,
-0.0445218869,
0.0159062762,
0.0125083402,
-0.0010681791,
0.0384417586,
0.0166408885,
0.0009906243,
0.0352584794,
0.0751888081,
-0.0025863172,
-0.019597223,
0.0089426348,
0.004789032,
0.0494420417,
0.0061288783,
0.0297884122,
0.0277006198,
-0.0416553915,
-0.0430589058,
-0.0197208989,
0.0371083096,
-0.0367163084,
0.0423653051,
0.033893615,
-0.026899796,
-0.0129509047,
-0.0286617652,
-0.023084227,
-0.0164881032,
0.0144651728,
-0.0006925351,
0.0421380028,
-0.0306744017,
-0.0404725857,
0.0361224152,
-0.0554311536,
-0.0104068713,
0.0257655419,
0.0802157149,
-0.0204239059,
0.0183619205,
0.0178697202,
-0.0483576804,
-0.0003080291,
-0.0366185941,
-0.0655097216,
0.0072251777,
0.0005973201,
0.075686425,
0.0205902513,
-0.0585967191,
-0.0130517511,
-0.0315752365,
0.0219125543,
0.0302334968,
0.0391281955,
0.060751494,
-0.0441300906,
0.0136016933,
0.0150889056,
0.0328470543,
0.0589346327,
-0.0148835834,
-0.0035941962,
-0.0204641279,
-0.0122833317,
0.0189259946,
-0.0000326405,
-0.01922144,
0.0278434698,
0.0680578426,
-0.0174701549,
0.0309561491,
-0.043886587,
2.914e-7,
-0.0168653466,
0.0166195557,
-0.0120105268,
-0.0288918149,
0.0441288687,
0.0456091575,
-0.0135447532,
0.0664230809,
-0.0154712312,
0.0252686217,
-0.0298794676,
-0.0112287905,
0.0638007969,
0.0151237408,
-0.0639663488,
-0.0111309486,
-0.0678310767,
0.0383378007,
-0.0475402921,
-0.0397817716,
-0.0201583896,
0.0977170393,
0.0519035049,
-0.038074512,
0.0048133479,
-0.0286675543,
0.0275342353,
-0.0265107937,
-0.0428149924,
-0.0398086123,
0.0429254882,
0.1278426796,
0.0049784267,
-0.0158395208,
-0.036237739,
0.0269627776,
-0.0499976017,
0.0715486705,
0.0272859335,
0.0099084247,
0.0043715057,
-0.047091987,
-0.0518402942,
0.0136050442,
0.0452916138,
0.0160197057,
-0.0325359516,
-0.0146441543,
0.0323743857,
-0.0728883892,
0.0406217948,
-0.0154396594,
0.0005341715,
0.0213314816,
0.0049033384,
-0.0411575623,
-0.0026329847,
-0.0654587448,
-0.026383834,
-0.0594166666,
-0.0420145877,
-0.0147451488,
-0.0139155099,
0.0390473865,
0.00688816,
0.0086340103,
0.0171892382,
2.781113794e-34,
0.006667797,
-0.0448078997,
-0.0015182879,
0.0307588186,
0.0182563439,
-0.0273490716,
0.0118884956,
0.0046539041,
-0.0039387783,
-0.0206603389,
-0.0238195825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14894v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14894v1 | Talking the Talk Does Not Entail Walking the Walk: On the Limits of Large Language Models in Lexical Entailment Recognition | 2024-06-21T06:30:16 | 2024-06-21T06:30:16 | Candida M. Greco, Lucio La Cava, Andrea Tagarelli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.IR, physics.soc-ph | Verbs form the backbone of language, providing the structure and meaning to
sentences. Yet, their intricate semantic nuances pose a longstanding challenge.
Understanding verb relations through the concept of lexical entailment is
crucial for comprehending sentence meanings and grasping verb dynamics. This
work investigates the capabilities of eight Large Language Models in
recognizing lexical entailment relations among verbs through differently
devised prompting strategies and zero-/few-shot settings over verb pairs from
two lexical databases, namely WordNet and HyperLex. Our findings unveil that
the models can tackle the lexical entailment recognition task with moderately
good performance, although at varying degree of effectiveness and under
different conditions. Also, utilizing few-shot prompting can enhance the
models' performance. However, perfectly solving the task arises as an unmet
challenge for all examined LLMs, which raises an emergence for further research
developments on this topic. | [
0.0366609879,
0.0163792409,
-0.021170117,
0.1000169441,
-0.0622194074,
0.0479887947,
-0.0302836355,
0.0324086398,
0.005431585,
-0.0768132955,
-0.0166773759,
-0.0189427994,
-0.0253692437,
0.0023129561,
-0.0043423907,
0.0333764777,
0.063799426,
-0.0030637588,
-0.0202564653,
0.0079928152,
0.0168423988,
0.0325677693,
-0.0055554514,
0.0080314167,
0.0136956247,
0.0148284426,
0.0442687348,
0.0199154615,
0.0334337875,
-0.0221223999,
-0.0347509533,
0.0183595456,
0.0273966696,
0.0243684854,
0.0000015959,
-0.0941184908,
-0.0059715938,
-0.0536351986,
-0.0385403223,
-0.0221355669,
0.0281478763,
-0.0417539738,
0.0397328287,
-0.0270578191,
-0.0268078502,
0.0305315498,
0.0142912697,
0.0307933297,
0.018827077,
0.0478659272,
-0.0068733478,
0.0026590677,
0.0262210481,
0.0081936549,
-0.0067827515,
0.0145611633,
0.0306201223,
0.0041072643,
0.0003625047,
-0.0174040124,
-0.0415062793,
0.046984043,
0.0005881051,
0.0048879841,
-0.0336826481,
0.0257760566,
-0.0254294649,
-0.0180476569,
0.0112332115,
0.0512764789,
-0.0298362672,
-0.024802817,
0.024631219,
-0.0348063558,
-0.0256434716,
0.0636320934,
-0.0332802907,
0.066009827,
-0.0095822057,
0.0196694341,
0.0289490782,
-0.0450106785,
0.031209724,
0.0294406153,
-0.0086664734,
0.0844070241,
0.0193719789,
-0.0191947594,
0.0085079912,
0.0106514161,
-0.0114878621,
-0.0409765579,
-0.0254087448,
0.0083680302,
0.0004813455,
0.0560489371,
-0.0057504331,
-0.0224319454,
0.0106526623,
-0.0550296456,
0.0128678596,
0.0233054385,
-0.0077834958,
0.0610007383,
-0.0814386159,
0.0240812544,
-0.0001792341,
0.0058350577,
-0.0540412255,
-0.0237618219,
-0.028159732,
-0.000239545,
-0.0248623062,
0.0180875137,
-0.0407923274,
-0.0612106696,
-0.0287114587,
0.0128350751,
0.0103246579,
0.0074570468,
-0.041584637,
-0.0370587893,
-0.004369949,
-0.0155526353,
-0.036477048,
0.011347698,
-0.0116645172,
0.0673492178,
-0.039691031,
-0.0416030735,
-0.0334698334,
0.0297066644,
0.0444783866,
-0.0441086106,
0.0256619304,
0.049504634,
0.040915627,
-0.058828529,
-0.0176813155,
-0.0468686447,
-0.0278891549,
-0.0543141887,
0.0052421512,
-0.0538677275,
0.0245980546,
-0.0008035423,
0.009070971,
0.0012261993,
0.0367962755,
0.018703049,
-0.032378871,
0.0720389634,
0.0260233711,
0.018075956,
-0.0303556491,
-0.0176622346,
-0.0184286498,
0.04436481,
0.0152194733,
0.0015136041,
0.0417327136,
0.0261705294,
0.0071620597,
0.0288365036,
0.0021263924,
0.0335215665,
-0.0576909594,
-0.0033600512,
0.0705934241,
0.0247322414,
-0.0153066656,
0.0319585539,
-0.0361927077,
0.002716955,
0.0544439517,
0.0871555954,
-0.017201487,
-0.076541394,
0.078072302,
-0.0346875042,
0.0051568197,
-0.0128802005,
-0.0640736818,
-0.0039883032,
-0.0686318651,
-0.0151916286,
-0.0431969278,
0.0249055307,
0.0025044724,
-0.0169272292,
-0.058512345,
-0.0190155394,
0.0058510276,
0.0060548754,
0.0656122789,
0.0265676137,
-0.0122884586,
0.0143752834,
0.0497439057,
-0.0443969928,
-0.0074836221,
-0.0374875441,
0.0341223404,
0.039097257,
0.0462841429,
0.016055014,
-0.0321830995,
-0.0144108953,
0.0191786829,
0.0398142561,
-0.017111605,
-0.0014469678,
0.0026643553,
-0.0346175916,
-0.0156052178,
0.0061325207,
0.0204344727,
-0.0168499034,
-0.0154274562,
0.0112096965,
0.0201176144,
-0.0410153717,
-0.0049291924,
0.0531273745,
-0.0356541872,
-0.0103824222,
0.0102132121,
0.02344211,
0.0237757806,
-0.0099421265,
0.0029200315,
0.0087726023,
0.0247304533,
-0.055703003,
-0.0565581657,
0.000833348,
-0.0096075721,
-0.1004991308,
0.0191507433,
-0.0028325643,
-0.0268860646,
0.0151724881,
-0.019658871,
-0.0391429514,
-0.0074246568,
-0.0091918176,
0.0511434041,
-0.0435409546,
0.0023228289,
0.0217827503,
0.019351095,
-0.03485699,
0.0699007511,
0.0085581895,
0.0550919548,
-0.0197374728,
-0.0272808746,
0.0169237014,
0.0123549458,
-0.041119948,
0.0048967884,
-0.0049649435,
-0.0331522115,
0.0164469369,
-0.0078217862,
-0.0504350364,
-0.0005069246,
-0.0722185075,
0.0353621431,
-0.0093693063,
0.0180598311,
0.0147860292,
0.0058419704,
-0.0126182521,
-0.0284966677,
-0.0157204643,
0.0354568884,
0.028037088,
0.0201251041,
0.0293448176,
-0.0170769878,
-0.0560052544,
-0.0356606208,
-0.0103736296,
-0.0498345084,
0.0601334162,
-0.0016471556,
-0.0195143819,
0.017752111,
0.017941488,
-0.0564469025,
-0.0091870911,
0.0007526639,
-0.0163505208,
-0.0296500344,
-0.005103189,
0.0158203132,
0.0638129264,
-0.0350729972,
0.0136336936,
0.0703723133,
-0.0129477847,
-0.0404432602,
-0.0177823603,
-0.0392130464,
-0.0206504613,
-0.0149679007,
0.0097843604,
-0.0027231867,
0.0620209053,
0.0360941514,
-0.0004591586,
0.0088403178,
-0.0094435364,
-0.0136571452,
0.0011974993,
-0.0398900993,
-0.0276519377,
-0.0260280892,
0.0511772148,
-0.0273666959,
-0.0405184664,
0.028346749,
-0.0011254519,
0.0057311067,
-0.0356742889,
-0.0476869531,
-0.032797005,
0.076806657,
0.0377968475,
0.0413699672,
0.0364185348,
-0.0109935161,
-0.0250248481,
-0.0538237728,
0.0377698392,
-0.0210140795,
0.0827673525,
-0.0549167432,
0.0366914086,
-0.0226415284,
0.007215322,
-0.0300112013,
-0.078771621,
-0.0435199402,
-0.0155126266,
-0.0511504821,
0.0067089922,
0.0432118438,
-0.0102239437,
0.0168561749,
0.0142342877,
0.0077674342,
-0.0165967196,
-0.0466528833,
0.0579135828,
0.0712570474,
-0.030895995,
0.0068090977,
-0.0227679536,
0.0271864533,
0.0122292591,
-0.012170596,
0.02941438,
-0.027492879,
0.0118812285,
0.0304810163,
-0.0319954865,
-0.0141034843,
0.0085820872,
0.0203606207,
-0.0429269895,
0.0086563788,
0.1111369357,
0.0364436172,
-0.0066272216,
0.0328135602,
-0.0237659439,
0.0172399636,
0.0321547128,
-0.0175575633,
-0.0759124756,
-0.0604965203,
0.0140797412,
-0.047883939,
-0.0042327452,
-0.0334791504,
-0.0046719988,
-0.123446174,
0.0427320227,
-0.0210142042,
-0.0140058165,
0.0057311645,
-0.040556509,
0.0278948471,
-0.0027978404,
-0.0132449158,
-0.0293563958,
-0.0225324351,
-0.019859314,
-0.014505717,
0.0287309475,
-0.0399098434,
0.063719973,
-0.0549404621,
0.0398519337,
0.031210022,
0.0626248643,
-0.0033632105,
-0.0096767684,
0.0220683757,
-0.0100172469,
-0.0291964542,
-0.0166186467,
0.0317511,
-0.0191343334,
0.0058477321,
0.0051476029,
0.0436242297,
-0.0666860864,
-0.0301674791,
0.0126454132,
0.0924807489,
-0.0355797894,
-0.018683672,
-0.0176468976,
-0.0124175735,
-0.0176832285,
0.0908497944,
0.0206492003,
-0.003399557,
0.0118125826,
0.0035307282,
-0.0682617724,
0.0154357459,
-0.035219714,
-0.0240168516,
-0.0287780389,
0.0288301539,
-0.0621229187,
-0.0350441784,
0.0276581552,
0.0120584778,
0.0025324116,
0.0575187355,
0.0280979052,
-0.0140906563,
-0.0081313755,
0.0271759424,
-0.0541411042,
0.0430189818,
0.0260795895,
0.0366353057,
0.0719231814,
0.0221355204,
-0.0359340683,
0.0364038199,
-0.0791460946,
-0.0328204297,
-0.0661911666,
0.0107214022,
0.0192492884,
0.036946509,
-0.0227758121,
0.0402259789,
-0.0227342807,
0.0205643885,
-0.0116300033,
0.0399699919,
0.0066990806,
0.0141168637,
0.0033848546,
0.0720643848,
-0.0300024524,
0.0344708785,
0.0392697826,
0.0371022113,
-0.0407102816,
-0.0592446141,
0.0428355411,
0.0020485604,
0.0582092106,
0.0036739004,
-0.0117684267,
-0.0465579182,
-0.0045344518,
-0.024859244,
-0.0311086569,
-0.0205562655,
0.034493681,
0.0698501989,
0.0181438476,
-0.0416313969,
-0.0031285193,
0.0114104254,
0.029617181,
-0.0033982908,
-0.0187042952,
0.0288920943,
-0.0350961797,
0.0017322204,
-0.0049798605,
-0.0203771107,
0.0317107476,
-0.0149126621,
-0.0008251902,
-0.0201389287,
0.0325249583,
0.0260396358,
-0.0043478385,
-0.0256686676,
-0.0080489088,
-0.0491294526,
-0.0119583439,
0.0194974262,
0.0083796671,
0.0547526479,
-0.0522155277,
0.0332244486,
-0.0378060974,
0.0110439453,
-0.0135875819,
0.036828164,
-0.0310420822,
-0.0221248008,
0.0676384196,
0.0177894142,
-0.0414671712,
0.0196512099,
0.0254162997,
-0.0508230887,
0.0841031447,
0.0667472854,
-0.0032788888,
-0.0303923842,
-0.0325296223,
0.0665252432,
0.0111154327,
0.0002018875,
0.0559649803,
-0.0666071102,
-0.0654430464,
0.026116902,
-0.0145486621,
-0.0141631737,
-0.0297152773,
0.0290639196,
0.0293846373,
0.0447680354,
-0.0196323097,
-0.0478399992,
-0.0033667486,
-0.062873818,
-0.0063462523,
-0.0417165011,
-5.940719962e-33,
-0.039525453,
-0.0318251774,
0.0090099871,
-0.0048680068,
0.0120464545,
0.015064219,
-0.038914118,
-0.0271373354,
-0.036650613,
0.0319382139,
0.0339534916,
0.0233871751,
-0.0034483315,
0.0087681701,
0.0546178184,
-0.0143727046,
0.0055819545,
0.0040896269,
-0.0180530176,
-0.0048247501,
0.0689852834,
0.0004725528,
0.0571213402,
-0.0280562602,
-0.0058671627,
-0.0040611983,
0.0002367701,
0.0535003804,
-0.0342083089,
0.0556994416,
-0.0595204644,
0.0330771059,
0.0182426535,
-0.047168199,
-0.0091887778,
0.0512813441,
-0.058693707,
-0.0457356162,
0.0545791313,
-0.0403491519,
-0.0414580926,
-0.0084019136,
0.0362045094,
-0.0111707468,
-0.0243391655,
0.0095014768,
0.0472931154,
-0.010849203,
-0.0176031534,
-0.0535278134,
-0.08656995,
0.0258404519,
-0.0064948373,
-0.0288153235,
-0.0053298776,
0.027255822,
0.0036720948,
0.0092030447,
-0.0320880599,
0.001983626,
-0.0079487879,
0.0211809501,
0.0525024757,
0.0079417434,
-0.0021519898,
0.0885852054,
-0.0393771417,
-0.0495728143,
0.0160258692,
0.0462514237,
0.0393191017,
0.0608899258,
0.010991659,
0.0497835055,
0.0284384973,
0.0316600017,
-0.0624621287,
-0.0254081674,
0.0238968879,
0.0343302302,
0.0090150088,
-0.0206251126,
-0.0319912806,
-0.0173531789,
-0.0534248278,
0.011473651,
-0.0302950814,
-0.010482992,
0.0548886284,
-0.0306102149,
0.0287234392,
0.0014928714,
0.0466290414,
-0.0613100603,
-0.0124720465,
0.0459432937,
-0.0089914994,
0.0019192238,
0.036766436,
0.0411794223,
-0.0562417358,
-0.0428979471,
-0.0162695013,
0.004614389,
0.0121347886,
0.0255072303,
0.0479728021,
-0.0194675997,
-0.0300247986,
-0.007210522,
-0.0417056829,
-0.0380653478,
-0.0404184982,
0.0088009117,
0.046545174,
0.0310220979,
0.0069773495,
0.0534440279,
-0.0019517348,
-0.0604461655,
-0.0226487312,
-0.0046279184,
-0.0247740224,
0.0212175511,
-0.0392073765,
-0.0087272432,
-0.0256662071,
0.0318903215,
0.0603378788,
-0.0345245861,
0.011878198,
0.0164461229,
2.574e-7,
0.0558512546,
0.0386050716,
-0.0166513547,
0.0405789055,
-0.0206411853,
0.0408720002,
-0.0289367605,
0.0434583202,
-0.0171862878,
-0.0564018153,
0.0086731026,
0.0507394895,
0.0247142818,
-0.0073725963,
-0.0618534386,
0.029594576,
-0.0466106832,
-0.0478391163,
-0.0440126769,
0.0145462258,
0.0992655531,
0.0918229744,
0.0457787849,
-0.018974103,
-0.0253212955,
-0.0996169671,
0.0663486421,
-0.032896623,
-0.0147355571,
0.0108895972,
-0.0002724371,
0.0068762624,
0.0342589431,
0.0409956053,
0.0185235087,
0.0728008598,
0.0055383914,
0.0700955465,
-0.0310941879,
0.0108986078,
-0.0397064425,
-0.0349117965,
0.0095556397,
-0.0312780663,
0.0906414688,
-0.0532417372,
-0.0092606526,
-0.0386535637,
0.0270749889,
0.0090421541,
0.027940752,
0.0105233155,
0.0121412463,
-0.0074807662,
0.0381254479,
-0.0119504305,
-0.0322927386,
-0.0772065595,
0.0153184468,
0.0476543829,
-0.0157251805,
-0.0371392742,
-0.0083363391,
0.0188010242,
0.0356486477,
-0.0797204673,
-0.0520104691,
2.092972054e-34,
0.0203648806,
-0.0219120122,
0.0212261006,
0.0379385278,
0.0254008137,
-0.0040596989,
-0.0478708558,
0.029674815,
0.0088822627,
-0.09810891,
0.0165907592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14891v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14891v1 | Generate-then-Ground in Retrieval-Augmented Generation for Multi-hop Question Answering | 2024-06-21T06:26:38 | 2024-06-21T06:26:38 | Zhengliang Shi, Shuo Zhang, Weiwei Sun, Shen Gao, Pengjie Ren, Zhumin Chen, Zhaochun Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Multi-Hop Question Answering (MHQA) tasks present a significant challenge for
large language models (LLMs) due to the intensive knowledge required. Current
solutions, like Retrieval-Augmented Generation, typically retrieve potential
documents from an external corpus to read an answer. However, the performance
of this retrieve-then-read paradigm is constrained by the retriever and the
inevitable noise in the retrieved documents. To mitigate these challenges, we
introduce a novel generate-then-ground (GenGround) framework, synergizing the
parametric knowledge of LLMs and external documents to solve a multi-hop
question. GenGround empowers LLMs to alternate two phases until the final
answer is derived: (1) formulate a simpler, single-hop question and directly
generate the answer; (2) ground the question-answer pair in retrieved
documents, amending any wrong predictions in the answer. We also propose an
instructional grounding distillation method to generalize our method into
smaller models. Extensive experiments conducted on four datasets illustrate the
superiority of our method. | [
0.0348365456,
0.0578586571,
-0.0037393291,
-0.0024246841,
-0.0417099074,
-0.0154680405,
-0.0159072448,
-0.0205326844,
-0.004792884,
-0.0491104648,
-0.0215532202,
-0.0130403051,
-0.0379101671,
-0.0253736787,
0.0326765776,
0.0143320393,
0.0652260706,
-0.029485153,
-0.0452312231,
-0.015723519,
-0.0106505323,
0.0331083722,
-0.0070400601,
0.0188308563,
-0.0148324529,
-0.036000967,
-0.0369486213,
0.011480879,
0.0013087769,
-0.0215146393,
0.0271420684,
0.0671804845,
0.0360856988,
0.0259099696,
0.0000020098,
-0.0308869164,
-0.034039937,
0.011444401,
-0.0382801443,
-0.0226907767,
-0.0395550765,
0.0550218225,
0.0329183452,
0.0313455276,
-0.0544074364,
0.0219090562,
0.0173233282,
0.0596161559,
0.0808186531,
0.0366769247,
0.0151427221,
-0.0405122824,
0.0304955672,
0.0089828474,
0.0689424649,
-0.019836016,
0.0126586147,
0.0465058871,
0.0135320891,
0.0315837637,
-0.0220228527,
0.0121782301,
0.0426898152,
-0.0004062388,
-0.0129372068,
0.0391712338,
-0.0171212815,
0.0203468725,
-0.0107217636,
0.1056380197,
0.0172433946,
-0.0171242692,
-0.0022419679,
0.0307108276,
0.0239698328,
0.0432159714,
-0.06848941,
0.0095119039,
-0.0421067365,
0.002839149,
-0.006987324,
-0.010920871,
0.0034984502,
0.0260506887,
-0.023421349,
0.0847530141,
0.024302965,
-0.0333073623,
0.012386403,
0.0292723626,
-0.0074007739,
-0.0269592274,
0.027934758,
0.0688845441,
-0.025612874,
0.0288145822,
-0.0219832174,
-0.0535866991,
0.0324425288,
-0.0181400348,
0.0420500897,
0.0459855907,
-0.0235234983,
0.0518715531,
-0.0469304658,
0.0188543629,
-0.0429062955,
-0.0032921731,
-0.0470115207,
-0.0117378635,
-0.0445421077,
-0.0302362163,
-0.0745884329,
0.0550929643,
-0.0767902955,
-0.0156304091,
0.0042202733,
0.0299556591,
-0.0103477463,
-0.043395102,
-0.0065418268,
0.0493986793,
-0.0442014486,
-0.0140107051,
-0.0261979066,
0.0544374958,
-0.0587092824,
0.0259111971,
0.0230042301,
-0.0563490465,
-0.0407288894,
-0.0003617335,
0.0257997066,
-0.0117447013,
0.0055333734,
0.0506831743,
-0.0428351723,
-0.0079349354,
-0.0684816465,
-0.0668664798,
0.0100064995,
-0.0697291493,
0.0196875166,
-0.0681133494,
0.0574367046,
0.0092784958,
-0.0370338336,
-0.0265654735,
0.0224690475,
0.0530667081,
-0.0124603398,
0.0546703227,
0.0296119433,
0.0047104969,
0.0611282364,
0.0178419203,
-0.0048998957,
0.0842431933,
0.006967755,
-0.0028516084,
0.0309381653,
0.0097335931,
0.0007843387,
0.0093661817,
0.0659722537,
0.0169229377,
0.0089411605,
0.0218930524,
0.0115222745,
0.0125983618,
0.0172924176,
0.0407269672,
-0.0522655472,
0.0023275234,
0.0424040407,
0.0361975394,
0.0130233886,
0.0008635243,
0.0757889748,
0.0046085063,
-0.0147202965,
0.0519171618,
-0.0309717115,
0.0436905697,
-0.0594358742,
0.0350378454,
0.0362401679,
0.0460862406,
-0.0381689146,
-0.0308420248,
0.022908885,
0.0050950218,
-0.0054972921,
0.0375418328,
0.0466506034,
0.0341966636,
-0.0542460606,
0.093238689,
0.0243358333,
-0.045797281,
0.0315615386,
-0.0338127725,
0.041170761,
0.0276911668,
0.0653783083,
0.014116697,
-0.0296926964,
-0.0137771089,
0.0382962227,
0.038888,
0.0001800567,
-0.0236786753,
-0.0009851026,
-0.0511131734,
-0.0194459278,
-0.0267214011,
-0.0112524303,
0.0078023733,
0.062572211,
0.0080608204,
0.0517355315,
-0.070424214,
0.0413105153,
0.0183867048,
-0.0724065825,
-0.0286824051,
-0.0080835931,
-0.0037249187,
-0.017910203,
0.0229648296,
-0.0034718204,
0.0319978856,
0.0537694953,
-0.0103999348,
-0.0345095508,
-0.0110757789,
-0.0498095937,
-0.0255261343,
0.0160393789,
-0.0286577195,
0.010218597,
-0.0029654917,
-0.0269817337,
-0.0572039001,
0.012363187,
-0.0364004411,
0.0463844612,
-0.0651551187,
-0.0256755464,
0.0465528257,
0.0054469039,
-0.0473132879,
0.0547142625,
-0.010161831,
0.0050878194,
-0.0040608551,
0.0303932186,
-0.0018465824,
-0.0395758301,
0.0201481488,
-0.0024680221,
-0.0024872413,
0.0111675896,
0.0195355695,
0.018436769,
-0.0753676817,
-0.0387685411,
-0.080827184,
0.0112882918,
-0.0242989752,
0.0196314156,
0.0382754281,
0.0209519342,
-0.0162135884,
-0.0209603067,
-0.0640795007,
0.0097021619,
0.0406579673,
0.0306858718,
0.0172791723,
0.0288812667,
0.002921202,
-0.0173099898,
0.0064361831,
0.0038070958,
0.0488375723,
-0.0232028682,
0.0221717097,
-0.0839224607,
-0.0021643408,
-0.0612983629,
0.0328615569,
0.013686073,
-0.0066817869,
0.0099899247,
-0.0407350026,
0.0656020194,
0.0038360173,
-0.003557876,
0.0141539639,
0.0541053712,
-0.0388976559,
-0.0756007284,
0.039176967,
-0.0359688923,
-0.0167309903,
0.014350187,
-0.0188536886,
-0.0101651391,
0.0584067442,
0.0075337593,
-0.0202109683,
-0.0286107454,
0.0250580627,
0.0080130836,
-0.0140411481,
-0.0738299042,
-0.0127030034,
0.0005051281,
0.0262445174,
-0.0347295366,
-0.0356498063,
0.1007272452,
-0.0279107857,
-0.0018848587,
-0.0591061749,
0.0189059842,
-0.0338257179,
0.0391714685,
-0.0425256416,
0.0131309163,
-0.016694976,
-0.0118145142,
-0.0576351136,
-0.006402289,
-0.0024953925,
-0.0509533286,
0.0523655303,
-0.0695176721,
0.0294618756,
0.0000869931,
-0.0167285632,
-0.0540682673,
-0.0025586996,
0.0168682709,
0.0025409309,
-0.0241963509,
0.0102360994,
-0.0141386706,
-0.0044654403,
0.0395437703,
0.0307474118,
-0.0499228351,
-0.0076103834,
-0.0126331216,
0.0724929646,
0.0884123221,
0.0197194982,
0.0111539029,
-0.0305279214,
0.0298780594,
0.0724823922,
0.0546670817,
-0.0213347711,
0.0420289673,
-0.009724481,
0.0197219066,
0.0028176943,
0.0072847344,
0.0070206099,
0.0243610367,
-0.0454586186,
-0.0639907494,
0.0832489729,
0.0441172086,
-0.0136589631,
-0.0057694381,
-0.0520282649,
0.0269060005,
-0.0058791167,
0.0528353639,
-0.0741857514,
-0.022762822,
-0.0075030709,
0.0315154009,
0.0247901715,
-0.0390824191,
-0.0163955446,
-0.1283159405,
0.0221025553,
0.0089033339,
-0.0445091687,
-0.0541227795,
-0.0346840061,
-0.0087711597,
0.0649301782,
0.0180351231,
0.0289088041,
0.0079257935,
0.0182507318,
0.0109128999,
0.0591951497,
-0.026854787,
0.004140072,
-0.0027877029,
-0.0190098081,
0.0650879666,
-0.0041108164,
0.0357403941,
-0.0518328659,
0.0099258469,
-0.0500295982,
0.0052131983,
-0.0054029091,
0.0166493151,
0.0114934063,
0.001631127,
-0.0197003745,
0.0570241027,
-0.0376058295,
-0.014646966,
0.0001134573,
0.0722762272,
-0.0257730596,
-0.0013313502,
-0.0253061578,
0.0317988321,
0.0453556143,
0.0739059895,
0.0372900292,
-0.047353629,
-0.0224037077,
-0.0275841244,
0.0281456094,
-0.0767135099,
-0.0078493729,
0.0201928392,
0.0148834381,
0.0651222765,
-0.0830967799,
-0.0494800098,
0.0411521904,
0.0544788502,
-0.0215669349,
0.0159582794,
0.0109942248,
0.0065994659,
-0.0350310802,
0.0320188068,
-0.0334929973,
-0.0075442577,
-0.0399822108,
-0.0332107395,
0.0512403511,
-0.0326114111,
-0.0236008577,
0.0353783183,
-0.0716707036,
-0.0513588786,
-0.0094351862,
0.0383069739,
0.0244086459,
0.0258141588,
-0.007061319,
0.020124672,
0.0232696328,
0.0224109609,
-0.0522042364,
0.0120097995,
-0.0007453811,
0.0047420855,
-0.0235645194,
0.0252443533,
-0.0681641996,
0.0131389238,
0.0154091865,
0.0880363137,
-0.0003153599,
-0.0184000749,
0.041240789,
0.0057633412,
0.0244047754,
0.0146062756,
0.0507600009,
-0.0180563089,
0.0282764137,
-0.0300254337,
-0.0225093998,
-0.027774727,
-0.0007582158,
-0.002580923,
-0.0685074255,
0.0200139452,
-0.0048212423,
0.0045878841,
0.0693371594,
-0.0318459719,
-0.0346995667,
-0.0112992711,
-0.0095544169,
0.0294191279,
-0.0214760862,
-0.0210823305,
0.0004581132,
0.0081597194,
0.0581087917,
-0.0167065691,
0.0794190466,
0.0349711291,
-0.0087099923,
-0.0423173159,
-0.0007599129,
-0.076003246,
-0.0270743184,
-0.0528434478,
0.0220492464,
0.0304833762,
0.0303257816,
0.0214828234,
0.0064807977,
-0.0302065592,
-0.0029942864,
0.0089893565,
0.013041297,
-0.0300924554,
0.0354301296,
0.0309666712,
0.0196471903,
0.0091198692,
0.090219304,
-0.0089682313,
0.0765318573,
-0.035476841,
0.0177006684,
-0.0367819332,
-0.05685829,
-0.0384880453,
0.0030581579,
-0.0030857224,
0.0293216072,
-0.0612056889,
-0.0636473373,
-0.0277673043,
0.0222756341,
-0.0198173597,
-0.0255938433,
0.0556350425,
0.0727695748,
-0.0028613766,
-0.0559422262,
-0.0193466395,
0.0613885038,
-0.0363047309,
-0.0420723408,
-0.0311803464,
-6.497997589e-33,
-0.0555135868,
-0.0474262908,
0.0523009747,
-0.0380253978,
-0.0305957533,
-0.006702824,
-0.0299583413,
-0.0188093726,
-0.0265751816,
-0.0073664631,
-0.0091147712,
-0.0016143882,
0.0012610682,
0.0465769619,
-0.0175996963,
-0.0172389634,
0.0405968167,
-0.0183133297,
-0.0121842008,
0.0499596745,
0.0647871867,
0.034116324,
0.0356904306,
-0.0075747874,
0.0075762309,
-0.0365278125,
-0.0080372952,
0.0277589355,
-0.0376357287,
0.0589217208,
-0.0098941829,
0.0249388441,
0.0105111832,
-0.0370379388,
-0.0228665322,
0.0379834324,
-0.0975988507,
-0.0401248708,
0.0145639824,
-0.0306432042,
-0.0466824621,
-0.0297432523,
0.0059151379,
-0.0182527658,
0.036041189,
-0.0010572552,
-0.0046175639,
0.0029666377,
-0.0096928487,
-0.035314057,
-0.0445108898,
-0.0140718743,
-0.0022614147,
-0.0378242433,
-0.0536796972,
0.0792882368,
0.0107153188,
0.0075052944,
-0.0299518071,
0.0097058984,
0.0242281444,
0.0209272113,
0.0394836329,
0.0095233601,
-0.008025948,
0.0339897238,
-0.0154892113,
-0.0377369598,
-0.0455078371,
-0.0363355465,
0.0013772822,
0.0046676798,
0.0129442541,
0.0272118896,
0.0256836116,
0.0115732057,
-0.0612861551,
0.0447055399,
0.0038503357,
0.0357035212,
0.0011944087,
-0.0225873459,
0.0063599669,
-0.0274334177,
-0.0466521271,
0.006560734,
-0.0224580113,
-0.0433460996,
0.0455204435,
0.0160050355,
-0.0395200998,
-0.0240753014,
0.0435386077,
-0.0208219215,
0.0020282834,
0.0819336474,
-0.0093910927,
0.0111493357,
-0.018108163,
0.0149830692,
-0.0269824117,
-0.0088588651,
0.034560848,
-0.0009439227,
-0.0151135996,
0.029801134,
0.002222881,
-0.004958726,
-0.0551164784,
0.0158806127,
-0.0531283021,
0.0622714385,
0.0062916516,
-0.0463794284,
0.0291235596,
0.0299540199,
-0.0157760121,
0.0502700694,
0.017195968,
0.0109828683,
-0.0085550146,
-0.0195890274,
-0.0065876679,
0.0540173911,
-0.0136323767,
0.0393333323,
-0.0222606584,
-0.0016526827,
0.0046660462,
-0.048913639,
-0.0104895392,
0.0465768501,
2.727e-7,
0.0377807841,
0.0084458115,
0.0484323613,
0.0274217874,
0.0062813009,
-0.0090447087,
0.0025802506,
-0.0007412093,
0.0296181068,
-0.0468482263,
-0.0319069028,
0.0408660993,
0.0365038626,
0.0307405014,
-0.09848243,
-0.0061613009,
-0.056830205,
-0.0105094602,
-0.0360435434,
-0.0378673449,
0.0379720815,
0.031367857,
-0.0239485204,
0.0016927157,
-0.0301157087,
-0.0179016218,
0.0701168925,
0.0037630224,
-0.0290492158,
0.0043016886,
0.0296663903,
-0.0255900007,
0.0171259716,
0.0149697922,
-0.0222160071,
0.0286394786,
-0.0093154311,
0.0327819809,
0.0152032571,
-0.0589421913,
-0.0313895568,
-0.028426379,
0.0181292705,
-0.0391411744,
0.0547783673,
-0.0384126045,
0.0127855605,
-0.0195953883,
-0.0338053256,
-0.0230923668,
-0.008654899,
-0.0328042544,
-0.024436824,
0.0167091247,
0.0083323391,
0.0067439661,
0.0211185757,
-0.0728094801,
-0.0135450317,
0.0549510606,
-0.0390383601,
-0.0499276742,
-0.0151467575,
-0.0511610061,
-0.0051762313,
-0.0442474186,
-0.0135147953,
2.467030427e-34,
0.0176103022,
-0.0019230047,
0.0251796562,
0.0428024791,
0.034217,
-0.0105729019,
0.0019688171,
-0.001997109,
0.0103771221,
-0.0882067382,
-0.031663321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14890v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14890v1 | InterBiasing: Boost Unseen Word Recognition through Biasing Intermediate Predictions | 2024-06-21T06:25:10 | 2024-06-21T06:25:10 | Yu Nakagome, Michael Hentschel | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Despite recent advances in end-to-end speech recognition methods, their
output is biased to the training data's vocabulary, resulting in inaccurate
recognition of unknown terms or proper nouns. To improve the recognition
accuracy for a given set of such terms, we propose an adaptation parameter-free
approach based on Self-conditioned CTC. Our method improves the recognition
accuracy of misrecognized target keywords by substituting their intermediate
CTC predictions with corrected labels, which are then passed on to the
subsequent layers. First, we create pairs of correct labels and recognition
error instances for a keyword list using Text-to-Speech and a recognition
model. We use these pairs to replace intermediate prediction errors by the
labels. Conditioning the subsequent layers of the encoder on the labels, it is
possible to acoustically evaluate the target keywords. Experiments conducted in
Japanese demonstrated that our method successfully improved the F1 score for
unknown words. | [
-0.0031951796,
0.0156668406,
0.0520345196,
0.0504076146,
0.0186669715,
0.0188111421,
0.0158849526,
0.034865655,
-0.0045145932,
-0.031627357,
-0.0861777216,
-0.0270804204,
0.0415604636,
0.0154286521,
-0.0202807188,
-0.0378586613,
0.0207731072,
-0.0408248641,
-0.0010188542,
-0.0155774914,
-0.0185305346,
-0.0103014149,
-0.0555929318,
-0.0007986485,
-0.0224491488,
0.0032286553,
0.0035897221,
0.0222572982,
0.001214934,
-0.0389571898,
0.0094858427,
0.0347498655,
-0.0271526426,
0.0293266661,
0.0000020131,
-0.0422132239,
-0.0365582779,
-0.0285102781,
-0.0480309576,
-0.0318781137,
0.0539018027,
0.0135002043,
-0.0252764132,
0.0474236012,
-0.0020455709,
-0.0270345435,
0.069431968,
0.0774482116,
0.0000799345,
0.0726581216,
-0.0070965244,
-0.0277255885,
0.0104475217,
-0.009861921,
0.0096251322,
-0.0158014055,
0.0051669399,
-0.0730480105,
-0.0278655998,
-0.0358299054,
-0.0181413684,
0.0438929424,
-0.0191713199,
0.0062819822,
0.0679197684,
0.0249763932,
0.0026957679,
-0.0605758056,
-0.0407739989,
0.0429809913,
-0.0176478419,
-0.015042142,
-0.0321631245,
-0.0128214546,
-0.0206414014,
-0.004354733,
-0.0072077201,
-0.0311045982,
-0.0022261932,
-0.0112491744,
0.0095049012,
0.0290468875,
0.0136644524,
-0.0023346578,
-0.0428674519,
0.0293467231,
0.0072060516,
-0.0686197877,
-0.0040245838,
-0.0214486644,
0.0181035604,
-0.0014117474,
0.0514384359,
0.0009396374,
-0.0129275676,
-0.0048525836,
-0.0233471766,
-0.0451335646,
-0.032375332,
-0.077338919,
-0.0285326317,
0.0171294697,
-0.05535179,
0.012564498,
-0.0639448091,
0.0346172489,
0.0144090373,
0.0526246876,
-0.0479993038,
-0.0272462014,
-0.0174796265,
0.003111321,
-0.0586117469,
0.0155433537,
-0.0052266563,
-0.0155496085,
-0.0433372036,
-0.006769862,
0.0065920334,
0.0070538661,
0.03320463,
-0.0143093141,
-0.0704711899,
-0.0234150272,
0.0053682909,
0.0033763647,
0.0232573561,
0.0305887628,
0.0089473184,
-0.0605990253,
-0.0319332704,
0.0074594915,
0.0714365169,
-0.0028240904,
0.0455747917,
0.0422572754,
-0.0072822995,
-0.0932512209,
-0.0246742126,
0.0309055913,
-0.0265621897,
0.0088887,
0.0009085996,
-0.0362332016,
-0.0204811618,
-0.0301047117,
0.0458879843,
-0.0642899871,
0.0031563954,
-0.0256865881,
-0.014133553,
0.1136755571,
-0.0339772664,
-0.0199225396,
0.0654469505,
0.0102457507,
0.0306030065,
0.0349777006,
0.0507355966,
-0.0004274018,
0.0137174837,
-0.0019490921,
0.0647108257,
0.035747759,
0.0116237653,
-0.0124397306,
-0.0655883998,
-0.0457194038,
0.0594349355,
0.024614634,
0.0355527624,
0.0258795787,
0.0004195017,
0.0247718003,
0.0298868772,
-0.0047355946,
0.00879307,
0.0221388955,
-0.0203620195,
-0.0034412311,
-0.0127190109,
-0.0024546394,
0.0081416219,
0.0089586386,
-0.058305908,
0.0067810831,
0.0610578954,
-0.0100429822,
-0.0492100269,
-0.0444477983,
-0.0177225191,
-0.0171089061,
-0.0073476839,
-0.0236935001,
0.0704471692,
0.0495744608,
-0.0611378103,
0.0099391406,
0.0131490594,
-0.0536128953,
0.031833183,
-0.0278305709,
-0.0114876777,
0.06423565,
0.0245255958,
-0.0103054186,
-0.011078231,
0.0117980363,
-0.0520378575,
0.0731737241,
0.018599147,
0.0084028123,
0.0295688249,
-0.0663265586,
-0.0361062512,
0.0769759938,
-0.0075099128,
0.05377746,
-0.0257541202,
0.0723797604,
0.031437546,
-0.047259938,
0.0100412024,
0.0126289437,
0.0164459571,
-0.06480629,
0.0400734954,
0.0136151602,
0.0426856242,
0.0389557891,
-0.0431655385,
-0.0055401251,
0.0190629605,
-0.0234051067,
-0.047565233,
0.0110582244,
-0.063007012,
-0.0594029725,
0.0135961492,
-0.0447056256,
0.0233681314,
0.0448494218,
0.0288119279,
-0.0882625654,
0.0199777652,
0.0214105025,
0.0346587896,
-0.0487021506,
0.063826479,
0.008341684,
0.0524314083,
0.0458826683,
0.0160872061,
0.0092497393,
-0.0084517831,
-0.001667575,
-0.0092635956,
-0.0307687391,
-0.0507047176,
-0.0494761504,
0.0498644859,
-0.0022695528,
-0.0044136937,
0.0011426024,
0.0199099537,
-0.0197248627,
-0.0095073171,
-0.0880822018,
-0.0155020701,
-0.0071953079,
-0.0044353595,
-0.0277213454,
0.0253372248,
-0.0320667848,
-0.0329981148,
-0.017711591,
-0.0250678174,
-0.0071367375,
-0.0081699351,
-0.0325531252,
-0.0077795163,
-0.0263459235,
0.0080107208,
0.0151617015,
0.0189032704,
0.0256192796,
0.0015941885,
-0.0708986223,
-0.0300195739,
0.0270587076,
0.0274745729,
0.0472582504,
0.0227400344,
-0.0127618769,
-0.0202736165,
0.002321145,
-0.0376741216,
0.0058868425,
0.0375308432,
-0.0377397761,
-0.0129937548,
-0.0173180569,
-0.0371724181,
-0.0137849702,
0.0191559363,
-0.0165475458,
0.0151623879,
0.0119733559,
-0.0536548756,
0.0922231153,
0.0212570988,
0.0331834741,
-0.0417949148,
-0.0362873748,
-0.0514799953,
-0.0459500551,
-0.0483186394,
-0.039763689,
-0.0321528316,
0.0038467129,
0.0143315699,
-0.0021986167,
0.0512821339,
-0.0942982361,
-0.0553294942,
-0.0531620234,
0.0020544713,
0.0314451419,
-0.0054396195,
-0.0147301769,
0.0082984185,
0.0514450409,
-0.0562997907,
0.0018869377,
-0.0005427232,
0.0109174028,
-0.0755776316,
-0.0269062389,
0.0081376089,
0.0040556323,
0.0367750749,
-0.0083500668,
-0.0435865745,
-0.0118590435,
-0.0140753612,
-0.0057775513,
0.0267278105,
0.0043527489,
-0.0180185642,
0.0402377024,
-0.0024855337,
0.0967376903,
0.014921885,
0.0027317421,
-0.0180222131,
0.0527353808,
-0.0100213354,
0.0108662685,
0.0044477973,
-0.0080746533,
0.0326878466,
-0.0040157167,
0.0688979402,
0.0121569009,
-0.0252858624,
0.0148347253,
0.0427101925,
0.0009425002,
0.0097140223,
0.0056334264,
0.0133615388,
-0.0156504363,
-0.0276443418,
0.1181987748,
0.0000445655,
-0.0903485641,
-0.0268097091,
0.0188213326,
-0.0142096411,
0.007570609,
-0.0216591936,
-0.0266365055,
-0.0263718888,
0.0532809347,
0.0498345904,
-0.0164680928,
0.0240822081,
-0.0059326845,
-0.0916398019,
0.0398466438,
0.0366596878,
0.003559744,
-0.0441954024,
-0.0822970197,
-0.0029284779,
-0.038313318,
0.0239655171,
0.0312783681,
-0.0166239943,
-0.0474940129,
0.0370180234,
-0.0240774509,
-0.0630961508,
-0.0133415917,
-0.0220352188,
0.0591763556,
0.0544372126,
0.0024153271,
-0.0376139507,
-0.0041916845,
0.0572716668,
-0.0323987603,
-0.0102110486,
-0.0482860953,
0.0356057659,
-0.0435052738,
-0.0130977724,
0.0612545013,
0.0175100677,
-0.041035369,
0.0062135928,
0.0298042577,
0.0208932441,
-0.0008199374,
0.0101896208,
0.0183756165,
-0.0124181574,
0.0095479228,
0.0560895391,
0.0017812565,
-0.041634053,
0.0374877453,
0.0034692979,
0.0094297985,
-0.0068638758,
0.006351857,
0.0187637266,
-0.0199353453,
-0.0342165083,
-0.0402431339,
-0.0623913258,
-0.0248620249,
0.0526284464,
0.0376779735,
0.0258415509,
-0.0388843417,
0.0452327281,
-0.0306102615,
-0.0094150687,
-0.0314285345,
0.0014128215,
-0.0616470873,
0.0074565937,
-0.0241489094,
-0.0627299622,
-0.0109252073,
0.0058219782,
0.0082015675,
-0.0231459513,
0.0092008738,
-0.0003887975,
0.0130200982,
0.0822685584,
-0.036868345,
-0.0410571955,
0.1298154145,
0.0262965076,
-0.0098323142,
0.0218483135,
0.0701538771,
-0.0470491722,
-0.025640551,
-0.0048415433,
-0.0629031882,
0.0301337615,
-0.0274084751,
0.0215242989,
0.0105686998,
-0.0492916629,
0.0167415459,
0.0019602745,
0.0962523594,
-0.0556661263,
0.0714416429,
-0.0571977198,
0.0598104671,
0.0143959485,
0.0216319188,
-0.0149988811,
0.0278690029,
0.0411372259,
0.0119054429,
-0.0081845969,
-0.0008676015,
-0.0640545711,
-0.0408598967,
-0.0001904152,
0.0611031167,
0.0053425543,
0.0302913263,
-0.007634087,
-0.015002395,
-0.0060345493,
0.01643949,
0.0601642542,
0.0386464,
-0.0018373001,
0.0308818538,
0.0066023846,
0.0107118329,
-0.0267116204,
0.0169594586,
-0.012591362,
0.0267561097,
-0.0909768343,
0.0202001221,
0.0253277663,
-0.0012342384,
0.0260752905,
-0.0123483595,
0.014402437,
-0.0057766787,
-0.0375493132,
-0.0327488966,
-0.0100571644,
0.0042290199,
-0.0233353656,
0.0195921063,
-0.0046299333,
0.03098418,
0.0043550674,
0.0305787325,
-0.0316977724,
0.0480796732,
-0.0333831832,
0.0022971858,
-0.0111605097,
-0.003632277,
-0.0263916254,
0.0009293756,
0.0432286523,
-0.0451278128,
0.0735952109,
0.0114012193,
0.0486134999,
0.0048109819,
0.0208471417,
0.0036327739,
-0.0428921506,
0.0162519775,
0.0034891134,
-0.0555720963,
0.0378784388,
-0.0138598112,
0.0405124016,
-6.621756573e-33,
-0.0526598729,
0.0210310817,
-0.0128550939,
0.004555813,
-0.0024647603,
0.0243936852,
-0.0183594339,
0.0284275729,
0.0294497237,
-0.0194912404,
-0.0455273166,
0.0271842275,
0.0486499816,
0.020540582,
-0.01266794,
0.0043212059,
0.0650569275,
-0.004128024,
-0.0225804895,
0.0044540185,
0.0195403155,
0.0634745508,
0.0790517181,
-0.0464121886,
0.0365572236,
0.018903615,
-0.0138706062,
-0.000282475,
0.0583917163,
0.0418435596,
-0.0319021419,
0.0454809107,
-0.016397858,
-0.0436996073,
0.0017809647,
0.0067547685,
-0.1234882623,
0.0178050622,
-0.0440105423,
0.0613747947,
-0.0034401461,
-0.0114680873,
0.0302402992,
0.0252867416,
-0.0549925901,
0.0125893531,
0.0097158281,
-0.0429157317,
0.0054617878,
-0.0018048651,
0.0003784198,
0.0442218482,
0.0088906772,
-0.0175763257,
0.081245929,
0.0571944043,
-0.0147665413,
-0.0393388644,
-0.0828766674,
0.0249367412,
0.0354204699,
0.0233897213,
0.0426424481,
0.0721586198,
-0.0471296087,
0.0359634906,
0.0531284772,
-0.083379373,
0.031106526,
-0.0588839725,
0.0420973413,
-0.0366565809,
0.013946699,
0.0367195569,
0.0511963442,
-0.0526967719,
0.0245787632,
0.0249088183,
-0.0056029377,
-0.0066769621,
0.0455425605,
0.0076243379,
-0.0783549026,
-0.0068664267,
-0.0730338469,
-0.0461775213,
-0.0623119995,
0.0059099915,
0.0580389909,
0.0387689397,
-0.0186822768,
-0.0053807464,
0.073683843,
0.0032337266,
0.0079596993,
0.0014640976,
0.033260107,
-0.009893964,
-0.0097550889,
0.0610268153,
-0.0423173159,
-0.0529922843,
0.0273039769,
0.034435913,
-0.0057864417,
-0.0245473981,
-0.0093969004,
0.0402632132,
-0.0497114994,
0.0045037777,
0.0171394963,
-0.015127317,
0.015299351,
-0.0161043964,
0.0296015088,
0.0098077292,
-0.0078816172,
0.0247015152,
0.0128888991,
-0.0015679694,
-0.0240264907,
-0.0308219716,
0.0111452229,
0.0186126903,
-0.0232196152,
0.0232989304,
0.0181862004,
-0.0200826712,
0.0304346699,
-0.0516049974,
0.0117874434,
0.050256744,
3e-7,
-0.0423992164,
0.0219175685,
0.0100959968,
-0.0393004976,
-0.005789794,
0.0229624901,
-0.0081259646,
0.0264431331,
-0.0143547384,
0.0034329831,
0.0508008711,
0.0058994954,
0.0607281886,
0.0101805953,
-0.0760656595,
-0.0567181185,
-0.0181881953,
0.0488074459,
-0.0071124071,
0.0091415029,
0.0218370557,
0.0989680067,
-0.0008066555,
-0.0421129577,
-0.0152927786,
-0.0130539564,
0.0236540399,
0.0133565515,
0.0378013067,
-0.0062713297,
0.0107507138,
0.0307445582,
0.0097411266,
0.0728174224,
-0.0272590257,
0.0369073562,
0.067845583,
-0.0381982513,
-0.0396283753,
-0.0246721916,
0.0183298551,
0.0728982612,
-0.0340885036,
-0.0124803344,
0.0545492321,
-0.0076068752,
0.0042021088,
-0.0258370005,
-0.0475131758,
0.0110044507,
-0.0030518819,
0.0002731313,
-0.0183536261,
0.0021057397,
0.0359808765,
0.0403455757,
-0.059901882,
-0.0326846018,
0.0042186966,
0.0182943251,
-0.0339428224,
-0.0177657772,
-0.0153206717,
-0.0036707725,
0.0293154567,
-0.0253143702,
0.0123967929,
1.83954213e-34,
0.0271391831,
-0.0241429657,
-0.0119587658,
-0.0028442403,
0.0077579059,
-0.0276411436,
0.0208123922,
-0.0021315548,
-0.0170576889,
-0.0454015508,
-0.0222397801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14887v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14887v1 | InternLM-Law: An Open Source Chinese Legal Large Language Model | 2024-06-21T06:19:03 | 2024-06-21T06:19:03 | Zhiwei Fei, Songyang Zhang, Xiaoyu Shen, Dawei Zhu, Xiao Wang, Maosong Cao, Fengzhe Zhou, Yining Li, Wenwei Zhang, Dahua Lin, Kai Chen, Jidong Ge | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models (LLMs) have showcased impressive capabilities,
they struggle with addressing legal queries due to the intricate complexities
and specialized expertise required in the legal field. In this paper, we
introduce InternLM-Law, a specialized LLM tailored for addressing diverse legal
queries related to Chinese laws, spanning from responding to standard legal
questions (e.g., legal exercises in textbooks) to analyzing complex real-world
legal situations. We meticulously construct a dataset in the Chinese legal
domain, encompassing over 1 million queries, and implement a data filtering and
processing pipeline to ensure its diversity and quality. Our training approach
involves a novel two-stage process: initially fine-tuning LLMs on both
legal-specific and general-purpose content to equip the models with broad
knowledge, followed by exclusive fine-tuning on high-quality legal data to
enhance structured output generation. InternLM-Law achieves the highest average
performance on LawBench, outperforming state-of-the-art models, including
GPT-4, on 13 out of 20 subtasks. We make InternLM-Law and our dataset publicly
available to facilitate future research in applying LLMs within the legal
domain. | [
0.0615284406,
0.0583194271,
-0.0082283989,
0.0109041743,
-0.0422019511,
0.0245368425,
0.0330033936,
0.0481228456,
0.0430003405,
-0.0771069899,
-0.0238997564,
-0.0400863402,
-0.042497851,
-0.0055383616,
0.0167525858,
-0.0477155484,
0.0315094069,
0.0057991687,
0.0437548682,
-0.0191600323,
0.0384607948,
0.0294663329,
0.0437622927,
0.017014889,
-0.0000042955,
-0.0302035566,
-0.0130110625,
0.0078398939,
-0.0060425675,
0.0033879085,
0.0305909254,
0.0693328902,
0.0247764271,
0.0401568376,
0.000001904,
-0.0584344529,
0.0024789036,
-0.0060762744,
-0.0000367689,
0.0487530045,
0.0245665014,
-0.0362361707,
-0.0189841762,
0.0200730655,
-0.0551435612,
0.0217214953,
-0.0178859774,
0.0454100817,
0.0600271598,
0.1069543585,
0.0038066886,
-0.0396470465,
0.0338276401,
-0.0718853846,
0.0074867266,
-0.0396596231,
0.0384967327,
0.0457882956,
0.0376290381,
-0.0175712798,
-0.0009811036,
0.0038507411,
0.0546986572,
-0.0320293941,
-0.0391771793,
-0.0040048212,
-0.0350518152,
0.0350817591,
0.0035036528,
0.0706111118,
0.009900162,
-0.0345664993,
0.0022560509,
-0.0098184394,
0.0491110682,
0.0109625822,
-0.0342778899,
0.0830883086,
-0.0084755216,
0.0181295387,
0.0198801458,
-0.0251856744,
0.0172999445,
0.0411382616,
-0.0368755125,
0.0407043099,
-0.012124259,
-0.0524545461,
-0.0107630389,
-0.0337110683,
0.0141999386,
-0.05495001,
0.0441213399,
0.0395083725,
-0.0167282093,
0.0206292979,
-0.0393251851,
-0.0185376648,
0.060276024,
-0.0564451553,
-0.0059010168,
-0.0066785123,
-0.016539095,
0.0739078224,
-0.0441325642,
0.0094754295,
-0.0028955354,
0.0224795528,
-0.016743632,
-0.0416343883,
-0.0353571996,
-0.0062587587,
-0.0275025107,
0.05867346,
-0.0826708078,
0.0125622861,
-0.0152405594,
0.0089038704,
-0.0213228036,
0.0207283329,
0.0053127245,
-0.0074129072,
-0.0228077509,
-0.0624925196,
-0.0490713827,
-0.0201229118,
-0.0304950252,
0.0597030856,
-0.0102151129,
-0.0149643989,
0.0146747287,
0.0156489182,
-0.0119109368,
-0.0041112723,
0.0133816544,
0.0929445177,
-0.0103332363,
-0.0042379838,
-0.0475238524,
-0.0568177924,
-0.0023903102,
-0.0607709475,
-0.0325818621,
-0.0737915039,
-0.0173757467,
-0.0388290696,
0.0029120259,
-0.0490074381,
0.0213251263,
0.0483859368,
-0.0008994333,
0.050024841,
0.003288392,
-0.0140392696,
-0.0285477638,
0.0367665701,
0.0461261943,
0.0371814705,
0.0039159111,
0.0144808646,
0.0297806468,
-0.0194980074,
0.01067934,
0.0379414335,
-0.0002866603,
0.0346954837,
-0.0327354632,
0.0358557478,
0.0016262818,
0.0033940014,
0.0069376514,
0.046119947,
0.0024960998,
-0.0046836007,
0.0277944319,
0.0571804121,
0.0012810244,
0.0554247573,
0.0082156304,
-0.0017292186,
0.0216119792,
-0.0151511058,
-0.0620296337,
0.0210939851,
-0.0169899408,
-0.0004027484,
-0.0591475479,
0.0399091579,
-0.0278290324,
-0.0458085313,
0.0043762387,
-0.003934612,
-0.0323240459,
0.012932987,
0.0194177702,
0.0082080346,
-0.0097280936,
0.0482364558,
0.0166789349,
-0.0486907773,
-0.0126017937,
-0.0075528393,
0.009770046,
0.062066447,
0.0308132116,
-0.0498721004,
-0.0150838532,
-0.0466478914,
0.0247704405,
0.0647225678,
0.0437268727,
-0.0162931364,
-0.0400718972,
-0.0538339429,
-0.0337618403,
0.0127887586,
0.0256915372,
-0.0182647388,
0.0402037129,
0.0104820486,
0.0435313433,
-0.0450839587,
-0.0376632884,
0.0280625373,
-0.0442294516,
-0.049815435,
0.0162363965,
-0.0152195711,
0.0183609519,
0.0239107274,
-0.003447298,
-0.011728459,
0.0177326817,
-0.0036172441,
-0.0219827313,
0.0121133709,
0.0122159803,
-0.0094220042,
0.0781359151,
-0.0418524146,
-0.0167763177,
0.008449547,
-0.0807891265,
-0.0283373725,
-0.0410348661,
0.0316168554,
0.0052130558,
-0.0735846087,
-0.0015235365,
0.0028605731,
-0.0072123571,
-0.030724138,
0.0498203859,
-0.0021453903,
-0.0069665853,
0.0238633044,
0.0198272895,
0.0403031111,
-0.012200796,
-0.0403653271,
-0.0256172605,
-0.0325236805,
0.0332533531,
0.0202530287,
0.0453835912,
-0.0423978642,
-0.0307602081,
-0.054363396,
0.02213821,
-0.0329715647,
0.004453076,
0.0174675863,
-0.0215433612,
-0.0190330464,
-0.0188407637,
-0.0575283058,
-0.0043484992,
-0.0192194935,
-0.0274288021,
0.008450944,
-0.0395614803,
-0.0064669242,
0.0138540994,
-0.0167287253,
-0.0282921996,
-0.0146477725,
0.0045850803,
-0.0115481941,
-0.0058658058,
0.0498231314,
-0.0069583426,
-0.0070599602,
-0.0201681387,
-0.0138214044,
-0.0242588017,
-0.0042082639,
-0.0175509062,
0.0126130199,
0.0311267097,
-0.0037473284,
0.023735946,
-0.0066046771,
-0.0657704026,
0.0082238996,
0.019379206,
0.0035387222,
-0.0593900606,
0.0022217443,
-0.0071129999,
0.0019928028,
-0.0024502801,
-0.0014567779,
-0.0194768272,
-0.0043833894,
-0.0078189531,
-0.0106089283,
-0.0435856543,
0.0238057654,
-0.0339366943,
-0.0019752174,
0.0003675842,
-0.060845416,
0.048240833,
0.0158659816,
0.0632971376,
-0.0565635301,
-0.0085684191,
-0.0435004607,
0.0804813579,
-0.0119107952,
0.0058147181,
-0.0168634299,
-0.0479459614,
-0.0091379592,
0.020363979,
0.040691644,
-0.0543068796,
0.1041511819,
-0.0284017157,
0.0234052893,
-0.0229019243,
-0.0349320397,
-0.0382276177,
-0.0383016691,
-0.0027224643,
0.0401095562,
0.003566571,
0.0074933367,
0.0105444277,
-0.0038694078,
-0.0122785186,
-0.0064366437,
0.0064607919,
-0.0028351177,
-0.0289295129,
0.0169650353,
0.0284052752,
0.0052231061,
-0.0026001539,
-0.0200152285,
0.0353169516,
0.0421653613,
0.0236133467,
-0.0009944697,
0.0469431467,
0.0198757425,
0.0168017168,
-0.0558651537,
-0.0076949224,
0.0499225222,
0.007686004,
-0.0868017823,
0.0212596357,
0.1093486696,
0.0273953173,
-0.0182006862,
-0.0260452386,
-0.0042604608,
0.0135614425,
0.0488340072,
0.0231652521,
-0.1323282123,
0.0015338247,
0.0044288626,
-0.017396016,
-0.0154815679,
-0.0075482987,
-0.0101357168,
-0.1281387955,
0.0881037563,
0.0225480907,
-0.0160740502,
-0.0393321663,
-0.006723179,
0.0010286635,
0.0059067928,
0.0435050167,
0.0035656581,
-0.0416258685,
-0.027918715,
0.0231023151,
-0.0136182318,
-0.0010368818,
0.0470904782,
-0.0469653681,
0.055072546,
0.0364782996,
0.0248935875,
-0.0370592847,
0.0032089106,
0.0355238356,
0.0036753446,
-0.0282060616,
-0.0166991185,
0.0182873663,
0.0211948864,
0.0064039356,
-0.0451866426,
0.0740325749,
-0.0314130597,
-0.0281996448,
0.0670066029,
0.0727420524,
-0.045320522,
-0.0033246698,
-0.0046152174,
-0.0107468115,
-0.0183665231,
0.0779267475,
0.0129092801,
-0.0077286046,
-0.0336034559,
-0.0505048558,
-0.0626928881,
-0.0487582684,
-0.0175968073,
0.0266703367,
-0.0113965897,
0.0063370252,
-0.0430263393,
-0.018265808,
0.0120633105,
0.0187098533,
0.0277123265,
0.044842843,
0.0450847335,
-0.0379214957,
-0.0230991896,
0.019927213,
-0.067114532,
0.0068325838,
-0.0408132933,
0.0010185026,
0.0001619842,
0.0043309671,
-0.0070145666,
-0.0077510532,
-0.0156213949,
-0.0264593046,
-0.0154456282,
-0.007658062,
0.0052081337,
0.0064120195,
-0.0528418124,
-0.0393757075,
0.038110923,
0.0492381938,
-0.0206070226,
-0.0257484931,
0.0649425909,
-0.0474023372,
-0.0154391052,
0.0240605455,
-0.02151151,
0.0126063572,
0.0332707316,
0.0214879438,
-0.0358318649,
-0.0005881924,
0.0534665547,
0.0609121397,
-0.0232684072,
0.0295650233,
-0.0239239093,
-0.0497417636,
0.0177362021,
-0.0180753749,
-0.0327843912,
-0.0178659372,
-0.0013832477,
0.0428814963,
-0.0327545591,
-0.0299958326,
0.0733477399,
0.0099612456,
-0.0050137923,
-0.0745268911,
0.0269838739,
-0.0046925698,
0.0032240134,
0.0113734677,
-0.036711175,
0.0162928123,
0.0331323706,
-0.0066401381,
0.0421587415,
-0.002400347,
0.0690092593,
0.0032325843,
0.0110196359,
0.016827317,
-0.0251141749,
-0.0333020873,
-0.0476578251,
-0.0203185584,
0.0555585772,
0.0602481514,
-0.0170103665,
0.0087538585,
-0.0436966978,
-0.0154646598,
-0.0205091927,
0.0266574286,
0.0005961906,
-0.0378476456,
0.0454214774,
0.0214211009,
-0.026208736,
0.0100675439,
0.0626601502,
-0.003860001,
0.0465729125,
0.0408666059,
-0.0052697961,
-0.0174965635,
-0.0445737578,
0.0409191065,
0.0159415733,
-0.0438413396,
-0.0038914382,
-0.0694473907,
-0.0484595187,
-0.0464544147,
0.0096600791,
-0.0205739439,
0.0209554639,
0.0191984773,
0.0594169013,
0.0067744311,
-0.0212480687,
-0.050131876,
0.0440548621,
0.0096931122,
-0.0241471324,
0.0028899058,
-5.742407821e-33,
-0.0213507991,
-0.0358477347,
0.0323615,
-0.0089497976,
0.0052079107,
-0.0291959196,
-0.0001711034,
-0.0227995254,
-0.0501180217,
0.0309277829,
-0.0043914248,
0.056564834,
0.0084405933,
0.0209547505,
0.0180704147,
-0.0278848223,
0.0056025954,
0.0122784777,
0.0369533896,
0.0316271745,
0.0171192102,
0.0318414606,
0.0238297265,
-0.0603227466,
0.0193484947,
0.0315480269,
-0.0249659047,
-0.0121064922,
-0.0930610448,
0.0663038865,
-0.0079950262,
0.0601274446,
0.0312397052,
-0.0666393489,
-0.0107151093,
0.0255407337,
-0.0943118408,
0.0183677301,
0.0068398463,
-0.0230353028,
0.0292701591,
-0.0410352945,
0.0361106247,
-0.0060797594,
0.0130413072,
-0.0356904976,
0.0448748767,
-0.0528505631,
-0.0246597715,
-0.0495230891,
-0.0594374277,
0.0628195927,
0.0001595885,
0.0380820297,
0.0084822392,
0.0227208789,
0.0102690673,
0.0586404279,
-0.0625591725,
-0.0075548287,
0.0346029401,
0.0321900323,
0.0277534518,
-0.0620444976,
0.0016433024,
0.0280663744,
-0.0337140858,
-0.0071577076,
-0.0288814399,
0.010195069,
0.0227456409,
0.103747353,
0.0262042563,
0.057572484,
0.0049522393,
-0.0251137149,
-0.1089828163,
-0.0157363638,
0.0197852682,
0.0364945531,
0.0025430915,
-0.0109501351,
-0.0281493478,
-0.0095307808,
-0.0190157481,
-0.0103816586,
-0.009747168,
0.0070023732,
0.0321210921,
0.0146411629,
0.0041930089,
-0.0306292493,
-0.0018997021,
-0.0684771836,
-0.0336139128,
0.0538668446,
-0.0108339544,
-0.0242418889,
-0.0069289408,
0.065709509,
-0.0808696598,
-0.0486692265,
0.0002746734,
-0.0676116049,
-0.0180829987,
0.0009256771,
0.0670322329,
-0.0119230319,
-0.065776974,
-0.0157463308,
0.0047257794,
0.0180769302,
0.0375500545,
0.052015923,
-0.0032088032,
0.0439398699,
0.0378401913,
0.0344713591,
0.0341508202,
-0.0430938676,
-0.039511431,
-0.0474090315,
-0.0331082419,
-0.0257419255,
-0.0027023165,
0.0264725946,
-0.0101099387,
0.050508298,
0.0662175789,
-0.0157589484,
0.0015919917,
0.0523784831,
2.516e-7,
0.0763437748,
0.0124083133,
-0.0054826019,
0.0449598208,
-0.0183235388,
0.0370571986,
-0.0048879446,
0.0582020655,
0.0250802077,
-0.0254618004,
0.0052979891,
0.0116613787,
0.0831188858,
0.0400114246,
-0.0805842876,
-0.0021517633,
-0.0470593795,
-0.0420629568,
-0.0430047363,
0.0307265446,
0.0202727932,
0.1085089147,
0.0073733912,
-0.0330590233,
0.0220293608,
-0.0329840668,
0.0385435745,
-0.0296405237,
-0.0395283252,
0.0247767512,
0.0706110299,
-0.0227732826,
0.0106793093,
0.0272194706,
-0.0108852042,
0.0499041639,
-0.0194420218,
0.1002468839,
0.0130606368,
0.0364124253,
-0.0301808938,
-0.0719447583,
0.0137043949,
-0.0457246639,
0.0675981417,
0.0169582292,
0.0042738039,
-0.0143743642,
-0.0129780164,
-0.0528363585,
0.0030842891,
-0.0098465187,
-0.0106911287,
-0.013283019,
0.0389221832,
-0.017270172,
0.0181247257,
-0.0754946396,
-0.0364168622,
-0.0030695179,
-0.0311045609,
-0.002014152,
-0.0076332125,
0.0029600989,
0.0091260616,
-0.051671274,
0.0438588746,
2.259687229e-34,
0.0288412739,
-0.021114964,
0.001155419,
0.0477578379,
0.0308746081,
0.0276152138,
-0.0157848019,
0.0068657966,
-0.016702868,
-0.0819203183,
0.0019117582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14884v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14884v1 | FlowBench: Revisiting and Benchmarking Workflow-Guided Planning for LLM-based Agents | 2024-06-21T06:13:00 | 2024-06-21T06:13:00 | Ruixuan Xiao, Wentao Ma, Ke Wang, Yuchuan Wu, Junbo Zhao, Haobo Wang, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | LLM-based agents have emerged as promising tools, which are crafted to
fulfill complex tasks by iterative planning and action. However, these agents
are susceptible to undesired planning hallucinations when lacking specific
knowledge for expertise-intensive tasks. To address this, preliminary attempts
are made to enhance planning reliability by incorporating external
workflow-related knowledge. Despite the promise, such infused knowledge is
mostly disorganized and diverse in formats, lacking rigorous formalization and
comprehensive comparisons. Motivated by this, we formalize different formats of
workflow knowledge and present FlowBench, the first benchmark for
workflow-guided planning. FlowBench covers 51 different scenarios from 6
domains, with knowledge presented in diverse formats. To assess different LLMs
on FlowBench, we design a multi-tiered evaluation framework. We evaluate the
efficacy of workflow knowledge across multiple formats, and the results
indicate that current LLM agents need considerable improvements for
satisfactory planning. We hope that our challenging benchmark can pave the way
for future agent planning research. | [
0.0080958791,
-0.0147260195,
-0.0188555047,
-0.0383051038,
-0.067125164,
-0.0136530967,
0.003214,
0.0313015953,
0.0254143085,
0.0039826934,
0.0037255648,
0.0269608013,
-0.0205392092,
0.0609572567,
-0.009465741,
-0.0578715876,
0.0006885796,
-0.0209781472,
-0.0479781181,
0.008338701,
-0.0222812798,
-0.0363404118,
-0.0184423048,
0.0271996763,
0.0149798431,
0.0064178202,
-0.0429062508,
0.0732330456,
0.0086791357,
-0.0253271908,
-0.0031588571,
0.0062401774,
-0.0031440309,
0.0013587245,
0.0000022347,
-0.0727471188,
0.0466991216,
-0.0128359459,
-0.0593953133,
-0.0266718548,
-0.0280939378,
0.0206295662,
-0.0130634615,
0.034148857,
0.0115161929,
0.0341610052,
0.005371911,
0.0445405282,
0.0287060793,
0.0542377606,
-0.0168944579,
0.0552797876,
0.0088079823,
0.0473570451,
0.0387010612,
-0.0568547696,
-0.0003502368,
0.0061071808,
0.0302296635,
-0.0199699327,
0.0136380875,
-0.0225735437,
0.0110602388,
0.0041149268,
0.0056402427,
0.0188648906,
0.0086931149,
-0.0521118529,
-0.056338571,
0.048174385,
0.0181762632,
0.0290362723,
0.0293427613,
-0.02215546,
-0.0358563624,
0.0094084805,
-0.0101333223,
0.0027631556,
-0.0203461889,
-0.0616278611,
-0.0309916902,
-0.0034185529,
0.0067300741,
-0.0062593608,
-0.0151403593,
0.0821413845,
-0.013648971,
0.016624013,
0.0296778549,
-0.0175266843,
0.0744265541,
-0.0742530972,
0.040076673,
0.0851763561,
-0.0767971575,
-0.0210487377,
0.0392024331,
0.0500939116,
0.0190047864,
0.0134424986,
0.0460271463,
0.0169016253,
-0.0150219565,
0.0101830559,
-0.0044572619,
0.0516650155,
-0.0295267031,
0.0303014833,
-0.0039072963,
0.023163937,
-0.0627704784,
0.0461807698,
-0.0236240514,
0.0049793287,
-0.0641320273,
-0.0137156509,
-0.0022351108,
0.0616290234,
-0.0352086201,
0.0870437026,
0.0184563585,
0.0070019816,
0.0142950574,
-0.0309160594,
-0.083771795,
-0.0449430868,
-0.0822251365,
0.0142900376,
-0.0043426845,
0.0049905148,
0.0055182781,
0.0209731702,
-0.0313074663,
-0.0041506249,
-0.0080468105,
0.0723491982,
0.0424228981,
0.0155776283,
-0.0459951125,
-0.0745172203,
0.0601905957,
-0.0660634637,
0.0292330701,
-0.0483408011,
0.02586562,
-0.0070161805,
-0.0611427799,
0.0069171633,
-0.003493191,
-0.0209214184,
0.0132139232,
0.010721867,
-0.0016588554,
0.0413913578,
-0.0140174627,
0.0376046672,
-0.0380203575,
0.0077934572,
-0.0036454489,
0.0397069827,
0.014578389,
0.0305594988,
0.0527055413,
0.0284392387,
-0.0685582161,
0.0106694214,
0.0508676209,
0.0750102326,
0.0006796084,
0.0128430994,
0.0081909643,
-0.0388878845,
0.0085722543,
0.0251163784,
0.0274193529,
0.0402130075,
0.0144125009,
-0.036361292,
0.0180548336,
0.0435198508,
0.0154500632,
-0.0075006993,
-0.0471367761,
0.0741757229,
-0.0224699881,
-0.0244421661,
-0.0781849399,
0.0269893501,
-0.0503299609,
-0.0406901538,
0.0094180647,
-0.0025579296,
-0.0026287544,
-0.0213900451,
0.0024722517,
0.0278316736,
-0.0644224659,
0.0058171712,
-0.0433713458,
-0.0221087765,
-0.0576824658,
-0.0417537577,
-0.0187509526,
0.0857406706,
0.072315909,
-0.0568199307,
-0.0812095702,
0.012766595,
0.0106333597,
0.028816158,
0.0291473232,
0.0017408488,
-0.0076132957,
-0.0428104065,
-0.0687770844,
-0.0132581992,
0.0067627658,
0.0248264242,
0.0302980375,
-0.038321089,
-0.0264862236,
-0.0043092207,
-0.0301109292,
0.0333844386,
-0.0337086059,
-0.0156864021,
0.0076401285,
0.0146308895,
0.0550526902,
0.0064573633,
0.0095481789,
0.0168733988,
0.0559138805,
0.0402908809,
-0.0371165983,
0.0082763284,
0.0101556415,
0.0269845221,
-0.0211110841,
0.0136428578,
0.0226626787,
-0.032170888,
-0.0216773953,
-0.0305430908,
-0.0175629575,
0.0384414308,
-0.0065635797,
0.0407371931,
0.0476145037,
-0.0042524743,
-0.0519923903,
0.0033595138,
0.0100849671,
0.032331001,
-0.0303495154,
0.0075609731,
0.0455035754,
0.0119449971,
0.0327070728,
0.0463311784,
0.01729789,
0.0167650543,
0.0267378315,
0.0211128853,
0.0078934878,
-0.0316553265,
-0.0371160805,
-0.0383596495,
0.0292670932,
-0.0219187178,
0.0089881783,
-0.0080608316,
-0.0234353188,
-0.0038644965,
-0.0125743179,
-0.0148483505,
0.0795567408,
-0.009971288,
-0.0037969227,
0.0013017914,
0.0431187376,
-0.0313916802,
0.0062936437,
0.0511553548,
-0.002555225,
-0.0325278416,
0.0163000338,
-0.0136643676,
-0.0472455658,
0.0568755344,
-0.0539899729,
-0.0293617193,
-0.0230338331,
0.0131872501,
0.012397117,
0.0009695182,
-0.0247314628,
-0.010380026,
-0.0484494381,
-0.0044227154,
0.0631395131,
-0.0537966527,
-0.0243348908,
0.0248129647,
-0.0185547639,
-0.0163673386,
-0.0782400817,
-0.0016590201,
0.0084466562,
0.0035731196,
-0.0216925014,
0.0479626395,
0.0005377955,
-0.0366032943,
0.0369405933,
-0.0348816626,
0.0442901999,
-0.0370676219,
-0.0301222336,
0.0754112601,
-0.0405575633,
-0.0418946557,
0.0199814644,
0.0131724142,
-0.027980227,
0.0301231574,
-0.038049601,
-0.0722533464,
0.0551049076,
-0.0131379189,
-0.0149158025,
-0.0304563995,
0.0019005041,
-0.0386721902,
-0.0276744422,
-0.0117819412,
-0.0168473274,
0.0358401053,
-0.0477327257,
-0.0143453805,
-0.0016770296,
-0.0147213619,
-0.0322664268,
0.0409191884,
-0.0038008436,
0.0233277343,
-0.0302860066,
-0.0461746007,
-0.0380121134,
-0.0028564602,
0.0193512104,
0.0471375771,
-0.0012972708,
-0.0517171063,
-0.0291881636,
-0.0268210843,
-0.0438344665,
-0.0004363055,
0.0110307615,
0.0231119916,
0.0345645137,
0.0458918586,
0.0106826676,
-0.0635841191,
-0.0224156789,
-0.0090487702,
0.0114494571,
-0.032946676,
0.0320277251,
0.0535609536,
0.0598755814,
-0.0225815251,
-0.0246645249,
0.0373218954,
0.0573107824,
-0.0482021049,
0.0303915553,
-0.0358404107,
0.0323943049,
0.0517422482,
0.0687663704,
-0.0156702586,
-0.0168962181,
0.0041381032,
0.0154963685,
-0.0156132635,
-0.0617147908,
-0.0001963512,
-0.0102282865,
0.072039403,
-0.0036419267,
0.0252279118,
0.0370616168,
-0.083349444,
0.007858065,
0.0310923699,
-0.0013576954,
0.0167378355,
0.013741035,
-0.0767188519,
0.0053307591,
-0.0416102856,
-0.0114348959,
0.0358207859,
-0.0052399267,
0.0279951449,
0.0505000427,
0.0093990471,
-0.0175485704,
0.001411339,
0.0070864046,
0.0748357251,
0.0614817478,
-0.0172571,
0.0554142855,
0.026188612,
0.0193864275,
-0.0190375261,
-0.0171308052,
-0.0634625554,
-0.0544959903,
0.0832035169,
0.0887485743,
-0.0781576335,
-0.0316013061,
-0.0102079548,
-0.0290650669,
0.0152617311,
0.045581013,
-0.0350214355,
-0.0169572104,
-0.0503336191,
-0.0294065848,
0.0141844312,
-0.0257842001,
-0.0141712232,
0.0067719775,
0.0031853456,
0.0340506509,
-0.0320267119,
-0.0673277751,
0.0412919857,
0.0458781309,
0.019441057,
-0.0410132743,
-0.0182403103,
0.0371670462,
0.0067060976,
-0.0308771711,
0.0060243122,
0.048279278,
-0.0119122537,
-0.0148380753,
-0.0232847705,
-0.0146801742,
0.0310557522,
0.0292728916,
-0.0740431547,
0.0153913451,
-0.0190233178,
0.0491520129,
0.0300546717,
-0.0157888532,
0.0054481621,
0.0156231625,
0.0271933824,
-0.013450481,
-0.0341495238,
0.0138799893,
0.0095166331,
0.0328593403,
-0.0133841559,
-0.0152091347,
-0.0621504597,
0.0040403921,
0.0068628695,
0.0308859572,
-0.0344114751,
-0.0299182441,
-0.019314399,
0.0242529977,
-0.0569225401,
-0.0001499892,
-0.0185969826,
-0.001646175,
0.047449965,
0.0191822723,
0.0074981661,
-0.0221533794,
0.0276530348,
-0.0316388085,
-0.0259117503,
0.0788046718,
0.0708783641,
-0.0101640821,
-0.0221012253,
0.0025928123,
-0.0033516125,
-0.0159952268,
-0.0069970759,
0.0223943442,
0.0022647297,
-0.0142304748,
0.0203944799,
0.0220468193,
0.0315909162,
0.0333154351,
0.0293033794,
-0.0188691188,
0.0364533514,
-0.0673087612,
-0.012077379,
-0.0630152524,
-0.0781782791,
0.0570591614,
0.0309403725,
0.0421085171,
0.0014007917,
-0.002307418,
-0.0863081887,
0.0294742733,
-0.0270747636,
-0.0309870243,
-0.0175706651,
-0.0026648212,
-0.0295969378,
0.0256138612,
-0.0022628312,
-0.0398765691,
0.0324197114,
-0.0406602696,
0.0827399939,
-0.04098849,
-0.0909938812,
-0.0671772733,
-0.1024341211,
0.0090182554,
0.0310343336,
-0.0151794385,
-0.0524640046,
-0.0977980718,
-0.0024108132,
0.0272043347,
-0.0276475009,
-0.0120481281,
-0.0404625908,
-0.0002931593,
0.0236627832,
0.0293796081,
-0.004404665,
0.0034426192,
-0.0981625468,
-0.0265115649,
0.016841976,
-0.0271962751,
-5.433158767e-33,
0.0338597968,
-0.0639629886,
0.0916413888,
-0.0061897542,
0.0461645536,
-0.0235250629,
-0.0511535853,
0.0077059125,
0.0149609698,
0.0337397754,
-0.0395374261,
-0.0103503112,
0.0270172786,
-0.0615593977,
0.0284815896,
0.0400932096,
0.0176726859,
-0.0067856819,
-0.0525744967,
-0.0138933929,
0.0267831068,
0.0096698012,
0.0108666262,
-0.0169193279,
-0.0116997901,
0.0258436408,
0.0064674066,
0.0366138071,
-0.0306405723,
0.0194411203,
-0.0020352879,
0.0150125828,
0.0067294831,
0.0442367308,
-0.0130433636,
-0.0259878673,
0.00226678,
-0.0478051379,
0.0113364663,
-0.0186054111,
-0.0708452314,
0.0087451255,
-0.0013498043,
0.0388401039,
-0.0612636432,
0.0126282247,
0.0121488143,
0.0041827662,
-0.0051557459,
0.0049736714,
-0.0483288728,
0.0233816374,
0.0094971675,
-0.0034987244,
0.0289119873,
0.0239529088,
0.0025279352,
-0.0759738311,
-0.0635546148,
0.0244156234,
-0.0396120362,
-0.030062126,
0.0297892578,
0.0107244132,
-0.0029337087,
0.0304702763,
0.0025641902,
0.0652210563,
0.0039683715,
0.0432741418,
-0.0241772197,
0.126138702,
-0.0140857799,
-0.0166623555,
-0.0522202328,
-0.0042116125,
0.0106367283,
0.0664726719,
0.0107405083,
0.0670801029,
0.038748052,
-0.0173826199,
-0.0412624143,
0.0019558321,
-0.0083196228,
0.0274911262,
-0.0130574955,
0.0117380302,
0.0238750149,
0.0228990074,
0.032282792,
-0.0112092551,
0.0073918877,
0.0217453428,
0.0123691615,
0.0160996392,
0.0037158185,
0.032047838,
0.0090455916,
0.0048861769,
-0.0276434291,
-0.0591884814,
-0.0141380783,
-0.0137181412,
0.0400577597,
0.0146286692,
0.0072954786,
0.0303737763,
-0.0420183577,
0.0163224991,
-0.0913773328,
0.021509761,
0.0248923805,
-0.0424567685,
0.0112581933,
-0.0198694095,
0.0018552751,
0.0289307553,
-0.0293082278,
-0.0921227485,
0.0122694531,
0.0442955457,
0.0113339033,
0.0001595595,
-0.0247499701,
-0.0154792899,
-0.0272860657,
0.0147816194,
0.0421842262,
0.014642599,
-0.0021563391,
0.0468925424,
2.98e-7,
-0.00491367,
0.0210808478,
0.0140962666,
0.0853104442,
0.0402977392,
0.0277057737,
-0.0549555756,
-0.056457445,
-0.0604740456,
-0.0517926216,
0.0775682703,
0.0315383188,
0.0440759733,
0.0413154624,
-0.0431210026,
-0.0809574053,
0.046855621,
0.0106857195,
-0.0489490964,
-0.0318504982,
0.0306762941,
-0.0097406283,
0.0334822983,
-0.0273742247,
0.0119915772,
-0.0018769566,
0.0074581606,
-0.0276480895,
0.052332513,
0.0422865488,
-0.0083946707,
-0.016578313,
0.0092592845,
0.0282987878,
-0.0061645578,
-0.0310984738,
-0.05254573,
0.1041253731,
-0.0156390518,
-0.0584678948,
-0.0256728027,
-0.0426245295,
0.0230192617,
0.0110320952,
-0.0187225044,
0.036416322,
-0.0095749497,
0.0217097253,
-0.0256991219,
-0.0096763251,
0.0077428403,
0.0317469984,
0.028681213,
0.034568835,
-0.0132398084,
-0.0077485107,
-0.02025754,
-0.0440990441,
0.0256858338,
-0.0218546409,
-0.02917956,
-0.0415586866,
-0.057885278,
0.0360468924,
-0.0065412684,
-0.0247443896,
-0.0118291928,
2.754452112e-34,
-0.0313685052,
0.0253651105,
0.0107128052,
0.0650466979,
0.0118193617,
0.0287134796,
0.008212937,
0.0452633277,
0.0341370367,
-0.0225505326,
-0.0198109839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14883v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14883v1 | OATH-Frames: Characterizing Online Attitudes Towards Homelessness with LLM Assistants | 2024-06-21T06:09:47 | 2024-06-21T06:09:47 | Jaspreet Ranjit, Brihi Joshi, Rebecca Dorn, Laura Petry, Olga Koumoundouros, Jayne Bottarini, Peichen Liu, Eric Rice, Swabha Swayamdipta | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Warning: Contents of this paper may be upsetting.
Public attitudes towards key societal issues, expressed on online media, are
of immense value in policy and reform efforts, yet challenging to understand at
scale. We study one such social issue: homelessness in the U.S., by leveraging
the remarkable capabilities of large language models to assist social work
experts in analyzing millions of posts from Twitter. We introduce a framing
typology: Online Attitudes Towards Homelessness (OATH) Frames: nine
hierarchical frames capturing critiques, responses and perceptions. We release
annotations with varying degrees of assistance from language models, with
immense benefits in scaling: 6.5x speedup in annotation time while only
incurring a 3 point F1 reduction in performance with respect to the domain
experts. Our experiments demonstrate the value of modeling OATH-Frames over
existing sentiment and toxicity classifiers. Our large-scale analysis with
predicted OATH-Frames on 2.4M posts on homelessness reveal key trends in
attitudes across states, time periods and vulnerable populations, enabling new
insights on the issue. Our work provides a general framework to understand
nuanced public attitudes at scale, on issues beyond homelessness. | [
0.0186402183,
0.0999744833,
0.0039172666,
0.000179854,
-0.0046141767,
0.0355460383,
0.018859908,
-0.0092853811,
0.0483963192,
-0.0892861336,
0.0243006647,
0.0058024498,
-0.0537258349,
0.02643851,
-0.0157256834,
-0.0511851534,
-0.0186265241,
0.0615922101,
0.0488669202,
-0.008779224,
0.0543584563,
0.026406778,
0.0034904664,
0.056264244,
-0.0151535869,
-0.0330239199,
-0.0002273511,
0.0079549821,
0.0162697472,
-0.0591358282,
0.0527600348,
0.0765927136,
0.0082949353,
0.0293170679,
0.0000020075,
0.0000559321,
0.0150811896,
0.0012863191,
0.0318408497,
-0.0553909019,
0.0627074093,
-0.0894844308,
0.0194167923,
0.0206366498,
-0.0455497839,
-0.0379057117,
0.0624487437,
0.0234520324,
0.0692875534,
0.0292032585,
-0.0060570538,
-0.0314297043,
-0.0191337094,
0.0063935127,
-0.0254666973,
-0.0024154282,
0.0498483293,
-0.0259048678,
-0.0383298397,
-0.0155743416,
0.0126467105,
-0.006276981,
-0.0314477459,
-0.0172478724,
0.0023856633,
-0.0377499759,
-0.020974692,
-0.014588858,
-0.0034413051,
0.0814667791,
0.0653939471,
0.0062218443,
-0.0023913027,
-0.0098069757,
0.0203096215,
0.047754854,
-0.0432909392,
0.0423751771,
-0.0066993032,
0.0366557278,
-0.0223745219,
0.0041946862,
0.0386498533,
0.0317730606,
0.0294844881,
0.0317147747,
-0.0460184999,
-0.0214414317,
-0.0050019631,
0.037328247,
-0.0139415767,
-0.0279962718,
0.0120135061,
0.0061968956,
-0.0157485288,
0.0274394713,
-0.017134035,
-0.0091174245,
0.0115533229,
-0.0743734315,
0.0237749629,
0.0437370911,
-0.0065612858,
0.0108266752,
0.0568186752,
-0.0141792819,
-0.0194219351,
0.0010679568,
-0.0106747542,
0.0186806247,
-0.0938448459,
0.0459968485,
-0.0078873597,
0.0041274368,
-0.0344044231,
0.0483803414,
-0.0321536586,
0.0256728139,
-0.0447161905,
-0.0110529391,
-0.0466042571,
-0.0066649765,
0.0294345189,
0.0146901533,
-0.0442941077,
0.0576432459,
-0.0204120446,
0.0243738964,
-0.0249982364,
-0.0319666937,
0.0256384443,
0.0177402552,
0.005134224,
-0.0142159527,
-0.0019734805,
0.0462214798,
0.060274139,
0.0115653845,
-0.0358559676,
-0.0385547653,
-0.0146000097,
-0.0204470027,
-0.00197413,
-0.0892313272,
0.0018262129,
0.0216382537,
0.0130013777,
-0.0311081521,
0.0179737788,
0.0223786775,
-0.0693532005,
0.0538598746,
-0.0566484295,
-0.0169162564,
0.0240560975,
0.0492324382,
0.0274408683,
0.0848669857,
-0.0141730756,
0.0248641632,
0.0493452884,
-0.0281498097,
-0.0097438348,
-0.0023464225,
-0.023521198,
0.0098369224,
-0.0028841333,
0.0184727609,
-0.0251778793,
-0.0100430809,
-0.0054765679,
0.0353173986,
0.0294234771,
-0.0036852255,
0.0613763593,
0.0600570366,
-0.0353496186,
0.0420261025,
0.0038745161,
0.0305496249,
-0.0153419077,
-0.039665807,
-0.0191311538,
0.0011789486,
0.0136427619,
-0.0447334275,
0.0174215026,
0.0251923017,
-0.0103621855,
-0.0554298945,
-0.058829207,
0.0093264384,
0.0062290872,
-0.0344050527,
-0.0110290647,
-0.0314948447,
-0.0149282571,
0.0529822037,
0.0386199355,
-0.0361749865,
-0.0120630898,
-0.0479317829,
0.0043611471,
0.084503524,
0.003468995,
-0.0174761936,
-0.0204116553,
-0.0557113066,
0.0595672019,
0.0586560965,
0.0325635411,
0.0063542044,
-0.0458216928,
-0.0099254558,
-0.027238043,
0.0220915712,
0.0382375717,
0.0063495375,
0.0027698472,
0.0024932341,
-0.0042518657,
-0.0181319639,
-0.0494740121,
0.0311498512,
0.0693173781,
0.0109626092,
-0.0192304254,
0.0200089589,
0.0337163806,
0.0388106331,
0.0101174684,
-0.0124751888,
-0.0009540541,
-0.0245241672,
-0.0697092488,
0.0063002147,
-0.0237155389,
0.0206982493,
0.0296776108,
-0.0432767421,
-0.0274879262,
0.0338104665,
-0.032790672,
0.0357735008,
0.0336486883,
-0.0204241443,
0.0103994068,
-0.0088306442,
-0.0417204238,
-0.0392566249,
-0.0155225154,
-0.0323260352,
0.074907206,
-0.0555261821,
0.0092837308,
-0.0207101647,
-0.0501405261,
0.0031399566,
0.0190437585,
-0.0345901437,
-0.0325796381,
0.0137042012,
0.0369529203,
0.01741907,
0.0008001097,
-0.0297439564,
-0.0049142768,
-0.110936977,
-0.0072923368,
-0.0456077605,
-0.0004174328,
0.0130700991,
-0.0124742426,
-0.0007965281,
0.0186112709,
-0.0220966004,
-0.0503735095,
-0.0402118824,
0.0428822152,
0.0326946788,
-0.0081888111,
0.0171962306,
-0.0531031825,
0.0003216825,
-0.0391808227,
0.0079876389,
-0.0027630106,
-0.0728138685,
0.005672121,
0.0213160478,
-0.0169610493,
-0.0107534025,
0.0044995602,
-0.0251864325,
0.0136623038,
0.0025202495,
-0.0129981469,
-0.0241462644,
0.0201140419,
0.0950735584,
0.0523212142,
0.0442415923,
-0.016439775,
0.0018842176,
-0.0158570278,
0.0029971062,
-0.0574068278,
-0.0672764182,
-0.0043665655,
0.0771445185,
0.0200348925,
-0.0085976347,
-0.0487729199,
0.0488192961,
-0.0502753593,
-0.0109143285,
-0.0389935374,
0.0166402943,
0.0135475043,
0.0183636285,
-0.0120254448,
-0.0282162093,
0.0179872848,
0.0214496795,
0.0380008668,
-0.0087278262,
-0.0409610868,
-0.0541934259,
0.0275953449,
0.0054986146,
0.0172875077,
-0.0293601491,
0.004843954,
0.018085381,
-0.0647733435,
-0.0136332726,
-0.0271610208,
0.0373088345,
-0.0483830944,
0.0100299073,
0.0168914348,
-0.0655560866,
-0.0088293497,
-0.1045771241,
-0.0813721567,
-0.0140214665,
-0.033307299,
-0.0285183843,
-0.015741108,
0.0217675883,
-0.0121241119,
-0.0103934985,
0.0235787239,
-0.042975843,
0.0014541753,
0.0207298454,
0.0215470865,
0.0196750928,
0.0062283161,
0.0351082534,
0.0213909484,
0.0593343042,
0.003976068,
0.0537046753,
-0.0360576324,
0.0007041395,
-0.0012898402,
-0.0066701225,
-0.0028239978,
-0.0311100539,
0.0326224975,
-0.0170237459,
0.0138612334,
0.1110799536,
0.0354497917,
-0.0180816185,
-0.0026965947,
-0.0282086004,
0.0077610132,
0.0348412618,
-0.0056618107,
-0.096348092,
-0.0202559102,
-0.0255605914,
0.0418388173,
-0.0531956553,
-0.0565397032,
0.0127472673,
-0.080670692,
0.0494661629,
-0.0178543311,
0.0584910065,
0.0036398997,
-0.0363946892,
0.0201176293,
-0.0318068005,
-0.0157699306,
-0.0667659864,
-0.0017130696,
0.0211156495,
0.0119744269,
-0.0379639938,
0.0171866007,
0.0160855912,
-0.0449929386,
0.0731885582,
0.0003691483,
0.0894886181,
-0.0342400335,
-0.006931731,
0.0253443271,
0.0301957503,
-0.0035139038,
-0.0332334675,
0.0302364249,
-0.0209905244,
-0.0170995072,
-0.0301461834,
0.0322861187,
-0.0639561638,
-0.0218472481,
-0.0005016302,
0.0538349561,
-0.0109678777,
-0.0193335321,
-0.0299889091,
0.0492970608,
0.0563973784,
0.0638025105,
0.0292545334,
-0.0274659116,
0.0349094048,
-0.0549095832,
-0.0147649134,
-0.0067459745,
-0.0449356288,
-0.0087074097,
-0.0078867255,
0.0232794341,
-0.0341561548,
-0.0211580452,
0.0012483231,
0.0208754241,
0.0086689414,
-0.0274180938,
0.0406054482,
0.0224182121,
-0.0776618198,
0.0531664826,
-0.0261154398,
0.0151726035,
0.0154612195,
-0.0489056632,
0.0196471922,
0.0343683362,
-0.0359195136,
0.0297930241,
-0.0130775832,
-0.0358525775,
0.0572295375,
0.0089316918,
0.0226927735,
0.0082683126,
0.0120920027,
-0.0147396177,
0.0261907987,
0.0815099478,
0.0043016314,
0.0028823067,
0.0316208601,
0.0518735014,
0.0022329467,
0.0304003358,
-0.0007328438,
0.0431457311,
0.0052094925,
-0.015800396,
-0.0666885301,
0.0238321703,
-0.0207917094,
-0.0299953148,
0.0526263043,
0.0289972145,
-0.0324723199,
-0.02486239,
-0.0437788144,
-0.0082721282,
-0.0341823921,
0.0026182418,
-0.0075259926,
0.0404671095,
0.0051867361,
-0.0886942521,
0.0521884039,
-0.0358688645,
0.0350978933,
-0.0390714966,
0.068624571,
-0.0065769437,
0.0179555044,
0.0002821972,
-0.0317483395,
-0.008571757,
0.0271384586,
0.0105545027,
0.0159248915,
0.0040707802,
0.0296867993,
0.0052901111,
0.0386102386,
0.0171666965,
0.0252776891,
0.0083074905,
-0.0668453351,
-0.0284255911,
0.0219160616,
-0.0123344269,
-0.0092484476,
0.0110884802,
0.0125747947,
-0.0298537035,
0.0165064074,
0.0083534531,
-0.0025128673,
-0.0292425212,
0.0503866747,
0.0203052219,
-0.0365264937,
0.0032658263,
0.0129908891,
-0.0206169616,
0.0556560829,
0.0531315468,
-0.0583555847,
0.0006488084,
-0.0246405937,
-0.034348771,
0.0179810431,
0.0134835774,
-0.0001225284,
-0.0688717142,
-0.0397523157,
0.0243973583,
-0.0475584082,
0.017023813,
0.0071916338,
-0.0020531244,
0.0418901928,
0.0147953797,
0.0349620804,
-0.0625937581,
-0.0012910683,
-0.0507891551,
-0.0371793956,
0.0095518278,
-6.273907959e-33,
-0.0156190461,
-0.0825535208,
-0.0329969302,
-0.0173080713,
-0.0188125502,
-0.0080234725,
0.0092276009,
0.0437899381,
-0.0226693749,
0.015756052,
0.0327991024,
0.0408441387,
0.011001165,
0.0278558247,
0.018316403,
-0.0100210607,
0.01234503,
-0.0156768281,
0.0069745658,
0.0126703754,
0.0241858903,
0.0041687391,
0.0044205245,
-0.0676109344,
0.0700995401,
-0.036762435,
-0.0130395237,
-0.0020940895,
0.0505904816,
0.009361024,
-0.0383322053,
0.0748642907,
0.060832832,
-0.0075330166,
0.0263990276,
0.1094729006,
-0.0398644507,
0.0062975287,
0.0406307653,
0.0035549749,
-0.0148026114,
-0.0397666283,
-0.0002456817,
0.0342498422,
-0.0516216643,
-0.0088088978,
0.0373874865,
-0.0112047344,
0.0642514899,
0.0330236331,
-0.0526664406,
0.0213764515,
-0.0778167099,
0.0312412269,
-0.0255949032,
0.0024525577,
0.0243600123,
0.0804939047,
-0.0691010579,
-0.0077339793,
-0.0517190211,
-0.0162221007,
0.0236415844,
-0.044655107,
-0.009467775,
0.0909652933,
-0.0163604822,
0.0191005636,
-0.0428633094,
0.0281359535,
-0.0036524429,
0.0056781615,
0.044473324,
0.0536523685,
0.0296273567,
-0.0179955903,
-0.0650935322,
0.0053592874,
0.0456383117,
0.0156694967,
0.0358968452,
-0.0134137953,
-0.0333260931,
-0.0055763437,
-0.0554576628,
-0.1259323806,
-0.0359550156,
-0.0177998468,
-0.0020179115,
-0.0300227553,
-0.0162856188,
0.0294995923,
-0.0013783649,
-0.020392077,
-0.0297155306,
0.0148314964,
-0.0198859908,
0.0122335749,
0.0107232695,
0.0464329123,
-0.0470273905,
0.0105469823,
-0.0369988382,
0.0500908904,
0.0515925661,
-0.0265133921,
0.0736556277,
-0.0187248942,
-0.0815954655,
-0.0232675876,
-0.0108948862,
0.0553777143,
-0.0375458673,
0.0479715429,
0.0148899164,
0.0117094526,
0.017335251,
0.0471953973,
0.0162375066,
0.0347901024,
-0.007792173,
0.0035141862,
-0.0349923745,
-0.005522436,
-0.0240644496,
-0.0513089411,
-0.0079932008,
0.0132417269,
0.022110397,
-0.0733676702,
-0.011862047,
-0.0413100235,
2.614e-7,
0.0676918477,
0.074817732,
-0.0268215239,
-0.0192092862,
0.0299836565,
0.0383755565,
0.022555761,
0.0389556624,
-0.0268282071,
-0.0360694379,
-0.0147861391,
0.0248918831,
0.0288538523,
0.0215662252,
-0.0860996619,
0.0135912681,
-0.0328544565,
0.032722149,
-0.0519654676,
0.0494668037,
0.0262374915,
0.0744929686,
0.0153774377,
-0.0146460636,
-0.0077820341,
-0.0308043398,
0.0368357338,
-0.0437657759,
-0.0214758553,
0.0254984368,
-0.0105423816,
0.0340278372,
-0.0077982577,
-0.0290637054,
-0.0283670817,
0.0068785758,
0.0244131554,
0.0586087368,
0.0134176537,
-0.0341972448,
-0.0073232097,
-0.0079664271,
0.0214815401,
-0.0083895084,
0.0549972169,
-0.0613563173,
-0.038141083,
-0.0721003935,
-0.0126416385,
-0.0188937169,
0.0382156819,
-0.0097195357,
-0.0160936024,
0.0037987737,
0.0129123228,
-0.0426672138,
-0.0129472977,
-0.0716352984,
-0.0207346492,
-0.0277778432,
-0.0455892682,
-0.042891819,
0.0021592758,
-0.0071180011,
0.0446955077,
-0.0039611175,
0.0475373641,
1.942578572e-34,
0.0284712948,
0.0234187916,
0.0128651001,
-0.0138515308,
0.0258379914,
0.0230377484,
-0.0333297849,
-0.0165159646,
0.0129727321,
-0.0804924965,
0.0541353337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14882v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14882v1 | 70B-parameter large language models in Japanese medical question-answering | 2024-06-21T06:04:10 | 2024-06-21T06:04:10 | Issey Sukeda, Risa Kishikawa, Satoshi Kodera | cs.CL | cs.CL | Since the rise of large language models (LLMs), the domain adaptation has
been one of the hot topics in various domains. Many medical LLMs trained with
English medical dataset have made public recently. However, Japanese LLMs in
medical domain still lack its research. Here we utilize multiple 70B-parameter
LLMs for the first time and show that instruction tuning using Japanese medical
question-answering dataset significantly improves the ability of Japanese LLMs
to solve Japanese medical license exams, surpassing 50\% in accuracy. In
particular, the Japanese-centric models exhibit a more significant leap in
improvement through instruction tuning compared to their English-centric
counterparts. This underscores the importance of continual pretraining and the
adjustment of the tokenizer in our local language. We also examine two slightly
different prompt formats, resulting in non-negligible performance improvement. | [
0.0392337963,
0.0138445143,
0.0197342653,
-0.0032369511,
0.0022927686,
0.0370634682,
0.0608637445,
0.0378131047,
-0.0197524913,
-0.029973425,
-0.0702863857,
-0.0635464787,
-0.0207742192,
-0.0080387201,
0.0196522251,
-0.0559591055,
0.02399786,
-0.0349560194,
0.0037305285,
-0.0276353396,
-0.0194408633,
-0.0094696693,
-0.032385502,
0.0239688642,
0.0165298097,
-0.0122353835,
0.0443405285,
-0.0187919121,
0.003957653,
-0.0424564071,
0.0092719812,
0.0504685864,
-0.0097083533,
-0.0252318811,
0.0000017814,
-0.0545372218,
0.009050684,
0.0020464244,
-0.0260650776,
0.0405851305,
0.0133928796,
-0.0445230342,
0.0027432751,
0.0612818375,
-0.0488657877,
-0.059528023,
0.0123789627,
0.0342433117,
0.0915145129,
0.0884126648,
-0.0041333134,
-0.0222642384,
0.0144315381,
-0.0255219359,
-0.0150143187,
-0.0415663458,
0.0413144492,
0.0120804664,
0.0298453216,
-0.019767927,
-0.020225795,
0.0076776193,
0.0103149088,
0.0196603015,
-0.037261948,
0.0095716426,
0.0134697706,
0.0234858152,
0.0136033921,
0.0453490987,
0.008443729,
0.0099111171,
-0.0177539196,
0.0086088963,
-0.0017107223,
0.0114461854,
-0.0764712319,
0.032020174,
0.0097459275,
-0.012595024,
0.0440469272,
-0.03941378,
0.0260966551,
0.0243552178,
-0.0361185335,
0.0466800779,
0.0339174792,
-0.0450698845,
0.008577399,
-0.0134895649,
-0.0432257019,
-0.0412907638,
0.0413739644,
0.0970324576,
-0.0547625683,
0.0190417636,
-0.031368129,
-0.0242287647,
0.0674180612,
-0.0628879145,
0.0059421593,
0.0192201007,
-0.0163838603,
0.0347065069,
-0.0109897992,
0.0584477857,
-0.0154155884,
0.0152272237,
-0.0969996974,
-0.0230387431,
-0.0242786482,
-0.0129289851,
-0.0466465466,
0.0026324368,
-0.018222427,
0.0128865745,
-0.0706083104,
0.0198622346,
0.009499507,
-0.0046624499,
0.0200719517,
-0.00359407,
-0.0231451392,
-0.0050105848,
-0.019886367,
0.0492679216,
-0.0375789925,
0.0078645749,
-0.0009237936,
-0.0459969155,
-0.0031339291,
0.0143063888,
0.0200738106,
-0.0418339521,
0.0300622974,
0.041888427,
-0.0014557788,
-0.0109080374,
-0.0119886668,
-0.0092839086,
-0.0268297456,
-0.0101660509,
0.0333817042,
-0.0423760265,
0.0242639612,
0.0168539844,
0.0222699959,
-0.0404539853,
0.007476469,
0.0300073382,
-0.0113262376,
0.0310864449,
-0.0158984251,
0.0425648615,
0.0302733034,
0.0096269296,
0.0098570418,
0.0268625692,
0.0036011541,
-0.044582326,
0.0161123723,
-0.0585041605,
0.0108849285,
0.0391619764,
0.0118496399,
0.0110513978,
0.0239219069,
0.0325305536,
0.042592831,
0.0698744953,
0.0314955749,
0.0354145579,
-0.0038162123,
-0.0303992741,
0.0229327306,
0.0549345352,
-0.0011415638,
0.00545569,
0.0425400734,
-0.0594797842,
0.0256490353,
0.0054166694,
-0.0355166681,
-0.0099272449,
-0.0134568932,
0.0291449055,
-0.0313903578,
0.0098142615,
-0.0432143919,
-0.0259591322,
-0.0434589423,
-0.0162796061,
-0.0624348074,
0.0133243715,
0.0391375758,
0.0101858424,
-0.0010546977,
0.0957629085,
0.0510379411,
-0.01487411,
0.0028086749,
-0.0629363805,
0.0036404049,
0.037327759,
0.030378025,
-0.0258220285,
-0.0529336818,
0.0002697547,
0.0891267657,
0.0217090938,
0.0646947026,
-0.02541098,
-0.0059492202,
-0.0505973808,
0.0013313995,
0.0118252467,
-0.0069782822,
-0.0002099066,
0.0195897333,
0.0465977676,
-0.000389354,
-0.0170553885,
-0.0079335868,
0.0355804451,
-0.0766670555,
-0.0396783091,
-0.0057742805,
0.0088711819,
0.032130558,
0.0022252137,
-0.0173842311,
0.0139095625,
0.0266132504,
-0.0507804602,
0.0082916543,
-0.0156717915,
-0.0527392812,
-0.0272732172,
0.0594674796,
0.0116533209,
-0.0080242306,
-0.0160522368,
-0.029886255,
-0.0418665074,
-0.0503375679,
-0.0250201263,
-0.0002522234,
-0.0306039229,
0.0420019515,
0.0183750354,
0.0106769549,
-0.0543521158,
0.01317719,
0.0149615165,
0.0240477547,
0.0444338433,
-0.0221556947,
0.0162920877,
-0.0498964675,
-0.0179589037,
0.0428835973,
0.0016529367,
0.001316189,
-0.0456504859,
0.0307184793,
-0.0312617309,
-0.0373376347,
-0.1023216695,
0.0063853767,
-0.0085455282,
0.0120399222,
0.0309042316,
0.0205860548,
-0.0390051194,
-0.0207229014,
-0.0786781088,
-0.0233364664,
0.0439029448,
0.0374912657,
0.0109198773,
0.0238345191,
0.0265134517,
-0.0135619072,
-0.0308942422,
-0.0199297555,
0.0191585869,
-0.0049137077,
-0.0018026382,
-0.0610150509,
0.0337092727,
-0.0277719498,
0.0070095067,
0.021561373,
-0.0633780807,
-0.023956297,
-0.0335893333,
-0.0041666594,
0.0535569899,
-0.0078003379,
-0.0271002799,
0.0447688028,
0.0119486023,
-0.0311507117,
0.0241969004,
-0.0039743092,
-0.0499958768,
-0.0221752133,
-0.0375984311,
0.0009658779,
0.0776323304,
-0.0134268133,
-0.010975223,
-0.0014601746,
-0.0158655159,
-0.0645528659,
0.0119412029,
-0.0322815664,
0.0312415194,
-0.0245284177,
0.0194455162,
0.0237381458,
-0.0298728012,
0.085783273,
-0.0134157967,
0.0101138065,
-0.0943063721,
-0.0098392125,
-0.0469267257,
0.0026617919,
-0.0139093231,
0.0276917052,
0.0081066228,
-0.0408426672,
-0.0296907071,
0.0415247753,
-0.0157209989,
-0.0476853475,
0.0328725688,
-0.037919756,
-0.0001193189,
-0.0183620751,
-0.0737537742,
-0.0323995352,
-0.0404188372,
-0.0203399975,
0.0327449106,
-0.0202454999,
0.0221437328,
-0.0366458781,
0.0288066939,
-0.0024675634,
0.0334288478,
-0.0079273013,
0.01195079,
-0.021230951,
0.0376773141,
0.0668751225,
0.0567692257,
-0.0001833009,
-0.0367874876,
0.0418392047,
0.018980803,
0.0360711887,
-0.0055399602,
-0.0047176047,
0.012022051,
0.0481258929,
-0.0711383224,
0.0093754195,
0.0192974564,
0.0334957764,
-0.0514838398,
-0.0133195231,
0.1513436735,
0.0361778177,
-0.029776359,
-0.0007259081,
-0.0437808633,
-0.0278205108,
-0.0054808781,
0.0631973222,
-0.0498312153,
-0.0367774516,
0.0100225946,
0.0342839584,
0.0145691,
0.0162893031,
0.0314647667,
-0.1074604392,
0.0166651998,
0.0039160792,
-0.0444090143,
-0.0166346766,
-0.0369607173,
-0.0135294897,
0.0139549356,
0.0687765628,
0.0103517547,
-0.031813778,
-0.0097379684,
0.033843413,
-0.0353433043,
-0.072148025,
0.0371503681,
-0.0361054167,
0.0437068678,
0.030076785,
-0.0077135274,
-0.0280919988,
-0.0085074902,
0.0317969434,
-0.0144438585,
0.0195927694,
-0.0337424874,
0.0364183336,
0.0274070855,
-0.0273125842,
-0.0195743628,
0.0308060739,
-0.059264224,
-0.0061088176,
0.0490014181,
0.0583876744,
-0.0090744244,
-0.0157423746,
-0.0376681499,
0.0170388333,
-0.0246341694,
0.0585187413,
0.0095030218,
-0.0608667396,
0.0042269411,
0.0018473973,
-0.0195582509,
0.0093832016,
0.0174471494,
0.0363938771,
-0.0551991761,
0.0241534878,
-0.0739665702,
-0.0294112116,
0.039423991,
0.0293105729,
0.0331208669,
0.0091737173,
-0.017260205,
0.0015100247,
-0.0034083314,
0.0617562681,
-0.0215686616,
0.0255757961,
-0.097086966,
-0.0209207777,
0.069674246,
0.0103953686,
-0.0170041788,
-0.0053838002,
0.0045739901,
-0.0217067506,
0.0023409745,
0.0486300364,
0.0121338107,
0.0115184989,
-0.0106395632,
-0.0658644885,
0.0058868835,
0.005888476,
-0.0264767129,
0.0248114131,
-0.0044464562,
-0.0089873262,
-0.0086768633,
0.0059523396,
-0.0369673185,
-0.0085501736,
0.0544492528,
0.0414062589,
-0.0059675262,
-0.0114280619,
0.0152378976,
0.0601866767,
0.0077638421,
0.018104922,
0.0155511573,
-0.0228367969,
0.0706489757,
-0.013393498,
0.0097390134,
-0.0173529387,
-0.0210098196,
0.0571262315,
-0.0192689002,
-0.0050885212,
0.0162297506,
-0.0014944458,
-0.0149340769,
-0.0507683158,
0.0517499335,
0.0202363208,
0.00602317,
0.0254119392,
-0.0149083398,
-0.0256147645,
-0.0197039936,
0.0511265844,
0.0188922808,
0.0032010411,
0.096789591,
-0.0282517802,
0.0077713081,
-0.0098531945,
0.0345836133,
-0.0391706005,
-0.0306781121,
-0.0080341892,
0.0404597409,
0.0699358657,
-0.0056908168,
0.0174247865,
0.000530833,
-0.0222832169,
-0.0180294737,
-0.0203704908,
-0.0067306156,
0.0156671461,
0.0785657465,
0.0197008885,
0.0098790135,
-0.014757907,
0.1067098379,
0.0472004078,
0.0735328943,
0.0151825249,
-0.0082706567,
-0.0146991499,
-0.0093381507,
0.0243564975,
0.008378664,
-0.048443079,
-0.0029103335,
-0.0170992296,
-0.0595203713,
-0.0016790845,
-0.0176161435,
-0.0243679229,
0.0037593131,
0.0356330015,
0.0461608134,
0.0078654746,
-0.0578327887,
-0.0259961691,
0.0664746389,
-0.012143218,
-0.0053512864,
0.0199242029,
-5.743738701e-33,
-0.0344460718,
0.0165925957,
0.0511597395,
-0.0246795677,
0.0022372676,
0.0191843081,
-0.0112549253,
-0.0001767172,
-0.0501404889,
0.004385754,
-0.0478073135,
0.0109597016,
0.0290315282,
0.0451713167,
-0.0044641369,
-0.0442965701,
0.0168556832,
0.00526261,
-0.0044548027,
0.0022214712,
-0.0393163785,
0.0291859023,
0.0245936997,
-0.0137919644,
0.0049236547,
-0.0001017862,
0.0365569554,
0.0112560457,
-0.0354907401,
0.0968864933,
-0.0055278512,
0.0646094903,
0.0339509584,
-0.037697982,
-0.0264078751,
0.0110239098,
-0.0947904959,
-0.0223843288,
0.015558375,
0.0317679197,
0.0082245516,
-0.0751867518,
0.0270221066,
0.0005045774,
-0.0279876683,
-0.0189392269,
0.003362037,
-0.0524573512,
-0.0434686579,
-0.0157368854,
-0.0060022636,
0.0091825873,
0.0072297761,
0.0228625406,
-0.0188823715,
0.004673027,
-0.0360810347,
0.0128709199,
0.0099235512,
0.0079670744,
0.0780559555,
0.0479181223,
0.0296547301,
-0.0109707862,
-0.0168863777,
0.0020260869,
0.0385190956,
-0.0291698705,
0.0115469797,
-0.0019634089,
-0.0172975119,
-0.0085780006,
0.0612345189,
0.0283787493,
0.0023349733,
-0.0077245985,
-0.1148387119,
0.0365478918,
-0.0216466151,
0.0617483109,
0.0303701237,
-0.023616543,
-0.0279138517,
-0.0216817651,
-0.0301559865,
0.0414698869,
-0.0337290876,
-0.0443104245,
0.0539663322,
-0.0149051324,
0.0095042316,
-0.0058412869,
0.0281272922,
-0.050216224,
-0.0068457243,
0.0179725531,
0.0389793999,
0.0124307871,
-0.0462847948,
0.0186712798,
-0.0326027572,
-0.029077366,
-0.0231140796,
-0.0514207855,
0.0211695991,
0.0229633655,
0.0130909709,
-0.0323417485,
-0.0676803216,
-0.003937758,
0.0021890125,
-0.0344249196,
0.025661625,
0.0550335944,
0.0119680241,
0.0256138463,
0.0219750684,
0.0535858348,
0.0133725572,
-0.0478055105,
-0.0209748149,
-0.0773925781,
0.0150600486,
-0.0056284876,
-0.0438875705,
0.0211436097,
-0.014480236,
0.0455293804,
0.0023234317,
-0.0409925058,
-0.0144969588,
0.0040069115,
2.464e-7,
0.097292304,
0.0726721138,
-0.035197597,
0.0144734457,
0.0360315442,
-0.0069900933,
-0.0309457965,
-0.0215079617,
0.077034086,
0.04955348,
0.0230626687,
0.0064324425,
0.0284574982,
0.0069535887,
-0.114366211,
-0.0166411791,
-0.0563609414,
0.0112460079,
-0.0548736639,
-0.0062234136,
0.0247300155,
0.1127158105,
-0.0440437272,
-0.0379328467,
0.0137125766,
-0.0766669363,
0.0371841751,
-0.0358601287,
-0.0274044741,
0.0493769534,
0.0205776952,
-0.0092866477,
0.0271425396,
0.0428817123,
-0.031943243,
0.0076236236,
0.0438288637,
0.1070823222,
-0.0242253877,
0.0003442822,
0.032764703,
0.0087379785,
0.0038870287,
-0.0558517538,
0.0816255212,
-0.0585670061,
-0.0294385441,
-0.0058327364,
-0.0187391844,
-0.0709713176,
0.0451956652,
-0.0377356,
-0.011995038,
0.019523317,
0.0435537808,
0.0012648689,
-0.0435496308,
-0.0324529074,
-0.0248405337,
0.0176724587,
-0.0135092074,
-0.0552323386,
0.0039201365,
-0.0029849824,
-0.0113247084,
-0.0723323002,
-0.0040364549,
2.130641138e-34,
0.0165793449,
-0.0102502294,
0.0220895503,
0.0597351082,
0.0005790601,
-0.0168115031,
0.0075810933,
0.0308499169,
0.0078473594,
-0.0996374488,
-0.0073209428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14877v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14877v1 | Sports Intelligence: Assessing the Sports Understanding Capabilities of Language Models through Question Answering from Text to Video | 2024-06-21T05:57:50 | 2024-06-21T05:57:50 | Zhengbang Yang, Haotian Xia, Jingxi Li, Zezhi Chen, Zhuangdi Zhu, Weining Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding sports is crucial for the advancement of Natural Language
Processing (NLP) due to its intricate and dynamic nature. Reasoning over
complex sports scenarios has posed significant challenges to current NLP
technologies which require advanced cognitive capabilities. Toward addressing
the limitations of existing benchmarks on sports understanding in the NLP
field, we extensively evaluated mainstream large language models for various
sports tasks. Our evaluation spans from simple queries on basic rules and
historical facts to complex, context-specific reasoning, leveraging strategies
from zero-shot to few-shot learning, and chain-of-thought techniques. In
addition to unimodal analysis, we further assessed the sports reasoning
capabilities of mainstream video language models to bridge the gap in
multimodal sports understanding benchmarking. Our findings highlighted the
critical challenges of sports understanding for NLP. We proposed a new
benchmark based on a comprehensive overview of existing sports datasets and
provided extensive error analysis which we hope can help identify future
research priorities in this field. | [
0.0044198199,
0.0399246626,
0.0223139599,
0.0723296106,
0.000506042,
0.0173415132,
-0.0149557851,
0.0235517174,
-0.0258394722,
-0.110034585,
0.0113473181,
-0.0607154518,
-0.0149567565,
0.0164290033,
0.0114578847,
-0.0562223382,
0.0069904886,
-0.0428977124,
0.0403609537,
0.0010427671,
0.0223734677,
0.0203911792,
-0.0392799601,
0.0069472226,
-0.0386349261,
-0.0187567044,
0.0130157648,
-0.0087305922,
-0.0141068567,
-0.0410375185,
-0.0458873771,
0.0196222793,
0.0709843934,
-0.0110058887,
0.0000016669,
-0.0665026456,
0.0476413555,
-0.027043974,
-0.046377521,
0.022032205,
-0.01152327,
-0.0058199847,
0.0416772068,
-0.0170335062,
-0.0419114493,
0.0277588423,
0.0442680307,
-0.0155895008,
0.0317086093,
0.0487300158,
-0.0103471251,
-0.0402470231,
-0.014353998,
-0.0139468722,
0.0043031266,
-0.0716120303,
0.0057521318,
0.0341298431,
-0.0055590658,
-0.0001647494,
-0.0419273674,
0.0169261694,
0.0089494605,
0.0420390181,
-0.0477574393,
0.015035809,
-0.0435385779,
0.0075841909,
0.0006677589,
0.0598217994,
-0.0152220009,
0.018751448,
-0.011611307,
0.0069361622,
-0.0257754866,
0.0006987392,
-0.0410062075,
0.0642893985,
0.0200295299,
0.0041403864,
-0.0360310003,
0.0308754425,
0.0165362507,
0.0115165487,
-0.0213911533,
0.0301449411,
0.0165753122,
0.0280744769,
-0.0284925215,
0.0283629373,
-0.0084843114,
-0.0762934536,
-0.0172055904,
0.0272628441,
-0.0203596279,
0.0164381824,
0.0090169962,
-0.0120038958,
-0.0184610728,
-0.0438314229,
0.0768021047,
0.0282037351,
0.0124426251,
0.0571112223,
-0.0099570956,
0.0205301046,
0.0044776718,
0.0036560558,
-0.029717138,
-0.0262729283,
-0.0743361712,
-0.0069898539,
-0.0062611331,
0.0426154286,
-0.0729148909,
-0.0257806517,
-0.0227289982,
0.0122166183,
0.0247626025,
-0.0159860328,
-0.02776655,
0.0171965659,
0.0410749689,
-0.0232687946,
-0.0557741486,
0.0270520169,
-0.0913412422,
0.0120917819,
0.0055781314,
-0.0692035705,
-0.0083186282,
0.0055951299,
0.0094266571,
-0.0303411838,
0.044316262,
0.0355108455,
-0.009415416,
-0.0292250514,
0.0079329815,
-0.0175822526,
-0.0140630631,
-0.0824810266,
0.017025223,
-0.0751565546,
0.0584252886,
-0.0124989981,
-0.0090335347,
-0.0559833646,
0.0238840673,
0.038943287,
-0.0750366375,
0.0764089599,
0.0068720337,
0.016082542,
-0.0156880952,
-0.0051099528,
0.0294852834,
0.0903895721,
0.0066458574,
-0.0431173518,
0.0464003868,
0.0426127575,
0.010378561,
0.0225286111,
-0.0112827802,
-0.021527987,
-0.0917906389,
0.032797534,
0.014402125,
0.0517926924,
-0.0115731852,
0.028301686,
-0.017654581,
-0.0447126217,
0.0541573316,
0.0578701608,
-0.0143033229,
-0.0494621806,
0.0660693645,
-0.0128501514,
0.0293475967,
-0.0069609936,
-0.0467469729,
0.0568223782,
0.0020297009,
0.0210149121,
-0.0092218872,
0.0201198831,
-0.0545509942,
-0.0528553575,
-0.0379842557,
0.011450002,
-0.0038976455,
0.0360985585,
0.0646350905,
-0.0072170305,
-0.0199337341,
0.07337486,
-0.0178250745,
-0.0090909265,
0.0334758945,
-0.0125975292,
-0.0167177524,
0.034571372,
0.002472321,
-0.0317399465,
-0.038676545,
0.0139926607,
0.0524314307,
0.0350147076,
0.0079286862,
0.009320884,
0.077909939,
-0.032137271,
-0.0110033182,
-0.0393197127,
0.0458208285,
-0.0005407936,
-0.0357105024,
0.0097256955,
-0.0118962172,
-0.0164853428,
-0.0091498494,
0.0478859097,
-0.0071231904,
-0.0439567603,
-0.0098580653,
-0.0204774104,
-0.0219049361,
0.0515719429,
-0.029251365,
-0.0045330822,
0.0215095151,
-0.0357806236,
-0.0009690787,
0.0152333211,
-0.0166709684,
-0.0466635078,
0.0375349075,
-0.0727386102,
-0.0424730703,
0.042269066,
-0.0512726046,
-0.0149089899,
0.0323550627,
0.0037620508,
0.0059678792,
-0.052618444,
-0.0334220566,
0.0166530069,
0.0025223326,
-0.013823824,
0.041833628,
0.0150667662,
-0.0303992499,
0.0167208221,
-0.0139553323,
0.0315149054,
-0.0567668527,
-0.0390924327,
0.0680149719,
-0.0079783946,
0.0030099943,
0.0466206148,
0.0038760828,
-0.0682207644,
0.022116255,
-0.0734386221,
0.0309098009,
-0.0507708527,
0.0252546109,
0.0211827569,
-0.0054841107,
-0.0026812691,
-0.0277269464,
-0.0236068573,
-0.0178870223,
0.0108077312,
0.0279364493,
0.040591836,
0.0160049051,
0.0280932728,
0.0084229968,
-0.0173648987,
-0.0003407147,
0.1080357805,
0.0014460701,
-0.0018435194,
-0.0012922243,
-0.0040780334,
-0.0671820119,
0.0428240076,
0.0017603156,
0.0077675055,
0.0458875895,
-0.008114499,
0.0003012737,
0.0654211268,
0.0237212908,
-0.0000909217,
0.0188898854,
-0.0799898803,
0.0200621393,
0.0115507878,
-0.0205819439,
-0.0486091077,
-0.0629771501,
-0.0118887434,
0.0014145497,
0.0246363208,
-0.0319308639,
0.0143106366,
-0.0716489106,
0.0398393683,
-0.020477334,
0.0103404643,
-0.0935627595,
0.0173983369,
-0.0114220651,
0.0397112891,
-0.0385178663,
0.0183683801,
0.0302120037,
-0.0079462118,
0.0098269712,
-0.0251792166,
0.0032507293,
-0.0101999659,
0.1060737222,
0.0402692221,
0.0576542541,
-0.0206348319,
-0.0046424745,
-0.052209828,
-0.0356983207,
0.0423253626,
-0.0084980652,
0.0167725701,
-0.0363356024,
0.0330476053,
0.0164607279,
0.0013459254,
-0.0189562142,
0.0069710808,
-0.0562400706,
0.0069900579,
-0.0539617166,
0.0111493208,
-0.0254907608,
-0.0103622675,
0.0103413407,
-0.0302667208,
0.0052475571,
-0.0124667855,
0.0275067762,
0.068859078,
0.0574587435,
0.03502772,
-0.0239541009,
-0.0406057127,
0.0618794262,
0.0865074918,
0.0444289781,
0.0065084412,
-0.0174984746,
0.0355492085,
0.0028531353,
-0.0203734674,
-0.0435531065,
0.0668332726,
0.0873761624,
-0.0674609095,
0.0168334134,
0.1024286225,
0.0343785286,
-0.0004534573,
0.0026562044,
0.0281759817,
-0.0378071181,
0.037493784,
-0.0162745751,
-0.0885976329,
-0.0729294121,
0.0032697567,
0.010471466,
0.004020792,
-0.0413865857,
-0.0394608788,
-0.1136908233,
-0.0053626364,
-0.017217923,
-0.0531753972,
-0.0383499786,
-0.0131500997,
0.0196265243,
-0.0172079206,
-0.0077691488,
-0.0052141519,
0.0116469143,
0.0254768301,
0.0051999283,
-0.0149228023,
-0.0514883175,
0.0654033944,
-0.0861796364,
0.0547891185,
-0.007577233,
0.0291236974,
-0.026674347,
-0.01510996,
0.0114020538,
-0.0190683678,
0.0168676041,
-0.0006331837,
0.073683247,
-0.0506850369,
-0.000358262,
0.0034593516,
0.0188968629,
0.0064697736,
-0.0297430083,
0.0186254904,
0.0898571536,
0.0253277458,
0.0017371884,
-0.0249678958,
0.0137361102,
-0.0375709869,
0.0486936234,
0.0125357015,
-0.0173939392,
-0.0351831913,
0.0008513464,
-0.0188553259,
-0.053590335,
-0.0818174109,
0.0057141753,
0.065528892,
0.0095841549,
-0.015037124,
-0.0289430954,
0.0380263329,
0.0339027755,
-0.0385909714,
0.0618062578,
-0.0287466273,
0.0100997174,
-0.0703438893,
0.0624860972,
-0.0130665889,
-0.0158528592,
-0.0152833601,
0.0163771156,
0.0386200659,
-0.01741492,
-0.021039756,
0.0472413339,
-0.0213206802,
-0.0109969256,
0.0004376498,
0.0392423719,
0.0218193587,
0.0185178965,
0.0314396657,
-0.0255174618,
-0.0363978371,
0.0216445383,
-0.0069080917,
0.0402915552,
-0.0212012827,
-0.0180998687,
-0.0015277434,
0.0246211216,
-0.0139506366,
0.0339750722,
-0.0075450866,
0.0524972267,
-0.0524470657,
-0.0143693583,
0.0423849747,
-0.0056908671,
0.0656671897,
0.0150581328,
-0.0703651235,
0.0082906503,
-0.0262226723,
-0.0435670279,
0.0182209127,
-0.048309017,
-0.0009905357,
0.0020097189,
0.019994868,
-0.0264377929,
0.0111892931,
-0.0417160206,
0.0222784411,
-0.0210660305,
0.0236987025,
0.0297525935,
-0.0143554173,
-0.0255129356,
0.0050394088,
0.0164935961,
0.0088164154,
-0.0311587825,
0.0425552726,
0.0076369396,
0.0406039059,
0.0174548868,
-0.0319152065,
-0.0001919902,
0.0137611236,
-0.0353240333,
0.016515946,
0.0195700265,
0.030588109,
0.0831190273,
-0.0384538025,
-0.0361573771,
0.0152257299,
-0.0024110049,
0.0240912866,
0.0152454078,
0.0044542369,
-0.0706350058,
0.0391593836,
0.0274139587,
-0.0098107578,
0.019912852,
0.0427891128,
0.024641363,
0.01725295,
0.0178257395,
-0.0292575341,
-0.0114465971,
-0.0176430196,
0.0009327015,
0.0321382917,
-0.0212237965,
0.0382105559,
-0.1050215214,
-0.051357232,
-0.0279954094,
-0.0166652557,
0.0124720754,
0.0232145358,
0.0374755003,
0.0476126187,
0.0109768612,
-0.0138005884,
-0.0096042976,
0.001591772,
-0.0465040952,
-0.0145168873,
-0.0196610726,
-5.599598849e-33,
0.0073229326,
-0.0375458039,
0.0471060686,
-0.0394504666,
-0.04556318,
0.0266096275,
-0.029111892,
0.0169070382,
-0.0553094372,
0.0191237461,
0.0127590448,
0.0150082028,
-0.0130639309,
0.0183169134,
0.0398212187,
-0.0775200725,
0.0036631103,
-0.0629015341,
-0.0163929984,
-0.0423700213,
0.0299107321,
0.0417357981,
0.0475416109,
-0.0306725912,
0.0033852211,
0.0063844137,
-0.0199395902,
0.0424667522,
0.0320415124,
0.0527793951,
-0.0053296899,
-0.0277533643,
0.0440946259,
-0.0744493753,
-0.0076030223,
0.0253500622,
-0.0264089257,
-0.0348626487,
0.0074772015,
0.0116347577,
-0.0473492183,
0.0293671004,
0.029722346,
-0.0059232791,
-0.0253984034,
-0.0595063195,
0.0264275521,
-0.0227628238,
0.058603473,
-0.0131824147,
-0.0263498537,
0.04013405,
-0.0191616435,
-0.0211338401,
0.0459969714,
0.0259201117,
-0.0172147937,
0.0322068296,
-0.0464478023,
-0.003196334,
-0.046460893,
0.0241269693,
0.0641658083,
0.0071260142,
-0.0251583699,
0.0419768058,
0.0419053845,
-0.0451803878,
-0.0637746677,
-0.0120197264,
0.0118042324,
0.0318904668,
0.0650949478,
0.0335251167,
0.0565904267,
0.0666191354,
-0.0618615374,
-0.0277480111,
-0.0108201439,
0.073932603,
-0.0160939395,
0.0189179536,
-0.0159842595,
0.020393189,
-0.0559968241,
0.0007174083,
-0.0256413035,
-0.022835115,
0.0361267664,
-0.0310538448,
0.0180150345,
0.0034387591,
0.0390434563,
-0.0076245684,
0.0203343108,
0.0456267409,
-0.0042105569,
0.0465587787,
0.0129667735,
0.0507581159,
-0.0649326146,
0.0294561759,
0.0124309622,
0.0179132763,
-0.0019796018,
-0.0394710936,
-0.03178804,
0.0369413681,
-0.0126566896,
-0.0216384698,
-0.0080378978,
-0.0179216396,
-0.0120800277,
0.0062914118,
0.0269026905,
0.0575234666,
-0.0331670083,
0.0325458534,
0.0041114758,
-0.0500525199,
0.0025525421,
0.0111549729,
0.0173656289,
0.0267237388,
-0.0016885027,
0.0077888253,
-0.0211588815,
-0.0048827427,
0.0074304659,
-0.0185208432,
-0.0289139282,
0.0452676117,
2.468e-7,
0.0637855753,
0.0645179376,
-0.0401857197,
0.0011102504,
-0.0183186773,
0.050056342,
-0.0248052459,
0.0447264798,
0.0006911719,
-0.0087383091,
0.0083159907,
0.1004937962,
0.0167972073,
0.0229820348,
-0.0318459161,
-0.0488875248,
-0.0150655108,
-0.0398204364,
-0.0438607857,
0.0121495724,
0.0789026767,
0.0536503419,
0.0341632366,
0.0140468311,
-0.0025581485,
-0.0716637,
0.0570394844,
0.0017915636,
-0.0158978421,
-0.0252505187,
-0.0009171519,
-0.0208197497,
-0.029584825,
0.0308670029,
-0.0234539472,
-0.0049818009,
0.042120479,
0.0319144204,
-0.0497761033,
-0.0196947288,
-0.0345308818,
0.0125008821,
-0.0521551669,
-0.0188436229,
0.0894006789,
-0.0510811917,
-0.0601977557,
-0.0349833518,
-0.0699800849,
0.0207817685,
0.0047430838,
0.0128590157,
-0.0141781112,
0.0060720993,
0.0166535527,
0.0013035879,
0.0036696536,
-0.083020933,
0.0226937309,
0.0157363862,
-0.0222207643,
0.0384280682,
-0.01906983,
-0.0002383806,
0.0223503932,
-0.0447786525,
-0.0428195372,
1.718439694e-34,
0.0096417852,
-0.001498254,
-0.0049646082,
-0.0339656882,
-0.008767915,
-0.0159733035,
-0.024192011,
0.0093025779,
0.0327013172,
-0.045005627,
0.0232255366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15524v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15524v1 | Rethinking Pruning Large Language Models: Benefits and Pitfalls of Reconstruction Error Minimization | 2024-06-21T05:13:34 | 2024-06-21T05:13:34 | Sungbin Shin, Wonpyo Park, Jaeho Lee, Namhoon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This work suggests fundamentally rethinking the current practice of pruning
large language models (LLMs). The way it is done is by divide and conquer:
split the model into submodels, sequentially prune them, and reconstruct
predictions of the dense counterparts on small calibration data one at a time;
the final model is obtained simply by putting the resulting sparse submodels
together. While this approach enables pruning under memory constraints, it
generates high reconstruction errors. In this work, we first present an array
of reconstruction techniques that can significantly reduce this error by more
than $90\%$. Unwittingly, however, we discover that minimizing reconstruction
error is not always ideal and can overfit the given calibration data, resulting
in rather increased language perplexity and poor performance at downstream
tasks. We find out that a strategy of self-generating calibration data can
mitigate this trade-off between reconstruction and generalization, suggesting
new directions in the presence of both benefits and pitfalls of reconstruction
for pruning LLMs. | [
-0.0115432758,
0.1221352294,
0.0020365505,
0.056348376,
-0.0235914662,
-0.0021717041,
0.0266668815,
0.0269061364,
-0.0493591763,
0.0010039192,
-0.0460823216,
-0.0988986641,
0.0451803319,
0.0041616871,
0.0131252026,
-0.0113012912,
0.0193626769,
-0.05505367,
-0.0155768683,
-0.0385083035,
-0.0224244837,
0.0081698131,
0.0117990747,
0.0218069199,
-0.0173724238,
-0.0060961018,
0.0019812188,
0.022658227,
-0.0255704056,
0.0113209784,
0.0117358211,
0.0562396795,
0.0406202786,
0.0613850057,
0.0000020329,
0.0013881854,
-0.0008167102,
-0.000890911,
-0.0519354418,
0.0685572624,
0.0617192462,
-0.0118086655,
-0.0104460148,
0.0218367018,
0.0050074635,
-0.0412564129,
0.049867101,
-0.0373263843,
0.011334517,
0.065634653,
0.0145558454,
-0.0222242456,
-0.0209928378,
-0.0373575948,
-0.0236739255,
-0.0444002338,
0.0169110186,
0.002806155,
-0.0517680347,
-0.0059072869,
-0.0184529051,
0.0155998729,
0.002947869,
0.0057296497,
-0.0260348246,
0.0152659407,
0.0048850197,
-0.0388397686,
-0.006231741,
0.0190837812,
-0.025148496,
-0.0369754285,
0.0049096229,
-0.0108295623,
-0.0191966761,
-0.0470931083,
-0.036605563,
0.0455793887,
0.0286067165,
0.0237563625,
-0.0042545754,
-0.047578983,
0.0642122403,
-0.0194854811,
-0.0310220141,
0.0392683223,
0.0462893955,
0.0099160299,
-0.0453904457,
0.0193555132,
0.0005413131,
-0.0465650298,
-0.0159412306,
0.0187219493,
-0.0430011153,
0.0159832686,
-0.0801468268,
-0.0153646534,
-0.0021288597,
0.0129966335,
0.0778345466,
0.0474253222,
0.0086979931,
0.0335815474,
0.0013229839,
0.0549304895,
-0.0138283968,
0.0049134335,
-0.0517783239,
-0.0122805694,
-0.008073993,
-0.0119093908,
-0.0139898835,
0.0129915606,
-0.0399034917,
0.0195905957,
-0.0391598381,
-0.0120177921,
0.0154589908,
-0.0090353386,
0.000350037,
0.0114526236,
-0.0618533008,
-0.0253977142,
0.0322404467,
0.0462180898,
0.0171139352,
0.0292926412,
-0.0006580816,
-0.0774737448,
-0.0468492918,
0.0253500044,
0.0020192845,
-0.0287134033,
0.0244541857,
0.0321056731,
0.0131683452,
-0.0675660223,
-0.0202366952,
-0.0034420034,
-0.0532968715,
-0.0778788701,
0.0142588457,
-0.0786704123,
0.0247725565,
-0.0038681265,
0.0112674655,
-0.0923923627,
-0.0083913747,
-0.0081120534,
-0.0418950692,
0.0353368707,
-0.0160367992,
0.0265345927,
-0.0098162685,
-0.0109912893,
0.0434541777,
0.0920934454,
0.0441465825,
0.0117246117,
0.0038415228,
-0.0131483963,
-0.0156767536,
0.0678138211,
0.0386989154,
0.0241749063,
-0.0669141486,
-0.0286020506,
0.0208434798,
-0.0060310699,
0.0651421249,
0.075891085,
-0.0404053517,
-0.0060860976,
0.0454462394,
0.0259246193,
0.0053493115,
0.0347824693,
0.0221872907,
-0.021128146,
0.0163254812,
0.007025938,
-0.045022212,
0.0075290878,
-0.0232634395,
-0.007880602,
0.0321713835,
0.0408193059,
-0.0498739816,
-0.0286104716,
-0.0119252354,
-0.0188739933,
-0.0146499686,
0.0293666106,
0.0714388639,
-0.024332352,
-0.0287563596,
0.0719851851,
0.0344914682,
-0.0848795548,
0.0063808537,
-0.0570447184,
-0.0110674296,
0.0246252585,
0.0316399597,
-0.0200097691,
-0.0157703254,
0.0471017659,
0.0040147598,
0.0135832727,
0.0561239533,
-0.0003023242,
0.0651277825,
-0.0319187343,
-0.0082010506,
-0.0260602515,
0.0356612727,
0.0125420829,
0.0360758081,
-0.0126924617,
0.0225840192,
-0.0583159924,
-0.0155985365,
0.0287573636,
-0.0534168333,
-0.0111976229,
0.0163994301,
-0.0212342851,
0.0149816452,
0.001863056,
-0.0399817973,
0.0057283249,
0.0563991331,
-0.0385871753,
0.0309103932,
-0.0236388128,
-0.0498803332,
-0.0332181416,
0.0731981844,
0.0256129559,
-0.0060017426,
0.0435904972,
-0.0330051593,
-0.064583011,
0.0470207669,
-0.0300120134,
0.0347651467,
-0.0542998388,
0.046321284,
-0.0640225932,
0.0410834104,
-0.0115217315,
0.0286858324,
-0.0217925664,
0.0252844188,
0.0107662939,
-0.0343613066,
0.0113155777,
-0.0372569561,
-0.0812111944,
-0.0252730493,
-0.0165334828,
0.0320850611,
0.0121058729,
-0.014596465,
0.0048930855,
-0.0089774467,
-0.0692606494,
0.0222355835,
-0.0464820489,
0.0165855531,
0.0346463509,
0.0544596203,
0.0021662344,
-0.0151380058,
0.0115307756,
-0.0010566788,
0.033926405,
0.0296322331,
0.0005630991,
-0.0127701815,
-0.0420513414,
-0.0273766853,
-0.0485535711,
0.005520504,
0.057964474,
-0.0545164794,
-0.014835869,
-0.0855476037,
0.0859578624,
-0.0132131251,
0.0439523458,
-0.0127136307,
-0.0419416353,
-0.003013212,
-0.0266334824,
0.0023684269,
0.0557945482,
-0.0516841635,
0.0250386484,
0.0653307661,
-0.0037601758,
-0.0244374201,
-0.0001373806,
-0.0075294664,
-0.0566480793,
-0.0234667044,
-0.0530403219,
-0.031664338,
0.0824097916,
-0.0060333116,
-0.0249957237,
-0.0280461591,
-0.0096245315,
0.0121130627,
-0.0407270044,
-0.0169481654,
0.0067974743,
-0.0159096457,
0.0409423374,
-0.0220673028,
-0.0678161904,
0.0221926644,
-0.0574588589,
-0.0067142914,
0.0065303324,
-0.0075908629,
-0.0289473478,
0.0419064499,
0.0379790142,
0.0020470889,
-0.0255629718,
-0.0002787481,
-0.0594468042,
-0.0152662843,
-0.0044127535,
-0.0314008445,
0.0371374637,
-0.0596710481,
0.0234827809,
-0.0198540445,
-0.0460827835,
-0.0188576914,
-0.0209970456,
-0.0431442074,
0.0155980084,
0.0350676142,
-0.0352215767,
-0.0546603948,
-0.00458419,
0.0086602345,
0.0407499857,
0.0123589179,
0.0428783372,
-0.0028155132,
0.0120494189,
0.0381611958,
0.0148725295,
0.0150477523,
-0.0534638986,
0.0117324935,
0.0458884872,
0.0467522927,
0.0483634956,
-0.0589041039,
0.000819205,
0.0481460653,
0.0275420789,
-0.0311293639,
0.0162796471,
0.0767780542,
-0.0300409645,
-0.027348727,
0.1095936149,
0.0046367855,
-0.053324718,
-0.0028521304,
0.0095494129,
0.0487627946,
0.0286017079,
0.0176278967,
-0.0472696349,
-0.0221957099,
0.0300224237,
0.0013043849,
0.0391796976,
-0.003379761,
-0.0068128165,
-0.1249305382,
0.0161404163,
0.0283290595,
-0.0148694608,
-0.0304552242,
-0.0429683439,
0.0263521671,
-0.0244322792,
0.0348942466,
0.0428577363,
0.0041964254,
-0.0074716271,
0.0302166753,
-0.0102833351,
-0.0576151423,
0.0148471547,
-0.0086204754,
0.0697597861,
0.0447473377,
0.0120856175,
0.0113525139,
0.0114456043,
0.0341663659,
0.010176816,
-0.0160984304,
0.015147008,
0.0406089947,
0.0603886992,
-0.0047819014,
0.0439797267,
0.0138418218,
-0.0513481237,
-0.0136329066,
-0.0307371691,
0.0534886643,
-0.0010369439,
-0.0194478948,
0.0143120056,
-0.0051045385,
-0.0088139232,
0.069729805,
0.0332001522,
-0.0177245531,
-0.0416886099,
-0.016843684,
-0.002360031,
-0.055046875,
0.003161367,
0.0532902889,
0.0194994956,
-0.0254130233,
0.0178048573,
0.0256635342,
0.0400435142,
0.0269796532,
0.000800261,
0.0058621531,
-0.0019916568,
-0.0067704641,
-0.0445308648,
0.0076622111,
-0.0755341053,
0.0073916684,
-0.0412186421,
0.0098321578,
-0.0139271384,
-0.0014856679,
0.0004102369,
0.0150801986,
-0.1549772024,
-0.0762888193,
-0.0029197256,
0.046660129,
0.0281493813,
0.0563920774,
0.025474526,
-0.053339947,
0.0242799558,
0.0382828675,
-0.0143734664,
0.0746652037,
-0.0086830528,
-0.0429797955,
-0.0173262972,
0.0680501014,
-0.0159388166,
0.0063650883,
0.0648022518,
0.0336415172,
0.0054416023,
-0.0369460471,
0.0103915827,
0.0208143201,
0.0491798371,
-0.0210755169,
0.0090006487,
-0.0043118037,
0.0124341892,
-0.0052621854,
-0.0072603864,
-0.0366634838,
0.0035798855,
0.0299088024,
0.0148509638,
-0.008818619,
-0.0174626075,
0.0131507665,
0.0575315766,
-0.0228420831,
0.0007983042,
0.0299843997,
-0.0193652939,
0.0587353669,
-0.0095326239,
0.0050694612,
0.0441814885,
-0.0090554804,
0.0319370888,
-0.0037184567,
-0.0317314863,
-0.0095640579,
0.021584006,
-0.0861783847,
0.0068197739,
-0.0625273585,
-0.0838761777,
-0.0426022001,
0.0409900583,
0.0511883125,
-0.0060120742,
0.0484287255,
0.0135499714,
-0.0156973135,
-0.0617660396,
0.0286307391,
0.0131679829,
-0.0180401094,
0.0171334837,
-0.004646522,
-0.0281987656,
0.0128682293,
0.0864259824,
0.0331452861,
0.0646523684,
0.0149114067,
-0.0033353642,
-0.0270208176,
-0.0373682044,
-0.0278406497,
-0.0101212179,
-0.0447226688,
-0.0184647981,
-0.0281656403,
-0.0904179066,
0.035416048,
0.0236976836,
0.0202388372,
-0.0052563627,
0.0031159425,
0.0407950319,
-0.0125520481,
0.0244299117,
-0.0054828725,
0.0157012381,
-0.0083516883,
-0.0470886379,
-0.012335618,
-6.373315842e-33,
-0.0143100023,
0.0284807775,
0.016961148,
-0.0292378366,
-0.0057969783,
0.0018650154,
-0.0354469083,
0.0196898766,
-0.0147317126,
0.0022711938,
-0.0421506613,
0.0274773873,
0.0184587426,
0.0307037123,
-0.002726556,
0.015880812,
0.0725084767,
-0.0399348885,
-0.0413007215,
0.0237425268,
0.0232644137,
0.0456889085,
0.093392998,
-0.0113920951,
-0.0370601676,
0.0119794654,
-0.0131641189,
0.0193475448,
-0.0077105276,
0.0264652967,
-0.0176967122,
0.0432604477,
0.0178514272,
0.0226579737,
-0.0323154852,
0.0021466543,
-0.0753538609,
0.0076967794,
0.0398207828,
0.0212892909,
0.0043511903,
-0.0173544064,
0.01561826,
-0.0052647153,
-0.0394368842,
-0.0295381565,
-0.0129175344,
-0.0343184955,
-0.0498236045,
0.0369679518,
-0.0233224295,
0.0019100669,
-0.0064129755,
-0.0212976336,
0.026365703,
0.0181611553,
0.000245939,
0.0253739674,
-0.0672529936,
0.0106664654,
0.0137247955,
0.1005740091,
0.0798602626,
0.039636232,
-0.0054698307,
0.0599745251,
0.0320341289,
-0.0021115134,
-0.0198633056,
-0.0131785991,
0.060860537,
-0.0011566933,
0.02305522,
0.0567092001,
0.0502179861,
-0.0376865901,
-0.0839935839,
0.004015353,
0.0089873224,
0.0229334291,
0.0625041947,
0.0467031933,
0.0102457255,
-0.0402256586,
-0.0432191193,
-0.0614192709,
-0.05134077,
0.0058095707,
-0.0101473769,
0.0221507624,
-0.0470152944,
-0.0232397541,
0.0480293855,
-0.0686834529,
-0.019790994,
0.0215231329,
-0.004259422,
0.008646681,
-0.0058642705,
0.0493195429,
-0.0296133738,
-0.0415627547,
-0.0076599405,
0.0191562772,
0.0124587407,
-0.0164577998,
0.0246500764,
0.0334813111,
-0.0479617603,
-0.0151367793,
-0.0621222891,
0.0159179475,
0.0317745656,
0.0644222647,
0.038571436,
0.0057135392,
0.0151537526,
-0.0025485256,
0.0211455319,
-0.004045269,
-0.0232839566,
-0.0194766335,
0.0232571717,
0.0129884928,
-0.0322438478,
-0.0148892989,
-0.0406789593,
-0.0093982844,
0.0415735841,
-0.0499898531,
-0.038776651,
0.0036377255,
2.58e-7,
0.0527475774,
-0.0045825695,
0.0149986055,
-0.0063375989,
0.0287111588,
0.0118077071,
-0.0251798276,
-0.0093335956,
0.0035787101,
-0.0271741338,
0.0063333833,
0.0326137803,
0.071375981,
0.0079839407,
-0.0706367865,
0.0131100556,
-0.0435204916,
0.0029128385,
-0.0079920301,
-0.0534261689,
-0.0394182913,
0.1065864787,
0.0052630492,
-0.0515579134,
-0.0163642075,
-0.0350008681,
0.0565502122,
-0.0186407585,
-0.0066942698,
0.0279366747,
0.0239371769,
0.0095343171,
0.0015234149,
0.0021983702,
0.0078640273,
0.0190469772,
-0.0176018272,
0.0558671877,
0.0061677182,
0.0076567251,
-0.0014387238,
0.0172063224,
-0.0135508841,
-0.0362886749,
0.0356727466,
0.0033486139,
-0.0039018129,
-0.0822553709,
0.0028029806,
0.0120647885,
0.0174983162,
-0.0210441668,
0.0107240416,
0.0300746597,
0.0285105873,
-0.0071862526,
-0.0164008029,
-0.0498602502,
-0.0428351723,
0.0100762937,
-0.0841978341,
-0.0397786498,
-0.0140832923,
0.0023556154,
0.017120013,
-0.0553966351,
0.0238041021,
2.478670806e-34,
0.0360286757,
0.0028453656,
0.0078819701,
0.0301865805,
0.0249959752,
-0.0459839366,
-0.0002955703,
0.0176692046,
-0.0430639423,
-0.0675819367,
-0.0165328123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14868v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14868v2 | Direct Multi-Turn Preference Optimization for Language Agents | 2024-06-21T05:13:20 | 2024-06-25T08:44:24 | Wentao Shi, Mengqi Yuan, Junkang Wu, Qifan Wang, Fuli Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Adapting Large Language Models (LLMs) for agent tasks is critical in
developing language agents. Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) is a promising
technique for this adaptation with the alleviation of compounding errors,
offering a means to directly optimize Reinforcement Learning (RL) objectives.
However, applying DPO to multi-turn tasks presents challenges due to the
inability to cancel the partition function. Overcoming this obstacle involves
making the partition function independent of the current state and addressing
length disparities between preferred and dis-preferred trajectories. In this
light, we replace the policy constraint with the state-action occupancy measure
constraint in the RL objective and add length normalization to the
Bradley-Terry model, yielding a novel loss function named DMPO for multi-turn
agent tasks with theoretical explanations. Extensive experiments on three
multi-turn agent task datasets confirm the effectiveness and superiority of the
DMPO loss. | [
0.0149525255,
0.0347410031,
-0.0101513155,
0.0156433433,
-0.0069451309,
0.0132036293,
-0.0006615637,
-0.0382894203,
-0.0247757956,
0.0094202403,
-0.0049844938,
-0.0515205525,
-0.0304558799,
-0.0151480138,
-0.0025700377,
-0.0682710856,
0.0670276061,
-0.0610943921,
-0.0039965878,
-0.040296372,
-0.0092250295,
-0.0208738875,
-0.003722792,
0.041289378,
-0.0049163019,
-0.0087230755,
-0.0126413051,
-0.0248335004,
0.0317790061,
-0.0317050256,
0.0216659401,
0.0078478437,
0.0694872662,
0.0276873969,
0.0000024419,
-0.0519597046,
-0.0293378904,
-0.0281941779,
-0.0099176625,
-0.063081108,
0.0802748278,
0.0047722892,
-0.0039129406,
0.0406521969,
-0.0155911557,
-0.0011843613,
0.0430411398,
0.0322055593,
0.0048999395,
0.0968836248,
0.0147096729,
-0.0140587604,
-0.0246985741,
-0.0256871823,
-0.0120131066,
-0.0062376373,
0.0239142645,
-0.0145469885,
0.0016362059,
-0.0560131408,
-0.0637824312,
-0.0061105229,
0.0259392858,
-0.0009981106,
-0.0265612826,
0.0428722017,
0.0385103561,
-0.0034014459,
0.0164910704,
0.0481705293,
-0.0439725369,
0.0110142734,
0.0099145183,
-0.015496037,
0.0182629898,
-0.0216738768,
0.0125097679,
0.0138864536,
0.0383321978,
0.027669847,
0.0092120478,
-0.0217647534,
0.0228872504,
0.0140412087,
-0.103873007,
0.1234704778,
-0.0135920281,
-0.0174435824,
0.0381485932,
0.0018117552,
0.0434935912,
-0.0048155664,
0.0133959074,
0.0260344502,
-0.0893528536,
0.0170168858,
0.0141442288,
0.0452702604,
-0.0183231421,
-0.0567087382,
0.0415333472,
0.0196660962,
0.0173888467,
-0.0110042924,
-0.0013463239,
0.0516001619,
-0.024617102,
0.0528581701,
-0.0561865605,
-0.0026165722,
-0.02131184,
0.0257189181,
-0.0144050475,
0.0240688864,
-0.0170233622,
-0.0047563417,
-0.0256472621,
0.0700428188,
-0.0417913347,
0.0065584932,
0.0129673071,
0.0073126238,
-0.0259193759,
-0.0067943353,
-0.0554378107,
0.0568556786,
-0.0043240651,
0.0204241332,
0.0101685384,
0.0147521431,
0.0104706595,
0.0245996192,
-0.0254724305,
-0.0518605337,
-0.0037523424,
0.1376627535,
-0.0045715966,
-0.0220832601,
0.014065709,
0.0258150324,
-0.0330594853,
-0.0687849075,
-0.0144576412,
-0.0687666088,
0.0365093164,
-0.0388094373,
0.0055205594,
-0.0699749589,
-0.0022115533,
-0.0266055278,
-0.0373444334,
0.028647162,
0.0513256378,
0.0176733751,
0.004832204,
-0.0494457893,
-0.0221657809,
0.0616901703,
0.0629172176,
0.0270819645,
0.006725146,
-0.0038434914,
-0.0132749705,
0.0328293517,
-0.0063092271,
0.0521671735,
0.0135261789,
-0.0063854344,
0.0105405618,
0.0473750532,
0.0959692821,
0.0276997164,
-0.0456560887,
-0.0338407941,
0.0481830798,
-0.0039347578,
0.0257243607,
-0.0477893502,
0.0027567218,
0.0178284831,
-0.0511449203,
0.0035409417,
-0.0404619016,
0.0196838789,
-0.0071517644,
-0.0004640269,
0.0235693865,
0.0789611712,
-0.0136669138,
-0.0197548307,
0.0419158116,
-0.0201783776,
0.0710394308,
0.0336170718,
0.0509236604,
-0.0439013727,
-0.0596674606,
-0.0130188195,
0.0305482708,
-0.0161373187,
0.0263137408,
-0.0479635373,
0.0068692351,
0.029193677,
0.0109555041,
-0.0166828893,
-0.0486645587,
-0.0406754203,
-0.0550447404,
0.0263788942,
0.0353051797,
-0.027580183,
0.0342666581,
-0.0222681761,
-0.0550537482,
0.0532576926,
0.0005009208,
0.0546181127,
-0.0215673503,
0.0207003169,
-0.0004917345,
0.011833379,
-0.0597502925,
0.0273086708,
0.0348699987,
-0.0202021338,
0.033097256,
0.0210134555,
0.0568748526,
-0.0065414971,
-0.0026200262,
-0.0092970086,
0.0033767004,
0.0038874371,
0.0064715007,
-0.0107174078,
-0.0468201004,
-0.0491525643,
0.0587524101,
-0.0267433282,
-0.0104104644,
0.059187863,
-0.047173813,
-0.0399289839,
-0.0129883587,
-0.0204334371,
0.0495651066,
0.0260301251,
0.0214457121,
0.0106470929,
0.0007648405,
-0.047988534,
0.0351202339,
-0.0211935937,
-0.014530601,
-0.0139673343,
-0.0266982745,
-0.0215026792,
-0.0972209051,
-0.0200612471,
0.0534998551,
0.0193591937,
0.0196351912,
0.073054716,
0.0243919995,
-0.0095947459,
-0.0180629082,
0.025725035,
-0.0146337179,
-0.0190383196,
0.0134445103,
-0.0172119662,
-0.0172971785,
-0.0179995093,
0.0066355076,
-0.0159732085,
-0.0071955705,
-0.0047974735,
0.0104388306,
0.0032440568,
0.0176312234,
-0.0712233186,
-0.0398003757,
-0.0217141379,
-0.006015332,
-0.0315495133,
-0.0724322572,
0.0296762623,
-0.0299523845,
0.0242359173,
-0.0362542048,
0.0385192223,
-0.0272545014,
-0.024926072,
0.0166723356,
-0.0295830257,
0.0555077791,
0.1071880162,
0.0268238429,
0.0262116306,
0.0907438993,
-0.0267607216,
-0.0750460252,
0.0229619872,
-0.0909480825,
-0.0049059717,
-0.0747147352,
-0.0255373586,
0.0309223924,
0.0334385224,
-0.042726092,
-0.0311396867,
-0.0594689921,
-0.0861537457,
-0.011015093,
-0.0474275313,
0.004264737,
0.0505535007,
-0.0631025285,
0.0232235137,
-0.0257923491,
-0.0105585288,
0.0345151164,
0.0110971108,
0.0028292022,
-0.0665255338,
-0.0260814317,
-0.0202649366,
-0.0087308399,
0.0658290014,
0.0299001988,
-0.038946785,
0.0182936639,
-0.0759529844,
-0.0234064851,
0.0169787258,
-0.0044419337,
0.0801425427,
-0.0186002031,
-0.0099713597,
-0.0171457212,
-0.0464742966,
-0.0170924813,
0.0146424407,
0.033113461,
0.0040233075,
0.0041664289,
-0.0381847732,
-0.0673364848,
-0.0198660512,
0.0782917216,
0.0617733672,
0.0066147996,
-0.0010956309,
-0.0177905951,
-0.0347729921,
0.0649894103,
0.0121020209,
0.0352046192,
-0.0621077567,
0.0226268768,
0.0145857073,
0.0670464039,
-0.0384227633,
0.0214743037,
0.0172115732,
0.0386473462,
-0.0211320613,
-0.0156008955,
0.0659176111,
0.0320108943,
-0.0493699498,
-0.0043712184,
0.06932538,
0.0013308504,
-0.0586003102,
0.038016405,
-0.0309677348,
0.0733838975,
0.0192929581,
0.0482040606,
0.008362026,
0.0083321966,
0.0014392136,
0.0326297507,
0.0112730162,
-0.0062928628,
0.0133574354,
-0.1025211662,
-0.0050046295,
0.0201009698,
-0.068533048,
-0.0185327306,
-0.04213202,
-0.0106282188,
-0.0602622665,
0.0357469209,
-0.0059733172,
0.0023552275,
-0.0215982087,
0.0480305664,
0.0159322601,
-0.0101097813,
0.0117392829,
-0.0382401384,
0.0409198999,
0.0637887865,
0.033423733,
-0.0003416161,
-0.0188809521,
-0.0193768628,
0.034646038,
-0.0271168817,
0.0096857511,
-0.0422664434,
-0.0143123446,
0.0100332974,
0.0107717142,
0.0436456315,
-0.0021918148,
-0.0167698283,
0.0180390589,
0.062848419,
-0.0112802815,
-0.0184243377,
0.0133512989,
-0.0253500529,
0.0342389569,
0.0406610593,
-0.0137186255,
-0.0448455289,
-0.0456941202,
-0.0596851595,
-0.0650598481,
-0.0581684783,
-0.0177939199,
-0.0176544227,
-0.0376375429,
-0.0184622388,
-0.0385067202,
-0.0259360354,
0.0219719075,
0.0431775004,
0.0009325966,
0.0021930118,
0.0220901072,
-0.0213437751,
0.0192661267,
-0.0144482916,
-0.0372916497,
0.0425394624,
-0.071183607,
-0.0100653591,
-0.0072055152,
-0.0169134624,
-0.0159209408,
-0.0514566116,
0.0244156588,
-0.082075499,
0.0643760562,
0.0607708916,
0.0151744569,
0.0351400897,
0.0272074621,
-0.0173918623,
0.0474371724,
0.0013639536,
0.0171089135,
0.0044786315,
0.066720061,
0.0252250638,
0.010749856,
0.0383176804,
-0.0556053706,
0.003384653,
0.0005175669,
0.0341535695,
-0.0654631928,
-0.0166250467,
-0.003165835,
-0.037380781,
0.0062265489,
-0.0213833898,
0.0211675707,
-0.0104382895,
0.0284613781,
-0.0119171599,
-0.0062572658,
-0.0108358301,
-0.0035798424,
0.0200921316,
0.0017760372,
0.0337476023,
-0.0053838403,
0.027545711,
-0.0582752936,
0.019354254,
0.0404640809,
0.0756253377,
0.0142012285,
0.0426864401,
0.047486838,
0.0179266222,
-0.0008911595,
0.0244053993,
0.0302247368,
0.0641288757,
0.0403795168,
0.0290983692,
0.0159164686,
-0.0321666412,
-0.0089249844,
-0.038507849,
-0.0373819917,
-0.0069804424,
-0.0121830776,
0.0325586461,
-0.0420075394,
0.0667225718,
-0.0512946621,
0.0116595356,
-0.0188674424,
-0.0082106339,
-0.0315497406,
-0.0280496646,
0.0283555798,
0.0146788592,
0.0217574742,
-0.0111310566,
0.1088304669,
0.0290319156,
0.0928123891,
-0.0485851578,
0.0296295211,
-0.0394100249,
-0.0314436667,
0.0148175424,
0.0397372693,
-0.032969404,
0.0000632999,
-0.0570359826,
-0.0565571338,
-0.0573272593,
0.0226816256,
0.0405816399,
-0.0307203829,
0.0261215325,
-0.050844159,
-0.0419354625,
-0.0112169208,
-0.0649426952,
-0.0614806898,
0.0113858506,
-0.009096643,
0.0096001728,
-6.848048052e-33,
-0.016112661,
-0.0196008049,
0.0439079106,
-0.0304589029,
-0.0353120565,
-0.0672835857,
0.0072054896,
-0.0174988378,
-0.0287189856,
0.0063335933,
0.0072543654,
-0.0300849676,
0.0171694607,
0.0312387794,
0.0170930848,
0.0248763654,
0.005007993,
-0.0042635491,
-0.0446565524,
-0.0062975646,
0.0385689549,
-0.0195521377,
0.0167866144,
-0.008615219,
0.0115699125,
0.0267777964,
-0.0270911865,
0.041256316,
-0.0522633828,
0.0442061909,
0.0160876978,
0.0090329768,
-0.0191805735,
-0.0690510273,
-0.0403966941,
-0.0183088109,
-0.0290475916,
-0.0162600558,
-0.0298924521,
0.0248430967,
-0.0033422548,
-0.0410529114,
-0.0045809206,
0.0228135232,
-0.0264320038,
0.0117978817,
0.0189580098,
-0.0162998587,
-0.0300948303,
0.0487657636,
-0.0629888549,
0.0000796786,
-0.0059041865,
-0.0310927592,
0.0426820889,
0.0300115496,
0.0004606183,
-0.0224525668,
-0.0517291725,
0.0265795495,
0.000343621,
-0.0056028496,
0.0570758693,
0.0591622964,
0.0277583003,
0.0104769077,
0.0672543496,
-0.0209098645,
0.0377139673,
-0.0427683331,
0.0234736186,
0.0279740971,
-0.0190646928,
0.0366201922,
0.0013489329,
-0.0054019038,
-0.012288807,
0.0326751992,
0.018253902,
0.0428498164,
0.0230583996,
0.0424590111,
-0.0198611468,
-0.0277536828,
-0.0292427242,
0.0113387993,
0.0085513107,
-0.0339719392,
0.0111892736,
0.0139053501,
0.0066186115,
-0.0560564138,
0.0581246316,
-0.0199461095,
-0.04891802,
-0.0143315941,
-0.0342039317,
0.0034982297,
-0.0036397504,
-0.0196415745,
-0.0960611477,
-0.0759694576,
-0.0156143056,
-0.0479151942,
-0.0274199508,
0.0408911481,
0.0076156403,
0.0285916515,
-0.0535247736,
-0.0008272433,
-0.0296599958,
-0.0196368657,
0.0604069829,
0.0557003617,
0.0502850674,
-0.0442846827,
0.0003660643,
0.0304038543,
0.0222873427,
-0.0663112029,
0.0080667259,
0.0097932201,
-0.0220866129,
0.0315989926,
-0.0255727638,
0.0097773373,
-0.0239105783,
0.0328603983,
-0.0019766921,
-0.0198042169,
-0.0173409935,
-0.0292167887,
3.186e-7,
0.0229313094,
0.0520465188,
-0.0071127098,
0.0012753834,
-0.0224111844,
0.0513370745,
-0.0351028107,
0.0150807211,
-0.0189269818,
0.0607119724,
0.0473514237,
0.0389649235,
0.0117605589,
-0.0071715214,
-0.0334508531,
-0.0033344864,
0.0070504225,
0.0319944099,
-0.0316423886,
-0.0078903204,
0.00805174,
0.0830119476,
0.0380968228,
-0.0195907652,
0.0188347548,
0.0602896623,
0.0273958426,
-0.0682563782,
0.0472703241,
0.0092382897,
-0.016841827,
-0.0272936411,
-0.0078281732,
-0.0073367143,
0.0293280128,
0.0514377393,
-0.0353090838,
0.0477099232,
-0.02680384,
-0.0746184662,
0.0170319192,
0.024167452,
-0.011178988,
-0.0587811619,
0.0386616997,
-0.0215555672,
0.0015543158,
0.0191985797,
-0.0043711904,
0.0161611438,
0.0175581127,
0.0120522575,
-0.0274841432,
0.0038332036,
-0.0249392483,
0.0108812079,
0.0055126185,
-0.0398332998,
0.0167547949,
0.0267619733,
-0.0271901377,
-0.039201349,
-0.0042384719,
0.0702219382,
-0.0113246571,
0.0056257509,
-0.0155968638,
2.814712728e-34,
0.0139754014,
-0.0101295756,
0.0046046111,
-0.013861645,
0.0029675262,
0.0046497332,
-0.0292234533,
0.0043590982,
0.0508061722,
-0.041653011,
-0.0406569354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14867v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14867v1 | DistiLRR: Transferring Code Repair for Low-Resource Programming Languages | 2024-06-21T05:05:39 | 2024-06-21T05:05:39 | Kyle Wong, Alfonso Amayuelas, Liangming Pan, William Yang Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable performance on code
generation tasks. A recent application of LLMs for code generation is iterative
code repair, where a model fixes an incorrect program by rationalizing about
errors and generating a new program. However, code repair is primarily studied
on high-resource languages like Python, and the framework's efficacy is
under-explored on low-resource languages. To apply code repair for low-resource
languages, we propose Distilling Low-Resource Repairs (DistiLRR), an approach
that transfers the reasoning and code generation ability from a teacher model
to a student model. Our results show that DistiLRR consistently outperforms
baselines on low-resource languages, but has similar performance on
high-resource languages. To investigate this behavior, we perform a further
analysis and find that the correlation between rationale quality and code
correctness is weaker than previously perceived. We hypothesize this weakness
is magnified in low-resource settings where base models lack deep knowledge of
a programming language, leading to wavering benefits of code repair between
high-resource and low-resource languages. | [
0.0100451177,
0.1163554862,
-0.0141595034,
0.0131812068,
-0.0188904162,
0.0199149232,
-0.0273807012,
-0.0115735298,
-0.043906983,
-0.0090517607,
0.0231048036,
0.0004939197,
0.0337988548,
0.0033851706,
0.0296104625,
-0.0660486668,
0.0109888911,
-0.0663049519,
-0.0047279648,
0.0068288408,
-0.0159653146,
0.0303044841,
-0.0168455262,
0.0346139036,
0.0450065881,
-0.0402476788,
-0.0068187672,
0.0246692058,
-0.0116846878,
0.0016206871,
0.0082407007,
0.0173826497,
0.0031987824,
-0.0078661051,
0.0000022327,
-0.0452562794,
0.0075981845,
0.0205247812,
0.0305183548,
0.0680821165,
-0.014878476,
0.0073467381,
-0.0163724311,
0.0455209352,
-0.0163230225,
0.0205901824,
0.0157551467,
-0.0437891185,
0.0609153323,
0.0332343616,
0.0296053141,
-0.0134474663,
0.0168512203,
0.0297553167,
0.0226255525,
-0.0149650583,
-0.0002395458,
0.0883963108,
-0.010917387,
-0.0104540884,
-0.0210753437,
0.0114118988,
0.0411280245,
-0.0521207117,
0.0095093017,
0.0135312099,
-0.0175382625,
-0.0214633886,
0.0145530719,
-0.0006063117,
-0.0680128932,
-0.0330856256,
-0.0035641575,
0.0072608241,
-0.0016851735,
-0.0280919764,
-0.0640824065,
0.0277209096,
0.0281568747,
0.0253962316,
0.040193174,
-0.0800709501,
0.0232370459,
0.0080598183,
-0.0325426459,
0.027535582,
0.0057049859,
-0.0001605361,
-0.0587403364,
0.0039416621,
0.0069781579,
-0.0382219963,
-0.0456716865,
0.0698576346,
-0.0114868656,
0.0012537694,
-0.027707085,
0.0225361772,
0.0101856375,
0.0271852333,
-0.0026117573,
0.0213556401,
-0.0002666112,
-0.0049588261,
-0.0392054059,
0.0359399132,
0.0092836609,
-0.0090840114,
0.010981028,
0.0148353288,
-0.0476660952,
-0.0111915851,
-0.006194043,
0.0137157841,
0.013358376,
0.0526675731,
-0.0307475869,
0.0347478464,
-0.0277190041,
0.0601337701,
-0.0250769462,
-0.011145574,
-0.0124120777,
-0.016298607,
0.0027897307,
0.0639571846,
0.0045147864,
-0.0294800773,
0.0410148501,
-0.0866806358,
-0.0019569132,
0.011148815,
-0.0400146879,
-0.0386690684,
0.0207824856,
0.0491224527,
-0.0202237964,
0.0449478626,
-0.0682598948,
-0.0540114269,
0.0165104195,
-0.0534337759,
-0.0277787801,
-0.1168507934,
-0.0694649145,
0.0325592421,
0.0154506862,
-0.0928556174,
0.0142668225,
-0.0189309102,
-0.0278344527,
0.0375044197,
-0.045234587,
0.051786568,
0.0105621079,
0.0306703411,
-0.0123112844,
-0.0013950234,
0.0444988087,
-0.0224497914,
0.0070829266,
-0.0569208935,
0.0342311524,
-0.0260067247,
-0.0176290553,
0.0364003554,
-0.0226184744,
0.005099352,
0.0138770835,
0.0272200443,
0.0297783632,
0.0550567769,
-0.0107698506,
0.0981624201,
0.0127911409,
0.0076116673,
0.0249370486,
0.0594986752,
0.0406361446,
0.013742011,
-0.0118757477,
-0.0130163785,
-0.048372414,
0.0645641014,
-0.0000245611,
0.0147469146,
0.0048989295,
0.0622509159,
-0.0056789685,
-0.0847378001,
0.004552871,
0.0104662897,
0.0013115233,
0.0100251567,
0.0666959584,
-0.0132569466,
-0.0199018698,
0.057849057,
0.0081545813,
-0.0652406141,
0.0002416512,
-0.1019816473,
0.0527098812,
0.0557713844,
0.0494161621,
-0.0484932587,
-0.0125015946,
-0.0261063091,
0.0183739122,
-0.0507045425,
0.0380955674,
-0.0024237894,
-0.0064289602,
-0.0339382067,
-0.0269159731,
-0.0604376271,
0.011770756,
0.0160301812,
0.0390809774,
-0.0114205051,
0.0431888849,
-0.0306806564,
-0.092571944,
0.0219971649,
-0.0391046852,
-0.0060610576,
-0.0103615532,
-0.0047907792,
-0.0207067076,
-0.0276658423,
-0.033647012,
0.0141171487,
0.0074499967,
0.0088918488,
-0.014076014,
-0.0338194519,
-0.0450676158,
-0.0091399895,
0.0349143483,
-0.023988571,
-0.0484037884,
0.0237764791,
-0.0320878811,
-0.0250608008,
0.0942780897,
0.0125286197,
0.0174793955,
0.0039612115,
0.0676430613,
-0.0455865376,
-0.0487359278,
-0.0014640576,
0.0072128717,
0.0413636267,
0.0031566753,
0.0073047569,
0.0563284196,
0.0068792542,
0.0055941883,
-0.0048169727,
0.0240015816,
-0.039815139,
0.0461680219,
0.0136448508,
0.0458655767,
-0.0254568253,
-0.0311595984,
-0.0063794949,
0.007625001,
-0.028618766,
-0.0143326493,
0.011062677,
0.0272596627,
0.016805917,
0.0071490565,
-0.0202397984,
-0.0233057961,
0.0174405109,
0.0224085581,
0.0224833861,
-0.0279160123,
-0.0513011329,
-0.0445249416,
0.0067200763,
-0.0100627271,
0.0298597496,
0.0092562744,
0.0203893147,
-0.0834794641,
0.0845955014,
-0.0085287811,
-0.0080830492,
0.0052884221,
-0.0400619879,
0.0152619956,
-0.0370982699,
0.0594216622,
0.0432968847,
-0.0490391962,
0.0195475817,
0.0836439878,
0.0054731569,
-0.0354106501,
0.0105730463,
0.0321607329,
-0.082119137,
-0.0039216969,
-0.0538023971,
-0.0301592872,
0.0505228043,
-0.0134903779,
-0.0222931858,
-0.0378315076,
0.0527371988,
-0.0097538205,
0.0167045314,
-0.0050678318,
-0.0245413166,
0.0283901412,
0.0649146438,
-0.0222867001,
-0.0867754146,
0.0481367745,
0.0094765117,
0.0049564326,
-0.0080217337,
-0.0285743959,
-0.0445357747,
0.0667397305,
-0.018249983,
0.0189066902,
-0.0114816595,
-0.0335954987,
-0.0393909477,
0.0009444405,
0.0248666182,
-0.0184732806,
0.0658542663,
-0.103328906,
-0.0093233613,
-0.0041293316,
-0.0222377665,
-0.0176404379,
0.0367899053,
-0.0183201246,
0.0017896999,
-0.0116316145,
-0.0262898598,
0.0189075507,
-0.0306060892,
0.0376241617,
0.0079908138,
0.0206461437,
-0.049627699,
0.0281592645,
-0.024334982,
-0.0454592183,
-0.0489935428,
0.0041301358,
-0.0638286695,
0.0535802692,
0.0133415852,
0.0462917015,
0.0167022757,
-0.0655625835,
-0.0097869933,
0.0141203953,
0.0162816681,
-0.032881245,
0.0464479439,
0.0862892717,
-0.0550116301,
-0.0476024263,
0.0677948743,
0.0057082763,
0.0116661787,
0.0174744241,
-0.0474257916,
0.0604301132,
0.0524292476,
0.034039665,
-0.0415212661,
-0.0252679121,
0.0332318023,
0.0509947389,
0.0084498655,
-0.0146551635,
0.0017495435,
-0.0846678317,
0.0398093574,
0.0545454957,
-0.0000733409,
-0.0452818349,
-0.0591321737,
-0.0150727723,
-0.0171619486,
0.0084129106,
0.0678556338,
-0.0131768994,
0.0385225117,
0.0370410085,
-0.0250120983,
-0.0373071842,
0.0182868354,
-0.0021864779,
0.0158190113,
0.0599415749,
0.0254284944,
0.0034913903,
-0.0100853126,
0.0262247398,
0.0137673467,
0.0393088795,
-0.0002087807,
0.0192606263,
0.0572599508,
-0.014830119,
0.0366041511,
0.0372479744,
-0.0606984496,
-0.0401300304,
0.04155121,
0.0524826311,
-0.0068171946,
-0.0183575954,
-0.0100474451,
-0.0551129654,
-0.0185227338,
0.0202324409,
0.0579240471,
-0.0048148045,
-0.0540481508,
-0.0832813904,
-0.0556815304,
-0.0376127623,
-0.0080249542,
-0.0271832477,
-0.0074975006,
0.0193940699,
0.0006399316,
0.0093059577,
0.0142010674,
0.0130438963,
0.0102792541,
-0.0515885726,
-0.0068922439,
0.0111720748,
-0.0503451861,
0.0103412205,
-0.038895715,
0.0396152437,
-0.0363240205,
-0.0152105764,
-0.0594736449,
-0.0246440079,
-0.0032428531,
-0.0324535631,
-0.0590635985,
-0.0660439208,
-0.0123863192,
0.0651957318,
0.0292352978,
0.0286016017,
-0.0115540875,
-0.0497715585,
-0.0473720431,
0.0119332727,
-0.022007579,
0.0284615066,
0.0081771184,
-0.0330928788,
0.0288263597,
0.0004689184,
-0.0409227721,
-0.0029787594,
0.0571266115,
0.0209831223,
-0.0100642396,
0.0117930332,
0.0265886411,
0.0425126851,
0.0040279478,
0.0335819274,
-0.0288602822,
-0.0143633448,
-0.0080452552,
0.0259386972,
-0.0067324769,
-0.0342048742,
0.0242574308,
0.0489884838,
-0.0059307478,
0.0354874358,
-0.0023102765,
-0.0016988243,
0.041705966,
0.0068960558,
0.0590144917,
-0.0319067203,
0.0365155563,
0.1052383408,
0.0070729423,
-0.0102111623,
0.0165977776,
-0.0031961342,
0.0375067107,
0.0163846463,
0.0344680548,
0.0067618215,
0.063422963,
0.0190570131,
-0.0235731676,
-0.0470869951,
-0.1359106898,
0.0299264789,
-0.0117968014,
0.0359730162,
0.0491425656,
0.0482463874,
-0.0051026023,
0.0084370952,
-0.0095826043,
0.063382268,
0.0173491146,
-0.0369082168,
-0.0296086632,
0.0189726111,
-0.0016308744,
-0.0121776816,
0.0622087494,
-0.0195389371,
0.0358099937,
-0.0470552221,
-0.0123356115,
0.0027064544,
0.0010360053,
0.045361463,
-0.0379141644,
0.0118498756,
-0.0234446581,
-0.0273612775,
-0.0775549114,
-0.0431077369,
0.0247064568,
0.0237614363,
-0.0311561543,
-0.0111239683,
0.0850749165,
-0.0314899087,
0.0333072059,
-0.0305151474,
0.0250855237,
-0.0006314967,
-0.0412387475,
-0.0169346463,
-5.829064529e-33,
-0.0051769661,
0.0042705783,
0.0047798902,
0.003925479,
0.0030739675,
-0.008227122,
-0.0640574694,
0.0257662758,
-0.0066071539,
0.0159102697,
0.0153591353,
0.0290252101,
-0.0235430337,
-0.0081144189,
0.0558653511,
0.0649979562,
0.0635165647,
0.0657745898,
-0.0445912033,
0.0285893977,
-0.0055597899,
0.0360375084,
0.0318553671,
-0.0376623645,
-0.0196318142,
0.0000177352,
0.0293644778,
0.0280221254,
-0.0150948446,
0.0102387797,
0.0380118303,
0.0152977612,
-0.0104000568,
-0.039922107,
-0.0389339551,
-0.0182549544,
-0.0296567027,
-0.0059322873,
-0.0053286324,
-0.0200979728,
-0.0154872704,
-0.0603333823,
0.0668961257,
0.0384229012,
-0.0365137495,
-0.034538243,
0.0219250582,
-0.0250239726,
0.0076620542,
-0.0085918745,
-0.0769113302,
0.0337219536,
-0.0722474381,
-0.0329316184,
-0.0539112911,
0.0101876631,
-0.0342386886,
0.030928418,
0.0172764659,
0.0064329156,
0.0411777161,
0.062519826,
0.0607159212,
-0.0123181194,
-0.0431326255,
0.0472082831,
0.0240022354,
0.0304008201,
-0.0160395391,
0.0016740642,
0.026693007,
0.0408771634,
0.0465182662,
0.0261059981,
0.0210921653,
-0.0217223689,
-0.0967912003,
0.0059793233,
-0.0307760797,
0.0570424944,
-0.0137177994,
0.0474829711,
-0.0120997783,
-0.0282458868,
-0.0631106645,
-0.0049234801,
-0.0161015894,
-0.0461355262,
0.0174783748,
-0.0191721935,
-0.0676362887,
-0.0052224877,
0.0048692627,
-0.0153086716,
-0.0092253126,
0.0207272861,
-0.0476910062,
0.0186694246,
-0.0498801395,
0.0160883553,
-0.0230475459,
-0.0125735709,
-0.0121284267,
0.0093257511,
0.0770567581,
0.0076127932,
0.0462728813,
0.0315532535,
-0.0647909865,
-0.0120497774,
-0.0832668245,
0.0063701663,
0.0006052793,
0.0338726826,
-0.0027071759,
0.0176005401,
0.022419136,
-0.0003232643,
0.0099975122,
-0.0651523694,
-0.0453058109,
-0.0140851308,
0.0081617273,
-0.0054145516,
-0.0336694494,
-0.0712856278,
-0.0626289397,
0.0126610436,
0.0191847123,
-0.0339623764,
-0.0718542337,
0.007606904,
2.973e-7,
-0.0134390946,
0.0266951658,
-0.0208293833,
-0.0070947255,
0.0078208121,
0.0212574173,
-0.0305535216,
-0.0292572062,
0.0530768223,
0.0032191875,
-0.0140831647,
0.0195278693,
0.0533628426,
0.0189943668,
-0.0079372432,
0.0203916412,
-0.0319540091,
-0.0220355298,
-0.0385348946,
0.0032248551,
0.0208307803,
0.0010602758,
0.0349115096,
-0.0196449421,
0.0285352636,
-0.0272285603,
0.0118970033,
-0.0019331867,
-0.000482221,
0.0406509638,
-0.0409335271,
0.0400975049,
0.035079062,
-0.0211706683,
-0.0122021856,
-0.0502122901,
-0.0157931484,
0.0599325113,
-0.0228425525,
0.0858759582,
0.0176316872,
0.008729374,
0.0039102645,
-0.0866311342,
0.0249232203,
0.0015973159,
-0.0017683643,
-0.0068142414,
-0.0284260921,
-0.0046848394,
0.0022785247,
-0.0043257917,
0.0101140849,
-0.0018286589,
-0.0228763707,
0.0048416005,
-0.0330727175,
-0.011342518,
-0.0414316207,
-0.0008047617,
-0.000305349,
-0.0681328401,
-0.0266110133,
0.0057202755,
0.0262495019,
-0.0458523259,
0.028616637,
2.775394509e-34,
0.0399894528,
-0.0308792908,
0.042671781,
-0.0018479233,
0.0640215948,
0.0143329175,
-0.0075760377,
0.0084026977,
0.0053838254,
0.0462794192,
-0.0378244705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14862v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14862v3 | LatentExplainer: Explaining Latent Representations in Deep Generative Models with Multi-modal Foundation Models | 2024-06-21T04:39:03 | 2024-06-28T13:19:37 | Mengdan Zhu, Raasikh Kanjiani, Jiahui Lu, Andrew Choi, Qirui Ye, Liang Zhao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Deep generative models like VAEs and diffusion models have advanced various
generation tasks by leveraging latent variables to learn data distributions and
generate high-quality samples. Despite the field of explainable AI making
strides in interpreting machine learning models, understanding latent variables
in generative models remains challenging. This paper introduces
LatentExplainer, a framework for automatically generating semantically
meaningful explanations of latent variables in deep generative models.
LatentExplainer tackles three main challenges: inferring the meaning of latent
variables, aligning explanations with inductive biases, and handling varying
degrees of explainability. By perturbing latent variables and interpreting
changes in generated data, the framework provides a systematic approach to
understanding and controlling the data generation process, enhancing the
transparency and interpretability of deep generative models. We evaluate our
proposed method on several real-world and synthetic datasets, and the results
demonstrate superior performance in generating high-quality explanations of
latent variables. | [
-0.0303290039,
0.1142552346,
-0.0189298056,
-0.0000747558,
0.0141155319,
0.0273680836,
0.0572727881,
-0.0234952364,
-0.0934575871,
0.0509973727,
0.0268670432,
-0.0012527558,
-0.0192638282,
0.0726981983,
0.0599233285,
-0.0615076907,
-0.0034592026,
-0.0099636149,
0.0047082007,
-0.0183378123,
0.0136400126,
0.00269197,
0.0018565207,
0.0443712026,
-0.0294534694,
-0.0355661549,
-0.0227841437,
0.0295814909,
0.0077096694,
0.0028543533,
-0.0262881871,
0.0022699682,
0.0610903017,
-0.0038903747,
0.0000021762,
0.0069313496,
-0.0389682315,
0.0128867086,
-0.0521068573,
0.0016336342,
0.0284635872,
-0.0132646207,
0.003575037,
-0.0107610552,
-0.0019698299,
-0.0337903462,
0.0883421153,
0.0473197885,
0.0213227272,
0.0207307152,
-0.0066953213,
-0.0280056559,
-0.0086863376,
-0.0309567619,
0.0598226562,
0.0088976249,
-0.0089035211,
-0.0008884397,
-0.0462600626,
-0.0018720449,
-0.0391304903,
-0.0219208635,
0.0599174276,
-0.0452598147,
0.058499556,
0.025871329,
0.0574715249,
-0.0389792882,
0.0434835143,
0.0595511198,
-0.0046130158,
-0.0340878665,
0.0046093422,
-0.0468380935,
-0.0121164005,
0.0679138824,
-0.0697675198,
0.0005622139,
0.0251276828,
0.0179147217,
0.0292210523,
0.0138588622,
0.061890319,
-0.0025110876,
-0.0101524545,
-0.0177899878,
0.024426531,
0.0225496888,
-0.0843890235,
-0.0075367647,
-0.0153460363,
-0.0348062329,
-0.0062686251,
0.0152180111,
-0.0180018935,
-0.0036761872,
0.0317589082,
-0.0097495019,
-0.0209987443,
0.0405714735,
0.0294082239,
0.0414933152,
-0.0653170943,
0.0050403457,
0.0059880628,
0.021159092,
-0.0538420416,
-0.018916456,
-0.0317705236,
-0.0143070212,
-0.0169349369,
-0.0273947027,
0.0083118621,
-0.0367916189,
-0.0449612699,
-0.0062150261,
-0.0133018168,
0.0197605584,
-0.0396826454,
-0.0139185488,
0.0222232901,
0.0765612796,
-0.0431111529,
-0.0026322291,
-0.006584629,
0.0174802579,
-0.0766578019,
0.0239154622,
0.0576063395,
-0.034517277,
-0.0384851694,
0.0330090187,
0.0427226648,
-0.0038214503,
0.0032888022,
0.0423235483,
0.0199181046,
0.0339654163,
-0.0076383697,
-0.0563184731,
0.0147380112,
-0.0456193984,
0.0364432894,
-0.0069949753,
0.0199173354,
-0.0094917035,
-0.0034747622,
-0.0436344817,
-0.0106685385,
-0.0340670198,
0.0109984241,
0.0673183426,
-0.0162809212,
-0.00052089,
-0.0051622977,
0.0102256378,
0.0049101617,
0.0051953415,
0.0260920227,
0.0246879552,
-0.0161677301,
-0.0583748929,
0.0432221107,
-0.0327473357,
0.0401680283,
-0.0445810892,
0.0067858854,
-0.0397598967,
-0.0665380359,
0.0239043757,
0.0623302981,
-0.024792036,
-0.0254813544,
0.0207302701,
0.0121484445,
0.0019761953,
0.0520569831,
0.0503387228,
0.0883657038,
-0.0175181776,
-0.0573625825,
0.0060542333,
-0.0304233357,
0.0729400963,
0.021420652,
0.0028180412,
0.0026180458,
0.0269867592,
-0.0219860077,
-0.0542783178,
0.0334215946,
0.0070273117,
-0.0329667479,
0.0049515758,
0.0531651191,
-0.0110697979,
-0.0235643107,
0.018685421,
0.0258344095,
-0.0327040292,
-0.0016240885,
-0.0407870933,
0.0427268259,
0.0941970274,
0.0445922613,
0.0016610648,
-0.0128753707,
-0.0110004954,
-0.006715795,
-0.0098210406,
-0.0272073913,
-0.0211251117,
-0.0024105336,
-0.0314433165,
-0.0497251041,
-0.0519358106,
0.0412521139,
0.0379237048,
-0.028888464,
-0.0484923124,
0.0140812527,
-0.0498360023,
0.012120883,
0.0089239515,
-0.0418854468,
-0.0387836099,
0.0277384911,
0.0041849567,
0.0259368755,
0.0305550341,
0.0067414157,
0.0082391473,
0.0247213915,
-0.0305967685,
-0.0038583514,
0.0663474426,
-0.0184165128,
0.0158294048,
-0.0195833873,
-0.0622706041,
0.0085777091,
-0.0023470272,
-0.0284321848,
-0.0507134907,
0.0579518899,
-0.0300713666,
0.0048641893,
-0.0477333441,
-0.0345723927,
0.020263955,
0.0472150892,
0.0218440313,
0.0486057773,
0.0043309126,
-0.0446364656,
0.0540653691,
0.0573081374,
0.0080240443,
0.0101281302,
0.0840576217,
-0.0284804553,
-0.0269028321,
-0.0485634394,
0.0256531201,
-0.0135037797,
0.0003740069,
0.0216348507,
-0.0033912514,
-0.0107278163,
-0.0251448695,
-0.0328714326,
0.0297986269,
-0.0083130077,
0.0069937855,
0.0254497752,
-0.0155108403,
0.0617672317,
0.0456445776,
-0.0244465675,
0.0252477229,
-0.0431714579,
-0.0241008662,
-0.0576875843,
0.0155051677,
-0.0297091641,
0.0920767263,
0.0342533961,
0.0225110836,
-0.0160791036,
-0.0109163336,
0.0014119893,
-0.038236212,
-0.0270651691,
-0.0350764915,
0.0176181253,
-0.0334971026,
0.0355970152,
0.0249019116,
-0.0057773381,
0.1096310541,
0.0237633158,
-0.0237158109,
-0.0599867254,
-0.0181230251,
-0.0733204633,
0.0197652783,
-0.0134421829,
-0.0530570075,
-0.0357672162,
0.0484819487,
0.0092188986,
-0.0149975149,
-0.0524187386,
0.0887493715,
0.026699787,
-0.0181998443,
0.0175772589,
-0.0170907546,
-0.0029096201,
0.0480925404,
-0.0391478688,
-0.0586838834,
0.0517649464,
0.0137788234,
0.0091171861,
0.0149585651,
-0.000274431,
-0.019228017,
0.0458006747,
0.0005632248,
0.0140284449,
0.0239877515,
0.012223566,
-0.0098689869,
0.0346595086,
0.0521051139,
0.0129413148,
-0.0236103293,
-0.0621684231,
-0.0313323289,
0.0340447612,
0.0174817834,
-0.0411479324,
-0.0321026705,
0.0236806851,
0.0290112719,
0.057915993,
-0.0275810882,
-0.0116851432,
-0.0416540056,
0.026735127,
-0.0022370357,
-0.0188188031,
-0.0066333981,
-0.0156774335,
0.0173227526,
0.0401442908,
0.0117822932,
0.0381101668,
-0.0565165058,
0.0100823557,
-0.0033556572,
-0.0174193643,
0.0018519075,
-0.0665723979,
0.0403995737,
-0.0391679741,
0.0308142491,
0.010083884,
0.000627563,
0.0528808311,
-0.0559885874,
-0.0115937945,
0.0600012764,
0.0014563273,
0.0154267373,
0.055395849,
-0.0029312358,
0.0510080457,
-0.0016771819,
0.0343552046,
-0.0659611896,
-0.0017525391,
-0.0209350791,
0.010180898,
0.0192542151,
0.0061822874,
0.0164223164,
-0.0416706391,
0.0959676355,
-0.0049900063,
-0.0168119762,
-0.0177996103,
-0.0472066589,
-0.0388152376,
-0.0323396362,
-0.025343677,
-0.0271071214,
0.0416640863,
0.0308917295,
0.0461880378,
0.0065939105,
-0.0905714184,
-0.0123332767,
-0.0307858717,
0.0396239497,
0.0647174865,
0.0227583535,
0.0080943694,
-0.0340874158,
-0.0378317535,
0.0062428918,
0.0054958416,
0.002087703,
0.0452504605,
0.0565228015,
-0.0128372526,
-0.0201180726,
0.0929979458,
-0.0591885708,
-0.0384703577,
-0.0454483591,
0.0343367197,
-0.0255176388,
-0.0307392459,
-0.0305835288,
-0.0011844527,
0.0342657119,
0.041627381,
0.0595538989,
-0.0024481686,
-0.0440986753,
-0.0605646782,
0.0209588613,
-0.0235713534,
-0.0187184662,
-0.0373193584,
0.0508537851,
-0.0795102566,
-0.0155416736,
-0.0303078685,
0.0085904924,
0.0227195565,
-0.0030421254,
-0.0259325691,
-0.058168225,
-0.0387642048,
-0.0330235511,
0.0575809889,
0.051300589,
-0.0253275745,
0.0262766629,
-0.0628121868,
0.022724716,
-0.0934752077,
-0.0273916777,
0.0083668213,
-0.0477795564,
-0.0313023739,
0.0123929791,
0.0413537547,
0.0238394942,
0.0396218561,
-0.0046252427,
-0.0502092876,
0.0403996967,
0.0282518994,
-0.0220650863,
-0.0222908817,
0.0159257781,
-0.0090408018,
0.0080911964,
0.0009259602,
-0.0297063272,
0.0483659245,
0.0007983162,
0.0004170548,
-0.0209177081,
-0.0044555063,
0.0487261191,
-0.0428589843,
0.050917875,
-0.0207805242,
-0.0196175203,
-0.0638150498,
-0.0165885091,
-0.0003852111,
0.0064346925,
-0.0585081242,
0.0145469634,
0.0272055008,
0.0008612499,
-0.0188650191,
-0.0172929447,
0.0209597405,
0.0177194681,
-0.0252865516,
0.003839321,
-0.0057479823,
0.0221798047,
-0.0302510895,
0.0186157599,
0.0417444631,
0.0178881194,
-0.0493202284,
0.0214902591,
-0.0012504567,
0.043072626,
0.0136008263,
0.0119451052,
-0.0177605674,
-0.0017235625,
-0.0659980252,
-0.0397274196,
-0.0394094437,
0.0134238647,
0.0284073502,
-0.0088625373,
0.0583167858,
-0.0127803693,
0.0120490538,
0.0067592603,
0.0794322789,
0.0426817909,
-0.0344080292,
-0.0003175706,
0.0167771596,
-0.0282359421,
-0.0617012233,
0.0544439778,
0.0483390428,
0.0251163561,
-0.067649819,
0.016551584,
-0.0128672607,
-0.0074860761,
-0.0039010574,
0.0249168482,
0.0056161578,
0.0285288915,
-0.0279693529,
-0.033417847,
-0.0476044603,
0.0231970008,
-0.011182474,
0.0117940307,
0.0106243249,
0.0697981641,
-0.0550876036,
-0.0620362721,
-0.0132732596,
0.0072636334,
-0.0335329548,
0.0009715022,
-0.0100382315,
-6.888641546e-33,
-0.0273221582,
-0.0587820299,
0.018820636,
-0.042692475,
-0.021246668,
-0.0100375861,
-0.0808579996,
-0.0301674698,
0.0242664628,
0.0488204397,
0.0204244573,
0.0323815905,
-0.002302781,
0.0228414163,
0.0180132948,
-0.0253803711,
0.0755482465,
0.0224759132,
0.0046208114,
0.0620773099,
0.0253202915,
0.0308041219,
0.0210605469,
-0.1056215242,
0.0320408344,
0.015594013,
-0.0455001891,
-0.0175482426,
-0.0069764978,
0.052916456,
-0.0390849933,
-0.0085405661,
-0.0075091389,
-0.0629959479,
0.0006185803,
-0.0294368528,
-0.0710317641,
0.0078577651,
-0.001478905,
-0.0026237534,
-0.0693834201,
-0.089451015,
0.0304895639,
0.0092659835,
0.0259156004,
-0.0166038182,
0.0494204015,
-0.0050434181,
0.0253321417,
-0.0357021727,
-0.0622906722,
0.015489242,
-0.0645589009,
0.0039973548,
0.0060555846,
0.0014231408,
0.0145389074,
0.0119811427,
-0.0078380136,
0.0285807103,
0.0329020061,
-0.0128994565,
0.0900732428,
0.0194688533,
0.0298912358,
0.0453999527,
0.0487577058,
-0.0406873487,
-0.0818880051,
0.0085907448,
0.0028916814,
0.0796820298,
0.052058313,
0.0641266406,
0.0392399989,
0.0306167677,
-0.0668207183,
0.0521542355,
-0.0589340813,
-0.0051743104,
0.0205960609,
0.0146399001,
0.0110476473,
-0.0127993114,
-0.0235096384,
-0.0607304201,
-0.0311691575,
-0.030214021,
0.0175173692,
-0.0260093454,
-0.094473809,
-0.0227602646,
0.0033860102,
-0.0582948774,
0.0216942225,
0.0241780262,
0.01040419,
0.0035094051,
0.0078173503,
-0.0193235278,
0.0106527992,
-0.0043270201,
0.0499297641,
-0.0026218302,
0.0439973846,
0.0339880176,
0.0021304155,
0.0367457084,
0.0205789339,
-0.0050515183,
-0.0639595836,
-0.0371149257,
-0.0299541261,
-0.0220719427,
0.001961611,
0.0071211746,
-0.0270532798,
0.0070558973,
0.042290885,
0.060326416,
0.0073748208,
0.003889509,
-0.0145997386,
0.0234956741,
-0.0352363326,
-0.0079377005,
-0.0245704241,
-0.0402707048,
0.0861967057,
-0.0604588203,
-0.0351795889,
0.0103341723,
2.756e-7,
0.040038269,
0.0248472504,
0.028799912,
-0.0021171686,
0.0236507729,
0.0178996548,
0.0220421217,
-0.0138656236,
-0.0294541456,
-0.0410409346,
0.057611376,
0.0534398295,
0.0265867878,
0.0086072637,
0.0188228749,
0.0088078845,
-0.0120572234,
-0.0238741357,
-0.0186153315,
-0.0022398033,
0.0360164195,
0.0578838401,
-0.0018222932,
-0.0113368519,
0.1056049168,
0.0412946939,
0.0456382632,
-0.0178007167,
0.0216116756,
-0.0053375666,
0.0332185663,
-0.0296896026,
-0.0045141773,
-0.0293115806,
-0.02080011,
-0.0120598441,
-0.0130389733,
0.0366868451,
-0.0174717531,
-0.0548991933,
-0.0143320961,
-0.0115932049,
0.0245484971,
-0.0452958532,
0.0439915322,
-0.0053357952,
-0.0256992746,
-0.0075695268,
-0.0677362308,
0.0029774068,
-0.0109617794,
-0.0096010556,
0.0078387512,
-0.0174390823,
-0.0332872607,
-0.0321818255,
0.0180877242,
-0.0462157205,
-0.009942892,
-0.0249473732,
-0.0512685701,
0.0123851364,
-0.0232983325,
-0.0289416071,
0.0815282091,
0.044406198,
-0.0301114284,
2.549504213e-34,
0.0162796006,
0.0285696834,
-0.0192764681,
-0.013314683,
0.0457275286,
-0.0023534922,
-0.0192472171,
0.0125603843,
0.0496249013,
-0.0409447774,
-0.0480988398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14859v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14859v1 | From LLMs to MLLMs: Exploring the Landscape of Multimodal Jailbreaking | 2024-06-21T04:33:48 | 2024-06-21T04:33:48 | Siyuan Wang, Zhuohan Long, Zhihao Fan, Zhongyu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs) and Multimodal Large
Language Models (MLLMs) has exposed vulnerabilities to various adversarial
attacks. This paper provides a comprehensive overview of jailbreaking research
targeting both LLMs and MLLMs, highlighting recent advancements in evaluation
benchmarks, attack techniques and defense strategies. Compared to the more
advanced state of unimodal jailbreaking, multimodal domain remains
underexplored. We summarize the limitations and potential research directions
of multimodal jailbreaking, aiming to inspire future research and further
enhance the robustness and security of MLLMs. | [
0.0326163471,
0.0801608413,
-0.0185239352,
0.0704900548,
-0.0529135205,
-0.0047399867,
0.0545727052,
-0.0041327546,
0.0234259572,
-0.0634558499,
-0.0448137484,
-0.0340151936,
0.0156191979,
-0.0061305589,
0.0674326345,
-0.0290404968,
0.024145456,
-0.0347633623,
-0.0501273908,
0.0046299077,
0.0272129625,
-0.016679259,
0.0212928504,
0.0361215509,
-0.0155257117,
-0.0175169278,
-0.0323033109,
0.024488844,
0.0081619062,
-0.0260608196,
-0.0104535781,
0.0368008427,
0.0100718774,
0.0666330829,
0.0000020484,
-0.012108176,
-0.0348793417,
0.0223686006,
0.0437253304,
0.0427761413,
0.0324841551,
-0.0704912245,
-0.012606306,
-0.0004443884,
-0.0297444295,
0.0024455844,
0.0164385363,
0.0322487615,
0.0740935132,
0.0627564192,
0.002307178,
-0.0280125197,
0.0445130467,
-0.0111718867,
-0.0186703037,
-0.0516878255,
0.0072342278,
-0.0191434715,
-0.0147428252,
-0.0142002683,
-0.014909572,
0.023607485,
0.0251870137,
0.0068137152,
-0.0653266534,
-0.0188512858,
-0.0024459192,
-0.0142259235,
-0.0079840701,
0.0595918,
-0.0627338588,
0.008779794,
-0.0006063352,
0.0191580374,
0.0182071812,
0.0366254672,
-0.0331191868,
0.0556221642,
-0.0047203139,
-0.02398674,
-0.0207984429,
-0.0481291488,
0.0607658215,
-0.0098981187,
0.0088337669,
-0.0047861794,
0.040769957,
-0.0235185921,
-0.0192498285,
-0.0361666791,
-0.0202970523,
-0.0424046852,
0.0010589345,
-0.0049711061,
0.0394598544,
0.0011181905,
-0.11014162,
-0.0444549099,
0.0137461973,
-0.0478284247,
0.0556894429,
-0.0226123258,
-0.0178661384,
0.02081565,
0.0086845579,
-0.0154285971,
-0.0401291847,
0.0276467726,
0.0098194703,
0.0082770949,
-0.0024279745,
-0.0159223173,
0.0163690019,
-0.0027211728,
-0.0300172716,
-0.0126975039,
-0.0197537187,
0.0184127782,
-0.014757745,
0.0240875371,
-0.0908847898,
-0.0104695698,
0.0174170528,
0.0040809498,
0.0612395965,
-0.0127280336,
0.0063998504,
-0.0124183334,
0.0049534244,
-0.0626851171,
-0.0128743947,
0.042864982,
-0.070966363,
-0.035534557,
-0.0159221292,
0.1402466446,
0.0340998434,
-0.0340435617,
-0.06816452,
-0.0802044943,
-0.0482833274,
-0.0537323356,
0.0423812978,
-0.0727479234,
-0.0172182471,
-0.0389315821,
-0.0063431459,
-0.039229691,
0.0086042378,
-0.0090889391,
-0.0279390346,
0.0617553815,
0.037673939,
-0.0421895199,
0.0132449772,
0.0453590378,
0.0472203307,
0.0918571129,
0.001939947,
0.049368225,
0.0787297189,
-0.0124543477,
0.0336375386,
0.067059204,
-0.0074316096,
0.0460096858,
-0.0345100164,
-0.0343327746,
0.0636600852,
0.0086821672,
-0.0342597552,
0.0391256586,
-0.0160810445,
-0.0727702379,
0.1149664149,
0.0312978178,
-0.0183444694,
0.0243911278,
-0.0104727317,
-0.0525677428,
0.0415130779,
0.0195042118,
-0.0592099503,
0.0236937888,
-0.0805345476,
-0.0314830802,
-0.0084319534,
0.0642032772,
-0.017984245,
-0.0039461921,
-0.0004286651,
-0.0351040103,
-0.0159576684,
-0.0096653234,
0.0240834709,
0.0041263248,
0.0002476878,
0.0353812911,
0.0097832019,
-0.0324337482,
-0.0337843075,
-0.0746628642,
-0.0366657078,
0.0124085778,
0.0505133979,
-0.0110530378,
0.0064517818,
-0.0268240348,
0.0175587516,
0.0186775643,
-0.0093768416,
-0.0004090148,
0.0420926772,
-0.0171096213,
-0.0037391596,
-0.0612612553,
0.0200473275,
0.0291584916,
-0.0129742371,
0.0031358572,
-0.030299399,
-0.027528625,
0.0140872011,
0.0118605588,
0.0144128902,
0.0153094083,
0.0149500379,
0.0485321842,
0.0111029698,
0.0057755075,
-0.0474598855,
-0.0044339746,
0.0718404949,
-0.0216998067,
0.0255147349,
0.0025716783,
-0.0064776554,
-0.0367154926,
0.0281652641,
-0.0520297177,
0.005554914,
0.0938401148,
-0.0431529395,
0.0253977943,
0.0697277337,
0.0029488634,
0.0224920064,
0.0020471057,
0.0097802198,
0.0042997967,
0.0472755097,
-0.0432075001,
-0.003691677,
-0.0625562891,
-0.0071691172,
-0.0263776835,
0.0000920844,
0.0145226093,
0.0004796382,
-0.0525226295,
0.0426069237,
-0.0322615914,
0.0147576388,
-0.0329184011,
-0.0033322102,
0.000286676,
-0.0417898893,
-0.0355000049,
-0.0368703678,
-0.0448030457,
-0.0009133767,
0.0312592387,
0.0063288156,
-0.0125219421,
-0.0190562345,
0.0031528794,
0.0039641229,
-0.0037126283,
0.0181536227,
-0.0101616718,
-0.0091043944,
-0.0280376524,
-0.0054862807,
-0.0415479392,
0.0135174002,
0.0871415734,
-0.0499670096,
-0.0301625691,
-0.0038390486,
-0.0425894558,
-0.0086048367,
0.0408727042,
-0.0304652359,
-0.0327533372,
0.0468371399,
0.0029111898,
0.000460289,
0.0891532302,
0.017421212,
0.0731829554,
0.0822827145,
0.0045817737,
0.0005346648,
-0.0240606107,
0.0547510982,
-0.0351220854,
-0.0399127714,
-0.0393509828,
0.0263068751,
0.0553100556,
0.0349870697,
0.0077992384,
0.0096284663,
0.0380408466,
-0.0134346206,
-0.0580854788,
-0.0107143121,
0.0233820491,
-0.0289114751,
-0.0188142154,
-0.011374752,
-0.0682014525,
0.0372184068,
-0.0546688922,
0.0148061002,
0.0261331294,
-0.0572344996,
-0.0024837002,
0.0532908849,
0.0047980831,
0.0464984179,
0.0171914604,
-0.0047005452,
-0.0270184055,
-0.0281035081,
0.0371258371,
0.0126102231,
0.0609920099,
-0.0516281202,
-0.0150129758,
-0.0172740985,
-0.0332867764,
-0.0103948386,
-0.0615663454,
-0.0033037642,
-0.013241115,
0.0117367748,
-0.0357887261,
-0.0190745257,
-0.0230386108,
0.0269377306,
-0.0253771506,
-0.0040121358,
-0.0035891244,
-0.0264234673,
0.073887825,
0.0265629292,
-0.023640817,
-0.0046254545,
-0.0466781929,
0.0145382071,
0.079196997,
0.0244388394,
0.0294093471,
-0.0325072035,
0.0307450052,
0.019763371,
0.0374366418,
-0.014902195,
0.0047299433,
0.067321457,
-0.0328216739,
0.022964647,
0.0177361928,
0.0018919974,
0.0006737743,
0.0128141576,
0.031482663,
0.0400463864,
0.0000935468,
0.0121233314,
-0.0631899312,
-0.0414025225,
0.0077840486,
0.0532973632,
0.0131125087,
-0.0136474576,
-0.018586142,
-0.0608217828,
0.0013681467,
0.0214327127,
-0.0323977359,
-0.0228731576,
-0.0198411588,
-0.0387806073,
0.015480536,
0.0292285979,
-0.0196287949,
-0.0051475256,
-0.0062576048,
0.0072227316,
-0.0312524326,
-0.0300744474,
-0.0052291942,
-0.0309808701,
0.0415840298,
0.0699945092,
0.0017570187,
-0.0432132334,
0.0143671073,
0.0529199764,
0.0290464405,
0.0035245894,
0.0107709877,
0.0194517914,
-0.0018156498,
-0.008344329,
0.0124302097,
0.0515498109,
0.027779419,
-0.0228516869,
0.0354546346,
0.0273056012,
0.0070916498,
-0.0167048555,
-0.0268400311,
-0.0029537221,
0.0117196552,
0.0375561416,
0.0416798852,
-0.0491339415,
-0.0394206867,
-0.0857680067,
-0.0303857494,
-0.0401462875,
-0.023316877,
0.0316421874,
0.0362033024,
0.0000728348,
-0.0324081555,
-0.0049825939,
-0.0344284251,
0.0561874211,
0.0104698427,
0.0136278607,
-0.0616651513,
0.0191103537,
-0.0259181485,
-0.0245153196,
0.0154899536,
0.0674640015,
-0.0395660289,
0.0291596465,
0.0005864821,
-0.0403330475,
-0.0018392629,
0.010240607,
-0.0967852175,
-0.0849162713,
0.0104592312,
0.0547378883,
0.0126012797,
-0.0008962284,
-0.0010896983,
-0.0755906925,
0.0333101116,
0.0768907145,
-0.0193937197,
0.0524281301,
0.0949510634,
0.0023440896,
0.0014770186,
0.0555778071,
-0.0208862424,
-0.028817378,
0.0864624009,
0.0010288659,
-0.0205244403,
0.0158027001,
-0.0133422092,
0.0121814758,
0.0204107948,
-0.0279495213,
-0.0078428928,
0.0347073674,
0.0295713693,
-0.0076380861,
-0.0185139962,
-0.0306674168,
0.0031541823,
0.0304402728,
0.0025109309,
0.0187801328,
0.0409101471,
0.0564623512,
0.0011997013,
-0.0226016212,
0.0589320175,
0.0362780169,
0.0206565596,
0.0458897389,
0.0379302539,
-0.0245634783,
0.064145714,
-0.0285426546,
0.0312551185,
-0.0151471933,
0.0664359108,
0.0104920771,
-0.0220786631,
-0.0167007335,
0.0721018612,
-0.0559817962,
-0.0206370745,
-0.0083170962,
0.0719250813,
0.0465233102,
0.0256788637,
-0.0014562124,
-0.0226560496,
-0.008854975,
-0.0402288176,
-0.000642886,
-0.0096196597,
-0.0416364968,
0.0251735076,
-0.0130157787,
0.0008712985,
0.0439536348,
0.051146552,
0.0376298241,
0.0519866981,
0.0372359715,
0.003597772,
-0.0397127159,
-0.0073916116,
0.0928107575,
0.0040402259,
-0.0341973417,
-0.0529894605,
-0.0547292009,
-0.0787029937,
-0.0178642832,
0.0213450044,
0.0330522284,
0.0198376477,
-0.0454461537,
0.0595805608,
0.0307338163,
0.0479620621,
-0.0551787615,
0.0096778693,
0.0134257795,
-0.0452488735,
0.0430911444,
-6.168972313e-33,
0.0194757394,
-0.0302329157,
-0.0510165542,
-0.0596187711,
0.0097327456,
-0.0030447759,
-0.0004573606,
0.0164220743,
0.0045250608,
-0.0396851785,
0.007857441,
-0.0333449617,
-0.0179101154,
0.0248736553,
-0.0456456132,
-0.0349555574,
-0.0135527607,
0.0015105488,
-0.0249293093,
-0.0003699521,
0.0381120667,
0.0236895327,
0.0230475571,
-0.0285545178,
0.0231874511,
-0.0109918611,
-0.0524972752,
0.0003766812,
-0.0505378023,
0.055339396,
-0.0176841784,
0.0169920828,
0.0066406149,
0.0005701008,
-0.0109129352,
0.0404885076,
0.0070201778,
0.0265350379,
-0.0150672225,
0.0311314613,
-0.0165489465,
-0.0233171117,
0.0420053042,
-0.0192836337,
-0.0077086925,
-0.0254149772,
-0.0048341178,
-0.0085320743,
-0.022395039,
-0.0020559717,
-0.0018103472,
0.0111812577,
-0.0298552066,
-0.0013889994,
0.0096069649,
-0.0166000761,
0.0234780703,
0.0105550885,
-0.0399290062,
0.0427400731,
0.0048455037,
-0.0089036888,
0.0755697563,
0.0114473095,
0.0005834951,
0.0709003806,
0.0133683505,
-0.0229285136,
0.0004883219,
0.0145943789,
0.0367275178,
0.062583521,
0.082141459,
0.1029107645,
0.0472896844,
0.0095528634,
-0.0595832951,
-0.0052252868,
0.0086541325,
0.0136330519,
0.0286009237,
0.0149105834,
-0.0119164372,
0.0145605644,
-0.0288805589,
-0.0514083281,
-0.0298698917,
-0.0333896354,
0.0377310999,
-0.0051721265,
-0.0174403898,
-0.0212579258,
0.0356743634,
-0.062956199,
-0.0503943302,
0.0128616877,
-0.0074728006,
0.0284700971,
-0.0015186956,
0.018433461,
-0.0131199453,
0.0221471209,
0.0127191124,
-0.0509099402,
0.0331078656,
-0.0212598443,
0.0397027135,
0.0368364193,
-0.0433855243,
-0.0112417024,
-0.0134169674,
0.0201803669,
0.0290757753,
0.0182925519,
0.0376174934,
-0.0572389886,
-0.0186592955,
-0.0209869947,
0.0224744286,
-0.001657174,
-0.039195694,
-0.0086371116,
-0.048319187,
0.0151187461,
0.002632054,
0.0066151675,
-0.0287557952,
-0.0193166342,
0.0577229708,
-0.0848058611,
0.0012830201,
-0.016356824,
2.765e-7,
-0.0432003029,
0.0042005465,
-0.0060760253,
-0.0452389345,
0.0297160856,
0.0703763217,
-0.0483800322,
0.0741430148,
-0.0335469358,
-0.0382684693,
-0.0780311003,
-0.0034943188,
0.0751609653,
0.0343477651,
-0.0233037639,
0.0268885382,
-0.0261903964,
0.0146766435,
-0.0532987118,
-0.0064876857,
0.0107270936,
0.0850217566,
0.0047054728,
-0.0380333588,
0.031589102,
-0.0712346658,
0.0067187399,
-0.0111734094,
-0.0281916875,
-0.0468578339,
0.0350429267,
0.0200038161,
-0.0073552788,
-0.0028152792,
-0.0257141031,
-0.0407495275,
-0.0162220411,
0.0190928001,
0.0216268133,
-0.0362409651,
-0.0317461863,
-0.0140639069,
-0.0554664582,
-0.0226325504,
0.0763256252,
0.0246363953,
-0.0286100563,
-0.0323557816,
0.0328604802,
-0.0454238802,
0.0247815922,
-0.0550189316,
-0.0053752172,
0.0083335647,
0.0200100485,
-0.0059251557,
0.0255548693,
-0.0618461296,
-0.008662357,
0.0030690019,
-0.0139414463,
-0.0294542536,
-0.0228357278,
0.0065843021,
0.050873857,
-0.0315456465,
-0.0417731293,
2.764634832e-34,
0.0059295762,
-0.0488275774,
0.0226094574,
-0.0231777485,
0.025546208,
-0.0141325463,
-0.0121393744,
-0.0063959211,
-0.0118641984,
-0.0605060495,
-0.0148774022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14848v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14848v1 | Leveraging Passage Embeddings for Efficient Listwise Reranking with Large Language Models | 2024-06-21T03:33:51 | 2024-06-21T03:33:51 | Qi Liu, Bo Wang, Nan Wang, Jiaxin Mao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Recent studies have demonstrated the effectiveness of using large language
language models (LLMs) in passage ranking. The listwise approaches, such as
RankGPT, have become new state-of-the-art in this task. However, the efficiency
of RankGPT models is limited by the maximum context length and relatively high
latency of LLM inference. To address these issues, in this paper, we propose
PE-Rank, leveraging the single passage embedding as a good context compression
for efficient listwise passage reranking. By treating each passage as a special
token, we can directly input passage embeddings into LLMs, thereby reducing
input length. Additionally, we introduce an inference method that dynamically
constrains the decoding space to these special tokens, accelerating the
decoding process. For adapting the model to reranking, we employ listwise
learning to rank loss for training. Evaluation results on multiple benchmarks
demonstrate that PE-Rank significantly improves efficiency in both prefilling
and decoding, while maintaining competitive ranking effectiveness. {The Code is
available at \url{https://github.com/liuqi6777/pe_rank}.} | [
-0.0062559196,
0.0632622391,
-0.0082723321,
0.0699076876,
0.0146473534,
0.0128419744,
-0.0109426742,
0.0081054382,
0.0355676711,
-0.0474441424,
0.0027637805,
-0.0240722187,
0.0155950682,
0.0166738313,
0.050635498,
-0.0332537927,
-0.0023377687,
-0.0415685587,
0.0256870259,
-0.0112268208,
-0.0171286482,
0.012666896,
0.026417125,
0.0221472345,
0.0860429108,
0.0011560975,
0.0151235266,
0.0093625197,
0.05196831,
-0.0673990622,
0.0048093335,
0.0128782587,
0.0528817922,
0.033756651,
0.0000019357,
-0.0123020457,
-0.0323495939,
0.0092900237,
-0.0158961769,
0.0453244187,
0.0192931723,
0.005941717,
-0.0066095842,
0.0177670307,
-0.0003755353,
-0.0218563024,
0.0371647961,
0.0078453626,
0.0470695458,
0.0443758667,
-0.0053608757,
-0.0427436978,
-0.0276058428,
-0.070309557,
-0.0077195689,
-0.0635011047,
0.016903514,
-0.0324390642,
0.0021837349,
0.0591326095,
-0.0447141603,
0.0090803467,
0.0122412872,
0.000917689,
0.0186839849,
0.0505333319,
-0.0332478769,
0.0597856045,
-0.0083558084,
0.0882946774,
-0.0440721847,
-0.0349894576,
-0.0080817835,
0.0073939497,
-0.0160229709,
-0.0388109386,
-0.0409693941,
0.0258662347,
0.0074920892,
0.038692344,
0.0243697427,
0.0448854938,
0.0638693199,
0.0125001026,
-0.0515944734,
0.0284699909,
0.0523062535,
-0.0353179872,
-0.0014749614,
0.0020957717,
-0.0336889289,
-0.0031045547,
0.0116925575,
-0.0287490208,
-0.0202956386,
0.0248611402,
-0.0038749906,
0.0049237418,
-0.0119133452,
-0.0220457856,
-0.0019802018,
0.0428509973,
0.0160612296,
0.0137726758,
-0.0473728552,
0.0695152432,
0.0250010565,
0.0156563316,
-0.0775741488,
0.0221390855,
0.0234354753,
-0.01674488,
-0.0202630349,
0.0245062318,
-0.0375663862,
-0.015277952,
-0.0475501157,
-0.0129026668,
0.0205166917,
0.0164463595,
-0.0103085339,
-0.0179440379,
-0.0292175002,
-0.0128367338,
0.0238625258,
0.0271289572,
0.0037503671,
-0.0267428644,
-0.0289894566,
0.0367080644,
-0.0231991336,
-0.0239017904,
-0.0340122394,
-0.020578688,
0.0163656045,
0.0268597286,
-0.0256028008,
-0.0133625949,
-0.0048060003,
0.0340614729,
0.0079578348,
-0.0251087639,
-0.045729585,
-0.0406232923,
0.0401492715,
0.0110372156,
0.0307873618,
-0.0282585975,
0.0267661195,
0.0428361818,
-0.0428338386,
0.0639711991,
0.0510079525,
-0.0211066529,
0.0097947977,
0.0443295315,
0.0455561914,
0.052550707,
0.0346157588,
0.0346125141,
0.0325513743,
-0.0099659786,
-0.0433959737,
0.0604245216,
0.0103331702,
0.0278388225,
-0.0163701475,
-0.0196749847,
0.0472230949,
0.0257615279,
0.052436851,
0.0433603935,
-0.0617091022,
-0.0336617455,
0.055559855,
0.0568972975,
0.0577085018,
0.0175748002,
0.0274587516,
0.0009932137,
-0.0175590683,
0.0170809459,
-0.0271986295,
-0.0167896394,
0.0068331561,
0.0233703423,
0.0950765759,
0.0460298955,
0.0014061279,
-0.0211238246,
-0.0108214254,
-0.0080590565,
0.0111876447,
0.0089035993,
0.0288305599,
0.0010891404,
-0.0709066465,
0.053292647,
0.0475732796,
-0.0686422512,
-0.0024095869,
-0.0142404335,
-0.0358105004,
0.0873373151,
0.0684324503,
-0.0299855974,
-0.0183538981,
0.0096256537,
-0.013638325,
0.0158041697,
-0.0081009641,
-0.0314072296,
0.0411775224,
-0.0542957149,
-0.006512335,
0.0219658725,
-0.0026631332,
0.0712141395,
0.0034002098,
0.0088860914,
0.0083890827,
-0.0893914923,
-0.0107646724,
0.0362707339,
-0.0339399502,
-0.0225586072,
0.0174149666,
-0.0033397535,
0.012193176,
0.0184264537,
-0.0033005532,
0.002508546,
0.0268799383,
-0.0686073676,
0.0097282585,
-0.0121645462,
-0.0683933944,
-0.0660806596,
0.0343298987,
-0.0245898385,
0.0216420405,
0.0815202296,
-0.0595776401,
-0.0202992726,
-0.0347305164,
-0.028234804,
0.0333186276,
-0.0001851321,
0.0129123256,
0.0184403621,
-0.0061537926,
-0.0650298968,
0.0767906979,
-0.0186146051,
0.0758551881,
0.0690097138,
0.032867413,
-0.0048094145,
-0.0157710947,
-0.0579249188,
0.0739701688,
0.0060257679,
-0.0284790024,
0.0114331963,
0.0130866617,
-0.0078887157,
-0.0201269351,
-0.1068519279,
-0.0033725542,
-0.0035526066,
0.0107540917,
0.0084478892,
-0.0043986025,
-0.0000996779,
-0.0071933838,
-0.0218335241,
-0.0544779748,
-0.0071845911,
0.006006571,
-0.0048165759,
-0.0016659931,
-0.0234042536,
-0.0245617814,
-0.0398055092,
0.0040656724,
0.067919381,
-0.0517549552,
-0.0165434573,
-0.0820424557,
0.0475557037,
-0.0185819604,
0.0103321727,
-0.0330212936,
-0.0494932495,
-0.0256139804,
-0.0082488563,
0.0541510396,
0.0267975386,
0.010061726,
0.0139500024,
0.0612402335,
-0.0254346468,
-0.034301769,
0.009662346,
0.0183704291,
-0.0081863655,
-0.0462489948,
-0.0316424668,
-0.0315033048,
0.028880002,
-0.0031229274,
-0.0044213361,
-0.0638815761,
-0.0157987513,
-0.0376738608,
-0.0073036193,
-0.0531776063,
-0.0213325564,
-0.0255297273,
-0.002669553,
0.0031347221,
-0.0466033965,
0.0354037061,
-0.0600097291,
-0.0218609218,
-0.0699937567,
0.0005680131,
-0.0644809753,
0.0644571483,
0.0378841087,
0.034869954,
-0.039201308,
-0.05792889,
-0.0398833193,
0.0504293889,
0.0144216139,
-0.0628763363,
0.0301413145,
-0.0413224921,
0.0022099216,
-0.0393955484,
-0.0404069647,
-0.0320795514,
-0.023317825,
0.0248105321,
-0.0143326949,
0.0229635127,
-0.020069804,
0.0262513049,
0.0322404578,
-0.0012759436,
0.0719000399,
0.0012207269,
0.0116894869,
-0.0022485682,
0.0671847016,
0.0333280489,
-0.0180705376,
0.0151000675,
-0.0201471467,
0.0532744341,
0.0502596386,
0.0685186833,
-0.007815972,
0.030836625,
0.0183789358,
0.0737739205,
-0.0415589027,
-0.0202676579,
0.0304736421,
0.0303437654,
-0.0534803644,
-0.024955783,
0.1143785417,
0.043095842,
-0.0749619082,
0.0026593616,
0.0050152512,
0.0507420599,
-0.0081551103,
0.0155772464,
-0.0682023615,
0.009669181,
0.0269064624,
0.0172521044,
0.0118113915,
-0.0130334944,
-0.0182083771,
-0.1273951232,
0.0323647782,
0.0563148521,
-0.0343440361,
-0.0361192636,
-0.0431879424,
-0.0248953458,
-0.0036360163,
-0.004312322,
0.039046552,
-0.0125171887,
-0.0048687053,
-0.0001726048,
-0.0159769263,
-0.0215548165,
0.0051357918,
-0.0251573622,
0.0524676181,
0.0261674076,
0.0485065393,
-0.0181386825,
-0.0058541526,
-0.010834774,
-0.0891897827,
-0.056015715,
-0.0117267082,
0.0029087057,
-0.0123746321,
0.0135371871,
-0.0002442549,
0.0452339053,
-0.0086868573,
-0.0094562452,
-0.0229027104,
0.0426698364,
0.0164249763,
0.0050903969,
-0.0042963466,
-0.0012193677,
-0.01086633,
0.0696444809,
-0.0106771169,
-0.0138736321,
-0.0145910941,
-0.0778052956,
0.0311241783,
0.0014894942,
-0.0577764325,
0.0259623528,
0.0081151063,
-0.0041646147,
-0.0708994418,
-0.0047296477,
-0.007544341,
0.0327603295,
-0.0023574897,
0.0797620118,
-0.0453478061,
-0.007215884,
-0.0420437045,
-0.0275911186,
-0.0172729641,
0.0214409214,
-0.0257596094,
-0.0055185426,
0.0305145364,
-0.0024918262,
-0.0292331614,
0.0068829912,
-0.0667721778,
-0.0625820607,
-0.0177674759,
0.0241286885,
0.0172322262,
-0.0010873816,
-0.0059488155,
-0.0236933101,
0.08487425,
0.0041571916,
-0.0203100517,
0.0290524904,
0.0374151133,
0.0379685052,
-0.0200181361,
0.0344741233,
-0.0463927947,
-0.0232749209,
-0.0164396223,
0.0527056605,
-0.0006718084,
-0.0437046848,
0.0065797702,
-0.0027785629,
0.0028859696,
-0.0320604555,
-0.0242702272,
-0.0498968586,
0.0587281063,
-0.0562120155,
-0.0172986072,
-0.0142827928,
0.0275359601,
0.0658384562,
-0.0049645682,
-0.0185165592,
-0.0190583915,
0.0465590954,
-0.002930867,
-0.0665371716,
0.0234082043,
0.0096394317,
-0.0532104373,
0.0247479137,
0.0216004066,
-0.0396459326,
-0.0338562243,
0.000880971,
0.044184152,
-0.0456115305,
0.0213047471,
0.0137806609,
-0.0388268866,
-0.0117316395,
0.07443887,
-0.0558328405,
0.0098128002,
-0.0519728102,
0.0061812354,
0.0748790652,
0.006728827,
0.0911582038,
-0.0006350936,
0.0005319829,
-0.0123647396,
-0.0306306612,
0.0162284058,
-0.0182862487,
0.0041290079,
0.0437401757,
0.001998367,
0.0584600233,
0.0931139961,
0.0536099076,
0.0058986987,
0.030377984,
-0.0274340268,
-0.0249287952,
-0.026578445,
-0.022085432,
0.0725609586,
-0.0033999316,
0.0027094234,
-0.0247897115,
-0.0479530394,
0.0166811347,
-0.0134207457,
0.0119951181,
-0.0312171597,
-0.0033206735,
0.0356481522,
-0.02158604,
0.0100654634,
-0.0446198285,
-0.017313648,
0.0101130763,
-0.058172524,
-0.0353210308,
-5.60184992e-33,
-0.0462693125,
-0.0197666753,
-0.0146288518,
-0.0436942056,
-0.0729080811,
0.0246131122,
-0.0146042267,
-0.0131219467,
0.0352472067,
-0.0004998453,
-0.0084949043,
-0.001206915,
0.0050186748,
0.0173958968,
-0.0172245204,
0.0067481371,
0.0397033505,
0.0319476128,
-0.020489743,
0.015281152,
0.0076074777,
0.0412616953,
0.0155960228,
0.0180564038,
-0.0122682229,
-0.0658120438,
-0.009011874,
-0.012459347,
0.034866754,
0.0278928038,
-0.0195291005,
-0.0016796822,
0.0282964986,
-0.0674184933,
0.0082715871,
0.0192874949,
-0.0452885665,
-0.0084120389,
0.0112387501,
-0.022009993,
0.0140245054,
-0.0238250718,
0.0122655146,
0.001530704,
0.031487342,
-0.0502644442,
0.0082745655,
-0.0297700576,
-0.0386673845,
-0.0476183966,
-0.0214145463,
0.0300895758,
-0.0298167039,
-0.0073568621,
0.0448710583,
0.0449012183,
0.0091167949,
0.027773086,
-0.0381328054,
0.0163510926,
-0.0065812608,
0.0780471489,
0.0221101679,
-0.0070500392,
-0.0327948667,
0.0420037135,
-0.0051336419,
-0.0432435274,
0.0182771087,
-0.0191187225,
-0.0014730818,
-0.0188858937,
0.0296157319,
-0.0023412737,
0.0054113171,
0.0026126083,
-0.085017629,
0.0454254895,
0.0287586488,
0.0031220056,
0.0331036225,
0.0581856705,
-0.0229220316,
-0.046928782,
-0.0449743792,
-0.039380081,
-0.004033572,
-0.0296473112,
0.0409690514,
0.0002384157,
-0.0290742684,
-0.0259112865,
0.0481523648,
-0.0286430139,
-0.0380483866,
0.039265193,
0.0070580905,
0.0297409538,
-0.0162926186,
0.0541899614,
-0.0233137012,
0.0185780227,
0.0174817555,
-0.0591722913,
-0.0096683027,
-0.0439772382,
0.0090083545,
0.0103735887,
-0.0688148513,
0.0079836864,
-0.0155467326,
-0.0501032136,
-0.0173826888,
0.1074212715,
0.0066922242,
-0.0064937179,
0.0101501551,
0.0672308952,
0.0200075507,
0.0287373457,
-0.0405768752,
0.0136950035,
0.0073459437,
-0.0088280085,
-0.0312028639,
0.0233340114,
-0.0025665329,
0.0829304904,
0.0225192811,
-0.0379895046,
-0.0369099267,
0.0030901399,
2.594e-7,
0.02472849,
0.0293313991,
0.007932513,
0.0225068275,
0.0163344312,
0.0047360146,
0.0024340807,
0.0547436289,
0.018557746,
0.0092852041,
0.0345558636,
-0.0045531243,
0.0275696311,
0.0257954653,
-0.101966545,
-0.007532923,
-0.0337237529,
-0.0529620312,
-0.033296667,
-0.0399654284,
0.0478975326,
0.1026243344,
-0.017826682,
0.0228812862,
-0.0002908038,
-0.0219855476,
0.0363461375,
-0.0495011732,
-0.0419725217,
-0.0089408346,
0.0251894686,
0.0052910754,
-0.0340506621,
-0.0139813675,
-0.0336845331,
0.0438910052,
0.0538627282,
0.0499986298,
0.0054692524,
-0.0379281342,
0.0038301458,
0.0236232728,
-0.0123916548,
-0.0469172709,
0.0551262051,
-0.0124767963,
-0.021448262,
-0.0007712058,
-0.0279139299,
-0.0155407218,
0.011464024,
0.0003644275,
-0.0431039594,
0.0586751252,
0.0293218624,
-0.0106750261,
0.005347942,
-0.1104117855,
-0.0389008969,
0.0055516111,
-0.0452937968,
-0.0279332325,
-0.0125092091,
-0.0389659181,
0.0018749026,
-0.064358525,
0.0106896143,
2.737625783e-34,
0.0455647111,
-0.0412556306,
0.0134284711,
0.0378227606,
0.0497307368,
-0.0252544172,
0.0313775428,
0.0249116123,
-0.0003178908,
-0.0917207673,
-0.0170639828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14835v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14835v1 | ToVo: Toxicity Taxonomy via Voting | 2024-06-21T02:35:30 | 2024-06-21T02:35:30 | Tinh Son Luong, Thanh-Thien Le, Thang Viet Doan, Linh Ngo Van, Thien Huu Nguyen, Diep Thi-Ngoc Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Existing toxic detection models face significant limitations, such as lack of
transparency, customization, and reproducibility. These challenges stem from
the closed-source nature of their training data and the paucity of explanations
for their evaluation mechanism. To address these issues, we propose a dataset
creation mechanism that integrates voting and chain-of-thought processes,
producing a high-quality open-source dataset for toxic content detection. Our
methodology ensures diverse classification metrics for each sample and includes
both classification scores and explanatory reasoning for the classifications.
We utilize the dataset created through our proposed mechanism to train our
model, which is then compared against existing widely-used detectors. Our
approach not only enhances transparency and customizability but also
facilitates better fine-tuning for specific use cases. This work contributes a
robust framework for developing toxic content detection models, emphasizing
openness and adaptability, thus paving the way for more effective and
user-specific content moderation solutions. | [
0.0342942923,
0.0550214015,
-0.0228289086,
-0.0176226813,
-0.0105444994,
0.0195819065,
0.0255782027,
0.0406843983,
0.0446075797,
-0.021694554,
-0.0238417834,
0.0523148961,
-0.0480122194,
0.0800178051,
-0.0172378551,
-0.020118054,
0.0216001309,
0.0370208211,
-0.0147449533,
0.0282936022,
0.0325067677,
0.0034286515,
0.027275946,
0.0447498001,
-0.0150218559,
-0.0325702392,
0.0335859098,
0.009850801,
0.055209849,
-0.0540603586,
0.0134570161,
-0.0075006424,
0.0029319138,
0.0616143644,
0.0000021062,
0.0087717315,
-0.0020036853,
-0.0030294755,
-0.0084144277,
-0.0601490289,
0.05833707,
0.0063058231,
-0.0073968056,
0.0663588792,
-0.0257066116,
0.0106946481,
0.0767069459,
0.0052034222,
0.091252394,
0.0274097752,
-0.0357945189,
0.0082810493,
-0.0066716559,
0.0186364613,
0.0205887221,
0.0623430535,
0.0515987091,
-0.0029855054,
-0.0159684345,
-0.0055511785,
-0.0104329111,
0.0044144546,
0.0101582585,
-0.0330619551,
0.0109571284,
-0.0159230493,
0.026178183,
-0.0849432275,
0.014673491,
0.0754411295,
-0.0401190855,
-0.020927418,
0.0109357806,
-0.0139036821,
0.000310736,
0.0299224593,
-0.0308218822,
0.0142797641,
-0.0270375963,
0.0275648497,
-0.0301670916,
0.0449046828,
0.0296232253,
0.0423614047,
0.0584929325,
0.0135122919,
-0.0200464595,
-0.0044446709,
-0.0047661178,
-0.0244686902,
0.0076921792,
0.0033875473,
0.0576736927,
-0.0306120552,
-0.0088924691,
0.0079812165,
-0.0121387951,
-0.0321065113,
0.0438894555,
-0.0835644901,
0.0291086882,
-0.0007841365,
-0.0483804084,
0.0415501334,
0.0080549074,
-0.0417050645,
-0.015990803,
0.0882899389,
-0.0035637156,
0.0322959796,
-0.0165922791,
0.0242226534,
-0.0030821587,
-0.009510017,
0.0566595979,
0.0496128388,
-0.0363689251,
0.0237816777,
-0.0802460462,
-0.0101394998,
0.0498359203,
0.036525581,
0.0133887492,
0.0353306085,
-0.0315981843,
-0.013906735,
-0.0288991276,
0.0600189306,
0.0035973946,
0.0013890421,
-0.0107098781,
0.0352324881,
-0.0162474997,
-0.0054679611,
0.0272758659,
0.0859585181,
0.0613619387,
0.0124172149,
-0.0479884259,
-0.0332698859,
-0.0056167645,
0.0069557549,
0.0018163347,
-0.0244933125,
-0.0022107058,
-0.0426662266,
0.0161634367,
-0.0796877071,
-0.0226184577,
0.016069008,
-0.0164058339,
0.0544094481,
-0.0492013693,
-0.0316571593,
0.0091542006,
0.0139316507,
-0.050837364,
0.0478534922,
0.0104378676,
0.0873315632,
0.040387433,
-0.0062433337,
-0.024160143,
0.0065297703,
0.004680668,
0.0098329419,
-0.0258596893,
0.0134330513,
-0.0318754092,
-0.0127538657,
-0.0573409833,
0.0065780729,
-0.0117639592,
-0.0162665844,
0.0616109185,
0.0117574967,
-0.0131078856,
0.0002632126,
0.0299113002,
0.0032870127,
-0.0662389398,
-0.0744258389,
-0.0328089818,
0.0397271812,
-0.0120462719,
-0.0637723282,
-0.0031147085,
0.0603040233,
-0.0064951293,
-0.0817275122,
-0.0376736633,
-0.0024257298,
0.0403305069,
-0.0100854738,
0.037361566,
0.0364102945,
-0.0004231947,
-0.0211543627,
0.0520945936,
-0.0431298576,
-0.0143777644,
-0.0496181026,
0.0851118267,
0.0432485379,
0.0409028232,
-0.0476896837,
0.0097458782,
-0.0754462853,
0.0144032668,
-0.0318808556,
-0.0311765615,
-0.0257078987,
-0.0448121503,
-0.0055320486,
-0.0641596466,
0.0274298787,
-0.0051173205,
-0.0305775497,
-0.0099448198,
0.0213289894,
-0.0254250783,
-0.017695779,
-0.0457188711,
0.0445101187,
0.0705000907,
-0.0058597592,
-0.0056738546,
0.037805967,
0.084657833,
-0.0166868996,
0.0117325382,
-0.0151410773,
0.0410329327,
0.0077412105,
-0.0334908888,
-0.0436059572,
0.0388501845,
0.0498340651,
0.0351383425,
-0.0525633469,
0.0135685215,
0.0567395054,
-0.009572912,
0.0338581316,
0.0038135159,
-0.0021990149,
-0.0615308322,
-0.0325942636,
-0.0289474968,
-0.0301498026,
0.0137344077,
-0.0040315376,
0.0669073686,
0.0060694497,
-0.022367293,
-0.023994904,
-0.0655484721,
0.0229126345,
0.0455957651,
0.0045598778,
-0.0336190686,
-0.0526398532,
0.0061785858,
0.0281631555,
0.0160215087,
-0.0244444311,
0.0160611514,
0.0100233881,
-0.0171074867,
-0.0135478023,
0.0091681071,
0.0296852607,
-0.0092140846,
0.0091830026,
0.0081486097,
-0.039549429,
-0.0188672002,
0.0037606221,
0.0152014717,
0.0008167458,
-0.0419470072,
-0.0094699487,
-0.0034113203,
-0.0154695092,
-0.0252421983,
0.0562202744,
-0.0003902198,
-0.0578918345,
0.0431022234,
0.0155714881,
-0.0457665808,
-0.0097343596,
-0.000544111,
-0.0392438695,
0.0323335901,
-0.0066757072,
-0.0631121546,
0.0501430891,
0.0475794375,
0.0491178632,
0.0608929209,
0.0609019622,
-0.0367160514,
-0.0071353675,
-0.0383862741,
0.0006623533,
0.0045399652,
-0.0311990622,
0.0026752455,
0.0407069735,
-0.0166972838,
-0.0287069809,
-0.0375297815,
0.0741896927,
-0.0306521431,
-0.0208349694,
-0.0426552258,
-0.0781416446,
0.0167285968,
0.0009985669,
-0.0266451538,
-0.060749609,
0.0630680993,
0.0229497422,
0.04426907,
0.0019509033,
-0.0058779432,
-0.0094853118,
0.0057366095,
-0.0105930697,
0.0314743221,
0.0335724019,
0.0528226234,
0.02822496,
0.0008476738,
0.0870462283,
-0.044433862,
-0.02335269,
-0.0241749529,
-0.0241313744,
0.0275591407,
-0.0602365322,
-0.0442298055,
-0.0165616218,
-0.0004320763,
-0.0065801959,
0.0150880553,
0.0152966389,
-0.03641757,
0.0337600522,
0.015380905,
-0.022962464,
0.0218364932,
-0.0192777831,
0.0280836523,
-0.0106601994,
0.0091386838,
-0.0696094334,
0.0316190571,
0.0140930936,
0.0535826348,
0.0949587747,
-0.0147772525,
-0.037874762,
-0.0056333458,
0.039682027,
-0.0021942612,
0.0077336468,
0.0385979675,
-0.0087657133,
-0.0138840703,
-0.0057249507,
0.0120633394,
0.0105365673,
0.0401830561,
-0.0368491523,
0.003968162,
0.0009702911,
0.0098527819,
0.0380860902,
-0.0299824327,
-0.0637292564,
-0.006697733,
-0.0083821369,
0.0247046705,
-0.0964021832,
-0.0664232373,
0.0369799323,
-0.0485520139,
0.0278257858,
0.0172499437,
-0.0559111312,
-0.0156495087,
-0.0707831979,
-0.0127582951,
-0.0724337175,
-0.0146024097,
-0.047141917,
0.0254317727,
-0.0269939806,
-0.0061625717,
-0.0232413262,
-0.0171244144,
0.0220057648,
-0.0144891394,
0.0246233586,
0.0174951404,
0.0375510007,
-0.0205561388,
-0.0155126909,
0.0372758135,
-0.0022078604,
-0.0441819988,
-0.0059740618,
0.084843114,
-0.0134239094,
-0.0207788069,
-0.0539962649,
0.0707924068,
-0.0105766617,
-0.0336976163,
-0.0011287938,
0.0792748705,
0.0191816986,
-0.0171107799,
-0.0581766218,
0.0044510644,
0.0471868701,
0.0439512581,
0.0323632956,
-0.0599086136,
0.0125463568,
-0.047523126,
-0.0241078045,
-0.0048865061,
-0.0447235256,
-0.0071775988,
-0.0453582667,
-0.0341233537,
-0.037470486,
0.0383970179,
0.0213106778,
0.0048251292,
0.012295845,
-0.0313257948,
-0.0201037731,
0.0067673963,
-0.0172071699,
0.0515443161,
0.0671759322,
0.0240054596,
-0.0336607955,
-0.0240553878,
-0.0196611639,
0.0192344002,
-0.0434020385,
0.0712702274,
-0.0152484085,
-0.0105363624,
0.0386290476,
0.0663913339,
0.0144759193,
-0.0469304249,
-0.0177626517,
-0.0164293256,
0.069568336,
0.0468839109,
-0.0257432312,
-0.0869308338,
0.0552139543,
-0.0092444802,
0.0293332227,
0.0161607619,
-0.0364913009,
0.021221865,
0.0415438302,
-0.045044113,
-0.0749961585,
0.0762472674,
0.0545011349,
0.0071476209,
0.0514208376,
-0.0164420549,
-0.0211961307,
-0.0073908824,
0.0043781968,
0.014028118,
-0.0334954076,
0.0085533625,
0.0383120105,
0.063478075,
-0.0489964485,
-0.0396843702,
0.0542993993,
-0.0102064367,
0.0262120701,
-0.0386022255,
0.0214816406,
0.0304084159,
0.0333201252,
0.0567426682,
0.0269069709,
-0.0214700121,
0.0107782539,
-0.0061828285,
0.0040579927,
-0.0144136334,
0.000356118,
0.0077886228,
0.0361162685,
0.0132141253,
0.0459820591,
-0.0143684633,
-0.0150279272,
-0.0339432508,
0.0189010855,
-0.0218674932,
0.0325554088,
0.003400343,
-0.0214121155,
-0.0320579857,
-0.0086560128,
0.0092532663,
-0.0470408127,
-0.0500924997,
-0.0112868072,
0.0099624945,
-0.0199018382,
-0.030118566,
0.0383400656,
-0.0081860349,
0.0042342194,
-0.0206100252,
-0.0395300947,
-0.0111272419,
0.0080300448,
0.0059634554,
0.0407311209,
-0.0016679358,
0.006606204,
-0.0421368405,
-0.0469616354,
-0.0133609101,
-0.0143959168,
0.0360357463,
0.053816691,
0.0071575353,
0.0238665827,
0.0079809483,
-0.0128170103,
-0.0100123053,
-0.0333775729,
-0.0282669961,
-0.044275362,
0.0008284316,
-5.852683884e-33,
0.0007319677,
-0.0300479829,
-0.0421050489,
0.0264329705,
0.0387567207,
-0.0375856012,
0.0262013394,
-0.016270604,
-0.0008926633,
0.0316276886,
-0.0044753589,
0.0216584485,
-0.0152358785,
0.00692175,
0.025564814,
-0.0314169116,
0.0156277344,
-0.032315433,
-0.0290794391,
0.0336738378,
0.0575898476,
0.0007692219,
-0.0051990463,
-0.0923556536,
0.0068026064,
0.0444184169,
-0.0434678197,
0.0061630956,
-0.0477026477,
0.0876630098,
0.0108277081,
0.0739986002,
0.0192845538,
-0.0197333787,
-0.0057027172,
0.0295326579,
-0.0505890436,
0.0115071051,
-0.0038652809,
-0.0425119177,
-0.0258379448,
-0.028119266,
0.043448884,
0.0141262915,
0.0035288306,
-0.0376462638,
0.0466503203,
-0.0491747111,
0.0019628124,
-0.0485458598,
0.0111900661,
-0.0096027637,
-0.0492368042,
0.0007164379,
0.0029726599,
0.0652837083,
0.0233278535,
0.0298410114,
-0.0682181194,
0.0283980109,
-0.048454836,
-0.0254216716,
0.0019434433,
0.0093887309,
0.0264057405,
0.0686973706,
-0.0114653325,
0.0395499356,
-0.0344287902,
0.0147038493,
-0.0275645908,
0.0550271273,
0.0747314319,
0.0348604806,
0.0272194538,
-0.05627992,
-0.0893673599,
-0.0006290203,
0.0072560976,
0.0352083184,
-0.01226932,
-0.0420317538,
-0.0291474015,
0.0024070223,
-0.0150970267,
-0.0668450668,
-0.0265203416,
-0.0220907144,
0.0039044914,
-0.01078624,
-0.0760477409,
-0.061720062,
-0.0259259511,
-0.0593416654,
0.0110546527,
0.0272327214,
0.0367395692,
0.0131437602,
0.0405009501,
-0.0109933848,
-0.0449499302,
0.0332588889,
0.0064386306,
-0.0443845429,
0.0272765849,
-0.0278300345,
0.0777240172,
0.0375049226,
-0.055831667,
0.0111874361,
-0.0404395051,
0.0536858216,
0.020795133,
0.0334027968,
-0.0333562754,
0.0037255574,
0.022428792,
-0.006264756,
0.0204535965,
0.049421262,
0.0115284482,
-0.0240310021,
-0.0505879372,
0.0087743849,
-0.0075063198,
-0.0385038815,
-0.0240292046,
-0.0040265773,
0.0796605647,
-0.0889369771,
0.0080053937,
-0.0203050654,
2.772e-7,
0.0431049764,
0.00309216,
0.0002038885,
-0.0048321569,
0.0128823873,
0.0186566096,
0.0213136375,
0.0422053002,
-0.0360096693,
-0.0623633079,
0.0028437376,
0.008554033,
0.0238853991,
0.0368801244,
-0.0306318328,
-0.0280074049,
-0.0593399815,
0.0073229028,
-0.0683242306,
0.0177887809,
0.0267216526,
0.0515556596,
0.0413501672,
-0.0401991792,
0.0158929639,
-0.0259751156,
0.0162142813,
-0.0781266689,
0.0200782679,
-0.0003542681,
0.0736506805,
-0.0185892619,
0.001751091,
0.0019035299,
-0.0189796798,
-0.0219217539,
-0.0172189046,
-0.0027556065,
0.0033789338,
-0.0336525328,
-0.0049986537,
-0.0556641258,
0.034999907,
-0.0342150666,
0.0938270539,
0.0131335389,
-0.0205070581,
-0.0354779996,
-0.0172101259,
-0.05856001,
0.0681421757,
-0.038670741,
-0.013844898,
-0.0095206136,
0.0062624556,
0.0087405769,
0.0236254651,
-0.0633632094,
-0.0040285015,
-0.0329780541,
-0.0399591774,
-0.0749176666,
-0.0100366073,
0.0132675534,
0.0228627995,
0.0349138305,
0.0156811289,
2.46657148e-34,
0.00954099,
-0.0331197046,
0.0315161422,
-0.0544068106,
0.0243792105,
-0.0138824983,
0.0175278094,
-0.0513355806,
-0.0022237569,
-0.0400498696,
0.0277484935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14833v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14833v2 | Efficient Continual Pre-training by Mitigating the Stability Gap | 2024-06-21T02:28:37 | 2024-06-27T08:11:01 | Yiduo Guo, Jie Fu, Huishuai Zhang, Dongyan Zhao, Yikang Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Continual pre-training has increasingly become the predominant approach for
adapting Large Language Models (LLMs) to new domains. This process involves
updating the pre-trained LLM with a corpus from a new domain, resulting in a
shift in the training distribution. To study the behavior of LLMs during this
shift, we measured the model's performance throughout the continual
pre-training process. we observed a temporary performance drop at the
beginning, followed by a recovery phase, a phenomenon known as the "stability
gap," previously noted in vision models classifying new classes. To address
this issue and enhance LLM performance within a fixed compute budget, we
propose three effective strategies: (1) Continually pre-training the LLM on a
subset with a proper size for multiple epochs, resulting in faster performance
recovery than pre-training the LLM on a large corpus in a single epoch; (2)
Pre-training the LLM only on high-quality sub-corpus, which rapidly boosts
domain performance; and (3) Using a data mixture similar to the pre-training
data to reduce distribution gap. We conduct various experiments on Llama-family
models to validate the effectiveness of our strategies in both medical
continual pre-training and instruction tuning. For example, our strategies
improve the average medical task performance of the OpenLlama-3B model from
36.2% to 40.7% with only 40% of the original training budget and enhance the
average general task performance without causing forgetting. Furthermore, we
apply our strategies to the Llama-3-8B model. The resulting model,
Llama-3-Physician, achieves the best medical performance among current
open-source models, and performs comparably to or even better than GPT-4 on
several medical benchmarks. We release our models at
\url{https://huggingface.co/YiDuo1999/Llama-3-Physician-8B-Instruct}. | [
0.0369378999,
0.0639139339,
-0.006523564,
-0.0210224688,
0.0057829274,
0.0148333674,
-0.0219042823,
0.0060774679,
-0.0269976314,
-0.0362414196,
-0.0527661331,
-0.1011895388,
0.0020253996,
0.0055865315,
0.0078300778,
-0.0589541383,
0.0577542856,
-0.0269602761,
-0.0062508234,
-0.0153776752,
-0.0173815209,
-0.0264835041,
-0.045847442,
0.0178943649,
0.0253205076,
-0.0275200382,
0.0330839753,
-0.0413722321,
0.0104281679,
-0.055493094,
0.0118383216,
0.0615834184,
0.0175014995,
-0.027574366,
0.0000023146,
-0.0665264353,
0.013039981,
0.0025678687,
-0.0343325473,
0.0228841286,
0.0598719269,
-0.028223332,
-0.0256116185,
0.0356553867,
-0.043174956,
-0.0430049002,
0.0280569158,
-0.0043659438,
0.0345263891,
0.0570934676,
-0.009377406,
-0.0154696386,
0.0580385253,
-0.0326734334,
-0.0155646773,
-0.0620739795,
0.0245996546,
-0.010357419,
-0.0078931609,
-0.0220122561,
-0.0210531261,
0.028475523,
-0.006875081,
0.0273845699,
0.0342679098,
0.069929637,
-0.020786982,
-0.0247251019,
-0.0201195534,
0.0213446636,
-0.0391568094,
-0.0084833819,
-0.0026916149,
0.0201463085,
-0.0231088288,
-0.0159267858,
-0.0425590798,
0.0298262723,
0.016924927,
0.0087418938,
0.0355492868,
-0.0152748935,
0.0517938063,
0.0167016797,
-0.0466330871,
-0.0082419524,
0.028523257,
-0.0285707675,
0.0300551001,
0.0314475372,
-0.0646476373,
-0.024474211,
0.0292867124,
0.0672363415,
-0.0411695093,
0.0225292351,
-0.081290096,
-0.03907286,
0.0283109937,
-0.040779233,
0.0597825684,
0.0458970517,
-0.0419446379,
0.0315478519,
-0.0415698327,
0.023476107,
-0.0334589556,
0.0166090429,
-0.026361132,
0.0402388945,
-0.0323855206,
0.0126516912,
-0.0258295927,
0.019593671,
0.0042309947,
-0.0082359798,
-0.0779646114,
0.0351188816,
-0.0000447687,
-0.0430135429,
0.0232874397,
0.0120043587,
-0.0419166908,
0.0154756699,
-0.0301467851,
0.0228928849,
0.0375818685,
0.0362470224,
-0.0264023375,
-0.0792652518,
-0.0106428647,
-0.006283707,
-0.0272132438,
-0.0098945927,
0.0342597105,
0.0516729392,
-0.0223541278,
-0.0449755974,
-0.0495916903,
0.0132128904,
-0.0167481657,
-0.0643214583,
0.0318127461,
-0.0371667631,
0.0113779698,
0.0144878747,
0.0330730937,
-0.0240542274,
0.0153611759,
0.0146972444,
-0.0224847179,
0.0727901608,
-0.0374412537,
0.0284775533,
0.0397205725,
0.0217173174,
0.0359599367,
0.0630585179,
0.0238135122,
-0.0829695463,
0.0061916965,
-0.0135344034,
-0.0101201665,
0.0314784124,
0.0186559018,
-0.0160387196,
-0.0016881569,
0.0003619468,
0.0389414355,
0.0568100698,
0.015686227,
0.032454025,
-0.0168980248,
-0.0189063903,
0.0383153483,
0.0584350526,
0.0305639915,
0.0060202316,
0.0165961124,
-0.0576460175,
0.0244406946,
-0.0069340551,
-0.0530800819,
-0.0122018605,
0.0050605526,
-0.0099740895,
-0.0462278426,
0.0264235605,
-0.0398546681,
-0.034700498,
-0.0212627873,
-0.0287470147,
-0.0464596227,
-0.00431995,
0.0775299668,
-0.0115010627,
-0.045254305,
0.0873076469,
0.0638764724,
-0.0370330103,
-0.0066438317,
-0.0939903408,
-0.003828723,
0.0480356105,
0.027667731,
-0.0483202003,
-0.0848726183,
0.0137184728,
0.0353701413,
-0.0058274008,
0.0295127649,
0.0122570796,
0.0338209122,
-0.0672620833,
0.0068315575,
0.0464328006,
0.024470184,
0.019290274,
0.0280413069,
0.0477181226,
0.0017639524,
-0.0141226212,
-0.013815538,
0.0587410554,
-0.0713027641,
-0.0000925095,
0.0068227951,
-0.0073563331,
0.0420627445,
-0.0064849262,
-0.0392660163,
0.0047251745,
0.0320643485,
-0.0554344431,
0.0376582034,
0.0088191358,
-0.0889048725,
0.0254430752,
0.0497701801,
0.0476951934,
0.038638439,
0.0115820048,
-0.0092509817,
-0.0440370962,
-0.0079942793,
-0.0174966697,
0.0571739674,
-0.0224496964,
0.0628682375,
0.0045479964,
0.0193420369,
-0.0501948632,
0.0320979618,
-0.0043172468,
-0.0346355401,
0.0174579397,
0.0196081642,
0.0049611893,
-0.0382434949,
-0.0172038246,
0.0233181845,
-0.0183085334,
0.0295978859,
-0.0502537824,
-0.0016629852,
-0.0253024604,
-0.0489858389,
-0.0882738158,
0.0097351614,
-0.01932339,
0.0243986286,
0.0122358501,
0.0000148917,
-0.0232973993,
-0.0112436274,
0.0080617256,
0.0285665672,
0.0174392238,
0.0265491474,
-0.0077991281,
0.0214339495,
-0.0051151644,
-0.0349281691,
-0.0199186876,
-0.0026726543,
0.0066454308,
-0.0036703364,
-0.0171847008,
-0.0419233888,
0.0640596524,
-0.005922114,
0.0421587229,
-0.0120927384,
-0.0274488069,
-0.0028324837,
-0.0074666324,
0.0531715266,
0.0752191171,
0.0088756504,
0.0021358528,
0.0603363253,
0.0183230303,
0.0027805082,
0.0006493623,
-0.0172478519,
-0.0729951188,
-0.0157475192,
0.0107259061,
-0.0151830716,
0.108169727,
-0.0324602909,
-0.016375551,
-0.0392640159,
-0.0511660911,
-0.0510327518,
0.0187052973,
-0.0342095234,
0.0275181048,
-0.0406846255,
0.0281163622,
-0.0122653954,
-0.0634628907,
0.0323077329,
-0.0066755023,
0.0307628643,
-0.0515617318,
-0.0279607233,
-0.0286269579,
0.0023942341,
-0.0113465693,
-0.0165423788,
0.0055674603,
-0.0277979746,
-0.0445356146,
0.0293322746,
-0.0089554945,
-0.0527063534,
0.0731204674,
-0.0453466848,
0.0194378234,
-0.0311276913,
-0.0454221033,
-0.061945755,
-0.0146074947,
-0.024087809,
-0.002604499,
-0.0113039752,
0.0231444258,
-0.059210632,
0.0159388538,
-0.0393022113,
0.0854720697,
-0.0146813914,
0.0039760978,
-0.0116413031,
0.0100615416,
-0.0124481916,
0.0306578018,
-0.0221734773,
-0.0584194809,
0.0047056139,
0.0412355512,
0.0647492632,
-0.0118762078,
-0.0446953066,
0.0081850234,
0.0431169942,
-0.0136803631,
-0.0329786949,
0.0437764041,
0.0252252407,
-0.0664684176,
-0.0160413999,
0.1034530401,
0.0147042293,
-0.060617283,
0.0006146897,
-0.0104751438,
0.0153326029,
0.0221299566,
0.0248175245,
-0.0478366427,
-0.0097577693,
0.0159854107,
0.035288088,
0.0056795678,
-0.0052446644,
0.0232583638,
-0.0771003142,
0.0279385522,
0.0230534952,
-0.0254271887,
0.0256652497,
-0.0506140813,
-0.0024862327,
-0.0132675646,
0.0058241421,
0.0155403679,
-0.0286052898,
0.000703618,
0.0418900549,
-0.0126175471,
-0.0691802502,
0.0430558026,
-0.0181678124,
0.0433499441,
0.068951726,
-0.0094728377,
-0.0010405951,
-0.0447645113,
0.0731533617,
-0.0164159872,
0.0087075802,
-0.0146371368,
0.0623091459,
-0.0069307801,
-0.00707153,
0.0144803151,
0.0036394114,
-0.0300765242,
-0.034353815,
0.0079568466,
0.0473114848,
-0.0188181773,
-0.0030274976,
-0.0316595994,
0.0063124932,
-0.0120684328,
0.0234235674,
-0.0129950689,
-0.038106814,
-0.0054596867,
0.0318770409,
0.0477561541,
-0.0402617715,
-0.0093262251,
0.0270858929,
-0.0430708341,
-0.0338919461,
-0.0213878546,
0.0012490255,
-0.0010957158,
0.0464074872,
0.0320773758,
0.0043696342,
0.0267273001,
0.0240297019,
-0.0668600649,
0.050986439,
-0.0235719793,
0.0153182186,
-0.1067242324,
-0.0359746963,
0.0713586956,
-0.0076538012,
-0.0163771305,
-0.023238251,
-0.0612357855,
-0.0350228623,
0.0263664406,
0.0694785416,
0.0200759899,
0.0349882096,
0.0099986568,
-0.0519100465,
0.0587510839,
0.0210082792,
-0.035371989,
0.0569276512,
0.0099549778,
-0.0558846854,
-0.0038876508,
-0.0017252208,
-0.0084264372,
0.0242533144,
0.0227109045,
0.0033832861,
0.0153744537,
-0.0126757668,
-0.0109988321,
0.0031940031,
0.0689365789,
-0.0000991855,
0.0112847798,
-0.0381461903,
0.0351093896,
0.0121831959,
0.0454892293,
-0.0219042245,
-0.0055960841,
0.0407565795,
0.0017946758,
0.0008605029,
0.0052373973,
-0.0163108837,
-0.013285391,
-0.041046191,
0.0113297105,
-0.0026202579,
-0.0084023941,
0.051425267,
0.0208420791,
-0.0240706317,
-0.0010991913,
0.005582992,
0.0150502464,
-0.0267852694,
0.0524033904,
-0.0161701571,
0.0321258381,
-0.0132395225,
0.038742546,
-0.0425922349,
-0.0197204128,
-0.0213141665,
0.0400417261,
0.0711726397,
-0.0158694442,
0.0200830121,
-0.0071071493,
0.0115889423,
-0.0440745838,
-0.0033662934,
-0.0422415957,
0.0294269957,
0.0557036623,
0.0104974573,
0.0287798792,
-0.0018317717,
0.0884555206,
0.0101914909,
0.0631366819,
0.0109776454,
0.0095324432,
-0.0277066808,
-0.0193887576,
-0.0025504685,
0.0247070845,
-0.0399016663,
0.0000224182,
-0.0100490386,
-0.0485962629,
0.0282068178,
-0.01651402,
-0.0209454726,
-0.0301044285,
0.0348919071,
0.0420491546,
-0.0102340449,
-0.0122734848,
-0.0087809386,
-0.0029263606,
0.0148667097,
0.0111135645,
0.0448042713,
-6.535185823e-33,
-0.0219326206,
0.0276336297,
0.0586677901,
-0.0236559957,
-0.0380282477,
0.0256843995,
-0.0214919243,
0.0168549977,
-0.0285979416,
-0.0075373854,
-0.018092094,
0.0169064123,
0.0339794904,
0.0221845228,
-0.0037065109,
-0.015370464,
0.0433600955,
-0.0187185444,
0.0005931815,
0.0185551494,
-0.0207321886,
0.0579202548,
0.0471550412,
-0.0596859939,
-0.0475028791,
0.0269444268,
0.0373165235,
-0.0059039029,
-0.0094280913,
0.0687666163,
-0.0344590247,
0.054363884,
0.0294045676,
-0.0267800968,
-0.0181645211,
-0.0148861241,
-0.0674883425,
0.0024692074,
0.0198889393,
0.0145562049,
-0.0367175192,
-0.0395277664,
0.0388086513,
0.0222408697,
-0.0459206477,
-0.0269703977,
0.0167415626,
-0.0622239113,
-0.0548723713,
-0.0139458384,
-0.0400442816,
0.0347556509,
0.0407675095,
-0.0241339877,
0.0102172978,
-0.0476159565,
-0.0298106354,
0.0138534112,
-0.0294793118,
-0.0018201624,
0.0584557913,
0.068512246,
0.0158356521,
0.0478498004,
-0.0049166516,
0.0349225663,
0.0288399942,
-0.003183523,
0.0127228796,
-0.0190112367,
0.0343679711,
0.0110128801,
-0.0010184402,
-0.0115357786,
0.0548244715,
-0.0462602191,
-0.1069220155,
-0.0083544757,
-0.0359458253,
0.0545414761,
0.0249309577,
0.0028552685,
-0.0040570465,
-0.0198717192,
-0.0069562923,
0.0062032477,
-0.0356738605,
0.0055298214,
0.0483118743,
0.0397959761,
0.0050056172,
0.0034850982,
0.0291850995,
-0.0301642735,
0.0200118683,
-0.0149959093,
-0.0111588165,
0.0315676145,
-0.0387902297,
0.0294856485,
-0.0599943995,
-0.056275472,
0.0008704275,
-0.0002932557,
0.0310136005,
-0.0063490234,
0.009214852,
0.0219622664,
-0.0771423876,
-0.0179379899,
-0.0068235477,
-0.0094495136,
0.0657243207,
0.080853954,
0.0554835238,
0.0099259308,
0.0129286703,
0.099874571,
-0.0060468144,
-0.0431460999,
-0.0511642434,
-0.0198763497,
0.0370080806,
0.0339320749,
-0.0333668478,
0.0115529448,
-0.0191584509,
0.0243842844,
0.0116193863,
-0.0775466338,
-0.0318356976,
-0.0236467849,
2.972e-7,
0.0518806875,
0.0441098362,
-0.0288760457,
-0.033688806,
0.0206225999,
-0.010319123,
-0.0267578457,
0.0203980692,
0.0160993114,
0.0060049985,
0.0108765857,
0.0437326729,
0.0318639465,
-0.0063554314,
-0.0392353274,
-0.0225639362,
-0.0364961401,
0.0295517817,
-0.0296217501,
-0.0247702189,
0.0097798696,
0.0887272209,
-0.034407936,
-0.0530063547,
0.013780131,
-0.0398495048,
0.0818337053,
-0.0251029637,
-0.0024218673,
0.0409915894,
0.0230112039,
0.087007083,
-0.016859889,
0.0278665125,
-0.0377143659,
0.0044952896,
-0.0213577915,
0.09817487,
-0.0520644784,
0.0372620113,
0.0511084758,
0.0468335971,
-0.0210221056,
-0.022910919,
0.0690195262,
-0.0804321915,
-0.0279481411,
-0.0214200784,
-0.0081021432,
-0.0453407802,
0.04600228,
-0.0251882859,
0.0012559271,
0.0115139624,
0.0181982741,
0.0059154751,
-0.0799472928,
-0.0916102082,
-0.0110414801,
0.034336023,
-0.0405889899,
-0.0453326404,
-0.018541187,
-0.0415321328,
0.0417084023,
-0.059111882,
0.0015775053,
2.819411032e-34,
0.0333122276,
-0.0109041212,
0.0358402915,
0.047297854,
-0.0329398736,
-0.0357100628,
0.0385876261,
0.0226930436,
-0.0133036748,
-0.0700892434,
-0.0145841287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14829v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14829v1 | Is this a bad table? A Closer Look at the Evaluation of Table Generation from Text | 2024-06-21T02:18:03 | 2024-06-21T02:18:03 | Pritika Ramu, Aparna Garimella, Sambaran Bandyopadhyay | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding whether a generated table is of good quality is important to be
able to use it in creating or editing documents using automatic methods. In
this work, we underline that existing measures for table quality evaluation
fail to capture the overall semantics of the tables, and sometimes unfairly
penalize good tables and reward bad ones. We propose TabEval, a novel table
evaluation strategy that captures table semantics by first breaking down a
table into a list of natural language atomic statements and then compares them
with ground truth statements using entailment-based measures. To validate our
approach, we curate a dataset comprising of text descriptions for 1,250 diverse
Wikipedia tables, covering a range of topics and structures, in contrast to the
limited scope of existing datasets. We compare TabEval with existing metrics
using unsupervised and supervised text-to-table generation methods,
demonstrating its stronger correlation with human judgments of table quality
across four datasets. | [
0.0319417529,
0.0742630139,
-0.0110611571,
0.0111625912,
-0.0408747159,
0.068988502,
-0.0329272375,
0.0588212274,
-0.0094265258,
-0.0185777079,
0.0030058483,
0.0014548815,
0.0259229131,
0.0060869525,
0.0251926519,
0.0091792345,
0.0274545699,
0.0383979268,
-0.0505683124,
0.0515027717,
0.0142290667,
-0.0149275875,
-0.0261478834,
0.0246955305,
-0.0263537597,
0.0210513379,
-0.0276786685,
-0.0098945582,
-0.0123482635,
0.0092876917,
-0.014948816,
0.0952249989,
-0.0258416478,
-0.0080071418,
0.0000018478,
-0.0095238043,
-0.0267508682,
-0.0314340331,
0.0077899531,
0.0149639221,
0.0633124262,
-0.0513313673,
-0.0059676529,
-0.0252884552,
-0.0181069337,
0.0112083498,
0.018014323,
0.0284781195,
0.0672688112,
0.0347079225,
-0.0022088112,
-0.0254149027,
-0.0237600319,
0.0130032925,
0.0944578573,
0.014958078,
-0.0234620441,
0.0175412111,
-0.0308889113,
-0.0486706346,
0.0289560501,
0.0377927981,
0.0071340213,
-0.0544977076,
0.0486573987,
0.016456306,
-0.0454809479,
-0.0167221762,
0.0366670862,
0.071875602,
0.0538823754,
-0.0188661627,
0.0400369428,
-0.0091553442,
0.0194202922,
0.0112212794,
-0.0320508406,
0.0069304174,
-0.0079726344,
-0.0340610109,
0.0151400473,
0.0062315562,
-0.0006593776,
-0.0124318842,
-0.0002895377,
0.0431738757,
-0.0127464738,
-0.029561948,
-0.0031186319,
0.0097961798,
0.0024803304,
-0.0529304259,
-0.0089376858,
0.0200203136,
-0.0299778897,
0.0101341177,
-0.0135394027,
-0.0377360545,
0.0494605713,
-0.0470037721,
0.0081829932,
0.0301983561,
0.027283784,
0.0033565662,
-0.0183529798,
-0.0048418576,
-0.0044030538,
0.020000007,
-0.0399790294,
0.0165863037,
-0.0404889062,
0.0164886657,
-0.0070157149,
0.0140536968,
-0.0337939262,
-0.0086558368,
0.000592967,
-0.009071325,
-0.02660078,
0.0701275691,
0.0042007752,
0.0215563215,
-0.0251475256,
0.0167106297,
-0.0727098808,
-0.0365109742,
-0.0237970501,
0.0065336768,
-0.0060316673,
-0.0190449748,
0.0164698958,
0.0009761368,
0.0536839031,
0.0063355211,
0.0266933758,
0.0622533076,
-0.0336043015,
0.0264291856,
-0.0569515489,
-0.0499194935,
-0.0341673791,
-0.0315779187,
-0.0007517874,
-0.0484727584,
0.0374348275,
0.0161404703,
-0.0162117593,
-0.0603361614,
0.0090593165,
0.0472079404,
-0.0094494298,
0.035345912,
-0.0424329303,
0.0337886885,
-0.0043158606,
-0.0192307439,
-0.0387923159,
0.0388403907,
0.0490814224,
0.0399843305,
0.0087013207,
-0.0035877533,
-0.0166192353,
0.0143653536,
0.0315695666,
0.009211746,
-0.001991062,
0.0495872423,
0.0081384704,
0.033017952,
-0.049763754,
0.0133960573,
-0.0160100069,
0.0753335357,
0.0440307558,
0.0077822455,
0.0227522235,
0.0801569745,
0.0211567022,
-0.018600652,
0.0285822265,
0.0530671477,
-0.0244545899,
0.0276451353,
0.0273940936,
0.0314821675,
0.0612468868,
-0.0267041959,
0.0242622495,
-0.0582504198,
0.0091291368,
0.0137194786,
0.0364234261,
-0.043905817,
0.0179377757,
0.0397922285,
-0.0626264736,
-0.0110002868,
0.0016597889,
-0.0925817341,
0.0247817263,
0.0104925847,
0.0446391068,
0.0977106914,
0.0380560085,
-0.0335566774,
0.0000298854,
-0.0081446683,
0.0272996109,
0.0451195613,
0.0291346237,
-0.0573090836,
0.0006049367,
-0.0034041191,
-0.0424469747,
0.0146653028,
0.0301408898,
-0.0419538617,
0.0001979903,
-0.0046635121,
0.0533920191,
-0.0834903568,
-0.0588264428,
0.0509576462,
0.0476090349,
0.0086719329,
-0.0161824562,
0.0338849947,
0.0005325737,
0.0290949456,
-0.0100150136,
0.0391536467,
0.0209281575,
-0.014853185,
0.0031296231,
-0.0057624262,
-0.0016544387,
0.0249084886,
0.0204375703,
-0.0389438458,
-0.0486771986,
-0.0099585317,
-0.0172463562,
-0.0461029969,
-0.0042853183,
-0.0531209745,
-0.0384663641,
-0.0072452845,
0.0036164308,
-0.0140246004,
-0.0268804766,
0.0149892932,
0.0928107351,
0.0079777641,
0.0269771125,
0.0240839142,
-0.0984062627,
0.0385584794,
-0.0205229297,
0.0302909687,
-0.0413080454,
-0.0212586578,
0.0309456587,
0.0546725653,
0.0553124063,
-0.0913499296,
-0.0014410987,
-0.0950571522,
0.0094076004,
-0.0368861184,
0.0332324542,
0.0411291309,
-0.0350629166,
-0.0102378102,
0.0097153429,
-0.0413550474,
-0.0259703081,
-0.0077552185,
-0.0142079806,
0.085770674,
-0.0059767039,
-0.0016740595,
-0.0316102393,
-0.0272061303,
-0.0274172164,
0.0289902911,
0.0342324451,
-0.0201822016,
0.0168742575,
-0.0064365529,
-0.0123256426,
-0.0434303991,
0.0766406953,
-0.01176803,
-0.0041605742,
-0.0001908105,
0.0208940357,
0.0355077535,
0.0102092046,
0.0107060382,
0.0099981483,
-0.0303805824,
0.0026546789,
-0.0075760284,
-0.0025760189,
0.0379602201,
0.0476725176,
-0.093938373,
0.0624169409,
-0.0013801159,
-0.0069829095,
0.020345591,
-0.053804785,
0.0140178194,
-0.0157998856,
0.0193906222,
-0.0750413388,
0.0410090126,
0.0167078171,
0.0520091094,
-0.0157158542,
0.0196913779,
0.0047348747,
-0.0301247984,
0.0529042482,
-0.0183604583,
0.0140947988,
-0.0285461489,
0.0668760464,
0.0174842943,
0.021638222,
0.0318990797,
0.0023359868,
-0.055883117,
0.0317367688,
0.0667896867,
-0.0175107308,
0.0893118829,
-0.0587050095,
0.0141326524,
-0.0451073423,
-0.0069750277,
0.0090387408,
-0.0296127368,
0.0098383538,
-0.0135013042,
0.0485887453,
0.0030649949,
-0.0307347402,
-0.0419248641,
0.0388925001,
0.0328181311,
0.0153660635,
-0.0393059775,
-0.0278608352,
0.053103365,
0.0363142528,
-0.0229251403,
-0.0303281806,
-0.0296742041,
0.013964531,
0.0511140637,
-0.0367542915,
0.0170681663,
0.0006431274,
0.0354513489,
-0.0464587174,
-0.0364810303,
-0.0035466289,
0.0305280685,
-0.0511592217,
-0.0589924417,
-0.0150739355,
0.0678472072,
0.0308388621,
0.0169619359,
-0.0156825483,
0.0147165321,
0.0122164786,
-0.0059614643,
-0.0042942013,
-0.0883265212,
-0.0202415977,
-0.0005002598,
0.0160761457,
-0.0126057705,
-0.0584784374,
0.0013294092,
-0.072737664,
0.01215313,
-0.0226665027,
-0.0729620978,
-0.075937964,
-0.0461575799,
-0.012055818,
-0.0398188457,
-0.000833978,
0.0449295454,
-0.0008377583,
0.0378829502,
-0.0001382536,
-0.0543849096,
-0.0267497208,
-0.032438606,
-0.0483832583,
0.0170729235,
0.0371857099,
0.0663755089,
-0.0157021321,
-0.0182689782,
-0.0039300974,
0.0113717038,
-0.0061624311,
0.0110162692,
0.1009582207,
0.0235668737,
0.0054603214,
-0.0282347854,
-0.0182300862,
-0.0273333471,
-0.0041710637,
0.0213872138,
0.0475114547,
-0.0190033931,
-0.0063286792,
0.0070978883,
-0.0130616454,
0.0084405644,
0.0539345033,
0.0525197014,
0.0062411246,
-0.0403440595,
-0.0452679619,
-0.0466648787,
-0.0944070965,
0.0194543339,
0.0435365327,
-0.0303257499,
-0.0327818356,
-0.0933017582,
-0.0340883732,
0.0253205188,
0.015245623,
0.0324748755,
0.0212428924,
-0.0099653313,
-0.0145503199,
-0.0743322819,
-0.030187292,
-0.0353846215,
-0.0079086442,
-0.0109548252,
-0.0485109426,
-0.000447301,
0.0088572372,
-0.0065862569,
0.0286291819,
-0.0168171413,
0.0022540779,
-0.0118479747,
0.0150421169,
0.0195539501,
-0.0422540568,
0.0206780974,
0.0036478268,
0.0060821143,
0.0286612548,
-0.0858712643,
-0.0601223111,
-0.0285369065,
-0.0373478755,
0.0037838807,
0.0365746319,
-0.045109164,
-0.0257149991,
-0.042626936,
0.0215321146,
0.0409860387,
0.0562016629,
0.0367342792,
0.0380364694,
-0.0308080409,
-0.0066232886,
-0.0460840575,
-0.0043209037,
0.0111322496,
-0.0583826415,
-0.0641906485,
0.0211915039,
0.0235575326,
0.0042802072,
0.0265956931,
-0.0110955518,
0.0623798296,
0.0109425057,
0.0327545963,
-0.0288592316,
-0.016339004,
0.0233592037,
-0.0156974178,
0.0142263742,
-0.0410797223,
-0.032743752,
-0.0371312276,
-0.0169317443,
0.0043549147,
-0.0091436272,
-0.0222048443,
0.0459163301,
-0.0373072699,
-0.0173688326,
0.0599101521,
-0.02813139,
-0.0164869912,
-0.0167145319,
-0.0110295853,
0.0274386946,
0.0084989257,
0.0389378481,
-0.0318931788,
-0.0380999297,
0.0148640908,
0.046657566,
0.0507296845,
-0.0095514925,
-0.0083220024,
-0.0128695201,
-0.0182108823,
-0.040167626,
0.0691874251,
0.0103885401,
-0.0081521245,
0.0018198246,
-0.0299879014,
-0.0716588721,
0.0095226727,
-0.0339483134,
-0.0183641687,
-0.0388352536,
-0.0545442738,
-0.0386096872,
-0.040469531,
0.0187269188,
0.0795217082,
0.0129305348,
0.0242366996,
0.0286097676,
0.0427353419,
0.0528106987,
0.0018132537,
-0.0310455319,
0.0248397272,
-0.0404591821,
-0.00119011,
-0.0140075926,
-5.870123445e-33,
-0.0526983961,
-0.0521697588,
-0.0121430987,
-0.0110034775,
0.017090274,
-0.0528721139,
-0.0745918453,
0.0063253702,
0.0263144821,
0.0297125783,
-0.0004819848,
0.0315978378,
0.0122618638,
-0.0356102772,
0.049283959,
-0.0789857954,
0.0395059697,
0.0038597409,
-0.0559544228,
0.0137128821,
0.0140319141,
-0.0051537431,
0.0008444001,
-0.0256519914,
0.0524725355,
-0.0146702267,
-0.0136926882,
-0.0435496345,
0.007410856,
0.0140025243,
-0.0216471907,
0.0375979729,
0.0172815509,
-0.0448530391,
-0.0196382627,
0.0040131658,
-0.0940812007,
-0.0230213404,
-0.0149709368,
-0.0025107074,
-0.0282250848,
-0.0410067365,
0.0423159637,
0.0094500221,
-0.0293806791,
-0.0101440847,
0.0584264845,
-0.0170307066,
0.0224147458,
-0.022156626,
-0.0232480969,
0.0270114001,
-0.0204208512,
0.0010054746,
0.0363783166,
0.0337630659,
0.048820775,
-0.0312852487,
-0.0409729406,
0.0375407189,
-0.0002843122,
-0.0021782464,
0.0623234212,
-0.0559778698,
0.0189650413,
0.0320215076,
-0.0041709775,
0.0550928153,
-0.0380091555,
0.0255300533,
-0.0473935157,
0.0720791966,
0.0613441803,
0.0344263054,
0.033115074,
-0.0122369388,
-0.0672878101,
0.1060203463,
-0.0620347708,
0.0200889688,
-0.040652521,
-0.0377223454,
0.0004819746,
-0.0200223513,
-0.0149579458,
-0.0106820837,
-0.027539121,
-0.0076633827,
0.0117523456,
-0.0234413538,
-0.0073700761,
-0.0243889578,
-0.0378276892,
0.0042894888,
-0.026748186,
0.0478477143,
-0.032449685,
0.0099427048,
0.0015488218,
-0.0535131767,
-0.0069999062,
-0.0118138185,
0.0116668418,
0.0237499457,
0.0632466525,
0.038024731,
0.0450248867,
0.0261266511,
-0.04664791,
0.0115194879,
-0.0105262389,
0.0236816555,
0.0140523231,
-0.0308699328,
0.0062673595,
-0.007936202,
-0.0010586339,
0.0078162113,
0.0302133039,
0.0230133031,
-0.0233512074,
-0.0047100475,
0.0146910436,
-0.0031641494,
0.0364368297,
-0.0094985617,
-0.047063794,
0.0091141276,
0.041724842,
-0.0164698865,
0.0052572456,
-0.0225744843,
2.414e-7,
0.0707686543,
0.0299776532,
0.0591588244,
0.0422353074,
0.0002800255,
0.0337330066,
-0.0390443504,
-0.0028701604,
-0.0670207813,
-0.0512543656,
0.0584281608,
-0.0323180631,
0.0640225634,
0.0567049421,
-0.0038960353,
-0.0357873291,
-0.0485825948,
-0.0248219874,
-0.0494090505,
0.0220546592,
0.054898724,
-0.0033066643,
-0.063637808,
-0.0173845924,
0.0100910598,
-0.0260475148,
0.0265540592,
-0.0623212345,
0.0482249036,
0.0382098407,
0.0719124973,
-0.0277633294,
-0.0045287991,
0.0627311021,
-0.0567452051,
-0.0166457836,
0.008753825,
0.0269701798,
0.0059997784,
0.0519854166,
-0.0082965996,
-0.0947924331,
0.0666295215,
-0.0744897947,
0.0726416931,
-0.0073418384,
0.0101704877,
0.0978754014,
-0.0158615112,
0.040880505,
0.0341139138,
0.0044538276,
-0.0429980718,
0.001404401,
0.0042800452,
0.0212766305,
0.0252990127,
-0.0201002229,
-0.0300279688,
0.0351235494,
0.0055442946,
-0.026697034,
0.0053409752,
0.0037061707,
-0.0146215539,
-0.0593339093,
-0.0286800489,
1.881305584e-34,
0.0309948958,
0.0011190578,
0.0386129282,
-0.0263489746,
0.0760091096,
-0.0384623967,
-0.0189111549,
-0.0207301583,
-0.0071868184,
-0.0524838082,
-0.0053700497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14828v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14828v1 | Word Matters: What Influences Domain Adaptation in Summarization? | 2024-06-21T02:15:49 | 2024-06-21T02:15:49 | Yinghao Li, Siyu Miao, Heyan Huang, Yang Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Domain adaptation aims to enable Large Language Models (LLMs) to generalize
domain datasets unseen effectively during the training phase. However, factors
such as the size of the model parameters and the scale of training data are
general influencers and do not reflect the nuances of domain adaptation
performance. This paper investigates the fine-grained factors affecting domain
adaptation performance, analyzing the specific impact of `words' in training
data on summarization tasks. We propose quantifying dataset learning difficulty
as the learning difficulty of generative summarization, which is determined by
two indicators: word-based compression rate and abstraction level. Our
experiments conclude that, when considering dataset learning difficulty, the
cross-domain overlap and the performance gain in summarization tasks exhibit an
approximate linear relationship, which is not directly related to the number of
words. Based on this finding, predicting a model's performance on unknown
domain datasets is possible without undergoing training. | [
0.0195917413,
0.0071154246,
0.018168401,
-0.0031620939,
-0.0040081227,
0.026861079,
-0.0063924654,
-0.0090694232,
-0.0635446534,
-0.0588060953,
-0.0283109732,
-0.0197382197,
0.0404181667,
-0.0018058851,
0.0180965085,
-0.0901262388,
0.0138688218,
-0.0134336278,
-0.0222365297,
-0.0115783438,
0.0060190093,
-0.011831793,
0.0242309067,
0.0067942538,
0.0227944721,
0.0267735105,
0.0217594262,
-0.0106897904,
0.0033585215,
-0.0084361415,
-0.0205168538,
0.0336840302,
0.0625439063,
0.0213834532,
0.0000019037,
-0.0825518817,
-0.0581329465,
0.004845845,
-0.0006303085,
0.013473629,
0.050474681,
-0.0771544725,
0.0176941361,
0.0290355124,
-0.007088501,
-0.0663612187,
0.033736553,
0.0602538027,
0.0606418662,
0.0830267817,
-0.0195178352,
-0.0371617153,
-0.0028597647,
-0.0814062208,
-0.0564020053,
-0.0455977321,
0.0167827941,
0.0452675335,
-0.0219415352,
-0.0222367197,
-0.0553557724,
0.0267170072,
-0.0136144636,
0.0372424945,
-0.0213422421,
0.023902623,
-0.0287612863,
0.0160761792,
0.0427557044,
0.0459624864,
0.0192793999,
0.0018139576,
-0.0031566776,
0.0069560031,
0.0351140127,
0.0221928116,
-0.0747331381,
0.0300868917,
0.0121684819,
0.0234090853,
-0.038915839,
0.028988434,
-0.0010157761,
-0.007706583,
-0.0436285287,
-0.0016079169,
-0.0032358714,
-0.0099500054,
-0.0171866622,
0.0241302997,
-0.0429837704,
-0.039240364,
-0.0118052708,
0.0184978489,
0.0013251035,
0.0105107864,
-0.0925871953,
-0.0657918379,
-0.001505828,
-0.0163764041,
0.0357143655,
0.0063812323,
0.0282993317,
0.031980034,
-0.0479953922,
0.0353617407,
0.0389097258,
0.0036294607,
-0.050624799,
-0.0319719613,
-0.0366888084,
0.0110172443,
-0.0504437461,
0.0313016772,
-0.029105287,
0.0066679693,
-0.0613323823,
0.0079100095,
0.0274670124,
-0.0392673835,
0.0095066046,
-0.0364299305,
-0.024990296,
-0.0171406697,
-0.0121295117,
0.0213365983,
-0.0489745475,
0.0266237147,
0.0429924279,
-0.0106791062,
-0.0227160156,
-0.0081154192,
0.036297217,
-0.0027481911,
0.0093429368,
0.079175286,
-0.0363254733,
-0.0243673846,
-0.0437651016,
0.0017100774,
-0.0074719419,
-0.0300874319,
0.0279777478,
-0.0624502562,
0.0044834372,
0.0162500385,
-0.0031037349,
-0.0567928217,
-0.0359825343,
-0.0179294553,
-0.0337980799,
0.0350743644,
-0.0200298652,
0.0242832284,
0.0528784283,
-0.0003804959,
0.0108544081,
0.0774560943,
0.0349097513,
-0.0071081552,
0.0248344354,
-0.0020449706,
0.0001246156,
0.0160382688,
0.0322345421,
0.0340054184,
0.0038463776,
-0.0293625649,
-0.0257368106,
-0.0058129267,
0.0946292728,
0.0512618907,
-0.0354267471,
-0.0000313528,
0.0465540104,
0.0558311343,
0.0401894674,
0.0280470587,
0.0267172493,
0.0136203747,
0.0185782891,
0.074150756,
-0.0196973514,
0.0039808699,
-0.0240822602,
0.0751629695,
0.083103992,
0.0194620937,
-0.0374760404,
-0.053550534,
0.0011175878,
-0.0008082433,
0.0384288542,
-0.016543515,
0.0433953702,
0.0449265242,
-0.0222496558,
0.065237537,
0.0175409745,
-0.0619996898,
-0.009082743,
-0.0342393033,
-0.0103732804,
-0.003741706,
0.0187134929,
-0.0098083979,
0.0129379602,
-0.0136111844,
0.0490371063,
0.0200763997,
0.0460276455,
-0.0003349727,
-0.0063834339,
-0.0503932945,
-0.0429655388,
-0.0189190041,
0.0230813213,
0.0164257735,
0.0194774698,
-0.0207563043,
0.0525593907,
-0.0517906696,
-0.0540467575,
0.0234088618,
-0.0558288135,
-0.0327432826,
-0.0003357749,
-0.0098987594,
0.0161712635,
0.0143481456,
-0.0238331314,
0.0077688019,
-0.0145637346,
-0.0484238304,
-0.0319428034,
-0.004400264,
-0.0279940944,
-0.0238566771,
0.0126251634,
-0.0672004223,
0.0303779859,
0.022035161,
-0.0363747627,
-0.0483495444,
0.0421797335,
-0.0426779389,
0.017025983,
-0.0364515521,
0.0375689492,
0.0020328076,
0.0452013351,
-0.0198114533,
0.0530266277,
0.0128726093,
0.0204778053,
0.0197565034,
0.0090140579,
0.0002804344,
0.0029393518,
-0.0012169008,
-0.0090301866,
-0.0238590874,
0.0368160866,
0.0399658866,
-0.0065649287,
-0.0209763944,
0.005990597,
-0.0606404655,
-0.0096537685,
-0.0209904853,
0.033188086,
0.0258770492,
0.0385578573,
-0.0206615403,
-0.001774655,
-0.027294863,
-0.0109117394,
-0.0068861535,
0.0325800627,
0.0256178416,
0.0138203688,
0.0296141524,
-0.0440958589,
-0.0141619463,
0.038856376,
0.0648664236,
-0.0281156078,
-0.0315733477,
-0.0379812457,
0.1003479734,
-0.0128263431,
-0.0092968242,
0.0034497455,
-0.0161210522,
-0.0375935137,
0.0147675853,
0.0639573261,
0.0208843295,
0.0214179438,
0.0116794677,
0.0622104593,
0.0041357512,
-0.0264990181,
-0.0019228177,
-0.0178360287,
-0.0172054712,
-0.0037869248,
-0.0297430567,
0.0220069904,
0.0869598389,
-0.0004705496,
-0.0102199884,
-0.0288401246,
0.0135339424,
-0.0440448262,
-0.0092845066,
-0.0268926639,
-0.0017068946,
-0.0015658753,
0.037627589,
-0.0201519504,
-0.0413404666,
0.0549844392,
-0.0144098699,
0.019788824,
-0.0749623775,
-0.0238879696,
-0.0599174164,
0.0341222622,
0.0130029777,
0.0276751202,
0.0534816086,
-0.0206385031,
-0.0654304475,
-0.0119989663,
0.0374968164,
-0.0049571856,
0.0912803933,
-0.0511169434,
0.0057593603,
-0.0638452694,
-0.0008505153,
-0.0048687458,
-0.0069670132,
-0.0068007875,
0.0290768016,
0.0309524704,
-0.0076383827,
-0.0577521138,
0.011213515,
0.0352936462,
0.0710482448,
-0.018571835,
-0.0299915932,
0.0025974636,
0.0513738543,
0.0555995516,
0.0496541411,
0.0005458019,
-0.0535403006,
0.0189539883,
0.0016627893,
0.0230860841,
-0.00171724,
0.0015629275,
-0.0045148823,
0.0044279033,
-0.0406388566,
0.008120683,
0.0089376848,
0.0621023588,
-0.0143138636,
0.0000023012,
0.1130856052,
0.0110543203,
-0.0128922313,
-0.0043070423,
0.0063973712,
0.0355885401,
0.0201054551,
0.0203201938,
-0.0389601998,
-0.0260233711,
-0.000778975,
0.0187035892,
-0.0009921229,
-0.0032443863,
-0.035951335,
-0.1099584699,
0.0082342895,
0.0045565069,
-0.0902526975,
-0.0484879166,
-0.0423586741,
0.0082480032,
-0.0096840356,
0.039170377,
-0.0182780884,
-0.0547365174,
-0.0063630333,
0.0412568413,
-0.059765555,
-0.047879193,
-0.0442546494,
-0.0130844656,
0.0168188103,
0.0613125339,
0.0120028928,
-0.0229305234,
0.0400675312,
0.0414463319,
0.0077651949,
-0.0060311947,
-0.0136025939,
0.1014725119,
0.0318619311,
0.024868628,
0.0309835076,
0.0297506396,
0.0052872654,
0.0070879026,
0.0078644902,
-0.0001221016,
0.0322948806,
-0.0428807884,
-0.0258589312,
0.0016520679,
-0.0436737202,
0.0706842989,
0.0736633688,
-0.0190055463,
-0.0026685924,
-0.0293366853,
-0.0324236415,
-0.0494597852,
-0.0434803888,
-0.0062724454,
-0.0507865511,
-0.0216757879,
-0.0815257281,
-0.0177702159,
0.0224493165,
0.0127526103,
0.0070785224,
0.0075374418,
-0.0192062594,
0.037079256,
-0.0509248041,
-0.0028209998,
-0.0212113112,
-0.0097537627,
-0.0719352216,
-0.0051955194,
0.061978057,
-0.0243326966,
-0.0420498587,
0.0273737926,
-0.0604133047,
-0.0473770238,
-0.0393027589,
-0.0078668278,
0.0262200013,
0.0606133416,
0.0272454657,
-0.0442198515,
0.0687498599,
0.0340726227,
-0.002836081,
0.061199028,
0.0331303366,
0.0009246102,
-0.0214161035,
0.0268758088,
-0.0695549175,
0.0595239624,
-0.0070257261,
0.0079129972,
0.0083445264,
-0.0161634982,
-0.0026004552,
0.0193867274,
0.0195515249,
-0.0068615023,
-0.0249557067,
-0.0207976885,
-0.0278009214,
-0.0041622776,
0.0076988367,
-0.047138121,
-0.0137266172,
0.0086273504,
0.0183812231,
-0.0037654499,
0.0631295368,
0.0061576413,
0.0028559172,
-0.0510076433,
0.0072285249,
-0.0426320769,
0.0094125029,
-0.0171044692,
0.0054384219,
-0.0421018898,
-0.0599955432,
-0.0001170422,
-0.0172747914,
-0.0119331442,
0.0090666786,
-0.0032075713,
0.0539792813,
-0.0118658794,
0.0241441261,
-0.0584882237,
0.0280676354,
-0.0572090521,
0.0279079489,
0.0197361857,
-0.0610772036,
0.0849195123,
-0.0007263788,
0.0085117957,
-0.0369792283,
0.0011432036,
0.0216811951,
0.0069429241,
0.0160477515,
0.007392447,
-0.0071727629,
-0.0085624009,
0.1241880581,
0.0304465964,
0.0148206037,
-0.0175065007,
-0.0004720965,
-0.0269752219,
-0.0456891507,
-0.0026216588,
-0.0048999148,
0.0076410524,
-0.0022976468,
-0.0544456467,
-0.0549667738,
-0.0201553814,
-0.0308108367,
0.0167372655,
-0.0179759115,
0.0491381101,
0.0409207791,
-0.0217744447,
0.0151191158,
-0.0366835073,
-0.0204629134,
0.0140430424,
0.0088464795,
0.0082073733,
-5.852940289e-33,
-0.0436349623,
0.0331604816,
-0.0008690015,
0.0068862443,
-0.0252960809,
0.0041944566,
-0.0559045374,
0.0127582345,
-0.0115673579,
-0.0100879967,
-0.020833984,
0.014976332,
0.0159058068,
0.0473051071,
-0.0098255156,
0.0265254304,
0.0816178545,
-0.0171203166,
-0.0578409508,
0.010817552,
0.0185730532,
0.0100213699,
0.0131699331,
-0.0542931221,
0.007394305,
0.016775107,
-0.0120011056,
-0.0328930691,
0.0928310007,
0.0416574068,
-0.0066627124,
0.028541021,
0.0236944277,
-0.0917375758,
-0.0771534741,
0.0039619026,
-0.0798288807,
-0.0251720436,
0.0469938554,
-0.0241253786,
-0.0098584862,
-0.0572063737,
0.043384362,
0.0087471316,
0.0089506721,
-0.0783852637,
0.0477430634,
-0.0768661201,
-0.0427593291,
-0.0814914554,
-0.0445826277,
0.0378528982,
-0.0061812038,
-0.0222736485,
0.0547639318,
0.0402089059,
-0.0103650643,
-0.0167373456,
-0.006686708,
0.0457039401,
0.0480561741,
0.0852735937,
0.0546996258,
0.0385583416,
-0.0083369762,
0.0378068462,
-0.0177574158,
-0.0025048316,
0.0292260889,
0.0158984549,
0.0124119427,
0.0063224547,
-0.0123059861,
0.0532142296,
0.0651932508,
0.0042860317,
-0.0455968119,
0.0789406151,
-0.0558444373,
-0.021612687,
0.0267759878,
0.0157693811,
-0.0119584315,
-0.0290519465,
-0.0353312269,
0.0422756225,
-0.0129626011,
-0.0184927005,
-0.007018426,
0.0254254919,
-0.0275590699,
-0.0471532084,
0.0203695409,
-0.0428330339,
-0.0046400288,
0.0098812813,
-0.0060992581,
0.0223945975,
0.0102699501,
-0.0435955152,
-0.0110533675,
0.0051505673,
0.0113677839,
0.0279519074,
0.0058790166,
-0.0232653432,
0.0672348887,
0.0109930076,
-0.0678691939,
-0.0072792163,
0.0153674623,
0.0188106373,
-0.0238230508,
0.053777542,
-0.0221906416,
-0.0020764079,
-0.0092895115,
0.0270410087,
-0.0132095814,
-0.057206504,
-0.0045262706,
0.0539830923,
0.0103329113,
0.0430060476,
-0.0386800393,
-0.0110152252,
-0.0114793135,
0.0077078105,
0.0902097896,
-0.032059107,
-0.0590003431,
-0.0148238242,
2.458e-7,
0.0294545218,
0.0360365212,
0.0262849964,
-0.0127211856,
0.0046682945,
0.0343547799,
-0.0163995419,
0.0413572118,
0.0412205644,
0.0313786007,
0.0313525423,
0.0124670258,
0.0858891979,
0.0212676525,
-0.1164014488,
-0.0187043007,
-0.0105853714,
0.0152105503,
0.0072055007,
-0.0005276534,
0.0173221845,
0.0879133195,
-0.0353016332,
0.0014489425,
-0.0068038329,
-0.0398833305,
0.048211053,
-0.0491935313,
0.0163622294,
0.0333756693,
-0.0019518915,
0.0411244743,
-0.0167759769,
-0.0030412271,
-0.0404854268,
0.0194383729,
0.0652809218,
0.0482741445,
0.0369694009,
0.0171523709,
0.0258346908,
-0.0007313369,
0.0030339274,
0.0299976803,
0.0491031185,
-0.0927099809,
-0.0266295318,
-0.0042880718,
0.0068079112,
0.0332545079,
-0.0254354328,
-0.0012762055,
-0.0124874432,
0.0213706437,
0.0282417741,
-0.0008993967,
-0.0049731997,
-0.0643314496,
-0.0300827865,
0.0207428206,
-0.003216221,
-0.0457102209,
-0.026993908,
-0.0005703361,
0.0408463664,
-0.0560445599,
0.018035017,
2.332707469e-34,
0.0703467801,
-0.0011430759,
-0.0308386423,
-0.0104298554,
0.0042247428,
-0.0493515283,
-0.0059141996,
0.0062548872,
-0.0150136072,
-0.0805613995,
0.0098049045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14825v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14825v3 | TemPrompt: Multi-Task Prompt Learning for Temporal Relation Extraction in RAG-based Crowdsourcing Systems | 2024-06-21T01:52:37 | 2024-06-30T08:54:37 | Jing Yang, Yu Zhao, Yang Linyao, Xiao Wang, Long Chen, Fei-Yue Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Temporal relation extraction (TRE) aims to grasp the evolution of events or
actions, and thus shape the workflow of associated tasks, so it holds promise
in helping understand task requests initiated by requesters in crowdsourcing
systems. However, existing methods still struggle with limited and unevenly
distributed annotated data. Therefore, inspired by the abundant global
knowledge stored within pre-trained language models (PLMs), we propose a
multi-task prompt learning framework for TRE (TemPrompt), incorporating prompt
tuning and contrastive learning to tackle these issues. To elicit more
effective prompts for PLMs, we introduce a task-oriented prompt construction
approach that thoroughly takes the myriad factors of TRE into consideration for
automatic prompt generation. In addition, we present temporal event reasoning
as a supplement to bolster the model's focus on events and temporal cues. The
experimental results demonstrate that TemPrompt outperforms all compared
baselines across the majority of metrics under both standard and few-shot
settings. A case study is provided to validate its effectiveness in
crowdsourcing scenarios. | [
0.0702522099,
0.0288160685,
0.0061687673,
0.0437537283,
-0.042110756,
-0.0072844438,
-0.005696699,
-0.0139114959,
-0.0050285147,
-0.0509333909,
-0.0129104732,
-0.0432653539,
-0.0171351675,
0.0251488667,
-0.0259094629,
-0.0783190355,
0.0289656017,
-0.0166862886,
0.0259225387,
0.0363157317,
0.0161170214,
0.0213355981,
-0.0397336707,
0.0526728518,
-0.0093161818,
-0.0160729606,
-0.0206456315,
0.0072172857,
0.0374797992,
-0.0598971099,
0.0130484272,
0.0770770386,
0.0255436562,
0.0085274568,
0.0000019319,
-0.077357091,
-0.004997734,
-0.0242325999,
-0.0463370346,
-0.0459204614,
-0.0025135016,
0.022019159,
0.0299590547,
-0.0008125619,
-0.0679282025,
-0.0322187245,
0.0150762359,
0.0510144383,
0.0272370372,
0.0593343526,
-0.0125650428,
0.0252689365,
0.0127227902,
-0.0255094822,
0.0399705768,
-0.0510969348,
0.0012074026,
-0.074549526,
0.0751683265,
0.0251132585,
0.0292035751,
0.0117287906,
0.0211653728,
-0.0072783409,
0.0284312256,
0.037324287,
-0.0371795036,
-0.0083186226,
-0.0583222955,
0.0992496982,
0.0499567427,
-0.0077385991,
0.012241859,
-0.0024526296,
-0.0016759089,
0.0317598879,
-0.0236267485,
-0.0078997342,
-0.0207075607,
0.0016298088,
-0.0174118187,
0.0713609532,
-0.0091049941,
0.0178938024,
0.0323168226,
0.0573979989,
-0.003999305,
-0.0332237594,
-0.0261852033,
0.0265467614,
0.0322411731,
-0.0641593486,
0.0180368554,
0.0516893864,
-0.0765477493,
-0.0018947287,
-0.0099969069,
0.000529947,
0.0107138725,
-0.0105653154,
0.010936561,
-0.0014246613,
-0.0557329133,
0.0882063806,
0.0038364371,
0.0301925205,
0.0042802696,
0.0105971759,
-0.0290169735,
0.0081174523,
-0.0707110688,
0.0279027354,
-0.0336438082,
0.0089564016,
-0.0489517525,
0.0047531226,
0.0069963257,
0.0303622112,
0.0021479456,
0.0075735338,
0.0200494807,
0.0223625246,
-0.0664381981,
-0.0271897558,
-0.0540475398,
-0.0066481694,
-0.023359647,
0.0157294963,
0.00292429,
-0.041253224,
-0.0239522066,
-0.0219644215,
0.0461295731,
-0.0461406,
-0.0231804363,
0.0160696208,
-0.0164028071,
-0.0074620149,
-0.0740321055,
-0.0401930772,
0.0215022098,
-0.0291839428,
-0.0199666508,
-0.0321926251,
0.0828634501,
-0.0098364744,
-0.0401601903,
0.0262502804,
0.0191554036,
0.0118761379,
-0.0515248887,
0.0887438506,
-0.0366636738,
0.019055333,
-0.0202268399,
0.019760441,
0.0130550386,
0.032433033,
0.0392707326,
0.0457526222,
0.0587663762,
0.0355937742,
0.0085528791,
0.0139658712,
-0.0000971118,
-0.0281371903,
-0.009465402,
0.0412168503,
0.0336996801,
0.0142661259,
0.0414475612,
0.0351380929,
-0.0027625498,
0.0121205039,
0.0467816852,
0.0145930862,
-0.0326999873,
-0.0604502261,
0.0938436911,
0.0356485844,
-0.0225417148,
0.011374699,
-0.0425575785,
0.0206293892,
-0.0015591735,
-0.0044034007,
0.01328889,
0.0274323076,
-0.0332269892,
0.0024009345,
-0.0015019296,
-0.0121668885,
-0.0342671573,
0.0213730261,
0.0295853987,
0.033711262,
-0.0690527856,
0.0236406177,
0.0165098086,
-0.0115373088,
0.0322434306,
-0.0272007771,
0.0471526794,
0.0786148682,
0.0287370924,
-0.0451103784,
-0.026090743,
-0.0418358073,
0.0428744219,
0.0333414674,
0.0264546964,
-0.0557388216,
0.0169197153,
-0.0234883819,
-0.0582043156,
0.0399950072,
-0.0173542667,
-0.0110963099,
0.0488762595,
-0.0091430396,
0.0166820623,
0.0080819093,
-0.0163297821,
0.0219424572,
-0.0141904689,
-0.0628452525,
0.0046207611,
0.0381558314,
0.0135732898,
0.0266358275,
0.0034183941,
0.0017029409,
0.0263415556,
-0.0463980213,
0.0121955611,
0.0411094502,
-0.0467858501,
-0.0668687448,
0.0277643278,
0.0393468589,
-0.0394504555,
0.0264137574,
-0.038573727,
-0.0296889078,
-0.0240351409,
0.0291010924,
0.0248878822,
-0.0417984389,
-0.0249861125,
0.0366809852,
-0.001336159,
-0.0440756492,
0.0704780966,
0.0095153647,
-0.0031678183,
0.0407388434,
0.0065811062,
-0.0105865402,
-0.040363241,
-0.0214527622,
0.0015276072,
0.0209340081,
-0.0142920641,
0.0307621919,
0.0275938846,
-0.0690739602,
0.0000098259,
-0.072336264,
0.0244794209,
-0.0230779834,
0.0171520375,
0.0071087652,
0.0028839626,
-0.0060537667,
-0.0472964123,
-0.0300085153,
-0.0420168154,
-0.0139209498,
0.0314264745,
0.0660223216,
0.0652209371,
0.012393401,
-0.0375928544,
0.0040580938,
-0.0389965214,
0.0407192037,
0.0463292748,
-0.0327862836,
-0.0313757248,
0.0120764636,
-0.0115194097,
0.0184833463,
0.0038761103,
0.0092200628,
0.0074361255,
-0.0088813799,
0.0648569465,
0.0302146953,
0.0212772992,
0.031074794,
0.0083147017,
-0.0338175967,
-0.0404716693,
0.0397984311,
-0.0440526307,
0.0033061404,
0.0048435088,
-0.0258658044,
0.0110005178,
0.055143334,
-0.0089032417,
0.0097701056,
-0.0573969185,
-0.0138121136,
0.0007749108,
0.0094551854,
-0.0453996845,
-0.0114282053,
-0.0437086262,
0.0165178273,
-0.0617735721,
-0.0176088121,
0.076049529,
-0.0076501495,
-0.0238760374,
-0.0035642022,
-0.0002038627,
-0.0429908819,
0.1008275598,
0.004214982,
0.0171070807,
0.0240099635,
-0.033739347,
-0.0380118228,
0.0065466245,
0.0253099687,
-0.0214431062,
-0.0234268829,
-0.0540938079,
0.0088628419,
-0.0176466946,
-0.043666888,
-0.052680064,
-0.094666943,
-0.0114483284,
0.011083534,
-0.0445949696,
0.0151268644,
0.0405596085,
0.0088122319,
0.0021152552,
0.0314345509,
-0.0093724057,
-0.0309212673,
-0.037696179,
0.0647043958,
0.0711668655,
0.0324451067,
-0.0179825481,
0.0109810019,
-0.0060433717,
-0.0028712559,
0.0900729373,
-0.0373474211,
-0.0237018969,
0.0226618573,
0.0366775729,
-0.035413377,
0.0098600015,
0.0259421188,
0.0568211377,
-0.0493771844,
0.0140131507,
0.091850847,
0.0333578475,
-0.0492502749,
-0.0032345767,
0.0385550037,
0.0002683109,
0.022954911,
0.0255029928,
-0.0552921705,
-0.037157014,
-0.003225721,
0.016952021,
-0.0158060696,
-0.0803164542,
-0.0314319842,
-0.1191100404,
0.0174245965,
-0.0367571414,
-0.0144404611,
0.032498952,
-0.0389043912,
0.021069929,
-0.011834817,
-0.0083700949,
0.009477919,
-0.0225891098,
0.0161124151,
0.0294439849,
-0.0244040377,
-0.0647173077,
0.0367022641,
-0.0551453829,
0.0756926462,
0.0518151037,
0.0261499584,
0.0030347938,
-0.055684261,
0.0237459969,
0.0093030492,
0.0163888428,
-0.0104286084,
0.0362561494,
-0.0088444296,
-0.0137312068,
-0.0228777453,
0.0242122971,
-0.0405878089,
-0.0291904677,
0.00659172,
0.1180500612,
0.0021473379,
0.0185148232,
0.0077880863,
-0.0121912435,
0.0711142719,
0.0828796253,
0.0059714271,
-0.033527825,
-0.0364197046,
-0.0107369982,
-0.0111560598,
-0.0798645243,
-0.0243555345,
-0.0156636182,
-0.0351412818,
-0.0305808075,
-0.0525023043,
-0.0669037402,
0.0339254364,
0.0327420123,
0.0049403231,
0.0112065487,
-0.0049897218,
0.0192793198,
-0.0510024875,
0.0668314248,
-0.0249277223,
0.0054553756,
-0.0536655411,
-0.0331214294,
0.0002227793,
-0.0206727516,
-0.0126837818,
0.0293551721,
-0.0988698006,
-0.0293531772,
-0.017104378,
0.0376913808,
0.0143987248,
0.0530789047,
-0.0197613537,
-0.0154898977,
-0.0021137304,
0.0336537063,
-0.0557104982,
-0.0218705814,
-0.0001952795,
0.0314520486,
-0.0293218363,
0.0363048427,
-0.0587470271,
0.016942868,
0.0089898156,
0.0546298213,
-0.0335101783,
-0.0338988975,
0.0256038606,
0.0109916581,
0.0982300118,
-0.0076875151,
-0.0411272608,
-0.0809451938,
-0.021716563,
-0.0083148861,
-0.012441623,
-0.0631442294,
0.0469065793,
-0.0313179679,
-0.0144075807,
-0.012939781,
0.0025409383,
-0.0194632336,
0.0351152979,
-0.0410435423,
0.0060987333,
0.0582894981,
0.041793637,
0.0444140062,
-0.0005382283,
-0.0204057805,
0.0118393507,
0.0213854574,
0.0041044336,
0.0069807214,
0.0151322102,
0.029045172,
-0.0030682383,
0.0166428369,
0.01319467,
-0.068454653,
-0.0172235537,
0.0134435575,
-0.0174876116,
0.0416885316,
-0.0146659454,
-0.0180204436,
0.0240506362,
0.0139488094,
0.0069614486,
0.0523684248,
0.03608042,
-0.0094709126,
0.0132865254,
0.0131155588,
-0.0413413011,
0.0602938831,
0.0898517892,
-0.0589468665,
0.0356434025,
0.0244415123,
-0.0187396295,
-0.0479150154,
-0.0183177106,
-0.032241106,
0.0040461225,
-0.034076903,
0.027569022,
-0.0692281947,
-0.0195378363,
0.01557812,
-0.0182374194,
-0.0366771482,
0.0238894112,
0.0365304016,
0.0655554682,
0.0016332822,
-0.0220053755,
-0.0363810435,
0.0006711906,
0.0074705789,
-0.0214787051,
-0.0332140438,
-6.365489989e-33,
-0.0221025925,
-0.0495563895,
0.038860999,
-0.0060289344,
-0.0228125919,
0.0301506054,
-0.0497568995,
-0.0223766342,
-0.0033804628,
0.0109469388,
-0.0350288711,
-0.0130501026,
0.0258725602,
-0.0206715949,
0.036995329,
-0.0442621745,
0.0642060265,
-0.0103935758,
0.015429629,
0.0311487969,
0.0559403971,
0.047199741,
0.0338244848,
-0.0603324957,
0.0500590168,
-0.0142314201,
-0.0138538079,
0.0710544437,
0.0703441724,
0.0359455198,
-0.0219736937,
0.0149067817,
0.045660913,
-0.0521148555,
0.0013601695,
0.0459455997,
-0.1037388518,
-0.0402787551,
0.0130811958,
-0.0199590158,
-0.0713086873,
-0.0253159143,
-0.0198715515,
-0.0146907941,
0.0143166846,
0.0011549869,
0.042503193,
-0.0137850912,
-0.0026355914,
-0.0376421884,
-0.0266253855,
0.0156152677,
0.0036837969,
-0.0481927805,
0.0257212874,
0.0557153746,
0.0179972406,
0.0264400151,
-0.0434712656,
0.0139983147,
-0.0528114364,
-0.0013782675,
0.0096893981,
0.0062106536,
-0.0323787071,
0.0453438722,
-0.0265158676,
0.0128444061,
-0.0102713397,
0.0070241438,
-0.0274232067,
0.0495964289,
-0.0033194181,
0.0392354764,
0.02738804,
0.0048120064,
-0.0365663841,
0.0548568033,
0.057549078,
0.0077143656,
-0.0310100485,
-0.028429402,
-0.0191090498,
0.0188027024,
0.0142031526,
-0.0182360075,
-0.0224093124,
0.0024175218,
0.0415598601,
0.0391858444,
0.0234829895,
0.0421520099,
0.0377075411,
-0.0144277494,
-0.019295115,
0.0144559406,
-0.0083722919,
-0.0105244927,
0.0135946246,
0.007559095,
-0.0616180077,
-0.0017728125,
0.0195018537,
-0.0078455489,
0.0237512961,
0.0326251872,
0.0503367446,
0.0226862207,
-0.0326546691,
0.0038380194,
-0.0264284518,
0.0453516431,
-0.0266933553,
-0.0171909258,
0.0405274592,
0.0099827964,
-0.0237842463,
0.0383896306,
0.0120943123,
-0.0056382525,
-0.0148584852,
0.016025681,
-0.0079001579,
0.0246571843,
0.0128924074,
-0.0190460775,
-0.0082405638,
0.0620120205,
0.0056462311,
0.0021318479,
-0.0115342699,
-0.0040804227,
2.611e-7,
-0.0007126551,
0.0105703343,
0.0310452841,
0.0362362601,
-0.0250461157,
0.008235286,
-0.0067807133,
0.0470679738,
-0.0360500813,
0.0035462498,
0.0179467816,
0.0074534863,
0.0477410816,
0.0356408656,
-0.1073085144,
-0.0739695355,
-0.0904561654,
0.0017166118,
-0.0850410834,
-0.019727638,
0.0773677751,
0.0372794718,
0.0579161458,
0.0089571821,
-0.0135793947,
-0.0488229804,
0.0341375582,
-0.0329677388,
-0.0224671159,
0.034455318,
0.0287983529,
-0.053790167,
-0.0319209881,
0.0161738265,
-0.0520670302,
0.0005022844,
0.000644038,
0.0433121994,
-0.0021202187,
-0.055380553,
-0.0145534389,
-0.0209193192,
0.014519169,
-0.0309908837,
0.0880052447,
-0.0277841669,
0.0064472612,
0.0198327117,
-0.0030100574,
0.0019980352,
-0.0176038574,
0.0278082676,
-0.0164249819,
0.0002192426,
0.0231729485,
0.0002757997,
-0.0289617311,
-0.1104062423,
0.0090302769,
0.0248257536,
-0.009937481,
-0.037533313,
-0.0072105443,
-0.044839032,
0.0055686762,
-0.0551002771,
0.0187370647,
2.398080796e-34,
0.0246041138,
0.0126421563,
0.0034287409,
0.0471330769,
0.0252188463,
-0.0113992253,
-0.0451610573,
-0.0060339719,
0.0379541814,
-0.0437716804,
-0.0109455185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15518v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15518v1 | Steering Without Side Effects: Improving Post-Deployment Control of Language Models | 2024-06-21T01:37:39 | 2024-06-21T01:37:39 | Asa Cooper Stickland, Alexander Lyzhov, Jacob Pfau, Salsabila Mahdi, Samuel R. Bowman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models (LMs) have been shown to behave unexpectedly post-deployment.
For example, new jailbreaks continually arise, allowing model misuse, despite
extensive red-teaming and adversarial training from developers. Given most
model queries are unproblematic and frequent retraining results in unstable
user experience, methods for mitigation of worst-case behavior should be
targeted. One such method is classifying inputs as potentially problematic,
then selectively applying steering vectors on these problematic inputs, i.e.
adding particular vectors to model hidden states. However, steering vectors can
also negatively affect model performance, which will be an issue on cases where
the classifier was incorrect. We present KL-then-steer (KTS), a technique that
decreases the side effects of steering while retaining its benefits, by first
training a model to minimize Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence between a steered
and unsteered model on benign inputs, then steering the model that has
undergone this training. Our best method prevents 44% of jailbreak attacks
compared to the original Llama-2-chat-7B model while maintaining helpfulness
(as measured by MT-Bench) on benign requests almost on par with the original
LM. To demonstrate the generality and transferability of our method beyond
jailbreaks, we show that our KTS model can be steered to reduce bias towards
user-suggested answers on TruthfulQA. Code is available:
https://github.com/AsaCooperStickland/kl-then-steer. | [
0.0792439505,
0.0727763474,
-0.0286253449,
0.032183852,
-0.0257255863,
-0.0159972031,
-0.0040227859,
0.0078740008,
0.0389046073,
-0.0598189794,
0.0046187425,
-0.0132844858,
-0.0074717868,
0.0044642435,
0.0098184953,
-0.0172955096,
0.0492414534,
-0.0444966666,
-0.0016752752,
-0.0097830892,
0.0201826636,
0.0037203797,
0.0031893649,
0.0584010109,
0.0017153666,
-0.0415173322,
0.0132697113,
-0.0034389091,
-0.0267268978,
-0.0288555995,
0.0226139259,
0.0463772565,
-0.0562728196,
0.0393897519,
0.0000023932,
-0.0265881121,
-0.0203131568,
0.0121185901,
-0.0207224321,
0.0351243019,
0.0157030635,
-0.0194656998,
-0.0296352301,
0.0707093328,
-0.0549618714,
0.0308699291,
0.0373953581,
0.026153801,
0.0882480666,
0.051375661,
0.0077045318,
0.0013031467,
0.0136675444,
0.0108024906,
0.0112583535,
-0.0496683419,
-0.0117458897,
-0.0329572745,
-0.0315752216,
0.0040912959,
0.0079814587,
0.0178110432,
0.0350873396,
-0.0093728919,
-0.0391968302,
0.0206449814,
-0.0366811156,
-0.0382756814,
-0.0054159067,
0.0488286465,
-0.048499275,
-0.0445930324,
0.0067161373,
-0.0088986177,
0.0088351853,
0.0320976414,
0.0007649306,
-0.0108128842,
-0.0150098298,
-0.0339836217,
0.020956194,
-0.04314062,
0.0509088635,
0.0106627131,
-0.0193647034,
0.0615970939,
0.0198592432,
-0.0135685811,
-0.0158292763,
-0.0146310963,
0.0165891461,
-0.063049607,
0.0073150899,
0.0132828727,
-0.005560047,
0.0349943154,
-0.0544446446,
-0.0403963551,
0.0412690267,
-0.1067165136,
0.0068467134,
0.0292379688,
-0.0476206914,
0.0133431926,
-0.0199122243,
0.0186583437,
0.0127288988,
0.0291259978,
-0.0014566761,
0.0175397508,
-0.0089070192,
-0.0064668697,
-0.0131381825,
0.0103085507,
-0.0113349082,
0.0305934921,
-0.0022790728,
0.060416691,
-0.0025238646,
0.0090701152,
-0.0307401083,
0.011849694,
-0.0093846917,
0.019127395,
0.0106753372,
0.0154020144,
-0.0284541715,
0.0000618111,
-0.0121988319,
-0.0948127881,
-0.0045298659,
-0.0122852838,
-0.0624522679,
-0.0235579368,
-0.0183384456,
0.098430939,
0.024045011,
-0.0050238553,
-0.080312416,
-0.0709295347,
-0.0285693109,
-0.0144180562,
-0.0153105967,
-0.0772084072,
-0.0164219774,
0.0125970608,
-0.0177542549,
-0.0713936016,
-0.0027327489,
0.0165076442,
-0.0484972559,
0.0590742342,
-0.0123457853,
-0.0117584821,
0.0288078822,
0.048492752,
-0.0120697962,
0.0903162062,
-0.0002688392,
0.0510619096,
0.0603355244,
-0.036953073,
0.0719828606,
0.0322375484,
0.0174024254,
0.0263812859,
-0.0120132426,
-0.0129509382,
0.024156468,
-0.0335413329,
-0.0022378245,
0.0252293125,
-0.0001703671,
-0.032337334,
0.0983016491,
0.0155316209,
-0.0200290028,
0.0299679842,
-0.0302059371,
-0.0255595203,
-0.0140650645,
-0.0088246241,
-0.0756890252,
0.0215887986,
-0.1053858325,
-0.022392055,
-0.0124611696,
0.0391833968,
-0.0132976053,
-0.0426359698,
0.0092373155,
-0.0171834286,
0.0147769321,
0.0364378318,
0.0080414545,
0.0058770352,
-0.0060942797,
0.0486751385,
0.0394743979,
-0.0245591141,
-0.0231987536,
-0.0889871046,
0.0119439671,
0.042064406,
0.0486142486,
0.006618523,
-0.0442994051,
-0.0167521238,
-0.0084192371,
0.0052392744,
0.0283806883,
-0.0017168549,
0.0173087958,
-0.0172426943,
-0.0305369273,
0.0240727682,
0.0104864761,
0.0106929094,
-0.008544161,
0.035418056,
-0.0068641864,
-0.046560768,
-0.0435352288,
0.0366693847,
0.0157429073,
-0.0340813063,
0.0147571107,
0.0132349357,
0.0256377384,
-0.0005932367,
0.002375619,
0.0155629208,
0.0483985804,
0.0018365363,
0.0020725993,
0.0050568311,
-0.0264888033,
-0.0167278294,
0.0433856957,
0.0238223672,
0.0205598921,
0.0697270483,
-0.0340795889,
0.0086420272,
0.0623725057,
-0.0196835957,
0.079170607,
0.0028015457,
0.0259462669,
-0.0080546802,
0.004899092,
-0.0417388827,
0.0089605385,
-0.0136904558,
0.0007701714,
-0.0557620302,
-0.0161809456,
-0.0040488048,
0.0296732653,
-0.0388807766,
0.0497883558,
-0.0223297104,
0.0523201823,
0.0194431823,
0.0148941502,
-0.0012639129,
-0.0234227814,
-0.0551385358,
-0.0455825329,
-0.0548296869,
0.0220075566,
0.0348539576,
0.0250602793,
-0.0126066618,
-0.0265638307,
-0.0208275132,
-0.0365411043,
0.0062402957,
0.0334180743,
-0.0133496122,
-0.0155767817,
-0.0348945707,
-0.0314451084,
-0.0083243623,
-0.0016429685,
0.0372258797,
-0.0300499517,
-0.0314304382,
-0.0460074432,
-0.0163555983,
-0.043017894,
0.0318732709,
-0.0269276649,
-0.0737130046,
0.0177385993,
0.0325894095,
-0.0077030417,
0.0551449321,
0.0233987477,
0.0223023295,
0.0800127834,
0.0465404019,
-0.0753033906,
-0.0204259884,
0.043294508,
-0.0704928562,
-0.0356986746,
-0.0248274263,
0.0557137169,
0.0706213266,
0.0268706679,
-0.0153142819,
-0.0492566861,
-0.0146009643,
-0.0429114886,
-0.0531192385,
0.0051648063,
-0.0054150573,
-0.0410216041,
0.0215951744,
-0.0157012567,
-0.0786842853,
0.0787063539,
-0.0327185839,
0.0151978908,
-0.0639145151,
-0.023895869,
0.0190078095,
0.0240592118,
-0.0289921556,
0.0373315997,
0.0406445488,
-0.0135364262,
-0.0203168187,
-0.0496772788,
0.0261205211,
-0.0345217101,
0.0377757959,
-0.0509849936,
0.0065133655,
0.008181138,
-0.0241090301,
-0.0416816287,
-0.0819205865,
-0.026182821,
-0.0510981567,
0.0208569821,
-0.0088605303,
0.0294426084,
-0.0059316107,
0.0028011268,
0.0292641167,
-0.0067119808,
-0.0144102499,
-0.0113119008,
-0.0257289074,
0.0413643532,
-0.0275488216,
0.0235907454,
-0.0165870637,
0.0215994958,
0.0946492478,
0.0695797578,
-0.0133428993,
-0.0030229427,
-0.0112377498,
0.0475691557,
-0.0241260547,
-0.0466662422,
0.0707701147,
0.0356320068,
-0.0428481698,
-0.0052939872,
0.0535967015,
0.0411721319,
-0.0366251655,
0.0163665824,
-0.0179439075,
0.0625532493,
0.0314551443,
0.0384443663,
-0.0837948397,
-0.0334856212,
0.0130385403,
0.0699679628,
-0.0069390782,
0.0008758539,
-0.0092047183,
-0.1078186929,
-0.0020707378,
0.0206219312,
-0.0369940847,
0.0132969143,
-0.0491951928,
-0.0389308035,
0.0075520999,
0.0331856795,
-0.0068511791,
-0.0019326442,
0.0163422208,
0.0351999588,
-0.071619086,
-0.0114497021,
0.0161435138,
-0.0484669283,
0.0687431097,
0.0914199054,
0.0008254577,
-0.0038866617,
0.0016955787,
0.0485729352,
-0.0127433492,
0.0050391587,
-0.0087860897,
0.0224074703,
-0.0075237476,
0.0045179976,
0.0328842662,
0.0122232996,
-0.0208721794,
-0.0044241496,
0.0389318243,
0.0431956127,
-0.0380747244,
-0.0274101179,
-0.0216839965,
-0.006810667,
0.0310249142,
0.0393160954,
0.0289811306,
-0.0514080338,
-0.0359729752,
-0.0681267679,
-0.0031218692,
-0.0012798718,
-0.0400643796,
0.0159240458,
0.0356033184,
-0.0416820385,
-0.0788426846,
-0.0100539094,
-0.0170584004,
0.0556553379,
0.0306299031,
0.0359923914,
-0.0296005998,
0.0060703824,
0.015414306,
0.0110041304,
-0.0201935153,
0.0479204319,
-0.0685187429,
0.0338696577,
-0.0002553627,
-0.0206870306,
-0.0016804473,
-0.0142199788,
-0.0181957912,
-0.1020645797,
0.0435017049,
0.0825247169,
0.024829179,
0.0259914454,
-0.0542976484,
-0.1022375748,
0.0397663191,
0.0535782203,
-0.0602071881,
0.0200028662,
0.0611841753,
-0.0019226655,
-0.004143347,
0.0202245433,
-0.0478793047,
-0.0105507066,
0.0608395822,
-0.025356153,
-0.0617914982,
-0.002259186,
0.0027723382,
0.0381756686,
0.0477546118,
-0.006898657,
0.0081124203,
0.0254740305,
0.0128252124,
0.0092473514,
-0.0283634122,
-0.000247603,
0.0095631611,
-0.0149096381,
-0.0060061715,
0.0127312429,
0.0153028769,
-0.005278795,
-0.0057118125,
-0.0241674446,
0.0345122032,
0.0776408464,
0.0616168566,
0.035140302,
0.0277333781,
-0.0143833812,
0.0365547426,
0.0082218079,
0.0563157052,
-0.0241846405,
0.0297213234,
-0.0049994597,
-0.0134351002,
0.0032254437,
0.0614006966,
-0.0690674782,
-0.0790297836,
0.0089763962,
0.0599428602,
0.0323841088,
0.0215784814,
0.0179291349,
0.0129372189,
0.0133170998,
-0.0208148025,
-0.0061802804,
-0.0048142797,
-0.0394821204,
0.0284129176,
-0.000786449,
-0.0132106096,
0.0024496086,
0.0720463172,
0.0228399895,
0.065369077,
-0.0142904827,
-0.0073747472,
-0.0318128616,
0.0138098374,
0.0639282465,
0.0138580436,
-0.0491522364,
-0.0380336158,
-0.0571058057,
-0.0835391879,
-0.0263782274,
-0.0038510109,
0.0384932905,
-0.0146225132,
0.0029288467,
0.074557744,
0.026731655,
0.0071754362,
-0.0740362331,
-0.0282751806,
0.0033378236,
-0.0242469255,
-0.0105339289,
-6.81954011e-33,
0.0238128435,
-0.0174885541,
-0.0307681039,
-0.0393413343,
0.0091480101,
-0.0101595642,
-0.0152937518,
0.025986487,
-0.0607094504,
-0.0348723233,
-0.0223190859,
0.0101290569,
0.0143989399,
-0.0079161106,
-0.0024911501,
-0.0242210962,
0.0205010511,
-0.0010374406,
-0.0489085838,
0.0451096334,
0.0313892588,
0.0068178913,
0.0226807501,
-0.0554148778,
0.0280800723,
-0.0031079503,
-0.0065721753,
0.0142958369,
-0.0566508099,
0.0637069643,
0.011294038,
0.0241743829,
0.0061512175,
-0.0255622137,
-0.0177610032,
-0.0140200937,
0.0223461837,
-0.0233085398,
0.0093679884,
0.0153969899,
-0.0009966765,
-0.0463716201,
0.0809757635,
-0.0150074558,
-0.0161437821,
0.0120434891,
0.0224704631,
0.0021428172,
-0.0561105162,
0.0048816628,
-0.0133175934,
-0.0026478083,
-0.0215455107,
-0.017223103,
-0.0168050062,
0.0522506945,
0.0043040765,
-0.0227393303,
-0.0592238456,
0.0006492093,
0.0190483592,
0.0219213814,
0.0764204115,
0.0223775227,
-0.0227080677,
0.0421836004,
-0.0183796361,
0.0055079199,
-0.0086840307,
-0.0344125368,
0.033455655,
0.0237472728,
0.06464912,
0.0406125709,
0.0357490666,
-0.0799283907,
-0.0349930413,
0.0229612514,
0.0379725248,
0.0247463547,
0.0106017273,
0.0067445184,
-0.0826694146,
-0.032970909,
-0.0301981624,
-0.0332542956,
-0.027270494,
-0.051519677,
0.0327453539,
-0.0027902857,
-0.0396584384,
-0.0515486933,
0.0254747663,
-0.0556793362,
-0.0076846736,
0.0202611107,
-0.0021526618,
0.0108799897,
-0.0069119697,
0.0310229156,
-0.0206918512,
0.0261675194,
-0.0164977387,
-0.0407386422,
0.0312697925,
-0.0032083874,
0.0134268124,
0.0349300243,
-0.0781599358,
0.006975499,
-0.0255852137,
0.0406987555,
0.039841406,
0.0371817686,
0.0345158465,
-0.0346802287,
0.0251589287,
0.0223424342,
0.0094970334,
-0.0020029603,
-0.0713217407,
0.0081123877,
-0.01293205,
0.0105218953,
-0.0356723294,
-0.0207451303,
-0.0070925057,
0.0228977911,
0.0269266181,
-0.0611804575,
-0.0320651308,
-0.0381245166,
3.148e-7,
-0.0277733542,
0.0233897083,
-0.0191482417,
-0.0058514052,
0.0081740366,
0.0819734186,
-0.0052167904,
0.0526612736,
0.0311919153,
-0.0155895734,
-0.0443678126,
-0.0184998829,
0.0366378836,
0.0614857487,
-0.0429153331,
-0.0105631286,
-0.0663425103,
0.0389609374,
-0.060205292,
-0.0276718233,
0.0438346677,
0.1117296144,
0.0075894864,
-0.0245914813,
0.0071484484,
-0.0148341749,
-0.0076468317,
0.0111116106,
-0.0045138975,
-0.0008078657,
0.0486333147,
0.0321333446,
0.0221316703,
0.0051303371,
-0.043235179,
-0.0326314829,
-0.0647415444,
0.0387129821,
-0.0132756298,
-0.0374835394,
-0.0093035158,
-0.0138769308,
0.0065970644,
-0.0456865616,
0.0850337818,
0.0236600284,
-0.0221201479,
-0.0302503761,
0.0256328359,
-0.0528926514,
0.0258059446,
-0.00161314,
-0.009905328,
0.0098372921,
0.0209746696,
0.0188229829,
-0.0047179954,
-0.0637122169,
-0.0484743081,
0.0097210277,
0.0226597171,
-0.0248451252,
-0.0169418696,
0.0478928834,
0.0053333319,
-0.0369214378,
0.0238706227,
3.254915848e-34,
-0.0006458617,
-0.0456494242,
0.0301684421,
0.0218648408,
0.0372395515,
0.0216966011,
0.0742954239,
0.0093837846,
0.0304370858,
-0.00924116,
-0.0063895904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14805v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14805v1 | How Well Do LLMs Represent Values Across Cultures? Empirical Analysis of LLM Responses Based on Hofstede Cultural Dimensions | 2024-06-21T00:58:01 | 2024-06-21T00:58:01 | Julia Kharchenko, Tanya Roosta, Aman Chadha, Chirag Shah | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) attempt to imitate human behavior by responding
to humans in a way that pleases them, including by adhering to their values.
However, humans come from diverse cultures with different values. It is
critical to understand whether LLMs showcase different values to the user based
on the stereotypical values of a user's known country. We prompt different LLMs
with a series of advice requests based on 5 Hofstede Cultural Dimensions -- a
quantifiable way of representing the values of a country. Throughout each
prompt, we incorporate personas representing 36 different countries and,
separately, languages predominantly tied to each country to analyze the
consistency in the LLMs' cultural understanding. Through our analysis of the
responses, we found that LLMs can differentiate between one side of a value and
another, as well as understand that countries have differing values, but will
not always uphold the values when giving advice, and fail to understand the
need to answer differently based on different cultural values. Rooted in these
findings, we present recommendations for training value-aligned and culturally
sensitive LLMs. More importantly, the methodology and the framework developed
here can help further understand and mitigate culture and language alignment
issues with LLMs. | [
0.0696115047,
0.0181146637,
-0.0370045565,
0.0213040188,
-0.0203155912,
-0.0004844984,
0.0048151831,
-0.0195196532,
0.0097445557,
-0.0024395126,
-0.0304508731,
-0.0515193455,
-0.0236769542,
-0.0053685517,
-0.0074630496,
-0.0819337741,
0.0517166331,
0.0008996343,
0.0375809446,
-0.0291282367,
0.0304433946,
0.0457770713,
0.0103051299,
0.0386773124,
-0.015898332,
-0.0019053635,
0.008656661,
-0.0033566218,
0.0753858089,
-0.0323831253,
0.0479660891,
-0.0039659869,
0.0243856665,
-0.0220999662,
0.0000021613,
-0.0588030294,
0.0091110291,
-0.0288458765,
0.0056605497,
0.0232255924,
0.0808259472,
0.0070876302,
-0.0359978192,
0.0164048895,
-0.049880065,
0.0168729126,
-0.0092630414,
0.0375626162,
0.036844831,
0.0572122149,
0.0157130212,
0.0007587393,
-0.0274509359,
0.0014099932,
-0.0373959802,
-0.03294475,
-0.0015240922,
0.0667022839,
-0.0206153598,
0.0267765038,
-0.014498367,
0.0182681791,
0.0077788727,
-0.0050007282,
-0.0336795114,
-0.0168907326,
-0.0184449069,
-0.0237925928,
0.0085420758,
0.0477411672,
0.069157891,
0.0284863487,
-0.0203862004,
-0.013658599,
0.0109461732,
-0.0065930882,
-0.006799323,
0.0566851422,
-0.00238378,
0.0244680233,
0.0236861464,
0.0205076355,
-0.0047739181,
0.0367757156,
0.0231395196,
0.0431964733,
-0.0275503714,
-0.0161323473,
-0.0453009605,
-0.0158996526,
0.0158664323,
-0.0345470086,
0.0262338053,
0.0585935004,
-0.0180643965,
0.0151865706,
0.0186183322,
0.0493386649,
0.0532138348,
-0.087404713,
0.0171263162,
0.0690219849,
-0.0228510927,
-0.008535984,
0.0264999289,
0.0301446859,
0.0146980723,
-0.0005975042,
-0.0476890877,
-0.0054448256,
-0.0402747504,
-0.0090312734,
0.0519670211,
-0.0157441404,
0.0172908101,
0.042288579,
-0.0652951077,
0.0148240076,
-0.0504456088,
0.0514481142,
-0.0327684619,
-0.0141956359,
0.0029326968,
-0.0118800877,
-0.0733065903,
0.1101974994,
-0.0599123091,
0.0033215426,
-0.026137989,
-0.0575925447,
0.0648832545,
0.0022136257,
-0.0365939848,
0.00772129,
0.0127130281,
0.0231267847,
-0.0046285936,
0.0261221472,
-0.0413267799,
0.0093127862,
0.0076130242,
-0.0704006851,
0.0110894656,
-0.0493550338,
0.0107214134,
0.0138743119,
0.0044644871,
-0.0372637808,
0.0381229147,
0.0400462672,
0.0001641361,
-0.0153633542,
0.013658586,
0.0585204922,
0.0661148429,
0.0328679532,
-0.0006786053,
0.0705910027,
-0.0056705996,
0.0243414287,
0.054282859,
-0.0569525249,
-0.0253493823,
0.034340445,
-0.0560625419,
0.0164905544,
-0.050933931,
0.0257337838,
0.0132559426,
-0.0004450824,
0.0650909096,
0.0315242,
-0.0166216027,
0.0197952799,
0.0549139418,
0.0636952594,
-0.0187278092,
0.0169776399,
0.042229943,
0.0148858791,
0.0046476554,
-0.0056624832,
-0.0396320969,
-0.0053505185,
0.0073653129,
0.0142528247,
-0.0346195102,
0.0716293082,
-0.0372241959,
-0.0305168424,
-0.019581819,
-0.0071590631,
0.0142247425,
0.0368184261,
-0.0052819117,
-0.0394432768,
0.0331084467,
0.0217248742,
0.0228097606,
-0.0881048515,
-0.0216835272,
0.0115901046,
0.0343303233,
0.1108553037,
-0.0174199138,
0.0231659245,
-0.0029634349,
-0.0337731242,
0.0134973228,
0.0449996851,
0.087567918,
-0.0118852062,
-0.0361212902,
-0.0385778621,
-0.0399056152,
-0.001360073,
-0.0388623215,
0.0087878229,
0.0205674395,
0.0453085266,
0.0052367374,
0.0146788619,
-0.0590534508,
-0.0104458686,
-0.0369240306,
0.0012534081,
-0.0380154364,
0.0104548698,
0.0160868187,
0.042708572,
0.0166053064,
-0.0055556116,
-0.0153480107,
-0.0116723767,
0.0173963923,
0.013807849,
-0.0795461908,
0.0487775691,
0.0460409634,
-0.0354510807,
-0.0368830897,
-0.0235599112,
0.0036297587,
0.0207324326,
-0.0098380521,
0.0041199327,
-0.0058642463,
-0.0493181981,
-0.0267429613,
-0.0269642603,
-0.0137895532,
-0.0346999727,
0.0140841939,
-0.0415278114,
-0.0088464329,
-0.034527272,
-0.0284662545,
0.0336406752,
-0.0253587272,
-0.0270598307,
0.0249198601,
-0.0099641038,
0.0327141471,
0.0375546291,
0.0496838242,
-0.0245884303,
0.0088270372,
-0.0778177455,
-0.0462608449,
-0.0025155304,
0.0102075944,
0.0099303201,
-0.0141197611,
-0.0271857735,
0.0017644278,
-0.0984426215,
-0.021906618,
0.0554895587,
0.0271053016,
0.0470231548,
-0.0062817112,
-0.0046839523,
0.0076727537,
-0.0009563859,
-0.007593588,
-0.0257161651,
-0.0437333398,
0.001593398,
-0.0351285972,
-0.0149823409,
-0.050370574,
-0.0289185438,
-0.026307594,
-0.0648798645,
0.0117506534,
0.0373440087,
0.0627660155,
0.0114071649,
0.060059011,
0.0181856677,
0.0330077037,
0.0308351927,
-0.066685468,
-0.0303569231,
-0.0167801026,
-0.0027358383,
-0.0253064111,
-0.0814626962,
-0.0050337981,
0.0361053161,
-0.0152266594,
0.0334218778,
-0.0207615774,
0.031772092,
-0.0351479277,
-0.0388019085,
0.0025809987,
-0.0093569942,
-0.0149827888,
0.0655253008,
0.032824222,
-0.026005961,
0.0518691614,
0.0144889858,
0.0014668481,
-0.0041109445,
-0.0329625458,
-0.0459190533,
0.0068843486,
-0.0567479394,
0.0489706919,
0.0153653333,
-0.0282945577,
-0.0217004474,
-0.041387815,
0.0379179716,
-0.0675051436,
0.047692664,
-0.0193197317,
-0.0407499969,
-0.014101712,
-0.0164189823,
-0.0356571116,
0.0221408922,
-0.0339785032,
0.0194590092,
-0.0143945841,
0.0073798052,
0.0030570128,
-0.0245516077,
0.069805555,
-0.041715797,
-0.0301900413,
0.0215351153,
0.0134141129,
-0.0691034347,
0.0441118665,
0.0338384323,
0.0324417949,
-0.0584012903,
0.0214795042,
0.0206645429,
0.0079293707,
-0.0531964339,
0.0242607109,
0.0046511022,
0.0632980764,
-0.001321525,
-0.020108372,
0.0342117585,
0.0528933369,
-0.0257079005,
0.0181597415,
0.0846298262,
-0.0056031896,
-0.0409413502,
0.0113858664,
-0.1054521576,
0.0169884246,
0.0254791956,
0.0560308062,
-0.0975352302,
0.0251904372,
-0.0331624039,
0.0097339777,
-0.0618473031,
0.0145545015,
-0.0133010438,
-0.0850460678,
0.0286905803,
0.0361314192,
0.0013941278,
-0.0268720165,
0.0418660268,
-0.0382704623,
0.0210790467,
0.0966171101,
-0.0097195702,
-0.0210250765,
-0.0388042741,
0.0351343118,
-0.0715670884,
-0.053559415,
0.0363197289,
-0.0349188186,
0.0334446505,
0.0642753989,
0.0058711371,
0.0054372847,
-0.1033489928,
-0.0346527025,
0.0406936482,
0.0160549227,
0.0071383798,
-0.0346733555,
-0.0450975411,
0.0050704633,
-0.0349298157,
-0.0138116004,
0.0119755389,
-0.0248835832,
0.0287099238,
0.0350365415,
-0.0248819217,
-0.0028075848,
-0.0127105946,
0.0392981991,
0.0252641384,
0.0501716584,
0.005732391,
-0.0761229768,
0.0288724974,
-0.0235929769,
-0.0327352956,
0.0223003738,
-0.0700145736,
0.0247246884,
-0.0366303921,
0.0127731739,
0.000748051,
-0.0690581575,
-0.0079684751,
-0.0073696948,
0.0174363665,
-0.0426769778,
-0.0065045669,
0.0292470809,
0.0132004041,
0.014510653,
-0.0558112822,
0.0412663072,
-0.0354847535,
0.0151949581,
0.0211176425,
-0.0533158481,
0.0319716223,
-0.0406619497,
0.0356454514,
-0.0131246094,
0.0268893447,
0.0760259032,
0.0098325573,
0.0020045701,
0.0663660392,
-0.046093829,
-0.0029717993,
0.0119035086,
-0.0155538972,
0.0011579529,
0.0201466996,
0.0729336813,
-0.0018416983,
0.0200384371,
0.000697478,
0.0388804823,
0.0178347621,
0.0317149311,
-0.0475969948,
-0.0608073398,
0.024416633,
0.0336287618,
-0.0307958312,
-0.022253463,
-0.0101215923,
-0.0068723471,
-0.0231267978,
-0.0341944098,
-0.0455562696,
-0.0173331127,
-0.0190716274,
0.0070073712,
-0.0130967041,
0.0441643968,
-0.038567733,
-0.0347240791,
-0.0042509339,
-0.0206464212,
0.0559606701,
0.0025408315,
0.0556088462,
-0.0265643317,
0.0181346852,
-0.0341781005,
0.0073137293,
0.0245025624,
0.0327358358,
0.0073621282,
0.133119911,
0.0008218937,
0.0020179749,
0.014293273,
0.01201005,
0.0042636441,
-0.0717931241,
0.0268192478,
0.0017538923,
0.0344113559,
-0.0101700956,
0.0364807919,
-0.0000720446,
0.0169487745,
-0.0245789122,
0.0039256788,
0.0018734711,
-0.0557468385,
0.0294903982,
0.0122283101,
-0.033495158,
-0.0363278314,
0.0118126962,
-0.0393594392,
-0.0107339956,
-0.0164357889,
-0.0165654384,
-0.0189674776,
-0.0229171496,
0.0456474647,
-0.0097373985,
-0.0673521906,
-0.022910608,
-0.1105475277,
-0.028568618,
-0.0291726068,
0.0219782442,
-0.0340918452,
-0.0490279384,
0.0006417012,
0.0467217825,
-0.0113459416,
-0.039200604,
-0.0608926006,
-0.0162124708,
-0.0395147987,
0.0232132841,
0.002369093,
-5.890653454e-33,
-0.0144880833,
-0.0272123273,
0.0426680371,
-0.0001034232,
-0.0364719965,
-0.0252078362,
-0.0079125548,
0.0336253271,
-0.0497502685,
0.0132415807,
-0.0264443979,
-0.0360514149,
-0.0023580275,
0.0009715054,
0.0503226668,
-0.0093726125,
0.0064572813,
0.0101873828,
-0.0199109334,
0.007217302,
0.0347147584,
-0.0051282737,
0.0861034393,
-0.0870242491,
0.054432299,
0.0104646813,
-0.0228091646,
0.0260951705,
0.0132593848,
0.0275663789,
-0.017115606,
0.0559020042,
0.0147682009,
-0.0416275784,
-0.0069130617,
0.019565938,
-0.0237764455,
-0.0398372337,
0.0489373803,
0.0192760471,
0.0372879729,
-0.0643830374,
-0.0098401187,
-0.0457101576,
-0.0381617025,
0.019018529,
0.0341624767,
-0.006768473,
0.0211479813,
0.0153107112,
-0.0441028811,
-0.001569377,
-0.0238405801,
0.0364148989,
-0.0123676853,
0.0869550779,
-0.0401542,
-0.0080134114,
-0.0469613597,
0.0362697095,
0.0076797451,
-0.0247210842,
0.0846578181,
0.0084121553,
-0.0295261145,
0.061002437,
-0.0095088156,
0.0569427907,
-0.0364651792,
-0.0393451042,
0.0394295864,
0.0263479184,
-0.0114196166,
0.0874289423,
-0.0538074747,
-0.0385113545,
-0.0099696573,
0.0142830499,
0.0724349245,
0.0197086744,
0.0099514117,
0.0017343296,
-0.0236543827,
-0.028183639,
-0.00793928,
-0.0039104572,
0.01471256,
-0.0633154958,
0.0237179343,
-0.0246707499,
-0.0079725953,
0.0046211034,
0.0505166203,
-0.0213971529,
-0.0224241111,
-0.0197684206,
0.0032885328,
-0.0258374698,
0.029877495,
0.0055138078,
-0.0601812303,
-0.0087217726,
-0.0541651994,
-0.0418406799,
-0.0149245793,
0.0344200656,
0.0061835758,
0.0016892569,
-0.0441632271,
-0.0180234034,
-0.0031327459,
0.0187083241,
-0.0378035568,
0.0059137358,
0.0276883468,
-0.0213014688,
-0.0111761382,
0.0161118954,
0.0143714668,
-0.0335418954,
-0.034200035,
-0.0436038785,
-0.0190518312,
0.0522454605,
-0.0515097231,
0.0015087831,
-0.0507303886,
0.0540522188,
0.071353808,
0.0187155325,
-0.0090722125,
-0.0146080377,
2.753e-7,
0.0072858632,
0.0332555287,
-0.01779758,
0.0319232643,
-0.0096389493,
0.0672766194,
0.0064012907,
0.0244700629,
0.0477657914,
-0.0010039201,
0.0398797989,
0.0051929457,
0.055702135,
0.0258074049,
-0.0696671605,
-0.0070078378,
-0.0247025508,
0.0005331195,
-0.0256749894,
0.0503158644,
0.0060243644,
-0.0025121325,
-0.0041693891,
-0.0262195058,
-0.0200705752,
0.0499196351,
0.0430505648,
-0.0801418126,
-0.0101994909,
0.0172247253,
0.0001658086,
-0.0523941554,
0.046764411,
0.0095664812,
0.0043523479,
0.0029026081,
0.0049884161,
0.123371616,
-0.0060083494,
-0.0250980742,
0.0067386227,
0.0170602333,
-0.0055005532,
-0.0885454789,
0.0039182384,
-0.0023909868,
-0.0337873995,
-0.0551107638,
-0.0058717486,
-0.0280245598,
0.0192821063,
-0.0184352398,
-0.0315573551,
0.0365094729,
0.0265043601,
-0.0090867421,
-0.0074704797,
-0.0033190562,
0.0232855398,
-0.0331815332,
0.0259765983,
-0.0511301383,
-0.0015462342,
0.0324346386,
-0.0271565039,
-0.0098554501,
0.009202051,
2.260008424e-34,
-0.0092176422,
-0.0035681915,
0.0230410174,
0.0392554142,
0.0537633039,
0.0689289793,
0.0241645873,
0.0316569693,
0.017212905,
0.0019995316,
-0.0079042828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14785v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14785v1 | Understanding Finetuning for Factual Knowledge Extraction | 2024-06-20T23:27:06 | 2024-06-20T23:27:06 | Gaurav Ghosal, Tatsunori Hashimoto, Aditi Raghunathan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this work, we study the impact of QA fine-tuning data on downstream
factuality. We show that fine-tuning on lesser-known facts that are poorly
stored during pretraining yields significantly worse factuality than
fine-tuning on well-known facts, even when all facts are seen during
pretraining. We prove this phenomenon theoretically, showing that training on
lesser-known facts can lead the model to ignore subject entity names and
instead output a generic plausible response even when the relevant factual
knowledge is encoded in the model. On three question answering benchmarks
(PopQA, Entity Questions, and MMLU) and two language models (Llama-2-7B and
Mistral-7B), we find that (i) finetuning on a completely factual but
lesser-known subset of the data deteriorates downstream factuality (5-10%) and
(ii) finetuning on a subset of better-known examples matches or outperforms
finetuning on the entire dataset. Ultimately, our results shed light on the
interaction between pretrained knowledge and finetuning data and demonstrate
the importance of taking into account how facts are stored in the pretrained
model when fine-tuning for knowledge-intensive tasks. | [
0.0541855916,
-0.0053066369,
-0.0143529791,
0.0291643329,
0.0047527077,
0.0430735797,
-0.0155980159,
-0.0166329574,
-0.0444732197,
-0.0624555796,
-0.0073058903,
0.0203553904,
-0.0064273709,
-0.0111493347,
0.0491520539,
-0.0128320744,
0.059488114,
-0.0121073779,
0.0266399272,
-0.0343726501,
0.0133605069,
-0.0091949794,
-0.0012158902,
-0.030235067,
-0.0169400275,
-0.0139705716,
0.0058101681,
-0.0368344784,
0.0236216094,
0.0284773745,
0.0368904769,
0.0578704067,
-0.0208415408,
-0.0138340304,
0.0000017715,
-0.0772539377,
0.0051339255,
-0.023250347,
-0.0985520482,
0.0500326306,
-0.052548416,
0.0337293223,
0.0138714584,
0.0004563662,
-0.0522866882,
-0.0048351735,
0.0145702865,
0.0765216872,
0.0398345329,
0.0522407107,
0.0139446054,
-0.0181339793,
0.0066656894,
-0.0312591195,
-0.0104832659,
-0.0530771017,
0.0363597758,
0.0070010158,
-0.0228105374,
0.0229712799,
-0.0209200028,
0.0133171221,
-0.0004087347,
0.0621817037,
-0.0016905456,
0.0533365533,
-0.0231046714,
0.0082660113,
0.0277298298,
0.0820509866,
0.0061867912,
-0.0131889665,
0.0050851861,
0.0092876749,
0.0182380304,
0.0025712927,
-0.0178496707,
-0.0057674791,
-0.047894273,
-0.0116950832,
0.0190969277,
-0.0297347158,
0.0129509149,
0.0171107762,
-0.0176252294,
0.0405249894,
-0.0178636424,
-0.0552584566,
0.0147895617,
0.0232969541,
-0.0039199772,
-0.0728357583,
-0.0111420043,
0.015901655,
0.0052812407,
0.014403766,
-0.0201452859,
0.0263823178,
0.0496118926,
-0.0304666944,
-0.0246892087,
0.0218705516,
-0.0418993682,
0.0581857488,
-0.0325973779,
0.026669126,
0.0088757323,
0.0591664799,
-0.0299383774,
-0.0133780986,
-0.022629723,
-0.0090591526,
-0.0339979939,
0.0532257929,
-0.0179660264,
0.0177780688,
-0.0227832943,
-0.0240401793,
0.0068449271,
0.0090287412,
-0.0234663915,
-0.0016791301,
-0.0435139351,
0.0090470826,
-0.0635303482,
0.0467746258,
-0.100155063,
0.0727696866,
0.0034797548,
-0.0790668949,
-0.0422995165,
-0.0405950882,
0.0292195491,
-0.0180608332,
0.0416596569,
-0.0147621492,
-0.0081537412,
-0.0438933186,
-0.0499994233,
-0.0375349969,
0.0108318878,
-0.0895688608,
-0.0008758577,
-0.0404679365,
0.0558237694,
0.0107453903,
-0.0101845926,
-0.0186960753,
-0.0042856331,
0.0169472769,
-0.0430947654,
0.0815296695,
-0.0282544624,
0.0135781933,
0.0214152541,
0.0095132114,
0.0149764018,
0.0812924355,
-0.0017454893,
0.0227668528,
0.0501641855,
0.0024400223,
-0.012302544,
0.0122255506,
0.0500567406,
-0.0135553386,
0.0727481544,
0.0476448014,
-0.0040665958,
0.0081531461,
0.0442134775,
0.0072957827,
-0.0246597007,
-0.021341132,
0.0411654487,
0.0292586796,
0.0139515139,
0.0141982762,
0.0091882525,
-0.0318842493,
0.0527043007,
0.0654074475,
-0.0690798312,
0.0307013933,
-0.031954933,
0.0289726797,
-0.0152842496,
0.0654589385,
-0.0321491174,
-0.028668005,
0.0153984446,
0.0167576075,
-0.0421382524,
0.0304598548,
0.0166253764,
0.0530767255,
-0.0167515129,
0.0729945377,
0.0466142148,
-0.0122501915,
0.0032360754,
-0.0307684317,
0.034886837,
0.0215780847,
0.0214421824,
-0.0294960588,
-0.0650505349,
0.006995609,
0.026353823,
-0.0281435903,
0.0718895271,
-0.0223401189,
0.0150152016,
-0.0295958538,
-0.0080874925,
-0.0453283228,
0.0397283919,
-0.0123479199,
0.0198460128,
0.0227790289,
0.0035317542,
-0.0539564155,
0.0088772671,
0.0339395665,
-0.0351893827,
-0.0631650463,
-0.0353295207,
0.0344938822,
-0.0113166329,
0.0015853038,
-0.0112001933,
0.0067725149,
0.0244848635,
0.0087138982,
0.0178860147,
-0.0244204868,
0.0103566842,
-0.0222536456,
0.026725024,
-0.0000695085,
-0.0239991732,
0.0112096323,
-0.0470463298,
-0.014872469,
-0.0370435193,
-0.0099617504,
0.0004427261,
-0.0326743163,
-0.0129354717,
0.0051871715,
0.0252624974,
-0.0342812911,
0.0812406167,
-0.0090153264,
0.0147992438,
-0.0268336926,
-0.0390394367,
0.003470059,
-0.0419074818,
-0.0106975902,
0.0076518273,
0.0116970465,
0.0116222948,
0.0046700211,
-0.025168797,
-0.0754859075,
0.0117592337,
-0.0731497779,
0.0185570009,
-0.0348234549,
0.0435730293,
0.018860355,
0.0049321246,
-0.0415769629,
-0.0155022312,
-0.0350476615,
-0.0261335708,
-0.027965758,
0.0559761338,
0.0432003848,
0.0414585173,
0.0253783073,
-0.0481917337,
-0.0063058636,
-0.016531514,
0.0036390182,
0.0125622032,
0.0013878816,
-0.0374241583,
0.0163709763,
-0.0731875896,
0.0262436643,
-0.0141652748,
-0.0606355816,
-0.0260124914,
0.0241970122,
0.0226564445,
0.0868218392,
-0.002480909,
0.0053268648,
0.0276409797,
0.0053969896,
-0.01620166,
0.0582062751,
-0.0354880206,
-0.0334648266,
-0.018829152,
-0.0259831063,
0.0147462776,
0.0274551064,
0.0004437282,
-0.0014334932,
-0.0337197967,
0.0735626817,
-0.0087740012,
-0.0155935455,
-0.0182428677,
0.0442774147,
-0.0013857926,
0.0664049834,
-0.0296473745,
-0.0021457765,
0.0905377194,
-0.0126567306,
0.0059683267,
-0.0280192271,
0.0032154894,
-0.0154806599,
0.0089480868,
-0.0217413213,
0.0068681724,
0.021981217,
0.0045513329,
-0.0495265611,
-0.0092192004,
0.0372685008,
-0.0486318842,
0.0507896245,
-0.0118254218,
0.0044084145,
0.0096631488,
-0.0593592301,
-0.0365541168,
-0.0732085556,
-0.02235559,
-0.0030871131,
-0.0187416263,
0.0044131754,
0.0142491721,
-0.0339610316,
0.0366767235,
0.0028059012,
-0.0250169653,
-0.0068416232,
-0.0214126743,
0.0295512546,
0.0849057063,
0.0576755293,
0.067624025,
-0.0068469639,
0.003342635,
0.0389887914,
0.0179406535,
-0.0300869439,
0.0426733233,
-0.006003391,
0.0203925762,
-0.0624124333,
-0.0182882417,
0.0025290854,
0.0752665773,
-0.0423870496,
-0.0397411883,
0.0813977346,
0.0063963188,
0.0515054427,
0.0036878658,
0.0028717548,
-0.004601418,
0.0226313975,
0.0305107385,
-0.0757149979,
-0.0334839411,
0.0043387357,
0.0576635227,
-0.007293636,
-0.0410253927,
-0.0038989307,
-0.106039457,
0.0082642678,
-0.0437736362,
-0.0108790183,
-0.0566757806,
-0.0329950638,
0.0245588776,
-0.0178364143,
0.0199465044,
0.0121411793,
-0.0281600729,
0.023496028,
0.037672393,
0.0113137309,
-0.0575432852,
0.0691725761,
-0.0403853133,
0.0307969451,
0.0323590748,
0.0227881968,
-0.0288279466,
-0.0296732951,
-0.0329867378,
-0.0813364685,
0.0130589195,
0.009629366,
0.0803948864,
-0.0187727176,
-0.0289864726,
-0.0091645382,
0.015244809,
0.0327537693,
0.0199630056,
0.0034873302,
0.0364656411,
0.0110088559,
-0.032492131,
0.0275086053,
0.0032101236,
-0.0171227027,
0.0836126059,
0.0452679992,
0.0157273486,
-0.0146015119,
-0.0251160264,
0.0072762021,
-0.0025741297,
-0.0204070881,
0.0282883421,
-0.0279879086,
0.006531788,
-0.0619097799,
-0.0791488066,
0.0432415418,
0.0320679694,
-0.0185321774,
0.026643049,
0.0455088578,
0.0045522279,
-0.0241078455,
0.0549478978,
-0.0612214133,
-0.0085620387,
-0.0211124253,
-0.0189732555,
0.0605791099,
-0.0116823232,
-0.0263940599,
-0.0458903089,
-0.0634178072,
-0.0406956784,
0.0384631716,
0.0537538864,
0.0205457006,
0.0352961607,
-0.0216051526,
-0.0510765761,
0.0030008128,
0.0441440679,
-0.0759205818,
0.0462961085,
0.0426603295,
-0.0386874676,
-0.0059662652,
0.0553630739,
-0.0537178293,
0.0202266816,
0.0217632372,
0.0189622398,
-0.0386907086,
-0.0289524533,
0.0278314482,
0.0354906619,
0.059647426,
0.028528424,
-0.0168713182,
-0.0402395688,
0.0309248958,
0.0166245792,
-0.0106286975,
0.0118225534,
-0.0357583612,
-0.0036470466,
0.0134810749,
-0.0160936229,
-0.0010678032,
0.001868103,
0.0408470072,
-0.0684323832,
-0.0264111888,
0.0251559243,
-0.0138880545,
0.0264965426,
-0.0235663634,
-0.0354316011,
0.045775,
0.0177322458,
0.0804718584,
-0.0181537345,
0.0232921857,
0.0450344458,
0.0138907796,
-0.0373414084,
0.0019949307,
-0.0418011136,
-0.0246623475,
-0.0051633269,
0.0473278426,
0.0293693207,
-0.0500172414,
0.0033996429,
-0.0080118319,
-0.0302990191,
0.0108750267,
-0.0360657014,
-0.0065725823,
0.0218651686,
0.0440754034,
0.0150965741,
-0.027342394,
0.0022641679,
0.0827940255,
-0.0303888451,
0.1002168134,
-0.0171794035,
-0.0087515563,
-0.0219631866,
-0.0363754369,
-0.0414384753,
-0.0047138287,
0.0140533391,
0.0361815169,
-0.0936021879,
-0.0624892153,
0.0094167795,
-0.0077344659,
-0.0149517199,
-0.0303274523,
0.0360885337,
0.0720178708,
0.0189862158,
-0.0596796088,
-0.0302975606,
0.0204159301,
0.0142168794,
0.0138633391,
0.018523626,
-6.84948289e-33,
-0.0508319736,
0.0093121985,
0.0322818123,
0.0289697722,
-0.0037035986,
0.0268333331,
-0.0071962285,
-0.0153561877,
-0.1118482426,
0.0316564329,
-0.0291700605,
0.0183888972,
0.0135714179,
-0.0168297812,
-0.0255895164,
-0.0693631619,
0.0461288728,
-0.0045969766,
-0.0596262775,
-0.0054614823,
0.029949978,
0.0416548699,
0.0629334748,
-0.0246557333,
0.0024846045,
-0.0195225328,
-0.0113674784,
0.0455498025,
-0.044455722,
0.0372372866,
-0.004842673,
0.023453515,
0.0352503657,
-0.0565980785,
0.0133839957,
-0.0004177784,
-0.1386649311,
-0.0680502728,
0.0614955537,
0.0025059006,
0.0138805509,
-0.0316105969,
0.0539283752,
-0.0030526305,
-0.0155756949,
-0.0190807916,
0.008223258,
-0.0037862253,
-0.0006897016,
-0.057400614,
-0.0274936296,
-0.0000386621,
0.0196333118,
-0.0311648622,
-0.0170801487,
-0.0156983547,
0.0268073026,
-0.0186789837,
-0.0634029657,
-0.0215336736,
0.0572700649,
0.0319064111,
0.0420650691,
-0.0231982451,
-0.0185508747,
0.0457593426,
-0.0033153223,
0.030389633,
-0.0439390279,
0.0190311819,
0.0265944898,
0.024263246,
-0.0036747789,
0.0584601089,
0.0175827872,
-0.0250058342,
-0.0611933731,
0.0030187003,
-0.0126738595,
0.0415675715,
-0.0152689097,
-0.0376093723,
-0.0760245398,
-0.0387358367,
-0.0748018324,
0.0597244538,
-0.0271211248,
0.0311710294,
0.0280239135,
0.0133830076,
-0.0236270949,
0.0205248818,
-0.0301814415,
-0.0179018416,
0.022451194,
0.0240978189,
-0.0106684277,
-0.0159921926,
-0.0130003178,
0.0009164105,
-0.0745355412,
0.0151139786,
0.0077954107,
-0.0203662533,
0.0245708302,
0.0244551282,
0.0471288264,
-0.0142193679,
-0.038914796,
0.0082200076,
-0.0028561056,
0.0528491437,
0.0321365148,
-0.0262216292,
0.0358707979,
0.0539930724,
-0.005123653,
0.011816686,
0.0697962418,
0.0201446377,
-0.0388160162,
-0.0251404494,
0.0321522132,
0.0221641399,
-0.0178666525,
-0.0064219641,
-0.0090872273,
0.0052979197,
-0.0383426398,
-0.0340126194,
-0.0157243405,
0.0291227736,
2.601e-7,
0.0217635464,
0.0482452437,
0.0214768853,
0.0132297752,
-0.0113738813,
0.0637479201,
0.0046933074,
0.009973119,
0.0446627848,
-0.058581166,
-0.0119971177,
0.0443298854,
-0.0037552991,
0.0235508289,
-0.0783121809,
-0.0153050935,
-0.0245252419,
-0.0175163522,
-0.0417066999,
-0.0530779548,
0.0183683708,
0.0821509138,
0.0402272753,
-0.0071135182,
-0.0121887736,
-0.0470055081,
0.0423801467,
0.0150025701,
-0.0310052782,
0.0406800099,
0.0750568211,
0.0157423913,
0.0087721059,
0.0383842401,
-0.0033398152,
0.0336283483,
-0.005767284,
0.0398463123,
0.0084453253,
-0.0343085155,
-0.0386896431,
-0.0549799688,
0.007330508,
-0.0546649396,
0.0900588632,
-0.0334577225,
-0.0254338775,
-0.0279454682,
-0.0125219487,
0.0145197567,
0.0177589227,
0.002761631,
0.0010833441,
0.0200689398,
-0.0002526158,
0.0251095947,
-0.0302914586,
-0.0614499375,
0.0070196902,
0.0683119223,
0.0084192958,
-0.0764708072,
0.0141466316,
-0.0479155816,
0.0061554099,
-0.0880719647,
0.0358146988,
2.041527875e-34,
0.005907909,
-0.0043284469,
0.0244666468,
0.0175650287,
0.0280974619,
-0.005732303,
-0.0031382404,
-0.0145547763,
-0.0020064055,
-0.0514095798,
0.0028557046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14783v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14783v1 | Evaluating RAG-Fusion with RAGElo: an Automated Elo-based Framework | 2024-06-20T23:20:34 | 2024-06-20T23:20:34 | Zackary Rackauckas, Arthur Câmara, Jakub Zavrel | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Challenges in the automated evaluation of Retrieval-Augmented Generation
(RAG) Question-Answering (QA) systems include hallucination problems in
domain-specific knowledge and the lack of gold standard benchmarks for company
internal tasks. This results in difficulties in evaluating RAG variations, like
RAG-Fusion (RAGF), in the context of a product QA task at Infineon
Technologies. To solve these problems, we propose a comprehensive evaluation
framework, which leverages Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate large
datasets of synthetic queries based on real user queries and in-domain
documents, uses LLM-as-a-judge to rate retrieved documents and answers,
evaluates the quality of answers, and ranks different variants of
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) agents with RAGElo's automated Elo-based
competition. LLM-as-a-judge rating of a random sample of synthetic queries
shows a moderate, positive correlation with domain expert scoring in relevance,
accuracy, completeness, and precision. While RAGF outperformed RAG in Elo
score, a significance analysis against expert annotations also shows that RAGF
significantly outperforms RAG in completeness, but underperforms in precision.
In addition, Infineon's RAGF assistant demonstrated slightly higher performance
in document relevance based on MRR@5 scores. We find that RAGElo positively
aligns with the preferences of human annotators, though due caution is still
required. Finally, RAGF's approach leads to more complete answers based on
expert annotations and better answers overall based on RAGElo's evaluation
criteria. | [
0.079226613,
0.0131730745,
-0.018174978,
0.0084223272,
-0.0165702663,
-0.0085252235,
-0.0133934291,
-0.0235746186,
0.0031857479,
-0.0685355514,
-0.0299967937,
0.0078117503,
-0.0526213646,
-0.0013497848,
0.0182234403,
0.0093091084,
0.0173117239,
0.0016845495,
-0.0011643955,
0.001238657,
0.0156171508,
0.0307657942,
-0.0016258861,
0.04083886,
0.0078085796,
-0.0023169091,
-0.0029614195,
0.0178422537,
0.0179133993,
0.007540294,
0.0227293782,
0.0441295542,
0.0213097148,
0.0198159851,
0.00000189,
-0.0856170431,
-0.0319921821,
0.0069950977,
-0.0378339104,
-0.0089242645,
0.024456365,
0.0699583814,
0.0200699214,
0.0370211974,
-0.0571511239,
0.009750016,
0.0013181404,
0.0256223455,
0.1005008593,
0.0546064861,
0.006694715,
-0.0199833941,
0.0191170685,
-0.0091664204,
0.0546312854,
-0.0623385422,
0.0059699989,
0.0509813093,
0.0591082722,
-0.0105827097,
0.0415339991,
0.0329910852,
0.0021391269,
-0.0142932283,
0.0433194302,
0.0035398805,
-0.0661343634,
0.0089203762,
-0.0027710686,
0.0761610568,
0.0238140039,
0.0012427284,
-0.0131358569,
0.0246266481,
0.036324922,
0.0443182774,
-0.0277189091,
-0.0043195835,
-0.041122973,
-0.0226505343,
-0.022517059,
0.0038646907,
0.0006657405,
0.0164189097,
-0.0126710925,
0.0847841874,
0.0183336753,
-0.0397317857,
0.0289835073,
0.0036838793,
-0.023296589,
-0.0420733318,
0.0155007495,
0.0495938845,
-0.0408266075,
0.0290943012,
-0.0213811025,
-0.0287075918,
0.0543329865,
-0.0529928803,
-0.009535687,
0.0204407685,
0.0172688589,
0.0452395901,
-0.0301299933,
0.0533808582,
-0.0123783797,
0.0155594191,
-0.0905135199,
-0.0482892841,
-0.0692739338,
-0.0505021736,
-0.0326030254,
0.0707716048,
-0.0457286946,
-0.0125167165,
-0.0440786369,
0.0200513005,
-0.0033399356,
0.0037329199,
0.0046684528,
0.0495434403,
-0.0240714848,
-0.0177582838,
-0.0924722776,
-0.0149427308,
-0.0449271612,
0.0270533562,
0.018864803,
-0.0634326041,
0.0142845847,
0.031279128,
-0.0072094235,
-0.0123192323,
0.0304110479,
0.0325285904,
-0.0214673094,
-0.0244209673,
-0.0177565832,
-0.0554531366,
0.0150341894,
-0.0509596393,
-0.0178117603,
-0.0599985644,
0.0455038324,
0.0212610606,
-0.043230515,
-0.0102227172,
0.0169924702,
0.0663321987,
0.0195076745,
0.0364054367,
-0.0094365356,
0.0144469077,
0.0760231018,
-0.0044733668,
-0.0074873185,
0.0412212834,
0.0074667297,
0.0436495952,
0.0268598385,
0.0057327547,
0.0337425061,
0.0127603961,
-0.0058503277,
-0.0080256248,
0.0052023339,
0.0869556963,
-0.025688041,
0.0040329145,
0.0194062237,
0.0569715835,
-0.0093137911,
0.0159023777,
0.020885976,
0.0218305923,
0.0412912443,
0.004920701,
0.0373211838,
0.0203971416,
0.0183742289,
-0.0125156725,
0.0238268096,
0.0280362852,
-0.0339707807,
0.0239466336,
0.0633821189,
0.0278100278,
-0.0389855132,
-0.0550839528,
-0.0144474441,
0.0286374558,
-0.0273270383,
0.0402280353,
0.0056081037,
0.0006041386,
-0.0485699177,
0.0354033634,
-0.0177685171,
-0.0334597416,
0.0185696706,
-0.0505567305,
0.0228383355,
0.0800903141,
0.0693438351,
-0.027467858,
-0.0285249576,
-0.016946299,
-0.0284604393,
0.0351505019,
0.0360606797,
-0.0200617611,
-0.0572868548,
-0.0411574282,
-0.0349383838,
-0.0421251953,
-0.0102592539,
0.0110856313,
-0.0054759271,
0.02287017,
0.0454085767,
-0.0801969618,
-0.0456713066,
0.0315632857,
-0.0319443494,
-0.0446765572,
0.0060633849,
0.0048387111,
-0.0141937751,
0.0542106405,
-0.0190872867,
0.071045801,
0.0247074384,
-0.0366518348,
-0.0599430501,
-0.0094206315,
-0.0008405589,
0.0055012014,
0.0140350163,
-0.0256852452,
-0.0022358524,
0.0021628786,
-0.0255460273,
-0.0346755385,
-0.0373877175,
-0.0615983903,
0.0023764807,
-0.0785935149,
-0.0303909834,
0.0090365736,
0.0087320162,
-0.0660596937,
0.0866293609,
0.0133010438,
0.0322371572,
0.0424214602,
0.0136295781,
0.0282469206,
-0.0604337938,
-0.0032865102,
-0.0295823105,
0.0117627252,
0.051718358,
0.0424627289,
-0.0070868279,
-0.0586178713,
-0.0243141465,
-0.1013664156,
0.0108907856,
-0.0324075744,
0.0161846764,
0.0310172234,
-0.0051937373,
0.0032194257,
-0.0027281947,
-0.0582676008,
-0.031747479,
0.0331102498,
0.0257807225,
0.0384610072,
0.040760763,
0.0046997466,
-0.041318804,
-0.0005190149,
-0.003013087,
0.0203986596,
0.044296436,
0.0430668406,
-0.0664350465,
0.0199156459,
-0.0642625391,
0.0062620165,
0.0177265201,
-0.0126789659,
-0.0009891199,
-0.0367525332,
0.0116283763,
0.0207728408,
0.0369758457,
-0.0198699553,
0.0286174156,
-0.0053356872,
-0.0563696995,
0.0076587023,
-0.0198364351,
-0.0319096148,
0.0005301468,
-0.0099281333,
0.0596055314,
-0.0160778984,
0.014018314,
-0.0102093769,
-0.0458517,
0.0301097427,
0.0012404801,
-0.0454886556,
-0.0274770837,
-0.0113368453,
-0.0043333666,
0.0624884292,
-0.00371849,
-0.0184919704,
0.0820879489,
-0.0074944473,
0.0039528757,
-0.0815356672,
-0.0088338479,
-0.0744597763,
-0.0012871893,
-0.044361867,
0.0274517331,
-0.0616514422,
-0.0144662587,
-0.0207846574,
-0.0066851014,
0.0064882282,
-0.0697537661,
0.0044517224,
-0.025149446,
0.0389048196,
0.0129531557,
-0.0103573389,
-0.0568758138,
-0.0474236421,
0.0018208021,
0.0155284889,
0.0179437455,
0.0166643243,
-0.046841003,
0.0130931083,
0.0279941428,
-0.0069956281,
-0.0124246599,
-0.0310575645,
0.0111682648,
0.052245006,
0.0777045712,
0.0359898806,
0.0192950703,
0.0175934788,
0.017218966,
0.0294066947,
0.0548391603,
-0.0339144468,
-0.0056671295,
-0.0245116018,
0.0151222032,
-0.0395253822,
0.0142131504,
-0.0017992132,
0.0095193824,
-0.0202378053,
-0.0090045417,
0.0807790458,
0.036450848,
-0.0017637529,
-0.023791004,
-0.0354551971,
0.0301645212,
0.0387938917,
0.079054065,
-0.0505486205,
-0.0156982355,
-0.017599158,
0.0549776182,
0.0041914987,
-0.001560685,
-0.0050165644,
-0.1610446423,
0.0437071696,
-0.0334541984,
-0.0180776771,
-0.0222215168,
-0.0310907122,
0.0008278149,
0.0116079459,
0.009003073,
0.0387002379,
-0.0276334565,
0.0135812368,
0.0315769985,
0.0170175657,
-0.0136911161,
0.056403935,
-0.0086335894,
-0.0115013747,
0.0917233303,
0.0188712329,
0.0053577307,
-0.0572736934,
0.0010026088,
-0.0394961014,
0.0416340716,
0.0191293471,
0.0506151058,
-0.0122928331,
0.0155637274,
-0.0171404984,
0.0179669354,
-0.0315926597,
0.026690416,
-0.0010949089,
0.0460846834,
-0.0151497228,
0.0325127654,
-0.03857195,
0.0088493926,
-0.0150451865,
0.0682936981,
-0.0037926624,
-0.0392979905,
-0.0348264724,
-0.001927695,
0.0346306451,
-0.049662184,
-0.0134278638,
0.0438475572,
-0.0101259872,
-0.0031841646,
-0.0866837054,
-0.0735186562,
0.0304570515,
0.0276744887,
-0.0008790259,
0.0037491058,
-0.0506425984,
0.0230128579,
-0.0095974337,
0.0160830282,
-0.0212057997,
0.02196276,
-0.0250003431,
0.0125634391,
0.042363137,
-0.0450817607,
-0.0446313433,
0.0127509618,
-0.0361106768,
-0.0388483405,
-0.0161461644,
0.0382377394,
0.0271104723,
-0.0035455744,
-0.0083261495,
-0.0432826169,
0.0605047941,
0.0598954149,
-0.0685692653,
0.0023802549,
-0.0083528068,
-0.0028330872,
-0.0392015986,
0.0208854917,
-0.1033940837,
-0.0093077784,
-0.0293034185,
0.0711313114,
0.0058110422,
-0.0661183149,
0.0648909211,
0.0190875437,
-0.0200566445,
-0.0017172797,
0.0118906181,
-0.0090205306,
0.0261337366,
-0.0020386456,
-0.0262389295,
-0.0242727157,
-0.0013413365,
-0.0031449178,
-0.0302110389,
0.0449224077,
0.0225804523,
-0.0368368067,
0.0598616228,
-0.0223614536,
-0.0206016637,
0.0383872427,
-0.0022611984,
-0.0146881631,
-0.0049715117,
-0.0336623006,
-0.020586662,
0.0061817486,
0.0606036969,
-0.0152992681,
0.047594104,
0.0031678972,
0.0152190886,
-0.0025483144,
0.0336346216,
-0.0705238059,
-0.0892693251,
-0.0406932756,
-0.0016358346,
0.0174127184,
0.0177599695,
0.0306172688,
-0.0067303181,
-0.0078352932,
-0.016724458,
-0.0248252954,
0.0132488692,
-0.0071682981,
0.0380119644,
0.028551491,
-0.0145638082,
0.0013596278,
0.0594526082,
-0.0157982167,
0.0306907352,
-0.0689226538,
-0.0272480492,
-0.0566037446,
-0.0418218151,
0.0168425646,
0.0103633013,
-0.0160765387,
-0.0221627615,
-0.0822468475,
-0.0381236002,
0.0106751053,
0.024334088,
-0.0330861658,
0.0027880566,
0.0669054762,
0.1023363397,
0.0096226148,
-0.0323701315,
-0.065238215,
0.0149785234,
-0.0790797099,
0.0148932682,
-0.0151887108,
-6.468755698e-33,
-0.0165819768,
-0.0473106876,
0.0527942516,
-0.0299974494,
0.0137739098,
-0.0238795504,
-0.0015122021,
-0.0113279326,
-0.0341445617,
-0.0192529373,
-0.0236927364,
-0.0095517915,
0.00392333,
-0.0082868654,
0.022397792,
-0.0239107553,
0.0269075036,
0.0028770794,
-0.026254857,
0.0257086288,
0.0483505875,
0.0155230509,
0.0098807327,
-0.0458446853,
0.034126915,
-0.0324191712,
-0.010064411,
0.0465740263,
-0.0080709895,
0.0601605102,
0.0033629609,
0.0405395031,
0.0268063024,
-0.0510000475,
0.0209910572,
0.0072999368,
-0.0486344956,
-0.0227834899,
0.0159452893,
-0.0278385226,
-0.0178796761,
-0.0124782585,
0.045491349,
-0.0165523272,
0.0024753716,
0.0176685769,
0.0524715446,
-0.0116092637,
0.017246522,
-0.0560952984,
-0.048147399,
0.008353631,
-0.0077313394,
-0.02310846,
-0.0149883814,
0.0807651877,
0.0002714393,
0.0204704627,
-0.0500857756,
0.0138798943,
-0.0167652275,
0.0199201088,
0.0860668272,
0.024586983,
-0.0156069566,
0.0297517963,
0.003635098,
0.0185519177,
0.0098015061,
-0.0002243634,
-0.0200982373,
0.0612428822,
0.0237005074,
0.0512065738,
0.0211394858,
0.0232088845,
-0.0169793945,
0.0896349847,
-0.0009677687,
0.0623682141,
0.0203132778,
0.0014419195,
-0.0459369868,
0.0100382892,
-0.0363741294,
0.0563407131,
-0.0677170828,
-0.0401375815,
0.045556251,
0.0214347746,
-0.052148167,
-0.0067344615,
0.0223568082,
-0.0207368173,
0.0055546961,
0.009045803,
-0.0455794446,
-0.0068244343,
-0.0163481738,
-0.0072854259,
-0.0280428845,
0.0225853622,
0.0142986234,
0.0160026848,
-0.009905302,
0.0020729054,
-0.0357027538,
-0.0086348085,
-0.0266921874,
0.02064755,
-0.0295090526,
0.0296839308,
-0.0507237874,
-0.04481709,
0.0025966186,
0.0556183755,
-0.022002941,
0.0337158553,
-0.0021096538,
0.0326166861,
-0.0127050886,
-0.0256743878,
0.0391316041,
0.004684777,
-0.0146146938,
0.0473790057,
-0.006137209,
0.0372772478,
-0.0120024579,
-0.0148865255,
-0.0069056237,
0.0139345638,
2.727e-7,
0.0487765335,
0.0140108122,
0.0129431291,
0.0427954756,
-0.0232712552,
0.026221171,
0.0194980428,
0.0258665551,
0.0494665131,
-0.0305695496,
0.0099554118,
0.0101298839,
0.018437067,
0.0372280218,
-0.073123984,
-0.0528490022,
-0.0486431345,
-0.0243020821,
-0.0430524498,
-0.0255721491,
0.0954161286,
0.0351151079,
-0.0090862084,
-0.0470294058,
-0.0523999371,
-0.079685986,
0.0752279907,
0.0221074689,
-0.0373995975,
0.0625085756,
0.0766441599,
0.019102443,
0.0018146746,
0.0198939443,
-0.0075848489,
0.0300956164,
0.0605535358,
0.0141282482,
-0.0017757559,
-0.0827474296,
-0.0195688121,
-0.0362405553,
0.0192571301,
-0.0538271628,
0.0616224147,
-0.0142856706,
-0.0044409996,
0.0022762392,
-0.0526094958,
0.0090863528,
0.0019590552,
-0.044717446,
-0.0143858623,
0.0080498187,
-0.0180887766,
0.0116175888,
-0.0016950961,
-0.0321699902,
-0.0079145096,
0.0177841112,
-0.0665044636,
-0.0383356102,
-0.0272838008,
0.034212403,
-0.0286388062,
-0.0416430309,
0.0287111383,
2.216525464e-34,
0.0206172969,
0.0225616563,
0.0086811222,
0.0359855033,
0.0295006074,
0.0207424499,
-0.0306674317,
0.0250212289,
0.0093837567,
-0.0879107714,
-0.0057120598
] |
Subsets and Splits