id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17534v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17534v2 | Retrieval-style In-Context Learning for Few-shot Hierarchical Text Classification | 2024-06-25T13:19:41 | 2024-06-29T09:24:33 | Huiyao Chen, Yu Zhao, Zulong Chen, Mengjia Wang, Liangyue Li, Meishan Zhang, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Hierarchical text classification (HTC) is an important task with broad
applications, while few-shot HTC has gained increasing interest recently. While
in-context learning (ICL) with large language models (LLMs) has achieved
significant success in few-shot learning, it is not as effective for HTC
because of the expansive hierarchical label sets and extremely-ambiguous
labels. In this work, we introduce the first ICL-based framework with LLM for
few-shot HTC. We exploit a retrieval database to identify relevant
demonstrations, and an iterative policy to manage multi-layer hierarchical
labels. Particularly, we equip the retrieval database with HTC label-aware
representations for the input texts, which is achieved by continual training on
a pretrained language model with masked language modeling (MLM), layer-wise
classification (CLS, specifically for HTC), and a novel divergent contrastive
learning (DCL, mainly for adjacent semantically-similar labels) objective.
Experimental results on three benchmark datasets demonstrate superior
performance of our method, and we can achieve state-of-the-art results in
few-shot HTC. | [
0.0037757475,
0.0372716002,
0.0120017324,
0.0277444888,
-0.0395280458,
0.0222652759,
0.0349032208,
0.0351005346,
0.0344475806,
-0.0887200981,
-0.0456431322,
-0.0410074256,
-0.0348576866,
-0.0247180052,
-0.0073823198,
-0.0679772198,
0.0226525534,
0.0056857537,
0.0073357993,
0.0135517903,
-0.0020766726,
0.0096413027,
0.0313159712,
-0.0111352159,
0.024040252,
-0.0311298165,
0.004042686,
0.0166102424,
0.0355337821,
-0.0600397587,
0.0542380735,
0.0234511923,
0.0711079985,
0.0289069135,
0.0000020165,
-0.0498297401,
-0.0244944859,
0.0024862844,
-0.0262279715,
-0.0041302238,
0.1118495911,
-0.017830668,
0.0299005136,
-0.0000558525,
-0.0115155447,
-0.0449764878,
-0.0083403103,
0.0479490906,
0.0230779927,
0.0669069812,
-0.0166481733,
-0.0614565723,
0.0015861822,
-0.0269558188,
0.0104030119,
-0.0509232804,
0.0411097445,
-0.0429124162,
0.002455079,
0.0756494179,
0.0086375251,
0.0463859662,
0.026748443,
0.0316461287,
0.0045756814,
0.0308916587,
0.0004268762,
0.0212241337,
0.0087658027,
0.0300209615,
-0.0274167713,
-0.0670079514,
0.0062059043,
-0.0345374942,
-0.0146831917,
-0.0342918076,
-0.0312393755,
0.0250862408,
-0.0045252419,
0.0189865921,
0.0393626243,
0.0496606231,
0.0198999979,
0.0142060909,
-0.0031749117,
-0.0278424006,
-0.0076858583,
-0.0475559644,
-0.0171788577,
-0.0247358643,
0.0208534002,
-0.0324494168,
-0.0060306424,
0.015435976,
-0.0391061716,
0.0217580218,
-0.0333438665,
-0.0607182905,
0.0413413756,
-0.0593873002,
0.0129844304,
0.0041091125,
-0.016512474,
0.0662628263,
0.0150319813,
0.0058074985,
-0.0130544985,
-0.0008339157,
-0.0288644973,
-0.0118790474,
-0.0656049624,
-0.0197609141,
-0.0484352149,
0.0356266834,
-0.0248980541,
0.0102743525,
-0.014573697,
0.0163219068,
-0.0277228318,
0.01033941,
-0.0417598486,
0.0096087204,
-0.0362462811,
-0.0133074373,
0.0291386787,
0.0083188452,
0.0068334881,
0.0056120134,
-0.0088956105,
0.0094567807,
-0.0112694958,
0.0422245041,
0.0245224331,
-0.0224991757,
0.0320884325,
0.037146192,
-0.0289548971,
-0.0883730873,
-0.040602386,
0.0060662436,
-0.0128111662,
-0.0367272757,
0.0003574613,
-0.0463158675,
0.000077419,
-0.0217578802,
-0.0008786207,
-0.0272070095,
-0.0116913123,
0.0513101369,
-0.0090151988,
0.0483810976,
0.0114262784,
-0.0521922819,
0.0832430273,
0.0243488718,
-0.0220006742,
0.0453346483,
-0.0113777956,
0.0206289291,
0.0286387615,
0.0329031758,
0.0288997348,
0.0184603464,
0.0366239287,
0.0174427051,
-0.0595889986,
0.0234007407,
-0.0086668581,
0.0139848078,
-0.0048943385,
0.0119817248,
-0.0311261937,
0.001446027,
0.032605812,
0.0413152017,
0.0095045706,
-0.0386267081,
0.0133122867,
0.0344029851,
-0.0213888418,
-0.0302778855,
-0.0178065989,
0.0156209618,
-0.029955456,
-0.0114370417,
0.0135510759,
-0.0352200568,
-0.0338028334,
-0.0287617594,
-0.0057869246,
0.006050651,
-0.0270055886,
0.02241336,
0.067158334,
0.0137843378,
-0.0377074741,
0.0012531739,
0.035020519,
0.0125420671,
0.0058363881,
-0.037436422,
-0.0049617444,
0.0354743078,
0.0257332847,
-0.0484772697,
0.0081971595,
-0.022282254,
0.0595877953,
0.0229360592,
-0.0207988601,
-0.0290182885,
0.0197683889,
-0.0191599391,
-0.0270007439,
-0.0265832357,
0.0312282387,
0.0021070053,
-0.0259834304,
0.0154948551,
0.0269553624,
-0.0075514442,
0.0094063506,
0.0398999378,
-0.0275680162,
-0.0326224603,
0.0535440929,
0.0160497203,
0.0371033363,
-0.0031750132,
-0.0412066802,
-0.0204601213,
0.0209094826,
-0.035369195,
-0.0260161366,
-0.0621008873,
-0.0215488728,
-0.1117955446,
0.0023894229,
0.0145385005,
-0.0037805494,
-0.0036759337,
-0.0588859878,
-0.0142912278,
-0.0294529907,
-0.0087290127,
0.0344819129,
-0.0469822474,
0.0056089954,
-0.0091681704,
-0.0272569992,
-0.064387545,
0.0991394594,
0.0123531045,
0.0177155714,
0.0088948393,
0.0392268598,
0.0308947153,
-0.0143096941,
-0.028398646,
0.0083513865,
-0.02235879,
0.0208545197,
0.0222781785,
0.0436329506,
-0.0361287408,
0.0135669354,
-0.0716025084,
0.0034265921,
-0.051164791,
-0.007175169,
-0.0013845335,
-0.0316237062,
0.0063593085,
-0.0339878425,
-0.0128465388,
-0.0232194085,
-0.0092178173,
0.0190646071,
0.021564357,
0.012039151,
0.0012484891,
-0.0061684074,
-0.002497301,
0.0128416875,
0.0761531889,
-0.0359967165,
-0.0187641047,
-0.0141927237,
0.0073356363,
0.0014163693,
0.0142800799,
-0.0197891258,
0.0285026059,
-0.0047638402,
-0.0000149312,
-0.0281478893,
0.047520306,
0.0087007815,
0.0437254049,
0.0120889712,
0.0184174869,
-0.0559727326,
0.0169963427,
-0.014189939,
0.0076004313,
-0.0178407319,
0.0133690238,
0.0233170763,
0.0445171259,
0.0192017853,
0.0160068125,
-0.0416502245,
-0.0145840384,
-0.0061357198,
-0.0100248689,
-0.0802194327,
0.0109914644,
-0.0071512843,
0.0100322934,
-0.0073967082,
-0.0286745895,
0.0538864024,
0.0051708878,
-0.0009369319,
-0.0363024324,
-0.0478085056,
-0.0431571268,
0.067071341,
-0.0067367149,
0.0253318809,
0.0166823827,
-0.0180219375,
-0.0325926393,
-0.0061129914,
0.0007050209,
-0.0231147055,
0.0107640019,
0.0012232749,
0.0243503954,
-0.0154750356,
-0.066790171,
-0.0171295274,
-0.0707204342,
-0.0033367809,
0.0296482723,
-0.0347969905,
0.0311664585,
-0.04857108,
-0.0080337431,
0.0302254613,
0.0875580683,
0.0139132161,
-0.0405975468,
0.0056639598,
0.0382055491,
0.0361488387,
-0.0462822244,
-0.0190361496,
-0.0161725879,
0.0289583448,
0.0416649655,
0.0340907797,
0.0030990252,
-0.0052427999,
0.0099306153,
0.0204043984,
-0.0121080782,
-0.0007399562,
0.0409216471,
-0.0000099458,
-0.0635239258,
-0.0153379329,
0.0712647438,
0.0188189857,
-0.0748606622,
-0.0194567796,
0.0057723192,
0.0087126624,
0.0056048818,
0.0207789708,
-0.0869687125,
-0.0295585189,
-0.0131288953,
0.0247194562,
-0.0058796937,
0.0055092522,
0.0075654811,
-0.0968012214,
0.0402855314,
0.011790487,
-0.05688278,
0.0018351733,
-0.0554401539,
-0.0139046479,
0.009374951,
0.002878862,
0.0029494953,
-0.0162479486,
-0.0414402261,
-0.0035131474,
0.0200373791,
-0.0739754885,
0.0558940656,
0.0006980819,
-0.0054309219,
0.0068880869,
0.0128984051,
-0.0028959729,
-0.0102793723,
0.0104325861,
-0.0513429642,
-0.0037228961,
-0.0319008231,
0.0236048065,
-0.0419751033,
0.0094916513,
-0.0159835983,
0.019905569,
-0.0334378965,
-0.0415810421,
-0.0046356265,
0.0635228157,
-0.0329081416,
-0.0092258388,
-0.0443136431,
-0.0370222554,
0.0321536474,
0.0548711345,
-0.0207243618,
-0.0540662222,
-0.0070961504,
0.0029043066,
0.0247005448,
-0.0174484774,
0.0395991392,
0.043433506,
-0.0452861413,
0.0025274518,
-0.0336017571,
-0.0240651127,
0.005103495,
0.0289172959,
-0.0495227054,
0.0149765257,
-0.0276022609,
-0.0194760691,
-0.0410569049,
0.0109388027,
-0.0239778589,
0.013614581,
-0.0273076519,
0.0083012246,
0.0855148137,
-0.0293477364,
-0.052281253,
0.0111558316,
-0.0521325357,
-0.0406792611,
-0.0160623249,
0.0331833549,
-0.0044505824,
0.0500979498,
0.0285519939,
-0.0788642541,
0.0927355587,
0.0634128451,
-0.0058657555,
-0.0008221692,
0.0229058117,
0.0148596382,
-0.0394314229,
0.0313509777,
-0.0686847493,
0.0367420428,
0.0443052202,
0.0208887309,
-0.0432555303,
0.0111958506,
0.0114990091,
-0.0630066767,
0.0787538067,
-0.0338473618,
-0.0524048246,
-0.0138077913,
0.0352938958,
-0.0033612659,
-0.0514672995,
-0.0152134504,
-0.0007126696,
0.0025739097,
-0.0311715491,
-0.050413236,
0.0466549732,
0.0158801433,
0.0819967389,
-0.0025121707,
-0.0070167743,
-0.0080219442,
0.0131848985,
0.0112728411,
0.0368129387,
-0.0483577326,
0.0049054204,
0.0056688921,
0.0246526077,
-0.0197819564,
0.052463498,
0.0442573018,
0.0001556591,
-0.0531558059,
0.0140369637,
-0.0304510929,
0.0286800861,
-0.0463482216,
-0.049557656,
0.0867305398,
-0.0005583327,
-0.014239816,
-0.0166734923,
-0.0212660953,
-0.0233174134,
0.0035140838,
-0.0262312219,
-0.0636024848,
0.0188926216,
0.0219400655,
-0.0140631562,
0.0515689664,
0.0436006449,
0.0571723245,
-0.0096549839,
0.045437552,
0.0236400608,
-0.0240035281,
0.0173799247,
0.0863338783,
0.1032552123,
0.0256644599,
-0.0128120091,
-0.0342371278,
-0.0264986977,
0.0500452034,
-0.0334159061,
-0.0565403402,
0.0046929861,
0.0293587185,
0.0454966016,
0.025331689,
-0.0382480025,
-0.0118021322,
-0.0183930416,
0.0415995903,
-0.0239380952,
-0.0440881923,
-6.201101512e-33,
0.0121511566,
-0.0371826366,
0.0223406535,
-0.0191475004,
0.0075332788,
0.0010280149,
-0.0293287579,
-0.0297842976,
-0.0127101308,
0.0191925615,
-0.0098149609,
0.0039453837,
-0.0061311251,
0.0772847682,
0.0228158366,
0.004901927,
0.0459843688,
-0.0054782825,
-0.0049021249,
0.034040615,
0.0273254439,
0.0476340726,
0.0631420091,
-0.0771855786,
0.0097769666,
-0.0208009221,
0.0004148401,
0.0308708008,
0.014108343,
0.044478327,
-0.0160256568,
0.0504988059,
0.0533496663,
-0.0257834774,
0.0101061603,
0.0269177891,
-0.0655165911,
-0.0306746829,
-0.0445542969,
-0.0106387585,
0.0015141653,
0.0006414637,
0.0237316824,
0.0022369316,
-0.0088885175,
-0.0478309244,
0.0411316045,
0.0111459009,
-0.0272265021,
-0.0882208943,
-0.0329372026,
0.045340687,
0.0192091856,
0.0058475486,
0.0197066776,
0.0222964957,
0.0090656588,
0.0858053714,
-0.1175171956,
-0.0299195182,
-0.0366401784,
-0.0066478644,
0.0108371433,
0.0388452932,
0.0059146788,
0.0489707254,
0.0175388735,
0.0696809888,
0.0106035694,
-0.044260107,
0.0387926102,
0.0213722885,
0.017517481,
0.0661662817,
0.0744102672,
0.0079807555,
-0.0795602053,
0.0015199578,
-0.042450171,
0.0150688197,
0.0064204447,
0.0565595403,
-0.0498159751,
-0.0212161653,
-0.0357925259,
0.0075366898,
-0.0356485359,
-0.0235688351,
0.0336333402,
0.0410729758,
0.0095973313,
0.0212627761,
0.0633280501,
-0.0194051024,
-0.0530472174,
0.0224098172,
0.0028746726,
0.0527871512,
0.0162098967,
0.0174927674,
-0.0422133133,
-0.0528019033,
-0.0028877044,
0.0053025559,
-0.0100594331,
-0.0186124817,
0.0586103424,
0.0179659985,
-0.0786046609,
0.016744731,
0.0295428336,
-0.0255822167,
0.0072509688,
0.0334746204,
0.0037864931,
0.0343931578,
0.0278344173,
0.1051024273,
0.0424332246,
-0.052807454,
0.0025211433,
0.0151763847,
-0.0366099365,
-0.0189487804,
0.0197860282,
0.0059593953,
-0.0042991131,
0.0300834104,
0.0425877869,
-0.0556872599,
0.0250183176,
0.0160499755,
2.718e-7,
0.0225914568,
0.0415834785,
-0.0341881961,
0.0006602161,
0.0415891632,
0.0538790673,
-0.0072609605,
0.0196769927,
-0.0001439312,
0.0051489971,
0.0265691131,
-0.0162696559,
0.0483406074,
0.0355343111,
-0.0765509456,
0.0027507967,
-0.0847285166,
-0.0363534875,
-0.0603162609,
0.0129096182,
0.0922975391,
0.1083523557,
0.0424202085,
-0.0076268567,
0.0002157054,
-0.0534759201,
0.0918001905,
-0.0088961506,
0.0203784071,
0.0115921041,
-0.0538572222,
0.0343854502,
-0.0139483809,
0.0082599418,
-0.0367319435,
0.053463228,
-0.0140443118,
0.0678113773,
-0.0162123628,
-0.0361236855,
0.0208584778,
0.0180789828,
-0.0193208288,
-0.0593232028,
0.0607920773,
-0.1313437074,
0.0029980589,
-0.0015645048,
-0.0304233916,
-0.0319642127,
0.0201649759,
0.0112468898,
-0.012430504,
0.0134467157,
0.0012871531,
0.0253613088,
-0.0239148214,
-0.1309320629,
0.0048393239,
0.0637538955,
-0.051184386,
0.0345649794,
-0.0100575425,
0.0491406992,
0.0235662758,
-0.0374268442,
0.030023925,
2.270237979e-34,
0.0164528973,
-0.0319727398,
-0.0429704152,
0.0193219576,
-0.0081360526,
0.0107556302,
-0.040377602,
0.0226305891,
0.0456055701,
-0.0782336295,
0.0331571549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17532v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17532v1 | Can Large Language Models Understand DL-Lite Ontologies? An Empirical Study | 2024-06-25T13:16:34 | 2024-06-25T13:16:34 | Keyu Wang, Guilin Qi, Jiaqi Li, Songlin Zhai | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LO | Large language models (LLMs) have shown significant achievements in solving a
wide range of tasks. Recently, LLMs' capability to store, retrieve and infer
with symbolic knowledge has drawn a great deal of attention, showing their
potential to understand structured information. However, it is not yet known
whether LLMs can understand Description Logic (DL) ontologies. In this work, we
empirically analyze the LLMs' capability of understanding DL-Lite ontologies
covering 6 representative tasks from syntactic and semantic aspects. With
extensive experiments, we demonstrate both the effectiveness and limitations of
LLMs in understanding DL-Lite ontologies. We find that LLMs can understand
formal syntax and model-theoretic semantics of concepts and roles. However,
LLMs struggle with understanding TBox NI transitivity and handling ontologies
with large ABoxes. We hope that our experiments and analyses provide more
insights into LLMs and inspire to build more faithful knowledge engineering
solutions. | [
0.0183971766,
0.0540046133,
-0.0382768214,
0.1089994088,
-0.0342944153,
-0.0083855148,
-0.0447046831,
0.0119850226,
-0.0109123047,
-0.0786575302,
-0.0382887907,
-0.0358168818,
-0.0316183567,
0.0605385602,
-0.0197697282,
-0.0121509796,
0.0185902044,
-0.0271136947,
-0.0381585918,
-0.0073249666,
-0.0303823464,
0.0285606682,
0.0130431438,
-0.0090257553,
0.0114953164,
-0.0070172185,
0.0039651385,
-0.0101502081,
-0.0006918943,
-0.0131065166,
-0.0489782169,
0.0155305956,
0.0254515465,
0.0320962109,
0.0000020915,
-0.0765312016,
-0.0101984963,
0.0207322668,
-0.0147518758,
-0.0057255947,
0.0606952235,
0.0002964908,
-0.0054732901,
-0.0329450667,
-0.0081162062,
-0.0152468886,
0.0253468528,
0.0253395233,
0.0061119683,
0.0181306843,
-0.0040844553,
-0.0436438173,
0.0132309357,
0.016418349,
0.0563599393,
0.001012988,
0.0315312594,
0.0508952104,
0.0594833307,
0.0038619181,
0.0129851056,
0.0237980988,
-0.0049030753,
-0.0017439254,
-0.0085136406,
0.0063896477,
0.0101233134,
0.0068114549,
0.0244368259,
0.0172949228,
0.0513861962,
0.0214899555,
-0.0016907089,
0.0179906618,
-0.0145747541,
0.0071785711,
0.0079186922,
0.0691599026,
-0.0211303607,
0.0022571657,
0.0445251837,
0.0279803183,
0.0548947118,
0.0131416367,
-0.0659996569,
0.1159261987,
0.002689831,
0.0231011324,
-0.0226993747,
-0.023052603,
-0.0056348937,
-0.0275003295,
-0.0182372387,
0.0276554357,
-0.0180741251,
0.0673413426,
0.0078891162,
0.0065690433,
0.0258676521,
-0.0478021391,
0.0528344847,
0.0288651213,
-0.0313251317,
0.0350135006,
-0.0145181017,
0.0323732533,
-0.0277095288,
0.0461193435,
-0.0390269831,
-0.0390494876,
-0.0713991299,
-0.0213343222,
-0.0187366363,
0.0510916822,
0.0144913346,
-0.0097057978,
-0.0027039915,
0.0377641656,
-0.0288152974,
0.0434858352,
-0.0418585315,
-0.0161784515,
0.0071171494,
-0.0144572482,
-0.0802579969,
-0.0357670486,
0.0412655585,
-0.0271904692,
-0.0098297335,
-0.0243290309,
0.0465604924,
-0.020751968,
-0.0135060502,
-0.0348185971,
0.0009275955,
0.1023067608,
0.0607920587,
0.0105007738,
-0.0089613274,
-0.0845725462,
-0.008514245,
-0.0367480405,
0.0115684951,
-0.058058925,
0.0004505481,
0.0478768609,
0.0145503953,
-0.0904983357,
0.0116176382,
-0.0378573909,
-0.0246407092,
0.0854171887,
-0.0235447474,
0.0027649917,
-0.0193918236,
0.0296281576,
-0.0029083467,
0.0389505774,
0.0175876413,
0.0214939695,
0.0194734763,
0.0231112968,
-0.0416593961,
-0.0010146038,
-0.0161135662,
0.0043678652,
-0.0676271617,
0.0479066111,
0.0014667648,
0.025513893,
0.0100486176,
0.0201200526,
0.0184254237,
0.0026661872,
0.0557025261,
0.0231405981,
0.0223718714,
0.0154789574,
0.0493519567,
0.005037358,
0.0081442185,
-0.0329057053,
-0.0455735736,
0.0227250867,
-0.032596346,
0.0170117673,
-0.0393689834,
0.0139605338,
0.0065993443,
-0.0538579226,
-0.0638400614,
-0.0133853182,
-0.0445015505,
0.0344381295,
0.0615161732,
-0.0039077988,
0.0522345863,
0.1192201674,
0.0379892662,
-0.0181868002,
0.0126511604,
-0.0350652784,
0.0178872589,
0.0598282032,
0.0210789368,
-0.074272491,
-0.0573838539,
0.0097808754,
-0.0655790791,
0.0468543097,
0.0454764888,
-0.0119620208,
-0.0379327908,
0.0171869844,
-0.0193925612,
-0.0363831967,
0.0324641168,
0.0344250724,
-0.0084201209,
-0.003064506,
0.0221023336,
-0.0915690064,
-0.0009714548,
-0.014092505,
-0.0031831572,
0.0121648638,
-0.0279662423,
0.0168462601,
0.0508695804,
0.0125661101,
-0.0118647572,
0.0226417333,
0.0385502018,
-0.0331384949,
-0.0612000488,
0.0437128879,
-0.0288771074,
0.0353441685,
0.040777389,
0.0285473652,
0.0082271295,
0.0290940721,
-0.0137095135,
0.0079595717,
0.0300122313,
0.0161186885,
0.0347257629,
-0.035465207,
0.0033478439,
-0.0234762039,
-0.040247988,
-0.0107870447,
0.0524833798,
0.0075436844,
0.0063830032,
0.0028079038,
-0.0427663624,
0.0196715351,
0.0068941396,
-0.0199360065,
0.019573763,
0.005257613,
0.0319019482,
0.003944682,
-0.0154802073,
-0.0008815613,
0.0158976391,
0.0048812344,
0.010080386,
0.0242016595,
0.0354870744,
0.0449547544,
0.0029214933,
0.0035616898,
0.0398190282,
-0.0277285427,
0.0154466666,
0.0031254636,
-0.0143477675,
0.0478406362,
0.0065518399,
-0.0579965897,
0.0232706442,
0.0163507666,
-0.0411763377,
0.0520028509,
-0.04438705,
0.008070997,
-0.0321831368,
0.0117014861,
-0.0898251459,
0.0157448296,
0.009956548,
0.0253455248,
-0.0331132784,
-0.0362171307,
-0.0257442985,
0.0196624324,
-0.0171759203,
0.0367615111,
0.0911179781,
-0.0132108703,
-0.0204204395,
-0.0289716478,
0.0179390106,
-0.0055830474,
-0.0769857392,
-0.0306500308,
-0.0162039474,
0.067065537,
-0.019242106,
-0.0167747252,
-0.0231295414,
0.0100833485,
-0.0599102378,
0.0188220367,
-0.0441417769,
0.0090981731,
0.0137641421,
0.0693670809,
0.0065197791,
0.0031947766,
0.0328522064,
-0.0214926731,
0.0263312384,
0.0090578776,
0.016570393,
-0.073322989,
0.1478990018,
-0.0078880619,
0.0617573522,
0.0751679614,
-0.0286353882,
-0.0041007539,
-0.0422295444,
0.0271607153,
-0.0116796605,
0.0289533846,
-0.0518926457,
0.038075082,
-0.0129295699,
0.0044652862,
-0.0330585465,
0.0326548852,
-0.0620990135,
0.061752554,
-0.0367161892,
-0.0147429779,
-0.0177558791,
-0.0063882559,
-0.0241585076,
-0.0159658827,
0.0434656702,
-0.0131472005,
-0.045783069,
-0.0053576035,
0.0179589763,
-0.0126229944,
-0.0074542016,
0.0156980455,
0.0161239263,
0.0235563908,
-0.0415572934,
-0.025648348,
-0.0055372179,
-0.009404148,
0.039928712,
-0.073810041,
-0.0350313187,
0.0133163389,
-0.0164600071,
-0.0747211501,
-0.0133503191,
0.1060737967,
0.0592149124,
0.0185463037,
0.0408892147,
-0.0193511993,
-0.0439233631,
0.0241257288,
0.0282660704,
-0.1169722527,
-0.0163875408,
-0.0064016972,
-0.0529971756,
0.0165078416,
-0.0242554117,
-0.0146091152,
-0.0533471853,
0.0276981574,
0.0037927018,
-0.0270394851,
-0.0059227874,
0.0058517894,
0.0208216161,
-0.0290866178,
-0.0082769264,
0.0138368011,
-0.0247784033,
-0.0374949947,
-0.028209744,
0.0272132531,
0.0001535605,
0.1008357927,
-0.0160376821,
0.0066456022,
0.0115669919,
0.0421851501,
-0.014816531,
-0.01826014,
-0.0064978637,
0.0224178992,
-0.0016228058,
-0.0035434153,
-0.0149092097,
0.0005994791,
0.0039267945,
-0.0159879401,
0.0214252304,
-0.0778280348,
0.0043033566,
-0.0248865187,
0.0774321556,
-0.0415721387,
-0.0169430282,
-0.0006428013,
-0.0293983109,
-0.0334091634,
0.0635978952,
-0.0316604972,
0.0072481157,
-0.0018562842,
-0.0414349362,
-0.0954598039,
0.0133779934,
-0.0332907625,
0.0303432383,
-0.0171355885,
-0.0204517934,
-0.0204658117,
0.0096875308,
-0.0051923632,
-0.0475336388,
0.0064780302,
0.0074997591,
0.0142614031,
-0.0115861744,
-0.0576075129,
0.0102847153,
-0.0801763088,
0.0670776218,
0.0059632515,
0.0017160535,
0.0413125753,
-0.0305250734,
-0.0319255367,
-0.0616685152,
-0.0344809033,
-0.0376788117,
0.0032633247,
-0.0009990266,
0.0245144758,
0.0158745367,
-0.0148743354,
0.0153465923,
0.0209761783,
0.0169267766,
-0.0352933258,
-0.0306262802,
0.0348975249,
0.0179788712,
0.0214344766,
0.0857379511,
-0.0452960581,
0.0232943855,
-0.0007406895,
-0.0111671127,
-0.0214160755,
-0.0394894555,
0.0367492363,
0.0468568206,
-0.0422293767,
0.0172893535,
-0.0480074398,
-0.0092536286,
0.0237604212,
-0.0625172704,
-0.0632683784,
-0.0193201546,
0.0196229126,
-0.0123797609,
0.0017683037,
0.0073399013,
-0.0136270244,
-0.0136964228,
0.042505119,
0.0064510689,
0.0091220345,
-0.0010953108,
-0.0500638969,
0.0529238284,
0.0079125622,
-0.0027751795,
0.001501276,
-0.0253623091,
0.0343395844,
-0.052428972,
0.0161256194,
0.0038091096,
-0.0129899029,
-0.0625084192,
0.0192845054,
-0.0103638591,
-0.086217925,
0.0319821723,
0.0269959066,
0.0786778331,
-0.0018667208,
0.0251764841,
-0.1055133045,
0.0032085003,
0.0118394494,
0.018665703,
0.0164832305,
-0.0270678736,
0.0227233022,
0.0114029367,
0.0059830952,
-0.0264960974,
0.0612358376,
0.0235066991,
0.042755425,
0.0185393319,
-0.0534365065,
-0.0495957881,
0.0073287063,
0.0566246547,
0.0128603559,
-0.0669759065,
0.008702972,
-0.0728799105,
-0.0518386476,
0.0457571596,
0.0048122425,
-0.0169945974,
-0.047161527,
0.0179909393,
0.0268556736,
0.0630528703,
-0.0560005307,
-0.0542254113,
-0.0325336419,
-0.0372656509,
0.033123523,
0.0503010154,
-5.722695882e-33,
-0.0340057425,
-0.0205501691,
0.0152356578,
0.0041632284,
-0.0169087388,
0.0036889093,
-0.0306348372,
-0.0170272719,
-0.0053211218,
0.0128049152,
0.0299880393,
-0.0001581238,
-0.0051412918,
-0.0057876697,
0.0418698378,
-0.0054667788,
0.0100734271,
0.0209452324,
0.0231121741,
-0.0091913277,
0.0660687611,
-0.0297018941,
0.016420519,
-0.0061420561,
0.0636194572,
0.005378169,
0.0111294026,
0.0215111058,
-0.0441238917,
0.0439986847,
-0.0069234585,
0.0523823574,
0.0148062697,
0.0129507333,
-0.0118291331,
-0.0605742112,
-0.0564019643,
0.0079059275,
0.0352580585,
0.0102253258,
0.0212226231,
-0.0355532542,
0.0214754995,
0.014688679,
0.0151169552,
-0.0322346613,
0.0159829278,
-0.0321637131,
0.0185579807,
-0.0386714637,
-0.0798340812,
0.0088624172,
0.0358335972,
-0.0296318475,
0.0360957608,
-0.0329120606,
0.0208521672,
-0.0153859537,
0.0007550453,
0.021346584,
-0.0072392453,
-0.0097226119,
0.0617142878,
0.0211415067,
0.0051997169,
0.0157090742,
-0.0420224145,
0.0346347019,
0.0271686781,
0.0540743843,
-0.0380802341,
0.0967910066,
-0.0260930583,
-0.0209337603,
0.0138510996,
0.0290461797,
-0.0445025414,
-0.0001552746,
0.0065519274,
0.0624929592,
0.0279067885,
0.030907806,
0.0000093368,
-0.0065418878,
-0.0541555472,
0.0537308007,
-0.0332695544,
-0.0379549675,
0.007329958,
-0.0479340255,
-0.0170676503,
0.0128435977,
-0.0114252623,
-0.0869989172,
-0.0413014814,
-0.02866292,
0.019472504,
-0.0121323457,
-0.0143646905,
0.0325336941,
-0.0385131203,
-0.0472522303,
-0.0257777907,
-0.0279637873,
-0.0167076383,
0.0454344153,
0.0243265573,
0.0299825501,
-0.0212276168,
0.0247861575,
-0.0652775168,
-0.0610932373,
-0.0327843465,
0.000611238,
0.0332044847,
0.0241307989,
0.0185031444,
0.0040049623,
0.0213726424,
-0.0336573124,
-0.0286310781,
0.0528502576,
-0.000984359,
0.006085624,
-0.0045671565,
-0.0233418625,
-0.0714475214,
-0.0529441535,
0.0455050804,
0.0322367661,
-0.0192504637,
-0.0364150777,
2.919e-7,
0.0526315197,
0.0105631994,
-0.0126632834,
0.1153075546,
0.0227321107,
0.0250829086,
-0.0093931695,
0.0115472451,
-0.0066550765,
-0.0310735274,
0.0142657654,
0.0272319298,
0.0029367006,
0.0577086471,
-0.0504694991,
0.0063344846,
0.0363497138,
-0.0748736113,
-0.0445308164,
0.0205621868,
0.0498286188,
0.021132933,
0.0066893087,
-0.0128017571,
-0.007742309,
-0.0713452101,
0.0442359447,
-0.0251171999,
-0.0032182925,
0.0099250842,
0.0047039804,
0.0094154524,
0.0187785178,
0.0282752085,
0.0278046336,
0.0092262104,
-0.0432251431,
0.0362524576,
-0.0527225845,
0.0231836922,
-0.0544199832,
-0.0858319178,
0.0145127028,
-0.042564217,
0.0577010848,
-0.0350212678,
-0.0465629175,
-0.0013100812,
-0.0087386416,
-0.013151072,
-0.0635725558,
0.0051732566,
-0.0050108577,
0.0055941213,
0.001426088,
-0.0230302066,
0.0042068609,
-0.0567489117,
-0.0117849465,
0.0655872002,
0.0062775081,
-0.0589837432,
0.0068489518,
-0.0123985754,
0.020623764,
-0.0628661364,
-0.0281399619,
2.721656738e-34,
0.0271946285,
0.0547547638,
-0.0028208999,
0.0244859513,
0.0484873019,
-0.0059863916,
-0.0243774056,
0.0135284429,
0.0149492482,
-0.0460522026,
0.0062478008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17526v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17526v1 | LumberChunker: Long-Form Narrative Document Segmentation | 2024-06-25T13:08:35 | 2024-06-25T13:08:35 | André V. Duarte, João Marques, Miguel Graça, Miguel Freire, Lei Li, Arlindo L. Oliveira | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, I.2 | Modern NLP tasks increasingly rely on dense retrieval methods to access
up-to-date and relevant contextual information. We are motivated by the premise
that retrieval benefits from segments that can vary in size such that a
content's semantic independence is better captured. We propose LumberChunker, a
method leveraging an LLM to dynamically segment documents, which iteratively
prompts the LLM to identify the point within a group of sequential passages
where the content begins to shift. To evaluate our method, we introduce
GutenQA, a benchmark with 3000 "needle in a haystack" type of question-answer
pairs derived from 100 public domain narrative books available on Project
Gutenberg. Our experiments show that LumberChunker not only outperforms the
most competitive baseline by 7.37% in retrieval performance (DCG@20) but also
that, when integrated into a RAG pipeline, LumberChunker proves to be more
effective than other chunking methods and competitive baselines, such as the
Gemini 1.5M Pro. Our Code and Data are available at
https://github.com/joaodsmarques/LumberChunker | [
0.0076696537,
0.0425040573,
-0.0070362971,
0.0176814012,
-0.0533641092,
-0.009605051,
-0.0033267778,
0.0156885404,
-0.0175393261,
-0.0468269289,
0.0309046619,
0.0011461193,
-0.0261371229,
0.0436186008,
-0.0242636632,
-0.0526848659,
0.0162210036,
-0.0229418296,
0.0203020312,
0.0296537075,
0.0270207394,
0.0335167348,
-0.0214118902,
-0.0251736213,
0.0039475048,
-0.0433351286,
-0.0289794132,
0.0181762557,
0.0104759168,
-0.0261590797,
0.0365286544,
-0.0120987622,
0.0250855051,
-0.0095600607,
0.000002089,
-0.0575067326,
-0.0696366951,
0.0023606406,
-0.0373525433,
-0.0069147707,
0.0376665555,
0.0040745479,
0.0192948096,
-0.011714112,
-0.0188811254,
0.0284076203,
-0.0472987965,
0.0847884789,
0.0423204713,
0.0928670764,
-0.012568851,
-0.0382826999,
0.0411309674,
0.0254218392,
0.0396598279,
-0.0167424493,
-0.0041093025,
0.0133007104,
0.0472060591,
0.0265925378,
-0.0239557009,
0.0028198848,
0.0334479026,
-0.0135859,
0.0106720245,
0.0225577187,
-0.0507537648,
0.025639886,
-0.0327891596,
0.0626453385,
0.0388985798,
-0.0101056704,
0.0234610122,
0.0112642013,
-0.0040773316,
-0.002826127,
-0.0784327388,
0.0347469933,
-0.0482500792,
0.0035313468,
0.0096192742,
0.0195130482,
-0.0079326695,
-0.0009451644,
-0.0164400321,
0.0462579951,
0.0005454218,
-0.0166911036,
-0.0031255358,
-0.0173838586,
0.0074719065,
-0.0468953699,
0.0414110646,
0.0367761478,
-0.0107567264,
0.0197790824,
-0.03779855,
0.0266550109,
0.0054516937,
-0.0043084924,
-0.0305973962,
-0.0021120277,
-0.0129927061,
0.0779677778,
-0.0099504488,
0.0072229714,
0.0121340137,
-0.010915353,
-0.0396705456,
0.0043508671,
-0.0486350134,
-0.0207560156,
-0.0410250239,
0.0488438085,
-0.0774146467,
-0.041092027,
0.0194755681,
0.0118561247,
0.0347113535,
0.0047758063,
-0.0110591063,
0.0104700448,
0.0005211881,
0.0119732199,
-0.0310370065,
0.0216686223,
-0.083218433,
-0.0146395536,
0.015901899,
-0.0249409769,
0.0028530024,
-0.0011067055,
0.0108267637,
-0.0484980643,
0.0232819468,
0.0077427733,
-0.0326651819,
-0.0372355059,
-0.0456366464,
-0.05522421,
-0.0033092869,
-0.0488179401,
-0.0017964134,
-0.0614714622,
0.0317467153,
0.0052213743,
0.0150952544,
0.0154971005,
0.0024478028,
0.0289276466,
-0.0495769009,
0.0354604088,
0.0424268581,
-0.0172318872,
0.0255378634,
0.0318052173,
0.0445676781,
0.063625358,
0.0406957716,
0.0105871139,
0.1135090441,
0.0154622123,
0.0041137664,
0.0115829334,
-0.0424354188,
-0.0120728435,
-0.0090704449,
0.0280969553,
0.0163767915,
0.0258488059,
0.0133780753,
0.0288369823,
-0.0381895192,
-0.0387318246,
0.028232323,
0.0971624106,
0.0292723347,
-0.0003573886,
0.0321649835,
0.0301233698,
0.0090078916,
0.0546829998,
-0.010435774,
-0.0169067327,
0.0151844621,
-0.0153687503,
0.0298546683,
0.0131269135,
-0.0019030769,
-0.0173847135,
-0.0236900188,
0.0261492748,
-0.0296377931,
0.0015934817,
0.013604396,
0.01116875,
-0.0422246717,
0.0409183353,
-0.0029080978,
-0.0551851839,
0.0245843679,
0.010516786,
0.0365642309,
0.0402793139,
0.0794641525,
-0.0736755729,
-0.033014223,
-0.0253872573,
0.0412762202,
0.0056663593,
0.0382888839,
-0.032945849,
0.0338524021,
-0.0305358507,
0.0090499735,
-0.039968919,
-0.0080853915,
-0.0239883624,
0.0402717926,
0.01335508,
-0.0069422745,
-0.0746564418,
0.0113065876,
0.0729242265,
-0.0550558269,
-0.030328,
-0.0120265689,
-0.0469479635,
-0.0217211712,
0.0061588665,
-0.0093324902,
-0.0250898078,
0.0614345856,
-0.0432864465,
-0.0076446212,
0.0084129088,
-0.0397582799,
-0.0478764065,
0.0253553763,
-0.0292312969,
-0.0033656924,
-0.0314996615,
-0.0332652591,
-0.0232884474,
-0.0099887531,
0.014629201,
-0.0053531975,
-0.0134041328,
0.0096277567,
0.0263489503,
-0.0064908029,
-0.0757972971,
0.0539388061,
0.028824972,
0.033838734,
-0.0413447246,
-0.0184092894,
-0.0057456791,
-0.0359268636,
0.0319330841,
0.0601996891,
-0.009607303,
-0.0436669216,
0.0238135792,
-0.0279416963,
-0.0539799966,
-0.038165804,
-0.0686834678,
0.0347625501,
-0.0260970984,
0.0234822091,
0.0173351727,
-0.0039754701,
-0.0397398807,
-0.0053196261,
-0.0454741418,
-0.0291623455,
0.0056679384,
0.0088473819,
0.0417421833,
0.0087712808,
0.0155051006,
-0.0323488377,
-0.016703479,
-0.0139101548,
0.0515119582,
0.0244718809,
0.0059301606,
-0.0661084577,
-0.0446396805,
0.0136624472,
-0.0017237173,
-0.0268405508,
0.0335173011,
-0.0005011706,
-0.0517172664,
0.080408141,
0.0640029311,
0.0152470339,
0.0108623551,
-0.0008050185,
-0.0406547785,
-0.0482609086,
0.0306756143,
-0.0105708316,
0.0524041392,
-0.0564132296,
-0.0482299104,
0.0725151375,
0.0282807816,
-0.0053280257,
-0.0051752115,
0.0188535787,
-0.0095133446,
0.0097425291,
0.0041502398,
0.0036157402,
-0.019851068,
-0.0238653198,
0.046182353,
-0.004993618,
-0.0101547968,
0.0459912233,
-0.0427663289,
-0.0282101911,
-0.0676743761,
-0.0043957392,
-0.0910277739,
0.0902321935,
0.0053886422,
-0.0195634998,
-0.0195545871,
-0.0341428369,
-0.0130653074,
0.0086407028,
0.0153203374,
-0.0075924019,
0.0447967947,
-0.0357813798,
-0.0024558629,
-0.0118225897,
-0.0015020639,
-0.0293609947,
-0.0436297804,
0.0107240556,
0.0006760213,
0.0113731623,
-0.0045381561,
-0.0232751016,
0.0115274675,
0.0096798576,
0.0503483862,
-0.0515712015,
-0.0276953503,
0.0008206429,
0.0830431655,
0.0743663311,
0.0153065408,
0.0411005691,
-0.0198598877,
0.048489932,
0.0664119646,
0.0622731224,
-0.0127843944,
0.0272298157,
0.0085130623,
0.0384642556,
-0.0969264284,
0.0138723189,
-0.0146885952,
0.0515371487,
-0.0894765705,
-0.0358913615,
0.0978565887,
0.0592139438,
-0.0167199243,
-0.0239558406,
-0.0232760292,
0.024184363,
0.0230763145,
0.0239942838,
-0.0613898411,
-0.0227144435,
-0.0033258647,
0.0390008017,
0.0122323278,
-0.0540112555,
-0.0045913309,
-0.0747387856,
0.0306036957,
-0.0205876268,
0.0116270408,
0.0532612987,
-0.0502675101,
-0.0110036721,
0.0267022084,
-0.0230801683,
0.0220604278,
-0.0685229823,
0.0002081972,
-0.0241911728,
-0.0388368815,
0.0660968721,
-0.0008575839,
-0.0277778357,
-0.024989564,
0.0221358743,
0.026190063,
-0.0118466038,
0.0298589263,
0.0653237849,
-0.0879935771,
-0.0366587415,
0.0022003904,
0.0594204776,
-0.0407870449,
0.0485712551,
-0.0101089589,
0.0413897038,
0.0163269658,
-0.0222081058,
0.053350158,
0.0333006643,
-0.0089931218,
-0.018334657,
-0.0473700501,
0.0185501445,
-0.0480641574,
0.0829159692,
-0.0029181705,
-0.0021803135,
-0.0818775967,
-0.0163175464,
0.0059787366,
-0.0268611219,
-0.0098125413,
0.0129109351,
-0.0457757376,
0.0357060134,
-0.0892522782,
-0.0440620929,
0.0075681522,
0.0526181981,
-0.0013262708,
0.0168118626,
-0.0310791358,
-0.0106424578,
-0.0670148954,
0.0174553972,
-0.0151119074,
-0.0019851986,
-0.0563148148,
0.051227238,
0.0337927006,
-0.042851463,
0.017419491,
0.0229409225,
-0.0816465914,
-0.0342518054,
0.0290031601,
-0.0439266339,
0.0089635281,
0.0636987612,
-0.0233857352,
-0.0111434385,
0.0631871,
0.0139986286,
-0.065614827,
0.0198421143,
-0.0191551335,
0.0778230876,
-0.0315114781,
0.013622757,
-0.0333297066,
0.0195034519,
-0.0333376452,
0.0463666096,
-0.0291982442,
0.003125394,
-0.0254444815,
0.0189918317,
0.0247878991,
0.0218326394,
0.0157695357,
-0.0495704114,
0.0183602273,
-0.0098016262,
-0.0208153259,
-0.0049747676,
0.0259782467,
0.0100828456,
-0.0378391668,
-0.0334370397,
0.0803576186,
-0.019324109,
0.0812318698,
-0.0617070049,
0.0213285666,
0.0386376344,
-0.0157555826,
-0.0216953792,
-0.0073667453,
0.0009720261,
-0.014123369,
-0.0279851537,
0.1039483547,
-0.0077930745,
0.0700832531,
0.0282615367,
-0.0301144514,
-0.0146251665,
-0.0005571023,
-0.108076416,
0.0379864164,
0.0187684093,
0.0258562174,
-0.0082980739,
-0.0499079265,
0.0488518029,
0.0029496381,
-0.0244485494,
-0.0083164461,
-0.0088929487,
0.0413933583,
-0.0071880128,
-0.0232900232,
0.0609316453,
-0.0428394116,
0.0519247465,
0.0141743552,
-0.0020597493,
0.018958373,
0.0419083238,
-0.0399702564,
-0.0342865586,
-0.0362941958,
0.0064488482,
0.0360247642,
0.0173825156,
-0.0162380654,
-0.0437666029,
0.0320094898,
0.0720224231,
-0.0175337885,
0.0106571643,
-0.015568139,
0.0021146126,
0.0685290694,
0.0316916816,
-0.0036054759,
-0.0584481023,
0.0295549817,
-0.0209161583,
-0.0370533988,
0.0258337203,
-6.342293077e-33,
-0.0053277067,
-0.0204992779,
0.0083935,
0.001193844,
-0.0723779649,
0.0114791011,
-0.0023024832,
-0.0332116559,
0.0230307207,
-0.0040346426,
-0.0375872143,
0.0049262014,
0.0238688756,
0.015131468,
-0.0123856133,
-0.0328030735,
0.0296568256,
0.0162048116,
-0.0688237995,
0.0100883208,
0.0468258448,
0.0602519587,
0.0234909244,
-0.0032513721,
0.0468958914,
-0.0288109872,
0.0236263685,
0.0127928453,
0.0293646958,
0.039323654,
-0.0105494643,
0.0002468306,
0.0416680649,
-0.0255812276,
0.0126557779,
0.0012287169,
-0.1186883748,
-0.0175932217,
-0.0150788287,
-0.0013089628,
-0.0238938667,
-0.0025956256,
0.0416361131,
0.0002483972,
0.0418074317,
-0.0455462597,
0.0534804165,
-0.0169105288,
-0.0103917802,
-0.0524847396,
-0.038239941,
0.0138176084,
-0.0079279486,
0.0088634361,
0.0241184924,
0.0316829644,
0.043005269,
0.0254890975,
-0.0427014418,
-0.0185150672,
-0.016852634,
0.0502734743,
-0.0241902154,
-0.0100936927,
-0.0268981047,
0.0695053563,
0.0202457141,
-0.0324399434,
-0.0108338632,
0.0340916738,
0.0053946772,
-0.0030524884,
0.0081273625,
0.0147314854,
0.0451573022,
0.0429972894,
-0.0426739082,
0.0478859432,
0.0562698133,
0.0327330269,
-0.0028409152,
0.0058263438,
-0.0226720646,
-0.0105716269,
-0.0084034819,
0.0123084662,
-0.005748027,
0.0330603942,
0.0097965142,
0.0241026692,
-0.0377170853,
0.018780224,
0.0354800671,
0.0055655707,
-0.0026533823,
0.0292992741,
-0.0415651947,
0.0369800441,
0.0074234037,
0.0222425405,
-0.0125031825,
0.0239620637,
0.0300476681,
-0.0202959795,
0.0056314543,
-0.024237331,
0.0273569468,
-0.0190946925,
-0.0723282248,
0.0047614579,
0.016905345,
0.0119372169,
-0.0413867198,
0.0427359454,
0.0209293235,
0.0133920601,
-0.0027222149,
0.0553713292,
0.0300178491,
-0.0045443359,
-0.0540591925,
-0.0276550632,
-0.0114991292,
0.0092408219,
-0.0289017074,
0.0352857932,
0.0240095723,
0.0239614882,
-0.0185618177,
-0.0757107139,
0.0109974099,
0.0527470037,
2.767e-7,
0.0139040183,
0.0389506668,
0.089251928,
-0.0114455558,
0.0095638195,
-0.0187921021,
-0.0038995449,
0.0081134085,
-0.0097726416,
-0.0509921834,
-0.0211452376,
0.0247878414,
0.0640413314,
0.063301079,
-0.1200735047,
-0.0277012829,
-0.0157112014,
-0.046511963,
-0.0843506455,
-0.0290540364,
0.0678491518,
0.0156897381,
0.0314372145,
-0.0019123059,
-0.0190503094,
-0.0383634195,
-0.0024832978,
0.0007693421,
-0.0198756438,
0.0471156761,
0.0123960851,
-0.0220572725,
-0.0148731833,
-0.0595368929,
-0.0037035728,
0.0403844342,
-0.002075932,
0.0667362139,
0.0348542444,
-0.0509670153,
-0.0152463196,
-0.0089332191,
-0.0007656995,
-0.0044459086,
0.0905878469,
0.0218587145,
0.0119341696,
0.0182334967,
-0.023016829,
-0.030589899,
-0.0241434388,
-0.0019121447,
-0.0129294014,
0.0759447888,
-0.0029204548,
-0.0095389849,
-0.00313968,
-0.0835492015,
-0.0108901709,
0.0032098042,
-0.0496858992,
0.0029917539,
-0.0064375266,
0.0312817805,
-0.0508254878,
-0.0788350925,
-0.0138951149,
3.155744073e-34,
0.0278727859,
0.0182176474,
-0.0475503318,
0.0395802781,
0.0474453233,
0.0024559351,
0.000944775,
-0.0103998315,
-0.0150184333,
-0.0745824203,
-0.0134810815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17519v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17519v1 | Entropy-Based Decoding for Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T12:59:38 | 2024-06-25T12:59:38 | Zexuan Qiu, Zijing Ou, Bin Wu, Jingjing Li, Aiwei Liu, Irwin King | cs.CL | cs.CL | Augmenting Large Language Models (LLMs) with retrieved external knowledge has
proven effective for improving the factual accuracy of generated responses.
Despite their success, retrieval-augmented LLMs still face the distractibility
issue, where the generated responses are negatively influenced by noise from
both external and internal knowledge sources. In this paper, we introduce a
novel, training-free decoding method guided by entropy considerations to
mitigate this issue. Our approach utilizes entropy-based document-parallel
ensemble decoding to prioritize low-entropy distributions from retrieved
documents, thereby enhancing the extraction of relevant information of context.
Additionally, it incorporates a contrastive decoding mechanism that contrasts
the obtained low-entropy ensemble distribution with the high-entropy
distribution derived from the model's internal knowledge across layers, which
ensures a greater emphasis on reliable external information. Extensive
experiments on open-domain question answering datasets demonstrate the
superiority of our method. | [
0.0240727998,
0.0634779632,
0.0300644543,
0.0501295403,
0.0178230237,
0.0114540635,
-0.0464665256,
0.0064191041,
-0.0166967083,
-0.0677068233,
-0.0254141781,
-0.0265893992,
-0.0044579809,
-0.0893930271,
0.0053178095,
-0.0318198241,
0.0235509612,
-0.038256675,
0.0031383387,
-0.026419878,
-0.0151666151,
0.0054058353,
-0.004258262,
0.0176975392,
0.0677631646,
-0.0457005575,
0.005395629,
0.0245861951,
0.0248629805,
0.0082035502,
0.0137697766,
0.0591193922,
0.0038434665,
0.0238502081,
0.0000017692,
-0.0360296816,
-0.0070671951,
0.017857559,
-0.0152772991,
0.0322392285,
0.0057509774,
-0.0076334295,
-0.0016888401,
0.0184286665,
-0.0232007373,
-0.0448055901,
0.0537758842,
0.0669504553,
0.043332167,
0.0360310785,
0.0129641946,
-0.0505060628,
0.0435779542,
-0.0044100583,
0.0196814872,
-0.0309207235,
0.0387279801,
-0.0075185467,
-0.0272775739,
-0.0005569842,
-0.0054748137,
0.0455376469,
0.0093946289,
0.0238088071,
0.0470975414,
0.0279890187,
0.020997243,
0.0376661085,
-0.0002278323,
0.0742435008,
0.0308998767,
-0.027347194,
-0.0259837229,
-0.0033320005,
-0.0096022701,
-0.0027558508,
-0.0523904301,
0.0381282382,
-0.0143578043,
0.0374608524,
0.0415213145,
0.0242682155,
0.0314274468,
0.0384439938,
-0.0399051942,
0.0432579406,
0.0133545073,
-0.0698511824,
-0.0044839322,
0.027277451,
-0.0103396289,
-0.0161884967,
-0.0076212897,
0.0347460508,
0.0050365785,
0.0430135876,
-0.0009241133,
-0.1008721441,
0.0178127792,
-0.0525475219,
-0.0194264036,
0.0249147173,
0.0182905551,
0.0421971567,
0.0168274008,
0.0272757225,
-0.0184423979,
0.0045994166,
-0.076479964,
-0.0332723409,
-0.01279514,
-0.0084456345,
-0.0114306053,
0.0351182111,
-0.0309340823,
-0.0177740566,
-0.0039379406,
0.0213681199,
-0.0016131103,
-0.0293800551,
0.0575049892,
0.0220643841,
-0.0321578011,
-0.0157749858,
0.0172200352,
0.0485038348,
-0.0027019808,
0.000349441,
0.0014565949,
-0.0476385355,
-0.0047897385,
-0.0084568001,
-0.006531904,
-0.0220984016,
-0.0229640715,
0.0179425683,
-0.0223206449,
-0.0183223989,
-0.0297081731,
0.0092960559,
0.0033068615,
-0.0299969036,
0.0021693239,
-0.0344327278,
0.0212311186,
0.0178703498,
0.0174380634,
-0.0333071649,
0.0099922009,
0.0149096763,
-0.0483042039,
0.0564931855,
-0.018008275,
-0.0009935199,
0.0319323428,
0.0109190699,
0.059602987,
0.1087130904,
0.0000520671,
-0.0105588036,
0.0402263626,
-0.013319849,
-0.007780435,
0.0239630453,
0.0197896697,
0.0157329701,
-0.0040829154,
0.0362938903,
0.0121755535,
-0.0012433216,
0.0749784112,
0.0352408402,
-0.0613199547,
-0.0194985867,
0.0680689216,
0.0132362423,
0.0185634829,
-0.0063331667,
-0.0223543905,
0.005521425,
0.0185634587,
0.0344277285,
-0.0196225606,
0.0226090923,
-0.030616954,
0.0344908722,
0.0840246305,
0.0240095202,
-0.0239492748,
-0.0209912304,
-0.003777564,
-0.0051317918,
-0.0245391577,
0.0765590146,
0.0511317328,
0.0255923439,
-0.0266780946,
0.0503466353,
0.0308819227,
-0.0408980697,
0.0112955198,
-0.0064846706,
0.0307419356,
0.0968768522,
0.0656443536,
-0.02557078,
-0.001516662,
-0.0042728661,
-0.034721721,
0.0330366381,
0.0111713512,
-0.0068656169,
0.0264238324,
-0.0710393265,
-0.0220130179,
0.0121613657,
0.0063009928,
0.0123150358,
0.0201502405,
-0.0098196398,
0.006297607,
-0.0227909107,
0.0003554347,
0.0275538526,
-0.0364410728,
-0.0651925579,
0.039838817,
0.0025221317,
0.0288087968,
0.0148812663,
-0.0487211756,
0.028809445,
0.0409540012,
-0.0401312336,
-0.0382214561,
-0.0074488125,
-0.0332320631,
-0.0767635182,
0.0120007871,
0.0123546934,
-0.0213341992,
0.024035573,
-0.0205887742,
-0.0259800088,
0.0242198315,
-0.0351219214,
0.0630028322,
-0.076522693,
-0.0295523386,
0.0204055533,
0.020426333,
-0.0747953579,
0.0499184057,
-0.0395096131,
0.0353342034,
0.0161608346,
-0.0052130362,
-0.00439092,
-0.0365324281,
0.0146640595,
0.0507928543,
-0.0039197612,
0.0423527434,
0.011949677,
-0.0290260464,
-0.0211372059,
-0.0172431618,
-0.067023322,
0.0134633137,
-0.0324962288,
0.0239802971,
0.0315955207,
0.0322220661,
0.0113740396,
-0.0225810409,
-0.0090763168,
0.0208594911,
-0.0079139462,
0.0201466773,
-0.0161914062,
0.0153120542,
0.0202004481,
-0.0081582246,
-0.0317506157,
0.0162075628,
0.0496746562,
-0.0435049534,
0.0524417385,
-0.0740936026,
0.0490410775,
-0.0037150623,
0.0333883725,
0.0039478601,
-0.0214512665,
-0.0129188653,
-0.0648126826,
0.030146433,
0.0581790917,
0.0189063493,
-0.0144805731,
0.044533398,
0.0022782702,
-0.062125098,
-0.0044473116,
-0.0184388328,
-0.01611601,
-0.0332481638,
-0.0443564169,
0.0180796664,
0.0457246862,
0.0242201481,
-0.0002667305,
-0.0561513603,
-0.0406938531,
-0.0316031277,
-0.0582020208,
-0.0732929781,
-0.0090968572,
-0.0137353679,
0.0058423108,
-0.0190650448,
-0.0183784701,
0.0776944086,
-0.0234585963,
-0.0100685582,
-0.0613804944,
-0.0070924284,
-0.0450932533,
0.0300608631,
-0.0129856365,
0.0048675961,
0.0076916865,
-0.0303099416,
-0.0095483968,
-0.0292575024,
0.0094846403,
-0.0530613288,
0.0476276241,
-0.0087688658,
0.0088409977,
-0.016152095,
-0.0505448356,
-0.0369772874,
-0.0695730671,
-0.0003825263,
-0.0027932285,
0.0218412131,
-0.0256746169,
-0.0081673404,
-0.0125826374,
0.0529665165,
0.0035943289,
-0.0295153204,
-0.01040217,
-0.0195741672,
0.0956397951,
0.0801355839,
0.0336723663,
0.0345995352,
-0.0255534463,
0.0235747155,
0.0743738487,
0.0790611133,
-0.0319573954,
-0.0262623373,
-0.0316190943,
0.0768493712,
-0.0171316266,
0.0277330801,
0.0030192439,
0.0143581703,
-0.0421814732,
-0.0251464788,
0.1120247617,
0.0270315204,
-0.0679693744,
-0.0298845805,
-0.0522319339,
0.0215902664,
0.000097715,
0.0239076745,
-0.0352353454,
-0.0375137888,
0.0071121939,
0.0557016507,
0.0059518828,
-0.0069892071,
0.0098760258,
-0.1204106212,
0.0318500586,
0.0131800082,
-0.0467124134,
-0.0522472486,
-0.0632349551,
-0.003690483,
-0.0159328617,
0.012312728,
0.0380648598,
-0.0104160467,
0.0111908959,
0.0235373005,
-0.0001174951,
-0.0552827343,
-0.0207637344,
-0.0195260141,
0.0320915617,
0.0887048244,
0.0010529918,
-0.0056766532,
-0.0195509363,
-0.0325623453,
-0.1393517256,
-0.0193679165,
-0.0106872348,
0.0397719741,
-0.0235111751,
0.0164949335,
-0.043936722,
-0.0015515524,
-0.0575058907,
0.0066804411,
-0.0035522059,
0.0574177131,
-0.0304321293,
-0.0178486779,
-0.0226388518,
-0.0346636437,
0.0510234609,
0.0944433585,
0.0152106062,
-0.0260200836,
-0.0235871896,
-0.0371865556,
0.0156585202,
-0.0545440353,
0.0315111205,
0.0338899083,
0.0254446156,
-0.0525861457,
-0.0696498975,
-0.0580535494,
0.0004891701,
-0.0152490269,
-0.0241853315,
0.0649074391,
0.0113996258,
0.0044535575,
-0.0376310945,
-0.0015754366,
-0.0313858613,
-0.0058970982,
-0.0125107951,
0.0080747008,
0.0409763791,
-0.0291308742,
-0.0058456627,
0.050647296,
-0.0128526026,
-0.0491092205,
0.0058556665,
0.0047196094,
0.0104205487,
0.0513742492,
-0.0299090762,
-0.085604392,
0.0536910668,
0.0286719874,
-0.0609527491,
0.0233357828,
0.0039897063,
-0.0184116811,
-0.0046137241,
0.0477598459,
-0.0678018704,
0.0057965703,
0.0185561534,
0.0521322526,
-0.0258546751,
-0.0651268065,
0.0268814676,
0.0168116111,
0.0118583404,
0.0073676747,
-0.0222372916,
-0.0142400358,
0.0287467055,
-0.0162979402,
-0.0001542939,
-0.0117938584,
0.0002418823,
0.0621173196,
-0.0406229869,
-0.0054400428,
0.0508997552,
0.0261120684,
0.005984284,
-0.0223138947,
0.0014142606,
-0.0029252397,
0.027839072,
0.0348964483,
-0.0164208822,
-0.0411731377,
0.003895855,
0.017361233,
0.0290788319,
-0.0025952642,
0.0192201287,
0.0416154303,
-0.0308991019,
-0.0067479876,
-0.0067373426,
-0.1093682349,
-0.0133877024,
-0.0157453474,
-0.027251564,
0.050879322,
0.0319521017,
0.0895929411,
-0.0260292422,
-0.0250831302,
-0.0256016701,
-0.0152633134,
0.0254274216,
0.0182217322,
0.0327409059,
0.0261755269,
-0.0090595931,
0.0115070064,
0.0877299905,
-0.0039556907,
0.0303464588,
-0.009406738,
0.0081689069,
-0.0339595005,
-0.0273544677,
-0.0288645066,
0.0472795069,
-0.0438791737,
0.0335579813,
-0.0223643649,
-0.04612213,
-0.0339535736,
0.0085041188,
-0.0327681042,
-0.0431634896,
0.0266646687,
0.0436268859,
-0.0020541307,
-0.050458096,
-0.0418712571,
0.0679174885,
-0.0865160227,
-0.0210877638,
-0.0439210273,
-6.516993578e-33,
-0.0224211924,
-0.0009632334,
0.001600631,
-0.039773766,
-0.0051235883,
0.0020941324,
-0.0303265303,
-0.0156131051,
-0.0413445048,
0.0136058582,
-0.0314107388,
0.0364614204,
0.0022061453,
0.0487507805,
-0.0151223354,
-0.0058557214,
0.0350762308,
-0.0345543362,
-0.0012151168,
0.0289547257,
0.0662885457,
0.0197803359,
0.0427524,
-0.0439279787,
0.0228527673,
-0.0321194343,
0.0164667703,
0.0183296297,
0.0030340848,
0.0329925641,
-0.0445367917,
0.0577615872,
0.0258343816,
-0.0779125243,
-0.0262753386,
0.0349699371,
-0.1025267467,
-0.0062844669,
0.0019560673,
0.0051574996,
-0.0475523807,
-0.0508281253,
0.0172503162,
0.021853786,
0.0075175506,
-0.0484508798,
0.0165022239,
-0.030926669,
-0.0143789528,
-0.0624303743,
-0.0163800418,
0.0251729675,
-0.0038648124,
0.0146573829,
0.0166141205,
0.0283035245,
-0.0151802748,
0.0474403501,
-0.0578116961,
0.0078951446,
0.0186588801,
0.0306466687,
0.03919046,
0.0374806225,
0.0011107319,
0.027035391,
-0.0044708373,
-0.0192079246,
-0.0489913002,
-0.0573154688,
-0.0171913449,
-0.0041182498,
0.021484891,
0.0505152754,
0.0563098229,
0.0138319712,
-0.0738242418,
0.0392872505,
0.0085472669,
0.0192524232,
0.0439499356,
0.022530226,
-0.0345184542,
-0.006374212,
-0.0346605368,
0.026907241,
-0.0231005382,
-0.0008516162,
0.0476906933,
0.0213166624,
-0.0102065401,
-0.0117013808,
0.0524534844,
-0.0529668629,
0.0125471698,
0.1130180508,
0.0259930622,
0.0098722419,
-0.0059644338,
0.016324399,
-0.0363866724,
0.0231214594,
0.0312819071,
0.0001772352,
-0.0530086309,
0.0422371328,
0.0071862373,
-0.0350232944,
-0.0339009203,
-0.0135940583,
-0.0217025895,
0.0209320448,
-0.0066846255,
-0.0071006538,
0.0276010539,
0.0170241855,
0.0182120167,
0.01958072,
0.0037346664,
0.0404470488,
0.0057840915,
-0.0086326711,
0.0264664851,
0.0067600138,
0.0179091617,
0.0131153753,
-0.0062886029,
-0.0203613397,
0.0362047032,
-0.0151966736,
-0.0070991013,
0.0362437665,
2.476e-7,
0.0530068092,
0.0159627981,
0.0099490779,
0.0247034263,
0.0377624221,
0.0385465361,
0.0097549921,
0.0031868375,
0.0457519628,
-0.0178927351,
-0.0135764098,
0.0388835333,
0.0647563115,
-0.0038991997,
-0.0958302915,
-0.0369814597,
-0.0097175753,
0.0000238112,
0.0040120678,
-0.0035912595,
0.0309920721,
0.1123801246,
-0.023186503,
-0.0109626213,
0.0157987364,
-0.0560840778,
0.0536388122,
-0.0272782631,
0.0033547722,
0.0353890806,
0.0506863818,
-0.0297694579,
0.0136041967,
0.0094508724,
-0.0152668906,
-0.0113440938,
0.0039240294,
0.0211477783,
-0.0004934516,
-0.063275069,
-0.0200589187,
-0.0361359976,
0.0253515206,
-0.0598421991,
0.055323001,
-0.0344958901,
-0.0408488922,
-0.0111814663,
-0.0504146703,
-0.0039038053,
-0.0083101466,
-0.0129252728,
0.0053780228,
-0.0058942903,
0.0078320811,
0.0043969671,
-0.0142430635,
-0.0582437217,
-0.0418678485,
0.0125953788,
-0.0592814535,
-0.0596235096,
-0.0035010716,
0.0098177055,
0.0221252516,
-0.082982339,
0.0317099877,
2.223016627e-34,
0.0286732502,
0.0064113559,
0.0060678506,
0.0594009236,
0.0196254086,
-0.0264601652,
-0.0331854187,
0.0097515807,
0.0198552627,
-0.1459422559,
0.0088343322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17513v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17513v2 | Benchmarking Mental State Representations in Language Models | 2024-06-25T12:51:06 | 2024-07-01T06:48:34 | Matteo Bortoletto, Constantin Ruhdorfer, Lei Shi, Andreas Bulling | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While numerous works have assessed the generative performance of language
models (LMs) on tasks requiring Theory of Mind reasoning, research into the
models' internal representation of mental states remains limited. Recent work
has used probing to demonstrate that LMs can represent beliefs of themselves
and others. However, these claims are accompanied by limited evaluation, making
it difficult to assess how mental state representations are affected by model
design and training choices. We report an extensive benchmark with various LM
types with different model sizes, fine-tuning approaches, and prompt designs to
study the robustness of mental state representations and memorisation issues
within the probes. Our results show that the quality of models' internal
representations of the beliefs of others increases with model size and, more
crucially, with fine-tuning. We are the first to study how prompt variations
impact probing performance on theory of mind tasks. We demonstrate that models'
representations are sensitive to prompt variations, even when such variations
should be beneficial. Finally, we complement previous activation editing
experiments on Theory of Mind tasks and show that it is possible to improve
models' reasoning performance by steering their activations without the need to
train any probe. | [
0.0310266297,
0.0380461104,
-0.0579912812,
0.0227733981,
-0.0615961701,
0.0020430337,
0.026003873,
-0.0133414511,
0.0147664538,
-0.0489482358,
-0.0526827425,
-0.0692201853,
0.019568,
0.0332178734,
0.06388399,
-0.0651586279,
0.0350626968,
-0.0426459163,
0.0404906273,
-0.0149076488,
-0.0336084925,
0.0162420459,
-0.0182453245,
0.0209894422,
-0.0151987886,
-0.0023029437,
-0.0295795854,
0.000114021,
0.0333057977,
-0.0464299768,
-0.0369791538,
0.0541229844,
0.0263435133,
0.0320878401,
0.000002078,
-0.0733709335,
-0.0001126609,
-0.0318721905,
-0.0090870261,
0.0028681892,
0.018028181,
-0.0174993966,
0.0162215419,
0.0036078338,
-0.0299554076,
-0.0063124448,
0.0189075489,
0.0545776151,
0.0039878986,
0.0584579036,
-0.016066689,
0.0334954262,
-0.0026445745,
-0.0379012525,
0.0312991813,
-0.0425574593,
0.027473947,
0.0026688518,
-0.0036940568,
0.0002036758,
-0.0291441735,
-0.005378061,
0.0038137932,
-0.0005415857,
-0.0282473993,
0.0202003475,
0.0225393493,
-0.0138875283,
-0.019617429,
0.041750107,
0.0686535314,
-0.0254743919,
-0.0178405419,
-0.0106590483,
0.0297021922,
0.0288442411,
-0.0013950976,
0.0446526594,
0.0089695929,
0.02183396,
0.0015617367,
0.0276765991,
0.007304349,
0.0133800413,
-0.0353311896,
0.0487363264,
0.0020652241,
-0.0283623822,
-0.0010516264,
0.0046196794,
-0.0407195538,
-0.073112905,
-0.0496929102,
0.0154275801,
-0.0034079349,
0.0203297324,
-0.0324666947,
0.0157484524,
-0.0190624781,
0.0151873147,
0.0693738163,
0.0683567673,
-0.0172292162,
0.0351737924,
-0.0225757658,
0.0646007434,
0.0024532701,
0.058873266,
-0.0041053002,
0.0159337297,
-0.0642228723,
-0.017403625,
-0.0238832198,
0.0305841845,
0.0376005135,
-0.0140134115,
-0.0216440707,
-0.0074332603,
-0.0235696789,
-0.0318523943,
-0.0634573102,
0.0264865067,
-0.0053890222,
-0.0025238195,
-0.0692784786,
0.0251643788,
-0.0561121739,
0.0324982964,
0.0458883531,
-0.0862853676,
-0.0381546691,
-0.0211580917,
0.0207287278,
0.0076418733,
-0.004090013,
0.0041202852,
-0.0014957824,
-0.0455303416,
-0.0258507095,
-0.0235879701,
0.0069778832,
-0.0710071847,
0.0267003365,
-0.0068636457,
0.0132288476,
0.0036891371,
0.0069103474,
-0.0393310748,
0.0151945325,
-0.012727634,
-0.0318561159,
0.0621131361,
0.014380197,
0.00354977,
-0.0288161654,
0.0204036385,
-0.0197963361,
0.0390124507,
0.0118336147,
-0.007874581,
-0.028814299,
0.0175107867,
0.0130510507,
-0.0105249202,
0.0165593531,
-0.0401182845,
-0.0353723317,
-0.0057527022,
0.0233265962,
0.0452396348,
0.0507989079,
0.0584257804,
-0.0314860977,
0.0117014339,
0.0670737773,
0.0690979809,
-0.0280107446,
-0.0227878671,
0.0274609774,
0.0189630017,
0.0381254554,
0.013520781,
-0.0646942928,
0.0446961522,
-0.0241974555,
-0.0262240637,
0.0199455041,
0.0150149893,
-0.0492823347,
0.0074661844,
-0.041024778,
0.0071643842,
0.0225477163,
0.0061418964,
0.0288737863,
0.0099910274,
-0.0107820621,
0.039031487,
0.0173878409,
-0.0198762976,
-0.0383224711,
-0.0755909085,
0.0091447383,
0.0177211426,
0.0310392231,
-0.0160420071,
-0.0340511911,
-0.0262772944,
-0.0221301951,
0.0663288385,
0.091569975,
0.0119043011,
-0.0293760989,
-0.0231490787,
-0.0110982815,
-0.0666102841,
0.0350546762,
0.0359828807,
-0.0204010997,
-0.0033489296,
0.0063773813,
-0.0267114416,
0.0375907421,
0.0254160687,
0.0183382705,
-0.0318834223,
-0.0679690689,
0.019008521,
0.0121955508,
-0.0069995164,
0.0054781069,
0.0121594183,
0.0055078897,
0.0055141971,
-0.0043824613,
0.0480257943,
-0.0532746837,
-0.0147849545,
0.0171482246,
0.0161280353,
-0.0291802082,
0.0194355883,
0.0024839004,
-0.0507804714,
0.0329201035,
-0.0457510017,
0.0334735103,
-0.0437281504,
0.0073426859,
-0.0299032964,
0.0006948228,
0.0067176586,
0.0777560174,
-0.0159510579,
-0.0011377056,
0.0496595092,
-0.0058213696,
0.0322041363,
-0.026745934,
0.0013688125,
-0.0101128649,
0.001376804,
-0.0266288612,
0.0003091627,
-0.0421220176,
-0.0409877785,
-0.0183773171,
-0.0824260935,
-0.0505131669,
0.0173565429,
-0.0333644003,
0.0177507829,
-0.0121675907,
-0.0164425261,
0.0126268482,
-0.0551362336,
0.0121460017,
0.038486626,
0.0300242156,
0.017405387,
-0.0327871256,
-0.0076457961,
-0.0283864699,
0.046061404,
-0.045562502,
0.0480923653,
-0.0045858626,
-0.0146046896,
-0.037401285,
0.0264784694,
-0.0777879655,
0.0227692332,
-0.0431515351,
-0.0348080918,
0.0538857281,
0.0157303456,
0.0523087718,
0.0840293542,
-0.0130146341,
0.0079987999,
0.0833617449,
0.0111952955,
-0.0652539134,
0.0195150487,
0.0331555456,
0.0074375239,
-0.0270000994,
-0.0344345979,
-0.0293681566,
0.0673214197,
0.05076598,
-0.0016956002,
-0.075427711,
0.0644995794,
-0.0085097319,
-0.0714965388,
-0.006138036,
0.0039075948,
-0.0317983627,
0.0879467353,
-0.0247692689,
-0.0674945489,
0.0952204317,
-0.0115503017,
0.0008477035,
-0.0073446119,
0.0553402714,
-0.0004132152,
0.0845300406,
0.0190304872,
0.0165625941,
0.0563005209,
0.0144104054,
-0.0824212953,
-0.0260123108,
-0.0132625494,
-0.0128266932,
-0.0203959029,
-0.0222811401,
-0.0181271806,
0.003079758,
0.002784949,
-0.0551268347,
0.0226342939,
-0.065302752,
0.0188776311,
-0.0035373643,
0.0154850939,
-0.0027980506,
-0.0133524798,
0.0401917994,
-0.0121677686,
-0.0212264843,
-0.0163606722,
-0.012172957,
-0.0169183537,
0.0376248881,
0.0007655965,
0.0481226481,
-0.0363469981,
0.0325796306,
0.0232651252,
0.0038378313,
0.0522313006,
-0.006366421,
-0.0005055408,
0.0164793804,
0.0378002673,
-0.0071002133,
0.0428959467,
0.0981471315,
-0.0168702081,
-0.0225717761,
0.1066465154,
0.0520876758,
-0.0180523172,
0.0110366391,
-0.017823942,
0.0162745006,
0.0328296497,
-0.000061336,
-0.0567463562,
0.0037803119,
0.0198218785,
-0.0255575795,
-0.0469465181,
-0.0509698242,
-0.0124869021,
-0.0851629749,
0.0103124892,
-0.0043717176,
0.0262780618,
0.00370355,
-0.0181222372,
0.0444517136,
0.05123711,
0.0182171147,
0.0270556882,
0.0177456401,
0.0169445388,
-0.0058856197,
0.0189540498,
-0.0562579669,
0.0512710176,
-0.0157911237,
0.0970801339,
0.0662578195,
0.0252733137,
0.0272947624,
-0.0885359347,
0.0211991593,
0.0706790537,
0.0489316098,
-0.0084337462,
0.0115152001,
0.0121697811,
0.0123756239,
-0.0153296655,
0.0220481213,
-0.0155822206,
-0.0241113044,
-0.042834755,
0.0549088083,
-0.0368004404,
-0.0421509631,
0.0234138761,
0.0218842439,
-0.0350534581,
0.0867056921,
0.0680455565,
-0.0437465087,
0.0079035433,
-0.033840023,
-0.0181188323,
-0.0031394777,
-0.0398528874,
-0.0137572354,
0.0697275102,
0.0030321286,
-0.0551212952,
-0.0574874952,
0.0438929759,
0.0257127974,
0.0166481901,
-0.028225109,
-0.0141705759,
0.0053609484,
-0.0017898532,
0.0318675973,
-0.0563661344,
-0.0095123434,
-0.0095906388,
-0.0314628445,
0.0264249742,
-0.0424144343,
-0.0053615146,
-0.0123111783,
-0.0503198877,
-0.0759174898,
0.0095963534,
0.051466845,
0.0319057629,
0.0056595402,
0.0055372422,
-0.0280603971,
0.0187860169,
-0.0563952252,
-0.0236370843,
0.0658406764,
0.0163477845,
0.0556914434,
0.0031650104,
0.0511872433,
0.0004156122,
0.0167823248,
0.0606143251,
0.0037145,
0.0309623238,
-0.0127995899,
0.0327900313,
0.0165450592,
0.0393848866,
0.020954242,
-0.0075803073,
-0.0258225109,
-0.0280382186,
-0.0549884103,
-0.0072578001,
-0.0290420614,
-0.0058299415,
0.0590993129,
0.0564211644,
-0.0271100365,
-0.0969398916,
-0.0116600906,
0.0257262308,
0.0060128858,
-0.0211238097,
-0.002066422,
0.0259076934,
0.0019041885,
0.0147318849,
-0.0145114018,
0.020804856,
-0.0639522448,
0.0178185143,
0.0112145646,
0.0903520435,
0.0221944172,
-0.0259935707,
-0.0473417193,
-0.0023022864,
-0.0681098849,
-0.0658945888,
0.0522110537,
-0.0161731541,
0.0127596641,
0.0037770988,
0.0003019227,
-0.0506816171,
0.0277546104,
0.0317410603,
0.0253422633,
0.0296693891,
-0.05068703,
0.0229339078,
-0.0052740239,
-0.0077606863,
-0.0178664699,
0.0482662767,
-0.0340371914,
0.0427557006,
-0.0246671773,
0.0028251142,
-0.0498975441,
0.0407124907,
-0.0391138308,
0.0614426471,
-0.0127997249,
0.0423565991,
-0.0876028612,
-0.0356877744,
0.0447586514,
0.0140947308,
0.0056757377,
-0.0186023526,
0.0374290906,
0.0611033663,
-0.0046954742,
-0.0216148477,
0.0109188594,
-0.0331449136,
0.0171782635,
-0.0083582066,
-0.0556846075,
-6.297793269e-33,
-0.0249186102,
0.0151651809,
-0.0010327382,
-0.0160664152,
-0.0197806787,
-0.0099147931,
-0.0807800591,
0.0191897154,
-0.0063944417,
0.0024830082,
-0.0267732404,
0.0068425639,
0.0006727175,
0.0066616219,
0.0180473924,
-0.0076593435,
0.0383476131,
-0.0283918306,
-0.0582949556,
-0.0229157973,
0.0293115824,
0.0092841731,
0.0343131013,
-0.0407174416,
0.0552263409,
0.0348255225,
0.004367088,
0.015316898,
-0.0651513189,
-0.0022891401,
-0.0442829058,
0.0090500889,
0.0361037105,
-0.0236064699,
-0.0317102671,
-0.0004337864,
0.0045046387,
-0.0611047149,
0.055924058,
-0.0306655932,
-0.0203967616,
-0.0504200421,
-0.0161371697,
-0.0284351334,
-0.0459279567,
0.0114288265,
0.0005186751,
0.0188417453,
0.0246611834,
0.0351166986,
-0.0675144047,
-0.0448736437,
0.0187310912,
-0.029306842,
-0.0015159479,
0.0070442925,
-0.0072509563,
-0.0303882733,
-0.051966764,
0.0036536767,
0.0422462411,
0.0045863357,
0.0423971452,
0.0056492062,
0.0258594546,
0.0777539015,
0.0525247678,
0.044162225,
-0.0547226295,
0.0010654258,
0.0490818471,
0.0147218807,
0.0539905988,
0.0102738487,
-0.000077723,
-0.0330017507,
-0.0237101596,
-0.0201404933,
0.033784952,
0.0196691435,
0.0646111891,
0.0021880069,
-0.0118115637,
-0.0155003648,
-0.0656224042,
-0.0376794711,
-0.0287359282,
-0.0151037164,
0.0235568658,
0.0204822849,
-0.0229983237,
-0.0667124316,
0.0296960641,
-0.0114532216,
0.0179755185,
-0.0210040808,
-0.0085852994,
0.0433215015,
-0.0042905062,
-0.0130566098,
-0.0669861883,
-0.0017124811,
0.0214314274,
0.0202961769,
0.0139704477,
0.0026180306,
-0.007309576,
0.0200756956,
-0.0615798794,
0.0037582074,
-0.0606601499,
0.0226422902,
-0.0017706044,
-0.0407648869,
0.0314956941,
0.04080249,
-0.0331655815,
-0.0657566935,
-0.0122425081,
-0.0627839044,
-0.0668326542,
0.0676252395,
-0.0373155847,
0.01826947,
-0.0290133208,
-0.0199626777,
-0.0295042153,
0.0086352453,
0.0420386344,
-0.0095524536,
-0.0143686123,
0.0140133118,
2.908e-7,
0.005086157,
0.0650762469,
0.001250758,
0.0148891229,
0.0296459105,
0.0389378034,
-0.0302774254,
0.0158114452,
0.0631463006,
-0.0664825737,
-0.0430382378,
0.0472266078,
0.0329606496,
0.0216687452,
-0.0650837049,
0.0365706533,
0.0206181463,
0.0069069704,
-0.0050580292,
0.0147530688,
0.0280618574,
0.03997311,
0.0345640779,
-0.0027379692,
0.0209336728,
0.016084576,
0.0683764815,
-0.0391296595,
0.0315516181,
-0.0112422723,
0.0565680712,
-0.0129572516,
0.0311272852,
0.029351145,
0.0540726893,
0.0429651886,
-0.05955863,
-0.0073908297,
-0.013102022,
-0.03775445,
-0.041280102,
0.0114292493,
-0.0264901221,
-0.0678641498,
0.0431848615,
-0.0733589455,
-0.0355971605,
0.0179611798,
0.0261677857,
0.0098594204,
0.0209532566,
0.0402664393,
-0.0300787222,
0.0191034675,
-0.0004522917,
0.016019145,
0.0131658344,
-0.068289116,
-0.0111515457,
-0.0424653962,
-0.0214114469,
-0.0519245379,
-0.0403559655,
-0.0122146402,
0.0079763215,
-0.0760901049,
-0.0097116353,
2.488340395e-34,
0.0117975883,
-0.0145078236,
0.0413687862,
-0.0014236195,
0.0523006096,
-0.0273455568,
-0.0014022546,
-0.0013329557,
0.038204316,
-0.1105789021,
-0.0217851643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17825v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17825v1 | Automatic speech recognition for the Nepali language using CNN, bidirectional LSTM and ResNet | 2024-06-25T12:14:01 | 2024-06-25T12:14:01 | Manish Dhakal, Arman Chhetri, Aman Kumar Gupta, Prabin Lamichhane, Suraj Pandey, Subarna Shakya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper presents an end-to-end deep learning model for Automatic Speech
Recognition (ASR) that transcribes Nepali speech to text. The model was trained
and tested on the OpenSLR (audio, text) dataset. The majority of the audio
dataset have silent gaps at both ends which are clipped during dataset
preprocessing for a more uniform mapping of audio frames and their
corresponding texts. Mel Frequency Cepstral Coefficients (MFCCs) are used as
audio features to feed into the model. The model having Bidirectional LSTM
paired with ResNet and one-dimensional CNN produces the best results for this
dataset out of all the models (neural networks with variations of LSTM, GRU,
CNN, and ResNet) that have been trained so far. This novel model uses
Connectionist Temporal Classification (CTC) function for loss calculation
during training and CTC beam search decoding for predicting characters as the
most likely sequence of Nepali text. On the test dataset, the character error
rate (CER) of 17.06 percent has been achieved. The source code is available at:
https://github.com/manishdhakal/ASR-Nepali-using-CNN-BiLSTM-ResNet. | [
0.0066395351,
0.0083777495,
0.0085837189,
0.0819323808,
-0.0309737101,
-0.0027062329,
-0.0120706819,
-0.0137111899,
-0.0359333418,
0.0195357837,
-0.0290470999,
-0.0566960275,
0.0467946939,
0.0283163916,
-0.0328133442,
-0.0494916886,
0.011459671,
-0.0264182631,
0.01445702,
-0.002280138,
-0.0099721057,
0.0143682463,
-0.0595333055,
0.004662165,
0.0015161961,
-0.0011029552,
-0.0107005239,
0.040690653,
0.0245186873,
-0.0594279058,
-0.0197971631,
-0.0032409201,
0.0008443099,
0.0006931685,
0.0000019847,
0.0068115373,
-0.0128366435,
-0.0288927667,
-0.0302585177,
-0.0377796143,
0.0177795719,
0.011949542,
-0.0242366213,
0.0575712062,
-0.0139613962,
-0.0016491814,
0.0516961776,
0.0587735176,
-0.0112387845,
0.0809738934,
-0.0137043772,
-0.0840151906,
0.0513658337,
0.0097715296,
0.0057999138,
-0.0124690095,
-0.0136305727,
-0.0082115903,
0.0101879509,
-0.030325735,
-0.0279762577,
0.0506291054,
0.0308195204,
-0.0037078448,
0.0070756888,
-0.0061905826,
0.0011303667,
-0.0217444338,
0.0277690496,
0.0579505265,
-0.0458335355,
-0.0292967372,
-0.0075510838,
0.0023054206,
-0.0621150732,
-0.0299457796,
0.0143839698,
0.0229072552,
-0.0073203505,
0.0227870271,
0.0102001177,
0.0310910046,
0.0119389705,
-0.0011650656,
0.0615196191,
-0.068719916,
-0.0111449435,
-0.0390975624,
-0.0002302448,
-0.0618367307,
0.0133030005,
0.038366951,
0.0398688056,
0.0197311584,
-0.0053505632,
-0.0020179837,
0.0254365578,
-0.0339155197,
-0.0072840312,
-0.0415107869,
-0.0337425023,
0.0480340719,
-0.0445451662,
-0.0155808432,
-0.0489100441,
0.0192944761,
-0.0261294786,
0.014523142,
-0.013624643,
-0.002600963,
-0.0019990494,
-0.0375396796,
0.0050176084,
0.0098199081,
0.0105592664,
0.0126040326,
-0.0551795773,
-0.0130230887,
0.0237680133,
-0.0255630687,
0.0385284908,
-0.0013974569,
-0.0706035718,
-0.0329227336,
0.0096107395,
0.0341046527,
0.0070228297,
0.0586591288,
-0.028224038,
-0.0956309587,
-0.0038244654,
0.0341813341,
0.0172194187,
-0.0017715519,
-0.0082064252,
0.0237421636,
-0.0176961143,
-0.0377602838,
-0.1044014171,
0.0207336843,
-0.0144148543,
-0.0369409844,
-0.0187564697,
-0.0628655329,
0.0230137445,
0.0195150208,
-0.0021937231,
-0.0179958753,
-0.0025213647,
-0.0014764416,
0.0405077748,
0.083951585,
0.0191891082,
0.0030055812,
0.102500692,
0.0033472432,
0.0658687502,
0.0323566832,
0.0639628693,
0.0246692803,
-0.0429565161,
-0.0319177583,
0.0433456153,
0.0321891531,
-0.0354763791,
-0.0152553953,
-0.062454965,
0.0096427379,
0.0147612076,
0.0364109389,
-0.0082500027,
0.0356657766,
0.0279744584,
0.0118431048,
0.0337633006,
0.0336750373,
0.0543937869,
0.049179174,
0.0142123895,
0.0045415503,
0.0215601139,
-0.0340904109,
0.037468832,
0.0367016047,
-0.0002044156,
-0.0019502307,
-0.0046503977,
-0.0104826391,
-0.0098914867,
0.0273096953,
-0.0026878691,
-0.0637686551,
-0.024409309,
-0.0019417477,
0.0559440441,
-0.0097200032,
-0.0665329099,
-0.0041789724,
-0.0134337004,
-0.0414824486,
0.025790859,
-0.0383566394,
0.0245613474,
0.0055327457,
0.0218334682,
-0.0514081307,
-0.0046752756,
-0.0561185293,
-0.0471818969,
0.0489366353,
0.0259555336,
0.0290562958,
-0.0122497901,
-0.0834601447,
0.029076647,
0.1050988585,
-0.0549295507,
0.0552025661,
-0.0696122944,
0.0609408617,
0.0091778683,
0.0180136878,
-0.0527674444,
0.0034423815,
-0.0098033277,
-0.0031509225,
-0.0111141736,
0.0414219834,
0.0727365986,
0.0342946239,
0.0092145577,
-0.0200734511,
0.0285367761,
-0.0135309519,
-0.0001848114,
0.034594994,
-0.0500387736,
-0.0544796064,
0.0263957996,
-0.0298411548,
0.0430783518,
0.0652413294,
0.0346056148,
-0.094618015,
0.0540606715,
0.0122318612,
0.0421887636,
-0.03277307,
0.0445192903,
0.0132881161,
0.0161919445,
0.0203534737,
-0.0113359364,
-0.0042988155,
-0.0054936442,
0.0376608074,
-0.0002656596,
0.0263198111,
-0.0781911239,
-0.058690086,
0.0637780875,
-0.017150702,
-0.0219456367,
0.0074927853,
-0.0222057886,
-0.0143771032,
-0.0153735774,
-0.0424968004,
-0.004991699,
-0.0115499152,
0.003458973,
-0.0601067729,
0.0364651978,
-0.002856564,
-0.0450085215,
-0.0047395397,
-0.0353918448,
0.011192875,
-0.0512721986,
-0.0200113337,
0.0157540776,
-0.0145677403,
-0.0164951645,
-0.0280772168,
0.0054952395,
0.0165973026,
-0.031602893,
-0.0591063611,
-0.0211911201,
0.0182654485,
0.0594974048,
0.0406795479,
-0.0130293965,
-0.0774165243,
-0.0511546209,
-0.0155140171,
0.0227369573,
0.0106641361,
0.0352330282,
-0.0298706666,
-0.0307928454,
0.0357828699,
-0.0101918019,
0.0152694257,
0.0052048406,
0.019442331,
0.0083198268,
-0.0082724597,
-0.0707855672,
0.020372767,
0.0291261859,
0.0481817313,
-0.0118866768,
-0.0872333795,
-0.0412890799,
-0.0033693437,
0.0053203851,
0.0239218194,
-0.0624045655,
0.022423394,
0.0144188013,
-0.0072994917,
0.0127357487,
-0.0467517748,
-0.0463159457,
-0.0412316397,
-0.0358954743,
-0.0433659926,
0.0117251845,
0.0011186231,
-0.0331438445,
-0.0417894945,
-0.0592299849,
-0.0345022827,
-0.0179456249,
0.014278695,
-0.0544833727,
0.0078543788,
-0.0082474397,
0.0165721383,
-0.0637600124,
0.0123728225,
-0.0148500353,
-0.038843181,
0.006429086,
0.0076323655,
-0.0015258556,
-0.0116694765,
0.0066060764,
0.0793091953,
-0.0055650077,
0.0237142388,
-0.0248731803,
0.0421591736,
-0.0235230643,
0.0839832798,
0.0241416059,
0.0142456135,
-0.0141131626,
0.0086119948,
0.0447074845,
-0.0680123195,
0.0276623648,
0.0266223662,
-0.0782216936,
-0.035134472,
0.0177793968,
0.0100692175,
0.0084840339,
0.0218432043,
0.0065182117,
-0.041947145,
0.0479520187,
0.0576503798,
0.0100745996,
-0.0628848299,
-0.0720929801,
-0.0084994063,
-0.0462507904,
-0.0317346901,
0.012842386,
-0.0449294001,
-0.0195846763,
0.0375163406,
0.0214178134,
0.022627959,
0.0072750705,
-0.031964317,
-0.0539542846,
-0.0099309068,
-0.0040233196,
-0.0276758447,
-0.0393296406,
-0.004853847,
-0.0651622564,
-0.0196781028,
0.0369638726,
0.0554235242,
-0.0457433984,
-0.0426430777,
0.0899369493,
-0.077610597,
-0.0255270042,
0.001975606,
-0.040777564,
0.0769678503,
0.0360317603,
0.017024165,
-0.0555619188,
-0.0083155762,
0.0109970383,
-0.0187600218,
0.0017375906,
0.0043358859,
-0.0064119538,
0.0040479838,
-0.0054447735,
0.049994994,
0.0301659405,
-0.0328471735,
0.013854607,
-0.0043760305,
0.0637966469,
-0.0224592742,
-0.0048389058,
-0.0015092557,
0.0179897752,
0.0212715752,
0.0477592237,
-0.0028843095,
-0.0065810042,
-0.0372534469,
0.0158293117,
0.0242203977,
-0.050353542,
-0.0051495656,
-0.0034215699,
-0.0100911837,
-0.019882489,
0.0169524848,
-0.0253031794,
0.0067213201,
-0.0018473759,
0.063320905,
0.021052964,
0.0224162508,
0.0480251163,
-0.0496463217,
0.0071616792,
-0.0177120008,
0.0539845042,
-0.0939046219,
0.0214667618,
0.0412482731,
-0.0907794237,
0.0151779409,
0.001405971,
-0.0344223231,
0.0023295158,
0.029499542,
-0.0467115864,
0.0128037436,
0.0370076522,
-0.0191472359,
-0.0523256958,
0.0604730435,
0.0283140559,
-0.0825764909,
-0.0456698462,
0.056363225,
-0.0037792346,
-0.0157926101,
0.0027474489,
-0.0199769605,
0.0288467389,
-0.0228911452,
-0.0306181256,
-0.0012061999,
0.0137746483,
-0.011569825,
-0.0046342462,
0.071217373,
-0.0286093466,
0.002293718,
-0.0621947832,
0.0245754514,
0.0236065425,
0.0524878539,
0.0105586294,
0.0172136873,
0.0616785996,
0.0529455468,
-0.0264280271,
-0.0165515337,
0.0107560912,
-0.0559835024,
0.0587527007,
0.109511815,
0.0181671344,
0.0507800616,
0.0316405818,
0.019252548,
-0.0234972294,
0.0009960028,
0.0178440027,
0.0143078007,
0.0160754025,
0.0385811292,
-0.0071661444,
0.0291738957,
0.0512690321,
0.0198157337,
0.0376923084,
0.0075184554,
-0.0168391597,
-0.023426231,
0.053967651,
-0.0064993384,
0.0137606068,
-0.011109475,
0.0407735966,
-0.0392815247,
0.0116590755,
-0.0267271847,
0.0345695578,
0.0544381104,
0.0003789896,
-0.0419697575,
0.0255674794,
0.0166284107,
-0.0168526899,
-0.0164529271,
0.0020794433,
0.0070336098,
-0.0398098305,
-0.0091770729,
-0.0344493389,
-0.0073238513,
-0.0300528407,
-0.0089470102,
0.0025713569,
-0.0499256998,
0.0514911339,
-0.0068207602,
0.0462023653,
-0.013932786,
0.0008276775,
-0.0271180216,
0.0194325019,
0.0386297219,
-0.0147183975,
-0.0121832602,
0.001251513,
0.0003257656,
-0.0327147692,
-5.621504186e-33,
0.0040758662,
0.0142683275,
-0.0153242815,
0.05669453,
-0.0213974323,
0.0066168299,
-0.0166784469,
0.0048350003,
-0.0255125891,
-0.0348827913,
-0.0365178771,
0.0155961001,
0.0406532586,
0.0162398983,
0.0300911982,
-0.0233410392,
0.0475851074,
-0.0070506232,
0.04261088,
0.0028158154,
0.0223903023,
0.0498913564,
0.0668419823,
-0.031819623,
-0.0266573112,
-0.0371335782,
-0.0015848997,
0.020955015,
0.0280238967,
0.0163151734,
-0.0392166935,
0.0373266935,
-0.0052927481,
-0.0692288429,
0.0035930665,
0.0312286802,
-0.0783210844,
0.036474891,
-0.010276976,
0.1003604308,
-0.0438711196,
-0.0221643336,
0.0285566393,
0.046047423,
-0.0591071844,
0.0222551022,
0.0234773885,
-0.0160829946,
-0.0156776942,
-0.0049140234,
-0.0084034624,
0.0501386337,
-0.0294804797,
-0.019340938,
0.0714710653,
0.0202531423,
-0.0209920146,
-0.0222951919,
-0.0914992094,
0.0238017999,
0.0041830414,
0.0336735472,
0.0418084413,
0.0482710078,
-0.0480286554,
-0.011303314,
0.0457800739,
-0.0820903331,
0.0377817191,
-0.0303616952,
0.0331976302,
-0.0087653175,
0.0246409215,
0.022094693,
0.0736238435,
-0.0755421296,
-0.0368186161,
-0.0062364093,
0.065573208,
0.0357474536,
0.0335631073,
0.0215432085,
-0.0345789865,
0.0056191538,
0.0324709266,
-0.0158102755,
-0.0297545437,
-0.0334411487,
0.053335309,
0.0017266731,
0.050836239,
0.0233919788,
0.0662589744,
-0.0278540775,
0.0641781688,
-0.0051058833,
-0.0352322757,
0.020447854,
-0.0126397964,
0.0118850917,
-0.0617300905,
-0.0566177554,
0.0244156737,
-0.0007315489,
-0.0008509971,
-0.0215580277,
0.0170858987,
0.0628130287,
-0.0249356627,
0.0087167565,
0.0070899171,
0.0302143283,
0.0194902867,
0.0448572189,
-0.0063326214,
-0.0320625938,
0.0096434867,
0.0507889204,
-0.0185633954,
0.0502319708,
-0.0132397106,
-0.0241644569,
0.0353117324,
0.0084782317,
-0.0422846712,
0.0197514072,
-0.0264916271,
0.0119520249,
0.01257178,
-0.0181169622,
0.0134577136,
0.0396017879,
2.879e-7,
-0.0149609111,
-0.0103029571,
0.0872475207,
-0.0130058993,
-0.0064906776,
-0.0203185771,
-0.0011102306,
0.0008265941,
-0.004723601,
0.0792447105,
0.0549417473,
-0.0350828618,
0.0818880275,
0.0019086075,
-0.1306198239,
-0.0099604344,
-0.0776289403,
0.0217218716,
-0.0214993861,
0.0037107395,
-0.0043976172,
0.0607672334,
-0.0034674022,
-0.032680843,
-0.0273804329,
-0.0031322509,
0.033788003,
-0.0070102988,
0.0061788261,
-0.0130029405,
0.0031112384,
0.0208524652,
-0.04133185,
-0.0146569666,
-0.0378758423,
0.0274288487,
0.0342934616,
0.0089857187,
0.0001388858,
-0.0780805945,
0.0452269688,
0.0651350692,
-0.0295209475,
0.0181124862,
0.0244899746,
0.022259023,
-0.0328859724,
0.0328725241,
-0.0296110492,
0.0188171845,
0.0293644089,
0.0090215513,
0.0266840477,
-0.029665323,
0.0021534974,
-0.0535650142,
-0.0641759783,
-0.0186982211,
-0.0050596055,
0.0127922194,
-0.0592211783,
-0.011400003,
-0.0102955047,
-0.0041905893,
0.0826847479,
-0.0062754191,
-0.0152496789,
1.876466313e-34,
0.0485391356,
-0.017781321,
-0.0029688433,
-0.0081857126,
-0.0153867612,
-0.0123686511,
0.0015259149,
0.0146624818,
0.0069590798,
-0.0555453748,
-0.0661022738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17484v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17484v1 | MedCare: Advancing Medical LLMs through Decoupling Clinical Alignment and Knowledge Aggregation | 2024-06-25T12:05:56 | 2024-06-25T12:05:56 | Yusheng Liao, Shuyang Jiang, Yanfeng Wang, Yu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown substantial progress in natural
language understanding and generation, proving valuable especially in the
medical field. Despite advancements, challenges persist due to the complexity
and diversity inherent in medical tasks, which can be categorized as
knowledge-intensive tasks and alignment-required tasks. Previous approaches
either ignore the latter task or focus on a minority of tasks and hence lose
generalization. To address these drawbacks, we propose a progressive
fine-tuning pipeline. This pipeline employs a Knowledge Aggregator and a Noise
aggregator to encode diverse knowledge in the first stage and filter out
detrimental information. In the second stage, we drop the Noise Aggregator to
avoid the interference of suboptimal representation and leverage an additional
alignment module optimized towards an orthogonal direction to the knowledge
space to mitigate knowledge forgetting. Based on this two-stage paradigm, we
proposed a Medical LLM through decoupling Clinical Alignment and Knowledge
Aggregation (MedCare), which is designed to achieve state-of-the-art (SOTA)
performance on over 20 medical tasks, as well as SOTA results on specific
medical alignment tasks. Various model sizes of MedCare (1.8B, 7B, 14B) all
demonstrate significant improvements over existing models with similar model
sizes. | [
0.0380315334,
0.0533581115,
0.0298837777,
-0.0084068701,
-0.0272547714,
0.0136519577,
-0.0158174317,
-0.0108832559,
-0.0043693413,
-0.014458322,
-0.0261657853,
-0.0685448423,
0.0311055556,
0.0341012217,
0.0335098691,
-0.0243244171,
0.0607318729,
0.0181818772,
0.032624118,
-0.0053295838,
-0.0179183222,
0.0212969426,
-0.0429569595,
0.044315096,
0.0093399379,
-0.0180338062,
0.0215231851,
-0.0156720635,
0.0318575166,
-0.0651165545,
-0.0093315728,
0.0350727886,
0.0050049978,
0.0203450155,
0.0000019474,
-0.0674277917,
-0.0094299251,
0.0316095762,
-0.0542798564,
-0.0581920482,
0.011314068,
-0.0587175414,
-0.0047718901,
-0.0073133507,
-0.0318072289,
-0.027271077,
0.0406871773,
0.0337786116,
0.0473813303,
0.0648772046,
-0.0052159675,
-0.0002162993,
0.0442844369,
-0.0324213021,
0.0219288226,
-0.0596129932,
0.0497002862,
0.0162669178,
0.0022360291,
-0.026796937,
0.0112494137,
0.0535563901,
-0.0419750512,
0.0344699956,
0.0448780358,
0.0584116429,
-0.0168495327,
-0.0293012019,
-0.0133679947,
0.0520563312,
-0.0410443805,
0.0015424505,
0.0230588205,
-0.0022356268,
-0.0070987446,
-0.0194303393,
-0.0463985987,
0.0058361525,
-0.017757412,
0.0183882173,
-0.0070153694,
-0.0171424113,
0.0556616746,
-0.0011954857,
-0.0278977696,
0.004151036,
0.0178118329,
-0.0151708433,
0.00834936,
-0.0123573402,
-0.02635899,
-0.0477241762,
0.0169163067,
0.06952779,
-0.0669032261,
0.0215267316,
-0.0461476855,
-0.0274738427,
0.0799350441,
-0.0366608724,
0.0110773975,
0.0303993225,
0.0080182413,
0.068386808,
0.0002274967,
0.0178337637,
-0.0476134233,
0.0131421043,
-0.0443738587,
-0.0048445305,
-0.0271755122,
-0.0341921151,
0.008799132,
0.046601966,
-0.0157214329,
-0.0147787007,
-0.0645318255,
0.012476204,
-0.0155935716,
0.045911856,
0.0211185366,
0.0371843837,
-0.0257355794,
-0.0260483269,
-0.0268447995,
0.0376977064,
0.0230281074,
0.014011642,
0.0017165854,
-0.0244167857,
-0.0153759802,
0.0175177567,
-0.0056083859,
-0.0119559076,
-0.0041063004,
0.0637015775,
-0.0045759529,
-0.0029951155,
-0.0026451829,
-0.0477322564,
-0.0293329619,
-0.049987223,
0.0016310224,
-0.0512859188,
0.0927680731,
0.0085615544,
-0.015057792,
-0.0738953575,
0.0184370559,
-0.0031301687,
-0.0747230724,
0.0648533329,
-0.0658032522,
0.0072233411,
0.021864593,
0.0231417008,
-0.004734633,
0.0414697416,
0.0202805083,
-0.0470980629,
-0.0301714726,
-0.0086425748,
-0.0201802924,
0.0068282778,
0.0233918503,
-0.0636111796,
0.0159860644,
0.0097308373,
-0.003814287,
0.0918101072,
0.0038371419,
0.0757620931,
0.0081581604,
0.0004295386,
0.0216471553,
0.0436460041,
0.0320126973,
0.0162249189,
0.0136710024,
-0.0067969556,
0.0018520453,
-0.0167168267,
-0.0224059764,
0.0331206508,
-0.0015683735,
0.0179654378,
0.0029194253,
0.0568209141,
-0.0417877808,
-0.024520928,
-0.047520224,
-0.0217257496,
-0.0374766476,
-0.0141538847,
0.040555317,
-0.0271310229,
-0.0429483503,
0.1185975522,
0.0621193759,
-0.0192423854,
-0.0016246382,
-0.0302211512,
0.0049286662,
0.0641096085,
0.0645139292,
-0.0456194766,
-0.0965408236,
-0.003479027,
-0.03151628,
0.0187860448,
0.0318803601,
-0.0039122491,
0.0114419563,
-0.082521975,
-0.0348328799,
0.031791769,
0.0021289722,
-0.0244931877,
-0.0010099151,
-0.0117621776,
0.0041225641,
-0.0146229127,
0.0007379131,
0.0466024876,
-0.0610602871,
0.0033330396,
-0.0196670089,
-0.0106900558,
0.0343949124,
0.0106564322,
-0.0029928584,
0.0466899611,
0.0531010367,
-0.0387386605,
-0.0121345436,
0.0163743254,
-0.0488292649,
-0.0571760125,
0.0515697002,
0.0161697175,
-0.026333835,
-0.0336417817,
-0.0299050342,
-0.0405518711,
-0.0378611386,
-0.0337650068,
0.0215977859,
0.0008655061,
0.0521297827,
0.0474456362,
-0.0127206296,
-0.0629825518,
0.0711842105,
-0.0488579609,
-0.0102305319,
0.0173703954,
-0.0228645075,
0.0014137343,
0.0029949285,
-0.0168516412,
0.0025280395,
-0.0123509504,
0.0173855834,
-0.0224959813,
-0.0121048689,
-0.0389982685,
-0.0715852976,
-0.0799071491,
0.0294660944,
0.0372418091,
0.0170858055,
0.0337393098,
0.0293083806,
0.016162537,
0.0069954535,
-0.0593982972,
0.0082826819,
0.0274439231,
-0.0036099048,
0.0329006352,
0.032149002,
0.0004481284,
-0.0249398109,
0.0209098924,
-0.0358523056,
0.00414469,
-0.0199682731,
-0.0273056161,
-0.0203051344,
0.0081608789,
-0.0768647045,
0.0007937058,
-0.0079426486,
-0.0011816099,
0.0093660867,
0.004792396,
0.0276456568,
0.007237087,
-0.0111710085,
-0.0002269775,
0.048823081,
-0.0146518452,
-0.0273527149,
0.0301523935,
-0.0176624022,
-0.016397072,
-0.0067792484,
-0.0176066812,
-0.0163774677,
0.096470356,
0.0219272822,
0.0020756603,
-0.0604048371,
-0.0191499535,
-0.0029778325,
0.0200284962,
-0.0532396287,
0.0089215655,
-0.0387845077,
0.0231175851,
-0.0364900045,
-0.0261419211,
0.0970197171,
-0.0069043105,
0.0355313867,
-0.0561476648,
-0.0024277866,
-0.0408783183,
-0.0150469318,
-0.0274869073,
0.0266868286,
0.007085464,
-0.0166188478,
-0.0378151499,
0.0052662012,
-0.0300638936,
-0.0922079161,
0.0998522639,
-0.0316692367,
0.0446242057,
0.0072827805,
-0.0289065726,
-0.0596921444,
-0.0059221108,
-0.0064703906,
0.0095702885,
0.007083219,
0.0160826985,
-0.0919759721,
0.0221906286,
-0.0001428686,
0.0242368076,
0.0290535409,
-0.0018689471,
-0.0187420715,
0.0462686531,
0.0387213267,
0.0289047994,
-0.0074551585,
-0.0058338144,
0.0176955387,
0.0665056929,
0.0116688749,
0.0184741076,
0.0088971537,
-0.0114533538,
0.0272495616,
-0.0237364806,
-0.001789014,
0.0148413274,
0.0462156199,
-0.0462043695,
0.0085480036,
0.1312520653,
0.0292274915,
-0.0386218876,
0.0071869288,
0.0103719737,
0.0134595362,
-0.0085271494,
-0.0007108154,
-0.0403621681,
-0.0181072764,
-0.0134333586,
0.0207687747,
0.010083409,
-0.0111551061,
0.0026826472,
-0.0497151166,
-0.0045558102,
0.0624592341,
-0.0504255183,
-0.0486503504,
-0.0049414197,
0.0102030961,
-0.0249647722,
0.0283541977,
0.0168391559,
0.0030717098,
-0.0200595595,
0.0125377597,
-0.0461455658,
-0.0918710455,
0.0006517934,
-0.0279348008,
0.0884938836,
0.0503005534,
0.0315402821,
0.0035953873,
-0.0096704438,
0.00872555,
0.0104058934,
0.0149050197,
-0.0099874064,
0.0647153258,
0.01112743,
-0.00798262,
-0.0436996557,
0.0056725293,
-0.0651352853,
-0.0447590686,
-0.034745235,
0.0929735526,
-0.0365612581,
-0.0006931543,
-0.0325782262,
0.0276164189,
0.0043120375,
0.0768036172,
-0.0278475732,
0.0332550332,
0.0024752507,
0.025566157,
0.0416429266,
0.0045769764,
0.0016940461,
0.0667639375,
-0.0286839046,
-0.0159380678,
-0.0434592664,
-0.0172225591,
0.0440203696,
-0.0018386315,
0.0210173726,
0.0546935908,
0.0422144644,
-0.0261408687,
-0.071507901,
0.0409251377,
0.0225079302,
-0.0103153083,
-0.0122030722,
-0.0514239594,
0.0376730151,
-0.0025720117,
-0.0047604898,
0.0323717631,
-0.0662093908,
-0.050668858,
-0.0221731197,
0.0428175293,
0.024562059,
0.0402251594,
-0.0079300134,
-0.015631672,
0.0508450456,
0.0438573845,
-0.0348657668,
-0.0001611582,
-0.0316271521,
-0.0059808353,
-0.0254741218,
0.0281760711,
-0.0370585062,
-0.0096850451,
-0.0097418996,
0.0698129758,
-0.0251280498,
-0.017107131,
0.0325625055,
0.0199173149,
0.0111450292,
-0.0415318497,
0.010846626,
-0.0114950333,
0.0045920918,
-0.0236946419,
0.0095880497,
-0.0180903301,
-0.0134588089,
0.0381364077,
-0.0379907452,
0.013764278,
0.0228262134,
-0.0299261454,
-0.0072281803,
-0.0501239672,
-0.0062484057,
-0.0455456115,
-0.0278001726,
0.0540430397,
-0.0158942677,
-0.0257771108,
0.0261537135,
-0.0297749229,
-0.0100009199,
-0.0151380915,
0.0438438095,
-0.0157869253,
0.0525656752,
-0.0119802309,
0.0477540158,
-0.0196932238,
-0.0429763049,
-0.0232978966,
0.0131801451,
0.0590807386,
0.0045331842,
0.0471851416,
-0.0052020787,
0.0045118276,
-0.0252154116,
0.0249970332,
-0.0480909608,
0.0360658281,
0.0471970662,
0.0170186087,
0.0042783516,
-0.0481490195,
0.1031489819,
-0.031083405,
0.0557607897,
-0.0329891257,
-0.0157157592,
-0.0653921962,
-0.0344186276,
0.02478805,
0.0282010045,
-0.0730003268,
0.0179695394,
-0.0598248839,
-0.0410409383,
0.0301467367,
-0.011530024,
-0.0386632942,
-0.0147426268,
0.0712728351,
0.0259750113,
-0.0265587922,
-0.0230089352,
0.0071129506,
0.0261219423,
-0.0364387482,
-0.0063245893,
0.0264522266,
-6.177781173e-33,
-0.027536748,
-0.0295766462,
0.0494922884,
-0.0325419866,
-0.0437552221,
0.0246098526,
-0.0336416289,
-0.0053427396,
-0.0192648154,
0.0180688389,
0.0131099969,
-0.0111754509,
-0.0014200499,
0.0539737493,
0.0017608267,
-0.0238463059,
0.0221049879,
0.0132200709,
0.0037597357,
0.0133735398,
-0.0050776149,
0.0700651556,
0.021902049,
-0.0698730275,
0.0048085768,
0.014562821,
0.0109053906,
0.0054054172,
-0.0155176017,
0.0633868873,
-0.0521301702,
0.0349738076,
0.0516958088,
0.0275797993,
-0.0377232991,
-0.0134015298,
-0.0459948853,
-0.0132653061,
0.0360747613,
-0.0328800939,
-0.0322807878,
-0.0655802116,
0.064238444,
-0.0157509577,
-0.0184240025,
-0.0194618534,
0.0042497241,
-0.0387052596,
-0.0545754395,
-0.0363642313,
-0.0540430322,
0.0483687557,
-0.0005697875,
-0.0354122594,
-0.0144115193,
-0.0283848848,
-0.0043328279,
0.0330975391,
-0.0458555147,
0.0029491482,
0.0028466429,
0.037615288,
0.0464031063,
0.0023671156,
-0.0152363926,
0.0762105808,
-0.0047913999,
-0.0151040247,
-0.0413639769,
0.0193113387,
-0.0496710353,
0.0608354658,
0.0322859883,
0.0083814152,
-0.0017748064,
0.0026471701,
-0.0946905389,
0.0438674614,
-0.0696686208,
0.0687406585,
0.0235246252,
0.0062755733,
-0.0499020182,
0.0055731866,
-0.0097550228,
0.0174593497,
-0.0200486258,
-0.0201067291,
0.0137555972,
0.008705359,
0.015636215,
0.0183581933,
-0.010192804,
-0.0086231045,
0.0485244542,
-0.0055520437,
0.0498868152,
0.0004951928,
-0.0512038544,
0.0163473077,
-0.0614997521,
-0.0409958549,
0.0278872158,
-0.0006774974,
0.0244542826,
0.0450545438,
0.0030427403,
-0.0256286338,
-0.0546720326,
-0.0029890134,
-0.009100344,
-0.0150087485,
-0.0148882419,
0.0001271906,
0.0497308113,
0.0247190874,
0.0035240036,
0.0426047258,
0.0091406982,
-0.0147592509,
-0.0141348513,
0.0092672249,
0.0124646313,
-0.0014628907,
-0.0295569114,
0.0197598469,
-0.0338898338,
0.008519561,
0.0514064543,
-0.0173614416,
-0.019331675,
0.011068048,
2.799e-7,
0.0942492113,
0.029914232,
0.0134167187,
-0.0123987226,
0.0292037968,
0.0026245557,
-0.030550098,
0.0084099919,
-0.0179875977,
-0.030902084,
0.0351701751,
0.0172611494,
0.040572118,
0.03051221,
-0.0591959208,
-0.0021726901,
-0.0575288236,
-0.02684181,
-0.0210575238,
-0.0227337759,
0.0470093042,
0.0935903788,
-0.0387784392,
-0.0262947381,
0.0121254688,
-0.025971055,
0.067702733,
-0.0090672076,
-0.0343431272,
0.0744760856,
0.0263796374,
-0.0004162218,
0.0065208431,
0.0477488674,
-0.0266015995,
0.0003239595,
0.0016135647,
0.1085543558,
-0.0639487281,
-0.0111120176,
0.0288580991,
0.0091689406,
0.0168148,
-0.0441052504,
0.0339074731,
-0.0646111071,
-0.0524200983,
-0.0384876207,
0.0017783871,
0.0234253816,
0.0459444746,
-0.0149173085,
-0.0259165466,
0.01757879,
0.0327010602,
0.0211682059,
-0.0652206391,
-0.0839669034,
-0.0395644195,
0.0497849025,
-0.0570048839,
-0.0460654087,
0.0437679589,
-0.0399994627,
0.0356485024,
-0.0928260833,
-0.0016640257,
2.285216349e-34,
0.0248672571,
-0.0033234451,
0.0200249627,
0.0536566265,
0.0153623112,
-0.0356307924,
-0.0377386883,
0.0346534289,
0.0116618834,
-0.0649233237,
0.0129277855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17474v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17474v1 | Transformer-based Named Entity Recognition with Combined Data Representation | 2024-06-25T11:41:16 | 2024-06-25T11:41:16 | Michał Marcińczuk | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study examines transformer-based models and their effectiveness in named
entity recognition tasks. The study investigates data representation
strategies, including single, merged, and context, which respectively use one
sentence, multiple sentences, and sentences joined with attention to context
per vector. Analysis shows that training models with a single strategy may lead
to poor performance on different data representations. To address this
limitation, the study proposes a combined training procedure that utilizes all
three strategies to improve model stability and adaptability. The results of
this approach are presented and discussed for four languages (English, Polish,
Czech, and German) across various datasets, demonstrating the effectiveness of
the combined strategy. | [
0.0174503494,
0.0207669344,
0.0278721713,
0.022930352,
0.0055315616,
0.051960025,
0.0144916316,
-0.0155682024,
-0.0210504197,
-0.0503666215,
-0.0286016576,
-0.0385114364,
0.0332731791,
-0.0318764895,
0.020282831,
-0.0495257042,
0.0373240747,
-0.0159132965,
-0.0371219963,
0.0286499709,
-0.0093426406,
-0.0274474416,
0.0019757156,
0.007731617,
-0.0033085288,
0.0291466434,
0.003694423,
0.0192874111,
0.0544881895,
-0.0260412246,
-0.0012788371,
0.0409094505,
-0.0069394317,
0.0502547622,
0.0000016238,
-0.0482531264,
-0.0568414181,
0.0009933126,
-0.0277792551,
-0.0544387996,
0.0320697054,
-0.0911943614,
-0.0374912396,
0.0174173173,
0.0051269815,
-0.0724284053,
0.0591783412,
0.1075961441,
0.017310055,
0.0617608428,
-0.0136083374,
-0.0800773427,
0.08289361,
0.0061266227,
-0.0547909513,
-0.0089504523,
0.0633493066,
-0.0077849776,
-0.0401365422,
0.0194337834,
-0.0076699378,
0.0433849916,
-0.0130732115,
0.0180431604,
-0.0089601707,
0.0443228781,
-0.0416355506,
-0.0023899544,
-0.0209212508,
0.0360758416,
-0.0447177291,
-0.0180884246,
0.0034021966,
-0.0111751696,
-0.009707367,
-0.0270461775,
-0.0393319651,
0.0194777809,
-0.0288552344,
-0.0059820502,
0.008717387,
0.0278621707,
0.0073072771,
-0.0077613825,
-0.0703147501,
0.0172021799,
0.0097651267,
-0.0477245972,
0.025239097,
0.0135065531,
-0.0183368698,
-0.0064632138,
0.0429608338,
0.0267528947,
0.0401782766,
0.0268320683,
-0.0227277763,
-0.0692662746,
-0.0157096926,
-0.0522206947,
0.0047215968,
0.0504075289,
-0.0179515705,
0.0231879335,
-0.093148455,
0.0613309965,
-0.0243961588,
0.0348841958,
0.0107033253,
-0.0374959521,
-0.0623487607,
0.0164684728,
-0.0628863648,
0.0283614956,
-0.0413344838,
0.0024236953,
-0.0408779085,
0.0241196789,
0.0319573693,
0.0052729785,
0.033810433,
-0.0210922379,
-0.0120694553,
0.0316297077,
0.0158236101,
0.0764514208,
0.0108074863,
-0.0128817223,
-0.0036557219,
-0.0526105762,
0.0078525962,
-0.0200837068,
0.0374196768,
-0.0618105158,
0.0219469815,
0.0483341739,
0.0137453191,
-0.0941099823,
-0.0463664308,
0.0286944527,
-0.0346026793,
-0.0414540619,
0.0212220531,
-0.0341063254,
0.0575206131,
0.0291196406,
0.0284831543,
-0.0271227695,
0.0075514796,
0.0094367201,
-0.0394779928,
0.0823474824,
-0.0149880173,
-0.0008670886,
0.0143591464,
0.0043951701,
0.0446502417,
0.0477085002,
0.0209952518,
-0.0073982263,
0.0118270991,
-0.0054797963,
-0.0043755667,
0.0268201698,
0.0035074479,
-0.0315586776,
0.0303793997,
0.0238730293,
-0.0061523085,
-0.0146828433,
0.0235504936,
0.0575067028,
-0.0023404402,
-0.0078619067,
0.0494524017,
0.0163944103,
0.0670923442,
0.0196951721,
0.0139185991,
-0.0276469924,
0.0133140739,
-0.0054091448,
-0.0283929985,
-0.0192792863,
-0.0008909957,
0.0444017015,
-0.0640207157,
0.0620328039,
-0.0193696544,
0.0130649554,
0.0005718055,
-0.0246005151,
0.0218953602,
-0.0102365306,
0.0577113256,
0.0195273925,
-0.0896104872,
0.0816501528,
0.0290933624,
-0.0572471581,
-0.0238115117,
0.0150725525,
-0.0394766442,
0.0349722281,
0.0188855547,
-0.0059790667,
-0.0408241823,
-0.0458590649,
-0.0250247065,
0.0021029084,
0.010780165,
0.0154671464,
0.0242175292,
-0.0376621075,
-0.0065304944,
0.0668540075,
-0.0064291735,
0.0362652689,
-0.0073987874,
0.0126343938,
0.0276214145,
0.0014768442,
-0.0288728159,
0.0432398841,
-0.0098650279,
-0.0044449489,
-0.0067186831,
0.0343241841,
0.0070806909,
0.0517134815,
0.0178658571,
-0.019007897,
0.0484977365,
-0.0259382762,
-0.0036277797,
0.0319348723,
-0.0184072219,
-0.0445531644,
-0.0125130164,
-0.0116567407,
-0.0114086214,
0.011436007,
0.0079359831,
-0.0537842289,
-0.0598686188,
-0.0232419744,
0.0165080484,
-0.0157996528,
0.0507547036,
0.0063909921,
0.0506564081,
-0.0305313244,
0.0587513261,
-0.0207127985,
0.0212311503,
0.033070609,
-0.0121720172,
0.0146679739,
-0.0314022936,
-0.0445794836,
0.0209920127,
-0.0345958807,
-0.0356317684,
0.0036922747,
-0.0427083112,
-0.0206097588,
-0.0198716354,
-0.0899872482,
-0.0123076001,
-0.02145789,
0.0529194884,
-0.0088541741,
0.0396443941,
-0.0151650338,
-0.0052485382,
-0.0072930623,
-0.0285423156,
0.0102399364,
0.0065951501,
0.0191463307,
0.0191346332,
-0.0371415094,
-0.0100306142,
0.0045692781,
-0.0540015325,
0.0480266511,
0.0145524088,
-0.0703451633,
-0.0789180174,
0.0499019474,
0.0038755985,
0.0162663516,
-0.0092482492,
-0.0087568723,
-0.018809054,
0.0419630148,
0.0924258456,
0.0561493337,
0.0078853527,
0.0148511259,
-0.0125680836,
-0.0250992458,
-0.0210685376,
0.0170947034,
-0.0425574668,
0.0303606205,
-0.0409170762,
-0.0235082973,
0.0309628639,
0.0789954811,
-0.0381249115,
0.027666688,
-0.0210478026,
-0.0239250064,
-0.0161869489,
0.0066966447,
0.0094903195,
-0.0092412261,
-0.0215571262,
0.0035009601,
-0.0076701087,
0.015508445,
0.0432374254,
-0.0726691782,
-0.0350242592,
-0.0205663405,
-0.0064392947,
-0.0357621051,
0.038040977,
0.0143541545,
0.0101370364,
0.0181420222,
-0.0872509405,
-0.0088122217,
0.0133078406,
-0.0071527287,
-0.0205515083,
0.0673275068,
0.0372950695,
0.0238260273,
-0.038449388,
0.0011793948,
-0.035512127,
-0.0274374019,
-0.0345892571,
0.0365766808,
0.0248171296,
-0.0136287445,
-0.0485365689,
0.0638084114,
0.0177040119,
0.0443348549,
0.0004198199,
-0.0157865137,
-0.0267774258,
0.0361891612,
-0.0157103781,
0.0251579396,
0.0347717442,
-0.0210253559,
-0.0099186059,
0.0017843712,
0.0210001133,
-0.0055179303,
-0.0127533562,
-0.0503327213,
0.0312054921,
-0.0780284032,
-0.0088879969,
-0.0337841138,
0.0204911511,
-0.0475660302,
-0.0172586795,
0.0979048461,
-0.0058329934,
-0.0070401891,
-0.028786337,
0.0172499977,
0.0013482653,
-0.003743697,
0.0228866264,
-0.0867559388,
-0.0160018541,
0.0045990902,
-0.0054593761,
-0.0033078003,
-0.0466534123,
0.0151013462,
-0.0900734738,
-0.0123214433,
-0.0147420336,
-0.059789855,
-0.0340376981,
-0.0530289337,
0.002181971,
-0.0473657362,
0.0113943163,
-0.0031288892,
-0.0605055131,
-0.0365961827,
0.029909553,
-0.0048764544,
-0.0561091043,
-0.0159181952,
-0.0448911749,
0.0187821165,
0.0449930355,
0.014791782,
-0.034364406,
-0.0251385216,
-0.0057016392,
-0.0432297252,
0.0038959065,
-0.0045644669,
0.0324057899,
-0.0411867835,
-0.0154410228,
-0.0182404369,
-0.0303654224,
-0.0066227973,
-0.0323074199,
-0.0231523383,
0.0491519161,
-0.0033907283,
0.0066195047,
0.0210634712,
-0.029011054,
0.0182036012,
0.0717778951,
0.009436788,
-0.0018202493,
-0.0286739059,
0.0251063034,
0.033444196,
-0.0336777084,
-0.023812402,
0.0442113765,
-0.024707282,
-0.0581979938,
-0.0287006069,
-0.05181228,
0.0322142206,
0.0516480953,
0.019506285,
0.0078346506,
0.0272508338,
0.038070824,
-0.0700351447,
0.0317418985,
-0.0048455959,
0.0324868746,
-0.0668124631,
0.0261318628,
0.018731527,
-0.0072064181,
-0.0311930683,
-0.0148789855,
-0.0855384767,
-0.0294851046,
0.0436690003,
0.015483941,
0.0169055443,
0.0279188585,
0.0066277981,
-0.0241256766,
0.016044857,
0.0308080055,
-0.0335919,
-0.0090897819,
0.0400423482,
-0.0003192636,
-0.0175708979,
-0.0060878312,
-0.015883958,
0.0405059606,
0.0348066278,
0.0158638097,
-0.035535492,
-0.0105817914,
-0.0154349022,
-0.0058986326,
0.0616781712,
0.0024018052,
-0.0171957202,
-0.0291482788,
0.039941147,
0.0103346994,
0.0360803157,
0.0028792555,
-0.0178716462,
0.0177700967,
0.0081562465,
-0.0127707981,
0.0457778797,
-0.0319177136,
-0.0323332176,
-0.061270386,
0.0461891778,
0.0096705472,
0.0259641539,
0.004048049,
-0.0045446623,
-0.0027903519,
0.0362473167,
0.0826801211,
0.0193751007,
-0.006877285,
0.0204759613,
-0.0005850674,
-0.0100543145,
-0.0190390497,
0.0279676914,
-0.0652989224,
0.0511056408,
-0.0198216662,
-0.001396349,
0.036119584,
-0.011331819,
0.0558093116,
-0.0009262649,
0.0041480446,
-0.0014323435,
0.0003934285,
-0.0192179196,
0.0120994244,
0.0257940814,
0.0068301177,
-0.013702089,
-0.0306772236,
0.0341756791,
-0.0066564251,
0.0082460428,
-0.0010918237,
-0.003964779,
-0.036187429,
-0.0032070964,
-0.0109453555,
-0.0263877586,
-0.0470499285,
-0.0215605572,
-0.0338433646,
-0.0287973769,
0.0545468926,
-0.0238461494,
0.0021914067,
-0.0035917021,
0.001349841,
-0.0118019795,
0.0257002469,
-0.0206049122,
-0.0205522217,
0.0235117115,
0.0393230543,
-0.0171258319,
-0.0206578933,
-5.522116506e-33,
-0.0380607657,
-0.0116431387,
-0.000875132,
0.0067850873,
-0.0322739892,
0.0307607502,
-0.0151070962,
0.0020972921,
-0.0265508294,
-0.0353816897,
-0.0115588279,
-0.0092370668,
0.049500417,
0.0092853438,
-0.0330045708,
-0.0392771177,
0.067136012,
0.0480084084,
-0.0180059299,
-0.0157197732,
0.0384967327,
0.0819910094,
0.1031252071,
-0.0825578496,
0.0275959484,
-0.0167204961,
0.0038797213,
-0.0132755116,
0.0867145807,
0.0935016125,
0.0053383536,
0.0042301603,
0.0241228845,
-0.0811127201,
-0.0052941348,
0.0700781792,
-0.1588085294,
0.0334481262,
0.0060722278,
0.0905361623,
-0.0082806265,
-0.0289231129,
0.0590623505,
-0.0141534777,
0.0320229381,
0.0079133222,
0.0240799431,
-0.0301839542,
0.0009299812,
-0.0510650277,
-0.0696647391,
0.0296632256,
0.0262097437,
0.0429885387,
0.052495461,
0.021510439,
0.0411786065,
0.0214133319,
-0.0838942677,
-0.0043233703,
0.0534055717,
-0.0069291196,
0.0318517052,
0.0431348123,
-0.0247092769,
0.0108848857,
0.0352645107,
-0.0096956948,
-0.0298696812,
-0.0231936686,
0.0381372385,
0.0162366536,
0.027807625,
0.0336052291,
0.0008120311,
-0.0110298833,
-0.0643430278,
0.0093797566,
0.0021664633,
0.0057919607,
-0.0106445607,
-0.0247305948,
-0.0562365092,
0.0070018806,
0.008106878,
-0.0198562369,
-0.0270049237,
-0.006296685,
0.0371024944,
0.0013446087,
-0.0513873771,
0.0700223073,
0.0737496242,
-0.0431504287,
-0.0558391549,
-0.0002213094,
0.0473065525,
0.0481350496,
-0.0347945355,
0.0087286187,
-0.0521630645,
-0.0619299598,
0.024779899,
0.0352735817,
0.0115379663,
-0.0138754891,
0.0757145509,
-0.0079150219,
-0.087463744,
-0.0119100567,
-0.0001504437,
0.0250781663,
-0.0324247777,
0.0500984788,
0.0330976509,
0.0140127484,
0.0053723049,
0.0229185708,
0.0505820513,
-0.0304735303,
-0.0342607461,
0.0210703257,
0.0536110885,
0.0637464374,
0.0003663361,
-0.0040022219,
0.0138414418,
0.039748624,
0.0281182844,
-0.0400814228,
0.0005003428,
0.0244122259,
2.361e-7,
0.0681052059,
0.0184895992,
0.0289500002,
-0.0282265767,
-0.0113862781,
-0.0195363574,
0.0257533137,
0.0309563112,
-0.0083616059,
0.0430681743,
0.0034649235,
-0.0347537026,
0.0101607423,
-0.0004975908,
-0.0890488327,
-0.0550340451,
-0.050199043,
0.0076748524,
-0.0505842045,
0.0629980266,
0.0407106504,
0.095979549,
-0.0280786958,
-0.0021879326,
-0.0452492796,
0.020191269,
0.0615015291,
0.0048255152,
0.0438221283,
0.0428679064,
0.0185851958,
0.0578923412,
-0.0148425968,
0.0357380435,
-0.0058275834,
0.0382239223,
0.0187306609,
0.0242064372,
-0.0146856336,
-0.0020333955,
0.0235549249,
-0.0345485806,
-0.0167681091,
-0.0515252277,
0.0583535805,
-0.1067062095,
-0.0005268685,
0.0113627547,
-0.0322819464,
0.0146598304,
-0.0071243299,
0.0390655696,
-0.0022088874,
0.0310650934,
0.0297292061,
-0.0318457782,
-0.0223453436,
-0.0699310228,
0.0116516324,
0.0107405437,
0.0256045181,
-0.0031944574,
-0.0283978041,
-0.0739781559,
0.0349002816,
-0.0246677846,
-0.031358894,
2.097880661e-34,
-0.0322406664,
0.0098267104,
-0.0208842568,
0.0522278585,
-0.0170478076,
-0.0330824554,
0.0072743413,
0.0090244086,
-0.0353701003,
-0.070968315,
-0.0093604187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17465v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17465v1 | Enhancing Tool Retrieval with Iterative Feedback from Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T11:12:01 | 2024-06-25T11:12:01 | Qiancheng Xu, Yongqi Li, Heming Xia, Wenjie Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Tool learning aims to enhance and expand large language models' (LLMs)
capabilities with external tools, which has gained significant attention
recently. Current methods have shown that LLMs can effectively handle a certain
amount of tools through in-context learning or fine-tuning. However, in
real-world scenarios, the number of tools is typically extensive and
irregularly updated, emphasizing the necessity for a dedicated tool retrieval
component. Tool retrieval is nontrivial due to the following challenges: 1)
complex user instructions and tool descriptions; 2) misalignment between tool
retrieval and tool usage models. To address the above issues, we propose to
enhance tool retrieval with iterative feedback from the large language model.
Specifically, we prompt the tool usage model, i.e., the LLM, to provide
feedback for the tool retriever model in multi-round, which could progressively
improve the tool retriever's understanding of instructions and tools and reduce
the gap between the two standalone components. We build a unified and
comprehensive benchmark to evaluate tool retrieval models. The extensive
experiments indicate that our proposed approach achieves advanced performance
in both in-domain evaluation and out-of-domain evaluation. | [
0.0379030146,
-0.0159533061,
-0.0275241677,
0.0389785916,
-0.018547222,
0.0134434439,
-0.019897975,
0.0067248829,
0.002344609,
-0.036100585,
-0.0431842245,
-0.0025388582,
-0.0561698526,
-0.0322819836,
0.0018481043,
-0.0318248682,
0.0535246953,
-0.0116388835,
-0.0617095269,
0.0396996588,
-0.0152184526,
0.0193834677,
0.0026544379,
0.0726365075,
0.0184375308,
0.0041572177,
-0.0173854344,
0.0236054491,
-0.0016438285,
0.0034505047,
0.0336781405,
0.0107884388,
0.0237397123,
0.0499735847,
0.0000019013,
-0.0556515604,
-0.0503301099,
0.0035533013,
-0.0264490098,
-0.0210528243,
0.0536835082,
0.0111746388,
-0.0089929914,
0.0133513333,
-0.0202765614,
-0.0011421151,
0.0469585583,
-0.0069203041,
0.0277368911,
0.0517434031,
0.0221803226,
0.0321596414,
-0.0209139548,
-0.006740489,
-0.0164245404,
-0.0197009854,
-0.0150429336,
0.025192935,
0.069095321,
0.0450213999,
0.0429793,
0.0447656512,
0.0203081723,
0.0210495386,
0.0311568193,
-0.002160951,
0.0050335461,
0.0099953841,
0.0078921532,
0.0212656017,
-0.0244877823,
-0.0135363862,
-0.0021889587,
-0.0098863393,
0.0068788277,
0.0609498844,
-0.0589468814,
-0.0041552507,
-0.0348576084,
-0.0301405266,
-0.027659934,
-0.043896433,
0.0131918732,
0.0057509299,
-0.0032158184,
0.0659048259,
0.0088062631,
-0.0068012951,
-0.0048409919,
-0.0358071811,
-0.0149648925,
-0.0239723157,
0.0038913523,
0.0719090849,
-0.0627861917,
0.025386462,
0.022107739,
0.0281536374,
0.0237900652,
-0.0679712445,
0.0470513105,
0.0353402644,
-0.0526038259,
0.0452770963,
-0.0375392698,
0.0122912228,
-0.0084961783,
0.009879237,
-0.0652203783,
-0.0099226348,
-0.0771698579,
-0.0544977263,
-0.0274253357,
0.0252571497,
-0.032694906,
-0.043485105,
0.0216591284,
0.050586991,
0.0080776447,
0.016167555,
-0.0085604005,
-0.0506617278,
-0.0453285724,
-0.0246394388,
-0.0164133683,
0.0255615618,
-0.0339209326,
0.0070363521,
0.0042346637,
-0.0409473106,
-0.0202377476,
0.0048509301,
-0.0333543308,
-0.0376155265,
0.0014668405,
0.0990163088,
-0.022879215,
0.0150716566,
-0.0507292785,
-0.0627462119,
0.0399342515,
-0.0050281188,
-0.0066422792,
-0.0659603924,
-0.0177280903,
0.0352955014,
-0.0040990878,
-0.0221210066,
-0.0093403021,
0.0193747245,
0.0077298987,
0.0280936491,
-0.0130235907,
0.0142738558,
0.0435982011,
0.0128431143,
0.0117968628,
0.0351283178,
-0.0577184558,
0.0757245868,
0.026653951,
-0.0176822115,
-0.0016973721,
0.0505545288,
-0.0384012125,
-0.011463373,
-0.0477258042,
0.0190309454,
0.0449213497,
-0.0103361811,
0.0072666719,
-0.0033818989,
-0.0209698118,
0.0402502157,
0.0165064409,
0.0434551835,
0.0850507021,
-0.0016833724,
0.051804807,
0.0309339818,
-0.023442883,
-0.0169407222,
-0.0535360202,
0.0071087265,
-0.0753096938,
0.0130339265,
-0.0274933986,
-0.0040598824,
-0.0145633835,
-0.0172137506,
-0.0115210777,
0.0105445124,
-0.0266392343,
0.0064720404,
0.0720312893,
0.0003814878,
-0.0126552079,
0.0283536874,
0.0447347276,
-0.0214698222,
-0.0381912217,
-0.0711453408,
-0.0023626385,
0.0836596563,
0.0667476803,
-0.0454321764,
-0.0407465212,
0.0440850183,
-0.0162921455,
-0.0194375496,
0.0129111223,
-0.0322388224,
-0.0160209611,
-0.0173813943,
-0.057855133,
-0.0205911603,
-0.0116632786,
0.0461367294,
0.0391535796,
-0.0355553888,
0.0516506806,
-0.0768192559,
0.0019092516,
0.027097024,
0.0173822511,
-0.0439081751,
-0.011007838,
0.0229692962,
0.0067189494,
-0.0112758493,
-0.0262297634,
0.018401131,
0.0473071299,
-0.0148558337,
-0.0312552191,
-0.0189425591,
-0.0121119246,
0.0265359469,
0.0429178663,
0.0513134338,
0.0289626755,
-0.0079586953,
0.012095294,
-0.0166888852,
0.001136211,
-0.0192917455,
0.0516784601,
-0.0122401984,
0.0309314448,
-0.0406708494,
-0.0388480388,
-0.0730638802,
0.0487153903,
0.0142562846,
0.0014104758,
-0.0113998614,
0.0224611536,
-0.0021215491,
-0.0182004664,
-0.0192791522,
0.029487567,
-0.0088002309,
0.0563312322,
0.0313434973,
0.0094130514,
-0.0106833996,
-0.0434886701,
-0.08572907,
0.0222325474,
-0.0210028719,
0.0067409477,
0.0090719145,
0.01126674,
-0.0014910207,
-0.0534829311,
0.0201827306,
-0.0025659322,
-0.0206681881,
0.0403947979,
-0.0308029,
0.0253330767,
-0.0389732569,
-0.0176783744,
-0.0416130573,
0.0020464831,
0.0219054855,
-0.0071279807,
-0.0300921407,
-0.0672097057,
0.0775797367,
-0.0165682584,
0.0042759012,
-0.0198109467,
-0.0049729585,
0.0281298067,
-0.0393548086,
-0.0009072402,
0.0656881556,
-0.0450548269,
0.0322954282,
0.0691916272,
-0.0127770565,
-0.112875022,
-0.0044984333,
0.0128082857,
-0.0971633047,
0.00553559,
0.0308203604,
0.0314183086,
0.0111515773,
-0.0125297401,
0.0360805355,
0.0178275798,
-0.0222280677,
-0.0119531453,
-0.0354045779,
-0.0438492149,
-0.0287673157,
-0.0041759559,
0.0290671587,
-0.004047472,
-0.0703756958,
0.054096844,
-0.0195118636,
-0.0027299351,
-0.0092891315,
-0.0442067944,
-0.0193742961,
0.0736401156,
-0.0003040823,
0.0219895281,
-0.011798799,
-0.0311006326,
-0.0290743988,
-0.0054601957,
0.0354691707,
-0.0585181862,
0.0343427993,
-0.0352225229,
0.0362796187,
-0.0012768827,
-0.032859832,
-0.0217542835,
-0.0030447431,
-0.006409457,
0.0277814548,
0.0084965834,
-0.0044885431,
-0.0149505297,
0.0444593206,
0.0596130379,
0.0384060442,
0.0335599519,
-0.0225219782,
-0.0080695003,
0.0070857597,
0.0225696657,
-0.0260176007,
-0.0279902685,
-0.0060874326,
-0.0024968877,
0.0260424372,
0.0528249443,
-0.0571320355,
-0.0597978979,
-0.0186881255,
0.04460923,
-0.0266158525,
-0.011503024,
0.0530930124,
0.0247555748,
-0.0763124898,
-0.0157923531,
0.0636746436,
0.0293966737,
-0.0595198944,
-0.0179524347,
0.012423588,
0.0042539029,
0.0494723246,
0.0650840774,
-0.0695964918,
-0.0219985265,
0.0264210328,
0.0399459675,
0.0246342923,
0.0215315055,
0.0159570109,
-0.1324676275,
0.0287124664,
0.020167727,
-0.0133549608,
-0.0135071548,
-0.0527434982,
-0.0010601755,
0.0204744544,
-0.0022054717,
0.0427285619,
-0.0271253604,
-0.0020665994,
0.0149580948,
0.0076341,
-0.0643509254,
0.0179695152,
-0.019472383,
0.004826759,
0.0914158747,
-0.04375517,
0.0246402677,
0.0493879244,
0.1089918092,
0.0048965821,
0.0359890684,
-0.0414242074,
0.0100435894,
0.0066196066,
-0.0137378862,
-0.0129934866,
-0.0015592457,
-0.0020705932,
-0.0014615197,
0.0062275659,
0.0509260595,
-0.0228164122,
0.0684692562,
-0.0208376814,
-0.0578087866,
0.0145929353,
0.0192986839,
0.0140207112,
0.0044493042,
0.0150787346,
-0.0409881137,
-0.046594929,
0.0268200599,
-0.0351835564,
-0.0007036948,
-0.0306497756,
0.0236308966,
-0.0420053415,
-0.0241667014,
0.0343995802,
0.044678852,
0.0253363047,
0.000663802,
-0.0329063796,
0.0181765631,
-0.0754953772,
0.0372699462,
-0.0373309068,
0.042045325,
-0.0490323491,
0.0017942559,
0.0109779825,
-0.0182431564,
-0.0262483377,
0.0418723077,
-0.0204264987,
-0.062453717,
-0.025691865,
0.0379401743,
0.0238323584,
0.0143893007,
-0.0404404402,
-0.0774927214,
-0.0233858787,
0.0263930056,
-0.0263996013,
-0.0013449903,
-0.0086853644,
0.0167695638,
-0.0288361702,
0.029974414,
-0.065350689,
0.0064320033,
0.0238338262,
0.0249378476,
-0.0197036434,
-0.0718575269,
0.0529198833,
0.0374009497,
0.0133056408,
0.0456158295,
0.0240511261,
-0.0323582478,
0.0271988343,
0.0252315756,
-0.0564702563,
-0.0262940563,
0.0328625999,
-0.0196309965,
-0.0543099195,
0.0474451706,
0.0018085979,
0.0370530747,
0.0614312068,
-0.0557630882,
0.0040024007,
-0.0100813592,
0.0063262046,
0.0376156233,
0.0326332115,
-0.0182945449,
-0.0024256369,
0.0193853471,
0.0759858862,
-0.0350959972,
0.0590503439,
0.0050953254,
-0.0035706696,
-0.0577799268,
0.0193276219,
-0.0291070435,
-0.1044462398,
-0.0235983636,
-0.0039678863,
0.0415662676,
-0.0449162535,
0.0258539207,
-0.0109373853,
-0.0298289414,
-0.0611729585,
0.0124517623,
-0.0059890114,
0.0069573792,
-0.0015700515,
0.0469954051,
-0.0079320204,
-0.0110798059,
0.0287902132,
-0.0465166643,
0.0187244639,
-0.0158940759,
-0.0380706675,
-0.0513581373,
-0.013382107,
0.0547630489,
-0.0048182383,
-0.0316587128,
-0.0191198662,
-0.0238318741,
-0.0461795442,
-0.0573876351,
0.0073100333,
-0.0358286574,
-0.0082473932,
0.0275879782,
0.1386935413,
0.0101111988,
-0.0155035984,
-0.0230550431,
-0.010220157,
-0.0413760841,
0.0008688187,
-0.0278788619,
-5.210856255e-33,
-0.0541792475,
-0.0172605477,
0.0327176489,
-0.023341259,
0.0308275577,
-0.0076723164,
-0.0179709606,
0.0253895689,
-0.009788787,
-0.031514965,
-0.0029239105,
-0.0167429615,
0.0146349203,
-0.0353998914,
0.0525497161,
0.0427130796,
0.0624754243,
0.0450137109,
-0.0448452719,
0.0132877184,
0.0493967682,
0.0317519642,
0.0538406372,
-0.0619481876,
-0.0058997381,
0.0170030799,
0.0295522753,
0.0329386964,
0.0135370158,
0.0759768337,
0.0008086995,
0.0414627381,
0.0121613182,
-0.0155363521,
-0.0166812465,
-0.0225881059,
-0.0641885772,
-0.0112257814,
0.0043052319,
0.0031545528,
0.0597244129,
-0.0437824875,
0.0491195507,
-0.0126196463,
-0.0183295906,
0.0147276148,
0.0332020782,
-0.0109947361,
-0.0498460978,
-0.0025590737,
-0.0401522368,
0.0317587256,
0.0213337261,
-0.0473866723,
0.0043458948,
0.0243635196,
0.009161477,
-0.0044441451,
-0.0229815766,
0.0133017357,
0.0288335904,
0.0802302137,
0.0877265707,
0.0513484254,
-0.0091247717,
0.0153709538,
0.0095746173,
-0.0165805705,
0.0252494104,
-0.0437903851,
0.0216865893,
0.0646209866,
-0.0072699911,
0.0024236043,
-0.0012670445,
0.0316725969,
0.0104909372,
0.0410617925,
0.0073293438,
0.1198821217,
0.0473093241,
0.0784583688,
-0.0638225302,
0.0019729845,
-0.0357818045,
0.0199346337,
-0.0456767827,
-0.059419509,
0.0517398901,
0.0346188508,
0.0036810373,
-0.0045565739,
0.0327521861,
-0.0017483011,
0.009908908,
-0.0062747058,
-0.0250554122,
0.0207843296,
-0.0213910975,
0.0163308773,
-0.0127629451,
-0.0360847265,
-0.0191610865,
-0.0321735702,
-0.0006699253,
-0.0207133256,
-0.0162422694,
0.0256651528,
-0.0852845982,
0.0265444759,
-0.0495359637,
-0.0365188718,
-0.02455475,
0.0085582752,
0.0446381345,
-0.003479366,
0.0065328907,
0.0362932645,
-0.0131940991,
-0.0784088075,
-0.0344208404,
-0.0355403237,
-0.0135715315,
-0.0379808247,
-0.009225497,
0.0530839115,
-0.0375036635,
0.0334352255,
0.0326564722,
0.0099466434,
0.0026238305,
0.004120931,
2.695e-7,
0.0376828648,
0.0069637066,
-0.0025005746,
0.0278979857,
-0.035175845,
0.0150016444,
-0.0335082747,
-0.0089786816,
0.0345782489,
0.0138977217,
-0.016033398,
0.0486293435,
0.0341159813,
0.0140950289,
-0.0405341275,
0.0231268518,
-0.0017283929,
0.0143058505,
-0.0700666457,
-0.0256876908,
0.0273142569,
0.0702527389,
-0.0165627953,
-0.0119449105,
-0.0082417894,
-0.1148080006,
0.030380765,
-0.0454006195,
-0.0235326905,
0.004448995,
0.0008629571,
0.0714020133,
0.0051921867,
-0.00334713,
0.0189430136,
0.0385504924,
0.0067679756,
0.0583444983,
-0.0111742718,
-0.0087254522,
0.0027923356,
-0.0452684425,
0.0006725228,
-0.0399981365,
0.0224144477,
-0.0475892276,
0.0091928486,
-0.0009438534,
-0.0018215305,
-0.0071214326,
-0.0380545631,
-0.0180060621,
0.0009959663,
0.0024581593,
-0.0003455869,
0.0153755089,
-0.0229698997,
-0.0514704175,
-0.0275845323,
0.0878034756,
-0.0305045247,
-0.0672747791,
-0.0401177406,
-0.0179012846,
-0.0403177962,
-0.0059560002,
0.0111855855,
2.341874258e-34,
0.0169767849,
0.0155797061,
0.0330505706,
0.0875608772,
0.0538086593,
0.0002208783,
-0.0249386113,
0.0525177978,
0.0107754236,
-0.0777325854,
-0.0057381145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00875v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00875v1 | MoE-CT: A Novel Approach For Large Language Models Training With Resistance To Catastrophic Forgetting | 2024-06-25T11:03:45 | 2024-06-25T11:03:45 | Tianhao Li, Shangjie Li, Binbin Xie, Deyi Xiong, Baosong Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advent of large language models (LLMs) has predominantly catered to
high-resource languages, leaving a disparity in performance for low-resource
languages. Conventional Continual Training (CT) approaches to bridge this gap
often undermine a model's original linguistic proficiency when expanding to
multilingual contexts. Addressing this issue, we introduce a novel MoE-CT
architecture, a paradigm that innovatively separates the base model's learning
from the multilingual expansion process. Our design freezes the original LLM
parameters, thus safeguarding its performance in high-resource languages, while
an appended MoE module, trained on diverse language datasets, augments
low-resource language proficiency. Our approach significantly outperforms
conventional CT methods, as evidenced by our experiments, which show marked
improvements in multilingual benchmarks without sacrificing the model's
original language performance. Moreover, our MoE-CT framework demonstrates
enhanced resistance to forgetting and superior transfer learning capabilities.
By preserving the base model's integrity and focusing on strategic parameter
expansion, our methodology advances multilingual language modeling and
represents a significant step forward for low-resource language inclusion in
LLMs, indicating a fruitful direction for future research in language
technologies. | [
0.0017917196,
0.0997517183,
-0.0047524357,
0.0321464092,
-0.0029091171,
0.0386086367,
0.0075338809,
-0.0468936712,
-0.0317066573,
-0.0196578242,
-0.0642459691,
-0.0426805764,
-0.0213165898,
-0.0107313637,
0.032117676,
-0.0445039459,
0.0573492795,
-0.0603136085,
-0.0677396283,
-0.0231524184,
-0.0102000954,
0.0155762881,
0.0305239391,
0.0014872742,
-0.0096548842,
-0.0182693619,
0.0044078948,
-0.0095796315,
0.0004731253,
-0.0297063142,
-0.0076448084,
0.0254121609,
0.028297985,
0.044266738,
0.0000022183,
-0.0558064505,
-0.0347162224,
-0.0094981315,
-0.0257368889,
0.0075837579,
0.0708770454,
-0.0331088901,
-0.0297562145,
0.0254244152,
-0.0084959799,
-0.0073609208,
0.0674771592,
0.0066774916,
0.0446319543,
0.0660446957,
-0.0124970945,
-0.0085906973,
0.0542087443,
-0.0345724523,
-0.026476616,
-0.033079382,
0.0330695659,
0.0088214697,
-0.0178236067,
-0.0068733096,
-0.0287430901,
0.0405418463,
0.0281271525,
0.0175666716,
-0.0223933309,
0.0420393981,
0.0182104148,
-0.0177913867,
-0.0263290908,
0.0246215295,
-0.0412778258,
-0.0141322725,
-0.0134769948,
0.0157682095,
-0.0159109682,
-0.0228905473,
-0.069853209,
0.0249320287,
0.0392283686,
0.0241133478,
0.0299813915,
-0.0072466051,
0.0623586476,
0.0328058824,
-0.057174243,
-0.0010344675,
0.0541467592,
-0.0291647725,
0.0330269411,
0.0137651376,
-0.0154490108,
0.0052553583,
-0.0072381836,
0.0328570716,
-0.0182935968,
0.0462875627,
-0.0244999994,
-0.0121737486,
0.0372962467,
-0.0490646735,
0.0465605445,
0.0266043935,
-0.0531363599,
0.0654453784,
-0.0472662896,
0.0197794568,
-0.0187166519,
-0.0092532141,
-0.047275085,
-0.0348945633,
-0.0438453183,
-0.0033185857,
-0.0182655063,
0.0200022683,
0.0090216985,
-0.0251154434,
-0.0150722628,
0.0283411387,
-0.0089688404,
0.0101967799,
0.0039644009,
-0.0267040562,
-0.0444595963,
-0.0210847091,
0.0304277986,
0.0787555128,
0.002284742,
0.0140272044,
-0.0021839351,
-0.0765145421,
-0.0190016143,
0.0309369676,
-0.0221697204,
-0.0261051264,
0.0354675502,
0.0811106041,
-0.0321159624,
-0.0433478728,
-0.0296945944,
0.0403790101,
-0.009068463,
-0.0740714595,
0.0161275938,
-0.0642410293,
0.0439990312,
-0.0124222152,
0.0380831733,
-0.0598380342,
-0.0012309533,
0.0041701975,
-0.0291169733,
0.0385157429,
-0.0210880432,
-0.0015203792,
0.0178675503,
-0.000537144,
0.0251932964,
0.0816979781,
0.0141339181,
-0.0203086995,
0.0504514165,
-0.009786916,
-0.0378280096,
0.0874628723,
0.0110752629,
0.0622281246,
-0.0378682874,
-0.0133798216,
0.0428272672,
0.0168513432,
0.046374999,
0.027050361,
-0.0017883431,
0.0167661142,
0.0564485192,
-0.0041065207,
0.0121305613,
0.058632154,
0.0263619591,
-0.025976127,
-0.0101004364,
-0.0109337727,
-0.0367884189,
0.0079910439,
-0.0063277441,
0.0076059145,
-0.0036943194,
0.0627311096,
-0.0435256176,
-0.004121182,
-0.0095407646,
-0.0320276842,
-0.0114089027,
0.0289336499,
0.083760336,
0.0196623169,
-0.0181297902,
0.0879795551,
0.0766304806,
-0.0240313802,
0.0391639099,
-0.0440783165,
-0.0083189784,
0.0339993797,
0.0226817261,
-0.038795732,
-0.0291131698,
-0.0282930788,
0.0256556086,
0.0304320604,
0.0627666935,
0.0067792232,
0.0524544194,
-0.0666679591,
0.0010870147,
0.014238419,
0.0237368364,
0.0609681085,
0.0178726856,
0.0506979562,
-0.0071841925,
-0.0178762767,
-0.0326008238,
0.037749853,
-0.0962351188,
-0.0139975771,
-0.0018305387,
-0.0059273974,
-0.0035399832,
0.0207834952,
-0.0170201454,
-0.0229710173,
0.0185929835,
-0.0488665402,
-0.006753217,
0.0200271625,
-0.092835471,
-0.0131605798,
0.0652284175,
0.0448345169,
-0.0177202467,
-0.0098690726,
-0.0256205238,
-0.0500164442,
0.0187670309,
-0.0054696221,
0.0461635217,
-0.0825306848,
-0.0013057489,
-0.019784566,
0.0344875157,
-0.0064969156,
0.0408333242,
-0.0205702297,
-0.0064691622,
0.0185156595,
-0.0109073035,
0.0001200476,
-0.0486123562,
-0.0387080647,
0.0402088314,
-0.0034328988,
0.0389564149,
-0.01385138,
0.0166892242,
-0.0167982541,
-0.033797916,
-0.0795579106,
0.0086443285,
-0.0289093368,
-0.0021007238,
-0.0162378214,
0.0187938288,
-0.0202108491,
-0.0233889315,
-0.0188605022,
-0.0129707977,
0.0023617861,
0.0286630075,
-0.0174223799,
-0.0042343466,
-0.007401986,
-0.0087770214,
-0.01437019,
0.0424082652,
0.0442334563,
-0.0604835376,
-0.0178732704,
-0.0589625426,
0.017658541,
-0.0385763869,
0.0090666078,
-0.0116194412,
-0.0194166247,
-0.0186461303,
-0.0400685109,
0.0156046487,
0.0379547328,
-0.0224775597,
0.012939984,
0.0728246272,
-0.0196965691,
-0.041165527,
0.0114643723,
-0.002685247,
-0.0439065211,
-0.0375200137,
-0.0092337262,
-0.0349489897,
0.0579797179,
-0.0325338319,
-0.0050830003,
-0.0302341562,
-0.0387216136,
-0.0331112929,
-0.0175093748,
-0.0318090729,
0.0473485515,
-0.0399826467,
0.0038745862,
-0.0076296516,
-0.0455180518,
0.038543243,
-0.02101353,
-0.0307994857,
-0.0290571004,
-0.0122040631,
-0.0348657183,
0.0138060972,
-0.0098694647,
0.0391347967,
-0.0089990385,
-0.0323976949,
-0.0500235632,
-0.001240416,
0.0133031197,
-0.0133281946,
0.0373928472,
-0.0235597175,
-0.0038618909,
-0.0060403547,
-0.033613719,
-0.0350173414,
0.0057827299,
-0.0126550198,
0.0409391969,
-0.0385173075,
-0.0096428506,
-0.0375041738,
-0.022646578,
0.0422780998,
0.0493992567,
0.0109815719,
0.016281601,
-0.015576941,
0.0321434326,
0.0413824953,
0.0450845137,
0.0408882983,
-0.0669248104,
0.0435065292,
0.0333696939,
0.0355959609,
-0.034779653,
-0.0253134836,
0.014194251,
0.0234851632,
0.0015060024,
-0.011179938,
0.0009941373,
0.0038975489,
-0.051457122,
-0.0240699891,
0.0728803352,
-0.0039406479,
-0.0464348309,
0.002913943,
-0.0189291332,
0.0729865506,
0.0279237721,
0.0469654687,
-0.0837645307,
-0.0237270091,
0.0326916799,
0.0160504468,
0.0383096561,
-0.0029440867,
-0.0318840444,
-0.1094025671,
0.009948696,
0.030303942,
-0.0539958514,
0.0101687415,
-0.0565440208,
-0.0119513348,
-0.0147832613,
0.0324504115,
-0.0020302371,
-0.0256219991,
-0.0457721688,
0.0199053027,
-0.0122587085,
-0.0709599182,
0.0359071158,
-0.0177249033,
0.0473292954,
0.0358869471,
0.0142559838,
-0.01783856,
0.0123795141,
0.066371873,
-0.0100593464,
-0.0046474501,
-0.0182205271,
0.0137638645,
0.01355277,
-0.0176070947,
0.0379675813,
0.0180253163,
-0.0204608887,
-0.0173608642,
0.018944554,
0.0993907005,
0.0244771391,
-0.0047255559,
0.0285558142,
-0.054938361,
0.0044821994,
0.0563849099,
0.0037136965,
-0.0554114319,
-0.0196287986,
-0.0082850382,
-0.0433258191,
-0.0122585157,
0.0255444739,
0.0236702915,
-0.0477448478,
-0.0416590124,
-0.0393344127,
-0.0338121727,
-0.017119633,
0.0178088229,
0.0376345776,
0.0198234562,
-0.0129639283,
-0.0011033862,
-0.0171811618,
0.0172302853,
-0.0631681979,
0.0121683646,
-0.0539335646,
0.0087822182,
0.0379231907,
-0.0271328352,
0.0000817152,
-0.0094607882,
-0.0756774917,
-0.06141809,
0.0045478665,
0.0693459362,
0.0134385843,
0.0723537505,
0.0133267315,
-0.0580437183,
0.0473645106,
0.0167951342,
-0.0236998685,
0.0284079928,
0.0714573488,
-0.0092200907,
0.004259211,
0.0523275211,
-0.0224018991,
0.0123279439,
0.0203537513,
0.0457212329,
-0.0355385244,
0.0309783388,
-0.0082613518,
-0.0304922834,
0.0001549708,
-0.0506165549,
-0.0053107133,
-0.0620253272,
0.0338595174,
0.0003496603,
-0.0025084652,
-0.0399205722,
0.0010336594,
0.0478105992,
0.0223685373,
0.0079078674,
0.0040399702,
0.0428153798,
0.0190950986,
-0.0090540498,
0.0172483716,
0.007886,
-0.0013293178,
0.0386275724,
0.0395152308,
-0.0271389969,
0.0302121546,
-0.016394712,
0.0291992109,
-0.0558112115,
0.0437466651,
-0.0000495882,
-0.0260476861,
-0.0227975473,
0.0042785653,
-0.0009325792,
-0.0569314025,
-0.0036383439,
0.0342559591,
0.0945698544,
-0.0082840119,
0.0907082409,
-0.0157270767,
-0.0273115318,
-0.0362484604,
-0.0054207607,
-0.0229022503,
-0.0553151332,
0.0072596725,
0.0101729278,
-0.0018220922,
0.0431918651,
0.0573032163,
0.0010424604,
0.0160496868,
-0.0301527157,
0.0427156501,
-0.0263827089,
-0.0091111073,
0.0255531725,
0.0207382478,
-0.0297398958,
0.0279798135,
-0.0296543371,
-0.0814722329,
-0.0158294085,
-0.0316801667,
-0.0153686786,
0.0046242652,
0.0055860193,
0.0361308865,
-0.0468008742,
0.0118738227,
-0.054271169,
-0.0024584096,
0.0342949294,
-0.0066157933,
0.0346238017,
-6.678406585e-33,
0.0090075219,
0.0364302285,
0.0265857335,
-0.0336664319,
-0.0262281019,
-0.00902119,
-0.0370224342,
0.0105145955,
-0.0168023985,
-0.0076559838,
-0.0193573758,
-0.0238698758,
0.0098950043,
0.0553097874,
0.0151019581,
0.0249176063,
0.0636283159,
0.0133539271,
0.0226937532,
0.0351828039,
0.0559195206,
0.0517380275,
0.0811990499,
-0.032225389,
-0.0002896935,
-0.0001186254,
-0.0056755934,
0.0280294344,
0.0147789977,
0.063558951,
-0.029345993,
0.0388132185,
0.0102602215,
-0.0405100659,
-0.0351523533,
-0.0228221156,
-0.0861375928,
-0.0237412844,
-0.0008399283,
0.0171650145,
0.0080063138,
-0.0353395529,
0.0092394352,
-0.0137989484,
0.0001909145,
-0.0329209976,
0.0053314851,
-0.0461142883,
-0.0662863404,
0.0350846499,
-0.0680958927,
0.0342362262,
0.0247389209,
0.0058508618,
0.0273523349,
0.0057271216,
-0.0139007559,
-0.0077794841,
-0.0706216246,
-0.0033233745,
-0.0120098665,
0.035542734,
0.0732037351,
0.0418877117,
-0.0076874853,
0.0481450818,
0.0292812549,
-0.0098323505,
0.0463371836,
0.0074851089,
0.0719133094,
0.0095897708,
0.0329715386,
0.0220910925,
0.0230671689,
-0.0329660848,
-0.0553586744,
-0.0339802466,
0.0321611986,
0.0591981895,
0.0386721268,
0.0126697244,
0.0052631865,
-0.0295983404,
-0.0358011648,
-0.0110543324,
-0.0411654077,
-0.0219239816,
0.0438716486,
0.024881456,
-0.012521036,
-0.0072394116,
0.0620815605,
-0.0418450572,
-0.0378062911,
0.047519628,
-0.0101863919,
0.016520381,
-0.0137835573,
0.0540884659,
-0.0790653527,
-0.0574552938,
-0.0413043164,
-0.0467159711,
-0.0206888486,
-0.0179076884,
0.0759874582,
0.0511890948,
-0.0751164556,
0.0091147814,
-0.0390566438,
0.0041623595,
0.0424398333,
0.0548806973,
0.0287768897,
0.002653626,
0.0074945055,
0.066145137,
0.0489157215,
-0.0320939682,
-0.0440131128,
-0.0163739603,
0.0064257346,
0.0305469185,
-0.0170483775,
0.0134466337,
-0.0547149181,
-0.0200164337,
0.0348180309,
-0.063648738,
0.0009952682,
0.0161139164,
2.804e-7,
0.0164984409,
0.0349009037,
-0.0271158684,
-0.0358037278,
0.0291557275,
0.007879016,
-0.0542213544,
0.0292425398,
0.008734053,
0.0546100512,
-0.0138226477,
0.0594576783,
0.0685923323,
0.0219232664,
-0.0848963782,
0.0139337387,
-0.0414292403,
0.0365372375,
-0.0542880036,
0.0002403425,
-0.0105939321,
0.1064023525,
-0.0045523294,
-0.0274817739,
-0.0102567617,
-0.0647081062,
0.0974545702,
-0.0236035474,
-0.0009846726,
0.015392215,
-0.0036340128,
0.0765004531,
-0.016836714,
-0.0321142226,
-0.0362259187,
0.0385433175,
-0.0034344825,
0.0748358145,
0.0168812871,
-0.0391671434,
0.0544120781,
0.0011242857,
-0.0534713715,
-0.0624691881,
0.0617937334,
-0.0276036654,
-0.0025902689,
-0.0463355444,
0.004065576,
0.0004881556,
0.0298860837,
-0.0488143116,
-0.0491441153,
0.0221877918,
0.0426305383,
0.0050874981,
-0.0466168337,
-0.0641403794,
-0.0234748889,
0.0153898271,
-0.0512422137,
-0.0533322357,
-0.0271053705,
-0.0160167962,
0.0011861763,
-0.0427687056,
0.0107948678,
2.582081478e-34,
0.0419941656,
-0.0220518783,
0.0096315006,
0.0411563143,
-0.0111915814,
-0.0419325046,
0.0263581108,
0.0359796658,
-0.0061496766,
-0.0586895682,
-0.0041574277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17456v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17456v1 | Improving Grammatical Error Correction via Contextual Data Augmentation | 2024-06-25T10:49:56 | 2024-06-25T10:49:56 | Yixuan Wang, Baoxin Wang, Yijun Liu, Qingfu Zhu, Dayong Wu, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Nowadays, data augmentation through synthetic data has been widely used in
the field of Grammatical Error Correction (GEC) to alleviate the problem of
data scarcity. However, these synthetic data are mainly used in the
pre-training phase rather than the data-limited fine-tuning phase due to
inconsistent error distribution and noisy labels. In this paper, we propose a
synthetic data construction method based on contextual augmentation, which can
ensure an efficient augmentation of the original data with a more consistent
error distribution. Specifically, we combine rule-based substitution with
model-based generation, using the generative model to generate a richer context
for the extracted error patterns. Besides, we also propose a relabeling-based
data cleaning method to mitigate the effects of noisy labels in synthetic data.
Experiments on CoNLL14 and BEA19-Test show that our proposed augmentation
method consistently and substantially outperforms strong baselines and achieves
the state-of-the-art level with only a few synthetic data. | [
0.0480468646,
0.0860085115,
0.0054011517,
0.03234905,
-0.0017373461,
0.0201845858,
0.0009598091,
-0.0376506783,
-0.0419835337,
-0.0743856505,
-0.0102809584,
-0.0375799201,
-0.0000380507,
0.0067877583,
0.0498700626,
-0.0359769128,
0.0523751378,
0.0284270402,
-0.0125519456,
0.0184124969,
0.0046062339,
-0.0024229237,
-0.0160870291,
0.0183273833,
-0.0821487829,
-0.0128239729,
0.0016032932,
0.0365519002,
0.0198130812,
-0.0253638607,
0.0759903342,
0.0725220963,
-0.0106412377,
0.0573812835,
0.000001829,
-0.0386914387,
-0.0207795557,
0.0054947501,
-0.0355684496,
0.0318937153,
0.0280662943,
-0.0233188979,
-0.077937834,
0.0179798305,
-0.0080113271,
-0.027032746,
0.0573189408,
0.0187609084,
0.0493110083,
0.1055562645,
-0.0084586069,
-0.0200447608,
0.0322840586,
-0.0023642087,
0.00384647,
0.0145294927,
0.0448137224,
0.0134197399,
-0.034292873,
-0.0213016607,
-0.0349581502,
0.0373540632,
0.0263139457,
-0.037464302,
0.0209661666,
0.0066426443,
0.0031720956,
0.0050167046,
-0.0208642669,
0.031287685,
0.0029988841,
-0.0454028137,
-0.0238541141,
0.0026760343,
0.0229509082,
-0.0298768934,
-0.0102687655,
0.0159180518,
-0.0066243964,
0.0377523489,
0.0588135831,
-0.0680143312,
0.0178331286,
-0.0106452126,
0.0043413462,
0.0207460076,
0.0249756426,
-0.0637732074,
-0.0532796569,
0.0398849808,
-0.0160763655,
-0.0541719981,
0.0146482512,
-0.0273044799,
-0.0461959764,
0.0077005527,
-0.0744736642,
-0.0970030203,
-0.0073953611,
-0.0220709667,
0.0125475135,
0.0040300963,
-0.0411702804,
-0.0177093558,
-0.0006938146,
0.0183426421,
0.0563843995,
0.0223952495,
-0.0133377537,
-0.0026885732,
-0.0168101266,
0.0257685501,
-0.0539667457,
0.0144636799,
-0.0709380731,
0.0308724586,
-0.0890681744,
-0.0012994788,
-0.0462723188,
0.0156799965,
0.0319779404,
0.000101072,
-0.0635454655,
0.0081255836,
-0.0021907648,
-0.0238775667,
0.0026754646,
0.0377521142,
0.0213367958,
-0.0695644617,
-0.0111337528,
-0.0109929563,
0.049199257,
-0.0160634685,
-0.0087994598,
-0.0032095553,
-0.0087478729,
-0.0206476972,
-0.0702554658,
-0.0034969286,
-0.0178327635,
-0.0070273844,
-0.0775158033,
-0.0638387874,
-0.0192235373,
-0.0436037928,
0.0095751788,
-0.0199999027,
-0.0006156507,
-0.0064514801,
0.0065627466,
0.079102084,
-0.0918965489,
-0.0068420502,
-0.0081213899,
-0.0289035849,
0.0326465219,
0.0161202066,
0.0255211703,
-0.0580018051,
0.0454059653,
0.0109868785,
0.0506928675,
0.0109326132,
-0.0073953629,
-0.0424862429,
-0.0112591963,
-0.0471930876,
-0.0033674659,
0.0274180826,
0.0680497214,
0.0606381185,
-0.0348911956,
0.0411787927,
0.035545636,
-0.0274485964,
0.0509766042,
0.0045062075,
0.0594759136,
-0.043682225,
0.0008287339,
0.0102853579,
-0.0525769703,
-0.037976373,
-0.0487249531,
0.0092369523,
0.0098185781,
0.0162015054,
0.0052879504,
-0.0675855875,
0.0017541163,
0.0034111866,
-0.0237870868,
-0.0325447358,
0.024019096,
0.06527289,
-0.0115220295,
0.0213587657,
0.0381205082,
-0.0884812102,
-0.0051835445,
0.0071372883,
-0.0028274462,
0.0591563955,
0.0584918931,
0.0081007192,
-0.0554365888,
-0.0232199151,
-0.0209558215,
0.0237075724,
0.0419872329,
-0.0233533569,
0.0065397867,
-0.0588251576,
-0.0051360102,
0.0059184274,
0.0444904268,
-0.0193472523,
0.0332197808,
-0.0000736121,
0.0176172946,
-0.0180293303,
-0.0615255609,
0.0376202688,
-0.0086205006,
-0.0308337957,
0.0081312945,
-0.0016186386,
0.0323654115,
0.0258510374,
-0.0390220694,
-0.0078184167,
0.000728517,
-0.0029231943,
-0.0149529381,
0.0083429618,
-0.0517419167,
-0.0849395916,
0.0356286466,
-0.0237564705,
-0.051470723,
0.0036276719,
-0.0594658107,
-0.0523449183,
-0.0266177543,
-0.0464364626,
0.020070672,
-0.0642726049,
0.0388614796,
0.0273792446,
0.0018301521,
-0.0328955837,
0.0322500952,
0.0138610536,
0.0206261314,
-0.0155204628,
0.0472853072,
-0.0061445702,
-0.0411150083,
-0.0139265992,
-0.0316100083,
-0.0267929304,
0.0362953953,
0.0043499712,
0.0249213055,
-0.0635552332,
-0.0060152332,
-0.0625771731,
-0.0160164703,
-0.0438268855,
0.0212562717,
0.0518630743,
0.010729434,
-0.0328267887,
-0.0335362293,
0.0078141289,
0.003194449,
0.0170885846,
-0.020052569,
0.0543874018,
-0.0054490152,
-0.0472233668,
-0.0594911389,
0.0258247107,
-0.0226381235,
-0.0277381614,
0.0094749201,
-0.0169160347,
-0.0547348708,
0.0555238165,
0.0009443497,
0.0563872792,
0.0358144119,
-0.0542395823,
0.0009374053,
-0.0045137559,
0.0567262396,
-0.00604286,
-0.0164414365,
0.0282029435,
0.0016893627,
-0.0372841731,
-0.0237366725,
0.0096945222,
-0.0032791141,
-0.0060958345,
-0.0242026728,
-0.0357523859,
0.0260486789,
0.0588867851,
-0.003299423,
-0.0297550838,
0.0092386315,
0.0221772548,
-0.0142775364,
-0.0238821041,
-0.016480552,
0.0052970159,
-0.0324851535,
0.0217453744,
-0.0425498523,
-0.0184083041,
0.0612872876,
0.0118628843,
-0.0095667476,
-0.0692907646,
-0.0113478806,
0.0012392449,
-0.0390833355,
-0.0014466767,
0.0107842023,
-0.0034073275,
-0.031001756,
-0.0294186901,
0.0078583332,
0.0593069829,
-0.0053605544,
0.035351757,
-0.0916974321,
0.0252879392,
0.0219666846,
-0.0344754234,
-0.048072163,
-0.0202725157,
0.017159719,
-0.0441870838,
0.0271961149,
-0.0240216013,
0.0052025546,
-0.0524552576,
-0.0104491105,
0.0738593638,
0.008591258,
-0.0289532375,
-0.0162976272,
0.0230995826,
0.0063904286,
0.0213370044,
0.0049283486,
0.0109424442,
0.0066065174,
0.0558532961,
0.0005272305,
0.0395943932,
-0.0386149697,
0.0184012372,
0.0226998143,
-0.0057547502,
-0.0305958651,
0.0141828209,
0.0565057956,
-0.0440598987,
-0.0440938137,
0.0959606394,
0.0439916141,
-0.0145030394,
0.0083640488,
0.0050362623,
0.0061277673,
0.0159041788,
0.0219165124,
-0.0754059628,
-0.0084344633,
0.0402294323,
0.0296046995,
-0.0233014505,
-0.0030099035,
0.0172277968,
-0.138417393,
0.0703651309,
0.0278365277,
-0.0481491871,
-0.0502354465,
0.0135649424,
0.0310684592,
-0.0053497097,
0.0595270433,
0.0338082165,
-0.0140648363,
0.0066908686,
0.0462808162,
-0.0129316039,
-0.1312606782,
-0.05498017,
-0.0495056659,
0.100121811,
0.0304468591,
0.0059446422,
0.0103919776,
-0.016954042,
0.0604551062,
0.0074095046,
-0.0291993432,
-0.0022268847,
0.0459886007,
0.0246330611,
-0.0142904036,
-0.005808284,
0.0450766832,
-0.0170972999,
-0.0126491375,
-0.0112194158,
0.0548603013,
0.0111984406,
0.0399234742,
0.0119876247,
-0.0226047393,
0.0326899588,
0.0336705931,
0.0537542179,
-0.0079611242,
-0.0176746901,
-0.06159091,
0.0077450792,
-0.0772951543,
0.0604338199,
0.0464964211,
-0.0668227524,
-0.0636784732,
-0.0860433429,
-0.0812599063,
0.0242863093,
0.0166151542,
0.0273248702,
-0.0363178104,
-0.0420690291,
-0.0215760395,
-0.0048385318,
-0.0051064342,
-0.0082304329,
0.0234290659,
-0.0549444258,
-0.0127352178,
-0.0271625221,
0.0298480541,
0.0008799544,
0.0092025679,
-0.024056742,
-0.045662351,
0.0822826698,
0.0421149991,
0.0016329819,
0.054766003,
-0.0252481606,
-0.0356130004,
0.0078876177,
0.0879531056,
-0.0097879646,
0.0247466955,
0.048258841,
-0.0187097061,
0.0223343205,
0.0094635412,
-0.0194704849,
0.028294405,
0.0128414305,
0.0714614764,
-0.0473150015,
0.0048251855,
0.0791578963,
0.0491969138,
0.0525500886,
-0.0250750072,
-0.0186537486,
-0.0647233501,
0.0168907791,
-0.0543111674,
-0.0279427804,
-0.0289925467,
0.0294653606,
0.021938974,
0.0017215725,
-0.0209676865,
0.0089155659,
-0.0506008975,
0.0096725887,
-0.0377676152,
-0.0269157197,
0.0421590246,
0.0336783268,
0.0292485524,
0.0220787395,
0.0011470284,
-0.0031338618,
0.0621751063,
0.0428717099,
-0.0030210174,
-0.0171063859,
0.03130446,
0.0023234598,
-0.0276877396,
-0.0039715338,
-0.0340085328,
0.0719485655,
-0.0760855079,
0.0105350986,
0.0784424245,
0.0129447272,
0.0884583592,
-0.0397187471,
-0.0147538306,
-0.0023876096,
0.0426373929,
0.0198366083,
-0.01181449,
0.012317664,
-0.0156568624,
0.0043707802,
-0.047070317,
0.0251129661,
-0.0303285643,
0.0554364771,
-0.0431875214,
-0.0201581735,
-0.0349203013,
0.0163419638,
0.0020373785,
-0.0202657469,
0.0037098303,
-0.0138758635,
-0.030725738,
-0.0812837034,
-0.0231013577,
0.0699823797,
0.0146047799,
-0.001724969,
0.0098351417,
0.0299513787,
-0.0112978043,
0.0130122108,
-0.0292399451,
-0.0141256703,
0.0347168632,
-0.0528160557,
-0.0408586226,
-5.760102317e-33,
-0.046506919,
-0.0020201241,
-0.0159698911,
-0.0396301448,
-0.0273162276,
0.0019292715,
-0.0284633972,
-0.0035877384,
0.0566220395,
0.0579326525,
-0.0097899446,
0.0290341619,
0.0143434526,
0.0315422192,
0.0305254404,
0.0316998996,
0.0846555009,
0.0197641961,
-0.0030021016,
-0.0291074682,
0.0333194472,
0.0526228696,
0.0910546929,
-0.059061069,
0.0503813587,
0.0395704471,
-0.0311868861,
0.0430925004,
-0.0042153737,
0.036251273,
0.0352370031,
0.0634718984,
0.0026238381,
0.0256232508,
-0.0339678079,
-0.0385516621,
-0.0930127203,
-0.0410872735,
0.0061171483,
0.0358106382,
-0.0187192522,
-0.0226159543,
0.0538987666,
-0.0286922548,
-0.0190257337,
0.0249900129,
0.0155136874,
-0.043826621,
0.0161554664,
-0.0093283979,
-0.0432074741,
0.0168753378,
0.0214335099,
0.0016734024,
-0.0203736778,
0.0198005494,
0.0043120319,
-0.037227843,
-0.0482254252,
-0.0105891554,
0.0530247018,
0.035612341,
0.0213258509,
-0.0050805127,
-0.0536575653,
0.0232907645,
0.0233641937,
0.0064487364,
-0.0043159006,
0.0052567781,
0.0072995103,
0.0163432397,
0.0142508466,
0.0824302658,
0.072829701,
-0.0264377389,
-0.0081900973,
0.0419210717,
-0.0291745886,
0.0149093503,
-0.0428844504,
0.0029521741,
-0.0400527194,
-0.0322809182,
-0.0213754829,
0.0207233895,
-0.0109885093,
0.015614124,
0.0426753126,
0.0147592546,
-0.0256967209,
0.0120751308,
-0.0401892811,
-0.0164725892,
-0.0170621555,
-0.0387686007,
0.0028707767,
0.0167980473,
-0.0079832925,
-0.0271519925,
-0.0111883851,
-0.0105223656,
0.0415106006,
0.0516690947,
0.0059030615,
0.0054644006,
0.0561279953,
0.0341444574,
-0.0566529818,
0.0325868353,
-0.020906752,
0.0405225866,
-0.0082825236,
-0.0373911336,
0.0095327832,
0.0028755767,
0.0027840431,
0.0043623117,
0.0415451266,
0.030952204,
-0.0159685276,
0.0022303443,
-0.009199243,
0.0302926172,
-0.0028305801,
-0.007581362,
-0.0055779284,
-0.0004310017,
0.0465438776,
-0.0422161333,
0.0041269735,
-0.0122011881,
2.491e-7,
0.033579234,
0.0418945923,
0.0418379232,
-0.0072901561,
0.0062271222,
0.0022092997,
-0.0045640813,
0.0085837748,
0.0145315509,
0.0465077721,
0.0305190347,
-0.0294673312,
0.0380017236,
0.0237686802,
-0.0346918739,
-0.0288921259,
-0.0368131995,
-0.0010824038,
-0.0141861774,
0.0121105574,
0.0371619649,
0.0531155728,
0.0372665115,
-0.0328681059,
0.0117072342,
0.0107813505,
-0.0002661637,
-0.0136096589,
-0.0229583848,
0.0324955359,
0.0558543801,
0.019692257,
0.0524061993,
0.007399552,
-0.0500879511,
-0.0263036154,
-0.0187351331,
-0.0095046433,
-0.0015830373,
0.0540757291,
-0.0025329506,
0.0127303628,
-0.0026728881,
-0.0343763717,
-0.0025413572,
-0.0348432921,
0.0386836864,
0.0166575518,
-0.0668008178,
0.0179205071,
-0.0182357226,
-0.036731638,
-0.0419368781,
-0.0052377633,
0.0612279363,
0.048484467,
-0.0345680639,
-0.0303487293,
-0.0182275027,
0.0303725246,
0.0186185576,
-0.0284411442,
0.035444174,
-0.0000485343,
0.0101551106,
-0.0462677889,
0.0100171389,
2.324295567e-34,
0.0575281456,
0.0140758054,
0.0565637425,
-0.0013253848,
0.0257886797,
0.0065900353,
0.0155796269,
0.0284912866,
-0.021088317,
-0.023734685,
-0.0301294327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17453v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17453v1 | Learning to Ask Informative Questions: Enhancing LLMs with Preference Optimization and Expected Information Gain | 2024-06-25T10:44:01 | 2024-06-25T10:44:01 | Davide Mazzaccara, Alberto Testoni, Raffaella Bernardi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Questions are essential tools for acquiring the necessary information to
complete information-seeking tasks. However, large language models (LLMs),
especially open-source models, often perform poorly in generating informative
questions, as measured by expected information gain (EIG). In this paper, we
propose a method to enhance the informativeness of LLM-generated questions in
20-question game dialogues. We sample multiple questions from the same model
(LLAMA 2-CHAT 7B) for each game and create pairs of low-EIG and high-EIG
questions to apply a Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) algorithm. Our
results show that this method produces more effective questions (in terms of
EIG), even in domains different from those used to train the DPO model. | [
0.0852891281,
0.0241740458,
-0.0191720072,
0.0566105433,
-0.0231182557,
0.0159345455,
-0.0470653996,
0.0014540971,
0.0393054374,
-0.0085631255,
-0.0429281481,
-0.040981628,
-0.0167025384,
0.0089007635,
0.0338601433,
-0.0433989502,
-0.0035010173,
-0.0262330193,
0.0142636653,
-0.0184563417,
0.0095777428,
-0.0188744031,
-0.0275768805,
0.0318366438,
0.0270013306,
-0.0055920123,
-0.0408615768,
0.0219724569,
-0.013712734,
-0.0482655168,
0.0233940408,
0.0308588352,
-0.018482944,
-0.0387399942,
0.0000020419,
-0.0437852889,
-0.0138835981,
-0.0436030924,
-0.0301397722,
-0.0295333918,
0.0253387596,
0.047359813,
0.0350742936,
0.0363519192,
-0.0453371257,
-0.0010216904,
0.0443155318,
0.0294856448,
0.0509131774,
0.0721214637,
0.008655631,
-0.0102052595,
0.0255077276,
-0.0255341101,
0.0738680214,
-0.055027172,
-0.0018565471,
0.0236806795,
0.0074580777,
0.0446665883,
0.0156338513,
0.006015237,
0.00244484,
-0.0126436334,
0.0232868325,
0.0437858813,
0.0224005021,
0.0032306612,
-0.0150890294,
0.1129423305,
0.025479598,
0.014182264,
0.008520348,
-0.0006227989,
0.0517319553,
-0.0212420896,
-0.0530695878,
-0.0069745937,
0.0125308735,
-0.0191216506,
0.01711783,
0.0154560823,
0.0056186789,
0.0061960989,
-0.0068147015,
0.0667974353,
-0.0103684561,
-0.0289135929,
-0.0192880575,
-0.0273249056,
-0.0539928004,
-0.0794932321,
-0.0218137335,
0.0405785069,
-0.0629138723,
0.0525953695,
-0.0031588711,
0.0186008085,
0.0109197358,
-0.0220654272,
0.0130673032,
0.0359233096,
-0.008637161,
0.0474534109,
0.0230441689,
0.0329229422,
-0.003315839,
0.0080674188,
-0.0695146769,
0.006264769,
-0.0023622094,
-0.016676778,
-0.0375537351,
0.0563431643,
-0.0514969602,
-0.0397490747,
-0.0159633476,
0.0634630099,
0.0523585714,
0.0220256951,
0.0275383014,
0.0146478927,
-0.0118970629,
-0.0044268882,
-0.0793242976,
-0.0110122636,
-0.0606055595,
0.0143632246,
0.0416180938,
-0.068309404,
-0.0034471699,
0.0088998592,
0.0060509094,
-0.0125655867,
0.007425447,
0.0618174486,
0.0014897144,
-0.0318634063,
-0.009738734,
-0.0167271998,
-0.0146633992,
-0.0265341215,
0.0056511005,
-0.0392851457,
0.0339338779,
-0.0114109376,
-0.0037203694,
-0.0054156207,
0.0202440247,
0.0174714141,
-0.012935739,
0.0531872846,
-0.0082621444,
0.0144364843,
0.0582150705,
-0.0033767861,
-0.0188163705,
0.0766928196,
0.0387750641,
0.0120579004,
0.0586444326,
0.0089566596,
-0.0045881914,
0.0319427028,
0.0062976647,
-0.0064531686,
0.0134809352,
0.0349660963,
-0.0101474198,
0.0623461306,
-0.0012405374,
0.061524421,
-0.0426382944,
-0.035158854,
0.0796047002,
0.0248341542,
-0.0018899465,
-0.0314150192,
0.0197900999,
0.0547306314,
-0.0182306804,
0.031389229,
0.0166152883,
0.0631305724,
-0.0156460237,
-0.0096752932,
0.0367191024,
0.0030568414,
-0.0397232212,
-0.0780169442,
0.0269679893,
-0.0116926478,
0.0137938485,
0.0698584914,
0.0095912265,
0.0013773078,
-0.0596357174,
0.041592747,
0.0307688694,
-0.0127820065,
-0.0288150478,
-0.05881951,
0.0759307072,
0.0242441166,
0.0588752776,
-0.0190284252,
-0.0710303038,
-0.0096822521,
-0.0273590274,
0.042694781,
0.0508353412,
-0.0248080641,
0.0306243543,
-0.0571824834,
-0.0288374964,
-0.0383507609,
0.0038854918,
0.0243918598,
0.0056118658,
-0.0190426931,
0.0087530334,
-0.0428298935,
0.013035927,
0.0250459556,
0.0115100406,
-0.0408472717,
0.0398306996,
0.0019212207,
0.0051819328,
-0.0052350443,
0.0308527537,
0.0135092167,
0.0217092875,
-0.0095841624,
-0.0394873694,
0.003721897,
-0.0383138917,
-0.0550526083,
0.0310520325,
-0.0148868756,
0.0074806302,
0.0241167545,
-0.0209895447,
-0.0074786502,
-0.0156474747,
-0.0250330959,
0.060525693,
-0.0327858813,
0.0188162345,
0.0213815514,
-0.0009811957,
-0.0818041414,
0.0628572032,
-0.003878532,
-0.0079216091,
0.0080920393,
-0.0381537043,
0.0180222429,
-0.0609875359,
0.0484852307,
0.0509397425,
-0.0253147036,
-0.0255728737,
0.0169077367,
0.0362963378,
-0.0942014083,
-0.0495242476,
-0.0869617835,
0.0297026597,
-0.0064261919,
0.0155181587,
0.03628207,
0.0230199415,
-0.0154322227,
-0.0050640157,
-0.0868680477,
-0.0093870405,
0.0005388863,
0.0020908955,
0.0596826933,
0.0487465002,
0.0173044689,
-0.0333534442,
-0.0020464403,
0.008941656,
0.0050097494,
-0.0218277574,
0.0357314236,
-0.0320283994,
0.0378323197,
-0.0532224365,
-0.0075906208,
-0.0158714429,
-0.0233957376,
0.0135178845,
-0.0282876659,
0.0358256586,
0.0786333084,
0.0378397405,
-0.0063484535,
0.0250251833,
-0.0094731925,
-0.0674949884,
0.0268661659,
-0.0203327239,
-0.0217816625,
-0.027651567,
-0.0386126414,
0.0616234727,
0.0237105805,
-0.0066767903,
0.0019216342,
-0.0597008392,
0.0311933402,
-0.004011861,
-0.0229186844,
-0.0571283661,
-0.002265899,
-0.0028352716,
0.0325662121,
-0.0319552906,
-0.015868634,
0.0714852065,
-0.0024647089,
-0.008135356,
-0.0815644711,
0.0178094003,
-0.0458122455,
0.0179073978,
0.0103896121,
0.0184594672,
0.0322090611,
-0.0445445664,
-0.07880909,
-0.0224136002,
0.0483228341,
-0.0381986238,
0.0134933665,
-0.0286989156,
-0.0310336463,
0.0418771692,
-0.0718356669,
-0.0540953986,
-0.0539737716,
0.000997067,
-0.0419642963,
0.0466301031,
-0.0050780256,
-0.0195022449,
-0.0180561207,
0.0413881429,
-0.0063126357,
-0.0305225495,
-0.0405678824,
-0.0055744061,
0.0782106072,
0.0993624255,
0.0077738818,
0.0068934136,
-0.0448355414,
0.0543375015,
0.0397904143,
-0.0045259804,
-0.0311844461,
0.0439543314,
-0.0023305581,
0.0473207831,
-0.0290990453,
-0.0330500901,
0.0402999558,
0.0509114563,
-0.0049003395,
-0.0067807683,
0.1186404824,
0.0647438467,
-0.0208796114,
-0.0020197467,
-0.0310134254,
0.0473121926,
0.022247659,
0.0422772616,
-0.0770666897,
-0.0309844837,
-0.0069658444,
0.0169649255,
-0.0384345353,
-0.0233277846,
-0.0118739763,
-0.1297053844,
-0.0193256959,
-0.0215647649,
-0.0149149336,
0.0124113681,
-0.0008735112,
-0.0120035913,
0.0010224471,
-0.0032469886,
0.0140604749,
0.015707003,
0.022650633,
0.0169406421,
-0.0272827744,
0.0146869672,
0.0028337326,
-0.00477672,
0.0454805717,
0.0814671516,
0.0484765358,
0.0211097002,
-0.0141628738,
0.0198978763,
0.0001117679,
-0.0269550588,
-0.019536132,
0.0626464859,
-0.0283150878,
0.000516177,
-0.0318227187,
0.0546725504,
0.0209752191,
0.0202418324,
0.0313605145,
0.005886557,
0.0016182197,
-0.0087345885,
0.0166186597,
0.0175891556,
0.0210905392,
0.0545571446,
0.025356533,
-0.0485390164,
0.0499499701,
-0.0358572602,
-0.0087094996,
-0.0698655471,
-0.0131563842,
-0.0313454494,
0.0638930947,
0.0400880687,
-0.1159410849,
-0.0215187706,
0.0165410284,
0.0062029897,
-0.0122052999,
0.0168799292,
-0.0238858387,
-0.0027089203,
0.0206160564,
-0.0089647938,
-0.0377986096,
-0.0373055823,
-0.0787761137,
-0.0200515557,
0.0513841137,
-0.0799848214,
-0.0121776517,
0.0126264337,
-0.0380814038,
-0.0612418242,
-0.0350459181,
0.0823683366,
0.0136330584,
0.0049036271,
-0.0156358909,
-0.043974217,
-0.0204969626,
0.0024026316,
-0.012123866,
-0.0216933005,
0.0001927018,
0.0392892882,
0.0159689672,
0.0266531594,
-0.0391803756,
0.0081248041,
-0.0073915841,
0.0360107198,
-0.0364750214,
-0.0795799643,
0.0375586785,
0.0468228944,
0.0237490218,
-0.0038244585,
-0.0138644073,
-0.0191863701,
0.0712229759,
-0.0251419023,
-0.0064056334,
-0.0425746404,
0.0233198814,
0.0367157906,
-0.0083865114,
0.0088502774,
-0.0124164829,
-0.0428739376,
0.0173458587,
-0.0261043422,
-0.0287322495,
0.0341442116,
-0.009615995,
0.0198373087,
-0.0058938293,
0.0084893135,
0.0482058562,
0.0415926762,
0.0701271072,
0.0245833658,
0.06721358,
0.0093460865,
-0.0579721332,
0.0041514672,
0.0233089011,
-0.0119077442,
-0.0700727552,
0.0013602863,
0.0287866946,
0.0429623313,
0.02271045,
-0.007238395,
0.0030613497,
-0.0008249193,
0.015825849,
0.0154792396,
0.0017716916,
-0.0576875061,
0.0596480779,
0.0332141742,
-0.0211483072,
0.0123658059,
0.0470158011,
-0.0026478276,
0.0481384657,
-0.0241401903,
0.0077053732,
-0.0483222716,
0.0013351842,
0.0348937288,
0.060957253,
-0.0536493696,
0.0403098837,
-0.0248617269,
-0.0141371125,
-0.0403130874,
0.0252175704,
-0.0061994167,
-0.0312731229,
0.0469620414,
0.0413522944,
-0.0166670848,
-0.0232576579,
-0.0696051791,
0.0056252712,
-0.0770024061,
-0.0084744906,
0.0072872266,
-6.504002162e-33,
-0.0139438808,
-0.0320700966,
0.0161297731,
0.0023909891,
-0.0401870497,
-0.0293004047,
-0.0353555158,
0.0300762504,
-0.0600165501,
-0.0239164978,
-0.0242090877,
0.0115890289,
-0.0052003423,
0.0102029126,
-0.0284658894,
-0.0580461435,
0.0100715421,
-0.0033685432,
-0.0464396141,
0.0344592109,
0.021962842,
0.0254471898,
0.0008999566,
-0.0179761536,
0.034730535,
-0.0297964942,
-0.0048552989,
0.0532014035,
-0.0052962359,
0.0517082922,
-0.0128634097,
-0.0090670539,
0.0124450633,
-0.0448337458,
0.0169008803,
-0.0044360785,
-0.0203992426,
-0.025489321,
0.0133982282,
-0.0304815043,
-0.0413774997,
-0.0350178219,
-0.0041965926,
0.0114892498,
0.0385525152,
-0.0132133737,
0.0241997857,
-0.0015540821,
-0.02594864,
0.0121116703,
-0.0226225387,
-0.0107828649,
-0.0412764139,
-0.0553857535,
-0.0146328043,
0.0887085721,
0.0163189117,
0.0130186826,
0.0198096223,
0.0635015592,
0.013291005,
0.0323245451,
0.0260814745,
0.0251891501,
0.008470498,
0.0063268482,
0.0132694645,
0.0004768855,
0.0104793608,
-0.0149645135,
-0.0028708235,
0.0317663401,
0.0100054517,
0.035526786,
0.0329082869,
0.0107634878,
-0.0701974854,
0.056684006,
0.0461299829,
0.0036663439,
-0.0157826841,
-0.0045940168,
-0.0446537957,
0.0083820689,
-0.057899233,
0.0478456244,
-0.0346430577,
-0.0547279418,
0.0307576749,
-0.0095950672,
-0.0138603626,
-0.0628858879,
0.0116425548,
-0.0131934546,
-0.0050511076,
0.0076432745,
-0.0484374762,
0.0333727598,
-0.0234944168,
0.0174405407,
-0.0538302697,
0.0118707241,
0.0343735553,
-0.0139977001,
-0.0369398408,
0.0570722297,
-0.0107054142,
-0.0109353736,
-0.0453420319,
-0.0086919507,
-0.027118681,
0.0318810456,
-0.0281115063,
0.0178946517,
-0.0168861467,
-0.0060836454,
-0.0354055688,
0.0486767329,
0.0034615302,
-0.0119257644,
-0.0662334859,
-0.0587764792,
-0.0089754928,
0.0130863022,
-0.0329207592,
0.0158920083,
-0.0070257224,
0.0157293361,
-0.0350963771,
-0.0217966624,
-0.0438285209,
-0.0166383516,
2.836e-7,
0.0021283652,
0.0531777292,
-0.0169137809,
0.0609411895,
-0.0437095948,
0.0591010675,
-0.0075337901,
-0.009588778,
0.0701711476,
-0.0375220999,
0.0545816123,
0.0375000276,
0.0469519645,
-0.0221124478,
-0.1342182159,
-0.0481115058,
-0.0138115184,
-0.0113154165,
-0.0037047146,
-0.0196910352,
0.0646603927,
0.0614072867,
0.0039452957,
0.0177903324,
-0.0118615944,
0.0009938969,
0.0508863814,
-0.0440952219,
-0.0295169298,
0.0683400705,
0.0536376573,
0.0000189771,
-0.027114924,
-0.0170277953,
-0.0225190669,
0.0197593141,
0.0075329328,
0.0464387946,
0.0211270992,
-0.0679550767,
-0.0100849457,
0.0222713612,
0.0010568053,
-0.0626076385,
0.0885925367,
-0.0215756223,
-0.0409902483,
0.0031006848,
0.0056014629,
-0.0357621722,
0.0115367491,
-0.0751127154,
-0.041363284,
-0.0248507801,
0.0069918418,
-0.0073137926,
0.0206431467,
-0.0378955007,
-0.0206889752,
-0.0055439342,
-0.0206874795,
-0.0537613519,
-0.0385451615,
0.000091239,
-0.0384851135,
-0.0068293842,
0.013341465,
2.176695721e-34,
0.0084045408,
0.0106186597,
0.0018916052,
0.028296629,
0.0220306683,
0.0029958924,
0.0317734592,
-0.0180378817,
0.0598504469,
-0.0721482113,
0.0278147869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17430v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17430v1 | Towards Probing Speech-Specific Risks in Large Multimodal Models: A Taxonomy, Benchmark, and Insights | 2024-06-25T10:08:45 | 2024-06-25T10:08:45 | Hao Yang, Lizhen Qu, Ehsan Shareghi, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) have achieved great success recently,
demonstrating a strong capability to understand multimodal information and to
interact with human users. Despite the progress made, the challenge of
detecting high-risk interactions in multimodal settings, and in particular in
speech modality, remains largely unexplored. Conventional research on risk for
speech modality primarily emphasises the content (e.g., what is captured as
transcription). However, in speech-based interactions, paralinguistic cues in
audio can significantly alter the intended meaning behind utterances. In this
work, we propose a speech-specific risk taxonomy, covering 8 risk categories
under hostility (malicious sarcasm and threats), malicious imitation (age,
gender, ethnicity), and stereotypical biases (age, gender, ethnicity). Based on
the taxonomy, we create a small-scale dataset for evaluating current LMMs
capability in detecting these categories of risk. We observe even the latest
models remain ineffective to detect various paralinguistic-specific risks in
speech (e.g., Gemini 1.5 Pro is performing only slightly above random
baseline). Warning: this paper contains biased and offensive examples. | [
0.0252624582,
0.0494991876,
-0.0458958447,
0.0238553062,
-0.0162799712,
0.0063962331,
0.0316260457,
0.0142824994,
-0.0465020426,
-0.0563084297,
-0.0740729645,
-0.0367299877,
0.0168144107,
0.0181793235,
0.0627092123,
-0.0653272346,
0.0429248363,
-0.0419078544,
0.0161084738,
-0.0045354823,
0.0636499524,
0.0268197395,
-0.0397268757,
0.0651483163,
-0.0590233617,
0.0037454956,
0.000918293,
0.0521258004,
0.0254801065,
-0.0111882277,
0.0101714227,
0.0344085768,
0.0317386389,
0.0368938893,
0.000001723,
-0.0520628951,
0.027305875,
-0.0141232107,
-0.0133395866,
-0.0381130464,
0.0813445598,
-0.0024833991,
-0.0197533872,
0.0376408882,
-0.0225257371,
0.0024359999,
0.0510474741,
0.0044626798,
0.030595379,
0.0239555612,
-0.0052715307,
0.002551053,
0.0091715716,
-0.0104003269,
0.0094055543,
-0.0375628471,
0.0210010111,
-0.0303859785,
-0.0244823359,
-0.0262430459,
-0.0360454731,
-0.003184773,
-0.0359975286,
0.0027159215,
-0.0073557226,
-0.0160493311,
0.0080383122,
-0.0836037993,
-0.0000786182,
0.0867874548,
-0.0137012759,
0.0215715822,
-0.0092075272,
0.0214877967,
0.0052783373,
0.0204523709,
-0.0028345431,
0.0152137382,
0.015141909,
-0.0438804999,
-0.0546643585,
0.0271714199,
0.0231769774,
0.0258185323,
0.0589360669,
0.0114501305,
0.0085565932,
0.0062332307,
0.028382713,
-0.0587527305,
-0.0115812868,
-0.001224216,
-0.0133053279,
-0.0175540633,
-0.0529319048,
0.0138594946,
-0.0760842189,
-0.0401701555,
0.033849448,
-0.054282546,
-0.0001276746,
0.0091656847,
-0.062285576,
0.0280830227,
0.0596785285,
-0.0037945102,
-0.0326863155,
-0.0069415388,
-0.006246442,
-0.006087915,
0.0074504269,
-0.0013792885,
0.0259572435,
-0.034387093,
-0.0177381057,
-0.0131257838,
-0.0247839931,
-0.0214011688,
-0.0701573342,
-0.0324874334,
-0.0294769946,
0.0253364816,
-0.0406966321,
0.0248556156,
-0.0027212347,
0.0055521117,
-0.0036554164,
0.0660284609,
-0.035305094,
-0.1047718301,
-0.0005429902,
0.0285515357,
0.0103512323,
-0.05588663,
0.0178592671,
0.1078227684,
0.0224555098,
-0.0348639488,
0.0021844946,
-0.058287397,
-0.0653234273,
-0.0446018092,
0.0483190231,
-0.0099526644,
0.0134660052,
-0.0378005058,
-0.0133189261,
-0.0154191563,
0.0117848869,
-0.0111213094,
-0.0294049885,
0.0863062218,
0.043051146,
0.0093225427,
0.0449649431,
0.0475918055,
-0.0653003529,
0.0444120504,
0.0376379043,
-0.029321909,
0.0369979925,
-0.0342723988,
-0.0039318241,
0.0707266629,
0.0248119533,
0.0160990749,
-0.0250469893,
-0.0017159343,
-0.0046886527,
0.007808283,
0.0553360805,
0.0237853266,
-0.0265291948,
-0.0884366781,
0.087717481,
0.0464196131,
-0.0603079759,
-0.019457208,
0.0294095017,
-0.0115831047,
-0.0144123575,
-0.0222348217,
-0.052247528,
-0.0071264072,
-0.0356282964,
-0.0525882468,
0.0257558301,
0.0347366109,
-0.0104183108,
0.0415683836,
-0.0152363833,
-0.0260037165,
0.0279461667,
-0.0024463295,
-0.0104352161,
0.0189537071,
-0.0150967706,
-0.0044946587,
0.0218996778,
-0.0319394022,
-0.0015384129,
-0.0217213184,
-0.0103569478,
0.037679974,
0.0039263298,
-0.0075130803,
-0.0054013007,
-0.0713880286,
-0.0460183732,
0.0102354493,
-0.0129962368,
-0.0092415512,
0.0915618762,
-0.0232918505,
-0.0030622333,
0.0156893637,
0.007345981,
0.0257462133,
0.0187461115,
0.0154474042,
-0.0239043757,
-0.0013498977,
0.0473878905,
-0.0020038765,
-0.0143707218,
-0.0253143553,
-0.0345106013,
0.01211196,
0.1012749895,
0.0013331469,
-0.0444641411,
-0.0237487033,
-0.0058893994,
0.0020000113,
-0.0013499643,
0.0620407537,
-0.0426247008,
-0.025174493,
0.0350617021,
-0.0499200672,
-0.0320419148,
0.056151621,
-0.0169475079,
0.0317261368,
0.0562681966,
-0.0597599708,
-0.003651628,
-0.046497345,
-0.0251642074,
-0.0147621594,
0.0523640849,
0.0188971832,
0.0133707384,
-0.0238192305,
-0.0498213992,
0.0246043205,
-0.0180905517,
-0.0160105154,
-0.0298021361,
-0.0720830038,
-0.0146778151,
-0.012702235,
0.0259100962,
-0.0259655621,
-0.0267632622,
-0.0351404473,
0.0075382455,
-0.0826272592,
-0.0252529047,
-0.0067035831,
-0.0360099562,
0.0012252878,
-0.0176468883,
-0.0023871125,
-0.0158984717,
0.0313218497,
-0.0264374185,
0.012424632,
0.0543736741,
-0.0493930317,
-0.0177278463,
-0.017447317,
-0.0186313372,
0.0009501331,
-0.0105573405,
0.0709037706,
-0.0377132148,
0.0031947291,
0.0366673209,
-0.0180985387,
-0.0342982858,
0.0520080775,
-0.0084730433,
-0.0517624058,
0.0252804179,
0.0340376496,
0.037803866,
0.0437517315,
0.0611630455,
0.0653476119,
0.0226288494,
-0.0278032254,
-0.0024388372,
0.0035167178,
0.0067574279,
0.010841772,
-0.020293735,
-0.0654095411,
-0.0410995856,
0.0434146896,
0.0562759899,
0.028786324,
-0.0497654192,
0.0088594994,
-0.0127849532,
-0.0967252702,
-0.0131821446,
-0.0621856824,
-0.0551652089,
0.0091263996,
-0.0025180478,
-0.049758397,
0.0520370044,
-0.0350003392,
-0.0242170375,
0.0346637554,
-0.0421429761,
0.0217097625,
0.0573648177,
-0.0069193328,
0.0305492021,
0.0419493616,
-0.0032627427,
-0.0354033485,
-0.0405095816,
0.0588031858,
-0.0302336812,
0.0105652595,
-0.0212702509,
-0.0200079493,
0.0171520375,
-0.0367150903,
-0.0063099153,
-0.0452692322,
-0.0258355103,
-0.0305439569,
-0.0167949162,
-0.017286351,
0.011352364,
0.0271027237,
0.0093401717,
-0.0304306056,
-0.0198573396,
0.0251200423,
0.0102346512,
0.0155516798,
0.0777076706,
0.0458028503,
-0.0021429097,
-0.0188965723,
-0.0030187054,
0.030258663,
-0.0292142723,
0.0016276854,
-0.0458120257,
0.0377077162,
-0.002309256,
0.0781622082,
-0.0194835514,
0.0110307736,
0.0287609566,
-0.0010392949,
0.0411751531,
0.0504798815,
-0.030517038,
-0.0125940135,
0.0184861757,
-0.0021739805,
0.0095541086,
0.0127110258,
-0.0537098944,
-0.0522450432,
-0.0414607525,
0.0241059884,
0.0113845244,
-0.0407486148,
-0.0107426932,
0.0055371695,
-0.0665589273,
0.0417462885,
-0.0061661243,
-0.0378261767,
0.0018503865,
0.0218338314,
0.0233345516,
-0.0289869104,
0.069478862,
-0.0028495542,
0.0066944784,
-0.0179676041,
0.0081205405,
-0.0578781143,
-0.0544428863,
0.0431331843,
-0.0259200539,
0.0592337437,
0.0171328466,
0.038143307,
-0.0433400571,
-0.0215897355,
-0.0064849318,
0.0047178082,
0.0121472059,
-0.0175412614,
0.0665614009,
-0.023092512,
-0.0028566422,
-0.0139608365,
0.0461772457,
0.041101139,
-0.002605743,
-0.007294517,
0.0240503307,
-0.0286691263,
0.0194751248,
-0.0581129678,
0.0508090779,
0.0346997418,
0.0469908081,
0.0047616954,
-0.0663442537,
0.019979706,
0.0135951117,
0.0129626179,
0.0208076742,
-0.0461323969,
-0.0028145534,
0.0214621108,
-0.0710759759,
-0.0357534252,
-0.0024236029,
-0.0193384737,
0.0202927738,
-0.0026113077,
-0.0234099329,
-0.0551731028,
0.0377136171,
-0.0417757183,
0.0420224294,
0.0381241255,
0.0463188887,
0.0041878419,
0.0507072397,
-0.0030846668,
-0.0617088899,
-0.0160369761,
0.0583944879,
-0.0709093213,
-0.0623408891,
0.0360528864,
0.068589747,
0.024679523,
0.0461141653,
0.0032528799,
-0.0647011697,
0.0531995669,
-0.0185382497,
-0.0195831843,
0.0685717762,
0.0668445304,
0.0031841269,
-0.0131775895,
0.0179048199,
-0.0130440397,
0.0139484173,
-0.0071628541,
-0.0264610872,
-0.0605621077,
-0.0473526753,
-0.0457670763,
-0.0021513442,
0.0507914871,
-0.015603804,
-0.0120335743,
-0.0071137762,
0.0081440946,
0.0303723942,
0.036186371,
-0.0368214659,
-0.0119869607,
0.0084529286,
0.0200662129,
-0.0218828283,
-0.0315166339,
-0.0365210772,
0.0182786528,
-0.0001786561,
0.0410076119,
0.0457659513,
-0.0110477386,
-0.006521516,
0.049407661,
-0.011836553,
0.0373994745,
-0.0374270268,
-0.0230627526,
0.0307815392,
0.0345712081,
0.0094148088,
-0.0180193614,
0.0365071148,
0.0299464576,
0.0211193729,
0.0113183754,
0.008327215,
-0.002020851,
0.0044052368,
0.0188754201,
0.0571246296,
-0.0022780725,
0.0096135316,
-0.0193429068,
0.036780864,
-0.0464689247,
-0.052347146,
0.0644042864,
0.0100637935,
-0.0119092595,
0.03489374,
0.0462189093,
0.0140419304,
0.0411802679,
-0.0163874459,
-0.0208887886,
-0.0308480449,
-0.0153232226,
0.0665364265,
0.021397274,
-0.0047729146,
0.0040381611,
-0.0705914423,
-0.0567383245,
0.021838529,
-0.0279587042,
0.0106874639,
-0.0204447731,
0.0318193845,
0.0271198675,
0.0095658256,
-0.0096147545,
0.012918232,
-0.0407188497,
-0.0194862671,
-0.0028691164,
0.043599721,
-5.612743079e-33,
0.0006423697,
-0.0285350624,
-0.0324396938,
0.003291057,
-0.0228066929,
0.0091245575,
0.0010650832,
0.0066273543,
-0.014038777,
-0.0067663607,
0.0518502481,
0.0058040675,
-0.0024267596,
-0.0324308351,
-0.0147231547,
-0.030470727,
0.0361703895,
-0.025192108,
0.0093951533,
-0.0167343803,
0.0630168021,
0.0144366557,
0.0299882572,
-0.0988852382,
0.0161494128,
0.0171119552,
-0.0842496678,
-0.0062131672,
-0.0218973327,
0.0636926442,
-0.007590726,
0.067339994,
-0.0069654766,
-0.0119437454,
0.0103351064,
0.0404682048,
-0.0339352116,
0.005789273,
0.0417494029,
0.0280814245,
-0.0207810365,
-0.0040306062,
0.0234987009,
0.0139082987,
-0.0335409939,
-0.0373921692,
0.0259076003,
-0.0068281377,
0.0500250645,
-0.021380784,
-0.0424828641,
0.0052596522,
-0.0167090092,
-0.0386627652,
0.0037466462,
0.0686302036,
0.0036766147,
-0.0040748995,
-0.0306919534,
0.0374508686,
-0.0644281209,
-0.0338009149,
0.0214292314,
0.0342649147,
0.0181832947,
0.0765345544,
0.0242913757,
-0.0329490267,
0.0154176541,
-0.0446097851,
0.0413664319,
0.0844583586,
-0.0009999577,
0.0949646384,
0.0052964999,
-0.0325280726,
-0.0315314233,
-0.0106941229,
0.0477806255,
0.0084975474,
0.0254574958,
0.0020999003,
-0.0315568708,
-0.0148109021,
-0.0431731865,
-0.0098557035,
-0.0233228151,
-0.0274532009,
0.030254025,
-0.0186454151,
-0.0116126053,
0.0081676645,
0.0779090747,
-0.0239867251,
0.0158291887,
-0.0089882296,
-0.0002014355,
0.0172426421,
0.0067406562,
0.0295042172,
0.0058769486,
0.0051389881,
0.0838453546,
-0.0480960235,
0.0651277453,
-0.0082832091,
0.0374033265,
0.0640529767,
-0.0387875028,
-0.0125605073,
0.0264470801,
0.0778267682,
-0.0140013583,
0.0454665311,
0.0386076532,
0.0344465896,
-0.0367975459,
-0.0160199534,
0.037665125,
0.0289382152,
-0.0470795445,
0.0062231068,
-0.0431701355,
0.0187122431,
-0.0285772104,
0.0006683783,
0.0035475376,
-0.0834343508,
0.0405554734,
-0.0706944689,
-0.0104037542,
-0.0260105859,
2.627e-7,
-0.0254461151,
0.0486482307,
-0.0014299148,
0.0242221076,
0.0655919686,
0.084519133,
0.0035509104,
0.0747207999,
0.0275667254,
-0.0357983783,
0.0240050685,
-0.0110421292,
0.0630148128,
0.0863637403,
-0.0062427423,
-0.0200650673,
-0.0674458221,
0.0053165643,
-0.0256193038,
-0.0147511233,
0.0325613357,
0.0585241392,
0.034794908,
-0.0581562147,
0.0243490711,
-0.0122551546,
0.0251241848,
-0.0268838406,
-0.0002797696,
-0.0676855817,
0.0038048725,
-0.0347746648,
0.0162165165,
0.0606060475,
-0.0004741025,
-0.012733859,
-0.0061354917,
0.0446023159,
-0.036122445,
-0.0799801275,
-0.0132144652,
0.0334116258,
-0.0701904893,
-0.0269661993,
0.0375131741,
0.03033581,
-0.0513840839,
-0.0356642343,
-0.0398138054,
-0.0000269436,
0.0461673439,
-0.042902682,
-0.0062647653,
0.0039288667,
0.0321970992,
-0.0118841035,
-0.0319835395,
-0.0780645907,
0.003780114,
-0.0031114414,
-0.0693616048,
-0.080823794,
0.0094348723,
0.0067191441,
0.0154711809,
-0.0585904308,
-0.0116775483,
1.798763611e-34,
0.0077074086,
-0.0188035369,
0.012891178,
-0.0434949808,
0.0439844877,
0.0175787527,
0.0029369737,
-0.0040961993,
0.0365849547,
-0.0082050292,
-0.0174819157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17419v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17419v1 | Leave No Document Behind: Benchmarking Long-Context LLMs with Extended Multi-Doc QA | 2024-06-25T09:42:56 | 2024-06-25T09:42:56 | Minzheng Wang, Longze Chen, Cheng Fu, Shengyi Liao, Xinghua Zhang, Bingli Wu, Haiyang Yu, Nan Xu, Lei Zhang, Run Luo, Yunshui Li, Min Yang, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Long-context modeling capabilities have garnered widespread attention,
leading to the emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) with ultra-context
windows. Meanwhile, benchmarks for evaluating long-context LLMs are gradually
catching up. However, existing benchmarks employ irrelevant noise texts to
artificially extend the length of test cases, diverging from the real-world
scenarios of long-context applications. To bridge this gap, we propose a novel
long-context benchmark, Loong, aligning with realistic scenarios through
extended multi-document question answering (QA). Unlike typical document QA, in
Loong's test cases, each document is relevant to the final answer, ignoring any
document will lead to the failure of the answer. Furthermore, Loong introduces
four types of tasks with a range of context lengths: Spotlight Locating,
Comparison, Clustering, and Chain of Reasoning, to facilitate a more realistic
and comprehensive evaluation of long-context understanding. Extensive
experiments indicate that existing long-context language models still exhibit
considerable potential for enhancement. Retrieval augmented generation (RAG)
achieves poor performance, demonstrating that Loong can reliably assess the
model's long-context modeling capabilities. | [
0.0414836071,
0.022398496,
0.0138266915,
0.0483694263,
-0.0133890808,
-0.01294926,
0.0272810236,
-0.0125013348,
-0.0263807382,
-0.0521165207,
-0.0067091766,
-0.0401103981,
-0.0326946415,
-0.0394474901,
0.030805869,
-0.0043788636,
0.0533271879,
-0.0281887054,
-0.0078684725,
-0.0211611837,
0.001094845,
0.0023278384,
0.0279049557,
0.0323269032,
-0.0123230731,
-0.0450405739,
-0.0344276614,
0.0075932965,
-0.0112167429,
-0.032880608,
0.0206325985,
0.0178906657,
0.0320405327,
0.0183050763,
0.0000018583,
-0.0679193363,
-0.031888105,
0.015087775,
-0.0415210426,
0.0311929081,
0.0056248889,
0.0273801815,
0.0242158007,
0.0086093917,
-0.012987677,
0.0278852787,
-0.0052380618,
0.0155933322,
0.0372979157,
0.056197837,
0.0139321983,
-0.0348671973,
0.0291490722,
-0.0375622623,
0.0749065727,
-0.0788923353,
0.0106364898,
0.008427253,
0.0728129745,
0.0100786658,
-0.0086524123,
0.0372318402,
0.0342867672,
0.0033855832,
-0.0276618209,
0.0316305272,
-0.0296872593,
0.0477465875,
0.0111443494,
0.0641560405,
0.0338753834,
0.0000421,
0.0088395132,
0.0249732956,
-0.0027945586,
-0.0305163283,
-0.071818471,
0.0213285889,
-0.0024341515,
-0.0272057112,
0.0413759276,
0.0041899551,
0.0311459452,
0.0240961686,
-0.0327982716,
0.0648839325,
0.0367665552,
-0.041950278,
-0.0226396676,
-0.0123769613,
-0.0460682027,
-0.0452398062,
0.0090661105,
0.0866798982,
-0.0240283832,
0.0291620772,
-0.0081478627,
-0.0398762226,
0.079007104,
-0.0066109365,
-0.0163362529,
0.0206887033,
-0.042106092,
0.0726716965,
-0.0471503995,
0.0428914838,
-0.0300433431,
-0.0484822132,
-0.0593312085,
-0.0430124514,
-0.0070218821,
-0.0461130887,
-0.0530103855,
0.0472908765,
-0.0512952432,
-0.0355388783,
-0.0093222614,
0.0353771709,
0.0031799991,
-0.0127651012,
-0.0003991711,
0.0266708173,
-0.0375817828,
-0.0156562869,
-0.0119529171,
0.0161642469,
-0.0680184066,
0.0204228275,
0.0245506112,
-0.0370716341,
-0.023600217,
0.0302823652,
0.0040933918,
-0.0390018784,
0.0233622212,
0.0612185486,
-0.010054484,
-0.0357573926,
-0.0167251527,
-0.0523436889,
-0.0488082767,
-0.0491749011,
-0.0084324395,
-0.0819313377,
0.0241787024,
0.0111790271,
-0.0207596011,
0.0191667266,
0.0087111788,
0.0303075537,
0.0125332884,
0.0330715477,
0.0292453859,
0.0053454991,
0.0518866703,
0.0283782035,
0.0182442833,
0.0624945313,
0.0067586564,
-0.0055306694,
0.0514567979,
0.0319991186,
0.0006165746,
0.0333105177,
0.0338197574,
0.0312165152,
0.0248721093,
0.0624791943,
0.0153806303,
0.0329603814,
0.0223596711,
0.0384876467,
-0.0397314839,
-0.0430938266,
-0.0101553071,
0.0493929833,
0.0345147029,
-0.0122438967,
0.0292682499,
-0.0143364584,
-0.0118140439,
0.0160573702,
-0.0162396114,
0.0229251049,
-0.0613861308,
0.0315475687,
0.0474565737,
-0.0035300269,
-0.0556448586,
-0.0016699734,
-0.0182025861,
0.002342039,
-0.0072037759,
0.0056986702,
0.0316185206,
0.0077209244,
-0.0366756208,
0.0670313761,
-0.0012988163,
-0.0426289216,
0.0085207848,
-0.0505227484,
0.0606180504,
0.0271356422,
0.0679695457,
-0.051476974,
-0.0345767662,
0.0041526794,
0.0440313146,
0.025837779,
0.0153774256,
-0.0153061915,
0.0269465782,
-0.0125289625,
-0.0058323825,
-0.0575382411,
0.0003465592,
0.0165382344,
0.0399054699,
0.0092317732,
0.0472607538,
-0.0689669251,
0.034654472,
0.0221140031,
-0.059882205,
-0.0351151675,
-0.013933287,
-0.0021748699,
0.0071745315,
0.03253337,
0.0057216068,
0.0334040783,
0.0442249514,
-0.044453878,
0.004377929,
-0.0108917765,
-0.0779246092,
-0.0398123786,
0.0377514549,
-0.0114119686,
-0.0125514232,
-0.0032928896,
-0.0154684791,
-0.0445673913,
-0.0156584699,
-0.0291255433,
0.0393354483,
-0.0466269776,
0.0049365945,
0.0213595033,
0.0076356675,
-0.0534174368,
0.0761328861,
-0.0097777313,
0.0325542316,
0.0515125655,
0.0662530512,
0.0281926077,
-0.0737893358,
-0.0217714049,
0.0089025237,
-0.0058214767,
-0.0042808163,
0.0157512706,
0.0149087179,
-0.0606704317,
-0.0438415967,
-0.1044662967,
0.0272464994,
-0.0411640629,
0.0208483394,
0.0235050619,
0.0132384114,
-0.0031966961,
-0.0009929228,
-0.0650902241,
-0.0012924527,
0.0398663916,
0.029573027,
0.0100687621,
0.0337876566,
-0.0105133317,
-0.0561906435,
-0.0216959771,
0.0017865439,
0.0474784337,
-0.0064713894,
0.0136708803,
-0.0420633182,
0.0118773365,
-0.0358455852,
0.0073170639,
-0.0312097091,
0.0156201171,
0.0169430003,
-0.047223758,
0.0475713126,
0.0255102273,
0.0136579676,
-0.0182286073,
0.0210788436,
-0.0300183278,
-0.0636166707,
0.0283331387,
-0.0099368449,
-0.0226570051,
-0.0180066023,
-0.0012620274,
-0.0082242712,
0.0250730421,
-0.0057022609,
-0.0232414305,
-0.0238623116,
-0.0020105713,
0.0042904401,
-0.0242763348,
-0.042764131,
-0.0291429795,
-0.0036742075,
0.0231915452,
-0.0305803493,
-0.0164089818,
0.0542771406,
-0.0397714823,
0.0011176411,
-0.046142485,
0.0184185635,
-0.0712056383,
0.0823466927,
-0.0246436782,
0.0060321591,
-0.0660767406,
-0.0201838166,
-0.0192942861,
-0.0000145115,
-0.0342455432,
-0.0418941788,
0.0581140593,
-0.0177091621,
0.0379769616,
-0.0182382576,
-0.03103902,
-0.0348557942,
-0.0260936767,
-0.0009746365,
0.0286373142,
0.0056109419,
0.0273340587,
0.0057185069,
0.0034012515,
0.0390554629,
0.0438457131,
-0.0190242659,
-0.0007880231,
-0.013201355,
0.0798203945,
0.0657164529,
0.0148111805,
0.0336715505,
-0.0307625812,
0.0273777135,
0.0699722245,
0.0715853721,
-0.014436584,
-0.001625534,
-0.0268706828,
-0.000014836,
-0.0193678364,
-0.0236686748,
0.0037213732,
0.0569483899,
-0.0749157146,
-0.0326743945,
0.0824279264,
0.0478458479,
-0.038805984,
0.005591759,
-0.0589653514,
0.0454249494,
0.0197796915,
0.032359086,
-0.0907174572,
-0.0379006304,
0.0054014516,
0.0287923999,
0.0120296637,
-0.0235137083,
-0.0060076062,
-0.0951360017,
0.0098670991,
-0.0139843952,
-0.0402424745,
0.0217025839,
-0.0325993076,
0.0103490483,
0.0564573854,
0.0132822543,
0.0588079132,
-0.0072593866,
-0.0118705453,
-0.014293042,
0.0132769244,
0.0064395247,
0.0705091059,
-0.011504476,
0.0112635409,
0.0559988208,
0.0161163025,
0.0286979172,
0.0010938565,
0.0391912162,
-0.0536115654,
0.0481095873,
0.0066926787,
0.0019560435,
-0.0101312036,
0.0132363709,
0.002757035,
0.035106875,
-0.0371386595,
-0.0045620082,
0.0482731238,
0.0549584217,
-0.0063544889,
0.0034453964,
-0.0286983866,
0.0007380976,
0.0098972451,
0.0862480178,
0.0293169245,
-0.0248483382,
-0.0712791383,
-0.0121822022,
-0.0092121949,
-0.0361981206,
0.0318420455,
-0.0106254509,
0.0110344319,
0.0625250489,
-0.0686761439,
-0.057901673,
0.0125576463,
0.0468839593,
-0.0423970819,
0.0335486792,
-0.0532767661,
-0.0135245025,
-0.0327371471,
0.0264124088,
-0.0443042144,
0.0231089238,
-0.0360303149,
0.0522103906,
0.0434444472,
-0.0352259241,
-0.0063602766,
0.0630643368,
-0.0888989866,
-0.0565422177,
0.0040138592,
0.003235579,
0.0200370308,
0.0359068401,
-0.0156952813,
-0.0551940277,
0.0398740284,
-0.0050096037,
-0.0262564309,
0.0596021265,
0.0146655384,
0.0199790038,
-0.0027545788,
0.0451793335,
-0.0945765674,
0.0067014638,
-0.0145313377,
0.0718645379,
-0.0147120282,
-0.0424419753,
0.0010886416,
0.0161914304,
-0.0390134454,
0.0073452173,
0.0067129228,
-0.000738372,
0.0422300771,
-0.0521941222,
-0.0122750206,
0.0068362779,
0.000808393,
-0.0061190706,
-0.0687358603,
0.0217427928,
0.029894175,
0.0023744314,
0.0540797859,
-0.0345742591,
0.0114604728,
0.0275647212,
-0.0105962632,
0.0147470105,
-0.007672498,
-0.0196823161,
-0.0280586164,
-0.0295238104,
0.060727939,
-0.0304419175,
0.0621991009,
0.0182508957,
-0.0182600431,
-0.0289673321,
0.0114967776,
-0.1034929827,
-0.0150443269,
-0.0166890472,
0.0093355905,
0.0315557942,
0.0078905029,
0.0707637146,
-0.0028506455,
-0.0249579661,
-0.0216908399,
-0.0023179404,
0.0056896266,
-0.0342902876,
0.0261102002,
0.0556427613,
-0.0012596411,
0.0583412945,
0.0726735219,
0.0054387599,
0.0354354233,
0.0102786906,
0.0337977819,
-0.0289164875,
-0.0311826989,
-0.0045108343,
0.0719290376,
-0.011707576,
-0.0052339528,
-0.0353025571,
-0.0445725247,
0.0151040023,
-0.0016830252,
-0.0225176271,
-0.0184134226,
0.037265189,
0.0802596658,
0.022087682,
-0.0211755,
-0.0122492919,
0.0363104045,
-0.043077752,
-0.0138099212,
-0.0159800835,
-6.209246218e-33,
-0.033710707,
-0.0402547792,
0.0527566746,
-0.059495952,
-0.02367137,
0.0242292173,
-0.0538868606,
-0.0002893547,
-0.0283891838,
-0.0203866921,
-0.0339168683,
0.0116398074,
-0.0120780384,
0.0368377417,
-0.0279172268,
-0.0034976632,
0.012453543,
0.0038235569,
0.0024036956,
0.0252679773,
0.0510014072,
0.0125367101,
0.0015980565,
-0.0205633845,
0.0134077361,
-0.0292603988,
0.0049746023,
0.0104584927,
-0.0223296862,
0.0829739422,
-0.0413664505,
0.0250649061,
0.0364438891,
-0.0278233718,
-0.0173713565,
0.0318347439,
-0.0951266959,
-0.0107425814,
0.009694539,
-0.0621610619,
-0.064518705,
-0.0536751226,
0.0304172225,
0.0146629438,
0.0098966267,
-0.0060400679,
0.0097766723,
-0.0299623851,
-0.0411450304,
-0.0247983821,
-0.0512991473,
0.0158418696,
-0.0080682384,
0.004214359,
-0.0368696228,
0.0431482568,
0.0000025517,
0.0784729421,
-0.0713920593,
-0.0055582896,
-0.0207215436,
0.0260849334,
0.0548578985,
-0.0033275685,
0.0000330226,
0.0222867113,
0.0087074814,
0.0183696188,
-0.0082853045,
-0.0541946217,
0.0012617048,
0.020666033,
0.0387842022,
0.0639247149,
0.0385419242,
0.0123653589,
-0.0669280589,
0.0291415192,
-0.0002524648,
0.0287335739,
0.0302148703,
0.0064250855,
-0.0275170803,
-0.0076759313,
-0.0502370149,
0.0330990031,
-0.0375635549,
-0.0116550727,
0.0591705255,
0.0281677768,
-0.0239235125,
-0.0253127962,
0.0431816652,
-0.0332102776,
0.0246188864,
0.0660542324,
-0.0398516953,
0.012761143,
0.0052032489,
0.0536925867,
-0.0389394574,
0.0165470112,
0.0222447626,
0.0027735329,
-0.0195436701,
-0.0003860465,
0.0057670227,
-0.0171164218,
-0.0585375167,
0.0067579844,
-0.0363688245,
0.018605588,
-0.0356876366,
-0.0381539576,
0.0214162301,
0.0034082669,
0.0073828483,
0.0937798545,
0.0249498319,
0.0129939113,
-0.0064481297,
-0.0528687984,
-0.0127426311,
0.0043308195,
-0.0207805727,
0.0445294641,
-0.0180936158,
0.0383680612,
0.0363689512,
-0.0426468663,
0.0021486641,
0.0539095439,
2.509e-7,
0.0455191657,
0.004616105,
0.0686731264,
-0.0001642516,
0.0468134098,
-0.0113195302,
0.0066501237,
0.0151907858,
0.0018419115,
-0.0178311598,
-0.0192404874,
0.0296700913,
0.0314709544,
0.019037094,
-0.0507802181,
0.0268789697,
-0.0696091503,
-0.0120553644,
-0.0524129421,
-0.0353731513,
0.015253731,
0.0775787085,
-0.047103513,
-0.0035509467,
-0.0325399972,
-0.0693618655,
0.0662134066,
-0.0073223114,
-0.0252329316,
0.0187591985,
0.0322218426,
0.0006573363,
0.0283913296,
-0.0426981039,
0.0087730801,
0.0485742576,
0.0072468198,
0.0612584129,
0.0179307759,
-0.0893921107,
0.0223149657,
-0.0364622846,
-0.0071113594,
-0.0528700985,
0.0930974633,
-0.0280981213,
0.0061329356,
-0.0324394815,
-0.0258129463,
-0.0072146291,
-0.0134406062,
-0.0088716717,
0.0088418275,
0.0085033737,
-0.0084876483,
-0.0099698799,
0.011083344,
-0.0929834023,
-0.0303455498,
0.0144027108,
-0.066529654,
-0.0212490298,
-0.0344517343,
-0.0065700365,
0.0031409629,
-0.0775600597,
-0.0015160283,
2.428778647e-34,
0.0414282829,
-0.0190445893,
-0.0033272137,
0.0066001494,
0.027673509,
-0.0120091699,
-0.0490496345,
-0.0027066192,
0.0379336402,
-0.11038699,
-0.0262409989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17415v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17415v2 | Layer-Wise Quantization: A Pragmatic and Effective Method for Quantizing LLMs Beyond Integer Bit-Levels | 2024-06-25T09:37:15 | 2024-06-26T08:00:18 | Razvan-Gabriel Dumitru, Vikas Yadav, Rishabh Maheshwary, Paul-Ioan Clotan, Sathwik Tejaswi Madhusudhan, Mihai Surdeanu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.0 | We present a simple variable quantization approach that quantizes different
layers of a large language model (LLM) at different bit levels. Specifically,
we quantize the most important layers to higher bit precision and less
important layers to lower bits to achieve floating point quantization levels.
We propose two effective strategies to measure the importance of layers within
LLMs: the first measures the importance of a layer based on how different its
output embeddings are from the input embeddings (the higher the better); the
second estimates the importance of a layer using the number of layer weights
that are much larger than average (the smaller the better). We show that
quantizing different layers at varying bits according to our importance scores
results in minimal performance drop with a far more compressed model size.
Finally, we present several practical key takeaways from our variable
layer-wise quantization experiments: (a) LLM performance under variable
quantization remains close to the original model until 25-50% of layers are
moved in lower quantization using our proposed ordering but only until 5-10% if
moved using no specific ordering; (b) Quantizing LLMs to lower bits performs
substantially better than pruning unless extreme quantization (2-bit) is used;
and (c) Layer-wise quantization to lower bits works better in the case of
larger LLMs with more layers compared to smaller LLMs with fewer layers. The
code used to run the experiments is available at:
https://github.com/RazvanDu/LayerwiseQuant. | [
-0.0496628173,
0.0646087602,
-0.0069038668,
0.0488603748,
-0.0157771483,
0.008692909,
0.0146690952,
0.0394858196,
-0.0236210618,
-0.042216219,
0.0238513052,
-0.0384687595,
-0.0101119317,
0.0069977986,
0.0446432345,
-0.0229783431,
0.0616203286,
-0.033278428,
0.0041478286,
-0.0068623275,
-0.0160144512,
-0.0243455432,
0.0581734963,
0.0157770123,
0.0213381667,
-0.0070547471,
-0.0134708043,
0.0110275131,
0.0194024388,
0.0026692904,
-0.0371034555,
0.0208368115,
0.0627285764,
0.0040250095,
0.000002275,
-0.0020688348,
-0.0232527498,
0.0202459209,
-0.0419210605,
0.0763497055,
0.0135889351,
-0.0182902068,
-0.0775115788,
0.0054365685,
-0.0153612876,
-0.0107405204,
0.0631775185,
-0.0157976355,
0.0737337545,
0.050505057,
-0.0058722571,
-0.0337721705,
0.0166476406,
0.0028987473,
-0.0127046872,
-0.0022147307,
0.002740965,
0.0485169888,
-0.0088470755,
0.0144004319,
-0.0287439376,
0.020062523,
0.0028525528,
-0.0116419429,
-0.0137468027,
0.027428858,
-0.0381898731,
-0.0033980366,
0.010977882,
0.038324222,
-0.1153480336,
-0.0180023815,
0.0164713748,
0.0110832388,
-0.0272276085,
-0.0825984254,
-0.0636241063,
0.0497943573,
0.0428398401,
0.0379053988,
-0.0099471519,
-0.0073830914,
0.0496058613,
0.0096946945,
-0.0577464066,
0.0700920373,
0.0164683554,
-0.0023209755,
-0.047237698,
-0.0380563326,
-0.0621866025,
-0.0510673411,
-0.0177330356,
0.0053421888,
0.0390958376,
-0.0073468965,
-0.0425920561,
0.0179997571,
0.0047980794,
-0.0719516799,
0.0269245915,
0.0742520466,
0.0001880102,
0.0295246933,
-0.0363219604,
0.0487655774,
-0.0117000071,
0.0219651833,
-0.0221071467,
0.0400042534,
0.028251145,
-0.0072867605,
-0.0264467355,
0.075092122,
-0.0225543119,
-0.000652979,
-0.0548998229,
0.0062012528,
-0.0058727441,
0.0002806117,
0.0069499845,
-0.0082117282,
0.0142550003,
0.0029970915,
0.047451172,
-0.0053003686,
-0.0211170502,
-0.0017489642,
-0.0093953367,
-0.0450311229,
-0.0120178265,
0.0212476347,
0.0017191414,
-0.0100399638,
0.0221305285,
0.0455873609,
0.0211613867,
-0.0185008086,
-0.0035753385,
-0.0076303692,
0.0123848235,
-0.0464767516,
-0.0238780845,
-0.0694612488,
-0.0279601701,
-0.0093384599,
0.012135542,
-0.0161983706,
-0.0002467311,
0.004639016,
0.0011315114,
0.0433046818,
-0.0179417953,
-0.0069172885,
0.0068940306,
0.030167833,
0.0452972427,
0.0795501247,
0.0633101612,
0.0327999704,
0.0187668484,
-0.0311037581,
-0.0340793729,
0.0344784446,
0.0205200426,
-0.0039588339,
-0.0569095649,
-0.0296422355,
-0.0270738173,
0.0253568236,
0.0847374052,
0.0767311752,
-0.0788328648,
-0.0662864372,
0.019844519,
0.0426407531,
0.0521247275,
0.0354779102,
-0.003210919,
0.0347218364,
0.0146451835,
0.0136466976,
-0.0262756255,
0.0495837219,
0.0217101146,
0.0053879586,
0.0581829809,
0.0453715883,
-0.0225373935,
-0.023931019,
-0.0317483507,
-0.0080383653,
0.0117292264,
-0.005704036,
-0.0091349725,
-0.013545529,
-0.0194410402,
0.122354582,
0.0090979412,
-0.0913670808,
-0.0116805229,
-0.0762936547,
-0.0053216699,
0.0458105914,
0.0173826106,
-0.0042802314,
0.0294186603,
0.0220608152,
0.0213825163,
0.0042288508,
-0.0238343179,
-0.0033111142,
0.0385637991,
-0.0704298094,
-0.0189445764,
-0.0118444832,
0.0075983233,
0.0187771376,
0.0118732722,
0.015049804,
-0.0008591487,
-0.0555165485,
0.0086064776,
-0.002806871,
0.0154236183,
-0.0124249635,
0.0221248735,
-0.0139295384,
0.0168619733,
0.0239385311,
-0.0206119362,
0.0030883059,
0.0526692495,
-0.0374643058,
0.0005959804,
-0.0510510579,
-0.0202125609,
-0.0219758824,
0.057647448,
-0.0058242418,
0.0410303697,
0.033458285,
-0.0737085491,
-0.0377182439,
0.0426841825,
-0.0308848303,
0.0155911837,
-0.0298196729,
0.0120974733,
-0.0172265638,
0.0263812356,
-0.0501574427,
0.0081149144,
-0.0269652419,
0.0148338592,
0.0318303667,
0.006762783,
0.0165917017,
-0.0332254507,
-0.035494633,
0.0078823017,
-0.014213671,
0.0529939197,
-0.0146172037,
-0.0015101507,
0.0170743931,
-0.0159512758,
-0.1001094282,
-0.0125710713,
-0.0218645465,
0.0367769785,
0.0073593934,
0.0524955019,
0.0226195529,
-0.0033310908,
-0.0306109842,
-0.0115031786,
-0.0118823545,
0.0115094017,
0.0049029794,
-0.0186789725,
-0.0258296337,
-0.0556143597,
-0.0560279079,
0.0219367631,
0.0484836102,
-0.0693290308,
-0.0505085364,
-0.0766019523,
0.0042341007,
-0.0254602823,
0.0294914749,
-0.0052973349,
-0.0604143143,
-0.0010237739,
-0.0132648759,
-0.0122412471,
0.0585065074,
0.0009417656,
0.0150318742,
0.0758647174,
-0.0048284214,
-0.0544806309,
0.0219694097,
0.0050725667,
0.0056365021,
-0.0119150328,
-0.0257139876,
-0.0245728008,
0.0894214585,
-0.0203220658,
-0.0135242669,
-0.0373685397,
0.0342582464,
-0.018852856,
0.0043116678,
-0.0132821295,
-0.0088870255,
-0.0112771988,
0.0596500598,
-0.0033488125,
-0.071615085,
0.0158317797,
-0.0419973172,
-0.0073408177,
0.0151268002,
-0.0224022083,
-0.0444285572,
0.0345996544,
0.0065548182,
0.0469949841,
-0.03872291,
-0.0139470249,
-0.060168419,
0.0048458213,
-0.0121745421,
-0.0428553298,
0.0210516024,
-0.0286493655,
0.0418717675,
-0.0430843793,
-0.0241445974,
0.0183773451,
0.0257631522,
-0.0120610772,
0.0389180444,
0.0111390958,
-0.0293571912,
0.0310035795,
0.0732508972,
0.0019806235,
0.0211659893,
0.0062473519,
0.0116406213,
-0.0021157996,
0.019205125,
-0.0137609961,
0.0302861687,
0.0350154452,
0.025400361,
0.0236355104,
0.02933993,
0.0025846211,
0.0736298263,
-0.0582556687,
0.0080084782,
0.0477770828,
-0.0162847284,
-0.048895251,
0.0100990981,
0.0746666119,
-0.0439650267,
0.0040117805,
0.0796609521,
0.0268146321,
-0.0204186961,
0.0325109661,
-0.0192268901,
0.0423949622,
0.0093808211,
0.0198155921,
-0.1066902652,
-0.0176282879,
0.0167331863,
-0.017998606,
0.0187521223,
0.0019017645,
-0.016672736,
-0.0654841065,
0.0218900777,
0.0473015606,
0.0379855894,
-0.0179820247,
-0.0415164158,
-0.0417213105,
-0.0164416209,
0.0445721932,
0.0256603993,
0.000027999,
-0.0094644669,
0.0177906863,
-0.0527381636,
-0.0545939207,
0.0309374891,
-0.0078737941,
0.0486203767,
0.063696973,
0.045139391,
-0.0071505541,
-0.0067671747,
0.0314339437,
0.0208406989,
-0.0133733777,
-0.026452614,
0.0168118794,
0.0429609716,
-0.0022314042,
0.0279941112,
-0.0491182581,
0.0298212934,
0.0201662388,
-0.0314699858,
0.0436292998,
-0.0166672152,
-0.0154695036,
-0.0159022771,
-0.0247242711,
-0.0424324945,
0.0221271329,
0.0271637011,
0.0169629976,
-0.0665628165,
-0.0677699745,
0.0048309858,
-0.0372684859,
-0.0453439802,
-0.0033799838,
-0.0130336015,
-0.038337402,
-0.0223547332,
0.0350231677,
-0.02320816,
0.0005280139,
-0.0182471089,
-0.015701944,
0.0285704415,
0.0114456117,
-0.1054614261,
-0.0253638495,
-0.031851463,
0.0496750511,
-0.0392613113,
0.0108591048,
0.0194050875,
0.0040393532,
-0.0195819996,
-0.0535162948,
-0.1210429445,
-0.0772296339,
-0.0145206321,
0.0362070054,
0.0196324717,
0.0463580191,
0.0031920967,
-0.1066972613,
0.08752051,
0.0273790173,
-0.0378084593,
0.0636900514,
0.0437653065,
-0.0348446332,
-0.0075091422,
0.0391183347,
-0.0240606833,
0.0326965712,
-0.012842047,
0.0373052508,
-0.0647286177,
-0.0281890109,
-0.0333754681,
-0.0053724423,
0.0225648601,
0.0123316562,
-0.0098070847,
0.0240617059,
0.0349336192,
-0.0142355114,
0.0069522359,
-0.0608712099,
0.005449648,
0.0173572991,
0.0031183509,
-0.0037127128,
-0.0063374741,
0.0236164946,
-0.006297553,
0.0575489886,
0.0532329082,
-0.0411687568,
0.0056498945,
0.0516366549,
-0.003930951,
-0.0277979169,
0.0038565379,
-0.0121496171,
0.0267834757,
-0.0475524515,
-0.0308723785,
-0.0256613754,
0.0217171293,
-0.0201611761,
0.0686655343,
-0.014590174,
-0.0654563159,
-0.039731659,
-0.0096357735,
0.0584976114,
0.0483363122,
0.0646072999,
0.0152031481,
0.0053635659,
-0.0201870687,
0.0130648362,
0.0199127905,
-0.0254850555,
0.0479720719,
0.0326071046,
-0.0448752679,
-0.0042476761,
0.0370771587,
0.0530850329,
-0.0019920515,
-0.0173161924,
-0.0029541303,
-0.0160368923,
-0.0095352316,
-0.0495367534,
0.0481160358,
-0.0133884847,
-0.0150579764,
-0.0392574295,
-0.0468585007,
-0.0024130202,
0.0329976976,
0.0238954145,
-0.0384509712,
0.0119825518,
0.0239636339,
0.031283997,
-0.0047946912,
-0.0321199261,
-0.0585892387,
0.0017719322,
-0.0297522247,
0.0123751648,
-6.362761373e-33,
-0.033715602,
0.0018593055,
0.0017555302,
-0.0263007954,
-0.0224315915,
0.0381514505,
-0.0177011471,
-0.0016555156,
-0.0244514532,
-0.0266502723,
-0.01765237,
0.016793156,
0.0197791904,
-0.0057957666,
-0.0272412337,
0.0256345887,
0.0719981715,
0.0117239505,
-0.0152147468,
0.0207049642,
-0.0317269303,
0.0148239387,
0.0439180098,
0.024897065,
-0.0319717415,
0.0361013822,
-0.0038712556,
-0.0260876212,
0.0267174169,
0.0417794064,
-0.0289552752,
0.0136561543,
-0.0050003761,
-0.0006380244,
-0.0340467803,
-0.0167259555,
-0.0478311405,
-0.0222490653,
0.0262854081,
0.0491203517,
0.0191678163,
-0.0388849229,
0.0399149321,
0.0239879936,
-0.0283497926,
-0.051461868,
-0.0209889933,
-0.0074056787,
-0.0587356836,
-0.0592689961,
-0.0134845115,
0.0632540286,
0.0303954482,
0.0267300904,
0.1003362387,
-0.0278421957,
-0.0324093364,
-0.006475314,
-0.068686381,
0.0203376319,
0.0097089317,
0.1070641428,
0.0584492162,
0.023506863,
-0.0040952964,
0.0452546403,
0.0418887809,
-0.0291316826,
-0.0273746103,
0.061984282,
0.0438473485,
0.0144545073,
0.0478651449,
0.0107945725,
0.1030216962,
0.0026069882,
-0.0641304702,
-0.0085841492,
0.0270304587,
0.0088792061,
0.0160968602,
0.0720253736,
-0.0015498739,
-0.0458309427,
-0.0361846127,
0.0151376175,
-0.0332203917,
-0.0628912002,
-0.0020717934,
-0.0106867105,
-0.0556854717,
-0.0396571308,
0.0388855524,
-0.0551674217,
-0.0379139371,
0.0022042231,
-0.0097599439,
0.0381724909,
0.0171358325,
0.024188308,
-0.0215784572,
-0.031736616,
0.0067062159,
-0.0264617242,
0.0383928195,
-0.0069328169,
-0.0070069334,
0.0609433204,
-0.0663785562,
-0.0289134458,
-0.0275833402,
-0.0417138077,
-0.0108909002,
0.0820805281,
-0.0015277233,
0.0041211266,
0.0143407574,
0.0195925757,
-0.0250410419,
0.0136201838,
0.003293745,
0.0107420217,
-0.0005329046,
0.0624426603,
-0.0508954264,
-0.0124713713,
-0.0699061081,
0.0560134351,
0.0400883481,
-0.0577993877,
-0.0648863465,
0.0396906026,
2.916e-7,
0.0151105877,
0.0305323489,
0.0230919179,
0.0136645036,
0.0042643934,
-0.0070806304,
0.006843043,
0.007711764,
-0.0072076311,
-0.0241298415,
-0.0132453442,
0.0145841846,
0.0253939088,
0.0150552606,
-0.0756945536,
0.0265416093,
-0.0209895596,
-0.003340964,
-0.0148123624,
-0.0254360978,
0.008231773,
0.1275156289,
-0.0093463929,
0.0040933532,
0.0244924873,
-0.0099351229,
0.0104943095,
0.0053252759,
0.0244447794,
0.0111022955,
0.028831847,
0.0160289519,
-0.0184689872,
-0.0448188223,
-0.0081731081,
-0.016783189,
-0.0177711062,
0.0897791162,
-0.0280703418,
0.0208122674,
0.0193421897,
-0.0348971225,
-0.0272842478,
-0.0328018703,
0.0526224039,
-0.0099006882,
-0.0328415856,
-0.0936215073,
0.0099805854,
-0.016617965,
0.0061505432,
-0.0049614748,
-0.0059304414,
0.0226933453,
0.0223170873,
-0.0257840566,
0.019973997,
-0.0824341699,
-0.0665070489,
0.0084824152,
-0.0191480219,
-0.0619594455,
-0.0488768294,
0.0160816684,
0.0329310559,
-0.0289844219,
0.005752238,
3.070548283e-34,
0.0365270451,
-0.0231515653,
0.0368901715,
0.0444130003,
0.000458254,
-0.0098102409,
-0.0275593363,
0.0196183156,
-0.0095295291,
-0.0261227228,
-0.0230178349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17404v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17404v1 | Make Some Noise: Unlocking Language Model Parallel Inference Capability through Noisy Training | 2024-06-25T09:25:39 | 2024-06-25T09:25:39 | Yixuan Wang, Xianzhen Luo, Fuxuan Wei, Yijun Liu, Qingfu Zhu, Xuanyu Zhang, Qing Yang, Dongliang Xu, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Existing speculative decoding methods typically require additional model
structure and training processes to assist the model for draft token
generation. This makes the migration of acceleration methods to the new model
more costly and more demanding on device memory. To address this problem, we
propose the Make Some Noise (MSN) training framework as a replacement for the
supervised fine-tuning stage of the large language model. The training method
simply introduces some noise at the input for the model to learn the denoising
task. It significantly enhances the parallel decoding capability of the model
without affecting the original task capability. In addition, we propose a
tree-based retrieval-augmented Jacobi (TR-Jacobi) decoding strategy to further
improve the inference speed of MSN models. Experiments in both the general and
code domains have shown that MSN can improve inference speed by 2.3-2.7x times
without compromising model performance. The MSN model also achieves comparable
acceleration ratios to the SOTA model with additional model structure on
Spec-Bench. | [
0.0369807817,
0.087568529,
0.0076993108,
0.0256238226,
-0.0254894774,
0.0031633193,
-0.0100810444,
0.0086544678,
-0.0609223023,
-0.0166075118,
0.0038725717,
-0.02994656,
-0.0104106469,
0.0122610852,
0.0036433223,
0.005132522,
0.0499204323,
-0.054799933,
0.0587478504,
-0.0298273452,
-0.0206772387,
0.0356381051,
0.0201632883,
0.041539792,
-0.0070461305,
-0.0212302227,
-0.020408133,
0.039854642,
-0.0532314405,
-0.0282116402,
-0.0284898914,
0.0436170287,
0.0152029321,
0.0342599414,
0.0000022609,
0.0000179098,
-0.0272274949,
0.0286388304,
-0.0391513631,
0.0539694615,
0.0471336991,
0.0019211258,
-0.0271124262,
0.0127785392,
0.0035147208,
-0.0283549298,
0.0721259639,
-0.0102500021,
-0.000143881,
0.0593970679,
-0.0080264015,
-0.0357217863,
0.0280290134,
-0.0104731536,
-0.0198333748,
-0.0581507571,
0.004688412,
-0.0074295038,
-0.0210907329,
0.0062214597,
0.0159363728,
0.0122770732,
0.0273443069,
0.0342562646,
-0.0159337539,
0.0123290475,
0.003969403,
-0.024777893,
-0.0210279822,
0.0168277696,
-0.0178662185,
-0.0721622482,
-0.0146640139,
0.0162594616,
-0.0361422151,
0.0064449082,
-0.0166020766,
0.0341084823,
-0.0480216034,
0.0204919931,
0.05874677,
-0.0004838527,
0.051600486,
0.0037055872,
-0.0432204306,
0.048059836,
0.0409231968,
-0.0408067256,
-0.027282346,
-0.01664792,
-0.0020080064,
-0.0303011406,
0.0199041702,
-0.0101089319,
-0.0392661318,
0.0190872699,
-0.038559448,
-0.1105755717,
-0.0043554734,
-0.081853129,
-0.0006099896,
0.0769372135,
0.001246765,
0.0011025202,
-0.0273274351,
-0.0052982536,
-0.0025297974,
0.0183390975,
-0.0406968966,
-0.017367322,
-0.0015499961,
-0.0330895968,
-0.0770747811,
0.0655474886,
-0.0725554302,
-0.0289263204,
-0.0180664044,
0.0257918648,
0.0464538001,
-0.0322444998,
0.0279914942,
-0.0178864487,
-0.0758687034,
-0.0141564896,
0.0550455116,
0.0152330296,
-0.0100275418,
0.0029273294,
-0.0092033651,
-0.051518105,
-0.017047707,
0.0069378419,
-0.0016862522,
-0.0414531529,
0.0034275833,
0.0705235675,
-0.0154361716,
-0.0318879075,
-0.044493597,
-0.0100722108,
0.0188187156,
-0.0289704446,
0.0121314283,
-0.0592522174,
0.0013526255,
0.0092518693,
0.0002627755,
-0.0302122328,
-0.0168551281,
0.0120470021,
-0.0303949974,
0.0633677095,
-0.0301966034,
-0.0059671835,
0.0202809684,
-0.0003914102,
0.0208608303,
0.1067488343,
0.0009165883,
0.0523067415,
0.0243834238,
-0.0054069199,
-0.0221045259,
0.0635572374,
0.0412133783,
-0.0006181596,
-0.0331406146,
-0.0194263123,
-0.0113269379,
-0.0158839468,
0.0437722765,
0.046584513,
-0.0556302406,
0.0198420491,
0.0407953188,
0.0536434725,
0.0265097283,
0.020985635,
0.0428080037,
0.0214773398,
-0.0143198185,
-0.0009499903,
-0.0074555548,
0.0085461661,
-0.0276657324,
0.0475102551,
0.0587837659,
0.0554320253,
-0.0162346717,
-0.0010865557,
0.0004680967,
-0.0128064808,
0.0045185611,
0.0214842297,
0.0808007121,
0.0314956419,
-0.0637119189,
0.0732925609,
0.0532316975,
-0.0628475249,
-0.0511681028,
-0.0822547823,
0.0254490171,
0.0382833816,
0.0650779977,
0.0111586228,
0.0043372931,
0.0408106856,
-0.0307091475,
0.0408323817,
0.0174404699,
0.0094605898,
0.02569554,
-0.0637070835,
-0.0022126231,
0.0437012017,
0.0338112749,
0.0798532814,
0.038035918,
-0.016837392,
0.0259451792,
-0.055871658,
-0.0354131646,
0.006874809,
0.0087648705,
-0.0041864691,
0.0358734503,
0.0237503164,
0.028665157,
0.0212881397,
-0.0266923252,
0.0226521175,
0.0515851714,
-0.0390881635,
0.0589814261,
0.0117638102,
-0.0405310132,
-0.0172045678,
0.0258410797,
0.0236129295,
-0.0061212913,
0.0361962616,
0.0147817414,
-0.0376997776,
0.0668460205,
-0.0167416967,
0.0757156461,
-0.0601157919,
0.0345852375,
0.0026408476,
0.0096803913,
-0.0104833832,
0.0493671335,
-0.0280137192,
-0.0056165876,
0.0156773087,
0.0374393798,
0.0028519053,
-0.0079607703,
-0.0220169891,
0.0168311801,
-0.0326295048,
0.0066739381,
0.0065842387,
0.0087412102,
0.0329534858,
-0.0223747399,
-0.0688316301,
0.0072081829,
-0.0481456593,
0.0153854173,
0.0161869694,
0.0700845718,
0.0007373331,
-0.0104042161,
0.0238503478,
-0.0025912588,
-0.025937777,
0.0122104855,
-0.0550352633,
-0.000488638,
-0.0455784015,
0.0100969616,
-0.0325290337,
0.0057233023,
0.049191989,
-0.0440356657,
-0.0611433722,
-0.062396042,
0.0245202295,
0.0292853415,
0.0279439203,
-0.0079817129,
-0.0571673922,
0.0460631214,
-0.0544297323,
0.052832257,
0.0140297003,
-0.0322501697,
-0.0012451456,
0.0010492625,
-0.0197323207,
-0.0444165915,
0.0194282383,
0.0174564626,
-0.0118694929,
-0.0274337307,
-0.0585210472,
0.021336453,
0.0811504945,
-0.0176033154,
0.0102591505,
-0.0827720389,
-0.0355694667,
0.0002273296,
-0.0546262078,
-0.0184958205,
-0.0167937148,
-0.0248494204,
0.022713162,
-0.0401775613,
-0.0545606092,
0.0601876192,
-0.0557275303,
0.0011515282,
-0.0707735792,
0.0002836255,
0.0029805319,
0.069229804,
-0.0168219451,
0.0378608629,
0.0094616385,
-0.0709495395,
-0.0050062588,
0.0344222933,
0.0075556356,
-0.0284980014,
0.0113824634,
-0.0355409682,
0.0250267517,
-0.0154840378,
-0.0147272516,
0.005482805,
-0.0181714073,
-0.0209670663,
0.0033562114,
0.0604219101,
-0.0370903723,
0.0173105653,
0.048627723,
-0.0602980554,
0.0585579202,
-0.0084955357,
0.0109585347,
-0.0271076821,
0.0137846796,
0.0403399952,
-0.0436175764,
-0.0044232714,
-0.0327497497,
0.0342387743,
0.0261202995,
0.0407760255,
-0.0075323293,
-0.0517321415,
-0.0083359648,
0.057563521,
0.0205117911,
0.0029463291,
0.0964127108,
0.0610120296,
-0.0312794968,
-0.064100638,
0.0818449184,
0.0232906137,
-0.059958823,
-0.0182961952,
-0.0166585986,
0.0825576708,
-0.0060164304,
0.0035934104,
-0.0735432133,
-0.031551823,
0.039458707,
0.0380455181,
-0.0082981205,
0.0338227376,
-0.0249282606,
-0.0975122899,
0.0205893517,
0.0173108317,
-0.0658444837,
-0.0176554918,
-0.0366019234,
-0.0592568144,
0.0302965567,
0.0599949621,
0.0322640054,
0.032021381,
0.0178142115,
0.0331327803,
0.0014971037,
-0.0509406999,
-0.0155789768,
-0.0032223121,
0.0591745265,
0.0758153498,
-0.0207551382,
0.0093672639,
-0.0072923591,
0.0367475338,
0.0004675864,
0.0132506909,
-0.0323106609,
0.0099456795,
-0.0057747005,
0.0054625622,
-0.01161242,
-0.0019546256,
-0.0261001028,
-0.0235272385,
-0.0260141958,
0.0252934657,
-0.0052939076,
0.0198180918,
-0.0036433318,
-0.0271999203,
0.0057481267,
0.0451380312,
0.0302835219,
-0.0154924234,
-0.0374966078,
-0.0556736849,
0.0060561327,
-0.0887535363,
0.0344467461,
0.000843625,
0.0175331421,
-0.0658011213,
-0.0162845664,
0.0125327418,
0.002866019,
0.0325104855,
0.0069697769,
0.0450737588,
0.0057684523,
-0.0222040769,
-0.0697532818,
-0.0137681449,
-0.0382629298,
0.0118249366,
-0.0458310507,
0.0011052592,
0.0042855474,
-0.0069428189,
-0.0041026357,
0.0347616524,
-0.0949748531,
-0.073226355,
-0.0029485796,
0.0503944643,
0.0288083684,
0.0301639438,
-0.0554342866,
-0.0657414198,
-0.0079808896,
0.02738484,
-0.1038780808,
0.0087096728,
0.0330644734,
-0.0664141998,
0.0049162637,
0.02081405,
-0.0389111564,
0.0025439924,
0.0295376256,
0.0207570922,
-0.0335614532,
-0.0044709262,
0.0429013632,
0.0274951998,
0.0388593972,
-0.013703716,
-0.0310454983,
0.0072727231,
0.0586690828,
-0.031114921,
0.0045946226,
-0.0234727655,
-0.0115122842,
0.0086008394,
-0.0066481992,
-0.0110349143,
-0.01165774,
0.0404779352,
0.0435907207,
-0.0159597863,
-0.0022129037,
-0.0211932864,
0.0490367189,
0.0438682213,
-0.042915646,
-0.0236514173,
-0.0072873663,
-0.0060173119,
0.0259344149,
-0.0437384285,
0.0177419893,
0.0093286932,
0.0148095926,
-0.0173481908,
-0.0066300379,
-0.0511552133,
-0.0617972165,
-0.0329646729,
0.0210207924,
0.0649833605,
0.0006736366,
0.0447996147,
-0.0305899195,
0.0099799233,
-0.0131236361,
0.0169850439,
-0.0048754644,
-0.0206573196,
0.0075272699,
-0.0010095974,
-0.0144419158,
-0.0113949133,
0.0845846161,
0.0184366927,
0.0407713838,
-0.0171419699,
0.005370907,
-0.0408422798,
-0.0269466713,
0.0166912638,
0.0744090155,
-0.0655853301,
0.0016561854,
-0.0019054081,
-0.0506588221,
-0.0236459058,
-0.0069365231,
0.0397478491,
-0.0085208621,
0.0071256259,
0.0889648572,
-0.0227299947,
-0.0536708608,
-0.0216184873,
-0.0114288973,
0.0230639633,
-0.0355787314,
-0.0226190276,
-6.802565237e-33,
-0.0274468306,
0.0095853666,
0.0125257671,
-0.0370166376,
-0.0096842581,
0.0055136317,
-0.0296934284,
-0.0167901274,
0.0000926955,
-0.009301356,
-0.0319491811,
0.0406458117,
0.0359025002,
0.028718343,
-0.0061309151,
0.0478609949,
0.0757429674,
-0.0179705806,
0.0065350304,
-0.0007813602,
0.0182563737,
0.0470634848,
0.027174022,
-0.0175158586,
-0.0186488591,
-0.0321479663,
-0.0149271423,
-0.0470110066,
0.0091220345,
0.0295615885,
0.0006529396,
0.0009020427,
0.0013839599,
-0.0462346636,
-0.0396883935,
0.00251717,
-0.0857269093,
0.0205142293,
0.0485506505,
0.0379795358,
0.0177519061,
-0.0583303384,
0.0094023058,
0.0280597806,
-0.0132502066,
0.0140604163,
-0.0337913781,
-0.0008963426,
-0.0623676553,
-0.0474142209,
-0.0386808068,
0.0430568531,
0.0056792814,
0.0207557995,
0.0705963522,
-0.0061799521,
-0.0331251733,
-0.0271917284,
-0.0381406136,
0.0354914814,
0.0008544932,
0.0659976676,
0.0308627877,
0.0376246087,
-0.0086979307,
0.0070335935,
0.0412911437,
-0.0318445452,
-0.0115353633,
0.0177854449,
0.0287494175,
0.0286336094,
0.0034207189,
0.0198028423,
0.0885979906,
-0.0520402789,
-0.0726791471,
0.0066009797,
0.0180601012,
0.0480803661,
0.077668488,
0.0379904956,
-0.0482108295,
-0.0309577025,
-0.0177573431,
-0.0288750902,
-0.0595670715,
-0.0225111172,
0.0357816555,
0.0225298032,
-0.0353145488,
-0.0239074454,
0.0451199897,
-0.046296373,
0.0366912708,
0.0338485651,
-0.0046615186,
0.0246452931,
-0.0559046306,
0.0246055219,
-0.0346789882,
-0.0521993488,
0.0215326026,
-0.0031569721,
0.0088788839,
0.0178156067,
-0.0015273133,
-0.0002614739,
-0.0518163703,
-0.0108035803,
-0.0200503394,
0.0213742089,
0.0275203716,
0.0455230661,
0.0649581775,
-0.0087551586,
0.021141272,
-0.0081987167,
-0.002509278,
0.0264710877,
-0.0358103029,
0.0159631297,
0.0167463478,
0.0277917217,
-0.0170796122,
0.0118723689,
-0.0507372133,
-0.0270033497,
0.0460099503,
-0.031894058,
-0.0377908871,
0.0573161058,
2.957e-7,
0.0053288965,
0.0302590244,
0.0408194177,
0.0016219585,
0.0034696362,
0.005099053,
0.0171996299,
-0.0083541777,
0.0393482707,
-0.0074493303,
-0.0077524534,
0.0091583179,
0.0528487824,
0.0031524873,
-0.1028727219,
-0.0044548488,
-0.0381750613,
0.0323467851,
-0.0383882299,
-0.0123863937,
-0.0076126112,
0.1117820218,
-0.0444530435,
-0.0230121464,
0.0345915258,
-0.0300440993,
0.0171253644,
0.007741929,
-0.0263093468,
0.0116180312,
-0.0264986381,
-0.00183946,
-0.0061846604,
0.0148553913,
-0.01888014,
-0.0158542488,
-0.0078633064,
0.0305548795,
-0.0075728861,
-0.0193266645,
0.023050664,
-0.010731142,
-0.0308765974,
-0.0022948636,
0.0399701782,
0.0101920879,
-0.0365912877,
-0.0564265773,
-0.0253129229,
0.0397847258,
-0.0650647655,
0.0001521429,
0.0178074967,
0.0304371249,
0.0379285961,
-0.0089970985,
0.0078455526,
-0.0536470227,
-0.0381239913,
-0.0230444185,
-0.0461703315,
-0.0437529869,
-0.0663832054,
0.0030704148,
0.0263716318,
-0.0380261131,
0.0270606559,
3.161171321e-34,
0.066969119,
-0.0086049456,
0.0177938472,
0.0792020187,
0.019240994,
-0.0324535221,
0.0112601472,
0.0546679348,
-0.0011059677,
-0.0670073256,
-0.0410302579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17385v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17385v1 | Native Design Bias: Studying the Impact of English Nativeness on Language Model Performance | 2024-06-25T09:04:21 | 2024-06-25T09:04:21 | Manon Reusens, Philipp Borchert, Jochen De Weerdt, Bart Baesens | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) excel at providing information acquired during
pretraining on large-scale corpora and following instructions through user
prompts. This study investigates whether the quality of LLM responses varies
depending on the demographic profile of users. Considering English as the
global lingua franca, along with the diversity of its dialects among speakers
of different native languages, we explore whether non-native English speakers
receive lower-quality or even factually incorrect responses from LLMs more
frequently. Our results show that performance discrepancies occur when LLMs are
prompted by native versus non-native English speakers and persist when
comparing native speakers from Western countries with others. Additionally, we
find a strong anchoring effect when the model recognizes or is made aware of
the user's nativeness, which further degrades the response quality when
interacting with non-native speakers. Our analysis is based on a newly
collected dataset with over 12,000 unique annotations from 124 annotators,
including information on their native language and English proficiency. | [
0.0198093578,
0.0285828318,
-0.0463351086,
0.0401812568,
0.0023063377,
0.0133395121,
0.0707438588,
-0.0200315937,
0.0123100141,
-0.0487606339,
-0.0545990765,
-0.0406350344,
0.0133977011,
-0.0094897905,
0.0117962118,
-0.0244564172,
0.0170164071,
-0.0411441028,
0.0147015564,
-0.0481864102,
0.024637552,
0.0295354053,
0.0096499985,
0.0713035688,
-0.0238674805,
-0.0238318089,
0.0274877958,
0.0059587136,
-0.011241911,
-0.0349010453,
0.0624252222,
0.05377068,
-0.0237243846,
0.0596525185,
0.0000020612,
-0.0307252072,
0.0405631885,
-0.0034621337,
-0.0171277672,
0.0416132472,
0.0534687303,
0.0255940743,
-0.0138346087,
0.0342185274,
-0.0475849882,
-0.0338824205,
0.029444037,
0.0313363373,
-0.008465887,
-0.0014487726,
-0.0069270548,
-0.0018532629,
-0.0355974287,
-0.0037403323,
-0.0393218808,
0.007412198,
-0.0185948685,
0.0133362981,
-0.0378646255,
-0.0412423052,
-0.0212696735,
0.0365880281,
0.0208866242,
-0.0058430484,
-0.002777392,
0.0184642356,
0.0049253958,
-0.0198236518,
0.0022186988,
0.0684551522,
0.0254642889,
0.0046945182,
-0.034241762,
-0.0068579921,
0.0051127304,
0.0281925518,
-0.0115784789,
0.0275946986,
-0.0182099249,
-0.0026966974,
-0.01058657,
-0.0196782351,
0.0150902122,
-0.0209712703,
-0.0221879575,
0.0602780208,
0.0190155413,
-0.0323209055,
-0.0124959378,
0.0500526726,
0.0684313774,
-0.0725937337,
0.0300622322,
0.0003497918,
-0.0627145469,
0.0197704006,
0.0127708819,
-0.0030843855,
0.0173360594,
-0.0788320899,
0.0185026135,
0.0259619579,
-0.0340641029,
0.0074412902,
-0.0046198973,
0.0271921735,
-0.0111242775,
0.0176438242,
-0.038259089,
0.0106329508,
-0.0329380147,
-0.0260263067,
0.0465415418,
-0.0041756653,
-0.0266211592,
0.0346210264,
-0.0489752926,
0.005728968,
0.0052063046,
-0.0020376765,
-0.0204742271,
-0.0009521154,
-0.0280134827,
-0.0179191455,
-0.057770554,
0.0702894777,
-0.0594701804,
0.0180042423,
-0.0241121482,
-0.097959049,
0.0434213057,
0.0111860428,
-0.0274628792,
-0.0611241721,
-0.0208997745,
0.0154411718,
-0.0082676057,
-0.0123667056,
-0.0428097546,
-0.0152184954,
-0.0044322335,
-0.0402876921,
-0.0164383687,
-0.053366404,
0.0080184592,
0.0423132107,
0.0078854561,
-0.060157828,
-0.0322916433,
0.03241653,
-0.0372679159,
0.0159124788,
-0.0403152406,
0.0442679562,
0.052850347,
0.0021672002,
0.0555512272,
0.0791601166,
0.0052158991,
-0.0136871748,
0.0354079716,
-0.0474627912,
-0.0061940472,
0.0690873414,
-0.0180960465,
0.0047532683,
-0.0404920094,
0.0106826201,
-0.0051701334,
-0.0220695436,
0.0796819851,
0.0248404462,
0.0103794159,
0.0435339399,
0.0607288741,
0.087043196,
-0.0208516903,
0.0179688968,
0.030648021,
0.0108084213,
0.00189081,
0.0231321137,
-0.0381577387,
-0.0126070082,
-0.0300364755,
-0.0174039863,
0.005417407,
0.0682089627,
-0.0492177457,
-0.0354632735,
-0.012749278,
-0.0102219209,
0.0231113192,
0.0473770201,
0.0140034845,
0.0002176102,
0.0228716377,
0.0295174681,
0.0116976285,
-0.0469883084,
-0.0097689591,
-0.0298088752,
0.015664937,
0.0798400789,
-0.0313985012,
0.0186317563,
0.0035474477,
-0.0164826699,
0.0041743168,
0.0707254633,
0.0897201151,
-0.0200937837,
0.016158333,
-0.0220829938,
-0.0332694054,
-0.005026048,
-0.0021698906,
0.0538723506,
0.0184968375,
0.0443292335,
0.0239247642,
-0.0390792564,
-0.073811695,
0.014349537,
-0.0628097951,
-0.0291692372,
-0.020544298,
0.0024859933,
-0.0009795874,
0.0216310211,
-0.0259701852,
-0.0025090266,
-0.0123335458,
-0.0125528872,
0.0178520419,
0.0460825413,
-0.0495131575,
-0.0113483788,
0.0417699404,
-0.032713823,
-0.0482798554,
-0.0192943234,
-0.0125417877,
-0.0406193063,
0.0278341658,
0.0033866405,
0.0620245785,
-0.01954934,
-0.017827874,
-0.0304017272,
0.0046718116,
-0.0317672715,
0.0114236856,
-0.0037027844,
0.0331566781,
0.0155132422,
-0.0095476396,
0.0324261002,
-0.0403513871,
-0.0566167608,
0.0429319218,
-0.0147380466,
0.0150290364,
0.0644419789,
0.0228911377,
-0.0576447062,
0.034475714,
-0.0841295645,
-0.0136877494,
-0.0183791779,
0.0261951443,
0.0103796814,
0.0030664362,
-0.0436510481,
-0.0590798855,
-0.0557249673,
-0.0594264418,
0.0064624725,
0.0702925101,
0.0100278398,
-0.0064882599,
0.0213522706,
-0.0367752276,
-0.0394375473,
0.0124058556,
0.0179077145,
0.0199409816,
0.0004429077,
-0.0322046503,
-0.0136902481,
-0.0284322165,
0.0055500283,
0.0015669743,
-0.0468914807,
0.030156089,
0.0231612064,
0.0700862408,
0.0443813913,
-0.0066325739,
0.0193674471,
0.0343993269,
-0.0131546222,
-0.0661276281,
-0.0206168536,
0.0306829438,
-0.0483145043,
-0.0415767841,
-0.063607268,
0.003776615,
0.0966972038,
0.0016827674,
0.0014139405,
-0.035645552,
0.006644079,
-0.081189163,
-0.0505816378,
-0.0485032909,
0.0106789377,
-0.0152101843,
0.0807821229,
-0.0039524352,
-0.0584132075,
0.0587588511,
-0.0072319619,
-0.0115269786,
0.0075678881,
0.0056279246,
-0.008982446,
-0.0028021578,
-0.026713673,
0.0446505174,
0.0196581129,
-0.0471013263,
-0.049714122,
-0.0262904372,
0.0276600383,
-0.0358596183,
0.0213099755,
-0.0252016988,
-0.0292316526,
-0.0163913649,
-0.0581041723,
-0.034478303,
-0.0227249954,
-0.0674194917,
-0.0345786661,
0.0273358393,
-0.0060915207,
0.0347361378,
-0.0100434804,
0.0565440767,
0.0183353759,
-0.0216921475,
0.006374157,
0.012566139,
-0.0011027209,
0.0244361572,
0.0491744615,
0.0361105725,
-0.0598258786,
0.0485341661,
0.0081931576,
0.025974134,
-0.0182280485,
0.0021922844,
-0.0065620979,
0.0628074333,
-0.0060756444,
-0.0579156317,
0.0458211154,
0.0812156051,
-0.0431483351,
0.0262408014,
0.0935827345,
0.026058089,
-0.0470661595,
-0.0031727436,
-0.0626265928,
0.0602282137,
0.0480321273,
0.0445094258,
-0.054174915,
0.0138274254,
-0.0062623881,
0.0186273158,
-0.0124919983,
0.0189266205,
-0.0048778947,
-0.137432754,
-0.013146664,
-0.010385666,
-0.0596814528,
0.0423875153,
-0.005148151,
-0.0352437384,
0.012981236,
0.0651955009,
-0.0024699306,
-0.0170134809,
0.0073657855,
0.031664893,
-0.0988875106,
-0.0774482861,
0.0261766315,
-0.021255197,
0.0438627824,
0.0538261272,
0.0148823401,
-0.0255552493,
-0.0389290676,
0.0639417544,
-0.0069815768,
0.0288841818,
-0.0220777001,
0.0257664546,
0.0256796684,
-0.0138595095,
-0.0585119799,
-0.0236313269,
-0.0155853936,
0.0073309671,
0.0259390138,
0.0335126556,
0.0224029105,
0.0066256435,
-0.0156500489,
-0.0147237675,
-0.0067066578,
0.037419498,
0.0211886354,
-0.0758222193,
-0.0336659513,
-0.0487650558,
-0.020278465,
-0.0157531407,
-0.0675425008,
0.0662707984,
-0.0200102143,
-0.0416193791,
-0.0324039124,
-0.067545481,
0.0098389927,
0.0061121262,
0.0400820933,
-0.0138005726,
-0.0075147212,
-0.0241763331,
0.0333466008,
0.0612074621,
-0.0487653762,
0.0316325203,
-0.0599612184,
0.0138838459,
0.0097567076,
-0.0165971499,
0.013379192,
-0.0150483511,
0.0321667679,
-0.0401601605,
0.0036779721,
0.071905978,
0.0197118074,
0.0445999727,
0.0163827036,
-0.0959789902,
0.0061724535,
-0.010108714,
-0.0043940679,
-0.0063021039,
0.0295974053,
-0.0000317107,
-0.0123600746,
0.0260562971,
-0.0272673909,
0.022230342,
0.0492201969,
0.0082933251,
-0.0067526773,
-0.010695911,
0.0124690393,
0.0563997589,
0.0588756017,
-0.044545427,
0.0089091174,
-0.0170681719,
0.0023187767,
-0.01585152,
-0.0066546579,
-0.0113190105,
-0.0241635144,
0.0150752403,
-0.005872705,
0.0215622447,
-0.0012782157,
-0.0299144238,
0.0211143009,
-0.0311952662,
0.0511374921,
0.0261679534,
0.0303873811,
0.0330572687,
0.0469073243,
-0.0175460037,
0.04141929,
0.0415055417,
0.0534862801,
-0.0047126426,
0.0657859072,
-0.0038564664,
0.004009658,
0.0100263059,
0.0080847787,
-0.0054284404,
-0.0423919223,
0.0234807599,
0.0014815954,
0.052169621,
-0.046185378,
0.0585401542,
0.0353571996,
0.01930275,
-0.0290063079,
0.0118442448,
0.0259975288,
-0.0450167321,
0.0333026275,
-0.0202928819,
-0.042491883,
-0.014363029,
0.0699389204,
-0.0021304525,
-0.0043340214,
-0.0225197487,
0.0008770209,
-0.0307099167,
0.007492939,
0.0379546843,
0.000631313,
-0.0618455224,
-0.0045383237,
-0.0961616188,
-0.0782810524,
-0.0299645737,
0.0109319277,
0.0102076046,
-0.0160463005,
0.014706024,
0.042932421,
-0.0224199258,
-0.0291831922,
-0.0411187261,
-0.0023048839,
-0.0267367959,
0.0048190141,
0.0073670079,
-6.329055541e-33,
-0.0299354866,
-0.0190595742,
0.0058539067,
-0.0522511639,
0.0161940735,
-0.0024168082,
-0.0191615932,
0.0423684046,
-0.0317460224,
0.0120598124,
-0.0470037945,
0.0027975535,
0.024048388,
0.0038227285,
0.0327046886,
0.0017680267,
0.0498503558,
0.00496476,
-0.0176059362,
0.0154740224,
0.01532338,
0.0085567608,
0.0601698831,
-0.0635714233,
0.0587635376,
-0.0103362324,
0.016544966,
-0.001495752,
-0.007549366,
0.0447886176,
-0.037300434,
0.0925659165,
0.0173306521,
-0.0360199101,
-0.0361427553,
0.0206123181,
-0.0155194709,
-0.036611665,
0.025921315,
0.046481926,
0.0296393558,
-0.0481636077,
0.006925704,
-0.0063888389,
-0.0726971254,
0.0299788378,
0.0401892401,
-0.0031770382,
0.0109819528,
0.0323219113,
-0.0559953302,
0.0251143202,
-0.0246124621,
0.0342509411,
-0.0050962884,
0.0736312345,
-0.0169630032,
-0.0599454269,
-0.0226342995,
0.0293364991,
0.0484654494,
0.0131454794,
0.0859388933,
0.0415918715,
0.0111188805,
0.0283561647,
0.0588061213,
0.0638991445,
-0.0065023485,
-0.0117501058,
0.0419367403,
-0.0271474924,
0.0171097498,
0.0933285132,
0.016572088,
-0.0441347435,
-0.0285628438,
0.0059911003,
0.0234099366,
0.0244310703,
0.0075897565,
0.0019602294,
-0.0203983244,
-0.0618206412,
-0.0382256024,
-0.0072648679,
-0.0154803758,
-0.0528965108,
0.050457444,
-0.0066954661,
0.019383613,
-0.025620576,
0.0532693751,
-0.0441368893,
-0.0411299244,
-0.027037045,
-0.0165218841,
-0.0093514156,
0.0023872466,
0.0524288677,
-0.0582683235,
-0.0058663636,
-0.0505149625,
0.0084819896,
0.0091948686,
0.0352278091,
0.0090650748,
-0.0063414811,
-0.0816314146,
0.004485847,
-0.0164390635,
0.0020296541,
0.0108005702,
0.0071289469,
0.0652000681,
-0.0069160601,
-0.0260998756,
0.0247005951,
0.0143315261,
-0.0304169767,
-0.0652270764,
-0.0416011587,
-0.00667571,
0.037347313,
-0.0405965596,
-0.0143837826,
-0.0390187949,
0.0232183728,
0.0517108105,
-0.0403901488,
-0.0447202995,
-0.040787112,
2.611e-7,
0.0291082058,
0.0553480834,
-0.0113088712,
-0.0313341059,
0.0283322241,
0.0159826428,
-0.0240338296,
0.0048796837,
0.0456504747,
0.0138172684,
-0.0472477674,
-0.0080456873,
0.0514320284,
0.0438425466,
-0.1012528837,
0.0202650353,
-0.0760995448,
0.083841309,
-0.0519318283,
0.0514828041,
-0.0110958498,
0.027253665,
-0.0429906435,
-0.0138627663,
-0.0328659564,
-0.0402836911,
0.0549908429,
-0.0383451767,
0.0119087063,
-0.005910859,
0.0095032873,
0.0055867424,
0.0325442478,
0.0430239625,
-0.005001049,
-0.0026001893,
0.0096828863,
0.0450324453,
-0.0074778232,
0.0070596375,
-0.0075506205,
0.0060486128,
-0.0038705105,
-0.0649710968,
0.046540767,
-0.0061610104,
-0.036806602,
-0.0285124909,
0.0149119543,
-0.039985422,
0.0488741174,
-0.0278591961,
-0.0229313634,
0.0129042743,
0.0304855034,
-0.002179249,
-0.0079024574,
-0.0347200446,
-0.0280463416,
0.0390478373,
0.0008931881,
-0.0596451834,
-0.0186692458,
0.0635409877,
-0.0090839155,
0.0050185882,
0.0383472666,
1.952083316e-34,
0.0239510629,
0.0336062685,
0.0611976907,
0.0334268063,
0.0331931897,
0.0088500176,
0.0279111564,
-0.0034387782,
0.0285901632,
-0.0426465385,
0.0072389646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17378v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17378v1 | A Text is Worth Several Tokens: Text Embedding from LLMs Secretly Aligns Well with The Key Tokens | 2024-06-25T08:55:12 | 2024-06-25T08:55:12 | Zhijie Nie, Richong Zhang, Zhanyu Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Text embeddings from large language models (LLMs) have achieved excellent
results in tasks such as information retrieval, semantic textual similarity,
etc. In this work, we show an interesting finding: when feeding a text into the
embedding LLMs, the obtained text embedding will be able to be aligned with the
key tokens in the input text. We first fully analyze this phenomenon on eight
embedding LLMs and show that this phenomenon is universal and is not affected
by model architecture, training strategy, and embedding method. With a deeper
analysis, we then find that the main change in embedding space between the
embedding LLMs and their original generative LLMs is in the first principal
component. By adjusting the first principal component, we can align text
embedding with the key tokens. Finally, we give several examples to demonstrate
the vast application potential of this finding: (1) we propose a simple and
practical sparse retrieval method based on the aligned tokens, which can
achieve 80\% of the dense retrieval effect of the same model while reducing the
computation significantly; (2) we show that our findings provide a fresh
perspective to help understand fuzzy concepts (e.g., semantic relatedness vs.
semantic similarity) and emerging technologies (e.g., instruction-following
embedding) in this field. | [
0.0216414165,
0.0149210654,
-0.0025149151,
0.0706176013,
-0.0150643196,
0.0054255072,
-0.0173698068,
0.046867393,
-0.0108883996,
-0.0588168837,
-0.029435223,
-0.0297743734,
-0.0120660169,
-0.0136216031,
0.0631951317,
0.0006274676,
0.051478453,
0.0314214416,
0.0263040382,
0.0025216485,
0.0375800617,
0.0061914241,
0.0502415262,
0.0321019143,
-0.0430885218,
0.0119607402,
0.0121815093,
0.0075139399,
0.019449858,
-0.0100763738,
-0.0199631862,
-0.0271162018,
0.055808492,
0.0217763782,
0.0000017882,
-0.0053679878,
-0.0136570791,
0.0118160797,
0.0133560449,
0.0451977961,
0.0580997877,
-0.0040134927,
0.01680292,
0.0029881755,
-0.011557404,
-0.0184620786,
0.0473549664,
0.0766748786,
0.0262854025,
0.0795493051,
-0.0173738897,
-0.0398966894,
0.0251177698,
-0.0111104921,
0.0199975483,
-0.0196629707,
0.0268534776,
-0.0441133417,
-0.0187503155,
0.0736265481,
-0.0044299182,
0.0168380477,
-0.0122628361,
0.0285024252,
0.0294047259,
0.0598626025,
-0.0399541222,
0.0161154047,
0.0289650895,
0.0533271655,
-0.0570187718,
-0.0292419344,
-0.0039551002,
0.0017488931,
-0.0017554977,
-0.0043003103,
-0.0581495799,
0.0178655349,
0.0330909379,
0.0781229883,
0.0394528247,
0.0190423951,
0.0472593196,
0.0122718047,
-0.0412095077,
0.0346926935,
0.0127754901,
-0.0725712255,
-0.042120479,
-0.0055794949,
-0.0506004877,
0.0197705161,
0.0074423915,
0.0185010638,
0.0338871554,
0.0218430981,
-0.0551608838,
-0.0025749288,
0.0355340131,
-0.048259832,
0.0153107801,
0.0735649019,
-0.0029072056,
0.051681228,
-0.0940562114,
0.0587835498,
-0.0306036621,
0.0433339886,
-0.0670862421,
-0.0166535974,
-0.0320490673,
-0.0405680798,
-0.0422718301,
0.0726835728,
0.0031915577,
-0.0536574274,
0.003127818,
0.0458851382,
0.0023467736,
0.0405663811,
-0.0179051682,
0.0149347913,
0.0099048503,
-0.0036638342,
-0.0035768084,
-0.004043892,
-0.0324240066,
0.0069517498,
-0.0126195541,
-0.0134215606,
-0.0297195762,
0.0338004455,
0.0194720086,
-0.0166816674,
0.0080251871,
0.0292979963,
-0.0162195414,
-0.0571317226,
-0.0225952696,
-0.0042914301,
0.0092856884,
-0.0094884392,
-0.0341210887,
-0.0639959723,
0.0213640202,
0.0067592678,
-0.0155703509,
-0.036754366,
0.0267857313,
0.068403326,
-0.0779067054,
0.0689301789,
7.117e-7,
0.0000339744,
0.0253188368,
0.0136004016,
0.0291199498,
0.0399633497,
0.0044466271,
0.0249256603,
0.0701649114,
0.0138998469,
-0.023484109,
0.0147950659,
0.0368716009,
0.0009776443,
-0.0205994342,
0.0142633198,
0.0187347196,
0.0456905663,
0.0257373396,
0.071675092,
-0.0377222635,
-0.0454355627,
0.0504792929,
0.1094622016,
0.0067845825,
0.0132778771,
0.0230926871,
0.0354722701,
-0.0313895307,
0.0175989661,
-0.0443502627,
-0.0019200539,
-0.0313368626,
0.0316938907,
0.0663307682,
0.0118582295,
-0.0540601388,
-0.0208351072,
-0.0290590804,
-0.0224352144,
-0.0113045219,
-0.0249766279,
0.0256546009,
-0.0306063574,
-0.0530183986,
0.0521043874,
0.0369697288,
-0.0481816456,
0.0002400904,
-0.0140097858,
0.0224302411,
0.0410781913,
0.0556513295,
-0.0560571849,
-0.0085842237,
0.031796284,
-0.0139874583,
-0.0033459035,
0.0088753654,
-0.000808905,
-0.0108154118,
-0.0696715787,
-0.0285447408,
-0.0357475393,
0.0047903596,
-0.016628867,
0.0105725909,
0.0217687041,
0.0497566648,
-0.0204503499,
0.0241300743,
0.0526247434,
0.0083946185,
-0.0214659013,
-0.0126947239,
0.0277860463,
0.0098120095,
0.0121668996,
-0.002576516,
0.0339140892,
0.0586675033,
-0.0513742305,
-0.0282002762,
-0.0572279394,
-0.0612472594,
-0.0506744571,
0.0348195806,
-0.0071448958,
0.0267557148,
-0.0115312058,
-0.0495415255,
-0.0135484831,
-0.0168489832,
-0.0314194672,
0.0450779051,
-0.0421098843,
0.0365815125,
-0.0172658879,
0.0039796601,
-0.0627459288,
0.0603354834,
-0.0252376087,
0.054155454,
-0.0251608267,
0.0188379455,
0.0467524491,
-0.0357187986,
-0.0686555579,
-0.0114825983,
0.0017774676,
0.0269358885,
0.0152081056,
-0.0318641923,
-0.002874417,
-0.0476953015,
-0.0952538773,
0.0032859661,
0.0008910592,
-0.016318474,
0.0091002369,
-0.0119281979,
0.0037005011,
-0.0148494085,
-0.0571744516,
-0.0305407885,
-0.0056336536,
0.0330634676,
0.0560167171,
0.0023043468,
-0.0110160895,
-0.0399634279,
-0.0059429267,
0.003095262,
0.0583292469,
-0.0538291112,
-0.0134852575,
-0.067324765,
0.0451954529,
-0.0415924229,
7.137e-7,
-0.0215307437,
-0.0337787718,
-0.0034989493,
-0.0371307246,
0.0406857394,
0.059620209,
0.0190685559,
0.0396389142,
0.0359783359,
0.016349066,
-0.0690036044,
-0.0120502207,
-0.0446994863,
0.0210306924,
-0.005904336,
-0.0120512601,
0.0143900532,
0.0245146658,
0.0091226213,
-0.0197033007,
-0.0507428832,
0.0065052384,
-0.0211764984,
0.0291954167,
-0.0495120548,
0.0033196977,
0.0012818439,
-0.007353059,
-0.0237020068,
-0.0595299713,
0.0560841523,
-0.0592643246,
0.0038244736,
-0.0005456338,
-0.0551249348,
-0.0622899495,
0.0322191864,
-0.0041303374,
0.0363453701,
-0.0380477197,
-0.0025725437,
-0.0543248393,
0.0240952484,
-0.0089624003,
-0.0503968745,
0.0609232597,
0.0403753854,
0.0039725034,
-0.0075378274,
-0.0341543704,
-0.0277503338,
-0.0672956705,
0.0019404473,
0.0214366689,
0.0325101838,
-0.0020036458,
-0.0618982501,
0.018402461,
0.0232812855,
0.0140770301,
-0.0022574817,
0.009556368,
-0.041107934,
0.0324006565,
0.0403872728,
-0.046569638,
-0.0277776737,
-0.0088057332,
0.0034211995,
0.0528177693,
0.0298351906,
-0.0382614508,
-0.0188784581,
-0.0028859777,
0.028627865,
-0.0243717115,
-0.0370049253,
-0.0089272661,
0.0275757592,
-0.0051072119,
0.0025798786,
0.1294656843,
0.0439806134,
-0.0504113957,
-0.0037030431,
-0.0109161595,
0.0160673968,
0.0305109546,
0.0061321817,
-0.0545097105,
-0.0264361911,
0.0024822545,
0.0042815246,
0.0124117536,
0.0111289881,
-0.0015501833,
-0.0918688774,
-0.0044996212,
0.0186655,
0.0113369906,
-0.0919325873,
-0.0357608236,
-0.0044388436,
0.0184618086,
0.0116728013,
0.0038255637,
-0.0045934664,
-0.0195064023,
-0.0121644121,
0.0194323696,
-0.0271409024,
-0.0301276408,
-0.0503578335,
0.0364672728,
0.0156743061,
0.026343219,
0.0220264886,
-0.0487487018,
-0.0153780393,
-0.0268311445,
-0.0082586436,
-0.0095008519,
0.0204395019,
-0.0342153497,
0.0048911576,
0.004966375,
-0.0062756897,
-0.0117709003,
-0.0077849445,
-0.0123557886,
0.0877627656,
-0.0095152277,
-0.0017432446,
-0.0490516424,
-0.0117421765,
-0.0324408822,
0.0864264295,
0.023379568,
-0.0109879803,
-0.0179303307,
-0.0137931453,
0.0304799434,
0.060159225,
-0.0426574498,
-0.0171879996,
-0.032014247,
0.039155744,
-0.0685186982,
-0.0073402915,
0.0238423217,
0.0329321325,
-0.0135710035,
0.0314892977,
-0.0048090634,
-0.0631708056,
-0.0361040682,
0.0097446712,
-0.0405264273,
0.0104345027,
-0.057983987,
0.0126451515,
0.048454605,
-0.019846091,
-0.0292929392,
-0.0380232409,
-0.0388857126,
-0.0581334122,
-0.0566590279,
0.01242337,
-0.0002503567,
0.0308137238,
-0.0000144225,
-0.0359396189,
0.0970667601,
0.0584110469,
-0.051928889,
-0.000066742,
-0.0023518975,
0.0199946128,
0.0074723023,
0.0327830054,
-0.0464838631,
-0.0020027903,
0.0066778846,
0.0430683866,
-0.0277478956,
-0.0386457555,
0.0255378075,
0.0017637521,
0.0663818792,
0.018196173,
0.0523938015,
-0.0360400453,
0.0164680444,
-0.0234100167,
-0.0308442302,
-0.0322241075,
0.0043376372,
0.0405135415,
-0.0136857843,
-0.0011331284,
-0.0188923329,
0.0135204121,
0.0867598429,
-0.0145535674,
-0.0304086879,
-0.043577116,
0.0184450317,
0.0145039503,
0.0260225162,
-0.0344357193,
-0.0003764731,
-0.0494805649,
0.0019415503,
-0.0548663847,
0.026051715,
0.0171203259,
-0.0102532767,
-0.0608486608,
0.0504674427,
-0.041775845,
-0.0207157712,
-0.0296813268,
0.0220826827,
0.0357225128,
-0.0453444049,
-0.014613946,
-0.0066891541,
-0.0300481599,
-0.0091861235,
-0.0141599653,
-0.0015156749,
-0.0374557301,
0.0419646762,
0.0347210243,
-0.0324294902,
0.0039947387,
0.0626697987,
0.0053077079,
0.007919142,
-0.0210577101,
-0.0368453451,
-0.0178136844,
0.0051451721,
0.102309607,
0.0741091892,
-0.0189658757,
0.021062851,
-0.0172500573,
-0.037775699,
-0.0039412002,
-0.0239960216,
-0.0571625419,
-0.0090034241,
0.0390179344,
0.0536556095,
-0.0040396745,
0.000778965,
-0.0334588066,
-0.0023822174,
0.0021544672,
-0.0554369986,
-0.0251353364,
-6.035400522e-33,
-0.0167241003,
0.0084000286,
-0.0031357072,
0.0111906808,
-0.0259545874,
0.020433154,
0.0050577568,
-0.0256801229,
-0.0207221322,
0.018031517,
-0.0116556501,
-0.0123198805,
-0.0099598002,
0.0414182693,
-0.034323059,
0.0052408669,
0.0213910751,
-0.0068699177,
-0.0000815723,
0.0226793401,
0.0412118584,
0.014787687,
0.0262100287,
-0.0436414741,
-0.0180062801,
-0.0373476855,
0.0270191915,
0.0460579358,
0.0474544875,
0.0698122904,
-0.0372347236,
0.043217089,
0.0332320519,
0.0061031473,
-0.0283316076,
0.0204070844,
-0.0359089151,
-0.034738183,
0.0132864416,
-0.0219204929,
0.0036515638,
-0.0317510962,
0.0449631996,
-0.0385825075,
-0.0086077452,
0.0072039515,
0.0392069668,
0.0014103334,
-0.0581061728,
0.0114213731,
-0.055706732,
0.0280279424,
0.0091243479,
0.0143345781,
0.0298166703,
-0.0098067634,
0.0489078946,
0.0751607716,
-0.0726402998,
0.0038544605,
-0.0553256497,
0.0799595416,
0.0074006491,
-0.0018952549,
0.007786111,
0.054919377,
-0.003880155,
-0.0333619304,
-0.0646360889,
-0.0049537057,
0.0293519907,
0.0299010053,
0.0423067883,
0.0258002225,
0.036526978,
-0.0285449494,
-0.0316147469,
0.0242563896,
0.0098087406,
0.0165348444,
0.0553585775,
0.0710695609,
-0.076469183,
-0.0236540399,
-0.0218967013,
0.0118483473,
-0.0451037437,
-0.0106269848,
0.0169006828,
0.0316779725,
-0.0093271965,
-0.0148757752,
0.0214626212,
-0.0437453091,
-0.0010239914,
0.0255316794,
-0.0131811472,
0.0147667332,
0.0033007711,
0.0283315238,
-0.0573797897,
-0.084453024,
0.0300449096,
-0.0418240018,
-0.0287327319,
0.0082763927,
0.0461148061,
0.0019032806,
-0.0757325515,
-0.0055851289,
-0.0047908067,
-0.0692698807,
-0.018454833,
-0.0192155521,
0.0048205061,
0.0112971859,
0.0260173008,
0.0452702604,
0.0395728238,
0.0092286626,
-0.0199054796,
-0.0320591144,
0.0013720804,
-0.000506819,
-0.0001451547,
0.0439386442,
-0.058574371,
0.0248379111,
0.0129513899,
-0.053184852,
-0.0041629937,
0.0294515248,
2.524e-7,
0.0252934601,
0.0327535905,
0.0260051973,
-0.0022742725,
-0.0020109818,
0.0608397163,
-0.0038788086,
0.0303688459,
-0.0046487325,
0.009391549,
0.040484108,
0.0180610083,
0.0020011137,
-0.0098481188,
-0.0808888152,
0.0614954531,
-0.0748704672,
-0.0392866731,
-0.0410175808,
0.0076632081,
0.0643677562,
0.1395390183,
0.0394904017,
0.0193497594,
-0.0047792098,
-0.0728814825,
0.0710880682,
-0.0263341554,
0.0186805651,
0.0044569862,
0.0014308384,
0.0305414926,
0.0090111773,
-0.0224185474,
0.0046660416,
0.0736104995,
0.0516789742,
0.0513076223,
-0.0019184063,
-0.0190613233,
-0.0043586954,
-0.0501333065,
-0.0077397404,
-0.0988361239,
0.0647952333,
-0.0404207557,
-0.005733809,
-0.0315338224,
0.0002219629,
0.0190233979,
0.0271790382,
0.0093690082,
-0.0438588299,
0.028587183,
0.0383405015,
-0.0057337005,
-0.0154827544,
-0.1175099313,
-0.0020108621,
-0.0125250714,
-0.0699424893,
-0.0077545485,
-0.0378087573,
0.0380434692,
0.0647936985,
-0.0326285958,
0.0030311965,
2.646236837e-34,
0.0142088486,
-0.0186252706,
0.0034454565,
0.0340598933,
0.0394265316,
-0.0101720011,
-0.0102716964,
0.027285384,
0.0117647052,
-0.0746672675,
0.0028407031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17377v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17377v1 | A Three-Pronged Approach to Cross-Lingual Adaptation with Multilingual LLMs | 2024-06-25T08:53:46 | 2024-06-25T08:53:46 | Vaibhav Singh, Amrith Krishna, Karthika NJ, Ganesh Ramakrishnan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Low-resource languages, by its very definition, tend to be under represented
in the pre-training corpora of Large Language Models. In this work, we
investigate three low-resource cross-lingual approaches that enable an LLM
adapt to tasks in previously unseen languages. Llama-2 is an LLM where Indic
languages, among many other language families, contribute to less than
$0.005\%$ of the total $2$ trillion token pre-training corpora. In this work,
we experiment with the English-dominated Llama-2 for cross-lingual transfer to
three Indic languages, Bengali, Hindi, and Tamil as target languages. We study
three approaches for cross-lingual transfer, under ICL and fine-tuning. One, we
find that adding additional supervisory signals via a dominant language in the
LLM, leads to improvements, both under in-context learning and fine-tuning.
Two, adapting the target languages to word reordering may be beneficial under
ICL, but its impact diminishes with fine tuning. Finally, continued
pre-training in one low-resource language can improve model performance for
other related low-resource languages. | [
0.0269473922,
0.0220230594,
-0.0252116229,
0.0599457882,
-0.0260742418,
0.0342288278,
-0.0152182737,
0.0047232383,
-0.0107247876,
-0.0228393339,
-0.1093615666,
-0.0394842401,
-0.0240215026,
-0.015601011,
0.0411178991,
-0.0351206698,
0.0746736154,
-0.0546085611,
-0.0200630259,
-0.0083931684,
-0.0058850325,
0.010419921,
-0.0087095937,
-0.0229518786,
-0.0006548125,
0.0109485025,
0.037011873,
0.005678915,
0.0175362881,
-0.0399191901,
-0.0047715656,
0.0196359716,
0.0178792384,
0.0159596261,
0.0000018536,
-0.0794830099,
-0.0120323217,
-0.0256027859,
-0.0015263291,
0.0216494258,
0.0532946475,
-0.0454741046,
-0.024567306,
0.0189901683,
-0.0230857544,
0.0349015146,
0.0595915429,
0.0203813314,
0.0177565701,
0.1243655831,
-0.0160451569,
-0.0205513705,
0.0187610425,
-0.0321135931,
0.0083328271,
-0.029389143,
0.0144397449,
-0.0290985461,
-0.0004258199,
-0.0078850212,
-0.0464120209,
0.0472426973,
0.0054633776,
0.0030269884,
-0.0111421961,
-0.01035331,
-0.0153255556,
-0.0105880499,
-0.0255438834,
0.0435232334,
-0.0578410029,
-0.0328706205,
-0.0011150676,
-0.01415205,
-0.0205229893,
-0.0334281959,
-0.0530238934,
0.0188212525,
0.0256559402,
0.0317128524,
0.0812830403,
-0.0132694375,
0.0462122709,
-0.0124162212,
-0.0135744149,
0.0442431122,
0.0370883681,
-0.0194370896,
0.0200161487,
0.0251334235,
0.0259112809,
-0.0274817124,
0.0029896889,
0.0300336406,
-0.021044815,
0.0439299308,
-0.0441511013,
0.0069478038,
0.0110026896,
-0.0237728897,
0.033234816,
0.0505850725,
-0.0484464355,
0.0288630836,
-0.040444985,
0.0245218594,
-0.0527451746,
0.0629043952,
-0.0487925895,
-0.0305458438,
0.0235207081,
-0.0076192105,
-0.0012331639,
-0.0078041963,
-0.0406963937,
0.0258750413,
-0.0750503615,
0.0386902764,
0.0286262799,
-0.0337913036,
0.0336639732,
-0.0716635212,
-0.0379094519,
-0.023537606,
-0.013270841,
0.0372013636,
0.0030210989,
0.0398953669,
0.0011173177,
-0.0766773373,
-0.0163899902,
0.0410997458,
-0.0343249813,
-0.0369187109,
0.0246547367,
0.0978736505,
-0.0551401004,
-0.0346394815,
-0.0876868963,
0.0658996776,
-0.0152178891,
-0.0536724478,
0.0352055393,
-0.0599930994,
0.0387954228,
0.0203276165,
0.0285790432,
-0.0310369097,
-0.0098999087,
-0.0159891043,
-0.0261976235,
0.0579261109,
-0.0059707304,
-0.0028950782,
0.0199371781,
-0.0086886864,
0.0261778366,
0.091288358,
0.0370675661,
-0.008505594,
0.0493835285,
-0.0210483707,
-0.0190298893,
0.0825567469,
-0.0055084587,
0.0357671939,
-0.0282759573,
0.0024876073,
0.0110907005,
0.0212236512,
0.0554638728,
0.0046185963,
0.0108259302,
0.0269696843,
0.0293328092,
0.063877143,
0.0422911905,
0.0353963599,
0.0496152565,
-0.0487067662,
-0.0148778446,
0.025028443,
-0.0506714657,
0.0353018716,
-0.0071334094,
-0.0238829907,
0.0127522545,
0.036552649,
-0.0355622247,
-0.0035252126,
-0.0063879741,
-0.0331868529,
-0.0283436924,
-0.0156388152,
0.0536598898,
0.0045337332,
-0.0299721304,
0.0559946038,
0.0947328359,
-0.0447929129,
0.0299354549,
-0.0515362918,
0.0208884757,
0.037788704,
-0.0218387675,
-0.0480165407,
-0.0286016315,
0.0380062833,
0.0288211424,
0.056831196,
0.0536450297,
0.0023112881,
0.0204535853,
-0.0529119633,
0.0348759033,
0.0092909858,
0.0036976647,
0.0818623826,
-0.0236593988,
0.0382308587,
-0.0101982895,
-0.0201977193,
-0.005956314,
0.0348680466,
-0.0720768198,
-0.0288548656,
0.0141536249,
0.0060533565,
0.0512359142,
-0.0105968043,
-0.0069424328,
-0.0238057002,
0.0115394723,
-0.0511499532,
0.0268874336,
0.0058273589,
-0.0488246009,
-0.0256348774,
0.0371242017,
0.0049198987,
0.0274105817,
0.0029394545,
-0.0148492521,
-0.0553019457,
0.0286449622,
0.0180508737,
0.0473568179,
-0.035174448,
0.0463209674,
-0.0020857304,
0.0344803594,
-0.0237814803,
0.0116871763,
0.0260972735,
-0.0239408631,
0.0151816802,
-0.0019506207,
0.0308839437,
-0.0550929643,
-0.0056748316,
0.0471982472,
0.0162309613,
0.0147142988,
-0.0020165215,
0.0467947088,
-0.0352562368,
-0.0380229652,
-0.0653536394,
0.0006184707,
-0.0259361789,
0.0447841585,
0.0087858541,
0.0291863345,
-0.0402654447,
-0.010354314,
-0.0345314182,
0.0282924995,
0.0387048908,
0.0283657145,
0.0303627942,
-0.0072131548,
-0.0033391418,
-0.044443842,
-0.0242711026,
0.0242650453,
0.0166961625,
-0.0457184874,
-0.0726413354,
-0.0624634624,
0.0322283618,
-0.032361269,
-0.0015915998,
-0.0384504199,
-0.0478299148,
-0.0355091952,
-0.009539552,
0.0218903814,
0.0311421528,
-0.0432462506,
-0.0092023071,
0.0337054841,
-0.0247229543,
-0.0298117921,
-0.002850082,
0.0464343838,
-0.0359091088,
-0.0715146214,
-0.0091536157,
-0.0037939586,
0.0769055486,
-0.0428207815,
-0.0199599247,
-0.047691457,
-0.0644644126,
-0.0405640304,
-0.0264105387,
-0.0027382872,
0.0347931907,
-0.0223595835,
0.0638407394,
-0.0079682637,
-0.0359768085,
0.0109595535,
-0.0391192809,
-0.0084702158,
-0.062353231,
-0.0337719806,
-0.0724269599,
-0.0075366469,
-0.0265489817,
0.0029539389,
-0.0444659255,
-0.0305727087,
-0.0786371455,
-0.0089257937,
-0.011596771,
-0.0096819066,
0.0365585536,
-0.0664901733,
0.0208285972,
-0.0461235233,
-0.0293849427,
-0.0081436671,
-0.0168622565,
-0.0027083959,
0.0108482037,
0.0342657194,
0.0044034813,
-0.0251158364,
0.0155796241,
0.0401016586,
0.0236794408,
0.0034633919,
0.0287862886,
-0.0190364327,
0.0121577745,
0.030919183,
0.0430660918,
0.0253708139,
-0.0430968553,
0.0028460401,
-0.0170385595,
0.0543797053,
-0.043074429,
0.0089107174,
0.0324937403,
0.0623823069,
-0.0175729319,
-0.0435096473,
0.0076119276,
0.0637298077,
0.0116207339,
-0.0085448818,
0.0518609881,
0.0016533481,
-0.0573213771,
0.0015397252,
-0.047888495,
0.0074166935,
0.0195737612,
0.0555693433,
-0.0718455091,
-0.0140768383,
0.0149583463,
-0.0353847146,
0.0267055072,
0.0052832686,
-0.0390838645,
-0.11764355,
0.007830183,
0.0078821452,
-0.045960322,
-0.0259553399,
-0.0219580717,
-0.007036027,
-0.0022949139,
0.0449449271,
0.0009408676,
-0.0327887908,
-0.039962355,
0.0412483141,
0.0042693331,
-0.0320371017,
-0.0239657145,
-0.0205640681,
0.0381938741,
0.0345971547,
-0.0067764535,
-0.0399199612,
-0.019525962,
0.0682534799,
-0.0443299636,
-0.0153987389,
-0.0212518442,
-0.0053721252,
0.0189497788,
-0.0203200225,
0.0541364364,
0.0110356929,
-0.0296068098,
-0.0105116963,
0.0260692015,
0.0664570928,
0.0282202139,
-0.0096495654,
0.0205315128,
-0.0257945322,
0.0095470296,
0.0275246818,
0.018678695,
-0.044034332,
0.0035299973,
-0.00517317,
-0.0313461833,
-0.0231231116,
-0.0239024349,
0.0050164936,
-0.085735999,
-0.0219849665,
-0.0516475439,
-0.0371978804,
0.0088925799,
0.048977755,
0.0565231219,
0.0454760268,
-0.0246089082,
-0.0151340934,
0.0071896156,
0.0087884935,
-0.0606877878,
0.0225197412,
-0.0912393332,
-0.0103721451,
0.0279470831,
-0.0359765068,
-0.0057976977,
-0.0288423412,
-0.0455796123,
-0.0648965016,
-0.0071007637,
0.0547567829,
0.0122063868,
0.0107308058,
0.0036354365,
-0.0663845167,
0.081409283,
0.0034059356,
-0.026991047,
0.058306776,
0.0447537266,
0.0382286124,
-0.0030968294,
0.0533617958,
-0.0610798299,
0.0100069782,
0.043200247,
0.0296293646,
-0.029489411,
-0.0224369653,
-0.0143455332,
0.0428239517,
0.0130695486,
-0.064877294,
-0.0235009491,
-0.0526148453,
0.0643518344,
-0.0127090272,
0.0086165443,
-0.0242555439,
-0.0402675383,
0.0452929325,
-0.006236956,
-0.0101402849,
0.0065447683,
0.0072434004,
-0.0072947238,
-0.0130743673,
0.0447784923,
0.0149412528,
0.0508826524,
0.0158862788,
0.0476453006,
0.0148408106,
-0.0064842198,
0.0123771178,
0.0372128785,
-0.0294737145,
0.0161894411,
-0.0248334166,
0.0015104191,
-0.0099301105,
0.0537715442,
0.0023723305,
-0.0092424573,
0.019228695,
0.05386227,
0.0945684537,
-0.0279792473,
0.0946845859,
0.0002144581,
-0.0038924341,
-0.031405285,
0.0171823986,
-0.0326970555,
0.0315200426,
0.0343981907,
-0.0168813653,
-0.0251137689,
0.0141258445,
0.0564367846,
0.0043332856,
0.0205405187,
-0.0019657454,
0.0407123566,
-0.0088397013,
-0.0325340219,
0.052228082,
-0.0263580456,
0.0107378736,
0.0000881052,
-0.0508632846,
-0.0506568849,
0.0143271443,
-0.034012761,
-0.0176768005,
-0.0246282145,
-0.0074126436,
0.0734869689,
0.0191201847,
0.0352695324,
-0.0352598242,
-0.0408657975,
0.0313706361,
-0.0214188211,
0.0451626778,
-6.164331314e-33,
-0.0609837174,
0.0357191451,
0.0370866396,
-0.0038802053,
-0.0029739474,
-0.0057499339,
-0.0037080732,
-0.0189274196,
-0.002234593,
-0.0162677336,
-0.039506577,
-0.0092237433,
0.0323791541,
0.0053890105,
0.0251809042,
0.0055138804,
0.0105390986,
0.0056194775,
-0.0084182862,
0.0115517955,
0.0225792099,
0.0446034446,
0.1056497842,
-0.0264643375,
0.0106610721,
0.0029644833,
0.0332542732,
0.0318508148,
-0.0078383945,
0.036881499,
-0.0278209858,
0.0379482768,
0.0322333425,
-0.0306245182,
-0.0354463272,
-0.0003808419,
-0.061815355,
-0.0186307523,
0.0607349575,
0.038436234,
0.0242931433,
-0.0612241365,
0.0321568586,
0.0025722715,
-0.0281728748,
0.0099246772,
0.0068968423,
-0.0035293815,
-0.0228249617,
0.006593789,
-0.093380779,
0.0332657769,
0.0177456196,
0.0084221121,
0.0276768133,
0.0192525573,
-0.00560319,
-0.0050389017,
-0.028166078,
0.0160925239,
-0.0096908221,
0.0745012835,
0.0726985112,
0.0159731302,
-0.0595188774,
0.0075686476,
0.0291331131,
-0.0302174445,
0.0771963969,
-0.0161064975,
0.0205334313,
0.0189902745,
-0.0023063086,
0.0525874123,
0.0081617478,
-0.0453867875,
-0.086136654,
0.0173234865,
0.0346207917,
0.0198701452,
-0.0126094176,
0.034780547,
0.003547143,
-0.0319453925,
0.0132107073,
-0.0144800432,
-0.012346182,
-0.0318100117,
0.0442871712,
-0.0211919956,
0.0127268014,
-0.0077558998,
0.0619231686,
-0.0123769883,
-0.0285421573,
-0.0126549387,
-0.0152330408,
0.0154172527,
0.002542357,
0.0537598729,
-0.0868753046,
-0.0601499267,
-0.023988409,
-0.0144594796,
0.0042248932,
-0.017891679,
0.0553902313,
0.0111303953,
-0.0786574408,
-0.0011806547,
-0.0205672104,
0.022489557,
0.0391012803,
0.0683484226,
0.0052966224,
-0.0095823165,
-0.0026217566,
0.0204274114,
0.0364681929,
-0.0477022342,
0.0141349183,
-0.0024093299,
0.0051338491,
0.0247657597,
-0.0384301469,
0.016114492,
-0.0376833566,
0.0646299273,
0.0043161334,
-0.0506983101,
-0.0105558857,
0.0190513749,
2.684e-7,
0.0248984396,
0.0275004152,
0.0008672431,
-0.0300585534,
-0.0009296539,
-0.0115199834,
-0.0890116766,
0.0330164433,
0.0022826316,
0.0214300137,
0.0157455094,
0.0293688141,
0.0686146617,
0.0092269722,
-0.0684498176,
-0.0039040314,
-0.0266982224,
0.054021515,
-0.0404867902,
-0.0059808972,
-0.0458855182,
0.0838993117,
-0.0007701596,
-0.0300263986,
-0.0260215979,
-0.0446007922,
0.0576261058,
-0.0607647337,
-0.0254848395,
0.026151292,
0.0147476736,
0.0174847208,
-0.0477276146,
-0.0189113077,
-0.0244906135,
0.0593937524,
0.0068323086,
0.0703288689,
0.0103478804,
-0.0301212985,
0.0387049727,
0.0432929583,
-0.027899364,
-0.024969006,
0.051278159,
0.0133228879,
-0.0202075876,
-0.0319510363,
0.0112018315,
-0.0112722991,
0.0174569804,
-0.0270024575,
-0.0159123745,
0.0154191274,
0.0481361598,
-0.0254394934,
-0.0793608129,
-0.0265900847,
-0.0136030866,
0.0340324529,
-0.0208983924,
-0.0759541094,
-0.0289205965,
0.0116571989,
0.0087607428,
-0.0377733484,
0.0271558743,
2.118583596e-34,
0.0336015299,
-0.004917427,
0.0257100612,
0.0309694335,
0.0073049967,
-0.0280500166,
-0.0184134562,
0.0327797867,
0.0014848144,
-0.0741328299,
0.0084449966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17375v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17375v1 | An Empirical Study on the Characteristics of Bias upon Context Length Variation for Bangla | 2024-06-25T08:49:11 | 2024-06-25T08:49:11 | Jayanta Sadhu, Ayan Antik Khan, Abhik Bhattacharjee, Rifat Shahriyar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models inherently exhibit various social biases,
prompting a crucial examination of their social impact across various
linguistic contexts due to their widespread usage. Previous studies have
provided numerous methods for intrinsic bias measurements, predominantly
focused on high-resource languages. In this work, we aim to extend these
investigations to Bangla, a low-resource language. Specifically, in this study,
we (1) create a dataset for intrinsic gender bias measurement in Bangla, (2)
discuss necessary adaptations to apply existing bias measurement methods for
Bangla, and (3) examine the impact of context length variation on bias
measurement, a factor that has been overlooked in previous studies. Through our
experiments, we demonstrate a clear dependency of bias metrics on context
length, highlighting the need for nuanced considerations in Bangla bias
analysis. We consider our work as a stepping stone for bias measurement in the
Bangla Language and make all of our resources publicly available to support
future research. | [
0.0234380905,
0.0294750612,
-0.0633498579,
0.0154144978,
-0.0232404843,
0.0222513545,
0.041992195,
-0.0465881787,
0.0028073327,
-0.0136272535,
-0.0361435935,
-0.0550857149,
0.075938426,
-0.0095002558,
0.0116794314,
-0.0692981109,
0.0396141857,
0.0190974213,
0.0707230046,
-0.0114386557,
0.0216967575,
0.030478986,
0.004504587,
0.0202650558,
-0.0306947976,
0.007066601,
0.0276668817,
0.0117623387,
-0.0118474467,
-0.0329013653,
0.0243226327,
0.0874414966,
-0.021200113,
0.0156127159,
0.000001694,
-0.1077713519,
0.0067665279,
-0.0019080818,
-0.0248913188,
0.0261302516,
0.0581733026,
0.0094512822,
-0.0332010053,
0.0388905406,
-0.0433369279,
0.0109999683,
0.0641437694,
0.0017255873,
-0.0148027921,
0.0490087792,
-0.0156847183,
-0.0350781977,
-0.0741575807,
-0.0326937847,
0.0033271143,
-0.0017669334,
0.0426254757,
-0.0143289203,
-0.0371788032,
-0.041483704,
-0.0448636338,
-0.0051771291,
0.0157166664,
-0.0051637958,
-0.0106830727,
0.0083510717,
-0.0240448378,
-0.0573526956,
0.0151612228,
0.0357704051,
0.0166188497,
-0.0452417098,
0.0097245527,
-0.0052214451,
0.0373220704,
-0.0330652595,
-0.0164260399,
0.0108543904,
0.0230620895,
-0.0077326489,
0.0303543843,
0.0282624401,
0.0037029607,
0.0136154909,
-0.0040213997,
0.0494852439,
0.0231762398,
-0.0349545442,
-0.0131674139,
0.0089764781,
0.0463544242,
-0.0386773385,
0.0059836968,
-0.0293998495,
0.0063738395,
0.0170349572,
-0.0168438368,
-0.0183027294,
0.0281318389,
-0.0564896576,
-0.0066372794,
0.0232995637,
-0.0488141105,
-0.0137087163,
-0.0002953361,
-0.01234446,
0.017275285,
-0.0193346404,
-0.0215566419,
-0.0096701924,
0.0156917945,
-0.0143422522,
-0.0195563063,
-0.0554411225,
-0.0183939021,
0.0493705645,
-0.0773579031,
0.0181042328,
-0.0411414392,
-0.0312234871,
-0.0097466344,
0.0070958384,
-0.0063637546,
-0.0162836462,
0.0250856169,
0.020267237,
-0.071420975,
0.0292001329,
-0.0292162821,
-0.1427743137,
0.024482118,
0.006147387,
-0.0024088474,
-0.0401884578,
-0.0246625282,
0.0231549572,
-0.0089750076,
-0.0113026388,
-0.0250436515,
-0.0009512268,
-0.0617919005,
-0.057200335,
-0.0453981571,
-0.0508466065,
0.0300178062,
0.0523609146,
0.0089502446,
-0.0161573924,
-0.0365048014,
0.0029610542,
-0.0099149076,
0.0293130837,
0.0283686183,
0.0193480086,
0.0795689896,
0.0194496047,
0.0488868989,
0.09479177,
0.0111380108,
-0.0422421433,
0.0589282885,
-0.0344041884,
-0.021958068,
0.0369954444,
0.0341435634,
0.0101916436,
-0.0344002917,
0.0181216486,
-0.0037503683,
0.0019695791,
0.0610476583,
0.0006754549,
0.0016414637,
0.0138757471,
0.0369685739,
0.0665108562,
0.0301798452,
0.0369755141,
-0.0032806995,
0.0025170601,
-0.0111749796,
0.0147602018,
-0.0474412404,
-0.0162854791,
-0.0237551071,
-0.0294004194,
0.0153330062,
0.0485296808,
-0.0109244399,
0.0014812609,
-0.0068255216,
0.0238394905,
0.0175485723,
-0.0182705186,
0.0355947837,
0.0168042891,
0.0311692245,
0.0331495404,
0.0564732775,
-0.0558038466,
0.0180249624,
-0.0158833824,
0.0324324183,
-0.0213695876,
-0.0400457457,
-0.0175121836,
0.0378310531,
0.0032848762,
-0.0021403066,
0.0398885421,
0.0706522539,
-0.0045586526,
0.0120400954,
-0.0347154327,
0.0207899269,
0.0676081553,
0.0280370843,
0.0240784436,
0.0162422527,
0.0692841932,
0.0161320399,
-0.0355650708,
-0.0332734659,
0.0221892949,
-0.0090364553,
-0.0219403561,
-0.0130366711,
0.0002816905,
0.0447360687,
0.0026021374,
-0.0473116934,
-0.004142601,
-0.0318272971,
0.0146179013,
0.0278554522,
0.0698760003,
-0.0699357986,
-0.0108946254,
0.0057211658,
-0.0647827387,
-0.0166570861,
-0.0090791937,
0.0268072486,
-0.0196732264,
0.0913865268,
0.0021081511,
0.069676131,
-0.0094755897,
0.0233415719,
-0.0569309928,
0.0363066122,
-0.0120566897,
0.0203440115,
0.0032497963,
-0.0471821055,
0.0207401291,
-0.0083000008,
0.0555951409,
-0.0738263056,
-0.0233961158,
0.0239944737,
-0.0183019731,
-0.008470336,
0.0342508107,
-0.0098424908,
-0.0555028021,
-0.0049065356,
-0.118833214,
-0.0447270125,
-0.015595993,
-0.0079641165,
0.0176244266,
0.0539426841,
-0.0595711581,
-0.0366745703,
-0.0070925052,
-0.0271856915,
0.0255358666,
0.0481035151,
-0.0048670657,
-0.0234110355,
-0.0161333103,
-0.0545945019,
-0.0316778012,
-0.027233921,
0.0502340905,
0.0445351899,
-0.0226049013,
-0.0330765806,
-0.0290182885,
0.0041652811,
-0.0136595424,
0.0015997281,
-0.0325532816,
0.0208145808,
0.0303918552,
0.0334220789,
0.0840238333,
0.0244057756,
-0.002410922,
0.0351870432,
-0.0094394544,
-0.047348015,
-0.0485173725,
0.0057333601,
0.0193718858,
-0.0201832838,
-0.0625965893,
-0.0205751918,
0.0461785644,
0.0281116404,
0.0055370368,
-0.0324465334,
0.020988144,
-0.0352169126,
-0.0542995147,
-0.0162074137,
0.0011306007,
-0.0279732011,
0.0672234967,
-0.0334573574,
-0.0727830082,
0.0173172168,
-0.0061611347,
-0.0014482808,
-0.0290656239,
0.0353566892,
-0.0218112525,
0.03034514,
-0.0269277934,
0.0112920031,
0.0031523842,
-0.0267240275,
-0.0560162701,
-0.0049434085,
0.0471083745,
-0.0051383721,
-0.0266806353,
-0.0500708036,
0.0105505753,
-0.0118842563,
-0.0371304899,
-0.0051735863,
-0.0253857505,
-0.0041162143,
-0.0118690189,
0.0061286939,
0.0077873748,
0.0660193264,
0.0136515787,
-0.0258201715,
0.0034875595,
-0.0099988086,
0.0202585589,
0.0196630545,
-0.0271535013,
0.0072326781,
-0.0062353299,
0.0658631176,
-0.0194076169,
-0.0105627663,
-0.0281541944,
0.0397252925,
0.0306522585,
-0.0089711072,
0.0185346268,
0.0327438042,
-0.0279365592,
-0.0097039342,
0.0314678773,
0.0550748482,
0.0048256209,
-0.0019852389,
0.0872476548,
0.0056796456,
-0.0667228624,
0.0203534011,
-0.0556626171,
0.0432853922,
0.0060596848,
-0.0017854895,
-0.0756398961,
0.0163916685,
0.0330374688,
-0.0225934405,
-0.0086125117,
-0.0273663122,
-0.0113882655,
-0.1349581182,
-0.0177060217,
0.0050423774,
-0.0470682792,
-0.0295746494,
-0.0271833278,
0.0252659712,
-0.0081999842,
0.0603108145,
0.0411019139,
-0.0161428843,
-0.0136950333,
0.0297193788,
-0.0521453433,
-0.0730333924,
0.0249143932,
-0.0686569512,
0.0630873665,
0.0340364426,
0.0153002953,
-0.0409030989,
0.0503172949,
0.0445432402,
-0.031918142,
-0.0163002014,
-0.0281526092,
0.0019318598,
-0.0217721015,
-0.0296757128,
-0.023926381,
0.0517146513,
0.0412908085,
0.0360079259,
0.016640814,
0.0146676367,
0.0418561995,
-0.0281818919,
-0.0209864266,
-0.0344431289,
0.0144096296,
0.0403358601,
0.0569267385,
-0.049735751,
-0.0188936871,
-0.0271291863,
-0.0143341552,
0.0396188088,
-0.0583517142,
0.0023263125,
-0.0238629784,
-0.0688193515,
-0.0104991747,
-0.061307136,
0.0037143177,
0.0515900068,
0.0268925261,
-0.029306205,
0.0043437248,
-0.0050670654,
-0.0331552029,
0.0218705181,
-0.0350372829,
0.0295255985,
-0.0199921969,
-0.0085130464,
-0.0493005589,
-0.024186898,
-0.0200454816,
-0.0161309242,
-0.0410122499,
-0.0604234338,
0.0813953355,
0.0096209338,
0.032079868,
0.0506439693,
0.0041711046,
-0.0793741792,
0.0625494197,
-0.0197084267,
-0.0319576152,
0.0737449303,
0.0426377095,
-0.0042432733,
0.0280777272,
0.0333697312,
-0.0319191106,
0.0228239335,
0.0082621733,
-0.0198306963,
-0.0254564937,
-0.0223064031,
-0.0165638346,
-0.0188969597,
0.032066647,
-0.060814511,
-0.0057502124,
-0.0537207834,
-0.0015471786,
0.0035065305,
-0.0273496192,
0.0224505924,
-0.0543215834,
0.0392533019,
0.0551095717,
-0.0086533939,
-0.0460634418,
-0.0618443228,
-0.0010309378,
-0.0047786199,
0.0634688213,
0.0564771742,
0.0724481642,
0.0172174741,
0.0295159128,
0.0214326233,
-0.00048409,
-0.0461666025,
0.0489606969,
0.0148390112,
0.0073538492,
0.0135290446,
0.0127999866,
0.0123727201,
0.029045945,
0.0244285595,
0.0350103192,
0.019340517,
-0.0206398834,
0.0384042636,
-0.0596990138,
0.0738897175,
0.0044597192,
0.0240722299,
-0.0322731175,
0.0157720707,
-0.0367099792,
-0.0088921823,
0.0138655547,
-0.0189033411,
-0.0214579627,
0.0437484533,
0.0364823192,
0.0288707707,
0.0308954641,
-0.0100338142,
-0.0127988188,
0.0030773927,
-0.0143154757,
0.0061593694,
-0.0199298356,
-0.0306827147,
-0.0201704726,
-0.1045767069,
-0.0669196621,
-0.0460705385,
-0.0170640089,
0.0448497385,
0.0165373012,
-0.0038571521,
0.0619164556,
-0.0322058536,
-0.0107462918,
-0.0071070134,
-0.0357412249,
-0.0135526787,
0.0138424467,
-0.0076083057,
-5.778212276e-33,
-0.0296172146,
-0.0190255828,
-0.0237156358,
-0.0523748696,
-0.0132422633,
0.0056519462,
-0.0306113418,
0.0247064941,
-0.0137252603,
0.0053359782,
-0.0153431809,
0.0154741751,
0.0288978908,
-0.0304038767,
0.064177677,
0.0015392707,
0.0235762298,
0.0290611442,
-0.0103227524,
-0.0363855287,
-0.0027802298,
0.0135794636,
0.0651062131,
-0.0368581973,
0.0876309201,
-0.0141341444,
-0.0129176741,
-0.0110185323,
-0.0151203433,
0.0245480519,
-0.0020693312,
0.0579752773,
0.0325092822,
0.0103628058,
-0.0118666645,
0.0697689056,
-0.0476806238,
-0.0486872643,
0.0476891473,
0.0711381957,
0.0233055782,
-0.0001078232,
0.023101503,
0.0038777201,
-0.0864287987,
0.0237846561,
0.0190529656,
0.0216787048,
0.053048972,
0.0783966035,
-0.0485924371,
0.0222537462,
-0.0267592166,
0.0308083035,
0.0029350733,
0.0005768352,
-0.020035781,
-0.0370252654,
-0.0223159809,
0.0321733132,
0.0283962712,
0.0197741631,
0.0356655978,
0.0244929828,
0.0343458988,
0.0153826633,
0.1090587899,
0.0091207102,
0.0159361251,
-0.0577956811,
0.0730538294,
-0.0496525392,
-0.0025143826,
0.077426061,
0.0565996282,
-0.0346762799,
-0.0250931792,
-0.045410309,
0.0814458728,
0.0372679271,
0.0120458305,
0.0136740096,
-0.081890285,
-0.0677071065,
-0.0182595048,
-0.0714973584,
-0.0095759034,
-0.0163621195,
0.0622126833,
-0.013024386,
0.0032307948,
0.0047436291,
0.0364026055,
-0.0267896503,
-0.0229834113,
-0.0002612664,
-0.0279346574,
0.0017262113,
0.0365612507,
0.0367732942,
-0.0801121071,
-0.0011974731,
0.0128662987,
0.0507843494,
0.0001340298,
0.003191994,
-0.0111659458,
-0.0131738465,
-0.0628029928,
0.0122095076,
-0.0140220011,
-0.0229115821,
0.0061528529,
0.0224793274,
0.0365043022,
0.0099020815,
-0.0098988349,
-0.00052019,
0.0510100834,
0.020851763,
-0.0318590403,
-0.0229527988,
-0.0351998173,
0.0278197881,
-0.0321625695,
-0.0193602424,
-0.0116247749,
-0.0073985686,
0.0469549634,
-0.0140515286,
0.0047231363,
-0.0288049001,
2.38e-7,
-0.0245235041,
0.0543717518,
0.0550190099,
-0.0132308658,
0.0246959366,
0.0141614638,
0.0026923751,
0.0296967719,
0.0177855249,
0.0273029339,
-0.0228318181,
0.0088523403,
0.004830475,
0.0176350661,
-0.0699636117,
-0.0079236086,
-0.091224812,
0.0433783755,
-0.0057059783,
-0.0090951808,
-0.0679464787,
0.0382460095,
0.0206066687,
-0.0093417084,
-0.0468437783,
0.0061234692,
0.0043445323,
-0.0349880345,
0.0350589044,
0.0222259834,
0.0133270221,
0.0152695216,
0.0350019671,
0.0215085391,
0.0123706032,
0.0223557334,
-0.026365865,
0.0052060853,
-0.0327240676,
0.043269515,
0.0269310102,
-0.0077617359,
-0.0533772893,
-0.0739307404,
0.0663056672,
0.0403716229,
-0.025359327,
-0.0511109047,
-0.0175436381,
-0.0148134725,
0.0558441505,
-0.0134165389,
-0.0053194342,
0.0047112992,
0.039694868,
-0.0364411436,
-0.019553205,
-0.0393117033,
-0.0265597329,
0.0082772616,
-0.0183641706,
-0.0423028208,
0.0047840374,
0.0620596334,
0.0152188232,
-0.0373575091,
0.0503358394,
1.583050755e-34,
0.0341945551,
0.0245516412,
0.0516346097,
-0.0149558028,
0.0276392549,
-0.0261796955,
-0.0111974301,
-0.0012004656,
0.0727547556,
-0.0228925422,
0.0027681922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17363v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17363v2 | Leveraging Synthetic Audio Data for End-to-End Low-Resource Speech Translation | 2024-06-25T08:26:41 | 2024-06-27T09:08:03 | Yasmin Moslem | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper describes our system submission to the International Conference on
Spoken Language Translation (IWSLT 2024) for Irish-to-English speech
translation. We built end-to-end systems based on Whisper, and employed a
number of data augmentation techniques, such as speech back-translation and
noise augmentation. We investigate the effect of using synthetic audio data and
discuss several methods for enriching signal diversity. | [
-0.0192323793,
0.0271235853,
0.0113830781,
0.0080341892,
-0.0459674299,
-0.0436601639,
0.0372214429,
-0.0111700976,
-0.0308708828,
0.0204090755,
-0.0334306471,
-0.0426830985,
0.036581032,
0.0242821947,
0.0555373244,
-0.0131564066,
0.0680889785,
-0.0369403884,
-0.0474905558,
-0.0379630551,
-0.0209808294,
-0.0063941497,
-0.0188296344,
0.0093443729,
-0.048764132,
0.0134629859,
0.0013167221,
0.0694210753,
0.032323774,
-0.0048233676,
-0.063448973,
-0.0165783782,
0.0097075393,
0.0587543733,
0.0000015749,
-0.0318137258,
-0.0211698804,
0.0305250231,
-0.0539233945,
0.0160445254,
0.0173562374,
0.0446056947,
-0.0257113967,
0.0332918018,
0.0041861609,
0.0005249376,
0.0525328591,
-0.0420020148,
0.0558167659,
0.1051026508,
-0.0210286807,
-0.0418755449,
-0.0032710158,
-0.0469919257,
0.0350833014,
0.0221728813,
-0.0267720837,
-0.0236729551,
0.0002311172,
0.008007939,
0.0097086327,
0.0894481391,
-0.0089829732,
-0.0143169016,
0.0040853266,
-0.0039980747,
-0.0534586012,
-0.0147161707,
-0.0140494369,
0.0682685897,
-0.0306597911,
0.0026899229,
-0.0133850025,
0.0315782949,
0.001968554,
-0.0642788485,
-0.0458191447,
-0.038605988,
0.0047858781,
-0.0116323046,
-0.0228794832,
0.0492249243,
0.034456972,
-0.0734108314,
-0.0175161902,
-0.0174117684,
0.0095109539,
-0.0250126012,
-0.0124293482,
-0.0080874106,
0.0221501086,
0.0154530164,
0.0234219525,
0.0016008681,
0.0142899081,
-0.0094178114,
-0.0121073052,
-0.0724166036,
-0.0349318571,
-0.0591297746,
0.03814869,
0.0502857901,
-0.0489944555,
0.0024138014,
0.0365663134,
-0.012579795,
-0.042482432,
-0.0392183661,
-0.0463431105,
-0.0132167917,
0.023047328,
0.0477060005,
-0.062541008,
0.0131365452,
-0.1059306338,
-0.0155275082,
-0.016525263,
-0.0390200205,
-0.0201125611,
0.0068244752,
0.0674600974,
-0.0089844605,
-0.0894538537,
-0.0323894769,
0.023730725,
0.0500243679,
0.0360798724,
0.037760336,
-0.0183859579,
-0.0782795921,
-0.0262670573,
0.0396084785,
0.03578756,
0.0244008023,
-0.0163878705,
0.1014664248,
-0.018108217,
0.0201099236,
-0.0358404219,
0.0139211183,
-0.0012426215,
-0.032515958,
-0.0341846682,
-0.0698867068,
0.0557667948,
-0.0453925282,
0.0151937725,
-0.0145362131,
0.0101826731,
-0.0292863771,
-0.0129004149,
0.0415786952,
-0.0765704289,
0.0229394864,
0.0197737999,
-0.0276809931,
-0.0416716896,
0.0520744547,
0.0744961202,
-0.0065329415,
0.006205441,
-0.0307789426,
0.0014710909,
0.0675207004,
0.0196508169,
0.0260821711,
-0.0275443532,
0.007675169,
-0.00005943,
0.0119103817,
0.0294772685,
0.0442173816,
-0.009725336,
-0.0141972601,
0.082446605,
0.0045850542,
0.0687066466,
0.0093962215,
0.0526039191,
-0.0022203417,
-0.0184363984,
-0.0287159178,
0.0025872355,
0.0071736029,
0.0274386201,
-0.0047787298,
0.1028652638,
0.0477965213,
0.0051244521,
-0.0195179097,
0.0068674134,
0.0110719325,
-0.0140596051,
0.0254502837,
0.0038977219,
0.0240621157,
-0.0165047087,
-0.0147265242,
-0.0044552144,
-0.0549833179,
0.064452216,
-0.0009653824,
-0.0276238192,
0.0802607015,
0.0432596691,
0.0043025594,
0.044448562,
-0.0881467387,
0.0071500274,
0.0519087985,
0.019080935,
0.007497821,
0.0739297345,
-0.0450857058,
0.0003756395,
0.0423934162,
-0.0205005817,
0.0565131046,
-0.0054833335,
0.0461394452,
-0.0016200971,
-0.0242090225,
-0.053817194,
-0.0264795497,
-0.0005282768,
0.0034904457,
0.0537262186,
-0.0058904337,
0.0448258966,
0.0589289665,
-0.0817854479,
0.0092940526,
0.010834422,
-0.049135372,
0.0580851138,
0.0392439142,
-0.0081220707,
0.0031892026,
0.0447047725,
-0.0552715957,
0.0465682,
0.0129870176,
0.001319741,
-0.0702107847,
0.0344799794,
-0.0582081527,
0.0321328379,
-0.016968403,
0.0479417704,
0.0363013037,
0.0173285343,
-0.0017791067,
-0.0197023023,
0.0059553846,
-0.0192797482,
-0.0510272197,
0.0088919327,
0.0295646265,
-0.0875391811,
0.0122978128,
0.0447055176,
-0.0061583715,
0.0535916314,
0.0012740375,
-0.0320809521,
-0.0099152913,
-0.0039404528,
-0.0484202765,
-0.0011070048,
-0.0218971241,
-0.0066854372,
0.0259019267,
0.0588492826,
0.0140901962,
-0.0150903137,
-0.0478511229,
-0.0076044593,
-0.0200947057,
-0.0147148268,
-0.0704691708,
0.0006945569,
0.0117803551,
-0.0137289139,
0.0152054299,
0.0370658897,
-0.0174937434,
-0.0057590147,
-0.0181481149,
-0.0648108199,
-0.018791819,
0.0231377482,
0.0314496532,
-0.0005901393,
-0.0377722122,
-0.0232353155,
-0.0069610719,
0.0707933381,
-0.0344040506,
-0.0078921188,
-0.0528886877,
0.0045432653,
-0.0284749232,
-0.0521134771,
0.0153889954,
0.0332532749,
0.0397773162,
-0.0620985217,
-0.0080354717,
-0.0066610817,
-0.002747908,
0.039863281,
0.0078638438,
-0.0468494222,
-0.0287156589,
0.0076218667,
-0.0541854836,
-0.0237057507,
-0.030021023,
-0.0055304351,
0.0267898273,
-0.0410686135,
-0.0109789595,
-0.0295012742,
-0.0860633925,
-0.0395357609,
-0.0517134257,
-0.0500374399,
-0.000192345,
-0.0096727498,
-0.0655561239,
0.0285951477,
-0.0545381904,
0.0079490244,
0.0029223254,
0.0085098557,
0.0101978946,
-0.0654898435,
0.0276015326,
-0.0186060313,
0.0031037738,
0.0018815391,
0.0218206942,
-0.0292898882,
-0.0158387478,
0.0219799299,
-0.0451065823,
0.0318434574,
-0.057585068,
-0.0443509109,
0.0452567078,
-0.0032134347,
0.098982662,
0.0037003851,
0.0135548245,
-0.0043264008,
0.0264588408,
-0.001023062,
0.0161450822,
0.0292731691,
-0.0026133526,
0.0190085527,
-0.0492395014,
0.0335145853,
-0.0112607293,
-0.0415907763,
-0.007194797,
0.0150816776,
0.0273644887,
-0.0214585699,
0.0040754247,
0.0785757676,
-0.0041434192,
-0.0276017785,
0.067594178,
-0.0457246713,
-0.0260323882,
-0.0062638689,
-0.0047848136,
0.0231102668,
0.0345929936,
-0.001262494,
-0.0094541935,
0.0120508196,
0.0324561223,
0.0769511387,
0.0491928086,
0.0344715752,
-0.0601169914,
-0.0494302586,
0.0732107162,
0.0696179643,
-0.0852960572,
-0.063706696,
0.021735305,
-0.0468816273,
-0.0368384942,
0.0382953696,
0.0003367113,
0.0183335319,
-0.0181952138,
0.0196482334,
0.0062518339,
-0.0066343709,
-0.0719925761,
-0.0198475886,
0.125295192,
0.0157933254,
-0.0081864353,
0.0076116081,
-0.0243362859,
0.0456485897,
0.028737681,
0.0051224199,
0.0329867341,
0.0421092734,
0.0193418935,
-0.0128403483,
0.0253506489,
0.0029082431,
0.0048502348,
0.0214234255,
0.0161058828,
0.0178972855,
-0.021196086,
0.0585005581,
0.0374776423,
0.0474447422,
0.0419209786,
0.0526748374,
0.0220620055,
-0.028542323,
0.0486379601,
-0.0136521924,
-0.0192658305,
-0.0528336018,
0.0049232952,
0.0249310788,
-0.0046744668,
-0.086840719,
-0.0605775267,
-0.0036984822,
-0.0062182709,
0.0568703897,
0.0265966561,
0.0222460758,
-0.0057234159,
-0.0160588175,
-0.0271827336,
0.0258647203,
-0.0697345808,
0.0233978964,
-0.0276245922,
-0.0422311611,
0.0067643644,
-0.04381736,
0.0372966491,
0.0352721252,
-0.0713168681,
-0.0575043485,
0.0427448303,
0.0168983471,
0.0319744311,
0.0888860896,
-0.0294089559,
-0.0031586909,
0.0444499664,
0.0088813473,
-0.0426533036,
0.0083319834,
0.0497170016,
0.0276231635,
0.0022713037,
0.0316129699,
-0.0403637737,
0.0028875042,
0.0068697124,
0.016594626,
-0.0022374233,
-0.0369707942,
0.0080015594,
0.0121816341,
-0.0062087085,
-0.0196299925,
0.0224304236,
-0.0316279978,
0.0438084975,
-0.0503888875,
0.0356624275,
-0.0390040949,
-0.0497652888,
0.0609013848,
-0.0000300364,
0.0070923888,
-0.0054632961,
-0.0294927526,
-0.0360443108,
-0.0106446566,
-0.0177780688,
-0.0085371574,
-0.0065253037,
0.0361966081,
0.0148741128,
0.0133715533,
0.0610316209,
-0.0218004249,
-0.0043880716,
0.0050312784,
-0.0230698939,
-0.0095005687,
0.0089878142,
0.0229632016,
0.0158406757,
-0.06749852,
-0.0132300053,
-0.016060723,
0.0343375616,
0.0420006998,
0.0284007452,
0.1070346981,
0.0271166246,
0.0274010524,
-0.0185600109,
0.0266382806,
-0.0052457456,
0.0065842327,
-0.0496362783,
-0.0259869471,
-0.006118977,
0.0354706757,
0.0330007188,
-0.029815957,
0.0321918502,
-0.0342467651,
0.0428375676,
-0.0224390235,
-0.0556879342,
-0.0218305103,
0.0116036879,
-0.0176530797,
-0.0048012924,
-0.0011345155,
-0.0621781759,
0.0049779085,
0.0272426736,
0.0248735361,
-0.0096361283,
0.0004207158,
0.0156132113,
-0.0301142912,
0.0447126925,
0.0076065939,
-0.0469846949,
0.0314148851,
-0.0354884192,
-0.0215158798,
-5.654781329e-33,
-0.038263537,
0.0233749263,
-0.0033181049,
-0.0095699383,
-0.0243815221,
-0.0233221948,
-0.0311456528,
0.0052084061,
-0.00940945,
0.0141336769,
0.0091574201,
0.0284734145,
0.0268748123,
0.0168320294,
-0.0316646174,
0.0296268445,
0.0689178631,
-0.0075267674,
-0.0102187479,
0.0085382797,
0.0363784358,
0.0007401283,
0.0087859314,
-0.0493701324,
-0.0118372086,
-0.0062565058,
-0.0106032146,
0.0123036783,
0.0245500356,
-0.0314293467,
0.014019087,
0.0579882152,
-0.0414355733,
-0.0107814707,
-0.0228253864,
-0.0238707326,
-0.0589113124,
-0.0003111187,
0.0251222868,
0.0432507806,
0.0295549538,
-0.0202051047,
0.0253536887,
-0.0215577222,
-0.0202372354,
-0.0015832798,
-0.0118047912,
-0.0486453548,
-0.0039395043,
-0.043906536,
-0.0125702703,
-0.0128686652,
-0.0370138474,
-0.0094413171,
0.0258625597,
0.0666742101,
-0.0105008502,
-0.0941005051,
-0.0664598346,
0.0598040223,
-0.0241304748,
0.0270907898,
0.0548959039,
0.006994132,
-0.0280321389,
0.0013178478,
0.0391757898,
-0.0360531285,
0.0351158455,
0.0318033472,
0.0371914729,
-0.0183579586,
0.0609975383,
0.0251509845,
0.0223903302,
-0.0320266299,
-0.0062703737,
0.0160384066,
0.0313325003,
-0.0394527763,
-0.0022382925,
0.048699785,
-0.0212712493,
0.0252605155,
-0.0461543798,
-0.0487148091,
-0.0127106104,
-0.035943836,
0.0320433751,
0.01890398,
-0.0097608129,
-0.0060734409,
0.0917854086,
-0.0290784445,
0.0320306681,
-0.0212751552,
0.0277459584,
-0.0142873963,
-0.0354531929,
0.0395361818,
0.040216282,
-0.0266587418,
0.1166878715,
0.0575395897,
0.0157245286,
-0.0557669252,
-0.0044326289,
0.0566760264,
-0.0590925366,
0.0233710874,
-0.0039152815,
0.0619291849,
0.0133197512,
-0.0141441552,
0.0243987422,
-0.0326833092,
-0.0126654785,
0.0145732993,
-0.0043181004,
0.0187334735,
0.0216093902,
-0.0025628142,
-0.0009502462,
0.0225997213,
-0.0682333335,
0.0426926091,
-0.0248394534,
-0.0366005711,
0.0427462533,
-0.0010269362,
-0.0332553089,
0.0018596231,
2.448e-7,
-0.0229623057,
-0.0208227746,
0.0350457504,
0.0044218143,
0.0169689227,
-0.0472295135,
-0.0179345831,
0.0190076083,
-0.0371685363,
0.0156648606,
-0.0057176515,
-0.0007028324,
0.12020538,
0.0090702949,
-0.0558377132,
-0.0698984861,
-0.0377078727,
0.016124351,
-0.0334441923,
0.0035049408,
0.0280978121,
0.0724685341,
-0.0014532119,
-0.0157125033,
-0.0042564655,
-0.0066573676,
-0.0011534292,
-0.0289418884,
-0.0098996703,
-0.0128110815,
0.0244044606,
0.0134687852,
-0.0581450947,
0.0023673358,
-0.045557227,
0.0272515621,
0.0278054327,
0.0170127209,
-0.0278739166,
-0.0464540645,
-0.0138399266,
0.032863982,
-0.0034701009,
-0.0001804016,
0.0200938042,
0.0425205305,
0.0028334772,
-0.0012843239,
-0.0435942709,
0.0481913909,
-0.0103581026,
-0.0343950316,
0.0317879617,
-0.0222133789,
0.0327305347,
0.0036493079,
0.0030094904,
-0.0192614775,
-0.0390897021,
-0.0031565626,
-0.0228902753,
-0.0289596524,
0.0053149713,
0.0088753272,
-0.0066585909,
-0.0078449389,
-0.0103324028,
1.602688513e-34,
0.0591331497,
-0.0354635008,
0.0458102226,
-0.0032653783,
0.0196785666,
-0.0550281145,
0.0393316746,
0.0112679247,
-0.0246723108,
0.0020318027,
-0.0599793941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17328v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17328v1 | Dual-Space Knowledge Distillation for Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T07:25:15 | 2024-06-25T07:25:15 | Songming Zhang, Xue Zhang, Zengkui Sun, Yufeng Chen, Jinan Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge distillation (KD) is known as a promising solution to compress
large language models (LLMs) via transferring their knowledge to smaller
models. During this process, white-box KD methods usually minimize the distance
between the output distributions of the two models so that more knowledge can
be transferred. However, in the current white-box KD framework, the output
distributions are from the respective output spaces of the two models, using
their own prediction heads. We argue that the space discrepancy will lead to
low similarity between the teacher model and the student model on both
representation and distribution levels. Furthermore, this discrepancy also
hinders the KD process between models with different vocabularies, which is
common for current LLMs. To address these issues, we propose a dual-space
knowledge distillation (DSKD) framework that unifies the output spaces of the
two models for KD. On the basis of DSKD, we further develop a cross-model
attention mechanism, which can automatically align the representations of the
two models with different vocabularies. Thus, our framework is not only
compatible with various distance functions for KD (e.g., KL divergence) like
the current framework, but also supports KD between any two LLMs regardless of
their vocabularies. Experiments on task-agnostic instruction-following
benchmarks show that DSKD significantly outperforms the current white-box KD
framework with various distance functions, and also surpasses existing KD
methods for LLMs with different vocabularies. | [
0.0140282139,
0.0385860279,
-0.0079428181,
0.0527653135,
-0.0072759101,
0.0207637064,
-0.0063228142,
0.0020067126,
-0.0004202912,
-0.0145672578,
-0.0288876221,
-0.0423794612,
-0.0188873,
0.0160238389,
0.0370229967,
-0.0645530075,
0.0399932116,
-0.0592626892,
-0.0206569992,
-0.0183497462,
-0.0046977908,
-0.0092928158,
0.0349833444,
0.0205919966,
0.0545426756,
-0.031871777,
-0.0145851746,
-0.0023981768,
0.0182176158,
0.0308439936,
0.0268447381,
0.0570846908,
0.0355553329,
0.0242769234,
0.0000024137,
-0.0073252656,
0.0079640755,
-0.0071059368,
-0.0308807176,
0.0423664674,
-0.0007342352,
-0.0167567413,
0.03640287,
-0.0207164958,
-0.0040222537,
-0.0067747324,
0.0343827605,
0.0123001207,
0.0663842186,
0.040544942,
0.0122156078,
-0.0530381463,
0.0291269682,
-0.0277264062,
-0.0014346446,
-0.0263773464,
0.0436783321,
0.0147898868,
-0.0491137877,
0.0209169388,
-0.0637327656,
0.0783022568,
-0.0030921556,
-0.0092296666,
0.0303887054,
0.0103493342,
-0.0038040411,
-0.0175875649,
0.0106256232,
0.0755506232,
-0.0434103273,
-0.0198878925,
0.0205339976,
0.002488941,
0.0017247517,
0.0085039232,
-0.0632010549,
-0.0083770324,
-0.0007926652,
0.0123698004,
0.0292881019,
-0.0224675406,
0.0254462902,
-0.0331290402,
-0.0429632887,
0.0164211374,
0.0191675182,
-0.0422159247,
-0.0103704045,
0.0004885421,
-0.0270440057,
-0.0568320975,
0.0031325079,
0.0221166313,
0.0243257061,
0.0239071567,
-0.0495011397,
-0.0647611171,
-0.0047653476,
-0.0325997174,
0.0647321343,
0.0479965471,
-0.0082904138,
0.0397721976,
-0.011989166,
0.0919945315,
-0.0032494587,
0.0490160435,
-0.0450962558,
0.018650515,
-0.0594153665,
0.0020076041,
-0.0187103897,
0.0122580361,
-0.0131104859,
-0.0112201897,
-0.0008399024,
0.0111706667,
-0.0412617102,
-0.0329076461,
0.0558986664,
-0.0143179335,
-0.0341766365,
0.0000378904,
-0.0043176729,
0.1004288942,
-0.0162923243,
-0.0210615862,
0.0121160904,
-0.0273141898,
-0.0266814828,
0.0029786038,
-0.0185410772,
-0.022582395,
-0.0255234633,
0.0371730551,
-0.0138903912,
0.003014958,
-0.0359767266,
-0.0379639566,
-0.0222749375,
-0.0797157064,
0.0243516229,
-0.0846493468,
0.0566895232,
0.0009866108,
0.0000046975,
-0.0725768059,
0.0096993037,
-0.0146211097,
-0.0466900542,
0.0466541983,
0.0436586887,
0.034452945,
0.0158412121,
0.0235017817,
-0.0310287438,
0.0623690821,
-0.013275356,
-0.0019221831,
-0.0123108514,
-0.0117605599,
-0.0241303984,
0.0276861433,
0.0631501228,
0.0294487439,
-0.030545719,
-0.0033269881,
0.0010671106,
0.0215666611,
0.0700589716,
0.0382802784,
-0.0374899805,
0.0037615898,
0.0449250489,
0.0170425568,
0.0436605178,
-0.0015062421,
0.0500271991,
0.0306690894,
-0.0124231065,
0.0574355982,
-0.0421292707,
0.0163633265,
-0.0086219953,
0.0081389947,
0.0505058691,
0.0559370928,
-0.0386791527,
-0.053888198,
0.0246557016,
0.0050905021,
-0.0019003854,
0.0265376028,
0.0707444325,
-0.0220264085,
-0.0187460482,
0.1082302183,
0.0640579462,
-0.0474920645,
0.0054409401,
-0.0429668128,
0.0119605511,
0.0563622303,
-0.0004041985,
-0.0200940277,
-0.0470961928,
0.0174052846,
0.0128339007,
0.0046518366,
0.0442690998,
-0.0003359229,
-0.0049003274,
-0.0387601517,
-0.0505518615,
-0.0113216396,
0.0149048083,
0.0107204644,
0.0289814696,
0.0064685936,
0.0262317825,
-0.0515420288,
-0.0133975931,
0.0158331525,
-0.0569117852,
-0.0293029025,
-0.0628392547,
0.0167633761,
0.0294134989,
-0.0054708356,
-0.0038774349,
0.0042481497,
0.0335618891,
-0.0200698022,
0.0148045681,
-0.032523226,
-0.0589996725,
-0.0770609975,
0.052070573,
-0.0083875768,
0.0318489783,
0.055766806,
-0.0329545289,
-0.0453357324,
0.0414650701,
0.0073431209,
0.0637611151,
-0.0101181511,
0.0607686676,
-0.0093669351,
0.0144441687,
-0.0387440845,
0.0638973489,
-0.0444264561,
0.0135437809,
0.0097104888,
-0.01280428,
-0.005553646,
0.0322237462,
-0.0448712409,
-0.0121896369,
0.0018343815,
0.0419066101,
0.0064071296,
-0.0278202631,
-0.0391777679,
-0.0265346691,
-0.02979449,
0.0186479706,
-0.0298052188,
0.0098648788,
0.0224773064,
0.0177757815,
0.0195338558,
0.0102592753,
-0.0150964679,
0.0104816994,
-0.0204622578,
-0.0038766346,
-0.0321802869,
0.0042860606,
-0.0024095681,
-0.0262369197,
-0.0399371162,
0.0094509814,
0.0260340665,
-0.042356696,
-0.0086773699,
-0.0411807075,
0.0773219094,
-0.0279831868,
0.0413877591,
-0.0125136925,
-0.0114840399,
-0.0153228296,
-0.0322304219,
0.0357975736,
0.0639991313,
-0.0290782191,
0.0275490843,
0.0804327428,
-0.0218947567,
-0.0898123235,
0.0336676389,
-0.0101683214,
-0.0229076408,
-0.0383652709,
-0.0402748734,
-0.017215088,
0.0893985033,
-0.0104087312,
-0.0482502058,
-0.0649965182,
-0.0415646359,
-0.0083089462,
-0.0234452859,
-0.0354485288,
0.0237026606,
-0.028856799,
-0.0074034408,
-0.0362235829,
-0.0407503359,
0.053981021,
-0.0208586194,
0.0135535505,
-0.0181755964,
0.0066291196,
0.0039004211,
0.0276715476,
-0.0018033307,
0.0097542899,
-0.0084175253,
0.0023835963,
-0.0560585633,
0.0294620823,
0.007339308,
-0.016135864,
0.0775390863,
-0.0495691635,
-0.0179378316,
-0.0084225927,
-0.0007845744,
-0.0159491096,
0.0040627345,
-0.0006386915,
0.022094937,
0.0294716153,
-0.0338519551,
-0.0307379272,
0.0082696918,
0.0208982006,
0.0208020769,
-0.0114922076,
0.0039168932,
-0.0336319506,
0.0049795951,
0.032219585,
0.0087527204,
-0.0470874161,
-0.0629894733,
0.0006900355,
0.050563857,
0.0240592565,
-0.0112778712,
0.0229839273,
-0.0140349567,
0.0705411509,
0.002361418,
-0.0549149327,
0.0185334235,
0.0506249666,
-0.0774720535,
-0.0001084866,
0.1061753631,
0.0018155668,
-0.0297037754,
-0.0052033644,
-0.0053648259,
0.0553020388,
0.0209390372,
0.0384651534,
-0.0498827808,
-0.0360042825,
-0.0064194766,
0.0235260259,
0.0416902043,
-0.0215292741,
-0.0123357987,
-0.0926430374,
-0.0026804837,
0.0478839539,
-0.0209800638,
-0.0632065013,
-0.0293025095,
0.0141096674,
0.0181661472,
-0.0149520487,
0.0114651313,
-0.0213472173,
0.0173369665,
0.0111685097,
-0.0149216391,
-0.0608305782,
0.0293756668,
-0.0152309248,
0.0394632742,
0.0332993157,
0.0357604325,
0.0232528634,
-0.0655592382,
-0.0506807938,
0.0046335105,
-0.0016868004,
0.0091229929,
0.0399584733,
0.0087052379,
-0.000739517,
0.0340997949,
0.023482943,
-0.0445211455,
0.0218533445,
0.0123796072,
0.111450009,
0.0215918086,
-0.0610648356,
-0.0212236643,
-0.0284740962,
0.0182883404,
0.1175597683,
0.0608915649,
-0.0221088678,
-0.0450795069,
-0.0114300093,
-0.0146456705,
0.0000845336,
-0.0078685386,
0.0218901727,
-0.0521023795,
-0.0343130268,
-0.0295369066,
-0.00909926,
0.0223495383,
0.0156058846,
0.0020362018,
0.0341596566,
0.0190841258,
-0.0179837048,
-0.0511686765,
-0.0024639997,
-0.0307204127,
0.0146384081,
-0.0329764634,
-0.0255775433,
-0.0314988978,
-0.0036213011,
-0.0387359895,
0.0120843966,
-0.135931164,
-0.0915394425,
-0.0014202619,
0.0250147749,
0.0099372799,
0.089384079,
0.0125943236,
-0.0319537185,
0.0535499789,
-0.0240741968,
-0.0142497728,
0.0394111015,
0.0391771942,
-0.0445155315,
0.0004812672,
0.0415915921,
-0.0412610248,
0.0019029668,
0.0383082293,
0.0248479694,
-0.0601548366,
-0.0265063792,
-0.0190008283,
0.0342692398,
0.0432950035,
0.0048381696,
-0.026720671,
-0.0345463492,
-0.0029977264,
0.0190615151,
-0.0068644546,
-0.0633250847,
-0.0093780309,
0.0394950248,
-0.0103817768,
0.0260361787,
0.0328818373,
0.0498055369,
-0.0138362767,
-0.0552418716,
0.0099618435,
0.0117495218,
0.0213999487,
0.077155225,
0.0132310363,
0.0000400762,
-0.0109584294,
0.0094380025,
0.0210653711,
-0.0235363711,
0.041170191,
0.013528212,
0.0294149145,
0.0068307715,
-0.0007779563,
-0.0592350401,
-0.0804596096,
-0.0417953841,
0.0223495811,
0.0212919917,
-0.0107642757,
0.0640611202,
-0.0113858022,
-0.0068265521,
-0.0418549664,
0.0141518982,
-0.008866692,
-0.0037359823,
0.0300137047,
0.0113102309,
0.0250898786,
-0.0003509077,
0.1062912121,
-0.0092879338,
0.0467315689,
-0.0345814712,
-0.0047720815,
-0.0349199884,
-0.0324522108,
0.0311812591,
0.0426983088,
0.025463894,
0.0195643194,
-0.0402445458,
-0.0731422752,
-0.0107613485,
-0.0237660836,
-0.0390579589,
-0.0373002663,
0.0461047813,
0.0405941941,
-0.022915462,
-0.0187538397,
-0.0452702641,
-0.0073908214,
0.0068498175,
-0.0305368602,
0.0190060604,
-6.835895645e-33,
-0.0322876386,
0.03644678,
0.0015604908,
-0.0172799863,
-0.0475917272,
0.0040074964,
-0.0214130487,
-0.0193757433,
-0.0355603881,
0.0276369248,
0.0091319634,
0.0224293824,
0.0073366412,
0.0267555043,
0.0262322892,
0.0239284504,
0.066415906,
0.0071478058,
0.0069698729,
0.0675399378,
0.032346651,
0.0478714518,
0.0598383471,
-0.0465147533,
0.0310199633,
-0.0362925753,
0.0641074479,
-0.006894147,
-0.0022954773,
0.0206812937,
-0.026832588,
0.0718123615,
-0.000866171,
-0.072913833,
-0.0768774375,
0.0031149918,
-0.0555888936,
-0.0487210751,
0.0409177355,
-0.0265270788,
-0.0281149801,
-0.0444178097,
0.0486203693,
0.0331860892,
0.0306035448,
-0.0878448412,
0.0351800025,
-0.0140066454,
-0.0293148123,
-0.0053303121,
-0.0690467358,
0.0003996589,
-0.0332012773,
-0.0360435024,
0.0438684449,
0.009640825,
0.0093740495,
0.0024571454,
-0.0655960888,
0.0245863069,
0.0489853583,
0.0784964561,
0.0977531075,
0.0374599919,
-0.0079324218,
0.0504921786,
-0.0235700421,
-0.017470086,
-0.0092101488,
-0.0292583946,
0.0425522588,
0.0712588727,
-0.0043562585,
0.0072853556,
0.0397486575,
-0.0117984079,
-0.0464573652,
-0.0085912058,
-0.0095073218,
0.0325995907,
-0.0052350145,
0.0082392823,
-0.0205244422,
-0.0510202758,
-0.0440287851,
-0.0234069135,
-0.0186066851,
-0.0115214996,
0.0448902696,
-0.0032130766,
-0.0120532047,
-0.0269767791,
0.0340217911,
-0.0803793371,
0.0138732493,
0.0455930643,
-0.0094426516,
0.0159963183,
0.0163786002,
0.0303040631,
-0.0693515316,
-0.0128034363,
0.0138179101,
0.00293564,
0.0000276363,
0.0518567599,
0.029211944,
0.0038863719,
-0.0366818756,
-0.0267718937,
-0.0579325482,
-0.0380579866,
0.0223642215,
0.0281179547,
0.0377828702,
0.0045465073,
0.005097446,
0.0076199449,
0.0327642225,
-0.0157765821,
-0.0064939614,
-0.0027849339,
0.0182183702,
0.0312272348,
-0.0187721923,
-0.0063457196,
-0.054040689,
-0.0248207785,
0.0421220846,
-0.0269523393,
-0.0284205377,
0.0110850632,
2.962e-7,
0.0340104885,
-0.0046026148,
-0.003005282,
-0.0131802401,
0.0043191751,
0.0181401577,
0.0044852723,
0.0300080236,
0.0262025297,
-0.0446499661,
-0.0041405484,
0.0529665388,
0.0374949947,
-0.0196388941,
-0.0936317369,
-0.0099588204,
-0.028035868,
-0.026083177,
-0.0188473947,
-0.0280029848,
0.0308215488,
0.0672710389,
0.033229351,
-0.0087597053,
0.0012854772,
0.0016162106,
0.0237171482,
0.0014644553,
0.0348578766,
0.0545233078,
0.0363576226,
-0.0238878913,
-0.0244706944,
0.0373518318,
-0.0175843854,
0.015045586,
0.0118385935,
0.0911549181,
-0.0277420525,
0.0165164564,
-0.007082935,
0.0012691015,
-0.0220713988,
-0.0737113804,
0.0626222715,
-0.0194434617,
0.0300388671,
-0.0206131134,
-0.0321266837,
-0.0142860608,
-0.0052305427,
0.0142487045,
0.0399212837,
0.0183017738,
-0.0013217662,
-0.0313645005,
-0.0229129959,
-0.0743770003,
-0.0312683806,
0.0244357344,
-0.0554843619,
-0.0630804002,
-0.0346307419,
-0.0594522692,
0.0115064504,
-0.0475715101,
-0.0012600988,
2.870126496e-34,
0.0385420471,
0.030138718,
0.029093178,
-0.0017778357,
-0.0189932827,
-0.0478853583,
-0.0629014373,
0.0314710848,
0.0016735487,
-0.0872392133,
-0.0351007544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00087v1 | ARES: Alternating Reinforcement Learning and Supervised Fine-Tuning for Enhanced Multi-Modal Chain-of-Thought Reasoning Through Diverse AI Feedback | 2024-06-25T07:20:11 | 2024-06-25T07:20:11 | Ju-Seung Byun, Jiyun Chun, Jihyung Kil, Andrew Perrault | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) excel at comprehending human instructions and
demonstrate remarkable results across a broad spectrum of tasks. Reinforcement
Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) and AI Feedback (RLAIF) further refine LLMs
by aligning them with specific preferences. These methods primarily use
ranking-based feedback for entire generations. With advanced AI models
(Teacher), such as GPT-4 and Claude 3 Opus, we can request various types of
detailed feedback that are expensive for humans to provide. We propose a
two-stage algorithm ARES that Alternates REinforcement Learning (RL) and
Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT). First, we request the Teacher to score how much
each sentence contributes to solving the problem in a Chain-of-Thought (CoT).
This sentence-level feedback allows us to consider individual valuable
segments, providing more granular rewards for the RL procedure. Second, we ask
the Teacher to correct the wrong reasoning after the RL stage. The RL procedure
requires massive efforts for hyperparameter tuning and often generates errors
like repetitive words and incomplete sentences. With the correction feedback,
we stabilize the RL fine-tuned model through SFT. We conduct experiments on
multi-model dataset ScienceQA and A-OKVQA to demonstrate the effectiveness of
our proposal. ARES rationale reasoning achieves around 70% win rate against
baseline models judged by GPT-4o. Additionally, we observe that the improved
rationale reasoning leads to a 2.5% increase in inference answer accuracy on
average for the multi-modal datasets. | [
0.0381052047,
0.070757173,
-0.0068823528,
0.0096636722,
-0.0483162589,
0.0106873708,
0.0202983487,
-0.0370083749,
-0.028670229,
-0.0504831746,
-0.0181895606,
-0.0030027968,
0.00663799,
-0.0018411105,
0.0226449668,
-0.0859921947,
0.0427409224,
-0.052942574,
0.0284902342,
-0.0176016185,
-0.0049376511,
0.0100275492,
-0.0392395668,
0.0353364348,
0.0093112411,
-0.0179251749,
-0.0494446568,
-0.0125734387,
0.0644037873,
-0.0252983607,
0.0119117443,
0.0450545512,
0.0341026857,
-0.0013247274,
0.0000023504,
-0.0626291558,
-0.0364688374,
-0.0037141647,
-0.0247775614,
-0.0324245058,
-0.0080328751,
0.05275039,
0.0242264643,
0.0206505638,
-0.0128687136,
0.0742060915,
0.0371827595,
0.0462557003,
0.0686248466,
0.0471074283,
0.0141497394,
-0.0397754945,
0.0176982805,
-0.0072904015,
0.0227724388,
-0.0288893376,
-0.0142217753,
0.048011627,
0.056972947,
0.0281932168,
-0.0397724658,
0.0237685144,
0.0439699106,
0.0044269562,
0.0047865263,
0.0305061676,
0.0191610437,
-0.0056273742,
0.0023959749,
0.0841203779,
0.0043160012,
-0.0111803319,
-0.0219158437,
0.0009039001,
0.0346141756,
-0.0044738827,
-0.0508137792,
0.0506018214,
-0.0149855185,
0.0242052749,
0.0171966776,
0.0029009474,
0.004411838,
0.028406674,
-0.0247454531,
0.0302752145,
-0.0245588627,
-0.0439230055,
0.0461001992,
0.0130928429,
-0.0511724427,
-0.0239906851,
-0.0034358716,
0.0401652418,
-0.0792262033,
0.0105695501,
-0.0121809924,
0.0019850819,
-0.0009826001,
0.0387508534,
0.0397198014,
0.0502633415,
-0.0076782801,
0.0355963185,
-0.0126716932,
0.0244856868,
-0.015313589,
0.0530660078,
-0.0035385212,
0.0046850513,
-0.0998201072,
-0.0089734998,
0.0126697561,
0.0563476011,
-0.0180016328,
0.0073636179,
-0.0383465514,
-0.0095973108,
-0.0320093483,
0.0255129952,
0.0136177149,
0.0383466631,
-0.0096317567,
-0.0207135193,
-0.0683714449,
0.0758474469,
-0.0742846429,
0.0501810312,
0.0646438524,
0.0149364946,
-0.0186754763,
-0.0195512902,
0.0140382312,
-0.0233494993,
0.0522585846,
0.0791005865,
-0.0593617484,
-0.0040480555,
-0.0227776337,
-0.0561455041,
-0.0125280367,
-0.084133938,
0.0291601066,
-0.0395861305,
-0.0096884277,
-0.0131829353,
0.004232836,
0.0187133085,
0.006631521,
0.0302056484,
-0.0293084122,
0.0935717598,
0.0209442321,
-0.011553064,
-0.0167598538,
0.0266213156,
-0.0540032871,
0.0512382053,
0.0312473495,
0.0197785702,
0.0336851776,
0.005367198,
-0.0005585231,
-0.017817352,
0.0188413505,
-0.0079290299,
0.0078146793,
-0.0142451469,
-0.0706340671,
0.0676462054,
0.0011755876,
0.0075529693,
-0.0122279441,
0.0284486935,
0.0416153334,
0.0108156875,
-0.0013745122,
-0.0009097513,
0.008998231,
-0.0080902372,
0.0085094022,
0.0056906398,
-0.0666813329,
0.0728383288,
-0.0445507914,
0.0076194825,
0.0445508026,
0.0190057438,
0.0070442525,
-0.0710117072,
0.0388730653,
0.0134505071,
0.0050458433,
0.0428402945,
0.0541448928,
-0.0127884494,
-0.0306890998,
-0.0242067929,
0.0322228186,
-0.0080457255,
-0.0272961166,
-0.0562106185,
0.0327190533,
0.0483476371,
0.0382249318,
-0.0517192259,
-0.0460981615,
-0.0242091715,
0.0096725747,
-0.0087170852,
-0.0026073377,
-0.0092209401,
-0.0132275065,
-0.0471802205,
-0.0596228018,
-0.0474631153,
0.0036096505,
0.0349461474,
0.0093858764,
-0.0102566145,
-0.0189796165,
-0.0300520193,
0.004368186,
0.0035024451,
0.0077055437,
0.0047832606,
-0.0079176147,
0.0188116338,
0.0307625476,
0.0025767491,
0.0061019626,
0.0162853785,
-0.0050234497,
-0.0116707291,
-0.0327620991,
-0.0061866124,
-0.0778096393,
-0.0094522228,
0.0315465443,
-0.0614621416,
-0.0213772506,
0.0243651439,
-0.0447989032,
-0.0373342931,
0.0407311544,
0.0009606012,
-0.0389951207,
0.0028367932,
-0.0041051819,
0.017143758,
-0.0162928961,
-0.0482023321,
0.071220614,
0.0120612057,
-0.0047758529,
0.0207875203,
0.016878156,
0.0237711743,
-0.0227521565,
0.0175093319,
0.0133835403,
0.0000694694,
0.003898365,
0.0153968045,
0.0413951166,
-0.0631937832,
-0.014725361,
-0.0647628307,
-0.0118290661,
0.0015774865,
0.0086351102,
-0.0171252042,
-0.0022614268,
0.0102772843,
-0.0019948226,
-0.0181355886,
0.0133343125,
0.001318468,
0.0005451895,
0.032389529,
-0.0106620071,
0.0076799588,
-0.0210142191,
-0.0064326422,
-0.0297753997,
0.0388106443,
0.0272507444,
0.0450379737,
-0.0419240929,
-0.0252776649,
-0.0405527204,
0.0311995279,
-0.0113661811,
-0.0338472724,
0.0414188877,
-0.0208516438,
0.030161893,
0.1255889982,
-0.0020198959,
0.002314291,
0.0766577497,
0.0008856466,
-0.0626450628,
0.0549711771,
0.0139496289,
-0.0291508958,
-0.016578773,
0.0064779557,
-0.036208339,
0.0347927026,
-0.0049232948,
-0.0042263973,
-0.0626541898,
0.04280743,
0.0239553079,
-0.0071781506,
-0.0558383949,
0.0044715041,
-0.0058595403,
0.0585715026,
-0.01471477,
-0.0083305864,
0.1191678792,
0.0270225089,
0.0135880895,
-0.0467304103,
0.0083974916,
-0.007089376,
0.0504696742,
-0.0230549257,
0.008811173,
0.0176702086,
0.0438966155,
-0.0871353596,
-0.0039352491,
0.0405783281,
-0.0123423534,
0.0426619612,
-0.0558836497,
-0.0340626687,
-0.0098801134,
-0.053520076,
-0.032108821,
-0.0106915226,
-0.050667204,
0.0130950017,
-0.021413574,
-0.0353297479,
-0.0269831885,
-0.045161061,
0.0742186904,
-0.0040068622,
-0.0431626588,
-0.0343068615,
-0.0237618349,
0.021912612,
0.0420709811,
0.0416252762,
0.0273760259,
-0.0342085548,
0.0248789992,
0.0173265971,
0.03413276,
-0.0303766057,
-0.0363581553,
0.032221254,
-0.0172558334,
0.0195956733,
-0.0076522832,
0.0336819589,
0.0619345084,
-0.0467500202,
-0.0080568939,
0.0870694742,
0.0322403423,
-0.0353605486,
0.0046193646,
-0.0128408968,
0.0695979372,
0.0142502747,
0.0371905789,
-0.0759282336,
-0.0765505582,
0.020831624,
0.0394929945,
-0.0042859451,
-0.0308861323,
0.0332408883,
-0.1135568917,
0.0229589101,
-0.011481693,
-0.0241739042,
-0.0058487691,
-0.0177502222,
-0.0032768997,
-0.0040000016,
-0.0383611321,
0.0149533907,
0.0083180135,
-0.0013870625,
0.046041362,
0.0557333827,
-0.0359089635,
0.0523206964,
-0.0077913906,
0.0332976431,
0.0288813394,
0.0072004483,
-0.004600062,
-0.0685749501,
0.0278490204,
0.0132472394,
0.0213880148,
-0.0037297665,
0.0044828909,
0.001924519,
-0.0178078096,
-0.0272771083,
0.0824290216,
0.0179721918,
-0.0252329074,
0.0262614079,
0.1063454449,
-0.0287806783,
0.0172284171,
-0.0276720915,
0.0191089157,
-0.0321612991,
0.0330194756,
0.0104716774,
-0.0430910178,
-0.0397380106,
-0.0474046804,
-0.0328463688,
-0.0729530007,
-0.0138839018,
0.0161241889,
0.0110733155,
0.0468234159,
-0.0328697041,
-0.0194934905,
0.0102358237,
0.0459856391,
-0.0081153978,
-0.0402568951,
-0.0150862057,
0.0477180295,
-0.0032831214,
0.0309566054,
-0.0281438399,
0.017028885,
-0.0217631366,
0.0276460461,
0.0008365025,
-0.086485371,
-0.0340077616,
0.0061665955,
-0.0335376002,
-0.0451819822,
-0.0398242287,
0.0685035363,
0.0177164972,
0.064917244,
0.0162034985,
-0.0444642603,
0.0143297296,
-0.0063200356,
0.0034001258,
0.0039540539,
0.0631049499,
0.0175349507,
0.0023678099,
0.0203596652,
-0.0429301858,
0.0002069846,
0.0072633303,
0.0233945753,
0.0101922983,
-0.0027740523,
0.0421285555,
0.0058945925,
0.0283043534,
-0.0297869164,
-0.0272157323,
-0.0286700837,
0.0363397859,
-0.0045216898,
-0.0350281671,
-0.0237445906,
0.0124979932,
-0.0015312402,
-0.0457056761,
-0.0014830442,
-0.0723945946,
0.0389624275,
0.0195005685,
-0.0021021252,
-0.0013834069,
0.0263583809,
0.0164652951,
-0.0195428152,
0.0100532314,
0.0062512662,
-0.005579459,
0.0206565261,
0.0559712909,
-0.0284529887,
0.126171127,
0.0757861808,
-0.0260602813,
-0.0476710238,
0.0285735447,
-0.0684237629,
-0.0379647687,
0.0087963967,
-0.0035273496,
0.0514225215,
0.0446842387,
-0.0093436195,
-0.0266566463,
-0.0221955944,
0.0254972,
0.0649569482,
0.014871534,
0.005751906,
0.0191921592,
0.0284164157,
0.034117192,
0.0130208926,
0.0355416648,
-0.0221124887,
0.023655992,
-0.0149695938,
-0.0024008136,
-0.043173898,
-0.0179191697,
-0.0230247956,
0.0260395538,
0.0242172424,
-0.0097478488,
-0.0305619538,
-0.0501499921,
-0.0383504927,
0.0302724689,
0.0061346795,
-0.0015373068,
0.0291752927,
0.0343922153,
-0.0293902587,
-0.0402238145,
-0.0091562402,
-0.022520991,
-0.0075641358,
-0.0135669289,
-0.0144244628,
-7.09384539e-33,
-0.0122839306,
-0.0223453473,
0.0338128507,
-0.0173141044,
-0.0198740289,
-0.0081137409,
-0.0381941646,
0.0068534254,
-0.0237610023,
0.0357788503,
-0.0125758396,
-0.0260957405,
-0.0103470851,
0.0132390549,
0.0395060964,
-0.0158025995,
0.0098020164,
0.020637935,
-0.0513802096,
0.0202577263,
0.0435956679,
-0.0254973322,
0.0432990082,
-0.0399378315,
0.0194759425,
0.0468978472,
-0.0615822822,
0.0441155285,
-0.1239833981,
0.0583439767,
-0.000102004,
0.0199566241,
0.0213027466,
-0.0508470163,
0.0249284282,
0.0163181387,
-0.0789251998,
-0.056607645,
0.0248198267,
-0.0448591597,
-0.0980893224,
-0.0448915698,
0.0180898905,
0.0273854546,
-0.0002733354,
-0.0449542366,
0.0259937309,
-0.0332687981,
0.0167318303,
-0.0004641267,
-0.0175073408,
-0.0096414508,
-0.0585881285,
-0.044242844,
-0.0260950848,
0.0789117366,
-0.0036584723,
0.0587264486,
0.0008673678,
0.0169494525,
0.0473575778,
-0.0049280575,
0.0509580337,
0.0150621841,
-0.0271927919,
0.0389292091,
-0.0149170207,
-0.0334917568,
-0.0363932848,
-0.0123928031,
0.0028442342,
0.0440244414,
0.0764251202,
0.045983579,
0.0015340981,
0.050310865,
-0.1007599309,
0.0020453739,
-0.0400240719,
0.0745042637,
0.0053975899,
0.0149626965,
-0.030918207,
-0.0016316272,
-0.0773832202,
-0.0246443972,
-0.0428697094,
0.0032869366,
0.0336632617,
0.0116807837,
-0.0406392068,
-0.0018650288,
0.0099619161,
-0.0233347155,
0.0052283145,
0.0047430694,
-0.015918266,
0.0262011345,
-0.0099553689,
-0.0038463671,
-0.0286554322,
0.0088080205,
0.0550758392,
-0.0120102037,
0.0244985148,
-0.0056349877,
0.0504058823,
0.0266992226,
-0.025467474,
-0.0051841587,
-0.0426653922,
0.0162414107,
-0.0034058723,
-0.0218304321,
0.0149760973,
0.0130126039,
-0.0285669044,
0.0529861748,
0.018670449,
0.0011805306,
-0.0357277356,
-0.0228500031,
-0.0070937364,
0.0003907928,
-0.011051191,
0.0224757995,
-0.0315558985,
-0.0563337058,
-0.0195710249,
-0.0667621195,
-0.0243191328,
0.0490427837,
3.166e-7,
-0.0128081348,
0.0512080677,
-0.0054673282,
-0.0119494963,
0.0169899892,
0.0805201232,
-0.0194000807,
-0.0243415795,
0.0226143226,
-0.0393024273,
0.0145038627,
0.0462382399,
0.0437120087,
0.021163946,
-0.0275571365,
-0.0380027518,
-0.0350835547,
-0.0361802205,
-0.0613826141,
-0.0063741249,
0.0981920958,
0.0593362637,
0.0221954174,
-0.0365710855,
0.0269225221,
0.0239188559,
0.0279002693,
0.005451736,
-0.0224625114,
-0.0379610062,
0.0230943318,
-0.0333881527,
0.0141286198,
0.0383556038,
0.0074844942,
-0.0222296007,
-0.037509419,
0.0352059118,
-0.0171911754,
-0.0460138842,
-0.0270806737,
0.0288420431,
0.0015429314,
-0.0632847697,
0.0688259825,
-0.0414640903,
-0.0298512001,
0.0081258388,
-0.010085457,
-0.0461575054,
0.0008278368,
-0.0148530398,
-0.0271482132,
-0.011632517,
-0.0266699996,
0.020475924,
-0.0097888494,
-0.0873318836,
-0.0247532949,
0.0341345407,
-0.0070992745,
-0.0003039186,
-0.0098817926,
-0.011661699,
0.0636914,
-0.087508671,
-0.0265407935,
2.895905409e-34,
0.0167911593,
-0.0413522311,
0.0501470715,
-0.0097676087,
0.0573915951,
0.0168617852,
-0.0348024592,
-0.0157898087,
0.0544457771,
-0.0673848614,
-0.0532822013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17324v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17324v1 | Delving into the Utilisation of ChatGPT in Scientific Publications in Astronomy | 2024-06-25T07:15:10 | 2024-06-25T07:15:10 | Simone Astarita, Sandor Kruk, Jan Reerink, Pablo Gómez | cs.CL | cs.CL, astro-ph.IM, cs.DL | Rapid progress in the capabilities of machine learning approaches in natural
language processing has culminated in the rise of large language models over
the last two years. Recent works have shown unprecedented adoption of these for
academic writing, especially in some fields, but their pervasiveness in
astronomy has not been studied sufficiently. To remedy this, we extract words
that ChatGPT uses more often than humans when generating academic text and
search a total of 1 million articles for them. This way, we assess the
frequency of word occurrence in published works in astronomy tracked by the
NASA Astrophysics Data System since 2000. We then perform a statistical
analysis of the occurrences. We identify a list of words favoured by ChatGPT
and find a statistically significant increase for these words against a control
group in 2024, which matches the trend in other disciplines. These results
suggest a widespread adoption of these models in the writing of astronomy
papers. We encourage organisations, publishers, and researchers to work
together to identify ethical and pragmatic guidelines to maximise the benefits
of these systems while maintaining scientific rigour. | [
0.0832244605,
0.0562374741,
0.022597665,
-0.0117415776,
-0.0689994022,
0.0041655493,
0.0395536646,
0.0421243347,
0.0320608988,
-0.0543923378,
-0.002565471,
-0.0257367212,
-0.0017011964,
0.0403943583,
0.0147123365,
-0.036657244,
0.0480765849,
-0.0032759614,
0.0629908144,
-0.0031868711,
-0.0110644614,
-0.0074457293,
0.0237214789,
0.0234990343,
0.0090619903,
-0.0496103652,
0.0521544777,
-0.0433782116,
0.0163738225,
-0.0264561623,
-0.0003314062,
0.0798448324,
-0.0100671528,
0.1040261909,
0.0000016165,
-0.06071252,
-0.0281922668,
0.0408780985,
0.0082381321,
0.0714425519,
0.0908808038,
-0.0045536938,
-0.0060053542,
-0.0247918088,
-0.0345892087,
0.034506131,
0.0742327198,
-0.0151694296,
-0.0166078452,
0.0308941323,
-0.0114465002,
-0.0279450212,
0.0292703621,
-0.0114117572,
0.0015852713,
0.0119544612,
0.0481230468,
0.0318709984,
0.020163117,
0.072005026,
-0.0075128819,
0.0818875581,
-0.0163335726,
-0.0354344994,
0.0186237805,
0.045678217,
-0.0672162101,
-0.0143805835,
0.0246064346,
-0.0199697074,
0.0439353175,
-0.0561498217,
0.0482114255,
-0.0134196421,
-0.0431274958,
0.0555246621,
-0.0568246581,
0.0098935608,
-0.0193978008,
-0.028905265,
0.0363400653,
-0.0283377878,
0.0053931521,
0.0628893375,
0.0050401432,
0.0524846762,
0.0187468808,
-0.0502501689,
0.0235501677,
0.0217452329,
0.0103081251,
-0.0729151592,
0.0227713734,
-0.0205794387,
0.0239403043,
0.0283117387,
-0.0300370716,
0.0021801752,
0.0400180593,
-0.0457045361,
0.0086308233,
0.0305869877,
0.019050993,
0.0662812218,
0.026410697,
0.0052919677,
0.0173462741,
-0.0155231562,
0.0374186374,
0.006069771,
-0.0398188494,
-0.0527541414,
-0.0124630928,
-0.0408754461,
0.0136458939,
-0.0216362551,
-0.0428364873,
-0.0215933416,
0.0337116383,
-0.016426228,
0.0121863401,
0.0278682336,
-0.0654669702,
0.0075436928,
0.0112658227,
0.0117844874,
0.038719371,
0.0193373952,
0.0238373876,
-0.0519627929,
0.0111660566,
0.0403286628,
-0.0125533901,
-0.0015682164,
0.012813108,
0.0826995671,
0.0391995572,
-0.0453792736,
0.0498763509,
-0.039988298,
-0.0294900872,
-0.0369884335,
0.006392702,
-0.0321913622,
0.013307794,
0.0383905545,
-0.0184645839,
-0.0294245388,
-0.0028397879,
0.0424697846,
-0.0554089509,
0.0195292458,
-0.0659025162,
0.0054021445,
0.032362096,
0.0126246465,
-0.0244842023,
0.0126271686,
0.0506212451,
0.0131292967,
0.0613838211,
-0.0558354668,
0.0390581824,
0.013553868,
-0.0250847228,
-0.0026292093,
-0.0091885133,
0.0154601932,
-0.072265625,
0.0195759013,
0.0067829085,
0.0669083521,
-0.0302932374,
0.0015598808,
0.0063389689,
0.1013335064,
-0.0045826579,
0.0772502571,
0.0126233706,
-0.0022206262,
0.0391821638,
-0.0262636188,
-0.010359996,
0.0440585688,
-0.0355451219,
-0.0135528697,
-0.0011950333,
0.0280372426,
0.0292794257,
-0.0147389723,
-0.0195345357,
0.0524857976,
-0.007354788,
-0.0451628417,
0.0274550393,
-0.0269830059,
0.0056279348,
-0.0120158689,
0.0584860966,
-0.0317755714,
0.0203418266,
-0.0039832229,
0.026415702,
0.0268160366,
0.0524522141,
-0.0148791205,
0.0189414732,
-0.0112866303,
0.0216739625,
0.0885302648,
0.0209453795,
0.0068809842,
-0.0567627288,
-0.0310276933,
-0.0280351732,
0.002136868,
-0.000656301,
0.0082837958,
0.0089043472,
0.032596875,
0.0101289479,
-0.0069188932,
-0.0762216374,
0.0408458188,
-0.0708017424,
-0.0655169189,
-0.0235625561,
-0.0390321463,
0.0270405319,
-0.0236727484,
-0.0472616851,
0.0360008031,
0.0030316096,
0.0143071888,
-0.0377680324,
0.0247563664,
0.0379258208,
0.032232862,
0.0111165587,
-0.08013165,
0.0005596325,
-0.0136903403,
0.0147310058,
0.0016719654,
0.0117040724,
-0.0363113545,
0.0151689369,
-0.0290996265,
-0.0044005327,
-0.0361586884,
0.0095195258,
-0.0497973822,
0.023953069,
-0.0099573387,
0.0781278387,
-0.014979627,
-0.0402537733,
0.040269807,
-0.0157850832,
-0.0301092174,
0.0217581261,
0.0299543124,
0.0004387388,
0.0457477607,
0.0040668598,
-0.0036684666,
-0.0366959125,
-0.0471148677,
-0.0302928258,
0.0194695219,
-0.0079649482,
0.0184767712,
-0.0410034619,
-0.0447408669,
0.0321603343,
0.0315482169,
-0.0277582072,
0.0156372935,
0.0170275662,
0.0621696413,
-0.0293949023,
-0.0092755277,
-0.0583914779,
-0.0365152396,
-0.0468376093,
0.0311487652,
0.0870244578,
-0.027918512,
-0.0551799983,
0.0447142422,
-0.0176745933,
-0.0328001268,
-0.0158724822,
-0.0299355984,
0.0401247516,
-0.0064268927,
-0.0204161629,
0.0442982949,
0.0263178907,
0.022532884,
0.0297941919,
-0.0107060652,
0.0007355601,
-0.0414355993,
-0.0314119272,
0.0049547632,
0.0418582857,
-0.0137773985,
0.0695196837,
0.0055183643,
-0.0173916202,
-0.0177104492,
-0.0049264743,
0.0512749217,
-0.0603481308,
-0.0137631465,
0.0051241051,
0.0124882953,
-0.0532228723,
0.0158709008,
0.0457322188,
-0.0398409441,
0.029128911,
-0.0349258259,
-0.018983772,
-0.0758764297,
-0.0186702441,
0.003771353,
-0.0116579179,
-0.0179589577,
0.0230773296,
0.0470224135,
-0.0024170049,
-0.0367619917,
0.0151005127,
0.0025883061,
-0.003111724,
-0.002463632,
-0.0333048292,
0.0061245565,
0.0051264712,
0.0097973086,
0.0005059235,
-0.058316391,
-0.0343269743,
0.0197940152,
0.0535030365,
-0.0878865272,
-0.0456726402,
-0.0048879972,
0.0357223414,
-0.0195299741,
-0.035130173,
-0.0278240442,
-0.0131585365,
0.0016314718,
0.0802278668,
-0.0248213299,
0.0214898419,
-0.0081068315,
-0.0533996113,
0.0428515039,
-0.0286061652,
0.0378602222,
0.0130933737,
-0.0457498841,
0.0256579667,
-0.0398823321,
-0.0204369295,
-0.0086217215,
0.0348832086,
-0.0353279859,
0.0172655191,
0.0924728513,
0.0077383374,
-0.0210208762,
-0.0118792709,
0.000787003,
-0.0015277987,
0.0080565298,
0.0035089408,
-0.0803183317,
0.0215655938,
-0.0247284099,
-0.0118214684,
-0.0139871351,
-0.0361650847,
-0.0299629159,
-0.0287449602,
0.0537586026,
0.0156810209,
-0.0537702106,
0.0212333705,
-0.0493258536,
-0.0071081114,
-0.0264467448,
-0.0326497257,
-0.0020083669,
-0.0199689735,
0.0140781431,
0.0348539986,
-0.0375092216,
-0.0622569509,
0.0076907156,
-0.0532296896,
0.026906034,
0.0049406686,
0.0688680336,
-0.0543350764,
-0.0295720715,
-0.0182737727,
0.0220474433,
-0.0048164995,
0.0116423434,
0.019675605,
0.0185785871,
-0.006584242,
-0.040750064,
0.0572110228,
-0.0556741767,
0.0085691754,
0.0089267483,
0.0753156543,
-0.0336136818,
-0.0416571423,
-0.0628121644,
0.0160113852,
0.0145557029,
0.077005744,
-0.0179365072,
-0.0192071442,
-0.0471323915,
-0.0485518873,
0.016060289,
0.0018799297,
-0.038234029,
-0.0391405858,
-0.0026002529,
-0.0429629683,
-0.0262166224,
-0.0353192203,
0.0011003491,
0.0239722356,
0.0412054881,
0.022139078,
0.0158124659,
-0.0149720535,
-0.008205655,
0.0135111595,
-0.0210924838,
-0.0109887896,
-0.04847157,
-0.0185908768,
0.033606682,
0.0496473573,
-0.0530700423,
-0.0116382279,
-0.0319080129,
-0.0688450783,
0.0114388391,
-0.0119042695,
0.0327963829,
-0.0366984084,
0.0203737952,
-0.0554389469,
0.021779228,
0.0605878122,
0.0052159973,
0.0144259501,
-0.0394900553,
-0.0145666376,
-0.0071787271,
-0.0422890447,
0.0015225196,
-0.0151021788,
-0.0137986904,
-0.0282802209,
-0.0461945422,
-0.0277647302,
0.0279844366,
0.0282945074,
0.0432687216,
-0.09995839,
0.0005460069,
-0.0047339601,
-0.0776070952,
-0.0392149724,
0.0079468936,
-0.0194930565,
0.0149868941,
0.0195083022,
0.0350991637,
-0.0281162374,
0.0363475308,
-0.0392889082,
0.0100777475,
-0.0377902351,
0.056472484,
0.0104900161,
0.0281026196,
0.030225791,
-0.0147164576,
-0.0109239072,
-0.0113128945,
-0.05865914,
0.0076790066,
0.0070881722,
0.0216279086,
0.0637342706,
0.0163189527,
0.0240984447,
0.0381476469,
-0.1241436824,
-0.0467737243,
-0.0151905054,
0.0305371061,
0.0325341336,
0.0068833646,
0.0008490143,
-0.0808996111,
-0.0464594252,
-0.0171681922,
0.0278574955,
0.0206568297,
0.0265620165,
0.0223836675,
-0.0034239804,
-0.0501163788,
-0.0429682843,
0.0865988359,
0.0404755361,
-0.0025337467,
0.0060698939,
-0.0042742165,
-0.0131322332,
-0.0287644118,
-0.0438171886,
-0.0198256802,
0.0350764021,
0.0111177741,
-0.0661509633,
-0.0095741497,
-0.0068236594,
0.0186858214,
-0.0110188285,
-0.0647144839,
0.0044853352,
0.0636025071,
-0.0423384681,
-0.0163666811,
-0.0242119897,
0.0506056808,
-0.0583292618,
-0.05035346,
-0.0277251173,
-5.738129021e-33,
0.0131964423,
-0.0151170827,
0.0180260148,
0.0550161079,
-0.0180403944,
0.008300663,
-0.0434277318,
-0.0269159526,
0.0121810148,
0.0349203162,
-0.0264314264,
-0.0089323102,
0.0013872371,
-0.0167054776,
0.0542973801,
0.0240579192,
0.033747796,
-0.0156920645,
-0.0203023143,
0.0102756396,
0.0577925406,
0.0266406201,
0.0511391386,
-0.1022925898,
0.0446443595,
0.0260862727,
-0.0118526118,
-0.0096347574,
-0.0017804288,
0.0368317217,
-0.0497625917,
0.0112678055,
-0.0098805036,
-0.0157664381,
-0.0064457636,
0.0148591828,
0.003499534,
-0.011945379,
0.027572779,
0.0026639472,
0.0179866329,
-0.0211267471,
0.0258154813,
-0.0186281316,
-0.0638278052,
-0.0130059598,
0.0444205105,
0.0054851831,
-0.070697777,
-0.0404094383,
-0.0320504196,
0.0179114323,
-0.0128617976,
0.0550633185,
0.0131241996,
0.0070466259,
-0.0180881061,
0.0871270075,
-0.0153147085,
0.0420726016,
0.035604693,
0.018884467,
0.0049414942,
-0.0131082842,
0.0515833274,
0.0822352841,
0.0251014885,
-0.0094778659,
0.0238532256,
-0.0041526197,
0.0308209118,
0.0258439146,
0.0396729819,
0.0549728349,
0.0632445738,
-0.0689749867,
-0.0272582211,
-0.015337483,
0.0179603528,
-0.0211916789,
0.0008699353,
0.0148398727,
-0.0391142704,
-0.0306166057,
0.043897815,
-0.0352999382,
0.0104207527,
-0.0398505256,
0.006106534,
-0.052384913,
-0.0110259606,
0.0468842611,
-0.0009897709,
-0.0365872905,
-0.0414633825,
0.0434481017,
-0.0357856303,
0.0318627954,
-0.0069274423,
0.020527577,
-0.1113250107,
-0.0304600727,
-0.0005665083,
0.0306241624,
0.0324048921,
0.0040783319,
0.0124059329,
0.0407014564,
-0.0398629569,
0.0036573345,
0.0287417006,
-0.0180062875,
0.0546025671,
-0.0015602083,
0.0002244686,
0.0107834497,
0.0447003171,
0.0146355052,
0.0447011143,
0.0343120694,
-0.0022836493,
-0.0139246266,
-0.0387535356,
0.0102720633,
0.004602944,
-0.0189541727,
-0.0030900128,
-0.0245540868,
0.0515266135,
-0.046330113,
0.015768148,
-0.0199577585,
2.503e-7,
0.0541611314,
0.0847079009,
0.0192005709,
-0.0152433058,
0.0215715151,
0.0210795235,
-0.0096077435,
0.0241206773,
0.0218346752,
0.0432745554,
-0.0096863592,
-0.0683664009,
0.0212916099,
0.0444170311,
-0.0677432194,
-0.0223469473,
-0.0936950892,
-0.0805115104,
-0.0580908917,
0.0078584505,
0.0360811129,
0.0127984304,
0.0093360543,
-0.0191622879,
-0.0227444433,
-0.0752422586,
0.0460417792,
-0.0275246706,
0.0179752931,
0.0563335605,
0.0313559882,
0.0282493494,
0.0260826927,
0.0249157343,
-0.0304482467,
0.021590801,
0.0579410754,
0.03067673,
0.0119005051,
0.0380137116,
0.0292236265,
-0.0178881902,
0.0233782027,
-0.0401876122,
0.0280561987,
-0.0140714534,
-0.0233637411,
-0.0506522618,
0.0033032072,
-0.0394878723,
0.0242968295,
-0.0340423398,
-0.0175936408,
-0.0013214506,
-0.0167822838,
0.0256870333,
0.0005097016,
-0.0510859117,
0.0064402511,
0.0515965894,
-0.042035941,
-0.0300019663,
-0.0073074442,
-0.0250263438,
0.0253373384,
-0.0004060526,
-0.0109553989,
2.280525392e-34,
0.0546056665,
-0.0040299776,
-0.0173166469,
0.006496951,
0.0049944622,
0.0306568276,
0.0846948847,
0.036286138,
0.0068856739,
-0.0606852733,
0.0107396254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17312v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17312v1 | Not All Preference Pairs Are Created Equal: A Recipe for Annotation-Efficient Iterative Preference Learning | 2024-06-25T06:49:16 | 2024-06-25T06:49:16 | Sen Yang, Leyang Cui, Deng Cai, Xinting Huang, Shuming Shi, Wai Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Iterative preference learning, though yielding superior performances,
requires online annotated preference labels. In this work, we study strategies
to select worth-annotating response pairs for cost-efficient annotation while
achieving competitive or even better performances compared with the random
selection baseline for iterative preference learning. Built on assumptions
regarding uncertainty and distribution shifts, we propose a comparative view to
rank the implicit reward margins as predicted by DPO to select the response
pairs that yield more benefits. Through extensive experiments, we show that
annotating those response pairs with small margins is generally better than
large or random, under both single- and multi-iteration scenarios. Besides, our
empirical results suggest allocating more annotation budgets in the earlier
iterations rather than later across multiple iterations. | [
0.009111139,
0.0325045548,
0.0368062034,
-0.0386302881,
-0.0046277354,
0.0164288431,
-0.0119421715,
-0.0166242551,
-0.0296233334,
-0.040820118,
-0.0492923334,
0.0060299458,
-0.0131731331,
-0.045177456,
-0.0260664225,
-0.0919877738,
-0.0075727571,
-0.0106190545,
0.0167022571,
-0.0226554591,
0.0184640158,
-0.0206980743,
-0.0225630086,
0.0289452877,
0.0105582988,
-0.0001901269,
0.012058421,
0.0032796133,
0.0382373445,
-0.0927502513,
0.0214668866,
0.0277756564,
-0.0170337949,
0.0088212304,
0.0000021069,
-0.0566772372,
-0.0638638735,
-0.006407069,
-0.036170397,
0.0162480827,
0.0413255766,
0.0825542212,
0.0252380483,
0.0240069516,
-0.0126889003,
0.0206032041,
0.0774119124,
0.0078391861,
0.0054473183,
0.0110804318,
-0.0026419542,
0.0180159286,
-0.0346037522,
-0.0857035965,
-0.0003341586,
-0.0309615731,
0.0062748762,
-0.0401573628,
-0.048392918,
0.00912032,
-0.0123531846,
-0.0298213083,
-0.0037834705,
0.0005738214,
0.0705678836,
0.0307003092,
0.0271435007,
-0.0123290615,
-0.0383022577,
0.0390618816,
0.011217054,
0.0453420579,
-0.010114559,
-0.0657164231,
0.0107094934,
-0.0282625165,
-0.0092804506,
-0.0194032099,
-0.0074419845,
0.0485947616,
0.0055428748,
0.0595509894,
0.0049641966,
0.0149071794,
-0.0317105763,
0.0771245509,
-0.0618506186,
-0.0199949462,
0.0749467164,
0.0291011073,
-0.0781294778,
-0.0755040273,
-0.0005347219,
-0.0193066448,
-0.0342790224,
-0.0035227463,
0.0423234291,
0.0195709076,
0.0020806498,
-0.0065195467,
0.1117917374,
0.008710796,
-0.0149218058,
0.0227612127,
0.0370461717,
0.0098117748,
-0.0103220418,
0.0109453471,
-0.0299247969,
0.0806208476,
0.0032151088,
0.0102134692,
0.0341529101,
0.0783528537,
-0.0215625446,
-0.0028007056,
-0.054088559,
0.0129241161,
-0.0240464564,
0.0331470184,
-0.0086700618,
0.0242058225,
-0.0360847302,
0.0401050895,
-0.0863964707,
0.0236518346,
-0.033232931,
0.0213645026,
0.056870956,
0.0538779832,
0.0309860036,
0.0182943549,
-0.0224375501,
-0.0460728556,
-0.000861956,
0.0861775577,
-0.0074494304,
-0.0243234653,
0.0301112961,
-0.0104311481,
-0.0310506262,
-0.0132734869,
-0.0027697443,
-0.0142905992,
-0.0187221635,
-0.0063551683,
-0.0101169031,
-0.0058618789,
0.0026100075,
-0.0136918798,
-0.0173780322,
0.0932156593,
0.0598309077,
-0.0278202426,
-0.0062531396,
-0.0443623886,
-0.042942211,
0.0473923609,
0.0456718244,
0.0718948245,
0.0340431705,
-0.0047150259,
-0.0312083736,
-0.0114370771,
0.0233565662,
0.0001827154,
-0.0241715014,
0.0019874659,
0.0314351209,
0.0497618131,
0.060331244,
-0.0246721525,
-0.0527836382,
0.0082663447,
0.039726764,
0.0153215611,
0.028038539,
-0.0532098748,
-0.0342401266,
0.0234473255,
-0.0200736597,
0.0095844911,
-0.0182313863,
0.0728829578,
-0.0128023652,
-0.0357335806,
0.0303337406,
-0.0551829562,
-0.0110155558,
-0.0748618767,
0.0182496682,
0.0102842189,
0.0080123562,
0.060047701,
0.0511668734,
-0.0193426646,
-0.045737654,
-0.0511537306,
0.0396188349,
-0.0028683026,
-0.0352422036,
-0.0395306349,
0.0572800823,
0.08361689,
0.0053676628,
-0.0526619628,
-0.0118341101,
-0.0250800215,
-0.057556089,
-0.0079838084,
0.0798620507,
-0.0607160367,
0.012483919,
-0.0062509566,
-0.0790689513,
-0.0185921863,
0.0031557451,
0.0546487011,
0.0120936902,
-0.0214027558,
-0.0416770279,
0.0035594546,
-0.0024641438,
-0.0022892428,
0.0542834923,
-0.0163851287,
0.0980933458,
0.0161118098,
0.0920536816,
-0.0238783192,
0.0369592533,
0.0024552494,
-0.0025020617,
-0.0185051486,
-0.0182773415,
-0.0103523415,
-0.0151633872,
0.0029496821,
0.0290109962,
0.0065602562,
-0.0081269918,
0.0022009984,
-0.0348430425,
0.0100357411,
-0.027856214,
0.0035187167,
0.009854015,
0.0100827338,
0.0038056993,
0.0173788369,
-0.0154945925,
-0.1021056995,
0.0171880908,
-0.0269975364,
-0.0110925231,
-0.0165285319,
-0.0068659298,
-0.0098392488,
-0.0513251126,
0.0199722815,
-0.0050655571,
0.0056527313,
-0.0001199845,
0.0357362293,
0.0043791309,
-0.005129735,
-0.032941252,
-0.0393982418,
0.0342990868,
0.0154834539,
0.0004193898,
-0.0241628606,
-0.024259612,
0.0362932011,
-0.0253246278,
0.0035482347,
0.0155985914,
-0.066190213,
0.0421494879,
0.0197886359,
0.0233435575,
0.0253694858,
-0.0502052195,
-0.0251664501,
0.0153137753,
0.0032809516,
0.0284305029,
0.0070941397,
-0.0079666823,
-0.0260399468,
-0.0280710701,
-0.0337823294,
0.0001966167,
0.0251070522,
0.0223516896,
-0.0055609499,
-0.0054669152,
0.1008118019,
0.032077264,
0.0637138635,
0.0577894896,
0.0030676518,
-0.0766717792,
0.0092717316,
-0.0404881239,
-0.0244361348,
-0.0148912231,
0.0059899725,
0.007159627,
0.0606379397,
-0.0493331514,
-0.0003740746,
-0.0374148376,
-0.0139209181,
0.0051154718,
-0.0349614844,
-0.0318468437,
0.0573033802,
-0.0086920056,
0.0710484162,
0.0012059745,
-0.0239633545,
0.0953273922,
0.0506742075,
0.0183080751,
-0.0522774681,
0.0298872236,
0.0037497403,
0.0020676679,
-0.0100898938,
0.0019117533,
-0.0103557026,
-0.0144606791,
-0.0336333625,
-0.0417401306,
0.0847912207,
-0.0214278977,
0.0222895816,
-0.0090582231,
0.0035364788,
-0.0361435339,
-0.08291132,
0.0000948873,
-0.0544605516,
-0.0168276876,
0.001969442,
0.002940326,
-0.0086226687,
0.0287951846,
-0.0175432712,
-0.0043110526,
0.0398710556,
-0.0081533883,
-0.0288895089,
0.0023056595,
-0.0094140274,
0.0011497891,
0.0395721309,
0.0086512929,
-0.0085852435,
-0.0340651982,
0.0270912908,
0.046187643,
0.0046634558,
0.0078980317,
0.0344427712,
0.0345630459,
-0.0851034522,
-0.0066009029,
0.0334556289,
0.016806554,
-0.0109432265,
0.0412919,
0.0416569449,
0.0217552576,
-0.0791542605,
0.0193508267,
0.0155878756,
0.0797926113,
0.0221052542,
0.0120286783,
-0.0801121369,
-0.0153873945,
0.0097628394,
0.0907686651,
-0.0120629352,
-0.0283400305,
0.0004704394,
-0.1012819484,
0.0194081198,
-0.0427851379,
-0.0597802848,
0.0500205271,
-0.0695461109,
-0.0043809898,
-0.0665178075,
-0.0158497635,
0.0119944941,
-0.0011404912,
-0.0002720966,
0.0369751416,
0.0157024916,
0.0076105483,
0.0217539873,
-0.0062723351,
-0.0185475554,
0.113279663,
0.0132130953,
0.0059364839,
0.0036342749,
0.0258288011,
-0.0071412972,
-0.0163643137,
-0.0391990803,
0.0459929854,
-0.0008223575,
-0.0010739142,
-0.0169299711,
0.0495638363,
0.0389744937,
-0.0097565418,
-0.0024642653,
0.0111920508,
-0.0077399714,
0.0077122329,
0.0211639367,
-0.0224391669,
0.041337952,
0.0114910454,
-0.0243049469,
-0.0960774869,
-0.0330367573,
-0.0574176386,
-0.0006489023,
-0.0551992878,
0.0307325926,
0.0133091127,
-0.0133387307,
-0.0154862935,
-0.0774051026,
-0.0085611977,
-0.0078529697,
0.0605868548,
-0.0043910281,
-0.0580389276,
-0.032200627,
0.007022344,
-0.0468211211,
0.0107777305,
0.0295927208,
0.0008519784,
-0.0378417447,
-0.0311907548,
0.0152556682,
-0.0295413807,
-0.0618247166,
-0.0285605118,
0.0165692233,
-0.0487436391,
-0.0224900618,
0.0928773284,
0.0163200535,
0.0654951334,
0.0179387257,
-0.0357980356,
0.0074179275,
0.0499785393,
0.0554818101,
-0.0156348515,
0.0756056905,
0.0686510205,
-0.0360287577,
0.0048401426,
-0.0403910242,
0.0204399824,
0.0215021428,
-0.0017013875,
0.0087051177,
-0.0102985334,
0.0239507463,
-0.0150105814,
0.0452702232,
-0.0391929075,
0.0006802133,
-0.0125878891,
0.0433567241,
0.0262102205,
-0.0367674083,
-0.0420131572,
-0.0342823751,
0.0294590257,
-0.048094891,
-0.0185638797,
-0.01177599,
0.0377875976,
0.0037053733,
-0.0298375245,
-0.0078436006,
0.0501031801,
0.0294903256,
0.0186832193,
0.0281043928,
0.0102032963,
-0.0065724393,
0.038232211,
0.042352289,
0.0518218018,
-0.0048145424,
0.0403686166,
0.0320752338,
0.0075127273,
-0.0056750551,
0.0156092625,
-0.039363578,
-0.032129284,
-0.044878602,
0.0078589739,
-0.0185377114,
0.0643066168,
-0.0088039627,
-0.0198464245,
-0.0278961807,
0.0217854232,
-0.0587736107,
-0.0005665736,
0.0203629974,
0.0116415489,
0.0079013342,
0.0110538723,
0.07385353,
-0.0098558292,
0.003237359,
-0.0480897687,
-0.0025795109,
-0.0513318144,
-0.0201203283,
-0.014462932,
0.0486736596,
-0.0188737623,
0.0000804121,
-0.0052974825,
-0.0014622499,
-0.004460841,
-0.0263348967,
0.0055903816,
0.0083293971,
0.0325433798,
0.0115038957,
-0.0265333336,
0.0017303661,
-0.0420610942,
-0.0329425707,
-0.0474113896,
0.0074967607,
-0.0346273556,
-6.380544398e-33,
-0.0087834978,
-0.01405265,
-0.0209381618,
0.0374279805,
-0.0143623706,
-0.0100897942,
0.0062818574,
0.0248169918,
0.0494334064,
0.0054772124,
-0.0070908866,
-0.0434351005,
0.0157757122,
0.0059352322,
0.0442342497,
-0.0337123573,
0.0453694724,
0.0195585098,
-0.0837584361,
0.0055778883,
0.0198407862,
-0.0116767334,
0.0186029039,
-0.0601012893,
0.0045836596,
0.0945942327,
-0.0320683606,
0.0052198693,
-0.0248927455,
0.0684964806,
0.0176403839,
-0.0096964529,
-0.0094593419,
-0.0300844312,
-0.0089879623,
-0.001497351,
-0.0791602433,
-0.0095733134,
-0.0239187684,
0.0013315553,
-0.0040663374,
-0.0335989855,
0.0254681166,
0.0414754339,
-0.0104000969,
-0.0315704644,
0.009511508,
-0.0234740637,
-0.032042332,
0.0224240199,
0.0058674975,
0.0162933115,
-0.0248597097,
-0.0048697563,
0.0372278765,
0.0697214082,
0.0076323804,
0.0507548377,
-0.0325078331,
0.0426093861,
-0.0233964641,
0.0195523966,
-0.0107310079,
-0.0027455888,
0.0418965481,
0.0115672434,
-0.0175418351,
-0.0008198128,
0.0729752779,
-0.0422935039,
-0.0291941166,
0.0262191743,
0.000583684,
0.0104338909,
0.0422626361,
0.0058128503,
-0.053440582,
0.0318729728,
0.0265528746,
-0.0512750708,
0.0323245749,
0.0622309297,
-0.006352325,
-0.0318172202,
-0.0259085987,
-0.0629797429,
-0.0378296003,
-0.0421338081,
0.0386303626,
0.0612641647,
-0.0178008303,
0.0626848638,
0.0242225137,
-0.016724024,
-0.0603954196,
-0.0444116518,
-0.0403970741,
0.0541004911,
0.0123170521,
-0.0415473096,
-0.0882827565,
-0.0254768636,
-0.0342049785,
-0.0408090577,
-0.0358692929,
0.0186812505,
0.0440993831,
0.0023274906,
-0.0178241134,
-0.0065118321,
0.0124939978,
0.0007944669,
-0.0166409276,
0.0117357811,
0.0467294231,
-0.0131139131,
-0.0123470314,
0.0569349974,
-0.011254169,
0.0115601439,
-0.0431715176,
-0.0268810261,
-0.0237953234,
0.0230060276,
-0.007408313,
0.0106929177,
0.0156269837,
-0.0252514184,
-0.0547859445,
-0.028533332,
-0.0340111479,
-0.0140610011,
2.687e-7,
0.0338843577,
0.045673538,
0.0003334167,
-0.0278309919,
0.0215443727,
0.0481178761,
0.0249114148,
-0.0300427675,
0.0338436589,
0.0263544284,
0.0269295909,
-0.0053860578,
0.0272086188,
-0.0006369615,
-0.0250301342,
-0.0763432607,
-0.0260839872,
0.0553191155,
-0.0090387706,
-0.0449315235,
-0.0153534738,
0.0183173735,
0.0507821068,
0.0113309193,
0.0244650226,
0.0736821592,
0.0699732602,
-0.056019064,
0.0334602073,
0.0110266637,
-0.0291711614,
-0.0189751666,
-0.013616343,
0.0004232925,
-0.0160724372,
-0.00144859,
0.0130867166,
0.0465165786,
0.0051086345,
-0.0756399259,
-0.0071858591,
0.0480483584,
0.0460749604,
-0.0411530584,
0.0511526577,
-0.0798768848,
-0.0472083874,
-0.0338664949,
-0.0072078425,
-0.0153349703,
0.0368145593,
0.0060358732,
0.0000732028,
-0.0123107145,
-0.0156423505,
0.0705959275,
-0.0231422391,
-0.0355475955,
-0.0203915406,
0.0782783255,
-0.0091139348,
-0.0193978995,
-0.0260821432,
0.0585495979,
-0.0347401612,
-0.03020785,
-0.0277588945,
2.186062712e-34,
0.0210208446,
-0.014141948,
0.0012514153,
0.0358119793,
-0.0079113673,
0.02728392,
0.0027622969,
-0.0274052657,
0.0833971649,
0.0014945389,
-0.0051870174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17305v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17305v1 | Retrieval Augmented Instruction Tuning for Open NER with Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T06:24:50 | 2024-06-25T06:24:50 | Tingyu Xie, Jian Zhang, Yan Zhang, Yuanyuan Liang, Qi Li, Hongwei Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The strong capability of large language models (LLMs) has been applied to
information extraction (IE) through either retrieval augmented prompting or
instruction tuning (IT). However, the best way to incorporate information with
LLMs for IE remains an open question. In this paper, we explore Retrieval
Augmented Instruction Tuning (RA-IT) for IE, focusing on the task of open named
entity recognition (NER). Specifically, for each training sample, we retrieve
semantically similar examples from the training dataset as the context and
prepend them to the input of the original instruction. To evaluate our RA-IT
approach more thoroughly, we construct a Chinese IT dataset for open NER and
evaluate RA-IT in both English and Chinese scenarios. Experimental results
verify the effectiveness of RA-IT across various data sizes and in both English
and Chinese scenarios. We also conduct thorough studies to explore the impacts
of various retrieval strategies in the proposed RA-IT framework. Code and data
are available at: https://github.com/Emma1066/Retrieval-Augmented-IT-OpenNER | [
0.0518025644,
0.0429399647,
0.0346805863,
0.0362632759,
-0.0226492845,
0.0339228213,
-0.0115302484,
0.0371371321,
0.0014302499,
-0.0532670952,
-0.0656891093,
-0.0258749798,
-0.0319244787,
-0.0318439454,
-0.0170679279,
-0.0037454669,
0.0201993529,
-0.0064519257,
-0.0064269789,
0.0287575275,
-0.0318589881,
0.0109712826,
0.0154342996,
0.0184180364,
0.0651831031,
0.0167162474,
-0.0087294392,
0.0422684029,
0.0272805206,
-0.0437336378,
0.0253553577,
0.0087019484,
-0.0001049826,
0.0198452882,
0.0000018348,
-0.0622708946,
-0.0801770389,
0.0270102154,
-0.0522399209,
-0.0026711512,
0.0558881871,
-0.0075891782,
-0.0011826777,
0.0200547054,
0.0095083835,
-0.0585044362,
0.0247633383,
0.0975554511,
0.0168823805,
0.1038113311,
0.0103318058,
-0.0240536295,
0.0356255844,
0.0084679723,
0.0032179505,
-0.0121824378,
0.0477522872,
-0.0466609895,
0.0028020544,
0.0561861545,
0.0015494371,
0.0123684853,
0.0052823797,
0.0243967995,
-0.0054076435,
0.0418755598,
-0.0305250827,
0.0208063163,
-0.030285703,
0.0613932647,
0.0078261858,
0.0417305343,
0.0215682387,
-0.001273405,
-0.0419292897,
-0.0129105551,
-0.0399321243,
0.040859133,
-0.0232008621,
0.0193394609,
0.0418380834,
-0.0273782164,
0.007488315,
0.0184160452,
-0.0373772718,
0.0440530144,
0.0381531864,
-0.0695107132,
0.0246477444,
-0.0160835776,
-0.0122162215,
-0.0209610015,
-0.0069599175,
0.0463629626,
0.0134577658,
0.0494301952,
-0.0062349159,
0.007421812,
0.0070212437,
-0.0229302198,
0.0448928066,
0.0313177668,
-0.0368042029,
0.0305736847,
-0.0438302346,
0.01245136,
-0.0129124606,
0.0199165195,
-0.0260972083,
-0.0183548126,
-0.0587838441,
-0.0035127385,
-0.0341995358,
0.0442164876,
-0.0619710572,
-0.0059316852,
-0.0106739309,
0.0286805201,
0.0186447222,
0.0089907954,
0.0362815335,
-0.0303121265,
-0.0102866208,
0.0039549381,
-0.0473593771,
0.031294059,
0.004935801,
-0.0069022714,
-0.0172960516,
-0.0556254946,
-0.0140287606,
-0.0107899606,
0.0329467356,
-0.0538783893,
0.0320253968,
0.0349213518,
0.0285732076,
-0.0744863898,
-0.0771634281,
-0.0032898551,
0.0241362024,
-0.0382454693,
0.0005318116,
-0.0212016683,
0.0008090065,
0.0044517019,
0.0019638734,
-0.0409892127,
0.0466723144,
0.0367591828,
-0.0434420742,
0.0416538641,
-0.021800844,
-0.0221063886,
0.0150525058,
0.0002975197,
0.0660897866,
0.044930324,
0.0100317262,
-0.0221137851,
0.0644084811,
0.0209326353,
-0.0222863406,
0.0213435031,
0.0191849321,
0.0092746327,
0.0171015393,
0.0576464199,
0.0201705899,
-0.0021570802,
0.015427975,
0.0416187644,
-0.0109758638,
0.0036354985,
0.0002800261,
0.0178374164,
0.036949493,
-0.0384052992,
0.0319927298,
0.0071229315,
-0.0147303715,
0.0152203944,
-0.0264410228,
-0.009459761,
-0.0581555292,
0.0469038785,
0.0347592048,
0.0337364078,
-0.0295575634,
-0.0241880547,
-0.0136959599,
-0.0021057329,
-0.0191486236,
0.037498638,
0.0705949962,
0.0163964834,
-0.076996699,
0.0374163166,
0.0659189969,
-0.0235674623,
0.0305475276,
-0.0500678271,
0.0160551015,
0.0459084511,
0.0438596532,
-0.0455231369,
-0.0227839015,
-0.0122756083,
-0.0446112826,
0.0339306928,
0.00275773,
-0.021714922,
-0.0033884563,
-0.0672701523,
-0.019452773,
0.0018105659,
-0.0013271533,
0.0141230477,
0.045767758,
0.0262201112,
0.032838203,
-0.0014024777,
-0.0660188571,
0.0481181629,
-0.0435195677,
-0.0742329434,
0.0158377402,
0.0409665816,
0.0054207658,
0.0411029831,
-0.0289675593,
-0.0071577937,
0.0268020555,
-0.0105383433,
-0.0198285338,
-0.0548017211,
-0.0099928332,
-0.0399185866,
-0.0036202078,
0.0171868373,
-0.010816507,
-0.013089899,
-0.0350841545,
-0.0445754603,
-0.040043924,
0.0537867546,
0.0391943492,
-0.066304408,
0.0337149352,
0.01889636,
-0.0127563439,
-0.046923317,
0.0501860306,
-0.0080125984,
0.0398110822,
0.0641735941,
0.01503025,
-0.0023427079,
-0.0504573956,
-0.0697940066,
0.0064034606,
0.0103525938,
0.001570433,
0.0267139599,
0.024869306,
-0.0593552403,
-0.0511436723,
-0.0874141678,
0.0649527907,
-0.0544141755,
0.0505971536,
0.0106036672,
0.0448206402,
-0.0289527327,
-0.0126101747,
0.000267593,
-0.0215181857,
-0.0318258256,
0.0133371782,
0.0001322477,
0.0376099572,
-0.0303460471,
0.0056959633,
0.0101605738,
-0.0113658188,
0.0154550597,
0.0097808177,
0.0070549524,
-0.0706104562,
0.0624701641,
-0.0237316918,
0.0079601305,
0.0045953859,
0.0297220349,
-0.0110920323,
-0.0062142806,
0.032340955,
0.0651433617,
-0.0218636952,
0.0313094892,
0.0087679429,
-0.0159541983,
-0.0547665358,
0.0231437515,
-0.0266314615,
-0.0575771518,
-0.0207305048,
-0.0475990921,
0.027863387,
0.0491672903,
-0.005377328,
0.0044863289,
-0.0253754202,
-0.0533212833,
-0.0361467376,
-0.0089208083,
-0.0409929566,
0.0412553996,
-0.0186152756,
-0.0242720451,
-0.0128418552,
-0.0310721025,
0.0603187419,
-0.0348282419,
-0.0137690986,
-0.0516006313,
-0.0154895838,
-0.0956086963,
0.046018213,
-0.0211637579,
0.007028921,
0.0596689582,
-0.0635744706,
-0.0151106594,
0.0339418724,
-0.0273231938,
-0.0333201513,
0.0425769649,
0.0035525628,
0.0088697001,
-0.0105811823,
0.000405611,
-0.0469090603,
-0.0169945173,
0.0043859901,
0.0376364961,
-0.0024666784,
-0.0124564357,
-0.0086069787,
0.0371121094,
0.0213743616,
0.0400306061,
0.0084385667,
-0.0046655852,
-0.0310738664,
0.0127900206,
0.0552455448,
-0.009896135,
-0.0222964957,
-0.0302428864,
0.0116646709,
0.0190841015,
0.0282966215,
-0.0219703242,
0.0303800646,
0.0063788099,
0.0334151164,
-0.0831357837,
0.024771139,
0.0248580258,
0.0313837081,
-0.0385900997,
-0.0185363907,
0.1082982048,
0.015514018,
-0.0284767076,
-0.0460091941,
-0.0076466152,
0.0233394187,
0.0193181373,
0.0075593391,
-0.0747403353,
-0.0313668922,
0.0036615112,
0.0447991006,
0.0041950042,
-0.0380648896,
-0.0030860782,
-0.1371907592,
0.0228070505,
-0.0236368142,
-0.0543676168,
-0.024193963,
-0.0562842414,
0.0259517394,
-0.02369399,
0.0294952225,
0.0141222402,
-0.0567036383,
-0.0011257749,
0.015474651,
0.0647635981,
-0.0450144745,
0.0117176147,
-0.0568847097,
0.0369387977,
0.0282698981,
-0.0039225337,
0.0096001411,
-0.0034407694,
-0.0163235739,
-0.059840586,
-0.0013384438,
-0.0308349878,
0.0365852416,
-0.0447424613,
0.0080477893,
-0.0303863436,
0.0018752012,
-0.0026874479,
0.0188806336,
0.0388050787,
0.0551369041,
-0.0050633578,
0.036936,
0.0000773782,
-0.0580649786,
0.0376251675,
0.0976289436,
-0.0028373715,
-0.0324324891,
0.0085576437,
0.0237518661,
-0.028857613,
-0.0058381995,
-0.0119473133,
0.0407499634,
-0.0806832016,
-0.0030104839,
-0.0286701974,
-0.0404943898,
0.0324875005,
0.0183675345,
0.0228363518,
0.0071465187,
0.0182910971,
0.0159287378,
-0.0411583111,
0.0511477627,
-0.0403783731,
-0.0032224639,
-0.094774656,
-0.0266407225,
0.022095358,
-0.0056424951,
-0.0166407712,
-0.0087332083,
-0.0303158034,
-0.0450602658,
-0.0224982891,
-0.0070744501,
-0.0026067763,
0.0440106466,
0.0239221938,
-0.0036937769,
0.0317393877,
0.0140801081,
-0.0303605516,
-0.0160339214,
0.0272101425,
0.013733712,
-0.0134971933,
0.0332845449,
-0.0561474226,
0.0102569219,
0.0407124832,
0.0558867976,
-0.0022448183,
-0.0598869547,
0.0252895616,
0.051417429,
0.0526940189,
0.0007333388,
-0.0052126911,
-0.0823521614,
0.061544694,
0.0013011368,
-0.0093298545,
-0.0234038364,
-0.0140052037,
0.0349804312,
-0.0360876471,
-0.0178280007,
0.0715884939,
-0.002599444,
0.0356947519,
-0.0657185987,
0.0335297883,
-0.0085573858,
0.0742513835,
0.0232513025,
-0.0254455078,
-0.014655821,
0.0410628319,
0.039790459,
0.0407648832,
-0.0231738128,
0.0727183074,
0.0074488102,
0.01639398,
0.0051163291,
-0.0022893429,
-0.0358498171,
0.0103845447,
-0.0164806824,
0.040203549,
0.0222768616,
-0.0110976966,
0.0261749737,
-0.0159068331,
-0.0111753792,
-0.0218332354,
-0.0056622704,
0.0045160148,
-0.0172452573,
0.0282102004,
0.0203608032,
-0.0251825079,
0.0047518364,
0.0272876509,
-0.0069016018,
0.0385368094,
0.0044551911,
0.005242731,
-0.0240862444,
0.0129241329,
0.0648161769,
-0.003844931,
-0.0415768251,
0.0256705936,
-0.0087595247,
-0.0295230113,
-0.0182519723,
-0.0119609665,
-0.0405219607,
0.0001360524,
0.0196310077,
0.0256860051,
-0.0032527228,
-0.0451389104,
-0.0447756052,
-0.0042328681,
-0.0328611508,
-0.0238572359,
0.0065165553,
-6.328226818e-33,
-0.0356444605,
0.0096300589,
0.030394353,
-0.0032781537,
-0.0052649556,
0.0274409447,
-0.0079335868,
-0.0444718599,
-0.014999304,
-0.0465558879,
-0.0218623765,
-0.0229569338,
0.0288386066,
0.0482031032,
-0.0282664541,
-0.0261968244,
0.0438890494,
0.0367431119,
-0.0174616612,
0.0142034134,
0.0602178276,
0.061401587,
0.062596105,
-0.0696651414,
0.0591238141,
-0.0278751384,
0.0380555503,
0.0178830214,
0.058262147,
0.0722383335,
-0.0307757575,
0.0442049503,
-0.0006051359,
-0.0959081128,
0.01656764,
0.0126575008,
-0.160079211,
-0.0153961582,
0.0029073376,
0.0067055384,
-0.0322050825,
-0.029448323,
-0.0047954759,
-0.0135974027,
0.0220132004,
0.0032809649,
0.0142004071,
-0.0037632382,
0.0131742125,
0.0174299013,
-0.0558298156,
0.0450126305,
0.0287768636,
0.0180843007,
0.0358556919,
-0.0221078601,
0.0304996241,
-0.0178086106,
-0.0762104169,
-0.0107252225,
0.0414151996,
0.0120748468,
0.0206705406,
0.0612225607,
-0.0003862479,
0.0085998131,
0.001999178,
-0.0111720944,
-0.0229404997,
-0.0332677141,
0.0101636201,
0.0463996492,
-0.0520885587,
0.0008521716,
0.0207750425,
-0.0035609729,
-0.0774997845,
0.0314176604,
0.0025496662,
0.0277601071,
0.0135070514,
-0.0084685208,
-0.0795507878,
0.0078871502,
-0.0043645366,
-0.0072703664,
-0.055013258,
-0.0329643153,
0.0557937101,
0.0474569127,
-0.0619441494,
0.0030072308,
0.0434510969,
-0.0173223689,
-0.019012535,
0.025204733,
0.0328425802,
-0.0084713809,
-0.0526833571,
0.0207515378,
-0.0824414641,
-0.0663759634,
0.019191049,
-0.052309718,
-0.0222816803,
0.0083194254,
0.0282250308,
0.0075648893,
-0.0772325173,
0.0069370763,
-0.0061768424,
0.0201203804,
-0.0186097156,
0.0190810114,
0.0073621352,
0.0277788211,
0.0111600449,
0.0366723053,
0.0734712258,
0.0048180548,
-0.0523988269,
-0.0580069534,
0.0407008156,
-0.0086544259,
0.0034926445,
0.0532520264,
0.0065658456,
-0.0034934839,
-0.0159027167,
-0.0358157903,
0.0080179768,
0.0387561806,
2.597e-7,
0.0044653527,
-0.0093551297,
0.0145347062,
0.0430729464,
-0.0563683882,
0.0005638639,
0.0137415733,
0.0280607082,
0.0008326784,
-0.0040456881,
0.0157676376,
0.0002565851,
0.0124301258,
0.0036032929,
-0.0922643915,
-0.0173099563,
-0.0066700373,
-0.0073068826,
-0.0546688214,
0.0320646986,
0.0445498861,
0.0925942287,
-0.0189590268,
0.0122123221,
-0.0466392934,
-0.0395721421,
0.035503488,
0.0122451801,
-0.0087640155,
0.058087308,
0.0526007079,
0.0676999241,
-0.0148332939,
-0.0009301801,
-0.0001690362,
0.0588999651,
0.0189240631,
0.0723759159,
0.018680986,
-0.0449853018,
0.0139631918,
-0.045613043,
-0.0034878373,
-0.0344835408,
0.0843606293,
-0.0144549198,
-0.0021921867,
0.0267240368,
0.0057009207,
-0.0178277027,
0.0155717731,
-0.0006996517,
-0.0107155321,
0.0328174084,
0.0193755124,
-0.0295543857,
-0.0197788998,
-0.0959222838,
0.0254677199,
0.0144896321,
0.010457295,
-0.0395939127,
0.0000378784,
-0.0125707099,
-0.0223441496,
-0.0689434856,
0.0055221487,
2.50860803e-34,
-0.0153367762,
0.010032949,
-0.035000585,
0.0475214645,
0.039740447,
-0.016840985,
-0.0635029376,
0.0203162841,
-0.0198686887,
-0.1248810142,
-0.0136685111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17304v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17304v1 | Leveraging LLMs for Dialogue Quality Measurement | 2024-06-25T06:19:47 | 2024-06-25T06:19:47 | Jinghan Jia, Abi Komma, Timothy Leffel, Xujun Peng, Ajay Nagesh, Tamer Soliman, Aram Galstyan, Anoop Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL | In task-oriented conversational AI evaluation, unsupervised methods poorly
correlate with human judgments, and supervised approaches lack generalization.
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) show robust zeroshot and
few-shot capabilities across NLP tasks. This paper explores using LLMs for
automated dialogue quality evaluation, experimenting with various
configurations on public and proprietary datasets. Manipulating factors such as
model size, in-context examples, and selection techniques, we examine
"chain-of-thought" (CoT) reasoning and label extraction procedures. Our results
show that (1) larger models yield more accurate dialogue labels; (2)
algorithmic selection of in-context examples outperforms random selection; (3)
CoT reasoning where an LLM is asked to provide justifications before outputting
final labels improves performance; and (4) fine-tuned LLMs outperform
out-of-the-box ones. Our results indicate that LLMs that are suitably
fine-tuned and have sufficient reasoning capabilities can be leveraged for
automated dialogue evaluation. | [
0.0591271333,
0.0596310422,
0.0100800209,
0.0610467419,
-0.053961549,
0.0188011322,
0.0390067771,
-0.0019982834,
0.0163724907,
-0.0629931092,
-0.0605277829,
-0.0481132269,
0.0224606507,
0.0363082103,
0.0156152397,
-0.0448140353,
0.0022404131,
-0.0372545049,
0.0588320605,
0.0114715593,
0.0093516968,
0.0028436454,
-0.0202383008,
0.0439252034,
-0.0247842036,
-0.0344639383,
-0.0032121539,
0.0021272611,
0.0027526903,
-0.0295495577,
0.0104208151,
0.0348340087,
0.0077836774,
-0.0180244818,
0.0000019455,
-0.0480198786,
0.0121855019,
-0.0152056869,
-0.0491750464,
0.0056327223,
-0.0153810224,
0.0374111012,
-0.0058985339,
0.0152431987,
-0.0373511948,
0.0140496939,
0.0201759581,
0.078078486,
0.0532951951,
0.0739187375,
-0.0003365507,
-0.0233348627,
0.0102586085,
-0.0076937201,
-0.0076114018,
-0.0649988279,
0.02195381,
0.0432009548,
0.0025945613,
0.0286735818,
0.0263633691,
0.013801082,
0.0048480113,
-0.0651094541,
0.0267065354,
0.0194205567,
-0.048612494,
-0.0446521677,
-0.0186540671,
0.1077204049,
0.0330569595,
-0.0059367167,
0.006786149,
-0.0033297432,
-0.0160945281,
-0.052597709,
-0.0362279303,
0.0192056317,
-0.0010585376,
0.0154856667,
0.0016374497,
0.0357443467,
0.0217771344,
0.0412608795,
-0.011769074,
0.0460821316,
-0.0127991065,
-0.0531046763,
0.001931609,
0.0014442087,
-0.0219218079,
-0.0532777011,
-0.0122484984,
0.028344322,
-0.0676715672,
0.0350088142,
-0.0222577807,
0.0167849846,
0.0010119246,
0.0100038359,
0.0116006127,
-0.0040636314,
-0.0110617746,
0.0832476169,
0.00207149,
0.0680440068,
0.0044729989,
0.0213901885,
-0.0205279756,
-0.036398083,
-0.0678273365,
0.0295741782,
-0.016792208,
0.0524186715,
-0.026954392,
-0.0315418802,
-0.0118534258,
0.0060718986,
-0.0248805098,
0.0310043208,
0.0442875959,
0.01236609,
0.0026765424,
-0.0168751422,
-0.036596965,
0.0304477699,
-0.0238033999,
0.0163142346,
0.0533546135,
-0.0507656857,
-0.0293196626,
0.0534055121,
0.0150448969,
-0.0074652587,
0.0197222102,
0.0702796653,
0.0025943855,
-0.0348266475,
-0.025872957,
-0.0159581117,
-0.0528349467,
-0.0793185979,
-0.0392007418,
-0.0306732394,
0.0194546301,
-0.0029355865,
-0.0004363879,
-0.0291712098,
0.00998234,
0.0064318753,
-0.0114722755,
0.0273249727,
0.0094049387,
0.0333530419,
0.0163653884,
0.0031166773,
-0.0220570266,
0.0346864201,
0.0656580999,
0.0134346383,
0.0679671615,
0.000677528,
0.0332515687,
0.0054684686,
0.0055200369,
0.0256122705,
0.0098260101,
0.0164753255,
-0.0237858575,
0.0355092324,
0.0057646963,
0.083333917,
-0.031487897,
0.0248150472,
0.0847401321,
0.0466386788,
0.0148652978,
-0.0049125305,
0.0503645279,
0.0523551852,
0.0140560465,
-0.0013844246,
-0.0273945928,
0.0199240185,
0.0035842245,
-0.0106496494,
0.0762496516,
0.0059946864,
-0.0274998676,
-0.0948610306,
-0.0115513289,
0.0060445657,
-0.006158914,
0.0225001276,
0.0089915814,
0.0143134333,
-0.0543453619,
0.0266361237,
0.0028322565,
-0.0441717617,
-0.0338120162,
-0.0480575114,
0.0531380996,
0.0473826602,
0.0470664576,
-0.0093135322,
-0.0171464086,
-0.0458092391,
0.0207705069,
0.0429155231,
0.028486168,
-0.0267850999,
0.0469646119,
-0.0658550262,
-0.0143369967,
-0.0093034981,
0.0207193196,
-0.0061412365,
-0.0093233027,
-0.0126172034,
0.0211290624,
-0.039944876,
-0.0386128388,
0.011304426,
0.0036485565,
-0.0417578369,
0.0558771007,
0.0249946397,
0.0528650247,
0.0267022587,
-0.0287981238,
-0.0033939129,
0.0131261721,
-0.0316576473,
-0.0112703769,
-0.0007063875,
-0.0843584836,
-0.0512885265,
0.0009499978,
-0.0090272138,
-0.0317281671,
0.0035378549,
-0.0444820523,
-0.0506140068,
0.0055751055,
-0.0460178554,
-0.0217454098,
-0.0480790399,
0.0194198526,
0.0040500914,
-0.0018276416,
-0.0342856497,
0.0507153273,
0.021915596,
-0.0129764928,
0.0369267762,
0.0172676463,
0.0277983882,
-0.035134688,
-0.0133957798,
0.0275207553,
-0.0126573052,
0.0268718507,
0.0302359238,
0.0221102666,
-0.0586095192,
-0.0339831673,
-0.1100941673,
0.0181658063,
-0.0235201344,
0.0159576815,
-0.0087255081,
-0.0197097044,
0.0073094764,
0.024686547,
-0.037887536,
-0.0475021526,
0.0189581364,
-0.0270132832,
0.0411879309,
0.0098456973,
-0.002087682,
-0.0264242236,
0.030568447,
0.0162689406,
0.0593104921,
-0.0130041623,
-0.0071805175,
-0.0313436836,
0.0497872233,
-0.0583988391,
-0.0142111816,
0.001830542,
-0.048859518,
0.0118407216,
0.0062046666,
0.004283607,
0.0884680077,
0.0130112367,
0.0041343714,
0.0249443874,
-0.0114286309,
-0.0469538607,
0.0127924029,
0.0064682877,
-0.0001821505,
-0.0131605398,
0.0006717418,
0.029478468,
0.0552084222,
0.0174657367,
0.0342657939,
-0.0477021672,
0.0212102514,
-0.0078322105,
-0.0260836165,
-0.0064901235,
-0.0083154133,
-0.0242808722,
0.0613478087,
-0.0215725955,
-0.0381641053,
0.0812884942,
-0.0446920916,
-0.0149538089,
-0.0296574254,
-0.0243640188,
-0.0523972549,
0.0471684299,
-0.0220338423,
0.0019074834,
0.0145732118,
0.0006969885,
-0.0042098421,
-0.022462178,
0.0184586029,
-0.0358002633,
0.0376103297,
-0.0631975234,
0.0043016775,
0.0235967003,
-0.0550542623,
-0.0504341684,
-0.0135617312,
-0.0416939631,
0.0091914646,
0.0136382766,
0.0105175208,
0.0069102072,
-0.0020022867,
0.0213765036,
-0.0004890104,
-0.0085526416,
0.0189182982,
0.0029919085,
0.0495061018,
0.0479148366,
-0.0028072689,
0.0275800489,
-0.0058976375,
0.0901399255,
0.0287441015,
0.0025880358,
0.0344635025,
-0.0266529731,
-0.0196346454,
-0.0199575145,
0.027261395,
-0.0419740789,
0.0336767696,
0.0796628222,
-0.055485595,
-0.0201703198,
0.1255352646,
0.0116630485,
-0.0347744413,
-0.0116222864,
0.0043492448,
0.0258175936,
0.009611492,
-0.0024476706,
-0.0742182508,
-0.0577485003,
0.0060952608,
0.0035680921,
-0.0646655038,
-0.0413592719,
-0.0173101854,
-0.1369758248,
0.050643906,
-0.0107656168,
-0.0035678435,
-0.0159890801,
-0.0365311019,
0.0398913175,
-0.0135446778,
0.0221116524,
-0.0127689969,
0.0369962715,
-0.0191671979,
0.0315911733,
-0.0172784813,
-0.0529549308,
0.0445419773,
-0.0067395847,
0.0794078559,
0.0467090718,
0.0688296631,
0.0432993844,
-0.0312706418,
0.0408400781,
-0.0440763831,
-0.0138289155,
-0.0011557519,
0.042210985,
-0.0114462823,
-0.0022747517,
-0.0177367087,
0.0363211669,
0.0141801257,
-0.0112762032,
0.013217045,
0.0145485485,
-0.0517126732,
-0.0100637944,
0.009795676,
0.0286258329,
0.0258680079,
0.0932646841,
0.0698409528,
-0.0461802632,
-0.0312410463,
-0.0121626528,
-0.0341236889,
-0.0516586825,
-0.0019434171,
0.0197615139,
0.0202422459,
0.0201205201,
-0.0848870054,
-0.0195105877,
0.0015604789,
0.0159685239,
-0.0146609573,
-0.0114079062,
0.0070933667,
0.011670108,
0.03981971,
0.0067742518,
-0.0362761915,
-0.0000742425,
-0.0876511112,
0.0278768968,
0.0357922353,
-0.0229526814,
-0.016924208,
0.0277885441,
-0.0698094964,
-0.0489667058,
-0.0450224876,
0.051918976,
0.0170912743,
0.0422328971,
-0.0069186143,
-0.0353637338,
0.0128574101,
0.0089809168,
-0.0053592674,
0.0030374599,
0.052833613,
0.0454890467,
0.0015568393,
0.0706010163,
-0.0490237065,
0.0575196519,
0.0092950249,
0.0287584122,
-0.0335674509,
-0.0740457848,
0.0061397715,
0.0258618109,
0.0382377505,
0.0243709125,
0.0012621487,
-0.0048349961,
0.0280455202,
-0.0177520905,
-0.0409545638,
-0.0523962677,
0.0197144151,
-0.0042009125,
-0.0242695138,
-0.0299559329,
-0.0070415721,
-0.0484993234,
0.0521605089,
-0.0102982521,
-0.0072678071,
-0.0220956411,
-0.0253736135,
-0.0022142865,
-0.0176736135,
-0.0409285687,
0.0188790411,
0.0330433175,
0.0441377014,
0.0273310561,
0.0717385262,
0.0384706594,
-0.0162982848,
0.0117166368,
0.041355744,
-0.063843973,
-0.0552933626,
0.0147242891,
0.0066264565,
0.0345266424,
-0.0162777994,
0.0681154504,
-0.0095485747,
0.0010201795,
-0.0164816137,
0.07634902,
0.0389417112,
-0.0263484232,
0.0121846953,
0.0226714294,
-0.0279193427,
0.023194354,
0.0559206158,
-0.0202402435,
0.0168467853,
0.0225672051,
0.0205644667,
-0.0571222901,
-0.0110901315,
-0.0292570796,
-0.0058769216,
0.0264523122,
0.0170751512,
-0.0382736139,
-0.0462788418,
0.0069751283,
-0.0141871916,
0.0137883425,
-0.0169449206,
0.0298808943,
0.0380357094,
-0.0204825494,
0.0187437944,
-0.050502643,
-0.0551850945,
0.0139157809,
-0.0124386773,
-0.0294153765,
-6.200449113e-33,
-0.0023109175,
-0.0327303931,
-0.0107835699,
-0.0005889552,
-0.0157622416,
0.0064472957,
-0.0678313449,
-0.0172483623,
-0.0435134731,
0.0296056028,
-0.0017979131,
0.004210996,
0.0029555012,
0.0428242199,
-0.0334641635,
-0.0462433919,
0.0289594233,
0.0109755341,
-0.0430505462,
0.035558261,
0.0245021377,
-0.0151103782,
-0.0184786376,
-0.1026425511,
0.0087186191,
0.0005290584,
-0.0352613255,
0.0364282839,
0.0197855849,
0.0733817816,
0.013112382,
0.0458031036,
0.0360769294,
-0.0707142353,
0.0116607854,
0.0240925234,
-0.0382465385,
0.0022801796,
-0.0032594327,
-0.0435888916,
-0.0145773534,
-0.0343109965,
0.0053241663,
0.0112620918,
-0.0226294175,
-0.0235846192,
0.015377461,
-0.0372779928,
-0.0076467595,
-0.0249024928,
-0.0383345336,
0.0205207933,
-0.0499068536,
-0.0919291452,
0.0132712713,
0.0470731333,
-0.0249576587,
0.051042445,
-0.0008965362,
0.029696906,
-0.0191062372,
-0.0206305031,
0.0379921123,
0.0047197654,
-0.0041210894,
0.0638359785,
-0.0143785486,
0.0393598452,
-0.0311907232,
-0.0751317441,
-0.028624922,
0.0625946,
0.0426344536,
0.0361695774,
-0.0162231009,
-0.0079847509,
-0.07225959,
0.000068469,
-0.0069460738,
0.0317803808,
-0.010078866,
0.0123019526,
-0.0455453955,
-0.0092287781,
-0.0512189269,
-0.0273785889,
-0.0325452685,
0.0002767539,
0.0205635484,
0.0042082458,
-0.0320332348,
-0.0362407155,
0.0405847058,
-0.031167889,
-0.0041749678,
0.0443703905,
-0.0510160625,
0.0051368088,
-0.0117816729,
0.0023412576,
-0.0709096268,
-0.0085597923,
0.0367728733,
0.0426865406,
0.0293480251,
-0.0146406023,
0.0335870795,
-0.0129470713,
-0.0386332683,
0.0034006899,
-0.051414188,
0.0521558486,
-0.037045069,
0.0438148528,
0.006184719,
0.0124098146,
-0.0360625051,
0.1099773794,
-0.0350207388,
-0.0035828946,
-0.0062468238,
-0.0149742402,
0.0003611245,
-0.000253053,
-0.0702574924,
-0.0069181323,
-0.0005696657,
-0.0324672684,
0.0183628872,
-0.0379069746,
-0.0142296078,
-0.0237384383,
2.719e-7,
-0.03879508,
0.0738250092,
0.0058982261,
0.008555877,
0.026444545,
0.0795287117,
-0.0127314329,
-0.0060582901,
0.0026606228,
-0.0627809912,
0.0033448243,
0.0278557148,
0.1174905449,
-0.0045316541,
-0.0856676549,
-0.014096926,
-0.0822741389,
-0.0454631113,
-0.0346567854,
-0.0148722036,
0.0641989559,
0.0810423568,
0.0075138002,
-0.0016536349,
0.0151830949,
-0.0420180075,
0.0307057519,
-0.0247604325,
-0.0301176701,
0.0272187144,
0.0479425937,
-0.0027728837,
0.0037343681,
0.0148310689,
-0.0196049623,
0.0040140129,
0.0035733234,
0.0972866714,
0.0153427087,
-0.049722787,
-0.0249056965,
0.0210718662,
0.0270046052,
-0.0358944163,
0.0793588161,
-0.035290204,
-0.0288776588,
-0.0161228776,
-0.0186770801,
-0.0266208742,
0.0130883642,
-0.0156150926,
-0.0042068949,
0.023381805,
0.009881041,
-0.0014205758,
0.0058508716,
-0.0722237453,
-0.0140373632,
-0.0148390634,
-0.0261134133,
-0.0275859609,
0.0045158472,
-0.0175749976,
0.0273569934,
-0.0567090847,
0.0096709933,
2.342188336e-34,
0.0598586351,
-0.0323267169,
0.0348690413,
0.021432288,
0.0629366785,
0.0130305504,
-0.0218798034,
-0.0346077271,
0.0220601242,
-0.0703005269,
0.0397344418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17300v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17300v1 | CausalScore: An Automatic Reference-Free Metric for Assessing Response Relevance in Open-Domain Dialogue Systems | 2024-06-25T06:08:16 | 2024-06-25T06:08:16 | Tao Feng, Lizhen Qu, Xiaoxi Kang, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatically evaluating the quality of responses in open-domain dialogue
systems is a challenging but crucial task. Current evaluation metrics often
fail to align with human judgments, especially when assessing responses that
are grammatically correct. To address this issue, we propose a novel metric,
called CausalScore, which assesses the relevance of responses by measuring the
causal strength between dialogue histories and responses. The causal strength
is estimated by utilizing both unconditional dependence and conditional
dependencies from the dialogue history to responses. We compare our metric with
the existing competitive metrics in terms of their alignment with human
judgements. Our experimental results demonstrate that CausalScore significantly
surpasses existing state-of-the-art metrics by aligning better with human
judgements. Additionally, we collect a new dialogue dataset CGDIALOG+ with
human-annotated causal relations and a set of pairwise human judgements to
facilitate the development of future automatic metrics. | [
0.0502664149,
0.0689076632,
-0.0107259313,
0.0106494939,
-0.0254822411,
0.0133519117,
-0.0138130644,
0.0142905917,
0.0267573837,
-0.0609513298,
-0.033498276,
-0.0241453275,
-0.0218284689,
0.0501508489,
-0.0305132754,
-0.0416805558,
0.0587169938,
-0.0075315898,
0.0371267162,
0.0160222668,
0.0073231179,
-0.0079185134,
-0.0609730743,
0.096242778,
-0.0256037097,
-0.019422967,
-0.0215115808,
0.0261073802,
0.0183593743,
-0.0326573066,
0.021761369,
0.0604796596,
-0.0498680361,
0.0592207611,
0.0000016392,
-0.0746744648,
0.0222124234,
-0.0273424666,
-0.0186270885,
-0.0013067906,
-0.007638447,
0.0576263703,
-0.0051132166,
0.0178370476,
-0.0796543434,
0.0103276698,
0.0434943996,
0.029744545,
0.0654088184,
0.0586701222,
-0.0085017011,
-0.0071067619,
0.0055916598,
-0.0011222014,
-0.0047123763,
-0.0565714054,
0.0011264576,
0.0400209688,
-0.0075654285,
-0.028508883,
0.0040937299,
-0.0026999454,
0.0069788075,
-0.0797699764,
-0.0073848017,
-0.0274065677,
-0.0176912099,
0.0017552634,
0.0122616198,
0.1127099544,
0.0933897346,
0.0223696176,
-0.0098869856,
-0.0130750658,
0.0228198692,
0.0062408447,
-0.0559889264,
-0.0455596708,
-0.0173167381,
-0.0239033457,
-0.0175539423,
0.0290385149,
-0.0237225555,
0.0262941383,
0.0222834572,
0.0987360775,
0.0031532925,
-0.0198671091,
-0.0367987938,
0.0013220898,
-0.0022592759,
-0.0539143048,
-0.00030751,
0.0214302652,
-0.0821089447,
0.0133653088,
-0.0062102983,
0.0045414115,
0.0410229079,
-0.0445025414,
0.0029014393,
0.0145773776,
-0.0021498099,
0.0356009267,
-0.0023334452,
0.0747144595,
-0.0044902237,
-0.0173299406,
-0.0247863978,
-0.0024413697,
-0.0572821498,
0.0136473961,
-0.0028068838,
-0.0007428899,
-0.0613393448,
-0.0023203946,
-0.0512150377,
0.0312384423,
-0.029264465,
-0.022461595,
0.0194787439,
0.0448343866,
-0.013887275,
-0.0004373598,
-0.0833216012,
0.0334961787,
-0.051593516,
0.0367485136,
0.0171947852,
-0.0379599631,
-0.0057514156,
0.0430426076,
0.0306054596,
-0.0118867457,
-0.0460150801,
0.0731367841,
0.0079255393,
-0.0219384618,
0.0048058243,
-0.0353330299,
-0.0310555175,
-0.0429597311,
-0.0374892093,
-0.019452678,
-0.0022982059,
0.0225368422,
-0.0434729867,
-0.0061447443,
0.0132918945,
0.0243419688,
-0.004698474,
0.0202939268,
0.013102836,
0.0024086717,
-0.0002601465,
-0.0020736472,
-0.0111723999,
0.0217565186,
0.0286105201,
0.0090780426,
0.0467129052,
-0.0093329102,
0.0209459197,
-0.0129148485,
-0.0109533351,
0.005374867,
-0.000339577,
0.0414943956,
-0.0164828897,
-0.0001171727,
-0.0051728371,
0.0173748359,
-0.0312771164,
-0.0196318328,
0.0617771223,
0.0360672474,
-0.0052706241,
-0.0172740333,
0.0338310935,
-0.0040728119,
0.0106490375,
0.0318226926,
-0.0234362315,
0.0135724777,
0.0029414671,
-0.0170749687,
0.0522080883,
-0.0174818449,
0.0043033287,
-0.0867377222,
0.0325626023,
0.0162925329,
0.0076314588,
-0.0115696359,
0.0233805664,
0.0259190463,
-0.0485383905,
0.0406775288,
0.0132720163,
-0.0727279782,
-0.0166610833,
-0.0342848077,
0.0423864871,
0.0409191065,
0.0549311787,
-0.0277074724,
-0.0315130465,
-0.0288763829,
-0.0041504088,
0.0354103781,
0.0414289981,
-0.0155239021,
0.0553075597,
-0.0191034898,
-0.0061411299,
0.0316060968,
0.0125086987,
0.04591728,
-0.0016708927,
-0.0170662887,
0.0060839038,
0.019721847,
0.0213392731,
0.0068475334,
0.0421020314,
-0.0145252002,
0.0456249826,
-0.0093028015,
0.0562965535,
0.0295228809,
-0.0056522163,
0.0046313675,
0.0282742735,
0.0112886392,
-0.0413809791,
0.0363399908,
-0.0752565265,
-0.0311676022,
0.0141869588,
-0.0188340992,
-0.0196137503,
0.0201007351,
-0.013628995,
-0.069264099,
0.0678084865,
-0.0339114368,
0.0210607927,
-0.0584201328,
-0.0001396724,
0.0298631079,
0.0065465393,
-0.0633295774,
0.0436394475,
0.0215337351,
0.0483840257,
0.0316005833,
0.0184877198,
0.0593399554,
-0.0454563759,
-0.0038330881,
-0.006188951,
-0.0610595159,
0.0056320154,
0.0438806973,
-0.0167621505,
-0.0800790042,
-0.007858431,
-0.1196152344,
0.0100725405,
-0.0147230588,
0.0336672626,
0.0164256841,
0.0156653412,
-0.0026205357,
-0.0429665409,
-0.0153280636,
-0.0060663023,
0.0440153554,
0.0075332336,
0.0534528606,
0.0189602338,
-0.0080693765,
-0.0615776964,
0.0080472976,
-0.0020444058,
0.0260045808,
0.0269625019,
0.0296664946,
-0.0332746841,
-0.0126634482,
-0.0357052125,
0.0317491256,
-0.0014769828,
-0.0750264674,
0.0547538958,
0.0335383676,
0.0136301955,
0.0434486419,
0.057540305,
-0.0150140123,
-0.0166508332,
-0.0315484032,
-0.0613206849,
0.030340232,
-0.0549815185,
-0.0088093989,
-0.0262351073,
-0.0048471149,
0.0181660596,
0.0383609831,
0.0166057888,
0.0207427572,
-0.0455389023,
-0.0125058563,
-0.0011391441,
-0.0321677476,
-0.0196261145,
-0.0274262857,
-0.0497560315,
0.051094979,
-0.016110247,
-0.0454120338,
0.0612188466,
-0.0347363316,
-0.0213545784,
-0.0213197786,
0.0059051905,
-0.0454600267,
0.0419153385,
-0.0046239132,
-0.0015655782,
0.0419252589,
-0.0561449453,
-0.0204645153,
0.0037286007,
0.0484785847,
-0.0315483958,
0.0431116968,
-0.0681809634,
0.0136954812,
0.0069981571,
-0.0450629666,
-0.0629312545,
-0.0425141379,
0.0001534235,
-0.0170556325,
0.002361564,
-0.0381100401,
-0.0296430029,
0.0098433895,
0.0082189804,
0.0204330143,
-0.0151094859,
-0.0015855434,
-0.0190469325,
0.0606805496,
0.0332987085,
0.0438381545,
0.0080861747,
0.0365795232,
0.0378903896,
0.0344597958,
0.0161706116,
-0.0120744342,
-0.020708492,
-0.0178891476,
-0.0105887782,
-0.009124307,
0.0025279631,
0.0078849606,
0.0702987164,
-0.0238572396,
-0.0154581927,
0.0964489952,
0.0223868955,
-0.0102621065,
-0.0106445029,
-0.0327467844,
0.0234088469,
0.0390846953,
0.0056557106,
-0.0546184555,
-0.0569533072,
-0.0088478373,
0.0291947275,
-0.0208042413,
-0.0670254752,
0.0098630469,
-0.0933322906,
0.0066083558,
-0.0468675122,
-0.0091165407,
0.0034112986,
-0.0328425653,
0.0400874801,
-0.0330001377,
-0.0237892214,
0.0015413736,
0.0236607101,
-0.0074432674,
0.0194684733,
-0.0263168868,
-0.005632061,
0.0202210508,
0.0123936515,
0.0539327897,
0.0854120702,
0.0538107604,
0.0375617929,
-0.0230555944,
0.0124192005,
-0.0288194735,
0.0076397243,
0.0134573849,
0.0499658361,
0.0274820961,
-0.0024371799,
-0.0603197776,
0.0026664301,
-0.0037665793,
-0.0154893473,
0.0343221538,
0.0274319146,
-0.0362435989,
0.0480405018,
-0.0233746693,
0.0379023179,
0.0392870009,
0.052051682,
0.0390069522,
-0.051787395,
-0.0460381843,
-0.0323496014,
-0.0146370037,
-0.0539550856,
-0.0099199498,
-0.0305994228,
0.0225768331,
-0.0072781905,
-0.1124980003,
-0.0556569882,
-0.0384785868,
0.0064444607,
-0.0430155545,
-0.0019905565,
-0.0382527038,
0.0231920648,
0.0044522905,
0.0502279848,
-0.0060031028,
0.0198454559,
-0.0970378444,
0.0221490469,
0.006359661,
0.0078138588,
-0.0337147377,
0.0344747975,
-0.0299247634,
-0.0356488749,
-0.0122897876,
0.0508895144,
0.0230940059,
-0.0039842371,
-0.0159349572,
-0.0263192691,
-0.0436183922,
0.023474725,
-0.0456395186,
-0.0193204358,
0.0770750269,
0.0317445137,
-0.0380581915,
0.039138265,
-0.0236372221,
0.0321779363,
-0.0211876296,
0.0681602806,
-0.0267735608,
-0.0836499855,
-0.001504804,
-0.0119444244,
0.0929974318,
0.0148025453,
-0.0285137836,
-0.0078580193,
0.0363302305,
-0.0139715038,
-0.0058023133,
-0.0546558797,
0.0075748097,
-0.0294535868,
-0.025031535,
-0.0077492064,
-0.0325204991,
-0.0778382793,
0.0371264778,
-0.0165571645,
0.0294119641,
0.0708213076,
0.0402899198,
0.0073497724,
-0.0097431503,
-0.0181280617,
0.0124342581,
0.0266238973,
0.031084884,
0.0138533693,
0.0968398005,
-0.0002160817,
-0.0066650584,
0.0655877665,
0.0051285648,
-0.1021529585,
0.0314860865,
-0.0018515958,
-0.0031065843,
0.0374635272,
0.0194243528,
0.0786082,
0.0119999414,
0.0264466945,
-0.0166963767,
0.062999323,
0.0339686349,
-0.0109424358,
0.0060428632,
0.0341291875,
-0.0051994054,
0.0540555976,
0.0611099005,
-0.0220176596,
0.006352914,
-0.0318887942,
0.0018011713,
-0.0361049734,
-0.0618810169,
-0.0247196611,
0.0259042848,
-0.0092549603,
0.0102888811,
-0.0732661635,
-0.0358388536,
-0.0084337834,
0.0222429018,
0.0297636334,
-0.0054190224,
0.0529441014,
0.0171255488,
0.0011421752,
-0.0148061765,
-0.0570756979,
0.0018394873,
-0.0383928008,
-0.0107511245,
-0.0523584038,
-5.47444323e-33,
-0.0264486559,
-0.0768494532,
-0.0112716313,
-0.0115461536,
0.0082199927,
-0.0174034871,
-0.0543609038,
0.0411733724,
-0.0155665176,
0.0201322716,
-0.0246309359,
0.0260573514,
0.0082959514,
0.0166193806,
-0.0152074713,
-0.0221587811,
0.024857536,
0.017960947,
-0.0221971087,
0.0361646973,
0.0473769531,
-0.0016803257,
0.0100811534,
-0.1004066989,
0.060123913,
-0.0001499109,
-0.0050024414,
0.0193453655,
0.0033019418,
0.076461859,
0.005539645,
0.0686580315,
0.0195642747,
-0.0492799133,
0.0057121161,
0.0348962806,
-0.040053755,
-0.0390712656,
0.0344280116,
-0.0066883564,
-0.0345874354,
0.0167021882,
-0.0228312816,
0.0024442179,
-0.0076516797,
0.0066686128,
0.0200586468,
-0.0236989409,
0.0131388623,
-0.0017761219,
-0.031314835,
0.0479000509,
-0.0371359512,
-0.0524063706,
-0.0322127827,
0.0904474184,
0.0135106966,
-0.02945254,
0.0271886531,
0.0230772384,
-0.0300062783,
0.0032392745,
0.0326757543,
0.0157507621,
-0.0065352349,
0.0572942644,
-0.0006629914,
0.0127983699,
-0.0128912581,
-0.0629542917,
-0.034276247,
0.0383595005,
0.0515045412,
0.0844825283,
0.0132159367,
0.0110897636,
-0.0599999018,
0.0475610793,
0.0171095561,
0.0366372317,
-0.0042830519,
-0.0085918466,
-0.0162499007,
0.0161894877,
-0.0338059701,
0.0170797724,
-0.0397590622,
-0.0239318479,
0.0463589728,
-0.0089304661,
-0.0148558132,
-0.0579903126,
0.0486685634,
-0.025126135,
0.0039473167,
0.0519196205,
-0.0206697118,
-0.0025720675,
0.0117427614,
-0.0074703442,
-0.0188003331,
0.0174821876,
0.0535263494,
0.0255969316,
0.038227696,
-0.0257846769,
0.0058913012,
-0.0412881449,
-0.0456329845,
0.000123756,
-0.002170471,
0.0390165709,
-0.0641341358,
-0.0025916609,
0.0218067616,
-0.0068846238,
-0.0326498821,
0.0892130584,
-0.0152470889,
0.0258290805,
-0.0431793183,
-0.0867533609,
0.0043921787,
-0.0073354766,
-0.0577461943,
-0.0200250931,
0.0036348735,
0.0101427045,
-0.0355577245,
-0.0190037191,
-0.0205730535,
0.0094645657,
2.312e-7,
0.0220545884,
0.0342809223,
0.0314962715,
0.0253556985,
0.0155767258,
0.0581683815,
0.0059201322,
0.0054525048,
0.0287866499,
0.0097510787,
0.0129513675,
-0.0336926095,
0.0692042559,
0.0063675148,
-0.0946097374,
-0.0497723632,
-0.0754776299,
-0.0319141783,
-0.001007128,
0.0164483991,
0.0878452733,
0.0352190956,
-0.0030955796,
0.0070908889,
-0.0273718461,
-0.0171239488,
0.0108513515,
-0.0207920279,
0.0084790625,
0.0039064088,
0.0508401208,
-0.053920377,
0.0037380068,
0.0383864343,
-0.0082655428,
-0.0073209084,
0.0134610515,
0.0345979109,
0.0000373707,
-0.0767564625,
-0.0166692045,
-0.0223151483,
0.0562116019,
-0.0227910858,
0.0434605815,
-0.0230543036,
-0.0164881144,
0.0185897276,
-0.0405306332,
-0.017309133,
0.0330588259,
-0.0107028252,
-0.0306273699,
0.0202758741,
0.003263653,
0.010890536,
0.0144418003,
-0.0707379356,
-0.0378353372,
-0.0095372749,
-0.0062107546,
-0.0637042224,
-0.0177392699,
-0.0103118094,
-0.0000328211,
-0.0101827718,
0.0186457336,
1.573496534e-34,
0.0295179747,
-0.0020254848,
0.026722949,
0.0014626654,
0.0694058314,
0.0022010249,
-0.0121600749,
0.005548127,
0.0740874708,
-0.1004271284,
-0.0033517715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17294v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17294v2 | Math-LLaVA: Bootstrapping Mathematical Reasoning for Multimodal Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T05:43:21 | 2024-06-26T16:43:27 | Wenhao Shi, Zhiqiang Hu, Yi Bin, Junhua Liu, Yang Yang, See-Kiong Ng, Lidong Bing, Roy Ka-Wei Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive reasoning
capabilities, particularly in textual mathematical problem-solving. However,
existing open-source image instruction fine-tuning datasets, containing limited
question-answer pairs per image, do not fully exploit visual information to
enhance the multimodal mathematical reasoning capabilities of Multimodal LLMs
(MLLMs). To bridge this gap, we address the lack of high-quality, diverse
multimodal mathematical datasets by collecting 40K high-quality images with
question-answer pairs from 24 existing datasets and synthesizing 320K new
pairs, creating the MathV360K dataset, which enhances both the breadth and
depth of multimodal mathematical questions. We introduce Math-LLaVA, a
LLaVA-1.5-based model fine-tuned with MathV360K. This novel approach
significantly improves the multimodal mathematical reasoning capabilities of
LLaVA-1.5, achieving a 19-point increase and comparable performance to GPT-4V
on MathVista's minitest split. Furthermore, Math-LLaVA demonstrates enhanced
generalizability, showing substantial improvements on the MMMU benchmark. Our
research highlights the importance of dataset diversity and synthesis in
advancing MLLMs' mathematical reasoning abilities. The code and data are
available at: \url{https://github.com/HZQ950419/Math-LLaVA}. | [
-0.0276961774,
0.0922459364,
-0.0106544523,
0.0900251567,
-0.0416204333,
0.0266776271,
0.0390067063,
0.0017987806,
-0.0272533651,
-0.0420811959,
-0.0215811972,
-0.0145987514,
-0.0207014009,
0.0104060322,
0.0538159683,
-0.0555094332,
0.0141650569,
-0.0604004003,
-0.0311558377,
-0.0261556227,
-0.0085938154,
0.0034459382,
-0.0386953093,
-0.0072706076,
-0.0390715599,
-0.0631879494,
0.00718839,
-0.0166599229,
0.0085740397,
-0.0357848518,
-0.0137722204,
0.0439544655,
0.0639048889,
0.0079602906,
0.000002266,
-0.0369578861,
0.0102306912,
0.0111947525,
-0.0125081623,
-0.0197640397,
-0.0092195682,
-0.0142031582,
0.0266866591,
-0.0095922006,
-0.0672563389,
0.0206311308,
0.0290510524,
0.0183854662,
0.0972458199,
0.0489656031,
-0.0133965416,
-0.0453902036,
0.0326504968,
0.014039279,
0.0722236708,
-0.0547735505,
-0.0042876936,
0.0641765296,
0.0309574176,
-0.0001012868,
-0.061320994,
0.0577876084,
0.0856499672,
-0.002758042,
-0.0319495127,
0.022814652,
-0.0209059473,
-0.0243668053,
-0.0210030507,
0.1041830778,
0.0062643401,
0.0208903179,
-0.0393555388,
0.0110868746,
-0.0019847525,
0.0199194904,
-0.0787022561,
0.0507252477,
-0.0283257272,
-0.011441444,
-0.0464840606,
-0.0069396161,
0.0097237974,
0.0193942785,
-0.0148695521,
0.0652025342,
0.020709293,
0.0140742399,
-0.0038731019,
-0.0036941553,
-0.0966082141,
-0.0200911649,
0.0168351363,
0.0651180148,
0.0209003817,
0.0069794655,
-0.0211237036,
-0.0579137132,
-0.0333760716,
-0.0025428643,
0.0572380088,
0.0413489491,
-0.0260139406,
0.0450291932,
-0.031737186,
0.0137539431,
-0.0338857323,
0.0403081253,
-0.0167492945,
0.005590023,
-0.0077894363,
0.0004384739,
-0.0079828035,
-0.0049856901,
-0.027103385,
-0.0072861956,
-0.0039063324,
0.0314135887,
-0.0017135142,
0.0084517356,
-0.0089737326,
0.0112881232,
-0.0015708951,
-0.0416397378,
-0.0353127979,
0.0133409081,
-0.06401328,
0.0240735132,
0.0068815108,
-0.0541918389,
-0.0051128953,
0.0277234111,
-0.0010465313,
-0.0622282252,
0.037171226,
0.0863410607,
-0.0105311098,
0.0008120326,
-0.0110506127,
-0.0152324969,
0.0236370135,
-0.0973604694,
0.03207561,
-0.0872385129,
0.0480686128,
0.0163176935,
-0.0250517875,
-0.0141554698,
-0.0062328451,
0.0287871808,
0.0317783877,
0.0916319117,
0.0091643119,
-0.0090270545,
0.042462334,
0.002635191,
-0.0190239958,
0.0799339116,
0.0491808914,
-0.0062146275,
0.0423619449,
-0.0212884974,
-0.006294616,
0.037487004,
0.0261124019,
0.0198158175,
-0.0226014201,
0.0408192985,
0.0105135245,
0.0444299877,
-0.0101347845,
0.0297219567,
-0.0469670407,
-0.0401630178,
0.0413152575,
0.0361633077,
-0.0059823277,
0.0018995892,
0.0103601161,
-0.014114867,
0.0476730689,
-0.0308898017,
-0.0712275207,
0.083883293,
-0.0181360189,
-0.0049834321,
0.0245759431,
0.0251070224,
-0.0252938662,
-0.0444014594,
0.0039714598,
0.0175963938,
-0.0338452421,
0.0295979921,
0.0456095189,
-0.0038897018,
0.0035536818,
0.0320168473,
0.0213860869,
-0.0227699578,
-0.0129386345,
-0.0287770368,
0.0490045622,
-0.0083029121,
0.0498046242,
-0.0396243781,
-0.0459122136,
-0.0299415644,
0.0515166894,
0.0240259599,
0.0241055321,
0.0123388506,
0.0005230381,
-0.0633918792,
-0.0068015023,
-0.0512194298,
-0.0183604173,
-0.0152946478,
0.0197543744,
0.0060632676,
-0.0073657432,
-0.0543138199,
0.0632019415,
0.0193539672,
-0.0238687843,
-0.015860986,
-0.0305266138,
0.0066628251,
0.0009078046,
-0.0304727219,
0.0263824817,
0.018063264,
-0.0072996435,
-0.0352319479,
0.0254261289,
-0.01482346,
-0.0557359718,
-0.057015527,
0.051564876,
-0.06318409,
-0.0417671688,
0.0183403008,
-0.058436323,
0.013805531,
0.0253850799,
-0.0111220367,
-0.035055507,
-0.0298003387,
-0.0229429863,
0.0272019636,
0.0288622268,
-0.0281416737,
0.0537095927,
-0.0208176114,
0.0229190383,
0.0105505632,
0.0293954834,
0.0179878548,
0.00359113,
0.0212009922,
-0.002771765,
-0.017730074,
0.0358938128,
-0.0428411998,
0.0179477651,
-0.0407649428,
0.0064797779,
-0.0138589265,
0.0020933028,
-0.0001034979,
0.0192643087,
0.0160978921,
-0.0199644584,
-0.0066676382,
-0.0155144017,
-0.0348936766,
0.0222153589,
0.0034874559,
0.017595876,
0.0251474287,
-0.0085611762,
0.0390546732,
-0.0030081922,
-0.0328673534,
-0.0288735591,
0.0634975359,
0.0041962327,
0.0644521117,
-0.0083500016,
-0.0117663462,
-0.0700456202,
0.0187130012,
-0.0193524975,
0.0077596596,
0.0409035496,
-0.0458698869,
0.055171214,
0.0752505288,
0.0019500008,
0.0161384139,
0.0066723372,
-0.0344394967,
-0.0417365469,
0.0332790725,
0.0072189514,
0.0051138331,
-0.0063943239,
-0.0006179733,
-0.0595246889,
0.0435452871,
-0.0402665511,
-0.0226134341,
-0.0266253073,
0.0521131866,
0.0057667908,
-0.0346572287,
-0.0556957573,
0.0543284044,
0.006048236,
0.0346095823,
-0.0399774015,
-0.0465250574,
0.0423919596,
-0.0115922121,
-0.0269796029,
-0.0179942977,
0.0300100651,
-0.043454688,
0.0549062975,
0.0038015351,
-0.0077983541,
-0.0419725217,
0.0185319707,
-0.0558157936,
-0.0137404613,
0.0470569581,
-0.0222851429,
0.0685691088,
-0.0422199667,
-0.0015074115,
-0.0408215672,
-0.0418029428,
-0.0218162332,
0.0044255266,
-0.0145953177,
-0.0104295323,
-0.0420353785,
-0.0278329011,
0.0057470808,
-0.0055945339,
0.0482519232,
-0.0063384511,
-0.0391030647,
-0.011621736,
-0.0199572723,
0.0277665593,
0.0597570911,
0.0592723191,
0.0413599461,
-0.0882298946,
0.0172499232,
0.0243799221,
0.0412829518,
-0.0138798077,
-0.0217380915,
0.0411246046,
-0.0068115676,
0.0471114591,
0.0024406014,
0.0288753491,
0.0692265257,
-0.0527613275,
0.0113784531,
0.0540570579,
0.0107911956,
-0.0130796218,
-0.0196677037,
-0.0467776991,
0.0471096262,
0.0465513505,
0.0106656011,
-0.0921127349,
-0.0549982563,
0.0211513564,
-0.0314017534,
0.0484959334,
-0.0316702388,
-0.0071853115,
-0.0817699954,
0.0374932066,
-0.0071542049,
-0.0493066274,
-0.0013662954,
-0.0089162178,
0.0086290082,
0.0326841213,
0.0071506617,
0.0033194639,
0.0034066939,
0.0377537496,
0.0089306673,
0.0439631902,
-0.012131609,
0.0245789513,
-0.0128874471,
-0.0499760658,
-0.0169050507,
0.0085095633,
-0.0234080981,
-0.0832563937,
0.0389009565,
0.030105168,
-0.0329559073,
-0.0071324948,
0.0370832756,
-0.0037403896,
-0.0243042763,
-0.0317014381,
0.0512357801,
-0.0390317552,
-0.0263099447,
0.0133591481,
0.0999632329,
-0.0157934036,
0.0065195593,
-0.0356781147,
0.0157571919,
-0.0462007709,
0.0109677278,
0.0336950198,
-0.021224495,
-0.0569317676,
-0.0253698919,
-0.0263929646,
-0.0580546483,
-0.0213569924,
0.0300870761,
0.0497783199,
0.0153356586,
-0.0318702422,
-0.0151114454,
0.0322638527,
0.0612979941,
-0.0141211478,
-0.0385744162,
-0.0035252508,
0.0069093578,
-0.0378811918,
0.064016588,
-0.0333242379,
0.0598509163,
-0.0253165588,
0.0460533053,
-0.0002998855,
-0.0350282528,
-0.0251944438,
0.0320664011,
-0.1100901291,
-0.0380440764,
-0.0455719233,
0.053708259,
0.0115601718,
0.0024646958,
0.0181177873,
-0.0359855928,
0.0087525547,
0.0365147479,
-0.0191140268,
0.0127596529,
0.026580967,
-0.004165791,
0.0191905536,
0.0235676263,
-0.0001004503,
0.0000085279,
0.00799328,
0.0392426476,
0.0024218122,
0.0015389329,
-0.0045465971,
0.0262049045,
-0.0179516394,
0.0147927441,
0.01084923,
-0.0186546464,
0.0303154103,
-0.014027643,
-0.0086170696,
-0.0495095775,
0.0141973179,
0.0065001626,
-0.0367515646,
0.0124800568,
-0.0264893118,
0.0580000617,
0.0365707651,
-0.009773735,
0.050983306,
0.0255356841,
0.0086448416,
0.0359468013,
-0.0033416683,
0.0182594359,
-0.0059062815,
-0.0292163733,
0.0500700921,
-0.0083957231,
0.0955947787,
0.0172226615,
-0.0281209964,
-0.0296171885,
0.0050116051,
-0.0215143375,
-0.081005834,
0.0041387337,
0.0200705118,
0.0529690795,
0.0264807567,
-0.0229533762,
-0.0204751231,
-0.0186888762,
0.003121967,
0.0361022763,
0.0161397662,
-0.0185397733,
0.0832266808,
0.0404708907,
0.0437152833,
-0.0479627177,
0.0256305914,
-0.0404294841,
0.0301495548,
0.0114482502,
0.0530528389,
-0.029612368,
-0.0318556391,
0.013036699,
-0.0078101195,
0.0294588711,
0.0392374471,
-0.041091606,
-0.095261462,
-0.0248059593,
0.0166214127,
-0.0504915267,
0.0265301839,
0.037080545,
0.0582756922,
-0.0162068866,
-0.0427637212,
0.0100617241,
0.0552262105,
-0.031897027,
-0.0141805755,
0.0200227778,
-5.99657578e-33,
0.0005249486,
-0.0205791797,
0.0700282529,
0.0010685045,
-0.0056134844,
-0.028766226,
-0.0310243256,
0.0176691487,
-0.0358133391,
0.0042623836,
0.007430431,
0.0062913368,
-0.003562062,
0.0396212749,
-0.0084681772,
-0.0212366544,
-0.0321971476,
-0.0163188428,
-0.0255200621,
0.0001866076,
0.0014851593,
-0.0023515334,
0.0655656159,
-0.0365111046,
-0.0157658886,
0.0072571915,
-0.0181985665,
0.0351823345,
-0.0668657497,
0.0660419688,
-0.039439626,
0.0244153291,
0.0278237797,
-0.0192412212,
-0.0172585361,
0.0099258116,
-0.0539983921,
-0.0365478545,
0.0069702361,
0.021550566,
-0.1212556213,
-0.0153979119,
0.0268716943,
-0.0128394729,
-0.0011009226,
-0.0649321079,
0.0303224027,
-0.0255175885,
0.0038686744,
0.0189237539,
-0.0177163426,
0.02665703,
-0.026772486,
-0.0469098166,
0.0173711702,
0.0550946258,
0.0121160885,
0.0318796299,
-0.0115344953,
0.0146084717,
0.0028767565,
0.0003875204,
0.066137068,
0.00933001,
0.0220315587,
0.0307539981,
0.0033265005,
-0.0527547896,
-0.0122892354,
0.0102578914,
0.0306488313,
0.0950352699,
0.0735652521,
0.0715190619,
0.0268921908,
0.0370939635,
-0.0497335009,
-0.002285053,
-0.026047539,
0.0548972525,
0.0153264441,
0.0017418143,
0.013362593,
0.0125322128,
-0.0445734933,
0.0187242702,
-0.0591924191,
-0.0037320936,
0.0316434912,
-0.0385925584,
-0.0183705986,
0.0310221575,
0.051644329,
-0.0265836399,
-0.046342928,
-0.0036011485,
-0.0001072234,
0.0379904099,
0.0280686133,
0.0551499911,
-0.0230811145,
-0.0140227685,
0.0127902851,
-0.021595059,
0.0287214722,
0.0116312224,
0.0266344287,
0.0196294971,
-0.0287000109,
-0.0324596725,
-0.0585024431,
-0.0019817408,
0.0464435481,
0.0461710989,
0.0266540125,
0.0177527145,
-0.0451575853,
0.0373142846,
-0.0253682993,
-0.0173543654,
-0.0316272974,
-0.0289918035,
-0.0391661562,
0.0321664624,
-0.0235834364,
0.0083309002,
-0.0695079714,
-0.0536834337,
0.0151698561,
-0.092462033,
0.000185945,
0.0352767184,
2.747e-7,
0.0441490375,
0.0290862527,
0.0014078378,
0.0060573728,
0.0293667112,
0.0437035114,
-0.0570906624,
-0.0187346451,
0.0030824321,
-0.0626665726,
-0.0370038562,
0.0885801464,
0.0375973135,
0.0551860109,
0.0003654315,
0.0298299193,
-0.0128386514,
-0.0173033345,
-0.0588666126,
0.0218892749,
0.0633115619,
0.0618099384,
-0.0044016959,
-0.0333660319,
0.033005707,
-0.036228206,
0.0530482456,
-0.0130803594,
-0.0202770345,
-0.0222041141,
-0.0232136082,
-0.0184607655,
0.0285998248,
-0.0052557262,
0.0043131402,
-0.0354991071,
0.0282492656,
0.0482877344,
0.0082565704,
-0.0136215352,
-0.0220100526,
-0.0303806942,
-0.040136829,
-0.0522216819,
0.0734812394,
-0.0338642001,
-0.0564305931,
-0.0264090654,
-0.0172920395,
-0.0320093669,
0.0372225754,
-0.0244374759,
-0.0023205341,
-0.0003345323,
0.0353579521,
-0.0319771469,
-0.0143929105,
-0.0562302396,
-0.0271518659,
0.0110548912,
-0.0642642081,
-0.0277147219,
-0.0606602356,
-0.0226470102,
0.0386004858,
-0.0170279108,
-0.0557953157,
2.38992259e-34,
0.0307489783,
-0.0177263878,
0.0503826439,
0.025060676,
0.0263825003,
-0.0281542875,
-0.0550901555,
0.0033924843,
0.0046031242,
-0.0772707835,
-0.0232223291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17287v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17287v1 | Predicting the Big Five Personality Traits in Chinese Counselling Dialogues Using Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T05:30:55 | 2024-06-25T05:30:55 | Yang Yan, Lizhi Ma, Anqi Li, Jingsong Ma, Zhenzhong Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Accurate assessment of personality traits is crucial for effective
psycho-counseling, yet traditional methods like self-report questionnaires are
time-consuming and biased. This study exams whether Large Language Models
(LLMs) can predict the Big Five personality traits directly from counseling
dialogues and introduces an innovative framework to perform the task. Our
framework applies role-play and questionnaire-based prompting to condition LLMs
on counseling sessions, simulating client responses to the Big Five Inventory.
We evaluated our framework on 853 real-world counseling sessions, finding a
significant correlation between LLM-predicted and actual Big Five traits,
proving the validity of framework. Moreover, ablation studies highlight the
importance of role-play simulations and task simplification via questionnaires
in enhancing prediction accuracy. Meanwhile, our fine-tuned Llama3-8B model,
utilizing Direct Preference Optimization with Supervised Fine-Tuning, achieves
a 130.95\% improvement, surpassing the state-of-the-art Qwen1.5-110B by 36.94\%
in personality prediction validity. In conclusion, LLMs can predict personality
based on counseling dialogues. Our code and model are publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/kuri-leo/BigFive-LLM-Predictor}, providing a valuable
tool for future research in computational psychometrics. | [
0.0888932347,
0.0565934889,
-0.0409633219,
0.0212049186,
-0.0215972606,
0.0020085685,
0.0528885834,
-0.0312601402,
0.0369898155,
0.0041693863,
-0.0408878662,
-0.0400846265,
-0.0049503879,
0.0138913179,
-0.0031792358,
-0.0632626414,
0.0261519272,
-0.0012546969,
0.0438873582,
-0.0206160918,
0.0036100631,
0.0271180831,
0.0008862602,
0.0363695733,
0.005679897,
-0.0235561226,
0.0154238073,
-0.002144045,
0.0243149698,
-0.0184282064,
0.0422068313,
0.0722631365,
-0.03083371,
-0.0186759029,
0.0000024367,
-0.043600332,
-0.0136415344,
-0.0135577433,
0.0373804905,
0.0102025094,
0.0661463365,
0.0467625223,
0.0325652137,
0.066280432,
-0.0323651582,
-0.0332296193,
0.0260328427,
0.1043679193,
0.0862428173,
0.0509064794,
-0.0039682677,
-0.0489592738,
-0.0361318886,
-0.0256013926,
0.0234507918,
-0.0320126489,
0.0329554118,
-0.0101256119,
-0.0054488904,
0.0250759553,
-0.0174306016,
-0.0293010455,
-0.0182526447,
0.0089733955,
-0.019937193,
-0.0179767832,
-0.0410760604,
-0.018934384,
0.0185264014,
0.0692561567,
0.0366107859,
0.0022822418,
-0.0094424151,
-0.029840989,
0.0501933321,
-0.0006255158,
0.0086195208,
0.0023025256,
0.0057695238,
-0.0356596112,
0.0471990071,
0.0211516526,
-0.0122776283,
0.0000925628,
0.0018652296,
0.0327071995,
-0.014449114,
-0.012881483,
0.0108807981,
-0.0231088176,
-0.0292616151,
-0.0559102036,
0.0142674502,
-0.0128861833,
-0.050695058,
0.0072747595,
-0.0162467565,
0.0339237675,
0.0405278616,
-0.0318462104,
0.0447344482,
0.0363005362,
-0.0308730211,
-0.0220383108,
0.0676977485,
0.0516352914,
0.0517183803,
-0.0145594142,
-0.0652364939,
0.0161135253,
-0.0670731962,
-0.008099163,
0.024592055,
0.0166149195,
0.002809071,
-0.0034830042,
-0.0894814283,
0.0125316335,
-0.0142175397,
0.0159764048,
0.0072042802,
0.0080748275,
0.0095531344,
0.0403064564,
-0.0818582326,
0.0533186123,
-0.0527662523,
0.0032920772,
-0.0183125604,
-0.0424754284,
0.0608733445,
-0.0078121633,
-0.0102851233,
-0.04096248,
0.0504204109,
0.0197046008,
0.0077791926,
-0.0340535492,
-0.0063395421,
-0.035335321,
-0.0545476638,
-0.0634224862,
0.0258827247,
-0.0348722078,
0.0384987816,
-0.0147394445,
0.0114864185,
-0.0414811447,
0.0311399903,
0.0293050725,
-0.0201829169,
0.0650727376,
0.0202545151,
0.0075182663,
0.0087646795,
0.0148897432,
0.0354247428,
0.0228601918,
-0.0055409898,
0.0021805945,
0.0234655235,
-0.0692926049,
0.0182590354,
0.0320951566,
-0.0297311991,
-0.0126443645,
-0.0036685129,
-0.0082178274,
0.0166448243,
0.0299777463,
0.0062112059,
0.0389837362,
-0.0084243855,
-0.0145212989,
0.0970853716,
0.0579988137,
0.0360274501,
0.038162671,
-0.0179129764,
0.0431509875,
0.0347675011,
-0.0185522176,
-0.0465172157,
0.0290094744,
-0.0276176892,
-0.0014551239,
-0.0231978707,
0.0286580604,
-0.0109877773,
-0.0596738905,
-0.0047030505,
-0.0306082778,
0.0071862871,
0.0343149267,
-0.0344907939,
-0.0188867413,
-0.0173961986,
-0.0153892478,
0.0481912382,
-0.0198607408,
-0.0590674765,
-0.0564962886,
0.0094078416,
0.105445914,
0.0328640193,
-0.019377863,
-0.0366943441,
-0.0158240944,
-0.0270249061,
0.0022351672,
0.0571590848,
0.0013335168,
-0.0164568089,
-0.0535914637,
0.0038019544,
0.0107809016,
-0.0007365478,
-0.0004651543,
0.0022188525,
0.0058533074,
-0.0107648065,
0.0403319821,
-0.0239841249,
0.011632571,
-0.0458709709,
-0.0464210026,
0.0424297899,
0.0298907924,
0.065205954,
0.0104255006,
0.0017474147,
-0.0065427832,
0.0228619818,
0.0110606002,
-0.0103230886,
0.0282290429,
-0.0445441566,
-0.0257380251,
0.0172526278,
0.022411542,
-0.0053882794,
0.0272638891,
-0.0224449988,
0.0119351419,
-0.017387839,
-0.0183886439,
0.0055032023,
-0.0067804973,
0.0342729986,
-0.038161736,
0.0860311985,
-0.0222635027,
0.0363351777,
-0.0120426053,
0.0238393415,
0.0086890515,
-0.0037392096,
-0.0411542021,
-0.038389165,
-0.0364930108,
-0.0310159083,
0.0220518634,
0.0242818613,
-0.0009993942,
0.0318188705,
-0.0449884422,
-0.0696561337,
-0.1000184715,
0.0156084551,
0.0289189816,
-0.0144017283,
-0.0009320903,
0.003707716,
-0.0388147347,
0.0177255645,
-0.0281665716,
-0.0146182636,
0.0057858708,
0.0104184505,
0.0158066731,
0.0006190379,
-0.0233010352,
-0.0304364096,
0.0027554648,
-0.0393131413,
0.0138452491,
-0.0203931257,
0.0598114207,
0.0147622861,
0.0156095913,
-0.0678149387,
-0.0059223757,
-0.0154444408,
-0.0542967543,
-0.0132539896,
-0.0021103064,
0.026822947,
0.0611933023,
0.0572793633,
0.0262518525,
0.0062566423,
0.0036753332,
-0.0137689887,
0.0052681933,
-0.0125192031,
-0.0463295579,
-0.0393494479,
-0.0777877793,
-0.0338460989,
0.024181189,
0.0385424197,
0.0214201882,
-0.0346640721,
0.0215040464,
0.0403946154,
-0.0199338626,
0.0560720377,
0.0367908888,
-0.0279499963,
0.0265826657,
0.0114983721,
0.0210623071,
0.0787802637,
-0.007676241,
0.0050890613,
-0.0372758768,
-0.0340229571,
-0.0318675935,
0.0398467369,
0.0214399304,
-0.0178615637,
0.0661380962,
0.0070446776,
-0.013710781,
-0.0697872639,
0.0212698337,
-0.0541581437,
0.0122772614,
-0.0034367328,
-0.0453790538,
0.0393764973,
-0.0230823271,
-0.0379816443,
-0.0694685653,
-0.0283430647,
-0.0166123081,
0.0399987176,
0.0159392748,
-0.0540804118,
-0.0395235457,
0.0243605953,
-0.0208134986,
-0.0382550359,
-0.0129396869,
0.0063351067,
0.0004284474,
0.0643466786,
0.000683259,
0.0165996086,
-0.068195343,
0.0239255894,
-0.0100254426,
-0.0617280491,
0.03153852,
-0.0012969333,
0.016150156,
-0.0094746174,
0.0204897299,
-0.0053305696,
0.0326398276,
0.0009166294,
-0.0188753102,
0.000182858,
0.142290324,
0.0296030808,
0.0009771578,
0.02032586,
-0.0066315588,
0.0188363269,
0.0397410728,
0.0326391123,
-0.0413646437,
-0.04293577,
-0.0207958408,
0.0314623043,
-0.0451138206,
-0.0326809213,
-0.0017298026,
-0.111547336,
0.0571802706,
0.0026315541,
0.0065723788,
-0.0237238109,
-0.0237828288,
0.0199021921,
-0.0254201591,
0.0030469925,
-0.0342639498,
0.0128478538,
-0.0064758253,
-0.0123077445,
-0.058164876,
-0.0173615739,
0.1176266298,
-0.0135375326,
0.0456535518,
0.0348651372,
0.0469787642,
-0.0105899032,
-0.012992179,
-0.0803288892,
0.0352891758,
-0.0077494048,
0.0218493957,
0.0567672215,
-0.0124065103,
0.0142885223,
-0.0753720999,
0.0416260026,
0.0045532049,
0.0326882638,
0.0356128141,
0.0317237414,
0.0046727844,
-0.0587834455,
-0.0030630173,
0.069395341,
0.0388369858,
0.0514055118,
-0.0236430373,
-0.087775968,
0.0250879284,
0.0078583807,
-0.0293945074,
-0.0054881885,
-0.0940729827,
-0.0222969539,
0.0278143547,
0.0187051464,
-0.0461651608,
-0.0535022914,
0.0182192177,
-0.001233928,
-0.0194813497,
-0.0230573211,
-0.0138783948,
0.03720624,
-0.0328788348,
0.0081132967,
-0.0126307579,
0.0222524051,
-0.0333966687,
-0.0037560435,
0.1001299694,
-0.0548692755,
-0.0162839107,
0.0466606058,
-0.0682475716,
-0.024579756,
0.0179539472,
0.0354580916,
0.0048776409,
-0.010297819,
0.0314284526,
-0.0365553871,
0.005703236,
0.0636065677,
-0.0192027297,
0.0445331745,
-0.0173187498,
0.0387135297,
0.012539966,
0.0095921857,
-0.0183344353,
0.0441064164,
0.0079590082,
-0.0263084192,
-0.0230945107,
-0.1060426682,
-0.003978285,
0.0536467843,
-0.0152742127,
0.0024817714,
-0.0070760939,
-0.0164611395,
-0.0167334098,
-0.0300322026,
-0.0392732732,
-0.0000017798,
-0.0455844961,
0.0186971482,
-0.0039468221,
-0.0001048254,
-0.0542977117,
-0.0156722162,
-0.0207650866,
-0.0571689568,
-0.006118882,
0.013300485,
0.0026065984,
-0.0217430945,
0.0074680406,
-0.0047038742,
-0.0175741296,
0.0252432786,
0.0509350263,
-0.0049654851,
0.0916863978,
-0.0233472642,
0.0245341845,
-0.040117871,
0.0099119572,
-0.0122907097,
-0.0658125877,
-0.0297422446,
0.0014368452,
0.000934277,
-0.0141903916,
-0.0013201192,
-0.0459968597,
0.0168281179,
-0.0335098319,
0.0504756384,
-0.0147338593,
-0.0502644591,
0.0352451131,
0.0165419038,
-0.0063486034,
-0.0318025015,
0.0311096441,
0.0416854583,
0.0038995924,
0.01872834,
-0.046175845,
-0.0627404749,
0.0031004006,
0.0251737963,
0.0517824031,
-0.0360620022,
-0.0136494972,
-0.0811446309,
-0.0847487524,
0.0503687747,
-0.0318785831,
-0.0077767284,
-0.01385694,
0.0196316298,
0.018742254,
-0.0257537123,
-0.0230844393,
-0.0736662149,
-0.0039874744,
-0.0184709672,
-0.0033865792,
-0.0216817297,
-6.59500673e-33,
-0.0423849523,
-0.0131131317,
0.0181795638,
0.0210332554,
-0.0058281715,
-0.0463885814,
-0.0060572149,
0.034850169,
-0.018096799,
-0.0060713151,
-0.016402036,
0.0017901426,
0.0022414934,
-0.0029445505,
0.0274709146,
0.015779756,
0.0237626713,
-0.0315012969,
-0.0236182846,
0.0056728041,
-0.003573694,
0.0061138161,
0.0397359803,
-0.0797404051,
-0.0167516712,
-0.0094669517,
-0.0165307596,
0.0047432338,
-0.0289416742,
0.0694355071,
0.010811761,
0.0537547842,
0.0267476737,
-0.0261458084,
0.0026084601,
0.017588798,
-0.0575954132,
-0.0355353057,
0.0120764254,
0.0024807493,
-0.0072186799,
-0.0239644479,
-0.0047616577,
-0.0071563818,
0.0045153508,
-0.043284215,
0.056579899,
-0.0258202404,
0.0313046537,
0.0308651086,
-0.0080327643,
-0.0320442058,
-0.0680208281,
-0.0204451717,
-0.0227263477,
0.0345138945,
-0.0219349526,
0.0222954191,
-0.0518637747,
0.0522247329,
-0.0143077318,
-0.008555077,
-0.0213330239,
0.0181343909,
0.0121113509,
0.042599488,
0.0498011261,
0.0242623724,
0.0126266079,
-0.0452016853,
0.0332698822,
0.050293684,
-0.0103042647,
0.0621349476,
-0.0163551159,
-0.0683538914,
-0.0297124665,
-0.0025275869,
0.1089736521,
-0.0550750457,
0.0618685223,
0.0037186451,
-0.036694359,
-0.0476274639,
-0.0322257318,
0.0110108033,
-0.0370941721,
-0.0263802279,
0.0243849531,
-0.0075678374,
-0.0195913725,
-0.0117191654,
0.04043689,
-0.0289209094,
0.0071833092,
0.0492118895,
-0.0667598248,
0.0242504869,
-0.0339949168,
-0.0256985407,
-0.0633085147,
0.009566769,
0.0020672751,
-0.0211767294,
0.0547317192,
0.0192085281,
0.007235304,
0.0043901871,
-0.0737236887,
-0.0219122544,
0.0279204249,
0.0095382249,
0.0197587647,
0.0475183129,
-0.0284310747,
0.0062158224,
-0.0047619864,
0.031303063,
0.0046101236,
0.0102088507,
-0.0549416579,
-0.0371016189,
0.0284669902,
-0.0234811716,
-0.0060295817,
0.0051914193,
-0.0681399181,
-0.0118406266,
0.0416913889,
0.0106055802,
-0.002660875,
-0.0153254215,
3.105e-7,
-0.0300096683,
0.0746575668,
-0.0656657815,
0.0468749888,
0.0100717749,
0.0839474574,
0.0229692608,
0.0124638723,
0.0783210322,
-0.0009626301,
0.0516139343,
0.0291110184,
0.0476186574,
0.0189835206,
-0.0668719858,
0.0149260899,
-0.0099732224,
-0.0201152489,
-0.0448886305,
-0.0145712839,
0.0419145003,
0.1010718197,
0.0385577306,
-0.0016184269,
0.0086576268,
0.0440989658,
0.0316938832,
-0.0104052331,
-0.0425883979,
0.0806422159,
-0.0307401698,
-0.0065923962,
-0.0009254973,
0.0572497845,
0.0090773413,
0.0083974972,
-0.0188964531,
0.0854183957,
-0.0067797564,
-0.0275121778,
-0.006542624,
0.0563129224,
-0.020420447,
-0.0185862351,
0.0310757812,
-0.0262936093,
-0.0552588254,
-0.0305079054,
-0.0379968807,
-0.0379249081,
0.0480149649,
-0.0043642656,
-0.0107320929,
0.0364978425,
0.0045006042,
-0.0109411366,
-0.0050542438,
-0.0341633148,
0.025167184,
0.0280454252,
-0.0559025742,
-0.0436316431,
0.0145378737,
0.0021735358,
0.0094123231,
-0.0497406758,
0.0460427888,
2.961346465e-34,
-0.0069501735,
0.048025921,
0.0237290878,
-0.0190194622,
0.0818099156,
0.0151940305,
0.0046986276,
0.0326338336,
0.0133122383,
-0.0630996376,
-0.0241291206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17283v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17283v1 | A Recursive Encoding for Cuneiform Signs | 2024-06-25T05:18:12 | 2024-06-25T05:18:12 | Daniel M. Stelzer | cs.CL | cs.CL | One of the most significant problems in cuneiform pedagogy is the process of
looking up unknown signs, which often involves a tedious page-by-page search
through a sign list. This paper proposes a new "recursive encoding" for signs,
which represents the arrangement of strokes in a way a computer can process. A
series of new algorithms then offers students a new way to look up signs by any
distinctive component, as well as providing new ways to render signs and
tablets electronically. | [
-0.0441779532,
-0.007900795,
-0.0590653494,
0.0230282247,
-0.0257909819,
-0.0065359897,
0.0248815622,
0.0560250953,
0.0354124159,
-0.014715788,
0.0588081479,
-0.0551668219,
0.0302992053,
-0.0115451487,
0.0098073324,
-0.0811053962,
-0.0119333547,
-0.0081097409,
-0.0178767797,
0.0012238247,
-0.0496427119,
-0.0082920333,
-0.0271357056,
-0.0188139752,
-0.0573949479,
-0.0757557973,
-0.0539390631,
-0.0091217263,
0.0244894903,
-0.0296189003,
-0.0875242501,
0.0183609761,
0.0336172245,
0.0447689034,
0.0000016129,
-0.0487675145,
-0.0313870013,
-0.0099454243,
0.0148218349,
0.0246460754,
0.0255055185,
-0.074325107,
-0.0627485886,
-0.054322388,
0.0014815989,
-0.0085531408,
0.0656840801,
0.0473077931,
0.0310653243,
0.040000625,
0.0037289448,
-0.0529507585,
0.0296298005,
0.0059597227,
0.0139139714,
0.0629442483,
0.0031013836,
-0.0160619933,
0.0141028361,
0.0415971056,
-0.0381675884,
0.0517291948,
0.0076585175,
-0.032102529,
-0.0594350025,
-0.0178231746,
0.0128846383,
0.0099649113,
-0.0216753688,
-0.0276418868,
-0.0827944428,
-0.0141976085,
0.0195821207,
0.010345947,
-0.0159467645,
-0.031496197,
-0.0279636607,
0.0441595651,
-0.0610569268,
-0.0206681937,
-0.0132998871,
-0.0041823899,
-0.0017361954,
-0.0302110948,
-0.0027736623,
0.0172170848,
0.0407494903,
-0.0203989632,
-0.0353470221,
-0.010309645,
0.0326339863,
-0.0253742281,
0.0448771417,
0.0474547036,
0.0145049999,
0.0025297883,
-0.0003150725,
-0.0286607854,
-0.007024298,
-0.0094316434,
0.0571776181,
0.0723550171,
0.0420581028,
0.0351522751,
-0.029709775,
0.0430562906,
-0.0165408868,
0.034529034,
-0.0061245603,
0.0753787383,
-0.0047599203,
-0.032223165,
-0.0874737203,
-0.0310681965,
0.0214620121,
0.0063033123,
-0.019035032,
0.0083316676,
0.0510497577,
-0.0027812344,
0.0166436434,
-0.0188149884,
0.0607487671,
-0.0121644316,
0.008153311,
-0.0154616805,
-0.0270400941,
-0.0117066083,
-0.0499918908,
0.0179774463,
0.0318777226,
0.0032636065,
0.0397171639,
0.0408186391,
0.0022406259,
0.0334339663,
0.0019315504,
0.0056522889,
0.0027345924,
0.0320501961,
0.0224905796,
0.0267890133,
0.0418650284,
-0.0139859887,
-0.010202379,
-0.0194154307,
0.0025139414,
-0.018052645,
0.0042458409,
0.0245621987,
0.0439462885,
-0.0051291534,
-0.0153244184,
0.0307518058,
0.0237430856,
0.0333975144,
-0.0268042665,
-0.0246027131,
0.0782167166,
0.068224974,
0.0140039809,
-0.0440578386,
-0.003439531,
0.0088773593,
0.0010977235,
-0.0247975681,
-0.0212682523,
-0.066530697,
0.0510491654,
0.0580653697,
-0.0931590796,
0.015466271,
-0.0224211104,
-0.02031333,
-0.0100716911,
0.0342338458,
0.0670377091,
0.031727042,
0.0046030357,
-0.0037465217,
0.0539519861,
-0.0262537915,
-0.01430964,
0.0333341509,
0.0716062486,
-0.0403649546,
-0.0627484322,
0.0307458229,
0.0053397878,
-0.0227870867,
0.007466373,
-0.0103280246,
0.0465634838,
-0.0298990197,
0.0447848737,
0.0350395329,
-0.0493337177,
-0.0680843145,
-0.0067783338,
0.0025615531,
-0.0199618731,
-0.0074481177,
0.0596157201,
0.0568406321,
0.0406841636,
-0.0321406089,
0.0586803555,
0.03737133,
0.0046451134,
0.0423422232,
-0.0557580628,
-0.0128821665,
0.0188577361,
-0.0410597287,
-0.025942523,
0.0516955405,
0.0020623202,
0.0429871529,
-0.0182623807,
0.0776904002,
0.0041258987,
0.0220908727,
-0.0066117253,
0.0254358519,
0.0172923617,
-0.0258155167,
-0.0185221806,
0.0416754335,
-0.0481466167,
0.0439811237,
0.0198197663,
0.0133699803,
0.0528062955,
-0.0751871392,
-0.0373415798,
-0.0374033749,
-0.046536915,
0.0442504063,
0.0522441305,
-0.0741066933,
-0.0257855263,
0.0013075521,
0.0415918976,
-0.0155920656,
0.055081699,
-0.0241102073,
0.0899172127,
0.0360262468,
0.0191533174,
-0.0316075049,
-0.0259353183,
0.0133119216,
0.0475590453,
0.0036168415,
0.0124410326,
0.0171110816,
-0.0611549839,
-0.0123148514,
-0.0215520188,
0.0188893266,
0.0089019798,
0.0012346111,
-0.001378548,
-0.0605271272,
0.0384432413,
0.0281672068,
0.0084810592,
-0.0487180017,
-0.0301947705,
-0.0033872048,
0.0151339946,
0.0149168381,
-0.0563282967,
0.0202244092,
-0.0486106537,
-0.0481766984,
-0.0138954278,
-0.0242202319,
-0.0378028713,
0.0113984738,
-0.0479672551,
-0.0611568354,
0.009853486,
-0.037132889,
-0.028097989,
-0.0104357637,
0.0419716984,
-0.0760121644,
-0.0562271625,
-0.0455502048,
0.0120933997,
0.0082306918,
-0.0091481628,
-0.0088746455,
0.0342630073,
0.0004379113,
-0.0901486054,
0.0432258137,
-0.0079031764,
0.0120051,
-0.028561689,
-0.0234724917,
0.018529065,
-0.0101483203,
0.013427184,
0.0496981554,
0.0190243442,
-0.0799660459,
0.0050256085,
0.0116354441,
-0.013210237,
0.0334085226,
-0.0398781747,
-0.0232960731,
0.004600605,
0.0148651591,
-0.013451566,
-0.0275431778,
0.003302553,
0.0158808865,
-0.0350760035,
-0.0053030849,
0.0262996126,
-0.0285362974,
-0.0280178618,
0.0340030752,
0.0507455915,
-0.0488529392,
0.0437286012,
0.0200026147,
0.0366893448,
-0.0226715077,
-0.0376181453,
-0.0210106019,
0.1176825166,
0.0382575616,
-0.0485950671,
-0.0138198277,
0.0297754742,
-0.0290163234,
-0.0356029086,
0.0189488642,
-0.0074169026,
0.0352846421,
0.0285402797,
-0.0339350738,
0.0488023609,
-0.0339429267,
-0.0553734191,
0.03506542,
-0.0020992158,
-0.0089256372,
0.0401273295,
0.0387818515,
-0.0078559658,
-0.0080788732,
-0.0166552346,
-0.0071512638,
-0.0359176137,
0.0050229579,
0.007024894,
0.0330828987,
-0.0245196763,
-0.0232309662,
-0.0190154724,
0.0403050408,
0.0168245342,
0.0212661158,
-0.0290136617,
-0.0358598717,
-0.0100972438,
-0.028927736,
0.0555053242,
-0.0059260582,
0.0298889782,
-0.0186945889,
0.030350361,
0.0313347131,
-0.0814427882,
-0.0007033452,
-0.0137748383,
-0.073155269,
0.0237366222,
-0.0157766659,
0.0003470362,
0.0164344031,
-0.0130500542,
0.0308611244,
-0.0257019047,
-0.0165947732,
0.0283126142,
-0.0901076719,
-0.0084413532,
-0.0094130887,
0.0238465369,
0.0568491966,
-0.0910919383,
0.0416434221,
-0.0070935921,
-0.0045130132,
0.0172552895,
0.0396412574,
0.0552733988,
-0.0463935994,
0.0379974209,
-0.0610668026,
0.0153490826,
0.0197921041,
0.0324979685,
-0.0579495914,
-0.0454202443,
-0.0092314286,
0.0437760241,
-0.0217046961,
-0.0188827924,
0.03935818,
-0.0255365148,
-0.0293100774,
-0.0133759622,
-0.0764335319,
-0.0145906983,
0.0292710792,
0.0223329123,
0.0249943212,
0.0185446311,
-0.0017664828,
-0.0588421337,
0.0103148613,
-0.0219380613,
-0.0360311158,
-0.0031457604,
-0.0203401987,
-0.0599549487,
0.0633523315,
0.0525407344,
-0.1389086843,
0.0098361345,
0.0031470782,
-0.0347845741,
-0.0457494222,
0.0086823534,
0.028288478,
0.0731393173,
0.063191779,
-0.0092706643,
0.0450998209,
-0.0162961185,
-0.065971069,
-0.0519594513,
0.0219259951,
0.0564881749,
-0.0699836761,
-0.0226718467,
-0.0742029473,
-0.0223977789,
0.009363343,
0.0275951698,
-0.0370063595,
-0.038694486,
0.0162850544,
0.0630206168,
0.0266914014,
-0.0694527924,
0.0089799799,
-0.0033297227,
-0.0060412674,
0.0061766896,
0.0956544057,
0.0190761443,
-0.0251242742,
-0.0588062182,
-0.0051608398,
-0.0139652612,
0.0152273625,
-0.0025522115,
0.0180065352,
0.0068140379,
-0.076713115,
0.0033032233,
-0.0383221097,
-0.0257471427,
-0.0320417285,
-0.0366274416,
-0.0291717909,
0.001541245,
0.0208535884,
-0.0716469139,
0.0002234553,
-0.01275553,
0.0390758701,
-0.029617101,
-0.0259696562,
0.0150093855,
-0.0315486193,
0.0482893251,
-0.0127833718,
-0.0034120108,
0.0559367128,
0.0008164814,
0.0338216983,
0.0129178129,
0.0273809731,
0.0198117401,
0.0833781287,
-0.0258960966,
0.0669852644,
0.0118496316,
-0.0026959032,
-0.0078113885,
-0.0187180694,
0.0137447668,
0.0141541176,
0.0273722727,
-0.1111883819,
-0.0014086544,
0.0246995036,
0.0357373729,
0.0082000233,
0.0285999738,
-0.0097777396,
0.0149409631,
0.0009035181,
-0.0035961564,
0.011283705,
-0.0382147916,
-0.0388447829,
0.011374929,
0.0286162365,
-0.0551819615,
0.0229915883,
-0.0932882801,
-0.0083543509,
0.0134694828,
-0.0505511351,
-0.0073568295,
-0.0125346519,
0.0230833627,
-0.0274006147,
-0.0154765341,
-0.0122907795,
-0.0404362604,
-0.0210293736,
0.069324553,
0.0254873224,
0.0034294238,
0.0088900691,
0.0444518179,
-0.0451191515,
0.0173065215,
-0.0024458684,
0.0168649461,
0.031009417,
-0.0729066357,
-0.0215992481,
-0.0185454395,
-4.760817875e-33,
-0.0344637409,
-0.0192166027,
0.0078659514,
-0.0359463021,
-0.0073243231,
-0.0071165254,
0.0017382229,
0.061822854,
0.0195841342,
-0.0307101849,
0.0103166522,
-0.0059891264,
0.0142596075,
-0.0066651045,
0.031985648,
0.0264209639,
0.0259067528,
0.016864473,
-0.0410797819,
-0.0052431161,
0.044613231,
0.0225308314,
0.0799075142,
-0.0691042915,
-0.0181193426,
-0.0477089137,
0.0154968621,
-0.0037009511,
-0.0221984815,
0.0059419987,
-0.0071643563,
-0.0201295037,
0.0235154349,
0.0305383448,
0.0481795557,
0.0103911599,
-0.0571711399,
-0.0309198331,
-0.0315802582,
0.0976774618,
-0.0207562018,
-0.0134820174,
-0.0401424505,
-0.0310214814,
-0.0009739127,
0.0234177019,
0.0215538256,
-0.0139283258,
-0.0350292139,
0.0117309606,
-0.0204363186,
0.0013839115,
-0.0049049854,
-0.0435586795,
-0.0243368186,
-0.0106819384,
0.0204534177,
-0.0308509544,
-0.0809827819,
0.0547797345,
-0.0158205554,
-0.0032342849,
0.0220817793,
-0.029709151,
0.0294360705,
0.0180027802,
0.0410616025,
0.0047190986,
0.0033376338,
0.0091972556,
0.0207171869,
-0.0158850756,
0.0223129578,
0.0015123721,
0.0492659137,
-0.0232266188,
-0.0005587668,
-0.0053926059,
0.0117939962,
0.0337471254,
-0.0096173771,
0.0390300751,
-0.0340630189,
-0.0293090027,
0.044449985,
-0.0324974433,
0.0447404422,
-0.0087191099,
-0.0042283013,
0.0392808132,
0.0175854471,
0.0410853699,
-0.0369001739,
-0.0189863425,
-0.0015131917,
-0.0107036103,
0.0145851308,
0.0528433099,
-0.0075004133,
-0.0217513423,
0.0290354956,
-0.042721428,
0.0285484437,
-0.0524739958,
0.0326399803,
0.0183155127,
-0.0183534212,
0.0442284234,
-0.0208598934,
0.0181513485,
0.0201068763,
-0.0271132514,
0.0383229889,
-0.0541153848,
0.0466506518,
-0.0135558331,
0.0177334249,
-0.0027458419,
0.0489382334,
-0.0087237777,
0.0165573917,
0.0018438019,
-0.0343966857,
-0.0286937449,
0.0048882496,
-0.0137395989,
-0.0172042493,
0.0057603,
0.0319532305,
-0.0905701816,
-0.009346257,
-0.0048991088,
2.353e-7,
0.0182015486,
0.0240090135,
0.0642724484,
0.0724033415,
0.046591714,
-0.0115054706,
-0.0276022889,
-0.0217145886,
0.0358101092,
-0.0154047394,
0.0363259502,
0.0017037496,
0.0172554161,
0.0017793195,
-0.0341819748,
0.0473349094,
0.008444625,
-0.0419695564,
-0.0287453476,
0.0551614277,
0.0689233392,
0.0214814525,
0.0123313544,
-0.0365899131,
-0.0234401617,
-0.00121271,
0.0080479356,
0.0124114528,
0.0680157244,
-0.0465244427,
-0.0200665817,
-0.0725900307,
-0.0349547155,
-0.0003706233,
0.0109857246,
0.0113782063,
0.0519781187,
-0.0163408928,
-0.0315603726,
0.1304175556,
0.0340402536,
-0.0129170613,
-0.0259713177,
0.0421859175,
0.0149881775,
0.0867552012,
0.0439851061,
0.0085346755,
0.0201314632,
0.0214383285,
-0.0146600641,
0.0094642797,
0.0140977232,
0.028540343,
0.0168565921,
-0.0177220944,
0.0628979877,
-0.0009166382,
0.0006122632,
-0.0297652297,
-0.0122013967,
0.0067596263,
-0.0242262036,
0.0014522679,
-0.0040575792,
0.000920954,
-0.0697214752,
1.855640892e-34,
-0.0015052014,
-0.0440095887,
0.040871378,
0.0227218457,
-0.0219716914,
-0.0097199911,
0.0671806335,
-0.0083262818,
0.0352762416,
-0.0047519482,
-0.0300601088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17282v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17282v2 | SetBERT: Enhancing Retrieval Performance for Boolean Logic and Set Operation Queries | 2024-06-25T05:14:54 | 2024-06-26T14:38:31 | Quan Mai, Susan Gauch, Douglas Adams | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce SetBERT, a fine-tuned BERT-based model designed to enhance query
embeddings for set operations and Boolean logic queries, such as Intersection
(AND), Difference (NOT), and Union (OR). SetBERT significantly improves
retrieval performance for logic-structured queries, an area where both
traditional and neural retrieval methods typically underperform. We propose an
innovative use of inversed-contrastive loss, focusing on identifying the
negative sentence, and fine-tuning BERT with a dataset generated via prompt
GPT. Furthermore, we demonstrate that, unlike other BERT-based models,
fine-tuning with triplet loss actually degrades performance for this specific
task. Our experiments reveal that SetBERT-base not only significantly
outperforms BERT-base (up to a 63% improvement in Recall) but also achieves
performance comparable to the much larger BERT-large model, despite being only
one-third the size. | [
-0.018698357,
0.0621614382,
-0.0241101943,
0.017543979,
-0.0617529675,
-0.0066932556,
-0.0144786257,
0.0127282739,
0.0087751029,
-0.033465635,
-0.0079639982,
-0.0020285845,
-0.0403837971,
0.0326918103,
0.0474658459,
0.0014796149,
0.0823523551,
0.0534154065,
0.0160742346,
-0.0125090154,
0.0163828656,
0.0002499197,
-0.0130211506,
0.0302637797,
-0.0150760971,
0.000046965,
-0.0178704113,
0.0588585623,
0.0157369673,
-0.0413310789,
0.0240853075,
0.0651380345,
0.0094577819,
0.0484504178,
0.0000016343,
-0.0314086005,
-0.034361016,
-0.0129017262,
0.0119684422,
-0.0038472328,
-0.0084227286,
0.01710416,
0.0133735137,
0.0413484387,
-0.0164347738,
0.0121490834,
0.0336025283,
0.0436624549,
0.0778463408,
0.0826143697,
0.006029896,
-0.0025279883,
0.0146704214,
-0.0394483842,
0.0153269172,
0.0083435867,
0.0106732128,
-0.0704924464,
0.006053383,
-0.0125014428,
0.0251822583,
0.0286625698,
0.0449734814,
0.0189650506,
-0.0133846691,
0.0281600133,
-0.1192360371,
0.0229171179,
0.0142029859,
0.0493453592,
0.0059325052,
-0.021649003,
-0.0141835297,
0.0031333396,
0.0226768311,
-0.035883639,
-0.0199705977,
-0.0135633973,
-0.0007502857,
0.0089309439,
-0.0590142719,
-0.0234918781,
0.0327017419,
0.0177062079,
-0.0324458741,
0.0226699263,
0.0486081839,
-0.0453783348,
0.0179631729,
-0.0062924935,
-0.0446404181,
0.0054310118,
0.0533231087,
-0.001693268,
0.0108382907,
-0.0040703118,
-0.0091674086,
-0.0319665633,
0.0418595076,
-0.0390136503,
-0.0020160002,
0.0641393289,
-0.0412651375,
0.0289353784,
-0.0587485619,
0.0394344293,
-0.0003574092,
0.0824941695,
-0.0149855698,
-0.0112630278,
-0.0514761284,
-0.049180828,
-0.0905914977,
0.0610710382,
-0.0135008367,
0.0195840336,
0.0043770825,
-0.0400369242,
-0.0350021459,
-0.0063141044,
-0.0001489036,
0.0164528303,
-0.0290095322,
-0.0119928643,
-0.0407510661,
0.0419603623,
-0.0731573999,
-0.0027715706,
0.0176991634,
-0.0259527937,
-0.0306089558,
-0.0074351672,
-0.0119526777,
-0.015638832,
0.0341047235,
0.0207004827,
-0.0196747202,
-0.0464674346,
-0.027340075,
-0.0108907335,
0.0216652788,
-0.0328622647,
0.0280647185,
-0.0296658222,
0.0307014603,
-0.0134171974,
-0.0151938228,
-0.0355465822,
0.0228521712,
0.0491369367,
0.0361783952,
0.0581302978,
0.0187230762,
-0.0553115718,
0.0114494283,
0.0041196216,
0.0124211507,
0.0613467656,
0.0054749944,
0.0276273359,
0.0118382294,
0.0355290882,
-0.0392419472,
-0.0110931545,
0.0911860242,
-0.0028871836,
-0.1016819775,
0.0121692186,
-0.0187927037,
0.0570203513,
-0.0323041566,
0.0671219453,
-0.0476146638,
-0.0479802676,
0.0232224911,
-0.0061569829,
0.0051950025,
0.0039027319,
-0.0394510813,
0.005579113,
-0.0155758355,
-0.0322929099,
-0.0485953316,
0.0238112453,
-0.0437769182,
-0.0087941242,
-0.0083677666,
-0.0185902044,
-0.0236756522,
-0.014149826,
0.0136727681,
0.0058096275,
0.0148442229,
-0.0174964406,
0.0383777842,
-0.0183450412,
-0.0757011697,
0.0880412236,
0.0067731529,
-0.0950423554,
0.0028432631,
-0.0424545184,
-0.0094384933,
0.0228802152,
0.0382066257,
-0.0745396167,
-0.0531075783,
0.0110354489,
-0.0237622578,
0.03365428,
0.0057258243,
0.0202449784,
0.0200844947,
-0.0531009994,
-0.0075387871,
0.001136097,
0.0187898744,
0.0178666785,
0.0373300388,
0.0112338932,
0.0194880851,
-0.0537768565,
0.0355261788,
0.0272046868,
-0.0135365538,
-0.0344849862,
0.0056551672,
0.0332714841,
-0.0209610425,
0.0113308895,
-0.0004670983,
0.037480969,
0.0282776263,
-0.0348107405,
-0.0832830593,
-0.0315081626,
-0.0569921881,
-0.0596395954,
0.0375427529,
-0.0548431501,
-0.0239074286,
0.0927577019,
-0.0396686681,
-0.0307821687,
-0.0295108631,
-0.0767857283,
0.0537899658,
-0.0564376749,
-0.0158989597,
0.0147967646,
-0.0565138645,
-0.0551737174,
0.0758592635,
-0.0585299283,
0.0230526514,
-0.0379053093,
0.0028038961,
0.066927515,
-0.0405410193,
-0.035648793,
0.0102467388,
-0.0224632416,
0.0373863801,
0.0250478834,
0.0109231109,
-0.0635338426,
-0.0025561848,
-0.0752048269,
0.0337409899,
-0.0077921208,
0.0040422766,
0.0083446028,
-0.005620488,
0.0108724535,
-0.0322341062,
-0.0337656625,
-0.0072302357,
-0.0184276458,
0.0524429642,
0.0286799315,
0.0276592672,
-0.0262956452,
-0.0160943344,
-0.0515677929,
-0.0507326312,
0.0015908786,
-0.0454894602,
0.0114729609,
0.0452378988,
0.019607177,
-0.0240842309,
0.0315316804,
-0.0067292033,
-0.055008892,
0.0252382848,
-0.0574168637,
-0.0111697605,
0.0522847436,
0.0071078246,
0.001209729,
0.018663412,
-0.0079913884,
-0.0430928618,
0.0594104752,
-0.0231193565,
0.0105109755,
0.0223427173,
-0.0165043995,
-0.0181496684,
0.0107717952,
0.0040602861,
0.0038879828,
-0.1021581888,
-0.0191201456,
0.0036338102,
-0.0150428396,
-0.0605635867,
0.039656274,
-0.0081009762,
0.0228738301,
-0.0465330742,
-0.0289412066,
0.0691981018,
0.039780356,
0.0030198528,
-0.0326766074,
0.0346060209,
-0.0058322921,
0.0661795437,
-0.003847257,
0.0197930802,
0.0142765846,
-0.0534958057,
-0.0694678873,
-0.0584434234,
0.0421056375,
-0.0460935682,
0.0177422687,
-0.0197946951,
0.0057261549,
-0.0092923157,
-0.0646181777,
-0.0389459915,
-0.0185560491,
0.0233791824,
0.0432386734,
-0.0110416142,
-0.0258241352,
-0.0736616477,
-0.0398267955,
-0.0113783851,
0.0235980153,
-0.0176889375,
-0.002717826,
-0.01202456,
0.0176282451,
0.010523933,
0.0141186202,
0.0167303793,
-0.0049932543,
-0.0336360112,
0.0435290933,
0.0510986336,
-0.017730834,
0.0122104278,
-0.0120945089,
0.030001007,
-0.0519883931,
-0.0010243779,
-0.0069419569,
0.0022166586,
-0.0664925948,
-0.0310442876,
0.0996163413,
0.0516558662,
0.0193996988,
-0.0321317837,
-0.0498965122,
0.0362589471,
0.0356481671,
0.0014920457,
-0.0486437716,
-0.0371066369,
0.0038408549,
0.0227836818,
0.0143793439,
-0.0084830374,
0.019037392,
-0.1368145496,
-0.0065975883,
-0.0029718641,
-0.0301412158,
-0.0667518899,
-0.0285006315,
-0.0258665625,
-0.017734617,
-0.0092478348,
0.0172344241,
0.0160073433,
-0.0081451358,
0.0083612725,
0.039849326,
-0.0003024988,
0.0147417504,
-0.0346088111,
-0.0216807127,
0.0508399531,
0.0503898337,
-0.0297386274,
-0.0573891141,
0.030281201,
-0.0297667552,
-0.0206549,
-0.0323570482,
0.061119698,
0.0021719376,
-0.0116730342,
-0.0573628284,
0.0081168544,
-0.0343497247,
-0.0327251367,
-0.0325754993,
0.0626494288,
0.0030078711,
0.0439716242,
-0.0486442968,
-0.0106735546,
-0.0261298977,
0.0800826699,
-0.0053729033,
0.0241095312,
-0.030620113,
0.0006942184,
0.048312109,
-0.0606978834,
0.012895721,
0.0003826568,
0.0168573111,
-0.0046422617,
-0.0513196737,
-0.0488126911,
0.0129643707,
0.0544888228,
-0.0247099008,
-0.0054733423,
0.0170723088,
0.014215962,
-0.0687926412,
0.0339852758,
-0.0002639704,
0.015925115,
-0.0352862142,
-0.0051898127,
0.0161177348,
0.0271911658,
-0.0503146052,
-0.0047377148,
-0.0220752098,
-0.0353274643,
-0.0046922131,
0.0243088268,
0.0124796843,
-0.0084285382,
-0.0086225113,
-0.0109194536,
0.0080599124,
0.0955002233,
0.0031625959,
-0.0212894995,
0.0852755755,
-0.0219857804,
-0.0033930624,
0.0538969375,
-0.01682055,
-0.0198032502,
-0.0116383359,
0.0827250853,
-0.0360168777,
0.0064837369,
0.0332694501,
0.0168465022,
0.0557950921,
0.0198003147,
0.0016915898,
-0.0245491471,
0.0523360707,
-0.0292482171,
-0.0107533699,
-0.0135562355,
-0.0086236438,
0.034465082,
-0.032639619,
-0.0267324336,
0.0014899545,
0.004907337,
0.0360394903,
-0.0288421065,
0.0205744058,
0.0287817772,
0.0357937142,
0.009806864,
-0.000503406,
-0.0204455648,
0.0025798678,
0.0258271918,
0.0339957997,
-0.0662694201,
0.0507605299,
0.0547981709,
-0.005215744,
-0.0394520238,
0.0197986085,
-0.0247811954,
-0.013111365,
-0.0093873506,
0.0022312044,
0.0102880755,
-0.0133996494,
-0.0091986144,
-0.0098816482,
-0.0342861824,
-0.0081620915,
-0.0050040861,
0.0270736013,
0.0043293405,
0.0234470405,
0.0293807257,
0.0224267356,
-0.0693919957,
0.0295670889,
-0.0152487047,
0.0864170864,
-0.0095888898,
-0.024694344,
-0.0227045137,
-0.0257190336,
0.0911232233,
0.0480848625,
-0.0047124997,
0.0292174779,
-0.0555725619,
-0.0292765182,
0.0386194326,
0.0334990434,
0.0165259968,
0.0116406074,
0.0715826824,
0.0461154133,
-0.0106327841,
-0.0576902442,
0.0003183687,
0.0436216407,
-0.0325002857,
-0.0169332884,
-0.0226846915,
-5.484374688e-33,
-0.0606947839,
0.0159773342,
0.0126017351,
-0.06013209,
-0.0194815602,
-0.0052341996,
-0.0313114114,
-0.0050690253,
-0.0253609158,
0.0509219356,
-0.0004260922,
0.0600619279,
0.0064309486,
0.0386519171,
-0.0040625893,
-0.0484662354,
0.0619962886,
0.0297427494,
-0.0032867482,
0.0144829815,
0.0376129225,
0.0559618585,
0.0315855145,
-0.0489947721,
-0.0578217655,
-0.0068297912,
-0.0119467936,
0.0519470498,
-0.0260542333,
0.0252936892,
0.0059037604,
0.036599122,
0.0038465753,
-0.011101447,
0.0122124813,
-0.0191885158,
-0.0724425837,
-0.0833378956,
-0.0009581564,
-0.0166813657,
-0.0172245111,
0.0013403946,
0.0283880886,
-0.0095090438,
0.0158925448,
-0.0040823058,
0.0184339918,
-0.0081724143,
-0.0257480051,
-0.0112535944,
-0.0610099398,
0.0091828685,
0.020923743,
-0.040510457,
-0.0214391705,
0.0081137586,
0.0141810225,
0.0157943871,
-0.0352884345,
-0.0277206376,
0.0024676363,
0.0101173203,
-0.0188901275,
0.0204429906,
-0.0262481198,
0.0565973483,
0.0480803885,
0.0217403583,
0.0477376506,
-0.0144313723,
0.0678608939,
0.0396519825,
0.077767849,
0.0589026734,
0.0272863768,
-0.0036291608,
-0.0793747678,
0.017665375,
-0.0059618386,
0.0697419494,
0.0049386155,
0.0372614525,
-0.0448620655,
0.0166174788,
-0.0275501441,
-0.0020428149,
-0.0375130251,
0.0288091768,
0.0476533659,
0.008433125,
-0.0177379809,
0.0086061899,
0.0133726103,
0.0080742184,
0.001137358,
0.0532176979,
0.0050790044,
-0.0328963995,
0.0126660783,
0.0490032658,
-0.0475948788,
-0.0001229867,
0.029066382,
0.0252402462,
-0.0087073175,
-0.0102193356,
0.0702398643,
0.0192827974,
-0.069693841,
-0.0104091922,
-0.0337686054,
-0.0069488301,
-0.0467540063,
-0.0034915146,
0.0030488828,
0.0271104109,
0.0279814377,
0.048674494,
0.0270241704,
-0.019731354,
-0.0643527433,
-0.020177966,
0.0235990882,
0.0102250809,
0.0253076833,
0.0194842294,
-0.0348274633,
0.0061815679,
0.0078528943,
-0.0624014027,
0.0025005692,
-0.0195753258,
2.35e-7,
0.0427087806,
0.0185253285,
0.0386531912,
0.0933188722,
-0.0227140412,
0.0610424764,
-0.0316829197,
0.0252667312,
0.0180704799,
0.032212574,
-0.0010924883,
0.0298601054,
0.0150631526,
0.0246624164,
-0.0145165278,
0.0435525924,
-0.029855134,
-0.0489299409,
-0.030801218,
0.0020804256,
0.1165890917,
0.0835737139,
0.0312922932,
-0.0075874496,
0.0169562437,
-0.0456116349,
0.0649329126,
-0.0070774886,
-0.0110203512,
-0.0253702775,
-0.0032153344,
0.0288132243,
0.0089572417,
0.0131528825,
-0.0167805273,
0.0071797674,
0.0251280367,
0.0423317924,
-0.03344265,
-0.0567811131,
-0.0107933441,
-0.0273298826,
-0.015222528,
-0.0184074491,
0.0500858389,
-0.0193911716,
0.021261543,
0.0307212267,
-0.0333035775,
0.0023091154,
0.0728846043,
-0.0022750522,
-0.0654725283,
-0.0226564743,
0.0145241516,
0.0048348098,
0.0119350646,
-0.0934177712,
-0.0082608713,
0.027726192,
-0.0261441786,
-0.0237398539,
-0.043131467,
0.062352404,
0.0065628542,
-0.0498006307,
-0.0142186852,
2.068238229e-34,
0.0398325361,
-0.001146892,
0.0020567935,
0.0217613913,
0.0570678152,
0.0144678829,
-0.0188169517,
-0.007064491,
0.0325943455,
-0.010799082,
0.002740819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17276v1 | OPT-Tree: Speculative Decoding with Adaptive Draft Tree Structure | 2024-06-25T04:45:53 | 2024-06-25T04:45:53 | Jikai Wang, Yi Su, Juntao Li, Qinrong Xia, Zi Ye, Xinyu Duan, Zhefeng Wang, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Autoregressive language models demonstrate excellent performance in various
scenarios. However, the inference efficiency is limited by its
one-step-one-word generation mode, which has become a pressing problem recently
as the models become increasingly larger. Speculative decoding employs a "draft
and then verify" mechanism to allow multiple tokens to be generated in one
step, realizing lossless acceleration. Existing methods mainly adopt fixed
heuristic draft structures, which fail to adapt to different situations to
maximize the acceptance length during verification. To alleviate this dilemma,
we proposed OPT-Tree, an algorithm to construct adaptive and scalable draft
trees. It searches the optimal tree structure that maximizes the mathematical
expectation of the acceptance length in each decoding step. Experimental
results reveal that OPT-Tree outperforms the existing draft structures and
achieves a speed-up ratio of up to 3.2 compared with autoregressive decoding.
If the draft model is powerful enough and the node budget is sufficient, it can
generate more than ten tokens in a single step. Our code is available at
https://github.com/Jikai0Wang/OPT-Tree. | [
0.042025324,
0.0690727457,
0.0131616537,
-0.0296223089,
-0.0361716561,
-0.0114451889,
-0.0514720157,
0.0299457163,
-0.0485598296,
-0.0138297845,
0.0396177806,
-0.0763890743,
0.0208607428,
0.0369448662,
-0.0144970343,
-0.002756583,
0.0224788729,
-0.0626922026,
0.0489640832,
-0.0362900645,
-0.0225249864,
0.0292522423,
0.021047987,
0.0394541025,
0.0022457843,
-0.0180240143,
-0.0704304054,
0.0223268475,
-0.0500370711,
-0.0521071292,
-0.0269001238,
0.046573054,
-0.0097068064,
0.0413077697,
0.0000024212,
0.0055168839,
-0.0512490198,
0.0058205388,
-0.0542224869,
0.0037613336,
0.0602462776,
-0.0145429978,
-0.0416964255,
0.039428141,
-0.0107603259,
-0.0687981397,
0.0443412513,
-0.0216329806,
-0.0150210876,
0.0684986562,
-0.012756383,
-0.0355183072,
0.0130979437,
-0.0078138513,
-0.0380415246,
-0.0538811423,
0.0069283405,
-0.0614782386,
-0.0263542552,
0.0121399034,
-0.0170429237,
-0.0110514602,
0.0396944061,
0.0061048875,
-0.0199134089,
0.0262266304,
0.0060382169,
-0.0380279124,
-0.0334723368,
0.0155508025,
-0.0171749406,
-0.081585221,
0.0073299832,
-0.0028101192,
-0.0440214463,
-0.0246657822,
-0.0236605927,
0.0333787277,
-0.0555456989,
0.0118328109,
0.0584869348,
0.0101519777,
0.0416073538,
0.0027939365,
-0.045068197,
0.1061672941,
0.0328966714,
-0.0359078608,
-0.0295283776,
-0.0069771167,
0.0210291278,
-0.0601424538,
0.0253651049,
0.0103269564,
-0.0533697978,
0.0121187447,
-0.0646020919,
-0.0480142199,
0.0106199691,
-0.0275352504,
0.0213856436,
0.044092983,
0.0230132006,
-0.0048074457,
-0.0355285294,
-0.0154021187,
0.009112156,
-0.0236752126,
-0.0349246711,
-0.0011423852,
0.0199103877,
-0.0050965361,
-0.0895068645,
0.0350846089,
-0.0445978977,
-0.0490277559,
-0.0027145057,
0.0200169738,
0.0502519794,
0.0015754248,
0.0437852181,
-0.0105100023,
-0.017697705,
-0.0152174514,
0.0644927919,
-0.01793647,
-0.0211777762,
-0.0084578395,
0.0059693996,
-0.0353231467,
-0.0103079118,
0.0300322119,
0.0218345728,
0.0101311654,
-0.0264514983,
0.0551856197,
0.0016340892,
-0.0056872438,
-0.0163024813,
-0.0418120809,
0.0052125929,
-0.0301048048,
-0.0017824789,
-0.0493737124,
0.0219640974,
0.0048117368,
-0.0080905156,
-0.0092952913,
-0.0160064343,
0.0144820912,
0.0075335517,
0.0305068288,
-0.0493040755,
0.0268087331,
-0.0075134435,
-0.0089994418,
0.0195584074,
0.0846391171,
0.0552280694,
0.0617907867,
0.0370973796,
-0.0088411914,
-0.02571618,
0.071239002,
0.0400732309,
-0.0086157927,
0.0263927728,
-0.0284903329,
-0.0551677234,
-0.0082283802,
0.0018435748,
0.0542246699,
-0.0450700074,
-0.0133416578,
0.0261672959,
0.0399313346,
0.0517764688,
0.0098899743,
0.0491745695,
0.0396736376,
-0.0083082095,
-0.009308367,
-0.01225169,
0.0061085029,
-0.0507599935,
0.0221093912,
0.0127437403,
0.015378884,
-0.0073671686,
0.0189691186,
-0.0212108772,
-0.0147269461,
0.0165761672,
-0.0247023087,
0.0524515174,
0.017054813,
-0.0819568038,
0.0337391011,
-0.0006620056,
-0.0392158777,
-0.0275664441,
-0.0429809093,
0.0093632462,
0.0423445553,
0.0610743314,
0.0629386976,
0.0480482504,
0.0214093905,
-0.0339138545,
0.0385132991,
0.0407886542,
-0.0168888923,
0.0150539856,
-0.0377009846,
-0.0138407657,
0.0869439244,
0.0263254605,
0.057985846,
0.0501691625,
0.0160090663,
0.0230339933,
-0.0224709138,
-0.0274857022,
0.0097769229,
-0.0080512157,
-0.0033156993,
0.0300880596,
-0.0013075219,
0.0375047922,
0.020133419,
-0.0078248866,
0.0285418853,
0.0347466506,
-0.0129619092,
-0.0411753729,
0.0422068685,
-0.0666194633,
-0.0372526869,
0.0144795608,
0.0109530082,
-0.0046344772,
0.0010826726,
-0.0136364968,
-0.0560752004,
0.0182693787,
-0.0527703464,
0.0845696703,
-0.0474142209,
0.0657759756,
0.0023602578,
0.0084482422,
0.0364089236,
0.0381607488,
-0.0319519527,
-0.0006272009,
-0.0055698091,
0.0002164961,
0.0290903877,
-0.0199868828,
-0.0094960285,
0.0174315143,
-0.038133841,
-0.0104423994,
0.0289196633,
0.0286104921,
-0.0107688867,
-0.0065069743,
-0.0768064931,
-0.0045578959,
-0.0460821949,
0.0496035889,
-0.0089856992,
0.0179549959,
-0.0120402901,
-0.0026115982,
-0.0065961755,
0.005989064,
-0.0111622419,
0.0192054231,
-0.0214540102,
-0.0289685614,
-0.032197006,
0.0112924315,
-0.0132917874,
0.0065281843,
0.0547319427,
-0.0172624402,
-0.0334536247,
-0.0494520292,
0.0030215904,
0.0354597941,
-0.0015929486,
0.0296202954,
-0.0317995995,
0.0062971096,
-0.042166505,
0.0255811699,
-0.0193646122,
0.0174885523,
0.0044768252,
-0.013824923,
0.0153369969,
-0.0357707404,
-0.0193775576,
-0.0034267223,
0.0233170446,
-0.0202513561,
-0.0496254675,
0.0174475387,
0.0610581413,
0.0232444461,
0.0105555663,
-0.0791836157,
-0.0157732274,
-0.0028297405,
-0.0212998595,
-0.0055409661,
-0.0249180198,
-0.0241110306,
0.0290623698,
-0.0383517854,
-0.0482740849,
0.0758944005,
-0.0722043961,
-0.0226731952,
-0.0369053222,
0.0079820706,
-0.0258631799,
0.0468374193,
0.0143352896,
0.018260872,
0.0046911193,
-0.0423994437,
0.0124979811,
0.0761170387,
0.0205095932,
-0.0346626416,
-0.0041307691,
-0.0040125302,
0.0274749082,
-0.0192299522,
-0.0207991358,
-0.0168951899,
-0.0453378707,
-0.0147132073,
0.0073007154,
0.0567776673,
-0.0509016104,
0.0049073207,
0.0544071831,
-0.0619554035,
0.0756604373,
-0.0078476472,
0.0058416566,
0.0032924274,
0.0119667016,
0.0378910266,
-0.028776072,
0.0230535511,
-0.0471960083,
0.0534760393,
0.0731380507,
0.0753420442,
0.0349285901,
-0.0444028601,
-0.0017596076,
0.0395362824,
-0.009750735,
0.0129934726,
0.0586924888,
0.0479000807,
-0.0288006216,
-0.0122638382,
0.1001675352,
0.0143394945,
-0.0494185835,
0.0194869153,
-0.0055410033,
0.092204757,
-0.0274369828,
-0.0088076405,
-0.0882681534,
-0.0345843732,
0.0405671783,
0.0499230959,
-0.0113639217,
-0.0276659448,
-0.0313289277,
-0.1062776595,
0.0266627409,
0.0195062812,
-0.0160127189,
0.0143055562,
-0.0209802072,
-0.06245232,
0.0485689975,
-0.0038067889,
0.069171302,
0.0247564502,
0.0026963167,
0.0066152634,
-0.0555305108,
-0.0069754017,
-0.0027574443,
0.0030967281,
0.0598138086,
0.0548981577,
0.0067787687,
0.0417539105,
0.0119194929,
0.014416717,
-0.0190114062,
-0.0156871807,
-0.0341005176,
-0.0255121849,
-0.0037298605,
0.0371546522,
0.0270801336,
0.0168615654,
-0.064028129,
0.0062765498,
0.0022032997,
0.0392017514,
0.0081257457,
-0.0614424832,
-0.0194044001,
-0.0076297745,
0.018050747,
0.0541218705,
0.0209368505,
-0.0323390104,
-0.0681407303,
-0.0540320985,
0.0027802591,
-0.1302249283,
0.0154092573,
0.0098144487,
0.0593361966,
-0.0380162075,
-0.0429055393,
0.011858915,
0.0144285057,
0.0440526195,
-0.0287626889,
0.0380247049,
-0.0107039474,
-0.0359950252,
-0.0529114828,
-0.0504206941,
-0.0010711724,
0.0122883329,
-0.0458528996,
-0.000687431,
0.0241523981,
-0.006163965,
-0.0174997598,
0.0421872474,
-0.0855805799,
-0.0529885031,
0.0127286231,
0.0189401638,
0.0253966674,
0.0003606994,
-0.0600374788,
-0.0328177437,
0.0347457305,
0.0225448143,
-0.0754198059,
0.0107986489,
0.0076357243,
-0.0049604322,
0.004335436,
0.0232571084,
-0.0326648951,
-0.0036884469,
-0.0368045531,
0.0354836807,
0.0074019637,
-0.0305724721,
0.0380663536,
0.0497130491,
-0.0337919965,
-0.0541042089,
0.0071516559,
0.0368296243,
0.0427829921,
-0.0163446367,
0.0081689144,
-0.0193646718,
0.0472398475,
-0.0192411989,
-0.0390481986,
-0.0059692441,
0.0001434771,
0.0137878088,
0.0349855497,
0.0194496065,
0.0044479938,
0.0330514908,
0.0475949943,
0.0691717789,
-0.0415695421,
-0.0069873519,
-0.0016585741,
-0.0017742901,
0.0076879915,
-0.0432742871,
0.0044050924,
0.0220743008,
0.0061564953,
-0.0137946513,
0.0088940691,
-0.0375522263,
-0.0405828208,
-0.0440106355,
0.0450092144,
0.0440553837,
0.0610229708,
0.0261281896,
-0.0386071987,
0.0275158789,
-0.0257767048,
0.0103229685,
-0.0083206519,
-0.0562651791,
0.0200697649,
0.014962391,
-0.0299610533,
0.0271744486,
0.0521414429,
0.0577664562,
0.0279675592,
-0.0012857722,
0.0165234804,
-0.029230034,
-0.025982134,
-0.0690068528,
0.0631811395,
-0.0476393402,
0.0153394006,
-0.045156192,
-0.0468374006,
0.0032814746,
0.0228174813,
0.050727658,
0.00791342,
0.0149682602,
0.045069702,
-0.0245767329,
-0.0166642312,
-0.0411594957,
-0.0081320079,
0.0081100408,
-0.0252922997,
-0.0038389701,
-6.860330499e-33,
-0.0049196607,
-0.03029304,
0.0010716948,
-0.0500692837,
-0.0202088133,
-0.0258514211,
-0.0634708181,
-0.0145814931,
0.0347070843,
-0.0029592635,
-0.0221639201,
0.024695877,
0.0295887198,
0.037822973,
0.0127578471,
0.042092558,
0.0856347382,
-0.0316818058,
-0.0270961132,
0.0029858896,
0.0309577323,
0.0297483858,
-0.0147491004,
0.0190609563,
-0.0019239986,
-0.0444513671,
-0.0204162747,
-0.0209150705,
0.0048832549,
0.041311577,
0.0123406425,
0.0088314796,
0.0162503812,
-0.004731833,
-0.0442736931,
0.0040747635,
-0.1026525497,
0.0120805837,
0.0390874445,
0.0280064959,
-0.0302792136,
-0.0045453911,
0.0026229373,
0.0084385294,
-0.0149823185,
0.0212477222,
-0.0527633764,
0.006422739,
-0.0592929535,
-0.0680894107,
-0.0152301611,
0.0447131954,
0.038177222,
0.0266319793,
0.0479233824,
0.0475233831,
-0.0235036202,
-0.0074821413,
-0.0449342355,
0.0475477129,
-0.0350568071,
0.0460100137,
0.0259372331,
-0.0396163575,
-0.0256781299,
0.0077053988,
0.0466137938,
-0.0556152128,
-0.0456970148,
0.0027685193,
0.0216844548,
-0.0158468205,
-0.0054347944,
0.0135009624,
0.0823839083,
-0.0523557961,
-0.0190659724,
0.0088560889,
0.0524244122,
0.0261888243,
0.0529166907,
0.0098856715,
-0.0249453019,
-0.0444794968,
-0.0581815429,
-0.0468308106,
-0.0403222144,
-0.03113815,
0.0418927968,
0.0535394289,
-0.0247147977,
-0.0335743539,
0.0592273623,
-0.0347839668,
-0.0112120081,
0.0562004037,
-0.0267479327,
0.0232778024,
-0.0370125137,
0.0583687574,
0.0155842872,
-0.0287672207,
0.0251023285,
-0.0200135708,
-0.0165808015,
0.0012574075,
-0.0384695604,
0.0329589397,
-0.068939507,
0.0047517335,
-0.0103380783,
0.0399214514,
-0.0087494757,
0.0166090466,
0.0562014431,
-0.0037457475,
0.0161806978,
0.0224852432,
-0.0113953892,
0.0337922946,
-0.0276225731,
0.0198848844,
0.0171059761,
0.0532651022,
0.0050482568,
0.0280727744,
-0.027513694,
-0.0168623533,
0.0281364191,
-0.0286007896,
-0.0116528077,
0.0716817304,
3.014e-7,
0.0054769996,
0.0380997434,
0.084460631,
-0.0250158701,
0.0430580825,
0.0099493871,
0.0019040536,
-0.0010768089,
-0.0240749344,
-0.0002262322,
-0.0249682385,
-0.007607732,
0.0703633502,
0.0078459755,
-0.1225661412,
-0.010176369,
-0.0611096509,
0.0158134699,
-0.0317681767,
-0.0244175587,
-0.0031018434,
0.0675152689,
-0.0318971537,
-0.0118109398,
0.0195891671,
0.0099522313,
0.0126615427,
0.0219685491,
-0.010685185,
0.0041710082,
-0.0043827617,
-0.0153259365,
0.0091754207,
-0.0053234138,
-0.0307242014,
0.0095408289,
-0.034968175,
0.0704343468,
-0.0038676569,
-0.0188723914,
0.0432682224,
-0.0287082791,
-0.0329832025,
0.0083423555,
0.0315738358,
-0.0122915572,
-0.0104335286,
-0.0261720568,
-0.000252924,
0.0127954409,
-0.0792725533,
0.0047039283,
0.018014282,
0.0510020144,
0.0257475432,
0.0082385391,
0.0143332453,
-0.0726048425,
-0.0226099137,
-0.0322915949,
-0.0557298288,
-0.018316796,
-0.048876144,
0.0442124791,
0.0409555323,
-0.0442953743,
-0.0075216088,
3.159695065e-34,
0.0801800862,
-0.0135272015,
-0.0166933406,
0.0806468427,
0.0001460084,
-0.0271145999,
0.0743745714,
0.0482482165,
0.0211910959,
-0.0268012136,
-0.0561674759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17274v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17274v1 | Can We Trust the Performance Evaluation of Uncertainty Estimation Methods in Text Summarization? | 2024-06-25T04:41:17 | 2024-06-25T04:41:17 | Jianfeng He, Runing Yang, Linlin Yu, Changbin Li, Ruoxi Jia, Feng Chen, Ming Jin, Chang-Tien Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Text summarization, a key natural language generation (NLG) task, is vital in
various domains. However, the high cost of inaccurate summaries in
risk-critical applications, particularly those involving human-in-the-loop
decision-making, raises concerns about the reliability of uncertainty
estimation on text summarization (UE-TS) evaluation methods. This concern stems
from the dependency of uncertainty model metrics on diverse and potentially
conflicting NLG metrics. To address this issue, we introduce a comprehensive
UE-TS benchmark incorporating 31 NLG metrics across four dimensions. The
benchmark evaluates the uncertainty estimation capabilities of two large
language models and one pre-trained language model on three datasets, with
human-annotation analysis incorporated where applicable. We also assess the
performance of 14 common uncertainty estimation methods within this benchmark.
Our findings emphasize the importance of considering multiple uncorrelated NLG
metrics and diverse uncertainty estimation methods to ensure reliable and
efficient evaluation of UE-TS techniques. | [
0.0439298265,
0.058448296,
0.034948986,
-0.0153377121,
-0.0019439372,
0.0073664887,
-0.0174907539,
-0.0353742242,
-0.039831534,
-0.056415651,
-0.0049866717,
-0.0723112226,
0.0548255034,
-0.0102252532,
0.0200392809,
-0.0878938884,
0.0096726101,
-0.0251820609,
0.0077225571,
0.0179172438,
0.0174077377,
0.0075841695,
0.0096894251,
0.0502545945,
-0.0107912701,
0.0485380627,
0.0163634233,
0.0435667858,
0.0773303285,
-0.0497452356,
0.0103576882,
0.0483422205,
0.0063186539,
0.0136847729,
0.0000019264,
-0.0479596853,
-0.0305921063,
-0.002042582,
-0.0051307869,
0.0377164297,
0.0675152391,
0.0150574008,
-0.0121276835,
0.0190758295,
0.0052562607,
0.0347445048,
0.0247889273,
-0.0006060718,
0.036777366,
0.021714367,
-0.001004866,
0.0148491571,
-0.0018438562,
-0.0376251899,
-0.032575056,
-0.0568104014,
-0.014100695,
-0.0009097862,
-0.0100771459,
-0.0115285497,
0.0275049917,
0.0132945506,
-0.0102573382,
0.03589347,
-0.0346078016,
0.0163240079,
-0.0227368791,
-0.0288203228,
-0.019802412,
0.0442873091,
0.0210535526,
0.0317511372,
-0.0209192354,
-0.0069007496,
0.0084301019,
0.0165642481,
-0.0152231706,
0.0747904629,
-0.0192477088,
0.0031860571,
-0.0379000939,
0.0676709786,
-0.0140993837,
0.0233837608,
-0.0004472557,
0.0605459623,
0.003949062,
0.0138559612,
-0.0066730813,
0.0219371617,
-0.0504850633,
-0.0429794937,
0.017903775,
0.026431717,
-0.0454226248,
-0.0007769553,
-0.0802593753,
-0.047403615,
0.0243943501,
-0.029423831,
-0.015594759,
0.0207066871,
0.0288787782,
0.0011357929,
0.0082555301,
0.0353045985,
0.0529168695,
-0.0144214928,
-0.0588600896,
0.019280592,
0.0094806571,
0.0096920924,
-0.0388331227,
0.0170481745,
-0.0442118086,
-0.043311961,
-0.0919659659,
-0.0199340824,
-0.0056178565,
-0.0058951401,
-0.020484969,
0.0262014717,
-0.0242260881,
-0.0218746383,
-0.0074164127,
-0.0229097269,
-0.0144061456,
-0.0216930117,
0.0498543084,
-0.0248537418,
0.0101532275,
0.0195031743,
0.0118583348,
0.0192677658,
0.0040124566,
0.0379970558,
-0.0353644677,
-0.0525422283,
-0.0220572129,
-0.0298013501,
-0.0400264598,
-0.0393291339,
-0.051552169,
-0.0581363142,
-0.0297137145,
-0.012339564,
-0.0057428353,
-0.0450642481,
0.0255882517,
0.0070883166,
-0.040839415,
0.0291313864,
-0.0436583944,
0.0016567794,
0.0532108508,
0.0102940425,
0.0049171923,
0.0426653065,
0.0798957646,
0.0584779717,
0.047926113,
0.0476583987,
0.010461852,
0.0100987479,
-0.0102302907,
-0.0052462886,
0.0004643167,
-0.0360010527,
-0.0660066679,
0.0012521191,
0.0081851622,
0.0979844034,
-0.0366149284,
0.045730453,
0.0617657565,
0.0286494419,
-0.0403335951,
-0.0315307826,
0.0468103811,
0.0388959013,
0.0632197037,
0.0369353965,
-0.0081819249,
0.0133912768,
-0.062749207,
0.0610902719,
0.0877808109,
0.0459977686,
0.0146170128,
-0.06575872,
-0.0451238267,
-0.0100541664,
0.0287168156,
-0.0117780417,
0.0164697412,
-0.0125707798,
-0.06567128,
0.0143533889,
-0.0011912915,
-0.0633210242,
0.0146563733,
-0.0159631893,
-0.0010915739,
0.05591131,
0.0553613305,
-0.0140904877,
-0.0288519021,
-0.0055489973,
-0.0066846595,
0.0207220018,
0.0362933725,
-0.004374532,
-0.0001138349,
-0.0497398749,
-0.0284133498,
0.0122141717,
0.0245778151,
-0.0055324859,
0.0109777628,
0.0003696252,
0.0558692217,
-0.0145152407,
-0.060712833,
0.0260841604,
0.0210014805,
-0.0158716235,
0.0092871329,
-0.0385641307,
0.0267741475,
0.0254242029,
-0.0324807912,
0.0385991819,
0.0003574769,
0.002852102,
-0.0264059938,
0.0096176052,
-0.0201220531,
0.0021894781,
0.0181618594,
-0.0364758447,
-0.0174522139,
-0.0082135135,
-0.0337803699,
-0.0497562103,
0.0020682921,
-0.0549938455,
-0.066872336,
-0.0420199819,
0.0459074788,
0.015775308,
0.0106450999,
-0.0565594621,
0.0574037097,
-0.0083923321,
-0.006782339,
0.0380999148,
0.0178038832,
0.0142481728,
-0.0238328744,
-0.0127982851,
-0.0429499783,
-0.0322946087,
0.0237693768,
0.0659784302,
0.032764636,
-0.020002149,
-0.0240166672,
-0.0717509463,
0.0108375903,
-0.0267672334,
0.0469143987,
0.0426039994,
0.0094727725,
-0.0256128963,
0.0134373168,
-0.0049253716,
-0.0377036706,
0.003542138,
-0.0050912229,
0.0318505317,
0.0174701121,
0.0512632765,
-0.0811513886,
-0.0006346718,
0.0141065158,
0.0434089676,
0.0354592092,
-0.0303660948,
-0.0521188937,
0.0749506876,
-0.0395449549,
-0.0448399447,
0.041432593,
-0.0450661257,
0.0112563362,
0.0319218114,
0.067134656,
-0.0054774885,
0.0700484514,
0.0375173576,
0.0298245773,
-0.02150671,
0.0175092909,
0.0015608263,
-0.0299809817,
-0.0040193773,
0.0339723788,
-0.0506620109,
0.0580571704,
0.0310472809,
0.0220309515,
0.0046213684,
-0.0473783985,
0.0420240201,
-0.0555740334,
-0.0144814551,
-0.0425220504,
-0.041074954,
0.0012621968,
0.0599196926,
-0.0112130037,
-0.0132654132,
0.0430695005,
-0.0344639085,
0.025445722,
-0.0391673595,
0.0007691856,
-0.0066070408,
-0.0248782542,
0.0250062812,
0.0463260561,
-0.0016797865,
-0.0007309052,
-0.0526345484,
-0.0280429367,
0.0804586783,
-0.0318980701,
0.0087651014,
-0.0896123871,
-0.0007372763,
-0.0084592151,
0.0092084892,
-0.0201270338,
-0.0300162602,
-0.0369224772,
0.0054369508,
0.0959190726,
-0.035067331,
0.0119868414,
0.0275606066,
0.0294347461,
0.0421934426,
-0.0303738173,
-0.0349569246,
-0.0057066549,
0.0489139892,
0.0360275134,
-0.0089363707,
0.0847808495,
-0.0380157754,
-0.001174757,
0.0335281156,
0.0331977122,
-0.0078656925,
0.0041967221,
-0.0238475297,
0.0115010859,
-0.0394257121,
-0.0132626798,
0.0589592904,
0.0993764251,
-0.0112266326,
-0.0081287669,
0.1080163121,
0.0173130613,
0.0133630084,
-0.0074655442,
0.0241457429,
0.0606500804,
-0.0095411632,
-0.0020438719,
-0.0300552156,
-0.0321552455,
0.0129415384,
0.0464991517,
-0.0107907709,
-0.0313105658,
-0.0273086932,
-0.0623083822,
0.0427648798,
0.0170483496,
-0.0740973204,
0.0021012705,
-0.0168422423,
0.0090609994,
-0.0201255698,
0.0351094455,
0.0265889764,
-0.0289351847,
0.0335655399,
0.0509952307,
-0.1165476963,
-0.051138334,
-0.0709252805,
-0.0217853561,
0.0147076985,
0.0336001627,
0.0237351563,
-0.0007569975,
0.0521166697,
0.0340539888,
-0.04194244,
0.0072997576,
0.0063745715,
0.0924007148,
0.0276059043,
0.0126199806,
-0.0346253924,
0.0262304544,
-0.0037225925,
-0.0058206981,
-0.0172578543,
-0.0286410488,
0.0109357042,
-0.0034835825,
-0.0125424433,
0.0378816463,
-0.0093182772,
0.0517884344,
0.0153886117,
-0.028534431,
-0.0321454294,
-0.0534541346,
0.0456977747,
-0.07116016,
0.0053009787,
0.0142383547,
-0.0287451837,
-0.0388570689,
-0.0991370901,
-0.0562410355,
-0.0082028303,
-0.0089614978,
-0.0156845041,
-0.0246614851,
0.0372171327,
0.0250669606,
-0.0240872707,
0.0017169759,
0.018052768,
0.0201022997,
-0.0394763909,
0.0276019536,
0.0030694217,
-0.007161676,
-0.0133729186,
0.0781874135,
-0.0921970233,
-0.0684688389,
-0.0169319529,
0.0609265007,
0.0251570288,
0.0073473924,
0.0060367668,
-0.0419272259,
0.0644806623,
0.0487645753,
-0.0060215378,
0.0129037108,
0.0272095427,
0.0525066853,
-0.0361719616,
-0.000837493,
-0.0509203747,
0.0076664817,
-0.0238845572,
0.0393531285,
-0.0164207947,
-0.0831825063,
-0.0032983576,
0.0502401888,
0.0080529228,
-0.0911985412,
0.0254163258,
-0.0121958256,
-0.065278776,
-0.0199832227,
-0.0178533383,
-0.0423805118,
0.0331078321,
-0.0050251517,
-0.0038888617,
-0.022809431,
0.0405943021,
0.022319112,
0.0064341025,
0.0029291227,
-0.0299008358,
-0.0145525141,
0.0269771349,
-0.0087635461,
-0.0235438943,
-0.0204861853,
-0.0166004151,
-0.0459161773,
-0.008444801,
0.0276051424,
0.0158619508,
0.0132622533,
-0.0208060071,
0.0252357963,
0.0442880467,
-0.0677227229,
-0.0220791195,
-0.0801474005,
0.0065637138,
0.0410266183,
0.0139534958,
0.0860372111,
-0.0276291464,
0.0064543206,
-0.0312153064,
0.0366190709,
0.0279942639,
0.0142306006,
-0.0207645427,
-0.0030976443,
0.0030021481,
0.0014175937,
0.0765200928,
-0.0047735586,
0.0046460684,
-0.0264057554,
-0.0696141347,
-0.0336416587,
-0.0304896086,
-0.0520981662,
0.0231962372,
0.0000333833,
-0.0137051828,
-0.0642566457,
-0.0243927203,
0.0352191329,
0.0405261368,
0.0386718698,
-0.0331620015,
0.0365120359,
0.0009412076,
-0.0178464018,
0.0396930389,
-0.0366902128,
-0.0503346398,
-0.0236739554,
0.0537709519,
-0.01930416,
-6.200032547e-33,
-0.0333863199,
-0.056530945,
-0.0468747243,
-0.0512754284,
-0.0152753498,
0.0071904478,
-0.0413850956,
0.0326044038,
0.0629986003,
0.0259377155,
0.0071583064,
-0.0254830979,
0.0163615942,
0.0319313742,
0.0023853644,
0.0209213961,
0.04156835,
0.0082582431,
-0.0653969198,
-0.0001758239,
0.0248583127,
0.018776238,
0.0399889909,
-0.0417665467,
0.0444962643,
0.0031167141,
-0.0738402903,
-0.0026507617,
0.0450637937,
0.0088593215,
-0.0047087846,
0.0149895241,
-0.0162335727,
-0.0273883864,
-0.0464438386,
-0.02986723,
-0.047771547,
-0.0429706722,
-0.0105789965,
0.0045474367,
-0.0332482457,
-0.0002684744,
0.0154075762,
-0.0160899945,
-0.0446968339,
0.0010508659,
0.0183513686,
-0.0403429084,
-0.0269299876,
-0.0972723067,
-0.0144361202,
0.0544763096,
-0.0190270171,
-0.0328746289,
0.0142159797,
0.0598458685,
-0.0329976752,
-0.0355769247,
-0.0165103562,
0.010016202,
0.0291951951,
0.0004680231,
0.0484907404,
0.0196311511,
-0.031840574,
0.0453268811,
-0.0403156802,
-0.009442294,
-0.0511172339,
0.0120084072,
-0.0249997247,
0.0242393706,
0.0377299488,
0.0745622367,
0.0185748264,
0.0501533374,
-0.0512204245,
0.1035989672,
-0.0341660827,
0.0049139075,
0.0268623717,
0.0015232827,
-0.0339912176,
-0.0220053159,
-0.0491265915,
-0.0168261435,
0.0094999028,
-0.0013391195,
-0.0088333385,
0.0110581722,
-0.0563234761,
-0.0338194482,
0.0035116589,
0.0054556695,
0.0101371063,
-0.006991731,
-0.0388006046,
0.0040705982,
0.0080178054,
0.0048228609,
0.0001147522,
0.0134757254,
0.0460123569,
0.0466485135,
-0.0211090837,
-0.0240737367,
0.0280294083,
0.0097456407,
-0.0421598852,
0.0456248894,
0.0117285708,
0.0652427673,
-0.0147104152,
-0.0254473761,
0.0115435682,
-0.0465761237,
-0.0133794872,
0.0443009473,
0.0021821589,
0.0198206715,
0.0125111574,
0.0189738963,
0.0203816816,
0.0043686698,
-0.0179028716,
0.0038109533,
0.019823106,
-0.0312644541,
0.0176838934,
-0.008792297,
-0.0391594283,
-0.0027663086,
2.58e-7,
0.0665821284,
0.0465189554,
0.0588378794,
0.0309137683,
-0.0232884753,
0.0430305786,
0.0191253666,
-0.0157031268,
0.0040478562,
0.0202317461,
0.0460701548,
0.0063895495,
0.0562859923,
0.0352254324,
-0.0110903233,
-0.0602179244,
-0.0617699958,
0.0190154836,
0.010129177,
-0.0105506554,
0.0853846371,
0.0213738922,
-0.0356251001,
0.0041452451,
-0.0249331407,
-0.0160235837,
0.0438400619,
-0.0480294786,
-0.0342985801,
0.0411485061,
0.0815223455,
0.0200493,
-0.0195684023,
-0.0095253447,
-0.0172063112,
-0.0473029986,
0.0626496971,
0.0156797953,
0.0416663587,
0.0158610828,
0.0171093177,
0.0004764405,
0.0470818281,
-0.0039555319,
0.02101494,
-0.0838571191,
-0.0204208307,
-0.0310621057,
-0.0166067462,
0.0034712295,
0.0299959313,
-0.0234510247,
-0.023925269,
0.0232592467,
-0.0102836229,
0.0508318543,
-0.0074070166,
-0.0308193099,
-0.0536424033,
0.0253986754,
0.0101608401,
-0.0199057888,
-0.017701406,
0.0226918794,
0.0036774387,
-0.0739274099,
-0.0088272812,
2.089193712e-34,
0.0725988969,
-0.0228706971,
-0.0408999361,
-0.0170196928,
0.0492101423,
-0.0035411839,
-0.0143439537,
-0.0185061134,
0.0046615461,
-0.0269588381,
0.0062258122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17271v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17271v1 | DARG: Dynamic Evaluation of Large Language Models via Adaptive Reasoning Graph | 2024-06-25T04:27:53 | 2024-06-25T04:27:53 | Zhehao Zhang, Jiaao Chen, Diyi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The current paradigm of evaluating Large Language Models (LLMs) through
static benchmarks comes with significant limitations, such as vulnerability to
data contamination and a lack of adaptability to the evolving capabilities of
LLMs. Therefore, evaluation methods that can adapt and generate evaluation data
with controlled complexity are urgently needed. In this work, we introduce
Dynamic Evaluation of LLMs via Adaptive Reasoning Graph Evolvement (DARG) to
dynamically extend current benchmarks with controlled complexity and diversity.
Specifically, we first extract the reasoning graphs of data points in current
benchmarks and then perturb the reasoning graphs to generate novel testing
data. Such newly generated test samples can have different levels of complexity
while maintaining linguistic diversity similar to the original benchmarks. We
further use a code-augmented LLM to ensure the label correctness of newly
generated data. We apply our DARG framework to diverse reasoning tasks in four
domains with 15 state-of-the-art LLMs. Experimental results show that almost
all LLMs experience a performance decrease with increased complexity and
certain LLMs exhibit significant drops. Additionally, we find that LLMs exhibit
more biases when being evaluated via the data generated by DARG with higher
complexity levels. These observations provide useful insights into how to
dynamically and adaptively evaluate LLMs. The code is available at
https://github.com/SALT-NLP/DARG. | [
0.0165728051,
0.0455613248,
-0.0132923396,
0.0446713157,
-0.066158101,
0.0255581439,
-0.0027454556,
-0.0006654298,
0.0404326022,
-0.0645404011,
-0.0136287138,
-0.0202584043,
-0.0049890443,
0.0416585319,
0.018051764,
0.0033322906,
0.0657855123,
-0.0598036535,
0.0212985408,
-0.004532252,
-0.0170336608,
-0.0015809243,
-0.0079835802,
0.0278961528,
0.010244607,
-0.0125166895,
-0.000900802,
0.0039561447,
-0.0004941642,
-0.0430121757,
-0.0180695355,
0.0396827012,
-0.0039258101,
0.0398343913,
0.0000022108,
-0.0516081415,
-0.0176849924,
0.0238235984,
-0.0311522093,
0.005395751,
0.0477283671,
0.0288993828,
-0.0027405911,
0.0295566339,
-0.0396864749,
-0.0410268009,
0.007902029,
-0.0042767269,
0.0671434328,
0.0846604109,
0.0125192162,
-0.017033508,
0.0072412002,
-0.0251592062,
-0.0209824443,
-0.0630119666,
0.02692209,
0.0379736051,
0.0439086743,
-0.0200774819,
-0.0316092893,
0.023217693,
0.0194480028,
-0.0004730411,
-0.0144190248,
0.0214874092,
-0.0042665526,
-0.0010034648,
0.0030760458,
0.0725434273,
-0.0395854041,
-0.0143667385,
-0.0083515123,
-0.0086006941,
0.0068695219,
-0.0052029043,
-0.0481008328,
0.0086265597,
-0.0162642878,
0.0097066304,
0.0316916555,
-0.0487437062,
0.0634433627,
0.0197043829,
-0.0544501208,
0.1457888484,
0.0225101169,
-0.022064561,
0.0088230846,
-0.0451211594,
-0.0356043912,
-0.0557980649,
-0.0096526006,
0.0310934819,
-0.0486468151,
0.0525001474,
-0.0183816161,
-0.0120751318,
0.0043649534,
-0.0257883444,
0.0754645467,
0.0374763086,
0.0203022566,
0.0585318767,
-0.0424647518,
0.1036815792,
-0.0070470897,
0.03431274,
-0.0535276122,
-0.0136851314,
-0.0702810809,
0.0040138266,
-0.0270073004,
0.0490165576,
-0.0001326217,
-0.0148064019,
-0.0402943119,
0.0376047976,
-0.0296746809,
0.0134465247,
0.0337546244,
-0.0293128379,
0.0131142111,
-0.0039448701,
-0.0410491154,
-0.0070132925,
-0.0295527969,
0.0057068602,
0.0200533886,
-0.0435388684,
0.0084651764,
-0.0037980035,
0.0021236059,
-0.0127475429,
0.0152932005,
0.072551176,
0.0214395635,
-0.0144637218,
-0.0421748646,
-0.0111451354,
-0.0456941836,
-0.0689259917,
0.0052622706,
-0.0763211399,
0.0357204527,
0.0111519638,
-0.014425491,
-0.0724856034,
0.001040074,
-0.0124569405,
-0.0490389988,
0.0662458241,
0.0063552759,
0.0416650921,
-0.0060650096,
-0.0185768455,
-0.031587366,
0.0860840455,
0.0442589037,
-0.0251946952,
0.0529227331,
-0.0036862893,
-0.0297527723,
0.0501699932,
0.0085030692,
0.0211410224,
-0.0279865675,
0.0156753175,
-0.0049192519,
0.0232079048,
-0.0385540873,
0.0655164719,
-0.0166104287,
-0.0286136065,
0.0180485193,
0.0191438291,
0.0282778051,
-0.0240853988,
0.0474524647,
-0.0153797241,
-0.0068868967,
-0.0022461992,
-0.0721392632,
-0.0272560604,
-0.0435307585,
0.0234231707,
0.0070713335,
0.0134215746,
0.0054263561,
-0.0468093455,
-0.0589633845,
0.01738015,
0.0423590839,
-0.0043610297,
0.0586537644,
0.0376379862,
-0.0472032167,
0.0322546437,
0.0352330841,
-0.0488381572,
-0.0196988303,
-0.0489535145,
0.0214689709,
0.0573384464,
0.050502874,
-0.0099316621,
-0.0560719296,
0.0406526439,
-0.0035034053,
0.0009974046,
0.0475002602,
-0.007296388,
-0.0070221829,
-0.0370890461,
-0.0407445095,
-0.0244178902,
0.0103614889,
0.0260437075,
0.0594999082,
-0.0039790841,
0.0158178043,
-0.1005315781,
-0.0520798862,
0.0290425625,
-0.0438392311,
-0.0007486599,
0.007570399,
-0.022005165,
0.0393349193,
0.0022771088,
-0.0163278691,
0.0447318964,
0.028261859,
-0.0172226541,
-0.0260841511,
0.0062144939,
-0.0378706083,
-0.0507511422,
0.0615913719,
0.0048554922,
-0.0151680112,
0.0053126505,
-0.0540077239,
-0.0307548083,
0.0697508901,
-0.01618574,
0.0005057768,
-0.0213530622,
0.0557250641,
-0.0325326137,
-0.0094034923,
-0.0326669328,
0.0813334212,
-0.0126568805,
0.0249415953,
-0.0058276458,
0.0842307061,
0.0119451676,
-0.0157283638,
-0.025510639,
0.0273915976,
-0.0172205791,
-0.003329749,
0.0049763853,
-0.0047536343,
-0.0644874573,
-0.0248306878,
-0.0553223789,
0.0326887183,
-0.0159493648,
0.0342088677,
0.0197195299,
-0.0040804395,
0.0134090493,
0.0238579847,
-0.021936005,
0.0200119372,
0.0403587185,
0.0344248861,
0.0070138113,
0.006505399,
-0.0357157327,
-0.0198607761,
-0.0293332618,
-0.0384327285,
0.0859257728,
-0.0010832597,
0.0301252082,
-0.0343172587,
0.0080033401,
-0.0502603985,
0.0391680636,
-0.0165450461,
-0.005733348,
0.0100862039,
-0.026426902,
0.0331613086,
0.0560172647,
-0.0134549728,
-0.0053759008,
0.0517501086,
-0.0055844677,
-0.0497512035,
0.014054657,
-0.0272509288,
-0.0106114838,
-0.0328608006,
-0.0349059887,
-0.0170161147,
0.0643008947,
-0.0048626619,
-0.0205724649,
-0.0639789551,
0.0185592361,
-0.0567251146,
-0.003949543,
-0.0259773135,
-0.0169377383,
0.0029156427,
0.0199888181,
-0.0476075411,
-0.0511711873,
0.0896592513,
-0.017828621,
0.0095838001,
-0.040139053,
0.0064050164,
-0.0697387904,
0.0895105228,
0.0168565121,
0.0053254063,
0.0242323466,
0.005217493,
-0.0486715101,
-0.0392723382,
0.0319497101,
-0.0551994331,
0.057593748,
-0.0812252238,
0.0367687345,
0.0234532654,
-0.0377221107,
-0.0395319313,
0.0217713732,
-0.029046474,
0.0520137958,
0.0168519933,
-0.0163282286,
-0.0229390673,
0.0209258553,
-0.0141067589,
0.036846146,
-0.0162149724,
0.012909661,
-0.0094785253,
-0.0018392242,
0.0181394052,
0.0075430395,
0.0197711419,
-0.0137493415,
0.0391634516,
0.0293498673,
0.0501757599,
-0.0098861568,
-0.0626605004,
0.0293087121,
-0.0056911157,
-0.0150377462,
-0.0054235561,
-0.0014038904,
0.0025692445,
-0.0703313574,
-0.0181564111,
0.1083292291,
0.0370948352,
-0.0091753248,
0.0248447526,
0.0001803926,
0.0371021517,
0.0596825555,
0.0244117696,
-0.069290489,
-0.0472890586,
0.0115055563,
0.0180033501,
-0.0002158553,
-0.055328317,
-0.0081997095,
-0.1595338434,
0.006629969,
0.0039613722,
-0.0135091897,
0.0037388788,
-0.0380878113,
0.0068231449,
0.002283975,
0.0058526243,
0.0406829044,
0.0160290021,
-0.0010805191,
0.0215943698,
-0.0371477418,
-0.0468007624,
0.0338973366,
-0.0189289376,
0.0381517224,
0.0347431935,
0.0234750062,
0.0014397132,
-0.0271697547,
0.0922231898,
-0.0074068201,
0.0166030675,
-0.037333183,
-0.0031824394,
0.0327627249,
-0.0058220364,
0.0233624484,
-0.006806701,
-0.0291173309,
-0.0065681734,
0.0149889188,
0.0853950232,
0.0073168664,
-0.0255578738,
-0.0015244297,
-0.0128985979,
-0.0350382961,
0.0576132424,
0.0224124771,
-0.0206446741,
-0.0276152659,
-0.0478443801,
-0.0387315564,
-0.072037138,
-0.0249489434,
0.0504690968,
-0.0139587922,
0.0164654013,
-0.0553798862,
0.0078515671,
0.0196292829,
0.0073912116,
0.0092083169,
0.0026176998,
0.0238903463,
-0.0046327235,
-0.0631873682,
0.0254244786,
-0.0345767364,
0.0380205698,
-0.0414607823,
0.0045263157,
0.0266798064,
-0.0005328784,
-0.0312203784,
0.0355857722,
-0.0915041789,
-0.0970297456,
0.0019890165,
0.012073053,
0.0193013996,
0.0708238333,
-0.0326619409,
-0.0512048602,
0.0113784606,
-0.0115158809,
0.0205724984,
0.0257559195,
0.0124455057,
-0.0109181711,
0.0110398177,
0.0392713696,
-0.0607966743,
0.0104129286,
0.0267011523,
0.0710548759,
0.0054765819,
-0.0217453837,
0.0134430137,
0.065046519,
-0.003932558,
-0.0084556052,
-0.0458542779,
-0.0164280161,
0.01404458,
-0.0064572152,
-0.0612288378,
-0.0410625525,
0.016992433,
0.0199666228,
-0.0361734442,
-0.0030146292,
-0.0108565856,
0.0198679473,
0.0239824522,
-0.0325574279,
0.0056515131,
0.0069036139,
-0.0008986488,
0.0279953238,
-0.0205455329,
-0.0117664142,
0.0164289996,
-0.0227835216,
0.021769302,
-0.0380024202,
0.0338201784,
0.0377737135,
-0.0205752309,
-0.0479599759,
0.0004938444,
-0.056061212,
-0.0489669964,
0.0151195312,
0.0373987742,
0.0433268622,
0.0320891626,
0.0420768969,
-0.0208141916,
-0.0118442532,
-0.0355002135,
0.0079678325,
0.0174905714,
-0.0491341166,
0.0484776124,
0.0363148339,
-0.0065990747,
0.0193423945,
0.0502962805,
0.0279510934,
0.039211601,
0.0094754687,
0.0095461626,
-0.0417859629,
-0.0278813448,
-0.0501406863,
-0.0081818728,
-0.0292892233,
0.0214353018,
-0.0458953083,
-0.0943033919,
0.0106090512,
0.0383446366,
0.0200367067,
-0.009181371,
0.0213445146,
0.059209995,
0.0090622306,
-0.0255918819,
-0.0328384377,
0.0000401434,
-0.018765375,
-0.0273118299,
-0.0162100941,
-6.634761949e-33,
-0.0044113481,
-0.0412466452,
0.0208845399,
-0.0515052825,
-0.0156296603,
-0.0010636004,
-0.0368298665,
0.0223928671,
-0.0287477374,
0.0002754815,
-0.0034366164,
0.0212286524,
-0.0052598412,
0.0195146333,
-0.0199794266,
-0.0319359675,
-0.000384232,
-0.0003904337,
-0.0415912755,
0.0110830562,
0.0240245089,
-0.0025571124,
0.0341762491,
-0.0767749399,
0.0059721139,
0.0185662769,
-0.0183761213,
0.0354591534,
-0.0446111746,
0.0910855234,
0.0214786232,
0.0200209189,
0.0278924257,
-0.0330514908,
-0.0042824652,
-0.0437489972,
-0.0709863752,
-0.0218104701,
0.0389428735,
0.0080547929,
-0.0467563421,
-0.0217207633,
0.0480669551,
0.013798384,
-0.0323567577,
-0.0138638727,
0.0036240064,
-0.0228067599,
-0.0254253894,
0.0113684768,
-0.0376631878,
0.0538397133,
-0.0069674845,
-0.0081985258,
-0.0013825247,
0.0146595836,
-0.0225167777,
0.0341839641,
-0.0107220402,
0.0109519139,
0.0154376626,
0.0139374267,
0.0809799731,
0.0354610644,
0.0087255379,
0.0323704891,
0.0019395045,
0.0269149821,
0.0030769859,
-0.0278833676,
0.0470304973,
0.0766481757,
0.0514951423,
0.018306464,
0.0169067848,
0.0082265129,
-0.0712323859,
-0.0197272152,
0.0323217921,
0.0397732146,
0.0408681184,
0.0231397785,
-0.0362495147,
-0.0303636976,
-0.0803003237,
0.0344355442,
-0.0613342375,
0.001895164,
0.0458829701,
-0.0044856882,
-0.037730284,
-0.0210743826,
0.0015767359,
-0.0678980574,
-0.0162067004,
0.027036896,
-0.0313362181,
0.009154235,
0.0041545043,
0.0570100471,
-0.0003177631,
-0.0536975525,
-0.002487974,
0.01616925,
0.0262352303,
-0.0233671088,
0.0114422021,
0.0137015935,
-0.0473269746,
0.0000052595,
-0.0581187122,
0.0109803611,
-0.0067746476,
0.0218149051,
0.0487923473,
0.0269725025,
0.004750404,
0.0349088013,
0.0612526573,
0.0047519132,
-0.0290246531,
0.0205766149,
0.0152708422,
0.0442231558,
-0.0334731489,
-0.0077038174,
-0.014743018,
-0.0013789402,
0.0082371505,
-0.0256397817,
-0.0183100924,
0.0560286865,
2.931e-7,
0.0601480231,
0.0645638034,
-0.0022596326,
0.0549496561,
0.0405767299,
0.0198302288,
-0.056446977,
-0.0402228497,
0.023530107,
-0.0024482291,
-0.0331237465,
0.0525117032,
0.0523187034,
0.0405611098,
-0.0283585843,
0.0086334962,
-0.0460452996,
0.0093363738,
-0.0307131335,
0.0286881085,
0.0274976641,
0.0808558315,
0.0138867553,
0.0097354893,
-0.0320674703,
-0.104639098,
0.0309722107,
-0.0009931045,
0.0065848022,
0.0312956385,
-0.0162620544,
0.0257443432,
0.0334727243,
0.027772136,
0.0057667061,
0.0295335408,
-0.0078319022,
0.0544985346,
-0.0011554667,
0.0102786589,
-0.001293765,
-0.050489381,
0.0071760695,
-0.0598710999,
0.0984437317,
-0.035667982,
-0.0450609587,
-0.0415497087,
-0.0005896305,
-0.0011029689,
-0.0041157422,
-0.0109594986,
-0.0186887011,
0.0290773492,
0.0383770689,
-0.0186825693,
-0.013335255,
-0.0654527992,
-0.0439223759,
0.0106992396,
-0.0326341353,
-0.0512974299,
-0.0203966722,
0.0275707506,
0.0015738494,
-0.0624082312,
0.0110454131,
3.165187058e-34,
0.0540205799,
-0.0113034947,
0.0036465102,
0.0032974067,
0.0660181642,
-0.0283886977,
-0.0319375247,
0.0188279487,
0.0022581851,
-0.0970484838,
-0.0153854061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17266v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17266v1 | AG-LSEC: Audio Grounded Lexical Speaker Error Correction | 2024-06-25T04:20:49 | 2024-06-25T04:20:49 | Rohit Paturi, Xiang Li, Sundararajan Srinivasan | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Speaker Diarization (SD) systems are typically audio-based and operate
independently of the ASR system in traditional speech transcription pipelines
and can have speaker errors due to SD and/or ASR reconciliation, especially
around speaker turns and regions of speech overlap. To reduce these errors, a
Lexical Speaker Error Correction (LSEC), in which an external language model
provides lexical information to correct the speaker errors, was recently
proposed. Though the approach achieves good Word Diarization error rate (WDER)
improvements, it does not use any additional acoustic information and is prone
to miscorrections. In this paper, we propose to enhance and acoustically ground
the LSEC system with speaker scores directly derived from the existing SD
pipeline. This approach achieves significant relative WDER reductions in the
range of 25-40% over the audio-based SD, ASR system and beats the LSEC system
by 15-25% relative on RT03-CTS, Callhome American English and Fisher datasets. | [
-0.014979043,
0.0397893861,
0.0233198088,
0.0147450566,
-0.0067698611,
-0.0057996241,
0.0331577957,
-0.0208061635,
-0.0223075673,
-0.0218226146,
-0.0526549332,
-0.0131427869,
0.0793275759,
0.0009337022,
0.0137074068,
-0.0155901518,
0.0342741162,
-0.0449956283,
-0.0273666922,
-0.0495843217,
-0.0058917948,
0.0040192157,
-0.0560034811,
0.0052380669,
-0.0089008622,
0.0097005209,
0.0386456698,
0.0353284851,
0.0408375449,
-0.0039768429,
0.0312266424,
0.0396965481,
0.0236389283,
0.0650319755,
0.0000017698,
-0.0382699408,
-0.0018302499,
0.0019632215,
-0.0294047203,
0.0141288405,
-0.0016436211,
0.0284783076,
-0.0222276449,
0.0445053764,
0.0125711812,
-0.0697098076,
0.062575601,
0.0300535318,
0.0361182354,
0.0068228841,
0.0136878919,
-0.0679069087,
0.0036307925,
0.0113002984,
-0.0403682217,
0.0109397676,
0.0277726334,
-0.0027466035,
-0.064732708,
-0.061552193,
-0.0265605301,
0.0631901696,
-0.0372537263,
-0.0287703648,
0.0367726199,
0.0033234651,
-0.0316729173,
-0.0093110753,
0.0010827631,
0.0446575619,
0.0273912903,
-0.0242277235,
-0.0047465665,
0.0287843291,
-0.0261864681,
-0.0221340694,
0.0033807857,
-0.0207732841,
0.0137875136,
-0.014219041,
-0.0388898216,
0.0092706345,
0.0067595611,
-0.0513269305,
-0.0316227004,
0.0232960489,
0.012778529,
-0.0510058217,
-0.0191301573,
0.0018193558,
-0.0107715307,
-0.0132067371,
0.0607634448,
-0.0368584655,
-0.0208956916,
-0.0117489751,
0.0204670168,
-0.0269368608,
-0.0363032706,
-0.0354591459,
0.0064094062,
0.0403759591,
-0.0401283689,
-0.0367130153,
-0.0008183452,
0.0700384527,
0.0349039473,
-0.0152505888,
-0.0118243471,
0.0034977531,
0.0106884344,
0.0231235772,
-0.0261634346,
0.0045562228,
0.0028515446,
0.0153328413,
-0.0694156066,
-0.0057930807,
-0.0366884544,
0.0191337876,
0.0471714735,
-0.0044131298,
-0.0201952904,
-0.0203807186,
0.0079236953,
0.0386709869,
0.0282416958,
0.0491855964,
-0.0541125722,
-0.0463313386,
0.0223960932,
0.0320088938,
0.0372005105,
0.0123555362,
-0.0139678847,
-0.0187263228,
0.0291533582,
-0.0268087536,
-0.0345288292,
0.0010068114,
-0.0368205979,
-0.0111799296,
-0.0662789643,
-0.055849079,
0.0416380167,
0.0131821949,
0.0043803635,
-0.0407418422,
-0.0071677351,
-0.0100777755,
0.0105693135,
0.0739905685,
-0.0064469939,
0.0525125377,
0.0741966218,
-0.0041623656,
0.0410393588,
0.0184191056,
0.0340261571,
-0.0950939357,
0.0356367417,
-0.04040787,
-0.0163959935,
0.0777559876,
0.0035228371,
-0.0041056783,
-0.0268022735,
-0.0305918269,
0.0035729415,
0.0175313726,
0.0622890778,
0.0536217466,
-0.0325593576,
-0.0088786501,
0.0535264947,
0.0646262914,
0.0202843118,
-0.0005830831,
0.0176780149,
-0.0032150988,
-0.0078908829,
0.0153876925,
-0.041629158,
-0.0418210439,
-0.0290088896,
-0.0205803849,
0.0663259774,
0.0276023392,
-0.0247680582,
-0.00130721,
0.0069460776,
-0.0493952855,
0.0234224107,
0.0177613851,
0.0181261189,
0.0040996396,
-0.0010885575,
0.1058167517,
-0.0035408863,
-0.089785777,
0.0274623595,
-0.0036408498,
-0.0627197474,
0.0304660685,
0.0409948938,
0.0097785834,
0.003448877,
-0.0666273832,
-0.0596468933,
0.0315326564,
0.000389437,
-0.010478952,
0.0057775718,
-0.0713310316,
-0.0183255896,
0.0740325004,
-0.0158653427,
-0.0006588048,
0.0117491465,
0.0075788833,
0.026213346,
-0.0471575335,
0.0292436704,
-0.0111842323,
-0.0519166924,
-0.0037077123,
-0.0078998171,
0.0081671057,
0.0352439024,
0.0640405267,
-0.0512326956,
-0.0141598806,
-0.0017701642,
0.0004023778,
-0.0117802462,
0.0184603482,
-0.0676884651,
-0.0209842958,
0.0760984793,
-0.0155706201,
-0.0026674999,
0.0574477054,
0.0219497383,
-0.0732715353,
0.0273676198,
-0.0296938755,
0.0265881121,
-0.061766021,
0.0765476078,
0.004067013,
0.0260062441,
-0.0039367927,
-0.0172566473,
-0.0150725674,
0.0285671577,
-0.0359070823,
0.0095847668,
-0.0039958949,
-0.0801853836,
-0.0024579766,
-0.0018316898,
0.0053732716,
0.0491770171,
0.003463719,
-0.0214016121,
-0.0091402428,
-0.0010562509,
-0.0606147423,
-0.0094042281,
-0.033166416,
0.0104586417,
-0.0031625617,
0.042496141,
0.0084430529,
-0.032194484,
-0.0207487773,
-0.029880736,
0.0336764529,
-0.0185295455,
-0.0465679504,
-0.0329718143,
-0.0759365559,
-0.0020621968,
0.0120676728,
0.0049678376,
0.0081567355,
-0.026445888,
-0.016241489,
-0.086447373,
0.0376804583,
-0.0135942316,
0.0420336537,
0.0360466018,
0.0228351243,
-0.0589962043,
0.0367404819,
0.0329658985,
-0.0378533974,
-0.0164618548,
-0.0257521551,
-0.0055734627,
-0.0397878103,
-0.0264492761,
-0.027321972,
0.040306855,
0.0195344184,
-0.0127668213,
-0.0015644199,
-0.0216175076,
0.0278091803,
0.0352386832,
0.0197885055,
-0.0049404688,
-0.0447475463,
-0.0250058305,
-0.0048435619,
0.0046753236,
-0.0736774951,
-0.0319582485,
-0.0203364268,
-0.0467222035,
-0.0093461666,
0.0180659164,
-0.0859617069,
-0.0445005372,
-0.0795628354,
-0.0269959588,
-0.0090417098,
-0.0689349025,
-0.0033705973,
0.0068892939,
-0.0323230661,
-0.0638040453,
-0.015149625,
-0.0559955947,
0.0395495519,
-0.0695919991,
0.0872462615,
-0.0187469628,
0.0367511846,
0.0083814999,
-0.0387699716,
-0.0112614259,
0.0315582678,
-0.0132948915,
0.0164779816,
0.0241017044,
-0.0463512018,
-0.0102117648,
0.0587885939,
0.0313413627,
0.0630708933,
-0.0043725218,
0.0275984351,
-0.0269104261,
0.0591425598,
-0.0203310158,
0.0016251862,
-0.0063263355,
-0.021264188,
0.0530751906,
-0.0133209806,
0.0366656557,
0.0085601043,
-0.020274302,
0.0030090413,
0.0678928792,
-0.0005675841,
-0.0351148546,
-0.005293204,
0.0273586195,
0.0349482708,
-0.0204377733,
0.1332482845,
0.0070495191,
-0.0462684743,
-0.0276871137,
-0.0529356599,
-0.0329815447,
0.0260284897,
-0.0258817822,
-0.0040178932,
0.0168194212,
0.0612033233,
0.0500699058,
0.0543893538,
0.0121537847,
-0.0080266781,
-0.0754608214,
0.0677998364,
0.0428621918,
-0.0557164326,
-0.0800538287,
-0.0448253565,
-0.0007003153,
0.0077643525,
0.0695981979,
0.0381277129,
0.0031482975,
-0.0639445633,
0.0373296961,
-0.0907214507,
-0.0355936624,
-0.0032212839,
-0.0557771027,
0.088205263,
0.0591396354,
0.0048568216,
-0.0045307791,
-0.0271388944,
0.0172674023,
-0.0310844053,
-0.0370842181,
-0.0180463381,
0.0293309502,
-0.0003888881,
0.0206929594,
0.0328972042,
0.0326422416,
0.0069891242,
0.0081360852,
-0.0122963041,
0.0438750759,
-0.0128960023,
0.0566260219,
0.0500579216,
0.0697825551,
0.0248798579,
0.0361030512,
0.0233188048,
-0.0327348523,
0.0261364784,
0.021347506,
0.0558891483,
0.0080297794,
-0.0072601419,
0.0401178971,
-0.028320739,
-0.0767000094,
0.0164179578,
-0.0135594234,
-0.0234555379,
0.0017749686,
0.0147589901,
0.0196659863,
-0.0154053438,
0.0045208056,
0.0000586438,
-0.0327605121,
-0.0337734036,
0.0616370887,
-0.0295553841,
0.0132635552,
0.023482956,
-0.0091744028,
0.0046502226,
0.0221556127,
-0.0183472447,
-0.0359109752,
0.0645785183,
-0.0500745326,
0.0218915846,
0.0366317295,
-0.0358144492,
-0.0688971207,
0.054848928,
0.0103701409,
0.0024884834,
0.0686614662,
-0.0003960038,
0.0206845365,
-0.0151622519,
0.0279284827,
-0.0464137532,
0.0500304326,
-0.0105674006,
0.0158788431,
-0.0198440887,
-0.1057607308,
-0.0250923671,
0.0556602515,
0.051622089,
-0.0073970063,
0.0346819647,
-0.0300594233,
0.0428965166,
-0.0274922419,
0.0224847514,
0.0136861727,
-0.0034672425,
0.0141765578,
0.0080841668,
-0.031715624,
0.0543844178,
-0.0794153586,
-0.0051067495,
-0.0162721928,
0.0329078212,
0.0303569604,
0.0236036759,
0.0207077153,
-0.0010399683,
-0.0267119482,
-0.0104330657,
0.0647856072,
0.0102346446,
-0.0045249467,
0.038481541,
-0.0421499461,
0.0162794292,
-0.0203147922,
0.0147731556,
-0.0312040765,
0.0030981661,
-0.0252907481,
0.0213273056,
0.0248838868,
0.0493757538,
0.0650053471,
0.0303110387,
0.0273709595,
-0.0439511612,
-0.0084451651,
-0.0089100087,
0.0033403088,
0.0287877545,
-0.01409877,
-0.003030756,
0.0367144495,
-0.0004400238,
-0.0112331854,
0.0286466815,
-0.0735618919,
0.0024562369,
-0.0191155206,
-0.0443681888,
-0.0244697277,
-0.0302275009,
-0.0474766865,
-0.0500955209,
-0.0086534349,
-0.0868588462,
0.0374016464,
0.0243925173,
0.0301083587,
0.0006541279,
-0.0294375047,
-0.0063638501,
-0.0325860232,
0.0097783748,
0.0347978324,
-0.0454155691,
-0.0038795243,
-0.0397171639,
-0.0115591679,
-5.670348915e-33,
-0.0494094864,
0.0229306482,
0.0062950091,
-0.0183299426,
-0.027120797,
0.0064830412,
0.0008527496,
0.0061863922,
0.0314589292,
-0.0058258586,
0.0014570003,
0.0399535373,
0.0322390497,
0.0081380839,
-0.028867336,
0.0186966881,
0.0965221673,
-0.0435273349,
-0.0164311472,
-0.0020966034,
0.0569759533,
0.0358244441,
0.0039595473,
-0.0665313005,
-0.0030060101,
0.0108857863,
-0.0205397196,
0.0150095858,
0.0255912114,
0.0125850923,
0.0155298281,
0.0589264669,
-0.0204071086,
-0.0041749282,
-0.0256960187,
0.0228368696,
-0.113014929,
-0.0024343119,
-0.0243106335,
0.0713000447,
0.0555260144,
0.0264042895,
0.038059976,
0.0077262539,
-0.075375393,
-0.0125550516,
0.029562721,
-0.0133308414,
-0.0115390411,
-0.0181281399,
0.0161094833,
0.0102299005,
0.0170316864,
-0.0186335426,
0.038385354,
0.0248186085,
0.0074330168,
-0.0254155528,
-0.0853514895,
0.0242225584,
0.0040575,
-0.0067447252,
0.0416161641,
0.0518685728,
-0.0394321233,
-0.0037989733,
0.0324576497,
-0.0818104148,
0.0236278903,
-0.0961627066,
0.041510649,
-0.0019777648,
-0.0042960104,
0.0075921165,
-0.0143782599,
-0.0456151217,
-0.0060368953,
0.0068674483,
-0.0054448419,
0.0142775532,
0.0194531325,
0.0275060348,
-0.0558409691,
-0.0415557884,
-0.070416905,
-0.0299846046,
-0.0243413057,
0.0053351698,
0.0416089259,
-0.0064109168,
0.0052634478,
-0.0384586118,
0.0379283987,
-0.0307998564,
-0.0012020625,
0.0182468463,
0.0283317044,
0.0014110388,
-0.0346814767,
0.0101475986,
0.0043403585,
-0.0386141762,
0.0749658197,
0.0569197536,
0.0121408636,
-0.0606352426,
-0.0227882303,
0.0444596112,
-0.0799141154,
0.0192025024,
0.0352600962,
0.0133853052,
0.0002557958,
-0.0033638249,
-0.0049570929,
-0.0004561915,
0.0300288554,
0.0357421003,
0.033378426,
0.0107096471,
0.0265494194,
-0.0271436311,
0.0161245521,
0.0664730892,
-0.0465245061,
0.0241165608,
0.0678791553,
-0.0472858399,
0.0501078628,
-0.0206300616,
-0.0018166223,
-0.0542519614,
2.523e-7,
-0.0310283192,
0.0059822327,
0.0479426496,
-0.0446619466,
0.0160367489,
-0.0100668017,
0.0144705838,
0.0065288022,
0.019866718,
0.0245427322,
0.0260469727,
-0.0271489862,
0.071717307,
0.0297042709,
-0.0369168408,
0.0045092585,
-0.0579999238,
0.0318718292,
0.0094216168,
0.0199214164,
0.0336830728,
0.0278659817,
-0.0037977218,
-0.0577992983,
-0.0290905647,
-0.0190500543,
-0.0103803566,
-0.0127073256,
-0.0198669862,
-0.0067639272,
0.0710931569,
-0.0448362678,
0.0261542872,
0.0751865581,
-0.0196018368,
0.057970684,
0.0191589165,
0.0113704056,
-0.0312121473,
-0.0119534992,
-0.0516088344,
0.0263897702,
-0.0377238318,
0.0027608976,
0.030752359,
0.0405209102,
0.0067908713,
-0.0121007133,
-0.0848649517,
-0.0033422105,
-0.004353547,
0.002078427,
-0.0013249255,
-0.0029377709,
0.0365241915,
0.0360574983,
-0.0303516071,
-0.0401596613,
0.0111633958,
0.0531825237,
-0.0240945294,
-0.0348998867,
0.0499975309,
-0.0116080139,
0.0020050399,
-0.0056365808,
0.0180131737,
2.179226936e-34,
0.0363121331,
0.0045727794,
0.0239575934,
-0.0091224452,
0.0335098244,
-0.0622117184,
0.0104259625,
0.0432112403,
0.0039618439,
-0.0398963876,
-0.0183658842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17262v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17262v1 | D2LLM: Decomposed and Distilled Large Language Models for Semantic Search | 2024-06-25T04:03:04 | 2024-06-25T04:03:04 | Zihan Liao, Hang Yu, Jianguo Li, Jun Wang, Wei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The key challenge in semantic search is to create models that are both
accurate and efficient in pinpointing relevant sentences for queries. While
BERT-style bi-encoders excel in efficiency with pre-computed embeddings, they
often miss subtle nuances in search tasks. Conversely, GPT-style LLMs with
cross-encoder designs capture these nuances but are computationally intensive,
hindering real-time applications. In this paper, we present D2LLMs-Decomposed
and Distilled LLMs for semantic search-that combines the best of both worlds.
We decompose a cross-encoder into an efficient bi-encoder integrated with
Pooling by Multihead Attention and an Interaction Emulation Module, achieving
nuanced understanding and pre-computability. Knowledge from the LLM is
distilled into this model using contrastive, rank, and feature imitation
techniques. Our experiments show that D2LLM surpasses five leading baselines in
terms of all metrics across three tasks, particularly improving NLI task
performance by at least 6.45%. The source code is available at
https://github.com/codefuse-ai/D2LLM. | [
0.0170628484,
0.0142780058,
-0.0109890252,
0.0626701415,
-0.0032531288,
0.0051840935,
-0.0365035348,
-0.023612177,
0.020100411,
-0.0497009717,
-0.0316042081,
-0.0021529889,
-0.0154141802,
0.0040338053,
0.0092701185,
-0.0246743318,
0.0438247062,
-0.0057577081,
-0.0272928979,
0.0048736753,
0.0149746714,
0.0364139192,
0.0105927512,
0.0372416228,
0.0113016292,
0.0098948823,
-0.0426790677,
0.0251375306,
0.0011323965,
-0.0095994007,
0.0161589105,
0.0447486341,
0.0974388868,
0.0256471671,
0.0000021033,
-0.0250035319,
0.0088477638,
-0.0306353942,
-0.0159214996,
0.0026500574,
-0.0176312495,
-0.0164803155,
0.0475356355,
0.0092946757,
-0.0294246674,
-0.0031008911,
0.0015278563,
0.0191835556,
0.0832116902,
0.0557095148,
0.0013501226,
-0.033525046,
0.0475630909,
-0.0306592342,
0.01651619,
-0.0373457447,
-0.0015873868,
-0.0014832361,
0.0219335966,
0.0281893481,
-0.0065541421,
0.0402630307,
0.0282155424,
-0.0021975073,
0.0244637225,
0.0346532725,
-0.0507906228,
-0.0070010703,
-0.0046920539,
0.0845938474,
-0.0735701323,
-0.0163217373,
-0.0077260337,
-0.0021876579,
-0.0277915914,
-0.034175355,
-0.0282274708,
0.0100473566,
0.0099074226,
0.0414398387,
0.0093404101,
-0.0221751519,
0.0492928326,
0.0079531912,
-0.0229382608,
0.0597361885,
0.0222575068,
-0.0341146886,
0.0107324198,
0.0177294035,
-0.0255344845,
-0.0106686177,
0.0183817223,
0.0325972922,
-0.0510214567,
0.0193325281,
-0.0307525191,
-0.0379466116,
-0.0045404532,
-0.0259979609,
0.0057328986,
0.0514905527,
-0.0191373471,
0.0710690692,
-0.0384506173,
0.0540888831,
-0.0214732643,
0.0391992778,
-0.066285722,
-0.0582691431,
-0.0126987575,
-0.0199194737,
-0.0698064119,
0.0536911823,
-0.0417007618,
-0.0629297197,
0.0087810811,
0.0310377646,
0.0281623323,
-0.0165006202,
0.046113953,
-0.0038267174,
-0.0250959657,
0.0060582096,
-0.0254152119,
0.0169400983,
-0.0200843848,
-0.001602842,
-0.0056988602,
-0.07137236,
-0.0427986011,
0.0315193571,
0.0097791078,
-0.0573408864,
0.0039724363,
0.0532992929,
-0.0225179736,
-0.0694762617,
-0.0278675277,
-0.0187194478,
0.0163055342,
-0.0178448595,
0.0253357477,
-0.0378024578,
0.0822066441,
-0.0133208996,
-0.007038638,
-0.0421295837,
0.0316231064,
0.0325193219,
-0.0297701489,
0.080922462,
0.0171498917,
0.023696512,
0.0250801146,
0.0042560217,
0.0232357811,
0.0877288803,
0.0438367091,
0.0461570956,
0.0183724184,
0.0187362786,
-0.0184921566,
0.0342608579,
0.0434162952,
0.0289222933,
-0.0159234386,
0.0298778489,
0.0006047044,
0.0848464444,
0.0713570938,
0.047262162,
-0.031944599,
-0.0171338879,
0.0414054245,
0.0546532311,
0.033002343,
0.0095578711,
0.0563061647,
0.0275069941,
-0.0381244607,
-0.0423467234,
-0.0388994068,
0.0528281294,
0.0077576917,
0.0020307221,
0.0636146292,
0.0161606837,
-0.043947842,
-0.0007043406,
0.0003567533,
0.0181278624,
-0.0125279827,
0.0245854836,
0.003511514,
-0.0097057903,
-0.0707886741,
0.1009756327,
0.004457877,
-0.0326590724,
0.0378821902,
-0.0425887182,
0.0106427455,
0.1068560556,
0.0651876479,
-0.0212047622,
-0.0020347214,
-0.0079070954,
-0.0235625878,
0.0686800703,
0.0137549592,
0.0076683597,
0.0235145036,
-0.0643363297,
-0.0470969155,
-0.0555987097,
-0.0072149741,
0.0147990901,
0.0240204874,
0.0187844969,
0.0207282249,
-0.03798078,
0.0182572939,
0.0465524606,
-0.0385720208,
-0.02003452,
-0.0180529263,
0.019616412,
-0.0075494526,
-0.0082557146,
0.0006558697,
0.0099506816,
0.035533417,
-0.0409247726,
-0.0265864879,
-0.0263808779,
-0.0162637774,
-0.0764797777,
0.0201458577,
-0.041603487,
-0.0232013725,
0.0677137449,
-0.0451728106,
-0.0266069416,
-0.0135239121,
-0.0496539176,
0.0429175086,
-0.0449954681,
0.001134836,
0.0118017299,
0.0178122912,
-0.0346312933,
0.0542578958,
-0.0637991279,
0.0040802895,
0.027971914,
-0.0071695326,
0.0024475879,
-0.0559236929,
-0.0377432592,
0.0054760901,
0.0249226727,
0.0051799212,
-0.0105823111,
0.0289778002,
-0.0374944024,
-0.0212102886,
-0.0989920646,
0.0207658075,
-0.047198981,
-0.001959661,
0.0235415529,
0.0390886851,
0.0072520492,
-0.0206006821,
-0.0415071622,
-0.0233708099,
-0.0085560661,
0.0042368267,
0.0388529897,
0.0052373884,
-0.0006728769,
-0.0349377133,
-0.0137552032,
-0.0032162578,
0.0432245396,
-0.0572279841,
-0.001042501,
-0.0306921843,
0.0261780005,
-0.0257853772,
0.0264867768,
-0.0066896467,
-0.0156552773,
0.008445913,
-0.043423444,
0.0055732252,
0.0646672994,
0.0175290965,
0.0394028276,
0.0403330997,
-0.0019079759,
-0.0831281468,
0.0599700809,
-0.0147098145,
0.0056243278,
-0.0225104634,
-0.0070997463,
0.0191147551,
0.0500497036,
-0.0030991926,
0.021145327,
-0.0676529706,
-0.0151720103,
0.0544119887,
-0.0390789695,
-0.0657938123,
0.0029188979,
-0.0008116776,
0.0352747999,
-0.0579426549,
-0.030068703,
0.0760704651,
-0.0282527115,
-0.0141959833,
-0.0427021608,
0.0027351961,
-0.0578603074,
0.0700858235,
-0.0208382439,
0.0227381214,
-0.0557110831,
-0.0268515851,
-0.044216387,
0.0276287831,
-0.007879734,
-0.0386436693,
0.0726290345,
-0.0135896523,
0.0195648298,
-0.0075336592,
-0.0494456738,
-0.0204712152,
-0.0471438952,
-0.0406579748,
0.0494460128,
0.0089358008,
-0.0138284732,
-0.0703478232,
0.0117480075,
0.0200761072,
0.0519440956,
0.0305829998,
-0.0088476781,
-0.0297445655,
0.0337167978,
0.0671574324,
0.0336064175,
-0.037835449,
-0.0035620069,
0.0123888785,
0.0184605643,
0.0324569009,
-0.0126170395,
-0.0191184506,
-0.0032952889,
0.0510349981,
-0.0377463736,
-0.0044287723,
-0.0227763802,
0.0196160525,
-0.042454388,
-0.0403408296,
0.104544431,
0.0212525073,
-0.0517170355,
-0.0033186562,
-0.0363152288,
0.0186853148,
0.0344779044,
0.0342684649,
-0.061619252,
-0.0750089735,
0.0014195141,
0.0063575967,
0.0498625152,
-0.0040875175,
-0.004121752,
-0.1261463016,
-0.001242246,
-0.0170699097,
-0.0172865056,
-0.0393289812,
-0.0186213702,
0.0075672506,
-0.007216048,
0.0163806546,
0.0125467358,
0.0310869943,
-0.0070189745,
-0.025974866,
0.019491395,
-0.0268032905,
0.0434327535,
-0.0182095151,
-0.0036995271,
0.0775729269,
0.0221461058,
0.0223857537,
-0.0679645613,
0.0235463753,
-0.0592731498,
0.00522578,
-0.0262398906,
0.0277625117,
-0.0746774822,
-0.0085483873,
-0.0141896931,
0.0015648904,
-0.0489995815,
0.0063011982,
-0.0223482084,
0.0930973291,
-0.0274829101,
0.0151047558,
-0.0360954367,
-0.0201816801,
0.0041511515,
0.0787710622,
0.0396642163,
-0.015681956,
-0.028165821,
-0.0259597711,
-0.0114911078,
-0.0366479903,
-0.0520573743,
0.0084448224,
0.0244010761,
0.0219942778,
-0.0164741781,
-0.0381631926,
0.0259735435,
-0.0070479247,
-0.0046737487,
0.0021534869,
-0.0112234652,
-0.0161908083,
-0.0496664904,
0.0304443259,
-0.0277496446,
0.0233130194,
-0.018964326,
0.0218608435,
0.0581816584,
-0.0216243826,
-0.0192156658,
0.0197567437,
-0.0615677685,
-0.0350122526,
-0.0508362539,
0.0373381712,
0.0137241893,
0.0510939509,
-0.0424741805,
-0.0162349213,
0.0116646001,
0.0150590912,
-0.0385681354,
0.0156771932,
-0.0163383018,
0.0229832772,
-0.0075184223,
0.0550571121,
-0.0664184242,
-0.0216210019,
-0.0162412617,
0.0808136091,
-0.0325271823,
-0.0673537254,
0.0211217646,
-0.0044823126,
0.076557979,
0.0118653467,
0.0430618376,
-0.0302040521,
0.0507183,
0.0023656194,
-0.0166684054,
-0.0604279041,
-0.0093744686,
0.0206151586,
-0.0207869615,
0.0015474297,
0.0474667624,
0.0038748949,
0.0066657593,
-0.0453792997,
-0.0017634071,
-0.0058093197,
0.0162950139,
-0.0119266268,
0.0072564026,
-0.0193358064,
0.0126710264,
-0.0048953961,
0.0393583477,
-0.0252745394,
0.0165861603,
0.0215294771,
-0.0313541368,
-0.012908075,
0.0328174531,
-0.0487242676,
-0.072779797,
-0.0428494662,
0.0055632214,
0.0509468205,
0.0163328648,
0.0264313687,
0.0092805028,
-0.0039483611,
0.0005336194,
0.0246106852,
-0.0087296432,
-0.0434597321,
0.0459915735,
0.0347466767,
-0.009824858,
-0.0309617892,
0.0578526296,
-0.0206391905,
0.0538977385,
-0.0065776682,
-0.0155853909,
-0.0313265622,
-0.0631270558,
0.05809604,
0.0502848029,
-0.0346583053,
0.0223951638,
-0.0288405828,
-0.0402337722,
-0.0189340785,
0.0007327416,
-0.0249534454,
-0.0301084314,
0.0746031106,
0.0511468947,
0.025494948,
-0.0301859025,
-0.0177378934,
0.0175799858,
-0.0371392295,
-0.0534657985,
-0.0221090969,
-6.749949375e-33,
-0.0356804878,
-0.0142061533,
0.0281048566,
-0.051345475,
-0.0796780288,
-0.0080946479,
-0.0378937721,
-0.0172022562,
-0.0580018833,
-0.0188192856,
0.000990945,
0.0487362146,
-0.0074107544,
0.0303635728,
0.0001862332,
-0.0428616442,
0.0287917703,
-0.006765049,
-0.0259447005,
-0.0011406777,
0.0257621631,
0.0577793457,
0.0226904638,
-0.0138475047,
-0.0304810293,
-0.0182443205,
0.0037734115,
0.0606606416,
-0.0206667166,
0.0551666021,
-0.0230022632,
0.0362739749,
0.0124369236,
-0.0443842001,
-0.0028773069,
0.0212346204,
-0.0569336154,
-0.0094094202,
0.0279191211,
0.0068778037,
-0.0669560134,
-0.0225098431,
0.0476033166,
0.0118620303,
0.0167261362,
-0.0065914956,
0.0215795729,
-0.0057523712,
-0.0308470801,
-0.0157914609,
-0.0271383151,
-0.0001044108,
0.0004665356,
-0.0428263471,
0.0448662937,
0.0355706997,
0.0197466165,
0.0703254193,
-0.0545751378,
-0.0048473342,
-0.0281580333,
0.0344001316,
0.0644810051,
0.0071031414,
0.024898354,
0.0791845173,
0.0000330088,
-0.0267446619,
-0.0076558916,
-0.0195680484,
0.0247023422,
0.0608793013,
-0.0022850099,
0.0177841522,
0.0037945353,
0.0277519543,
-0.0519018397,
0.0211285483,
-0.0048502954,
0.0620795712,
0.0102397995,
0.0476412959,
-0.0132870357,
-0.0148481326,
-0.0472657233,
0.0285573117,
-0.0568753667,
-0.0220785849,
0.046848204,
0.0309480354,
0.0155783296,
-0.0162904616,
0.0242107119,
-0.0138963927,
0.0402180217,
0.0338704512,
-0.0074386634,
0.0009771694,
0.0193900727,
0.0408545472,
-0.0207147729,
-0.0302540325,
0.010500893,
-0.0028089008,
-0.0110914623,
0.0287114121,
0.0019292994,
0.0207950082,
-0.0268573426,
-0.022877153,
-0.0329525657,
-0.0264191646,
-0.0632781908,
0.0232891981,
0.0032536609,
-0.003431313,
-0.0165477619,
0.0333727114,
0.0142010367,
0.0035832133,
-0.0343247727,
-0.0270742215,
0.0344666392,
0.0124366237,
0.001078635,
0.0309808124,
-0.0374205448,
0.0217783321,
0.0025327182,
-0.061940372,
-0.0316585973,
0.0374103338,
2.864e-7,
0.0541592799,
0.015912842,
0.0158229526,
0.0501812398,
0.0189604219,
0.0219420809,
-0.0075968853,
0.0651406124,
-0.0038874864,
-0.0440134294,
0.0343610831,
0.0514336713,
0.0435812809,
-0.0301495381,
-0.1002170667,
-0.0075915637,
-0.0243541729,
-0.0252314433,
-0.0641511008,
-0.0438583717,
0.0346677601,
0.1000598669,
-0.0072421418,
0.0110988067,
-0.0069396789,
-0.0245840382,
0.0756063759,
-0.0301731378,
-0.0123041039,
-0.0131750861,
-0.0150228152,
0.0595777035,
-0.0208161119,
-0.014649475,
-0.0068864394,
0.0648705587,
0.044736255,
0.0813323706,
-0.0136299552,
-0.0618197657,
-0.0000701113,
-0.0248529948,
0.0047761523,
-0.0557495542,
0.0529547334,
-0.028501831,
-0.0080226576,
0.0067071896,
-0.0091331387,
0.0128845917,
0.0247901827,
-0.0337338261,
-0.0332786627,
-0.0218384359,
0.0229191445,
0.0017559082,
0.001140114,
-0.1015566289,
-0.0108031956,
0.0063850442,
-0.0657595173,
-0.0217652936,
-0.0722133219,
-0.0011146575,
0.0426705293,
-0.0448417068,
-0.016144691,
2.434965605e-34,
0.0448779315,
-0.0009556091,
0.0000467651,
0.0583154671,
0.0214788225,
-0.0230532251,
-0.0116264289,
-0.0091904346,
0.0337684825,
-0.0884093344,
-0.024477547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17261v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17261v1 | TRAWL: Tensor Reduced and Approximated Weights for Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T04:01:32 | 2024-06-25T04:01:32 | Yiran Luo, Het Patel, Yu Fu, Dawon Ahn, Jia Chen, Yue Dong, Evangelos E. Papalexakis | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50 (Primary), 65F55 (Secondary), I.2.7 | Large language models (LLMs) have fundamentally transformed artificial
intelligence, catalyzing recent advancements while imposing substantial
environmental and computational burdens. We introduce TRAWL (Tensor Reduced and
Approximated Weights for Large Language Models), a novel methodology for
optimizing LLMs through tensor decomposition. TRAWL leverages diverse
strategies to exploit matrices within transformer-based architectures,
realizing notable performance enhancements without necessitating retraining.
The most significant improvements were observed through a layer-by-layer
intervention strategy, particularly when applied to fully connected weights of
the final layers, yielding up to 16% enhancement in accuracy without the need
for additional data or fine-tuning. These results underscore the importance of
targeted and adaptive techniques in increasing the efficiency and effectiveness
of large language model optimization, thereby promoting the development of more
sustainable and accessible AI systems. | [
0.0028313231,
0.0958791375,
-0.0173683967,
0.0667391196,
-0.0027337144,
0.0284766275,
0.0284532141,
0.0197619963,
-0.0129462564,
0.0026502376,
-0.051121708,
-0.0338809788,
0.0222838819,
-0.0151289003,
-0.0061294534,
-0.004389483,
0.0130752344,
-0.0547344871,
-0.0398955047,
-0.0178358089,
-0.0282520968,
0.0237124804,
0.0145911053,
0.0273589958,
0.0041125314,
0.0036521743,
0.0048367088,
-0.0149783725,
-0.0093895933,
0.0492845848,
0.0056559732,
0.0470913649,
0.0215584412,
0.073410362,
0.0000020625,
0.03365504,
0.0287684556,
-0.0085355174,
0.0010740906,
0.0524525195,
0.0714014992,
-0.0293102581,
-0.0121182781,
0.0032429425,
-0.013295291,
-0.0307981167,
0.0488195159,
0.0432778634,
0.0628916696,
0.0519951098,
-0.0123128584,
-0.0358257182,
0.0240879543,
-0.0149925351,
-0.0507231131,
-0.0269627143,
0.0139503162,
-0.018562166,
-0.0378890112,
-0.0241160039,
-0.0174058508,
0.0367838256,
0.014890519,
0.0083582681,
0.0023023572,
0.0362434238,
-0.0508465953,
-0.0456445254,
-0.0113340197,
0.0576270223,
-0.0430091582,
-0.0261678156,
-0.0179442819,
0.0026348801,
-0.0195644777,
-0.0153836319,
-0.0267610122,
0.013261144,
0.0466407351,
0.0508442558,
0.0100567564,
-0.044544667,
0.0341673829,
0.0323723741,
-0.0592037626,
0.0432490669,
0.0546374954,
-0.0143182296,
-0.0241645202,
0.0051957425,
-0.0011970069,
-0.0028613487,
0.0332275592,
0.0154551342,
-0.0221004896,
-0.0157263484,
-0.0350370184,
-0.0951967612,
-0.0276009403,
-0.0563819595,
0.0906669497,
0.0503100194,
0.0094456626,
0.0452609062,
-0.0429046825,
0.0450304784,
-0.0401084907,
-0.0403828286,
-0.038261909,
-0.0343302898,
0.0153491115,
0.0078872992,
-0.0511474051,
0.0137460046,
-0.0761984736,
-0.0194448214,
-0.016853679,
0.0160521492,
-0.0142442454,
-0.0358921923,
0.038725961,
0.0246040951,
0.0101056853,
-0.0332545452,
0.0009975808,
0.0477452576,
0.0388513654,
-0.0019160808,
-0.0509662256,
-0.0281600468,
-0.0049380655,
0.0390995368,
0.008399467,
-0.0294224508,
0.0502560511,
0.0789307132,
-0.0271645095,
-0.0740956441,
0.0029562877,
0.0380935259,
-0.0095999613,
-0.0444407649,
0.0190086141,
-0.0241965018,
0.0438805558,
-0.0310050361,
-0.0008581014,
-0.0496205129,
0.0068914206,
0.0129877618,
-0.0753607526,
0.0374475531,
0.0025388428,
0.0213938393,
0.0279310755,
-0.0080859372,
0.0326835364,
0.0361511037,
0.0367407352,
0.0469794422,
-0.0034207469,
-0.0455046892,
-0.0042380746,
0.0497843996,
0.0122014992,
0.004165207,
-0.0477424115,
-0.0358488895,
-0.0263848044,
0.0180758573,
0.0463796519,
0.106155619,
-0.0395515598,
0.0007698974,
0.0847537816,
0.0347688049,
0.0361468568,
0.0749050751,
0.0239337031,
-0.01447191,
-0.0129430266,
-0.0302348081,
-0.050777778,
0.0185617041,
-0.0164134521,
-0.0372500382,
0.0089047365,
0.0752867162,
-0.0188295301,
-0.0220049582,
-0.0067911088,
-0.0304549504,
0.0407654867,
0.0113826776,
0.0529339649,
-0.0215354227,
-0.0435028002,
0.0916735753,
0.0247739553,
-0.0410891138,
-0.0081664957,
-0.0672432557,
0.0016065123,
0.0263257008,
0.0260763094,
0.0189465638,
-0.0063954093,
0.0137617057,
-0.0033696941,
0.0189647209,
0.0191038344,
0.0191507228,
0.0476970896,
-0.0637834817,
0.0063435668,
0.0204336699,
0.0044319229,
-0.018899072,
-0.0022051656,
-0.004611989,
0.0093730642,
-0.0040581245,
-0.03001564,
0.0417302474,
-0.0228865594,
-0.0319939516,
0.0460862182,
-0.0010281121,
0.0147116454,
-0.002702381,
-0.015765788,
-0.03373456,
0.0381274,
-0.0592708252,
-0.0379714109,
-0.033369761,
-0.0340441689,
0.0165131781,
0.0456562005,
0.0041664657,
0.0112664467,
0.0594353788,
-0.0277755056,
-0.0324012041,
0.0668961778,
-0.0451977886,
0.032211747,
-0.0334437415,
0.0140828276,
-0.0495137461,
0.0486209318,
-0.0207397137,
0.0281916037,
-0.0354787372,
-0.00523559,
0.0195151214,
-0.0610072985,
0.0026505932,
-0.023953123,
-0.0374191217,
0.0130280294,
0.0146466428,
0.02260812,
0.0285258088,
0.0302482564,
0.0499573164,
-0.0501205213,
-0.1050622463,
0.001296093,
-0.0478516109,
0.0018293288,
0.0217237547,
0.0199563615,
-0.0003347074,
0.0096487161,
0.0231335573,
-0.0043065469,
-0.0025084435,
-0.0160680246,
0.0086844806,
-0.0483198985,
-0.0398584194,
-0.0267351642,
-0.0625067577,
0.0139349774,
0.0817065313,
-0.0352962986,
-0.0177618731,
-0.0617576838,
-0.0277911387,
-0.0029160432,
0.0416743569,
0.0071809585,
-0.036502149,
-0.0208445955,
0.0054366989,
0.0579107963,
0.0476227701,
0.0240058731,
0.0427318141,
0.0761405006,
0.0295881126,
-0.0104452539,
0.0137316845,
-0.0243918225,
-0.009875779,
-0.0382809155,
-0.0315234773,
-0.0075308974,
0.0882766768,
-0.0135655208,
-0.0129361758,
-0.0286775418,
-0.018493535,
-0.0220500343,
-0.022601774,
-0.0360735394,
-0.0293125771,
-0.0137896677,
0.0047369874,
-0.004039357,
-0.0232864507,
0.0444579795,
-0.0376435295,
-0.0290783774,
-0.040596623,
-0.0439765677,
-0.0257035568,
0.0078468481,
0.0238571037,
0.0563092269,
-0.0682926103,
0.0111876074,
-0.0375313163,
0.0103017176,
-0.0034464921,
-0.0247795433,
0.0351466388,
-0.0091592027,
0.0003865905,
-0.0054809186,
-0.0473926477,
-0.0112392493,
0.0120048169,
-0.0167231448,
0.0235327985,
0.0507693663,
-0.0468347631,
-0.0377590172,
0.010974315,
0.0273652524,
0.0448995493,
0.0019496371,
0.0030990352,
-0.0110173644,
0.0631065592,
0.0417313501,
0.0092041744,
0.0731562302,
0.0036613068,
0.0303945225,
0.0492222495,
0.0306688696,
0.0080075571,
-0.0714313462,
0.0074849576,
0.0562150069,
-0.0037132893,
-0.0130925151,
-0.0272695646,
-0.0015738233,
-0.0371455662,
0.0084615462,
0.0751603544,
0.0133794053,
-0.0575976223,
0.0185459517,
0.0267979782,
0.0041871271,
0.0082167825,
0.0434198231,
-0.0610568784,
-0.0187404267,
0.0040664184,
0.0027639035,
0.0405995883,
-0.0348485783,
0.0242764931,
-0.0632759184,
0.0533263423,
0.0110097639,
0.0173231456,
-0.0319386497,
-0.0736325532,
-0.0295301545,
-0.023393143,
0.0567865632,
0.0253541004,
-0.0115380986,
-0.04130942,
0.0028268648,
0.0129129104,
-0.0457504354,
0.0016615011,
0.0104970671,
0.0265212655,
-0.0108652851,
0.0228900537,
-0.0318820849,
-0.0609272048,
0.0571867526,
0.0105131213,
-0.0031688449,
0.0053393105,
-0.0056758286,
0.0320081897,
-0.0332850032,
-0.0323791467,
0.0201985445,
-0.050928589,
-0.0156241804,
-0.063432008,
0.105843924,
0.0060347198,
-0.0575306416,
-0.0074091172,
-0.040774554,
-0.0280361734,
0.0585876368,
0.0269024931,
-0.0693016648,
-0.026285572,
0.0257344525,
-0.0008533482,
-0.0338620953,
-0.0409604944,
-0.0077219624,
0.0161850769,
-0.0381774232,
-0.0259088762,
0.0307411049,
-0.0110875312,
0.0054247328,
-0.0239014663,
-0.0383202992,
0.0226789694,
-0.0134797478,
-0.0492717102,
0.0482901298,
-0.0296267848,
0.0008094487,
-0.050199464,
0.0262069255,
0.0304810945,
-0.0177509356,
-0.0179327428,
0.0053932746,
-0.1135817394,
-0.0514841378,
0.0082841096,
0.0544796549,
0.0140608642,
-0.0107763028,
0.0294661243,
-0.0582826249,
0.0809412897,
0.0076328819,
-0.0499727763,
0.0709835365,
-0.0003159247,
-0.0818391666,
-0.014496712,
0.0320717245,
-0.0198799502,
0.0366958678,
0.0281232521,
0.0338542387,
0.0126686422,
0.009619805,
0.010501964,
0.0246056262,
0.0309051722,
-0.0310111977,
0.0182230957,
-0.0406685956,
0.0292636175,
0.0122924289,
0.0076350919,
-0.0473788008,
-0.0096386774,
0.0275782589,
0.0456205606,
-0.0136063099,
0.0163111351,
0.0552288294,
0.0109635126,
0.0024982831,
0.0269351397,
-0.0093397778,
0.0104629807,
0.0504267961,
0.0241979193,
-0.0142962234,
0.017770132,
-0.0138119888,
0.0245774761,
-0.0318220742,
-0.0024697562,
0.0058819489,
-0.017543871,
-0.0885187909,
0.0609458387,
-0.0265489705,
-0.0935679004,
-0.0262216534,
-0.0064743091,
0.0612443723,
0.0261220261,
0.028072102,
-0.0137750274,
-0.036057543,
-0.0078454306,
0.0035567442,
0.0057784882,
-0.0089147352,
0.0066950498,
-0.0062428382,
-0.0249059238,
0.0312922746,
0.0371780954,
-0.0061925999,
0.0288600717,
-0.0059935451,
0.001678698,
-0.0150849037,
-0.0474109203,
-0.039796032,
0.0216982793,
-0.0432549119,
-0.0115846107,
-0.0118449684,
-0.0727924258,
-0.0139634283,
0.0077191093,
-0.0032573177,
-0.0515390374,
0.0130667239,
0.026895538,
0.0137685193,
0.0096777631,
0.0010915878,
-0.0293194707,
-0.0108517846,
-0.0499068424,
-0.0283591785,
-6.137466493e-33,
0.0106173111,
0.0316089876,
0.0222247373,
-0.0061642565,
-0.0282011777,
0.0347689241,
-0.0313050523,
-0.0074458439,
-0.0149693824,
0.0232900809,
-0.017661579,
-0.0114547871,
-0.0181967169,
0.0334003866,
0.0064015426,
0.0377423726,
0.0334296897,
-0.0172416065,
-0.011336918,
0.0358591899,
0.0140716871,
0.0337133259,
0.0403924137,
-0.0353388861,
-0.0700748488,
0.0161570422,
-0.0025029958,
0.0263588671,
0.0271834694,
0.0424635075,
-0.0856624991,
0.0310619585,
0.0286257695,
-0.0215150416,
0.0026269434,
-0.0030201657,
-0.0568581074,
0.012862022,
0.01570048,
0.009428991,
-0.0318200812,
-0.0152663663,
0.0471826531,
0.0426812358,
-0.0620671697,
-0.011474343,
0.0110670319,
-0.0016137902,
-0.0249316264,
-0.0210034568,
-0.0643345565,
-0.0024864327,
-0.0151230386,
0.0098794689,
0.02988513,
0.0082637668,
-0.0362610407,
0.0481196493,
-0.0689924285,
-0.0136839338,
0.0007773697,
0.0144347465,
0.069621861,
0.0243968144,
-0.0012252528,
0.0338528678,
0.0599217936,
0.0017999068,
-0.0445769839,
-0.0291797332,
0.0840749964,
0.0211916585,
0.0624363124,
0.006107755,
0.0088751046,
-0.0348969623,
-0.0630187839,
-0.0294688586,
0.0275818408,
0.0301422011,
0.0284823645,
0.0308377501,
0.0303405225,
-0.0236408114,
-0.04540319,
-0.0021518094,
-0.0465875641,
0.0151733262,
-0.0173784364,
0.0241897292,
-0.0618739948,
-0.0347566418,
0.0351657569,
-0.080945842,
0.0397651531,
0.0514992326,
-0.0082289753,
0.0358887725,
0.0406306051,
0.0232039075,
-0.0284211393,
-0.0448990688,
-0.0140499752,
-0.0317895226,
0.0197395198,
-0.0076166624,
0.0129115023,
0.0667913333,
-0.0532245412,
-0.0092199389,
-0.0332854763,
-0.0065326896,
0.0353193805,
0.0598253533,
0.0141481543,
0.0228644256,
0.0081016431,
0.0236603711,
0.0171112549,
0.0786213577,
-0.0162655823,
-0.0014774775,
0.0422917008,
0.0313447751,
-0.0190009493,
-0.0021789153,
-0.0380708277,
0.0324301422,
0.0670112073,
-0.0846607611,
-0.0360375158,
0.0010745353,
2.691e-7,
0.0448220745,
0.0508449711,
-0.0139786415,
-0.0151340142,
0.025280416,
0.021325998,
0.0228420347,
0.00529633,
0.0159308836,
0.0619183928,
0.0297802296,
0.0327587873,
0.0296717919,
-0.0067958888,
-0.052681528,
-0.0055915541,
-0.083293885,
-0.0072461818,
-0.0571730509,
-0.0143181607,
-0.0329683311,
0.1082453877,
0.0433007814,
-0.0574290343,
-0.0076841079,
-0.0147497971,
0.0557788722,
-0.0563485846,
0.0375632234,
0.0119777936,
0.0232111271,
0.0051730857,
-0.0184683967,
-0.0238665268,
-0.000183581,
0.0481967516,
-0.0271697938,
0.0674413368,
-0.0259660352,
0.0208148416,
0.0294419825,
0.0016470921,
-0.0323098637,
-0.0570229031,
0.0479209125,
-0.0240485817,
-0.010276706,
-0.0682506189,
-0.0235920884,
-0.0128316209,
0.0068265516,
-0.0402838513,
0.021982396,
0.0523284003,
0.0201375969,
-0.0164613482,
-0.0038633889,
-0.0888976455,
0.0154035036,
0.0204317234,
-0.0457689315,
-0.0200354625,
-0.0333833881,
-0.0452432781,
0.0615644976,
-0.0308556352,
0.0124348309,
2.530320696e-34,
0.020365838,
-0.0001194096,
0.012267014,
0.0567356199,
0.033375062,
-0.0430329107,
-0.0003293993,
0.004225539,
-0.0312865488,
-0.1032721102,
-0.0108317947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17260v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17260v1 | Mitigating Hallucination in Fictional Character Role-Play | 2024-06-25T03:56:33 | 2024-06-25T03:56:33 | Nafis Sadeq, Zhouhang Xie, Byungkyu Kang, Prarit Lamba, Xiang Gao, Julian McAuley | cs.CL | cs.CL | Role-playing has wide-ranging applications in customer support, embodied
agents, computational social science, etc. The influence of parametric world
knowledge of large language models (LLMs) often causes role-playing characters
to act out of character and hallucinate about things outside the scope of their
knowledge. In this work, we focus on the evaluation and mitigation of
hallucination in fictional character role-play. We introduce a dataset with
more than 2,000 characters and 72,000 interviews, including 18,000 adversarial
questions. We propose RoleFact, a role-playing method that mitigates
hallucination by modulating the influence of parametric knowledge using a
pre-calibrated confidence threshold. Experiments show that the proposed method
improves the factual precision of generated responses by 18% for adversarial
questions with a 44% reduction in temporal hallucination for time-sensitive
interviews. The code and the dataset will be available at
https://github.com/NafisSadeq/rolefact.git. | [
0.0312502012,
0.0617876388,
-0.0466560759,
0.0460443906,
-0.0166591238,
-0.0067357449,
-0.0087130917,
0.0034939416,
0.0078399582,
0.0039168466,
0.0068897842,
-0.0679221228,
0.0197794251,
0.0220927615,
0.0535877272,
-0.0462578423,
0.0296431947,
-0.0266319606,
0.0300571974,
-0.0244196206,
-0.0294640604,
0.0407382324,
-0.0233188067,
0.0456577055,
0.0285342596,
-0.0553240851,
0.0061920169,
0.0074806078,
0.0598058924,
-0.0016901877,
0.0498726517,
0.0152261313,
0.0048115994,
0.0277446192,
0.0000019494,
-0.04170724,
0.0169383809,
-0.0238479786,
0.0019948271,
-0.0092269266,
0.0196841154,
0.0227916073,
0.017727131,
0.0250418559,
-0.0464933254,
0.0074548572,
0.044861652,
0.0543579943,
0.0551524386,
0.0670911297,
-0.0059649069,
-0.0107140206,
-0.0258837715,
0.0067850524,
0.0646922365,
-0.0096184853,
0.009845241,
0.0220373813,
0.0275709424,
-0.0540955961,
-0.0229155496,
0.014302087,
0.0021619394,
0.0224649329,
-0.033290185,
0.0317193195,
-0.04577877,
0.0384489521,
0.0324965641,
0.0789250508,
-0.014959651,
-0.0560226478,
-0.0110389953,
0.0079520913,
0.0480078049,
0.0631923974,
-0.0204853434,
-0.0005043703,
-0.0094835153,
-0.0323737785,
-0.0336477421,
0.0355313271,
0.0380554684,
0.0060206098,
-0.0034859977,
0.046768941,
0.0132681811,
-0.0123269381,
-0.0357180126,
-0.0341066606,
-0.0355731994,
-0.0569335297,
0.009569671,
0.0182296392,
-0.0443828069,
0.0074547864,
-0.046749644,
0.0395691656,
0.0266013909,
-0.0745738819,
0.0060174619,
0.0046042814,
-0.0333757214,
0.0332015865,
0.0108687133,
0.0342494324,
-0.009153991,
0.0450384729,
0.0102071157,
0.0209687147,
-0.0225545298,
-0.0245097801,
-0.0363224596,
-0.0051000565,
-0.0041010599,
0.0191813689,
-0.0015290588,
0.0060808188,
-0.0451904461,
0.0550145917,
-0.0320361406,
0.0529698282,
-0.0197432488,
-0.0226386599,
-0.0386850722,
0.0215265565,
-0.0614672489,
-0.0023374166,
-0.0096190227,
-0.0769071132,
-0.0071763527,
-0.034275569,
0.0118765878,
-0.0170208979,
0.0276992712,
0.0404847413,
0.0367830284,
-0.0081682578,
-0.0116914641,
-0.0271481369,
-0.0186198298,
-0.0927612409,
-0.0291569438,
-0.03184608,
0.0212189704,
-0.0342395343,
0.0161069334,
-0.043205671,
0.0021750634,
0.0128141642,
-0.0019230733,
0.10250175,
0.0302341674,
0.0002861614,
0.0439797826,
0.0519906469,
-0.0063648429,
0.0569464713,
0.034892723,
0.0006868063,
0.0235956293,
-0.0334959365,
0.0417679921,
0.0208199639,
0.0013651319,
-0.0075606387,
-0.0137828439,
0.013530816,
0.019060174,
0.0481341109,
0.0127815651,
0.0211571902,
-0.0419245325,
-0.0650139526,
0.0808665752,
-0.0003733824,
-0.0129353795,
-0.0223166924,
0.0125079164,
0.025179984,
0.0263960678,
0.0356104523,
-0.0360595174,
0.014751995,
0.0067392075,
-0.0346985012,
-0.0599252097,
-0.0017154644,
-0.0102334507,
0.004680871,
0.0161278956,
0.0056075179,
0.0201645549,
0.0322491676,
-0.0073091728,
0.02643371,
-0.0565482788,
0.0332194418,
0.0080116382,
-0.0568061732,
0.0320661142,
-0.0238363091,
-0.0083467187,
0.0646120831,
0.0601150021,
-0.0751325712,
-0.0247640498,
-0.0557798147,
0.0151506476,
0.0268990062,
0.0206634849,
-0.0235990454,
0.0339298509,
-0.0378498696,
0.0469062664,
-0.0350625962,
0.031295564,
0.0542290434,
-0.0419052839,
0.0343122184,
-0.002041413,
-0.0191961117,
-0.0228817146,
0.013265131,
-0.0515597872,
-0.0526727587,
-0.050083451,
0.0082052834,
0.0130453091,
0.0021678202,
-0.029185215,
-0.0063322554,
0.0178264473,
-0.0238721482,
-0.0263896678,
0.0532150641,
-0.0493683331,
-0.0187042654,
0.0499838889,
-0.0672292113,
-0.0325827226,
0.0477835797,
0.017317012,
-0.000725439,
0.0071021095,
-0.0328625217,
0.0535046421,
-0.0209372658,
-0.0017716537,
-0.0193635579,
0.073392719,
-0.0311047379,
0.0487936661,
-0.0029195559,
0.0187959485,
0.0065300618,
0.0288672242,
-0.0149794202,
-0.0413266122,
0.0051538497,
0.0493076891,
0.000433105,
0.0015939971,
0.0111338906,
-0.0825632587,
-0.0529977642,
-0.0198899247,
-0.0521878526,
-0.0106769232,
0.0010785564,
-0.0159639791,
0.0228735507,
-0.0196950957,
-0.0382145457,
0.0087886686,
-0.0593887419,
-0.0236528441,
-0.0030592016,
-0.0005832812,
0.0010610378,
0.022428235,
-0.0125757018,
0.0045839697,
0.0259920731,
-0.021494396,
0.0530304126,
-0.0128872013,
0.0198551528,
-0.0354958214,
0.0144776879,
-0.0541658141,
0.035008546,
-0.0438778698,
-0.0427565947,
0.0148022734,
0.0000615423,
-0.0164482668,
0.0528011881,
0.0311864335,
0.0033577799,
0.0806997716,
-0.0482214652,
-0.0114909215,
0.0039575659,
0.0301544778,
-0.0116725126,
-0.0363296121,
-0.0580180511,
0.0198877975,
0.0530648753,
0.030049907,
0.0129812956,
-0.0680581406,
0.0548563935,
-0.0013999273,
-0.0748115927,
0.0391332805,
-0.0237834509,
-0.0403921194,
0.0188187677,
-0.024412984,
0.0188125633,
0.070920907,
-0.0212239865,
-0.0350923799,
0.010739252,
0.0244150162,
0.0097340709,
0.0624417663,
0.020160282,
0.0308165923,
0.0124448556,
-0.021210745,
-0.0776415914,
-0.0324520096,
0.0473348349,
-0.0569408908,
-0.0141095696,
-0.0104050338,
-0.0300862379,
0.0191273745,
0.0112825818,
-0.0651195869,
-0.0464449897,
-0.0183033645,
-0.0348703787,
-0.0393493474,
-0.0284781493,
-0.0534927584,
-0.0002066615,
-0.0288924091,
0.0085176229,
-0.0101830978,
-0.0152497366,
0.000746679,
-0.007591187,
0.0772585422,
0.0284940563,
0.0203678608,
-0.0116151264,
0.0800710022,
0.0636241883,
-0.034668494,
0.0210937057,
-0.0053231167,
-0.0187786408,
0.0147706335,
-0.0414597914,
0.0181717277,
0.0006230581,
0.0300182588,
-0.0634824485,
-0.0084762927,
0.1008951962,
0.0291109346,
-0.0114891045,
0.0381508134,
-0.0427242629,
0.0426304266,
0.0206251815,
-0.0084653366,
-0.0632443503,
0.0099016456,
0.0027772048,
0.023863893,
-0.0631952658,
-0.0731424838,
-0.0189251211,
-0.1090875417,
0.0406084396,
0.0219898615,
-0.0265325289,
-0.0365907401,
0.0159191173,
0.0063052704,
0.0036697825,
0.0574677922,
-0.008241483,
0.0219877791,
-0.0051379413,
-0.0116749946,
-0.0367450155,
-0.0011291311,
0.0455959737,
-0.0224404726,
0.0822077319,
0.0265787933,
0.0983914807,
-0.011979823,
-0.0246311706,
-0.0556512438,
0.0214486029,
-0.0255616158,
0.028134834,
0.0718724951,
-0.018697679,
-0.0228739213,
0.0088933231,
0.0419788994,
-0.0136415018,
-0.0337307639,
0.0353127345,
0.0532290004,
-0.0310885943,
-0.0402042829,
-0.0010682456,
0.0283346269,
0.0299786646,
0.074135147,
-0.0015244074,
-0.02528302,
-0.0018838182,
-0.0080407197,
0.0370221175,
-0.0445670821,
-0.0895525888,
0.0257695951,
0.0709684864,
0.0055558654,
-0.076048784,
-0.0514259301,
0.0166421495,
0.0212824754,
-0.0056050452,
0.0161794852,
-0.0364142433,
0.0103283133,
-0.0431991331,
-0.0086883456,
-0.0525087602,
0.0374687575,
0.037862055,
-0.0011730691,
0.0205287263,
-0.0538645685,
0.0053592408,
0.0322663374,
-0.0441377424,
-0.0677016675,
0.0594674014,
0.0240832679,
0.0285433084,
0.0489589535,
-0.0205300935,
-0.0641820133,
0.0448244736,
0.0215132032,
-0.0473538227,
0.0320531093,
0.0104096057,
0.0173242614,
-0.0024652877,
0.0201662518,
-0.0184480753,
-0.0256577022,
-0.012830846,
0.0067581222,
-0.0318155698,
-0.0188150406,
0.0187998395,
0.0084777353,
0.0120624006,
-0.039634902,
0.022716891,
-0.0263329707,
-0.0051564807,
-0.0674361289,
-0.0032989562,
-0.0007260918,
-0.0029963525,
0.0502770059,
-0.0082646385,
0.0092374459,
-0.0482291542,
-0.0568125919,
-0.0263401214,
-0.0211067218,
0.0016753006,
0.0587709807,
0.0163682066,
0.0327938572,
0.0007940851,
-0.0092601059,
0.0198947508,
-0.0185248442,
0.0581810139,
0.0549190007,
0.0296860244,
0.0082503669,
-0.0226972271,
-0.0337950513,
0.0135514224,
-0.0482091494,
-0.0715247616,
0.0071522845,
0.021935327,
0.0079250876,
-0.0189243928,
0.0229849145,
-0.0375292152,
0.0156758707,
0.0197085552,
-0.0006943104,
0.0431789048,
-0.0180546567,
-0.0197819993,
0.0379070677,
-0.0327853709,
0.0305038523,
0.0563268177,
0.0339050181,
0.0814802721,
-0.0060047712,
-0.0346177556,
-0.02593592,
-0.0609076023,
-0.0262481477,
0.0182727929,
-0.034413036,
0.0030766935,
-0.100671038,
-0.0700226799,
-0.0107374312,
0.0141850496,
-0.0011204606,
-0.0180859882,
-0.0143345147,
0.0164525807,
0.0039509912,
0.0226956233,
-0.0470434912,
0.0347129442,
0.0111501571,
-0.0054142233,
0.0124290828,
-5.908621252e-33,
-0.0160446726,
-0.0218875464,
-0.0216189902,
-0.0260127485,
-0.0502940454,
0.0079502854,
-0.0099625075,
-0.0025171684,
-0.0003194656,
0.0162704941,
0.0053169876,
0.0400817804,
-0.0001460375,
-0.0141657917,
-0.0253730919,
-0.0600839593,
0.048871953,
0.0422685817,
-0.0438889749,
0.0163120031,
0.0398681127,
0.0224464722,
0.0562032163,
-0.0938663855,
0.0391014107,
-0.0296570398,
-0.0534283929,
-0.0042279353,
-0.0111524817,
0.0268842448,
-0.0044991225,
0.0336881988,
-0.0050565144,
-0.009311636,
0.007382188,
0.0020680958,
-0.0474896878,
-0.0199927278,
0.015600984,
0.0522323698,
0.0027815413,
-0.0218234751,
-0.00464063,
-0.0246848818,
0.0332009271,
-0.0304688886,
0.0339829922,
-0.0364827178,
0.019906139,
0.0404122248,
-0.0650815964,
-0.0158878881,
-0.0417267121,
-0.016389979,
-0.001608561,
0.0845189244,
0.0227840561,
-0.0231503509,
-0.088668935,
0.0091343727,
-0.0331147388,
-0.023483837,
0.0102070142,
0.0495021902,
0.0112152649,
0.0831149966,
0.0648297668,
0.0478194766,
-0.0466420539,
-0.0010424756,
0.0293490887,
0.0192517489,
0.0391112901,
0.0816215426,
0.0445527993,
-0.0186254326,
-0.0346321017,
-0.0062996405,
-0.0141174262,
0.0357245393,
0.0628427714,
-0.0104373731,
-0.0449701771,
-0.0270927008,
-0.0257551484,
0.0006598835,
0.0022207624,
-0.020733526,
-0.0090677757,
-0.044833377,
-0.0512892902,
0.0024766347,
0.0217185169,
-0.059645839,
0.025253661,
0.0173509773,
-0.0281376243,
0.0064031053,
-0.0040692659,
0.0200287756,
0.0308373775,
0.0229566284,
0.0367331728,
-0.0119963782,
0.0573449433,
0.0106250867,
-0.0014413784,
0.0307554398,
-0.0302057769,
-0.0127797099,
-0.0130966539,
0.0319581777,
0.0037128993,
0.0507869869,
0.0187107064,
-0.0204984173,
-0.0198437236,
-0.0573083013,
0.0194511898,
-0.0180886202,
-0.0165571179,
0.0387648903,
-0.0319781192,
-0.0077537242,
-0.0536768734,
-0.0232413914,
-0.0247978661,
-0.0164165627,
0.0493914336,
-0.0725007206,
-0.0114049073,
-0.0711027682,
2.859e-7,
-0.0250315927,
0.0237439238,
-0.009803107,
0.024526298,
0.0147770541,
0.0319127329,
0.0177853648,
0.0482753813,
0.0397233367,
-0.0961323902,
0.0304123759,
0.0099453628,
0.0500620455,
0.0664272383,
-0.0914929584,
-0.0468684584,
-0.0224587135,
-0.008577792,
-0.0255348682,
-0.0337728597,
0.0418607742,
0.0470058359,
0.0631343499,
-0.0260708705,
0.0431157164,
-0.0458273068,
0.0324262455,
-0.0226428285,
0.0056295502,
0.0474670008,
0.0608882681,
-0.0000224541,
0.0148459151,
0.0365120731,
-0.0108310208,
-0.0085166581,
0.0020814934,
-0.0091544073,
-0.0298131555,
-0.0044542607,
-0.0491308421,
-0.0179856122,
-0.0156679228,
-0.0741104707,
0.0696894228,
-0.0223215129,
-0.0538361482,
0.00955135,
-0.0354859419,
-0.0207451135,
0.0618282594,
0.0025210977,
-0.041056443,
0.0234006736,
0.0122690629,
0.0259713419,
0.0098477723,
-0.0748652518,
-0.03108114,
0.0037717107,
-0.0270358957,
-0.0375665613,
0.0382630453,
-0.03625286,
-0.0134686567,
-0.0675171465,
0.0435698815,
2.562532915e-34,
-0.0217369776,
0.0607163943,
0.0168574322,
0.0066548893,
0.0494875386,
-0.0010686732,
0.0675528869,
0.0220716149,
0.0478476472,
-0.0150236171,
-0.0183689222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17257v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17257v1 | Leveraging Parameter-Efficient Transfer Learning for Multi-Lingual Text-to-Speech Adaptation | 2024-06-25T03:50:54 | 2024-06-25T03:50:54 | Yingting Li, Ambuj Mehrish, Bryan Chew, Bo Cheng, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Different languages have distinct phonetic systems and vary in their prosodic
features making it challenging to develop a Text-to-Speech (TTS) model that can
effectively synthesise speech in multilingual settings. Furthermore, TTS
architecture needs to be both efficient enough to capture nuances in multiple
languages and efficient enough to be practical for deployment. The standard
approach is to build transformer based model such as SpeechT5 and train it on
large multilingual dataset. As the size of these models grow the conventional
fine-tuning for adapting these model becomes impractical due to heavy
computational cost. In this paper, we proposes to integrate parameter-efficient
transfer learning (PETL) methods such as adapters and hypernetwork with TTS
architecture for multilingual speech synthesis. Notably, in our experiments
PETL methods able to achieve comparable or even better performance compared to
full fine-tuning with only $\sim$2.5\% tunable parameters.The code and samples
are available at: https://anonymous.4open.science/r/multilingualTTS-BA4C. | [
-0.0055777212,
0.0317217745,
0.0014996903,
0.0026286819,
0.0106970891,
-0.0260821097,
0.0387544446,
-0.0323311128,
-0.0327063985,
0.0234316923,
-0.0820638984,
-0.0188758876,
0.0352907442,
0.0305705927,
0.0367897376,
-0.0925459042,
0.0315575078,
-0.0359709896,
-0.0428781882,
-0.0032784669,
-0.0147397658,
0.0509811528,
-0.0265440997,
0.0199834425,
0.0207866821,
0.0344393179,
-0.0180869419,
0.0141494209,
0.0384833552,
0.0393177606,
-0.0298268516,
0.0035827837,
0.0071691042,
0.034862753,
0.0000020886,
-0.0122952759,
-0.0621084757,
0.0006760674,
0.0166582204,
0.0197100416,
0.079788141,
-0.0208790153,
-0.0269888788,
0.0247674938,
0.0187632889,
-0.0159662347,
0.0925131664,
0.0446488038,
0.0363864861,
0.0974241719,
-0.0283336136,
-0.0054898765,
0.0044237282,
-0.0014063256,
-0.0423400775,
-0.0217652805,
-0.005984195,
-0.0281962175,
0.0064896871,
-0.0253084432,
-0.0460888445,
0.0469429307,
-0.0002559593,
0.0030542233,
-0.050165657,
-0.0322588645,
-0.0275534093,
-0.0282591507,
-0.0201220904,
0.0654630363,
-0.0504487231,
-0.0164965913,
0.0208603311,
-0.0000047566,
-0.0110296961,
-0.0120206708,
-0.0094901696,
-0.0224110913,
0.0345901661,
0.0016307924,
-0.00289806,
0.0030032096,
0.016990656,
-0.0293880906,
-0.0405150466,
0.0050901542,
0.0394546203,
0.0065365112,
0.0142649086,
-0.0025671828,
0.026770005,
0.031155806,
0.0549098924,
0.0089428397,
-0.0203020703,
-0.0023559863,
-0.0491440259,
-0.0783694535,
-0.0404290371,
-0.0111260274,
0.068358615,
0.0429885797,
0.0030563653,
-0.029499637,
-0.0652612746,
0.0022502297,
-0.0483739339,
-0.0101661868,
-0.0482090078,
-0.0546698831,
-0.0408996977,
0.0473738499,
-0.0803970844,
0.0128319161,
-0.02287836,
-0.0104125086,
-0.0172560159,
0.0136346351,
-0.0281517301,
-0.0317756385,
0.0331384614,
-0.0168666746,
-0.0650033653,
-0.0440250002,
0.0334077962,
0.0846113563,
0.0194029044,
0.017454017,
-0.0194486529,
-0.0781711861,
-0.0052096406,
0.0346458368,
0.0476726219,
-0.0098764636,
0.0213843938,
0.0502805933,
-0.0415394306,
-0.0101011163,
-0.0270844623,
0.0174768157,
-0.0072961994,
-0.0379358903,
0.0303157289,
-0.0456931479,
0.0472737998,
-0.0344574377,
0.0059584472,
-0.0270043276,
-0.0409685895,
-0.014020157,
-0.0045667607,
0.0189059321,
-0.0196223576,
0.0118914833,
0.0418964475,
-0.0179115254,
-0.0476714894,
0.0722987652,
0.0773231909,
-0.0034992425,
-0.0299798213,
-0.0605159104,
-0.0427429378,
0.0620829836,
0.02282409,
0.0239762645,
-0.0052119363,
-0.0340349041,
0.0109075895,
0.0303417575,
0.0682396814,
0.0154162953,
-0.0069190431,
0.013460624,
0.0747339427,
-0.000727677,
0.0756866783,
0.037291605,
0.0650792718,
0.008670765,
-0.0039134431,
-0.0402675271,
0.0000027885,
0.0418487899,
0.0103001343,
0.0061597633,
-0.0117824655,
0.0688614249,
-0.0371773653,
0.0076136715,
0.0441567041,
-0.0156591795,
-0.0073367837,
-0.0140574798,
0.0394127965,
0.0501228422,
-0.0728206187,
0.0957571268,
0.0271725766,
-0.0697082505,
0.0498125367,
-0.0058290903,
-0.0032687765,
0.0219219588,
-0.0187860988,
0.0097698187,
-0.0207559578,
-0.0273807328,
0.0054107248,
0.0404434875,
0.0408132896,
0.0260916892,
0.0796715766,
-0.0722812265,
0.0101360064,
0.0212980937,
-0.0133782048,
0.1052983329,
-0.0739603937,
0.0601892397,
-0.0003433148,
0.0048562982,
0.0255479142,
-0.0031305468,
-0.0489176027,
0.0068858555,
0.0513622984,
0.0102255139,
0.0380726941,
0.0179826394,
-0.0118286777,
-0.01404671,
-0.019782275,
-0.0271179397,
0.0056202882,
0.0012525127,
-0.0553034283,
-0.0117995096,
-0.0000595071,
-0.0460413806,
0.0497621782,
0.0519536398,
0.0236154385,
-0.0934769735,
0.0735783204,
0.0113969557,
0.037542928,
0.0064157345,
0.0104865246,
0.0045912438,
0.0706058517,
0.038467519,
-0.0449003838,
0.0701277405,
-0.0194457006,
0.0191524047,
0.0169337206,
-0.0023035035,
-0.0434312448,
-0.0025329664,
0.04622164,
-0.0017806785,
0.0174924023,
-0.0196418297,
0.0224013329,
0.0089061474,
-0.0313595757,
-0.0680872723,
0.0337492079,
-0.0025188976,
0.0418613888,
0.0024710835,
0.0390466191,
-0.0034218789,
-0.0049316422,
-0.0234133657,
0.0004643855,
-0.0152331078,
-0.0184264611,
-0.0209254846,
-0.0055084256,
-0.0241334606,
-0.0188155137,
-0.0049477466,
0.0346880704,
0.0100285718,
-0.0540826991,
-0.0119364653,
-0.0394767188,
-0.0137280086,
-0.0010995818,
0.0216556247,
0.030402096,
-0.0277744122,
-0.0320231989,
0.0058551366,
0.0367797948,
0.0085115079,
-0.0202541985,
-0.0440827906,
0.0328577086,
-0.0231327694,
-0.0389396884,
0.0084262965,
-0.0209289957,
0.0042893109,
-0.0338884704,
0.0052445671,
0.0011435915,
0.0396389291,
0.0085739521,
-0.0223038793,
-0.0795182213,
-0.022050688,
0.0171272047,
0.003117376,
0.0271499902,
0.0189098641,
-0.0272573549,
-0.0182893164,
0.0085874163,
-0.0064839222,
0.0107991192,
-0.0619937517,
-0.0557038561,
-0.073297821,
-0.0300706029,
0.0033853611,
-0.0383623838,
0.0089007085,
0.0389016382,
-0.0112897847,
-0.0235114321,
-0.0377828516,
0.0279979259,
0.0248526093,
-0.0237253942,
0.0298843402,
-0.0230167657,
-0.0257454775,
-0.0328271762,
-0.02174142,
-0.001776728,
0.0375498608,
-0.0028978197,
0.0365815386,
0.0169471931,
-0.0462808646,
-0.0241206083,
0.0001895588,
0.0414996184,
0.0737852082,
0.016419813,
0.0003007037,
-0.040924754,
0.0390909798,
0.010402089,
0.0209646672,
0.0029164767,
0.0131412316,
0.0003942335,
-0.031321343,
0.0501112081,
0.0030281574,
-0.0626384541,
0.0117634758,
0.0430973247,
0.0133228535,
0.0102445474,
0.0225538537,
0.0557090379,
-0.0237238109,
0.0208314527,
0.0762568787,
-0.0481379144,
-0.0124226101,
0.0105607063,
0.0044805189,
0.0499870367,
-0.017134618,
0.0224046409,
-0.0270273387,
-0.0196941905,
0.030912105,
0.0194854047,
-0.0019903702,
0.0060010948,
-0.0562704988,
-0.1047614366,
0.0187988505,
0.0429418869,
-0.0606793649,
-0.0363214575,
-0.0175470971,
-0.0306110661,
-0.0036477293,
0.0215855297,
0.007777947,
-0.0001361424,
-0.0402551852,
0.042367503,
-0.0404026136,
-0.0541152209,
-0.0078466311,
-0.0271352753,
0.0712806359,
-0.0192336682,
0.0183755439,
-0.0408677794,
-0.0357975885,
-0.0067423363,
-0.0152573893,
-0.034559194,
0.0097610392,
0.0007190282,
0.0279710088,
-0.0309930127,
0.0437148884,
0.0410305858,
-0.0561207831,
0.0313565917,
0.0211329199,
0.0817290172,
0.026853852,
-0.0332116149,
0.0241107792,
0.0108632334,
0.0126772579,
0.0280251428,
0.0111726588,
-0.0774717554,
0.0189154204,
0.0264738984,
-0.0524387769,
-0.0719628036,
-0.0070458814,
0.0098012304,
-0.0400700532,
-0.060061641,
-0.0551275089,
0.0390931256,
-0.0135423429,
0.0543211177,
0.0486616157,
-0.0014748932,
0.014938659,
0.0082982825,
0.0074714241,
0.0079935333,
-0.019429585,
0.0158873107,
-0.0338203348,
-0.0192712229,
0.0195381977,
-0.0524147749,
-0.0044178558,
0.0080491491,
-0.0314310454,
-0.0429202355,
-0.0084202448,
0.0172503125,
0.0053860447,
0.0601148568,
-0.0019587397,
-0.0153902592,
0.040147204,
-0.0025983469,
0.0018235078,
0.0074947695,
0.0921527967,
0.000080677,
0.0050374917,
0.0181296784,
-0.0441465639,
0.0397326164,
0.0150020998,
-0.0070393179,
0.0393339135,
-0.0528369136,
-0.0284080543,
-0.005277745,
0.0003578279,
-0.0137746427,
0.0212105233,
-0.0354180709,
0.0035814703,
-0.0078176074,
0.0573287867,
-0.0615237579,
-0.0127341775,
0.0370800756,
0.0229253378,
-0.0042927065,
-0.0271897726,
0.0544832312,
-0.0129557857,
0.0318075642,
0.0328747071,
0.0220615007,
0.0288627036,
0.0406675152,
0.0127339475,
-0.0279006008,
-0.0189410951,
0.0262730643,
0.0051110866,
-0.0336149894,
-0.0084957927,
0.0057966658,
-0.0043064686,
-0.0192102231,
0.0023801301,
-0.0089514256,
-0.017178975,
-0.0311461575,
-0.0223438814,
0.0329519063,
0.0003973839,
0.1432947367,
-0.0275838152,
0.0192113947,
-0.024599947,
0.0338618755,
-0.0587327331,
0.0442402028,
-0.0045950636,
-0.0313860215,
0.0074451836,
0.0193699915,
0.0138705084,
-0.0152309313,
0.0268720221,
-0.023279462,
0.0514205433,
-0.0074525662,
-0.0194850117,
-0.0157410763,
-0.016066242,
-0.0193150844,
-0.021418564,
0.0064883428,
-0.0422213264,
0.0355611853,
-0.0326091312,
0.003910928,
-0.0453461744,
0.0255217031,
0.0002495912,
-0.0391990654,
0.0022514102,
-0.0107301176,
-0.0342680439,
0.0365846381,
0.0150602525,
0.0172259584,
-5.942402389e-33,
-0.0193458777,
0.0499091595,
-0.00053807,
0.0317671299,
-0.0434923656,
-0.0414288864,
-0.0407106206,
-0.0065779323,
-0.0315388255,
-0.0031476927,
0.0049910676,
-0.0402603522,
0.0263797175,
0.0499685295,
-0.0033190434,
0.022960959,
0.0655288473,
-0.0096757673,
-0.011013452,
0.0737437382,
0.04479184,
0.0443725027,
0.0772000253,
-0.0381558836,
-0.0559820235,
0.0135818291,
0.0014646344,
-0.0262501128,
0.0180379692,
0.0103917001,
0.0340984166,
0.0752613097,
-0.0180310216,
-0.0418209322,
-0.0493606776,
0.02591406,
-0.0575665645,
-0.0110580502,
-0.0087078335,
0.0636760592,
-0.0022976801,
-0.0458465777,
0.0298231151,
0.010209728,
-0.0270311292,
-0.035129901,
0.0034400786,
-0.0474337265,
-0.0287222676,
-0.0775539652,
-0.0661159307,
0.0239430778,
-0.0158365704,
-0.0047951741,
0.0366865322,
0.0690182,
-0.0424005352,
-0.0170013327,
-0.0641518384,
0.0021271314,
-0.020423336,
0.0301862136,
0.0464329496,
0.02480538,
-0.0356386378,
-0.0130792279,
0.0583650805,
-0.0379756838,
0.0742295161,
0.0360753611,
0.0921078026,
0.0392864943,
0.057916712,
0.0394368432,
-0.0099051828,
-0.081215933,
-0.0174419619,
-0.0159836058,
0.0027108307,
-0.0240879823,
0.0338772684,
0.0230641663,
0.0147548849,
0.0172358695,
-0.0495916866,
-0.0337510966,
0.0082242601,
-0.0398065299,
0.0381154828,
-0.0196536556,
-0.0002675122,
-0.0109364064,
0.09721113,
-0.0225820467,
0.0063512274,
0.0069780839,
-0.0762325153,
-0.0037982808,
-0.0067982012,
0.0149133811,
-0.0517039485,
-0.0868289024,
0.0236801766,
0.0146678034,
0.0238609202,
-0.0174697116,
-0.013617822,
0.0688768253,
-0.0634401366,
0.0008594871,
-0.0282783732,
0.0392057039,
0.0036691104,
0.081312567,
0.0032633874,
-0.047523696,
-0.0046163928,
0.024434479,
-0.0296667833,
-0.0256536845,
0.0424308255,
0.0327119306,
0.0209450163,
0.0169894472,
-0.0538625158,
0.0276788622,
-0.0246716253,
-0.0157756805,
0.0488299988,
-0.0278627388,
-0.0260087494,
0.0111634247,
2.935e-7,
-0.0176648386,
0.014071472,
0.0027875789,
-0.0684472546,
0.0163057428,
0.0301878136,
-0.0220479369,
0.0413831957,
0.0058284975,
0.0525199696,
-0.006133758,
-0.0094754044,
0.1027002335,
0.0166973956,
-0.0729959458,
-0.0665462911,
-0.0338990539,
0.043153096,
-0.0227066446,
-0.0047822851,
-0.0028243698,
0.0579333976,
-0.0110612223,
-0.0383085497,
0.0256104544,
-0.0151477493,
0.0249609184,
-0.033888761,
0.0070724268,
-0.0073669227,
0.0130116874,
-0.0183902495,
-0.0448204614,
-0.0135754263,
-0.0526579805,
0.06018674,
0.0132262325,
0.0643498898,
0.0185664147,
-0.0367109403,
0.0532993414,
0.0124038793,
-0.0492790863,
-0.022761384,
0.0558601841,
-0.0371717177,
-0.0171371549,
-0.0140507817,
0.0045996257,
0.0085177477,
-0.0075911079,
-0.0506468639,
-0.0052192044,
0.0204503965,
0.0437011681,
0.0090417191,
-0.0552692302,
-0.017594656,
-0.0012739375,
0.0486992821,
-0.0511826463,
-0.045117721,
-0.0309394374,
-0.0401786491,
0.0344590098,
-0.0265113004,
0.0108240405,
2.202517107e-34,
-0.0068408288,
-0.0560452379,
0.038096007,
-0.0227689296,
-0.0071790619,
-0.0339654088,
0.0253393892,
0.024590414,
-0.0072219064,
-0.0550604463,
-0.051362399
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17255v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17255v1 | MPCODER: Multi-user Personalized Code Generator with Explicit and Implicit Style Representation Learning | 2024-06-25T03:45:28 | 2024-06-25T03:45:28 | Zhenlong Dai, Chang Yao, WenKang Han, Ying Yuan, Zhipeng Gao, Jingyuan Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated great potential for assisting
developers in their daily development. However, most research focuses on
generating correct code, how to use LLMs to generate personalized code has
seldom been investigated. To bridge this gap, we proposed MPCoder (Multi-user
Personalized Code Generator) to generate personalized code for multiple users.
To better learn coding style features, we utilize explicit coding style
residual learning to capture the syntax code style standards and implicit style
learning to capture the semantic code style conventions. We train a multi-user
style adapter to better differentiate the implicit feature representations of
different users through contrastive learning, ultimately enabling personalized
code generation for multiple users. We further propose a novel evaluation
metric for estimating similarities between codes of different coding styles.
The experimental results show the effectiveness of our approach for this novel
task. | [
-0.0007687935,
0.0591626577,
-0.0335278437,
0.0096999509,
-0.0016104935,
-0.0076139634,
0.0012709559,
0.0165392458,
-0.0089103933,
0.0150453821,
-0.0614116602,
0.0055079437,
-0.0197707545,
0.0143095208,
0.0392998271,
-0.0462694205,
-0.0149526317,
0.0078555224,
0.007173555,
0.0033798935,
0.0275044758,
0.0217669159,
0.0385865681,
0.0729927495,
0.0171643235,
-0.0302546304,
0.0113185728,
0.021417113,
-0.0152588794,
-0.0057096411,
0.0350228325,
0.0648889318,
-0.0023420227,
0.013478091,
0.0000018131,
0.0002481152,
-0.0056705195,
-0.0413603224,
0.0527499132,
0.0270411689,
0.0071247811,
0.02366364,
-0.0045020762,
-0.0008271154,
-0.0583864599,
-0.0673222989,
0.0617659613,
-0.0029865368,
0.1055274904,
0.0300472137,
-0.0045923074,
-0.0369484723,
-0.006523483,
0.0035470352,
0.0443275906,
0.0137976687,
-0.0222350229,
0.015014166,
-0.0247611813,
-0.0055762818,
0.0028443388,
0.0002376425,
0.0112971859,
-0.0219856314,
0.0383094773,
0.031081086,
-0.0372770801,
0.0360284783,
0.0028524895,
0.0555544943,
-0.0049980381,
-0.0247477889,
0.0144751435,
-0.0106050959,
-0.0088530025,
-0.0155366156,
-0.04922406,
-0.0169453546,
-0.0152154258,
0.0226517413,
-0.0146910744,
0.004515897,
0.0024648476,
-0.0084213885,
0.0047496818,
0.0022560558,
0.0204879474,
0.005760096,
-0.0560309961,
-0.0032998829,
-0.0148029644,
-0.0657524019,
0.0021168969,
0.0194977392,
-0.0151142031,
-0.0307324901,
-0.0591681525,
-0.0615907535,
0.0126218116,
-0.0394302234,
0.0867986232,
0.0539554097,
-0.0015318039,
-0.027384866,
-0.0750167072,
0.0474301204,
-0.0154209845,
-0.0136813717,
0.0052930457,
0.003028617,
-0.0780423507,
-0.0054676854,
-0.0347793736,
0.0221773703,
0.0221385229,
0.0239316747,
-0.0170574896,
0.0707357153,
-0.016262766,
0.0356357805,
0.006603471,
-0.008726011,
-0.0435200557,
0.001695462,
0.0416881219,
-0.0248168465,
-0.0441445671,
-0.0429990441,
-0.0114048822,
-0.0382452495,
0.0100831641,
0.0202464499,
-0.0108519476,
-0.0181594249,
-0.0166023076,
0.0444358103,
-0.0186126456,
0.0446776114,
-0.0499209948,
-0.0296798125,
0.0392540097,
0.0258149039,
-0.0267101657,
-0.0961544439,
-0.0653441623,
0.02161148,
0.0029724734,
-0.1241846085,
-0.0151260961,
-0.0166109372,
0.0510044619,
0.0175910071,
-0.0264140908,
-0.0098502077,
0.0418486334,
-0.0051393257,
-0.0254825559,
0.0383079425,
0.0403400101,
0.0343824811,
-0.0048667132,
-0.0497847609,
0.003144868,
0.0222303346,
-0.0068990113,
0.038106937,
-0.0471330248,
-0.0028238927,
0.0660214052,
-0.009127304,
0.0548713878,
0.0471434668,
-0.0279171448,
-0.0282268915,
0.0101524442,
-0.0224670321,
0.0539040156,
0.0873620734,
0.1128033474,
0.0191172566,
-0.0018282204,
-0.0080439011,
0.0265786853,
0.0332050174,
0.0045309626,
0.0042436346,
0.0157306697,
0.0137214577,
-0.0295022037,
-0.0345763713,
0.0163595248,
-0.005642972,
0.003731129,
-0.0221962091,
-0.0016098676,
-0.0111864218,
-0.0390075259,
0.0140226223,
-0.0040304014,
-0.0825442523,
-0.0294262189,
-0.0219980702,
0.0153407808,
0.0825992674,
-0.0014624242,
0.0128720626,
0.0025865869,
-0.0166483168,
-0.0243362747,
-0.0327968895,
0.0497200228,
-0.0336795747,
0.0225716922,
-0.0830368251,
-0.0237459093,
-0.0191308949,
-0.0308689829,
0.0332583673,
0.0140314605,
-0.0134575749,
0.0453979447,
0.0225125607,
-0.0201081447,
0.0365779139,
-0.0229380932,
-0.0161158815,
0.0407610014,
-0.0193765759,
0.0016748416,
-0.0262233745,
-0.0312345214,
-0.016930161,
0.0053734854,
-0.0553344674,
-0.0024258511,
-0.0190180615,
-0.0528076924,
-0.032088615,
0.0093518514,
-0.0326382518,
0.0008936556,
0.0025670445,
-0.0176255126,
-0.0072514955,
0.030674791,
-0.0012031306,
0.0678510368,
-0.0177313462,
0.0038487203,
-0.0000230815,
-0.0032694526,
-0.0144736283,
0.0256086104,
-0.0054070847,
0.0048457901,
-0.0111260861,
0.0599318705,
0.0263631362,
0.0056528267,
0.0152232563,
-0.0411573946,
0.0045231455,
0.0506180674,
-0.0172715336,
0.0373073258,
-0.0148195429,
-0.0437856838,
-0.0841743052,
-0.0104344739,
-0.016342517,
-0.0001051719,
0.0119469883,
0.0553828701,
0.0081961779,
-0.0231141169,
-0.0523085594,
0.0091205928,
-0.0533722267,
0.0145755066,
0.0242503863,
-0.0094333272,
-0.0785075054,
-0.0363017768,
-0.0119222803,
-0.0293980427,
0.0522179343,
-0.0090344157,
0.0220236927,
-0.0668777004,
0.0173010491,
-0.0022635863,
0.0049589584,
0.0103494041,
-0.048818551,
0.0147993509,
-0.0573223643,
0.0717445835,
0.0500588417,
0.0139308861,
0.002140319,
0.033426933,
0.0064453166,
-0.0644421801,
0.0072493409,
0.0384680815,
-0.0367552936,
-0.0042259167,
-0.032636527,
0.0521672405,
0.0672146082,
0.0369482078,
0.0031907051,
-0.0688728467,
0.0376766101,
0.0481903777,
-0.0057807374,
0.0513297208,
-0.0068521025,
0.0164295994,
0.0449967571,
0.0095453747,
-0.0899870768,
0.078588292,
-0.0459831432,
-0.0120956693,
0.0438186713,
-0.0309852492,
-0.0417539887,
0.0307595432,
-0.0185503941,
0.0418039784,
-0.0049728053,
-0.0585372485,
-0.0198244788,
-0.0057176519,
0.031835299,
-0.0028337459,
0.0461961553,
-0.024438737,
0.010799096,
0.0145266708,
-0.0491160266,
-0.0241046622,
-0.0517624915,
-0.0095082289,
0.003911044,
0.0445503704,
-0.0142592369,
0.0700886846,
0.0209785756,
-0.0171316862,
0.0390970297,
0.01742764,
-0.0482595563,
0.0045482418,
-0.0245216712,
-0.0361723937,
-0.0463051461,
-0.0770934969,
-0.0332576782,
-0.0444997326,
0.0083254091,
0.0333131552,
0.0331317261,
-0.0781912208,
0.0326387659,
0.0723612532,
-0.0263336524,
-0.0425326824,
0.0383754857,
0.0874414966,
-0.0203177612,
-0.0038586382,
0.0959510952,
0.0393342376,
-0.1003531367,
0.0061740526,
-0.0386008285,
0.0884888247,
0.0605108999,
0.0540736318,
-0.0467086956,
-0.0381372347,
-0.025274029,
-0.0006885107,
-0.0050212145,
-0.0130015239,
-0.0178114325,
-0.030447023,
-0.0240182523,
0.0307708755,
-0.0481696017,
0.003303451,
0.011923233,
-0.0090721929,
0.0105048558,
-0.0674239695,
0.0187123809,
-0.0251804255,
0.0194625184,
0.0052352962,
-0.0228846967,
-0.0142855216,
-0.0062152725,
-0.0517176054,
0.0332805701,
0.1155843884,
-0.0172880776,
0.0304054171,
-0.051923383,
-0.0267299972,
-0.0062319576,
0.019013796,
-0.0388849713,
0.0104965605,
-0.007655276,
-0.0084721353,
0.005806407,
0.0189151913,
-0.0211794656,
0.0202883538,
0.0281651076,
0.0259213429,
-0.0295420811,
-0.0051524835,
-0.0143059324,
-0.0211261958,
0.0277932789,
0.0015081137,
0.0761429295,
-0.0347551182,
-0.0448636077,
-0.1112470925,
0.0026640347,
-0.0261095483,
-0.0092958026,
-0.0244233925,
0.0053262408,
-0.0235201381,
-0.0651101843,
0.0056084529,
0.0027992488,
0.034938138,
-0.0044228747,
-0.0379191115,
-0.0507944077,
-0.0193977486,
-0.0643666089,
-0.0317481942,
-0.0141733335,
0.0242474247,
-0.0129896086,
-0.0555372946,
0.0346754976,
-0.0209443215,
0.0177310519,
0.0067303395,
-0.0683286786,
-0.0430254489,
-0.0252173878,
0.0602900274,
0.0022476453,
0.0440112203,
-0.0050632372,
-0.09797059,
-0.0204827916,
0.0337790139,
-0.0159664713,
-0.015438363,
0.0473639742,
-0.0305961147,
0.042950172,
0.0132356184,
-0.0466152132,
0.0058198581,
0.0294719748,
-0.0000165003,
-0.0338391215,
-0.0097993091,
0.0279159229,
-0.0062290896,
-0.0127278166,
0.0160375386,
-0.0035760568,
0.0266823135,
-0.02438052,
-0.0113390135,
-0.0436076708,
-0.0425094478,
-0.0003800908,
0.0135079743,
-0.011953447,
0.0254047699,
0.0034665023,
-0.0120850271,
0.057743486,
-0.0312319621,
0.0837038904,
0.004388758,
0.0657220334,
0.0388666987,
0.0092290444,
-0.0366743244,
0.0185772907,
0.0201717131,
0.0334460884,
-0.0154454587,
0.0530132204,
0.0083218878,
0.0484878123,
0.0049443417,
0.0138699887,
-0.0175901353,
-0.0595038459,
-0.0426843837,
-0.0194816962,
0.0162153058,
0.0449569821,
0.0131953349,
-0.0019251691,
0.0312220231,
-0.0172614232,
0.0761421472,
-0.0278479308,
-0.0324092545,
-0.0174256917,
-0.000435734,
-0.0127999699,
-0.0582041591,
0.0941984281,
0.0009522565,
-0.0249893256,
-0.0511100739,
-0.0143732,
-0.0304007158,
0.0549471453,
0.0748101175,
-0.0041505415,
0.0254409797,
-0.025963055,
-0.0060663833,
-0.0362300165,
0.0422005765,
0.0285204779,
0.0052361307,
0.0363623984,
0.0197094288,
0.088618286,
-0.023369506,
-0.05727439,
-0.0450526252,
0.0156930294,
0.0105396882,
-0.0335860327,
-0.0500022471,
-5.537734785e-33,
-0.0537767895,
-0.0165828969,
-0.0158254094,
0.0410976708,
-0.0031711753,
-0.0414864756,
-0.0349130481,
-0.0060693272,
0.0265386607,
-0.0493616089,
0.0221367609,
-0.0084631564,
-0.0133726625,
-0.0167077407,
0.0744401813,
0.0329967327,
0.0891661867,
0.04140817,
-0.036257688,
0.0457054563,
-0.012540631,
0.0229859781,
0.0399448238,
-0.0481609218,
-0.0446150899,
-0.0114527037,
0.0488644987,
-0.0231468529,
0.0590127185,
0.0620470196,
0.0355402566,
-0.0186621416,
-0.0190966483,
-0.0118352873,
-0.0483165458,
-0.0571619347,
-0.0119024906,
-0.0618701801,
0.0022349996,
0.0178172104,
0.0152250454,
-0.0884542912,
0.1198026985,
-0.0383743159,
-0.029238889,
-0.0036638458,
0.039865125,
0.0197777078,
-0.0044431654,
-0.0277242716,
-0.0073274197,
0.0338813141,
-0.0273880735,
0.0299821831,
-0.0103664855,
-0.0073902085,
-0.0249960274,
0.0379521661,
-0.0200216491,
0.0113137132,
-0.0202264711,
0.0248709992,
0.0380990803,
0.0518178158,
0.0413994044,
0.0230971016,
0.0396613143,
0.0279127546,
-0.0485815816,
0.0202456955,
0.0362551995,
0.0312543325,
-0.0047977455,
0.0622790493,
0.0057811947,
-0.0016739338,
0.034304522,
0.0452006646,
0.0223741494,
0.0163178053,
0.0187976416,
0.0757038742,
0.0000079559,
-0.0202192161,
-0.0407247841,
-0.0399881303,
0.0008831852,
-0.0721730888,
-0.00348262,
-0.0430070199,
0.010372295,
0.0084946863,
0.0370839983,
-0.0207797345,
-0.0131273232,
-0.0001609665,
-0.0515294857,
0.0550156087,
-0.0023003784,
-0.0211901646,
0.0026862198,
0.0048171571,
0.0179766919,
-0.0366051272,
0.0576286428,
0.0280283429,
0.0226711538,
0.0206335168,
-0.073152259,
-0.0277159903,
-0.0214280542,
-0.0465660729,
-0.0135898702,
0.004163689,
0.0228852164,
0.0118403286,
-0.0229079723,
0.0314671323,
-0.0117383283,
-0.0258699134,
-0.0403754301,
-0.0474298745,
0.046028275,
0.0125336638,
-0.0298027508,
-0.0146566723,
-0.0754025802,
0.0149863297,
0.0179264806,
-0.0160013027,
-0.0505662523,
-0.0005150701,
2.534e-7,
-0.0210667066,
0.0054276451,
-0.0107507026,
0.0257008635,
0.0015317983,
0.0582270361,
-0.0006808104,
0.0167499278,
-0.0081238979,
0.0169304572,
-0.0129106632,
0.0362412073,
0.0266127959,
0.0491919331,
-0.0382737108,
0.0515667424,
-0.0248332322,
0.0507085286,
-0.041108802,
0.0149135636,
0.0693210512,
0.0335151404,
0.0290711876,
0.0320034064,
0.0777437165,
0.0044422825,
0.0558018498,
-0.0114973979,
0.0220614392,
0.0324684829,
-0.0244532283,
-0.0286620893,
-0.0026538393,
-0.0066080447,
0.0096037546,
-0.0389356613,
0.009133446,
0.0716026276,
-0.0368225873,
0.0707693249,
0.0274521858,
-0.0016396629,
0.000900567,
-0.0387737751,
0.012721085,
-0.0002036703,
0.0010407065,
-0.0008201837,
-0.0154582709,
-0.0083585158,
0.0191614684,
-0.0092231119,
0.0176597554,
0.0268614963,
0.0061719394,
-0.0294635482,
-0.0512178019,
-0.0117998468,
-0.0449763164,
0.004444323,
-0.0103140194,
-0.0151903266,
-0.0510759838,
0.0139510809,
0.0023038052,
0.0285606924,
0.0384245589,
2.136249531e-34,
0.0162835903,
-0.0050516557,
0.0255977642,
0.0340327024,
0.0467344411,
-0.0101966327,
0.0168732256,
0.0332727022,
0.0460896343,
-0.0538490377,
-0.0165061858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17253v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17253v1 | How Well Can Knowledge Edit Methods Edit Perplexing Knowledge? | 2024-06-25T03:41:02 | 2024-06-25T03:41:02 | Huaizhi Ge, Frank Rudzicz, Zining Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) are widely deployed, targeted editing of
their knowledge has become a critical challenge. Recently, advancements in
model editing techniques, such as Rank-One Model Editing (ROME), have paved the
way for updating LLMs with new knowledge. However, the efficacy of these
methods varies across different types of knowledge. This study investigates the
capability of knowledge editing methods to incorporate new knowledge with
varying degrees of "perplexingness", a term we use to describe the initial
difficulty LLMs have in understanding new concepts. We begin by quantifying the
"perplexingness" of target knowledge using pre-edit conditional probabilities,
and assess the efficacy of edits through post-edit conditional probabilities.
Utilizing the widely-used CounterFact dataset, we find significant negative
correlations between the "perplexingness" of the new knowledge and the edit
efficacy across all 12 scenarios. To dive deeper into this phenomenon, we
introduce a novel dataset, HierarchyData, consisting of 99 hyponym-hypernym
pairs across diverse categories. Our analysis reveal that more abstract
concepts (hypernyms) tend to be more perplexing than their specific
counterparts (hyponyms). Further exploration into the influence of knowledge
hierarchy on editing outcomes indicates that knowledge positioned at higher
hierarchical levels is more challenging to modify in some scenarios. Our
research highlights a previously overlooked aspect of LLM editing: the variable
efficacy of editing methods in handling perplexing knowledge. By revealing how
hierarchical relationships can influence editing outcomes, our findings offer
new insights into the challenges of updating LLMs and pave the way for more
nuanced approaches to model editing in the future. | [
0.0949498713,
0.0515384264,
-0.0509095825,
0.0331018716,
-0.0353276841,
0.0095224734,
-0.0244066324,
0.0011065981,
-0.0232184529,
-0.0546692982,
-0.0310993772,
-0.0233131107,
0.0236031357,
0.0129614277,
0.0218495373,
-0.0585770793,
0.0589649156,
-0.0115218582,
-0.0093619665,
0.0056927018,
-0.019163752,
0.0025813174,
0.011374482,
0.0243287887,
0.0293612219,
-0.0326278992,
-0.0190151148,
0.0205003526,
-0.0042452728,
-0.040928375,
0.0066708415,
0.1044955105,
0.0042565218,
0.083588846,
0.0000021105,
-0.0722627193,
-0.0368669778,
0.0018213291,
-0.0537050143,
0.0368274786,
0.0256950893,
-0.005285264,
-0.0240103267,
-0.0352307223,
0.001531468,
0.0394293852,
0.050241679,
0.0028007785,
0.0220909137,
0.0133311972,
0.0006178177,
-0.0020360902,
0.0089130737,
-0.0233982969,
0.0274496675,
-0.0400079638,
0.0318496414,
0.047696501,
-0.0630928203,
0.0212892964,
-0.0128507875,
0.0442146026,
-0.0110607371,
-0.0212253779,
0.0235562678,
-0.0226668194,
-0.0047722398,
-0.010949105,
0.0271805171,
0.0467485152,
-0.0024348404,
-0.0003787034,
-0.0297273155,
-0.0196065344,
0.042648077,
0.0684655979,
-0.0352620967,
-0.0050808964,
0.0065298029,
-0.0418005735,
0.0058358852,
-0.073346369,
0.0360209197,
0.0325694941,
-0.013087485,
0.0655568168,
0.026697645,
-0.0354559571,
-0.0173312929,
-0.0275054201,
-0.0325603969,
-0.0928513706,
-0.0232497212,
0.0016581576,
-0.0190125853,
0.0458305925,
-0.0138944825,
-0.0136531238,
0.0254553724,
-0.069004938,
0.0421278849,
0.0290646609,
0.0319501385,
0.0638125613,
0.0218209978,
0.025716817,
0.0010158647,
-0.0111101624,
-0.0059401197,
0.0637791306,
-0.0712920949,
-0.0409762599,
-0.0332622379,
0.0258067269,
-0.0233042296,
0.0209865402,
-0.0329524055,
0.0216488279,
-0.0091155637,
0.0201789606,
-0.0393948555,
-0.0006617349,
-0.0320105813,
-0.0429467112,
-0.0456173792,
0.0260908492,
0.0199071486,
0.0479872972,
0.0067457547,
0.0012482664,
0.0213861559,
-0.0341755301,
-0.0067023099,
-0.0051129819,
0.0197908189,
0.0530820489,
-0.0152966073,
-0.0124426857,
-0.0318242945,
-0.0594402887,
-0.0073301471,
-0.02022098,
0.0067678904,
-0.052927386,
-0.0079954201,
0.01021362,
-0.0074358643,
-0.0569662265,
-0.0135941282,
-0.0261118934,
-0.0766982436,
0.0754721761,
-0.0480098277,
0.0414471403,
0.066457957,
0.0415408574,
-0.0638580397,
0.0629894808,
0.0383161046,
-0.0328650512,
0.0913938433,
-0.0148967365,
0.0087886481,
0.0186374448,
-0.0197808687,
0.0072871405,
-0.0335808843,
0.0078764781,
-0.04057822,
0.0194032397,
0.0127778035,
-0.0090521472,
-0.0198468678,
0.0391569585,
0.0916930735,
0.0112041533,
-0.0120346714,
0.0307975225,
0.0060243891,
-0.0080464389,
-0.0055588484,
0.0115149133,
-0.0281475633,
0.0142364297,
-0.0358076692,
0.0277603343,
-0.008697778,
-0.0075374665,
-0.0051266458,
-0.0475833677,
-0.0148588857,
0.0494102277,
0.0134106968,
-0.0225686897,
0.0394165143,
0.0526095927,
-0.0089494362,
0.028883189,
0.015680965,
-0.0317946263,
0.0184997469,
-0.0488764718,
-0.0166375395,
0.0972667411,
0.0823826939,
-0.0448563211,
-0.0750410259,
0.0113768568,
-0.0271739196,
0.0131675014,
0.0535940602,
-0.0127417073,
-0.0189667661,
0.0052257408,
-0.0321482047,
-0.0526375622,
0.0432308614,
-0.00104487,
0.0350584127,
-0.0143460836,
0.0067641013,
-0.0576586127,
-0.0341588259,
0.0047475519,
-0.0491255186,
0.0226352774,
-0.0413428023,
0.0033440047,
-0.0116394423,
-0.008265445,
-0.0313548185,
0.0192375574,
-0.0105903614,
0.0135062076,
-0.0204750951,
-0.0119543606,
0.0325433388,
-0.0077876044,
0.0316714682,
-0.0029320891,
-0.0258259736,
0.0059556724,
-0.0104109924,
-0.0004446589,
0.0364441425,
-0.0201450381,
0.0850753263,
-0.0038795962,
0.0792195052,
-0.030098537,
-0.037807934,
-0.0192242749,
0.0278667435,
-0.0182808712,
0.0255253557,
0.0104981186,
-0.032714352,
-0.0057754125,
0.0162470788,
-0.0366549082,
-0.0038947742,
-0.0143377064,
-0.0281151719,
-0.0012686569,
-0.0091634328,
-0.0464245863,
-0.0220279377,
-0.0708736777,
-0.03397955,
0.0010155399,
0.0103145503,
0.0361018963,
0.0076358914,
-0.0196646489,
-0.0030116241,
0.0289159399,
0.0121557917,
-0.0359031744,
0.0649465173,
0.0286559984,
0.0229329746,
-0.0644961074,
-0.0652957633,
-0.0117069148,
0.0124661243,
0.0561390221,
0.0147611909,
0.0151549755,
-0.0270035937,
0.0382990688,
-0.0818555951,
-0.0197037924,
-0.0180682875,
0.0012791955,
-0.0104380101,
0.03087762,
0.0627751723,
-0.025845252,
-0.0221370719,
0.0294570997,
0.0752930641,
-0.0377998427,
0.0107886363,
-0.0280089248,
0.0116446912,
-0.0395284146,
-0.0239152033,
-0.0406423174,
0.0079261139,
0.0684908852,
-0.001212423,
-0.0304336771,
-0.010309536,
0.0729789138,
-0.0388432555,
-0.0323692337,
-0.0650703236,
-0.049788978,
-0.0051874015,
0.081385754,
-0.0279716458,
-0.0519015677,
0.0593869463,
0.0015625206,
0.0418705903,
-0.0267326832,
0.0128786564,
-0.0034916371,
0.0882284716,
-0.0282881483,
0.037991479,
0.0147618204,
-0.0203514099,
-0.0999067873,
-0.0114804646,
0.0405179597,
-0.0283633284,
0.0510407388,
-0.084330231,
-0.0198385995,
0.0182067063,
0.0059924107,
-0.0219187494,
-0.0118539976,
-0.022585718,
0.0137421153,
0.084731631,
-0.0236782972,
0.0093977489,
0.0013701541,
0.0312056057,
0.0575855859,
0.0172741096,
-0.0406964011,
-0.0067397831,
-0.0007384225,
0.035272494,
0.0120847728,
0.0470149741,
-0.0405414067,
0.0541154929,
0.0324592441,
0.0228251703,
-0.0635299608,
0.0298116077,
-0.0052894712,
-0.0106314747,
-0.0700986609,
-0.0516492985,
0.0042353263,
-0.008783564,
-0.0464727245,
0.0064669857,
0.089603059,
0.0512455851,
-0.0191897955,
0.0487154126,
-0.0746100843,
0.0205995999,
0.0503741615,
0.0180936456,
-0.0832527503,
0.0150767416,
0.0279560816,
-0.0067023253,
-0.0486010499,
-0.0604093634,
-0.0240826495,
-0.0626057088,
0.0283490475,
-0.0102608586,
-0.0301607773,
-0.0331826769,
0.0043861656,
0.0165454093,
0.0427127443,
-0.0037184134,
0.0443124361,
-0.0157461502,
0.0082275318,
-0.0244811885,
-0.0505328476,
-0.0450331978,
0.0197911523,
-0.0206008814,
0.0211769678,
0.0231142268,
0.0114403963,
-0.0213063117,
-0.0083575221,
0.0230628308,
0.0432264581,
0.0154361445,
-0.0054443087,
0.018765891,
0.0188916102,
0.0340377502,
-0.0084649064,
-0.0309006814,
0.0116568096,
-0.0609626584,
0.021189658,
0.0767266229,
-0.0105728786,
0.0047307201,
-0.0087084342,
-0.013220503,
-0.0198588241,
0.0780262873,
0.0309315342,
-0.0257087592,
0.0631508157,
-0.0257528815,
0.0129120201,
0.0146566601,
0.011766756,
-0.0106460359,
-0.0421922244,
0.0126777673,
-0.0610430352,
-0.0309269316,
0.0449140035,
-0.007885525,
0.0714627057,
0.0243752263,
-0.0073377592,
-0.0077352324,
-0.0373215675,
0.0030633162,
-0.0009699393,
-0.0020791988,
-0.0221197251,
-0.025120249,
-0.0015593347,
-0.0154916728,
-0.0334453881,
-0.0220519379,
-0.0006608153,
-0.0468635112,
-0.0056518335,
-0.0017382746,
0.0371559039,
0.0164540615,
0.0449965447,
-0.0725313947,
-0.0230788421,
-0.0145946881,
0.0049925018,
0.0389667228,
0.0259152073,
0.0483514294,
-0.0119328257,
0.0499208942,
-0.0532038696,
-0.0288815945,
0.0431157202,
0.042108912,
-0.0117552327,
-0.0298740026,
0.023529375,
-0.0002180056,
0.0334721617,
-0.0296762735,
0.0170571152,
-0.0514081568,
0.0369506888,
-0.038652584,
-0.0234455485,
-0.0084601799,
-0.0075873611,
0.0219210498,
0.0223476477,
-0.0160814896,
0.0332820155,
-0.0095552281,
0.0424665175,
-0.0294663329,
-0.0199682023,
-0.0348165892,
-0.0072054234,
0.044250112,
0.0037669195,
-0.005621166,
0.0180454198,
-0.0309591107,
0.0090851896,
-0.0017646673,
0.0575845018,
0.003739469,
-0.0349973552,
-0.0735162124,
0.0341102146,
-0.0344600268,
-0.075574182,
-0.0015092032,
0.0005225164,
0.0253213793,
0.0047206399,
0.023327481,
-0.0611993149,
-0.030644577,
-0.0026070166,
-0.0037312647,
0.0189691987,
-0.0535811335,
0.0226584077,
0.0245625768,
-0.0122281862,
0.0295594726,
0.0747828335,
0.00847892,
0.0944953412,
-0.0387108587,
-0.0524143502,
-0.0195747018,
-0.0163356587,
0.0498432778,
0.0589180067,
-0.0401804782,
-0.0035419997,
-0.1246101037,
-0.057246469,
-0.0151028447,
0.0114259785,
-0.0144676724,
-0.0086401096,
-0.008985729,
0.0950906649,
-0.0167113822,
-0.0467367843,
-0.0364160053,
0.0135717867,
-0.0131492028,
0.0117076486,
-0.0142965904,
-5.862656485e-33,
-0.0102301827,
-0.0131354798,
0.0045274207,
-0.0035351939,
-0.0222393814,
-0.0055916705,
-0.0399261005,
0.0646590963,
0.0025014116,
0.0315934308,
-0.0250964221,
0.0049561514,
-0.0088504339,
-0.0228677373,
0.0392386019,
0.0359719992,
0.0516179167,
0.0263354778,
-0.0354275294,
0.0008375298,
0.0116654607,
0.0077702007,
0.0789250806,
-0.0270041991,
0.0762510374,
0.0086463848,
0.0143156657,
0.0056893202,
-0.0451662093,
0.0297696888,
0.0060710912,
0.0069708237,
0.0362517759,
-0.0294371899,
-0.0218663551,
-0.0371751897,
0.0311319213,
0.0004303535,
0.0555733368,
0.0211596303,
0.015032324,
-0.0408346727,
0.0329395756,
0.0335705653,
-0.0533431247,
-0.0259936452,
0.0093181413,
-0.042224925,
0.0026123538,
0.0168902185,
-0.0880076885,
0.0295017306,
-0.013560866,
-0.015543378,
-0.0207387283,
0.0026689456,
0.03344886,
-0.0552867353,
-0.0683860332,
0.0316213034,
0.0813641772,
0.0408464111,
0.088647306,
0.0099241324,
-0.0056321817,
0.0439088382,
0.0085320864,
0.0744501576,
0.0233327709,
0.0169491358,
0.0006228652,
0.0444529206,
0.0200161356,
0.0393820181,
0.0288588069,
-0.0041434905,
-0.0200332087,
-0.0166845191,
-0.0748933703,
0.0127580455,
0.0195244867,
0.0492935553,
-0.0365847014,
-0.0207791924,
-0.0528954677,
0.0115849525,
-0.0452528968,
-0.0382689051,
0.0299091171,
-0.0019313541,
-0.0018506845,
-0.0020340432,
-0.0007891693,
-0.0194422211,
-0.0417287163,
-0.0080024218,
-0.0276874788,
0.0611545257,
-0.0017834562,
-0.0072090873,
-0.0268355515,
0.031342186,
0.0106275044,
-0.0077393865,
0.0068787653,
-0.0019953665,
0.0084777018,
0.0229173098,
-0.0549061,
-0.004850687,
-0.0043717632,
-0.0024589966,
0.0152649134,
-0.0401053764,
0.0116446577,
-0.006685989,
-0.0078976303,
-0.0195359457,
0.0823979005,
-0.0231605135,
-0.0622750707,
0.0655182675,
-0.030106863,
0.004629612,
-0.0007805141,
-0.0279749166,
-0.0118866246,
-0.02665147,
0.0290689971,
-0.026351884,
-0.0457351804,
-0.0090156319,
2.841e-7,
0.0653843209,
0.0818387493,
-0.023472866,
-0.0158312265,
0.0532422848,
0.025943974,
-0.0353059024,
-0.0017210627,
0.0165507626,
-0.0223164521,
0.0112471618,
-0.0140932659,
-0.0029978466,
0.0028169956,
-0.0229500178,
-0.0308573563,
-0.0389753953,
0.0205761846,
-0.0608731844,
-0.0100178057,
0.0465030521,
0.0177189689,
0.0286221374,
-0.0030901255,
-0.0590594076,
-0.0155265955,
0.0363220014,
-0.0279092714,
0.0160833076,
0.043527022,
0.0288322382,
0.0208831485,
0.0226908009,
0.070512414,
-0.0498951748,
0.0067070434,
0.0037518335,
0.0226144381,
-0.029834792,
0.0561148636,
-0.0105956765,
-0.0096698515,
0.008758842,
-0.1097004935,
0.0482292846,
-0.0483035706,
-0.0143399173,
0.02891404,
-0.0487229005,
0.0263648313,
0.0074758395,
-0.0208405349,
-0.0123494426,
-0.0064118979,
0.0025476234,
0.052022554,
-0.0253159329,
-0.0114319641,
-0.0066794488,
0.0443512537,
-0.0236442946,
-0.0903750956,
-0.0322804973,
-0.0497430637,
0.0060424139,
-0.0409617573,
-0.0035656523,
2.502124214e-34,
0.0166386776,
0.0144700082,
0.0235518292,
0.0190732442,
0.0403943211,
-0.0135457236,
0.0178088583,
0.0033535804,
-0.0084557626,
-0.0699145496,
-0.005369226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17245v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17245v1 | Unlocking Continual Learning Abilities in Language Models | 2024-06-25T03:24:06 | 2024-06-25T03:24:06 | Wenyu Du, Shuang Cheng, Tongxu Luo, Zihan Qiu, Zeyu Huang, Ka Chun Cheung, Reynold Cheng, Jie Fu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Language models (LMs) exhibit impressive performance and generalization
capabilities. However, LMs struggle with the persistent challenge of
catastrophic forgetting, which undermines their long-term sustainability in
continual learning (CL). Existing approaches usually address the issue by
incorporating old task data or task-wise inductive bias into LMs. However, old
data and accurate task information are often unavailable or costly to collect,
hindering the availability of current CL approaches for LMs. To address this
limitation, we introduce $\textbf{MIGU}$ ($\textbf{M}$agn$\textbf{I}$tude-based
$\textbf{G}$radient $\textbf{U}$pdating for continual learning), a
rehearsal-free and task-label-free method that only updates the model
parameters with large magnitudes of output in LMs' linear layers. MIGU is based
on our observation that the L1-normalized magnitude distribution of the output
in LMs' linear layers is different when the LM models deal with different task
data. By imposing this simple constraint on the gradient update process, we can
leverage the inherent behaviors of LMs, thereby unlocking their innate CL
abilities. Our experiments demonstrate that MIGU is universally applicable to
all three LM architectures (T5, RoBERTa, and Llama2), delivering
state-of-the-art or on-par performance across continual finetuning and
continual pre-training settings on four CL benchmarks. For example, MIGU brings
a 15.2% average accuracy improvement over conventional parameter-efficient
finetuning baselines in a 15-task CL benchmark. MIGU can also seamlessly
integrate with all three existing CL types to further enhance performance. Code
is available at \href{https://github.com/wenyudu/MIGU}{this https URL}. | [
0.0090944469,
0.0664204359,
-0.0069681192,
0.0364930741,
-0.0031458582,
0.0195378792,
-0.0151395239,
-0.0703307763,
-0.0546781458,
0.01011224,
-0.0591544807,
-0.0523914695,
-0.002674906,
-0.0021632542,
0.0343760289,
-0.0043110009,
0.038882535,
-0.0363949314,
-0.0413287804,
-0.0197346695,
0.0136429276,
-0.0156434644,
-0.0314255841,
0.0101533132,
-0.0114706252,
-0.0477961116,
-0.0157075617,
-0.0114319026,
0.0057789199,
-0.0239575561,
0.0504919402,
0.0462055579,
0.0118553601,
0.0084935138,
0.0000023574,
-0.0422553569,
0.0143648367,
-0.0320558436,
-0.0565272123,
0.0067696008,
0.0448361635,
0.0350440219,
-0.0491841622,
0.0233311392,
-0.0336800106,
-0.024960788,
0.0470798612,
0.0123077435,
0.052238144,
0.0327440239,
0.0007047328,
-0.0132882139,
0.0719470307,
-0.0652196705,
0.0038064199,
-0.036371883,
0.0344214514,
-0.0264616981,
-0.0356018618,
-0.0260102544,
-0.0152593451,
0.0611533411,
0.0321257152,
-0.0131310076,
0.0137504321,
0.0669541955,
0.0171341114,
-0.0420548692,
-0.0081312386,
0.0456973612,
-0.0395361744,
-0.0180676095,
-0.0141408741,
0.0214304235,
-0.017160641,
-0.0447292812,
-0.0701542124,
0.0330177732,
0.0205610096,
0.0455480404,
0.0119608622,
-0.0238111783,
0.0438948981,
0.025020469,
-0.0372067168,
0.0179022215,
0.0224699546,
-0.009893734,
0.0083078882,
-0.0244309083,
-0.051731877,
-0.0221260469,
0.0004996187,
0.0489487685,
-0.0219746232,
0.0056185992,
-0.036982324,
-0.0245481282,
0.0170777962,
-0.0342471041,
0.0872332081,
0.0388189554,
-0.0454011634,
0.0355831124,
-0.0448553041,
0.0646679476,
0.0118828146,
0.0311584156,
-0.0340363011,
0.0235890169,
-0.0212833676,
-0.0126326671,
-0.0131680835,
0.0369947068,
0.0171214007,
0.0071891686,
-0.0053833495,
0.0665666834,
-0.0054689329,
0.0205700938,
-0.0113430414,
0.005735225,
-0.0782231092,
0.0088162161,
-0.0169726647,
0.0412567891,
-0.0132650333,
0.0344287865,
0.0234940462,
-0.0472073108,
-0.0386339054,
0.018794544,
-0.0014425755,
-0.0194265451,
0.0338156484,
0.0464650318,
-0.0296711624,
-0.0241490286,
-0.0493849628,
0.037594419,
-0.0133545138,
-0.0816459954,
0.0306489561,
-0.0225990918,
0.0316573046,
-0.0232520178,
0.0181900319,
-0.0671032071,
0.0172768869,
0.0057339366,
-0.0201174691,
0.0730325803,
0.0247525573,
0.0006931971,
0.0224681739,
-0.0024780829,
0.0046107387,
0.050456129,
0.028841475,
0.02469014,
0.008105265,
0.0178443585,
0.0051864898,
0.0415967815,
0.0307065193,
0.0342663303,
-0.0472379029,
-0.0202928018,
0.0374970622,
0.0149876475,
0.0650810823,
0.0442018025,
-0.0096115312,
0.0073789381,
0.092385605,
0.0041165114,
0.0121086547,
0.0494312309,
0.0415623374,
-0.0308535658,
0.0183316395,
0.0027867409,
-0.0660194233,
0.0265655611,
-0.0072432379,
0.0063648,
0.0258382577,
0.0180657282,
-0.0499313325,
-0.0404775292,
0.0156648867,
-0.0166219268,
-0.0297130458,
0.013221262,
0.045514904,
0.0263715275,
-0.0405003205,
0.029649606,
0.0242914334,
-0.0180236772,
0.0278750714,
-0.0290565416,
0.0203713216,
0.0530016087,
0.0246724337,
-0.0287120733,
-0.0824010968,
-0.0130188745,
0.029483458,
0.0151568213,
0.0160378646,
-0.0049689822,
0.0527148619,
-0.0620287992,
0.0128860753,
-0.00124756,
0.0250306092,
0.0073777372,
-0.0059588719,
0.0237659141,
0.0089844931,
-0.0397961065,
-0.0610457398,
0.0378001183,
-0.0680029839,
-0.0283922199,
0.0138143711,
-0.0348722599,
-0.0173376165,
-0.0077457381,
-0.0323677026,
0.0102348635,
0.0405412316,
-0.0496620052,
0.0158729479,
0.0255945642,
-0.0792440176,
-0.0045256088,
0.0696177855,
0.0504141487,
0.0074459831,
0.012645754,
-0.0370286442,
-0.0403076969,
0.0046906653,
0.0240881946,
0.0217493102,
-0.0544344448,
0.0258188248,
-0.0181340333,
0.0312125962,
-0.0298503097,
0.022172777,
-0.0603140481,
-0.0159354918,
0.0121682463,
0.0332999602,
-0.0184140261,
-0.0707896054,
-0.0356318913,
0.0152535122,
0.0091781504,
0.0216118991,
-0.0306252595,
0.0074474346,
-0.0121242404,
-0.0331119671,
-0.0692805424,
0.010542742,
-0.0321132354,
0.0097532012,
0.0253757723,
-0.0009682846,
-0.0128525458,
-0.0116173243,
0.0211642589,
0.0050279298,
-0.0315161757,
0.0096381707,
0.021177765,
0.0057437802,
0.0026883523,
-0.0562389679,
-0.0257094037,
0.0254267659,
0.029080417,
-0.0600824058,
-0.0054246956,
-0.0500479341,
0.0109816575,
-0.0304153133,
0.0392703451,
-0.0362874046,
-0.0359082296,
-0.0017626948,
-0.0372307412,
0.0662334114,
0.0649958029,
-0.0020797257,
0.0319576934,
0.063623555,
-0.0187742673,
-0.0226753205,
0.0126834828,
-0.0289973468,
-0.0501574576,
-0.0247431714,
0.0096568167,
-0.0087419786,
0.0634675026,
-0.0168701485,
-0.0066102408,
-0.02746181,
-0.0002846413,
-0.0312428158,
0.0034226931,
-0.0200495534,
0.0280155353,
-0.0615005083,
-0.0105160046,
-0.0234450735,
-0.0634126291,
0.0233780798,
-0.0176990218,
-0.0182439741,
-0.0211651791,
-0.00430666,
0.0023720323,
0.0284258705,
-0.0062272479,
-0.0026485389,
0.0312466584,
-0.028503038,
-0.0411204323,
0.0201320387,
0.0439664237,
-0.0207973644,
0.0621603206,
-0.0144305462,
0.0006404836,
-0.0172775574,
-0.0335863605,
-0.0689587668,
-0.0016055342,
0.0000134989,
0.016312141,
-0.0317189358,
0.0065787202,
-0.0125620924,
-0.0048783515,
0.0230518188,
0.0611175746,
-0.02322804,
-0.0069563272,
-0.0101315798,
0.0228805076,
0.0269203875,
0.0561207198,
0.0159911737,
-0.0249523167,
0.0212903693,
0.0325213298,
0.0512797534,
0.0068720109,
-0.0425067283,
0.0156479198,
0.022493314,
0.0219410118,
0.0084553212,
0.0081564225,
0.0179269034,
-0.0492901094,
-0.0353401378,
0.0881354213,
0.0030246498,
-0.0660652071,
0.0011609702,
0.0104819601,
0.0649428293,
0.032729622,
0.0264114402,
-0.0422649793,
-0.0003349051,
0.0521879867,
0.0492660329,
0.0342231654,
-0.013933517,
-0.0122896321,
-0.0621305183,
0.0188120306,
0.0389446542,
0.0088325618,
0.0170044005,
-0.0269194096,
-0.0094050094,
0.0066605452,
0.0256550405,
0.0448755324,
-0.0179184731,
-0.0049574869,
0.0458098203,
-0.0285194069,
-0.09515623,
0.0200137272,
-0.0348366052,
0.0610023476,
0.0640516356,
0.0035640071,
-0.0079875169,
-0.0489657819,
0.1361041218,
-0.0086971717,
0.0077723982,
-0.008439959,
0.0311699212,
0.0151971597,
-0.0216117911,
0.0066263517,
0.0305999294,
-0.0248338822,
-0.0027202715,
-0.0096905548,
0.0608211942,
-0.01180097,
0.0116705811,
0.010238748,
-0.060228996,
-0.0262916051,
0.0333602801,
0.0222431626,
-0.0487123616,
-0.0175457783,
-0.0285660047,
-0.0057138638,
-0.0433400683,
-0.0051603238,
0.0192761347,
-0.0205072667,
-0.0573585816,
-0.0321973413,
-0.0304052569,
-0.0074613485,
0.0449117869,
0.0237244647,
-0.0138912164,
0.0008184535,
-0.0116866697,
-0.0700534955,
0.0120190373,
-0.0347870775,
0.0147373248,
-0.0644848719,
0.0009074935,
0.0663590431,
-0.008835718,
-0.0019925546,
-0.0042959414,
-0.118450582,
-0.0700354949,
0.0217302125,
0.0690536574,
0.0128082884,
0.0706705824,
-0.0032538241,
-0.0469395593,
0.0360993035,
0.0103951003,
0.008115381,
0.0478956066,
0.0571833141,
-0.0402084701,
0.0228793025,
0.0382087156,
-0.0300971065,
0.014006664,
0.0464090519,
0.0707013607,
0.043546766,
0.038581755,
0.0297849067,
-0.0425012447,
0.0191930775,
-0.0079709357,
-0.0111172237,
-0.0629989728,
0.0339376517,
0.0371606611,
-0.0055128308,
-0.0348926634,
0.012540075,
0.0382998437,
0.036429856,
-0.0069776345,
-0.0038583637,
0.0655641183,
0.0448847711,
-0.0315843783,
-0.0168117378,
-0.0174176209,
0.001943822,
0.0395767316,
0.0283697508,
-0.0422849208,
0.0240396168,
-0.0162945725,
0.0247991122,
-0.027959859,
0.0347924866,
0.0395673886,
-0.006320775,
-0.0474232286,
0.0368653461,
-0.0184259415,
-0.0913945362,
-0.0593657233,
-0.0104181999,
0.1005552858,
0.0296239648,
0.0415157676,
-0.0087062772,
0.008011695,
-0.0335646681,
-0.0159805845,
-0.0125417123,
-0.0280498601,
0.0173526723,
0.0057778708,
0.0082838014,
0.0336439051,
0.0666425228,
-0.0140624354,
0.0295579247,
-0.0222389698,
0.0474339612,
-0.0389435813,
0.0071816286,
-0.0325930193,
0.0007018686,
-0.0249139927,
0.0004553362,
0.0139855379,
-0.067399174,
0.0164698716,
-0.0043851323,
0.0009074358,
-0.0171809532,
0.0056056804,
0.0146783656,
-0.0202341694,
0.0138260406,
-0.0161316805,
-0.0029717665,
0.0355264693,
-0.0099143591,
-0.0110822665,
-7.220366786e-33,
-0.0220401958,
0.0361939333,
0.0264207833,
0.0094626723,
-0.0743275434,
-0.01757106,
-0.0624238253,
0.0167443845,
-0.0136986701,
-0.0106613366,
-0.0243805107,
-0.0031985007,
0.009007128,
0.0183866099,
0.0471676812,
-0.0336530022,
0.0582513958,
-0.0066530877,
-0.0191553738,
0.0317357033,
0.0138456207,
0.0585785396,
0.0584980771,
-0.0409527905,
0.012513618,
0.0062087565,
-0.0201885998,
0.0477378443,
-0.0032515347,
0.0356015973,
-0.0563646257,
0.0314744599,
0.0111860828,
-0.0385105908,
-0.0611917004,
-0.0591594838,
-0.1331488192,
-0.0343359858,
-0.0271352865,
0.0049616066,
-0.0475725047,
-0.0097066835,
0.0425024368,
0.0237485506,
-0.0341362096,
0.0061958004,
0.000944207,
-0.0420700833,
-0.044955425,
-0.0118472371,
-0.042500928,
-0.0100244097,
0.0184049681,
-0.0230071563,
0.0205835756,
-0.0281439424,
-0.0157297123,
-0.0237898286,
-0.1189244166,
-0.0366647467,
-0.0055651893,
0.050361786,
0.0308853388,
0.0558265336,
0.0362273455,
0.0464207269,
0.036244344,
0.0110565638,
0.0045765433,
-0.0152867725,
0.0725001246,
-0.0228872579,
-0.0016661355,
-0.0431093946,
0.0467074402,
-0.0521620139,
-0.0283292271,
-0.0182171334,
0.0543729551,
0.0721262395,
0.0468368344,
0.0369142517,
0.0047296975,
-0.0467858724,
-0.0473089591,
-0.0035714789,
-0.0454789288,
0.0081322379,
0.056986127,
0.0534804538,
0.0059197559,
-0.0307954717,
0.0167039204,
-0.0109313279,
-0.0235695634,
0.0099535994,
-0.0112221595,
0.0252746642,
0.0158720147,
0.0067990711,
-0.0472912975,
-0.0002097428,
-0.0352921076,
-0.017360758,
0.0067159361,
0.0110304812,
0.0350862071,
0.0785421282,
-0.0341860615,
-0.0219081864,
-0.0569377318,
0.0170541126,
0.0650036186,
0.0480830483,
0.0228439867,
0.0025066037,
-0.0068770349,
0.0660961419,
0.0234464332,
-0.0154005643,
-0.0596815571,
0.0711564198,
0.0470916592,
0.0324406661,
-0.0254620556,
-0.0153777553,
-0.0402264707,
0.0509992838,
0.0121661797,
-0.0887649879,
-0.0176506639,
0.009585104,
2.992e-7,
-0.000597237,
0.0116782896,
0.0202792734,
-0.0103535932,
0.0425919704,
0.0160243474,
-0.0646159798,
-0.0015847362,
0.0113422768,
0.0482040979,
0.0035701382,
0.0269710533,
0.0495497659,
0.0134787597,
-0.0682824776,
-0.0039598919,
-0.0399759077,
0.0327869542,
-0.0467684008,
-0.0339141563,
-0.0230781399,
0.0752979741,
0.0366375707,
-0.0122987879,
0.0228527244,
-0.0665664896,
0.0616223738,
-0.0013319273,
0.0558353402,
-0.0029125209,
0.0098239211,
0.0428949073,
-0.0318131857,
-0.0195448715,
-0.0105278138,
0.0082626445,
-0.0319839716,
0.0496115275,
-0.0162271913,
-0.0571386516,
0.0085308421,
0.0280813165,
0.0017979575,
-0.0620880835,
0.0628267378,
-0.0671616346,
0.0082497979,
-0.0102226445,
0.0199680571,
0.0142417122,
-0.0034781615,
-0.0089006359,
-0.0304985065,
-0.0014005038,
0.0244659912,
0.031153556,
-0.055544313,
-0.0950964987,
-0.0023190731,
0.0346884392,
-0.0615430661,
-0.0376105756,
-0.0621709004,
-0.0091543477,
-0.0011525758,
-0.0319994763,
0.0110197021,
2.782649513e-34,
0.0230602119,
-0.0416676477,
0.0218796283,
0.0729315057,
-0.0004125037,
-0.0343969129,
0.0115257287,
0.0081971707,
-0.0005390262,
-0.0691291094,
-0.0418834984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17241v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17241v1 | What Do the Circuits Mean? A Knowledge Edit View | 2024-06-25T03:09:53 | 2024-06-25T03:09:53 | Huaizhi Ge, Frank Rudzicz, Zining Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the field of language model interpretability, circuit discovery is gaining
popularity. Despite this, the true meaning of these circuits remain largely
unanswered. We introduce a novel method to learn their meanings as a holistic
object through the lens of knowledge editing. We extract circuits in the
GPT2-XL model using diverse text classification datasets, and use hierarchical
relations datasets to explore knowledge editing in the circuits. Our findings
indicate that these circuits contain entity knowledge but resist new knowledge
more than complementary circuits during knowledge editing. Additionally, we
examine the impact of circuit size, discovering that an ideal "theoretical
circuit" where essential knowledge is concentrated likely incorporates more
than 5% but less than 50% of the model's parameters. We also assess the overlap
between circuits from different datasets, finding moderate similarities. What
constitutes these circuits, then? We find that up to 60% of the circuits
consist of layer normalization modules rather than attention or MLP modules,
adding evidence to the ongoing debates regarding knowledge localization. In
summary, our findings offer new insights into the functions of the circuits,
and introduce research directions for further interpretability and safety
research of language models. | [
0.0535994619,
0.0347644575,
-0.0340850763,
0.0655083433,
-0.0177148543,
0.0195954312,
0.0008936296,
-0.0087987781,
0.0280935168,
-0.0277409572,
-0.033139199,
-0.0180667061,
0.0087192329,
0.0459881201,
0.0192268994,
-0.0333000422,
0.0377295129,
-0.0120938411,
-0.0114151789,
-0.0007910844,
-0.0007987467,
0.014280715,
0.0322236121,
0.056351915,
0.0287764054,
-0.0180385094,
0.0030373663,
-0.0068046497,
0.0249392428,
0.0262985732,
-0.0216604639,
0.0902488083,
0.0114687802,
0.0542812943,
0.0000021564,
-0.0270441864,
-0.028896803,
0.0002940366,
-0.0658870712,
0.0269050859,
0.0093379607,
-0.0455978252,
-0.0017058732,
-0.0285473056,
-0.0172871947,
0.005934665,
0.07269869,
0.0567210019,
0.0089616328,
0.0542551167,
-0.012317108,
-0.0391332433,
0.0433040559,
-0.0283853803,
0.0326542221,
-0.0368093625,
0.060134206,
0.0116192559,
-0.0402382202,
-0.0112764314,
-0.043479912,
0.0316171534,
0.0300461091,
0.0015755129,
0.0269572716,
0.031069994,
-0.0056739547,
-0.0204412155,
0.0273861401,
0.0711488649,
0.0238004588,
-0.0276977587,
-0.0075262822,
0.031913463,
0.0061163153,
0.0251500513,
-0.0127310315,
0.0064798538,
-0.0249468964,
0.0286769867,
0.0391187817,
-0.0647841766,
0.0584988445,
-0.010918797,
-0.018922599,
0.1258034706,
-0.0027567712,
-0.0080040675,
-0.0049365703,
0.0192740317,
-0.0415684022,
-0.0432893671,
0.0220101103,
-0.0241487604,
0.0158974994,
0.0560778193,
-0.0251116883,
0.0291009545,
-0.0091436049,
-0.0674727485,
0.0049130716,
0.0000686426,
0.0346809551,
0.043433018,
0.0206124857,
0.0123213343,
-0.0229690354,
0.039861165,
-0.0257142298,
0.0054460745,
-0.0751578361,
-0.0674081147,
-0.0142117832,
0.0391953103,
-0.0212463457,
0.0087135592,
-0.0302986354,
0.0181692317,
-0.0452171937,
-0.019185489,
-0.0225359686,
0.0114188138,
-0.0032217058,
-0.0038246948,
-0.0277044345,
0.0362379365,
-0.0172387287,
0.0185836051,
-0.0339109749,
-0.020991914,
-0.0139317159,
-0.0251553301,
0.0108959032,
-0.0181811173,
-0.0414313972,
0.0557089485,
0.0149569772,
-0.0536954701,
-0.0620514713,
-0.0552702807,
-0.0399121121,
-0.0447626114,
-0.0131256217,
-0.0427964404,
0.0354696997,
0.0221909266,
-0.0027555835,
-0.0648755208,
-0.0025665779,
0.0052008429,
-0.0850786939,
0.0621598437,
-0.0166114457,
0.028826233,
-0.0018113226,
0.0312502868,
-0.0019147004,
0.0650597736,
0.0476209335,
-0.0312314164,
0.0432642661,
-0.0167843271,
-0.018445719,
0.0330367349,
0.0243326668,
-0.0041839075,
-0.0190175902,
0.0015971097,
-0.020347571,
-0.0186768249,
0.0108197164,
0.0154716112,
-0.032947246,
-0.0094128083,
0.0716547742,
0.0160250291,
-0.0005845299,
0.0398742706,
0.0190311112,
-0.0116678746,
0.0026364175,
0.0260460116,
-0.0824909583,
0.0139100859,
-0.0562282465,
-0.0178865474,
-0.010524503,
-0.0272457488,
0.0002430147,
-0.0135791469,
0.0022631781,
0.0416550264,
0.0228099525,
-0.0100479564,
0.0229491666,
0.0096749691,
-0.015239846,
0.0671663806,
0.033832185,
-0.0339999348,
0.0236657877,
-0.0390436538,
-0.000148471,
0.0769796222,
0.0368026495,
0.0006079318,
-0.0019064981,
-0.0195798762,
-0.0185283255,
0.0087912902,
0.0051160222,
-0.02180361,
0.0408112369,
0.0078095221,
-0.0262485463,
-0.0248963255,
0.0531379767,
0.0284008458,
-0.0012113823,
-0.0215681605,
-0.0009130189,
-0.0653419197,
-0.023931874,
-0.0005068191,
-0.0376410969,
-0.0129985921,
-0.0291928388,
0.0146350516,
0.011158118,
0.0201778673,
-0.0058014328,
-0.0198470615,
-0.0018522458,
0.000589525,
0.0068954118,
0.0064003319,
-0.0129107321,
-0.0170123,
0.0251703449,
-0.0518168621,
-0.0374693684,
0.0172809269,
-0.0155258309,
-0.0383387655,
0.0364052504,
-0.0560158864,
0.0683061704,
-0.0220454708,
-0.0006306764,
-0.0290641021,
-0.0208605155,
-0.0185569339,
0.0908482,
-0.0083667589,
-0.0095888916,
0.0429105312,
-0.0418629795,
0.0007047231,
0.0005918298,
-0.0395185649,
0.005521093,
0.010536924,
-0.0187021717,
0.0303656999,
-0.0377908833,
-0.0349565335,
-0.0272344574,
-0.0740002021,
-0.0097750556,
-0.0217536408,
0.0195100568,
0.0558266416,
0.0020788915,
0.0006279201,
0.0235688966,
0.0072220699,
-0.0159172304,
-0.0485947728,
0.0383042246,
0.0160867497,
-0.0012618421,
-0.0371985883,
-0.0263998937,
-0.0200974494,
-0.0346886925,
0.0739396214,
0.0155218542,
-0.022992583,
-0.0468382351,
0.0257756729,
-0.0253766999,
0.0084761307,
-0.0081335157,
-0.026895389,
-0.006092947,
0.0382762738,
0.0593655594,
0.0315989256,
-0.0101453206,
0.0909219161,
0.0628779754,
-0.0294768419,
-0.0066659027,
-0.0044556595,
-0.0220486186,
-0.0073548481,
-0.0690934509,
-0.0716358051,
-0.0145715456,
0.0996064097,
0.029791316,
-0.0235703867,
-0.07762409,
0.0135248201,
-0.0377608202,
-0.0444507115,
-0.0533512272,
-0.0275815446,
-0.0066133221,
0.0437890887,
-0.0392067842,
-0.0442450345,
0.0799726173,
0.008055998,
0.0088195037,
-0.0279973485,
-0.0158000644,
-0.0270403791,
0.0849340558,
0.0308288932,
0.0188832451,
0.0254468024,
-0.0131888567,
-0.0618390776,
0.0268856287,
0.0257678479,
-0.0211048368,
0.0604189113,
-0.0607185774,
0.0066803191,
0.0094053233,
-0.0126590254,
-0.0108292634,
0.0258901399,
-0.0116209369,
0.0019935556,
0.0597946346,
-0.036277134,
-0.0429737866,
0.0209375639,
0.0488803834,
0.0373906493,
-0.0234911554,
-0.0131475031,
-0.0325786136,
-0.0089055384,
0.0643507764,
-0.0194724891,
0.046742022,
-0.0482397266,
0.0294344164,
0.0527282804,
-0.020154763,
-0.0116317226,
0.0109813698,
0.0175208542,
0.0007769736,
-0.0450451262,
-0.0331091918,
-0.017614495,
0.046342887,
-0.0648209155,
-0.0206830595,
0.1207666472,
0.0291354712,
-0.0645049289,
0.0245465226,
-0.0021279696,
0.0049442654,
0.0364988856,
-0.0091961194,
-0.0807351768,
0.0012741055,
0.0094757359,
0.0075799916,
-0.0076539847,
-0.0471156165,
-0.0224259719,
-0.0412745699,
0.0109155206,
0.0045385067,
-0.0978089869,
-0.0702682212,
-0.0393862724,
0.0066068694,
-0.0259233601,
0.0024693736,
0.0251526572,
-0.0126647959,
0.0230671503,
-0.0112532703,
-0.0312151257,
-0.0527935401,
0.0350657925,
0.0016580737,
0.0475571007,
0.0484735928,
0.0216558874,
-0.013436812,
0.0011963997,
-0.0203265361,
-0.0077531054,
-0.0103207668,
-0.0053215674,
0.0722050667,
0.0026441033,
0.0034172591,
-0.0485752076,
0.0428052843,
-0.0459099896,
-0.0375000238,
0.0024707688,
0.078598775,
-0.0211832877,
-0.0747645721,
-0.0281459223,
0.0073681301,
-0.015057805,
0.0934279636,
0.0498540848,
-0.0318568796,
0.0050578653,
-0.056166634,
0.0312107522,
-0.0401446596,
-0.0480621606,
0.0010596578,
0.0261018071,
-0.0203965567,
-0.0187726021,
-0.0522064231,
0.0368663371,
-0.0097823897,
0.0384451635,
-0.0002653131,
0.0235710107,
-0.029939821,
-0.0332852341,
0.0241444577,
-0.0264107939,
-0.0278002452,
-0.0246402286,
-0.0362197496,
-0.017582966,
-0.0343499295,
-0.0495177992,
0.0032598726,
-0.0662293732,
-0.0676658005,
0.0095484145,
0.0052053225,
0.0344879478,
0.0457669459,
0.0169622041,
-0.0487994328,
-0.0059847902,
0.0152214859,
-0.0269453116,
0.0437204465,
0.0077730073,
-0.0150992265,
0.0119873732,
0.061861746,
-0.0235259533,
0.0201311819,
0.034598235,
0.0251444336,
-0.0574156307,
-0.0255061258,
0.0392888673,
-0.0055102562,
0.0302200783,
0.0317784734,
0.0147287492,
-0.0663425252,
0.0242935587,
-0.0171298049,
-0.0132416645,
-0.0494237915,
-0.0069739018,
0.0343430564,
-0.001584416,
-0.0284668468,
-0.0174939875,
0.010581526,
0.0306565277,
-0.0434275605,
-0.009333998,
0.007588814,
-0.0044662845,
0.0261376295,
0.0010046483,
-0.0149930399,
0.0382676348,
-0.0233971234,
0.0234572794,
0.0088536832,
0.0310559254,
0.0232841,
-0.0100844717,
-0.009879359,
-0.0010014734,
-0.0734283254,
-0.0440683998,
0.0064630979,
0.0316499695,
0.0348497033,
-0.0082019446,
0.0713729113,
-0.0528791957,
-0.0101152277,
-0.0211280547,
0.0304953717,
0.0219983421,
-0.0487910509,
0.0155623117,
0.0228840262,
-0.0258457772,
-0.0249145795,
0.0961907879,
0.0253029447,
0.0754026994,
-0.0200047288,
-0.0220789239,
-0.0358174443,
-0.0387091711,
-0.0007298957,
0.0426504388,
-0.0357931964,
0.0347332135,
-0.0845790803,
-0.0712138787,
0.0095609967,
-0.0429242179,
-0.0030038408,
-0.0249951351,
0.0084206415,
0.04521925,
0.0010128962,
-0.0420013592,
-0.0284526702,
-0.0061022639,
-0.001704563,
0.0055221352,
-0.0009652284,
-6.658177062e-33,
-0.0272525586,
-0.0358316526,
0.0133143924,
0.0286457073,
-0.0030305909,
0.0420406982,
-0.0709413439,
0.0360125415,
-0.0237595141,
0.0457010157,
0.0159181934,
0.0413391069,
-0.002953873,
0.0059959679,
-0.0177017469,
-0.0171545409,
0.0440749675,
0.0307268333,
0.0069891335,
0.038275823,
0.056442041,
0.0220990311,
0.1196788177,
-0.0770150349,
0.0860813409,
0.0172761753,
-0.0109169306,
0.0056185392,
-0.063012287,
0.0494177453,
-0.0171381198,
0.060846135,
0.0308133792,
-0.0484484509,
0.0072458512,
-0.0209591407,
-0.0791128427,
-0.0254074,
0.0551020987,
0.0214416571,
-0.0312361214,
-0.0534898117,
0.0597981811,
0.009845919,
-0.0028577992,
-0.0517816879,
0.0619545206,
-0.0259403344,
0.0115419012,
0.0004127167,
-0.0658696443,
0.0187575854,
-0.0192234423,
0.0083471974,
0.0180255361,
0.0184672698,
0.0065831924,
-0.0145928813,
-0.0923059136,
0.0114911012,
0.0704982579,
0.0160349235,
0.0427724868,
-0.0058469111,
0.0197935235,
0.0665672123,
0.0239679925,
0.0350637659,
-0.0541411005,
-0.0232576448,
0.0361874066,
0.0566403754,
-0.0001631018,
0.0207473803,
0.0073916009,
-0.009005026,
-0.0647985563,
-0.0282864645,
-0.03361376,
0.0202766657,
0.0594586469,
-0.004612952,
-0.0213510785,
-0.0346411914,
-0.041615352,
-0.0094401157,
-0.0440517329,
-0.0196611024,
0.0063031367,
-0.0086938888,
-0.0218475703,
-0.0027906874,
0.003757108,
-0.0619139597,
-0.0146421138,
0.0591285266,
0.0264330842,
0.0206296109,
0.0320765227,
0.0077919178,
-0.0526400693,
-0.0046090675,
-0.0129345441,
-0.0312379133,
0.0025504264,
0.0347348899,
0.0194518119,
0.0255324859,
-0.0137263527,
-0.030516848,
-0.0268430319,
0.0060697836,
-0.0174435545,
0.0270637646,
0.0277315546,
0.0181770809,
-0.0047528148,
-0.0025139467,
0.0702805445,
0.0112672169,
-0.0132562006,
0.0623808131,
-0.0231400188,
0.0345885418,
-0.010251008,
-0.0364951566,
-0.023734767,
-0.023805704,
0.0483707599,
-0.0368505903,
-0.0157696698,
-0.0014373917,
2.889e-7,
0.0974134058,
0.0578123592,
0.0054697944,
0.0370777212,
0.0409415588,
0.0239050295,
0.0240648761,
0.0428644828,
0.0126964105,
-0.0324793085,
-0.0015163297,
0.0195164755,
0.0161500201,
0.0300305393,
-0.0647895709,
-0.001012132,
-0.0534476861,
0.0059538237,
-0.0336368531,
0.0252818372,
0.0287121609,
0.0728217885,
0.038803108,
0.0116987452,
-0.0090626599,
-0.0213872921,
0.0463722795,
-0.062321458,
0.0478217006,
0.0332266018,
0.0014302804,
0.0105381347,
0.0094417371,
0.0804091915,
0.0059713824,
0.0245439298,
-0.0114478413,
0.0646670908,
-0.0083916839,
0.0253423918,
-0.0239181425,
-0.0343378522,
0.0051552388,
-0.1036976427,
0.060185086,
-0.0523381047,
-0.0469434112,
-0.0027672627,
0.011272802,
-0.0201797783,
0.0060786386,
0.0183130261,
0.0078696124,
-0.0046503483,
-0.0165610947,
0.0006251083,
0.0012930755,
-0.0452135876,
0.0005021622,
0.0387803912,
-0.0163137428,
-0.0495092496,
-0.0475653149,
-0.03764119,
0.0210379735,
-0.0513248444,
0.0102777416,
2.734793117e-34,
-0.0045890682,
-0.0208007228,
0.0184950177,
0.0272773784,
0.063480489,
-0.0279024839,
-0.0124149211,
-0.0165862069,
-0.0161019992,
-0.0921102092,
-0.0199891888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17233v1 | Self-Constructed Context Decompilation with Fined-grained Alignment Enhancement | 2024-06-25T02:37:53 | 2024-06-25T02:37:53 | Yunlong Feng, Yang Xu, Dechuan Teng, Honglin Mu, Xiao Xu, Libo Qin, Wanxiang Che, Qingfu Zhu | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Decompilation transforms compiled code back into a high-level programming
language for analysis when source code is unavailable. Previous work has
primarily focused on enhancing decompilation performance by increasing the
scale of model parameters or training data for pre-training. Based on the
characteristics of the decompilation task, we propose two methods: (1) Without
fine-tuning, the Self-Constructed Context Decompilation (sc$^2$dec) method
recompiles the LLM's decompilation results to construct pairs for in-context
learning, helping the model improve decompilation performance. (2) Fine-grained
Alignment Enhancement (FAE), which meticulously aligns assembly code with
source code at the statement level by leveraging debugging information, is
employed during the fine-tuning phase to achieve further improvements in
decompilation. By integrating these two methods, we achieved a Re-Executability
performance improvement of approximately 7.35\% on the Decompile-Eval
benchmark, establishing a new state-of-the-art performance of 55.03\%. | [
-0.0614273213,
0.0559380092,
-0.0033241403,
0.0784914121,
-0.0131389145,
0.0414073952,
-0.0392520763,
-0.0173100922,
-0.0227065831,
-0.0111762909,
-0.0376850963,
0.0898267105,
-0.005679816,
-0.0308276843,
0.0169917364,
0.0564664491,
0.0311965756,
0.0087753152,
-0.0626045018,
0.0261970665,
-0.0257561505,
0.0164936576,
0.0164255686,
-0.0081375567,
0.0180006158,
-0.0485027805,
-0.0056405705,
0.0706338882,
0.0350919962,
0.0041394634,
0.0230316818,
-0.0217224043,
0.0281158555,
-0.0135985566,
0.0000023654,
0.0135554746,
-0.0295936652,
0.0276282448,
-0.0532409996,
0.0560931116,
-0.0051168939,
-0.0089528514,
-0.0208697766,
0.0255748201,
-0.0214710496,
-0.012863283,
0.0205143262,
-0.034139242,
0.0466746315,
0.0639106557,
0.022443397,
-0.0572711863,
0.0045965221,
0.026929047,
-0.0022875231,
-0.0230951458,
-0.0238404442,
0.0091596665,
-0.0432653688,
-0.0196558032,
-0.002412519,
0.0224268697,
0.0273297839,
0.037814673,
-0.0099877492,
-0.011223861,
-0.0421287864,
0.019569939,
-0.0264569465,
0.0416029245,
-0.0675050914,
-0.0453143604,
0.0121882735,
-0.0225424692,
-0.0080475053,
-0.0648758337,
-0.0009324998,
0.0302090086,
0.0037333507,
0.0599704497,
0.0330017395,
-0.0239203125,
0.0468570776,
-0.0331923589,
-0.033469893,
0.0707805231,
-0.0050350823,
-0.0026168255,
-0.0170384571,
-0.0380502306,
0.0257614031,
-0.0064262571,
0.0033350266,
0.0153045487,
0.0184326954,
0.0210735369,
-0.0463587232,
0.0133286836,
0.0108208898,
-0.0283848643,
0.0023705096,
0.0611639358,
-0.0312703028,
-0.0055727144,
-0.0651299432,
0.0401702821,
-0.0131519353,
0.0041626971,
-0.0375160761,
0.0369359404,
-0.0001069693,
0.0131461853,
-0.0496271066,
0.0406255908,
-0.0572176836,
0.0773488358,
-0.049820859,
0.0233059917,
0.0157387238,
0.0466540866,
-0.0326743722,
-0.0249038283,
-0.0373879187,
0.0050110421,
0.0521135516,
-0.0149443485,
-0.0047814604,
-0.044381991,
-0.0244930498,
-0.0658065453,
-0.0287250336,
0.0053341417,
-0.0498097613,
-0.0507791564,
0.0353651308,
0.0562368296,
-0.009359221,
0.0010216953,
-0.0730126053,
-0.0393823795,
0.0174103957,
-0.0197407808,
0.0021557542,
-0.0822141469,
-0.0095303571,
-0.0219235197,
-0.0077041532,
-0.0350766443,
0.0153689515,
-0.0169796608,
0.0012460494,
0.0718898848,
-0.0610200502,
-0.0142445136,
-0.006258016,
0.0369762667,
0.069834888,
0.0514543913,
0.0093330359,
0.0367486775,
-0.0249025598,
-0.0622059442,
-0.009863588,
0.0306359231,
0.0123047177,
-0.0068412977,
-0.0334220007,
0.0407618172,
0.0174496006,
-0.0248553902,
0.0882738829,
-0.0083215451,
-0.0104298629,
-0.0125334896,
-0.0628096536,
0.0255324319,
0.0323425829,
0.0360159725,
0.0103367558,
0.0331264623,
-0.0092569152,
0.0322590098,
-0.0576427504,
0.0140922274,
-0.0260403473,
0.0110231359,
-0.0010323745,
0.0620117635,
-0.0101044644,
-0.0673070997,
0.0082701407,
-0.0248702634,
0.0046517253,
-0.0016861628,
0.0023309821,
0.0004382278,
-0.0429206975,
0.05751222,
0.0408754908,
-0.0691312104,
-0.0588709041,
-0.0649660975,
-0.007618723,
0.009134911,
0.0314586349,
-0.0739041567,
-0.0403075963,
0.0378155559,
-0.0196619444,
-0.0573239326,
-0.0318246856,
-0.0134804314,
0.0743049607,
-0.0488054119,
-0.0108462907,
-0.0555175692,
0.0133828633,
0.0371081643,
0.0052738399,
-0.0569314249,
0.0289580878,
-0.0255207289,
-0.0046076151,
0.035183832,
0.0211620703,
-0.0473586842,
0.0312499087,
0.040124096,
0.0134537006,
-0.0093284743,
-0.0419058986,
-0.0123913521,
0.0813664123,
-0.0379341096,
0.0200755727,
-0.0404332802,
-0.0592032708,
-0.0817361996,
0.0240409579,
-0.023202192,
-0.0244772136,
-0.0045244703,
-0.0771227032,
-0.0171928722,
0.0277614053,
-0.0100474562,
0.0291784629,
-0.0045899781,
0.0388970822,
0.0065093078,
0.0233080443,
-0.0757610351,
0.0841878355,
-0.0003095523,
-0.0357069634,
-0.0035429089,
0.0316253081,
0.0411319509,
0.0285150465,
0.006336709,
-0.0468299389,
-0.0387342572,
0.0052662254,
-0.0285027362,
0.0053054872,
-0.0107780024,
-0.0405334122,
-0.0657665506,
0.0454600155,
-0.0220620874,
0.0434122197,
0.0494470894,
0.0236106198,
0.0223559905,
-0.0349698141,
-0.0061844136,
0.0078414092,
-0.024722036,
-0.0362130478,
0.0397895649,
-0.0185514484,
-0.0579979271,
-0.0311079267,
-0.0142379496,
-0.0235097036,
0.0066297282,
-0.0597309954,
-0.0147234779,
-0.0676839352,
0.1048897058,
0.0403589569,
0.0233436376,
-0.0214207117,
-0.0189987924,
-0.011875703,
-0.0209729467,
0.0122199031,
0.0850372761,
-0.0424376242,
0.0289543234,
0.0460266806,
-0.0032420016,
-0.0889340937,
0.0273769144,
0.0487262607,
-0.0313531086,
-0.0220328867,
-0.0209184512,
0.0345659964,
0.0579251125,
0.0078933407,
0.0097097363,
0.0109026162,
-0.0122036058,
0.0700843558,
-0.0291057732,
0.0078970548,
-0.0176135059,
-0.0044585653,
0.0197206251,
-0.0185367521,
-0.0749870166,
0.012729886,
-0.0266292803,
-0.0000872346,
0.001384386,
-0.033107359,
-0.0590570197,
0.0414514132,
-0.000912412,
0.0056109806,
-0.0120095788,
-0.0490290672,
-0.0129991211,
0.0173962731,
-0.0041281828,
-0.0402442031,
0.0699348226,
-0.0326041877,
-0.0043171085,
-0.0151741905,
-0.0287912153,
-0.01960955,
0.0086180447,
0.0254903585,
-0.0040881145,
0.0255509242,
0.0141049838,
0.0285940673,
-0.0133365253,
-0.0054134871,
0.0052650226,
0.06562078,
-0.0258323923,
-0.0204805359,
-0.0169231743,
-0.0364885628,
-0.01109883,
-0.0080841016,
-0.0035394265,
-0.0158867612,
0.0291359276,
0.0348046422,
0.0104695028,
-0.0773880705,
-0.0156395938,
0.0461698845,
0.0100754146,
-0.054992035,
0.0434476286,
0.0660611466,
-0.0697052032,
-0.0381928794,
0.0422778092,
0.0338249393,
-0.0284104757,
0.0230013188,
-0.0067349961,
0.0039896588,
0.0520401783,
0.0439523682,
-0.0872107148,
-0.056272652,
0.0029849152,
0.0191529468,
0.0546486825,
0.0235555731,
-0.0089676296,
-0.0685796589,
0.0501852892,
0.0454433858,
-0.0107020307,
-0.0629861802,
-0.0474684499,
-0.0326170176,
0.0013302269,
-0.0018424678,
0.0391453467,
-0.0113939308,
0.0148114255,
-0.0052192425,
-0.0470068157,
-0.0023581081,
0.0156307202,
-0.0056804586,
0.0678209811,
0.070570156,
0.0207532272,
0.0226072427,
0.0186145678,
0.0833545998,
-0.0546917543,
0.0480598286,
-0.0483035892,
0.041881416,
0.0176799651,
0.0011534384,
0.0439396091,
0.0063028028,
-0.0261299293,
-0.015808383,
0.0344564468,
0.0458985642,
-0.0131899314,
0.0082703251,
-0.0052975458,
-0.050488323,
-0.0168842208,
0.013936623,
0.0481938757,
0.0236273091,
-0.057668712,
-0.0311632473,
-0.0143239331,
-0.0355510339,
0.0322650634,
-0.0032639049,
-0.0344594195,
0.0058858162,
0.0035038344,
0.0403603241,
-0.0186582245,
0.0085219033,
-0.0036417146,
-0.0464772731,
-0.0203735903,
-0.0170743093,
-0.109051913,
-0.0044930908,
-0.0232403465,
0.0163448378,
-0.0110254521,
-0.0010298489,
-0.0072257533,
0.0083854748,
0.0247366093,
0.0276329443,
-0.0536392145,
-0.042841021,
-0.0064177061,
0.0747748166,
0.0054140212,
0.0693391338,
-0.0207451656,
-0.0155893415,
-0.0129801352,
0.0536234155,
-0.0182782169,
0.0617114231,
0.0324652158,
0.0094779748,
0.0213398524,
-0.0128495386,
-0.0174151789,
0.0108545832,
0.0805809423,
-0.0221639946,
-0.0368930958,
-0.0234247968,
0.0174521301,
0.0565294102,
0.0119024748,
0.0434079766,
0.0182172861,
0.0349593684,
0.0382483266,
0.0073424014,
-0.0054549156,
-0.0476076864,
0.0375892743,
0.0183094945,
-0.0431897901,
0.0365961567,
0.0140195563,
-0.0056447349,
0.0452410802,
-0.0312641263,
0.0425183922,
-0.017046703,
0.0494396202,
0.031718757,
0.0228418857,
-0.006804842,
0.0156103903,
0.0504626222,
0.0663254187,
-0.0133667542,
0.0091334563,
0.005945046,
0.0776061863,
-0.0253566727,
0.0375220738,
0.0048874966,
0.0174051858,
-0.0451431349,
-0.010112213,
0.0239153076,
0.0408749692,
0.0448901579,
0.0523653291,
0.0066561671,
-0.0113189444,
0.0582949147,
-0.0255797058,
-0.0218309816,
-0.0009560336,
0.0203767065,
-0.0410936624,
-0.0339707285,
0.0494469032,
-0.0197489578,
0.0352627747,
-0.0083073713,
0.0134359142,
-0.0449521355,
-0.041433055,
0.0037443959,
-0.0394399315,
-0.0114225727,
-0.0133960349,
-0.003356471,
-0.0441472009,
-0.0154696796,
0.0484950095,
0.0399351232,
0.0052480125,
0.0072832713,
0.0611813851,
0.0293129943,
-0.0490718074,
0.0087944493,
0.0077979537,
0.01756474,
-0.0463282615,
-0.0054388042,
-6.122690896e-33,
-0.0453592129,
-0.0019876177,
-0.0039975657,
-0.0036324554,
-0.0267134774,
-0.0207052678,
-0.0393839777,
-0.0073452354,
0.0255094282,
-0.0339228101,
0.0061713499,
0.008885297,
-0.0015633252,
-0.0399681479,
0.0040276782,
0.0134720504,
0.0317832865,
0.0122865606,
-0.0627821758,
0.0039500324,
-0.0095702177,
0.0436717942,
0.0192674901,
-0.0650644451,
-0.0733107254,
0.0093820682,
0.0211506467,
0.0090965983,
0.0138395438,
0.0085455105,
0.006863479,
-0.0563583821,
0.004809293,
0.020866489,
-0.0380817279,
-0.0136058638,
-0.0817190856,
-0.0115223415,
0.0247904193,
0.011234168,
0.0004579512,
-0.0778317153,
0.0519888327,
0.0331707485,
-0.0296898782,
-0.0209953282,
0.0087826326,
-0.0240741353,
0.0109378677,
-0.046374917,
-0.0491953455,
0.0096004745,
-0.0342877954,
0.0171425231,
0.0370190479,
-0.0154386964,
-0.0025778005,
0.019252006,
-0.0044584628,
-0.0065394319,
0.0205285084,
0.058622539,
0.0964930207,
0.0221622754,
0.0067587746,
0.0098085273,
0.0594986118,
-0.009916516,
-0.0389367528,
-0.0132070752,
0.034197282,
0.0817302391,
-0.0377276354,
0.0085546365,
0.0734084249,
0.0132340342,
-0.0795776919,
0.0227388181,
0.0063608787,
0.0141343344,
-0.033062201,
0.0688836575,
-0.0231405254,
-0.0013600691,
-0.0314156227,
0.0448749028,
-0.0392406695,
-0.0190904625,
0.0178654566,
0.0003871145,
-0.0677069649,
-0.0244198292,
-0.0040700813,
-0.02246641,
0.0343301073,
-0.0084889466,
-0.0124711208,
-0.0304546133,
-0.0052202805,
0.0043418733,
-0.0032266804,
-0.0484430641,
-0.0168861151,
-0.025840994,
0.119435139,
-0.0160535015,
0.0244557746,
0.0398269705,
-0.0565734021,
0.0163976699,
-0.0407276303,
-0.0461203791,
-0.0188236684,
0.0168266371,
-0.0263450816,
0.002816058,
-0.0004856411,
0.009298618,
0.0016564205,
0.0078005567,
-0.031224383,
0.014499221,
0.0470234938,
0.0356774442,
-0.0253201928,
-0.011810855,
0.0275034476,
0.0303937178,
0.0239560623,
-0.0266791061,
-0.0486395396,
0.0408327244,
2.929e-7,
0.035992045,
0.011531814,
0.0501733236,
0.0165331773,
0.001755645,
0.0343581438,
-0.0080968924,
0.0156842936,
0.0018617634,
-0.0080297561,
0.0071128886,
0.0287090838,
0.0528494194,
0.0027953333,
0.0077726771,
0.0985269472,
0.0367832109,
-0.0224941,
-0.0277721509,
-0.0384121314,
-0.000481101,
0.0592485219,
-0.0214688592,
-0.0270292256,
0.03371647,
0.0218898337,
-0.0168666057,
-0.036992237,
-0.0051287343,
0.0199431367,
-0.0795855224,
0.0326671377,
-0.0552279279,
-0.0378283784,
-0.021542212,
0.0063481666,
-0.037993297,
0.076303035,
0.0093578259,
-0.0127385454,
0.0561359115,
-0.0338362008,
0.0009800203,
0.0169278421,
0.0525491796,
-0.0376071669,
0.0047915154,
-0.0233031958,
-0.059456829,
0.0245028622,
-0.0316482075,
0.0050662463,
0.0468728766,
0.002176397,
0.0160628501,
-0.0382096581,
-0.0512976795,
-0.0557864495,
-0.0846292675,
0.0257242154,
-0.0097573306,
-0.0271094311,
-0.0156904552,
0.0435984321,
0.0067706611,
-0.0451909639,
0.014193303,
3.032895041e-34,
0.0212574489,
-0.0332444571,
0.017952852,
0.0477116853,
0.0160756353,
-0.0182001833,
-0.0515374243,
0.0579135865,
-0.0173859168,
-0.004938053,
-0.0003558492
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17232v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17232v1 | Beyond Demographics: Aligning Role-playing LLM-based Agents Using Human Belief Networks | 2024-06-25T02:37:29 | 2024-06-25T02:37:29 | Yun-Shiuan Chuang, Zach Studdiford, Krirk Nirunwiroj, Agam Goyal, Vincent V. Frigo, Sijia Yang, Dhavan Shah, Junjie Hu, Timothy T. Rogers | cs.CL | cs.CL | Creating human-like large language model (LLM) agents is crucial for faithful
social simulation. Having LLMs role-play based on demographic information
sometimes improves human likeness but often does not. This study assessed
whether LLM alignment with human behavior can be improved by integrating
information from empirically-derived human belief networks. Using data from a
human survey, we estimated a belief network encompassing 18 topics loading on
two non-overlapping latent factors. We then seeded LLM-based agents with an
opinion on one topic, and assessed the alignment of its expressed opinions on
remaining test topics with corresponding human data. Role-playing based on
demographic information alone did not align LLM and human opinions, but seeding
the agent with a single belief greatly improved alignment for topics related in
the belief network, and not for topics outside the network. These results
suggest a novel path for human-LLM belief alignment in work seeking to simulate
and understand patterns of belief distributions in society. | [
0.0518994406,
0.0725319311,
-0.017705759,
0.027034102,
-0.0521214008,
-0.0130634401,
-0.0124615747,
-0.0512206331,
0.0462245308,
0.0097254757,
0.0084542213,
-0.0889441818,
-0.0144979777,
0.0145885479,
0.0225894824,
-0.0282768086,
0.0104736844,
0.0096943537,
0.0525287054,
-0.0422321521,
-0.0006393008,
0.0466002636,
0.0070146197,
0.0180811379,
0.0055361087,
0.0035856375,
-0.0300687216,
-0.0137327807,
0.0735059232,
-0.0036744799,
-0.0147499852,
0.0095795859,
0.0556420982,
0.0322245136,
0.0000017729,
-0.0487305149,
0.046402622,
-0.0210435912,
-0.0007645977,
0.0064362204,
0.0635546148,
0.0423135795,
-0.0188594609,
-0.0062797354,
-0.0671932623,
0.0257389657,
0.0271038003,
0.054018233,
0.0246355459,
0.0199088473,
0.0078606019,
-0.0401072614,
-0.0286935773,
-0.0013197697,
0.038091477,
-0.0118423691,
0.0538134128,
0.0612586513,
0.0244189166,
-0.0154820038,
-0.0096513638,
-0.0075138714,
-0.0152770039,
-0.0185619667,
-0.0018231962,
0.0289532319,
-0.0134543125,
-0.0474295765,
0.0346773788,
0.0608980581,
0.0722768083,
-0.0487265661,
0.0107013127,
-0.0082518626,
0.0264250692,
0.1006404757,
0.0113176396,
0.0272739027,
-0.010035974,
0.0387012251,
0.017949285,
-0.0045988141,
0.0287798438,
0.0196930207,
-0.0288815722,
0.0926722661,
0.0098163579,
-0.0294151735,
-0.0250543226,
-0.0108883968,
-0.0399501324,
-0.0613308325,
-0.0102131581,
-0.013795183,
0.0013210234,
0.0397939868,
-0.0379960239,
0.0854015872,
0.023484569,
-0.0382251255,
-0.0133344578,
0.0289155077,
0.0243229587,
0.042593535,
0.0433881693,
0.0234318059,
-0.0292933192,
-0.0122772753,
-0.014282126,
-0.0077845999,
-0.0282218307,
-0.0028746061,
0.0059168134,
0.0025138729,
0.0462617613,
-0.023541037,
-0.0577472486,
0.0237466227,
-0.0563550927,
0.0197914131,
-0.0139376912,
0.0179286376,
0.0079082958,
-0.0307764504,
-0.0623539612,
0.042385973,
-0.0394733548,
0.0381074399,
-0.0140747111,
-0.0530128479,
0.0383696705,
-0.0017115405,
0.0015921071,
0.0032417702,
0.0111013865,
0.0127698658,
0.0231695436,
0.0077717514,
-0.0048201475,
-0.0065896199,
-0.0051712361,
-0.0769566745,
-0.013382338,
-0.0659807324,
0.0446255356,
-0.0106925843,
-0.0072185886,
-0.0428094007,
0.0023046571,
0.0181709174,
-0.05643427,
0.0642070919,
0.013033798,
0.0364901498,
0.0481920913,
0.0047764843,
0.0379142836,
0.0215773564,
0.0263230409,
-0.0022556165,
0.0052824924,
-0.0046076206,
-0.0023137999,
0.0210326631,
-0.0113554243,
0.0183890536,
0.005693045,
0.0024989175,
-0.0053841132,
0.0613770336,
0.0424997248,
0.0382632762,
-0.0295107272,
-0.0385044217,
0.0713896006,
0.0880612954,
-0.0060318015,
-0.0003306308,
0.0199121814,
0.0718568712,
0.0316829123,
0.0176856462,
-0.0583665296,
0.0344172455,
-0.0125293909,
-0.0141912,
-0.0147038791,
0.052382201,
-0.0213868041,
0.0433687679,
0.0034098523,
0.0042521576,
0.0456809178,
-0.0013364428,
0.0009124612,
-0.0534417853,
0.0019833636,
0.0069134072,
0.0434632748,
-0.0312094968,
-0.0170887224,
-0.0244231746,
0.0262410343,
0.0664728358,
0.00931245,
-0.0088438988,
-0.0424226448,
-0.0010982591,
-0.0001113766,
0.0499050692,
0.0442447066,
-0.0099587375,
-0.0708134472,
-0.040213529,
0.0010928826,
0.0336785056,
-0.005002521,
0.0547013469,
0.014958865,
-0.0183564425,
-0.0027579374,
-0.0170202367,
0.0210601017,
0.0114129679,
-0.0543317981,
0.034417022,
-0.0705476105,
0.0013901743,
0.0756641254,
0.0272222124,
-0.0118056471,
-0.0041332296,
0.005569757,
0.0336896703,
-0.0235407781,
0.0546979494,
-0.0427732877,
0.0249095727,
0.0445424877,
-0.0723100454,
-0.03489355,
0.0032292039,
0.0098442379,
0.006753752,
0.0256038066,
-0.0186953153,
0.0252963342,
-0.0272562504,
-0.0139366286,
-0.0322658159,
0.0276278444,
-0.0121210506,
0.0318456031,
-0.0028396733,
-0.009604631,
0.0123521006,
-0.0031128721,
0.0119730001,
-0.0533736683,
0.0100447387,
-0.0151429093,
0.030723026,
0.0143697606,
0.0551513508,
-0.0399996974,
-0.0336901546,
-0.035489127,
-0.0507846884,
-0.0204228312,
0.0342738964,
-0.0041565993,
0.0391697958,
-0.0147637147,
-0.0249417871,
0.0374132693,
-0.0762510449,
0.0412059017,
0.0351757258,
0.0248185601,
0.0064956849,
-0.0383662805,
-0.0526577942,
-0.0265094806,
0.0218086187,
-0.0434598625,
0.0131721394,
0.0337604843,
-0.0092724925,
-0.0429715998,
-0.0132037252,
-0.0820119679,
0.0217527524,
-0.0286227446,
-0.0500598177,
0.0154368337,
0.0263425335,
0.0260557048,
0.0263751447,
0.0305577386,
-0.0200878307,
0.0514119044,
0.0283548348,
-0.0576269701,
-0.0298516192,
-0.0348034315,
-0.0004946156,
-0.0653738379,
-0.0994023159,
-0.0085532097,
0.0570087098,
0.0225297641,
0.0018453128,
-0.057920821,
0.0436381735,
0.0161325056,
-0.045857545,
0.0112858498,
-0.0630906075,
-0.0271162651,
0.0083166528,
-0.0350714661,
-0.00643116,
0.087765418,
0.0074192784,
0.0185317602,
0.0219842214,
0.001413819,
-0.013436649,
0.0155011136,
0.0542760193,
-0.0000905034,
0.0064360322,
0.0264515486,
-0.0706226304,
0.0144596901,
0.0389135405,
-0.0447720438,
0.0381207392,
-0.0384551771,
0.0066869231,
0.020282913,
0.012139718,
-0.0212568734,
-0.0455976054,
-0.0274447072,
-0.0018825858,
0.0313041881,
-0.0298039522,
-0.0445701443,
-0.0134499129,
0.0327971652,
-0.0477263182,
0.0339130796,
0.0109422849,
-0.0113250911,
-0.0302725695,
0.0477216989,
0.0190511066,
0.030033486,
-0.0310675837,
0.0346869454,
0.0066704545,
-0.0195335913,
-0.0084261689,
-0.0307787806,
-0.0105322748,
0.0254948679,
0.0116417501,
0.013353141,
0.0263538938,
0.0412429199,
0.0253979452,
0.054921452,
0.0974183977,
0.0207012594,
-0.0215722173,
0.0044491799,
-0.0027609421,
0.0301036965,
0.0269066505,
0.0243899859,
-0.0831633583,
0.041970659,
-0.0146219498,
-0.005120913,
-0.016101297,
-0.0799181759,
0.0005978842,
-0.0934040397,
0.0184911359,
0.0241811555,
0.0074887616,
-0.0073134671,
-0.0345490053,
0.0285978578,
-0.0289759114,
0.0039954749,
-0.0060887877,
0.0264361035,
-0.0125512602,
-0.0093059754,
-0.044239141,
-0.0254679434,
0.033937797,
-0.0619697496,
0.115663901,
0.0161402356,
0.065767616,
-0.0115902852,
-0.0471003093,
-0.0342805311,
0.0377351753,
-0.0105985058,
0.0643261597,
0.0082892263,
-0.0235214867,
0.016194405,
-0.0588070564,
0.0327179953,
-0.0166347045,
-0.0448688604,
-0.0106403353,
0.0801630318,
-0.0164868962,
-0.0689776838,
-0.0039907983,
0.0332071632,
0.0049079256,
0.0740085021,
-0.0066481535,
-0.056986995,
0.0419349261,
-0.0120452195,
-0.0026425561,
0.0299353749,
-0.0914014652,
-0.0055957017,
-0.0088387206,
0.0000108628,
-0.0354381874,
-0.0488654785,
-0.0113998633,
-0.0104586529,
0.0023804088,
-0.0296114814,
0.0738513321,
-0.0387281813,
-0.0195985492,
0.0035867502,
-0.0750785023,
0.0208204947,
0.0294247624,
-0.0237470865,
0.0272271112,
-0.0692318454,
-0.0000718969,
-0.0566150956,
-0.0375418589,
-0.0706061497,
0.0720508769,
-0.0341242068,
0.0237161126,
0.0547131449,
0.0091582481,
-0.0216424856,
0.0258321594,
-0.0145229604,
-0.0369888842,
0.0581153333,
-0.0623208918,
0.0540637374,
0.0013680963,
0.0068875127,
-0.0184371043,
0.0431904458,
0.0085088741,
-0.0046911142,
-0.0666558594,
-0.121867232,
0.042684067,
0.031982217,
-0.0059149237,
-0.0140825817,
0.0047404873,
-0.0382276773,
-0.035019137,
-0.0446090475,
-0.0188071895,
0.0082287444,
-0.0727822632,
0.0482548922,
0.0088461442,
0.0199778583,
-0.0317507498,
-0.028440576,
0.0235016197,
-0.0025066012,
0.001723494,
0.0018969263,
0.0364568979,
0.0217084698,
-0.0080591803,
0.005693987,
0.0411977842,
-0.051506456,
0.0343224555,
0.0294797029,
0.0465545096,
0.0106316358,
-0.0350592546,
-0.0182120781,
-0.0039315014,
-0.0549616069,
-0.0482799411,
-0.0101866135,
0.0211293474,
0.0061368416,
-0.0041001728,
0.0183376428,
-0.0635217577,
0.0239490177,
-0.0040887436,
-0.0019846037,
0.0086084967,
-0.0305723753,
0.0573431551,
0.0234573949,
-0.0270461105,
0.0224304162,
0.0212766025,
0.0462868363,
0.0192957781,
-0.036842104,
-0.0474435054,
-0.0122768218,
-0.0103065912,
0.0021644183,
0.0105881887,
-0.0687862709,
-0.0151248593,
-0.0796947256,
-0.0392049849,
-0.0148293497,
0.0484796986,
-0.0137003502,
-0.0307675805,
0.0148181291,
0.0444500707,
-0.0292232502,
0.0226788502,
-0.0237411223,
0.0130898673,
-0.039121069,
-0.0010170088,
-0.0328255445,
-5.93585011e-33,
-0.0343015753,
-0.0271189753,
0.0269146655,
-0.0070167617,
-0.0534299053,
-0.0280888658,
-0.0246451572,
0.0276823156,
-0.0108073484,
0.0509546474,
0.0155432941,
0.0087332698,
0.014528078,
-0.0395623222,
0.023020912,
-0.0034517401,
0.0290366746,
-0.0050176224,
-0.0014954008,
-0.0341336764,
-0.0108309733,
-0.0220591202,
0.010839927,
-0.0996467024,
0.0342556834,
-0.0222255606,
-0.0202893596,
-0.0132695595,
-0.007771702,
0.0204789992,
-0.0236925706,
0.0174379367,
0.0216447152,
-0.0097503476,
0.0011799698,
0.0860242099,
-0.0008126686,
-0.0273795314,
0.0496285856,
-0.0044994741,
0.0032682742,
-0.0221816022,
-0.0007340906,
-0.0215152372,
-0.056015674,
0.0304735769,
0.0608858652,
-0.0146014709,
0.0399188548,
0.0254342165,
-0.0582711697,
-0.008323892,
0.0091000041,
0.0323545001,
-0.0402971171,
-0.0140203694,
-0.0313745663,
0.0180360172,
-0.0530756265,
0.0498840213,
-0.0288145076,
-0.0273840874,
0.0410401225,
0.0318483375,
0.0403376669,
0.0846382976,
0.0362672545,
0.0261012558,
-0.1036287397,
-0.047425095,
0.0306719076,
0.0016304499,
0.0187909491,
0.1200307384,
-0.017062692,
0.0065588909,
-0.0347805768,
0.0067278766,
0.0393928774,
-0.0055774837,
0.0404205136,
0.0315124094,
-0.0175379608,
-0.0197053812,
-0.0241764374,
0.0262688287,
-0.003483962,
-0.0504766069,
-0.0275211465,
-0.0213159025,
-0.0156754516,
-0.0049343747,
0.0167266056,
-0.0522784293,
-0.035435427,
0.0039729914,
-0.0106752003,
0.0007133465,
-0.0132550132,
-0.0083395494,
-0.0942009464,
-0.0095272455,
-0.001268295,
-0.0014040758,
0.0175241288,
0.0531584844,
-0.0402782708,
0.0036648724,
-0.0386528224,
-0.0179657862,
0.0006939732,
-0.0556700826,
0.0155572761,
-0.039938733,
0.0574942231,
0.0004242183,
0.0077255913,
-0.0606440231,
0.0385409407,
-0.0305437688,
0.002688779,
0.0179677512,
-0.0345838629,
0.0067590326,
-0.0187851302,
0.00985076,
-0.0660090372,
0.0062939371,
0.0270188935,
-0.0258911289,
-0.0199759547,
0.0000626823,
2.704e-7,
0.0022875306,
0.0512789823,
0.0054710116,
-0.0027288268,
0.0271990746,
0.031514965,
-0.0009480719,
0.0142143257,
0.0604667738,
-0.0973394364,
0.0451022647,
0.0303706899,
0.001266291,
0.0412367061,
-0.0815346465,
0.0213124715,
-0.0278546102,
-0.0061570294,
-0.0004620863,
0.0250904299,
0.0283906963,
0.0516726412,
0.0612734705,
0.0227524582,
-0.0232963581,
0.006617255,
0.0392310768,
-0.0490456484,
-0.0463902652,
0.025846431,
-0.0194763802,
-0.0469781496,
-0.0073899534,
0.0668028817,
0.0352941081,
0.0119035728,
-0.0163936932,
0.0140098501,
-0.0197927952,
0.0364451669,
-0.050314825,
-0.0357672162,
-0.0179985147,
-0.0281128883,
0.0198954865,
-0.0675623715,
-0.055881504,
-0.0140958242,
-0.0536056086,
-0.0189318378,
-0.0112273116,
0.0137544079,
0.0009337119,
-0.0081669074,
0.0206613149,
0.0251351967,
-0.0020022974,
-0.029529294,
0.0158843473,
-0.016390983,
-0.0674376264,
-0.0794510692,
0.009593972,
0.006656114,
0.0270705391,
-0.0188065544,
0.0365477689,
2.112861326e-34,
0.0198552832,
0.0371798575,
-0.0009343564,
-0.0383985005,
0.0436286926,
0.0010985646,
-0.0044107023,
0.0440752693,
0.0534723252,
-0.0719488189,
0.0117038302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17231v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17231v1 | CogMG: Collaborative Augmentation Between Large Language Model and Knowledge Graph | 2024-06-25T02:37:12 | 2024-06-25T02:37:12 | Tong Zhou, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models have become integral to question-answering applications
despite their propensity for generating hallucinations and factually inaccurate
content. Querying knowledge graphs to reduce hallucinations in LLM meets the
challenge of incomplete knowledge coverage in knowledge graphs. On the other
hand, updating knowledge graphs by information extraction and knowledge graph
completion faces the knowledge update misalignment issue. In this work, we
introduce a collaborative augmentation framework, CogMG, leveraging knowledge
graphs to address the limitations of LLMs in QA scenarios, explicitly targeting
the problems of incomplete knowledge coverage and knowledge update
misalignment. The LLMs identify and decompose required knowledge triples that
are not present in the KG, enriching them and aligning updates with real-world
demands. We demonstrate the efficacy of this approach through a supervised
fine-tuned LLM within an agent framework, showing significant improvements in
reducing hallucinations and enhancing factual accuracy in QA responses. Our
code and video are publicly available. | [
0.0493960641,
0.0212399028,
-0.0155193396,
0.0723815635,
-0.0211349856,
0.0106620574,
-0.0471639894,
-0.0075678537,
0.0599286854,
-0.0406312793,
-0.0114429556,
0.0111985439,
-0.0341638029,
0.0227849651,
0.0254303049,
-0.020192232,
0.0506736636,
-0.0275738109,
-0.0080832103,
-0.0449873097,
-0.0042277128,
0.0330403782,
-0.0226765387,
-0.0042239297,
-0.0018861479,
-0.0460965335,
-0.0077307485,
-0.0038122605,
0.0067919074,
-0.0048780884,
-0.0149369715,
0.0241115522,
-0.0004645178,
0.025787808,
0.0000019398,
-0.0485680625,
0.0168829076,
0.0055763824,
-0.0679648295,
0.0046615768,
-0.012144004,
0.0081609292,
0.0331870951,
0.0035203309,
-0.0872081742,
0.0160001609,
0.0066612544,
0.0324083678,
0.0588117912,
0.0715481639,
0.0124131264,
0.0082572578,
0.016379185,
0.0009148542,
0.0582725853,
-0.0545154288,
0.0492495932,
0.0653522089,
0.0684418753,
-0.0111795366,
-0.0364065729,
0.0465667173,
0.0019760721,
-0.0195609648,
0.0562606044,
0.019612249,
-0.0519156568,
0.0108665712,
0.0081507126,
0.0950272009,
0.010159852,
0.0138365766,
-0.0094423508,
0.0122192819,
0.0344513059,
0.0369419828,
-0.0434586667,
-0.0138078099,
-0.0185787976,
-0.0131034842,
-0.0298048779,
-0.0674163848,
0.043025557,
0.0183486231,
-0.0282550473,
0.1146927997,
0.008997567,
-0.0152377738,
0.0050949133,
0.0165418722,
-0.0187198129,
-0.0638317689,
-0.0057369769,
0.0771468133,
-0.0581089444,
0.0326109193,
-0.0115981735,
0.0011432333,
0.045175612,
-0.0491577052,
-0.0130247353,
-0.0071869814,
-0.0131116901,
0.068067126,
-0.0214155931,
0.0175682586,
-0.0208370611,
0.0384073816,
-0.0667821318,
-0.0301392563,
-0.0428200811,
-0.0362759344,
-0.0443644151,
0.0686430559,
-0.0249918923,
-0.0217066016,
-0.0322423428,
0.0523767658,
-0.0335601307,
0.0538992546,
-0.0006235963,
0.0586145967,
0.0045571392,
-0.0466678254,
-0.0386830121,
0.0544055849,
-0.0410861745,
0.0284017846,
0.0159183089,
-0.0383870266,
-0.0125472378,
0.005097216,
0.01214989,
-0.0050883899,
0.0027761699,
0.0546532869,
0.0184466839,
-0.0019777911,
-0.0103247035,
-0.0427789986,
-0.0111138755,
-0.0431224033,
-0.0243911501,
-0.0571994036,
0.0401493236,
0.0020243158,
-0.0316323042,
-0.0215804633,
0.0457774438,
0.0018585647,
-0.0547079369,
0.0675321072,
-0.0805313066,
0.0264309477,
0.0443716384,
0.0159795377,
-0.0343806259,
0.0705897734,
0.0200585648,
-0.0019038469,
0.0649922639,
-0.0062718745,
0.0393834785,
0.0175107848,
-0.0004402648,
0.0194816086,
0.0275413189,
0.0325308517,
0.0057275984,
0.0397531316,
0.0001388587,
0.0133451577,
-0.0223448202,
-0.022619402,
0.04420707,
0.0090211397,
0.0080563305,
0.0002775441,
-0.0041953805,
0.0054987608,
0.0039804685,
0.0356833637,
-0.0458304137,
0.0365366638,
-0.0567392334,
0.0210345127,
0.0208076555,
0.0388112739,
-0.0217378177,
-0.0220063254,
0.0052891248,
0.000712473,
0.0485887118,
0.0384127274,
0.0311454535,
0.0120111657,
-0.0089581953,
0.0342284068,
0.0252931491,
-0.0091596376,
0.0346446075,
-0.0195658412,
0.017074842,
0.0904867947,
0.0633630753,
-0.0472432487,
-0.1000469849,
0.0124624288,
0.002921249,
0.01567051,
0.024554994,
-0.0295448601,
-0.0061044553,
-0.0430890098,
-0.0310069583,
-0.0278750341,
-0.0019002623,
-0.0046248054,
0.015717186,
0.0095603941,
0.011225543,
-0.0731079206,
-0.0256622415,
0.0144293914,
-0.0339747928,
-0.0074327029,
-0.012087849,
-0.0083436845,
0.0038359945,
0.0325755365,
0.0193653721,
0.0254910532,
0.0271625593,
-0.034473259,
-0.0589545295,
0.0072084684,
0.0102604544,
-0.059126284,
0.0646321476,
-0.0043433909,
-0.0298554078,
-0.0133048659,
-0.0481558032,
-0.0382753722,
0.020106459,
-0.0145559926,
0.0522934236,
-0.041793976,
-0.0064350683,
0.0277053714,
-0.0035081676,
-0.0148207908,
0.0594716258,
0.012645375,
-0.010763335,
0.0242087469,
0.006043727,
-0.0139319096,
-0.0084217787,
0.0222570021,
0.024521837,
0.0238747038,
0.0289179161,
-0.0003246497,
-0.0545267537,
-0.0998183563,
-0.0039726524,
-0.0967458412,
0.0135197956,
-0.008833711,
0.0138361361,
0.0230312422,
0.0143332751,
-0.0085978368,
-0.0248563085,
-0.0644985884,
0.0461983792,
0.0325334854,
0.0257632639,
0.0059263962,
0.0338351801,
0.0107776159,
-0.0245945323,
0.0188625026,
-0.0046731168,
0.0213946868,
0.0273305569,
-0.0260586143,
-0.0860403255,
0.0128473882,
-0.0735923797,
0.0315475427,
-0.0060155871,
0.0017733277,
-0.0115871485,
-0.0203200206,
-0.0067368783,
0.0338477567,
-0.0013419221,
-0.0076726018,
0.0507414341,
-0.0191675201,
-0.0468168631,
0.0184861794,
-0.0252198465,
-0.027568398,
-0.0537001267,
0.0056418385,
0.0174700916,
-0.0119142858,
0.0007615324,
-0.0276567712,
-0.0556047559,
0.0034382425,
-0.0200637933,
-0.0255433656,
0.0023301726,
-0.0349524468,
-0.0139600923,
0.0109976716,
-0.0317628309,
0.0110370461,
0.0893170163,
-0.0110031497,
0.0000507,
-0.0201719068,
0.0013484631,
-0.0426826514,
0.0457546189,
0.0047131944,
0.0237259418,
-0.0528424159,
-0.0220577791,
-0.0502409935,
-0.0249403436,
-0.0123612387,
-0.0550109744,
0.0270164125,
-0.0325430296,
0.019819105,
0.0220331065,
-0.0100092208,
-0.0547009669,
-0.0373212807,
-0.0238655545,
0.0206307024,
-0.0311057717,
-0.0080079343,
-0.0043409565,
-0.0405051112,
0.0108137745,
-0.0106524704,
-0.0181921348,
-0.005671409,
-0.0319493823,
0.0257973578,
0.1029231399,
0.0409034118,
0.0159677248,
-0.0176573023,
0.0231841505,
0.0861351639,
0.0374283083,
-0.022362927,
0.0014786135,
-0.0283100177,
0.0069349254,
-0.058422707,
-0.0001680621,
-0.0211046338,
0.0502503775,
-0.0479676761,
0.0144549189,
0.101598978,
0.0222933777,
-0.0507945605,
0.0068527772,
-0.0498889163,
0.0040808548,
0.0358807407,
0.0450264961,
-0.1231695116,
-0.0084149232,
-0.03308345,
0.0296698045,
0.0298288278,
-0.0513774753,
0.0131553663,
-0.1155926809,
0.0250035282,
0.0295170005,
0.0179008245,
-0.0535314903,
-0.0113191335,
0.0490755923,
0.0344409496,
0.0077358433,
0.0094007971,
-0.007852857,
-0.0133857429,
0.032058984,
-0.0082052611,
-0.0107707232,
0.0170814153,
-0.0222910922,
0.0695826411,
0.0451494232,
0.0173686557,
-0.0100427307,
-0.0342558995,
-0.0044262419,
0.0094303237,
0.0260875318,
0.019665258,
0.0389309861,
-0.0003682134,
0.002830554,
0.0134098977,
0.0258767679,
-0.0431268439,
-0.0133981304,
0.0442013629,
0.111883536,
-0.0412202924,
-0.0338757932,
0.0138347931,
0.0217877999,
0.0107392492,
0.0525706299,
0.0233205762,
0.0005958064,
-0.011470844,
-0.0244465973,
0.0040518665,
-0.0244237967,
0.0026823769,
0.0538334027,
0.0006441211,
0.0473877005,
-0.0746555775,
-0.0740617439,
0.0892475471,
-0.0034026394,
0.0079612667,
0.0633389056,
0.0170748681,
-0.038704142,
-0.0040460783,
0.0157121513,
-0.0737773702,
0.0104695829,
0.0189966727,
-0.0053578485,
-0.0015788784,
-0.0311710313,
0.0111714136,
-0.0156478621,
-0.0626605898,
-0.0902077183,
0.0115562892,
0.0182199571,
0.0215345658,
0.0793512836,
-0.0510062166,
-0.0328408182,
0.0440884158,
0.0375570431,
-0.036829032,
0.0382380933,
-0.001978057,
-0.0117669934,
-0.0062612598,
0.0488799326,
-0.0887327343,
-0.0324995816,
-0.0146980314,
0.074026987,
-0.0582710765,
-0.0653536543,
0.0232532192,
0.0385211334,
-0.0262847394,
0.0194371417,
0.0401604511,
-0.0231958143,
0.0328744575,
-0.0146260476,
-0.022741193,
-0.0082715973,
-0.0295752622,
0.0164050199,
-0.068110168,
0.052088026,
-0.0355623737,
-0.0294574983,
0.0196855944,
-0.050444141,
-0.0359745137,
0.0006677943,
-0.0459827408,
0.0651182309,
0.0117508462,
-0.0174445938,
0.0245877057,
0.0220497753,
0.0403869376,
0.001986084,
0.0452252328,
0.0270722881,
-0.0377078466,
-0.0488363914,
0.0072417459,
-0.0467692018,
-0.1069346741,
0.0003818697,
0.0556464419,
0.0471864715,
0.005694312,
0.0523913354,
-0.0341798216,
-0.0236217324,
-0.0032203489,
-0.0102226483,
0.0100956662,
-0.0315792412,
0.0268452503,
0.0303529799,
-0.0188284367,
0.0192783903,
0.0829960778,
-0.0446696728,
0.0864323378,
-0.0046044067,
-0.016698163,
-0.0229434054,
-0.0648822188,
-0.005475265,
0.016734926,
-0.0399761945,
-0.0013577185,
-0.0405961946,
-0.0826275945,
0.0094406586,
-0.013399126,
-0.0500677489,
-0.01666536,
0.0272497758,
0.0487241521,
0.0340398364,
-0.0255603865,
-0.0417155959,
0.0359042324,
-0.0212026294,
0.0045269146,
0.0356179997,
-6.555250042e-33,
-0.0208192244,
-0.0530632101,
0.0461663194,
-0.0075628287,
-0.0551190749,
-0.0084040761,
-0.002776739,
0.0146731781,
-0.0341689028,
0.0328739993,
-0.006786054,
0.0317683741,
-0.0031766009,
0.0147205861,
0.0191014558,
-0.0305030085,
0.0152777694,
0.0060537155,
0.0015733397,
0.0290721022,
0.008689357,
0.0323547833,
0.0454966351,
-0.0639563054,
0.0417379811,
-0.0211319625,
0.0041574887,
0.0340234376,
-0.0243458692,
0.0414713584,
-0.0167272501,
0.0734080449,
0.0202473886,
-0.0046421639,
-0.006466303,
-0.0150709525,
-0.0580635928,
-0.0431823097,
0.0356560014,
0.0196146704,
-0.0672382116,
-0.0328757055,
0.0415317267,
-0.0009124934,
0.0451748073,
-0.0119253853,
0.0300907809,
-0.0509988926,
-0.040844176,
0.0083090831,
-0.0397314541,
0.0021185293,
0.0092803314,
0.0010431703,
-0.0184157714,
0.0123333661,
0.0003666852,
-0.0202383623,
-0.0583658777,
-0.0016288275,
-0.0007286437,
0.0081137754,
0.0570797436,
-0.0025515223,
0.0097137457,
0.0522257388,
-0.0109225735,
0.0352393948,
-0.0645238534,
0.0079835923,
-0.0364902429,
0.0569539852,
0.0033190332,
0.0258726142,
-0.0212197807,
-0.0083231898,
-0.0370666459,
0.0083142454,
-0.0225337092,
0.0461820737,
0.0079933871,
0.0051352489,
-0.020538412,
-0.0180140659,
-0.0260587223,
0.0524489693,
-0.0336848684,
-0.0520022735,
0.0144378645,
-0.0104396697,
-0.020613838,
0.016362207,
-0.0209174491,
-0.0657073036,
-0.0020088581,
0.0179548077,
-0.0105234627,
0.0017720766,
-0.0012034777,
0.0231011603,
-0.0056765587,
0.003415629,
0.0177307334,
-0.0250865053,
0.0012558108,
0.0480733626,
0.0092810737,
-0.0119111165,
-0.0364112705,
0.0079746656,
-0.0372128561,
0.0124538532,
-0.001729147,
-0.0458760932,
0.0245792884,
0.0401573181,
-0.0088766199,
0.0285490062,
0.0505211093,
0.0397826359,
0.0071330369,
0.0068392525,
-0.0008273273,
-0.0159883928,
-0.0382854231,
0.0080673164,
-0.0291636419,
-0.0064054942,
-0.0076147686,
-0.0440481715,
-0.014179376,
-0.0083547747,
2.81e-7,
0.0492269695,
0.0462150238,
0.0197637659,
0.0297134351,
0.0110952966,
0.0190666076,
-0.0101071578,
0.0062665944,
0.0379480273,
-0.0487650521,
0.0281987134,
0.0514975823,
0.0068307435,
0.050820969,
-0.0602567717,
0.0179881044,
-0.0371499993,
-0.0278603863,
-0.0714563876,
-0.0331326798,
0.0471806973,
0.0377971195,
0.0335477777,
-0.0023208433,
-0.0216079298,
-0.0906502157,
0.0476546064,
0.0129545145,
-0.0381557047,
0.0383670181,
0.0672170371,
0.0154321454,
0.0079264175,
0.0573680885,
0.0001624753,
-0.0135073448,
0.0104471985,
0.0218917578,
-0.0350462608,
-0.0381781869,
-0.0293494873,
-0.0408455841,
0.0523329042,
-0.0452163294,
0.0776378587,
-0.0272187162,
-0.0127081182,
-0.0050648027,
-0.064637132,
-0.0285478123,
-0.0012291139,
-0.0280778762,
0.0127412025,
0.0019588505,
0.0127463713,
0.0230713952,
-0.0238248892,
-0.0393086597,
0.0042149848,
0.0036547827,
-0.0402576216,
-0.0431084707,
0.0119661232,
-0.0001596255,
-0.013194656,
-0.0512944274,
0.0400893614,
2.29402521e-34,
0.0124423616,
0.0316314399,
0.0108137513,
0.0332390368,
0.0266615693,
-0.0075098337,
-0.0243332721,
0.0159395393,
0.0098971231,
-0.1154351532,
-0.0067610936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17224v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17224v1 | Large Language Models are Interpretable Learners | 2024-06-25T02:18:15 | 2024-06-25T02:18:15 | Ruochen Wang, Si Si, Felix Yu, Dorothea Wiesmann, Cho-Jui Hsieh, Inderjit Dhillon | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.SC, 68T05 | The trade-off between expressiveness and interpretability remains a core
challenge when building human-centric predictive models for classification and
decision-making. While symbolic rules offer interpretability, they often lack
expressiveness, whereas neural networks excel in performance but are known for
being black boxes. In this paper, we show a combination of Large Language
Models (LLMs) and symbolic programs can bridge this gap. In the proposed
LLM-based Symbolic Programs (LSPs), the pretrained LLM with natural language
prompts provides a massive set of interpretable modules that can transform raw
input into natural language concepts. Symbolic programs then integrate these
modules into an interpretable decision rule. To train LSPs, we develop a
divide-and-conquer approach to incrementally build the program from scratch,
where the learning process of each step is guided by LLMs. To evaluate the
effectiveness of LSPs in extracting interpretable and accurate knowledge from
data, we introduce IL-Bench, a collection of diverse tasks, including both
synthetic and real-world scenarios across different modalities. Empirical
results demonstrate LSP's superior performance compared to traditional
neurosymbolic programs and vanilla automatic prompt tuning methods. Moreover,
as the knowledge learned by LSP is a combination of natural language
descriptions and symbolic rules, it is easily transferable to humans
(interpretable), and other LLMs, and generalizes well to out-of-distribution
samples. | [
0.0300083533,
0.0578305572,
-0.0282202866,
0.0477545448,
-0.0082585514,
0.0192544181,
0.0150894495,
0.0280768368,
0.0091356477,
-0.0359922722,
-0.022920128,
0.0102984058,
-0.0414267965,
0.0690258667,
0.0147561431,
-0.0320696644,
0.0387847498,
-0.0310786758,
0.0338391364,
0.0290374607,
-0.0340665728,
0.0127519676,
0.004812168,
0.0411955044,
-0.0209729038,
-0.0050681653,
-0.0249316953,
-0.0003968818,
0.006049287,
-0.0233630054,
-0.0290078893,
0.0174019039,
0.0773680508,
0.0290782414,
0.0000022751,
-0.0443399623,
-0.0000849185,
-0.008472125,
-0.0718814507,
0.0011853931,
0.0264581367,
-0.0345674679,
0.0161084682,
0.0072555682,
-0.0279890206,
0.0086089056,
0.0340758301,
0.0235090721,
0.0768978074,
0.0751673952,
0.0108968336,
-0.008113713,
0.0300504565,
0.0167478081,
0.0190281663,
-0.0006508764,
0.0214055926,
-0.0069672582,
-0.0274998061,
-0.0162663441,
-0.0183328241,
0.0110454606,
0.0470531508,
0.0107044624,
0.0088098701,
0.0280240308,
-0.0076742657,
-0.0117816553,
-0.0400713533,
0.0905596763,
-0.0462807938,
-0.0169475675,
0.0018356984,
-0.0316260643,
0.0099885752,
-0.023606522,
-0.0211531445,
0.0391274206,
0.0036612828,
0.0268468652,
0.0098437183,
0.0264455955,
0.0568399429,
0.0202210248,
-0.0514519215,
0.0588102639,
-0.0281598717,
-0.0183281898,
0.0371764749,
-0.0376086794,
-0.0275270473,
-0.0205807947,
0.0389443897,
0.0533457771,
-0.0462760888,
0.0453960188,
-0.0206224732,
0.006494801,
0.0027574026,
-0.0557383671,
0.068125166,
0.041698169,
-0.0010812668,
0.0460609868,
-0.0334181488,
0.0449774414,
0.0158514027,
0.0620242804,
-0.0454979651,
-0.0056269336,
-0.0762851536,
-0.0196363088,
-0.0165598188,
0.0286633894,
-0.055520501,
-0.0214592963,
-0.0213549491,
0.0247822125,
-0.0237230845,
0.0263001788,
0.0179966893,
0.0116150267,
-0.0153300697,
-0.0082011037,
-0.0510841236,
-0.0141588096,
-0.0246676244,
0.0071781743,
-0.0172430612,
-0.0303510725,
0.0020774228,
0.001866994,
-0.020360399,
0.0013749436,
0.0219828859,
0.1158153415,
0.0076246178,
-0.0392673314,
-0.0584520847,
-0.037181031,
0.0285719242,
-0.0444434173,
-0.0069708461,
-0.0294933338,
0.0458795018,
-0.0048462222,
-0.0062202602,
-0.0719866306,
0.0062742536,
0.0069265594,
0.0236216951,
0.0760972351,
-0.0011913349,
-0.0110004116,
-0.0003119515,
-0.0047086659,
-0.0362193324,
0.0353581049,
0.0380234458,
0.0665339977,
0.0009904391,
-0.0211794898,
0.0065457206,
0.0282461252,
0.0037289213,
-0.0020451713,
-0.0729805008,
0.0057037203,
-0.0108834347,
0.0548111871,
0.025265554,
0.0269247461,
-0.0081479186,
-0.027590178,
0.0560957715,
0.043458201,
0.0335498601,
0.0012335764,
0.0785047635,
0.0364710838,
0.0232616924,
-0.0835241228,
-0.0931359753,
0.0078031528,
-0.0236098506,
-0.0201886147,
-0.0551298968,
0.007451334,
0.0113342945,
-0.0688051954,
0.0138459364,
-0.0180781428,
0.0313571133,
0.0351225734,
0.0690854639,
-0.0294257663,
-0.042302575,
0.0492248833,
0.0415210947,
0.0063315486,
0.0054204529,
-0.0600854494,
0.0545766763,
0.0912289619,
0.0109444745,
-0.056249354,
0.0342940465,
-0.031539429,
-0.0250488836,
0.0150594208,
0.0026806274,
0.0004773985,
0.03476125,
-0.0418004729,
-0.0312793031,
0.0086464612,
0.008016197,
0.0430050455,
-0.0095780045,
-0.0151627613,
-0.0013700881,
-0.0261709616,
-0.046900861,
0.0654833838,
-0.0229571927,
-0.0573382527,
0.0164360013,
-0.0006144361,
0.0496408641,
0.0068220901,
0.0073073814,
-0.0050085899,
0.0241331626,
-0.0465330705,
-0.0445295833,
-0.0161051527,
-0.0561240353,
-0.0192331113,
0.0302593987,
-0.0173456669,
-0.0032726668,
0.0284977797,
-0.064482905,
-0.0290910359,
0.0134491054,
-0.0550498143,
0.0053129178,
-0.0310829282,
-0.0141263548,
0.010139714,
0.0050338195,
-0.0459369309,
0.0398699082,
-0.005328299,
-0.0383948311,
0.0345486924,
0.0048742499,
-0.0113294227,
-0.0114588374,
0.0016985803,
0.0099736005,
-0.0151662724,
0.0006323391,
-0.0188741684,
0.0186582208,
-0.0258821603,
0.0066783121,
-0.0644588023,
0.0143832359,
-0.0058997129,
-0.0092575308,
0.0016588796,
-0.0453918912,
-0.0080685122,
-0.0206376128,
-0.0283612423,
0.0307565685,
-0.0199574567,
-0.0050870935,
0.040758457,
0.0248380266,
-0.0495131016,
-0.0164274275,
-0.0198639464,
-0.0371841192,
0.0714721009,
0.014612617,
0.0145662623,
-0.0788256079,
0.0176564641,
0.0119993193,
0.0243742298,
-0.0147938803,
-0.0187654719,
-0.0018460531,
-0.0207116585,
-0.0550649688,
0.0543762818,
0.004032799,
0.0528060161,
0.0375597849,
0.0026750132,
-0.0899178162,
0.0141675882,
-0.0046331696,
0.0105546014,
-0.0374861807,
-0.0466220751,
0.0378279909,
0.0820354447,
0.0393565744,
0.0048158891,
-0.0580742434,
0.0452281758,
-0.0093561169,
-0.055034101,
-0.0832314789,
-0.0085746031,
-0.0154939741,
0.0418540202,
0.0086345226,
-0.0755775124,
0.0826443657,
0.009975276,
0.0024312269,
-0.0142534934,
-0.0719306991,
-0.0576509275,
0.082572028,
0.0146456556,
0.0090933694,
0.0191259794,
-0.0284547787,
-0.0316515155,
-0.0203756578,
-0.0302588977,
-0.0219995845,
0.0545076393,
-0.0690826178,
-0.0159968995,
0.0132984547,
-0.0111741191,
-0.0463776439,
-0.048920691,
-0.0333754346,
0.0064863185,
0.0080798026,
-0.0222960152,
0.0029759342,
-0.0241599567,
0.0087416889,
0.0271917228,
-0.0020371387,
-0.0281785559,
-0.0341690816,
-0.0289469119,
0.0141620617,
0.016419556,
0.0303260013,
-0.0167013854,
0.0201415867,
0.0287070293,
-0.0317343883,
-0.0032540106,
-0.0709419399,
0.0379747413,
-0.0088475691,
-0.0609042682,
0.0054802271,
0.0597356781,
0.0258896835,
-0.1152704656,
0.0035093431,
0.1124260202,
0.0339210518,
-0.0264891963,
0.0339146592,
0.0004761652,
-0.0340407453,
0.026918713,
0.0310982931,
-0.0797333792,
-0.0555135459,
0.0028119811,
0.0170359351,
-0.0214926433,
-0.0407946818,
-0.0213759765,
-0.0862844661,
0.0126310205,
0.0030805594,
-0.0816749632,
-0.0088793319,
-0.0461854823,
-0.0461210869,
-0.0311693791,
0.0047654761,
0.031720344,
-0.0211990941,
0.0010850013,
0.0000294427,
-0.0212374851,
-0.0117021017,
0.0674191341,
-0.0099740168,
0.0370997787,
0.0317051411,
0.0120690018,
-0.0297315065,
-0.0243632682,
0.0334542207,
-0.0110275764,
0.0300591178,
-0.0240039006,
0.0259067286,
0.0142793264,
-0.0092517324,
-0.0260058939,
0.0395081826,
-0.0629963428,
-0.0196492895,
0.0138829667,
0.0883515328,
-0.026558565,
-0.0245220251,
-0.0193823371,
-0.0136727924,
0.0244518947,
0.0812975541,
0.0249005836,
-0.0539865643,
-0.0507135876,
-0.0351410843,
-0.0263748057,
-0.0094750402,
-0.0412850343,
0.0132248597,
-0.0147725744,
-0.0091428552,
-0.0473585613,
-0.0326605402,
0.0342694782,
0.0090948371,
0.0261503328,
-0.010838843,
0.0097270031,
-0.0160847697,
-0.0465845279,
0.0689985901,
-0.026705442,
0.0317896754,
-0.0246109199,
-0.0098261004,
0.0132532753,
-0.0507970341,
-0.0463744849,
0.0214972459,
-0.0368036926,
-0.0259364191,
-0.0093134716,
0.0864782631,
0.0263409391,
0.0199356712,
0.005429009,
-0.0256456528,
0.0514177307,
0.0485194884,
-0.0129699791,
-0.0336595811,
0.0363578796,
0.0511324331,
0.0088387392,
0.0257266667,
-0.0372825116,
0.0370404199,
0.0181495696,
0.0065888474,
-0.037599273,
0.0128942812,
0.0353129469,
0.0228779223,
0.0149137694,
-0.0102815572,
-0.0619975254,
-0.0309027676,
0.0046075094,
-0.0128334723,
-0.0011356168,
-0.0532552786,
0.0145546161,
0.0278172418,
-0.0083917631,
-0.0030310568,
-0.065310806,
0.0011962883,
-0.0089411056,
-0.0083058551,
0.0098400768,
0.034730006,
0.0376238413,
0.0167334247,
0.0053092157,
-0.0279985443,
0.0355366059,
-0.0224189125,
0.0330702886,
0.0142039638,
0.0647221729,
0.0195003115,
0.0047521521,
-0.083386369,
0.013478823,
-0.0320144147,
-0.0666261315,
0.0131004471,
0.0184835065,
0.0151764862,
0.0299754217,
-0.0189088229,
-0.0363893807,
0.0218118057,
-0.0013288958,
0.0261478983,
-0.0055525866,
-0.0130312229,
0.0471992493,
0.0353068449,
-0.0245098323,
-0.0352477171,
0.0509051532,
0.0008392938,
0.0416226313,
-0.0012422582,
-0.0027785557,
-0.0597322509,
0.009766533,
0.0360839553,
0.0148423351,
-0.0341596827,
-0.0065732077,
-0.0484094471,
-0.043364279,
0.0301057454,
0.050200358,
0.0178688411,
-0.0142927198,
0.036839135,
0.0182030741,
-0.0099703465,
-0.0403883494,
-0.0270365719,
0.0112056099,
0.0084259463,
-0.0296486467,
-0.0399668925,
-6.309443888e-33,
-0.0040528565,
-0.0157306138,
0.03123012,
-0.0001231017,
-0.0157261603,
-0.0098358644,
-0.0325279832,
-0.0306601897,
0.0234320275,
0.0188152995,
0.0030814996,
-0.0023920874,
0.0139573896,
0.0099599976,
0.0167048499,
-0.0563857108,
0.0399777591,
0.0123432642,
0.009026506,
0.009777463,
0.0803813115,
0.0524344705,
0.0468901433,
-0.0666302443,
0.0377390124,
0.0483042002,
-0.0024193819,
0.0239499472,
-0.0331054069,
0.0286694262,
-0.0147904223,
0.0541484393,
0.0258159488,
-0.0573107153,
-0.0161337815,
0.0280817281,
-0.0479271486,
-0.0331438817,
0.0238888729,
0.0178749468,
-0.0239879601,
-0.0301824044,
0.0786305517,
-0.0177673995,
-0.0118283927,
0.0009427049,
0.0240539629,
-0.0544013567,
0.003571491,
-0.054287605,
-0.0461047925,
0.0101599405,
-0.019138325,
-0.0024578532,
-0.0069748671,
0.0415742137,
-0.0306851305,
0.0464452542,
-0.0568755828,
-0.0209152568,
0.0281276535,
-0.0118910372,
0.0452237874,
0.0173841808,
0.0104025519,
0.0595341213,
0.0506407693,
-0.0510635488,
-0.0239629317,
0.012509061,
0.0270566251,
0.063659057,
0.0538916811,
0.0246923696,
0.0632372275,
0.0025438999,
-0.0770286471,
0.0158140603,
0.0214131661,
0.0397741646,
0.0218353383,
0.0299299713,
-0.0544689037,
0.0028813907,
-0.0457464494,
-0.0073936302,
-0.0322898068,
-0.0272358917,
0.0491959453,
-0.0102270423,
-0.02115798,
-0.0111010764,
0.0200233236,
-0.0488269925,
0.0080791702,
0.0243895259,
0.0221555252,
0.0095384903,
0.0056102723,
0.0000143207,
-0.040692728,
-0.0626171157,
0.0189654585,
-0.0526712015,
0.0578481071,
0.0019111125,
0.0259929132,
0.0399604626,
-0.0276124608,
-0.004376397,
-0.0388129354,
0.0013112803,
0.0162126347,
0.0407892875,
0.0391228497,
0.0142865684,
-0.0248230025,
0.0241571181,
-0.0188108254,
-0.0318687186,
0.0024323198,
0.0298303552,
-0.0075195376,
0.0208480097,
-0.0244432949,
-0.0135115311,
-0.0167574473,
0.0046219872,
0.0449722297,
-0.0695321262,
0.0069240546,
0.0233526062,
2.91e-7,
0.0210988373,
0.0534656234,
0.0055666231,
0.0403097309,
0.023533931,
0.0458356254,
-0.0133570172,
0.0264301877,
-0.0061640907,
-0.0393115543,
0.0235914774,
0.0451492816,
0.0301053748,
0.0122801736,
-0.0714415833,
0.003613964,
-0.027542565,
-0.014804366,
-0.0764572844,
0.0362268575,
0.0808896422,
0.1213050559,
0.0482900925,
-0.0288221203,
0.0512044877,
-0.0197275113,
0.024102034,
-0.0895472765,
0.0227344837,
-0.0124464519,
0.0285746865,
-0.0183616672,
0.0216843206,
0.0537837408,
0.0001753318,
0.0362032838,
-0.0327609666,
0.0869571269,
0.0015908459,
0.0059232498,
-0.0161543954,
-0.0262796767,
-0.0007526515,
-0.0365968943,
0.0613009818,
-0.092072852,
-0.0352881514,
-0.0325836204,
-0.0057419166,
-0.0607508458,
0.0186330415,
-0.0223396122,
0.0358080305,
0.0277186893,
-0.0097230794,
-0.0305145755,
0.0106098885,
-0.0552001558,
-0.0266790204,
-0.0044524097,
-0.0563040562,
0.0020799018,
-0.0628976673,
0.0329748355,
0.0337846875,
-0.0670824796,
-0.00607133,
2.648846343e-34,
0.0265812352,
-0.0151543859,
0.0145498393,
0.0333476551,
0.0356236622,
0.0281178448,
-0.0609721467,
0.0282074362,
0.0385117456,
-0.0661156848,
-0.0012921931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17213v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17213v1 | Detecting Frames in News Headlines and Lead Images in U.S. Gun Violence Coverage | 2024-06-25T01:56:47 | 2024-06-25T01:56:47 | Isidora Chara Tourni, Lei Guo, Hengchang Hu, Edward Halim, Prakash Ishwar, Taufiq Daryanto, Mona Jalal, Boqi Chen, Margrit Betke, Fabian Zhafransyah, Sha Lai, Derry Tanti Wijaya | cs.CL | cs.CL | News media structure their reporting of events or issues using certain
perspectives.
When describing an incident involving gun violence, for example, some
journalists may focus on mental health or gun regulation, while others may
emphasize the discussion of gun rights. Such perspectives are called
\say{frames} in communication research. We study, for the first time, the value
of combining lead images and their contextual information with text to identify
the frame of a given news article. We observe that using multiple modes of
information(article- and image-derived features) improves prediction of news
frames over any single mode of information when the images are relevant to the
frames of the headlines. We also observe that frame image relevance is related
to the ease of conveying frames via images, which we call frame concreteness.
Additionally, we release the first multimodal news framing dataset related to
gun violence in the U.S., curated and annotated by communication researchers.
The dataset will allow researchers to further examine the use of multiple
information modalities for studying media framing. | [
-0.0104271257,
0.0360665992,
-0.0096445056,
0.0035464738,
-0.0411866829,
0.0277061276,
0.01948121,
0.008579866,
-0.0271997601,
-0.0779227614,
0.0295252483,
-0.0010455997,
-0.0071551292,
0.0346088819,
-0.0314890258,
-0.0874440223,
0.0425752886,
0.0515437648,
0.0576773509,
0.0485951081,
0.0463205352,
0.0384751223,
-0.0327499546,
0.0336734466,
-0.0543854684,
-0.0114668803,
-0.0186589807,
0.0189485811,
0.036605835,
-0.0510263517,
-0.0370481424,
0.0281447563,
0.0601543449,
-0.0214297473,
0.0000016235,
-0.0041838768,
0.0268121678,
-0.0380241685,
0.023173837,
-0.0244372971,
0.0471947305,
-0.1148287132,
0.0120576099,
-0.022411583,
-0.020117538,
-0.0771509111,
0.0294289701,
0.0567363799,
0.0316811875,
0.0329601429,
-0.0223322064,
-0.0336724557,
-0.017244814,
-0.0029376666,
-0.0082461173,
-0.0008139576,
0.0132920379,
-0.0009272072,
-0.0267287288,
0.0250023603,
-0.0240210332,
-0.0013412337,
-0.0070065251,
-0.0027906038,
-0.0773366764,
0.0107441489,
-0.0042587877,
-0.0308666639,
0.0312845632,
0.0511145853,
0.0577954017,
-0.0275521073,
0.0111298738,
-0.0234876238,
0.0031993822,
0.0441595651,
-0.0448790416,
0.021865705,
-0.0290212017,
0.0221353434,
-0.0167534612,
0.0116124405,
-0.010594137,
0.028220918,
0.027321605,
0.0012029817,
-0.0139316199,
0.0237503331,
-0.0154225184,
0.0083316118,
-0.0042050541,
-0.0242071375,
-0.032644596,
0.0009366494,
0.009851872,
0.0399507619,
-0.032270547,
-0.0403921269,
-0.001253925,
-0.0686915144,
-0.0607936569,
-0.0023054995,
-0.0171348043,
0.0282655712,
0.0237043165,
-0.034986116,
0.0021912344,
-0.003469473,
-0.0013531628,
0.0461861752,
-0.0784781128,
0.0152525399,
0.0030080208,
0.0013869938,
-0.0132632442,
-0.0388845503,
-0.0179618746,
-0.0190790985,
-0.016168071,
-0.0101109454,
-0.0933528095,
0.0062509589,
-0.0142556336,
-0.0055157812,
0.010635064,
0.0430119708,
-0.0523494333,
0.021320425,
0.0188823342,
-0.0101318108,
0.0098578809,
0.0058527221,
-0.0174217653,
0.0080617666,
-0.0324104875,
0.0160160121,
-0.0345286019,
0.0155257806,
-0.0472122021,
-0.0637465194,
-0.0189682525,
-0.0108935777,
0.0298857335,
-0.0380443335,
0.0217201654,
0.0243194718,
0.0413493849,
-0.0263710227,
-0.0126509899,
-0.0020875933,
-0.0447508432,
0.0802175254,
0.0362089239,
-0.0018654023,
0.0760074109,
0.0606279261,
0.0402951837,
0.1054903045,
-0.0081965225,
0.0531590246,
0.0328970663,
-0.0268396251,
-0.0264965799,
-0.0208239984,
0.0045926487,
0.0292300582,
0.0003453871,
-0.0039210278,
0.0097849891,
0.0000364908,
0.0192255434,
-0.0528537892,
-0.0241037477,
-0.0068731345,
0.0459435806,
0.0377917849,
-0.0174738038,
-0.0267365649,
0.036955066,
0.0553010292,
-0.0076216208,
0.0332809128,
0.0067753913,
0.0187384244,
-0.0169893391,
-0.0186921842,
-0.0181032345,
0.0110979425,
-0.055009611,
0.0039395061,
0.0044286456,
0.0196936224,
0.0266846027,
-0.0408250652,
0.0151700824,
0.0175339561,
-0.038624391,
0.0966010019,
0.0370865017,
0.0134047195,
-0.0028204217,
-0.0256883986,
-0.026610801,
-0.0041837762,
0.0158811379,
0.002328051,
-0.0225664712,
-0.0292951837,
0.0870258287,
0.0252561737,
0.0087179532,
0.0208905805,
-0.0201739371,
-0.0018854244,
-0.029074356,
-0.0263703912,
0.0362827443,
0.0219462402,
-0.017421281,
0.0370408557,
0.0009349239,
0.0740857273,
-0.013072459,
0.0350903086,
0.0539658964,
-0.0220648702,
-0.0359914415,
0.0350830965,
0.0098139616,
0.0058861626,
0.0011035862,
-0.0209031552,
0.0149632497,
0.0105607891,
0.0130762132,
0.0658829734,
-0.0326164812,
0.024925258,
-0.0307732914,
-0.0826331228,
0.0223895498,
-0.0224076305,
-0.0418763794,
-0.0045698583,
0.0490909256,
-0.0269090291,
-0.0319501683,
-0.0183613729,
-0.0200219657,
0.000949428,
-0.0160015263,
0.012592108,
0.0858316123,
0.0080335326,
0.00528938,
0.0023780093,
-0.0197702013,
0.0037879078,
-0.0025674715,
0.0205242354,
0.0111988038,
-0.0381688625,
0.0088866875,
0.0180239547,
-0.0623445585,
-0.0273895748,
0.0202210154,
-0.084035106,
-0.0008730862,
-0.0255672652,
-0.0345983319,
0.0522507653,
-0.0294710994,
-0.0268490817,
-0.0145652192,
0.0297520943,
-0.0319304876,
-0.0060224356,
0.023447223,
-0.0177306626,
0.0384606197,
0.0210062191,
-0.0129203638,
-0.0136876516,
-0.0359330252,
0.0850110576,
-0.00272916,
-0.0749809593,
-0.0357003249,
0.0212769993,
-0.0031971599,
-0.0134931877,
-0.0234691352,
-0.0157575179,
0.0350511745,
0.0150746386,
-0.0816570297,
0.0631221831,
0.0509794541,
0.0986009762,
0.0312008914,
0.0118044652,
-0.0128297228,
0.0020485269,
-0.0260515548,
0.0015994391,
-0.0168486629,
-0.0683399513,
0.0382210314,
0.0096306838,
0.0246210974,
0.0320209339,
-0.0322371013,
0.0099744694,
-0.0020704989,
-0.0360893942,
-0.05072302,
-0.0144498115,
0.0294279233,
0.0625625104,
-0.0154832406,
0.0089113461,
-0.0088338656,
0.0325805843,
0.0691952184,
0.0241168607,
0.015942134,
-0.0477081798,
0.0294902138,
0.0112967435,
0.0272688176,
0.0076227067,
-0.0384579152,
0.0179082677,
-0.0661298856,
0.0600784197,
-0.0059031984,
0.0394333042,
-0.0158263277,
-0.0002590918,
0.0051954659,
-0.0462037362,
-0.0108158858,
-0.0839705095,
-0.0090242736,
-0.0208020862,
-0.0461539775,
0.0093579106,
-0.0615930036,
0.0164802223,
0.0398323424,
-0.0237062853,
0.0146988099,
0.0028077944,
0.0085013388,
0.0857921615,
0.0291060377,
-0.0427295528,
-0.0237441044,
-0.0149323456,
0.019733388,
0.0469834246,
-0.0221893024,
0.0743004456,
-0.0280699525,
0.0154448356,
-0.0158545524,
-0.001442853,
-0.0340555646,
-0.0083071161,
0.0471858233,
-0.0009786832,
0.0308927968,
0.0669226721,
0.0425368212,
-0.0110574318,
-0.0204625688,
0.0121637546,
-0.0275762249,
0.0298760626,
0.0066216951,
-0.0582464747,
0.004117297,
-0.0072971843,
-0.0397304446,
-0.0517921634,
-0.0441777408,
-0.0116120996,
-0.0569773689,
0.0379812755,
0.0100857448,
0.014690185,
-0.0021022253,
-0.0506599881,
0.0062569105,
-0.0053610788,
-0.0287306402,
-0.0069570737,
-0.0271712057,
-0.0413858294,
-0.014240548,
-0.0136005329,
-0.0358236246,
-0.0361796543,
-0.0185196269,
-0.0252182353,
-0.0071681459,
0.041485019,
-0.0518960655,
0.0034927735,
-0.0534159057,
0.0208523273,
0.0079667503,
-0.0088040549,
0.066024892,
-0.0295548774,
-0.0134008182,
-0.0339983292,
0.0466197357,
0.0731125176,
-0.0666510388,
0.009338256,
-0.0058669746,
-0.0388247631,
-0.0167323109,
-0.0348522589,
0.0492300764,
0.0389512368,
0.0250629187,
0.0578149818,
-0.0102751171,
0.0237884074,
-0.0357773937,
0.0426598899,
-0.0283304043,
-0.0306322426,
0.0007002742,
-0.0310689956,
0.0061113741,
-0.0351261273,
-0.0165075194,
0.0074958303,
0.0186981708,
0.0041137231,
-0.0081043057,
-0.0030745459,
0.0006936255,
-0.0921174958,
0.0237469189,
0.0330850035,
-0.0283378065,
0.0368541777,
0.0358973257,
0.0158288144,
0.0178780183,
-0.0394465886,
0.0737609565,
-0.0372580141,
-0.0110009694,
0.0124241542,
-0.0423109606,
0.0105061485,
0.0124176061,
0.0392225198,
-0.0226041395,
0.053552635,
0.0541984066,
0.0256902128,
-0.00733764,
-0.0157419182,
-0.0195027776,
-0.0004510601,
-0.0255347677,
0.02465377,
0.0390502177,
0.0295817852,
-0.0582618788,
-0.0475386828,
0.0806066915,
0.0077497405,
-0.0474950038,
0.0376978181,
-0.0325929187,
-0.0202038474,
-0.0062626377,
-0.0336892083,
-0.0334342234,
-0.0018142747,
0.0256903227,
0.0034851274,
0.0130952224,
-0.0013980659,
-0.051254075,
0.059372507,
-0.0230195336,
0.0712822005,
-0.0415767431,
-0.0009111576,
-0.0111942003,
-0.0106732091,
-0.037425857,
-0.0065828236,
0.0051941713,
0.0581267923,
-0.0197172835,
0.0165880378,
0.0010816228,
0.0835345089,
0.0376261771,
0.0330181941,
0.0018950839,
0.0126224989,
-0.0387682281,
0.0002098304,
-0.0387796275,
0.0527782291,
0.0450124182,
-0.0563904047,
-0.0210517328,
-0.0036206322,
-0.0317093171,
0.0152528109,
0.0249627735,
0.0269484557,
-0.0471232422,
0.03660243,
0.049730245,
0.0053351196,
0.0116207963,
0.0300397724,
0.0008595817,
0.0332601778,
0.0700416714,
-0.0515663587,
-0.010918363,
0.0161854401,
0.0475807972,
0.0288319252,
0.0213488061,
-0.0073743504,
-0.0545344166,
-0.0072904979,
0.0597210117,
-0.0157440715,
0.0106981099,
0.0390887409,
-0.0326267593,
0.0385461524,
0.0531266518,
-0.0197278336,
-0.0286067668,
0.0154153919,
-0.0715279207,
-0.0075791487,
0.0214741845,
-5.729916724e-33,
-0.0402396545,
-0.0308065731,
-0.0546369366,
0.0149641139,
-0.0190237183,
0.0464565717,
-0.0065608313,
-0.0023934355,
-0.0144639378,
0.0490408875,
0.0359756015,
0.0304615423,
0.0141392658,
-0.0271265246,
-0.0039808522,
-0.0108161867,
0.0033666107,
0.0031869495,
-0.0145314801,
0.0194754414,
0.0218103155,
-0.0095762582,
0.0245890617,
-0.0489052981,
0.0102810943,
0.0005028041,
-0.0290456545,
-0.0629825294,
0.0679486692,
0.0565619208,
-0.0062861871,
-0.0121476855,
0.0571011789,
-0.0584191158,
-0.0106124086,
0.1234230101,
-0.0606260225,
-0.0107600233,
0.0827711448,
0.0044336105,
-0.0246913321,
-0.012654826,
0.0096218865,
-0.000253308,
-0.0289589949,
-0.0512454584,
0.0436151661,
-0.0494560972,
0.0316197053,
-0.0027380565,
-0.05469881,
-0.0100645516,
-0.0480751134,
0.0477108583,
-0.015612131,
0.0308138374,
0.0059196306,
0.0683713779,
-0.0743559971,
-0.0062631662,
-0.0286646876,
0.0262617487,
0.029484123,
-0.0022344422,
-0.0181586351,
0.0617903545,
-0.001403064,
-0.000062557,
-0.0682781637,
0.021011319,
0.0432428829,
0.0622926801,
0.0448597632,
0.1011314988,
0.0405814089,
-0.0226737317,
-0.1043035239,
-0.0011061653,
-0.0143342679,
0.0447262228,
0.0149507355,
-0.0104663009,
-0.0113538839,
0.0009755106,
-0.0532945879,
-0.0789413676,
-0.0374099799,
-0.0408320464,
-0.0018478229,
0.0169594977,
-0.0176850464,
0.043330159,
0.0410337336,
0.0021338968,
0.0056040175,
0.0288118534,
-0.012746105,
0.0463310219,
-0.0143947387,
0.0174386911,
-0.0076495213,
0.0021149341,
0.0342145711,
0.0248605888,
0.0436436944,
-0.0653497651,
0.0770300552,
-0.0181094594,
-0.03267809,
-0.006580404,
0.0020239388,
0.0186004676,
-0.0352170281,
-0.0171728209,
0.0415629968,
0.0491649769,
-0.014677817,
-0.0282116551,
0.0161628556,
-0.044784829,
0.0375753865,
-0.0473498479,
-0.0485880114,
0.0427328758,
-0.017314041,
-0.0299701504,
0.016047962,
-0.0203075949,
0.0527053699,
-0.0681159273,
-0.0357563794,
0.002365265,
2.468e-7,
0.0306922588,
0.0345624872,
-0.0147398775,
0.0319801942,
0.0334797241,
0.0358920321,
0.000115476,
0.0589080565,
0.020106649,
-0.1177653894,
0.021610273,
0.0408788025,
0.0380946249,
0.0195369814,
-0.0637373254,
0.0429063477,
-0.0294958781,
-0.0181874409,
-0.0516593195,
0.0175420977,
0.0628008321,
0.0265714601,
-0.0141657004,
0.0025496138,
0.005946578,
-0.0123321544,
0.0405568369,
-0.0349839553,
-0.0685749874,
-0.0184374917,
0.0114564244,
0.0313210189,
-0.0373172909,
0.0058999737,
-0.0283841677,
-0.0159475729,
-0.0052771224,
0.0178463385,
0.0271116253,
-0.0208957382,
-0.0490494147,
0.015738057,
-0.0335364901,
-0.0160292257,
0.0619150065,
-0.0518867187,
-0.03022727,
-0.0890302062,
-0.0783143267,
-0.0069780708,
0.0274476055,
-0.000305273,
-0.0119995708,
0.0269360468,
0.0132348016,
-0.0050757029,
-0.0083033619,
-0.0613035671,
-0.0102410512,
0.0298071876,
-0.0218581054,
0.051542405,
-0.0100588631,
-0.0356085449,
0.0332632251,
-0.0349271595,
0.0045939344,
1.536318885e-34,
0.0203101765,
0.059344627,
0.0161000732,
-0.0255773924,
0.0062007075,
0.0035051354,
-0.1033104062,
-0.0395619422,
-0.0073290351,
-0.0483623594,
0.0625534207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17186v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17186v2 | CLERC: A Dataset for Legal Case Retrieval and Retrieval-Augmented Analysis Generation | 2024-06-24T23:57:57 | 2024-06-27T15:55:57 | Abe Bohan Hou, Orion Weller, Guanghui Qin, Eugene Yang, Dawn Lawrie, Nils Holzenberger, Andrew Blair-Stanek, Benjamin Van Durme | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Legal professionals need to write analyses that rely on citations to relevant
precedents, i.e., previous case decisions. Intelligent systems assisting legal
professionals in writing such documents provide great benefits but are
challenging to design. Such systems need to help locate, summarize, and reason
over salient precedents in order to be useful. To enable systems for such
tasks, we work with legal professionals to transform a large open-source legal
corpus into a dataset supporting two important backbone tasks: information
retrieval (IR) and retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). This dataset CLERC
(Case Law Evaluation Retrieval Corpus), is constructed for training and
evaluating models on their ability to (1) find corresponding citations for a
given piece of legal analysis and to (2) compile the text of these citations
(as well as previous context) into a cogent analysis that supports a reasoning
goal. We benchmark state-of-the-art models on CLERC, showing that current
approaches still struggle: GPT-4o generates analyses with the highest ROUGE
F-scores but hallucinates the most, while zero-shot IR models only achieve
48.3% recall@1000. | [
0.036945764,
0.0048670038,
0.0052326699,
-0.0166070573,
-0.0602848902,
0.0051316209,
-0.0004380615,
0.0038059007,
-0.010577973,
-0.0623946823,
-0.0126536898,
0.0210755337,
-0.0460863933,
-0.0084013836,
-0.0333086662,
-0.0148425233,
0.0343183577,
0.0397883728,
0.0674763024,
0.033339899,
0.0093628708,
0.0206304621,
-0.0003104198,
0.0264423881,
-0.0076149977,
-0.021638779,
-0.0107838344,
0.0207614675,
0.0112425014,
-0.0349790603,
0.016564209,
0.0521139167,
0.0284853373,
0.033455532,
0.0000016623,
-0.0584016815,
-0.0019624594,
-0.0102022439,
-0.0092122853,
0.0045620725,
0.0224955641,
0.0021228273,
0.017890092,
0.0060357624,
-0.0449112952,
0.0207615718,
-0.0252284892,
0.0197618436,
0.0413158014,
0.0763943866,
0.0045308792,
-0.0603585541,
0.0586313829,
-0.0365891382,
0.0261807814,
-0.0206631348,
0.0099840816,
0.0278330725,
0.0300552752,
0.0003606578,
0.0559895262,
0.0073861554,
0.0232737232,
-0.0375771709,
0.0053194552,
-0.0133849699,
-0.0503525063,
0.029622525,
0.0285943393,
0.0301668458,
0.0481346361,
-0.0439398997,
0.0062188031,
0.0097222431,
0.0613533854,
0.0332177319,
-0.032219857,
0.0675316304,
-0.0399784558,
-0.0259731822,
0.0235969219,
0.0184451845,
-0.0134453848,
0.0191419162,
-0.0034967347,
0.0365443081,
-0.0104300184,
-0.0471328236,
0.0220420249,
0.008816869,
0.0401547365,
-0.0151571147,
0.0177761205,
0.0488001294,
-0.0121199256,
0.0122288996,
-0.0087509993,
-0.0300415866,
0.0801148638,
-0.0070609828,
0.014113429,
0.0089478241,
-0.0195333753,
0.068358399,
-0.0533204861,
-0.0328426808,
-0.0084856981,
-0.0151060224,
0.0042410642,
-0.0229860451,
-0.0607244782,
-0.0063680219,
-0.0428274237,
0.0489342883,
-0.1000471041,
0.0262526907,
-0.0219780616,
0.0182860494,
-0.0250149295,
0.0234694146,
0.0075703091,
0.0098759942,
-0.0189139042,
-0.0021303401,
-0.0655631945,
-0.0540278144,
-0.0430721603,
0.046774298,
0.0138076507,
-0.0230793878,
-0.0075459005,
0.0006840061,
0.0185674801,
-0.0318511799,
0.0190672465,
0.0692124665,
-0.0060451538,
-0.0431025401,
-0.0542754754,
-0.1095676199,
0.0004459838,
-0.0760636181,
-0.019453261,
-0.0708089694,
0.0176117197,
-0.0013991898,
-0.0445765331,
-0.0613253266,
-0.0035197681,
0.0732013136,
-0.0010950614,
0.0244708844,
-0.0205853321,
-0.039099887,
0.017810531,
0.0278221425,
0.0245609861,
0.0073226341,
0.0013317665,
0.0247524977,
0.019636089,
0.022604784,
0.0194110833,
-0.0126838982,
0.0205513723,
0.0497646853,
0.0199449696,
0.0361862667,
-0.0586675033,
0.0384412892,
0.0077695078,
0.0469663478,
-0.0268811043,
-0.0164372567,
0.0049001104,
0.0497313812,
0.0291256234,
0.0573224686,
0.0443428047,
-0.0106310351,
0.025506163,
-0.0156015037,
-0.0110335331,
0.0211702511,
-0.031092681,
0.0402976759,
-0.0526615791,
-0.0017340089,
-0.0399234965,
-0.0620347336,
0.0216717236,
0.0161949191,
-0.0443124846,
0.0022717619,
0.0357295386,
0.0388557762,
-0.0513915904,
0.0262624603,
0.0001231714,
-0.091298759,
-0.0238575507,
-0.0010625134,
0.0347719342,
-0.0049964092,
0.0771880001,
-0.0561175011,
-0.0034096201,
-0.0328473262,
-0.0143866949,
0.037717782,
0.0015530314,
0.0063982713,
-0.0299784038,
-0.0473271385,
-0.0529048815,
-0.0010386074,
0.0261694826,
-0.0075039994,
0.0168489665,
0.0125009939,
0.0507472046,
-0.0351478569,
-0.029798463,
0.0423466377,
-0.0168442,
-0.0400525853,
0.0190942157,
-0.0209792927,
0.0339182205,
0.0544927046,
-0.0041535632,
0.0089414008,
0.0308721568,
-0.0063076792,
0.0082615288,
0.0287041385,
0.013435021,
0.0136425765,
0.0395204574,
-0.0591786057,
-0.0085171945,
-0.0061886343,
-0.0519026518,
-0.0224127807,
-0.0019279816,
-0.0067715733,
0.0101052783,
-0.0507699847,
-0.0331009701,
0.0173051059,
-0.0305216108,
-0.0231893491,
0.0815998763,
0.0089287832,
-0.0060395487,
0.0206512883,
-0.0012878336,
0.0671146959,
-0.06548246,
-0.0123262517,
-0.0696653649,
-0.0298177041,
0.0025388889,
0.0371679999,
-0.0048172232,
-0.0748599246,
-0.0064846091,
-0.0583575219,
0.0296594612,
-0.0265598148,
-0.0044514821,
0.0028344453,
-0.0264124461,
-0.0078344662,
-0.0199488476,
-0.0012115997,
-0.015952386,
-0.0028851179,
-0.0042469408,
0.0333299339,
0.0122389551,
0.0244927872,
-0.0402714051,
-0.0283606667,
-0.0129097542,
0.028083384,
0.0527124517,
0.0279290974,
-0.024802167,
0.0882786661,
-0.0312385876,
-0.0115413638,
-0.034408953,
0.0467088334,
0.0138611263,
0.0002467846,
-0.0049745152,
0.0403898694,
0.0438821018,
0.0193065908,
0.0159844961,
0.000804543,
-0.0566642694,
0.0059687849,
-0.0025794401,
-0.0013560696,
-0.0000247335,
0.0035846084,
0.0215375498,
-0.0091159465,
-0.0039433446,
0.0029384056,
-0.0099852867,
0.0042955247,
0.0176292527,
0.0139879761,
-0.0475669429,
-0.0242113359,
0.0004757507,
0.0564065203,
0.0076703909,
-0.0524700657,
0.028142035,
0.0101198517,
0.0484973229,
-0.0509828925,
0.0137379449,
-0.0574895851,
0.0851897076,
0.0061936462,
-0.0141706597,
-0.0471334383,
-0.0034475441,
-0.0122093428,
-0.0330103152,
0.0778310597,
-0.061014235,
0.0913712606,
-0.0174948741,
0.0512109399,
-0.0344477557,
-0.0491103306,
-0.0247015562,
-0.0212513003,
-0.0201697908,
0.0198911484,
0.0154395169,
0.0059829908,
-0.0532305576,
-0.0207586959,
0.0413088687,
0.0377746411,
0.0086061489,
-0.044468049,
-0.0274975356,
0.0359507352,
0.0160923582,
-0.0449341349,
0.0129339807,
0.0046532783,
-0.0174703132,
0.0236864667,
0.0205379315,
-0.0068030655,
-0.0197784584,
-0.0249930955,
-0.0232690722,
-0.0899152309,
0.0108052343,
0.0041089919,
-0.0006033467,
-0.0477841496,
0.0116898241,
0.0642781332,
0.0145388534,
-0.0390020423,
-0.0411786251,
-0.036420241,
0.0261798222,
0.0228870008,
0.0390469618,
-0.1193399429,
-0.000133235,
-0.0118844267,
0.0269192364,
-0.0512410253,
-0.0443880521,
-0.019070467,
-0.135813728,
0.0966390893,
0.02550954,
0.0396339484,
-0.0352474973,
-0.0269403514,
0.0020479553,
-0.0319014862,
-0.0351834595,
0.0416729487,
-0.0417205021,
0.0067398939,
0.0002667559,
-0.0184043758,
0.0078946715,
0.0251654219,
-0.0364708602,
0.0138710868,
-0.0136233903,
0.0394203775,
-0.0007273029,
-0.0302122161,
-0.0070804805,
-0.0551141873,
0.0215436183,
0.0099518048,
0.0485714935,
0.0128084915,
0.0453930646,
-0.047863435,
0.0499605462,
-0.0266495384,
-0.0309262834,
0.0693409145,
0.0338547416,
-0.0556726418,
0.0234332364,
-0.0459782481,
0.0070019569,
-0.0193736013,
0.0525282919,
0.0187724717,
0.0396839641,
-0.0325409956,
-0.0159386564,
0.000808975,
-0.0734062567,
-0.0102596562,
-0.0215434507,
-0.0395092629,
0.0349840298,
-0.0352884494,
-0.0414437689,
-0.0090689706,
0.0361235738,
0.0006393821,
0.0320212431,
-0.0107070506,
-0.0093138209,
-0.0894321427,
0.0438339859,
-0.0394493118,
-0.0187267177,
0.0049046879,
0.0101958178,
0.0112740695,
-0.0191635024,
-0.0165219381,
0.0496602021,
0.0576512106,
0.0083312495,
-0.015835803,
0.0209114533,
0.0259706806,
0.0258164965,
-0.0228764527,
-0.0242536999,
0.0469544418,
0.0570904128,
-0.0254561994,
-0.0266771037,
0.0362335108,
-0.0613255464,
-0.0382776968,
-0.0240587369,
-0.0173929483,
0.0351453088,
-0.0155777773,
0.0135712903,
-0.0382505618,
0.0073987884,
0.0259913225,
0.0187271759,
0.0410404317,
0.0041522803,
0.0007708194,
-0.0261082854,
0.0024034109,
-0.0482564159,
-0.0113525074,
-0.0014483595,
0.0168193709,
0.0107954275,
-0.028149005,
-0.0203876887,
0.0609589592,
-0.0445586145,
0.0457588583,
-0.0473874845,
0.037824139,
0.0170187131,
0.0427867584,
-0.0072553339,
-0.0550623424,
-0.0425443575,
0.0165354367,
-0.0295775235,
0.0602286495,
0.0052519813,
0.0510135442,
0.0156241907,
0.0417453535,
0.0382897891,
0.0092322892,
-0.0846075416,
0.0052156798,
-0.0208468232,
-0.0123446872,
0.0400170349,
-0.0142868292,
0.0205168743,
-0.0288554933,
-0.0178891774,
-0.0020984535,
0.0448555201,
-0.0032239356,
-0.0123565057,
0.012699944,
0.0421579406,
-0.0173233952,
0.0141623635,
0.028289305,
-0.0167453066,
0.0301529896,
-0.0143777076,
-0.0343382061,
-0.0174889397,
-0.0588985942,
-0.0262053609,
0.042857185,
0.0075892578,
-0.0747602656,
-0.0926833004,
-0.0143077439,
0.0070547597,
0.0295376908,
0.0057229232,
0.0288906787,
0.0179486535,
0.0375608504,
0.0138757797,
-0.0376991592,
-0.0634435117,
0.059004765,
-0.0660471544,
-0.0369820371,
-0.0122491401,
-5.157424894e-33,
-0.0142517742,
-0.0506389104,
0.0471406765,
0.0198524874,
-0.0227076411,
-0.0117700538,
-0.0205208249,
-0.02126237,
-0.0435157716,
0.0242690556,
-0.0378488488,
0.0386242494,
0.0169729646,
0.0121887811,
0.029012939,
0.0244743284,
0.0189027283,
0.0187630299,
-0.0245275609,
0.0325872079,
0.0291423295,
0.0074925083,
0.0075893491,
-0.1062527597,
0.0283437371,
-0.0053959922,
0.0063249264,
-0.0277349371,
-0.0480280668,
0.053890992,
0.0074223829,
0.0417995341,
0.0231945515,
-0.0339219831,
0.025413353,
0.0271279812,
-0.1002584174,
-0.0033070869,
0.0033828607,
-0.0639058575,
-0.02366421,
-0.0222348273,
0.0454606228,
0.0041521462,
-0.0235686507,
-0.0089630615,
0.0414592363,
-0.0506044626,
-0.0377397463,
-0.0815560669,
-0.0578057803,
0.0523517132,
-0.0133734252,
0.0316665173,
-0.0130610792,
0.0356990211,
0.0165801905,
0.0612989366,
-0.0734295473,
0.0016301554,
-0.0409370959,
-0.0034383878,
0.0132235391,
-0.0597117543,
-0.0073141363,
0.032952901,
-0.0196450278,
-0.0002852891,
-0.0287229251,
-0.0262508262,
-0.0080013983,
0.077542372,
0.0463338122,
0.0774346888,
0.036931213,
-0.0281428937,
-0.0560285747,
0.0078485217,
0.0346840322,
0.0617446341,
0.0120396297,
-0.0481784679,
-0.0324361436,
0.0219671093,
-0.0170568861,
-0.0468200296,
0.0012488363,
-0.0045794793,
0.0223774314,
0.013774151,
0.0502736159,
-0.0093398429,
0.012579916,
0.0151560297,
0.0414808206,
0.0564386472,
-0.0130128153,
0.0169537831,
-0.0057491167,
0.0100990729,
-0.0459600948,
-0.0269499794,
0.0133566093,
0.0036151465,
-0.0118700173,
-0.0141207688,
0.066058889,
-0.0224955678,
-0.0340954289,
-0.012539817,
0.0184650198,
0.0649879128,
-0.0133231506,
-0.0096708667,
-0.0096122837,
0.0578851737,
0.0387836881,
0.0311337542,
0.0279035848,
0.026954595,
-0.0249147806,
-0.049760446,
0.0244943239,
-0.0191636365,
0.03838313,
0.0115715163,
0.0234538019,
0.080370754,
0.028951196,
-0.0060049896,
0.0310060307,
0.0691067502,
2.515e-7,
0.1000586301,
-0.0057097473,
-0.0001668648,
-0.0003736648,
-0.0303294491,
0.0100071402,
0.0214097649,
0.0398067348,
0.0434008427,
-0.0127478559,
0.0276311971,
0.0032583638,
0.0251958091,
0.0409768932,
-0.0614953898,
-0.0721337199,
-0.063617833,
-0.0687373877,
-0.0565645136,
0.0159292482,
0.0471751504,
0.0490342081,
0.0043397178,
-0.0325315781,
-0.0132003613,
-0.0354822204,
0.0749241859,
0.0023710101,
-0.012695876,
-0.0111297201,
0.1013758108,
-0.0047441348,
-0.0009373199,
0.0283802673,
-0.0124100428,
0.0476431064,
-0.0578358546,
0.0209775008,
0.0180620626,
0.0084226904,
0.0111998934,
-0.0324367806,
0.0123873707,
-0.0337790549,
0.0377028212,
-0.03030481,
0.0135086654,
0.00451467,
-0.0718007609,
-0.0004027117,
0.0015066315,
0.0268446766,
-0.0016917688,
-0.0230900571,
0.0028500811,
0.0052145072,
0.013921842,
-0.0829938278,
0.0303689335,
0.0592397675,
-0.0058840155,
0.014872781,
0.0102559766,
-0.0297599025,
0.0440612584,
-0.0849093795,
0.0296478644,
1.924953159e-34,
0.0512259975,
-0.0030236698,
0.0178083163,
-0.0120951347,
0.0522545427,
0.0396777168,
-0.0362140574,
0.012998905,
-0.0047892504,
-0.0490300171,
0.0293425247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17185v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17185v1 | Vaporetto: Efficient Japanese Tokenization Based on Improved Pointwise Linear Classification | 2024-06-24T23:47:20 | 2024-06-24T23:47:20 | Koichi Akabe, Shunsuke Kanda, Yusuke Oda, Shinsuke Mori | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper proposes an approach to improve the runtime efficiency of Japanese
tokenization based on the pointwise linear classification (PLC) framework,
which formulates the whole tokenization process as a sequence of linear
classification problems. Our approach optimizes tokenization by leveraging the
characteristics of the PLC framework and the task definition. Our approach
involves (1) composing multiple classifications into array-based operations,
(2) efficient feature lookup with memory-optimized automata, and (3) three
orthogonal pre-processing methods for reducing actual score calculation. Thus,
our approach makes the tokenization speed 5.7 times faster than the current
approach based on the same model without decreasing tokenization accuracy. Our
implementation is available at https://github.com/daac-tools/vaporetto under
the MIT or Apache-2.0 license. | [
0.0106941629,
0.0325395763,
0.0019342417,
0.0499071591,
-0.0230919067,
0.0186649878,
0.0424654037,
0.0376727954,
-0.0287301466,
-0.026421221,
-0.0116431583,
0.0133381607,
0.0465389602,
0.0568957739,
0.0024444021,
-0.0888300687,
0.0657585487,
-0.0110424608,
0.0328421406,
0.0029068093,
0.020599084,
-0.0252948217,
-0.0094759511,
0.0541045666,
-0.0481294543,
-0.0052382443,
0.0066366568,
-0.0285431985,
0.001635209,
-0.0110308304,
-0.0352876671,
0.0236078575,
-0.0508882515,
0.0159545578,
0.0000017847,
-0.0391198061,
-0.0463884845,
-0.0166247524,
0.0439480841,
0.0139290448,
0.0259923451,
-0.0343378149,
-0.0337244086,
0.0251464862,
0.0090591423,
-0.074399434,
0.0622294508,
0.0364234298,
0.048749648,
0.0608527213,
-0.0333105549,
-0.0694442391,
0.0153876012,
0.0201364625,
-0.0491998978,
-0.01735669,
0.0234780293,
-0.0563740358,
0.0009016414,
-0.0442359969,
0.0060264552,
-0.0091645755,
-0.0358951688,
-0.019568406,
-0.0048098792,
0.0113362353,
-0.0384199768,
0.0026363314,
-0.0162936617,
0.0261742622,
-0.0467048138,
0.0041941423,
0.0043219663,
0.0228096824,
0.0015166819,
-0.0565609448,
-0.0148035269,
-0.0056560165,
-0.0360243022,
0.0030432388,
0.0044477056,
0.0245107915,
-0.001297709,
0.0049123205,
-0.051796414,
0.0429104306,
0.0271834247,
-0.0300795399,
-0.0162235275,
-0.028715156,
-0.0251050442,
-0.0646334216,
0.052579321,
0.0403836854,
-0.0206055678,
0.0090578385,
-0.015255468,
-0.0707391948,
0.016192507,
-0.0741908103,
-0.0068538105,
0.045717258,
-0.0330722295,
-0.0099608907,
-0.0586422086,
0.0597083531,
0.0304390937,
0.0364698023,
-0.025783848,
-0.0032589226,
-0.0413414016,
-0.0249686148,
-0.1175397635,
0.0760684535,
0.0123203639,
-0.0042262576,
-0.0548292361,
0.0062385937,
-0.0263727959,
-0.008828125,
0.0061036702,
-0.0358107165,
0.0230610333,
0.0348098837,
0.0106798429,
0.0085564284,
-0.0421370193,
-0.0304186027,
-0.0252353735,
0.0123871006,
0.0338367261,
0.0276158098,
0.0429583304,
0.018455578,
0.0352512114,
0.0506142639,
-0.0102231223,
-0.0359003656,
-0.0273772161,
0.0012346247,
-0.0306175705,
0.0004338057,
-0.0268045738,
-0.0427833796,
0.0305089522,
0.0076836799,
0.0127344402,
0.0200635046,
-0.0117230155,
0.0104168169,
0.0129087912,
0.0766360611,
0.0189050511,
-0.0007610616,
0.0293977521,
-0.0328801312,
-0.0118446629,
0.0121166231,
0.0498700663,
0.0575087033,
0.0337609015,
-0.025927633,
0.0284842327,
0.1031564251,
-0.0538245961,
-0.0503051877,
-0.0379989594,
-0.0209167115,
0.0345427133,
0.011766877,
0.0639771745,
0.0639624149,
-0.0114325983,
0.0634415373,
-0.0259996727,
0.0602329187,
0.0088350568,
0.0265363697,
0.0689391419,
-0.0211344026,
-0.0038946976,
-0.0339486189,
-0.0037400632,
-0.0043009464,
-0.0252689533,
0.0218620654,
0.008530803,
0.0035326625,
-0.0271301344,
-0.0428689234,
0.0082746977,
-0.0429460593,
-0.0056135892,
-0.0366099589,
0.0546849854,
0.0037207012,
-0.0554674752,
0.0613078661,
0.0005338542,
-0.0358711891,
-0.0331970304,
-0.0573226959,
0.0124572432,
0.0863616168,
0.0436843075,
-0.0284594391,
0.0586213805,
0.0477410704,
0.0182535518,
0.0090627605,
0.0122283166,
-0.0241620261,
-0.0079068011,
-0.0111063663,
0.002210405,
0.0613512956,
-0.0213618483,
0.0679755211,
0.0045833234,
0.0369471014,
0.0114252232,
-0.0200329293,
-0.0133951018,
0.0332281664,
0.0713122264,
0.01720386,
0.0398549661,
0.0554241948,
0.015424272,
0.0354587659,
-0.0102135241,
0.0345394462,
0.0118935267,
-0.0845702961,
0.0246598218,
0.0276132822,
-0.0010643218,
-0.009371751,
0.065493457,
0.0388317704,
-0.0380959362,
0.0052405219,
-0.0090727545,
-0.0312911607,
-0.0009071337,
-0.0166924242,
0.0247383751,
-0.0589431375,
0.0585070737,
-0.0028874248,
0.0127988253,
-0.0150061063,
0.0556008965,
0.0223486684,
-0.0054433942,
-0.0354044773,
-0.015800938,
0.0628083646,
-0.0302391052,
-0.0451056883,
0.0556353331,
-0.0393633321,
-0.0187437162,
-0.0154339438,
0.0260271933,
0.0042455951,
-0.0254148599,
-0.1305234581,
-0.0370317064,
-0.0107863415,
0.0116130542,
-0.0472983271,
0.0304862577,
-0.0147027941,
-0.0309989359,
-0.0106367329,
0.0083391406,
-0.0010546575,
0.012218209,
0.0311915223,
-0.0007097248,
-0.0526044667,
-0.0049675126,
-0.0070484127,
0.0218618698,
0.014216858,
-0.0179041903,
-0.0969553962,
-0.063244164,
0.010679788,
-0.0026102515,
0.0072588711,
0.0394975208,
-0.0321599245,
0.0100453664,
-0.0488232784,
0.0240490902,
-0.0007870306,
0.0131168021,
-0.0129458895,
0.0210445952,
-0.0201117191,
-0.0400159471,
0.0153689701,
0.0355460681,
0.0418069288,
0.0184421781,
-0.018703118,
0.0550512373,
0.0180787761,
-0.0102185924,
0.032519348,
-0.0380586497,
-0.0437411182,
-0.0049555395,
-0.0311667807,
-0.0456730835,
-0.0198488217,
-0.049079936,
-0.0274297353,
-0.0262688398,
-0.016929388,
0.0299965777,
-0.0618949607,
0.0111329518,
-0.0628895015,
0.0420078859,
-0.0398688577,
0.0599748231,
-0.0101325447,
0.0484666936,
-0.0190233197,
-0.1000503823,
0.0292415414,
0.0564265437,
-0.0189391095,
-0.0219001584,
0.0452646911,
-0.0320726335,
0.0428951867,
-0.0209365822,
-0.0234016888,
-0.0158299003,
-0.0111535368,
-0.0154431593,
0.017881183,
0.0223744381,
-0.0318473093,
0.0100591378,
0.1017771438,
-0.0273264702,
0.028720703,
-0.0209050961,
0.0133156488,
0.0163127631,
0.0336112194,
-0.0006898419,
-0.0079076979,
-0.0433765575,
0.0382331721,
0.0454269424,
0.0290062707,
0.0547332466,
-0.0058374167,
-0.0248021409,
-0.0062983409,
0.0291143786,
-0.082277596,
-0.0008818083,
-0.0054216809,
0.0169146601,
-0.0015254492,
-0.0242963489,
0.0928548723,
0.0377576463,
-0.0423299111,
-0.0254001264,
0.012835484,
-0.0262943283,
-0.0277123097,
0.0181723516,
-0.0637336522,
-0.0137502821,
0.0232647266,
0.0295234062,
-0.0105729317,
-0.00662287,
0.0192953981,
-0.1095471829,
0.0227816291,
-0.004664633,
-0.0746038482,
-0.053650979,
-0.0588422455,
-0.0165036563,
0.0138116367,
0.0409264863,
-0.0038894496,
0.0111482292,
-0.031774912,
0.0358981416,
-0.0706720203,
0.0103577459,
-0.0324042253,
-0.0101662846,
-0.0098455101,
0.0409340672,
0.0386785418,
-0.0117508741,
0.0000539559,
0.002561114,
0.012606509,
0.0146776671,
-0.0677888691,
-0.009578472,
0.0250665303,
-0.0496459566,
0.0491448119,
-0.0259461273,
0.0326346718,
-0.0124285445,
0.0118854837,
0.0154583175,
0.0309495777,
0.0343570337,
-0.0276280213,
-0.0452051088,
0.0024704726,
0.0326916464,
0.0233702455,
-0.0442151576,
-0.0224268641,
-0.0424749479,
-0.0200543758,
-0.0840003788,
0.0250704233,
-0.0574424565,
-0.0429329835,
-0.0314639024,
-0.0734151602,
0.0043514045,
0.0471551232,
0.0391148925,
-0.0288388003,
-0.0237366706,
-0.0573567487,
0.0437757224,
-0.0533645786,
-0.0311316121,
-0.0204549674,
0.0349941142,
-0.0804971531,
-0.0037510246,
-0.0166320708,
0.0302717574,
-0.0141709214,
0.0044873143,
0.000126292,
-0.0315160602,
0.0370951444,
0.06121004,
0.0062656384,
-0.0374148153,
-0.0206490345,
-0.0136679783,
0.0483217053,
0.0216413531,
-0.0153654963,
-0.0041617574,
0.0170839448,
0.0117586888,
-0.021085009,
-0.0086858403,
-0.0299209747,
0.0106955003,
-0.0003051588,
0.0122457966,
-0.0183067676,
-0.0050174198,
0.0202099569,
0.0472596772,
0.0304401722,
-0.0590060651,
0.0017113702,
0.0000871072,
0.0226091985,
-0.0235110465,
-0.0315833129,
-0.0074208872,
0.00999106,
-0.0018957034,
-0.0110639725,
-0.0258236062,
-0.0131473718,
-0.0108239055,
-0.0083344262,
0.0648842081,
-0.0048281485,
-0.0000184659,
0.064403154,
0.00648143,
-0.0123925433,
-0.0184109118,
-0.0342547446,
0.0528197251,
-0.028689757,
-0.0609348565,
-0.0042390712,
-0.0264146924,
0.0182630401,
-0.059733808,
0.0545581616,
0.0287232455,
0.0157888457,
-0.0099277422,
0.0464076549,
0.0332661644,
0.0060872822,
0.0012164133,
-0.0421722084,
-0.0137194376,
-0.0094238808,
-0.0199628342,
0.015288976,
-0.020936057,
-0.0252235532,
-0.0038517576,
0.0104759652,
-0.0792325735,
0.0623063669,
-0.0218074191,
0.0097116046,
-0.0248903278,
-0.009823069,
-0.0530698784,
0.0121214315,
0.0394884497,
0.0232069772,
-0.0483082607,
-0.0691522509,
-0.0301414579,
-0.0079251835,
0.0458703339,
0.0082995314,
0.0227998141,
0.0705988109,
0.0137409642,
0.0387877114,
0.0405347571,
0.0576015599,
0.0013689287,
0.0083150882,
0.0499945134,
-0.0269704331,
0.0156670287,
-5.007678301e-33,
-0.0350093879,
-0.0386232957,
-0.0102456594,
0.0175355449,
0.003047883,
-0.0104911616,
-0.0059020328,
0.0320917144,
0.0448026806,
-0.0532378666,
-0.0294974726,
-0.0070008277,
0.0497976691,
-0.0039203437,
0.0354364254,
0.0111661283,
0.0506572388,
0.0020502785,
-0.0018080551,
0.0035341708,
0.0614746772,
0.0344151817,
-0.0168289226,
-0.0235909317,
0.0203176476,
0.0342615321,
-0.0442369655,
0.0096495906,
0.0311488621,
0.0375444144,
-0.0151344743,
0.0618027598,
0.0193308163,
-0.0027127648,
-0.0012931169,
0.0601803325,
-0.110036552,
-0.0229916405,
-0.0034109238,
0.0645281971,
0.0663879812,
-0.0694985911,
0.0170722883,
0.0092753954,
0.0043106535,
0.0255748425,
0.0060110502,
-0.0442807935,
-0.0262230206,
-0.034537755,
-0.0836153477,
0.0121119916,
0.035967309,
0.0207014065,
0.0905955583,
-0.0410948135,
0.0069819461,
-0.0470473133,
-0.0189356562,
0.054618232,
-0.0183300972,
0.0004749213,
0.0316565745,
0.0413920097,
-0.0182665251,
0.0225622673,
0.0730732158,
-0.0307142232,
0.0195073802,
0.0512413494,
0.0243857615,
-0.0276264977,
0.0429573543,
0.0146631952,
0.0405033492,
-0.0417928845,
-0.0502822623,
0.0455787703,
0.0209068116,
0.0028345932,
-0.0313650519,
0.0182616357,
-0.0363104381,
-0.0326340497,
0.0354298651,
0.0148158222,
-0.0438294336,
-0.0568666942,
0.0078429533,
0.0088773705,
-0.048600208,
-0.0043896185,
0.0173575077,
-0.0065865307,
-0.0378218554,
0.0096301436,
0.0472207181,
0.051773455,
-0.0362544172,
-0.0237580296,
0.0116913719,
-0.0893215686,
-0.0110991756,
-0.04630455,
0.018392887,
-0.0124739567,
0.034814436,
0.0068254825,
-0.0807599649,
0.029510729,
0.0349612832,
0.00911202,
0.0075094276,
0.0552363656,
0.0043384442,
-0.0023834526,
0.0402389877,
-0.0404185168,
0.0332295559,
0.0084532639,
-0.0295457114,
-0.0160120577,
-0.0137388753,
0.0213011131,
-0.018183399,
0.0345750675,
-0.0164212827,
0.0376726314,
0.0109868348,
-0.0214148462,
-0.0161460117,
-0.0183724128,
2.475e-7,
0.0401308052,
0.0277264602,
0.0487382971,
-0.0290492773,
-0.0117809316,
0.0042104847,
0.0044088629,
0.0058944151,
0.0184696186,
0.0446671434,
0.0223707594,
-0.0093307039,
0.0301791355,
0.0220352635,
-0.1487678587,
0.0498287603,
0.0186559819,
0.0267709251,
-0.077140063,
0.0449727401,
0.0488187075,
0.0534355305,
-0.0486595854,
-0.0171840582,
-0.0249930937,
-0.0287569035,
0.0160966981,
0.053694699,
-0.0126922,
0.0074309832,
0.0446247309,
-0.0208644159,
0.0105585391,
-0.0277726408,
0.0105541851,
0.0291597378,
0.0696237236,
0.0022732753,
-0.030833045,
-0.0146682858,
0.0251202434,
-0.011280016,
-0.0033725065,
0.0024414237,
0.0458892249,
-0.0126548205,
0.0395313352,
-0.0130918697,
0.0274142064,
0.0337257795,
-0.0525249168,
-0.0099306367,
-0.0287847351,
0.0741636977,
0.0513860472,
-0.0573481098,
0.00586467,
-0.0300770476,
-0.0424040891,
-0.0245975684,
-0.0001453954,
-0.0165728629,
-0.0323640592,
0.0428244695,
0.0174513664,
0.0016635968,
0.0019382323,
2.073506143e-34,
0.0028743146,
-0.0176467523,
-0.0115318866,
0.0574718453,
-0.0190408509,
-0.0348892808,
0.0051228805,
0.0401212536,
-0.0314802788,
-0.0269539859,
-0.0103853168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17169v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17169v1 | Multi-LogiEval: Towards Evaluating Multi-Step Logical Reasoning Ability of Large Language Models | 2024-06-24T23:02:56 | 2024-06-24T23:02:56 | Nisarg Patel, Mohith Kulkarni, Mihir Parmar, Aashna Budhiraja, Mutsumi Nakamura, Neeraj Varshney, Chitta Baral | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As Large Language Models (LLMs) continue to exhibit remarkable performance in
natural language understanding tasks, there is a crucial need to measure their
ability for human-like multi-step logical reasoning. Existing logical reasoning
evaluation benchmarks often focus primarily on simplistic single-step or
multi-step reasoning with a limited set of inference rules. Furthermore, the
lack of datasets for evaluating non-monotonic reasoning represents a crucial
gap since it aligns more closely with human-like reasoning. To address these
limitations, we propose Multi-LogiEval, a comprehensive evaluation dataset
encompassing multi-step logical reasoning with various inference rules and
depths. Multi-LogiEval covers three logic types--propositional, first-order,
and non-monotonic--consisting of more than 30 inference rules and more than 60
of their combinations with various depths. Leveraging this dataset, we conduct
evaluations on a range of LLMs including GPT-4, ChatGPT, Gemini-Pro, Yi, Orca,
and Mistral, employing a zero-shot chain-of-thought. Experimental results show
that there is a significant drop in the performance of LLMs as the reasoning
steps/depth increases (average accuracy of ~68% at depth-1 to ~43% at depth-5).
We further conduct a thorough investigation of reasoning chains generated by
LLMs which reveals several important findings. We believe that Multi-LogiEval
facilitates future research for evaluating and enhancing the logical reasoning
ability of LLMs. Data is available at
https://github.com/Mihir3009/Multi-LogiEval. | [
0.0249127522,
0.0584999286,
0.0115963202,
0.038737122,
-0.0841524452,
0.0308271833,
0.0382661819,
-0.0244827382,
0.0355808772,
-0.0403419845,
0.0016216771,
-0.0159764886,
-0.0111998636,
0.0463317558,
-0.0000615573,
-0.0257373918,
0.0519344211,
-0.0714881271,
-0.0042912066,
-0.0052189697,
-0.0274318866,
0.0135160396,
-0.0195481442,
0.036366757,
0.0182713978,
-0.0343811661,
-0.0358537957,
0.0039976202,
0.0371975936,
-0.0425344296,
-0.0281660073,
0.0455431417,
0.0331714712,
0.0598987862,
0.0000019031,
-0.0690260455,
0.0094571039,
0.0060519562,
-0.0588599853,
-0.0094231404,
-0.0053265756,
-0.0077234409,
0.000593559,
0.031443093,
-0.0210406706,
-0.0129163424,
0.009262857,
0.0511707775,
0.0739504397,
0.061435204,
-0.0014089475,
-0.0818750039,
-0.000290998,
-0.0251493156,
-0.0140074743,
-0.0579306893,
0.0179626811,
0.0522023588,
0.0306780804,
-0.0177967139,
0.0151531408,
0.0073503735,
0.0587464646,
0.002162145,
-0.0725318864,
0.0385155976,
-0.0477147512,
-0.0363920033,
0.021341132,
0.0620837361,
-0.0063673919,
-0.0132819926,
-0.0410866253,
0.0038233919,
-0.0160075352,
-0.027500404,
-0.0179011598,
0.0372357927,
-0.0520594232,
0.0151784848,
0.0423976146,
-0.0093133403,
0.0412867256,
0.0137615493,
-0.0594005585,
0.1332449764,
-0.0017480531,
-0.0361632295,
0.0496968776,
-0.012991651,
-0.0299573503,
-0.04861404,
-0.0038598832,
0.0370983034,
-0.0232537426,
0.0382090807,
0.0035771292,
0.0354819074,
0.0412747078,
-0.0336611345,
0.0044312556,
0.0605336837,
0.0073416694,
0.0882005766,
-0.0261500888,
0.0418633297,
-0.0009757152,
0.0442614481,
-0.0019501774,
-0.0434629954,
-0.0430315547,
-0.0053369496,
-0.0082444474,
0.0181124248,
-0.0056295735,
-0.0036712994,
-0.043593958,
-0.0151259555,
-0.0167465694,
0.0178231914,
0.0387133695,
-0.0116751976,
0.0299837943,
-0.0453662761,
-0.0546703972,
0.0242112298,
-0.0510891229,
0.0411103033,
0.0300223567,
-0.0511964895,
-0.0172299407,
-0.0102944467,
-0.0035424596,
-0.0338484272,
0.0315144099,
0.0578478947,
0.0098149525,
-0.0271413922,
-0.0346872471,
-0.0320422128,
0.0174500942,
-0.1030041799,
0.0017217795,
-0.0611151792,
0.023525143,
0.0148136765,
-0.0092342161,
-0.0100729009,
0.0056182188,
0.0285638832,
-0.0263483599,
0.0831872225,
-0.0086294189,
0.0013008419,
-0.0213315766,
0.0158212781,
-0.0427742861,
0.0713695884,
0.02479285,
0.0241976865,
0.0141346594,
-0.0037647516,
-0.0257362388,
0.0109254923,
-0.0135922255,
-0.0254709609,
-0.0144380461,
0.0333386995,
-0.0685026273,
0.02919521,
0.0065304479,
0.0326396152,
-0.0329998136,
-0.0282995179,
0.0096300999,
0.045081757,
0.0389890857,
-0.0153747862,
0.0680534393,
-0.0233545266,
0.0239016637,
-0.0092305075,
-0.0835450664,
0.0176886749,
-0.0209262874,
-0.0016121037,
0.0085524544,
0.025283426,
-0.007415724,
-0.0491097309,
-0.0336400531,
0.0221511312,
0.0011657097,
0.006347877,
0.057186041,
-0.0009143739,
-0.0132652186,
0.0261444673,
0.0361373127,
-0.0432705954,
-0.0260250047,
-0.0582555868,
0.0164437443,
0.054031577,
0.0308742318,
-0.0157580581,
-0.0227327924,
0.0091839703,
-0.0044197901,
0.0255295616,
0.0211095568,
0.0131971519,
0.0228978395,
-0.0377610922,
-0.0165407993,
-0.0039508501,
0.013873578,
0.0388706066,
0.0153069794,
-0.0013367524,
-0.004031986,
-0.0275576711,
0.0417456925,
0.0153105753,
-0.0237585884,
0.020439554,
0.002446678,
-0.0038467145,
0.047441002,
-0.0042962986,
0.0013017086,
0.0055256947,
0.0083122822,
-0.0177791864,
-0.0433677211,
0.0230632033,
-0.0361537933,
-0.0657925531,
0.0423179828,
-0.0157678127,
-0.051192943,
0.0139662782,
-0.064016059,
-0.0228892993,
0.023306502,
0.0081682028,
0.0218279213,
-0.0490451492,
-0.0003138887,
0.0268668644,
0.0016107539,
-0.0055186423,
0.0983944833,
-0.021763403,
0.0175280161,
-0.0015981337,
0.028936049,
0.0281702336,
-0.0253606755,
0.0147261005,
0.0221340917,
-0.0253936611,
-0.0108680511,
-0.0324417837,
0.0100802928,
-0.0644173697,
-0.0178712197,
-0.0710591078,
0.0106162969,
-0.0154402955,
0.0334819406,
-0.0044643674,
-0.0127425753,
-0.0029919439,
0.0005830496,
-0.0314767361,
0.0093596447,
0.0146824839,
0.0234274101,
0.0119328825,
-0.022572536,
-0.00236257,
-0.015612416,
-0.0125072431,
-0.0457221158,
0.0399070829,
0.0027224501,
0.040553499,
-0.0219203997,
0.0058537666,
-0.0513837263,
0.0135099832,
-0.012664427,
-0.0307902731,
0.0264471751,
-0.010153261,
0.0268811751,
0.0894375667,
-0.0106909173,
0.0031375596,
0.0539466478,
-0.0207470097,
-0.0194292292,
0.0500518978,
0.0007248106,
-0.0038867581,
-0.025753038,
-0.0080707259,
-0.0518514402,
0.0655716062,
-0.0126595059,
0.0068355962,
-0.0492455363,
0.0294565503,
-0.0037051735,
-0.0089819105,
-0.0241570715,
0.0149641261,
0.0010874713,
0.0510029681,
-0.0251248125,
-0.0190817267,
0.07724116,
-0.0089352047,
-0.0063399714,
-0.0369573981,
-0.0027123732,
-0.0476935692,
0.0865340084,
0.0108509017,
-0.0104509732,
-0.0037044981,
-0.0088496357,
-0.0272135213,
-0.0146152629,
0.0319636837,
-0.0170344654,
0.0526367128,
-0.0606576912,
0.0213246066,
-0.0196979977,
-0.0431395508,
-0.0295488313,
-0.0182414148,
-0.0701255351,
0.0197073519,
-0.0353586897,
-0.0043005082,
-0.0516325273,
0.0057640029,
0.0066155349,
0.0308915898,
0.0101582985,
-0.0097156549,
-0.0131007507,
0.0101540787,
0.0241870657,
0.034701813,
0.034735743,
-0.0139238928,
0.0602932125,
0.0434711017,
-0.0009322157,
0.0051987288,
-0.0270846989,
0.0421451963,
-0.0184549764,
0.0012177021,
-0.0006519216,
-0.0028939904,
0.0394098125,
-0.0690337047,
-0.0027062031,
0.1185563132,
0.0179482903,
-0.0084978221,
0.0009696638,
-0.0379160754,
0.0561283529,
0.022001639,
0.0024659487,
-0.0799610391,
-0.0787099674,
0.0298271962,
-0.0039043552,
-0.010762943,
-0.0502529144,
-0.0153670367,
-0.1137166619,
0.0331054367,
-0.0296768472,
-0.0219041668,
-0.018002497,
-0.0654083192,
0.0177195258,
-0.0281309001,
-0.0148931881,
0.0287862699,
0.0112413801,
-0.009353945,
-0.0057373489,
-0.0253362805,
-0.0219069216,
0.0978529677,
-0.0295476839,
0.0258133132,
0.0169835035,
0.0207962338,
0.0059879646,
-0.0328808241,
0.0165934581,
-0.0123219863,
-0.0110536721,
-0.0092080189,
0.0194517244,
0.0104812849,
0.0062217363,
-0.024968775,
0.0284119472,
-0.0326047987,
-0.0197786111,
0.0173710696,
0.0753288865,
-0.0041869101,
-0.0399618037,
-0.0288631991,
0.0407934524,
-0.052644413,
0.0716665089,
0.012645944,
0.0052607832,
-0.0766350627,
-0.0443268083,
-0.050389532,
-0.0190720893,
-0.0105250645,
0.045896288,
0.031072516,
-0.0269821417,
-0.0144119672,
-0.0318139084,
0.0191519596,
0.0434606858,
-0.0438045152,
0.0076903775,
0.0201273989,
0.0324896611,
-0.0072338576,
0.0169740189,
-0.0237928871,
0.0360642299,
-0.0278860573,
0.0407479741,
0.0086674448,
-0.0005025804,
-0.0490602404,
0.0534814447,
-0.0771080032,
-0.0435015522,
-0.0193661377,
0.0263984054,
0.0313145071,
0.0174590889,
-0.0343011916,
-0.0124495132,
-0.0195163954,
-0.0021994682,
0.0233304296,
0.0070631145,
0.0474735796,
0.0249565542,
0.0163630638,
0.0477447547,
-0.0031134493,
0.0235001314,
-0.0152002722,
0.0579611287,
-0.0180704966,
-0.0272880401,
0.0129709123,
0.0112831965,
0.0315612741,
0.0235425513,
-0.0067174062,
-0.0086232862,
0.0434580892,
-0.0531352572,
-0.0234163124,
-0.0296540372,
0.0275261011,
0.0186664555,
-0.0416826196,
-0.0201771706,
-0.0701490045,
-0.0020988504,
0.0001172546,
0.0067121023,
0.0009201191,
0.045599062,
0.0129766064,
0.0252301525,
-0.0686231554,
-0.0327244364,
-0.0272809733,
-0.0241365116,
0.0415014476,
-0.0244364385,
0.0788527951,
0.0439382307,
-0.0168371722,
-0.0183226503,
0.0063014058,
-0.075839445,
-0.0483280271,
0.0412813053,
-0.0034296585,
0.0691346526,
0.0291797202,
0.0355265923,
-0.0278783832,
-0.0117574809,
0.001624675,
0.024363542,
0.0279606525,
-0.0502576716,
0.0341540426,
0.0363087468,
-0.0205364153,
0.0033374967,
0.042157013,
0.0268386938,
0.0430407003,
0.0083120922,
-0.0038458074,
-0.0315244198,
-0.0458450094,
-0.0356825367,
0.030677963,
0.0005306813,
0.0230229851,
-0.0897709206,
-0.0976805612,
-0.0230122395,
0.0489471629,
0.0099530397,
0.0142837772,
0.0184229352,
0.0703773648,
0.0061554895,
-0.0678764582,
-0.0351915509,
-0.0248070527,
-0.0151525494,
-0.0054084118,
-0.0138632944,
-6.157725403e-33,
-0.0113523407,
-0.0128476154,
0.052715648,
-0.0227517039,
-0.0204269569,
-0.0134633156,
-0.0497898459,
-0.0082967235,
-0.0576237738,
0.0404185057,
-0.0106818583,
0.020330254,
0.0127199767,
0.0085960552,
0.0010325272,
-0.0285915285,
-0.0013271358,
0.0319290794,
-0.0069299433,
0.0074479184,
0.0432571433,
-0.0114079248,
0.0439643227,
-0.0246341471,
-0.00706203,
0.0369952023,
-0.0257965121,
0.0450413376,
-0.088748239,
0.0509829223,
-0.0001739995,
0.0016768427,
0.0321848467,
-0.0231743399,
0.0337896459,
-0.0157015715,
-0.0859427378,
-0.0197743513,
0.0315723456,
-0.0204145517,
-0.0639805868,
-0.0105636884,
0.0286704767,
0.0258632414,
0.0140271252,
-0.0562503785,
0.0068844799,
-0.0238097031,
0.004225323,
-0.0058199335,
-0.0416640043,
0.0504117347,
-0.010279499,
-0.0350844301,
-0.0291852914,
0.0616641343,
-0.0069192904,
-0.0022863082,
-0.0430576317,
0.00265188,
0.0086686211,
-0.0223290529,
0.0737113431,
-0.0096072201,
-0.003082175,
0.0691698119,
0.0229719933,
-0.0140926577,
-0.0538116619,
0.0035986584,
0.0080818525,
0.0700450018,
0.0431653224,
-0.0004349083,
0.0386690721,
0.0378174819,
-0.1144530624,
-0.0004091629,
0.0260573421,
0.0834477395,
0.0262211543,
-0.0018032282,
-0.0325346999,
0.0096857855,
-0.0507424176,
-0.0016156132,
-0.047862757,
-0.018606687,
0.0407238454,
-0.0242808145,
0.0042311954,
-0.0306050386,
0.0418946408,
-0.024160888,
-0.0158987269,
0.0498656891,
0.0001740907,
-0.0075351759,
-0.0019070603,
0.0765651837,
-0.0167719182,
0.0014820204,
0.0133600719,
0.0061854213,
0.0192101486,
-0.0145891001,
0.0261499304,
-0.0020022045,
-0.0359363146,
-0.017455779,
-0.0579750724,
0.0125792287,
-0.0388635099,
0.0428232588,
0.0539187938,
0.0201430582,
0.0081523219,
0.0415123701,
0.0042937621,
-0.0121971322,
-0.0447601862,
0.0235968493,
0.010305577,
0.014478446,
-0.0177310985,
-0.0062807314,
-0.0523064919,
-0.0323186181,
0.0147345942,
-0.0448874123,
-0.0003056009,
0.0540369004,
2.672e-7,
0.0265776534,
0.0452497937,
-0.0089617139,
0.0633399338,
0.0350516737,
0.0458789803,
-0.0313153341,
-0.0137101244,
0.0144361947,
-0.0382544436,
-0.0234955233,
0.0487906374,
0.0461836644,
0.0593178011,
-0.0490844734,
-0.0033627092,
-0.0437752567,
-0.0689138919,
-0.0453964658,
0.012512695,
0.1016422659,
0.096787475,
0.0209534839,
-0.0241125226,
0.0307076965,
-0.0371795483,
0.0289478395,
0.0188536961,
-0.0019659493,
-0.0163218696,
0.0446992666,
0.016522646,
0.0429287963,
0.0400999486,
0.0241586361,
-0.0046524447,
-0.0229783971,
0.0777599514,
-0.0209934954,
-0.0110543864,
-0.0309777427,
-0.0592024773,
0.0039392272,
-0.0749770254,
0.1093933731,
-0.0574855097,
-0.0572401583,
-0.0036756743,
0.0009241849,
-0.0329802744,
0.0211069193,
0.0112799732,
-0.0335316472,
0.0110716373,
0.011813879,
-0.0428752638,
-0.0132667683,
-0.0789530948,
-0.0258361213,
0.0112535395,
-0.0414085202,
-0.0147061199,
-0.0198941622,
0.0067252782,
0.0595880076,
-0.0557419658,
-0.0153313847,
2.505183255e-34,
0.0481738858,
-0.0431403667,
0.0177420788,
-0.000856808,
0.0748464912,
0.0095079597,
-0.0140585387,
-0.0027562436,
-0.0114440024,
-0.0952380002,
0.0010916351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17163v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17163v1 | Paraphrase and Aggregate with Large Language Models for Minimizing Intent Classification Errors | 2024-06-24T22:30:26 | 2024-06-24T22:30:26 | Vikas Yadav, Zheng Tang, Vijay Srinivasan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLM) have achieved remarkable success in natural
language generation but lesser focus has been given to their applicability in
decision making tasks such as classification. We show that LLMs like LLaMa can
achieve high performance on large multi-class classification tasks but still
make classification errors and worse, generate out-of-vocabulary class labels.
To address these critical issues, we introduce Paraphrase and AGgregate
(PAG)-LLM approach wherein an LLM generates multiple paraphrases of the input
query (parallel queries), performs multi-class classification for the original
query and each paraphrase, and at the end aggregate all the classification
labels based on their confidence scores. We evaluate PAG-LLM on two large
multi-class classication datasets: CLINC, and Banking and show 22.7% and 15.1%
error reduction. We show that PAG-LLM is especially effective for hard examples
where LLM is uncertain, and reduces the critical misclassification and
hallucinated label generation errors | [
0.0412707962,
0.0692061484,
0.001669302,
0.0254935939,
-0.0328252465,
0.021335952,
0.0182002783,
0.0082510514,
0.0085261008,
-0.1061692089,
-0.0216864459,
-0.0590206981,
-0.0055498378,
-0.0262268409,
0.0246133953,
-0.0101340665,
0.0509760566,
-0.0250255801,
0.0055108173,
-0.0019812321,
-0.0162965544,
0.0521466322,
0.0277754422,
0.0324021354,
0.0107543208,
-0.0062604309,
0.0089230184,
-0.0041111917,
-0.0233191047,
-0.0119329505,
0.0120448126,
0.0056922161,
0.0295277797,
0.0580164157,
0.0000015988,
-0.0817338228,
-0.0471119098,
0.0014951419,
-0.0206438601,
0.0468781926,
0.0777407736,
0.0069701099,
0.0617656969,
0.0584419742,
-0.0101403892,
-0.0083122002,
0.0051839245,
0.0370380022,
0.0538671091,
0.0264950953,
-0.0040616323,
-0.0942136496,
0.0023961456,
-0.0240581557,
0.0109134596,
-0.065110445,
0.0606326871,
0.0168192219,
-0.016323043,
0.0121520152,
-0.0015248734,
0.0342507437,
-0.0290196836,
0.0008205889,
0.0071338024,
0.0070699556,
-0.005179924,
0.0133535499,
0.0053904294,
0.0446188189,
-0.0351034962,
-0.0185648594,
0.0081990995,
-0.0092770532,
0.0079079242,
0.0099904528,
-0.0262875985,
0.0451285504,
-0.0062085958,
0.0296695847,
0.0220432691,
-0.0012515936,
0.0283920448,
0.0495214425,
-0.0611305609,
-0.0096924771,
0.0292796604,
-0.0145458402,
0.0081741828,
0.0126122963,
-0.0467535704,
-0.0135632651,
0.006430184,
0.0302412994,
-0.0615680069,
0.0369272269,
-0.0474766716,
-0.0263648201,
0.0716236532,
-0.0694447383,
-0.0029099185,
0.0034226589,
0.037613783,
0.0592484623,
-0.0247962363,
0.0397941098,
-0.004785582,
0.0321594886,
-0.0882750377,
-0.0349366181,
-0.0882174373,
-0.0081618512,
-0.0427794978,
0.0785567015,
-0.0298184529,
-0.0117813796,
-0.0893613175,
0.0191781893,
0.0223866738,
0.0087573864,
0.0010959054,
0.0182300955,
-0.0210930128,
-0.0041051637,
-0.029575618,
0.0079139881,
0.0301958807,
0.0546911992,
-0.0160757136,
-0.0545693785,
0.0124700433,
0.0286937319,
0.006281442,
-0.0025335765,
0.0173466876,
0.0362965353,
-0.033505924,
-0.0649829358,
-0.0620980188,
-0.0710992068,
-0.0325510092,
-0.0342145115,
-0.0351760834,
-0.037507575,
0.0679633021,
-0.0101343058,
0.0020908709,
-0.0235957354,
0.0187660754,
0.0251775123,
-0.0327979513,
0.06471131,
0.0061715818,
0.0094260676,
0.0527806841,
-0.0092669791,
0.0216371622,
0.049589891,
0.0250612181,
0.0237843934,
0.0341359116,
0.0196042564,
-0.0059815496,
0.0249033384,
0.0209578015,
0.0099857338,
-0.0233530961,
0.0115114423,
0.0176825244,
0.0334310532,
0.0102728093,
0.0908773541,
-0.0167238992,
0.0058701811,
0.0522349328,
0.0052865893,
0.0242565945,
-0.014626205,
0.0365663581,
0.0141845634,
-0.0101222107,
-0.0189832281,
0.0021498126,
-0.0403414965,
-0.0305755753,
0.0448426083,
0.0448330231,
0.0274760574,
-0.0440725423,
-0.0426527895,
-0.0092106601,
-0.0226925313,
-0.0409943461,
0.0289729293,
0.0350628681,
0.0145603744,
-0.0470440425,
0.0705482364,
0.0050958898,
-0.0115559176,
0.0145925069,
-0.0657164678,
0.035894867,
0.0597541183,
0.0506013632,
-0.0287050046,
0.0126725677,
-0.0204932075,
-0.0444494337,
0.0145380832,
0.052847404,
-0.028022822,
-0.0147403637,
-0.0626339167,
-0.0167240258,
0.0384701416,
0.0286773778,
-0.0239486415,
0.0077435956,
-0.0074775149,
0.043669492,
-0.0339307375,
-0.0603370965,
0.0368377417,
0.0208301693,
-0.0519181006,
0.0442547239,
-0.0121830376,
0.0424330905,
0.0223205537,
-0.0104790851,
0.0342133604,
0.0229807515,
-0.0325253606,
-0.0631887168,
-0.0149515094,
-0.0032866597,
-0.031522993,
0.0444169901,
0.006864043,
-0.0116300303,
-0.0218278188,
-0.049941849,
-0.0560846329,
-0.055551298,
-0.0558356643,
0.0566105209,
-0.0881690457,
0.0604828373,
-0.0142230177,
0.0111560542,
-0.0518360622,
0.069568865,
0.0086181546,
0.0127124861,
0.0311195143,
-0.0253969114,
0.0223483723,
-0.0065203723,
-0.012014756,
-0.0005188209,
0.0197775532,
0.0428513139,
-0.0186350346,
0.0089115612,
-0.0465478189,
-0.0194347966,
-0.0760201588,
0.0002593308,
0.0009701288,
0.0024226664,
0.0104776016,
0.0258193891,
0.0193038136,
-0.0009110723,
-0.0191208124,
0.0173370317,
0.0218003411,
0.0370238498,
0.0471898243,
0.0390195101,
-0.0534156039,
-0.015700547,
0.0054963836,
-0.0154410442,
0.0651620701,
0.03257218,
-0.0183041841,
-0.0536120199,
0.0343202762,
-0.0224471372,
-0.0048188651,
0.0202556625,
-0.0042306562,
-0.0573896579,
-0.0411807001,
-0.0231735669,
0.0009965965,
0.0296389908,
-0.0514006317,
0.049712874,
0.0244472995,
-0.049284026,
-0.0176448785,
-0.0290505998,
-0.0553086549,
-0.0093118036,
-0.0440097377,
0.0208929107,
0.0222321637,
0.0224476717,
-0.0120721357,
-0.025469128,
-0.0424797982,
-0.0076108356,
-0.0010369847,
-0.0753466114,
-0.0091237705,
0.0000853788,
0.0173795465,
0.0143981306,
-0.0471644886,
0.0634804219,
-0.0234526768,
0.0083507327,
-0.0737383887,
-0.0153739974,
-0.0504647121,
0.0450962856,
-0.0163006857,
0.0502714626,
-0.0042784037,
-0.050048463,
-0.0276018977,
-0.0652026832,
0.0070849075,
-0.0328377783,
0.1015115455,
-0.0567826405,
0.0292242691,
0.0092323003,
-0.0244076606,
-0.0486280136,
-0.1077041402,
-0.0393951535,
0.0242237262,
0.0204339381,
0.010657344,
-0.0568285137,
0.0061803441,
-0.0109907901,
-0.0045624059,
-0.0188737102,
-0.035859257,
-0.0085096648,
0.0385241397,
0.0591084994,
0.0078735836,
-0.0041795182,
-0.0287332162,
0.0172128547,
0.019615477,
0.0194601212,
0.0223831013,
-0.010090109,
-0.0332150459,
0.0183623638,
-0.0486497506,
-0.0196208972,
0.0178564303,
-0.031476818,
-0.0006501504,
-0.0135162883,
0.1153290719,
0.0303476043,
-0.02976292,
-0.0100166881,
0.011460552,
0.0300872196,
0.0044503068,
0.0329615772,
-0.0346954837,
-0.0399791896,
-0.0151189277,
0.0313113146,
0.0002798633,
0.0010829231,
-0.0212904401,
-0.1314488351,
0.0455145501,
0.0120414151,
-0.0441045873,
-0.0282883327,
-0.0331704132,
-0.0199388471,
-0.0129394634,
0.0195745379,
0.0254335962,
-0.0286951587,
-0.0020846403,
0.0143363504,
-0.0226577204,
-0.0399907827,
-0.0099498117,
-0.0238752533,
0.0018592807,
0.019039711,
0.0189882554,
0.0040205005,
-0.0392951667,
0.041745767,
-0.0867094025,
-0.010117162,
-0.0045474945,
0.0578099824,
-0.0021971604,
-0.001892739,
0.0225260872,
0.003552964,
-0.0499051735,
0.0171302669,
0.0043004914,
0.0391847678,
-0.0223839264,
0.0236827545,
0.0033932498,
0.0018456483,
0.0074519902,
0.0824859366,
-0.0048009083,
-0.0123152072,
-0.013332339,
-0.0013025434,
-0.029809555,
-0.0242852699,
0.0219123755,
0.0428248979,
-0.0480122454,
-0.0295222551,
-0.0436798334,
-0.0263095535,
0.022677213,
0.0237546023,
0.0126927327,
0.0787772685,
0.0319805443,
0.0020925675,
-0.0101085473,
-0.0444674604,
-0.0731665939,
0.0430920906,
-0.0120678348,
0.0243536904,
0.0802455992,
-0.0376011059,
-0.0244355202,
0.0081275553,
-0.0708098263,
-0.0515842848,
-0.017534079,
-0.0017939531,
0.0199863464,
-0.0043731476,
0.0005490263,
-0.0283753593,
0.0553906821,
0.0708526596,
-0.0249613915,
0.0114633217,
-0.0045030401,
0.0300342198,
-0.0215253867,
0.0347235911,
-0.0806563944,
-0.0131515367,
-0.0223439392,
0.0049289493,
-0.0583538748,
-0.0511173941,
0.0501776449,
0.054967422,
-0.0176964067,
-0.0511778072,
0.0057504424,
-0.0134688588,
0.0427090377,
0.0167468488,
-0.0404417515,
-0.0146230469,
-0.0051411833,
0.0566435829,
-0.0305527393,
0.0053071268,
-0.0026831166,
-0.0181866642,
0.0125185372,
-0.0003121184,
-0.0200913195,
-0.0172452591,
0.0089147072,
0.0063066566,
-0.0329302661,
-0.0273700599,
-0.0118944943,
-0.0055301357,
0.0116324257,
-0.0073846201,
0.0194693655,
0.0095820185,
0.0071707894,
-0.085965082,
-0.0021100671,
-0.0609395579,
-0.0403142497,
-0.0182693545,
0.0427582003,
0.0724042207,
-0.000262786,
0.0377330445,
-0.0223668665,
-0.020076016,
-0.0283227749,
0.040372435,
0.0090980902,
-0.0142488843,
0.0521610752,
0.0040265713,
-0.0223475117,
0.0073646675,
0.0971393809,
0.000120013,
0.0455130301,
-0.0118256547,
-0.0521839894,
-0.0498388559,
-0.0264405254,
0.0569513887,
0.0300601851,
-0.0276209395,
-0.0444719642,
-0.0429784618,
-0.0359533317,
0.0632395372,
-0.0071852831,
0.0088407416,
-0.0128000854,
0.0591803715,
0.0659624487,
0.0137557043,
-0.0235075504,
-0.0748441368,
0.0220696311,
-0.0081536481,
0.0099713737,
-0.0444626771,
-5.505349916e-33,
-0.0142273223,
-0.026587991,
0.0163016599,
-0.0337925591,
-0.0037281977,
0.0163967591,
0.0211976543,
-0.0293699168,
0.0191105176,
-0.0019455384,
0.0040705441,
0.0254403483,
0.0256964006,
0.0462212972,
0.0437269844,
-0.0334767327,
0.0582049452,
-0.0149918841,
0.0180748627,
0.0166818667,
0.0254014265,
0.0334147662,
-0.00946349,
-0.0930022448,
-0.0032780748,
-0.0195728038,
-0.043505948,
0.0052128294,
-0.0137798507,
0.0559674688,
-0.0172297042,
0.0673529357,
0.0174248703,
-0.0401939228,
-0.0184123572,
-0.0087308222,
-0.0338772759,
0.005729387,
0.0277164411,
0.0085613774,
0.0089143347,
-0.0281705055,
0.0415082388,
-0.0119705629,
-0.0043883515,
0.0150113618,
0.0175596271,
-0.0350823551,
-0.0175408144,
-0.0319591537,
-0.0171712879,
0.0158521291,
0.0187236425,
0.0154923238,
0.0079816598,
0.0320960954,
-0.007258716,
0.077949062,
-0.0511860251,
0.0452606343,
-0.0036351359,
-0.0030857564,
0.0291250739,
0.0513712801,
-0.0153959151,
0.0192435924,
-0.008128712,
-0.0288368315,
0.0191967953,
0.0103431009,
-0.0442281999,
0.0263415966,
0.0037096101,
0.0780729428,
0.003729434,
0.0036085469,
-0.0596690476,
0.04664471,
0.0087110065,
-0.0169405546,
0.0492422618,
0.0130102271,
-0.0470828377,
-0.0395237543,
-0.0388349704,
0.0242888089,
-0.0289596431,
0.036565505,
0.0266131032,
0.044339139,
-0.0031261903,
0.0128562469,
0.009723424,
-0.0485467017,
-0.0621767193,
-0.0124431988,
-0.0195513368,
0.0042361338,
-0.0154326316,
0.006995548,
-0.0223928262,
-0.0514894724,
0.0175070539,
-0.0008756276,
-0.0194919668,
0.0164826103,
0.0324139781,
-0.0039320439,
-0.0653241351,
0.0289955921,
0.006835598,
-0.0461403579,
-0.0253248382,
-0.0173463002,
0.0111259585,
0.0224332791,
0.019892931,
0.008162518,
0.0293437969,
0.0013938406,
0.0197367668,
-0.0387999639,
0.0171801448,
0.0458773896,
-0.0036710699,
0.0238005705,
0.0232251957,
-0.0075022248,
0.030554032,
-0.0380639918,
-0.0170787442,
0.0050855135,
2.42e-7,
0.0769094229,
0.0292623881,
-0.0321057737,
0.0550467521,
-0.0076662865,
0.0580468066,
0.0282190368,
0.0090259137,
0.010308994,
-0.0055910167,
0.0458127446,
0.0033108036,
0.0088509433,
0.0087322202,
-0.0895053521,
-0.000485336,
-0.0242177323,
0.0057062455,
-0.0653297901,
0.004984403,
0.1172658429,
0.1277490109,
-0.0007453215,
-0.0578677095,
-0.0166087113,
-0.0878115296,
0.0505641736,
0.0094793262,
-0.053764049,
0.0388779528,
0.0396397635,
0.030992398,
0.0088200578,
0.0686848313,
-0.0079071559,
-0.0072472198,
0.0223350972,
0.0399251096,
-0.0027182759,
0.0010904417,
-0.0265455972,
-0.0097169317,
0.0051071765,
-0.0490812249,
0.0677654296,
-0.0184973534,
0.0068444605,
0.0095417807,
-0.0021998149,
0.0157730114,
0.0319290981,
0.0084363138,
0.0028250956,
0.0019791424,
0.0214495026,
0.0196779985,
-0.0440943092,
-0.0622322485,
0.0239689201,
-0.0108266566,
-0.0466152951,
-0.0205346383,
0.0037059202,
0.0313659534,
0.03136608,
-0.0952280313,
0.0160824638,
2.3142281e-34,
0.0559231713,
-0.0052644857,
0.0138816815,
0.0309535265,
0.0300773643,
-0.0119885616,
0.0008863059,
0.0412703082,
0.0039549945,
-0.0920558795,
0.0123658562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17158v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17158v1 | DEXTER: A Benchmark for open-domain Complex Question Answering using LLMs | 2024-06-24T22:09:50 | 2024-06-24T22:09:50 | Venktesh V. Deepali Prabhu, Avishek Anand | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Open-domain complex Question Answering (QA) is a difficult task with
challenges in evidence retrieval and reasoning. The complexity of such
questions could stem from questions being compositional, hybrid evidence, or
ambiguity in questions. While retrieval performance for classical QA tasks is
well explored, their capabilities for heterogeneous complex retrieval tasks,
especially in an open-domain setting, and the impact on downstream QA
performance, are relatively unexplored. To address this, in this work, we
propose a benchmark composing diverse complex QA tasks and provide a toolkit to
evaluate state-of-the-art pre-trained dense and sparse retrieval models in an
open-domain setting. We observe that late interaction models and surprisingly
lexical models like BM25 perform well compared to other pre-trained dense
retrieval models. In addition, since context-based reasoning is critical for
solving complex QA tasks, we also evaluate the reasoning capabilities of LLMs
and the impact of retrieval performance on their reasoning capabilities.
Through experiments, we observe that much progress is to be made in retrieval
for complex QA to improve downstream QA performance. Our software and related
data can be accessed at https://github.com/VenkteshV/DEXTER | [
0.0130938441,
0.0038322166,
0.0124393376,
0.0543343276,
-0.0142599605,
0.0024534361,
-0.0124494629,
0.0260863509,
-0.0031449848,
-0.036123544,
-0.0321289934,
-0.0498188548,
-0.0427262485,
0.0311774239,
-0.0204667281,
-0.013750664,
0.0516529717,
-0.0149210086,
0.0031404856,
0.0086186118,
-0.0139430407,
0.0178622231,
-0.005871302,
0.0078849709,
0.0168379936,
-0.0151822455,
-0.0196741894,
0.0163246561,
0.0247527324,
-0.0254493989,
0.0316877998,
0.045951996,
0.0558792278,
0.0249819588,
0.0000016959,
-0.0480752215,
-0.0300081205,
-0.0019939835,
-0.0542411841,
-0.0189357046,
-0.0105670532,
0.0460125655,
0.049993556,
0.0109099485,
-0.0620137043,
-0.0053741029,
0.0027158407,
0.0518501252,
0.0175661352,
0.0703030825,
0.0184221752,
-0.0340914242,
0.0263584778,
-0.0023391061,
0.0101249451,
-0.0462285317,
0.0284935832,
0.00736921,
0.0295132976,
0.0541200675,
0.0051711099,
0.0130044436,
0.0349776447,
0.0384630412,
-0.0114817899,
0.0314016342,
0.0011924696,
0.0163676701,
0.0212003887,
0.1067032218,
0.0409889258,
-0.0016173298,
-0.020719165,
0.0100086629,
0.0050518615,
0.007834956,
-0.0645864978,
0.0466647781,
-0.0245113987,
-0.0032690531,
-0.0310984757,
0.0163504835,
0.0260772258,
0.0320105702,
-0.0214253552,
0.0675454214,
-0.0041144378,
-0.0336793326,
0.0270809978,
-0.0113029554,
-0.0482657664,
-0.0460660867,
-0.0132462373,
0.0857801959,
-0.036387369,
-0.000391101,
0.0236513074,
-0.0208519585,
0.0312400702,
-0.0221555289,
0.023731323,
0.0461823829,
-0.0327953026,
0.057316307,
-0.0248030983,
0.0194056779,
-0.0400115438,
0.0173803065,
-0.038837038,
-0.0378945917,
-0.0242524873,
-0.0312617831,
-0.0091713946,
0.070945099,
-0.055551488,
-0.0140560288,
-0.0085926503,
0.0173990037,
0.0077211661,
-0.0331421793,
-0.0051202429,
0.0539700203,
-0.0094016232,
-0.0118601779,
-0.0780081451,
0.0138020068,
-0.0676275715,
0.0552240349,
0.0393667482,
-0.0428875796,
-0.0436646268,
0.0161431581,
-0.0060807499,
-0.0379901156,
0.0112410514,
0.0247515459,
-0.0228758957,
-0.0335642174,
-0.0252440721,
-0.0510491729,
0.0070547969,
-0.0597578548,
-0.0025068966,
-0.0794344023,
0.0049317013,
0.0173805729,
-0.0278092157,
-0.0444541387,
0.0079023382,
0.0512903221,
-0.0228075124,
0.0358762033,
0.0006765974,
-0.0357194878,
0.0148332007,
0.0549989082,
-0.0070758113,
0.0505633727,
-0.0310751181,
0.0256599821,
0.0474088937,
0.0462687053,
0.0023029605,
-0.0148422755,
0.0265778117,
0.0103953462,
0.0259502009,
0.086742878,
0.0019064618,
0.0249021184,
0.0075868629,
0.0322227105,
-0.0333380178,
-0.0636696219,
0.0074019483,
0.0620381832,
0.0211062245,
-0.0404879786,
0.0271816757,
-0.0011306036,
0.0209209621,
-0.0020291917,
-0.0323057994,
0.0287685841,
-0.0734819025,
0.0019525015,
0.0219812412,
0.0271253064,
-0.0430950448,
-0.0315640382,
-0.0150835626,
0.0025059145,
-0.0068362891,
0.0388480574,
0.0468649901,
0.0036821319,
-0.0312814303,
0.0510617942,
0.0230002142,
-0.0389657393,
-0.0261716023,
-0.0483303852,
0.0746703744,
-0.0005309185,
0.0409725197,
-0.0575750917,
-0.0335587822,
0.0031788317,
0.0261212438,
0.0031300643,
0.0104279844,
-0.0013116488,
0.0418816395,
-0.0291421637,
-0.0200370438,
-0.0711568296,
0.0050727646,
0.0036628949,
0.0602070764,
0.0058435942,
0.0227433573,
-0.0521275736,
0.0332761817,
0.023828961,
-0.0244219434,
-0.0288680624,
-0.0203666929,
-0.012872682,
0.0151486574,
0.0149986586,
0.0045983559,
0.0171964727,
0.06968759,
0.0021732491,
-0.0496596321,
-0.0299007967,
-0.0502639785,
-0.0431734622,
0.0303681307,
0.0075397636,
-0.0373105332,
0.0121561941,
-0.0426739007,
-0.0292093214,
0.011527813,
0.0124089327,
0.0181239471,
-0.050021708,
-0.0350267366,
0.0333557166,
0.0125084408,
-0.0570917428,
0.0878081843,
-0.0288410969,
0.0202293377,
0.0244538076,
0.0112277213,
0.0157254357,
-0.0354828127,
0.0097465981,
-0.0303891487,
-0.0161073003,
-0.0045434115,
-0.0045506638,
-0.00911899,
-0.0699018463,
0.0119788432,
-0.0673251972,
0.0563725419,
-0.0411822088,
0.0009515207,
0.0024693299,
0.0163574163,
0.002201943,
-0.0140938619,
-0.0411610678,
0.0380554125,
0.0256305095,
0.0191839337,
0.02484685,
0.0432014614,
0.0132688861,
-0.0293887835,
-0.00270231,
0.0059983605,
0.0446465462,
-0.041215539,
0.0331842154,
-0.0019188458,
0.0223373994,
-0.0443611667,
0.0190015323,
-0.0384624638,
0.0172538664,
0.0266854204,
-0.0448524095,
0.0329798199,
0.06566751,
-0.0155223003,
0.0217646491,
0.0161547344,
-0.0171364471,
-0.0728033781,
0.024348719,
-0.0274784695,
-0.0080815274,
-0.0284207221,
-0.0137213673,
0.0080858981,
0.0293283947,
-0.0132926451,
-0.0038571726,
0.007384703,
-0.0004662638,
0.0442024507,
-0.0027583078,
-0.0513702333,
0.010282686,
0.0020564296,
0.0698372424,
-0.0298477318,
-0.0327424929,
0.067293264,
-0.0079549924,
0.0017055802,
-0.0052520186,
-0.0227421653,
-0.083916761,
0.0650578737,
-0.0326574296,
-0.0119970692,
-0.0007306819,
0.0018078336,
-0.0530029163,
-0.027360389,
0.0062537831,
-0.0388450772,
0.0395791791,
-0.0287441202,
0.018213382,
-0.026117241,
-0.0359205268,
-0.0391196273,
-0.0315510668,
-0.0179589354,
0.0419354215,
-0.0055626929,
-0.0142285712,
-0.0254348591,
0.002761475,
0.0061739869,
-0.0119123459,
-0.0090359133,
-0.0108970953,
-0.005856385,
0.0586519875,
0.0372827761,
0.0686471537,
0.0306493305,
-0.0232860483,
0.0202956591,
0.0845035613,
-0.0087831318,
-0.0571067035,
-0.0272147339,
-0.005995905,
0.0249961782,
-0.0201358087,
0.0027256692,
0.0237768833,
0.0556920543,
-0.0442289375,
-0.0026963765,
0.0862880126,
0.0196673088,
-0.0168717708,
-0.035898231,
-0.0509876087,
0.0179762971,
0.0295208916,
0.0188030787,
-0.1034296378,
-0.0476717167,
-0.0087844599,
0.0192816351,
0.00416857,
-0.0275445152,
0.0075584138,
-0.1196984127,
0.0219879597,
-0.035108123,
-0.0103608286,
-0.0168807954,
-0.0543591306,
0.0281786676,
-0.001350062,
-0.005013248,
0.0207550656,
-0.0127242561,
-0.0106719611,
-0.0042949817,
0.0299420878,
-0.019055089,
0.0493946411,
-0.0453802906,
0.0164386258,
0.0281408522,
-0.0058942335,
0.0039167483,
-0.0384293161,
0.0299206693,
-0.016200887,
0.0158674829,
-0.0359998271,
0.0322118476,
0.0048839995,
0.0197087787,
-0.0462869294,
0.0171922743,
-0.0397899263,
-0.0420228206,
0.0042774579,
0.0679704994,
-0.0269371495,
0.0078045535,
-0.0503978059,
0.0093566552,
-0.0198083483,
0.0882196203,
0.0137360571,
0.0319543332,
-0.0547962524,
-0.0097204698,
-0.0464560129,
-0.0309033878,
-0.0245840643,
-0.0066430033,
0.0198777728,
0.0497645624,
-0.0400321223,
-0.0202148836,
0.0277862363,
0.041941423,
-0.0479634628,
0.0184139833,
-0.0365467742,
0.0097768698,
-0.0642857924,
0.079990536,
-0.0477146097,
0.0287052765,
-0.0590984896,
0.0202837791,
0.0188586731,
-0.0580387227,
-0.0174307618,
-0.0192917697,
-0.0622817315,
-0.027203314,
-0.0310156327,
0.0482655801,
0.0199740063,
0.0263873674,
-0.002849974,
-0.0281674564,
0.02409265,
0.0233221427,
-0.0391448401,
0.020219041,
0.0326403379,
0.0012298797,
-0.0062436108,
0.0258060358,
-0.0613974668,
0.0103110587,
0.0235062316,
0.0538599566,
-0.0335051827,
-0.0506918058,
0.0283639356,
-0.0241947584,
0.0379647762,
0.0450114943,
-0.0396080762,
-0.014298181,
0.0166225787,
-0.0229774863,
-0.0196482837,
-0.0104660997,
0.0180999413,
0.018191237,
-0.0288014933,
-0.0117193591,
0.0417014137,
-0.0184381567,
0.0687862784,
-0.0346916132,
0.0001560285,
0.0640288368,
-0.0224838145,
0.0105200494,
-0.0000776384,
-0.0435802862,
0.0162474979,
-0.0297061205,
0.078040719,
0.0012941505,
0.0675132796,
0.002941442,
-0.0133695276,
-0.0467870049,
0.0050217109,
-0.1103898808,
-0.0266606119,
-0.0022835508,
0.0099009471,
0.01548672,
0.0031208957,
-0.0193613153,
0.0129850861,
-0.0240805633,
-0.0122845694,
-0.0267127603,
-0.0073446697,
0.0015001689,
0.083500132,
0.0442746729,
-0.0090808282,
0.0493400358,
0.0689140409,
-0.0188455638,
0.0224284176,
-0.0077094212,
0.0020985664,
0.0003825008,
-0.029035395,
0.0319942273,
0.0720910653,
-0.0012476372,
0.0101353452,
-0.0377409309,
-0.0475862436,
0.0305908658,
-0.0105644856,
-0.0386720635,
-0.0018652586,
0.0356483757,
0.0747781917,
0.0503874607,
-0.0330602713,
-0.0043958053,
0.0204249751,
-0.0347516462,
-0.014417694,
-0.0030281534,
-6.37060192e-33,
-0.0253257789,
-0.0473608151,
0.0341887623,
-0.0283928476,
-0.013847624,
0.023837585,
-0.0264547598,
0.0077106007,
-0.0583996736,
0.0002918236,
-0.0055258228,
0.0267762858,
-0.0040310281,
0.0205215774,
-0.0296410155,
-0.0299137477,
-0.0096376631,
-0.00906388,
-0.0112678949,
0.000800807,
0.052321624,
0.0302285962,
0.009413464,
-0.0265841931,
0.0298906378,
-0.034639962,
0.0311208162,
0.0629840046,
-0.0515366197,
0.0748812407,
-0.0209872611,
0.0427532569,
0.0384445526,
-0.0232942924,
0.0117672607,
0.0251675807,
-0.1084486097,
-0.0310067497,
0.038490314,
-0.0429422706,
-0.0703924969,
-0.017794691,
0.0008065899,
0.0136238234,
0.0237084068,
-0.0284723435,
0.0162395276,
-0.0215468295,
-0.0144339772,
-0.0334511884,
-0.0353631638,
0.0241127405,
-0.0185983106,
-0.0242521279,
-0.0304009113,
0.0287789106,
0.0059984624,
0.0689983368,
-0.0399283394,
-0.0256763343,
-0.02637982,
0.000212177,
0.0263540968,
0.0217698794,
-0.0288263857,
0.0427050665,
-0.0071687941,
-0.0216993634,
-0.085672915,
-0.0389371663,
-0.02241119,
0.0781177953,
0.0501818322,
0.0785968974,
0.0356434509,
0.0362200998,
-0.075678803,
0.0413879007,
0.0116137452,
0.044998724,
-0.0000435076,
0.0207438581,
-0.0011845082,
-0.0102479495,
-0.0516750179,
0.0525575653,
-0.0525992103,
0.0005135881,
0.042805139,
0.0156122455,
0.0121147735,
-0.028928034,
0.047352951,
-0.0432643518,
0.049040392,
0.0157441348,
0.0044240332,
0.0059730513,
0.0132711818,
0.0541459173,
-0.0367369018,
0.006326023,
0.0584367774,
-0.0388278924,
-0.0371703357,
0.0151433535,
0.0223103184,
-0.0284877252,
-0.0273913592,
-0.0258562397,
-0.0244413838,
0.0043382659,
-0.0150572443,
0.0242280681,
0.014484304,
0.0648323745,
-0.0014854425,
0.072629109,
0.0068836901,
0.0242231525,
-0.0454276949,
-0.0547799058,
-0.0006034392,
-0.0157505237,
-0.0077158762,
0.0408252366,
-0.0093828384,
0.0044484418,
-0.0427489989,
-0.0429400094,
-0.0061916672,
0.0682686865,
2.403e-7,
0.0764027461,
-0.0192213878,
0.0120839616,
0.0470948517,
-0.013600884,
0.00928804,
0.0011218986,
-0.011655814,
0.0250567961,
-0.0407490842,
-0.0157586578,
0.0858110934,
0.0519855395,
0.0482598506,
-0.0267831236,
-0.0117386747,
-0.03504939,
-0.0812267736,
-0.0563150458,
-0.0232965928,
0.0736112297,
0.0784804076,
-0.0118132168,
-0.0014361423,
-0.0125507675,
-0.0454223603,
0.0775548592,
-0.0249838717,
0.0217332412,
-0.0160485916,
0.0312349144,
0.0153376749,
0.0293429624,
0.016856702,
0.0236241668,
0.0327886119,
0.0162539054,
0.0544043221,
0.0271292292,
-0.081507355,
0.0040310416,
-0.0575000346,
0.038487725,
-0.0300436374,
0.1016483828,
-0.0570752732,
-0.0310173351,
-0.00530391,
-0.0305169597,
-0.0122903707,
0.0280322358,
-0.0060043726,
0.0255311988,
0.0029750757,
0.0049146209,
-0.0174374115,
-0.0061331494,
-0.1089790687,
0.0146041363,
0.0001576577,
-0.0433905423,
-0.0258055609,
-0.0094164666,
-0.007506303,
0.0285032,
-0.0115863159,
-0.0253967829,
2.164512365e-34,
0.052899614,
-0.0066096648,
0.0085062915,
0.0497096106,
0.0459578931,
-0.0058813458,
-0.0306721386,
-0.0232225358,
0.0236582216,
-0.1393121183,
0.010838029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17135v1 | Testing network clustering algorithms with Natural Language Processing | 2024-06-24T20:54:32 | 2024-06-24T20:54:32 | Ixandra Achitouv, David Chavalarias, Bruno Gaume | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.CY, physics.soc-ph | The advent of online social networks has led to the development of an
abundant literature on the study of online social groups and their relationship
to individuals' personalities as revealed by their textual productions. Social
structures are inferred from a wide range of social interactions. Those
interactions form complex -- sometimes multi-layered -- networks, on which
community detection algorithms are applied to extract higher order structures.
The choice of the community detection algorithm is however hardily questioned
in relation with the cultural production of the individual they classify. In
this work, we assume the entangled nature of social networks and their cultural
production to propose a definition of cultural based online social groups as
sets of individuals whose online production can be categorized as social
group-related. We take advantage of this apparently self-referential
description of online social groups with a hybrid methodology that combines a
community detection algorithm and a natural language processing classification
algorithm. A key result of this analysis is the possibility to score community
detection algorithms using their agreement with the natural language processing
classification. A second result is that we can assign the opinion of a random
user at >85% accuracy. | [
0.0297250133,
0.0376635566,
-0.0400357172,
0.060860958,
-0.0316200443,
0.0038336816,
0.0056063188,
0.0013760646,
0.0795025676,
-0.0202376731,
-0.0104311705,
-0.0460257158,
0.036783386,
0.0112568839,
0.0245806314,
0.0010098519,
0.0274150781,
0.0470677167,
0.0060641174,
0.0015663146,
0.0159333535,
0.0298843477,
0.0249492936,
0.0134669067,
0.0381961018,
0.0048545697,
0.0375931114,
-0.0541611984,
0.0536153987,
0.0035542981,
0.0091741793,
0.0553994402,
-0.0679791942,
0.0575972013,
0.0000020169,
-0.0448029973,
-0.0139421877,
-0.0438937694,
0.0559517592,
-0.0292348173,
0.0448940881,
0.0377466008,
0.0227830485,
0.0544142313,
-0.0886003077,
0.0056832181,
0.0279603582,
0.0108602569,
0.0479968488,
0.0548427477,
-0.013673123,
-0.0823260695,
-0.0348320231,
0.0089838458,
-0.0338040479,
0.0477457605,
0.0476146489,
0.0058475318,
0.0051640738,
-0.0066069718,
0.0134782717,
-0.0059397654,
-0.01681244,
-0.0009599088,
0.0192905925,
0.0042422256,
-0.0556251667,
-0.0350896977,
0.0259234477,
0.0258990042,
0.044793129,
-0.001720243,
0.0452358201,
0.0393984504,
-0.0223599728,
0.0706951395,
0.0177839324,
0.0258995388,
-0.0396282673,
0.0036187973,
0.0125130853,
0.0707019269,
0.0249783918,
0.0030680739,
-0.0044454336,
0.1173132136,
-0.0086041717,
0.0257176291,
-0.040676564,
0.0057447944,
-0.0219230093,
-0.0119753415,
0.072203733,
-0.0038109194,
0.0164088998,
0.0049108677,
0.0034206461,
0.0365884677,
0.017287828,
-0.0488245152,
-0.0210656729,
-0.0298502594,
0.0360583663,
0.0207670238,
0.0241758749,
-0.0353038609,
-0.0130893448,
-0.0252720714,
0.0099840034,
0.000309045,
-0.0795475319,
0.0150078582,
0.014105103,
0.0119612357,
-0.0098824035,
0.0158979874,
-0.08640486,
0.0076904409,
-0.0785429403,
-0.0062086829,
-0.031455148,
-0.0013203981,
0.0679155663,
-0.0059107933,
-0.047387775,
-0.0091442792,
-0.0372471884,
0.0136633562,
-0.0505505539,
0.0044523603,
0.0817659423,
0.0238971207,
0.052869577,
0.0019581218,
0.010321592,
0.0192765705,
0.0431119837,
-0.0202202853,
-0.0039390535,
-0.0410961322,
0.0081967162,
-0.0047177025,
0.003721361,
-0.0759252757,
0.06104156,
0.036410518,
-0.0010927881,
-0.0078990739,
-0.014875643,
-0.0029253669,
-0.0441579595,
0.0508127771,
-0.0395575576,
0.0302341953,
0.0525778048,
-0.0029867257,
0.0214253049,
0.0022295557,
-0.0030614214,
-0.0060686674,
0.094429329,
-0.0090258643,
0.0240166392,
0.0147906085,
-0.0418069661,
-0.0457160845,
0.0247574802,
-0.0085300021,
-0.0074692639,
-0.0576081388,
-0.0233576428,
0.0637638345,
-0.0285972264,
-0.0146724181,
-0.0091534834,
0.0501134023,
-0.0161380377,
0.0547662824,
-0.0222294573,
0.0470378324,
0.0143228294,
0.0317487493,
-0.0202000663,
-0.0293936413,
-0.049404975,
-0.0280713234,
0.0330793187,
0.0536113307,
-0.004293316,
-0.0486867577,
0.0038588827,
0.0029334889,
0.1016887277,
-0.0145842489,
0.014408946,
-0.0260054339,
0.0014495231,
-0.0494959578,
0.0369055383,
0.0196649395,
0.0323287733,
-0.0444526821,
0.0287702996,
0.0393731222,
-0.003828885,
-0.0060317158,
0.0447146557,
0.0085257823,
-0.009253893,
-0.024176864,
-0.0074363137,
-0.0185147617,
-0.0506304204,
-0.0063227098,
0.0132245021,
0.0486145243,
-0.0089547085,
-0.0062196432,
0.0352317616,
-0.0048031849,
-0.0096026026,
0.0409593694,
-0.0229552239,
-0.0058223489,
0.0165690556,
0.0679299682,
0.015938418,
0.0177209321,
0.043950621,
0.0569418631,
-0.0065899435,
-0.0409014262,
-0.0006024634,
-0.0265100263,
-0.0442638099,
-0.002920599,
0.021656068,
-0.0199423302,
0.0071691633,
-0.0605276823,
-0.0307864435,
0.0217952486,
0.0210143942,
-0.0083322283,
0.092131339,
-0.0145299649,
0.0355565101,
0.0123207811,
-0.0037726888,
-0.045643799,
0.0214680582,
-0.0366403162,
0.0614514574,
-0.0349556282,
0.0423995145,
-0.0594944805,
-0.0451350808,
0.016640326,
0.0074158129,
-0.0366224274,
-0.0261730216,
-0.0026603648,
0.0070242924,
0.0560823604,
0.0055803028,
-0.0335449353,
-0.0258201659,
-0.0565140024,
-0.0234149508,
-0.0105223246,
0.0351938009,
0.009156513,
-0.0081895553,
0.0004669798,
0.0047769677,
-0.0049738614,
0.0373722874,
0.0301128086,
-0.0046357028,
0.0530683547,
-0.0325542502,
-0.0307209343,
-0.0119821262,
-0.0535626858,
-0.0264100023,
0.0475378372,
0.0357585438,
-0.0799813271,
-0.0270262528,
-0.0144677162,
-0.1006591842,
-0.0367676914,
-0.0067355246,
-0.026358394,
0.008609416,
0.015570893,
-0.0046987212,
0.000165995,
0.0507706888,
0.0090968022,
0.0207307879,
0.0771916807,
0.0559203215,
-0.0485383384,
-0.046043735,
0.0425426513,
-0.007985563,
-0.0496115945,
0.0252478868,
0.0334730521,
0.0356094539,
-0.0091778226,
-0.0124741122,
0.0182301383,
-0.0547553599,
0.0068502501,
-0.0043283449,
-0.0366986282,
0.04724437,
0.0170872919,
0.0014142379,
-0.016883539,
0.0227548182,
0.0220427513,
0.0144108199,
0.0061168345,
-0.0827541575,
-0.0121508045,
-0.0020989787,
0.1016894504,
0.031306576,
0.0381258279,
-0.0269598756,
0.0213572495,
0.0017974023,
0.0452180654,
-0.0153102269,
-0.0437631682,
0.0359441712,
-0.0259947162,
0.0340408981,
0.001100329,
-0.0241975691,
0.012554545,
-0.0193617828,
0.002248063,
0.0918603837,
-0.0177601725,
0.045071777,
0.0429809056,
-0.0003458673,
-0.0423694104,
0.0120419906,
-0.0182619058,
-0.0093768351,
0.0926420391,
-0.0386398956,
-0.0577010959,
0.0403983667,
-0.015993908,
-0.0473231748,
0.0180879831,
-0.0151505908,
-0.0106026912,
-0.0075944909,
-0.0362125598,
0.0094537875,
-0.009144567,
-0.0176727884,
0.019073192,
0.0097349351,
0.0137142939,
0.0284311716,
0.0921503529,
0.0612176582,
-0.0364935771,
0.0077185975,
0.05455897,
-0.0236952174,
0.0627564415,
0.0279965345,
-0.0327735581,
0.0519102924,
-0.0666425079,
0.0126994168,
-0.0173460376,
-0.0554605462,
0.0239861999,
-0.0473821983,
0.0165290162,
0.0085160816,
-0.0833680332,
-0.0153760258,
-0.0929251462,
0.0081252521,
-0.0305563752,
-0.0237067714,
-0.0409060307,
0.0149241881,
0.0127703371,
-0.0101182405,
-0.131449461,
-0.0275924951,
0.0063328492,
-0.049863562,
0.0571992658,
-0.0244157575,
0.0498274788,
-0.0266312417,
-0.0159040783,
-0.0034759929,
-0.0115454914,
0.0135258017,
-0.0214143489,
0.0339701883,
0.036951229,
-0.0003131079,
-0.0634846985,
-0.0051803999,
-0.0163771808,
0.019209953,
0.0082950927,
0.0187682398,
0.016671,
-0.0848888084,
-0.0024535086,
0.0355725177,
0.0006151191,
-0.0015401604,
-0.0112726465,
-0.0281457864,
0.0135870716,
-0.0251398664,
0.0249462649,
-0.0062858756,
-0.0602120198,
-0.0155866789,
0.0053160149,
0.0003873442,
-0.0559165105,
-0.0098012974,
-0.0107629057,
0.0397981107,
-0.0313919671,
-0.0372232199,
0.1164935306,
-0.0054622698,
-0.0570748709,
-0.0066990326,
-0.0175803024,
0.0006370182,
-0.0033110015,
-0.0330008008,
0.0238468722,
0.0034369461,
-0.0258184727,
-0.0427580215,
-0.0157295652,
-0.0495063886,
0.016448468,
-0.015201523,
0.0127596855,
0.0278535169,
-0.0376691148,
-0.0107182218,
0.0120318737,
-0.0109682372,
-0.0241570435,
-0.0082588112,
-0.0195291191,
0.025977958,
-0.0124508403,
0.0067618494,
0.0187913813,
0.0193978958,
-0.015458704,
-0.0739499554,
-0.1153717712,
-0.012582792,
-0.0173831079,
0.021686431,
0.0213228054,
-0.0061901584,
-0.0104760751,
-0.0120966928,
-0.0833862126,
-0.0198633168,
-0.0300489925,
0.0269978419,
-0.0792625025,
0.0049314448,
0.0142166736,
-0.0268966332,
0.0347992517,
0.0035590148,
0.0231386181,
-0.0294513498,
0.0200997107,
0.0340253338,
0.0341495201,
-0.0220397245,
-0.0052954955,
0.0260545257,
-0.0125122545,
0.0232520849,
0.0339495987,
-0.0195668153,
0.0224989355,
-0.0274980813,
-0.0247209407,
-0.0447734445,
0.0603752583,
-0.0249495842,
0.0116749983,
-0.0224471763,
0.0135408659,
-0.0094085271,
-0.0184890777,
0.0220571868,
0.0045696604,
-0.0131990323,
-0.0088262614,
0.0702672452,
-0.0319347195,
-0.0695311278,
-0.0168081764,
-0.0037643791,
-0.0299160462,
0.0392796621,
0.0068360884,
-0.0393763669,
-0.1030514762,
0.0065050358,
-0.0887033567,
-0.0308862533,
0.0144831501,
0.0048187817,
0.044352375,
-0.0101675317,
0.0201068632,
-0.0220957194,
-0.0435754396,
0.005640334,
0.0019422804,
0.0411496423,
0.0126909912,
0.0141458679,
0.0379290953,
-0.0023080399,
0.0358057618,
-0.048229035,
-0.0248979721,
-0.0302474927,
0.0052330927,
0.0055438974,
-6.55951929e-33,
-0.0090011507,
-0.1443444341,
-0.0219501648,
0.0120605221,
0.0028641846,
-0.0154867442,
-0.0143730296,
0.0415844284,
0.011740326,
-0.0016055703,
-0.0009636102,
0.0336097181,
-0.007310221,
-0.0043970244,
-0.0013185674,
0.0229087174,
0.0013547296,
-0.0223433077,
0.0112329517,
0.027525207,
0.0423928797,
-0.0453935266,
0.0233666413,
-0.0835136473,
0.0215729419,
0.012721166,
0.0020936206,
0.0149565712,
0.0710292459,
0.005379952,
-0.030134812,
0.0334850959,
0.0285380501,
0.0106670354,
0.0284070484,
0.0170018896,
-0.0567987971,
-0.0347181261,
-0.0237955917,
0.0079154326,
-0.0139182089,
0.0173116401,
0.0260212589,
-0.0159801319,
-0.0154855167,
0.0338953957,
0.0817833394,
0.022746196,
0.0141070634,
0.0053375391,
-0.0339015014,
0.044096902,
-0.0079871062,
0.0511022732,
-0.0387525037,
0.0019974713,
-0.0187277142,
-0.0110393409,
-0.0673785135,
0.0431097858,
-0.0663963258,
-0.025723815,
0.0081087751,
0.0469725914,
-0.0009635134,
0.0371927097,
0.0236157905,
0.0955209583,
-0.0070678429,
0.0290996395,
0.0377020836,
0.0125112766,
0.0128979217,
0.050392516,
-0.0359499864,
-0.028113829,
-0.0261240322,
0.0268193502,
0.0691691935,
-0.0824723691,
0.0122463387,
0.0072931657,
-0.0623322241,
-0.0581377894,
0.0511428602,
-0.0701276287,
-0.0016572403,
-0.0128480066,
-0.0536234193,
-0.0283645466,
-0.0737389028,
-0.0277925916,
-0.010977176,
-0.0751522928,
-0.0091829961,
-0.0041906475,
-0.002577092,
0.0239304379,
0.0099135898,
-0.0234144889,
-0.0209881403,
-0.0273758452,
-0.0453649424,
-0.0061067701,
0.02601826,
-0.028167164,
-0.0364289246,
-0.0085362792,
-0.0340960734,
0.0075813956,
0.0488289967,
0.0032628935,
-0.0221780371,
-0.0194854513,
0.0294778943,
0.0310381409,
-0.0158578437,
-0.0085575115,
0.0443168953,
0.041140642,
0.0367650315,
-0.0022678571,
-0.0373867191,
-0.0136225726,
-0.0264398791,
-0.011474994,
-0.026489079,
0.0741758272,
0.0235640015,
-0.0134683978,
-0.0289448127,
-0.0787249878,
2.89e-7,
0.0396100543,
0.0506642647,
0.0053197062,
0.0067797969,
0.0414656699,
0.0102175837,
0.0447038598,
0.0080373352,
0.0063364832,
-0.0462303385,
0.0073033124,
0.026446756,
0.007261618,
0.0568787605,
-0.0188382231,
0.0182387307,
-0.0006983929,
-0.0240965113,
-0.0215886142,
0.0220778044,
-0.0148477843,
0.0293209143,
0.0084766084,
0.0111560617,
-0.0712246895,
-0.0353044495,
-0.0020037051,
-0.0132058468,
-0.0522209704,
0.0133881057,
-0.0078419372,
-0.0258655418,
0.0019658075,
0.0525055788,
0.0040095095,
0.0249782782,
0.0346598886,
-0.0234306399,
0.0062125763,
0.0533880219,
0.0122595504,
-0.0059790662,
0.0109754084,
-0.0097203143,
0.0472426899,
-0.0333472714,
-0.0432131477,
-0.0034456493,
-0.0089880489,
-0.0435008556,
0.0455301479,
0.0164879449,
-0.0193582997,
0.0598379225,
-0.0100480821,
-0.0356225781,
0.0041970145,
-0.0422743112,
0.0192731619,
0.0123993466,
-0.0217972398,
-0.0618574657,
0.0527388044,
0.0066811866,
0.0647059605,
0.042798575,
0.0366420262,
2.302871264e-34,
0.0028595291,
0.022787014,
-0.0127074374,
-0.0422683731,
0.0537245944,
-0.0121393306,
-0.0746363774,
-0.0066640414,
0.0357259549,
-0.0384524837,
0.0091767088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17104v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17104v1 | Automated Adversarial Discovery for Safety Classifiers | 2024-06-24T19:45:12 | 2024-06-24T19:45:12 | Yash Kumar Lal, Preethi Lahoti, Aradhana Sinha, Yao Qin, Ananth Balashankar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Safety classifiers are critical in mitigating toxicity on online forums such
as social media and in chatbots. Still, they continue to be vulnerable to
emergent, and often innumerable, adversarial attacks. Traditional automated
adversarial data generation methods, however, tend to produce attacks that are
not diverse, but variations of previously observed harm types. We formalize the
task of automated adversarial discovery for safety classifiers - to find new
attacks along previously unseen harm dimensions that expose new weaknesses in
the classifier. We measure progress on this task along two key axes (1)
adversarial success: does the attack fool the classifier? and (2) dimensional
diversity: does the attack represent a previously unseen harm type? Our
evaluation of existing attack generation methods on the CivilComments toxicity
task reveals their limitations: Word perturbation attacks fail to fool
classifiers, while prompt-based LLM attacks have more adversarial success, but
lack dimensional diversity. Even our best-performing prompt-based method finds
new successful attacks on unseen harm dimensions of attacks only 5\% of the
time. Automatically finding new harmful dimensions of attack is crucial and
there is substantial headroom for future research on our new task. | [
0.0411893837,
0.0582233518,
-0.0169177167,
0.0175648984,
-0.0054101814,
0.0031841595,
0.0024481225,
0.0219740029,
0.0608078688,
-0.0387320742,
-0.0091920607,
-0.0082258759,
-0.0104170274,
0.0089820931,
0.0619738847,
-0.0156293213,
0.0471986271,
0.0079771979,
-0.0238196626,
-0.0041828165,
0.0224357657,
-0.0141397547,
-0.0148099139,
0.0298197549,
-0.0475747138,
-0.0277613513,
0.0090445941,
0.0062658316,
0.0658538043,
-0.0587424785,
0.0265289657,
0.0249493588,
0.0040561357,
0.0693660676,
0.0000017284,
-0.045427423,
-0.0229070671,
0.0175156333,
-0.0054871268,
-0.0174508691,
0.0451787114,
-0.0321587585,
0.0039311629,
0.0506902151,
-0.0132586518,
-0.0112245055,
0.0348059908,
0.0332822874,
0.0477423705,
0.1278704256,
-0.0224882755,
-0.0068743257,
0.035837993,
-0.0274595693,
0.0124873845,
-0.0362783074,
0.046246361,
-0.0555550121,
-0.0363094769,
0.0060681286,
-0.0000706609,
0.0085909972,
-0.0087178377,
-0.0051264926,
-0.0151612312,
-0.0025192089,
0.0104300994,
-0.0225027706,
0.0063002114,
0.0756654218,
0.0046701445,
-0.0045384481,
0.0205214806,
0.0050151674,
0.0435047448,
-0.001977036,
-0.0286908541,
-0.0134649286,
-0.0078136716,
-0.0265419744,
-0.022965081,
0.0236166958,
0.0658277646,
0.0386590213,
0.0457304753,
0.0134023381,
0.0073724962,
-0.0082228025,
0.0224044826,
-0.027901195,
0.001988569,
0.009414318,
0.0346541628,
0.0181063432,
-0.0175062921,
0.0119781224,
-0.0638461336,
-0.0641882941,
0.0566602387,
-0.0772882625,
0.0435888059,
-0.0091169681,
-0.0333398767,
0.0165769868,
0.0256805737,
-0.0082281213,
-0.0360026807,
0.0490219481,
-0.0005328193,
0.0252404753,
-0.008628956,
-0.0119871432,
-0.0024988251,
0.0084614214,
0.0355643071,
0.0324089415,
-0.050470829,
0.0570543632,
-0.0700834021,
0.0106359264,
-0.0087254746,
0.0104727577,
-0.0091125974,
0.030193666,
0.0060667954,
-0.0681320354,
-0.0180189759,
-0.0041381894,
-0.0023514328,
-0.0637830049,
-0.0404016785,
0.044824481,
-0.037050534,
-0.0278029032,
-0.0093820356,
0.1446098983,
0.0526906811,
-0.0214111432,
-0.0327018984,
-0.07106971,
-0.0520093255,
-0.0098832222,
0.0398010723,
-0.0254417155,
-0.0080090603,
-0.0381470323,
-0.0328526087,
-0.0715254471,
-0.0018022956,
0.0011557816,
-0.007752791,
0.0587258339,
0.0030338259,
-0.0278590992,
0.0319214724,
0.0555503629,
-0.0434726439,
0.0617694743,
0.0067876712,
0.0481601208,
0.0415693372,
0.0170722846,
0.0241241474,
0.0347368084,
0.0332053937,
0.0070840199,
-0.0162091628,
0.0073978235,
-0.0209438056,
-0.0079824021,
-0.0517696626,
0.0502195433,
-0.0108197974,
-0.0755435973,
0.0736649781,
0.0010174084,
-0.0471997447,
0.024683468,
0.0247286335,
-0.0063049244,
-0.0112293698,
-0.0206910465,
-0.0523076802,
-0.012269794,
-0.0920868292,
-0.0759967491,
0.0212364402,
0.0207496919,
-0.0309452452,
-0.0401621759,
-0.0080209887,
-0.0162604917,
0.0706548467,
-0.0260922592,
0.0262537748,
0.0457083918,
-0.0177182052,
0.0103663672,
0.030427536,
-0.0221690163,
-0.0221716091,
-0.0421813875,
-0.0158572346,
0.0325310677,
0.0483427681,
-0.0592840798,
0.0134103214,
-0.0515349209,
0.031658113,
0.0150632849,
0.041436024,
-0.0038803974,
0.0125715593,
-0.0112223011,
0.0058887219,
-0.0200063176,
0.001305737,
-0.0028903091,
0.056009464,
0.0134285176,
-0.0165763982,
-0.0034629419,
-0.0561360791,
0.0609774217,
0.0326976515,
-0.046566654,
0.031914629,
0.0355273187,
0.0649113208,
0.0162455607,
-0.0055668307,
0.0097401412,
0.0464341789,
-0.0079588853,
-0.0742082745,
-0.031115124,
0.0234538633,
0.0068577765,
0.0225303192,
-0.0253474768,
-0.0279075149,
0.0527378097,
-0.0430767015,
0.0684457719,
0.0573975518,
-0.0422237478,
-0.0588773154,
-0.0112567516,
-0.022669971,
-0.0116366446,
0.0268033706,
-0.0036878374,
0.0825203657,
-0.0360327885,
-0.0257854331,
-0.0187452957,
-0.0085796984,
-0.0036911389,
-0.017925635,
-0.0264557302,
-0.0257060155,
-0.0897587091,
0.025144361,
0.0036800622,
-0.0178528987,
-0.0334515907,
-0.0200862605,
0.0000894413,
-0.0312120076,
-0.0204567667,
0.0080050854,
-0.0059617087,
-0.0411614105,
0.0177717712,
-0.0193046033,
0.0068614217,
0.0017633667,
-0.0142881842,
0.0567158908,
0.0115030287,
-0.0087643247,
-0.0225166231,
-0.0217214525,
-0.0021603361,
-0.0214967914,
0.0678647906,
0.0043776697,
-0.0455347896,
0.0064724856,
0.0184957329,
-0.0280485209,
0.0190946646,
-0.0261499081,
-0.0516602658,
0.0587174743,
0.0445073545,
-0.042891141,
0.0542098247,
0.078675136,
0.1098073348,
0.0520089455,
0.0651241168,
0.0000844603,
0.0033122578,
-0.0163462758,
-0.0155505687,
-0.0059918999,
-0.030927768,
0.0165373255,
0.0234446395,
0.0155417323,
-0.0160983298,
-0.0280110333,
0.0622883104,
-0.0187594686,
-0.0492259264,
-0.0144776395,
-0.0487923138,
-0.0074746553,
-0.0188818369,
-0.0072770626,
-0.0608860329,
0.0909835473,
0.0230648965,
0.0480551943,
-0.0061943135,
-0.0574082583,
0.0353451036,
0.0487505421,
-0.0231864732,
0.0219272468,
0.0291941334,
0.0149633046,
-0.0173345506,
-0.0225441437,
0.0517212339,
-0.0210370105,
0.0096077854,
0.0004657709,
0.0116245979,
0.040088065,
-0.056071654,
-0.0908495709,
-0.063399978,
-0.0138858045,
-0.0086642085,
-0.0261604954,
0.003189276,
-0.034837395,
-0.0176364183,
-0.0167153291,
-0.0544423461,
0.0022839783,
-0.0184458345,
0.0059733223,
0.0106243184,
0.0368169583,
-0.0356719084,
0.0292920526,
-0.0318321995,
0.0419706255,
0.0814838037,
-0.0298764613,
0.0028895531,
-0.0203698557,
-0.0383679196,
-0.0333160423,
0.0000844921,
0.0284938272,
0.0213878583,
0.0008989507,
-0.0152584771,
0.0098189889,
0.0020469187,
-0.0042012534,
0.0087971454,
0.0741633028,
0.041659981,
0.0115596661,
-0.0037615935,
-0.0230340753,
-0.0662451386,
-0.0005790789,
-0.0032521063,
0.0438685752,
-0.0454930067,
-0.0246367846,
0.007834278,
-0.0643021315,
0.0150756417,
0.0007206109,
-0.0572523661,
-0.0220619962,
-0.0168743581,
-0.0309578162,
-0.0326305777,
0.0317961276,
-0.0194608532,
0.0205543172,
-0.0293053053,
-0.011894837,
-0.040987853,
-0.0523711927,
-0.0260193963,
-0.0306497663,
0.0282808784,
0.0291982424,
0.0216431357,
-0.0409939773,
-0.0113987513,
0.0451527312,
0.017110059,
0.0014642646,
-0.0026879476,
0.1166631132,
0.0118640596,
-0.0190769285,
-0.0277733523,
0.0399112105,
0.0029138902,
-0.0300938711,
0.0080475695,
0.0251869299,
-0.0106119048,
-0.0407677703,
-0.0255820099,
0.056983646,
0.0564277768,
0.0609641671,
0.0062984782,
-0.0484661832,
0.0033422841,
-0.0747765675,
0.0107517662,
-0.0480044708,
-0.061534401,
0.0066086291,
0.0037360832,
-0.0432023145,
-0.0519341864,
0.0117790643,
-0.0131171104,
0.0116967699,
0.0077774161,
-0.0146674449,
-0.0578072108,
0.0317959972,
-0.0327061079,
0.0137607967,
0.0252393764,
0.0241521336,
-0.0062921802,
-0.0127505353,
-0.0074672112,
-0.002753715,
-0.0291269384,
0.0363125876,
-0.0831225291,
-0.1043047532,
0.0147507032,
0.0714454949,
0.0091594011,
0.0195827521,
-0.0390067138,
-0.0684694871,
0.0802418441,
0.0770575032,
0.0212033074,
-0.0083149904,
0.0680566207,
0.0011170252,
0.0176639501,
0.01808488,
-0.0364255793,
-0.0126884524,
0.054642912,
-0.0162518378,
-0.0410912484,
0.012031029,
-0.0012072199,
0.0249476749,
0.0349714123,
-0.0099065984,
-0.0144229718,
0.0251641199,
0.0035676323,
0.0127568236,
-0.0179026537,
0.0276879016,
0.0285260063,
0.0200577248,
-0.0190163143,
-0.0094384355,
0.014593496,
-0.0225093942,
0.0588043779,
-0.0596372001,
0.0173424892,
0.0230240673,
0.0309239756,
0.0384475067,
0.0211290419,
-0.0217007417,
0.0538071319,
0.0071566487,
0.0122509608,
0.001917546,
-0.0121863633,
-0.0041000755,
0.0258598328,
-0.0095802499,
0.0036718531,
-0.0234778766,
-0.0292807557,
-0.0347711295,
0.0447330587,
-0.0007678657,
0.0185665302,
-0.0169143267,
-0.0138548361,
-0.0121208774,
-0.0239754114,
-0.0043546231,
-0.0370413661,
-0.0550377257,
0.0287875645,
0.0043984544,
-0.0212676432,
0.0088491961,
0.0717376322,
0.0058453283,
0.0607275739,
0.0236247275,
-0.0454103015,
-0.0169188324,
-0.0225229114,
0.0419910401,
0.0251842197,
-0.0209746193,
-0.0183702018,
-0.0604756847,
-0.0705170855,
0.0129737891,
-0.0070996629,
0.0251796898,
0.0193600524,
-0.0384936742,
0.0181706119,
0.0181495957,
0.0462461598,
-0.0426576659,
0.0023665584,
-0.010826014,
-0.0596532412,
0.0303406361,
-5.354155628e-33,
0.0383101329,
-0.053718172,
-0.0555843525,
0.0140723549,
0.0292868298,
0.0053703329,
0.0216709431,
-0.0179155897,
-0.0166344568,
0.0191495977,
0.0249668285,
0.0044922349,
-0.026337212,
-0.0112945875,
-0.0131128374,
-0.0871356726,
0.0077905152,
-0.0307317078,
-0.0171810277,
0.0174186826,
0.0416658632,
0.0140252262,
0.014533015,
-0.1087094173,
0.0320607945,
0.0172156505,
-0.0285498183,
0.0167130306,
-0.0236036852,
0.0715169981,
0.0249429028,
0.0489384606,
0.007470611,
0.0155813303,
0.0294966586,
0.0148672033,
0.0065151867,
-0.0050492124,
-0.0327943563,
-0.0182748083,
-0.025266204,
-0.0552034564,
0.0328053162,
-0.0130647402,
-0.015649233,
-0.0342879742,
-0.0064836033,
-0.0068134167,
0.0060033584,
-0.0516234413,
-0.0416367538,
0.0022159172,
-0.0388162881,
-0.0268524997,
-0.0235304628,
0.052491419,
0.0514556728,
0.0173772275,
-0.0440269038,
0.0183485541,
0.000230715,
-0.0327199511,
0.0166756418,
-0.0260410607,
0.0004473964,
0.0680189952,
0.0073268339,
0.0580630153,
-0.0156120015,
-0.0201325174,
-0.0075456193,
0.0329861417,
0.0729865879,
0.0751219392,
0.0246230029,
-0.0545416549,
-0.1297006309,
-0.0042906841,
0.035373345,
-0.0115597975,
0.0314223282,
-0.0287823603,
-0.0548561923,
-0.0038480514,
-0.0070391418,
-0.0402997769,
-0.0339365005,
-0.0204701554,
-0.0030670215,
0.0148070781,
-0.0474275127,
-0.0436746515,
-0.0289890803,
-0.0494792424,
0.0241398346,
0.0598794334,
-0.0008498575,
-0.0392374247,
0.0161755029,
0.0001453301,
0.0088411309,
-0.0013389839,
0.0349510014,
-0.0699677989,
0.0385035276,
-0.0020909568,
0.08747188,
0.0395936519,
-0.0177836828,
-0.0223146882,
-0.0077700224,
0.0534519963,
0.0096437335,
0.0268829539,
0.0209196527,
0.0170373246,
-0.0182528701,
-0.0020290611,
0.0646841154,
0.0309282951,
0.0003191398,
0.0484588258,
-0.0439765528,
0.000392946,
0.004410882,
-0.0264318679,
0.0110817086,
-0.0036575657,
0.0486961603,
-0.1040327549,
0.0177896507,
-0.0636279881,
2.657e-7,
-0.0024432593,
0.0392709561,
-0.0039937696,
0.0036822869,
0.0494942516,
0.0515825525,
0.0160735827,
0.0793674216,
-0.0417486653,
-0.0415906832,
0.0135879042,
0.0190344881,
0.0736575723,
0.0372104049,
-0.0396648906,
-0.0140174218,
-0.0855956748,
0.0016798757,
-0.040839754,
0.0075584175,
0.0285358746,
0.0574465431,
0.0079575283,
-0.016044911,
-0.013286096,
-0.0425299406,
0.026889544,
-0.0366013311,
0.0202945601,
0.0027274971,
0.0686712861,
0.0135664232,
0.0258681271,
0.0240604039,
-0.0516445152,
-0.0271855872,
-0.0166262202,
0.0234993268,
0.006834277,
-0.0236609597,
0.0049962434,
-0.0160974041,
0.0159031302,
0.0056251553,
0.0504389741,
-0.0319766402,
-0.0096616866,
-0.0447171964,
-0.0058899089,
-0.0349827297,
0.0623684414,
-0.0466877073,
-0.0048235217,
-0.0012804936,
-0.002186435,
-0.0027775101,
0.0425512269,
-0.0551780947,
0.0056401459,
0.0048538647,
-0.0273253489,
-0.0491947047,
0.0101194112,
0.0262159836,
0.0467064753,
0.0182017256,
0.0197732877,
2.207945733e-34,
0.0108954739,
-0.0143839736,
-0.0235256385,
-0.0277157556,
0.0421103947,
0.0115650529,
0.0106936926,
-0.0168427695,
-0.004595736,
-0.0216474459,
-0.0059198411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17095v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17095v1 | Attention Instruction: Amplifying Attention in the Middle via Prompting | 2024-06-24T19:35:11 | 2024-06-24T19:35:11 | Meiru Zhang, Zaiqiao Meng, Nigel Collier | cs.CL | cs.CL | The context window of large language models has been extended to 128k tokens
or more. However, language models still suffer from position bias and have
difficulty in accessing and using the middle part of the context due to the
lack of attention. We examine the relative position awareness of LLMs and the
feasibility of mitigating disproportional attention through prompting. We
augment the original task instruction with $\texttt{attention instructions}$
that direct language models to allocate more attention towards a selected
segment of the context. We conduct a comprehensive investigation on
multi-document question answering task with both position-based and index-based
instructions. We find that language models do not have relative position
awareness of the context. Nevertheless, they demonstrate the capacity to adapt
attention to a specific segment using matching indexes. Our analysis
contributes to a deeper understanding of position bias in LLMs and provides a
pathway to mitigate this bias by instruction, thus benefiting LLMs in locating
and utilizing relevant information from retrieved documents in RAG
applications. | [
0.0475093685,
-0.0016096801,
-0.0077452157,
0.0284721907,
0.0038156861,
0.0120986532,
0.0136094308,
-0.0006942565,
-0.0075392793,
-0.0490262061,
-0.0363579616,
-0.0421244875,
-0.0344985537,
-0.0557611845,
0.0316732265,
-0.042164959,
0.0678030774,
-0.053943038,
0.0189448837,
-0.0266444907,
-0.0200325064,
-0.0001464062,
-0.0005022911,
0.0147429053,
0.0227395445,
-0.0219154637,
-0.013756061,
0.0055564647,
0.0010899499,
-0.0167331249,
0.0112121822,
0.0341589749,
0.0146412253,
0.0088295555,
0.0000018003,
-0.0422910899,
0.0188020766,
-0.0236307513,
-0.0504617207,
0.0132061262,
0.013562372,
0.0249329992,
0.0149883674,
0.0084736478,
-0.0166938659,
0.0338771679,
0.0182087962,
0.0236088857,
0.0272356011,
0.0564708747,
0.0179806016,
0.0106248613,
0.0232493635,
-0.0100278473,
0.0894927457,
-0.0778716803,
0.0013422859,
0.0067896391,
0.0521094352,
0.0527395085,
-0.017733762,
0.0434644446,
0.0169018656,
0.0068736989,
0.0061933678,
0.0567511693,
-0.0320987254,
0.0167737249,
-0.0258097854,
0.0447170585,
0.0099913124,
-0.0086829597,
-0.0024927543,
0.0118069258,
0.0340947472,
0.0076476946,
-0.1001095176,
0.0530441068,
-0.0207335018,
-0.0218168907,
0.042498704,
-0.0113031929,
0.0179260746,
0.0268851947,
-0.0279458854,
0.0835709199,
0.0158307981,
-0.0479593948,
0.0123876883,
0.0012064066,
-0.0118378419,
-0.0517439805,
0.0081367688,
0.0734016672,
-0.0378784835,
0.03540124,
-0.0149069959,
-0.0363745578,
0.047091227,
-0.0442932807,
0.0199667104,
0.0426445715,
-0.0309540611,
0.0652528331,
-0.0270278901,
0.0436361507,
-0.055205062,
0.0010115844,
-0.0659279227,
-0.0161672775,
0.0151728522,
-0.0493593141,
-0.0568746962,
0.0165084396,
-0.051291272,
-0.0346887559,
0.0034761934,
0.0723248795,
0.0310913902,
-0.0274610184,
-0.0030773506,
0.0290222764,
-0.0256600045,
-0.0097849658,
-0.0140536996,
0.0385695845,
-0.0528265238,
0.0139848283,
0.0218140706,
-0.0611931533,
-0.0282883719,
0.0169036891,
-0.0165718626,
-0.0566079207,
0.0205910485,
0.0406404622,
-0.0025853729,
-0.0267160982,
-0.023624599,
-0.0148950862,
0.0041632433,
-0.0436349213,
0.015620891,
-0.0559038259,
0.0176080111,
0.0487798676,
-0.0202812087,
0.0193637554,
0.0120010097,
0.046371948,
-0.0292080306,
0.0310791638,
0.0271538869,
0.0259397551,
0.0468301959,
0.0153116649,
0.0053823218,
0.0743568614,
0.0083722714,
0.0146750091,
0.0397868715,
-0.0032945964,
-0.013418505,
0.0253203101,
0.0153947556,
0.0220899414,
0.0137927346,
0.0448573232,
0.0023871723,
0.0251186714,
0.058878269,
0.0152195124,
-0.0223715659,
-0.0173120406,
0.039198827,
0.0902821273,
-0.0050020446,
-0.0064647915,
-0.0103588253,
-0.0156193404,
-0.0152025381,
0.0330574624,
-0.0640139952,
0.0614453815,
-0.0126280999,
0.037929818,
0.0608306527,
0.007525418,
-0.0439571142,
-0.02111076,
-0.0341645516,
0.0303709153,
-0.0258213617,
0.0425085649,
0.0334775299,
-0.0145585202,
-0.0097530596,
0.0879273936,
0.0132701509,
-0.0371896438,
0.0085554309,
-0.033151716,
0.0192559808,
0.0549632199,
0.0394698866,
-0.0570974089,
-0.0459770039,
0.0048331842,
0.0714786202,
0.026463069,
0.0503992401,
0.0146562103,
0.0005624093,
-0.0166674722,
-0.0291754939,
-0.0420712233,
-0.0049460349,
0.0146515714,
0.0459409282,
0.0212440621,
0.0036091448,
-0.0777940005,
0.002719945,
0.0317715555,
-0.0208371747,
-0.0497112125,
-0.0346428752,
0.0085094906,
-0.0041401894,
0.0031740901,
-0.0007775924,
0.0240326747,
0.0515352786,
-0.0155461337,
0.0415229872,
-0.0357908309,
-0.0489574373,
0.0220193043,
0.03445049,
-0.0157328062,
-0.0348836444,
0.0044122348,
0.0033043784,
-0.0262223687,
0.0012046887,
-0.0598821007,
0.0274888799,
0.0045562899,
0.0007390251,
0.032078281,
-0.0021695965,
-0.0684569776,
0.0731313527,
-0.0126292147,
0.0599161312,
0.076931268,
0.004205754,
0.0013662131,
-0.0654935092,
0.0287261307,
-0.0151272891,
0.0064021032,
-0.0083555607,
0.0204663798,
0.0014208002,
-0.0484164841,
-0.0494006947,
-0.1088521034,
0.0143624693,
-0.0428475887,
0.0371929705,
0.033877857,
0.0402608886,
-0.0221613869,
-0.0428468361,
-0.0641508847,
-0.01499533,
0.0210048631,
0.0575385243,
0.0243118182,
0.0073701111,
0.0146919349,
-0.0475584269,
-0.0347302668,
-0.0056290431,
0.0181901287,
0.0210416783,
-0.0183201674,
-0.0746342465,
0.013223853,
-0.0003707722,
0.0280857924,
-0.0220543072,
0.0035113127,
0.0117059285,
-0.0319522209,
0.0337270871,
0.1052581146,
0.0174910929,
0.0263047889,
0.0613266118,
-0.0066420594,
-0.0801409483,
0.0277444459,
0.0130109284,
-0.0145850787,
-0.0313399546,
-0.016770415,
0.0157477446,
0.0400571339,
-0.0062428429,
-0.0020791267,
-0.0048500635,
-0.0104706576,
0.0160660855,
-0.0330799334,
-0.048510015,
-0.0099759102,
-0.040336296,
0.0404674932,
-0.0230064858,
-0.0436095297,
0.0448504053,
-0.0089566326,
-0.0260084756,
-0.0493687764,
0.0162118357,
-0.0481187291,
0.0429586023,
-0.0150585799,
0.0229401682,
-0.0576936007,
-0.0547113493,
-0.0623569451,
0.0121762957,
-0.0233106315,
-0.0241550375,
0.0669491738,
-0.0065010544,
0.0301939379,
-0.0332060345,
-0.0345495269,
-0.0601654649,
-0.0476165377,
-0.0000068747,
0.0230298713,
0.0021907662,
-0.0010293372,
-0.0434881635,
0.007339614,
0.0812644586,
0.0321209356,
-0.0253534801,
-0.0100612612,
-0.0313046202,
0.0180811994,
0.0806696415,
0.0501868725,
0.0173504483,
-0.038448371,
-0.003479959,
0.0672566667,
0.0798668414,
-0.0080740144,
0.0265195929,
-0.0144059639,
0.0729333088,
-0.0857937783,
-0.0069292309,
0.0112272939,
0.0532671213,
-0.0683448836,
-0.0329301879,
0.1023518816,
0.0386830717,
-0.0655506849,
-0.0156462863,
-0.0545209646,
0.0113681648,
0.0580456182,
0.0575325675,
-0.07248009,
-0.0073343618,
0.0145566836,
0.0200427175,
0.0105099799,
0.0050608581,
-0.0040659471,
-0.0977744907,
0.0157296415,
-0.0144198323,
-0.0274952874,
-0.0086837457,
-0.0338497907,
0.0080299927,
0.0667276606,
0.0278630182,
0.0512312502,
-0.042102892,
-0.0239937995,
0.0163378026,
0.0497573614,
0.0092407567,
0.0225006696,
-0.0326848216,
0.0012329982,
0.0473819412,
-0.0139314085,
-0.0156160025,
-0.0428981856,
0.0464042947,
-0.0332841501,
0.0394742936,
-0.0044513051,
0.0128722843,
-0.0363706611,
0.0118090622,
-0.0149639025,
0.0111456364,
-0.0308670215,
0.0165774096,
0.0397757478,
0.0797951072,
-0.0305507276,
0.0048920754,
-0.0423352979,
-0.01343715,
-0.0096471077,
0.0716075599,
0.0397515707,
-0.0362884067,
-0.0388647467,
-0.0374231227,
-0.0197689477,
-0.0179545339,
0.0112600354,
0.0084157139,
-0.0193802454,
0.0264377389,
-0.0432932526,
-0.0478885397,
0.0399763286,
0.03600467,
0.0108280331,
0.0282493476,
-0.0326753668,
-0.0160852503,
-0.0281505324,
0.0259584915,
-0.025298629,
0.0240270868,
-0.054752782,
-0.0097419284,
-0.0020501642,
-0.056266211,
0.0003510685,
-0.0015263165,
-0.0563552454,
-0.0446559936,
-0.0066175573,
0.0197649319,
0.0257109571,
0.0190806612,
-0.0167934299,
-0.0583958477,
0.0197683647,
-0.010141938,
-0.0479793325,
0.0421931446,
0.0049374076,
-0.0130567504,
0.0138435047,
0.0230779517,
-0.102300629,
-0.0120649524,
0.0178047568,
0.0378909484,
-0.0303349923,
-0.0459492616,
0.0131718954,
0.0103387134,
0.0121873599,
-0.001608394,
0.0291014854,
-0.0161296874,
0.0473727025,
0.0043075881,
-0.0212449618,
0.0093054809,
-0.0025388333,
-0.0070336144,
-0.0437675528,
0.0129235154,
0.0233078599,
0.0153078306,
-0.000930241,
-0.0518827699,
0.0279943142,
0.0009040124,
-0.0004042654,
0.0151841678,
0.009180136,
-0.0431912541,
-0.0106095308,
-0.0066725579,
0.0648593158,
-0.0031450822,
0.0610643737,
0.0253987219,
-0.0395965874,
-0.0357448123,
0.0425956286,
-0.1254876554,
-0.0341761708,
0.0212751999,
0.0286349207,
0.0490628593,
-0.0364576764,
0.0247295909,
-0.0119146043,
-0.0122323995,
-0.0140110599,
-0.0340431295,
0.0272295997,
-0.0183774699,
0.0318148136,
0.0425914712,
0.0163727384,
0.0022245906,
0.0626529381,
0.0107291108,
0.0148511566,
-0.0082773445,
-0.0289505944,
-0.0052159596,
-0.0327109918,
-0.0057022055,
0.0394149087,
-0.0295334086,
0.025485212,
-0.0354325473,
-0.0452125445,
-0.0079170046,
0.000451036,
-0.0220022332,
-0.0643652976,
0.038955193,
0.0834543332,
0.0284191631,
-0.0574274622,
-0.0381792039,
0.054636538,
-0.0435941182,
-0.0222201422,
-0.0306322873,
-6.082968738e-33,
-0.03183892,
-0.0424660742,
0.0372977071,
-0.0143379029,
-0.0230582301,
0.005588247,
-0.033179041,
0.0066542542,
-0.0293797702,
-0.0276794303,
-0.0525139868,
0.0274417419,
0.0177171901,
-0.0088324174,
0.0280692484,
-0.0301542729,
0.0041409661,
-0.0048371027,
-0.042128779,
0.0066499617,
0.0308845062,
0.0116384421,
0.0536983907,
-0.0061425157,
0.0397113934,
-0.0108781783,
0.060404975,
0.0049852696,
-0.0297765266,
0.0744558647,
-0.0065591792,
0.0548488349,
0.03830567,
-0.0269837454,
-0.0335398018,
0.0616685562,
-0.0806697607,
-0.0552802384,
0.0501845628,
0.0033763207,
-0.0289821737,
-0.0501246266,
0.0459424034,
0.0070475768,
0.0023835609,
-0.008735205,
0.0273832474,
-0.034174215,
-0.0619629323,
-0.0041508661,
-0.042709291,
-0.0035455495,
-0.0082031963,
-0.0023041831,
-0.0137140406,
0.0479744114,
-0.0068904203,
0.0349423215,
-0.0195786227,
0.0000834176,
0.0118230395,
0.0635371283,
0.0689844862,
0.0377270319,
-0.0029888966,
0.0312638171,
0.0152564384,
0.0112389596,
-0.0224260688,
-0.0540913567,
-0.0039157053,
0.0029389302,
0.0169953015,
-0.0255891234,
0.0294445455,
0.0283531677,
-0.0395349525,
0.0191736296,
0.0367028527,
0.0646884143,
0.0414025001,
0.0020262783,
-0.0498194061,
-0.0168380775,
-0.0303129591,
0.0303239245,
-0.0539302602,
-0.0171484184,
0.0591690987,
0.0118705705,
0.013510284,
-0.0108789662,
0.0440700464,
-0.0181347504,
-0.0067292959,
0.0377409384,
0.0173047781,
0.0213387161,
0.0040118638,
0.0101054134,
-0.0397901796,
0.0226687323,
-0.0057251356,
0.0046260688,
-0.0208013821,
0.0358144417,
-0.0012442105,
-0.0287169218,
-0.0619385689,
-0.0197045729,
-0.0470838174,
0.0050239051,
-0.0104862638,
-0.0046550478,
0.0569483414,
-0.0164450761,
0.0094803786,
0.0611627586,
-0.0028046493,
-0.0337353498,
-0.0386071876,
-0.0332626104,
-0.0133100906,
0.0131542524,
-0.0341446586,
0.0302959904,
-0.0437011123,
0.0839840621,
-0.0271377917,
-0.0685493872,
-0.0046985513,
0.0425107256,
2.549e-7,
0.0477704778,
0.019284917,
0.0412523709,
0.046285335,
0.0131687084,
-0.0221677888,
-0.0099226646,
0.0207569245,
0.0366102532,
-0.0131690316,
-0.0183829591,
0.0402925536,
0.0122054201,
0.0018651091,
-0.1026331112,
-0.0029642733,
-0.0516778603,
0.026923053,
-0.0411192812,
-0.0170057304,
-0.0010436377,
0.0619445145,
-0.0398489088,
0.0005897916,
-0.0076913405,
-0.0626984164,
0.0322731584,
-0.0161504671,
0.0100403586,
-0.0107055539,
0.0521482043,
0.0081841229,
0.0083575463,
-0.0050606886,
0.0080967452,
0.0262118112,
-0.0039711078,
0.0528096668,
-0.0021832129,
-0.0565730296,
-0.0200535413,
-0.0615690649,
0.0124506941,
-0.0594298691,
0.0735217482,
-0.0042531742,
0.0197575465,
-0.0269622933,
0.0063316617,
-0.0248097703,
-0.0294217486,
-0.0117815882,
-0.0009822629,
-0.006882227,
0.0030198013,
-0.0346838124,
0.0033749538,
-0.0834024921,
-0.037836466,
0.0109057315,
-0.0452540852,
-0.0469077788,
-0.0354470387,
0.0080823787,
0.0146264974,
-0.037179362,
-0.0400368012,
2.152351738e-34,
0.020207854,
-0.0210487135,
0.0391218551,
0.074170433,
0.0059163184,
-0.0124098565,
-0.0511958189,
0.01584097,
0.0425706245,
-0.0934426785,
-0.0318313465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17055v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17055v2 | Large Language Models Assume People are More Rational than We Really are | 2024-06-24T18:15:27 | 2024-07-01T17:29:54 | Ryan Liu, Jiayi Geng, Joshua C. Peterson, Ilia Sucholutsky, Thomas L. Griffiths | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | In order for AI systems to communicate effectively with people, they must
understand how we make decisions. However, people's decisions are not always
rational, so the implicit internal models of human decision-making in Large
Language Models (LLMs) must account for this. Previous empirical evidence seems
to suggest that these implicit models are accurate -- LLMs offer believable
proxies of human behavior, acting how we expect humans would in everyday
interactions. However, by comparing LLM behavior and predictions to a large
dataset of human decisions, we find that this is actually not the case: when
both simulating and predicting people's choices, a suite of cutting-edge LLMs
(GPT-4o & 4-Turbo, Llama-3-8B & 70B, Claude 3 Opus) assume that people are more
rational than we really are. Specifically, these models deviate from human
behavior and align more closely with a classic model of rational choice --
expected value theory. Interestingly, people also tend to assume that other
people are rational when interpreting their behavior. As a consequence, when we
compare the inferences that LLMs and people draw from the decisions of others
using another psychological dataset, we find that these inferences are highly
correlated. Thus, the implicit decision-making models of LLMs appear to be
aligned with the human expectation that other people will act rationally,
rather than with how people actually act. | [
0.0385977663,
0.0737768337,
-0.0314031318,
0.0222869366,
-0.0159362685,
0.0117931319,
-0.0306586213,
0.0184936337,
0.0466151759,
-0.0033445093,
-0.0376134366,
0.0112262955,
0.025265893,
0.0272083562,
0.0355590694,
-0.0258452296,
0.0126470597,
-0.0399466194,
0.0830207169,
-0.0421731882,
-0.0240119975,
-0.0043994128,
0.026051918,
0.0378216654,
0.0375001654,
0.0023203092,
-0.0141560547,
-0.0249347985,
0.0319423452,
-0.0304499958,
-0.0260413233,
0.0584567077,
0.0327387899,
0.0034343486,
0.0000021116,
-0.0633159578,
0.0388985761,
-0.0394587405,
-0.0275199525,
0.059086334,
-0.0025479223,
0.0270323586,
0.028029833,
-0.0059122336,
-0.0569892377,
0.052721709,
0.0000342245,
0.0519175939,
-0.001642331,
0.0194379631,
-0.0004162064,
-0.0216800161,
-0.0046297959,
-0.0327879488,
-0.0274976809,
-0.0601102486,
0.0552486405,
0.0157102272,
-0.0351619571,
0.0108643435,
0.0020659999,
-0.0168630537,
0.0112160854,
0.0019311721,
-0.0472114682,
0.0657700673,
0.0219730195,
-0.0395174325,
0.0000249812,
0.0583923534,
0.0272452924,
-0.0230801199,
0.0239307284,
-0.0202572346,
0.0162466764,
0.0125966556,
-0.0297109913,
0.0285857767,
0.0281447023,
0.0369763672,
0.0333767831,
0.0654920265,
0.0162133388,
0.04289129,
-0.0051961574,
0.0523064323,
-0.0193269998,
0.0020438056,
0.027665088,
0.0238174703,
-0.0689695701,
-0.0785885751,
-0.0609462261,
0.0044298796,
-0.0187791307,
0.0295213684,
-0.0199821219,
0.0550037734,
0.0216950923,
-0.0493211187,
-0.0164980609,
0.0523404665,
0.0707202777,
0.0211163498,
0.0175854377,
0.047095757,
-0.0177190267,
0.0102502974,
0.0011289564,
0.0355302021,
-0.0169301722,
-0.0105229411,
-0.0004259058,
0.0064150067,
-0.0242149308,
-0.0206158217,
-0.063772887,
-0.0191160906,
-0.0625255406,
0.029020166,
-0.0114997448,
0.0132222595,
-0.005213385,
-0.0360191055,
-0.0987323225,
-0.0094649997,
-0.0222871322,
0.0623785481,
-0.0043631569,
-0.0495484844,
0.0321039446,
-0.0122708166,
0.0027017461,
-0.0165256113,
0.0066818781,
0.082952328,
-0.0201132521,
-0.0106762573,
-0.0370581597,
-0.0166465305,
0.0070679942,
-0.0706999823,
-0.0243390761,
-0.0216682162,
0.0117793111,
0.0101797963,
-0.0042566392,
-0.0591802225,
0.0141558228,
-0.0005623174,
-0.0559522025,
0.0653687343,
0.0205441173,
0.0265566278,
0.0403878614,
0.0160434283,
-0.0095729819,
0.0342084579,
0.0446841121,
0.0433017574,
0.0269969199,
-0.0064775418,
0.0296480302,
0.0378000438,
-0.0162788983,
-0.0023744623,
-0.0440519527,
0.0245974399,
-0.0464322083,
0.0223770626,
0.067521356,
0.0579096973,
-0.0252872203,
-0.023976082,
0.1024419442,
0.070776172,
-0.0470251516,
0.0301614497,
0.0110830115,
0.0426756963,
0.0196327884,
-0.0281769391,
-0.0335215144,
0.0268066693,
-0.0097389286,
-0.0145153254,
0.0424843244,
-0.004333246,
-0.0276240557,
-0.0218634829,
0.0018770217,
-0.0330916904,
0.0539445579,
0.0243787766,
0.0211602952,
-0.0731501803,
-0.0247107279,
-0.0366908573,
0.0177982096,
0.0078517199,
-0.0386813171,
-0.0760090426,
0.0870590433,
0.06278117,
0.0142815122,
0.0409060046,
0.0521362312,
0.0115402816,
-0.0361864343,
0.0220225975,
0.081120491,
-0.0147213303,
-0.0274241976,
-0.0392725356,
-0.0017797136,
0.0268068742,
0.0154332062,
0.0295179673,
0.0313198753,
0.0306694061,
-0.0057393527,
-0.0216049328,
-0.0084857754,
0.0041903392,
-0.0537367836,
-0.0284875128,
-0.0534280464,
-0.0091754692,
0.043661382,
-0.018106686,
0.0258564893,
0.0152141573,
-0.0079844538,
0.0282699466,
-0.0456105582,
0.0332260877,
-0.0448610298,
0.0285915509,
-0.0087090069,
-0.0139441686,
-0.014848276,
-0.0041894172,
-0.012808932,
0.0117073245,
0.0315502845,
-0.0279600043,
0.0247402638,
-0.0154006155,
0.0226492472,
-0.0130344545,
0.019675998,
0.0046407506,
0.058722727,
-0.0180053934,
-0.0247465819,
0.0064481208,
-0.0045066318,
0.0099709183,
-0.0685215369,
0.0194686037,
-0.000200251,
0.0274413954,
0.0305042639,
0.0113667073,
-0.0027977882,
-0.0487690046,
-0.0078290366,
-0.0288770515,
-0.0619589724,
0.0273978617,
-0.0110011455,
-0.0054190387,
-0.0330246389,
-0.0225955192,
0.0247914121,
0.0023702101,
0.0231962819,
0.0194633529,
0.0345166996,
0.0259064604,
-0.0100284824,
-0.0106138205,
-0.0528819971,
0.003391464,
-0.0106252152,
0.0223912802,
0.0039475607,
0.0202513393,
-0.0232509337,
0.0166382696,
-0.0373820961,
0.0257392544,
-0.0376774855,
-0.056751918,
-0.0157997794,
0.0039028868,
0.0408966392,
0.0694292635,
0.0205881167,
0.0283915102,
0.040877901,
0.0347213149,
-0.0904825479,
-0.025986271,
-0.0492414832,
-0.0275364723,
-0.054388769,
-0.066942744,
-0.0006840195,
0.0949123278,
-0.0002491747,
0.0365127288,
-0.0551079847,
0.0888325721,
-0.0067815278,
-0.060396567,
-0.018856084,
-0.0342636406,
-0.009377243,
0.1083074808,
0.0066279932,
-0.0398367755,
0.0801846981,
0.0111588053,
0.0278545823,
0.0081554251,
0.0030652427,
-0.0014865696,
0.0447183028,
-0.0005079532,
-0.025135817,
0.0075020124,
0.0146632101,
-0.0409300551,
-0.0513575301,
-0.0096004689,
-0.050933253,
0.076082617,
-0.0613903366,
-0.006084363,
0.0263741501,
-0.0275897719,
-0.0147492466,
-0.0377602503,
-0.0966515988,
-0.0245203767,
0.0298815388,
-0.0665565506,
-0.0056139152,
-0.0340714343,
0.0372074619,
-0.017141927,
0.0031419604,
-0.0270065386,
0.0038637982,
-0.0235780627,
0.0588989034,
0.024917284,
0.0386424325,
-0.0586634502,
0.0643608421,
0.041142948,
-0.0194093734,
-0.002942543,
-0.0124799553,
-0.0133395446,
0.0120920409,
0.0321729518,
-0.0043568541,
0.089002952,
0.039792832,
-0.0061447276,
0.0068360711,
0.1008050516,
0.008207473,
-0.025259532,
0.0176786091,
-0.0507804044,
0.0371280462,
0.015729595,
0.0001631535,
-0.0256123673,
-0.0375580378,
0.0066069658,
0.019087838,
-0.0448340885,
-0.0406602919,
0.0146858227,
-0.1182162762,
0.0377071314,
-0.0072506792,
0.0409573354,
0.0111209042,
-0.0085544214,
0.0155292423,
-0.0447386876,
-0.0067167059,
-0.0055666976,
0.0151637439,
0.0118936216,
-0.0138949715,
-0.0556356981,
0.0048121004,
0.060424,
-0.0178837813,
0.020042222,
-0.0053063477,
0.0772586465,
-0.0180036016,
-0.0698893145,
-0.0339870788,
0.0108329207,
-0.008384279,
0.019562196,
0.0190866273,
-0.0045119794,
0.0248692539,
-0.0443896092,
0.0417214148,
0.0002898433,
-0.0241973531,
0.0077061211,
0.0422713123,
-0.0210548881,
-0.0870435461,
0.0152441896,
0.0324802436,
0.0012629435,
0.0842971206,
-0.0022769179,
-0.0446511358,
-0.0383339822,
-0.0222047865,
-0.0226996131,
0.0051646382,
-0.0787266716,
-0.0065946067,
0.0253435671,
-0.0228422023,
-0.0240572747,
-0.0604538359,
-0.0229797531,
-0.0326988213,
0.0087918397,
-0.0486549325,
0.0205337927,
-0.0031498761,
0.0080899298,
0.0115059009,
-0.043938566,
0.0001135622,
0.00772386,
0.0407630391,
0.0141777974,
-0.0670901164,
-0.0330196358,
0.0201773141,
-0.0022407996,
-0.0472044535,
0.0047391937,
0.0298716631,
0.0295566022,
0.0069561545,
0.0031069021,
-0.0423449986,
0.0019410138,
-0.02233213,
-0.0167186614,
0.0575451553,
0.0068257097,
0.0849253684,
0.0117043201,
0.0496841483,
-0.0048427391,
0.0453682356,
-0.016230071,
0.001504825,
-0.0587558858,
-0.0789617598,
0.0173365287,
-0.000534254,
0.0120744882,
-0.0013652297,
0.0163367633,
-0.014902981,
-0.0393523313,
-0.0161945429,
-0.0061604171,
-0.0045579569,
-0.0530005991,
0.0355446227,
0.0468649007,
-0.0237672515,
-0.0495116822,
-0.011583589,
-0.0017504517,
0.0332489125,
0.0083040819,
0.0222082641,
0.0427112058,
0.0299207568,
-0.0305055548,
0.0063614706,
0.0064900904,
-0.0323767215,
0.0664549172,
0.0203799419,
0.0790194348,
0.0195953716,
-0.0255535748,
0.0098191816,
0.0005226767,
-0.0347625017,
-0.120587863,
0.0461357906,
-0.0200512055,
-0.030210292,
-0.0229614023,
0.0413165279,
-0.0921607688,
0.0119497795,
-0.0128105227,
0.0189689249,
-0.0277064238,
-0.0246952083,
0.026524175,
-0.0022647758,
-0.0602612905,
0.0255701188,
0.0555663891,
-0.0052543106,
0.0143306097,
-0.0548293032,
-0.0379830338,
-0.0275207032,
-0.0301451646,
0.0081372866,
-0.0151046338,
-0.0332014151,
-0.0124334916,
-0.075397186,
-0.0493524596,
-0.027612621,
0.0319577977,
-0.0248393938,
-0.0718606189,
-0.0023970602,
0.0488949679,
-0.0149962632,
0.0184672978,
-0.0286756717,
0.0360820852,
-0.0717094466,
0.0071434584,
-0.0755755231,
-6.140591838e-33,
0.0022870491,
-0.023614727,
0.0101002101,
-0.0376796573,
0.0025094934,
-0.0096631777,
-0.0320084505,
0.0176097322,
-0.022642605,
0.0315737687,
-0.0128003424,
-0.0001578484,
0.0114187058,
-0.04222247,
0.054378923,
-0.0072184247,
0.018902773,
-0.0256428439,
-0.0155817559,
-0.0389413536,
0.0012079716,
-0.0248874202,
0.0281573962,
-0.0509471484,
0.029358184,
0.0097522847,
-0.023917919,
-0.0015381158,
-0.0091243619,
0.0134534249,
-0.0483935513,
-0.001737452,
0.0081869652,
-0.0392513201,
-0.0156726241,
0.0621713623,
0.0015667151,
0.003486655,
0.0340031721,
-0.0270241778,
-0.0250671972,
-0.0213703047,
0.0022399556,
0.0062785596,
-0.0899538472,
0.0199434292,
0.0254554525,
-0.0041099214,
0.038360171,
0.0437179543,
-0.0233768579,
0.0046601142,
-0.0262326188,
0.0290567856,
-0.0140386699,
0.0637521371,
-0.0315599702,
0.0524359792,
-0.0729525611,
0.0826627016,
-0.0025588444,
-0.0217742864,
0.0332204439,
-0.0314315185,
0.0396190882,
0.0695001334,
0.0532825068,
0.0001520849,
-0.0607044175,
-0.0036288435,
0.0274656899,
0.0647617579,
0.0220265146,
0.0588297322,
0.0013579418,
-0.0369539447,
-0.0257214624,
0.0177557077,
0.0161916092,
0.011763053,
0.0655514151,
0.0272814631,
-0.0800292939,
-0.0367920585,
-0.0034494027,
-0.0245244838,
-0.0207807291,
-0.0217367765,
0.0049352823,
-0.0021853882,
0.0221947785,
-0.015480726,
0.0374579057,
-0.0399537496,
-0.0146995895,
-0.0129960869,
-0.0132825021,
0.022180438,
-0.0000234164,
0.0055564609,
-0.0605192333,
-0.037999142,
-0.0198700856,
-0.0008046618,
0.0146866664,
0.036729563,
-0.0255452208,
-0.0005163745,
-0.0031763345,
-0.0129112834,
-0.0030154698,
-0.0093320152,
0.0115491031,
-0.0232099351,
0.0505156741,
0.0022863573,
-0.0043916912,
-0.0356135406,
-0.0134362625,
0.0071547707,
-0.005820787,
-0.0458712615,
0.0109660234,
0.0187120438,
-0.0211750083,
-0.0128423302,
-0.0589000434,
-0.0116184391,
0.0148480162,
-0.0178544372,
-0.0197324101,
-0.0005194434,
2.787e-7,
-0.0100437868,
0.0499862656,
-0.0220371708,
0.0055646817,
0.0186044797,
0.1043663323,
-0.0019762176,
-0.0033132825,
0.0316941254,
-0.0257875323,
0.0441198684,
0.0186154172,
0.0409106389,
-0.0126843583,
-0.0306200106,
-0.0118100736,
-0.0568548068,
-0.0296330955,
-0.0061929398,
-0.021764338,
0.0237018038,
0.0416769311,
0.0430844463,
0.0151567254,
-0.0192078203,
0.0197603814,
0.0507317223,
-0.0692238659,
-0.0260741916,
-0.000899496,
0.0146039417,
0.0072675985,
-0.0075230626,
0.0143262241,
0.0007026748,
0.0163284969,
0.0013210415,
0.0805867165,
-0.0063777147,
-0.0296615139,
-0.0159648862,
-0.0110519463,
0.0122044999,
-0.0467029773,
0.044770807,
-0.0841292292,
-0.0793844312,
0.0017856687,
-0.0134988464,
-0.0134013342,
0.0044838912,
0.0068273381,
-0.00012879,
-0.0005084254,
0.0160956252,
0.0082499646,
0.0262838919,
-0.0290635489,
-0.0138720525,
-0.0045956769,
-0.0625016093,
-0.0732959509,
-0.0476978496,
0.0678722858,
0.0258033574,
-0.0264242701,
0.0074137296,
2.086683159e-34,
0.0435235687,
0.0475350246,
0.006445684,
-0.0076841405,
0.0670491233,
0.026140444,
0.0447177067,
0.0418433063,
0.0731809288,
-0.0532293245,
-0.0136686089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17038v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17038v1 | modeLing: A Novel Dataset for Testing Linguistic Reasoning in Language Models | 2024-06-24T18:00:59 | 2024-06-24T18:00:59 | Nathan A. Chi, Teodor Malchev, Riley Kong, Ryan A. Chi, Lucas Huang, Ethan A. Chi, R. Thomas McCoy, Dragomir Radev | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce modeLing, a novel benchmark of Linguistics Olympiad-style
puzzles which tests few-shot reasoning in AI systems. Solving these puzzles
necessitates inferring aspects of a language's grammatical structure from a
small number of examples. Such puzzles provide a natural testbed for language
models, as they require compositional generalization and few-shot inductive
reasoning. Consisting solely of new puzzles written specifically for this work,
modeLing has no risk of appearing in the training data of existing AI systems:
this ameliorates the risk of data leakage, a potential confounder for many
prior evaluations of reasoning. Evaluating several large open source language
models and GPT on our benchmark, we observe non-negligible accuracy,
demonstrating few-shot emergent reasoning ability which cannot merely be
attributed to shallow memorization. However, imperfect model performance
suggests that modeLing can be used to measure further progress in linguistic
reasoning. | [
0.0173161905,
0.05699642,
-0.028526498,
0.0563440956,
-0.0802796185,
0.0398511887,
0.0283368118,
-0.0015547896,
-0.0163036603,
-0.025317369,
0.03034712,
-0.0090703396,
-0.0032398757,
0.0062278723,
0.025686495,
-0.0078941956,
0.0629426688,
-0.0356086493,
0.0085168732,
-0.0166437384,
-0.0048142471,
0.0359886698,
-0.0157578532,
0.0373144858,
-0.0093704341,
-0.0108006587,
-0.0345088355,
-0.0164600443,
-0.0202246495,
-0.0276040994,
-0.0357779488,
0.0392280221,
0.0174667798,
0.0527460203,
0.0000020348,
-0.0644717142,
-0.0046839365,
-0.0061708158,
-0.0677513257,
-0.0277875364,
-0.022091981,
-0.0057792673,
-0.0109147849,
-0.0138497427,
-0.0466194414,
-0.006587917,
0.0335899964,
0.020820491,
0.0497290529,
0.0689785108,
0.0057304972,
-0.0489868037,
0.0100444295,
0.0035142531,
0.0354653522,
-0.0752460584,
0.001563352,
0.0102276793,
0.0164089296,
-0.0099443719,
-0.0298717879,
0.0220291913,
0.057280276,
0.0284544285,
-0.0527567156,
0.0367095284,
-0.0600502789,
-0.0346074626,
-0.0025722201,
0.0549136549,
0.0026316168,
-0.0494673923,
-0.0179425851,
-0.0102457516,
0.001826436,
0.000040016,
-0.0433823578,
0.0368012227,
-0.0008991598,
0.0259453394,
0.0535088256,
-0.0202083141,
0.0164962541,
0.0111354506,
-0.0278658513,
0.1081044972,
0.0012223906,
-0.0339992642,
-0.0017561662,
-0.0114550889,
-0.0264611673,
-0.0531654656,
-0.0282684695,
0.044493366,
-0.0193704292,
0.0471652411,
-0.0129551403,
-0.0268219635,
0.0080839312,
-0.0028619876,
0.0374394581,
0.0346329473,
0.0229137167,
0.0893279091,
-0.0198331513,
0.0804033875,
0.0136731984,
0.0502760112,
-0.0229824521,
-0.0276428349,
-0.0671496019,
-0.0171066709,
-0.0268636905,
0.0559462868,
0.0373662822,
-0.006272098,
-0.0226466004,
-0.0301558636,
-0.0027424502,
0.0532904826,
0.0065638549,
-0.0054686982,
-0.0198355094,
-0.0449943505,
-0.0347746909,
-0.0121078156,
-0.0759005323,
0.0170091055,
0.0189688243,
-0.0603596233,
-0.059902586,
-0.0235721041,
0.02143557,
-0.0416727439,
0.0189274829,
0.0203295834,
0.0152809164,
-0.0421389937,
-0.0265175886,
-0.0326822549,
-0.0161695201,
-0.1044563651,
0.0088747274,
-0.0784611776,
0.0495910607,
-0.0093512842,
-0.0233996883,
-0.0615094565,
-0.001020971,
0.0290802699,
-0.0341384523,
0.0737931952,
-0.0001234182,
0.010369244,
-0.0183252208,
0.0054585943,
0.0152151985,
0.0832834393,
0.0495012254,
0.0072335429,
0.0243072901,
0.0087109292,
0.0110285012,
0.0232524779,
0.0245182831,
-0.0193826351,
0.0003233794,
0.0169260222,
-0.0130251693,
0.01980244,
-0.0592261814,
0.0381539427,
-0.0018337963,
-0.0260198805,
0.0290790144,
0.0783098638,
-0.0026932177,
-0.021657845,
0.06059983,
-0.0235924181,
0.0188546591,
-0.0021660789,
-0.0437420458,
0.0453205407,
-0.0256615411,
0.0004310536,
-0.0126720183,
0.0365992375,
-0.0287631564,
-0.0469349213,
-0.0280347839,
0.009108915,
-0.0054760873,
0.0128728719,
0.0884959772,
0.0432582311,
-0.0221865624,
0.0122039793,
0.0386229157,
-0.0415948257,
-0.0295057688,
-0.0547903292,
0.0434289314,
0.0144848777,
0.0592726097,
-0.0221142415,
-0.0424187183,
0.0045479708,
0.0324518941,
0.0382536501,
0.0368947349,
0.0098202107,
0.0161078162,
-0.0409062617,
0.0029444052,
-0.0232441723,
0.0280434601,
0.0209806152,
0.0075665964,
0.0087919123,
-0.0147793526,
-0.0292895455,
0.0138025023,
0.0474162772,
-0.0476613939,
-0.0192997884,
-0.0145341875,
0.0178715084,
0.0093285227,
0.0004191928,
0.0095968619,
0.0057446915,
0.0060046627,
-0.0114466157,
-0.0251038857,
0.0310053378,
-0.0300609544,
-0.0540858954,
0.0246776193,
-0.0350931138,
-0.0202765726,
0.0135113969,
-0.0492736474,
-0.0374953896,
0.0685554743,
-0.0147311194,
0.0080591189,
-0.0319905281,
0.0223002397,
-0.0126029598,
-0.0078945141,
-0.0182640571,
0.0752315819,
-0.0083934311,
0.0194685943,
-0.0309699904,
0.0137656042,
0.0418903045,
-0.0627010837,
-0.0307115521,
0.0250608232,
-0.0280258209,
-0.0254482273,
0.004461138,
0.0054101576,
-0.0477811433,
-0.0096621467,
-0.0539175645,
0.0243236646,
-0.0065756463,
0.0130903963,
0.0070532644,
-0.0134383524,
0.0041192896,
0.006727274,
-0.016552018,
0.0068323314,
0.0248429608,
0.0117752282,
0.0372399762,
0.0033685784,
-0.0137214297,
-0.0218569227,
-0.0121790562,
-0.0644388199,
0.0425946377,
0.0121476566,
0.0335990004,
0.001000742,
0.0242922083,
-0.0403105207,
0.005034293,
-0.0063827015,
-0.0420166291,
0.042598892,
-0.0278249681,
-0.0124960244,
0.0963460058,
-0.0432329178,
0.0309952796,
0.0351006687,
-0.029586304,
-0.0435835719,
0.0317488313,
-0.0230346303,
-0.0144870831,
-0.018583864,
-0.0413040482,
-0.0341264531,
0.0797998011,
0.0093954867,
0.0004712254,
-0.0767680705,
0.1013939902,
-0.0225152709,
-0.0228485428,
-0.0483619906,
0.0235712044,
0.0037914901,
0.0458086394,
-0.0497778952,
0.0024125869,
0.0941468477,
-0.0219824724,
0.000618804,
-0.0165401604,
0.0065483837,
-0.0307758339,
0.0844092071,
0.0110097807,
0.0057278033,
0.0512169264,
0.0170170702,
-0.0774970129,
-0.0042429948,
0.0296069551,
-0.0165872127,
0.0077065774,
-0.0607440323,
-0.0031591565,
0.0078221457,
-0.0585673749,
-0.0239880644,
-0.0004501912,
-0.0500277355,
0.0212595984,
-0.0154207954,
0.0049890382,
-0.0120527158,
0.0029265992,
0.0138016138,
0.0196956769,
-0.0093620112,
-0.012195305,
-0.0346520171,
0.005490114,
0.0434838049,
0.0279611219,
0.0072372053,
-0.0196086261,
0.0485108197,
0.0252946056,
0.0488090366,
0.0312408749,
-0.0348335057,
0.0377319269,
-0.0213025101,
-0.005530355,
-0.0020861209,
0.0116264001,
0.0277322643,
-0.083836548,
-0.0360202193,
0.1072540134,
0.0606615916,
0.0094003836,
0.0110264076,
-0.000145099,
0.0285787489,
0.0416533947,
0.0381199345,
-0.0956872553,
-0.0458416529,
0.0421497934,
-0.0176835638,
-0.0260240287,
-0.0590588637,
-0.0280341543,
-0.1329597682,
0.0399577543,
-0.012442993,
-0.0390968435,
0.0034993801,
-0.033232186,
-0.0198035054,
-0.0313119851,
-0.0227069892,
0.0153365163,
0.0402299277,
0.0005900057,
-0.0285648778,
-0.0059287697,
-0.0390315205,
0.0582552627,
-0.0254524704,
0.076413177,
0.0411894582,
0.0368586592,
-0.0178433247,
-0.0257016625,
0.0064883628,
0.0026942766,
-0.010955615,
0.007725786,
0.039729394,
0.0204965938,
-0.0256090946,
0.0016898726,
0.0180581305,
-0.0418241248,
-0.033682391,
0.0186771061,
0.0873860791,
-0.0068191509,
-0.0556048118,
0.0006419474,
0.0059299194,
-0.0459426977,
0.0833718106,
0.0363275111,
-0.0047090291,
-0.0539915115,
-0.0579460673,
-0.0258631092,
-0.0770661682,
-0.0421844758,
0.0522501245,
0.0507980995,
0.0003123421,
-0.0644298941,
-0.0506878309,
0.0383531936,
0.0240597278,
-0.0036258418,
-0.0213789586,
-0.0029255056,
0.0225089081,
-0.0151304873,
0.0123698879,
-0.0347789675,
0.0032165521,
-0.0163778532,
0.0009015962,
0.0228664614,
-0.0299660936,
-0.0436453633,
-0.0061013168,
-0.0892454311,
-0.0538321808,
0.0028899063,
0.0801568255,
0.0254827179,
0.0141036045,
-0.0312263258,
-0.0320849903,
0.0040377541,
0.0220257882,
0.0004561224,
0.0104587367,
0.0121227251,
-0.0321283042,
0.0111771477,
0.041645024,
-0.02307285,
0.0344236568,
0.0379741266,
0.0412410088,
-0.0269977804,
0.0580842681,
0.0638571233,
0.0231237691,
0.0264881551,
0.0080192285,
-0.0311419051,
-0.0120814256,
0.0296049137,
-0.0404381715,
-0.0348059349,
-0.0282873679,
-0.0034315803,
0.0064375857,
-0.010137436,
-0.0021560714,
-0.0172204711,
0.0085735861,
0.0438282043,
-0.0045795036,
-0.0299297981,
0.0586427636,
0.0177694745,
-0.0217645876,
-0.0013272116,
-0.0018734728,
0.0522779226,
-0.0462195799,
0.0523223691,
-0.0358962044,
0.0426116362,
0.0286010671,
-0.0138998162,
-0.0006357239,
0.0060535809,
-0.0639228076,
-0.0251561832,
0.0243440755,
0.0093024811,
0.0720143616,
-0.0170739591,
-0.0004405355,
-0.0270728711,
0.0096896077,
0.0045960839,
0.0010860139,
0.0217184089,
-0.0399739705,
0.0192187801,
0.0492062829,
0.0050310385,
-0.0084378226,
0.0569688343,
0.0026516451,
0.0540430807,
0.0104749007,
0.0377764478,
-0.031386409,
-0.0306447931,
-0.0098898504,
0.0305559319,
0.0116189783,
0.0280766301,
-0.0612188019,
-0.0824810266,
-0.0140942056,
0.0402154215,
0.0313540064,
0.0458749793,
0.0279856622,
0.0681780949,
-0.0263364222,
-0.0357797779,
-0.0240483936,
-0.0328422785,
-0.0429507233,
-0.0212522764,
-0.0014360945,
-6.297154829e-33,
-0.0319825411,
-0.0084973788,
0.043285694,
-0.0046121036,
0.0430721231,
-0.0400274768,
-0.0491764359,
-0.0085348096,
-0.0595222227,
0.0249447189,
-0.0323488675,
0.0237055495,
0.0012310898,
0.0151799265,
0.0027921617,
-0.0234907046,
-0.0162195191,
-0.0108942324,
-0.0361405984,
-0.0085362401,
0.0228275973,
0.0000779225,
0.0606603026,
-0.0108512659,
-0.0051163733,
0.0124301482,
-0.0376294777,
0.0316548683,
-0.0766412318,
0.0518376008,
0.0066137523,
0.0015775588,
0.0322138742,
-0.0312319286,
0.0227975752,
-0.0310385432,
-0.0418900996,
-0.0375071242,
0.0197991412,
0.0063375221,
-0.0362805463,
-0.0449200384,
0.0153142186,
-0.0267829895,
-0.0169666559,
-0.0090954853,
0.0226277299,
-0.0112138037,
0.0327573344,
0.0256454106,
-0.0495356619,
0.0027920867,
-0.0443440787,
-0.0224893782,
0.022324862,
0.0098532252,
-0.0105520552,
0.0202361178,
-0.0228362326,
0.0264607593,
0.0051043392,
0.0041278135,
0.079081744,
-0.03169984,
-0.0022810928,
0.0638863444,
0.0345185548,
-0.0034870226,
-0.0361752547,
0.0335762501,
0.0562729388,
0.0565586574,
0.0841102973,
0.0438038111,
0.0392251313,
0.0272461399,
-0.0761724412,
-0.0122268926,
0.0117590334,
0.0643361509,
0.0258826036,
-0.0026991765,
-0.044186119,
-0.0050617033,
-0.0569007248,
-0.0064834468,
-0.0509635806,
-0.0213417951,
0.0432369411,
-0.0118276188,
-0.02333102,
-0.0395542942,
0.0317478105,
-0.0492444374,
0.0034206002,
0.0178199578,
0.0022066608,
0.0036170951,
0.0017944115,
0.0475949161,
-0.0467154644,
-0.0056012124,
-0.0061083017,
0.0379553735,
0.0444845855,
0.0096912384,
0.0446468741,
0.0362404622,
-0.0309433304,
-0.0174170416,
-0.0563530065,
-0.017090207,
0.0023720597,
-0.0197375659,
0.015811393,
0.0440153256,
-0.0076864702,
0.0176922586,
0.038908124,
-0.0125019336,
-0.0461376756,
0.0284444038,
-0.0260766633,
0.0106274178,
-0.0123778069,
-0.022366602,
-0.0377988517,
0.0089564007,
0.014606948,
-0.0279380698,
0.0017840427,
0.0481372885,
2.738e-7,
0.0231240671,
0.0860555843,
-0.0087398281,
0.0602545552,
0.0147988768,
0.0293215197,
-0.0558197871,
-0.0237670951,
-0.0135532115,
-0.0318850838,
-0.002710029,
0.0789315626,
0.0442049131,
0.0434442833,
-0.0959612504,
0.0600249879,
-0.0485908464,
-0.0358314924,
-0.0736272857,
-0.0005757609,
0.0640295222,
0.1077617332,
0.045348268,
0.0083858119,
-0.0004874094,
-0.065090701,
0.0373675041,
0.0198928751,
-0.0139613803,
0.0201147012,
-0.0238273237,
0.0395377055,
0.0031611586,
0.0206020921,
-0.0044627772,
0.018966727,
0.0096328259,
0.0282722358,
-0.0338704437,
-0.0227956232,
-0.041927781,
-0.0204026774,
-0.0097954571,
-0.0568355322,
0.1131417006,
-0.0749365464,
-0.0428262837,
-0.0165495668,
0.0035621047,
-0.0040836819,
0.0156257283,
-0.0058375495,
-0.0192195792,
0.0022039446,
0.0157007221,
-0.0239493046,
0.019865267,
-0.0738669261,
-0.0116404891,
0.0122760991,
-0.0056189811,
-0.0231508091,
-0.0186294802,
-0.0183957517,
0.0045475545,
-0.0498341359,
-0.0278103407,
2.517040136e-34,
0.0270162262,
-0.0104376813,
0.0320809856,
0.0291902125,
0.0459988303,
-0.0088940067,
-0.0169268437,
0.0097884024,
0.0094023151,
-0.0685849562,
-0.0207046289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16858v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16858v2 | EAGLE-2: Faster Inference of Language Models with Dynamic Draft Trees | 2024-06-24T17:59:11 | 2024-06-30T15:03:25 | Yuhui Li, Fangyun Wei, Chao Zhang, Hongyang Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Inference with modern Large Language Models (LLMs) is expensive and
time-consuming, and speculative sampling has proven to be an effective
solution. Most speculative sampling methods such as EAGLE use a static draft
tree, implicitly assuming that the acceptance rate of draft tokens depends only
on their position. Interestingly, we found that the acceptance rate of draft
tokens is also context-dependent. In this paper, building upon EAGLE, we
propose EAGLE-2, which introduces a new technique of context-aware dynamic
draft tree into drafting modeling. This improvement leverages the fact that the
draft model of EAGLE is well-calibrated: the confidence scores from the draft
model approximate acceptance rates with small errors. We conducted extensive
evaluations on three series of LLMs and six tasks, with EAGLE-2 achieving
speedup ratios 3.05x-4.26x, which is 20%-40% faster than EAGLE-1. EAGLE-2 also
ensures that the distribution of the generated text remains unchanged, making
it a lossless acceleration algorithm. | [
0.03531982,
0.0390879437,
-0.0232707486,
0.005360825,
-0.0694986433,
-0.0198682453,
-0.0093342485,
0.025522612,
-0.0310155954,
-0.0655159503,
0.0008296489,
-0.0994509682,
0.0209375098,
0.0180893186,
0.0007595746,
-0.038273748,
0.0082124658,
-0.0833779201,
0.0058900905,
0.0004042152,
0.0074257934,
0.027184587,
-0.0106830215,
0.0499439202,
0.0061025983,
-0.0440917462,
-0.0471351929,
0.0025276404,
-0.0221962389,
-0.0185018722,
-0.0308097433,
0.0809251294,
0.0010016377,
0.0523296781,
0.0000020924,
-0.0401261933,
-0.0310661439,
-0.0086085862,
-0.0229109395,
0.0041682818,
0.0981281176,
0.0114050601,
-0.0394532196,
0.0347974151,
0.0017087082,
0.0110012805,
0.0300038736,
-0.0111833988,
0.0024439767,
0.0398662239,
-0.0127965501,
0.0161246117,
-0.0195175093,
-0.0065169912,
-0.0455868617,
-0.0269625168,
0.023450911,
-0.0259768348,
-0.0026723202,
-0.0023170738,
0.0143043008,
0.0083448822,
0.0119198076,
-0.0693097785,
-0.0393645652,
0.0476434678,
-0.0157325584,
-0.0091687823,
-0.0057399264,
0.0380675755,
-0.0171103887,
-0.0364424586,
0.0016938763,
-0.0294120796,
0.0005736124,
0.0155642927,
-0.0695574805,
0.0221088249,
-0.0473448932,
-0.004754418,
0.0166533254,
-0.0132560926,
0.0072760875,
-0.023236705,
0.0097528957,
0.0854371563,
0.0376602896,
-0.0125096207,
-0.0146237891,
0.0032759218,
0.0051019173,
-0.0960954204,
0.025736928,
0.0154824266,
-0.0259047803,
0.0248080902,
-0.0757775679,
-0.0707393214,
0.0300993193,
-0.0276537593,
0.0528156981,
0.029131664,
-0.0059796018,
0.0098095657,
-0.0188174117,
0.0079492601,
0.0113168368,
0.0044061891,
-0.0448772199,
0.0072810254,
-0.0064765788,
-0.0156154828,
-0.0678809583,
0.026789099,
-0.0405760631,
-0.0408565961,
-0.0439488739,
0.0465975441,
0.0158326998,
-0.0104885809,
0.0414204486,
-0.023811968,
-0.044961039,
-0.0026684641,
0.0351624973,
-0.0165486075,
0.0155684687,
0.0268053897,
0.000025834,
-0.0284966826,
-0.0006509894,
0.016291162,
0.0155082494,
-0.0178163461,
-0.0349094458,
0.0743266866,
-0.0160360262,
-0.0055499878,
-0.0368272513,
-0.0229962319,
-0.0256082676,
-0.036249321,
-0.0161122773,
-0.1117853969,
0.0074725486,
0.023154337,
-0.0179371219,
-0.019870529,
-0.013961439,
0.0353902057,
-0.0115521671,
0.0254870299,
-0.0216217078,
0.0337543562,
0.0037227524,
-0.0238050576,
-0.0312136579,
0.1093329713,
0.052096054,
0.0527156182,
0.0471460558,
0.0159945916,
-0.0021203933,
0.1083205268,
0.0016723195,
0.0009510449,
0.0023771389,
-0.0307999998,
-0.0131984362,
0.012722387,
0.0437993594,
0.0296081919,
-0.0332584903,
-0.0184426606,
0.0571748242,
0.0647076741,
0.0510335453,
-0.0056919074,
0.0687368512,
0.0242374483,
0.0218970012,
-0.0063262014,
-0.0465182327,
-0.0093578342,
-0.0287114158,
0.0469455831,
-0.0192646123,
0.0265186951,
0.0241384823,
0.0057471017,
-0.0340523347,
0.0123474449,
-0.0370048098,
-0.0038236356,
0.0598796755,
0.0082402527,
-0.0321717486,
0.0570569001,
0.0065873191,
-0.0344722904,
-0.0308893975,
-0.0262840167,
0.0128730563,
0.0350476727,
0.0455011576,
-0.0040872237,
-0.0300001483,
-0.0000777641,
0.0163831543,
0.0481653772,
0.0370317809,
-0.0430664904,
0.0218607839,
-0.0154366158,
-0.0173378214,
0.0389287025,
0.011374807,
0.033735767,
0.0528714471,
-0.0008950309,
0.0147981513,
-0.0806019604,
-0.0288998298,
0.0326301344,
-0.0108311102,
0.0136284167,
-0.0082715582,
-0.0040324731,
0.032980714,
0.0100469263,
-0.0291621331,
0.0190833993,
0.0087331673,
-0.0300740805,
-0.0165594444,
0.0510429256,
-0.024839025,
-0.0243603066,
0.0459616482,
0.012900291,
-0.0243960265,
-0.0083856732,
-0.0272119306,
-0.0442107059,
-0.0278807767,
-0.0176726189,
0.0643286929,
-0.0337829515,
0.0440868326,
-0.0131232589,
-0.0383567438,
-0.0093948962,
0.0729914829,
-0.0165422838,
0.0123101687,
0.0514350645,
0.0415949151,
0.0081510032,
-0.0339020155,
-0.0228071511,
0.004515904,
-0.023243241,
-0.0193762463,
0.0174203329,
0.0185436253,
-0.0236883219,
-0.013721277,
-0.1075837389,
0.024901662,
-0.0337672532,
0.0462352745,
0.0363062806,
0.0141205089,
-0.0410146564,
-0.00270274,
-0.0049353591,
-0.0284861494,
0.0023415589,
0.0375659727,
0.0106272073,
-0.0240651574,
-0.0018206876,
-0.0383096188,
0.0012410012,
-0.0234192889,
0.0235508773,
0.0236143526,
-0.0346874036,
-0.0423461236,
0.0617175624,
0.0086914953,
0.0082210461,
0.0018934822,
-0.0152697666,
-0.0015221158,
-0.050912194,
0.0297411829,
0.0316264965,
0.0067342645,
-0.0099187111,
0.0351748466,
0.005179388,
-0.0467306562,
-0.0221310779,
0.0116665298,
0.0362206288,
-0.0101012476,
-0.0397954285,
0.0005583867,
0.0850029588,
0.0179359671,
0.0015147044,
-0.0295508802,
0.0081298454,
-0.0276935119,
0.005877004,
-0.0249179546,
-0.0187604949,
-0.0456165001,
0.0387480631,
-0.0465441011,
-0.0660660192,
0.0603055805,
-0.0792304203,
-0.0064928485,
-0.0170962475,
0.0175705217,
-0.0098199062,
0.0787046477,
0.0277420394,
-0.0042407867,
0.0090829208,
-0.0269063823,
-0.052958101,
0.0578288175,
0.0383643471,
-0.0290824063,
0.043387875,
-0.0595675111,
0.0481459573,
-0.0324439183,
-0.0114132576,
-0.0243689995,
-0.0152471364,
-0.0473588929,
0.0240373258,
0.0249719825,
-0.047191646,
0.0194259044,
0.0454845428,
-0.02681306,
0.0862902328,
-0.0123282811,
0.0022748809,
-0.0155760879,
0.0498515666,
0.0838098675,
-0.030028956,
0.0048024575,
-0.0448393933,
0.0393535197,
0.0595936738,
0.0829144269,
0.038135767,
-0.0308356173,
-0.0259540901,
0.0150269764,
-0.0338070393,
0.0106255654,
0.0394430384,
0.0395632759,
-0.0348886997,
0.003497195,
0.1211011782,
0.0212456379,
-0.0585485399,
-0.004393233,
-0.019179726,
0.0639772415,
0.0092739919,
0.0318937637,
-0.0742430463,
-0.0335120857,
0.0508780442,
0.0326957665,
-0.0196384359,
-0.035973426,
0.0054526515,
-0.1335404068,
0.0326202959,
-0.0305728093,
-0.0529342704,
0.0503843799,
-0.0250973143,
0.0437484905,
0.0149496729,
-0.0267910473,
0.0187227428,
-0.020144457,
0.0063071307,
-0.0027574569,
-0.0718093961,
-0.0235765483,
-0.0015884632,
-0.0256068744,
0.0287196003,
0.0199101754,
0.0315158702,
0.0179389287,
0.0389287658,
0.0551183186,
-0.0246997923,
-0.0122067863,
-0.0148223694,
0.0323813409,
0.0147946179,
0.0354609005,
-0.0112080146,
0.0303729717,
-0.0174464025,
-0.0120182224,
-0.0072631352,
0.0356663354,
-0.0159683973,
-0.0172823668,
-0.0203668606,
-0.0011187027,
0.0204672292,
0.0557027906,
0.0490977094,
-0.0249762926,
-0.0373640805,
-0.0477515087,
-0.0094314255,
-0.0940906703,
-0.0131754121,
0.0124135222,
0.0133166723,
-0.0092867259,
-0.0696135089,
-0.0102555016,
0.0493009835,
0.0660981983,
0.0112367887,
0.0553644337,
-0.0066394443,
-0.0324399211,
-0.045946721,
0.022563098,
-0.0224850383,
0.0316643789,
-0.0403517075,
-0.0103241578,
0.0226808377,
0.0022341604,
-0.035562925,
0.039004799,
-0.1296601593,
-0.0817123204,
0.0135422722,
0.0419446342,
0.0285591595,
0.0380648077,
-0.0328033343,
-0.03056903,
0.0452586114,
-0.0051802057,
0.0119284419,
0.0103956098,
-0.0260326155,
-0.0093826754,
-0.0147691444,
0.0340362266,
-0.0448296443,
0.0024836098,
0.0210454836,
0.0326128304,
-0.0068972935,
-0.052863434,
-0.0006596296,
0.0267873909,
-0.016857069,
-0.0263185501,
-0.007817667,
-0.0311594959,
0.0228912253,
-0.0297467243,
-0.0121774003,
-0.0515589416,
0.0204129908,
-0.0439624824,
-0.0282834265,
0.0003917477,
0.0146457311,
-0.0203922838,
0.0619708411,
-0.018451035,
0.0043804487,
0.0445672162,
0.0403385088,
0.0627578348,
-0.0284060389,
0.009097795,
-0.0016866436,
-0.0353612155,
0.0365209021,
-0.0098959897,
0.0416733399,
0.0305161048,
-0.0196894668,
0.0148537727,
0.0229372717,
-0.0646605641,
-0.0555924699,
-0.0570852123,
0.0542669222,
0.0541736633,
-0.028875228,
0.0487430878,
-0.0404608212,
0.0210681316,
-0.0162388198,
0.0406464599,
0.0243225638,
-0.0547199398,
0.0154432803,
0.0057529882,
0.0059540919,
0.0379405096,
0.0886391476,
0.0245333593,
0.0404721051,
-0.007286936,
-0.0159597583,
-0.0086839097,
-0.0145398239,
-0.0015499485,
0.0342015997,
-0.0303509291,
-0.0097444411,
-0.0713745281,
-0.0608717687,
0.050855726,
0.0227923635,
-0.0079659075,
-0.0175422952,
0.0168460403,
0.0668506473,
0.0031836948,
-0.0323039405,
-0.0433701389,
0.0084810117,
-0.01397835,
-0.0279032625,
-0.0466047935,
-5.788718992e-33,
-0.0476012267,
-0.0584780611,
0.002310503,
-0.0039511751,
-0.048293259,
-0.0064124586,
-0.0461220443,
-0.0083965659,
0.0468087271,
-0.0120966956,
-0.0342253745,
0.0195122492,
0.0232615359,
0.0261398312,
0.0178546757,
0.0407879464,
0.0516555943,
-0.0200387053,
-0.0580883622,
-0.0096989218,
0.0225860663,
0.0227940381,
0.0235419739,
-0.0125461109,
0.0183801893,
-0.0355398059,
0.0068025053,
0.0067362124,
0.0073337778,
0.050317239,
0.0104908459,
-0.0053850245,
0.0236314759,
-0.0122599071,
-0.0230979845,
0.021618586,
-0.0405604988,
-0.0126877325,
0.0345445275,
0.0209297761,
0.0159335136,
-0.0033707612,
0.0210429244,
-0.0151894372,
0.0153489346,
-0.0045883018,
0.0133834286,
-0.0006621717,
-0.0573442467,
-0.054779835,
-0.063157998,
0.0488765389,
0.0253566317,
-0.0074565094,
0.0070486963,
0.0569980517,
0.0173700098,
-0.008858934,
-0.0491613671,
-0.0020146822,
-0.013087594,
0.0439883024,
0.0533503927,
0.0162755195,
0.0055725104,
0.0388764068,
-0.0190345421,
0.0006103135,
-0.0280251876,
-0.0192639492,
0.0435718559,
-0.0010164566,
0.0014950366,
0.0216922779,
0.0377383679,
0.0152297653,
-0.005979063,
0.0367244706,
0.0336782075,
0.0248656124,
0.0440552235,
0.0012214134,
0.0075760074,
-0.0210132506,
-0.0549381413,
-0.0325710736,
-0.0166999996,
-0.0270657353,
0.0452426672,
0.0031024104,
-0.027886739,
-0.0300152395,
0.0610960647,
-0.0155128269,
-0.0243173297,
-0.004780123,
-0.0128694009,
0.0710919499,
-0.0364105105,
0.0372085758,
-0.0067997035,
-0.0188765787,
0.0011145551,
0.0246245936,
0.0177578535,
0.0192078017,
-0.0000051164,
0.0041144025,
-0.049101565,
0.0170392245,
-0.0295786466,
0.0239442494,
-0.017533375,
0.0596041344,
0.0542312227,
-0.0133929439,
0.0221164376,
0.0007671526,
0.0391349345,
0.0186206605,
-0.0375278592,
0.0042108954,
-0.0185966361,
0.0187885016,
-0.0296294857,
-0.000481797,
-0.0149698341,
-0.0010257091,
0.0037684173,
-0.0348203368,
0.0066553117,
0.0299337842,
2.563e-7,
0.0612519085,
0.0065948623,
0.0277987234,
0.0199157167,
0.0274639428,
0.0032414433,
-0.0215969719,
-0.0120093068,
0.0493532196,
0.0083445301,
-0.0048273401,
-0.014610569,
0.0703401789,
0.04398866,
-0.1463595331,
-0.0047253724,
-0.0602357686,
0.0121246148,
-0.0384184271,
-0.0023274631,
-0.0109987548,
0.0683677942,
-0.0350531749,
-0.0344992429,
-0.0193567146,
-0.0534072332,
0.042716939,
0.0064341002,
0.0069675087,
0.0195504557,
0.0442842469,
-0.0272854734,
-0.0006366146,
0.0163530521,
-0.0301537402,
0.0062467349,
0.0122531531,
0.0438939184,
-0.0182977859,
0.0526513942,
0.0215478167,
-0.0480030663,
0.0060801408,
-0.0359020382,
0.0581999607,
-0.0467166714,
0.026012551,
-0.0881417766,
0.0247949213,
-0.0205829106,
-0.0582027137,
-0.0109134121,
0.0213678386,
0.0674924999,
0.0225248318,
-0.0475003347,
0.0034214954,
-0.0596736595,
-0.0656172857,
-0.0184857585,
-0.0362977646,
-0.0293416884,
-0.0484525822,
-0.0101778442,
0.012181133,
-0.0815319791,
-0.0047216574,
2.696294529e-34,
0.0503477305,
0.0203346461,
-0.02286347,
0.0870918706,
0.0109198987,
-0.0079756416,
0.0868434906,
0.0152709335,
-0.0133920591,
-0.0701816902,
-0.0399807096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16851v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16851v2 | Losing Visual Needles in Image Haystacks: Vision Language Models are Easily Distracted in Short and Long Contexts | 2024-06-24T17:58:03 | 2024-07-03T03:55:59 | Aditya Sharma, Michael Saxon, William Yang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | We present LoCoVQA, a dynamic benchmark generator for evaluating long-context
extractive reasoning in vision language models (VLMs). LoCoVQA augments test
examples for mathematical reasoning, VQA, and character recognition tasks with
increasingly long visual contexts composed of both in-distribution and
out-of-distribution distractor images.
Across these tasks, a diverse set of VLMs rapidly lose performance as the
visual context length grows, often exhibiting a striking logarithmic decay
trend. This test assesses how well VLMs can ignore irrelevant information when
answering queries -- a task that is quite easy for language models (LMs) in the
text domain -- demonstrating that current state-of-the-art VLMs lack this
essential capability for many long-context applications. | [
0.0085156569,
0.0418966636,
-0.008798413,
0.0775562897,
-0.0531286374,
0.031231638,
0.036861632,
0.0129293604,
-0.0088960035,
-0.0505582839,
0.0034998574,
-0.0429110564,
0.0194167662,
0.0182782039,
0.0208761729,
-0.0693656057,
0.016988229,
-0.0871280879,
0.0257566776,
0.0106404489,
-0.0125420345,
-0.0314321294,
0.0169218518,
0.000421759,
0.0019840114,
-0.0515771918,
0.0135652944,
-0.0039621615,
0.0048560691,
-0.0025782101,
-0.0351447873,
0.0027536745,
0.012078722,
-0.0154115632,
0.000001966,
-0.0398645587,
0.0204814579,
0.0091377832,
-0.0135391103,
-0.0012398625,
0.0084823584,
-0.0055257436,
0.0121487547,
0.0124251675,
-0.0267640892,
0.0048583946,
0.039472267,
0.032324858,
0.0070995158,
0.0234487094,
-0.0084216231,
0.0021193735,
-0.0021871177,
-0.0345909186,
0.0753101408,
-0.0736759976,
0.0243403092,
0.0152936196,
0.0173577815,
-0.0225387253,
-0.0424446836,
0.0702528507,
0.0463951714,
-0.0033234786,
-0.0258249212,
0.0715355203,
-0.0421610512,
-0.0151244029,
-0.0046149641,
0.0605419725,
-0.0219640434,
-0.0054926332,
0.0093898149,
0.0015432164,
-0.0025544933,
-0.0112208193,
-0.0571092181,
0.0455831885,
-0.006302624,
-0.0036016873,
-0.0295771547,
-0.0066796918,
0.0132825337,
0.0103251999,
-0.051755026,
0.0157867484,
0.0172727145,
0.005536058,
-0.0026561208,
0.0015248148,
-0.04701823,
-0.049765002,
-0.0043917703,
0.0510997288,
0.00403941,
0.0171796307,
-0.0317272879,
-0.0330022238,
-0.016162755,
-0.0454687402,
0.0089639807,
0.0411231443,
-0.0725312084,
0.0898991078,
-0.041189488,
0.0819746926,
-0.0152762439,
0.0446695909,
0.0135213332,
-0.0198208671,
-0.0000556801,
0.004104821,
-0.0171248261,
-0.0094239339,
-0.0530129783,
-0.0499574915,
0.0167082939,
0.0268640462,
-0.0244984198,
-0.009156812,
-0.0125773009,
0.0146464771,
-0.0175665114,
-0.0348016061,
-0.0370398574,
0.0303441938,
-0.0004265048,
0.0002761042,
-0.002181737,
-0.0581293106,
-0.0284490976,
0.0400403328,
0.004533886,
-0.0613207035,
-0.001743037,
0.0889824629,
-0.0131175462,
-0.0463885628,
-0.0240073297,
0.009084736,
-0.0261628069,
-0.0685730651,
0.0254447144,
-0.0729161352,
0.0220805835,
0.0105513735,
-0.0369416885,
-0.0318780653,
0.019564217,
0.0294833817,
-0.0235499032,
0.0870950893,
0.0009385767,
-0.006798794,
0.0142030297,
0.0155906528,
0.0091018369,
0.077966392,
0.014748415,
0.0385718346,
0.0392802507,
-0.0016336694,
0.0226130225,
0.0350357257,
-0.0150518762,
-0.0048975782,
-0.0797227398,
0.0341819488,
0.0204758942,
-0.0120426016,
0.029780006,
0.0850577578,
-0.0231893454,
-0.0417940803,
0.0468820445,
0.0554708093,
0.0290172528,
-0.0599284917,
0.0150990281,
-0.035582412,
-0.0055016684,
-0.0009182401,
-0.1030531228,
0.0477196649,
0.000951306,
0.0307348594,
-0.0186758004,
0.0129093667,
-0.0298052132,
-0.0495511815,
-0.0344476178,
-0.0061160321,
-0.0008666398,
0.0589506514,
0.0774867907,
-0.0045636473,
-0.0188410822,
0.0085498337,
-0.0236068051,
-0.0277742799,
-0.00785603,
-0.0324155465,
0.0438357368,
0.0462446809,
0.0314204618,
-0.0219856594,
-0.015458663,
0.0204169992,
0.0393027812,
0.0303369593,
-0.0134129375,
0.0108067626,
0.0472740903,
-0.0290690456,
-0.0335056894,
-0.0222209692,
-0.0056879898,
-0.0488443114,
0.0313763656,
0.0084915953,
0.0188851804,
-0.061639268,
0.002323936,
0.0404667184,
-0.0063705244,
-0.0330226533,
-0.0287677068,
0.0192913432,
-0.0203088298,
-0.0360077135,
-0.0106395315,
0.0187782086,
0.0240647439,
-0.0477070622,
0.0273156129,
-0.0081061199,
-0.0473072939,
-0.0102781858,
0.0524736345,
-0.0554922298,
-0.0142249949,
-0.0211096425,
-0.0157658346,
0.0053377165,
0.0095610488,
-0.0194473248,
0.0146385385,
-0.0315139815,
0.0067186789,
0.0147590572,
0.0312007237,
-0.0335558951,
0.0828559846,
-0.0274498109,
-0.0073162802,
0.0432267971,
0.0280640014,
0.0005353457,
-0.0342676751,
0.0248631518,
-0.0068753515,
-0.0015308681,
0.0011096295,
-0.0268410351,
0.0098255025,
-0.0412874185,
-0.0123409741,
-0.0518761724,
-0.022420859,
-0.046219606,
0.0069735032,
-0.0115429666,
0.0017674941,
-0.0121451942,
-0.0376486182,
-0.0101530887,
0.0297621582,
-0.0139910718,
0.0166473966,
0.0144273704,
0.0061085164,
-0.0004354081,
-0.0282819755,
-0.0213852804,
0.0068348516,
0.0802611634,
0.0151795456,
-0.0211239699,
-0.0182622261,
0.0544932485,
-0.0219118204,
0.0430710018,
-0.0391817987,
0.0393675156,
0.0058415285,
-0.0579064898,
0.0528252237,
0.1103964671,
0.0116185723,
-0.0001671909,
0.0299139246,
-0.0214930754,
-0.0359366089,
0.0072365208,
0.0085475193,
-0.02584056,
-0.0078990199,
-0.0086269947,
-0.0468483828,
0.0231868681,
-0.0420762636,
0.0132074608,
-0.055770725,
0.0255960096,
-0.0045021018,
-0.0251038186,
-0.0606203191,
0.0298661683,
-0.0056851557,
0.0554241166,
-0.0505097769,
-0.0841905624,
0.036245022,
-0.0187873598,
0.0044012042,
0.0260984916,
0.0214800797,
-0.0311639737,
0.0900879949,
0.0087821456,
-0.02376654,
0.0070191254,
-0.0126768965,
-0.0468434244,
-0.0373141654,
-0.0206256248,
-0.0259238128,
0.1057351679,
-0.0598353595,
0.0332333557,
-0.0439674109,
-0.0129112992,
-0.0590203218,
0.0137851899,
-0.0393541977,
0.0058933515,
-0.0514856987,
-0.0032643657,
0.0027480666,
0.0378412567,
0.059799742,
0.027094068,
-0.0119615616,
-0.0012128308,
-0.0073693311,
0.030792024,
0.0724802092,
0.041553285,
0.0138541292,
-0.0448120311,
0.0075186328,
0.0583939888,
0.0497330092,
-0.0278262477,
-0.033413738,
0.0151829338,
0.0076450678,
0.0402447209,
-0.0018050823,
0.0547599606,
0.0326404795,
-0.0794421658,
-0.0275443289,
0.0718453825,
0.0259864237,
-0.0341513604,
-0.0194668565,
-0.0161263533,
0.0478562899,
0.0474874079,
0.0139062703,
-0.0900482386,
-0.0373359285,
0.0167465825,
0.0097493436,
0.0294335447,
-0.0067506307,
-0.0250521954,
-0.1031400785,
0.0513413101,
-0.00923122,
-0.0091438666,
-0.0112821935,
0.0140338494,
0.0081599029,
0.0020464517,
-0.0059831017,
0.021897329,
-0.0245703943,
0.0163977519,
-0.0116052534,
0.0096599627,
-0.0110057062,
0.0470114239,
-0.0426451825,
-0.0247468837,
0.0251305401,
-0.0137807513,
0.0113784866,
-0.0871705115,
0.0319870859,
-0.0381998867,
0.0104847336,
0.0047880276,
0.0571544878,
-0.0216082539,
-0.0494192131,
0.0249744076,
0.0285380837,
-0.0458248146,
-0.0361853316,
0.0136032244,
0.0438228771,
-0.0048259664,
-0.0258267317,
-0.0109124025,
-0.0180061199,
-0.035223823,
0.0611389093,
0.0377431288,
-0.0219572987,
-0.0712846816,
-0.0093117086,
-0.0261792578,
-0.0651149899,
-0.0218883343,
0.0054437607,
0.0488443114,
-0.0201550648,
-0.0307377372,
-0.0179369207,
0.0520710088,
0.0724994838,
-0.034555126,
-0.0167177115,
0.0016168058,
0.0264400374,
-0.0769315213,
0.0609411113,
-0.0166540965,
0.0444548465,
-0.0358261988,
0.054126367,
-0.0180449951,
-0.0311748888,
-0.0119445482,
0.0343996733,
-0.1150114089,
-0.053036429,
0.0114825638,
0.0487485006,
0.023229653,
0.0345856845,
0.0009628688,
-0.0376197919,
-0.0147118429,
0.0322950408,
0.0103548588,
0.0520882495,
0.0024776659,
-0.032596156,
0.021862736,
0.0484461561,
-0.047654219,
0.0007473658,
0.0517906062,
0.0172953177,
-0.0278876089,
0.0195482168,
-0.0078584105,
0.0114272386,
0.0337516405,
0.0138117662,
-0.0080385916,
-0.0132492306,
0.0230065379,
-0.0109822499,
0.0043928577,
-0.0519412607,
0.0107948231,
-0.0114931455,
0.031466376,
0.0226765182,
-0.0020759606,
0.0028162901,
-0.0073020915,
-0.0333460271,
0.0060017491,
0.0163258985,
-0.0133296158,
0.0124638835,
-0.0190063417,
0.0051823431,
0.0103656705,
-0.0251723621,
0.0595843643,
-0.0022192448,
0.0550698787,
0.0449711457,
-0.009523239,
-0.0228048451,
0.0040054047,
-0.0500197858,
-0.054125458,
0.0152941458,
0.0321405269,
0.0318630934,
-0.0116327684,
-0.00767361,
-0.0096110785,
-0.0119824745,
-0.0321245007,
0.0302505102,
0.0191540141,
-0.0238731727,
0.0560539663,
0.0545704998,
-0.0175467469,
-0.0173073988,
0.0550929122,
0.011635825,
0.005054676,
0.018779479,
0.0233139582,
-0.0142216841,
-0.0406193174,
0.000593108,
-0.0078964308,
-0.0040980144,
0.0306613352,
-0.0488385372,
-0.097295396,
0.0208946243,
0.0229632538,
-0.0124195917,
0.0079720244,
0.0286994353,
0.077225551,
0.0239657126,
-0.0352189206,
0.0008895167,
0.0009812171,
-0.0158489794,
0.0113408575,
-0.0222994238,
-6.135337011e-33,
-0.0054951343,
-0.0244146604,
0.0652989969,
-0.0033932377,
-0.019849468,
0.0258328095,
-0.0416592695,
0.0217535943,
-0.0219891518,
-0.0115589267,
-0.0019016539,
0.032080628,
0.0062967292,
0.0550136417,
-0.0325627513,
-0.0134284925,
0.0022441726,
0.0195263121,
-0.0103120692,
-0.0139196115,
0.0294227712,
0.0129179722,
0.0121550476,
-0.0619048104,
-0.0063035875,
0.0354399495,
0.0146649834,
0.0112229558,
0.0035911144,
0.0827600509,
-0.0285672508,
0.0114828171,
0.022427462,
-0.0030172062,
-0.0353740938,
0.038881246,
-0.0797130242,
-0.0093791736,
0.0184506159,
0.011344647,
-0.0904545337,
-0.0199136548,
0.057037212,
0.0022449901,
-0.0098528778,
-0.065646939,
0.0373921916,
-0.0354778022,
-0.044056125,
0.0222025067,
-0.0427803919,
0.031417761,
0.0110822013,
-0.0059955991,
0.0501417369,
0.0197553374,
-0.0082830675,
0.0584939718,
-0.0354504846,
-0.014695527,
0.0014892981,
0.0176740326,
0.0805706382,
0.0665889904,
0.0267657787,
0.0459992066,
0.0236581825,
-0.0271724798,
-0.0258130282,
-0.0696269944,
0.0386690907,
0.068913877,
0.060911689,
0.0142578222,
0.045377858,
0.0062368559,
-0.0664757118,
-0.0420912094,
-0.0637252629,
0.0711479634,
0.0300130807,
0.0135434484,
-0.015652027,
-0.0049234629,
-0.0349034593,
0.0209907554,
-0.0572064631,
0.014620061,
0.0835521668,
0.0255004875,
0.0026244782,
0.0380896702,
0.0514921285,
-0.037359789,
0.023613086,
0.0168182272,
-0.0135073783,
0.0253791474,
0.0272750575,
0.0253949799,
-0.056969244,
0.0081350459,
0.0272024535,
0.0454740487,
-0.0076021166,
-0.0090605756,
0.0209735967,
-0.016116973,
-0.0657380894,
-0.0191343315,
-0.0693474934,
0.0189576186,
0.0001339242,
0.075642474,
0.0533108599,
0.0185576621,
-0.0284592304,
0.0345028006,
-0.0162563156,
-0.0570441373,
-0.0248036087,
0.0044351956,
-0.0015865506,
0.0261298399,
-0.0088023581,
-0.0155057572,
-0.0323554017,
0.0372620299,
0.0259788521,
-0.0604829527,
-0.0054840394,
0.0561715551,
2.634e-7,
0.0493038744,
0.0304366574,
0.0205158796,
0.0232559815,
0.0059483559,
0.0248404648,
-0.0108048562,
-0.0062207305,
0.0036390673,
-0.0501419008,
-0.0390282683,
0.0795468763,
0.0239558108,
-0.0149149066,
0.0093945907,
0.0447564311,
-0.0127909752,
-0.0291827042,
-0.0407268852,
-0.0026768958,
0.0509913713,
0.0719889775,
-0.0300686844,
-0.0046424121,
0.0467548259,
-0.1001072824,
0.0685833767,
-0.0264619514,
0.0198444575,
-0.0272555295,
-0.0211901292,
0.0188570824,
0.0086723678,
0.017157672,
-0.001067995,
-0.010689998,
0.0282909665,
0.0399431139,
-0.0216745101,
-0.0384538248,
-0.0448197499,
0.0027490067,
-0.0294907708,
-0.0636836737,
0.1162561849,
-0.0538892299,
0.0024711047,
-0.019435063,
-0.0211467054,
0.0037660394,
0.0096765133,
0.0275794379,
-0.0101309363,
-0.0095552513,
0.0464285351,
-0.0384684615,
-0.0461165197,
-0.1164093241,
-0.0227590576,
-0.0060971719,
-0.0322375,
-0.0100644585,
-0.0814061016,
0.012045932,
0.0304492936,
-0.0018123831,
-0.0457538888,
2.310486722e-34,
0.040888343,
0.0031884038,
-0.0105852736,
0.0140397139,
0.0182519071,
-0.0273300745,
-0.0378200822,
0.0044492786,
-0.0007790705,
-0.0813581795,
0.0023611281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16845v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16845v1 | RaTEScore: A Metric for Radiology Report Generation | 2024-06-24T17:49:28 | 2024-06-24T17:49:28 | Weike Zhao, Chaoyi Wu, Xiaoman Zhang, Ya Zhang, Yanfeng Wang, Weidi Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper introduces a novel, entity-aware metric, termed as Radiological
Report (Text) Evaluation (RaTEScore), to assess the quality of medical reports
generated by AI models. RaTEScore emphasizes crucial medical entities such as
diagnostic outcomes and anatomical details, and is robust against complex
medical synonyms and sensitive to negation expressions. Technically, we
developed a comprehensive medical NER dataset, RaTE-NER, and trained an NER
model specifically for this purpose. This model enables the decomposition of
complex radiological reports into constituent medical entities. The metric
itself is derived by comparing the similarity of entity embeddings, obtained
from a language model, based on their types and relevance to clinical
significance. Our evaluations demonstrate that RaTEScore aligns more closely
with human preference than existing metrics, validated both on established
public benchmarks and our newly proposed RaTE-Eval benchmark. | [
0.0374612547,
0.0631557032,
0.0267700348,
-0.0253111348,
-0.0034261255,
0.0445275158,
-0.0265713986,
0.0599166714,
-0.0138210189,
0.0106200809,
-0.0115843434,
-0.0532925799,
0.0230673347,
0.0626465678,
0.0188228562,
-0.0587806217,
0.018186491,
0.051892899,
0.0146589009,
0.0313801058,
-0.0002354869,
0.0241722837,
-0.0028867978,
0.0615804903,
-0.0364177488,
0.0121221775,
0.0227159411,
0.0118980352,
0.0399620198,
-0.0634341314,
-0.0413485728,
0.0304672606,
-0.0085171442,
0.0070258179,
0.0000018629,
-0.0276734903,
-0.0157817975,
0.0459917113,
-0.0067843604,
-0.0350607857,
0.0830440223,
-0.0806355476,
-0.0077487803,
0.0051015313,
-0.0127677405,
-0.0414048061,
0.0433956608,
0.0347562395,
0.0555772223,
0.0733605474,
-0.0225967076,
0.0276924428,
0.0149471667,
-0.0331526957,
-0.0019130129,
-0.0266720075,
0.0021205381,
0.0163395256,
-0.0029195866,
0.0052271597,
-0.0122442544,
0.0234813336,
0.0190250464,
0.0038702919,
0.0253705494,
0.0870460197,
-0.0085966168,
-0.0085961381,
0.0283452962,
0.0601424649,
-0.0233797487,
-0.0014547745,
0.0178913176,
-0.0131289139,
-0.0227990765,
-0.0282517131,
-0.0317724347,
0.0051678685,
-0.0154342484,
0.0082286391,
0.0231514778,
0.0039482196,
0.0254961792,
0.0201170128,
0.00679301,
-0.0212965086,
0.0154314293,
-0.0179582778,
-0.0087361895,
0.0094413711,
-0.0119343298,
-0.0618189946,
0.0318247229,
0.0341109596,
-0.0734939426,
0.0158924963,
-0.0556097478,
-0.0061705443,
0.0794495717,
-0.0503913276,
-0.0220683012,
-0.0055111009,
0.0237913243,
0.0579126924,
-0.0228654258,
0.0061940411,
-0.0056117806,
0.019954823,
-0.0243993923,
-0.0040199407,
-0.0398264453,
-0.0079344753,
-0.0060963412,
0.0412121341,
0.018615827,
-0.0406973623,
-0.0619890429,
-0.0250228494,
-0.023833992,
0.0400707051,
0.0529373065,
0.0576086417,
-0.0634844974,
0.0065383371,
-0.0357085913,
0.0166560058,
-0.0383298472,
-0.0129697975,
-0.0031389345,
0.0078170374,
0.0217408389,
0.0174726471,
0.0058119781,
0.0230761431,
0.0008629474,
0.0145204756,
0.0129434373,
-0.0204521958,
0.0232963581,
-0.0730087534,
0.0088033099,
-0.0230257753,
-0.0317893811,
-0.0609869212,
0.0585795902,
0.0006980311,
0.0006966203,
-0.0565183014,
0.0079037743,
0.033140365,
-0.0330035277,
0.0415919311,
-0.0538808368,
0.0081642056,
0.0171857718,
0.0407279283,
0.021922797,
0.0024420545,
0.0310056191,
-0.0013554605,
-0.0019093887,
0.0219392218,
-0.0112315211,
-0.023960758,
0.0208333824,
-0.0229508281,
-0.0198101439,
-0.0023129894,
-0.0555509739,
0.0925273001,
0.0069196909,
0.0873008668,
-0.0043248674,
-0.0450437441,
0.0220332686,
0.0454377383,
0.0350360163,
0.0199013576,
0.0465345979,
-0.0285256635,
-0.0535447821,
-0.0002435598,
-0.0078857094,
0.0645139962,
0.0415695496,
0.0115440264,
0.0322284028,
-0.0050432775,
-0.0322439261,
-0.0201831684,
-0.0151911993,
-0.0132010328,
-0.0265589245,
-0.0271649212,
0.0051179752,
0.0013659155,
-0.0537802503,
0.0331877545,
0.0380764864,
-0.031097861,
0.024630554,
-0.046135813,
0.0025295108,
0.0806527436,
0.0942158252,
-0.0242358409,
-0.0488117635,
-0.0066205226,
-0.0129703898,
0.0638555214,
0.0406652056,
-0.0297462568,
0.0267456919,
-0.0388740525,
-0.0318978615,
0.0128634656,
0.0246190894,
-0.0161167886,
0.0100088557,
0.0484336279,
0.0131866047,
-0.0480472296,
-0.0617498457,
0.0549345762,
-0.0546401627,
0.0087319314,
0.0144694187,
0.0075947791,
0.0005770048,
0.0290594287,
-0.0308153555,
0.0446646623,
0.0263756979,
-0.0160509553,
-0.0539871864,
-0.004578738,
-0.0359050892,
-0.033531785,
0.0138390008,
-0.0708940029,
0.0139996819,
-0.0048086783,
-0.032818567,
-0.0186172631,
-0.0446837619,
-0.0546889454,
0.011216321,
-0.0145523502,
0.0335853882,
0.0599924624,
-0.0157717839,
-0.0006019995,
0.0436340682,
-0.0432992056,
0.0323669985,
0.0404639952,
-0.0088178432,
0.0310853049,
-0.030538803,
-0.0555650443,
0.0077094045,
0.020595124,
0.0152786141,
0.0145159429,
0.0090305265,
-0.0239371527,
-0.0340509266,
-0.0895485803,
0.0047454135,
0.0040013101,
-0.0062358025,
0.0522153676,
0.0048003253,
0.0237570629,
-0.0052963817,
-0.0551963486,
-0.0414119102,
0.0479264259,
0.0266770255,
0.0564686581,
0.0296039991,
0.00496927,
-0.044360429,
-0.0155114038,
-0.0282621924,
0.009609608,
0.0486421064,
0.0133336969,
-0.0286263786,
0.0596862249,
-0.0766248703,
-0.0321541578,
0.026913235,
-0.0324343368,
0.0439337529,
-0.0182230752,
-0.0326230675,
0.0639728978,
0.0085431766,
0.0308969039,
0.0475764088,
0.0165506341,
-0.0255950596,
-0.0148278149,
-0.048948586,
0.0301249865,
0.0359998792,
-0.1111958101,
0.0363327935,
0.0120499469,
0.0088121984,
0.0000710232,
-0.0567314699,
0.0065828008,
-0.0433412865,
-0.0031203157,
-0.0116186179,
0.0098684439,
-0.0022529883,
0.02327195,
-0.00342835,
-0.0246190373,
0.1142688245,
-0.0000032048,
0.0380006246,
-0.0481838919,
-0.0110130422,
-0.0462301299,
0.0291106291,
-0.0088609029,
0.044541236,
0.0120672826,
-0.0066726082,
-0.0157495141,
0.0467861928,
0.0286476165,
-0.0648363829,
0.0208814386,
0.0179654174,
0.0001941192,
0.0086789476,
-0.0360499211,
-0.0413308963,
-0.0198953152,
0.0407195874,
0.0107674431,
0.0217856374,
-0.029039165,
-0.06283544,
0.0577683076,
-0.0137604717,
0.0317016989,
0.0060138148,
-0.0414680056,
0.0132773835,
0.0605055653,
0.0503306836,
0.0143859386,
-0.0060007628,
-0.011333501,
0.0188449118,
0.0756238699,
-0.0110187717,
0.0481561907,
-0.0222855248,
-0.0059853657,
-0.0402685814,
-0.0154387048,
-0.0029735549,
0.0061883084,
-0.0057461574,
-0.0302446987,
-0.0330071636,
0.1099431142,
0.0509829931,
-0.0340007469,
0.0011127954,
0.0163022578,
0.020668881,
0.0048005194,
-0.0003214361,
-0.0106137767,
0.0142554054,
-0.014002094,
0.0291032009,
0.0039092433,
-0.0575493202,
0.0066293748,
-0.0384900011,
0.0159205422,
-0.0153241521,
-0.0328739397,
-0.0569794178,
-0.0645612404,
-0.0133414511,
-0.0116474647,
-0.0468766242,
-0.0231554173,
0.0000685513,
-0.0062966319,
-0.0043477407,
-0.0446632802,
-0.0847452953,
-0.0038003118,
-0.0718162209,
0.045401495,
0.0425511077,
0.0676710308,
-0.0211697537,
-0.0122047802,
-0.0544930696,
0.0252252091,
-0.023974698,
0.0047818543,
0.1052058488,
-0.0061266972,
-0.0073702349,
-0.0667820573,
0.0001407029,
0.0079779141,
-0.0014646315,
-0.0311549418,
0.0447728336,
-0.0207678508,
-0.015271225,
-0.0786089972,
0.0412286669,
0.0350476392,
0.0744717419,
0.0118842768,
0.0110236891,
-0.0164106935,
0.0115826186,
0.0901377201,
-0.0399242081,
-0.0113752764,
0.0211885683,
-0.0699651167,
-0.0747132748,
-0.0874155089,
-0.0502906963,
0.0259141698,
0.0110900011,
0.0006911106,
0.0022450634,
0.0092192618,
-0.0538673513,
-0.0574897379,
0.0263182223,
0.0485344902,
0.0029794101,
-0.0416844301,
-0.0307790712,
0.0479961745,
0.0508866608,
-0.0253740381,
0.0186594445,
-0.0297659263,
0.0069807176,
-0.0492157228,
0.0261699352,
0.0132100442,
-0.028832987,
-0.0031082551,
-0.0283760503,
0.0421314724,
0.0626676977,
-0.0383969806,
-0.0124366982,
-0.0123892492,
-0.0302591957,
-0.0171896089,
0.0248923544,
-0.0280537233,
-0.000205285,
-0.0170010999,
0.0694568753,
-0.0233661793,
-0.0318659246,
0.0351141356,
0.0240955763,
-0.0151946535,
-0.057342574,
0.0031146577,
-0.0287319068,
-0.0347861387,
-0.0274926033,
0.0040845014,
-0.0276610423,
0.0036255508,
0.0388191231,
0.0033622121,
-0.0262577757,
0.0775229558,
-0.046939116,
0.0070266789,
-0.0296060797,
0.0073184059,
0.0132119227,
-0.0011556579,
0.0292597581,
-0.0026747892,
-0.0319505669,
-0.0554373302,
0.0044420306,
0.0122462353,
-0.0327613242,
0.0196938328,
0.0208252594,
0.0619301796,
-0.0013829309,
0.0556073487,
0.0058665336,
-0.0230251234,
-0.0472126119,
0.0010834142,
0.0208413228,
0.0344978496,
0.0301465169,
-0.0473984517,
-0.0063966103,
-0.0168927256,
0.0370855294,
-0.0109902155,
0.0084983278,
0.0400337689,
0.0074400953,
0.0285801254,
-0.0056158677,
0.0940020531,
-0.0185796488,
0.0262955036,
-0.0205906741,
-0.0718634874,
-0.0483631492,
-0.0037915988,
0.0216993466,
0.002172213,
-0.0268527623,
0.0012369793,
-0.0718501732,
-0.0555192493,
0.0130604189,
0.0066997674,
-0.0250465814,
-0.0003983947,
0.0585456304,
0.0443955101,
0.0077047194,
0.0222853981,
-0.0212763119,
0.0253795553,
-0.045649264,
-0.0489411764,
0.0019468137,
-5.792786937e-33,
-0.0082693053,
-0.067084372,
0.0247079004,
-0.0401417986,
-0.0024476801,
0.0725621283,
-0.0383185148,
-0.0275867078,
0.0265359748,
0.0317774303,
-0.0165415946,
-0.0051603108,
-0.0038039018,
0.0177755263,
-0.016211316,
-0.0006658928,
0.0369719788,
0.0005082552,
-0.0446942523,
0.0242222827,
-0.0186293498,
0.0291656721,
0.0220818948,
-0.097058244,
-0.0149717694,
0.0185934305,
-0.0028165155,
-0.0263580997,
0.0440228954,
0.0733039752,
-0.0485978797,
0.0125368582,
0.0419357531,
-0.0311779566,
-0.0048059803,
0.0011292752,
-0.0827587321,
-0.0420271866,
-0.0068409806,
-0.0466253832,
-0.0463385656,
-0.003733519,
0.0368092433,
-0.0128726745,
0.0210530069,
-0.0182542112,
0.0374944024,
0.0008955284,
-0.023259243,
-0.024070859,
-0.0468833111,
0.0681594238,
0.0006772595,
-0.0264128018,
0.0047870451,
-0.0181503203,
-0.0202856343,
0.0401523747,
-0.0453952402,
0.0073842118,
0.0171243902,
0.0314219445,
0.0155631918,
-0.0636372417,
-0.0460107252,
0.0580614395,
0.0575066842,
-0.0235038567,
-0.0193398632,
0.0176349767,
-0.0305821355,
0.054113593,
0.0365308635,
0.0404899642,
0.0312328115,
-0.0310511198,
-0.0627775341,
0.1055815518,
-0.0342767164,
0.0668657124,
0.0192932505,
-0.0282293018,
-0.0821996406,
0.0090920329,
0.0026785228,
-0.0388759784,
-0.0344001614,
-0.0434764847,
0.0398660973,
0.0365956575,
-0.0207442269,
0.0163248088,
-0.0012800157,
0.0041643814,
-0.0007379546,
0.0041378094,
0.016829446,
0.012176672,
-0.035751991,
-0.0062434403,
-0.0348400995,
-0.0015056592,
0.0466638617,
0.0045933733,
0.0337220766,
-0.0121211726,
0.0380565822,
0.0085094105,
-0.062972948,
0.0158692654,
0.0237133112,
-0.0272235181,
-0.0441234373,
0.0092870621,
0.0107938945,
0.0103018451,
-0.0140448995,
0.0181774348,
0.0008180515,
0.0232764594,
-0.0345919095,
-0.0378373265,
0.0357328281,
0.0190536268,
-0.0368950702,
-0.0259218309,
-0.0444267616,
-0.0104532996,
0.0560337044,
-0.035709776,
-0.0388548672,
0.0021652235,
2.613e-7,
0.082529746,
0.0261158291,
0.0218792818,
0.0324216671,
0.0083737122,
0.0078825243,
-0.0115787564,
0.0285095926,
-0.0316504538,
0.0156135838,
0.0240771733,
-0.0163609423,
-0.007928336,
0.0583901033,
-0.0632929876,
0.0033450774,
-0.095759213,
-0.0257444456,
-0.0111844176,
-0.0574452206,
0.0631371513,
0.0513133109,
-0.0272725802,
-0.042088937,
-0.0104864025,
0.0033601981,
0.0336894356,
-0.0231070518,
0.0024266182,
0.031061504,
0.0470079631,
0.036471907,
0.0241899882,
0.0272408724,
-0.0265880544,
-0.0269604903,
0.0429899991,
0.0751527324,
-0.033844132,
-0.0369879529,
0.0272388551,
-0.0266183317,
0.0265550278,
-0.045214273,
0.0536630824,
-0.0136744585,
-0.0171824079,
-0.010902415,
-0.0218029208,
0.0368260853,
0.0913420171,
-0.0542438142,
-0.076768674,
0.0390593857,
0.0302553978,
0.0216943938,
-0.0389752239,
-0.0640490949,
-0.0050743031,
0.0137535939,
-0.0013935199,
-0.0345110595,
0.0162284039,
-0.0193886161,
-0.005908771,
-0.0439726561,
0.002120516,
2.536561148e-34,
0.0362537056,
0.0275666844,
0.0040353644,
0.0083988374,
0.0380206406,
-0.0130301323,
-0.0159486402,
-0.0001889616,
0.0127691114,
-0.0385579616,
-0.0102116093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16842v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16842v1 | Exploring Factual Entailment with NLI: A News Media Study | 2024-06-24T17:47:55 | 2024-06-24T17:47:55 | Guy Mor-Lan, Effi Levi | cs.CL | cs.CL | We explore the relationship between factuality and Natural Language Inference
(NLI) by introducing FactRel -- a novel annotation scheme that models
\textit{factual} rather than \textit{textual} entailment, and use it to
annotate a dataset of naturally occurring sentences from news articles. Our
analysis shows that 84\% of factually supporting pairs and 63\% of factually
undermining pairs do not amount to NLI entailment or contradiction,
respectively, suggesting that factual relationships are more apt for analyzing
media discourse. We experiment with models for pairwise classification on the
new dataset, and find that in some cases, generating synthetic data with GPT-4
on the basis of the annotated dataset can improve performance. Surprisingly,
few-shot learning with GPT-4 yields strong results on par with medium LMs
(DeBERTa) trained on the labelled dataset. We hypothesize that these results
indicate the fundamental dependence of this task on both world knowledge and
advanced reasoning abilities. | [
0.0159623343,
0.0377493836,
0.0027570764,
0.0506551117,
-0.035328988,
0.0622549392,
0.004778326,
-0.0162011087,
0.0024165206,
-0.062848635,
0.0285382848,
0.0313507132,
-0.0145348664,
-0.0069865296,
0.0012059096,
-0.005582747,
0.0538972765,
0.0261342805,
0.0474366397,
-0.0084672403,
-0.002134599,
0.0567393452,
-0.019659264,
0.0113863302,
-0.0268900357,
-0.0010441676,
0.0175505895,
0.0024303726,
0.0519757047,
-0.0148667851,
-0.0334387012,
0.057461746,
0.0746569335,
0.0457554683,
0.0000018283,
-0.0659927502,
0.0328452773,
0.0031985517,
-0.062012326,
-0.0116823614,
-0.0180921759,
-0.0432218984,
0.0313169286,
-0.0092491768,
-0.0209586341,
-0.0418803468,
0.0189950243,
0.0528846942,
0.0650025755,
0.0776228681,
-0.0206932984,
-0.0571171604,
0.0211455952,
-0.0093659209,
0.0225366186,
-0.0230030324,
0.0305037089,
0.0523696877,
-0.0268076006,
0.0322909541,
0.0267963801,
0.0128979757,
0.0286128707,
0.0025415279,
-0.0252984148,
0.0405019149,
-0.0658739284,
-0.0204049852,
0.0487751737,
0.0459994748,
0.0404748432,
-0.0539271683,
-0.0190730002,
-0.0114906644,
-0.0193129051,
0.047649391,
0.0016896711,
0.0375541486,
-0.0560425073,
0.028312441,
0.0504102036,
-0.0203965735,
0.0128374295,
0.0322401524,
0.0113557409,
0.042123083,
-0.0069747572,
-0.0233100466,
0.0197386649,
0.0460810959,
-0.0601952858,
-0.0339734741,
-0.0196522996,
-0.00573075,
0.0298020132,
0.0220835488,
-0.0405517593,
0.0005528689,
0.0362608209,
-0.0861721933,
-0.0116167981,
0.0115365544,
-0.0305633061,
0.0756199807,
-0.0365904979,
-0.0026889734,
-0.0035756992,
-0.0150009841,
0.0177643076,
-0.0392806716,
-0.0443858504,
0.0127696004,
-0.0178018734,
0.0464498475,
-0.0084271124,
0.0038665447,
-0.0035145064,
-0.0120895393,
0.0198046826,
0.0436697938,
-0.0259693228,
-0.0468791313,
-0.0303138774,
-0.0072130384,
-0.0585528649,
0.0379040316,
-0.0540375523,
0.062520422,
-0.0364487395,
-0.0292860679,
-0.0151984766,
0.0184444226,
0.0132290199,
-0.0202506315,
0.0241307039,
0.0104795471,
-0.0027904951,
-0.0179777537,
-0.0628314093,
-0.017516287,
0.0011896405,
-0.0633129478,
-0.0137701128,
-0.0593511499,
0.0110463863,
0.0025302074,
-0.0260285307,
-0.0069761537,
-0.0106673986,
0.0441849045,
-0.048780676,
0.0832412392,
-0.0056269034,
-0.0049698325,
0.0500344224,
-0.0013497424,
-0.0070977025,
0.0891295299,
0.0269864518,
0.0125732813,
0.0425694734,
0.0431499109,
-0.0028292709,
-0.0171103366,
0.0215117671,
0.0301250815,
0.005792941,
0.007220244,
-0.0200348888,
0.0023750835,
0.0184034836,
-0.0112195276,
-0.0314133093,
-0.0140677188,
0.0630070493,
-0.0052099586,
0.010285804,
-0.0065158657,
0.054024484,
0.0049383226,
0.0244612284,
0.0260781497,
-0.0481709056,
0.0673559457,
-0.0450577736,
-0.0069484832,
0.0206422452,
0.0367950313,
-0.0312194861,
-0.0273883287,
0.0030874778,
-0.0280159116,
-0.0061022826,
-0.0013968304,
0.0388715826,
0.0173094347,
-0.02207819,
0.0141245481,
0.0633124411,
-0.0288340747,
-0.027137462,
-0.0242494363,
0.0285894051,
-0.0190965738,
0.0090188915,
-0.0055886619,
-0.0531879403,
-0.0264960509,
0.0170867387,
0.0550696515,
0.0186366048,
0.0093563758,
0.0067397649,
-0.0207642913,
-0.0066865329,
-0.0594964288,
0.0435010344,
0.0222089607,
-0.014515698,
0.0422262661,
0.005424994,
-0.0250277482,
0.0196611974,
0.0451261736,
-0.0143272355,
-0.0194288194,
0.0155845191,
0.0337264948,
0.0074957754,
0.0185645949,
-0.0061629871,
-0.0413210057,
0.0107639506,
-0.0054132361,
-0.0250268225,
0.007438682,
-0.0011014075,
-0.111762628,
-0.0033964799,
-0.0539000928,
-0.0677228943,
0.0009473948,
-0.0596459098,
-0.019116791,
-0.0026555522,
-0.0120112225,
-0.0243727285,
-0.0743618533,
-0.0598284081,
-0.0119491713,
-0.0009981543,
-0.0130615495,
0.1041960418,
0.0231782738,
-0.006494307,
-0.0301207732,
-0.0055983881,
0.0409694351,
-0.0158787202,
-0.0027864685,
0.0065350877,
0.0283724032,
-0.0122961933,
0.0456352308,
-0.0112181762,
-0.0190647803,
-0.0079179024,
-0.0727302656,
0.0334226638,
-0.0237088539,
0.0025659583,
0.013327634,
-0.0344441459,
-0.0059172539,
-0.000399045,
-0.009659267,
-0.0440710299,
-0.0189430285,
0.0080127958,
0.0592204146,
-0.0059984806,
0.0211163647,
-0.0030323982,
0.0251272935,
-0.0434076376,
0.0340522639,
0.0226999838,
-0.0141635751,
-0.0302503612,
0.0281119663,
-0.077164188,
0.0036297909,
-0.0135430321,
-0.0241326969,
0.0266921353,
0.0241024997,
-0.0004345594,
0.069870688,
0.0093973903,
0.0297861341,
0.0343657285,
0.0306473505,
-0.0191585645,
0.0381716341,
-0.0264257155,
0.0181418285,
-0.0038729834,
-0.0218458734,
-0.0031838282,
0.0051596379,
0.0086716218,
0.0129626021,
-0.0387579091,
0.0522019267,
0.0134346066,
-0.0019397321,
0.0105097145,
-0.0057052667,
0.0191210266,
0.053271722,
-0.0157039519,
0.0107157817,
0.0782256797,
-0.0098830014,
0.0153248189,
-0.060319759,
-0.0507086366,
-0.0212189127,
0.050954897,
-0.0153129892,
-0.0029253655,
-0.0001566205,
0.0153250201,
-0.0423345342,
-0.0305224266,
0.0744172484,
-0.0069211889,
0.059000887,
-0.0376918241,
0.0252102129,
-0.0062208502,
-0.0323484987,
-0.0275693201,
-0.0644743741,
-0.0168969724,
-0.0284480918,
-0.0788889006,
0.007047642,
-0.0433860868,
-0.004520684,
0.0409149118,
0.0248073917,
0.0013392424,
-0.0038012729,
-0.0017427424,
0.0466842949,
0.055607561,
0.0141013768,
0.0005455131,
0.0177974179,
0.035815496,
0.024018826,
-0.0611881576,
0.0285356883,
-0.0456146747,
-0.0074836458,
-0.0380319357,
0.0034474446,
-0.0500300974,
-0.0410389937,
0.0454211682,
-0.0314985923,
-0.0005161639,
0.1037853658,
0.0104443338,
-0.0124863032,
-0.0321022272,
0.0299286302,
-0.0135085182,
0.0171596538,
-0.0076410035,
-0.0918378979,
-0.0436147042,
-0.0137871839,
-0.0289829504,
-0.0301214755,
-0.0317513496,
-0.0361730196,
-0.0954124182,
0.0375505462,
-0.0342290737,
-0.0289281663,
-0.031058481,
-0.1041716784,
0.0093539208,
-0.0097386725,
0.0079551991,
-0.0173186883,
0.0359445587,
0.0240321141,
0.0051298048,
-0.0194916427,
-0.0439302064,
0.0457618907,
-0.0107469829,
0.0312098283,
0.0020164785,
0.0464131571,
-0.0154549135,
0.0036189531,
-0.0297854412,
-0.016848404,
-0.0330946073,
-0.0095537193,
0.0725378171,
-0.0608424768,
-0.0117834881,
-0.0361912921,
0.0296233147,
0.0269407872,
-0.0354837254,
0.013453491,
0.0547197387,
-0.0242267996,
-0.0204619262,
-0.0209640097,
0.0193321314,
-0.0179685373,
0.0949026644,
0.0163430627,
0.0252501722,
0.0005348906,
-0.0263288617,
-0.01842333,
-0.0201037675,
-0.0315883197,
0.0211972017,
-0.0212461557,
-0.0124181099,
-0.0368023999,
-0.0450025648,
0.0209737122,
0.0320771635,
-0.0435356721,
0.0097722886,
0.0410245396,
0.0190647058,
-0.0125489086,
0.0019325315,
-0.034596011,
-0.0313687846,
0.0597513691,
-0.0048640026,
0.0591890253,
0.0040689828,
-0.0175208114,
0.0113108428,
-0.064400129,
-0.0386644565,
-0.042511709,
0.0167633258,
0.0216710046,
0.0365768448,
-0.0025850702,
0.0243134629,
0.0113228979,
0.1015615165,
-0.0357898101,
0.0349004939,
0.0170598961,
0.0147918407,
0.0235558022,
0.0387050547,
-0.0104289167,
0.0436240323,
-0.0163795836,
0.0219012033,
-0.0598820448,
0.0037328075,
0.0457034893,
0.0026494109,
0.0826381817,
0.0040100571,
-0.0361644924,
-0.0376888141,
0.0103898449,
-0.066695556,
-0.0162905958,
-0.0218878463,
0.016810067,
-0.0108935544,
0.0118991332,
-0.04641103,
-0.0230616834,
-0.0285751913,
0.057577271,
-0.0154183563,
-0.0238683354,
0.0461183898,
0.0181604773,
-0.0593999699,
-0.0270189699,
-0.0674147159,
-0.00359508,
-0.0092508085,
0.0253156647,
-0.023968691,
0.0275910217,
0.0595325418,
0.0185119826,
0.0306378063,
-0.0307606217,
-0.0658276826,
0.0096921856,
-0.0112820268,
0.0529978238,
0.0344067216,
-0.0379766114,
0.0258495566,
-0.019448854,
-0.0159373879,
0.0322217569,
0.0303984806,
-0.0003241928,
-0.0238071252,
0.0334549956,
0.005351705,
-0.0439978838,
0.0248302631,
0.0501159318,
-0.0276192036,
0.0405020453,
0.0551740788,
-0.0084999958,
-0.0456753522,
-0.0470984839,
0.0106211863,
0.0144891134,
0.019189924,
0.0249959901,
-0.0678858384,
-0.0536293276,
-0.0240349602,
-0.0276918132,
0.0061037689,
0.0151743162,
-0.0031492638,
0.0723354667,
0.032382872,
-0.0385698639,
-0.0142374663,
0.0075894045,
-0.0402374938,
0.0007835645,
-0.0098454626,
-6.551469358e-33,
-0.0501252487,
-0.0189230796,
0.0090490738,
0.0351917781,
0.0218785461,
0.0112274652,
-0.0269684214,
-0.0251377393,
-0.0757776126,
0.0584240966,
0.0406642556,
0.0273079146,
0.0026538305,
-0.0100572528,
-0.007600938,
-0.0393702276,
0.0091077229,
0.0068558725,
-0.0544291399,
0.0003449898,
0.0585627519,
-0.0300164074,
0.0768000111,
-0.0575968027,
-0.0010332335,
-0.0224394072,
-0.0299342982,
0.0264182482,
-0.0184323136,
0.0257383753,
-0.0009413151,
0.0323445126,
0.0418493859,
-0.0443930067,
0.0392782614,
0.0138562592,
-0.0740862414,
-0.072093755,
0.0696668476,
-0.0235284604,
-0.013238498,
0.002520032,
0.0018001727,
0.0150324218,
-0.0075533148,
-0.0332594775,
0.0477715284,
-0.022433484,
0.0157805663,
-0.0202493574,
-0.0646895617,
0.0108651165,
-0.0010582492,
-0.0149486009,
-0.0399928614,
0.0088185752,
0.0135562345,
0.0048167882,
-0.078700766,
-0.0112030571,
-0.0273639914,
0.0033931423,
0.0143696377,
-0.0538249984,
0.0067015053,
0.0741733164,
-0.0082666511,
-0.0014920131,
-0.0933970585,
0.0221469607,
0.0505689569,
0.0294097066,
0.0272835176,
0.1007557288,
0.0528989881,
0.0193364732,
-0.1257744133,
0.0121937459,
0.0649105608,
0.0331708342,
-0.004299676,
-0.0304814912,
-0.0202123411,
-0.0028037976,
-0.031905815,
-0.0013583185,
-0.0305943433,
-0.0216384176,
-0.0209244974,
-0.0065027904,
-0.0265351888,
0.03876701,
0.0306817442,
-0.0070956857,
0.0145795168,
0.0182774682,
-0.044593852,
-0.0110305231,
0.0173967015,
0.0320389345,
-0.0604710467,
-0.0048895027,
0.0258462112,
0.043879196,
0.0341808125,
-0.0002910745,
0.0826827958,
-0.0227455962,
-0.0366875604,
-0.0111487349,
-0.0230080578,
0.0100189652,
-0.0435245074,
-0.0309791863,
0.0234587565,
0.0427333713,
0.0052512372,
0.0098973606,
-0.0030849639,
-0.000145414,
-0.0330419093,
-0.0369452946,
-0.0192003716,
0.0167905353,
-0.0207832474,
-0.0090870922,
0.0008486186,
-0.0236986466,
-0.012475593,
-0.0652517676,
-0.0014546425,
0.0152589362,
2.732e-7,
0.0339105763,
0.0787665173,
0.0079101939,
0.0425335728,
-0.0042400383,
0.0536657386,
-0.0089623528,
0.0351684801,
0.0326522626,
-0.0959731489,
0.0185446087,
0.0547992066,
0.0225863904,
0.0709590539,
-0.0599991344,
0.0354401879,
-0.0654311031,
-0.0454957783,
-0.0725415125,
-0.0171862841,
0.0864406675,
0.0741470754,
0.0721189231,
-0.0078834174,
0.0021584418,
-0.0472239479,
0.0733547583,
0.0250285156,
-0.0517925173,
-0.0284383018,
0.027353067,
0.0130889341,
0.0042251139,
0.0635503381,
0.0008760841,
0.0172854848,
-0.0105193676,
0.0397328474,
0.0049219602,
-0.0237755682,
-0.0400467999,
-0.0130049298,
0.0158108566,
-0.0491947457,
0.0932867154,
-0.0493919142,
-0.0604537129,
-0.0295763332,
-0.0426651202,
0.0063008014,
0.0543232001,
0.0231042039,
-0.0303074382,
-0.0037258319,
0.0081432303,
0.0027701273,
0.0020400437,
-0.028997248,
-0.0094446307,
0.042682007,
-0.0227068942,
-0.0234707557,
0.020247167,
-0.0165584162,
0.0746659115,
-0.0437577181,
0.0233446229,
2.19841252e-34,
0.0359520949,
-0.0260997321,
0.0198562704,
-0.0273084547,
0.0447239652,
0.0295361821,
-0.0615865439,
-0.0124049252,
0.0276992545,
-0.0310363956,
0.0259943083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16838v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16838v1 | From Decoding to Meta-Generation: Inference-time Algorithms for Large Language Models | 2024-06-24T17:45:59 | 2024-06-24T17:45:59 | Sean Welleck, Amanda Bertsch, Matthew Finlayson, Hailey Schoelkopf, Alex Xie, Graham Neubig, Ilia Kulikov, Zaid Harchaoui | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | One of the most striking findings in modern research on large language models
(LLMs) is that scaling up compute during training leads to better results.
However, less attention has been given to the benefits of scaling compute
during inference. This survey focuses on these inference-time approaches. We
explore three areas under a unified mathematical formalism: token-level
generation algorithms, meta-generation algorithms, and efficient generation.
Token-level generation algorithms, often called decoding algorithms, operate by
sampling a single token at a time or constructing a token-level search space
and then selecting an output. These methods typically assume access to a
language model's logits, next-token distributions, or probability scores.
Meta-generation algorithms work on partial or full sequences, incorporating
domain knowledge, enabling backtracking, and integrating external information.
Efficient generation methods aim to reduce token costs and improve the speed of
generation. Our survey unifies perspectives from three research communities:
traditional natural language processing, modern LLMs, and machine learning
systems. | [
0.0377919748,
0.0603784919,
-0.0092418604,
0.030587187,
-0.0740080103,
0.0105717182,
-0.0158216581,
-0.0037299383,
-0.0600019656,
-0.0558650829,
0.0111655965,
-0.0248054024,
0.0163634997,
0.0290006865,
0.0169911496,
-0.0317164361,
0.0378735699,
-0.0575877763,
0.0021742233,
-0.0133001702,
-0.0369051918,
0.009710121,
0.0097168954,
0.0701157823,
-0.0032053646,
-0.0102785816,
-0.0085697956,
0.0015294561,
-0.01537883,
-0.0073003136,
-0.0580157079,
0.0273603927,
-0.0042648017,
0.0589624159,
0.0000018137,
-0.0264358278,
-0.0166308694,
0.0035588716,
-0.0326924957,
0.0052859131,
0.0496512651,
-0.0176620539,
-0.000278801,
0.0472451933,
-0.0141881434,
-0.0705882907,
0.0733368546,
-0.0180116985,
0.0055293622,
0.0574103296,
0.0051459214,
-0.0362278447,
0.0029025017,
-0.0131970868,
-0.035324771,
-0.0569206066,
0.0251846667,
-0.031262394,
-0.0301416777,
-0.0057471008,
-0.0351830646,
0.0167356208,
0.0122290179,
0.007412924,
-0.0111953607,
0.053338442,
-0.0407322459,
-0.024089992,
-0.0342646129,
0.0244687144,
-0.0197592508,
-0.0526314639,
-0.0142383054,
-0.0070259417,
0.0083176531,
0.0239449125,
-0.0304457322,
0.0562705249,
-0.0287423339,
0.0438910984,
0.0562418774,
-0.0208720937,
0.0574887507,
-0.0016590406,
-0.0731118247,
0.0787675604,
0.0442485176,
-0.0114718638,
-0.019540254,
-0.0118390946,
-0.0350825489,
-0.0759780332,
-0.0016053193,
0.0161698852,
-0.0369043685,
0.0177529622,
-0.0482612886,
-0.0506721027,
-0.0039499509,
0.0204173867,
0.0282649454,
0.0368853696,
0.0180594344,
0.0288051013,
-0.0115059875,
0.0133866491,
-0.0002504176,
-0.0002978196,
-0.0684050247,
-0.0371954367,
-0.0161735453,
-0.0264701638,
-0.0667580888,
0.0399639308,
-0.0390727855,
-0.0149520198,
-0.0539124981,
0.0161613524,
0.0411576182,
-0.015096982,
0.0354779437,
-0.0232522022,
-0.0273482949,
-0.0069158422,
0.0183712896,
0.0242029279,
-0.0190010052,
0.0055121668,
-0.0004416244,
-0.0399429351,
-0.0065068398,
0.0173893198,
0.0029960701,
-0.0328538306,
-0.0196902137,
0.0864501223,
0.0207165573,
-0.0598273501,
-0.0122850137,
-0.010733163,
-0.0270733852,
-0.0741511732,
-0.0045697843,
-0.0669091269,
0.0244520642,
0.0301943105,
0.0037975318,
-0.0013615265,
-0.0007545642,
-0.0042168503,
-0.0134635465,
0.0540898964,
-0.0156104304,
0.0378022194,
-0.0119889313,
-0.0236488972,
-0.0178040117,
0.0865147933,
0.0212486573,
0.0413572602,
0.0249589048,
-0.0067419079,
-0.0157643892,
0.0575629622,
0.0303437244,
-0.0134097496,
-0.019423373,
-0.0330281444,
0.0410671495,
0.0119953826,
0.0069197332,
0.0762522593,
-0.0581242256,
0.0053377957,
0.0150552019,
0.0725940317,
0.0101796417,
0.0111501114,
0.0930372179,
-0.0154499784,
-0.0006691791,
0.0027452011,
-0.0246093366,
-0.020145895,
0.0155590689,
-0.0075055729,
0.0523911566,
0.0617637672,
-0.0158784445,
-0.0168226194,
-0.0152550656,
-0.0026809378,
-0.0246698726,
-0.0064907935,
0.0861361548,
0.0230993517,
-0.0272990949,
0.0379638523,
0.0203290563,
-0.033224199,
0.0171542652,
-0.087770544,
0.0112341298,
0.0680629462,
0.0565978363,
0.0062671294,
0.0109657431,
0.0226946883,
0.0287495665,
0.0513796061,
-0.009289776,
-0.0239606779,
0.0174778029,
-0.0441078544,
-0.0097652674,
0.0384069905,
0.0242108721,
0.0296993218,
0.0175693855,
-0.0098712603,
0.0150789823,
-0.0950397104,
-0.0207614414,
0.0395904407,
-0.0323184654,
-0.0361730084,
0.0425993539,
0.007110564,
0.0472856648,
0.0198352188,
-0.0048635164,
0.0381405801,
0.0253416579,
-0.0534530431,
-0.0131183714,
0.0577029027,
-0.0153124221,
-0.061039675,
0.0453178585,
-0.0379557423,
-0.0070303623,
-0.0124923615,
-0.0465452038,
-0.0425816327,
0.0397657044,
-0.039273683,
0.1041068658,
-0.0466686487,
0.0285129752,
0.0050479504,
-0.0045640152,
-0.0226661786,
0.0520210825,
-0.0424917676,
0.0062103476,
0.0468036905,
-0.0039600474,
-0.016566975,
-0.0037026198,
0.000484466,
0.0359918922,
-0.0225313548,
0.0005006777,
0.0150597729,
-0.0061429171,
-0.0068188854,
-0.0260093268,
-0.097118929,
-0.0146176964,
-0.0334272832,
0.0289546959,
0.0004090221,
0.0264776517,
0.0040112091,
0.0184608493,
0.0093314601,
0.0109722307,
0.0043367264,
0.0460418575,
-0.0039486759,
0.0306676719,
-0.044613082,
-0.0151386075,
-0.0397198163,
0.0044133463,
0.080460161,
-0.015507875,
-0.0020655086,
-0.0696762279,
-0.0008042509,
0.0058338894,
0.0098915743,
-0.004112131,
-0.0178837925,
0.0108535616,
-0.0451907031,
0.0744376853,
0.0028015822,
0.0202915072,
0.0387579054,
0.0315292925,
-0.0083837425,
-0.0518727824,
-0.0143993469,
-0.0313912556,
-0.0393394232,
-0.0425330475,
-0.0521105602,
0.0171338748,
0.0794161633,
-0.0043762545,
-0.0323618352,
-0.0656886175,
0.0129693635,
-0.0281180814,
-0.0702292323,
-0.0008527669,
0.0086897882,
-0.0193275493,
0.0317112766,
-0.0070707467,
-0.0619414262,
0.0520109311,
-0.0396246687,
0.0260897037,
-0.030312825,
0.0141452877,
-0.018017916,
0.0785766318,
0.0022028948,
0.0391450338,
-0.0143699208,
-0.0579462349,
-0.0023917775,
-0.0037471894,
0.0238094367,
-0.0282233711,
0.0199707821,
-0.0402032882,
0.030688908,
-0.0024845672,
-0.0414778441,
-0.0408001728,
-0.0178854838,
-0.0327828899,
-0.0041619483,
0.0164866969,
-0.0143486401,
-0.037884254,
0.0110688107,
-0.0317577533,
0.0153065361,
-0.0105263339,
0.0061986698,
0.0000318883,
0.0315342881,
0.0392745994,
-0.0229732879,
0.005619172,
-0.0451580174,
0.0110071125,
0.0606494248,
0.0592627563,
0.0424197465,
-0.0278164428,
-0.0303821657,
0.0464281291,
-0.0268811751,
0.008622366,
0.0326606408,
0.0002921101,
-0.0286126286,
-0.0190558471,
0.1191293299,
0.0402754322,
-0.0386408605,
0.0140171601,
-0.0197755024,
0.0325780474,
0.0069224099,
0.0055245114,
-0.0851932392,
-0.0477784686,
0.0362586156,
0.0256754719,
-0.0325124376,
-0.0286237411,
-0.0101839323,
-0.1138213947,
0.0410979576,
0.0042442721,
-0.047985822,
-0.0554163083,
-0.056128405,
-0.0234644152,
-0.0125128375,
0.0249688998,
0.0468695648,
-0.0213781614,
0.0181529615,
0.0424815267,
0.0083529316,
-0.0552488118,
-0.0212391783,
-0.0357702747,
0.0512702465,
0.0470319651,
0.0169729702,
-0.0003177398,
0.0032839875,
0.0579312406,
0.0196906924,
-0.0053729699,
-0.0424320176,
0.0105283698,
-0.0381402709,
0.0102209933,
-0.0025801647,
0.0378522091,
-0.0061395597,
-0.018251121,
0.0136628784,
0.0705986768,
0.0004216188,
-0.0302156974,
-0.0191766657,
-0.01928013,
0.0256612189,
0.0885016024,
0.0424067788,
-0.0507165603,
-0.0334473737,
-0.0296402667,
-0.0005178286,
-0.0451717414,
0.0168446656,
0.0019467098,
0.0224872399,
-0.0276091974,
-0.0480351076,
0.0033242328,
0.0548485219,
0.0360013358,
0.0055621089,
0.0450212844,
0.0154984556,
-0.0124879824,
-0.0715790689,
-0.01050309,
-0.0574050844,
0.005537421,
-0.0583171397,
-0.003259595,
0.0414347053,
-0.0334927365,
-0.0157324281,
0.0498993509,
-0.082660459,
-0.0742745474,
-0.0095145395,
0.041753944,
0.0230033994,
0.0276396666,
0.0018831347,
-0.0252606813,
0.0477613173,
0.0733299777,
-0.0081281466,
0.0064672078,
0.0188800544,
-0.0020539016,
-0.0083374931,
0.052879367,
-0.0304403603,
-0.0003082317,
0.0271405485,
0.0708532184,
0.0158347562,
0.0082183871,
0.0325247794,
0.0399843417,
0.0311192442,
-0.0637077764,
-0.0178071838,
-0.0077071167,
0.015472685,
-0.0263017863,
-0.0103089167,
-0.0450910665,
0.0355927981,
0.0354045443,
-0.0097890161,
-0.0151408771,
-0.028273195,
-0.0189589132,
0.022199437,
0.0131325843,
0.0051448136,
-0.0427229367,
0.0322799534,
0.0680701062,
-0.0404226556,
-0.0062428555,
-0.0180503111,
0.0280771535,
0.0027939861,
-0.0339481682,
-0.0042992402,
0.0408165939,
0.0099540185,
-0.0682382211,
0.0099352375,
-0.0278279223,
-0.0319876336,
-0.0137836458,
0.0380455218,
0.061484497,
0.0254669134,
0.0361276232,
-0.0392310061,
-0.0207474269,
-0.03150649,
0.0397081375,
0.0275226235,
-0.0254187807,
0.0168563761,
0.0007279874,
-0.0419336557,
-0.014215528,
0.0967633128,
0.0312230252,
0.0486659296,
-0.0077271261,
-0.0261090826,
-0.0367068574,
-0.0484173521,
-0.0513678119,
0.0165257528,
-0.0257957466,
0.0289283711,
-0.0935495123,
-0.0793759152,
-0.0131859072,
0.0231641065,
0.0075175059,
0.0141666159,
0.0255244095,
0.0845665559,
0.0180550925,
-0.0240625273,
-0.0414740592,
0.0458810739,
0.0196288116,
-0.0509133898,
0.0129929828,
-6.204147512e-33,
-0.0259497687,
-0.0321665667,
0.0239523575,
-0.0184088051,
-0.0106049767,
-0.0089126267,
-0.0224327482,
0.0037804458,
0.0376846381,
0.0090422453,
-0.0237657074,
0.0100350799,
0.0223646294,
0.0506005585,
0.0004627253,
0.0076883622,
0.0571570732,
-0.0224147011,
-0.0255824216,
0.01441749,
0.0505086184,
0.0240597073,
0.0109338155,
0.0132627338,
-0.0255817212,
0.0125339199,
0.0138870701,
0.0219409876,
-0.0105874594,
0.0403567329,
-0.0235185884,
0.0397579148,
0.0245231651,
-0.0314563662,
-0.0197914876,
0.0047128955,
-0.089659296,
-0.0076662861,
0.0605310723,
-0.0143037066,
-0.043198932,
-0.0507025905,
0.0150816403,
0.025322834,
-0.0286583975,
0.0156630762,
-0.010134913,
-0.0242931023,
-0.0331785493,
-0.0130436877,
-0.0546844453,
0.0399626605,
0.008154422,
0.0182367601,
0.0636525527,
0.022469487,
-0.0102591291,
0.0158786029,
0.0218026508,
0.0527272858,
0.0172741376,
0.0564688928,
0.0467913188,
0.0627324432,
0.0177786425,
0.0422180071,
0.0550493672,
-0.0269988403,
-0.0112087894,
0.0265134107,
0.0210255347,
0.0090718009,
-0.0301830955,
0.0560113899,
0.0494103916,
-0.0139994472,
-0.0776866823,
0.0010021543,
0.0026040184,
0.021435041,
0.0691396296,
-0.0065957424,
-0.014238352,
-0.0316341966,
-0.0728872195,
-0.0475133657,
-0.0299929455,
0.0069336905,
0.0275081396,
0.0488606095,
-0.0584986396,
-0.0306598451,
0.0713195205,
-0.0364465378,
-0.0247041378,
0.0332812667,
0.0115738986,
-0.0046109976,
-0.029302597,
0.0338173918,
-0.0328142382,
-0.0490867533,
0.0152289104,
-0.0089344792,
0.0029115563,
-0.013927348,
-0.0051359893,
0.0115394192,
-0.0538773313,
-0.0035130037,
-0.0419124663,
0.0210159887,
-0.0338134654,
-0.0016311426,
0.0682926327,
0.0291014407,
0.0101857344,
0.0005044111,
0.0137478616,
-0.0077632791,
-0.0089614121,
0.0022818004,
0.0252147019,
0.0243574586,
-0.0316808559,
0.0139711546,
-0.0410409532,
-0.001886635,
0.0623540916,
-0.0479367301,
-0.0298469998,
0.0351973698,
2.551e-7,
0.0518841892,
0.0407208838,
0.0626640692,
0.0058609466,
0.0337760188,
-0.0004339904,
0.0275478903,
0.0067754122,
0.0374174751,
0.0203092434,
0.0061621196,
0.0287904982,
0.0464043245,
0.0124890059,
-0.0892367885,
0.0360040665,
-0.0437927172,
0.0112075713,
-0.0458951853,
-0.0124312378,
0.0148963258,
0.1023669168,
-0.0028224583,
-0.0212947503,
0.0107710194,
-0.0220131725,
0.0430089869,
-0.0231349617,
0.0029265527,
0.0198506936,
-0.0376268998,
0.0227505621,
0.0316635594,
0.013597263,
-0.0045594131,
0.0050237817,
0.013938725,
0.0713720918,
0.0023121277,
0.0191958919,
0.0020696826,
-0.0123780156,
-0.0042517693,
-0.0170382652,
0.0515666716,
-0.0592332333,
-0.0289151538,
-0.0681489855,
-0.0044803242,
-0.0057070092,
-0.0368008241,
-0.0376826301,
-0.0161084402,
0.0572818331,
0.0250812415,
0.0122200511,
0.0116634248,
-0.063206777,
-0.0108308373,
-0.0362286679,
-0.0604657233,
-0.0699979886,
-0.0219516847,
0.0116356602,
0.0325383842,
-0.0804823041,
0.0002648332,
2.560857147e-34,
0.0573231168,
-0.0154064959,
0.0038109543,
0.0347744562,
0.0011945134,
-0.0318648145,
-0.0237339027,
0.0201224498,
-0.0051914956,
-0.0946854278,
-0.0393575169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16833v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16833v1 | USDC: A Dataset of $\underline{U}$ser $\underline{S}$tance and $\underline{D}$ogmatism in Long $\underline{C}$onversations | 2024-06-24T17:41:53 | 2024-06-24T17:41:53 | Mounika Marreddy, Subba Reddy Oota, Venkata Charan Chinni, Manish Gupta, Lucie Flek | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Identifying user's opinions and stances in long conversation threads on
various topics can be extremely critical for enhanced personalization, market
research, political campaigns, customer service, conflict resolution, targeted
advertising, and content moderation. Hence, training language models to
automate this task is critical. However, to train such models, gathering manual
annotations has multiple challenges: 1) It is time-consuming and costly; 2)
Conversation threads could be very long, increasing chances of noisy
annotations; and 3) Interpreting instances where a user changes their opinion
within a conversation is difficult because often such transitions are subtle
and not expressed explicitly. Inspired by the recent success of large language
models (LLMs) for complex natural language processing (NLP) tasks, we leverage
Mistral Large and GPT-4 to automate the human annotation process on the
following two tasks while also providing reasoning: i) User Stance
classification, which involves labeling a user's stance of a post in a
conversation on a five-point scale; ii) User Dogmatism classification, which
deals with labeling a user's overall opinion in the conversation on a
four-point scale. The majority voting on zero-shot, one-shot, and few-shot
annotations from these two LLMs on 764 multi-user Reddit conversations helps us
curate the USDC dataset. USDC is then used to finetune and instruction-tune
multiple deployable small language models for the 5-class stance and 4-class
dogmatism classification tasks. We make the code and dataset publicly available
[https://anonymous.4open.science/r/USDC-0F7F]. | [
0.0647407994,
0.0794606507,
0.0069404235,
0.0279410034,
-0.0291643105,
0.0367705896,
-0.0029623702,
-0.0313751325,
0.0224649161,
-0.0887630656,
-0.0277256593,
-0.0045098546,
-0.0319502875,
-0.0170106366,
-0.0241800193,
-0.0480425358,
0.0384095758,
0.0268438887,
0.0417550243,
-0.0037881576,
0.0679545179,
0.031132292,
-0.0255542099,
0.0304512046,
-0.0254314411,
-0.0455357693,
-0.0019113448,
-0.0151685523,
0.0428751707,
-0.00576034,
0.041003678,
0.0799838752,
0.0035121993,
0.0696463808,
0.0000017131,
-0.0249084439,
-0.0094037745,
-0.0202629715,
0.0213130265,
-0.0076786242,
0.0458675995,
-0.0114801554,
-0.0079513723,
0.036645256,
-0.0615358502,
0.0172666647,
0.0383655578,
0.0825765431,
0.0933792666,
0.0812508613,
-0.0113211013,
-0.0582127869,
-0.0056056334,
-0.036644455,
-0.0318983309,
-0.0517753549,
0.0342799239,
0.0116586732,
-0.0585596934,
0.0672532991,
0.0149773424,
-0.0047991932,
-0.0061706188,
-0.0371295698,
-0.0426576063,
-0.0103905099,
-0.0200232267,
-0.0271252207,
0.0046054097,
0.0763041824,
0.0177762862,
-0.0331994817,
0.0104209799,
0.0121359043,
0.0069117658,
-0.0135562215,
-0.0403275564,
0.0022426441,
-0.0087119788,
0.0483038723,
0.0275081862,
-0.0028958027,
0.0217006467,
0.056564033,
0.008204394,
0.0210138429,
-0.0352673307,
-0.018139258,
0.0172108784,
0.0328290462,
-0.0322056301,
-0.0442821607,
0.0264373869,
-0.001845923,
0.0019582915,
0.0196437258,
-0.0321574844,
0.001116639,
0.0477673076,
-0.0903269202,
0.0022977039,
0.0073163323,
0.0139513342,
0.0821573362,
-0.0019684925,
-0.0051566814,
-0.0307563469,
-0.0139861805,
0.0099691693,
-0.008894342,
-0.0809558704,
0.0091797467,
-0.0337091908,
0.0115686376,
-0.0223516673,
-0.0014580144,
-0.056985788,
0.0146938218,
-0.0315297619,
0.0028677597,
0.0236842893,
-0.0218589138,
0.0159774683,
-0.0100676743,
-0.0241152309,
0.0619426928,
-0.0422512479,
0.0294413641,
-0.0009952574,
-0.0452800952,
0.0123773916,
0.0258772224,
0.0082805175,
-0.0273631085,
-0.0069005648,
0.011066881,
0.0351966321,
0.0096808737,
-0.0108442437,
-0.011530404,
-0.0366322771,
-0.0772677958,
-0.0213035662,
-0.0713057369,
0.0362453312,
0.0052413084,
0.0005338562,
-0.0164478514,
0.0254909117,
0.0461548939,
0.00059353,
0.0942174196,
-0.0120305419,
-0.0198204555,
0.0359700508,
0.0197123997,
0.0156171285,
0.05803461,
-0.0058867945,
0.0419614427,
0.0360384658,
-0.0174532831,
-0.0012788873,
0.012486957,
-0.0057181921,
-0.0210007094,
-0.004642101,
0.0371537358,
-0.0346176848,
-0.001967734,
0.0082982043,
0.07147035,
-0.0127221812,
-0.0322646946,
0.0773613378,
0.0489368662,
-0.0311628878,
0.0254931282,
-0.0047997967,
0.0436577722,
0.0080398554,
-0.0297743361,
-0.0231397338,
0.0075484482,
-0.0251145121,
-0.0541195869,
0.0113921296,
-0.007484992,
-0.0149289863,
-0.0594679751,
-0.0313778892,
-0.0313126035,
0.0291308518,
-0.0030864533,
0.0222725291,
-0.0008300962,
-0.0167440958,
0.0272450447,
0.026865365,
-0.0617884696,
-0.0375979617,
-0.0412662849,
0.0241772383,
0.0408730507,
0.0008701857,
-0.0316651016,
-0.0379051156,
-0.0694429204,
0.0571582392,
0.0522297211,
0.087815173,
-0.0284156669,
-0.0489282608,
-0.0390458591,
0.0000847441,
0.0066780904,
0.001697881,
0.0099187503,
0.0242317691,
0.0067287069,
-0.0087699033,
0.0447277837,
0.0011580937,
0.0149082663,
0.056012325,
-0.0098056598,
0.0010930008,
0.0052827718,
0.0732034668,
0.0325002074,
0.0005956311,
-0.0286585875,
0.012402921,
-0.0097884359,
-0.0561291948,
-0.0033892647,
-0.0196942668,
-0.0247878321,
0.0502155907,
-0.0007934898,
-0.0359649174,
0.0391567275,
-0.0398984291,
-0.0048232945,
0.0225665122,
-0.0261393897,
-0.0077563175,
-0.0491559096,
-0.0278763585,
-0.0322816931,
0.0149692735,
-0.0467501283,
0.0515650921,
-0.0197339579,
-0.0089147491,
-0.0383386686,
-0.0383259915,
0.0191014428,
-0.0191456024,
-0.0408744514,
-0.012597423,
0.029925013,
0.0247390792,
0.0588698685,
-0.0140581615,
-0.0179276206,
-0.0488040261,
-0.1128662378,
-0.0059961407,
-0.0224260688,
0.0500950925,
0.0233382005,
-0.0034404846,
0.0251498967,
-0.0012226468,
-0.0341747031,
0.015031972,
-0.0080688512,
0.0353968516,
0.0562538132,
-0.0219500437,
0.0132879326,
-0.0491284765,
-0.0037827671,
-0.0163047705,
-0.0057813958,
0.0330219492,
-0.0396038964,
-0.040370658,
0.0085354447,
-0.0342993848,
0.018654814,
-0.0205966327,
-0.0765660256,
0.0253296141,
-0.0003211288,
0.0348620303,
0.0547987446,
0.0401364565,
0.0821285918,
0.003223656,
0.0418661945,
-0.0495165065,
-0.0037961761,
-0.0279528797,
-0.0041275038,
-0.0476478748,
0.0133530628,
0.0153848873,
0.0984136984,
-0.013819335,
-0.0023722677,
-0.0473316833,
0.0411787815,
-0.0204044301,
-0.0063835736,
0.005421761,
-0.0171562396,
-0.0133241462,
0.0065288092,
-0.0139661962,
-0.0372392647,
0.070808813,
0.013202861,
0.014580939,
-0.0521313734,
-0.0425072126,
-0.0375190414,
0.0536279045,
0.0085168406,
0.0012206152,
-0.0323235467,
0.0096626068,
0.0304123294,
-0.03591948,
0.0110571086,
-0.0540864095,
0.0162916221,
-0.0073023485,
0.0398739576,
-0.0060316492,
-0.051594954,
-0.0083106905,
-0.0559914857,
-0.069472827,
-0.0198964085,
0.0153974798,
-0.0174968466,
0.0107325008,
0.0059719249,
-0.0103126308,
0.0112656569,
-0.0216538236,
-0.0000453184,
0.004064851,
0.0134936869,
0.0491493754,
-0.0032109509,
0.0135579379,
-0.003525445,
0.0267626848,
0.0825692937,
-0.0121143209,
0.0124141118,
-0.0462039113,
-0.0619540885,
0.0180605929,
-0.032959789,
0.0030814765,
-0.0609315,
0.0794013441,
-0.0490583591,
0.0210020933,
0.1117444783,
0.0299033318,
-0.0556044914,
-0.0141485455,
0.0049272068,
-0.0010083563,
0.0263803732,
-0.006709469,
-0.1129827127,
-0.0508715101,
-0.03003156,
0.025074739,
-0.0285049435,
-0.0377165228,
0.0033500034,
-0.0899003968,
0.0005791792,
-0.0233844854,
-0.0423638076,
0.0032996463,
-0.0628554001,
0.0220571309,
-0.0442526639,
0.0074063614,
-0.0239489693,
0.01955509,
0.0033341618,
0.0209388901,
-0.0520989485,
-0.0321371406,
0.0325038806,
-0.0226671025,
0.0398781523,
0.0153988069,
0.0496849045,
0.0193495434,
-0.0411402844,
0.0945716426,
-0.0247864425,
-0.021958014,
-0.0290726069,
0.0529035255,
-0.0317926705,
-0.0189942811,
-0.0510611311,
0.0507769845,
-0.0360565633,
-0.000800116,
-0.0237341765,
0.060135249,
-0.0056561017,
-0.0076591391,
-0.0125068631,
0.0301845595,
0.0578704402,
0.0674883723,
0.0275400653,
-0.06229477,
-0.0385775641,
-0.0336224996,
0.0029256493,
-0.0485658459,
-0.0294107869,
-0.0487235114,
0.0219342411,
-0.0020114211,
-0.0437578931,
-0.0456617661,
0.0154869715,
-0.0029992783,
-0.0216264967,
-0.010166483,
0.0239881277,
0.0173739288,
-0.0300541762,
0.0555488877,
-0.0181492139,
0.0184807796,
-0.03393225,
-0.038164977,
0.0665133297,
0.010455071,
-0.024528781,
0.0367421061,
-0.0878938958,
-0.0562646538,
-0.0108839832,
0.0570963696,
0.0213578008,
0.0258457437,
-0.0191472378,
-0.0554200672,
-0.0390423685,
0.0504038557,
0.0114910137,
-0.0345890298,
0.0430910252,
0.0836923271,
0.004388643,
0.0468867868,
0.0201315489,
0.034192238,
0.0057597049,
-0.0053599817,
-0.0862183347,
-0.0177994389,
0.0119910585,
-0.0111960983,
0.0246957839,
0.0335102901,
-0.01725577,
-0.0238462202,
-0.0131704435,
-0.0243027564,
-0.0368665755,
-0.0277266447,
-0.0123274093,
0.0250076279,
-0.0607063882,
-0.0457446128,
-0.0067855893,
-0.0236218702,
0.0361069515,
-0.0376714095,
0.0454598553,
0.0344066359,
0.015101891,
0.0034410825,
-0.0192351062,
-0.043300014,
0.0072321068,
0.009404608,
0.00768709,
-0.0128385304,
0.0577565469,
0.0110726478,
-0.009942485,
0.0390632451,
0.0204166677,
-0.0086456034,
-0.0169766452,
0.0115390206,
0.0397371165,
0.0258476939,
-0.0260473732,
0.07050208,
-0.0201811139,
-0.0436902866,
-0.0225248523,
0.0514669381,
-0.0260519367,
-0.0192054585,
0.0183296502,
0.0265922826,
-0.04408288,
0.0016547573,
0.0525233224,
-0.0426415019,
0.0132455043,
0.046887394,
-0.0603858232,
-0.0464185402,
0.0007551415,
-0.0198587384,
0.0200259909,
0.0044561257,
0.0359438658,
-0.0339039043,
-0.0342871472,
-0.0207002554,
-0.0016097999,
0.0044741658,
0.0129388198,
0.0080828518,
0.0614376776,
-0.0019786789,
0.0151466243,
-0.0751004592,
0.0297779925,
-0.006810918,
-0.0349258259,
-0.0338850096,
-5.818147493e-33,
0.0184049997,
-0.032744851,
-0.0124049047,
0.041252479,
-0.0013432379,
-0.012703835,
0.0011437146,
0.0212668628,
-0.0165205393,
0.0520966761,
0.0196420271,
0.0298404973,
-0.0016983189,
0.0356575288,
0.0045119934,
-0.0021809584,
0.0353288874,
-0.0262611322,
-0.0186316408,
0.0361997597,
0.0390325449,
-0.0276043154,
0.0439649113,
-0.073384352,
0.0354443416,
0.008893637,
-0.0068308832,
0.042087432,
0.0030736215,
0.0605101287,
-0.0184552241,
0.0486728698,
0.0553595498,
-0.0183950886,
0.0200262479,
0.0689140782,
-0.0651310459,
-0.0002227548,
-0.0002288665,
0.0247630738,
-0.0138556873,
-0.0242651701,
0.0377107039,
-0.0203618705,
-0.0356024541,
0.0039565065,
0.0166910216,
-0.0073904744,
0.0336998589,
-0.0267433412,
-0.0434082784,
0.0316067524,
-0.0252040289,
-0.0481186397,
-0.0144602004,
-0.0059419018,
0.0112271849,
0.0639538392,
-0.0718655959,
0.0071035838,
-0.0437784232,
0.0178531874,
0.0012006835,
-0.0312313642,
0.0101453559,
0.0740363747,
0.0108855693,
0.0610242896,
-0.0446215086,
0.0093002776,
-0.0332679376,
0.0120476326,
0.0585197136,
0.0277891774,
0.0226876438,
-0.0327849388,
-0.0709958449,
-0.0181156825,
0.062967889,
0.0199568085,
0.0415893197,
0.0118452068,
-0.0229359753,
0.0069567626,
0.0159762688,
-0.0583601482,
-0.0200943537,
0.0056089777,
-0.0244140141,
0.0017173798,
-0.029503094,
0.0251900107,
0.0238317214,
-0.0393661633,
-0.0495110974,
0.0413201563,
0.0017295007,
0.0081336107,
0.0199904926,
0.0185827129,
-0.0387628749,
0.0325879604,
-0.0142505746,
-0.0184646714,
0.0191088524,
-0.0105980616,
0.0905255601,
-0.0035757355,
-0.069104068,
-0.0204886831,
-0.018611582,
0.0425260849,
-0.0593305081,
0.0755924061,
0.0470369607,
0.0352459587,
0.0041759061,
0.0663591176,
0.0173831452,
0.0410377868,
-0.0058313217,
-0.0192635413,
-0.015802579,
-0.010642129,
-0.0021953562,
-0.0315013714,
-0.0038752267,
0.0367892012,
-0.0353539772,
-0.0621725023,
0.0137567092,
-0.0088593774,
2.459e-7,
0.0376265272,
0.0744684711,
0.001226373,
-0.0147091504,
0.0583873428,
0.0439556576,
0.0069027655,
0.0182336941,
-0.0081455037,
-0.0394720808,
-0.0170366857,
0.05377803,
0.0518288016,
0.0265813768,
-0.075849779,
-0.0286397245,
-0.0434987508,
0.0007833451,
-0.032153111,
0.0216142256,
0.042457547,
0.0869055092,
0.0476275869,
-0.0155718969,
-0.017916223,
0.0087008355,
0.0622799434,
-0.0024945049,
-0.0276216678,
0.0089069167,
0.0454266779,
-0.0427369289,
-0.004363168,
-0.0012581913,
-0.0000088272,
0.0038760139,
-0.0026803862,
0.081944786,
0.0033202881,
-0.0137874829,
-0.0020941882,
-0.0186428092,
0.0051213196,
-0.02974662,
0.0543841794,
-0.0789026543,
-0.0516841859,
-0.0790756792,
-0.0173949674,
-0.0259920713,
0.045672223,
-0.0035467828,
-0.010378371,
0.0031601654,
0.004612308,
-0.0171920843,
-0.0153214531,
-0.0566268414,
0.0024522792,
0.0004474267,
-0.0631034598,
-0.028969273,
0.0100668818,
0.0076826182,
0.038354449,
-0.0200551171,
0.0230255071,
1.818376573e-34,
0.0441486984,
-0.0269247573,
-0.0051740119,
0.0037550055,
0.0489609726,
0.0406098962,
-0.0078960089,
0.0057222485,
0.0413627923,
-0.055812154,
0.0029007753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16829v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16829v1 | Understanding and Mitigating Tokenization Bias in Language Models | 2024-06-24T17:38:02 | 2024-06-24T17:38:02 | Buu Phan, Marton Havasi, Matthew Muckley, Karen Ullrich | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | State-of-the-art language models are autoregressive and operate on subword
units known as tokens. Specifically, one must encode the conditioning string
into a list of tokens before passing to the language models for next-token
prediction. We show that, for encoding schemes such as maximum prefix matching,
tokenization induces a sampling bias that cannot be mitigated with more
training or data. To counter this universal problem, we propose a novel
algorithm to obtain unbiased estimates from a model that was trained on
tokenized data. Our method does not require finetuning the model, and its
complexity, defined as the number of model runs, scales linearly with the
sequence length. As a consequence, we show that one can simulate token-free
behavior from a tokenized language model. We empirically verify the correctness
of our method through a Markov-chain setup, where it accurately recovers the
transition probabilities, as opposed to the conventional method of directly
prompting tokens into the language model. | [
0.0261591915,
0.0851395279,
-0.0159367919,
0.0220312569,
-0.0371136107,
0.0006552357,
0.0135159912,
0.0157818794,
-0.0359830968,
-0.0404724292,
0.0257656164,
-0.0464766249,
0.0039720009,
0.0565061457,
0.0448524803,
-0.0472590253,
0.0542426221,
-0.0625373796,
0.014603721,
-0.0123572713,
0.0052380925,
0.011671829,
0.0161248967,
0.0851682201,
-0.0321664624,
0.0166734587,
-0.0039109406,
-0.005020767,
-0.0390109532,
-0.0259266999,
-0.0059825038,
0.063496612,
-0.0013420504,
0.0325903967,
0.0000018825,
-0.035910897,
-0.0352829285,
-0.0290347319,
-0.0007378435,
-0.0098320022,
0.0554858483,
-0.0127234049,
0.0021925915,
0.0474435948,
-0.0048145596,
-0.0166676566,
0.0472260155,
0.0157143194,
0.0146489572,
0.0380090214,
-0.0007087055,
0.00846125,
-0.0078980774,
-0.0309926961,
-0.0193496477,
-0.0291334614,
0.0435362644,
-0.0339066125,
-0.0168472249,
-0.0100249797,
-0.0609431379,
0.0106173372,
-0.0081516849,
0.0132971043,
-0.0107561564,
0.0506758727,
-0.003368499,
-0.0232331362,
-0.0216171071,
0.0140360026,
-0.0491195358,
-0.0529913493,
0.0272063594,
-0.0073106191,
-0.0031577116,
-0.002633519,
-0.0327615067,
0.0128053874,
0.0212145466,
0.0379876643,
0.0273508206,
0.0025872027,
0.0336317904,
0.005605611,
-0.0544380806,
0.0935265347,
0.0383819081,
-0.0273307525,
-0.0241812244,
-0.0113266185,
0.026249785,
-0.0936922431,
0.0015458924,
-0.0193213038,
-0.0279186964,
0.0293661486,
-0.0478547327,
-0.0260751434,
0.0003573828,
0.0102910995,
-0.0041903849,
0.0310257338,
0.013146772,
0.0062853056,
-0.0238566697,
0.0264998693,
0.0191507656,
0.0087463921,
-0.049180571,
-0.0085850889,
-0.0134655563,
-0.0074199871,
-0.0536191352,
0.0192496143,
-0.0168497916,
-0.0123045398,
-0.033141911,
0.0008744411,
0.0252730791,
-0.0312177408,
-0.0289397445,
0.0011861448,
-0.0487129092,
0.007269531,
-0.0143713923,
-0.0050224676,
-0.0445266403,
0.0160667691,
0.0134083889,
-0.0582602434,
-0.0149677712,
0.0012204838,
0.0006309979,
-0.0465483926,
-0.0129494648,
0.0928605422,
0.0219907165,
-0.0286571309,
-0.0051857419,
-0.0447993986,
-0.017016748,
-0.0007752651,
-0.0014834824,
-0.0684508011,
0.0104718218,
0.0273568165,
0.007747137,
-0.020714093,
-0.0146481926,
-0.0026336764,
-0.0607877374,
0.0577844493,
-0.0217209049,
0.0003976675,
-0.0203177501,
-0.0221444536,
0.0129429027,
0.0762704536,
0.0235075559,
0.0316011496,
0.0598136447,
0.002050261,
0.0070149559,
0.0783998445,
0.0437705293,
0.0050354656,
-0.0435973033,
-0.0079379668,
0.0647468567,
0.0177086852,
0.0659129769,
0.0508236736,
-0.0288866851,
-0.0307793338,
0.0101349484,
0.0758172497,
-0.0351225175,
0.0011050763,
0.050921686,
-0.0190546028,
-0.0242335126,
0.0357769653,
-0.0278620217,
-0.0233098157,
0.018563807,
0.0126054175,
0.0646181703,
0.0470284708,
-0.0221154243,
-0.0198485311,
-0.0181670971,
-0.021335816,
0.022725448,
-0.0407981984,
0.0360507295,
0.0068180417,
-0.0248806924,
0.0840474963,
0.0324304961,
-0.0302093569,
0.015369487,
-0.0684251264,
0.0033970177,
0.0468661562,
0.0487921871,
0.0087090442,
0.0040734275,
-0.0104604568,
0.0317091793,
0.0411025025,
0.0212391708,
-0.0058881775,
0.0256606005,
-0.0361833833,
-0.0296204463,
0.0677243173,
0.0143292602,
0.0397019796,
-0.0028647636,
0.0187423509,
0.0148528581,
-0.0728157684,
-0.0251548234,
0.0556629822,
-0.0439046286,
-0.0423132814,
-0.0047982284,
-0.0026317562,
0.0530575588,
-0.0030163124,
-0.0060032462,
0.0332055315,
0.0170606561,
-0.0008440032,
-0.0023143434,
0.0117410878,
-0.0522757359,
-0.0095020076,
0.0602429509,
-0.0090931989,
0.0069539715,
0.013709479,
-0.0193993282,
-0.0444686301,
0.0298238117,
-0.0107626943,
0.1183802038,
-0.0119875995,
0.0275951959,
-0.0072130766,
0.027049955,
-0.0185362343,
0.0158089846,
-0.0254865531,
0.0304497872,
-0.0024643424,
-0.0232414976,
0.0090312455,
-0.0247775931,
-0.0336376242,
-0.0051636994,
-0.0160703678,
-0.0046453332,
0.058287628,
-0.0145719945,
-0.0311181098,
-0.0094505064,
-0.0964425951,
-0.0338387564,
-0.0189037491,
-0.00075803,
-0.0179208871,
0.0401838906,
-0.0315479971,
-0.0249357112,
-0.0224258695,
-0.0595404729,
-0.0032759504,
0.0464808382,
0.0185240358,
0.0059893546,
-0.0468228832,
-0.0636106953,
-0.0297396816,
-0.0399347357,
0.0617586188,
-0.0080676964,
-0.017716134,
-0.0477858558,
-0.0391570516,
-0.0338361487,
0.0505899787,
-0.0151951862,
-0.0339523144,
0.0328688137,
-0.0304849297,
0.0413613096,
0.0280649532,
0.0371011943,
0.0025029078,
0.0399023294,
-0.0192392021,
-0.0650745034,
-0.0270266291,
-0.0309018716,
0.0006447641,
-0.0323032774,
-0.0449916534,
0.0196862333,
0.0996269435,
-0.0032030572,
-0.0053551761,
-0.0597757883,
0.009380308,
-0.0076518343,
-0.0336317234,
-0.0007824178,
-0.0212691687,
-0.042044878,
0.041310329,
-0.0183158647,
-0.0652928352,
0.0699216351,
-0.062474627,
0.0252814628,
-0.0142120803,
0.0341703892,
-0.003180821,
0.0303349327,
0.0299460478,
0.0185138844,
0.0190750882,
-0.0319590904,
-0.0290429536,
-0.0024815428,
-0.0097135464,
-0.0215875097,
0.0036340514,
-0.0208740272,
0.0165194683,
0.0330265574,
-0.0241327379,
-0.0370837711,
-0.0363122746,
-0.0330270976,
0.0120480033,
0.0490784571,
-0.0191679858,
-0.0169462338,
0.0342087559,
-0.0190354548,
0.0487264767,
-0.0152082536,
0.0128229102,
-0.0130195878,
0.0115381554,
0.0798713267,
-0.0461684093,
0.0196797941,
-0.03131501,
0.0070048119,
0.0299136937,
0.1208282411,
0.0279858615,
-0.0284650121,
-0.0115919132,
0.0380577855,
-0.0527680814,
-0.0078665577,
0.0517261922,
0.0193623006,
-0.0053289919,
-0.0334149823,
0.1388955712,
0.0252221245,
-0.0346309841,
0.0282317642,
0.0121043809,
0.0709896833,
0.0177185219,
0.0076757367,
-0.0731921494,
-0.0322632603,
0.0408121757,
0.0313411616,
-0.0060406742,
-0.0515365116,
0.0148229422,
-0.1171470955,
-0.0122332508,
0.0121891983,
-0.0592128821,
-0.0305103175,
-0.0474150702,
0.0101785827,
-0.0152018871,
0.0423429646,
0.0162044521,
-0.0184811987,
0.0261776987,
0.052261088,
-0.0436279736,
-0.0220438633,
0.0036881999,
-0.0719736218,
0.0750341937,
0.0614811033,
0.01457245,
-0.0117279375,
-0.0078620706,
0.0613850094,
0.0271631628,
0.0045627998,
-0.0190363228,
0.0148945525,
-0.037346188,
0.0007964986,
0.0209640879,
0.0165123045,
0.0094924457,
0.00106106,
0.0030381205,
0.0511510037,
0.0136211719,
-0.0227079969,
-0.0300728455,
-0.037546888,
0.0250233486,
0.083573252,
0.0416545011,
-0.0513787195,
-0.0188442767,
-0.0496837199,
0.0239571966,
-0.0126684997,
0.0026766208,
-0.055481866,
-0.0133598363,
-0.0057378444,
-0.0732066184,
-0.0198693629,
0.0361854285,
0.0564824753,
0.0071390625,
0.0115548419,
-0.0176373348,
-0.0217950772,
-0.0244143661,
-0.0097460253,
-0.0420747213,
0.0250792075,
-0.091861099,
0.017001709,
-0.0086448966,
-0.0030777915,
-0.049698323,
0.0271793362,
-0.0706868395,
-0.0833829194,
0.0309477467,
0.0610958673,
0.024725683,
0.0686004683,
-0.0032361362,
-0.0458180569,
0.0534162484,
0.027403269,
-0.0096782204,
0.0057076653,
0.0173447225,
-0.0317180566,
0.0031678423,
0.0201805122,
-0.0513486937,
0.0016375988,
0.0168119762,
0.0502161644,
-0.0055085914,
-0.0219796766,
0.0031231856,
-0.0015543301,
0.1018199921,
-0.0592573881,
0.0192473792,
-0.0118079372,
-0.0045459997,
-0.0000489925,
0.0011083389,
-0.0140857948,
0.0261961129,
-0.003554655,
0.0309945829,
-0.0062872348,
-0.0438893363,
-0.0494817086,
0.017097814,
0.0101051126,
0.0059770448,
-0.0329401046,
0.0311907884,
0.0457304567,
-0.0251562651,
0.0101904301,
0.0114969872,
0.0024740391,
0.0369027965,
-0.0356050469,
-0.0159532689,
0.0305791833,
0.0385871977,
-0.0159324463,
0.0054166457,
-0.0571571812,
-0.0129436795,
-0.0435414426,
0.0252251402,
0.018435929,
-0.0523216911,
0.0168878175,
-0.0325448215,
0.0235570483,
-0.0229594689,
0.0044291359,
0.0145198675,
-0.040562056,
0.0273409244,
0.0099248998,
-0.0609046295,
0.0017486544,
0.0748666227,
0.0648945943,
0.050261531,
-0.0159009714,
-0.0400000177,
-0.0066490015,
-0.0033827082,
0.0105853006,
0.013548566,
-0.0257915724,
-0.0175839402,
-0.0510490388,
-0.0972272158,
0.0002869134,
0.0175815839,
0.0188982785,
0.0179033745,
0.0167699978,
0.0592290424,
-0.0166773908,
0.0073646763,
-0.0419305973,
0.018639233,
0.0417040624,
-0.0524784923,
-0.0031227432,
-6.456469578e-33,
-0.0138513101,
-0.0013362328,
-0.0304033887,
-0.0159185249,
0.0048839827,
0.0004304365,
-0.0223142989,
-0.0038975715,
-0.0028331263,
-0.0131506454,
-0.0422354937,
-0.010339939,
0.0257217623,
0.013512806,
0.0417133048,
0.0205221251,
0.0483570993,
-0.0271893069,
-0.0334864669,
-0.0030513019,
0.0297666546,
0.0356974229,
0.0407561623,
0.0058230506,
0.0198984537,
-0.0225352533,
0.0012424813,
-0.0050889752,
0.0380177349,
0.055794701,
-0.0036004793,
0.0075693945,
0.0182612035,
-0.0447810106,
-0.0335359424,
0.0154893203,
-0.0613587759,
-0.0257163737,
0.0413639657,
0.0058765751,
0.0033278062,
-0.0092657497,
0.0225169268,
-0.0118667334,
-0.0605626218,
0.0385579728,
0.0304602478,
-0.0044456637,
-0.0393792354,
-0.0140933068,
-0.0389127918,
0.0276837274,
-0.0029679569,
0.0262767039,
0.0387510695,
0.0060299579,
0.0225665011,
-0.0003154445,
-0.0041991957,
0.0312395357,
0.0287742242,
0.0895039141,
0.0473661125,
0.0594152957,
0.0170606989,
0.0607332438,
0.0525388233,
-0.0249240156,
0.0173563324,
0.0425285473,
0.0633570254,
-0.0333183892,
0.0107685803,
-0.0146282725,
0.0472531021,
-0.0359525345,
-0.026648175,
0.0093132276,
0.0502371639,
0.0445405655,
0.0307041258,
0.0081129475,
-0.057938233,
-0.0404951759,
-0.053882733,
-0.0683769882,
-0.0100807417,
-0.0366553962,
0.0402592085,
0.0202090368,
-0.0127266115,
-0.0116769588,
0.0617656447,
-0.0206283815,
-0.0903031155,
0.0170114711,
0.0034103289,
-0.0245047361,
-0.0137264058,
0.0441757403,
-0.0472769476,
-0.0413760245,
0.0164570399,
-0.006669356,
0.022736432,
-0.0054910681,
0.0066409111,
0.003571793,
-0.0805941522,
-0.0139810769,
-0.0394034013,
0.0093283104,
0.0102344668,
0.0053549567,
0.0845767781,
-0.0081451759,
0.0159103479,
-0.0095857233,
0.0155323949,
-0.035320133,
-0.0129715549,
0.0105335703,
-0.0025487132,
0.0184110235,
-0.0454900861,
-0.0151634561,
-0.0541567057,
0.0350474119,
0.0358458348,
-0.0313225836,
-0.0293825641,
0.0390393622,
2.583e-7,
0.0234728791,
0.0612831302,
0.057266064,
-0.0213422142,
0.0068765855,
0.0280617382,
-0.0105895987,
0.0396896824,
0.014791253,
0.000370675,
-0.0189216584,
-0.0148458574,
0.0283738729,
0.0068326406,
-0.1161478013,
0.0141471336,
-0.0979926735,
0.0661100447,
-0.0548217185,
-0.0216556937,
-0.0013969513,
0.1182954311,
0.0228382442,
0.0056697871,
-0.0217449646,
-0.0452567339,
0.0007489722,
-0.0185744073,
0.0076297224,
0.0233790558,
0.0023096672,
0.0108011104,
0.0084691364,
0.0036474448,
-0.0341172963,
0.0215297062,
0.0177952647,
0.0048493575,
-0.0240337364,
0.0048051639,
0.0301355515,
-0.0185629018,
-0.009041626,
-0.0554195531,
0.059844844,
0.0139817484,
0.028106939,
-0.091665417,
-0.0270133875,
0.0258092768,
-0.0197532009,
-0.007687584,
-0.0388696529,
0.0654435605,
0.0372156911,
0.0162048675,
0.0071887965,
-0.0686937943,
-0.0329778083,
-0.0540963002,
-0.0383401588,
-0.0375700817,
-0.0492757931,
0.0328573547,
0.0026533713,
-0.037367247,
-0.0124303401,
2.604961833e-34,
0.0606337115,
-0.018685976,
0.0100830207,
0.0139121227,
0.0351469629,
-0.0331982747,
0.0223488528,
0.0555584617,
0.0121780634,
-0.0638440475,
-0.0501282252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16828v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16828v1 | Ragnarök: A Reusable RAG Framework and Baselines for TREC 2024 Retrieval-Augmented Generation Track | 2024-06-24T17:37:52 | 2024-06-24T17:37:52 | Ronak Pradeep, Nandan Thakur, Sahel Sharifymoghaddam, Eric Zhang, Ryan Nguyen, Daniel Campos, Nick Craswell, Jimmy Lin | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Did you try out the new Bing Search? Or maybe you fiddled around with Google
AI~Overviews? These might sound familiar because the modern-day search stack
has recently evolved to include retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) systems.
They allow searching and incorporating real-time data into large language
models (LLMs) to provide a well-informed, attributed, concise summary in
contrast to the traditional search paradigm that relies on displaying a ranked
list of documents. Therefore, given these recent advancements, it is crucial to
have an arena to build, test, visualize, and systematically evaluate RAG-based
search systems. With this in mind, we propose the TREC 2024 RAG Track to foster
innovation in evaluating RAG systems. In our work, we lay out the steps we've
made towards making this track a reality -- we describe the details of our
reusable framework, Ragnar\"ok, explain the curation of the new MS MARCO V2.1
collection choice, release the development topics for the track, and
standardize the I/O definitions which assist the end user. Next, using
Ragnar\"ok, we identify and provide key industrial baselines such as OpenAI's
GPT-4o or Cohere's Command R+. Further, we introduce a web-based user interface
for an interactive arena allowing benchmarking pairwise RAG systems by
crowdsourcing. We open-source our Ragnar\"ok framework and baselines to achieve
a unified standard for future RAG systems. | [
0.0397682004,
0.0387439281,
-0.0149081331,
0.0000248199,
-0.0158518795,
-0.0257741231,
-0.0078825811,
-0.0047045508,
-0.0380847044,
-0.021741394,
-0.0475500189,
-0.0068704477,
-0.0171567947,
0.0374720246,
0.0002717378,
-0.0365824699,
0.049333185,
-0.0124526396,
-0.0472281277,
0.0205212347,
0.0050244713,
0.0229391586,
-0.0105987443,
0.0609613732,
-0.0169835445,
0.0158936456,
-0.0270170029,
0.0239838809,
0.028261628,
-0.0324896239,
-0.0009809103,
0.0454167537,
0.0406494737,
0.0947339237,
0.0000018414,
-0.0618452206,
-0.0100289835,
-0.002327296,
-0.0079037789,
0.0142427757,
0.0359801278,
0.0705041513,
0.0089784805,
0.0311946068,
-0.0336556546,
-0.0130699808,
0.0329203233,
-0.0132621182,
0.0400226153,
0.0538911261,
0.0061934846,
-0.0107227415,
0.0408460684,
-0.0449294858,
0.0520310625,
-0.0369528532,
-0.025916243,
0.0089777624,
0.0715581328,
0.0142120095,
0.0148733463,
0.0433113761,
0.0122031672,
-0.0314014927,
0.0342494398,
0.0329250246,
-0.093832545,
-0.0096499026,
-0.006413728,
0.0529453382,
0.0499660075,
-0.0492398031,
-0.0009823607,
0.0287863687,
-0.0224105287,
0.0083326474,
-0.0425842553,
0.0146728503,
-0.0179456603,
0.0331000723,
-0.0188768879,
0.0195708703,
0.0178587604,
0.0294522122,
0.0066146939,
0.0817487538,
0.0337095037,
-0.0239553154,
0.0146256573,
0.023972366,
0.0153093645,
-0.011610589,
0.0222243089,
0.0247564372,
-0.075035654,
0.0116909379,
-0.0187605731,
-0.04668843,
0.045983687,
0.0161841512,
0.0367509909,
0.0279563591,
-0.0221373383,
0.0517994761,
-0.0253542587,
0.0397957191,
-0.0175466873,
-0.0320090912,
-0.0598076917,
-0.0479183346,
-0.0433366261,
-0.0284843501,
-0.0698602125,
0.0227572471,
-0.0549644753,
-0.0299643483,
-0.024838455,
0.0385977924,
-0.0006004743,
-0.0185779519,
0.0086712269,
0.0096398126,
-0.0886223167,
0.0138095878,
-0.047819782,
0.0102950111,
-0.0259918515,
-0.0276878551,
0.0238117352,
-0.0701956674,
0.0036039394,
0.0229068454,
-0.0080572721,
-0.0251484402,
0.0006542185,
-0.0020950518,
0.001351821,
-0.0290476345,
0.0139846951,
-0.0510700047,
-0.0008522377,
-0.0449877344,
0.0114559093,
-0.0545247197,
0.0155342864,
-0.0215465371,
-0.0076255929,
-0.0069314949,
0.0028328227,
0.0514647625,
0.0005688668,
0.0194634777,
-0.0261480175,
0.0168812331,
0.0301864035,
0.0029707882,
0.0548960939,
0.0646480918,
0.0098902062,
0.0790108219,
0.0365151539,
0.0128803039,
0.0009363414,
0.0433973335,
0.012814017,
0.0239659585,
-0.0501097217,
0.0221533552,
-0.0229559932,
0.0525516793,
0.0147119286,
0.0529642217,
-0.0305344854,
0.0145497881,
0.0068105236,
0.0261846874,
0.0410126746,
0.0223507956,
0.0649535432,
-0.002005598,
0.0082765501,
-0.0354633778,
0.023227144,
0.0273542516,
-0.0393953584,
0.0348147415,
0.0587834157,
0.0169678181,
-0.0320129357,
-0.0165492538,
-0.0265774112,
0.0382217765,
-0.04722929,
-0.0047007138,
0.0481706448,
0.0131168319,
-0.0411797501,
-0.0109826596,
-0.0090290476,
-0.0808269233,
0.0345737934,
-0.0767771751,
0.0285259597,
0.0891103372,
0.1189677641,
-0.0405262187,
-0.026877908,
0.0306515954,
-0.011922935,
0.0719710067,
0.0681445748,
-0.020584261,
-0.0256217308,
-0.0470774882,
-0.0644355267,
0.0291477609,
-0.0212592948,
0.0358206108,
0.026355546,
0.0165533274,
0.0267516747,
-0.0281637609,
-0.0301493909,
0.0314580724,
-0.0109163672,
0.0019549052,
-0.004963513,
-0.0077394885,
0.0116567751,
0.0424256772,
-0.0184846316,
0.030154448,
0.0609010719,
-0.0023246405,
-0.0023582815,
-0.0080961185,
-0.0012095922,
0.0116844559,
0.0141171273,
-0.0487040356,
0.0055610798,
0.0742257982,
-0.0355380289,
-0.0333088562,
-0.0032606293,
-0.0461456925,
-0.0051413449,
-0.0648091212,
-0.0067486158,
-0.0062936898,
0.0134565476,
-0.0469091907,
0.0513961129,
0.003190577,
-0.0003019024,
0.0236888546,
0.0138737606,
0.0181698427,
-0.0991862863,
-0.0504065268,
0.000213754,
0.0080004577,
0.0126103265,
0.0523849763,
0.021315055,
-0.0592529923,
0.00974405,
-0.1192665026,
0.0384193994,
-0.021901045,
0.0044057183,
0.0109889405,
0.0176596008,
-0.0062543866,
-0.0156425238,
-0.0143350381,
-0.0091143679,
0.0547746494,
0.0117550213,
0.0290506389,
0.0203890204,
0.0095054628,
-0.0464242846,
-0.039364472,
-0.0073146573,
0.0257729143,
0.0254009925,
0.0097649721,
-0.0505505726,
0.0254552327,
-0.0563650616,
0.0297884792,
0.0090228729,
-0.0049661854,
0.0496357158,
-0.0502191707,
0.0337114446,
0.0093664266,
0.0279766005,
0.0305068847,
0.0451673977,
-0.0162077826,
-0.0700288787,
0.0355588757,
-0.0178839099,
-0.0270479023,
0.0276509207,
-0.0293082632,
0.0364444181,
0.0057128579,
-0.0256125312,
-0.0138989529,
-0.0406010672,
-0.0135393906,
-0.0098911934,
-0.0350765288,
-0.0423246808,
-0.0148227941,
-0.0020420041,
0.030516386,
-0.0230248831,
-0.0465571024,
0.0476112403,
-0.0284527261,
-0.0037117535,
-0.0735779181,
0.0173183978,
-0.0525490567,
0.0520378798,
-0.026984049,
0.0133864731,
-0.071685493,
0.0140421949,
-0.0189788323,
0.0010226181,
0.0071075694,
-0.0647572055,
0.0247307122,
-0.0316727683,
0.0160696004,
-0.0003289882,
-0.0189479813,
-0.0420620814,
-0.0235230904,
0.0111669498,
0.026721552,
0.0066223582,
-0.0112360986,
-0.042351,
0.0114965169,
0.0222562142,
0.0374226011,
-0.0137759494,
-0.0332522467,
0.0095768617,
0.0263010561,
0.0885581672,
-0.0089950124,
0.0130132437,
0.0446574949,
-0.0084854551,
0.0320330597,
0.096647121,
-0.0287624821,
-0.0424022302,
-0.0212157257,
0.0612460338,
-0.0048952056,
0.0085690757,
0.0118773887,
0.0064778449,
-0.0277758427,
-0.0369350873,
0.0578333661,
0.0399722531,
-0.0407710485,
-0.019777745,
-0.0126836533,
0.086428538,
0.0433802754,
0.0585068464,
-0.048832383,
0.0061311573,
0.0056171683,
0.0486111343,
-0.0106857009,
-0.01728555,
-0.0067136805,
-0.132150352,
0.074128218,
-0.0051613855,
-0.0316563621,
0.0070264335,
-0.0329358876,
-0.007667345,
0.0200557299,
-0.0062514539,
0.0574618392,
-0.0227522273,
0.0188394655,
0.015890114,
0.0225004461,
-0.0276395045,
-0.0130863339,
-0.042685464,
0.0304453634,
0.0973777473,
0.0340021886,
0.0144048091,
-0.0568705648,
0.0312865786,
-0.0255409088,
0.0445884168,
-0.0397993736,
0.0321533903,
0.0022870051,
-0.0050880797,
-0.05608394,
-0.0139213176,
-0.0066404589,
-0.0050930674,
-0.0151167316,
0.0702255592,
-0.028632246,
0.0303843543,
-0.0648317859,
-0.0122389542,
0.0022714834,
0.0690234378,
-0.0051225573,
0.0005276193,
-0.0363478512,
-0.0104671149,
0.044937294,
-0.0729279667,
-0.040525414,
0.0138287786,
-0.0469334573,
-0.0474659614,
-0.062002264,
-0.0441317149,
0.0130066536,
0.0278213695,
-0.0129412292,
-0.0122370226,
-0.0853197798,
-0.0036253282,
-0.0717546418,
0.0248569362,
-0.0350320935,
-0.0076608257,
-0.0577919185,
-0.0011858946,
0.0318046734,
-0.0592107326,
-0.0117023252,
0.0491767824,
-0.0419636741,
-0.0389508642,
0.0215597693,
0.0555357821,
0.0289380401,
-0.0065391017,
-0.0084336922,
-0.0603943393,
0.0528645553,
0.0102808755,
-0.0214938391,
-0.0000348554,
-0.0259316172,
-0.0277383886,
-0.038659133,
-0.0011411136,
-0.0840003192,
0.0127215497,
-0.0318953209,
0.0521579683,
0.0311103202,
-0.0043459418,
0.0378177725,
0.0431370847,
0.0787300244,
-0.0242598932,
-0.0080692619,
-0.0257645547,
0.0149694765,
-0.0421710275,
-0.0001425528,
-0.0252982881,
0.0368576199,
0.0102609377,
-0.0261500403,
0.0293795988,
0.0486669242,
-0.0247983225,
0.0565460399,
-0.0424017049,
-0.0044487012,
0.0108512565,
0.0386133641,
0.0061966334,
0.00250819,
-0.0305783805,
0.010916247,
-0.0292977821,
0.0545575619,
-0.0104749482,
0.0349264294,
0.0195263531,
-0.0167414602,
0.0330617093,
0.0563828833,
-0.0797223523,
-0.0366513096,
-0.0263294503,
0.0381536111,
0.0392948724,
0.0544669516,
0.0352913924,
-0.0244310517,
0.000066539,
-0.0279011913,
-0.0139494268,
-0.0087091876,
-0.0296666268,
-0.0151411192,
0.0376249254,
0.0008553691,
0.0137171196,
0.0511276498,
-0.0129461456,
0.0315255299,
-0.0112223914,
-0.041399654,
-0.0186641794,
-0.0399179235,
0.0082158586,
0.0163654685,
-0.0410161093,
-0.0309732463,
-0.0471510366,
-0.0319631286,
0.0081754467,
0.0596596114,
-0.0143758543,
0.0011435164,
0.0635583773,
0.0567333438,
-0.004469716,
-0.0026518651,
-0.0363182425,
0.0249281656,
-0.1003864408,
-0.0240923241,
0.0033152492,
-6.342430463e-33,
-0.0342723541,
-0.0322269388,
0.0573797822,
-0.057030756,
-0.0506973788,
-0.0048801256,
-0.0158897676,
-0.0149952406,
0.0036544118,
-0.0177329369,
-0.0338317715,
0.0166701488,
0.0180488024,
0.0123994546,
-0.0081149582,
0.0065132487,
0.0675365031,
-0.0019326797,
-0.0337140299,
0.0256714802,
0.0500896499,
0.0120940199,
0.0143182026,
-0.0239387844,
-0.0061457539,
-0.0176866893,
-0.0257007349,
0.030516034,
-0.0243456457,
0.0872049034,
-0.0128539279,
0.0347073451,
0.008137906,
-0.0104370313,
-0.0011972948,
-0.0035685501,
-0.0671763644,
-0.0332957059,
-0.0163884908,
-0.0007819347,
-0.0512079895,
-0.0098650698,
0.0279186051,
-0.0224011112,
-0.0336108021,
0.0238304213,
0.0185855515,
-0.0069567212,
-0.0295514483,
-0.0468418524,
-0.0268811714,
0.0064321612,
0.0077128229,
-0.0209746063,
0.016198406,
0.0622532591,
0.0221640877,
0.0361231826,
-0.0526950099,
0.0480786748,
-0.0490853526,
0.0479144119,
0.0957161859,
0.0100082429,
-0.0027227208,
0.0399116054,
0.0276469402,
-0.0263311267,
0.0201274846,
-0.0365027003,
0.0173809621,
0.0526743233,
0.0319223739,
0.0473048948,
0.0382503532,
-0.0120937554,
-0.013293718,
0.0899098441,
-0.001345339,
0.0702747926,
0.0084326323,
0.0159427226,
-0.0693884417,
0.0218959022,
-0.0099748392,
-0.0156420302,
-0.0563376434,
-0.0283275936,
0.0557618812,
0.0216156356,
-0.0309908912,
0.0161772985,
0.030753538,
0.0038039917,
0.0153030204,
0.0246894173,
-0.0252903942,
0.0109924814,
-0.0310535282,
0.014144104,
0.0024045489,
-0.0289436467,
0.0473034121,
0.0176301263,
-0.005206049,
-0.0039562583,
-0.0104122646,
0.0425194241,
-0.0384968966,
0.0258090217,
-0.0252110176,
0.0357718952,
-0.004809008,
-0.044325877,
0.0181170013,
-0.0100124665,
0.0057107504,
0.0319178663,
0.0447446369,
-0.0056967391,
-0.0347142965,
-0.0352259688,
0.0331050567,
-0.026198063,
0.0095102862,
0.0463456362,
-0.0213144906,
0.0390877128,
0.0509034581,
-0.0280419122,
-0.025521582,
0.0507199839,
2.649e-7,
0.0255881939,
0.0321317427,
0.0795470029,
0.0044938806,
-0.0184925944,
-0.0171557087,
-0.008214877,
0.0230704527,
0.0157687925,
0.0661765188,
-0.0039432873,
-0.0080147879,
0.0321146883,
0.034814056,
-0.0583741181,
-0.0321973711,
-0.0569773652,
-0.028374685,
-0.0712273195,
-0.0267361905,
0.0422684923,
0.0447224751,
0.0032796978,
-0.0247363653,
-0.0170226693,
-0.0387393497,
0.0455506779,
0.0031594902,
-0.0108789103,
0.0160731673,
0.0343962833,
-0.0114034675,
-0.0265193097,
-0.0454067886,
0.0003897298,
0.0160369892,
0.0286642704,
0.0156955197,
-0.0149095422,
-0.058075767,
0.0040666466,
-0.0145614985,
-0.0023613523,
-0.0561657473,
0.0520569123,
0.0315693729,
0.0256888159,
-0.0151390759,
-0.0073091667,
0.0108151194,
0.0018774803,
-0.0508390181,
-0.0297855567,
-0.0125120357,
-0.0107191792,
0.0176826473,
-0.0322993211,
-0.0546301976,
0.0041387202,
-0.0232364107,
-0.0552650653,
-0.0549564362,
-0.0655556992,
0.0101606231,
-0.0292666946,
-0.0441574454,
-0.0038467422,
2.450524834e-34,
0.0368228331,
0.0181941111,
-0.0000706217,
-0.0163330883,
0.0375997201,
-0.0131294942,
-0.0423389487,
0.0445195735,
0.0005952964,
-0.0917661265,
-0.0452881008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16810v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16810v1 | PISTOL: Dataset Compilation Pipeline for Structural Unlearning of LLMs | 2024-06-24T17:22:36 | 2024-06-24T17:22:36 | Xinchi Qiu, William F. Shen, Yihong Chen, Nicola Cancedda, Pontus Stenetorp, Nicholas D. Lane | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recently, machine unlearning, which seeks to erase specific data stored in
the pre-trained or fine-tuned models, has emerged as a crucial protective
measure for LLMs. However, unlearning approaches for LLMs that have been
considered thus far have focused on the removal of independent data points and
have not taken into account that the stored facts are logically connected to
one another and form an implicit knowledge graph. To facilitate the development
of structural unlearning methods, which are essential for the practical
application of unlearning, we propose PISTOL, a pipeline for compiling
multi-scenario datasets for benchmarking structural LLM unlearning.
Additionally, leveraging sample datasets synthesized using PISTOL, we conducted
benchmarks with four distinct unlearning methods on both Llama2-7B and
Mistral-7B models. This analysis helps to illustrate the prevailing challenges
in effectively and robustly removing highly inter-connected data, batched data,
or data skewed towards a specific domain. It also highlights the choice of
pre-trained model can impact unlearning performance. This work not only
advances our understandings on the limitation of current LLMs unlearning
methods and proposes future research directions, but also provides a replicable
framework for ongoing exploration and validation in the field. | [
-0.0627646223,
0.0537635498,
0.001751752,
0.0694605857,
-0.0136501752,
0.0284737647,
0.0046718405,
0.0043223226,
0.0396302491,
0.0203267522,
-0.0545543134,
0.0424804389,
-0.0155623406,
0.0340984613,
0.0144884624,
0.0071337088,
0.0413772613,
-0.0296226628,
-0.0125748375,
-0.0101967882,
-0.0333737321,
-0.022600079,
-0.0077322889,
-0.0305513479,
0.0111410134,
-0.0347124562,
-0.0284082405,
0.01664019,
0.0241364241,
-0.027951749,
0.0116268145,
-0.0027283684,
0.0414845757,
0.0059385095,
0.0000022396,
-0.025509458,
-0.0376743898,
0.0036516632,
-0.0317965373,
0.0328108929,
-0.0279551819,
0.0313310027,
-0.0102822501,
0.0115843732,
-0.0182935242,
-0.0003465242,
0.014937778,
0.032075908,
0.03284958,
0.0823856294,
0.0020562855,
-0.0263695884,
0.017872192,
-0.0308715347,
0.0177361351,
-0.006856686,
0.0391777232,
-0.0208378844,
-0.0726716295,
-0.0743836015,
0.0088417036,
0.0115550971,
0.0295290221,
0.0401871651,
-0.013362918,
0.0325772502,
-0.0001025895,
0.0053778305,
-0.0194129851,
0.0800239146,
-0.0043057986,
-0.016761411,
0.0525159426,
-0.0321593434,
-0.0113296667,
0.0144233517,
-0.0269276071,
-0.01657914,
-0.0211703572,
0.0501410402,
-0.0286847856,
-0.0240320936,
0.0756769478,
-0.0619123876,
-0.0160004031,
0.0816866383,
-0.0017895035,
0.0038554054,
0.0157450438,
-0.0337325335,
0.0401290692,
-0.0477910824,
-0.0208342802,
0.020438863,
-0.0200733058,
-0.0018335632,
-0.0003827593,
0.0348231494,
0.013636224,
-0.016565755,
0.0899508297,
-0.0114187105,
-0.0200848319,
0.0573296174,
-0.0399691164,
0.0163712893,
-0.0149289137,
0.0441172607,
-0.0378189646,
0.0278288554,
-0.0384516679,
-0.0027922057,
0.067659542,
0.0551421382,
0.0142850028,
0.0370017439,
-0.0227551013,
0.0225675497,
-0.0375286601,
0.022044288,
0.0038809387,
0.0061965669,
-0.0034418975,
0.0000804375,
-0.0802981183,
-0.0037614682,
0.0065058596,
0.0403488167,
0.0109768603,
-0.0584997162,
-0.0241220873,
0.0049882303,
-0.0005785699,
-0.014220248,
0.0527105965,
0.0941674858,
-0.0010919713,
-0.0304919295,
-0.1073448211,
-0.0257174131,
0.0290205795,
-0.0743507072,
0.0767502561,
-0.0347738415,
0.0507897064,
-0.0290724244,
-0.0003249557,
-0.0421414152,
-0.0040395092,
-0.0287495684,
-0.044544898,
0.0688268393,
-0.0356078781,
-0.0191616267,
0.0032746282,
0.009860226,
-0.0384078845,
0.0584570728,
-0.0140377088,
0.0552437268,
0.0136194564,
-0.0223594196,
0.0422612466,
0.04371107,
0.0298696067,
0.0063308822,
-0.0492774658,
0.0172140542,
0.0071438421,
-0.0196333509,
0.0342084616,
-0.0318098888,
-0.0255847201,
0.0067911884,
0.0290181171,
-0.0117291808,
0.0362750292,
0.0174657777,
-0.0093793189,
-0.0379560702,
0.0399507843,
0.0568270087,
-0.0741408169,
0.0326529667,
-0.0757197812,
0.0261559859,
-0.0277750194,
0.0317169614,
-0.0389157236,
-0.0810701698,
0.0011760126,
-0.0342339091,
-0.0158223361,
0.0185595397,
0.0558278598,
0.0179369431,
-0.045176629,
0.1017358303,
0.0627106205,
-0.0627752393,
-0.0330506228,
-0.036059197,
0.0209328793,
0.0176747087,
0.0336704887,
-0.08252877,
-0.0570389815,
0.0173341557,
0.004178761,
-0.032746084,
-0.028697269,
-0.0115825702,
0.0767273903,
-0.0393671282,
-0.0466139205,
-0.0225576125,
0.0242621452,
0.0104477005,
0.008727639,
-0.0581360459,
-0.0095823538,
-0.0601360351,
-0.0014114731,
0.0329277143,
-0.0788763016,
-0.0381107405,
0.0244712289,
0.0092024403,
0.0487562679,
-0.0059470241,
-0.0025164196,
-0.0363120586,
0.0937310532,
-0.0235563871,
-0.0078361873,
-0.028000135,
-0.0286360979,
-0.0046483972,
0.0436042324,
-0.0180111974,
0.0149626359,
0.0218157638,
-0.0788909048,
-0.0252395384,
-0.0167612936,
0.0455153063,
0.0247237645,
-0.0241396539,
0.0339292288,
-0.0194142759,
0.0017732664,
0.0149998059,
0.0519005544,
-0.055600293,
-0.035795182,
-0.0038430057,
-0.0183047689,
0.0098243607,
-0.0123131424,
0.01549106,
-0.001330044,
-0.01872872,
-0.0050235502,
-0.0197986867,
-0.0383803397,
-0.0464136042,
-0.0224949028,
-0.0258371159,
0.0060955943,
-0.0145410318,
0.0333670676,
0.0205541775,
-0.0251222402,
-0.0189160034,
-0.018298367,
0.0143254511,
0.028008543,
-0.0285527352,
-0.0080644051,
0.040573284,
-0.0168099981,
-0.0523915552,
-0.0281887967,
0.0019536696,
0.0023073449,
0.0396699533,
-0.0228836127,
-0.040744435,
0.0029351441,
0.0885274485,
-0.0434375741,
0.005821194,
-0.0445201583,
-0.0197269488,
-0.0047728424,
-0.0198456217,
-0.0273654405,
0.0500627346,
-0.0501147881,
0.0477761328,
0.0883458778,
-0.0187035222,
-0.0147605669,
0.0114255343,
-0.0295477994,
-0.0124938944,
-0.0236767828,
-0.0047995844,
0.0087002609,
0.0125028538,
0.0185193159,
0.0320569761,
0.0200362969,
0.0206059515,
0.0424269326,
-0.0613654144,
-0.0377951786,
0.0170207825,
-0.022971645,
0.0119073913,
-0.0046618842,
-0.0557365045,
0.0234647878,
-0.0140998745,
0.0429007262,
0.0247501899,
-0.0272124428,
-0.0329654887,
-0.0027354497,
0.0187945087,
-0.0012407317,
0.0295050573,
-0.0009426679,
-0.0074727186,
-0.029773429,
0.0234475825,
-0.0154085318,
0.0094257006,
-0.0685862675,
-0.0035702393,
0.0225803535,
-0.0427726321,
-0.0090483604,
0.0295207016,
0.0141945733,
0.0115434965,
-0.0243949033,
-0.0263526943,
-0.0310555585,
-0.0821318477,
0.0227030441,
0.0049172346,
0.0127520738,
0.0085891578,
-0.0487170964,
0.048255939,
-0.0043692249,
-0.0053650499,
0.0437863134,
-0.0335953906,
0.0280118342,
0.0583726391,
0.0217846408,
-0.0208394602,
-0.048170615,
0.0162777845,
0.0037987579,
-0.0051366691,
-0.0013281828,
0.0222356077,
0.0327773094,
-0.0133869648,
0.0072866939,
0.0674112514,
0.0000497014,
-0.0200038739,
0.0031460884,
0.0316876248,
-0.0019779226,
0.0305034239,
0.000769148,
-0.0773339346,
-0.0263870694,
0.009092642,
0.0309517477,
0.0090273004,
-0.042926006,
0.0120728211,
-0.0749160945,
0.0375020839,
0.0222588126,
-0.0169987734,
-0.0179973468,
-0.059468206,
0.0002619098,
-0.0593495257,
0.0054304572,
0.0037554603,
-0.0377528742,
-0.0309126452,
0.0130612943,
-0.0556429252,
-0.0738031343,
0.0023805154,
-0.0419143662,
0.0124026202,
0.0098375808,
0.0101845926,
-0.0466512479,
-0.0207262021,
0.0522928983,
0.0071166884,
0.0436248109,
-0.0233363882,
0.0550255142,
0.0570150912,
0.0070971325,
-0.0125773232,
0.0696193203,
-0.0195118971,
-0.0417935066,
0.0098377094,
0.0712414756,
-0.017585421,
-0.0095026204,
0.0062006409,
-0.0564979762,
-0.0148137528,
0.0673814565,
0.0128049254,
-0.0072308686,
-0.031176988,
-0.0019477166,
-0.013978296,
0.0406868048,
0.0244783182,
0.0050001815,
-0.0453660972,
0.0176949669,
-0.0393005498,
0.0116810864,
-0.006940654,
-0.0000674365,
-0.0045295749,
0.0191561356,
0.0024720167,
-0.0052721705,
-0.0586426519,
0.0058458606,
-0.0154504869,
-0.0143259866,
-0.0340540297,
0.0177747067,
0.0225276835,
-0.0280495677,
-0.0144492108,
0.0134835504,
-0.084664993,
-0.0740251392,
0.0084262481,
0.0369623937,
0.0228158031,
0.064171195,
0.0314013697,
-0.008338646,
0.1035072953,
0.0678174645,
0.0046575298,
0.0450397953,
0.0281025898,
0.0001363712,
-0.0129189137,
0.0111172153,
-0.0374192409,
-0.0021284644,
0.0607712977,
-0.0330013707,
-0.0287088137,
-0.0162159707,
-0.0011752591,
0.0598178618,
0.0853981674,
0.0333791301,
-0.0056284275,
-0.0277648252,
0.0377203524,
0.0130136898,
0.0038749799,
-0.0192617849,
0.0139108105,
0.0307145156,
0.0010908879,
-0.0010348723,
-0.0011210977,
0.0245934129,
0.0299566314,
-0.0470655784,
-0.0053319791,
0.0347241834,
-0.0142238019,
0.011237096,
-0.0045563774,
0.0052601937,
0.0374259949,
0.0088369111,
0.019857306,
0.0013013334,
0.0402744673,
0.0027959342,
0.0592955165,
-0.0617149174,
0.0239463914,
-0.0121740308,
-0.0469106473,
-0.0563434288,
0.0392636843,
0.0497350059,
0.0115920343,
0.0058691986,
0.0080966121,
-0.0085083265,
-0.0356337875,
0.015572032,
-0.00445606,
0.0556310117,
0.0402944647,
0.0068170791,
-0.0382288694,
0.0187129192,
0.0722292811,
0.0106108887,
0.0808541104,
-0.0176522564,
0.0318552218,
-0.058176212,
-0.0335362926,
0.0358172953,
-0.0065570124,
0.0227521751,
-0.0757992566,
-0.0254676249,
-0.0390515104,
0.0520295762,
0.0232889019,
-0.0025619296,
-0.0134456111,
0.011759134,
0.0687103048,
0.0134533066,
-0.0090993438,
-0.0147656118,
-0.0711314157,
0.0056355316,
-0.0278947111,
0.0276876949,
-6.585681387e-33,
-0.0025198974,
-0.0047906847,
0.009628932,
0.0430462994,
0.0036658181,
-0.0094513968,
-0.0021022349,
-0.0545051359,
0.0048727714,
0.0057319859,
-0.0306242146,
0.0005508421,
0.0206652358,
-0.0318545401,
-0.0086441692,
-0.0254564807,
0.0523368977,
-0.0255820435,
-0.0259451997,
0.0168091636,
0.0617909878,
0.0347292535,
0.0407216884,
-0.1010855138,
-0.031241823,
0.0077883042,
-0.0514925942,
0.0301133711,
-0.0401961133,
0.0267050862,
-0.0385314748,
0.008399046,
0.0054837,
0.0013272312,
-0.0378123224,
-0.0372862555,
-0.0723364875,
-0.0051195929,
-0.0037906917,
-0.0285222791,
0.003738672,
-0.0670870617,
0.0421090461,
0.0149202403,
-0.0291361399,
-0.0612980276,
0.0275474489,
-0.0335774794,
-0.0100626554,
-0.0489823222,
0.008940096,
0.0152363442,
-0.0108674094,
-0.0065380437,
0.0289310031,
-0.002822015,
-0.0186933372,
0.0226379074,
-0.1078468859,
0.0149180666,
0.0585787557,
0.0146784689,
0.0990732312,
0.0294138156,
0.0117175626,
0.0842246339,
0.0636554286,
-0.010763865,
0.0195012651,
0.0009839729,
0.0028377941,
0.113635987,
0.0117359925,
0.0172081143,
0.0383853465,
-0.0192433428,
-0.1067871824,
0.0512729026,
-0.0164572317,
0.0336413942,
-0.0389396399,
0.0542751364,
0.0269724671,
-0.023803154,
-0.0192635879,
-0.0001682361,
-0.0138703426,
0.0013343949,
0.0052222647,
0.0003453269,
-0.017065363,
-0.0127575584,
-0.0065588513,
-0.0361523964,
0.0099904742,
0.039999757,
0.0212835167,
0.0235067457,
0.0337806903,
-0.0359388478,
-0.0604836941,
-0.0344657302,
-0.0019008922,
-0.0174657237,
0.061042048,
-0.0094115399,
0.0095970454,
0.0738205239,
-0.0118836258,
0.0033095267,
-0.0395714603,
-0.0086845877,
0.0502698682,
-0.0047531058,
0.0129185198,
-0.0254057422,
-0.0023648441,
0.007596937,
0.0199523233,
0.0261145607,
-0.0329485685,
0.0395351946,
0.0007728798,
0.0483848229,
-0.0011962707,
-0.0112741208,
-0.0050498568,
-0.0280661099,
0.0523560792,
-0.0394993797,
-0.0017708604,
0.0295423865,
2.849e-7,
-0.0087043243,
0.0155782877,
0.0251643714,
0.0035684854,
0.0307296664,
0.0564146899,
-0.0845296234,
-0.0005130844,
-0.0023828235,
-0.0382860154,
0.0399811082,
0.0175936613,
0.0582565963,
0.0132818483,
-0.0529525839,
0.0250900369,
-0.0295491088,
-0.0391387418,
-0.0437381566,
-0.0488849878,
-0.0070752809,
0.0430142395,
0.0184675734,
-0.0400565602,
0.0265512746,
0.0019956315,
0.0418707207,
-0.0736307576,
-0.0293670446,
0.0302881543,
0.0351823047,
-0.0221005138,
-0.0235285237,
0.0030602498,
-0.0338657275,
0.0195718389,
-0.0228036288,
0.0562062971,
0.0592194311,
-0.0641956627,
0.0303293094,
0.0180772971,
0.030770326,
0.0246255808,
0.1037964523,
-0.0289866645,
-0.0336940885,
-0.0029027192,
-0.061658442,
-0.0193343032,
0.0427642874,
0.0191606879,
0.0287349913,
0.0364603847,
-0.0503506772,
0.001710862,
-0.0427409746,
-0.0238843951,
-0.0131010767,
0.0156630166,
-0.0713980347,
-0.0531816445,
0.0166032612,
0.0090707224,
0.0012320471,
-0.0832771584,
0.0152396914,
2.719158583e-34,
-0.0300136898,
-0.0359268114,
-0.0031993445,
0.0179011244,
0.0112558743,
-0.0331373513,
-0.0428542234,
0.0163386017,
-0.0397508256,
-0.0641750246,
0.0389323235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16807v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16807v1 | Beyond Thumbs Up/Down: Untangling Challenges of Fine-Grained Feedback for Text-to-Image Generation | 2024-06-24T17:19:34 | 2024-06-24T17:19:34 | Katherine M. Collins, Najoung Kim, Yonatan Bitton, Verena Rieser, Shayegan Omidshafiei, Yushi Hu, Sherol Chen, Senjuti Dutta, Minsuk Chang, Kimin Lee, Youwei Liang, Georgina Evans, Sahil Singla, Gang Li, Adrian Weller, Junfeng He, Deepak Ramachandran, Krishnamurthy Dj Dvijotham | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Human feedback plays a critical role in learning and refining reward models
for text-to-image generation, but the optimal form the feedback should take for
learning an accurate reward function has not been conclusively established.
This paper investigates the effectiveness of fine-grained feedback which
captures nuanced distinctions in image quality and prompt-alignment, compared
to traditional coarse-grained feedback (for example, thumbs up/down or ranking
between a set of options). While fine-grained feedback holds promise,
particularly for systems catering to diverse societal preferences, we show that
demonstrating its superiority to coarse-grained feedback is not automatic.
Through experiments on real and synthetic preference data, we surface the
complexities of building effective models due to the interplay of model choice,
feedback type, and the alignment between human judgment and computational
interpretation. We identify key challenges in eliciting and utilizing
fine-grained feedback, prompting a reassessment of its assumed benefits and
practicality. Our findings -- e.g., that fine-grained feedback can lead to
worse models for a fixed budget, in some settings; however, in controlled
settings with known attributes, fine grained rewards can indeed be more helpful
-- call for careful consideration of feedback attributes and potentially beckon
novel modeling approaches to appropriately unlock the potential value of
fine-grained feedback in-the-wild. | [
0.0229630824,
0.0478506014,
0.011615485,
-0.0037842696,
-0.0113826171,
0.0274465382,
0.0093762083,
0.0245636888,
-0.0019725165,
-0.0208298583,
-0.0509589948,
-0.0059984229,
0.0412322916,
0.0548414513,
0.0172220767,
-0.1133362949,
-0.0176295601,
-0.0113224592,
0.0071067405,
-0.0274441987,
0.0315591693,
-0.0272348877,
0.0291535631,
0.0113483286,
-0.0331158303,
0.0061870883,
-0.0003056226,
0.019204421,
0.0308051817,
-0.0166011956,
-0.0191221815,
0.0603360794,
-0.0055266274,
0.0059080999,
0.0000021894,
-0.0306943152,
0.0342266634,
-0.0224631391,
0.0119135017,
0.0339212306,
0.0853006691,
-0.0036462615,
-0.0031335694,
-0.0273196008,
-0.002162047,
0.0728159174,
0.0801895633,
0.0393513516,
0.0427919105,
-0.0092500243,
0.0025339155,
-0.0106890881,
-0.061454691,
-0.0280565433,
0.0403348505,
0.0495004021,
-0.0247327052,
-0.0032184771,
0.0116413105,
0.0051868111,
-0.0169693567,
0.0208884384,
0.0152414981,
-0.0149859516,
0.0462026596,
0.0747746229,
0.0288146697,
-0.0400514267,
-0.0124609638,
0.0538529307,
-0.0243088566,
0.0000881037,
-0.0281739607,
-0.0734032691,
0.017550502,
0.0051970677,
-0.0301154424,
-0.0135933198,
-0.0038048928,
0.0106389849,
-0.0589824319,
0.0318584219,
0.0054246634,
0.0135450391,
0.0292772427,
-0.0141788498,
0.0000185082,
-0.0246051401,
-0.0179502796,
0.0766858384,
-0.0259038694,
-0.0508314371,
0.0493929796,
-0.0054649669,
-0.0041637751,
-0.0207640324,
-0.0183949508,
0.0112380441,
0.0208659712,
-0.0284029711,
0.0747799277,
0.0054667126,
-0.0327405259,
0.0216822587,
-0.0025191917,
0.0325658657,
-0.0133751985,
0.044019673,
-0.0372880101,
0.0704816431,
0.014267901,
-0.0069481465,
0.0391275175,
0.0044031488,
-0.0142316539,
-0.0049458556,
-0.04212429,
-0.0047146706,
-0.0439208858,
0.0431831926,
0.0148192449,
0.0690426454,
-0.0560246781,
0.029272886,
-0.1033591479,
0.0254642367,
-0.0590971224,
0.0152762514,
0.032148663,
0.0569455884,
0.0274801552,
-0.0037216407,
0.020672923,
0.0171483997,
0.0296609793,
0.0477937125,
-0.0143213691,
0.0172678232,
0.0232831296,
-0.0174538847,
-0.0471227355,
-0.0162051693,
-0.0027589775,
-0.0309586115,
0.021517437,
-0.0114419395,
-0.0078779729,
0.0161946993,
-0.0133097004,
0.0002158271,
-0.0267636944,
0.0568075962,
0.001059894,
-0.0122992117,
0.0245533064,
-0.0203746557,
-0.0233227834,
0.0138843441,
0.038772054,
0.1251801401,
0.038587369,
-0.0138582196,
0.0148814199,
0.0176977552,
0.0117942505,
0.0228387788,
-0.0300767887,
0.0131554948,
-0.0432104617,
0.0458622761,
0.0554548539,
0.0507569909,
-0.0172619075,
0.0128924288,
0.1268012673,
0.0305297896,
0.0172435399,
-0.0267879125,
0.0030195778,
0.0024604343,
-0.017711157,
0.0329171382,
-0.0289944988,
0.0912246704,
-0.0089352271,
0.0262447763,
0.0123486826,
0.0093016513,
-0.0263035037,
-0.0675230473,
0.0117556956,
-0.0149675403,
0.0214018039,
0.0121199545,
0.0341127403,
0.0102693643,
-0.0358540341,
-0.0710691363,
0.0177373216,
-0.0327934735,
0.0475560464,
-0.0449677259,
0.0663828105,
0.1255853176,
0.0256070253,
0.0261923224,
0.0532622933,
-0.0233566668,
-0.0318506509,
0.0413345248,
0.0365386792,
-0.017224472,
-0.0277641751,
-0.029544631,
-0.0432426259,
0.0027685019,
0.0049311407,
0.0269818194,
-0.0401800722,
-0.0135556599,
-0.0303209759,
0.0374487005,
-0.0524701662,
0.0194796361,
0.0826524645,
-0.0290227756,
0.0057448088,
0.0209130682,
0.010907487,
-0.0021227752,
0.0084503349,
0.0206333492,
-0.0057883463,
0.0150344763,
-0.0138642015,
0.0166653264,
-0.0311906077,
0.0067342548,
-0.0166280996,
-0.0266952626,
-0.004820908,
0.0241224971,
-0.0269217808,
0.00634772,
-0.0162090585,
0.0051840045,
-0.0146435844,
-0.0026852752,
0.0044990219,
-0.005400205,
-0.0528210215,
-0.039948266,
0.041414585,
-0.0396433696,
-0.0024436668,
-0.0226019248,
-0.0178353954,
-0.016342001,
-0.03056743,
-0.0203885604,
0.0291793123,
0.0315928236,
0.0361284912,
0.0463827513,
0.0475124419,
-0.0642828122,
-0.0181838702,
-0.0277592074,
-0.0411440879,
0.0222494528,
-0.0065019615,
0.0127121294,
-0.0350743718,
0.0128316833,
-0.0124689806,
-0.045850683,
0.0199637897,
0.0011895177,
0.0295005403,
0.0451242179,
0.0083155707,
0.0394012928,
-0.060318049,
-0.032397192,
0.0276547559,
0.004993733,
0.06790784,
0.0208739582,
-0.0479342006,
0.0085285669,
-0.0321786068,
-0.0300711114,
0.0264833272,
-0.0239566956,
0.0303407069,
0.0222955961,
0.0108907921,
0.0886193737,
0.0232265815,
0.0172986612,
0.0214637741,
0.0296592526,
-0.0870516598,
-0.0343902111,
-0.0462181829,
-0.028556468,
0.0377013609,
-0.043287769,
0.0175093468,
0.0428918451,
-0.0087691974,
0.0439540409,
-0.0891489089,
0.061998982,
-0.0246868301,
-0.0275137704,
-0.0505845249,
0.016196141,
-0.0060346909,
0.0388582349,
-0.0435223617,
-0.0621205047,
0.083201915,
0.0080347396,
0.0179780293,
0.0364615098,
0.0412758067,
0.0162932258,
0.0120308874,
0.0006147519,
0.0238340907,
0.0342320092,
0.0340048149,
-0.0701640844,
-0.0118271643,
0.0764358565,
-0.0414529629,
0.0310092326,
-0.0079201097,
-0.0326480195,
-0.0449125804,
-0.0861397833,
-0.0116430921,
-0.040780399,
-0.0046851076,
-0.0130084502,
0.0241271444,
-0.0113335261,
0.0212162267,
0.0119279493,
0.025727246,
-0.0168626923,
-0.0224711839,
-0.0428558104,
0.0137008904,
0.0162486956,
0.0340395048,
-0.0200926587,
-0.0095338272,
-0.0630907193,
-0.0492622294,
0.0417243391,
0.0086488435,
0.0100555345,
-0.0204808991,
0.0212452486,
0.025241321,
0.038050998,
-0.0033536945,
0.017501289,
0.0553536303,
-0.0301319733,
0.0106107257,
0.0441872813,
0.0088265268,
-0.0743580535,
0.001210293,
0.0297886655,
0.0646544695,
-0.0080530737,
0.0152144115,
-0.0628446937,
-0.0258439314,
-0.0302852746,
0.0514452457,
-0.0322992057,
0.0004477853,
0.0338845737,
-0.1074485481,
0.0358730778,
0.0072486722,
0.0095226886,
-0.0107416827,
-0.000195388,
0.0107014561,
-0.0109115215,
-0.0515730754,
0.0220178217,
0.0023315032,
0.0219194964,
0.0173757281,
0.037605688,
-0.0250908732,
-0.0027747075,
-0.0406150147,
0.0199643932,
0.085959211,
0.0161836483,
0.0087693604,
-0.0843986943,
-0.0123042241,
0.0486030653,
0.0138170039,
-0.0055727111,
0.0534961969,
-0.0036831342,
-0.0007240595,
-0.0415368751,
0.0338556319,
0.0303213466,
0.0180880446,
-0.0037835857,
0.0025963606,
0.0130264843,
-0.0212190617,
-0.0535277016,
-0.0008597225,
0.0216261167,
0.0215358809,
0.0155584868,
-0.0848662108,
-0.036617808,
-0.0370517112,
-0.0066383462,
-0.0747181773,
-0.0479411334,
-0.004371135,
0.0000781392,
-0.0278417803,
-0.0988422409,
-0.0180116016,
-0.0044693607,
0.009357349,
0.0180396698,
-0.0497327261,
-0.0478928648,
-0.0066040009,
-0.013810087,
0.0246757604,
0.0076120193,
0.0052953693,
-0.0559669621,
-0.0414831676,
-0.0010384306,
-0.0464441217,
-0.020266328,
-0.0012985847,
-0.0326998085,
-0.0131293135,
-0.0283431895,
0.1259047091,
0.0176994391,
0.0192257296,
0.0222392101,
-0.0474440083,
0.0327804834,
0.0620075464,
0.014100411,
-0.0128114363,
0.0096517745,
0.053892754,
-0.0142696919,
0.0016284056,
-0.044607576,
0.0007292532,
0.0200648345,
-0.0153800379,
0.0022097242,
-0.0119566191,
0.0180493891,
-0.0073830835,
0.013588015,
-0.0723314658,
-0.0149951279,
-0.009925249,
-0.0108779976,
0.0074892268,
-0.0334037915,
-0.046994824,
-0.0500550456,
0.0103484457,
-0.0059911185,
-0.0058223088,
-0.0158870034,
-0.0080149388,
0.0556288622,
-0.085089393,
-0.009229321,
0.0012229154,
0.0263633654,
0.0142720379,
0.0165044498,
-0.0172786228,
0.0249246694,
-0.0216949191,
0.0304619595,
-0.0071179788,
0.0374259129,
0.0188817456,
0.0002235659,
0.0134846065,
0.0717299655,
0.0060574412,
-0.0169605017,
-0.0762438253,
-0.0152091794,
0.0221365392,
-0.0077488474,
0.0323399603,
-0.0023939894,
-0.0183424056,
-0.0130682904,
0.0143802268,
0.002210665,
-0.0280621052,
0.0179383475,
0.0132440114,
0.0069756121,
-0.0388338342,
0.0353980549,
-0.0560379848,
-0.0255729221,
-0.061023064,
-0.0236106049,
-0.0157027915,
0.0101291817,
0.0061789686,
-0.0053826906,
0.0147178182,
0.0017854776,
-0.0851706639,
-0.0212886166,
-0.0286590327,
0.0660844743,
0.0268528648,
-0.0080501251,
0.0623503402,
0.0088820094,
-0.0339811221,
0.0365007371,
-0.0005734548,
-0.0145066613,
-0.0704523474,
-0.0002262694,
-0.0466395095,
-6.341461415e-33,
-0.0158450641,
-0.0280105788,
-0.0160305873,
0.0125616975,
0.0055422741,
-0.0200582258,
0.0025218155,
0.0121716252,
0.0499347448,
-0.0042136661,
-0.0015279542,
-0.0668829083,
-0.008205262,
0.0023285295,
0.0338159241,
-0.0163213704,
0.0821860433,
-0.0158046354,
-0.0921804458,
0.0197376553,
0.0447028913,
-0.0322380401,
0.0218851175,
-0.0517120659,
0.0153236771,
0.0165915992,
-0.0562790222,
-0.0441097096,
0.0034808032,
0.0512371324,
-0.0125064971,
0.0276883747,
-0.0095527852,
-0.0270404294,
-0.0234806817,
0.0334687345,
-0.0386648923,
-0.0031379629,
-0.0127743287,
-0.0155427167,
-0.0640114099,
-0.0050207092,
0.0302961506,
-0.0078574698,
-0.0479751006,
0.0040852288,
0.0417744257,
-0.0396580957,
0.0144603029,
-0.0179763492,
-0.0396385193,
-0.0034625735,
-0.0143269217,
-0.0504979715,
0.0134656765,
0.0805489272,
-0.006762228,
0.0402132161,
-0.0359953456,
0.077932924,
0.0702246428,
0.0218564551,
0.0762590319,
0.0191330239,
0.0308858901,
0.0338539071,
0.006193093,
0.028275568,
0.0048246798,
-0.0372634418,
0.0172019489,
0.0269645434,
0.060819827,
0.0635722056,
0.0651040301,
-0.0383612365,
0.0299246944,
0.0598898195,
-0.0387698226,
-0.0020126635,
0.0368072502,
0.0342160277,
-0.0242609624,
-0.0048160404,
-0.0402173623,
-0.064668268,
-0.0508061126,
-0.0454990901,
0.017894838,
0.0221348293,
-0.0252553504,
0.0104624163,
0.0197548028,
0.0044002514,
-0.0256703254,
-0.057270132,
-0.0448361151,
0.0589705184,
0.007406516,
-0.079776302,
-0.0655303746,
-0.0016127082,
-0.004192065,
0.0246799141,
-0.0023064993,
0.0331771672,
0.0261380263,
0.0009708794,
-0.0146208061,
-0.007190926,
-0.0116829704,
0.0166259464,
0.0106488978,
-0.0469050892,
0.0222575311,
-0.0380919874,
-0.0476563945,
0.0179851484,
-0.0346515663,
-0.0114295529,
-0.0445108786,
-0.0114793191,
-0.0229506902,
0.0157324076,
-0.0309184287,
-0.0103501892,
-0.0199655183,
-0.0241968408,
0.0378463678,
-0.0490256138,
-0.0293033905,
-0.0118256127,
2.728e-7,
-0.0130517539,
0.053989213,
-0.0044720322,
-0.0415263325,
0.0175824631,
0.1022096649,
0.012696241,
-0.0043699509,
0.0308593046,
-0.0275173914,
-0.0027964786,
0.0025518436,
0.0194422472,
0.0076080505,
-0.0018625386,
0.0081074601,
-0.025692964,
0.0684390962,
0.0079427324,
-0.0099823251,
0.0455052182,
-0.003431519,
0.0204294771,
-0.0023554789,
0.0385811999,
0.02945593,
0.0833161548,
-0.0698036402,
0.0172560178,
-0.0647555292,
-0.0080657098,
-0.0365168713,
-0.0245080143,
-0.0005017818,
-0.0198598672,
-0.0491653979,
0.0123059349,
0.0364756659,
-0.0161316805,
-0.0298581142,
-0.0268301964,
0.0237807501,
0.0244800244,
-0.0664936975,
0.0411180519,
-0.0618149675,
-0.0281635858,
-0.0572841354,
0.0140621252,
0.0071425494,
0.052018024,
-0.0433106348,
-0.0663444176,
-0.0279085264,
0.0130163869,
0.0534782894,
-0.0344344042,
-0.0393029936,
-0.0335135199,
0.0167342052,
-0.0012395239,
-0.0494395979,
-0.0664142817,
0.0400260873,
-0.0185787342,
-0.0386726968,
-0.0401504897,
2.293594042e-34,
0.0314320959,
-0.0031372774,
0.0635523424,
-0.0540652722,
0.0203100592,
0.0293644145,
0.0270718187,
-0.0097155841,
0.0675199255,
0.0009732221,
-0.0189047866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16801v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16801v2 | RES-Q: Evaluating Code-Editing Large Language Model Systems at the Repository Scale | 2024-06-24T17:08:17 | 2024-06-25T18:04:23 | Beck LaBash, August Rosedale, Alex Reents, Lucas Negritto, Colin Wiel | cs.CL | cs.CL | The instruction-following ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) has
cultivated a class of LLM-based systems capable of approaching complex tasks
such as making edits to large code repositories. Due to the high sensitivity
and unpredictability of LLM behavior in response to changes in prompting,
robust evaluation tools are needed to drive future iteration of these systems.
We propose RES-Q, a natural language instruction-based benchmark for evaluating
$\textbf{R}$epository $\textbf{E}$diting $\textbf{S}$ystems, which consists of
100 handcrafted repository editing tasks derived from real GitHub commits.
Given an edit instruction and a code repository, RES-Q evaluates an LLM
system's ability to interpret the instruction, navigate the repository to
gather relevant information, and construct an appropriate edit that satisfies
the specified criteria. We argue that evaluating LLMs in this way addresses
issues with traditional benchmarks and provides a more holistic assessment of a
model's abilities. We evaluate various state-of-the-art LLMs as language agents
in a repository-editing system built on Qurrent OS, our language agent
development software. Despite their 1% pass@1 performance difference on
HumanEval, we find Claude Sonnet 3.5 outperforms GPT-4o by 12% pass@1 on RES-Q,
indicating RES-Q's capacity to differentiate model capability as traditional
benchmarks approach saturation. We further investigate token efficiency,
performance relationships with existing benchmarks, and interesting disparities
between closed and open-source LLMs. Code and dataset are available at
https://github.com/Qurrent-AI/RES-Q. | [
0.0484211035,
0.0770056322,
-0.0308097433,
0.0254363772,
-0.0273869243,
-0.0005453913,
-0.0210316088,
-0.0159469172,
-0.009410087,
-0.0113276402,
-0.0474510565,
0.021679325,
-0.0069370302,
0.0028757185,
0.0070777941,
-0.009153069,
0.052407112,
-0.0318401456,
-0.0006581419,
0.0304013453,
-0.0025133488,
0.0186498538,
0.0079343934,
0.0569731109,
0.0311769564,
-0.015147958,
-0.0191683546,
0.0279699173,
-0.001209264,
0.002747173,
-0.0001072525,
0.0451936014,
-0.0274858084,
0.0764183179,
0.0000022004,
-0.0531661138,
-0.0048707179,
0.0152713889,
-0.0194843877,
0.0263138302,
0.0223392844,
-0.0170626547,
-0.0410288312,
0.0034248019,
-0.0241608582,
0.0245548487,
0.0497406907,
-0.0288951416,
0.0732681826,
0.071721904,
0.0164409988,
0.0248076078,
0.0088288626,
-0.0005258729,
0.0513465367,
-0.0128902737,
-0.0090426262,
0.0169955194,
0.0566188246,
0.0463354066,
0.0205543321,
0.0227720011,
0.0371578783,
-0.0318006687,
0.0085503235,
0.0259654373,
-0.0421846621,
-0.0225783587,
-0.0021925049,
0.0195725001,
-0.0152920242,
0.0075181015,
-0.0010343236,
-0.0147970002,
-0.0289926101,
-0.0086837159,
-0.0170042533,
0.0216502063,
0.0140341865,
-0.0184245873,
-0.0095298318,
-0.0707119852,
0.0020077964,
0.012030785,
-0.0134808011,
0.0639994144,
0.0252059828,
-0.0000697627,
0.0039132172,
-0.0359459855,
-0.0401802883,
-0.0858309269,
-0.0095293969,
0.0654012784,
-0.0489790328,
0.011055191,
-0.0152232107,
-0.0075233169,
0.0506532528,
-0.0331595168,
-0.0151248276,
0.0507731512,
-0.0307963621,
0.0432209298,
-0.0004021758,
0.1138556153,
-0.0058046053,
0.0337237455,
0.0074707526,
0.0072763893,
-0.0687581524,
0.0160435475,
-0.0629326701,
0.0250139143,
-0.020076219,
0.0294213369,
-0.0244590342,
0.0301432312,
0.032812953,
0.0603288785,
0.0102155535,
-0.0441050418,
-0.0540786497,
-0.0015984568,
-0.0258556083,
-0.0021939008,
-0.045535557,
-0.0167580582,
-0.0136549855,
-0.0349960849,
0.0050204364,
-0.0180962924,
-0.0279258341,
-0.0542554073,
0.0176840369,
0.072667025,
0.0499071814,
0.0136209112,
-0.039761629,
-0.0239779484,
-0.0029041786,
-0.0676893741,
-0.0715467334,
-0.0870546028,
-0.0144512793,
0.0422338694,
-0.0221835896,
-0.1102035493,
-0.0177347362,
-0.0115227532,
0.0006180236,
0.0260675456,
-0.0481740348,
0.018133888,
0.0472139567,
0.0135755101,
-0.057959713,
0.0364426635,
0.0430877618,
0.0179861113,
0.0441093296,
-0.0032685287,
0.0462661125,
0.0458001383,
-0.0481063649,
0.0347881727,
0.0299360342,
0.040775273,
0.0260089245,
0.0124690076,
0.0363058746,
0.0640923455,
0.0100644846,
-0.0197193716,
0.0561674461,
0.0449402295,
0.0055277459,
0.0007422987,
0.0294205043,
0.0456950665,
0.0262964536,
-0.0398290418,
-0.0530156009,
0.0531805083,
0.0285195224,
0.0036163256,
-0.021830678,
-0.0104405284,
0.0068544415,
-0.0412214398,
-0.0075499061,
-0.0082631409,
-0.04113755,
-0.0271188505,
0.027524665,
-0.0031310525,
-0.0256430209,
-0.0054252804,
0.0146144535,
-0.0410032682,
-0.0095299315,
-0.0497880876,
0.022215426,
0.0712330788,
0.0830367059,
-0.061986614,
-0.0527758077,
-0.0207588822,
0.0042520827,
0.0214868151,
0.0275375675,
-0.0177051015,
-0.0053809448,
-0.0060872831,
-0.0334876031,
-0.0662817806,
-0.0003257603,
0.0272139292,
0.0317629464,
-0.0132798431,
0.0017842734,
-0.0124053527,
-0.0659930781,
0.0269543342,
-0.0270827189,
-0.013940718,
-0.0274121296,
-0.0028905706,
0.00389874,
-0.0060418169,
-0.0416095778,
0.0020660823,
0.0106632654,
0.0077224886,
-0.0374487713,
-0.0051682349,
0.0379829407,
0.0121212583,
0.0451090038,
0.0012271685,
-0.031207826,
0.0008520902,
-0.0420794077,
0.0014216785,
0.014316122,
-0.0470531769,
0.0388674252,
0.0183754489,
0.0376853123,
-0.0416429266,
-0.0433076471,
-0.0095581785,
0.0030838889,
0.0032293322,
0.0272160675,
0.03587671,
0.0686199218,
0.0252475869,
-0.0184304193,
-0.0354696698,
0.0113484794,
0.0001288936,
0.0108762588,
0.0138025181,
0.0527928174,
-0.0390922874,
-0.064288266,
-0.0459004939,
0.0031132943,
-0.0386769772,
0.0027687701,
0.0251684207,
0.0162323415,
-0.0121381432,
-0.0166546311,
0.0152759999,
0.0007151783,
-0.0254857838,
0.0345571078,
0.0306170639,
0.0344481543,
-0.0625438616,
-0.0767231062,
0.0210319441,
-0.013759301,
0.0135574667,
0.0254329443,
0.0046650497,
-0.0689218715,
0.0307358596,
-0.0245687384,
0.0068246759,
-0.003456386,
-0.0569354407,
0.0153973214,
-0.0186743904,
0.081460692,
0.0172300581,
-0.0243841428,
-0.0205213111,
0.0494665951,
0.0013035339,
-0.0336375162,
0.0026110495,
0.0406889468,
-0.0801349357,
-0.0306040831,
-0.0383676626,
0.0159134641,
0.0475417264,
-0.002639683,
-0.0083600469,
-0.0292454492,
0.0182074755,
-0.032642141,
-0.0135176098,
0.0303008575,
-0.0094709834,
-0.003836462,
0.0467994101,
-0.0350015126,
-0.1011966169,
0.0482106209,
-0.0415970981,
-0.0303963646,
-0.0401630513,
-0.0286549591,
-0.0597924069,
0.0638649687,
0.0190050378,
0.0156144938,
-0.0247140639,
-0.0162357613,
-0.0430145636,
0.0153595004,
-0.0203027893,
0.0025715472,
0.0421819128,
-0.0657427758,
0.0074724243,
-0.0182163734,
-0.0050755059,
-0.010591073,
0.0090975948,
-0.0484423786,
0.0107403658,
0.0480512492,
-0.0289514307,
0.0294292159,
0.0123917488,
0.0298816133,
0.0802280605,
0.0385095663,
-0.0456816889,
-0.0250099655,
-0.0660492554,
0.0075018909,
-0.0148851285,
-0.0003508933,
0.0025647299,
0.0376656502,
0.0175946448,
0.0827671885,
-0.0181785505,
-0.0614500903,
-0.0136350058,
0.004393483,
-0.0701402724,
-0.0316178314,
0.0358965509,
0.0438924097,
-0.0367135145,
-0.0338597782,
0.1217034683,
0.0532991737,
-0.0570277385,
0.0178763326,
-0.0357198976,
0.0264288448,
0.0733481497,
0.0606233589,
-0.0947685018,
-0.0230069607,
0.002579405,
0.0244768728,
0.0130918352,
-0.0371061638,
-0.0200481247,
-0.0700776801,
0.0332175791,
-0.0173714869,
-0.0292873438,
-0.0074111768,
-0.0555040725,
0.0161249936,
-0.0219912454,
-0.0382737182,
0.0465924628,
-0.0009503288,
0.0072903014,
-0.0294794738,
-0.0154329967,
0.0455006957,
0.0606135391,
-0.0582450107,
0.0248585008,
0.0698907003,
0.011773875,
0.0202348121,
0.007805774,
0.032368768,
0.0024389927,
0.005347529,
-0.0262750201,
0.0342711881,
-0.0007883633,
-0.0098912669,
0.0388216451,
0.0085744001,
-0.0173196848,
-0.0130519904,
0.0480675772,
0.0720231533,
-0.0348845646,
0.0153820207,
-0.0020838829,
-0.0315548293,
-0.0071020126,
0.041187156,
0.034668956,
-0.0442141071,
-0.0294646267,
-0.052639775,
-0.0287583023,
-0.0217012558,
-0.0148854489,
-0.026238054,
-0.0138336224,
0.014841008,
-0.0740993395,
-0.0687880293,
0.0272015352,
0.0024701955,
0.0811010674,
-0.0029176469,
0.0361340418,
0.0084280288,
-0.0053121764,
-0.0059719589,
-0.0231392197,
0.0222530384,
-0.0953774676,
-0.0384776071,
0.0262766425,
-0.0221753586,
-0.032508444,
-0.0390854552,
-0.0364347957,
-0.0348557457,
-0.0054083453,
0.049692627,
0.0235036146,
0.0044432655,
-0.028472092,
-0.0808122084,
-0.04865871,
-0.0080936309,
-0.0687214658,
0.0262473691,
0.0264691487,
0.0263842605,
-0.0230505709,
0.0252936706,
-0.0860600099,
0.0113055073,
-0.0097877793,
0.0256857313,
0.0028099304,
-0.0371548161,
0.0242847614,
0.0014870377,
0.0097286263,
0.0354212783,
-0.001548596,
-0.0296525825,
0.0365710333,
0.0070188614,
-0.0073276935,
-0.0221785065,
-0.0210071225,
0.0078174649,
-0.0263719838,
0.0096407132,
0.0412607044,
-0.0401902832,
0.0287239365,
-0.004955661,
0.0286075491,
0.0022515235,
0.0523383915,
0.0488716103,
0.0013914219,
-0.0202357192,
0.0086068902,
-0.0112150135,
0.0359463468,
-0.0205851607,
0.0700891167,
-0.0050242268,
-0.0105681485,
0.0212668292,
0.0132828755,
-0.0545218326,
-0.052271273,
0.0278293565,
0.0172065515,
0.0443735607,
0.0331197158,
0.0478630625,
-0.0445425697,
-0.0071886228,
-0.052818466,
0.0331559107,
0.0114818923,
-0.0531806648,
0.0188937001,
0.0139184417,
-0.0085056862,
0.0048943511,
0.055442106,
-0.0251483563,
0.0602816381,
-0.004739935,
-0.0150535293,
-0.0198110119,
-0.0248882174,
-0.0128167234,
-0.0745834187,
-0.0438037664,
-0.0482452512,
-0.038402006,
-0.0384014919,
-0.0204186309,
0.0439273901,
-0.0042975522,
-0.0196861178,
0.025010556,
0.0666095763,
-0.0099815419,
-0.0205696914,
-0.0207915548,
0.0083110984,
-0.0383365788,
-0.0194220562,
-0.0330379754,
-5.063729178e-33,
-0.0131009165,
-0.0194341689,
0.0670351088,
0.0364040546,
0.0288968068,
-0.0009762838,
-0.0798381045,
-0.0046084966,
-0.0071175322,
-0.0275409743,
-0.0135677457,
0.0134523073,
-0.005532119,
-0.0546408594,
0.0683123097,
0.0372877158,
0.0862239823,
0.0443273075,
-0.0445089452,
0.0381902084,
-0.0309192352,
0.0136791971,
0.0135155516,
-0.015968442,
0.0093027493,
0.00633559,
0.0457936488,
0.0071298168,
0.0100441454,
0.0621528402,
0.0085487096,
-0.0033223133,
-0.0121382512,
-0.0388138629,
-0.0276114289,
-0.0592771582,
0.0024383354,
-0.0102992542,
-0.0159242079,
0.0323490277,
0.013156482,
-0.0440315977,
0.0426745862,
0.0000743579,
-0.0586770698,
0.0270702038,
0.0183742382,
0.0123189744,
0.0261679403,
0.0427719355,
-0.0829208121,
0.0541762523,
-0.0202037189,
-0.0112125203,
-0.0136752063,
0.006963951,
0.0263120029,
0.0338826999,
0.0008718619,
-0.0131547889,
0.0090309037,
0.0463120006,
0.0698019117,
-0.0373506732,
-0.0378143638,
0.0101375571,
0.0385004245,
0.028785089,
0.0249734018,
0.0532927588,
0.0151915038,
0.0508818254,
0.0578272305,
0.0196287706,
-0.0043501337,
0.0283573028,
-0.0264975578,
0.0273280367,
-0.0169902686,
0.0816036016,
-0.0115685808,
0.063591592,
-0.0237151384,
0.0287431646,
-0.0478631966,
0.0244184639,
-0.0290629826,
-0.0446709953,
0.0545171015,
-0.0202188361,
0.0111258216,
-0.0110228034,
0.0172900427,
-0.020872362,
-0.0370967537,
0.043630667,
-0.0783213302,
0.0597448647,
-0.0141043458,
0.0256627835,
-0.0331354737,
0.0348231271,
0.0303394329,
0.0252411496,
0.0721746534,
0.0051093958,
0.0286882725,
0.0422130562,
-0.0642121583,
0.0178657994,
-0.0567358658,
0.0134015502,
-0.04757284,
-0.0106621385,
-0.0115894722,
-0.0342574716,
0.0117970845,
0.0425223485,
-0.0144494995,
-0.0294217467,
-0.0825066045,
0.0488935784,
0.0314771496,
0.0019333306,
-0.03230327,
-0.0029626936,
-0.0264454149,
0.0722821057,
-0.0004235831,
-0.0344772898,
-0.0230871681,
0.0140932519,
2.922e-7,
0.0139225041,
0.0631884113,
0.0316371247,
0.0259545967,
0.0027264068,
0.0170069057,
-0.0768679678,
0.0005980621,
0.0242814552,
0.0153335342,
-0.0272914972,
0.0223488845,
0.0179087184,
0.0617705584,
-0.0414237604,
-0.0222811364,
-0.0057081548,
0.027076738,
-0.1093287617,
0.0115153957,
0.0139197996,
0.0332943201,
0.01304885,
0.0060592075,
-0.0037856614,
-0.0461230241,
-0.0126511818,
-0.0047094086,
0.0333658867,
0.0518069528,
-0.0428574756,
0.0597049966,
0.0064630248,
-0.0471715964,
-0.0116388071,
-0.0263354219,
-0.019066954,
0.0758234411,
-0.0116672022,
0.0131473923,
0.0311007667,
-0.0135954125,
-0.0165998172,
-0.0423425883,
0.0250305068,
-0.0155439656,
0.0060597914,
0.0027219618,
-0.0130251525,
-0.0174802169,
0.0130077954,
-0.0398411155,
-0.0129672997,
-0.0201573391,
0.0038804556,
-0.0192133933,
-0.0384097621,
-0.0225961078,
-0.0104980627,
-0.0117851188,
-0.0040746708,
-0.0626917332,
-0.0842446163,
0.0505221598,
-0.0220519993,
-0.0303755011,
0.0243308358,
2.553533725e-34,
0.004970999,
-0.0342514627,
0.0241071414,
0.0169178229,
0.076958783,
-0.0001598704,
-0.0380397774,
0.0058708983,
-0.013582929,
-0.0319222733,
-0.0431317911
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16797v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16797v2 | Lottery Ticket Adaptation: Mitigating Destructive Interference in LLMs | 2024-06-24T16:58:23 | 2024-06-25T13:46:41 | Ashwinee Panda, Berivan Isik, Xiangyu Qi, Sanmi Koyejo, Tsachy Weissman, Prateek Mittal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing methods for adapting large language models (LLMs) to new tasks are
not suited to multi-task adaptation because they modify all the model weights
-- causing destructive interference between tasks. The resulting effects, such
as catastrophic forgetting of earlier tasks, make it challenging to obtain good
performance on multiple tasks at the same time. To mitigate this, we propose
Lottery Ticket Adaptation (LoTA), a sparse adaptation method that identifies
and optimizes only a sparse subnetwork of the model. We evaluate LoTA on a wide
range of challenging tasks such as instruction following, reasoning, math, and
summarization. LoTA obtains better performance than full fine-tuning and
low-rank adaptation (LoRA), and maintains good performance even after training
on other tasks -- thus, avoiding catastrophic forgetting. By extracting and
fine-tuning over lottery tickets (or sparse task vectors), LoTA also enables
model merging over highly dissimilar tasks. Our code is made publicly available
at https://github.com/kiddyboots216/lottery-ticket-adaptation. | [
0.0098162713,
0.0609791093,
0.0041182181,
0.052350115,
-0.0080608884,
0.0332431644,
-0.0206234958,
-0.0241234172,
-0.0137134902,
-0.0650380179,
-0.0640409514,
-0.0420317873,
-0.0006309898,
-0.0222556647,
0.0500851311,
-0.0396322161,
0.0647386461,
-0.0712037683,
-0.0178440716,
-0.0023020408,
-0.0234143008,
0.0048235604,
-0.0262445528,
0.016861679,
0.0527371392,
-0.0024092086,
0.0137263732,
0.0114710415,
0.0274268575,
-0.0114744287,
0.0152697759,
0.0526466034,
0.0216583516,
0.0126912212,
0.0000018606,
-0.0370633639,
-0.0044198767,
-0.0328107588,
-0.0275306944,
0.0137783894,
0.0204270072,
0.024056647,
-0.0160069484,
0.0191795751,
-0.0296090636,
0.0012957783,
0.0523528457,
0.0375385843,
0.0704046711,
0.0948800221,
0.0046261582,
-0.0034545732,
0.0387347154,
-0.0539529845,
0.0335584097,
-0.0717025623,
0.0262476988,
-0.0171599649,
-0.0243406314,
-0.0165416077,
-0.0161890723,
0.0173197519,
0.0020782677,
0.0102624428,
0.0034535541,
0.0264780931,
-0.037234053,
0.0095269829,
-0.0199015941,
0.0584334619,
-0.0442012884,
-0.0128463991,
-0.0011728607,
0.0050536352,
0.0117879361,
-0.0398700498,
-0.0685290247,
0.0120310094,
0.0424639806,
0.0250013713,
0.0386394449,
-0.0470456965,
0.0351469927,
0.0074532661,
-0.0404044278,
0.0266337115,
0.0369033329,
-0.0258995481,
-0.0135136126,
0.0152504919,
-0.0430100299,
-0.0456883498,
-0.0039770305,
0.0380694605,
-0.0471994132,
0.0151210446,
-0.0941024646,
-0.0476359241,
-0.005894999,
-0.0103479438,
0.1114996597,
0.0606025048,
-0.013032903,
0.0411198586,
-0.0486709736,
0.0296560545,
-0.013324351,
0.0432326607,
-0.0453768298,
0.023050366,
-0.0428535827,
0.026539851,
-0.0129536912,
0.051845964,
-0.0300562251,
0.017625792,
-0.0263961516,
0.0464659743,
-0.0232283399,
-0.0009063887,
0.0126887215,
-0.0257335212,
-0.0393949561,
-0.0177618768,
-0.017781999,
0.0440321416,
-0.0151837291,
0.0190496463,
0.0358556658,
-0.0087120486,
-0.054360792,
0.0167190824,
0.0039563808,
-0.0538272858,
-0.0039866273,
0.0653638616,
-0.0589911528,
-0.0055286144,
-0.0766855553,
0.0132628111,
0.0194224678,
-0.0674525574,
0.0020872264,
-0.0641226918,
0.0224369895,
-0.0248095039,
0.0049189208,
-0.0416373499,
0.001871106,
0.0064759599,
-0.0325627513,
0.0415728018,
0.0100230416,
-0.0275803506,
0.0227810182,
0.0213629287,
-0.0155857094,
0.0623440593,
0.0160869919,
-0.0030330406,
0.0076166843,
-0.0003894035,
-0.0292361826,
0.0422476232,
0.0164652131,
0.025861904,
-0.0016431212,
-0.0008069984,
0.0393647403,
-0.0154956011,
0.0514772981,
0.0252210796,
-0.0288498122,
0.018024249,
0.0615346842,
0.0510290861,
0.0223563351,
0.0135676712,
0.0069431635,
-0.0106536252,
-0.0154598057,
0.0467973836,
-0.095108144,
0.0439163893,
-0.058544796,
0.0116469646,
0.0474577099,
0.0332510807,
-0.0357543081,
-0.067505464,
-0.0030433442,
0.0039710798,
0.0089920014,
0.0244093724,
0.0361058116,
-0.0096773067,
-0.0539759658,
0.0336037539,
0.0393321253,
-0.0344449989,
0.0152521674,
-0.0695815682,
0.0239126999,
0.0535391383,
0.0295654088,
-0.0522989519,
-0.0777770653,
0.0088041741,
-0.0009449165,
0.0197700299,
0.0204177089,
-0.0134880282,
0.0212773476,
-0.0729709789,
-0.0277165715,
0.0072212252,
0.0328040496,
0.012753428,
0.0235184059,
-0.005468498,
0.0230935663,
-0.0031239095,
-0.0091787195,
0.0319366902,
-0.0529467687,
-0.0527793802,
0.0017150601,
-0.0150814755,
0.0256769489,
-0.0125979465,
-0.005133918,
-0.0015647664,
0.0221812408,
-0.0324740596,
0.0116825271,
-0.0453406796,
-0.0576512143,
-0.024771763,
0.0298513118,
0.0292403232,
-0.014061626,
0.0774704292,
-0.0466453172,
-0.0468601994,
0.0174123347,
-0.0209706314,
-0.0043516043,
-0.0164508652,
0.0331461988,
0.0281668212,
0.024687862,
-0.0480808169,
0.0531528406,
0.0022617923,
-0.0315151587,
0.0185382459,
-0.0153072784,
-0.0134325176,
-0.0695163533,
-0.0330527648,
0.0036686873,
-0.0149113825,
0.0433939248,
-0.0170041863,
0.0190933738,
-0.0500637889,
-0.0340988338,
-0.0652941614,
0.0552290156,
-0.0398800075,
0.0556408986,
0.0315401256,
0.0130148195,
-0.0003086035,
-0.0136718946,
-0.0207797177,
-0.0005603664,
-0.0223365854,
0.0131876636,
0.0033002463,
0.0046115709,
0.0142893353,
-0.0740684569,
-0.0428210124,
0.0008658069,
0.0138994316,
-0.0613354146,
-0.0054903589,
-0.0779533535,
0.0685890019,
-0.0279958509,
0.0248187426,
-0.0091757765,
0.0118316496,
-0.0296062231,
-0.0439585894,
0.0762954876,
0.089188315,
-0.0116157988,
0.008734528,
0.0679229796,
-0.0211137366,
-0.0356328078,
0.0218396075,
0.0112470333,
-0.0285144858,
-0.0476371646,
-0.0069483402,
-0.0091435686,
0.0710133016,
-0.0149092497,
-0.0290011019,
-0.044359643,
-0.026881529,
-0.0172498748,
-0.0190051235,
-0.050136447,
0.0395694748,
-0.0193033628,
0.002502478,
-0.0391247831,
-0.0167322867,
0.0489363335,
-0.0028946023,
0.0038739319,
-0.070820488,
-0.0273771603,
-0.0442867503,
0.0121295284,
-0.0036259941,
-0.0206221957,
-0.0060906652,
-0.0221666247,
-0.085094519,
-0.0382507034,
0.0066097998,
-0.0119212801,
0.1088453382,
-0.0544426925,
0.017568171,
-0.0534559228,
-0.0304225683,
-0.0327196755,
-0.0267238859,
0.0037499627,
0.0188846216,
0.0088183144,
-0.0171016082,
-0.0674156398,
-0.0255838055,
0.0239780173,
0.0739061013,
-0.0319184065,
-0.0002556491,
-0.0397695899,
0.0519813672,
0.0704369769,
0.0680660754,
0.0275532324,
-0.0679599568,
-0.0101848617,
0.0362438336,
0.0761870593,
-0.0330733284,
0.0000929431,
0.0341350287,
0.0618477613,
-0.0447262824,
-0.0025913396,
0.0378962904,
0.0694487318,
-0.0584998615,
0.0111370981,
0.0972725451,
0.0031896892,
-0.0492687561,
-0.006042535,
-0.0227732789,
0.0635625646,
0.0198582597,
0.0308006704,
-0.0488804653,
-0.0431219339,
0.0135961026,
0.0105364854,
0.0448428616,
-0.0127590094,
0.0064892313,
-0.1000436842,
0.0139524937,
0.0530681312,
-0.0183313545,
0.000460308,
-0.0012305626,
0.0290763341,
-0.0090317912,
0.0523038246,
0.0112491706,
-0.0272876844,
-0.0162222981,
0.0197382737,
0.0173223224,
-0.0387822911,
-0.0021490848,
-0.0108972089,
0.0636642352,
0.0219299197,
-0.0200351011,
-0.0113890972,
-0.0218395609,
0.069287926,
-0.010432696,
-0.0316359438,
-0.0160196517,
0.0276312679,
0.0052085049,
0.0043101148,
0.0293327514,
0.0235107914,
-0.0432265885,
-0.0319376513,
0.0379369408,
0.0841146186,
0.0064803488,
-0.011745262,
0.0006335917,
-0.0258201417,
-0.002344613,
0.0502357893,
0.0233483054,
-0.0425997488,
-0.0091586169,
-0.0188076422,
-0.0420288257,
-0.0838624239,
-0.0108836628,
0.0068332264,
-0.0210460462,
0.0095421905,
-0.0490371548,
-0.004262052,
0.0261181183,
0.0173645038,
0.0097917691,
0.0246678144,
0.0088900896,
-0.027027797,
-0.0252774823,
0.0408022813,
-0.0660991967,
-0.0131635377,
-0.0628587678,
-0.0265688132,
-0.0021075455,
-0.0117392316,
-0.0074712858,
-0.0044337315,
-0.1265463382,
-0.0663861483,
-0.0176113341,
0.0430965424,
0.0144405458,
0.0575257279,
0.0259048808,
-0.0591769069,
0.03742617,
-0.0155923115,
-0.0020681201,
0.0660838112,
0.0247005839,
-0.0250868741,
-0.0024517218,
0.0295182094,
-0.0550029017,
0.011245843,
0.0374986306,
0.0636110902,
-0.0192649476,
0.004194323,
-0.0280566961,
0.0057674702,
0.0033635849,
-0.0006370512,
0.0032188375,
-0.0426692441,
0.0443404242,
0.0122860698,
0.0136247659,
-0.0334860049,
-0.0177670177,
0.0188739952,
-0.0161334611,
0.0209532399,
0.014920624,
0.0338035487,
0.0399176516,
-0.0527081564,
-0.0001825695,
-0.0184174236,
-0.0225377679,
0.0234010033,
0.0196615197,
-0.0284308325,
0.0134366872,
0.021523267,
0.0283312518,
-0.0213283598,
0.0123209255,
0.0175900515,
-0.0015515946,
-0.0334484465,
0.042781435,
-0.050929796,
-0.0405232869,
-0.0219527353,
0.0322082974,
0.0858503133,
-0.0097021498,
0.047742825,
0.0113918921,
-0.0046655908,
-0.0359797552,
-0.0147724692,
0.000191175,
0.0366159789,
0.0224826504,
0.0278739873,
0.0294113718,
-0.0003987131,
0.0759003609,
0.0130840661,
0.0323392488,
0.0061565624,
0.0532406792,
-0.0418607257,
-0.0426200889,
0.0056302352,
0.0336244181,
-0.0273328405,
0.001548731,
0.0115778446,
-0.0638978854,
0.006511779,
0.0057864301,
0.0027803618,
-0.0357568078,
0.0307002533,
0.0262891892,
-0.0217956174,
0.0133900149,
0.000241441,
-0.0184171982,
0.0153809953,
-0.025583582,
-0.0202903226,
-6.388607555e-33,
-0.0597683303,
0.0114826867,
0.0431401134,
0.0325057432,
-0.0181607492,
-0.0185970794,
-0.0521370135,
0.0292484313,
-0.0177848823,
-0.023753589,
-0.0079083825,
0.002929298,
0.0235837512,
0.0418386981,
0.0118273543,
-0.015843261,
0.041699145,
0.0057665501,
-0.0368440598,
0.022146035,
0.0070028603,
0.0200836398,
0.0514685586,
-0.0368944108,
0.0154160531,
0.0099037476,
0.0218553953,
0.0216960609,
-0.0076075215,
0.0620269291,
-0.0106779533,
0.0588241331,
0.0311634559,
-0.0332124792,
-0.0564989336,
0.0158801191,
-0.0704840049,
-0.049529314,
0.0445679873,
-0.0163439587,
-0.0253886525,
-0.0650147498,
0.0282884613,
0.0293007661,
-0.013847962,
-0.0689817593,
0.0353981145,
-0.0392490178,
-0.0464470126,
0.0187720302,
-0.0678177699,
0.0038763301,
0.0039298618,
-0.0240446515,
0.0297867935,
-0.0212696269,
-0.0078914817,
0.0059362655,
-0.0465082824,
0.0008696961,
-0.0201213136,
0.1131183729,
0.0667708293,
0.0328734741,
-0.056320522,
0.0286639333,
0.0004398442,
0.0198131055,
0.0039771264,
-0.0372035503,
0.0510295182,
0.0251567513,
0.0310754869,
-0.0029609923,
0.0394166112,
0.0138499774,
-0.0552480295,
0.0199233983,
0.0161187239,
0.0195618998,
0.0292869303,
0.048309084,
0.0224611145,
-0.0024396293,
-0.0313328765,
0.0565999299,
-0.0441485904,
0.0183669403,
0.0261083618,
0.0116388947,
0.0132928668,
-0.0010402505,
0.047810968,
-0.0429147631,
0.0177466776,
0.0129208947,
0.0021821794,
0.0044952207,
0.0019786851,
0.0219212472,
-0.0433438718,
-0.0579186268,
0.0161853768,
-0.0033993856,
-0.0025936132,
0.004260336,
0.0527917743,
0.0161912367,
-0.0527374223,
-0.0088699572,
-0.0168710686,
0.0284594689,
0.0256397873,
0.0937655568,
0.010479101,
-0.0081257373,
0.0205775257,
0.0480453968,
0.0001647156,
-0.0264101122,
-0.0051834802,
0.0278541017,
0.0051265634,
0.03072902,
-0.0040752748,
0.0285979956,
-0.0419474691,
0.0098935729,
0.0121814786,
-0.041749794,
-0.0148425903,
0.0117546106,
2.574e-7,
0.0167853665,
0.0381042324,
-0.019076081,
-0.0075067347,
0.0069513679,
0.0523439609,
-0.0507459976,
0.0251262169,
0.0421385951,
0.0273139328,
0.0041301432,
0.0653413683,
0.0468540676,
0.0057792696,
-0.0690197274,
-0.0020161653,
-0.0283312574,
0.0480770618,
-0.0256051067,
0.0011076262,
0.0423316695,
0.0891186595,
0.0092411917,
-0.0280649737,
-0.0006075469,
-0.0353497043,
0.0444198139,
-0.0217422917,
-0.0244351104,
0.0320394672,
0.0011848052,
0.0236217193,
-0.0215019993,
0.0094263554,
-0.0340501033,
0.037075635,
-0.0197363384,
0.0742020905,
-0.0081791654,
-0.0216336176,
0.0028870853,
0.0203074981,
0.0108644431,
-0.0165717732,
0.0643088743,
-0.0513439551,
-0.0297425296,
-0.019817885,
-0.0057368339,
-0.010413873,
-0.0081873434,
-0.0196267944,
-0.0155475019,
-0.006915207,
0.0365232788,
0.0119680073,
-0.041847907,
-0.0932923332,
-0.006696716,
0.056092646,
-0.0517768301,
-0.0523162149,
-0.0451945625,
-0.0132838013,
0.0212978553,
-0.0891635492,
0.0041225073,
2.575276008e-34,
0.0430395044,
-0.0061484235,
0.024097532,
0.053373795,
0.0067384313,
-0.0128728952,
-0.0446890965,
0.0220092591,
0.004790768,
-0.0845037326,
-0.022967387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16783v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16783v2 | M2Lingual: Enhancing Multilingual, Multi-Turn Instruction Alignment in Large Language Models | 2024-06-24T16:45:13 | 2024-06-28T10:14:53 | Rishabh Maheshwary, Vikas Yadav, Hoang Nguyen, Khyati Mahajan, Sathwik Tejaswi Madhusudhan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Instruction finetuning (IFT) is critical for aligning Large Language Models
(LLMs) to follow instructions. While many effective IFT datasets have been
introduced recently, they predominantly focus on high-resource languages like
English. To better align LLMs across a broad spectrum of languages and tasks,
we propose a fully synthetic, novel taxonomy (Evol) guided Multilingual,
Multi-turn instruction finetuning dataset, called M2Lingual. It is constructed
by first selecting a diverse set of seed examples and then utilizing the
proposed Evol taxonomy to convert these seeds into complex and challenging
multi-turn instructions. We demonstrate the effectiveness of M2Lingual by
training LLMs of varying sizes and showcasing the enhanced performance across a
diverse set of languages. We contribute the 2 step Evol taxonomy with the
guided generation code: https://github.com/ServiceNow/M2Lingual, as well as the
first fully synthetic, general and task-oriented, multi-turn, multilingual
dataset built with Evol - M2Lingual:
https://huggingface.co/datasets/ServiceNow-AI/ M2Lingual - containing 182K
total IFT pairs, covering 70 languages and 17+ NLP tasks. | [
0.0084252385,
0.0237385705,
-0.0020913025,
0.0457066521,
-0.0379584208,
0.0299049895,
-0.0011070069,
-0.0483651571,
-0.023241207,
-0.0283736121,
-0.0602094419,
-0.011718832,
-0.0116224289,
-0.0304581597,
0.0469094329,
-0.0311722755,
0.0642347857,
-0.0287749674,
-0.0556307808,
-0.0026084504,
0.0215019472,
0.0597250424,
-0.0255765785,
0.0359004065,
0.0029405619,
-0.0523860753,
-0.0166149214,
0.0152212419,
0.0346222892,
-0.0378575996,
0.0430262797,
0.044454392,
0.0269394759,
0.0388754532,
0.0000019317,
-0.0245986804,
-0.0041239699,
-0.0134203443,
-0.0471022502,
0.0003396371,
0.0294157472,
-0.0341322832,
-0.0230701696,
0.0111609157,
-0.0118297152,
-0.0001958975,
0.0601362139,
0.0413095206,
0.0617438778,
0.0735992119,
0.0085919816,
-0.0381445065,
0.0356906615,
-0.0267406106,
-0.0102040721,
-0.038837947,
-0.0028700703,
-0.0071831918,
-0.0215517469,
0.0284902547,
-0.0329691581,
0.0286918059,
0.0465320535,
0.0173367988,
-0.0443024896,
0.0198594499,
-0.0421147011,
-0.0271737613,
-0.0229089558,
0.0884798765,
-0.0401331224,
-0.0103084212,
-0.0335300304,
-0.0110892579,
-0.0094566001,
-0.0462273359,
-0.0348082632,
0.0329912603,
-0.0044039236,
0.02659286,
0.0537409969,
-0.0460592806,
0.0254999287,
-0.0036274083,
0.0053737001,
0.0523343794,
0.0300145913,
-0.0328614675,
0.0210531093,
0.0022805452,
-0.03294532,
-0.0249029547,
-0.035259597,
0.010336793,
-0.0579769984,
0.0239371471,
-0.0664573237,
0.0060163243,
0.0386156291,
-0.0007036016,
0.0734820962,
0.0393826552,
-0.0111335581,
0.0098971324,
-0.01444529,
0.0520160906,
-0.0159398019,
0.041248031,
-0.0496769212,
-0.0097922329,
-0.0342245214,
0.0195451397,
-0.0353099145,
-0.0074227317,
-0.0450565666,
0.0064721624,
-0.0290556848,
0.0158814732,
-0.0295327157,
0.0300832763,
0.0343173407,
-0.0258367024,
-0.0636859685,
-0.0000466404,
0.0194422789,
0.0339473672,
-0.0428932868,
0.021460291,
0.0041246209,
-0.065436855,
-0.0173921604,
0.0268590562,
-0.019790329,
-0.042366866,
0.0165597852,
0.0609863661,
-0.0247865971,
-0.0259044338,
-0.0316409059,
-0.0023565844,
-0.0055925474,
-0.0673633814,
-0.0023022648,
-0.0712064654,
0.0647463053,
-0.0174188204,
0.0142157441,
-0.0005955645,
0.0181181822,
0.0207133088,
-0.006983507,
0.0544273183,
-0.0042184321,
0.0067285253,
-0.0253831986,
-0.0285959728,
0.0188730881,
0.0758479983,
0.0278980937,
-0.0237241294,
0.0462043919,
-0.0115406141,
-0.0228993017,
0.0834529251,
0.0254536048,
0.022049604,
0.0429324508,
-0.0044482509,
0.0126931481,
0.0375384055,
0.061127726,
0.0389805026,
-0.0086781094,
0.0091424882,
0.0178660005,
0.0131683908,
0.011180155,
0.0133351265,
0.0949597061,
0.0136204334,
-0.0420180596,
0.039897874,
-0.0759833679,
0.0255822074,
-0.0123033747,
0.0245532822,
0.0168686993,
0.0588081963,
-0.0522587299,
-0.0139135746,
0.0047678789,
0.0015311139,
-0.0058305091,
0.0000628895,
0.0260780621,
0.0258990899,
-0.0528776795,
0.0245618336,
0.0530148447,
-0.0274775606,
0.0117869545,
-0.0212794095,
-0.0157081224,
0.0661148578,
0.0174830593,
-0.0121124862,
-0.0981796011,
-0.0020983852,
0.0227589644,
0.0451326035,
0.0512517579,
-0.0299198311,
0.0248773415,
-0.0816174746,
-0.0167340152,
-0.0106330467,
0.0008113468,
0.0066776099,
0.0236488096,
0.000882432,
-0.0107255494,
-0.0080446564,
-0.0575664975,
0.0503581651,
-0.0478191376,
-0.0604263321,
-0.0225780141,
0.0207876973,
0.0233311299,
-0.0047799218,
-0.0004641815,
-0.005049597,
0.0387831368,
-0.0169137027,
0.0312297493,
-0.0092010228,
-0.0517189354,
-0.0614089668,
0.0448113754,
-0.0101729175,
-0.0714150742,
0.0176857486,
-0.0823525414,
-0.0410169177,
-0.0235455818,
-0.0053798021,
0.0000907594,
-0.0035321773,
0.0389047787,
0.0301554073,
0.010262874,
-0.036802832,
-0.0003968399,
-0.0259530004,
0.0422997214,
0.0135476589,
-0.0109296981,
-0.0052190907,
-0.0216898229,
0.0025467093,
0.012325854,
-0.0157365464,
0.022331208,
0.0029137402,
0.0711947381,
-0.0628473759,
-0.0509468913,
-0.0653104112,
0.0351074263,
-0.0383755825,
0.0400665142,
0.0561827756,
0.0008347599,
0.0012155834,
-0.0041788868,
-0.0375942439,
-0.0093387961,
0.0050447579,
0.0228010565,
0.0039604004,
-0.0043206224,
-0.0255371854,
-0.0378357023,
-0.0230165776,
-0.0145568261,
-0.0243716203,
-0.0346692167,
0.0312823802,
-0.0664863288,
0.0041789766,
-0.0023942739,
0.0299703497,
-0.0193220563,
-0.0505877547,
0.0170719959,
0.0043636407,
0.0712464303,
0.0479617119,
-0.0273453668,
0.0252743904,
0.026717376,
-0.0289208852,
-0.0522568822,
0.0307377223,
-0.0245662499,
-0.0535378829,
-0.0605066791,
-0.0428689457,
-0.0179885682,
0.071852982,
-0.0135011943,
-0.0017006592,
-0.0765694082,
-0.0300879013,
-0.0062425984,
0.0045459955,
0.0170354154,
0.0465626195,
-0.0253520664,
-0.0050874338,
-0.0549414195,
-0.051952377,
0.0467086434,
-0.0369132496,
-0.0383784361,
-0.0699643195,
0.0122484164,
0.0024291275,
0.0177392513,
0.0158125386,
0.0247463044,
-0.0133220078,
-0.0265358072,
-0.0702740401,
0.0224182289,
0.0225292426,
-0.0142504266,
0.0719097182,
-0.0488437712,
-0.0159523971,
-0.0284785312,
-0.0301760938,
-0.0190541167,
-0.0157771111,
0.0252250526,
0.0267326385,
0.0463736206,
-0.0313151106,
-0.0472280458,
-0.0330164209,
0.0311983954,
0.0497499034,
-0.0302437488,
0.0111985663,
-0.0459381714,
-0.017695507,
0.0679519102,
0.0227503069,
-0.0025593757,
-0.0458105318,
0.0495788194,
0.0248874035,
0.0446379334,
-0.0242881663,
-0.0002067275,
0.0133969365,
0.0540595502,
-0.0356274135,
-0.0176391583,
0.0074480497,
0.0880055428,
-0.0515308231,
-0.020301396,
0.1072647423,
0.0109459814,
-0.0445284545,
0.0094091399,
-0.0028967501,
0.0356726907,
0.0436917692,
0.0216692239,
-0.0662508383,
-0.0300340634,
0.0040569617,
0.0179706533,
0.0218043327,
-0.0094996179,
-0.0108865155,
-0.1214892194,
0.0375158079,
0.0228915457,
-0.0716155767,
-0.0658344254,
-0.0118566146,
-0.0062670182,
0.0030344061,
0.0540731959,
-0.0033627446,
-0.0262215715,
-0.004088481,
0.0308153257,
0.0120986681,
-0.0619113706,
0.0524956621,
-0.0515438318,
0.0798072666,
0.0813591778,
0.014633094,
0.0059851743,
-0.0262894928,
0.03748345,
-0.0214668401,
-0.0309631545,
-0.0105188619,
0.0500420108,
-0.0217230394,
-0.0243051406,
0.020785626,
0.0451334082,
-0.0313573033,
0.0086039724,
0.0177133586,
0.0833615065,
-0.0066935858,
0.0160267465,
0.0145468665,
-0.0073563857,
0.0143097714,
0.0456872918,
0.011992055,
-0.0497378521,
0.0082530528,
-0.0301782545,
-0.0031983813,
-0.0788171589,
-0.0217485167,
0.0514130332,
-0.0578062721,
0.0074459049,
-0.0555891804,
-0.0906263813,
0.0708374158,
0.020652391,
0.0243562292,
-0.0134444069,
0.03459315,
-0.0548785217,
-0.0296733472,
0.032182727,
-0.0268247873,
0.0328714103,
-0.0984066948,
-0.0690191537,
0.0045692809,
0.0172105711,
0.0096653374,
0.0190535467,
-0.0520948991,
-0.0633170456,
-0.0074790046,
0.0727018043,
0.0024244264,
0.0621192902,
-0.0064978725,
-0.0018190651,
-0.0238119159,
0.0146958111,
-0.0270508695,
-0.0134176193,
0.0584009029,
0.0192191452,
-0.0030515643,
0.0563188381,
-0.0261700358,
0.0290892702,
0.0090023698,
0.068167299,
-0.022016285,
-0.0160130002,
0.0241552759,
0.0070556379,
0.0348785333,
-0.0399592109,
0.0113914851,
-0.0432620384,
0.0105339503,
-0.004023097,
-0.0446733795,
-0.0298682414,
0.0061842506,
0.0192925967,
-0.0207373481,
0.0099578882,
0.0169966426,
0.0099446699,
-0.0290690456,
-0.0418922082,
0.0163166244,
0.0042557651,
0.0255970974,
0.0159962457,
0.04108233,
-0.0226850063,
0.0008417872,
0.011444822,
0.0476907268,
-0.0215319134,
0.0723758265,
0.0358382091,
0.0385110378,
-0.023798665,
0.0346295647,
0.016230626,
-0.0236398336,
-0.0306837372,
-0.0155609353,
0.0801145583,
-0.0386581346,
0.0790570751,
0.0037567373,
-0.0226604939,
-0.0216917619,
0.0340253599,
-0.0307005979,
-0.0179245453,
0.0359594189,
0.0395990424,
-0.0002963583,
-0.0121609867,
0.0714120567,
-0.0211565103,
0.0483163111,
0.0087775467,
0.0542730838,
-0.0313099623,
-0.0444737263,
0.0002048419,
-0.0196504854,
-0.0106348516,
0.0201216284,
-0.0057594972,
-0.0639848039,
-0.0481934212,
0.0321893841,
-0.0137840742,
-0.0052179755,
0.0419550538,
0.0362859778,
-0.039348837,
-0.0201348048,
-0.0423994809,
-0.0138674201,
0.0191544276,
-0.0393766426,
-0.0402407125,
-6.113250207e-33,
-0.0406405032,
0.0129674217,
0.0521691665,
0.0104824612,
-0.0262061711,
-0.0079840049,
-0.0174543727,
-0.0074023441,
-0.0336964875,
0.0233075973,
0.0075621288,
-0.0125903264,
0.0084415972,
0.0465433709,
0.0469563194,
0.0081601348,
0.0445243157,
-0.0183686204,
-0.0078554852,
0.0498518981,
0.0166951492,
-0.003266494,
0.0861473083,
-0.037666887,
0.0272892565,
-0.0107551636,
-0.0063210842,
0.0248904414,
-0.0561592579,
0.0689589232,
0.0066625527,
0.0208475403,
0.0162014142,
-0.0238839313,
-0.0389972739,
-0.0091758091,
-0.0745965913,
-0.0280877165,
0.013630528,
0.0331017561,
-0.050344497,
-0.04044085,
0.0089210598,
-0.0333477966,
-0.0160173513,
-0.0095733115,
0.026512932,
-0.0159788467,
-0.005379715,
0.0022244249,
-0.0926148072,
-0.0084374612,
-0.002290633,
-0.0681210309,
0.014138788,
0.0348671153,
0.020455841,
-0.0111474302,
-0.0484557413,
-0.0013567072,
-0.0176125448,
0.0697909296,
0.0818203539,
0.0142674977,
0.0063804984,
0.0175312124,
-0.0116097387,
-0.0129951574,
0.0434140526,
0.0244985037,
0.0331088603,
0.0449292101,
0.0174134504,
0.0181855094,
0.0245431457,
0.0200881492,
-0.0127455639,
0.0275921375,
0.0124431131,
0.0499696061,
0.0019648275,
-0.0171309318,
-0.0056855329,
-0.021764474,
-0.031033136,
-0.0117677115,
-0.0165628027,
-0.0047893459,
0.033599142,
0.0001988897,
0.0238400064,
0.0123359133,
0.0456759706,
-0.0029507922,
-0.0402551852,
-0.0064998548,
-0.016689375,
0.0124043738,
-0.0133823166,
0.0315376595,
-0.084622547,
-0.0699692816,
-0.0011507444,
-0.0290903766,
0.0319427215,
0.0241085067,
0.073988907,
0.0148326354,
-0.0664029047,
0.0201358236,
-0.0520630553,
0.0504794866,
-0.0060205087,
0.0210063122,
0.033018589,
0.0029730087,
-0.0098078325,
0.0714332759,
0.0352296568,
-0.0397618599,
-0.0237316117,
-0.039049685,
-0.0037039013,
0.0420353003,
-0.0252629183,
0.0257004444,
-0.0669215173,
0.002864179,
-0.0008111153,
-0.0305830408,
-0.0104378434,
0.023936294,
2.565e-7,
0.0410358831,
0.048222322,
0.0383154675,
0.0300953276,
0.0004515002,
0.016430717,
-0.0343135782,
-0.0063157966,
-0.0217308812,
0.0250895526,
0.004431807,
0.0187230203,
0.0518621206,
0.0193083864,
-0.059035603,
0.0130376164,
-0.0420356691,
0.0427859873,
-0.0534856059,
0.0200068504,
0.0192178804,
0.1160565466,
0.0048575364,
0.0124187218,
0.0147978906,
0.0105795339,
0.0269902535,
-0.0260770638,
0.0192997009,
0.038897384,
-0.0388032272,
0.0163122136,
-0.0209221952,
0.0124614704,
-0.0296145845,
0.0006147047,
-0.0336955264,
0.0826367438,
-0.0010385776,
-0.0070054079,
0.0289409198,
-0.0207073763,
-0.0232338589,
-0.0416957401,
0.030663047,
-0.0491962843,
-0.0028271745,
-0.0048180791,
-0.0162585862,
0.0361793377,
0.0069027077,
-0.0349855609,
-0.0199871827,
0.0412919335,
0.0462218523,
-0.0275401622,
-0.0518934876,
-0.0631768033,
0.0061072581,
0.0513490774,
-0.0253842119,
-0.0271113403,
-0.0136193372,
-0.0156303495,
-0.0176606756,
-0.0326427147,
-0.0140156457,
2.5842853e-34,
0.0123623833,
-0.0237779226,
0.0614486076,
0.0317859873,
0.0107272817,
-0.0406463966,
-0.0468307473,
0.0418547131,
-0.0042920178,
-0.0555565991,
-0.0290897544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16779v1 | It Is Not About What You Say, It Is About How You Say It: A Surprisingly Simple Approach for Improving Reading Comprehension | 2024-06-24T16:43:11 | 2024-06-24T16:43:11 | Sagi Shaier, Lawrence E Hunter, Katharina von der Wense | cs.CL | cs.CL | Natural language processing has seen rapid progress over the past decade. Due
to the speed of developments, some practices get established without proper
evaluation. Considering one such case and focusing on reading comprehension, we
ask our first research question: 1) How does the order of inputs -- i.e.,
question and context -- affect model performance? Additionally, given recent
advancements in input emphasis, we ask a second research question: 2) Does
emphasizing either the question, the context, or both enhance performance?
Experimenting with 9 large language models across 3 datasets, we find that
presenting the context before the question improves model performance, with an
accuracy increase of up to $31\%$. Furthermore, emphasizing the context yields
superior results compared to question emphasis, and in general, emphasizing
parts of the input is particularly effective for addressing questions that
models lack the parametric knowledge to answer. Experimenting with both
prompt-based and attention-based emphasis methods, we additionally find that
the best method is surprisingly simple: it only requires concatenating a few
tokens to the input and results in an accuracy improvement of up to $36\%$,
allowing smaller models to outperform their significantly larger counterparts. | [
0.0373918042,
-0.008395168,
-0.0230317749,
0.0157181695,
-0.0578308105,
0.0269902945,
0.0389990248,
-0.0291768964,
-0.0185218584,
-0.0418115333,
0.011592227,
-0.0096503468,
0.0472947918,
0.0047335546,
0.0436995327,
-0.0845856965,
0.0742117092,
-0.0259207916,
0.0511708334,
-0.0018328056,
0.0248975568,
-0.0124336444,
-0.0089009218,
0.0106440214,
0.027173603,
-0.0147846686,
-0.0126543269,
0.0067650699,
0.00876489,
-0.0076524541,
-0.019394476,
0.0269939024,
-0.0396827608,
-0.0086330352,
0.0000022354,
-0.035714522,
-0.0296868626,
-0.0139935259,
0.0144028431,
0.0606241301,
0.040750403,
-0.0394986309,
0.0126944026,
0.022253789,
-0.0208084788,
0.0202017669,
0.0167628955,
0.0694475323,
-0.0018410733,
0.040646404,
0.0130866505,
-0.0264490955,
0.0068767844,
0.0197879113,
0.0160444323,
-0.0438296534,
0.0121440068,
0.0040655392,
0.0227227136,
0.0433321409,
-0.0511861369,
0.0794234574,
0.0184973367,
0.0394124649,
0.0465844199,
0.0428328216,
0.0384263322,
-0.0031182072,
-0.0219792612,
0.0466303006,
0.0042340434,
-0.0049973554,
-0.0475425236,
-0.0235668533,
0.0169355702,
0.0187736601,
-0.0354213007,
0.0068808156,
-0.0260009207,
0.001520745,
0.0427960046,
0.0094975093,
0.0051643057,
0.0336617604,
-0.0234359875,
0.0793767869,
0.0052693356,
-0.0756581947,
-0.0067565138,
0.0056609046,
-0.0433269218,
-0.0392873921,
0.0374187827,
0.0273935348,
0.0262403488,
0.0329226665,
-0.0163847916,
-0.0373968333,
0.0187777877,
-0.0147983842,
0.0036125472,
0.0466286689,
-0.0454343706,
0.023973383,
-0.0423813537,
0.0524267145,
-0.005728066,
0.02872587,
-0.0543933138,
0.0091444133,
-0.0015476581,
-0.0159427542,
-0.0477771163,
0.0164624583,
-0.0430210829,
-0.0276325438,
-0.0248278119,
0.0046993415,
0.0261075664,
-0.0351432525,
-0.0638965219,
-0.0164742991,
-0.0294237174,
0.0228223074,
-0.0055597969,
0.0357106365,
-0.074288398,
0.0600200035,
-0.0007117884,
-0.0570138283,
-0.0254853163,
0.0231702477,
-0.0026103628,
0.003228643,
-0.0443165638,
-0.0026379291,
-0.0192927197,
-0.0457628369,
-0.0180916861,
-0.0306048598,
-0.015141177,
-0.0304684639,
-0.0257743634,
-0.0488347821,
0.0115149403,
0.0518525094,
-0.0149853071,
-0.0197578445,
-0.0168879367,
0.0266905967,
-0.0408420451,
0.0471924767,
-0.0123857884,
0.01165553,
0.0370367654,
0.0325741805,
-0.0006096148,
0.0211650766,
0.0172801241,
-0.0145214656,
0.0456895493,
-0.0068717031,
-0.0120548233,
0.0225586891,
-0.0265226439,
-0.0115479864,
0.0209835283,
0.0206555538,
-0.0563816689,
0.0342525169,
0.0441080965,
0.0452698097,
-0.0418797135,
0.0216422491,
0.0958484635,
0.0504132658,
0.0030699875,
0.0053622583,
-0.0042039719,
0.0495206043,
0.0161865894,
0.0395895578,
0.0109507311,
-0.0363421217,
-0.0400757827,
0.0566521958,
0.0386677347,
-0.0555622093,
0.0046898732,
-0.0607575476,
-0.0295599569,
0.0328219086,
0.0345978029,
0.0507601574,
0.0101326285,
0.0313115083,
-0.0678130984,
0.015690878,
0.0048483531,
-0.0317517705,
0.0048852107,
-0.0380915143,
0.0334139802,
0.0116306106,
-0.0281976089,
0.0098644542,
-0.0082519455,
0.0124040907,
0.0325265601,
0.0327827558,
0.0075028581,
0.0062662796,
0.0135623878,
-0.026804477,
0.0182410814,
0.0049794437,
0.0161867961,
0.0146314865,
-0.0208935253,
0.0080559459,
0.0250960439,
0.0010670787,
-0.0138782421,
0.0164296106,
-0.002645799,
-0.0478103571,
-0.0186143313,
0.0078943493,
0.0109537756,
0.009554985,
0.0224124193,
0.0119781774,
-0.0036329415,
-0.0125628477,
0.0215080567,
0.0029486094,
-0.0848140195,
-0.0287879407,
-0.0254306085,
-0.0096790949,
-0.0091312733,
0.0273343194,
0.0129303206,
-0.03246722,
0.0098355347,
-0.0451358259,
0.0665854514,
-0.0104644857,
-0.0088962996,
-0.0173057467,
-0.0048401891,
-0.0678913817,
0.038351763,
-0.0022030936,
0.0250954144,
0.0278591346,
0.0413379036,
-0.0055725528,
-0.034070529,
-0.0124427658,
0.0030031221,
0.0107360184,
-0.0014679005,
0.0122270258,
-0.0134209748,
-0.0790044516,
0.015535566,
-0.0674836338,
-0.0195517056,
-0.028828118,
-0.0243893061,
0.0376844816,
0.0034857169,
-0.0204094015,
-0.029313894,
0.0043741059,
0.0089678075,
-0.0282055829,
0.0278063007,
0.0500856675,
0.0664130226,
-0.0056286473,
-0.0228143819,
-0.0302622411,
-0.0154630886,
0.0278995819,
0.0647476837,
-0.0024850047,
-0.075713262,
0.0192016177,
0.0074266028,
-0.0509527512,
-0.0035258955,
-0.0394460484,
0.0020804564,
0.0090527106,
0.006020749,
0.0758152008,
0.0129003152,
0.0038193653,
0.0076672547,
-0.0047368035,
-0.0449503772,
-0.0036127272,
-0.0241957903,
0.0108872419,
0.0018949267,
-0.0450450033,
-0.0030793299,
0.0473914035,
0.0682115108,
-0.0041779717,
-0.0433224104,
0.0222123601,
-0.0539317541,
-0.0349080265,
-0.0749596059,
-0.0804936215,
-0.0421226062,
0.0562891662,
-0.0328647345,
-0.0331897587,
0.0654500872,
-0.0268613584,
-0.0262132846,
-0.0744861737,
0.0158589073,
-0.0307234433,
0.0230684727,
-0.0198656302,
0.0088367071,
0.0019900028,
-0.0784559771,
-0.027025193,
0.0084734103,
0.0066248118,
0.0049440889,
0.0762099028,
-0.0403687581,
-0.015491209,
0.0120044183,
-0.0437679142,
-0.0590426549,
-0.0236185119,
-0.0349285863,
-0.0088759223,
0.0307092648,
0.0100816051,
-0.0405462086,
0.0236028042,
0.0567907393,
0.0237265769,
-0.0580594502,
-0.0158963278,
-0.0386812799,
0.013633321,
0.0209364388,
0.0206678677,
0.0420030318,
-0.0447488688,
0.0384960547,
0.0535942577,
0.014316625,
0.0080899224,
-0.0139825484,
0.0133242719,
0.0576700382,
-0.0681365058,
-0.0259263366,
0.019106945,
0.0573357753,
-0.0941266343,
-0.011569012,
0.1170456931,
0.0139909862,
0.0170863383,
0.0065176841,
-0.0193359535,
0.0250957161,
-0.0119387703,
0.0020634199,
-0.0383841246,
-0.033799842,
-0.0000390143,
0.0619112179,
0.0115866689,
-0.0037970815,
-0.0270227417,
-0.0603195392,
0.0045634997,
0.0161744393,
-0.0992542431,
-0.0119585684,
-0.0752616152,
0.0148970708,
0.0251509193,
0.0594620705,
0.065084666,
-0.0257020555,
0.0125264712,
0.0231657941,
-0.003642197,
-0.0292929541,
-0.0350449234,
-0.0069898176,
-0.0034584813,
0.0298770368,
-0.0089293718,
-0.0264297873,
0.0150040928,
0.0330833495,
-0.0155341187,
0.0337398276,
-0.0465287827,
0.0273305979,
-0.0314454064,
0.027560655,
-0.05634325,
0.0271667875,
0.0066094934,
-0.0158644766,
0.0051235538,
0.0158048086,
0.0186234023,
-0.0057569151,
-0.0287502725,
0.0657793954,
0.0289309509,
0.0927201137,
0.0532859601,
-0.0262515526,
-0.0148841143,
-0.018568052,
0.0067633246,
-0.0204966702,
-0.0504729524,
0.0113003552,
0.0090644984,
-0.0277803615,
-0.0537197888,
-0.1244993284,
0.0124692768,
0.0207081828,
0.0255087595,
0.0572879687,
0.0223755967,
-0.0196306817,
-0.0157006308,
0.0555895902,
0.0357052162,
-0.0158061478,
-0.0657628849,
-0.0064647468,
-0.0220998581,
-0.0169835817,
-0.0470403284,
0.0289281216,
-0.0373490751,
-0.0258806888,
0.0376051925,
0.022517778,
0.0179822054,
0.035158135,
0.0105689401,
-0.0637147725,
0.0201574173,
-0.0304295924,
-0.0112911724,
0.0284263976,
0.0208230168,
-0.0400868133,
0.0207473394,
0.0374701768,
-0.0013451232,
0.0320807397,
0.0154329054,
0.0356527381,
-0.0620990135,
-0.0472026169,
0.0103313429,
0.0346795619,
0.0842167363,
0.008444461,
-0.0416384488,
-0.0144870179,
0.0055204364,
-0.0297560971,
-0.0054687811,
-0.0002447326,
-0.0199371241,
0.006615642,
-0.0068371771,
-0.0530010089,
0.0005617682,
-0.048967611,
0.0411013924,
-0.0466447063,
0.0691862926,
-0.0074933213,
0.0116358837,
-0.0003820344,
0.0212461967,
-0.0430767797,
0.0320091769,
-0.0084671928,
0.0506574847,
-0.0082708523,
0.0761728734,
0.0218535066,
0.004090575,
-0.0153611861,
0.0035656504,
-0.0943141207,
-0.0167524982,
0.0312137045,
0.001777494,
-0.0203506388,
-0.0670965686,
0.0563264377,
-0.0306133088,
0.0022229566,
-0.012150215,
0.0287104584,
0.0011843441,
-0.0506341085,
0.0389342159,
0.0035063133,
0.0076328781,
-0.0175614543,
0.0315811187,
-0.0127714472,
-0.0275114272,
0.0244111419,
-0.0102117565,
-0.0180090051,
-0.0032903161,
0.0232444182,
0.0653483793,
-0.0289957821,
0.0409783572,
-0.0911578238,
-0.0065662796,
0.0193834603,
-0.0006396397,
0.0389198959,
-0.0259168334,
0.0497450307,
0.0506563149,
-0.009354338,
-0.0668728054,
-0.0372963995,
0.0428349078,
-0.0208882261,
-0.0328798629,
-0.0074730651,
-6.753196678e-33,
-0.0098057091,
-0.0130054718,
-0.0044282223,
-0.0342302136,
-0.0170754157,
0.0299983881,
-0.0576894209,
0.0292519107,
-0.0060046078,
0.0029537079,
-0.041990146,
0.0282454472,
0.0222604237,
0.0316956267,
-0.0142682381,
0.0069039399,
0.0285655931,
0.0169122312,
-0.037723016,
-0.0238363557,
0.0308159608,
0.0326314457,
0.0448334925,
-0.0719687492,
0.0498746224,
-0.0325947292,
-0.0002328661,
-0.0412674993,
0.0243458562,
0.0146186603,
-0.0029764264,
0.08242964,
0.0188222472,
-0.0666862875,
-0.0120443767,
0.0812588558,
-0.0347672515,
-0.0406250022,
0.0738551244,
0.0366061553,
-0.0857821032,
-0.0027921603,
0.0303323008,
-0.0185480192,
0.0142287062,
-0.006239688,
0.0478253365,
-0.0399578214,
-0.0301498994,
0.0275666416,
-0.0859677643,
0.0271260794,
-0.0432222448,
0.006869622,
0.0296133552,
0.02702366,
-0.0042066155,
0.0339167193,
-0.0463744774,
0.0196955744,
0.0533918813,
0.0196453016,
0.0429123603,
0.025924664,
-0.0135708181,
0.019490255,
-0.0109177427,
0.018162176,
-0.0108490605,
-0.0266874358,
0.0341160744,
0.0013746235,
0.0320515856,
0.0312994048,
0.0493620373,
0.0038377969,
-0.0624424368,
-0.0069450457,
-0.000426072,
-0.014383737,
0.0273951255,
-0.0275221113,
-0.1199146584,
-0.0286258776,
-0.0490180925,
-0.0135632325,
-0.0260166563,
-0.0240056384,
0.0306467321,
-0.0388283692,
-0.0582000501,
0.0123120816,
0.0115809701,
-0.0095181037,
-0.0082459925,
0.0097251236,
-0.0408272222,
0.0143347429,
-0.0118299872,
0.0731624067,
-0.0579458661,
0.0401832201,
-0.0260654818,
0.0194532089,
0.035138607,
0.0165254232,
0.0187289733,
-0.0212136693,
-0.0559525229,
-0.0162497889,
0.0048968275,
0.0272411685,
0.0046546315,
-0.0288214032,
0.0498179533,
0.0363366939,
-0.0020890466,
0.0887564868,
0.0092226602,
-0.025761636,
-0.0398447588,
-0.0140247829,
-0.0445223078,
0.0211802833,
-0.0530868582,
0.0022424089,
0.0119311213,
0.0284841191,
0.0236637648,
-0.0571647361,
-0.0204993971,
0.0713321716,
2.826e-7,
0.0426232181,
0.0696416125,
0.016299149,
0.0566310473,
-0.0128747597,
0.0272416007,
0.0038334397,
0.0141606499,
0.0452768169,
0.0183104426,
-0.0117784124,
0.0454868749,
0.0129911359,
-0.0168165751,
-0.0867074504,
-0.0715165809,
-0.051600039,
0.0838505849,
-0.0297299549,
0.0201595984,
0.0640741363,
0.0727129877,
-0.0218115784,
0.0024227083,
-0.0040153484,
-0.0113790985,
0.0196407847,
-0.0247246083,
0.0449068211,
0.0282013211,
0.0270390324,
0.0218041074,
0.0286930501,
0.0548959188,
-0.0039166771,
-0.0236045793,
0.0325894989,
0.0657335892,
0.0370661654,
-0.0449573584,
-0.0311056394,
0.0185790714,
-0.0005371641,
-0.1059697643,
0.0634932742,
-0.0388831869,
-0.0182722732,
0.0236408692,
-0.0464427769,
-0.0107875615,
0.0082238317,
0.0146418633,
-0.0572608337,
0.0037937085,
0.0241238363,
-0.0714779124,
0.0116344597,
-0.0730987862,
-0.0032160524,
0.0121938428,
-0.009464222,
-0.0082683871,
-0.0260164291,
-0.0135814212,
0.0502882265,
-0.0701742694,
-0.043226283,
2.580759735e-34,
-0.003185313,
-0.0118649686,
0.055496823,
0.0257363748,
0.0010407894,
-0.0074948976,
0.0113014467,
-0.0008957321,
0.0555602387,
-0.0713073388,
-0.046006348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16778v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16778v1 | Finding Transformer Circuits with Edge Pruning | 2024-06-24T16:40:54 | 2024-06-24T16:40:54 | Adithya Bhaskar, Alexander Wettig, Dan Friedman, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The path to interpreting a language model often proceeds via analysis of
circuits -- sparse computational subgraphs of the model that capture specific
aspects of its behavior. Recent work has automated the task of discovering
circuits. Yet, these methods have practical limitations, as they rely either on
inefficient search algorithms or inaccurate approximations. In this paper, we
frame automated circuit discovery as an optimization problem and propose *Edge
Pruning* as an effective and scalable solution. Edge Pruning leverages
gradient-based pruning techniques, but instead of removing neurons or
components, it prunes the \emph{edges} between components. Our method finds
circuits in GPT-2 that use less than half the number of edges compared to
circuits found by previous methods while being equally faithful to the full
model predictions on standard circuit-finding tasks. Edge Pruning is efficient
even with as many as 100K examples, outperforming previous methods in speed and
producing substantially better circuits. It also perfectly recovers the
ground-truth circuits in two models compiled with Tracr. Thanks to its
efficiency, we scale Edge Pruning to CodeLlama-13B, a model over 100x the scale
that prior methods operate on. We use this setting for a case study comparing
the mechanisms behind instruction prompting and in-context learning. We find
two circuits with more than 99.96% sparsity that match the performance of the
full model and reveal that the mechanisms in the two settings overlap
substantially. Our case study shows that Edge Pruning is a practical and
scalable tool for interpretability and sheds light on behaviors that only
emerge in large models. | [
-0.0008214287,
0.0498108491,
-0.0287047289,
0.077528812,
-0.0381899774,
-0.0164294504,
0.0143303275,
0.0013190365,
-0.014695676,
0.0175649635,
-0.0364479646,
0.0046536662,
0.0081937294,
0.0465723984,
0.0169078391,
0.0114181787,
0.045265764,
-0.0383555777,
-0.0354292318,
-0.0150813982,
-0.0136421621,
0.0235394463,
0.0164288301,
0.0674451217,
0.0051698103,
-0.0169196408,
-0.0357578136,
0.0043893331,
0.0175278597,
0.0291232187,
-0.0161438547,
0.0616322011,
-0.0102701662,
0.0417217575,
0.0000022757,
0.0289288666,
-0.0462946258,
-0.0190496985,
-0.0600026324,
0.0303453598,
0.0113154193,
-0.0148898792,
-0.0199944787,
-0.0044187885,
0.0015838111,
-0.0436258949,
0.0867203772,
0.0244649909,
0.0475286692,
0.0606393926,
-0.0090188459,
-0.0446107201,
0.0052522602,
-0.0067510349,
0.0075487439,
-0.0193428323,
0.0022509075,
-0.0667653531,
0.0056766262,
-0.0669992939,
-0.0208224952,
0.0053635449,
0.0344033875,
0.013813369,
-0.0213254895,
0.019628007,
-0.0448304303,
-0.0280256066,
-0.0048800954,
0.0625599325,
-0.053593345,
-0.0503475815,
0.0148213236,
0.021255305,
-0.0384262875,
-0.0217344649,
-0.0030926464,
0.0014304203,
-0.0400044359,
0.0159160513,
-0.0223505739,
-0.0626929849,
0.0376809239,
-0.0454486497,
-0.0410832129,
0.0963309184,
0.0124819521,
0.0131084155,
-0.0380647071,
-0.0145729566,
-0.048296079,
-0.0195049122,
0.0374863856,
0.0143612688,
-0.0154119665,
0.001416253,
-0.0083270837,
0.0214546658,
-0.0458837412,
0.0303426404,
0.0611666776,
0.0503899269,
0.0066818567,
0.0049460479,
-0.0237308443,
0.0387165546,
-0.0287355632,
0.0453495868,
-0.0483445227,
0.0382763185,
-0.0398810245,
-0.0406138562,
-0.0521624684,
0.0424253717,
-0.0080097001,
-0.0279212985,
-0.0089075202,
0.0114471968,
-0.0337888822,
-0.0247926582,
0.0145701347,
0.0000840516,
-0.0045264056,
0.0058183856,
0.0148094306,
0.0523392856,
0.0088474983,
-0.0229843315,
-0.0410447121,
-0.0609635599,
-0.0342910327,
0.0047557373,
0.0196145847,
-0.0225057397,
0.0046685147,
0.0578238145,
0.0017054309,
-0.0669274032,
-0.0741737634,
-0.0347757004,
-0.0176724922,
-0.0352776758,
0.0161244292,
-0.0700908825,
0.0132567529,
-0.0006891947,
0.0103016086,
-0.0341839194,
0.0077091069,
0.0496170782,
-0.0077229147,
0.0572644174,
0.0160771627,
-0.0038320669,
-0.0071142241,
0.0042805728,
0.0162012521,
0.0357066095,
0.0360018723,
0.0239509344,
-0.0155233908,
-0.0234662648,
-0.0056843883,
0.0516804047,
0.048719883,
-0.0308434516,
-0.0112551739,
-0.0665096417,
-0.0006402012,
-0.0293510091,
0.0186434723,
0.0656637475,
-0.0137334876,
-0.0154993376,
0.0551041216,
0.0201877318,
0.0420934372,
0.0516245104,
0.0385465994,
-0.0021274504,
-0.0086859642,
0.0378255136,
-0.064830929,
0.0291994866,
-0.0312620141,
0.0277114846,
-0.0169071946,
0.0288394392,
-0.0068905181,
-0.0195875652,
0.0002322031,
0.0032049033,
-0.005951649,
0.0037255143,
0.0360395163,
0.0065070591,
-0.0954545587,
0.066914849,
0.0241595339,
-0.0199237093,
-0.0399013497,
-0.0829938203,
0.0149625586,
0.0418341607,
0.045991268,
-0.0118242316,
0.0159534048,
0.0231026374,
-0.0257576331,
0.0020516906,
-0.0289907716,
-0.0226357672,
0.0322616622,
-0.0038238592,
-0.0108245853,
-0.0269573107,
0.047901962,
0.0331734456,
0.0024914844,
-0.0541050844,
0.0089141922,
-0.0497055948,
0.0103669427,
0.0143501321,
0.0188149475,
-0.005745105,
0.046887286,
0.0443450212,
-0.0166746154,
-0.0187545624,
-0.0131624164,
0.0154927941,
0.0255177878,
-0.0488888547,
0.0506903157,
-0.0047812234,
-0.063842319,
-0.0192121211,
0.0527710952,
-0.0399878398,
0.0003182063,
0.0595429167,
-0.0141397472,
-0.0349686407,
0.0307382178,
-0.0922186524,
0.0582015589,
-0.0071372553,
0.0103344051,
-0.0151458699,
0.0032014046,
0.000630385,
0.084959574,
0.0377553999,
-0.0132817226,
0.0509581529,
-0.0170943439,
0.0155530171,
-0.0197773464,
-0.0360082574,
-0.004208778,
-0.0213265996,
-0.0207201634,
0.0047136499,
-0.0264269672,
-0.0046561086,
-0.0098060127,
-0.0640210211,
-0.0123147648,
-0.0149009051,
0.0203402396,
0.0312149823,
-0.0030132963,
0.0379977338,
0.0362347811,
0.0249307379,
-0.0118346661,
-0.0105381915,
0.031638477,
0.0064191143,
0.0159515943,
-0.0832842886,
-0.0350247957,
-0.0511428528,
-0.0346823335,
0.0759919956,
-0.0247296169,
-0.0018392943,
-0.0508330613,
0.0397182852,
0.0625628456,
0.0415085144,
-0.0158219878,
-0.049092412,
0.0046100379,
0.0023128211,
0.0283001047,
0.0653329715,
-0.000057261,
0.0611627102,
0.0735290721,
-0.0171255898,
-0.0003769771,
0.0055745565,
-0.0243651252,
-0.0121261841,
-0.0231391098,
-0.048720412,
-0.0271224007,
0.1140600666,
0.0117202885,
0.0096194874,
-0.0736244023,
-0.0155012105,
0.0062104305,
0.0192404352,
-0.0289681572,
-0.0370911881,
-0.0106384195,
0.0502918363,
-0.0188790634,
-0.0495320894,
0.0591665134,
-0.0208859332,
-0.0026760192,
-0.0260308571,
-0.0111508369,
-0.0250386633,
0.0578041673,
0.0457741097,
0.0507130846,
0.0390328802,
-0.0022114576,
-0.063367404,
0.0399140231,
0.0265552588,
-0.0121544264,
0.0529538244,
-0.0347095728,
0.0208738614,
0.015857581,
-0.0241523869,
-0.0197251774,
0.0380319692,
0.0082577653,
0.0213124901,
0.0629777312,
-0.0583831184,
-0.0387875363,
0.0471944138,
-0.0034894117,
0.0597163551,
0.0108497245,
-0.0110770818,
-0.0220412109,
0.0174872708,
0.0229969732,
-0.0447256044,
0.0433388837,
-0.0476079732,
0.0468576029,
0.0137011856,
0.022133803,
0.0246491432,
-0.0581724942,
0.015320831,
0.0121300947,
0.0043643774,
-0.0000016075,
0.0189367291,
0.0221129414,
-0.0304088145,
-0.0516264886,
0.0893411711,
0.0240777489,
-0.0851650685,
0.0271197595,
0.0072105392,
0.0176696014,
0.0288203489,
0.0417934395,
-0.0821145028,
-0.00901483,
0.0098726079,
0.0169782564,
-0.0058607794,
0.0218907334,
0.0060925805,
-0.0875339881,
0.0369327143,
0.0087289549,
-0.0322047137,
-0.0417168662,
-0.0506915711,
-0.019547049,
-0.0207923427,
-0.0096718231,
0.0204329919,
-0.0296608545,
-0.0087674139,
-0.0015484921,
-0.0130119473,
-0.0313782953,
0.037732102,
0.0395135917,
-0.0116987694,
0.0435503647,
-0.0088161388,
0.005980521,
-0.0335011519,
0.0519570969,
-0.0109653063,
0.0070978738,
-0.0317502394,
0.0256930087,
0.0666923523,
-0.0301022846,
-0.0138203222,
0.0262194481,
-0.0383818783,
-0.0323606394,
-0.0548513345,
0.0778226107,
-0.0230484344,
-0.0482605956,
0.0158446711,
-0.0042937011,
-0.02192761,
0.0301809702,
0.0347008035,
-0.0099995639,
-0.043548204,
-0.0252224877,
0.0374871492,
-0.046985697,
-0.0977979451,
0.0179318562,
0.0467222966,
-0.0569688082,
0.0082918638,
0.03869991,
0.0051654885,
0.0132767288,
0.0077078794,
-0.072975643,
0.0173851084,
-0.0005796329,
-0.065857999,
0.0260587893,
-0.0173889473,
0.0287217107,
-0.0976140574,
-0.0439272821,
-0.0038350732,
-0.0478830002,
-0.0630078241,
-0.00080516,
-0.1006592959,
-0.0678110868,
0.0050047799,
0.0514875911,
0.0234518815,
0.0293596946,
0.0035997042,
0.0243959744,
-0.0133696785,
0.0581717342,
-0.0264386535,
0.023182869,
0.0306602325,
-0.0903252587,
-0.0300886892,
0.0239442606,
0.022524856,
0.0503786132,
0.0387911499,
0.0214108191,
-0.0409460962,
-0.0085708853,
0.0816635862,
0.0010276608,
0.064939186,
0.060692098,
0.0192541089,
-0.0518660545,
0.0240136851,
0.0417560861,
0.0116775222,
-0.0497133918,
-0.0377900451,
0.0060463804,
-0.0003673613,
0.025352763,
-0.0704040378,
0.0231419671,
-0.005265173,
-0.0301789101,
0.0543917492,
0.0066092815,
-0.0047689388,
0.027396109,
-0.023282811,
0.0009119378,
0.0165659375,
0.0143212592,
0.045347847,
0.0016903982,
-0.002373141,
0.0252843294,
0.0133706294,
-0.0391121432,
0.0211993773,
-0.0354709402,
-0.0576784238,
-0.0512816831,
0.0068089822,
0.035285335,
-0.0229482614,
0.0141677661,
-0.0268046837,
0.0052520623,
-0.0387675315,
0.0126791056,
0.0292490367,
-0.0194917135,
0.0368602425,
0.0454526804,
0.0231762137,
-0.0522870682,
0.0586447902,
0.0054249344,
0.0798780695,
0.0082254009,
-0.0195538849,
-0.0345504619,
-0.0598453507,
-0.0352456942,
0.0094417641,
-0.0486235917,
-0.0046711033,
-0.0387065336,
-0.0575423017,
-0.018012831,
0.0009093948,
0.0353605375,
-0.0206030551,
0.0499967299,
0.0435391963,
0.0297461469,
-0.0246552676,
0.0235971771,
-0.0255318414,
0.0070250514,
-0.0005029459,
-0.002985646,
-6.457844907e-33,
-0.0243424103,
-0.0497250669,
0.0145084588,
0.0447026417,
0.0095715253,
0.0294253584,
-0.1053716093,
0.0069845608,
-0.0306177437,
0.0036627846,
-0.0050277053,
-0.0053106663,
0.0201215986,
0.0077497261,
-0.0020089112,
-0.0063734767,
0.0585510992,
0.0388621427,
-0.0359491892,
0.0408975817,
0.0212972034,
0.0136171123,
0.0674081072,
-0.0462460928,
-0.0449382961,
0.0160540938,
-0.0264514927,
0.0005190843,
-0.0505086631,
0.0586027354,
-0.0134323454,
0.0363480598,
-0.0072644218,
-0.0493677109,
0.0219925027,
-0.0167919286,
-0.0503608435,
0.0167152639,
0.0286956411,
0.0317983367,
-0.0086146761,
-0.0575416684,
0.0135546159,
0.0093609598,
-0.0246615969,
-0.0381386131,
0.0296401866,
-0.0151274977,
0.0066795838,
0.0109622823,
-0.0712050721,
0.0219895095,
-0.0051074643,
-0.0583509319,
0.0317666121,
0.0340180844,
-0.0201209337,
-0.0060283444,
-0.0527629741,
0.035269402,
0.0416602269,
0.08272098,
0.0817452297,
0.0052113961,
0.0244647413,
0.016792072,
0.0144834211,
0.011166825,
-0.0007391612,
-0.0020929931,
0.0333167538,
0.0884698853,
0.0106994612,
-0.069114089,
0.0469632372,
-0.0208464712,
-0.0496698059,
-0.0193241909,
0.0195513014,
0.0720741823,
0.0418636501,
0.0121397153,
-0.0108497674,
-0.0181380846,
0.0043316423,
-0.0156217497,
-0.0638235211,
-0.0321290344,
0.0006140318,
0.0244156811,
-0.0431318581,
0.0068205749,
0.0215840321,
-0.049586989,
0.0372939706,
0.0386529863,
-0.0016396483,
0.0297825448,
-0.0055689141,
0.0082301218,
-0.0046912292,
-0.0574207827,
-0.0178102311,
-0.0231911596,
0.0319500566,
0.0186533928,
-0.0121453525,
0.0558767766,
-0.0145086581,
-0.0145821869,
-0.0774331614,
0.003589825,
-0.0412870757,
0.0512778386,
0.0118978079,
0.0191623904,
-0.0169475898,
-0.0052146446,
-0.0007795016,
-0.0082059642,
-0.0248930138,
0.0454977341,
-0.0077095316,
0.0453005508,
-0.0356006585,
-0.0507595651,
-0.0632972196,
0.062598139,
-0.000679734,
-0.0284556858,
-0.0369166136,
0.0196764059,
3.027e-7,
0.044053521,
0.0163497459,
0.018080797,
0.0641013533,
0.0115710255,
0.0027106458,
0.0157277063,
-0.0271408968,
-0.0092209019,
-0.0336814262,
0.0058423914,
0.0144202132,
0.0345540382,
0.0160387103,
-0.0500581563,
0.0415239111,
-0.065752767,
-0.0172571428,
-0.0276544746,
-0.0114267077,
-0.0011199687,
0.0832795501,
-0.0194004606,
-0.0257143825,
0.0096333697,
0.0182771217,
0.0026017404,
-0.0227355435,
0.0536296628,
-0.0007493749,
-0.0497877263,
-0.0384314358,
-0.0325848386,
0.0338837951,
0.0002641767,
0.0139189856,
-0.0346091911,
0.0486905873,
-0.0077509624,
0.0099250041,
0.0394107848,
-0.0020058746,
-0.0151488194,
-0.0567587949,
0.0443903059,
-0.0114645483,
-0.0102721676,
-0.0296068415,
0.0141472146,
-0.0424465835,
-0.0091812424,
-0.0234600473,
0.0240107663,
0.0207299888,
-0.0144473175,
-0.0465757847,
0.0229273979,
-0.0230416786,
0.0174327716,
0.0382616036,
-0.0399185643,
-0.0240150783,
-0.0535655394,
-0.0013103498,
0.0516932718,
-0.0003467302,
-0.0113069145,
3.128887471e-34,
-0.0083110286,
-0.0262424741,
0.0105553968,
0.0717003718,
0.059207201,
-0.0094519537,
0.0148968296,
-0.0058217132,
-0.0298365168,
-0.0850070864,
-0.0506613404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16777v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16777v1 | Blending LLMs into Cascaded Speech Translation: KIT's Offline Speech Translation System for IWSLT 2024 | 2024-06-24T16:38:17 | 2024-06-24T16:38:17 | Sai Koneru, Thai-Binh Nguyen, Ngoc-Quan Pham, Danni Liu, Zhaolin Li, Alexander Waibel, Jan Niehues | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are currently under exploration for various
tasks, including Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR), Machine Translation (MT),
and even End-to-End Speech Translation (ST). In this paper, we present KIT's
offline submission in the constrained + LLM track by incorporating recently
proposed techniques that can be added to any cascaded speech translation.
Specifically, we integrate
Mistral-7B\footnote{mistralai/Mistral-7B-Instruct-v0.1} into our system to
enhance it in two ways. Firstly, we refine the ASR outputs by utilizing the
N-best lists generated by our system and fine-tuning the LLM to predict the
transcript accurately. Secondly, we refine the MT outputs at the document level
by fine-tuning the LLM, leveraging both ASR and MT predictions to improve
translation quality. We find that integrating the LLM into the ASR and MT
systems results in an absolute improvement of $0.3\%$ in Word Error Rate and
$0.65\%$ in COMET for tst2019 test set. In challenging test sets with
overlapping speakers and background noise, we find that integrating LLM is not
beneficial due to poor ASR performance. Here, we use ASR with chunked long-form
decoding to improve context usage that may be unavailable when transcribing
with Voice Activity Detection segmentation alone. | [
-0.0033597001,
0.0286113713,
0.0091867102,
0.0385226086,
-0.0325202644,
-0.0054324772,
0.0342978612,
0.0052935332,
-0.0010691695,
-0.0121833803,
-0.0432608277,
-0.0449987948,
0.0473226383,
-0.0040237079,
0.0226713326,
-0.0407271758,
0.0380770266,
-0.0597817637,
-0.034179043,
0.0142914876,
-0.0182516202,
0.0244026929,
-0.0136738745,
0.0201995838,
0.0128751546,
-0.0035731962,
0.0162627734,
0.050727237,
0.0256322213,
-0.0170720126,
-0.0295590181,
-0.0019933817,
0.0557625331,
0.0510389283,
0.0000021712,
-0.0464351699,
-0.0346796662,
0.0359230191,
-0.0323553123,
0.0047315466,
0.0108835325,
-0.0244788341,
-0.0255792122,
0.0530740134,
-0.0033249278,
0.0251149777,
0.0152551709,
-0.0118620489,
0.0328244381,
0.0760865137,
-0.0151276747,
-0.0268859155,
0.0424216688,
-0.0171032269,
0.0029690552,
-0.0461608991,
-0.0147346072,
-0.0121574551,
-0.0163847674,
-0.0041315011,
0.0125942146,
0.0506083891,
-0.0232922919,
-0.0313830711,
0.0056982655,
-0.0188763104,
-0.0396365486,
-0.0407514796,
-0.0213728882,
0.0591896288,
0.0006626468,
-0.0076293433,
0.0292335246,
0.0061339024,
-0.0572180226,
-0.0536393523,
-0.0509178042,
0.015220291,
-0.0154819312,
-0.020398384,
0.0220257565,
0.0757239684,
0.0191428345,
-0.0344269909,
-0.054800652,
0.0092563545,
0.0187013745,
-0.0456901118,
0.0023345386,
-0.0174038336,
0.0144471657,
-0.0030992138,
0.0672349855,
-0.0071669174,
-0.0094841952,
0.0238957014,
-0.036970973,
-0.0260511078,
-0.0193093475,
-0.0297481585,
0.0269402582,
0.0781492069,
-0.0075134463,
0.0390159562,
-0.0035464291,
0.0569955893,
-0.0033790015,
-0.0409483463,
-0.0463757925,
0.0015943554,
-0.01436467,
0.0463084988,
-0.0356788859,
-0.0251064971,
-0.0729963332,
-0.0410463512,
0.0015855908,
0.0180103015,
0.0376152769,
0.015474706,
0.0824521333,
-0.0607071072,
-0.0659455433,
-0.0454270206,
0.0270199217,
0.0448620506,
0.0514488481,
0.0000132696,
0.0079062898,
-0.060290426,
-0.0235501751,
0.0465659648,
0.025281148,
-0.0075595798,
-0.0303873587,
0.0850290135,
-0.0044503212,
-0.0154158603,
-0.0146280592,
-0.0111428304,
-0.0238630567,
-0.047507219,
-0.0137538165,
-0.0510202348,
0.0550976656,
0.0033865047,
0.0257970393,
0.0040033706,
0.0150992284,
-0.0076990579,
0.010822569,
0.0569372289,
-0.0118468367,
0.0354898907,
0.0220804866,
-0.0010313038,
-0.0129276859,
0.0560411252,
0.0627004504,
0.0056305961,
0.0218388513,
-0.0127625009,
-0.028381709,
0.090436399,
-0.0116790058,
0.0474111326,
-0.0290669762,
0.0005807436,
0.0167277884,
0.0105323894,
0.0287416168,
0.0376387946,
-0.0053602359,
0.0656136647,
0.0721942484,
0.0244702734,
0.0135711497,
0.0198444501,
-0.0010139188,
0.0372589603,
-0.020725742,
-0.0193001647,
0.0042058527,
-0.0167532191,
0.0029831098,
0.0052647516,
0.0473228879,
0.0317892171,
0.0208754037,
-0.0093599083,
-0.0393374301,
-0.0208787527,
-0.0134866247,
0.0189910848,
0.0327567346,
-0.0170088802,
-0.0818781704,
0.0655037537,
-0.0081221974,
-0.0631051585,
0.0301523767,
-0.0464170612,
-0.0114702908,
0.0782364234,
0.0574931726,
-0.0006005336,
-0.0199612621,
-0.0605001375,
-0.01991277,
0.067697607,
0.0088503463,
0.0276669152,
0.0319378451,
-0.0915727094,
-0.0175547935,
0.0651816949,
0.0163032152,
0.0228113756,
-0.0187600423,
0.0282840561,
0.0248305947,
-0.0232564043,
-0.0284577645,
-0.0014025876,
-0.047440283,
-0.0143224187,
0.0167332869,
0.0081463046,
0.0517300442,
0.0319143347,
-0.0279214848,
-0.0095086936,
0.0286148433,
-0.0486728847,
0.0182717927,
0.0395160615,
-0.0608439967,
-0.0384054631,
0.0333306007,
0.0082320319,
0.0361211672,
0.0059892242,
0.0045465124,
-0.0739599019,
-0.0157485679,
-0.0122807324,
0.0170242395,
-0.0235193819,
0.0623480789,
0.0231846683,
0.0109045394,
-0.0387218483,
-0.0035205863,
-0.0184632074,
-0.0203944128,
0.0181717314,
-0.0348291546,
0.0054263817,
-0.042798657,
0.0100592505,
0.0549074113,
0.0008962064,
0.0306462459,
-0.000736173,
0.0157253295,
-0.005799877,
-0.0445264131,
-0.0937013105,
0.0265162606,
-0.0339159928,
0.0409916155,
0.0089203361,
0.0416860171,
-0.0096408306,
0.0136610819,
-0.0035958774,
-0.014180705,
0.0070877587,
-0.0307029635,
-0.0596521944,
-0.006662658,
-0.0180746894,
-0.0109548755,
0.017764153,
0.0177019816,
-0.008924976,
-0.0256218147,
-0.0749324188,
-0.0787133351,
0.0406730101,
0.0200613383,
-0.0077735316,
-0.0248513985,
-0.0200298633,
-0.0206377599,
-0.0385647044,
0.0310615618,
0.0341119692,
-0.0066677337,
-0.0093142791,
-0.0016871111,
-0.0423814915,
-0.0749990866,
0.0099926703,
0.0416218564,
-0.0104817413,
-0.0237116683,
-0.0122616608,
0.0066530956,
0.0332544036,
0.0326327421,
0.0280136224,
-0.0406445786,
-0.0507847145,
-0.0278209597,
-0.0122396937,
-0.007277722,
-0.0445772335,
-0.0448286831,
0.0359604172,
0.0120597295,
-0.0427052118,
-0.0027315293,
-0.0991651416,
-0.0289203953,
-0.0711090639,
-0.0491525903,
-0.0379971638,
0.0192461126,
-0.0332768075,
-0.0119720716,
-0.0350839496,
-0.032062456,
-0.0035651389,
0.0039834906,
-0.0163599439,
-0.0525816679,
0.0234192479,
-0.0461120233,
0.012321963,
-0.0308807846,
-0.0020196373,
-0.0111965751,
0.0208492707,
-0.0244381465,
-0.0237268154,
0.0220458116,
-0.041147422,
-0.0144484239,
0.0635059625,
-0.0170733221,
0.0804857537,
-0.022788493,
0.0276711043,
-0.0266255364,
0.0547903478,
0.0240434147,
0.0157043003,
0.0132346693,
-0.0226620231,
0.0404210091,
0.0018823917,
0.0554049723,
-0.0094282944,
0.0007482215,
-0.0300642047,
0.0625971705,
0.0097739315,
-0.0419713669,
0.0080664987,
0.0795590505,
-0.0773125291,
0.0164235737,
0.119602263,
0.0014776046,
-0.0456769802,
-0.0345521942,
-0.0282333158,
0.0336985216,
-0.0064172316,
0.0090972977,
-0.0576137565,
-0.0219901316,
0.0558112711,
0.0725476071,
0.0230295137,
0.0246393662,
-0.0417087562,
-0.0707914904,
0.0715277866,
0.0689201429,
-0.0280384328,
-0.0005284632,
0.0068006399,
-0.0581624992,
-0.0186162014,
0.0561342686,
0.0152054317,
0.0052328468,
-0.036411114,
0.0227767508,
-0.051641468,
-0.0486684069,
-0.0033320361,
-0.0118570197,
0.076745227,
0.0764188468,
0.0330726318,
0.0062627546,
-0.0353587568,
0.0634536892,
-0.0575325526,
0.0251974408,
-0.0094658369,
-0.0313132517,
-0.0138345314,
0.0022898999,
0.0234187823,
0.0380842127,
-0.0112376548,
0.0192675609,
0.0425230414,
0.0468443558,
-0.0429643989,
0.0164015666,
0.0201988723,
0.0141911982,
0.029826466,
0.0666700602,
0.0008148073,
-0.0200177208,
0.0227996428,
-0.0005750911,
0.0166400857,
-0.0171591938,
0.0112141427,
-0.0158620365,
-0.0393534936,
-0.0242103562,
-0.0697491467,
-0.0220973957,
0.0157081112,
0.0560069457,
0.0055371202,
0.0400019772,
-0.0070772981,
0.0311676562,
-0.0138967456,
0.0167155694,
-0.0356578901,
0.0272752941,
-0.0724318698,
0.0124982474,
0.0372299515,
-0.0402304381,
-0.000497611,
0.0632596835,
-0.0991527587,
-0.0575764365,
-0.013821885,
0.0027382185,
0.0315286331,
0.0860653147,
-0.0308497008,
-0.0256394241,
0.0320370384,
-0.0105890203,
-0.0158920679,
-0.0019000118,
0.0386545882,
0.0174013935,
-0.0292331148,
0.036046505,
-0.0323992819,
-0.0085597001,
-0.0587090701,
0.0379536711,
-0.0083847074,
-0.0786923543,
-0.0129076121,
0.0358015858,
0.034383554,
-0.0206536055,
-0.0357417278,
0.0009719608,
0.0784407482,
-0.0017209847,
0.0288376603,
-0.0695792809,
-0.000664181,
0.0426405892,
-0.004142365,
-0.011918162,
0.0358854719,
-0.0113305319,
-0.041213084,
-0.0075888727,
0.0546963364,
-0.028649671,
0.0151331797,
0.0285701044,
0.0003446686,
-0.0356586464,
0.031606663,
0.0126911858,
0.0089589357,
-0.01806584,
0.0360177197,
-0.0339121483,
0.0116854412,
0.0265524071,
0.043854665,
-0.0440668948,
-0.0101293717,
-0.0298297964,
0.0419119224,
0.035017807,
0.0160754472,
0.1272226423,
-0.0166353583,
0.0106102061,
-0.0423086621,
0.0412927754,
-0.0122383386,
0.0151507249,
-0.0069942209,
-0.0036050247,
-0.0183366369,
0.0418139994,
0.0494811982,
-0.0002754679,
0.0134003367,
0.0108241821,
0.0109647615,
-0.0338810459,
-0.0356718153,
0.0141179068,
0.0030184437,
-0.0117038088,
-0.0396094397,
0.0045922636,
-0.0386351533,
0.0232116338,
-0.0027843481,
-0.0017286831,
-0.0462537557,
-0.0228791349,
0.0343164131,
-0.0496553816,
0.0176536757,
0.0063994289,
-0.0487119071,
-0.0102773188,
-0.0345971994,
-0.0040634703,
-6.722956352e-33,
-0.0383794717,
0.0110319182,
0.0231729373,
-0.0050013671,
-0.0783465728,
-0.011048493,
-0.0234140866,
-0.041036509,
0.0273623616,
-0.0321139358,
-0.0357049927,
-0.0167992022,
0.0537141226,
0.0009561612,
-0.0219194144,
0.01129949,
0.0770883262,
0.0007767016,
-0.0206864923,
0.0204636063,
0.0119816652,
0.0182785019,
0.0351125598,
-0.0588941313,
-0.0046516969,
-0.0136309033,
-0.0117791723,
0.009040107,
0.00676717,
0.0068166242,
0.0186434165,
0.0179484189,
-0.0136658633,
-0.0099452408,
-0.0427939408,
0.0188142341,
-0.0822961628,
0.0460023694,
0.0229218118,
0.0620975569,
0.0418271013,
-0.0379169434,
0.0397952348,
-0.0166982915,
-0.0222555753,
-0.0274022389,
-0.0135442158,
-0.0566934943,
-0.0474194847,
-0.0646085739,
-0.0358011909,
0.0429996289,
-0.0035398197,
-0.0161620714,
0.0479287282,
0.0596801862,
-0.0033697982,
-0.0056583988,
-0.100284785,
0.0380361676,
-0.0016704967,
0.0536111891,
0.071793437,
-0.005827527,
-0.0152180484,
-0.0058689192,
0.0354611911,
-0.0375580043,
0.0388079993,
-0.0310699567,
0.0443101786,
0.0209537577,
0.0078270333,
0.0041328236,
0.0221034195,
-0.0095610172,
-0.0153973857,
0.019330075,
0.0208312906,
0.004939517,
0.0231585596,
0.0484847501,
-0.0439537875,
-0.0051341462,
-0.0317386985,
-0.0364418328,
-0.0076277219,
-0.0268774703,
0.0427977592,
0.0300407801,
-0.0087926537,
-0.0300083309,
0.0999578759,
-0.0197787769,
0.0328063741,
0.0047405479,
-0.0112630548,
-0.0072788536,
-0.0548001453,
0.0443937704,
-0.0153859463,
-0.0353472531,
0.0450955182,
0.0303572658,
0.0080447588,
-0.0169726182,
-0.0128033906,
0.0577090941,
-0.0569643602,
-0.0052021132,
-0.0100166081,
0.00955527,
-0.0227305871,
0.039767053,
0.0493869185,
-0.0465172939,
0.0212396141,
0.0520268977,
-0.0126223983,
0.0174440388,
0.0048809741,
-0.0013364289,
0.0037433954,
0.0310818888,
-0.0519846119,
0.0348733738,
0.0134311561,
-0.0379413664,
0.0363285616,
-0.0159344301,
-0.0139362551,
0.0072949957,
2.976e-7,
-0.0203296617,
0.0785233229,
0.0065889629,
-0.0242403969,
0.0221091844,
-0.0033593948,
-0.0317406841,
0.0015724591,
0.0288675241,
0.0260925237,
0.0309192576,
-0.0216771923,
0.1359444112,
0.0087096831,
-0.101739496,
-0.0466868542,
-0.0388565771,
0.0132023916,
-0.0475399531,
-0.0097552231,
0.0496952645,
0.0958181322,
-0.0331119336,
-0.0135651818,
0.008277568,
-0.0312913172,
0.0293974634,
-0.0237123426,
-0.0540492535,
-0.020667918,
0.013138704,
-0.0276903994,
-0.0510757454,
0.0087839002,
-0.0383805633,
0.0436723195,
0.003954859,
0.0900501311,
0.0091623338,
-0.0342211761,
0.011655896,
0.0241013262,
-0.0132565582,
-0.0292872135,
0.069916971,
0.022616988,
0.018795073,
-0.0092644058,
-0.0548938699,
-0.0119422916,
-0.0097454945,
-0.0075618019,
0.0214325264,
0.0301647428,
0.0251989178,
-0.0130188391,
-0.0254775509,
-0.0249397755,
-0.0150202336,
-0.0255321153,
-0.0470584705,
-0.0695028827,
-0.0203740951,
-0.0006364822,
-0.0013477618,
-0.0312218517,
-0.0097220615,
3.135198865e-34,
0.0531921759,
-0.0074901278,
0.0173263792,
0.0075433361,
0.0273006577,
-0.0287721455,
0.0091537545,
0.0447921231,
-0.0216734838,
-0.0659443513,
-0.0263080578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16772v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16772v2 | OlympicArena Medal Ranks: Who Is the Most Intelligent AI So Far? | 2024-06-24T16:31:12 | 2024-06-26T15:00:04 | Zhen Huang, Zengzhi Wang, Shijie Xia, Pengfei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this report, we pose the following question: Who is the most intelligent
AI model to date, as measured by the OlympicArena (an Olympic-level,
multi-discipline, multi-modal benchmark for superintelligent AI)? We
specifically focus on the most recently released models: Claude-3.5-Sonnet,
Gemini-1.5-Pro, and GPT-4o. For the first time, we propose using an Olympic
medal Table approach to rank AI models based on their comprehensive performance
across various disciplines. Empirical results reveal: (1) Claude-3.5-Sonnet
shows highly competitive overall performance over GPT-4o, even surpassing
GPT-4o on a few subjects (i.e., Physics, Chemistry, and Biology). (2)
Gemini-1.5-Pro and GPT-4V are ranked consecutively just behind GPT-4o and
Claude-3.5-Sonnet, but with a clear performance gap between them. (3) The
performance of AI models from the open-source community significantly lags
behind these proprietary models. (4) The performance of these models on this
benchmark has been less than satisfactory, indicating that we still have a long
way to go before achieving superintelligence. We remain committed to
continuously tracking and evaluating the performance of the latest powerful
models on this benchmark (available at
https://github.com/GAIR-NLP/OlympicArena). | [
0.0044815638,
0.0685664341,
-0.0104079144,
0.0412495658,
-0.0294886418,
-0.0047393376,
0.0753884166,
-0.0022005923,
0.0201307852,
0.0065581286,
-0.0432334095,
0.0320471115,
-0.0501595996,
0.0605765395,
-0.0024802873,
-0.0084796008,
0.0495639481,
-0.0388692096,
0.0171210542,
-0.0348221734,
-0.0602755435,
-0.0526784025,
-0.0437461734,
0.0182050504,
0.0415049382,
-0.0020750216,
0.0023107682,
-0.0304747485,
0.0157729611,
-0.0317059159,
-0.0249218177,
0.0284225401,
-0.018216284,
0.0834818482,
0.000002229,
0.0002269293,
0.0056494917,
0.0323874876,
0.00985099,
0.0106608514,
0.0283550024,
0.0264045596,
-0.0054955008,
-0.0128876353,
-0.0359051041,
0.0527342893,
0.0259204675,
0.0249737278,
0.0320397578,
0.0525626764,
0.0053140074,
-0.013541705,
0.085596025,
-0.0445046462,
-0.0195620954,
-0.0665436983,
0.001297485,
0.0128608635,
0.0055082566,
0.0184010323,
-0.0032018553,
0.0331294723,
0.0184286814,
0.0136111369,
-0.002231224,
0.034295924,
0.0022054631,
0.0140929595,
0.0005344069,
0.0479751751,
0.0152307358,
0.0074852356,
-0.0049858694,
0.0191540662,
0.0258197449,
-0.0145363621,
-0.0497627147,
0.0000739647,
0.0373948514,
-0.0496139266,
0.0298259221,
0.0453716666,
0.0083985664,
0.0207321271,
-0.055588156,
0.0562080219,
0.0387334488,
-0.0236565731,
0.0375400148,
-0.0178647786,
-0.0717257187,
-0.0170594286,
-0.015768962,
-0.0011811525,
-0.0275251754,
-0.0362277552,
0.002259616,
-0.0019595802,
-0.0120790703,
0.0292614643,
0.0518885516,
0.0267000757,
0.0541072078,
0.0498449169,
0.0141284503,
0.0841936246,
-0.0430422872,
0.0346701182,
-0.029174054,
-0.002671638,
-0.0676796064,
0.0034310508,
0.0116229104,
0.0136235617,
0.0094063673,
-0.0163240694,
-0.0220140945,
-0.0175159555,
-0.0476928726,
-0.0009576395,
-0.0007979507,
0.0182322543,
0.0144019276,
-0.0116124861,
-0.0662860051,
0.0028573249,
-0.0556469783,
0.0206074417,
-0.0059033851,
-0.0026090548,
-0.00206212,
-0.0015255394,
-0.028197268,
-0.0203067362,
0.0445765592,
0.0880655423,
0.0315742195,
-0.05754577,
0.0618178472,
-0.0063122204,
0.0020211309,
-0.082292296,
0.0179315824,
-0.0078919744,
0.0407422632,
0.0052828612,
0.0054542427,
-0.0769973397,
-0.017086396,
-0.0288720913,
-0.0294440612,
0.0006127694,
-0.0206862874,
-0.0160832144,
0.0134302238,
-0.0133659132,
-0.0532862954,
0.0144258291,
0.0348906852,
0.033614248,
0.0234889984,
0.0186427031,
0.0264097136,
-0.0014142666,
-0.001886887,
0.0031910955,
0.0211708099,
-0.0065609319,
-0.0289485287,
0.0564465523,
0.0006251365,
0.0066430862,
-0.0058910539,
-0.015260973,
0.0649137348,
0.0474184602,
-0.0449603871,
0.0599803776,
0.0225421805,
-0.0499216728,
0.0626747832,
-0.0088397339,
-0.0551147908,
0.0819357783,
-0.0117882099,
0.0045451024,
-0.0025425882,
-0.0109944111,
-0.0030517227,
-0.0927419662,
0.0215723906,
0.0122502921,
-0.0247237682,
0.0107317185,
0.0578888655,
-0.0467034914,
-0.0355236791,
-0.0434270389,
-0.0122252898,
-0.0338779762,
-0.0584541969,
-0.0657278076,
0.0225862525,
0.0532179959,
0.0363725424,
-0.0821534544,
-0.0445138663,
0.03484191,
-0.0024890834,
0.0298376754,
0.0419813059,
0.0012787948,
0.0147292167,
-0.0022401351,
0.0009293425,
-0.0379609056,
0.0303177238,
0.0297932047,
-0.036448136,
0.0215724614,
-0.0218987446,
0.0079786517,
-0.0332395323,
0.0239866581,
-0.0386090167,
-0.0036108561,
-0.0110661909,
-0.0342655592,
0.0750211701,
0.0228390563,
-0.029989535,
0.016863361,
0.0559352934,
-0.0324707925,
-0.0075600757,
-0.0202422328,
0.0380689874,
0.0507468842,
0.0281364471,
-0.0992901772,
-0.0015939953,
0.0575647131,
-0.0107080499,
-0.0259402171,
0.0355201177,
0.009437413,
0.0182648525,
0.0216425359,
0.0178617314,
-0.0536781661,
-0.0122735389,
0.0007005646,
0.0688860267,
-0.0236878544,
0.0026660396,
0.0516075045,
-0.0099828765,
0.027831085,
-0.0266751833,
-0.0129407719,
0.0068518794,
0.0115945293,
-0.0061265393,
0.0282211024,
-0.0091402791,
-0.0043970007,
-0.057390362,
-0.1155540943,
0.0179701131,
-0.0164125282,
-0.010819139,
-0.0035851889,
-0.0368346237,
-0.0130106015,
0.0317514092,
0.0174018275,
0.0082930354,
-0.0272780564,
-0.0211780258,
0.0192214642,
-0.0187197812,
-0.009382545,
-0.0783116445,
-0.0254605077,
-0.0310992077,
0.0478209294,
0.0343504064,
0.0529684611,
-0.0130124353,
0.0272342768,
-0.0605713539,
0.0293996185,
-0.0495785028,
-0.0364832543,
0.0272067208,
-0.029460961,
-0.0052959891,
0.1017917618,
0.0067215352,
0.0192716625,
0.073432669,
0.0184283424,
-0.0145309195,
0.0387404971,
0.0052261581,
-0.0159108061,
-0.0165939257,
-0.0144116487,
0.0318300426,
0.0515540205,
-0.0211285036,
-0.0100767678,
-0.0106516397,
0.0663355738,
-0.0182485059,
-0.0532868393,
0.0002421493,
0.0312168114,
0.0108397445,
0.047429271,
-0.012933285,
-0.0178320818,
0.0259746369,
-0.0052584368,
0.0334544778,
-0.0255338028,
-0.0136244148,
-0.0115267877,
0.033437375,
0.0372714177,
0.0408422463,
-0.0620183349,
0.03009337,
-0.0534743816,
0.0160679687,
0.0003104524,
-0.0269304253,
0.024015734,
-0.0310142115,
-0.0118800653,
0.0113696232,
-0.0778558701,
-0.003949963,
0.0149513418,
-0.0446945205,
0.0164158326,
0.03996142,
-0.0833242089,
-0.0574059337,
-0.0359912142,
0.0384669863,
0.010099222,
-0.0283091664,
-0.0009208937,
-0.0220958851,
0.0051020184,
0.0532733239,
0.0061363182,
0.0491943769,
-0.0348113216,
0.0516374372,
0.0468610339,
0.0222726092,
0.0227655377,
-0.0387736373,
0.0139664998,
0.0238659866,
-0.0273275934,
-0.0314881951,
0.0249669962,
0.0299738646,
-0.0160142928,
0.0224155467,
0.1182842851,
0.0069328011,
-0.0419163443,
0.0121610817,
0.0271697585,
-0.0237392057,
0.0236637294,
0.0094251474,
-0.015590556,
-0.0326537751,
0.0173973404,
0.0105169229,
-0.0204862133,
-0.0442567393,
0.0054837256,
-0.0282295328,
0.034286838,
0.0002262445,
-0.0407629944,
-0.0647861809,
-0.0346586965,
-0.0232061129,
-0.0480473712,
-0.0350206867,
0.0064956108,
0.0193823595,
0.0057207276,
-0.0335910134,
-0.021263795,
-0.0320723392,
0.0104829967,
-0.0218881909,
0.0321568362,
0.0458551385,
0.0404280908,
-0.0693185329,
0.0017617099,
0.0062864861,
0.0033016612,
0.0126542421,
0.0105709126,
0.0704103708,
-0.0119333304,
-0.0127205541,
-0.0228856243,
0.0409867391,
-0.0220442154,
0.0177244153,
0.0466417968,
0.0720422864,
0.0076936986,
-0.0163728856,
-0.0368830785,
-0.0424606539,
-0.0499222055,
0.0569047108,
-0.000205459,
-0.0113494527,
-0.0471878573,
-0.0406881496,
0.0243474524,
-0.0404469222,
-0.0204166956,
-0.0049161706,
0.0497626066,
-0.0615659617,
-0.0317489617,
-0.0425813124,
-0.0012097288,
0.0216754284,
0.0271719713,
-0.0142829306,
-0.0051642843,
-0.0043416759,
-0.0403112471,
-0.0098146321,
0.0175115392,
-0.000744122,
-0.0756200179,
-0.0350581072,
0.0710332617,
-0.0437770486,
-0.0440307409,
0.0421335176,
-0.0209367853,
-0.022886727,
0.0159498286,
0.0773279369,
0.0278361142,
-0.0229915809,
0.0047623785,
-0.0206544325,
0.0224533584,
-0.0010316392,
-0.012937868,
0.0135673992,
0.0166845974,
-0.0484314859,
0.0021593918,
0.0148246214,
-0.0391807593,
0.051954221,
0.0293585658,
-0.021108022,
-0.0238604248,
-0.0124519728,
0.0232981574,
0.0231343973,
0.0464683436,
-0.0103937034,
-0.0141075114,
0.0016275364,
-0.0230533686,
-0.0243813507,
-0.0151991118,
-0.0358485766,
-0.0157766212,
0.0336704254,
0.0066666771,
-0.0051698349,
0.0197359622,
0.0525827557,
-0.0115562929,
-0.041524753,
0.0087411143,
-0.0256430935,
0.0625202879,
-0.0153346909,
-0.001953946,
-0.0273494795,
-0.0141872503,
-0.0409001447,
0.0619206354,
-0.0188062303,
0.0454096943,
0.0130275115,
-0.0087900981,
-0.0440909639,
0.0812527388,
-0.1513212025,
-0.0428396314,
0.0069551696,
0.0674665794,
0.1197714731,
0.0554178432,
0.0238940045,
-0.029575197,
-0.0134438667,
-0.0245787241,
0.0223914757,
0.0394711234,
-0.0071891844,
-0.0316092931,
0.035559196,
0.008674087,
0.0002789746,
0.0514787622,
0.0241663996,
0.0275790114,
0.0156720467,
0.0045449524,
-0.0263412818,
-0.0236875527,
-0.0445491858,
0.0213391241,
0.0020892925,
-0.0257817749,
-0.0543200634,
-0.0365278795,
-0.0001679871,
0.0581524223,
-0.0011276738,
-0.0075550685,
0.0081212642,
0.0454424955,
-0.0146513144,
-0.0578451864,
0.004952712,
-0.0358358026,
-0.0426222831,
-0.0339619741,
-0.034231659,
-6.155923591e-33,
-0.0200372785,
-0.0006656668,
0.0228928812,
0.0055006049,
-0.0155608393,
0.0081764786,
-0.0613581203,
-0.0082792975,
-0.05991745,
0.0345521159,
-0.036432717,
0.0036290062,
-0.0180080831,
-0.0446551815,
0.0451475568,
-0.0147117963,
0.0406966954,
-0.0007487088,
-0.036042843,
0.0508202799,
0.0076534213,
-0.0070579844,
0.0119566135,
-0.0308806319,
-0.0081436569,
-0.0055815945,
0.0036089483,
-0.0207863972,
-0.0492008924,
0.0445132144,
-0.0192842335,
0.0220425539,
0.0103591848,
-0.002241452,
0.0208529811,
-0.0691152364,
-0.0033486628,
-0.0230555478,
-0.0690014809,
-0.0255309101,
-0.0182587896,
-0.0804498494,
0.028567886,
0.0262256395,
-0.0845694244,
-0.0469374992,
0.0501302592,
-0.0071960632,
0.0108702574,
-0.0065371254,
-0.04163526,
0.0023397815,
-0.0454118736,
0.0261353031,
0.0095526204,
-0.0261358451,
0.0175500754,
-0.0013794187,
-0.0134977279,
0.0736419633,
-0.0348773152,
0.0150156785,
0.0419909246,
-0.0458503589,
0.0200739168,
0.0425660051,
0.1109268144,
0.0148487166,
0.0331155322,
-0.0256526712,
0.0019091796,
0.0844400451,
0.0927143991,
0.0151195433,
0.022691831,
-0.0089614717,
-0.0775719807,
0.0169934072,
0.0498283207,
-0.025395507,
-0.0253529698,
-0.0064830789,
-0.0857983157,
0.0143837053,
-0.013363773,
-0.0457143523,
-0.0022332931,
-0.01578678,
0.0283481926,
-0.045516368,
0.0128683336,
-0.0137797305,
0.033840701,
-0.0704668611,
0.0448448434,
0.0521934479,
0.0129213203,
0.0677204207,
0.0053737317,
0.0507042408,
-0.044688154,
-0.0357107297,
-0.0172798224,
0.0302317198,
0.0572257526,
-0.0054815738,
-0.01701032,
0.0407306552,
0.0053558587,
0.000662883,
-0.0502991006,
-0.0484254993,
0.0480866916,
-0.0336954296,
-0.0185359158,
-0.0092926444,
0.0121220937,
0.0242160074,
-0.0111740837,
0.0467594825,
-0.0369648561,
0.0075519048,
0.0136451451,
-0.0037988611,
0.0062150517,
-0.0237605963,
-0.0611770041,
0.0132068824,
-0.0322654881,
-0.0431478582,
-0.0383847356,
0.0204133559,
2.916e-7,
0.0243450198,
0.0528191291,
-0.0076293359,
0.0033364047,
-0.0040600779,
0.0387537479,
-0.0454170853,
0.0076074242,
0.0080492152,
0.0902912766,
0.0385468416,
0.0276531205,
0.0247041211,
0.0281981267,
-0.0403434411,
-0.0047602151,
-0.016294159,
-0.0101855937,
-0.0738758892,
0.0213920865,
0.0502224453,
0.0459936857,
0.0058588181,
0.023185553,
0.018985061,
-0.0721176043,
0.0286494214,
-0.006175607,
0.0233646929,
0.0298906788,
-0.0210851599,
0.0412662961,
-0.0346415974,
0.0156799629,
0.007839581,
0.0080209207,
0.0201673303,
0.0262959879,
-0.0136891389,
0.0058719721,
0.003090149,
0.0263983682,
0.0105900578,
-0.0309151169,
0.0789606273,
0.0286327098,
-0.0645517036,
-0.0271492358,
-0.0701127425,
-0.0047193496,
-0.0088612214,
0.0010543553,
-0.0173186883,
-0.0012237818,
-0.0280193016,
-0.0297149085,
0.0072538257,
-0.0219979845,
0.0449653603,
-0.0219305232,
-0.0541234389,
-0.0785190091,
-0.0445405729,
0.0375156403,
0.0626786798,
-0.0442813784,
-0.0084779961,
2.703927896e-34,
0.0187672917,
-0.0341483168,
0.0628933907,
0.0088000773,
0.0449957028,
0.0205377359,
-0.0084921652,
-0.0387459695,
0.0059991027,
-0.037394207,
-0.029735025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16767v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16767v1 | The GPT-WritingPrompts Dataset: A Comparative Analysis of Character Portrayal in Short Stories | 2024-06-24T16:24:18 | 2024-06-24T16:24:18 | Xi Yu Huang, Krishnapriya Vishnubhotla, Frank Rudzicz | cs.CL | cs.CL | The improved generative capabilities of large language models have made them
a powerful tool for creative writing and storytelling. It is therefore
important to quantitatively understand the nature of generated stories, and how
they differ from human storytelling. We augment the Reddit WritingPrompts
dataset with short stories generated by GPT-3.5, given the same prompts. We
quantify and compare the emotional and descriptive features of storytelling
from both generative processes, human and machine, along a set of six
dimensions. We find that generated stories differ significantly from human
stories along all six dimensions, and that human and machine generations
display similar biases when grouped according to the narrative point-of-view
and gender of the main protagonist. We release our dataset and code at
https://github.com/KristinHuangg/gpt-writing-prompts. | [
0.0130303465,
0.0679422617,
-0.0377883539,
-0.0128659103,
-0.0150590315,
0.0209773015,
0.0288442615,
0.010165398,
0.0242783818,
-0.0102672679,
0.0020450705,
-0.0315852351,
0.0111766607,
0.0895699635,
0.0329809077,
-0.0800447166,
-0.0144975632,
0.0227904133,
0.0534848534,
0.0004962807,
0.0000436982,
0.0848390013,
-0.0107704783,
0.0504389815,
-0.0213056467,
-0.0569396801,
0.0219095796,
0.024891749,
0.036512956,
-0.012462982,
0.0096218437,
0.0439688042,
0.0232001338,
0.0220429655,
0.0000019093,
-0.0232329816,
0.021277437,
-0.0295564104,
0.0551407002,
-0.0164305754,
0.0577652752,
-0.0038546945,
-0.0239016451,
-0.0001001668,
-0.0120828645,
-0.0294238217,
0.0402675532,
0.0741842762,
0.0387005396,
0.0842424482,
-0.0220300257,
-0.0157101806,
-0.0157400575,
-0.0144554982,
0.0440054312,
0.0552207679,
-0.024625428,
-0.0266794376,
0.0204713773,
-0.0563294776,
-0.0367024206,
-0.0236840472,
0.0165586248,
-0.0000663086,
-0.0303547624,
0.0730742514,
0.0243580416,
-0.0073219603,
0.0013849924,
0.0411011875,
0.0235083047,
-0.0025768231,
-0.0107915103,
-0.0186303444,
0.0118532516,
-0.0032099206,
-0.04537265,
0.0560141876,
-0.0297138598,
0.0129408892,
-0.0290865861,
0.0085521843,
-0.0071457732,
-0.0022523357,
0.0865484774,
-0.0049269293,
0.0315630026,
0.009428259,
-0.0282151643,
0.0020727324,
0.008343935,
-0.0716955736,
0.0040266416,
-0.0084830998,
0.0254303776,
-0.0013343171,
-0.0563372374,
0.0160386972,
0.0016412096,
-0.0310325678,
0.0483022332,
0.0275556706,
0.0179789979,
-0.0203758776,
-0.0050655738,
0.046408955,
0.0231608078,
-0.0291321669,
-0.0174727514,
0.0378641821,
-0.03637724,
-0.0113703506,
-0.032655634,
-0.0175446793,
0.0031007063,
-0.019325858,
-0.0398051776,
-0.0095243985,
-0.0006384757,
-0.0155224046,
-0.0142832519,
0.0353052132,
-0.0312836878,
0.018041905,
-0.0291553233,
0.0269784778,
-0.1035793051,
-0.002358241,
0.0041377372,
-0.0221225787,
-0.007108252,
0.0063268715,
0.0272621792,
-0.030660728,
0.0239896737,
0.0280846134,
0.0133581357,
-0.0315476991,
-0.0428465195,
-0.0304505639,
-0.0040248418,
-0.0509423986,
-0.0314963199,
-0.0350626297,
0.0495454557,
0.0086712791,
0.0355454311,
-0.0661843792,
-0.0126672452,
0.0079118479,
0.0027660436,
0.0054993653,
-0.0042982353,
-0.0111453338,
0.0335543901,
0.0106888637,
-0.0056748567,
0.007785195,
0.0610526577,
0.0669782087,
0.0207253639,
-0.0066028694,
0.0582068563,
-0.0099299047,
-0.0289911944,
0.0095745176,
-0.0123242764,
-0.0346223675,
0.0058855372,
0.0763076767,
0.0555514693,
0.0315514132,
-0.0316381417,
0.0023062236,
0.094239749,
0.1025483236,
0.0217084941,
0.0693110526,
0.0723609254,
0.0093135349,
0.0293084551,
0.0359590463,
-0.0091433963,
0.0212008264,
0.032825321,
-0.004319814,
-0.0152363461,
0.0346367434,
-0.0119600659,
0.0109169073,
-0.0183871761,
0.0031842671,
-0.0354363695,
-0.0472729877,
-0.0176832508,
-0.0000141469,
-0.0468970947,
-0.0411076546,
0.0176793784,
-0.1238179505,
-0.0008978602,
0.0031641147,
0.0803890452,
0.0764686316,
0.0319245644,
-0.0087719373,
-0.0125914374,
-0.0451013818,
-0.010310513,
0.0219610203,
0.0178416017,
0.0050741467,
0.0214635003,
-0.0133986436,
0.0298940502,
-0.0359664224,
0.0212868135,
0.0276007243,
-0.0129751125,
0.0124440975,
-0.0132331559,
0.0004684023,
-0.0413510017,
0.0410853028,
-0.0585307702,
-0.0194297787,
-0.0338401794,
0.0012354186,
-0.020672489,
-0.0102183865,
-0.0413097069,
-0.0173044037,
0.0119774155,
-0.0083638085,
-0.0141181387,
0.0829840377,
-0.0472660176,
-0.0279982891,
0.0007287077,
-0.0957543775,
-0.016994115,
0.0015805764,
0.0129387053,
-0.0225954521,
0.0479535908,
-0.0442744903,
0.0278077312,
-0.0215675868,
-0.0218504779,
0.0044440473,
0.0117544392,
0.0057011554,
0.0497664958,
0.0091280015,
0.0237897132,
-0.0274529047,
-0.0015476315,
0.0016219622,
-0.0240555834,
0.0276732109,
0.015481025,
0.0316886082,
-0.0111034401,
0.0200060122,
-0.0337530635,
-0.0558929518,
-0.0594608821,
-0.0644602254,
0.0043916539,
0.0290097222,
-0.0142428484,
0.0364340097,
-0.0200460739,
-0.0645159855,
0.033376772,
-0.0686989054,
-0.0117780315,
0.0092618633,
-0.0202510152,
0.01380549,
0.0055363127,
0.0374685526,
-0.0385866538,
0.0152118858,
-0.0345445164,
0.0583899282,
0.0512600429,
0.0131985378,
-0.0260464139,
0.0453152061,
-0.02326441,
-0.0268799663,
-0.0149616851,
-0.0504288115,
0.0206955243,
-0.0144398212,
0.0840878561,
0.0369892269,
0.0115140872,
0.065328151,
0.0433872528,
-0.0211598761,
0.0025532832,
0.0017041938,
0.0103461873,
0.0355929285,
-0.0032510352,
-0.1041575968,
-0.0098408451,
0.0491812155,
0.0414357111,
0.0104148937,
-0.0547427423,
0.0680720136,
0.0049832179,
-0.0061675822,
0.0432732478,
-0.0238982495,
-0.0144553268,
0.0493477099,
-0.022809403,
-0.0561947152,
0.070874989,
-0.0303866938,
-0.0170147214,
0.01954473,
0.0037303693,
-0.0247850977,
0.0978386253,
0.0161074828,
0.0458078831,
0.0085111028,
0.0020680439,
-0.0344001837,
0.0087660523,
0.0361684337,
-0.0001426168,
-0.0062867356,
-0.0193801299,
-0.0345692039,
0.0069722538,
-0.0117207179,
-0.0019588324,
-0.0420501493,
-0.0038487439,
-0.0251934789,
0.0229794346,
-0.0671289265,
-0.0073702387,
-0.0097587025,
0.003350815,
0.0235601943,
-0.0393785425,
-0.0293230545,
0.0059422818,
0.0005653968,
0.0594411492,
-0.0432988368,
-0.0129091376,
-0.0479541905,
0.0380630493,
0.0310891904,
-0.02745446,
0.0314431116,
0.0168374274,
0.035393931,
0.0140624857,
-0.02492043,
-0.0090289153,
-0.0207672752,
0.0487418175,
-0.042909693,
-0.0194861926,
0.1193176731,
0.0071536601,
-0.0388670713,
0.019533176,
-0.0014546751,
0.0274328031,
0.0279892888,
0.0277380291,
-0.0587085411,
0.0016131407,
0.0150389904,
0.0566288829,
-0.0175053626,
-0.0668892264,
-0.0355627425,
-0.1002528444,
0.0543414056,
0.0028056472,
-0.0302656107,
-0.039450381,
-0.0177688878,
-0.0213258043,
0.0178797655,
-0.0349135809,
-0.0082918089,
-0.008206496,
0.0259475615,
-0.0394533165,
-0.0100944731,
-0.0016083436,
-0.0019432089,
-0.047928337,
0.0322910249,
0.0346192792,
0.1013802141,
0.0075222105,
-0.0180582721,
-0.0541183725,
0.0343445241,
0.0012534941,
0.0049888021,
0.0577151962,
-0.0315227509,
0.0062050531,
-0.0757781416,
0.0960195586,
0.020309601,
-0.0340113901,
-0.0003518793,
0.0395299159,
-0.0046007051,
-0.0747074783,
-0.0209679455,
0.0263329428,
0.0152902175,
0.0733879358,
0.0441058092,
-0.0475342646,
-0.0461860746,
-0.0522570498,
0.049021706,
-0.0354332067,
-0.0569622107,
-0.0203001574,
-0.0005297806,
-0.0004362249,
-0.0564077497,
-0.0730789378,
0.0147786411,
0.0357652567,
0.0223860741,
-0.0529540926,
-0.0673832521,
-0.0045979498,
-0.0589559749,
0.035963133,
0.0018114696,
0.0078904592,
-0.0069933822,
-0.0203374848,
0.0096839406,
-0.0569970123,
0.0084618293,
0.0490416475,
-0.0606729947,
-0.0266031977,
0.0013423639,
-0.0003358002,
0.021499278,
0.0059654522,
0.0145858061,
-0.0534685366,
0.0320100188,
-0.0021309578,
-0.0297499914,
0.0493119881,
-0.0276907142,
0.0281738695,
-0.0096259397,
-0.004631266,
0.0000643217,
0.0123787019,
-0.0122344019,
-0.0196054354,
0.0281578023,
-0.032291837,
-0.002783136,
-0.009464616,
0.0056908936,
-0.0772549808,
0.0019373385,
-0.0946520865,
-0.0594562814,
-0.0243929923,
-0.0134037137,
-0.0261286609,
-0.0041087945,
0.0406270698,
0.0027487129,
-0.0494734906,
-0.0173171572,
-0.0458817258,
0.0024631384,
-0.0798254162,
-0.0026904067,
0.0386477932,
0.0096837794,
0.0216453485,
0.0187775157,
-0.0057526394,
0.0123755345,
-0.0742540732,
0.0264247768,
-0.0108274492,
0.0228526089,
0.0137959197,
0.0022834965,
0.0341362171,
0.0247449279,
-0.0571070835,
-0.0207158122,
-0.0321211033,
-0.0019326425,
0.0444968864,
-0.0215136893,
0.0830205157,
-0.0340460688,
0.0131709138,
0.003244671,
0.0278198477,
0.0197227448,
0.0015481408,
-0.0593334995,
0.0108209727,
-0.0202517752,
-0.0096333437,
0.0713457987,
-0.0345559083,
0.0772872791,
0.0200847089,
-0.0413091704,
-0.0118675567,
-0.0089164739,
0.0181334279,
0.0103896689,
0.0338175967,
-0.0205043163,
-0.0773037151,
-0.0412848443,
0.0257910285,
-0.0026663672,
0.0148934545,
-0.0368109383,
0.0105878888,
0.0155481054,
-0.0364443511,
0.0066472888,
-0.0409395508,
0.0457768887,
-0.0318183377,
-0.0061461315,
-0.0159603097,
-5.53031962e-33,
-0.0298290346,
-0.0214762613,
-0.041709777,
0.0378652439,
-0.0812189281,
-0.0033647923,
-0.0359595083,
0.0006552964,
0.0294003822,
0.0674508214,
-0.0018705293,
0.0159936883,
-0.0052140113,
0.0022075661,
-0.0019759247,
0.0295831375,
0.0447978079,
-0.0042468221,
-0.06185342,
0.0388334841,
0.0237453543,
0.0392130278,
0.0321261771,
-0.029351972,
0.0227109287,
-0.0732901022,
-0.0310080536,
-0.0266143344,
0.0470187068,
0.0039673168,
-0.0169045515,
0.0654049292,
0.0214910526,
-0.0234315563,
-0.0188760981,
0.0171126481,
-0.0278494023,
-0.0284904875,
-0.0034745745,
-0.0186639037,
-0.0114437286,
-0.0521740951,
0.0040725614,
0.0077491426,
-0.0063523282,
-0.0384063572,
0.0595638976,
0.0123117305,
0.0611571595,
-0.0469332561,
-0.0534465276,
0.000319302,
-0.0234358031,
-0.0464064516,
-0.0151607906,
0.0465850718,
0.0364507549,
0.0129745742,
-0.0191588011,
0.0367735177,
-0.0256577563,
0.0324843489,
-0.0092722718,
0.0009056738,
-0.0038326688,
0.0827756822,
0.0468200892,
0.0271598287,
-0.0732781813,
0.0394950807,
-0.0039076279,
0.0136200283,
0.0339003615,
0.0739179328,
0.0059723724,
-0.0347663872,
-0.0142780188,
0.051605612,
0.0261524022,
-0.0169497728,
0.0280644428,
-0.0016437199,
0.0140862521,
-0.0401316993,
-0.0248301961,
-0.0835771263,
0.0016058377,
-0.0179852881,
-0.0083209919,
-0.0391410924,
-0.0001452561,
-0.016642591,
-0.0279558636,
-0.00805014,
0.0094615016,
0.0363939516,
-0.0758841857,
0.0489299037,
0.0089527359,
0.0196066741,
0.0053040069,
0.0072016497,
0.0326375142,
0.0558383688,
0.0780909583,
-0.0014680426,
0.0001391662,
0.0297565032,
-0.0464242026,
0.0062694582,
-0.0450627133,
0.0241588689,
0.0048636496,
-0.0025163922,
-0.0126178125,
-0.0145674441,
-0.0077751852,
-0.0240895357,
0.0134018976,
0.0425585061,
-0.0279161669,
-0.0330601372,
-0.0183804389,
0.0000371453,
-0.0227094702,
0.0127311982,
-0.0187388994,
0.0036001466,
0.066340223,
-0.0378439501,
-0.0159881394,
-0.0440315194,
2.596e-7,
-0.0018768598,
0.0239053052,
0.049666848,
0.010107832,
0.0333682336,
0.042853184,
-0.0019814165,
0.0547697134,
0.0282570068,
0.0103098946,
0.0051966435,
0.0222134199,
0.049012959,
0.0466585346,
-0.092593722,
0.0503815636,
-0.0760937333,
0.0205590501,
-0.0704281926,
-0.0003594692,
0.0956053361,
0.00922105,
0.0575068258,
-0.0232392233,
0.0488568954,
-0.0172377434,
0.0409153737,
-0.0399747342,
0.0080525521,
0.0138086705,
-0.0410549641,
-0.024840137,
-0.0196880903,
-0.0436309054,
-0.0128306104,
-0.02622669,
0.0142220147,
0.0416729264,
-0.0126813194,
-0.0033081267,
0.0659942329,
0.0257881172,
-0.0208785348,
-0.0367204659,
0.0497510433,
0.0202990547,
-0.0314472541,
-0.0223431103,
0.0299988296,
-0.0118546244,
0.0399705842,
-0.0491279811,
-0.0250827726,
0.024402516,
0.0109162489,
-0.0059091598,
0.0032019683,
-0.0482957885,
-0.0341815911,
0.0175535362,
-0.039629519,
-0.0414908044,
-0.030128628,
0.0084785251,
0.0076896977,
-0.0615163147,
0.0196069926,
2.123473377e-34,
-0.0058761463,
0.0353404209,
-0.0121235419,
-0.0219994262,
0.0514870994,
0.0085262787,
0.0442588925,
-0.0120729236,
0.0417997576,
-0.0208411794,
-0.043785084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16758v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16758v1 | Towards Fast Multilingual LLM Inference: Speculative Decoding and Specialized Drafters | 2024-06-24T16:06:50 | 2024-06-24T16:06:50 | Euiin Yi, Taehyeon Kim, Hongseok Jeung, Du-Seong Chang, Se-Young Yun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized natural language processing
and broadened their applicability across diverse commercial applications.
However, the deployment of these models is constrained by high inference time
in multilingual settings. To mitigate this challenge, this paper explores a
training recipe of an assistant model in speculative decoding, which are
leveraged to draft and-then its future tokens are verified by the target LLM.
We show that language-specific draft models, optimized through a targeted
pretrain-and-finetune strategy, substantially brings a speedup of inference
time compared to the previous methods. We validate these models across various
languages in inference time, out-of-domain speedup, and GPT-4o evaluation. | [
0.0334285907,
0.0925022364,
0.0008602802,
0.0373565555,
-0.0357239395,
0.0111952564,
0.0013984387,
0.0085796062,
-0.0181565825,
-0.0167196766,
-0.0155959791,
-0.1089753434,
-0.0128818015,
0.0057610385,
0.0166849401,
-0.0055679535,
0.0319331847,
-0.0658086613,
-0.0041745789,
-0.0120168328,
-0.0168809164,
0.0393194631,
0.0115741817,
0.0579470657,
0.01714902,
-0.0149975829,
-0.0045916205,
0.0077700769,
-0.0240606666,
-0.0522271097,
-0.0161921494,
0.052738294,
0.0028964509,
0.0290062632,
0.0000020402,
-0.0385928638,
-0.0148938978,
0.0209580678,
-0.0324406177,
0.0276126172,
0.0340134837,
-0.0569608621,
-0.0335380584,
0.005569201,
-0.0332508162,
-0.0500726514,
0.0441657528,
0.0054012607,
-0.0025591152,
0.0862228796,
-0.0052248994,
-0.0382068902,
0.0376949832,
-0.0243748371,
-0.0323914737,
-0.082511507,
0.0165597592,
-0.0367199965,
-0.0339122452,
-0.0094968583,
-0.0083315661,
0.0373685062,
0.0422901511,
0.0354736373,
-0.0606087819,
0.0348944403,
0.0000312133,
-0.0182283949,
-0.021133272,
0.0352746025,
-0.0191537794,
-0.044548586,
-0.0301438253,
0.0107483491,
-0.0228041187,
-0.0281636454,
-0.0066374829,
0.0549027584,
-0.0472102128,
0.0128270127,
0.080225043,
0.0077212746,
0.0590989627,
0.0322009139,
-0.0492351092,
0.0956133604,
0.0336007699,
-0.0307753552,
0.0070300996,
0.0313307606,
-0.0186302979,
-0.0533888042,
0.0218752921,
0.0189216062,
-0.0183902923,
0.0102507453,
-0.0471801758,
-0.05933851,
0.0072191926,
-0.0246281587,
0.0351936296,
0.0533427596,
-0.0236549713,
0.024118593,
-0.0496527627,
0.002814864,
-0.0523186587,
0.0188917462,
-0.0444519073,
-0.0431273021,
0.0038493432,
-0.0029127311,
-0.0595389493,
0.0225870237,
-0.0381010845,
-0.0129659595,
-0.0197485089,
0.0170895159,
0.0189206861,
0.0069736196,
0.0447123982,
-0.0153900115,
-0.0344985984,
-0.0415458828,
-0.0009620425,
0.0219992734,
-0.0143793197,
0.0214494597,
-0.0239382666,
-0.0781466439,
-0.0371986926,
0.029166691,
-0.0151595119,
-0.0380516648,
0.0099092619,
0.0853988379,
-0.0131399184,
-0.0270290449,
-0.0389232375,
-0.0236159861,
0.0073011699,
-0.1015042067,
-0.0208165497,
-0.0738897398,
0.0382115245,
0.0053326734,
0.0228378139,
-0.0496451557,
-0.001022284,
0.0015690095,
0.0017363356,
0.0659460649,
-0.017868977,
-0.0025233079,
-0.0077519082,
-0.0003270154,
-0.0142815411,
0.1108790264,
0.0182451829,
0.0236157458,
0.0358268432,
0.0013709596,
-0.0127286268,
0.1070698574,
0.0063475803,
0.0084494231,
0.0053780223,
-0.0178477783,
0.008151738,
0.0056368322,
0.0392657146,
0.0315879099,
-0.0480096899,
-0.0063204076,
0.0455741547,
0.0584092289,
0.0197750442,
0.0308591798,
0.0877097175,
0.0151844583,
0.0075475327,
0.0074274605,
-0.0447330661,
0.0095875636,
-0.0114548979,
0.0078709796,
-0.0019117699,
0.0687555075,
-0.0176165327,
-0.0062567913,
0.0054627932,
-0.0231887624,
-0.0098629771,
0.0108329067,
0.0654723942,
0.0229402203,
-0.0710307658,
0.0652390867,
0.0199693795,
-0.0264188331,
-0.0047651036,
-0.0369268209,
0.0094506452,
0.0630261824,
0.0315339863,
0.0315187648,
-0.0221159477,
0.0063013085,
-0.0104587376,
0.0616815872,
0.0443189293,
0.000869623,
0.0526387691,
-0.0477661975,
0.0004679935,
0.0326993018,
0.0196924619,
0.0654454753,
0.0493819863,
0.0272310339,
0.0075794435,
-0.0464222394,
-0.0164981987,
0.0258950498,
-0.0126546714,
-0.032604225,
0.0309546478,
0.0114300484,
0.0290673189,
0.013719568,
0.0014344099,
0.0055733845,
0.0191479847,
-0.0589767285,
-0.0094813462,
0.0440768078,
-0.0359043516,
-0.0475427732,
0.0254571196,
0.0046313871,
-0.0288436022,
0.0023759985,
-0.0276002679,
-0.0261439476,
0.001985657,
0.0056260899,
0.055760175,
-0.0569986515,
0.0177363921,
0.0122244433,
0.0177276842,
0.0314954296,
0.0491439477,
-0.0320946388,
-0.0106676072,
0.0201096833,
0.0056459941,
0.004151552,
-0.0279290732,
-0.0290790331,
0.0478017628,
-0.0166292097,
-0.0121405385,
-0.006905898,
0.0190120228,
0.0018647937,
-0.0144639164,
-0.0944448113,
-0.0052423058,
-0.0466572009,
0.0298221521,
-0.0018103758,
0.0133743836,
-0.0318806358,
-0.0177011006,
0.0039882027,
-0.0299353246,
0.0045308415,
0.0185621008,
-0.0073861731,
0.0068514193,
-0.0090211052,
0.0039115627,
0.0050228983,
0.0090275481,
0.0330685712,
-0.0331093892,
-0.0518109836,
-0.0899190456,
0.0184458233,
0.0061423481,
0.0278868582,
0.0018774832,
-0.0441737138,
0.0113479169,
-0.0289121997,
0.0267524961,
0.0223294348,
-0.0187320616,
-0.0141046271,
0.0533825271,
0.0164463483,
-0.0428639203,
0.0102369552,
-0.005654668,
-0.0267037917,
-0.0749092624,
-0.0378002971,
0.0099921608,
0.0563050099,
0.0035943282,
0.0017492201,
-0.07513614,
-0.0171738788,
-0.0159055032,
-0.0421154946,
0.0131528415,
-0.013249658,
0.0000308481,
0.0447721891,
-0.0199729223,
-0.0403940342,
0.098018527,
-0.0603705533,
-0.0123565346,
-0.0156331081,
-0.0063650464,
-0.0419575684,
0.0587275811,
-0.015270262,
0.0023015107,
-0.0254553352,
-0.0417743251,
-0.002768697,
0.0359140523,
0.0016790782,
-0.011140354,
0.0555222854,
-0.0473618135,
0.0103330808,
-0.015030304,
-0.0547437482,
-0.0272324756,
-0.0347372405,
-0.0628355965,
-0.011074109,
0.0228157528,
-0.0224416759,
-0.0019942434,
0.0243522115,
-0.0580647886,
0.0537292063,
-0.0233250372,
0.0186792463,
-0.0131423566,
0.0044973455,
0.0296507198,
-0.0430499651,
-0.0023721005,
-0.0594329201,
0.0508710593,
0.0702858865,
0.0185997225,
-0.0135791544,
-0.0483948179,
0.0069095478,
0.0474528633,
-0.0029646519,
0.0155634787,
0.0225505307,
0.0596027076,
-0.0734455734,
0.004451721,
0.1051375717,
-0.0017581247,
-0.0702067316,
-0.0099741956,
0.0077780704,
0.0417942442,
-0.0072886427,
0.0292797945,
-0.1045463756,
-0.0576107875,
0.0275564529,
0.0008801728,
-0.0104672993,
-0.0272545498,
-0.0359022804,
-0.1342600882,
0.0396344624,
0.0111828409,
-0.0271052662,
0.0116913626,
-0.0261441823,
-0.0427637435,
0.015836671,
0.0112918355,
0.007452094,
0.0223014355,
-0.0133255217,
0.011635364,
-0.0228635594,
-0.0343860574,
0.0173470229,
-0.0336581878,
0.0220341738,
0.0403847545,
-0.0034219618,
0.0115819173,
-0.0054785255,
0.0224855505,
-0.0345717221,
0.0022365917,
-0.0189999938,
0.014123912,
-0.040677391,
0.0107257552,
0.0306704957,
0.0212242771,
-0.0358116627,
-0.002427232,
0.0100097312,
0.05030559,
-0.0057514184,
-0.0378314666,
0.0067016119,
-0.0062363371,
0.0159704089,
0.0621639304,
0.0127631333,
-0.0229994524,
-0.0519403554,
-0.0363722853,
-0.0202715807,
-0.1048601568,
-0.0063409884,
-0.009075948,
0.0300982948,
-0.0020246983,
-0.0377477072,
-0.0302791707,
0.036820583,
0.0184825417,
0.0072541526,
0.0591214821,
-0.0147019522,
-0.0191249456,
-0.0472268574,
0.0422139056,
-0.0176136363,
0.0184765924,
-0.0631121695,
0.0063339295,
0.0454852395,
-0.0214304645,
-0.0020289652,
0.0442788154,
-0.1092178375,
-0.0648781806,
-0.0144268572,
0.0602787137,
0.019749159,
0.0498854518,
-0.0485107377,
-0.0423266478,
0.0137238419,
0.0264421813,
-0.0440788902,
-0.0031060886,
0.0369033292,
-0.0121006696,
0.0133792488,
0.0573853776,
-0.0163106658,
0.0191224106,
-0.0054562511,
0.0541058183,
0.0015039716,
-0.0415981598,
0.0324410908,
0.0132019753,
0.0208697412,
-0.0636293218,
-0.0142545542,
-0.0098566096,
0.0522962585,
-0.0140494313,
-0.0093212649,
-0.0140039586,
0.0223696921,
0.0253685471,
-0.035360802,
-0.0044737714,
0.0118451593,
0.0217917208,
0.013254215,
-0.0008403516,
-0.00094402,
0.0243041944,
-0.002225196,
0.0504248925,
0.0037059998,
-0.018724557,
0.0193099752,
-0.0062451353,
0.0243189242,
-0.0446324125,
0.0066391812,
0.0224239305,
0.0126399584,
-0.0236516576,
0.0067610894,
-0.0402710885,
-0.0558204241,
-0.0171909891,
0.0177551694,
0.0723259374,
-0.0075715506,
0.0567476526,
-0.0444952287,
-0.002339653,
-0.0132081537,
0.0171390753,
-0.0231460333,
-0.0292904675,
0.0446180813,
-0.0013345386,
-0.0179723296,
0.0186640974,
0.0878154784,
0.0261636134,
0.070499979,
0.0173333324,
-0.0036375085,
-0.0077545419,
-0.0622754879,
-0.0284280665,
0.0302714985,
-0.0383472405,
-0.0078757694,
-0.040841274,
-0.0705409423,
0.0173424631,
-0.0062095337,
-0.0063999691,
0.0035245251,
0.0005401902,
0.0809057653,
0.0022342091,
-0.0416228473,
-0.0174907371,
-0.0224760082,
0.038013421,
-0.0262972508,
-0.0252141841,
-6.217155826e-33,
0.0020219882,
-0.0287817959,
0.0378353447,
-0.0302337538,
-0.016815614,
-0.0009979268,
-0.0187024493,
-0.0387467928,
-0.0022000126,
-0.0000912306,
-0.0362566188,
0.0223532561,
0.0362092145,
0.0236922093,
0.0075998749,
0.0173288137,
0.066977933,
0.0027422521,
-0.0136261778,
-0.0167929716,
0.0235272609,
0.049688641,
0.0726164803,
0.0060549625,
0.0112878243,
-0.0309340656,
-0.0229814537,
0.0182986241,
-0.0232917368,
0.0561379083,
-0.0248932298,
0.014939975,
0.0228071082,
-0.0001760322,
-0.0205612183,
0.0028885256,
-0.1062612459,
-0.002824859,
0.0496306792,
0.0316138268,
-0.00775962,
-0.0396871343,
-0.0040797861,
0.0026026596,
-0.0114603909,
0.000845103,
-0.0189654659,
-0.0173601862,
-0.0070164069,
-0.063262932,
-0.0666442737,
0.0511885285,
0.0181979444,
0.0208943672,
0.0951987654,
0.040554639,
-0.0121037401,
-0.0004774323,
-0.067246303,
0.0055625038,
-0.0418086164,
0.0395768918,
0.0580095202,
-0.0109045375,
-0.0228091367,
0.0284361485,
0.0009293062,
-0.0261412542,
-0.0587042309,
-0.0025440478,
0.0317769907,
0.0243364647,
-0.0011819992,
0.0555372573,
0.0792690143,
-0.0213210639,
-0.058580257,
0.015567923,
0.0212532096,
0.0415659174,
0.046046488,
0.0011844101,
-0.0134637747,
-0.0194125082,
-0.0488745198,
-0.0237493142,
-0.034427885,
-0.0239813719,
0.0381753445,
0.023462493,
-0.0045489171,
-0.003814125,
0.0688579082,
-0.043884445,
-0.0061494755,
0.029488232,
-0.0109300492,
0.022973109,
-0.010193374,
0.0611993112,
-0.019085573,
-0.0134434532,
0.0156367831,
-0.0180142839,
0.0029421034,
0.0028723902,
0.0291151162,
0.0098332921,
-0.0640677512,
0.0069026332,
-0.0432573073,
0.0254362058,
0.0065165884,
0.0407818407,
0.0720451549,
0.0137392124,
-0.0044072745,
0.0473407432,
0.005098559,
0.0501341484,
-0.0312261861,
0.0061242268,
0.0294841174,
0.0544530712,
0.0028661694,
0.0100684017,
-0.0177295078,
-0.0125994189,
0.0311263558,
-0.0578714833,
-0.0152704697,
0.0630223677,
2.691e-7,
0.0389529355,
0.0257885549,
0.0384407938,
0.0236538406,
-0.0092422245,
0.0075688446,
-0.0192222241,
0.0047130994,
0.0184695814,
0.0020458791,
0.01169129,
0.0445989408,
0.0740355253,
0.0466977544,
-0.0987842306,
-0.0159800388,
-0.015024405,
0.0151326759,
-0.0669248104,
-0.0492974222,
0.0120232338,
0.098784104,
-0.01602499,
-0.0314947441,
0.012185636,
-0.0400125757,
0.0642248988,
-0.0055588922,
-0.0171476807,
0.0232215635,
0.0181152988,
0.0076459185,
0.0080416035,
0.0199591517,
-0.0152728604,
0.0045104427,
-0.0170290843,
0.0574820936,
0.0031479707,
-0.0123746572,
-0.0039389553,
-0.0224364512,
-0.036385823,
-0.0310695264,
0.066575624,
-0.0232857037,
-0.021256309,
-0.0280335881,
-0.0097148027,
-0.0134660732,
-0.0130593562,
-0.0312838815,
0.0131063238,
0.0788021982,
0.0486873686,
-0.0148104103,
-0.0310976859,
-0.0796018913,
-0.0363126844,
-0.0124844955,
-0.0363855921,
-0.0071530943,
-0.024886854,
-0.0114651695,
0.0313171074,
-0.102675125,
0.0142631559,
2.628500648e-34,
0.0470466502,
0.0065741511,
0.0075274329,
0.0795168579,
0.0214451179,
-0.0170908459,
0.0387210697,
0.0384383909,
-0.0252287742,
-0.0639328361,
-0.028838696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16751v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16751v2 | Towards Zero-Shot Text-To-Speech for Arabic Dialects | 2024-06-24T15:58:15 | 2024-06-25T14:18:21 | Khai Duy Doan, Abdul Waheed, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Zero-shot multi-speaker text-to-speech (ZS-TTS) systems have advanced for
English, however, it still lags behind due to insufficient resources. We
address this gap for Arabic, a language of more than 450 million native
speakers, by first adapting a sizeable existing dataset to suit the needs of
speech synthesis. Additionally, we employ a set of Arabic dialect
identification models to explore the impact of pre-defined dialect labels on
improving the ZS-TTS model in a multi-dialect setting. Subsequently, we
fine-tune the
XTTS\footnote{https://docs.coqui.ai/en/latest/models/xtts.html}\footnote{https://medium.com/machine-learns/xtts-v2-new-version-of-the-open-source-text-to-speech-model-af73914db81f}\footnote{https://medium.com/@erogol/xtts-v1-techincal-notes-eb83ff05bdc}
model, an open-source architecture. We then evaluate our models on a dataset
comprising 31 unseen speakers and an in-house dialectal dataset. Our automated
and human evaluation results show convincing performance while capable of
generating dialectal speech. Our study highlights significant potential for
improvements in this emerging area of research in Arabic. | [
-0.0280356463,
0.0436385497,
0.0286396723,
-0.0218496714,
-0.0165423136,
-0.0145878885,
0.0584243797,
-0.0191748533,
-0.0538326576,
-0.0436588936,
-0.0675021261,
-0.07110551,
0.0673018247,
0.0050464123,
0.0337416045,
-0.0416002199,
0.0044613322,
-0.0712478086,
-0.0052994927,
0.0042279982,
0.035614077,
0.0436462946,
-0.0335700475,
0.0171402115,
0.0010734495,
-0.0127702337,
-0.0386116318,
0.0047887992,
0.02148588,
0.0337935835,
-0.0296302773,
0.0400318429,
0.0025771474,
0.0506439283,
0.0000019593,
-0.0394141376,
-0.020913979,
-0.0289184786,
-0.0566839986,
0.0084602954,
0.0355632417,
-0.0353321768,
-0.05567687,
0.0001742887,
0.007871368,
-0.0036049651,
0.0551264063,
0.0256504305,
0.0360472538,
0.0504980832,
-0.0021032682,
-0.0410878584,
-0.0206154529,
0.005131118,
-0.0057597226,
0.0057881614,
-0.0489246659,
-0.0549724996,
0.0289831217,
-0.0155222816,
-0.0267681666,
0.0322829038,
-0.0158341751,
0.0065295864,
-0.0231446847,
-0.0138968797,
-0.0521483123,
-0.0218373053,
0.0131496014,
0.0724330917,
0.0034361449,
-0.0204901323,
0.0054913932,
0.0295846201,
-0.0146093098,
-0.0298172534,
-0.0064602825,
0.0444021299,
0.0007770543,
-0.0176314209,
0.0116508752,
0.0228442345,
-0.0027120071,
-0.0362060964,
-0.0498166457,
0.031475652,
0.0065115499,
-0.0365418904,
0.0284179132,
-0.0160193834,
0.0372474678,
-0.044529397,
0.0021779758,
0.0206458364,
-0.0252228864,
-0.0309321303,
-0.0291136578,
-0.0324494503,
-0.042586714,
-0.0290191323,
0.0595971569,
0.058627706,
-0.0162375756,
-0.0218843408,
-0.0155037399,
0.0021663266,
0.0416480117,
0.0138832238,
-0.0510901287,
-0.0202627834,
-0.0547955856,
0.031048594,
-0.0168727152,
0.0416529477,
-0.0338177346,
0.0129770692,
-0.0405693352,
-0.0162741113,
-0.0416718274,
0.0232143681,
0.0134119662,
-0.0114301676,
-0.0527612977,
-0.0516614057,
0.0267392006,
0.044009842,
0.0172723066,
0.0283622555,
-0.0452089198,
-0.1044753343,
-0.0156049561,
0.0250908583,
0.0309560169,
0.0528620183,
-0.0109541817,
0.0258335043,
-0.0274463892,
-0.0463081896,
-0.0460969731,
-0.0202233214,
-0.0483090803,
-0.0516518876,
-0.0229351278,
-0.0576739386,
0.0292080138,
-0.0146971326,
-0.0177932214,
-0.0030307467,
-0.0292520896,
-0.0038814542,
0.0518735349,
0.0310017634,
0.0225122534,
0.0239974633,
0.0659849867,
0.0045721997,
0.0321692973,
0.0733301491,
0.0447232313,
-0.0118006142,
-0.0388816595,
0.0000387936,
0.0161683857,
0.0694304407,
0.007044137,
0.0419941396,
-0.0537392795,
-0.0567234084,
-0.0017504145,
0.0661572888,
0.0187694691,
0.0156364068,
-0.0249064043,
0.0049306592,
0.0836713985,
0.0158589277,
0.0387113541,
0.0175040234,
0.0700014532,
0.0604331419,
0.0254427306,
-0.0116122579,
0.0443963483,
0.0085718967,
0.0175627787,
0.0314658135,
0.0197729561,
0.0429958701,
-0.0627171323,
-0.0104418807,
-0.0148294494,
-0.0414491445,
-0.030562738,
-0.0050920649,
0.0682914555,
0.016281534,
-0.0582067221,
0.0284127817,
-0.0012451757,
-0.0389854759,
0.0380378813,
-0.0381096862,
-0.0245688353,
0.0253801718,
0.0000534275,
0.0150007559,
-0.0281701759,
-0.0527799316,
0.0076678069,
0.0479451716,
0.0131477788,
-0.0238977429,
0.06253241,
-0.0675659478,
0.0063745412,
0.0262944158,
0.0132763889,
0.0195960104,
-0.0512929112,
0.0615718961,
-0.011288113,
-0.0108015351,
0.04789754,
-0.0045444188,
-0.0605235249,
-0.0109087033,
0.0420857444,
0.0235720593,
0.0162373874,
0.0562254637,
-0.033667475,
0.0007159807,
-0.0236349404,
-0.0319415405,
-0.0053274538,
0.0292375255,
-0.0433255583,
-0.0324440859,
0.0434799306,
-0.0225994028,
0.0384941064,
0.0257182065,
0.0035168712,
-0.0931375548,
0.1184329987,
0.0005559098,
0.0485993363,
-0.0197924767,
0.0239838045,
0.0371345058,
0.0034040308,
0.0391298681,
-0.0061895251,
0.0055925567,
-0.0396519639,
0.0342022665,
-0.0021589324,
0.0414140336,
-0.0502094179,
0.0119942371,
-0.0092901755,
-0.024360152,
0.0372985192,
0.0005474087,
-0.0164567009,
-0.0045441543,
-0.0192871764,
-0.0732271224,
0.0034011556,
0.0019278168,
0.0447987579,
-0.0214817915,
0.000057548,
-0.0071880068,
-0.0118672242,
-0.0184637886,
-0.0271161497,
0.0124298194,
-0.0258335043,
-0.0016156489,
-0.0070582107,
-0.0247737598,
-0.0256247651,
0.0064410288,
0.001640128,
0.0247105993,
-0.0121514509,
-0.0294322558,
0.0319399126,
-0.0314141065,
0.0057630651,
0.0008342704,
0.0352940895,
-0.0130095193,
0.0203568488,
-0.0003735282,
0.024088081,
0.0120634045,
-0.0457102992,
-0.0180300977,
-0.0048887944,
-0.0193885956,
-0.0168552883,
-0.0101140141,
0.0165594611,
-0.0267301351,
-0.0108812992,
-0.0469680838,
-0.0443889052,
0.0324454568,
0.0231241398,
0.0120739629,
-0.0716063976,
0.0106699271,
0.0074643958,
-0.0042566862,
0.0329565182,
0.0313471928,
-0.0067267343,
0.0436833017,
-0.0122234998,
-0.0184958316,
-0.0032316374,
-0.0629300252,
-0.0335621648,
0.0062367027,
0.0162829068,
-0.0172950383,
-0.0403598659,
-0.0452835597,
0.0281101223,
0.0069193714,
-0.013715433,
-0.0638957247,
-0.0116833132,
-0.0033081148,
-0.0208230373,
0.0087996488,
-0.040558897,
0.0107442969,
-0.0407624133,
-0.0288191177,
0.0271882266,
0.0193398725,
-0.0734211355,
0.0468579382,
-0.0005116154,
-0.0168013927,
-0.0129572963,
0.0186235383,
0.0418084413,
0.053924378,
-0.0021126976,
0.0177668259,
-0.0115828142,
0.0092245564,
0.0225838833,
0.003964907,
-0.0146470703,
-0.0303873904,
0.0469084643,
-0.0017774008,
0.0217393804,
0.0627024844,
-0.0559347682,
-0.0405533724,
0.0301781483,
-0.0049615796,
-0.0226690397,
0.000850216,
-0.0138377789,
-0.0000174301,
0.0300890002,
0.0912772641,
-0.0160546564,
-0.0162129868,
-0.0125597995,
-0.0023035221,
0.031515833,
-0.0157301612,
-0.0273302067,
-0.1220497712,
-0.0490868576,
0.060291592,
0.0353486277,
0.0094430307,
0.0241118018,
0.0028831132,
-0.1151685715,
0.0160902124,
0.02907563,
-0.0380447358,
-0.0168693904,
-0.0088428557,
-0.0350214429,
-0.0319311023,
-0.0152415307,
-0.0105300769,
-0.001724177,
0.0027274108,
0.0537867136,
-0.0101223597,
-0.0855148509,
0.0262435004,
-0.0333939269,
0.0966818929,
0.0046363426,
-0.0025278002,
-0.0132886535,
-0.0226373971,
-0.036966674,
-0.0423065424,
-0.0368256122,
-0.0048511657,
0.0212880932,
-0.0133525627,
0.0081808669,
-0.0046726079,
0.0062881853,
-0.0388412513,
0.0344407894,
-0.030126797,
0.0216539316,
-0.0037588649,
0.0246055964,
0.0286605153,
0.0442064367,
0.0077895266,
0.0374195538,
-0.0000416697,
-0.0694857314,
-0.0423934087,
0.0069150738,
-0.0117256371,
-0.0923876911,
-0.0288878158,
0.0115158046,
0.0279908609,
-0.0445362441,
-0.054551851,
-0.0091358954,
-0.0032235475,
0.0534268841,
0.0316570736,
0.0051559494,
-0.0102130165,
0.0350841209,
0.0014621411,
-0.0488713905,
-0.0044460646,
0.0265636537,
-0.0765015334,
-0.0045277919,
0.0466315076,
-0.074116908,
0.0214659683,
0.0026116883,
-0.0671707913,
-0.0410570279,
0.0057625682,
0.0111441649,
0.0177047309,
0.0328520983,
0.0131456228,
-0.0396815352,
0.0777367353,
-0.0034925954,
0.0441439711,
0.0466240682,
0.072049439,
0.0213661306,
-0.0325056985,
0.0395658761,
0.0032457968,
0.0285254084,
0.0283423848,
-0.0325882025,
-0.0498152375,
-0.0517324246,
-0.0117467996,
-0.0319209248,
-0.0169797372,
-0.0336650386,
0.0064362781,
-0.0261646844,
-0.0178065374,
-0.0370485745,
0.0544773117,
-0.0420526825,
-0.0086889761,
0.0620790198,
0.039955955,
0.0330012329,
0.0168727506,
-0.0329181291,
0.006921547,
0.0461960584,
0.022984257,
0.030628873,
0.0121795218,
-0.0154927522,
0.001696449,
-0.0138363596,
0.0035791995,
-0.0327680483,
0.0482062027,
-0.0355392732,
0.012974361,
-0.0155220255,
0.0339912474,
0.0066247289,
0.0505466349,
0.0261850655,
-0.0043735281,
-0.0286177322,
0.0343624093,
0.0410444997,
0.0176593345,
0.0901952609,
0.0105619533,
0.0197157618,
-0.0212730747,
0.0230567008,
-0.0517835952,
0.0014925911,
-0.0469380915,
-0.0128995329,
-0.0104079042,
0.0400863551,
0.0606262237,
0.0417909212,
-0.0087778252,
-0.0074974028,
0.0557857454,
0.0019596417,
-0.0152394129,
-0.0061750608,
-0.0212053042,
-0.0261931326,
-0.0054288697,
-0.0762515068,
-0.0802844465,
0.0483357422,
0.0056069512,
0.0213389602,
-0.0272257086,
0.0424650647,
-0.0127295069,
-0.0191273615,
0.0009957574,
-0.0389916152,
-0.0259748697,
0.0210219193,
-0.0380185992,
0.006067073,
-5.919083887e-33,
-0.004904259,
0.0229507256,
-0.0022082964,
-0.0157555062,
0.0082273297,
-0.0385029428,
-0.0412337221,
0.0206383932,
-0.023592256,
-0.0151160518,
-0.0228663366,
-0.0117561296,
0.0242506657,
0.0385541096,
0.0355607048,
-0.0040901224,
0.0424929857,
-0.04671783,
-0.0111426152,
0.037505392,
0.0511523448,
0.0300269052,
0.0768667087,
-0.0219614748,
-0.0247227754,
-0.0465547778,
-0.0289381407,
-0.0132203726,
0.0106115174,
0.0564722717,
-0.0022510129,
0.0612141304,
-0.0024162701,
-0.0513774641,
-0.0025584796,
0.003051881,
-0.0015595463,
0.0180327725,
-0.0191228576,
0.0517776497,
0.0147868833,
-0.0245110895,
-0.0325370505,
0.0069999662,
-0.1021375433,
-0.0206442717,
-0.0095626684,
-0.0158299487,
-0.006704946,
0.0051265503,
-0.0900915936,
0.0367299207,
-0.0190650299,
-0.0602386929,
0.097447902,
0.1005822718,
-0.0324280523,
-0.0163175762,
-0.0587412082,
0.0237702094,
0.0168290045,
0.0323310979,
0.083672896,
0.0432161465,
-0.0625115857,
0.0045621567,
0.050186228,
-0.0456437208,
0.0222863331,
0.0114308447,
0.0457269251,
-0.03942772,
0.0364675373,
0.1115598008,
0.028971551,
-0.0080375923,
-0.0526883416,
0.0072074905,
-0.0055588572,
-0.0094838943,
-0.0084864013,
0.0040774844,
-0.0170267951,
-0.0144395875,
-0.0135723678,
-0.0866418108,
0.0040837349,
-0.0004177854,
0.0284732953,
-0.0034718071,
0.0158369187,
0.0209087804,
0.0663184524,
0.0170540735,
0.0443908945,
-0.0115425074,
-0.0478920229,
0.0212670136,
0.0042592324,
0.0288546029,
-0.0862276703,
-0.0368394069,
0.0443758965,
0.0836287662,
0.0322172828,
0.0058043022,
0.0266618766,
0.0704268143,
-0.0450225882,
0.0103243822,
-0.0091282614,
0.048063539,
-0.0109585421,
0.0654363707,
0.01876444,
-0.0226862561,
0.0238647666,
0.0403156579,
-0.0009237981,
-0.0053099329,
0.0453312434,
-0.0069542639,
-0.0158312041,
-0.0185237806,
-0.0094886264,
0.0534038693,
-0.0043133902,
-0.0291735083,
0.0233694073,
-0.0210571866,
-0.0040822662,
-0.003025688,
2.728e-7,
-0.0275413487,
-0.0155378561,
0.0313022137,
-0.0354820229,
0.0207189824,
0.0620632246,
0.0045368145,
0.0172237046,
-0.0040262123,
0.0251571611,
0.0002758822,
-0.0155620594,
0.1133963689,
-0.0198293049,
-0.1176983118,
-0.0089189634,
-0.0372695923,
0.0588757508,
-0.0466572791,
0.0066362862,
0.016486004,
0.1104966998,
-0.054499764,
-0.0182822179,
0.0122801978,
-0.0139153302,
0.0475914814,
0.0193000939,
-0.0092153884,
0.023635488,
0.0239793025,
-0.0672942996,
-0.0269828513,
-0.0368350297,
-0.0460605398,
0.0304399002,
0.0072437664,
0.0853383616,
-0.0124727758,
-0.0581200235,
0.0260419361,
0.0173732284,
-0.0534037128,
0.0069557545,
0.0584080592,
0.0122991018,
-0.0205512494,
0.0298481118,
-0.0236849673,
0.06765908,
0.001552287,
-0.0437438004,
-0.0008552842,
-0.0083224447,
0.0479785316,
0.000723955,
-0.0023475387,
0.0011613335,
0.0203633159,
0.0127031794,
-0.0242555309,
-0.0117763067,
0.0209771451,
-0.0211001337,
0.0200694818,
-0.0334698595,
0.0038143308,
2.017231188e-34,
0.0294738151,
-0.0245720856,
0.0351595879,
-0.0142862983,
-0.0101668118,
-0.0161840469,
-0.0501494929,
0.0052745114,
0.0340495519,
-0.0001120074,
-0.0311827492
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16748v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16748v1 | OCALM: Object-Centric Assessment with Language Models | 2024-06-24T15:57:48 | 2024-06-24T15:57:48 | Timo Kaufmann, Jannis Blüml, Antonia Wüst, Quentin Delfosse, Kristian Kersting, Eyke Hüllermeier | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Properly defining a reward signal to efficiently train a reinforcement
learning (RL) agent is a challenging task. Designing balanced objective
functions from which a desired behavior can emerge requires expert knowledge,
especially for complex environments. Learning rewards from human feedback or
using large language models (LLMs) to directly provide rewards are promising
alternatives, allowing non-experts to specify goals for the agent. However,
black-box reward models make it difficult to debug the reward. In this work, we
propose Object-Centric Assessment with Language Models (OCALM) to derive
inherently interpretable reward functions for RL agents from natural language
task descriptions. OCALM uses the extensive world-knowledge of LLMs while
leveraging the object-centric nature common to many environments to derive
reward functions focused on relational concepts, providing RL agents with the
ability to derive policies from task descriptions. | [
0.0658393577,
0.0535705686,
0.0092936298,
0.0315505527,
-0.0341109745,
0.0026659353,
-0.0501907952,
-0.0049599824,
-0.0163782798,
-0.0415105037,
-0.0499994121,
0.0362884142,
-0.0331299081,
0.0349511467,
-0.0215895642,
-0.0840996727,
0.0262574162,
-0.0329094268,
0.028397074,
0.0229416713,
0.0015660237,
-0.0023492128,
-0.0098990668,
0.0447692126,
0.0104115857,
-0.0150165325,
-0.0452189893,
-0.0448254831,
0.0119034005,
-0.0484506562,
0.0120942928,
0.0259090159,
0.0627578348,
0.0043423558,
0.0000020401,
-0.0586619712,
-0.0340323113,
-0.0075025507,
-0.0136061013,
-0.0828815997,
0.0568107702,
-0.0053822584,
0.0153650837,
-0.0038777341,
-0.0414740629,
0.0010043146,
0.0480360165,
0.0563162155,
0.0358575955,
0.0537394919,
0.0123809362,
-0.004326683,
-0.0021374931,
-0.0092643481,
0.0558381565,
-0.0597456507,
0.0109608816,
0.0473910123,
0.0399893969,
0.0119250733,
-0.0154050486,
-0.0402095094,
0.0512124971,
-0.0023873653,
0.0159641486,
0.0349907354,
0.0099415686,
-0.0133962696,
-0.0157401841,
0.0535310246,
-0.0184982922,
0.025037555,
-0.0165471286,
0.0081469612,
0.0227157306,
-0.0005870869,
-0.0120833693,
0.0643545911,
0.0087529775,
0.0209780131,
0.0197725501,
0.0422946028,
0.0188402403,
0.0271622464,
-0.0251906477,
0.0996132717,
-0.0398396216,
-0.0095632952,
0.0133724781,
0.0281716324,
-0.0101869665,
-0.0423894413,
-0.0213165041,
0.0729469657,
-0.070902884,
0.01687981,
-0.0045719342,
0.0273629837,
-0.017612109,
-0.0326877795,
0.0465726182,
0.0024040677,
-0.0151463915,
0.0530901626,
-0.0190165043,
0.0703352764,
0.0204690844,
0.0089593343,
-0.0334611461,
0.0095800189,
-0.0932549536,
0.0020064865,
-0.0045512132,
0.0378576331,
-0.0111549078,
-0.005772314,
-0.0309275426,
0.0495464876,
-0.0796974152,
-0.0008599584,
0.0045554163,
0.0285410061,
-0.0282310564,
0.0200277623,
-0.106208764,
-0.019973211,
-0.0262790807,
0.0223901756,
-0.0025394976,
0.0056668445,
0.0069213337,
0.0067461967,
0.0059022694,
-0.0097195217,
0.0199643485,
0.1446282119,
-0.0028397948,
-0.0341619961,
0.0063553583,
-0.0603517704,
-0.004679061,
-0.0304561518,
0.0066671241,
-0.0731166974,
-0.0037910836,
-0.0184925795,
-0.0070884656,
-0.0187494438,
0.0221410692,
0.0097819138,
0.0074616647,
0.0634197891,
0.0207343046,
-0.0275554191,
-0.0337102488,
0.0076424065,
-0.0111009981,
0.0672073439,
0.0503966585,
0.0398980901,
0.0008140461,
0.0507407151,
0.0087655094,
0.0175661761,
-0.0099332025,
0.0070626242,
0.0046565044,
0.0051539708,
-0.0014950181,
0.0289660916,
0.0502176136,
-0.0054228241,
-0.0151554542,
0.0400326513,
0.0505467728,
0.0274353828,
-0.0152808707,
-0.0215409379,
0.0407983772,
0.0067198793,
-0.0080119269,
-0.0413579829,
-0.0590613075,
0.0600742623,
-0.0052008526,
0.0068808636,
-0.0517681651,
-0.0262147915,
-0.0033346186,
-0.058301229,
0.0438619368,
-0.0228738356,
0.0690110624,
0.0526528917,
0.0649299398,
0.0119449897,
-0.0382871106,
-0.0180558078,
0.0319102108,
-0.0055842642,
0.0293380842,
-0.0848398954,
0.0355187543,
0.063636817,
0.0521267429,
-0.064961955,
-0.0083815651,
-0.0289251301,
-0.0235485006,
0.0505474247,
0.0123884706,
-0.0431783721,
-0.0145223662,
0.0264771115,
-0.070184879,
-0.0296544321,
-0.0029061015,
0.0299402159,
0.0248582363,
-0.0331773795,
-0.0135380663,
0.0037045379,
-0.0737645179,
0.0475160852,
0.0372900665,
-0.0290733054,
0.0017427293,
0.0136871897,
0.0225971714,
-0.0002309879,
0.0102868201,
0.0096864095,
0.036430385,
-0.0134425918,
-0.0282242,
-0.0147695653,
-0.0187000334,
-0.0078846943,
0.0175534189,
-0.0061092377,
0.0068421471,
0.0368918665,
-0.015178632,
0.0092503736,
0.0185428206,
-0.0232051797,
0.0428197347,
-0.0013749815,
0.0102501269,
-0.0161395855,
-0.0512227677,
-0.0546114817,
0.0618906282,
0.0115404278,
-0.0014378568,
-0.0338576213,
-0.0147100044,
-0.0177175254,
-0.0478331707,
-0.0263581425,
0.0019253826,
0.0155670308,
0.059494365,
0.0737461299,
0.0598550141,
-0.0307574291,
-0.0258045327,
-0.0182193313,
-0.0200827774,
-0.0040922342,
0.0033228493,
0.0237064734,
-0.032758452,
0.0178737137,
-0.0078274701,
-0.0383638218,
-0.0056616645,
0.0062792785,
0.0027028846,
0.0396893583,
0.0198814478,
-0.0257679205,
-0.0174013358,
0.0108824475,
-0.0326588526,
0.0012290825,
0.0392974354,
0.0581573471,
-0.0559651367,
0.0405387171,
-0.0305951405,
0.0370860882,
-0.010881139,
-0.0132662142,
0.0562591255,
-0.016027078,
-0.0002604156,
0.0948101059,
-0.0143040512,
0.0892005637,
0.0692535341,
-0.014215908,
-0.0546874963,
-0.0015192116,
-0.0540756732,
-0.0584956259,
-0.0515763611,
-0.0240431,
0.0130633153,
0.0761896968,
-0.0289054886,
0.0020933691,
-0.0450211428,
0.0422453098,
-0.0340395607,
-0.0427001752,
-0.0721571967,
0.0029786087,
-0.0122312056,
0.0151089113,
-0.0276153442,
-0.0270216092,
0.0815662742,
0.0282465909,
0.0083914585,
-0.0362058543,
-0.0278140921,
-0.0422940589,
0.0760719106,
0.0050770193,
0.0302446354,
-0.011416628,
0.0089990078,
-0.0580835752,
-0.0165494494,
0.0110168857,
-0.0220652651,
-0.0092504229,
-0.0500245094,
-0.005935661,
0.0209766701,
-0.0344806574,
-0.0513046384,
0.0237558465,
-0.0298381094,
0.0562837534,
-0.0366005301,
-0.0104282778,
-0.0509295352,
0.0067705931,
0.0374904461,
-0.0186699182,
-0.0287466049,
-0.0217432156,
-0.0463099033,
-0.047110226,
0.0721583739,
-0.0012869879,
-0.0106669823,
-0.0601559877,
-0.0063998736,
0.0345008522,
0.0234492943,
-0.0410354398,
-0.0219145585,
0.0665813684,
0.0101877395,
-0.0418435596,
0.0217950828,
0.0476552658,
-0.0071984613,
-0.0824494287,
-0.0480173975,
0.1060411781,
0.0264404081,
-0.034661863,
0.0162953306,
-0.0406827778,
-0.012382457,
0.0253355764,
0.0644601211,
-0.0430981889,
-0.0355748683,
-0.0235626996,
0.0187165886,
-0.014318049,
-0.0451780744,
0.0214681756,
-0.111369364,
-0.0135304369,
-0.017847063,
-0.0765994862,
-0.0353317671,
-0.0037721426,
-0.0187261235,
-0.0505389161,
-0.0400229245,
0.0233482569,
0.0075874883,
-0.0132481055,
0.0209005419,
0.0344217978,
-0.0045944774,
0.0837537944,
-0.0665799379,
0.0347542576,
0.0878631473,
0.0095085315,
-0.0210391544,
-0.002388163,
-0.0550011992,
0.0499764308,
-0.0051948773,
0.0213376023,
-0.0152993537,
-0.0356481075,
-0.0151680596,
-0.0070330175,
0.0233236682,
-0.0225323942,
-0.0330372676,
-0.0097830733,
0.0662275776,
-0.0067784223,
-0.0089530433,
-0.0163401701,
-0.0117354672,
0.0408205353,
0.0785488486,
-0.0400913246,
-0.0607666746,
-0.050209105,
-0.0362885296,
-0.0661328435,
-0.0183809325,
-0.0449965596,
0.0083930567,
-0.0468331985,
-0.0256358422,
-0.0508160666,
-0.0467397645,
0.0320349559,
-0.0056616417,
0.0279112104,
-0.0540388301,
0.0280414354,
0.0165741146,
-0.0488542579,
0.0285727903,
-0.0292105675,
0.0217927583,
-0.0350433141,
-0.0131685482,
0.0125049036,
-0.0371006429,
-0.0402476266,
-0.0060697696,
-0.0090373373,
-0.0171855185,
-0.0145251555,
0.0924363732,
0.0165498778,
0.0205309093,
0.009420977,
-0.0259781536,
0.0147490166,
0.0178018864,
-0.0515203774,
-0.0112632914,
0.0247531962,
0.041806262,
0.0214646775,
0.0149784433,
-0.0885647684,
0.0288025532,
-0.0181867443,
0.0373846516,
-0.0083548296,
0.0099632172,
0.0457268506,
-0.0623672381,
0.018727107,
-0.0142938225,
-0.0194412116,
-0.0129801193,
-0.0173329413,
-0.0181351006,
-0.0390008464,
-0.0356684253,
0.0102780042,
0.0065349974,
0.0178251844,
0.0509613603,
-0.0057843416,
-0.0139637683,
0.010343547,
0.0120906085,
-0.0014888516,
0.0484568365,
-0.005891718,
0.0101000462,
0.0257094782,
0.0274971537,
-0.0316737629,
-0.0113024153,
0.0457534418,
0.0136250081,
0.0738647506,
0.0328837223,
0.0196659248,
-0.0568112284,
0.0081993481,
-0.0339236073,
-0.0039417208,
0.0134321339,
0.0092896884,
0.0306925662,
0.0029311446,
0.0218805522,
-0.079902567,
0.0130513385,
0.0196656361,
0.0093752425,
-0.0330006219,
-0.0429319143,
0.0414068066,
0.0450612642,
0.0317575932,
-0.047374282,
0.0574030951,
0.0411632992,
0.0426863544,
-0.0421805419,
-0.0236245319,
-0.0189602412,
-0.0110848248,
0.0454717949,
0.0121948356,
-0.0233854931,
0.006094384,
-0.0401465893,
-0.0540998392,
-0.0399574712,
0.0805980265,
0.0132088307,
-0.0195460059,
0.049804043,
0.0194365308,
-0.0388385616,
-0.0554119907,
-0.0588046759,
-0.0278496109,
-0.003170908,
-0.015145014,
-0.0503174551,
-5.390189305e-33,
-0.0105800396,
-0.050646577,
0.058935035,
0.0111872451,
-0.0006809425,
0.0086653316,
-0.0254372098,
-0.0035497434,
0.0272302981,
0.0397320129,
0.0312182289,
-0.0185201596,
-0.0138891386,
-0.005080774,
0.0265612975,
-0.0253325421,
0.0063398904,
-0.024489589,
-0.0308102556,
-0.0074422411,
0.0411320068,
-0.0226046406,
0.0478660315,
-0.0720850974,
0.0990059376,
0.0209720619,
-0.0398987085,
0.0520704277,
0.024446344,
0.0554543771,
0.0070394627,
0.0147790946,
0.0183529705,
-0.0320791006,
-0.0041941251,
0.0160678588,
-0.0758885741,
-0.0477363057,
0.0182094071,
0.005369294,
-0.0828514546,
-0.0009829093,
0.0133700464,
0.001068906,
-0.0197742712,
0.0187888481,
0.037339773,
-0.0105349226,
0.0242886264,
0.0463820845,
-0.0552166775,
-0.0236642603,
-0.0181230661,
-0.0610965192,
0.0413039066,
0.0086113652,
-0.0247352142,
-0.0061991327,
0.0185382925,
0.0428075679,
0.0014593996,
-0.0006030336,
0.0568547584,
0.0653774738,
0.015527362,
0.0677345023,
0.0010993313,
0.0200421512,
-0.0151135754,
0.0065939617,
0.0253161509,
0.0631745979,
0.0352847464,
0.0267261174,
0.0081459191,
0.0684301779,
-0.0515684336,
0.0312822014,
-0.0176519416,
0.0636427552,
0.0265252646,
0.0117158713,
-0.0226183422,
-0.0234347302,
-0.0466424078,
0.0036970905,
-0.0174833182,
-0.0253830831,
0.039932128,
0.0021086033,
-0.0274310298,
-0.0397084989,
0.0006265386,
-0.0520304739,
-0.0222353805,
0.0123579549,
-0.0345255807,
0.0187256709,
-0.0214239042,
-0.0369278751,
-0.0529416837,
-0.0300189331,
0.0103425793,
-0.0295435414,
0.0114981076,
0.0415280834,
0.0070416429,
0.0363670848,
-0.0058100796,
-0.0099326214,
-0.0524348877,
0.0034629791,
0.0321385041,
0.023372991,
0.0395053662,
-0.0005673954,
-0.013056661,
0.0505993739,
0.0088712452,
-0.0629965439,
-0.0063290088,
0.0102900164,
-0.0216379296,
0.0165492948,
-0.0321689136,
-0.0098269945,
-0.0385154523,
-0.0067699268,
0.002223759,
-0.0289398488,
0.0126624266,
0.0035709161,
2.655e-7,
0.0230221674,
0.0439493395,
-0.0095090913,
0.0801289156,
0.0247426014,
0.0641686395,
0.0049384432,
0.06034128,
0.008343501,
-0.0003698491,
0.013613916,
0.0587183908,
0.0112907505,
-0.0284114815,
-0.0665815547,
-0.0125333937,
-0.0219696313,
-0.024797501,
-0.0193097275,
-0.0063382308,
0.0366431326,
0.0331418887,
0.0370592177,
0.0003138931,
0.0100279767,
-0.0288174972,
0.0307895374,
-0.048673775,
0.0114007909,
0.0100297807,
-0.0219011735,
0.0230778959,
0.0081481598,
0.0141485902,
0.0208318606,
0.0057200012,
-0.0020193637,
0.0713860989,
-0.0270840675,
-0.0072051841,
-0.0158310272,
-0.0037382955,
0.0137221515,
-0.0299539845,
0.0334943719,
-0.0572585277,
-0.025717197,
-0.0315365717,
0.0275870897,
-0.0418362543,
-0.0374704525,
-0.024337044,
-0.0430310667,
-0.0017436064,
-0.0041891313,
0.0300150476,
-0.017055409,
-0.0318631753,
-0.0178523306,
0.0329405181,
0.0117022581,
-0.029890256,
-0.0313290395,
0.0319168083,
-0.021005746,
-0.0687900484,
-0.0200224239,
2.25611919e-34,
-0.0252865236,
0.0109549267,
-0.0189687572,
0.0177474841,
0.0404351242,
0.0413505435,
-0.0441992246,
0.0254331287,
0.0589666888,
-0.0229835622,
-0.029459564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16747v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16747v1 | Sparser is Faster and Less is More: Efficient Sparse Attention for Long-Range Transformers | 2024-06-24T15:55:59 | 2024-06-24T15:55:59 | Chao Lou, Zixia Jia, Zilong Zheng, Kewei Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Accommodating long sequences efficiently in autoregressive Transformers,
especially within an extended context window, poses significant challenges due
to the quadratic computational complexity and substantial KV memory
requirements inherent in self-attention mechanisms. In this work, we introduce
SPARSEK Attention, a novel sparse attention mechanism designed to overcome
these computational and memory obstacles while maintaining performance. Our
approach integrates a scoring network and a differentiable top-k mask operator,
SPARSEK, to select a constant number of KV pairs for each query, thereby
enabling gradient-based optimization. As a result, SPARSEK Attention offers
linear time complexity and constant memory footprint during generation.
Experimental results reveal that SPARSEK Attention outperforms previous sparse
attention methods and provides significant speed improvements during both
training and inference, particularly in language modeling and downstream tasks.
Furthermore, our method can be seamlessly integrated into pre-trained Large
Language Models (LLMs) with minimal fine-tuning, offering a practical solution
for effectively managing long-range dependencies in diverse applications. | [
0.0192884672,
0.1007415876,
0.0162541158,
0.0349451005,
-0.0134049971,
-0.0048696185,
0.0126628028,
-0.000850011,
-0.0323501863,
-0.0467521809,
-0.0376353674,
-0.0596997812,
-0.0077177729,
0.0395668186,
0.0509640835,
-0.0356952548,
0.0246765446,
-0.0398786515,
-0.0370805822,
-0.0021377325,
-0.010623103,
-0.0005563881,
0.020497065,
0.0389784239,
-0.0157062113,
-0.0108619453,
-0.0207056738,
-0.0118002575,
0.019076217,
-0.0304273237,
0.0275674183,
0.0753168613,
0.001898907,
0.0484467149,
0.0000022047,
-0.0026858496,
0.0220213626,
-0.0225833785,
-0.0404065773,
0.034185227,
0.0112713473,
-0.0049952306,
0.0317573361,
-0.0113270972,
-0.0178962145,
-0.0405236743,
0.0531918369,
0.0288968794,
0.0635363087,
0.0659171119,
0.0028356635,
-0.0390975997,
0.0067414995,
-0.0778628215,
0.0304652248,
-0.1008171514,
0.0071896757,
-0.059238065,
-0.0031574036,
0.0039814766,
-0.0138919596,
0.0597476177,
0.0186142921,
-0.0177193824,
0.0396232791,
0.0497623123,
-0.0445646457,
-0.0180305354,
0.0107185142,
0.0680527613,
-0.0600363389,
-0.0311850272,
0.0106768152,
-0.0039666868,
-0.037357986,
-0.041107513,
-0.0290598981,
0.0180756338,
0.0301902555,
-0.0030935521,
0.0141178584,
0.0310781039,
0.0379563607,
0.0295837931,
-0.0707214922,
0.008154152,
0.0355642326,
-0.0021630798,
-0.0249033086,
-0.0017382741,
-0.0517110936,
-0.061170429,
-0.0046255789,
0.0509071872,
-0.0224806871,
-0.0117418095,
-0.0560947992,
-0.0311823655,
-0.0048150113,
0.0145695349,
0.0622441955,
0.032598678,
-0.0108028436,
0.0395003296,
-0.0176468659,
0.0341035612,
-0.0324763171,
-0.0107516926,
-0.0142623428,
0.000731695,
0.0160551164,
-0.0119404439,
-0.034921702,
0.0065476131,
-0.0267632492,
-0.0193162728,
-0.0157301798,
0.0265154466,
-0.0021169272,
-0.0554175414,
0.0346263759,
0.0280792527,
-0.0665192455,
-0.0266628396,
0.0171707645,
0.0316029564,
-0.0315101892,
-0.0029212546,
0.0108269285,
-0.0169425718,
-0.0580457523,
0.0450650156,
0.0232848488,
-0.0427911878,
-0.0146639599,
0.0605067052,
-0.0057727913,
-0.0300989915,
-0.0169219747,
0.0063314862,
-0.0311344359,
-0.083185643,
0.0083982982,
-0.0555357784,
-0.0012455096,
0.0132191405,
-0.008164838,
-0.0278789457,
0.0185572729,
0.050083451,
-0.0152007369,
0.0312916674,
0.051011268,
-0.0057172612,
-0.0096051591,
0.005436874,
0.0325271711,
0.0709041059,
0.0055457447,
0.0400234796,
-0.0308165494,
0.0109884162,
-0.0133770471,
0.014922522,
0.0660343245,
-0.0166949593,
-0.0196418799,
-0.0002844028,
-0.002678537,
0.0085441256,
0.0403110124,
0.0382113792,
-0.0053915824,
-0.0494685136,
0.0413194112,
0.0313662365,
0.0333730914,
0.042005226,
0.0529134125,
-0.0029364491,
-0.0525744297,
-0.0146586876,
-0.0366744585,
0.0771709979,
0.0070857615,
0.0025421218,
0.0328061208,
0.0405420884,
-0.0469581895,
-0.0170186181,
0.0039200154,
0.0263330769,
-0.0270226933,
0.0333667621,
0.033247862,
0.0177516676,
-0.0640820563,
0.085249573,
0.0131416991,
-0.0391355567,
0.0053739226,
-0.050121773,
0.0001092714,
0.0184366871,
0.0055986168,
-0.0304656569,
-0.0043912986,
-0.0097023174,
0.0133595001,
0.0370642506,
-0.0070325849,
0.0115960082,
0.012427317,
-0.0420708098,
-0.0108781047,
-0.0162317213,
0.0088176392,
0.0243473407,
0.0142564513,
0.0345306881,
0.060934335,
-0.0221909638,
0.0155090904,
0.0224745739,
-0.0293496177,
-0.0395575166,
-0.0004442788,
0.0310415272,
0.0149329053,
0.0243480857,
0.0168553274,
0.0379812792,
0.0445989706,
-0.0743959397,
0.0218253471,
-0.0446011424,
-0.0843594,
-0.0588642433,
0.0051078345,
-0.004228591,
0.0032023371,
0.0708139166,
-0.0116529511,
-0.0382603221,
0.0595343076,
-0.0529500693,
0.0263658483,
-0.0407925099,
-0.0051151901,
0.0387191698,
0.0533637479,
-0.0551012121,
0.0570122413,
-0.0036233182,
0.0066732033,
0.0102496399,
0.004352909,
-0.0218156558,
-0.0174892973,
-0.0565410703,
-0.0032453702,
-0.0211288668,
-0.0016986086,
0.0202878136,
-0.0042405277,
-0.0107124373,
-0.0295009892,
-0.0581280068,
0.0042741043,
-0.0739329532,
0.0024858683,
-0.0194975343,
0.0414099768,
0.0224669222,
-0.0060542701,
-0.0404190645,
-0.0006558246,
0.0261252243,
0.0125424229,
-0.005834592,
0.0230761524,
-0.0041839723,
-0.0240554288,
-0.0554014444,
0.0390506126,
0.077798754,
-0.0191684831,
-0.0298315734,
-0.0140789319,
0.0364673547,
-0.0156293623,
0.017225761,
-0.0220448207,
-0.0147244614,
-0.0402173176,
-0.058228761,
0.0523605719,
0.060266085,
0.0344684124,
-0.0072035366,
0.0210143235,
-0.0392686091,
-0.0204505473,
0.0329601467,
-0.0351030529,
-0.0174685232,
-0.0169128422,
0.0213569831,
0.0183180869,
0.1082936227,
-0.0268145017,
-0.0323724113,
-0.0613217913,
-0.0091128033,
0.0089059761,
-0.040780697,
-0.0213319324,
0.0342974663,
-0.0185684096,
0.0276517961,
-0.0246685613,
-0.0139890518,
0.0562567413,
-0.0096322466,
-0.002842702,
0.0027813667,
0.0131649273,
-0.0281409603,
0.0486527197,
0.032578066,
0.0085233347,
-0.0264987294,
-0.0295580439,
-0.0358249061,
0.0158039797,
-0.0151885934,
-0.0035780193,
0.0867704675,
0.0006453608,
0.0442729332,
-0.0214544535,
-0.0273107272,
-0.0513894148,
-0.0475255847,
0.0000907865,
0.0119360052,
0.0407281481,
0.0195060931,
-0.0598819703,
0.0540398508,
-0.0001182437,
0.0583584793,
-0.0230866447,
0.0250580702,
-0.0015060544,
0.0215059798,
0.0650408119,
0.0202388298,
0.0080619855,
-0.0221044179,
-0.0127821695,
0.0420139395,
0.0412774011,
0.0041292864,
-0.0035125341,
-0.0039255787,
0.0378289111,
-0.007893757,
0.0064320001,
0.0011985956,
0.040616136,
-0.0704155415,
-0.022295462,
0.0710269362,
-0.0155142536,
-0.0489506125,
-0.004155512,
-0.0046437848,
0.068999216,
0.0313480198,
0.0312246531,
-0.0693612322,
-0.025792703,
-0.019097954,
0.0343540162,
0.0240151864,
-0.0430153236,
0.0085485037,
-0.1033415198,
0.0232034866,
0.0112425815,
-0.028210111,
-0.0215461142,
-0.0171475541,
0.0273335408,
-0.0084500602,
-0.0029041634,
0.0341574177,
-0.0188117139,
-0.0221615992,
0.0335658453,
0.0207319241,
-0.0451924354,
0.0372595936,
-0.0244635306,
0.0124667799,
0.0339032225,
0.0081521338,
0.0344432667,
-0.026472101,
0.0014040478,
-0.0320795923,
-0.0032750701,
-0.0044580898,
0.0282419343,
-0.0348192938,
-0.0308926683,
0.0070254002,
0.0020940986,
-0.0178674478,
0.0087252511,
-0.0269930512,
0.0770944059,
-0.0013148743,
-0.0014413532,
-0.0012015067,
-0.0039138864,
0.0062988428,
0.0616851896,
0.0453201607,
-0.0104687093,
-0.0577615537,
0.0012262238,
0.0157031585,
-0.0884509608,
-0.054333657,
0.031359341,
0.0155937104,
-0.0821525902,
-0.0452220738,
-0.0225535315,
0.0186380744,
0.0497730263,
-0.0220535602,
-0.0023962629,
0.0095923236,
-0.0111722397,
-0.0783890113,
0.0287714396,
-0.0516103022,
-0.0010533964,
-0.0599868037,
-0.0030301821,
0.0207522884,
-0.0227441806,
-0.021436302,
0.0287753139,
-0.1290178299,
-0.0537975207,
0.0191319548,
0.0639482588,
0.0040850653,
0.0372057036,
0.0059318496,
-0.0417065546,
0.0608866923,
0.029103402,
-0.0466354974,
0.0483949073,
0.0264939424,
-0.0549052544,
-0.0129937567,
0.063295275,
-0.044003617,
0.0536161549,
0.0273067933,
0.0667602569,
0.0093653714,
-0.0020231833,
-0.0170429051,
-0.0231910814,
0.035492532,
-0.0062969038,
0.0443218797,
-0.0206799489,
0.039504122,
0.0082766591,
0.0029483032,
-0.0535569377,
0.0055926498,
0.0079893712,
-0.0202647466,
-0.0016180053,
0.0309411865,
0.0171857458,
0.0034947605,
-0.0728842169,
0.042440109,
-0.0179731846,
-0.0084369835,
0.0283089839,
0.0179442186,
-0.0351232961,
-0.0230654795,
0.0183534641,
0.0176108144,
-0.0140015287,
0.0056000743,
0.0122488691,
0.0198387112,
-0.0345408879,
-0.0040245564,
-0.062566638,
-0.0352684334,
-0.0218147002,
-0.0252415128,
0.0461668186,
-0.0494096018,
0.0271099601,
0.0010284337,
-0.0204837825,
-0.0360725708,
0.0122268125,
-0.0021241237,
-0.0236637834,
0.0130456565,
0.0214834213,
0.0104062855,
0.0114948619,
0.0785118714,
0.0332058109,
0.0346899815,
0.0255251303,
-0.0075218966,
-0.0404565707,
-0.0347189941,
-0.0050933873,
0.014125539,
0.0082215322,
0.0349767804,
-0.0077798893,
-0.0756625161,
0.0200034715,
-0.0549115092,
-0.031104628,
-0.0064116931,
0.0454870164,
0.047503192,
0.0265354943,
-0.0100239394,
-0.0273721702,
0.0469704121,
0.0068729152,
-0.0143745989,
-0.0093241744,
-7.487366369e-33,
-0.0276322197,
-0.0185540318,
0.0040730909,
-0.019545963,
-0.0653512627,
0.020167293,
-0.0588356331,
-0.0240238812,
-0.0119640296,
-0.0021714948,
-0.0226543732,
-0.0044288207,
-0.0013021842,
0.0585709326,
0.0004304681,
-0.0405788086,
0.0593702123,
0.0278518032,
0.0003833247,
0.0681473836,
0.0106599005,
0.0415079594,
0.0629234314,
-0.0300500989,
-0.0459725223,
-0.0009543901,
0.0219638422,
-0.0225150976,
-0.0009306019,
0.0418310203,
-0.0310085714,
0.0464966297,
0.0234600492,
-0.0574614443,
-0.0365277193,
0.0142941764,
-0.0841614604,
-0.0159205012,
-0.0168541372,
-0.0185113028,
-0.0083056102,
-0.0361355431,
0.0309545659,
0.018738335,
0.0275704898,
-0.0474454015,
0.0096975509,
0.0006976753,
-0.0527481511,
-0.0528038666,
-0.0575381257,
0.0409395695,
-0.0068987519,
-0.0270303413,
0.0297714546,
0.025897976,
-0.0027302322,
0.0203562062,
-0.0533040836,
0.0064024027,
0.0082333256,
0.1105611399,
0.0625484809,
0.0674090832,
0.0269241948,
0.0284212735,
-0.0150728403,
0.0013681898,
-0.0323689021,
-0.0295759216,
0.0310792401,
0.0265107937,
0.0200590976,
-0.0214546658,
0.0335271284,
-0.0061874366,
-0.0814150944,
-0.0354647152,
-0.0473202169,
0.074089542,
0.0527277216,
0.0136439055,
-0.0010098374,
-0.0172110107,
-0.0064316336,
0.0048104711,
-0.0518845804,
0.0209081769,
0.0290153455,
0.0562599748,
-0.0312741473,
0.0195751674,
0.0610121228,
-0.0203707218,
0.0141510461,
0.0310041402,
0.0285147373,
-0.0087667704,
0.0028346565,
0.0341133997,
-0.0451097935,
0.0216315147,
0.0023440041,
-0.008038993,
-0.0141205713,
-0.0184855331,
-0.0004746247,
0.0289712939,
-0.0574580394,
-0.0546613894,
-0.041040089,
0.0523081906,
-0.0144770415,
0.0701816604,
0.0466386043,
-0.0026934023,
0.0109187802,
0.106683746,
-0.0193754509,
-0.0136890849,
-0.0055236104,
-0.001096991,
0.0467914455,
0.0356047712,
-0.0421951897,
0.0183273163,
-0.0442295484,
0.0185182523,
0.0191833731,
-0.0557799302,
-0.0189456083,
0.0534209274,
2.943e-7,
0.0388553999,
0.010830651,
0.0035967312,
0.0204967037,
0.0039970018,
-0.0032795663,
0.0327179283,
0.0331122912,
-0.0041459845,
-0.0039609228,
-0.0013445872,
0.0359218828,
0.0463644676,
0.0000655783,
-0.088754639,
-0.0067637241,
-0.0649091303,
-0.0012613939,
-0.0621513762,
-0.0562845804,
0.0179339759,
0.1252665967,
-0.0241984334,
0.0128898732,
0.028011322,
-0.007384418,
0.0512510128,
0.0101330942,
-0.0017586361,
0.0219267849,
0.0456430018,
-0.028664358,
-0.0024650828,
-0.0065421299,
-0.0236335751,
0.0267593209,
0.0210650098,
0.0736237168,
-0.0081086224,
-0.0597784519,
0.0082962597,
0.0210967008,
0.0127109969,
-0.0509903505,
0.066116862,
-0.0726210997,
-0.0197052807,
-0.0216829907,
0.0004563313,
0.0064831725,
0.0114518618,
-0.0205273516,
0.0181925818,
0.0264273286,
0.0257546641,
-0.0246107746,
-0.0112670148,
-0.1096556634,
-0.006059445,
-0.0073083006,
-0.0718449205,
0.0011613299,
-0.0793704093,
-0.0396212265,
0.0301336367,
0.006917696,
-0.0053092008,
2.792315199e-34,
0.0341378972,
-0.0113669485,
-0.0378150567,
0.0013266257,
0.0145111885,
-0.0240454786,
-0.0207695775,
0.0229694601,
0.0181884728,
-0.1072988063,
-0.0515356623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16746v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16746v2 | The Responsible Foundation Model Development Cheatsheet: A Review of Tools & Resources | 2024-06-24T15:55:49 | 2024-06-26T02:19:01 | Shayne Longpre, Stella Biderman, Alon Albalak, Hailey Schoelkopf, Daniel McDuff, Sayash Kapoor, Kevin Klyman, Kyle Lo, Gabriel Ilharco, Nay San, Maribeth Rauh, Aviya Skowron, Bertie Vidgen, Laura Weidinger, Arvind Narayanan, Victor Sanh, David Adelani, Percy Liang, Rishi Bommasani, Peter Henderson, Sasha Luccioni, Yacine Jernite, Luca Soldaini | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Foundation model development attracts a rapidly expanding body of
contributors, scientists, and applications. To help shape responsible
development practices, we introduce the Foundation Model Development
Cheatsheet: a growing collection of 250+ tools and resources spanning text,
vision, and speech modalities. We draw on a large body of prior work to survey
resources (e.g. software, documentation, frameworks, guides, and practical
tools) that support informed data selection, processing, and understanding,
precise and limitation-aware artifact documentation, efficient model training,
advance awareness of the environmental impact from training, careful model
evaluation of capabilities, risks, and claims, as well as responsible model
release, licensing and deployment practices. We hope this curated collection of
resources helps guide more responsible development. The process of curating
this list, enabled us to review the AI development ecosystem, revealing what
tools are critically missing, misused, or over-used in existing practices. We
find that (i) tools for data sourcing, model evaluation, and monitoring are
critically under-serving ethical and real-world needs, (ii) evaluations for
model safety, capabilities, and environmental impact all lack reproducibility
and transparency, (iii) text and particularly English-centric analyses continue
to dominate over multilingual and multi-modal analyses, and (iv) evaluation of
systems, rather than just models, is needed so that capabilities and impact are
assessed in context. | [
-0.0015840266,
0.1112729013,
-0.0334251486,
-0.0025412091,
-0.0325530134,
-0.0106276507,
0.0350517444,
-0.0492005721,
0.0024771201,
-0.0058213687,
0.0206798557,
0.0225629956,
0.0074063223,
0.077196002,
0.0148067037,
-0.0297429524,
0.0840224549,
-0.0284827705,
-0.0300918277,
0.0322107114,
-0.0012231832,
-0.0044017411,
-0.0050004255,
0.0484941602,
-0.04128436,
-0.0081592211,
-0.0117115807,
0.0359445326,
0.0181635562,
-0.0368320234,
0.0225479081,
0.0387342833,
0.0224358831,
0.0143431891,
0.0000026878,
-0.0340935811,
-0.0314365849,
0.0556278713,
-0.0308929607,
0.0104194339,
0.0882826075,
-0.0009039235,
0.0008665306,
0.0174746346,
0.004821056,
0.0159650482,
0.0766848251,
-0.0091836136,
0.0324070677,
-0.0152782016,
0.0044805803,
0.0117485877,
0.0612984523,
0.0112076597,
-0.0390845984,
0.0183514357,
0.0131794447,
0.0545749217,
0.0025465442,
-0.0184721798,
-0.0016897577,
0.0637976825,
0.043518357,
-0.0182175152,
0.0437159389,
-0.007024195,
0.0069423132,
-0.0848079622,
-0.0291946586,
0.0275574699,
0.0858022496,
-0.0059615215,
0.0116691804,
-0.0119859073,
-0.0015094785,
-0.006243208,
-0.0338078961,
0.0218328368,
0.0104996543,
-0.008501647,
0.0157007184,
-0.0204941593,
0.0062056431,
0.0282269344,
0.0230508596,
0.056760326,
-0.0362166464,
-0.0017131589,
0.0069666835,
-0.004701667,
0.0475218222,
-0.0389298163,
-0.0042867335,
-0.0063682236,
-0.0125293639,
-0.0084394496,
-0.0092377318,
-0.0241757557,
0.0463531874,
-0.0332012698,
0.0367087536,
-0.0171335991,
-0.0082871597,
-0.0074793259,
0.0320252813,
0.0155414036,
-0.0238647424,
0.0421056971,
0.0011185213,
0.0219041631,
-0.0607402399,
0.0161837153,
-0.0155186681,
-0.0132226208,
-0.0229727048,
0.0167731307,
0.0016785765,
0.0050935699,
-0.0630119294,
0.0154394554,
0.0064978362,
0.0432948954,
0.0191791523,
0.0286077298,
-0.006097524,
-0.030157214,
-0.0527651682,
0.0482272767,
0.0243154205,
-0.0693735406,
0.0149190426,
-0.0028023021,
-0.0646910891,
-0.0128142964,
-0.0013295214,
0.0864534676,
0.0552293211,
0.0129099162,
-0.0499356724,
-0.0351542905,
0.0411572829,
-0.0295449756,
0.0019303916,
-0.0285052843,
-0.0115136039,
-0.0430129655,
0.0158936922,
-0.0560401268,
0.000727676,
-0.0261001606,
-0.0071996162,
0.0082496926,
-0.0808790028,
0.0231804047,
0.0329326279,
0.0535110757,
-0.0146941803,
0.0810373724,
0.0290996153,
0.0218654051,
0.0209402442,
-0.0145775443,
-0.0143530564,
-0.0069508199,
0.000450169,
0.0089521902,
-0.0213877987,
0.0435877889,
-0.0386970863,
-0.0066519501,
-0.0435586162,
-0.0068058954,
-0.0086049968,
0.0614487305,
0.064771235,
0.0163254589,
0.0060941349,
0.0418945849,
0.0250236001,
0.0161432717,
0.0189313013,
-0.1087813005,
-0.0549610592,
0.0173273906,
-0.0371207371,
-0.0149178365,
-0.1207855567,
0.1049464568,
-0.004408848,
-0.0519822687,
0.0058573596,
-0.0369747356,
0.0198621247,
0.0329821333,
0.0263447557,
-0.0075208433,
0.0277846456,
0.0037362934,
-0.0181259904,
-0.0412903205,
-0.0356907956,
-0.0581844226,
0.0265489686,
0.0510268807,
0.0303880814,
-0.0603106432,
-0.0703621283,
-0.0507192314,
-0.0312855802,
-0.0242106505,
0.0122783221,
-0.0217925776,
0.0151616624,
-0.0026185808,
-0.0477390215,
-0.0147953751,
0.0151719013,
0.0112322923,
0.00914698,
0.0251654759,
0.000968102,
0.0053762123,
-0.0737624243,
0.0597840622,
-0.0611738898,
-0.0152363628,
-0.0452574939,
0.000048591,
0.0394758955,
0.0432937816,
-0.0212915782,
0.0107114026,
0.0290897284,
0.0606121086,
-0.0187381785,
0.0087352144,
0.0408720151,
0.1327656657,
0.0148423249,
-0.0233405791,
0.0061187181,
0.0589223579,
-0.0252464227,
-0.0011133988,
-0.0256758444,
0.0045339176,
-0.0168117601,
0.0029076764,
0.0254629981,
-0.072348401,
0.0116033927,
-0.0106192827,
-0.0099516427,
0.0025843398,
-0.0664935708,
0.0088597061,
-0.027232606,
0.0316694006,
-0.0008432477,
-0.0079853553,
0.004979779,
-0.0524516962,
0.0196931474,
0.0447508246,
0.0225714613,
-0.0515793748,
0.0670011714,
-0.086821802,
-0.0035893163,
0.0068106097,
-0.0010274112,
-0.0083343489,
-0.0499662198,
-0.0291876886,
0.0252855569,
0.0524527244,
-0.0143372286,
-0.0215033889,
-0.0029720829,
-0.0130928773,
-0.0254941676,
-0.0363159515,
-0.0402546301,
0.0096512726,
-0.0254990943,
0.0422711782,
0.067770794,
-0.0453671068,
-0.036405053,
0.0361515395,
-0.0223680492,
-0.0086391168,
0.0238930248,
-0.0195296407,
0.0124152927,
0.0424383245,
-0.0732027292,
0.0055090636,
-0.0142423082,
0.0610464141,
0.0377874896,
-0.0063445675,
-0.0207754523,
0.0025555913,
0.0413574427,
0.0240333099,
-0.0024804496,
-0.0225116387,
-0.0010737898,
0.0025770112,
-0.0399442576,
0.0159308836,
0.0411470868,
0.0523460992,
-0.0429023094,
-0.0816054195,
0.0198273212,
-0.0363821499,
0.0049388544,
0.0457475819,
-0.0312021598,
-0.0720213428,
0.0483743958,
-0.0203900635,
0.0259203091,
-0.0239512175,
-0.046058137,
-0.0176024586,
0.0170304272,
-0.0428639613,
0.0061393692,
0.0703190118,
0.0440132655,
-0.0215550531,
-0.026441006,
0.0201008189,
-0.006451814,
-0.0158336535,
-0.0541899726,
-0.0012618697,
-0.0022050987,
-0.0299535431,
-0.0305119343,
-0.0050695436,
-0.0167938937,
0.04857108,
0.0067813639,
-0.0276608784,
-0.0234623924,
0.0036515954,
0.0809002668,
-0.0189067721,
0.0031864792,
-0.0103538651,
0.0167115927,
-0.0413115397,
0.0120389974,
-0.0126214772,
0.0712501407,
-0.025031982,
0.0289650727,
0.0092031173,
0.0170392506,
-0.0183614884,
-0.0642364249,
0.011700266,
0.0032421462,
0.0272924099,
0.0139426244,
0.0356231704,
0.0267234091,
-0.0426059626,
-0.0212734751,
0.0358387642,
0.0044660368,
0.0039918865,
0.0305112675,
-0.0266537908,
-0.0207526926,
0.0131912241,
0.0029797773,
-0.0460532904,
0.0116490889,
0.0297890846,
0.0411054231,
-0.0607897565,
-0.0394383855,
0.0450524054,
-0.024072811,
0.0924934894,
-0.0018683624,
-0.0587376654,
-0.0067369463,
-0.0676082447,
-0.0118444059,
-0.0617831275,
-0.0169877578,
-0.0005091784,
0.0018451085,
-0.01598919,
0.0368399546,
-0.0365941077,
-0.0673721209,
0.0006459097,
-0.0552471429,
0.0587126203,
0.1154748872,
-0.0072539817,
-0.039282158,
0.0221465658,
-0.0006067294,
0.0064591668,
0.0317565054,
-0.0006151581,
0.0074309893,
0.0140143242,
0.0040758108,
-0.0252883267,
0.0064768433,
-0.0260893647,
-0.0367139764,
0.0627814755,
0.0808560699,
-0.0313428603,
0.0077387406,
-0.0801453218,
-0.0224878732,
0.0546218455,
0.0243317354,
0.0081146862,
-0.0260562655,
-0.0221209787,
-0.0231880117,
-0.0009514298,
-0.0263322443,
-0.0007630952,
-0.0081188418,
-0.0335937701,
-0.0512661673,
-0.0134798465,
-0.0503850132,
-0.0011670876,
-0.0117176753,
0.0110426201,
-0.0715759844,
0.0517517254,
0.0213677306,
-0.0366250835,
0.0526524372,
-0.0017611757,
0.0247500744,
-0.030216841,
-0.0186841618,
0.0178863723,
-0.0042011011,
-0.0095763002,
0.0645176843,
-0.0169171449,
-0.0164058208,
0.0544012412,
0.1083166301,
0.0281279609,
-0.0500469767,
-0.0060280166,
0.0116372937,
0.0189315677,
0.0348671265,
-0.0508793592,
-0.0094098914,
0.0401770361,
-0.0525220707,
-0.0136530055,
-0.0287956633,
-0.0107465116,
0.0402703881,
0.0133646345,
0.0056370692,
-0.0184464883,
0.0055446103,
-0.001432681,
0.0508742556,
0.0428392254,
-0.0256986395,
-0.0156609602,
-0.0148903122,
-0.015658332,
0.000103976,
-0.0233015735,
-0.0455138013,
0.04033833,
0.0120636895,
0.0100556491,
0.048845306,
0.034195222,
-0.0023836065,
-0.00174311,
-0.017113857,
0.0803595558,
0.0143333711,
0.0817928016,
-0.0215932,
0.0187733565,
-0.0289846864,
-0.03431198,
-0.0525397398,
0.0105465623,
0.027506128,
0.0328469649,
-0.0249331519,
0.0151869711,
-0.0049387631,
0.0555624515,
-0.0007838062,
-0.0825833157,
-0.0784935802,
0.0386311114,
0.0069649699,
0.0604304746,
-0.0090337303,
-0.057153143,
-0.0072808131,
-0.0465875082,
0.010726192,
0.0016317151,
-0.0245600473,
-0.0057687433,
0.0218654647,
-0.0481639542,
-0.067362763,
0.0160633698,
0.0438817404,
0.0427208841,
-0.0547160953,
-0.0340431593,
-0.0072954083,
-0.0487718582,
0.0147494888,
-0.035061162,
-0.0248660352,
-0.037692938,
-0.0976326913,
-0.0708246827,
0.0292544831,
0.0358530879,
0.0014434238,
-0.0002276174,
0.0077940342,
0.0129316244,
0.0080085797,
-0.0676387176,
-0.0021174047,
-0.0611175448,
-0.0929487571,
-0.0044188253,
-0.0090534315,
-6.429748387e-33,
-0.0196673721,
0.0008573643,
0.0222778935,
-0.0319320187,
-0.0360539146,
0.0158666763,
-0.0140992664,
0.0051539601,
-0.0578732044,
0.0271646213,
0.0239602011,
-0.0048591942,
-0.0041504856,
-0.0176123176,
0.0524789616,
0.0048194258,
0.0285931658,
-0.0156496484,
-0.0008156559,
0.0004720396,
0.000603582,
0.0140423393,
0.0404755734,
-0.1034015268,
0.0264975484,
0.0156047037,
-0.0326804444,
-0.00425416,
-0.0427521132,
0.0392995961,
0.0404314399,
0.0316838026,
0.0111330058,
-0.0306302533,
-0.020902656,
-0.0070195463,
-0.0612557232,
0.0143391229,
0.0029708589,
-0.0535749942,
-0.0103407465,
-0.0225390736,
0.0284922533,
0.0168225318,
-0.0332349241,
-0.0056092655,
0.038221363,
-0.0600563362,
0.0127285067,
-0.0143356863,
-0.05992743,
0.0069696521,
-0.0521710403,
0.0178321097,
-0.0078296345,
0.0741854161,
-0.0034946571,
0.0015226573,
0.0092108017,
-0.0174501631,
0.0324472599,
-0.0594518296,
0.0797070563,
0.0385027863,
0.0403195843,
0.0396916084,
0.0130707165,
0.0156182442,
-0.015086907,
-0.0420140326,
0.0305178985,
0.0931876153,
0.0524006784,
0.0627791807,
-0.0513820834,
-0.0360134467,
-0.0736404508,
0.0268478226,
0.0071400614,
0.0716081262,
-0.0179640185,
-0.017080484,
-0.0306981895,
-0.0068051801,
-0.0223022923,
-0.0403873362,
-0.0000352225,
0.00267268,
0.0539995916,
-0.0183725115,
-0.0826485977,
0.038652245,
-0.0056021297,
-0.0557879321,
0.0586905926,
0.0582437366,
0.0210491326,
0.0419249646,
0.0212395526,
0.035045933,
-0.063199617,
-0.0272381864,
-0.0069603985,
0.0235457178,
0.0547259375,
-0.016396502,
-0.0152031304,
0.0167472325,
0.0221706387,
0.0129203666,
-0.0219573993,
0.0468331352,
0.0361375883,
-0.0296710208,
0.0016440065,
-0.0146017633,
0.01535754,
0.0058908574,
0.0162343439,
0.000812674,
-0.0230186675,
0.0132080438,
-0.0288190972,
0.0090694875,
0.007082005,
-0.0445922352,
-0.0305394493,
0.0021335732,
0.0529127307,
-0.046642378,
-0.0119152013,
0.006768899,
3.247e-7,
0.0143984705,
0.033839941,
0.033804547,
-0.0188323408,
0.0002653699,
0.0472289734,
-0.0133560132,
0.0215316545,
-0.0010278858,
0.0152585823,
0.0329243205,
0.0103153782,
0.0521858856,
0.0244883243,
0.0162035599,
-0.0486900844,
-0.0245253406,
0.0034701542,
-0.0752970055,
0.0133709656,
0.0005385713,
0.0185327418,
0.015604727,
-0.0210892353,
0.0284750257,
-0.0172817353,
-0.0264738575,
-0.0594010465,
0.0577674732,
0.0233228616,
-0.0233862698,
0.0314633325,
0.0205311757,
-0.0103475517,
0.0008763543,
-0.0291589387,
-0.0061803306,
0.0715941861,
-0.016172763,
-0.000406517,
0.0106597012,
-0.0488322452,
0.0199323762,
-0.0699211508,
0.0390004627,
-0.0038406248,
0.0049498468,
-0.0308768041,
-0.0554096512,
-0.0055017136,
0.018087063,
-0.0289845578,
0.0363413393,
-0.0149834165,
-0.0254215896,
-0.0170573927,
-0.0215037167,
0.0259944536,
0.0337224118,
-0.0055402312,
-0.0035718009,
-0.0609261505,
-0.0144017888,
-0.008106159,
-0.0012938081,
-0.0335178412,
0.0416745842,
3.150464221e-34,
-0.0148101328,
-0.0423135459,
0.0042281416,
0.0084945951,
0.0475868434,
0.0274119303,
-0.0057385759,
-0.0207965076,
-0.0330486149,
0.0188832656,
-0.0092903925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16743v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16743v1 | Adversarial Contrastive Decoding: Boosting Safety Alignment of Large Language Models via Opposite Prompt Optimization | 2024-06-24T15:51:30 | 2024-06-24T15:51:30 | Zhengyue Zhao, Xiaoyun Zhang, Kaidi Xu, Xing Hu, Rui Zhang, Zidong Du, Qi Guo, Yunji Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the widespread application of Large Language Models (LLMs), it has
become a significant concern to ensure their safety and prevent harmful
responses. While current safe-alignment methods based on instruction
fine-tuning and Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) can
effectively reduce harmful responses from LLMs, they often require high-quality
datasets and heavy computational overhead during model training. Another way to
align language models is to modify the logit of tokens in model outputs without
heavy training. Recent studies have shown that contrastive decoding can enhance
the performance of language models by reducing the likelihood of confused
tokens. However, these methods require the manual selection of contrastive
models or instruction templates. To this end, we propose Adversarial
Contrastive Decoding (ACD), an optimization-based framework to generate two
opposite system prompts for prompt-based contrastive decoding. ACD only needs
to apply a lightweight prompt tuning on a rather small anchor dataset (< 3 min
for each model) without training the target model. Experiments conducted on
extensive models and benchmarks demonstrate that the proposed method achieves
much better safety performance than previous model training-free decoding
methods without sacrificing its original generation ability. | [
-0.0052879006,
0.0765790865,
0.0067391312,
0.0477568656,
-0.0185173955,
0.0267927907,
-0.0000395909,
-0.0397754535,
-0.0245480575,
0.0101207169,
-0.0646077842,
-0.0503026955,
0.0121658174,
0.0068204566,
0.03448366,
-0.0382584818,
0.0556282513,
-0.060672719,
-0.012543913,
0.0084186643,
-0.0072383261,
0.0106721446,
-0.0113258017,
0.0342603885,
0.0277675558,
-0.0546523258,
-0.0252616387,
0.0469509922,
0.0394215621,
-0.0368263312,
0.0235528015,
0.0543377176,
0.0066009504,
0.0718156546,
0.0000019015,
-0.0174378902,
-0.01990306,
0.0130560184,
-0.0566157028,
0.0086870734,
0.0552187301,
-0.0537383184,
-0.0334060863,
0.0355480276,
-0.0025888558,
-0.0482547618,
0.0662825927,
0.0329490714,
0.0729613975,
0.075581871,
0.01499377,
-0.0298510697,
0.0315492302,
-0.0222566184,
-0.0582474135,
-0.0417470373,
0.0178130176,
-0.0208534431,
-0.0411537439,
0.0123642571,
-0.0397922248,
0.0457396097,
0.0237636287,
0.0081852293,
-0.0286638383,
0.0219549704,
0.0120968008,
-0.0342638083,
-0.046455089,
0.0748454407,
-0.023539627,
-0.0326043591,
-0.0203954205,
-0.0297524817,
0.0013121113,
-0.034372922,
0.0026465498,
0.0181038026,
-0.0215376113,
0.0546458364,
0.061482992,
0.0084014125,
0.0312250927,
-0.0053368299,
0.0035552485,
0.0145965023,
0.0333033465,
-0.0326294601,
0.0059600188,
0.0062146364,
-0.0099766133,
-0.0379602015,
0.0003963774,
-0.0135101918,
-0.0754760429,
0.0189077482,
-0.0708554015,
-0.085681051,
0.0198177602,
-0.0127028516,
0.0507030971,
0.0559622943,
-0.0270399954,
0.0296316203,
0.0026473976,
0.0528631844,
-0.0322380178,
0.0359131396,
-0.0437254608,
0.0006154361,
0.0203080699,
-0.0051562847,
-0.0176944342,
-0.0228447039,
-0.0543877669,
0.0171181429,
-0.0164140034,
0.0206284449,
0.0185996909,
0.0264435131,
0.0158321131,
0.0071053877,
-0.0737728029,
-0.0146403359,
0.031490773,
0.0234902054,
-0.0211016461,
0.0013520992,
0.0059658685,
-0.0649718121,
-0.0322295353,
0.0153748868,
-0.0324840881,
-0.0382014103,
-0.0221833196,
0.0958057195,
-0.0398030244,
0.00462814,
-0.0261894688,
0.0140744559,
-0.0120687364,
-0.0289198495,
-0.0167468637,
-0.0493867584,
0.02757922,
0.0118938247,
-0.0132740317,
-0.0653927922,
0.001951971,
-0.0050112777,
-0.0148231639,
0.0968771055,
-0.0406667255,
-0.0147466008,
0.0174448024,
-0.0044999574,
-0.0260258,
0.0796550363,
0.0230405349,
0.0384716094,
0.0067278915,
0.0039508324,
-0.0042681824,
0.056833405,
0.0396554209,
0.0282698609,
-0.0329162069,
0.0087686228,
0.0392056815,
0.0139597869,
0.0537607558,
0.0787028,
-0.0174140073,
-0.0353555493,
0.0620965362,
-0.0023482658,
-0.0248740446,
0.0235801823,
0.0138111543,
0.0255670194,
-0.0170317646,
0.0089480383,
-0.046044942,
0.0107477121,
-0.0458410457,
0.0154041611,
0.0454806313,
0.0309058726,
-0.0264325552,
-0.0161971673,
-0.0038635293,
-0.0180245135,
0.0231219567,
0.0063235159,
0.0432054512,
0.0060198219,
-0.0778311864,
0.0116683608,
0.0327035226,
-0.0149218375,
-0.0038150637,
-0.0309229102,
0.0091573251,
0.0710011646,
0.030868791,
0.0110587385,
-0.0344943739,
-0.0103514241,
0.0074096252,
0.0550982468,
0.0393922254,
0.0049361303,
0.0403375663,
-0.0626861304,
-0.0361285992,
0.0228879713,
-0.0053718584,
0.0259045959,
0.02589624,
-0.0087320982,
-0.0151325166,
0.015202553,
-0.0571554527,
0.0467043146,
-0.0517320558,
-0.0499805324,
-0.0039587994,
0.02988635,
0.0327921137,
-0.0130033372,
-0.0236915313,
0.0070265289,
0.0219830591,
-0.0283620916,
0.0274441577,
-0.0093158223,
-0.0723852888,
-0.0562295988,
0.0293305479,
-0.006715083,
-0.0523105301,
0.0655018389,
-0.0533317551,
-0.0211671237,
-0.0005043146,
-0.0202097837,
0.0233188216,
0.0017154174,
0.0242921337,
0.0157507453,
-0.0043284837,
-0.0396653935,
0.0409756005,
-0.025770532,
0.0060520461,
0.0184099562,
0.028153494,
-0.0048403637,
-0.0386980772,
-0.0355152488,
-0.0004745948,
-0.024386853,
0.0236665588,
0.0028695932,
0.0261885673,
-0.0219737235,
-0.0176216234,
-0.030108802,
0.0123922387,
-0.0357579067,
0.0275430027,
0.0390811972,
-0.020542128,
-0.0139440838,
-0.019125564,
-0.0125906691,
-0.0104282023,
-0.0252996124,
0.0006567551,
0.017347984,
0.0115720788,
-0.022482533,
-0.0507561564,
-0.0104306145,
-0.0014377937,
0.0214931909,
-0.0094370227,
-0.0080985669,
-0.0887087733,
0.066414766,
0.0434186049,
0.0431721844,
-0.0029474951,
-0.0721185356,
0.0217446759,
0.0279299635,
0.0352746509,
0.0837211162,
0.0000999547,
0.0271107592,
0.0364692844,
0.0158791207,
-0.0527994446,
0.0038956378,
0.0004429152,
-0.0559581034,
-0.0315534063,
-0.0503579676,
-0.0171132311,
0.0910454839,
0.0243600439,
0.0231072828,
-0.0886686444,
-0.0008574894,
-0.0075629721,
-0.0530548245,
-0.0158055201,
-0.0146382814,
-0.0412498526,
0.0294721369,
-0.0483045802,
-0.0544015057,
0.0992524326,
-0.037167266,
-0.0036750473,
-0.0219328087,
-0.0066630915,
0.0107772527,
0.0248075556,
-0.0275501627,
0.0281890277,
0.020826498,
-0.0596928485,
-0.0627300069,
-0.0301086847,
0.0221893955,
-0.0303038955,
0.0259267073,
-0.036336489,
-0.0083145667,
-0.0378226563,
-0.0727813318,
-0.0677201226,
-0.0422516093,
-0.0065036733,
0.0097353887,
0.0420050994,
-0.0278275609,
-0.0370614678,
0.0021132526,
0.0081144376,
0.0305440221,
-0.0283023007,
0.0212814994,
-0.0438599437,
0.0152950855,
0.0713042468,
-0.0253140982,
0.0209494513,
-0.0627222434,
0.0502002351,
0.0535057075,
0.0356763788,
0.019601725,
-0.0462351516,
0.0036877689,
0.0595700964,
0.0089184316,
-0.0027935847,
0.038791284,
0.0384702869,
-0.0333102234,
-0.030672485,
0.0848548338,
0.0194856673,
-0.0410160869,
-0.0066937106,
-0.0216022767,
0.0405929387,
-0.0006679164,
-0.0037829569,
-0.038433224,
-0.043030709,
0.027729366,
0.0724269003,
0.0270166621,
0.0126717044,
-0.0017246861,
-0.1094450578,
0.0050498401,
0.0453314148,
-0.0577046312,
-0.0622720756,
-0.0024614036,
-0.0102412747,
-0.0314842686,
0.0703253821,
0.0459802002,
0.0105153117,
-0.0076031755,
0.0397365987,
0.0284504611,
-0.0525568277,
-0.0069457148,
-0.0557325482,
0.0905605108,
0.1032025442,
-0.0117510986,
-0.0002937454,
-0.0420654938,
0.0123062031,
-0.0233832095,
-0.0182820167,
0.0033132348,
0.0258066244,
-0.0312354881,
-0.0172058716,
0.0008302011,
0.0376203693,
-0.025220219,
-0.0228774659,
-0.0097488621,
0.0363600031,
0.0059334077,
0.0279647689,
-0.0146067329,
0.0029539417,
0.046842806,
0.0885545909,
0.0210580863,
-0.0482992604,
-0.0133122094,
-0.0356270932,
0.0154748727,
-0.0662809461,
-0.0046004178,
0.0195896216,
-0.0025506401,
-0.029131053,
-0.0460679904,
-0.0274145231,
0.0089030918,
0.0068251686,
0.006127554,
0.0012044011,
-0.0283909496,
0.0049209786,
-0.0391899794,
0.0285969302,
-0.0157199297,
0.026670631,
-0.0858306438,
0.000709918,
0.0141159808,
-0.0272280108,
-0.0166697595,
0.0598906241,
-0.057729125,
-0.090851061,
0.0175886881,
0.0370284617,
0.0143295005,
0.0730313361,
-0.0356904119,
-0.0465326495,
0.0440544039,
0.060571339,
-0.0176351015,
-0.016529562,
0.0460725129,
-0.017676184,
-0.0056134206,
0.0268688127,
-0.0579663329,
-0.0321061723,
0.0722357258,
0.0486987531,
-0.0295943394,
-0.0159661137,
0.0241464674,
0.0274717994,
0.0700174347,
-0.0465330221,
-0.0110989632,
-0.0191815626,
0.0192564484,
-0.0011204169,
-0.0073216176,
-0.0134300031,
0.0185060725,
0.036565952,
-0.0365547724,
0.003033278,
-0.0057205632,
0.0186014008,
0.0258856043,
-0.01202852,
0.0122821461,
-0.0158636533,
0.0699357986,
0.0561688505,
0.0081960447,
-0.0345023535,
0.0271626003,
0.006991873,
0.025483191,
-0.0103912726,
0.0225233529,
0.0381387696,
0.0275600608,
-0.0182672199,
0.0432149507,
-0.0268307589,
-0.0300956592,
-0.0692493021,
-0.016581947,
0.0400709361,
0.0163112897,
0.0364258252,
-0.0193803273,
-0.0000390177,
-0.0307972692,
0.0225723051,
-0.0049356967,
-0.0255103111,
0.0453569554,
0.014809466,
-0.0112903463,
-0.0239301119,
0.0639735833,
0.0107527785,
0.0377996564,
-0.0169743691,
0.0078802211,
-0.0367627405,
-0.0077863671,
0.0325482637,
-0.0204036161,
-0.0506447516,
0.0055940049,
-0.0261621531,
-0.0725058019,
-0.0133711491,
0.0532796569,
-0.0041925954,
0.0187990461,
0.0440871827,
0.016650755,
-0.0352074914,
-0.0290439669,
-0.00751743,
0.0196859408,
0.0329240113,
-0.0461728685,
-0.0386155285,
-6.34630739e-33,
-0.0287118927,
0.0132912351,
-0.0036752096,
-0.0627228394,
-0.0072293631,
-0.0213733278,
-0.0272241589,
-0.0123521583,
-0.008424242,
-0.0125163086,
-0.0170283411,
0.0084428927,
0.0262442995,
0.031996388,
-0.011445771,
-0.0380203873,
0.0547181629,
-0.0228811614,
-0.0295566265,
0.0115393121,
0.0291144066,
0.0361639783,
0.0340539925,
-0.0613996424,
0.0267354008,
-0.0050000204,
-0.0112875896,
0.0217665676,
-0.0253816452,
0.0498301797,
-0.0122154616,
0.0144336894,
-0.0152574806,
-0.0457871705,
-0.0235051233,
0.0229395796,
-0.071980156,
0.0007823271,
0.0304987915,
0.0282683522,
-0.0538431369,
-0.0601294376,
0.0227517709,
-0.0080043077,
-0.028789144,
0.000556071,
0.0018852525,
-0.0296747759,
0.0033899043,
0.0090124588,
-0.0484048612,
0.0113812201,
-0.0050728535,
-0.0383274816,
0.0356791317,
0.035230428,
0.011278416,
0.0189670399,
-0.0586333275,
-0.0026414294,
0.0451028645,
0.0366039015,
0.107844837,
0.0730807334,
-0.009833998,
0.0543045253,
0.014384089,
-0.0493062325,
0.0119942185,
-0.0195160881,
0.0141208181,
0.0175113566,
0.0388127789,
0.0673662201,
0.0388711728,
-0.0216512028,
-0.0655159131,
0.0288734511,
-0.0234702732,
0.0327905864,
0.0306923445,
0.0357196853,
-0.0538638905,
-0.0145035014,
-0.042757038,
-0.0753074437,
-0.0290946364,
-0.0191020723,
0.0390331782,
0.0103128701,
-0.050361108,
-0.0581423044,
0.0376425385,
-0.0268100593,
0.0231151544,
0.038140364,
0.0099403858,
-0.0125483936,
-0.021610463,
0.0436363667,
-0.0437828153,
-0.0234700367,
0.0323828757,
-0.015522561,
0.0281154197,
0.0121217519,
0.0189680997,
0.0155409127,
-0.0778928772,
0.0203491803,
-0.0345292017,
0.0343169868,
0.0277945474,
-0.0106695453,
0.0759781003,
-0.0143212397,
-0.0003946336,
0.0209844429,
0.0216950905,
-0.0112662809,
-0.0281424448,
-0.0088467747,
-0.0255280156,
0.0266231056,
-0.016495619,
0.01558284,
-0.0080209868,
0.0233910661,
0.0409108698,
-0.0537927523,
-0.0153013431,
0.0278276261,
2.523e-7,
0.0248891469,
0.0365024507,
0.0657214224,
0.0360838957,
0.0061261947,
0.0592790917,
-0.0380018428,
0.0436163396,
0.0122004403,
-0.0123562422,
0.0031461501,
0.0144885387,
0.078634508,
0.0470384695,
-0.0653311759,
0.0317218564,
-0.0840106085,
0.0577413328,
-0.0383938774,
0.0028848462,
0.0599834435,
0.1185130849,
-0.0131726759,
0.0003012709,
0.0194059014,
0.0018885619,
0.0162508283,
-0.0355734043,
0.0115738008,
0.0005477012,
-0.0086077591,
0.00006485,
-0.0006208275,
0.0149373617,
-0.0013602099,
-0.0161752813,
-0.0130111519,
0.0511048138,
0.0062577208,
-0.0488542505,
-0.0256681927,
-0.0045781904,
-0.0162956566,
-0.0291383807,
0.0455817468,
-0.0520546101,
-0.0055505945,
-0.0286326334,
-0.0334156454,
0.0010236437,
0.0070113977,
-0.0476444848,
-0.0163502041,
0.0217834655,
0.0342228748,
0.0281586759,
-0.0301907491,
-0.034388762,
-0.0246540029,
-0.0016549123,
-0.0184914768,
-0.0668431446,
-0.0264138654,
0.0502611175,
0.0034602471,
-0.0626146495,
0.0063060024,
2.34541245e-34,
0.0209460277,
-0.025596438,
0.0135995848,
0.0110666323,
0.0247720592,
-0.0176964272,
-0.0285305679,
0.0306070168,
0.0234913193,
-0.0543577857,
-0.0381865092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16732v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16732v2 | CLIMATELI: Evaluating Entity Linking on Climate Change Data | 2024-06-24T15:36:00 | 2024-06-27T14:44:51 | Shijia Zhou, Siyao Peng, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Climate Change (CC) is a pressing topic of global importance, attracting
increasing attention across research fields, from social sciences to Natural
Language Processing (NLP). CC is also discussed in various settings and
communication platforms, from academic publications to social media forums.
Understanding who and what is mentioned in such data is a first critical step
to gaining new insights into CC. We present CLIMATELI (CLIMATe Entity LInking),
the first manually annotated CC dataset that links 3,087 entity spans to
Wikipedia. Using CLIMATELI (CLIMATe Entity LInking), we evaluate existing
entity linking (EL) systems on the CC topic across various genres and propose
automated filtering methods for CC entities. We find that the performance of EL
models notably lags behind humans at both token and entity levels. Testing
within the scope of retaining or excluding non-nominal and/or non-CC entities
particularly impacts the models' performances. | [
0.0337010473,
0.0562119298,
-0.0127328895,
0.0112594813,
0.0042692474,
0.0315146074,
-0.0198871959,
0.0231311787,
0.046565894,
-0.0535716377,
0.0392724574,
0.0470942222,
-0.0151490225,
-0.0149447853,
0.025982175,
-0.0647618249,
0.045537632,
0.0174549762,
-0.0080006989,
-0.0135437716,
-0.0066489209,
0.0015521031,
-0.0092367884,
-0.0028673715,
0.0010375325,
0.0046933857,
0.0162398387,
0.0270547234,
0.0572067536,
-0.021826392,
0.011386591,
0.052693896,
-0.0168503635,
0.0356579982,
0.0000018149,
-0.0573039278,
-0.0166049525,
-0.0184721909,
-0.022049142,
0.0259289015,
0.0254173335,
-0.0208502598,
-0.0029276195,
-0.0427555405,
-0.030512657,
0.0117219156,
0.0375948846,
0.0033436948,
0.0521739125,
0.0323288515,
0.0117656281,
-0.0257239193,
0.0137752881,
0.0021143898,
-0.0207772087,
0.0437867083,
0.0663178712,
-0.0355542637,
-0.0182864573,
0.0126110474,
-0.0025409341,
0.0820891187,
-0.0055879201,
0.0144420527,
0.0282296836,
0.0207562614,
-0.0608213134,
-0.0321119353,
0.0406989232,
0.0620943271,
0.0515107736,
-0.0293382946,
0.0375326537,
0.0406893343,
0.0036088214,
0.0403123833,
-0.0268932972,
-0.026249893,
0.000051913,
-0.0084104389,
0.0108563518,
-0.0018190205,
0.0163281392,
0.0598579831,
-0.0242910702,
0.0863100439,
0.0020383941,
-0.0372381397,
0.0214058962,
0.0073812935,
0.0311416667,
-0.0491336063,
0.0312232841,
-0.0099240448,
-0.0251152068,
0.0168548394,
-0.037317615,
0.0044935727,
0.0107002333,
-0.0475771055,
-0.0846405551,
-0.0144697521,
0.047706116,
0.0276112333,
0.0374115072,
-0.0263419244,
0.0040320107,
0.0160377212,
0.0368749164,
-0.0432061516,
-0.0564649627,
-0.0165357534,
-0.0027099305,
-0.0045147529,
-0.0284582004,
0.0377090201,
-0.0342963152,
-0.050129842,
-0.0327699073,
0.0470153019,
0.0086147096,
-0.0264249276,
0.0035496322,
0.0063731615,
-0.0316572897,
0.0273048859,
-0.0617083684,
0.0096684014,
-0.0024614302,
-0.0045243944,
0.0124553218,
-0.0167911556,
0.0255566407,
-0.028257424,
0.0022050072,
0.0550191328,
0.0741165727,
-0.008400972,
-0.02323406,
-0.0422413126,
0.0307934824,
-0.0308084097,
-0.0137255965,
-0.029898528,
-0.0063735675,
0.009974475,
0.0110687409,
-0.0950787738,
-0.0179832745,
-0.0063156872,
-0.0834758058,
0.0917575583,
-0.0708696768,
-0.0327400416,
0.0394431464,
0.0144126201,
0.020584967,
0.0657148883,
0.0562525801,
-0.0294826292,
0.0742109194,
0.0388338231,
-0.0364987962,
0.0099811703,
0.0613834821,
0.0286057461,
0.0114806835,
0.0084006423,
-0.0532810353,
0.0207465012,
0.0331278145,
0.0341020375,
-0.0077168993,
-0.0549836867,
0.0245560892,
0.0124912336,
-0.0102580469,
0.0349061713,
0.022685986,
0.0167627949,
0.0075927526,
-0.0027324695,
-0.0245420299,
0.0133487554,
-0.02703535,
-0.0379333794,
0.0123658041,
0.0314666517,
-0.0032207815,
0.0052342913,
-0.0022906833,
0.0235137679,
0.0053663864,
-0.0500828028,
0.0120537113,
-0.0175213683,
0.0021040062,
0.0712959319,
0.0269538816,
-0.0151267257,
0.0211810097,
0.028347332,
-0.0280978885,
0.0648210943,
-0.0091628134,
0.0326992869,
-0.0409559458,
-0.0269717257,
0.0187513009,
0.0277718846,
0.0126243811,
-0.0369401388,
-0.0416620746,
0.0012922152,
-0.0159219969,
0.0228644013,
0.0013972974,
-0.0124053573,
0.0325576179,
0.058141131,
0.0222870223,
-0.0506361052,
0.02266456,
0.0441476852,
-0.0097312909,
0.0068352725,
-0.0553824343,
0.0259007476,
-0.0046102046,
0.0268696584,
0.0205374993,
-0.0119122006,
0.0542550795,
-0.0185176805,
-0.0529691242,
0.0437335186,
0.0517198816,
-0.0145895192,
0.0470962264,
-0.0403355621,
-0.0288681015,
0.0304787681,
-0.0065081455,
-0.0353638045,
0.022059761,
0.0144299138,
0.0299816318,
0.0109722074,
-0.0396186523,
0.0105394246,
0.0366631635,
-0.0265721828,
0.0637679026,
-0.0260879286,
0.0140377562,
0.0371309407,
0.0113191875,
-0.0212833975,
-0.0427845567,
-0.0284671262,
0.0050063115,
0.0181779973,
-0.0287263915,
0.0057281754,
-0.0565364771,
-0.0956647769,
0.0210398939,
-0.0172815062,
0.0218788628,
-0.0089651858,
0.0416555144,
-0.006768038,
-0.0329969861,
-0.0395057537,
0.0401375256,
0.0560769252,
-0.037338499,
-0.0553847328,
0.0150722181,
0.0178737734,
0.0037034713,
0.0122882295,
-0.0642517135,
-0.0112633612,
-0.0381459221,
0.0901041329,
0.0291640069,
-0.101447247,
-0.0124646584,
0.0264559705,
-0.0440274812,
-0.031298846,
-0.0052335495,
0.0269893724,
-0.0268704649,
0.005868488,
0.0176225379,
0.0039203628,
0.0214427281,
0.0221704766,
-0.0325062126,
-0.0460218452,
-0.063634254,
0.029839417,
0.0258631874,
0.0318269022,
0.0012478109,
0.0055361865,
0.0265570432,
-0.009706893,
-0.0572764762,
0.0003227801,
0.0027067605,
0.0822445005,
-0.0415099077,
0.0026387288,
-0.025584314,
-0.0214859005,
-0.0209176447,
0.0311736669,
-0.0033557629,
-0.0092123533,
0.0168318283,
0.0294949412,
0.0482784659,
-0.0394933857,
-0.0046930253,
0.0170878824,
0.0211320836,
0.0229959227,
-0.0059170863,
0.0338808633,
0.0139334705,
0.0001108396,
0.0203139763,
0.0020853041,
-0.0046027862,
0.0005834782,
-0.0073468382,
0.0572741479,
0.0228958279,
0.0195189491,
-0.0042903316,
0.0118788686,
-0.049370829,
0.0214843303,
0.0063450662,
-0.0553670935,
-0.0314041562,
0.0212431587,
0.0172168352,
-0.0132226599,
0.0423476212,
-0.0410119109,
0.0262414087,
0.0091025904,
0.0203407127,
0.0167523716,
0.0341228917,
0.0352665074,
-0.0082088681,
0.0119093535,
0.0493397154,
-0.0321180783,
0.0038922266,
-0.0036353488,
-0.0058839601,
-0.0966287628,
-0.0290321689,
-0.0330323949,
0.0203532409,
-0.0577588081,
0.0218803454,
0.0873854011,
0.0365500487,
-0.0372725129,
0.0192670915,
0.0041263001,
0.0071370052,
0.0153645631,
0.0011206049,
-0.0686353669,
-0.0173707549,
0.0063790153,
-0.0198180936,
-0.0099282768,
-0.1131696105,
-0.005655922,
-0.0589924939,
0.0166617129,
-0.0248051248,
-0.0554824211,
-0.0167932883,
-0.1141066253,
0.0178673025,
-0.0475799516,
-0.0649750307,
-0.0151660629,
-0.0035113266,
0.028935777,
0.0151904989,
-0.0503119454,
-0.0590030737,
0.0209295992,
-0.0493727401,
0.0572995655,
0.0270750858,
0.0655569583,
-0.0139351785,
-0.0192239601,
0.0226689521,
-0.0427294411,
-0.0558557995,
-0.0186362565,
0.0502268784,
-0.0154052684,
0.0160065778,
-0.0156893879,
0.0190944616,
-0.0168486126,
-0.0340878814,
-0.0083408365,
0.0603750013,
0.0395799689,
0.0170315336,
-0.0186407957,
0.0096786404,
0.0260788184,
0.0553454123,
0.0145290382,
-0.00351981,
-0.0091431774,
-0.0632938147,
-0.0076192459,
-0.0286173206,
-0.0554894842,
-0.0036160885,
-0.0527674444,
-0.0288573764,
-0.0741031393,
-0.0616546795,
0.0369724222,
0.0262104627,
-0.0312760249,
0.0195800159,
0.0717600584,
0.0012122799,
-0.069974795,
0.0367308483,
-0.0421334356,
0.0469629951,
0.0106922388,
-0.0334789418,
0.0426277108,
0.0776620135,
-0.0264345743,
0.0487848744,
-0.0588613749,
-0.0563858971,
0.0080718482,
-0.0129124317,
0.0272656642,
0.0023565055,
0.0005305333,
-0.0341135152,
0.0209458265,
0.1103751957,
-0.0415544212,
0.0059964075,
-0.0132128168,
0.04292842,
0.0007306781,
0.050541997,
-0.0018942513,
-0.0200114045,
-0.0385614187,
0.0528738424,
-0.0580963716,
-0.0067558405,
-0.0157892611,
0.0076220967,
0.0090899784,
-0.0104501238,
-0.0218240991,
-0.014487531,
-0.001300099,
0.042328652,
-0.0156182339,
0.0174358077,
0.0083517302,
-0.0159171447,
0.037441384,
-0.056240283,
0.0450692996,
-0.0045295814,
0.01225622,
-0.0933637545,
0.0099736154,
-0.0087692533,
0.0511790216,
-0.0165257994,
-0.0157989413,
0.0253493935,
-0.0455413461,
0.0327318572,
0.0228312705,
-0.0346461087,
-0.0405595563,
0.0223769024,
0.0020130936,
-0.0266471393,
-0.0048804786,
-0.0492374077,
0.0234063994,
-0.006628233,
0.0464746393,
0.0190443899,
0.0327014625,
0.0640762597,
-0.0216200445,
-0.0525531657,
0.0284457933,
-0.017147135,
0.0109238196,
0.0091580981,
0.0493350588,
0.000693035,
-0.0440416411,
0.0428131372,
0.02019508,
0.0040349741,
0.0797571242,
0.009601716,
-0.0439633057,
-0.0285326224,
-0.023406785,
-0.0774186552,
-0.0446774513,
0.003404425,
-0.0072633633,
-0.0605508164,
-0.0486916564,
0.0543773137,
-0.0210125521,
-0.0208583418,
0.0007154772,
0.0191215482,
0.0005173204,
0.0362294316,
-0.0433649831,
0.0161218718,
-0.0009016768,
-0.0030194444,
-0.0419252589,
-0.0240524709,
-6.101811178e-33,
-0.0573697425,
-0.026306862,
0.015874913,
0.0223061629,
-0.0276524592,
0.0107489787,
0.0105475169,
0.0038929759,
-0.0506426357,
0.0185714923,
0.0050240345,
0.0125092752,
0.0130083356,
-0.0409499221,
0.0032698591,
-0.0244873967,
0.0423373096,
0.0171418581,
-0.0148510747,
-0.0156936049,
0.0579801351,
0.020969661,
0.052237127,
-0.1143191531,
0.0701533481,
0.0238275882,
-0.0231878292,
-0.0094639184,
0.013852302,
0.0496897735,
0.0089811655,
0.0493904129,
0.0077300677,
-0.0494495481,
-0.0102904085,
-0.0112463739,
-0.1347111464,
-0.0095162597,
0.0155513501,
0.0029939751,
0.0250125024,
-0.0293733124,
0.0531582125,
0.053135857,
0.0197826792,
0.0304423254,
0.0480589569,
0.0063538118,
-0.0328924432,
-0.0605968051,
-0.0214325525,
0.0619252287,
-0.0265405923,
0.0845911652,
-0.0396698564,
0.0078540286,
-0.0045898594,
0.0870836452,
-0.120209381,
0.0132625923,
0.0310897343,
0.0112146363,
0.006939678,
-0.0550404489,
0.0155278752,
0.0642753318,
-0.0139764585,
0.0220371448,
-0.065218918,
0.001636095,
0.0494742244,
-0.018719608,
-0.0035491895,
0.0969944298,
0.0235484019,
-0.040397495,
-0.0937289894,
0.0553371795,
0.0104440907,
0.0503428839,
-0.0232191924,
0.0019798521,
0.0175792407,
-0.0048751743,
-0.0488355905,
-0.0119144786,
-0.028460497,
0.0130163236,
-0.0081044622,
-0.0005231295,
-0.0571911745,
0.0578100644,
-0.0266104043,
-0.0302907974,
-0.0538864322,
0.033957202,
-0.0213793293,
0.0135801854,
0.0201932304,
0.0070817601,
-0.0683125183,
-0.0043819472,
-0.003902449,
0.0319500156,
0.011252299,
-0.0449432395,
0.0431073532,
0.0015059049,
-0.0369050875,
-0.0084409928,
0.0103783263,
-0.0256146435,
-0.038544029,
-0.0444355346,
-0.0053526522,
0.0284361765,
0.0180453714,
-0.0210118629,
0.079061918,
0.0154286306,
0.0212422274,
0.0119992997,
-0.0035138321,
0.0094571412,
0.007369522,
-0.0199066307,
0.001095933,
0.0153836673,
-0.0162449908,
-0.0792334452,
0.0050422647,
-0.0307134558,
2.557e-7,
0.0649238676,
0.0546504408,
-0.0213998333,
-0.0050817132,
-0.0113170268,
-0.0106370468,
0.0469885059,
0.0375896841,
-0.0192494746,
-0.0221777782,
-0.0488528349,
-0.0129942847,
0.0053427205,
0.0363991559,
-0.0584076643,
-0.0577044636,
-0.0076481625,
-0.0282165632,
-0.0656255782,
-0.0221682191,
0.0064825602,
0.0066049374,
0.0496249758,
0.0208521746,
-0.0152456909,
-0.0004604974,
0.0563021004,
-0.0590354465,
-0.0121344067,
-0.0033211487,
0.0274484027,
0.0027909288,
0.0114968186,
0.0592221543,
-0.037182115,
0.0165143367,
0.0149926972,
0.0153998351,
0.0526590832,
-0.0249629337,
0.0047498727,
-0.0642867982,
0.0163811669,
-0.0181158986,
0.0361367986,
-0.0006383246,
0.0033839957,
0.0549199879,
-0.0586851761,
0.050895188,
0.0147113195,
-0.0406921804,
-0.0346833542,
0.0203196909,
-0.0088819172,
0.0029818884,
-0.0081587667,
-0.0713905916,
-0.0070300666,
-0.0215349458,
-0.0099012526,
-0.0291817561,
-0.0018324381,
-0.0302035864,
0.0259268451,
-0.0003214586,
0.0088595636,
1.992509302e-34,
-0.0019015864,
0.0270749405,
-0.0443829671,
-0.0195842329,
0.0382232964,
-0.0144752134,
-0.0159274451,
0.0099924048,
-0.0033553026,
-0.0512630828,
0.0179465208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16722v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16722v1 | Venturing into Uncharted Waters: The Navigation Compass from Transformer to Mamba | 2024-06-24T15:27:21 | 2024-06-24T15:27:21 | Yuchen Zou, Yineng Chen, Zuchao Li, Lefei Zhang, Hai Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer, a deep neural network architecture, has long dominated the field
of natural language processing and beyond. Nevertheless, the recent
introduction of Mamba challenges its supremacy, sparks considerable interest
among researchers, and gives rise to a series of Mamba-based models that have
exhibited notable potential. This survey paper orchestrates a comprehensive
discussion, diving into essential research dimensions, covering: (i) the
functioning of the Mamba mechanism and its foundation on the principles of
structured state space models; (ii) the proposed improvements and the
integration of Mamba with various networks, exploring its potential as a
substitute for Transformers; (iii) the combination of Transformers and Mamba to
compensate for each other's shortcomings. We have also made efforts to
interpret Mamba and Transformer in the framework of kernel functions, allowing
for a comparison of their mathematical nature within a unified context. Our
paper encompasses the vast majority of improvements related to Mamba to date. | [
0.0576305687,
0.0456154905,
-0.0170548651,
0.0223908499,
-0.0365121663,
-0.0099750347,
-0.0332742035,
-0.0293599516,
-0.0186644923,
-0.0363118686,
-0.0384737104,
-0.0013287582,
0.0224928893,
0.0717890635,
0.018443631,
-0.0885403678,
0.032372091,
-0.0189845264,
-0.0252077896,
0.0212445017,
-0.0202628281,
-0.0150362607,
-0.0293020867,
0.0785922855,
-0.0358359404,
-0.0141993696,
-0.0230737869,
-0.026055431,
0.021002125,
-0.0296452828,
0.0151492385,
-0.0014005144,
-0.0105893053,
0.0240459982,
0.0000020063,
-0.0054106703,
0.0174791403,
-0.0109818438,
-0.0074072056,
-0.0167301465,
-0.0187708717,
-0.0476989821,
-0.0260962322,
0.0185794346,
-0.0413004085,
-0.0330330767,
0.0391697139,
0.067011863,
0.0444658473,
0.1199663356,
-0.0316436924,
-0.1060922071,
0.0470743813,
-0.0441288427,
-0.071940057,
-0.0165444985,
0.0441929512,
-0.0134002371,
-0.0079872245,
0.0021146783,
-0.057869982,
0.0514902472,
0.035083361,
-0.0099096429,
-0.0053875279,
0.0426163413,
-0.0040149027,
-0.0176012684,
-0.0174587443,
0.0606215596,
-0.032347694,
-0.0090163732,
0.0154447695,
-0.0090162819,
-0.0084826089,
0.0191913564,
-0.0026430045,
0.0022779899,
0.0256793965,
0.0438883863,
0.0253176522,
0.0198371187,
0.0567726381,
0.0049172025,
-0.0450762659,
0.0849635899,
0.0092901476,
-0.0290390868,
0.004689306,
-0.0176589806,
-0.006236223,
-0.0516675822,
0.0339541808,
0.0784179121,
0.0145847807,
0.0026786327,
-0.0188689083,
0.0018468528,
-0.0154571664,
-0.0215339623,
0.025396606,
0.0238537267,
-0.0280897412,
0.0228543058,
0.0167976804,
0.018939212,
-0.0934919193,
0.033625517,
-0.0273483116,
0.0243600104,
-0.0691551715,
-0.043525774,
-0.0219521467,
0.0175772924,
-0.0181830283,
-0.0419381447,
-0.0297580697,
0.0314945318,
0.0140913213,
-0.0333689377,
-0.0087629138,
0.0488567427,
0.0021833233,
0.0430238657,
-0.0179375373,
0.0849672258,
-0.0054239691,
0.0078021721,
-0.0112093911,
-0.0425969362,
0.0033670685,
0.0354841314,
-0.0129934233,
-0.0133486437,
0.0308237001,
0.0468255877,
0.0312101748,
-0.0385288559,
-0.0123755783,
0.0101915533,
-0.0398394763,
-0.0538384914,
0.0297178552,
-0.0514385737,
0.0175647717,
-0.0114040077,
0.0324264318,
-0.0009222687,
0.0155486865,
0.005244527,
-0.0226204842,
0.071257703,
0.0568608195,
-0.0100013185,
0.0476703122,
0.0011656875,
0.0379053503,
0.0139905289,
0.0584327951,
0.0279697012,
0.0078190975,
-0.0108345523,
0.0033018952,
0.0530353524,
-0.0190315396,
-0.0364639834,
-0.0312877819,
-0.0422962308,
-0.0774778873,
0.0095820902,
-0.0367674902,
0.0728751123,
-0.0116032558,
-0.002127138,
0.0467546731,
0.029278636,
0.0310742538,
0.049899172,
0.0585741065,
-0.0347500667,
0.0255076289,
0.0112015437,
-0.0021955466,
0.0041279807,
-0.0261641815,
-0.0360748582,
-0.0362468325,
0.0400553718,
-0.0273525957,
-0.054245729,
0.0138565376,
-0.0154067762,
-0.0404923707,
-0.0364055857,
0.0844551995,
0.010112416,
-0.051913552,
0.0460295379,
-0.0105006592,
0.0140402345,
0.0267709047,
-0.0426315144,
-0.0318817124,
0.0209259447,
0.0590973161,
-0.0145812891,
-0.0195590518,
-0.0229786355,
-0.05375164,
0.039292492,
0.0043187514,
-0.0120819584,
-0.0020374102,
-0.0451176092,
-0.0135153271,
0.0219226535,
0.0231947396,
-0.0104708252,
-0.0125882495,
0.0178961791,
0.0279351082,
0.0126772784,
0.0289205872,
0.0391376205,
0.05165077,
0.0009286255,
0.0114592295,
0.0140099218,
0.0798417628,
0.0113944728,
-0.0060278638,
0.0178608187,
0.0375105813,
-0.0582282506,
-0.018896902,
0.0284645688,
-0.0491149165,
-0.0451644845,
0.0125842886,
-0.0349763855,
0.0541267619,
0.1040147245,
-0.025837075,
-0.0720273703,
-0.0146669559,
-0.0504111201,
0.0340493396,
-0.0286442433,
0.0067751752,
0.0288769919,
0.0403792188,
-0.0405994579,
0.0731208771,
-0.0277884994,
-0.0174163599,
-0.0079398211,
-0.0168868192,
0.0104301935,
-0.0153997168,
-0.0501102917,
0.0165445823,
-0.0251511633,
-0.0099816369,
-0.0047021308,
-0.0348191783,
-0.0058552721,
-0.0435761288,
-0.0409357771,
0.0040797982,
-0.0353264101,
0.0054648952,
0.0076740799,
0.0171223767,
0.019416336,
0.0130200488,
-0.0302713718,
0.0184085164,
0.0531295575,
-0.0225797761,
0.0418698117,
0.0115789948,
-0.0735844523,
-0.0435041636,
-0.0592455193,
-0.0158649739,
0.0284434799,
-0.0070717731,
-0.0432585292,
-0.0310604703,
0.0151355928,
-0.0189308226,
0.0467437804,
-0.0528943166,
-0.0234457199,
-0.0214441102,
-0.0172886048,
0.0338540897,
0.0143732252,
0.0262187645,
0.0775480568,
0.0082123457,
0.009592942,
0.0275683273,
0.0247726291,
-0.0713535771,
0.0077493843,
-0.0642460734,
-0.0049869064,
0.0457957238,
0.0896768719,
0.0028579214,
0.0027114681,
-0.046250049,
-0.0429922082,
-0.0194758363,
-0.0370993353,
0.0405156054,
0.0032626174,
-0.0282376688,
0.0009864153,
-0.0381789729,
-0.0319851004,
0.0602597781,
-0.0246224124,
-0.0103755118,
-0.0121824378,
-0.0172286481,
-0.0359618515,
0.0414715856,
0.0585413836,
-0.015158318,
-0.0370539799,
-0.0232050736,
0.0013448884,
-0.0234750193,
-0.031526003,
-0.0169906262,
0.0322887897,
-0.002897785,
0.0202917196,
0.0040389504,
-0.0187718086,
-0.0341385454,
-0.0047907275,
-0.0198116191,
0.037792597,
0.0258930046,
0.0018551295,
-0.0510687977,
0.054237999,
-0.0139534064,
0.0146717811,
0.002346762,
-0.0126189161,
-0.0498903207,
0.0695924759,
0.0560457036,
0.0113738421,
0.0432224162,
-0.0063947216,
-0.0093035735,
0.0468490869,
0.0438011028,
0.0385233834,
-0.0428022109,
-0.0030673137,
0.0267859455,
-0.0186226126,
-0.04494844,
0.0048854072,
-0.0166153423,
-0.0588557646,
-0.0247597732,
0.076835826,
0.0330541246,
-0.0036615103,
0.0344288759,
0.0283167716,
0.0242049936,
-0.0126704769,
0.0107504288,
-0.0228872653,
-0.0196994506,
-0.003477392,
-0.0283637587,
-0.0230828188,
-0.0111649875,
0.0405592918,
-0.0647847727,
-0.0064915782,
-0.0121195652,
-0.0475627556,
-0.0340096615,
-0.0459524058,
0.0015350551,
-0.0181361809,
-0.0293236431,
0.0032559887,
0.0023990294,
-0.0303662252,
0.0586773269,
-0.0062081837,
-0.0552453771,
-0.0065455218,
-0.0350512676,
0.011582844,
0.0790394843,
0.0246087778,
-0.0416530333,
-0.0384857208,
-0.0184549857,
-0.0183113813,
0.001710696,
-0.0177780073,
-0.0186538398,
-0.0139296344,
-0.0599624775,
-0.010563734,
0.0212965906,
-0.0421746373,
0.000917402,
-0.052145388,
0.0727228299,
-0.0428636633,
0.0063183676,
-0.0423133783,
-0.0038837208,
-0.0126867378,
0.0368606038,
-0.0095542483,
-0.0310178921,
-0.0659630001,
0.0160187092,
0.029385075,
-0.0014457474,
-0.0386670269,
0.0030587106,
0.0207160767,
-0.0426845662,
-0.0607151948,
-0.0661963895,
-0.0087172631,
0.0272397473,
0.0243575349,
-0.0000317978,
0.0422550216,
-0.0204728656,
-0.048058603,
0.0141017176,
-0.0474781804,
0.0481586009,
-0.0439121835,
0.0086574275,
0.0489830375,
0.0005347308,
-0.059197817,
-0.012517496,
-0.0939242467,
-0.0540197566,
0.0335067697,
0.0556709133,
0.0246624965,
-0.0450434014,
-0.0257575624,
-0.0426089801,
0.0708627179,
0.0170163177,
-0.0256299265,
0.0306034535,
0.0528426245,
-0.0128961718,
0.0047798841,
0.0353704467,
-0.0100246146,
0.0364979208,
-0.0200582668,
0.0579486303,
-0.0111141242,
-0.0757679269,
-0.0059018023,
-0.0719685331,
0.0836617947,
0.0476971269,
-0.0111343032,
-0.0327873267,
0.008790588,
0.0222830344,
0.0156138511,
-0.0309640076,
-0.0254164506,
0.0610558577,
0.0811336786,
-0.0241301265,
-0.0014764693,
0.0137554929,
-0.0111738453,
0.0403129719,
0.0145310154,
0.101726748,
-0.0279464908,
0.0071694665,
0.0246719178,
-0.0178630874,
-0.0010994979,
0.0387219638,
0.0025540979,
-0.0051293527,
0.0711020902,
0.0256762132,
-0.0054102372,
-0.0526624992,
0.0323423333,
-0.0609892569,
0.0005087241,
-0.0123522747,
0.047685165,
0.0491074175,
-0.0392528102,
0.0472013243,
-0.0170974024,
0.0040064892,
-0.030136643,
0.0038122267,
0.0001568126,
-0.0172276013,
0.0517059341,
0.0137613472,
0.0007813161,
0.0256559066,
0.0275291502,
-0.0015800516,
0.0578350537,
0.0022970184,
0.0116260191,
-0.0312903821,
-0.012651098,
0.000679017,
-0.0057266355,
0.0029133924,
-0.0014463386,
-0.0616548844,
-0.0694218576,
0.0549781956,
-0.0020711988,
0.0370639227,
-0.0276129879,
0.0497649722,
0.0472056866,
0.0231084172,
-0.0019887162,
-0.0546861961,
-0.0493329652,
-0.0026858847,
-0.0136780245,
-0.0046154018,
-6.309478418e-33,
-0.0102721835,
-0.0336650051,
-0.0012441584,
0.042096626,
-0.0417349376,
-0.017855281,
-0.0124232974,
-0.0065225977,
-0.0424954332,
0.0006199333,
-0.0188071411,
0.0295912419,
0.0248456914,
0.0500173606,
-0.0117676016,
-0.0378956795,
0.0502557643,
0.0314691439,
0.0031054714,
-0.0163160078,
0.0227871183,
0.0458418615,
0.0336257443,
-0.035204336,
0.0188454259,
-0.0143369455,
0.0025567019,
0.045661062,
-0.0456251092,
0.0743493736,
-0.0606216192,
0.0298489705,
0.0428210646,
-0.0039242837,
0.021045683,
0.0143561335,
-0.072478056,
0.0042665233,
0.0018503068,
0.0260052923,
-0.0451162457,
0.0027378772,
0.0897123665,
-0.0113908825,
0.013842877,
0.0093574496,
0.0553118363,
-0.0034255004,
-0.0144611429,
-0.0050798119,
-0.0453403406,
0.0204259567,
-0.0156179303,
-0.0353389159,
0.025710091,
0.053826984,
-0.0085424585,
-0.0290145501,
-0.0428691842,
-0.0007047812,
0.0102204531,
0.049551744,
0.0354234613,
0.066484496,
-0.0038597009,
0.0322488658,
0.0401690342,
-0.0701665133,
-0.0328372978,
-0.0386805981,
0.0259338357,
0.0284766126,
0.0350648239,
-0.0290032905,
0.0062037045,
-0.0481671244,
-0.0800397322,
-0.0050549838,
-0.0106459698,
0.0695501715,
-0.0169774964,
0.0006699042,
-0.0551114045,
-0.00814432,
-0.0091451649,
-0.0508214422,
-0.0103902053,
-0.010080969,
0.0203267746,
0.0373018272,
-0.0298230629,
0.0676622987,
0.0267133955,
-0.0420914032,
0.0378964357,
-0.0219470952,
0.0238651969,
0.0625742078,
0.005810427,
0.0004502083,
-0.0776261911,
-0.0256611165,
0.0050962656,
-0.0139524341,
0.0028323049,
-0.0181695577,
0.0143979425,
0.0549522974,
-0.0528627709,
-0.027879471,
-0.0275325477,
-0.0046689175,
-0.024480192,
0.0497450642,
0.060420543,
0.0158158988,
-0.0152359735,
0.0141638117,
0.0254529864,
0.0098432489,
-0.0071476912,
0.0326037034,
0.0161825698,
0.0273353532,
-0.0276246704,
-0.018511489,
-0.0265923068,
0.0486482978,
0.0067876023,
-0.1031325981,
-0.0027076753,
0.0015752603,
2.811e-7,
0.0389650017,
0.0124900993,
0.0565072037,
-0.028118534,
0.0503104217,
0.0216994453,
-0.0002672329,
0.0255726818,
-0.0150022209,
0.00401974,
0.0205818024,
-0.0110964943,
0.0154996831,
-0.0058231982,
-0.0650276691,
-0.0123390043,
-0.0421842411,
-0.0118135409,
-0.0225457978,
-0.0031611943,
0.0433521457,
0.1118906885,
0.0365905464,
-0.048729416,
-0.0256743282,
-0.0220050253,
0.0759046823,
0.0196973421,
0.0187242068,
0.0142940646,
0.0310652517,
0.0369128436,
-0.0206685513,
-0.0106289564,
0.025071241,
0.0548056923,
0.0193719491,
0.0905690938,
-0.0065913079,
-0.0352672897,
0.0037014917,
0.0203163326,
-0.0164740663,
-0.0187692288,
0.078966707,
-0.0688748062,
-0.0329659805,
-0.0313778371,
-0.0095600039,
0.0400175638,
0.0050015226,
0.0220617354,
-0.0452973023,
0.0062417905,
0.0119302087,
-0.0015989384,
-0.0116836242,
-0.0678481013,
0.0012003302,
-0.0301115047,
-0.0545585752,
0.0110166837,
-0.049215164,
-0.0300100204,
0.0198147129,
-0.0094697904,
-0.04965882,
2.611192412e-34,
0.0033598095,
-0.0252627879,
0.0110263079,
0.0152681572,
-0.0281835031,
0.0062069632,
-0.0150937298,
-0.0060754218,
-0.0052574882,
-0.0898634568,
-0.0295031574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16714v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16714v1 | AutoDetect: Towards a Unified Framework for Automated Weakness Detection in Large Language Models | 2024-06-24T15:16:45 | 2024-06-24T15:16:45 | Jiale Cheng, Yida Lu, Xiaotao Gu, Pei Ke, Xiao Liu, Yuxiao Dong, Hongning Wang, Jie Tang, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Although Large Language Models (LLMs) are becoming increasingly powerful,
they still exhibit significant but subtle weaknesses, such as mistakes in
instruction-following or coding tasks. As these unexpected errors could lead to
severe consequences in practical deployments, it is crucial to investigate the
limitations within LLMs systematically. Traditional benchmarking approaches
cannot thoroughly pinpoint specific model deficiencies, while manual
inspections are costly and not scalable. In this paper, we introduce a unified
framework, AutoDetect, to automatically expose weaknesses in LLMs across
various tasks. Inspired by the educational assessment process that measures
students' learning outcomes, AutoDetect consists of three LLM-powered agents:
Examiner, Questioner, and Assessor. The collaboration among these three agents
is designed to realize comprehensive and in-depth weakness identification. Our
framework demonstrates significant success in uncovering flaws, with an
identification success rate exceeding 30% in prominent models such as ChatGPT
and Claude. More importantly, these identified weaknesses can guide specific
model improvements, proving more effective than untargeted data augmentation
methods like Self-Instruct. Our approach has led to substantial enhancements in
popular LLMs, including the Llama series and Mistral-7b, boosting their
performance by over 10% across several benchmarks. Code and data are publicly
available at https://github.com/thu-coai/AutoDetect. | [
0.0029885396,
0.0678001791,
-0.0396132618,
0.0641787872,
-0.0227628276,
0.0035690081,
-0.0073356791,
-0.01653721,
0.0355563685,
-0.0430994108,
-0.0003937699,
-0.0073304218,
-0.0122666247,
0.0185554475,
0.038521748,
-0.0316481963,
0.0547717027,
-0.0616350733,
-0.0387843624,
0.0135104107,
0.0076786522,
-0.0013935723,
-0.014097672,
0.0465660132,
0.0368674695,
-0.0436581448,
-0.0264898222,
-0.0263260566,
-0.0067240479,
-0.0615480207,
0.0114724357,
0.0654328763,
-0.0187937487,
0.0465431549,
0.0000023695,
-0.0469265543,
-0.0210743379,
-0.008326917,
-0.0133963851,
0.0730732307,
0.0184812862,
-0.0013135517,
-0.0353436023,
0.0429048873,
-0.0256329272,
-0.0161964409,
0.0323109217,
-0.0170783773,
0.0858861879,
0.0522960648,
0.0201594662,
0.0395693853,
0.0150664095,
0.0090576168,
-0.0097404541,
-0.0379798748,
0.0086667882,
0.0048291888,
0.0339554772,
0.0060587302,
-0.0273338053,
0.0289536938,
0.0337591022,
-0.0265744831,
-0.0097303148,
0.0155868195,
-0.0512778759,
-0.0236121025,
-0.0158844218,
0.0633667484,
-0.0358317271,
-0.0300622433,
-0.0115581444,
-0.0066923937,
-0.0061306371,
0.0024448065,
-0.0284118466,
0.0035132521,
0.0059035267,
-0.0020477043,
0.0244495235,
-0.0334242173,
0.0249075405,
-0.0147470357,
0.0065232557,
0.0402981602,
0.0199369378,
-0.0275774579,
-0.0176423956,
0.0200991314,
-0.0109894183,
-0.0522938706,
0.0006974664,
0.0404244326,
-0.0369628184,
0.0351730324,
-0.0319847912,
-0.0200625025,
0.0395370573,
-0.0495538972,
0.0157929026,
0.050396841,
-0.0439241864,
0.0489746965,
-0.0234708954,
0.1056889147,
0.0196752772,
0.0172221977,
-0.0205399748,
0.024619747,
-0.0279948544,
-0.0035722423,
-0.0276897568,
0.0113409255,
0.038666293,
0.0024883742,
-0.0245232005,
0.0511635058,
-0.0272545759,
0.0414183252,
-0.0167640243,
-0.0362699479,
0.0023869833,
0.0167915802,
-0.0029193501,
0.0386798047,
-0.0079172719,
-0.0275099128,
0.0004416099,
-0.0886875242,
-0.0069930791,
0.010506345,
-0.0451132618,
-0.0203959383,
0.0064545474,
0.0797204599,
0.0088403001,
-0.0209738575,
-0.0518474542,
-0.017427668,
-0.011290458,
-0.0575063415,
-0.0174483191,
-0.085020721,
-0.0324294493,
0.0256962385,
-0.0009380122,
-0.0265874248,
0.0230919626,
0.0048535704,
0.0222954396,
0.0507414863,
-0.0378769152,
0.0174121521,
0.0076702009,
0.03761971,
-0.0160926096,
0.0985311419,
0.0055093043,
-0.0015722165,
0.0357008763,
-0.0170717109,
0.0559167564,
0.0681938231,
0.0079052849,
0.0460402854,
0.0091262748,
-0.021141706,
0.0125058126,
0.0118011879,
0.0037969449,
0.0497093983,
0.0064250808,
0.0089499438,
0.0536948852,
0.0231833644,
-0.0230044257,
-0.0046662255,
0.0126205413,
0.0182052646,
0.0361976139,
-0.0041571544,
-0.0473994091,
0.0073792264,
-0.0346963592,
-0.0048009502,
-0.0183237791,
0.0408489816,
-0.0083236024,
-0.0778615922,
-0.0470974557,
-0.00512193,
-0.0109109525,
0.0286447853,
0.0646398738,
0.0010976968,
-0.0285706762,
0.034780059,
0.0181482155,
-0.0553337932,
-0.0080273477,
-0.0998067558,
0.0309266374,
0.0769594759,
0.0852258354,
-0.04478186,
-0.066781044,
0.0070082815,
0.0140706347,
-0.0001055544,
0.045409888,
-0.0301421918,
-0.0042574136,
-0.0267916508,
-0.0358036458,
0.010220632,
0.0348318182,
0.0234166086,
-0.0013337597,
0.0089330235,
0.0028618816,
-0.0395942591,
-0.0599890351,
0.0410311073,
-0.032981921,
-0.0325727724,
-0.0314181596,
0.0081827044,
-0.0029252775,
0.003127258,
-0.006621391,
-0.0027861956,
0.026397489,
-0.0036186718,
0.0227541421,
0.0075386479,
-0.0378345922,
-0.0239841565,
0.0622427911,
-0.0042616944,
-0.0400484502,
0.0686432943,
-0.0424826443,
-0.0391230546,
0.0378209837,
-0.0399145,
0.0108451601,
0.0017240416,
0.0743970349,
-0.0454912335,
-0.0040725474,
-0.0212276187,
0.0339672528,
-0.0077497819,
0.0262362771,
0.0249915272,
0.0521072634,
0.0238304865,
-0.0197648704,
-0.0700481907,
0.0101148477,
-0.0230220873,
0.0454801358,
0.014514708,
0.034625724,
-0.0395772234,
-0.0066099768,
-0.0812922344,
0.0015424973,
-0.0240173247,
0.0291666165,
0.0155861694,
0.0034458223,
-0.0225724299,
-0.0141976122,
-0.0065072207,
-0.0232713316,
0.0243847072,
0.0225108415,
0.0133873466,
-0.0176992808,
-0.0514890142,
-0.070399709,
-0.0152011057,
-0.0408496857,
0.0208222438,
0.0071009421,
0.001582268,
-0.0596560687,
0.058188796,
0.0142733064,
0.0320768729,
-0.002759824,
-0.0761976019,
0.0190724116,
-0.0302111525,
0.0166457966,
0.0731176138,
-0.0313080661,
0.0561759286,
0.0772985294,
-0.0179478638,
-0.0656776354,
0.0041914997,
0.0179852787,
-0.027842015,
-0.0218491703,
-0.0291895475,
-0.0255198274,
0.093141064,
-0.0086668963,
-0.0349711739,
-0.0187218804,
0.0096297245,
-0.0616258457,
0.0201815795,
-0.0118891094,
-0.0233435109,
-0.0098349471,
0.0250844937,
-0.0107552782,
-0.0498219021,
0.0696112365,
-0.0566156097,
-0.000294137,
-0.0532409772,
-0.0260382406,
-0.0428337082,
0.0528813787,
0.0103220195,
0.0031442421,
0.0152768884,
-0.039377328,
-0.0319455601,
0.0164801925,
0.0319107361,
-0.0357104763,
0.0264667962,
-0.0796276852,
-0.0056879614,
0.0121528357,
-0.043184679,
-0.0610013306,
0.012709314,
-0.0422575362,
-0.0090976311,
0.0155578107,
-0.0142450137,
-0.0068333456,
-0.0105134109,
-0.0118135884,
0.0428956561,
-0.0123995757,
-0.0088441456,
-0.0155634014,
0.0124787232,
0.0058251037,
-0.0415020399,
0.0317970887,
-0.0721112266,
0.0500672497,
0.0477109849,
0.0643942878,
0.0110558346,
-0.0456327721,
-0.0025131055,
0.0401392467,
-0.027176464,
-0.0018165376,
0.0184223801,
0.0602043942,
-0.0928613394,
-0.0343389586,
0.1145999655,
0.0335316435,
-0.0420124382,
0.0090420023,
-0.036615897,
0.0407148413,
0.0437946245,
0.0279373284,
-0.0845826119,
-0.0306072943,
0.0153522892,
0.0459672883,
-0.0084884819,
0.0053199087,
0.0140065802,
-0.1215549856,
0.029861968,
0.0056964578,
-0.0124062793,
0.0022841746,
-0.0472967513,
-0.0036515372,
-0.0333727039,
0.0590510629,
0.0107676312,
0.0016542089,
0.0085021909,
0.0293214992,
-0.078134127,
-0.0690627769,
0.0518099628,
-0.0311600994,
0.0841707587,
0.0646052063,
0.0113697993,
-0.0019565402,
-0.0172355231,
0.0695333481,
-0.0069476822,
-0.0145295048,
0.0064678206,
0.046990037,
0.0200319886,
-0.0276503284,
0.0089498926,
0.0081801163,
-0.0146663301,
0.0236838702,
0.0428829417,
0.0821049511,
-0.0000097025,
0.0005782764,
-0.0262882635,
-0.0336514376,
0.0169834811,
0.0629869998,
0.049185887,
-0.0313321725,
-0.0518919863,
-0.0462857708,
-0.017679587,
-0.0506442077,
-0.0407681428,
0.0222023744,
0.0119564021,
-0.0263822954,
-0.0362783261,
-0.0490064695,
0.0418410338,
0.0062186285,
0.0206180848,
-0.0160193872,
-0.0051625287,
0.014116466,
-0.024116762,
0.0256262161,
-0.0020788915,
0.0212144572,
-0.0985842049,
-0.0064181462,
-0.0009256387,
0.0072129122,
-0.0143246623,
0.0235219374,
-0.1173720509,
-0.0941526592,
0.0248505417,
0.074333176,
0.0222006068,
0.0209340081,
-0.0414891429,
-0.0608895123,
0.0291797258,
0.0017859257,
-0.0431513861,
-0.0062656086,
0.029151177,
-0.0510936789,
-0.0057192063,
0.0129544418,
-0.0360449702,
0.0110447193,
-0.0141793685,
0.0203757863,
-0.0324908979,
0.0088744964,
0.0150370002,
0.0339080729,
0.0308742151,
-0.005673381,
-0.0008191761,
-0.0444762595,
0.0050132242,
-0.0159259606,
-0.0124646518,
-0.0395577177,
0.042530641,
0.0207395237,
-0.0254999325,
0.0245687105,
-0.020559838,
-0.0094764987,
0.0417932384,
-0.0118474243,
0.06488242,
0.0136701912,
0.0224655401,
0.0647834167,
-0.0045973491,
-0.001692889,
0.012854333,
0.0103217419,
0.0564064272,
-0.0045453282,
0.0455164872,
-0.0158921499,
-0.0118288966,
0.0408382751,
0.0347127765,
-0.0274959095,
-0.0642713159,
-0.019281147,
0.055619847,
0.0467262603,
0.0217741691,
0.0590848699,
-0.0359989703,
0.0050324085,
-0.0229087435,
0.0035758037,
-0.0352834426,
-0.0296774376,
0.0224519204,
0.0331369266,
0.0076441402,
-0.0048934957,
0.0685437024,
0.0200287905,
0.0475399531,
0.0167631954,
0.0048720445,
-0.0350127891,
0.0029969281,
0.0319464132,
0.0003175226,
-0.0427472368,
-0.009172366,
-0.0523026101,
-0.0745307803,
-0.0108172968,
0.0517594218,
-0.0036851284,
-0.0158009566,
-0.0007969061,
0.0703056455,
-0.0008818411,
0.0287613831,
-0.0496970043,
-0.0179909319,
-0.005403915,
-0.0205774009,
-0.0003244231,
-6.342065325e-33,
-0.0352917761,
-0.0433555208,
0.0173759535,
-0.0107054384,
0.0101304669,
0.0164627209,
-0.0726767182,
0.0331321098,
-0.0124305263,
-0.005335839,
0.0135923149,
0.0232082289,
0.004303596,
-0.0090241991,
0.0453715138,
0.0219508037,
0.0579218827,
0.0248297825,
-0.0405583903,
0.038046591,
0.0028049243,
0.0070203911,
0.0551983863,
-0.0422436334,
0.0087281102,
-0.0209166836,
-0.011998455,
0.033896625,
-0.0283339228,
0.0711301565,
-0.0067661186,
0.0395865813,
-0.000983978,
-0.0292543694,
-0.0291663278,
-0.0397011787,
-0.0327594765,
-0.0503109954,
-0.0105480803,
0.050058838,
-0.026493242,
-0.031481009,
0.0313508362,
-0.0069865072,
-0.0235793069,
0.0045669619,
0.043100439,
-0.0052870791,
-0.0061586807,
0.0172169395,
-0.0582384393,
0.0447050221,
-0.0439721569,
-0.0407749824,
0.0010729368,
0.0492073335,
0.0012851771,
-0.0220819879,
-0.0397126824,
0.0251985285,
0.0544215851,
0.0603442453,
0.1085517555,
0.0129725691,
-0.0366308056,
0.0600887462,
0.0403512903,
0.024260385,
0.035472203,
-0.0047881026,
0.0667914748,
0.0201006308,
0.0765569434,
0.0245840196,
0.0144560337,
-0.0048240968,
-0.0286632944,
0.0283885878,
0.0490541123,
0.0262375306,
0.0082427682,
0.0096347919,
-0.0822166204,
-0.0288658962,
-0.0315112919,
-0.0079850741,
-0.0284300726,
-0.0342017785,
0.048847951,
-0.0144173698,
-0.0344689414,
-0.0289685801,
0.0364997797,
-0.0422574654,
-0.0321295559,
0.0172993857,
-0.0393409133,
0.035812825,
-0.0415087305,
0.0565467663,
-0.0324308313,
-0.0285382643,
-0.026003236,
0.0073183891,
0.0515886061,
0.0093956245,
0.0055391528,
0.0327175446,
-0.0621398501,
0.0054202206,
-0.0426720828,
0.0132691562,
0.0067321756,
0.0329354592,
0.0101272305,
-0.0385135673,
-0.0053239372,
0.0646822751,
0.0315371864,
-0.0190457609,
-0.0717094988,
0.0122467866,
-0.0106205214,
-0.0143762454,
-0.0317947567,
-0.033727061,
-0.0679153129,
0.035644237,
0.0137995938,
-0.0613868609,
-0.0030995114,
-0.0121563515,
2.915e-7,
0.0124231866,
0.059048228,
0.0052216328,
-0.0029847601,
-0.0140028456,
0.0438528396,
-0.0504771881,
-0.0142635796,
0.018350631,
0.0126863774,
-0.0076525966,
0.0266782288,
0.0552453212,
0.0591886267,
-0.0653409362,
0.040860191,
-0.0498486198,
-0.0061633866,
-0.0660666227,
-0.0115573192,
0.0254807696,
0.0784612224,
0.0045098891,
-0.0063522379,
-0.0038994052,
-0.0477265045,
-0.0041234642,
0.0051253298,
-0.0237020031,
0.0455179326,
0.0217612162,
0.036083281,
-0.0083443532,
-0.0074465564,
-0.0237762164,
-0.0241413116,
-0.0240549296,
0.0169092938,
-0.0028958833,
0.0003851987,
0.0272896271,
-0.028223535,
-0.0090719732,
-0.0446504503,
0.0625649691,
-0.0062426049,
0.0033457628,
-0.0232141539,
0.0020688102,
-0.0520385727,
0.0168346185,
-0.019155642,
-0.0177967455,
0.0226918645,
-0.0131445937,
-0.0553239249,
-0.0182575975,
-0.0504332334,
-0.0308671463,
0.0000962389,
-0.0133033693,
-0.0509792976,
-0.0248449575,
-0.00153921,
-0.011010482,
-0.0495814979,
0.0156324822,
3.041441023e-34,
0.0459571294,
-0.0184021853,
0.0275159739,
0.0377497599,
0.0331449546,
0.0090365037,
-0.0220803078,
0.0118843298,
0.0065035271,
-0.0168566499,
-0.0268959403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16694v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16694v1 | Task Oriented In-Domain Data Augmentation | 2024-06-24T14:58:11 | 2024-06-24T14:58:11 | Xiao Liang, Xinyu Hu, Simiao Zuo, Yeyun Gong, Qiang Lou, Yi Liu, Shao-Lun Huang, Jian Jiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown superior performance in various
applications and fields. To achieve better performance on specialized domains
such as law and advertisement, LLMs are often continue pre-trained on in-domain
data. However, existing approaches suffer from two major issues. First,
in-domain data are scarce compared with general domain-agnostic data. Second,
data used for continual pre-training are not task-aware, such that they may not
be helpful to downstream applications. We propose TRAIT, a task-oriented
in-domain data augmentation framework. Our framework is divided into two parts:
in-domain data selection and task-oriented synthetic passage generation. The
data selection strategy identifies and selects a large amount of in-domain data
from general corpora, and thus significantly enriches domain knowledge in the
continual pre-training data. The synthetic passages contain guidance on how to
use domain knowledge to answer questions about downstream tasks. By training on
such passages, the model aligns with the need of downstream applications. We
adapt LLMs to two domains: advertisement and math. On average, TRAIT improves
LLM performance by 8% in the advertisement domain and 7.5% in the math domain. | [
0.0289611388,
0.061287161,
-0.0143405441,
0.0417760387,
-0.0141314706,
0.0243010111,
0.0296054482,
-0.0253531579,
0.0257068705,
-0.0769909322,
-0.0581751578,
-0.0515132807,
-0.040456064,
0.0233627036,
0.0535249561,
-0.0331182927,
0.030423319,
-0.0427131355,
-0.0011893162,
0.0044645183,
0.0005569405,
0.0094762677,
0.0112056173,
0.0055609122,
0.0159036089,
-0.0435559601,
0.0168844424,
-0.0140778245,
0.0009334654,
-0.0123781301,
0.0672416389,
0.0636357591,
0.0565964878,
-0.0027350029,
0.0000020774,
-0.0541311502,
0.000867678,
0.0042324965,
-0.0607383177,
0.0340055563,
0.0391386449,
-0.0201710574,
0.0099406671,
0.0155223208,
-0.0609108508,
-0.0176757332,
0.0113839805,
0.032984782,
0.0482019186,
0.1026890352,
-0.007354504,
-0.0348404907,
0.0406332612,
-0.0750009865,
0.0080385711,
-0.052695144,
0.0386802331,
0.0136996452,
0.0170628615,
0.0341645069,
-0.0282859113,
0.010997924,
0.046735622,
-0.013997308,
0.0309356749,
0.0016698109,
-0.003366044,
0.0305384062,
-0.0045602978,
0.0677972957,
-0.0213627368,
-0.0174346454,
-0.009474772,
-0.0029433998,
0.033139877,
-0.0015459175,
-0.0400240794,
0.0078877499,
0.0240346827,
0.0014650265,
0.0149028478,
-0.0056580505,
0.0293528456,
0.0281009544,
-0.0426293612,
0.0317389965,
0.0181550048,
-0.0343575813,
0.0158734042,
0.0330292769,
-0.0658524334,
-0.0594807975,
0.0078624263,
-0.0006351296,
-0.0346565843,
0.0264417008,
-0.0891116485,
-0.0756659061,
-0.0150650954,
-0.041738648,
0.0609834418,
0.0181685183,
-0.0161370952,
0.0361863971,
-0.0221131425,
0.0294216853,
-0.0118504176,
0.0004451404,
-0.0630852282,
0.00009335,
-0.0352784656,
-0.000743982,
-0.0482422635,
0.0422213152,
-0.0863820314,
0.0098689981,
-0.0201034248,
0.0351801515,
-0.0220159236,
-0.0206011515,
0.0268365014,
-0.0168904345,
-0.0401501879,
-0.0387707651,
-0.0136021161,
-0.0006689908,
-0.0223280359,
0.0292993747,
0.0023500491,
-0.0326611511,
-0.0053777806,
0.0193717033,
-0.0068411827,
-0.0448967591,
-0.0005714018,
0.0796493441,
-0.0219405778,
-0.0311320629,
-0.0432457142,
-0.0269176792,
-0.0015856628,
-0.0844060406,
-0.0026633111,
-0.0429306664,
0.0166449845,
0.0061516403,
-0.015844943,
-0.0664749444,
0.0126590729,
0.0203294083,
-0.0063222605,
0.0480101854,
0.0022829918,
-0.0050806417,
-0.0115846274,
0.0052348324,
0.0265636314,
0.0930520147,
0.0195431672,
0.000978609,
0.0224441737,
0.0005322084,
-0.0077972589,
0.0489261895,
0.030671604,
0.021005949,
0.0070233978,
0.033875037,
0.0403337553,
0.020126462,
0.0360667631,
-0.004115168,
-0.0331765898,
0.0149580883,
0.0616293922,
0.0156002222,
0.0427727886,
0.0018906239,
0.0517299138,
0.02072349,
0.0103991302,
0.01243944,
-0.0669065788,
-0.0002201049,
0.0039053536,
0.0073536676,
0.0019440333,
0.0343309492,
-0.0280688629,
-0.0543789342,
0.0088775689,
-0.0070672478,
0.0129650142,
0.0463322215,
0.0597190745,
0.0439496487,
-0.0347998962,
0.0399472825,
0.0224312637,
-0.0251968596,
0.0185244735,
0.0019048001,
-0.0042453287,
0.0595195293,
0.0432680547,
-0.0430656075,
-0.0563532189,
-0.0255521759,
0.0595075302,
0.0497868434,
0.0515654236,
-0.0288515314,
-0.0028011922,
-0.0712165982,
-0.0414065905,
-0.037376903,
0.0270995665,
0.0140921837,
0.0445650965,
0.0143483458,
0.0464605987,
-0.0701105744,
-0.0315764658,
0.0262319371,
-0.0825907513,
-0.0390377752,
0.0214367602,
-0.0027169115,
-0.0033280964,
0.0156511869,
-0.0015452323,
0.0068192626,
0.0074629905,
-0.0447840914,
0.0103464443,
0.0046752892,
-0.0492899045,
-0.0222568158,
0.041811116,
-0.0146990232,
-0.0359775685,
0.0287992992,
-0.0465385988,
-0.0207440183,
-0.0102955764,
-0.0452791154,
0.0284238365,
-0.0406482033,
0.0191894397,
0.0093896398,
0.0083745895,
-0.0313685946,
0.0503330231,
0.035717722,
-0.0096909842,
0.0115664769,
0.0139139798,
0.0128500713,
-0.008743708,
0.0028321517,
-0.0381709822,
-0.0050772568,
0.0187827945,
0.0077554546,
0.0102040395,
-0.0385870785,
0.013023288,
-0.062522456,
0.0237591378,
-0.0329475291,
0.0355396867,
-0.0011698559,
0.0263900179,
-0.0219709799,
-0.0208448879,
-0.039483536,
-0.0181009453,
-0.0118248397,
0.004252946,
0.0077778921,
0.0057734945,
0.0156279672,
-0.0168101285,
-0.0006487872,
0.0131622488,
0.0161173344,
0.0109969871,
-0.008645908,
-0.0720886812,
0.0752226338,
0.0039742929,
0.025930671,
-0.0104534207,
0.0064942841,
-0.0540441163,
-0.0061395355,
0.0656098425,
0.0422579944,
-0.0055994331,
-0.0066227438,
0.0144186839,
0.0059096408,
-0.045277223,
0.0181449857,
-0.0013369544,
0.0097759999,
-0.0586736426,
0.013905325,
0.033139132,
0.0598603487,
-0.0444773845,
-0.0467158593,
-0.0154254716,
0.0040085474,
-0.0390461832,
-0.0260831546,
-0.021954583,
0.0141773336,
-0.023078762,
0.0357408784,
-0.0189605448,
-0.0381203629,
0.0676932409,
0.0116523989,
-0.0141888084,
-0.0851696059,
0.0064109783,
-0.0471320003,
0.0459451638,
0.0039110496,
-0.0183847789,
0.027689781,
-0.044984594,
-0.0475176126,
0.022641927,
0.0377077758,
-0.0274093822,
0.1045685261,
-0.048351638,
0.0267188977,
-0.0296260118,
-0.0603709929,
-0.0675400123,
-0.0505462438,
0.0081835818,
0.002778962,
0.0094820177,
0.0063401279,
-0.0340156965,
-0.0194004513,
-0.0037451035,
0.0728159323,
-0.0416186415,
0.0028021296,
-0.0277583394,
0.0358136147,
0.0679768026,
0.040107999,
-0.0275208615,
-0.0570818,
-0.0108377729,
0.017581258,
0.0113460645,
-0.0360431522,
0.0016735983,
0.0028280846,
0.0335759595,
-0.0552730598,
-0.0180516802,
0.0243937392,
0.0445529893,
-0.0695700347,
-0.0201853067,
0.1038294733,
0.0181375965,
-0.0246523321,
-0.01349492,
0.0021785763,
0.0040205303,
0.0318170264,
0.0415319018,
-0.0976551548,
-0.0285891425,
0.002249541,
-0.0048418022,
0.0338158645,
-0.0164860711,
-0.0168902464,
-0.144070223,
0.0560494252,
0.0094893873,
0.0100065358,
-0.0367030129,
-0.0250154939,
0.0144832768,
-0.0080700899,
0.0274627358,
-0.0185417011,
-0.0289328787,
0.0002067079,
0.0327286683,
0.0259681437,
-0.0648786053,
-0.0093275951,
-0.0316531472,
0.0194472857,
0.0395714715,
0.0137611106,
0.0006883724,
-0.0127408495,
0.0422210284,
0.0045828577,
-0.0112729557,
0.0084945252,
0.0672242716,
0.0027694691,
-0.0048353323,
0.0033335013,
0.0581942275,
-0.0449638329,
-0.0176576953,
0.0402186401,
0.0933696181,
-0.003478063,
0.0235879682,
-0.0124916369,
-0.0200395584,
0.0316962264,
0.0711805746,
0.0107036158,
-0.0676536858,
-0.0103111733,
-0.0180487987,
-0.0345223993,
-0.0841433704,
0.0002280496,
-0.010566053,
-0.0290595312,
0.0071397363,
-0.0588819571,
-0.0581667945,
0.0374739245,
0.0396738201,
0.0285218861,
0.0205832198,
0.0037745463,
-0.03850336,
-0.0767929181,
0.0282615684,
-0.0885416269,
0.0288744252,
-0.0277210549,
-0.0135111632,
0.0266214479,
-0.0524410941,
-0.0193421487,
0.0173878334,
-0.0890343487,
-0.0529398695,
-0.0079866936,
0.0235537495,
0.0150269028,
0.0717696622,
-0.0437310785,
-0.0367776528,
0.0634010956,
0.0176137052,
-0.0877043083,
0.0164925307,
0.0538230911,
-0.0401431322,
0.0063311928,
0.0264426265,
-0.0331131704,
0.0166263301,
0.0581792109,
0.012772439,
0.0193650518,
-0.0040660729,
0.0126600293,
0.0036376938,
0.0168824177,
0.0108325304,
0.0188903082,
-0.0603956543,
0.046602983,
-0.0195427667,
-0.0310657807,
-0.0415796936,
0.0146409627,
0.0298033878,
0.0015844522,
0.0017200063,
0.0668812618,
0.0020290092,
0.0230852515,
-0.0417941287,
0.0069960998,
-0.0000442779,
0.0164331291,
0.046989128,
-0.0007137731,
0.0040692189,
-0.0016132327,
0.0222609341,
0.0457010977,
-0.029329678,
0.0411968455,
0.0105109466,
0.0154167367,
-0.00628804,
0.0118550919,
-0.0441966876,
-0.0074750148,
-0.0381852612,
0.044945769,
0.0466492362,
-0.0397454835,
0.051324144,
-0.0385432541,
-0.0182026438,
-0.0289096422,
0.0261729136,
0.0065929666,
-0.0174314287,
0.0083308099,
0.0100771021,
-0.0214829762,
-0.0067737605,
0.0980737656,
0.0265143141,
0.0479207374,
-0.0093703158,
0.0111194868,
-0.0408122018,
-0.0385193489,
0.020544935,
0.009126639,
-0.0204102844,
0.0151387798,
-0.049167335,
-0.0760498717,
-0.0080473078,
-0.0265624728,
-0.045104757,
-0.0042355973,
0.0468218885,
0.0457554162,
-0.0388097949,
-0.0127830487,
-0.0338327214,
0.0479471385,
0.0129195424,
-0.0236376412,
-0.0206319764,
-5.759457264e-33,
-0.0227440409,
-0.0096140625,
0.0319444686,
-0.0128051713,
-0.0458109528,
0.0037057893,
-0.0243763905,
-0.0185564365,
0.0169830453,
0.0145827541,
0.0004864165,
0.0128188347,
0.0168799274,
0.0550112166,
0.0091808755,
-0.0377433114,
0.0616019964,
-0.0072993487,
-0.0074217063,
0.024330616,
-0.001540921,
0.0372632332,
0.0469491668,
-0.0567068756,
0.0292011313,
-0.0087031517,
0.0239215363,
0.0024757723,
0.0134730563,
0.0576478168,
0.0108441431,
0.0377700962,
0.0194526128,
-0.0904991627,
-0.039349366,
0.0222317595,
-0.085046269,
-0.0087519484,
0.0382161774,
0.0238668099,
-0.0128169246,
-0.0458212495,
0.0343678221,
-0.0147575662,
0.0106370486,
-0.0319316983,
0.0381890498,
-0.0607763231,
-0.0109118605,
-0.0338546261,
-0.1098410413,
0.0151489666,
0.0030519434,
-0.0217903499,
0.0312455334,
0.0464664251,
0.0175338127,
-0.0184464138,
-0.0137220966,
0.0141976764,
0.0086744092,
0.0351379737,
0.0398572348,
0.0051673446,
-0.0067236484,
0.0272647869,
-0.0222651586,
0.0259576254,
0.02586703,
0.0022245806,
0.029518798,
0.0160934888,
0.0031496801,
0.0610602722,
0.035648983,
-0.0061767492,
-0.0617203414,
0.0195418559,
0.0222135298,
-0.0392922387,
0.0008930653,
-0.0024867235,
-0.0130064609,
-0.0379195549,
-0.0156764872,
0.0219872613,
0.0010948965,
-0.0323864669,
0.0502416231,
0.0113453418,
0.0017133572,
0.0309323054,
0.0212351941,
-0.0610169917,
-0.0209290236,
0.0286411755,
-0.0105192084,
0.0070139654,
-0.0099194413,
0.0293546841,
-0.0561188497,
-0.0265834425,
0.0235002842,
-0.0007200667,
-0.0165954828,
-0.0125158029,
0.0670108497,
-0.0152080972,
-0.0497343838,
-0.0048893834,
-0.0305916686,
0.0347832553,
0.044796221,
0.1049588323,
0.0339113548,
0.0364506356,
-0.0036263717,
0.0806664377,
0.0215830207,
-0.0455333516,
-0.0395774879,
0.0125507647,
0.0131265959,
0.0173388161,
-0.0092874886,
-0.0069962125,
-0.0161855929,
-0.0072616329,
0.0191747751,
-0.0610959716,
-0.0055779512,
-0.0014047615,
2.64e-7,
0.0366375484,
0.0282888431,
-0.0089620641,
0.0140737491,
0.0187944453,
0.0250056051,
-0.00709518,
0.0291681755,
0.0347047374,
-0.0079353163,
0.0020541612,
0.0089655453,
0.0710007325,
0.0018362775,
-0.1034298316,
-0.0202652775,
0.0134589784,
-0.0236504413,
-0.0388105884,
-0.001773379,
-0.0034498489,
0.1069061309,
0.0321237035,
-0.014106228,
0.0147855124,
-0.0360631533,
0.0673732311,
-0.0209652316,
-0.040793024,
0.0507763736,
-0.0393764749,
0.0461773761,
-0.0258860085,
0.027597703,
-0.0503527708,
0.0543356128,
0.0222460683,
0.0761070549,
0.0423773751,
0.0399329625,
-0.0426451303,
-0.0166210756,
-0.0091399662,
-0.0074782339,
0.0564999133,
-0.0808297843,
-0.0281965695,
-0.0165996924,
-0.0217107814,
-0.0100036599,
-0.0357304774,
-0.000152774,
0.0158980954,
0.0035065257,
0.0576768853,
-0.0126613425,
-0.0253877845,
-0.0524342693,
-0.010491929,
0.0305421595,
-0.0547419935,
-0.0254514255,
-0.035576947,
0.0031026588,
0.0538940728,
-0.0895470679,
0.0174349323,
2.64925524e-34,
0.0366900079,
0.0007487091,
0.0253107399,
0.0183513612,
0.0103964871,
-0.0076770955,
0.0016425443,
0.0005616868,
0.0291556008,
-0.0770002902,
-0.0039850678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16690v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16690v1 | Scaling Laws for Linear Complexity Language Models | 2024-06-24T14:51:31 | 2024-06-24T14:51:31 | Xuyang Shen, Dong Li, Ruitao Leng, Zhen Qin, Weigao Sun, Yiran Zhong | cs.CL | cs.CL | The interest in linear complexity models for large language models is on the
rise, although their scaling capacity remains uncertain. In this study, we
present the scaling laws for linear complexity language models to establish a
foundation for their scalability. Specifically, we examine the scaling
behaviors of three efficient linear architectures. These include TNL, a linear
attention model with data-independent decay; HGRN2, a linear RNN with
data-dependent decay; and cosFormer2, a linear attention model without decay.
We also include LLaMA as a baseline architecture for softmax attention for
comparison. These models were trained with six variants, ranging from 70M to 7B
parameters on a 300B-token corpus, and evaluated with a total of 1,376
intermediate checkpoints on various downstream tasks. These tasks include
validation loss, commonsense reasoning, and information retrieval and
generation. The study reveals that existing linear complexity language models
exhibit similar scaling capabilities as conventional transformer-based models
while also demonstrating superior linguistic proficiency and knowledge
retention. | [
0.0197020117,
0.0343190096,
-0.0040456969,
0.0128988167,
-0.0078805853,
0.0006438015,
0.0027299577,
0.0124651967,
-0.0050530834,
-0.0187639035,
-0.0209521614,
-0.0503897779,
0.0117603671,
0.0428602062,
0.0342027731,
-0.0403130427,
0.0129822129,
-0.0584728457,
0.0046625733,
-0.0046539693,
-0.0171946008,
-0.0199465342,
0.0352875628,
0.0212930609,
0.0287454128,
0.0189713109,
0.0046574655,
0.016134955,
0.0012798232,
-0.0172571745,
-0.0183675084,
0.0490710624,
0.0329033881,
0.0290641021,
0.000002087,
-0.0431934074,
0.0342390724,
-0.0076268702,
-0.0253008083,
0.0604248643,
0.0251522232,
-0.0023495925,
-0.0112802032,
0.042363856,
0.0253706314,
-0.0323428623,
0.0593678169,
0.0513752364,
0.0308238585,
0.0649836212,
0.0061427066,
-0.0541089587,
0.0623654015,
-0.0780411512,
-0.0261166878,
-0.0700920001,
0.044400651,
-0.0041444185,
-0.0133497138,
0.0308338311,
-0.0320390165,
0.0558120646,
0.0433769114,
0.0031211779,
0.0181832183,
0.0584862195,
0.0113117369,
0.0083976379,
-0.0008738937,
0.0573252141,
-0.0278810598,
-0.0397284143,
-0.0082568284,
0.0040589604,
0.0124551412,
-0.0401962847,
-0.034025684,
0.0360144749,
0.0304936469,
0.0075287037,
-0.0093756793,
-0.0178735293,
0.0539923981,
0.0103159826,
-0.0255788565,
-0.0104605434,
0.0193865299,
-0.0168225411,
-0.0280013513,
-0.033968389,
-0.0404556207,
-0.0138042103,
0.0039345548,
0.0531918071,
0.0102176955,
0.0151859056,
-0.0028058134,
0.0021112345,
0.0219689831,
-0.0865934417,
0.056766808,
0.0069387089,
-0.0195537582,
0.0598872416,
-0.0624865033,
0.0997336507,
-0.0187767092,
-0.0055605625,
-0.0382683463,
0.0037269213,
-0.0070951139,
-0.0102992784,
-0.044530645,
0.035909567,
-0.0217798892,
-0.0113503346,
-0.0311053935,
0.0068779904,
0.0051278565,
-0.0116785588,
0.0247109924,
-0.0039551877,
-0.0443380736,
-0.0181936137,
-0.0228041429,
0.0544979908,
-0.0493282788,
-0.0005851126,
0.0191753227,
-0.080054611,
-0.0260288641,
0.0138146831,
0.0068245381,
-0.0035996938,
0.0260346252,
0.0582992472,
-0.007193001,
-0.0431133918,
-0.0906689465,
0.0233442616,
-0.0358974859,
-0.0760262385,
-0.0095809819,
-0.0671040863,
0.0260659773,
-0.0278738774,
-0.0274187457,
-0.0122501757,
0.005505702,
0.0290513765,
-0.0278463103,
0.0339316577,
0.0412017144,
0.0149618899,
0.0256714318,
-0.0102996444,
0.0079968544,
0.0520513318,
0.0373342633,
0.0117833428,
0.0114692328,
-0.0278715957,
-0.0130347209,
0.0285502747,
0.006178923,
0.002272021,
-0.0165866222,
-0.005956165,
-0.0272098929,
0.0398763195,
0.030757241,
0.0988272354,
-0.0492962375,
-0.0083125671,
0.060676299,
0.0416498147,
0.0546972826,
0.0532487519,
0.0227686577,
-0.0036158778,
0.0002025271,
0.0033552996,
-0.0677157268,
0.05264939,
0.016946163,
0.0069094766,
0.048419144,
0.0270251557,
-0.0626470074,
-0.0559067614,
-0.0185623448,
-0.0054219533,
0.0088565769,
-0.0421907492,
0.0671850368,
-0.0041805473,
-0.0684081614,
0.050865043,
0.0059208591,
-0.0373058096,
0.016238058,
-0.0355162062,
-0.006994294,
0.0348341651,
0.0258885417,
0.0017681567,
0.0000742827,
0.0167275947,
0.0305998456,
0.0192075688,
0.055232469,
0.0252063293,
-0.0198156349,
-0.0853258595,
0.0233087819,
0.0142502021,
-0.0009394713,
0.0170991682,
0.0176381879,
0.0228567757,
0.0221088454,
-0.0403496809,
-0.0481556579,
0.0171926171,
-0.0460379198,
-0.0303689167,
0.000683974,
-0.012631706,
0.0415907204,
-0.0009685351,
-0.0168375187,
0.0275795367,
0.0387053527,
-0.052789025,
-0.0192826875,
0.0095909024,
-0.0415630862,
-0.0155073907,
0.0199696813,
-0.0008960388,
0.0592986643,
0.0660282746,
0.0016207825,
-0.0470784493,
0.0694225654,
-0.0502071381,
0.0252072047,
-0.0410267897,
0.0273613445,
-0.0228424966,
0.0365374126,
-0.0411177278,
0.0550839156,
-0.0463544168,
0.0460617058,
0.0139104407,
-0.0150388032,
-0.0108026071,
-0.0244814102,
-0.0624762177,
0.012795506,
-0.0093520815,
0.0114729526,
-0.0106540918,
-0.0319041535,
0.0100585101,
-0.0481854826,
-0.0224884618,
-0.0119493613,
-0.0411505885,
0.0448459461,
0.0186952651,
0.0073597608,
0.0248772465,
0.0132900309,
-0.0118855415,
0.0418182239,
0.0079295579,
0.0284115206,
0.0380990878,
-0.0023980362,
-0.0576142818,
-0.0470713265,
-0.0492321588,
0.0254910532,
0.0455054902,
0.0006483294,
-0.0195719097,
-0.0337018818,
0.0246903636,
-0.0000172882,
0.0273368917,
-0.0310138464,
-0.0552786924,
-0.0019103615,
-0.0241733305,
0.0515385121,
0.0776555911,
0.023262864,
0.0140796993,
0.0475393087,
-0.0084194615,
-0.031276051,
0.0230545662,
-0.0080364654,
-0.0360831581,
-0.0090267146,
-0.0345470309,
0.0156468581,
0.094247885,
-0.0274509788,
-0.008704572,
-0.0759428665,
-0.0546047688,
-0.0136322398,
-0.0053087212,
0.0332514197,
0.0084717153,
-0.0414435826,
0.0217631795,
-0.0278857853,
-0.0511511378,
0.0413408987,
-0.0340102203,
0.0003337233,
-0.0070834481,
-0.0053997091,
-0.0403741226,
0.0596848056,
0.0387431905,
0.0202378798,
0.005968737,
-0.0402948447,
-0.024389891,
-0.0239636917,
-0.0022665502,
-0.028293075,
0.0765560344,
-0.0281371735,
0.0082967402,
-0.0229293834,
-0.0175887998,
-0.0102243097,
0.0344345421,
-0.0004894738,
0.0217962749,
0.0484403037,
-0.0399153978,
-0.0494021885,
0.0154240485,
0.0210719667,
0.0583338775,
-0.0011492723,
-0.0085008042,
-0.0012556646,
0.0529219583,
0.0237885248,
0.0499685816,
0.0666490272,
-0.0469757169,
0.013055752,
0.0674218833,
0.013103324,
0.0168295745,
-0.035228692,
-0.0424925052,
0.043883197,
-0.0181719139,
-0.0178739727,
0.0474304892,
0.0425921828,
-0.0479656495,
-0.0228609722,
0.0987472832,
0.0003584106,
-0.0230621323,
0.0222655609,
-0.021496404,
0.0603500642,
0.0025105658,
0.0175784938,
-0.0466266386,
-0.0145856831,
0.0164117627,
0.0285380278,
0.0092627145,
-0.015701443,
0.0140975742,
-0.0756961554,
-0.0019098043,
0.0071482048,
-0.0248745363,
-0.0475886427,
-0.0370502882,
-0.0035011398,
-0.0200716183,
0.0059529082,
0.0460397191,
-0.0169368815,
-0.0154039143,
0.0207260046,
-0.023829747,
-0.0431387573,
0.029504519,
-0.0482616499,
0.078034237,
0.0208432693,
0.0086604487,
-0.0151593983,
-0.0726856887,
0.0736983493,
-0.0011145055,
0.0234928764,
0.0004312553,
0.0084426692,
0.04576369,
-0.017324172,
-0.0429926626,
0.0257137232,
-0.0321655683,
0.022891568,
-0.0144515587,
0.0465046652,
0.0373559929,
-0.068967402,
-0.0138725601,
-0.0032744005,
-0.0579482317,
0.0818510428,
0.0650430545,
-0.0224335026,
-0.0749683902,
-0.0019716348,
0.0206414778,
-0.0521433875,
-0.0480605662,
-0.0100089516,
0.011917064,
-0.0264997352,
-0.0647320747,
-0.007906043,
-0.0154194031,
0.0471761078,
-0.0124846203,
-0.0522049479,
-0.0028051031,
0.0042282096,
-0.0356465206,
0.0405348502,
-0.0319724269,
0.0056434493,
-0.08990933,
0.0476152562,
0.0252945311,
-0.01926139,
-0.0178912766,
0.0377092808,
-0.1179332137,
-0.0530850962,
-0.002598509,
0.0227435399,
0.0187926665,
0.0135807237,
0.0068913791,
-0.0472241975,
0.033603102,
-0.0203208067,
-0.0114969229,
0.0657512173,
0.0339834616,
-0.0321082212,
-0.0014053058,
0.070117414,
-0.0248748902,
0.0137733314,
-0.0004187862,
0.0696266666,
-0.0058435784,
-0.0325984247,
-0.0327793173,
0.0015602956,
-0.0090192389,
0.0183906797,
-0.0214428734,
-0.0218077525,
0.0389156379,
0.0195677411,
0.0339180306,
-0.0557701588,
-0.015884297,
0.0459848307,
0.0306193363,
0.006511372,
-0.0154667972,
0.0330516323,
-0.0106714005,
-0.01351301,
0.0130836051,
-0.021920085,
0.0251296926,
0.027016975,
-0.0130416574,
-0.0341987982,
-0.0267500449,
-0.0186864194,
0.0164069571,
-0.0106158806,
0.0398811363,
-0.0014790748,
0.0062838471,
-0.0339745097,
0.0196378957,
-0.0448489189,
-0.018890677,
-0.0157337878,
-0.0343389809,
0.0380757041,
0.0224411488,
0.0622137636,
-0.0083950143,
-0.0038380623,
-0.0368677191,
-0.0104782172,
-0.0043063322,
-0.0197348855,
0.0367857292,
0.0317794383,
0.0134570915,
-0.0153819341,
0.0864905566,
0.0124400724,
0.0261333231,
-0.0224618278,
0.021343274,
-0.0089343097,
-0.0314679816,
-0.0688836351,
0.0293314867,
-0.0071404246,
-0.0133585678,
-0.0356201343,
-0.0609743223,
0.0212025661,
-0.0132079143,
0.0114751812,
-0.0215837918,
0.0249049924,
0.0431983247,
0.0265311394,
0.0019740784,
-0.0114102988,
0.0074949074,
0.026439704,
-0.0060679377,
0.0044984305,
-7.178686695e-33,
-0.0142994253,
0.0108632976,
0.0041102464,
-0.0079178018,
-0.0559550487,
0.0445888527,
-0.0379149802,
0.0005791599,
-0.0656066015,
-0.013862351,
0.001574135,
0.0064365282,
-0.0085842414,
0.0505389869,
0.0067587453,
-0.0090673687,
0.0446866378,
0.011782431,
-0.0186223071,
0.033845935,
0.0306130573,
0.0161816534,
0.0509237647,
-0.0017801357,
-0.0078953523,
0.0096234409,
0.0056229178,
0.0239643008,
-0.0023265986,
0.0467871167,
-0.0277998596,
0.0609271862,
0.0321272761,
-0.1014811695,
-0.0264269151,
-0.0004713891,
-0.1220535561,
-0.0212152395,
0.0196838845,
0.0095691169,
-0.0073206802,
-0.0297102928,
0.0829645619,
0.0123494146,
-0.0049781795,
-0.035486538,
0.0091747083,
-0.0201156344,
-0.0390593521,
0.0048823655,
-0.007856016,
0.0258344393,
-0.0169626921,
0.0038987552,
-0.0121125197,
0.0080426382,
-0.0381904468,
0.037617214,
-0.0709147602,
0.0220357627,
0.0218031909,
0.0683343858,
0.0378658995,
0.0396114215,
0.0060397382,
0.0383901,
0.025766978,
0.0075272615,
-0.0921389163,
-0.0208177343,
0.0415921509,
0.0163560957,
0.0522854775,
0.0015122277,
0.0249662939,
-0.0138361873,
-0.076802969,
-0.0255521815,
0.0244706143,
0.1132645309,
0.0387610346,
0.0112112463,
-0.0375878848,
-0.0358216278,
-0.0470459759,
-0.0083842222,
-0.0510296524,
-0.0172296856,
0.0271956753,
0.0362817012,
0.0071383966,
-0.0181330033,
0.0190374609,
-0.0182155706,
-0.0060121319,
0.0364857614,
0.0165029485,
0.0345552489,
-0.0038716907,
0.0326826274,
-0.0812665597,
0.0030974324,
-0.0029772096,
0.0048071691,
-0.0210130997,
0.0062223733,
-0.0142159015,
0.0381081738,
-0.0727909431,
-0.0328277685,
-0.0486369655,
-0.0097732935,
0.0280476958,
0.0657001138,
0.0332339033,
-0.0325917415,
0.0085580014,
0.0609728172,
-0.0257401932,
-0.009998803,
-0.0070722289,
0.0685424432,
0.0191803519,
0.0307943262,
-0.0458267555,
0.0015004491,
-0.0590581559,
0.0598745309,
0.0426307581,
-0.0678687543,
-0.0342491828,
0.02923855,
2.962e-7,
0.0017415679,
0.0169342309,
0.0333776399,
-0.0047403648,
0.0137143619,
0.0164204091,
0.0135643296,
0.0409810953,
-0.0143009657,
0.03131219,
-0.0006550595,
0.0341344364,
0.0132102519,
-0.0205867682,
-0.073541142,
-0.0377131552,
-0.0921644121,
0.0346066765,
0.0046047489,
-0.0263164267,
-0.0214930419,
0.0997531489,
-0.0054960432,
-0.012837152,
0.000229079,
-0.0467932783,
0.0273233783,
-0.0235794652,
0.024121793,
0.0071959933,
0.0317508914,
0.0155264931,
-0.029449895,
0.0070099682,
-0.0080367979,
0.0083328094,
-0.0009935541,
0.0857321993,
0.022399893,
-0.0374222323,
0.0470122546,
-0.0025477728,
-0.0333645679,
-0.0443431549,
0.083055526,
-0.0418915637,
-0.0513147414,
-0.0133406268,
-0.0202306714,
0.0086980164,
-0.0048382827,
-0.0214942675,
-0.0065995129,
0.0184617639,
-0.0013445154,
-0.0088097109,
0.0085288538,
-0.0730733424,
-0.0132669592,
-0.0086799972,
-0.0598702133,
-0.0307167005,
-0.1165747046,
-0.03660376,
0.0159576535,
-0.040235512,
-0.0004099552,
2.642658237e-34,
0.0407464653,
-0.0436641984,
0.0171778146,
-0.0004784712,
-0.0061464077,
-0.0157494042,
-0.0081174914,
-0.0051955464,
0.0081925094,
-0.1268044561,
-0.0211846828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16678v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16678v1 | Segment Any Text: A Universal Approach for Robust, Efficient and Adaptable Sentence Segmentation | 2024-06-24T14:36:11 | 2024-06-24T14:36:11 | Markus Frohmann, Igor Sterner, Ivan Vulić, Benjamin Minixhofer, Markus Schedl | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Segmenting text into sentences plays an early and crucial role in many NLP
systems. This is commonly achieved by using rule-based or statistical methods
relying on lexical features such as punctuation. Although some recent works no
longer exclusively rely on punctuation, we find that no prior method achieves
all of (i) robustness to missing punctuation, (ii) effective adaptability to
new domains, and (iii) high efficiency. We introduce a new model - Segment any
Text (SaT) - to solve this problem. To enhance robustness, we propose a new
pretraining scheme that ensures less reliance on punctuation. To address
adaptability, we introduce an extra stage of parameter-efficient fine-tuning,
establishing state-of-the-art performance in distinct domains such as verses
from lyrics and legal documents. Along the way, we introduce architectural
modifications that result in a threefold gain in speed over the previous state
of the art and solve spurious reliance on context far in the future. Finally,
we introduce a variant of our model with fine-tuning on a diverse, multilingual
mixture of sentence-segmented data, acting as a drop-in replacement and
enhancement for existing segmentation tools. Overall, our contributions provide
a universal approach for segmenting any text. Our method outperforms all
baselines - including strong LLMs - across 8 corpora spanning diverse domains
and languages, especially in practically relevant situations where text is
poorly formatted. Our models and code, including documentation, are available
at https://huggingface.co/segment-any-text under the MIT license. | [
0.0200725943,
0.0316633135,
-0.0024634993,
0.030301664,
-0.0740907416,
0.0055349413,
0.0418867432,
0.0028878183,
0.0027529795,
-0.0158657376,
0.0298205912,
-0.004401892,
-0.0190825332,
-0.0145072192,
0.0192524921,
-0.0722999647,
0.0368633196,
-0.0105629843,
0.0368841738,
0.0408881716,
0.0177546889,
-0.0089551164,
-0.0068940572,
-0.0071448795,
-0.0423110984,
-0.0175572913,
-0.0205420982,
0.0257861055,
0.0137974927,
-0.0312434677,
0.0290017985,
0.0387035981,
-0.0639928132,
-0.0086813271,
0.0000017567,
-0.0386082456,
-0.058647804,
-0.0289926622,
0.0188548919,
0.0046731401,
0.0016852809,
-0.0460658185,
-0.0286939461,
0.0276664551,
-0.0075095696,
0.044884637,
-0.0156207671,
0.052608192,
0.0600156635,
0.1355630904,
-0.0284733754,
-0.0183532927,
0.0312167052,
0.0077715819,
-0.0413681865,
-0.0075184484,
0.0356701612,
0.0003767017,
0.0045041894,
-0.0229929574,
0.0072166519,
0.0513263084,
0.0175061449,
0.0246831588,
0.0030450537,
-0.0118742092,
-0.0896025449,
-0.0311692879,
-0.0267257392,
0.0178260542,
-0.0272166971,
-0.0107593136,
0.0328852013,
0.019886082,
0.0003827097,
-0.0721444041,
-0.0342977978,
0.0065979422,
-0.0000630054,
0.0409156084,
0.0144334426,
0.0099425316,
0.0143611068,
0.0134456679,
-0.0322079882,
0.0448424183,
-0.0050231172,
-0.0733068362,
0.0557079762,
0.0374500975,
-0.0508301333,
-0.0326030105,
0.0607078448,
-0.0166829173,
0.0193718504,
-0.0137231508,
-0.0738433227,
-0.0507150739,
-0.0026093782,
-0.0189297348,
0.0058298986,
-0.0078452919,
0.0009482379,
0.0479648337,
-0.0038497418,
-0.035339471,
0.0190393161,
0.0020880536,
-0.0057120346,
-0.0216965713,
-0.018030528,
0.0045897178,
-0.0601792,
0.0066340156,
-0.0192763936,
-0.0244221184,
-0.0313565508,
-0.0040841871,
0.0200789422,
-0.0059994683,
0.0129905157,
-0.0372611582,
0.0222881697,
0.0189247709,
0.0520818941,
-0.0111093605,
-0.0580633134,
0.0156034566,
0.0124746049,
-0.0086627016,
-0.0059485268,
0.0435627215,
0.0300545171,
-0.0159279183,
0.035824731,
0.0209965128,
-0.0253142919,
-0.0777512342,
-0.06285052,
-0.0440401882,
-0.0640907362,
-0.0372873023,
-0.0232659299,
-0.0569946691,
-0.020172717,
-0.0266371872,
0.0096073337,
-0.0096785966,
-0.0039690263,
0.0309740975,
-0.0133013474,
0.0682321638,
-0.0202346202,
0.0146247577,
-0.042827487,
-0.0121111674,
0.0592218228,
0.0608822145,
0.0573843159,
0.0232654065,
0.083874844,
0.0492640287,
0.0262155756,
0.0862878263,
-0.0377611332,
-0.0010757354,
-0.038721744,
-0.03323723,
-0.0235684011,
0.0258645043,
-0.0249667428,
0.0462243073,
0.0179180447,
-0.0058691818,
0.0256710947,
0.0137322703,
0.0132933082,
0.0605437756,
0.0108208712,
0.0136308055,
0.0215665977,
0.0110277357,
-0.0349083953,
-0.0370926298,
0.0139174564,
0.0387810618,
0.0520619228,
0.0143401101,
0.0143593457,
-0.0343948379,
-0.0392880775,
-0.0168737862,
-0.0089733414,
-0.021075571,
0.026908515,
0.036645405,
-0.0634612069,
0.0560274944,
-0.0199869312,
-0.0809126645,
-0.0415856317,
0.0184044596,
0.0159184784,
0.0341278464,
0.0587175228,
-0.0654604062,
0.0390811674,
-0.0128635298,
0.0620610565,
0.0714102238,
-0.0272263736,
-0.0010853288,
0.0334650315,
-0.0440183766,
0.0169012025,
0.0419792235,
0.0221932624,
-0.0370681807,
0.0079305973,
0.0230596084,
-0.0000319758,
-0.0517241322,
0.0268653315,
0.0486472026,
0.0340710133,
-0.0106789516,
0.0017391436,
0.0136891305,
0.007230347,
0.048646681,
-0.0192804784,
-0.0009441591,
0.0306599699,
-0.0495211072,
0.0415176079,
0.005590118,
-0.0514261313,
-0.0883522555,
0.0135148289,
-0.0451942533,
-0.0147786206,
0.0315820724,
-0.0097012697,
-0.0434916168,
-0.0343677364,
0.0172664933,
0.02188484,
-0.0148684606,
0.0431278124,
0.0145612042,
0.0068402868,
-0.010033044,
0.0142480331,
0.0133322719,
-0.0026670373,
-0.0470419191,
-0.0328562111,
0.0349731594,
-0.0136318495,
-0.0348388255,
0.0018970997,
-0.0284748171,
-0.0054203151,
0.0012019946,
0.0107850963,
-0.0356978178,
-0.0506635606,
-0.1144398898,
0.0346034393,
-0.0540930182,
0.0111309253,
0.0115598319,
0.0129559273,
-0.0638443083,
-0.0291443057,
-0.0015681473,
-0.005924827,
0.0257736705,
-0.0120179448,
0.0416532643,
-0.0262160711,
-0.0372443646,
-0.0466825888,
-0.0008744344,
-0.0221990347,
0.0100166854,
-0.0186904352,
-0.0384016037,
-0.0242939238,
0.0330947191,
0.0089994883,
-0.0065885922,
0.0285807848,
-0.0350305066,
-0.0045301295,
-0.0309578199,
0.0398711748,
0.0559542403,
-0.0079926765,
-0.0254187323,
-0.0140933972,
-0.0226233508,
0.0717142373,
0.0203478765,
0.0156894382,
0.0719907954,
-0.0584397316,
-0.0041449829,
0.0508207306,
0.0690532327,
0.007647845,
-0.0184746794,
-0.0011993886,
-0.0208099522,
-0.0125875408,
0.0011823452,
-0.000849777,
0.0267252326,
-0.0466054864,
0.018577192,
-0.0154417651,
-0.0085987095,
0.0276476759,
-0.0404269658,
-0.0161816515,
-0.068673268,
-0.0575535148,
-0.0481854305,
0.0386059918,
0.0209078342,
-0.0279181655,
0.0476974919,
-0.036424309,
-0.0195163414,
0.0362422243,
-0.0136718843,
0.0197136644,
0.0559910983,
-0.0232874025,
0.0000570982,
0.0054115499,
-0.030517675,
-0.0170854274,
-0.0339651369,
-0.035681136,
0.0082540764,
0.007093329,
0.0091731623,
-0.0116717685,
-0.0070544765,
-0.0446451865,
0.0745745525,
-0.0263293479,
0.0021636947,
-0.0262911674,
0.0704650655,
-0.0158678815,
-0.0081886072,
-0.0164986029,
-0.0314062051,
0.0257834494,
0.0421318747,
0.0332570598,
-0.009284134,
0.0264910664,
0.0068830531,
-0.0029832255,
-0.0449687503,
-0.0000160056,
0.0061741066,
0.0484803766,
-0.0642382652,
-0.0239198469,
0.1252412945,
0.0651682615,
-0.0003690792,
-0.0174198877,
0.0231525004,
0.0375658944,
0.0149985952,
-0.026677601,
-0.0779899806,
-0.0634379983,
0.0190526843,
0.0534084775,
0.0214133803,
-0.0205694977,
0.0166896246,
-0.0096501503,
0.004391449,
0.009919554,
-0.0512535386,
0.0170284808,
0.010655432,
-0.0061499793,
-0.0281630158,
-0.0015972164,
-0.0218725111,
-0.0399718881,
0.0172207877,
-0.0062797642,
-0.0540439002,
0.005725835,
-0.0357195362,
-0.0566455238,
-0.003928897,
0.0407267138,
0.0569351353,
-0.0159881935,
0.0232075565,
0.0624748729,
-0.0565840825,
-0.0220522732,
-0.0038438318,
0.0642698035,
-0.0156413447,
0.0024326732,
-0.0084529268,
0.0147594335,
-0.0364373066,
-0.0113308262,
0.0804065093,
0.0290101804,
0.01252387,
0.0034596245,
-0.0177209564,
0.0138600292,
-0.0299654994,
0.0888282657,
0.0229164883,
-0.031246705,
-0.0683331117,
-0.0303239916,
0.0043138233,
-0.1091422364,
-0.0415398367,
-0.0135308038,
-0.0223142803,
-0.0028878017,
-0.0722764134,
-0.0705591962,
0.0397236682,
0.0251361188,
0.0130863143,
-0.0112107703,
-0.0005204933,
-0.0263360348,
-0.0468126982,
-0.0216958113,
-0.0198009871,
-0.0079170074,
-0.0649039,
-0.0035579819,
-0.0065753968,
-0.0067585991,
0.0004919269,
-0.0245556179,
-0.0667428523,
-0.0369829088,
0.0563760176,
0.0066205808,
0.0063357363,
0.047938697,
-0.0284954235,
0.0090998085,
0.0418066382,
0.0615612678,
0.0074165403,
0.0332894176,
0.0597088411,
0.0229992568,
0.004619047,
0.0372165702,
0.0011882546,
0.0235999264,
0.0024217886,
0.0400479995,
-0.042015139,
-0.022995729,
-0.0033735889,
0.0022680881,
0.064841792,
-0.0031290513,
-0.0506744273,
-0.017559329,
-0.0062153069,
-0.0250244793,
0.0036457207,
-0.0163105838,
0.0416025408,
0.00578553,
0.031572178,
-0.060884621,
0.0359355547,
-0.0180249233,
0.0118669039,
-0.0579361618,
0.0310572069,
0.0467572473,
-0.0273768809,
-0.0253437497,
-0.0056119654,
0.0192130357,
0.0114130061,
0.011623119,
0.0210504998,
0.0175311156,
0.043360021,
-0.0086715445,
-0.0496430956,
-0.0601511635,
0.0441172905,
-0.0755983144,
0.0645956397,
0.0064580371,
0.0733091161,
0.0567535087,
-0.0433530919,
0.0512909964,
-0.0227932315,
-0.0152604226,
0.0086008115,
0.0419557169,
0.0135435238,
0.0020598313,
-0.0578059368,
0.0096278396,
-0.0379498303,
-0.0146999815,
0.0344945602,
-0.0272549521,
-0.0018538717,
0.0547595993,
-0.0229460839,
-0.0499938577,
0.0190518573,
-0.0190129466,
0.0220084954,
-0.0015077333,
0.0146382973,
-0.0346430466,
-0.0302340649,
0.0443074405,
0.0022571653,
0.0278362874,
0.0027453478,
0.0015810149,
0.0601236224,
0.0026362923,
-0.0054160971,
-0.0102039371,
-0.0223117862,
0.0274145976,
-0.0472367182,
0.0370677598,
-5.824696466e-33,
0.0011395704,
-0.000727725,
-0.0315705463,
-0.0049651116,
-0.0281859189,
-0.0119672092,
-0.0364568047,
0.0162416175,
0.046942059,
-0.0105905337,
-0.0250237975,
0.0135510368,
0.0326002464,
0.0403543152,
0.022874333,
-0.0145879816,
0.0698013976,
-0.0120730465,
-0.0315192603,
-0.0280390661,
0.0139620937,
0.0644178838,
0.0167596247,
-0.017964866,
0.0282639768,
-0.020558035,
-0.021271944,
0.0299237147,
0.0408858359,
0.0421323776,
0.0167695526,
0.004554024,
0.0450340025,
0.0099894432,
-0.0111481976,
0.0412478521,
-0.0835912228,
-0.0150829824,
-0.0107513908,
0.0212112647,
-0.0139037911,
-0.0297622774,
0.0365734063,
-0.0238603707,
0.0424208492,
0.0093180351,
0.0386257879,
-0.0510733761,
0.0274686087,
-0.0435313024,
-0.0550653376,
0.0221925788,
-0.0318878181,
-0.0214705151,
0.0568073057,
0.0534466095,
0.0183070358,
0.0417218879,
-0.0240122098,
-0.0060165669,
0.0009600548,
0.0326808766,
-0.0197626147,
-0.0153633617,
-0.0356341302,
0.0469458289,
-0.0068800887,
-0.0431303009,
-0.0048836004,
0.0439609662,
0.0132106906,
0.0192903858,
0.067005612,
0.025559783,
0.029684402,
-0.0101358341,
-0.0418316722,
-0.0031808827,
0.0364889279,
-0.055028256,
-0.0088447556,
0.0416215248,
-0.0745396763,
0.0108911637,
0.0538213067,
-0.0595964603,
0.0197674148,
0.0120259803,
0.0323648937,
0.0219631493,
-0.0461172797,
0.025788229,
0.0050807809,
-0.0143720787,
-0.0203391891,
-0.0088535156,
-0.0328239016,
0.0430007689,
-0.0291465931,
0.0069928039,
-0.0572614893,
-0.008528674,
0.0302595682,
-0.0055422927,
0.0244789552,
-0.0254354216,
0.0672805607,
-0.0136990296,
-0.090534173,
-0.001650061,
0.0221406147,
0.0420903489,
-0.0136367287,
0.0751001835,
0.011693133,
0.0505948626,
0.0200226866,
0.0779488459,
0.0414773524,
-0.0186989177,
-0.0431181863,
-0.0114676179,
-0.0229921099,
0.0362315141,
-0.0184832886,
-0.0196296573,
0.0171935186,
0.0103559624,
-0.0174351446,
-0.0676356331,
0.0061058267,
0.005836532,
2.411e-7,
0.0534201674,
0.0442264341,
0.0631667078,
-0.0236941054,
-0.0076116077,
0.0366008542,
-0.0392341241,
0.0130917085,
-0.0257042814,
0.0140763326,
0.0252972804,
-0.0166250616,
0.090698339,
-0.0024777176,
-0.1723490655,
0.0061016213,
-0.0108323218,
-0.051413171,
-0.0854155496,
-0.025135193,
0.0663053691,
0.089990817,
0.0186548103,
0.0108479746,
-0.0316207223,
-0.0430773906,
-0.0260854643,
-0.0038756509,
-0.0250974465,
-0.0263798963,
0.0165627655,
-0.007252221,
-0.0323118046,
0.0151097551,
-0.0125852786,
0.0282112695,
0.0280399323,
0.0710816011,
0.0496053696,
0.020758003,
0.0346326828,
0.0179603398,
-0.008991532,
0.0180710088,
0.07769344,
0.0370073095,
0.0069282041,
0.0179652013,
0.0242979955,
-0.016776653,
0.0127935763,
-0.0096588684,
-0.0426520407,
0.0181125645,
0.0335880406,
-0.022008786,
-0.0046407725,
-0.0543099195,
-0.0410391204,
0.0004883104,
-0.0201294348,
0.0159252491,
-0.0244002715,
0.030314561,
-0.0263766032,
-0.0860056877,
-0.0202543903,
2.650423158e-34,
0.0371953212,
-0.0519458055,
0.0032179293,
0.0435416885,
0.0179658104,
-0.0061584264,
0.0042559621,
-0.0114971073,
-0.0440670177,
-0.0475950241,
-0.0059675109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16674v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16674v1 | Computational Approaches to the Detection of Lesser-Known Rhetorical Figures: A Systematic Survey and Research Challenges | 2024-06-24T14:31:34 | 2024-06-24T14:31:34 | Ramona Kühn, Jelena Mitrović, Michael Granitzer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Rhetorical figures play a major role in our everyday communication as they
make text more interesting, more memorable, or more persuasive. Therefore, it
is important to computationally detect rhetorical figures to fully understand
the meaning of a text. We provide a comprehensive overview of computational
approaches to lesser-known rhetorical figures. We explore the linguistic and
computational perspectives on rhetorical figures, emphasizing their
significance for the domain of Natural Language Processing. We present
different figures in detail, delving into datasets, definitions, rhetorical
functions, and detection approaches. We identified challenges such as dataset
scarcity, language limitations, and reliance on rule-based methods. | [
0.0719118416,
0.0457708426,
-0.0377813727,
0.075932093,
-0.0376449563,
0.0283437558,
-0.0217247996,
0.032844007,
-0.0064943554,
-0.0262636021,
0.0400126353,
-0.0109578483,
0.0486432761,
-0.0021879966,
-0.0038537539,
-0.0651420802,
0.0214073826,
0.0124421334,
0.1013382375,
0.0116878459,
0.0330707356,
0.036032103,
-0.0138586741,
0.0468938388,
-0.066968441,
-0.0278969891,
0.0249928273,
0.0402984954,
0.016133178,
-0.0397974215,
-0.0133174146,
-0.0060344078,
-0.0081684403,
0.0097340364,
0.0000015986,
-0.0440388806,
0.0251938961,
-0.0445791967,
-0.0076430552,
0.0212643649,
0.1178841963,
-0.0103657227,
-0.0173359383,
-0.0085341195,
-0.021619739,
0.0326593108,
0.0767982453,
0.0868553594,
0.0089687984,
0.0765930414,
-0.0107500907,
-0.0269452576,
-0.0135666085,
0.0374582633,
-0.0216463543,
0.0201535486,
0.024160618,
-0.0269743688,
-0.0308675822,
0.0051681902,
-0.0296697803,
0.0264706835,
-0.0161376186,
0.0281770397,
-0.0673845485,
0.0195976794,
-0.0247511379,
0.0168226548,
-0.0424618274,
0.0331136435,
0.010404164,
-0.024413174,
0.0226581134,
-0.0058104871,
0.0143078873,
-0.0083698453,
-0.0210159756,
0.002795924,
-0.0053990972,
0.0187756456,
0.0336550139,
0.0101248752,
-0.0234430432,
0.0419121198,
0.0169494525,
0.0304416735,
-0.0113848811,
-0.0181752201,
0.0037272878,
-0.0263782032,
-0.0798818469,
-0.0077814572,
0.0490139015,
0.0163112506,
0.0209415555,
0.0403323546,
-0.0329614654,
-0.0497680716,
0.0502688475,
-0.0557231493,
0.0297587551,
-0.0296641681,
-0.0118645607,
0.0402499028,
-0.0180350114,
0.0062896027,
-0.0299017336,
0.0113873985,
-0.0011157305,
0.0130278403,
-0.0128303543,
-0.0334798582,
-0.0492512919,
0.0230913591,
-0.0092917802,
-0.045862224,
-0.0396674238,
-0.0053079268,
-0.011624652,
-0.0096071986,
-0.0403629355,
0.037463963,
0.0083429292,
0.001909537,
-0.0279013086,
0.0070095505,
-0.0454617254,
0.0164096244,
-0.0601764694,
-0.0113091385,
0.0136735486,
0.0450314581,
0.075788945,
-0.0121478364,
0.0311485585,
0.066778779,
0.0229241513,
-0.0249675456,
0.0064071491,
-0.0349693224,
-0.0591036826,
-0.0210637767,
-0.0169336684,
-0.0294916239,
-0.0151852621,
-0.0205175169,
0.0302701835,
-0.0295308046,
0.0296335705,
0.0403200053,
0.0022711421,
0.0463026725,
-0.0124333482,
-0.0149046155,
0.0106694177,
-0.0141263967,
0.0104959188,
0.0377172194,
0.0385388508,
0.0120100603,
0.0706146806,
0.003739774,
0.0047203037,
0.0285262242,
-0.0145934727,
-0.0106584867,
0.0260210223,
-0.0105311023,
-0.0337130614,
0.0100897644,
-0.0453826897,
0.0488230884,
-0.0137760406,
-0.0520540662,
0.0447366871,
0.0896511748,
-0.0230545904,
-0.0186139811,
0.0474976823,
0.0249457322,
0.0237049665,
0.0249420814,
0.0219332762,
-0.0366930068,
-0.0031883046,
-0.0189648308,
-0.0258583296,
0.0095541682,
0.0127188535,
-0.062033806,
-0.0072847311,
0.0092039639,
-0.031379737,
-0.0591779724,
0.0099665374,
0.0099401604,
-0.0539060868,
-0.0203646868,
0.0235709194,
-0.0391711332,
-0.0262977816,
0.0025744543,
0.0021968442,
0.0284813084,
0.0482619144,
-0.0235604178,
0.0476602912,
-0.0243740771,
0.0464900807,
0.057713937,
-0.030539928,
0.0216161665,
-0.0049680714,
-0.0113232667,
0.0508203842,
-0.0104121231,
0.0404436179,
0.015064314,
-0.0013840926,
0.0399200283,
-0.0100776404,
0.0038170204,
-0.0408102907,
0.0318598412,
0.0740965605,
-0.0142066758,
0.0050425665,
0.0359885842,
0.0162065122,
0.0007840333,
-0.0194497481,
-0.0056861322,
-0.0166849233,
-0.0475666858,
-0.0082434919,
0.0437662266,
-0.0253821034,
0.0055105533,
0.0408779122,
-0.0977400169,
-0.0352852531,
-0.0047551622,
0.0087488908,
-0.0029501987,
0.0303506944,
-0.1071770713,
0.0512963571,
-0.0305795055,
-0.0014492156,
-0.0222512484,
0.0517682582,
0.0031572494,
0.0590072833,
0.0374303646,
-0.0003171683,
0.0131595731,
0.0024478137,
0.0411360078,
0.0132400068,
0.0008275563,
-0.0563368164,
-0.0178848505,
0.0202120245,
-0.0058948239,
-0.0264577884,
-0.0504580513,
-0.0465856865,
-0.0833331719,
-0.0380498134,
-0.0095436098,
-0.0145242633,
0.0256975349,
-0.059302032,
-0.017998701,
0.0081301061,
0.0020109916,
-0.0432847105,
-0.0248435363,
0.0083048726,
0.077011019,
-0.0338031799,
-0.0459398925,
-0.0185967926,
0.0288134106,
-0.0657770038,
0.058010336,
0.0589459278,
-0.04662285,
-0.0278558042,
0.0345303044,
-0.0271389447,
-0.0249546003,
0.0015630737,
-0.0562230423,
0.0377084166,
0.0224805139,
0.0695095956,
0.0652183145,
0.0596134439,
0.0108766165,
-0.0001671976,
-0.0221824553,
-0.042934861,
-0.0324643888,
-0.0450909026,
0.0260057095,
-0.0240247007,
-0.0440376066,
0.0598975308,
0.0084372722,
0.0384017341,
0.023319535,
-0.0210739449,
0.0706166923,
-0.0008888294,
-0.0449361354,
-0.0182972476,
-0.0031760393,
-0.0393560827,
0.0185553618,
0.0040173046,
0.0089301402,
0.0361721255,
-0.0190077797,
-0.0022625942,
-0.0110270428,
-0.0096440231,
-0.0507358126,
0.0390069559,
0.0205100682,
0.01796587,
0.0512170978,
-0.0612086579,
0.0486525558,
-0.0137298545,
-0.0077968864,
-0.0303337462,
0.0196419731,
0.0039138626,
-0.0198704414,
0.0370349139,
-0.0307396408,
-0.0041311746,
-0.0409177579,
-0.0326483101,
-0.0552319735,
-0.0205908511,
-0.0219586641,
-0.0241950415,
-0.0321957394,
-0.0117318416,
-0.0063879597,
0.0104973633,
0.0019409567,
-0.0246301908,
0.0190784056,
0.0378611311,
0.0147460178,
0.0140595641,
-0.0104877492,
-0.0279264618,
0.0438246615,
-0.0251724664,
-0.0207865387,
-0.0248792507,
-0.0054484345,
-0.0027355039,
-0.0128560169,
0.0302567035,
0.017687805,
0.0175896566,
-0.0424706228,
0.0078884354,
0.0710277855,
0.0204465613,
0.0005907776,
0.0271846205,
0.0148237757,
0.0344926491,
0.0045420732,
-0.0253120065,
-0.0760054737,
-0.0293724444,
-0.008218877,
-0.0471042208,
-0.0736307204,
-0.0056582945,
-0.0373834595,
-0.0775002241,
0.0443382785,
-0.0004337326,
0.0102875028,
-0.0077876761,
0.0022985514,
0.0026688888,
0.0208756775,
-0.0529915281,
-0.0354408063,
-0.0354333259,
0.0041877031,
-0.0137177138,
-0.0586823933,
0.025690306,
-0.0240390543,
-0.0045983884,
-0.0243620109,
-0.0110180927,
0.0760146156,
-0.008767914,
-0.0162986927,
-0.035569042,
-0.0348274671,
-0.0017841299,
-0.0172670726,
0.0682275593,
-0.0059146914,
-0.0347060598,
-0.0465030298,
0.0021383886,
-0.016166199,
-0.020605782,
0.0476322472,
0.0387129672,
0.0159526151,
-0.0287336446,
-0.0500867888,
0.0821224153,
0.0062951888,
0.0502871498,
0.0451935902,
-0.0590656921,
-0.037447352,
-0.030997077,
0.0635403618,
-0.087576814,
-0.084440887,
-0.0523981415,
0.0134303197,
0.0255161971,
-0.0662200376,
0.0022739479,
-0.0118746655,
0.0264968984,
0.0416032113,
0.0378482826,
-0.0249633621,
0.0125903236,
-0.0611710176,
-0.0135505525,
-0.0212911367,
0.0060449312,
-0.0417206548,
-0.0032781016,
0.0202936623,
-0.0140217394,
-0.0185359307,
0.0327802785,
-0.0226813778,
-0.0390761234,
-0.000519673,
-0.0012691541,
0.0128373569,
-0.0187984519,
0.0204391368,
-0.0234989375,
0.0639934987,
0.0785175934,
-0.0217515901,
0.0390678346,
0.024424335,
0.043851085,
0.0189449284,
0.0177782774,
0.0375206918,
0.0374692827,
0.0052972073,
-0.0166986007,
-0.068834886,
0.0452670865,
0.0115475925,
0.025500508,
0.006668942,
0.0386140943,
-0.0456312709,
-0.0064550471,
-0.0126136793,
-0.0148410518,
-0.0495240539,
-0.0220626649,
0.0196391027,
-0.0393677764,
0.0165125374,
-0.0640009418,
-0.0409161709,
-0.0302304402,
0.0669354647,
0.0373609066,
0.0104714176,
0.0587792248,
0.0255072135,
-0.0304727908,
-0.0136753283,
0.005278707,
0.0514534861,
-0.027021477,
0.0526881106,
0.0554486401,
-0.0059869844,
0.0081150495,
-0.0348784178,
-0.0290042348,
-0.0042601763,
-0.0299514141,
-0.0024887018,
0.0209595785,
-0.028303979,
0.0296407137,
-0.0065418514,
0.06044982,
-0.0321708061,
0.0050376784,
0.0110976323,
0.0151561592,
-0.0130790845,
-0.0304633304,
-0.0002321703,
0.0153295286,
-0.0289263893,
-0.0428059772,
-0.0243374668,
-0.0609382764,
0.027576942,
0.0684617236,
-0.0233811438,
-0.0256043635,
-0.0625188351,
-0.0193123799,
0.0038823427,
0.0677917898,
0.063014254,
-0.0628196746,
-0.0244992375,
0.0472559854,
-0.0220594741,
0.0276433453,
-0.0108887637,
0.0019779932,
0.0349663682,
0.0171320643,
-0.0043639704,
-0.0427944958,
0.0161227882,
-0.056166824,
-0.006096967,
-0.0333559141,
-5.370372307e-33,
-0.0105589759,
-0.0792350024,
-0.0316288508,
0.0598872751,
0.013316717,
0.0257332139,
-0.0107296538,
0.0211764835,
0.0176492315,
0.0574210323,
-0.0014077784,
0.0150725925,
0.002208845,
0.0013039145,
0.0016674695,
0.0206535812,
0.0268721469,
0.0021993525,
-0.0472224317,
-0.0142392004,
0.0801157355,
-0.0105253803,
0.0265029483,
-0.1090958565,
0.0260041542,
0.0277858153,
-0.0390279107,
0.006207101,
0.0296397917,
0.0571624301,
0.0127531672,
0.0873937607,
0.0190025046,
0.045988217,
-0.0093817106,
0.0883776248,
-0.0382215343,
-0.029706778,
0.0598894991,
0.0112911249,
-0.0073365504,
-0.0659729615,
0.0387822799,
-0.0491959192,
-0.0426248461,
-0.0008475706,
0.0745419264,
-0.0375326388,
0.0590083934,
0.0017866928,
-0.0502897315,
0.0184486844,
-0.0327716731,
0.0453938991,
0.0189864188,
0.0391895622,
0.011595197,
0.044272542,
-0.0312556773,
0.0702147633,
-0.0294520874,
0.0101103634,
-0.0627766624,
-0.0255727787,
0.0133118797,
0.1078213006,
0.0217880476,
0.0109987818,
-0.0147009669,
0.0428080447,
-0.003614994,
0.0460790768,
0.0622300804,
0.0802536085,
0.0405962504,
0.001909734,
-0.0217404123,
-0.0596517697,
0.0166109223,
-0.0145988008,
0.0435910411,
-0.0414798297,
-0.0677919611,
-0.0072357818,
-0.0072067636,
-0.0203957651,
-0.0213516094,
-0.016224619,
0.0055928421,
-0.0194542669,
-0.037436951,
0.0020912846,
-0.0124120601,
-0.030318182,
-0.0133169265,
0.0026038375,
0.0238252915,
0.0388354994,
0.0228579864,
-0.0106833903,
-0.0211765002,
-0.0224467833,
0.0082067372,
0.0185913779,
0.0589446388,
-0.0405773595,
0.0248323753,
-0.0143197998,
-0.0756660998,
-0.0058240253,
0.0240638442,
0.0143789938,
-0.0682315901,
-0.0252326466,
0.0022615027,
0.0111864172,
-0.0162616111,
-0.0152861383,
-0.0110752052,
-0.017044466,
-0.0312676653,
-0.0040877396,
-0.0679253638,
0.0437078029,
-0.0675977692,
-0.0452187881,
-0.0086078485,
-0.0144794835,
0.0533411577,
-0.0756340921,
0.0188563876,
-0.0350135751,
2.363e-7,
0.0379652828,
0.083454825,
0.0465866998,
0.0271661934,
0.0438993871,
0.0431205519,
0.0067113834,
0.0009926503,
0.016179014,
-0.0211022664,
-0.0059328764,
0.0256580487,
0.0073234914,
-0.0214598943,
-0.0953953117,
-0.0029907818,
-0.0489916392,
0.0013596892,
-0.0558869094,
0.0163721051,
0.0507451408,
0.0212875959,
0.0247510411,
-0.0329976156,
-0.0132327583,
-0.0228569638,
0.0300286394,
-0.0838247165,
0.0183026996,
0.0173930675,
-0.0473176688,
-0.0221566502,
0.0100042308,
0.0188356005,
0.0289927535,
0.0129115097,
0.0093724765,
0.0587705187,
0.0478651561,
-0.0198804978,
-0.0306706578,
0.0321115702,
-0.0405854881,
0.0111703873,
0.0387332998,
-0.0204580333,
-0.0517187901,
-0.0268148966,
-0.0075689219,
-0.0273652878,
0.0332954898,
-0.0037232384,
-0.0515430681,
-0.0096567869,
0.0225247033,
-0.0238248631,
0.0160946194,
-0.0549237058,
0.0151803279,
-0.0173268486,
-0.0121136764,
-0.0129710408,
-0.0189817231,
0.0226629879,
-0.0052842246,
-0.086889945,
0.0082220901,
1.897217921e-34,
0.0405598059,
-0.043174766,
0.0412636846,
0.0184160676,
0.0470180549,
0.0361953191,
0.0445308685,
-0.0255543701,
0.0421716496,
-0.0340682603,
0.0117211202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16672v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16672v1 | CAVE: Controllable Authorship Verification Explanations | 2024-06-24T14:27:54 | 2024-06-24T14:27:54 | Sahana Ramnath, Kartik Pandey, Elizabeth Boschee, Xiang Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Authorship Verification (AV) (do two documents have the same author?) is
essential for many sensitive real-life applications. AV is often used in
proprietary domains that require a private, offline model, making SOTA online
models like ChatGPT undesirable. Other SOTA systems use methods, e.g. Siamese
Networks, that are uninterpretable, and hence cannot be trusted in high-stakes
applications. In this work, we take the first step to address the above
challenges with our model CAVE (Controllable Authorship Verification
Explanations): CAVE generates free-text AV explanations that are controlled to
be 1) structured (can be decomposed into sub-explanations with respect to
relevant linguistic features), and 2) easily verified for explanation-label
consistency (via intermediate labels in sub-explanations). In this work, we
train a Llama-3-8B as CAVE; since there are no human-written corpora for AV
explanations, we sample silver-standard explanations from GPT-4-TURBO and
distill them into a pretrained Llama-3-8B. Results on three difficult AV
datasets IMdB2, Blog-Auth, and FanFiction show that CAVE generates high quality
explanations (as measured by automatic and human evaluation) as well as
competitive task accuracies. | [
0.0426590592,
0.0734949559,
0.004645708,
0.0647498593,
-0.0362423025,
0.0292098373,
0.0783416107,
-0.0134649836,
-0.0068366369,
0.0142713189,
-0.0168440975,
-0.0238594227,
0.0106618786,
0.0346224271,
0.0451728143,
-0.0184300151,
-0.0166519862,
-0.0056474623,
0.0710865855,
-0.0050653061,
0.0241695363,
0.044535771,
-0.0109133199,
0.0348440036,
0.0143804327,
-0.0369553491,
-0.0129173873,
0.0031284473,
0.0370800085,
0.0401245914,
0.0083348276,
0.0449821874,
0.0291943029,
0.0568132773,
0.0000018774,
-0.0315512531,
-0.0048857327,
0.0191409234,
-0.0518129356,
0.0333738588,
-0.0070791696,
0.0360250212,
0.0026470511,
0.0209783092,
-0.0008129122,
-0.0031031268,
0.0302115045,
0.0701481029,
0.0785628781,
0.1047277823,
-0.0105116367,
-0.0672790483,
0.013676147,
-0.0430212393,
0.033774741,
-0.041039262,
-0.0001034339,
-0.0153365247,
-0.0153709138,
0.0244880598,
0.0008680657,
0.0245196223,
0.0178780165,
-0.0457063504,
0.0057360688,
0.0359556489,
-0.0336514823,
-0.014710255,
0.045180764,
0.0499315038,
0.0167619996,
-0.0493944623,
0.0322007798,
0.0096574966,
-0.0324928127,
0.0204737037,
-0.0389785171,
0.0462481193,
-0.0380576104,
-0.0168930069,
0.0154163232,
0.0193930343,
0.0372995138,
0.0342550538,
0.0256166328,
0.0266716145,
-0.0135839498,
-0.0059438623,
-0.0514042415,
-0.0076590697,
-0.0091937324,
-0.0707718879,
0.0469165295,
0.0483893864,
-0.0010718646,
-0.0101420488,
-0.0178342368,
-0.0404685512,
-0.0029606663,
-0.014499221,
0.0328663662,
-0.0153970355,
-0.057512816,
0.0658208355,
0.0058496813,
0.0850508586,
-0.0225298014,
0.0437242649,
-0.0002925578,
-0.0144546116,
-0.0531575084,
-0.0131648183,
-0.0215388946,
-0.0145851867,
-0.0161120053,
0.0033131742,
-0.0199820176,
-0.0072600478,
-0.0089591285,
0.0233940408,
0.0015689284,
0.009855967,
-0.0275446773,
-0.0306637846,
-0.0445810705,
-0.0190348737,
-0.0368106067,
0.0130930431,
0.0136906775,
-0.0070700343,
-0.0411734134,
0.0236189961,
0.042149432,
-0.010006465,
0.0382531919,
0.0292528644,
0.0138824172,
-0.0054225493,
0.0134107359,
-0.0440096371,
0.0039713578,
-0.0919225439,
-0.0361786224,
-0.0134854773,
0.0789756253,
-0.0219492149,
-0.0263815094,
-0.0591890216,
-0.0240546502,
0.0187325757,
-0.0147811761,
0.078644298,
-0.0248315092,
-0.0035527984,
0.027121922,
0.0301308166,
-0.0561428852,
-0.0169947445,
0.042821493,
0.0545885265,
0.0530197062,
-0.0106307287,
0.0728365704,
-0.0098716747,
0.0372987129,
-0.0050701168,
0.0520825572,
0.0102844276,
-0.0259173643,
0.0326794721,
0.0206543114,
0.0304676127,
-0.0322811753,
-0.0397883952,
0.0484737828,
0.0531535037,
0.0219246224,
0.0230131075,
0.0611344054,
0.0069174608,
0.0419845879,
0.025062656,
-0.0579137951,
0.0621817037,
0.0011573206,
-0.0207895935,
0.0018950201,
0.0054129977,
-0.0574971028,
-0.0450339541,
0.0058922679,
-0.0079679461,
-0.016336076,
0.0174010266,
0.0297671743,
0.0074750991,
-0.0363483727,
-0.014445453,
-0.0010637848,
-0.0707014576,
0.0022689397,
-0.0890822783,
0.0698215961,
0.0882408991,
0.0534217581,
-0.0328307152,
-0.0035769045,
-0.059407182,
0.0339080878,
0.0545890592,
-0.0157488547,
-0.0145737631,
0.033191707,
-0.0643169135,
-0.0165688321,
-0.0282598976,
0.0198469069,
0.0486660562,
0.0149553269,
-0.0203656126,
0.0369594917,
-0.0338544138,
-0.0174333826,
0.0310671441,
-0.0333771557,
-0.0209635645,
0.0004877621,
0.0192834903,
0.0412245579,
0.0527001247,
-0.0094582066,
-0.0207177438,
0.0058269715,
-0.0368147567,
-0.0639495179,
0.0128727695,
0.0162696019,
-0.0423640907,
0.0261157211,
-0.0284531265,
-0.0159666352,
0.029992098,
-0.0452998318,
-0.0570818,
0.0419353172,
-0.0132161519,
-0.0142132351,
-0.0653338358,
-0.0202079117,
0.0089494837,
0.0153565845,
-0.0253529027,
0.0604095981,
0.011636097,
0.0085362382,
-0.0426386371,
-0.0217753705,
0.0276819225,
-0.0331130028,
0.0184690785,
-0.0029975318,
-0.0237718634,
0.0311366413,
0.0054741949,
-0.0028440575,
0.0007102748,
-0.0557148792,
-0.0450520627,
0.0016215593,
-0.0255318917,
0.0499957129,
0.0190104637,
-0.0410728939,
0.0034516663,
-0.0083335442,
-0.0652968735,
-0.0153163401,
-0.0253041014,
-0.0142049277,
0.0547519475,
0.0092089167,
-0.0571705885,
-0.0487492271,
-0.0023031621,
-0.0205297954,
0.0507215448,
0.0361161977,
0.0027215993,
-0.0434288569,
-0.0220680144,
-0.0336395763,
-0.0105743045,
-0.0430485904,
-0.021110883,
0.0277506784,
-0.0214466248,
-0.0335917659,
0.0404675044,
-0.0090156151,
0.0383091532,
-0.0079298634,
0.0248158127,
-0.0104061402,
-0.0054269419,
-0.00775901,
0.0064472058,
-0.0043448475,
-0.0279477518,
-0.0019216202,
0.0496107191,
-0.0098151956,
-0.0203130413,
-0.0639291927,
0.0166695211,
0.0487858281,
0.0000042193,
0.0288569238,
-0.0765709877,
0.0222257413,
0.0152715771,
-0.0424444228,
-0.0487154983,
0.0732304081,
-0.0775870308,
-0.0186691266,
-0.0135083646,
-0.0340120085,
-0.055698771,
0.0893032029,
-0.0040077376,
0.0308049135,
0.0530296378,
-0.0314389654,
-0.0043847947,
-0.0299682356,
0.0806589648,
-0.0015245344,
-0.0274223313,
-0.0006321252,
0.0196034871,
-0.0032948805,
0.0007464464,
-0.0052654082,
-0.0638038814,
-0.0510324016,
-0.0046872422,
-0.0284931716,
-0.0461513139,
-0.000112584,
-0.0199107137,
0.0377477482,
0.0417958312,
-0.0186172761,
-0.0033914302,
-0.0234192368,
0.0275088344,
0.0093872622,
0.0198021568,
0.0171434544,
-0.0475661904,
0.0007483464,
0.015346542,
0.0025330679,
-0.0030122481,
-0.0340335667,
-0.0242186822,
-0.031061912,
-0.0448626652,
-0.0276050214,
-0.027726341,
0.0386314429,
-0.0668597072,
0.0388801694,
0.1183322519,
0.0033376019,
-0.0362310782,
-0.0261681136,
0.0123810358,
-0.0307816211,
0.001749562,
0.0122644743,
-0.0719874874,
-0.0126025649,
-0.0042176498,
0.0333960801,
0.0243069325,
-0.017407665,
-0.0367910452,
-0.0225753933,
0.0540114865,
-0.0133620752,
-0.0537746735,
-0.0013019866,
-0.0575733706,
-0.0424430557,
-0.0238692258,
-0.0218977425,
-0.0031726051,
0.0274553616,
0.0334160924,
0.0122763887,
0.0197771862,
-0.0209804494,
0.0465743467,
-0.0517928936,
0.052906651,
0.0529272333,
0.0739108697,
-0.0145238219,
-0.0248750318,
-0.017581081,
-0.0176995508,
0.0025165621,
0.0039084777,
0.1130617559,
-0.0149091184,
-0.013918018,
-0.032198377,
0.069030039,
-0.0524536036,
-0.0144572519,
-0.0054632253,
0.0520399697,
-0.0119198179,
-0.0368474983,
-0.0037670336,
0.0029116615,
0.0153322788,
0.0760503784,
0.0409802273,
-0.009536732,
-0.0609208085,
-0.010945715,
0.0071591856,
-0.0330929607,
0.0027328876,
-0.0382439122,
-0.0002166773,
-0.0421698578,
-0.0417326093,
-0.0225329157,
-0.0307438243,
0.0235184412,
-0.002676077,
0.0075105708,
0.002382196,
-0.024963405,
-0.0441155955,
0.0319452211,
-0.0563123375,
0.0535164773,
0.0214374494,
0.0136940563,
0.0265569463,
-0.0366621576,
-0.0054693413,
0.0031675366,
-0.0690317675,
-0.0433982573,
-0.0392802767,
-0.0014511537,
0.0337813236,
0.0608961321,
-0.0333925895,
-0.1051329598,
0.0013417086,
0.0085192248,
-0.0383676663,
0.0175470039,
0.0559911579,
-0.0222437605,
-0.0189038254,
0.0360343941,
-0.0191005971,
0.0362049043,
0.0015767536,
-0.0284381118,
0.0076730633,
0.0043087578,
-0.0234330166,
0.0209194534,
0.0094081508,
-0.0177744161,
0.0029394226,
-0.0498416685,
0.0199867077,
-0.0327682942,
0.0025433288,
-0.0261363052,
0.0118177542,
0.0051356005,
-0.0519584343,
-0.0056772819,
-0.0069502322,
-0.0347812772,
0.0419522673,
-0.0334790163,
0.0144104157,
0.0189022683,
0.0218478385,
-0.0299986973,
0.0144181196,
-0.0127342725,
-0.0117388619,
0.0079095354,
0.0596118048,
-0.0055619935,
0.0444643572,
0.0272255931,
0.0160507411,
-0.0056934985,
0.0165816974,
-0.1011015996,
0.0067204051,
0.0060571097,
0.0228890013,
0.0487453751,
0.0063249879,
0.0441049114,
0.0078197829,
-0.0018974344,
-0.0167329013,
0.0787863508,
0.0170071516,
-0.0162015129,
-0.013212299,
0.0167483781,
-0.0356689468,
0.0271258596,
0.088308461,
0.0421088673,
0.0174139496,
0.0097768484,
-0.0246095248,
0.0176413767,
-0.0396218412,
-0.0371212289,
0.0514878258,
0.0133382063,
-0.0372455344,
-0.0388358757,
-0.0458441861,
0.0383102298,
0.0096270535,
0.008686088,
0.0084346728,
-0.0090373261,
0.053046383,
0.0125669884,
-0.0185054112,
-0.0280390177,
0.0226525925,
-0.0218767393,
-0.0163843967,
0.0230247341,
-5.981577575e-33,
0.0014742285,
-0.0677446201,
-0.0053182752,
0.0242672581,
-0.0367941335,
0.0400994383,
-0.0573267229,
-0.0465034209,
-0.016407026,
0.0518174209,
-0.0097268922,
0.045711536,
0.0132462615,
-0.0014246537,
-0.0345892198,
-0.0299782492,
0.0306155104,
0.0165161621,
-0.0314594209,
0.0754876733,
0.0567132607,
0.0003527196,
0.0421553254,
-0.1059623957,
0.0354087688,
-0.0421957001,
-0.0794087946,
0.0003163818,
-0.0332036763,
0.0523363203,
-0.0347221345,
0.0288396478,
0.0149638886,
0.0005632397,
0.0175968148,
0.0104295397,
-0.1018564105,
-0.0297646243,
0.0094568245,
0.0030970473,
0.0138190575,
-0.0459149368,
0.0292139556,
-0.025174655,
0.0258511398,
-0.0215084665,
0.0615313537,
0.004278129,
0.0081324307,
-0.0338798128,
-0.027638115,
0.0237912871,
-0.0358413346,
-0.0411950089,
0.0378387272,
0.0002698174,
0.017658947,
-0.0277199149,
-0.056925226,
-0.0019011282,
-0.0131731303,
-0.0141142905,
0.0287283957,
0.0096987272,
-0.0320564657,
0.0364266485,
0.0302879047,
0.000777657,
-0.0617807917,
0.0072198799,
-0.0033516658,
0.0390475132,
0.0883651748,
0.0599605553,
0.0109591419,
0.006994579,
-0.08435224,
0.0512747988,
0.0075867809,
0.0054416782,
0.0281001758,
0.0048835962,
-0.0674356818,
-0.0361857787,
-0.0321040079,
-0.0408948958,
-0.039506983,
-0.0198111497,
0.007270813,
-0.0038929002,
-0.0346282832,
-0.0156875532,
-0.0189602673,
-0.0720999688,
0.010895215,
0.0311004985,
-0.0349047892,
0.0169764217,
0.0119695794,
-0.0130542982,
-0.0222147461,
-0.0128558455,
0.0102728307,
0.0404662117,
0.0547027327,
-0.0068713939,
0.0889231414,
0.0594141297,
-0.0423537642,
-0.0029488071,
-0.046928294,
0.0049212547,
-0.0110031012,
0.0255033113,
-0.0067205238,
0.0320984237,
-0.0285264887,
0.0531688407,
0.0034187839,
0.0369272754,
-0.0245003179,
0.0143445889,
-0.021029992,
0.0184822921,
-0.0220316779,
-0.0037645986,
0.0253839456,
-0.0456151813,
0.0265537351,
-0.0588076971,
0.0096429763,
-0.0102378549,
2.532e-7,
0.0091695618,
0.0125835733,
0.0803126469,
-0.0299184937,
0.0334306993,
0.0524235964,
0.0287568457,
0.0233571958,
-0.0440567099,
-0.030529378,
0.0100734178,
0.0386744961,
0.0682628229,
0.0313149951,
-0.0248158611,
0.0015312663,
-0.0345932245,
-0.0372970551,
-0.0568305291,
-0.0020202335,
0.078162916,
0.0403283164,
0.0833983347,
-0.030724261,
0.0119280117,
-0.0503384992,
0.0650535524,
0.0332619026,
-0.0041483021,
0.0343165547,
0.0516380109,
0.0035881395,
-0.0002839708,
-0.0165625997,
-0.0129545154,
0.0174670704,
-0.0020900592,
0.0958981365,
-0.0151660778,
0.0000711396,
-0.0128157446,
-0.054912813,
0.0124370465,
-0.0418230109,
0.0835941434,
0.0316743143,
-0.0289654825,
-0.0216159914,
-0.033811368,
-0.0359425507,
0.0124599542,
-0.0187346339,
0.0156953204,
0.0404948033,
-0.0173143707,
-0.0361302048,
0.0035680635,
-0.1017862633,
-0.0454734713,
-0.0006576233,
-0.0275033787,
0.027096523,
-0.0109101273,
0.0128673194,
0.0553475581,
-0.0666791052,
0.0171793476,
2.317960754e-34,
0.0327306651,
-0.0058924295,
-0.0021406556,
0.0038681212,
0.0329641961,
0.0326310769,
-0.0162158646,
0.0137275485,
0.0231303647,
-0.0300095864,
-0.0103234956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16655v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16655v1 | Large Language Models Are Cross-Lingual Knowledge-Free Reasoners | 2024-06-24T14:03:04 | 2024-06-24T14:03:04 | Peng Hu, Sizhe Liu, Changjiang Gao, Xin Huang, Xue Han, Junlan Feng, Chao Deng, Shujian Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models have demonstrated impressive reasoning capabilities
across multiple languages. However, the relationship between capabilities in
different languages is less explored. In this work, we decompose the process of
reasoning tasks into two separated parts: knowledge retrieval and
knowledge-free reasoning, and analyze the cross-lingual transferability of
them. With adapted and constructed knowledge-free reasoning datasets, we show
that the knowledge-free reasoning capability can be nearly perfectly
transferred across various source-target language directions despite the
secondary impact of resource in some specific target languages, while
cross-lingual knowledge retrieval significantly hinders the transfer. Moreover,
by analyzing the hidden states and feed-forward network neuron activation
during the reasoning tasks, we show that higher similarity of hidden
representations and larger overlap of activated neurons could explain the
better cross-lingual transferability of knowledge-free reasoning than knowledge
retrieval. Thus, we hypothesize that knowledge-free reasoning embeds in some
language-shared mechanism, while knowledge is stored separately in different
languages. | [
-0.0113550387,
0.0292700417,
-0.0205717869,
0.0753234774,
-0.0298371669,
0.0369766578,
0.0593555719,
0.0032622034,
0.0034952306,
-0.0129268123,
-0.0737198666,
-0.0115310447,
-0.0003262022,
0.0069185356,
0.0334655009,
0.0050076586,
0.0627950579,
-0.0609384552,
0.0216960553,
-0.0292214323,
-0.0221390706,
0.0069844178,
-0.0048464192,
0.01549464,
0.0211175755,
0.0102769136,
-0.0044442099,
-0.0409269854,
0.002859418,
0.0174316987,
-0.0373979174,
0.0102575673,
0.0155240474,
0.0587867312,
0.0000018433,
-0.0228359196,
0.0131056868,
-0.0097271306,
-0.0225396119,
0.0017858034,
-0.0207978822,
-0.0072110551,
-0.0110429255,
-0.0254970267,
0.0005607481,
-0.0355588011,
0.0625749826,
0.0573143363,
0.0003523942,
0.0687796623,
-0.0076667122,
-0.0304031335,
0.0182016343,
-0.0421954356,
0.0437086746,
-0.0277166516,
0.0205579512,
0.0182471331,
-0.0252953656,
-0.0021431413,
-0.0192501117,
0.0619192831,
0.0397995897,
-0.0165413581,
-0.0516700856,
0.0360225886,
0.0119888894,
-0.0083654309,
0.0254454128,
0.034564089,
-0.039036762,
-0.0426860452,
-0.0031710828,
-0.0022848779,
-0.0049575814,
0.0327606015,
-0.0756824389,
0.0592028722,
0.0109136505,
0.0387715138,
0.052910462,
-0.0082935207,
0.0682181418,
-0.0178227779,
-0.0418140143,
0.0905441642,
0.0052833338,
-0.0108040906,
0.035585627,
-0.0021818066,
-0.0113806855,
-0.0660474598,
0.0027194228,
0.0312196333,
0.0183385257,
0.0326632187,
0.0209509488,
0.0075105526,
-0.0189557895,
-0.0378030315,
0.0307791103,
0.0604038276,
-0.008546955,
0.0655844286,
-0.1011980698,
0.0349535048,
-0.0535596795,
0.0513924211,
-0.020748565,
-0.0509367548,
-0.0598030537,
-0.0563166291,
0.0148598049,
0.006106839,
-0.0310612116,
-0.0125451954,
-0.0124684805,
-0.0026577094,
-0.0382555313,
-0.0252745152,
0.0157912727,
0.0161319673,
0.0288410094,
-0.0093637146,
-0.0469269715,
0.0484625809,
-0.0172565412,
0.0189691707,
0.0268131029,
-0.0207755622,
-0.0162220132,
0.0082293339,
-0.0016401816,
-0.0635534078,
0.0283876602,
0.0356924571,
-0.0277317483,
0.0158278961,
-0.0915519372,
-0.0074149254,
0.0239869393,
-0.056547042,
0.0580484457,
-0.0506865904,
0.0428895205,
0.0185250938,
-0.0009104504,
-0.0528034754,
-0.0009086674,
-0.001531845,
-0.0533493236,
0.0487201326,
-0.006474846,
0.0242556985,
0.0139745576,
0.0023418185,
-0.0195241477,
0.0211700536,
-0.0032398754,
-0.0100672273,
0.0204133019,
-0.0210461989,
-0.0442219488,
-0.0024885146,
0.0509551726,
-0.0208496451,
-0.0435481854,
-0.0086092893,
0.0276587848,
-0.0069338614,
0.0338542908,
0.0179777965,
-0.0370286964,
-0.0287589505,
0.0202843938,
0.0681805611,
0.0291133504,
0.0296873413,
0.0527280159,
-0.0521919392,
0.0043401946,
-0.0181056373,
-0.0609377921,
0.0816957653,
-0.0181234032,
-0.0206951536,
0.0162430834,
0.0175753683,
-0.0624083206,
-0.01614503,
0.0239294861,
-0.0022925588,
0.018035708,
0.0260833595,
0.0616110861,
0.0173360892,
-0.0096692741,
0.0592013933,
0.0506678894,
-0.0373808965,
-0.0110054109,
-0.0468479469,
0.069407478,
0.0251320135,
-0.0332200415,
-0.0004822165,
-0.0166298877,
0.02442321,
0.0230587125,
0.0274833422,
0.0302944109,
0.0096681435,
0.04341048,
-0.0399165116,
0.0070082336,
-0.0627040043,
-0.0011507323,
0.0268746186,
-0.044208046,
0.0229185671,
0.0135871377,
-0.0269824564,
-0.0010725277,
-0.0025817882,
-0.0615437776,
0.0000759273,
-0.0099042589,
0.0287714228,
0.0006822285,
-0.007484871,
-0.0080087725,
0.0379834995,
-0.010166971,
-0.0536907129,
-0.0261463393,
0.0476837829,
-0.0515291169,
-0.043424055,
0.0170860104,
0.0156118749,
0.0080477362,
0.0055183042,
0.0161517244,
-0.0472801924,
0.0578774251,
0.0017137401,
0.0620002598,
-0.056946788,
0.005423604,
-0.003423742,
0.0197171364,
0.0354668833,
0.0978941843,
0.0235480722,
0.0378912501,
0.0088521065,
-0.0037873506,
0.0639771968,
-0.0055058668,
-0.0120894406,
0.0284153204,
-0.0252917595,
-0.026898358,
-0.0183722526,
-0.0383693799,
0.0061689126,
0.0337227359,
-0.0670250952,
-0.008155142,
0.0114329271,
0.0129080862,
0.007269992,
0.00437601,
0.0250219647,
0.0267070588,
-0.0632051677,
0.0387039296,
0.0371839255,
0.0570469312,
0.0033671348,
-0.0124242716,
9.684e-7,
-0.0375991873,
-0.0475794747,
-0.0080321999,
0.0844693929,
0.0002036495,
0.0042569139,
-0.0238804575,
0.0556031317,
-0.0772297829,
0.0239448119,
-0.0455390401,
-0.0475794263,
0.0121550616,
-0.0337469839,
-0.0365840755,
0.0786892474,
-0.0644426718,
-0.0381002538,
0.0784208328,
-0.0361141339,
-0.0385232158,
0.0131512946,
-0.0218003336,
0.0325518735,
-0.0411728919,
0.009215218,
-0.0223547965,
0.0775294527,
0.0082005588,
-0.0416397192,
-0.0658397526,
0.0055009048,
-0.0236644875,
-0.0154501628,
-0.0525026768,
-0.0091162575,
0.0256869886,
0.0920426473,
-0.039277669,
-0.0079426738,
0.0599536635,
-0.004323218,
-0.0137908356,
0.0006870237,
-0.0044713472,
-0.0156691186,
0.0649194121,
-0.0196264125,
0.0459737033,
0.0005525474,
-0.0141503112,
-0.0235975571,
-0.0483917259,
0.0206510983,
0.0012899607,
0.0115591474,
-0.0084491819,
-0.0042328313,
0.0029215298,
-0.014570375,
-0.0153642725,
0.023835903,
-0.0228900947,
0.0301415808,
0.0006444745,
-0.0348990411,
-0.0159972962,
-0.003272583,
0.0720780492,
0.0257658809,
-0.0217002109,
0.009871752,
0.0043295287,
0.026424855,
-0.0121331187,
0.0009093549,
0.038658943,
-0.0312819295,
0.0158838201,
0.0233503785,
0.0085163377,
0.0104367305,
-0.0124978647,
0.0538643375,
0.0329474285,
0.0145054134,
-0.0561461858,
-0.0543682501,
0.0545374528,
-0.0386249945,
-0.0044739149,
0.091299586,
0.0122827366,
-0.0312370639,
-0.0058258981,
-0.0841867998,
-0.0164510831,
0.0529366359,
0.0438050032,
-0.0288766958,
-0.0192777142,
0.0185327046,
-0.0239316039,
0.0065183183,
-0.0135874422,
-0.0102028539,
-0.1279373765,
0.0113382088,
0.00652115,
-0.0558048561,
-0.0616834946,
-0.0254105069,
-0.0051142406,
0.0193796325,
-0.0070671909,
0.0198703539,
0.0194748361,
-0.0210441668,
0.0009484138,
0.0257860273,
-0.0393779464,
0.0395207405,
-0.0248293243,
0.044283282,
0.0203428455,
0.0390806608,
-0.0046974397,
-0.0795125663,
0.0361750312,
-0.0287854038,
0.0155759156,
-0.0189903434,
0.0255180784,
0.0572508425,
-0.0387054011,
-0.0128624318,
0.0023397568,
-0.0408241004,
-0.0283098146,
-0.0257189777,
0.1030749306,
-0.0077836243,
-0.0433765985,
0.0431993306,
0.0076779509,
-0.038128864,
0.0649310276,
0.0289462395,
0.0058107558,
-0.0376358479,
-0.0086042639,
-0.0481134914,
-0.032458216,
-0.0492081717,
0.0420706756,
0.0379493348,
-0.0488977432,
-0.0436042361,
-0.0279403795,
0.024198791,
0.0080384156,
0.02398251,
0.0164559949,
-0.0053282273,
-0.0460761227,
-0.0253945496,
0.0440699048,
-0.024257239,
0.0233793221,
0.0014507766,
0.0014671525,
-0.010912287,
-0.066536434,
-0.0227385964,
-0.0318803079,
-0.0118283341,
-0.0735090598,
-0.0304038636,
0.0315428488,
0.023796007,
0.0141486879,
-0.0097424844,
-0.0320915617,
0.0201989319,
-0.0138354795,
-0.0333977975,
0.0058545009,
0.0341582783,
-0.0131460009,
0.0292080548,
0.0607745498,
-0.0318621919,
-0.0258657001,
0.0618477538,
0.0238754991,
-0.0031769369,
0.0453030989,
0.011016855,
-0.002225861,
-0.0112895425,
0.0538969897,
-0.0084327264,
-0.0735512301,
-0.0041509084,
-0.0193282478,
-0.0010797089,
-0.0398156159,
-0.0138375089,
0.053936474,
0.0069778226,
0.019456571,
-0.0311920159,
0.0488524698,
-0.0206769034,
0.0141504863,
-0.0145980222,
0.0352476276,
0.0280732904,
0.0002074046,
0.0172100943,
0.00281243,
0.0068791974,
-0.0189089403,
0.0274551362,
-0.0413873568,
0.0420942791,
0.0198241044,
-0.0271798763,
-0.0463769175,
-0.0197593123,
-0.0738923848,
-0.0952060223,
0.0833395571,
-0.0376546681,
0.0719411075,
-0.0544177182,
0.0465055704,
-0.0138648478,
0.0030389982,
-0.0009645091,
0.0140147386,
0.0302090514,
-0.0162062515,
0.0421934612,
0.0165933166,
0.0161228161,
-0.0274016093,
0.0652268901,
-0.0194025096,
0.035345953,
-0.0153261442,
-0.0243077632,
0.0065189395,
-0.0056592966,
0.0248725414,
0.0170482118,
-0.0404022448,
0.0174368117,
-0.0251029078,
-0.1159788668,
-0.0266345199,
0.0205636136,
-0.0190264545,
0.01380031,
-0.0137743028,
0.0645395964,
0.0118201301,
-0.0277948119,
-0.020150952,
0.0348722264,
-0.0197783802,
0.010613597,
-0.011399813,
-5.983075595e-33,
0.0071448605,
0.0049607176,
0.0192689244,
-0.0146514475,
0.0096171713,
-0.0210546739,
-0.0803084895,
0.0068828217,
-0.0394480042,
0.0470534563,
-0.0190751739,
0.0091881435,
0.0088116433,
0.0193287749,
0.0166217759,
-0.0096849874,
-0.0051687751,
0.0323627926,
-0.004361249,
0.0440771654,
0.0933569819,
0.0159504563,
0.0686809272,
-0.0530903973,
0.0427673645,
0.0080597531,
0.0558439195,
0.0638752729,
-0.0526384376,
0.046080146,
-0.0123489546,
0.0216873139,
0.0328060985,
-0.0421499349,
-0.0064357854,
-0.0153142652,
-0.0695266947,
-0.0544500649,
0.0788907781,
-0.0163518973,
0.0036254765,
-0.0513119139,
0.0358619317,
-0.0249383207,
0.0340308212,
-0.0042908695,
0.017884789,
-0.0135446945,
0.0039808359,
0.0278040301,
-0.0594865531,
-0.0100443987,
-0.0117310425,
-0.0108791776,
0.0260379612,
0.0275823977,
-0.0312392786,
-0.0154497065,
-0.071429126,
0.0158411022,
-0.0606048033,
0.0442291684,
0.0773227289,
-0.0043971688,
0.0300371908,
0.0367605016,
0.0518472344,
-0.0008512374,
-0.025934618,
-0.0016567622,
0.0100782765,
0.0439449139,
0.0439928882,
0.0000628553,
0.0414947905,
-0.0311361048,
-0.0708022416,
-0.0412372239,
-0.0123924622,
0.0216183458,
0.0508059263,
-0.0114193894,
0.0310237035,
-0.0458384305,
-0.0297020096,
-0.0188990477,
-0.0484924912,
-0.0319237337,
0.0339541212,
-0.0302260946,
0.0247513615,
-0.0362732746,
0.0390662327,
-0.0353500508,
0.0229130555,
0.080502145,
0.0306921825,
-0.005328944,
-0.0017420335,
-0.0001853719,
-0.0680142418,
-0.018888399,
-0.0375528522,
-0.021463614,
-0.0013408629,
0.0299334265,
0.0318104774,
0.0386136472,
-0.0068851998,
-0.0150621049,
-0.0774395466,
-0.0299813487,
-0.0095097134,
0.0590809397,
0.0187064372,
0.0304764267,
-0.0292054638,
-0.0180278085,
0.0081171989,
0.0005283313,
-0.0097011868,
0.0343795381,
-0.0075650383,
0.0224099886,
-0.0360921286,
-0.0263868906,
-0.0948368162,
0.0547865108,
0.022008149,
-0.040167965,
-0.0172697473,
0.0423446,
2.674e-7,
0.0284204949,
-0.0134136407,
-0.0216081664,
0.0208556298,
0.0353096128,
0.0163010359,
-0.0346346647,
-0.0543489009,
0.0342358761,
-0.0435968749,
-0.0562212728,
0.0748624206,
0.0388085544,
0.0559192151,
-0.0297733434,
-0.0086513394,
-0.0091465823,
-0.0345806442,
-0.007932731,
-0.0234754495,
0.0068217418,
0.0468333885,
0.0217284802,
-0.0270776544,
0.0506262667,
-0.0608917512,
0.0774520412,
-0.0143559752,
0.0255736783,
-0.0395537838,
0.0176300108,
-0.0187956002,
0.0008391163,
0.0267053377,
0.0179255437,
0.0272948109,
-0.0089880675,
0.0360974371,
0.0040570982,
-0.0209015403,
-0.0307871532,
-0.0298227873,
-0.0109060248,
-0.0774323568,
0.0831443518,
-0.0430097319,
-0.0537150316,
0.0298099667,
0.0286433529,
0.0149349356,
0.0105118696,
-0.0011900004,
-0.0153222876,
-0.0232883673,
0.0191998146,
0.0031503383,
-0.0013051464,
-0.0625752434,
-0.0365853123,
0.0091902949,
-0.0411544405,
-0.0218705852,
-0.0355591699,
-0.0270315539,
0.0618776865,
-0.014076788,
0.0079416372,
2.06229808e-34,
-0.0201576818,
0.0066177892,
0.0364953764,
-0.0200565215,
0.0141345626,
-0.0199245214,
-0.0071899681,
-0.0237245392,
-0.0028650078,
-0.0598508492,
-0.0412385538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16635v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16635v1 | ShadowLLM: Predictor-based Contextual Sparsity for Large Language Models | 2024-06-24T13:41:08 | 2024-06-24T13:41:08 | Yash Akhauri, Ahmed F AbouElhamayed, Jordan Dotzel, Zhiru Zhang, Alexander M Rush, Safeen Huda, Mohamed S Abdelfattah | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The high power consumption and latency-sensitive deployments of large
language models (LLMs) have motivated techniques like quantization and
sparsity. Contextual sparsity, where the sparsity pattern is input-dependent,
is crucial in LLMs because the permanent removal of attention heads or neurons
from LLMs can significantly degrade accuracy. Prior work has attempted to model
contextual sparsity using neural networks trained to predict activation
magnitudes, which can be used to dynamically prune structures with low
predicted activation magnitude. In this paper, we look beyond magnitude-based
pruning criteria to assess attention head and neuron importance in LLMs. We
developed a novel predictor called ShadowLLM, which can shadow the LLM behavior
and enforce better sparsity patterns, resulting in over 15% improvement in
end-to-end accuracy without increasing latency compared to previous methods.
ShadowLLM achieves up to a 20\% speed-up over the state-of-the-art DejaVu
framework. These enhancements are validated on models with up to 30 billion
parameters. Our code is available at
\href{https://github.com/abdelfattah-lab/shadow_llm/}{ShadowLLM}. | [
-0.0039187148,
0.0891858116,
-0.0042310557,
0.049158372,
-0.0035731802,
-0.012864273,
0.0183339082,
-0.0019499186,
-0.0335988104,
0.0005214768,
-0.0200428516,
-0.0494949967,
0.0114261908,
0.0098287156,
0.0297016185,
-0.0168095678,
0.0604931265,
-0.0266702995,
-0.022348078,
-0.0052684685,
0.020990612,
0.004937809,
0.0265100244,
0.0551945679,
0.0043820054,
-0.0167436004,
-0.0218708646,
0.0125296284,
0.0080591673,
-0.0201250892,
0.0126437843,
0.0690247715,
-0.0025152571,
0.0475224704,
0.000002222,
-0.0061996798,
0.0299461447,
-0.0064735492,
-0.0440550409,
0.0518792272,
0.008020794,
-0.0042601726,
-0.0107429391,
-0.0064352248,
0.0057061329,
-0.0071675349,
0.0676746443,
0.0071189869,
0.0403963104,
0.0719951019,
0.0021850169,
0.0218697116,
0.0338158756,
-0.0538746044,
0.0328051895,
-0.0164046362,
0.0075428612,
-0.0301012993,
-0.0579856485,
-0.0022388271,
-0.0185736138,
0.0464826822,
0.0432785973,
0.0183839351,
0.0019618084,
0.034427058,
-0.0380987674,
-0.0120517006,
0.0042509176,
0.0543059334,
-0.0674250275,
-0.0462115072,
0.0062388582,
-0.00380091,
-0.0263604075,
-0.0547042489,
-0.0706599727,
-0.0050992277,
0.0364799611,
0.0342263766,
-0.0000313439,
-0.0084794825,
0.0725733936,
0.0173044037,
-0.0177868195,
0.0215854906,
0.0134879006,
-0.0136203207,
-0.0320767947,
-0.0088155968,
-0.0354570374,
-0.0500120148,
-0.0050556483,
0.014871249,
-0.0239700861,
0.0070480392,
-0.0580381528,
-0.0386799388,
0.0224466324,
-0.0127785392,
0.0577748977,
0.0409374423,
0.0067858598,
0.0308985915,
-0.0379654169,
0.049851723,
-0.0244319625,
0.005087777,
-0.0051482064,
0.0157255437,
-0.000609944,
0.0098374728,
0.0125358375,
0.0427822582,
-0.0140186017,
-0.0267285462,
-0.0219258852,
0.0119927516,
-0.0270202402,
-0.0471080802,
-0.002725583,
0.0398185439,
-0.0317363515,
0.0040946607,
0.0150949499,
0.0366696678,
-0.0187252164,
0.0073086102,
-0.0181038361,
-0.0596019849,
-0.0337887593,
0.0377901383,
0.0147523545,
-0.0523933135,
0.0174931083,
0.0514274612,
-0.0021296896,
-0.0359659605,
-0.0342641585,
0.0063307509,
0.0009189656,
-0.0623280816,
-0.0155261792,
-0.0718204528,
-0.0120347915,
-0.0140913296,
0.0131350644,
-0.0691637173,
0.0189661235,
0.0472942293,
-0.0170243979,
0.0467941798,
0.0348535404,
-0.009087868,
-0.0276730843,
-0.0032470175,
0.0230399556,
0.0625818148,
0.0264752712,
0.0511760898,
-0.0135930572,
0.0017751093,
-0.0301685762,
0.0323279165,
0.0521046147,
0.0197152831,
-0.0673454404,
-0.0317546763,
-0.0234401394,
0.0043842094,
0.089702934,
0.0645041987,
-0.0195011925,
-0.0332423039,
0.0818337798,
0.03607646,
0.0187403075,
0.0344863944,
0.0260333288,
-0.009151102,
-0.0338956453,
-0.0096337851,
-0.0733270645,
0.0662666634,
-0.0096847555,
0.0100315567,
0.0351000354,
0.0183038935,
-0.0383478813,
-0.0110867489,
-0.0024168668,
0.0142119406,
0.0081603397,
0.0387940928,
0.0206176471,
-0.0012848708,
-0.0397068337,
0.1166618541,
0.0313142613,
-0.029594576,
-0.0201497823,
-0.0478715003,
-0.0064125378,
0.016940631,
0.0324431546,
-0.0148213198,
-0.0177671649,
0.0172341336,
0.0041799964,
0.0303687919,
0.0050530578,
0.0186816566,
0.0458767414,
-0.037299037,
0.0073330072,
-0.0262584407,
0.0246230587,
0.0030691097,
0.0370615236,
0.0183645785,
0.0294899009,
0.0038312494,
-0.0211291388,
0.0412574075,
-0.0175556261,
-0.0461162739,
0.0077199996,
-0.0016951218,
0.0406503491,
-0.026970163,
-0.0007190275,
0.0151214022,
0.0527339876,
-0.0568509847,
0.0458981544,
-0.0333384611,
-0.0756204799,
-0.0343026966,
0.0499668419,
0.0354010761,
0.0366438329,
0.0733416677,
-0.0321274102,
-0.0377074443,
0.0536136627,
-0.0341906436,
0.035136804,
-0.0450088717,
0.0108181061,
-0.0194220189,
0.0530945398,
-0.0140112685,
0.0272313226,
-0.0420913883,
0.0290470812,
0.0711309016,
0.0210857745,
-0.0156146558,
-0.0429687612,
-0.0357479118,
-0.0471755937,
-0.0319323093,
0.0236791801,
-0.0076679564,
0.0054023867,
0.0114918714,
-0.0022192237,
-0.0736556277,
0.0074403794,
-0.0431054719,
0.0056981277,
0.021465214,
0.0448922813,
0.0399679206,
-0.0043185633,
0.006073337,
0.0136250481,
-0.0190061312,
0.0273288954,
-0.0162025485,
-0.0148904026,
-0.0375202149,
-0.0535184741,
-0.0519305058,
0.0242761876,
0.0510425605,
-0.0430371463,
-0.0387810171,
-0.0192388184,
0.0530754961,
0.0080427816,
0.0465081371,
-0.0141738839,
-0.0424734019,
0.0081281038,
-0.0156518016,
-0.0017605992,
0.0662498549,
-0.0193545576,
0.0248014312,
0.0889818892,
0.0073224385,
-0.0381971374,
0.03168815,
-0.0238208193,
0.0112664392,
-0.0437511206,
-0.0191833675,
-0.0063887057,
0.0825670063,
-0.0075774784,
-0.0097029842,
-0.0402596444,
-0.0026470704,
-0.0010431365,
-0.0261753388,
-0.0254720952,
0.0083031431,
-0.0611204207,
0.0461339578,
-0.0289974716,
-0.055274751,
0.0373707749,
-0.0420230068,
-0.007599398,
0.0247938726,
0.0045115361,
-0.0277819578,
0.0429687612,
0.0421948731,
0.0195254516,
-0.0177624226,
-0.0252154544,
-0.061322514,
0.0065448117,
-0.0470616519,
0.0043603894,
0.0426824801,
-0.0185055658,
0.0146789039,
-0.0068150377,
-0.0273637716,
-0.0238351747,
0.0020021775,
-0.0256169755,
0.0393187255,
0.0324416235,
-0.0276632067,
-0.0446762666,
0.0248949025,
0.0018852992,
0.0748036429,
-0.0106947022,
0.0037746558,
-0.0220495034,
0.0266369171,
0.0483234338,
0.0339814052,
0.0361170806,
-0.0202515051,
-0.0238226764,
0.0517456979,
0.023042975,
0.0145378364,
-0.0625005439,
-0.0025780285,
0.0240772888,
0.0181159172,
0.0075613689,
0.021019375,
0.0452851765,
-0.0882931799,
-0.0218964461,
0.0845704749,
-0.0006978253,
-0.0693129599,
0.0229140781,
-0.0061619366,
0.0794897527,
0.0521785989,
0.0206743311,
-0.0377324708,
-0.0509421378,
0.0176529102,
0.0123935519,
0.0115006957,
-0.0104293684,
0.0014514778,
-0.0785343274,
0.0128432922,
0.0027510561,
-0.0468000025,
0.002229756,
-0.033347901,
0.009736117,
-0.0226847418,
0.0299386177,
0.0303874314,
-0.005558026,
-0.0282790679,
0.003726478,
-0.0141894817,
-0.0414723083,
0.0501059741,
-0.0074267471,
0.0399472043,
0.0557956658,
0.0090656113,
0.003103435,
-0.0194455311,
0.0420336239,
-0.0404344797,
0.0067049772,
-0.0082643349,
0.0224442817,
0.0298074819,
-0.0157762077,
-0.0045942483,
-0.0018766326,
-0.0240871664,
-0.0083511034,
-0.0352563336,
0.0759144872,
-0.0136957066,
-0.008224641,
-0.0218059793,
-0.0234313048,
-0.0235478729,
0.055038292,
0.0754974559,
-0.0232931823,
-0.052144438,
-0.0055303867,
-0.0350567326,
-0.0615572631,
-0.0524842478,
-0.0014164998,
0.0391319431,
-0.0649676248,
-0.028800467,
0.0001886388,
0.020040568,
0.0082055144,
-0.0213877987,
0.019152537,
-0.0057568536,
-0.0055664489,
-0.0511584617,
0.0468614735,
-0.0169788413,
0.0192567874,
-0.0740301087,
0.0180845764,
-0.0130840465,
-0.0097572245,
-0.0139622288,
-0.0008575171,
-0.146027416,
-0.0666654855,
0.0002108418,
0.0636116415,
0.0181757119,
0.0384299122,
-0.0099836066,
-0.0764801949,
0.0587610304,
0.026295118,
-0.033042267,
0.0532048419,
0.0096245296,
-0.0543904006,
-0.0066366945,
0.0631745234,
-0.0247569121,
0.0222609788,
0.0373996682,
0.0595013238,
-0.0310608875,
0.0024700835,
-0.0037517466,
-0.0037548691,
0.0276700165,
0.0036986482,
-0.0036638612,
-0.0220973473,
0.023090506,
0.0274273362,
0.0179499108,
-0.0433726311,
-0.0079564312,
0.0035363149,
0.0062385011,
-0.004129794,
-0.0279577505,
0.023398133,
-0.0348729864,
-0.0154733071,
0.0389192551,
0.0103869503,
-0.0119590778,
0.0663269982,
0.0207208525,
-0.0252324771,
0.010628039,
-0.0295445416,
0.0160254668,
-0.0335964933,
-0.0313990973,
0.0031337363,
0.000272191,
-0.0746707097,
0.0177118033,
-0.0476444438,
-0.0425960198,
-0.0417553671,
-0.0136720082,
0.0345381759,
-0.0057332288,
0.0652472228,
-0.003249811,
-0.0171067808,
-0.0502180606,
0.0034424902,
0.0118262097,
-0.0126919355,
0.0289346632,
0.0498406179,
0.003503701,
0.0138168093,
0.0786630884,
0.0321780033,
0.0120388139,
0.0233815759,
-0.0113277733,
-0.0148572316,
-0.0118368333,
-0.0281918794,
0.0480843857,
-0.0386643745,
0.0082496461,
-0.0244459826,
-0.0930051953,
0.0062289126,
-0.0331106707,
0.0020802801,
-0.0500258841,
0.0084033208,
0.0139887305,
0.0220683645,
0.0053551323,
-0.0120309312,
-0.014123884,
-0.0058237407,
-0.040116705,
-0.0335216783,
-7.228199252e-33,
-0.0045023123,
-0.0345637538,
0.0068168743,
-0.036771141,
-0.0271188002,
0.0552710295,
-0.076306507,
-0.0069142138,
-0.0290378351,
0.0059294896,
-0.0254845675,
0.0052497587,
0.0041266005,
0.0448978618,
-0.0026184621,
0.0194212887,
0.056525562,
-0.0032492129,
0.0016331932,
0.0327444859,
0.0225629937,
0.0198329818,
0.0523667112,
-0.0205555875,
-0.0215644017,
0.0239423476,
-0.0000130615,
0.0171881057,
-0.0099991839,
0.0464548953,
-0.0437339805,
0.0382537544,
0.023800116,
-0.0355260447,
-0.0255116262,
-0.0199944917,
-0.052765388,
-0.0138779916,
0.0231598802,
-0.0051375972,
-0.0182757471,
-0.0424635634,
0.0644705892,
0.0136401625,
0.0089830365,
-0.0354346447,
0.0085888822,
-0.0129521647,
-0.0777975097,
-0.0201476775,
-0.067542702,
0.0300004017,
0.0050679245,
-0.0165963452,
0.0471807085,
-0.0029285818,
-0.0443407372,
0.0411235504,
-0.0669212788,
-0.0392074101,
-0.0224937908,
0.0945010409,
0.0671288446,
0.0554161072,
0.021768989,
0.0514888503,
0.0164360646,
0.0158046708,
-0.0093573807,
0.0168038569,
0.0718252212,
0.0690055043,
0.0553156734,
-0.0108479252,
0.0807254612,
-0.0037665381,
-0.0742723569,
-0.028515948,
-0.0038722726,
0.0962086469,
0.0663648918,
0.0435115471,
-0.0037470118,
-0.0293296706,
0.0038680863,
-0.0172792897,
-0.069025211,
-0.0183410011,
0.0283598397,
0.0258423332,
-0.0337634645,
-0.0171365254,
0.0454261117,
-0.024247678,
0.0011175293,
0.0554978997,
-0.0049706409,
0.0245561469,
0.0256301388,
0.015415933,
-0.0374614447,
0.0027359484,
-0.0048477575,
-0.0074809366,
0.035242822,
-0.0059336913,
0.0269737914,
0.0343411751,
-0.0518784784,
-0.0486829802,
-0.0525412634,
0.0063067479,
0.0049486994,
0.0911392644,
0.0365273729,
-0.0227984861,
0.0029207291,
0.0478396118,
-0.0079972399,
-0.0171906427,
-0.0219480414,
0.0055845538,
0.0197206512,
0.0295112282,
-0.0549110882,
-0.0355864353,
-0.0629224181,
0.034281306,
0.0400497839,
-0.0516108088,
-0.0507430695,
0.0093045281,
2.896e-7,
0.0132845836,
0.0096206265,
-0.0418814719,
0.0353980474,
0.0313511789,
0.013861225,
0.0030541986,
-0.006409551,
-0.0247451682,
-0.0143585093,
0.0109085077,
0.0297165811,
0.0793068632,
0.0038209001,
-0.0805106759,
0.0125312209,
-0.0823243856,
0.0008375217,
-0.0224788524,
-0.0450998433,
-0.0612478592,
0.106920287,
0.0038500605,
-0.0357462205,
0.0406678952,
-0.0078399628,
0.0068667256,
-0.001409588,
0.0407741293,
-0.0030343612,
0.0354795195,
-0.0142253423,
-0.0154018924,
-0.0371120274,
-0.0067158593,
-0.0049108937,
-0.0407886803,
0.0780425742,
-0.0417507216,
-0.0548583679,
0.0184025895,
-0.0053275619,
-0.0013794805,
-0.0634840503,
0.0524953827,
-0.0201083403,
-0.0281532183,
-0.0558865517,
0.0068082744,
-0.0064252755,
0.005262502,
-0.0051960568,
-0.01449716,
0.0055378354,
0.0049493276,
-0.0527720451,
-0.0464228876,
-0.0820474401,
-0.0555907972,
0.0130132632,
-0.063174516,
-0.0218683239,
-0.0832371488,
-0.0298110377,
0.039553199,
-0.0285175294,
0.0014842133,
3.185003091e-34,
0.0427838117,
-0.0112175886,
0.0172370523,
0.0475540534,
0.0149328383,
-0.0106953764,
0.0010054292,
0.0143711083,
0.0068137459,
-0.0888299048,
-0.0442035198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16620v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16620v2 | OmAgent: A Multi-modal Agent Framework for Complex Video Understanding with Task Divide-and-Conquer | 2024-06-24T13:05:39 | 2024-06-25T02:43:41 | Lu Zhang, Tiancheng Zhao, Heting Ying, Yibo Ma, Kyusong Lee | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have expanded their
capabilities to multimodal contexts, including comprehensive video
understanding. However, processing extensive videos such as 24-hour CCTV
footage or full-length films presents significant challenges due to the vast
data and processing demands. Traditional methods, like extracting key frames or
converting frames to text, often result in substantial information loss. To
address these shortcomings, we develop OmAgent, efficiently stores and
retrieves relevant video frames for specific queries, preserving the detailed
content of videos. Additionally, it features an Divide-and-Conquer Loop capable
of autonomous reasoning, dynamically invoking APIs and tools to enhance query
processing and accuracy. This approach ensures robust video understanding,
significantly reducing information loss. Experimental results affirm OmAgent's
efficacy in handling various types of videos and complex tasks. Moreover, we
have endowed it with greater autonomy and a robust tool-calling system,
enabling it to accomplish even more intricate tasks. | [
0.0159140807,
0.0557661541,
-0.0028687015,
0.0546290502,
-0.0364985354,
0.005039216,
0.0154262697,
0.0259131305,
0.0017155557,
-0.0841614753,
-0.0010208673,
-0.0400500931,
-0.0494492352,
0.040662922,
-0.0263976566,
-0.0896272957,
0.0313224494,
-0.0290970132,
0.0363168381,
0.0071633649,
0.0338082984,
-0.0144105507,
-0.0121537577,
-0.0004783443,
-0.0556640662,
-0.0442661643,
-0.0337947309,
-0.0219503697,
0.0230862089,
-0.0117437998,
-0.0450620465,
0.0280465055,
0.1076411605,
0.0461157523,
0.0000020743,
-0.0427865162,
-0.0214023758,
-0.0127462642,
-0.0181820579,
-0.0112213409,
0.047078412,
-0.0072523472,
0.012709355,
-0.0096670147,
-0.040600419,
0.01444289,
0.0360167287,
-0.0146285119,
0.0527144074,
0.0496362634,
-0.0388891995,
-0.0403430536,
-0.0068127667,
0.0198883358,
0.0126759503,
-0.0415108167,
0.0083530387,
0.0070792208,
0.0775991231,
-0.0107377982,
-0.0510449149,
0.0385009311,
0.0131829334,
-0.0412930027,
-0.0140723707,
0.0236558672,
-0.0141272331,
-0.0848730281,
-0.0140609024,
0.0235195216,
-0.0032472082,
0.0380636044,
0.0081289299,
0.0219707526,
0.0020507921,
-0.0037758923,
-0.0858282298,
0.0498668253,
-0.0079788538,
0.0023779941,
-0.0473537706,
-0.004149036,
0.0072528566,
0.0135068996,
-0.0095528802,
0.0095638195,
0.0221713465,
0.0344422124,
-0.0512992442,
-0.0221834891,
-0.0056556892,
-0.0522515327,
0.0284044575,
0.0753142983,
-0.0138847986,
0.0158634726,
-0.0165894479,
-0.0095586404,
-0.0284926258,
-0.0703764781,
0.0085524786,
0.0058185607,
-0.0413500071,
0.0755141452,
0.0008336897,
0.0504661351,
-0.0304497648,
0.017239077,
-0.0181390829,
-0.0340191759,
-0.0956396908,
-0.0185850505,
-0.0026579597,
0.0464926958,
-0.0530519783,
-0.0225101318,
0.0190072954,
0.0533722527,
-0.0456467718,
0.0222202763,
-0.0671958998,
0.0131031871,
0.0335434191,
-0.0441856794,
-0.0315449387,
0.0501622371,
-0.0585323572,
0.0292678233,
0.0095531838,
-0.0637679473,
0.000642448,
0.0018056958,
0.0264669321,
-0.0105241789,
0.006151496,
0.0620243549,
-0.0562461428,
-0.0289527141,
-0.0300993901,
-0.0105012674,
-0.005664411,
-0.0436777957,
0.0102526862,
-0.0786937624,
0.0563072003,
0.0017010099,
-0.0197971705,
-0.0137927514,
0.0140702687,
-0.002027971,
-0.0605365075,
0.0712824985,
-0.0162686557,
0.0432860292,
0.0359788984,
0.0342180207,
0.0061271084,
0.0676576868,
0.0045834803,
0.0445640758,
0.0549278706,
0.0418718345,
0.0496702231,
0.0277605988,
-0.061276067,
-0.0090210298,
-0.0577741824,
0.021165885,
0.0032296423,
0.0342015028,
0.0077857296,
0.0303922798,
-0.0107474029,
-0.0093435925,
0.052818615,
0.027755037,
-0.0384409763,
-0.0248579774,
0.0344411992,
0.0516598858,
-0.0043291599,
0.0107444488,
-0.038552247,
0.0903099328,
0.017244678,
-0.0344677679,
-0.0248138327,
0.0429789871,
-0.0620166697,
-0.0337405689,
-0.0188707449,
-0.0032888022,
0.0127326669,
0.0293491483,
0.0824556053,
-0.0293806233,
-0.0237053577,
0.035829328,
-0.0040668664,
-0.0123069612,
0.0314397663,
-0.0578942709,
0.02234504,
0.0713020712,
0.0081657637,
-0.0474987626,
-0.0420385785,
0.0249094665,
0.0453589968,
-0.0350730307,
-0.0042334888,
-0.0348401554,
0.0141379395,
-0.0648758039,
-0.0261954498,
-0.0015394042,
0.0312895328,
0.0412936695,
-0.0147896279,
0.0118492646,
-0.009829903,
-0.0228018053,
-0.0038549209,
0.0387607999,
0.0675362125,
-0.0234293733,
-0.0269031096,
0.012691807,
-0.0016023476,
0.0184338577,
-0.0174988788,
-0.0095992424,
0.0466510542,
-0.0019100844,
-0.0066435174,
0.0235478971,
-0.004019137,
-0.0033175761,
0.0401299894,
-0.0301740803,
-0.0041732593,
0.0351936743,
-0.0435974896,
-0.0499107316,
0.0255684108,
-0.013503952,
0.0035113888,
-0.0403543562,
0.0108729582,
0.0121490359,
-0.0246637128,
-0.0021333026,
0.0348196514,
0.0330895633,
-0.0404106379,
0.0253192242,
0.02379377,
-0.0032679541,
-0.0118702417,
-0.0013763246,
0.0195397716,
-0.0089511778,
0.0122068012,
0.0229367949,
-0.0228220932,
-0.0428836085,
-0.0383109413,
-0.0885319933,
-0.0031597263,
-0.0111700445,
-0.0101641733,
-0.0080049345,
0.0217225999,
-0.0070042405,
-0.0429894812,
0.0187691078,
0.0347127281,
0.0096159149,
0.0442208014,
-0.0073078154,
0.0569596589,
-0.0345071629,
-0.0033582356,
-0.0130621055,
0.0062983152,
0.0217261855,
0.0152182244,
-0.0453400761,
0.0164340883,
-0.047435049,
-0.0169348605,
0.0540966839,
-0.0339839756,
-0.0061564818,
0.0098303342,
-0.0525222495,
-0.0359722897,
0.0687902197,
0.0154514909,
0.0337029397,
0.0344229266,
-0.0433012098,
-0.0264786016,
0.0208094008,
-0.0047562881,
-0.0469640605,
-0.0395534784,
-0.0091117145,
-0.0309524238,
0.014979016,
-0.0295549277,
0.0445744917,
-0.0553789511,
-0.0209670383,
0.0102098836,
-0.0213357117,
-0.0477343611,
0.0035614562,
-0.0208648033,
0.0298635177,
-0.0119325928,
-0.0286940541,
0.0445177965,
-0.0049020904,
-0.0243616793,
0.0179133043,
-0.0071186461,
-0.0274132807,
0.1354063004,
0.0426895879,
0.0371742584,
-0.0301910602,
-0.021560397,
-0.0626802966,
-0.015160827,
0.0304783229,
-0.0099829948,
0.0485021099,
-0.0818660781,
0.0006340401,
-0.0055457405,
-0.0064595728,
-0.0245850775,
-0.0034547481,
-0.0464300737,
-0.0196589455,
-0.055920735,
-0.0011647771,
-0.0323752239,
0.0213678237,
0.0184707325,
0.0414919108,
-0.0203238875,
0.0206306912,
-0.0099983346,
0.0348969139,
0.0510331653,
0.0445806533,
-0.0444505736,
-0.0463126078,
0.0836363435,
0.0699059442,
0.0399585925,
-0.052789934,
-0.0188882481,
0.0461837016,
0.0357156321,
-0.000847857,
-0.0259366445,
0.0275957044,
0.0504407287,
-0.0913761035,
0.016607238,
0.0970963761,
0.0240938514,
-0.0887533128,
-0.02200686,
-0.0312756114,
-0.0407349281,
0.0476500094,
0.0344728902,
-0.0578725673,
-0.0425924771,
0.0121999402,
-0.0063088522,
0.0223714393,
-0.0179111902,
-0.0128840953,
-0.0658553094,
0.0991449878,
0.0018015419,
0.0204825886,
-0.0095218783,
-0.0283286944,
0.0248331837,
-0.026818309,
-0.0227940883,
0.033027146,
-0.0191758834,
-0.0072900606,
0.0053104451,
0.023189595,
-0.0156242382,
0.0392965339,
-0.0616270863,
0.043190673,
0.035537485,
0.0334767513,
-0.0155249443,
-0.0360746719,
0.0017721425,
-0.0027864298,
0.0062323026,
-0.0126257362,
0.0226666573,
-0.0288633779,
0.0074236323,
0.0035519463,
0.022072861,
0.0280916858,
-0.0491528474,
0.0051733595,
0.0953679457,
-0.0445528813,
0.0094553726,
-0.0312035158,
-0.025541896,
-0.0037840183,
0.0655952021,
-0.0366028398,
-0.0037176553,
-0.0226277262,
0.0294256825,
-0.0708571151,
-0.026881678,
-0.0023076546,
0.0138383685,
-0.0299000032,
-0.0176324453,
-0.0076936875,
-0.0157315638,
0.0707840547,
0.0409730747,
-0.0176135898,
-0.0073901517,
0.037754029,
0.0514818653,
-0.0774973109,
0.0289505739,
0.006440009,
-0.0204205047,
-0.0241126735,
0.0019566815,
0.0508551374,
-0.0351457521,
-0.0023843024,
0.0058574672,
-0.0526425727,
-0.0338837206,
0.0216813479,
0.0640166625,
0.0233258512,
0.0918707773,
0.0115085915,
-0.0129704019,
-0.0286029428,
-0.0099691479,
-0.0455350317,
-0.01009952,
0.0002360942,
-0.0282253623,
-0.0215149485,
0.0584652275,
-0.0698801801,
0.0203289613,
-0.0220201127,
0.0038691014,
-0.0655088276,
0.0172974933,
0.0156498719,
-0.0118838241,
0.0113426764,
-0.0005998707,
-0.0151528083,
-0.032985311,
0.0069793263,
0.0007738588,
0.0093077347,
-0.0801612362,
0.0402582325,
-0.007041296,
0.0113412933,
0.0230129622,
0.0345534459,
-0.001583032,
-0.0637596697,
-0.0080544529,
-0.0049729333,
-0.0153510775,
-0.0299311075,
0.0177344847,
0.0207704045,
0.0470087491,
0.0442735739,
-0.0080056721,
0.043828629,
-0.0113643715,
0.0746859163,
0.0131865637,
-0.0128106102,
-0.0289933756,
0.0351577774,
-0.0365040079,
-0.0590641052,
0.0063502584,
0.0555173047,
0.039645873,
-0.0426367819,
-0.0276180096,
-0.033902403,
-0.0025820276,
-0.0299632866,
0.0324759856,
0.012159328,
-0.0557949916,
0.0231054183,
0.0358300991,
-0.0011654956,
-0.0010449773,
0.0572761185,
-0.0221389774,
0.0287953597,
0.0221988056,
-0.0410936065,
-0.026921764,
-0.0095818797,
0.0100693665,
-0.0060525411,
-0.0285826605,
0.0066303802,
-0.031232737,
-0.0311843418,
-0.032064274,
-0.0167934969,
-0.0195851196,
0.0102061797,
0.0372117274,
0.0573162585,
0.0045344243,
-0.0190890338,
-0.0294275433,
-0.0161674116,
-0.0576292649,
-0.0072947005,
0.0336967781,
-6.280531135e-33,
-0.0194437038,
-0.0187661648,
0.0515460633,
-0.0107170083,
-0.0193527415,
0.0045755301,
-0.0050078458,
0.0013627416,
-0.0189047065,
0.0214029793,
-0.0031763786,
0.0399861895,
0.0157656278,
0.0431588776,
0.0380816199,
-0.0471432693,
0.0421655402,
-0.0417093262,
-0.0043755993,
-0.023812063,
0.0343352444,
0.0390866026,
0.0187334269,
-0.0624270737,
-0.0224728733,
0.0269004181,
-0.020153394,
0.0594339222,
0.0215163957,
0.0564726032,
0.0121638989,
-0.0054206587,
0.0282307416,
-0.0206383597,
-0.0302406084,
0.0324331298,
-0.0760640129,
0.018058423,
0.0173370242,
0.0448357239,
-0.0345703922,
-0.0071941321,
0.0188098345,
0.0084719928,
0.0117144519,
-0.0272132624,
0.0391671881,
-0.032907337,
0.0385956541,
0.0393164717,
-0.035454262,
0.0231088996,
-0.0027203371,
-0.0556697622,
0.0807987526,
-0.0143374838,
0.0167814009,
-0.03841969,
-0.0314844772,
0.0090029631,
-0.0327519774,
0.0290940702,
0.064645268,
0.0187180899,
0.0070165233,
0.0424667597,
0.0330056772,
-0.0729874149,
-0.0403771512,
0.0092490148,
0.0054659373,
0.0917896554,
0.0038357226,
0.0202833768,
0.0001221092,
0.0029718231,
-0.0278772824,
0.0005693494,
-0.0362932198,
0.0737874657,
0.006210323,
0.0505549461,
0.0306676421,
0.0203253366,
-0.0136300288,
-0.0112983203,
-0.020373594,
-0.0154943075,
0.0127654569,
0.0283512007,
0.0010086892,
-0.0058895894,
0.0783443078,
-0.0255646855,
0.0342394263,
-0.0184283536,
-0.0220642481,
0.0533236228,
0.0335364342,
0.0605158582,
-0.0149708763,
0.0066588121,
0.0129178967,
-0.0136019941,
-0.0192946121,
0.0164767243,
-0.0344138257,
0.0639674142,
0.003161977,
-0.0200902652,
-0.030223554,
-0.0003039181,
0.0036211947,
0.0319134556,
0.0256654266,
0.0358141586,
-0.0328282416,
0.0653376579,
-0.0142243626,
-0.0013150679,
-0.0165264308,
-0.0164931919,
-0.0119734751,
0.0138910869,
-0.0426939242,
0.0090501634,
-0.0679801479,
-0.0460386649,
0.0108647225,
-0.0543152168,
0.0021688358,
0.0362565555,
2.856e-7,
-0.0040884954,
0.0359229557,
-0.0095478585,
-0.0126595888,
-0.0003999956,
0.0528880879,
-0.014474012,
0.010245312,
-0.0016156376,
-0.0622317456,
0.0267295968,
0.064800486,
0.0220731851,
0.0206520837,
-0.0393302292,
-0.0159309451,
0.0133234439,
-0.0406678468,
-0.0628415048,
0.0059189782,
0.0407766886,
0.1067179739,
0.0319583751,
0.0075601269,
0.0338028297,
-0.0807042271,
0.0437902287,
0.0080580693,
-0.0372409485,
0.008550263,
-0.0013769264,
0.009560802,
-0.0192535706,
0.0080123423,
-0.0049651661,
-0.0027829742,
0.0258953851,
0.0819946676,
-0.0394621603,
-0.0344860516,
-0.0341141783,
-0.00317007,
-0.0328775719,
-0.0274214838,
0.0706133619,
0.0154801998,
-0.0026775165,
-0.0192181133,
-0.0145845413,
-0.0021917166,
-0.0777660161,
0.0166499075,
-0.0000112818,
0.0184670389,
0.0148862936,
-0.0342857912,
-0.0361819677,
-0.1187845841,
0.0318826288,
-0.0222567208,
-0.0659728423,
-0.0048424392,
-0.0381465517,
-0.009116455,
0.0729146376,
-0.0304560959,
-0.0588030517,
2.363837406e-34,
0.0124477027,
0.0233363826,
-0.0350455195,
0.0187392216,
0.0174815543,
0.0240253881,
-0.0556564778,
0.0247803591,
-0.0082154656,
-0.0576006696,
-0.0133229932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16611v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16611v1 | Evaluation of Language Models in the Medical Context Under Resource-Constrained Settings | 2024-06-24T12:52:02 | 2024-06-24T12:52:02 | Andrea Posada, Daniel Rueckert, Felix Meissen, Philip Müller | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Since the emergence of the Transformer architecture, language model
development has increased, driven by their promising potential. However,
releasing these models into production requires properly understanding their
behavior, particularly in sensitive domains such as medicine. Despite this
need, the medical literature still lacks technical assessments of pre-trained
language models, which are especially valuable in resource-constrained settings
in terms of computational power or limited budget. To address this gap, we
provide a comprehensive survey of language models in the medical domain. In
addition, we selected a subset of these models for thorough evaluation,
focusing on classification and text generation tasks. Our subset encompasses 53
models, ranging from 110 million to 13 billion parameters, spanning the three
families of Transformer-based models and from diverse knowledge domains. This
study employs a series of approaches for text classification together with
zero-shot prompting instead of model training or fine-tuning, which closely
resembles the limited resource setting in which many users of language models
find themselves. Encouragingly, our findings reveal remarkable performance
across various tasks and datasets, underscoring the latent potential of certain
models to contain medical knowledge, even without domain specialization.
Consequently, our study advocates for further exploration of model applications
in medical contexts, particularly in resource-constrained settings. The code is
available on https://github.com/anpoc/Language-models-in-medicine. | [
0.0461516269,
0.0864609331,
0.0247344319,
-0.0245331507,
-0.0103493398,
0.022646552,
0.0506499112,
0.0283388514,
-0.0273250043,
-0.0529455096,
-0.0299291853,
-0.0917978212,
0.0266541839,
0.0498051122,
0.0225360375,
-0.031643413,
0.0232277066,
0.0026546163,
0.0068650106,
0.0050658672,
-0.0327022858,
0.0188837945,
-0.023220174,
0.0616315231,
0.0205966793,
-0.0036841452,
0.0288664941,
-0.0002026855,
0.01700099,
-0.0457440019,
0.0058809272,
0.0802431852,
-0.003899574,
0.0448505133,
0.0000017935,
-0.0282321833,
-0.0124565354,
0.0119375642,
-0.0160358455,
-0.018228747,
0.0759231225,
-0.0917169303,
-0.0035449071,
0.0201823357,
-0.0282794069,
-0.0655036643,
0.0644357055,
0.0304529071,
0.0209393203,
0.0724277943,
-0.0156601463,
0.0008220952,
0.0440129526,
-0.0498052835,
0.0134440335,
-0.004693802,
0.0555526726,
-0.0294098388,
0.015399931,
0.0117777744,
0.0047095753,
0.044455912,
-0.0022000067,
0.0132830031,
0.0152506363,
0.0693533793,
-0.0299668852,
-0.0555203855,
0.0125514651,
0.0457765646,
-0.0265483614,
-0.0403222591,
0.0323103108,
0.0082909316,
-0.0424304903,
-0.0020173769,
-0.0261743851,
0.0302094799,
0.0011477239,
0.0031439231,
0.014275955,
0.0079238415,
0.0436410159,
0.010625748,
-0.0209861826,
-0.0117748994,
0.0287287049,
-0.0013735248,
-0.0239299163,
0.0011273301,
-0.0245835353,
-0.0674007908,
0.0172397681,
0.0286876056,
-0.0145692788,
0.0063890633,
-0.0623875149,
-0.0488899648,
0.0740583688,
-0.0246028174,
0.0396161489,
-0.0003379054,
0.0232691523,
0.0109751541,
-0.0260359906,
0.0195054989,
-0.02540561,
0.0238925107,
-0.0155889001,
0.0130413435,
-0.0295341089,
-0.0190903302,
-0.0217061564,
-0.0066130161,
-0.0110058738,
-0.0169570874,
-0.0787352249,
0.0065798783,
0.0094896359,
-0.0187650733,
0.0223236643,
0.0510278791,
-0.0425872393,
-0.0197856966,
0.0282275602,
0.0193049945,
0.0335503034,
0.0102417497,
-0.0048495936,
-0.0516296364,
-0.0010043961,
0.0244771391,
-0.0042569567,
-0.0154666603,
0.012484964,
0.0470336005,
0.0023726884,
-0.0412039235,
0.0096944598,
-0.020661423,
-0.0483060628,
-0.0432547443,
-0.0055267564,
-0.08755593,
0.0283155087,
0.0489584468,
0.0203239657,
-0.0644853562,
0.0164471772,
0.0035546834,
-0.0408399813,
0.0641149804,
-0.0308500249,
-0.0064539798,
0.0428265557,
0.0352715626,
0.0239803642,
0.0330602378,
0.0454146713,
-0.0187158436,
-0.0105211902,
-0.0169660728,
0.0159532372,
-0.0010129587,
0.0193425212,
-0.0196896922,
-0.0057288758,
-0.0101232044,
-0.00336298,
0.0712820664,
-0.0093578193,
0.0649718791,
-0.004726992,
-0.0258838721,
0.0414022505,
0.051511135,
0.0463426709,
0.025914425,
0.0575397834,
-0.0200592615,
-0.0183209255,
-0.0450397469,
0.0069565931,
0.0023821269,
0.0079345079,
0.0069410233,
-0.0157293007,
0.032014966,
-0.0409612805,
-0.0376945026,
-0.0294741057,
-0.0505800396,
-0.0189003702,
-0.0230630189,
0.0511304103,
0.0138234179,
-0.0465183444,
0.0900086835,
0.0483534299,
-0.0590396933,
0.0061522024,
-0.0647124499,
0.0031574329,
0.0389028937,
0.0674612299,
-0.0353809036,
-0.0215110946,
-0.0189664569,
0.0147165051,
0.0337243751,
0.03582206,
0.007713784,
0.0219791234,
-0.0503132455,
0.0070743919,
0.0249668546,
0.0322773233,
-0.0139539465,
0.0081666941,
0.0196064822,
0.0232558604,
-0.0285752621,
-0.0344041027,
0.0376622677,
-0.0929445326,
-0.0222121887,
0.032370016,
-0.0200279243,
0.0158822481,
-0.0129645308,
-0.0189688839,
0.0519244969,
0.0245730951,
-0.0586518385,
-0.0289178006,
-0.0111935046,
-0.0239602383,
-0.0317370445,
-0.0163873807,
-0.0131090358,
0.0382172987,
0.0133839501,
-0.0129163852,
-0.0328082778,
-0.0074855308,
-0.0554651208,
0.0328886695,
-0.0116168186,
0.0413621403,
0.0129421363,
0.010145098,
-0.041219838,
0.0171823129,
-0.0056591518,
0.0167719387,
0.0192480627,
-0.0271766763,
0.0155189978,
-0.0075541437,
-0.0462726541,
0.0127402777,
-0.0027922271,
0.0173409171,
0.001070478,
0.0207945593,
0.0150129087,
-0.0534685664,
-0.0923735946,
-0.0042638709,
-0.0013173695,
0.0046165287,
0.0166485645,
0.0323710293,
0.0132522201,
0.0075840228,
-0.0398774408,
-0.0110129723,
0.0315192826,
0.0154994754,
0.0208397117,
0.0091898516,
0.0023420169,
-0.0321800932,
-0.013010418,
-0.0267645232,
0.0663627312,
0.0212669056,
-0.0020012788,
-0.012968176,
0.0167110357,
-0.0295406375,
-0.0165739954,
0.0195185486,
-0.0287339613,
0.0230031926,
0.0117425472,
0.0339093767,
0.0168771669,
0.025392225,
0.0391067006,
0.0378077514,
0.0293444395,
0.0020879528,
-0.0237535387,
-0.0574253574,
-0.01485785,
-0.0022216195,
-0.0509907566,
0.0060313814,
0.1163122654,
0.0227784943,
-0.0099142492,
-0.069268465,
0.0108221108,
-0.0254636519,
0.0066707209,
-0.0125296144,
0.0363151766,
-0.0245217867,
0.0555522405,
0.0003109506,
-0.0583248176,
0.0842719674,
-0.0378497355,
0.0164041389,
-0.0399648584,
-0.0147398692,
-0.0395529568,
0.0129279774,
0.0249273777,
0.0328523256,
0.0338434801,
-0.0016650774,
0.0013108873,
0.0548362434,
-0.027227046,
-0.0600787476,
0.058004763,
-0.0131532205,
0.0079234941,
0.0004734975,
-0.045479469,
-0.0403303653,
-0.0397123098,
-0.0112944851,
-0.0011760568,
0.0280923173,
-0.0203211885,
-0.0635671988,
0.0632353649,
-0.0190226696,
0.0864360929,
-0.0043555354,
-0.0205358025,
-0.0148545206,
0.0298003517,
0.0543678328,
-0.0179420002,
0.0127623314,
-0.0327067338,
0.0323493816,
0.0574174896,
0.0111380927,
0.0613100603,
-0.0217277016,
-0.0117200054,
0.0238863491,
-0.0259470567,
-0.0151258782,
0.0095113814,
0.0380175151,
-0.0284372531,
-0.0406489335,
0.1313197911,
0.0309557002,
-0.0696261004,
0.0320020355,
0.0149410805,
0.0296738409,
-0.0182057582,
0.0113069499,
-0.0696822852,
-0.0197753571,
-0.0179251451,
0.0405357182,
-0.0310836099,
-0.0191312302,
0.0098425429,
-0.0506724492,
0.012068334,
0.0323442034,
-0.0288243331,
-0.0176071636,
-0.039885547,
-0.032199651,
-0.0252679884,
-0.0079475669,
-0.0126195196,
-0.0207413472,
-0.0088224541,
0.0212938115,
-0.0326448008,
-0.0993488654,
0.0239856523,
0.0003984511,
0.0480163917,
0.0409857482,
0.0125303371,
-0.0023264415,
-0.0215966627,
-0.0126165897,
-0.0103065455,
-0.0080609052,
-0.0064003742,
0.0722238049,
0.0147405351,
-0.0096355425,
-0.0121219764,
0.0127071915,
-0.065692991,
-0.0364970565,
-0.0408059247,
0.0652967319,
-0.0368666649,
-0.0483743772,
-0.0256949738,
0.0369170122,
0.0123334574,
0.0612745807,
0.0200044941,
-0.0346394368,
-0.0305246357,
0.0055907103,
0.0488861091,
-0.0412166901,
-0.0364106074,
0.0148546956,
-0.0051982417,
-0.0598151274,
-0.0689388737,
0.0096752709,
0.0270593334,
0.0006501714,
0.0001643673,
-0.0117409658,
0.0078360802,
-0.0241725948,
-0.0628750175,
0.0463015549,
0.0285872743,
0.0056199422,
-0.0840774253,
-0.0523709767,
0.0669112504,
-0.0178371351,
-0.0193988103,
0.0208262652,
-0.0790526047,
-0.0467003547,
-0.0091108121,
0.0612469986,
0.0246416014,
0.0002284583,
-0.0031329303,
-0.0382644907,
0.0597252734,
0.0506493524,
-0.0379990451,
-0.0094630886,
0.0113333929,
-0.0375412256,
-0.0240035206,
0.0318834223,
-0.0117478948,
0.0412263982,
0.0057126461,
0.0160935167,
-0.0271097198,
-0.0394708142,
0.0096472437,
-0.014946715,
0.0473687053,
-0.0444035046,
-0.0161094181,
-0.0243690517,
0.0003186208,
-0.0228282902,
0.0375971496,
-0.0483199321,
-0.0123386597,
0.0501878448,
0.0128694363,
-0.0239079874,
0.0021542173,
-0.0541776717,
-0.0017374241,
-0.028882945,
0.0433203615,
0.0036485174,
0.0025405129,
0.0697886199,
-0.0162670054,
-0.0208143722,
0.0111408895,
-0.0283139516,
-0.008282342,
-0.0287247747,
0.0490456522,
-0.010229541,
0.0570167266,
-0.0057233535,
0.0715529621,
-0.0550465547,
-0.0070556449,
-0.0302505586,
0.0070418199,
0.0153676914,
0.0030828912,
0.0623939298,
-0.0299476944,
0.0073838667,
-0.0525137894,
0.0625104234,
-0.0254498031,
0.0126099139,
0.0390518382,
0.008784947,
-0.0081077525,
-0.014500984,
0.1157433316,
0.0448824391,
0.040606454,
0.0234305598,
-0.0372645333,
-0.0323414952,
-0.0133468062,
-0.0063078767,
-0.0129761631,
-0.0635253936,
0.0249029752,
-0.056047488,
-0.0535466708,
0.0423520058,
-0.0266145766,
-0.0105628548,
-0.0245079249,
0.0370555967,
0.0414363481,
-0.004971473,
0.0141738886,
-0.0527378619,
0.0260742903,
-0.0179872327,
-0.0214293767,
0.0055682394,
-5.815193329e-33,
0.0013091593,
-0.0327741466,
0.0304748956,
-0.010630792,
-0.0004292943,
0.0451101325,
-0.0540779084,
0.0207486264,
0.0188963134,
0.0223084688,
-0.0057165059,
-0.0178482514,
0.0021375592,
0.0683665499,
-0.0126319239,
-0.0068831062,
0.0369190089,
-0.0092529645,
-0.0262338612,
0.0626867563,
0.0064384323,
0.0458722748,
0.0341730677,
-0.0486017466,
-0.0130174318,
-0.0125384666,
0.0142594539,
-0.0173488278,
0.0048551774,
0.0742932335,
-0.0577879101,
0.0463577472,
0.0335912853,
-0.0254358333,
-0.0097465953,
0.0106166266,
-0.0611249432,
0.0229292065,
-0.0162923764,
-0.026064191,
-0.0377377979,
-0.0441930331,
0.0341231115,
-0.0095085148,
-0.027611848,
-0.0308626574,
0.0233681519,
-0.0345165953,
-0.036150679,
-0.0567330979,
-0.0669527054,
0.054143738,
0.0135912718,
-0.036732018,
-0.0074034296,
0.0488066003,
-0.0416566841,
0.060059201,
-0.0316613875,
0.0018530233,
0.0427396372,
0.0369537026,
0.022637967,
-0.0058348509,
-0.0183205437,
0.0507192425,
-0.0098746764,
-0.0008039983,
-0.035995651,
0.0364449434,
-0.0102916015,
0.0349538177,
0.0566983558,
0.0186302736,
0.0112497797,
-0.0425677672,
-0.0801557899,
0.0203844123,
-0.0496568456,
0.0101503776,
0.0434632674,
-0.0403804034,
-0.0205355939,
-0.0166143011,
-0.0149018187,
-0.039274849,
-0.0196870118,
-0.0189018548,
0.0189339481,
0.0233766418,
-0.0059177489,
0.0170403775,
0.0140936384,
-0.0362222493,
0.0125642745,
-0.0002257773,
0.0183041524,
0.0203270167,
-0.0409684666,
0.0267606974,
-0.0551802665,
-0.0286300257,
0.045468919,
-0.00051541,
0.0294557735,
0.0009227439,
0.0204041637,
0.0060712332,
-0.0568008795,
-0.0121613238,
-0.0052353027,
0.0201867744,
0.0156019218,
0.0686543882,
0.0084735649,
0.0173151661,
-0.0004657567,
0.0454988666,
-0.0165097378,
-0.017113883,
-0.0171370935,
-0.009082946,
0.0187817905,
0.0334227756,
-0.0545576736,
-0.0155573655,
-0.0410312377,
0.0331278704,
0.0605786406,
-0.057875216,
-0.0278467406,
-0.0230112262,
2.504e-7,
0.1009975076,
0.0506099947,
-0.0066455053,
-0.0304981712,
0.0359047502,
0.0085844891,
0.0124943182,
0.0319821984,
-0.023193581,
0.0181870721,
0.0263085663,
0.0006632344,
0.0721019208,
0.0199922603,
-0.0614614077,
-0.0074736574,
-0.1167287305,
0.0068994001,
-0.0262603611,
-0.0499971807,
0.0247482024,
0.0962384418,
-0.0436293632,
-0.0342784375,
0.0200148392,
-0.019596586,
0.0842885301,
-0.0307121631,
0.001258091,
0.0606720634,
0.0385251082,
-0.003601779,
0.0318698622,
0.0008722083,
-0.0379905142,
-0.0129992897,
0.0005860736,
0.1042594835,
-0.0327487923,
-0.0088694831,
0.0726980194,
0.0132856863,
0.0071905395,
-0.0667925626,
0.0569778085,
-0.083219327,
-0.0377792865,
-0.03286862,
0.0194768962,
0.0128719052,
0.0632525235,
-0.0568518378,
-0.038833309,
0.0370784923,
0.0419234186,
0.0124497432,
-0.0243307073,
-0.0486629345,
-0.0351016931,
0.0184096061,
-0.0612791926,
-0.0101059591,
-0.0078688571,
-0.0330306776,
0.0144720199,
-0.0654871613,
0.0118392669,
2.563944197e-34,
0.0354472212,
-0.0092445379,
-0.025010094,
-0.0080164298,
0.009621283,
-0.0351369865,
0.0309196319,
0.0085836034,
-0.0011768026,
-0.0844530538,
-0.0110565042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16605v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16605v1 | CLEAR: Can Language Models Really Understand Causal Graphs? | 2024-06-24T12:46:15 | 2024-06-24T12:46:15 | Sirui Chen, Mengying Xu, Kun Wang, Xingyu Zeng, Rui Zhao, Shengjie Zhao, Chaochao Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ME | Causal reasoning is a cornerstone of how humans interpret the world. To model
and reason about causality, causal graphs offer a concise yet effective
solution. Given the impressive advancements in language models, a crucial
question arises: can they really understand causal graphs? To this end, we
pioneer an investigation into language models' understanding of causal graphs.
Specifically, we develop a framework to define causal graph understanding, by
assessing language models' behaviors through four practical criteria derived
from diverse disciplines (e.g., philosophy and psychology). We then develop
CLEAR, a novel benchmark that defines three complexity levels and encompasses
20 causal graph-based tasks across these levels. Finally, based on our
framework and benchmark, we conduct extensive experiments on six leading
language models and summarize five empirical findings. Our results indicate
that while language models demonstrate a preliminary understanding of causal
graphs, significant potential for improvement remains. Our project website is
at https://github.com/OpenCausaLab/CLEAR. | [
0.010703831,
0.05717659,
-0.0436084606,
0.0247395728,
-0.0448507667,
0.0079951631,
-0.0023009873,
0.0070622982,
0.0320881233,
-0.0362330079,
0.0555810966,
0.0068286681,
0.0133174565,
0.0425645895,
0.0121066747,
-0.0347759314,
0.0451677442,
-0.0232002754,
0.0492072664,
-0.0123730842,
-0.0201138537,
-0.011271677,
-0.0097598396,
0.02912586,
-0.0038981796,
-0.0123145049,
-0.0115672424,
0.0128215542,
-0.0076583815,
-0.0311968103,
-0.0387519486,
0.0120332846,
-0.0182936005,
0.0663544908,
0.0000019765,
-0.0413325317,
0.0144955739,
0.00439901,
-0.0206545368,
0.0041925958,
-0.0302377418,
-0.0213333517,
0.0258298721,
-0.007109697,
-0.0214644261,
-0.0235268548,
0.0374640711,
0.0184749365,
0.0035306921,
0.076494813,
-0.0225178786,
-0.05423804,
0.0213120934,
-0.0079840422,
0.0068609067,
-0.0096615274,
0.0257416964,
0.0396891162,
0.028538499,
-0.0347975157,
-0.0716671497,
0.0118498486,
0.0420301445,
-0.0177976824,
0.0234781522,
0.0067996527,
0.0411605313,
-0.0362710208,
0.0487875454,
0.0732447505,
0.0332140401,
-0.0536401495,
0.0175872687,
-0.0247178208,
-0.0107115963,
0.0807321072,
-0.0544933155,
0.0183821749,
-0.0005793334,
0.0048512984,
0.0330331884,
-0.0054205176,
0.0746935084,
0.0074550565,
-0.0341879986,
0.1112205535,
0.0095445029,
-0.0010583689,
-0.000928984,
0.0078283334,
0.0059922431,
-0.0673147216,
-0.0147794355,
0.0360304341,
-0.0678299963,
0.036018569,
0.0152969593,
0.0124867577,
-0.0025611727,
-0.0151027413,
0.045528885,
0.0157779101,
0.0329545885,
0.0410334878,
0.0062305438,
0.0439775474,
-0.0270302761,
0.0572181158,
-0.0069122221,
0.0237149093,
-0.0348343141,
-0.0125493752,
-0.0151872411,
-0.011377139,
0.007168191,
-0.0109327566,
-0.0159007758,
0.0292164311,
-0.0190298054,
-0.0036091998,
-0.0081333425,
-0.0340778418,
0.0054671797,
-0.0089416075,
-0.0177945979,
0.0271832738,
-0.059421137,
0.0265837144,
-0.0302051306,
-0.025791686,
-0.0013914059,
-0.0085203927,
-0.0133348973,
-0.0293884985,
-0.0315858424,
0.088542141,
0.0549768135,
-0.0038542282,
-0.0068671647,
-0.0400828458,
0.0088544479,
-0.0422876254,
0.0203779005,
-0.0567703396,
-0.0248882771,
0.0640017167,
0.0184057653,
-0.0389954299,
0.004303874,
-0.0220424477,
-0.0718785748,
0.0432574563,
-0.0172062367,
0.0418804474,
-0.0201132447,
-0.0236381274,
0.029058557,
0.0482682735,
0.0356124863,
-0.0109846443,
0.0293418951,
-0.0104717081,
0.0015648775,
0.0198180117,
0.0071793739,
0.0056980681,
-0.0554216318,
-0.0337259322,
-0.0161497779,
-0.0032158254,
-0.0274876412,
0.0574569777,
-0.0046158703,
-0.0188393071,
0.0480790436,
-0.0094064577,
0.0009091764,
-0.042360004,
0.0544329509,
-0.0373866037,
-0.0002047872,
0.0355335996,
-0.0640355498,
0.0009708633,
0.0048636738,
-0.0019370323,
-0.0199594237,
-0.0594607219,
0.0092056692,
-0.0506550111,
-0.0429000482,
0.0074698497,
0.0469465889,
-0.0121051557,
0.0743290856,
0.0341398232,
-0.0168230012,
-0.011188685,
0.0181327369,
-0.0425803624,
-0.0026386369,
0.0034230917,
0.009131155,
0.0466738418,
0.0713527948,
-0.0258734953,
-0.0075975955,
0.0173397064,
0.0182866007,
0.0004182023,
0.0805356055,
-0.0030267695,
-0.0221666787,
-0.0131581472,
-0.0191215239,
0.0030118804,
0.0260770153,
0.0051311511,
-0.0052877017,
-0.0178610217,
-0.0168594848,
-0.0567710251,
-0.0439894609,
0.0223131645,
-0.0300045814,
0.0263488051,
-0.0542742945,
0.002298387,
0.0268842857,
0.0168529153,
-0.0323686115,
0.0493211299,
0.0207081884,
-0.0253076125,
-0.0289362688,
0.0825849026,
-0.0286199469,
-0.0063787471,
0.0325328186,
-0.0607401878,
-0.023482943,
0.0549938343,
0.0017149682,
-0.0549741611,
0.102738969,
-0.049807217,
0.031579338,
0.0183850415,
0.0216170531,
-0.0416039824,
-0.0213404913,
-0.0080211787,
0.0801521167,
0.0209269654,
0.0593183711,
0.0058015208,
0.0274680331,
0.0439599827,
-0.0109767681,
0.006443609,
0.014463882,
0.0089157131,
-0.0144983605,
0.0656187385,
-0.044646129,
-0.0409654044,
0.008766125,
-0.0564391874,
-0.0180102084,
-0.0094635962,
0.0086806724,
0.0187642239,
-0.0038911824,
0.0119819501,
-0.0149627933,
-0.0036923829,
0.0476513095,
0.0084280344,
0.028791029,
0.032395307,
-0.0366104767,
-0.0376333334,
-0.034584526,
-0.0285733864,
-0.0751224235,
0.0582111962,
0.0567962788,
-0.0420259684,
0.0129674962,
-0.0043448242,
-0.0186069421,
0.0099771041,
-0.038506411,
-0.0047742175,
0.04737968,
-0.0171116758,
0.0151721006,
0.0466551259,
-0.0195963476,
0.0332173295,
0.0424224176,
-0.0311754253,
-0.0361250974,
-0.0145277595,
-0.0341357626,
0.0242009908,
-0.0612046868,
-0.060346134,
-0.0424987413,
0.100687474,
0.0005400717,
-0.0274659451,
-0.0469996855,
-0.0022163717,
-0.066930674,
-0.0014636472,
-0.0177078675,
-0.0315099955,
-0.0277495384,
0.0413915068,
-0.0537296943,
-0.0614606887,
0.0548679493,
0.0184673145,
0.0078947311,
0.0255998448,
0.0155822672,
-0.0590358116,
0.0956993178,
0.0851670206,
-0.000766982,
0.0177009348,
-0.0379585177,
-0.0620361716,
-0.0064878482,
0.0569763444,
0.0191932563,
0.0014212163,
-0.065063484,
0.0378991179,
0.0036812788,
-0.0130317286,
-0.0239089634,
-0.0094948979,
-0.0291026402,
0.0183128789,
0.0120536871,
-0.022035649,
-0.0048552291,
-0.0046311435,
-0.0045811059,
0.0054165805,
-0.0210146885,
0.0137281679,
-0.0533510931,
-0.0196315385,
0.0430238731,
-0.0441951305,
0.0390131585,
-0.047618933,
0.0078508472,
0.0157589689,
-0.0012067605,
-0.0001638681,
-0.0267385952,
0.0132071516,
-0.014320109,
-0.0223637242,
-0.03696106,
0.0032811693,
0.044587709,
-0.0412778705,
0.018985685,
0.0905955508,
0.0480117202,
-0.0174969956,
0.0450715385,
-0.0122768134,
0.0095496159,
0.0744096413,
-0.0219764393,
-0.0911397487,
-0.0200532228,
0.0209323484,
-0.0235038679,
-0.0128960786,
-0.0649867356,
-0.0092035076,
-0.0606899261,
-0.0060401754,
0.0096379556,
-0.010547583,
0.0133292014,
-0.0492520221,
-0.0043260856,
0.0086776596,
-0.0342014469,
-0.0173067674,
-0.01716334,
0.0139674339,
0.0012039518,
-0.0022706399,
0.005862671,
-0.0024223051,
0.0075225472,
0.0419065543,
-0.0102957357,
0.0382218286,
-0.0300605632,
0.001914422,
0.0497077517,
0.028788412,
-0.0129227014,
-0.0125509202,
0.0093308836,
0.0697513297,
-0.0162329189,
-0.0181941036,
-0.0106721753,
-0.0350093879,
-0.0361067355,
-0.0190991517,
0.0842137262,
-0.0195459276,
-0.0888964534,
-0.022072874,
-0.0056561306,
-0.0381927751,
0.0492773764,
0.0598832406,
0.0099092005,
-0.0859320164,
-0.0454609431,
0.0060861618,
-0.0426277332,
-0.0628218651,
-0.0151874041,
0.0434474945,
-0.0349639878,
-0.0252327807,
-0.0428998061,
-0.014404906,
-0.0147345578,
0.0237544738,
0.0028318316,
0.0369484164,
-0.0558074936,
-0.058090236,
0.0273249988,
-0.0292608682,
0.0522612631,
-0.03361018,
-0.0216680784,
-0.0381777138,
0.0028085308,
-0.00913445,
0.0170733631,
-0.033298824,
-0.0809752345,
0.0109237228,
-0.0086568641,
0.0303851143,
0.0189505797,
-0.0212709289,
-0.0501322262,
-0.0427441075,
-0.01443356,
-0.0082091754,
0.0215361286,
0.0492244847,
-0.0409387834,
0.0100788558,
0.0589686744,
-0.0397303328,
0.0378437564,
0.0067814682,
0.0433931351,
-0.0402542315,
-0.0059970841,
0.0227343943,
0.0427189581,
0.0339391232,
0.0421211012,
0.0010060035,
-0.037110094,
-0.0220788531,
-0.0445734933,
-0.0479508378,
-0.0125095211,
-0.0076872702,
0.0058441758,
0.0257319137,
-0.0190398116,
-0.0500030555,
-0.0316936597,
-0.0116382008,
0.0020740146,
0.0262154639,
-0.0033185864,
0.0168350767,
0.0475794785,
0.0071038697,
0.006551953,
0.0458908565,
-0.0152923241,
0.0281785764,
-0.0072487937,
0.0223413017,
0.0451477133,
0.0137864891,
-0.030136304,
-0.0628573522,
-0.0929820463,
-0.0359410271,
0.0797551498,
-0.0323754586,
0.0751543343,
-0.0062450143,
0.0725469887,
-0.0462650172,
0.0118059926,
-0.0057904259,
0.0345007256,
0.0635673478,
-0.0305721238,
0.0184749402,
0.0279884879,
-0.0172661804,
0.0178433489,
0.0672657043,
0.0415654667,
0.0462534167,
0.0083107734,
-0.015810607,
-0.0130876265,
-0.0499777049,
-0.0116654718,
0.0196213331,
-0.0103730354,
0.0366412774,
-0.0964932218,
-0.0713716447,
-0.0183167849,
0.0083147697,
0.0292035975,
-0.0259693135,
0.0151932165,
0.0135975983,
0.0150779104,
-0.020733159,
-0.0355537087,
0.0474813953,
-0.0402958021,
-0.0000242118,
0.0171584468,
-6.200176545e-33,
-0.0131585505,
-0.0587992221,
0.0220121965,
0.0131784426,
0.0106657017,
0.0090122027,
-0.1036904007,
0.0218794309,
-0.0478287004,
0.0646610931,
0.0052479049,
0.0468827747,
0.007327015,
-0.0051084007,
0.0010775826,
-0.0034715594,
0.0171283502,
0.0092551326,
-0.0199006367,
0.0119148232,
0.0455236062,
-0.0151933767,
0.0209093336,
-0.0587804019,
0.0541497879,
-0.0096802507,
0.0133916745,
0.0166697148,
-0.0509739369,
0.0251257494,
0.0121328318,
0.023955876,
0.0459604822,
-0.0317681506,
-0.0149157653,
0.0136170397,
-0.0469579212,
-0.0658303872,
0.0747257024,
0.0372939892,
-0.0945067257,
-0.0419706516,
0.0538313277,
-0.0072041997,
-0.004804628,
-0.0113100698,
0.043068964,
-0.0017987405,
-0.028908981,
0.0338827483,
-0.0602066256,
0.0229649916,
-0.0413524397,
0.0209224056,
-0.0011723015,
-0.0112003842,
-0.0090454966,
0.0000807075,
0.0092357136,
0.0464665033,
-0.0198634006,
-0.0060542934,
0.0126112988,
0.0145967631,
0.0289945453,
0.0675656274,
-0.0140327513,
0.032584358,
-0.0092941392,
0.0400242545,
0.0225183722,
0.0490485691,
0.0418049768,
0.0050892979,
0.0139431367,
-0.0057520852,
-0.0929838717,
-0.0398834758,
0.0401313566,
0.0141595434,
0.0060339808,
0.0027428837,
-0.0307198483,
-0.0493224189,
-0.0587662496,
-0.0267657395,
-0.0314888544,
-0.0022105325,
0.0049990029,
-0.0249258205,
0.0119909598,
-0.0325587615,
0.0000984573,
-0.0749921203,
-0.0231133141,
0.0746539086,
-0.0254728869,
0.0250942335,
0.0148363439,
0.0182271954,
-0.0409893095,
-0.0196669754,
-0.0307036731,
0.026899118,
0.0446261577,
0.0139363827,
0.0338982567,
-0.0086623523,
-0.0062749479,
-0.0061753592,
-0.0473666489,
-0.0510931313,
-0.0120753553,
-0.0294626858,
0.0624881014,
0.0453133173,
0.0064946758,
0.0386661254,
0.0455241911,
0.0288830567,
-0.0135241169,
0.029135434,
-0.0348644666,
0.0224586278,
-0.0255088452,
-0.0552092493,
-0.0482058525,
0.0815470666,
0.0686239824,
-0.0470248014,
-0.0298657566,
-0.0063155475,
2.593e-7,
0.0856524408,
0.0641196594,
0.030973075,
0.0892652497,
0.0703870058,
0.0145001672,
-0.0128268283,
-0.0053730304,
-0.0239478797,
0.0291985273,
0.0002495099,
0.0278240833,
0.0225337464,
0.0094966954,
-0.0419230312,
0.0262150392,
-0.0503868274,
-0.0087293433,
-0.0223373845,
0.0300140474,
0.0267973449,
0.0164996851,
0.0434805341,
0.0361126326,
-0.0278255939,
-0.0344051309,
0.03175864,
-0.0195756294,
0.0235933941,
0.0044070892,
-0.0245399587,
-0.0173194744,
0.0065413811,
0.029605817,
0.0049795308,
0.0084725479,
-0.017451115,
0.0195076931,
-0.0162620395,
0.0146357678,
-0.0296890642,
-0.066105485,
0.015375074,
-0.0423772372,
0.0739610791,
-0.017621696,
-0.0754995942,
0.0384462588,
-0.0087390272,
0.0096370159,
0.0109340455,
0.0408162549,
-0.0206106603,
0.0132011781,
0.0042676046,
-0.0042283293,
-0.0011884862,
-0.0532733984,
-0.0614311658,
-0.0031599679,
0.0127960742,
-0.0598422624,
-0.0301070493,
0.0238079317,
-0.0081522828,
-0.0059276242,
-0.0116740847,
2.582871722e-34,
0.0510280207,
0.0097404364,
0.0167990122,
-0.0573525466,
0.0339734517,
-0.0584866032,
-0.0358219184,
0.051911816,
0.0522817783,
-0.0804187655,
-0.0284773167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16567v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16567v1 | Data Augmentation of Multi-turn Psychological Dialogue via Knowledge-driven Progressive Thought Prompting | 2024-06-24T12:02:56 | 2024-06-24T12:02:56 | Jiyue Jiang, Liheng Chen, Sheng Wang, Lingpeng Kong, Yu Li, Chuan Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing dialogue data augmentation (DA) techniques predominantly focus on
augmenting utterance-level dialogues, which makes it difficult to take dialogue
contextual information into account. The advent of large language models (LLMs)
has simplified the implementation of multi-turn dialogues. Due to absence of
professional understanding and knowledge, it remains challenging to deliver
satisfactory performance in low-resource domain, like psychological dialogue
dialogue. DA involves creating new training or prompting data based on the
existing data, which help the model better understand and generate
psychology-related responses. In this paper, we aim to address the issue of
multi-turn dialogue data augmentation for boosted performance in the psychology
domain. We propose a knowledge-driven progressive thought prompting method to
guide LLM to generate multi-turn psychology-related dialogue. This method
integrates a progressive thought generator, a psychology knowledge generator,
and a multi-turn dialogue generator. The thought generated by the progressive
thought generator serves as a prompt to prevent the generated dialogue from
having significant semantic deviations, while the psychology knowledge
generator produces psychological knowledge to serve as the dialogue history for
the LLM, guiding the dialogue generator to create multi-turn psychological
dialogue. To ensure the precision of multi-turn psychological dialogue
generation by LLM, a meticulous professional evaluation is required. Extensive
experiments conducted on three datasets related to psychological dialogue
verify the effectiveness of the proposed method. | [
0.0719346032,
0.0596352667,
-0.0197616741,
0.0315832123,
-0.041193679,
0.0074941618,
0.0211551376,
-0.0401053615,
0.020204084,
-0.0421119109,
-0.0377275534,
-0.0218656939,
0.0003004638,
0.0464774668,
0.0407917798,
-0.0898854807,
0.0654594079,
-0.0091315825,
0.0272326898,
-0.0137726068,
0.0120475823,
-0.0090593817,
-0.0503739528,
0.0269248411,
-0.0271866955,
-0.0191900302,
-0.0496715494,
0.0061359396,
0.0177167896,
-0.0592747107,
-0.0138455406,
0.0336154923,
0.0303861927,
0.0153842894,
0.0000019778,
-0.0441241637,
0.0204058737,
-0.0142152365,
-0.041019205,
-0.0146375187,
0.0349851921,
-0.0114533892,
0.0188265759,
0.0199189819,
-0.0416938439,
-0.0130379964,
0.0252893157,
0.0981883854,
0.1112341434,
0.0810210705,
-0.0082632676,
-0.0161456671,
0.0262936521,
-0.0055300528,
0.0038637156,
0.001249869,
0.0181792919,
-0.0050526303,
0.0039944155,
0.0175760854,
-0.0169158522,
0.0186802428,
0.0109703559,
-0.0290048067,
-0.0075378479,
0.0089343032,
-0.0242650826,
-0.011808712,
-0.0279659443,
0.0891341567,
0.0462622792,
0.0357999317,
-0.0001953983,
-0.0190884899,
-0.0123436572,
-0.0382109731,
-0.0394672342,
0.0182747394,
0.0083373087,
-0.0077646603,
0.0158557892,
0.0240124613,
-0.0291390568,
0.0228909086,
-0.0422821902,
0.0555825047,
-0.0096551757,
-0.0559529476,
-0.0034016573,
0.0059465533,
0.0008841458,
-0.0736768916,
-0.0012476173,
0.0139624644,
-0.0509438217,
0.0352395438,
-0.0262191091,
-0.0136982035,
0.0190859791,
0.0084802201,
0.0125151556,
0.0420715995,
-0.0330219865,
0.0115155131,
0.0163420122,
0.0440942869,
-0.0269240588,
0.0124890562,
-0.0482726097,
0.0025390289,
-0.0323622935,
0.0017301467,
-0.0340468735,
0.0324696265,
-0.0303121787,
-0.0456275903,
-0.0404062271,
0.0630472302,
-0.0159004666,
0.0187354144,
-0.0203900728,
-0.0002454734,
-0.0098389331,
0.0023668574,
-0.0377959237,
0.0452591032,
-0.0286878776,
0.0209306087,
0.0505420454,
-0.0541767888,
-0.0143334083,
0.0309256744,
0.0061728014,
-0.0003691891,
-0.0024769818,
0.0245582461,
-0.0327018537,
-0.01037437,
-0.032198891,
-0.0501406565,
-0.0334163532,
-0.0450837798,
-0.0095609557,
-0.0099872481,
0.0537626669,
-0.0122507308,
-0.0350784212,
0.0200329404,
0.0430754013,
0.0042490931,
-0.0362321325,
0.0470187403,
-0.0549527258,
0.0091211526,
0.0359307677,
0.0125496881,
-0.0445224121,
0.05720485,
0.0518112816,
-0.0290795621,
0.0202762056,
0.0025161938,
0.0068098004,
0.0293828771,
0.0046355538,
-0.0224016327,
0.0224529691,
0.0128381746,
-0.0134247281,
0.0673152953,
0.0179025531,
0.0546928942,
-0.0554090105,
0.0189158712,
0.0555759594,
-0.0009078557,
-0.001678183,
0.0253075808,
0.0377570912,
0.0316305757,
0.0105713774,
0.0434979126,
-0.0304792374,
0.003409262,
-0.0342141278,
0.0195835792,
0.0540664382,
0.0232456475,
-0.0206840932,
-0.037554957,
0.0435635485,
-0.0004997726,
0.038049221,
0.0257158671,
0.009249337,
0.0079767583,
-0.0364692062,
0.0023586063,
0.0145355379,
-0.0463095531,
-0.0302502476,
-0.0359801278,
0.002041149,
0.0830144584,
0.0572125427,
-0.0121607622,
-0.0643838048,
-0.0404554233,
-0.0198983159,
0.0659568459,
0.0295093916,
-0.0146243116,
0.0075385068,
-0.0619291328,
-0.0151671823,
0.0015131758,
-0.0210188963,
0.0089115901,
-0.017061647,
0.0097141936,
0.0124334125,
0.0543554351,
0.0396917425,
0.0122764027,
-0.0135222171,
0.0086189769,
0.0220478959,
-0.0086512035,
0.0387724563,
0.0472730398,
-0.0216748957,
0.0132201742,
0.0408431515,
-0.0202236157,
-0.0330335982,
0.037010666,
-0.082375586,
-0.1227412224,
0.0247006323,
0.0103941057,
0.0165821146,
-0.0259726215,
-0.0211955514,
-0.0786226913,
-0.001851756,
-0.0417768322,
0.0470487922,
-0.0298170932,
0.0384550132,
0.0365016758,
0.0325521603,
-0.0265658032,
0.035998635,
-0.0046651149,
0.0228235833,
0.0687013492,
0.0469618924,
0.0132977823,
-0.0640398562,
0.0073922658,
0.0195021033,
0.0078312168,
-0.0159142073,
0.00363324,
-0.0220680293,
-0.0733698308,
-0.0304821488,
-0.1244290844,
-0.0109098619,
0.013083322,
-0.0205678362,
0.0098914038,
0.0083116069,
-0.031019045,
-0.0125632277,
-0.0608645193,
0.0011583959,
0.0689856708,
0.0286198221,
0.0225714203,
0.0319795087,
-0.0273201242,
-0.021722395,
0.0301537253,
0.0022373807,
0.0285220686,
-0.0150108002,
-0.0198740587,
-0.0567568317,
0.0308188815,
-0.0506668687,
0.0307458173,
-0.037050534,
-0.0496391654,
0.0157853328,
0.017043611,
0.0838759616,
0.0382693149,
0.0632543564,
-0.0432325266,
0.0035973391,
-0.0465315618,
-0.0583124608,
0.0293553248,
-0.0064672395,
0.0120784594,
-0.008302236,
-0.0022158986,
0.0322401635,
0.0128461067,
0.0504284352,
0.0245466363,
-0.0260507837,
-0.0226495806,
0.036780905,
-0.0479246154,
0.0126670599,
-0.0325702056,
-0.0472145192,
0.0273716152,
-0.0043180343,
-0.0066981236,
0.0748533309,
-0.0401063338,
-0.0410332456,
-0.0473994203,
-0.009718081,
-0.0173246432,
0.0380260572,
-0.0049113357,
0.0157767981,
0.0069949464,
0.0022209499,
-0.0330367684,
-0.001225248,
-0.0095582576,
-0.048664175,
0.0345486365,
-0.0395951122,
-0.0082094744,
0.0068280241,
-0.0264064744,
-0.0931492969,
-0.0637673065,
-0.004207362,
-0.0249377172,
0.0330169126,
-0.0076576164,
0.0039597941,
-0.02099072,
0.0658015609,
0.0526138395,
-0.021199625,
-0.0103073679,
-0.0256256461,
0.0231315214,
0.0517324805,
-0.0008831508,
0.0076739038,
-0.0233931616,
0.081766732,
0.022671992,
0.0000391664,
-0.0057735066,
-0.013881444,
-0.0039207675,
-0.0059730657,
0.0132803172,
-0.0159520805,
0.0090718716,
0.0469248854,
-0.0350280143,
-0.0154172014,
0.115740709,
0.0327473283,
-0.0532999374,
-0.0043136543,
-0.0201321226,
0.0050539519,
0.0114840092,
0.0175874755,
-0.0951839089,
-0.0014497858,
-0.0144055793,
0.0160093252,
-0.0577268675,
-0.0317420848,
-0.02305918,
-0.1053927988,
0.042814672,
0.0027496556,
0.010439558,
-0.0260003079,
0.0046780529,
0.0036718615,
0.0286264066,
0.0092396578,
0.0063429787,
0.0296717752,
0.0133518148,
0.0186475832,
-0.0398316532,
-0.0485781506,
0.0103016188,
-0.0016780297,
0.0774581581,
0.0442900062,
0.0248546042,
0.0377940871,
-0.0439553708,
-0.0367241129,
0.0099968761,
0.0159477927,
0.0020239879,
0.0675681531,
-0.0089736832,
-0.001458653,
-0.0259629041,
0.0481244326,
-0.0092530428,
-0.024304172,
0.0431593433,
0.0407896377,
-0.0677103698,
0.02430664,
-0.0066335318,
0.0646949634,
0.0410151891,
0.082629241,
0.0146242259,
-0.0593058653,
0.0207914207,
-0.0044461731,
0.0084530134,
-0.0351591557,
0.0056494935,
0.0011129394,
0.0059761428,
0.0420289002,
-0.0800325722,
-0.0483079702,
0.025022503,
0.0180650819,
-0.0257818047,
0.0025521596,
-0.0034278505,
-0.0178792998,
-0.0180512946,
-0.0124995047,
-0.0143603459,
0.0066392072,
-0.0315536447,
-0.0507694297,
0.0703852624,
-0.0511135124,
-0.0002419465,
0.0322887562,
-0.0588282123,
-0.0579853579,
0.0096972771,
0.0348214731,
0.0164367631,
0.0768396929,
0.0331861004,
0.0051337588,
0.0210020468,
0.0145188356,
-0.0412024148,
0.0005645118,
0.0147977443,
0.1136350855,
-0.0092137624,
0.0073188255,
-0.0043100812,
0.0234110896,
-0.0129418885,
0.0260393899,
-0.0625116229,
-0.0939532816,
0.0202197954,
0.0188125446,
0.0343110487,
-0.0129997125,
0.0128329042,
-0.0155544905,
0.0218050666,
-0.0531143695,
-0.0355215333,
-0.0684543177,
-0.0089765033,
0.0122388955,
-0.0353040248,
0.0129853785,
-0.0696056336,
-0.0568425059,
0.0006848566,
-0.0432162434,
-0.0203543138,
0.0051437342,
-0.0091841575,
0.0055798911,
-0.0013965731,
-0.0310660079,
-0.0060407845,
-0.0056388555,
0.0171898883,
-0.0029628,
0.1446856558,
0.0270562377,
-0.0491177998,
0.0151440827,
0.0330792554,
-0.0696137697,
-0.0349629596,
-0.005239401,
0.0158496872,
0.0218457077,
0.0486344807,
0.0443327501,
-0.0230594166,
0.0230215993,
0.0045773084,
0.0535300635,
0.0064715841,
-0.0598433502,
0.0481462926,
0.011022768,
-0.0281107724,
0.014166778,
0.0585488379,
-0.0606233515,
0.0274635162,
-0.0098607037,
0.0055472204,
-0.0744132102,
-0.0135398926,
0.001847306,
0.0581739098,
-0.0012426755,
0.032019075,
-0.0506300777,
-0.0214558467,
0.0152153857,
-0.008943419,
0.0058232537,
-0.0443899371,
0.0507060103,
0.0153375091,
-0.0164864026,
-0.0218321215,
-0.0340630673,
0.0433344766,
-0.0005250659,
-0.0160717051,
-0.0600628406,
-5.827417368e-33,
-0.0385927372,
-0.0092964638,
0.0322284289,
0.0116204582,
-0.0982316434,
-0.024973372,
-0.0408681445,
0.016694976,
-0.005901176,
0.0021847575,
-0.0124532385,
0.0009554559,
0.0048149452,
0.0629861951,
0.0074061798,
-0.0110358987,
0.0420969203,
-0.0158585943,
-0.0201366283,
0.0328322127,
0.0218078718,
0.0166792944,
0.0199357495,
-0.0932375863,
0.0066921641,
-0.0293170009,
-0.0265196916,
0.007225133,
-0.0072073033,
0.0452580638,
-0.0234617293,
0.0375945941,
0.009130897,
-0.0460834987,
-0.0329639167,
0.0355849527,
-0.0089233033,
-0.0235608537,
0.0391375944,
0.0186539572,
-0.0491650701,
0.0007972977,
-0.0092346407,
-0.044827383,
0.0272606742,
0.0189383458,
-0.0169389229,
-0.0479587503,
-0.0058924239,
-0.0086172549,
-0.03721039,
0.0017702252,
-0.0178244691,
-0.055232361,
-0.0323908888,
0.0679092854,
0.0095549487,
-0.0373550169,
-0.0544638894,
0.0303575192,
0.0446302146,
-0.0125422375,
0.0291413963,
0.0401485972,
0.0130529776,
0.0489867851,
0.0223079734,
0.0092774527,
-0.0216579568,
0.026873894,
-0.0077895317,
0.0204600897,
0.010625218,
0.0583713353,
-0.0168468524,
0.0080566853,
-0.0079416167,
-0.0128381653,
0.0745175332,
-0.0256594047,
0.0292671714,
-0.000521175,
-0.0068506715,
-0.0400206298,
-0.0328815877,
-0.0039395662,
-0.0017540555,
-0.0277272593,
0.0347517505,
0.0492624268,
0.0041142311,
-0.0070764762,
0.0402189456,
-0.0183562469,
0.0171691366,
0.0168143958,
-0.0556335002,
0.0423525423,
-0.010903745,
-0.0225625541,
-0.0415616184,
-0.0258222986,
0.0771425366,
0.0199842658,
0.0140753845,
0.0250249431,
-0.0017016169,
0.0025988179,
-0.058646623,
0.0022780516,
-0.0106620844,
0.0659793839,
-0.0431251116,
-0.0201957989,
-0.0111742588,
0.0198418275,
-0.054101564,
0.0563397147,
-0.0031649296,
0.0032424019,
-0.0297092646,
-0.0357032008,
0.0231690109,
0.0352959596,
-0.0445869565,
0.0288621504,
0.0146631468,
-0.0474930815,
0.0110489996,
-0.0152292605,
-0.0035829761,
0.0034563597,
2.698e-7,
-0.010342584,
0.0411129855,
0.0176657382,
0.0234336369,
0.0352912471,
0.0256922133,
-0.0145103037,
-0.0046580015,
0.0535105616,
-0.031947989,
0.0297304131,
0.0116955396,
0.0410212539,
0.0012840136,
-0.0709907636,
-0.0484803766,
-0.0270834025,
-0.0451911613,
-0.0608581677,
0.0119519485,
0.1302087009,
0.0563397594,
0.0029672794,
0.0163865499,
0.0071320911,
0.0250054337,
0.0662117004,
-0.0116162645,
-0.0292557292,
0.0204948634,
0.0490103289,
-0.0114636645,
0.0039241733,
0.0589328557,
0.0103707705,
0.0371047147,
-0.027736906,
0.0409444682,
0.0000566442,
-0.0300945807,
0.0068681608,
0.0229492281,
-0.0085585564,
-0.0404860489,
0.0538956709,
-0.0592663586,
-0.0210513473,
-0.0164603759,
-0.0449222401,
-0.0106220711,
0.0284824912,
-0.038033288,
-0.0435303859,
0.0200057253,
0.0220215358,
0.0033439912,
0.011113503,
-0.0659032241,
-0.0047143055,
-0.0056462744,
-0.0746032223,
-0.0358766541,
-0.0154417222,
-0.0230308808,
0.0084106717,
-0.0534733012,
0.0042646294,
2.542764636e-34,
0.0226563793,
-0.0080320816,
0.0305208713,
0.0084153758,
0.0240704566,
-0.004973141,
0.0204298776,
0.0187731218,
0.022055883,
-0.0928599909,
-0.0193787944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16563v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16563v2 | Are there identifiable structural parts in the sentence embedding whole? | 2024-06-24T11:58:33 | 2024-07-02T14:14:48 | Vivi Nastase, Paola Merlo | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | Sentence embeddings from transformer models encode in a fixed length vector
much linguistic information. We explore the hypothesis that these embeddings
consist of overlapping layers of information that can be separated, and on
which specific types of information -- such as information about chunks and
their structural and semantic properties -- can be detected. We show that this
is the case using a dataset consisting of sentences with known chunk structure,
and two linguistic intelligence datasets, solving which relies on detecting
chunks and their grammatical number, and respectively, their semantic roles,
and through analyses of the performance on the tasks and of the internal
representations built during learning. | [
0.0042067119,
0.0071805934,
-0.0376779586,
0.0555286147,
-0.0440059751,
0.0222668108,
-0.012679182,
-0.0325595737,
-0.0356692895,
-0.0541698262,
-0.009510085,
0.0087258909,
0.0040889625,
-0.0146134719,
0.030531114,
-0.040276587,
0.0415088609,
-0.0059243799,
0.0136564942,
0.0282580089,
0.0131196678,
-0.0408051051,
0.0042856708,
0.0385275744,
-0.0275463518,
-0.0058739516,
-0.0070586833,
-0.0522850752,
0.006981716,
0.0083735185,
0.0200427175,
0.0203643832,
-0.0005622286,
0.0137738418,
0.0000016225,
-0.0014809063,
-0.0025363967,
-0.0324237831,
-0.0352043584,
-0.0097977621,
0.0053765373,
-0.0618171059,
0.0006800204,
-0.0069870036,
-0.0251997467,
-0.0012101654,
0.0242593084,
0.1042966843,
0.0371635072,
0.0604160167,
-0.0151298335,
-0.042692218,
0.0458022095,
0.0149814077,
0.018931916,
0.0123597588,
0.0232053772,
-0.0199066997,
-0.0195355099,
0.0332839154,
-0.0630806237,
0.0199139006,
0.0512771271,
0.0050714361,
-0.0144654587,
0.0364005603,
-0.0263599902,
-0.0223708544,
-0.0057362113,
0.0259809848,
-0.0054942574,
-0.0006250983,
-0.0174719524,
0.0108853588,
0.0361303128,
0.019124046,
-0.0676946416,
0.0797515512,
0.0296990331,
0.0356355309,
0.0434420109,
0.018967852,
-0.0150037427,
-0.0426811725,
-0.0496734306,
0.054676041,
-0.0002822872,
-0.0743345469,
-0.0149129741,
0.0182249602,
-0.0125345131,
0.0048638126,
-0.005090659,
-0.0004040256,
0.0088477684,
0.0239280406,
-0.021924803,
-0.0257736612,
-0.0112077715,
-0.033097893,
0.0176178869,
0.0326765962,
-0.0072840867,
0.0271454062,
-0.0646258444,
0.0906075463,
-0.0222935472,
0.0546723045,
-0.0436911583,
0.0158185363,
-0.0653486699,
-0.0603556931,
-0.0354127176,
0.0743436888,
-0.015156487,
-0.0489357635,
-0.0202689487,
0.0189134665,
-0.0000973081,
0.002108627,
-0.0219102856,
-0.0000670065,
-0.0109167323,
0.0373168811,
-0.028505329,
0.013570182,
-0.0323923752,
0.0186180584,
-0.0009092028,
-0.0162299573,
-0.0275775827,
0.0197409615,
0.023464594,
-0.014132008,
-0.0453550108,
0.0131357173,
-0.0295088999,
-0.0482957587,
-0.0181591399,
-0.0505438782,
-0.0380609445,
-0.0431565419,
0.056464985,
-0.053073559,
0.0255987607,
-0.0018732214,
-0.0014707496,
-0.0081953658,
0.0005797906,
0.038205944,
-0.0268780347,
0.0529524013,
0.0526212715,
-0.0087773977,
-0.0227555539,
0.0183384735,
0.0633335635,
0.0687865242,
0.0272830371,
0.0146939186,
0.0211398434,
-0.0196701139,
0.0090011638,
0.0198659655,
-0.0167679321,
-0.0331190638,
-0.009503684,
-0.0209502857,
0.0508443005,
-0.0013168068,
-0.0074264514,
0.0429090075,
-0.0157546774,
-0.001210017,
0.0453280583,
0.0668692514,
0.0446608104,
0.0070658033,
0.0436303131,
0.0094143152,
0.0100180544,
0.0781167969,
-0.0250143707,
-0.0077017443,
0.0069245272,
0.0110088456,
-0.0324625224,
-0.0097927852,
-0.0192634519,
-0.0310075544,
-0.0338786654,
-0.0214504171,
0.0136160869,
-0.0563627966,
0.0444772989,
0.0199227966,
-0.041016683,
0.0706928447,
0.0055192919,
-0.0570916496,
-0.0232395399,
0.0237090904,
0.0026465673,
-0.0094804233,
0.010700006,
-0.0101807676,
-0.0217039064,
-0.0002714166,
0.0098937582,
0.0442648754,
-0.0147743896,
-0.0028412726,
-0.0028248075,
-0.0402204506,
-0.0031495551,
-0.0370529853,
0.0229065288,
-0.0439861342,
-0.0015907243,
-0.0237258505,
-0.009527293,
-0.0063031591,
0.0178695153,
0.0530675873,
-0.0231244229,
-0.001720166,
-0.0245057382,
0.0315616131,
0.0178255066,
-0.0169222336,
0.011286336,
0.02093146,
0.0383961424,
-0.0705116317,
-0.0597209856,
0.0622611307,
-0.0580040142,
-0.0788709521,
0.0151487961,
-0.0799111575,
0.0016240495,
0.0245471336,
-0.0098796887,
-0.0206267554,
0.0161057729,
-0.0776156113,
0.0219616164,
0.002681995,
0.0246099569,
0.0141750695,
0.0510443896,
-0.0284519773,
0.0738417208,
-0.0254317857,
0.0558405966,
-0.0400999412,
-0.0261590444,
0.0322799794,
-0.0221336521,
-0.0187306181,
-0.0053493613,
-0.0344855338,
-0.03249247,
0.0141246747,
-0.040990375,
-0.0350903571,
-0.043425113,
-0.0547565147,
-0.007669175,
0.0094316946,
0.0245143175,
0.0203769393,
-0.0134831527,
0.0093242908,
-0.0059507401,
-0.0122260479,
-0.0249791816,
0.0064905249,
0.0110830339,
0.0465237722,
-0.0016715958,
-0.0399770103,
-0.0176072177,
-0.0161633659,
-0.0756562799,
0.0774459913,
-0.0049334988,
-0.0263417158,
-0.0616819113,
0.0092388121,
0.0028618469,
-0.0174333081,
-0.0209863875,
-0.0920982286,
0.015571706,
0.0104285702,
0.0837135464,
0.0777129754,
0.002155009,
0.0688203573,
0.0437001921,
-0.0155364117,
0.0063355523,
0.0123876557,
-0.0634070709,
0.0639243051,
-0.0465037487,
-0.0369520746,
0.0192178898,
0.1138662919,
0.0271159094,
0.0077839354,
-0.0399749801,
0.0295728724,
-0.0359021574,
0.0033807058,
0.0006012396,
-0.0056659654,
-0.0333608314,
0.0131870881,
-0.0302905552,
-0.0115256757,
0.0578752719,
-0.004583281,
-0.0258589275,
-0.0435437188,
-0.0234854035,
-0.0538633093,
0.0556296781,
0.0417500436,
-0.0016106571,
-0.0055601643,
-0.0255236626,
-0.060598366,
0.0442371033,
-0.0029783011,
0.0183577668,
0.0224507209,
0.0009285137,
-0.0332315937,
-0.0272480715,
-0.047821749,
-0.0214496739,
-0.0348998159,
-0.0241593663,
0.0280368328,
0.0535572171,
-0.0056176679,
-0.0579224974,
-0.0102400137,
0.0526189394,
-0.0096298568,
-0.0355901718,
0.0075475699,
-0.0570722111,
0.0355903208,
0.0259964149,
0.0382558256,
0.000220852,
-0.0503010601,
0.0558032356,
0.0354005806,
-0.0028642181,
0.0438103117,
-0.0260740519,
0.0067856167,
0.0199886654,
-0.0264371764,
-0.0105140042,
0.0007087256,
0.040179342,
-0.0299414936,
-0.0282249115,
0.101741299,
0.0439574756,
0.010422878,
0.0248422287,
-0.0073980526,
0.007921394,
0.0350747295,
0.0114508271,
-0.1004424766,
-0.0254883058,
0.0203001462,
-0.0654442534,
-0.0122122625,
-0.0185818076,
0.0069665415,
-0.0995233059,
0.0330307595,
-0.020141121,
-0.0224210713,
-0.009513706,
-0.0010609288,
-0.0167296324,
0.0330912508,
-0.0262467936,
-0.0385696366,
-0.0426002033,
-0.0124634225,
0.0192360636,
-0.0540411063,
-0.0101161972,
-0.0335206315,
-0.0271996018,
0.0129261138,
-0.0094182361,
0.0306197796,
-0.0211333409,
-0.02827207,
0.0271382332,
-0.0108582275,
0.0004009992,
0.0228367038,
0.0705236942,
0.0062450129,
-0.0159563981,
-0.0324213244,
0.0101781413,
-0.0388193652,
-0.0274720974,
0.0077718715,
0.0939298049,
-0.0085909059,
-0.0443718992,
-0.0069975187,
0.0293419454,
-0.058926627,
0.1002765298,
0.0619775392,
-0.0301817078,
-0.0275359508,
-0.0390826017,
0.0354060829,
0.0034698988,
-0.0369494893,
0.0717318431,
0.0301624909,
0.0282916203,
-0.0827328041,
-0.0612068735,
0.0430132449,
0.0215694346,
0.0226754341,
0.0002969918,
-0.0009202232,
-0.0214193221,
-0.0350182578,
-0.004052015,
-0.0138390288,
-0.01688198,
-0.0622796044,
0.0276273489,
0.0044493261,
-0.0130185168,
-0.0418216921,
-0.0428060032,
-0.0525986739,
-0.0424253382,
0.0272359252,
0.0161088482,
0.0096311113,
0.0214798748,
0.0131951626,
-0.0398600921,
0.0574374348,
0.0135486042,
-0.0896037444,
0.0255730376,
0.0367296189,
-0.0157126188,
0.027718462,
0.0247114711,
-0.0240333714,
0.0084405532,
0.0055584563,
0.0349562541,
-0.0009178566,
0.0255927108,
0.0433591343,
-0.0137185035,
0.0517235771,
0.0466075987,
0.0259458777,
-0.0273382608,
0.0186737962,
-0.0353620499,
-0.0212878287,
-0.0371965505,
-0.0209132303,
0.0199744906,
0.0267943908,
0.0071399841,
0.0614568591,
0.0141984625,
0.0269877929,
0.002830653,
0.0016080972,
0.0306137037,
-0.0267103948,
-0.0233049579,
0.0546847954,
0.004225194,
-0.0044487654,
-0.021827966,
0.0185871851,
0.0059456271,
0.0283609033,
0.0279195867,
0.0044023525,
-0.0372265428,
0.0045794435,
-0.0697279647,
0.0244761035,
0.0198384691,
-0.0366368368,
0.0087170647,
-0.0432251059,
0.0030459634,
-0.0285991449,
-0.0038980385,
-0.0017688184,
0.0183056481,
-0.0363051258,
-0.0157350004,
0.0708138794,
0.0282869618,
-0.0323405713,
-0.0392826758,
0.0719566718,
0.0051414436,
0.0272580013,
-0.0095221056,
-0.0004654227,
-0.0524659678,
-0.0011538547,
0.0210960787,
0.0272809099,
-0.0007719416,
0.0252952185,
-0.0364802778,
-0.0436874069,
0.0086220978,
0.0084530311,
0.029288549,
-0.0130285816,
0.0080521973,
0.0248864982,
0.0087942928,
-0.0494305864,
-0.0147633506,
-0.0026569376,
-0.0197443329,
-0.0338996314,
-0.0080048218,
-5.503280678e-33,
-0.0206405707,
-0.0273290966,
-0.0026554184,
0.0498309433,
0.0091647627,
0.0173788089,
-0.0159345493,
0.0233245082,
0.0028169737,
0.057744123,
0.0087484512,
0.007069624,
0.0086325845,
0.0313811079,
0.013019843,
-0.0193898883,
0.0498482212,
-0.0268804561,
-0.0306837093,
-0.0314281955,
0.0334801525,
0.0265595149,
0.0883303061,
-0.0022928163,
-0.0024614022,
-0.0119471829,
0.042405773,
0.028027216,
0.0121656852,
0.106076695,
-0.0187670775,
0.0211899411,
0.0567622334,
-0.0617061518,
-0.0266504567,
0.0619991384,
-0.0589827113,
-0.0456505902,
0.0312331598,
0.0465875566,
-0.053277187,
-0.0800899044,
0.0417218879,
-0.0575952381,
0.0035951806,
-0.0419281349,
0.059470322,
0.0074365409,
0.024620004,
0.0101449518,
-0.1002166197,
-0.0179069042,
-0.0234009326,
-0.0111653842,
0.0439650714,
0.0275768172,
0.0158099364,
0.025898207,
-0.0352841318,
0.0148745831,
-0.0230128299,
0.0727636963,
-0.0021024367,
-0.0094187791,
-0.0141627733,
0.0850225613,
0.0484093353,
-0.0338138267,
-0.0265325606,
-0.0190786347,
0.0656128451,
0.0375985168,
0.0632125512,
0.013189869,
0.0339713432,
0.0249229949,
-0.0633073822,
-0.0238050912,
0.0380402766,
0.036029581,
0.0251729209,
-0.0053340602,
-0.0416218564,
-0.0296034273,
-0.0124426428,
0.0071675875,
-0.0145590119,
0.0004368043,
0.0501343049,
0.0197811332,
0.027503971,
-0.0198703762,
0.0459965952,
-0.0684232637,
0.0275055524,
-0.0036774583,
-0.025527833,
0.0534067638,
0.0142477406,
-0.0029489635,
-0.0555569194,
-0.0272018425,
-0.009756282,
0.0065902406,
0.0312989801,
0.0087855849,
0.0943574309,
0.0175203197,
-0.035583552,
-0.0042606248,
-0.0220959038,
-0.0451561734,
-0.0216685664,
-0.015396161,
0.0467477515,
0.0415800437,
-0.0441908017,
0.0074991644,
0.0196852088,
0.0181679763,
-0.0288688671,
0.0205565672,
-0.0039218203,
0.0451241806,
-0.0133415526,
-0.0274993014,
-0.0482344031,
0.019158192,
0.0284769312,
-0.0534575097,
0.0094528673,
0.0451734364,
2.435e-7,
0.0162589345,
0.06771373,
0.0519242845,
-0.0231265966,
0.0426070988,
0.0134214116,
-0.02581615,
-0.0013562026,
-0.0116902208,
0.0185774621,
-0.0062786369,
0.0156885143,
0.0447649099,
-0.0085499473,
-0.1223963574,
0.0238334145,
-0.0358924083,
-0.034524709,
-0.0501111448,
0.0164327528,
0.053312771,
0.104436107,
0.0143799456,
0.0343279131,
-0.0533627942,
-0.0481302626,
0.0544934645,
-0.0293825474,
-0.0042254413,
0.0131995548,
0.0042395685,
0.0226293355,
0.0081170555,
0.0148403337,
0.0124233142,
0.0636337176,
0.0136140762,
0.0127158007,
0.0475078076,
0.0191725772,
0.0066031073,
-0.0089729764,
-0.03391454,
-0.0255295057,
0.0441271216,
-0.1171047091,
-0.0799680576,
-0.0004880746,
0.000883689,
-0.0056062345,
0.0195719413,
0.0347534157,
-0.0146520892,
-0.0103882449,
0.038258899,
-0.0342672206,
0.0218980946,
-0.0680795461,
-0.0156979207,
0.0413603932,
-0.0566463023,
0.0043306844,
-0.0408491567,
-0.0261847284,
0.0449500047,
-0.0492865928,
-0.0250585526,
2.255320221e-34,
-0.0205033626,
0.010818216,
0.0379667953,
0.0453862809,
0.0337870121,
-0.0598175339,
0.0023871162,
0.0127935307,
0.0035182445,
-0.083814472,
-0.0004246426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16562v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16562v2 | EVALALIGN: Supervised Fine-Tuning Multimodal LLMs with Human-Aligned Data for Evaluating Text-to-Image Models | 2024-06-24T11:56:15 | 2024-06-27T03:57:05 | Zhiyu Tan, Xiaomeng Yang, Luozheng Qin, Mengping Yang, Cheng Zhang, Hao Li | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | The recent advancements in text-to-image generative models have been
remarkable. Yet, the field suffers from a lack of evaluation metrics that
accurately reflect the performance of these models, particularly lacking
fine-grained metrics that can guide the optimization of the models. In this
paper, we propose EvalAlign, a metric characterized by its accuracy, stability,
and fine granularity. Our approach leverages the capabilities of Multimodal
Large Language Models (MLLMs) pre-trained on extensive datasets. We develop
evaluation protocols that focus on two key dimensions: image faithfulness and
text-image alignment. Each protocol comprises a set of detailed, fine-grained
instructions linked to specific scoring options, enabling precise manual
scoring of the generated images. We Supervised Fine-Tune (SFT) the MLLM to
align closely with human evaluative judgments, resulting in a robust evaluation
model. Our comprehensive tests across 24 text-to-image generation models
demonstrate that EvalAlign not only provides superior metric stability but also
aligns more closely with human preferences than existing metrics, confirming
its effectiveness and utility in model assessment. | [
0.0107755577,
0.0791027695,
0.0330690369,
0.0453355573,
-0.0209600702,
0.0107440045,
0.0122986306,
0.0081947772,
-0.0357288495,
-0.0489744321,
-0.0722650513,
-0.0379228331,
0.0328247808,
0.0133037893,
0.0567207709,
-0.0609358884,
-0.0342253521,
-0.0356044732,
-0.0318928324,
-0.0108671617,
0.0341639221,
0.0161213111,
-0.0064880843,
0.0296720155,
-0.0269668084,
-0.0305159315,
0.0235265233,
0.0494981967,
0.0369224623,
-0.0091456985,
-0.0239376053,
0.0488007627,
0.0042811981,
-0.0047502667,
0.0000019313,
-0.0380611457,
0.0160082094,
0.0120670274,
0.0480179004,
0.013326915,
0.0706390217,
-0.0255277772,
-0.0206849128,
-0.0395813361,
-0.0183532331,
0.0310116336,
0.0770092532,
0.0333387554,
0.0908033401,
0.0516823828,
-0.0166457631,
-0.0280341674,
-0.0060394234,
-0.0264570378,
0.0113481069,
-0.0173268523,
-0.0000450652,
0.039548479,
-0.0234705824,
-0.0023976751,
-0.0178117733,
0.0394127071,
0.0145055912,
-0.0348610654,
0.0187144391,
0.0264060702,
0.0149011137,
-0.042453222,
-0.008049746,
0.0791337639,
-0.0264383741,
-0.0107407579,
-0.0304634348,
-0.0284806751,
-0.0058720452,
0.0142169362,
-0.0312629044,
0.0155449593,
0.0247879941,
0.0244833492,
-0.0554676652,
0.0158790909,
0.0172111858,
0.0087051876,
0.01301907,
-0.0082892859,
0.0423247553,
0.0043427972,
-0.0357962884,
0.0328980647,
-0.0441631526,
-0.0438725688,
0.0279505458,
0.022433266,
0.0128606902,
-0.0094247749,
-0.0663480684,
-0.0175301898,
0.0030037847,
-0.0190800987,
0.0762139708,
0.0074246014,
-0.0420037732,
0.0341954976,
-0.0448329784,
0.0662471205,
-0.0000551517,
0.0356470607,
-0.0368755385,
0.0099675935,
-0.0133091453,
0.0230686571,
0.005768002,
-0.0285879523,
-0.0258365646,
-0.0287120827,
-0.0547203086,
-0.0013295636,
-0.0070655411,
0.0121099483,
0.0139160827,
0.0290745944,
-0.032978408,
-0.026392702,
-0.0300648566,
0.0131659498,
-0.0069839489,
0.0299351048,
0.0112655144,
-0.0129394252,
0.0197251514,
0.055726435,
0.0063054091,
-0.0163492784,
-0.0031145159,
0.0809317157,
-0.0467244647,
-0.0178744923,
-0.0067543816,
-0.0036122387,
-0.0465390682,
-0.074702844,
0.006221957,
-0.0568500645,
0.026354691,
-0.0159553289,
0.0129780071,
-0.0355615579,
-0.0203251112,
-0.0113574043,
0.0209371131,
0.0696664751,
0.0302337203,
0.0187637191,
0.0210696477,
-0.0010327228,
0.0073741521,
0.0366925634,
0.0584389418,
0.0857303441,
0.016580157,
-0.0125951795,
0.0136404037,
0.0762373134,
0.0097859064,
0.0102830371,
-0.0307358298,
-0.0140567599,
-0.0140270088,
0.0491342954,
0.0671966821,
0.0812445283,
-0.0042613996,
0.0085309194,
0.137421906,
0.0282266065,
0.0309891067,
-0.0001484219,
0.0390530303,
-0.001277521,
-0.0041413028,
0.0100466013,
-0.0345765166,
0.0539555512,
-0.0035481867,
0.0396525264,
0.0592698753,
0.063413702,
-0.0173690934,
-0.0324265249,
-0.0101622343,
-0.0159822199,
-0.0151885785,
-0.0171817075,
0.0298642274,
0.0155658396,
-0.0654518157,
0.0041439207,
-0.010014629,
-0.0452167876,
0.0239420738,
-0.0499133095,
0.0404627807,
0.0868787393,
0.0566966385,
0.0576577894,
0.0206528716,
0.0142462756,
0.0136803584,
0.0781650022,
-0.0135462014,
0.0080911126,
0.0188028999,
-0.0503032766,
-0.0238060225,
0.006422204,
-0.0064687002,
0.0124408565,
0.0019860591,
0.0070683411,
0.0083473949,
-0.0529609509,
-0.0460180677,
0.0506722406,
0.0068179299,
-0.0123947216,
-0.0309546012,
0.0290571991,
0.0095872916,
-0.0157528743,
-0.0431376807,
0.006990667,
-0.0042408719,
-0.0268752389,
0.0266050324,
-0.0048314938,
-0.0216541644,
0.0011174383,
0.0168717932,
-0.0554111302,
-0.0160400923,
0.0125695979,
-0.0261995606,
-0.0134842405,
-0.0282700025,
-0.0289967414,
-0.0269136801,
-0.0668262765,
0.0146971308,
0.0239228513,
-0.0035437036,
-0.0400466323,
0.0363962464,
-0.0264856424,
-0.0004272549,
0.002008074,
0.0103761936,
-0.0197435711,
-0.0272219814,
-0.0330181159,
-0.0009676271,
0.0209251251,
0.0427455083,
0.0112968115,
0.0635768324,
-0.0439997427,
-0.0463881306,
-0.0731503069,
-0.0204951558,
-0.00608397,
-0.0033056096,
0.0202407129,
-0.0331524946,
0.0078407852,
0.0163399503,
-0.0435237847,
0.0040449211,
0.0276617222,
-0.0116016287,
0.0516087636,
-0.0227473751,
0.0184874982,
-0.0571654551,
0.0010155635,
0.0396956205,
0.0645639375,
0.0269721076,
0.0169664361,
-0.05288665,
0.0242811218,
-0.0489022508,
-0.01652335,
0.0060798014,
-0.0545435548,
0.0249629747,
0.0117700193,
0.0423150957,
0.0749888495,
0.0381168164,
-0.0275277589,
0.0082002748,
0.017931195,
-0.0488306843,
-0.0397768393,
-0.0039141416,
-0.0429864116,
0.0033857159,
-0.0405632444,
-0.0091661615,
0.0364813618,
0.0116233509,
0.041825328,
-0.0570870005,
0.0364331268,
-0.0093002412,
-0.0507792421,
-0.0300635006,
0.0393815748,
-0.0173105989,
0.0142331608,
-0.0667658225,
-0.0921049491,
0.050997261,
-0.0808069408,
-0.0137121193,
0.0398998074,
0.0122171994,
0.0121368449,
0.050885316,
0.0167762693,
0.0478279963,
-0.0042573111,
0.035893362,
-0.0587792993,
-0.0111494157,
0.0285568517,
-0.0424620956,
0.0508055985,
-0.0377579406,
0.0197889246,
-0.0192996506,
-0.0213288628,
-0.0281314403,
-0.028054826,
0.0052393959,
-0.0269756783,
-0.003922137,
-0.0342747383,
-0.0014899067,
0.0399112478,
0.0109601039,
-0.0109172994,
-0.0200202614,
-0.0267571975,
-0.0113559831,
0.0515221544,
0.0568026192,
0.0049098926,
-0.0299412478,
-0.0505746566,
-0.0144387893,
0.0268845931,
-0.0092773028,
0.0281597599,
-0.0731268674,
0.0230021309,
0.0190184116,
0.0747078508,
0.0291217826,
0.0223784763,
0.0800504088,
-0.0298653487,
0.0048627649,
0.0754041597,
-0.013301827,
-0.0180311371,
-0.0276588183,
0.02995486,
0.0618593134,
-0.0105391443,
-0.0118569667,
-0.068205148,
-0.0455553755,
-0.0193736739,
0.0283997208,
0.0345623828,
0.0082684485,
-0.012550001,
-0.0762247145,
0.0440651774,
0.0438082516,
-0.0160946697,
-0.0274300016,
0.0096507976,
0.0117164003,
-0.0208269488,
0.0070805019,
0.0114914468,
-0.0004888411,
0.0075711757,
0.0240195561,
0.0258919876,
-0.0718839169,
0.0066301287,
-0.0447803922,
0.027463723,
0.0849273056,
0.0329899751,
0.0235761702,
-0.0753997266,
0.0322518833,
0.0278198235,
0.0029442168,
0.006419498,
0.0223365538,
-0.0147624817,
-0.0208176803,
-0.0107982,
0.0447945446,
0.0208042879,
0.0074198782,
-0.0116343265,
0.0052933348,
-0.0050442321,
-0.0072213593,
-0.0273737963,
0.0119833173,
0.0014640574,
0.0520989113,
0.0432154574,
-0.0646232441,
-0.0332101732,
-0.0166327842,
0.0227093808,
-0.0864149407,
-0.0494269952,
0.0229033288,
-0.038098149,
-0.0160014816,
-0.0871240795,
-0.0059911339,
0.0141075486,
0.0430497378,
-0.0064166524,
-0.0389076434,
-0.0326636545,
0.0075463154,
-0.0232725311,
0.0749070197,
-0.0379308313,
0.028488094,
-0.0628030151,
-0.0041793925,
0.0262467228,
-0.0379591286,
-0.009805616,
0.056921687,
-0.0995219797,
-0.034531869,
-0.0325376615,
0.0823075622,
0.0130095799,
0.0136176702,
0.0091896942,
-0.0667759776,
0.0441640802,
0.0502201058,
-0.0038018913,
0.0192740336,
-0.008057544,
0.0196262598,
-0.0154060712,
0.0166119318,
-0.0355361924,
0.0379540995,
0.0115848081,
0.0335920602,
0.0171661321,
-0.0675968453,
0.0044739828,
0.0257692058,
0.003919553,
-0.0838107094,
-0.0178108644,
-0.0361504816,
-0.031597849,
-0.0046102344,
-0.0292833801,
-0.0806955695,
-0.0190168004,
0.031147996,
0.0377889276,
-0.0133612147,
-0.0039462661,
0.0118602132,
0.0639314801,
-0.0602949262,
0.0038623004,
0.0031702656,
0.005769148,
0.006586262,
0.02294714,
-0.020328423,
0.0302179325,
-0.053899467,
0.0170134678,
0.0053623626,
0.0432765521,
0.0202533212,
0.0045409212,
0.0043847617,
0.0678423122,
0.0161832273,
-0.0192243252,
-0.0980329216,
0.0198266394,
0.0765862018,
0.0284140892,
0.0891202167,
-0.0092852451,
-0.0099924859,
-0.0283675101,
0.0445796102,
-0.0019037807,
-0.0052657332,
0.0271721259,
-0.009983398,
0.0205982104,
-0.0145828342,
0.0392837077,
-0.0038613244,
0.0001136691,
-0.0502946228,
0.001953277,
-0.0350081623,
-0.0356496125,
-0.0029540511,
-0.0455635563,
0.0107727051,
-0.0199963469,
-0.0151681919,
-0.0593455248,
-0.0136133917,
0.0849587917,
-0.0171792358,
0.015616768,
0.0423660502,
0.0422915183,
-0.0308405273,
0.0224596765,
-0.0173613708,
-0.0223279167,
0.011787937,
-0.000123037,
-0.0177784786,
-6.010005436e-33,
-0.0460810177,
-0.0483061746,
0.0255080964,
-0.0399711914,
-0.0443829633,
-0.0069337599,
-0.0283185709,
0.0177973807,
0.0250625778,
-0.0069914213,
0.0312987044,
-0.055831857,
0.0073202169,
0.0352539532,
-0.0215203445,
0.0137307812,
0.0341649316,
-0.0140906414,
-0.050047718,
-0.006304258,
-0.0073956437,
-0.0012079019,
0.0212809592,
-0.0507294126,
0.0139248623,
-0.0096135214,
-0.0837208405,
-0.0154161854,
-0.0000562803,
0.0580774061,
-0.0265337639,
-0.0021474801,
0.0028763625,
-0.0083656767,
-0.0329910256,
0.0203770325,
-0.032736823,
0.0229680426,
0.0175528154,
0.0010455338,
-0.0788239539,
-0.0142834103,
0.0643337369,
-0.0356554948,
-0.0446750596,
-0.0224936325,
0.0527487844,
-0.0501579307,
0.0127538946,
-0.0316782966,
-0.0418955907,
0.0085652638,
-0.0226041172,
-0.0531418622,
0.0145323928,
0.0566333681,
-0.0048686825,
0.050177414,
-0.0476757213,
0.034820281,
-0.0024467539,
0.0297395885,
0.101049535,
0.0562022291,
-0.0061690449,
0.0570858233,
0.0000362851,
-0.0239802599,
-0.0077917227,
-0.0123836612,
0.025097806,
0.064851217,
0.0424367227,
0.0863655061,
-0.0175138805,
0.0059296489,
-0.0147037366,
0.0707232058,
-0.06383688,
0.0034540242,
0.0405191146,
0.0270087924,
0.0087230932,
0.0250103045,
-0.0545153953,
-0.0257393289,
-0.048586607,
-0.0185025055,
0.0351684615,
0.0045942604,
-0.0169711933,
-0.0195142757,
0.0587407947,
0.0054578888,
-0.020062929,
-0.0326505564,
-0.0538833886,
0.0516187921,
-0.0269975737,
-0.0049064015,
-0.0124074426,
-0.0283312779,
0.0549155176,
0.0311160944,
0.0265580583,
0.0044790329,
0.0166781377,
0.004103397,
-0.0373184383,
0.0126717128,
-0.0370736904,
0.0033026279,
0.0001573334,
0.0057715965,
0.019423401,
-0.0412307642,
-0.0636965781,
0.0403081365,
-0.0148129743,
0.007056904,
-0.0127270762,
-0.0389180221,
0.019175861,
0.0105670244,
-0.0551083051,
0.0418035351,
-0.0130220391,
-0.0450218916,
0.0188572239,
-0.0288697109,
-0.0159942098,
0.034346357,
2.487e-7,
0.0368751585,
0.0179946311,
0.0091283675,
0.0042815474,
0.0018351347,
0.0532982089,
-0.0336107127,
0.0142908012,
0.0151864719,
-0.0503816828,
0.001101371,
0.0288837124,
0.0852601752,
-0.0040832637,
-0.00177478,
0.0230733231,
-0.0497468263,
0.0315212496,
-0.0160757825,
-0.0121178934,
0.0613646023,
0.0399036743,
-0.0196798556,
-0.0369069986,
0.0447014645,
-0.0364167169,
0.0824242681,
-0.0475274138,
-0.0441711657,
-0.0088846507,
0.0544118546,
-0.0214884467,
-0.0094043231,
-0.0083985813,
0.006983608,
-0.0500528552,
0.0629144683,
0.0585857034,
-0.0152880987,
-0.0259518791,
-0.0223721303,
0.0051708487,
-0.0067465403,
-0.0592245497,
0.0424149148,
-0.0341711193,
-0.0039210366,
-0.0226434935,
-0.0137634007,
-0.004420714,
0.0382445008,
-0.0554230176,
-0.0421415865,
0.0349392295,
0.0707259849,
0.0138647575,
-0.0448539108,
-0.0309610553,
-0.057872165,
-0.0069738827,
-0.0473216511,
-0.0491719209,
-0.0531452447,
-0.0077239904,
0.0096480744,
-0.0510734916,
-0.0344502367,
1.840183027e-34,
0.0090436079,
-0.008074726,
0.0224191993,
-0.0236678645,
0.0355195291,
0.0167878214,
-0.0225814227,
-0.0181415584,
-0.0209823493,
-0.0689271837,
-0.015322255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16554v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16554v1 | LLaMA-MoE: Building Mixture-of-Experts from LLaMA with Continual Pre-training | 2024-06-24T11:43:07 | 2024-06-24T11:43:07 | Tong Zhu, Xiaoye Qu, Daize Dong, Jiacheng Ruan, Jingqi Tong, Conghui He, Yu Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) has gained increasing popularity as a promising
framework for scaling up large language models (LLMs). However, training MoE
from scratch in a large-scale setting still suffers from data-hungry and
instability problems. Motivated by this limit, we investigate building MoE
models from existing dense large language models. Specifically, based on the
well-known LLaMA-2 7B model, we obtain an MoE model by: (1) Expert
Construction, which partitions the parameters of original Feed-Forward Networks
(FFNs) into multiple experts; (2) Continual Pre-training, which further trains
the transformed MoE model and additional gate networks. In this paper, we
comprehensively explore different methods for expert construction and various
data sampling strategies for continual pre-training. After these stages, our
LLaMA-MoE models could maintain language abilities and route the input tokens
to specific experts with part of the parameters activated. Empirically, by
training 200B tokens, LLaMA-MoE-3.5B models significantly outperform dense
models that contain similar activation parameters. The source codes and models
are available at https://github.com/pjlab-sys4nlp/llama-moe . | [
0.0341990553,
0.0933955386,
0.0085256277,
0.0014966102,
0.0080123534,
-0.0199825335,
0.0396404415,
-0.0109655354,
-0.0246137064,
-0.0086823599,
-0.0854361728,
-0.0241477918,
-0.0111488895,
0.044053182,
0.0567601621,
-0.0216059238,
0.0249564964,
-0.0650050268,
-0.0332551524,
-0.0316562206,
-0.008019248,
0.0144066187,
0.002842861,
0.0311970394,
-0.0274841227,
0.0122826211,
0.0067441049,
-0.037019968,
-0.0023281225,
0.0093446448,
-0.0180920232,
0.0450352579,
0.0238278247,
0.0224967767,
0.0000020201,
-0.0194397215,
0.0094983289,
-0.0142145539,
-0.0369597971,
0.0479851998,
0.0229413956,
0.0289808027,
-0.0294806752,
0.0344920345,
0.0020327463,
-0.0504108183,
0.0330649093,
0.0231479891,
0.0578882918,
0.1063040942,
0.0185793303,
-0.0475282334,
0.0887378082,
-0.049353987,
-0.0096136499,
-0.0277423616,
0.0280581918,
0.0005810811,
-0.0032157872,
0.008717468,
-0.0038667026,
0.0456385054,
0.0484564677,
0.0043411721,
0.0282245297,
0.0464828685,
0.0221662093,
-0.0292632096,
-0.0174066015,
0.0611729771,
-0.0621250235,
-0.0124176443,
-0.0130945724,
-0.0048651677,
-0.0244777668,
-0.0050431076,
-0.0433841459,
0.0137420427,
0.0416624732,
0.0343401358,
0.0264691934,
-0.0047265957,
0.0688488632,
0.0256346334,
-0.086567767,
0.0517493971,
0.0080715045,
-0.0013698153,
0.0088567017,
-0.0344309621,
-0.0301599111,
-0.0463642739,
0.0327936299,
0.0462375358,
-0.0138221318,
0.0192396753,
-0.0385898091,
-0.0198996607,
0.0034984869,
-0.0334764197,
0.012490971,
0.0380775817,
-0.0415028594,
0.026046725,
-0.0476404279,
0.0175657962,
-0.022859592,
0.0170804821,
-0.0561341308,
0.0022143638,
-0.0394849479,
-0.0113070207,
-0.0276295207,
0.0349320769,
-0.0258453395,
-0.0379635543,
-0.0451053865,
0.0023861581,
-0.0081321634,
-0.004034684,
0.0257833041,
-0.006912794,
-0.0223587044,
-0.0193509664,
-0.008611572,
0.0347422622,
-0.0330023021,
0.0478072278,
0.0195328388,
-0.0588494316,
0.0058883033,
0.0246621873,
-0.0267832838,
0.0266675744,
0.0361023359,
0.0790150091,
-0.020980468,
-0.0246000122,
-0.0729071051,
0.0108128143,
-0.0082647996,
-0.057056766,
0.0124315117,
-0.0698397458,
0.0647680759,
-0.030302234,
0.03630035,
-0.0564679466,
0.0071676816,
0.0094770929,
-0.013051453,
0.0352869481,
-0.0495762117,
0.0215120614,
0.0312325079,
-0.0052656098,
-0.0065081711,
0.0726937726,
0.0346162096,
0.0231077764,
0.0111509897,
0.0153092127,
-0.0059742248,
0.0526526198,
0.0231168363,
-0.000536121,
-0.0232796948,
-0.020687947,
-0.0128018372,
0.0508809015,
0.0595067926,
0.0709325969,
-0.0447694063,
0.0190764628,
0.0465886258,
0.0445688814,
0.019243231,
0.0584528334,
0.0707794428,
-0.0149953021,
0.0436617099,
-0.0095855081,
-0.0283316504,
-0.0002204657,
-0.0063978969,
-0.0107355742,
0.0501077101,
0.0814340636,
-0.0668024197,
-0.0457146503,
0.0393234417,
-0.0178185143,
-0.0702354237,
0.0117951697,
0.0804978013,
-0.0098463763,
-0.0032994912,
0.0350634344,
0.0380126014,
-0.0250421688,
0.0320109203,
-0.0711220279,
0.0184963048,
0.0492034927,
0.015503332,
-0.0272134338,
-0.0269835405,
0.0056109987,
-0.0147839542,
-0.0192735288,
0.0177266616,
-0.0152864074,
0.0015556636,
-0.0800173804,
0.0029426664,
0.0042126356,
0.0333211422,
0.044114273,
-0.0047992873,
0.0259614289,
0.0222936235,
0.0102569917,
-0.032579992,
0.0388053693,
-0.0621133,
0.0148194088,
0.0219454058,
0.0047835857,
0.0490332358,
0.0315865725,
-0.0216369592,
0.025198387,
0.0104643721,
-0.0532244816,
-0.005297476,
-0.0142179346,
-0.0862155557,
-0.0182110425,
0.0646541491,
0.0332279317,
0.040287517,
-0.0247197058,
-0.0360487215,
-0.0699421093,
0.0011121358,
-0.0135777649,
0.0460953228,
-0.0579903722,
0.0279334988,
0.0168268159,
0.0282569844,
-0.0054989508,
0.0404452421,
-0.0354401842,
-0.0112982141,
-0.0041798628,
0.0119383316,
0.0228814203,
-0.0432121418,
-0.0175776165,
-0.0065969946,
0.0074978103,
0.0455035903,
-0.0538787991,
0.0147040663,
-0.0224504992,
-0.0733741,
-0.078046836,
0.0042408719,
-0.055192668,
0.003527655,
0.0260923393,
-0.0004667899,
-0.0159168784,
0.0330544338,
-0.0289291926,
0.025474295,
-0.0076704696,
-0.0046505937,
-0.029500965,
0.0228312146,
-0.0522240847,
-0.0323630422,
-0.0477856025,
0.0029633185,
0.0388652682,
-0.0355296209,
-0.0349520296,
-0.0428502001,
-0.0182429496,
-0.0104504693,
0.0233908352,
-0.0181875005,
-0.0305529721,
-0.0003251664,
-0.0332035311,
0.0662417188,
0.0360701978,
-0.0166478846,
0.0085259862,
0.0451052152,
-0.0167446192,
-0.0383440033,
0.0115553066,
0.0024656248,
-0.0027676942,
-0.0388527401,
-0.0116607966,
0.0127603095,
0.0330036916,
-0.021816846,
-0.0301369485,
-0.0445762835,
-0.0084258001,
-0.008297571,
-0.0451579951,
-0.0170284417,
-0.0167026855,
-0.0188276842,
0.0177882053,
-0.0049796845,
-0.0484814979,
0.017967917,
-0.0554478504,
0.0081625637,
-0.0175743774,
-0.0396749489,
-0.0359939262,
-0.0125966202,
0.0037710078,
0.0234905388,
-0.0257818885,
-0.0223629307,
-0.047004208,
0.0236280523,
-0.0412697457,
-0.0100253997,
0.0268068798,
-0.0236333366,
0.0128963254,
0.0128669608,
-0.027569592,
-0.0243758596,
-0.0015893849,
-0.0456074551,
0.0451750681,
0.0179426987,
-0.0346954055,
-0.0213780347,
0.0244589131,
0.0065557384,
0.0603478886,
-0.031176623,
0.0212365594,
-0.0301880371,
0.0275304224,
0.0062503023,
0.0100560049,
0.0269934572,
-0.0648325235,
0.008546018,
0.0078914557,
0.0626396984,
-0.0350484401,
-0.0537983775,
0.0125195673,
0.0100080268,
-0.0198338199,
-0.0078391554,
0.0007392424,
0.0436260961,
-0.0328959376,
0.0257835872,
0.0771392286,
0.0026221722,
-0.0589040369,
0.0182705,
0.0208533108,
0.0166453384,
0.0082796682,
0.0509809852,
-0.0395502709,
0.0004923525,
0.0213676989,
0.0145243127,
0.0206029043,
0.0080396207,
-0.0123317325,
-0.1013194919,
0.0084190052,
0.0216292664,
-0.0443672501,
-0.0366775058,
-0.0107370783,
-0.0119622163,
-0.010136554,
0.0393020697,
0.0278381445,
-0.015071041,
-0.0319445133,
0.0366644412,
0.0224629045,
-0.0528658591,
0.0236819647,
-0.0306042079,
0.1020331904,
0.0299212262,
-0.0252335146,
0.0042662863,
-0.0272278339,
0.0600256436,
-0.00152447,
0.0040220073,
0.0076632979,
0.0092193605,
-0.0066703507,
-0.0246594753,
0.0437647477,
0.0451767556,
-0.0118714804,
-0.0062797563,
-0.0055599338,
0.0520679653,
-0.0029878875,
-0.0382808261,
-0.0142879197,
-0.0229273699,
-0.0147225019,
0.0267509297,
0.044643525,
-0.0544396415,
0.0136206569,
0.008331717,
-0.0322982185,
-0.0252417997,
-0.0133117205,
0.0088683991,
-0.0033673244,
-0.0590573587,
-0.0339049362,
0.0001872958,
0.035176523,
0.081453152,
0.0227434449,
0.0130306343,
0.0344853401,
0.0007815033,
0.0361034498,
0.0393094197,
-0.0520328917,
0.0043021101,
-0.0925544426,
-0.0062067918,
0.0660633966,
-0.0158350393,
-0.0181779303,
-0.0304324329,
-0.0805585757,
-0.0707406476,
0.007179155,
0.0607937053,
0.0202395469,
0.0181650873,
-0.0141133526,
-0.0961620137,
0.0930435732,
0.0175637472,
-0.076565817,
0.0110184597,
0.0307789762,
-0.0272960085,
0.0068253959,
0.0285318121,
-0.0126520721,
0.0386366956,
0.0298757683,
0.0236083139,
-0.0287611354,
0.0000244752,
-0.0261286385,
-0.0063741277,
0.0114873694,
-0.0217284858,
0.0265564024,
-0.0839635506,
0.0244293381,
0.0103284251,
0.0213724989,
-0.0431836471,
0.0181032177,
0.0371892452,
0.0211043283,
0.0097267143,
-0.0494483262,
0.04965185,
0.0112480428,
0.035985779,
0.0067357002,
0.0001666306,
0.0141598927,
0.0291544292,
-0.0122957146,
-0.0285272337,
0.0034516761,
0.0062322505,
-0.0012234814,
-0.0531288981,
0.0207295977,
-0.0059060692,
-0.0155914742,
-0.0702167377,
0.0491465069,
-0.0467439443,
-0.0689487383,
-0.0475992821,
0.0803444088,
0.0959733874,
0.0122006629,
0.0170051455,
-0.0109758442,
0.0120360861,
-0.0238931831,
-0.0037184474,
-0.0194771364,
0.0070947451,
0.01690205,
0.0161238648,
-0.0107508674,
0.013105548,
0.0649868697,
0.0218312778,
0.0219142325,
0.0008578815,
0.0491092987,
-0.0082950359,
-0.0033043886,
-0.0011592656,
0.0293395817,
-0.0502802506,
-0.0265259761,
0.000227384,
-0.0709382817,
-0.0134242028,
0.0117872078,
-0.0253854189,
0.0188716501,
0.0344179124,
0.0362121239,
-0.0152929034,
0.0547309965,
-0.0083172116,
-0.0186114367,
0.0537510552,
-0.0125596961,
0.0372254401,
-6.821315841e-33,
-0.0048703528,
0.0355210975,
0.028079344,
-0.0402010381,
-0.0301150661,
-0.0166521631,
-0.0203073137,
-0.001063708,
-0.0270206388,
-0.0127170356,
-0.0653808117,
-0.0004554931,
0.0251245312,
0.0184515994,
0.0138082393,
0.0290051252,
0.0755795985,
-0.0366102383,
0.022037847,
0.0458029285,
0.0267767422,
0.020794984,
0.0396538228,
-0.0402909443,
-0.0488893539,
0.017315533,
-0.0131000821,
0.0316496491,
-0.0363153517,
0.0377949663,
-0.0280364044,
0.0532723889,
0.0144942831,
-0.0206165239,
-0.0437472798,
-0.027571423,
-0.0726115331,
-0.0355338417,
0.0134913223,
0.0021768613,
-0.0097717317,
-0.0339987651,
0.0840193257,
0.0116499914,
0.0019810414,
0.0249192137,
0.0116444789,
-0.0062190304,
-0.0204147957,
-0.0089456709,
-0.005436305,
0.0239506215,
0.0210361797,
0.0218339078,
0.0158838704,
-0.019424133,
-0.0159903113,
-0.0517125279,
-0.016644001,
0.0110618519,
0.0387730934,
0.0561745837,
0.0479452163,
0.0492977388,
0.0192642715,
0.0396410003,
0.0259583201,
-0.0251442641,
-0.0116098933,
0.0012609117,
0.0584593825,
0.0332132466,
0.0262741446,
-0.013907454,
0.0323066302,
-0.0684578046,
-0.0752814785,
-0.0122831846,
0.0447591171,
0.0511903167,
0.0428649858,
0.0004675606,
0.0022280652,
-0.0119321235,
-0.0394167937,
-0.036467392,
-0.0312203653,
-0.0389664583,
0.0321690366,
0.0484352708,
-0.0208735727,
-0.0445994772,
0.0286410917,
-0.0408284031,
-0.0112160249,
0.0111022219,
-0.0089105424,
0.0421575196,
-0.0049543004,
0.0350940935,
-0.1177902594,
-0.0739723966,
-0.0043194108,
-0.0222063269,
-0.006589904,
0.0007029282,
0.0166900139,
0.0367374383,
-0.055108536,
-0.0061008306,
-0.0116196908,
0.0035961287,
0.0466791838,
0.074630402,
0.0535199903,
-0.0013683331,
0.0034593316,
-0.0092414171,
-0.0113970358,
-0.0034660446,
-0.0004183658,
0.0068269079,
0.0312002804,
0.0577195249,
-0.0361047685,
0.0117776683,
-0.0665093884,
-0.0147801377,
0.0301250145,
-0.0514437072,
-0.0265769325,
0.0257702153,
2.769e-7,
0.0143022826,
0.0193637945,
-0.0036904397,
-0.0148789575,
0.0207304899,
-0.0172082726,
-0.0324227735,
0.0053200033,
0.0232050549,
0.0014848538,
0.0272104628,
0.0325131491,
0.0006982032,
0.0169312507,
-0.1068032756,
-0.0148112262,
-0.0460512936,
0.0726326779,
-0.0538777746,
-0.0624552853,
0.0007956596,
0.1414985508,
0.0266755316,
-0.033921212,
0.0019790628,
-0.036875505,
0.0268925782,
0.0168647487,
0.0041352711,
0.0519222282,
0.0498584732,
0.0519201681,
-0.0380457304,
0.001190746,
0.0065748245,
0.0660947859,
-0.0061860951,
0.0733549967,
-0.0033118746,
-0.0203429423,
0.0551322214,
0.0144822821,
-0.0221396014,
-0.0260477252,
0.0673963726,
-0.051095318,
0.0028047222,
-0.0242161844,
-0.011568578,
-0.0158725791,
0.0017647985,
-0.0338753536,
-0.0039170384,
0.0451235473,
0.0220888238,
-0.0157308429,
-0.0219263863,
-0.0853453279,
0.0004244249,
-0.0214173123,
-0.066355817,
-0.0568509027,
-0.0578151606,
-0.0062840264,
0.0226663258,
-0.0090988735,
0.0098981429,
2.451796067e-34,
0.0471222959,
-0.0297471993,
0.0171114169,
0.0493873656,
-0.019998705,
-0.0339172222,
-0.0493127331,
0.0118743954,
-0.0064828023,
-0.0948727056,
-0.0417092517
] |
Subsets and Splits