id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18312v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18312v1 | AI-native Memory: A Pathway from LLMs Towards AGI | 2024-06-26T12:51:37 | 2024-06-26T12:51:37 | Jingbo Shang, Zai Zheng, Xiang Ying, Felix Tao, Mindverse Team | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated the world with the sparks of
artificial general intelligence (AGI). One opinion, especially from some
startups working on LLMs, argues that an LLM with nearly unlimited context
length can realize AGI. However, they might be too optimistic about the
long-context capability of (existing) LLMs -- (1) Recent literature has shown
that their effective context length is significantly smaller than their claimed
context length; and (2) Our reasoning-in-a-haystack experiments further
demonstrate that simultaneously finding the relevant information from a long
context and conducting (simple) reasoning is nearly impossible. In this paper,
we envision a pathway from LLMs to AGI through the integration of
\emph{memory}. We believe that AGI should be a system where LLMs serve as core
processors. In addition to raw data, the memory in this system would store a
large number of important conclusions derived from reasoning processes.
Compared with retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) that merely processing raw
data, this approach not only connects semantically related information closer,
but also simplifies complex inferences at the time of querying. As an
intermediate stage, the memory will likely be in the form of natural language
descriptions, which can be directly consumed by users too. Ultimately, every
agent/person should have its own large personal model, a deep neural network
model (thus \emph{AI-native}) that parameterizes and compresses all types of
memory, even the ones cannot be described by natural languages. Finally, we
discuss the significant potential of AI-native memory as the transformative
infrastructure for (proactive) engagement, personalization, distribution, and
social in the AGI era, as well as the incurred privacy and security challenges
with preliminary solutions. | [
0.0641117096,
0.0580641367,
-0.0434283689,
0.0353889763,
-0.0346714221,
-0.0207085088,
0.0206467416,
-0.0275378674,
0.0534949303,
-0.0236995257,
-0.0092641069,
-0.0440726057,
-0.0144283017,
0.0521501638,
-0.0002601142,
-0.0130856,
0.03656983,
-0.0146437343,
0.0346792825,
-0.0017061341,
-0.0176900197,
0.018166624,
0.0306717195,
0.0311543178,
-0.0303507429,
0.0007230549,
-0.035668321,
-0.0109077087,
0.003849139,
-0.0301492754,
-0.0321443304,
-0.0025737262,
0.0457127877,
0.0325032547,
0.0000023685,
-0.0813021734,
0.0030223995,
-0.0019789592,
-0.0508481562,
-0.0159600042,
0.0120483842,
0.0531761199,
0.0057960334,
-0.0119539993,
-0.0603862442,
-0.0149773853,
0.0376050361,
0.0133817261,
0.0166366734,
0.0466303155,
-0.015321875,
-0.0787590593,
0.0267626531,
-0.024018079,
0.0495152734,
-0.072133705,
0.0128813861,
-0.0551332384,
0.0188581273,
0.0015295062,
0.0050878827,
0.0372743495,
0.0514788963,
0.0076353638,
0.018208934,
0.015943259,
-0.0133721568,
-0.018504981,
-0.0089951809,
0.043583937,
0.0466783904,
-0.0130118579,
0.0180558525,
0.0280374829,
0.0253849234,
0.0075168163,
-0.021966964,
0.0764292777,
-0.0451057777,
0.0050436943,
0.0224981904,
0.0101529602,
0.0365871005,
0.0326884352,
-0.0544601977,
0.0742662773,
-0.0207518637,
-0.0236692913,
0.0063173375,
-0.0120621575,
0.0123048658,
-0.045378577,
0.0306069329,
0.0686869994,
-0.0053043142,
0.0302097593,
-0.0463014692,
-0.0040588989,
0.0087801469,
-0.0447674729,
0.005860799,
0.0261398815,
-0.0146641182,
0.0453122891,
-0.000755273,
0.0305930898,
-0.0351805054,
0.0000520976,
-0.0259332415,
-0.0506874956,
-0.0438615195,
-0.0228284802,
-0.0316977128,
0.0985481218,
-0.0254337601,
-0.0234201066,
-0.0376705304,
0.0584261492,
-0.0231771879,
0.0236543976,
-0.0483691916,
0.0531346798,
-0.0304387081,
-0.0052793478,
-0.067636475,
-0.0337599292,
-0.080025956,
0.0013248617,
0.0338089801,
-0.0667265803,
0.0171876326,
-0.001170387,
0.0275350325,
-0.0050179502,
0.0092746671,
0.0766501203,
0.0229496732,
-0.040048901,
-0.0835019648,
-0.070622839,
0.0171020404,
-0.074346222,
0.00379838,
-0.0485274792,
0.0353846513,
0.0068902965,
-0.0279594287,
-0.0716051832,
-0.0093009872,
0.0304062981,
-0.0420771837,
0.0327042863,
0.0139572099,
-0.0005166893,
0.0602062084,
0.0433039181,
0.0501228906,
0.0121716531,
0.0353671983,
0.0557856858,
0.051492393,
0.0198855083,
0.022732228,
-0.0152717866,
0.0213842578,
-0.0325807184,
-0.0127873141,
0.0108189071,
-0.0404463261,
-0.0041286098,
-0.0192653332,
0.0648584813,
0.0018385904,
-0.0188923944,
0.0481692776,
0.1205351204,
-0.012953178,
0.0391781814,
0.0480351411,
0.0004535943,
0.0017695709,
-0.0162784047,
-0.038893126,
0.0285214186,
-0.0589337684,
-0.0107092131,
0.0410960503,
0.0305866543,
-0.0432227924,
-0.0351092964,
0.0186122786,
-0.0346502885,
0.045863606,
0.0498153232,
0.0207831543,
0.0074744076,
0.0122078294,
-0.0125073595,
-0.004145911,
-0.047461275,
0.0132128401,
-0.0783535019,
0.0421369784,
0.0956930593,
0.033096429,
-0.0170640349,
0.0009931825,
0.0321344733,
-0.0286133643,
0.0314169861,
0.0235896129,
0.0070922519,
0.0128314365,
-0.0283207763,
-0.0000247208,
-0.0312928259,
0.0138008557,
0.0385210626,
0.0161854085,
0.026811583,
0.02669519,
0.0111058829,
0.0104482369,
-0.0154327666,
-0.0318152905,
-0.0259596687,
-0.0038237001,
0.0235150438,
0.0227256194,
0.0409072489,
0.0159669779,
0.0086920923,
0.0332180187,
-0.0209805351,
-0.0351352766,
-0.0018176875,
-0.0477313325,
0.0641432479,
-0.0024200198,
-0.0037551082,
0.0342728272,
-0.0183357559,
-0.0019714308,
-0.0570226014,
0.036626976,
-0.038304735,
0.0570017509,
-0.0442591831,
0.0035666751,
-0.0085296258,
0.0154901473,
-0.014686414,
0.0829658359,
-0.0111568356,
-0.0643283874,
-0.0043145274,
0.0379964486,
0.0272487588,
-0.0645878911,
-0.0221979357,
0.0075914054,
-0.0029563485,
0.0157335084,
0.0542680435,
-0.019726472,
-0.0398119502,
0.0169711336,
-0.0917288363,
0.0189303216,
-0.0027993205,
-0.0090012075,
-0.0171835516,
0.0458378308,
0.0170413051,
-0.0115989083,
-0.0651669279,
0.0353084542,
0.0148168299,
0.0258302595,
0.0302935429,
0.0498640165,
-0.0020902532,
-0.0294163823,
0.0002606711,
-0.010222856,
0.0274398029,
0.0217134356,
-0.0257595405,
-0.0208562519,
0.0098873628,
-0.0665372685,
0.0355703905,
-0.0180258732,
-0.0087488536,
0.0201859009,
-0.0399834029,
0.0132874921,
0.1092118472,
0.0046247845,
0.0468139276,
-0.0022191782,
-0.0126228658,
-0.0412287265,
0.0110331466,
-0.0131838527,
-0.0251405295,
-0.0243055448,
0.0095147416,
0.0199838411,
0.0521309003,
0.0162938312,
-0.0058836625,
-0.0531318933,
0.0514884889,
0.0108284298,
-0.040255446,
-0.0256477688,
-0.0106255589,
-0.0007293221,
0.0596322864,
-0.0067944396,
-0.0608691163,
0.1023470759,
0.0193192139,
0.0346514769,
-0.001926687,
-0.0427747704,
-0.0350229964,
0.1002544239,
-0.0119078327,
0.0404348075,
-0.0130090062,
-0.0018783818,
-0.0249319356,
-0.0071612084,
-0.0233525932,
-0.0402760878,
0.0266504884,
-0.0563878454,
0.0017940383,
0.0326393731,
-0.0525883399,
-0.0528700352,
-0.0033372878,
-0.0446855202,
-0.0110630868,
-0.0044828737,
-0.0395402573,
-0.0362515673,
-0.032281708,
0.0383767523,
0.0362548716,
0.0013181017,
-0.0199503396,
-0.0086213574,
-0.023017304,
0.0246947743,
-0.0034937551,
-0.0125096096,
0.0155431172,
0.0235278197,
0.0728850886,
0.0322081745,
-0.0217492878,
0.0175351538,
-0.006561493,
0.014924217,
-0.0117399311,
-0.0582510978,
0.0455290005,
0.0214234013,
-0.0666065961,
-0.0482073128,
0.0836002231,
0.0281389542,
-0.053738717,
-0.0060686655,
-0.0059605865,
0.0001311144,
0.0122733777,
0.0350412242,
-0.0790769979,
-0.0070911227,
0.0055900062,
0.0031231155,
-0.037346147,
-0.0388167687,
-0.0281994361,
-0.117112495,
-0.006494273,
0.0036731702,
-0.0309588388,
-0.010239982,
-0.0169790499,
-0.034581989,
0.0461240336,
-0.0051222704,
-0.0010420198,
0.0127486577,
-0.0315675102,
-0.0441867113,
-0.0089556621,
-0.0056358804,
0.0282657761,
-0.0453718156,
0.0365632027,
0.0595405139,
0.03886896,
0.0237583928,
-0.0418929867,
0.016225569,
0.0101413243,
0.0473692939,
-0.0025180504,
0.0480518788,
-0.0188740995,
0.0209719669,
-0.0203899946,
0.0409165956,
-0.0317387581,
-0.0161269158,
0.0209748559,
0.054968901,
-0.0553318076,
-0.000890185,
-0.0360652134,
-0.0196470562,
-0.0052977367,
0.0697159618,
-0.0186483711,
-0.0469797365,
-0.0398170501,
-0.0372822843,
0.0065024053,
-0.0255251396,
-0.0155647788,
0.0288070906,
0.0066261818,
-0.0258607268,
-0.0407396182,
-0.0502392985,
-0.0017934118,
0.0305485129,
0.0251023713,
-0.0221473128,
0.0137516316,
0.0004877488,
-0.0595484227,
-0.0028820385,
-0.0772935972,
-0.0221810564,
-0.0275602136,
-0.0089470139,
0.0328217968,
-0.0495889001,
0.0140311392,
0.0260727461,
-0.0388369896,
-0.0492598005,
0.0094138011,
0.0548666902,
0.0382107645,
0.0476100408,
-0.0045580794,
-0.0617204607,
0.0509805866,
0.0079122633,
-0.0423372686,
0.0276176147,
0.0068159336,
0.0378413834,
0.0090148104,
0.0257693827,
-0.0675720945,
0.0098244725,
0.0110759903,
-0.0202927664,
-0.009207652,
-0.0380212627,
0.0167907625,
0.0285587497,
-0.0033376047,
0.0166286211,
0.0177678671,
-0.0035096381,
0.0200855657,
-0.0354090668,
0.0088150818,
-0.0142426956,
-0.0002311618,
0.0201491639,
0.0168527681,
0.0301829297,
-0.0196331348,
0.022182649,
0.0102847079,
-0.0190590862,
-0.0551451221,
0.0137833888,
0.0180083793,
-0.0049418928,
0.0185999852,
-0.0351283364,
0.0351301543,
-0.0058890954,
0.0701884106,
-0.0440424941,
0.0674849674,
-0.0042931885,
-0.0161514897,
-0.02456389,
0.0388979539,
-0.068583414,
-0.0839750692,
0.0406030715,
0.0511370152,
0.0217337459,
0.0167614911,
-0.0410334542,
-0.0453587733,
0.0143499104,
-0.0123685049,
0.0074322619,
0.032527145,
-0.080329068,
-0.0500029549,
0.0341203623,
-0.0317607522,
0.0271419045,
0.0499606691,
-0.0169135742,
0.0405495465,
-0.0263948385,
-0.0157771017,
-0.0449883863,
-0.0213261358,
-0.0076349485,
0.0659543052,
-0.0006586695,
-0.0151572349,
-0.069631055,
-0.0504354984,
0.0183322057,
0.0055073132,
0.0057041845,
-0.0276996139,
0.0489611663,
0.0524147302,
-0.0032409066,
-0.041085586,
-0.0249957964,
0.0231666565,
-0.0897360817,
0.004645586,
-0.0079310667,
-6.640508647e-33,
-0.0144629236,
-0.0359515101,
0.0245263726,
-0.0202920679,
-0.0041169431,
-0.0218163002,
-0.0256848484,
-0.0101963952,
-0.0278745312,
-0.0273377299,
-0.0313894004,
0.0266268458,
0.0026001572,
0.0305131488,
-0.0152930319,
-0.0254275985,
0.038369678,
0.0283873398,
0.0056369887,
0.058915481,
0.0782586932,
0.0159813911,
-0.0020837772,
-0.0944846943,
0.0267511383,
-0.0018212033,
0.0044057835,
0.0276269726,
-0.0363934673,
0.0495130718,
-0.0229590908,
0.0514143743,
0.0179924686,
0.0092835845,
0.0192975383,
0.0605022348,
-0.080293864,
-0.0455374382,
0.0051760287,
-0.0247694999,
-0.0287857931,
-0.0705988184,
0.023028098,
-0.0246869978,
-0.0059582172,
0.0278489739,
0.0360797122,
-0.0231541693,
-0.0078188535,
-0.0393411554,
-0.0336677916,
-0.0183730815,
-0.0013125418,
0.022521995,
-0.0190478191,
0.0034786998,
-0.0085131973,
0.0245467275,
-0.0418753624,
0.0280929096,
-0.0348694809,
-0.0298042782,
0.0432166755,
0.005227258,
0.0363334268,
0.0462450907,
0.0561994575,
0.0376488231,
-0.0631472617,
-0.0246471018,
0.00719355,
0.0353029482,
-0.018607812,
0.0377538763,
0.0286121033,
-0.0299262647,
-0.0542856604,
0.0161915645,
0.0321403965,
0.0374685526,
0.046723593,
0.0023223625,
-0.0780986771,
-0.0286473557,
-0.0253653731,
0.0099576693,
-0.045871906,
-0.0245597903,
0.0369972251,
0.005093812,
-0.0407659635,
-0.0055321124,
0.0156197557,
-0.0491734222,
0.0393882915,
0.0352725834,
0.0216874722,
-0.0220907256,
-0.0095945494,
0.0191269256,
-0.0172017533,
-0.02938243,
-0.027240634,
-0.0046980651,
0.0144085316,
0.0382939093,
0.0077593196,
0.0409289747,
-0.0198413227,
-0.0077556684,
-0.0293901395,
0.018438153,
0.0014679064,
-0.0365359075,
0.0320710391,
0.0371758193,
-0.0034422199,
0.065853402,
0.0398868918,
0.0289846957,
-0.0403830558,
-0.0103258956,
-0.0073918728,
-0.0129067656,
-0.009565372,
-0.0008435158,
-0.050236892,
0.0255846996,
0.049074363,
-0.0590689108,
0.0041468521,
-0.0017033318,
3.17e-7,
-0.0341869332,
-0.0055999565,
0.0298298877,
-0.0167308841,
0.0041553127,
0.0244594235,
0.0554982871,
0.0331754461,
-0.0002649512,
-0.0261256564,
-0.0051597618,
0.0696374029,
0.0134323724,
0.0109731741,
-0.0689481348,
0.0247614291,
-0.019526409,
-0.0018204894,
-0.0675641745,
0.0484362207,
0.0378419012,
0.082420066,
0.0550197475,
-0.0181590114,
0.0098606423,
-0.0795690939,
0.0574872755,
-0.025213575,
0.0123175532,
-0.0002851691,
0.001260934,
0.0852427632,
-0.0306866504,
-0.0074262009,
0.0122629264,
0.0116908569,
-0.0531626493,
0.0613761395,
-0.0053638397,
-0.0456508622,
-0.0220209267,
-0.0510707758,
-0.0043467218,
-0.0197203271,
0.0681847706,
-0.0504101068,
-0.0525154248,
0.005268801,
0.0446397439,
-0.0238491632,
-0.0315225348,
0.0006420747,
0.0067096348,
-0.0258427225,
-0.0063843923,
-0.0112572387,
0.0296910349,
-0.1129518375,
0.0044378606,
0.0076238178,
-0.0245624147,
-0.0262802485,
-0.0421914868,
0.0172567964,
0.0380698666,
-0.0417359136,
0.0298971385,
2.79321335e-34,
0.0086174067,
0.0116837732,
0.0010981176,
0.014200815,
0.0540433824,
0.0049521667,
-0.0247392524,
0.0314346254,
0.0673209876,
-0.0685736164,
-0.031867601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18305v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18305v1 | S3: A Simple Strong Sample-effective Multimodal Dialog System | 2024-06-26T12:45:43 | 2024-06-26T12:45:43 | Elisei Rykov, Egor Malkershin, Alexander Panchenko | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we present a conceptually simple yet powerful baseline for the
multimodal dialog task, an S3 model, that achieves near state-of-the-art
results on two compelling leaderboards: MMMU and AI Journey Contest 2023. The
system is based on a pre-trained large language model, pre-trained modality
encoders for image and audio, and a trainable modality projector. The proposed
effective data mixture for training such an architecture demonstrates that a
multimodal model based on a strong language model and trained on a small amount
of multimodal data can perform efficiently in the task of multimodal dialog. | [
0.0514015742,
0.0923671797,
-0.0128529202,
0.0437224098,
-0.0014756542,
0.0008982687,
0.0408712737,
-0.029393224,
-0.0337364376,
-0.0893241614,
-0.0663861409,
-0.0138559993,
-0.036064323,
0.0852366537,
0.0502515584,
-0.0762522593,
0.0277221296,
-0.0640073493,
-0.0013914071,
0.0025539671,
0.0573257953,
0.010009205,
-0.0495383516,
0.0361227356,
-0.0583669208,
-0.0048455424,
-0.0461623557,
-0.0034835045,
-0.0244508125,
-0.0530950949,
-0.0116926329,
0.0416704416,
0.0689137578,
0.008164186,
0.0000017465,
-0.0254573971,
0.0240192078,
-0.0159954075,
-0.0198504906,
-0.0282195881,
0.0262911879,
0.0023806144,
0.0154178999,
0.0121532539,
-0.0217421073,
-0.0171581544,
0.0498909876,
0.0829560831,
0.0994793326,
0.0652486831,
-0.0346482508,
-0.0165420026,
0.0164917149,
-0.0165896397,
0.0301417802,
-0.0424654447,
-0.0257351212,
0.0248350985,
0.0146788601,
0.0253082551,
-0.0269653816,
0.0276943296,
0.0089552356,
-0.0336256921,
-0.0280359946,
0.0121872853,
-0.0011861742,
-0.0314113013,
-0.0511952005,
0.1252182871,
0.0256786011,
0.0479692742,
-0.0118974699,
0.0012862337,
-0.0042004804,
-0.0356383957,
-0.0609253198,
0.036349304,
0.0104172193,
-0.0162434764,
-0.0570874065,
0.0315988734,
-0.0010512556,
0.0151061192,
0.0116801374,
-0.0178408958,
0.0095427362,
-0.0040861131,
0.0074650096,
-0.0111641809,
-0.0038991224,
-0.0606287457,
0.0010912159,
-0.0036961674,
-0.0610789433,
-0.0036506322,
-0.0351316221,
-0.0079330951,
-0.0142734554,
-0.0203380771,
0.0070709721,
0.0212698784,
-0.0271446127,
0.0713465959,
0.0302386303,
0.0230925828,
-0.0090660369,
0.0268178359,
-0.0052376958,
-0.0373216718,
-0.0412410609,
0.0060704034,
-0.0436240584,
-0.0016880777,
-0.0660361946,
-0.0592779852,
0.0037137102,
0.0296106357,
-0.0146738328,
0.0075606718,
0.0186102353,
0.0308936313,
-0.038217932,
-0.009748986,
-0.0356538035,
0.0573174506,
-0.0303206928,
0.0500166975,
0.0088125309,
-0.0577082969,
0.0175327174,
0.0645606369,
0.0056771482,
-0.0175146349,
-0.0009093005,
0.0977584198,
-0.0648604408,
-0.0389765278,
-0.0024609591,
-0.0112161273,
-0.0404669568,
-0.0569283776,
0.0183569044,
-0.0215604156,
0.0587221794,
-0.010857909,
-0.0022607713,
0.0077072573,
0.0124231083,
-0.0200521648,
0.0254007839,
0.0724537298,
0.0172488224,
-0.0082189236,
0.0566626489,
0.0181914922,
-0.0403340347,
0.074600108,
0.0401107073,
0.035742417,
0.0392344594,
0.0046820389,
0.0171983279,
0.0450672023,
-0.0324645564,
0.00816694,
0.0154600861,
0.0032606698,
-0.0281046554,
0.0318536535,
0.036336422,
0.0758516341,
-0.0438791402,
-0.0304345116,
0.0720434263,
0.0200675316,
0.0027159259,
0.0058964635,
0.0109012406,
0.0120851146,
0.0044970592,
-0.0473116413,
-0.0268740728,
0.0485723205,
0.0136500914,
-0.0177618265,
0.0468913168,
0.031167496,
-0.0428213254,
-0.0101582296,
0.0503149442,
-0.028889617,
-0.013746921,
0.0052850614,
0.0366829187,
0.0007382504,
-0.06030697,
0.0355780572,
-0.0116119664,
-0.04701088,
-0.001054339,
0.0023076523,
0.0214244965,
0.025144659,
0.0115871495,
-0.0033612212,
-0.0117701674,
-0.0406156071,
0.0235357657,
0.0315306187,
0.0217196941,
-0.0313151032,
0.064192161,
-0.0797924623,
-0.0460496955,
-0.0156821012,
-0.0126309153,
0.0163062774,
-0.0366908982,
-0.0020475548,
0.0141096087,
-0.006194151,
0.0689820349,
0.0017921753,
0.0471423008,
0.0142586082,
-0.0157383271,
-0.001742996,
0.0652965233,
0.0081133014,
-0.0399388373,
-0.0165327061,
0.0098991906,
-0.0286480859,
0.020424135,
0.045911707,
-0.079927884,
-0.0465634465,
0.0219814833,
-0.0561941117,
-0.0008875333,
0.0078295795,
-0.0476032235,
-0.0436012857,
0.0194122847,
-0.0579415821,
-0.0106503107,
-0.0490252562,
-0.0016124848,
0.0270814262,
0.0126973325,
-0.0273367539,
0.0173138548,
-0.0045552962,
-0.0365781933,
0.0252151098,
0.0289146099,
0.0376614891,
-0.0433627516,
-0.0403388217,
0.0278714318,
-0.0057649296,
0.0303583406,
0.0062017883,
-0.0127118481,
-0.035637375,
-0.0400285199,
-0.132952854,
-0.031674657,
-0.0000604901,
-0.0276825242,
-0.0047078789,
0.0139305014,
-0.0031890247,
-0.0373163819,
-0.038095206,
0.0225906055,
0.0623694807,
0.0070864721,
0.012966793,
0.0392455384,
0.0146702016,
-0.0417311341,
0.0026263474,
0.0167435482,
0.051403679,
0.002988267,
-0.0070673632,
-0.0148349991,
-0.0155844167,
-0.0362591743,
0.0663151368,
-0.0171483979,
-0.0567365326,
0.0249609072,
-0.011815818,
0.0752394572,
0.0102928989,
0.0269119684,
0.018084215,
-0.0095631648,
-0.025662642,
-0.0340647176,
0.033461269,
0.0064016161,
0.0158071369,
-0.036940068,
0.0032204227,
0.013757214,
0.0282541141,
0.033715412,
0.0487572476,
-0.0276392978,
0.0171708521,
0.0357402302,
-0.082044825,
-0.0242102519,
-0.0065744095,
-0.0088234777,
0.0310137291,
-0.027769167,
-0.0170829855,
0.0239842497,
-0.0794105902,
-0.0354386903,
-0.0066459379,
0.002706344,
-0.0110022128,
0.0623084642,
-0.0182946958,
0.0356281362,
-0.0171555225,
-0.011932225,
-0.0501944497,
-0.0273849256,
0.0308125429,
-0.006011527,
0.0379642993,
-0.0289427973,
0.0133486576,
-0.0148856808,
-0.082970202,
-0.0236325376,
-0.0404138863,
-0.0318797156,
-0.0408352353,
-0.0085837869,
0.0029878372,
-0.0437447876,
0.0115837827,
0.0344176814,
0.0300149564,
0.0059049944,
-0.0037851934,
-0.024367895,
0.054507561,
0.053890463,
0.066140987,
-0.0445820652,
-0.0669924989,
0.0320293419,
0.0309195742,
0.0380707346,
0.0057864427,
-0.0602100044,
0.0249127522,
-0.0007875746,
0.0602498241,
0.0011119914,
0.0235148892,
0.0516025387,
-0.0291507654,
0.0087006651,
0.0727152079,
-0.0181158725,
-0.0339345224,
-0.0222223271,
0.0146999331,
0.0040799906,
0.0195814576,
0.0004202412,
-0.0794737637,
-0.0738023371,
-0.0123994332,
-0.0328144692,
0.0136113213,
0.0121086659,
0.0099598654,
-0.0626873076,
0.0412539206,
-0.0103939343,
-0.017526241,
-0.0375105441,
0.0062987572,
-0.011566096,
-0.0047587929,
0.0012310204,
-0.0133158909,
0.0201727878,
0.0054833079,
0.0101095103,
0.0412709042,
-0.0424965322,
0.015164719,
-0.0310377497,
0.0581324399,
0.0481288098,
0.0074739135,
-0.0175246801,
-0.0382402092,
0.0175104048,
0.0286030658,
-0.0074041253,
0.0129052922,
0.057821285,
-0.0387018248,
-0.0378468446,
-0.0299632661,
0.0039309873,
0.0064710947,
-0.0197750404,
0.0062809489,
0.0581727177,
-0.037584547,
0.0234794673,
-0.0247682463,
0.0248010401,
0.0427888073,
0.0472580567,
0.0064349235,
-0.0547073111,
-0.023683751,
-0.0136041967,
0.0155607415,
-0.0239037108,
0.0071568023,
0.0109471967,
0.0351539515,
0.0338294469,
-0.059933152,
-0.0205397848,
0.0123441769,
0.0550006405,
-0.0091156764,
-0.0255324189,
-0.0178089663,
0.0334652588,
-0.0188828334,
0.0418224335,
-0.0054860152,
0.0090144798,
-0.0642977059,
0.0025191118,
0.0512578674,
-0.0195150618,
-0.0177801251,
0.0301276818,
-0.0521996878,
-0.0211023055,
-0.0507710092,
0.0907416269,
0.0129421223,
0.0324778594,
0.0277934801,
-0.0426785722,
0.0228133537,
-0.0123100271,
-0.0277177189,
-0.0092190737,
0.0483781584,
0.0156383123,
-0.01594075,
0.0091417721,
-0.0474003479,
0.0106074046,
-0.0114534153,
0.0260985382,
-0.0085997954,
-0.0568879135,
-0.0219899938,
-0.0236840751,
0.0172406286,
-0.005451553,
0.0035220669,
-0.0391644835,
0.0193002187,
0.00857173,
-0.0090666534,
-0.0870158151,
0.0215943772,
0.0038000585,
0.0131771928,
0.0289197918,
-0.0005585052,
0.0014830725,
0.0419779122,
-0.0141283143,
0.038231384,
0.0559158027,
-0.0249026977,
-0.0206011869,
0.0086500235,
0.0010745059,
0.0347135812,
0.0018201976,
0.0098150978,
-0.0144954231,
0.134813264,
0.0069399625,
-0.0481240265,
0.0081669576,
0.0534135848,
-0.0128026837,
-0.0029143204,
-0.0261103194,
0.0456288531,
0.0228739511,
0.0274124984,
0.0161687881,
0.005835962,
0.00976755,
-0.0146473534,
0.0776871592,
-0.0126403812,
-0.0222185142,
0.0453971848,
0.0203569308,
0.0041955072,
0.0221190806,
0.046601776,
-0.0247075073,
0.0288319904,
-0.0052212826,
0.0181566514,
-0.0686851963,
-0.0231601521,
0.0401020981,
0.0429101698,
-0.0074094483,
0.029834697,
0.0084646735,
-0.0361788198,
-0.0195810013,
0.011551518,
-0.0146139665,
0.0181277636,
0.0727966204,
0.0706510842,
0.0038965216,
-0.0148830703,
-0.0149458973,
-0.0118659781,
0.0170820393,
0.0001132464,
-0.0166309401,
-5.57196665e-33,
-0.0127363605,
-0.0143616395,
0.0349584855,
-0.0493784845,
-0.0223055948,
-0.0120267579,
-0.0418228544,
0.0130869439,
-0.0054224194,
-0.004998778,
0.0198730174,
-0.0068315081,
-0.0023427026,
0.0729202405,
-0.0137995081,
0.0181874204,
0.0461933762,
-0.0127974134,
-0.0328929722,
0.0216412321,
0.0373770818,
0.003437896,
0.02933635,
-0.0826886147,
-0.0268481374,
0.0307092126,
-0.0506423488,
0.0130791971,
0.0195628218,
0.0754337907,
-0.0236978699,
0.0365781374,
0.0050314865,
-0.0334012136,
-0.0131393764,
0.0315151438,
-0.0441263057,
-0.0211331528,
0.0222499333,
0.0297323968,
-0.0537693799,
0.0215589907,
0.0048980941,
-0.0487531312,
0.034380421,
-0.0008727992,
0.0216461457,
0.0140173938,
0.0094357319,
0.0006701972,
-0.0530281067,
0.0232190378,
-0.0380111411,
-0.0269545522,
0.0206168573,
0.051417727,
0.0395941213,
-0.0307827834,
-0.010506927,
0.0365520343,
-0.0174718704,
-0.0095314104,
0.0471129827,
0.0301263463,
-0.0124184191,
0.0768577009,
0.0355291516,
-0.0343180671,
-0.0161744524,
-0.0132393567,
-0.0056293942,
0.0630194992,
0.0280103311,
0.0932218656,
-0.0294213947,
0.0111142686,
-0.0307183396,
0.0182272606,
0.0216258075,
0.0252467114,
0.0096708555,
0.0251789819,
-0.0064842035,
0.006734991,
-0.0586668067,
-0.0176502522,
-0.0213631745,
-0.0477311946,
0.0644248277,
0.0339828804,
0.0143781789,
0.0107595352,
0.0990894362,
-0.0177010838,
-0.0217341352,
0.0007562558,
-0.0056728963,
0.0457631275,
-0.0113198953,
-0.0125015937,
-0.0303257238,
-0.0252115168,
0.0852202401,
-0.0094126938,
0.0298120826,
0.0064794659,
-0.0068385531,
0.0374388136,
-0.0375104137,
-0.0162477475,
-0.0223855153,
0.009761869,
-0.0163553413,
0.0538220182,
0.0072199046,
-0.0139928991,
-0.0831456706,
0.0352779292,
-0.055962462,
0.0046196962,
-0.0374694504,
-0.0981409326,
-0.0172980558,
0.0114519624,
-0.0527874269,
0.0071020997,
-0.0482017063,
-0.0892468914,
0.0384519808,
-0.0588230342,
0.0013540472,
0.0147121083,
2.446e-7,
-0.0197997931,
0.0170675814,
0.0028606795,
-0.0008631081,
0.0294010397,
0.0632493198,
-0.0226210672,
0.0190074518,
-0.0064115259,
-0.040495906,
0.0029903206,
0.0307370592,
0.0102236457,
0.0172332041,
-0.038401138,
-0.0170646366,
-0.0466773026,
-0.0163666401,
-0.0464852974,
0.0278403871,
0.076479882,
0.1483282745,
-0.0094371596,
-0.0150525579,
0.0021249119,
-0.0449261963,
0.0730368569,
-0.0214327332,
-0.0126771796,
-0.0068869148,
0.0412163287,
-0.0178108159,
-0.0214300938,
0.0112707326,
0.0075282664,
-0.0031108807,
0.0331818536,
0.0465027355,
-0.0086307293,
-0.0515322722,
-0.0054195183,
0.048950851,
-0.0290142503,
-0.008658479,
0.0575146526,
-0.0203684494,
-0.0537128747,
-0.0636054873,
-0.0210817456,
-0.0243802741,
-0.0078014634,
-0.0234931968,
-0.0419881307,
0.0067372364,
0.0227816403,
-0.0207534973,
-0.0107601639,
-0.0884349868,
0.0080962628,
-0.0348876975,
-0.0424065292,
-0.0343972854,
-0.0424902812,
-0.0537507236,
0.0458746143,
-0.0364497676,
-0.0155970436,
1.636314769e-34,
0.0268331952,
-0.0145175429,
0.0240225419,
0.0101804473,
0.0519500524,
0.0008475547,
0.0112611558,
-0.0263949595,
0.0041910708,
-0.0683220476,
-0.032355763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18301v1 | MSR-86K: An Evolving, Multilingual Corpus with 86,300 Hours of Transcribed Audio for Speech Recognition Research | 2024-06-26T12:35:12 | 2024-06-26T12:35:12 | Song Li, Yongbin You, Xuezhi Wang, Zhengkun Tian, Ke Ding, Guanglu Wan | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Recently, multilingual artificial intelligence assistants, exemplified by
ChatGPT, have gained immense popularity. As a crucial gateway to human-computer
interaction, multilingual automatic speech recognition (ASR) has also garnered
significant attention, as evidenced by systems like Whisper. However, the
proprietary nature of the training data has impeded researchers' efforts to
study multilingual ASR. This paper introduces MSR-86K, an evolving, large-scale
multilingual corpus for speech recognition research. The corpus is derived from
publicly accessible videos on YouTube, comprising 15 languages and a total of
86,300 hours of transcribed ASR data. We also introduce how to use the MSR-86K
corpus and other open-source corpora to train a robust multilingual ASR model
that is competitive with Whisper. MSR-86K will be publicly released on
HuggingFace, and we believe that such a large corpus will pave new avenues for
research in multilingual ASR. | [
-0.0256809704,
0.0503705665,
-0.0106097069,
0.0501827449,
-0.031933099,
0.0086255958,
0.025403332,
-0.0128060086,
0.0029331071,
0.0122096641,
-0.0885717645,
-0.0391371772,
0.0248463191,
0.0104136216,
0.0334812365,
-0.0665962771,
0.0273681246,
-0.0878105387,
0.0163261462,
-0.0248504374,
0.0188638959,
0.0320701897,
-0.0496385619,
0.0344165675,
-0.0230100267,
0.013742811,
0.013716802,
-0.0103786215,
0.0323029943,
-0.0008771546,
-0.0368678533,
0.0188605469,
0.0231347568,
0.0413728431,
0.0000018314,
-0.0308051351,
-0.0008887512,
0.0145889455,
-0.0331566446,
-0.0100002028,
-0.0017735705,
-0.0169331636,
-0.0169688333,
0.0557362624,
-0.022945784,
-0.0148381423,
0.0372600332,
-0.0272503272,
0.0232020654,
0.0429617241,
-0.0189726967,
-0.0454194844,
0.0323850363,
-0.0139600094,
-0.0083018243,
-0.0447823294,
-0.0279016234,
-0.0282179993,
-0.0036093257,
-0.0226827096,
-0.0296612103,
0.062434338,
0.0054666218,
-0.0153102027,
-0.0420503542,
-0.0033305332,
-0.0612285733,
-0.0802634656,
-0.0072793718,
0.0581252426,
-0.0238572899,
-0.0017561807,
0.041535072,
0.0207642633,
-0.0528666154,
-0.0638720319,
-0.0256118979,
0.0291301757,
-0.0066092182,
-0.0122516304,
0.0046400498,
0.0155243184,
0.0255114771,
-0.0289336648,
0.0414613746,
-0.0076833661,
0.0256297458,
-0.0353825614,
0.0385877565,
-0.0217275303,
0.024354307,
0.0026795343,
0.067839779,
-0.0057814843,
-0.0157027058,
0.011490277,
-0.0147806639,
-0.025222322,
0.0145661738,
-0.0655566081,
0.0155772287,
0.072201632,
-0.0558838099,
0.0335018858,
-0.0075762016,
0.0523484461,
-0.0078937057,
-0.0127861751,
-0.0204752292,
-0.034335237,
-0.0298934579,
0.0131593961,
-0.0304504242,
-0.0147884507,
-0.031291917,
-0.0384041592,
-0.0230563898,
0.0137448227,
-0.0011892557,
0.0140591618,
0.001210736,
-0.0378220379,
-0.0187818054,
-0.0052688532,
0.0473367572,
0.0220721811,
-0.0033943835,
0.0351831764,
-0.0207275134,
-0.087593317,
-0.0114397714,
0.0351133905,
0.0263361279,
-0.014075527,
0.0246426687,
0.0555456057,
-0.0335245132,
-0.0347852334,
-0.0161817688,
0.0163182411,
-0.0209618472,
-0.0407694094,
0.0063322824,
-0.0420306139,
0.0964976177,
0.0130318217,
0.0098923082,
-0.014792406,
0.000757707,
-0.0178158134,
0.0082060816,
0.0699913129,
0.0121143479,
0.0333405063,
0.0385445282,
-0.0151152797,
-0.0167660695,
0.0622541122,
0.0569759496,
-0.0268629715,
0.0614918396,
-0.0240115877,
-0.0002973578,
0.0895910338,
-0.0423378125,
0.0249888655,
0.0215926636,
-0.0236672852,
0.0113562057,
0.0116513297,
0.0184403993,
0.0600799918,
-0.0089852335,
-0.0575439595,
0.0283036679,
0.0574804842,
-0.0104821147,
0.0274612904,
0.069336161,
0.0147764022,
0.0063379789,
-0.0039404957,
0.0324716419,
0.0123123163,
0.0149420677,
0.027230233,
0.0352596417,
0.0621193387,
-0.0559018813,
0.0158555824,
-0.0255500935,
-0.0453757681,
0.0007413811,
0.0523478724,
0.053407751,
-0.0103779817,
-0.0298133381,
0.0310316011,
0.0295691341,
-0.0562451594,
0.0307152197,
-0.0478251949,
-0.0030124658,
0.0448199064,
-0.0035704072,
-0.0277028196,
-0.0391733237,
-0.0352288894,
-0.0142993405,
0.0524500087,
0.0193713587,
-0.0253631342,
0.079379864,
-0.0855711997,
0.0049747257,
0.037599355,
-0.0105578611,
0.0808567107,
-0.0320132822,
0.0455837585,
0.0048836111,
-0.0198834091,
0.016870603,
-0.0190609209,
-0.0539599769,
0.0115988581,
0.017503975,
0.0102130668,
0.0794512704,
0.0554510206,
-0.0449438244,
-0.0264711287,
0.0334648453,
-0.0276810657,
0.034075208,
0.0783106238,
-0.0353525318,
-0.0091566369,
0.0551303551,
-0.0293665472,
0.0030247651,
0.0329863913,
0.0158666577,
-0.0671050549,
0.0671183988,
-0.0033818926,
0.0481669642,
-0.05532033,
0.0529839732,
0.0294596795,
0.0343106799,
0.0542361438,
-0.0357806943,
0.0234744977,
-0.0091950214,
0.0048282915,
-0.0302852597,
0.0530094281,
-0.0828238651,
-0.0325583555,
0.0523699597,
-0.0302486084,
0.0108516384,
0.0325807706,
0.002996335,
-0.0088843293,
-0.0157450344,
-0.0770761669,
-0.0187326409,
-0.0368222222,
0.0399973951,
-0.0457847528,
0.0346176177,
-0.0239677113,
-0.0445707999,
-0.0123958178,
-0.0161413141,
0.0152518461,
0.018322615,
-0.055393368,
-0.01676994,
-0.002081434,
-0.0224142149,
-0.0230349787,
0.0239510015,
-0.011333527,
-0.0229203757,
-0.0565382987,
-0.0463148132,
-0.0173530485,
-0.0035443339,
0.0279715601,
-0.0246622786,
-0.0422414541,
-0.008437641,
0.0247966424,
0.0366101079,
0.0238047875,
-0.0324498378,
0.0031999857,
0.0128124878,
0.0034109836,
-0.0358843803,
0.0122708417,
0.0329803601,
-0.0145236747,
-0.0230047815,
0.0161910318,
-0.0257123411,
0.0108894641,
0.0182753783,
0.0315221399,
-0.049398832,
-0.0662740096,
-0.0324184187,
-0.0354590714,
-0.0061331415,
-0.0092048794,
-0.0467155725,
0.0284994673,
0.017741397,
-0.0046742936,
0.0410711579,
-0.0754235163,
-0.0555116199,
-0.037384484,
-0.0398181304,
-0.039436955,
0.024946209,
-0.031031901,
0.0219522752,
-0.0257438123,
-0.0527891107,
-0.0089406027,
0.0212180726,
0.0203475058,
-0.0230445713,
0.0161771215,
-0.0497009307,
0.0002244812,
-0.0091871126,
-0.0705123544,
0.0039296458,
0.0163000189,
-0.0338351876,
0.0226338245,
0.0138711799,
-0.0164482072,
-0.044979807,
0.0290336907,
0.0371523164,
0.06128015,
0.0160415787,
0.0598591566,
-0.0105121406,
0.0335417986,
0.0160375386,
-0.0100911204,
-0.0404961966,
-0.0397708751,
0.0436941832,
-0.0172755253,
0.0657810792,
-0.0219443794,
-0.0248771422,
0.0007166985,
0.0668275431,
0.0105263926,
-0.014724087,
-0.0214555543,
0.0405828767,
-0.0028326469,
0.0357319638,
0.0884969607,
-0.0121084237,
-0.0540127903,
-0.0245577786,
-0.0189912878,
0.001493493,
0.0150740827,
0.0114692664,
-0.0888561308,
-0.0061666789,
0.0507732444,
0.0142764188,
0.0411800295,
0.0233047791,
-0.0138931032,
-0.0835212767,
0.0132398456,
0.0074047404,
-0.0534050912,
-0.0352013819,
-0.0551381148,
-0.0370969102,
-0.068560414,
0.0348443836,
-0.0302450843,
0.0101124849,
-0.0330030955,
0.0511750579,
-0.0444145314,
-0.0700554252,
0.0298788808,
-0.0404828452,
0.0807233155,
0.029407518,
0.0437513404,
-0.0454461351,
-0.0450079292,
0.0070262263,
-0.0051581627,
0.0006345423,
-0.0159865227,
0.0013766724,
0.0153870182,
-0.0382163972,
0.03545269,
0.0167252105,
-0.0122516062,
0.0112267733,
0.0386451036,
0.0633418486,
-0.016561063,
0.00311544,
0.0305291452,
-0.0105777103,
0.0228415802,
0.0449945554,
-0.0111752003,
-0.0368002579,
0.039043542,
0.0184931289,
0.0037324156,
-0.0140034417,
0.0122662084,
-0.0085939663,
-0.0127102742,
-0.0344159268,
-0.0269632526,
-0.0207571313,
0.0190687962,
-0.0090178717,
0.0318310335,
-0.0132529046,
0.0177203715,
0.0425793268,
-0.0187652688,
0.0127744833,
0.0178314913,
0.0189487692,
-0.0794190541,
-0.0447236113,
0.0264022816,
-0.0561850481,
-0.0149870841,
0.0086748283,
-0.0361034758,
-0.0777201802,
0.0126749072,
0.041472245,
0.0179640017,
0.0650037825,
-0.0510062389,
-0.017238304,
0.0215620063,
-0.0058603799,
-0.0443723649,
-0.0105931573,
0.0574472584,
0.0039711613,
-0.0296666175,
0.0201850682,
-0.0462924913,
0.0216686372,
-0.0329937041,
0.0032484047,
-0.0450730622,
-0.0525388494,
-0.0454570167,
0.0275153741,
0.0458796211,
-0.0411434136,
-0.0158771779,
-0.0715138167,
-0.0024201302,
0.0039198492,
0.0644376501,
-0.0439695977,
0.0164555088,
0.0375787094,
0.0191072375,
-0.0276120156,
0.0199878123,
-0.0136187579,
-0.0644450113,
0.0009378736,
0.0586260185,
0.0401698016,
-0.0062728804,
0.003093079,
0.0311416183,
-0.0190698951,
0.0754965842,
0.0084460331,
0.0127256373,
-0.0049141147,
0.0176235922,
-0.0311660413,
0.0092799952,
0.05995268,
0.042715136,
-0.0140992962,
-0.0186429191,
0.0108019048,
0.0565554351,
0.0671361461,
-0.0048088916,
0.0960024595,
-0.0046614041,
0.0107439971,
-0.0336679928,
0.04871995,
-0.023232799,
-0.0293472987,
0.0017021789,
-0.0067196069,
-0.0311971642,
0.0437019207,
0.0793590844,
-0.0335133672,
0.0231553689,
0.016453309,
0.0300466195,
-0.0224651545,
-0.0327813812,
0.0053684344,
-0.0096064853,
-0.0383361503,
-0.0010506414,
0.0099352496,
-0.0812224373,
0.00700043,
-0.0078428052,
0.0167821366,
0.0016644693,
-0.0018046208,
0.0582271591,
-0.0313400775,
0.0223020595,
-0.0271537341,
-0.0802426413,
-0.0390676036,
-0.0257609468,
0.0357747376,
-5.827405613e-33,
0.0151878176,
0.051506225,
-0.0055983276,
0.0380501635,
-0.0215671621,
-0.0201223288,
-0.010375469,
0.0098889554,
-0.0208896007,
-0.0160900708,
-0.0273860861,
-0.0135004018,
0.0365346223,
0.0000390154,
0.0557393059,
-0.0035346409,
0.0658567771,
-0.001460481,
0.0261863973,
0.0166743714,
0.0400064103,
0.0636951998,
0.0777778551,
-0.0629166216,
-0.0042388029,
0.0233123172,
0.0033889289,
-0.0044292146,
0.0154969674,
0.0841938183,
-0.0170765016,
0.0466721579,
-0.0132848183,
-0.0098174904,
-0.0188364629,
0.0005233037,
-0.0619382709,
0.0106124701,
-0.0014927449,
0.0935868695,
0.0197956953,
-0.0113070589,
-0.015287431,
-0.0327241383,
-0.0185839366,
-0.0015045544,
0.0257441662,
-0.0110882595,
-0.0043975292,
-0.0322620049,
-0.0355300866,
0.0417158604,
-0.0262628235,
-0.0474304259,
0.1002355441,
0.0546385571,
-0.0176876821,
-0.0471435748,
-0.053109616,
0.0342267118,
-0.0618850514,
0.0201950204,
0.0670711249,
0.0100491168,
-0.0083970279,
0.0122081544,
0.0351481698,
-0.0940239057,
0.0554066785,
-0.0187658165,
0.0191217307,
0.0301548094,
0.0003403274,
0.0329673886,
0.0139621869,
-0.065448314,
-0.0257908497,
-0.0513048396,
0.0701415092,
0.0196681581,
0.0096683456,
0.0100828195,
-0.0303727258,
0.0062876735,
-0.0474023037,
-0.0544239208,
-0.0215629674,
-0.0265176222,
0.0229400229,
0.0105662858,
0.037067093,
0.022832714,
0.0759697706,
0.0009850421,
0.0195088144,
0.0018885011,
0.0016690345,
-0.0179090593,
0.0062102615,
0.0578815192,
-0.0614708513,
-0.0231735483,
0.0027255954,
0.0086602783,
0.0172943864,
-0.0191378165,
0.0117469402,
0.0822617933,
-0.0581468642,
0.0114167342,
-0.0142050115,
0.0215130597,
0.0111436285,
0.0359697342,
0.0389668494,
-0.0013700753,
-0.0235776566,
0.0544201806,
0.0122503629,
0.0506719127,
-0.0095045641,
-0.0355715007,
-0.0395367257,
0.008179266,
-0.0422510616,
0.0198629647,
-0.0183587484,
-0.034671884,
0.0121516185,
-0.0300178118,
-0.0054844478,
0.0137084378,
2.718e-7,
-0.0440277159,
0.0244997367,
0.0113446228,
-0.0004684606,
0.0170418024,
0.0117360335,
-0.0473661795,
0.0140552018,
-0.0097527932,
0.0385704301,
-0.0106614679,
-0.0052047535,
0.1000409797,
0.0384057611,
-0.1042164713,
-0.0549532138,
-0.0794412196,
0.0040759668,
-0.0232182425,
0.0069901659,
-0.0213244688,
0.1011574194,
-0.0121693863,
-0.0056859162,
-0.0107091283,
-0.0250344649,
0.035361018,
-0.0086049056,
-0.0386797041,
-0.0307963844,
0.0195568465,
-0.0131761702,
-0.01984643,
-0.0165770184,
-0.0417733639,
0.040113207,
0.0414371863,
0.0548347831,
-0.0034941614,
-0.0552037135,
0.0186201669,
0.0451295897,
-0.063426815,
-0.0148440488,
0.0470685773,
0.044503957,
-0.032154046,
-0.0357035585,
-0.0085000042,
0.0030662583,
0.0476725921,
-0.0335994177,
0.0141880829,
0.0420602262,
0.0284855478,
-0.0424797609,
-0.0179614369,
-0.0379089117,
0.0229572505,
-0.0209175125,
-0.0354109816,
0.0095447609,
0.0112288734,
-0.0050149276,
-0.0076519153,
0.0007101506,
0.0046859295,
1.492924317e-34,
0.0469464473,
-0.0236613099,
0.0178090539,
-0.0181720536,
0.0131975729,
-0.0449946709,
0.0114433253,
0.0265649892,
-0.0198758282,
-0.0103485137,
-0.0405580141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18297v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18297v1 | FactFinders at CheckThat! 2024: Refining Check-worthy Statement Detection with LLMs through Data Pruning | 2024-06-26T12:31:31 | 2024-06-26T12:31:31 | Yufeng Li, Rrubaa Panchendrarajan, Arkaitz Zubiaga | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid dissemination of information through social media and the Internet
has posed a significant challenge for fact-checking, among others in
identifying check-worthy claims that fact-checkers should pay attention to,
i.e. filtering claims needing fact-checking from a large pool of sentences.
This challenge has stressed the need to focus on determining the priority of
claims, specifically which claims are worth to be fact-checked. Despite
advancements in this area in recent years, the application of large language
models (LLMs), such as GPT, has only recently drawn attention in studies.
However, many open-source LLMs remain underexplored. Therefore, this study
investigates the application of eight prominent open-source LLMs with
fine-tuning and prompt engineering to identify check-worthy statements from
political transcriptions. Further, we propose a two-step data pruning approach
to automatically identify high-quality training data instances for effective
learning. The efficiency of our approach is demonstrated through evaluations on
the English language dataset as part of the check-worthiness estimation task of
CheckThat! 2024. Further, the experiments conducted with data pruning
demonstrate that competitive performance can be achieved with only about 44\%
of the training data. Our team ranked first in the check-worthiness estimation
task in the English language. | [
0.0281821527,
0.0563504882,
0.0181530602,
0.0407276452,
-0.0616867691,
0.0081377001,
-0.0172804072,
0.013310208,
0.0214996338,
-0.0469894372,
0.0185855273,
-0.0153538734,
-0.0102797942,
0.015433914,
0.0037098229,
0.0173772704,
0.081376195,
0.0109061087,
0.0757082105,
-0.0260097217,
0.0110038742,
0.0266959015,
-0.046472121,
0.0097716833,
-0.041464895,
0.0140846595,
0.0455171913,
-0.0044356361,
0.0554458909,
-0.0230648778,
0.0024350509,
0.0480054319,
-0.0069637755,
0.0678253993,
0.0000018085,
-0.0474208556,
-0.0167495944,
0.025680976,
-0.0391665325,
0.0460973904,
0.0635452494,
0.0170284137,
-0.0390117839,
0.0207442977,
-0.006704872,
-0.0102364095,
0.0295571387,
0.035764005,
0.0943156034,
0.100048773,
0.0009157029,
-0.0010561539,
0.0286871586,
-0.0095447646,
-0.0133955562,
-0.043961484,
0.0646857172,
-0.0102082752,
-0.0294461381,
0.0239333361,
0.0188618079,
0.0460145101,
0.0071356408,
-0.0067375116,
-0.0452286378,
0.0113769909,
-0.0850109905,
-0.0141694732,
-0.0178028103,
0.0288750622,
0.0197184961,
-0.0565830022,
0.0152605446,
-0.0331416801,
0.005820455,
0.0264525991,
-0.005529779,
0.0368984416,
-0.0425357074,
0.0124056572,
0.0134839546,
-0.0250451341,
0.0230494738,
0.0425468609,
0.0094029251,
0.0782740712,
-0.0135869933,
-0.0652851313,
0.0489088185,
0.0073005133,
0.0017688356,
-0.043160636,
0.0189740155,
-0.0169423223,
0.0003137397,
0.01522737,
-0.0202235635,
0.0122590996,
0.0685978606,
-0.044231303,
-0.0186542347,
0.0084394263,
-0.0565817915,
0.0812969059,
-0.0118816607,
0.0503482409,
0.021172408,
-0.0039568204,
0.0223030765,
-0.0234285593,
-0.0245585553,
0.0135198841,
-0.002072264,
0.0441726223,
-0.0174536183,
0.0208086949,
-0.0560321137,
-0.0392903723,
-0.027578041,
0.0405974239,
0.0158010907,
-0.0390597284,
0.0119873378,
0.006506084,
-0.0672631264,
0.0304968487,
0.0075991461,
0.0142677398,
-0.0417498648,
-0.0789755657,
0.0050151092,
0.027135713,
0.011375932,
-0.0201985892,
0.0083049983,
-0.0282984115,
0.0095455665,
-0.0340491943,
-0.0427495055,
-0.0057486552,
-0.0381694771,
-0.0656240582,
-0.0007809795,
-0.0572102256,
0.0062544448,
-0.0364141054,
0.0234951731,
-0.0159459729,
0.0012999789,
0.0488920212,
-0.0250281971,
0.024596408,
0.0127609689,
0.0217489786,
0.0062848129,
-0.0069758832,
0.0421851836,
0.0646308139,
0.044899635,
0.0270254184,
0.0734021291,
0.0037434357,
0.0247243363,
0.0324917994,
0.0268965866,
0.0356563181,
0.0348007828,
0.0140620992,
-0.022261966,
-0.0201275125,
-0.0079604648,
0.0598417819,
0.0000092749,
-0.007738349,
0.0814855024,
0.009613364,
0.017138971,
-0.0248117819,
0.0386050418,
0.0454702228,
0.0281078797,
0.0079574455,
-0.0370293893,
-0.0020969119,
-0.0401609279,
-0.0281312894,
0.0308788363,
0.0788901821,
-0.0075681587,
-0.0391652212,
-0.0400068387,
0.0155823734,
-0.0131341768,
0.0337607525,
0.0048792814,
-0.0171952061,
-0.0564433858,
0.0540816002,
0.045733396,
-0.0806152374,
-0.0143163167,
-0.0707644895,
0.037817426,
0.0046293614,
0.030982757,
-0.0223680902,
0.0041490542,
-0.0362933166,
0.05008623,
0.045868475,
0.0804375112,
-0.0068231388,
-0.0043878104,
-0.0190517996,
-0.02078126,
0.0152327018,
0.0456606746,
-0.0384288393,
0.0664085448,
0.0321746245,
0.0021719174,
-0.0479231626,
-0.0609848462,
0.0375225842,
0.0233321972,
0.0110093858,
0.0097241448,
0.0183040816,
0.02589144,
0.0171368252,
-0.0050931168,
-0.0323820338,
0.0391411595,
0.0021676819,
0.0082627023,
-0.0291701853,
0.0204111896,
-0.0158100482,
0.0301310103,
-0.0387224704,
-0.0306502096,
0.0698778704,
-0.0580008216,
-0.0109778168,
-0.0489870533,
-0.0356066376,
-0.0241209604,
-0.0493725725,
-0.0075701075,
-0.0389656723,
0.0136368945,
-0.0039284723,
0.0706711933,
-0.023929216,
0.0140710603,
-0.018780252,
-0.0225649178,
0.0340428203,
-0.0339665897,
-0.0400706194,
0.0195421334,
-0.011201988,
0.0255998094,
0.0320591033,
0.0022239438,
-0.03727993,
-0.0264039282,
-0.0528137796,
0.0081406794,
-0.0189996175,
0.020310495,
0.0115205534,
-0.0390623473,
-0.0131682716,
0.0169257633,
-0.0125248097,
-0.0247378889,
0.0429594256,
0.0065742154,
0.0445879661,
-0.0335063078,
-0.0150041496,
-0.0050991504,
0.0173721407,
-0.025247464,
0.0146823172,
0.0389176868,
-0.0501488596,
-0.0149102984,
0.0455853119,
-0.0609585643,
-0.0033929755,
-0.0095815687,
-0.0220949687,
-0.0041101007,
0.0354350731,
-0.0171190742,
0.0312653929,
0.0217306465,
0.0042260527,
0.0356376767,
0.0218785368,
-0.0150493011,
0.0117864404,
-0.0264148992,
-0.0193611551,
-0.0062250607,
-0.0558917113,
0.0559761487,
0.0186087601,
0.0237472579,
-0.0211085454,
-0.0487774163,
0.020864157,
-0.0306370426,
-0.0055710669,
0.0096824393,
0.0109270616,
-0.0200582594,
0.0473264717,
-0.0328146294,
-0.0305706486,
0.0669826269,
-0.0324235372,
0.042221006,
-0.039992258,
-0.0133884409,
-0.0269326009,
0.0184347499,
0.0000999405,
0.0047097472,
0.0193024855,
0.0138902096,
0.0091680726,
-0.0364233628,
0.0508715771,
-0.0495105982,
0.0212341771,
-0.0364894904,
0.0386533849,
0.0023207963,
-0.0480422974,
-0.0315577425,
-0.0918938667,
-0.0325483084,
-0.0008034857,
-0.040155191,
-0.0150917955,
-0.0652790219,
-0.0109354025,
0.0462482236,
0.039843481,
-0.0010039745,
0.0259556416,
0.0060631433,
0.0153138749,
0.0145529453,
0.0038272417,
0.0483662449,
-0.0010452523,
-0.0231360234,
0.0481341332,
-0.013350185,
0.0249620229,
-0.0038312234,
-0.0498225391,
0.011112445,
-0.0471141785,
0.0024644481,
-0.0104540782,
0.0389211476,
-0.0484779179,
0.0058332416,
0.0912523866,
0.0107732993,
0.0071877083,
-0.0059527536,
0.0392762423,
0.0015730072,
0.028041508,
-0.0009250951,
-0.1272762418,
-0.0157206953,
0.0046332143,
-0.0055721966,
-0.0392416827,
-0.018298367,
-0.0507982746,
-0.1246545687,
0.0724790767,
-0.0144222127,
0.0097243302,
-0.0400283523,
-0.0547376573,
0.0186566338,
-0.0421123318,
-0.0192516483,
0.0246410742,
0.0019259432,
-0.0073853559,
-0.0018590365,
-0.0586236082,
-0.0847878084,
0.0573214367,
-0.0007310208,
0.01170965,
0.0387961157,
0.0480475314,
-0.0277581532,
-0.0653613359,
0.0308308974,
-0.016903406,
-0.0553039089,
-0.0048708781,
0.0653479993,
-0.0304058269,
0.0056272461,
-0.0122133661,
0.0149110127,
0.0357215069,
-0.0033320112,
0.0213081799,
0.0767911375,
-0.0023926846,
-0.0392202623,
0.0018941545,
0.0424924679,
0.0228118282,
0.099997811,
0.0075442968,
0.0183757655,
-0.0083532622,
-0.019745741,
-0.0245257374,
-0.0388804451,
-0.0317523032,
0.0581444018,
-0.008243423,
-0.0290710963,
-0.0579292215,
0.0058714719,
0.0025962871,
-0.0042312373,
-0.0284725036,
0.008384781,
0.0477449298,
0.022133518,
-0.0094431518,
0.0201812424,
-0.0704877749,
0.0321715511,
-0.0466163084,
-0.0054107062,
0.0457321368,
-0.0064064693,
-0.0258988794,
0.0434945114,
-0.0935158655,
-0.0435984842,
-0.0117639685,
-0.0021551328,
0.0265772119,
0.0292453319,
-0.0368726663,
-0.0183503442,
0.0231788792,
0.0736471415,
-0.0501570255,
0.0293391347,
0.0186422579,
-0.0220540725,
0.0016950535,
0.0099927792,
-0.0159382895,
0.0319497697,
0.0215254221,
-0.0033048983,
-0.0218291208,
-0.0297345575,
0.0288456529,
0.0727301314,
0.0458302684,
0.0025632926,
-0.0378602259,
-0.0555933528,
0.0030893555,
0.0215676054,
-0.0428484082,
-0.0008861686,
0.0462318063,
0.0029327529,
-0.0297629274,
-0.0458257198,
0.0106684091,
-0.0333154127,
0.0397845432,
-0.0514737219,
0.0233142991,
-0.009661491,
0.0132365394,
0.004902414,
-0.0534564964,
-0.0391166955,
0.0194789339,
0.0091958409,
0.0147390068,
0.0131868618,
0.0070032976,
0.0116319153,
0.0019371994,
0.0435493812,
-0.0190845672,
-0.0644894242,
-0.0074670915,
-0.0443147793,
0.0166584551,
0.0435506776,
0.0161792841,
0.0454803742,
-0.0110005327,
-0.0425764583,
-0.0217303224,
0.0000052346,
0.0137962187,
-0.0101717077,
0.0359883979,
0.0010331681,
-0.0440168865,
0.0186017435,
0.0394912921,
0.0081418715,
0.049167607,
0.0382585078,
-0.0537692755,
-0.0646066517,
-0.0793144032,
-0.0589114726,
-0.0100932512,
-0.0086525902,
-0.0053632306,
-0.0766615197,
-0.0372204557,
0.0405713581,
0.0309545286,
0.0319497548,
-0.0008512892,
0.0015019005,
0.0682732835,
-0.0037097838,
0.0072022956,
-0.054589428,
-0.0354161039,
0.0059938808,
-0.0018540191,
-0.0018007455,
-6.237267065e-33,
-0.017827278,
-0.0370385833,
0.0182056539,
-0.0051123071,
-0.0233086981,
0.0349080712,
-0.0258057639,
-0.0451856703,
-0.0496324524,
0.0409030989,
0.0005721523,
0.0343862288,
0.0237961002,
-0.0017792195,
-0.0408867486,
-0.0073401751,
0.0653696582,
0.0031102775,
-0.0525663421,
0.0203193463,
0.0276181102,
-0.0112409191,
0.0600146726,
-0.0440073684,
0.0284636226,
0.018212337,
-0.0590358712,
0.0266136881,
-0.0594843775,
0.0525707789,
-0.0060054185,
0.0387907997,
0.0291065164,
-0.0386698171,
0.0232702196,
0.0166405011,
-0.0656718835,
0.0090714945,
0.0412456281,
-0.0207405016,
0.0294474792,
0.0137669342,
0.0370742269,
-0.0195927862,
-0.0419535935,
0.0107844779,
0.0268638562,
-0.0384608395,
0.008323282,
-0.0333153345,
-0.0350787081,
0.0636359155,
0.0051740506,
0.0085701793,
-0.0280275904,
0.0530956984,
0.0021317925,
0.0460436121,
-0.05435412,
0.0562431179,
0.0240026899,
0.0030994853,
0.0473420583,
-0.0719284192,
-0.0309307724,
0.0673486888,
-0.0176743679,
0.0114702955,
-0.0301482677,
-0.0165243372,
0.0048456625,
0.0268561523,
0.0491539314,
0.1279854625,
0.0141342245,
-0.0672993511,
-0.0983195305,
-0.0057677221,
0.0430698618,
0.0173647758,
0.0319065526,
-0.0393130928,
-0.0328009538,
-0.0116310846,
-0.0377044491,
0.0092191305,
-0.0366850048,
0.0435635708,
0.0064066108,
0.0310195461,
-0.032218229,
0.0309537854,
0.0071575004,
-0.0350518711,
0.0062284581,
0.0465829186,
-0.0457942858,
0.0001366895,
-0.0076836483,
0.0229663849,
-0.074486725,
0.0176267605,
-0.0140984086,
0.0169225428,
0.0073831389,
-0.0110336924,
0.0528713055,
0.004988906,
-0.079743959,
0.0406333469,
-0.0181935783,
0.0385790281,
-0.0307082813,
-0.0023778847,
0.0292008109,
0.0078205056,
0.0111197447,
0.0144043034,
0.009611723,
-0.0140633192,
-0.0219350532,
0.007534598,
-0.0062918742,
0.038105242,
-0.0139964242,
-0.0070182788,
-0.0109087294,
0.0335689373,
0.0081980787,
-0.0499244556,
0.0244352594,
0.0161720403,
2.596e-7,
0.0153247314,
0.0571617819,
-0.0288346764,
-0.007400977,
-0.0009048562,
0.0243325178,
-0.0019225205,
-0.0148845445,
-0.0171331614,
-0.0466039926,
-0.0199474581,
0.0256847274,
0.0548981316,
0.0395183191,
-0.0746222958,
-0.0028413341,
-0.0691869333,
-0.0306085981,
-0.0563910417,
-0.009327231,
-0.0077229165,
0.043673452,
0.039735619,
-0.0265534353,
-0.0160613786,
-0.0249081179,
0.0277508777,
-0.0045272447,
-0.0623065345,
0.0273990016,
0.0702434778,
-0.0090808449,
0.0179546587,
0.0479979962,
-0.0281639919,
0.0131371459,
-0.0158468001,
0.0935846046,
0.0472714864,
0.0013669751,
-0.0323364586,
0.0023658022,
-0.0100707375,
-0.0486335866,
0.0751217604,
-0.0042340616,
-0.0292637236,
-0.0637289882,
-0.02819998,
-0.0313872136,
0.0392921194,
-0.0306016263,
-0.0224333312,
-0.0122860456,
-0.0248344857,
-0.0020957079,
-0.0209613908,
-0.0211918261,
0.019723976,
-0.0090445736,
-0.0428217053,
-0.0966328755,
0.0352000706,
-0.0136113325,
0.0197325349,
-0.0686886683,
0.0244400334,
2.388836865e-34,
0.0405286625,
-0.014680339,
0.0032511612,
-0.0654714406,
0.0670780912,
0.0513810478,
-0.0131110419,
-0.0163493063,
-0.0168021806,
-0.0232400317,
0.0045168856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18294v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18294v2 | Hierarchical Context Pruning: Optimizing Real-World Code Completion with Repository-Level Pretrained Code LLMs | 2024-06-26T12:26:16 | 2024-06-27T04:40:52 | Lei Zhang, Yunshui Li, Jiaming Li, Xiaobo Xia, Jiaxi Yang, Run Luo, Minzheng Wang, Longze Chen, Junhao Liu, Min Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Some recently developed code large language models (Code LLMs) have been
pre-trained on repository-level code data (Repo-Code LLMs), enabling these
models to recognize repository structures and utilize cross-file information
for code completion. However, in real-world development scenarios, simply
concatenating the entire code repository often exceeds the context window
limits of these Repo-Code LLMs, leading to significant performance degradation.
In this study, we conducted extensive preliminary experiments and analyses on
six Repo-Code LLMs. The results indicate that maintaining the topological
dependencies of files and increasing the code file content in the completion
prompts can improve completion accuracy; pruning the specific implementations
of functions in all dependent files does not significantly reduce the accuracy
of completions. Based on these findings, we proposed a strategy named
Hierarchical Context Pruning (HCP) to construct completion prompts with high
informational code content. The HCP models the code repository at the function
level, maintaining the topological dependencies between code files while
removing a large amount of irrelevant code content, significantly reduces the
input length for repository-level code completion. We applied the HCP strategy
in experiments with six Repo-Code LLMs, and the results demonstrate that our
proposed method can significantly enhance completion accuracy while
substantially reducing the length of input. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/Hambaobao/HCP-Coder. | [
0.0091516348,
0.0930036083,
-0.042176567,
0.002322017,
0.0005203602,
0.0099442843,
-0.0244821142,
0.0360025428,
0.0008119083,
0.0448782519,
-0.0539043918,
0.0368670337,
0.0325152613,
-0.0171447396,
0.0050364593,
-0.0106877284,
0.0390214249,
-0.0172367021,
-0.0425020419,
-0.0134036075,
-0.0376481302,
0.0165699683,
0.0383396819,
0.0538668856,
-0.000664156,
-0.0537356697,
0.0040870835,
0.0367514677,
-0.0325971134,
-0.0026002831,
0.0312989466,
0.0410772152,
0.0001778985,
0.0187371653,
0.0000023954,
-0.0256575085,
-0.0094623659,
-0.0141773866,
-0.0268711895,
0.0290145706,
-0.0172330365,
-0.0181936733,
0.0065940549,
0.0008659902,
-0.0087354481,
0.001647182,
0.033280354,
-0.0121439574,
0.0227421094,
0.0195697546,
0.0292358473,
-0.0178083032,
0.0059877485,
-0.0126361428,
0.0735821202,
-0.0150760207,
-0.0017035933,
0.0487116277,
0.0424267836,
0.0075674918,
0.0010779264,
0.0187809505,
0.0466339588,
0.0166344214,
0.0297281891,
0.054676529,
0.0041979337,
-0.0291826185,
0.0315041617,
0.0544964932,
-0.0741818175,
-0.0335021242,
0.0070055383,
-0.0343503654,
-0.053577438,
-0.0501560159,
-0.0288534351,
-0.0029879929,
-0.023274174,
-0.0020094677,
-0.0388932116,
-0.0310549662,
0.0226715188,
0.0082451273,
-0.0357978046,
0.0581395626,
-0.002688749,
-0.0034877451,
0.0046951892,
-0.0273447372,
-0.0132872369,
-0.062902458,
0.0016527297,
0.0414311588,
-0.0284804944,
0.0183510482,
-0.016005598,
-0.0093858549,
0.0631138682,
-0.0304900873,
-0.054374788,
0.0518911369,
-0.0686581731,
0.013405256,
-0.0474140011,
0.0752784759,
-0.030436866,
-0.0420115106,
-0.0376223959,
-0.0069043082,
-0.0232528672,
0.0006502002,
-0.0562454872,
0.0393816791,
-0.0409873798,
0.0204741769,
-0.0368130952,
0.0242018681,
0.0076953359,
0.0578393675,
-0.0328986607,
-0.015294007,
-0.0499700196,
-0.001817255,
0.0279471911,
-0.0298502706,
-0.0415617488,
-0.0299467836,
-0.0480531678,
-0.0149916159,
0.007115081,
0.0062218867,
-0.0457462259,
-0.0546760559,
0.0326850079,
0.0433564149,
0.0504329875,
0.0084049087,
-0.026716955,
-0.033940345,
0.0080947783,
-0.0247823466,
-0.0311531536,
-0.0915891379,
-0.0427791774,
0.0274548028,
-0.0007487052,
-0.0819944143,
-0.0253704581,
-0.0010521897,
-0.0049440679,
0.0175635964,
-0.0645753816,
0.0282474775,
0.0616347492,
0.0297494624,
-0.0369215459,
0.0354538001,
0.0169497468,
0.0543758906,
-0.0006830215,
-0.0630902871,
0.0256834775,
0.0152810011,
-0.0177792236,
0.0077695618,
0.0123432418,
0.0325682983,
0.0322433449,
-0.0221911687,
0.0604358651,
0.0137811378,
-0.0093031032,
0.0012392862,
0.0078065563,
0.0191296153,
0.0832698569,
0.0272278581,
0.0241456851,
0.0589572005,
0.0076672114,
0.0031640059,
-0.0669889003,
0.0383218192,
-0.0231834073,
0.0218687411,
-0.0182073247,
0.0360998064,
0.004164333,
-0.0517293476,
0.0096321413,
-0.051942315,
-0.0436185673,
0.0347604752,
0.0342082754,
-0.016990019,
-0.0243066438,
0.0116326604,
0.0479571298,
-0.03517434,
-0.0037481834,
-0.0080178138,
0.0531591587,
0.0455504023,
0.0352483764,
-0.0679286271,
-0.0196137689,
-0.0045070392,
0.0174077675,
-0.0698098168,
-0.0084908772,
-0.0133046452,
0.0236767549,
-0.0370275676,
-0.0468474962,
-0.0311211348,
-0.0300386623,
0.0492209382,
0.0193704758,
-0.0426740795,
0.0143593922,
0.0099399714,
-0.0313420407,
0.0470483191,
0.0138785383,
0.0328103416,
0.0264639799,
0.0154844858,
0.0212917216,
-0.0354121663,
-0.0382828601,
-0.035310775,
0.0589543581,
-0.0031935114,
-0.018879557,
-0.0507116802,
-0.048613593,
-0.0158593059,
0.0159095861,
0.0001229515,
-0.0159987118,
-0.0191055499,
-0.0181364678,
0.0035620555,
-0.0232884567,
-0.0230972059,
0.0588762946,
0.0102391923,
0.0286090523,
-0.0433879979,
0.0063166954,
-0.0494279377,
0.0539103746,
0.0243527237,
0.0509439856,
0.0513135307,
0.0802915022,
0.0532523617,
0.0178838279,
-0.0173402373,
0.0216043331,
-0.0331542082,
-0.0013236994,
0.0182358809,
0.0445583574,
-0.0180248711,
-0.0483119115,
-0.0858510509,
0.0074544051,
-0.0088451598,
-0.0014231374,
-0.0054585249,
0.0300780255,
-0.0107230628,
-0.0420712419,
0.0284196511,
0.0215958096,
-0.0299864449,
-0.001872752,
0.0340783261,
-0.0046955724,
-0.0452953801,
-0.029260179,
-0.0183711722,
0.0036762739,
0.0439969786,
-0.0286251064,
-0.0471795164,
-0.0499113314,
0.1017275304,
0.0224749967,
0.0321332961,
-0.0157669913,
-0.029985562,
0.0064297933,
0.0154412957,
0.0972779468,
0.0350383148,
-0.0172647629,
-0.0499085337,
0.0851113796,
0.0315089673,
-0.0686892197,
0.0184419136,
0.0400730968,
-0.057538949,
-0.0262643546,
-0.0005981254,
0.0209278539,
0.0345987007,
0.0047897398,
-0.0073192185,
-0.0218146872,
-0.0494038202,
-0.0108614406,
0.0024486603,
0.0149921449,
-0.0501907654,
-0.0131953517,
0.0763168037,
-0.0296798833,
-0.1108090878,
0.0376653038,
-0.0614958741,
-0.0475598201,
0.0049666138,
-0.0153399054,
-0.0528683998,
0.0689400584,
0.0312455297,
-0.0021609003,
-0.0025583422,
-0.0634046942,
-0.0237414688,
0.0348649994,
-0.0637686402,
0.0123904618,
0.0402964465,
-0.0311714951,
0.004413716,
-0.0121677769,
-0.0271076951,
-0.0273449626,
-0.0020392432,
0.0006682539,
-0.0075490009,
0.0169357024,
-0.0069335392,
0.0589619018,
0.008160484,
0.0262218025,
0.0609307662,
0.067658551,
-0.0448681489,
-0.0164051503,
-0.0485901684,
-0.0107556041,
-0.0295365807,
0.0067573744,
0.0270661134,
-0.0095172701,
0.0009480281,
0.0760863051,
0.0619276538,
-0.0592328161,
-0.0124605363,
0.0503593907,
-0.0229154155,
-0.0964626372,
0.0633729771,
0.0499046557,
-0.0387277715,
0.0127303582,
0.0911342502,
0.041562587,
-0.0658200011,
0.0114598665,
0.0076363483,
0.0411668271,
0.0764091462,
0.0548008494,
-0.0922297686,
0.0059818416,
0.003467482,
-0.0156409983,
0.021642914,
0.0025498965,
0.0040371222,
-0.0474918261,
0.0295290481,
0.0068933102,
-0.0096861152,
-0.0171452481,
-0.0286219809,
0.0180060547,
0.0267299972,
-0.0463381447,
0.0357921384,
-0.0061088353,
-0.0057324674,
-0.0076721921,
-0.0755273849,
0.0358533487,
0.0610010177,
-0.0223953668,
-0.0076919138,
0.1039014682,
0.0068335063,
0.0169307515,
0.0233244486,
0.0279928576,
-0.0170158073,
0.0281176325,
-0.0398848578,
0.0311816167,
0.0168916993,
0.0074773631,
0.0602866076,
-0.002622844,
-0.0252920333,
-0.0362527519,
0.0369237922,
0.0725501701,
-0.0406135321,
-0.0220245328,
-0.0075564696,
-0.0153069338,
-0.0125662619,
0.0147450352,
0.0641442388,
-0.0247490145,
-0.0141626019,
-0.0407464653,
0.0035054523,
-0.0161343683,
0.0572615601,
-0.0182067417,
-0.0243726783,
-0.0107682478,
-0.0132889468,
-0.0074311094,
0.035814207,
0.0275205299,
0.0161992088,
0.0036792269,
-0.0145397475,
0.0074174497,
-0.0301253349,
0.017209176,
-0.0123078953,
0.029046163,
-0.0488992706,
-0.0206586216,
0.0296720974,
-0.0330600068,
-0.0240633078,
-0.027533032,
-0.0594698787,
-0.0176137872,
-0.0453106053,
0.0273855571,
0.0125931781,
0.0286508445,
-0.0482443497,
-0.1193911731,
-0.0329658613,
-0.008357048,
-0.0819741637,
0.0412500016,
0.0318095461,
0.0022803242,
0.0074496283,
0.0021044253,
-0.072411105,
-0.0001527983,
0.0311226528,
-0.0380547158,
-0.022341365,
-0.0077392524,
0.0191943292,
0.0017084639,
0.0329867788,
0.0200806856,
-0.0188309345,
-0.0145295225,
0.0331678465,
0.0335719734,
0.001269981,
-0.0105868578,
0.0109973233,
0.0256475471,
-0.0008050824,
0.048117701,
-0.0036513016,
-0.012637848,
0.0297722314,
-0.0133376811,
0.0345365852,
0.0160295386,
0.0417696871,
0.0989738107,
0.0260416735,
-0.0233845282,
-0.0117056444,
0.0074704518,
0.019989172,
-0.0333572552,
0.0193672143,
-0.0041137221,
0.0296256635,
-0.0001071243,
-0.0142114814,
-0.0250367131,
-0.0571632348,
-0.0249664746,
0.0267676637,
0.0451350622,
0.0426513851,
-0.0064107529,
-0.0079771653,
0.019376548,
-0.0455889292,
0.0313212462,
0.0113830706,
-0.0701813623,
-0.0013011624,
0.0117195882,
-0.0382960849,
-0.011087751,
0.0891796947,
-0.005551884,
0.0317429937,
-0.0348640867,
-0.0011215089,
-0.0151457032,
0.0206815768,
0.0186371226,
0.0187584236,
-0.0616945252,
-0.0263567287,
-0.0169232935,
-0.0407763384,
0.0552157126,
0.0073758289,
-0.0151143745,
0.005242588,
0.023904236,
0.1005618349,
-0.0020001491,
-0.0502993055,
0.0024723376,
-0.0148759764,
0.029967647,
-0.0369240195,
-0.0679155812,
-5.282745448e-33,
-0.0278729368,
-0.0458274782,
0.0137473959,
0.0103111584,
0.004351317,
-0.0016982997,
-0.0350428447,
-0.012121805,
0.0064327833,
-0.0692132562,
-0.0134902531,
0.0071327575,
-0.0152186528,
-0.049141299,
0.0616134293,
0.0632462725,
0.0623268336,
0.04175606,
-0.0363588184,
0.0478143468,
-0.0631062463,
0.0639642999,
-0.0021833603,
-0.0443734936,
-0.0570874847,
0.0070043737,
0.0601305962,
-0.0176150482,
0.0217060987,
0.0541188158,
-0.0167704746,
0.0096665062,
-0.0035292259,
0.0005367626,
-0.0458891056,
-0.0010738005,
-0.0596166514,
-0.0405913517,
0.0066659348,
0.0309932772,
0.027955275,
-0.0714199245,
0.0763738006,
0.0087432945,
-0.0006349184,
0.0037259648,
0.0285596661,
-0.0114900693,
-0.0425976403,
-0.0172365829,
-0.053013958,
0.0372441188,
-0.0104140658,
0.0207271967,
0.0166844614,
0.0214182325,
0.0148507487,
0.072680369,
0.0145425089,
-0.0226361491,
-0.0040621203,
0.0779952258,
0.0593870021,
-0.0131144114,
0.0053172503,
-0.0114619285,
0.0523904376,
0.0160980709,
-0.0062440075,
0.004545188,
0.0459259301,
0.0448398776,
0.0043410645,
0.000510485,
0.0289241746,
-0.0321798101,
-0.025446469,
0.015371426,
-0.014668256,
0.0619635396,
-0.01898643,
0.0706709102,
-0.0169784501,
-0.0012790492,
-0.035110347,
0.0235771071,
-0.0159626137,
-0.0611099638,
0.0208393112,
-0.0047252439,
0.0074595069,
0.0289533827,
0.0043008295,
-0.029955266,
0.0011906904,
0.0307808351,
-0.0473973639,
0.0548056513,
0.0020530366,
0.0289263912,
-0.0171141811,
-0.0119487839,
0.0154194841,
-0.0464761369,
0.0704770312,
-0.0010271795,
0.0312617421,
0.0175558347,
-0.0590693839,
0.0031897607,
-0.0365245342,
-0.0550010428,
0.0002190146,
0.0084195174,
0.0046870355,
-0.0096905259,
0.0240747593,
0.0325167961,
-0.0308133811,
-0.0259018708,
-0.0881395936,
-0.0062568802,
-0.0020542594,
0.0105491951,
-0.0257771332,
-0.0600906871,
-0.0272535868,
0.0561036244,
0.0515852459,
0.0080409683,
-0.0566326082,
0.0382085256,
2.974e-7,
-0.0122964643,
0.0282148421,
0.005375952,
0.0169066545,
-0.0270044971,
-0.0190738719,
-0.0224782564,
-0.0360540189,
-0.000316475,
-0.0156463124,
0.0062155505,
-0.0222432427,
0.046785906,
0.0266296174,
-0.0808582157,
-0.011857992,
0.005928237,
-0.0101788333,
-0.0929445624,
-0.0082690688,
-0.0015549998,
0.0755584911,
0.0043484317,
0.0011209457,
0.0345342159,
0.0017911337,
-0.0079529006,
-0.0255544707,
0.0376747996,
0.0584527254,
-0.0579048246,
-0.0080748508,
-0.0168838799,
-0.0215037987,
0.0106074577,
-0.0234200768,
-0.0066126524,
0.048295144,
0.0088881841,
0.03105901,
0.0248995982,
-0.011318706,
-0.0344247445,
-0.048132889,
0.0292991344,
-0.0339578353,
0.0463081598,
0.0049508596,
-0.0064882427,
-0.0340320431,
0.0122453431,
-0.0037656503,
0.0324502364,
-0.0050612646,
0.0024850208,
-0.0510960594,
-0.0438016094,
-0.0471300557,
-0.0095602684,
0.0370275676,
-0.052201543,
-0.0239745304,
-0.0655533895,
0.004857915,
0.0261820853,
-0.0126508363,
0.0170486625,
2.707112521e-34,
0.0053278445,
-0.0539368093,
0.0093819601,
0.0183925461,
0.0404624827,
-0.0186703466,
-0.0103111584,
0.0440037623,
-0.0060844924,
-0.0179158505,
-0.025380319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18276v1 | Sanskrit Knowledge-based Systems: Annotation and Computational Tools | 2024-06-26T12:00:10 | 2024-06-26T12:00:10 | Hrishikesh Terdalkar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | We address the challenges and opportunities in the development of knowledge
systems for Sanskrit, with a focus on question answering. By proposing a
framework for the automated construction of knowledge graphs, introducing
annotation tools for ontology-driven and general-purpose tasks, and offering a
diverse collection of web-interfaces, tools, and software libraries, we have
made significant contributions to the field of computational Sanskrit. These
contributions not only enhance the accessibility and accuracy of Sanskrit text
analysis but also pave the way for further advancements in knowledge
representation and language processing. Ultimately, this research contributes
to the preservation, understanding, and utilization of the rich linguistic
information embodied in Sanskrit texts. | [
0.0374806151,
-0.0555517487,
-0.0492421016,
0.0893948302,
-0.0203988105,
-0.0056908843,
-0.0570228919,
0.0323709734,
0.0248383544,
-0.0393331647,
0.0095772324,
0.0126093319,
-0.0233046822,
-0.0165107641,
0.0134451613,
-0.0335220508,
0.0256767813,
-0.0227236636,
0.0515660457,
0.009404961,
0.073815994,
0.0378773808,
-0.0277514402,
0.0066583562,
-0.0419301651,
-0.032723777,
0.006538712,
-0.044322148,
0.0182664376,
-0.0133023011,
-0.040542189,
0.0339096375,
-0.0214024,
0.025118731,
0.0000014437,
-0.0727265626,
-0.0474890061,
-0.000016641,
-0.0279673729,
-0.0239826441,
0.0101089999,
0.0167155508,
0.0461657792,
0.0008052738,
-0.0566249602,
0.0339761712,
0.0763986409,
-0.0535215549,
0.0442803688,
0.0326822437,
-0.0236512795,
-0.000981332,
0.0312248319,
0.034524627,
-0.0084281992,
0.0226653814,
0.0075222775,
0.0611393377,
0.0140859634,
-0.0286603682,
-0.0273714457,
0.0449441895,
-0.025540892,
-0.0180668198,
0.0343234167,
-0.0369536802,
-0.0611806251,
-0.005847842,
0.0254265666,
-0.0024746116,
0.0667180046,
-0.0318485834,
-0.0013834422,
0.0275464412,
-0.0504599996,
-0.0055417409,
-0.0381612629,
0.0131850448,
-0.0589049049,
0.0196882877,
0.0567808487,
-0.0064790426,
-0.0380625986,
0.0152899241,
0.0585685745,
0.0227443818,
-0.0031983049,
-0.0130981077,
-0.0054690335,
-0.0248546191,
-0.0600289367,
-0.0351692587,
0.027978329,
0.0826627016,
-0.0037900158,
0.069404617,
0.0052825436,
-0.0796995237,
0.0317103788,
-0.0231191348,
-0.007728735,
0.0234380998,
0.0026386688,
0.000241656,
0.0067600179,
0.0316129997,
0.0390226915,
0.011707901,
-0.0273450818,
-0.0426844694,
0.0164747648,
-0.0717444643,
-0.075823091,
0.0140910335,
0.004399925,
0.0362250023,
-0.0337780081,
0.022994455,
-0.0216796249,
-0.0087056914,
0.0167412125,
-0.0235188939,
0.0095511554,
-0.005226505,
-0.0409697592,
0.00713391,
-0.016208088,
-0.0116330059,
-0.0200937502,
-0.0272365101,
0.0259506684,
0.0059530637,
0.0135369999,
-0.0060473285,
-0.0367541946,
0.021779811,
0.0235926881,
-0.0225996524,
-0.038615901,
-0.0109311547,
-0.0247813947,
-0.0310371406,
-0.0126788663,
-0.0790923312,
0.0577848852,
0.0604084581,
-0.0332674943,
-0.0591455847,
0.0465743355,
0.004036441,
-0.0169548988,
0.0663111806,
-0.0574152358,
-0.018823918,
0.0154760666,
0.0043115239,
0.0185600854,
-0.0236379635,
0.0362139903,
-0.0075454903,
0.0900139883,
-0.0041227886,
0.0131474333,
0.0161901917,
-0.0045055682,
-0.0325065032,
0.0047077471,
0.06662184,
-0.0194571819,
0.0265197624,
-0.0494407788,
0.0460491553,
0.019666208,
0.0284222029,
-0.0136310868,
0.0753256381,
-0.0047523095,
0.0623266138,
0.0023353023,
-0.002121316,
0.0582523718,
-0.0190957896,
-0.0157130752,
0.0354157574,
0.0101781134,
0.0154654523,
-0.014148158,
-0.0555144995,
0.0109176086,
-0.0460522249,
-0.0650984719,
-0.03392189,
-0.0278570037,
-0.0269366875,
0.0504164957,
0.0019685307,
0.004766563,
0.0121156462,
0.0540968254,
-0.0563941225,
0.0460282415,
-0.0283643305,
0.0663556829,
0.0588318743,
0.0224544983,
-0.0733867735,
-0.0118078357,
0.0694968998,
-0.0064894776,
0.0361306556,
0.0079560075,
-0.035438098,
-0.0610456541,
-0.0159485601,
0.0381768718,
0.0218934603,
-0.0199671444,
0.0126633104,
-0.0129277231,
0.0151421512,
-0.0090728654,
-0.045041535,
-0.0188462771,
0.0257312823,
0.0362183414,
0.0025047294,
-0.045987118,
0.0113810999,
0.0389079638,
0.015454175,
0.0192212723,
0.0264808275,
0.0413318649,
0.0057550361,
-0.0158856194,
0.0003858768,
0.0573732331,
-0.0159808621,
0.0281444062,
-0.0369645134,
0.014901015,
0.0109937284,
0.0179798473,
-0.0482948609,
-0.0046412009,
-0.0399041474,
0.0508459248,
-0.0339488424,
0.0025419933,
0.0461014472,
-0.0237722136,
-0.0492508151,
0.0404976867,
0.0462654643,
0.0258536898,
-0.0185423139,
-0.0703071952,
0.0434257239,
-0.0443507694,
-0.0248015691,
-0.0004125607,
0.0249076653,
0.0069402321,
-0.006558212,
-0.0283293333,
-0.0400409102,
0.0202495828,
-0.1237588152,
0.0042510876,
0.001769043,
0.0672950819,
-0.0094077522,
0.0286312103,
-0.0116293635,
-0.0260932911,
-0.0181467757,
0.0372324586,
0.0705844536,
-0.0244221259,
0.0266673155,
-0.0002365238,
0.0148990601,
-0.056089785,
-0.0122832069,
-0.0319605246,
0.0190420058,
0.007839676,
-0.0754879415,
-0.009126924,
-0.0108325724,
-0.0744023919,
0.028125884,
-0.0014023498,
-0.0081839906,
-0.034521129,
-0.0109174782,
-0.019986121,
-0.0200513266,
-0.0044654342,
0.0084772035,
0.0245629419,
-0.0277247112,
0.0033575397,
-0.0092404187,
0.0125045013,
0.0195529107,
0.0071591465,
0.0061122738,
-0.007463818,
0.0058457237,
0.0197525658,
-0.0173981301,
0.0046380339,
0.0060444409,
-0.0691128224,
0.0466445461,
-0.0126543157,
0.0111062229,
-0.0390933342,
0.0630211905,
0.0076629929,
-0.028356865,
0.0666260868,
-0.0178818051,
0.0064152437,
-0.0620737523,
0.0326088145,
-0.0328461342,
0.053482268,
-0.0076416354,
0.0190284047,
0.0043335957,
0.0070034289,
-0.0252639819,
0.0023744549,
0.0376936086,
-0.0524325855,
0.0108986823,
-0.0467617661,
0.0504340678,
-0.0407426246,
0.0287097711,
-0.0110794576,
0.0331183039,
-0.0180725008,
-0.0029011609,
0.0462256707,
0.0207498763,
0.0753957927,
0.0640899166,
-0.0278817602,
-0.0302121434,
-0.0128986659,
0.0143083995,
0.0050693681,
0.0534906052,
0.0526393726,
0.0311284903,
0.0156165985,
0.0799175873,
0.0124040879,
0.0094117662,
0.0111357551,
-0.0318381786,
0.0314447917,
-0.0283783153,
0.0352020152,
-0.0765891746,
-0.0049682017,
-0.0170325078,
-0.0196306407,
-0.0346815512,
0.0340081118,
0.0594972596,
0.0844406262,
0.0025554502,
-0.0098589715,
-0.0780525729,
-0.0487320051,
0.0110078324,
0.0408669002,
-0.1365463138,
-0.0009116647,
-0.0258811992,
0.0010328478,
0.0103048123,
-0.018747285,
-0.006235268,
-0.0642352849,
0.0006939989,
-0.0423556119,
-0.0397670865,
0.009639631,
0.0154044349,
-0.0244331621,
-0.0099263694,
-0.0395475365,
0.0277066082,
-0.0408868119,
0.0190998726,
0.0247843079,
0.0074162902,
0.0559747666,
0.0070418203,
-0.0238711797,
-0.0055782837,
0.0128755393,
0.0524294004,
-0.0097067337,
-0.0064879372,
-0.0343410634,
-0.011502374,
-0.0052768732,
-0.0359556861,
0.0287431665,
-0.0038111487,
-0.0142081426,
-0.046604,
0.001784628,
-0.0181194879,
-0.0256853029,
0.0810955167,
0.0881498978,
-0.0092615969,
0.0046366896,
-0.0016837688,
-0.0072477642,
-0.0246140845,
0.0219785776,
-0.0194036514,
0.0447448492,
-0.0195965767,
-0.040186625,
0.0304092187,
-0.0103906896,
-0.0538744703,
0.0096366359,
-0.0471207201,
-0.0013260943,
-0.0628347024,
-0.0419446677,
0.0726151317,
-0.0111270081,
0.032968808,
0.0431085639,
0.0328102075,
0.0579857714,
-0.0776207,
-0.0491474718,
-0.0406544022,
0.0083032446,
0.0047029839,
-0.0145564359,
0.0208312925,
0.0014786455,
0.0001262645,
0.0119201168,
0.0363475196,
-0.0250274874,
-0.0134196216,
0.0386030674,
0.0201483145,
-0.0128451781,
-0.0435111783,
-0.0261463169,
-0.004960658,
-0.0140990578,
-0.0553145595,
-0.0052348906,
0.0214857794,
0.006947652,
-0.0240698643,
0.0326583721,
-0.0386138223,
-0.0265395977,
-0.0479411632,
-0.0028407741,
0.0050859405,
-0.0111864097,
0.061836984,
0.0583966933,
-0.0169355329,
-0.0686655641,
-0.0044146921,
-0.01162255,
0.0026307108,
-0.025543388,
-0.0422178209,
-0.016033886,
0.0149530936,
-0.0284912586,
0.0259912591,
-0.0278057754,
0.0216396637,
0.0086955754,
-0.0055226469,
0.0341192372,
0.0534948483,
0.0736834779,
0.0318497382,
-0.0130106583,
0.0041850433,
0.000337339,
-0.0069616702,
-0.0167010091,
0.001318646,
-0.0106391404,
0.0519110933,
-0.0193791278,
-0.0298345108,
0.0311446637,
0.0058747553,
0.0421096608,
-0.0008047048,
0.0163128935,
0.0225962661,
0.0549202897,
0.0134458262,
0.046539899,
-0.0632930398,
0.0035528336,
0.0129856961,
0.0054007228,
0.0179561488,
0.0077300444,
0.0331975743,
0.016742941,
0.0244037267,
-0.0116616897,
0.0671116933,
-0.0537633263,
0.0141187655,
0.029341178,
-0.0895549357,
-0.026638642,
-0.0612328388,
-0.0395469442,
0.0241258908,
0.0366784111,
-0.0203159228,
-0.0701979846,
-0.0596841425,
-0.0131427646,
0.0145792048,
-0.0078549329,
-0.0233174991,
0.0502774157,
0.0301250461,
0.0645209178,
-0.0330124125,
-0.0481527857,
0.0484943502,
-0.1135489792,
-0.0066241249,
0.0231623258,
-4.187087735e-33,
-0.0661089197,
0.0013814871,
0.0089493385,
0.0729545578,
0.0183907654,
-0.0074633057,
-0.0481512435,
0.0015482429,
-0.0233023688,
0.0210829657,
-0.0239651389,
0.0020225698,
0.009354515,
-0.0297146905,
0.0108179143,
-0.0179261938,
-0.0493709631,
0.0136099905,
0.0072282469,
-0.015307677,
0.0784664676,
-0.0357932411,
0.0824939236,
-0.0099502979,
0.079738386,
-0.0289831981,
-0.0150878346,
0.0428898633,
-0.0334654599,
0.0537370257,
-0.0548403747,
0.0808848664,
0.0188198779,
0.0013987086,
0.0093434816,
0.012427046,
-0.0910294354,
-0.044132106,
0.072766237,
0.0384048522,
-0.0371513478,
-0.0222614668,
-0.0195333231,
0.0057763867,
0.0186993685,
0.0667394176,
0.055615548,
-0.0136078661,
0.0089741182,
-0.0729849041,
-0.0619602464,
0.0209653862,
-0.0310399886,
-0.0229137354,
-0.0032080696,
-0.0151734725,
0.0192342568,
-0.0300178938,
-0.0326306559,
-0.0095343022,
0.0022665053,
0.0260463897,
0.0294170212,
0.0041765119,
-0.051027555,
-0.0415325239,
-0.0128008118,
-0.0860213041,
0.0439694673,
0.0649091974,
-0.0193756185,
0.0443652309,
0.0610446334,
0.032495819,
-0.0032910679,
-0.0131661789,
-0.0344441831,
-0.0133871995,
-0.0281131975,
0.044768773,
-0.0177641362,
-0.0143118836,
-0.0164105128,
-0.0292081703,
0.0118791526,
-0.0284840297,
-0.0276744906,
-0.0240481719,
0.0232531969,
-0.0543563403,
-0.026412731,
0.0454220399,
-0.0084216222,
-0.0470137522,
0.034625195,
0.0391708314,
0.0116393706,
0.0308819786,
-0.021380851,
0.02860629,
-0.0309657659,
0.0181870386,
-0.0221611038,
-0.0285685658,
-0.0199450012,
-0.0174289513,
0.0125236521,
-0.0149729839,
-0.0255895611,
0.015321522,
0.0072856057,
0.0487031601,
-0.0410740189,
-0.0100992555,
-0.0084794462,
0.0425485112,
0.0287205745,
-0.0063063134,
0.0655037835,
0.0380943455,
-0.052848272,
0.0177492239,
0.0150656747,
-0.0510360673,
0.0035505521,
0.0183881223,
-0.0253822636,
0.033668004,
-0.0127398372,
-0.0184226017,
0.0394153781,
0.0245455131,
2.217e-7,
0.0838553309,
0.0265676323,
0.0455732718,
-0.0163311176,
-0.0008082399,
-0.0275945049,
0.0097838352,
-0.0221121274,
-0.0097396225,
0.0157917552,
0.0132110538,
0.0358640216,
-0.0047150273,
0.0803923309,
-0.0810832158,
-0.0316744223,
-0.0275994781,
-0.0907610729,
-0.0544120558,
0.0522694103,
0.015965661,
0.0188397001,
0.0458027236,
0.0029741479,
-0.0611873306,
-0.0335100815,
0.0251445714,
0.0299473237,
0.0345485099,
0.0453383997,
0.0089969141,
-0.0559406541,
-0.0008107052,
0.022612704,
0.0150844278,
0.0296666846,
0.0181919169,
0.0306592248,
-0.0179434884,
0.0146412086,
0.0123708453,
-0.0160054155,
0.0537353419,
-0.0346870236,
0.0701541156,
0.0162966754,
0.0044634813,
0.0277721174,
0.0157460701,
-0.0018440433,
-0.0336162411,
-0.0031727667,
-0.0196951255,
-0.0046447744,
0.0026612645,
-0.0590496808,
-0.0121329073,
-0.0345280208,
-0.0097150793,
0.0642307699,
0.025480818,
-0.0680825934,
0.0073829526,
-0.0129120173,
0.0264673289,
-0.0771039128,
0.0054746326,
1.298384594e-34,
0.0150067303,
0.000445744,
0.016423421,
0.005812977,
0.0055018971,
-0.0129040508,
0.0008362816,
0.03518131,
0.0187310334,
-0.0519995317,
-0.0225061029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18266v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18266v2 | "Vorbeşti Româneşte?" A Recipe to Train Powerful Romanian LLMs with English Instructions | 2024-06-26T11:39:51 | 2024-06-27T20:30:47 | Mihai Masala, Denis C. Ilie-Ablachim, Alexandru Dima, Dragos Corlatescu, Miruna Zavelca, Ovio Olaru, Simina Terian, Andrei Terian, Marius Leordeanu, Horia Velicu, Marius Popescu, Mihai Dascalu, Traian Rebedea | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved almost human-like
performance on various tasks. While some LLMs have been trained on multilingual
data, most of the training data is in English; hence, their performance in
English greatly exceeds other languages. To our knowledge, we are the first to
collect and translate a large collection of texts, instructions, and benchmarks
and train, evaluate, and release open-source LLMs tailored for Romanian. We
evaluate our methods on four different categories, including academic
benchmarks, MT-Bench (manually translated), and a professionally built
historical, cultural, and social benchmark adapted to Romanian. We argue for
the usefulness and high performance of RoLLMs by obtaining state-of-the-art
results across the board. We publicly release all resources (i.e., data,
training and evaluation code, models) to support and encourage research on
Romanian LLMs while concurrently creating a generalizable recipe, adequate for
other low or less-resourced languages. | [
0.0031977003,
0.0522010401,
-0.001053753,
0.0552376509,
-0.0214062203,
0.0245311409,
-0.0012292912,
0.0130275339,
0.0128840031,
-0.0343461186,
-0.057019148,
-0.0613981783,
-0.0058697648,
-0.0346041135,
0.0522052683,
-0.0311664194,
0.0614645593,
-0.0387083702,
-0.0529651046,
-0.0106310127,
-0.0019838111,
-0.0064543001,
-0.0337781198,
-0.0016515477,
-0.0001278868,
0.0163106155,
0.0149642639,
0.0181981325,
0.0267073065,
-0.0109435739,
0.0117750587,
-0.0026220812,
0.0325001031,
0.0362905562,
0.0000017314,
-0.0569058023,
-0.0005906573,
-0.0247526821,
0.0161115676,
0.0279533789,
0.0525358096,
-0.0495703109,
-0.0332398005,
0.0142027903,
-0.0362966843,
-0.0147208255,
0.0233463217,
0.024762515,
0.0366403423,
0.0992462933,
-0.0046636248,
-0.0372040831,
0.0180677418,
-0.0566941425,
-0.0283639096,
-0.0268770661,
0.0254046563,
0.0128458831,
-0.001158266,
0.0137177985,
-0.0035331245,
0.0548199043,
-0.0034889553,
0.0037310813,
-0.0501652136,
0.0126020452,
-0.0357299671,
-0.0172414891,
-0.0456072465,
0.0538908169,
0.021753557,
0.0015971669,
0.0335063487,
0.0335936397,
-0.042126894,
-0.0268910397,
-0.0585408993,
0.0555078015,
0.0241894163,
0.0227064844,
0.0208504442,
0.0010768929,
0.0292960163,
0.011565025,
0.027273329,
0.0568187796,
0.0388440341,
-0.0316909179,
0.0502692796,
0.0003775747,
0.0277200677,
-0.022821093,
0.021646671,
0.0752629712,
-0.0111931767,
0.029111445,
-0.0163194425,
-0.0037263439,
0.0561592169,
-0.0507758111,
0.0296231117,
0.04129963,
-0.0237743277,
0.0522725359,
-0.0410134047,
0.0692037418,
-0.0213895459,
0.0219702516,
-0.0398177318,
-0.0176735781,
-0.0285409503,
0.0265667345,
-0.0410140194,
-0.018788537,
-0.0306679998,
0.0074550998,
-0.078094162,
0.0158079248,
0.0491490811,
0.0338517874,
0.0220562834,
-0.0289968196,
-0.0420142598,
-0.0017108815,
-0.0297638644,
0.0381454192,
-0.0192829035,
0.0093147662,
-0.0509446934,
-0.0473883785,
-0.0085125109,
0.0352511331,
-0.0316773057,
-0.0256872885,
0.0561410487,
0.0646631047,
-0.0345016979,
-0.0219769757,
-0.0377274379,
0.0105642751,
-0.0042253854,
-0.0987998471,
-0.0159317851,
-0.0664704889,
0.0302867014,
-0.0080171796,
0.0214843918,
-0.0668220297,
0.0169041194,
0.0419018157,
-0.037450999,
0.034466017,
-0.0127186002,
-0.0003738723,
0.0036818862,
0.0157587361,
0.0119626084,
0.0632486641,
0.0293999575,
0.0498746596,
0.044468943,
0.0161623918,
0.0022440013,
0.0769370496,
0.005555328,
0.0278223492,
-0.0411644839,
0.0515922531,
0.0163375102,
0.0355461314,
0.0616236925,
0.0923552588,
-0.0008634555,
0.0043835072,
0.059421178,
0.0374061167,
0.032319244,
0.0373601317,
0.0644101948,
-0.0302966479,
0.0158372652,
-0.0227453355,
-0.0473762155,
-0.0241829008,
0.0126547739,
0.0137300026,
-0.0196605101,
0.0267163143,
-0.0340261571,
-0.0236852635,
-0.0147246802,
-0.0439575203,
0.0177815408,
-0.0237777922,
0.0682027042,
0.0075591714,
-0.0466071963,
0.0638906583,
0.0498065352,
-0.0671940595,
0.0115357703,
-0.0250736978,
0.0656936318,
0.048224479,
0.0218375232,
-0.041802343,
0.0006347865,
-0.0095827347,
0.0521029234,
0.0465238243,
0.0577177294,
-0.0285968855,
0.0035156568,
-0.0919423625,
0.0230255555,
0.0049250373,
0.0079378197,
0.0374651328,
-0.0053053196,
0.0408734418,
0.0267326031,
-0.0044094068,
-0.037433967,
0.043026641,
-0.0541762449,
-0.0113377608,
-0.023146471,
-0.0161094368,
-0.0039241989,
0.0243506692,
0.0113284308,
-0.0218643397,
0.0622050427,
-0.0510748029,
0.0266811065,
-0.0112417853,
-0.0054548448,
-0.0127959047,
0.073934406,
-0.0303272512,
-0.0344103575,
0.0214694533,
-0.0331962258,
-0.0338893868,
0.0354783796,
-0.0333016291,
-0.0069128354,
-0.0363784991,
0.0364543274,
0.0079866964,
0.0104691284,
-0.0400196239,
0.0578214042,
-0.0246812366,
0.0123068215,
0.0611745231,
-0.0280109327,
0.0190101918,
-0.0387357064,
-0.0453346632,
0.0177159905,
0.0039702361,
0.0004467429,
0.0007532951,
0.0525952429,
-0.0178502705,
-0.0259642042,
-0.101761274,
0.0540926903,
-0.0530484542,
0.0354814194,
0.0044333558,
-0.0045808037,
-0.0283379182,
-0.0348191746,
-0.0652526543,
-0.0205269884,
-0.0122307641,
-0.0118726213,
0.0278243627,
0.0201579966,
-0.0194871649,
-0.048269596,
0.0080222441,
0.0094137378,
-0.0140261911,
-0.0208026897,
-0.0152537813,
-0.0610327162,
0.0496047176,
-0.0511986278,
0.0322890989,
-0.0593655258,
-0.050540816,
-0.0132181002,
0.0090541597,
0.0728742778,
0.0296775326,
-0.0173337962,
0.0151688186,
0.0471425168,
0.0053079282,
-0.0481477901,
0.0154257594,
-0.0190972108,
-0.023063032,
-0.0986391157,
-0.0482204743,
-0.0218207594,
0.0524486303,
-0.0272921938,
0.0222873893,
-0.0272876322,
-0.0247234274,
-0.0281556211,
-0.0117527833,
-0.007972518,
0.0051555671,
-0.025186073,
0.0395389237,
0.016372107,
-0.0326454304,
0.0273446143,
-0.0537683517,
-0.0187946334,
-0.0237885993,
-0.0431109741,
-0.0784107149,
0.0183876604,
-0.0044910936,
0.0044250148,
-0.0501698442,
-0.0153004378,
-0.0417838655,
-0.0194612425,
0.00421564,
-0.0399296097,
0.0920988321,
-0.0550246648,
-0.0041215043,
-0.0276414417,
-0.0274683256,
-0.0345017873,
-0.0164390765,
-0.0342069902,
0.0121757993,
-0.0018014875,
-0.0230135638,
-0.025105929,
-0.002879071,
0.013806751,
0.0527366735,
-0.0149843125,
0.0258042198,
-0.0233057719,
0.0028462198,
0.0373567604,
0.0176614784,
0.023309771,
-0.0407509953,
-0.006557595,
0.0453748181,
0.0529293157,
-0.0444832034,
-0.0372668654,
-0.0153566115,
0.0411275588,
-0.0513084903,
-0.0214414336,
-0.0232710801,
0.0237954836,
-0.0339709781,
-0.0190731194,
0.0941758454,
0.0155019825,
-0.0605883785,
-0.004769858,
-0.0180374514,
0.0218869932,
0.0298141073,
0.0371828936,
-0.0845519006,
-0.0126283765,
-0.0099018812,
0.015946839,
0.0117217964,
0.007713329,
-0.016295081,
-0.0969794765,
0.0103382803,
0.0049437173,
-0.0027273146,
-0.0229324643,
-0.022464186,
-0.0088242004,
-0.0514351539,
0.0272123888,
0.0141670881,
-0.0593421645,
-0.0332765281,
0.0262539033,
-0.0247879885,
-0.0513371378,
-0.0103077553,
-0.0290747844,
0.0718296543,
0.0428026058,
0.0261063445,
-0.0372015722,
-0.0293778721,
0.0726491883,
-0.0121068051,
0.0092049241,
-0.0338808596,
0.0456043631,
0.0135987131,
-0.0156307817,
0.0093947593,
0.009773979,
-0.0192667395,
-0.0038358697,
0.0489542931,
0.053776823,
-0.012165077,
-0.0151361842,
0.0175463744,
-0.0020225039,
0.032858558,
0.0591458641,
0.0128566269,
-0.0036814073,
-0.0121815978,
-0.0198823623,
-0.0432228409,
-0.0282317083,
-0.0767049044,
0.0063956324,
-0.0400535129,
-0.0251505189,
-0.0636107177,
-0.0547103025,
0.0325248912,
0.022998577,
0.0308328737,
-0.0046713767,
0.003207749,
-0.001590439,
-0.0356782675,
0.0444244333,
-0.0407572985,
0.0226299725,
-0.0782355592,
-0.020885203,
0.0573938712,
-0.0163590033,
-0.0120352237,
0.0223811138,
-0.0970773697,
-0.0643774122,
-0.007880033,
0.0695101619,
0.022333419,
0.0701694712,
-0.0065404344,
-0.0595259927,
0.0313225165,
-0.0247094836,
-0.0122699002,
0.0177999157,
0.0423293039,
0.0077478206,
0.0029768741,
0.0443942547,
-0.0309808441,
0.0281124301,
0.0169651061,
0.0414724275,
-0.045380231,
-0.0129815424,
-0.0046938616,
0.0152788432,
0.0177848991,
-0.052796375,
-0.0127911363,
-0.0250827149,
0.045710016,
-0.0542344078,
0.0084228367,
-0.0090407804,
0.0232582539,
0.0332069173,
-0.007398888,
-0.0312427953,
-0.0214278381,
-0.0216949284,
-0.0059540612,
-0.0453750938,
0.0312211066,
0.0016003926,
0.034538731,
0.0350734517,
0.0238020234,
-0.0148109449,
0.0670856535,
-0.0014648242,
0.0550147295,
-0.0188265853,
0.0312802643,
0.0083206408,
-0.0161408558,
0.0155969113,
0.022182066,
-0.0158562865,
-0.011655679,
0.0177328419,
0.0108781671,
0.0890425891,
0.003137687,
0.1189477369,
-0.0370397642,
-0.0014552523,
-0.0166583732,
0.0291445609,
-0.0085497489,
0.0023950667,
0.0139597207,
0.0071636378,
-0.0258993767,
0.0334221646,
0.0499601215,
-0.0006396618,
0.0207736958,
0.0222159307,
0.0065326523,
-0.0380080976,
-0.0449665822,
-0.0018111721,
-0.050067991,
-0.0394659862,
-0.0352520607,
-0.0499104112,
-0.0479089282,
0.0355118476,
0.04257131,
-0.0367284268,
-0.0104529355,
0.037814226,
0.0227187611,
0.0107854139,
0.0325760841,
-0.0738123879,
0.0229646917,
-0.0041170381,
-0.0384398811,
-0.0422103405,
-5.347072173e-33,
-0.0352815464,
0.0090783201,
0.0577030554,
-0.0005857543,
-0.0372051969,
-0.0300999805,
-0.0201327074,
-0.0047408394,
0.0019719247,
0.0183970202,
-0.0060323658,
-0.0124702994,
0.031503506,
-0.0002062782,
-0.008156592,
-0.0173852742,
0.0146077164,
0.0098687233,
-0.0045606908,
0.0259496756,
0.006724874,
0.0380186066,
0.0926551297,
-0.0700232983,
0.006416298,
-0.0327691846,
-0.0161850154,
0.054012794,
0.0345441215,
0.0871428549,
-0.023672685,
0.0181330293,
0.0073993322,
-0.0180717297,
-0.0063981717,
-0.0007866612,
-0.056170512,
-0.01594395,
0.0491376892,
0.0486633927,
-0.0017069856,
-0.0403372087,
0.0162837617,
-0.0229612999,
-0.0313146375,
0.0171478987,
0.0357357711,
-0.0413468145,
-0.0156186502,
-0.032927651,
-0.056693621,
0.0276785605,
-0.0036600567,
0.0049443957,
0.0278927535,
0.0373444855,
0.0077455807,
0.0066942247,
-0.0603654198,
0.0230002254,
-0.0235780142,
0.0403538235,
0.0635391995,
-0.0238662865,
-0.0161149725,
0.0375266671,
0.005635669,
-0.0159207936,
-0.003878033,
-0.0094035715,
0.0426799096,
0.0282964595,
0.0415363237,
0.0544391535,
-0.01034371,
-0.0106618553,
-0.0970611721,
0.0054220809,
0.0589408986,
0.0362121239,
-0.0079542305,
-0.0264799912,
-0.0374024808,
-0.0031917079,
-0.0096293399,
0.0081736939,
0.0040453291,
-0.0288483445,
0.0387738384,
0.0049828761,
0.012299994,
0.0055458737,
0.0097152861,
-0.0332055986,
-0.0411472395,
0.0031425611,
-0.0079150889,
0.016736351,
-0.0188317187,
0.0497294106,
-0.0537036099,
-0.0383524708,
-0.0168503877,
0.0024282478,
0.0346537977,
-0.0104857236,
0.0440337062,
0.0241211206,
-0.066881232,
0.0080720326,
-0.0169537123,
0.0227516796,
-0.0005068842,
0.0391965136,
0.0102641629,
-0.0028680388,
-0.006338059,
0.0522571504,
0.0132796504,
-0.0323269963,
-0.017805269,
-0.0417631753,
0.0457762852,
0.0355122834,
-0.0374827795,
0.0244854447,
-0.0203310661,
0.0597333647,
0.0391355492,
-0.0229467954,
0.0121380156,
0.0142558841,
2.348e-7,
0.0613150671,
0.0512443446,
-0.000627185,
0.0411643349,
-0.0164539944,
-0.0116172852,
-0.0766431838,
0.021509191,
-0.0205584094,
0.0291893277,
0.0345273949,
0.0406844094,
0.0707655102,
0.0147848614,
-0.0983677953,
-0.0041702306,
-0.0529437549,
-0.0222360305,
-0.0535767674,
-0.0068458929,
-0.0221083518,
0.0863674879,
0.0173154324,
-0.0189125109,
-0.0492791869,
-0.0218379851,
0.0667302608,
-0.0360925198,
-0.0321287736,
0.0578939319,
0.032369718,
0.0336380601,
-0.0391906388,
-0.0222763997,
-0.0017250851,
0.0291691776,
-0.0005752393,
0.1025223583,
0.0127580045,
-0.0260341968,
0.0479951687,
-0.0313716792,
-0.0219884366,
0.001661259,
0.0354501605,
0.0092815841,
0.0177081041,
-0.0313207358,
-0.0100904936,
0.0158044081,
0.0140940985,
-0.0190293286,
-0.0038263812,
0.0364454351,
0.0481308736,
-0.0316049717,
-0.0436481759,
-0.0842869282,
-0.0290871318,
-0.0112178996,
-0.0342172384,
-0.0501433462,
-0.0068650027,
0.0134813758,
-0.0478735678,
-0.0559350066,
-0.0143805631,
2.107817491e-34,
0.0480477549,
-0.019566102,
-0.0160674378,
0.0532114282,
0.0252483655,
0.000521766,
0.0006851453,
0.007546817,
-0.0052411426,
-0.0655375123,
0.005719231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18259v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18259v1 | Detecting Machine-Generated Texts: Not Just "AI vs Humans" and Explainability is Complicated | 2024-06-26T11:11:47 | 2024-06-26T11:11:47 | Jiazhou Ji, Ruizhe Li, Shujun Li, Jie Guo, Weidong Qiu, Zheng Huang, Chiyu Chen, Xiaoyu Jiang, Xinru Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As LLMs rapidly advance, increasing concerns arise regarding risks about
actual authorship of texts we see online and in real world. The task of
distinguishing LLM-authored texts is complicated by the nuanced and overlapping
behaviors of both machines and humans. In this paper, we challenge the current
practice of considering LLM-generated text detection a binary classification
task of differentiating human from AI. Instead, we introduce a novel ternary
text classification scheme, adding an "undecided" category for texts that could
be attributed to either source, and we show that this new category is crucial
to understand how to make the detection result more explainable to lay users.
This research shifts the paradigm from merely classifying to explaining
machine-generated texts, emphasizing need for detectors to provide clear and
understandable explanations to users. Our study involves creating four new
datasets comprised of texts from various LLMs and human authors. Based on new
datasets, we performed binary classification tests to ascertain the most
effective SOTA detection methods and identified SOTA LLMs capable of producing
harder-to-detect texts. We constructed a new dataset of texts generated by two
top-performing LLMs and human authors, and asked three human annotators to
produce ternary labels with explanation notes. This dataset was used to
investigate how three top-performing SOTA detectors behave in new ternary
classification context. Our results highlight why "undecided" category is much
needed from the viewpoint of explainability. Additionally, we conducted an
analysis of explainability of the three best-performing detectors and the
explanation notes of the human annotators, revealing insights about the
complexity of explainable detection of machine-generated texts. Finally, we
propose guidelines for developing future detection systems with improved
explanatory power. | [
0.0640406385,
0.0169966072,
-0.0218053907,
0.0356285647,
-0.0176690016,
0.0342947021,
0.0652968213,
0.0346773081,
0.0154058076,
-0.0237192456,
0.0187262502,
0.0126809394,
-0.0231263433,
0.0393744558,
0.0410520807,
0.0123817911,
-0.0072776461,
-0.0083458973,
0.048924759,
0.0310173221,
0.0250811465,
0.047925625,
-0.0027195334,
0.0194764845,
-0.0169432741,
-0.0305418484,
-0.0043859123,
0.0081451256,
0.0180846211,
-0.0064501441,
-0.0116191749,
0.0381470062,
0.0059348173,
0.0851035789,
0.0000019018,
-0.0368628316,
-0.030434953,
-0.0005774258,
-0.0692522824,
-0.0199632756,
0.0274004787,
0.0099297473,
-0.0217512846,
0.0241125561,
-0.0178562701,
0.0602467135,
0.0331230164,
0.058547657,
0.0448689647,
0.069078587,
-0.0272533055,
-0.0125013404,
0.0339813456,
0.0315898396,
0.025920935,
0.0109946514,
-0.0014583066,
-0.0438770428,
-0.0207481999,
0.0382041559,
0.0301851388,
0.0139731215,
0.0006500462,
-0.0533017851,
0.0061852848,
0.0167017411,
-0.0040477919,
-0.0390867889,
0.0043104989,
0.0247018971,
0.0134981051,
-0.046663627,
0.0651403666,
-0.0134170176,
0.0034777818,
0.0463829637,
0.0140908016,
0.0555630066,
-0.0492548496,
-0.0032505197,
0.0225712173,
0.0094500594,
0.0117961736,
0.0460356846,
-0.0103079099,
0.0356726386,
-0.0356177017,
-0.0259650908,
-0.0248431247,
-0.0026308247,
0.0196996275,
-0.060747467,
0.0438738093,
0.0397670493,
0.0037961323,
-0.0041994606,
-0.0365628526,
-0.0392314754,
0.0263805855,
-0.0454427898,
0.0459742434,
-0.0169882681,
-0.0411261842,
0.0525395945,
-0.0593032874,
0.050579641,
-0.0028036297,
0.0425712839,
0.0012801694,
0.0039662137,
-0.0234512463,
-0.0341607668,
-0.0076433844,
0.0028610537,
0.0191898495,
0.017095821,
-0.0211497191,
0.0408793353,
0.0064663105,
0.0186624825,
-0.0209427401,
-0.0250914432,
-0.0017423726,
-0.014400213,
-0.0328526907,
-0.023712093,
-0.0293955803,
0.0246156342,
-0.0118716639,
-0.0477087796,
0.0147712147,
0.0852990597,
0.0421509296,
-0.0050564464,
0.0137230316,
0.050455872,
-0.0073186611,
-0.0266846046,
-0.043513231,
-0.079961881,
-0.0124338167,
-0.0477834605,
-0.0294697378,
-0.0111095989,
-0.033192277,
0.0191997383,
-0.011035501,
-0.0193490852,
-0.0136868805,
0.0202031974,
0.0031717715,
0.0536189228,
-0.0725865141,
-0.003720856,
0.0529114455,
-0.0041740225,
-0.0440476276,
-0.0055812369,
0.0479218252,
0.0963158458,
0.0642043874,
-0.002844997,
0.0746296346,
-0.0014333876,
0.0056263828,
0.0032243489,
0.0292118676,
-0.0188178774,
-0.0839037076,
0.0013528217,
0.0255168881,
0.0302844662,
-0.0056217848,
-0.0096045788,
0.075429298,
0.0582633577,
0.0083622821,
0.0293753464,
0.0417222008,
0.0293312296,
0.0007112191,
0.0468503721,
-0.0035121355,
0.023253642,
-0.0428833291,
-0.0233439356,
0.0014585141,
-0.0235988796,
0.0055955821,
-0.0644113123,
-0.0079175495,
-0.0188218169,
0.0191318523,
-0.0176417287,
0.0261097904,
0.0001036346,
-0.0385621525,
-0.0031255099,
-0.0341569185,
-0.0735302269,
-0.0016882221,
-0.0894059241,
0.0898436382,
0.0785232559,
0.0308019407,
-0.0320212804,
0.0372128151,
-0.0464010537,
0.0395805351,
0.0491923615,
-0.0282988679,
0.0176279228,
-0.0014479085,
-0.030119637,
-0.0289075654,
-0.0156071419,
0.0064877304,
0.0038886294,
-0.0047140787,
-0.0223470703,
0.0131204389,
-0.0249322765,
-0.0472461358,
0.0472211018,
-0.0016307948,
-0.0391698517,
-0.0076701976,
0.0403728895,
0.0077810748,
0.0376987346,
0.0037565306,
0.0055862949,
0.0276785642,
-0.0298255291,
-0.045107238,
0.0034846198,
0.0367535092,
0.0265168454,
-0.0017024444,
-0.0221776254,
-0.0353321433,
0.006556042,
-0.0214501265,
-0.0253039747,
-0.0289125349,
-0.0617712028,
-0.0180531088,
-0.0661634281,
0.0012380485,
-0.0094168698,
0.0076113972,
-0.0219129156,
0.0712494329,
0.0016008187,
-0.0009823417,
-0.0248650946,
-0.0321808644,
0.0600876212,
0.015496525,
0.030495245,
-0.0098302877,
-0.0351709612,
0.0051516411,
0.0126939518,
0.0046107969,
-0.0091837496,
-0.032607194,
-0.0560303964,
-0.0187140331,
-0.0176248066,
0.0338896103,
0.0210781433,
-0.0433584489,
0.0070910375,
0.0045628245,
-0.0327689685,
-0.0141296498,
-0.0015120716,
0.0091786133,
0.0888792127,
-0.0286895297,
-0.0108466893,
-0.0087964414,
0.0141068501,
-0.0289660338,
0.0488733575,
0.0739738494,
-0.0496154912,
-0.0791875422,
0.0308299866,
-0.0084142042,
-0.0574957766,
-0.0162956771,
-0.015184883,
0.0198525265,
-0.0079013901,
-0.0399439819,
0.0597126633,
0.0292036179,
0.0574139431,
0.0093552778,
0.0594778359,
-0.0005579827,
-0.0311159082,
-0.0012277757,
0.0128116319,
0.0059939902,
-0.0705370307,
0.0346403234,
0.0304278322,
-0.0175674986,
-0.001902441,
-0.0226103086,
0.0164892189,
0.0171797555,
-0.0132798366,
-0.0071579963,
-0.067123808,
-0.01957196,
0.0953535438,
-0.0096175168,
-0.0784749687,
0.0639725178,
-0.0369426794,
-0.0042047962,
-0.0119651584,
-0.0319337472,
-0.0303167515,
0.0381788723,
-0.0073631536,
0.0290796533,
0.0299829207,
-0.0252799932,
-0.0133147454,
-0.004395667,
0.0705139413,
0.0124522336,
0.0091176117,
-0.0129257385,
0.0022928442,
-0.0102048228,
-0.0167628825,
-0.0142961768,
-0.0672895834,
-0.0109589612,
-0.0144094592,
0.0306853466,
-0.0433603302,
-0.0142963855,
-0.0246223975,
0.0434928238,
0.0411771573,
-0.0105045224,
-0.0253827702,
-0.0394288376,
0.0361399278,
-0.0032595317,
0.0050524306,
0.0247097798,
-0.0400417,
-0.0040543969,
0.0448373929,
-0.0155794555,
0.0110174315,
-0.0049279719,
-0.0214016177,
-0.017863458,
-0.0389398411,
-0.0223231614,
0.0024487961,
0.0315413401,
-0.0462484621,
0.0393770263,
0.0953055471,
0.0242658481,
-0.0155772464,
-0.0092113316,
-0.0206082053,
-0.0323491879,
-0.0107028205,
-0.0025674661,
-0.0897487178,
-0.0158029404,
-0.0057468885,
0.0229835622,
-0.0502010472,
-0.0079567302,
-0.015819218,
-0.0184303895,
0.0328679867,
-0.0112809381,
-0.0326427408,
0.0064634816,
-0.0622971617,
-0.0461590625,
0.0086684702,
-0.0554430299,
-0.0124471188,
0.0000431075,
0.015269327,
0.011551911,
-0.0305318981,
-0.009217551,
-0.0128740426,
-0.026437046,
-0.0024109096,
0.0447525606,
0.0732371956,
-0.0125126867,
-0.0277954098,
-0.0001537578,
0.0025654049,
0.0210904609,
-0.0120093683,
0.1078340635,
-0.0122981668,
0.0150460927,
-0.0617817268,
0.0384096541,
-0.0129319662,
0.0044663344,
0.0041017919,
0.0476278923,
-0.0223009512,
-0.0186901782,
0.0040380801,
-0.0100937458,
0.0083356071,
0.0530721135,
0.0312889852,
-0.0273844432,
-0.0652084574,
-0.0414066836,
0.039897684,
-0.0527164713,
-0.0039151739,
-0.0409954935,
-0.0306015685,
-0.0516276248,
-0.0731678009,
-0.0354263224,
-0.0452315807,
-0.0092362603,
0.0165960435,
0.0284442473,
-0.0056156814,
-0.0026017758,
-0.0387772657,
-0.0297581572,
0.0001590401,
0.0386524387,
-0.0328182615,
0.0012253878,
0.0143843293,
-0.0470036305,
0.0083358884,
-0.0024097501,
-0.0211019907,
-0.0070443107,
-0.0317420922,
-0.0128806513,
0.0259940941,
-0.0059307762,
-0.007361359,
-0.0839981586,
0.0604890361,
0.0610539839,
-0.0241510943,
-0.0013009404,
0.0427075624,
0.0181588139,
-0.0221472699,
0.0235934742,
-0.0154611552,
0.0135565102,
-0.0101473499,
-0.0677522346,
-0.087605983,
0.0007168183,
-0.0099310949,
0.014927974,
0.0151609806,
-0.0292742327,
0.0077712853,
-0.0271268636,
0.000646067,
-0.0049736626,
-0.0037709046,
-0.0219051074,
0.0151599916,
0.0056119575,
-0.0304847937,
-0.0090053556,
0.0215630699,
-0.0240593869,
0.0304087009,
-0.0030719473,
0.0468457527,
0.0001652272,
0.103869915,
-0.0339703523,
0.015374315,
-0.0025268942,
0.032562796,
0.0096861683,
0.0485812947,
0.0172997303,
0.0593813658,
0.0001262824,
-0.0029474855,
0.0239204299,
0.0342067927,
-0.0744241774,
-0.0126236547,
-0.0095408205,
-0.009245351,
0.0366699249,
0.0245668497,
0.0659283102,
-0.0163375046,
-0.0128724594,
-0.0054692402,
0.0610215366,
0.0112467855,
-0.0106283482,
-0.0602219589,
-0.0020554655,
-0.0505610295,
0.0014785385,
0.0799996108,
0.0458959751,
-0.0107957935,
-0.0068826317,
-0.0672427192,
-0.0339110345,
-0.0173174776,
-0.0006828966,
0.0250015743,
0.021868987,
-0.0129313907,
-0.0402643941,
-0.0308939684,
0.0473994911,
-0.0210445616,
0.0340087488,
-0.0168314837,
-0.0199765265,
0.0700911954,
-0.0057606413,
-0.0179389212,
-0.0737942681,
0.0256576799,
-0.0105256299,
-0.005342613,
-0.0297590606,
-5.51005777e-33,
0.0143587273,
-0.1332232952,
-0.0285561848,
0.003364519,
0.0211748797,
0.0401591919,
-0.0467106029,
-0.019722119,
-0.0003534697,
0.026249731,
-0.0121159004,
0.0211599153,
0.0092207883,
-0.0047823079,
-0.0152996844,
-0.0286666937,
0.0334245637,
-0.002785902,
-0.0382763706,
0.0406199358,
0.0613357387,
0.008412201,
0.0105278715,
-0.1336231232,
0.0822141767,
-0.0270919465,
-0.0651212558,
-0.0291728973,
-0.0475225709,
0.0581179745,
0.0024853107,
0.0262087248,
0.0443685614,
0.0148294587,
0.0023055181,
0.0460068062,
-0.0435642339,
-0.0274158791,
-0.0053874748,
0.0254827179,
-0.0062037506,
-0.0871529877,
0.0383323021,
-0.0528095812,
-0.0153139168,
0.0234705824,
0.0881151482,
-0.0190529935,
0.0000347651,
-0.0635944232,
-0.0352069065,
0.0242665298,
-0.0107499836,
-0.0096534621,
0.046950832,
0.0436564498,
0.0258853026,
0.0107879704,
-0.0857201889,
0.0131592741,
0.013410423,
-0.0270733964,
0.0334772468,
-0.0055816895,
-0.0404062159,
0.042922385,
0.0489174649,
0.0168061312,
-0.0453355014,
0.0046841879,
-0.0236749407,
0.0502787009,
0.1074154899,
0.0833490416,
0.0345532894,
-0.0120300353,
-0.0463937148,
0.0520804562,
-0.0038055987,
-0.0333119296,
0.0396388881,
-0.0067905476,
-0.0706325099,
-0.0181906801,
0.0087123839,
-0.0678968504,
-0.0527313091,
-0.0064002974,
0.0013719162,
-0.026494991,
-0.0506158471,
-0.0153022772,
0.0052515757,
-0.0633776411,
-0.0188082289,
0.0058332961,
-0.0220020954,
0.0411332473,
0.0115597034,
-0.0301818661,
-0.0063391649,
-0.0154650491,
0.0231778938,
0.0178834442,
0.0436265878,
-0.0000336828,
0.0707356557,
0.0212778989,
-0.0419764481,
0.0102707995,
-0.0110500464,
-0.0175426472,
0.0038221634,
0.0119817099,
0.0092741922,
-0.0193633903,
-0.0033933993,
-0.0031583877,
0.0233180951,
0.0258550923,
-0.0268048067,
-0.0316416956,
-0.0664546192,
0.0044117766,
-0.0200234596,
-0.0099738631,
0.0031167846,
0.0124637559,
0.0267291609,
-0.0631069839,
0.0156171871,
-0.0399211198,
2.472e-7,
0.0346620828,
0.0303372648,
0.0401892103,
-0.0481389165,
0.0435966291,
0.0634961724,
0.0573908091,
0.0006119948,
-0.034920305,
0.0050699976,
0.0256358683,
0.0073444545,
0.0737670437,
0.0125981681,
-0.0212574378,
-0.0145744793,
-0.0483648703,
0.0062740743,
-0.0741443187,
0.0467525274,
0.1197619215,
0.0040701134,
0.0331401005,
-0.0380031727,
0.0091977725,
-0.0699991807,
0.0200476404,
-0.011619769,
0.0568310283,
0.0123184239,
0.0552088395,
-0.0112781553,
0.0099658845,
0.0257500373,
-0.0277943891,
-0.0330835357,
-0.0139423097,
0.0663847476,
0.0147109404,
0.0081693307,
0.0111441668,
-0.0313477367,
0.0344434381,
-0.0413748026,
0.0576459654,
0.056469962,
-0.0302299336,
0.0208097566,
-0.0170498993,
-0.0807809532,
0.0139838904,
-0.0183297992,
-0.0074510789,
0.0255645569,
-0.01613703,
-0.0161448568,
-0.0065006241,
-0.0573456995,
-0.0210841373,
-0.0315462798,
-0.0215602256,
0.0006281431,
-0.0573193505,
0.0171872675,
0.0732513368,
-0.0646611005,
0.024036739,
2.363365601e-34,
0.005946605,
-0.0176515765,
-0.0094666909,
0.013635735,
0.0503650717,
0.0543819182,
-0.0045336643,
0.023822898,
0.0405566096,
0.0006763948,
0.0357709453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18256v1 | LLaMIPa: An Incremental Discourse Parser | 2024-06-26T11:08:17 | 2024-06-26T11:08:17 | Kate Thompson, Akshay Chaturvedi, Julie Hunter, Nicholas Asher | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper provides the first discourse parsing experiments with a large
language model (LLM) finetuned on corpora annotated in the style of SDRT
(Asher, 1993; Asher and Lascarides, 2003). The result is a discourse parser,
LLaMIPa (LLaMA Incremental Parser), which is able to more fully exploit
discourse context, leading to substantial performance gains over approaches
that use encoder-only models to provide local, context-sensitive
representations of discourse units. Furthermore, it is able to process
discourse data incrementally, which is essential for the eventual use of
discourse information in downstream tasks. | [
0.0079549747,
0.0531854518,
-0.005805294,
0.0312752053,
-0.0148743419,
0.0125829382,
-0.0011739734,
-0.0425986275,
-0.0483858474,
-0.0710578561,
0.0026928778,
0.0089596855,
0.0017258727,
0.0371309593,
-0.0053191488,
-0.0313572139,
0.0335578024,
-0.0436487533,
0.0532787256,
-0.0132677145,
0.0045493813,
-0.0097870091,
-0.0102357781,
0.0253067929,
-0.0001379158,
-0.0485359393,
-0.0171019733,
-0.0256143529,
0.0079791574,
-0.0407926254,
0.0428437553,
0.0066419858,
0.0389793478,
0.010654727,
0.0000021325,
-0.0275331065,
-0.0139750233,
-0.0167811271,
-0.0386389978,
0.0251728613,
0.0355904587,
-0.0198513977,
-0.0187545661,
-0.0000137866,
-0.0343746133,
-0.004671705,
-0.0135032898,
0.0507621467,
0.0611227043,
0.0475203581,
-0.0220170245,
-0.0739397183,
0.0376029946,
0.0012677722,
-0.1042219624,
-0.0417152718,
0.0106928283,
0.0580374822,
-0.0000564328,
0.0708277747,
-0.0032723052,
0.0528530069,
0.0173053946,
-0.0062758313,
0.0197920091,
0.0321460962,
-0.0002447532,
0.0187380873,
-0.0229407437,
0.0277835336,
0.0457630642,
0.0021927159,
0.0002387796,
0.0189667027,
-0.0224462226,
-0.0260471888,
-0.0438733473,
0.0230619796,
-0.0409770198,
0.0652645454,
0.0528737456,
-0.0077282223,
-0.0184061211,
0.0010589551,
0.0011200977,
0.060342703,
-0.0181623846,
-0.0269887056,
0.0040590675,
0.0164662581,
-0.03556104,
-0.048034437,
0.0538307577,
0.0515789427,
-0.0265384223,
0.0028833221,
-0.0111501869,
-0.0075322138,
0.0352858603,
-0.1141994894,
0.0378168412,
0.0339611843,
-0.0270147528,
0.0308592487,
0.004013902,
0.0664573237,
-0.0489085689,
-0.0513582341,
-0.0229634549,
-0.0205498356,
-0.043507129,
-0.0429405086,
-0.037675295,
0.0618661456,
-0.1366886199,
-0.0301217902,
-0.026950581,
0.0570407324,
0.0299550164,
0.0158274546,
0.0201884136,
-0.0160838123,
-0.0259450376,
0.0498742908,
-0.0343204997,
0.0481918827,
-0.0429954156,
0.0311084837,
-0.0208669621,
-0.0382404812,
-0.0289235767,
0.0135829635,
0.0036927795,
-0.0206198376,
-0.0320422351,
0.0395548716,
-0.0251679551,
-0.0208793394,
-0.011143514,
-0.0240629986,
0.0030219592,
-0.0238350928,
0.0155501273,
-0.0635829866,
0.0017872547,
0.003948132,
0.0257620234,
-0.0367383361,
0.0106848134,
0.0277489386,
0.0023606601,
0.0373877101,
-0.0076812692,
0.0020145685,
0.0733640343,
-0.0221128389,
0.0435681082,
0.0865108296,
0.0437131934,
-0.0123477988,
-0.0023612969,
0.0213357825,
-0.0392544493,
0.0381166823,
-0.0290712602,
-0.0154263712,
-0.0193891264,
0.0358395837,
-0.0246281307,
0.015628472,
0.0588004105,
0.0606306382,
-0.0422441773,
-0.0111135533,
0.0083610173,
0.0527081341,
-0.06360659,
-0.0172495842,
0.0370852761,
0.0282205082,
0.0008208105,
0.0233123656,
-0.0007484334,
-0.0018710616,
0.0299653336,
-0.0204225332,
-0.0020268168,
-0.0038128777,
0.0031564368,
-0.0339833051,
0.0119843017,
-0.0094893659,
0.012254444,
-0.0348717012,
0.032865338,
0.0141491434,
-0.0315555483,
0.0399423763,
0.0523582585,
-0.0168274883,
-0.0412533805,
-0.0406262949,
0.0082509546,
0.0306781456,
0.0413739868,
-0.0329168513,
-0.0365386717,
-0.0372019336,
0.0539059378,
0.0656762868,
-0.02363085,
-0.0263012759,
-0.0177925043,
-0.0282305274,
-0.0129631143,
-0.0434461385,
0.0271697026,
0.0335912742,
-0.0277316459,
-0.0163358096,
-0.0104915565,
0.0439110845,
-0.0050591738,
0.0195132419,
-0.035956677,
-0.0081536286,
-0.015675988,
-0.0234432779,
0.0496420749,
0.0274665561,
-0.0094936043,
-0.0096530691,
0.0398346297,
-0.065151833,
0.0145235965,
0.0372580066,
-0.0575876348,
-0.0520494245,
0.0350904576,
-0.0152525427,
-0.0296321865,
-0.0317082405,
-0.0218719523,
-0.0329802185,
0.0099780513,
-0.057591971,
0.0216446444,
-0.0279655755,
-0.0011226172,
-0.0057341657,
0.0019432496,
-0.0214509685,
0.0660094991,
-0.0214022808,
-0.0087703979,
0.0440207124,
-0.0194842014,
-0.0018290106,
-0.0436026156,
-0.0094232904,
0.0262331925,
0.0341425203,
-0.0394416451,
0.0173459891,
-0.0129479626,
-0.0020028555,
-0.0337901004,
-0.1279220432,
-0.0061274711,
-0.0280804615,
0.0577967949,
0.0276806429,
-0.0055426611,
-0.0016328408,
-0.0082594696,
0.0241751373,
-0.057098832,
-0.0062311417,
0.0257779565,
0.0444815755,
0.0042091706,
0.0034435946,
-0.0449355021,
-0.0040284381,
-0.0199324358,
0.0452376902,
0.0085996315,
-0.0567456447,
-0.0660937056,
-0.0085233003,
-0.0062772091,
0.0068753054,
-0.0173662566,
-0.04168237,
0.0354856886,
0.0327182449,
0.0852515623,
0.0383431651,
-0.0052559492,
0.0878040045,
0.0056071375,
-0.0563538671,
-0.0408628471,
0.0285901874,
0.0128113916,
0.022310324,
-0.0837629437,
0.0058415444,
-0.0037343528,
0.0978593752,
-0.0058753598,
0.0437862128,
-0.0039800773,
0.0276884586,
-0.0497807823,
-0.0194533505,
-0.0006276214,
-0.0552156195,
-0.0333613493,
0.0114610884,
-0.0164298415,
0.0261931438,
0.0323252566,
-0.0506916195,
-0.0112142572,
-0.043068707,
-0.0004057936,
-0.0281907674,
0.0541581064,
0.0048791394,
-0.0122363605,
-0.019215174,
-0.0651143268,
0.0296768863,
0.0098498426,
-0.0050794897,
-0.0278335623,
0.0689181238,
-0.0769194439,
0.0235202219,
-0.0091393329,
-0.0422925465,
-0.0368394032,
-0.0645492673,
-0.0299104266,
0.0478624776,
-0.0319091752,
0.0318277292,
-0.0232756957,
0.01382815,
-0.0268709734,
0.0493403636,
-0.0213592183,
0.0108021786,
-0.0674963519,
0.05667964,
0.0247251838,
0.016631579,
-0.0084221317,
-0.0019637216,
0.0335437283,
0.0507719852,
-0.0483873822,
-0.0197360925,
-0.0370338894,
0.0019701689,
-0.0263995733,
-0.0323357619,
-0.0307626054,
-0.053678114,
0.0897916853,
-0.0583808646,
-0.0439272784,
0.1265826374,
0.0208150242,
-0.0087284176,
-0.0084681511,
-0.0453200005,
0.0038628364,
0.025609266,
0.0073916637,
-0.059863098,
-0.011740528,
0.0252485145,
0.0017857209,
-0.017183654,
-0.0488543659,
0.0281252563,
-0.0541040972,
0.0188250169,
-0.0100141605,
0.0379692577,
0.0279585477,
-0.0573001802,
0.0004985112,
0.0006609629,
0.0454979241,
0.0251044184,
-0.0231386758,
0.0169523116,
0.0280277636,
0.0143429041,
-0.0292625017,
-0.0003060659,
-0.0025810727,
0.0450747721,
0.0302785374,
0.0498189218,
-0.010675244,
0.0164305754,
0.0642798916,
-0.0426393971,
-0.0029761896,
-0.0087266034,
-0.0203130562,
0.0132077262,
-0.0140138008,
-0.015257081,
0.0201862715,
-0.0283256061,
-0.0031109434,
0.0300033297,
0.0378091112,
-0.0537046418,
0.0451156944,
-0.0123293269,
-0.0250030272,
-0.0168929435,
0.0285194293,
0.0511897616,
-0.0001179534,
-0.0369498581,
-0.0455020182,
-0.0195475519,
0.0103965094,
0.025592057,
-0.0158156808,
0.0323874019,
0.0215735883,
-0.0559792854,
-0.0497587547,
0.0081694424,
-0.025015017,
-0.004780726,
0.0042605936,
0.0624861792,
-0.021104278,
-0.0530440584,
-0.0083269803,
-0.0223140344,
-0.0067043751,
-0.0389671884,
-0.0118783237,
0.0852316543,
0.014965958,
-0.0453677624,
0.0008754531,
-0.0462219641,
-0.0467073545,
0.0067476216,
0.038709335,
0.0160806607,
0.0325857326,
-0.0304712802,
-0.0159753915,
0.0373927839,
0.024018243,
-0.0383979492,
0.0611029677,
0.0052852705,
0.0444234349,
0.0046578436,
0.0176872052,
0.0214629527,
0.0429407097,
-0.0526410304,
0.0437305979,
-0.0395169184,
-0.0181607325,
0.0199431162,
-0.0078536086,
0.0569397099,
0.0248435587,
0.0160025321,
-0.0187830366,
0.0314671025,
-0.0554966293,
0.002958592,
-0.0326414891,
0.0274668038,
-0.0127905337,
-0.0221030451,
-0.0227258839,
0.0013651168,
-0.0175745785,
0.0474953018,
-0.0456535406,
0.0441698954,
0.0150233572,
-0.0038385722,
-0.0144875422,
0.0053525083,
-0.0238242839,
0.0243744738,
0.0048530721,
0.0426641516,
-0.0369210206,
0.0398047604,
0.0034689603,
0.0241936687,
-0.008968859,
0.0276278052,
-0.0308615752,
0.0346818864,
0.0188057106,
0.0199795067,
0.0489696041,
0.0039754901,
0.0913854018,
0.0096903276,
0.0181552116,
-0.0216878746,
0.0560420454,
0.0011192142,
-0.0411476903,
0.0308138337,
0.0122400736,
-0.0317954905,
-0.0025206159,
0.0585012138,
-0.0388556421,
0.0424525701,
0.0336988531,
0.015644962,
-0.0490935892,
-0.0889131352,
-0.0613954663,
0.0094006322,
0.0132883759,
0.0262730084,
0.0179624148,
0.0016066043,
0.0421950072,
-0.0163844787,
-0.0250804946,
-0.0486070998,
0.0348596685,
0.0265503433,
-0.008619424,
-0.0307590961,
-0.0344497934,
0.0198910609,
-0.0148684885,
-0.0232539549,
-0.0248416848,
-6.428089471e-33,
-0.0921708047,
-0.0138123203,
0.0434863344,
0.0299895983,
-0.0498028845,
0.0177557878,
-0.0774706081,
-0.0040855678,
0.0353588946,
0.0353767797,
-0.0187993478,
0.018913677,
0.0221617334,
0.0181244891,
0.0300010499,
-0.0248500295,
0.0769639164,
-0.0020877286,
0.0138371764,
0.0109818587,
0.0938069597,
0.0366147533,
0.0577723086,
-0.0354431719,
-0.010955167,
-0.0083310492,
0.0077119195,
0.0297866687,
0.0261374842,
0.0548487008,
-0.0257543102,
0.0059971414,
0.0347653739,
0.0071330434,
-0.016081715,
0.0262054112,
-0.1007430777,
-0.0054675024,
0.0286747757,
0.030102035,
-0.0194166563,
-0.0588635094,
0.0370186567,
0.0206184424,
-0.0128879007,
0.0302069373,
0.0283336677,
-0.0328180678,
-0.0134694763,
-0.0158156194,
-0.0610534213,
0.0239104405,
-0.0211219881,
0.0037464101,
0.0367203727,
0.0090657799,
0.0165862218,
-0.0487040915,
-0.0302502532,
-0.0155847501,
-0.0046135643,
0.034426406,
-0.0124376034,
-0.0246135779,
0.0280207675,
0.0618986189,
-0.0303025674,
-0.0507040322,
-0.0599128082,
0.0279845446,
-0.0002122155,
-0.0022870344,
-0.0402423367,
-0.0436774492,
-0.0294937138,
-0.0009441054,
-0.052513659,
-0.0295040775,
0.0498504713,
0.0778839216,
0.033344321,
0.0099777197,
0.010519241,
-0.0156557467,
-0.0267869905,
-0.0227799546,
0.0286533479,
-0.0161942896,
0.0116875162,
-0.0134283165,
0.0129247559,
0.0118284225,
0.0459622331,
-0.0218608994,
-0.0418441333,
0.0154163502,
0.0079084476,
0.0201689377,
-0.0052497438,
0.0371611826,
-0.0266714431,
-0.0219906159,
-0.0148524642,
-0.0093839122,
0.0208528079,
-0.0053050728,
-0.007676125,
0.0027477432,
-0.0397990458,
0.0167504717,
-0.044394996,
0.03572198,
-0.0497826077,
0.1057868898,
0.0332643352,
0.0225302111,
-0.0096014673,
0.0837438256,
-0.0155381309,
0.000149248,
-0.0521342345,
0.0114111491,
0.0037102401,
0.0474428982,
-0.043814823,
-0.0039147479,
-0.0165032521,
0.0706886575,
-0.0199377313,
-0.0457888134,
0.0106706778,
0.0226143524,
2.645e-7,
0.0198577661,
0.0715401247,
0.0492740199,
-0.0400814451,
0.0669929758,
-0.0294606388,
-0.0027452172,
0.0414138138,
-0.0009877004,
-0.0347427875,
-0.0368661508,
0.0364065319,
0.0153609551,
0.0412677824,
-0.1049301922,
-0.0361446589,
-0.0870374516,
-0.0376564935,
-0.0466327406,
0.0027492649,
0.0426932424,
0.0624516979,
-0.0301596578,
0.0269076321,
-0.0246683564,
0.0146164158,
0.0693687648,
0.022521181,
0.0022833019,
0.040405266,
-0.0231885724,
0.0006003104,
-0.0097700031,
-0.0148031777,
0.0347440429,
0.0466173217,
-0.0179743804,
0.0960770324,
0.0044687656,
-0.002836189,
-0.0014470661,
-0.0016132123,
-0.0004858859,
0.011459331,
0.0354069546,
-0.0532946847,
-0.0429270267,
-0.0101913046,
-0.04205079,
-0.0036771821,
-0.0080667296,
0.0209334865,
0.0100511545,
0.0310156029,
0.0069981036,
-0.032294482,
-0.022209201,
-0.0714653656,
0.0054064575,
-0.0089021856,
-0.0728616714,
-0.0143425995,
-0.0149774719,
-0.0045747622,
0.0028571456,
-0.0285339933,
0.0007072755,
2.012054421e-34,
0.049724821,
0.0069713765,
-0.003175939,
0.0768955573,
0.0150113255,
0.0021400554,
0.0140767731,
0.0382206254,
-0.0141224843,
-0.1003911048,
0.0124165323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18245v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18245v2 | Weak Reward Model Transforms Generative Models into Robust Causal Event Extraction Systems | 2024-06-26T10:48:14 | 2024-06-27T10:19:55 | Italo Luis da Silva, Hanqi Yan, Lin Gui, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL | The inherent ambiguity of cause and effect boundaries poses a challenge in
evaluating causal event extraction tasks. Traditional metrics like Exact Match
and BertScore poorly reflect model performance, so we trained evaluation models
to approximate human evaluation, achieving high agreement. We used them to
perform Reinforcement Learning with extraction models to align them with human
preference, prioritising semantic understanding. We successfully explored our
approach through multiple datasets, including transferring an evaluator trained
on one dataset to another as a way to decrease the reliance on human-annotated
data. In that vein, we also propose a weak-to-strong supervision method that
uses a fraction of the annotated data to train an evaluation model while still
achieving high performance in training an RL model. Our code is available at
https://github.com/oyarsa/event_extraction/tree/causal-event-extraction. | [
0.000989867,
0.0835861191,
0.0126949931,
0.0283023417,
-0.0146009736,
0.0447953567,
-0.0206507146,
-0.0110983085,
-0.00935762,
-0.0004820871,
0.0096464464,
0.0382750221,
-0.0625306219,
0.017853478,
-0.0115771964,
-0.0833470449,
0.0490502678,
-0.0083851349,
0.0465780646,
0.0340333171,
-0.0010662529,
-0.0220608916,
-0.0107587744,
0.0167630631,
-0.0223541576,
0.0078875432,
-0.0004337276,
-0.0088803265,
0.0518591553,
-0.0385179557,
-0.0083701294,
0.0178204626,
0.0176691972,
0.0411739871,
0.0000019821,
-0.0159486402,
-0.0345233269,
0.0179952923,
0.0142102893,
-0.0418714806,
-0.0269253887,
-0.0077452781,
0.0057941806,
-0.0247710701,
-0.0209829472,
-0.0425975621,
0.0277183913,
0.0804798305,
0.0262935665,
0.0900327042,
-0.0163714401,
-0.0430403985,
0.0009350037,
-0.0418819338,
0.0478885099,
-0.0590116344,
0.0318630263,
0.0019275374,
0.0139428126,
-0.0556134507,
-0.0377639346,
-0.0048211627,
0.0369406454,
-0.0135425879,
0.0234199408,
0.0324930958,
0.002035789,
-0.020625202,
0.0021290695,
0.0692452043,
0.021668924,
0.0094176931,
0.0567146316,
-0.0210571289,
0.0246462002,
0.0207842644,
-0.0370136648,
0.0114761638,
-0.0173229259,
0.0095605357,
0.0141635211,
0.0370778441,
0.0229303744,
0.0188331604,
-0.0002944077,
0.0473402999,
0.0084299641,
-0.0406116061,
-0.0247954745,
0.0311656799,
-0.0063473447,
-0.0266769342,
-0.0081965346,
0.0153927254,
-0.054962948,
0.0160797462,
-0.0167729333,
-0.000384863,
-0.0196285807,
-0.0409044661,
-0.0048516612,
-0.0048581725,
-0.0391814969,
0.0771690756,
-0.019386068,
0.0435352139,
0.0014390915,
0.0806255043,
0.0120432451,
0.0049730418,
-0.0517404154,
0.0319293849,
0.0034097331,
0.0052240775,
-0.0205329638,
0.0031878892,
-0.0482111871,
0.0048440564,
-0.0509403907,
0.0034064134,
-0.0059298901,
0.0317299813,
-0.0506573878,
0.0376281254,
-0.0318879634,
0.0032164303,
-0.0865943804,
0.0357746892,
0.028125111,
-0.0205683634,
-0.0200152546,
0.0127552031,
0.0381639041,
-0.0358738042,
0.0007880534,
0.0754554793,
0.0099384012,
-0.0264603104,
-0.0582683347,
-0.0371411517,
0.0009573028,
-0.0283696372,
-0.0103475144,
-0.0361272097,
0.0111911427,
-0.0274810493,
0.0040956591,
-0.03668084,
0.0061667003,
-0.047963351,
-0.0362368487,
0.0509201922,
0.0097392285,
-0.0111411856,
-0.0183545817,
-0.0076491316,
-0.026671933,
0.0338330157,
0.0390234143,
0.0710801855,
0.0217497181,
0.0322269946,
0.0089366417,
-0.0069137379,
0.0289713852,
-0.0083567714,
-0.0059037339,
-0.029577354,
-0.0209125429,
0.003749033,
0.0584431142,
-0.0008386701,
-0.0433796868,
0.0295778606,
0.037258599,
-0.0162987951,
0.0003488672,
-0.0286895614,
0.0640340149,
-0.0319293141,
-0.0196998063,
0.025879791,
-0.0430548862,
0.0251346435,
0.0099676894,
-0.000656264,
-0.012951727,
-0.0382037871,
-0.005764008,
-0.0474985205,
0.0315867364,
-0.0054429332,
-0.017203493,
0.0282880943,
0.0935371667,
0.0164435562,
-0.0220351685,
-0.0212606844,
0.0357097834,
-0.0251139197,
0.0255271513,
-0.0357850939,
0.0814236253,
0.0561237261,
0.0441939756,
-0.0467112958,
-0.0055258796,
-0.0117631173,
-0.013982567,
-0.0157045331,
0.0033417949,
-0.0571821071,
0.0154095758,
0.0039479509,
-0.0704782307,
0.003370058,
0.0254895631,
0.0299737249,
0.0340760574,
-0.0409308188,
-0.0130088562,
0.0141242174,
-0.0248704702,
0.0452711359,
0.0056862873,
-0.0509123802,
-0.0273234546,
0.0235859174,
0.0592334792,
-0.0044342219,
-0.0419990942,
-0.0017307359,
0.0331543945,
-0.028183246,
-0.0376884826,
0.0524571054,
-0.0234584399,
-0.0310738292,
-0.0098466724,
-0.0519931838,
-0.0472060964,
0.0358251855,
-0.0614550337,
-0.0485567003,
0.0160956029,
0.0062893094,
0.0033351406,
-0.0336814187,
-0.0139146643,
0.0140443007,
-0.0531646498,
-0.0509073995,
0.0895522386,
0.0154417893,
0.0091095585,
-0.0137177054,
0.0139856655,
0.0051521058,
-0.0492647402,
-0.0193391293,
-0.0017748997,
-0.0246015918,
-0.0203487221,
0.0728567466,
0.0026471736,
-0.0538237169,
-0.0182970203,
-0.0374164395,
0.004958204,
-0.0203984808,
0.0197748821,
0.021488281,
0.0163286608,
-0.0156870876,
-0.0194427371,
-0.005023038,
-0.0587830879,
-0.0139590697,
0.0048302943,
0.0206686445,
0.0367243215,
0.0190581307,
-0.0623294748,
0.0169398077,
-0.0269832239,
0.0357069634,
0.0703968629,
-0.0127708428,
-0.0116391582,
-0.0077598738,
0.0121110296,
0.0172906145,
-0.0128417984,
-0.0189892873,
0.0126365405,
-0.0381026827,
0.0246145912,
0.0848238543,
-0.0097593572,
0.0785177127,
0.0050913319,
-0.0429535098,
-0.0620697588,
0.013850362,
-0.0599276274,
0.008344261,
-0.0144135626,
0.0020203062,
0.0056362534,
0.0737986192,
-0.0028274788,
0.0165276639,
-0.0582965799,
-0.0115608443,
-0.0189806167,
-0.0531775244,
-0.0207102783,
0.0031518983,
-0.0360756181,
0.0152192265,
-0.0698096156,
-0.0436671749,
0.0794360265,
0.0380286127,
0.0028855565,
-0.0156900641,
0.0203484707,
-0.0323676653,
0.0593107417,
0.0170610715,
0.0087508392,
-0.0067893267,
-0.0272562727,
-0.037102364,
-0.0229006745,
0.0480031669,
0.015275239,
-0.006766804,
-0.0588458627,
0.0331610702,
0.0000660718,
-0.0324447416,
-0.063868545,
-0.0432644673,
0.0331734605,
0.0150391236,
-0.0052008391,
-0.0057598599,
-0.0389134958,
-0.0092805913,
0.0316135623,
0.0445756428,
-0.0327994525,
-0.0063783717,
-0.0214090534,
0.0093544936,
0.0684862509,
-0.0689129978,
-0.0284724534,
-0.042806074,
-0.0031993666,
0.0318218097,
0.0603683293,
0.0051062373,
-0.0432644412,
0.0397667997,
-0.0231974125,
-0.0400452204,
0.0398965925,
0.0256125871,
0.0315164514,
-0.0528176725,
-0.0250757523,
0.0805540606,
0.0120722139,
-0.0122185722,
-0.0016894897,
0.0122337267,
0.0118666077,
0.0248376261,
0.0113857221,
-0.0553980321,
-0.0233813152,
-0.0129637625,
0.055931624,
-0.0013335857,
-0.0517501719,
0.0600430407,
-0.076075606,
0.0421913229,
-0.0147807691,
-0.0611787662,
-0.0182819664,
-0.0359921232,
0.0310361832,
-0.052925121,
-0.0659006909,
0.0090338131,
0.0162004214,
0.0166024324,
0.0393649116,
0.0123667037,
-0.0711109266,
0.0319418609,
-0.0522965565,
0.0176307503,
0.1036812291,
0.0144664077,
-0.0078919809,
-0.0092029776,
-0.0080987075,
0.0167320203,
-0.0254166257,
0.0159117188,
0.0656473264,
0.0035772899,
-0.0175734926,
-0.0095486324,
0.0729049742,
0.0270117614,
-0.0264399182,
-0.0018336478,
0.0800908506,
-0.0204835963,
-0.0040094219,
-0.0031566618,
-0.036634624,
0.0185678322,
0.0619023815,
0.027851345,
-0.02297608,
-0.0634424686,
0.0261679832,
-0.0163677279,
-0.0849672556,
-0.0208093412,
-0.0188990086,
-0.0411897451,
-0.0823352486,
-0.0780683383,
-0.0737140924,
0.0134885553,
0.0345784537,
-0.0218581576,
-0.0289263055,
0.0133906873,
0.0049778284,
-0.0264863577,
0.0842229873,
-0.0266314298,
-0.0006021936,
-0.0273456499,
-0.0370562449,
0.0006739083,
0.0113723613,
-0.0371770114,
0.0570378266,
-0.03249285,
-0.0135823116,
0.0126962438,
0.0557617433,
0.0164812896,
0.0849517658,
-0.0259450469,
-0.0153303659,
-0.0049409685,
-0.0006691919,
-0.0267429985,
-0.0248289183,
0.0376959741,
-0.0196424853,
-0.0184290856,
0.0050367331,
-0.0602339767,
0.0572389513,
0.0160245392,
0.0393254198,
-0.0303945225,
0.0389806218,
0.041168917,
-0.0272501651,
0.0933844075,
-0.0369789973,
-0.0362194665,
-0.0631863996,
-0.0366724022,
-0.0058972356,
-0.0186311789,
-0.0440037772,
0.025544893,
0.0138524529,
0.034872815,
-0.0216560513,
-0.0247480348,
-0.0087071927,
0.0444121808,
-0.095806174,
0.0245027747,
0.0675185993,
0.021242138,
-0.0277885031,
0.0184261911,
0.0070914282,
-0.0061208573,
0.0206175726,
0.0343306884,
-0.0114369355,
0.0345786512,
0.0526733436,
0.043845512,
0.0262494441,
-0.0333951302,
-0.0911419988,
0.0475676022,
-0.0153396446,
0.0226722676,
0.0703055784,
-0.0240229294,
0.0244900882,
-0.0127375415,
0.0024801705,
0.0042083431,
0.031512145,
0.0138114691,
0.0101687424,
0.02152065,
0.0368539169,
0.002181089,
-0.0226599667,
0.040500138,
0.0031887321,
0.0805201754,
-0.0633456334,
-0.0268639214,
-0.0340895988,
-0.0497126803,
0.0433867015,
-0.005722939,
-0.0296764318,
-0.0214356445,
-0.042572286,
-0.0095507065,
-0.0142203709,
0.0231899526,
0.0181277972,
0.0109044863,
0.0475085489,
0.0297423378,
-0.0351883098,
-0.0189484078,
-0.0455607064,
0.0000833692,
0.012725166,
-0.0331963189,
-0.0211494174,
-6.272264471e-33,
-0.0416088253,
-0.0131509323,
0.0176612623,
0.0083780792,
-0.0049416493,
0.0177339464,
-0.0578584149,
-0.0376759842,
0.0204199236,
0.0434481986,
0.022523623,
-0.0005836322,
0.0208631065,
0.004113425,
0.0504300259,
-0.0284848064,
0.050975088,
0.0114770057,
-0.0091189342,
0.0390438698,
0.06561248,
0.0323897935,
0.0165985227,
-0.1279201061,
0.0550147705,
0.0145769855,
-0.0362313837,
-0.0096945744,
0.016337363,
0.0467668436,
0.0249203779,
-0.0295002218,
0.0123165315,
-0.0844300091,
-0.0098290239,
0.0036990296,
-0.1368454546,
-0.0077325087,
0.0194522142,
-0.0105891926,
-0.0599808171,
-0.0309473611,
0.0246467739,
-0.001418842,
0.0290772542,
0.012393726,
0.0568092912,
-0.0289666019,
-0.0037290656,
-0.0734231621,
-0.0696094036,
0.0418114029,
-0.0181662515,
-0.0122233946,
0.0269817803,
0.0081007099,
0.0137171736,
0.0359391607,
0.023783965,
-0.0081308903,
0.0118717663,
0.0094598485,
0.0333149433,
0.0618737377,
-0.0159464125,
0.0634470955,
-0.0363728814,
-0.0327782333,
0.0013232721,
0.0017295711,
-0.0154085075,
0.0978671238,
0.0230036397,
0.0339221954,
0.0164232999,
0.0521200523,
-0.1002889201,
0.0607745536,
0.0098938961,
0.043996688,
-0.0060236771,
0.0256731808,
-0.0352809988,
0.0209541451,
-0.0265335198,
-0.0104396055,
-0.0164681915,
0.0045828847,
0.0429087356,
0.0376736932,
-0.0101009719,
0.032210052,
0.0294994712,
-0.0262202471,
0.0209910329,
0.0161581207,
-0.0272296276,
0.0184773095,
-0.0197727997,
-0.036522951,
-0.046098154,
-0.0283664409,
0.0489252508,
0.0035352956,
0.0444505699,
0.0214148648,
0.0604865886,
0.0002466714,
-0.0039675119,
0.0079548424,
-0.0378603451,
-0.0017123182,
-0.0267728083,
-0.0089019407,
0.0216697548,
0.0167286266,
-0.0282557271,
0.0367707424,
0.0132756243,
0.061650034,
0.0181031823,
-0.04459396,
-0.0105402106,
0.0120425131,
-0.0245025102,
-0.018207714,
-0.0060758493,
0.0259871781,
-0.0248981249,
-0.0311904158,
0.0173918959,
0.0031340665,
2.681e-7,
0.0197222438,
0.0099701416,
0.0604605004,
0.0153716141,
0.0103324531,
0.0187695529,
-0.0083129155,
0.0247208849,
-0.0071569956,
0.0291814338,
0.0419766866,
0.0073887063,
0.0389305241,
0.0014490624,
-0.0539968573,
-0.0317836851,
-0.0789753348,
-0.0264228694,
-0.0393871702,
-0.018037064,
0.0938912481,
0.0660145357,
0.061088413,
0.0049265688,
0.0174628794,
-0.020579638,
0.0443204604,
-0.0125641953,
-0.0110546788,
0.0041779219,
0.0240608659,
-0.0103864269,
-0.0217734333,
0.0198678803,
-0.0263933092,
0.0034293982,
-0.0017921238,
0.0550483651,
-0.0355684571,
-0.006393325,
-0.0252408795,
-0.0011509707,
0.0519414619,
-0.0195997171,
0.0487619638,
-0.0557117537,
-0.015257678,
0.0409879945,
-0.0512926094,
0.0193420276,
-0.0483703613,
0.004900557,
0.0115590794,
0.0128174713,
-0.0068840017,
0.005749892,
-0.0326705538,
-0.0654781535,
-0.0167270042,
0.027120864,
-0.0093806507,
-0.0505767837,
-0.0081897387,
0.029152168,
-0.0075916313,
-0.0791192427,
-0.0379407257,
2.30869065e-34,
0.0141766667,
0.0462714732,
-0.0573712289,
-0.0146835474,
0.0433316454,
0.0085108913,
-0.0477084331,
0.0250075031,
0.018985793,
-0.0130937705,
-0.0069823884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18239v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18239v1 | Zero-shot prompt-based classification: topic labeling in times of foundation models in German Tweets | 2024-06-26T10:44:02 | 2024-06-26T10:44:02 | Simon Münker, Kai Kugler, Achim Rettinger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Filtering and annotating textual data are routine tasks in many areas, like
social media or news analytics. Automating these tasks allows to scale the
analyses wrt. speed and breadth of content covered and decreases the manual
effort required. Due to technical advancements in Natural Language Processing,
specifically the success of large foundation models, a new tool for automating
such annotation processes by using a text-to-text interface given written
guidelines without providing training samples has become available.
In this work, we assess these advancements in-the-wild by empirically testing
them in an annotation task on German Twitter data about social and political
European crises. We compare the prompt-based results with our human annotation
and preceding classification approaches, including Naive Bayes and a BERT-based
fine-tuning/domain adaptation pipeline. Our results show that the prompt-based
approach - despite being limited by local computation resources during the
model selection - is comparable with the fine-tuned BERT but without any
annotated training data. Our findings emphasize the ongoing paradigm shift in
the NLP landscape, i.e., the unification of downstream tasks and elimination of
the need for pre-labeled training data. | [
0.0322010033,
0.0003521301,
0.0186987165,
-0.0183550287,
-0.0318113603,
0.0436610132,
0.0298580825,
-0.0144568458,
0.0105845239,
-0.0912301242,
0.0241908282,
-0.0256491154,
-0.0505229011,
0.0220346879,
-0.0034214028,
-0.0616240948,
0.0431958847,
0.0042798221,
0.0425809473,
0.0103337625,
0.0175891276,
0.0149916392,
-0.0193646569,
0.0248808004,
-0.0112614706,
0.0401548035,
-0.0116264978,
-0.0136710852,
0.0016155328,
-0.0184489843,
0.0147019327,
0.1005994901,
0.0310936309,
0.0523630194,
0.0000016759,
-0.0702909827,
-0.0291432496,
-0.0229851324,
-0.00545032,
-0.0315599255,
0.0425144024,
-0.0373608284,
0.0094429348,
0.0165313855,
-0.0393432193,
-0.0054881661,
0.044883091,
0.0682412162,
0.0584160015,
0.0868527964,
-0.0236037858,
-0.0156324394,
0.0266708005,
-0.0334821977,
0.0024128996,
-0.0490424745,
0.0322558992,
-0.0490480363,
-0.0027376954,
0.0353467464,
0.027625598,
0.0207876619,
-0.016928073,
0.0033718091,
0.0328170545,
0.0233124644,
-0.0345932767,
-0.0579290725,
-0.0192305483,
0.048550874,
0.0301524848,
-0.0406227931,
0.0229552127,
-0.0165310018,
-0.0101503283,
0.0166661087,
-0.0141999265,
0.0299304444,
-0.0265746117,
0.004373868,
0.0616402663,
-0.0189877655,
0.0055788178,
0.0485738143,
0.030093085,
0.0883042291,
-0.0195621904,
-0.0567515157,
0.0489660501,
0.0670660064,
-0.0237061847,
-0.0814109519,
-0.0082084443,
0.0285455175,
-0.0172607526,
0.0058259424,
-0.0515042543,
-0.0438568667,
0.0051570828,
-0.0413467586,
-0.0143655874,
0.0332596414,
-0.0155860074,
0.0708324835,
0.0383090489,
-0.0379137136,
0.010378506,
-0.0221728254,
0.0086401943,
0.0036610826,
-0.0831337273,
0.0344193354,
-0.0590786301,
-0.0011769743,
-0.0223983768,
0.0055393325,
-0.0079257861,
0.0244107749,
0.0194322336,
-0.0131283766,
-0.0304559581,
-0.0447914749,
-0.0561061427,
0.0288407635,
-0.0088210776,
0.0382373445,
-0.0558986701,
0.0048889252,
-0.0156458877,
-0.0188940112,
-0.000434403,
0.0107019348,
0.0220896881,
-0.0271322727,
-0.0037078797,
-0.0091620116,
-0.0273629855,
-0.0499861538,
-0.0603263788,
-0.0030221581,
-0.0017009581,
-0.0059891785,
0.0078785922,
-0.0655469671,
0.0124137579,
0.0343493409,
-0.0199145433,
0.0034161471,
0.0141185122,
0.0185191799,
-0.0619050562,
0.0520479642,
-0.0858002827,
0.0093762223,
0.0574947521,
-0.0233455729,
-0.0322277583,
0.0941870585,
-0.0099961432,
0.0272401981,
0.0655336305,
0.0085796732,
0.0102422237,
0.0447485708,
0.0028904767,
0.0436595865,
-0.001768861,
-0.0027526054,
-0.0208841339,
-0.0064542387,
-0.0102128331,
-0.0215729401,
0.000738909,
0.0401762985,
0.0531802624,
0.0440829955,
0.0081690401,
0.0071366024,
0.0185051579,
0.037331868,
0.0373132043,
-0.0140410718,
-0.0298722424,
-0.0182159729,
-0.0503005348,
0.0029099544,
0.0100070024,
-0.023315575,
-0.0186090395,
0.0017396936,
-0.0195784904,
-0.0158117879,
0.0004425521,
-0.0246207248,
0.0629270002,
-0.0010195214,
-0.0021172427,
0.0391580127,
0.0416321121,
-0.0222987719,
0.0010603018,
-0.0243393872,
0.0312917084,
0.0277965534,
0.0016355703,
-0.0601665191,
-0.0385555401,
-0.0497761965,
0.1003307924,
0.0654455051,
0.0449955687,
-0.0088929636,
-0.012700933,
0.011425266,
-0.0337328687,
0.0055924091,
0.0316467583,
0.0055408026,
0.0249463748,
-0.0196273122,
-0.0154127879,
-0.0168580711,
-0.0148244584,
0.0362008773,
0.0034551362,
-0.0369815752,
0.0135953771,
0.0073371548,
-0.0087603787,
0.044854112,
-0.0233728439,
-0.0276611932,
-0.0024146398,
-0.0138798365,
-0.0276114773,
-0.0230696648,
-0.003957639,
0.0127820298,
0.0000804611,
0.0217396878,
-0.0522658937,
-0.0131823067,
-0.0633089989,
-0.0225146003,
-0.0145374676,
-0.0039018225,
-0.0123813888,
-0.0442447551,
-0.0179620497,
-0.0568562299,
-0.0152147198,
-0.0326903909,
0.0801835284,
0.0227737539,
0.0053359414,
-0.0090381531,
-0.0259612966,
0.0117104203,
-0.0229668207,
-0.0263921134,
0.0068889186,
-0.0017952222,
0.0154812261,
0.0577956475,
0.0291749686,
-0.0545709431,
0.0135164168,
-0.1301017851,
0.0417817943,
-0.0418395735,
0.027328087,
0.0412222072,
0.0400189497,
-0.0259456839,
-0.0173974782,
-0.0047309021,
-0.0126415119,
0.0006112462,
0.0327836536,
0.0537295789,
0.0039845333,
0.0216967743,
-0.0215459075,
-0.0012191311,
-0.0591169596,
0.0138268108,
0.064699322,
-0.0682272092,
-0.0248473659,
-0.0028776575,
0.0049658017,
0.0240253862,
0.020613594,
0.0068915244,
-0.0059176432,
-0.0252427552,
0.0055442755,
0.0242495146,
0.0220578182,
0.0568066351,
0.0100890324,
0.0338933617,
-0.0183569212,
0.0127792489,
-0.0373010226,
-0.0188211482,
-0.014175538,
-0.0147372354,
0.0392206982,
0.0840538293,
-0.0362002663,
0.0134095596,
-0.0543859303,
0.0033390657,
-0.043318402,
0.0236628745,
-0.058237467,
0.0065182177,
-0.0017954579,
0.0300473571,
-0.0161309615,
-0.0155917611,
0.0493211374,
0.0168873221,
0.0300303362,
-0.0667669699,
-0.0703940988,
-0.029607242,
0.0125601366,
0.0003848311,
-0.0043225172,
0.0413891934,
-0.0018709479,
0.0033619085,
-0.0141199678,
0.0304885358,
0.0135476468,
0.0251656212,
-0.0280596204,
0.0362836719,
-0.0132953459,
-0.0276082791,
-0.0098440284,
-0.1133529469,
-0.0545036793,
0.0240542646,
-0.030026501,
-0.0209379569,
-0.0236233473,
0.0041763629,
0.0309790783,
0.0384110473,
-0.0167148933,
-0.026331326,
-0.0115229888,
0.0421812274,
-0.0098509267,
-0.0109843099,
-0.0472387969,
0.0005078526,
0.030680703,
0.0089899832,
0.0696176067,
0.0222748425,
-0.0349407792,
-0.0017300907,
0.0101901358,
-0.0767191648,
-0.0251815338,
-0.0074288133,
0.0445477627,
-0.0124529051,
0.017044628,
0.1397731602,
0.0454343334,
-0.0452124476,
-0.0292048641,
0.0133855147,
0.0062552555,
0.0238869581,
0.0362829901,
-0.0849560127,
-0.0341198593,
0.0082739014,
0.0639306828,
-0.0236023013,
-0.0624816716,
-0.0016126148,
-0.0850004405,
0.0123444535,
-0.030979706,
-0.03152363,
0.0332836099,
-0.1048115641,
0.0409808569,
-0.0443298072,
-0.0511635095,
-0.0428398326,
-0.006409551,
0.0390140563,
0.0306419581,
-0.033277858,
-0.0768407583,
0.01265659,
-0.0394966789,
0.0306434445,
0.0195411295,
0.0131690241,
-0.0087871859,
0.0326419361,
0.0502797291,
0.0069328826,
-0.0031357186,
-0.0309600513,
0.0646462515,
-0.0183166489,
0.0038787464,
0.0292907171,
0.0060742418,
-0.0198400151,
-0.0257106163,
0.0055381809,
0.0498935841,
-0.0096789785,
0.0321579576,
0.0125257894,
-0.0003068575,
0.0504992604,
0.0694959238,
0.015725702,
-0.0672160164,
0.0040309029,
-0.0406883061,
0.0247845203,
-0.0352600142,
-0.0179564301,
0.0016407091,
-0.0818070471,
-0.0957017541,
-0.0341605544,
-0.032864701,
0.0566210635,
0.0302780755,
0.0081066405,
-0.0294997785,
0.0251989868,
0.0096086161,
-0.0449571647,
0.0530535802,
-0.0228666458,
0.0033968673,
-0.0568104684,
-0.0329193585,
0.0309648253,
0.0048836055,
-0.0190801341,
0.0081436438,
-0.0458543524,
-0.0414529145,
0.0353010967,
-0.0215484221,
0.0243996419,
0.0181842875,
-0.0212091152,
-0.054856509,
0.0077329883,
0.0744117275,
-0.0237818882,
-0.0185662806,
0.0185836535,
0.0184277818,
-0.0062807263,
0.0162816029,
-0.0500115827,
0.0515874587,
-0.0034180917,
0.0116601018,
-0.0325672701,
0.0063216831,
0.0035329398,
0.0217884369,
0.1149985865,
0.0015583613,
-0.0658445805,
-0.0566730164,
-0.0536573194,
0.0213953033,
-0.0328485593,
-0.0166572537,
-0.0004933749,
0.0074910005,
-0.0053024259,
-0.0186767746,
0.0547824726,
-0.0387254357,
0.0473911352,
-0.0616421178,
0.0100352783,
0.0211233478,
0.0561363772,
-0.0092033856,
-0.0206913278,
-0.0231768396,
0.0112580508,
0.0548330918,
0.0093150968,
-0.0246688016,
0.0498497672,
0.0108461296,
-0.003012324,
0.0241582952,
0.0083487071,
-0.0797903389,
-0.0120944614,
-0.0515605025,
0.0628853738,
0.0427651964,
-0.0354249366,
0.0338161178,
-0.0428128541,
-0.0392236821,
0.0028811449,
0.0017791275,
-0.0012125261,
-0.0261566453,
0.0025425798,
-0.0048776497,
-0.0347361974,
0.0394762307,
0.0306941066,
0.0017038053,
0.0364678539,
0.0450302102,
-0.0237869956,
-0.025176255,
0.021506004,
0.0226641726,
0.0009080822,
0.0127682388,
0.0149392849,
-0.0450338013,
-0.0126130991,
0.0532285795,
-0.0562749952,
-0.0433734879,
0.0063012596,
0.0419773869,
0.0795101449,
0.0021703269,
0.0372215398,
-0.0571628101,
0.0322131403,
0.0200447924,
-0.0542490445,
-0.0374545753,
-6.712332821e-33,
-0.0040507261,
-0.0150103569,
-0.0150019983,
0.0012874841,
0.0186124034,
0.0019389186,
-0.002913869,
0.0159691516,
0.0013912107,
0.0176150035,
-0.0183674153,
0.0218613353,
0.019471975,
0.00946844,
0.0014730028,
-0.0320204981,
0.030038571,
-0.0318534523,
-0.0499721318,
0.0368749201,
0.0381472856,
0.0196157787,
0.0421147048,
-0.0984209329,
0.0486255772,
0.0014154267,
0.0055537261,
0.0315273628,
0.0986592397,
0.0179801658,
0.0098605398,
0.0706382766,
0.0577509031,
-0.0657491088,
0.0326143764,
0.0824239776,
-0.0591949709,
-0.0504977927,
-0.0306594949,
-0.011383771,
-0.0122310258,
-0.0104297502,
-0.015131969,
0.0100531923,
-0.0044323131,
0.0239017997,
0.0458036214,
0.01687425,
0.0140998987,
-0.0284091774,
-0.0560034737,
0.0532483719,
-0.0145370336,
-0.0231907368,
0.0062796501,
0.0701377168,
0.0241785459,
0.0127255432,
-0.0260521378,
0.0245040227,
0.0142758107,
-0.0092556393,
0.0145696094,
-0.035579022,
-0.0429085493,
0.0199239068,
-0.001173778,
0.0617560595,
-0.0226569343,
-0.016542092,
-0.0217949841,
-0.0096422313,
0.0061620744,
0.0418468155,
0.0273950212,
-0.0029226753,
-0.0603210144,
0.050156299,
0.059829101,
-0.0075563197,
-0.0136987343,
-0.0218026564,
-0.0151841482,
-0.0165568851,
-0.0239677951,
-0.037471734,
-0.0309071504,
0.0138820922,
-0.0042270636,
-0.0092682512,
-0.0187350716,
0.0317600556,
0.0312385038,
0.0136207482,
0.0134983109,
-0.0160902273,
-0.0074459803,
0.0584920682,
-0.0006751098,
0.0222794004,
-0.0687605441,
-0.0517391115,
0.0151222739,
0.0367247164,
0.0305822827,
-0.010885898,
0.0357762277,
0.0137399957,
-0.0429614447,
0.000284586,
-0.0058584805,
0.0442631952,
-0.0271874908,
0.0396891385,
0.0066859219,
0.0182044506,
0.0218668412,
0.0472607426,
0.0667549297,
-0.0001292126,
0.010455505,
-0.0245250743,
-0.0206443053,
-0.0079051852,
0.0162013881,
0.0017836096,
0.0133703705,
0.0446197353,
-0.0002976276,
-0.0584000945,
-0.0154274264,
-0.0079145283,
2.646e-7,
0.063833192,
0.1003044471,
-0.0158969536,
-0.024086684,
0.0225438848,
0.0638603941,
-0.0014563983,
0.037818253,
0.0019823508,
-0.0109454133,
0.0021338933,
-0.0139876315,
0.0427363515,
0.0430530757,
-0.0774786621,
-0.06692449,
-0.055026181,
0.0492817014,
-0.0758878961,
0.0390954576,
0.048316732,
0.0575217567,
0.0281050149,
-0.000828303,
-0.0360545032,
-0.0625526011,
0.0400851108,
-0.0136096133,
-0.0204141941,
0.0205687955,
0.0433847494,
0.0237037819,
-0.0019789648,
0.0414448045,
-0.0330263637,
-0.0006162282,
-0.0109105641,
0.0352567099,
-0.0017517835,
0.0093028191,
0.0023115797,
-0.0268534757,
0.0275981855,
-0.0189568624,
0.0686719567,
-0.0961634442,
-0.0301237293,
-0.0247552134,
-0.0145286974,
0.0023594531,
0.0126950359,
-0.0082225027,
-0.0461736694,
0.014335365,
0.0102356831,
0.0111788763,
-0.0326417126,
-0.0323772877,
-0.0038805527,
0.0231591426,
-0.0102580739,
-0.0459065996,
-0.0137874903,
0.0005148815,
0.0223305766,
-0.053569112,
0.0585877113,
2.315513797e-34,
0.0182989463,
-0.0150481761,
-0.0184783712,
-0.0030222852,
0.0192745216,
0.0272539351,
-0.0286124423,
-0.0126454094,
0.0045932573,
-0.0504965894,
0.0212973021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18227v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18227v1 | GUIDE: A Guideline-Guided Dataset for Instructional Video Comprehension | 2024-06-26T10:24:00 | 2024-06-26T10:24:00 | Jiafeng Liang, Shixin Jiang, Zekun Wang, Haojie Pan, Zerui Chen, Zheng Chu, Ming Liu, Ruiji Fu, Zhongyuan Wang, Bing Qin | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | There are substantial instructional videos on the Internet, which provide us
tutorials for completing various tasks. Existing instructional video datasets
only focus on specific steps at the video level, lacking experiential
guidelines at the task level, which can lead to beginners struggling to learn
new tasks due to the lack of relevant experience. Moreover, the specific steps
without guidelines are trivial and unsystematic, making it difficult to provide
a clear tutorial. To address these problems, we present the GUIDE
(Guideline-Guided) dataset, which contains 3.5K videos of 560 instructional
tasks in 8 domains related to our daily life. Specifically, we annotate each
instructional task with a guideline, representing a common pattern shared by
all task-related videos. On this basis, we annotate systematic specific steps,
including their associated guideline steps, specific step descriptions and
timestamps. Our proposed benchmark consists of three sub-tasks to evaluate
comprehension ability of models: (1) Step Captioning: models have to generate
captions for specific steps from videos. (2) Guideline Summarization: models
have to mine the common pattern in task-related videos and summarize a
guideline from them. (3) Guideline-Guided Captioning: models have to generate
captions for specific steps under the guide of guideline. We evaluate plenty of
foundation models with GUIDE and perform in-depth analysis. Given the diversity
and practicality of GUIDE, we believe that it can be used as a better benchmark
for instructional video comprehension. | [
0.0308309421,
0.0033243452,
-0.0008863956,
0.0451489016,
0.0077636712,
0.0288856272,
0.0102445669,
-0.0338354893,
-0.0400295034,
-0.0485712849,
-0.0081558367,
0.0177251864,
0.0005193714,
0.0062454971,
-0.0155425817,
-0.1258415729,
-0.0078101191,
0.0058385995,
-0.0069682077,
0.0543870628,
0.0261805244,
0.0030564107,
-0.0448878519,
0.0450380966,
-0.0134316674,
-0.0116554881,
-0.0055776136,
-0.0058578132,
0.046521388,
-0.0374731235,
0.0051432489,
0.031999968,
0.0611946844,
-0.0424499996,
0.0000017624,
0.0036811847,
0.0053643119,
-0.0274735857,
-0.0295997187,
0.0290289037,
0.0016263593,
-0.0079977019,
0.0267806519,
0.016388746,
-0.0315699615,
0.0206578001,
0.019642232,
0.0237333868,
0.0552799515,
0.0536618456,
-0.0070316126,
-0.037248902,
-0.0022466457,
0.0019692597,
0.0207556579,
-0.0308007207,
-0.013147315,
0.091254212,
0.026561087,
-0.0038248152,
-0.0461604446,
0.0357251465,
0.0325218476,
-0.0067444835,
0.0038885898,
0.0299763065,
-0.0161767527,
-0.0347080119,
0.0100340052,
0.1001872569,
0.0232732035,
0.039286688,
0.0092601618,
0.0077913208,
0.0256135147,
0.0376943052,
-0.076376766,
0.0497776531,
-0.0166793074,
-0.0070875771,
-0.0153680164,
0.0371687301,
0.0034879956,
-0.0141371312,
0.0704857409,
-0.0354576744,
-0.0142037366,
0.015075,
-0.0263059698,
-0.0102435779,
-0.0465045832,
-0.031270761,
0.0538402721,
0.0274631735,
0.0081439093,
0.0283346437,
-0.0522794202,
0.0363780558,
-0.020182319,
-0.0374904945,
0.0770185515,
0.0559023581,
-0.0371417999,
0.0716555417,
-0.024953343,
0.0542436019,
-0.0047820825,
0.0337420255,
-0.062828593,
0.0383421704,
-0.0965459198,
0.0287842229,
-0.0536814742,
0.032126762,
-0.0275654923,
-0.0124971941,
-0.0329857357,
0.0035503928,
-0.025556922,
0.0402126312,
-0.0264416318,
0.032198403,
0.012653199,
0.0038774724,
-0.0154625047,
-0.0172743499,
-0.0822429731,
0.0462749302,
0.0061835959,
-0.0432059802,
-0.0082011763,
-0.0020469693,
0.0085418886,
-0.0008377985,
0.0229675137,
0.0156290717,
-0.0600510277,
-0.0330095515,
-0.0417146645,
-0.0356533453,
0.0092180138,
0.009199827,
0.0296381004,
-0.0392553024,
0.0197497588,
-0.0145314159,
0.0099172015,
-0.0237316247,
-0.0056084702,
0.0266940165,
-0.0118875224,
0.063645035,
0.0301344525,
0.0285136923,
0.0257097781,
0.0645890459,
-0.0639268234,
0.0458579883,
0.0303143319,
0.0165295824,
0.0633354783,
0.0127656376,
0.0348868147,
0.0116522023,
-0.0021904933,
0.0132297259,
-0.0339421332,
0.0453641675,
0.0067762579,
0.0349567942,
0.0313446298,
0.0167028904,
-0.0187828597,
-0.0072978283,
0.0370974019,
0.0314227715,
-0.0307665486,
-0.0042862082,
0.0871017575,
0.0525551662,
0.0335130617,
0.0492728613,
-0.0268217139,
0.0509018302,
-0.0007953015,
0.0097860498,
-0.0042975508,
-0.0085554011,
-0.0692879781,
-0.0672482252,
-0.0078926645,
0.0003259389,
-0.0022671046,
-0.0228174031,
0.017542515,
0.0277468618,
-0.0788811073,
0.0320914797,
-0.0217197947,
-0.0281148255,
0.0361819677,
-0.0099851424,
0.0086264852,
0.0482902043,
0.0108592622,
-0.0210976414,
-0.0395002924,
0.0084641948,
0.0990919173,
-0.0327905342,
0.0197781939,
-0.0612752698,
0.0368210189,
-0.0810512006,
-0.0508794449,
-0.0130125312,
0.0159911066,
0.0079597188,
0.0118871238,
0.0081343912,
0.0385596789,
-0.0323942155,
-0.0561431758,
0.0605000407,
0.0001241515,
-0.0278476346,
-0.0169812739,
0.0108261956,
0.0139783798,
0.0431331582,
-0.0060766032,
-0.0196188334,
0.0114566013,
-0.021411201,
0.0084847212,
0.0373580828,
-0.0604419485,
-0.0368823893,
0.0257962421,
-0.1029157564,
-0.0005018494,
0.0482897535,
-0.036675714,
-0.0454520248,
0.0048103393,
-0.0015988433,
-0.0182744488,
-0.0094122598,
-0.0079055959,
0.0476024225,
-0.0322779268,
0.0153637268,
0.0238844361,
-0.0041600689,
0.0196096115,
0.0467393175,
-0.002939204,
-0.0103346696,
-0.0538297966,
0.0122950319,
-0.0318882652,
-0.0444889925,
0.0013454208,
0.0245021489,
0.0241807513,
-0.0881763399,
-0.0165914185,
-0.0410159603,
0.0159005802,
-0.0114109339,
0.0052056378,
0.0232505891,
-0.0272409506,
-0.0217996631,
-0.0555776432,
0.0114667695,
-0.0223150477,
-0.020655591,
-0.0042250073,
-0.0148167778,
0.0680608824,
-0.0262946114,
-0.0469565392,
-0.0072578308,
0.000231826,
0.011889467,
0.0470243245,
0.0297866631,
-0.0168764424,
0.0180712119,
0.0176792461,
-0.0076364824,
-0.018837627,
-0.0213762559,
0.0143396249,
0.0060784747,
-0.0118691185,
0.0504630171,
-0.0077471901,
0.0514297001,
0.0072112093,
-0.0391627476,
-0.0254551619,
0.0200104415,
0.0093981531,
-0.0193837229,
-0.0165267717,
-0.0456421524,
-0.0194635633,
0.0107368566,
0.0063364436,
0.035812676,
-0.0674541146,
0.0056021917,
-0.0260837525,
0.0183859486,
-0.0473760217,
0.0003258093,
0.0154465716,
0.0089747421,
-0.0233139694,
-0.0288762338,
0.0474249758,
-0.0271552727,
-0.035722848,
-0.0140899625,
-0.004040766,
-0.0216446873,
0.0521913022,
0.0016653468,
0.0120633747,
0.0004026641,
-0.0386103764,
-0.0510399751,
0.0068417382,
0.0720803142,
-0.0044863233,
0.0589921474,
-0.0801251382,
-0.0292971395,
-0.0278629605,
0.0117212124,
-0.0511192121,
0.0013882974,
-0.0147533538,
-0.0184909049,
-0.0273569655,
-0.0060322867,
-0.062524572,
-0.0105886962,
0.0109721813,
0.0520002395,
-0.0111532658,
-0.0049706218,
-0.00429472,
0.0319092274,
0.0408621244,
0.0309208687,
-0.0608367175,
-0.0513599664,
0.0979962125,
0.0217576716,
0.0298760217,
-0.0636620894,
-0.0278217364,
0.0265151355,
0.0120639224,
-0.0467344038,
0.0034903896,
0.0720243305,
0.0529627241,
-0.0755962729,
0.0246552378,
0.1168534458,
0.0160605609,
-0.0228399727,
-0.0095772007,
0.0303500276,
-0.0182233192,
0.0522609428,
-0.0118395993,
-0.058485724,
-0.0455480963,
-0.0158227645,
0.0390126109,
0.0288615599,
0.0082847429,
-0.0179118887,
-0.059526749,
0.0631615818,
0.0292505883,
-0.0427300557,
-0.0288609043,
-0.0335407592,
-0.0169566441,
-0.0466290042,
-0.0069870958,
-0.0152867865,
-0.0479541682,
0.0443079062,
0.046703089,
-0.0241203029,
-0.0741692483,
0.0319325142,
-0.0349415615,
0.0426966064,
0.0259058047,
0.0075535788,
-0.0185911246,
0.0007942817,
0.0067021176,
-0.027587546,
-0.0068210205,
-0.0131972879,
0.0872605592,
-0.0132962679,
-0.0066260691,
0.0169892944,
0.0647282153,
-0.0326552689,
-0.0381018855,
0.0565872602,
0.0470122173,
0.0062630381,
0.0182496253,
-0.0648386255,
0.0338889733,
0.0227422956,
0.1063061431,
0.0152189163,
0.0114530623,
0.0320736542,
0.0128806625,
-0.0066206739,
-0.0764152259,
-0.006343462,
-0.01446833,
0.0142896716,
0.0488726236,
-0.0688091591,
-0.0412712321,
0.0761562958,
0.0229958557,
0.0064998306,
0.0115385782,
0.0288856868,
0.0469038077,
-0.0739140511,
0.0488295034,
-0.0119018136,
-0.0172789823,
-0.101505585,
-0.0416984223,
0.0346239358,
-0.0274388604,
-0.0222573392,
0.03687042,
-0.0176787395,
0.0033672084,
-0.0284710247,
0.058028996,
0.0188615769,
0.0573992133,
0.0320102088,
0.0175744593,
-0.031661395,
-0.0276957303,
0.001944511,
-0.0169067606,
0.0144577399,
-0.0179005209,
-0.0195052531,
0.003973552,
-0.0372158922,
0.0136106452,
-0.0475450531,
0.0280924607,
-0.0498412624,
-0.0378175341,
0.0201772172,
-0.0487184599,
0.0243278164,
-0.0003456089,
0.0115417792,
-0.0429684892,
0.0128227118,
0.0105215898,
0.029137522,
-0.0634402856,
0.0534623675,
0.0458768718,
-0.0012769658,
0.0005702862,
0.0439556949,
-0.0294192694,
-0.0025928651,
-0.0612858385,
0.0028212613,
-0.0310711488,
0.0125800967,
-0.0366799794,
0.0111075863,
0.0048058745,
0.0061405925,
0.0183590446,
0.0267768558,
0.0483553112,
0.0902251303,
0.016351236,
0.0255131107,
0.0157684945,
0.0420806259,
-0.0104128718,
-0.0182433277,
-0.0387180746,
0.0098551847,
0.0250426605,
-0.0667236373,
-0.0025214525,
-0.0079317903,
0.0129481507,
-0.0343137383,
0.0491731763,
-0.0362483449,
-0.0593945272,
0.0403655916,
0.0147289159,
0.021537099,
0.0079143997,
0.1003496051,
0.0046000248,
0.0448119864,
0.010764732,
-0.0234961901,
-0.0358468741,
-0.0256132521,
0.0217603073,
0.0201729815,
-0.0399156213,
0.0191804413,
-0.033123415,
-0.0462793335,
-0.0527364686,
-0.0279102027,
0.020531958,
0.0233319979,
0.0749000087,
0.0125644505,
-0.0345450938,
-0.0202753246,
-0.0192269087,
-0.0305878595,
-0.0638343692,
-0.0059782872,
-0.0294802431,
-5.168284257e-33,
-0.0463222302,
-0.0069341115,
0.0172053333,
0.0265593119,
0.0287887193,
0.0221774355,
-0.039854046,
0.0412059352,
-0.0223644432,
0.0441296026,
0.0299107712,
0.0143664423,
0.0209751353,
0.0370377488,
0.0298446082,
-0.0330766067,
0.0628532693,
-0.0229124483,
-0.0308495238,
0.0357856937,
-0.0006261283,
0.0077726636,
0.029712161,
-0.0754888654,
-0.0175741073,
-0.0182510968,
-0.0469878614,
0.007172998,
0.0337589271,
0.0746406913,
-0.0021498976,
-0.0594019555,
0.0188197047,
-0.0435038395,
-0.0372171141,
-0.0152491257,
-0.0795157701,
0.0011487246,
0.0134605123,
0.0264248792,
-0.0631272867,
-0.0246521141,
0.0084153973,
-0.0142355757,
-0.0084593892,
-0.0229970701,
0.0868918672,
-0.0450165682,
0.0337441228,
0.013950862,
-0.0121668363,
-0.0062216744,
-0.0659532323,
-0.1027056426,
0.0205587074,
0.0253475215,
0.0180361029,
-0.028232038,
-0.0488019921,
0.0122181689,
0.0102729695,
0.042141486,
0.093087025,
-0.0111184334,
-0.0230109692,
0.0402896553,
-0.0118242865,
-0.0542150289,
0.0050948989,
-0.0147809861,
-0.0148791866,
0.0888844505,
-0.0017309218,
-0.0215130635,
0.0498518907,
0.0441413447,
-0.0344913825,
0.1013066992,
-0.0342646614,
0.0400486067,
-0.0120254029,
0.0036706694,
-0.0328168832,
0.0408036076,
-0.0287304446,
-0.0023792726,
0.0040511517,
-0.0153170116,
0.0325375758,
0.0089222472,
-0.0038669792,
-0.027776463,
0.0329791084,
-0.0321253687,
0.0271554217,
0.0068760742,
-0.0278125089,
0.0290319026,
0.0118419649,
0.003058552,
-0.0807798058,
-0.0340662599,
0.0394563638,
-0.0084798383,
0.0130260717,
-0.001507732,
0.0228320863,
0.0532201938,
-0.0153994216,
-0.0009399794,
-0.0070757167,
-0.0142738763,
-0.0399120003,
0.021385463,
0.0153717501,
0.0404436067,
-0.0855160058,
0.0579117537,
-0.0364305675,
-0.002087781,
-0.0141063258,
-0.0261428896,
0.0198372472,
0.0107206404,
-0.0264812913,
-0.0059167277,
-0.040975716,
-0.0096034929,
0.038775716,
-0.0301091038,
-0.0011716263,
0.0337649211,
2.38e-7,
-0.0198214725,
-0.0124517446,
0.0122350324,
0.0037161172,
-0.0070546046,
0.0578012206,
-0.0363358893,
-0.005705209,
0.0019163381,
-0.0484761447,
0.0512089059,
0.0474831574,
0.0147271687,
-0.0105558261,
-0.0555529669,
-0.0473125055,
-0.0183206033,
-0.0178858079,
-0.028640978,
-0.0185029358,
0.0281272084,
0.0597462207,
0.0101931226,
0.0066621187,
0.0008847373,
-0.0534410514,
0.0480584018,
-0.0132393017,
-0.0095016882,
0.00642436,
0.0547440499,
0.0369653888,
-0.0460991971,
-0.0037028354,
-0.0304284412,
-0.0165513605,
0.0587682948,
0.0638610721,
0.0172577165,
-0.0110883471,
-0.040879555,
0.0344470739,
-0.011520369,
0.0007190581,
0.0241231136,
-0.0250548888,
-0.0247300714,
0.0210303012,
-0.0294785071,
0.0275398232,
-0.0256444737,
0.0298141688,
-0.0058189793,
0.0124237454,
0.0073155486,
-0.022655366,
-0.0418487862,
-0.0635369271,
0.0072208438,
0.0037173014,
-0.0274136607,
0.0024713594,
-0.0493998677,
-0.0036641029,
-0.0098925233,
-0.02120292,
-0.0525105409,
1.662610715e-34,
0.0144377723,
-0.0034605253,
0.0050324979,
-0.0146374125,
0.0176505949,
-0.0049670762,
-0.0749069154,
0.0074945991,
-0.0088662496,
-0.0248901229,
-0.00559104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18221v1 | Enhancing Data Privacy in Large Language Models through Private Association Editing | 2024-06-26T10:08:47 | 2024-06-26T10:08:47 | Davide Venditti, Elena Sofia Ruzzetti, Giancarlo A. Xompero, Cristina Giannone, Andrea Favalli, Raniero Romagnoli, Fabio Massimo Zanzotto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are powerful tools with extensive applications,
but their tendency to memorize private information raises significant concerns
as private data leakage can easily happen. In this paper, we introduce Private
Association Editing (PAE), a novel defense approach for private data leakage.
PAE is designed to effectively remove Personally Identifiable Information (PII)
without retraining the model. Our approach consists of a four-step procedure:
detecting memorized PII, applying PAE cards to mitigate memorization of private
data, verifying resilience to targeted data extraction (TDE) attacks, and
ensuring consistency in the post-edit LLMs. The versatility and efficiency of
PAE, which allows for batch modifications, significantly enhance data privacy
in LLMs. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of PAE in
mitigating private data leakage. We believe PAE will serve as a critical tool
in the ongoing effort to protect data privacy in LLMs, encouraging the
development of safer models for real-world applications. | [
0.0315022357,
0.1154447645,
-0.024076974,
0.0835983604,
-0.0349678844,
-0.0194263645,
0.0623105615,
-0.0059271157,
0.0102836536,
-0.0162161887,
-0.0271275844,
-0.0235526189,
0.021812778,
0.0016257867,
0.0491319709,
0.0287220664,
0.0573213696,
-0.0436584987,
0.0005930789,
-0.0286942385,
-0.0170251504,
-0.0235465076,
0.0297028571,
-0.0082249613,
0.0188422557,
-0.0234375,
-0.0177247077,
-0.0264435112,
0.0237119067,
-0.0137505857,
-0.0106648505,
0.0700728819,
0.0005663169,
0.0731672347,
0.0000021392,
-0.0357972421,
-0.076713793,
0.0538189262,
-0.0459742844,
0.0637825727,
-0.0268010367,
0.0095628779,
-0.016797645,
-0.0002689346,
-0.0197075531,
0.0124674551,
0.0447387099,
0.0236385372,
0.0936271846,
0.0719651654,
-0.0080186995,
-0.0284331385,
0.0325861312,
-0.0262408052,
-0.0043283976,
-0.0439411737,
0.0612344667,
-0.042756781,
-0.0543108992,
0.0012992593,
-0.0007764318,
0.0302348696,
-0.0056095095,
0.000069729,
-0.0294865482,
0.0076834625,
-0.0172173139,
0.0018823046,
0.0116795124,
0.0233881176,
0.0213654637,
-0.0249804333,
0.0312017854,
0.0191801954,
0.0220993608,
0.0194612145,
0.0113130054,
0.0403316319,
-0.0058714147,
-0.009928369,
0.0178198293,
-0.0503881201,
0.0421251692,
0.00021331,
-0.0091974856,
0.0191528779,
0.0381617211,
-0.0206597839,
-0.0358074903,
-0.0541658401,
0.0277629513,
-0.0628994703,
0.0437726937,
0.010526713,
0.0460933335,
0.0348157734,
-0.0759677738,
-0.052687604,
0.0086800838,
-0.0475204661,
0.0330921412,
0.019179631,
0.0207476616,
0.0253587477,
-0.0115407566,
0.0467117243,
-0.0123814354,
0.0420935676,
0.0498425812,
0.0284686685,
-0.0238378439,
-0.0059718317,
-0.0097301761,
0.0656543374,
-0.0089925854,
0.0500990041,
-0.0075190254,
0.0429543667,
-0.016634535,
0.0604184233,
-0.0019206158,
-0.0262408964,
-0.0020287011,
-0.0243506301,
-0.0056850449,
-0.0441563427,
0.0206953045,
-0.0194706339,
0.001575786,
-0.0468507744,
-0.0131840529,
-0.0539312363,
-0.0108403107,
-0.029239431,
-0.0258109141,
0.073406823,
0.0211066566,
-0.0094992798,
-0.0668199882,
-0.0938778222,
0.03218453,
-0.0254685394,
0.0051916335,
-0.0614085272,
0.0043597147,
-0.030729562,
-0.0201067869,
-0.1079928279,
-0.0054112351,
0.0162252262,
-0.0369303487,
0.0492485315,
0.000827049,
-0.0014404462,
0.0175802652,
0.0467390753,
-0.0015876134,
0.0065850136,
0.0264488366,
0.031099245,
0.0690306276,
-0.0209387857,
0.049106136,
0.0482204221,
0.0225606132,
0.0014688851,
-0.0408105142,
0.0370048583,
0.0318767801,
-0.0741855726,
-0.02000653,
0.0413122065,
-0.0144693125,
-0.0646093786,
0.1067450866,
0.037715815,
-0.0189667344,
0.0594182089,
-0.0609751791,
0.0120584508,
0.0119148642,
-0.0131576704,
-0.0574255846,
-0.0053589228,
-0.0789655223,
-0.0247977749,
0.0022714897,
0.0114507377,
0.005505038,
0.0157898962,
0.0207384862,
-0.046280846,
0.0333458856,
0.0184377898,
-0.0020457602,
0.0272993464,
0.0238678195,
0.0695355311,
0.0241775513,
-0.0630644485,
-0.0200926121,
-0.0717050582,
-0.0055345912,
0.0623447299,
0.0533614978,
0.0004316668,
-0.0065871044,
-0.0420601889,
-0.0556663275,
-0.0020527171,
0.0069020605,
-0.0009913472,
0.0633449182,
-0.0163113568,
-0.0324093476,
0.0287762415,
0.0245780237,
0.0164362695,
0.0249739513,
-0.0368706621,
0.0191379916,
-0.0166496299,
-0.0118958186,
0.0073363208,
-0.0314528011,
-0.051381655,
0.043590501,
0.035337124,
0.0029441288,
0.0309671368,
-0.0291483309,
0.0136462888,
0.0196463522,
0.0486656278,
0.040683791,
-0.0312227625,
0.0031891277,
0.0240892917,
0.0001809984,
-0.0106207319,
-0.0026322326,
0.0531250536,
-0.0009328106,
-0.0047292938,
0.0060484265,
-0.0265092645,
0.0444700383,
-0.0113901142,
0.0391208902,
-0.0180013049,
0.0147123029,
-0.0026405384,
0.0018453543,
-0.0339261442,
-0.0436371192,
-0.0406552516,
-0.0019272453,
-0.003738492,
-0.0552276112,
-0.0221223906,
0.020664867,
0.0019456416,
0.0130231455,
-0.0015805474,
-0.0135799479,
-0.0289277192,
-0.02853694,
-0.0070093195,
0.0083417036,
0.0118888086,
0.039572902,
0.0162317175,
0.0203129686,
-0.0395967737,
-0.0219417959,
-0.0370177403,
-0.0359534547,
-0.0577192307,
0.0306229033,
0.0203743801,
0.0192019697,
-0.0453384332,
-0.0048480206,
-0.0015170372,
-0.0000397724,
0.0347439572,
-0.0535016172,
-0.0528174751,
-0.0300328806,
0.032278195,
-0.0489550121,
0.0244599264,
0.0089734225,
-0.0252851509,
-0.0097667929,
0.0012810481,
-0.0014385364,
0.0414025262,
-0.006062387,
-0.0202504117,
0.0423605703,
-0.0337944217,
-0.0369265191,
-0.0264568236,
0.0269292258,
-0.0133481324,
-0.0206994377,
-0.0159929581,
-0.0029196541,
0.0292670131,
0.022820713,
-0.0225895718,
0.005236363,
0.0366240144,
0.0233171713,
-0.0207066946,
-0.0030921453,
-0.0430964902,
-0.019152293,
0.0000025157,
-0.0309332721,
-0.0546573587,
0.0666537732,
-0.0194513947,
0.0443229713,
-0.0228495374,
-0.0299693923,
0.0220204219,
0.0756363124,
0.0074495901,
0.0367262922,
0.0577476248,
-0.0544990823,
-0.0324692056,
-0.0349890664,
0.0251103137,
-0.0533892587,
0.0289769508,
-0.0443504229,
-0.0412095562,
0.0138792805,
-0.00908201,
-0.0567200445,
-0.0530983135,
-0.0132350614,
-0.0177125894,
-0.0087487381,
-0.0496043824,
0.0019013295,
-0.0439579189,
0.0570441894,
0.0183427967,
-0.021111615,
0.0209766198,
-0.0179316867,
-0.0209528524,
0.0155256288,
-0.0739057958,
-0.0248851757,
-0.0337734632,
-0.0112301391,
0.0843410194,
0.0589917488,
-0.0268462989,
0.0077427193,
-0.0319952108,
0.0101638362,
-0.0432658494,
-0.0121209277,
0.0272640493,
-0.0102626598,
-0.0619946644,
-0.0132867247,
0.0671070889,
0.0187184215,
-0.0705645457,
-0.0019822982,
0.0267587919,
-0.0124277389,
-0.006888771,
0.0127908373,
-0.09010306,
0.0108933561,
0.0134161077,
0.0312107559,
-0.02857293,
-0.0469697714,
-0.0441990122,
-0.0952238142,
-0.0243891515,
0.0404007398,
-0.0275052525,
-0.0229533948,
-0.0368213244,
0.016108945,
0.0152451312,
0.0124643315,
-0.0266665053,
0.0121843964,
-0.0127523812,
-0.0066702142,
-0.0326180421,
-0.0229639933,
-0.0186313856,
-0.0285701994,
0.0635775179,
0.0538164377,
-0.0031334609,
-0.0278858971,
-0.012068118,
0.0216346476,
0.0694644749,
-0.0225802436,
-0.0000085365,
0.0449795574,
0.0119412616,
0.0012699133,
0.0217493642,
0.0322208628,
0.0481087752,
-0.0196753088,
0.0466311313,
0.0404403396,
-0.0268031657,
0.035109356,
0.0232235696,
-0.0512775071,
0.0131877689,
0.0553222485,
0.0016126648,
-0.0133977206,
0.0257676635,
-0.0670879111,
0.0224291068,
-0.0112633165,
0.0101393219,
-0.0179201886,
-0.0208173469,
-0.0517961346,
-0.0291000474,
-0.0023658937,
-0.0160472076,
-0.001715121,
0.0754356384,
0.0071938927,
0.0487312786,
-0.0011516247,
-0.0410873108,
-0.0193248112,
-0.102187857,
0.0202545263,
-0.0499389358,
-0.0132526336,
-0.0029974689,
-0.0039619305,
-0.0057580704,
-0.0049315961,
-0.063040629,
-0.09335576,
0.040197514,
0.0500314534,
0.0200809203,
0.041847419,
-0.0033604859,
-0.1029401496,
0.0685485601,
0.0146632129,
-0.0464531258,
0.0049616741,
0.0614074729,
-0.0330960117,
0.0103600994,
0.0186099038,
-0.0231837463,
-0.0409762822,
0.0705832988,
-0.0438511483,
-0.0466850288,
-0.0394647159,
-0.0345059037,
0.0723424926,
0.0140075646,
0.0290371086,
0.0339004882,
-0.0365952291,
0.0638967305,
-0.0617672913,
0.0041700788,
0.0140453866,
0.0155631322,
0.0377788208,
0.0089064725,
0.04484367,
-0.0581141859,
0.0030387195,
0.0275483765,
-0.0110082114,
0.0210114699,
0.0209732074,
0.0274528414,
0.0312103312,
0.0096821934,
-0.0130848614,
0.0447983369,
0.0542657934,
0.0330534317,
-0.0297123473,
0.0527793802,
-0.013798546,
-0.0243950281,
-0.0355080999,
0.0330059715,
-0.034478873,
-0.0038166346,
-0.0013006622,
0.052825395,
-0.0178983137,
0.0116135739,
-0.003465655,
-0.0312628932,
0.0050205272,
-0.0404140837,
-0.0227924921,
-0.013742663,
-0.0329170302,
-0.0235591941,
-0.0184098203,
-0.0074038985,
0.0571642853,
0.0565242358,
-0.0196884703,
0.0530614592,
-0.0321969911,
-0.0205092188,
-0.0736769214,
-0.0165250879,
0.0338206552,
0.0113859409,
-0.0669521764,
-0.0532133803,
-0.0332964249,
-0.0634274557,
-0.0159245022,
-0.0130980648,
0.0282736216,
0.004194695,
-0.0196720921,
0.0099104447,
-0.0088473205,
-0.0016910239,
-0.0903770253,
0.0247321408,
0.030490512,
-0.0366326235,
0.0052770544,
-5.484526033e-33,
0.0164426342,
0.0069759362,
-0.0270300787,
0.0285570826,
0.0257167295,
0.0268445928,
-0.0331257544,
0.0176356826,
-0.0074682585,
-0.0308349784,
-0.0460856482,
-0.0079105413,
0.0152795548,
0.0151715986,
-0.0164586212,
0.0020787967,
0.0361161344,
0.0013803141,
-0.0127689149,
0.026474027,
0.0365368202,
0.0298260618,
0.0573365279,
-0.0948287472,
0.0607268028,
-0.0171701126,
-0.0455105565,
0.0177251901,
-0.0536697879,
0.07617753,
0.0056058583,
-0.035727486,
-0.0113735748,
0.0066731852,
-0.0179109033,
0.0197292548,
-0.0340097435,
-0.0159093421,
0.0013387292,
0.0070734895,
0.0490832478,
-0.078433834,
0.0226269867,
-0.0376581512,
-0.0212622974,
0.0065794322,
-0.0156220179,
-0.0214203559,
-0.0037064163,
-0.005882367,
0.0130877523,
0.0071732141,
-0.0124794291,
0.0130715137,
0.0833168626,
-0.0403838791,
0.024219675,
-0.0451409332,
-0.060072381,
0.0554402433,
0.0783440769,
0.0041717179,
0.0460776351,
0.018534787,
0.0292797964,
0.0387211815,
0.0485275798,
0.0389601402,
0.0536285825,
0.0178331397,
-0.0088356249,
0.0226666555,
-0.0170011502,
0.0371082239,
0.0231519174,
-0.0301046651,
-0.0152858756,
0.0219505001,
-0.0218343623,
0.0090458626,
0.0387581438,
0.0198780801,
-0.0637723804,
0.0241017435,
-0.0431722514,
0.0168906692,
-0.0473201908,
-0.0097582554,
-0.0196243078,
-0.0105456552,
-0.0675636232,
0.0170982908,
0.0109493854,
-0.0596609749,
-0.0313531347,
0.0366609842,
0.0455770753,
-0.0303642284,
-0.0108348159,
-0.0025505587,
-0.0193234384,
0.0029847068,
0.0060860314,
-0.0427809395,
0.0156265963,
0.013783385,
0.0357498005,
0.0218404252,
-0.0999264941,
-0.0273053814,
-0.0253117587,
0.0187575985,
0.0322765857,
0.0102597792,
0.0162489824,
-0.0011556969,
0.0165426638,
0.019229725,
0.0583198294,
0.0165897235,
-0.0507759266,
0.0558289178,
0.0000360149,
0.0096953707,
0.0312277153,
0.0005020256,
0.0422527194,
0.0326721072,
0.1037614793,
0.0036112051,
0.020043157,
-0.0367869437,
2.865e-7,
-0.0103297187,
0.0248779338,
0.0000575898,
-0.0161808953,
0.0237722434,
0.0755645782,
-0.0006768119,
0.0504916273,
0.0238725543,
0.0164876506,
-0.0111215152,
-0.0035418365,
0.0365363322,
0.0386476554,
-0.0382038057,
0.0257829856,
-0.0169076566,
-0.0056155501,
-0.0611204617,
0.0124026584,
0.0157889258,
0.0751640797,
0.0614779554,
-0.0271093454,
-0.0385812372,
-0.0364348851,
0.0138550429,
-0.0332288183,
-0.0504616536,
-0.002496717,
0.0236580558,
0.0660673454,
0.0350635126,
0.0087828152,
-0.0591695197,
0.0181175768,
-0.0658968017,
0.0792329982,
0.0099811815,
0.0004669993,
0.0039916886,
-0.0642906204,
-0.0172889102,
0.000588755,
0.0416343361,
0.0227587409,
-0.0151446797,
0.001114506,
0.0116863046,
-0.0495372079,
0.0228406787,
-0.019210536,
-0.009740768,
0.0239223,
-0.0010695492,
0.0132266451,
0.0048537082,
-0.0404815674,
-0.0560954474,
-0.0554503128,
-0.0121643431,
-0.0336743444,
0.0204696059,
0.0091595948,
-0.0147594316,
-0.0435009524,
0.0525304303,
2.672447836e-34,
-0.0298465397,
-0.0356343798,
-0.0268574301,
0.0375882424,
0.0595514104,
-0.0098799905,
0.0191800352,
0.0333530679,
-0.0069896313,
-0.0428536199,
-0.0333793238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18219v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18219v1 | A Closer Look into Mixture-of-Experts in Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T10:07:57 | 2024-06-26T10:07:57 | Ka Man Lo, Zeyu Huang, Zihan Qiu, Zili Wang, Jie Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Mixture-of-experts (MoE) is gaining increasing attention due to its unique
properties and remarkable performance, especially for language tasks. By
sparsely activating a subset of parameters for each token, MoE architecture
could increase the model size without sacrificing computational efficiency,
achieving a better trade-off between performance and training costs. However,
the underlying mechanism of MoE still lacks further exploration, and its
modularization degree remains questionable. In this paper, we make an initial
attempt to understand the inner workings of MoE-based large language models.
Concretely, we comprehensively study the parametric and behavioral features of
three recent MoE-based models and reveal some intriguing observations,
including (1) Neurons act like fine-grained experts. (2) The router of MoE
usually selects experts with larger output norms. (3) The expert diversity
increases as the layer increases, while the last layer is an outlier. Based on
the observations, we also provide suggestions for a broad spectrum of MoE
practitioners, such as router design and expert allocation. We hope this work
could shed light on future research on the MoE framework and other modular
architectures. Code is available at
https://github.com/kamanphoebe/Look-into-MoEs. | [
0.0724910423,
0.0707233995,
0.0011864993,
0.0371967182,
-0.0287534818,
-0.0045647826,
0.0428110845,
-0.0128656523,
-0.0382816158,
-0.0116745718,
-0.0588364378,
-0.0352468602,
-0.0001394465,
0.0149993375,
0.0426348746,
-0.034138009,
0.0143965092,
-0.0553087294,
0.0059463969,
-0.0276064016,
0.0025943071,
0.0013505282,
-0.008258367,
0.0647403747,
-0.0023011421,
0.0371650718,
0.009193372,
-0.0258957837,
-0.0086369701,
0.029319793,
0.0042146854,
0.0652513504,
0.0347899348,
0.052317135,
0.0000018764,
0.0001725617,
0.0169847254,
0.011603009,
-0.0173588209,
0.0061899801,
0.0187347326,
0.0012073301,
-0.0063832593,
-0.0002364416,
0.0019092984,
-0.033013884,
0.0661162734,
0.0478372276,
0.0032192271,
0.1218123212,
0.0106221912,
-0.0215119906,
0.0745068118,
-0.0410430208,
0.0098006427,
-0.0171444025,
0.0196032245,
-0.0123399263,
0.0014224561,
0.0229474846,
-0.0290429238,
0.0122421142,
0.0247265808,
0.0391888507,
0.0418821983,
0.053024739,
0.0495079383,
-0.0301004983,
-0.0128246779,
0.0388275795,
-0.0620806664,
-0.0041729929,
0.0022592137,
-0.0008354787,
-0.0163502935,
0.0247431081,
-0.0402392969,
0.0207652282,
0.0089453757,
0.0213018842,
0.0186035521,
0.0237035025,
0.0550905652,
0.0235413816,
-0.0731767789,
0.0304450095,
0.0216994118,
0.0000352615,
-0.0191665161,
-0.0147869196,
-0.0316704363,
-0.0465908945,
0.0230133459,
0.0283045135,
-0.0169646144,
-0.0055135251,
-0.0234876852,
-0.0255438499,
-0.0143008763,
-0.0016184832,
0.0258339439,
0.0423097461,
0.0092461882,
0.0614691079,
-0.0298163574,
0.0218972396,
-0.0363719985,
0.0278811455,
-0.033623334,
-0.0194963738,
-0.0518583544,
-0.0063337092,
-0.0180710573,
0.0311844815,
0.0057533192,
-0.0391438082,
-0.0298693515,
-0.0028162454,
-0.0109724803,
-0.0013332682,
0.0207427721,
0.0029874067,
-0.0357054844,
-0.0420633443,
-0.0219625775,
0.0362012498,
-0.0488619953,
0.0287667494,
0.0371371396,
-0.0383733772,
0.0114895441,
0.0422231592,
-0.0179173741,
-0.0205456726,
0.0257316399,
0.0516900159,
-0.0437022671,
-0.0375416502,
0.0018290483,
0.0166952554,
-0.033963941,
-0.0810818821,
0.0161600392,
-0.0943888575,
0.0635831207,
0.0091700824,
0.0278533194,
-0.0450906903,
-0.0090043014,
-0.0145954136,
-0.0543604232,
0.0255089849,
-0.0332121961,
0.0109855896,
0.0164570995,
0.0135230953,
-0.0475400835,
0.0574991144,
0.0182959735,
0.023493994,
-0.001581628,
-0.0032530853,
0.0189942755,
-0.0030822775,
-0.0129320836,
-0.0112083033,
-0.0195700452,
-0.0236192234,
-0.0220152587,
0.0199005753,
0.043623779,
0.0768004954,
-0.070723772,
-0.02014268,
0.0554333478,
0.0328904241,
0.0278342906,
0.0647105202,
0.0616197251,
-0.0284111034,
0.0326719657,
0.0358339101,
-0.0424524136,
0.0130981551,
-0.0335933305,
-0.0088953618,
0.0289444961,
0.0684608519,
-0.0577377751,
-0.0316011496,
0.0202829055,
-0.0066469824,
-0.0495672897,
0.0190322995,
0.0744363964,
-0.0339422561,
0.0091268569,
0.003596318,
0.0398336761,
-0.0037497617,
0.0212802254,
-0.0795962438,
0.0285691191,
0.0592100322,
0.0237214565,
-0.0319580436,
-0.0088962587,
-0.0021762848,
-0.03484587,
-0.0100684697,
0.0316830389,
0.012403965,
0.0117052123,
-0.0784050003,
-0.0102583626,
-0.0281008203,
0.0352361463,
0.0397626236,
0.0215354357,
-0.0008387216,
0.0188775398,
-0.025495993,
-0.0080929855,
0.0215484705,
-0.0260766,
0.0202759746,
0.0112793259,
0.0056096553,
0.0293407012,
0.0004542453,
-0.0412266031,
0.0389227755,
0.0003836434,
-0.0462265573,
-0.0184658244,
-0.0241097864,
-0.0770140216,
-0.0163503122,
0.0429417528,
-0.0100706518,
0.0135163292,
-0.0195008963,
-0.0125198225,
-0.0576494522,
0.0237965882,
-0.0338846929,
0.0339701846,
-0.0458865091,
-0.0150208035,
0.0157156959,
0.0241521075,
-0.019595325,
0.0772003084,
-0.0294455495,
-0.0088567883,
0.0159094632,
0.0149640096,
-0.0085944999,
-0.00987102,
-0.0300507508,
-0.0092633786,
0.0087795304,
0.0580697171,
0.0092366207,
-0.0214694161,
0.0037321339,
-0.1169217899,
-0.1096547842,
0.0166191123,
-0.0441634767,
-0.0174501799,
0.0007602475,
-0.0022870363,
0.0007319212,
0.0336472169,
-0.0154118454,
0.0165741872,
-0.0058038952,
0.017184373,
-0.0203089006,
0.0204851516,
-0.0266943611,
-0.0323829986,
-0.072245203,
-0.0035495532,
0.0602562055,
-0.0462462716,
-0.0180714708,
-0.0410130844,
-0.0189962201,
-0.0415844545,
0.0200712252,
-0.0337345675,
-0.0194599349,
0.0061281933,
-0.0653625503,
0.0941839218,
0.0604634807,
-0.0029529016,
0.0508425608,
0.0527949519,
-0.0094332425,
-0.01152262,
0.0209559426,
-0.0214404222,
0.0317161307,
-0.058121819,
-0.0024484496,
-0.032550741,
0.0634319857,
0.0025866528,
-0.0467069447,
-0.0518357344,
0.0037610501,
-0.0017005183,
-0.0452624336,
-0.0036281913,
-0.0010141139,
0.0163192693,
0.0362955369,
-0.0260656513,
-0.0315446369,
0.0451358147,
-0.0060334853,
0.0006102197,
-0.0055438676,
-0.0534651279,
-0.0390205272,
0.0146957403,
0.0310133193,
0.0330936015,
-0.0356671289,
-0.0061654216,
-0.0465214439,
0.0082490453,
-0.0059771119,
-0.0076155402,
0.0276376177,
-0.0185921788,
0.0148351751,
0.0033370159,
-0.0329266898,
0.0200199112,
-0.0161875486,
-0.0442538895,
0.0586738624,
0.0489877015,
-0.0459882766,
-0.0491650663,
0.0277492683,
0.0258288756,
0.0546032861,
-0.0407075547,
0.0168616269,
-0.037880525,
0.0367918238,
0.0173005555,
0.0148622477,
0.0323276669,
-0.0666266009,
0.0153698446,
0.0145125818,
0.0503667928,
-0.0321364813,
-0.0538637452,
0.0051778629,
0.0060927509,
0.0000691678,
-0.0320201889,
0.0183418225,
0.0558816493,
-0.0522281379,
0.0074750124,
0.1006401032,
-0.0158466548,
-0.0663488358,
-0.0098885363,
0.0421135463,
0.0492385253,
0.0038154803,
0.0377339125,
-0.016400747,
-0.0114797344,
0.0048109973,
-0.0254326742,
0.0073271762,
-0.0164342858,
0.01183281,
-0.0755694956,
0.0230283421,
0.0195810162,
-0.0476769991,
-0.0437246598,
-0.0145340888,
-0.0147149181,
-0.0263010282,
0.0251932684,
0.00640174,
0.0052925497,
-0.0156724639,
0.0331858471,
0.0178978853,
-0.0597034097,
0.0210185759,
-0.056551706,
0.0835251734,
0.0250211693,
-0.0201226696,
-0.0157444868,
-0.0011034027,
0.020805344,
0.0021535817,
0.0165182371,
0.0043355376,
0.0136001995,
-0.0224730019,
-0.0206911247,
-0.0004240347,
0.0130402232,
0.0026466369,
-0.0015128537,
-0.0288858358,
0.0778639615,
-0.0120545616,
-0.0425935909,
-0.0110007366,
-0.0266616996,
-0.0319197848,
0.0545483641,
0.0360981934,
-0.0464132093,
-0.0251032356,
-0.0180357099,
-0.0348423161,
0.0061603524,
0.005027778,
0.0161572509,
0.024640657,
-0.0850967243,
-0.0156562608,
-0.0116400486,
0.052894637,
0.0642219782,
-0.0043435604,
0.0072907121,
0.0024607666,
-0.0012026337,
0.0082562864,
0.0203680079,
-0.0269191097,
-0.0015558244,
-0.0887361541,
-0.0291861668,
0.0417712927,
-0.0231860634,
-0.0103279054,
-0.0343092494,
-0.0955270305,
-0.0840057209,
-0.0178319756,
0.0807803199,
0.020960208,
0.0333884619,
-0.0167313479,
-0.1046627834,
0.0815327689,
0.0323781036,
-0.0536694415,
0.0050170985,
0.0205616951,
-0.0307071432,
-0.0012003869,
0.0305652879,
-0.0084849512,
0.0090403771,
0.049777668,
0.0222448632,
-0.0484929867,
0.0168005563,
-0.0028242085,
-0.0450331308,
0.0234909151,
0.0037824793,
0.0336293466,
-0.0545120053,
0.0073723742,
0.0054242639,
-0.0006017353,
-0.0514177717,
-0.0130541623,
0.0555561259,
0.018167885,
0.0175759941,
0.01276136,
0.0678714067,
0.0318901911,
0.001127527,
0.0115743559,
-0.0067509315,
-0.0181528777,
0.0224257577,
0.0059168735,
-0.0228368919,
0.0271936096,
-0.0129763465,
-0.0029974033,
-0.0208605267,
0.0358204022,
0.0013798831,
-0.0258259811,
-0.0428993255,
0.019126704,
-0.1023337916,
-0.0774046108,
-0.0025271021,
0.0772176832,
0.0601798482,
-0.0164755061,
0.0299662836,
-0.0126634892,
-0.0158089977,
-0.0367506668,
0.0061872452,
-0.0147873582,
0.0202057455,
0.0140597597,
0.0357679464,
0.0142240375,
-0.006817528,
0.0743035525,
0.0372365043,
0.0096722571,
0.0216337144,
0.007960421,
-0.0316198021,
-0.0030112094,
0.0196476951,
0.0326565355,
-0.0511513688,
0.0164561421,
-0.0212675668,
-0.0466849431,
-0.0344713144,
-0.0034814752,
0.0169882942,
0.0046293736,
0.0191084165,
0.0416985601,
-0.0417285673,
-0.0017983707,
-0.0210837293,
-0.0153410714,
0.0338800922,
-0.0007382859,
-0.0061309976,
-6.566451034e-33,
-0.0046085515,
0.0008195901,
0.03015716,
-0.0657246485,
0.0185774378,
-0.0184153412,
-0.0045204558,
0.0197438113,
-0.0342639424,
0.0074071647,
-0.0388231166,
0.0052350215,
0.0041126618,
0.0321451947,
0.0142170005,
0.0159885157,
0.0655080825,
-0.0142312031,
0.0159172136,
0.0370848626,
0.0045052092,
0.0093748104,
0.0542962886,
-0.0337090045,
-0.0391002111,
0.0317384861,
-0.0230314378,
0.0333974548,
-0.0378916301,
0.0745810121,
-0.0235145893,
0.0244150106,
0.0320249423,
0.0086031426,
-0.0308885351,
-0.0373800062,
-0.0522450581,
-0.0284078065,
0.006338892,
-0.0304942522,
-0.0113175763,
-0.0399781466,
0.0777825788,
0.0038422383,
0.013129889,
-0.0327021517,
0.0327209122,
-0.0050179395,
-0.0535339005,
-0.004942887,
-0.026776636,
0.0396848135,
0.0079854829,
0.0112600755,
0.0188084915,
-0.0360638909,
-0.0155523084,
-0.0059893043,
-0.0033138599,
0.0044096136,
0.0412254967,
0.0819243118,
0.0043546609,
0.0492284447,
0.009174047,
0.0325650908,
0.0661690682,
0.0252732839,
-0.0316526182,
-0.0165417604,
0.04384581,
0.0624207482,
0.0591674447,
-0.0273909178,
0.0388730206,
0.0027573297,
-0.0437245145,
-0.0263718944,
0.0477569811,
0.0406795815,
0.0671771094,
0.0209180787,
-0.0204415843,
-0.0155303273,
-0.0283087343,
-0.0554505028,
-0.0531431101,
-0.0300683398,
0.0001819052,
0.0480898097,
-0.0207640138,
-0.0353206433,
0.0407797545,
-0.0505063795,
-0.010466163,
0.0056386879,
-0.0115023758,
0.0403700732,
0.0084417695,
0.033897832,
-0.1161245704,
-0.057954412,
0.0035647096,
-0.0146989645,
-0.0371913649,
0.0113463048,
0.0261679441,
0.030752847,
-0.0524302311,
-0.0210747086,
-0.0318346284,
-0.0002587496,
0.0308944844,
0.0781358257,
0.0330410078,
0.0105117885,
-0.0047556018,
0.0010234413,
-0.0046452251,
-0.006357694,
-0.0075774593,
-0.0081685334,
0.0077220225,
0.0084759966,
-0.0116480347,
0.0209547207,
-0.0762035549,
-0.0510250553,
0.0342133082,
-0.0179759245,
-0.0101002594,
0.0166161004,
2.594e-7,
0.0003502782,
0.0398031175,
-0.0122461347,
-0.0265069213,
0.0274798423,
0.0064162998,
-0.027055895,
0.0082319761,
0.003446958,
-0.0370843038,
0.0388249718,
0.0676485747,
0.0225911085,
0.0116182901,
-0.0765422434,
0.0127529893,
-0.0356503054,
0.0353026167,
-0.0427348763,
-0.01893658,
0.0088479044,
0.1371036172,
0.0277131405,
-0.0114391576,
0.0070052519,
-0.0342745408,
0.0583702698,
-0.024698291,
-0.0057565011,
0.0432410575,
0.0813886598,
0.0288815349,
-0.0075420826,
0.0353326797,
0.0392597914,
0.0605632216,
0.0247668102,
0.0834068656,
-0.0271388069,
0.0059518893,
0.0452902317,
-0.0063681705,
-0.0103707258,
-0.0507871956,
0.0549175963,
-0.0187286194,
-0.0196174365,
-0.0357718952,
0.0130406842,
-0.0173921771,
0.0074855443,
-0.0478493907,
-0.0455265269,
0.0143013932,
0.0116538331,
-0.0213549435,
0.0093869036,
-0.0757473782,
0.0099747656,
-0.0006192572,
-0.0797348991,
-0.0694375783,
-0.033169847,
0.0000428537,
0.0704825148,
-0.0250927974,
-0.0136630395,
2.5048065e-34,
0.0614622831,
0.0058537824,
0.003706147,
0.01856816,
0.0365827791,
-0.0223699063,
-0.0658717826,
-0.0037035793,
0.0059254356,
-0.1045522615,
-0.0608532764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18200v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18200v1 | SEED: Accelerating Reasoning Tree Construction via Scheduled Speculative Decoding | 2024-06-26T09:33:41 | 2024-06-26T09:33:41 | Zhenglin Wang, Jialong Wu, Yilong Lai, Congzhi Zhang, Deyu Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable emergent abilities across
various tasks, yet fall short of complex reasoning and planning tasks. The
tree-search-based reasoning methods address this by surpassing the capabilities
of chain-of-thought prompting, encouraging exploration of intermediate steps.
However, such methods introduce significant inference latency due to the
systematic exploration and evaluation of multiple thought paths. This paper
introduces SeeD, a novel and efficient inference framework to optimize runtime
speed and GPU memory management concurrently. By employing a scheduled
speculative execution, SeeD efficiently handles multiple iterations for the
thought generation and the state evaluation, leveraging a rounds-scheduled
strategy to manage draft model dispatching. Extensive experimental evaluations
on three reasoning datasets demonstrate superior speedup performance of SeeD,
providing a viable path for batched inference in training-free speculative
decoding. | [
0.0354655609,
0.0510720909,
-0.006856136,
0.022562921,
-0.0503505692,
0.0237316601,
-0.0222291686,
-0.0351964943,
-0.0230379011,
-0.0199615136,
0.0228434782,
-0.0732704848,
0.0074073388,
0.0252463445,
-0.0335558243,
-0.0356248729,
0.0295971297,
-0.0753278658,
0.0339827575,
-0.0140146157,
-0.0322943293,
0.0381735228,
-0.0252163317,
0.0279687122,
0.0093247723,
-0.0424095578,
-0.0601513721,
0.0074368198,
0.0013226192,
-0.0441259779,
-0.0472744852,
0.0332993194,
0.0249079019,
0.0474010892,
0.0000022405,
-0.0308989026,
-0.0207750667,
0.0009304755,
-0.0386648588,
0.0051248851,
0.0106312474,
0.0238156207,
-0.0171062704,
0.0276917573,
-0.027477067,
-0.0232524071,
0.029634973,
-0.0207456537,
0.0003242328,
0.0187464543,
-0.0078034415,
-0.0330652706,
0.0036381553,
0.012666286,
0.0078195781,
-0.0496255308,
-0.0000479925,
-0.0025320339,
-0.0199477393,
-0.0183278173,
-0.0152972434,
0.0234605446,
0.0469562858,
-0.000580315,
-0.0316205621,
0.038281817,
0.0116265994,
-0.0492098741,
-0.0294609312,
0.0125763752,
-0.0262373276,
-0.0448086448,
-0.0174341407,
-0.0030635316,
-0.0436976589,
-0.059819147,
-0.0087079052,
0.0909534097,
-0.0708337501,
0.0112195499,
0.1108609736,
0.0054996088,
0.0239949431,
0.0151780443,
-0.0535040759,
0.0977391675,
0.0304295644,
-0.0214070883,
-0.0100816237,
0.0106749525,
-0.0067159152,
-0.0720116496,
0.0244959723,
0.0396343321,
-0.0566620976,
0.038516961,
-0.0430814251,
-0.0244282819,
-0.0167084783,
-0.0009152009,
0.0286746696,
0.0958461091,
0.0206338018,
0.0230980795,
-0.0259228535,
-0.0076648053,
-0.0154085057,
0.0146244904,
-0.0436614789,
0.0138744991,
-0.0306143314,
-0.0076128808,
-0.0530067794,
0.0305239521,
-0.0593412891,
-0.0167387929,
-0.0084401872,
0.0397028103,
0.0132408263,
-0.003628202,
0.0418676622,
0.0133456122,
-0.008514056,
0.0005996283,
-0.0257341694,
-0.010120919,
-0.0358718298,
0.0035933787,
0.0117494306,
-0.0426542647,
-0.0149098141,
0.0031718144,
-0.0117885983,
-0.0021192404,
0.0018832154,
0.029960556,
-0.0491031408,
-0.0163509864,
-0.0552745089,
-0.0334919468,
0.0266373903,
-0.0731214136,
0.0096339723,
-0.0444496721,
0.0243118331,
0.012381251,
-0.0094335284,
0.0295141637,
0.0105472999,
0.0320729129,
-0.0002076221,
0.0505937114,
-0.0392726585,
0.0028295056,
0.0102434456,
0.0147783002,
0.0182496328,
0.0917361975,
0.0415563546,
0.0450843573,
-0.0163253006,
0.0228269193,
-0.0144644156,
0.0381107032,
0.0086918585,
-0.0306309666,
0.0211166795,
0.0211484712,
-0.0384861641,
0.0539594367,
0.0066811875,
0.0442333035,
-0.0298840441,
0.0209482983,
0.0284357723,
0.0607820265,
-0.0370264277,
0.0330940261,
0.071976386,
0.0008552304,
-0.0130228121,
-0.0190966278,
-0.025188826,
0.0189200696,
-0.0494221412,
0.0250493251,
-0.0078576412,
0.0499410108,
0.0055130082,
-0.0033142464,
-0.0106402962,
0.0284087788,
0.017837083,
0.026598813,
0.0620571896,
0.0193004254,
-0.059619192,
0.0324817412,
0.0043548457,
-0.0078580631,
-0.0695226416,
-0.0531733669,
0.030025363,
0.0810852647,
0.0400401279,
0.0164783951,
-0.0428964756,
0.0290659182,
-0.0145522607,
0.038730897,
-0.0118862754,
-0.0228706375,
0.0195871778,
-0.0456856601,
-0.0088632079,
0.0422064401,
0.0036362354,
0.0452753939,
0.0443166085,
-0.0041676089,
-0.0262129456,
-0.0069143251,
-0.0253725071,
0.0164855681,
0.0054438426,
-0.0144188553,
0.0103248842,
0.0110006044,
0.0114092035,
-0.0163291246,
0.0064716809,
0.0160092879,
0.028604228,
-0.0388046168,
-0.0021490084,
0.017484365,
-0.0653780252,
-0.0510732159,
0.0204747561,
0.0265295133,
-0.0203040652,
-0.0163278859,
-0.0341631658,
-0.0351330079,
0.0224104691,
-0.0271657612,
0.0558167808,
-0.0389909819,
0.041142419,
-0.0000901172,
-0.0287736654,
-0.0053216922,
0.0753427669,
-0.0469374768,
-0.0197561346,
0.0436378792,
0.0368126109,
0.0026087728,
-0.027722124,
0.0187793989,
0.0262601264,
-0.0276333392,
-0.0267618541,
-0.029621724,
0.0064819562,
-0.0291903671,
0.0196712874,
-0.0753120705,
0.0095430864,
-0.0143553475,
0.0272583999,
0.0122744404,
0.0039158226,
-0.0136776911,
0.0022759882,
0.0171502456,
0.0483831763,
0.0028480906,
0.0197659172,
-0.0107024964,
-0.004828285,
-0.0506769083,
0.0022017765,
-0.0090552336,
-0.0333744511,
0.0403551385,
-0.0048478739,
-0.0470557958,
-0.0541083291,
0.0533621721,
0.001147398,
0.0251400433,
-0.003026065,
-0.0006191487,
0.0308128912,
-0.0341856293,
0.0270547289,
0.0455519781,
-0.0133518139,
-0.0100064557,
0.0650354698,
-0.0174514465,
-0.0253543016,
0.0302108247,
0.002772047,
-0.010715316,
-0.0191916078,
-0.0270978641,
-0.0340552181,
0.0896086469,
0.0088633634,
0.0060713794,
-0.0605571754,
0.0112704728,
-0.0005872718,
-0.055332642,
-0.026049614,
-0.0253459234,
0.0049150381,
0.0803744048,
-0.0315513797,
-0.0655768439,
0.0798257589,
-0.0494332686,
-0.0064603612,
-0.0461708866,
0.006705822,
-0.0114878397,
0.0997706205,
-0.0146206962,
0.0118484069,
0.0041659181,
-0.0267529432,
0.0013301482,
0.032955844,
0.0093139671,
-0.0318578966,
0.017037224,
-0.0558099225,
0.0169840083,
-0.0238276534,
-0.0344593227,
-0.0432874635,
-0.0034365337,
-0.0678511262,
-0.0129714934,
0.078861475,
-0.0336109847,
0.0192023441,
0.0144372536,
-0.036644835,
0.0593957454,
-0.0008424945,
-0.022528287,
0.0033645572,
-0.0123584969,
0.0357815176,
-0.0212296341,
0.0308661889,
-0.007386466,
0.0682143793,
0.0601633266,
0.0549191609,
-0.0265595205,
-0.0671282113,
0.0246886946,
0.0229521934,
0.0224659052,
0.0102894548,
0.0413585529,
0.0296248384,
-0.0912641659,
-0.0596366823,
0.0893802643,
0.0451210476,
-0.0514184348,
-0.0033291983,
-0.0365415663,
0.0728681162,
0.0065912926,
0.055004891,
-0.1082508862,
-0.039869085,
0.0412216187,
0.0049989857,
-0.0272428412,
-0.0516262203,
-0.0285490099,
-0.1094394475,
0.0466333702,
-0.0118600642,
0.0075572305,
0.0168147795,
-0.0163130425,
-0.0455981717,
0.0365655981,
-0.0581039079,
0.0357448049,
0.0262741353,
0.0250420235,
0.0028264355,
-0.0146738626,
0.0046231928,
0.0557205342,
-0.0012501748,
0.0022488465,
0.0413780771,
0.0044375225,
0.0570798963,
-0.0498117879,
-0.024321517,
-0.0049642064,
0.0090611652,
-0.0632406995,
-0.0052024256,
-0.0228276197,
0.0262884237,
-0.0212018359,
0.0252102837,
-0.0477575883,
-0.0391112976,
0.013397512,
0.1065454781,
-0.0500647537,
-0.0443797372,
-0.010377598,
-0.0112192668,
0.032760229,
0.0637418553,
0.0005177718,
-0.0205694549,
-0.0545555837,
-0.0546660759,
-0.0276653431,
-0.0946168229,
-0.0101691531,
-0.0023280196,
0.0723605454,
0.0161649529,
-0.0190362632,
0.0079496792,
0.0578504167,
0.0520258881,
-0.01444594,
0.0026882221,
0.007319524,
0.0085480614,
-0.0930164233,
-0.0112318955,
-0.0022848689,
0.0137906298,
-0.0115675805,
-0.0148687474,
0.0132057006,
-0.0280852336,
-0.0174722262,
0.0520231687,
-0.1173035502,
-0.0277787503,
-0.0116884205,
0.0355687216,
0.0252025276,
0.0470933504,
-0.0267692264,
0.0009427094,
0.023466086,
0.0039736438,
-0.0191273112,
0.0060556121,
0.0044561005,
-0.0089865252,
0.0168483667,
0.0370293967,
0.00039167,
0.0192615557,
0.0095801167,
0.0410290696,
0.0139566958,
0.0122431098,
0.0183703918,
0.0255453028,
-0.0006722435,
-0.0472573377,
-0.0259061158,
-0.0094073871,
0.0497105941,
-0.0080041504,
-0.02436403,
-0.0309588071,
0.0427131951,
0.0242260303,
-0.02087304,
-0.00951102,
-0.0439488553,
0.0470012873,
-0.0247314665,
0.0281768795,
-0.0319024362,
0.0504425205,
0.0147349304,
0.0438921526,
-0.0248407181,
-0.0121092116,
0.0063743382,
-0.0146776317,
0.0552943945,
-0.0198715106,
0.0592969581,
0.025355,
-0.0043987664,
-0.0332452022,
-0.009593077,
-0.0520333536,
-0.1053349301,
-0.0176499374,
-0.0288847797,
0.0504564941,
0.0294409245,
0.0124825453,
-0.040348798,
0.0134284319,
0.0189082734,
0.0120477621,
0.001313376,
-0.0525342599,
0.0378216468,
0.0223464668,
-0.0148555851,
-0.004981169,
0.0229772367,
0.006227531,
0.0422346219,
0.0424747281,
-0.037621174,
-0.0273940694,
-0.0436488688,
-0.0960864723,
0.0354135446,
-0.0148076648,
-0.0039110724,
-0.0430357382,
-0.0395365804,
-0.0016297239,
0.0407940485,
0.0041778162,
0.0046845009,
0.0384410284,
0.0571350753,
0.0105545446,
-0.0493414551,
0.0009656637,
0.030068364,
-0.0113807134,
0.0034869646,
-0.0446745828,
-6.585178128e-33,
-0.0040345145,
-0.0302414503,
0.0828051493,
-0.0438257158,
-0.006712039,
-0.0130112022,
-0.0554790199,
0.0001925556,
0.0105497008,
0.0166754648,
-0.0298636239,
0.0314815566,
0.0238642935,
0.0385697149,
0.0308806486,
0.0179636646,
0.0330889151,
-0.0186332185,
-0.0136478227,
0.0192237999,
0.0371473134,
0.0394236445,
0.0102135427,
0.0054523209,
-0.0437954776,
0.0215102956,
0.0201267786,
0.0184218511,
-0.0514162257,
0.0189595968,
-0.035445299,
-0.0055881259,
0.0261260774,
-0.0201585703,
-0.0197029468,
0.0135057317,
-0.0868539512,
-0.0077781151,
0.0403860733,
-0.0073346458,
-0.0723080263,
-0.0028915755,
-0.0474342294,
0.0421574749,
0.021682892,
-0.0403715707,
-0.0491259359,
-0.0206869803,
-0.0052179121,
-0.0429797992,
-0.0646290332,
0.0255443081,
0.0247075334,
0.0098345364,
0.0616269261,
-0.0073342468,
-0.0258594565,
0.0064259823,
-0.0228351094,
0.0090176463,
-0.017278349,
0.0234930869,
0.0890944526,
0.0191772375,
0.007915508,
0.0338693187,
0.0229357406,
-0.0090249302,
-0.0676098838,
0.0481201597,
0.0059860544,
0.037521299,
-0.0203763787,
0.0022269888,
0.0795102641,
0.0225954261,
-0.0613949932,
-0.0180156808,
0.0321221389,
0.0384374596,
0.0621513017,
0.016120946,
0.000364787,
-0.0457076244,
-0.0380910449,
-0.0249921121,
-0.0350447036,
-0.0034123433,
0.0445899591,
0.0252676625,
-0.0341814123,
-0.0006658013,
0.0379905216,
-0.002558308,
0.0378165543,
0.0215728078,
-0.000705503,
0.0200661607,
-0.0086509408,
0.0571587645,
-0.0137130618,
-0.0303428341,
0.0124270665,
-0.0069233757,
0.0233731885,
0.0156888142,
-0.0189747196,
0.0088893166,
-0.0502163023,
-0.0073583205,
-0.0684273392,
0.0415290892,
-0.0081782946,
0.0510402843,
0.0535622686,
0.0243978538,
0.0056948527,
0.021751469,
-0.0040363651,
0.0474098101,
-0.0326474719,
0.0126713747,
-0.005241537,
0.0215108395,
0.0017029734,
-0.0094951503,
-0.0364711992,
-0.0271275025,
0.0150185423,
-0.0968181416,
-0.0130194416,
0.0801337436,
2.945e-7,
0.0146338539,
0.0481906794,
0.0128548089,
0.0200204756,
0.0273854807,
-0.0108774761,
0.0287253074,
-0.0339842588,
0.0459815413,
-0.0397871137,
0.0042775734,
0.0299819335,
0.0447445214,
0.0401126519,
-0.0883639604,
-0.0402558073,
-0.0294155385,
0.0116255134,
-0.0472562537,
-0.01798179,
0.0272278581,
0.0997704118,
-0.0194462687,
-0.0291213971,
0.0508529767,
0.0097397566,
0.0019834121,
0.0073274532,
0.0182254259,
-0.0109333135,
-0.0162550565,
0.0103566507,
-0.0080748862,
0.0441857241,
-0.00696126,
0.0134456689,
-0.0768220425,
0.0344676487,
-0.0108196614,
0.0124373538,
-0.0050402842,
-0.0418101512,
-0.0054854397,
-0.0359458961,
0.0594017021,
-0.032759577,
-0.0172209386,
0.0076496834,
0.0238983594,
-0.0016151168,
-0.0448692665,
0.0102809891,
0.0426220745,
0.0159646906,
0.0128362123,
-0.0262213405,
-0.0061019603,
-0.0783159807,
-0.0139021967,
-0.0037185319,
-0.0493114851,
-0.0398908146,
-0.0587601997,
0.0107925721,
0.0297335405,
-0.0589090921,
-0.0008661915,
3.197913785e-34,
0.0385197625,
0.0241025742,
0.0045110346,
0.0660147667,
0.0241723824,
-0.0009012123,
0.0481540076,
0.0028633038,
0.0013407791,
-0.1067743972,
-0.0392374918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18192v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18192v2 | Methodology of Adapting Large English Language Models for Specific Cultural Contexts | 2024-06-26T09:16:08 | 2024-06-27T02:17:19 | Wenjing Zhang, Siqi Xiao, Xuejiao Lei, Ning Wang, Huazheng Zhang, Meijuan An, Bikun Yang, Zhaoxiang Liu, Kai Wang, Shiguo Lian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rapid growth of large language models(LLMs) has emerged as a prominent
trend in the field of artificial intelligence. However, current
state-of-the-art LLMs are predominantly based on English. They encounter
limitations when directly applied to tasks in specific cultural domains, due to
deficiencies in domain-specific knowledge and misunderstandings caused by
differences in cultural values. To address this challenge, our paper proposes a
rapid adaptation method for large models in specific cultural contexts, which
leverages instruction-tuning based on specific cultural knowledge and safety
values data. Taking Chinese as the specific cultural context and utilizing the
LLaMA3-8B as the experimental English LLM, the evaluation results demonstrate
that the adapted LLM significantly enhances its capabilities in domain-specific
knowledge and adaptability to safety values, while maintaining its original
expertise advantages. | [
0.0487638451,
0.008747437,
-0.0345802978,
0.0282129366,
-0.0124724079,
0.0337786004,
0.0202197842,
-0.031287685,
-0.0032258406,
-0.0309516527,
-0.0678492561,
-0.0503319763,
-0.0193364266,
0.0127134807,
0.0156283397,
-0.0427160896,
0.0509420186,
-0.0316194631,
0.009894181,
-0.0128660398,
0.0186944511,
0.0082448544,
-0.0137929413,
0.0329529829,
-0.0002811221,
0.00281833,
0.0165024325,
0.0162838269,
0.0433888994,
-0.0372249186,
0.0344975963,
0.016895391,
0.0346769504,
-0.0060303039,
0.0000021322,
-0.0609787181,
0.0091973273,
-0.0431702882,
0.0089099193,
0.0286390148,
0.0781809613,
-0.0123516107,
-0.0526390485,
0.031543538,
-0.0454740375,
0.0114460839,
0.0349502452,
0.0416009314,
0.033389058,
0.0790389776,
0.0045935698,
-0.0221739877,
-0.0046798009,
0.0083180843,
-0.0352037288,
-0.0540587083,
0.0343836471,
0.0661805868,
0.0448131599,
-0.0034323607,
-0.0549866669,
0.0267533865,
0.0286667272,
-0.0008695524,
-0.044341363,
-0.0021992209,
-0.0269653108,
0.0133614531,
-0.0280701425,
0.0514919572,
-0.0141401635,
-0.0069484846,
-0.0152603639,
-0.0143973585,
-0.0175625533,
-0.029615216,
-0.0346561931,
0.0295449086,
0.0087857982,
0.0080309669,
0.0559135117,
-0.0202075075,
0.0264368635,
0.0395958051,
0.0009416905,
0.0810397342,
-0.0085476618,
-0.0185244214,
-0.001018157,
-0.0243777651,
0.0019653549,
-0.0143595291,
0.0432407483,
0.0602970272,
-0.0118093556,
0.0429398865,
-0.0151819624,
-0.0076061231,
0.0132991495,
-0.0910767391,
0.045576036,
0.0529214703,
-0.0149256866,
0.0124472519,
-0.0091837216,
0.0518773831,
0.0029050838,
0.0296839606,
-0.074523598,
-0.0000644677,
-0.0577004291,
0.0037012147,
-0.019068718,
-0.0035185863,
-0.0105459644,
-0.003250723,
-0.0768575743,
0.0349416174,
-0.0041078306,
-0.0130853001,
0.0058219549,
-0.0216419119,
-0.0365859158,
-0.0078554777,
-0.0124538187,
0.0379703827,
-0.0373089686,
0.0331460163,
-0.032946378,
-0.0402690172,
0.0410259776,
0.0184523817,
-0.0309193302,
-0.0164412688,
0.0162522513,
0.0650546476,
-0.0282070972,
0.0033225287,
-0.0861039534,
0.0455434658,
-0.014333806,
-0.0308556184,
0.0333670452,
-0.0438063629,
0.010443138,
-0.0207705311,
0.0159873124,
-0.0569925383,
0.0103416368,
0.0075630657,
-0.0079086469,
0.0221251901,
0.004437367,
0.025122121,
0.0468783602,
0.0137918573,
-0.0052380092,
0.1035771817,
0.0613263436,
0.0192123633,
0.0411142558,
-0.0271538738,
-0.0404208004,
0.0595891252,
-0.0229348857,
0.0128753213,
-0.0512504578,
-0.0063605472,
-0.0152473114,
-0.0033086848,
0.0205029752,
0.034021154,
0.0246271566,
0.030746622,
0.0412264243,
0.0270373933,
-0.0038991245,
0.0300440826,
0.0622730404,
0.0031717455,
0.0157425664,
-0.0142257689,
-0.056178268,
-0.0024340036,
-0.0610647872,
-0.0063690445,
-0.0577053726,
0.0633399636,
-0.0306732468,
-0.0492521524,
-0.0268236734,
-0.0059381705,
0.0418767408,
0.0169831309,
0.0302826203,
-0.0182723403,
0.0171404127,
0.0239119977,
0.035634052,
-0.0138929747,
-0.0147911822,
-0.0491078012,
-0.0073828097,
0.1109391525,
0.0050495313,
-0.0131710181,
-0.0602946989,
0.0250787865,
0.0201354958,
0.0304683875,
0.0570656061,
-0.0260517932,
-0.0120552359,
-0.0576262027,
-0.0208290108,
0.0226572473,
-0.0032596951,
0.0178455301,
0.0388595052,
0.0323048867,
0.0052954531,
-0.0009565981,
-0.076739803,
0.0125735626,
-0.0777225345,
-0.0267919805,
-0.0204993207,
0.0109266192,
0.0281926058,
0.0276580472,
-0.0024690537,
-0.0161018874,
-0.0040893112,
-0.0380028598,
-0.0079012513,
0.0259995554,
-0.056783095,
0.0315971524,
0.0477368459,
-0.0237538945,
-0.0076652481,
0.0244383346,
-0.0433044769,
-0.0279194601,
-0.010977352,
-0.0299508572,
-0.0015280434,
-0.0352510288,
0.031310048,
-0.0493255109,
0.01352295,
-0.0300258864,
0.0569859073,
-0.025594499,
-0.0442755707,
-0.0228738058,
0.0272636581,
0.0012434085,
-0.0246515721,
-0.0546169244,
0.0057817795,
0.0037597457,
0.0543392934,
0.014785016,
0.0695604756,
-0.043193765,
-0.0155624114,
-0.0639499575,
-0.0109553766,
-0.0181020107,
0.0236512721,
0.0171549208,
-0.0234623104,
-0.0455578417,
-0.0085522439,
-0.0563831031,
0.0323703438,
-0.0208649561,
0.025171252,
0.0038202431,
0.0005206284,
-0.0439556018,
0.0066062235,
-0.0090074111,
-0.0231021997,
-0.007659676,
-0.0151863629,
-0.0518682562,
-0.0723800063,
0.0459602401,
-0.0339309275,
0.0159188882,
-0.0002433215,
-0.0674757287,
0.0004682827,
0.0288231764,
0.0844090283,
0.0631440431,
-0.0093738446,
0.0079703974,
0.0762940794,
-0.0019295639,
-0.0188425872,
0.0120434789,
0.0183544755,
-0.0296311155,
-0.0328620337,
-0.0651755556,
-0.0227508638,
0.0581576079,
-0.0319261439,
-0.0064017698,
-0.0504191853,
-0.006882892,
-0.0632595867,
-0.0492153428,
-0.0034639447,
-0.019011071,
-0.0123642152,
0.0338927619,
-0.0181016382,
-0.0241140313,
0.0610238984,
0.0108571984,
0.0342976041,
-0.0649540052,
-0.0278323684,
-0.022897033,
0.0328442156,
-0.033836171,
0.049218785,
-0.0047915881,
-0.0219256915,
-0.0413361341,
-0.0031264189,
-0.0072524734,
-0.0525772832,
0.0493879281,
-0.0703991055,
-0.0212027561,
-0.0119926063,
-0.0259003509,
-0.0344001018,
0.0239337776,
-0.0280692689,
0.0438848212,
0.0048898491,
0.0041604941,
-0.0275759641,
0.0194030479,
0.0372313634,
0.0036504571,
-0.0132373394,
0.0400327183,
0.0027092479,
-0.058634907,
0.0518338121,
0.020727843,
0.016531894,
-0.032385245,
0.0624397025,
0.0274013579,
0.0565815568,
-0.0444189347,
-0.0243367366,
0.0319126323,
0.0252537485,
-0.0263203923,
-0.0135140801,
0.0562880188,
0.0587222204,
-0.0720514208,
0.0064208163,
0.0747083202,
0.0078613395,
-0.0201366656,
0.0269325431,
-0.0500389412,
-0.0175531674,
0.0217642356,
0.056586653,
-0.0622702837,
0.0029796783,
-0.0084910616,
0.0186736397,
-0.0050213886,
0.0031243607,
0.0131736482,
-0.1045573875,
0.024622865,
0.0146045666,
-0.0618755445,
-0.0407117344,
-0.0019920522,
-0.0084319096,
0.0010303251,
0.0741092712,
-0.0141347954,
-0.0372321494,
-0.054963097,
0.0211615637,
-0.0259273872,
-0.0966583043,
0.0386305377,
-0.0279727839,
0.0750133768,
0.0481381938,
-0.0001297975,
-0.0251073297,
-0.0187988542,
0.00313453,
0.0187266674,
0.020392267,
-0.0214594118,
-0.0172129087,
-0.0003469522,
0.0001590401,
0.0070807929,
-0.01078304,
0.0058250716,
-0.0105057303,
0.0437816158,
0.0665932,
-0.0177124906,
-0.0068546413,
-0.0320287757,
0.0126927178,
0.0042646285,
0.0517006665,
0.0166681055,
-0.0786892772,
0.0100317728,
-0.0266698617,
-0.069534719,
-0.0358347856,
-0.0553495735,
0.0642425492,
-0.0831733048,
-0.0406853929,
-0.0578732118,
-0.0357141308,
0.0113346968,
-0.0050285095,
0.0710735321,
-0.0186557434,
0.0369333699,
0.0080758175,
-0.0431448929,
0.0099849682,
-0.0287234504,
0.0310661905,
-0.0500835776,
0.0078976853,
0.0512215756,
-0.0394024253,
0.0208498165,
0.0096998708,
-0.0038733678,
-0.043967519,
0.0411341935,
0.0584176593,
0.0068575479,
0.0032111474,
-0.0066818721,
-0.060330186,
0.0528406762,
-0.0202168245,
0.0046318625,
0.0093299905,
0.0157484189,
0.0062599895,
-0.0021767637,
0.0174903329,
-0.0586686842,
0.0590563975,
0.04153952,
0.0553784743,
-0.0499029234,
-0.013046246,
-0.0029519722,
0.0487826094,
-0.0317663811,
-0.027006479,
-0.0132347243,
-0.0351211801,
0.0389045142,
-0.0216458272,
-0.0230610706,
-0.0012320983,
-0.0199350361,
0.0219529234,
-0.0201366525,
0.0127181932,
0.0057230764,
0.0104208384,
-0.0133932848,
-0.0256792717,
0.0767016932,
0.003275489,
0.0894434974,
-0.0037031998,
0.0349517241,
-0.0383349247,
0.0140871797,
0.0262267292,
0.0310687218,
0.0103082303,
0.0946613103,
-0.0165064,
-0.0079647554,
-0.0207259301,
0.0571096353,
-0.0139219873,
-0.023407869,
-0.022564495,
0.020759847,
0.0606911629,
-0.0092642661,
0.050260324,
-0.023494577,
0.000579901,
-0.032505732,
-0.0029436501,
0.0138927819,
-0.0429599136,
0.0342143252,
0.0135930842,
0.0096748248,
-0.0326529741,
0.042991057,
0.0006507759,
0.044367291,
0.019622853,
-0.0119463475,
-0.0244653691,
-0.0303708464,
0.0718319342,
-0.022454435,
-0.0629149899,
-0.0083129527,
-0.0640112162,
-0.0608413592,
-0.0163717456,
0.0093599372,
-0.0077510439,
-0.01495694,
0.0092504947,
0.0496007949,
-0.0021295359,
-0.0560502857,
-0.027073456,
-0.0274016261,
-0.0151280211,
-0.0001543854,
0.0377516225,
-6.414638877e-33,
-0.028487267,
-0.0061682193,
0.042906139,
-0.0234261546,
-0.0112560187,
-0.0128507204,
-0.0025804988,
0.0055198749,
-0.0392948985,
-0.000951677,
-0.020731261,
0.0103406897,
0.0139304092,
-0.0035967829,
0.018335646,
0.0238835346,
0.0079894941,
-0.0004134345,
0.006563073,
0.0070647299,
0.0269416105,
0.0321347378,
0.0807713494,
-0.0795513019,
0.0081695588,
0.0236781649,
-0.0031960723,
0.0162179023,
0.0004766051,
0.0841975734,
-0.004572046,
0.0485845916,
0.0346244052,
-0.0380302928,
-0.0219493676,
-0.0035978765,
-0.060981974,
-0.0302075036,
0.0384737179,
0.0288939364,
0.0289346334,
-0.0908687636,
0.0463808626,
-0.0244954973,
-0.0316510834,
0.0091175586,
0.0298009366,
-0.0658900589,
0.0181145575,
-0.011832254,
-0.0844318792,
0.0182057936,
0.0112033999,
0.0182156786,
0.0013665297,
0.0321502425,
-0.0288726594,
-0.0458606109,
-0.0179111604,
0.0191883352,
0.047454007,
0.0193897597,
0.0935082436,
0.0292790961,
-0.0232335515,
0.0222309884,
-0.0074261306,
0.0224951878,
0.0026121298,
-0.055008918,
0.0416679047,
0.0535464473,
0.0096658869,
0.0622687601,
-0.0036390834,
-0.0209447946,
-0.1057281047,
0.0383655988,
0.033099968,
0.0677592754,
0.0316358022,
-0.0013553082,
-0.066318661,
-0.0181820318,
0.0030303844,
0.0649077445,
-0.0155280167,
-0.0610998869,
0.0430338047,
-0.0171390325,
-0.0516111366,
-0.0161229689,
0.0089359181,
-0.0527172685,
0.0224000216,
-0.000281643,
0.015566648,
-0.0085501838,
-0.0059902924,
0.0377584286,
-0.0662968308,
-0.0651021525,
-0.0197188035,
-0.0173266474,
0.0089810668,
0.0031378595,
0.0235028658,
0.0513819009,
-0.047746487,
0.0093464246,
-0.0093044005,
-0.0180272628,
0.0437303148,
0.0034903313,
0.025465928,
-0.000137043,
-0.0056950171,
-0.0025554795,
0.0638496056,
-0.0384979136,
-0.0192713998,
-0.0592029095,
-0.0265568197,
0.0413481332,
-0.0427856408,
0.0255056433,
-0.0342699476,
0.0433257259,
0.0035787052,
-0.0568870679,
-0.0231776014,
0.0155721651,
2.829e-7,
0.0381940752,
0.0703518167,
-0.0189448539,
0.0469423048,
-0.0021075096,
-0.0066562654,
-0.0380369462,
0.0250387378,
0.0094071375,
0.0352204219,
0.0457617454,
0.055360239,
0.0526965186,
0.0465506017,
-0.0640946403,
-0.0260886457,
-0.0178988129,
0.0411097184,
-0.0571559444,
0.0344644152,
0.0259469431,
0.0764719173,
-0.0232370514,
-0.0211126246,
-0.0397134759,
-0.0364175066,
0.0144396862,
-0.0513212793,
-0.0001815218,
0.0438352711,
0.0116404584,
0.0542072356,
-0.0136164678,
0.0274689421,
0.0135881454,
0.0120457355,
0.013717033,
0.1045833826,
-0.0156542957,
0.0080911387,
0.0336046405,
0.0013161722,
-0.0067879129,
-0.0647002459,
0.0401264802,
-0.0160223786,
-0.0209201444,
0.0134227742,
0.0026966296,
-0.0046158833,
-0.0024118999,
-0.0410446227,
0.0060704281,
0.001348224,
0.0261869263,
-0.0062749279,
-0.0396943688,
-0.0203174949,
-0.0059783948,
0.0114874328,
0.0241224039,
-0.0720782429,
-0.0233936198,
-0.0064001083,
-0.0459659286,
-0.0453472249,
0.0292003974,
2.096677616e-34,
0.0067808572,
-0.0275115129,
-0.0094441893,
0.0194263589,
0.0335492864,
0.0182070676,
-0.0037183284,
0.0255726296,
-0.0029980012,
-0.0652799904,
-0.0221727211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18187v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18187v1 | Selective Prompting Tuning for Personalized Conversations with LLMs | 2024-06-26T09:03:52 | 2024-06-26T09:03:52 | Qiushi Huang, Xubo Liu, Tom Ko, Bo Wu, Wenwu Wang, Yu Zhang, Lilian Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In conversational AI, personalizing dialogues with persona profiles and
contextual understanding is essential. Despite large language models' (LLMs)
improved response coherence, effective persona integration remains a challenge.
In this work, we first study two common approaches for personalizing LLMs:
textual prompting and direct fine-tuning. We observed that textual prompting
often struggles to yield responses that are similar to the ground truths in
datasets, while direct fine-tuning tends to produce repetitive or overly
generic replies. To alleviate those issues, we propose \textbf{S}elective
\textbf{P}rompt \textbf{T}uning (SPT), which softly prompts LLMs for
personalized conversations in a selective way. Concretely, SPT initializes a
set of soft prompts and uses a trainable dense retriever to adaptively select
suitable soft prompts for LLMs according to different input contexts, where the
prompt retriever is dynamically updated through feedback from the LLMs.
Additionally, we propose context-prompt contrastive learning and prompt fusion
learning to encourage the SPT to enhance the diversity of personalized
conversations. Experiments on the CONVAI2 dataset demonstrate that SPT
significantly enhances response diversity by up to 90\%, along with
improvements in other critical performance indicators. Those results highlight
the efficacy of SPT in fostering engaging and personalized dialogue generation.
The SPT model code (https://github.com/hqsiswiliam/SPT) is publicly available
for further exploration. | [
0.0500583015,
0.0212575123,
-0.0197476558,
0.0256850459,
-0.007061719,
-0.0149587467,
0.0064090886,
-0.0366082825,
0.0070161247,
-0.0210404191,
-0.0409590378,
-0.0258729421,
0.0129937418,
0.0873595774,
0.0118570169,
-0.0756979436,
0.0437101014,
-0.0301634036,
0.0405878872,
-0.0094324946,
0.0051304745,
0.0219853818,
-0.0130511085,
0.0523315109,
-0.0100383023,
-0.0338422656,
-0.0446277261,
0.0323464163,
0.0313658789,
-0.0252902899,
0.0628497303,
0.0527066477,
0.0271461904,
0.0137923602,
0.0000022065,
-0.0532290861,
-0.0101815518,
-0.0321105421,
-0.0095275696,
-0.0231525693,
0.0236589592,
0.0438501984,
0.0110209193,
0.0367833599,
-0.0521212704,
0.0407593809,
0.0289544407,
0.0539678633,
0.0585264154,
0.0658017769,
-0.0085043432,
-0.0072445353,
0.0010318349,
-0.0282937009,
0.0018943342,
-0.0198936798,
-0.0309604667,
-0.0558481067,
0.0130900946,
0.0421003588,
0.0049436544,
0.0136304386,
0.0237842724,
-0.0165232271,
0.0357750766,
0.0532936379,
-0.0241592806,
-0.0287652388,
-0.0323702469,
0.1107803807,
0.0665992722,
0.0099776099,
-0.0059419125,
-0.0082165468,
0.0319964215,
-0.0457816981,
-0.0391598083,
0.0177369379,
-0.0071054352,
0.0128441257,
-0.0066265427,
0.0434962586,
-0.0134336324,
0.0229401104,
-0.0292637832,
0.0179354735,
0.0080020512,
-0.0236178394,
-0.0083726132,
0.0005030145,
0.0105806738,
-0.073089242,
-0.0077362079,
0.0384637192,
-0.0970679224,
0.011362642,
-0.0607115738,
0.0110460166,
0.0344091132,
0.0337642133,
0.0183429439,
0.0465202853,
-0.0469133183,
0.0250630695,
0.0130815497,
0.02079257,
0.0179854035,
0.0034015682,
-0.0182960443,
-0.0158916079,
-0.0342378393,
-0.0147574292,
-0.0235760007,
0.0360947028,
-0.0567332916,
-0.0257479288,
-0.020904718,
0.0591607951,
-0.0075931288,
0.0251239687,
-0.0080783553,
0.0282185022,
-0.0498014465,
0.0198452976,
-0.0504636057,
0.0165973343,
-0.0613574758,
-0.0097437073,
0.0515338145,
-0.0731366277,
-0.0256236531,
0.0150834676,
0.0225033499,
-0.0293519441,
-0.0076620793,
0.0123837367,
-0.0451512076,
-0.0662580207,
-0.0263495557,
-0.0264565498,
-0.0482954234,
-0.0647304282,
-0.0375616327,
-0.0340869352,
0.0365883633,
0.0071463832,
-0.011236609,
-0.0274900235,
0.0063412427,
0.0039883927,
-0.0112712439,
0.0391623639,
-0.0263521932,
0.004674552,
0.0317539498,
0.017040344,
-0.0306388959,
0.0411203988,
0.0119506391,
0.0255143233,
0.0187126398,
0.012268615,
0.005558176,
-0.0045539378,
0.0141285527,
0.0113692638,
0.0100700567,
0.0187771916,
0.0000516861,
0.0057746256,
0.045860026,
0.0617157929,
-0.0303562246,
-0.0004793454,
0.0766466483,
0.0250251181,
-0.0189003032,
0.0357281417,
0.0491745621,
0.0499351881,
-0.0126120597,
0.0305860806,
-0.0377117321,
0.0443282127,
-0.0272572041,
-0.0022658734,
0.0686781183,
0.0422373861,
-0.0417566299,
-0.0514472164,
0.0486440398,
-0.0125608891,
0.0243561789,
0.0299761798,
-0.0058188839,
0.0156631079,
-0.0608827844,
0.035090182,
0.0298432875,
-0.06888818,
-0.0281619839,
-0.0207837466,
0.0635356605,
0.092296578,
0.0336451083,
-0.0111608086,
-0.044006601,
-0.0218222756,
-0.0076848413,
0.0576416701,
0.0503384136,
-0.0085545108,
0.0574548915,
-0.0540785417,
-0.0149724055,
-0.0547255389,
-0.0162811819,
0.0519088544,
0.0118822251,
0.0043664393,
0.0115428595,
0.0383250974,
0.0141925933,
0.0029528451,
-0.0466967635,
-0.0136679625,
0.0402873009,
0.0185292009,
-0.0007317244,
0.0477703586,
0.0067165373,
-0.0046670511,
0.0266156625,
-0.0151276598,
-0.0009246805,
0.0122920172,
-0.0905089602,
-0.0376504138,
0.020003289,
0.0080264825,
-0.0332504995,
-0.015332167,
-0.0124962097,
-0.0558766387,
0.0229740832,
-0.0191032328,
0.0156317782,
-0.048979342,
0.0103365425,
0.0278109442,
0.0338664129,
-0.0313537791,
0.0600391887,
0.0106158461,
-0.0189703852,
0.0658781454,
0.0593683869,
-0.0081431316,
-0.0804612562,
-0.0083691878,
-0.0081758136,
0.0049345419,
-0.0163549148,
0.0243438687,
0.0224538278,
-0.0638365597,
-0.0652182251,
-0.102172628,
0.0123640997,
-0.0170706045,
-0.0339327976,
0.0093451524,
0.0521500334,
-0.0197650474,
-0.0177529696,
-0.0739861578,
-0.0163712651,
0.0396099277,
0.0060334257,
0.0500917658,
0.0186502952,
-0.0024957657,
-0.0498139895,
0.0327345841,
0.0226027556,
0.0135741904,
-0.0305418465,
0.0088385986,
-0.0378922299,
0.0249290243,
-0.0386997648,
0.02303968,
-0.0352471992,
-0.019959813,
0.0390973017,
-0.0056763492,
0.0766098797,
0.0624817163,
0.0473429412,
0.0291083381,
-0.0023691515,
-0.0134846671,
-0.0644976422,
0.0530871265,
-0.0169225428,
0.0020714302,
-0.011702464,
-0.0223026369,
0.0316434801,
0.0202882588,
0.0088332901,
0.0110728079,
-0.0869500488,
0.02194608,
0.0463733822,
-0.0474448502,
0.0080328556,
-0.0015811772,
-0.0236967616,
0.0366048291,
-0.0250124987,
-0.0395679735,
0.0715669766,
-0.020408405,
-0.0322715603,
-0.0395332426,
-0.0272198841,
-0.0504547209,
0.0190425441,
-0.030194154,
0.0128811393,
0.0009955002,
-0.0111212311,
-0.0490704812,
-0.0379461348,
-0.019146191,
-0.0220277328,
0.0635806471,
-0.0258016624,
-0.013638353,
0.0092428289,
-0.0699359179,
-0.0794145614,
-0.0456901155,
-0.004465932,
0.0059674089,
0.0218622219,
-0.0272479206,
-0.0024490119,
-0.0367943086,
0.0248775519,
0.0298743919,
-0.0465125144,
-0.0090081906,
-0.0393127464,
0.0260851681,
0.0667562112,
0.0529071093,
0.0171753857,
-0.0364245437,
0.0618714839,
0.0402470306,
-0.005113638,
-0.0237812977,
-0.0265218485,
0.0059071616,
0.0267640781,
-0.0030840077,
-0.0206391308,
0.0251925904,
0.0850377381,
-0.0088101411,
-0.0452991873,
0.1321920156,
0.0185517129,
-0.0627821237,
-0.0002844731,
-0.0234763213,
0.0662384853,
0.0143876653,
0.0305117462,
-0.0488325544,
-0.0326850303,
-0.0098976642,
0.0312665291,
-0.0125268679,
-0.019415345,
-0.0326893106,
-0.1260169446,
0.0288828146,
0.0045424066,
-0.0229863413,
-0.0102192927,
0.0005609862,
0.0146646695,
0.0138519844,
0.0352212973,
-0.0094026523,
0.0106591079,
0.0142620197,
0.0008929244,
0.0251083467,
-0.0409686863,
-0.0186053216,
-0.0269637275,
0.0725773126,
0.069635652,
0.0379082188,
0.0160252284,
-0.0310566742,
0.0019350428,
-0.0118328817,
0.0122010298,
-0.0249929465,
0.0422822125,
-0.0150987897,
0.012774311,
-0.0186155308,
0.053644117,
-0.0112793883,
-0.0352091081,
0.0298325047,
0.0048943651,
-0.0454616174,
0.0192734003,
-0.0159312729,
0.0319140814,
0.0457454808,
0.0832269341,
0.0431948788,
-0.0550202578,
-0.0064531723,
-0.0274092145,
0.0195046943,
-0.0507918522,
0.0240167379,
-0.0015488415,
0.0059729265,
0.0072355056,
-0.0627736971,
-0.0649094954,
0.0205858462,
0.0052840486,
-0.0062138746,
0.002858408,
-0.0518256389,
0.0150418654,
0.0018447948,
0.0324627236,
-0.0302475002,
0.0223542601,
-0.0777561367,
-0.0380875021,
0.0233061258,
-0.0982369632,
0.0018005912,
0.0087028211,
-0.0457472131,
-0.074478738,
-0.0300597511,
0.0563106239,
0.0189219993,
0.0809782222,
0.0048497417,
-0.0482300334,
0.0108197583,
0.0333220661,
-0.0174278487,
0.0137282703,
0.0164406821,
0.0732119232,
-0.0080859447,
0.031057125,
-0.0312613286,
-0.0040283585,
0.0021264565,
0.0334313177,
-0.0148949809,
-0.1140116677,
0.0054340051,
-0.0050997734,
0.0257019009,
0.0051991669,
0.0104611274,
-0.0175363775,
0.0027526801,
-0.0043093213,
-0.0232352093,
-0.052347295,
-0.0164111145,
-0.0117069101,
0.0006299689,
0.0004131893,
-0.0318611152,
-0.044141233,
0.0648790374,
-0.0548024252,
-0.0161322206,
0.016211655,
0.0012405837,
0.0067188004,
-0.0148279816,
-0.0172082819,
0.0427991115,
0.008548269,
0.0302774739,
0.0054724072,
0.0940431505,
0.0173841976,
-0.0269357469,
-0.0057524135,
0.0520829149,
-0.0547463447,
-0.012982538,
0.0215654839,
0.0469019078,
0.0104316389,
0.0235320013,
0.0455044582,
-0.0130971298,
0.0259081945,
-0.009271319,
0.0421478823,
0.0325835049,
-0.0267025065,
0.0328196809,
0.0140980184,
-0.0334323049,
0.0092331404,
0.0544440895,
-0.0623038374,
0.0052710073,
0.0123751294,
0.0379910693,
-0.0508787967,
-0.0048216325,
0.0265309177,
0.0349849351,
-0.0031190896,
0.0181582142,
-0.0363013223,
-0.0163747221,
0.0484137535,
0.0012391346,
-0.0249810275,
-0.0204111449,
0.0298788641,
0.0401833169,
-0.0182152707,
-0.0200917013,
-0.0433984026,
0.0117003825,
-0.001197538,
-0.0407207124,
-0.0381211564,
-6.808743929e-33,
-0.037796367,
-0.0175919142,
0.0110385623,
-0.0128686437,
-0.0514065921,
-0.0208676029,
-0.0648109093,
0.0016460682,
-0.0160650406,
-0.0243012831,
-0.0503801331,
0.0087796906,
0.0060340315,
0.0476805568,
-0.0293796975,
-0.0242816862,
0.0668216199,
0.0375630669,
-0.0252116714,
0.0682731569,
0.0367793441,
0.0317889191,
-0.009526765,
-0.0646489486,
0.0296969265,
-0.0158154666,
-0.0108725857,
0.0322619416,
0.0063783084,
0.0546110235,
-0.0230959971,
0.022580076,
0.0059534064,
0.0130769275,
-0.0184736755,
0.0651552156,
-0.0666064322,
-0.0453606285,
0.0195558574,
-0.0168188736,
-0.0525414757,
-0.0730134323,
-0.004346,
-0.0250335336,
0.0039509544,
0.0081951674,
0.0216476601,
-0.0110569308,
-0.0168479644,
-0.004419765,
-0.0379121713,
0.004710637,
-0.0331426226,
-0.0419090614,
-0.0263392571,
0.0522079766,
0.0169461519,
0.0494874381,
-0.0349814482,
0.041138947,
0.007806093,
-0.0119493837,
0.0130342888,
0.0330922082,
-0.014423782,
0.0430073291,
0.034418121,
0.0338960141,
-0.0119203608,
-0.0336555205,
-0.0069317059,
0.0391134247,
-0.0011268364,
0.0808379799,
-0.0102686258,
-0.0065931594,
-0.0065750973,
0.0596915968,
0.0343308821,
-0.0194625258,
0.0378691517,
0.0057216939,
-0.0327898562,
-0.0124142272,
-0.0227262583,
-0.0198086537,
-0.0306341015,
-0.0181535259,
0.0281460136,
0.0260561295,
-0.0413178168,
-0.0522498451,
0.0231093857,
-0.019181326,
0.0024372195,
0.0336344428,
-0.0467473604,
-0.0111434748,
0.0025365567,
-0.0042825863,
-0.0467008948,
-0.0319040604,
0.066469349,
-0.0108544566,
-0.0100496374,
0.0451060869,
0.0100108851,
0.0132275848,
-0.0397389755,
0.0056927316,
-0.0287674461,
0.0828379616,
-0.0423050262,
0.031119192,
-0.0003974978,
0.0118748415,
-0.0346007943,
0.0636715814,
-0.0009663439,
0.0089798952,
-0.060489323,
-0.0580577031,
0.004750215,
-0.0015805933,
-0.0368181914,
0.0114002302,
-0.0101245428,
0.0085147042,
0.0188071057,
-0.0317816585,
-0.0209026653,
-0.0021068801,
2.834e-7,
-0.0405111276,
0.0084055047,
0.0131136375,
0.0294292141,
0.0166865829,
0.0587928705,
-0.0036118904,
0.0323891751,
0.0224750079,
-0.0249835532,
0.0108956788,
0.0468584113,
0.0606760047,
-0.0016919461,
-0.0969343632,
-0.0145924557,
-0.0631455556,
-0.0075561586,
-0.0526645221,
0.0120944297,
0.0901609734,
0.0523529053,
0.0187681746,
-0.0095500806,
0.0185505599,
0.0225934945,
0.042394489,
-0.0326923467,
-0.018479092,
0.0171893053,
0.0264771841,
-0.0251647793,
0.0076975124,
-0.0099358913,
0.0048029968,
0.0453249551,
-0.0266246088,
0.0624660552,
0.0230230168,
-0.0727293566,
0.0201260783,
0.0314521976,
0.0135462293,
-0.0399270356,
0.0629778355,
-0.017487973,
-0.0231803209,
-0.0144820111,
-0.0172093827,
-0.0220165793,
0.0188587252,
-0.0297383405,
-0.0436572023,
0.0307767298,
0.0025039464,
-0.0050873761,
-0.0077854018,
-0.0827826262,
-0.0022119619,
-0.0165468547,
-0.0609086007,
-0.0518188775,
-0.0464620963,
0.0171951521,
0.0080832886,
-0.0369611681,
0.0303869285,
2.766069762e-34,
0.0193891563,
-0.0062170913,
0.0285308212,
0.0291716009,
0.0203739628,
-0.0043938751,
-0.0153243402,
0.0024359676,
0.0584366657,
-0.07540185,
-0.0323576517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18173v1 | UIO-LLMs: Unbiased Incremental Optimization for Long-Context LLMs | 2024-06-26T08:44:36 | 2024-06-26T08:44:36 | Wenhao Li, Mingbao Lin, Yunshan Zhong, Shuicheng Yan, Rongrong Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Managing long texts is challenging for large language models (LLMs) due to
limited context window sizes. This study introduces UIO-LLMs, an unbiased
incremental optimization approach for memory-enhanced transformers under
long-context settings. We initially conceptualize the process as a streamlined
encoder-decoder framework where the weights-shared encoder and decoder
respectively encapsulate a context segment into memories and leverage these
memories to predict outputs of the subsequent segment. Subsequently, by
treating our memory-enhanced transformers as fully-connected recurrent neural
networks (RNNs), we refine the training process using the Truncated
Backpropagation Through Time (TBPTT) algorithm, which incorporates innovative
incremental optimization techniques. These techniques not only diminish time
complexity but also address the bias in gradient computation through an
unbiased optimization process. UIO-LLMs successfully handle long context, such
as extending the context window of Llama2-7b-chat from 4K to 100K tokens with
minimal 2% additional parameters, while keeping the inference cost nearly
linear as context length increases. | [
0.0280601308,
0.0749914944,
0.0205439832,
0.0542258695,
0.0015904827,
-0.0155159291,
0.0023222051,
0.0034803408,
-0.0405224301,
-0.0229897667,
-0.0580163151,
-0.0527066775,
0.0167626254,
-0.0147719085,
0.0002527534,
-0.021323571,
0.0188757498,
-0.0203881804,
-0.008783251,
-0.0110421889,
-0.0044388031,
-0.0016040866,
-0.0021093413,
0.0291456319,
0.0051781386,
-0.024707783,
-0.0068145096,
0.005291915,
-0.0094455518,
-0.0501039065,
-0.0027868776,
-0.0012244323,
0.0057817013,
0.0346052721,
0.0000021849,
-0.0412902869,
-0.0105900904,
-0.041119691,
-0.0362410508,
0.0339358449,
0.0560850464,
0.0097251348,
-0.0113727488,
0.0291725397,
-0.0083635449,
0.0132523645,
0.0400409587,
0.0379945673,
0.0439443551,
0.0724180862,
0.0067745112,
-0.0332214758,
0.0363007709,
-0.0609954707,
0.0099716019,
-0.0299622975,
0.0050140745,
-0.0388131849,
-0.0240674969,
-0.0146325976,
-0.0384720489,
0.0508292615,
0.0550210029,
-0.0009912037,
-0.0070280875,
0.0247414969,
-0.0221316628,
0.0163936149,
-0.0052294633,
0.0640809759,
-0.0260266885,
-0.0120964423,
-0.0176828802,
-0.0081957132,
-0.0310660414,
-0.0762604326,
-0.0369640477,
0.0153080253,
0.0243118796,
0.0422605202,
-0.0028713164,
0.0202473868,
0.0543615744,
0.0144341383,
-0.0508401208,
0.0506080203,
0.0115732048,
0.0009463156,
-0.0151173696,
-0.010709432,
0.0017717169,
-0.024673067,
0.0316149779,
0.0825055987,
-0.0104565844,
0.0352807082,
-0.007386229,
-0.0288228933,
0.0016780832,
-0.0504580922,
-0.0163707901,
0.066398561,
0.0034982099,
0.0057269046,
-0.0076116407,
0.0217584409,
-0.0493582375,
-0.0133053791,
-0.0380361564,
-0.021058619,
-0.0356127135,
-0.0164869297,
-0.0261367932,
0.0220919847,
-0.0361180715,
0.0043390761,
-0.0636032745,
0.0397935808,
0.0384929664,
-0.0416304097,
0.0506002307,
0.0087854862,
-0.054868605,
-0.0056960168,
-0.0179500245,
0.0397257097,
0.0056948741,
-0.0105500212,
-0.00713654,
-0.0419053361,
-0.0403227732,
0.0283131767,
0.0009843173,
-0.0306248963,
-0.0083137518,
0.0921581909,
-0.0172433257,
-0.0563737638,
-0.0476643182,
-0.0079313507,
-0.0265982859,
-0.0468407534,
0.0376404934,
-0.0555233844,
0.0389191806,
-0.0336406901,
0.0020961873,
-0.0296851266,
-0.0027465646,
0.0270784181,
-0.0051032058,
0.0439403765,
0.0141423792,
-0.044362694,
0.0543963425,
0.0077353967,
0.0563322119,
0.0643539578,
0.0679046884,
0.0382659137,
-0.0078607146,
0.0235651731,
-0.0152804898,
0.0557196327,
0.0525692962,
0.0009388694,
-0.0599561296,
-0.0182673354,
0.0024959473,
0.0440925136,
0.0379892886,
0.0496855155,
-0.019573018,
-0.0106680552,
0.0428745337,
0.0137216188,
0.0304054003,
0.0186749231,
0.030003177,
-0.0190987214,
-0.0096592568,
-0.0168730412,
-0.02634288,
0.0457226522,
0.027871009,
0.0222281646,
0.0380240642,
0.0378687568,
-0.0482902341,
-0.043031808,
-0.0038797352,
-0.0391185135,
0.0114949625,
0.0036921615,
0.0416408442,
0.0195382331,
-0.0663555413,
0.1119872853,
0.0094628399,
-0.0144983521,
0.0050007161,
-0.0426554233,
-0.0138633335,
0.0537773967,
0.0422042087,
-0.0189080983,
-0.0327582844,
-0.0224090163,
-0.0050526671,
0.0524248369,
-0.0476955436,
0.0076605245,
0.0407069512,
-0.0682916716,
-0.0006569499,
0.0207579639,
-0.0064991829,
0.012706887,
0.0206484087,
0.0483275503,
0.0213571358,
-0.0084030936,
0.0325374454,
0.034183573,
-0.041454155,
-0.0333585851,
0.0307238363,
0.006248408,
0.0534465946,
0.0211349223,
0.0336526595,
0.0000675175,
0.0287199635,
-0.0640075505,
-0.0281811431,
0.019307375,
-0.1325140893,
-0.0747369975,
0.0507188141,
0.0182467978,
0.0177382343,
0.0229415987,
-0.0547191352,
-0.0532807708,
0.0402306095,
-0.0495455116,
0.0828348696,
-0.0345681943,
0.0171172097,
0.0064892359,
0.0345018283,
-0.0080557894,
0.0195754971,
-0.051882904,
-0.0196376443,
0.021179067,
0.0085388217,
-0.0143933529,
-0.0247916374,
-0.0158156753,
0.0573389605,
-0.0119662201,
-0.0114923846,
-0.0025933313,
0.024614403,
-0.0088440496,
-0.0342069492,
-0.1006442681,
0.0097334255,
-0.0341024995,
0.0404166207,
0.011549551,
0.0351679139,
0.0258483589,
-0.0093791177,
-0.0058671325,
0.001079492,
-0.0152520863,
0.0065583377,
0.0316942036,
0.0114117665,
-0.0348681137,
-0.0357423574,
-0.0363956988,
0.0249153022,
0.0721600652,
-0.0278904513,
-0.0464623496,
-0.0430680849,
0.0144223403,
0.0013783464,
0.0171790533,
-0.0283927321,
-0.0489260815,
-0.0245963614,
0.0121644689,
0.0577353053,
0.0336653516,
0.0263107754,
0.0150338011,
0.0348326825,
-0.0079633025,
-0.0349650234,
0.0189247727,
-0.0234441031,
-0.0441543311,
-0.0236669015,
0.0036005618,
0.0044499962,
0.0860493779,
-0.0434860513,
0.0104021719,
-0.038318485,
-0.0427305847,
-0.015902292,
-0.0174201559,
-0.0089358455,
-0.0290462598,
-0.0439621061,
-0.007410028,
0.0091826068,
-0.0379260816,
0.0446117073,
-0.0423423536,
0.0114907688,
-0.0439131223,
0.0054276367,
-0.0602804571,
0.0496767201,
0.0056848866,
-0.0053215423,
-0.0341612063,
-0.0478726551,
-0.0314735733,
0.0149678197,
-0.0334976204,
-0.0094757983,
0.042184893,
0.0004852197,
0.0122247627,
-0.018721791,
-0.0244729295,
-0.0453191064,
0.0069006924,
-0.012856015,
-0.0050697825,
0.0283623524,
0.0022028689,
-0.0244807415,
0.0147776678,
-0.0126412157,
0.0747983605,
-0.0077268877,
0.0033171626,
-0.0047558849,
0.0366991162,
0.0153545765,
-0.0000038628,
0.0188188776,
-0.031002501,
0.0107481321,
0.0314691328,
0.0445156023,
-0.0046064272,
-0.0274757221,
-0.0172190834,
0.0023696127,
-0.0104862154,
0.0078219892,
0.0129952757,
0.0332010053,
-0.0711226761,
-0.0126454663,
0.1057019085,
0.025079377,
-0.099754788,
-0.0064483997,
-0.0066885776,
0.0091864578,
0.0097981812,
0.0094943773,
-0.0594717525,
-0.0415026136,
0.0246257167,
0.0164083987,
0.0208968055,
-0.020200422,
-0.0408840515,
-0.0933788344,
-0.0246932395,
0.0159511603,
-0.0486389846,
-0.0013381341,
-0.0553049333,
-0.0541832708,
-0.0053044851,
0.0510310382,
0.0456468239,
-0.0182283632,
-0.0202462692,
0.0182990264,
-0.0508487299,
-0.0294466615,
0.0130884098,
0.0018730062,
0.0292482022,
0.0453575365,
0.0239739753,
0.0227971468,
-0.0153334681,
0.0777697563,
-0.0410441868,
0.0035156102,
-0.0089260209,
0.0258648954,
-0.0291668698,
0.0049389056,
0.0089792851,
0.0398428924,
-0.032984715,
-0.0052701035,
-0.0159039255,
0.0622683391,
-0.0028062719,
0.0013515354,
0.0007365624,
-0.0433931239,
0.0003645678,
0.0450943522,
0.0267140064,
-0.0456224047,
-0.035691537,
0.0011598389,
-0.0009605975,
-0.0312814675,
0.0229318831,
-0.0036551219,
-0.0033925499,
-0.036541149,
-0.0712510571,
-0.0296548624,
-0.0018548201,
-0.0001453601,
-0.0087451804,
0.0048227599,
0.0155645153,
0.0225104187,
-0.0819952413,
-0.0053438507,
-0.0483206399,
0.0031617288,
-0.0667852238,
0.0482196845,
0.0392516963,
-0.0208499152,
0.0009574467,
0.0500886515,
-0.1214655042,
-0.0513956062,
0.0173645262,
0.0153236575,
0.0114652431,
0.0699829906,
0.0215975456,
-0.0296561085,
0.0922318995,
0.0292855371,
-0.0142847272,
0.0395918526,
0.0312633328,
0.0451043509,
0.017766688,
0.0238173585,
-0.0516572744,
0.0313829258,
0.0156726055,
0.0102493092,
0.0189894233,
-0.0043217391,
-0.0323723257,
0.0067201643,
0.0272713304,
-0.0190182123,
0.016311571,
-0.0050234608,
0.0757301971,
-0.0113450661,
0.0473001935,
-0.0365798324,
0.034870863,
0.0114483312,
-0.0173725709,
-0.0047967918,
-0.0078083244,
0.0499586388,
-0.0281992536,
0.0269997604,
0.0427385904,
-0.0473879687,
-0.0140183084,
0.0236005373,
0.038763579,
-0.0237854011,
-0.0045589125,
0.0075247991,
0.0131586529,
-0.0480481982,
0.023731621,
0.0259917118,
0.0283533242,
-0.0687383339,
0.0309951771,
-0.0348664932,
0.0118728755,
-0.0377943143,
0.0129573923,
0.0439045168,
0.018220691,
0.0306060333,
-0.0045244829,
0.0216025598,
-0.0244667921,
0.0352967381,
-0.0155291455,
-0.0217005685,
0.0375344418,
-0.0031194859,
-0.0277031567,
0.0337950327,
0.0818526968,
0.0047775875,
0.0540594719,
-0.0059045535,
0.0462624729,
-0.0236990768,
-0.013531236,
-0.0220546816,
0.0218625478,
0.0055194902,
-0.0279798787,
0.0186753701,
-0.0535392463,
0.0417993143,
-0.0417505726,
0.0006792422,
-0.0231139902,
0.0458406471,
0.0273709595,
0.0072780834,
0.0092934221,
0.020747954,
-0.010977352,
0.0094562136,
-0.0232425537,
-0.0135470536,
-6.833941385e-33,
-0.021542225,
-0.0211488307,
0.0290103722,
0.0059967604,
-0.0723928884,
0.0047284178,
-0.0491134711,
-0.0390102677,
0.00432806,
-0.0319987424,
-0.0521427765,
0.0190198291,
0.0119272377,
0.0750788674,
-0.0081730941,
-0.0353191644,
0.0716857463,
-0.0102109564,
0.0028428282,
0.0435937159,
0.0600434802,
0.0521787889,
0.0637552068,
-0.0071836864,
-0.0173193607,
0.0063246046,
0.0166585371,
0.0356938355,
0.0282152649,
0.0508696437,
-0.0635078177,
0.0480302982,
0.0343121737,
-0.0748113543,
-0.0235124491,
0.0157266762,
-0.1042399183,
-0.0190763362,
-0.0140058324,
0.0319421254,
-0.0344082378,
-0.0615659617,
0.0480738021,
0.0305771809,
-0.0165409036,
-0.0218040254,
0.0098481234,
-0.0223919675,
-0.033702042,
-0.0502971858,
-0.0366136879,
0.0068703843,
0.0022481836,
-0.0022773591,
0.0388114601,
-0.0011042523,
-0.0143776964,
0.0441300496,
-0.0963580161,
-0.0232628509,
-0.0086616091,
0.0469253026,
0.0584180728,
0.0235859156,
0.0259436369,
0.0240054317,
0.0218105223,
-0.0132369855,
-0.0465369523,
-0.0235020034,
0.0348434784,
-0.0197101254,
0.0187118798,
-0.0077647138,
0.069143407,
-0.0679899082,
-0.0868255645,
-0.037805561,
0.0323963054,
0.0593813062,
0.0428962111,
0.0294819716,
-0.0002024911,
-0.0263558067,
-0.0181284659,
0.0225012098,
-0.0127603346,
-0.0241880417,
0.0209765732,
0.051447954,
-0.0004696865,
-0.0187803302,
0.0509025492,
-0.0179864187,
0.0106660528,
0.0335749239,
0.0000612137,
0.0170939285,
0.0036896793,
0.0212681312,
-0.045854196,
0.0159149226,
-0.0094949426,
-0.0040200581,
-0.004273498,
-0.0310661793,
0.027710449,
0.0468514711,
-0.0754106194,
-0.00351245,
-0.0449951962,
0.0422644988,
-0.0038645105,
0.0508631431,
0.0482520834,
0.0023333137,
-0.0167277865,
0.0817029402,
-0.0016816163,
-0.0009602573,
-0.0046760305,
-0.0077324165,
0.0207776502,
0.0286640506,
-0.0417257696,
-0.0077570346,
-0.0029841464,
0.0223527048,
0.023123676,
-0.082760565,
-0.0091458615,
0.0317068882,
2.915e-7,
0.0169196259,
0.0502121337,
0.0591587052,
-0.0169629771,
0.055761043,
-0.0128291212,
0.022325376,
0.0119237872,
-0.0125648128,
0.0022673807,
0.0119344192,
0.0041282759,
0.0407221057,
-0.0042786668,
-0.11586155,
-0.027747063,
-0.0859728754,
-0.0026464586,
-0.0143908141,
-0.0464100204,
0.0147251794,
0.1179644987,
-0.0003435593,
-0.0187835544,
-0.0158108063,
-0.0015200259,
0.0486925803,
-0.0193625353,
0.0102018369,
0.0293467492,
0.0191060938,
0.0147894127,
-0.0194540583,
-0.0508392081,
-0.0026832907,
0.0328956917,
-0.0544339418,
0.0570924357,
0.007369034,
-0.078925617,
0.0374829881,
0.031411279,
-0.0348267145,
0.0030172721,
0.0536116846,
-0.0760347322,
-0.0317183658,
-0.0256298278,
0.0118404506,
-0.0070611085,
0.0123340245,
0.0163385905,
0.0090025924,
0.0296682753,
-0.0043629254,
0.0020037347,
-0.0115712695,
-0.1241469681,
-0.0137801822,
-0.025256725,
-0.06722752,
-0.0295107625,
-0.0733738318,
-0.0007251218,
0.0341815092,
-0.0518792197,
0.0037921951,
2.484701414e-34,
0.045741111,
-0.0410543196,
-0.0060923174,
0.0552205667,
-0.0097637754,
-0.0259898044,
0.0181230586,
0.0149457911,
0.0164038595,
-0.0690131634,
-0.0196737088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18164v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18164v1 | NeBuLa: A discourse aware Minecraft Builder | 2024-06-26T08:24:44 | 2024-06-26T08:24:44 | Akshay Chaturvedi, Kate Thompson, Nicholas Asher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | When engaging in collaborative tasks, humans efficiently exploit the semantic
structure of a conversation to optimize verbal and nonverbal interactions. But
in recent "language to code" or "language to action" models, this information
is lacking. We show how incorporating the prior discourse and nonlinguistic
context of a conversation situated in a nonlinguistic environment can improve
the "language to action" component of such interactions. We fine tune an LLM to
predict actions based on prior context; our model, NeBuLa, doubles the
net-action F1 score over the baseline on this task of Jayannavar et al.(2020).
We also investigate our model's ability to construct shapes and understand
location descriptions using a synthetic dataset. | [
0.0259587504,
0.0150331147,
-0.0227043126,
0.0340230204,
-0.0188784245,
0.0121326922,
-0.026309628,
0.0077232569,
-0.0104590971,
-0.0465453565,
-0.0513315871,
-0.0216241218,
0.0041287644,
0.0504480563,
0.0240011923,
-0.0521865375,
0.0186010282,
-0.0547681078,
-0.0077897101,
0.0201267041,
-0.0144667029,
0.0003629203,
-0.0274609942,
0.0552715696,
-0.0143377194,
0.0038611176,
-0.0727086291,
0.0116737187,
0.0033240472,
-0.0330320559,
-0.0082837911,
0.0433370434,
0.0000532895,
-0.0151535217,
0.0000019334,
-0.0170112066,
0.0866149068,
-0.0436124615,
0.0133151365,
-0.0644909963,
-0.0197449811,
0.0069590746,
-0.0017451763,
0.0191714354,
-0.0665074289,
0.0173395593,
0.049430646,
0.0327208191,
0.0241596866,
0.0435475484,
-0.0160900149,
0.015714338,
-0.0324141905,
-0.0202249773,
0.0201855488,
-0.0277377423,
-0.0236148387,
0.0546612591,
0.0327598825,
0.0619267821,
-0.0346840508,
0.037615981,
0.010398088,
-0.0374509245,
0.0353663564,
0.0492265113,
-0.0057704565,
-0.0251773018,
0.0156173212,
0.0923326463,
0.0367591828,
-0.01609076,
0.0480116569,
0.0048812558,
0.0385921858,
-0.0005208455,
-0.0346556865,
0.0093774218,
-0.0130481906,
-0.0102845142,
-0.0100749563,
-0.0035072993,
0.0093379542,
0.0006347607,
0.0801766142,
0.0614098534,
-0.0284909122,
0.0259139966,
-0.0555605963,
0.006277747,
0.0111325886,
-0.0798280612,
-0.0208367724,
0.0370584652,
-0.0727993697,
0.0193223096,
-0.0267847497,
0.0623531267,
0.0047765723,
-0.0532790646,
0.0464234054,
0.0302326661,
0.0315958671,
0.0560717024,
-0.0093099093,
0.0035062721,
0.0152349835,
0.0155612249,
-0.0481830239,
0.0086548319,
-0.0461395718,
-0.0120546333,
-0.0096613467,
0.0255782157,
-0.0940976441,
-0.0476941019,
-0.0026745868,
0.0587033816,
-0.013186112,
0.0096453484,
0.0462095663,
0.0309609789,
-0.0187889934,
-0.0007809764,
-0.0282330792,
-0.0354283489,
-0.0099901333,
0.0309444182,
0.0112610497,
-0.0634799972,
-0.0114451675,
0.015682539,
0.0115216793,
0.0034639616,
-0.0112331156,
0.0862565711,
-0.026222907,
-0.0161515381,
0.0051847105,
-0.0252840165,
-0.0107000563,
-0.0627894998,
0.0314172655,
-0.0652638301,
0.0071224202,
-0.0004336909,
-0.0118625825,
-0.0119026983,
0.0179421101,
-0.008686536,
0.0084797954,
0.0704393834,
-0.0080751767,
0.0312436894,
0.0540240407,
0.0392556824,
0.0230191238,
0.063743189,
0.0537943617,
0.0213642009,
-0.0081800967,
0.0230515748,
0.0085702259,
0.0466937274,
-0.0416681245,
-0.0093264841,
0.0327372961,
0.0039462713,
-0.0246057119,
0.0162918065,
0.0250889026,
-0.0101925619,
-0.0268653501,
0.0051757847,
0.071703732,
0.0850325376,
-0.0073596523,
0.0488206707,
0.0180596262,
0.0318222158,
-0.0460428111,
-0.0508333854,
-0.0228112563,
0.0762284547,
-0.0037705551,
-0.0228115246,
0.0071328245,
0.0063789533,
-0.047244966,
-0.0572923161,
0.0116883293,
-0.0315409601,
0.0616559908,
-0.0150432345,
0.0049193967,
-0.0023902343,
-0.0534666255,
0.0219468735,
-0.0066304216,
-0.0623730458,
0.0061193765,
-0.0201014131,
0.026985772,
0.0567335784,
-0.0059045418,
-0.0125358058,
-0.0291688256,
-0.0007780396,
0.0101799136,
0.0519503765,
-0.0023532859,
-0.0299239419,
0.0491971634,
-0.0070036603,
-0.0270932559,
-0.0171984397,
0.0132229105,
0.058424402,
0.0248468332,
-0.028209582,
-0.0034001058,
0.0102593275,
0.0064013102,
0.0121350037,
-0.012615351,
-0.0123657407,
-0.0231546219,
-0.0065503661,
0.0464427434,
-0.0077255452,
0.0180649124,
-0.0151114631,
0.0341393352,
-0.029600665,
-0.0176670644,
0.0880244672,
-0.0615674704,
-0.0419535227,
0.0173008218,
-0.0246151797,
-0.015352414,
0.010724715,
0.0112477327,
-0.0324668549,
0.0723014101,
-0.0515796617,
0.0536085926,
-0.0105177769,
-0.0004067663,
-0.0126653835,
-0.015997909,
-0.0175463241,
0.0209877864,
0.0033110131,
-0.0191644505,
0.0153553756,
0.0094951354,
0.0219140686,
-0.0407525189,
0.0372151844,
0.055370573,
-0.0088354237,
0.020677859,
0.0305424128,
0.0202170834,
-0.0908188447,
-0.0517485626,
-0.1188715696,
-0.0682189465,
-0.0081561869,
-0.0012465005,
0.0281941798,
-0.0026108201,
-0.0179829393,
-0.0125669418,
-0.0367998853,
-0.0233181845,
0.0261268243,
-0.0073959087,
0.0418588854,
-0.0001136318,
0.0112078628,
-0.0434223488,
0.0160055868,
0.0019983544,
0.0190869272,
0.0324609354,
-0.0379710756,
-0.053742107,
0.0721288323,
-0.028092565,
-0.0053919018,
-0.0443354547,
-0.0363465846,
0.0367717519,
-0.0311932899,
0.0822129697,
0.0587735251,
-0.0089183766,
-0.0008423501,
0.0384610891,
-0.0452970788,
-0.08353962,
0.0150381858,
-0.0098058134,
0.0187190529,
-0.0659104437,
-0.0476666689,
0.0378629155,
0.0713028982,
-0.0179148465,
0.0387118906,
-0.0704847872,
-0.0086191567,
0.036247734,
-0.0567454323,
-0.0054204599,
-0.0357205234,
-0.030381389,
0.0579398572,
-0.0275825467,
-0.0338290446,
0.0213393085,
-0.0295756757,
-0.0512783378,
0.0137575846,
0.0002323177,
-0.0181314982,
0.0715802982,
0.0155528914,
-0.0040441174,
0.021579843,
-0.0335474834,
-0.0027433529,
-0.0211987998,
0.0229348354,
-0.0155472513,
-0.007291642,
-0.0631863549,
0.0020020597,
0.006690721,
-0.0163863227,
-0.0126785534,
0.0199728459,
-0.0199689716,
-0.0017957359,
0.0053854175,
-0.0231105443,
-0.020854583,
0.0218033809,
0.0183530655,
0.0122566642,
0.0084233517,
-0.017134754,
-0.0299363844,
0.0163032934,
0.0314288959,
0.0715451762,
-0.0476620756,
-0.0159218442,
0.0040873219,
0.0536723919,
-0.0051292856,
-0.0221202038,
-0.022215372,
0.017137479,
0.0507948697,
0.0517011061,
-0.0417625383,
0.0593030229,
0.0966957659,
-0.0009295414,
-0.048153691,
0.0803550929,
0.0206806585,
0.0068742889,
-0.0078379996,
-0.031873744,
0.043572925,
0.0230714902,
0.0136959106,
-0.0055576707,
-0.0334118269,
0.0101074064,
-0.0343941525,
0.0040430869,
-0.0458697267,
0.0130742444,
-0.1044025198,
0.038145192,
-0.0002266238,
-0.0085938815,
-0.0078759473,
-0.0320886858,
0.0257315896,
0.020869473,
-0.0480802022,
-0.018904645,
0.0089788279,
-0.0022977102,
0.0139563596,
-0.0460037142,
-0.0111701936,
0.0243105646,
-0.0113832867,
0.0832205787,
0.0378324203,
0.0703856498,
0.0208150372,
0.0153283393,
0.0090128435,
0.0487446077,
0.0148369959,
-0.0487708636,
0.0336026512,
0.0346041322,
0.0008946048,
0.0137550645,
0.0226771161,
-0.0511473753,
-0.0548986197,
-0.0014387211,
0.0310520586,
-0.0514875799,
-0.007320141,
-0.0090632644,
0.0662631467,
0.0419626199,
0.0041005909,
0.0185106471,
-0.0198748689,
-0.0251040682,
-0.046802707,
-0.0093358699,
-0.0504428558,
-0.0441817939,
-0.0659492463,
0.0470726565,
0.0302196294,
-0.0689495802,
-0.0454835966,
0.0250201114,
0.0172687359,
0.003208573,
0.0113367233,
0.0048285038,
0.0244020596,
-0.0300952364,
0.019933857,
0.0039896788,
0.0253749173,
-0.0307256654,
-0.0501773283,
0.0362312086,
-0.0735198483,
0.0248049758,
0.052967526,
-0.0522539653,
-0.0666842908,
-0.0403967947,
0.0628422424,
0.0196156614,
0.0414965674,
0.011118833,
-0.0192767102,
-0.0022855953,
0.0125893308,
-0.0426279902,
0.0346102677,
0.0213264786,
0.0593658313,
0.0021935017,
0.0088331634,
-0.0031270501,
0.0138135981,
0.0194475632,
0.0452925004,
-0.0867964029,
-0.0691590607,
-0.011163705,
-0.0284843072,
0.0195183363,
-0.016072074,
0.005183402,
-0.0090599898,
-0.0171515159,
-0.0177021977,
0.0206125863,
-0.0630977079,
0.0147066098,
0.0022136786,
-0.0032523277,
0.030190533,
0.0416631587,
-0.0557699017,
0.0363584198,
0.0286834072,
0.0484907478,
0.0033709221,
0.011726548,
0.0056997873,
0.0468506068,
0.009563189,
-0.0010725802,
-0.0014145009,
0.0499448031,
0.0122020263,
0.0397511907,
0.0115355374,
-0.0270287842,
0.0051234392,
0.0488155335,
-0.0537009835,
-0.0210905336,
-0.0141636524,
0.0451872759,
0.0498383231,
-0.0130234789,
0.028269222,
-0.0638964772,
0.0339550413,
-0.0074903755,
0.0762798712,
-0.0139868883,
-0.0691175684,
0.0503077209,
0.0418752506,
-0.0139783202,
-0.0393586718,
0.0210860856,
0.0067849574,
0.0017109849,
0.0215516295,
0.0053290222,
-0.057360068,
-0.0487175956,
0.0252987985,
0.0422879867,
-0.0299519505,
0.0258805137,
-0.0189999864,
-0.0433847159,
0.0087564122,
0.0348299816,
0.0207997281,
-0.0675513446,
0.0513571277,
0.0437258147,
0.0146075385,
-0.0210958887,
-0.0647637844,
-0.0182447173,
0.0185904019,
0.0052356594,
-0.0741414204,
-5.407195403e-33,
-0.0454488061,
-0.0797492564,
0.046530176,
0.0585192665,
0.0060784477,
-0.0209127441,
-0.0846685618,
0.050787162,
-0.0085046114,
-0.0163512025,
-0.021387618,
0.0277716815,
0.0039535174,
0.0110250199,
0.0305455551,
-0.002583107,
0.0270815194,
0.0053959852,
-0.0188019946,
0.0237648804,
-0.0003653091,
-0.0178098995,
0.02778426,
-0.0726497397,
0.0112997815,
0.0134239532,
-0.0310134813,
0.0078498814,
0.0152892023,
0.0052812407,
-0.0098089483,
0.0012041203,
0.0210776273,
0.0236605741,
-0.0101525895,
0.0257008579,
-0.0476903617,
-0.0021114689,
0.0270085558,
-0.0053620152,
-0.0490242466,
-0.0302153528,
-0.0126569979,
0.0103956321,
-0.0493526012,
-0.0273090955,
0.053943716,
-0.0085505079,
-0.0434193201,
0.0120425746,
-0.0744046047,
0.000845241,
-0.0593650416,
-0.0586174205,
0.0453547277,
0.05449019,
-0.0000431758,
-0.0164679866,
-0.04826314,
0.1156168506,
-0.0435643792,
0.0320541821,
0.0566533394,
0.0592931993,
0.0361655951,
0.0785473809,
0.0340727977,
0.0384136103,
-0.0091032619,
0.0110682696,
0.019424146,
0.0704568848,
0.0024145553,
0.0437293798,
-0.0210762378,
0.0364274345,
-0.0217991658,
0.0465634726,
-0.0419787429,
0.0256907996,
-0.0126577811,
0.0339831375,
0.0031530778,
-0.0298557561,
-0.026351193,
-0.0120451534,
0.0121910227,
-0.0197676551,
0.0075054769,
0.0071920659,
0.0230597686,
-0.0269321259,
0.0393246897,
-0.0259078108,
-0.0055656419,
-0.0105868746,
-0.0173872504,
0.0298296493,
-0.0041741901,
-0.0112022245,
-0.0508239307,
-0.0277180094,
0.0177315753,
0.047950536,
0.0242536962,
0.019654043,
-0.0286364276,
0.0210938528,
-0.0336533263,
-0.0275644101,
-0.0471822917,
0.0134563698,
-0.0243854281,
0.0099580418,
-0.0027715776,
-0.0418754667,
-0.0410858393,
0.0140556833,
-0.0278346799,
-0.0199093856,
-0.0521009192,
-0.0302114952,
-0.0398752466,
0.0052177012,
-0.0303159077,
-0.0222618636,
-0.0805057138,
0.0329361334,
0.0893747583,
-0.0291206297,
-0.0133240204,
0.0017039712,
2.743e-7,
0.0037601313,
0.0537011959,
-0.0058698133,
0.0043826359,
-0.0037826924,
0.0587310046,
-0.0424325503,
0.0263822712,
0.0490759164,
-0.0033717726,
0.029001683,
0.0453805551,
0.0397989787,
0.0000688325,
-0.0993028954,
0.0411374755,
-0.0316381566,
-0.0386790968,
-0.0018495998,
0.0031358846,
0.0056847646,
0.011609666,
-0.0218076557,
0.0032669213,
0.0040078457,
-0.0258174073,
0.0494802818,
-0.0927618295,
0.0054349187,
0.0343583897,
-0.0391715914,
-0.0502115116,
-0.0365785062,
-0.0104096569,
-0.0287493765,
-0.0353893451,
-0.0097293854,
0.0625589788,
-0.0216340702,
-0.0318627767,
-0.0149580101,
0.0190066677,
0.0035507565,
0.0058937455,
-0.0136736482,
-0.0617585145,
-0.0333511978,
0.0452693366,
0.0040392689,
0.0187684391,
-0.0172618646,
0.0075141951,
-0.022229908,
-0.022706721,
-0.0003189645,
-0.0287017673,
0.0223089214,
-0.0441736877,
-0.0511057414,
-0.0340160616,
-0.0843212008,
-0.0626287907,
-0.033909224,
-0.0049876021,
-0.0026983209,
-0.0018352395,
-0.0015571619,
1.880146276e-34,
-0.0194314886,
0.0355227627,
0.0091595482,
0.0547467731,
0.0287367757,
-0.0028990093,
0.0238878801,
0.0506781228,
0.0529468469,
-0.0437217504,
-0.0159883276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18139v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18139v1 | LOOK-M: Look-Once Optimization in KV Cache for Efficient Multimodal Long-Context Inference | 2024-06-26T07:44:24 | 2024-06-26T07:44:24 | Zhongwei Wan, Ziang Wu, Che Liu, Jinfa Huang, Zhihong Zhu, Peng Jin, Longyue Wang, Li Yuan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Long-context Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) demand substantial
computational resources for inference as the growth of their multimodal
Key-Value (KV) cache, in response to increasing input lengths, challenges
memory and time efficiency. Unlike single-modality LLMs that manage only
textual contexts, the KV cache of long-context MLLMs includes representations
from multiple images with temporal and spatial relationships and related
textual contexts. The predominance of image tokens means traditional
optimizations for LLMs' KV caches are unsuitable for multimodal long-context
settings, and no prior works have addressed this challenge. In this work, we
introduce LOOK-M, a pioneering, fine-tuning-free approach that efficiently
reduces the multimodal KV cache size while maintaining performance comparable
to a full cache. We observe that during prompt prefill, the model prioritizes
more textual attention over image features, and based on the multimodal
interaction observation, a new proposed text-prior method is explored to
compress the KV cache. Furthermore, to mitigate the degradation of image
contextual information, we propose several compensatory strategies using KV
pairs merging. LOOK-M demonstrates that with a significant reduction in KV
Cache memory usage, such as reducing it by 80% in some cases, it not only
achieves up to 1.5x faster decoding but also maintains or even enhances
performance across a variety of long context multimodal tasks. | [
0.0099916551,
0.054359585,
0.0114146834,
0.0829630047,
-0.0264240783,
0.0240195245,
0.0264376327,
-0.0032655331,
0.000086591,
-0.0640965104,
-0.0341650397,
-0.0585643388,
0.0338845961,
-0.0099136643,
0.0348003767,
-0.0277624335,
0.0494920053,
-0.0713990107,
-0.0205329061,
-0.0023678071,
0.0007587895,
0.0171853732,
0.0027001095,
0.0219162349,
-0.0342016257,
-0.0284444541,
-0.0481558517,
0.0304739214,
0.0028918933,
-0.0171712767,
-0.0183640737,
0.0434551165,
0.0178792384,
0.0040498939,
0.0000020552,
-0.0373674557,
0.017476717,
-0.0127642993,
-0.01590872,
0.0338577703,
0.0674123839,
-0.0251052584,
-0.0212054942,
-0.0234233513,
0.0150673259,
-0.0358867981,
0.0791493133,
0.0126018552,
0.0401332043,
0.0232983623,
-0.0151399905,
-0.0412861928,
-0.0156623404,
-0.0232048817,
0.0488248952,
-0.0775576159,
0.0379871093,
-0.0262380857,
-0.02837402,
-0.0119776046,
-0.0312023163,
0.0697548687,
0.0293926131,
0.0044641905,
-0.0028973124,
0.0612007752,
0.0109514426,
-0.0295063108,
-0.022576889,
0.0613309033,
-0.0061992188,
-0.0042434298,
-0.0000238406,
0.0105038965,
-0.0044556851,
0.0046934304,
-0.0304632466,
0.0308727548,
-0.0288969055,
-0.0154807447,
-0.0040440671,
0.0030073253,
0.0185457338,
0.0361850709,
-0.0464488603,
0.0016319016,
0.0469113179,
0.0117139146,
-0.0321246311,
-0.005366093,
-0.0198944937,
-0.0701267496,
-0.0112497499,
0.0331298746,
0.0068565481,
-0.002201577,
-0.0459666811,
-0.0182897225,
0.0129929679,
-0.0518519208,
0.0157446694,
0.0316101164,
-0.065782927,
0.068456322,
-0.0232264493,
0.0219912548,
-0.0519187041,
-0.0272200126,
-0.0456836559,
-0.0270622708,
0.0124915084,
-0.0124661764,
-0.0042923735,
-0.0214396138,
-0.0190780088,
-0.0335427299,
0.0072574932,
0.0343772285,
0.0172493905,
-0.0163651649,
-0.0213901401,
0.0203466937,
-0.0135409068,
-0.0016520207,
0.0040142634,
0.0684223548,
-0.0091837086,
-0.0167705305,
-0.040105693,
-0.0480558984,
-0.0125933522,
0.0476071015,
0.0237185359,
-0.0666304678,
-0.0075034304,
0.0854361653,
-0.0284350161,
-0.0250281449,
-0.0245213527,
-0.0307978559,
-0.0481191799,
-0.0509391502,
0.0435102433,
-0.0431113504,
0.0468150117,
-0.003196677,
0.00173098,
0.0162799135,
-0.0235018358,
0.0181132425,
-0.0371138938,
0.0856496543,
0.0413318016,
0.0021617289,
0.0451150648,
0.0118583497,
0.014393324,
0.0740369707,
0.000449446,
0.0493462831,
0.0137005271,
-0.0170430336,
-0.022035541,
0.0701834559,
0.0158493146,
0.0209081843,
-0.0146304388,
0.0012264154,
0.0654190481,
0.0068971943,
0.0654357001,
0.0488078743,
-0.0467589013,
-0.0289804246,
0.0539051592,
0.0302204024,
0.0217372831,
-0.044572711,
0.0191920623,
-0.0085252812,
-0.0187954623,
-0.0019153641,
-0.0734714195,
0.0808223858,
-0.0286539253,
0.0252939519,
0.0560414381,
0.0644318089,
-0.0274180546,
0.0293881632,
-0.0176004786,
-0.0315339044,
-0.0027610397,
0.0269032922,
0.03467682,
-0.0131280795,
-0.0439825542,
0.0392544791,
0.0037712413,
-0.0224953797,
-0.0224736016,
-0.0306389481,
0.0145528233,
0.0711392686,
0.0272524804,
0.0446176417,
-0.0125160515,
0.031969022,
0.028769996,
0.0194497854,
0.0011971592,
-0.0009796186,
0.0445674509,
-0.0617400445,
-0.0367339551,
0.0068638213,
-0.0241485834,
0.0296233837,
0.0164123401,
0.0189039744,
0.0258562583,
0.0239609331,
0.0690430701,
0.0016734346,
0.0121756829,
0.003607234,
-0.0255320128,
0.0256231129,
-0.0014297785,
-0.0088054733,
-0.0090318304,
0.0047233338,
0.0335087553,
-0.0280009303,
0.042404633,
0.0111680888,
-0.0892867222,
-0.0739749148,
0.0204486288,
0.016395865,
-0.0145057086,
-0.0240947064,
-0.0244638957,
-0.0067796814,
-0.0172952227,
-0.0092949504,
0.054636851,
-0.0301794112,
0.0016599619,
0.0322906896,
0.0290819928,
-0.0166185778,
0.0535967276,
-0.0441014059,
-0.0117746387,
0.0449500419,
0.0497870222,
-0.0144621665,
-0.0177688487,
-0.0232591536,
0.0399928242,
0.0012484618,
-0.0087724812,
-0.0078052501,
0.0158304162,
-0.029971512,
-0.0065957182,
-0.1221252456,
-0.0072683394,
-0.0169304274,
-0.0026733463,
-0.0127568152,
0.0210190378,
-0.0001682346,
-0.0264253411,
0.0060880785,
0.0054912637,
-0.0045168903,
0.0595128611,
-0.0210701153,
0.0088031851,
0.0130320741,
-0.0015495165,
-0.0411001071,
0.0162928086,
0.0872251987,
-0.0400960185,
-0.0527698249,
-0.0141927004,
0.0425913483,
-0.0241245907,
0.0069409613,
-0.0404847413,
-0.025653759,
-0.0010067646,
-0.0640559494,
0.0725715384,
0.0627637506,
0.0278826151,
-0.0319372974,
0.0147850113,
-0.0692002773,
-0.0422251783,
0.0043465942,
0.0248997211,
-0.0458943285,
-0.0016617738,
-0.0132660884,
-0.0556366444,
0.0586768277,
-0.0125709297,
0.0048216698,
-0.0228009336,
-0.0330871381,
0.0145295709,
-0.0447985791,
-0.0598102286,
0.0024014716,
-0.0024618679,
0.0031372146,
-0.0436746776,
-0.0449629575,
0.0479670912,
-0.0661746114,
-0.0205731615,
0.0212408286,
0.0081413584,
-0.0187219325,
0.0642172992,
0.0084762955,
0.0149975084,
-0.0243609194,
-0.005263099,
-0.0153297093,
0.0070855231,
-0.0028664903,
-0.0247536283,
0.0627896041,
-0.032316044,
0.0297269225,
-0.0359340198,
-0.0176089648,
-0.0166110117,
-0.0168262273,
-0.0310994703,
-0.0633204505,
-0.0201427545,
-0.0064878189,
0.0179729499,
0.0473514348,
0.0140107637,
0.0397229791,
-0.0144049944,
0.0171228442,
-0.0228877068,
0.0431824736,
0.0566308424,
0.0271984786,
-0.0300368443,
-0.041896604,
0.0170354079,
0.0844563767,
0.0448562205,
-0.0046551581,
-0.0356693566,
0.0464691296,
0.0401265137,
0.0724897459,
-0.0200888701,
0.0365630873,
0.0359673947,
-0.06340684,
0.0335692056,
0.0607602634,
0.0019133415,
-0.0863569602,
-0.0458044857,
0.0043907333,
0.0333055332,
0.0000771497,
-0.0001456438,
-0.0919924006,
-0.0777729675,
0.0383489691,
-0.0335955471,
0.0259667728,
-0.0005488714,
-0.0271619875,
-0.1019584015,
0.0177120343,
0.011568333,
-0.0183838718,
0.0016849057,
-0.0249363557,
-0.0180510767,
0.0182621162,
0.0153414775,
0.0306471903,
-0.0064349934,
-0.0235827789,
-0.0122166695,
0.036229156,
-0.0236101747,
0.0271844454,
-0.0330745094,
0.0103809489,
0.0311612748,
0.0016379566,
0.0373225249,
-0.0264861304,
0.0432139412,
-0.0024938546,
0.0105920406,
-0.0340060703,
0.0050014877,
-0.0578397475,
-0.0104819424,
-0.0188776758,
0.0148680434,
0.0013540176,
-0.0356914178,
-0.0128083276,
0.0451093316,
-0.0014746028,
0.0031574396,
-0.0307322145,
-0.0175053719,
0.0013099798,
0.0612984076,
0.0161306281,
-0.0174599327,
-0.0174581464,
-0.0055884793,
-0.0163590536,
-0.0278330594,
-0.0230161231,
0.007322717,
-0.0007675124,
-0.0267796945,
-0.0209651776,
-0.0120281242,
0.0052202386,
0.0406666473,
-0.0417482741,
0.0144743109,
-0.0288032498,
0.0046063117,
-0.0855506584,
0.0649782568,
-0.0447057933,
0.0412206426,
-0.0386949927,
0.0331982002,
0.0373049267,
-0.0306678154,
0.0054894369,
0.0625942051,
-0.1261572987,
-0.055874493,
-0.0280264821,
0.0455029123,
0.0097189229,
0.0687373132,
0.0197043568,
-0.0550148226,
0.0256894175,
0.0254241899,
-0.0262043346,
0.0602655858,
-0.0105101578,
0.021767864,
0.0074467044,
0.011476635,
-0.0479014143,
-0.0089744171,
-0.0127359824,
0.0091140456,
0.00669599,
-0.0316531099,
-0.0328325704,
-0.0088437609,
0.0230435003,
-0.0215314534,
0.004574988,
0.0100830728,
0.0371688306,
-0.0051438217,
-0.0170226991,
-0.0290695522,
0.0222123023,
-0.0143992184,
0.0086951498,
0.0253060162,
0.0035823884,
0.0639218241,
0.0107112341,
-0.0293303765,
-0.0073585017,
0.0138224848,
-0.0216369983,
0.0313016996,
0.0160426665,
-0.011411665,
0.0213049799,
-0.0074711437,
0.011544792,
-0.050283324,
0.0475565903,
0.0204511378,
-0.0288781412,
-0.0190687049,
0.0300827269,
-0.0278409086,
-0.0070310286,
-0.0136573594,
-0.0080351699,
0.0746703222,
-0.0160016138,
0.0439441837,
-0.0087411636,
-0.0102197975,
-0.040936362,
0.0324576907,
0.0201303158,
-0.0460504107,
0.0486149043,
0.0292635318,
0.0173828099,
0.0306820329,
0.038573049,
0.024186207,
0.0369145274,
-0.0145541653,
0.0094967932,
-0.0057877665,
-0.0250383373,
0.0031407103,
0.0139927007,
-0.0058921725,
-0.0182803441,
-0.0244515669,
-0.0773871318,
0.013134975,
-0.0063145454,
-0.0455940776,
0.0148402248,
0.0432853624,
0.0345126577,
0.0313512832,
-0.0420511104,
0.0064905183,
0.0187272597,
-0.0061836895,
-0.0020328101,
0.0191891994,
-6.564570243e-33,
-0.0288770534,
-0.0437013879,
0.0351694636,
-0.0487262867,
-0.0377495214,
0.038204357,
-0.0216263179,
-0.0274713077,
-0.012485492,
-0.0323005505,
0.0078228926,
0.0044406471,
0.0212769117,
0.0230295453,
-0.0210687034,
-0.0116204489,
0.0181598868,
0.0136177046,
0.0128934439,
0.0183448512,
0.0248626545,
0.0346750766,
0.0175520256,
-0.019816434,
-0.007832895,
0.0026110301,
0.0181746706,
0.0081283608,
-0.0014083302,
0.057784874,
-0.0668659136,
0.0131523805,
0.0169463195,
-0.0181804895,
-0.0285887197,
0.0473283045,
-0.0830585733,
0.0185960717,
0.0378933065,
0.027748201,
-0.0357697494,
-0.0448823087,
0.0104223266,
0.0220995825,
0.0097251069,
-0.0254590642,
0.0051239249,
-0.0008728746,
-0.0559699759,
-0.0075875847,
-0.0205679405,
0.020255262,
0.0141363842,
-0.0058856858,
0.0662539229,
0.0213481095,
0.0390423015,
0.0673798844,
-0.0814381838,
0.0197527539,
-0.0343775637,
0.0586425737,
0.1052762344,
0.0594800599,
0.0181214437,
0.0358864255,
0.0369262733,
-0.042452056,
-0.0588605329,
0.004910789,
0.0274733361,
0.0451005027,
-0.0137564773,
0.0684688091,
0.0250992943,
-0.0012399807,
-0.0218822639,
-0.0136439167,
-0.0115394732,
0.0453615598,
0.0393922403,
0.0205223095,
0.0082274424,
-0.0275640041,
-0.0528990515,
0.025131477,
-0.0635843426,
0.0098087555,
0.0456319004,
0.0360003449,
0.0011677899,
0.0110792723,
0.1240593269,
-0.0150186392,
-0.0078597572,
0.0329864211,
-0.0009295862,
0.0547991842,
-0.0142680993,
0.0509021096,
-0.0136133349,
-0.0130850328,
0.0525926873,
-0.0198642444,
0.01975636,
0.0200392604,
-0.0168555491,
0.0264085103,
-0.0494959876,
-0.0276200753,
-0.0411312208,
-0.0349231064,
-0.0126229981,
-0.0021300435,
0.0525466762,
-0.0039449413,
-0.0068426719,
0.0861600339,
0.0034355887,
0.0153378202,
-0.0177383702,
-0.0764732063,
0.0082236817,
0.0145101845,
-0.0102991378,
0.0257540103,
-0.0311083682,
-0.0431810841,
0.0408004597,
-0.0538072698,
-0.0174833219,
0.0694090202,
2.702e-7,
0.0131613761,
0.0196812898,
0.0384375006,
-0.000364711,
0.0227920897,
0.0445394926,
0.0120217009,
0.0204468332,
0.0049975459,
-0.0574319623,
-0.0232871305,
0.0521783456,
0.0483238697,
0.0051146611,
-0.0457507782,
0.0095156524,
-0.0430548973,
-0.0053040478,
-0.0664426461,
-0.0103031276,
0.0434850045,
0.0844800919,
-0.0357780382,
-0.0343243293,
0.0530618243,
-0.0141470125,
0.0641111806,
-0.0190753452,
-0.0334278867,
-0.0218172092,
0.0013805657,
-0.0240942873,
-0.0106451139,
0.002518076,
0.011751865,
-0.0502399243,
-0.0033453789,
0.0552559383,
-0.0042531085,
-0.0788015276,
-0.0044237692,
0.0000695076,
-0.0640463978,
-0.0414240807,
0.1083256379,
-0.0187069885,
-0.0082510561,
-0.0501217619,
0.0016605429,
-0.0304891225,
-0.0166984536,
0.0030013039,
-0.014185803,
0.0464331359,
0.0328554288,
-0.0257302169,
-0.0515730307,
-0.1172764003,
-0.055129949,
-0.012068253,
-0.0680258647,
-0.0314676054,
-0.0679822564,
-0.042879913,
0.0752249658,
-0.0701003671,
-0.0416059904,
2.466319391e-34,
0.0178600624,
-0.0305894185,
0.0212215949,
0.031559024,
0.0253459569,
-0.0191685446,
-0.0398039483,
0.0325336419,
-0.0144507419,
-0.0895194411,
-0.0454614274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18135v1 | Automatic Speech Recognition for Hindi | 2024-06-26T07:39:20 | 2024-06-26T07:39:20 | Anish Saha, A. G. Ramakrishnan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Automatic speech recognition (ASR) is a key area in computational
linguistics, focusing on developing technologies that enable computers to
convert spoken language into text. This field combines linguistics and machine
learning. ASR models, which map speech audio to transcripts through supervised
learning, require handling real and unrestricted text. Text-to-speech systems
directly work with real text, while ASR systems rely on language models trained
on large text corpora. High-quality transcribed data is essential for training
predictive models. The research involved two main components: developing a web
application and designing a web interface for speech recognition. The web
application, created with JavaScript and Node.js, manages large volumes of
audio files and their transcriptions, facilitating collaborative human
correction of ASR transcripts. It operates in real-time using a client-server
architecture. The web interface for speech recognition records 16 kHz mono
audio from any device running the web app, performs voice activity detection
(VAD), and sends the audio to the recognition engine. VAD detects human speech
presence, aiding efficient speech processing and reducing unnecessary
processing during non-speech intervals, thus saving computation and network
bandwidth in VoIP applications. The final phase of the research tested a neural
network for accurately aligning the speech signal to hidden Markov model (HMM)
states. This included implementing a novel backpropagation method that utilizes
prior statistics of node co-activations. | [
0.0184105597,
-0.0049692155,
-0.0102115292,
-0.006357702,
-0.0535048544,
-0.0270162374,
0.0107635828,
0.0045541613,
0.0120672528,
-0.041797094,
-0.0333051942,
-0.012059086,
0.0758139864,
0.0435211547,
0.0061588106,
-0.0251142699,
0.0094955601,
-0.0298232436,
0.0271859597,
0.0006936914,
0.012329747,
0.0263257828,
-0.0824543238,
0.0295224357,
-0.0464689024,
-0.0139185637,
-0.0160565153,
-0.0079403482,
-0.0146028912,
-0.015578934,
-0.062896654,
-0.0002707576,
-0.0008355581,
0.014846676,
0.0000017416,
-0.0361974314,
-0.0062147235,
0.0253442489,
-0.0155922528,
-0.0138511555,
0.0206868537,
0.0764221251,
-0.0484439619,
0.0682120547,
0.0168979988,
0.0392856188,
0.0771374702,
-0.0062862672,
0.0057403017,
0.0585031398,
-0.0246293321,
-0.0148319211,
0.0567897484,
0.0351739302,
-0.0389767475,
0.0015401434,
0.0161138456,
0.0019154402,
0.0240546465,
-0.0536075048,
0.0057527148,
0.0090018157,
-0.0347374044,
-0.0165161472,
0.0174125154,
0.0036252013,
-0.0460759215,
-0.0494311787,
0.0029170916,
0.0274343584,
0.013588204,
-0.0127588538,
0.057029292,
0.0140594216,
-0.0489871092,
0.0185481757,
-0.0086435238,
0.0174711589,
-0.0349080004,
0.0097799674,
0.0194057506,
0.0086670481,
0.0060580862,
-0.0061666691,
0.0943764299,
-0.029704798,
0.0069404081,
-0.0368514061,
-0.0181862805,
-0.0471261404,
0.048717577,
-0.0018454194,
0.1052109078,
0.0208051614,
0.0023049379,
0.0227186624,
0.0165772233,
-0.0576104224,
0.0087362677,
-0.0872982144,
0.0303902198,
0.0290314294,
-0.0335812308,
-0.0022215568,
0.0058778138,
0.0387651101,
0.0044902684,
-0.0457377397,
-0.0108711915,
0.0209729169,
-0.0071171252,
-0.0347008966,
-0.00703316,
0.021644989,
-0.0012672169,
-0.0174329095,
-0.0509889573,
0.0168032292,
-0.0155660436,
-0.0080990791,
0.0675074533,
-0.0327846557,
-0.0291568283,
-0.0185945611,
0.0421991572,
0.0265158154,
-0.001640451,
0.0408765785,
-0.0020275901,
-0.1044211984,
0.0352666713,
-0.0026525571,
0.0407684818,
0.0222470313,
-0.0080314623,
0.0460563414,
0.0080275675,
0.0021339087,
-0.0614305809,
0.012843458,
-0.022209011,
-0.0251043346,
-0.0132498369,
-0.0535794795,
0.046420496,
0.0128600718,
-0.0302073564,
0.0035869989,
0.0082638878,
0.0065570688,
0.0280593876,
0.0687503442,
-0.008216613,
0.0261964891,
0.0981728807,
-0.0079529798,
0.0356655307,
0.0177381448,
0.0433632433,
-0.0174840558,
0.0215592943,
-0.05049688,
-0.0008522627,
0.0515636094,
-0.051825501,
-0.0290537272,
-0.0341346674,
-0.005218707,
-0.0329147428,
0.039197579,
-0.0160021074,
0.0390841961,
0.0283525418,
0.0259002279,
0.0664866567,
0.0881286636,
-0.0038416551,
0.0523382351,
-0.0079482114,
0.009808776,
0.0132186925,
-0.0175989494,
0.0203560144,
0.0211809874,
-0.0259931386,
-0.0005407787,
0.0150332693,
0.0085234884,
-0.004697789,
-0.0010392466,
-0.0203759409,
-0.0479520634,
-0.0183472708,
0.0195088424,
0.0485766791,
-0.0230614617,
-0.041905839,
-0.0162734129,
0.0258797407,
-0.0568961464,
0.0099988114,
-0.0558223948,
-0.0077060289,
0.0314952731,
0.0246382561,
-0.0407127962,
-0.0059389002,
-0.0240003094,
-0.07243599,
0.010804343,
-0.0045209099,
0.0059815496,
-0.0081122834,
-0.0599354319,
0.0027969687,
0.0817581192,
-0.0130910277,
0.0428511202,
-0.0729983225,
0.0405303352,
0.0170953907,
0.0139425024,
0.0031435243,
-0.0061171069,
-0.0176716615,
-0.0004995597,
-0.0360464491,
0.0200151503,
0.1021531522,
0.0115923239,
-0.0210906416,
-0.0012074409,
0.030609915,
0.0060206321,
0.0262269657,
0.0363661647,
-0.0152299916,
-0.0042927759,
0.0639616251,
-0.0452429317,
0.0306633767,
0.0741476044,
0.0481833667,
-0.0914069936,
0.045702152,
-0.0520084091,
0.0041581742,
-0.0404412299,
0.0461233892,
0.0120941866,
0.0047983313,
0.0344521068,
-0.0332161523,
0.0365355462,
-0.0095375404,
0.0124127967,
-0.027365841,
0.0340902396,
-0.0505665354,
0.0043438952,
0.0415274911,
-0.0534716472,
0.0348579213,
0.0103773084,
-0.0266255215,
-0.0384336784,
0.0083304346,
-0.1268511266,
-0.0048335199,
-0.0002006153,
-0.006263352,
-0.0111940559,
0.0733235925,
0.007912227,
-0.0582367554,
-0.0262050815,
0.0097873211,
0.0162245519,
-0.0087115858,
-0.0083650667,
-0.0370445512,
-0.0461818874,
-0.0353991576,
-0.0336113498,
-0.008485646,
0.0168118905,
0.0094461516,
-0.0749888271,
-0.0158446133,
-0.0271346532,
0.028668439,
0.0482552648,
-0.0082175201,
-0.0402462184,
-0.0198107697,
0.0037367311,
0.0372292139,
0.0360691883,
0.0114442213,
-0.0274007693,
0.0009321998,
-0.0045711561,
-0.0355521329,
-0.0033662929,
0.0390690193,
0.0503473692,
-0.0139075834,
-0.0139759313,
-0.0160601661,
0.0212666802,
0.0499466583,
0.0253939386,
0.0115882047,
-0.0844642594,
-0.0473121218,
0.016576387,
0.0060700844,
-0.0287286285,
-0.0946198851,
0.024603352,
0.0248120185,
-0.0344814137,
0.0207165349,
-0.0560026579,
-0.0162897278,
-0.0719845369,
-0.0469201356,
0.0103017269,
-0.0082165515,
-0.0171988569,
0.0022396711,
-0.0348358788,
-0.0741289854,
-0.0274397917,
0.0154108424,
0.0110014947,
-0.0789072216,
-0.0651549771,
-0.0178583823,
0.0247350279,
-0.0203501433,
-0.0032831091,
-0.020464452,
-0.0260692108,
-0.019836219,
0.0343924016,
0.0086454032,
0.0195052773,
0.0367709361,
0.0740344375,
-0.0152975079,
0.0507992879,
0.0037699095,
0.0284154359,
-0.0062448601,
0.0237198304,
0.0415510833,
0.0037608433,
-0.0472563207,
0.0340578258,
-0.0093318345,
-0.0358509123,
0.0255902335,
-0.0000972948,
-0.0423085615,
-0.0156591889,
0.0246641543,
-0.0454991981,
-0.0196546204,
0.0423349477,
0.0193975456,
-0.0175160356,
0.0148637705,
0.0549377315,
0.0177360419,
-0.043693468,
-0.0635146722,
-0.0299886689,
-0.0419893265,
-0.0124514289,
0.0216747131,
0.0049452218,
0.0053667827,
0.0735578164,
0.0316706635,
0.0251573864,
0.0503080375,
0.011421605,
-0.0570478365,
0.0126242787,
-0.0019571118,
0.0066887885,
-0.0077955853,
-0.0506599098,
-0.0160789508,
0.0103365425,
0.0360542536,
0.0142973419,
-0.0157960188,
-0.0491068736,
0.0615628995,
-0.090531677,
-0.0265755076,
0.0076727797,
-0.0333120227,
0.0815055668,
0.0781645924,
0.0381432101,
-0.0242321175,
-0.0268424749,
0.0159521867,
-0.0073085809,
0.0139656849,
0.0244053882,
-0.0019711896,
0.0234668385,
-0.0016675449,
-0.0042767152,
0.0233457685,
-0.0140160574,
0.0168187618,
0.0099687884,
0.0593288913,
-0.0243959893,
0.0139459409,
-0.0117942709,
0.0632125661,
0.0216124468,
0.012085543,
0.0107386997,
-0.0325716846,
-0.0298699699,
0.0302908439,
0.0473490991,
0.011065769,
0.0103624333,
0.0078581832,
-0.0173535198,
-0.0644790679,
-0.015454975,
0.0010231811,
-0.0017186902,
0.0050232881,
0.0749513581,
0.0491036512,
0.0734047145,
0.0395279154,
-0.047620181,
-0.0375774577,
-0.0145599693,
0.0500933491,
-0.0535077155,
0.0015152108,
0.0361824408,
-0.0811980963,
0.0006963874,
-0.0276320856,
-0.0146475779,
-0.0172340665,
0.0551080965,
-0.0174619108,
0.0208590589,
0.0516367517,
-0.0689632446,
-0.0433734134,
0.0315425806,
-0.0124639617,
-0.0744421929,
-0.0317200609,
0.0366083793,
-0.0022476746,
-0.0167773049,
-0.0198805016,
-0.0503468551,
0.0169395301,
-0.0398948118,
-0.0248623546,
-0.0108070234,
-0.053527005,
0.0085731475,
0.0610139631,
0.0509898737,
-0.0394613557,
0.0305765532,
-0.0278152917,
-0.0041479245,
0.0377793647,
0.0500531048,
-0.0114841601,
-0.0080492515,
0.0419902243,
0.0450498424,
0.0022314414,
-0.005951813,
-0.0385673642,
-0.0805005282,
0.0100136818,
0.110274218,
0.0408188291,
0.036533013,
0.0141102271,
0.0021967681,
-0.0197786111,
-0.0026083756,
0.0495861843,
0.0101843467,
-0.0144621739,
0.0269573107,
-0.0210148823,
-0.0111130979,
0.0182906296,
0.0148123484,
0.0118619334,
0.0452472605,
-0.0099663241,
0.0603548475,
0.0541577227,
0.0148380157,
0.0229794811,
-0.0128069073,
0.0394090638,
-0.0409865119,
0.0519956797,
-0.0417381413,
0.0477333181,
0.0188379232,
-0.0034189881,
-0.03792895,
0.0291330405,
-0.0070338985,
0.0108720986,
-0.0259086676,
0.0059644305,
-0.0297304839,
-0.0277189426,
-0.006316694,
-0.0405105427,
0.0411176719,
-0.0303989816,
-0.0288410895,
0.0179958772,
-0.064058058,
-0.0014426594,
-0.0142299756,
0.0549786054,
-0.0380586535,
0.0132537549,
-0.0182815194,
-0.0150128035,
0.0322755873,
-0.0117211314,
0.0051067583,
-0.0177417472,
-0.0036643313,
0.0112977326,
-5.483399395e-33,
-0.0136538241,
0.0192621294,
-0.0115018301,
0.0272111706,
-0.0361656956,
-0.0093866158,
-0.0235581789,
0.00110077,
0.0148361651,
-0.0102947494,
-0.0479930043,
0.0103727356,
0.0333080366,
-0.0104250126,
0.0343154185,
-0.0017591977,
0.053574454,
-0.0200838316,
0.057473544,
-0.0222057309,
0.0331703834,
0.0521192513,
0.0454111136,
-0.0402277,
-0.046069514,
-0.0308196936,
-0.0212976504,
-0.0437662192,
0.0152251218,
0.0068000825,
0.0028118826,
0.0309006777,
-0.0104459971,
-0.0085680168,
0.0109179178,
0.0374722183,
-0.1001097038,
0.0167978629,
0.0040255282,
0.123380281,
-0.0250406787,
0.0172685385,
0.0365785435,
0.0173412282,
-0.0571512431,
0.0322893485,
0.0356574357,
-0.0286996849,
-0.0549300052,
-0.0569954589,
-0.0113441041,
0.0414754823,
-0.0365438759,
-0.0184928384,
0.0581150539,
0.0472368449,
-0.0237541627,
-0.0719448552,
-0.0527142473,
0.016078895,
-0.015653491,
0.013910925,
0.0251428448,
0.0753511786,
-0.0156430956,
0.000090591,
0.0482448153,
-0.1109298542,
-0.0042611463,
0.013688704,
0.0214374326,
0.0144645851,
-0.0073239021,
-0.0438625216,
0.0572740622,
-0.076631926,
-0.0310154334,
0.0166884027,
0.0503977202,
-0.0040891469,
0.0195275862,
0.0291705653,
-0.0649405196,
-0.0207805876,
0.0065418743,
-0.0296265408,
-0.0473322161,
-0.0218824316,
0.0552728809,
-0.0178462472,
-0.0068771574,
0.0161366649,
0.014644457,
-0.0310300402,
0.0383893996,
0.005453622,
-0.0380480289,
0.0062911911,
-0.012177364,
0.0073696328,
-0.0348863415,
-0.0356574431,
-0.0093524326,
0.0445943847,
0.0395302027,
-0.0014771378,
-0.0085068382,
0.0355594642,
-0.0581234917,
-0.0029698717,
0.0172851477,
0.0300737247,
0.0228745863,
0.040143732,
0.0244627073,
-0.0493922308,
0.0051031169,
0.0358718,
0.0037582682,
0.0281555653,
0.0153860869,
-0.0003663401,
-0.0167191476,
-0.0123908129,
-0.055231303,
0.0274782069,
-0.0131610632,
0.0573896207,
0.019702008,
0.0033988946,
-0.0023173483,
0.0211628787,
2.74e-7,
-0.055016119,
0.0455392972,
0.0378658324,
-0.0622166805,
0.0182475317,
0.0062579089,
-0.0446821935,
-0.0034168158,
0.022403663,
0.0538460389,
0.0099176513,
-0.0573501363,
0.0994106457,
0.0364648812,
-0.0837595463,
-0.062237829,
-0.1012005806,
0.0414033867,
-0.0273838192,
0.06669835,
-0.0276448391,
0.0457389392,
0.0125287604,
-0.0472197793,
0.0127396164,
-0.0249130521,
0.0117612779,
-0.0086277146,
0.0173637141,
-0.0109688686,
-0.0014935484,
-0.0191553254,
-0.0231481083,
-0.0218701717,
-0.0540622547,
0.0311761033,
0.0253889598,
0.0460514538,
-0.0233515743,
0.0155249061,
0.0365819186,
0.0359877013,
-0.0072746105,
0.0369291157,
0.0387415588,
0.0356461816,
-0.0672289059,
-0.0230834559,
-0.0483270176,
-0.0300042145,
0.0019594687,
0.0063266959,
0.0166587047,
-0.0327064395,
-0.031976074,
-0.0564516447,
-0.0384541228,
0.0083960611,
0.0030945104,
-0.0102172149,
-0.0413835607,
-0.0187213682,
-0.0000924839,
0.0114262858,
0.0424414799,
0.0310633667,
0.0023283311,
1.95864611e-34,
0.012746565,
-0.0338737443,
0.0092941849,
-0.0107444236,
0.0059161903,
-0.0125574581,
0.0278594457,
0.0405551717,
0.0202278495,
-0.0243085362,
-0.0545905232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18134v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18134v1 | Assessing "Implicit" Retrieval Robustness of Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T07:38:24 | 2024-06-26T07:38:24 | Xiaoyu Shen, Rexhina Blloshmi, Dawei Zhu, Jiahuan Pei, Wei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-augmented generation has gained popularity as a framework to
enhance large language models with external knowledge. However, its
effectiveness hinges on the retrieval robustness of the model. If the model
lacks retrieval robustness, its performance is constrained by the accuracy of
the retriever, resulting in significant compromises when the retrieved context
is irrelevant. In this paper, we evaluate the "implicit" retrieval robustness
of various large language models, instructing them to directly output the final
answer without explicitly judging the relevance of the retrieved context. Our
findings reveal that fine-tuning on a mix of gold and distracting context
significantly enhances the model's robustness to retrieval inaccuracies, while
still maintaining its ability to extract correct answers when retrieval is
accurate. This suggests that large language models can implicitly handle
relevant or irrelevant retrieved context by learning solely from the
supervision of the final answer in an end-to-end manner. Introducing an
additional process for explicit relevance judgment can be unnecessary and
disrupts the end-to-end approach. | [
0.0637865886,
0.0484694354,
-0.0221835393,
0.0315722823,
-0.0278004482,
-0.0235915948,
-0.0218353346,
0.017798245,
-0.0030335221,
-0.0705785602,
-0.029707022,
-0.024744181,
-0.0333563648,
0.0031294285,
0.0320084505,
-0.012664861,
0.073207967,
-0.0374061354,
0.0147640118,
-0.0034465429,
-0.016248839,
0.0028367012,
0.0319472812,
0.0467810035,
-0.0071181594,
0.0084466645,
0.0085408036,
0.0111299697,
-0.0133581357,
0.00045447,
0.0269014612,
0.0333568379,
-0.019366065,
0.0613168217,
0.000001852,
-0.0337830223,
-0.0293215569,
0.0084723942,
-0.0225508511,
0.0136207668,
0.0163600948,
0.0230039936,
0.0048133451,
0.0226830132,
-0.0518874004,
0.0266978461,
0.050004825,
0.0388094895,
0.039937634,
0.0468926951,
0.0122133698,
0.0099941939,
0.0098612066,
-0.0310638305,
0.0128657268,
-0.0671819672,
0.0211828835,
0.0103095379,
0.0126513531,
0.0460237637,
0.0016038197,
0.0659688488,
0.0144703779,
-0.0290379208,
0.0034520635,
0.0199547671,
-0.0656890497,
-0.001245797,
0.0031395319,
0.037442226,
0.0343700796,
-0.0162678417,
-0.0194312707,
-0.0049425829,
0.0122522749,
0.027359901,
-0.0463857539,
0.016931802,
0.0075120637,
-0.0108552417,
0.0009461322,
0.0023012182,
0.0280259158,
0.0337568,
-0.0079507679,
0.0435514711,
0.0392101035,
-0.0238770284,
-0.0334935114,
0.0195509158,
-0.0525229014,
-0.0462807491,
-0.0062476755,
0.0563246943,
-0.0343179256,
0.0447102338,
-0.0213993359,
-0.0153981168,
0.0474257469,
-0.0468996838,
0.0383773036,
0.0541361272,
-0.0460540242,
0.0411587097,
-0.0510328338,
0.0307454467,
-0.0384136289,
-0.018268019,
-0.0424198322,
-0.0295761954,
-0.0048577408,
-0.0428511612,
-0.0420164242,
0.0593938082,
-0.0348156802,
-0.0200401116,
-0.0267787743,
0.0235278104,
-0.0118462145,
-0.0055846716,
-0.0187464859,
0.0416368209,
-0.0756099895,
-0.0183726698,
-0.0164167359,
0.0194518231,
-0.0390949883,
0.0116644241,
0.0389736816,
-0.077290304,
-0.0058861156,
-0.0150227332,
-0.0002342504,
-0.0399666652,
-0.0260788929,
0.086692825,
-0.0145579297,
-0.036074616,
-0.04612175,
-0.0579869859,
-0.0487093218,
-0.0465103947,
-0.0010695157,
-0.038462352,
-0.0033893662,
0.0192215536,
-0.0221835338,
-0.033310838,
0.0259388853,
0.038795691,
-0.0181149468,
0.0288628899,
0.0129589206,
-0.0017838661,
0.0359348208,
0.0204928163,
0.0030155445,
0.0793279782,
0.000818118,
0.0253393464,
0.0560755059,
-0.0025335285,
-0.007971799,
0.0178891867,
0.03805371,
0.0145855574,
-0.0459352508,
0.0227894168,
0.0248764213,
-0.0086697014,
-0.0150277866,
0.0810348317,
-0.0340015665,
-0.0096712112,
0.0593563467,
0.0131295621,
0.0090200687,
0.0107466374,
0.0615023077,
-0.0228295755,
0.0038666844,
0.045309376,
-0.0551599301,
0.0314246044,
-0.1004172266,
0.012683956,
0.0485705398,
0.0101912702,
-0.0171020143,
-0.0464133844,
-0.0088276751,
0.0161206294,
0.0060634641,
0.0266935006,
0.0703864396,
0.0270009972,
-0.0377347134,
0.0455443673,
0.0234094467,
-0.045951046,
0.0138971498,
-0.0803044364,
0.0476725921,
0.0342007689,
0.07735008,
-0.0175213013,
-0.0031988497,
0.0346976705,
0.0029845543,
0.0327861272,
0.0600635558,
-0.0133610852,
0.005924569,
-0.0356826633,
-0.0240046997,
-0.0121909697,
0.0302297417,
0.0132890046,
0.0612132736,
-0.0051236288,
0.0499681458,
-0.0150925219,
0.0144016789,
0.0273149498,
-0.0454881266,
-0.0580426641,
-0.008564868,
-0.0178832803,
-0.0088741928,
0.0045217201,
-0.0102955047,
0.0430006124,
0.0265901294,
-0.0053424975,
-0.0296092685,
-0.03622609,
-0.0708643794,
0.0207422841,
0.0210972428,
0.0373699665,
0.0007328279,
0.0044063721,
-0.0063565015,
-0.0305908974,
0.0367558114,
-0.0512628518,
0.0793031752,
-0.0546292625,
0.0163620114,
0.0083203502,
0.0095837582,
-0.049518995,
0.06243724,
-0.0017417243,
0.0202103555,
0.0316109844,
0.0427656248,
0.0066017183,
-0.0762603804,
-0.0215383582,
0.017525807,
-0.0210030209,
0.0318238884,
0.0645663813,
-0.026430333,
-0.0438628793,
-0.0287354607,
-0.0716188699,
-0.0143487556,
-0.0258177985,
-0.0295956917,
0.0182373635,
0.0267547015,
0.0061773765,
-0.0172464699,
-0.0019068854,
0.0047558434,
0.0342846476,
0.0433350652,
-0.0088923406,
0.0344700292,
0.0075962483,
-0.0642661154,
-0.0352831706,
0.0155694243,
0.0539578758,
0.0010099676,
0.0052793315,
-0.0326082036,
0.0308814626,
-0.0709075704,
0.0417359173,
-0.0024802361,
-0.0290050227,
0.014742272,
-0.0532619357,
0.0228896309,
0.0509607904,
0.0338492095,
0.0062471987,
0.0525855944,
-0.0478018038,
-0.0797031,
0.0129305776,
-0.0294628944,
-0.0929230452,
0.0070435139,
-0.0053024846,
-0.0134349326,
0.0439772531,
0.0086788423,
-0.0124089681,
-0.0590272658,
0.0346246846,
-0.037578024,
-0.0547422133,
-0.0394141227,
-0.0263565481,
-0.0243970025,
0.0567981154,
-0.0283017028,
-0.0607383065,
0.0748794302,
-0.0193755105,
0.0167787932,
0.0024070069,
0.0034509827,
-0.0143826129,
0.0538097471,
-0.0333738327,
0.0346981622,
-0.0143600395,
-0.0173513889,
-0.0534218587,
-0.0454724766,
0.0297989957,
-0.0678262711,
0.0720042437,
-0.0468899421,
0.0307063758,
0.0031059885,
-0.0407201648,
-0.0785257742,
-0.0316896215,
-0.0011816859,
0.036258772,
-0.0133960135,
-0.0037615953,
-0.0361181572,
0.0023660576,
0.0488110781,
0.0153006036,
-0.0307186171,
-0.0212903377,
-0.0087981727,
0.0519231819,
0.0800660104,
-0.0043235365,
0.0198540296,
-0.0404294394,
0.0015420927,
0.0626782775,
0.0075155976,
-0.0209465567,
-0.0068525579,
-0.0026191652,
0.0437827669,
-0.0130906953,
-0.0182486009,
0.0380862281,
0.0315637663,
-0.0661758259,
-0.0516900569,
0.0618550852,
0.0397209153,
-0.0352448486,
-0.0095919156,
-0.0494429395,
0.0139422324,
0.0249807835,
0.0504340716,
-0.0411029309,
-0.0166577231,
0.0342619233,
0.0372127444,
-0.0146132484,
-0.021678891,
-0.0183945633,
-0.1632450223,
0.0315887332,
0.0062434878,
-0.029560985,
-0.0341145992,
-0.0179345086,
0.0229315534,
0.0264996849,
0.0351853967,
0.0497527793,
-0.0027956062,
-0.0124983974,
0.0065035024,
0.0394680426,
-0.049736727,
0.0153575595,
0.0040809084,
0.0280713737,
0.0877607316,
0.00204146,
0.0192414541,
-0.001953386,
0.0608247891,
-0.0420986116,
0.0204997659,
-0.0039153136,
0.0334364101,
0.0086495494,
0.004298937,
-0.0136803305,
-0.0142801199,
0.0274900217,
-0.0208807569,
-0.0063949935,
0.0428153239,
-0.0068302285,
0.0112432158,
-0.0457805209,
0.003389087,
0.0286406036,
0.0629645959,
0.0217254236,
-0.0093186749,
-0.0177061521,
-0.0277451798,
0.0043325168,
-0.0218934305,
-0.0363963358,
0.0109386574,
0.0131069822,
0.0285120606,
-0.069661133,
-0.0445299819,
-0.0200249944,
0.0207815692,
-0.003389542,
0.0065674037,
-0.0532680899,
0.0041233525,
-0.0215027984,
0.0304839313,
-0.0600427426,
0.0028807316,
-0.035610877,
0.0106288902,
0.0186953861,
-0.0601258837,
-0.0129246237,
0.062341094,
-0.0173069537,
-0.0657094494,
0.0097095547,
0.0522569492,
0.0323476121,
0.0403490253,
-0.0180131551,
-0.0601034574,
0.0318131261,
0.0167626999,
-0.0605822392,
0.0201851279,
0.0084419474,
0.0050979219,
-0.0137414057,
0.0479712524,
-0.096819669,
0.0249624141,
0.0178422853,
0.0756326318,
0.0178326257,
-0.0384190381,
0.0410281084,
0.0213873237,
0.0126305036,
0.0024101636,
0.0127554638,
-0.0090070972,
0.0136106201,
-0.0442854874,
-0.0263215005,
-0.0283905566,
0.0314517543,
-0.00001582,
-0.0173639897,
0.005778301,
-0.0177222751,
0.0100813517,
0.0787117705,
-0.0371885449,
-0.0227984544,
0.0022948636,
-0.0004458221,
0.0280022919,
0.0169539601,
-0.0311106388,
0.0162273068,
0.0007363331,
0.0584380887,
-0.0353046916,
0.0588568002,
0.0194096193,
-0.0158798974,
-0.0322938114,
0.0034792731,
-0.0935699716,
-0.0325319618,
-0.0473451391,
0.0116051808,
0.0464372709,
-0.0277785268,
0.0457294397,
-0.0152798919,
-0.0403905697,
-0.0308321659,
-0.0033331679,
0.0508920848,
-0.0599234104,
0.0144042494,
0.0313011296,
0.0070708552,
0.0388578139,
0.0464960672,
-0.020942742,
0.0366114862,
-0.0518476814,
-0.0046488349,
-0.0238838587,
-0.0352502428,
0.021109676,
0.0285312012,
-0.0200697891,
0.0133566232,
-0.0624487586,
-0.0969160199,
-0.0231530145,
0.0149575826,
-0.012313067,
-0.0177724268,
0.0304016303,
0.089317739,
0.0226826947,
-0.0204963535,
-0.0489382595,
0.0250025634,
-0.0517205931,
0.0231125169,
-0.0472052023,
-6.567278288e-33,
-0.0599010289,
-0.0370650776,
0.0113456929,
-0.063671872,
-0.0136728864,
0.0304945521,
-0.0782734454,
-0.0017483053,
-0.0336746052,
-0.0157615896,
-0.030583851,
0.0227268264,
0.0054168198,
0.008963651,
0.0117105404,
-0.0051673907,
0.038721852,
0.0141694555,
-0.0380723476,
0.0326613411,
0.0545937084,
0.0151518714,
0.0170908216,
-0.0601924285,
0.0318854935,
0.0010303021,
0.0037503685,
0.0178151298,
-0.024400074,
0.0887215734,
-0.0237766877,
0.0570210516,
-0.0028976623,
-0.0032242548,
-0.0246739406,
0.0023521099,
-0.0646866858,
-0.0248516407,
0.0139077092,
-0.0353290364,
-0.0360427387,
-0.0248100907,
0.0240121931,
-0.0179079492,
-0.0156352613,
-0.0114734499,
0.022187965,
-0.0180647057,
-0.031437289,
-0.0246142689,
-0.0659405515,
0.0208886452,
0.0198942963,
0.0015219422,
-0.0021465919,
0.0553889312,
0.0287552308,
0.0367168039,
-0.0027294883,
0.0240746606,
0.0147851501,
0.054976996,
0.0463769212,
0.0363558382,
-0.0183271915,
0.04100205,
0.0072657112,
0.0109988451,
-0.0063014193,
-0.0891806334,
0.0151387108,
0.0231570825,
0.0473015942,
0.0630016774,
0.015163607,
-0.0052883471,
-0.0308563262,
0.0025005424,
-0.0078779124,
0.0397667661,
0.0633148476,
0.0062135416,
-0.0337904729,
-0.0084218141,
-0.0501307882,
0.006729099,
-0.061950665,
-0.0281780902,
0.0633532926,
0.0397484824,
-0.0225724764,
-0.0126216467,
0.0408552252,
-0.0445489176,
0.0087238019,
0.0541004799,
-0.0189012177,
-0.0073894723,
-0.015851032,
0.0362844132,
-0.0102014318,
-0.014697073,
0.0163557418,
-0.0180948414,
-0.0443122275,
0.0111951381,
-0.0083431816,
0.0225582924,
-0.0558456518,
0.0171402581,
-0.0426886827,
0.0389091894,
-0.0079097087,
-0.0384489931,
0.0415055864,
0.0138811562,
-0.0051830127,
0.0525129437,
0.0344937705,
0.0296637975,
-0.0117020831,
-0.0283609703,
0.0205692835,
0.0069248872,
-0.0255162809,
0.0189960785,
-0.0190131869,
0.0623949431,
0.0203841291,
-0.0089001758,
-0.0183422621,
0.0172690228,
2.634e-7,
0.0576716587,
0.0137982564,
0.0269836467,
0.0170573257,
-0.0076608504,
0.0140982699,
-0.0126480563,
-0.0019276,
0.0545599274,
0.0141200004,
-0.0194426887,
0.0353262164,
0.0457272381,
0.024144223,
-0.0375442915,
0.0115255779,
-0.0770479292,
-0.001654105,
-0.0155974859,
-0.0130671356,
0.0502369404,
0.0759602413,
-0.009558429,
0.0032525894,
-0.037585713,
-0.0838722438,
0.0856658891,
-0.0125112263,
-0.0041576149,
0.0062015639,
0.0299022309,
0.0470403805,
0.0227062441,
-0.023596257,
-0.0086550601,
0.0168775916,
0.00806507,
0.0486004613,
0.0037117619,
-0.0479263328,
-0.0228536017,
-0.011441174,
0.0206718352,
-0.0606751144,
0.05815617,
-0.0525242612,
-0.0102618737,
-0.024559807,
-0.0316158943,
-0.0086097596,
-0.0053279144,
-0.0182410702,
-0.0399862751,
0.0072242864,
-0.0028515118,
0.0515295118,
-0.0089420658,
-0.0996159688,
-0.0479449406,
0.0129642896,
-0.0442187749,
-0.0595819578,
-0.0257905945,
0.0169010218,
-0.027582787,
-0.0601569936,
0.0155995004,
2.469057237e-34,
0.0431611277,
0.0028628199,
0.0151048414,
0.0103611713,
0.0389959179,
0.0009704284,
0.0048850812,
0.0256470758,
0.0391152389,
-0.0843252093,
-0.0427396595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18133v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18133v1 | ConvoCache: Smart Re-Use of Chatbot Responses | 2024-06-26T07:35:10 | 2024-06-26T07:35:10 | Conor Atkins, Ian Wood, Mohamed Ali Kaafar, Hassan Asghar, Nardine Basta, Michal Kepkowski | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present ConvoCache, a conversational caching system that solves the
problem of slow and expensive generative AI models in spoken chatbots.
ConvoCache finds a semantically similar prompt in the past and reuses the
response. In this paper we evaluate ConvoCache on the DailyDialog dataset. We
find that ConvoCache can apply a UniEval coherence threshold of 90% and respond
to 89% of prompts using the cache with an average latency of 214ms, replacing
LLM and voice synthesis that can take over 1s. To further reduce latency we
test prefetching and find limited usefulness. Prefetching with 80% of a request
leads to a 63% hit rate, and a drop in overall coherence. ConvoCache can be
used with any chatbot to reduce costs by reducing usage of generative AI by up
to 89%. | [
0.0422973596,
0.0520870052,
-0.0099092126,
-0.0195653383,
-0.021092739,
-0.0234667193,
0.0384965092,
-0.0074972766,
0.0587018505,
-0.019816637,
-0.0051700375,
-0.0372155719,
-0.0280105397,
0.0667610168,
-0.0156060252,
-0.0534453578,
0.0445494987,
-0.0200502705,
0.0219876654,
-0.0195069332,
-0.0081436802,
-0.013435374,
-0.0141545553,
0.0781571269,
-0.0665963963,
-0.0494297035,
-0.0413838923,
0.0274001565,
-0.0000696059,
-0.0138037894,
-0.0128750456,
0.0178620983,
-0.0199101456,
0.0229928996,
0.0000022169,
-0.0440129824,
-0.0215429496,
-0.0122219408,
-0.0765406191,
-0.0018084049,
0.0150916371,
0.0439206921,
-0.0589573421,
0.0454899669,
-0.0307893325,
0.0421984755,
0.045341637,
-0.0082953339,
0.0621110052,
0.0843140632,
-0.0227994658,
0.0028065483,
0.0218584947,
0.0125753591,
0.0067418464,
-0.0640356094,
-0.0346821621,
0.0029273105,
0.0025423893,
-0.0391032249,
-0.0221008584,
0.0467694625,
0.0372966714,
-0.0328216366,
0.002979781,
0.0170362853,
-0.0503895022,
-0.0432456359,
-0.0176249333,
0.0529091246,
-0.0015203103,
0.0058640209,
0.0192491394,
0.0058076829,
0.0142156482,
-0.032434009,
-0.0205542017,
-0.0014095185,
-0.0366445817,
-0.0181667078,
-0.0462378561,
-0.0048487457,
-0.0219660476,
-0.018154392,
-0.0155775696,
-0.0352819525,
0.0209796857,
-0.0143736247,
-0.0449725613,
-0.0025589692,
0.0288986079,
-0.0682414323,
0.0064907121,
0.0582821704,
-0.0809125751,
-0.0008493151,
-0.0608138144,
0.0059816516,
0.0062106666,
-0.0194964055,
0.003516058,
0.0561930314,
-0.0425453261,
0.0049426807,
-0.0081751924,
0.0477129407,
0.0024221232,
-0.0369764082,
-0.0332239829,
-0.0267178733,
-0.0400328524,
-0.0149045018,
-0.062969707,
0.0428138562,
0.0198356267,
-0.0461978838,
-0.055761613,
0.0605593883,
-0.0177312773,
-0.0013347249,
-0.0087094279,
0.0274302363,
-0.0369175375,
0.0150431199,
-0.0235352516,
-0.0029036768,
-0.0410731398,
-0.0041465913,
0.0181162581,
-0.1416526586,
-0.00630579,
0.0025094463,
0.0201859046,
0.0215233881,
0.0072208545,
0.0694489852,
-0.0219428558,
-0.0260055922,
-0.0134938369,
-0.0611150749,
0.0292200483,
-0.0630601197,
-0.0244527757,
-0.0394753516,
0.0008355444,
-0.0311368518,
-0.0002892139,
0.0170460474,
-0.0230508931,
0.0046594399,
0.0026934075,
0.0051700608,
0.0088342577,
0.0366753116,
0.0289236121,
0.0086163888,
0.0132381273,
0.0270077866,
0.0315791816,
0.017523542,
0.0306593869,
-0.0273137353,
0.0327157192,
0.0077453377,
0.0141497487,
-0.0156477336,
0.0184483137,
-0.0017106977,
-0.0185764004,
0.0397791453,
0.0211383253,
0.0191963818,
-0.0445319563,
-0.0111366734,
0.0616949201,
0.0596705042,
-0.0001299416,
-0.0025228576,
0.0353291705,
0.0344558023,
0.0264243577,
0.0043598395,
-0.0246839207,
0.0338972546,
-0.0223469455,
0.0107033597,
0.0262872856,
0.0228674579,
-0.0646315813,
-0.0337670594,
0.042565506,
-0.037244048,
-0.0136643983,
0.029810572,
0.0061568739,
0.0137752146,
-0.0505646616,
-0.0253076013,
-0.0290891938,
-0.0749787986,
-0.0696584359,
-0.0513449498,
0.0156677309,
0.1176166013,
0.0473900214,
0.0227784365,
-0.0382681005,
0.0274866149,
-0.0209375937,
0.0300537925,
0.0359961428,
-0.0083136307,
0.0343409777,
-0.0239187926,
0.0005106432,
0.0173821319,
-0.0169603936,
0.0516331978,
0.0080230134,
0.0218621809,
-0.0135945212,
0.0900944769,
0.0581183024,
-0.0080668312,
-0.0086237164,
-0.0057070064,
0.0014670452,
-0.0033047171,
0.073003158,
0.0275464877,
-0.0205294713,
-0.0066440958,
0.0045021079,
-0.0106226606,
-0.0191711094,
0.0545217581,
-0.069688566,
-0.0220783912,
0.0299060009,
-0.0146865668,
-0.0077393325,
0.0296335854,
-0.0147333099,
-0.0499655716,
0.042815607,
-0.0377530605,
0.0683347359,
-0.0233442634,
0.0377845727,
-0.0041512563,
0.0263537131,
0.0254099537,
0.0154592553,
0.0151904151,
-0.0201517791,
0.0379578955,
0.0794920325,
0.0010324797,
-0.068294853,
0.030953886,
0.0403684601,
-0.0266759358,
0.0327764973,
0.0085703544,
0.0132064177,
-0.0549376495,
-0.019791685,
-0.1135748476,
-0.0031125883,
0.0229328126,
-0.0443885587,
-0.0082928268,
0.0032649797,
-0.0122631341,
-0.0348626114,
-0.0334124714,
0.0304356758,
0.0353219919,
0.0320265628,
-0.018357547,
-0.0386469699,
-0.0537179038,
-0.0481211208,
0.0226225089,
0.0496734604,
0.0050489907,
-0.0027429815,
-0.0080080489,
-0.0278040878,
0.0068788049,
-0.0371424481,
0.029686613,
0.003655893,
-0.0625898466,
0.0384858884,
0.008840112,
0.0410970524,
0.0590730049,
0.0506649651,
-0.0098120831,
0.0023703666,
-0.0142309256,
-0.0801803246,
0.0181658156,
0.0086185755,
-0.0351481475,
-0.0117310854,
-0.0121139195,
0.0077406843,
0.0362358876,
0.0212864708,
0.0111388825,
-0.0402695164,
0.0251334552,
0.0278270058,
-0.0561508611,
-0.0131098153,
0.0019819315,
-0.053300567,
0.0238218158,
0.015019482,
-0.0588806011,
0.0318976715,
-0.0111374613,
-0.0092392098,
-0.0003012293,
-0.0422100984,
0.0045728381,
0.0524896123,
-0.017762769,
0.0286468267,
0.0186404176,
-0.0191769302,
-0.03156358,
0.0023404672,
0.0136574674,
-0.077169545,
-0.0083900094,
0.0052177361,
0.0035118626,
0.009906075,
-0.0477266163,
-0.0879783332,
-0.0090692742,
-0.0378861278,
-0.0080113774,
0.0405591354,
-0.0426780991,
-0.0297355987,
0.0061060311,
-0.0074467841,
0.0421370715,
-0.0021004144,
-0.0216312427,
-0.0101291696,
-0.0067909532,
0.0381282344,
0.0720116645,
-0.0063447692,
0.0385687053,
0.0684500411,
0.0622357279,
0.0608533993,
-0.0140666021,
-0.037194293,
-0.0036264728,
0.0213903598,
0.0226990934,
-0.003841982,
0.0203668363,
0.0319055319,
-0.0408307873,
-0.0122290794,
0.0782185495,
-0.0072072782,
-0.006359227,
0.0117979962,
-0.0128589422,
0.0420295782,
0.0150527665,
0.0332320742,
-0.0701638311,
-0.0437254645,
0.0644469261,
0.0418295749,
-0.0519699939,
-0.0102505619,
-0.0207346026,
-0.1297663003,
0.0238435697,
-0.0142283048,
0.0040804991,
0.0012759465,
-0.0254562162,
-0.0282157678,
0.0127675366,
0.0009835658,
0.0112689147,
0.0264121238,
-0.0108001782,
0.003015941,
-0.0456966572,
0.0150510082,
0.0177866276,
-0.015753489,
0.1002192199,
0.0747507364,
0.0591260418,
0.0598394349,
0.0027754151,
0.0155677218,
0.0231967028,
0.012045511,
0.004283139,
0.0372664668,
0.0259691272,
-0.0168308653,
-0.0125721339,
0.02868063,
-0.0036125637,
0.0062088957,
0.0197834447,
-0.007749069,
-0.0423640348,
-0.0065348689,
-0.024982905,
0.0441024899,
0.0284210537,
0.055103451,
0.0265553221,
-0.0381417871,
-0.0603156202,
-0.0117251342,
0.0153240012,
-0.0453603305,
-0.0636228248,
-0.0138675319,
-0.0075952746,
-0.0390677191,
-0.0764698684,
-0.0151059153,
-0.0446241274,
0.0440390743,
0.002346063,
-0.0086808391,
0.0122244004,
0.0332888067,
0.0030806165,
-0.0192939304,
-0.0323190838,
-0.0088135516,
-0.0779410675,
-0.0225483272,
0.028201798,
-0.0509271249,
-0.0195710566,
0.046752993,
-0.038400799,
-0.0447352193,
0.0278552398,
0.0269516986,
0.0288195219,
0.0404188037,
-0.0051541785,
-0.0178006757,
0.0312613845,
0.0573746786,
-0.0691331252,
0.0282587688,
0.0634330884,
0.0442460477,
-0.0084451102,
0.0252084173,
-0.0758958906,
0.0567671433,
-0.0297923647,
0.0312491525,
-0.0085313749,
-0.0609575659,
0.0087113557,
0.0552978031,
0.0042001274,
0.008152172,
0.0248752926,
0.0149999056,
0.0544841476,
-0.0005894331,
0.0232374035,
-0.0502123609,
0.0064182603,
-0.0131856343,
-0.0270125736,
0.0225971788,
0.0148444315,
-0.0244215447,
0.0196771212,
0.0238779355,
-0.0374228172,
-0.0164742544,
-0.0056388341,
0.0107567636,
-0.0105230659,
-0.000801284,
0.0385574326,
0.0149411475,
0.0082529923,
0.0036306798,
-0.009490951,
-0.0038108097,
0.0059209797,
-0.0099646552,
0.0199365858,
-0.0877277255,
-0.1001562998,
0.0276817847,
0.0430671647,
0.0405189507,
0.0280094985,
0.0468965918,
-0.0246654879,
0.0382110476,
-0.0430050902,
0.0430287346,
0.0340993255,
-0.0259180404,
-0.0387402959,
0.0066995504,
-0.0352805033,
-0.0031032169,
0.0562207326,
-0.0595546588,
0.0688666627,
-0.0424622037,
0.0046344995,
-0.0513304435,
-0.0509842187,
-0.0346924514,
-0.004685509,
0.0201112423,
-0.0322369039,
-0.0425582714,
-0.0289344173,
-0.0316769183,
0.0008887107,
-0.0021860469,
-0.0166483093,
0.0431627668,
0.0194186866,
-0.0063205822,
0.0028463344,
-0.0316975154,
0.0120234042,
-0.0362795629,
-0.0134315025,
0.034809038,
-6.671868632e-33,
-0.0178967752,
-0.0051238956,
0.0299636647,
-0.007099886,
-0.0399569571,
0.021319719,
-0.0556195453,
-0.0039897501,
-0.0234979782,
-0.0289698876,
-0.0390702263,
0.022729652,
0.0321411602,
0.0035224974,
-0.0227571707,
-0.0028635021,
0.0816059634,
-0.0177524015,
-0.0104787629,
0.0560804866,
0.081335701,
0.0276107695,
-0.0334347859,
-0.0724421591,
-0.043697536,
-0.0184340868,
0.012627366,
-0.0087683974,
0.0318309367,
0.0229242295,
-0.0065115406,
0.0430846997,
-0.0168501623,
-0.0268199686,
-0.0266904589,
0.0343695618,
-0.0529184155,
-0.03330791,
-0.0133433575,
-0.0066250316,
-0.0048094988,
-0.0350121185,
-0.0116966013,
0.0254650842,
-0.03878925,
0.0056060259,
0.0118365586,
-0.0138842845,
-0.0324959382,
-0.0241000317,
-0.063376613,
0.0125030819,
-0.0358970687,
-0.0655581355,
0.0043120664,
0.0928729698,
0.0090928385,
0.0065605692,
-0.0292677898,
0.0450527482,
-0.0259768665,
0.021539323,
0.0148457382,
0.0158627201,
0.0395432413,
0.0735634342,
0.0710446462,
-0.000057177,
-0.0265022963,
0.0057167225,
0.0273442417,
0.0268919505,
0.0142890876,
0.0307802502,
0.0658911914,
-0.0646174476,
0.0009973828,
0.0221945737,
0.0601382889,
-0.0004110658,
0.0409274437,
0.0152309733,
-0.0378839485,
0.0175741091,
-0.0216082688,
0.0362851731,
-0.0113270953,
-0.0364531651,
0.0303953197,
0.0471791029,
-0.0062373998,
-0.0640881211,
0.0643631965,
-0.0212780628,
0.0384520292,
0.0441913903,
-0.0290617812,
0.0145466141,
-0.0064906534,
0.0164298397,
0.0102426754,
-0.0253347326,
0.0816877261,
0.0178288836,
0.0395790562,
0.0153587256,
-0.0063621919,
0.0444341116,
-0.0480143614,
0.00070208,
-0.0371517353,
0.0504257195,
-0.0092815291,
-0.0329086855,
0.0223254468,
-0.0099563338,
-0.0213322882,
0.0419909135,
-0.0216514692,
0.0108479923,
-0.0383474603,
-0.0309024472,
0.0065488685,
-0.0049675447,
-0.0391094238,
0.0293259975,
-0.0510109514,
0.0158030782,
0.0267634895,
-0.0694296658,
-0.0422897525,
-0.0240685828,
3.028e-7,
-0.0741808936,
0.009036582,
0.025179565,
0.036700163,
0.0360605754,
0.0432470366,
0.0099327629,
0.0256298743,
-0.0192203298,
0.0049916445,
-0.0136346603,
0.0243328009,
0.0818542838,
0.0167171638,
-0.0802821666,
-0.0180865414,
-0.0954769254,
-0.0206357166,
-0.0276375711,
0.0020497527,
0.0314936154,
0.0674776286,
0.0182506461,
-0.0504739285,
0.0825833306,
0.0114814108,
0.009402954,
-0.0344542563,
-0.0005362252,
0.0168507155,
0.0515873358,
0.0356091484,
0.0259500854,
-0.0181836411,
-0.0094653871,
-0.0376065113,
-0.0088419802,
0.0395664088,
0.029188564,
-0.0787734836,
0.0235953126,
0.0034996029,
-0.0048677092,
0.0161479488,
0.0619008541,
0.0041800532,
-0.0297216438,
-0.0577629618,
0.0055020759,
-0.0188701637,
0.0157945193,
-0.0216842871,
-0.0074573127,
0.0162761956,
-0.0158365145,
-0.0052820183,
0.0166982878,
-0.0636825934,
-0.0014302797,
-0.0107015334,
-0.0659138113,
-0.0570374206,
-0.0416239239,
-0.0029998184,
0.0337958001,
-0.0078211958,
0.0186734479,
2.418855822e-34,
0.0297721159,
0.0215635076,
0.0261789802,
0.0711520463,
0.0177611317,
0.0023937996,
0.0763394162,
0.0059383311,
0.0350028612,
-0.0207803585,
-0.0370906293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18125v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18125v1 | ResumeAtlas: Revisiting Resume Classification with Large-Scale Datasets and Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T07:25:18 | 2024-06-26T07:25:18 | Ahmed Heakl, Youssef Mohamed, Noran Mohamed, Ali Sharkaway, Ahmed Zaky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | The increasing reliance on online recruitment platforms coupled with the
adoption of AI technologies has highlighted the critical need for efficient
resume classification methods. However, challenges such as small datasets, lack
of standardized resume templates, and privacy concerns hinder the accuracy and
effectiveness of existing classification models. In this work, we address these
challenges by presenting a comprehensive approach to resume classification. We
curated a large-scale dataset of 13,389 resumes from diverse sources and
employed Large Language Models (LLMs) such as BERT and Gemma1.1 2B for
classification. Our results demonstrate significant improvements over
traditional machine learning approaches, with our best model achieving a top-1
accuracy of 92\% and a top-5 accuracy of 97.5\%. These findings underscore the
importance of dataset quality and advanced model architectures in enhancing the
accuracy and robustness of resume classification systems, thus advancing the
field of online recruitment practices. | [
0.0770836025,
0.072446771,
-0.0141169485,
-0.0418792255,
-0.0144148543,
-0.0076582097,
0.0064482433,
0.0313516185,
0.0182192679,
-0.0748523623,
0.0108159306,
-0.0397926793,
0.016592728,
-0.0344133526,
-0.008775278,
0.0174208358,
-0.0017559854,
0.030607691,
-0.0113873146,
0.0075125596,
-0.0320330597,
0.0835129321,
0.0141775096,
0.0845582187,
0.0133139584,
-0.0275614355,
0.0461424254,
0.0232330468,
0.0235203244,
0.0334212407,
0.0607751831,
0.0487110168,
0.0013408519,
0.0375973918,
0.0000016445,
-0.0350696258,
0.0045175999,
0.0213210713,
-0.0595995225,
-0.0362647772,
0.044819124,
0.0116574671,
0.0192065928,
0.0375566594,
-0.0287800934,
0.0127738575,
0.0283907615,
0.0000553635,
0.0478639901,
0.0532665327,
0.0065940781,
-0.0403595977,
0.0149307996,
-0.0135811344,
0.0233756509,
0.0069253994,
0.051632002,
-0.0901454464,
0.0101486566,
-0.0125839226,
0.0198007431,
0.0006182048,
-0.0773367211,
-0.0596111417,
0.0101761632,
0.007869293,
-0.0538816191,
-0.0143817645,
0.034767203,
0.010526849,
-0.0200517885,
-0.0357611626,
-0.0196959022,
-0.0297796242,
0.0355181471,
0.0257023685,
-0.0125379572,
0.0365112387,
-0.045021601,
-0.0167749226,
-0.0241163597,
-0.0065687825,
0.0156148588,
0.0281776097,
0.0055276155,
0.0358863771,
-0.0178903267,
-0.0248079039,
0.0441610329,
0.0154093737,
0.0705379322,
-0.0490544885,
0.0539024323,
-0.0013305054,
-0.0324396715,
-0.0093948264,
-0.0227651577,
-0.0095778145,
0.0528116263,
-0.0485737845,
-0.0115029458,
-0.0120538399,
-0.0359246694,
0.0309113711,
-0.0080725243,
0.0259982999,
0.0209250133,
-0.0173723307,
0.0073002167,
-0.0126310168,
-0.1131870598,
-0.0289330594,
-0.019608153,
0.0066140252,
0.0219911467,
0.039652843,
-0.0793965012,
0.0139601398,
-0.0335741565,
0.0062694247,
0.0565937236,
0.0106520792,
-0.0168203153,
0.0323723741,
-0.0603780895,
-0.0418934226,
0.0633598641,
-0.0026746853,
-0.0272850432,
-0.0522373319,
0.0650736019,
-0.0075217169,
0.0217477027,
-0.0314133316,
0.032201793,
0.0079276813,
0.0481641851,
-0.0317621119,
-0.0364521518,
-0.0225843228,
0.0266205296,
-0.0463854223,
-0.0453865603,
-0.0118193459,
0.0357884914,
0.0038148148,
-0.0193186644,
-0.0551080145,
0.033111617,
0.0407162718,
-0.0061299982,
0.0342317037,
0.0071169054,
0.0103065781,
0.0760438889,
-0.026547147,
-0.0091300579,
0.0251969937,
-0.0010038355,
0.0784483999,
0.0410000235,
-0.0318783447,
0.061553888,
0.0632092208,
-0.0285947155,
-0.0346521772,
-0.0251164958,
0.070406951,
-0.0056784214,
0.0140807312,
0.0136145046,
-0.0001952891,
-0.0117842108,
0.0029305606,
0.0437153243,
0.0540286191,
-0.0082908422,
0.0206346605,
0.0364794172,
0.0619015135,
0.0034805748,
-0.0739533231,
-0.011828904,
-0.0143007413,
-0.0158437062,
-0.0506333262,
-0.0374540053,
0.0323402509,
-0.0348284543,
-0.0072457953,
-0.0194992945,
-0.0379355811,
-0.0209022034,
0.0312764831,
0.0036553661,
-0.0062467521,
-0.0330362581,
0.008577616,
0.0264025852,
-0.038956359,
-0.0126954764,
-0.060889829,
-0.0069690291,
0.0780083984,
0.0464158095,
-0.0332653522,
-0.0389366932,
-0.0768815205,
-0.0152182737,
0.0114617022,
0.054911878,
-0.0254141912,
0.0266139917,
-0.0288344175,
-0.0270600859,
0.0593639649,
-0.0099157654,
0.0138140786,
0.0309915226,
0.0223261081,
0.0327069238,
-0.0273974538,
-0.0493552126,
0.0406939052,
0.0043889321,
-0.0325991139,
0.0712075233,
0.0447423309,
-0.0115993414,
0.0162267108,
-0.0074320878,
-0.0032579976,
-0.0067401626,
-0.0055231713,
-0.0202330742,
-0.0341718122,
0.0351369306,
0.0072165728,
-0.0206804406,
0.0491166748,
-0.0552546009,
0.0350811034,
-0.0302447453,
0.0059410413,
-0.0409248434,
0.0111608459,
0.0253832173,
-0.0614010058,
0.0279366672,
-0.0426475629,
0.0302933101,
-0.0455610268,
0.0654507801,
0.0400937349,
0.034159217,
-0.0063934634,
-0.0675677732,
0.0130473012,
-0.1199087501,
-0.0092333024,
-0.0179551896,
-0.0208705403,
0.0104989726,
-0.0039742803,
0.0078534791,
-0.0285937358,
-0.044417128,
-0.0799847692,
0.0352073945,
0.0256548356,
0.0233423896,
-0.0339502096,
-0.0023435156,
0.0060784849,
-0.0049318913,
-0.0468189567,
-0.0201174524,
0.0070950347,
0.0210243687,
0.0347953178,
-0.0396255106,
-0.0349316522,
-0.0181827787,
-0.0337376706,
-0.0012007275,
0.0363801867,
0.0203074757,
0.002072741,
-0.0577390678,
-0.0326668434,
-0.016819749,
0.0073801442,
0.0327976383,
-0.0174463224,
-0.0493811034,
-0.0152072245,
-0.0337271653,
0.0419559553,
-0.0029307222,
0.0175158717,
0.020741716,
0.060901586,
0.0066564837,
-0.0051304121,
0.0085933954,
0.012950642,
-0.0312469397,
-0.0422250442,
-0.0345822647,
-0.0484764092,
0.019166477,
-0.0390079506,
-0.0101407487,
0.0263935719,
0.0045951749,
0.0039359997,
-0.073908098,
-0.0143158073,
-0.0106219435,
0.0115474984,
0.0027561274,
-0.0123180598,
0.0090434561,
-0.0055168997,
0.0266103335,
0.0069475574,
-0.0819947794,
-0.042066332,
0.0596693121,
-0.0021679299,
0.0096729258,
-0.0064579155,
-0.0366783477,
-0.0174067114,
-0.0292504858,
-0.0174774751,
-0.045695059,
-0.0383495651,
0.0215780567,
0.0165894236,
0.015926389,
-0.0318740085,
-0.0678297356,
-0.0614786632,
-0.0280131176,
0.0286224075,
-0.00264015,
0.0020092293,
-0.0813598558,
-0.0261266548,
-0.0287661478,
0.0392150767,
-0.0121525545,
-0.0470549315,
-0.0096350843,
0.0437949151,
-0.0002703437,
0.0208221395,
0.0028085068,
-0.0056673945,
-0.0268136207,
-0.0032269973,
0.0039177141,
0.0252967365,
0.0091195554,
-0.0319445319,
0.046441704,
-0.1019066498,
-0.0437856093,
0.004358761,
-0.0388846323,
-0.0692790374,
0.0231933445,
0.0723366439,
0.0082266424,
-0.0538375117,
0.0061183479,
0.0354759097,
-0.0545254052,
0.0225978196,
0.0655642971,
-0.0002813438,
-0.0069543133,
0.0012208743,
0.0274883267,
-0.0183652956,
-0.0041369223,
-0.0106943669,
-0.0593056716,
0.084369868,
-0.0348575823,
-0.0278570559,
-0.0125420485,
-0.053195782,
-0.013833994,
-0.0291220807,
-0.0431842469,
-0.0403907187,
-0.0507741757,
-0.0108732833,
0.0111581935,
-0.0340724513,
-0.0321256705,
0.0621566325,
-0.0230820142,
0.0078910589,
0.0376185849,
0.0695436895,
-0.0258197635,
-0.0332806557,
0.0367858633,
-0.0129098147,
-0.0157505982,
0.0367077887,
0.0487551577,
-0.012256559,
0.0017167712,
-0.0040672761,
-0.0284549817,
-0.0365518704,
0.0271259379,
0.0367419198,
0.081528984,
-0.0356759019,
-0.014987763,
-0.0274448656,
-0.0355940461,
0.0313679129,
0.0752978772,
-0.0318198167,
-0.0939092785,
-0.0020202834,
-0.005409122,
0.0066877091,
-0.0040498022,
-0.0033561604,
0.0451727435,
-0.0202885978,
0.0315871276,
-0.0091764703,
-0.0426844545,
0.0011044551,
-0.0172533728,
0.0251164883,
0.0358743928,
-0.0119555565,
0.005540655,
-0.0513303615,
0.0275299698,
-0.0246338043,
0.0702169612,
-0.0449811667,
-0.0040973849,
-0.0355425254,
-0.0560169145,
-0.0561506189,
-0.0730377808,
-0.0602108426,
0.0193453003,
-0.026233267,
-0.026139142,
0.0194302406,
-0.0228415895,
0.0028449742,
-0.0816514269,
0.0750873759,
0.0551520549,
-0.0140016917,
-0.0179263726,
0.0080908835,
0.0077709421,
-0.0493435524,
0.0313189775,
-0.0379446894,
-0.0015804996,
0.0334363133,
-0.0602631457,
0.042858839,
-0.0119451061,
-0.0237421803,
0.0133897234,
0.0132134138,
0.0175015945,
-0.0354439206,
-0.054862693,
0.0313638784,
0.001273973,
-0.0298513994,
-0.0102191083,
-0.0177471023,
0.0827161819,
0.0171803739,
-0.0122923087,
-0.0235101432,
-0.0161983296,
0.053119082,
-0.0660332888,
0.0404439494,
-0.0298679769,
0.0593493059,
0.017528547,
0.0025072289,
-0.0273089055,
0.0253424961,
0.0494959354,
0.0204370767,
-0.0238597095,
-0.0076586204,
-0.0288563389,
0.0370924845,
-0.0102802766,
0.0328063481,
-0.0125270076,
-0.0581302941,
0.0031909707,
0.0311714523,
0.0163287427,
-0.0587410629,
0.0148018943,
-0.0090392176,
-0.0135359028,
-0.0384740718,
-0.0007472995,
0.0375025123,
-0.0126505699,
-0.002866386,
-0.0064063505,
-0.0220537428,
0.0405469872,
0.0139071979,
0.0248059481,
0.0183812436,
-0.0326720513,
-0.0226849131,
-0.0302132349,
-0.0081344368,
0.073235862,
0.0368305221,
-0.0178225432,
0.0197102111,
-0.0401826575,
-0.0359486155,
0.0383032151,
-0.0382933654,
-0.0138860531,
0.0134639004,
0.0189532191,
0.0411058515,
0.0075618355,
-0.0033008582,
-0.0831606761,
0.0054699853,
-0.0125844209,
0.0094660074,
-0.0617377125,
-4.962879844e-33,
0.0197722875,
-0.0107975584,
0.0112537295,
0.0193401333,
0.013034787,
0.024616763,
0.0713646561,
-0.0638416335,
0.0099073825,
0.008099339,
-0.0389104001,
0.0224842466,
0.0143954474,
0.0530647971,
0.0267209504,
0.0421146713,
0.0403262302,
0.0110821817,
-0.012465572,
0.0081318095,
0.0191874597,
0.0429796427,
0.0431848168,
-0.0525136851,
0.0306133796,
-0.0026685679,
-0.021395674,
0.0441342816,
0.0086668339,
0.084726207,
-0.0111850658,
0.0392722413,
0.0454399846,
0.007736465,
0.0530811958,
0.0350130349,
-0.0318542048,
0.0065820706,
-0.0129491417,
0.0424265154,
0.0421511233,
-0.028177496,
-0.0051493994,
-0.025574483,
-0.0136700599,
-0.0108626727,
0.0831271932,
-0.0039603454,
0.0051414785,
-0.022286918,
0.0084233982,
0.0226895101,
-0.0343580842,
0.0103361122,
0.0141922645,
0.0361761488,
-0.0068266797,
0.0572289489,
-0.1183301806,
-0.0071968967,
-0.0418592989,
0.0113441451,
-0.028948633,
-0.0126951681,
-0.0419373587,
0.0499310046,
0.0728637427,
0.0370661542,
0.0372406989,
-0.0235747229,
-0.0159951411,
0.0422528014,
-0.012423302,
-0.0019621688,
0.0236354955,
-0.0529432185,
-0.0356919803,
0.0320405178,
0.029552117,
-0.0002515162,
0.0147305075,
-0.0051266653,
-0.0246147998,
0.008852019,
-0.0104877204,
-0.0351844132,
-0.0115660578,
0.0418788902,
0.0343567058,
-0.0104096001,
0.0219792724,
0.006390553,
-0.0323068835,
-0.0406229347,
-0.0203737542,
0.0327049419,
-0.0190920271,
-0.0131693901,
0.0191302579,
-0.0033459994,
-0.0275241844,
-0.02396526,
-0.011111293,
-0.0426942967,
0.025384238,
0.0484412387,
0.0534607805,
0.0454281904,
-0.0763034225,
-0.0052065225,
0.0150036002,
0.0246156827,
-0.0253690593,
0.0502885245,
0.0377341472,
0.0062632156,
0.0340712108,
0.0346282274,
0.0497087874,
0.03906269,
0.0062481998,
-0.0856335238,
0.0356162004,
0.0042868634,
-0.0002049224,
-0.0070866002,
-0.0292843077,
0.0208242647,
0.0197644681,
-0.0328184813,
0.0175098237,
-0.0289859083,
2.238e-7,
0.0452797748,
0.0260626432,
-0.0713976845,
0.0025103039,
0.0329795219,
-0.0008585539,
0.0056396564,
0.0355271064,
0.0217454154,
0.0511503294,
0.0022502246,
-0.0044040726,
0.0342289358,
-0.025148347,
-0.0877459422,
-0.0142313419,
-0.0233023558,
-0.027662633,
-0.0582424775,
0.0327691659,
0.0781655088,
0.0907522142,
0.0859027281,
-0.0602546819,
-0.0346714258,
-0.0109126056,
0.0236303043,
0.0010042057,
-0.0114236204,
0.0430402458,
0.070812121,
0.0057514184,
0.0030562964,
0.0557000935,
-0.0472987518,
0.0378251635,
0.0369826593,
0.0540021993,
-0.0445369631,
0.0476588495,
0.0294287875,
-0.0104031926,
-0.0082574142,
-0.0113414461,
0.0604012832,
-0.0163246915,
-0.00989844,
-0.0124168219,
-0.03142507,
-0.0155894933,
0.0550047159,
0.0119920541,
-0.0121232681,
0.0136262793,
0.0439010747,
-0.0329218395,
-0.065695174,
-0.0668835714,
0.0094823902,
0.0086231055,
-0.0325614586,
-0.0301640891,
0.0468199737,
0.0101342285,
0.0372786261,
-0.0333658531,
0.013306858,
1.974271461e-34,
0.0178076364,
0.0334892683,
0.0115957046,
-0.0156136574,
0.0340426713,
0.0129518025,
0.0638634413,
0.0131323719,
-0.0292987488,
-0.033078447,
0.0051369704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18122v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18122v1 | Poisoned LangChain: Jailbreak LLMs by LangChain | 2024-06-26T07:21:02 | 2024-06-26T07:21:02 | Ziqiu Wang, Jun Liu, Shengkai Zhang, Yang Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the development of natural language processing (NLP), large language
models (LLMs) are becoming increasingly popular. LLMs are integrating more into
everyday life, raising public concerns about their security vulnerabilities.
Consequently, the security of large language models is becoming critically
important. Currently, the techniques for attacking and defending against LLMs
are continuously evolving. One significant method type of attack is the
jailbreak attack, which designed to evade model safety mechanisms and induce
the generation of inappropriate content. Existing jailbreak attacks primarily
rely on crafting inducement prompts for direct jailbreaks, which are less
effective against large models with robust filtering and high comprehension
abilities. Given the increasing demand for real-time capabilities in large
language models, real-time updates and iterations of new knowledge have become
essential. Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG), an advanced technique to
compensate for the model's lack of new knowledge, is gradually becoming
mainstream. As RAG enables the model to utilize external knowledge bases, it
provides a new avenue for jailbreak attacks.
In this paper, we conduct the first work to propose the concept of indirect
jailbreak and achieve Retrieval-Augmented Generation via LangChain. Building on
this, we further design a novel method of indirect jailbreak attack, termed
Poisoned-LangChain (PLC), which leverages a poisoned external knowledge base to
interact with large language models, thereby causing the large models to
generate malicious non-compliant dialogues.We tested this method on six
different large language models across three major categories of jailbreak
issues. The experiments demonstrate that PLC successfully implemented indirect
jailbreak attacks under three different scenarios, achieving success rates of
88.56%, 79.04%, and 82.69% respectively. | [
0.0772217438,
0.0781198889,
-0.0214172192,
0.04770853,
-0.0623149984,
-0.0286847688,
0.0000200498,
0.0063759121,
0.0782113969,
-0.0506623313,
-0.0145219993,
-0.0086237052,
-0.0016957215,
0.0151042016,
0.0510025993,
0.0034853395,
0.059495464,
-0.014039116,
-0.0011365219,
0.0088427989,
0.0268203411,
0.0045159832,
0.0296330843,
0.0316657834,
0.000951694,
-0.0046364809,
-0.025457738,
0.0081543252,
0.0023530056,
-0.0331723168,
-0.0005458587,
0.0355086736,
-0.0024172829,
0.0577641912,
0.0000022337,
-0.0383742265,
-0.0417383462,
0.0325405486,
-0.0375324003,
0.0194705855,
0.0145690693,
-0.0431612097,
-0.036499951,
0.0171253774,
-0.0528337583,
0.026053926,
0.0228859372,
0.0570926592,
0.0787853524,
0.0707584471,
-0.0034670436,
-0.0238053557,
0.0575229041,
0.0004908137,
0.0246033985,
-0.039600499,
0.0218947306,
-0.0204555839,
-0.0019645249,
0.042884998,
0.0288392771,
0.0101125315,
0.020577427,
-0.0288677942,
-0.0343358256,
-0.0269314814,
-0.0380487405,
-0.0367915891,
-0.0009408666,
0.0337114856,
-0.0144000817,
-0.017421335,
0.0066060931,
0.0245302897,
0.0238662791,
0.0406904556,
-0.0231092349,
0.0455849022,
-0.0137010096,
-0.00768709,
0.0456497706,
-0.0369083248,
0.0630761608,
-0.0016360168,
0.0063309371,
0.0306275003,
0.0188519843,
-0.0477410629,
-0.0086393403,
-0.0597650856,
-0.0034391396,
-0.042191267,
0.0094636399,
0.0052245501,
0.0128101725,
0.039505925,
-0.0727820992,
-0.0357332639,
0.0436760113,
-0.0592260174,
-0.0028177171,
0.0322738737,
-0.0099132592,
0.0111786416,
-0.0056659901,
-0.0044835373,
-0.0302918795,
0.0093153203,
0.0049364162,
0.0008386829,
-0.0190829355,
-0.0406738371,
-0.0105238892,
0.0510132238,
-0.0206927359,
0.0073869806,
-0.0061807893,
0.029813746,
-0.031782601,
0.0420953259,
-0.0510125868,
0.0200916864,
0.005594573,
0.031433478,
0.0197383761,
-0.0165612735,
-0.001288088,
-0.0128388526,
0.0090439264,
-0.0756988525,
-0.0235153716,
0.0056381375,
-0.0610969141,
-0.0027590727,
-0.0205324441,
0.1091264561,
0.0188520048,
-0.0190074462,
-0.109675236,
-0.1184396222,
-0.020455353,
-0.0220995508,
0.0070565557,
-0.0834542662,
-0.0336424969,
-0.0201297551,
-0.0294649825,
-0.067441754,
0.0280806553,
0.0285718758,
-0.0548357219,
0.0397700667,
-0.013145498,
-0.0290301666,
-0.0080239438,
0.0455240831,
0.0418973677,
0.073422201,
-0.0041164495,
0.0455645062,
0.0629600734,
-0.0034002222,
0.0219668988,
0.0511042923,
0.0115199462,
0.0155987181,
-0.0298936609,
-0.0042408952,
0.0356973931,
-0.0212786198,
-0.0510126613,
0.0410835221,
-0.0183399599,
-0.0062683607,
0.078439638,
0.0441236198,
-0.0236152355,
0.0529435277,
0.0155270481,
-0.0206385758,
0.0068737133,
0.0141421994,
-0.0605731122,
-0.0150807528,
-0.1043861583,
-0.0300997607,
-0.0109350495,
0.0287431031,
0.008803606,
-0.008356276,
0.0128213326,
-0.0009430366,
0.0114472434,
0.0053725485,
0.0017273866,
0.0694397837,
0.0116594983,
0.0721294358,
0.0226156916,
-0.0529062711,
-0.0265630484,
-0.0777899399,
-0.0292215217,
0.0677064359,
0.0773630589,
-0.0129785491,
-0.0053933715,
0.0025595438,
-0.0473078564,
0.0186403524,
-0.0141311325,
0.0056675188,
-0.0166014805,
0.005760307,
-0.0013196139,
-0.0067323479,
0.0402438082,
0.0036805056,
0.0090840599,
-0.0009980298,
0.0177246127,
-0.0194708146,
-0.0346262008,
0.0098223547,
-0.0231633522,
-0.0221504215,
0.0214041118,
0.0221032966,
0.0103460178,
0.0470857248,
-0.0256384946,
0.0261714272,
0.0810579807,
-0.0030756949,
0.0196585841,
0.0029068473,
-0.0378588364,
-0.0247694757,
0.0201418307,
-0.0125437789,
0.0152277611,
0.0706783459,
-0.0072744819,
-0.0272642765,
0.0692517757,
-0.0514582768,
0.0605317205,
-0.0237577949,
0.0047115758,
-0.009993623,
0.0027386802,
-0.0343698934,
0.0150845749,
-0.0249221548,
0.0055316351,
-0.0069555216,
0.0238667671,
0.0092399288,
0.0128920274,
-0.03708281,
0.0213868786,
-0.0340651646,
0.0172624867,
0.0418726094,
0.0218163189,
-0.0263974909,
-0.0480436683,
-0.0533848293,
-0.017631555,
-0.0273631942,
0.0318500139,
0.0401145704,
0.0427473411,
-0.0154124955,
-0.0205724593,
-0.0254707746,
-0.0216878634,
0.014273908,
0.0286354367,
-0.0137975588,
-0.0092496527,
-0.0513714924,
-0.0176295955,
-0.0009974354,
0.0118876183,
0.059592437,
-0.0269395877,
-0.0286087226,
-0.0102320742,
0.0149813406,
-0.0142653678,
0.0169329904,
-0.0172360931,
-0.0316777565,
0.0425400734,
-0.0115936426,
-0.01972913,
0.055467613,
0.0123195052,
0.0668275133,
0.0683733374,
-0.0214474611,
-0.0449043252,
-0.0274569876,
0.032737352,
-0.0346266069,
-0.0474865325,
-0.0328502469,
0.0272045918,
0.0401318781,
0.0486713387,
-0.0056477627,
-0.0127785215,
0.0356786028,
0.0068841218,
-0.0339573435,
0.0079113236,
-0.0368805528,
-0.0469309278,
-0.010999009,
-0.0170177575,
-0.0852995962,
0.054942254,
-0.0533379987,
0.0336284637,
-0.0367556214,
-0.0434847511,
0.001380912,
0.0554516129,
-0.0063557918,
0.0279261563,
0.044205647,
-0.0343519785,
-0.0341941267,
-0.0050846497,
0.0377185643,
-0.0368493982,
0.0330708697,
-0.0518167503,
-0.0040533207,
0.0032851845,
-0.016305944,
-0.0790835395,
-0.0445907265,
0.0067392769,
-0.0060943267,
0.0545866303,
-0.0466876402,
0.0016767241,
-0.0515269451,
0.0660791844,
-0.0057120449,
-0.0023656625,
-0.0132938642,
-0.0331433527,
0.0444872752,
0.0297161024,
-0.0700601563,
0.0052110292,
0.0114161195,
0.0565905422,
0.1019054651,
0.0482188873,
-0.0057339552,
0.0183968209,
0.0350144543,
0.0184102822,
0.0132893361,
-0.0255516022,
0.0282004122,
0.0226813648,
-0.0495254174,
-0.0254456196,
0.0567861497,
0.0479512177,
-0.0249067936,
0.0070819259,
0.0000314434,
0.0290999487,
0.0240000356,
0.0360476114,
-0.0557943322,
-0.0162578486,
0.0297690816,
0.065385282,
-0.0539907329,
-0.0393729433,
-0.0505855344,
-0.1165702119,
-0.0037841203,
0.0285164528,
-0.017135689,
0.011339318,
-0.0439329334,
-0.038649939,
0.0557725877,
0.0162839238,
-0.0175854638,
-0.0006419093,
-0.0032326262,
-0.0204107985,
-0.0555918105,
-0.0038257313,
0.0093636606,
-0.0151085164,
0.0507846773,
0.0877701342,
-0.0027022625,
-0.0371068344,
0.0411277935,
0.0483114943,
-0.0212235078,
0.0000653841,
-0.0108981682,
0.0025683185,
0.0285223462,
-0.0010210773,
-0.0051489086,
0.0553182736,
0.0010056808,
-0.0424784832,
0.0207427107,
0.0511804223,
-0.0123773133,
0.0104396595,
-0.0237243995,
-0.0122966347,
0.0409323499,
0.041016262,
0.0223232936,
-0.03782814,
-0.0147736669,
-0.0812593848,
-0.0503181294,
-0.0290935189,
-0.049314525,
0.0376231372,
0.0188691206,
-0.0123501932,
-0.0672272593,
0.0097926585,
-0.0323055461,
0.0404012278,
0.0475475825,
0.0123333372,
0.0142145865,
-0.0157763511,
-0.0216623824,
-0.0117614092,
0.0008312016,
0.0222911648,
-0.0501822941,
0.0182964727,
-0.0033408089,
-0.0295078382,
0.0052130544,
0.0316721089,
-0.0420566872,
-0.0908768997,
0.0141396187,
0.0519942753,
0.020958595,
0.0264149979,
-0.0273805372,
-0.0477004498,
0.0433323011,
0.0853249282,
-0.0755785927,
0.0157614928,
0.0507752597,
-0.0107863359,
0.0126800304,
0.0259576924,
-0.0563982539,
-0.0181054249,
0.0459444448,
0.0056550028,
-0.0251953602,
-0.0061364057,
0.0359408148,
0.0656976625,
-0.0046386239,
0.0150762377,
0.0198927391,
0.0160139203,
0.0188208818,
-0.0229869373,
-0.0486700013,
-0.0122608449,
0.0266488846,
0.0044105211,
-0.0379691347,
0.0394411199,
0.0252219941,
0.0033042761,
-0.0013123249,
0.0023265406,
0.0116102016,
0.0218192171,
0.0259122569,
0.0710794479,
0.0209509693,
-0.0241183452,
0.0414539315,
-0.0281926207,
0.0416890159,
-0.0250409823,
0.0476750061,
-0.0122832227,
-0.0267336033,
-0.0222051311,
0.0358532481,
-0.0818461329,
-0.0291228946,
0.0119659426,
0.0660111904,
0.0016701871,
-0.0136453295,
0.0345105194,
-0.0248447973,
0.0151807964,
-0.0320056118,
-0.0234607346,
-0.0179432128,
-0.0822990984,
0.0044725752,
-0.0004762224,
-0.0133011164,
0.0401517563,
0.0608471073,
-0.0052873292,
0.0539112911,
0.0154066496,
-0.0215748847,
-0.0370398313,
-0.0081908014,
0.0586750731,
0.0179794412,
-0.0497716218,
-0.0296848137,
-0.0428681225,
-0.075633578,
-0.0156843774,
-0.0106256576,
0.0155556416,
0.0022385186,
-0.0232369862,
0.0645938069,
0.0138030741,
0.0266291462,
-0.0666710734,
0.0402311869,
-0.0124854082,
-0.0692145154,
0.0334314629,
-6.17017499e-33,
0.0166801494,
-0.0530413352,
-0.0352102108,
-0.0321737975,
0.0040254295,
-0.0112281423,
-0.0254025068,
0.0164133273,
-0.0201014765,
-0.027201796,
-0.0220444314,
-0.0028016476,
-0.0064955205,
0.0325212628,
-0.0319631211,
-0.0125184795,
0.0100556631,
0.0116798813,
-0.0026494067,
0.0502736606,
0.0911742523,
0.0166339483,
0.0157141946,
-0.0495332479,
0.0591237321,
-0.0318273529,
-0.0232785828,
0.0300790314,
-0.0475239716,
0.0638480484,
0.0131624024,
0.0432738252,
0.0002638322,
-0.0415198542,
-0.0147751179,
0.0520897508,
-0.0010968633,
-0.0089384532,
0.0125291105,
-0.0064061517,
-0.0047253985,
-0.047295846,
0.0408351459,
-0.0116914092,
0.0044681462,
0.017974982,
-0.0126247127,
-0.0223689824,
-0.0198006146,
-0.0185992345,
-0.0187381264,
-0.0018212126,
-0.0303212162,
0.0028085578,
-0.0125679914,
0.0058885524,
0.0259090997,
-0.0212643165,
-0.0401134752,
0.036054749,
0.0275540054,
0.0239538848,
0.0236423519,
-0.0183312017,
0.0058662491,
0.0631839857,
-0.0316084139,
-0.017742902,
-0.0029100818,
0.0112621207,
-0.002275364,
0.0662680864,
0.0461523794,
0.066064015,
0.0540571064,
-0.0329351015,
-0.0612069964,
-0.0114771724,
0.002287515,
0.0427582413,
0.0202731267,
-0.0168094952,
-0.0330618806,
-0.0100165401,
-0.0242340304,
-0.0081276866,
-0.0326703787,
-0.043187011,
0.024996385,
0.0132046426,
-0.0186410062,
-0.0729283839,
-0.007203273,
-0.0764710084,
-0.012167302,
0.0402574018,
-0.0230440795,
-0.0266731419,
-0.0187382381,
0.0211190227,
0.00414964,
0.0111413607,
0.015963871,
-0.0692028776,
0.0168525781,
0.0089076441,
0.0305685047,
0.0169188101,
-0.0785080642,
-0.0097021936,
-0.0133646224,
0.0665919483,
0.0193716101,
0.0027189294,
0.0232425034,
-0.0101757739,
-0.0024624839,
0.0145754516,
0.0439669713,
0.011381953,
-0.0551995635,
0.0143680554,
-0.0261128172,
0.0293659177,
-0.0112981787,
0.0196992047,
-0.0139532099,
0.033755362,
0.0428897217,
-0.0521860607,
0.0080925543,
-0.0072620627,
3.095e-7,
-0.0250025801,
0.0017371455,
0.0160642732,
-0.0096491631,
0.0386144891,
0.0637819096,
0.0035377215,
0.0556055233,
-0.0272361655,
-0.0764526576,
-0.0692582205,
-0.0310749728,
0.0627902299,
0.0451108888,
-0.0866604596,
0.0449500605,
-0.066691339,
-0.0194385499,
-0.0586316735,
0.0027045165,
0.0511183515,
0.0786313042,
-0.0125252726,
-0.0399244763,
-0.0260210894,
-0.0715056583,
-0.0018184383,
0.0102185123,
-0.0412652045,
-0.0334833451,
0.051162485,
0.0447704941,
0.0261982735,
0.0097212587,
-0.0540025383,
-0.005837942,
-0.0689499155,
0.008090362,
0.0088432552,
-0.0074013094,
-0.0222149752,
-0.0395386741,
-0.0106105311,
-0.0292011797,
0.0828898922,
0.0168857574,
-0.0085507641,
-0.0148599315,
0.0257914066,
-0.047354158,
-0.0112010231,
-0.0449175797,
0.0005589441,
0.0119685568,
0.023217991,
0.0148509387,
0.0406767279,
-0.0679224432,
-0.0159299169,
0.0027768894,
-0.0133468444,
-0.013139382,
-0.0283210911,
0.0238071438,
0.0102825267,
-0.0332824662,
0.0086727329,
3.26486806e-34,
-0.0063121771,
-0.0422377549,
0.0314410627,
0.0056972988,
0.0371808782,
0.0109885773,
0.0047875643,
0.0374860056,
0.0077152434,
-0.0727372095,
-0.0285701156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18120v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18120v1 | ArzEn-LLM: Code-Switched Egyptian Arabic-English Translation and Speech Recognition Using LLMs | 2024-06-26T07:19:51 | 2024-06-26T07:19:51 | Ahmed Heakl, Youssef Zaghloul, Mennatullah Ali, Rania Hossam, Walid Gomaa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Motivated by the widespread increase in the phenomenon of code-switching
between Egyptian Arabic and English in recent times, this paper explores the
intricacies of machine translation (MT) and automatic speech recognition (ASR)
systems, focusing on translating code-switched Egyptian Arabic-English to
either English or Egyptian Arabic. Our goal is to present the methodologies
employed in developing these systems, utilizing large language models such as
LLama and Gemma. In the field of ASR, we explore the utilization of the Whisper
model for code-switched Egyptian Arabic recognition, detailing our experimental
procedures including data preprocessing and training techniques. Through the
implementation of a consecutive speech-to-text translation system that
integrates ASR with MT, we aim to overcome challenges posed by limited
resources and the unique characteristics of the Egyptian Arabic dialect.
Evaluation against established metrics showcases promising results, with our
methodologies yielding a significant improvement of $56\%$ in English
translation over the state-of-the-art and $9.3\%$ in Arabic translation. Since
code-switching is deeply inherent in spoken languages, it is crucial that ASR
systems can effectively handle this phenomenon. This capability is crucial for
enabling seamless interaction in various domains, including business
negotiations, cultural exchanges, and academic discourse. Our models and code
are available as open-source resources. Code:
\url{http://github.com/ahmedheakl/arazn-llm}}, Models:
\url{http://huggingface.co/collections/ahmedheakl/arazn-llm-662ceaf12777656607b9524e}. | [
0.0262527633,
0.0490272194,
-0.0210837852,
0.0538118295,
-0.0559674203,
0.0387913138,
0.0389521383,
0.0316529572,
-0.0166503713,
-0.0500892997,
-0.057130754,
-0.0274359956,
0.0602046624,
0.0246781167,
0.0542993881,
-0.0072478261,
0.02152301,
-0.1006460115,
-0.0238489751,
0.0045238673,
0.031457074,
0.0303136501,
-0.021521328,
0.0067841713,
0.0183318648,
-0.0018771592,
-0.0282401126,
0.0314758793,
0.0097779091,
0.0357005596,
-0.0264585596,
0.0112458253,
-0.0089516873,
0.0520313419,
0.0000020932,
-0.0516194627,
-0.0434283316,
-0.0212647375,
-0.0296473689,
-0.0156276058,
0.0642890558,
-0.0527811684,
-0.0441457368,
0.0123044038,
-0.0234648585,
0.0290966909,
0.0566433147,
-0.003181377,
0.0422043577,
0.0650272667,
-0.0004805743,
-0.0618168674,
0.0054223556,
0.000750097,
-0.021212982,
-0.0704377517,
0.0096350387,
-0.026431486,
-0.0293208268,
0.0115875006,
-0.0231632702,
0.0658373535,
-0.0286377016,
-0.0360165164,
-0.0249706749,
-0.0257316437,
-0.0369495526,
-0.0464946814,
-0.0320188142,
0.0327000171,
-0.0349319614,
-0.0181692913,
0.0316563062,
-0.0061647701,
-0.0317939632,
-0.0419377238,
0.000192585,
0.0217250399,
-0.0257590767,
-0.0043022782,
-0.0000684224,
0.0455474667,
0.0180224068,
-0.0158078484,
-0.0552060939,
-0.0140126552,
0.0079175197,
-0.0319908857,
0.0174937192,
-0.0290297959,
0.0339576639,
-0.0218780693,
0.0741899461,
0.0175787639,
-0.0169988479,
-0.0097710574,
0.0018363906,
-0.0338736139,
-0.0153901586,
-0.0563368909,
0.0266439226,
0.093048729,
-0.0380328521,
0.0317319185,
-0.0291113909,
0.0630417392,
0.0090125985,
0.0127707869,
-0.0367682651,
0.0329814889,
-0.0149496961,
0.0339606665,
-0.0434847027,
0.0079962611,
-0.0468835346,
-0.0211269688,
-0.0411083773,
-0.0143109011,
0.0246605035,
0.0251681153,
0.0084155332,
-0.0704151988,
-0.021359032,
-0.0103154676,
0.0320355222,
-0.015019861,
0.0389754996,
0.0123123918,
-0.0361878313,
-0.0680051222,
0.0186286792,
0.0202381182,
0.0091219796,
0.0457179509,
-0.0228785705,
0.0805774406,
-0.0335646085,
-0.0247664042,
-0.05421919,
0.0376052335,
-0.0128737064,
-0.0486669354,
-0.028905144,
-0.0307041425,
0.0475138985,
0.0277025644,
0.0149027482,
-0.0397808068,
-0.0015351145,
-0.0149892289,
0.0455989204,
0.0846020505,
0.0311356355,
0.0223106872,
0.0797003284,
0.0032474911,
-0.0132090217,
0.0884617269,
0.0688913912,
-0.017794244,
0.0024520352,
-0.0042422125,
0.0015978315,
0.0750811845,
-0.0249501877,
0.0062695667,
-0.0127665279,
-0.0359948166,
0.0720909908,
0.0460315458,
-0.0151880141,
0.0644063652,
-0.0218111984,
-0.0339938737,
0.0225670915,
0.0332863964,
-0.0125960857,
0.0540551208,
0.0185240787,
0.0237595756,
0.0311290678,
-0.0085143754,
0.0386804044,
-0.0069714799,
0.0014051191,
-0.0225165784,
0.042341508,
0.0540704355,
-0.0182343125,
-0.0340148471,
-0.0163848698,
-0.0201081373,
0.0385903157,
-0.0071963011,
0.0545155592,
0.0044955323,
-0.0678892657,
-0.0084873419,
0.0081335902,
-0.0396737233,
-0.0010584472,
-0.0754862204,
-0.0554154478,
0.0633115992,
0.0123856897,
0.0045179818,
0.027805062,
-0.0289334338,
-0.0001589597,
0.0589895435,
0.021792924,
-0.0009861875,
0.0383471623,
-0.0747429654,
0.0112846373,
0.0595230497,
-0.0153284874,
0.0255395379,
0.0051307306,
0.0560206696,
0.0163320657,
0.0261902586,
-0.0259866733,
0.0095373187,
-0.075566873,
0.0272377543,
0.0090316478,
0.0060324143,
0.0244572088,
0.0278785769,
-0.0187718421,
0.0174104664,
-0.0060188249,
-0.0330416895,
0.0072158999,
0.0308673847,
-0.0300304983,
0.0026762695,
0.0339286327,
0.0160061158,
0.0334593765,
-0.0017752165,
0.0141227413,
-0.0702342838,
0.0716628209,
-0.0571601018,
0.0754896551,
-0.0054070833,
0.0998697802,
0.0102029387,
-0.0044940701,
-0.00791281,
-0.0087453937,
-0.0016569813,
-0.030730335,
-0.0041526868,
-0.0226114877,
0.0116296336,
-0.0209475197,
0.01072032,
0.0427328199,
-0.0093473243,
0.0221382659,
0.0131503241,
0.0029000638,
-0.0162578449,
-0.0815543681,
-0.0464226343,
-0.0206457246,
-0.0243363045,
0.0412815399,
-0.0300016794,
0.0247667469,
-0.0209434889,
-0.0119411293,
-0.0335014127,
-0.0020660197,
-0.0194675289,
-0.0163357016,
-0.0057321554,
-0.0177565906,
-0.0474830531,
-0.0351736508,
0.0188314188,
0.0279346742,
0.028129803,
0.0315615125,
-0.0483504608,
-0.0652235299,
0.0033556744,
0.016729584,
-0.0038225858,
-0.0049563725,
-0.0253565554,
0.0307970587,
-0.0213010814,
0.0179605242,
0.0031658965,
-0.0191185772,
0.0067484132,
-0.0091026248,
-0.0220977217,
-0.066867575,
-0.0324120931,
0.0188698061,
-0.036305435,
-0.0495117083,
-0.0431493185,
-0.0315471403,
0.0292138588,
0.0183576718,
0.0346880928,
-0.0468669608,
-0.0157287829,
-0.0219465587,
-0.0097295726,
0.0413543917,
-0.0088453041,
-0.0006420361,
0.0925773531,
-0.006678022,
-0.0319089107,
0.0021999213,
-0.0623499267,
-0.0099556753,
-0.0330291241,
0.0097281998,
-0.0518929511,
-0.0152598098,
-0.0616928563,
0.0177310985,
0.0124419741,
-0.0730082616,
0.0078800181,
-0.0058226716,
0.0014407397,
-0.0439390205,
-0.015615833,
-0.0456579998,
0.02880181,
-0.0103687374,
-0.0319794193,
0.0039763339,
0.0278938599,
-0.0680010915,
-0.0079054888,
0.0472901054,
-0.0357431881,
-0.0289999191,
0.054853797,
-0.0134495767,
0.0485755727,
0.0225328505,
0.0240553152,
-0.0057046115,
-0.0116414856,
-0.0319791697,
-0.0018330223,
-0.0145998597,
-0.0083007812,
0.0483948626,
0.0131279109,
-0.0052983002,
0.0050937366,
-0.0736414045,
-0.0118070431,
0.0750631988,
-0.0180515908,
-0.0209068488,
-0.0342428386,
-0.0056303134,
-0.0177124031,
0.0325865671,
0.082924448,
-0.0013967528,
-0.0585383214,
-0.0208970066,
-0.0276640207,
0.0079722414,
-0.0008932965,
-0.0180269461,
-0.0949184299,
0.011841191,
0.0530186966,
0.051575914,
0.0183644257,
0.037723735,
0.0182843599,
-0.0464012735,
0.0166659225,
0.044771634,
-0.0863274112,
-0.0582080558,
-0.0113573335,
-0.014060257,
-0.0276113059,
-0.0192429963,
-0.0142224524,
-0.0037778046,
-0.0207170919,
0.0479144193,
0.0001137695,
-0.0079521444,
-0.0137615902,
-0.0112984451,
0.0496601984,
0.0589570813,
0.0303552579,
0.0088797398,
-0.0383678749,
-0.0052653016,
0.0041110199,
-0.0188542772,
-0.0355295688,
-0.0131781083,
-0.01485625,
-0.0122856898,
0.0315930285,
-0.0093945814,
-0.028539896,
0.0101367878,
0.0113455299,
-0.0161008518,
-0.0319245309,
0.0288085528,
0.0469679944,
0.0327778682,
0.0086210864,
0.0103536304,
0.0019389153,
-0.0256811995,
-0.0172717907,
-0.0270769596,
0.0175294708,
-0.0169812851,
-0.0424364023,
-0.0183489919,
0.0199687108,
-0.0193258952,
-0.0741087645,
0.0136271855,
0.0058312751,
0.0433011539,
0.0536620878,
0.0277549475,
0.0346730575,
0.0449430794,
-0.0256609581,
-0.0786715448,
-0.0219900161,
0.019863151,
-0.0670393184,
-0.0448856466,
0.0433431417,
-0.0864781588,
0.032415159,
-0.0132521056,
-0.1108837724,
-0.0611112714,
0.0218081269,
-0.000034685,
0.0294723548,
0.0142257502,
-0.0229232349,
-0.0370574482,
-0.0116657475,
-0.0643396825,
-0.0304472614,
0.0228576306,
0.0552840978,
0.0497291572,
-0.0317072049,
0.0295382515,
0.0098345038,
-0.0084187081,
0.0076609431,
-0.0014088847,
-0.0579329841,
-0.0796016306,
-0.0302474499,
-0.0222646892,
-0.0106136864,
-0.0109772161,
-0.0561327226,
-0.0101233171,
0.0387161747,
0.0014108608,
0.0475854427,
-0.0316185616,
-0.0095199998,
0.0095892297,
0.0318620317,
0.0010190236,
-0.0279685035,
-0.0383842066,
-0.0446881987,
0.0074350368,
0.0642526001,
0.018473994,
0.0112843895,
0.0211162865,
0.0191734061,
-0.0057237535,
0.0342131145,
0.0056214891,
0.0117233861,
-0.0191001203,
0.0124599077,
-0.0058847554,
0.0133962575,
0.0439393744,
0.0450988486,
-0.0146306828,
-0.0502757169,
-0.0102153867,
0.0653291866,
0.0281372555,
0.0273133013,
0.1066895202,
0.0369688645,
0.0158271734,
-0.0071226317,
0.0469500199,
-0.0214320272,
-0.0133716008,
-0.0354804061,
-0.0056756651,
-0.0069131143,
0.0663688481,
0.0165334214,
-0.003423952,
-0.0154505381,
0.029055668,
0.0064943326,
-0.0133903539,
-0.0151393684,
0.0380673409,
-0.0436561592,
-0.0352335721,
-0.0138166146,
-0.0161393695,
-0.0703889951,
0.0498461239,
0.0212181471,
0.0350361392,
-0.0256944746,
0.0100957584,
0.075086005,
0.0023933484,
0.0197061226,
-0.0593195222,
-0.0068306625,
0.0415423363,
-0.0626683608,
0.0025645939,
-5.727043007e-33,
0.0150479004,
-0.0223798864,
0.0037884475,
0.039380312,
-0.0057604322,
-0.0350789241,
-0.0354388617,
0.0069612428,
0.0076027475,
-0.0613668822,
-0.0352019109,
0.0158744827,
0.0430649444,
-0.0297256447,
0.0351263992,
0.0124088153,
0.0442650355,
-0.0126887457,
-0.0268464312,
0.0355669186,
0.0206084643,
0.0423748642,
0.0479632355,
-0.0574350916,
0.0115088578,
-0.0377749577,
-0.0348636992,
-0.0248650238,
0.002783929,
0.0551919527,
-0.01724739,
0.0077809081,
-0.0095995283,
0.0029071984,
0.0068581221,
0.0011924919,
-0.0435031243,
0.064441368,
0.0189677272,
0.0891254693,
0.0518800579,
-0.046475932,
-0.0016031209,
-0.0322374403,
-0.0698117465,
0.0370839983,
-0.0199583191,
-0.0420776717,
-0.0183026195,
-0.0211046617,
-0.0995128602,
0.0506205745,
-0.0281154234,
-0.025442902,
0.1115036309,
0.0490916036,
-0.0245498866,
-0.0303786267,
-0.0615511015,
0.0508818887,
0.0303204879,
0.0283626486,
0.0535574332,
0.0411607958,
-0.0674738735,
0.001255703,
0.0540289842,
-0.0430820212,
0.0676037967,
0.0100734411,
0.040042609,
-0.0362707935,
0.0033026054,
0.013724247,
-0.0089049032,
-0.0397529714,
-0.0276300274,
-0.023854563,
0.0201910846,
0.0135106193,
0.0217299256,
0.0469611846,
-0.0543275028,
-0.0123760412,
-0.0303416383,
-0.0657065511,
-0.0152552854,
-0.0147408601,
0.0110226134,
0.0064356406,
-0.0181974042,
0.037637312,
0.0435871072,
0.0070251417,
0.0096967844,
-0.0390694626,
0.0111758243,
0.0143083641,
-0.0144947497,
0.0649084449,
-0.032848157,
-0.0574868955,
0.0352987684,
0.0196438432,
0.0477365702,
-0.030136371,
-0.0022800078,
0.0619809628,
-0.0463192351,
-0.0028697145,
-0.009081834,
0.0072451257,
0.0113217989,
0.0237121489,
0.001751457,
-0.0315956436,
0.0114072524,
0.0160382222,
0.0002185967,
-0.013472029,
-0.0326943435,
0.0270808525,
-0.0159081239,
0.0160332564,
-0.0641765147,
0.022992881,
-0.0223691296,
0.0144351488,
0.0295289829,
-0.0230602846,
-0.0200041924,
0.0118339304,
2.893e-7,
0.0084018307,
0.0268839914,
0.0081435768,
-0.0165396519,
0.010534755,
-0.0092800297,
-0.0221713763,
0.0087590935,
0.0392040797,
0.0274506919,
-0.0114692338,
0.00142058,
0.1317580044,
0.0065717697,
-0.0841207206,
-0.0579682998,
0.0250663497,
0.0348102674,
-0.0385901742,
0.0068431967,
0.0400593616,
0.1147982776,
-0.0594107583,
0.015002002,
-0.0498124026,
0.0111840516,
0.0312670171,
-0.0429011881,
0.0190105103,
-0.0143860029,
0.006329047,
-0.033835087,
-0.0216306578,
0.001242205,
-0.0145095373,
0.0027364471,
0.0683392137,
0.0829959884,
0.0092576463,
-0.0041670813,
0.0071651917,
0.0079359068,
-0.0342313424,
-0.0392084792,
0.027525926,
0.0368748382,
-0.0040821731,
-0.0063139275,
-0.003679282,
0.0304593109,
0.0016238558,
-0.0411856137,
0.0152611695,
0.0406897217,
0.0527926572,
-0.0103357704,
0.0074714315,
-0.0206951685,
0.0034445492,
-0.0570639782,
-0.0003991837,
-0.0228082929,
-0.0072336551,
-0.0116796503,
-0.0003665292,
0.0147634698,
0.0002811979,
2.18547198e-34,
0.0503713191,
-0.0337103456,
-0.0022416268,
0.0610278398,
0.0499623753,
-0.0208385494,
-0.0009144485,
0.0537669882,
-0.0045741377,
-0.0239346754,
-0.02722474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18118v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18118v2 | SafeAligner: Safety Alignment against Jailbreak Attacks via Response Disparity Guidance | 2024-06-26T07:15:44 | 2024-06-28T06:06:59 | Caishuang Huang, Wanxu Zhao, Rui Zheng, Huijie Lv, Shihan Dou, Sixian Li, Xiao Wang, Enyu Zhou, Junjie Ye, Yuming Yang, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | As the development of large language models (LLMs) rapidly advances, securing
these models effectively without compromising their utility has become a
pivotal area of research. However, current defense strategies against jailbreak
attacks (i.e., efforts to bypass security protocols) often suffer from limited
adaptability, restricted general capability, and high cost. To address these
challenges, we introduce SafeAligner, a methodology implemented at the decoding
stage to fortify defenses against jailbreak attacks. We begin by developing two
specialized models: the Sentinel Model, which is trained to foster safety, and
the Intruder Model, designed to generate riskier responses. SafeAligner
leverages the disparity in security levels between the responses from these
models to differentiate between harmful and beneficial tokens, effectively
guiding the safety alignment by altering the output token distribution of the
target model. Extensive experiments show that SafeAligner can increase the
likelihood of beneficial tokens, while reducing the occurrence of harmful ones,
thereby ensuring secure alignment with minimal loss to generality. | [
0.0329221077,
0.0562441759,
0.0122979172,
0.0306081772,
-0.0424689464,
-0.0171145014,
-0.0027163159,
-0.0334425233,
0.0100423293,
-0.0243762657,
-0.0006120809,
0.0075720698,
-0.0240653325,
0.0277760979,
0.0386279076,
0.0258413684,
0.0838408321,
-0.060035035,
0.0199744683,
0.0106874108,
0.0144718103,
0.0053707408,
0.0245855562,
0.0343673415,
-0.0239944849,
0.0017294864,
-0.0298899896,
0.0537770651,
0.0273449887,
-0.0402675271,
0.0156629533,
0.0491223633,
-0.0170114618,
0.0388172343,
0.0000021193,
-0.0153985294,
-0.0447803624,
0.039124921,
-0.0243619587,
0.0298238657,
-0.0117243798,
-0.0705512017,
-0.0282790605,
0.0267735589,
-0.0281209778,
0.0027082523,
0.0426497608,
0.0306845177,
0.0705095604,
0.0380659886,
0.0183906257,
-0.0004822191,
0.0497639365,
0.002532854,
-0.0246427134,
-0.0606180392,
0.0050314059,
-0.0428863727,
-0.0254125763,
0.0355854109,
-0.0069314674,
-0.0378322713,
0.030590456,
-0.0101382742,
-0.0215337593,
-0.003546034,
-0.0490322672,
-0.0193919577,
-0.0443418063,
0.01262064,
-0.0589703172,
-0.0396550782,
-0.0013304529,
-0.0025897152,
0.0159982219,
0.002997837,
0.0161807816,
0.0051751514,
-0.0070304018,
0.0024866287,
0.0348242261,
0.0007404306,
0.0412392803,
-0.0142644849,
-0.0299496949,
0.060026288,
0.0289309584,
-0.0229901038,
-0.0119097931,
-0.0458006673,
0.0081086718,
-0.0547060743,
-0.0062070568,
0.0065487148,
-0.0086776195,
0.0072323461,
-0.0841606781,
-0.0294446684,
0.0372677483,
-0.0427519158,
-0.0604472645,
0.0505342484,
-0.0340279564,
0.0015393122,
-0.0212483797,
0.0019317269,
-0.0131362416,
0.0456483997,
0.0095868148,
-0.0040049683,
-0.0070587117,
-0.0215247199,
-0.0017115641,
0.0524851903,
-0.015789412,
0.0075648422,
-0.0428446718,
0.0165679753,
-0.0093535203,
0.0187210701,
-0.0275984015,
0.0101712281,
-0.0038832936,
0.0187269226,
0.0578610301,
-0.0054937862,
-0.0283436086,
-0.0203637294,
-0.00666617,
-0.0694847107,
-0.0168573558,
0.0029246181,
-0.0890617296,
-0.029424103,
-0.0197757166,
0.1395939291,
0.0380621776,
0.0108833853,
-0.0912547782,
-0.0822156891,
-0.0333927795,
-0.0227069482,
-0.0063161352,
-0.076695621,
-0.0359713137,
0.0063410331,
0.0049189357,
-0.0677118227,
0.0082975868,
-0.0157797653,
-0.0607402585,
0.0268949121,
0.0145677617,
-0.025758246,
-0.0349443667,
0.0296838898,
0.0267176442,
0.0561588705,
-0.0086704642,
0.0544766262,
0.0431739017,
-0.0330054723,
0.0357667617,
0.0337465778,
-0.0125986245,
0.0125029953,
-0.0165014677,
-0.0082577672,
0.0619692318,
-0.0437829308,
0.0116071682,
0.0338830389,
0.0086623002,
-0.0332982726,
0.0721106157,
0.0809944794,
-0.0519204885,
0.0609659925,
-0.0328350626,
-0.0288189631,
-0.0161565877,
-0.0282549467,
-0.0830745175,
0.0176291224,
-0.0743246004,
-0.0146407317,
-0.011611471,
0.0471760929,
-0.0061423215,
0.0219858624,
0.0055770553,
-0.0163285341,
-0.0134071372,
0.0128427465,
0.0121120317,
0.0076060132,
-0.0012279035,
0.0708804131,
0.0270143561,
-0.0196741764,
-0.0385263488,
-0.0838713795,
0.0085250121,
0.0672765225,
0.0208406206,
0.0225931294,
-0.0023528666,
0.0172095019,
-0.0054503065,
0.0122248083,
-0.0188162606,
0.0342852436,
0.0454783328,
-0.0197703335,
0.0066914307,
-0.0046938327,
0.0375085287,
0.0351263173,
-0.0027213001,
-0.008327934,
0.0072354684,
-0.0143030481,
-0.0408875421,
0.0377769992,
0.0315592065,
-0.0041116844,
0.0371082723,
0.011778797,
-0.000135976,
0.014570782,
-0.0230681524,
0.027413819,
0.0545127429,
0.0056737899,
0.0601728596,
0.0041599865,
-0.0360743813,
0.0104401838,
0.0361688063,
-0.0157778319,
0.0072753546,
0.0611979999,
-0.0464350767,
-0.0266203806,
0.0901300088,
-0.0257984493,
0.0418299921,
0.0141708553,
0.0391849317,
-0.0045947768,
-0.0126394099,
-0.0227464791,
-0.0017210996,
-0.0166530088,
-0.0151784765,
-0.0336085111,
0.0309115611,
0.0233976711,
0.0204837061,
-0.0512280203,
0.0115735857,
-0.0649519339,
0.0350783169,
0.0179639868,
0.016903704,
0.0009080317,
-0.0329449624,
-0.0129480558,
0.0150584541,
-0.0436990336,
0.0448476411,
0.0495142899,
0.043169409,
-0.0197079014,
-0.0418919846,
0.0061059985,
-0.0356496684,
0.0126570426,
-0.0076595098,
-0.0144900056,
-0.0482395105,
-0.0452770665,
-0.0315359309,
0.0026981756,
-0.026007764,
0.0450565703,
-0.0521281362,
-0.0113592269,
-0.0245803371,
-0.0256411545,
0.0297660325,
-0.0062692547,
-0.0099328794,
-0.0472320169,
0.0512247235,
0.0204118416,
-0.0074714371,
0.0375262573,
0.0215167385,
0.035598956,
0.0684649199,
0.0074484255,
-0.042606201,
-0.0332288332,
0.047318168,
-0.057342764,
-0.0516026616,
-0.0716194659,
0.0189493261,
0.0784783959,
0.0293181613,
0.0125566665,
-0.0349158868,
-0.0086475266,
0.0111115677,
-0.025700191,
0.0108964769,
-0.0248105526,
-0.0459694974,
-0.0139906416,
-0.031634666,
-0.0683678836,
0.0564050116,
-0.0479892828,
0.0313792117,
-0.0295182597,
-0.0491133817,
0.0014620057,
0.0188983772,
-0.0374603719,
0.0278232843,
0.037624754,
-0.0389996767,
-0.0117104407,
-0.0496986955,
0.0036365492,
-0.0147884311,
0.0358752981,
-0.0436537899,
-0.016348524,
-0.0089049684,
-0.0188238081,
-0.0253822301,
-0.0500166789,
-0.036822848,
-0.0178867597,
0.0229131691,
-0.0402406901,
-0.0109157246,
-0.0083493758,
0.0086306073,
-0.0033134043,
-0.0284824055,
0.0027629349,
-0.0363441929,
0.0043707737,
0.0144872591,
-0.0980419144,
-0.0291726366,
-0.0073838253,
0.0390824154,
0.0793223009,
0.0420880653,
0.0257732999,
-0.0502265841,
0.0062331478,
0.0312487744,
0.0007126376,
0.0154655157,
0.0673794225,
0.0645086095,
-0.0070513822,
-0.0438772403,
0.0476291217,
0.0300066285,
-0.0017750788,
0.0401856564,
-0.034716852,
0.0548761152,
0.0082417866,
0.0183015764,
-0.0157187227,
-0.0232989229,
0.025064636,
0.068605192,
0.0070881178,
0.0213749055,
-0.0141125042,
-0.048090212,
0.0058373786,
0.0603693947,
-0.045952525,
-0.0277277399,
-0.0433625765,
-0.0334647782,
0.0043937508,
0.0221703667,
-0.0002775561,
0.0238372162,
0.0089956364,
0.0235803053,
-0.0635742471,
0.0057479627,
0.0074259397,
-0.0604486726,
0.0572500639,
0.0917859226,
-0.028241029,
-0.0206988342,
0.0346212611,
0.0255645923,
0.0037817175,
-0.0052580885,
0.0304008108,
-0.0276579577,
0.0095423833,
0.018904889,
-0.0048541361,
0.0488451645,
-0.0217211172,
-0.0625842214,
0.0418123342,
0.0198212173,
-0.0001498399,
0.0106608132,
-0.0448199101,
-0.0177629404,
0.0221894719,
0.0190640166,
0.0307470225,
-0.0239004549,
-0.0476833582,
-0.084514685,
-0.0147048421,
-0.0923978835,
-0.0151554905,
0.0347855724,
0.0366094969,
-0.0529166684,
-0.0086761573,
0.0271571577,
-0.0530836955,
0.0436752327,
0.043822296,
-0.0131055303,
-0.015052814,
0.0010130077,
-0.0286122076,
-0.010668667,
-0.0162108503,
0.056864582,
-0.0489694104,
0.0485158414,
-0.0289242845,
0.0117495786,
-0.0338627398,
0.0102197276,
-0.0584614314,
-0.0953977481,
0.0190826263,
0.0773205385,
0.0287050586,
-0.0158241428,
-0.0701230988,
-0.0479219146,
0.055947952,
0.0940594077,
-0.0755761117,
-0.0168864746,
0.050224755,
-0.0582580492,
0.0077762031,
-0.0228981618,
-0.0336509235,
-0.0209291242,
0.0911301002,
0.0184882861,
-0.0346765891,
-0.0079013444,
0.0285807084,
0.0319202654,
0.0078228628,
-0.0200359412,
0.0153928753,
0.0511965565,
0.013277119,
0.0042142216,
-0.026409192,
0.0343401656,
0.0232217982,
0.0520329326,
-0.0338332616,
0.0262136087,
-0.0046626935,
0.0038093089,
0.0320505314,
0.0235226173,
0.0235848762,
0.0194423348,
0.0914194509,
0.0444855802,
0.0017273525,
-0.0436887518,
0.0453673266,
-0.0205964968,
0.0242334623,
-0.0219134334,
0.0298388582,
-0.020075785,
-0.002146109,
-0.0321026854,
0.051088918,
-0.0711695999,
-0.048683688,
-0.0347162597,
0.0733842477,
0.0047209277,
0.0393111482,
-0.0056505278,
0.0016750797,
0.0141878836,
-0.051426623,
0.0022843333,
-0.0061879754,
-0.0431888774,
0.018079998,
-0.0050885654,
-0.0015962567,
-0.018361209,
0.0514819995,
0.0107363099,
0.0476167016,
0.0172269326,
-0.0277538616,
-0.027744282,
0.0101960022,
0.0704746693,
0.0325182676,
-0.0825270936,
-0.0568700694,
-0.0529034249,
-0.0809543282,
-0.0075979219,
0.0240781959,
0.0638466403,
0.0286833663,
-0.0458517931,
0.0473693274,
-0.0118502825,
-0.0012147565,
-0.046242632,
0.0155774783,
0.0175672378,
-0.0456106551,
-0.0104057835,
-5.533316028e-33,
0.0249496009,
-0.0003405139,
-0.0671440735,
-0.044289019,
0.0116322516,
-0.0258903112,
-0.0352495946,
0.0218567625,
-0.0035672716,
-0.0553897507,
-0.0000303627,
-0.0056696627,
0.0169800855,
0.0127387773,
-0.0224510953,
-0.0205037575,
0.0175950509,
0.0337216817,
-0.0318396576,
0.0404941514,
0.0462759137,
0.0341386683,
0.0008390895,
-0.0525264144,
0.0341693126,
-0.0338818096,
-0.0146381138,
0.0044696284,
-0.0323443189,
0.0621551648,
0.0171194263,
0.0076613277,
-0.0061867475,
-0.0166623574,
-0.0015172454,
0.054235138,
0.0192361716,
0.0066638784,
0.0140680354,
0.0087803304,
0.0134787355,
-0.0767190456,
0.0002195013,
0.0068204436,
-0.0191331841,
-0.0188650545,
-0.0115883974,
0.0100437813,
-0.0299634989,
-0.0120666362,
-0.0200153049,
-0.0041364748,
-0.0371743515,
-0.007459546,
-0.0069813691,
-0.0055056117,
-0.0141932555,
-0.0201857947,
0.0071429135,
0.0427652895,
0.0079416363,
0.0063766995,
0.0529024191,
0.0306234267,
-0.0583205819,
0.0305468552,
-0.0228405111,
-0.0635305941,
0.0204823352,
-0.015535784,
0.0000574298,
0.0589546822,
0.0515282899,
0.0854631886,
0.0720757395,
-0.0464439392,
-0.0741080418,
0.003687256,
0.0074273408,
0.0278656296,
0.0380285159,
0.0182456989,
-0.0290590525,
0.0123469438,
-0.0211712103,
-0.0169145856,
-0.0091253649,
-0.0663071424,
0.0268482175,
-0.0179113224,
-0.0487904139,
-0.0364916697,
0.0141915381,
-0.0587254949,
-0.003673,
0.0394916944,
0.016870575,
-0.0143587273,
-0.0505110659,
0.0403650068,
0.0163612179,
-0.0343826152,
0.0371310413,
-0.0618870035,
0.0372525193,
-0.015747577,
0.0424485318,
0.0031729345,
-0.063794136,
-0.0142226554,
-0.0174457654,
0.0308742933,
-0.0019251334,
0.0111612873,
0.0052739335,
-0.0144957909,
0.0133070126,
-0.0104119042,
0.0061045825,
-0.0093164351,
-0.0348801874,
0.0419562459,
-0.0205461308,
0.0392209217,
0.0186854377,
0.0279673953,
-0.0039254255,
0.0181482434,
0.0045893476,
-0.0266067944,
-0.0059961099,
0.0161681585,
2.874e-7,
-0.020954553,
-0.0208481327,
0.0423695147,
-0.0272865091,
0.0056466195,
0.0587952025,
-0.0209599715,
0.1151165068,
-0.0003444634,
-0.0508065522,
-0.041617129,
-0.0230766404,
0.0702236816,
0.0512980931,
-0.0165705886,
0.0542396605,
-0.078675814,
-0.0017413264,
-0.0572299175,
0.0066718962,
0.039304588,
0.0742088035,
-0.026405884,
-0.021531092,
0.0006360808,
-0.0460469201,
-0.0068927971,
0.0131658418,
-0.0062569035,
-0.0280291643,
0.008269649,
0.0256065875,
0.0322247967,
0.040621236,
-0.0325119868,
-0.0007087953,
-0.0600290596,
0.0267071892,
-0.0110283559,
-0.0093660746,
-0.0620296113,
0.0080687245,
0.0059219594,
-0.0432957672,
0.0215092357,
-0.002649293,
-0.0207814258,
-0.0373196602,
-0.0156141464,
0.0117148375,
-0.025650844,
-0.019244343,
0.0091224564,
0.0105735166,
0.049725309,
0.0424456336,
0.0190450884,
-0.0550328679,
-0.0310321897,
0.0163757838,
-0.0103798863,
-0.038585525,
-0.0108676329,
0.0731900781,
0.0482150055,
-0.0278340168,
0.0416632369,
2.693165924e-34,
0.0040296027,
-0.0548637249,
0.0220056735,
0.0454160497,
0.0278283656,
0.0215609819,
0.0185772069,
0.0414748751,
0.0083702244,
0.0145669859,
-0.0200449582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18116v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18116v1 | BADGE: BADminton report Generation and Evaluation with LLM | 2024-06-26T07:07:52 | 2024-06-26T07:07:52 | Shang-Hsuan Chiang, Lin-Wei Chao, Kuang-Da Wang, Chih-Chuan Wang, Wen-Chih Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Badminton enjoys widespread popularity, and reports on matches generally
include details such as player names, game scores, and ball types, providing
audiences with a comprehensive view of the games. However, writing these
reports can be a time-consuming task. This challenge led us to explore whether
a Large Language Model (LLM) could automate the generation and evaluation of
badminton reports. We introduce a novel framework named BADGE, designed for
this purpose using LLM. Our method consists of two main phases: Report
Generation and Report Evaluation. Initially, badminton-related data is
processed by the LLM, which then generates a detailed report of the match. We
tested different Input Data Types, In-Context Learning (ICL), and LLM, finding
that GPT-4 performs best when using CSV data type and the Chain of Thought
prompting. Following report generation, the LLM evaluates and scores the
reports to assess their quality. Our comparisons between the scores evaluated
by GPT-4 and human judges show a tendency to prefer GPT-4 generated reports.
Since the application of LLM in badminton reporting remains largely unexplored,
our research serves as a foundational step for future advancements in this
area. Moreover, our method can be extended to other sports games, thereby
enhancing sports promotion. For more details, please refer to
https://github.com/AndyChiangSH/BADGE. | [
0.032047566,
0.0107657006,
-0.0020404954,
0.065466173,
-0.0138052544,
0.0073774238,
-0.0466389842,
0.02765649,
-0.0012263121,
-0.0371600464,
-0.0129505144,
-0.0380311497,
-0.0008754437,
0.0509290621,
0.0254035611,
-0.073489219,
-0.0142228017,
-0.0409196392,
0.0533650704,
0.0149339121,
0.0324325152,
-0.0007921148,
0.0057924371,
0.036580611,
-0.0173525698,
-0.0171754211,
-0.0576502644,
-0.0005709227,
-0.0053844196,
-0.0738133639,
-0.0381270275,
0.0258023795,
0.0208065007,
-0.0162096974,
0.0000017825,
-0.0451839939,
0.0268458314,
-0.0375841223,
0.0183351748,
0.0327822901,
0.0171060059,
-0.0150668873,
0.010539107,
0.0015725244,
-0.0313797966,
-0.0108534992,
0.0397675857,
0.0130846798,
0.0895642936,
0.0696583912,
-0.010713106,
-0.0345076397,
0.0084782653,
-0.0141517399,
0.0168099422,
-0.0598715469,
0.0130610941,
0.0293830261,
-0.0102651082,
0.0192553382,
-0.0188059956,
-0.0143630095,
0.0054117148,
0.0046834797,
0.0046990514,
0.0278956797,
-0.0369678214,
0.0214339644,
0.011107021,
0.0427445099,
-0.0319226012,
-0.0129202874,
0.007853657,
-0.0128370868,
0.0288679786,
-0.0485618375,
-0.0556385331,
0.043530602,
0.0090444311,
0.0234302711,
0.0051063192,
0.007810778,
0.0030901146,
0.005204048,
-0.0025145935,
0.0135980798,
-0.0034627044,
-0.0289337263,
-0.0611007549,
0.0402970761,
0.0359871797,
-0.1226657331,
0.0224605687,
0.0454923995,
-0.0509754717,
0.026775388,
-0.0049079093,
-0.0287441872,
0.0057866075,
-0.0475796089,
0.0564677939,
0.0204664133,
0.0277262405,
0.016367076,
-0.0187764335,
0.0105178561,
0.034021616,
0.0059831059,
-0.0462815501,
0.0092916451,
-0.0512158237,
-0.0046245959,
0.003923791,
0.0441223197,
-0.0097867846,
0.0009064089,
-0.0595693476,
0.0414760895,
-0.0045783832,
0.0390369371,
0.0402382575,
0.0019137249,
-0.0016431478,
-0.0098465681,
-0.0408697128,
-0.0124586765,
-0.0622409955,
-0.0059768944,
0.0579181351,
-0.0318318903,
0.0222894792,
-0.0038455997,
0.0089491894,
0.0145308068,
0.0281698089,
0.0339026339,
-0.0085384399,
-0.000868779,
-0.0283409152,
-0.0347824506,
-0.010186784,
-0.0745042562,
-0.0284642559,
-0.1087467372,
0.0027859707,
0.0005032198,
-0.0065784082,
0.0015017255,
0.0230076872,
0.0417560488,
-0.0029232705,
0.0840640664,
-0.0098311659,
0.0245752707,
0.000370298,
0.0067020301,
0.0194187555,
0.038556736,
0.0309641771,
0.0440079011,
0.0082238829,
0.0266465023,
0.0566151515,
0.0390436128,
-0.0180680938,
-0.0179395601,
-0.0480095968,
0.0220784582,
-0.0378303342,
0.0527164191,
-0.0146017848,
0.0509387963,
-0.0015627433,
0.0501830466,
0.0826288387,
0.0562817641,
0.0300516915,
0.0162234567,
0.0728618801,
-0.0144578926,
0.0136185819,
0.0049008536,
-0.0185540561,
0.0394469462,
0.0035210077,
0.0659361109,
-0.0054636453,
0.005630122,
-0.0360022672,
-0.0866020471,
0.0011525283,
-0.0196861811,
0.0172319524,
0.0138236973,
0.0632174388,
-0.0126572326,
-0.0262722597,
0.0261302441,
-0.019295577,
-0.0522502363,
0.0340941623,
-0.0505756214,
0.0424727388,
0.0698161796,
0.0137897106,
-0.0367758051,
-0.0002826567,
-0.0117805079,
0.0041230051,
0.034724988,
0.0330137499,
-0.0283016078,
-0.0095280688,
-0.0359134935,
-0.0009807908,
0.009190049,
0.033743728,
0.0101888459,
-0.0222298317,
0.0201112907,
0.0115609383,
0.004005569,
-0.0819970965,
0.041483935,
0.0360528789,
-0.0673438087,
0.017708499,
-0.0168643221,
0.0023643728,
0.0509176441,
0.0080086617,
0.0191950444,
0.0472466722,
0.0058971839,
-0.007204188,
0.0257582124,
0.001850485,
-0.0362183377,
0.036859218,
-0.0470715873,
-0.0066578882,
0.0142895821,
-0.0412317701,
-0.0366781503,
-0.0228726659,
0.0192956403,
0.0508791506,
-0.0365187563,
0.0273650959,
0.0244115461,
-0.051162634,
0.0020651324,
0.0678817332,
0.0330669954,
-0.0017291083,
0.0040246248,
0.0162695143,
0.0105820745,
-0.0669798553,
-0.0240693074,
0.0559772067,
-0.0147291124,
0.0184551477,
0.0438189246,
0.050459858,
-0.0771990791,
0.0015971564,
-0.116790466,
0.0112486631,
-0.0167237874,
0.0053911675,
0.0235885102,
-0.0016788503,
-0.0221663732,
-0.0032361089,
-0.059224084,
-0.0186169576,
0.0497803912,
0.0056786528,
0.0267459489,
0.0136796227,
0.0356035791,
-0.0343314372,
-0.0066092671,
-0.0068378136,
0.0454222448,
0.0279920083,
-0.0061922814,
-0.1019657701,
0.0445257239,
-0.0576827675,
0.0062008076,
0.0235395934,
-0.000882684,
0.0357236825,
-0.0225783288,
0.0287231281,
0.0677774251,
0.024776211,
0.0067297909,
0.042134203,
-0.0740706027,
-0.0152506651,
-0.0045710467,
-0.0146654444,
-0.0330466032,
-0.0418997593,
-0.0404593274,
0.0639514849,
0.0070482302,
0.0003549764,
0.0144953402,
-0.049011454,
0.0282200594,
-0.0129324393,
0.0161181409,
-0.0660513714,
-0.0337573364,
-0.0432097279,
0.0168606639,
-0.0111594982,
-0.0262380429,
0.0471115038,
-0.0013073151,
0.0344583839,
-0.055163566,
0.0018275707,
-0.0245010313,
0.1021847054,
0.009746653,
0.0377510563,
-0.0158292614,
-0.0359282903,
-0.005555748,
-0.0023705575,
0.0385086387,
-0.0432326645,
0.0409958586,
-0.0195151959,
-0.007375841,
0.0043251691,
-0.0427834652,
-0.0226429868,
0.0071257027,
-0.0234731808,
-0.0255620759,
0.0266077723,
0.0117487507,
-0.0374290422,
-0.0032734082,
0.0153704109,
-0.0054718633,
-0.0278878044,
-0.0400326401,
0.022766931,
0.0604314171,
0.0219490062,
-0.0109067382,
-0.0244215038,
-0.0538633913,
-0.0016379385,
0.0520444401,
0.0518056341,
0.0261881649,
0.0258360934,
0.0005130711,
0.0162904728,
-0.0393650047,
-0.0370735116,
0.0556304008,
0.0672957525,
-0.0737315416,
0.0008687641,
0.1401822716,
0.060092885,
-0.0752620697,
-0.0014203895,
0.0107424604,
-0.0324174017,
-0.0007839665,
0.0273552593,
-0.0697727129,
0.0003590848,
0.0193999261,
0.0021447779,
-0.0254271626,
-0.024013998,
-0.0284755919,
-0.1265297234,
0.0201496221,
0.0113377422,
-0.0183370654,
-0.081617631,
0.0028252457,
0.0040683886,
-0.0180407576,
-0.0281501114,
0.0328717902,
-0.0113946097,
0.0396900624,
0.0113488743,
-0.0477682874,
-0.0429097302,
0.0265155919,
-0.0920128599,
0.0577975959,
0.0649620891,
0.0492867157,
-0.0221729465,
-0.0288518202,
-0.0128626693,
0.0141509464,
-0.0090534845,
-0.0255303551,
0.0501788333,
-0.0226453915,
-0.008034558,
-0.0446796343,
0.0224091765,
0.0287364591,
-0.0108955353,
0.069430396,
0.0705681294,
0.0357195288,
-0.0000463474,
0.0142861009,
-0.0463926457,
0.0205398537,
0.0538816638,
0.0208401792,
-0.0480748601,
-0.0079033794,
-0.0595581681,
0.0267209746,
-0.0466576219,
-0.0624156557,
-0.0481297635,
0.0198446754,
-0.0217066854,
-0.0542997532,
-0.0645451322,
0.0559596084,
0.0300921611,
0.0093282936,
0.0571385995,
-0.0429875888,
-0.014768403,
-0.0598022938,
-0.0014928987,
-0.0089198723,
0.0022489496,
-0.0520632304,
-0.0112799872,
0.0445836075,
-0.0230266321,
-0.0094302353,
0.0412247777,
-0.01369326,
-0.0226570424,
-0.01656425,
0.0564468056,
0.0264643189,
0.0108330632,
0.0155914947,
-0.0073121497,
-0.0289886482,
0.0201467276,
0.0025761449,
-0.0113461306,
-0.0263869315,
0.0130191101,
0.0144486735,
0.0034432367,
-0.0102858655,
0.019382704,
-0.0036042063,
0.0598941743,
-0.05667983,
0.0033162609,
0.0537234247,
0.0273283347,
0.0563480221,
-0.0275849011,
-0.0695843771,
-0.0044453563,
-0.0335351415,
-0.0657348782,
-0.0224306881,
-0.0346332602,
-0.0122035909,
0.0027594392,
0.0242382996,
-0.0291719288,
0.0079617091,
-0.0443342924,
0.0152973095,
-0.0585292354,
0.0354721174,
0.0309620183,
0.0072147031,
0.0039435267,
-0.0009988132,
-0.0128043573,
-0.0116332164,
0.0110496022,
0.0054562408,
-0.0106211882,
0.0102380561,
0.0273568258,
-0.0084350994,
0.0351359881,
0.0156315397,
-0.0056047342,
0.0587407686,
-0.0387804806,
0.0430077128,
0.0995910764,
-0.0059940685,
-0.0080226026,
-0.029361181,
-0.0086532449,
0.0016196113,
0.0254054163,
-0.0061744945,
-0.0579059646,
0.0118757254,
0.018119283,
-0.0021231037,
-0.0390905067,
0.0453158543,
0.0180781484,
-0.00817509,
0.0101523194,
-0.0721260086,
-0.0491977632,
0.0250934344,
0.0240026526,
0.0225938279,
-0.0425535403,
-0.0243569426,
-0.0730564967,
-0.0309187509,
-0.0003478329,
0.0395872854,
0.029404657,
-0.0003517925,
0.0223888215,
0.0642774403,
-0.0047760052,
-0.0028274178,
-0.0377717465,
0.0179769937,
-0.022237571,
-0.0482708476,
-0.0335184336,
-5.555677237e-33,
-0.0381396152,
-0.0722477436,
0.0345098786,
0.0467747077,
-0.0496342927,
-0.0011275457,
-0.0527933203,
-0.000134523,
0.0148543576,
0.0029758522,
-0.0215508305,
0.0039025531,
0.0116124088,
-0.0120712686,
0.0788611323,
-0.0528988838,
0.0569659285,
-0.0269619338,
-0.0290130023,
-0.0112311961,
-0.01297154,
0.0362339467,
0.031715136,
-0.0673136413,
0.050597541,
-0.0304098781,
-0.0539530776,
-0.0094556361,
0.0206161942,
0.0255590323,
0.0042886115,
0.005958559,
0.0346814804,
-0.0167177133,
-0.0141493874,
0.0426953472,
-0.0314593092,
-0.0324528553,
-0.0099013969,
0.0087681031,
0.0016470697,
0.0115391957,
0.0569932237,
-0.0319999047,
-0.0251144096,
-0.0189043898,
0.044806812,
-0.0492024906,
0.0160079785,
-0.0713819489,
-0.0570915043,
0.0245146304,
0.0265760738,
-0.0016408388,
0.0370069072,
0.0011782098,
-0.0140683306,
-0.0052188798,
-0.0499062464,
0.0579257198,
0.0164853875,
0.0507988818,
0.0362388007,
0.0400622524,
0.0006467464,
0.0088850725,
0.0334673189,
-0.0148905767,
-0.0491376445,
-0.0062072263,
0.0173233747,
0.0297525879,
0.0677384809,
0.0008260044,
0.0349723734,
0.0011060329,
-0.0530748703,
0.0312313363,
0.0556139499,
0.0325122848,
-0.0409982204,
0.0103248581,
-0.0242387597,
0.0096312212,
-0.0218139794,
0.0002442454,
-0.0285696853,
-0.0685239881,
0.0378463939,
-0.0149061587,
0.0127238799,
0.0204392541,
-0.00155333,
0.0305389725,
-0.0570372008,
0.0210096315,
-0.0031385373,
0.0866575316,
-0.0315625109,
-0.0129122529,
-0.067355305,
0.0148661807,
-0.0291944332,
0.0406242311,
-0.0129929455,
0.004589464,
0.0100403465,
0.0606395528,
-0.05656581,
-0.0002345875,
0.0011463168,
-0.0066476078,
0.0080494117,
-0.0112917162,
0.0049288706,
-0.0068894462,
-0.0092852535,
0.0174947549,
0.0179532692,
-0.0653285235,
-0.0391348936,
-0.0050453362,
0.0128349019,
0.0182475857,
-0.0000578187,
-0.0061458168,
-0.0380676836,
0.0511689484,
0.039208889,
0.0025061655,
-0.0121431164,
0.0088105751,
2.599e-7,
0.0226467643,
0.0806647092,
-0.052965641,
0.0212521572,
-0.0294526555,
0.0259214267,
-0.0535424687,
0.0310750566,
0.0632625446,
0.0450681001,
0.0448268354,
0.0240818989,
0.0243542176,
0.0513829961,
-0.1250981092,
-0.0222909246,
-0.0531049594,
-0.0318348631,
-0.0582619831,
0.0371239781,
0.0459789932,
0.0294003747,
0.044243414,
0.0224469267,
0.0270736963,
-0.0446717478,
0.065614678,
-0.0012401878,
-0.0202850252,
0.0035571528,
0.0202307981,
0.0045287274,
-0.0526576191,
0.0054352423,
-0.028001599,
-0.0174607169,
0.0350246467,
0.0288792271,
-0.0154441856,
0.0621286035,
-0.0052742823,
0.012375081,
-0.0283192471,
-0.0434546582,
0.0405164547,
-0.0267990865,
-0.0104338182,
0.0055066384,
-0.0438409857,
-0.0203280207,
-0.0124556636,
-0.0448836349,
-0.0485232994,
0.0195686724,
-0.0185859632,
0.0183137096,
0.0141421407,
-0.031487871,
-0.0257648714,
-0.0183394328,
-0.0198736023,
-0.013070818,
-0.030598361,
0.0339985937,
-0.0377176031,
-0.0795121118,
0.0077252225,
2.244426465e-34,
0.0182666536,
-0.0031743371,
-0.0170877296,
-0.0262842141,
-0.0053721219,
0.0283770468,
-0.0126242237,
0.0382108316,
0.0375965126,
-0.0362787172,
-0.02275653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18108v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18108v1 | Token-Weighted RNN-T for Learning from Flawed Data | 2024-06-26T06:48:11 | 2024-06-26T06:48:11 | Gil Keren, Wei Zhou, Ozlem Kalinli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | ASR models are commonly trained with the cross-entropy criterion to increase
the probability of a target token sequence. While optimizing the probability of
all tokens in the target sequence is sensible, one may want to de-emphasize
tokens that reflect transcription errors. In this work, we propose a novel
token-weighted RNN-T criterion that augments the RNN-T objective with
token-specific weights. The new objective is used for mitigating accuracy loss
from transcriptions errors in the training data, which naturally appear in two
settings: pseudo-labeling and human annotation errors. Experiments results show
that using our method for semi-supervised learning with pseudo-labels leads to
a consistent accuracy improvement, up to 38% relative. We also analyze the
accuracy degradation resulting from different levels of WER in the reference
transcription, and show that token-weighted RNN-T is suitable for overcoming
this degradation, recovering 64%-99% of the accuracy loss. | [
0.0362308957,
0.0487010479,
0.0227384269,
-0.0304446779,
0.0079037761,
0.04660023,
0.0093600359,
0.0121194301,
-0.0194060039,
-0.0059439577,
-0.0222766381,
-0.0376982763,
0.0363572836,
-0.0165620279,
0.0468266234,
-0.017688781,
0.0382354036,
0.0113886604,
0.039080184,
0.0051302449,
0.012205244,
-0.0090806633,
-0.0320183188,
0.0432385989,
-0.0901302546,
0.0208073799,
0.0363769978,
0.0269489978,
0.0252234135,
-0.0180552695,
0.0173941869,
0.0339563489,
0.008450849,
0.0688890442,
0.0000017785,
0.0017085264,
-0.0244845506,
0.0036951567,
-0.0110483877,
-0.0219386071,
0.0271447506,
0.0127182817,
-0.0268389527,
0.0350906327,
0.0141715072,
-0.0744743496,
0.080291979,
0.1117039397,
0.023523774,
0.0686146021,
0.0092601879,
0.0040351353,
0.000979643,
-0.0387048312,
0.0352912769,
-0.0454125889,
0.0335715488,
-0.0261612739,
-0.0139082791,
-0.0490079708,
0.0004620051,
0.0027296089,
0.0470428243,
-0.0021898062,
0.001890016,
0.0258844364,
-0.0541889966,
-0.0418298505,
0.0006869915,
0.0338506401,
-0.0155891497,
-0.0404396094,
0.0219006967,
-0.0145355156,
-0.0030746681,
-0.0517232791,
0.0084657092,
0.0084745567,
0.0135700144,
0.0280919615,
-0.0129797682,
-0.0044214311,
0.0675635412,
-0.0073761903,
-0.0263773222,
0.0358191021,
-0.0080457618,
-0.0520466827,
-0.0119330445,
0.0024607375,
-0.0113373855,
-0.0307825077,
0.0282122009,
-0.0010359699,
-0.0164202116,
-0.0025207913,
-0.0046005645,
-0.0393056385,
0.0379692242,
-0.0290737506,
-0.0042279647,
0.0025656533,
-0.0626037195,
-0.0008680699,
-0.0208193995,
0.050326243,
0.0359441079,
0.0630021766,
-0.0113629103,
-0.0143812289,
-0.0420595072,
0.0051205894,
-0.0256600175,
0.0725308731,
0.0125672175,
0.0086640837,
-0.0878948569,
-0.0134560727,
-0.0237930492,
0.0084378701,
0.0564702339,
-0.0038991927,
-0.0734871998,
0.02065612,
0.0177428424,
0.0022800346,
0.0381684862,
0.0131122321,
0.0142716449,
-0.0570505373,
-0.0225182921,
0.0160995871,
-0.0043766256,
-0.0286963712,
-0.0052891625,
0.0753670633,
0.0428918004,
-0.0411908887,
-0.0284955092,
0.0095363399,
-0.0560180694,
-0.0332777351,
-0.0594500229,
-0.0294388924,
-0.0227035116,
-0.0284644682,
-0.0076220725,
-0.0161617249,
0.0071704998,
-0.0163124632,
0.0154718459,
0.0457533561,
-0.0343087204,
-0.0420021601,
0.0089770369,
-0.0045033488,
-0.0197673328,
0.0295774527,
0.0351919271,
0.0242305025,
-0.0206874106,
-0.0069925911,
-0.017649062,
0.0072271321,
0.0444102436,
-0.0445253104,
-0.0045223502,
-0.054064732,
0.0265191346,
0.0569911152,
0.0532238632,
0.0722920373,
-0.0458437875,
-0.0006153154,
0.0181993432,
0.0084751258,
0.0143809589,
0.0377728827,
0.0315380618,
-0.0150901116,
-0.0415790156,
0.0264383219,
-0.0375184789,
0.0157256629,
0.0028654134,
0.020821197,
0.0719321743,
-0.0189103596,
-0.0255138893,
-0.0572325848,
-0.0272257533,
-0.0019468137,
-0.0325968489,
0.0111144567,
0.0542924218,
0.0067335237,
-0.0519713536,
0.0287050214,
0.0058431965,
-0.0409350581,
0.0283061452,
-0.0189340524,
-0.0150950449,
0.0376314297,
0.023569705,
-0.0755016357,
-0.023562111,
-0.0145691549,
-0.0296662934,
0.034334939,
-0.0013206407,
0.00739326,
0.0253518615,
-0.0292951297,
-0.0094274692,
0.0766085833,
0.0045290859,
0.0564703271,
-0.0572945029,
-0.0022229762,
0.0270546991,
-0.0712189823,
-0.0423527285,
0.0442770906,
0.009160948,
-0.0200606249,
0.0372978412,
0.0203888919,
0.066610083,
0.0412718132,
-0.0564293005,
0.013567959,
0.0391601473,
-0.0222002827,
-0.0426697582,
-0.0157225057,
-0.0826545805,
-0.0455181971,
0.0479548201,
-0.032710731,
-0.0367194079,
0.0224426687,
-0.0301038455,
-0.0659774318,
0.0360298902,
-0.0379868075,
0.0628546625,
-0.0711798593,
0.0044101109,
0.0417387299,
-0.0284481999,
-0.0396255292,
0.0198155381,
0.0069482666,
0.0836338326,
-0.031857647,
-0.0744988993,
-0.0133144157,
-0.0862043276,
0.0053522964,
-0.0052320063,
-0.0466645733,
-0.0047522867,
0.02583698,
-0.0089624738,
0.008062508,
-0.0044456143,
-0.0677485541,
-0.0432228968,
-0.0369501039,
0.0221357606,
-0.03721001,
0.0307921432,
0.0067944676,
-0.0214061774,
-0.0297612529,
-0.0535790697,
-0.0202715211,
-0.0147301732,
0.0180259403,
0.0141964108,
-0.0082705198,
-0.0167294499,
-0.0045612128,
-0.0321973003,
0.0028096149,
0.0012048964,
-0.0248866752,
-0.0583335347,
-0.0056071617,
0.0063614249,
0.008361741,
0.0232353378,
-0.0326543562,
0.0164046604,
0.01925602,
0.0158769656,
-0.0188682862,
-0.0145620741,
-0.0077015338,
0.0019603586,
0.0088659264,
-0.0488240235,
-0.0047855563,
-0.0088742981,
0.0369357765,
0.025899699,
-0.0306931045,
-0.0007718685,
0.062323276,
-0.0038541649,
-0.0038576913,
-0.0571618937,
-0.025279576,
-0.0058594276,
-0.04288451,
-0.0012718202,
-0.0309123751,
-0.0186899379,
-0.0067598736,
-0.0023340196,
0.0091001419,
0.0760672614,
-0.0356137156,
-0.0079312716,
-0.0358051211,
-0.0226197522,
-0.0168236233,
-0.0388640165,
0.0242790412,
0.0273596514,
0.0588465407,
-0.0685063824,
0.0044401241,
0.0031268457,
-0.0169303697,
-0.0020923417,
0.0133276079,
-0.0052646976,
0.0490396284,
-0.0103728315,
-0.0297408439,
-0.012881889,
0.0038825027,
0.002471226,
-0.0036854858,
-0.0014813496,
-0.0333064497,
-0.0149083426,
-0.0301250871,
-0.0096423374,
0.0949647501,
0.0012072041,
0.0150696877,
-0.0231167339,
0.0118115563,
0.018711688,
-0.0285351314,
0.0383215807,
-0.0142598264,
-0.0026544775,
0.0300944969,
0.0556607954,
0.0051047588,
-0.0170964319,
-0.0082680136,
0.0179309249,
-0.0401739776,
0.0350320786,
0.036877837,
0.0197800435,
-0.0015130508,
-0.0307638347,
0.1019982249,
0.0225182064,
-0.0374231376,
0.001266632,
0.0006485699,
0.0398018919,
0.001773939,
-0.0075388509,
-0.0607116111,
-0.0187522564,
0.0442510471,
0.0371737815,
-0.0289252531,
-0.0332677327,
0.063411139,
-0.0552387387,
0.029812118,
0.0339604542,
-0.0971615762,
-0.0309606604,
-0.0708318353,
-0.031537693,
-0.0803042054,
0.0747318491,
0.0291037597,
0.0038141848,
-0.00839708,
0.0960505083,
-0.0411277451,
-0.0772977397,
-0.0116888322,
-0.0438100062,
0.0703475922,
0.0870266706,
0.0043472266,
-0.0091316672,
-0.0601003207,
0.0412304588,
0.0023309463,
-0.0159535948,
-0.0187182166,
0.0187538825,
0.0215722229,
-0.0226870421,
-0.0144733731,
0.0125609701,
-0.0471424237,
-0.0078746192,
-0.0696426779,
0.0710064098,
-0.0136437276,
0.0059734997,
0.0286652315,
-0.0260611642,
0.0279470347,
0.0468854047,
0.0467595011,
-0.0138461087,
-0.0262492914,
-0.0248595364,
0.0865136236,
-0.0724779889,
0.0140643502,
-0.0137258302,
-0.0340680443,
-0.098232843,
-0.0916762799,
-0.018365575,
-0.0051503181,
0.0457086973,
-0.0017540768,
0.0015851628,
0.0160612352,
-0.0151957199,
-0.0208664499,
0.0067919213,
-0.0187251102,
0.0235629417,
-0.0686287135,
0.0052634641,
0.0188271515,
-0.0104864854,
-0.0022439021,
0.0159518458,
-0.038385611,
-0.0706171989,
0.0390327238,
0.0190936718,
0.0131953685,
0.021261761,
-0.0138396872,
-0.0371947959,
0.0660329908,
0.0711486042,
-0.0085342927,
-0.0313516818,
0.0402490534,
-0.052950155,
-0.0215781201,
0.0192843173,
-0.05538572,
0.0187902171,
0.0269539859,
0.0620645769,
-0.0314368382,
0.0019541257,
0.0465668477,
0.0221392084,
0.0910134539,
-0.0117589775,
-0.0216983575,
-0.0190492254,
0.028472485,
0.0021060163,
0.0218563918,
-0.0095072137,
0.0222724807,
0.0184300076,
0.0248415396,
-0.0364891998,
0.018879436,
-0.0583447032,
0.0028087925,
0.0122044655,
0.0227807686,
-0.0167831443,
0.0464488901,
-0.0188449696,
-0.0166628212,
-0.0120604048,
0.0060231248,
0.0342600159,
0.0329050608,
0.0122646056,
-0.0405019484,
0.0129418876,
0.056213934,
0.0191484168,
-0.0067919749,
-0.0501486957,
0.0443893671,
-0.059647873,
0.0112968097,
0.0521237589,
-0.0005593708,
0.0061097634,
0.0066318731,
0.0139836222,
-0.0401706994,
0.0046502226,
-0.0248771738,
-0.0118340813,
0.0227796175,
0.0187959336,
0.0045994995,
0.0126507403,
0.0628253818,
0.049891185,
0.0817392394,
-0.0494078696,
-0.0149132144,
-0.0139671117,
-0.016372418,
0.0037642897,
-0.0122319562,
-0.0504751839,
-0.0364544317,
-0.0162214004,
-0.1031107828,
0.0546651296,
0.0391484313,
0.0459197946,
0.0133761484,
0.0129572051,
-0.0232098773,
-0.0011755886,
0.0097357081,
-0.0181146562,
-0.0218441747,
0.0649126917,
-0.0556831136,
0.0153191015,
-6.61918371e-33,
0.0079588117,
-0.0130540039,
-0.0135596246,
-0.0031363738,
-0.0374880694,
0.0135619771,
-0.0139698405,
0.0088162217,
0.0257049166,
0.0052050776,
-0.0031664777,
0.0014329558,
0.0271674432,
0.023649253,
0.0080205202,
-0.006988863,
0.0552070998,
0.0076446519,
0.0093425903,
0.0018120866,
0.0591178313,
0.0403852165,
0.0551277548,
-0.0486352406,
0.0171916392,
0.0479550473,
-0.004670775,
-0.0003586307,
-0.0041957255,
0.0081595769,
0.0166452602,
0.0262986813,
-0.0087789707,
-0.0353075676,
-0.0222405717,
-0.0227973964,
-0.073811315,
-0.0260084532,
-0.0112625528,
0.047618825,
0.0147311399,
-0.0546344109,
0.0761421025,
-0.0179808326,
-0.0712587088,
0.017643014,
0.0284436569,
-0.0066831899,
-0.0491483733,
-0.0653785095,
-0.0241424423,
0.0421834514,
-0.0192329548,
0.0006703222,
0.0309505835,
-0.0006304915,
-0.0102905761,
0.0101247318,
-0.1010748148,
-0.0069315438,
-0.0300559904,
0.0620152503,
0.0134684173,
0.0171457566,
-0.025455866,
0.0295965802,
0.0562879071,
-0.0249879044,
-0.0036761519,
-0.0031757189,
-0.0026473175,
-0.0296352077,
0.0608660206,
0.0199427847,
0.0823135525,
-0.0433922671,
-0.0676110834,
0.0326690599,
-0.0402201004,
0.0611801371,
0.002717274,
0.0603875257,
-0.0215884373,
0.0257039797,
-0.0163104273,
-0.0329527259,
-0.0357257351,
0.0077956901,
-0.0094998684,
0.0288847797,
0.0121121947,
0.0541284643,
-0.0071961014,
0.0086754188,
-0.0031795013,
-0.0223271344,
0.0826940387,
-0.0085811922,
-0.0149996812,
0.0200403798,
-0.0635447279,
-0.0245858822,
0.0796148703,
0.0293526892,
0.0338009,
-0.0484127514,
0.0799390748,
0.0252366923,
-0.0471893139,
-0.0132556027,
0.0175196957,
0.0519488156,
0.0027143089,
-0.0274771098,
0.028043814,
-0.0338913016,
0.0081875697,
0.0020668576,
-0.0097977305,
0.0088227764,
-0.0106385248,
0.0654050186,
-0.0068601728,
0.013663495,
-0.0358152874,
-0.0369132385,
0.0421637781,
-0.0058922181,
-0.0055759912,
-0.046164915,
-0.030420864,
0.0302761514,
2.721e-7,
-0.0176846553,
0.0238749534,
0.0738257989,
-0.0641819239,
0.0150214098,
0.0306366682,
-0.0407317057,
0.0221128911,
0.0115632769,
0.0063705896,
0.0439834408,
-0.0386807695,
0.0530354902,
0.0109395655,
-0.1001160666,
-0.023870701,
-0.0667506605,
0.0416010879,
0.0254652556,
0.0138668064,
0.0078147156,
0.1191440448,
-0.0044107558,
-0.0530258417,
0.0380376242,
0.000348514,
0.0337431394,
0.0160816535,
0.0092948722,
-0.0153643768,
0.0223176312,
-0.0148516726,
0.0248819012,
0.0270376671,
-0.0340344049,
-0.0303787831,
0.0460861996,
-0.0190221556,
-0.0393383764,
-0.052358456,
0.0129055381,
0.0645990074,
0.0486536436,
0.0013537507,
0.0105020944,
-0.0069653885,
-0.0149132349,
-0.0195273925,
-0.0366306156,
0.0254741088,
0.0246583223,
-0.0160406511,
-0.0201363768,
0.0387352444,
0.0330406539,
0.0154455425,
-0.0110861724,
-0.0350678116,
0.0143179614,
0.0080329441,
-0.0412808135,
0.0092325471,
-0.0401182361,
0.0456983969,
0.0052300352,
-0.052731134,
-0.0144658666,
1.964326365e-34,
0.0334860608,
-0.0565796122,
-0.0105541851,
-0.0007173601,
0.0223046597,
0.0191775933,
-0.016750535,
0.027829485,
-0.0217719506,
-0.0299798772,
-0.0354099758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18094v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18094v1 | Shimo Lab at "Discharge Me!": Discharge Summarization by Prompt-Driven Concatenation of Electronic Health Record Sections | 2024-06-26T06:10:20 | 2024-06-26T06:10:20 | Yunzhen He, Hiroaki Yamagiwa, Hidetoshi Shimodaira | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we present our approach to the shared task "Discharge Me!" at
the BioNLP Workshop 2024. The primary goal of this task is to reduce the time
and effort clinicians spend on writing detailed notes in the electronic health
record (EHR). Participants develop a pipeline to generate the "Brief Hospital
Course" and "Discharge Instructions" sections from the EHR. Our approach
involves a first step of extracting the relevant sections from the EHR. We then
add explanatory prompts to these sections and concatenate them with separate
tokens to create the input text. To train a text generation model, we perform
LoRA fine-tuning on the ClinicalT5-large model. On the final test data, our
approach achieved a ROUGE-1 score of $0.394$, which is comparable to the top
solutions. | [
0.0526900701,
0.0091706701,
0.00406544,
-0.0788339972,
-0.00888946,
0.0238967761,
0.0178263504,
0.0143379914,
0.0208864436,
-0.001018467,
0.0253491327,
-0.028080117,
0.0347143151,
0.0916702747,
0.0308186449,
-0.0687616467,
0.0215592254,
0.022115659,
0.0195974316,
0.0142513793,
0.0008011378,
0.0003486088,
-0.0324146077,
0.0454929098,
0.0357282907,
-0.010457499,
-0.016210679,
0.0361627676,
0.0431146435,
-0.0662011132,
0.0071093454,
0.0139072966,
-0.0215670317,
-0.0371257029,
0.000002051,
-0.0500863791,
-0.0205292124,
0.0317828916,
-0.0765237361,
-0.0309715215,
0.0111156506,
-0.043216683,
0.0021442326,
0.0265400521,
0.0139664244,
-0.0308368523,
0.0188405495,
0.048506327,
0.0699083805,
0.0686235353,
-0.0203492939,
0.0328480564,
-0.0185814835,
-0.0440675206,
0.04123763,
0.0210196935,
-0.007197022,
-0.026797764,
0.0481531918,
-0.0627637431,
0.0022305232,
0.021651268,
0.0193554237,
0.0173762776,
0.0370422751,
0.0741263628,
0.0126859406,
0.0101659605,
-0.0174546652,
0.0475388579,
0.0360527486,
0.0204478931,
0.0706761479,
-0.0155828353,
0.0033538681,
-0.0323239565,
-0.0567960702,
0.0188109409,
-0.0391932167,
-0.0100877816,
0.0055577355,
0.0203837045,
-0.0042667761,
-0.0267347042,
-0.0097598573,
-0.0236285739,
0.0221472103,
-0.0426869206,
-0.0043526688,
-0.004955797,
0.0252385344,
-0.0687348843,
0.0554096587,
0.0598706938,
-0.0534607023,
-0.0195295438,
-0.0320246592,
-0.0309699662,
0.0893804058,
0.0207013525,
0.0272793733,
0.0010099967,
0.0455362126,
0.0101165688,
-0.0136372373,
0.0249028262,
0.0009831876,
-0.0069337436,
-0.0380297191,
0.0274066031,
-0.0291278493,
-0.0223366283,
-0.0134431422,
0.0471406505,
-0.0232535843,
-0.0035417913,
-0.0958931148,
-0.0234276038,
0.0272498038,
0.0362248942,
0.063302353,
0.0227198526,
-0.0367258862,
0.0215800218,
-0.0030001998,
0.0039587207,
-0.0159164052,
-0.023826886,
0.0208486654,
-0.0247011576,
-0.0034362888,
0.0132860346,
0.0106607201,
0.0039470764,
0.0109191043,
0.0659028515,
-0.0234725326,
0.0001649276,
-0.0092912912,
-0.0743093491,
-0.0316681974,
-0.0335638523,
0.0103551224,
-0.0479487702,
0.03660018,
-0.0082618603,
-0.0135079259,
-0.0243724249,
0.0205107369,
0.036695037,
-0.0161849838,
0.0097413659,
-0.081312649,
-0.0043628435,
0.0476349033,
0.0053829267,
0.006672109,
-0.0184282195,
0.0347659551,
0.0336985663,
-0.0206445493,
-0.0039028144,
0.0277976226,
0.0164115727,
0.0188950151,
-0.0471941121,
0.0492929853,
-0.0068986886,
0.0020641075,
0.0418907553,
0.0073208404,
0.0806138888,
-0.0093301404,
0.0567337833,
0.0281716045,
0.0585553981,
0.0310546812,
-0.0464433916,
0.0490777194,
-0.0194376502,
-0.0215004086,
-0.0065586409,
-0.0222889632,
0.0175832231,
0.0414033383,
0.0442897938,
0.0554969497,
0.019990718,
-0.0406498648,
-0.0583996736,
-0.0108566824,
-0.0165640097,
-0.0260402355,
-0.0062432317,
0.0210352968,
-0.0020844438,
-0.0548481382,
0.0536584072,
0.0474948622,
-0.0620488189,
0.0137288757,
-0.0624069646,
0.0049832813,
0.1050842553,
0.0519478954,
-0.0073301317,
-0.0511750132,
-0.0532207415,
0.0024117597,
0.0355822742,
0.0321267918,
-0.011491471,
0.0037502716,
-0.0649753809,
-0.025563322,
0.0220513865,
-0.0185713582,
-0.0051851626,
-0.0231904406,
-0.004886697,
0.025010068,
-0.0083989929,
-0.0724226832,
0.0505623966,
-0.0707886294,
-0.0267195757,
0.0205757506,
0.0054862262,
0.0363248698,
0.0432441756,
0.0058219898,
0.0475992747,
0.043335069,
-0.030364763,
0.0065153469,
0.0204812847,
-0.0377328396,
-0.0325538293,
0.0075065396,
-0.0288937241,
0.0148386415,
-0.0321586169,
-0.0125959748,
-0.0360847078,
-0.0440476611,
-0.0553392954,
-0.0064889709,
-0.0241921432,
0.0399600305,
0.0885402188,
-0.0330794938,
-0.0392199382,
0.0401279926,
-0.0107752653,
0.0245842207,
0.0421747454,
-0.0069693201,
0.0116901658,
-0.050963033,
0.009261841,
0.0045601577,
-0.0220662151,
-0.0127118491,
0.0280879233,
0.0308278017,
-0.0478241406,
-0.0243211016,
-0.1214301288,
-0.0019833094,
0.00599695,
0.0183707606,
0.0340129659,
0.0179956034,
-0.0170496237,
-0.0180425271,
-0.0476082116,
-0.0337396525,
0.0383244157,
0.0109058032,
0.0339390114,
0.0363003276,
0.0042694095,
-0.0082467925,
-0.0192724783,
-0.0276938323,
0.0247220527,
0.0338374339,
-0.0156110208,
-0.0310488846,
0.001454046,
0.0046101063,
-0.0350592956,
0.0134586934,
-0.0124019897,
0.0256176013,
-0.0030853159,
0.1036587358,
0.0227864496,
0.0183621962,
0.0152157452,
0.0242102258,
-0.0148659963,
-0.0268566459,
0.0114663523,
-0.02342855,
0.018397836,
0.0330442563,
-0.0895222425,
0.0480909608,
0.0380699262,
0.0443445854,
0.0360996649,
-0.0442432016,
-0.0336199813,
-0.0171537381,
0.0011136164,
-0.0195770524,
0.0102347089,
-0.0511793345,
0.0208214186,
-0.0134924036,
-0.0167201199,
0.0601608753,
-0.0090406416,
0.0261368547,
-0.0531200431,
-0.0145147434,
-0.0465098061,
0.0282021351,
-0.0158512387,
0.0145580182,
0.0465188213,
-0.0506378077,
0.0132411681,
0.0062118331,
-0.0284921695,
-0.0360284708,
0.0345715284,
-0.0254469793,
-0.0014165472,
-0.0099649308,
-0.04938123,
-0.0213391054,
-0.0238307305,
0.0024136291,
0.0013209708,
-0.0070100767,
0.015024893,
-0.0637357384,
0.0228670817,
0.0085343653,
0.0637105703,
-0.012196715,
-0.0139738601,
0.0015892193,
0.0483440757,
0.0559330136,
-0.0231720489,
-0.0090778945,
-0.087413989,
0.0099800536,
0.0586033389,
0.0410543643,
0.0485689044,
0.0394446366,
-0.0063852542,
-0.0165431239,
-0.0891852602,
-0.0279623177,
0.045706436,
0.0607407279,
-0.0406982265,
-0.0104028732,
0.1153815612,
0.0272074174,
-0.0402863398,
0.0196831822,
0.0092932899,
0.011061742,
0.0069098766,
0.0220881365,
-0.0204110574,
-0.0074854139,
0.0144106867,
0.0807753727,
-0.0260564517,
-0.0295544006,
-0.0064700795,
-0.0607184321,
0.0322703272,
0.0008790425,
-0.0409258008,
-0.0565805584,
-0.0288598482,
-0.0054776561,
0.0068384483,
-0.0266644228,
0.0163729824,
-0.0389782675,
0.0067215096,
0.0398140289,
-0.0528490841,
-0.0371151082,
-0.0140912337,
-0.0197377484,
0.0537860021,
0.0777901635,
0.0214632023,
-0.0043603047,
-0.0090101454,
0.0174633842,
-0.0390650295,
0.0142891239,
-0.0071667507,
0.0895120502,
0.0084780827,
0.0051426142,
-0.0653801858,
0.0546246655,
0.0012179995,
-0.0430984385,
0.0330033861,
0.026590826,
-0.0156545937,
-0.035681054,
-0.0425574593,
0.0497301184,
0.0147004798,
0.0460061803,
0.0350789353,
-0.023988137,
-0.0424940847,
0.0028509533,
0.0435002372,
-0.0323235579,
0.0273884125,
-0.0214899089,
-0.0547518097,
-0.0300197843,
-0.0699997395,
-0.0603102297,
0.0904851034,
0.0241327733,
0.0061120549,
-0.0077182301,
-0.0143629862,
0.0031310255,
-0.0517140664,
0.0116812671,
0.0006566548,
0.0002763723,
-0.0930821076,
-0.0594230182,
0.0176924728,
0.0081133414,
-0.0184140392,
0.048629161,
-0.0322133563,
-0.0195351448,
0.0115953935,
0.0451604165,
0.0276352037,
-0.0125933941,
0.0333197303,
0.0156836864,
0.0464100651,
0.0606394969,
-0.0306233857,
-0.0127347168,
-0.0512566417,
0.0258779731,
-0.0289003681,
-0.0229565538,
-0.0235214625,
0.0121960845,
0.0228788517,
0.0544353127,
0.0076408423,
-0.0164886322,
0.014227083,
0.0602730252,
-0.0119376248,
-0.0526969954,
-0.0497864857,
-0.0582147911,
0.0133321686,
-0.0166430138,
0.0077006547,
-0.0039116596,
0.0042162556,
-0.027788993,
-0.0015851703,
0.0206072088,
0.0306877568,
-0.0465821624,
-0.0068075699,
-0.0765924677,
-0.0262493808,
0.0092719486,
0.0260417815,
0.0310283042,
-0.0378456227,
-0.0272148736,
0.0217161253,
-0.0115505969,
0.0065066181,
-0.0167311355,
0.0553234331,
-0.0060566142,
0.0374160968,
-0.0006737652,
0.0581591837,
-0.0443217829,
-0.0081650065,
-0.038906239,
0.0246348586,
0.0118052606,
0.0351436697,
0.0254801791,
-0.0309138596,
0.0113403257,
-0.0382355265,
0.0367911309,
-0.0039098044,
0.021535987,
-0.0003976721,
0.0131815271,
-0.0011445256,
-0.052287668,
0.0733997971,
-0.0075117564,
0.0353958234,
0.0255650934,
-0.0165406186,
-0.0811165273,
-0.0147928828,
0.0411823541,
0.0138740083,
-0.0350584276,
-0.0413166471,
-0.0701471642,
-0.0097788041,
0.07227052,
0.0212419573,
-0.0046504489,
0.0162738375,
0.0692903623,
0.0000014042,
-0.0126702664,
-0.0235635806,
-0.0256455019,
0.0463757068,
0.016491754,
-0.0178613234,
0.0042860527,
-5.866654635e-33,
-0.0414762758,
-0.0440915674,
0.016264379,
0.0084169954,
-0.0320844539,
0.0081494944,
-0.0645942613,
-0.0186737292,
0.0530131459,
-0.0092952764,
-0.0262718983,
-0.0374815203,
0.0297493841,
0.0370640904,
0.0181382038,
-0.0122301681,
0.0615423396,
0.009380023,
-0.0555003919,
0.0541429482,
-0.0076278755,
0.0456401631,
0.0185144674,
-0.0249604098,
0.0326538943,
-0.0090369433,
-0.0175951868,
-0.0383342095,
-0.0057742507,
0.0460758619,
-0.0378662869,
0.0177634321,
0.0469505712,
-0.0314445011,
-0.0227323491,
0.0383689664,
-0.0853726044,
-0.0239573289,
0.0084985914,
-0.0650314093,
-0.0539853498,
-0.0921362787,
0.040584214,
-0.0296384078,
-0.0209818929,
-0.0271728132,
0.0373443477,
0.0016403653,
-0.0186793692,
-0.0795834512,
-0.0174921434,
0.0299680196,
-0.013914478,
-0.0165751521,
-0.0349873416,
0.0336709768,
-0.0365568474,
-0.0103911264,
-0.0284054335,
0.036748454,
0.0476100817,
0.0351299271,
0.009623548,
-0.019792024,
-0.0095709572,
0.0479252674,
0.026379142,
0.0151325548,
-0.0349038802,
0.0359020829,
-0.0465108044,
-0.0101995636,
0.0242105685,
-0.0062704179,
0.0482444949,
-0.0249417517,
-0.0702722296,
0.0769570842,
-0.0453381166,
0.0313485451,
0.0372812562,
-0.0512282439,
-0.024855677,
-0.0225379784,
-0.0116889765,
-0.006938702,
-0.0094301067,
-0.0326012783,
0.0347655751,
0.0289040133,
-0.0208774172,
-0.0215320513,
-0.0193389058,
0.0298085846,
0.0415044241,
-0.002475081,
0.0619120039,
0.0147973094,
-0.0466707461,
-0.0332809053,
-0.0413828939,
-0.0058175153,
0.0527070053,
0.0015111228,
0.0347377025,
0.0283620246,
-0.0106009645,
0.0035744444,
-0.0712746754,
0.0081206681,
0.0355698578,
0.057458397,
-0.0026777375,
0.0160400644,
0.0197830461,
-0.0029273692,
0.0072781141,
0.0412927568,
-0.0216114707,
-0.0266415905,
-0.0330283344,
0.0044356356,
0.0480505228,
0.0303908717,
-0.0288863443,
0.0323655009,
-0.0493007265,
0.0621191151,
0.0169118717,
0.0211402308,
0.0141963689,
0.0148257976,
2.681e-7,
0.0296506956,
0.0168571137,
0.0659809709,
-0.0112160724,
-0.0068841847,
-0.0167133007,
-0.0129078962,
0.0020339543,
-0.0012003094,
0.008802115,
0.0486744978,
-0.0204163361,
0.040269617,
0.0237623807,
-0.089819625,
-0.0366514102,
-0.0577239096,
-0.0394220054,
-0.044625435,
-0.0051770001,
0.0750921741,
0.0270318799,
-0.0440722778,
-0.0305976532,
-0.0066029779,
0.0374347605,
0.0093280319,
-0.0061967159,
-0.0260856412,
0.0300570112,
0.0111118536,
-0.0573783107,
-0.0120603349,
0.0071119475,
-0.0041607674,
-0.0460799038,
0.0039681136,
0.1038277522,
-0.0080846809,
-0.0086989673,
0.0439592972,
0.0052215164,
0.0121077411,
0.0057909377,
0.0404599383,
-0.0318405777,
-0.0296264887,
0.0100665484,
-0.0628348142,
-0.0104613248,
0.0464183949,
-0.022511242,
-0.0515103154,
0.0389145799,
-0.0031489667,
0.0053259307,
-0.0181029104,
-0.042013444,
-0.026323596,
0.0064032013,
-0.0476345383,
-0.0456702933,
0.0084269363,
0.0051920447,
-0.0301435571,
-0.0883204117,
-0.0103505431,
2.822837185e-34,
0.0315141678,
-0.0052652722,
-0.0034024776,
0.0016502438,
0.0184517633,
-0.0280243792,
0.0061663594,
0.0369039103,
0.0271288548,
-0.0794867277,
-0.0471280366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18088v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18088v2 | LLM-Driven Multimodal Opinion Expression Identification | 2024-06-26T05:52:47 | 2024-06-29T09:55:50 | Bonian Jia, Huiyao Chen, Yueheng Sun, Meishan Zhang, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Opinion Expression Identification (OEI) is essential in NLP for applications
ranging from voice assistants to depression diagnosis. This study extends OEI
to encompass multimodal inputs, underlining the significance of auditory cues
in delivering emotional subtleties beyond the capabilities of text. We
introduce a novel multimodal OEI (MOEI) task, integrating text and speech to
mirror real-world scenarios. Utilizing CMU MOSEI and IEMOCAP datasets, we
construct the CI-MOEI dataset. Additionally, Text-to-Speech (TTS) technology is
applied to the MPQA dataset to obtain the CIM-OEI dataset. We design a template
for the OEI task to take full advantage of the generative power of large
language models (LLMs). Advancing further, we propose an LLM-driven method
STOEI, which combines speech and text modal to identify opinion expressions.
Our experiments demonstrate that MOEI significantly improves the performance
while our method outperforms existing methods by 9.20\% and obtains SOTA
results. | [
0.0072719362,
0.1124599501,
0.0066968454,
0.0374459326,
-0.0312733501,
-0.0080780564,
0.0389023535,
-0.0135465842,
-0.0154488059,
-0.0608288907,
-0.0851433128,
-0.0352993123,
-0.0193706863,
0.0518062674,
0.0128053352,
-0.0206404533,
0.0198089741,
0.0084927566,
0.0331100151,
-0.0095264483,
0.0504361354,
0.0480298921,
-0.0539293885,
0.0333809517,
-0.0624211803,
-0.0431364924,
0.0210451279,
-0.002860819,
0.0159604438,
-0.0448594578,
0.0179249216,
0.0385620184,
0.0377425551,
-0.0201500859,
0.0000018578,
-0.0129407374,
0.0051810672,
-0.0005692986,
0.0262157042,
-0.0075017759,
0.1086449474,
0.01185985,
0.0029273145,
0.0085407449,
-0.0122838486,
-0.0150202289,
0.0528000556,
0.0833410174,
0.0862571299,
0.0612699091,
-0.0297413245,
0.0024556527,
-0.0107261417,
0.0086778514,
-0.007323138,
0.0083642891,
0.0040500965,
-0.0034707002,
-0.0070334962,
-0.027116945,
0.0048352568,
0.0453994796,
-0.0555704199,
-0.0128432512,
-0.0286156014,
-0.0079324562,
0.0182686578,
-0.0157915968,
-0.0340959355,
0.1191934422,
0.0631605461,
0.0223746207,
-0.0132952835,
0.0163377859,
-0.0441832654,
0.0082662143,
-0.0234378111,
0.0212193932,
0.0087370202,
0.0384613276,
-0.0232923739,
0.0444888361,
0.0116069783,
0.0074279546,
0.0093518151,
0.0297613591,
-0.0093538165,
-0.0195826385,
0.0256874431,
-0.0052186158,
-0.0532736219,
0.0206964239,
-0.0041371281,
-0.0041336883,
0.0050168475,
0.0064344821,
-0.015176747,
-0.0306314696,
-0.0298356488,
-0.0357425325,
0.0415619463,
-0.0022837508,
-0.0809681788,
0.0501883477,
0.0030969074,
0.0003952944,
-0.0087345028,
-0.016345419,
-0.002980988,
-0.0258755311,
-0.0647783577,
0.0011787793,
0.0401250012,
0.0408999659,
-0.0689450651,
-0.0728444755,
-0.0417097695,
-0.013390542,
-0.0521826111,
0.0016536376,
0.0121823633,
0.0146626774,
0.0431311429,
0.010388107,
-0.0266162977,
0.0592984445,
0.0099868663,
0.0707460344,
-0.0510087982,
-0.0433574878,
0.0293741915,
0.0729838982,
0.02363839,
0.000378088,
0.0362601094,
0.0595695041,
-0.0018422314,
-0.0293885954,
-0.0301366411,
-0.0305659659,
-0.0607493706,
-0.0494510308,
0.0204506479,
-0.0436783023,
0.033611577,
-0.008295686,
-0.0147433141,
-0.0358184315,
0.0259634815,
-0.0104708662,
0.0062097115,
0.0678063557,
-0.0002697525,
0.0395276137,
0.0035314467,
-0.0070415791,
0.0271373279,
0.0468157642,
0.0369824208,
0.0172858406,
0.0453604832,
-0.0187817048,
0.0343205668,
0.0504183769,
-0.0230092201,
0.008143682,
-0.0031289465,
-0.0272080917,
-0.0557313897,
0.0308320466,
0.0451812893,
0.0871569738,
0.0144448932,
-0.0088943932,
0.0936070457,
0.0311720651,
-0.034564808,
0.0304912925,
-0.019288782,
0.0127075287,
0.0025002626,
-0.0278403983,
0.0160889644,
0.0335014239,
-0.0153015582,
-0.0187781267,
0.0455505699,
0.0098410929,
-0.0354214758,
-0.0303329695,
-0.0384902023,
-0.0233729966,
-0.0312711298,
0.0242336504,
0.0185807534,
-0.0138122458,
-0.0459963307,
0.0196575578,
0.0322171263,
-0.0805181265,
-0.016155323,
-0.0370059647,
0.046685867,
0.0439445451,
0.0112799946,
-0.0309717339,
-0.0052923588,
-0.0288127679,
0.001025553,
0.066819571,
0.0175840538,
-0.0129123777,
0.0217903946,
-0.0485947244,
0.0139206257,
0.0060938988,
-0.0029661448,
-0.0058368817,
-0.0125674084,
0.011240392,
-0.0149142118,
-0.0603809357,
0.0234102979,
0.0143835573,
0.0378774069,
-0.0321793072,
0.0238175876,
0.0222996492,
0.0501480363,
0.0370458104,
-0.0497886091,
-0.0062009231,
0.0287372079,
-0.0332802869,
-0.030880956,
0.0312473495,
-0.030884143,
-0.0470481887,
0.0172522441,
-0.0345560685,
-0.0056476132,
0.038435284,
-0.0310442373,
-0.0100281285,
0.0315768979,
-0.0215370059,
-0.0073570595,
-0.0704443455,
-0.0264923293,
0.0190512538,
0.0285382085,
-0.0142028453,
0.0252125319,
-0.0047863182,
-0.0326001719,
0.0057521202,
-0.016528422,
0.0105157699,
0.0053891735,
-0.0540769473,
-0.0047041797,
0.0248679984,
0.0112032946,
-0.0124385795,
-0.0128605459,
-0.0048333062,
-0.0465805493,
-0.1202741638,
-0.0253150016,
0.0182390157,
0.0175817329,
0.0213732403,
-0.0145738432,
-0.0102913668,
0.0263141282,
-0.0501531847,
-0.0141022447,
0.0473312028,
0.0111182034,
0.0148876505,
-0.0200415887,
0.0192783829,
-0.0384548642,
0.0294419043,
-0.0230836049,
0.0348935202,
-0.032447435,
-0.0300346985,
-0.0125293406,
-0.0082197348,
-0.0577828214,
0.0494112372,
-0.0051707183,
-0.0318789668,
-0.0012874323,
-0.0091100316,
0.0503556952,
0.0117940167,
0.0051355725,
0.0412768722,
0.0342140459,
-0.003215892,
-0.0194188692,
0.0153692989,
-0.0270754788,
0.0172924474,
-0.014541761,
-0.0357507989,
0.0099547161,
0.0321917683,
0.0446875393,
0.0164563823,
0.0047695804,
-0.0043386673,
0.0153445331,
-0.037093997,
0.0073119141,
-0.0097708851,
-0.0304362178,
-0.0058006467,
0.0138727389,
-0.0211311877,
0.0339379571,
-0.0340781063,
-0.0255069416,
-0.0554250516,
-0.0179076251,
-0.0592725649,
0.06744463,
-0.070067063,
0.0158040766,
-0.0040140189,
0.0136193596,
-0.010822745,
-0.0296375807,
-0.03624513,
-0.04495674,
0.0243846867,
-0.0081947101,
0.0146482857,
0.0361085571,
-0.0477250628,
-0.0055151689,
-0.0630450025,
-0.0435716622,
-0.0183894373,
0.0111250561,
-0.0227750186,
-0.0018569215,
-0.0004288363,
0.0274257846,
-0.0500889905,
0.0092613287,
0.0251804199,
0.0097863721,
0.0603391416,
0.0748945102,
0.0305490028,
0.0070061134,
-0.0074718189,
-0.0018702853,
0.0383148231,
0.006474846,
0.017579399,
-0.0474992804,
-0.0225505102,
0.026613798,
0.0664099082,
0.0110313678,
-0.0258315857,
0.0415224507,
0.005638517,
0.0481879935,
0.1423469484,
0.0008534086,
-0.0553356782,
-0.0030189748,
0.0194755178,
-0.0152099961,
0.0134040909,
-0.0072363778,
-0.061046578,
-0.0712637901,
-0.0286118817,
0.0267266501,
-0.0222634282,
0.0112336781,
0.0043240865,
-0.1195890456,
0.0267268438,
-0.0147948368,
0.0243684258,
-0.0298252758,
-0.0090432065,
0.0276333839,
-0.00911815,
-0.004128153,
-0.0439240932,
-0.0082593001,
-0.0146663999,
0.0266005713,
-0.0470330752,
-0.0573520064,
0.0558075346,
-0.0131011531,
0.0609622449,
0.0347296372,
0.0468998142,
-0.0295639988,
-0.0454146564,
0.0415955894,
0.0088969236,
-0.0070222602,
-0.0145002231,
0.0546632968,
-0.0564313531,
-0.01989666,
-0.0083917202,
0.0364423953,
-0.0174223557,
0.0241100825,
-0.0097960522,
0.0448738225,
-0.0309010763,
-0.0221008267,
-0.0349569209,
0.0543337986,
0.0446290858,
0.0668992847,
0.0009180498,
-0.0746736303,
-0.0129771922,
0.0276563074,
0.0154840415,
-0.0021178755,
-0.0177253876,
-0.029781552,
0.0113528306,
0.0158000849,
-0.0745670572,
-0.0115976175,
0.0071949777,
0.0221937019,
0.0200409386,
-0.0148663232,
-0.0039291028,
0.0217297543,
-0.0436985083,
0.0431543961,
0.0062390463,
0.0326105915,
-0.0310782678,
-0.0048574172,
0.0673585162,
-0.0194189698,
-0.0202092063,
0.0286502168,
-0.0627255291,
-0.0390376784,
-0.0219694432,
0.0157083869,
0.005480818,
-0.0230544452,
0.0419842042,
-0.0457026735,
0.0382544249,
0.0469585843,
-0.0062307105,
0.0315985307,
0.0308662523,
0.0617684647,
-0.010668098,
0.0185226258,
-0.0141998921,
0.0602062047,
0.0095718242,
0.0222507436,
0.0052280347,
-0.0420147292,
-0.027991185,
0.0102349231,
0.0579136088,
0.0072303666,
0.0095739802,
-0.0540818721,
-0.026760947,
0.008123395,
-0.0089504775,
-0.0739803314,
-0.0008609826,
0.0144422986,
0.0333618149,
-0.0560191534,
-0.0138265248,
0.0069217253,
0.0425491668,
-0.0338243619,
0.0712455213,
0.0283722989,
-0.0418254994,
-0.0351021327,
0.0221790969,
-0.0362125747,
0.0304753017,
-0.0181107484,
-0.0378109328,
0.0140982335,
0.0597739331,
-0.0005084422,
-0.0343174376,
-0.0171638206,
0.0374290124,
0.0185852926,
0.014291239,
-0.0351532437,
0.0393917896,
0.0186130963,
0.0006318828,
0.0405884087,
-0.0259277001,
0.0133012952,
-0.0477426499,
0.039084103,
-0.0504703671,
0.0013119514,
0.048320774,
-0.0078807203,
-0.0265857056,
-0.0079604127,
0.0472769141,
-0.0401287228,
0.0305406787,
0.0099333227,
-0.0026682846,
-0.0574890785,
-0.0218088869,
0.0450610332,
0.0044186148,
0.0027301291,
0.0329694822,
-0.0188431218,
-0.0533618554,
0.0558591038,
-0.0297282711,
-0.0062887836,
-0.0258744191,
0.0147298621,
0.0412069969,
0.0094366232,
0.0440227278,
-0.0571139678,
-0.0327808186,
-0.0503371134,
-0.021752229,
-0.0283640269,
-5.780324493e-33,
0.0029277871,
-0.0224608779,
-0.024539886,
0.0227641966,
-0.0342774205,
0.0138999773,
-0.0178196933,
0.0332518071,
0.0089620072,
0.0252257064,
0.0265891757,
-0.0284048803,
-0.0041529089,
0.0485810153,
-0.0096815042,
-0.0100218998,
0.0327991955,
-0.0192270186,
-0.0102747446,
0.005805864,
0.0568935834,
0.0221916866,
0.0537697971,
-0.1214790195,
0.0182236582,
0.0127689755,
-0.0516611002,
0.005597699,
0.0388636999,
0.0593744628,
-0.0538076758,
0.0969142765,
0.0104449978,
0.0178297143,
0.0138917975,
0.0476092361,
-0.013502555,
0.0211546458,
0.0239707958,
-0.0082435738,
-0.0468607843,
-0.0013818704,
0.0021486713,
-0.002992037,
-0.0823326185,
-0.0032754135,
0.0494965836,
-0.0162878055,
0.0396688171,
-0.0657448024,
-0.0461233482,
0.0109129045,
0.0035196326,
-0.0395448953,
0.0414665379,
0.0377902687,
0.0010222076,
0.0189865194,
-0.0423243716,
0.0528868772,
-0.064401105,
0.0008031022,
0.0259257574,
-0.0026355411,
0.0235135183,
0.1047230512,
0.0163335465,
-0.0414873324,
-0.0449071452,
0.0187376365,
0.0256794412,
0.0388610139,
0.0217294041,
0.0599501356,
-0.0293571707,
-0.0234479327,
0.0004949856,
-0.006368163,
0.0340191312,
-0.0268709939,
0.0778041333,
-0.0098841749,
-0.035764236,
0.0077421749,
-0.0256632566,
-0.0142275151,
-0.0438267402,
-0.006277997,
0.0327212438,
0.0005135976,
-0.0115273148,
0.0006190978,
0.0397798568,
-0.0283101164,
-0.0174199473,
0.0091134254,
-0.0212465897,
0.0686006323,
0.0062991898,
0.0035312357,
-0.051918786,
-0.0045543541,
0.023330899,
0.0070549347,
0.0505001955,
-0.0328150317,
0.0053311125,
0.0434202217,
-0.0735940859,
-0.0078166258,
0.0045972131,
0.0042750542,
-0.0267467629,
0.0405583084,
-0.0255790837,
-0.008751194,
-0.0306032859,
0.01613467,
-0.0247038901,
0.0739801228,
-0.0187010355,
-0.0703170076,
-0.0141910184,
0.0056335488,
-0.0542483293,
-0.0091351001,
0.0186891779,
-0.0797385052,
-0.0356206745,
-0.0352941528,
0.0186369047,
0.02643588,
2.665e-7,
0.0239152759,
0.0464603305,
-0.0182615165,
0.0115199117,
0.0319429487,
0.0357935578,
-0.0140015185,
0.0111280344,
0.0113491043,
-0.0457224548,
0.0256053824,
0.0004664361,
0.0732665136,
0.002118547,
-0.0814221352,
0.0257291216,
-0.0086216321,
0.0169932954,
-0.0347990543,
0.034253452,
0.0801948011,
0.0920856819,
0.0042909943,
-0.0340316258,
-0.0179228242,
-0.0102821123,
0.0609023534,
-0.0226731561,
-0.0252840389,
0.0044413051,
0.0264422446,
-0.029969627,
-0.00350788,
-0.0340619534,
0.0052137752,
-0.0144539466,
0.0176758878,
0.053985782,
0.0204932615,
-0.1086676493,
-0.0107276691,
0.0747688636,
-0.0129180392,
0.0266028959,
0.0673382133,
-0.0094422819,
-0.0399199538,
-0.1144356206,
-0.0070521049,
-0.012424388,
0.0188338663,
-0.022810854,
-0.00471756,
0.0108030168,
0.0153530184,
-0.0529563688,
-0.0566844083,
-0.0665061846,
-0.0060220635,
0.0061299666,
-0.0728690475,
-0.0351963565,
0.0099664088,
-0.0082260082,
0.0147998212,
-0.0659708753,
-0.0120606795,
2.144498425e-34,
0.0392255597,
-0.0311476402,
-0.0207118578,
0.0241423212,
0.0330202393,
0.0041370005,
-0.0454349481,
-0.0348587893,
0.0192001294,
-0.0569789633,
0.006289321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18087v1 | EHR-Based Mobile and Web Platform for Chronic Disease Risk Prediction Using Large Language Multimodal Models | 2024-06-26T05:51:08 | 2024-06-26T05:51:08 | Chun-Chieh Liao, Wei-Ting Kuo, I-Hsuan Hu, Yen-Chen Shih, Jun-En Ding, Feng Liu, Fang-Ming Hung | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Traditional diagnosis of chronic diseases involves in-person consultations
with physicians to identify the disease. However, there is a lack of research
focused on predicting and developing application systems using clinical notes
and blood test values. We collected five years of Electronic Health Records
(EHRs) from Taiwan's hospital database between 2017 and 2021 as an AI database.
Furthermore, we developed an EHR-based chronic disease prediction platform
utilizing Large Language Multimodal Models (LLMMs), successfully integrating
with frontend web and mobile applications for prediction. This prediction
platform can also connect to the hospital's backend database, providing
physicians with real-time risk assessment diagnostics. The demonstration link
can be found at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oqmL9DEDFgA. | [
0.0094234161,
0.0665948018,
-0.0188552588,
-0.0418097004,
0.0295001827,
0.01136846,
0.0204818193,
0.0261826068,
0.0461694412,
0.0025784972,
0.0272549931,
-0.0282444656,
0.018192634,
0.0545988865,
0.0075100753,
-0.0575620793,
0.0049890801,
0.0035744344,
0.0249345135,
0.0252639707,
0.0185168739,
0.0052686622,
-0.00794861,
0.0673931539,
-0.0401181467,
-0.0296636485,
-0.0139587428,
0.0022222553,
0.0061532804,
-0.0772711411,
0.0108108297,
0.0010102596,
-0.0101139015,
-0.0374217406,
0.0000022071,
-0.0499078333,
-0.0515148677,
0.0180177428,
-0.0173577964,
-0.0818091929,
0.0706203803,
-0.0365174972,
0.0115592871,
0.0154199833,
-0.0252449345,
-0.0216382742,
0.041469615,
0.0477089286,
0.036259301,
0.019220043,
-0.0302297585,
0.0214071982,
0.0474454351,
-0.0057841307,
0.0276172049,
-0.0473318547,
0.0121920798,
-0.0153932841,
0.0280046128,
-0.0628100187,
-0.0051736725,
0.0278762728,
0.0029609022,
0.0731501654,
-0.025141824,
0.0217687991,
0.0314383283,
-0.0329856463,
-0.0343316272,
0.060017731,
-0.0069494778,
0.0047147595,
0.0286723562,
0.0140798902,
-0.0235600211,
0.026151605,
-0.0238611884,
-0.0188953895,
-0.0489333048,
0.0002410626,
0.0007321446,
-0.0242638364,
0.0339598693,
0.0054589715,
-0.00390821,
0.0207893271,
0.0167459734,
-0.0121998945,
-0.0092833601,
-0.0490081944,
0.0433278829,
-0.0300856903,
0.0193040892,
0.0540589094,
-0.0679939762,
-0.0235621352,
0.0015929545,
-0.0039951662,
0.0651660413,
-0.0532102808,
0.0480330959,
0.0270119458,
0.0014701954,
0.0257909168,
0.0134076038,
-0.0112501895,
-0.0395044945,
-0.0093854414,
-0.0297751855,
-0.0115558384,
-0.03090409,
0.0007762485,
0.0108918548,
0.0086597688,
0.0101817753,
-0.032310918,
-0.0939862356,
0.004059115,
0.0048607956,
-0.0018874086,
0.0143823847,
0.0432690047,
0.004115704,
0.0288675707,
-0.0573059954,
0.0408805162,
0.0293984748,
0.0070379162,
-0.0006619783,
-0.051788453,
0.0835328996,
0.0033516772,
0.0163156912,
-0.0168030336,
0.0339688845,
0.0900921896,
0.0234844722,
0.000239395,
-0.0209197905,
-0.0629403442,
-0.0087787556,
-0.0311166272,
-0.0012960098,
-0.0649520308,
0.014646058,
0.0148114609,
0.022865884,
-0.0491491035,
0.0269050766,
0.014035102,
-0.0133733694,
0.0320971049,
-0.0511009991,
0.0065901736,
0.0449003577,
0.0121140387,
-0.0009285788,
0.03845587,
0.0357572027,
-0.0004126526,
0.0198149253,
-0.0483905338,
0.031930957,
0.0462091565,
0.0044114995,
-0.0508226044,
-0.0005389678,
-0.0234746858,
-0.0115658669,
0.0397191197,
-0.0532742925,
0.0414066091,
0.0346185453,
0.0219073296,
0.0747167021,
-0.0011636844,
0.0362760276,
0.0099760778,
0.0002830299,
-0.0524872094,
-0.028561987,
-0.0676690489,
-0.0025091171,
0.0463889167,
-0.0437476337,
-0.0191098861,
-0.0040845303,
0.0177961402,
-0.0313555002,
-0.0471633598,
-0.0387680903,
-0.0420491621,
0.0300844014,
-0.0006389765,
0.0417578593,
-0.0573589616,
0.0061046723,
0.0295848027,
0.0354318656,
-0.0100693451,
-0.0420671366,
-0.0551148728,
-0.0108079407,
0.0915206894,
0.0031762999,
-0.0093406178,
-0.0269933604,
-0.0061314544,
-0.0089041842,
-0.0632525235,
0.0240648687,
-0.0074461708,
0.0389750823,
-0.0240972601,
-0.0157982837,
0.0593845844,
0.0294019207,
-0.0402178913,
-0.0244143996,
0.074706696,
-0.0236494206,
-0.0376628973,
-0.0140944663,
0.0043854509,
-0.0637190714,
0.0108517762,
0.0193705205,
0.0538601354,
0.0459911674,
0.0190043394,
0.034932822,
0.0203779414,
0.0229036454,
-0.0413220413,
-0.0353679024,
0.0291189905,
0.0177273639,
0.0206885077,
0.0371691436,
-0.007147213,
0.0316739455,
-0.0219414756,
-0.0238474142,
-0.0158398151,
-0.0084285764,
-0.0553764924,
0.0106053762,
0.0023905993,
-0.0198161341,
0.0758506283,
0.0362218693,
-0.0080981022,
0.0012818241,
-0.0034311188,
-0.0254021734,
0.0027426158,
-0.0564031675,
-0.0039161043,
-0.0303863063,
-0.0041799988,
-0.0094893081,
0.0006687441,
0.0235086605,
0.0063574887,
-0.0108737973,
-0.0272385571,
0.0247511398,
-0.1405617148,
-0.0039416607,
-0.0030746569,
-0.0160579924,
0.0261847135,
0.0481407233,
-0.0072659557,
-0.0489144847,
-0.0013769756,
0.0259424765,
0.0015050239,
0.026720237,
0.0193797853,
0.0443655476,
0.0239493381,
0.0015125587,
0.0124644181,
-0.0660087839,
0.0494134575,
-0.0046680565,
-0.0182927959,
0.0115012927,
-0.0809887126,
-0.0566629507,
0.0091280006,
0.0232110471,
-0.0125843668,
-0.023162635,
-0.0413142666,
0.031420067,
0.0343814343,
-0.02244181,
0.0409754775,
0.033004418,
-0.0124200266,
-0.0158901457,
0.0202642903,
-0.0399771892,
-0.0029789808,
0.0072757341,
-0.05773459,
-0.0242815353,
0.0527098253,
0.046114929,
0.0383353084,
-0.0038846971,
0.0135836732,
-0.018927848,
0.0322555937,
-0.0715892985,
0.0734995604,
-0.0307952445,
0.042174086,
0.0006611951,
-0.0209558886,
0.0559929386,
0.0152836526,
0.0549998917,
-0.0222515073,
-0.0594786517,
-0.0307697244,
-0.0082516214,
-0.0032657899,
0.0328695141,
-0.0254363529,
0.0141130732,
0.0120136691,
0.0022985707,
-0.0301128831,
-0.0581663363,
0.0191790536,
-0.0247566197,
-0.0174582526,
0.0127359498,
-0.0317616947,
-0.0068685533,
0.0000564376,
-0.0595021732,
0.0085668946,
-0.0510501452,
0.0454616919,
-0.0351931006,
0.0109960362,
-0.024091946,
0.061853461,
0.0194484629,
-0.0139561957,
0.0334455855,
0.0155525515,
0.0545473695,
-0.0033576461,
-0.0381573997,
-0.0237887427,
0.0425343923,
0.039738629,
-0.0065435097,
0.0163991582,
-0.0388669036,
0.0424469896,
-0.0032236585,
0.0099503864,
-0.024838686,
0.0599295311,
0.0107114026,
-0.0541534759,
0.0614897385,
0.0675610676,
0.0001159903,
-0.0532887392,
0.0114470087,
-0.0046321834,
-0.0327150039,
-0.0076407716,
-0.0098147681,
-0.0723430738,
-0.0590632744,
-0.0036443896,
0.0110880937,
-0.0065961243,
-0.0277620461,
0.0389967486,
0.0180235654,
0.0214920081,
-0.003264247,
-0.0311994944,
-0.0207052287,
-0.0378070921,
0.0292602871,
-0.0300831217,
-0.023223104,
-0.0380704626,
-0.0137924794,
-0.0235740151,
-0.0019707542,
-0.1160961017,
-0.0611282513,
0.0282019936,
-0.004590096,
-0.0111390715,
0.0793213248,
0.0535249226,
-0.0176622383,
-0.033251103,
-0.0077151875,
0.0410546176,
0.0422160253,
-0.060677167,
0.0520031676,
0.0198732018,
0.0093245916,
-0.0570106134,
0.0550966635,
-0.0262792017,
0.0023582743,
0.0226715636,
0.1148285717,
-0.030745469,
-0.0272182804,
-0.0788402855,
-0.0241199285,
0.0600740463,
0.0140745696,
-0.0196879618,
-0.075633876,
-0.0473860279,
0.0100318752,
0.0345559269,
0.0527322814,
-0.0045455461,
0.0277595297,
-0.030965697,
-0.0446279049,
-0.0313386656,
-0.0082874186,
0.0145103168,
-0.0409801267,
0.0245818887,
0.0555013642,
0.0412272885,
0.0259956699,
-0.0472258627,
0.0095907748,
0.0502090715,
0.0577076636,
-0.0571266189,
-0.0110962922,
0.0429659486,
-0.0463460088,
0.019011179,
-0.0088486727,
-0.0544640273,
0.0335374884,
-0.0133999363,
0.0586158261,
0.0148296859,
-0.0202076808,
0.0107331751,
-0.0252140574,
0.012073976,
0.0109752733,
-0.037236657,
-0.0223659314,
-0.0237706006,
0.0010610677,
-0.0160378851,
-0.0067058452,
-0.0247760639,
0.0019552007,
-0.0179175865,
-0.0123622091,
-0.0212758444,
-0.0201454777,
0.0152898263,
0.0432234444,
0.0762950256,
-0.0170203745,
-0.0557433031,
0.0058077271,
0.0366120413,
-0.0062170373,
-0.0001906944,
-0.0271243565,
0.0136389509,
-0.0185161382,
0.0281332359,
-0.0016262489,
-0.0153259253,
0.0276091918,
-0.071098946,
-0.0659193993,
0.1026349813,
0.0184827577,
0.0038186943,
0.0474079624,
0.0076330239,
0.0230599623,
0.0381328017,
-0.0100027481,
0.0001789304,
-0.0187418181,
0.0766709074,
-0.0425990038,
0.0153507562,
-0.0029180518,
0.0593837276,
0.0118623814,
-0.030468449,
-0.0136866206,
0.0317011513,
0.0410244316,
0.0286301859,
0.0138506694,
-0.0239157435,
0.0084543768,
-0.0597642586,
0.0262493379,
-0.0099113155,
-0.0036075143,
0.0660274774,
-0.0165453162,
-0.016236769,
-0.0196845718,
0.0672524422,
0.0090156449,
0.0292395465,
0.0091013247,
-0.0537161008,
-0.0452564955,
0.0358718112,
0.0888553485,
0.0212690011,
-0.0842134431,
-0.0031033088,
-0.0304109231,
-0.076769121,
0.0629572719,
-0.0253073107,
-0.0272292029,
-0.0245184619,
0.0181870647,
0.0389981531,
-0.0011746143,
0.0141809676,
-0.0474887453,
0.0268675629,
-0.0643186942,
-0.007881579,
0.0030849583,
-6.255163967e-33,
0.0298932754,
-0.0227635149,
0.0086105932,
-0.0373248793,
0.0325947702,
0.004732816,
-0.0210984554,
0.0054365592,
0.0260168798,
0.0073252153,
0.0111053409,
-0.0455717295,
0.0084834155,
0.0419822931,
0.0142742405,
-0.0378712267,
0.0129305581,
0.0186265726,
0.0076516708,
0.0066917469,
-0.0054638679,
0.0442052558,
-0.0016113927,
-0.0899773687,
-0.0382476151,
0.0257889703,
-0.0278598983,
0.0030439056,
-0.0318808146,
0.0774253383,
-0.0361325927,
0.0807349011,
0.0483530052,
-0.011715713,
0.0015146759,
0.0316162147,
-0.0633951277,
-0.0302138887,
-0.02673853,
-0.0019128511,
-0.0376966484,
-0.0331185199,
0.0416199192,
-0.0316052884,
-0.0326266214,
0.003412341,
0.0552369095,
-0.0542231426,
-0.0145103987,
-0.0553100556,
0.0262154769,
0.0267419349,
0.0003218086,
0.0227114372,
-0.0038472102,
0.0216162242,
-0.0296876431,
-0.0038611139,
-0.0624775887,
0.0011650944,
-0.0265841782,
-0.0154752573,
-0.0104906308,
-0.0089878831,
-0.0260917414,
0.0467277542,
0.0092429109,
-0.079550378,
-0.0268284604,
0.0265465397,
-0.0548691079,
0.0622158684,
0.0017805611,
0.0260236952,
0.0045123431,
-0.0487642325,
-0.0870495811,
0.0666209161,
-0.0304430071,
0.0084882835,
0.020059675,
-0.0172988623,
-0.0253440831,
0.0093262037,
-0.0241715331,
0.0240141973,
-0.0557100736,
-0.0432617627,
0.0342155918,
0.0120621985,
0.0392237343,
0.0170640945,
0.0201667808,
-0.0286778267,
-0.0370223001,
0.0120548606,
0.0344656073,
-0.0043863016,
-0.0130802067,
0.0132514834,
-0.0177021846,
-0.0011202566,
-0.0255543124,
-0.0122442637,
0.0463157929,
0.0036312919,
0.0183580667,
0.0076526636,
-0.0516001061,
-0.006182909,
0.0469514355,
0.0024642379,
-0.0025491004,
0.014389853,
0.0472973809,
-0.0127326418,
-0.0103763957,
0.092125535,
0.0028941424,
0.0296970103,
-0.0752333701,
-0.0628825426,
0.0075676693,
-0.018621264,
-0.0515211821,
-0.0042329999,
-0.0746605247,
-0.000824898,
0.0190772153,
-0.0570211336,
-0.0084534418,
0.0034752074,
2.915e-7,
0.0451162569,
0.0489339903,
-0.0549967438,
-0.0350021012,
0.0507118553,
0.0174769256,
-0.0304403864,
0.0044411672,
0.0034982166,
0.0036092694,
0.0425951295,
-0.0083710346,
0.0417690165,
0.0497654267,
-0.0086345095,
-0.0089391461,
-0.0485891588,
0.0165059268,
-0.0359885544,
0.0564473905,
0.0575483255,
0.084021613,
-0.0206630453,
-0.0404542871,
0.0470031202,
0.0456312113,
0.0269196443,
-0.0319448262,
0.0082322266,
-0.0240108781,
0.0030082322,
0.0112358546,
0.0236666873,
0.0209109932,
-0.0327487625,
-0.0426436141,
0.0065956921,
0.0644153804,
-0.063319765,
0.0341794901,
0.0397028737,
0.0019229861,
0.0197320096,
-0.0190123878,
0.0986128375,
-0.0069391541,
-0.0524650551,
-0.0190332681,
0.0006583582,
0.009098717,
0.0338397436,
-0.0127609065,
-0.0488320589,
0.0102678081,
0.0302790701,
0.0357052572,
-0.009155984,
-0.0345263369,
-0.0345324203,
0.0334925316,
-0.0065406803,
-0.0361333974,
0.013567782,
-0.0462416336,
0.0109151695,
-0.0960728973,
0.0089720972,
2.510465173e-34,
0.0166831985,
0.050273072,
-0.0054398263,
-0.00203949,
0.0290638655,
-0.0375955701,
0.0513047874,
-0.0070815329,
0.0017303627,
-0.0550935268,
-0.0498853773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18085v1 | Multilingual Knowledge Graph Completion from Pretrained Language Models with Knowledge Constraints | 2024-06-26T05:46:35 | 2024-06-26T05:46:35 | Ran Song, Shizhu He, Shengxiang Gao, Li Cai, Kang Liu, Zhengtao Yu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual Knowledge Graph Completion (mKGC) aim at solving queries like
(h, r, ?) in different languages by reasoning a tail entity t thus improving
multilingual knowledge graphs. Previous studies leverage multilingual
pretrained language models (PLMs) and the generative paradigm to achieve mKGC.
Although multilingual pretrained language models contain extensive knowledge of
different languages, its pretraining tasks cannot be directly aligned with the
mKGC tasks. Moreover, the majority of KGs and PLMs currently available exhibit
a pronounced English-centric bias. This makes it difficult for mKGC to achieve
good results, particularly in the context of low-resource languages. To
overcome previous problems, this paper introduces global and local knowledge
constraints for mKGC. The former is used to constrain the reasoning of answer
entities, while the latter is used to enhance the representation of query
contexts. The proposed method makes the pretrained model better adapt to the
mKGC task. Experimental results on public datasets demonstrate that our method
outperforms the previous SOTA on Hits@1 and Hits@10 by an average of 12.32% and
16.03%, which indicates that our proposed method has significant enhancement on
mKGC. | [
0.0349740162,
0.0532990098,
-0.0066379928,
0.0490576178,
-0.0209718011,
0.0038852373,
-0.0274775252,
0.0042125848,
0.0645103753,
-0.0043914435,
-0.0102475537,
-0.0177923907,
-0.032090269,
-0.0026482877,
0.0283547267,
-0.0203196462,
0.0326710828,
-0.006780169,
-0.0157916024,
-0.0782895535,
0.0099770427,
0.0608415827,
0.0024265447,
-0.0050580576,
-0.0093407817,
-0.0170939974,
0.0197430812,
0.0068736095,
-0.0066484483,
0.0236618258,
0.0036282963,
0.0485677235,
-0.0151965758,
-0.0212497991,
0.0000020955,
-0.0495357774,
-0.030608017,
-0.0137691488,
-0.0098914672,
-0.0386386663,
-0.0227538552,
-0.0202017538,
0.047557611,
0.0139258048,
-0.0465896204,
-0.0109172091,
0.020573454,
0.0172992051,
0.0195273105,
0.0335325785,
-0.0076100915,
-0.0251571909,
0.0006902188,
-0.0358927399,
0.0284394585,
-0.0614462197,
0.0325913578,
0.0334979147,
0.0190871432,
-0.0378740616,
-0.0348534957,
0.0435617045,
0.0119278328,
0.0129039176,
-0.02664092,
0.0070986045,
-0.0157252941,
0.0050113942,
0.0503958277,
0.0645901263,
-0.024264086,
-0.0061333068,
-0.0149283204,
0.008594743,
-0.0251626577,
0.0155915758,
-0.0151056619,
-0.0186854079,
-0.029718155,
0.0030663675,
-0.0116682136,
-0.0271218922,
0.0327781215,
-0.0063890941,
-0.0542298704,
0.1073396206,
0.0276048761,
-0.0072017959,
0.0194850843,
0.0317344405,
-0.0155743109,
-0.0343286097,
0.0144685097,
0.0150720375,
-0.0407751724,
0.0588528737,
-0.0169465318,
-0.0173566062,
0.023682652,
-0.0454554074,
-0.0585674457,
0.0246687066,
-0.0095021417,
0.0724766776,
-0.0286084358,
0.0113231009,
-0.0113630686,
0.0043311557,
-0.0617361963,
-0.0769086853,
-0.0282944813,
-0.0149090486,
-0.0493196771,
0.0148503883,
-0.0487422086,
0.0086339042,
-0.0412069708,
0.0144321145,
0.0012802059,
0.0206999239,
0.0279265959,
-0.0000139592,
-0.0190521311,
-0.0409647003,
-0.0334364884,
0.0472030155,
-0.0509135164,
-0.0003384243,
-0.0492150113,
-0.0208970532,
0.0065619894,
0.0063171727,
0.0229435097,
-0.05213416,
0.0330552161,
0.0376267321,
-0.0137336804,
0.0013188586,
-0.0658494681,
-0.0280597694,
0.0121124005,
-0.0597241074,
-0.0133926477,
-0.0635003299,
0.0971385464,
0.0349890217,
0.0023326911,
-0.0362643711,
0.0075982432,
-0.0076530413,
-0.0529282615,
0.069879286,
-0.0211148337,
0.0199746955,
0.0069157542,
-0.0113806296,
0.0053208373,
0.0880841315,
-0.0039061306,
-0.0078125857,
0.0741216317,
-0.0138889421,
-0.0235187225,
0.0540807843,
0.0555519871,
0.0170087107,
0.0131874951,
0.0271342229,
-0.0159804113,
-0.0087584807,
0.0265586097,
0.039434351,
-0.0186813045,
-0.0030538749,
-0.0073402277,
0.0039163926,
0.0164570417,
0.0163326189,
0.0308328103,
-0.0236482918,
-0.0256932545,
0.0207333509,
-0.0150111364,
-0.0071030683,
-0.0385546647,
0.0301728193,
0.0065343762,
0.0483242907,
-0.0299414545,
-0.0210068915,
0.0315845683,
-0.0220457204,
-0.0037841396,
0.0692328662,
0.1067611948,
0.0107366135,
-0.0228170417,
0.0484333485,
0.0382713489,
-0.0333967023,
0.061226435,
0.0217367392,
0.0027201842,
0.0463138483,
0.0332356617,
-0.0331035145,
-0.0532476082,
0.0255167093,
-0.0171997473,
0.0079165958,
0.0106693981,
-0.0288981702,
0.0092208423,
-0.0424164534,
-0.0470230207,
0.0289222337,
-0.0238253381,
0.0364281945,
0.0300382935,
0.0493850857,
0.0171743464,
-0.118812941,
0.0077314861,
-0.0041931355,
-0.0410678051,
0.025270706,
0.0133366333,
0.0341742225,
-0.0101987552,
0.036473792,
0.0186171047,
0.0114934025,
0.0074775685,
-0.0354780778,
-0.0222659428,
0.0148956534,
-0.0049985345,
-0.0611703321,
0.0441695303,
-0.0209793597,
-0.0019538116,
-0.0360083692,
-0.013319918,
-0.0624751374,
0.009246991,
0.018254336,
0.0690114349,
-0.0501006544,
0.0053801145,
0.0101035312,
-0.0290150382,
-0.0172193721,
0.0772388354,
0.0132401735,
0.0534531176,
-0.0035228198,
-0.0469488427,
0.0608909018,
-0.0235913098,
-0.0509389974,
0.0312908255,
0.0200661197,
0.0087645873,
0.0490529165,
-0.0030199406,
-0.0518483147,
0.031118067,
-0.0991975293,
-0.0104346536,
-0.0056535844,
0.0219500139,
-0.0237296838,
0.0418726131,
-0.0129092401,
-0.0465638041,
-0.0588370152,
-0.0160751957,
0.0308969934,
0.0371374264,
0.001082996,
0.0084089031,
0.014299552,
-0.0165581573,
-0.0274253692,
-0.0011665098,
0.0365778171,
-0.0232212916,
-0.0209470429,
-0.0130452467,
0.0465558618,
-0.0748832375,
0.0585561395,
-0.0246697739,
-0.0008355213,
-0.0092228865,
-0.0220484454,
0.0509155616,
0.003854332,
-0.0352318734,
-0.0580407716,
0.0316420309,
-0.010056234,
-0.0589306466,
0.0308253597,
-0.0487652719,
-0.0250212625,
-0.0361059457,
-0.0237676557,
-0.0101536363,
0.0161212645,
0.0050563491,
-0.0607752204,
-0.0817093924,
-0.0375119634,
-0.0038149231,
0.0012634834,
-0.0623532683,
0.0355964191,
0.0484654345,
0.0560654588,
-0.020718094,
0.0056411368,
0.0913973972,
-0.0134570636,
-0.0069274888,
-0.0112002352,
0.0294669643,
-0.0294052809,
0.0487308428,
0.0171823855,
0.0494058691,
-0.0035251954,
-0.0373045839,
-0.0556426384,
0.0085212896,
0.0343060568,
-0.0155062331,
-0.0003693409,
-0.0035192845,
0.0096791657,
0.0214017853,
-0.0142756347,
-0.016422702,
0.011432901,
-0.0138930911,
-0.0021480168,
0.0339511298,
0.001173977,
0.0126638077,
0.0145994537,
0.0321456753,
-0.0106741637,
0.0043678568,
0.0150748286,
-0.0164431706,
0.0170451179,
0.0565425716,
-0.0163555201,
-0.0259772521,
-0.0135932956,
-0.0057537742,
0.0249777641,
0.0416746363,
-0.0779228732,
0.0433885865,
0.017483307,
0.0638986081,
-0.0417973101,
-0.0436115488,
-0.0270598624,
0.007657344,
0.0085455067,
0.0374259204,
0.0803328827,
0.0131961592,
-0.0270971935,
-0.0145512205,
-0.0127620073,
0.0123858349,
0.0418216661,
0.063210845,
-0.1204875112,
0.0084995739,
-0.0301922653,
0.0118541159,
0.0460818149,
-0.0543271825,
-0.012371351,
-0.1227808446,
-0.0199166238,
0.000103204,
-0.0502054505,
-0.0506220981,
-0.0270957053,
-0.0244496651,
-0.0134504391,
-0.0278069898,
0.0006734038,
0.032309927,
0.0070077227,
0.0035885589,
-0.0103672491,
-0.0390328504,
0.0311484281,
-0.0501674451,
-0.0065763053,
0.0166611355,
0.0306380782,
-0.0019954776,
0.0011898878,
-0.0227164235,
0.0028378002,
-0.0176839791,
-0.0142139057,
-0.0004261185,
-0.0114249066,
-0.0296241958,
0.0233583786,
-0.0126556074,
-0.0463041775,
0.0044540996,
0.0330702551,
0.1185687333,
0.0284527261,
-0.0197583456,
0.0040181703,
-0.0293708816,
-0.0009064756,
0.0603931472,
0.0018010895,
0.0003383272,
-0.0123134498,
-0.0276326612,
0.0392116904,
-0.0458787568,
0.0223275106,
0.0475841314,
-0.0508951396,
0.0101131415,
-0.032603085,
-0.0588654988,
0.0702436119,
0.020507399,
0.0101075349,
0.0508431457,
0.0241949745,
-0.0116225947,
-0.0225504413,
-0.0090884594,
-0.0465949178,
-0.0021004498,
-0.0390368439,
-0.0094783455,
0.0146095315,
-0.0365180448,
-0.0139185535,
-0.0264459588,
-0.0143916467,
-0.0550218821,
-0.0696898177,
0.0380873792,
0.009148228,
0.0564109199,
-0.0633672997,
-0.0537010208,
0.0026703903,
0.0219549425,
-0.0341186784,
-0.0232662987,
0.0269423667,
-0.0170643087,
-0.0123545136,
0.0524557754,
-0.0603916757,
0.0098380856,
0.0026882384,
0.0891207978,
-0.0487664677,
-0.0456990227,
0.0414617173,
0.0539470166,
-0.001283795,
-0.0337659866,
0.002155599,
-0.0601475202,
0.018456934,
-0.0458933637,
-0.0414146557,
-0.0298373904,
-0.0165438764,
0.0250697732,
-0.0343980342,
0.018359093,
-0.0504548289,
-0.0101776244,
0.0106954388,
-0.0278006513,
-0.0264059901,
0.0404067412,
-0.0152809294,
0.0772735104,
0.0104955649,
0.0059340713,
0.0256129708,
0.0309697147,
0.0268087685,
-0.0408263393,
0.0201513227,
0.0061861146,
-0.0167141967,
-0.014125485,
-0.0381353013,
0.0022264353,
-0.0249940492,
-0.0135126375,
0.0272949133,
0.1060412228,
-0.0047782976,
0.0296749882,
0.0007424967,
-0.0166602917,
-0.0067950008,
0.0350318514,
0.0490367264,
-0.0467612371,
0.033207681,
0.0174380466,
-0.0126419682,
0.0333596207,
0.1049819216,
0.0186093077,
0.0531376638,
-0.011466397,
-0.0430725627,
-0.0181761216,
-0.0381678976,
-0.0035263631,
0.0238676146,
-0.0450468883,
0.0432758778,
-0.0297999326,
-0.1151566878,
-0.008630733,
-0.0111285159,
-0.0596453249,
0.026396744,
0.0263526589,
0.0854268447,
0.0313847326,
-0.0406998284,
-0.054138381,
0.018697679,
-0.0259185228,
-0.0001421582,
0.0543057323,
-6.050193017e-33,
-0.0112870885,
-0.0214096494,
0.0354948565,
-0.0149877686,
0.0265157744,
-0.0179068018,
-0.0238292068,
-0.0077121006,
-0.05416888,
0.0075757816,
-0.0311459154,
-0.0113189593,
0.0117198806,
0.0283475183,
0.0024698572,
0.0110700866,
0.0044679348,
0.0191102643,
0.0419547334,
0.0206315834,
0.0470594689,
0.0522954911,
0.0923095345,
-0.03563907,
0.0459533967,
-0.0351662003,
-0.0012048102,
0.0499063469,
-0.0087126736,
0.0544862188,
-0.0132218767,
0.0613787174,
0.0227824468,
-0.0162556786,
-0.0035841027,
-0.0350886807,
-0.1030372977,
-0.0676927865,
0.0498542041,
0.0381526239,
-0.027302118,
-0.0066391998,
0.0250837337,
-0.0330177173,
0.0526208915,
0.0143221403,
0.0391539149,
-0.0108848494,
-0.0551600978,
-0.0566191822,
-0.0350766145,
0.0194236096,
0.013386325,
0.0246674716,
0.0274384189,
0.0682310984,
0.009499263,
-0.0254801735,
-0.0403310917,
0.0369030647,
0.0065263221,
0.0042739259,
0.0466133878,
0.0012358392,
0.0114708804,
-0.0169684887,
-0.0044010524,
-0.010370018,
-0.0094013326,
0.0393044576,
0.0174088757,
0.0329232924,
-0.0075297724,
0.0655877963,
-0.0364536159,
-0.0241162442,
-0.0823298171,
0.0225293711,
-0.0192624107,
0.0250228103,
-0.0114283841,
-0.0190467015,
-0.0381626524,
-0.0752611309,
-0.049579531,
-0.0166434906,
-0.0371452607,
-0.0447047949,
0.0135155758,
-0.0144773684,
-0.0067843623,
-0.0154931899,
0.0126528386,
-0.0389319509,
-0.0312341936,
0.0629898459,
0.0136238486,
-0.0215613116,
0.0023095121,
0.08742439,
-0.0416407995,
-0.0127713466,
-0.0203029346,
-0.0661217794,
-0.0277087353,
0.0307815392,
-0.0014870769,
0.0064155734,
-0.0133676017,
0.0058881431,
-0.0305989403,
-0.0010191349,
-0.026093347,
-0.0110649159,
0.048913043,
0.0298067648,
0.0159236751,
0.0342183411,
0.0706083551,
0.0108887516,
-0.0242243521,
-0.007362558,
0.0255014412,
0.0307778083,
-0.0095583098,
-0.0046456987,
-0.0095082317,
-0.0195015762,
0.023457367,
-0.0024386432,
-0.0023333484,
0.0137743773,
2.789e-7,
0.0638517663,
-0.007637402,
0.0056281458,
0.0594259836,
-0.0310088415,
0.0064895782,
0.0031495893,
-0.0018708995,
0.0214295574,
0.001713015,
0.036036022,
0.0007272534,
-0.0049557663,
0.0630613938,
-0.0917111337,
-0.0044757682,
0.0101790065,
-0.017504897,
-0.0423787534,
-0.0030114255,
0.0376700498,
0.0248802882,
0.0207151882,
0.0116788,
-0.0505203716,
-0.0559968837,
0.0688791871,
-0.0021693453,
-0.0483097471,
0.0478205234,
0.0337736011,
0.0391662195,
0.0184253454,
0.0700895563,
-0.0328594856,
0.0176624116,
0.0501450449,
0.03327398,
0.0076082447,
-0.0305155199,
0.0139323948,
-0.0210311878,
0.0047864881,
-0.0694415048,
0.0939708799,
0.0068075913,
0.0250456668,
0.0616995357,
-0.0271456297,
-0.0165904611,
0.0151889063,
-0.0326595232,
-0.0355139114,
-0.010882169,
0.0453190766,
0.0139737092,
-0.0080354484,
-0.0550016463,
0.0054923403,
0.0407043286,
-0.0091925738,
-0.0237102378,
0.0260705519,
-0.0349688567,
-0.0190747418,
-0.022045264,
0.0250083376,
2.368350432e-34,
0.0292665306,
0.0148844272,
0.0079023158,
0.0111244032,
0.0483023748,
-0.0412508808,
-0.0419603735,
0.0244580787,
0.0211398285,
-0.0732032359,
-0.0498618893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18082v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18082v1 | Octo-planner: On-device Language Model for Planner-Action Agents | 2024-06-26T05:40:10 | 2024-06-26T05:40:10 | Wei Chen, Zhiyuan Li, Zhen Guo, Yikang Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | AI agents have become increasingly significant in various domains, enabling
autonomous decision-making and problem-solving. To function effectively, these
agents require a planning process that determines the best course of action and
then executes the planned actions. In this paper, we present an efficient
on-device Planner-Action framework that separates planning and action execution
into two distinct components: a planner agent based on Phi-3 Mini, a 3.8
billion parameter LLM optimized for edge devices, and an action agent using the
Octopus model for function execution. The planner agent first responds to user
queries by decomposing tasks into a sequence of sub-steps, which are then
executed by the action agent. To optimize performance on resource-constrained
devices, we employ model fine-tuning instead of in-context learning, reducing
computational costs and energy consumption while improving response times. Our
approach involves using GPT-4 to generate diverse planning queries and
responses based on available functions, with subsequent validations to ensure
data quality. We fine-tune the Phi-3 Mini model on this curated dataset,
achieving a 97\% success rate in our in-domain test environment. To address
multi-domain planning challenges, we developed a multi-LoRA training method
that merges weights from LoRAs trained on distinct function subsets. This
approach enables flexible handling of complex, multi-domain queries while
maintaining computational efficiency on resource-constrained devices. To
support further research, we have open-sourced our model weights at
\url{https://huggingface.co/NexaAIDev/octopus-planning}. For the demo, please
refer to \url{https://www.nexa4ai.com/octo-planner}. | [
0.0264776852,
-0.0079461746,
-0.00622751,
-0.0298971683,
-0.013813301,
-0.0038048637,
0.0347915255,
-0.0178565253,
0.0226947907,
-0.034507025,
-0.0328278318,
-0.0028891487,
-0.0246406794,
0.0449838899,
-0.0049496796,
-0.0288686231,
0.0251017679,
-0.0022547839,
0.004754723,
-0.0082420548,
-0.0118044233,
-0.0010042564,
0.0179650467,
0.0547613762,
0.0010865377,
0.0050190664,
-0.053201735,
0.0420856588,
0.0177546423,
-0.04045498,
0.0167460237,
0.0139630325,
0.0340750031,
0.0218974259,
0.0000021932,
-0.0375405401,
-0.0455953255,
-0.0248884168,
-0.0009219258,
-0.0526607148,
0.0196819529,
-0.0168854073,
-0.0055096475,
0.0539219342,
-0.0758883953,
0.0180725884,
0.0119723752,
0.0460640416,
0.0253705643,
0.0969111398,
-0.0103668543,
-0.0023312496,
0.0138240373,
-0.0163440686,
-0.0207110383,
-0.0503279902,
-0.0286923405,
-0.0577487573,
0.0153292669,
-0.024618607,
0.026888309,
-0.0143566886,
0.0448863506,
0.0533123873,
-0.0473229736,
0.0005358486,
-0.0198943578,
-0.0293945372,
-0.0311984383,
0.0308032669,
-0.0476470776,
-0.0071096774,
0.0690247267,
0.0013034671,
-0.0329590961,
-0.0245677065,
-0.0103018032,
-0.019656362,
-0.0140412645,
-0.0142023768,
-0.0180670936,
-0.0358476713,
0.0266209729,
0.0053482535,
-0.0255944896,
0.0992539003,
-0.0103590311,
-0.0123572042,
0.0081166578,
-0.0311312675,
0.0014499121,
-0.0669741407,
0.0291942023,
0.0873601288,
-0.0780168995,
-0.0044215452,
-0.0393590666,
0.0053213867,
-0.0127161043,
-0.0296726916,
0.0671341494,
0.0374198519,
0.037961524,
-0.003975383,
-0.0066301613,
0.0383888297,
0.0008322357,
0.0185570512,
-0.0404874682,
0.0317991115,
-0.0426954105,
0.031330198,
-0.0292858686,
0.0486864336,
-0.0637522265,
-0.0277531631,
-0.0168417804,
0.0129298903,
0.0037633344,
0.0166280996,
0.0143073592,
0.0218773335,
-0.0036095241,
-0.0279084947,
-0.046982035,
-0.0187005792,
-0.0360212587,
0.0588790402,
-0.0049270471,
-0.0496880896,
-0.0000052677,
0.0097600631,
-0.0114878798,
0.0016857293,
-0.0004596035,
0.0772570819,
-0.0126566403,
-0.05447229,
-0.0399161838,
-0.0670689344,
0.0412502028,
-0.0978202447,
0.0252161995,
-0.0488260463,
0.032996878,
-0.04218667,
-0.0135959983,
-0.0216264464,
0.0244592167,
0.0275388472,
0.0436586104,
0.0281755254,
-0.0089461859,
0.0278856624,
0.03267546,
0.0068254862,
0.0046390002,
0.0739231706,
0.0681904703,
0.0519359633,
-0.0174672306,
0.0100811245,
-0.0109540457,
0.0345012844,
0.0080720643,
-0.0203492101,
0.0517412461,
0.0051416652,
-0.0061726929,
0.0391560346,
-0.0230398551,
-0.0038968043,
-0.0163924675,
0.0184958,
0.0352323465,
0.0216975082,
0.0252819993,
-0.0057205246,
0.0200205166,
0.0103586689,
-0.009750098,
-0.070917584,
-0.0728173256,
0.0361586548,
-0.0134575218,
0.0121476343,
-0.0159133729,
0.0281111337,
-0.0173804406,
-0.0475246459,
-0.0121437609,
-0.0262319334,
-0.0051923124,
0.035079658,
0.0101804761,
0.0008366777,
-0.0912872553,
0.0233707186,
-0.0154050533,
-0.0321342945,
-0.0386187173,
-0.0692011267,
0.0488058627,
0.0757977888,
0.0187125001,
-0.0393645354,
-0.0782057568,
0.0099997772,
0.0290416311,
0.0174666122,
-0.000024239,
-0.0156810265,
0.0360821374,
-0.0496046543,
-0.0486197807,
0.0061862865,
0.0164703876,
0.0164526235,
0.0434346311,
0.0231245998,
-0.0139564341,
-0.0125488397,
-0.0132973557,
0.0178330857,
-0.0160750374,
-0.0546735823,
0.02082281,
0.0338170826,
0.0321542248,
-0.0034406465,
0.0022768967,
-0.0195088368,
0.0477534309,
-0.0323736742,
0.0225938223,
-0.0310743805,
-0.0439648591,
0.0354081728,
0.0399640165,
0.0172113925,
0.0191959143,
0.0480799004,
-0.040649008,
-0.0620719567,
-0.0077620302,
0.0051278993,
0.041713845,
0.0092659695,
0.0154508017,
0.0404692553,
-0.0166833661,
0.0087365732,
0.0352224298,
0.0156007847,
-0.0325894952,
0.0060236347,
0.0288739353,
0.026191581,
-0.0296278689,
0.0380302444,
-0.0168548487,
-0.0162420701,
0.0232960582,
0.015373067,
0.0519357249,
0.0031460272,
-0.0506373532,
-0.1046575382,
0.0227007754,
-0.065262951,
-0.0016454076,
0.0005823501,
0.037770316,
0.0073969057,
-0.0270252563,
0.0105935829,
0.0516497009,
-0.0179866403,
0.0276535433,
-0.0338680185,
0.0191330016,
-0.0437500775,
-0.0411939472,
0.0168518517,
-0.0154641513,
-0.0130439689,
0.0023158011,
0.0128269149,
-0.0226586964,
0.0083504803,
-0.0432671905,
0.0231417324,
-0.0174843799,
-0.0287492014,
0.0420951881,
-0.0191788431,
-0.0030390103,
0.0521169193,
-0.0215749014,
-0.0097778039,
0.0666146651,
-0.0082459645,
-0.0578168891,
0.0523239635,
-0.0277494229,
-0.0251964629,
-0.0706527233,
0.0138715524,
0.0081358049,
0.0534457304,
-0.0290043503,
0.0239412654,
-0.0535221063,
-0.0352443978,
0.0307913814,
-0.0526660681,
0.0361146219,
0.0350225754,
-0.0246770382,
0.0670785978,
-0.0176932421,
-0.0224052705,
0.0249032788,
0.0156702902,
-0.001247767,
-0.0213515647,
-0.040923629,
-0.0265822429,
0.0748452693,
0.0036777032,
0.016692277,
0.0070665595,
-0.0190027878,
-0.0261654351,
-0.0121343322,
-0.0122985523,
-0.0311938394,
0.0351839885,
-0.0564367548,
0.007213878,
-0.0113175688,
-0.0779564157,
-0.0045607081,
0.0137204556,
-0.0381662212,
0.0225015916,
-0.0524043702,
-0.0335089713,
-0.0608281605,
-0.006934721,
-0.0163472351,
0.0879355073,
-0.018720476,
-0.0090845777,
-0.0348425247,
-0.0086192135,
0.052382715,
0.0721799135,
-0.0452063382,
0.030890502,
0.0281397663,
0.0059860316,
0.0821255594,
-0.0290765073,
-0.0643187836,
0.0585662015,
0.0495574437,
-0.0196559392,
-0.0064414456,
0.0775162354,
0.064036876,
-0.0559461527,
-0.0153552182,
0.0811363906,
0.0184234381,
-0.0279861707,
-0.0003522987,
-0.0378639325,
0.0477366149,
0.0292972531,
0.0582767613,
-0.0264285672,
-0.0615445822,
0.0119230496,
0.0196359474,
0.0196579285,
-0.0160150882,
-0.0161085371,
-0.0962906703,
0.0381409749,
-0.0046212338,
0.0142981475,
-0.0030303716,
-0.0464058481,
0.0049862703,
-0.0167448726,
0.0055693099,
0.0010163301,
0.0051554595,
-0.0199299976,
0.0002283883,
-0.0215294454,
-0.0108569395,
0.0380123071,
-0.0046113394,
-0.0063369321,
0.0884395018,
0.0219982099,
0.0202486478,
-0.005529149,
0.0310880393,
0.0543860085,
0.0221819449,
-0.0301881805,
-0.0306950957,
-0.0091994517,
0.0217330772,
0.0072584832,
0.0365116857,
-0.0329503305,
-0.0442930982,
0.0336903408,
0.0971687883,
-0.0129398853,
0.018901892,
-0.0271295216,
-0.0126249986,
0.0355293639,
-0.0049335477,
-0.0457732007,
-0.0195860062,
-0.0737339184,
-0.0071588648,
-0.0442461818,
-0.0363545567,
-0.008052595,
-0.0146905594,
-0.0055715577,
-0.0237705037,
-0.0364800282,
-0.0330775939,
0.0620614477,
0.0411644652,
0.0423097014,
-0.0389047116,
0.0088071013,
0.0664222762,
-0.0404829606,
-0.023289524,
0.0131432721,
0.0347394124,
-0.0458746329,
-0.0061007957,
0.0515220948,
-0.0499989018,
0.0134402923,
0.051169876,
-0.049698174,
-0.0513163283,
-0.0050860248,
0.0791876763,
0.0244494826,
0.0226704776,
-0.0113004539,
-0.0167519655,
0.0360246412,
0.0627362579,
-0.0593933165,
0.0438033864,
0.0267287064,
-0.0019267137,
0.0031809909,
0.0527645163,
-0.0942999721,
0.0160373077,
0.0034765413,
0.0520120747,
-0.0988138169,
-0.0299652461,
0.0187229067,
-0.0143562499,
0.0201737639,
-0.0125268921,
-0.025012143,
0.0072186082,
0.0510280542,
0.0201923233,
0.0170018356,
-0.0483774953,
0.0157283209,
-0.0447188802,
-0.0292561203,
0.0619924031,
0.0284045748,
0.0354284793,
-0.0411471613,
-0.0083808154,
0.0160383303,
0.0075952779,
0.0068322276,
0.0049467082,
0.0157261342,
-0.0006055622,
0.0301162526,
0.013008018,
0.0147638395,
-0.0227754954,
0.0123386895,
-0.0133069865,
0.0352594741,
-0.0467883982,
0.019911265,
-0.0376434997,
-0.103506662,
-0.0009035266,
0.0073642749,
0.0316772424,
0.0109326951,
0.0164038651,
-0.0498343743,
0.014167252,
-0.0254441779,
-0.01139504,
-0.0291513242,
0.0101156421,
0.0384441391,
0.0242148209,
0.0018716562,
-0.0215163212,
0.0524806231,
0.023097517,
0.0836546123,
0.0141002573,
0.0055144108,
-0.062410634,
-0.0624362119,
0.0412779599,
0.0515958443,
-0.0000330143,
-0.0332290307,
-0.0179844331,
-0.0274409018,
0.0211860016,
0.0086457394,
-0.007233642,
-0.0483302847,
0.0444117673,
0.0320971832,
-0.0154691599,
-0.0515380539,
-0.0190321896,
-0.0829264,
-0.0563989207,
-0.0068133278,
0.0082419794,
-5.830190065e-33,
-0.0110686794,
-0.0131678907,
0.0708522052,
-0.0322159491,
0.006205162,
-0.0221150126,
-0.0166237019,
-0.0053673941,
-0.0334828198,
-0.0142089948,
-0.0553187579,
0.0163784605,
0.0263239536,
0.0022901045,
0.0070111784,
-0.0011842871,
0.0392646007,
-0.0426855721,
-0.0407771505,
-0.0043822667,
0.0244451687,
0.0288075432,
-0.0055936016,
-0.0094522927,
-0.0525445938,
0.0274208207,
-0.0401064754,
0.0015002323,
-0.0446660519,
0.0383721553,
0.0055060731,
0.0012277014,
0.0160663407,
-0.0068333191,
-0.0121529941,
0.0327094533,
-0.0585011952,
-0.0602377541,
0.0119471699,
0.0249909181,
-0.0487901233,
-0.046073053,
0.0364243165,
0.0237053316,
-0.0677405,
-0.0044434643,
0.0367059633,
0.0123578645,
-0.0506939217,
-0.0204390846,
-0.0334437937,
0.0113938386,
0.0357430652,
-0.0469602868,
0.050046593,
0.0273000766,
-0.0218906309,
-0.0205069929,
-0.0542725287,
0.0284065045,
-0.0667303875,
0.0464828834,
0.0175961237,
0.0229295287,
-0.0061010993,
0.05074111,
0.0413183905,
-0.0054394836,
-0.0016415215,
0.0317188799,
-0.0196114574,
0.1138628051,
-0.0317578167,
0.0170754772,
-0.0033481466,
-0.032389909,
-0.0513649434,
0.0253376383,
0.007086758,
0.0359379016,
0.0108913556,
-0.0046486892,
-0.0230485331,
0.0170611031,
-0.0053246706,
0.0007152787,
-0.0267137624,
-0.0255418401,
0.0371720567,
0.0565355755,
0.0187132712,
-0.0191667397,
0.0359496586,
-0.0154241156,
0.0466209017,
-0.0123383664,
0.0076688956,
0.0347765759,
0.0178984255,
0.0373294204,
-0.0410984494,
-0.0625696778,
-0.0288432296,
-0.0040803528,
0.0369532593,
-0.0020366181,
-0.0145633593,
0.1006619707,
-0.0482902527,
-0.0114286961,
-0.0317448266,
0.0348135717,
0.0189720262,
0.0185139049,
0.05129629,
-0.0199463237,
0.0033984927,
0.0421092883,
-0.0530692972,
-0.0899900571,
0.0022593928,
-0.0009921638,
0.018499868,
0.0175024942,
-0.0249413047,
-0.0064460412,
-0.0852368623,
0.0142809488,
-0.0176289938,
-0.0111720944,
-0.019546343,
0.0636078268,
3.093e-7,
-0.0635147542,
0.0051243543,
-0.0466932878,
0.0462156907,
-0.0027402279,
0.0445016213,
0.0312095955,
0.0217256881,
-0.0238654688,
0.0055606063,
0.0184412785,
0.0326334201,
0.0328839347,
-0.0052626277,
-0.0846086219,
0.0117009012,
0.0254891012,
0.0082352925,
-0.0525064133,
0.0130423745,
0.0172422417,
0.0875332952,
0.0198981445,
-0.0118394773,
0.0346406735,
-0.006515502,
0.0087954253,
-0.0078514973,
0.0289163403,
-0.0059367726,
-0.0456995629,
0.0054308455,
-0.0554930307,
0.0019350634,
-0.0075181746,
0.0248340704,
-0.0308142342,
0.1014171988,
-0.014619194,
-0.0545680411,
0.0126664853,
-0.0364209861,
-0.0086581111,
-0.0296862051,
0.0461439751,
0.0434547737,
-0.0217524674,
0.0351475105,
0.0344490707,
-0.019638801,
-0.0210181922,
0.0086209886,
0.0224974882,
-0.0098497747,
-0.0077804169,
-0.0256534163,
-0.0069721192,
-0.0663465559,
0.0343238972,
0.0427815467,
-0.0128173856,
-0.0386489145,
-0.0628535151,
0.037552055,
0.0390415788,
-0.0667080134,
-0.0070551597,
2.871255614e-34,
-0.0095579987,
-0.0127337333,
0.013213261,
0.0789709166,
0.0145887025,
0.0245987792,
-0.0022592607,
0.02674409,
0.0509871468,
-0.0625177771,
-0.0281193797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18078v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18078v1 | Self-Training with Pseudo-Label Scorer for Aspect Sentiment Quad Prediction | 2024-06-26T05:30:21 | 2024-06-26T05:30:21 | Yice Zhang, Jie Zeng, Weiming Hu, Ziyi Wang, Shiwei Chen, Ruifeng Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Aspect Sentiment Quad Prediction (ASQP) aims to predict all quads (aspect
term, aspect category, opinion term, sentiment polarity) for a given review,
which is the most representative and challenging task in aspect-based sentiment
analysis. A key challenge in the ASQP task is the scarcity of labeled data,
which limits the performance of existing methods. To tackle this issue, we
propose a self-training framework with a pseudo-label scorer, wherein a scorer
assesses the match between reviews and their pseudo-labels, aiming to filter
out mismatches and thereby enhance the effectiveness of self-training. We
highlight two critical aspects to ensure the scorer's effectiveness and
reliability: the quality of the training dataset and its model architecture. To
this end, we create a human-annotated comparison dataset and train a generative
model on it using ranking-based objectives. Extensive experiments on public
ASQP datasets reveal that using our scorer can greatly and consistently improve
the effectiveness of self-training. Moreover, we explore the possibility of
replacing humans with large language models for comparison dataset annotation,
and experiments demonstrate its feasibility. We release our code and data at
https://github.com/HITSZ-HLT/ST-w-Scorer-ABSA . | [
0.0422653221,
0.0595722683,
0.0237011593,
0.032465063,
0.0167903025,
0.0061978763,
0.0052596345,
0.0012423585,
-0.0138576049,
-0.018879367,
-0.1055848449,
-0.0061939661,
-0.0445337892,
0.0576477274,
-0.0167377293,
0.0001210687,
0.0315147713,
0.0216851477,
0.0097491546,
-0.011519691,
0.0135789039,
0.0216412675,
0.0063019712,
0.0083876643,
-0.0281840917,
-0.0124060838,
0.0276558306,
0.0057278364,
0.0263148099,
-0.0282158367,
0.036520578,
0.0717884302,
-0.0048821177,
0.0241961759,
0.0000020307,
-0.012339442,
-0.0180421509,
-0.0254055317,
0.0401036516,
-0.0092133787,
0.0678401291,
-0.0075273761,
0.0257631131,
0.0141714336,
-0.0626992807,
-0.0846990868,
0.0245875493,
0.0835018158,
0.0456900336,
0.0565823466,
-0.0301335286,
-0.0357008092,
-0.0216805786,
-0.054034248,
-0.0095917163,
-0.0707109645,
-0.0040709106,
0.0186315831,
-0.0346367843,
0.0839476958,
0.0090790316,
-0.0053837947,
0.0303110611,
0.0009777889,
0.0325636715,
0.0269062724,
0.0156798102,
0.0345663354,
-0.0043008681,
0.0521790758,
0.042637907,
-0.0433583371,
0.0006771851,
-0.0132910563,
-0.0007999895,
0.0064684553,
0.0280842055,
-0.0264562201,
0.0107110888,
0.0475769565,
0.0497290418,
0.0553464368,
0.012608503,
0.0031476344,
0.0375483483,
0.0315482654,
-0.0136667928,
-0.0331139527,
0.0262107402,
0.0825556666,
0.0333446637,
-0.0471424572,
-0.0025945811,
-0.0171383284,
-0.019906668,
-0.0020857791,
-0.0153020388,
0.0362939909,
0.0134589057,
-0.0593392476,
0.0390451625,
-0.0274448358,
-0.0113985017,
0.0370157883,
0.0089452798,
-0.01047544,
0.0424561054,
0.0090400316,
-0.0511256047,
0.0404473543,
-0.0940198377,
0.0179662369,
-0.0100969365,
0.0282984041,
-0.0100963805,
0.035788279,
-0.0879222006,
-0.0234795865,
-0.0253532473,
-0.0031070923,
0.0607837029,
0.0032823775,
-0.0171645917,
0.0170662049,
-0.0329979807,
0.0313241892,
-0.0462625585,
0.0347106121,
-0.0475373752,
0.0170107782,
-0.0040608249,
-0.0015917334,
-0.0108915139,
-0.0349569768,
0.0206183773,
0.0183250699,
0.026737608,
-0.0399668254,
0.0136871804,
-0.0222945437,
-0.0179856159,
-0.0623498447,
-0.0292552691,
-0.0783536062,
0.0446127355,
-0.0238539148,
-0.0135283833,
-0.0150367804,
0.0112262191,
0.0182946697,
0.0101730106,
0.0600642003,
-0.0519475415,
-0.0229930505,
-0.0166466422,
0.0014570577,
0.0223048348,
0.0497879833,
-0.0418870635,
0.0067306585,
0.0152233317,
-0.0029562069,
0.0480912328,
-0.0046973783,
-0.0019025498,
0.0075775557,
0.0072059403,
-0.0059187566,
-0.0162023138,
0.0084745176,
0.0303892568,
0.0048361332,
-0.0066139093,
-0.0636623949,
0.0174484309,
-0.0234180931,
0.0088547794,
0.0699818209,
-0.0007662887,
-0.0004755136,
-0.0003282253,
-0.0054600085,
-0.0069143893,
0.0421466529,
-0.0193106961,
-0.0204701144,
0.0195483249,
-0.0085016349,
-0.0460577011,
-0.0716313571,
-0.0101736235,
-0.007174057,
-0.0252132956,
-0.0259417407,
0.0680926591,
0.0396923162,
-0.0264208913,
-0.0435536727,
0.0463383608,
-0.0359863862,
-0.031629242,
-0.0436525419,
0.0230175182,
0.0728832856,
0.0209862031,
-0.0420925468,
-0.023680523,
0.0007349947,
-0.0591607802,
0.0215665083,
0.0603536963,
-0.0437365733,
-0.0314178169,
-0.0116178114,
-0.0195386354,
-0.0114920735,
0.0012020866,
-0.0029234686,
0.0149088027,
0.0362501442,
-0.0174616054,
-0.0538820922,
-0.033038497,
0.0178106409,
0.008076991,
-0.038351316,
0.0463835523,
-0.0087343007,
0.0385831483,
0.0531579554,
-0.007350754,
-0.0062184855,
0.053647656,
-0.028818788,
-0.070174247,
0.0150496233,
-0.0360337123,
-0.0548265949,
0.0317809656,
-0.0033610903,
-0.0057544052,
0.0234636534,
-0.0659897476,
-0.0267595407,
0.0193060804,
0.0190346502,
0.0118779317,
-0.0363517702,
-0.0335589871,
0.0348317064,
-0.0267020352,
-0.0098522948,
0.0691522956,
-0.0054524099,
0.028478995,
-0.0828629211,
-0.0136917327,
-0.0033667614,
0.0292183515,
-0.0313057564,
-0.0061342618,
0.013999898,
0.0203887112,
0.0350817852,
0.0185604822,
-0.0253333822,
-0.0250313897,
-0.1138856113,
-0.0002747225,
0.0223461855,
0.024297744,
0.0489088148,
-0.0430713147,
0.0094349943,
0.0060460581,
-0.0411826931,
-0.0151294982,
-0.0161661096,
0.0048298002,
0.0335620567,
0.0364769921,
0.0441634096,
-0.0625649244,
-0.0238918681,
-0.0278718732,
0.0362419486,
0.0172194112,
-0.0014564166,
-0.0371680632,
0.0409112386,
-0.0287554655,
0.012024275,
0.0156405028,
-0.0272691958,
-0.0230381992,
0.0056689656,
-0.0147083551,
0.0117952479,
0.0158296451,
0.0145061407,
0.0415231809,
0.0160756279,
-0.0299120806,
0.0218127575,
-0.0600366332,
-0.0178443603,
-0.0130507089,
-0.0406082496,
-0.0115348343,
0.090400517,
-0.0073065255,
-0.0052618003,
-0.0512643829,
0.0368412808,
-0.0348918363,
-0.0180323552,
0.0057237749,
0.0223933291,
0.0197547972,
0.0073401956,
-0.0068756389,
0.0115857664,
0.0696220398,
0.0292071439,
0.0346962065,
-0.0644206107,
0.0183178429,
-0.0227369312,
0.0839392394,
-0.0408132747,
0.0160795283,
-0.0026121079,
0.0516868494,
0.0079582501,
-0.0460135713,
0.0012920514,
-0.0159255117,
0.0013811807,
-0.0021388507,
0.0276025217,
0.0133848544,
-0.0695085153,
0.010767499,
-0.0300308801,
-0.0569472648,
-0.0300562587,
-0.043366842,
-0.0001428772,
0.0311815813,
-0.004277864,
-0.0491957702,
0.0276949257,
-0.0275690537,
-0.0310307927,
0.0339417569,
0.0516763106,
0.0499630421,
-0.0723486394,
0.0091027543,
-0.027060762,
0.0045491196,
0.0512263738,
-0.0144621311,
0.0067942184,
-0.0026576072,
-0.0335898437,
0.0287057441,
0.0015029295,
-0.0100478977,
-0.0441732667,
0.0686792284,
-0.0422185212,
-0.028571628,
0.1158523709,
0.0457839817,
-0.062026307,
-0.014779401,
0.0214142632,
0.0011064969,
0.0426735096,
0.0291055329,
-0.0865515396,
-0.0305597093,
-0.035681244,
0.046973709,
-0.0066949809,
-0.0042350697,
0.0075400886,
-0.1030430123,
0.0256777406,
-0.0291042458,
-0.0524690449,
-0.0638263524,
-0.0416915417,
0.0081050843,
-0.0669238567,
-0.0359859765,
-0.0135095641,
0.0069037257,
0.0377499051,
-0.004210121,
-0.0101290969,
-0.0167838372,
0.0714009702,
-0.0173890684,
0.0545777641,
0.0411274247,
0.0446625277,
-0.0065019387,
-0.0478139594,
0.0263233613,
-0.0695869252,
-0.0062205507,
-0.0291514937,
0.0942813009,
-0.0401410609,
-0.0204420928,
-0.0108275386,
0.0281669069,
-0.0434155315,
0.0064704511,
0.009231437,
0.0072506871,
0.0209541675,
-0.0319955871,
-0.0000100018,
0.0307705384,
-0.0020576685,
0.0654572025,
-0.0157373212,
-0.0745690167,
-0.0165867861,
-0.0058021559,
0.0192910526,
-0.0691798776,
-0.0759335384,
-0.0247448906,
0.0120407324,
-0.0776337609,
-0.082952708,
-0.0492354706,
-0.0066796965,
0.0356418043,
-0.0167363845,
0.0127701238,
-0.0098396949,
-0.0025681665,
-0.0433806442,
0.0144900018,
-0.0212788433,
-0.0166292433,
-0.0049540112,
-0.0318636075,
0.1068059132,
-0.017855417,
-0.0178240631,
-0.0012679311,
-0.0510276221,
-0.024182966,
-0.0059013073,
0.0721665472,
0.0037305686,
0.0279489346,
0.0035245926,
0.0102911852,
-0.0378895216,
0.0735487193,
-0.0174909867,
-0.0066551371,
0.0526316054,
0.0256601721,
0.0242985301,
0.0354929008,
-0.024187373,
0.0641696081,
0.0304291267,
-0.0051693674,
-0.043188639,
-0.0238609202,
0.0380347371,
-0.0338712372,
0.0629596859,
0.0027527965,
0.002467959,
-0.0452447906,
-0.0077980291,
-0.0203561224,
-0.027454786,
-0.0312676542,
0.0136799263,
0.0058145593,
0.0090632066,
-0.0493040942,
0.0407392718,
-0.0316469446,
0.06364768,
-0.0542318821,
0.025801776,
0.0132605862,
0.0062005422,
-0.0549830347,
-0.00444473,
-0.0052499115,
-0.0447076,
0.0356592722,
0.0263008121,
0.003407659,
0.0375586264,
0.0389980711,
0.0334679633,
-0.0001352321,
0.0261514764,
-0.0338169038,
0.0479466245,
-0.0599843115,
-0.0121215554,
0.0108117713,
-0.0234010462,
0.0276353676,
-0.0328335613,
-0.009660556,
-0.0067667374,
-0.0006433402,
-0.036257524,
0.0079517476,
0.0266793035,
0.0117017683,
-0.0087138088,
0.0029650633,
0.0690578595,
-0.0526600443,
0.0373042114,
0.0412649363,
-0.0081266081,
-0.0126323691,
0.0050938372,
-0.0237671267,
-0.0207223129,
0.019780213,
0.0017392846,
-0.0521741398,
-0.0441981852,
0.0328378938,
0.0114599569,
0.0134457648,
0.0377317555,
0.0277720112,
0.0356167629,
0.0235749427,
0.0410933457,
-0.0654729679,
-0.031784974,
0.0298497286,
-0.0268302709,
0.0002499818,
-6.594017846e-33,
-0.0332791433,
-0.0212365966,
-0.0164337698,
0.0002775397,
-0.0017412342,
-0.0006792613,
-0.0080971625,
0.0095598921,
0.0298664533,
0.0413149148,
0.0081985742,
0.0123851886,
-0.0036117581,
0.0108127743,
0.0518092923,
-0.0068993694,
0.0548592396,
-0.0262441263,
0.0146714887,
0.0438466631,
-0.0089692464,
0.0061340309,
0.0647484511,
-0.1208339185,
0.0153138516,
0.0021077048,
-0.0427136235,
0.0125826839,
0.0013824815,
0.0410630852,
-0.0120139057,
0.0384172499,
0.0340081751,
-0.0422804579,
0.0056401631,
-0.0190186407,
-0.0451351032,
-0.0166400466,
-0.0187865868,
-0.0174092166,
-0.0139327347,
-0.0061868243,
0.0074826321,
-0.0136670424,
-0.0648725033,
-0.0119533399,
0.0259423796,
-0.0196350291,
0.0261266567,
-0.112810187,
-0.0101785008,
0.0170389824,
0.0002284078,
-0.0279458072,
0.0128735704,
0.0658758804,
0.0255155694,
0.0113106165,
-0.0505003445,
0.0442554429,
-0.0610127598,
0.0606400482,
-0.005256563,
-0.0007838077,
0.0194892213,
0.0693907514,
0.0184683166,
0.0188741591,
0.0052403403,
0.0144274961,
-0.0085454741,
-0.0038495576,
0.0193072259,
0.0423794277,
0.0473996289,
-0.0524369255,
-0.0384364575,
0.0426064506,
0.0052173375,
-0.0630603284,
0.0478635468,
0.0048634494,
-0.0354593918,
0.005507112,
0.0034983067,
-0.0623812899,
-0.0376774892,
-0.0124211712,
0.0016351528,
0.0298754964,
-0.0261685718,
-0.002873153,
-0.0357977077,
-0.0651185736,
-0.0220397692,
-0.011763786,
-0.0391593836,
0.0262814052,
0.0102711413,
-0.0068149301,
-0.0637215748,
-0.0209004618,
-0.0047337012,
0.0437232368,
0.0256061833,
-0.0214766655,
0.1002990752,
-0.0108553143,
-0.1066616699,
-0.004189237,
-0.0148385502,
0.0437242873,
-0.007249753,
0.0217314698,
0.0087620448,
0.021585945,
-0.0190987885,
0.0892428905,
0.0141646639,
0.0441772752,
-0.0255968962,
0.0271957573,
-0.0047412897,
0.0264034551,
0.0340345055,
-0.0086777452,
0.0127792116,
-0.0039747679,
-0.0427043326,
-0.0372603051,
-0.036276333,
0.0271688048,
2.728e-7,
0.0541928709,
0.056212388,
-0.0019009059,
-0.0210206304,
0.0129417442,
0.0646097884,
-0.0000107752,
0.028340444,
0.0237247627,
-0.0209513828,
0.0510800481,
0.0278780647,
0.0121797863,
0.0469248146,
-0.0734753013,
0.0686522797,
-0.0321081579,
0.0048154676,
-0.0123965861,
-0.0235239025,
0.0666133165,
0.090881981,
0.026079664,
0.0046249353,
0.0024061769,
0.0381976925,
0.0362499394,
-0.002795656,
-0.0299145579,
0.0039561167,
-0.0211213063,
0.0047089728,
-0.0207566246,
-0.0078246836,
-0.0311814006,
0.0113616483,
0.0045989933,
0.0378099531,
0.0041309185,
-0.0756050795,
0.0392828472,
0.0523861311,
0.0270719193,
-0.0043571913,
0.0509921461,
-0.0302545615,
-0.0283144824,
-0.0841678828,
-0.0269563254,
0.0478014462,
0.0435874909,
-0.0001122774,
-0.0293628126,
0.0580527559,
-0.0094518457,
-0.0306499731,
-0.0392244868,
-0.0283056349,
-0.015389774,
0.0673245639,
0.0165620856,
-0.0275807437,
0.0115400767,
0.0203385148,
-0.0464690514,
-0.0299071595,
0.0192401186,
2.098170172e-34,
0.056951087,
0.0029475363,
0.0052931844,
-0.0332600661,
0.0155766876,
-0.0084165316,
-0.0630564019,
-0.0160094686,
0.0140610579,
0.0295967292,
0.0157380346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18069v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18069v2 | Large Language Models for Cuffless Blood Pressure Measurement From Wearable Biosignals | 2024-06-26T04:54:45 | 2024-06-27T03:58:25 | Zengding Liu, Chen Chen, Jiannong Cao, Minglei Pan, Jikui Liu, Nan Li, Fen Miao, Ye Li | eess.SP | eess.SP, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have captured significant interest from both
academia and industry due to their impressive performance across various
textual tasks. However, the potential of LLMs to analyze physiological
time-series data remains an emerging research field. Particularly, there is a
notable gap in the utilization of LLMs for analyzing wearable biosignals to
achieve cuffless blood pressure (BP) measurement, which is critical for the
management of cardiovascular diseases. This paper presents the first work to
explore the capacity of LLMs to perform cuffless BP estimation based on
wearable biosignals. We extracted physiological features from electrocardiogram
(ECG) and photoplethysmogram (PPG) signals and designed context-enhanced
prompts by combining these features with BP domain knowledge and user
information. Subsequently, we adapted LLMs to BP estimation tasks through
fine-tuning. To evaluate the proposed approach, we conducted assessments of ten
advanced LLMs using a comprehensive public dataset of wearable biosignals from
1,272 participants. The experimental results demonstrate that the optimally
fine-tuned LLM significantly surpasses conventional task-specific baselines,
achieving an estimation error of 0.00 $\pm$ 9.25 mmHg for systolic BP and 1.29
$\pm$ 6.37 mmHg for diastolic BP. Notably, the ablation studies highlight the
benefits of our context enhancement strategy, leading to an 8.9% reduction in
mean absolute error for systolic BP estimation. This paper pioneers the
exploration of LLMs for cuffless BP measurement, providing a potential solution
to enhance the accuracy of cuffless BP measurement. | [
-0.0173057858,
0.027806798,
0.0101025198,
-0.0018825472,
-0.026004158,
0.0000627733,
0.0539831296,
0.0162267443,
0.0177215338,
0.0160769187,
0.0041099885,
-0.034778852,
0.0478959754,
0.0474164784,
-0.0098463623,
-0.0460868776,
-0.0131180808,
-0.0059706373,
0.0888855159,
0.0122124236,
0.0323125906,
-0.0218210388,
-0.0316993818,
0.0451611988,
0.0125694722,
-0.0136921648,
-0.006276112,
-0.0265506357,
0.0015232923,
-0.0815142244,
-0.04019548,
0.0472004972,
-0.0301773939,
0.0018187867,
0.0000021141,
-0.0390884019,
0.0123041822,
0.0547824353,
-0.0271714423,
-0.0618514791,
0.0651283339,
-0.0253428537,
0.0204171017,
0.0052713011,
-0.0397703424,
-0.0497206002,
0.0548223294,
0.0555569492,
0.0203446615,
0.014240168,
-0.0272569396,
0.0711912811,
-0.036585249,
-0.0604253598,
0.0434567221,
-0.0605624244,
0.0334352925,
-0.0554103479,
0.0843917057,
0.0295609813,
-0.0189089086,
0.0529132225,
-0.0054718424,
0.0605217479,
0.0312667936,
0.0158047043,
-0.018926492,
-0.0228690282,
-0.0303223357,
0.0521109812,
0.0067158435,
0.0230996162,
0.0362385735,
0.0084821805,
-0.0011066014,
-0.0163050257,
-0.0740846097,
-0.0409244075,
-0.0255478416,
0.0084294463,
-0.044302173,
0.010300573,
0.0230914094,
-0.0375718921,
-0.0375940055,
0.0382444523,
0.0078749182,
-0.0129767507,
0.0153566338,
0.0180931855,
-0.0348822325,
-0.0576622337,
0.0419349745,
0.0196145922,
-0.0331696942,
-0.0180721842,
-0.0365557671,
-0.0029521098,
-0.002139441,
-0.0428192317,
0.0160803106,
0.0461491197,
0.0235692188,
0.0370970927,
0.0065844767,
0.0177761577,
-0.0283690318,
-0.0314155594,
-0.0430182479,
0.0183225349,
-0.0310539771,
-0.0036895971,
0.0102255968,
0.0131732216,
-0.0315492041,
-0.013725006,
-0.0902895704,
-0.0322169662,
-0.0149553884,
0.0066604866,
-0.032093104,
0.0134013752,
0.0203173235,
-0.0088123092,
-0.0064247916,
0.0268825125,
0.0356421396,
0.016207274,
-0.0158886183,
-0.0500417911,
0.0271007121,
-0.0189621355,
0.0397616476,
0.0102420216,
-0.0031408912,
0.0402937829,
-0.002021343,
0.0245020352,
-0.0271515269,
-0.050191287,
-0.0200611316,
0.0266802851,
-0.0147378733,
-0.0522070453,
0.039248798,
0.0179220345,
0.0210454147,
-0.0295597427,
0.0163418967,
0.0317382663,
-0.0280739143,
0.0616874397,
-0.0490183942,
0.0124614667,
-0.0102224872,
0.008644321,
0.0178354271,
0.0497666001,
0.0386555009,
-0.0681994259,
0.0272680894,
-0.0299870353,
0.0006585231,
0.0554592274,
0.0095103066,
-0.0706239194,
-0.0500913598,
-0.0163982548,
0.044811707,
0.0353304595,
-0.0068842829,
0.0493330546,
0.0418495052,
0.0326640271,
0.077666223,
0.0584226772,
0.0480747409,
0.0226426814,
0.0164721347,
-0.0394567735,
0.0049611763,
-0.0309560876,
-0.065210104,
-0.0217372049,
-0.0319870859,
0.0209042672,
-0.0396840163,
-0.026394777,
-0.0288214087,
-0.0566797666,
-0.0554745421,
-0.0363186412,
-0.0113016432,
0.0073372531,
0.0808561668,
-0.0512578823,
-0.0019361492,
0.029518934,
0.0230894834,
-0.0401762575,
-0.0042919903,
0.0152133871,
0.0029364803,
0.0774593875,
0.0162472613,
-0.0210411269,
0.0660103485,
-0.0216138009,
0.0415743589,
0.017358277,
0.0231034756,
-0.0006054438,
0.0256259013,
-0.0537689216,
-0.0340796076,
0.0595481209,
-0.0220636018,
-0.0015622267,
-0.0607123263,
0.0504047163,
0.0173924081,
-0.0012439112,
-0.0323934443,
0.0240551606,
-0.0775434226,
-0.0413869545,
0.0271348003,
0.0193844233,
0.0182155352,
0.0248032045,
0.0123723233,
0.0256638657,
0.0164281726,
-0.065135166,
-0.0238050632,
0.0032077788,
-0.0370578766,
0.0134560298,
0.0436875783,
-0.0270443317,
0.0409862138,
-0.0505309515,
0.001143045,
-0.041025348,
-0.0488617979,
-0.0291582942,
0.0459729098,
-0.0044212327,
-0.0191345848,
0.0199857224,
0.0029050449,
-0.0162419863,
-0.0280140229,
0.0417447649,
0.0197790079,
0.0165693406,
-0.012747135,
0.007749483,
-0.0259126537,
-0.035099227,
-0.0188775156,
-0.0183228329,
0.0070531713,
0.0258624703,
0.0389695279,
-0.0106820911,
-0.0005291433,
-0.1385159642,
-0.009402629,
0.0268030651,
0.0146459211,
0.0171286315,
0.0783084631,
-0.018290583,
-0.011779313,
-0.0308416691,
-0.0375247262,
-0.0016869338,
0.0240295529,
-0.0242501348,
0.0160783157,
0.0082607316,
0.0210801587,
-0.0103302021,
-0.0527630448,
0.0518046357,
0.0024759276,
-0.0034284091,
0.0323288962,
0.002005839,
-0.0325159989,
0.0227949992,
0.0404689983,
0.004533025,
0.0193689615,
-0.0166849345,
0.0385156684,
0.0358670391,
-0.0155439368,
-0.0239880085,
0.0328499377,
-0.0197530426,
-0.0095213782,
-0.0053009884,
-0.0457799099,
0.0188664366,
0.0175981466,
-0.0295314267,
-0.0335536636,
0.0650044903,
0.0392942429,
0.0148322061,
-0.0127037745,
0.0159682035,
-0.0463252068,
-0.0058095367,
-0.1048693135,
0.0303607527,
-0.0309415441,
0.0405402109,
0.0058830334,
-0.0335800424,
0.0404391736,
-0.0215493832,
0.007298294,
-0.0010854693,
-0.0324910097,
-0.0209787134,
-0.0137889339,
-0.0301484689,
0.0056418907,
0.0117942505,
-0.0042585144,
0.0273788925,
-0.001410994,
-0.0233034585,
-0.063785702,
0.0156652275,
-0.0521756038,
0.0106313042,
0.0138075408,
-0.0408994891,
-0.0502813086,
-0.0043928111,
-0.0695975497,
0.0046274993,
-0.0290797725,
0.0131763797,
0.0101330793,
0.037769746,
0.0088955211,
0.0202645455,
-0.0014461458,
-0.0095038293,
-0.0083111292,
0.0095787486,
0.0356337056,
-0.0263821576,
-0.0006395666,
-0.0075383512,
0.0590672307,
0.0422851704,
0.0593782328,
-0.0012108189,
-0.0294780582,
0.0121077485,
-0.0092604524,
-0.0012138895,
-0.0243048184,
0.0335580967,
0.0161916427,
-0.0142461108,
0.0139101231,
0.1510569453,
0.0269064624,
-0.0590974763,
-0.0025730396,
-0.019863477,
-0.0263238531,
0.0017074415,
-0.0483182147,
-0.0464837067,
-0.0318883434,
0.014123165,
0.0889018029,
0.0058016418,
-0.0205903109,
-0.0350683592,
-0.0391650014,
0.0088029364,
0.0427169204,
0.0017184134,
-0.0020561686,
-0.0672787726,
0.0666219294,
-0.043568857,
0.0217811577,
-0.0114985118,
-0.0321708918,
0.0098065538,
0.0246045552,
-0.1024015099,
-0.065809235,
0.0130864372,
0.0039759916,
0.0151313292,
0.0611108392,
0.0102589391,
-0.0128209349,
0.0061403802,
0.0226942319,
-0.0256031584,
-0.0141484812,
-0.0563300364,
0.0069156205,
0.074044697,
-0.0070629637,
-0.0278264377,
0.0998318419,
-0.0469388068,
0.0118070496,
0.0346028171,
0.0575090423,
-0.0025527983,
-0.015761774,
-0.0435881689,
0.0072063874,
0.0421673991,
0.0570903346,
0.007629029,
-0.0707682073,
-0.0112005947,
-0.0135716284,
-0.0092529701,
0.040508084,
-0.056062296,
-0.0261630584,
-0.027926499,
-0.0474140756,
-0.017531164,
-0.0155519163,
0.0371764489,
0.0685540661,
0.0464579128,
0.0604565889,
0.113187328,
0.0193315838,
-0.0247621015,
0.0352815017,
-0.024253197,
0.0401446596,
-0.031316597,
0.0532634221,
0.009576886,
0.0119668785,
-0.0255661942,
0.0586865209,
-0.037828885,
-0.0196477957,
0.0344220102,
0.0563199781,
0.0321770497,
-0.0209380351,
-0.0550993457,
-0.0245748796,
0.0199829489,
0.049201645,
-0.0404185317,
0.0409679599,
-0.0386090092,
0.034814693,
-0.0004372803,
0.0071063801,
0.0017507344,
0.0282898862,
-0.0185241513,
0.0377079025,
-0.0100533506,
-0.0585217215,
0.0260092989,
0.0443439335,
0.0480768494,
0.0183376875,
0.0014319903,
0.0060407999,
-0.0177135449,
-0.0649955794,
-0.0056130942,
-0.0395221338,
0.0439100266,
-0.0364417583,
0.0213223342,
0.0099444427,
-0.0444750302,
-0.05181133,
-0.0519687608,
-0.074034676,
0.0540996529,
-0.0066032223,
0.0224262141,
0.0406789258,
-0.0189605765,
0.0125376014,
0.0135338772,
0.0139104845,
-0.0051562516,
0.0087115681,
0.0727377832,
-0.0237688851,
-0.0022485715,
-0.0322856866,
0.0177595019,
-0.0324958637,
0.0442246087,
0.0142691545,
0.0861817971,
-0.0035626346,
0.0034176756,
-0.0113431066,
0.0151592549,
-0.0027804514,
-0.0744198263,
0.0282890163,
-0.0045691798,
0.0474155843,
0.0673976094,
-0.0038364823,
-0.0086571155,
-0.0006556191,
0.0702353716,
-0.0111874398,
-0.0174911544,
0.0183328465,
-0.0938715041,
-0.0179160107,
0.037288148,
0.0498535298,
0.0113660116,
-0.0580226108,
-0.0036113921,
-0.0727693215,
-0.0486393124,
0.0736775547,
0.0311391782,
-0.0287285615,
-0.0453687385,
0.010401424,
0.0371327661,
-0.0711669847,
0.0049306923,
0.0095925191,
0.0589340217,
-0.0570530407,
-0.0315939263,
-0.035454493,
-5.963967935e-33,
0.0114689711,
-0.0400455482,
-0.0053482479,
-0.0250823479,
-0.0026341719,
0.0593896098,
-0.0400548391,
0.0423106924,
0.0383125804,
0.0365659371,
-0.0172914937,
-0.0505026393,
0.0371840633,
-0.0080511896,
0.0183138829,
-0.0510893352,
0.0352227874,
0.0142560601,
0.0110147977,
0.0197143462,
0.0322666503,
0.0348792225,
-0.0183747951,
-0.1010472849,
0.0107925665,
0.0159517936,
-0.0324594416,
-0.0078692688,
0.0229927208,
0.0363851786,
-0.0317193903,
0.0732769966,
0.0130627118,
0.0142614814,
-0.0161612555,
0.0659156144,
-0.0648334548,
-0.0164687112,
0.0275268927,
-0.016315436,
0.0342766531,
-0.0197011176,
0.0287666023,
-0.0117814522,
-0.0585114174,
-0.0103148064,
0.0224146061,
-0.0779429078,
-0.0217650235,
-0.025614759,
0.0353489183,
0.0027546233,
0.0027073761,
-0.0038430088,
0.0294582918,
0.0161762983,
-0.0537859537,
-0.0296682175,
-0.0655071288,
0.0075446581,
0.0643188059,
-0.0014854006,
0.0127880042,
0.0270909406,
0.0014253726,
0.0030115051,
0.0098999087,
-0.0578639992,
0.0018134072,
0.0456489325,
-0.0129894195,
0.0461587869,
0.0598059669,
0.0280103777,
0.0123384567,
-0.0232001673,
-0.0699160397,
0.0244866926,
-0.015903173,
-0.041169513,
-0.0131920148,
0.0025927164,
-0.0464042686,
-0.0214776602,
-0.0032557591,
-0.0032200722,
-0.0425361022,
-0.0250398256,
0.0112982877,
-0.009042263,
0.0079167373,
0.0131869651,
0.0113810925,
-0.0329508781,
0.008565193,
-0.0311106183,
0.045466058,
-0.0209986381,
0.0183310974,
-0.0450188965,
-0.0326140039,
0.0217057262,
0.0271914992,
0.0490107499,
0.0341334939,
-0.0265174825,
-0.0178216286,
0.0176570415,
-0.0388804153,
-0.031536784,
0.0109699033,
0.0094416905,
-0.0196691286,
-0.024425948,
0.0677986965,
-0.0337337293,
-0.0009879625,
0.0836257562,
-0.0279290378,
-0.0127173383,
-0.0052198591,
0.0327930413,
0.0167223625,
0.0221768729,
-0.0414147824,
-0.030750934,
-0.017498564,
0.0185830817,
0.0253423061,
0.0064782258,
-0.0249670483,
0.0038264762,
2.881e-7,
0.0121903839,
0.009663946,
0.0043291133,
-0.0356729999,
0.0194921996,
0.0482644364,
-0.0376808606,
-0.0123170465,
0.0141706858,
-0.0368341953,
0.0219701584,
-0.0094549721,
0.0673421621,
0.0183375608,
-0.0204253662,
-0.0672367588,
-0.0054809684,
-0.0033610505,
-0.0311477445,
0.0009177344,
0.0659635663,
0.0244868528,
-0.0312347095,
-0.0153741362,
0.0310790893,
-0.0006551305,
0.0312538855,
-0.0405957513,
-0.0268808138,
-0.0191222727,
0.0026134336,
-0.0042326078,
0.0346760862,
-0.0005417285,
0.0035354956,
-0.0167937409,
0.0375807025,
0.0857304186,
-0.0415812545,
0.0503547937,
0.0158828311,
0.0282066986,
0.0194343682,
-0.0302469321,
0.0820963085,
-0.0465124622,
-0.0369208641,
-0.0615930147,
-0.0190175548,
-0.0019293498,
0.0096350713,
-0.0032816855,
-0.0252426229,
-0.0142543409,
0.0141823553,
0.0140109519,
-0.0302326474,
0.0247811861,
-0.020165883,
0.0409721099,
-0.0103306845,
-0.0359166637,
-0.0090982635,
0.06222165,
-0.0065773185,
-0.0860430226,
0.0061742356,
2.461122191e-34,
0.0093995435,
-0.0108975777,
-0.0126961069,
-0.0234172326,
0.014588384,
-0.0291305408,
-0.0249172207,
0.0259810202,
-0.0001382995,
-0.0928258449,
-0.0085662156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18067v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18067v1 | Exploring Energy-Based Models for Out-of-Distribution Detection in Dialect Identification | 2024-06-26T04:52:48 | 2024-06-26T04:52:48 | Yaqian Hao, Chenguang Hu, Yingying Gao, Shilei Zhang, Junlan Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | The diverse nature of dialects presents challenges for models trained on
specific linguistic patterns, rendering them susceptible to errors when
confronted with unseen or out-of-distribution (OOD) data. This study introduces
a novel margin-enhanced joint energy model (MEJEM) tailored specifically for
OOD detection in dialects. By integrating a generative model and the energy
margin loss, our approach aims to enhance the robustness of dialect
identification systems. Furthermore, we explore two OOD scores for OOD dialect
detection, and our findings conclusively demonstrate that the energy score
outperforms the softmax score. Leveraging Sharpness-Aware Minimization to
optimize the training process of the joint model, we enhance model
generalization by minimizing both loss and sharpness. Experiments conducted on
dialect identification tasks validate the efficacy of Energy-Based Models and
provide valuable insights into their performance. | [
0.0174232069,
0.0453409962,
0.0257430896,
0.0620901547,
0.0234664679,
0.0253013391,
-0.0396624245,
-0.0113016106,
-0.0523552001,
-0.0184500385,
-0.0365652591,
-0.0376596861,
0.019357644,
-0.0189094115,
0.0256831832,
-0.0151831694,
0.0431858599,
-0.0107397018,
0.0203573667,
-0.0326295346,
0.0112207662,
-0.0098563116,
-0.0070636254,
0.0113802133,
-0.0889427736,
0.0428326316,
0.0035026087,
0.0924868584,
0.0532855503,
0.0095447302,
0.0465260036,
0.0262941681,
-0.0367153361,
0.0312634893,
0.0000019915,
-0.043315392,
-0.0345428623,
-0.0246696211,
-0.0192187726,
0.0021112044,
0.0313399248,
0.0001389498,
-0.0584399141,
-0.0130641311,
0.024077097,
-0.0123960543,
0.1181958318,
-0.0109727196,
0.012508885,
0.0777269974,
0.0098457756,
-0.0358091854,
0.0229446255,
-0.0118198441,
-0.0315252282,
0.010040462,
0.0130237183,
-0.0610730723,
-0.1054165065,
-0.0815690607,
-0.0031922471,
0.0294117481,
-0.021104984,
0.0393879302,
-0.0048350729,
0.0043419544,
-0.0760893747,
0.0165559053,
-0.0088810846,
0.0502931923,
-0.0638608783,
-0.0174743608,
-0.0048515447,
-0.0115451589,
-0.0513382591,
0.0256263185,
0.0143250227,
0.0049394076,
0.002174201,
0.055451151,
-0.0319357477,
0.0101661533,
0.0401599295,
0.0046050563,
-0.0112311346,
0.0492904373,
0.0368516073,
-0.0171184186,
0.0243395846,
0.0265268814,
-0.0997306406,
0.0155321397,
0.0139687797,
0.0224654227,
0.025616359,
0.0014929181,
-0.0068297503,
-0.0288563613,
0.0080769444,
-0.0462197401,
0.0424318202,
0.0079206936,
-0.0438144132,
0.0005917123,
-0.0083707599,
-0.0054910169,
-0.0114453714,
0.016346341,
-0.0216020085,
-0.0325663947,
-0.0392887704,
0.0206744466,
-0.0278665759,
-0.0000397524,
0.0262421872,
-0.0041534244,
-0.0151993958,
-0.033873383,
-0.0416798778,
0.0033095011,
0.0393498726,
0.0096991286,
-0.0443270169,
-0.0447760932,
0.0477974825,
0.0483302586,
0.0051615899,
0.0056771771,
-0.0390587896,
-0.074677594,
-0.0237476304,
0.0337304287,
0.0197341535,
-0.0012626724,
0.0166398492,
-0.0025484068,
0.0181788784,
-0.0296672322,
-0.1033856422,
-0.0221194662,
-0.0705511048,
-0.0484548621,
-0.0130098797,
-0.0803494006,
-0.0263668671,
-0.0298838541,
0.0427879244,
-0.05074526,
0.0174497683,
-0.0351723991,
0.0255709998,
0.0202505644,
-0.0321210362,
0.0198867545,
0.0515920483,
-0.0197268222,
0.0027256338,
0.1124995351,
0.0327746086,
-0.0303287618,
0.0120386705,
0.0276745223,
-0.02123948,
0.0677171871,
0.0032096496,
0.0413405336,
-0.1022602394,
-0.0593205802,
0.0228902251,
-0.0021687979,
0.0700014979,
0.05228981,
0.0035568462,
-0.0089961626,
0.0740249902,
0.0044887234,
0.0319611952,
-0.0144370068,
0.0207558107,
0.0101606278,
-0.0231118593,
0.0149450442,
0.0352799818,
-0.0463003106,
-0.0321063995,
-0.0082469247,
0.0169535726,
0.0584616363,
-0.0519345254,
-0.0014858131,
-0.0342018083,
-0.0828248113,
-0.0263296366,
0.0072403708,
0.0840456039,
-0.0117676323,
0.0015167823,
0.06647221,
0.0497293957,
-0.0032618192,
0.0000054144,
-0.035230875,
-0.0139832078,
0.0033089721,
0.0030765533,
-0.0068680532,
0.0386558808,
0.0143906558,
-0.0262154713,
-0.0057420195,
0.0455618463,
-0.0050428738,
0.0576823354,
-0.0551329479,
-0.0094435643,
0.0163461082,
0.044790104,
0.001130475,
-0.045270972,
0.0329978094,
0.0294025149,
-0.0625815168,
0.0085914778,
-0.00150273,
0.0444960035,
-0.01392431,
0.0303504672,
0.0327859037,
0.0131723098,
0.0357412249,
-0.0194269251,
-0.0069635403,
0.0029763025,
-0.0579945855,
0.0425442457,
0.0025055646,
-0.0377845764,
-0.0469654389,
0.0584204644,
-0.0077279122,
0.0019527058,
0.0175182614,
-0.0012019527,
-0.0581450984,
0.0353635959,
-0.0666836575,
0.0582561269,
-0.0827701464,
0.0157914404,
-0.007381456,
0.0118935527,
-0.0042624064,
0.1046995446,
-0.0022356543,
0.0298116785,
0.0132324537,
-0.0350388475,
0.0490997061,
-0.0924439356,
-0.0096069239,
0.0338674001,
-0.0084505668,
-0.0054412,
-0.0165722072,
-0.0275245905,
-0.0167388003,
-0.0289754923,
-0.0658258274,
-0.0168249328,
-0.0531264581,
0.0221698694,
0.0241093617,
-0.0092813782,
-0.0316779315,
-0.0089893639,
0.0053427583,
0.0004852448,
-0.003867921,
-0.001161257,
-0.0350993499,
0.02519623,
-0.0193902515,
-0.0114388419,
-0.0178535301,
0.0081445025,
0.0430891551,
-0.0559661575,
-0.0315946564,
-0.0328433178,
-0.0137581956,
-0.0014650213,
0.0375347026,
0.0326684825,
-0.0570060983,
-0.048860427,
-0.0268340111,
0.0812969729,
0.0524854735,
-0.010480809,
-0.0381948352,
0.0542287603,
-0.0635444522,
-0.0122091193,
0.0047663446,
-0.0372589864,
-0.0090904655,
-0.0088705877,
-0.0455569699,
-0.0274217594,
0.0606729314,
0.0294605847,
-0.0008635863,
-0.0161996707,
0.0007463937,
-0.0080253547,
0.0112300245,
0.0192396753,
0.0202836655,
-0.0335096419,
0.0169725791,
-0.0439831577,
-0.018413581,
0.0649279803,
-0.0795687735,
-0.0177656393,
-0.0371838361,
-0.0281153917,
0.0062029054,
-0.0302472282,
-0.0103908442,
0.0377012379,
0.0023067845,
-0.0460957065,
0.0055540688,
-0.0241161641,
0.0229815617,
-0.01457367,
0.0400406346,
-0.0363802686,
-0.0051096007,
0.0069242097,
0.0263201874,
-0.0018649722,
-0.0117080975,
-0.0454440564,
0.033237122,
-0.0065958793,
-0.0126061309,
0.0463260487,
0.0282253549,
-0.010626954,
0.0515574291,
-0.0264219381,
0.027986588,
-0.0041521294,
0.0669629797,
0.0392983928,
0.0202297624,
-0.0153509742,
-0.0373951383,
0.0076545235,
-0.0219073147,
-0.0190195292,
0.0381896384,
-0.0115639418,
0.0146582238,
0.031205168,
0.0144095067,
-0.0200686157,
0.0354280286,
0.0641638339,
-0.0242525954,
-0.0086555481,
0.0814561248,
0.008482323,
-0.0225119535,
0.0030330189,
-0.0055090343,
0.0534892529,
0.0013765326,
-0.0311951321,
-0.0054331012,
-0.0453632548,
0.0362191759,
0.0549892746,
-0.0019364518,
0.010460983,
0.0052023763,
-0.0802890211,
0.0077482578,
0.0506829508,
0.0074406313,
-0.0166491698,
0.0043484904,
0.0251785628,
-0.026403673,
-0.0246031769,
-0.0239420049,
0.014066631,
-0.0384884365,
0.0727959424,
0.0014947995,
-0.091117233,
-0.0280694533,
-0.0713164732,
0.0289476514,
0.0302407853,
-0.0326607451,
-0.0278007612,
-0.0872714818,
0.0326793566,
-0.1013592854,
-0.0236603394,
-0.0240079761,
-0.0008821823,
0.0406729095,
-0.0272135753,
0.0147131896,
-0.0068399385,
-0.0207038224,
0.0168427117,
-0.0321779549,
0.0563796088,
-0.0283093266,
0.0076690363,
0.0415362827,
-0.0066919797,
0.0608241446,
0.0301052537,
0.0381700583,
-0.0036065048,
-0.0228034947,
-0.0133111048,
0.027683083,
-0.0079199048,
0.0163690057,
0.0596628413,
0.0369326212,
-0.1019840986,
-0.0295403283,
-0.0308051482,
-0.0368963666,
0.026816301,
0.0280030575,
-0.0218847152,
-0.0211178251,
0.0153158298,
-0.0188562851,
0.0456558242,
-0.0236298274,
0.0144246733,
-0.065363802,
-0.0453177728,
0.0468720533,
-0.0178047121,
-0.0018240941,
0.0064573698,
-0.061418172,
-0.0750339478,
0.0147098023,
0.018993577,
0.0220472161,
0.0303137191,
-0.0404120572,
-0.0322045907,
-0.0192276407,
0.0192878544,
0.0256742649,
0.019478865,
0.0504336953,
-0.032749299,
-0.01836426,
0.0403642915,
-0.026677439,
0.035068728,
0.0123208519,
0.0229794085,
-0.0598074943,
-0.0716219842,
0.0213422347,
-0.0516526625,
0.0471046269,
-0.0074269031,
-0.0482341275,
-0.0579815619,
0.0117279412,
0.0481831022,
0.0378358923,
-0.0302997679,
-0.0278684366,
0.0577069037,
0.0179034304,
-0.0011156026,
0.0725535303,
-0.0149500975,
0.0252893548,
-0.0190328732,
0.0349504501,
0.0530279614,
0.0327835865,
0.0156099331,
0.026157774,
-0.0601954237,
0.0526871383,
0.0214706734,
0.0058378149,
0.0117090289,
0.0219150763,
0.0012518865,
-0.0278407708,
-0.0145841837,
-0.0173494443,
0.0382881239,
0.0076213265,
-0.0610174574,
-0.0125070876,
0.0504230559,
-0.0253552385,
0.0254298784,
-0.0091598853,
-0.0081298733,
-0.0581427142,
-0.0036918826,
-0.0004554153,
-0.0215740651,
0.0434862748,
0.0018494673,
-0.0013716436,
0.0198175628,
0.0659798607,
0.0124231717,
0.0509003177,
-0.0342464335,
0.000343472,
-0.0031198848,
0.0129280817,
0.0332110636,
-0.0008200023,
-0.0374063104,
0.0351511165,
-0.003178844,
-0.0492196977,
0.0078095743,
-0.0279674344,
0.0190998707,
0.0284786951,
0.0474916063,
0.0201825779,
-0.0581848212,
-0.0296928436,
0.0042965701,
-0.0332564935,
0.0098994821,
0.0189011171,
0.0050229402,
-6.692085666e-33,
-0.0023682991,
0.0066174017,
-0.0488678999,
-0.0264057927,
-0.0140348868,
0.0073460024,
-0.0302479491,
0.033158429,
-0.0359807946,
-0.0078766076,
0.031725809,
-0.0130042741,
0.031992238,
0.0281198118,
-0.0319500752,
-0.0042593447,
0.0612354837,
0.0044406587,
0.0099669872,
-0.00239297,
0.0310536921,
0.0310631692,
0.0927255154,
-0.0361634754,
-0.0222996399,
-0.0131450025,
-0.0467722341,
0.0401571989,
0.0348201469,
0.0414376259,
-0.0363917574,
0.075683482,
0.0018340747,
-0.0250814501,
-0.0091704018,
0.0042620059,
-0.0393744372,
-0.0141994944,
-0.0485013165,
0.0448271409,
0.0413914099,
-0.0496112145,
0.0381908379,
0.0023968059,
-0.0184949096,
0.0076292655,
0.0382211804,
-0.055755645,
-0.0061028921,
-0.0248348303,
-0.0215044469,
0.0569795705,
-0.0001628526,
-0.0472293645,
0.0497010909,
-0.007016683,
0.0053878292,
-0.0254160892,
-0.0337464437,
-0.0027809655,
0.0708206967,
0.0497663021,
0.0480771773,
0.0290646795,
-0.0425059237,
0.0222844277,
0.0035904401,
-0.0435254574,
0.0345095024,
-0.0424160808,
0.0657430589,
0.0258818008,
0.0099934675,
0.0052226721,
0.0406608805,
-0.027147837,
-0.0672096014,
0.001253636,
0.0254993476,
-0.0087664463,
-0.0190309361,
0.0021494476,
-0.0026014082,
-0.036206264,
-0.0016835347,
-0.0557498001,
-0.0205895863,
-0.0053567272,
0.0104202535,
0.0055810083,
0.0053790906,
0.011717096,
0.0371331573,
0.0023698481,
0.038476292,
0.0253424086,
0.0181209501,
0.017283272,
0.0025783291,
0.0051474986,
-0.0451828577,
-0.0292884279,
0.0194576439,
0.0386958085,
-0.0016911621,
-0.012903817,
0.0489945337,
0.0456389263,
-0.0284673274,
0.0316909663,
-0.0423429534,
0.014147005,
-0.0290705804,
0.0837464929,
0.0401003882,
-0.0272876639,
0.0127066849,
0.0806376934,
0.0027933542,
0.0489725433,
-0.0031089548,
0.0128645664,
0.0154841766,
0.0695109963,
0.0128003275,
0.021475276,
0.0370010957,
-0.0328971818,
-0.015283566,
0.0072724032,
0.0037999132,
0.0278893542,
2.744e-7,
0.0273172241,
-0.0231848918,
0.0158581827,
-0.0458643287,
0.0288820807,
0.0093116136,
-0.0307575967,
-0.0523930788,
-0.0100799631,
-0.0643612146,
0.0370633453,
0.001773974,
0.0802118853,
0.0549826398,
-0.0830279514,
0.0177973025,
-0.054445304,
0.0244477782,
-0.0253093112,
-0.0495412312,
0.0125131914,
0.066419892,
-0.0212513171,
-0.0279115345,
0.022835793,
-0.0470181815,
0.041101642,
-0.0106903492,
0.0499896072,
-0.0039774235,
0.0354072154,
-0.0346509404,
0.0121253589,
0.0002250691,
-0.0219251942,
0.0278936476,
0.0057023061,
0.0378628895,
-0.0214782413,
-0.0835155696,
0.0181048494,
0.0565452762,
-0.0339063704,
-0.0373787545,
0.0539478399,
0.0021109674,
0.0011116522,
0.0230152551,
-0.0346199572,
-0.0046358695,
0.0140747344,
-0.033909563,
-0.0022543222,
-0.0039678668,
0.0192520097,
-0.0237851627,
-0.0369224325,
-0.0329320207,
-0.0105375955,
0.0954980925,
-0.0604819991,
-0.0330512412,
0.0313119702,
-0.0185213648,
-0.0100524407,
-0.0180453304,
0.0050059203,
2.103786831e-34,
0.0167265814,
-0.0118064806,
-0.0060681454,
-0.0037294542,
-0.0060634962,
0.0171599668,
-0.0657814592,
-0.0171005204,
-0.0219515115,
-0.0249817129,
-0.0148741659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18064v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18064v1 | Evaluating Quality of Answers for Retrieval-Augmented Generation: A Strong LLM Is All You Need | 2024-06-26T04:49:41 | 2024-06-26T04:49:41 | Yang Wang, Alberto Garcia Hernandez, Roman Kyslyi, Nicholas Kersting | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a comprehensive evaluation of answer quality in
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) applications using vRAG-Eval, a novel
grading system that is designed to assess correctness, completeness, and
honesty. We further map the grading of quality aspects aforementioned into a
binary score, indicating an accept or reject decision, mirroring the intuitive
"thumbs-up" or "thumbs-down" gesture commonly used in chat applications. This
approach suits factual business settings where a clear decision opinion is
essential. Our assessment applies vRAG-Eval to two Large Language Models
(LLMs), evaluating the quality of answers generated by a vanilla RAG
application. We compare these evaluations with human expert judgments and find
a substantial alignment between GPT-4's assessments and those of human experts,
reaching 83% agreement on accept or reject decisions. This study highlights the
potential of LLMs as reliable evaluators in closed-domain, closed-ended
settings, particularly when human evaluations require significant resources. | [
0.0801014155,
0.0225382727,
-0.0230172947,
0.0039025897,
-0.03939097,
-0.0150130093,
-0.0297701638,
0.0039200522,
0.0165132582,
-0.0503195822,
-0.0150626311,
-0.0492960811,
-0.001932668,
0.0138948178,
0.0082671689,
0.0129535273,
0.0367214046,
0.0111595327,
0.0286546182,
-0.0065692007,
0.0260156207,
0.0238408353,
0.0125357183,
0.0531695224,
-0.0169347562,
-0.0013946415,
0.00848806,
0.0106422249,
0.0130558843,
-0.0117810657,
0.003924239,
0.0531162918,
-0.037401408,
0.0188816022,
0.000002047,
-0.0616709888,
-0.0000760713,
0.0071372269,
-0.0235514194,
0.0361943655,
0.0265146922,
0.0736694112,
-0.0068831677,
0.0480854772,
-0.0569526888,
0.0076433397,
0.0226835925,
0.0037123375,
0.1157982275,
0.039527528,
0.0132490434,
0.0032770201,
0.0255400203,
-0.0124832252,
0.0522343889,
-0.0377641693,
-0.0198498834,
0.0614932366,
0.0280195773,
0.0115900058,
0.0422191061,
0.0506027453,
0.0133223729,
-0.0367714018,
0.0158923585,
0.0234840121,
-0.0469474308,
-0.0181899387,
0.0160110183,
0.0411444828,
0.0541822799,
-0.0068518971,
-0.025334686,
-0.0076314174,
0.0319895372,
0.0321843401,
-0.0475019179,
0.0105580129,
-0.0176190119,
-0.0041255266,
-0.0361350179,
-0.0020321442,
0.001321118,
0.0070698895,
0.0325593762,
0.0636740029,
0.0084488904,
-0.0241904408,
-0.026798049,
0.0123781348,
-0.002111444,
-0.0318070315,
0.0028093844,
0.0463186167,
-0.0227255877,
0.0245531052,
-0.0034580049,
-0.0067220451,
0.0771481991,
-0.0297962148,
0.0324823223,
0.0151889306,
0.0073428969,
0.0095070722,
-0.0296771731,
0.0557086207,
0.0189342368,
-0.0165367424,
-0.0510811582,
-0.0154919606,
-0.0458096005,
-0.0264473055,
0.0063138511,
0.0529963411,
-0.0117627596,
0.0136408741,
-0.0647822469,
-0.0017389716,
-0.0255006552,
0.0032239417,
0.0222301595,
0.0392061323,
-0.0068236408,
0.0146589158,
-0.0495386533,
0.0244334321,
-0.0347405262,
0.0131940795,
0.0296120457,
-0.0940950662,
0.0261945128,
0.0020016618,
0.0086549725,
0.0092930952,
0.0162780024,
0.0569881387,
0.0024695832,
-0.0064048911,
-0.0164635703,
-0.0627491996,
-0.0185303017,
-0.0446674004,
-0.0357288979,
-0.0843688175,
0.0169284977,
0.0287308265,
-0.0427333079,
0.0119318161,
0.027019294,
0.0567540787,
-0.0210130475,
-0.0035487928,
-0.0240260474,
0.0412427299,
0.038651932,
0.028616529,
0.0083582522,
0.0226946846,
0.0145566631,
0.0709706172,
0.0502279326,
-0.0101673435,
0.0616608597,
0.0157394111,
-0.0032647101,
0.0066950675,
0.0269339532,
0.0453987196,
-0.0168386679,
-0.008379776,
-0.0137216412,
0.0778757781,
-0.0403963588,
-0.0110571338,
0.0562670492,
0.0284802169,
0.0257500857,
-0.001615865,
0.0154948868,
0.0234037265,
0.0223967712,
0.0181022249,
-0.0063358699,
0.0434436984,
-0.0661876127,
0.0034798423,
0.0572352745,
0.0330815054,
0.0128607377,
-0.0631169826,
-0.0239845607,
0.0245752968,
0.0139040323,
0.0228780918,
-0.0115076257,
-0.0177154914,
-0.0323957764,
0.0190019943,
-0.0079709208,
-0.0748469755,
0.0213839151,
-0.0725056976,
0.0493885167,
0.0454411767,
0.0853921697,
0.0303415693,
-0.0016115955,
-0.0067293686,
-0.0377233177,
0.0182095226,
0.0536137894,
-0.0108616604,
-0.0322098993,
-0.0368371271,
-0.014880796,
0.0148442164,
-0.0159106832,
0.0100003546,
0.0035120726,
0.0287298821,
0.0447801873,
-0.0462822355,
-0.0466094501,
-0.0021330309,
0.042731341,
-0.0284092948,
-0.0063869427,
-0.0098362043,
0.0157447178,
0.050640285,
-0.0266714692,
0.061778605,
-0.0024928169,
0.0049240226,
-0.0315096006,
-0.0489249378,
-0.00651959,
0.0311397389,
0.0242681,
-0.0414764024,
0.0127640879,
0.019092219,
-0.0059342282,
-0.0305390414,
-0.0186664313,
-0.0654332414,
-0.0018807213,
-0.077843532,
-0.0058330493,
0.0093426714,
-0.0142114246,
-0.0608957447,
0.0521702617,
-0.0019229716,
0.0537043698,
0.0182365738,
-0.0337755419,
0.0427157246,
-0.0496754833,
-0.0293365661,
0.0369241759,
-0.0087041557,
0.0488029756,
0.084095493,
0.0305246413,
-0.0523677766,
-0.0214407016,
-0.0994553566,
-0.0162240155,
-0.0100210337,
0.0432584248,
0.0171206482,
-0.0088601494,
0.0008872264,
0.0095615443,
-0.0951687321,
-0.0113891754,
0.0736636817,
0.0281110574,
0.0233600512,
0.0012616427,
0.0027195162,
-0.05516183,
-0.0129957302,
0.0150357047,
0.0070274575,
0.0526008531,
0.0294811521,
-0.057478793,
0.0109643852,
-0.0837808773,
-0.0229202583,
0.0281995907,
-0.0663651526,
0.0256896093,
-0.001043512,
-0.0039931946,
-0.0107717216,
0.0347659402,
-0.0210305676,
0.0302424897,
-0.0225647073,
-0.0833220407,
-0.0219863802,
-0.0233740881,
-0.0390049405,
0.0120200794,
-0.083670795,
0.040271204,
-0.0051511237,
0.0443323329,
-0.0049072583,
-0.054057423,
0.017895218,
-0.0136981513,
-0.0346052982,
-0.0303740744,
-0.0251958016,
-0.0203947835,
0.0569593199,
0.0079245912,
-0.0599334128,
0.0631699413,
-0.0523533374,
0.0066377465,
-0.0277934112,
-0.0039502508,
-0.0244005136,
0.0284673125,
-0.0289927851,
0.0317021795,
-0.0120990314,
0.0092302281,
-0.0395411514,
-0.0080725523,
0.0324287638,
-0.0995154902,
0.0029019536,
-0.0350587852,
-0.0030845928,
-0.0029584079,
0.0034191322,
-0.0456170142,
-0.0459174439,
0.0144974561,
0.016814176,
0.0124303075,
0.0070578023,
-0.004303636,
-0.0031007379,
0.0442284942,
-0.0221471842,
-0.0370173939,
-0.0191317275,
0.0184515771,
0.0547985956,
0.0750873834,
0.0138042588,
0.0527184978,
0.012799358,
-0.0335951447,
0.0816239417,
0.0166508108,
0.0095554916,
0.0338718519,
-0.0376592316,
0.0527205765,
-0.0225133877,
-0.0444196351,
0.0299865752,
0.0224943124,
-0.0387694836,
-0.0132533759,
0.0672773346,
0.0435909703,
-0.0072952667,
-0.0229210965,
-0.0330035202,
0.0123074166,
0.0096952626,
0.0593741983,
-0.091718711,
-0.0019505959,
-0.0196773447,
0.0575338937,
-0.0222584028,
-0.0164778642,
-0.0032982053,
-0.1284004152,
0.0563971363,
0.0011314687,
0.0050383238,
-0.0147147328,
-0.0348264314,
-0.0006501593,
0.0292774923,
-0.0049634688,
0.0406802781,
0.0005888027,
0.0261399914,
0.0117173959,
-0.0017001287,
0.0022703153,
0.0449780449,
-0.0180942249,
0.042591121,
0.0833732933,
0.0255712401,
0.0071190828,
-0.1025436148,
-0.0056366175,
-0.0475001708,
0.027000824,
0.0081788916,
0.0168037079,
0.0021422296,
0.0245643631,
-0.0467001535,
-0.0300592892,
-0.0196061507,
0.0035950479,
0.0032860721,
0.0599174574,
-0.020860225,
-0.0019294218,
-0.060979683,
0.0071781236,
0.0078848591,
0.0771751255,
0.0321737565,
-0.0273464154,
-0.0352576189,
-0.0193473194,
0.0344588645,
-0.0316672176,
-0.0469804369,
0.0118357847,
0.0030734492,
-0.0124178734,
-0.0997159332,
-0.0491009429,
-0.0100967428,
0.0158765949,
-0.0246237833,
-0.0136438319,
-0.0410832167,
0.0172883738,
-0.0087549193,
-0.0107644238,
-0.0299575329,
0.0288952254,
-0.055713769,
0.0152948797,
0.0105366213,
-0.052140113,
-0.0130900042,
0.002303489,
-0.0138141103,
-0.0370414779,
-0.004251488,
0.0452987179,
0.0299015604,
-0.0223774929,
-0.0129463077,
-0.0323745236,
0.0271835234,
0.0303229392,
-0.0554487444,
0.0247161686,
0.0021684952,
0.0021492986,
-0.0103413351,
-0.003562687,
-0.0831161514,
0.0324905179,
-0.0077319033,
0.0501987971,
0.03407792,
-0.0781132206,
0.0228823591,
0.0825393125,
-0.0051726904,
-0.002841149,
0.0098243551,
0.0017122661,
-0.0032928989,
-0.0169405229,
-0.012051899,
-0.0389468782,
-0.0148538966,
-0.0158700068,
-0.0272571016,
0.0117999641,
0.0006170466,
-0.0552203581,
0.0667590126,
-0.0230787676,
0.0129909525,
0.0030224274,
-0.0012282954,
-0.0163238496,
-0.013456543,
-0.0469143949,
-0.0265058726,
-0.0099313064,
0.0497171246,
-0.0058656191,
0.0692461655,
-0.0178404488,
-0.0191050805,
0.0677375495,
0.0491554067,
-0.0621323697,
-0.0535352454,
-0.0351097845,
0.0142579032,
0.0126279807,
0.040558476,
0.0689616352,
-0.0140258148,
0.011492433,
-0.020438863,
-0.0054289764,
0.0344233289,
-0.028685987,
0.0153946858,
0.0173187777,
-0.025834756,
-0.0016815816,
0.0426236019,
-0.0446571372,
-0.0232215319,
-0.0712162107,
-0.0420158803,
-0.0204715058,
-0.0516725108,
-0.0125722652,
0.0080373622,
0.0005337492,
-0.0309930854,
-0.0932205468,
-0.037176948,
-0.0378896594,
0.0654523522,
0.0265993997,
-0.0156326517,
0.024374146,
0.0886848792,
0.0194658209,
-0.0076726773,
-0.0761258304,
0.0112740416,
-0.0681924298,
0.0257767625,
-0.0516731068,
-6.550375414e-33,
-0.0123393312,
-0.0516975746,
0.0107816672,
-0.0402617306,
-0.0093393661,
-0.0032824848,
-0.0153672677,
0.0174032953,
-0.0227792654,
-0.026253093,
-0.0157096703,
-0.0028474671,
0.0058430107,
-0.0088298135,
0.003307774,
-0.004443882,
0.036025513,
-0.0012275612,
-0.0607013516,
0.0406967923,
0.0326714665,
-0.0324362144,
0.0421998166,
-0.0505501479,
0.0522786528,
-0.0285749678,
-0.0253983494,
0.0058033229,
-0.0127041591,
0.0677856952,
0.0041682539,
0.0520818643,
0.0249362048,
-0.0392722413,
0.0160634387,
0.0041318466,
-0.028869966,
-0.031785652,
0.0423683226,
-0.0261068083,
-0.0483902022,
-0.0033713651,
0.0378936529,
-0.0235467833,
-0.0492288284,
0.0274793636,
0.0245113075,
-0.0138153331,
0.0089759296,
-0.0581731983,
-0.0171101168,
0.0244713072,
0.0200243387,
-0.0094458582,
-0.0381802097,
0.0854370221,
-0.0018548069,
0.0029580879,
-0.0446795858,
0.0251841284,
0.003081284,
0.0314665921,
0.0831664354,
-0.038242355,
-0.0203485489,
0.0622030683,
0.0173182469,
-0.0161295272,
-0.0105206715,
-0.0513097532,
0.0057227798,
0.0201547202,
0.0608016327,
0.0720529407,
0.0325910226,
-0.0236632284,
-0.0082885036,
0.0908129141,
0.0249657407,
0.0530787855,
0.010046171,
-0.0203628596,
-0.0527036972,
0.0027649973,
-0.0359331518,
0.0226691049,
-0.0662191436,
-0.0759916902,
0.0444136038,
-0.0020765814,
-0.0337423794,
-0.0409710072,
0.0412923358,
-0.0266540628,
-0.0122679938,
0.0307327397,
-0.0359782688,
0.0080459872,
-0.0109671047,
-0.0052691516,
-0.0029530674,
0.0526000299,
0.0250335522,
0.0074341325,
-0.0057049128,
0.0099668456,
-0.0175972637,
-0.0064180442,
-0.0573427603,
0.0198899526,
-0.0240375996,
0.0434655882,
-0.0190921389,
-0.0545737855,
0.0139117613,
-0.0106775286,
-0.0162547305,
0.0426581837,
-0.0091834906,
0.0260928608,
-0.050262101,
-0.0460827611,
0.0285217892,
0.0058281999,
-0.0418711789,
0.0279409289,
-0.0010064496,
0.022383783,
-0.0137553131,
0.0080989692,
-0.016768828,
0.004307705,
2.822e-7,
0.039379403,
0.0145822,
0.0095231477,
0.0343922004,
-0.0078936033,
0.0337841995,
0.0231822599,
0.0105197337,
0.0468943082,
-0.0078806626,
-0.000012316,
-0.0214587748,
0.037034031,
0.0661009252,
-0.0381956547,
0.0063485918,
-0.0655059293,
-0.005134874,
-0.0156926252,
0.0009555824,
0.1092028245,
0.0279471613,
-0.0204740874,
-0.0209795199,
-0.0306308512,
-0.0104526179,
0.0377607346,
-0.0029845345,
-0.0138684493,
0.0320200212,
0.0977102444,
-0.0192974564,
0.0465907641,
-0.0146842785,
-0.0105512412,
-0.0203028079,
0.0339253992,
0.0326365419,
-0.0009289579,
-0.0561678819,
0.0001739111,
-0.0432962887,
0.0401408896,
-0.0673340037,
0.067998372,
0.0041704746,
-0.0087806201,
-0.0350163057,
-0.0708052814,
-0.0286680833,
0.0155267157,
-0.0155961877,
-0.044731006,
0.0334478691,
-0.0228208769,
0.015714813,
-0.0066495584,
-0.0160237122,
-0.0321984962,
0.0095349401,
-0.0127620157,
-0.0726346597,
-0.0189864431,
0.0043476727,
-0.0453003235,
-0.055879619,
0.0103094485,
2.59536709e-34,
0.0241011139,
-0.0123682255,
0.0290189777,
0.0043482562,
0.0437488593,
0.0463885628,
0.0015751134,
0.0149383545,
0.0216115378,
-0.0474864393,
-0.024431413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18060v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18060v1 | AdaZeta: Adaptive Zeroth-Order Tensor-Train Adaption for Memory-Efficient Large Language Models Fine-Tuning | 2024-06-26T04:33:13 | 2024-06-26T04:33:13 | Yifan Yang, Kai Zhen, Ershad Banijamal, Athanasios Mouchtaris, Zheng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) has achieved remarkable performance
across various natural language processing tasks, yet it demands more and more
memory as model sizes keep growing. To address this issue, the recently
proposed Memory-efficient Zeroth-order (MeZO) methods attempt to fine-tune LLMs
using only forward passes, thereby avoiding the need for a backpropagation
graph. However, significant performance drops and a high risk of divergence
have limited their widespread adoption. In this paper, we propose the Adaptive
Zeroth-order Tensor-Train Adaption (AdaZeta) framework, specifically designed
to improve the performance and convergence of the ZO methods. To enhance
dimension-dependent ZO estimation accuracy, we introduce a fast-forward,
low-parameter tensorized adapter. To tackle the frequently observed divergence
issue in large-scale ZO fine-tuning tasks, we propose an adaptive query number
schedule that guarantees convergence. Detailed theoretical analysis and
extensive experimental results on Roberta-Large and Llama-2-7B models
substantiate the efficacy of our AdaZeta framework in terms of accuracy, memory
efficiency, and convergence speed. | [
0.0195060987,
0.0597144775,
0.0002742336,
0.0176635142,
0.0069130491,
0.0337005928,
-0.0056393608,
0.0120048886,
-0.0040329732,
-0.0290170703,
-0.046241425,
-0.0738393366,
0.0092581864,
-0.0064685014,
0.005219474,
-0.0025143006,
0.0070982175,
-0.0494245775,
0.0111896535,
-0.0109018087,
-0.0188237112,
0.0258570835,
-0.0143819619,
-0.0082888491,
0.0359697454,
-0.0000043383,
-0.0088785002,
-0.0005795599,
-0.0055763088,
-0.0163802654,
-0.010204873,
0.0633997098,
0.0195519645,
0.0597088635,
0.0000019107,
-0.0120007358,
-0.0115171643,
-0.0058785235,
0.0119503085,
0.0058574718,
0.0450428277,
-0.0554008856,
-0.0242408868,
0.0190523285,
0.0051462287,
-0.027787555,
0.0561840534,
0.0401462428,
0.0387813896,
0.0939652994,
-0.0155095812,
-0.016857015,
0.0489771739,
-0.0396881364,
-0.0200422965,
-0.0824259371,
0.0504128039,
-0.0530313477,
-0.0288587902,
-0.0022515056,
-0.0038546671,
0.0271744151,
-0.0342535563,
0.0189079754,
-0.009076097,
0.031637568,
-0.0162778739,
-0.0115467682,
-0.0166379977,
0.074498415,
-0.025416933,
0.014169977,
-0.0037563702,
0.0009281072,
-0.0403673165,
-0.0053582909,
-0.042706605,
0.0092567625,
0.0494790077,
0.0128293568,
0.0070171002,
-0.0607890859,
0.0258503836,
0.0341646709,
-0.0862762183,
0.0451839715,
0.047191292,
-0.0050429427,
0.023943197,
-0.0092847105,
-0.0309977382,
0.003394305,
-0.0061034719,
0.007957017,
-0.0181357618,
-0.0214263797,
-0.0362461768,
-0.1187841669,
-0.0097354157,
-0.0489049479,
0.1127542332,
0.0510424115,
-0.0078465752,
0.0526877306,
-0.0579820275,
0.0282007549,
-0.0177438967,
-0.0328990594,
-0.0417922251,
-0.0271797441,
-0.0079247775,
0.0238504503,
-0.0553182028,
0.0081046354,
-0.0458900928,
-0.0375297181,
-0.0504278466,
0.0159782991,
-0.0047386773,
-0.0472309291,
0.0061268881,
0.0086716851,
-0.0027259116,
-0.0022923644,
-0.0190913379,
0.0764707997,
0.0090086814,
0.0083107902,
-0.0857789144,
-0.0196356457,
-0.0265370551,
0.032145597,
0.0387512147,
-0.0349525884,
0.0368124917,
0.0257086698,
-0.0152990697,
-0.0466874354,
-0.0206702724,
0.0379555635,
0.0136929611,
-0.0823110417,
0.0193083063,
-0.030898191,
0.0438622832,
-0.0098452959,
0.0310504008,
-0.0294894688,
-0.005621362,
-0.0005009148,
-0.1040291414,
0.050103616,
0.0100158146,
0.011760301,
-0.0256111883,
-0.0093896706,
0.0885332227,
0.0651171654,
0.0361808911,
-0.012498307,
0.0075203986,
-0.0159392636,
-0.0601089336,
0.04295405,
0.0341832973,
0.0208921358,
-0.0440550558,
-0.0016633814,
0.0086389072,
0.0518510155,
0.0351103172,
0.0376283936,
-0.0472228341,
-0.0186045244,
0.0339478739,
0.0398945995,
0.0659065172,
0.0102737434,
-0.0062572793,
-0.0386291184,
-0.0271141008,
-0.0479260832,
-0.0575947575,
0.0429903828,
-0.0405567288,
-0.0054568779,
0.0654703453,
0.0498451665,
-0.0320279375,
-0.0048705172,
-0.001561859,
-0.0041928203,
-0.0009211672,
0.0007428972,
0.0706197247,
-0.0132086892,
-0.0283453818,
0.0318382084,
0.0304613691,
-0.0320402086,
-0.0176512413,
-0.0445525423,
0.013274963,
0.0687265694,
0.0233447924,
-0.0360342376,
-0.0201079138,
0.0166712813,
0.0370309018,
0.0087980488,
0.0083356509,
0.0245597865,
0.0423063487,
-0.059521582,
-0.0084790774,
0.0266720559,
0.0088566849,
-0.0031201667,
-0.0035109415,
0.0523119532,
0.0330454595,
-0.0137498556,
-0.023036439,
0.0308159143,
-0.0312154014,
-0.0442011692,
0.0359988362,
0.0089535993,
0.002653006,
0.0440446064,
-0.000880618,
-0.0072712749,
0.0374696292,
-0.0342058949,
0.0018975483,
-0.0768453479,
-0.0262024254,
0.0119640445,
0.0468219854,
0.018172238,
0.0421353765,
0.0125925271,
-0.0532065481,
-0.0549311526,
0.0955339149,
0.009005934,
0.022103129,
-0.0439235233,
0.0093671735,
0.0148230875,
0.0634550974,
-0.0175503585,
-0.002245951,
-0.0112281507,
0.0064047207,
0.0231005643,
-0.0295858085,
-0.0064152069,
-0.0061531267,
-0.0659122691,
0.0573036149,
0.0422467068,
0.0310117584,
-0.0002226364,
0.0078860503,
-0.0037614396,
-0.0299116597,
-0.1024891138,
0.0247856881,
-0.0463754237,
0.0065087336,
0.03081524,
0.0116279777,
-0.0011784299,
-0.0074855089,
0.0106043406,
0.0420239717,
-0.0296792351,
0.0274140108,
-0.0055122175,
-0.007576691,
-0.0138496356,
-0.0034964466,
-0.0455764793,
0.0043167877,
0.0388375372,
-0.0544584617,
0.0060027111,
-0.0308335163,
-0.0383161902,
-0.044113338,
0.062710762,
0.0028379716,
-0.0088397078,
0.0061520413,
-0.0335168652,
0.0470320918,
0.0554990023,
0.0058493768,
0.0245571602,
0.0573731624,
0.0135872113,
0.0040772506,
-0.0090085948,
-0.0463933311,
-0.0626908541,
-0.0245499425,
-0.0254335105,
-0.0273932721,
0.0637887716,
-0.0290469918,
-0.0151125267,
-0.0426231585,
-0.0237717293,
0.0057894867,
0.0122957602,
-0.0048264451,
0.0307388417,
-0.0092190159,
-0.0034239755,
0.0181684606,
0.0075509562,
0.0352893434,
-0.0337636843,
-0.008812991,
-0.0352980196,
-0.0242832433,
-0.0431491025,
0.0019025501,
0.0170184355,
0.0415507294,
0.0083658667,
0.0161036253,
-0.0127245318,
-0.029382268,
0.0247221813,
-0.0222916547,
0.0356317014,
-0.0095966095,
0.0157089494,
-0.0309955068,
-0.0022748094,
0.0103957504,
-0.0221914034,
-0.016361773,
0.0480341949,
-0.0207167417,
-0.0533528179,
-0.0283507835,
0.0368867442,
0.0039604721,
0.063055329,
-0.0334382541,
0.0057580923,
-0.0147744929,
0.0428488255,
0.0757541656,
0.028839929,
0.0164516848,
0.0064781979,
-0.0072190757,
0.0529488437,
0.0729271099,
-0.0089696767,
-0.0444270559,
-0.012764209,
0.050339222,
-0.0193480346,
0.0017831635,
0.0003808489,
-0.0113059515,
-0.0358651541,
0.0177352652,
0.1093422696,
0.0047378768,
-0.0524617545,
-0.0067844992,
0.0363283977,
0.0503362231,
0.0253131203,
0.0335214213,
-0.0612914935,
-0.0296461284,
-0.0137598719,
0.057138972,
0.0052414667,
-0.0418713167,
-0.0112089803,
-0.0939037427,
0.0074265017,
0.0207392108,
-0.0166168958,
-0.007402882,
-0.0616472848,
0.0346720926,
-0.0268078391,
0.0434920378,
0.0254802387,
-0.0044712806,
-0.0399055593,
0.0221669283,
0.0697040632,
-0.0213226452,
-0.0108336154,
-0.0222063959,
0.0566204228,
-0.0219604131,
0.0299055669,
-0.0040160296,
0.0063329316,
0.0429961905,
-0.0210443176,
-0.0008354983,
-0.0178483743,
0.0207938254,
-0.0215261802,
-0.0001851232,
0.0041759009,
0.0412093438,
-0.0328870565,
0.0104432926,
-0.0408222452,
0.0764605999,
0.0193192866,
-0.0293019172,
-0.0253720395,
-0.0185389183,
-0.0311065465,
0.0549815111,
0.0066617304,
-0.0535533093,
-0.0381211303,
0.0410865024,
-0.0015601928,
-0.0138445031,
0.0113203032,
-0.0387492068,
-0.0205446295,
-0.0423069,
-0.0211693309,
0.0556560792,
0.0112041701,
0.0384324379,
0.0029474357,
0.0149728721,
0.0177699123,
-0.0305885132,
-0.0173421185,
0.0622544922,
-0.0343313627,
0.0158667583,
-0.0658252016,
0.0017699115,
0.0380438194,
0.0011776958,
-0.0000877905,
0.0137184775,
-0.0836574882,
-0.0782093257,
-0.0074936259,
-0.0011292747,
0.0086501576,
0.0199445225,
0.0089661824,
-0.0825758874,
0.0577106625,
0.0273125544,
-0.0548951216,
0.0574822053,
0.0227390733,
-0.0373283289,
-0.0088230977,
0.0438301973,
-0.0187094584,
-0.0002620431,
0.0306544323,
0.0347074941,
-0.0009651009,
-0.0502322651,
-0.026045179,
0.0224898662,
0.0525246747,
-0.0010723787,
0.0295430385,
-0.0401307642,
0.0475711823,
0.0072132153,
0.0167290512,
-0.0298789199,
-0.0066889827,
0.039488513,
0.0076165195,
-0.0420437232,
-0.0164639037,
0.0199637283,
0.0054510329,
-0.0403420962,
-0.0037138062,
0.0077717509,
-0.0262708459,
0.0571291819,
0.0038770749,
-0.0056459624,
0.0272451285,
0.0029234625,
0.061970789,
-0.0533568561,
0.0406720191,
0.0098643228,
-0.0085963989,
-0.0809814259,
0.0540756322,
-0.0160376225,
-0.0845509619,
-0.0153490314,
0.0290913563,
0.0481132567,
-0.0116121611,
0.0600123368,
-0.0081839645,
-0.0194474254,
-0.009971221,
0.0130199892,
-0.0261713527,
0.026944736,
0.0122714015,
0.0001611941,
0.0081905257,
0.0701840967,
0.0489228889,
0.0480895266,
0.0278024189,
-0.0146394866,
-0.0016129276,
-0.0053190547,
-0.023717029,
0.0107983863,
0.0638978779,
-0.0449435823,
0.0188181959,
-0.0093443114,
-0.0641473457,
-0.0209983811,
-0.0740679055,
-0.0376956388,
-0.0515708178,
0.0206872672,
0.0204038918,
-0.0124833947,
0.0296371374,
-0.0106828315,
-0.0164183415,
-0.0076116985,
-0.03272672,
0.0239231419,
-6.566315852e-33,
-0.0318957902,
0.0358267948,
0.0012705269,
-0.0412256606,
-0.0272592995,
-0.0208310056,
-0.0152338352,
0.0040819361,
-0.0232021865,
-0.0225422569,
-0.0169948339,
-0.0131015442,
-0.0049602804,
0.0095504466,
-0.0145725831,
0.0472215749,
0.0450145155,
-0.0468170531,
-0.0277180839,
0.0308533609,
0.0386937968,
0.0307249855,
0.0693378448,
-0.0492265075,
-0.0299145821,
0.008848994,
-0.0025224451,
0.0329479203,
0.025204435,
0.017697813,
-0.0203838106,
0.0372142494,
-0.0013586731,
-0.0502442308,
0.0111115454,
-0.0115555599,
-0.0982439145,
-0.0135622891,
0.0404036976,
-0.0108186016,
0.0075058043,
0.0069054528,
0.0174523108,
0.0389381871,
-0.0107730208,
-0.0294146016,
0.0015656193,
-0.0024800848,
-0.0587419495,
0.0134714069,
-0.0429939665,
0.0288207941,
-0.0099683963,
-0.002929142,
0.0687131658,
-0.0064270776,
-0.0180684905,
0.0424338952,
-0.0543148294,
0.0030676157,
0.0183376167,
0.0337104388,
0.0417055711,
0.0345835462,
-0.0016669499,
0.017129695,
0.0422042422,
-0.006802401,
0.0097644841,
-0.0119294794,
0.0438853242,
0.0090813097,
0.0196194258,
-0.0107661849,
0.0090925666,
-0.0414227992,
-0.0685476139,
-0.0535726584,
0.0150743928,
0.0349947922,
0.061371766,
0.0142470477,
-0.0344030671,
-0.0305133145,
-0.044668261,
-0.0211620219,
-0.0597827956,
0.0139108282,
-0.0116255488,
0.0334992558,
-0.0606897362,
-0.0584717356,
0.0310271997,
-0.0631948188,
0.0358925536,
0.0366482958,
-0.0242122021,
-0.0112266904,
0.0087629473,
0.0305635687,
-0.093615599,
-0.0498993844,
0.0020881507,
-0.0540634096,
-0.0064091315,
-0.0129289366,
0.0311549008,
0.0400573835,
-0.081674397,
-0.0318239741,
-0.0393276885,
0.0067531327,
0.0173366535,
0.0959298685,
-0.0203639567,
0.0029457607,
0.0067927474,
0.0651928186,
0.0417711884,
0.0306671672,
0.013357712,
-0.0345698893,
0.0538700782,
-0.0157573838,
-0.0355769359,
0.0087259989,
0.013273282,
-0.010865625,
0.0522318184,
-0.0541180372,
-0.0410153493,
0.0364295654,
2.756e-7,
0.0116137005,
0.0297379419,
-0.0348177142,
-0.0010033036,
0.0316463113,
0.0386890769,
-0.0061248909,
0.0215292349,
0.0483477414,
0.0514730886,
0.0357525013,
0.0269421358,
0.0072472682,
-0.0259492733,
-0.0555905141,
-0.0214686375,
-0.0287430808,
0.0296667442,
-0.0547003411,
-0.026562728,
-0.0274978299,
0.0922999531,
0.0253019221,
-0.017109815,
0.0135128116,
-0.0617757849,
0.0429397523,
-0.0059561292,
0.0245506931,
0.0248915814,
0.02528744,
0.0639016777,
-0.0082665319,
-0.0052036499,
0.0014376204,
0.0750389248,
-0.0122819571,
0.06450703,
-0.0404975414,
-0.0345485024,
0.0514509976,
-0.0115981279,
0.0044234018,
-0.0579170808,
0.0781484172,
-0.0055903303,
-0.0144540723,
-0.0645238906,
0.0003174811,
-0.0254982933,
0.0382602625,
-0.028883351,
0.0328253247,
0.0290872995,
0.0564721376,
-0.0250738151,
-0.0266339295,
-0.0647218525,
0.0057095559,
0.0212449562,
-0.0134267863,
-0.0576560274,
-0.0314663351,
-0.0238940567,
0.0165839102,
-0.024118131,
-0.0032389013,
2.125664802e-34,
0.0464235432,
-0.0203996524,
0.0020736915,
0.0204154719,
0.0257545356,
-0.0323357098,
0.0043684025,
0.0100257387,
-0.0055877971,
-0.1345548183,
-0.0409772284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18616v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18616v1 | Towards Large Language Model Aided Program Refinement | 2024-06-26T04:29:27 | 2024-06-26T04:29:27 | Yufan Cai, Zhe Hou, Xiaokun Luan, David Miguel Sanan Baena, Yun Lin, Jun Sun, Jin Song Dong | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, K.6.3 | Program refinement involves correctness-preserving transformations from
formal high-level specification statements into executable programs.
Traditional verification tool support for program refinement is highly
interactive and lacks automation. On the other hand, the emergence of large
language models (LLMs) enables automatic code generations from informal natural
language specifications. However, code generated by LLMs is often unreliable.
Moreover, the opaque procedure from specification to code provided by LLM is an
uncontrolled black box. We propose LLM4PR, a tool that combines formal program
refinement techniques with informal LLM-based methods to (1) transform the
specification to preconditions and postconditions, (2) automatically build
prompts based on refinement calculus, (3) interact with LLM to generate code,
and finally, (4) verify that the generated code satisfies the conditions of
refinement calculus, thus guaranteeing the correctness of the code. We have
implemented our tool using GPT4, Coq, and Coqhammer, and evaluated it on the
HumanEval and EvalPlus datasets. | [
-0.0248057786,
0.071664229,
-0.0125206923,
0.0364421904,
-0.010186485,
-0.0086787203,
-0.0579825677,
-0.0277496353,
-0.0029434178,
-0.0086768884,
0.0112043712,
0.0083627682,
0.023680687,
0.0442800112,
0.006782813,
-0.0107715307,
0.0454992652,
-0.0436440445,
0.0047477954,
0.0242253486,
-0.0097717261,
0.0214641616,
0.0417940877,
0.0354853794,
0.0239010435,
-0.03225917,
-0.0045017111,
0.0426375531,
-0.0310694426,
-0.0216246471,
0.0093597909,
0.0589363798,
0.0073005995,
-0.0039606164,
0.0000024411,
-0.0612398386,
-0.0353833623,
0.0569160506,
0.0078971805,
0.0710895732,
-0.0038023347,
-0.0017057674,
-0.0020493485,
0.0241412371,
-0.0486901067,
-0.0438395068,
0.0196289662,
-0.0263551231,
0.1168448254,
0.0593327843,
0.0116466563,
-0.0629877374,
0.0079279542,
0.0349930897,
-0.0124008171,
-0.0281984564,
0.0289722886,
0.0176478177,
0.0011895021,
0.0044421959,
0.0299454145,
0.001579357,
0.043530453,
-0.0334495343,
-0.025699269,
-0.0101187443,
-0.0515081398,
-0.0224399231,
-0.0095524201,
0.0198664125,
-0.0034328634,
-0.0569675453,
0.0107259694,
0.0189165976,
-0.0199351199,
-0.0499168523,
-0.0298868492,
0.027747456,
-0.0067923442,
0.0238209683,
0.0069299978,
-0.0528766029,
0.0300528333,
-0.0132108834,
-0.0247354787,
0.0895710215,
0.0233101584,
-0.0250388533,
-0.034944918,
-0.0438586101,
-0.0204123054,
-0.0420579389,
0.0246717501,
0.0416407213,
-0.0325276069,
-0.0143013643,
-0.0267443918,
0.0017460759,
0.0391326882,
-0.0063768341,
0.0287806615,
0.0384908542,
0.003035123,
0.014091216,
-0.0320348851,
0.0556891039,
0.0017091914,
-0.0258270875,
-0.025866881,
0.0240532029,
-0.0164522566,
-0.0121557368,
-0.0785855725,
0.0060981368,
0.007631856,
0.0865417868,
-0.0350531712,
0.0514016226,
-0.0258642361,
0.0911100879,
-0.0140690701,
-0.0536047071,
0.0143139418,
-0.0012369334,
0.0263012815,
-0.0240239296,
-0.0061166221,
-0.0456138402,
-0.0367734693,
-0.0574790165,
0.0114748236,
0.0179472249,
-0.06218604,
-0.0062774448,
0.0087205069,
0.0466224179,
0.004243026,
0.0461078919,
-0.0483569279,
-0.0562030897,
0.033397682,
-0.0255724452,
-0.0245337635,
-0.1153130308,
-0.0211453103,
0.0003700265,
-0.0102173183,
-0.0307727437,
-0.0203404687,
-0.0232720971,
0.0201492533,
0.0457515568,
-0.0685474724,
0.0287091378,
0.0204232819,
0.0255261958,
0.0272204131,
0.0217833314,
0.0381556302,
-0.0372112058,
0.0185698513,
-0.0525181107,
0.023564782,
0.052025672,
-0.0353112929,
0.0112613747,
-0.029173363,
0.0306688976,
0.0245013181,
-0.0157722495,
-0.0293325689,
0.0399537981,
-0.0096743423,
0.0141960206,
-0.0186373293,
0.0202751551,
0.0021303168,
0.0219846088,
0.0724190623,
0.0568463579,
0.0050519709,
-0.0070604668,
-0.0368486568,
0.0007995841,
-0.0175633915,
0.0128839109,
-0.0147106368,
0.048321154,
0.0011367605,
-0.0785406753,
-0.001906035,
0.0323405862,
0.026459692,
-0.0287700091,
0.0170851052,
0.0165675934,
-0.0232689567,
0.0301059447,
0.0099723469,
-0.070329383,
-0.030294124,
-0.0292820558,
0.0536035411,
0.055573985,
0.0401430726,
-0.0472853705,
-0.0443861634,
-0.0011803909,
-0.0148197524,
0.0015332865,
0.0435735285,
-0.0189581104,
-0.0250672009,
-0.0227956306,
0.0023373831,
0.0104815615,
0.0385606587,
0.0241331328,
0.0242976435,
-0.0281774569,
0.0342856012,
0.0096262638,
-0.0643708706,
0.0385560542,
0.0241112933,
-0.0361843705,
0.0195060335,
0.0021303121,
0.0222466737,
-0.0162544549,
-0.041053202,
0.0260510724,
0.0761161372,
0.0346727259,
0.0133691123,
-0.0563730337,
-0.0025492846,
-0.0058608279,
0.0460426845,
-0.0102153961,
-0.0520991832,
0.0129170083,
-0.0643632859,
-0.0006742115,
0.0439706482,
0.0265896022,
0.0128672412,
-0.0207286477,
0.0597548299,
-0.0537568517,
-0.0260704458,
-0.0231594872,
-0.0059466758,
0.0541669019,
-0.0179750547,
0.0066340184,
0.0111289062,
0.0006691859,
0.0273972023,
-0.0384429656,
-0.0202199239,
-0.0094623026,
0.0347460434,
0.0016412572,
0.0989616886,
0.0036831694,
-0.0009552201,
-0.1028385684,
0.060665898,
-0.0069158585,
0.0133083882,
0.0196526852,
0.0281814579,
-0.0153050991,
0.0071809855,
0.0147778289,
-0.0103021916,
0.0084043648,
0.0099175628,
0.0381076671,
-0.0146309165,
-0.0917469487,
0.0129938396,
-0.0055086366,
-0.0339741483,
0.0258897468,
-0.0008612708,
0.0167162698,
-0.0877332836,
0.0406196788,
-0.0071518985,
0.0253369082,
0.00080274,
-0.0107601676,
0.026413288,
-0.0281703379,
0.0085652899,
0.0132890819,
-0.0136969145,
-0.0174680874,
0.0634103566,
0.0098592648,
-0.0358458459,
0.0225746669,
0.0390643254,
-0.0498917215,
0.0051249349,
-0.0183999967,
0.0366589651,
0.0609427504,
-0.0289870668,
-0.0166635197,
-0.0193309374,
0.0187062882,
0.0125865312,
0.0302486587,
-0.0164541919,
-0.0585622452,
-0.0163060967,
0.0281729996,
-0.0034813781,
-0.072425589,
0.077172026,
-0.0693133101,
-0.0375513434,
-0.0060303058,
-0.0424356647,
-0.0284550563,
0.0480499156,
-0.0167849921,
-0.004671453,
0.0094733033,
0.0052776928,
0.0130005572,
-0.0197586082,
0.0170578547,
-0.0263086297,
0.1118371859,
-0.0691509172,
0.0087356837,
-0.0159002561,
-0.022451818,
-0.0311897453,
-0.0145200193,
-0.0045778961,
0.0127776777,
0.0140648447,
-0.0077168313,
0.0591896176,
0.0117712086,
-0.0279874951,
0.0457737334,
0.0155709935,
-0.0393519215,
0.008949995,
-0.0562979095,
-0.0271794554,
-0.0337256677,
-0.0196958631,
0.0062073609,
0.0099657876,
0.0256693568,
-0.0126752276,
0.0032559915,
-0.0848962665,
-0.0203576926,
0.0338124596,
-0.0139105637,
-0.007859041,
0.0552864894,
0.028757019,
-0.0888318792,
-0.0202668626,
0.0711589903,
0.0179626569,
-0.0283916034,
0.0160680022,
-0.0078690732,
0.0583063662,
0.0483132973,
0.0666359067,
-0.0914749801,
-0.0259160157,
-0.0031027552,
0.0286627002,
0.0136980321,
0.0121200308,
-0.0439570434,
-0.0932272896,
0.0707577914,
0.029360909,
-0.0372016951,
0.019376263,
-0.0246900786,
-0.0283522028,
0.0415208228,
-0.0199960507,
0.0718434751,
0.0156256575,
-0.0073417542,
-0.0204000957,
-0.0356388353,
-0.0048012035,
0.0446640365,
-0.0253657885,
0.0187742598,
0.0554909594,
-0.0063361842,
0.0003264538,
-0.0096790958,
0.0890223905,
0.0178931616,
-0.0058941878,
-0.0631209463,
-0.0440573245,
0.0127731133,
-0.0026105985,
0.0238716025,
-0.0035975447,
-0.0289236698,
-0.0196693428,
0.0549504384,
0.0704097301,
-0.0144153666,
-0.0436562672,
0.0121649466,
-0.0174751766,
-0.0094747022,
0.0365837999,
0.0122260805,
0.0135855842,
-0.0291560907,
-0.0500857383,
-0.0685797483,
-0.0173675157,
-0.0095762266,
-0.0471812896,
-0.0311067905,
0.0016019735,
-0.0110250302,
0.0703908652,
0.0394089296,
0.0188964512,
0.0274693482,
-0.0357831307,
0.0476312861,
-0.0334037468,
-0.0744029731,
0.0436736755,
-0.0492544882,
0.0106880926,
-0.0205619838,
-0.0053054104,
0.0033055886,
-0.0040592174,
-0.0183025859,
0.0607824214,
-0.0345694944,
-0.0508266948,
-0.0406951942,
0.0794584006,
0.0226207357,
0.0273452159,
-0.0541145429,
-0.038547352,
-0.0487209931,
0.0271365587,
-0.0426994227,
0.0040476518,
-0.0018745605,
-0.0091631915,
0.0105480282,
-0.0253687855,
-0.0509214886,
-0.0048174919,
-0.0002391994,
-0.0329321213,
0.0121096494,
-0.0266820714,
0.0445477553,
0.0888344347,
0.0293392539,
-0.0077096503,
-0.0095458012,
0.0005187991,
-0.0103996703,
-0.0047528357,
-0.0626952723,
-0.0618849918,
0.0606875457,
-0.0017027772,
-0.0421839096,
0.0189465918,
-0.0261334982,
-0.0611741021,
0.0453696921,
-0.0108670611,
0.0321053304,
-0.0153104635,
0.0022210877,
0.0931808278,
-0.0258514807,
-0.001964726,
0.0283398181,
-0.001660149,
0.0304906927,
-0.0253496915,
0.0083600255,
0.0166351721,
0.0667760521,
-0.0266155042,
0.0211670212,
0.0150341736,
-0.0578515492,
-0.0070915874,
0.0455923937,
0.0177571513,
0.0585828833,
0.0316635147,
-0.0376460664,
0.0037986261,
-0.0400411561,
0.040136341,
-0.0018897421,
-0.0659506768,
0.0194072388,
0.045186203,
-0.0236665849,
-0.0520366132,
0.0542096384,
0.0066149626,
-0.0105082327,
0.0044070547,
-0.0264215562,
-0.0382211469,
-0.0298443623,
0.0273202956,
-0.0312744379,
-0.0593189821,
-0.0590955317,
-0.032762181,
-0.053760279,
-0.0120535456,
0.0360445343,
0.0042152475,
0.0144318622,
0.0125557957,
0.0746431053,
0.0109928362,
-0.0686282441,
-0.0181175917,
0.0034298741,
0.0098231491,
-0.0506816655,
-0.0090284152,
-6.494262456e-33,
-0.0152116176,
-0.0031978826,
0.0204087757,
0.0010498984,
-0.0071780286,
-0.03054698,
-0.0554190949,
-0.0178529397,
0.0617177859,
-0.0024351033,
0.0313883498,
-0.0023990176,
-0.0025044137,
-0.0427162871,
-0.0050145639,
-0.0034376474,
0.0376043916,
0.0227372777,
-0.0842746571,
-0.0171947647,
-0.017642796,
-0.0211171154,
0.0226300377,
-0.0359737016,
0.0094183227,
-0.0251152292,
-0.0105188768,
0.0604965575,
-0.0270798691,
0.0309727006,
0.033207573,
0.0042979531,
0.0005069022,
-0.0289410986,
-0.011918758,
0.000603398,
-0.034958452,
-0.0133509757,
0.0654083937,
-0.0100169322,
-0.0197069421,
-0.0206446107,
0.0814909637,
0.0104111945,
-0.0587987192,
0.059637621,
-0.0188304801,
0.0149544794,
0.0476610139,
-0.023461666,
-0.066721648,
0.0266156401,
-0.0519510768,
-0.0154662365,
-0.0327370949,
0.0059061381,
-0.0117811626,
0.0097165145,
0.0335355513,
-0.0010235012,
0.0656175613,
0.0198652577,
0.0852798894,
-0.0151843075,
0.0038276121,
-0.0076216669,
-0.0086615281,
0.0435189195,
-0.0395953059,
-0.0018585109,
0.0146765532,
0.0144619169,
-0.0031229975,
0.0163797662,
0.009616836,
-0.0158288144,
-0.0339186229,
0.0414423421,
-0.0384561308,
0.0483501405,
0.0081306295,
0.0012222233,
-0.0041162712,
-0.0327621959,
-0.0529228076,
0.0454485714,
-0.0443277545,
0.0043439744,
0.0282793939,
-0.0086604757,
-0.0398280695,
0.0191859119,
-0.0271594133,
-0.024112016,
-0.0101324487,
0.0117411641,
-0.0486078709,
-0.0347538069,
-0.0153923426,
0.0292793121,
0.0835233629,
-0.0099922763,
0.0193422493,
-0.0527782887,
0.0658992752,
0.016261695,
-0.0005727112,
0.0259943213,
-0.0481804311,
0.0300493166,
-0.0421032123,
-0.0024700919,
-0.0052297418,
0.0214978233,
0.013133632,
-0.0020781888,
0.0204540826,
0.0479214825,
0.0084067769,
-0.0366251729,
-0.0513879918,
0.0388989262,
0.0566973612,
0.029940391,
-0.0055374857,
-0.0077495123,
0.0066238358,
0.0218842942,
0.0267812312,
-0.0007953763,
-0.0313333273,
0.025638938,
3.226e-7,
0.0192395449,
0.0405345932,
0.006520865,
0.0367976315,
-0.0226695035,
0.0263937321,
-0.025458524,
-0.0284584165,
0.017222194,
-0.0097958623,
-0.0191605147,
0.0417868793,
0.0419915989,
0.0219709221,
-0.0412439369,
0.0147275859,
-0.0108488873,
-0.0056017842,
-0.0735089108,
-0.0099683469,
0.0556927696,
0.039371226,
0.0222132001,
0.0030705957,
0.0035634181,
-0.0637279227,
-0.0249762125,
-0.0263676159,
-0.0101620071,
0.0623152442,
-0.055350244,
0.0001832576,
0.0256452579,
0.0140468646,
0.0075701508,
-0.0249592364,
-0.0330076367,
0.1250246465,
-0.0062935641,
0.1077029109,
0.0318004414,
-0.0399902537,
0.0024721168,
-0.0603708364,
0.0391806588,
-0.0047528907,
0.0055247452,
-0.0374124572,
-0.0179561041,
-0.0475353859,
-0.0128927976,
-0.0434207059,
0.0348242521,
0.0140591105,
0.0036101553,
-0.0000525732,
-0.0306120366,
0.0077192248,
-0.0756811574,
0.0243852325,
-0.0182346944,
-0.0499487408,
-0.0169247072,
0.0436606668,
0.0088086529,
-0.0362548679,
0.0674814284,
3.538065804e-34,
0.0700887665,
-0.0186412241,
0.0286350269,
0.0047662952,
0.0393707454,
-0.0005967502,
-0.0583003648,
0.0370098315,
-0.0042011202,
-0.0118370894,
-0.0132860867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18049v1 | Improving Entity Recognition Using Ensembles of Deep Learning and Fine-tuned Large Language Models: A Case Study on Adverse Event Extraction from Multiple Sources | 2024-06-26T03:56:21 | 2024-06-26T03:56:21 | Yiming Li, Deepthi Viswaroopan, William He, Jianfu Li, Xu Zuo, Hua Xu, Cui Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Adverse event (AE) extraction following COVID-19 vaccines from text data is
crucial for monitoring and analyzing the safety profiles of immunizations.
Traditional deep learning models are adept at learning intricate feature
representations and dependencies in sequential data, but often require
extensive labeled data. In contrast, large language models (LLMs) excel in
understanding contextual information, but exhibit unstable performance on named
entity recognition tasks, possibly due to their broad but unspecific training.
This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of LLMs and traditional deep
learning models in AE extraction, and to assess the impact of ensembling these
models on performance. In this study, we utilized reports and posts from the
VAERS (n=621), Twitter (n=9,133), and Reddit (n=131) as our corpora. Our goal
was to extract three types of entities: "vaccine", "shot", and "ae". We
explored and fine-tuned (except GPT-4) multiple LLMs, including GPT-2, GPT-3.5,
GPT-4, and Llama-2, as well as traditional deep learning models like RNN and
BioBERT. To enhance performance, we created ensembles of the three models with
the best performance. For evaluation, we used strict and relaxed F1 scores to
evaluate the performance for each entity type, and micro-average F1 was used to
assess the overall performance. The ensemble model achieved the highest
performance in "vaccine", "shot", and "ae" with strict F1-scores of 0.878,
0.930, and 0.925, respectively, along with a micro-average score of 0.903. In
conclusion, this study demonstrates the effectiveness and robustness of
ensembling fine-tuned traditional deep learning models and LLMs, for extracting
AE-related information. This study contributes to the advancement of biomedical
natural language processing, providing valuable insights into improving AE
extraction from text data for pharmacovigilance and public health surveillance. | [
0.0167277809,
0.068032153,
0.0093114106,
-0.0060856948,
-0.0041493056,
0.0456446745,
-0.0029764406,
-0.0148304021,
0.0313550085,
-0.0299989413,
-0.0078206835,
-0.0557020493,
-0.0151984645,
0.0360514298,
0.0026413649,
-0.0405094437,
0.0404658318,
0.0182334892,
0.0062848912,
0.0214872807,
-0.0120341312,
0.0283359177,
-0.0179067571,
0.0396260694,
0.0449215136,
0.0140432287,
0.006981398,
-0.0025101753,
0.073116295,
-0.0871593207,
0.0152030177,
0.0065962886,
-0.0152396653,
0.0841341168,
0.0000019216,
-0.0302725192,
-0.0346713886,
0.0112869516,
-0.0369954519,
0.0013844479,
0.0112398788,
-0.0360412598,
-0.0083667487,
0.0065840636,
-0.0140267406,
-0.0955182016,
0.0390742384,
0.0569481738,
0.010490559,
0.075308241,
-0.0097915325,
-0.0494099855,
0.0692310035,
-0.0056918911,
-0.0061107683,
-0.0507326908,
0.0660257488,
-0.0435777865,
0.0141915185,
0.0150009645,
0.0405864269,
0.0394693352,
-0.0025265994,
0.0199821871,
0.0170595814,
0.0560148247,
-0.042718064,
-0.005024116,
-0.00416261,
0.1070941538,
-0.0143687772,
0.0017132411,
0.0223293193,
-0.0171506424,
-0.0335399024,
-0.0323788598,
-0.0262331646,
0.0027518736,
-0.0362299196,
0.0328950733,
0.0032816436,
0.0165341832,
0.066227518,
0.0183621943,
-0.0228040926,
0.0163613949,
0.0019061861,
-0.0343740322,
0.0189595558,
0.007819511,
-0.0194323696,
-0.0388853811,
0.0742049739,
0.0290453229,
-0.0148834297,
0.0371672474,
-0.0085058222,
-0.0565054491,
0.0365833305,
-0.0585811473,
-0.0141737461,
-0.0091552883,
-0.0104998508,
0.0299369954,
-0.0452024154,
-0.0082890783,
-0.0158528946,
0.0222079456,
0.0370218121,
-0.0023117452,
-0.0824910104,
-0.0004656463,
-0.006412168,
0.0660369769,
-0.0120926229,
0.0175866652,
-0.069742322,
-0.0263068471,
0.0050366046,
-0.0015808516,
-0.0057004751,
0.023146227,
-0.0256005395,
0.0073270351,
0.0227528438,
0.0424872823,
-0.0007292546,
0.0017179786,
0.008435267,
-0.0610412769,
0.013144277,
-0.0451599509,
0.0340434611,
-0.0228382368,
0.0252193585,
0.0756483525,
0.034583807,
-0.084402822,
-0.0108562233,
0.0010522302,
-0.0361954421,
-0.0318720117,
-0.0248270426,
-0.0396513976,
0.0612948015,
-0.0014037447,
-0.0099185091,
-0.0446186587,
0.0094205448,
-0.0288296435,
-0.07837791,
0.0667634383,
-0.0461808629,
-0.0044374149,
0.0497139581,
0.0236496329,
0.0577886254,
0.0267130844,
0.051034838,
0.0210361555,
0.0093173953,
-0.0068051037,
0.0192258861,
0.0168341715,
0.0047659501,
-0.0402920619,
0.0161250997,
-0.0100865094,
-0.0187274907,
0.0384624749,
0.0008338115,
0.0407965146,
-0.0016528589,
-0.0045867353,
0.055437047,
0.0212113895,
-0.001311017,
-0.020633135,
0.0062672351,
0.0053610713,
-0.0019004794,
-0.0290997494,
-0.01928108,
-0.0148935383,
-0.0009433163,
-0.0091193691,
0.0260207821,
0.048423171,
-0.0226620045,
0.0020062188,
-0.0148029719,
-0.0043127695,
-0.0317874551,
0.0102084801,
0.0530957207,
-0.0545418374,
-0.0821396485,
0.0395797677,
0.0538263023,
-0.0209192019,
0.0125668226,
-0.0257313661,
0.0020871535,
0.074695386,
0.0196390152,
-0.0227215774,
-0.0564974621,
-0.0413444042,
-0.0181396473,
0.0040479568,
0.0152207967,
0.0127500622,
0.0506009124,
-0.0272421222,
0.0077596973,
0.0313461944,
0.0293465648,
0.0339815766,
-0.0027150186,
0.0430572629,
0.0009144685,
0.0369168445,
-0.0308790393,
0.0480974503,
-0.0084452815,
-0.0695113465,
0.0074672224,
0.0174801499,
0.0500508696,
0.0324343406,
-0.0000224455,
-0.0022478108,
0.039301835,
-0.0645588711,
-0.0385564379,
-0.0276759267,
-0.028407786,
-0.0310110729,
0.0015903353,
-0.0080327308,
-0.0206841175,
-0.0044449293,
-0.0592857301,
-0.014916596,
-0.0279847346,
-0.0013631725,
-0.01378222,
-0.0041842111,
0.0155004496,
0.0002742565,
0.0296480469,
-0.0322110429,
0.0456970073,
-0.0059864223,
0.001719535,
-0.0237797778,
-0.0500431322,
-0.0053895875,
-0.0479566492,
-0.0162326116,
0.041435007,
-0.0067769303,
-0.0247480441,
-0.0161246825,
-0.0262464304,
-0.0464205481,
-0.0027474344,
-0.0927349105,
0.0447817966,
0.0076666512,
0.0482608266,
0.0190660618,
0.0395336561,
-0.0236956924,
-0.0069887619,
-0.0010461912,
-0.0604753196,
0.0046086214,
0.0229441468,
0.0435420685,
0.03326324,
-0.0242622923,
-0.0322859176,
0.0012159015,
-0.0692731366,
0.0321348198,
0.001633651,
-0.0846498683,
-0.0228205677,
-0.003804951,
0.0076485369,
-0.0036126501,
0.0059646564,
-0.0338424705,
-0.0102855004,
0.0257197283,
-0.0014591063,
0.0636648685,
-0.0074769133,
0.0522266962,
0.0050879251,
-0.0106540658,
-0.0202714726,
0.037341617,
-0.031683784,
0.0043731136,
0.0158217102,
-0.0268670786,
0.0050510466,
0.076296486,
-0.005724059,
0.0337904654,
-0.0250399206,
0.0099125244,
-0.0237194728,
-0.0128338886,
-0.0166564528,
-0.0410419814,
-0.0387381501,
-0.0155555606,
-0.0228611901,
-0.0200606454,
0.0541161112,
0.008952844,
0.0017277531,
-0.0423596688,
-0.009898073,
-0.0423238166,
0.0125217047,
0.0209805071,
-0.0060760751,
0.0130989701,
-0.0519323461,
0.0337663889,
0.0130389528,
-0.0211535376,
-0.0530548543,
0.0148091028,
0.009951571,
0.0277005415,
-0.016450217,
-0.0224276371,
-0.0469902121,
-0.051345285,
-0.0368728079,
0.0168104395,
-0.0007699218,
0.0159425177,
-0.0596233271,
0.0472852774,
-0.0036711702,
0.0304048639,
0.0030120823,
-0.0007870379,
-0.0023857779,
0.0404378846,
0.0247858781,
-0.0265160203,
0.0465288833,
-0.0252237674,
0.0245938227,
0.0330013148,
0.0283077825,
0.0291626155,
-0.0385839939,
-0.0103260297,
-0.0171323158,
-0.0666233152,
-0.0021970752,
-0.0063663307,
0.0743574724,
-0.0755029619,
0.0198513828,
0.0936444178,
-0.0002542686,
-0.0358856991,
0.0170174856,
0.0606248491,
-0.021072451,
-0.0350195915,
0.0143601131,
-0.0418852046,
-0.0369721912,
0.0189372376,
0.0012344224,
-0.0318729728,
-0.0893756375,
0.0286740065,
-0.0556401685,
0.0125230839,
0.0016715927,
-0.0590129532,
-0.0361506343,
-0.0679070652,
0.0227377098,
-0.0249433927,
0.0265898425,
-0.0323267654,
-0.0196766779,
-0.0038346609,
0.0220377874,
-0.0493570566,
-0.1025485024,
0.0272806343,
-0.0530322976,
0.0187778343,
0.0556300394,
0.0238500815,
-0.0257828757,
0.0113323461,
-0.0249256045,
-0.0247283839,
-0.0474439673,
0.0107961064,
0.0839832127,
-0.0154619161,
-0.0210851058,
-0.0338026695,
0.0200013332,
-0.0480748005,
-0.017465625,
-0.0076567656,
0.0668742135,
-0.010257056,
-0.0485804565,
-0.0239571109,
-0.0254587401,
0.0160685424,
0.0707072392,
0.0208574552,
-0.0176758133,
-0.0108156558,
0.0489615463,
0.0217617676,
-0.0903092548,
-0.0092531545,
0.0329814255,
-0.0175773464,
-0.0760066807,
-0.0383398682,
-0.0491558835,
0.0478199013,
-0.0042713955,
-0.0114875613,
0.0209796913,
0.0140272714,
0.0289190784,
-0.0256929453,
0.059516564,
0.0022011024,
-0.0114951236,
-0.0349467173,
-0.0004941358,
0.0137203308,
0.0593962073,
-0.0338067263,
0.0523160398,
-0.0506555215,
-0.0514048077,
0.018000517,
-0.027464401,
0.01320998,
-0.007533941,
0.0202179048,
-0.0291339252,
0.0573438369,
0.0721765533,
-0.0233683847,
-0.0551745184,
-0.030380005,
-0.0290590581,
-0.0158101451,
0.0126972487,
-0.0181460213,
0.0400741883,
0.0168384071,
0.0220255274,
-0.0136341415,
-0.0194917507,
0.0045677358,
0.0172947831,
0.0356313772,
-0.0111097079,
-0.0703852773,
-0.0590263233,
0.0132790385,
0.0470301919,
0.0403390005,
-0.0018553574,
0.0001882865,
0.030348612,
-0.0214682333,
-0.0514499135,
0.0390223972,
0.0027480638,
0.008159115,
-0.0573945977,
0.0500258133,
0.004767416,
0.0469007902,
0.0474077351,
-0.0224231333,
-0.0185363181,
0.0288196243,
0.0345989242,
0.0092804991,
-0.0549509972,
-0.0332951248,
-0.007383015,
0.0212741718,
-0.0056560612,
0.0394974649,
-0.0538398959,
-0.0071761776,
-0.0407379791,
0.044293642,
0.0747251585,
-0.023100106,
0.0346141495,
-0.0075152144,
-0.0113571603,
-0.0317393504,
0.0194844957,
-0.0225656442,
0.0419135243,
0.0335259847,
0.0291751418,
-0.0437423661,
-0.0147113074,
0.0589627661,
0.0219828561,
0.0833413526,
0.050689999,
-0.0044460259,
-0.0377035104,
0.0085331453,
0.0241389014,
0.007420491,
-0.0567949042,
0.0077864244,
-0.0255432986,
-0.0179012101,
0.0607859306,
-0.0672773644,
-0.014424189,
0.0120942416,
0.0112805218,
0.0287191458,
0.0260819644,
0.0095483428,
-0.0074828384,
0.0274397004,
-0.0057749432,
-0.0381451026,
-0.0125865089,
-6.14563177e-33,
-0.0009423185,
-0.0153287882,
0.0026267259,
-0.0378292948,
-0.0115873935,
0.023693068,
-0.0391699187,
-0.0271114111,
-0.0244025812,
0.0005303107,
-0.0066023255,
-0.0147416824,
0.0201316103,
0.0172182526,
-0.0007897789,
-0.0301509108,
0.0469826981,
0.0280603319,
-0.001325011,
0.0477038622,
0.0218667518,
0.0948355794,
0.0745838061,
-0.0853582099,
0.0152570913,
0.0065600416,
0.0269816369,
-0.0268744938,
0.0411538668,
0.0855279043,
-0.0439310372,
0.0255411305,
0.0428149253,
-0.0308561996,
0.010127577,
0.0431471132,
-0.0904216245,
0.0054757278,
-0.0358906612,
-0.0032201714,
-0.0189209878,
-0.0728844181,
0.0912618637,
0.0221721306,
0.00854336,
-0.013106714,
0.0250608474,
-0.0143531114,
-0.0189037677,
-0.0561910905,
-0.0639107376,
0.0520120971,
-0.0014673701,
0.0245872047,
0.0311235916,
-0.0182269663,
-0.0113674607,
0.109343417,
-0.0211318284,
-0.0492019281,
0.0164752491,
0.0069256769,
0.0226651933,
0.0065836827,
-0.0157046951,
0.0619898066,
0.0123902913,
-0.0154805463,
-0.0657944381,
-0.0159207955,
0.0075133163,
0.0448878296,
0.003700875,
0.0394184925,
0.0482524037,
-0.012386648,
-0.1378639638,
0.0245302618,
-0.0253028069,
0.0262706298,
0.0031454905,
-0.0025517505,
-0.0510274097,
0.0444863401,
-0.0128601585,
0.0029931196,
-0.0203598365,
0.0051149754,
0.0096568363,
-0.0198071022,
-0.0295190737,
0.05897085,
0.0017107794,
-0.019660173,
-0.0613378324,
0.0015250313,
0.0587404631,
-0.0023773285,
0.0019057597,
0.0228474252,
-0.0646854192,
-0.0324210115,
-0.008309654,
-0.0021840141,
0.030763194,
-0.0108098965,
0.0503106862,
-0.0345271602,
-0.0502660312,
-0.0091465469,
-0.0029467784,
0.0407980382,
-0.0427419953,
0.0842031538,
0.0347051807,
0.0071724532,
0.0204708781,
0.0362234749,
0.0168477017,
0.0164925866,
0.0146289244,
-0.0317819454,
0.0086867362,
0.0359853692,
-0.0016228445,
-0.0135318479,
0.0152286077,
0.0243581645,
0.0053197569,
-0.0661864802,
0.0037666268,
-0.0225572921,
2.743e-7,
0.0862659588,
0.0547135659,
0.0213068314,
-0.0477283746,
0.0072214636,
0.0193466786,
0.0055659157,
0.0199885592,
-0.0263153892,
-0.0241297577,
0.0066169738,
0.0153592033,
0.0360769406,
0.0290597994,
-0.0882708803,
-0.009304597,
-0.0784115642,
0.025903631,
-0.0592498071,
0.0009813028,
0.0405723266,
0.0983965471,
0.0021219989,
-0.0364874676,
-0.0102363359,
-0.0008090634,
0.0294091478,
-0.010200996,
-0.0033034196,
0.0566144325,
-0.0109984074,
0.0558892712,
-0.0257772282,
0.0488271974,
-0.0102853002,
0.0062468071,
-0.0166490246,
0.0636480376,
-0.0309340581,
0.0062170108,
0.0036990845,
-0.0335066542,
0.0087562194,
-0.0177171286,
0.0794257969,
-0.0613483191,
-0.0453655571,
0.0083213178,
-0.0485676676,
0.0077526537,
0.0368667133,
-0.0028291133,
0.006778066,
0.0540625341,
-0.0127338367,
-0.0397386551,
-0.0383610465,
-0.0837728083,
0.0314896032,
0.0407847613,
-0.0339587443,
-0.0266608857,
-0.0066543678,
-0.0127288206,
0.0281171352,
-0.0385712236,
0.0218444243,
2.4616918e-34,
0.0012039035,
0.0092457645,
-0.0199026782,
0.0351406001,
-0.0163571052,
-0.0122266924,
-0.0135912746,
0.0047290232,
-0.0349263288,
-0.0416546091,
0.0254102889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18045v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18045v2 | PharmaGPT: Domain-Specific Large Language Models for Bio-Pharmaceutical and Chemistry | 2024-06-26T03:43:09 | 2024-07-03T12:56:40 | Linqing Chen, Weilei Wang, Zilong Bai, Peng Xu, Yan Fang, Jie Fang, Wentao Wu, Lizhi Zhou, Ruiji Zhang, Yubin Xia, Chaobo Xu, Ran Hu, Licong Xu, Qijun Cai, Haoran Hua, Jing Sun, Jin Liu, Tian Qiu, Haowen Liu, Meng Hu, Xiuwen Li, Fei Gao, Yufu Wang, Lin Tie, Chaochao Wang, Jianping Lu, Cheng Sun, Yixin Wang, Shengjie Yang, Yuancheng Li, Lu Jin, Lisha Zhang, Fu Bian, Zhongkai Ye, Lidong Pei, Changyang Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized Natural Language Processing
(NLP) by by minimizing the need for complex feature engineering. However, the
application of LLMs in specialized domains like biopharmaceuticals and
chemistry remains largely unexplored. These fields are characterized by
intricate terminologies, specialized knowledge, and a high demand for precision
areas where general purpose LLMs often fall short. In this study, we introduce
PharmGPT, a suite of multilingual LLMs with 13 billion and 70 billion
parameters, specifically trained on a comprehensive corpus of hundreds of
billions of tokens tailored to the Bio-Pharmaceutical and Chemical sectors. Our
evaluation shows that PharmGPT matches or surpasses existing general models on
key benchmarks, such as NAPLEX, demonstrating its exceptional capability in
domain-specific tasks. This advancement establishes a new benchmark for LLMs in
the Bio-Pharmaceutical and Chemical fields, addressing the existing gap in
specialized language modeling. Furthermore, this suggests a promising path for
enhanced research and development in these specialized areas, paving the way
for more precise and effective applications of NLP in specialized domains. | [
0.0533000343,
0.0637567043,
0.014826782,
0.0173885822,
-0.0077601997,
0.0143560302,
0.0185505319,
0.0100845015,
0.0359651446,
-0.0522797294,
-0.0296317134,
-0.0319061987,
-0.0257759281,
0.0533350371,
0.0476140156,
0.0209054966,
0.0231551174,
-0.0203388892,
0.0209808294,
-0.001060605,
0.0080649452,
0.0228920151,
0.0100678736,
0.0404991917,
0.0198047031,
-0.0263518188,
0.0570245758,
-0.0271059386,
0.0055126376,
-0.0259890892,
0.0080821365,
0.0266407412,
-0.0033656126,
0.0478293933,
0.0000016884,
-0.0641190857,
-0.0319934301,
0.037978217,
-0.0166086201,
0.0302420724,
0.0731461644,
-0.0297371037,
-0.0039306632,
0.009697156,
-0.0180448405,
-0.0019515054,
0.0482781529,
0.0521955863,
0.0110170841,
0.0583287366,
-0.0141464137,
-0.0499699265,
0.0323909894,
-0.0447415784,
-0.0110764103,
-0.040803764,
0.0615242496,
-0.0279610306,
0.050107006,
0.0020748738,
-0.0060222959,
0.0350076407,
-0.0467858836,
-0.0024677962,
0.0057059978,
0.0230910871,
-0.0344184861,
-0.0488483869,
0.0015861144,
0.0751559809,
-0.0548039116,
-0.0256157052,
-0.0144041255,
0.0045687943,
-0.0331019089,
0.0009562452,
-0.0245612245,
0.0099777319,
-0.0023035596,
0.0440900847,
0.0494964905,
-0.0059053735,
0.0292244274,
0.0209870487,
-0.0211066995,
0.0516067632,
0.0166513976,
0.0074004247,
0.0167882759,
-0.0222048536,
-0.0626330748,
-0.0122754574,
0.0404879227,
-0.0124538159,
-0.0146423196,
0.024809856,
0.0233371053,
-0.0301836673,
0.0822706297,
-0.0817145184,
-0.0151214721,
-0.0113600157,
-0.0183427054,
0.0687438846,
-0.0420821197,
0.0158924703,
-0.0345618315,
0.001423217,
-0.037285842,
-0.0309645627,
-0.058815822,
-0.0042270687,
-0.0248658359,
0.0216904636,
-0.0234490409,
-0.0339197069,
-0.0687198713,
-0.0104512367,
-0.0110798087,
-0.0112573206,
0.0184314027,
0.048869703,
0.0099133449,
-0.0228324402,
0.0079976534,
0.0489706285,
0.0113578625,
0.0053266287,
-0.0498282164,
-0.0630421788,
-0.0013602179,
0.0043738927,
-0.005174234,
-0.0300560836,
0.0340783373,
0.1057685539,
0.0177564118,
-0.0454989374,
-0.0093470607,
-0.0327548236,
-0.0164567381,
-0.0526206531,
-0.0305490866,
-0.0635127947,
0.0681107864,
0.0030692951,
0.0286685284,
-0.0616470352,
0.011134685,
-0.0077983821,
-0.0590733252,
0.0888145566,
0.0175220296,
-0.0348806493,
0.0084258495,
-0.0104803899,
0.0075082728,
0.0143898902,
0.0076414505,
-0.0088811731,
0.0268323291,
-0.0094442777,
0.0079902513,
0.0197205972,
-0.0212962255,
-0.0285760723,
0.004033268,
0.0144366082,
0.0307147745,
0.0528669804,
-0.0042771352,
0.0315590724,
0.0005448213,
-0.0289375894,
0.0482061878,
0.0813109055,
0.0341145135,
0.0224778298,
0.021829946,
0.0027116686,
0.0021851694,
-0.0811948851,
-0.0200407226,
-0.032299526,
-0.0087959794,
0.0207785182,
0.0321727134,
0.037691582,
-0.0005607384,
0.0006643048,
-0.0209363904,
-0.0223428141,
-0.0166852549,
-0.0232472289,
0.0615910478,
-0.0392524973,
-0.0648543537,
0.0692444518,
0.056361001,
-0.0231791716,
0.0062800054,
-0.0257623196,
0.0084199701,
0.0715224743,
0.0465173982,
-0.0504110605,
-0.0206425078,
-0.0156719089,
-0.022689553,
0.0285737514,
0.0161344912,
-0.0079892613,
0.0261641517,
-0.0267710388,
0.0186605249,
-0.020770032,
0.0201934576,
0.0097320508,
-0.0135350414,
0.0374617018,
-0.0153814936,
-0.0231407657,
-0.0212000199,
0.0206353255,
-0.0449650809,
-0.0374144241,
0.0215503182,
-0.0216422398,
0.0159647111,
0.0442698412,
-0.0108468011,
0.0316258185,
0.04337807,
-0.0887860954,
-0.010241474,
-0.0223650094,
0.0431223623,
-0.0126174176,
0.0338469967,
-0.0132355988,
0.0173342023,
-0.0236426909,
-0.0427653566,
-0.0223322604,
0.0235058088,
0.0041093496,
0.0482657477,
-0.0201589819,
0.025376983,
-0.0209810417,
0.0602964163,
-0.0442673862,
0.0038090707,
0.0182445534,
0.0122153275,
0.013549706,
-0.026204057,
0.0085011562,
-0.0155838765,
-0.0064373584,
0.0378714837,
0.0165940989,
0.0193672124,
0.0143030118,
-0.0195062421,
-0.0157932192,
-0.0056900065,
-0.0550262965,
0.0100023896,
0.0069687832,
0.0254475977,
0.0045094704,
0.0055892915,
0.0007192915,
-0.0071696844,
-0.0216001533,
-0.0462936014,
-0.0180414245,
0.0100671453,
0.0074997074,
0.0158792064,
-0.0308590196,
-0.0428575315,
-0.0187558811,
-0.0224899575,
0.06755317,
-0.0210154224,
-0.0474855788,
-0.0239089988,
-0.0141334487,
-0.009998478,
0.0230808463,
0.0085162809,
-0.0009837269,
-0.0271513294,
-0.0080890022,
0.0036562355,
0.0178687833,
-0.0137777664,
-0.0017575496,
0.0491002388,
0.0273959227,
-0.0093765398,
0.0002620674,
-0.0401553959,
-0.0131097455,
-0.0103146043,
-0.0106229279,
0.0038854184,
0.0782349333,
-0.016758658,
-0.011992692,
-0.0301328152,
0.0052825944,
-0.0286125522,
-0.0089867068,
-0.0282182824,
0.0214396026,
0.0054129832,
-0.0013375474,
0.0086500384,
-0.0473196246,
0.0686613619,
-0.0479100086,
0.0224273931,
-0.0767859891,
-0.0177952852,
-0.0337711051,
-0.0038730542,
0.0208867211,
0.0238316134,
0.0213440768,
-0.0203611683,
0.0413615927,
0.0189129692,
-0.0222966131,
-0.0278533082,
0.0777961016,
-0.0386676416,
0.0418715812,
-0.0010142695,
-0.0267331488,
0.0006181658,
-0.0211821273,
-0.0410625264,
0.0339380167,
0.0573121421,
-0.036197342,
-0.0276209116,
0.0482665077,
-0.0216702893,
0.022981707,
0.0166726522,
0.0075055808,
-0.011689811,
-0.0034551059,
0.0639591664,
-0.0282330867,
0.0462882705,
0.0062460899,
0.0618763939,
0.0544636957,
0.0156072369,
-0.0147219738,
-0.0012234853,
0.008919809,
0.0175110865,
-0.0578568764,
-0.0224218722,
-0.0153663615,
0.0177937318,
-0.0332039893,
0.0043542972,
0.1262848675,
0.0289801024,
-0.0403907821,
0.0425003432,
0.018750174,
-0.0386038013,
-0.0036675681,
0.0402914621,
-0.0730055571,
-0.0420329869,
-0.0284925736,
-0.0199115891,
-0.0048113288,
-0.0383296832,
-0.0229694974,
-0.0652563572,
0.0339674763,
0.0228844676,
-0.0331008509,
-0.0141013404,
-0.0708904192,
-0.0344868563,
-0.0594579652,
0.0381394811,
-0.0074335407,
-0.0201027803,
-0.0308174863,
0.0088239722,
-0.0408041999,
-0.0840475261,
0.0476350263,
-0.0367333256,
0.0112172579,
0.0347471423,
-0.0029499864,
0.0019894047,
0.0137789259,
0.0214466956,
-0.0144316042,
0.0024808911,
-0.0069281664,
0.0315231644,
0.012968746,
-0.0316008404,
-0.0164409298,
0.0297421645,
-0.0914975852,
-0.0121209221,
-0.0553041771,
0.101573579,
-0.0000657628,
-0.001794625,
-0.0389244556,
-0.0205199663,
-0.021282874,
0.0490186848,
-0.0175349228,
-0.0452000983,
-0.0643102527,
-0.0135004586,
-0.0195818357,
-0.0183586217,
-0.0303252134,
0.007291879,
-0.0410313085,
-0.022527013,
-0.0618012547,
-0.0148051325,
0.0737652704,
-0.0214280933,
-0.0043321131,
0.0624526218,
0.030507274,
-0.0357107706,
-0.0285565779,
0.0630750284,
0.0240730029,
0.0355759338,
-0.0705747083,
-0.0264960434,
0.0766018108,
0.0162790902,
-0.0291610714,
0.0415863693,
-0.0774333179,
-0.0993722081,
-0.0258421898,
0.0033741612,
0.0160403997,
0.0166400429,
-0.0385916159,
-0.0603182837,
0.0685465336,
0.0328080282,
-0.0166225396,
-0.0377033316,
-0.0207141191,
-0.0022793382,
-0.0151822325,
0.0216133669,
-0.0289768353,
0.0163434688,
-0.0054084286,
0.0550414175,
0.0119225923,
-0.0182292089,
0.0443584472,
0.0086477976,
0.0458416678,
-0.0191277564,
0.0137104997,
-0.0480124168,
0.0030952897,
-0.0071652951,
0.0228172448,
-0.0208356436,
-0.0072160526,
0.0582541488,
-0.0424353033,
-0.0306684393,
0.0094065489,
-0.0425191298,
-0.0016105665,
0.0052316007,
0.0129381269,
-0.0213667881,
-0.0254651383,
0.07568378,
-0.016032666,
0.0002318321,
0.0181194711,
-0.0489425734,
0.0014220013,
-0.054923486,
0.0358997583,
-0.030709723,
0.030059278,
-0.051436238,
0.0465489514,
-0.0068813548,
-0.0647783577,
-0.0387364291,
0.0467041358,
0.0760907084,
-0.0517774522,
0.0744281709,
-0.0200115629,
-0.0161803737,
-0.0585641637,
0.0324077234,
-0.0097971242,
0.0309035964,
0.0336024091,
0.0293846559,
-0.0379643291,
-0.018211646,
0.1054576561,
0.0538699627,
0.0329725929,
0.0116191404,
-0.0403406657,
-0.0044668806,
-0.0325076729,
-0.0011688533,
-0.0076334341,
-0.0718080103,
0.0363933519,
-0.0427227356,
-0.0520937592,
0.0118156709,
-0.0231053289,
-0.0146836601,
0.005319688,
0.0023804358,
0.0682124496,
0.0264448114,
-0.0366717204,
-0.0702323839,
0.0047850977,
0.0222895462,
-0.0467727743,
0.0008444829,
-5.658909885e-33,
0.0580079444,
-0.0062807659,
-0.0003662257,
-0.0228711963,
0.0230313446,
0.0101466272,
-0.0166470353,
-0.0092562456,
0.005070325,
0.0469155572,
0.0074856221,
-0.0146041373,
-0.0030244268,
0.0136989588,
0.0180845205,
0.0120427497,
0.0248025469,
0.0338708833,
0.0311363544,
0.0075409506,
0.0410988964,
0.061555557,
0.0693325177,
-0.0253551938,
0.0185165722,
0.0188142229,
0.0330931097,
-0.0070906719,
-0.0156798828,
0.0678974614,
-0.0698518828,
0.0755791143,
0.0176097024,
-0.0577572398,
-0.0160360523,
-0.0199284554,
-0.043890316,
0.0155843776,
0.0231538992,
-0.0069873938,
0.006564911,
-0.0305843372,
0.0518063121,
0.0031775029,
-0.0166761652,
0.0165723953,
0.0233676229,
-0.0289773606,
-0.0064027882,
-0.0307023469,
-0.0804362893,
0.0353000835,
0.0085789552,
0.0219371244,
0.0350347534,
0.0132671623,
-0.0220961832,
0.0766152367,
-0.0248834509,
0.0064688032,
0.006530765,
0.0410146527,
0.061504215,
-0.0091141006,
0.000013742,
0.0533090271,
-0.0071695764,
0.0272803027,
0.029696418,
0.0064237257,
-0.0184455328,
0.0571626797,
0.0130063593,
0.0193269886,
0.0381592624,
-0.0001300271,
-0.0874309838,
0.0060609737,
-0.0434818938,
0.0383544303,
0.0096327215,
0.0188388526,
0.0131035615,
-0.0122426664,
-0.018755855,
0.0626569167,
-0.032360144,
-0.0045265993,
0.0027963659,
-0.0129290093,
-0.0159507524,
0.0275374912,
0.0115825217,
-0.0565639175,
-0.0510573573,
0.0006954192,
0.0176391471,
0.0193409566,
-0.0069677434,
0.0430670232,
-0.0797549039,
-0.0284975953,
-0.0241498258,
-0.0572809391,
-0.0081874263,
-0.0276835617,
0.0127117876,
-0.0170679428,
-0.0421967804,
0.0077064335,
-0.0428768918,
-0.0142448796,
0.0192264505,
0.0652017891,
0.0188566856,
0.0373275392,
0.0155948484,
0.0761189982,
0.0330483057,
-0.0252658594,
0.0184144974,
0.0154223004,
0.0431045182,
0.0194482431,
-0.0513382144,
0.0080965003,
-0.0368157476,
0.0215095319,
0.0294462014,
-0.0544201359,
-0.0204210039,
-0.0315249152,
2.494e-7,
0.0838439316,
0.0450035706,
0.0078930985,
-0.0078409864,
0.0252021234,
0.028004488,
-0.0160249658,
0.0539807379,
-0.0527849421,
-0.0029888421,
0.0007894147,
-0.0260438025,
0.0228709597,
0.0025078938,
-0.0678271949,
0.0142511232,
-0.0525441207,
-0.0339663662,
-0.0871812701,
-0.0196156595,
0.0157886408,
0.1341019869,
-0.0111749265,
-0.0213881657,
0.0215875767,
-0.0503274389,
0.0567123666,
-0.0456736647,
-0.0287042651,
0.0671277717,
0.0086272387,
-0.0040346473,
0.0047602677,
0.018236449,
-0.0210462678,
0.009641896,
0.0151530746,
0.0826358199,
-0.0552659631,
-0.0114290668,
0.039403297,
-0.0465563126,
0.0116023989,
-0.0406394936,
0.021377489,
-0.0212714598,
-0.0497338213,
-0.0672870353,
0.0069799041,
0.0065555661,
0.0624058023,
-0.0404809937,
0.0175234322,
0.0380557291,
0.0143054649,
0.0009003111,
-0.0167638641,
-0.0750649497,
-0.0199473146,
0.0350898504,
-0.0427874438,
0.0078226048,
-0.0113416212,
-0.012306842,
0.0400727503,
-0.0459185578,
0.0210119244,
2.196560657e-34,
0.0623880886,
-0.0202588234,
0.0244281385,
0.0418811925,
0.0544824526,
-0.0147057194,
-0.0210987125,
0.0245483592,
-0.0315809213,
-0.1108609289,
0.0005865235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18034v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18034v1 | LLMs for Doctors: Leveraging Medical LLMs to Assist Doctors, Not Replace Them | 2024-06-26T03:08:24 | 2024-06-26T03:08:24 | Wenya Xie, Qingying Xiao, Yu Zheng, Xidong Wang, Junying Chen, Ke Ji, Anningzhe Gao, Xiang Wan, Feng Jiang, Benyou Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent success of Large Language Models (LLMs) has had a significant
impact on the healthcare field, providing patients with medical advice,
diagnostic information, and more. However, due to a lack of professional
medical knowledge, patients are easily misled by generated erroneous
information from LLMs, which may result in serious medical problems. To address
this issue, we focus on tuning the LLMs to be medical assistants who
collaborate with more experienced doctors. We first conduct a two-stage survey
by inspiration-feedback to gain a broad understanding of the real needs of
doctors for medical assistants. Based on this, we construct a Chinese medical
dataset called DoctorFLAN to support the entire workflow of doctors, which
includes 92K Q\&A samples from 22 tasks and 27 specialists. Moreover, we
evaluate LLMs in doctor-oriented scenarios by constructing the
DoctorFLAN-\textit{test} containing 550 single-turn Q\&A and DotaBench
containing 74 multi-turn conversations. The evaluation results indicate that
being a medical assistant still poses challenges for existing open-source
models, but DoctorFLAN can help them significantly. It demonstrates that the
doctor-oriented dataset and benchmarks we construct can complement existing
patient-oriented work and better promote medical LLMs research. | [
0.0764166564,
0.0348533317,
-0.0145614427,
-0.0036557126,
-0.0175022855,
0.0013680769,
0.0027785613,
0.0332120582,
0.0046411897,
-0.0032452468,
-0.0254424773,
-0.0400383919,
0.0033915294,
0.0166074466,
0.0363069214,
-0.060563609,
0.0184954666,
0.0073048025,
0.0340454727,
-0.0083721336,
0.0150449164,
0.0139170364,
-0.0523268543,
0.065110527,
0.0362131782,
-0.0154416077,
0.0166312456,
-0.0017986895,
0.0274242032,
-0.0327280499,
0.0018316982,
0.0296324529,
-0.0090803588,
0.0011635049,
0.0000021077,
-0.0417138115,
0.019556025,
0.0103661129,
-0.0660272241,
-0.0340594426,
0.017529469,
-0.0276273768,
-0.0077259121,
0.037116494,
-0.0396748222,
-0.0239433311,
0.0075262324,
0.0400913283,
0.0571569093,
0.0715801716,
-0.0047824658,
0.0362756699,
0.0017084874,
-0.0246590916,
0.0334928185,
-0.0637373254,
0.018331496,
0.0102587827,
0.0516390391,
-0.0096413437,
0.0285557732,
0.0233078524,
-0.0214122701,
-0.0108238626,
-0.0084766224,
0.0440654755,
-0.0099856453,
-0.0028834434,
-0.0104180602,
0.0726929381,
0.015439542,
-0.0006595005,
0.010690093,
0.0067168609,
0.0084732156,
-0.0060934033,
-0.0530572571,
0.0131688155,
-0.0186731424,
-0.02027441,
-0.0025893534,
-0.0131207034,
0.0350125171,
0.0059636841,
0.0111838942,
-0.0186587274,
-0.0059588547,
-0.0232192427,
-0.0135436542,
-0.0182038415,
0.0280397255,
-0.039863307,
0.0473564751,
0.0516623631,
-0.0844675079,
0.0174062625,
-0.0119543951,
-0.0160696618,
0.0800097883,
-0.0293685067,
0.0414712392,
0.0235084277,
-0.0058355401,
0.0396827795,
0.0130453445,
-0.0072324979,
-0.0198685396,
0.0296126418,
-0.0446091183,
-0.0195138212,
-0.0524669327,
0.0021579002,
-0.0194220897,
0.0084789712,
0.0056669372,
0.0129095651,
-0.0579666123,
-0.0061485618,
-0.0137720536,
0.0525842942,
0.0298407543,
0.0413716361,
-0.0373600349,
-0.0035920243,
-0.0193844065,
0.0226629935,
0.0044359318,
0.0400400124,
0.0073686973,
-0.0491234809,
0.0177476741,
0.0044882731,
0.0035645387,
0.0173941012,
0.001741761,
0.0540334024,
0.0019000728,
0.0029608975,
0.0025571722,
-0.0469988473,
0.0007809934,
-0.0079678325,
0.0130809844,
-0.0608962663,
0.0307456721,
0.010613393,
0.0135978367,
-0.0299940258,
0.0277764816,
0.0344959013,
-0.0399785005,
0.0531324521,
-0.0512754582,
0.052330263,
0.0381476581,
0.0630877838,
0.0006556208,
0.0306102987,
0.0281461366,
-0.0381723493,
0.0313272849,
-0.0151131572,
0.0403569005,
0.027953729,
0.0081432043,
-0.0032655019,
0.029787397,
0.0326993279,
-0.0075301882,
0.0800736696,
-0.0289188437,
0.0518180579,
-0.0144049888,
0.0058286451,
0.0334453136,
0.0527064353,
0.0135048982,
-0.007186465,
-0.0000195315,
-0.026519984,
0.0033143216,
-0.0361887887,
-0.0134430109,
0.0132437171,
-0.0081391959,
-0.021093579,
-0.0367254727,
-0.0086709056,
-0.0618598945,
-0.0401751772,
-0.0501381084,
-0.0240196474,
-0.0588341504,
0.0029114096,
0.0216454212,
-0.0205489956,
-0.0141949011,
0.0836039186,
0.0257526338,
-0.0799263045,
-0.033086028,
-0.0631944239,
-0.014706051,
0.0984209701,
0.0660306811,
-0.053373944,
-0.0475180149,
-0.0215385351,
0.0166929793,
0.0277168918,
0.0642613992,
-0.0259238556,
-0.0000964871,
-0.0544879958,
-0.0089722574,
0.0341092423,
0.0045019644,
-0.0307350345,
-0.0047061904,
0.0445650928,
-0.0116693191,
-0.0409877598,
-0.0502924323,
0.0251687318,
-0.0947713405,
-0.0077038454,
0.0158929713,
0.0003327264,
0.0305782631,
0.0553052127,
-0.0060196365,
0.043733988,
0.0260801613,
-0.0302073061,
-0.007272434,
0.03933236,
-0.0333777927,
-0.0046911072,
0.023265874,
-0.037079934,
-0.0067592598,
-0.0004187178,
-0.029901458,
-0.0439816155,
-0.0419983976,
-0.0575024784,
0.0403067097,
0.0052854712,
0.0274120476,
0.0469185114,
-0.0041874428,
0.0057580532,
-0.0147257373,
-0.0337229557,
0.0080977445,
0.0133562256,
0.0186744612,
0.0040914379,
-0.0556159727,
-0.0051435228,
0.0097606517,
0.0110436939,
0.0323665366,
-0.0222258251,
0.0271722209,
-0.0352626741,
-0.0475250445,
-0.1230032369,
-0.0304199718,
-0.001614693,
-0.0049172281,
0.0379596278,
0.0311103426,
-0.0051438976,
-0.0224948581,
-0.0739469603,
0.0237631425,
0.0312888138,
-0.0044619129,
0.0248072222,
0.0244783107,
0.0127436183,
-0.041520454,
0.0129272025,
-0.036415685,
-0.0346296802,
0.0107115498,
-0.0219988171,
-0.0328946039,
-0.0143227028,
-0.0420608334,
-0.0098762438,
-0.0342893675,
-0.0470678732,
0.0174609758,
-0.0105444994,
0.0068549854,
0.0148339663,
-0.0065742196,
-0.0067915786,
0.0423794799,
-0.0041424776,
-0.0174991246,
0.0107073467,
0.0163369458,
-0.0450301506,
0.008133132,
-0.0692328662,
-0.0128294416,
0.0546702035,
0.0126668466,
0.0236966349,
-0.0090099415,
-0.011490481,
-0.0187212583,
0.0275367927,
-0.0167136174,
0.034102615,
-0.0341242105,
0.0535350069,
0.004100197,
-0.0197970811,
0.0715936571,
-0.0127559332,
0.0149734197,
-0.0655428693,
-0.0491034687,
-0.0546988919,
0.0114555117,
-0.0571460351,
0.0092025464,
-0.0018743174,
-0.0214577802,
-0.0052859033,
0.0375259519,
-0.0360162072,
-0.0816567615,
0.0594394282,
-0.036082156,
0.0045260116,
-0.0203189403,
-0.0312805101,
-0.0567494929,
-0.0141984383,
-0.0611874573,
0.0179338474,
0.0160102826,
-0.0002674804,
-0.0624945275,
-0.0014602846,
0.0029419954,
0.0856753066,
0.0520663075,
-0.0081687616,
-0.0056051807,
-0.0063633719,
0.0265339017,
0.0254777893,
-0.0130229276,
-0.0167741049,
0.0577223375,
0.0731582418,
0.0462544374,
-0.0052446215,
0.0263669267,
-0.0466783792,
0.0277335849,
-0.0201250557,
-0.01327316,
0.0287773795,
0.0444096178,
-0.0529226251,
-0.0148986652,
0.1106747687,
0.0216558054,
-0.0793101788,
0.0300103053,
-0.0512533151,
-0.0414825678,
0.006377358,
0.0100817429,
-0.1006983966,
-0.02736599,
-0.0252382085,
0.0446111821,
0.0049289754,
-0.0096663637,
0.0306525361,
-0.0814812928,
0.0505571216,
0.0039594946,
-0.0250394773,
-0.0268464703,
-0.0267961454,
0.0144487452,
0.0090726372,
0.0279773362,
-0.0096491296,
-0.0099781742,
-0.0267823301,
-0.0019799951,
-0.0485642999,
-0.0589508899,
0.0583905503,
-0.0107378867,
0.0598802119,
0.076308392,
0.0379002839,
-0.0124018434,
-0.0577204153,
-0.0360315815,
0.0215803906,
0.0163665153,
0.0092513571,
0.0733918697,
0.0046366225,
0.0039264439,
-0.0134105263,
0.0404140018,
-0.0910484567,
0.0051643862,
0.0631754249,
0.0568873957,
-0.0367255472,
-0.0201933514,
-0.0442706458,
0.0516888462,
0.0488550849,
0.0526545532,
0.0013129526,
-0.0112137496,
-0.0098301787,
0.0062644747,
0.0390969291,
0.0126442676,
-0.0189966001,
0.028338315,
-0.0126001034,
0.0007236595,
-0.0712914094,
-0.0377941802,
0.0450056754,
-0.0118980911,
0.019210618,
0.0312429927,
0.0179569554,
0.0143756196,
-0.0320004597,
0.0025896593,
0.0011890276,
0.0522990376,
-0.078626141,
-0.060234189,
0.0591195896,
0.0071328646,
0.0272201393,
-0.0072760493,
-0.0279313102,
-0.0303815138,
-0.0092651816,
0.055524841,
0.021120891,
0.0059006312,
-0.0197160114,
-0.0377216525,
-0.0032701038,
0.0383548513,
-0.0574430525,
-0.0057553295,
0.0124256099,
0.0286767464,
0.0006926822,
0.0195874758,
-0.035280142,
-0.0119256517,
0.0101873223,
0.0267092101,
-0.0533158854,
-0.0738963261,
0.0060666734,
0.0497751571,
0.0204402022,
0.0064983596,
0.0159806814,
-0.021886019,
0.0511514172,
-0.0450602844,
0.0009141142,
-0.0437647812,
0.0015927105,
-0.0105547504,
-0.0555584431,
0.0395839624,
0.013409582,
-0.0824395344,
-0.048586309,
-0.0677738935,
0.0391096994,
-0.0001691873,
-0.0076927827,
0.0304602366,
-0.0248159207,
-0.0057742572,
-0.0027888049,
0.0154191423,
0.0157838352,
0.0286283419,
0.0878581703,
-0.0163049772,
0.0139779514,
0.0096732276,
0.0467827506,
-0.0408348925,
-0.1063411161,
-0.0029390352,
0.0614493527,
0.0548528545,
0.0106342277,
0.035304267,
-0.0440764204,
0.0320786014,
-0.0285511371,
0.0261438508,
-0.0379095301,
0.0133605441,
0.0677028149,
0.0119307032,
0.0134481173,
-0.0120304292,
0.1151314676,
-0.0367123634,
0.0515545048,
0.0038892494,
-0.0229642708,
-0.0547059141,
-0.0242782198,
0.0545673072,
0.0269738175,
-0.0632098541,
0.0115777003,
-0.0607561022,
-0.0514553674,
-0.0105533246,
-0.0188687481,
-0.0268455055,
-0.0355762206,
0.0490253717,
0.0421775505,
0.013521729,
0.0038889025,
-0.0370251089,
0.0510672182,
-0.0379552282,
0.001954155,
0.0316462815,
-5.945216228e-33,
0.0114410492,
-0.04136841,
0.0411998853,
-0.0149561465,
0.018969046,
0.0278678946,
-0.0327018388,
0.015867291,
-0.0342442319,
0.0220233556,
-0.0513167493,
0.0232047178,
0.0129354717,
0.0301903859,
0.0207555275,
-0.0124634774,
0.0337415114,
0.0149688749,
-0.0000087325,
0.0469889082,
-0.0120520974,
0.0314946771,
0.031771671,
-0.0921683013,
0.0139847528,
-0.0289775413,
0.0218591373,
0.0261011664,
-0.0464487001,
0.0564672053,
-0.0083406875,
0.0498864166,
0.0464035533,
0.0152982818,
-0.0158435926,
0.0029859124,
-0.0340729319,
-0.0153008206,
0.0132708866,
-0.0066342289,
-0.0577764027,
-0.018902665,
0.0155613814,
-0.0194830578,
-0.0062109348,
-0.0003327843,
0.0276460219,
-0.0413164236,
-0.0178079959,
0.0060310424,
-0.0053548431,
0.0269434061,
-0.0039211009,
-0.0345959477,
-0.0500402562,
-0.0077448473,
-0.0336565562,
-0.0040696356,
-0.0508581847,
0.0121591277,
0.0347165838,
0.0258824676,
0.0214940403,
-0.0343494378,
-0.0197285842,
0.0239361785,
0.0177583639,
0.0139936497,
-0.0434639081,
0.0102094067,
-0.0654944703,
0.0628412068,
0.0420071967,
0.0372231789,
-0.0055739745,
-0.0335080102,
-0.0580111556,
0.0392053425,
-0.0150582548,
0.0679908618,
0.0002631239,
0.0114991786,
-0.0607640147,
-0.0050637643,
-0.00677572,
0.0028289852,
-0.0194635149,
-0.0252842009,
0.0215450563,
0.0058793938,
0.0139254387,
-0.0168502145,
-0.0236807615,
-0.0163808372,
0.0319178179,
-0.0245300811,
0.0218176339,
0.0003471416,
-0.0418360159,
-0.017481098,
-0.1086352468,
-0.0038166833,
-0.0103066023,
0.0036055082,
0.037483573,
0.0504551083,
0.0124913314,
-0.028398497,
-0.0434470549,
-0.0055000358,
0.0050509972,
-0.0066888635,
0.0024271468,
0.0062775994,
0.0320422165,
-0.0148641784,
-0.0102439737,
0.0687406212,
-0.0047488245,
-0.024830088,
-0.0634227619,
-0.0698725507,
-0.0042611761,
-0.0155406622,
-0.0839015841,
0.0125752501,
-0.0494655222,
0.0527174808,
0.0644052252,
-0.0143906698,
-0.0072329994,
-0.0301136728,
2.863e-7,
0.0485923812,
0.0323780924,
0.0099794688,
0.0148679335,
0.0303370561,
0.0137369474,
-0.0188322645,
0.0228648148,
-0.011784113,
0.0033095805,
0.0302400179,
-0.0126740048,
0.0564955063,
0.0409160554,
-0.0782422796,
-0.0268615242,
-0.0902081057,
-0.0122216279,
-0.0092764273,
-0.041927848,
0.0293622967,
0.061162971,
-0.0317819156,
-0.034146212,
-0.0035633731,
-0.01209612,
0.0425656252,
-0.0400752909,
-0.0019522642,
0.0639704838,
0.0826055631,
-0.0028739916,
0.0153369652,
0.0327928178,
-0.0335330032,
-0.0164211821,
0.0186403431,
0.1219064891,
-0.071266368,
0.0118309138,
0.0349319801,
-0.0075093564,
0.0178498905,
-0.0409677587,
0.0235241782,
-0.0191876236,
-0.0557402931,
0.0037679465,
0.0050900429,
-0.0281865746,
0.0528959483,
-0.0190916546,
-0.030904742,
0.031158261,
0.0124896271,
0.0258491207,
-0.046751719,
-0.0463942215,
-0.0201097168,
-0.000208686,
-0.0238048509,
-0.0582606383,
0.0479175374,
-0.0411975943,
-0.0470971912,
-0.0648463368,
0.0080446061,
2.025831123e-34,
0.0023483783,
0.0242132004,
0.0037393286,
0.0663161054,
0.0146375904,
-0.0118015725,
0.0355164669,
0.0392734185,
0.0384304747,
-0.0182088949,
-0.0374385901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18027v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18027v1 | Automated Clinical Data Extraction with Knowledge Conditioned LLMs | 2024-06-26T02:49:28 | 2024-06-26T02:49:28 | Diya Li, Asim Kadav, Aijing Gao, Rui Li, Richard Bourgon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The extraction of lung lesion information from clinical and medical imaging
reports is crucial for research on and clinical care of lung-related diseases.
Large language models (LLMs) can be effective at interpreting unstructured text
in reports, but they often hallucinate due to a lack of domain-specific
knowledge, leading to reduced accuracy and posing challenges for use in
clinical settings. To address this, we propose a novel framework that aligns
generated internal knowledge with external knowledge through in-context
learning (ICL). Our framework employs a retriever to identify relevant units of
internal or external knowledge and a grader to evaluate the truthfulness and
helpfulness of the retrieved internal-knowledge rules, to align and update the
knowledge bases. Our knowledge-conditioned approach also improves the accuracy
and reliability of LLM outputs by addressing the extraction task in two stages:
(i) lung lesion finding detection and primary structured field parsing,
followed by (ii) further parsing of lesion description text into additional
structured fields. Experiments with expert-curated test datasets demonstrate
that this ICL approach can increase the F1 score for key fields (lesion size,
margin and solidity) by an average of 12.9% over existing ICL methods. | [
0.0225942824,
0.0497610681,
0.0245044492,
0.0310858376,
-0.013224029,
0.0142612197,
-0.0454547405,
0.0660629198,
0.0002679097,
-0.0213089604,
-0.0120374039,
-0.0165618528,
0.0027075824,
0.0370211266,
-0.0169721562,
-0.0325807221,
0.0128476406,
0.0112123117,
0.0638020337,
0.039021764,
-0.0096191382,
-0.0024553649,
0.0070632026,
0.0001520606,
0.0082673654,
-0.0110361474,
0.0185359064,
-0.0288747661,
0.0459575653,
-0.0504754893,
0.018186599,
-0.0077613587,
-0.009767455,
0.0026081048,
0.000002175,
-0.0527849235,
-0.0601333268,
0.0426784381,
-0.0252267346,
-0.0425550714,
0.041991327,
-0.0841718763,
-0.0080913724,
-0.0327307843,
-0.0522329062,
-0.0004368231,
0.012087414,
0.0750221014,
0.0589730255,
0.0663659126,
-0.0339351669,
0.0133487154,
0.0209433492,
0.0142169828,
0.0034147536,
-0.0344353765,
0.0541060306,
0.0465555899,
-0.0076565845,
-0.0232721418,
0.038935639,
0.0626331046,
-0.0202626791,
0.0038468875,
0.0206888355,
0.0579183511,
-0.0125274509,
0.0031455755,
0.0035112204,
0.0416784175,
-0.041011095,
0.0106357951,
0.0199135225,
-0.0433964394,
-0.0136826597,
0.009877055,
-0.0302004479,
0.0004835394,
-0.0545936488,
-0.0029121882,
0.0283128899,
-0.0016802687,
0.0121076796,
-0.0184568577,
-0.0377559774,
0.0138259167,
-0.0364013463,
-0.0220752992,
0.036895927,
0.0184743088,
-0.0065074493,
-0.0472383127,
0.0393149331,
0.0520040914,
-0.0029115255,
0.0283557419,
-0.00832457,
-0.0319252163,
0.0855147243,
-0.0629082322,
-0.0152710238,
-0.0348567478,
-0.0406007729,
0.0606338382,
-0.0321198851,
-0.0267973244,
-0.0255626068,
0.0449119806,
-0.0207464136,
0.0304241367,
-0.0190968085,
-0.0317295007,
-0.001046635,
0.0397777148,
-0.0158800222,
0.0254815184,
-0.0474308357,
-0.005952701,
-0.0266462322,
0.0584502965,
0.0444404893,
-0.0141300308,
-0.0509449542,
0.0255071092,
-0.0232165772,
0.0252419598,
0.0243541654,
0.0021843344,
-0.01713573,
-0.0050676321,
0.0150034903,
0.0184008311,
0.0327089317,
0.0005036968,
0.0142982258,
0.0442369133,
0.0109445006,
0.0031528811,
-0.0389206633,
-0.0757240504,
-0.0065483763,
-0.0130172241,
0.0072118086,
-0.0731810555,
0.0104536405,
0.0072767539,
0.0040802094,
-0.0559917428,
0.0060271462,
-0.0088333637,
-0.0167314988,
0.0495213494,
-0.0807990581,
-0.0232477169,
0.0102300243,
0.0202255175,
0.002474074,
0.0123607973,
-0.0011484396,
-0.0440494455,
-0.004005115,
0.0102224359,
0.0306211747,
0.0281246919,
0.018465288,
-0.0648218021,
-0.0387275033,
0.0303964578,
0.013722254,
0.019513838,
0.0133956345,
0.0377591066,
0.009952262,
0.013037133,
0.0202520471,
0.0509308688,
0.0524344482,
-0.0166632105,
-0.0035854066,
-0.0030845744,
0.0086178221,
-0.0120406505,
0.0221438296,
-0.0099887466,
0.018047329,
0.0357423313,
-0.0385291576,
0.0101945549,
0.016386684,
-0.0668150708,
-0.0300905928,
0.0010828356,
-0.0220147837,
0.0252619553,
0.0764745027,
-0.0074568866,
-0.027626669,
0.0192323923,
0.0582145192,
0.0030882147,
-0.0347215459,
-0.0437183902,
-0.0105959391,
0.0856847614,
0.053551428,
-0.0705417097,
-0.0452701449,
-0.0325494297,
-0.0370032787,
0.0009147534,
-0.0219043549,
-0.0286417026,
0.0258481484,
-0.0144770099,
-0.0112319393,
0.0312342457,
0.0109198866,
-0.0399475135,
0.00714014,
-0.0044276798,
-0.0404548571,
-0.0439727753,
-0.0379884429,
0.0692504048,
-0.069228977,
-0.017787626,
-0.0307678655,
0.0127904108,
0.0083550634,
0.0066087353,
-0.0261299964,
-0.0118384128,
0.0398815833,
-0.0211311188,
-0.0487968065,
0.0188980661,
-0.0613733418,
-0.043408975,
0.0354295224,
0.0054939594,
-0.0364222787,
-0.083473824,
-0.0201783627,
0.0314419791,
-0.0583027937,
0.0033929162,
0.0678154454,
-0.0089248838,
0.0140972873,
0.0490904003,
-0.0248810314,
-0.059089683,
0.064691633,
-0.0149751166,
-0.0257059447,
0.0049036294,
-0.0778469667,
0.0120838014,
-0.0110429293,
-0.0132731702,
0.0200299174,
-0.0008287446,
0.0159963649,
-0.0105626648,
0.0138319638,
-0.0278219022,
-0.0311150365,
-0.0756595358,
0.0008286298,
0.0100469505,
-0.0073519722,
0.0254531987,
0.0227354653,
-0.0085405894,
-0.0368658565,
-0.0432973839,
-0.0509704389,
0.0288768131,
-0.0294796396,
0.0748125389,
0.0650317967,
-0.0227387957,
-0.0445857793,
0.0234830491,
-0.0462201722,
-0.0009370306,
0.0536310226,
-0.0618761703,
-0.0198371541,
0.1011869088,
-0.0266116336,
0.039923761,
-0.0257584825,
0.0196222886,
0.0007957116,
-0.0559059381,
-0.0463105403,
0.0831077024,
-0.0218458008,
0.0417788513,
0.0371883884,
-0.0161866024,
-0.0574992634,
0.0164600369,
-0.0163337104,
-0.013227962,
-0.0288364906,
-0.0261985455,
0.0317306221,
0.062962614,
0.0085101211,
0.0059981556,
-0.0031502296,
0.0096855396,
-0.0199135989,
0.0111170551,
-0.0513465479,
-0.007880196,
-0.0089912368,
0.050648164,
-0.017082056,
-0.0289387684,
0.0934240967,
-0.0180010386,
0.0379485413,
-0.0659360737,
-0.0012179799,
-0.0353076868,
0.0327349193,
-0.013663088,
0.0127986809,
0.0233064499,
-0.0177932698,
0.0180853177,
0.0106069874,
0.0326874889,
-0.0850237608,
0.0662029982,
-0.031676434,
0.053213615,
0.0255890395,
-0.0283265095,
-0.0613189004,
0.0091902269,
0.008708124,
-0.0012888773,
-0.0246293396,
0.0162132252,
-0.0309326313,
0.0286591053,
0.0207422748,
0.0604283363,
0.0396120958,
-0.0249135327,
-0.0031049815,
0.0197942592,
0.0246982742,
-0.0257441159,
-0.0408528782,
-0.023021603,
0.0200674348,
0.0850498825,
-0.0382650755,
0.0252397172,
0.0124167632,
0.0029730569,
-0.0146700302,
-0.0249252673,
0.0174601674,
0.0138254408,
0.0480585583,
-0.0830603689,
-0.0312044043,
0.0993877426,
0.0324798562,
-0.0403491445,
-0.0041860566,
-0.0115045663,
-0.0778540075,
-0.0110994028,
0.0353079177,
-0.0327317417,
0.0148295229,
0.0175764821,
0.0148748178,
-0.0230728332,
-0.0500461385,
0.0375856273,
-0.0594202057,
0.0512029156,
-0.0015626337,
-0.0548811741,
-0.0635730401,
-0.0617523976,
0.0015321213,
-0.0066930098,
-0.0291066542,
-0.0006101251,
-0.0148541564,
-0.0207141973,
0.0013606803,
-0.0412870124,
-0.0867007002,
0.0187102444,
-0.0397851504,
-0.0013999963,
0.0617659949,
0.0171798319,
-0.0351239666,
-0.0349482968,
0.0037042364,
0.0553549975,
-0.0084328977,
-0.0052907541,
0.0730771348,
0.0004745239,
-0.0072417385,
-0.035147313,
0.0178501979,
-0.006155611,
-0.0104834447,
0.0103018358,
0.0752373487,
-0.0391264036,
-0.0058864709,
-0.0191920251,
0.0018935332,
0.0313568972,
0.0527111888,
-0.007542083,
0.0091786487,
0.0056069978,
-0.0335788317,
0.0507364497,
0.0079862857,
-0.017251702,
0.0733435825,
-0.0568496883,
-0.0144807016,
-0.0638552681,
-0.0199606083,
0.0636565834,
-0.0044038063,
0.0385554396,
0.043653056,
0.0057983622,
-0.011392111,
-0.1001530215,
0.0368457176,
0.0220137313,
0.0011095927,
-0.0178062227,
-0.0335161462,
0.0329403393,
0.0016737932,
-0.0191431772,
0.0303395819,
-0.0109240962,
0.0115466826,
0.0049515213,
0.0185172353,
0.0181895941,
0.044856213,
-0.0040330123,
0.0290694106,
0.0736767873,
0.0258807521,
-0.0819035321,
-0.031035373,
-0.0102033708,
-0.0276767034,
0.0135170147,
-0.010741692,
-0.02518983,
0.0230966732,
0.0185361616,
0.0358235575,
-0.0449018665,
-0.0017336806,
0.0572383292,
0.0592527427,
0.0232083946,
0.0170884039,
-0.0278300755,
-0.0449819826,
0.0133862989,
-0.0213503577,
-0.0140866218,
-0.0266781412,
0.0250350796,
0.0089866808,
0.0027784139,
-0.0103333015,
0.0397936888,
-0.0240039639,
-0.010205253,
-0.0318130031,
0.0529279858,
0.0370404236,
0.0044147726,
0.0768625364,
-0.0185293872,
-0.0098729776,
-0.0356218889,
0.0391068533,
0.0442982242,
-0.0010848588,
0.0301051643,
0.0200058054,
0.0429338031,
-0.0389318019,
0.0112788286,
-0.0107402364,
0.0395488963,
-0.0640403479,
-0.016240852,
0.0018283497,
-0.0159686003,
0.0321141519,
-0.0472935364,
0.0073706349,
-0.0119853085,
0.0280326009,
-0.0217284318,
-0.0030962138,
0.0527008735,
0.0205377135,
-0.0085738441,
-0.0598717518,
0.0638158321,
-0.0260364786,
0.0487749763,
-0.0687473938,
-0.0542699732,
-0.0755207613,
0.0082829958,
0.03263193,
0.0056229308,
-0.0558305047,
0.0021976163,
-0.049260661,
-0.0401020683,
0.0341249816,
0.0090274662,
-0.0401219316,
-0.0093027921,
0.0037345893,
0.07784684,
0.0256007165,
-0.0575319156,
-0.0280748811,
0.0412344262,
0.0052543422,
-0.0254821964,
0.0124940053,
-6.066216474e-33,
-0.0177664477,
-0.0560604744,
0.0477007106,
0.0071517606,
0.0131699257,
0.0433705151,
-0.029071819,
-0.0395320766,
0.0149017526,
0.0219620652,
-0.0303836167,
-0.0235439278,
0.0163696464,
-0.0017330921,
0.0255263075,
-0.011923953,
0.0262336545,
0.0054201679,
-0.0086072572,
-0.0346633345,
0.0051799305,
0.0707290173,
0.0698442683,
-0.1182882339,
0.0158710796,
0.0420494452,
0.0177220926,
0.0089122327,
0.0116958767,
0.0502031781,
-0.0395573303,
-0.0031324551,
0.0436553471,
-0.0318194628,
-0.0066982228,
-0.0203091055,
-0.1149700284,
0.0041608885,
-0.0048162327,
0.0110887736,
-0.0158960614,
-0.0104396362,
0.0596546009,
-0.0237113703,
0.046092581,
-0.0176901817,
0.0484550335,
-0.0418948382,
0.0038574177,
-0.0533932857,
-0.0548453629,
0.0758248493,
0.015499902,
0.0320877321,
0.0189765953,
-0.0400327742,
-0.0059685586,
0.0425952002,
-0.0203414541,
-0.0123907337,
0.0442538932,
0.0461411476,
0.0033290593,
0.012190694,
-0.0150232119,
0.0871462449,
0.0236919858,
-0.0173831079,
-0.0269044358,
-0.0044918912,
-0.0022261802,
0.0483284332,
-0.0344972722,
0.0121077551,
0.0204851571,
-0.0025932523,
-0.0931463614,
0.0581110828,
-0.0489929952,
0.0292887334,
-0.0124399392,
-0.0244497564,
-0.0544007607,
0.0086519811,
0.0073097972,
-0.0050115604,
0.0012656435,
-0.0080181165,
0.0162243359,
0.0278364532,
0.0049170894,
0.0277119912,
-0.0128319543,
0.0076661757,
0.0067250351,
-0.0453484915,
0.0543234125,
0.0136442576,
-0.0604082122,
-0.0191284642,
-0.0336451083,
-0.0259875972,
-0.0161777288,
0.0076638451,
0.0543641523,
0.0074127004,
0.0636891946,
-0.0174116828,
-0.0757220611,
0.009218662,
-0.0107712606,
0.0161755029,
0.0007242755,
0.0407169424,
0.0403457396,
0.0310650468,
-0.0230410937,
0.0348666869,
0.0039746924,
-0.0099505298,
-0.0305968653,
-0.0146377776,
-0.0037092536,
-0.0106645431,
-0.043233145,
-0.037052989,
0.0022994052,
-0.0123478658,
0.0636032224,
-0.034367945,
0.0163114462,
0.0073323781,
2.906e-7,
0.1124250591,
0.0457593165,
0.0353051126,
-0.0190528277,
0.0160462633,
-0.0049836338,
-0.0363474376,
-0.0306776725,
0.0010556468,
-0.00126701,
0.0339021347,
-0.0039127357,
0.0006975733,
0.0619221814,
-0.0886208266,
-0.0303605702,
-0.0120637612,
-0.063898474,
-0.0028840802,
-0.0132024707,
0.0390669927,
0.0412706099,
-0.0404958054,
-0.0303074326,
0.0075551933,
-0.0388538316,
0.0114976484,
-0.0390422605,
0.0218345001,
0.0326948278,
0.0270593893,
-0.0127809821,
0.0247254074,
0.0680279583,
-0.0066062133,
0.0178296175,
0.002330686,
0.1095741019,
-0.022842247,
0.0177593585,
-0.0034593774,
-0.0119921016,
0.0332660936,
-0.0230970085,
0.0213016886,
-0.0425831415,
-0.0249415636,
-0.0154917687,
-0.0162750501,
-0.0199662335,
-0.0050092349,
-0.0252589546,
-0.0171883386,
0.0653230324,
0.0058378377,
0.0324113704,
-0.0343262739,
-0.0643806234,
-0.0321075246,
0.0252255928,
-0.0036224239,
-0.0288286079,
0.0682998151,
-0.0260247421,
-0.0199671108,
-0.0584218353,
0.0370240286,
2.93258244e-34,
0.0228755064,
0.0173556264,
-0.0335112885,
0.0448011309,
0.0191350412,
-0.0046852403,
0.0022551517,
0.0366326049,
-0.0296790898,
-0.0356180742,
0.0112595903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01599v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01599v1 | JailbreakZoo: Survey, Landscapes, and Horizons in Jailbreaking Large Language and Vision-Language Models | 2024-06-26T02:20:23 | 2024-06-26T02:20:23 | Haibo Jin, Leyang Hu, Xinuo Li, Peiyan Zhang, Chonghan Chen, Jun Zhuang, Haohan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CV, cs.LG | The rapid evolution of artificial intelligence (AI) through developments in
Large Language Models (LLMs) and Vision-Language Models (VLMs) has brought
significant advancements across various technological domains. While these
models enhance capabilities in natural language processing and visual
interactive tasks, their growing adoption raises critical concerns regarding
security and ethical alignment. This survey provides an extensive review of the
emerging field of jailbreaking--deliberately circumventing the ethical and
operational boundaries of LLMs and VLMs--and the consequent development of
defense mechanisms. Our study categorizes jailbreaks into seven distinct types
and elaborates on defense strategies that address these vulnerabilities.
Through this comprehensive examination, we identify research gaps and propose
directions for future studies to enhance the security frameworks of LLMs and
VLMs. Our findings underscore the necessity for a unified perspective that
integrates both jailbreak strategies and defensive solutions to foster a
robust, secure, and reliable environment for the next generation of language
models. More details can be found on our website:
\url{https://chonghan-chen.com/llm-jailbreak-zoo-survey/}. | [
0.0698621273,
0.0786489993,
-0.0055694249,
0.0488077924,
-0.0809419677,
-0.0188770089,
0.0305149928,
-0.0020183397,
0.0740283355,
-0.0371022299,
-0.0234740023,
-0.0038704393,
0.0116107035,
0.0406741425,
0.0298825353,
0.0076726428,
0.0523399077,
-0.0362896509,
-0.0156683046,
0.0028455411,
0.0142310848,
-0.0078733591,
0.0557678081,
0.0072194445,
-0.0052653304,
-0.0140481815,
-0.0289014746,
0.0146877579,
0.0064293621,
-0.0213123038,
-0.0163655132,
0.0122164804,
0.0030801289,
0.0801119357,
0.0000023205,
-0.0435899757,
-0.0519994199,
0.0422452725,
0.009432165,
0.0356619954,
0.019474484,
-0.095088847,
-0.0210631192,
-0.0175648052,
-0.0522694774,
0.0188254826,
0.0446520075,
0.0550167598,
0.0785370097,
0.0377043523,
-0.0041346457,
-0.0252892412,
0.0583946332,
0.0050092582,
-0.0199231263,
-0.063032575,
0.019394977,
-0.0197651908,
0.0003102758,
0.0166487079,
-0.001392329,
0.0133566065,
0.0353509858,
-0.0247586761,
-0.050956063,
-0.0151769891,
-0.0415756404,
-0.0562589616,
-0.0051853359,
0.028359456,
-0.0407408252,
-0.0245035216,
0.0103792455,
0.0311450679,
0.0177453887,
0.0199557301,
0.0067658434,
0.0625897124,
-0.0067010359,
-0.0185305607,
0.0494309328,
-0.0201475006,
0.0442274064,
0.0128373494,
0.0023612243,
0.0009840982,
0.0146591896,
-0.0384371318,
-0.0090086097,
-0.044780124,
-0.0069676987,
-0.0569421239,
0.0182295144,
-0.0018588455,
0.0265138876,
0.0052309954,
-0.0924097151,
-0.0256277192,
0.0147539889,
-0.0574272163,
-0.0022321437,
0.0134009821,
-0.0146687301,
0.0175672304,
0.0157540664,
0.0099316016,
-0.0423879549,
0.0239045992,
0.0111832116,
-0.0107451882,
-0.0064782924,
-0.0475328304,
-0.0000359745,
0.0667138398,
-0.0407428369,
-0.006303004,
-0.0103420336,
0.0243165195,
-0.0462892801,
0.0292365123,
-0.059655901,
0.018845899,
0.0271498673,
0.0114002433,
0.0410353951,
-0.0392017923,
0.0037747142,
-0.0272282343,
-0.0147177055,
-0.0642105862,
-0.0058761034,
-0.0018751496,
-0.0951455832,
-0.0033379204,
-0.0113988155,
0.1250312179,
0.0433873944,
-0.008939595,
-0.0818273649,
-0.0920694321,
-0.0345970057,
-0.0426035896,
0.0191018153,
-0.0757082105,
-0.024612898,
-0.0379214026,
-0.0032718398,
-0.0481105633,
0.0209302474,
-0.0037745519,
-0.0583458655,
0.039048925,
-0.0190935973,
-0.0160213802,
0.0028123665,
0.0524011962,
0.0678068548,
0.0384374261,
0.0019962494,
0.0510342494,
0.0713140815,
-0.0094599826,
0.0614498071,
0.0291973874,
-0.0298800822,
0.0082336161,
-0.0471944623,
-0.0010519361,
0.0447792448,
-0.0125235198,
-0.0565500036,
0.047784064,
0.0034026345,
-0.0419209078,
0.0963315964,
0.1058846414,
-0.0465030111,
0.0276457034,
-0.0139706228,
-0.0468206778,
0.0442313999,
-0.0145117156,
-0.0476513132,
0.0071634469,
-0.0626756251,
-0.0393394977,
-0.0855514333,
0.0577564426,
0.0063029691,
-0.0114436708,
0.0120819546,
-0.0413779244,
-0.0127771646,
0.0272053331,
0.0126163568,
0.0135338195,
0.0402641259,
0.0104425019,
0.0065337596,
-0.0428550318,
-0.035481859,
-0.0932925418,
-0.0032415155,
0.0803096145,
0.042956192,
0.0210563391,
0.0048975879,
0.0070887725,
-0.0143842846,
0.0042298199,
-0.0156897139,
0.0173592288,
0.0151745575,
-0.0012859429,
0.0075017381,
-0.0333015881,
0.0161097217,
0.0099263266,
-0.0271645449,
-0.007169914,
-0.0111993188,
-0.0228281841,
-0.035592109,
0.0032694193,
0.0252657272,
0.0242036916,
0.0105629172,
0.0220371038,
-0.012244991,
0.0233554691,
-0.0558384135,
0.0262191687,
0.0750222728,
-0.0066928412,
0.0684677586,
-0.0034341316,
-0.0140011832,
0.0215023309,
0.0276116468,
-0.0631549507,
0.0304748192,
0.0896018147,
-0.0279370993,
0.0024137737,
0.0457386076,
-0.039547503,
0.0218152236,
-0.0195030514,
0.0281431489,
-0.0351552963,
0.01617481,
-0.0422740467,
-0.0036548597,
-0.0342317335,
-0.0327318013,
-0.0219756979,
0.017636396,
0.0345466919,
0.0182321761,
-0.0462727621,
0.0467437953,
-0.0239847358,
0.0141443759,
0.0061599412,
0.0205622334,
-0.0050143893,
-0.0407425798,
-0.0233797189,
-0.0182617866,
-0.0123255709,
0.0101330103,
0.0253043734,
0.0138965361,
-0.0272232946,
-0.0258102119,
0.0052163526,
-0.0204863027,
0.0068758023,
-0.0000634768,
-0.0096932752,
-0.0216230284,
-0.0507514849,
0.0144359041,
-0.0218196027,
0.0078164199,
0.0301325303,
-0.0256648231,
-0.0359483734,
-0.0106607648,
-0.0198507532,
-0.0223872997,
0.0184306297,
-0.0087749129,
-0.0071414327,
0.0277909618,
0.0093646254,
-0.0383997746,
0.0718492791,
0.0087224413,
0.0691370815,
0.0565689728,
0.0021644698,
-0.0007334985,
-0.0535054319,
0.0771679059,
-0.0429907106,
-0.0409244299,
-0.0442831032,
0.0181417298,
0.0105706593,
0.0196915474,
-0.0009755301,
-0.015959302,
0.0590246581,
-0.0041110772,
-0.0511592887,
0.02632498,
-0.0482233986,
-0.0370238535,
-0.0103849825,
-0.0258383118,
-0.0873170346,
0.0562044121,
-0.0587708876,
0.0230813157,
0.0050217644,
-0.0649505779,
-0.0271047074,
0.060217645,
0.0125891557,
0.0457116216,
0.054280255,
-0.0246097781,
-0.0277032126,
-0.0015573795,
-0.0047616912,
-0.0274291094,
0.0412797481,
-0.0604092181,
-0.0243853945,
-0.0160399675,
-0.0332250819,
-0.0258795302,
-0.0392866619,
-0.0089674136,
-0.0086414907,
0.035254579,
-0.0371753387,
0.0214507245,
-0.0301765576,
0.0430276319,
-0.0209523663,
0.0016964775,
-0.0030820798,
-0.0367028266,
0.0252352636,
0.0044201682,
-0.0589243583,
-0.0074228444,
0.0312342234,
0.0369079858,
0.0922902301,
0.0499882028,
0.0326505676,
0.0265528448,
0.0596053675,
0.0360883921,
0.0281890985,
-0.0239977296,
0.0064492184,
0.0158046596,
-0.0222784225,
-0.0154888509,
0.0317485332,
0.0198495183,
-0.0176889896,
0.0304817986,
0.0131992148,
-0.0052762055,
0.0177947097,
0.0276709683,
-0.0738637745,
0.0010651948,
0.0112086134,
0.0704801679,
-0.0494520031,
-0.0227815807,
-0.0409948193,
-0.0731552541,
-0.0044095581,
0.0448556058,
0.0046514156,
-0.01963217,
-0.0291212033,
-0.0462399758,
0.0238818675,
0.0027114437,
-0.031393908,
-0.0096482225,
0.0011661338,
0.018793771,
-0.0465130322,
0.0276727695,
0.0177802015,
-0.0182464346,
0.0422555283,
0.0913966522,
-0.0058460669,
-0.043585334,
0.0274658892,
0.0132448766,
0.0218204968,
0.0092977574,
0.00570744,
-0.0179809928,
-0.0057292101,
-0.0159690697,
-0.0048570991,
0.0484729074,
0.0238717031,
-0.0527887493,
0.0374089405,
0.0411937311,
-0.0211820621,
-0.02761654,
-0.0290606562,
-0.047192242,
-0.0092172148,
0.0280221421,
0.0018594223,
-0.0363982096,
-0.0672904402,
-0.0538393371,
-0.0402457789,
-0.0584179722,
-0.0176775046,
0.0185659807,
0.030712422,
-0.0315751284,
-0.0215290003,
0.0028125397,
-0.0291185807,
0.0346010737,
0.0579993241,
-0.0119942287,
0.0047482261,
-0.0028420791,
-0.0302960761,
-0.0220951959,
0.0023363661,
0.0453025252,
-0.0213877223,
0.03539652,
-0.0085181938,
-0.0205960926,
0.0051651513,
0.0171290282,
-0.025999181,
-0.0546134412,
0.0416466929,
0.0669005662,
0.0191732608,
-0.0245355256,
-0.0334704071,
-0.0442845747,
0.0394280925,
0.0918294713,
-0.0412357338,
0.0361655243,
0.0625011772,
-0.0251961928,
0.0128588295,
0.0133232838,
0.0007912092,
-0.0273376126,
0.0827574953,
-0.0005923852,
-0.058768332,
0.011974996,
0.0147587406,
0.0509181023,
-0.0293706376,
-0.0129783619,
0.0438305922,
0.0439813584,
0.023030797,
-0.0067583313,
-0.0336982049,
-0.0275326483,
0.0080649666,
0.0499210134,
0.0024842874,
0.0313670821,
0.0411072969,
0.032529816,
-0.0451073311,
0.0147526395,
0.0306363795,
0.0301627498,
0.0520125851,
0.0415348075,
0.0390441492,
-0.0336132683,
0.06537918,
-0.0417633802,
0.0392101966,
-0.021850476,
0.0594511405,
-0.0039884434,
-0.0148482472,
-0.0378174596,
0.0799407735,
-0.0782578439,
-0.0477645732,
0.0100801978,
0.1137196273,
-0.0142414719,
0.0266687181,
-0.0282380544,
-0.0168592576,
0.0079101445,
-0.0434645228,
-0.0348282866,
0.0021577217,
-0.0563358963,
-0.0110052628,
0.0064246426,
-0.0203765426,
0.0243911948,
0.047810141,
0.0397013053,
0.049830012,
0.0137781054,
-0.0095093921,
-0.0177431833,
-0.0018359511,
0.0674258322,
-0.010894496,
-0.0400017574,
-0.0394192636,
-0.0752403587,
-0.0771218464,
-0.0096623218,
0.011570042,
0.0356933512,
-0.0028772182,
-0.0430594683,
0.0538196936,
0.0368366092,
0.0112687349,
-0.0634869635,
0.0119189983,
-0.009045165,
-0.0544304699,
0.0362846479,
-5.615268188e-33,
0.0404971354,
-0.0339399837,
-0.0667208955,
-0.0250565764,
-0.0074421838,
0.0007042507,
0.0049608019,
0.0047317501,
-0.0318867452,
-0.0441887714,
-0.0230971035,
-0.0096206069,
-0.0101067685,
0.0133234318,
-0.0369441174,
-0.0215887371,
-0.0255189594,
0.0195744671,
-0.0014645184,
0.0110112298,
0.0380216949,
0.021208372,
0.0118473712,
-0.0366354473,
0.0663530007,
-0.0251551084,
-0.0244086161,
0.0363265015,
-0.0531381741,
0.0527448989,
0.0144360587,
0.0060875006,
0.0109853176,
-0.0142334197,
-0.0114622544,
0.0891413763,
0.0081940377,
0.023308564,
0.0102504501,
0.0123659018,
-0.0010088197,
-0.0367896222,
0.009685602,
-0.0068958071,
0.0024854289,
-0.0016022596,
-0.0270059295,
-0.0368220434,
-0.0175567102,
0.0115896128,
-0.0000576855,
-0.0208585933,
-0.0455783941,
0.0163237918,
0.0212863758,
-0.0442961045,
-0.0123511609,
-0.001202144,
-0.0089338822,
0.0504531562,
0.0414116159,
-0.0253962912,
0.0572439767,
0.0004543036,
-0.0013567656,
0.0518258922,
0.0088528739,
-0.0500706397,
-0.0026460628,
-0.0259334836,
-0.0113194855,
0.0836078897,
0.0587347783,
0.0712532923,
0.0162589811,
-0.0132317534,
-0.04154668,
-0.0368986316,
0.0016504686,
0.0318564363,
0.0305738039,
-0.0067903944,
-0.0319392346,
0.0044418694,
-0.0154554462,
-0.0309275575,
-0.0375060551,
-0.0103454692,
0.0239449218,
0.0049268636,
-0.0406130999,
-0.0069495132,
0.0099909138,
-0.0927559212,
0.0112237642,
0.0106897,
0.0139897261,
-0.0034702094,
-0.0146064898,
0.0351470858,
-0.0137662068,
0.0024008334,
0.0134316413,
-0.0317284428,
0.0437899269,
-0.0185509585,
0.0299360882,
0.018656088,
-0.0308979936,
0.0004700197,
0.0017599151,
0.0417567901,
0.0286416989,
-0.0000393617,
0.0141192107,
-0.0290139485,
-0.0025923655,
-0.0262964312,
0.0320388488,
0.0152128786,
-0.0500423945,
0.0285111591,
-0.0458385982,
0.0295181442,
0.0224472266,
0.0183970071,
-0.0063776844,
0.0353211574,
0.0497109853,
-0.034956608,
-0.0007235091,
0.0143954838,
3.133e-7,
-0.0423265249,
-0.0331620313,
0.0101030599,
-0.0493264571,
0.0180396251,
0.0755407736,
0.002652755,
0.0773704797,
-0.0333884135,
-0.0288408361,
-0.038716577,
-0.0116433315,
0.0689482093,
-0.0079965713,
-0.0061211837,
0.046917107,
-0.0337713137,
-0.0277011022,
-0.0680201128,
0.0198938176,
0.0288303308,
0.0526443124,
-0.0092510944,
-0.0440995693,
-0.0010224674,
-0.082060419,
-0.017442327,
0.0060093366,
-0.010209512,
-0.0325374156,
-0.0066986852,
0.0604027882,
0.003231083,
-0.0012793357,
-0.0165248308,
-0.0233568698,
-0.0398043618,
0.0296257026,
-0.0072153434,
-0.0048722187,
-0.0574368089,
-0.0391827486,
-0.0320772938,
-0.0478357226,
0.0686268806,
0.0322058983,
-0.0375057682,
-0.0136899697,
0.040850766,
-0.0399248526,
0.0023463082,
-0.0341549665,
0.0226382054,
0.004143253,
0.0315244086,
0.0259271245,
0.0214032661,
-0.0766608864,
0.0064508948,
0.0121829342,
0.0140185421,
-0.0301221889,
-0.0048648953,
0.0563892536,
0.0557434261,
-0.0130756488,
-0.0043644244,
2.963256643e-34,
-0.0278221313,
-0.0609512143,
0.0178880468,
0.0342987329,
0.0188340936,
0.0177970491,
-0.0160909481,
0.0156163583,
-0.000967767,
-0.0256516524,
-0.0065287561
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18002v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18002v1 | Decoding with Limited Teacher Supervision Requires Understanding When to Trust the Teacher | 2024-06-26T01:16:12 | 2024-06-26T01:16:12 | Hyunjong Ok, Jegwang Ryu, Jaeho Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | How can sLLMs efficiently utilize the supervision of LLMs to improve their
generative quality? This question has been well studied in scenarios where
there is no restriction on the number of LLM supervisions one can use, giving
birth to many decoding algorithms that utilize supervision without further
training. However, it is still unclear what is an effective strategy under the
limited supervision scenario, where we assume that no more than a few tokens
can be generated by LLMs. To this end, we develop an algorithm to effectively
aggregate the sLLM and LLM predictions on initial tokens so that the generated
tokens can more accurately condition the subsequent token generation by sLLM
only. Critically, we find that it is essential to adaptively overtrust or
disregard the LLM prediction based on the confidence of the sLLM. Through our
experiments on a wide range of models and datasets, we demonstrate that our
method provides a consistent improvement over conventional decoding strategies. | [
-0.0070892591,
0.0758449286,
0.0219942145,
0.0297140926,
0.0074460292,
0.0087307412,
0.0200376753,
-0.0103850551,
-0.0411022715,
-0.0085482253,
-0.0036673443,
0.0045237984,
0.0042672944,
-0.0328044593,
0.0361328237,
-0.0055072205,
0.0122816246,
-0.0636858344,
-0.0008139953,
-0.0200005397,
-0.0377829932,
0.0179063436,
-0.0145086888,
0.0289138891,
-0.0347037949,
-0.0034426348,
-0.0133494548,
0.0505507775,
0.0270577446,
-0.0146667371,
-0.013877376,
0.0505408309,
0.0310885981,
0.0249124318,
0.0000018635,
-0.0111424439,
-0.0342618376,
-0.0161737558,
-0.0406053178,
0.007655168,
0.0092518805,
-0.0383106172,
-0.0362799242,
0.0133760059,
-0.033863306,
0.0086128898,
0.0334650949,
0.0071738246,
0.0389950871,
0.0764878765,
0.0144290552,
-0.0248736497,
0.0217234492,
0.0292200334,
0.0222855378,
-0.0454889312,
0.0239116047,
0.0060184444,
-0.0566064529,
-0.028743254,
-0.0412347466,
0.04691476,
0.0331376977,
-0.0236241072,
0.0160304792,
0.019894531,
0.0041483724,
-0.0308343209,
-0.0413201936,
0.0087058386,
0.0139142964,
-0.0565815866,
0.0058532851,
0.0030655975,
0.024446059,
-0.0193821657,
-0.0434988104,
0.064382568,
-0.0343101472,
0.0737521127,
0.0336285569,
0.0246924721,
0.0226427298,
-0.0167724025,
-0.0255245622,
0.0559151992,
0.0218005646,
-0.0303253792,
-0.0130095799,
0.0625706092,
0.0181420539,
-0.0104232132,
0.0004616708,
0.0250591058,
-0.0355437845,
0.0343359783,
-0.0676131546,
-0.0358442031,
-0.0021260162,
0.0617880374,
0.0073878313,
0.0216524526,
-0.0227930527,
0.0021879878,
-0.0155876391,
0.021444466,
0.0151339713,
0.0572637133,
-0.0381817631,
-0.0077065183,
-0.0225538574,
-0.0096337413,
-0.0215419661,
0.0387972817,
-0.026742436,
0.0329010822,
-0.0565072633,
0.0107510705,
0.0213388801,
0.0248979796,
0.0071958578,
-0.0121493256,
-0.0502965935,
-0.0021537002,
0.0205814727,
0.0187958702,
0.0088928146,
0.0398417749,
0.0184082985,
-0.0785919055,
-0.024146203,
0.0249600131,
0.012845681,
0.0113152349,
-0.0426646918,
0.0596797206,
-0.0317498334,
-0.0059386897,
-0.0934545845,
-0.0653233677,
-0.0178431515,
-0.0363300703,
0.0164960492,
-0.0826329961,
0.0152513199,
-0.0204854291,
0.0169817675,
-0.0325729772,
-0.0181475151,
-0.0275773313,
0.0375372097,
0.0287742075,
-0.0479635149,
0.0061003002,
-0.0112207253,
0.0119079426,
-0.0085322428,
0.0874292403,
0.0015581205,
0.0531372353,
0.0219640657,
0.0080378596,
0.0219546761,
0.0607975274,
0.0547227636,
0.0357547924,
0.0111621488,
-0.0344565883,
0.0088640284,
-0.0077230241,
0.0608567148,
0.0503502116,
-0.0714243129,
-0.0024780827,
0.072502248,
0.0720148683,
0.029066572,
0.0079435436,
0.0343969241,
0.0128673101,
0.0125673255,
0.0626185164,
-0.0221789293,
0.0000152978,
-0.0226054378,
0.0123511264,
0.023926964,
0.0313456468,
-0.016017748,
-0.0725349635,
-0.0091348849,
-0.045298636,
-0.0288340859,
-0.0000844877,
0.0601439998,
0.0220615827,
-0.0439629667,
0.0613714419,
0.0241968073,
-0.066171132,
0.0167555828,
-0.0801725835,
0.0257841926,
0.0593485609,
0.0451391041,
0.0163519476,
-0.0271247476,
-0.0106413253,
0.0394491516,
0.0464733131,
-0.021656679,
-0.0061198818,
0.0496998206,
-0.0550065041,
-0.0560022891,
0.0592427924,
0.0233723726,
0.0330989547,
0.0216330253,
-0.0058392896,
-0.0007189761,
-0.0351823196,
-0.0297583397,
0.0560127907,
-0.006398832,
-0.0435939059,
0.0070141293,
0.0100996736,
0.0408444926,
0.0465350486,
0.0039855707,
0.0147484411,
0.0493927561,
-0.0407264829,
-0.0358034149,
-0.0247686729,
-0.0706773847,
-0.0686608925,
0.027365692,
-0.0562874563,
-0.0308300145,
0.0018738569,
-0.0221092384,
-0.0516274944,
-0.0037271956,
-0.0572372563,
0.0629566982,
-0.0554015413,
0.0127197467,
0.0247636158,
-0.0160875041,
-0.0264872853,
0.0252139512,
-0.0331222415,
-0.0261666477,
0.0284798034,
0.0133070946,
-0.0041876505,
-0.0703773722,
0.0290284194,
-0.0008996452,
-0.0492534414,
0.0365190431,
-0.0067767166,
0.0475833416,
-0.0501839854,
-0.067466341,
-0.0308268573,
-0.0509814136,
-0.0526305735,
0.0235142522,
-0.0004986543,
-0.0476508066,
-0.017803764,
-0.0103282118,
-0.0464134291,
-0.0383249931,
-0.0169047695,
-0.0301933326,
-0.0041678422,
-0.0224583112,
-0.0401837192,
-0.0194779169,
-0.0111292098,
0.0077860449,
0.0270364173,
0.0104965931,
-0.0311716758,
-0.0716351271,
0.0291679036,
-0.0184475929,
-0.0165278018,
0.0069907117,
-0.0241385009,
0.0461300574,
-0.042373769,
0.0138731524,
0.0206090007,
-0.0232447349,
0.0065750619,
0.0238319654,
-0.0175067782,
-0.0835939795,
-0.0147167966,
0.0036324027,
-0.0549247675,
-0.0608294271,
-0.0240795556,
0.0227665324,
0.0395789221,
0.0509981327,
-0.0009344326,
-0.058783181,
-0.0098797828,
0.0029929953,
-0.0858339518,
0.0118402522,
0.0011130059,
-0.0122122932,
0.0402142406,
0.0081444839,
-0.0868213326,
0.0483437553,
-0.0422300994,
-0.0188159049,
-0.0149163259,
-0.0113441302,
-0.03154945,
0.0084308293,
-0.0573802479,
0.0184296891,
-0.0237092432,
-0.0675999075,
-0.0201453269,
0.0105397711,
0.0071161417,
-0.0388352945,
0.0242155194,
-0.054448653,
0.0102520064,
-0.024629591,
-0.0145164737,
-0.0494019389,
0.012668279,
-0.0139785185,
-0.0063317013,
0.0060179648,
-0.0322223417,
-0.0260077473,
-0.0386995673,
-0.0294775497,
-0.0075797373,
-0.0200752039,
0.0035694914,
-0.0319676921,
-0.0017640541,
0.0069343518,
-0.000869447,
0.0035107569,
-0.0696863458,
0.0366373025,
0.0622605532,
0.0611478835,
0.0282292236,
-0.0244484115,
0.0177858081,
0.0618923567,
0.0199090093,
0.0465613492,
0.0579040907,
0.0466753095,
-0.0205972716,
0.0136878341,
0.1252539009,
0.0163909625,
-0.0360303968,
-0.0181983598,
-0.0151453279,
0.0420545787,
-0.0087214792,
-0.0222409945,
-0.0742486119,
-0.0300380681,
0.0149600348,
0.0711939037,
-0.0001828607,
-0.0094826277,
-0.0193130895,
-0.0603435859,
0.054269772,
0.0669596195,
-0.0529392511,
-0.0157498233,
-0.0399900638,
-0.0687310472,
-0.0121298898,
0.0614588,
0.0257421918,
-0.0057864906,
0.0069078873,
0.0517930612,
-0.0160850808,
-0.0384293012,
-0.0464638881,
-0.0325237438,
0.073646158,
0.0602204874,
-0.0060784523,
0.0097046215,
-0.0502864458,
0.0194972046,
0.0019977575,
-0.0307658724,
-0.027172748,
0.0196547434,
-0.0334925652,
0.0085832058,
-0.0088101476,
0.0885502547,
-0.0509853065,
0.0103493147,
0.0166726168,
0.0532552861,
-0.0090072947,
-0.0347114168,
-0.0004469273,
0.0020659,
0.0270393509,
0.0870554373,
0.0536275059,
-0.0104560982,
0.0090990607,
-0.0369685963,
0.0154860206,
-0.0528009608,
-0.0058175945,
0.058561977,
-0.0030374893,
-0.0209932402,
-0.0577840172,
-0.0255321302,
0.0372249037,
0.0301022567,
-0.0154495556,
0.0447287075,
-0.021077197,
-0.0592444316,
-0.0274924822,
-0.0005163435,
-0.0406158306,
0.001666949,
-0.0824583247,
-0.0158139672,
0.003095448,
-0.0399864689,
0.0281742252,
0.0065496988,
-0.1015740111,
-0.0732183382,
-0.009780068,
0.029645808,
0.0257113278,
0.0288838297,
-0.004021633,
-0.0205833744,
0.0912611559,
0.0572097301,
-0.0048218565,
0.038700249,
0.0642455071,
0.0262201093,
0.0158584435,
0.0443309955,
-0.0524943061,
0.0048872749,
0.0437326357,
0.0328548215,
-0.0347346775,
0.0280933194,
0.0424221009,
0.0292085689,
0.0142067987,
-0.0586144291,
0.0043328507,
-0.0175004583,
0.0468098745,
-0.0081607709,
0.0246588849,
-0.0358878523,
0.0232764743,
0.0268832017,
-0.004511395,
0.0127484696,
0.0021355506,
0.0034322862,
0.0511741266,
-0.0245092511,
0.02220238,
-0.0145942327,
-0.0210894011,
0.0236553345,
-0.0159377456,
-0.0214673206,
0.0254005902,
0.0002026767,
0.0077049038,
0.0400970094,
-0.022188412,
0.0093751252,
0.065091908,
0.0011940347,
-0.0024664402,
-0.0486036465,
-0.054129947,
-0.0211126823,
0.0263100825,
0.0659852102,
0.0428090692,
0.0611939058,
-0.0180078596,
0.030841656,
-0.034379445,
0.0193616766,
-0.0209510084,
0.0071941828,
0.0342852287,
-0.0060378495,
-0.012788726,
-0.0180435572,
0.0505751483,
0.015186605,
0.0568447486,
-0.0466348603,
0.029258702,
-0.044571951,
-0.0423422195,
0.0303072128,
-0.0150119765,
-0.0155671462,
-0.0209443644,
-0.0276767369,
-0.0490873568,
0.0138405031,
0.0259520411,
0.0210801996,
0.0004062878,
0.0351151079,
0.0310078971,
-0.0522232428,
0.0120856911,
0.0077559482,
-0.0476358123,
0.0574897975,
-0.0473635122,
-0.000988581,
-6.086190327e-33,
-0.0342873298,
-0.0472801886,
0.0379962213,
0.0117382538,
0.0287535023,
0.0373226441,
-0.0123703247,
-0.0171312969,
0.0502407961,
0.0139353713,
-0.0031592213,
0.0045873309,
0.0465807803,
0.0460353419,
0.0202066526,
-0.006120753,
0.0562217534,
-0.0246302728,
-0.0173423253,
-0.0189037155,
0.0241054371,
0.0364377536,
0.0505365245,
-0.0195308551,
0.042753756,
-0.0179087929,
-0.0157787595,
-0.006420658,
-0.0306380913,
0.0712854192,
0.0000031932,
0.0241524559,
0.0157144815,
-0.0045940699,
-0.0618643202,
0.0025207088,
-0.0694240853,
-0.0119292876,
0.0002563581,
0.0070982473,
-0.0349519812,
-0.0457038172,
0.0244311765,
0.0161111578,
-0.0775902271,
-0.0189358182,
0.0099378889,
-0.0269703362,
-0.0381875485,
-0.0826586559,
-0.0143356295,
0.02986449,
0.0052862549,
0.0008704368,
0.0480440296,
-0.0012568211,
-0.0103998175,
0.0067498875,
-0.0030142097,
0.0673329607,
0.0504599661,
0.0254194289,
0.0845933408,
0.0104260817,
-0.0324344002,
0.0554265417,
0.0324838944,
-0.0357277766,
-0.0252801292,
-0.0093644289,
0.0299645718,
0.0521385297,
0.015758317,
0.0284875203,
0.0236315764,
0.0099062948,
-0.0469982587,
0.0406635068,
0.0088885734,
0.0195772275,
-0.0059789973,
0.039377436,
-0.0140592875,
-0.0160960425,
-0.0443942361,
-0.0362046286,
-0.0031814522,
0.0018164509,
0.0249005575,
0.0388386026,
-0.0450946167,
-0.0624080151,
0.0385634862,
-0.0334686786,
-0.0067327339,
-0.0230157953,
0.0273566153,
-0.028749926,
-0.0374900438,
0.0020886911,
-0.031857308,
-0.0269630216,
0.0724284276,
-0.0428229608,
0.0063588275,
0.0042475448,
0.0490261167,
0.0167142265,
-0.0531740449,
0.0152639737,
-0.0333764255,
0.0147357257,
0.0491285957,
-0.0310781486,
0.0495655835,
-0.055243209,
-0.0080834879,
0.0136809237,
-0.0084271459,
0.0248117633,
-0.0122149056,
0.0290526915,
-0.0047880253,
0.0128616532,
-0.0379481837,
-0.0014893025,
-0.005714885,
-0.0387121364,
0.0508485399,
-0.0137625197,
-0.0081366682,
0.0110080587,
2.446e-7,
0.0130253034,
0.0281631034,
0.0735992268,
-0.0185921192,
0.0210175235,
0.0052353176,
-0.0354592167,
0.0136793079,
-0.0257346705,
-0.041562926,
0.00050718,
0.0363225527,
0.061513532,
0.0474074595,
-0.0907197148,
0.016879214,
-0.0057676421,
0.0224469826,
-0.0368202962,
-0.0022425631,
0.0644051433,
0.0336565785,
-0.014181383,
-0.0550385006,
0.0441795327,
-0.001028617,
0.0118922256,
-0.0014252054,
-0.0100820428,
0.006073358,
0.0579720289,
-0.0367744081,
0.032944534,
0.0045799827,
-0.0097506624,
-0.016750142,
-0.020116007,
0.0494382307,
0.0200234298,
-0.0513515845,
0.0209194683,
0.0061508249,
-0.0068867458,
0.0396826528,
0.03000593,
0.0133722955,
0.0076984423,
0.0340377614,
-0.0257310029,
-0.0146786245,
-0.017865492,
-0.0340400301,
0.0155252274,
0.0531275086,
0.0107673137,
0.0171500277,
0.0028603422,
-0.0382148102,
-0.0207366068,
-0.093974337,
-0.0521586202,
-0.0955674797,
-0.0150134359,
0.0691648349,
0.0023877339,
-0.0556027889,
-0.0112214293,
2.208558046e-34,
0.0425597206,
-0.0210199412,
0.0395416282,
0.0657616332,
0.0021923457,
-0.0330869928,
-0.0609309264,
0.0462374464,
0.0023149815,
-0.024399044,
-0.017774431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17992v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17992v1 | Catching Chameleons: Detecting Evolving Disinformation Generated using Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T00:21:39 | 2024-06-26T00:21:39 | Bohan Jiang, Chengshuai Zhao, Zhen Tan, Huan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite recent advancements in detecting disinformation generated by large
language models (LLMs), current efforts overlook the ever-evolving nature of
this disinformation. In this work, we investigate a challenging yet practical
research problem of detecting evolving LLM-generated disinformation.
Disinformation evolves constantly through the rapid development of LLMs and
their variants. As a consequence, the detection model faces significant
challenges. First, it is inefficient to train separate models for each
disinformation generator. Second, the performance decreases in scenarios when
evolving LLM-generated disinformation is encountered in sequential order. To
address this problem, we propose DELD (Detecting Evolving LLM-generated
Disinformation), a parameter-efficient approach that jointly leverages the
general fact-checking capabilities of pre-trained language models (PLM) and the
independent disinformation generation characteristics of various LLMs. In
particular, the learned characteristics are concatenated sequentially to
facilitate knowledge accumulation and transformation. DELD addresses the issue
of label scarcity by integrating the semantic embeddings of disinformation with
trainable soft prompts to elicit model-specific knowledge. Our experiments show
that \textit{DELD} significantly outperforms state-of-the-art methods.
Moreover, our method provides critical insights into the unique patterns of
disinformation generation across different LLMs, offering valuable perspectives
in this line of research. | [
0.0303570982,
0.0293433275,
-0.021820344,
0.0617221743,
-0.0240810998,
0.0034576922,
-0.0071037905,
-0.0130918892,
-0.0118137589,
-0.0516560338,
0.0077871387,
-0.0187409408,
0.0118580358,
0.053577248,
0.0259188749,
-0.0109657766,
0.0902048573,
-0.006328275,
0.0313881189,
-0.0301075056,
0.0317694582,
0.0191513132,
0.0039913901,
0.0275991876,
-0.0354624428,
-0.0297166649,
0.0203132853,
0.0023056779,
0.0237767063,
-0.0135294339,
0.0310705602,
0.0390508249,
0.0469369367,
0.1137618646,
0.0000018568,
-0.0171290804,
-0.0055975132,
0.0081539284,
-0.0631179586,
0.0387899242,
0.0637786612,
-0.0398332439,
-0.0109236548,
0.0124021685,
-0.0205808822,
-0.0216264445,
0.0348739438,
0.0529988632,
0.0941913724,
0.0838366151,
0.0124714319,
-0.0087071694,
0.0081497906,
-0.0280217119,
-0.0193036571,
-0.009704724,
0.0548196323,
-0.0328499898,
-0.0651482493,
0.0359281786,
0.0043161064,
0.0067978664,
0.0208407193,
-0.0074236072,
-0.0463558771,
0.0190110989,
0.0056299907,
-0.0327506587,
-0.0232091285,
0.0649783313,
-0.0313447379,
-0.0556642823,
0.0041301232,
-0.0050103385,
0.0351204015,
0.0183587093,
0.0236025676,
0.0230285972,
-0.008130393,
0.0050931866,
0.0245061815,
-0.0205926336,
0.0580350459,
0.0319837183,
-0.0085244793,
0.0422206372,
0.0075180773,
-0.0294522829,
-0.0071057999,
-0.0532561392,
-0.009050631,
-0.0867700726,
-0.017909443,
0.0118017299,
-0.0379581824,
0.0252673738,
-0.0867680386,
-0.0256444551,
0.044690121,
-0.0680850297,
-0.0051388056,
-0.0118514011,
-0.0235798825,
0.0303011388,
-0.0232792702,
0.0305646602,
-0.0231194776,
0.0215963963,
-0.0059384853,
-0.0080278497,
-0.0023749059,
-0.0034956911,
-0.0006221978,
0.0357533358,
0.0065851482,
0.0095542129,
-0.0168442931,
0.0082722874,
-0.0382907242,
0.0380933359,
-0.0478275158,
0.0091950046,
-0.0217050668,
-0.023276899,
-0.028082462,
0.0510488525,
-0.0065481286,
0.0051586316,
0.002789455,
-0.0442657731,
-0.0174011234,
0.0280549955,
-0.0567083918,
0.0159048196,
-0.0133700129,
0.0158581622,
-0.0147940079,
0.0180768222,
-0.0448425412,
-0.0402040109,
-0.0479336493,
-0.0463847555,
-0.0038834538,
-0.0597197562,
0.001163921,
-0.0313312523,
-0.0214024,
-0.0631007701,
0.0099275634,
0.000951334,
-0.0565110669,
0.0735742003,
-0.0410184562,
-0.0067905313,
0.0753275901,
0.0344902314,
0.0082299616,
0.0825106353,
-0.0182166975,
0.0586772598,
0.0513815358,
0.0096989162,
0.0120468996,
0.013619584,
0.0529001765,
0.0754500702,
0.0047350414,
-0.0079030283,
0.0252678599,
-0.013279926,
0.0241083223,
0.0418780223,
-0.0143605573,
-0.0667816028,
0.0791050345,
-0.0494008102,
-0.0345731117,
-0.0246968698,
0.0591002665,
0.0355657488,
-0.0249716155,
0.0212384611,
-0.0455465727,
-0.0211762227,
-0.0597484484,
-0.0319527462,
0.0110440776,
0.0583369434,
-0.0044122864,
-0.0362496749,
-0.0142482556,
-0.0092222318,
0.0008863476,
-0.0100580286,
-0.0120966872,
0.0385429263,
-0.0244349483,
0.0875790417,
0.0620064922,
-0.0016624884,
-0.0040787682,
-0.0551234409,
0.0168726351,
0.040143691,
0.0432569869,
-0.0131767932,
-0.0386513993,
-0.0439445972,
0.0190549158,
0.0406162925,
0.0668822676,
-0.0342178158,
-0.0285339877,
-0.001700782,
-0.0010771542,
-0.0357659571,
0.0451160967,
0.020761326,
0.0206039064,
0.0147350775,
0.0102508133,
-0.0349696986,
-0.0496079512,
0.0355974063,
-0.0024917978,
-0.016017383,
-0.0039591896,
0.0218112934,
0.0215557776,
0.010767214,
-0.016768029,
-0.0085414769,
0.0479550362,
-0.0042245192,
-0.0381917283,
-0.0249081161,
-0.0087518701,
-0.0318951569,
0.0509362705,
0.0211330149,
-0.0298102479,
0.0056049493,
-0.0431831889,
0.0135451276,
0.0254294965,
-0.0337573141,
0.0338255875,
-0.0312945768,
0.0090798186,
-0.0288489833,
0.0286995899,
0.0048169428,
0.0673153698,
-0.0527915582,
-0.0194732677,
0.0240059551,
0.0193962809,
0.0024687271,
0.0181817953,
0.0059216991,
-0.0009437253,
-0.0035189227,
0.0015710214,
0.03495932,
-0.017812727,
0.0033303075,
-0.0329711847,
-0.008454279,
-0.0244740192,
-0.0340100005,
-0.0240165032,
0.0476032719,
-0.0386138372,
0.0067292647,
0.0144178849,
-0.020150777,
-0.0022444876,
0.0037419521,
0.0248919409,
0.0137092276,
0.004282109,
-0.0358419642,
-0.0229804702,
0.045809444,
-0.0140714934,
0.0488069728,
0.0125864893,
-0.0263144299,
-0.0532453805,
-0.0167813133,
-0.0638976693,
0.0440488905,
-0.0337450281,
-0.0332011282,
0.0124098929,
0.0393466726,
0.0478157401,
0.0014345227,
0.0417133868,
0.0628507882,
0.0583308898,
0.0163754709,
-0.0272387471,
-0.0225219652,
-0.0361376442,
0.0014848805,
-0.0556437261,
-0.0619271658,
0.0265170038,
0.058862064,
0.0382283926,
-0.0229984615,
-0.0211585686,
0.046228487,
-0.0172092076,
-0.0689963549,
0.0307318959,
-0.054470446,
-0.0196839087,
0.0240494758,
-0.0395960286,
-0.055874072,
0.0835269392,
-0.0519770049,
0.0409727767,
-0.0255460758,
-0.0097658569,
0.0209791064,
0.0111545743,
-0.0138677843,
0.0435243025,
0.0364916213,
0.0108537702,
-0.0518081002,
-0.030370634,
0.0467623919,
-0.0255890712,
0.017789321,
-0.0527524166,
0.0223461185,
0.0392788909,
-0.0206814669,
-0.0790617689,
-0.1047935784,
0.0184861068,
-0.0083237831,
0.0068873386,
-0.0297598206,
-0.0560092106,
-0.0501221903,
0.0193665773,
0.0068628932,
0.000856392,
0.0116112763,
-0.0150083778,
0.0046722591,
0.0568210669,
-0.0156723205,
0.0843723416,
-0.0392533913,
0.0198909063,
0.0495122559,
-0.0240751393,
0.0090835504,
-0.0096247923,
-0.066704087,
0.0072829039,
-0.0213743374,
0.0072436822,
0.0184516516,
0.0103430497,
-0.0638907552,
0.0010583061,
0.0928115845,
0.0191998295,
-0.0158588775,
0.0065294812,
0.016093405,
0.0247291327,
0.033023946,
-0.0150056779,
-0.0942199454,
-0.0054513742,
0.012760289,
-0.0087823803,
-0.0374328904,
-0.0106647536,
-0.0409275442,
-0.1061413139,
0.0110501237,
0.0080738673,
-0.0010438715,
-0.0274691824,
-0.0241899211,
-0.0240896717,
0.0530635305,
0.0248042345,
-0.0126121975,
0.0306164436,
-0.0259651765,
-0.0101726837,
-0.0327142589,
-0.0631402507,
0.0028129823,
0.0123688253,
0.0640969425,
0.054363288,
0.0203908645,
-0.0058253459,
-0.0574053414,
0.0513018966,
0.007064587,
-0.0472933613,
-0.0186891574,
0.0565463863,
-0.0358360186,
-0.0249632094,
0.0059866947,
0.023109097,
0.0333049521,
0.0102325948,
-0.0195857994,
0.0347687826,
0.0037296047,
-0.0564076528,
-0.0147388307,
0.0117504233,
0.0629245937,
0.059364181,
0.01483237,
0.0014466977,
-0.0005316183,
-0.044001773,
0.0209943764,
0.0270135552,
-0.0189847574,
0.0286180675,
0.0009399588,
-0.0435463004,
-0.0580843352,
-0.0050029173,
-0.0099734627,
-0.0096079959,
0.0270753521,
0.0068024513,
-0.0002957818,
-0.0221965425,
-0.015960196,
-0.0328864716,
-0.0510620847,
0.046863351,
-0.0285603125,
-0.016726777,
0.0004784566,
0.0081111584,
-0.0137515413,
0.0315318406,
-0.0897930488,
-0.0861143246,
0.0260312017,
0.026522629,
0.0111164004,
0.0622285865,
-0.0376142077,
-0.0468579419,
0.1013089418,
0.0286298934,
-0.0063731214,
0.0348093882,
0.0391561761,
-0.0146702928,
0.020048758,
0.0457588844,
-0.0223281588,
0.0278814211,
0.0218635947,
-0.0257990621,
-0.0633555129,
-0.0226590764,
0.0364044905,
0.0067298287,
0.0463967361,
-0.018551996,
0.0049426751,
-0.0396505967,
-0.0045643514,
-0.0081796441,
-0.0604990572,
0.0130890999,
0.0279059932,
0.0221580584,
-0.0080129867,
0.0361549407,
0.029118605,
-0.0268426314,
0.0376879387,
-0.0112388786,
-0.0456001572,
0.0077360063,
0.0369119793,
0.061950855,
-0.0099772252,
-0.0058466587,
0.0393946767,
0.0008423208,
0.0130190328,
0.0025405886,
0.0107328966,
0.0224900879,
-0.0251537785,
-0.0092683379,
-0.0164789986,
-0.0094304271,
-0.0335770994,
-0.0173691902,
0.0231900997,
0.0404653363,
0.0438631959,
0.0329233408,
0.0052712257,
-0.0326657854,
-0.015564342,
-0.0210947581,
0.0112983286,
-0.0401306711,
0.0398137234,
-0.0057552527,
-0.0543076657,
0.0349400118,
0.0699863285,
0.0099100675,
0.0605605058,
-0.0031564389,
-0.0357962139,
-0.027342191,
-0.031465441,
-0.0100317122,
0.0313388593,
-0.0153837735,
0.0182003081,
-0.0953383967,
-0.0656384602,
0.0164040606,
0.0115973074,
-0.0081035579,
0.0090103112,
-0.0178080685,
0.0719604343,
0.0061442233,
0.0081934379,
-0.0567345507,
-0.002565956,
0.0210539717,
-0.0221397523,
0.0350735821,
-6.517399124e-33,
-0.001546615,
-0.0609430708,
-0.0278401095,
-0.0379114263,
-0.0201280192,
0.0352311097,
0.0011696662,
-0.0261966083,
-0.0360170789,
0.061145965,
0.0574783087,
0.0331493616,
-0.0184097383,
-0.0024697862,
-0.0511578768,
-0.0364914834,
0.087684758,
0.0009369386,
-0.050753314,
0.0272168107,
0.0669368133,
-0.0072793439,
0.014132631,
-0.0656853169,
0.0636744052,
-0.0104571665,
-0.0499169976,
0.0374174602,
-0.0414600559,
0.0252526924,
-0.0000993493,
0.0729991421,
0.0045487871,
-0.0571653023,
-0.017631596,
0.0112591926,
-0.0135505134,
-0.0198146421,
0.0406918935,
-0.0210579671,
0.0068296189,
-0.0187074095,
0.0350023843,
0.0041207992,
-0.0062768706,
0.023169633,
0.0126735372,
-0.0125618754,
0.0025100023,
0.0178199038,
-0.0698893964,
-0.0054226336,
0.0126173133,
-0.0222556852,
-0.0402721949,
0.0265885051,
0.038282495,
0.022880232,
-0.1037770808,
0.0162980314,
0.0272064973,
0.0092474837,
0.0385262892,
-0.006927216,
-0.0140912635,
0.073450692,
0.019646341,
0.0642140508,
-0.0110164285,
-0.0098676644,
-0.0005044026,
0.0214717835,
0.0440409109,
0.0799905881,
-0.005354296,
-0.0493124202,
-0.0748951882,
-0.0074235057,
0.0222557951,
-0.0103958827,
0.0041050389,
-0.031773258,
-0.0058446941,
-0.0221921187,
-0.0685764179,
0.0170017928,
-0.0222655814,
0.0013252425,
0.0160742756,
0.0491075069,
-0.0245975815,
0.0290014874,
-0.0011348119,
-0.0384155214,
-0.0156598743,
0.0124738244,
-0.0110626798,
-0.0391330346,
0.0224066935,
0.0486158282,
-0.0540900603,
0.0057579675,
0.0333859436,
-0.0321146883,
-0.0106255962,
-0.001648056,
0.0571061336,
-0.0047912328,
-0.0680166259,
0.0336826965,
-0.0114879673,
0.0445675664,
-0.0063156402,
-0.0403769054,
0.0328833945,
-0.0081735561,
-0.0246628858,
-0.0071581956,
0.0447500274,
0.0076152515,
-0.0110952677,
0.0457925089,
-0.0348975845,
0.0545031056,
-0.0421564057,
0.0056790928,
-0.0286489855,
0.038901519,
0.0155813964,
-0.0799794346,
-0.0029613029,
-0.0471804179,
2.675e-7,
-0.0020584648,
0.0563703552,
-0.0140956212,
-0.002214794,
0.0458426587,
0.0653516203,
0.0123908091,
-0.014159821,
-0.0305257738,
-0.0813049972,
-0.0333134308,
0.0431367978,
0.0052338168,
0.0483800173,
-0.0174817313,
0.0248048138,
-0.0538208075,
0.0078816684,
-0.0596263036,
-0.0213760007,
0.016870277,
0.0928511769,
0.0412424654,
-0.0303300396,
-0.0095629031,
-0.0191226602,
0.0627545267,
0.0255836397,
-0.0391345769,
0.0307698697,
0.0329672992,
-0.0129782595,
0.006527212,
0.0085418569,
-0.0346364863,
0.0020746996,
-0.0588440299,
0.01786872,
0.0096769445,
-0.0115942089,
-0.0483664498,
-0.0246326197,
-0.0101387789,
-0.0534581393,
0.0778727382,
-0.0397642292,
-0.0038598978,
-0.0683681369,
-0.0266137347,
0.0090146437,
0.0095529836,
-0.037064258,
-0.0576820113,
0.022853341,
-0.0134999566,
0.0563942641,
0.0117556024,
-0.0603254549,
0.0040616374,
0.0238491017,
-0.0484929718,
-0.0496378019,
0.0132019613,
-0.0258946065,
0.0397567749,
-0.0110558216,
0.0662020445,
2.553679514e-34,
0.0608994514,
-0.0206708722,
0.0008632223,
-0.0129754627,
0.0446423069,
0.001660293,
-0.0348325074,
-0.0258412119,
0.013858784,
0.0016761341,
0.0017279505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17990v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17990v1 | Explicit Diversity Conditions for Effective Question Answer Generation with Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T00:12:08 | 2024-06-26T00:12:08 | Vikas Yadav, Hyuk Joon Kwon, Vijay Srinivasan, Hongxia Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Question Answer Generation (QAG) is an effective data augmentation technique
to improve the accuracy of question answering systems, especially in
low-resource domains. While recent pretrained and large language model-based
QAG methods have made substantial progress, they face the critical issue of
redundant QA pair generation, affecting downstream QA systems. Implicit
diversity techniques such as sampling and diverse beam search are proven
effective solutions but often yield smaller diversity. We present explicit
diversity conditions for QAG, focusing on spatial aspects, question types, and
entities, substantially increasing diversity in QA generation. Our work
emphasizes the need of explicit diversity conditions for generating diverse
question-answer synthetic data by showing significant improvements in
downstream QA task over existing widely adopted implicit diversity techniques.
In particular, generated QA pairs from explicit diversity conditions when used
to train the downstream QA model results in an average 4.1% exact match and
4.5% F1 improvement over QAG from implicit sampling techniques on SQuADDU. Our
work emphasizes the need for explicit diversity conditions even more in
low-resource datasets (SubjQA), where average downstream QA performance
improvements are around 12% EM. | [
0.0530610569,
0.0509117916,
-0.0071520549,
0.0152883828,
-0.0006214766,
-0.0102417748,
0.0374410339,
-0.0187422261,
0.0142333219,
-0.04547197,
-0.0122885071,
-0.0430125818,
-0.0048163398,
0.0205946397,
0.0366447009,
-0.0283785444,
0.0585170314,
-0.0148632061,
-0.0437916629,
-0.0396436714,
-0.0003432033,
0.0186363179,
0.0036886933,
0.0284672007,
-0.0161589794,
-0.0255436711,
-0.0395487249,
-0.0008469448,
0.0157360192,
-0.0263789054,
0.024404861,
0.0591151975,
0.015378762,
0.0227974113,
0.0000019254,
-0.0114490008,
-0.0245834123,
0.0066091516,
-0.0282170959,
0.0074191224,
-0.0492003933,
0.0248075556,
0.0506125093,
0.036829073,
-0.0514553003,
-0.0240534972,
0.0557455346,
0.0289658681,
0.0904615819,
0.0540676899,
-0.0042568101,
0.0012123322,
0.0130455028,
-0.0053513111,
0.0404936448,
-0.0160167981,
0.0118167317,
-0.0066307695,
0.0330226719,
0.0600932054,
-0.0046385806,
0.0157391094,
0.0283287838,
0.0107273124,
0.0038339179,
0.0463307984,
-0.0157847218,
0.0214019418,
-0.0084098158,
0.1009918898,
0.0138485432,
-0.0067003104,
-0.0018046004,
-0.0052496446,
0.0083753308,
0.0201946124,
-0.0465184227,
0.0127289379,
-0.0182867255,
-0.0085222451,
0.009610978,
0.016965339,
-0.0157263093,
0.0010076488,
-0.0230136905,
0.0411918312,
0.0527734123,
-0.0272496436,
-0.053057909,
0.0340273455,
-0.0366557054,
-0.0553044789,
0.0011237347,
0.0572745278,
-0.0551872589,
0.0190486312,
-0.0695687607,
-0.0443105735,
0.0236878414,
0.0117619717,
0.0245706886,
0.0210369825,
0.009001893,
0.0121705299,
0.0050927307,
0.0377494879,
-0.0325398073,
-0.0143147903,
-0.0893673897,
-0.0583355725,
-0.0076723457,
-0.0318439193,
-0.0512560904,
0.042781949,
-0.08772102,
-0.0224357918,
-0.0267471485,
0.0320453122,
0.0155650545,
-0.0433374383,
-0.0216029175,
0.0689695179,
-0.0601562858,
-0.0060533346,
0.0065566744,
0.0108059812,
-0.0646806657,
0.026013609,
0.0341860391,
-0.0860432163,
-0.0261958595,
0.0221153256,
0.0462842733,
-0.0393202268,
-0.0289609898,
0.0304578505,
-0.0273766667,
-0.0173084103,
0.0020306492,
-0.036941234,
-0.0330970883,
-0.0420293473,
0.0111248158,
-0.0646789744,
0.055377461,
0.0074531962,
-0.0317266621,
0.0091723343,
0.0171770882,
0.0331606939,
-0.0121284332,
0.0240231678,
-0.0360455848,
0.0356501825,
0.0608979091,
-0.0085600298,
0.0360242054,
0.0725478381,
0.0022441633,
-0.0080187768,
0.0271456297,
0.0210088212,
0.0198990889,
0.0149242934,
0.0474491082,
0.0374678262,
0.0128282402,
0.0553350374,
0.0133535657,
0.0323801935,
0.0157963336,
0.0504997261,
-0.0528400205,
-0.0084000975,
0.0369578488,
0.0262131393,
0.034859065,
0.0134164663,
0.0586033128,
0.0194092803,
-0.0030994341,
-0.010083016,
-0.0048874486,
0.0485500433,
-0.0161179621,
0.0091540115,
0.0663233176,
0.0563475676,
-0.0569125973,
-0.0153784379,
0.0088646039,
0.0309443865,
-0.0433325097,
0.0375269614,
0.0058090091,
0.0199689623,
-0.016984053,
0.0889056996,
-0.0065908087,
-0.045473434,
-0.0027390483,
-0.017584268,
0.0583110489,
0.0346667618,
0.0337639526,
0.0031811036,
-0.054290127,
-0.0071831327,
0.0003737961,
0.0407067351,
0.0551273189,
-0.0209744722,
0.0101874014,
-0.0541014597,
-0.0454638116,
-0.0087210368,
0.0062620188,
0.0449720547,
0.0582035929,
0.0414121784,
0.0332914516,
-0.0414914638,
-0.0118932864,
0.025099311,
-0.039055489,
-0.0353534743,
0.0434030518,
0.0041400143,
-0.0059756585,
0.027794484,
0.0010493512,
0.0234013461,
0.0098376824,
-0.0244035888,
-0.0312295035,
0.0023029156,
-0.0540437289,
-0.0899158269,
0.0126374848,
-0.0428344868,
-0.0006445601,
0.0408218913,
-0.0286726803,
-0.0473617688,
-0.0097951787,
-0.0644245893,
-0.0462344214,
-0.0632233024,
-0.0198406298,
0.0445881337,
0.0345713384,
-0.0584100001,
0.0662114844,
-0.0046200245,
0.013763153,
0.0174004342,
0.0498434566,
0.0423011407,
-0.0732683465,
0.0142824547,
-0.0176314637,
-0.0062865373,
0.027131794,
-0.0080458717,
0.0321176276,
-0.0447546132,
-0.0135613177,
-0.0701180324,
0.0219308659,
-0.0305688698,
0.0046916157,
0.0294248089,
0.0427883565,
-0.0207193047,
-0.0139111765,
-0.0816728026,
-0.0140360799,
0.050645221,
0.0479647405,
0.0326656066,
0.0115826344,
0.0275657754,
-0.0240379125,
-0.0182516426,
0.009344345,
0.0480444543,
0.0168553852,
0.019063063,
-0.0585742369,
-0.0002432515,
-0.041209098,
0.0179400295,
0.0257201344,
-0.0087997867,
0.0260124952,
-0.0251376107,
0.0494987443,
-0.0068937852,
0.0381033793,
-0.0345827304,
0.0157672223,
0.0159881338,
-0.0642849281,
0.0407228991,
-0.0471341759,
0.0180074032,
0.0260796733,
-0.0488596745,
0.0345397927,
0.0035585228,
0.0271733422,
-0.0400114208,
-0.0393904969,
0.0537229218,
0.0158013068,
-0.0569385588,
-0.0410947278,
0.0022425044,
-0.0040636593,
0.0215628818,
-0.0261215866,
-0.0157792885,
0.0266693328,
-0.0147983497,
0.0108489757,
-0.086343579,
0.0199422315,
-0.056326855,
0.0214697439,
-0.0293275043,
0.02617893,
-0.0027085578,
-0.0132595804,
-0.0385823548,
0.005944124,
-0.0362556912,
-0.0379546657,
0.0481094159,
-0.0193669554,
0.0140150068,
-0.0173013657,
-0.0272018556,
-0.0919629708,
-0.0412457287,
0.0373276435,
-0.0084923869,
0.0226314701,
0.0005753235,
0.0167494677,
0.0203052741,
0.0269374065,
0.0357538164,
-0.0729445145,
-0.0016061392,
-0.0275047366,
0.1056378037,
0.0987448841,
0.0875712484,
0.0381043218,
-0.0269244052,
-0.0050706211,
0.0295116659,
0.0251121745,
-0.0033765675,
0.027070567,
0.0021576453,
0.0154772298,
-0.0114653176,
-0.0108598219,
0.0100037763,
0.0764241293,
-0.0156747475,
-0.0656859502,
0.0759273991,
0.0550321154,
0.0025348987,
0.0045858109,
-0.0206475817,
0.0382581428,
0.0241146181,
0.0630894825,
-0.0722446591,
-0.0121763879,
-0.0458384268,
0.0161894336,
0.0011744726,
-0.0190263893,
-0.0332885049,
-0.1438507438,
0.0394137129,
-0.0215587281,
-0.0929550603,
-0.0406239815,
0.0096108709,
-0.0099996543,
0.0300420448,
0.0202330239,
0.007129625,
-0.0037210388,
0.0389876105,
0.0333061218,
0.0300862286,
-0.0366554745,
-0.0064125126,
-0.0404822566,
0.0328742266,
0.0449577682,
0.02046928,
0.0152662788,
-0.0074653248,
-0.0063094483,
-0.0729187578,
0.0107264016,
0.0009818418,
0.0312433336,
0.0112646474,
-0.0172331687,
-0.0072539612,
0.0310305431,
-0.0162676051,
0.0059081609,
0.0493135862,
0.050202474,
-0.0259021986,
0.0240883827,
-0.0337830894,
0.0297613516,
0.061223235,
0.0681609362,
0.0433743708,
-0.0349558592,
-0.0235112552,
-0.0257578976,
-0.0086954692,
-0.1073596999,
0.0002332351,
0.040069595,
0.0090532517,
0.0245627761,
-0.0964707658,
-0.0685945153,
0.0238110721,
0.0489934981,
-0.0268306993,
0.0057306122,
-0.0363701656,
-0.0132570583,
-0.0060325717,
0.0233763382,
-0.0359760113,
-0.0132443402,
0.0061818673,
-0.017052006,
-0.023410121,
-0.0899116471,
-0.0086868536,
0.0156075936,
-0.08153712,
-0.0378280655,
0.0044871783,
0.0286342818,
0.0134482235,
0.0461855866,
-0.0255871527,
-0.005367599,
0.0612844862,
0.0688009039,
-0.0192952473,
0.0254726857,
-0.0068205479,
-0.00928602,
-0.0111690266,
0.0399128832,
-0.0446558185,
0.006444904,
0.019714592,
0.073946178,
-0.0131354462,
-0.0291188229,
0.0351298749,
0.0257511064,
-0.0302220788,
-0.0115850242,
-0.0038966192,
-0.026496077,
0.0230461657,
-0.0339526422,
-0.011346411,
-0.0390641242,
0.010100767,
-0.0083518047,
-0.0199620277,
0.0062646298,
-0.0023645961,
-0.0063265944,
0.0690680072,
-0.0502281524,
-0.0332787298,
0.0030320326,
0.0015105064,
0.0115155568,
-0.012368436,
-0.0282167699,
0.0185406338,
-0.0011166879,
0.0434705317,
0.0041613164,
0.0347706825,
0.0019085937,
-0.0091408491,
-0.0415331125,
0.016941553,
-0.0742725432,
-0.0724393725,
-0.0369149633,
0.0346877687,
0.0253811069,
0.0103457095,
0.0236703455,
-0.006129636,
-0.00834121,
-0.01006997,
-0.0120234312,
0.0218568873,
-0.0116384216,
0.0411902778,
0.0110380929,
-0.0106624495,
-0.0088590384,
0.0812616572,
-0.0064214231,
0.0511819534,
-0.0174727943,
0.0196055789,
-0.0345122255,
-0.0195047352,
0.001447813,
0.0053551244,
-0.0232242495,
0.0189490113,
-0.0373502374,
-0.03571539,
0.0129085882,
0.0020100931,
-0.0143225668,
0.014859844,
0.0447196662,
0.0454169251,
-0.0184568986,
-0.0189053826,
-0.0467279367,
0.0434475616,
-0.0513241515,
-0.021343451,
0.0154632488,
-6.651966778e-33,
-0.0331507064,
-0.050056953,
0.0573255271,
-0.0940834954,
-0.0286210924,
0.0241768993,
-0.0121189971,
-0.0349503234,
-0.0316402838,
-0.025791157,
-0.0195830911,
0.001405051,
0.0079515465,
0.0513706617,
0.0048636948,
-0.0229101889,
0.0164986122,
-0.007431224,
-0.011768668,
0.0451649912,
0.0423990041,
0.0023502954,
0.0031812796,
0.0089021754,
-0.0166636985,
-0.0494484268,
-0.0060762842,
0.014430969,
-0.053923957,
0.0659452826,
-0.0460090823,
0.0343869068,
0.0198804978,
-0.0480297729,
-0.0146769071,
0.0201270189,
-0.0443995595,
-0.0522828065,
0.000770685,
-0.0223900769,
-0.0604008399,
-0.0405120626,
0.002678219,
-0.0164377764,
0.0251342859,
-0.0120990658,
0.0223624967,
-0.0183425695,
-0.0132869501,
-0.0248378534,
-0.0435517356,
0.0068237772,
0.0122622577,
-0.000796826,
-0.0841102451,
0.0781188458,
0.0082476214,
0.0006792496,
-0.0122822821,
0.035371352,
0.0936826617,
0.0148735363,
0.0311314203,
0.0250703935,
-0.0014112274,
0.0122752311,
0.0190963708,
-0.0321400911,
0.0058313352,
-0.0090682032,
-0.0295052361,
0.0016622709,
0.036808569,
0.0859927461,
0.0077635781,
0.0359817483,
-0.0672919378,
0.0565241277,
-0.0221266672,
-0.039316617,
0.0242878925,
-0.046462357,
-0.0334714986,
-0.0006599763,
-0.0154920844,
0.0436373055,
-0.0270680767,
-0.0301875733,
0.0684142709,
0.0227662027,
-0.0452352203,
0.0054283682,
0.0570886657,
-0.025739165,
-0.0174900778,
0.0203993674,
-0.028304778,
-0.0087562278,
-0.0049297777,
0.0349618457,
-0.0478076153,
0.0036312388,
0.0562878661,
0.0008306001,
-0.049509801,
0.0462689362,
0.0028055229,
-0.0034065454,
-0.0580990314,
0.0127477441,
-0.0192648768,
0.0370879546,
-0.0303488988,
0.0087549323,
0.0164380781,
0.0002152069,
-0.0058909641,
0.0450808704,
0.0062428536,
-0.0012415643,
-0.0058186399,
-0.0513414294,
-0.0011142448,
0.0440020971,
-0.0247980524,
0.0610910505,
-0.0342252813,
-0.0385734402,
-0.0303929653,
-0.0509965345,
-0.0133757181,
0.0235907696,
2.614e-7,
0.0431904681,
0.0069803027,
0.032052353,
0.0321018063,
-0.0012003907,
0.0098459888,
0.0322834328,
0.0462692901,
0.0076160147,
0.0426460169,
0.0046579773,
0.0353540033,
0.0156507678,
0.0269851424,
-0.0675493255,
0.0447113849,
-0.0537022687,
-0.0044513377,
-0.0636944696,
-0.0449389331,
0.0583842471,
0.0731575787,
-0.0316336676,
-0.0237789452,
-0.0181945041,
-0.0068475357,
0.0472326055,
0.0470807031,
-0.0516518876,
0.0437795743,
0.0434447378,
-0.0162679013,
0.0195061397,
0.0114783151,
-0.0154687958,
0.0110718086,
0.0410962701,
0.0354580134,
0.0142848417,
-0.067000933,
-0.0135016376,
-0.0182437412,
0.0045412588,
-0.0613601655,
0.0740704164,
-0.0369735323,
0.018172279,
-0.0099195195,
-0.0530927926,
0.0039987229,
0.014979735,
-0.042166464,
-0.0072176028,
-0.0064140353,
0.004809991,
0.0053029885,
0.0074961232,
-0.039678283,
-0.0034647887,
-0.0114562996,
-0.042943988,
-0.0405109785,
-0.0398734324,
0.0043139434,
0.0271360893,
-0.04514217,
-0.0069672181,
2.520492462e-34,
-0.0003452358,
0.0166953318,
0.0127411019,
0.002113123,
-0.0080768662,
-0.024309786,
-0.0190507211,
-0.0148572158,
0.0275195688,
-0.0675269663,
-0.0380279943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17987v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17987v1 | Multi-step Knowledge Retrieval and Inference over Unstructured Data | 2024-06-26T00:00:45 | 2024-06-26T00:00:45 | Aditya Kalyanpur, Kailash Saravanakumar, Victor Barres, CJ McFate, Lori Moon, Nati Seifu, Maksim Eremeev, Jose Barrera, Eric Brown, David Ferrucci | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) and Generative AI has
revolutionized natural language applications across various domains. However,
high-stakes decision-making tasks in fields such as medical, legal and finance
require a level of precision, comprehensiveness, and logical consistency that
pure LLM or Retrieval-Augmented-Generation (RAG) approaches often fail to
deliver. At Elemental Cognition (EC), we have developed a neuro-symbolic AI
platform to tackle these problems. The platform integrates fine-tuned LLMs for
knowledge extraction and alignment with a robust symbolic reasoning engine for
logical inference, planning and interactive constraint solving. We describe
Cora, a Collaborative Research Assistant built on this platform, that is
designed to perform complex research and discovery tasks in high-stakes
domains. This paper discusses the multi-step inference challenges inherent in
such domains, critiques the limitations of existing LLM-based methods, and
demonstrates how Cora's neuro-symbolic approach effectively addresses these
issues. We provide an overview of the system architecture, key algorithms for
knowledge extraction and formal reasoning, and present preliminary evaluation
results that highlight Cora's superior performance compared to well-known LLM
and RAG baselines. | [
0.0547375977,
0.0854258612,
-0.0337433703,
0.0290511791,
-0.0527970046,
0.0081210649,
0.0128305573,
0.0098395916,
0.0214372296,
-0.0001060057,
0.0186451022,
0.0368271172,
-0.0349055007,
0.0707079694,
-0.0001281978,
0.0003959615,
0.040235348,
-0.0086719859,
0.0948852599,
0.0035981319,
-0.0186181683,
0.0211366061,
-0.0245229844,
0.0005476283,
-0.0321310572,
-0.004325774,
0.0054992302,
-0.0295272823,
0.0212131441,
-0.058547046,
-0.02957711,
0.0357356854,
0.0553317778,
0.0432677492,
0.0000023676,
-0.0713420957,
-0.030788973,
0.0060487213,
-0.021569455,
-0.0488512591,
0.013674126,
-0.0245669987,
0.0159127023,
-0.0033067365,
-0.0595306456,
0.0330906063,
0.0293925107,
0.0203326028,
0.0099737309,
0.041361168,
-0.0193594899,
-0.0185402818,
0.0126508689,
-0.0257878192,
-0.0034964848,
-0.0050062141,
0.0526322238,
0.0162678733,
0.0289292205,
-0.0253446605,
0.027775161,
0.0385685116,
0.0180083606,
-0.001374588,
-0.0262425318,
0.0385890305,
-0.0553750694,
-0.0252100918,
-0.0272809342,
0.0695366487,
0.0473401211,
-0.0119740795,
0.0375560969,
0.020450132,
-0.0239114519,
0.0042357142,
-0.0395418257,
0.0648564249,
-0.0405076481,
-0.0006655868,
0.012154649,
-0.0028605291,
0.043756675,
0.0348422937,
-0.0417516716,
0.0926436186,
-0.0054105967,
-0.0288318787,
0.0222924445,
-0.024561977,
-0.034845084,
-0.0216946527,
0.0509578809,
0.0562037043,
-0.0342714563,
0.0422824882,
0.001784017,
-0.0432254262,
0.0465681218,
-0.0356920101,
0.009938878,
0.0298810583,
0.0226010513,
0.0554892607,
-0.032529816,
-0.0034873118,
-0.0353584886,
0.048312325,
-0.0086039156,
-0.0109226257,
-0.0432640426,
-0.0207987521,
-0.0290451031,
0.0467320047,
-0.0473911688,
-0.0281992741,
-0.0235431679,
-0.0090439795,
-0.037987452,
0.0568229295,
-0.0083558215,
0.0370266587,
-0.0024443844,
-0.0251227617,
-0.0643755943,
0.0050626541,
-0.0439816192,
0.0298230741,
0.0084224893,
-0.0070717926,
0.0070896144,
-0.0024412507,
0.0060928292,
-0.0196259711,
0.0239021145,
0.0795681253,
0.031022666,
-0.014901829,
-0.043661382,
-0.0510787778,
0.0038982942,
-0.1013061404,
0.0133276489,
-0.0576060228,
0.0774914622,
0.0125305448,
-0.0486284606,
-0.0819398463,
0.0302198306,
0.0028593349,
0.012418556,
0.0391379781,
-0.0135313952,
-0.0346768387,
0.0364396088,
0.0164167117,
-0.0052892347,
0.025282193,
0.0534502864,
0.032538157,
0.0260965656,
0.0277842749,
-0.0385483094,
0.0027196254,
0.021570174,
-0.0305156279,
-0.013283588,
0.0204050355,
-0.0156292431,
0.0458735786,
-0.0271678381,
0.0555811562,
0.0026516332,
-0.0193547774,
0.0451880693,
0.0766318664,
0.0267633498,
0.0102087278,
0.0354150608,
-0.0188897382,
0.0079920646,
-0.0770288855,
-0.0319732539,
0.0345995352,
-0.0465956926,
-0.0019388392,
-0.0167704728,
0.0697334185,
0.0022203922,
-0.0574812032,
-0.0209607836,
0.0174013395,
-0.006487465,
0.0101063251,
0.0759986714,
-0.0379584134,
-0.0074168425,
0.0140534732,
0.0406111069,
-0.0185160916,
-0.0238365475,
-0.020934362,
0.0614645258,
0.051039774,
0.0670102313,
-0.0557249673,
-0.019023316,
0.0052643954,
-0.0407414958,
0.0559484437,
-0.0007765852,
-0.0015091735,
-0.013861048,
-0.0320441425,
-0.012964447,
0.0141974641,
0.0130795687,
0.0363994688,
0.0239385217,
0.0307804421,
-0.0102859978,
-0.0173770711,
-0.0060433196,
0.0443584099,
-0.0564055704,
-0.0261829738,
-0.008650179,
0.0168624558,
0.0462343097,
0.0100699635,
0.0068465988,
0.0325674713,
0.0239543151,
-0.0356334448,
-0.053488899,
0.019205723,
0.0016849333,
-0.0166121181,
0.0315393545,
-0.0277978554,
-0.0107721565,
-0.0118478155,
-0.0458858758,
-0.0221745223,
0.0462213121,
-0.0022795957,
-0.0069397041,
-0.0450025983,
-0.0253006928,
0.0374682657,
-0.0243417546,
-0.0197136234,
0.0889435485,
0.017361125,
-0.0264273938,
0.0465763025,
-0.0258969162,
0.0067239306,
-0.0438882448,
-0.0024851009,
-0.0149157401,
-0.0096503366,
-0.0125522194,
0.0035463553,
-0.049035456,
-0.03686231,
0.004082859,
-0.0473193899,
0.0563888885,
0.0179518629,
0.0172901656,
-0.0238202829,
-0.015747482,
-0.0099220723,
-0.0054627289,
-0.0228109788,
0.0307271108,
0.0211954787,
-0.0062923706,
0.0326439515,
0.0520510525,
-0.0117529305,
-0.0346674435,
0.0009614302,
-0.0682138428,
0.0293992385,
0.0532974266,
-0.0086808493,
-0.0145055531,
0.0077873534,
-0.0706184953,
0.0565316342,
-0.0255862717,
0.0227637384,
-0.0011366362,
-0.0353362486,
-0.0273304395,
0.0572084635,
-0.00133059,
0.0151899764,
0.0489575341,
-0.008406193,
-0.0569293313,
0.044862356,
-0.0413210243,
0.051654201,
0.006646906,
-0.002190094,
0.018717831,
0.0566455238,
0.0083391974,
0.001808622,
-0.0332519226,
0.0348922275,
0.010156082,
-0.0044970922,
-0.0285287853,
0.0046436125,
0.0267857946,
0.0616455674,
-0.0231183432,
-0.043362543,
0.1052986011,
-0.0018033721,
0.0441192575,
-0.0448092781,
-0.0281067342,
-0.0683065504,
0.072593011,
-0.0061815707,
0.0156779364,
0.0138101829,
0.0161093548,
-0.0092224404,
-0.0124125341,
0.0074402438,
-0.0426198021,
0.0285509024,
-0.0678559318,
0.0395498313,
0.0083548622,
-0.0568797924,
-0.031190997,
-0.0042135622,
-0.0335373059,
0.0192272905,
0.0235691927,
-0.0215705968,
-0.0490427203,
-0.0014548209,
0.0220408849,
0.0312353205,
0.0015859109,
-0.0106881233,
-0.0399393886,
0.001302976,
0.0709342584,
0.0036108715,
0.03486114,
-0.009740442,
0.0080153579,
0.0485433489,
-0.0110663082,
-0.0116968853,
-0.0438998081,
0.0075558801,
-0.0093924878,
-0.0416169763,
0.0428087562,
0.038573999,
-0.0406715609,
-0.0742702484,
-0.0073949373,
0.0761131048,
0.0352759659,
-0.0309430882,
0.0003025006,
-0.0358155817,
-0.0055388743,
0.0117005231,
0.0716324076,
-0.1264135391,
-0.0283010453,
-0.0056134667,
-0.0029930836,
-0.0093891099,
-0.0676579177,
-0.0235230234,
-0.094672218,
0.0629123598,
-0.0140891522,
-0.0296524465,
-0.0131232366,
-0.0429351106,
0.0102126952,
-0.0086850626,
-0.0462664999,
0.0148763619,
-0.0057946104,
-0.0173455775,
-0.012956677,
-0.0083648162,
0.0034291174,
0.0233240705,
-0.0490252115,
0.0084550809,
0.0149337752,
0.0327901468,
0.0010292887,
-0.0257219896,
-0.0325478539,
0.016547326,
0.0229447857,
-0.0328000225,
0.0164875183,
0.0176853258,
0.0112559842,
-0.0543240309,
0.0579083823,
-0.0605428219,
-0.0341310762,
0.0280201808,
0.0832171366,
-0.0442234725,
-0.0108310115,
-0.0505947992,
0.0073933434,
0.0079748128,
0.0749880075,
-0.0469385982,
0.0136393299,
-0.0714438111,
0.0087821893,
0.0056836139,
-0.0382150449,
0.0034256671,
0.0118035795,
-0.0211513676,
0.0298863165,
-0.0664453506,
-0.0063617206,
0.0414402634,
0.0334760211,
0.0153930569,
-0.0145612014,
0.0422250442,
-0.0191964172,
-0.0600427836,
0.058587689,
-0.0462495647,
0.0156111177,
-0.0053467723,
0.0232133083,
0.0010323611,
-0.0523986183,
-0.033956565,
0.0388648883,
-0.0452631265,
-0.0445109978,
-0.0431175902,
0.0460463539,
0.0250714328,
0.0228428449,
-0.0237324815,
0.0261829123,
0.042275425,
0.0511418283,
-0.0285122767,
-0.0348163471,
-0.0177820399,
0.0118921017,
-0.0173134189,
0.0036455223,
-0.0332570747,
0.0292310007,
-0.01084451,
0.0760593116,
-0.0394411981,
-0.015647471,
0.0299746636,
0.0399855115,
0.0334881097,
0.0107786385,
-0.0339155421,
-0.0406903476,
0.0041702962,
-0.0296779089,
-0.0157437306,
-0.0192845315,
0.0110376691,
-0.0169055965,
-0.0047302265,
-0.003312879,
-0.0045689414,
0.0286040828,
-0.008733009,
-0.0253283381,
0.004453327,
0.0315155908,
-0.0017267108,
0.0187345408,
-0.0367388539,
-0.0038888932,
0.0353125818,
-0.0111042624,
0.0742357746,
-0.0333199129,
0.0650923774,
0.0369056985,
-0.0128778098,
-0.0619389564,
-0.0008635359,
-0.0378167443,
-0.0407072641,
0.0158939678,
-0.0126464395,
0.0170054622,
0.0262607541,
-0.0015021202,
-0.0767567381,
0.0037841694,
0.0179319195,
0.0030156407,
-0.0156403519,
-0.0253246538,
0.0512056313,
0.0284531377,
-0.0000650061,
-0.0246416796,
0.037244793,
-0.0236022398,
0.0589501522,
-0.0272624772,
-0.0470021814,
-0.0249033719,
-0.0628419891,
-0.002788577,
-0.0126282657,
-0.0332606621,
-0.0307663307,
-0.0785876736,
-0.0354327634,
0.0112994956,
0.0513794497,
-0.0248699319,
-0.0074071297,
0.023637196,
0.0441473834,
0.0194721036,
-0.0625394583,
-0.0055389213,
0.0184483267,
-0.0689847469,
-0.025269581,
-0.0079479376,
-6.791370857e-33,
0.0130710807,
-0.0382841639,
0.080943495,
-0.011076103,
-0.0098986775,
-0.0021677329,
-0.0593788214,
-0.0342853405,
0.0009691158,
0.0200186521,
-0.0049003786,
0.0054220832,
-0.0014457722,
0.0084618423,
0.0226742327,
0.0106425723,
-0.0204497389,
0.0352143534,
-0.0284531228,
-0.0244801473,
0.0785466731,
0.0190097522,
-0.0059121088,
-0.0346765369,
-0.0077246292,
0.0243276022,
0.0174412709,
0.0340365209,
-0.0645812899,
0.0407300368,
-0.0101923654,
0.0258111693,
0.0024775001,
-0.0236449484,
0.0332740135,
0.0274232607,
-0.0840241536,
-0.0444227196,
0.0111279245,
-0.0506723784,
-0.04168275,
-0.0302400254,
0.040005669,
-0.0010285806,
0.0125022866,
0.0053928625,
0.0367382132,
-0.0486509241,
0.0081421426,
-0.1141991243,
-0.0855216607,
0.026251765,
-0.0205886401,
0.032082852,
0.0006067372,
0.02389393,
-0.0118422033,
0.0471678227,
-0.047948774,
0.0242846925,
-0.0284698997,
-0.0248207748,
0.0558128469,
-0.0242676102,
0.0052280128,
0.0468506366,
-0.0355814882,
-0.0189149585,
-0.0497307852,
0.0236117374,
-0.0098651387,
0.1076541692,
0.0261196177,
0.030749863,
0.0303022526,
0.029483445,
-0.1082525104,
0.0476660766,
0.0317235775,
0.0843910277,
0.0369066074,
0.0196230076,
-0.0375379026,
0.0009742489,
-0.018739868,
0.0134236468,
-0.0467226505,
-0.0261717997,
0.0198233668,
-0.0004527394,
-0.0168711822,
0.0286463797,
0.0021507074,
-0.0259719044,
-0.0009649052,
0.0240014512,
0.0439795256,
-0.0047285943,
-0.0247691292,
0.028452402,
-0.0502792895,
-0.0363902189,
0.0035576744,
-0.0136157796,
0.0319760777,
0.021644365,
0.0243108273,
0.0008323867,
-0.0044519505,
-0.0056354464,
-0.0229939315,
0.010999769,
0.0067858738,
-0.0217050537,
0.019965142,
0.0421175547,
0.0071484861,
-0.0081675109,
0.0232443586,
0.0312525667,
-0.0149428369,
0.0368981659,
0.0138173914,
-0.0082474984,
-0.0121194543,
-0.0020969927,
-0.0422616154,
0.0421557985,
0.0035224657,
-0.0738791451,
0.0134036504,
0.056700591,
3.23e-7,
0.0325917415,
0.0573462583,
0.0328045748,
0.0228127614,
0.0220563561,
0.005225312,
0.001023335,
-0.0171029139,
-0.0056917309,
-0.0333466493,
0.0332317837,
0.0535753593,
0.022453744,
0.058403071,
-0.0439562239,
-0.0019665086,
-0.035010092,
-0.0577229187,
-0.0876758993,
0.0017213547,
0.0493855402,
0.0496505387,
0.0202343557,
-0.0237879399,
0.0072723017,
-0.0394337364,
0.0472239181,
-0.0167448297,
0.0352595039,
0.0157568287,
0.0175441522,
-0.0366861783,
-0.0050003901,
0.0442519113,
-0.0031119182,
0.0284030177,
-0.0428463668,
0.0713870376,
0.0007633755,
0.0088122841,
0.0092181368,
-0.0339840315,
0.0142407473,
-0.0381434374,
0.070665583,
-0.0686179325,
-0.0493355282,
-0.0008390848,
-0.0242491625,
-0.0229744054,
-0.0167208537,
-0.0038008194,
0.0258433335,
-0.0066648703,
-0.0129376212,
-0.0064710979,
-0.0109182391,
-0.0900707245,
0.0149062946,
0.0342407189,
-0.0589369833,
0.0040270919,
-0.0229378808,
0.0065926933,
0.0328929909,
-0.0876318514,
0.0153091392,
2.952581915e-34,
0.0028161048,
0.0147438161,
-0.0181817804,
0.0133799752,
0.0632762089,
0.0161308628,
-0.0782248303,
0.0347586647,
0.0048387544,
-0.102080971,
-0.0116387578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17982v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17982v1 | EDEN: Empathetic Dialogues for English learning | 2024-06-25T23:36:16 | 2024-06-25T23:36:16 | Li Siyan, Teresa Shao, Zhou Yu, Julia Hirschberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue systems have been used as conversation partners in English learning,
but few have studied whether these systems improve learning outcomes. Student
passion and perseverance, or grit, has been associated with language learning
success. Recent work establishes that as students perceive their English
teachers to be more supportive, their grit improves. Hypothesizing that the
same pattern applies to English-teaching chatbots, we create EDEN, a robust
open-domain chatbot for spoken conversation practice that provides empathetic
feedback. To construct EDEN, we first train a specialized spoken utterance
grammar correction model and a high-quality social chit-chat conversation
model. We then conduct a preliminary user study with a variety of strategies
for empathetic feedback. Our experiment suggests that using adaptive empathetic
feedback leads to higher perceived affective support, which, in turn, predicts
increased student grit. | [
0.056478858,
-0.0215368159,
-0.0513057411,
0.0082785971,
-0.0237103608,
0.0267148316,
-0.0166413188,
-0.036661759,
0.0356718265,
-0.0169675667,
-0.0084185014,
0.0430875979,
-0.015440247,
-0.0126243494,
0.0290091783,
-0.07775563,
0.0334555693,
0.0219691657,
0.034284737,
0.0116442339,
0.0492650047,
0.0249298308,
-0.0444328636,
0.0661544353,
-0.043109104,
-0.0337239392,
-0.056199681,
0.012566166,
0.0076222057,
0.0039332444,
0.0914875567,
0.034404695,
-0.0192183703,
0.0212728884,
0.0000018665,
-0.0164835211,
-0.020173233,
-0.0526886247,
-0.036556866,
-0.0126293199,
0.0490809456,
0.0427362025,
-0.0251450613,
0.0451067127,
-0.0393503793,
0.021496607,
0.046714101,
-0.0209583044,
0.0823878422,
0.0539714061,
-0.0134119419,
-0.0008736294,
-0.0026534053,
0.0257709194,
-0.0181074757,
0.0156580471,
-0.0258032642,
0.0242530964,
0.0417498238,
-0.0210035611,
-0.0293520764,
0.0304587036,
0.0095070228,
-0.0571753718,
0.0310148783,
0.0164618455,
-0.0469942391,
-0.048262082,
-0.0050473544,
0.0418221466,
0.0388770401,
0.0131202387,
-0.0099044666,
0.011180439,
0.0751108155,
-0.0173210613,
-0.0587669164,
-0.0049295695,
0.0074946424,
0.0164259672,
-0.0055709654,
-0.0562573858,
-0.0657512993,
0.0239174757,
0.0568576939,
-0.0421753749,
-0.0110133979,
-0.0209218357,
-0.0290534478,
0.0470228083,
0.0078928433,
-0.065033339,
0.0390589945,
0.0362735465,
-0.0370929874,
0.0258942544,
-0.0348221436,
-0.0123223923,
-0.0160514656,
-0.0114109199,
-0.0498913266,
0.0714418143,
-0.0145689081,
-0.0003298765,
0.0450954624,
0.0253178123,
0.0830123276,
0.059661258,
0.0053874403,
0.0034592624,
-0.0429235026,
-0.0103551038,
-0.0386221781,
0.0446862541,
0.0115276892,
0.0000449716,
-0.0817889944,
0.0089962995,
0.0037181822,
0.0258402843,
-0.0306034554,
-0.0245142337,
-0.0238555036,
0.0149774756,
-0.0218389705,
0.0315763839,
-0.0377820469,
-0.0088547906,
0.0339911543,
-0.0709913597,
-0.0003295933,
-0.0045423191,
0.0186623242,
-0.0159672461,
-0.0118779968,
0.00512345,
-0.0113113374,
-0.0545126684,
-0.0057418155,
0.0169437062,
-0.0053945757,
-0.0450939313,
-0.0107799415,
-0.0176504254,
-0.0247262102,
0.0017510701,
0.0112558203,
-0.0448792391,
-0.0004253503,
0.0200402141,
0.0040388196,
0.0219603535,
-0.0428373739,
0.0116338804,
0.0495830327,
0.0064441413,
0.0305597782,
0.0208273698,
0.0235351827,
-0.0247030519,
0.0294031426,
-0.0394580774,
0.0183226131,
0.0179700702,
-0.0156194409,
-0.0408340693,
0.0299190711,
-0.0463710465,
0.0072408272,
0.0254348293,
-0.0004082113,
0.0243824627,
-0.0238605496,
0.019979503,
0.0540742949,
0.0681784824,
-0.0073594637,
0.061052423,
-0.0390450694,
0.0034135457,
0.0399146974,
0.0267264992,
-0.0178519171,
0.0134427408,
-0.0036244558,
-0.0336094238,
0.0157039668,
-0.0126345903,
-0.0032859971,
-0.0527045354,
-0.0296007413,
-0.0227740575,
0.0365267061,
0.0276346914,
0.021371644,
-0.0097027188,
-0.0043154471,
-0.0157566871,
0.0438312553,
-0.1019585505,
-0.0194501728,
-0.0519425496,
0.0156389121,
0.1071770489,
0.0352867804,
-0.0294692982,
-0.0550494939,
0.0066538504,
-0.0087734545,
0.0210061744,
0.0668385699,
-0.0208917242,
0.0284856185,
-0.0168863218,
0.0212440006,
-0.0214819964,
0.0013293047,
-0.0300919265,
-0.0108777285,
0.0374859124,
-0.0405833386,
0.0538502447,
-0.0447790064,
0.0093179485,
-0.0404777452,
-0.0122251436,
-0.0416212827,
0.0055029588,
-0.0147760687,
0.0271842629,
-0.0043136571,
-0.0288944673,
-0.0160953887,
0.0297605209,
0.003717287,
0.0748898014,
-0.0219713729,
-0.0451899841,
0.0592200346,
-0.0001055287,
-0.0229461715,
0.0294200014,
0.017837869,
-0.0049099894,
0.0603108928,
-0.0543277115,
0.0909997895,
0.0126353102,
0.0563501231,
-0.0772296041,
-0.0007500799,
-0.0395071656,
-0.0435280465,
0.0425683074,
-0.0097913621,
-0.0159898456,
-0.024411466,
-0.0297475997,
-0.0386876464,
-0.019875573,
0.0166026112,
0.0035150521,
-0.0115421051,
-0.0002443031,
0.0131954802,
-0.1159928665,
-0.0362101234,
-0.1031500399,
-0.0081083542,
0.0190838892,
-0.0234695561,
0.005286037,
-0.0131142177,
-0.0291251577,
-0.0336753018,
-0.0363744721,
0.0595199391,
0.0175570138,
-0.0226207599,
0.0271203704,
-0.0376583785,
-0.0132367453,
-0.1015908495,
-0.0090440409,
-0.0360162966,
-0.0130780647,
0.053310696,
0.0208282843,
-0.0386447236,
0.0451799557,
-0.0037055812,
0.0059242602,
0.0128161451,
-0.0898966566,
0.0353299342,
-0.0154882371,
0.0488814823,
0.0726729035,
0.017665593,
0.0516110584,
-0.0046842666,
-0.0460345186,
-0.0621361323,
0.0285498705,
0.0251407735,
-0.013627979,
-0.0192539934,
-0.0519836731,
-0.0410832949,
0.0078858212,
0.0298194066,
0.0118846288,
-0.0496857092,
0.0466147922,
0.0193399079,
-0.0049420348,
-0.0121930297,
-0.0148187503,
-0.0064256624,
-0.0284114219,
0.0189864766,
-0.03924511,
0.0618858226,
0.0351633728,
-0.0330651067,
-0.0558384061,
-0.0110720713,
0.0228683464,
0.0257317405,
-0.0609157048,
0.0114726443,
0.0585615709,
-0.0250564441,
-0.0057420586,
-0.0264447611,
0.0353541933,
-0.0561197884,
-0.0041702357,
-0.028290242,
-0.0457316674,
0.0486365817,
-0.014265731,
-0.0465573967,
-0.0294729397,
-0.0536119714,
-0.0158325396,
0.0297804382,
-0.0100169294,
-0.0276528504,
-0.0599923395,
0.0233441219,
0.01463921,
-0.0387678184,
-0.0277898386,
0.0334688537,
-0.0481434204,
0.0161957256,
0.0481514931,
0.0385922007,
-0.017897835,
0.1126325205,
0.0346007682,
0.0511090979,
0.0162061546,
0.0185460597,
-0.0193853714,
0.0359281823,
-0.0003977625,
-0.0346504226,
-0.0191672929,
0.0898109376,
-0.0313433856,
-0.0330269374,
0.122531496,
0.0096892705,
-0.0271618739,
-0.0019657956,
-0.054417368,
0.0233642701,
0.0110081043,
0.0238546953,
-0.0120741967,
-0.0219144095,
0.0047123721,
0.0482772514,
0.0064340485,
-0.0108873071,
0.0184632093,
-0.0561369658,
0.0345350951,
0.001308771,
-0.0203823671,
-0.014803051,
-0.0193081275,
-0.0080883764,
0.0205885451,
0.0299699921,
-0.0075587984,
-0.0028847551,
0.0132018402,
0.0171580166,
-0.0004662665,
-0.0067041074,
0.016769981,
-0.0433303304,
0.0743592754,
0.0282607824,
0.0597633682,
0.0192510076,
-0.0041829743,
0.0166541673,
0.0671823099,
-0.0123307118,
-0.008391724,
0.060492035,
-0.0141571434,
-0.0059223203,
-0.0475654341,
0.0343698785,
-0.0113792196,
-0.0092747472,
0.0696450919,
0.0294408761,
0.0074361758,
0.0311263148,
0.0070872898,
0.0297819972,
0.0236785971,
0.0327892192,
0.0208635107,
-0.0657058433,
0.0058181761,
-0.0249358173,
0.0097477213,
0.0145740258,
-0.0698847324,
0.0077545098,
-0.0238887966,
0.0272831619,
-0.0560431406,
-0.0658483207,
0.0565223917,
0.0150569798,
0.0241282005,
-0.0357260443,
0.0203016493,
0.0485585853,
0.0094672795,
-0.0132209631,
0.0134502389,
0.030937111,
-0.0591974668,
-0.0395735353,
0.0029807843,
-0.0190644879,
0.0234612711,
-0.0367095247,
-0.0089010103,
-0.047794532,
0.0150522338,
0.0389589109,
0.0137528516,
0.0106067294,
0.0188565198,
-0.0623757243,
-0.0796657428,
-0.0114354473,
-0.0149734886,
0.0403997824,
0.0321270116,
0.0334325433,
0.0158888493,
0.0057788808,
0.0043661832,
-0.0343285426,
-0.0009968258,
0.0086908545,
0.0190317631,
-0.0286656506,
0.0487832315,
0.0469131097,
0.0081021786,
-0.0013320395,
-0.0420928411,
-0.0241816286,
0.0179031584,
-0.0532788746,
-0.0086092222,
-0.0323381871,
-0.022686664,
-0.0269606877,
-0.0046898159,
-0.0014362684,
-0.0659553483,
-0.0805946216,
0.0097728884,
-0.0613466688,
0.0396816246,
-0.0104811518,
-0.0152986366,
-0.022527365,
0.0161320828,
0.0031151266,
-0.0016181002,
0.0197847411,
0.046572417,
0.0036477512,
0.092175886,
-0.0171478018,
-0.0429941304,
0.0603942722,
-0.005842166,
-0.0341261178,
-0.0196207985,
0.0096759759,
0.0625916496,
0.0136366598,
0.0133043453,
0.0275339689,
-0.0392894447,
0.0285106767,
-0.0068097226,
0.0234700534,
-0.0186321791,
-0.0284839626,
-0.0224718694,
-0.0244972371,
-0.0123524591,
-0.0203472413,
-0.0007041523,
-0.0452385843,
0.0504594594,
-0.0177167226,
-0.0119093992,
-0.030336801,
0.0021875163,
0.0359645225,
0.0116604241,
0.0127681661,
0.0412669815,
-0.0300408397,
-0.0418004058,
-0.0337884314,
0.028619837,
0.0192563646,
-0.0596067496,
0.0112938685,
0.0350978523,
-0.0636734813,
0.0017871294,
-0.0497744605,
0.0325601809,
-0.0466767699,
-0.0075538717,
-0.0059022061,
-5.299946237e-33,
-0.0240248255,
-0.0039732703,
-0.0184111223,
0.0655130744,
-0.04280008,
-0.0073926793,
-0.055983454,
0.0565394536,
-0.0056637134,
0.0124815404,
-0.0409009233,
0.0895692632,
-0.0040121679,
-0.012521876,
0.0534005947,
0.012639218,
0.0289312545,
0.0063651791,
0.0207459647,
0.0054392074,
-0.0107333753,
0.0249129981,
0.069577612,
-0.0616210885,
0.0419483371,
0.012270635,
0.0038746994,
-0.0149433045,
0.0257366449,
0.0255358405,
0.0156368166,
0.0377628915,
-0.0107090631,
0.0273977704,
-0.0155117353,
0.0036932568,
-0.0127690947,
-0.0481447764,
-0.0271786936,
0.0251949411,
-0.0314509198,
-0.027998155,
0.0111376774,
-0.010289507,
-0.0396951698,
0.0046908311,
0.028025968,
0.0039165611,
0.0565892048,
0.0586730205,
-0.044193022,
-0.0082775299,
-0.0546469763,
-0.0841317028,
-0.034936659,
0.067570284,
0.0139842629,
-0.043996647,
0.00999902,
0.0597432181,
0.0018744974,
-0.0039370409,
0.0279063042,
-0.0318215601,
-0.012772155,
0.0645198897,
0.0226251744,
0.0457891002,
0.0216036718,
0.0084578777,
0.0583825931,
0.0094778854,
0.0643641874,
0.0629600659,
-0.0344323292,
-0.0587877147,
-0.0182602499,
0.0390046015,
0.1050227284,
0.0147812506,
-0.0331185199,
0.0381795354,
-0.0525015667,
-0.0103842933,
-0.0159728713,
-0.009169667,
0.014120752,
-0.02773639,
0.0252943058,
-0.0228625424,
0.0046779937,
-0.0910632387,
-0.0399635658,
-0.0290855356,
0.0089571448,
0.0076648248,
-0.061447829,
0.0282419492,
-0.0264404248,
-0.010985232,
0.0070168199,
-0.0265592746,
-0.0103327967,
0.0329720266,
0.0558513328,
0.0242149234,
-0.0283228215,
0.0544938147,
-0.0178793762,
-0.0060718362,
-0.0234256238,
0.0586709082,
0.0125388587,
-0.0610001609,
-0.0210215691,
0.0150726745,
-0.0090118339,
0.0314670727,
0.0203270931,
-0.0094634732,
-0.0744791254,
-0.0539747961,
0.026955111,
-0.0182357393,
-0.0432325192,
-0.042361103,
-0.020678984,
0.0147000803,
0.0021916006,
-0.0578349382,
-0.0255443584,
-0.0432909392,
2.634e-7,
-0.0367499068,
0.0648830831,
-0.0020054034,
-0.023584336,
0.0188442748,
0.0478038266,
-0.0156761818,
0.02466527,
0.0426357649,
0.0189702921,
-0.013189788,
-0.0003831169,
0.0639376044,
0.0211829785,
-0.0631917715,
-0.0347412191,
-0.0202485118,
-0.0037287336,
0.0003269328,
0.0120606748,
0.0869523212,
0.0168182775,
0.0556819513,
-0.0022046708,
0.0031658493,
0.0208616294,
-0.0176581759,
-0.0281846114,
0.0134075386,
0.0199903958,
-0.0122579373,
-0.0136131356,
0.0235431865,
0.0108574331,
0.0062626526,
0.0076048253,
0.0123647172,
0.0756592229,
-0.0016766052,
-0.0069037136,
0.0400609411,
0.0523345917,
-0.0330973454,
-0.0428187549,
0.0031096814,
-0.0468690284,
-0.0051204674,
0.0088506406,
0.0138276275,
-0.0489651933,
0.0355049074,
-0.0327613726,
-0.0467277169,
0.02784626,
-0.0219911914,
-0.0087627349,
0.0199043807,
-0.0170391891,
0.0141060511,
-0.0055473456,
-0.0310666338,
-0.0561709814,
-0.013498025,
-0.0425776392,
-0.0350895338,
0.0040518222,
0.0054887179,
1.444884136e-34,
-0.0280931536,
-0.0030028436,
0.0652540028,
0.0694048703,
0.0526831113,
0.020466689,
0.060857933,
0.033010114,
0.0557263382,
-0.0073929061,
-0.052549582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17975v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17975v1 | Inherent Challenges of Post-Hoc Membership Inference for Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T23:12:07 | 2024-06-25T23:12:07 | Matthieu Meeus, Shubham Jain, Marek Rei, Yves-Alexandre de Montjoye | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) are often trained on vast amounts of undisclosed
data, motivating the development of post-hoc Membership Inference Attacks
(MIAs) to gain insight into their training data composition. However, in this
paper, we identify inherent challenges in post-hoc MIA evaluation due to
potential distribution shifts between collected member and non-member datasets.
Using a simple bag-of-words classifier, we demonstrate that datasets used in
recent post-hoc MIAs suffer from significant distribution shifts, in some cases
achieving near-perfect distinction between members and non-members. This
implies that previously reported high MIA performance may be largely
attributable to these shifts rather than model memorization. We confirm that
randomized, controlled setups eliminate such shifts and thus enable the
development and fair evaluation of new MIAs. However, we note that such
randomized setups are rarely available for the latest LLMs, making post-hoc
data collection still required to infer membership for real-world LLMs. As a
potential solution, we propose a Regression Discontinuity Design (RDD) approach
for post-hoc data collection, which substantially mitigates distribution
shifts. Evaluating various MIA methods on this RDD setup yields performance
barely above random guessing, in stark contrast to previously reported results.
Overall, our findings highlight the challenges in accurately measuring LLM
memorization and the need for careful experimental design in (post-hoc)
membership inference tasks. | [
0.0149599267,
0.1391713321,
-0.0238662567,
0.0533307903,
-0.0542635471,
0.0041413079,
0.0241355225,
-0.0256790798,
0.0011718903,
-0.055353675,
-0.00136078,
-0.0650284439,
0.0104935868,
-0.0170778036,
0.0125235459,
0.0327330455,
0.0672267452,
-0.0525487065,
-0.0322337449,
-0.0486888327,
-0.0258436464,
-0.0027376891,
0.0031732589,
0.0042242561,
-0.0041058538,
-0.0010178128,
-0.0121406959,
-0.0036130957,
0.0068711713,
-0.0196913499,
0.0480941013,
0.1043960974,
0.0135405939,
0.1133909449,
0.0000021565,
-0.0357908867,
-0.0523572415,
0.022423394,
-0.0535851009,
0.0166980661,
0.0060290578,
-0.0010478635,
0.0270276312,
0.0138112968,
-0.0008323455,
-0.009265475,
0.0682884678,
-0.0136824977,
-0.0132311657,
0.0915874317,
0.0041902591,
-0.0320335664,
-0.0031136209,
-0.0196785908,
0.0126017677,
-0.00170903,
0.0311125722,
-0.0489667319,
-0.0072274916,
-0.0467259735,
-0.0311766192,
0.0226883031,
0.0132078175,
0.0383017845,
0.0013344712,
0.0510805063,
-0.0830036923,
-0.024186451,
0.0041467967,
0.0379234403,
0.0084159626,
-0.0288547166,
-0.0026249364,
0.0225158017,
0.0018719814,
0.0488637164,
-0.0232027825,
0.0091727162,
0.0135276243,
0.0162469801,
-0.0108866869,
0.0190369431,
0.0499505289,
0.0131070958,
-0.0660118312,
0.0381760672,
0.0224870946,
-0.032752201,
-0.0108352639,
-0.0088695139,
-0.0462994426,
-0.0248002242,
-0.0327529348,
-0.0272874255,
-0.0136182019,
0.0281328466,
-0.0310416985,
-0.0290553365,
0.0252819788,
-0.0380373672,
0.034485843,
0.014328694,
-0.0158108193,
0.0291668996,
-0.0199361145,
0.0183237698,
0.026541749,
0.0296073444,
-0.024241332,
0.0115102734,
-0.0335336961,
0.0032698042,
0.0400395989,
0.030476274,
0.0295391269,
-0.001231423,
-0.0522126928,
0.0044195419,
-0.0276105702,
0.0043300083,
-0.0389201492,
-0.0132744536,
-0.0175734907,
0.0167322457,
0.0080686668,
0.0108873565,
0.003514671,
0.020539308,
-0.0111287655,
-0.0568747781,
-0.0296672937,
0.0081891874,
-0.0176285785,
-0.0324772261,
0.0176969804,
0.0651756153,
0.0079064742,
-0.0855947807,
-0.0290843789,
-0.0119185587,
-0.0297994763,
-0.0951279104,
0.0319275111,
-0.0820013061,
0.0351799615,
0.0161795802,
0.0002768011,
-0.038504798,
0.0050540306,
0.0115149179,
-0.0601128191,
0.0841689557,
-0.0149156395,
0.0097503448,
-0.0341504253,
-0.0009593527,
0.0192695782,
0.1128140837,
-0.0040348093,
-0.0015469423,
0.0664329305,
0.0110679595,
-0.0015392959,
0.0322286002,
0.031805981,
0.0147774089,
-0.0320509039,
-0.0154678226,
0.0388494842,
-0.0348858051,
-0.0066704424,
0.0173481554,
-0.0011674112,
-0.0219336841,
0.0741749406,
0.0527907945,
-0.0151540926,
-0.0039744647,
-0.0206499286,
-0.0075390413,
-0.0098110717,
0.0148092061,
-0.0837555379,
-0.0406088419,
-0.0782747492,
-0.0136373956,
0.0269213021,
0.0338871516,
-0.0102619939,
-0.0166464616,
-0.0243434198,
-0.0114057893,
0.0087309834,
0.0384409726,
0.0594955608,
-0.0206771493,
0.0177993514,
0.065172486,
0.0624731891,
-0.0413830206,
-0.0045843325,
-0.053266339,
0.0369133204,
0.0057420931,
0.03965877,
-0.0513618477,
0.0172841512,
0.0010559611,
0.0522782393,
0.0009828466,
0.0315606222,
0.013838158,
0.0304427873,
-0.0364980362,
-0.0245233793,
0.0278197955,
0.061695952,
0.038141109,
0.0583861098,
-0.0019793527,
0.0142436791,
-0.0554093458,
-0.0222706627,
0.0445427224,
-0.0147770327,
-0.0182248279,
0.0209483281,
-0.0084505659,
0.0402959511,
-0.009318375,
-0.0519535802,
-0.0158930905,
0.0178419333,
0.0030784663,
-0.0059359437,
-0.0239686314,
0.0215653982,
-0.0336887091,
0.0332037881,
0.0181978177,
-0.0085316822,
0.0655523613,
-0.0506268218,
-0.0128499931,
0.0199846756,
-0.0159866866,
0.0383522846,
-0.0347315222,
0.0324798487,
-0.0378080532,
0.0517993383,
-0.0300588775,
0.0501596294,
-0.0226084813,
0.0256578159,
-0.0018599938,
-0.0233816598,
0.0128243407,
-0.0435322411,
-0.0802083537,
0.051127255,
-0.0224472452,
0.0152542163,
0.0193390772,
-0.0310455337,
-0.0136759635,
-0.0144212125,
-0.0545298792,
0.0221056007,
-0.039549049,
0.0022693593,
-0.0243188888,
-0.0212164782,
-0.036993999,
-0.0159735084,
0.0106542902,
-0.0023773059,
-0.0294466801,
0.0533251576,
-0.019489605,
-0.0180993024,
-0.0398493297,
-0.0201388281,
-0.0216250736,
-0.0032140405,
0.0947838798,
-0.0054538879,
0.0091436664,
-0.0149619412,
-0.0028045664,
-0.054452762,
0.0149989082,
-0.0086061023,
-0.0408659056,
-0.0027945528,
-0.0084777158,
0.0070740767,
0.0409065336,
0.0163955595,
0.0095172748,
0.0778572485,
-0.015844712,
-0.0207850244,
-0.0189386196,
-0.0205020253,
-0.0140970154,
-0.0167773236,
-0.0340798199,
-0.0038380648,
0.0594428033,
-0.002914872,
-0.0394221358,
0.0050965324,
0.0144371921,
-0.0279356204,
-0.0042632758,
-0.0194530822,
0.0135224555,
-0.0291220769,
0.0223320741,
-0.0107020466,
-0.0852332041,
0.0404614061,
-0.0408205353,
0.0212313086,
-0.0334153287,
-0.0299353749,
0.0073621008,
0.0435013026,
0.0329707935,
0.0105363764,
0.0494821891,
0.0037992159,
-0.0460896119,
-0.0209094118,
0.0486699082,
-0.0341773704,
0.0336737037,
-0.057423301,
0.04164977,
-0.0058468902,
-0.0005394347,
-0.0681163296,
-0.0697681531,
-0.0062506818,
-0.0056885281,
-0.0274015032,
-0.0283289589,
-0.0273562837,
-0.0021036705,
-0.0015257734,
0.0070073148,
-0.0169824269,
0.0203540344,
0.0061097937,
0.014361023,
0.0326999314,
-0.0123851821,
0.0356006883,
-0.0739572719,
-0.0112447264,
0.0444169827,
0.0192397386,
0.0405908562,
-0.0185750853,
-0.0293264762,
0.0431838594,
-0.0206744894,
-0.0079211835,
0.0296535771,
0.023529103,
-0.0489508286,
0.002337897,
0.1017261222,
0.0259846468,
-0.0643710792,
0.0121497279,
0.0355937369,
0.1020278707,
0.0071827471,
0.0023823143,
-0.0742704943,
-0.0044544954,
0.0258932356,
0.0238257758,
-0.0474774465,
-0.0403646789,
-0.0115542309,
-0.1190766245,
0.0382211171,
0.0114675192,
-0.0834714398,
0.0192710366,
-0.0382378921,
0.0333784409,
-0.0205175932,
0.0233631711,
-0.002437681,
-0.0216745157,
-0.0128641818,
0.0136116045,
-0.0665415898,
-0.0751663744,
-0.0014315748,
-0.0368397757,
0.0732629597,
0.0293464456,
0.0159357637,
-0.0458528958,
0.0135160936,
0.0798940361,
-0.0042490615,
-0.0546376444,
0.012649104,
0.0806011856,
-0.0159357041,
0.0073724901,
0.0158849154,
0.0300437063,
-0.0021370421,
-0.0343445726,
0.0073135281,
0.0457757525,
-0.0027721496,
-0.0291073266,
0.0009843823,
0.0042105336,
0.004642339,
0.0815752745,
0.0210697018,
-0.0176717881,
-0.0107809827,
-0.0328085795,
-0.0021047869,
0.0275471359,
-0.0280857477,
0.0312146842,
-0.0396079309,
-0.0647671372,
-0.0091535682,
-0.020235097,
0.036288932,
0.0338893533,
-0.0105435709,
0.0391446687,
-0.0381163396,
0.0106418869,
-0.0210878327,
0.0091589736,
-0.0669350699,
0.0293328799,
-0.0312476698,
-0.0091617983,
-0.0199265685,
0.0139748454,
-0.0147911189,
-0.0182824377,
-0.0884718522,
-0.0832222253,
0.0392618738,
0.0348722897,
0.0235474426,
0.0444343984,
0.0072818212,
-0.0578111634,
0.0794761777,
0.0465969332,
0.0097558899,
0.0271606781,
0.0389127992,
-0.0441012271,
-0.0044577406,
0.0353539772,
-0.0217074323,
0.011795233,
0.0652144998,
0.0075731836,
-0.0200627781,
0.0323427171,
0.0074635362,
0.0064219753,
0.0564253815,
-0.0376245938,
-0.0114023453,
-0.031816598,
0.0307543706,
-0.0195557382,
-0.021966869,
-0.0005948694,
-0.0448643416,
0.029607987,
0.0284676533,
-0.0302878506,
-0.0412606895,
-0.0267352778,
0.0735951364,
-0.0257036481,
0.0318159461,
0.05536443,
-0.0089866314,
0.0565735176,
0.0066852504,
-0.0088070016,
0.0117836446,
0.0082973614,
0.0428638607,
-0.0022362066,
0.0454527438,
-0.0049977629,
-0.0339676365,
-0.0497802012,
-0.0044195196,
-0.0647489652,
-0.0209915619,
-0.0025414329,
0.0411228947,
0.0242913291,
-0.0394005105,
0.0068873395,
0.0073194257,
-0.0084285755,
-0.0465672538,
0.0270405188,
-0.0135554094,
-0.0217144303,
0.0167017914,
0.0190088749,
-0.0259733126,
0.0484345146,
0.0750616491,
0.0391613804,
0.0187251996,
-0.0313790366,
-0.01654361,
-0.015511727,
-0.0289533157,
0.0301253796,
-0.0013845628,
-0.0467752106,
-0.0069816024,
-0.1052562445,
-0.0892194211,
-0.0107136341,
-0.0313800946,
0.0425610729,
0.0309128128,
-0.0153983962,
0.0429465547,
-0.0345430449,
0.032349553,
-0.0406452045,
-0.0230103172,
0.001394667,
-0.0037830512,
-0.0173001569,
-6.929594299e-33,
0.0019038995,
-0.0175919719,
-0.0171827469,
-0.0206414293,
-0.0133144241,
0.0171246286,
-0.0027594508,
0.021041017,
-0.0112997657,
-0.0191681925,
-0.0217128042,
-0.0035920083,
0.0194829442,
0.0312840044,
-0.0204556417,
-0.0237383563,
0.0333090909,
0.0125717195,
-0.0354376808,
-0.0108551634,
0.0598990172,
0.0234230012,
0.0447140895,
-0.0224507954,
0.0244465489,
-0.0226320866,
0.0092109824,
0.0238161273,
-0.030166341,
0.021724252,
-0.0007898909,
0.0568088107,
0.0187035576,
0.0241580233,
0.0111479741,
-0.0041752975,
-0.0196612366,
-0.0108480332,
-0.0000541072,
0.0106885731,
0.0467569344,
-0.0142350998,
0.0037605192,
-0.0196976718,
0.0219583251,
-0.0428097099,
0.0277733207,
-0.0237976369,
-0.032569252,
0.0226350296,
-0.0294335522,
0.0427029915,
-0.0079486212,
-0.0019524486,
0.0149537437,
0.0169280916,
0.036865741,
-0.0148170292,
-0.0467339605,
0.015182334,
0.0380133763,
-0.0007600518,
0.0449445546,
0.0581564344,
0.0068463068,
0.0609636046,
0.0682532713,
0.0508406907,
0.0237846989,
-0.0103783403,
0.0686835721,
-0.0107247652,
0.0378875658,
0.0640655831,
0.0843809769,
-0.0229282305,
-0.0771388635,
-0.029488029,
-0.0120017035,
-0.0016500767,
0.060142234,
0.010426905,
-0.0594902895,
-0.0479488857,
-0.0317201912,
-0.0135870902,
-0.037011303,
-0.0342667475,
0.0293312483,
0.0167671163,
-0.0502093993,
-0.0444827564,
0.0663808361,
-0.0499362424,
-0.0145222088,
0.0081452392,
0.0006533032,
-0.0010589168,
-0.016399093,
0.0011304049,
-0.0548541099,
-0.020814104,
0.0013857053,
-0.0203579366,
0.0161305256,
-0.0263599418,
0.0551658906,
0.0343252085,
-0.0544595905,
-0.0000524443,
-0.0225034207,
0.0211253352,
0.0256353021,
0.0490729921,
0.0386576802,
0.0126456078,
0.0143590365,
-0.0076121534,
0.0438816436,
0.0143761067,
-0.0423239954,
0.0500694625,
-0.0570465587,
-0.0047327741,
-0.0057092425,
0.0053869635,
0.0023496663,
0.0112312296,
0.0411234275,
-0.0670416206,
0.0131708067,
-0.0404254235,
2.899e-7,
0.0242431946,
0.0030091114,
-0.0298746936,
-0.0163661223,
-0.0085679563,
0.0005993554,
-0.0330383182,
0.0349172913,
0.0186078008,
0.0027619202,
-0.0247087479,
0.0323504955,
0.0726935938,
0.0448663309,
-0.0835119188,
-0.0152233895,
-0.0348493569,
0.0122374026,
-0.0741032362,
-0.0228759348,
0.0181911252,
0.0942132473,
0.0377183445,
-0.0072404761,
-0.0350453965,
-0.0474692993,
0.0454485118,
-0.0446313247,
-0.0469173342,
0.0295769107,
0.0472739339,
0.0015643458,
0.0185336135,
0.0576964505,
-0.0291439947,
0.0299716275,
-0.0127695296,
0.0108248154,
0.0285110958,
0.0067456756,
-0.0428319797,
-0.0197297875,
-0.006291776,
-0.0414530784,
0.0790361539,
-0.0623705201,
-0.0247872397,
0.0004400952,
-0.0262178592,
-0.0500946976,
0.0568546988,
-0.0143041955,
-0.0091343122,
0.0518391617,
0.0091931447,
-0.0134957843,
0.0250729043,
-0.060703665,
0.0038571928,
-0.011199289,
-0.0513580516,
-0.0619453304,
0.0320819505,
-0.0275507607,
0.0199986603,
-0.012693977,
0.0004806283,
3.019308209e-34,
0.039797347,
0.0009436249,
-0.0269808061,
0.033918418,
0.0547052138,
-0.0365719311,
0.067282103,
0.0188619886,
0.0017195452,
-0.0710442811,
0.0120208766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17974v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17974v1 | Evaluating Fairness in Large Vision-Language Models Across Diverse Demographic Attributes and Prompts | 2024-06-25T23:11:39 | 2024-06-25T23:11:39 | Xuyang Wu, Yuan Wang, Hsin-Tai Wu, Zhiqiang Tao, Yi Fang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Large vision-language models (LVLMs) have recently achieved significant
progress, demonstrating strong capabilities in open-world visual understanding.
However, it is not yet clear how LVLMs address demographic biases in real life,
especially the disparities across attributes such as gender, skin tone, and
age. In this paper, we empirically investigate \emph{visual fairness} in
several mainstream LVLMs and audit their performance disparities across
sensitive demographic attributes, based on public fairness benchmark datasets
(e.g., FACET). To disclose the visual bias in LVLMs, we design a fairness
evaluation framework with direct questions and single-choice
question-instructed prompts on visual question-answering/classification tasks.
The zero-shot prompting results indicate that, despite enhancements in visual
understanding, both open-source and closed-source LVLMs exhibit prevalent
fairness issues across different instruct prompts and demographic attributes. | [
0.0334349945,
0.0686057582,
-0.0227391534,
0.0590490624,
-0.0100209042,
0.0270507764,
0.0650924966,
-0.0026422718,
0.0166586433,
-0.0732215717,
-0.0180113278,
-0.0317106508,
0.0204920359,
0.0088465558,
0.0060352418,
-0.0591703393,
0.0245578047,
-0.0147223184,
0.023156248,
-0.0431994647,
0.0080707064,
-0.0049856394,
0.0198457483,
0.0506581627,
-0.0036028693,
-0.0312532373,
0.0371903218,
0.0257470701,
0.0151809817,
0.0142825944,
0.0106238862,
0.072584115,
-0.0082544833,
0.0335166492,
0.0000018072,
-0.0632679015,
0.0530369505,
0.0069668158,
-0.023935454,
0.02047446,
0.0199005939,
-0.0183491781,
0.0190396942,
0.0198386386,
-0.0229140464,
-0.0064922562,
0.0568584315,
0.0052911439,
0.0303366613,
-0.0369588919,
0.0031104987,
0.0221857913,
-0.0434203185,
-0.0122509077,
0.0164786801,
-0.0044752951,
0.0066940715,
-0.0236681495,
-0.0514725335,
-0.0362455808,
-0.05344804,
0.0415876731,
0.0622243695,
-0.0140107134,
0.0378549732,
0.0365770236,
-0.0522403754,
-0.0494664498,
-0.0290234163,
0.0990745947,
0.0080737844,
0.020796109,
-0.0362654552,
-0.0034216281,
0.0406607166,
-0.0211613178,
-0.0695559382,
0.0553763546,
0.0030910582,
-0.0081771091,
-0.0707323626,
0.0082181608,
0.0225801729,
0.0154323429,
0.0277338494,
0.0404218137,
0.0115958033,
0.0012194462,
-0.0101436414,
0.0428697765,
-0.0149708278,
-0.0410204642,
-0.0193961989,
-0.0209955983,
-0.0303349867,
-0.0206369516,
-0.0386712104,
-0.0020989687,
0.0261065532,
0.0040434012,
0.0596298166,
0.0309859943,
-0.0556280166,
0.0315255597,
0.0157690514,
0.0857142657,
0.0315569155,
0.0312976129,
-0.0265038498,
-0.0268162545,
0.026624497,
-0.011278443,
-0.006697529,
-0.0230596177,
-0.0626854151,
0.0303798392,
-0.0457601137,
-0.00533788,
-0.0521768518,
-0.0056354017,
0.0156237483,
0.0459913723,
-0.0183884166,
0.0108900759,
-0.0565674342,
0.0088962307,
-0.0299273524,
-0.0216869283,
-0.0141738877,
-0.1069306955,
-0.010440506,
0.0121514788,
-0.0329019129,
-0.0417754129,
-0.0137183331,
0.0356393903,
-0.0060792398,
-0.0189427622,
-0.0170574673,
-0.0267481841,
0.0155071793,
-0.0253605638,
0.0089903213,
-0.0587874837,
0.0076444005,
0.0051355795,
0.0183404665,
0.0116878841,
-0.0173870083,
0.0295999795,
-0.0202025771,
0.0793792903,
0.0312239844,
-0.0145792682,
0.0160051174,
0.0190465096,
-0.0056611211,
0.0845795348,
0.0108976439,
-0.0070207426,
0.0574310198,
-0.0011468654,
-0.0003555048,
0.0306550339,
0.0076791728,
0.0158882365,
-0.0596078187,
0.0475276113,
0.0120173041,
0.0365845896,
0.0618200637,
0.0325445011,
0.0047644093,
-0.0895379335,
0.0629106089,
0.074511975,
0.0203268584,
-0.0302865542,
0.0227950457,
-0.0181367826,
-0.0181853417,
-0.0028025259,
-0.0903209671,
0.0318499729,
-0.0235646572,
-0.0346632376,
-0.0169114042,
0.0516462959,
-0.0347170793,
-0.0361068584,
-0.00605935,
0.0067409622,
-0.0027643736,
0.0629244596,
0.0083814906,
-0.0094097061,
0.0223599616,
-0.0010934226,
0.0393409617,
-0.0439847223,
0.0018872697,
-0.0792182088,
0.0405705012,
0.0457191244,
0.0138917165,
0.0116808806,
0.0057708514,
-0.0154612288,
0.0201200321,
0.0416675359,
0.0661726817,
0.0065650595,
0.0364862755,
-0.0578527823,
-0.0532931723,
0.0067212745,
0.0034847811,
0.0237794258,
0.0220624004,
0.0119748088,
0.0101040546,
-0.0401931927,
0.0003021898,
0.0234966855,
0.008890437,
-0.0119396122,
0.0232059229,
0.0142044527,
-0.0001779538,
0.0077245883,
-0.0281889625,
-0.001696885,
-0.0237324983,
-0.0182288084,
0.0072456859,
-0.006957728,
-0.0779514015,
-0.0164349265,
0.031865567,
-0.0711231008,
-0.0392700993,
0.0512266271,
0.0008328718,
0.0203003734,
0.0264289007,
0.0079702027,
-0.0535439253,
-0.030820949,
-0.010868676,
-0.0121413749,
0.0226182491,
-0.0596490614,
0.0385649987,
-0.0265810601,
-0.0178348087,
0.0399161354,
-0.0262086187,
0.0093421815,
-0.0647470057,
-0.0221448187,
0.0298661664,
0.0010644896,
0.0087380521,
0.000288974,
0.0319648199,
-0.0421216674,
0.0365382954,
-0.0841090083,
-0.0035680803,
-0.0364844352,
-0.0392518006,
-0.0185267217,
0.0243780855,
-0.0216495674,
-0.0606689081,
-0.0343234167,
0.0210277028,
0.011510252,
0.0377362035,
0.0113724852,
-0.0271053389,
0.0052130013,
0.0012320583,
-0.0702342242,
0.000888697,
0.0806138515,
0.0625830889,
0.0528486297,
-0.0084005157,
-0.0321906246,
-0.0421204045,
0.0586551353,
-0.0218039658,
0.0117130745,
0.0212546531,
0.0137863588,
0.0116310706,
0.1068231985,
0.0265624262,
0.0387967862,
0.0402157977,
0.0034181259,
-0.0424708575,
0.0091110328,
0.0248834994,
-0.005989193,
0.005629953,
-0.0421405472,
-0.0174242724,
0.0119318739,
-0.0006019519,
-0.0169354994,
-0.0826207623,
0.0592579208,
-0.0459417813,
-0.0866826102,
-0.1032113284,
0.0130157052,
0.0120131746,
0.0464842431,
-0.0478868484,
-0.092297174,
0.0616979636,
0.004050782,
-0.008337561,
0.0078255152,
-0.0021908788,
-0.0669478327,
0.0793960392,
-0.0173248705,
0.018166991,
0.0126430392,
-0.0268902946,
-0.0874974132,
-0.0279743876,
0.0255466644,
-0.0359101593,
0.0847364143,
-0.0615315363,
-0.0049042585,
-0.0519163385,
-0.0493792556,
-0.0544973873,
-0.0561290011,
-0.0110781072,
0.0265696552,
-0.0399936549,
-0.0237028282,
-0.0186327714,
0.0110772178,
0.0207013916,
0.0079086088,
-0.0251191165,
0.003818365,
0.0093618464,
-0.0224043168,
0.0482289195,
0.0476910844,
0.0246131402,
-0.050174959,
0.0279372148,
0.0526084229,
0.0339142866,
0.0092811128,
0.0135768261,
0.0400257967,
0.0506613441,
0.008303646,
-0.0172896981,
0.0126395943,
0.0666580126,
-0.033630047,
0.0469013974,
0.0975553021,
0.0186694823,
-0.0786561891,
-0.0078162961,
-0.0238763373,
0.0378653109,
0.0346993543,
-0.0155477626,
-0.0972157717,
-0.0146742463,
0.0098639624,
0.0429342128,
-0.021236239,
-0.0372732282,
-0.0048348005,
-0.0970656574,
0.0537361689,
-0.0057405946,
-0.0271699652,
-0.0313844569,
0.0390648656,
0.0063379165,
-0.0169647988,
0.0524849966,
-0.0092056282,
-0.0031547612,
0.0194176193,
-0.0088476725,
-0.0011301409,
-0.0007911936,
0.0705893636,
-0.0597704351,
-0.0035932155,
0.0552277081,
-0.014893461,
0.0169517677,
-0.0604237728,
0.0101449406,
-0.0451996066,
0.021387659,
-0.0285834838,
0.056523256,
-0.0319747329,
-0.0338892117,
-0.0523638502,
0.0310512483,
0.0118472921,
0.0038265348,
0.0163504034,
-0.0094052916,
0.0066734902,
-0.0306810029,
-0.0662884116,
-0.0087720575,
-0.0292062741,
0.0452927165,
0.0228564814,
-0.0415101759,
-0.0445910543,
-0.0612073652,
-0.0180176198,
-0.0292809568,
-0.0634722933,
0.0351663642,
0.0432645716,
-0.0464964248,
-0.0183700379,
-0.0392345339,
0.0396708436,
0.0106108021,
-0.0250733048,
-0.0814349428,
-0.0149057694,
0.0100281676,
-0.0489055887,
0.0764800981,
-0.0507410802,
0.0559619926,
-0.0319992378,
-0.0024834082,
-0.0352074094,
-0.0391506404,
-0.0201459322,
-0.0170373823,
-0.0333858766,
-0.0160693396,
0.0127237123,
0.0447326042,
0.0189862903,
0.0326716527,
0.0079240566,
-0.0547168739,
0.0299563613,
0.0565562434,
0.0391528681,
0.0516525358,
-0.0124642998,
-0.0163197126,
0.0184794106,
0.0285434742,
-0.0219131429,
-0.0098749595,
0.0025939399,
0.0182802044,
0.007801943,
-0.0360302404,
-0.0023795834,
0.0250829272,
0.0464946553,
0.0047928509,
0.0019118905,
-0.015494681,
0.0058866735,
0.0123864422,
-0.0080753127,
-0.0516574569,
-0.0159967821,
0.0162441228,
0.0084163956,
0.0008350661,
0.0030548091,
-0.0163730104,
-0.0130381528,
-0.0747290179,
0.0102091506,
0.0192386284,
0.0105858659,
0.0210657921,
0.0344361812,
-0.0043568877,
0.0159864686,
-0.0097992644,
0.0491996631,
0.0490689352,
0.0538723655,
0.0219271127,
0.0031644455,
-0.0190462898,
0.018192986,
-0.0407385193,
-0.0199326072,
0.0352469124,
0.0465162396,
0.0380556881,
0.0074240863,
-0.0127501851,
0.0254244544,
-0.0002897562,
-0.0049451743,
-0.0090197232,
0.041081842,
-0.0314530358,
0.0875645578,
0.0107973842,
0.0042200447,
-0.030394759,
0.0453876294,
0.0311871972,
0.023625508,
-0.0187570751,
-0.0126681505,
-0.0145742828,
-0.0233286843,
0.0617616586,
-0.0198280793,
-0.0111561203,
0.0284538362,
-0.0901448429,
-0.0445015691,
-0.0246782228,
0.0381840542,
0.0238674842,
0.0079213576,
0.0264061838,
0.0512264147,
-0.0038635093,
-0.0862882659,
-0.0065130075,
0.0010735786,
-0.0613774285,
-0.0248392504,
0.017793715,
-5.997446748e-33,
-0.0275221523,
-0.0117996223,
0.0029730017,
-0.0325202905,
-0.0166018438,
0.0129109472,
0.0147975059,
0.0020256902,
-0.0339126587,
0.0018308143,
0.01077097,
0.0160301439,
0.0075435922,
0.0313722976,
0.0013176727,
-0.0585457273,
0.0407938249,
0.0092898188,
-0.02491487,
-0.0213398114,
-0.0484755337,
0.0031148863,
0.0207577981,
-0.0289602764,
0.0517791547,
0.0104105528,
0.0377752706,
0.0322741456,
-0.027751362,
0.062811859,
-0.0137213226,
0.082562007,
0.0381396785,
0.0198294688,
-0.0180504024,
0.0430683866,
-0.0538323261,
-0.0235237945,
0.0176869854,
0.0342624076,
-0.069821991,
0.0171067715,
0.0057349289,
0.0401112773,
-0.0272074603,
-0.0787249058,
0.051297456,
0.0073376079,
0.0099255256,
0.036539942,
0.0234478787,
0.0069273813,
-0.0274559055,
-0.0080886055,
-0.000283024,
0.0318506882,
0.0073556891,
0.0512704514,
-0.0108935796,
0.0214618277,
-0.0025644829,
-0.0307653267,
0.088477619,
0.059939649,
0.0255258251,
0.0325573161,
0.0719190687,
-0.0003332122,
-0.0584961399,
-0.0715053082,
0.0322571211,
-0.0252914056,
0.0351758599,
0.0752118751,
0.030852627,
0.0270853527,
-0.0536336154,
-0.0050701988,
-0.0111720348,
0.0342978463,
0.0024659233,
-0.0063175554,
-0.0428496152,
-0.0228740592,
-0.057394553,
-0.0148213888,
-0.0561354496,
0.0101516889,
0.0749734566,
-0.0010297354,
-0.0163745005,
0.0155026177,
0.018013563,
-0.0445064045,
-0.0182513762,
0.0043794527,
0.0172269326,
0.0016487268,
0.0279957373,
0.0261722151,
-0.0397067554,
0.0537309386,
0.0372707769,
0.005753113,
-0.0163353719,
0.0219663177,
-0.0088708717,
0.0046400637,
-0.0561375618,
-0.0046510948,
-0.0334636979,
0.0205218904,
-0.0199260674,
0.0216364712,
0.0172304418,
0.0119461836,
-0.0227795709,
0.0280751046,
-0.0119203487,
-0.0309142768,
-0.0393312499,
-0.0227015913,
0.0063206549,
0.0153922206,
-0.0206044912,
-0.0109576387,
-0.0089352624,
-0.009093455,
0.0449424535,
-0.0182736982,
-0.0059280656,
-0.0149046462,
2.191e-7,
-0.0083246371,
0.0187353343,
0.0060611009,
0.0306684971,
0.00016068,
0.0604452193,
0.0164200198,
0.0458465405,
0.0538648181,
-0.0160352662,
-0.0421071462,
0.0534007996,
0.0135736093,
-0.0025893692,
-0.0253114849,
0.0195883773,
-0.0404608995,
0.0057232259,
-0.030291535,
0.0217388142,
0.0387741141,
0.0273087826,
-0.0040114648,
-0.013362566,
0.0410912074,
-0.0432456285,
0.0252466239,
-0.0485802293,
-0.0058966079,
-0.0462242402,
0.0182390884,
-0.0065078894,
0.0420979448,
0.0689751804,
0.0170422401,
-0.0073340079,
0.013051562,
0.0241386015,
-0.0241064299,
0.0027370735,
-0.0401053354,
0.0191488992,
-0.0253930129,
-0.0594578274,
0.081634745,
0.0264873486,
-0.0489548333,
-0.0487830453,
-0.009424841,
-0.0260108039,
0.0719131976,
-0.0134332627,
-0.0326316878,
-0.0038325423,
0.030163452,
-0.023907911,
-0.0085971458,
-0.0690132007,
-0.0182992555,
-0.0720488504,
-0.0131585393,
-0.061792884,
-0.0407516956,
0.0382670686,
0.0014545928,
0.0170182008,
-0.0095149437,
1.756923588e-34,
0.0198619738,
0.0327801891,
0.0466382913,
-0.0406185351,
-0.0179414973,
0.0045206356,
-0.0038181683,
-0.0338469259,
0.043602936,
-0.0207815953,
-0.0012726855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17972v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17972v1 | LABOR-LLM: Language-Based Occupational Representations with Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T23:07:18 | 2024-06-25T23:07:18 | Tianyu Du, Ayush Kanodia, Herman Brunborg, Keyon Vafa, Susan Athey | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, econ.EM | Many empirical studies of labor market questions rely on estimating
relatively simple predictive models using small, carefully constructed
longitudinal survey datasets based on hand-engineered features. Large Language
Models (LLMs), trained on massive datasets, encode vast quantities of world
knowledge and can be used for the next job prediction problem. However, while
an off-the-shelf LLM produces plausible career trajectories when prompted, the
probability with which an LLM predicts a particular job transition conditional
on career history will not, in general, align with the true conditional
probability in a given population. Recently, Vafa et al. (2024) introduced a
transformer-based "foundation model", CAREER, trained using a large,
unrepresentative resume dataset, that predicts transitions between jobs; it
further demonstrated how transfer learning techniques can be used to leverage
the foundation model to build better predictive models of both transitions and
wages that reflect conditional transition probabilities found in nationally
representative survey datasets. This paper considers an alternative where the
fine-tuning of the CAREER foundation model is replaced by fine-tuning LLMs. For
the task of next job prediction, we demonstrate that models trained with our
approach outperform several alternatives in terms of predictive performance on
the survey data, including traditional econometric models, CAREER, and LLMs
with in-context learning, even though the LLM can in principle predict job
titles that are not allowed in the survey data. Further, we show that our
fine-tuned LLM-based models' predictions are more representative of the career
trajectories of various workforce subpopulations than off-the-shelf LLM models
and CAREER. We conduct experiments and analyses that highlight the sources of
the gains in the performance of our models for representative predictions. | [
0.0094538927,
0.1390409172,
-0.0136197004,
-0.0349908881,
0.0044883601,
-0.0054744915,
0.0429925956,
0.0012979548,
-0.0051673013,
-0.0034865611,
0.041747272,
-0.0022957847,
0.0027441848,
-0.010452114,
0.0218044966,
-0.0287623685,
0.0099941604,
0.0039547668,
-0.0071351598,
-0.0151287206,
-0.0367523804,
0.0328131393,
0.0038292638,
0.0939178094,
-0.0163545702,
-0.007303583,
0.0216235276,
-0.0085918345,
0.0188260283,
0.0122961132,
0.0326935537,
0.0223574527,
0.0383805297,
0.0023307393,
0.0000020834,
-0.0210255384,
-0.0248371586,
0.0117194345,
-0.0266586356,
-0.0877987295,
0.0421281345,
-0.0450613908,
-0.006724536,
0.0384790413,
-0.013172878,
-0.0091163479,
0.0493435413,
0.0170088895,
0.0434555523,
0.016179245,
-0.0069601838,
-0.0685233027,
-0.0416914523,
-0.0324486904,
0.0181834809,
-0.0284421202,
0.0580888428,
-0.0447908193,
-0.0739038736,
-0.0140455151,
-0.0495257527,
-0.0177736524,
-0.0170154776,
-0.0387796648,
0.0061987201,
0.0683068857,
0.0032805016,
0.0189771689,
0.0148905199,
0.0160595104,
-0.0365497917,
-0.0468068123,
-0.017225109,
-0.0158807542,
0.0455648042,
0.0486220717,
-0.0452579595,
0.0216095727,
-0.0062544439,
0.0257545467,
0.028869221,
0.0401481092,
-0.0025600502,
-0.010017884,
-0.0287953634,
0.1111981645,
-0.0156461839,
-0.0079526873,
0.050755024,
0.0148684401,
0.086865738,
-0.0221982449,
0.025472831,
-0.0002058679,
-0.0330333263,
0.0203349665,
-0.0257872958,
0.0123980278,
-0.0225902405,
-0.0072093681,
-0.0124910073,
0.0443484113,
-0.0333711244,
0.045005288,
0.0088567566,
-0.015411065,
0.008308595,
-0.0240766741,
-0.0382071547,
-0.0395738184,
-0.077343598,
-0.0234568845,
-0.044590544,
-0.0352667905,
-0.0007336402,
0.0485838242,
-0.0217458289,
-0.0055784378,
-0.0201610867,
-0.0123785557,
0.0106500341,
0.0239081383,
-0.0426732972,
0.0272244569,
-0.0666593239,
0.0492069796,
0.0281631667,
0.0546375699,
0.0158067103,
0.0242548008,
0.031725768,
0.0055880533,
0.009990315,
-0.020489566,
0.0381967761,
0.0450957157,
0.0295654181,
0.0503613725,
-0.0320135951,
-0.0379359871,
-0.0068909093,
-0.0158612859,
0.0205967668,
-0.0649761185,
0.048118636,
-0.0036943392,
0.0072563356,
-0.0651457235,
0.0110378806,
0.0195416473,
-0.0480926707,
0.0381405242,
0.02897273,
0.0097225895,
0.0379363894,
-0.0254535787,
-0.0108380429,
0.0218871832,
0.0429018475,
0.0416530818,
-0.0068002138,
-0.0802479535,
0.0343967564,
0.0561646372,
-0.030348029,
0.0061859004,
-0.0043046591,
0.0154241361,
0.0276946444,
0.0054776929,
0.0743194297,
-0.0337345339,
0.0099012563,
-0.0005081723,
0.0456320792,
0.0628941357,
0.0387630202,
0.0420766398,
0.0512348935,
0.0322406404,
-0.0203739181,
-0.0474002175,
-0.0224696323,
0.0163244084,
-0.0232935809,
-0.0264386255,
-0.0681686774,
0.0054034409,
-0.0192368962,
0.0002966207,
0.0505917333,
0.0117667336,
-0.0074242386,
0.0090692863,
0.0441662371,
0.0151511338,
-0.0330378674,
0.0962455347,
0.0411811508,
0.0073238085,
-0.0056552957,
-0.0273709595,
-0.0118807303,
0.0760683119,
0.0000473505,
0.0035059641,
-0.0061342032,
-0.0554920845,
0.0514058545,
0.0255316403,
0.029409593,
-0.0002318871,
0.0156822857,
-0.014008713,
-0.0212193094,
0.0628249571,
0.0270372611,
0.0154385297,
-0.0047099707,
-0.0036163274,
0.0075003887,
-0.0677227005,
-0.0335876755,
0.0316032469,
-0.075424701,
-0.0076461062,
0.0640221685,
-0.0049884883,
-0.0258353278,
-0.03603708,
0.0001914785,
-0.0010821505,
-0.0144608477,
-0.0136203663,
0.0006422965,
0.0220239926,
-0.0382582135,
-0.0035168212,
-0.0212383308,
-0.0143181132,
0.004463545,
0.0076023033,
-0.0607655309,
0.0050682402,
0.0053160442,
0.0206203777,
0.0214642547,
0.0195302628,
0.0220010243,
-0.0130445939,
0.0146496948,
-0.012438504,
0.0252044182,
0.0356198102,
-0.0040962431,
-0.0299140085,
-0.0263579972,
0.0026358494,
-0.0987248793,
0.0185513031,
-0.029969776,
-0.0089317979,
0.0194480531,
-0.0098163681,
0.0123023922,
-0.0140823368,
-0.0263209175,
-0.0649122223,
0.0159246866,
0.0270607732,
0.0036463088,
0.0056631328,
-0.0365995355,
0.0046891673,
0.0084987571,
-0.0436792001,
0.0160659682,
0.0254034046,
-0.0216065757,
0.0120378863,
-0.0154128633,
-0.0172901899,
-0.0392811634,
-0.0540194809,
-0.0395601802,
0.0424381495,
0.0193408448,
0.0213741921,
-0.0436025448,
-0.0435301475,
-0.0148138478,
0.0052657067,
-0.0199167803,
0.0178016312,
-0.0397085361,
-0.0146077592,
-0.0089186486,
0.032757964,
-0.0055671418,
0.0379073247,
0.0410339348,
-0.0332699157,
-0.0280197933,
0.0070022587,
-0.0248451065,
0.0133712506,
-0.0450860821,
-0.0580124483,
-0.0231058951,
0.0234652273,
0.0345731042,
-0.0260246377,
-0.0204963181,
0.0193156935,
-0.0262754019,
0.0079003749,
-0.0633230507,
0.0589453243,
-0.0109235412,
0.0443800539,
0.0082975347,
-0.0124066519,
-0.0136944354,
-0.0071277302,
0.0469809398,
-0.0022909325,
-0.0742178038,
-0.0462591574,
0.030910667,
-0.005336693,
-0.019985754,
0.0418591835,
-0.0123106502,
-0.0723631382,
0.0505353659,
-0.0219440516,
-0.0288195256,
-0.0222997274,
-0.0488156788,
-0.0018388351,
0.0236276276,
-0.0360726006,
-0.0383301266,
-0.0948436484,
-0.0312078055,
0.0489202403,
0.0221224651,
-0.0009609332,
-0.076065965,
-0.0057684644,
-0.0152383745,
0.0266023222,
0.0188751668,
-0.0296138842,
-0.0171879735,
0.0094070975,
0.0548362806,
0.0532420948,
-0.0283976085,
-0.0572638623,
-0.0036863931,
-0.0224694069,
-0.0148859974,
0.0438257381,
-0.019737646,
0.0049653789,
0.039156355,
-0.0411951579,
0.009014708,
0.0359849334,
-0.0179083385,
-0.0522850454,
-0.0050411248,
0.0920412019,
-0.0105397208,
-0.0020446973,
0.0021779283,
0.0215057693,
-0.0148033975,
0.0293506421,
0.0698485523,
-0.0469669886,
0.0000083213,
0.0113314968,
0.0309856292,
0.0088365879,
-0.0300756302,
-0.0099343602,
-0.1065505967,
0.071446836,
-0.011380543,
-0.0325246081,
-0.0000573413,
-0.0419828556,
-0.0040605795,
-0.0458155014,
-0.0249288585,
-0.0360396281,
-0.0274458099,
0.0111220386,
0.0471832678,
-0.0445848443,
-0.0273662154,
0.0647135675,
-0.031314604,
0.0134951798,
0.0412982181,
0.048919186,
-0.0407036729,
0.0134873493,
-0.0093904249,
0.0055837338,
-0.0010918798,
0.0435705446,
0.0383400582,
-0.0173672289,
-0.0219636988,
-0.0076398994,
0.004567943,
-0.0262013674,
0.0009949836,
0.0449661091,
0.0735815242,
0.0009356222,
-0.0562793761,
0.0092920763,
0.0282450002,
-0.0070549971,
0.0720996335,
-0.0374268629,
-0.0759566575,
-0.0025238108,
-0.0408326611,
-0.0125560537,
0.0297733918,
-0.0607644357,
0.0395565517,
-0.0397551283,
0.0015357562,
0.0159178562,
-0.0055430233,
0.0643368661,
0.0137991821,
0.0046936618,
0.0129585434,
0.0468571745,
-0.0355095603,
-0.056878373,
0.0037984545,
-0.0844152793,
0.0422579013,
-0.0334418342,
-0.0116284294,
0.016254276,
-0.0316445865,
-0.0603774674,
-0.0508038551,
-0.1136767119,
-0.0128878765,
-0.0080992915,
0.0155291082,
0.017335806,
0.0199012067,
0.0005779424,
-0.0259691812,
0.0692905784,
0.0891548172,
-0.0111769112,
0.0007796102,
-0.0106942933,
0.0012659433,
-0.0348526835,
-0.0130105037,
-0.0521714054,
0.0033264649,
0.0214516539,
-0.0205057561,
-0.015743576,
-0.0544980615,
-0.0227036476,
-0.029357072,
0.0275046807,
0.0030322883,
-0.0379103757,
-0.0485935956,
-0.0147170862,
0.0261214282,
-0.0117141688,
-0.0293442328,
-0.0297229607,
0.1076539755,
0.035192322,
0.0421556309,
0.004622804,
0.0423382111,
0.0258092806,
-0.0702747032,
0.0279108491,
-0.0356577411,
0.0277130976,
0.0044016838,
-0.00919866,
0.012557609,
-0.0372715294,
0.0447367318,
0.0405478701,
0.0367156416,
0.017437024,
0.0059257778,
0.0336669087,
0.0075865085,
-0.0179285668,
-0.0400260314,
-0.0819973275,
-0.0339772888,
0.0191553608,
0.0301696081,
-0.0878981948,
0.017456688,
-0.0177352112,
0.0061886227,
-0.020464059,
-0.0075107478,
0.0304332916,
0.0028619638,
0.0751599446,
-0.0254169479,
-0.0188573953,
-0.0091600399,
0.036033202,
0.1026585773,
0.0319076963,
-0.0326310173,
-0.0509625934,
-0.0288856383,
0.0040222807,
0.0336210504,
0.0195434745,
0.0030361116,
0.0135483826,
-0.0617243871,
-0.0429591052,
0.0190165322,
-0.0560309775,
-0.0162854586,
-0.0287017189,
-0.011998862,
0.0278277807,
-0.0267849658,
-0.0000179967,
-0.0429321565,
-0.020247696,
-0.0063696411,
-0.011004894,
-0.0708419457,
-5.836679529e-33,
-0.0238498095,
-0.0262172762,
0.0396942422,
-0.0009379495,
-0.0037551657,
-0.0125742536,
0.0057634586,
-0.0292148776,
-0.0069353753,
-0.0217291396,
-0.0332545005,
0.0031020171,
0.0236394424,
0.0496464595,
0.040743161,
-0.0023930278,
0.0452091657,
0.0374659672,
0.0135661187,
-0.0103311017,
-0.0086443247,
0.0358803049,
0.0851894915,
-0.0740861967,
0.016390698,
0.0160036664,
0.0030578461,
0.0179849174,
0.0032541666,
0.0377777219,
-0.0022824591,
0.0350870751,
0.0142999096,
-0.0857233033,
0.0013589389,
0.0108444029,
-0.0636457577,
-0.011927736,
-0.0207425877,
0.0233579725,
0.0583566464,
-0.0163089801,
-0.0086780172,
0.0258030873,
-0.0040414515,
-0.0614032932,
0.0730381906,
-0.0318360999,
0.0418356583,
0.0043733483,
-0.0377750657,
0.0147429891,
-0.011861871,
0.0196831804,
-0.0015713695,
0.0523588546,
0.0090201199,
0.0312420949,
-0.1116719097,
-0.0167851839,
-0.0020830205,
0.0229155365,
0.0151812583,
0.0269231293,
0.016832957,
0.0262647569,
0.0499920845,
0.0194059853,
0.0229812469,
0.0066185729,
0.022208875,
0.0487065874,
-0.0064284592,
0.0252293441,
0.0576525927,
-0.043477647,
-0.0270509906,
0.0037453144,
0.0144282077,
-0.0122663118,
0.0212795958,
0.0209678523,
0.007937042,
-0.0643904209,
-0.0562489145,
-0.0406707674,
0.0231702197,
0.015362463,
0.0388082527,
-0.0044610826,
0.0324528627,
0.0148699535,
0.0165754016,
-0.0593001768,
-0.0466129445,
0.0059774215,
-0.0603189878,
0.0001007536,
0.0199594926,
0.0043934649,
-0.0810042545,
-0.0208189301,
0.0006750409,
-0.0091600092,
0.0482853912,
0.0658312887,
0.0208171625,
0.0333120786,
-0.0657583252,
-0.0175314937,
-0.0152075831,
0.0074769454,
-0.0118472166,
0.0231721792,
0.0472789854,
-0.0001042383,
0.037748836,
0.0031194242,
0.012857222,
0.0136507303,
0.0295073483,
-0.0218356661,
0.0153710861,
-0.0087984204,
-0.0134716732,
-0.0337831825,
-0.0001775083,
-0.0238851048,
0.0330496877,
-0.0436848514,
-0.0268541556,
-0.0072739576,
2.618e-7,
0.0494438708,
0.0212674551,
-0.0591801479,
0.0191731751,
0.0172032379,
0.0252584927,
-0.0124807134,
0.032543771,
0.0648375824,
0.0259247683,
0.0078210244,
-0.0062680002,
0.048931282,
-0.0141262868,
-0.1019211039,
-0.0336791612,
-0.0265375488,
-0.0192134008,
-0.0580946542,
0.0054237107,
0.0847891644,
0.0897402391,
0.0526648797,
-0.0347015336,
0.0199289043,
0.0074261441,
0.0582565106,
-0.045626875,
0.0093121147,
-0.0013737418,
-0.0200719927,
0.0296255853,
-0.0234803911,
0.0391327739,
-0.0335603356,
0.0493624285,
0.0193996094,
0.0576032102,
0.0048751272,
0.0543811694,
-0.0036424871,
0.0231086351,
-0.0137732308,
-0.0346378312,
0.0597311147,
-0.0619121678,
-0.0265761316,
-0.0483670533,
-0.0805788934,
0.0234363377,
-0.0045587593,
0.0132817198,
-0.026813617,
-0.0598900244,
0.0333928727,
0.022973869,
-0.0452765599,
0.0128343385,
0.0043105949,
0.0555737168,
-0.0602613762,
-0.0422383435,
0.033608444,
0.0302986298,
0.0224482119,
-0.0440737344,
0.0253592562,
2.529474662e-34,
0.0342487283,
0.0639253557,
-0.0027624613,
-0.0363049246,
0.024689205,
0.019376792,
0.0438793749,
0.0374714248,
0.0081867892,
-0.0484125912,
-0.0071459892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17969v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17969v1 | Encourage or Inhibit Monosemanticity? Revisit Monosemanticity from a Feature Decorrelation Perspective | 2024-06-25T22:51:08 | 2024-06-25T22:51:08 | Hanqi Yan, Yanzheng Xiang, Guangyi Chen, Yifei Wang, Lin Gui, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | To better interpret the intrinsic mechanism of large language models (LLMs),
recent studies focus on monosemanticity on its basic units. A monosemantic
neuron is dedicated to a single and specific concept, which forms a one-to-one
correlation between neurons and concepts. Despite extensive research in
monosemanticity probing, it remains unclear whether monosemanticity is
beneficial or harmful to model capacity. To explore this question, we revisit
monosemanticity from the feature decorrelation perspective and advocate for its
encouragement. We experimentally observe that the current conclusion by
wang2024learning, which suggests that decreasing monosemanticity enhances model
performance, does not hold when the model changes. Instead, we demonstrate that
monosemanticity consistently exhibits a positive correlation with model
capacity, in the preference alignment process. Consequently, we apply feature
correlation as a proxy for monosemanticity and incorporate a feature
decorrelation regularizer into the dynamic preference optimization process. The
experiments show that our method not only enhances representation diversity and
activation sparsity but also improves preference alignment performance. | [
0.0240752641,
0.0668297037,
-0.0110686105,
0.0280555505,
-0.0579099953,
0.0107925991,
0.0294835065,
-0.0473267883,
-0.0602705143,
0.0226441342,
-0.0564397722,
-0.0757219195,
0.0391083397,
0.0394579284,
0.0359034054,
-0.0183704551,
0.0804702491,
-0.018527953,
0.0022536209,
-0.0436441265,
0.0125454972,
-0.0185257234,
0.0000714658,
0.024496736,
-0.0066777011,
-0.0471853837,
-0.0110695809,
-0.000184912,
-0.0152070532,
-0.0098348055,
-0.0228355583,
0.0647953972,
0.0245584529,
0.0179954767,
0.0000020157,
-0.0540635064,
0.0253108907,
-0.0030863753,
-0.0266758241,
-0.0046836804,
0.0017002192,
-0.0120914234,
0.0267586485,
-0.0336652622,
-0.0060353829,
0.0359419174,
0.0534156002,
0.0434771888,
-0.0106481081,
0.0470581651,
-0.0115181645,
-0.0328652337,
0.0147455344,
-0.0382007807,
-0.0148366969,
0.0100463908,
0.0258911327,
-0.0586708561,
-0.0055644833,
0.032318376,
-0.048989404,
0.0126232998,
-0.0007691826,
0.0232048593,
0.0370287225,
0.0179895889,
0.0244531184,
-0.0187027734,
0.0231199786,
0.0488832109,
-0.0113343503,
0.0189389717,
-0.0216808803,
-0.0056046392,
0.0040405518,
-0.0076724528,
-0.0271746852,
-0.0286606736,
0.0255392138,
0.0269025657,
0.0081284903,
-0.0521677099,
0.0446155965,
0.0110371327,
-0.0368794873,
0.0618891045,
0.0190893002,
-0.0447848327,
0.0095882136,
-0.0078313379,
-0.0482018739,
-0.0062494311,
0.0134855192,
-0.0236773659,
-0.0044368091,
0.0052336869,
-0.010812371,
-0.0158013348,
0.0189408679,
-0.0784822553,
0.0271911398,
0.0602924973,
-0.0101133259,
0.0286597591,
-0.0215112269,
0.0830012113,
-0.0358085409,
0.0286037363,
-0.0510904491,
0.0269197337,
-0.009854354,
-0.0442332737,
0.0225806441,
0.0637777373,
0.0486066341,
-0.0261608474,
-0.0401851237,
0.0309607722,
-0.0014304128,
-0.0132347252,
-0.0496089496,
0.0237024147,
-0.0022850733,
-0.0113667352,
-0.0476229377,
0.0805389583,
-0.0335755013,
0.0265834462,
0.0035854557,
-0.0095140412,
-0.016413644,
0.0205143113,
-0.019772863,
-0.0847158581,
0.0127109224,
0.0482996814,
-0.0203224514,
-0.0230530202,
0.0124866832,
0.0226619355,
-0.0722936392,
-0.0245558117,
0.0178950634,
-0.0597420298,
0.0226893332,
0.0332233645,
-0.021604361,
-0.0652884617,
-0.01622607,
-0.0493266322,
-0.0534192398,
0.0347462334,
-0.006730061,
0.019465575,
0.0096230339,
-0.0235617273,
0.0217300244,
0.0718402416,
0.0507025085,
0.0123307845,
0.0098791691,
0.0070361607,
-0.0683471784,
0.010203789,
-0.0189661346,
-0.0070018121,
-0.0817014277,
-0.0272094756,
0.0265399348,
0.0359249376,
0.0794968605,
0.0363379009,
-0.0367997289,
-0.0724288151,
0.0812739506,
0.0443582088,
0.0215720553,
0.0040695225,
0.0015515002,
-0.0235714447,
-0.0078266906,
0.0578180514,
-0.0334001407,
0.0599314459,
0.002902074,
0.0308204778,
0.0410647504,
0.0544881187,
-0.0352684297,
-0.0252625011,
-0.014045896,
-0.0069901082,
0.0125061218,
-0.0199989863,
0.040282052,
-0.0426428318,
-0.012471348,
0.0188792665,
-0.0012867635,
0.0098015424,
0.0051847151,
-0.0455912612,
0.0157457795,
0.0740521476,
0.0090600187,
0.0175526459,
-0.0500434972,
0.014102947,
-0.0468692556,
0.0682029948,
0.0272050202,
0.0161651373,
0.0621793866,
-0.0437062271,
-0.0320655406,
-0.0347741432,
0.0019960226,
0.0178981461,
-0.0198915713,
-0.01721186,
-0.0075578904,
0.023611106,
0.0220327638,
0.011636951,
0.0136600435,
-0.0022692319,
0.0233106073,
0.0044659339,
0.0135598667,
-0.0129768122,
-0.0206580907,
0.0358422771,
-0.0052269474,
-0.0277273394,
0.0045762518,
-0.0128453048,
-0.1104632542,
-0.030310275,
0.0472335815,
0.0378697887,
-0.007181779,
0.0329557434,
0.0112018725,
-0.036681883,
0.0145469392,
0.0235392991,
0.00274465,
-0.0243832059,
0.0211374164,
0.00164527,
0.0506525747,
-0.0608568415,
0.0409589037,
-0.0146767152,
-0.0009123588,
-0.0160256978,
-0.0182422101,
0.0363855101,
-0.0293942839,
-0.0590163693,
0.0050846832,
-0.0092239985,
0.0158907697,
0.0125808772,
-0.0325158536,
-0.0069239326,
-0.0460761897,
-0.0640683025,
-0.0042720796,
-0.0020979687,
-0.0044392007,
-0.0071766032,
0.0131149124,
0.0212790295,
0.0221488774,
-0.0229805224,
-0.0017725903,
-0.0348434336,
0.0735488683,
0.033065632,
0.0078758076,
-0.0249421149,
-0.05932476,
-0.0356121548,
-0.0113881724,
0.0402222797,
-0.0557055324,
-0.008569764,
-0.0065539717,
0.0346039571,
-0.0373200551,
-0.0142123559,
0.0041032834,
-0.022648152,
0.031740509,
-0.0074639157,
0.0667369738,
0.0509048551,
0.0054870001,
0.0075967615,
0.0700976551,
0.0333922915,
-0.025712939,
0.0022758609,
-0.0358862057,
0.0334206522,
-0.05130817,
0.0076297941,
-0.0447194017,
0.1044813618,
0.021985013,
-0.0507862642,
-0.0474060215,
-0.0154325413,
0.0159736667,
-0.0406265333,
-0.0283050276,
0.0010673461,
-0.0416552462,
0.0154481167,
-0.0423903875,
-0.0491807312,
0.0575228594,
0.0112017533,
0.0161968507,
-0.0048337523,
0.0069558416,
-0.0265117176,
0.0509758852,
0.0399306081,
0.0238192193,
-0.0080865631,
-0.0163877495,
-0.1028238237,
-0.010985232,
-0.001562882,
0.007470347,
0.0972296521,
-0.0125597091,
0.0097645409,
-0.0015825774,
-0.0500361472,
-0.0332733989,
0.0047223787,
0.0110583724,
0.0295879953,
0.0587267242,
0.0106259091,
-0.0415006243,
-0.0183951613,
0.0334028751,
0.033573091,
-0.023875121,
0.0045621679,
0.0193297807,
0.0288328473,
0.0531768054,
0.0694134384,
0.0086441841,
-0.0388604179,
0.0157182943,
0.0216244049,
-0.0173463039,
0.0170233734,
-0.0290925279,
0.0219276268,
0.0186308585,
-0.0206879545,
-0.0439606979,
-0.0103989393,
0.0400728323,
-0.0242997892,
0.0098169846,
0.0859355703,
0.0092757177,
-0.0459510423,
0.0193193145,
-0.0476552472,
0.0816745907,
0.0373687334,
0.0051944521,
0.0005761679,
-0.0011183149,
-0.0226161424,
-0.0387763903,
0.0323112011,
0.0177675523,
-0.0112157539,
-0.052713979,
-0.0371873938,
0.0263201725,
-0.0421934016,
0.0072188391,
-0.0071633835,
-0.0097681293,
-0.0358625688,
0.0527010001,
0.0406778269,
0.0002504514,
-0.0143325739,
0.0237948336,
-0.0389442667,
-0.0280894227,
0.0048176749,
-0.0342144705,
0.0307372231,
0.084065102,
-0.0116949277,
-0.0214903764,
-0.0038590566,
0.0009565066,
0.0475883149,
0.034050636,
0.0107755763,
0.0241534319,
0.0162207391,
-0.0153987631,
-0.0285147857,
-0.0071306261,
0.0073912302,
-0.0289125219,
-0.056078352,
0.0291097406,
0.001381057,
0.0010883813,
-0.0302184466,
-0.0158666652,
-0.0510941707,
0.0540055223,
0.0271076001,
-0.0980009958,
-0.0046664989,
-0.0117063401,
-0.0390964039,
-0.041817341,
-0.0320928693,
0.0156646352,
0.0632225052,
-0.0189149585,
-0.0524991155,
0.0078224763,
-0.0103285592,
0.0218587667,
-0.0085042175,
0.0221726596,
-0.0475175567,
-0.0348407291,
-0.0299464278,
0.0100048976,
0.0395339839,
0.0037837655,
-0.0619240142,
0.0086817667,
0.0189022589,
-0.0204977598,
-0.0105896015,
-0.0360721871,
-0.0887950286,
-0.0795290098,
0.0235379431,
0.0178910084,
0.0112643875,
0.0275370143,
0.0222372804,
-0.0298402142,
0.0458499305,
0.0654348582,
0.008067403,
0.0481376685,
0.0126022603,
-0.0048606987,
-0.0246835221,
0.031264212,
-0.013245563,
-0.0159129743,
0.0200727209,
0.0570729636,
0.00171595,
-0.0145331305,
0.0135316625,
-0.0091205034,
0.0327702798,
0.00337175,
0.0832648426,
-0.0270929858,
0.0171090029,
0.0153723024,
0.0165766273,
-0.0109520033,
-0.0623236261,
0.0728413686,
0.0054441649,
-0.0209175367,
-0.0212551095,
0.0424577035,
0.0188604724,
0.036212109,
-0.0455050729,
-0.0601535477,
-0.0200782809,
0.0206060372,
0.0434412025,
-0.0137826856,
0.0917030722,
-0.0380797572,
-0.0157307554,
-0.0105964001,
0.0205145739,
0.0132899107,
0.0218924657,
-0.0343483612,
-0.0040748063,
-0.045202937,
-0.0405732431,
-0.0151697714,
-0.0466659516,
0.0378162228,
-0.0081321551,
0.0735770538,
-0.013430194,
-0.0011450725,
-0.0436913483,
0.0039970214,
-0.0315696374,
0.0085036028,
0.0427281372,
0.0471951142,
-0.0140322717,
-0.0181700066,
0.0761310756,
-0.0070749056,
-0.0006429308,
-0.0035804529,
0.0293769445,
0.001446744,
-0.0177466273,
0.027711343,
0.034041021,
-0.0612077042,
-0.0018484527,
-0.0539800376,
-0.0475878865,
0.04607144,
0.0073851668,
0.0359915793,
0.0006601724,
0.0289699938,
0.0291962251,
-0.0292269401,
-0.0229102559,
-0.0076494142,
-0.0410258994,
0.0308104157,
-0.010495658,
0.01740635,
-6.911859028e-33,
-0.0423492938,
-0.0010211112,
0.0039039745,
-0.0387796275,
-0.0163723361,
-0.0811300501,
0.0039477311,
0.0571183525,
-0.0448330268,
0.0086024432,
-0.0131081203,
-0.00096026,
-0.0064227986,
0.0195147656,
0.071275115,
0.0069546932,
0.0326965638,
0.002413034,
0.0042694178,
-0.0408016145,
0.0657344013,
0.0209148508,
0.0603342988,
-0.0710287839,
-0.0153641673,
0.0348774381,
-0.0036191898,
-0.009890656,
-0.0223314688,
0.0619133264,
-0.0281255953,
0.0166128781,
0.0344287381,
-0.0162447579,
-0.0251807217,
-0.0723637268,
-0.0296289381,
-0.0621047802,
0.0448601507,
0.004652163,
-0.0216764938,
-0.0489228293,
0.0528086312,
0.0016173517,
-0.0023638539,
-0.046409972,
0.0349825323,
-0.0324412547,
-0.0679956824,
0.0307497177,
-0.0818978921,
0.0123764751,
-0.0039208555,
0.0292890184,
-0.0055709966,
-0.0143089369,
-0.0194227882,
0.0189186316,
-0.0277243927,
0.0243048426,
0.0052384268,
0.0809855312,
0.0320960283,
0.0493830144,
0.0302321222,
0.0529530495,
0.0566556081,
0.0015558213,
0.0223705117,
-0.0279524829,
0.055870045,
0.02566869,
0.0341983847,
0.0273079481,
0.0824161693,
-0.0134707838,
-0.0496929288,
-0.006704472,
0.0342327096,
0.0123947226,
0.0332750008,
0.0342638493,
-0.0172118526,
-0.0356387682,
-0.0141360462,
-0.0050464747,
-0.0698371753,
-0.1035255119,
0.0131551474,
-0.0166060515,
0.0226772744,
0.0214910787,
0.0499628857,
-0.0147152878,
-0.0386960693,
0.0549682677,
-0.0669217408,
0.0174519494,
0.0197824072,
-0.0173687115,
-0.0670324787,
-0.0263922233,
-0.0224073455,
0.0258977227,
-0.0036081721,
0.0435452238,
0.0391735621,
0.0265182611,
-0.0545251667,
-0.0330155157,
-0.009867792,
-0.0875299051,
0.0271099284,
-0.0036871554,
0.0408799537,
-0.0122170271,
-0.0172938276,
0.0623427667,
-0.0012955226,
-0.0254427828,
-0.0784521699,
-0.0342673585,
0.0074299816,
0.0406913646,
0.0176122822,
-0.014103814,
-0.0281261466,
-0.0057188664,
0.0265235417,
-0.0514638089,
-0.0374478102,
0.0216186885,
2.846e-7,
0.0216865093,
0.02539232,
-0.0085378783,
-0.0026201012,
0.028919436,
0.034789931,
-0.0543476865,
0.0185964033,
-0.0343338996,
-0.0240740925,
0.0242901929,
0.0564875901,
0.0197411999,
0.0167600121,
-0.0587106198,
0.0562961698,
-0.0208627321,
0.0605928451,
-0.0224328581,
0.0144022191,
0.0172935352,
0.0998391211,
-0.0085925655,
-0.0026520137,
0.0121806059,
-0.0070762057,
0.0771676451,
-0.0208843555,
0.0037229378,
0.033829812,
0.0055614933,
-0.0602911152,
-0.0337112099,
-0.013737902,
0.0120719709,
0.0523670912,
0.0117330011,
0.0696673989,
-0.0265055094,
-0.0389844105,
-0.0009673087,
0.0238905679,
-0.0263297316,
-0.0145209124,
0.0445401557,
-0.0368694738,
-0.0583977327,
-0.0253650341,
0.036489293,
0.0254307892,
0.031501282,
-0.019814346,
-0.0081253815,
-0.0134941759,
0.0009347569,
-0.0095706098,
-0.0272861272,
-0.0652572513,
-0.0263468996,
0.055075258,
-0.0612803735,
-0.0214492828,
-0.0580795258,
0.0309923906,
0.0793671161,
0.0116828447,
-0.0285356585,
2.511636765e-34,
0.0349927582,
-0.0380920842,
0.0217414834,
0.0384595022,
-0.0257633533,
-0.0481201746,
-0.0453333892,
0.0075128484,
0.018601777,
-0.075894706,
-0.0380253047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17967v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17967v1 | Unmasking the Imposters: In-Domain Detection of Human vs. Machine-Generated Tweets | 2024-06-25T22:49:17 | 2024-06-25T22:49:17 | Bryan E. Tuck, Rakesh M. Verma | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid development of large language models (LLMs) has significantly
improved the generation of fluent and convincing text, raising concerns about
their misuse on social media platforms. We present a methodology using Twitter
datasets to examine the generative capabilities of four LLMs: Llama 3, Mistral,
Qwen2, and GPT4o. We evaluate 7B and 8B parameter base-instruction models of
the three open-source LLMs and validate the impact of further fine-tuning and
"uncensored" versions. Our findings show that "uncensored" models with
additional in-domain fine-tuning dramatically reduce the effectiveness of
automated detection methods. This study addresses a gap by exploring smaller
open-source models and the effects of "uncensoring," providing insights into
how fine-tuning and content moderation influence machine-generated text
detection. | [
0.0733409449,
0.0446940884,
-0.029980544,
0.0383860506,
-0.0499101616,
0.0188977532,
0.0272992849,
0.0236452967,
0.0322231352,
-0.031282492,
0.0224562101,
-0.0339960493,
-0.016862154,
0.0374411792,
0.0458197854,
0.0020132314,
0.02529235,
-0.0138163855,
0.0061935754,
-0.0052188663,
0.0342381299,
0.044305563,
0.0223544426,
0.0334128402,
-0.0006593488,
0.0020113157,
0.0260613021,
0.0267047584,
0.004754263,
0.0075878361,
0.0350464433,
0.0843489245,
0.0119353132,
0.1047967151,
0.0000021557,
-0.0337373391,
-0.023177607,
-0.0117164524,
-0.0153527809,
0.0535022691,
0.1045107245,
-0.009700276,
-0.030777622,
0.0432299785,
-0.0536525734,
0.0445202552,
0.0361254066,
0.0248808619,
0.0514178611,
0.0732509419,
-0.0226411633,
0.0126544172,
0.0336790718,
-0.0138041256,
-0.0112653561,
-0.0030515795,
0.0318106934,
-0.0214137882,
0.0003753718,
0.0230845734,
0.039960254,
0.0370893404,
0.0032129288,
-0.0326300263,
-0.0140359178,
-0.0039856168,
-0.0325612538,
-0.0490314662,
0.0033466478,
0.0363382809,
-0.0246289,
-0.0636407807,
0.0307530686,
-0.0164355673,
0.0194499549,
0.0447158292,
0.0025374468,
0.0369832665,
-0.0190259684,
-0.0051505221,
-0.0116063543,
-0.0069425707,
0.0314926617,
0.0436873958,
0.0135339191,
0.0100364126,
0.0122750821,
-0.0499298871,
-0.021785304,
0.002907583,
-0.0380474627,
-0.0622864477,
0.0237936024,
-0.0054953941,
-0.0073542818,
-0.0071966811,
-0.0732965171,
-0.0438769348,
0.038533289,
-0.0354369581,
0.0309407506,
0.0182679798,
-0.0001818584,
-0.0030851108,
-0.0318352804,
0.0567047335,
-0.0443756692,
0.0013475551,
0.0141379861,
-0.0039204238,
-0.0193399675,
-0.0181674305,
-0.0150198285,
-0.0217346083,
-0.0188500267,
-0.0050337398,
-0.0578085929,
0.0310182534,
0.0022969905,
-0.0287612844,
-0.0226705968,
-0.0356186815,
-0.0089103514,
0.0029162108,
-0.0043995073,
-0.0056339712,
0.0240431484,
0.0178430397,
-0.0035986525,
-0.1150321066,
0.0030178684,
0.0498650931,
0.0312833674,
-0.0246160962,
0.0014188568,
0.0226017963,
-0.006694858,
-0.0470419563,
-0.0226839148,
-0.0480622873,
-0.0114944037,
-0.0579379797,
-0.0126848631,
-0.0820409283,
-0.0044284766,
0.0194672756,
-0.0080758287,
-0.0348317735,
0.0130422637,
0.0648638532,
-0.0287584346,
-0.0099380026,
-0.0602804683,
0.0482877456,
0.0221512448,
-0.0004210042,
0.0034497727,
0.06472864,
0.0186875686,
0.0789111927,
0.0398329534,
-0.0266482309,
0.0553109311,
0.0643987432,
0.0183732472,
0.0146303242,
-0.0066600167,
-0.0429479629,
-0.0280696079,
-0.0052039595,
0.0119105941,
0.0686402321,
-0.0096551729,
0.0114503885,
0.1055358574,
0.0494619235,
-0.0168225486,
0.0037519617,
0.0850764439,
0.0640632287,
0.0377922021,
0.0016588153,
-0.0344024822,
-0.0194505434,
-0.0403923802,
-0.0201592054,
0.013837886,
0.0558637902,
0.0007006572,
-0.0089906454,
-0.012587253,
-0.0100678112,
0.0115205571,
-0.0238182191,
0.004383944,
-0.0053081028,
-0.0534534454,
0.0052217511,
0.0042795595,
-0.0616080649,
-0.0126847057,
-0.0566241257,
0.0143287778,
0.0799085051,
0.0347876661,
0.0587582961,
0.054128997,
-0.0489999466,
0.0510557294,
0.0861694589,
-0.0000889616,
0.0101271821,
-0.0140880998,
-0.0286186822,
-0.0082328552,
-0.024170734,
0.0094030807,
-0.0044961497,
0.0475310758,
-0.0069136806,
0.0309658293,
-0.0120849526,
-0.0564923398,
0.008554521,
-0.0493069887,
-0.0083038546,
-0.0262558144,
0.0043532606,
-0.0114173843,
0.0309705455,
-0.0093090674,
-0.0158412978,
0.0174117927,
-0.0078882575,
-0.0188554022,
-0.0003946945,
-0.0202366468,
0.04324238,
0.0266053267,
-0.0143103404,
-0.0366821922,
0.0311508756,
-0.0106174638,
-0.0027757816,
0.0474347249,
-0.0530434549,
0.022355983,
-0.070850268,
0.0172062274,
-0.0716006979,
0.0391764306,
0.0161362384,
0.0594953075,
-0.0345770307,
-0.0054129208,
0.0592051521,
-0.0303579848,
0.0153884999,
0.0010382535,
-0.0102037191,
-0.0256684758,
-0.0331720337,
0.0389674157,
0.0224920735,
0.0075411578,
-0.0245378241,
-0.0382428989,
-0.0496913865,
-0.0020478098,
-0.0520245694,
-0.0008305762,
0.0499191396,
0.0108215865,
-0.0402073786,
0.0442168973,
-0.0102610076,
-0.040158201,
0.0546369739,
0.023851268,
0.0167067908,
-0.0507193357,
-0.0231159404,
-0.0235835984,
0.0078755254,
-0.0262681209,
0.0169482082,
0.0204293784,
-0.0507918186,
-0.0140913585,
0.040401347,
-0.0046911389,
0.0096593462,
-0.0027056066,
-0.0605211481,
0.0069953999,
-0.0176022053,
0.0399319716,
0.0322980881,
0.0364598706,
0.0266834646,
0.0082266517,
0.0207196288,
-0.0181027483,
-0.0291717779,
-0.0178375077,
-0.0517956242,
-0.0314335972,
-0.0750521272,
0.0212282799,
0.0583781153,
0.0141079715,
0.0011075557,
-0.0463500731,
0.0488058962,
-0.0254549775,
-0.0376732685,
0.013373049,
-0.0221681222,
-0.0325444527,
0.0279718917,
-0.0364421271,
-0.0825760737,
0.0341805369,
-0.0387991443,
0.0224933606,
0.0000097096,
-0.061234951,
0.0088827284,
-0.0317854099,
0.0391512662,
0.0369497091,
0.0323611759,
-0.0036518341,
0.0300112627,
0.0250574388,
0.0304193813,
-0.0385523662,
-0.0140391244,
0.00608182,
0.0162967592,
0.0197029971,
0.0045691072,
-0.0350790098,
-0.0623966716,
-0.0170973334,
-0.0092078559,
0.0541686267,
-0.0486759059,
0.0073290016,
-0.0121545531,
0.0156298447,
0.0088996338,
-0.0390347689,
-0.0010544788,
-0.0384509154,
0.024301935,
0.0215599332,
-0.0323208831,
0.0278220139,
-0.0521202385,
0.0118973562,
0.0399997197,
0.0009742828,
-0.0276158508,
-0.0117846224,
-0.0249216203,
0.0138075417,
0.0093058422,
0.0005262468,
0.0341569409,
0.077735424,
-0.0209297314,
0.0174489878,
0.1118760332,
0.0212489422,
0.0037353029,
-0.0077942908,
-0.0032904882,
0.0337964632,
0.0109387534,
-0.007294069,
-0.0935214981,
-0.0087395813,
0.0016124258,
0.0470617749,
-0.0688343123,
-0.0119668506,
-0.0246083308,
-0.1108273342,
0.054603111,
0.0058028935,
-0.0131183583,
-0.0121072475,
-0.0265466291,
-0.0178779606,
0.0049344334,
0.0125811351,
-0.0138033871,
-0.0387859978,
0.0160464849,
0.0133838123,
-0.0399493128,
-0.0921265632,
-0.003932429,
-0.042457886,
0.0222695209,
0.0440990292,
0.0227455739,
-0.0055377404,
-0.0542966053,
0.030925028,
-0.0262267198,
0.0077577778,
-0.0118258782,
0.0468649566,
-0.0108114267,
-0.0007531834,
-0.052726496,
0.038852077,
-0.0323186629,
0.0051374924,
-0.0388518944,
0.0410794131,
0.0117943715,
-0.0509825498,
-0.0088009946,
-0.0002840388,
0.0431858227,
0.0640116408,
0.0618648119,
-0.0379992202,
-0.043769829,
-0.0330305882,
0.0323656201,
-0.030092774,
-0.0641975552,
-0.0152830575,
0.0046280376,
-0.0527045801,
-0.0472527556,
-0.0259783901,
-0.0105637554,
-0.0193683915,
-0.0089488178,
0.0248107761,
-0.0079827234,
-0.0347348563,
-0.0294471905,
0.0074334629,
-0.053816691,
0.0600135885,
-0.0530712008,
0.0001383052,
-0.0082697663,
-0.0143010067,
0.0187641419,
0.0276649762,
-0.0935084596,
-0.0829041749,
0.0158264246,
0.0206610989,
0.0236889515,
0.0059140692,
-0.0197546557,
-0.0679691732,
0.0448695198,
0.0488365442,
-0.0239088181,
0.0455026031,
0.018250132,
-0.0052966443,
0.0041889646,
0.0180523973,
-0.0025479624,
0.0177524555,
0.0309880562,
-0.0294366721,
-0.0216651913,
-0.0052863723,
0.017555831,
0.037981201,
0.0260892026,
-0.0108965421,
-0.0060677473,
-0.0219900329,
-0.0644586608,
-0.0283506438,
-0.0002179496,
-0.0450548194,
-0.0088649616,
0.0295862816,
0.0194914117,
-0.0039400319,
0.0154886823,
-0.0643485934,
0.0582509376,
-0.0583108887,
0.0321568064,
-0.0335430205,
0.0647488832,
0.0295636673,
-0.0095246369,
-0.0073804422,
0.0380062722,
-0.0115725594,
0.0219641328,
0.0190112423,
0.0382348262,
-0.0388750881,
-0.0076337559,
0.0328492895,
0.0467924364,
-0.0211373772,
-0.0140203992,
-0.058546152,
0.0232739877,
0.0531865507,
-0.0196382012,
0.1014972627,
0.001907933,
0.0120815458,
-0.0202818252,
0.0134371351,
-0.0139550352,
-0.0386958085,
-0.0096248956,
-0.0206536502,
-0.0465839207,
0.0318476446,
0.0816241652,
0.0310317241,
0.0491254143,
0.005481354,
-0.0132359127,
-0.0108890645,
-0.0195294563,
0.0176291075,
0.007641471,
-0.0075767701,
0.0097465347,
-0.0488728695,
-0.069438763,
0.0109168189,
-0.0337155685,
0.0067859162,
-0.0023822344,
-0.0195806678,
0.0725045949,
-0.022161236,
0.0037163952,
-0.0646370947,
-0.0202108733,
0.0079633836,
-0.0422051772,
0.0049092821,
-7.075581882e-33,
0.0318074562,
-0.0656777918,
-0.019626623,
-0.0327433608,
-0.0009681801,
0.0000630549,
-0.0123992413,
-0.0042021731,
-0.0083974991,
0.0022089726,
-0.014777842,
0.0295803025,
0.0058468077,
0.0071336208,
-0.0211536884,
0.030471798,
0.0492298268,
-0.0165675413,
-0.0372756533,
0.0494488813,
0.051524125,
-0.0189801361,
0.0070372289,
-0.0933162197,
0.0350864604,
-0.0669069663,
-0.0278296545,
0.0042403801,
-0.0077777957,
0.048026491,
-0.0215938222,
0.0606140681,
0.0375059992,
-0.0157114342,
-0.0144764166,
0.0502186231,
0.0090833707,
0.0045920676,
0.0189866517,
-0.0220614448,
0.0098608341,
-0.0905083865,
0.0434337184,
-0.0413250513,
-0.0538388416,
0.0333341509,
0.0174581688,
0.0042259209,
0.0479282066,
-0.043554239,
-0.0494150035,
0.0367994495,
-0.0055264947,
-0.0124653438,
0.0095745809,
0.0722366795,
0.0170114376,
0.0204754137,
-0.0620847717,
0.0483676679,
0.0256789736,
-0.0110665029,
0.071631521,
-0.0266726296,
-0.0183698107,
0.0199351124,
0.0170858148,
0.0280593745,
-0.0105639501,
0.0125829102,
-0.0208496545,
0.0366937742,
0.0536114462,
0.0942416489,
0.0134491539,
-0.0632677674,
-0.04100601,
0.0155746005,
0.0007735051,
0.0028922588,
0.0504330359,
-0.0237939917,
-0.0463430993,
-0.025420649,
-0.0140450681,
-0.0634381622,
-0.0368109867,
-0.0323571451,
0.018820351,
0.0019602259,
-0.0413122661,
-0.0252706464,
0.0429558679,
-0.0608644411,
-0.0052509061,
0.0174671393,
-0.0616262779,
0.0294684768,
0.0152565315,
0.0454103611,
-0.0503848158,
-0.0221232045,
0.0559884347,
-0.0104043474,
0.0146327205,
-0.000550029,
0.0197492633,
0.031729769,
-0.0505256355,
0.0192916598,
-0.0029785093,
0.0596626513,
-0.0108464425,
-0.0098933335,
0.0255122203,
-0.013090089,
-0.0086139888,
-0.0069494764,
0.0447643325,
-0.0072024344,
-0.0289684739,
0.0002417411,
-0.0401184186,
0.0081087602,
-0.0306216609,
0.0157349482,
-0.0351877771,
0.0216531046,
0.0375690199,
-0.0477244407,
-0.0054972749,
-0.0321472473,
2.959e-7,
0.0005271054,
0.0803425536,
0.0008996031,
-0.0140478853,
0.0541681275,
0.0369870663,
0.0278130844,
0.0158476029,
0.0039959424,
-0.0325175673,
-0.0383978933,
0.0253076851,
0.0806739032,
0.0018394168,
-0.0380883105,
0.0239017177,
-0.0629510134,
0.0123403948,
-0.0685692281,
0.0007684396,
0.0363378525,
0.0406401269,
0.0083462549,
-0.0313265584,
-0.0143401371,
-0.0735974759,
0.0583311953,
-0.0076295827,
-0.0225411355,
0.0367452875,
0.0797832832,
-0.0011076104,
0.0208447427,
0.0025324693,
-0.0188039877,
0.0257335734,
0.0029666505,
0.0677963644,
0.0363379717,
0.0516710244,
0.0138486978,
-0.0658079833,
0.0069225803,
-0.0553079024,
0.0664011687,
-0.0150323575,
-0.0478644148,
-0.067227222,
-0.0321631767,
-0.0536561757,
0.0139493039,
-0.041334372,
-0.0327013806,
0.0303683002,
-0.0027952052,
0.0202884991,
-0.0285129026,
-0.0162381474,
-0.0146847898,
-0.0607236288,
-0.0358474031,
-0.0516301952,
-0.0560481101,
-0.0006510714,
0.044555191,
0.0009283379,
0.0695631355,
2.685430161e-34,
0.0217798334,
-0.0262994077,
0.0390092395,
-0.0050659785,
0.0422273278,
0.043593064,
0.0084309932,
0.0218863524,
-0.0035499164,
-0.0610003434,
0.0265820902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17962v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17962v2 | SimsChat: A Customisable Persona-Driven Role-Playing Agent | 2024-06-25T22:44:17 | 2024-06-30T21:15:47 | Bohao Yang, Dong Liu, Chen Tang, Chenghao Xiao, Kun Zhao, Chao Li, Lin Yuan, Guang Yang, Lanxiao Huang, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) possess the remarkable capability to understand
human instructions and generate high-quality text, enabling them to act as
agents that simulate human behaviours. This capability allows LLMs to emulate
human beings in a more advanced manner, beyond merely replicating simple human
behaviours. However, there is a lack of exploring into leveraging LLMs to craft
characters from several aspects. In this work, we introduce the Customisable
Conversation Agent Framework, which employs LLMs to simulate real-world
characters that can be freely customised according to different user
preferences. The customisable framework is helpful for designing customisable
characters and role-playing agents according to human's preferences. We first
propose the SimsConv dataset, which comprises 68 different customised
characters, 1,360 multi-turn role-playing dialogues, and encompasses 13,971
interaction dialogues in total. The characters are created from several
real-world elements, such as career, aspiration, trait, and skill. Building on
these foundations, we present SimsChat, a freely customisable role-playing
agent. It incorporates different real-world scenes and topic-specific character
interaction dialogues, simulating characters' life experiences in various
scenarios and topic-specific interactions with specific emotions. Experimental
results show that our proposed framework achieves desirable performance and
provides helpful guideline for building better simulacra of human beings in the
future. Our data and code are available at
https://github.com/Bernard-Yang/SimsChat. | [
0.0605549701,
0.0405835696,
-0.0435984954,
0.0246807598,
-0.0062871045,
0.0060907118,
0.0193379577,
-0.0141471578,
0.0425120145,
0.0177972913,
-0.0253438931,
-0.0476705134,
-0.0138226766,
0.055323422,
0.0061234022,
-0.0685062855,
0.0190761294,
-0.0299715623,
0.0341092013,
-0.0008900206,
0.0080448771,
0.049291864,
-0.0149660669,
0.0613056272,
-0.0097160162,
-0.0319919325,
-0.0219664704,
0.0084649334,
0.0396439657,
-0.0217297561,
0.0329408795,
0.0057150116,
0.0227127783,
0.0047044554,
0.000002078,
-0.020356454,
0.0158260763,
-0.0306511484,
0.0017584462,
-0.0111453598,
0.0833933204,
0.0631205663,
-0.0172105022,
0.0374593511,
-0.0435849428,
0.0006948793,
0.0482754745,
0.0446971767,
0.1018838286,
0.0762470886,
-0.0204117764,
-0.0314195789,
-0.0539550073,
-0.0165028572,
0.0248320792,
-0.0324404947,
-0.000977886,
0.0452871509,
0.0561831817,
-0.0106944898,
-0.0049061943,
0.0131195206,
-0.0143763013,
-0.0241498984,
-0.0171556883,
0.0436742604,
0.0134590268,
-0.015906712,
0.0192844737,
0.0700075701,
0.0083830832,
-0.0040075975,
0.0313660465,
0.0136088422,
0.0423048884,
0.0144898472,
-0.0160411056,
0.0350863375,
-0.0097538298,
-0.0076608947,
-0.0161715131,
0.0359499678,
-0.0022896999,
-0.0141744828,
-0.0117462687,
-0.0037312568,
0.00895207,
-0.0130843837,
-0.056157466,
-0.0247723199,
0.0213966221,
-0.0716009587,
-0.012091022,
0.0095716454,
-0.0520498492,
0.0393304005,
-0.0695887357,
0.054633759,
-0.0093418416,
-0.021459816,
0.0258452576,
0.0458676666,
0.0053911689,
0.0243558642,
0.044563923,
0.0144536039,
0.0143280448,
-0.0214762148,
-0.0217577443,
-0.0043045832,
-0.0337535962,
-0.0335354097,
-0.0332732014,
0.0384489782,
-0.0368616767,
-0.0320464335,
-0.0388095006,
0.071914874,
-0.028215887,
0.0247268938,
0.0084360698,
0.0173885636,
-0.0351930745,
0.0189476795,
-0.0560070276,
0.0000701267,
-0.0372171141,
-0.013670221,
0.009992457,
-0.055584576,
0.0372515954,
-0.0161969494,
0.0065401057,
0.0101475753,
0.0320814475,
0.0907070711,
-0.005925769,
-0.0120752249,
0.0387945734,
-0.0268639047,
0.028759772,
-0.0566010475,
-0.0411453731,
-0.0428414084,
0.0506534353,
-0.0300042275,
0.0207885094,
-0.0446323678,
0.0103220502,
0.0224652048,
0.0136605958,
0.0762322769,
0.0027052218,
0.0317078643,
0.0317610241,
0.0301278494,
-0.0062821507,
0.0266080834,
0.0426630937,
0.0284580588,
0.0060873698,
-0.0070246845,
0.0532953702,
0.0447399877,
-0.0592023358,
-0.0237771962,
0.0178830195,
-0.0044102985,
0.0035956365,
0.0596736372,
0.0096274223,
0.0347144417,
-0.060619168,
-0.0238404702,
0.0748976767,
0.0616992079,
0.0147865219,
0.0361689366,
0.0420511775,
0.0728142709,
0.0319511518,
-0.0384429805,
-0.0017081287,
0.0442707539,
0.0396065265,
-0.0230729207,
-0.0731835589,
0.0334265977,
-0.0203426518,
-0.0214417316,
0.0448033549,
-0.0238678399,
0.0295106396,
0.018424293,
-0.0093214735,
-0.0129488045,
-0.0423377827,
0.0278732609,
0.0276970398,
-0.0880405083,
-0.0157852843,
-0.053919062,
0.0327332318,
0.1489654332,
0.0429341234,
-0.0356905684,
-0.0502507426,
-0.0200995747,
-0.0213639271,
0.0426726565,
0.0143613843,
-0.0279779099,
0.0208284948,
-0.0398392119,
0.0287381578,
0.0020318199,
-0.0182710458,
0.0571186244,
-0.0002021787,
-0.0071500344,
-0.0174981207,
0.0607828125,
0.0211008862,
0.0066516269,
-0.0805476606,
-0.0012188713,
-0.0102402605,
0.0087377541,
0.0104581332,
0.0034787066,
-0.0106197912,
-0.0407998227,
0.0126424031,
-0.0115882251,
-0.0119390674,
0.0811493993,
-0.0412500687,
0.0022043912,
0.0489017293,
-0.0544339232,
-0.0162026882,
0.0337956026,
0.0093789548,
-0.0054922109,
0.0135884807,
-0.0404304005,
0.0437269993,
-0.0043100719,
0.0273271687,
-0.0173616279,
0.0570695996,
-0.0040030838,
0.029246375,
0.0199334864,
-0.0381634571,
0.0091788033,
0.0254952721,
-0.0213974919,
-0.0647957772,
0.0113077685,
-0.001023644,
0.001188745,
0.0207717493,
0.0203003194,
0.0018105292,
-0.0548549369,
-0.0543533228,
-0.0914560482,
0.0066956049,
0.0390101708,
-0.0323530734,
0.0337708332,
0.0311570764,
-0.055315353,
-0.0140881352,
-0.0688097775,
0.0042198221,
0.0133816395,
-0.0264044777,
0.0391683951,
-0.0074931751,
-0.0098314667,
-0.0547402687,
0.0067485594,
-0.0059695048,
0.025547795,
-0.0269048251,
0.0355505943,
-0.0154501582,
0.0025203049,
-0.0358122736,
0.0361062661,
-0.0314563289,
-0.0645240918,
0.0369422697,
-0.0323248915,
0.0358735472,
0.0279931594,
0.0394406393,
0.0417520665,
0.018592475,
-0.0315593146,
-0.0489709154,
0.0242367927,
0.006341652,
0.0180715509,
-0.0513222069,
-0.0593222119,
0.0280325972,
0.0456957929,
-0.0118907327,
0.0338466801,
-0.0768667385,
0.0474701785,
0.0471461304,
-0.0389173292,
0.0503772683,
0.0018656526,
-0.018149877,
-0.0179282166,
-0.0074356142,
0.0193289742,
0.0393553711,
-0.0063358592,
-0.0281285252,
-0.0043270858,
-0.0052901614,
-0.0132035809,
0.0801776201,
-0.0047382149,
0.0147070773,
0.0050042104,
-0.0177829005,
-0.0155631723,
-0.0273622628,
0.0161706898,
-0.0484742783,
0.0160371345,
-0.0565144978,
-0.0268414468,
0.0359355658,
-0.0080752084,
-0.0355063565,
-0.0481398404,
-0.0400363915,
-0.0407899879,
0.028449649,
-0.0417769328,
-0.0422073305,
-0.0196834672,
-0.0036362363,
0.0130692488,
-0.0011142027,
-0.0117763076,
-0.0304052569,
-0.0267357174,
0.0841982812,
0.0255287942,
-0.0218080226,
-0.0199296586,
0.0894200876,
0.0267462879,
-0.0741811246,
-0.0245728754,
-0.0019610405,
-0.0082347086,
0.0244894773,
-0.0340835936,
-0.0002827214,
0.0084304223,
0.0302750934,
-0.0414967611,
-0.0081360126,
0.1249676049,
0.0082520358,
-0.0082433512,
0.0264567249,
-0.0076581398,
0.0336371772,
0.0221195202,
0.0481841937,
-0.0636265576,
-0.0073881503,
-0.0046212813,
0.0205603577,
-0.0249682963,
-0.043907173,
-0.017421646,
-0.0908747539,
0.0237727743,
-0.0000868401,
-0.059752509,
-0.0078375535,
0.0104608154,
0.0036754638,
-0.0193535835,
-0.0063204067,
-0.0183348861,
0.0122595523,
-0.0136050535,
-0.022588836,
-0.0584146753,
-0.0238607861,
0.0604930148,
-0.0465008169,
0.1188957989,
0.0286459941,
0.0978531912,
0.0279906914,
-0.0157655496,
-0.0553719848,
0.0661953017,
-0.0018958331,
0.0137536256,
0.0448725596,
-0.0189956315,
-0.0363768339,
-0.064035058,
0.0227130558,
-0.0057139266,
-0.0082701407,
0.0214024968,
0.0240149759,
-0.0170267411,
-0.02435093,
-0.0325689502,
0.014475774,
0.0343215205,
0.0453820974,
-0.0391050503,
-0.0905622616,
-0.017444592,
-0.0170747731,
0.0070557599,
-0.0457327329,
-0.0890569314,
-0.0190595575,
0.0064879181,
-0.0156522971,
-0.0627221912,
-0.0610624924,
0.0156124579,
0.0267756283,
-0.0050563407,
-0.0332504809,
0.0043675345,
0.0314356163,
-0.0049178503,
-0.0232386403,
-0.0678155422,
0.0220543928,
-0.0138578666,
-0.0669208691,
0.0430462994,
-0.09352386,
0.0216058902,
-0.021248119,
-0.0424922891,
-0.0293241888,
0.0192833412,
0.0394270793,
0.0175479483,
0.0433462448,
-0.0057377638,
-0.0536317341,
0.0041922159,
-0.0000931881,
-0.0687586889,
0.0024103946,
0.0043299207,
0.0570657179,
0.0043156985,
0.0028586991,
-0.0228990577,
0.0366532095,
-0.0395056382,
0.0160754863,
-0.0476007983,
-0.0629059374,
0.0074305874,
0.0227651205,
-0.0563810468,
-0.0189246535,
-0.0181381628,
-0.006573562,
-0.0005304355,
-0.0756257847,
-0.0051898924,
-0.0303567946,
-0.0278847553,
0.0258956347,
-0.0026342645,
0.0107661616,
-0.0441157669,
-0.0401202329,
-0.0097612645,
0.0008378933,
0.0008697338,
0.0108440127,
0.0073658591,
0.0106144538,
0.0182207227,
0.0067012249,
0.0260355435,
-0.0338642187,
0.0408947803,
0.0105209202,
0.0274963789,
-0.0347558856,
-0.0611290671,
0.0035765532,
0.0592516623,
-0.0380783156,
-0.0441589616,
0.0289209113,
0.0278385896,
0.0263804439,
0.0111807184,
0.0373818278,
-0.0363520533,
0.0192924608,
-0.0063475501,
0.0118762432,
0.0064662374,
-0.0484155156,
-0.03339874,
0.0280262288,
-0.0220485665,
-0.0327156335,
0.0203111526,
0.0036722217,
0.0406014025,
-0.0105945254,
-0.0412072577,
-0.0664574802,
-0.0042139338,
0.0233909525,
0.0146935489,
-0.0342013426,
-0.0116350073,
-0.0886713639,
-0.0313309729,
0.0050643031,
0.064501524,
-0.0115338545,
-0.0390408076,
0.017327467,
-0.0053858864,
-0.004958028,
0.0325516947,
-0.0643025637,
0.0314572118,
-0.037295524,
0.0122151794,
0.0003012645,
-5.294537493e-33,
-0.029309595,
0.0006492847,
0.0395832993,
0.0220877845,
-0.0551408567,
-0.027309617,
-0.0376394428,
-0.0054121865,
0.0112219444,
-0.0030149678,
-0.0104520181,
0.0060774893,
-0.0024496631,
0.0049033603,
0.0005049569,
-0.0129209496,
0.0612947233,
0.0184412766,
-0.0187031906,
0.0373468325,
0.0206368789,
0.0007346977,
0.0171153657,
-0.1024906039,
-0.0221239235,
-0.0371604115,
-0.0317976996,
0.0010784619,
0.0403084382,
0.0592821538,
-0.0030346049,
0.0038045815,
-0.0021742121,
0.0001654274,
-0.0042418116,
0.0229435991,
-0.0550749041,
-0.0091249868,
-0.0037933099,
0.0170875676,
-0.0018897352,
-0.0487645492,
-0.0137919802,
-0.0117498823,
0.0165630318,
-0.018498702,
0.0504662618,
-0.0206264779,
0.0397444405,
0.0234056786,
-0.073638238,
-0.0068558427,
-0.0493660942,
-0.0533675142,
-0.0063967756,
0.0468633026,
-0.006960223,
-0.0126220128,
-0.0499481447,
0.0482969172,
-0.0183775183,
-0.0165124051,
-0.0010121275,
0.0505920388,
0.0451568961,
0.0784237385,
0.0598801821,
0.0422901437,
-0.0312214587,
0.0055374955,
0.0332776085,
0.0634146407,
0.014754287,
0.0706528425,
-0.0246579666,
-0.0441123582,
-0.0005184271,
0.0274507571,
0.0702795684,
0.0031547656,
0.037004564,
0.0344842747,
-0.0383309089,
0.0167563595,
-0.0173061583,
0.0404492952,
0.0046181055,
-0.0546459667,
0.012644643,
-0.0114633832,
-0.0467614159,
-0.020053912,
0.0106112203,
-0.0499847941,
-0.0006009769,
-0.0017013202,
-0.0457023829,
0.0113842469,
-0.0103676086,
0.0105188861,
-0.0086028278,
-0.0324055701,
0.047766421,
-0.0153966257,
0.0388012938,
0.060519129,
-0.03066363,
0.062472228,
-0.0431647003,
-0.0222162884,
-0.0123754228,
0.0395272933,
-0.0212539956,
0.0232228991,
-0.0077774017,
-0.0130956881,
-0.0440779701,
-0.0254591648,
-0.0009582406,
-0.0099506536,
-0.0201977473,
0.0080698831,
-0.0045924718,
-0.0140567552,
-0.0269584972,
0.0097412039,
-0.0890629888,
0.0437423289,
0.0339614302,
-0.0349195004,
-0.0079926066,
-0.016767107,
2.825e-7,
-0.0497314073,
0.0176372137,
0.003775582,
0.0426507927,
0.031614773,
0.0585747845,
0.0008840895,
0.0296872873,
0.015547853,
-0.0287562236,
0.0362307467,
0.053689234,
0.0374761969,
0.011043353,
-0.0981372148,
0.0108843548,
-0.0013665362,
-0.0106982673,
-0.0260655098,
0.0076548508,
0.0791281909,
0.0714581758,
0.0557733513,
-0.0069254357,
0.0306269657,
0.0452129394,
0.0286942776,
-0.0579956435,
-0.0242998321,
0.0333643705,
-0.0189574268,
-0.0048125889,
-0.0229264498,
-0.0003619368,
0.0097221946,
0.0113965329,
0.0091272891,
0.0534199104,
-0.0303474795,
0.0117525402,
0.0051588831,
0.0017093866,
-0.024858905,
-0.006916055,
0.0315709636,
-0.0085755736,
-0.0347914509,
-0.0452253334,
-0.0267457981,
0.0022929697,
-0.0186291728,
-0.0268243905,
-0.0580986701,
0.0040386608,
-0.0091109006,
-0.0205513779,
0.0079941079,
-0.0677260533,
-0.0012261695,
-0.0224774387,
-0.0596641041,
-0.0340041444,
-0.0291298199,
0.005125931,
0.014508632,
-0.020491818,
0.0474967137,
1.976410539e-34,
-0.0310869701,
0.0575835072,
-0.018139055,
0.0168098509,
0.0500247218,
0.0218377691,
0.0555998869,
0.0404518843,
0.0523747616,
-0.046554286,
-0.0132380398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17961v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17961v1 | NormTab: Improving Symbolic Reasoning in LLMs Through Tabular Data Normalization | 2024-06-25T22:40:03 | 2024-06-25T22:40:03 | Md Mahadi Hasan Nahid, Davood Rafiei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR | In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
capabilities in parsing textual data and generating code. However, their
performance in tasks involving tabular data, especially those requiring
symbolic reasoning, faces challenges due to the structural variance and
inconsistency in table cell values often found in web tables. In this paper, we
introduce NormTab, a novel framework aimed at enhancing the symbolic reasoning
performance of LLMs by normalizing web tables. We study table normalization as
a stand-alone, one-time preprocessing step using LLMs to support symbolic
reasoning on tabular data. Our experimental evaluation, conducted on
challenging web table datasets such as WikiTableQuestion and TabFact,
demonstrates that leveraging NormTab significantly improves symbolic reasoning
performance, showcasing the importance and effectiveness of web table
normalization for enhancing LLM-based symbolic reasoning tasks. | [
0.0261214729,
0.0556321517,
-0.039047949,
0.0148973046,
-0.053517133,
0.043960128,
0.0019634133,
0.0320287533,
0.0226896144,
-0.030487081,
0.0117782522,
-0.0266424492,
-0.0126315197,
0.0312022045,
0.0116162049,
0.0175896864,
0.0508345813,
-0.0196599402,
-0.0143115381,
0.0262827445,
-0.0102652647,
0.0024281838,
-0.0148476036,
0.0093600713,
0.0057475297,
-0.010181048,
-0.0019706367,
0.0051256791,
-0.0018084141,
-0.0108970795,
-0.0262541473,
0.0547695644,
0.0033259296,
0.0061850962,
0.0000021086,
-0.0250680204,
-0.0516708456,
-0.0206825081,
-0.0101892669,
0.0112791751,
0.0175776724,
-0.0311068948,
-0.0231341626,
0.0364687778,
-0.0368778668,
0.007841222,
0.0059279166,
0.009731451,
0.0318455212,
0.0508662947,
-0.0012497393,
-0.0365049504,
-0.0108464668,
0.0539572313,
0.052035857,
-0.0039168745,
-0.017999785,
0.0490621515,
0.0128541468,
-0.0571512841,
0.0406083874,
0.0407193005,
0.0394948907,
-0.0223562494,
-0.0212907642,
0.0318823345,
-0.0402773395,
0.0102337189,
0.000045381,
0.0611593127,
0.0171822496,
-0.0271273591,
0.0366047323,
0.0160236806,
0.0127292778,
0.0103743002,
-0.0505835749,
0.0497919582,
-0.0250463597,
0.0019696041,
0.0326739028,
-0.01931029,
0.016653223,
-0.006924097,
-0.0658473521,
0.0984633267,
-0.0046475041,
-0.0222676918,
-0.0349082835,
-0.0573639125,
-0.0177048873,
-0.0606710017,
0.0431753844,
0.0893474817,
-0.0081873424,
0.0395573713,
-0.0160114206,
-0.0204593036,
0.0400629155,
-0.0565716401,
0.0402924158,
0.0733580962,
0.0097629987,
0.0233336445,
-0.0355131142,
0.0491832346,
0.0047677746,
0.0558783934,
-0.0542176142,
-0.0183631293,
-0.0621913448,
-0.0158052165,
-0.0264236536,
0.037795227,
-0.0385890603,
0.0127833365,
0.0271808021,
0.0378452241,
-0.0057004378,
0.0589404404,
0.0187851992,
-0.0207678471,
0.0208324399,
-0.0090244487,
-0.0149378367,
0.0105424253,
-0.0300426725,
-0.0294310618,
-0.0322836898,
-0.0661819875,
0.0057582092,
-0.0226782151,
0.0105987322,
-0.0122035192,
0.0438566357,
0.0988170132,
-0.0156475306,
0.0360312685,
-0.0621683002,
-0.0497329757,
0.0108613735,
-0.0485911928,
-0.0128763579,
-0.0706671253,
0.027641369,
0.0590318739,
-0.0256482773,
-0.0496806316,
0.0155733451,
0.0442068242,
0.0065270835,
0.0545966178,
-0.0108804768,
0.0288222805,
-0.0004296645,
-0.0062499973,
-0.0351005979,
0.0549460091,
0.0539144836,
0.010011605,
-0.0181848221,
-0.0158247817,
-0.0180128403,
0.0434127748,
0.0038088709,
-0.016644476,
-0.0740788579,
0.0416880846,
0.0412144028,
0.0307979472,
-0.0148350038,
0.0417276248,
-0.0027653058,
0.0245167911,
0.0182531718,
0.0831784904,
-0.0041703526,
0.0419669114,
-0.0018739292,
-0.0170697756,
0.0362314135,
-0.0084491149,
-0.0499520414,
0.0295241326,
-0.0445788912,
-0.0045515979,
-0.0318484828,
0.0581261851,
0.003858452,
-0.0605754703,
-0.0415981971,
0.0077222441,
0.0182534866,
-0.0103378128,
0.0301526655,
-0.0197820608,
-0.0081032589,
0.0508686826,
0.0220512208,
-0.0807047859,
-0.0207244605,
-0.0114861345,
0.04114132,
0.0661915019,
0.0614307933,
-0.0501562059,
-0.0458687469,
-0.0124307796,
0.0005652482,
-0.0167613719,
0.0296814702,
-0.0396720096,
-0.0445606187,
-0.0154634109,
-0.0289660208,
0.0420369357,
0.0076797809,
-0.0074179498,
-0.005601244,
0.0019567043,
0.0240187179,
-0.0950555205,
-0.0350624137,
0.0271283854,
0.0176466387,
0.0172543582,
-0.0242587905,
0.0208157003,
0.00388622,
0.0277854726,
0.0056462022,
0.0375759602,
0.0090508508,
-0.0486545786,
0.0008137667,
-0.0072953454,
-0.0276709218,
-0.0105587896,
0.0758352876,
0.0020041368,
-0.0324409939,
0.019447282,
-0.0310791004,
-0.0249145832,
0.0405038111,
-0.0078716436,
-0.0123358415,
-0.0060405168,
0.0127559993,
-0.0175580103,
-0.0299509782,
-0.0097264145,
0.0580290668,
-0.0196990781,
0.0112903006,
0.0236247741,
-0.0579362623,
0.0232909657,
0.0324786827,
0.0399581753,
0.0389455259,
-0.0179386325,
0.0242883209,
-0.0180348158,
0.0274901018,
-0.051079046,
-0.0063930554,
-0.0834673271,
0.0303312205,
-0.0226476602,
0.0463108532,
0.046841681,
0.0223481115,
0.001803365,
-0.0108740423,
-0.065699704,
-0.0079457425,
0.0038117145,
-0.007842646,
0.0653132498,
-0.0196102448,
-0.0624578781,
-0.0097403768,
-0.0052835322,
-0.0650773719,
0.0193027239,
-0.0087046698,
0.0031887365,
0.0002935267,
-0.0013520415,
-0.0199904442,
0.0064084805,
0.0073841186,
-0.0218746085,
0.0008804672,
-0.0451713651,
0.0209821519,
0.0437821671,
-0.0305715278,
0.0171423499,
0.0333041959,
-0.0165714063,
-0.0738107339,
-0.004539995,
0.0608315617,
0.0242005475,
-0.0079868548,
-0.0866655707,
0.0102468869,
0.0840604007,
-0.0310196057,
0.0054442538,
-0.0122283557,
0.0185657423,
-0.0076518129,
0.0394893102,
-0.0682566315,
0.037285585,
-0.007800058,
0.0426704139,
-0.0175488275,
-0.0409814604,
0.0486589633,
-0.0359201841,
0.0126761971,
-0.0402105302,
-0.0052587176,
-0.0417530648,
0.0950826779,
-0.0268139485,
0.012108881,
-0.0224109422,
-0.0542135723,
-0.0423508473,
0.0029484793,
0.0183660202,
-0.0494536497,
0.112366803,
-0.0618336461,
0.0163164902,
-0.0244692117,
-0.0091095874,
-0.0300163291,
-0.0049434914,
-0.0190771017,
0.0158764739,
0.0128536718,
-0.0054903068,
-0.0050141187,
-0.0030774546,
0.0315114968,
0.0369235091,
0.0027392139,
-0.0112712327,
-0.0269290078,
0.0122306775,
0.0011801569,
-0.0230114143,
-0.0084706377,
0.0136582693,
0.018074153,
0.048271589,
0.0221209172,
-0.0419009663,
-0.0070887771,
0.0255651362,
0.0175848231,
-0.0483018756,
-0.0119883977,
0.0607000776,
-0.0219825525,
-0.0639658794,
0.0121772764,
0.1125044748,
0.0672201514,
0.0072660809,
0.0097444719,
-0.0325210802,
0.0079278275,
0.029163586,
0.0484960824,
-0.1008513942,
-0.0264094453,
0.0180199686,
-0.0092717689,
0.0182921458,
-0.050662227,
-0.0166552961,
-0.0744473562,
0.0033415679,
0.0134703685,
-0.0399606153,
-0.0527043901,
-0.0213908236,
-0.0058692307,
-0.0010486321,
0.0348851085,
0.1008149534,
-0.0227342043,
0.0095442822,
0.0128048966,
-0.0645082891,
-0.0438430198,
-0.0032365951,
-0.0459769964,
0.0347517394,
0.0227361377,
0.0204017181,
0.0014846579,
-0.0361934379,
0.023824187,
0.0319471136,
0.0129279578,
-0.0496930033,
-0.0064540007,
0.0415205285,
-0.0015891467,
-0.0266902689,
-0.001227491,
-0.065914847,
-0.0059046964,
-0.0002429246,
0.0932439566,
-0.041520346,
-0.0013958943,
-0.0075176801,
-0.0634871051,
-0.0346376151,
0.0632722527,
0.0315510705,
0.0125114955,
-0.0632830486,
-0.0607278347,
-0.0923530608,
-0.0297944918,
0.0249910355,
0.0169290602,
0.020177966,
-0.0213030279,
-0.061066106,
-0.0137365023,
0.073182866,
0.037383236,
-0.0005848209,
0.007165086,
-0.0196948256,
-0.0187098943,
-0.0771856606,
-0.0156761073,
-0.0622420236,
0.0373803303,
0.0153326234,
0.0037899052,
-0.0082745198,
-0.0444508307,
-0.0196119938,
-0.0025378016,
-0.0257788561,
-0.0369216204,
-0.0332890823,
0.01704094,
0.0285014566,
0.0035114971,
-0.0018289688,
-0.0281843543,
-0.0357576311,
0.0067914124,
-0.0644034818,
-0.0556026325,
-0.0013270105,
0.0101709208,
0.0406852551,
0.0316316895,
-0.0238692909,
-0.0069321352,
-0.0271335561,
0.0436740443,
-0.0022283522,
0.0599089377,
0.0390438326,
0.0733406022,
-0.0491324998,
0.0440348722,
-0.0588037223,
0.0114030959,
0.0376463048,
-0.0655908361,
-0.0564560518,
-0.0062780106,
0.0544772074,
0.0012885586,
0.0036788455,
-0.0081453733,
-0.031323228,
-0.0034877288,
0.0374740064,
-0.0064175036,
0.0488174297,
0.0336972028,
0.0172302164,
0.0532381125,
-0.0535580516,
-0.0086338334,
-0.0156178838,
0.0102843307,
0.02189699,
-0.0431901626,
0.0132783214,
0.0117072621,
-0.0186071768,
-0.0629900694,
0.0200340617,
-0.038443815,
-0.0682863742,
0.0392879955,
-0.0095033934,
0.0094449688,
0.0418550856,
0.0270475354,
-0.0210459121,
0.0023805012,
0.026104968,
-0.0026210614,
0.0326840505,
0.0093058813,
0.0380596519,
0.0118034286,
-0.009689372,
-0.0658653677,
0.0723451748,
-0.0277327541,
0.0224166401,
-0.0305547379,
-0.0246612616,
-0.0442166775,
0.0194166396,
0.0352529548,
-0.009103531,
-0.043280527,
-0.0291741602,
-0.0440102853,
-0.0564263761,
0.0268246531,
0.0548022427,
-0.0120824287,
-0.0084772417,
0.0038122255,
0.0738793314,
0.0583272204,
-0.009547947,
-0.017127227,
0.0243513789,
-0.0270228311,
-0.0396046825,
-0.0185682345,
-6.342104263e-33,
-0.0337988883,
0.0007745947,
0.025758462,
-0.0383411795,
0.0161953699,
-0.0466977879,
-0.0367006361,
-0.0129502267,
0.0131355878,
-0.012839146,
-0.025574116,
0.040558897,
0.0177510045,
-0.0275625885,
0.0440695547,
-0.0705368668,
0.0123787187,
0.0061407858,
-0.0249411948,
-0.0148158958,
0.0016489917,
0.0247333087,
0.0533287451,
0.0009194131,
0.0224788133,
-0.0034003225,
-0.0036181665,
-0.0145357372,
0.0055724294,
0.0229328349,
-0.0057354579,
0.0189322289,
0.0230515152,
-0.0071372995,
-0.0267695431,
0.0129815759,
-0.0915192664,
-0.0422798432,
0.0351649038,
0.0223063435,
0.0044425428,
-0.0409226976,
0.0547015034,
-0.0184919424,
-0.0147538194,
-0.0090879025,
0.0165689848,
-0.0450815037,
0.0244497526,
-0.0262960605,
-0.0155892279,
0.0301719587,
-0.0208224691,
0.0361298062,
0.03102169,
0.0024453739,
-0.0020501909,
-0.0276986659,
-0.002420238,
0.0103743821,
0.0322757624,
0.0315740593,
0.0789079517,
-0.0275751632,
0.0064608739,
0.0172910243,
0.0198105108,
-0.0205455273,
-0.0469677188,
0.0367482007,
0.0034260284,
0.0249485206,
0.0417477451,
0.0026567818,
0.0408813693,
-0.0073961099,
-0.061856132,
0.0680704042,
0.0325142071,
0.0263033062,
-0.0200836826,
0.0055151093,
-0.0284456182,
-0.0089023383,
-0.0231886022,
0.0069782957,
-0.0392700695,
-0.0304346513,
0.0213759094,
-0.043788299,
0.0028465968,
-0.0263952632,
0.0037335805,
-0.0229579657,
-0.0548480302,
0.0561437272,
0.0216648187,
0.0118691009,
0.0016911657,
0.0068674064,
-0.0007093783,
-0.037554618,
-0.0056317891,
-0.0344476178,
0.0516470894,
0.0672859773,
0.0076766065,
0.0382885821,
-0.0748257339,
-0.0109477928,
-0.0670128316,
0.0081117302,
0.0233766064,
0.0124828974,
0.0347108655,
-0.0016879342,
0.0121231629,
0.0181274693,
0.0157389808,
-0.016350545,
-0.040762376,
0.0380325802,
-0.0150288474,
0.011435437,
0.0030407086,
-0.0109776538,
-0.0465926453,
0.0255467687,
0.0389960594,
-0.028311016,
-0.0027451068,
0.0164294299,
2.78e-7,
0.0630562827,
0.0384395644,
0.0239178389,
0.0535012595,
-0.0100903371,
-0.0017078588,
-0.0219681319,
-0.0336125381,
-0.0191384517,
-0.0461882576,
0.0299538653,
-0.0012517581,
0.0379038937,
0.0533090718,
-0.0247516502,
0.0055877981,
-0.0453942567,
-0.0380967893,
-0.0457732789,
0.0463034511,
0.0617955402,
0.038697321,
-0.01954736,
-0.0328903534,
-0.0035578599,
-0.030234335,
-0.019771548,
-0.0564916432,
0.0564075895,
0.0243938304,
0.0289320163,
-0.0454056971,
0.0281869266,
0.0405511111,
0.0034169129,
0.0147067178,
-0.0142649217,
0.0595966354,
-0.0159429125,
0.0713055655,
-0.0062231729,
-0.1333393455,
0.0125023099,
-0.0788890868,
0.1120581552,
-0.0064080069,
0.0104259029,
0.0624051839,
-0.0082079889,
-0.0173821524,
-0.0298228376,
0.0070517892,
0.0153712211,
0.0578597561,
0.0067404807,
-0.0251908153,
0.0291776173,
-0.0542685278,
-0.0422249883,
0.025858853,
-0.0087019317,
-0.0163243692,
-0.0211631283,
-0.0093426872,
0.0069427211,
-0.0482132882,
-0.0252190679,
3.068848867e-34,
0.0462592356,
-0.0225286521,
0.0392224416,
0.05904001,
0.0635938197,
-0.0048000454,
-0.0317766182,
0.0047386009,
0.0054362882,
-0.0935608745,
-0.0096726269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17947v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17947v1 | Do they mean 'us'? Interpreting Referring Expressions in Intergroup Bias | 2024-06-25T21:47:53 | 2024-06-25T21:47:53 | Venkata S Govindarajan, Matianyu Zang, Kyle Mahowald, David Beaver, Junyi Jessy Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | The variations between in-group and out-group speech (intergroup bias) are
subtle and could underlie many social phenomena like stereotype perpetuation
and implicit bias. In this paper, we model the intergroup bias as a tagging
task on English sports comments from forums dedicated to fandom for NFL teams.
We curate a unique dataset of over 6 million game-time comments from opposing
perspectives (the teams in the game), each comment grounded in a non-linguistic
description of the events that precipitated these comments (live win
probabilities for each team). Expert and crowd annotations justify modeling the
bias through tagging of implicit and explicit referring expressions and reveal
the rich, contextual understanding of language and the world required for this
task. For large-scale analysis of intergroup variation, we use LLMs for
automated tagging, and discover that some LLMs perform best when prompted with
linguistic descriptions of the win probability at the time of the comment,
rather than numerical probability. Further, large-scale tagging of comments
using LLMs uncovers linear variations in the form of referent across win
probabilities that distinguish in-group and out-group utterances. Code and data
are available at https://github.com/venkatasg/intergroup-nfl . | [
0.0362188779,
0.0376335308,
-0.0231784917,
0.0131481653,
0.0133059295,
0.044269871,
-0.0232793726,
-0.0116231861,
0.0038415061,
-0.0970732793,
-0.0371561274,
-0.0242907088,
0.0385512821,
-0.027699057,
0.0507675745,
-0.0378563739,
0.0212653913,
0.0139768394,
0.0627828315,
-0.0529590771,
0.0350790471,
0.0094431294,
-0.0177984908,
0.0545456149,
-0.0797432438,
0.0239688661,
0.0546194054,
-0.0126828523,
-0.0199972875,
-0.0332504585,
0.030654883,
0.0318740457,
-0.0300732814,
-0.0280717369,
0.0000018626,
-0.0527144819,
0.018671589,
-0.024818277,
0.0478950329,
0.0128063681,
0.0353149362,
0.0265694354,
0.0416453145,
-0.0239157379,
-0.0374822468,
-0.0004065681,
0.066110082,
-0.0247619376,
0.0202460922,
0.0103457877,
-0.0085837236,
-0.0011244218,
-0.1032507941,
-0.0093467347,
0.0130504938,
-0.0563071668,
0.0587258451,
-0.0085905856,
-0.0869506896,
-0.0673996434,
-0.0041041807,
0.0157873221,
-0.0096314624,
0.0212811176,
0.0071038981,
0.0032592861,
-0.0265668631,
0.0134892408,
0.0016570985,
0.0001939396,
0.0691676065,
-0.0184462517,
-0.0264504924,
0.0221161246,
-0.0055213999,
0.0109395031,
0.0039295573,
0.0262741912,
-0.0211913399,
0.0076118489,
-0.0328785814,
0.0572377108,
-0.0109967217,
0.0139413504,
-0.0302442629,
0.088663429,
0.0220273435,
0.0249955356,
-0.0648750365,
0.0796256885,
-0.0280879643,
-0.0231001358,
0.0317910537,
0.0112322075,
-0.0283941366,
0.0092329066,
0.0005631473,
-0.0241238959,
0.0029352624,
-0.0389196724,
0.0379421115,
-0.0038646567,
-0.0277788192,
0.0203485191,
-0.0215742867,
-0.043248821,
0.0138338963,
-0.0447579175,
0.0287017059,
-0.0579332598,
-0.0114858495,
0.003162514,
0.0166169796,
0.0009603403,
-0.0279582739,
0.0519973412,
-0.043200817,
-0.0246909503,
-0.0577265248,
-0.0053607151,
-0.0170966629,
-0.0203936771,
-0.0171616916,
-0.0195758119,
-0.0759775713,
0.026225049,
-0.0648956746,
0.0222672448,
-0.0505083539,
-0.1064751148,
0.0225463193,
0.0245290548,
-0.0225031488,
-0.0299389232,
-0.007311068,
0.0231244024,
0.043658115,
0.0328213088,
-0.0188111346,
-0.0219050776,
-0.020887766,
-0.0389544219,
0.000714502,
-0.0510221869,
0.0237191599,
0.0155754155,
0.0127832182,
-0.0633412376,
0.0214450229,
0.0335257463,
-0.023833707,
0.0676615164,
-0.0382697061,
0.0341156274,
0.0357527621,
0.013849806,
-0.0216169469,
0.0386720672,
0.0102471514,
-0.0216886308,
0.0521181896,
-0.0093666809,
-0.0103595667,
0.0392754152,
0.0014053893,
-0.026551621,
-0.0400380529,
0.0085292682,
0.0156999193,
-0.0379186422,
0.0263298135,
0.0576128289,
-0.0022070582,
-0.0381697677,
0.0691844895,
0.0852426589,
-0.0533153005,
-0.0111524211,
0.0501310192,
0.0258207824,
-0.031293124,
-0.0216125492,
-0.0587951206,
0.0298210718,
0.0113179525,
-0.0258548521,
0.0467733704,
0.0194140077,
-0.0128694214,
-0.050334949,
-0.0066759964,
0.001864664,
0.0340312049,
-0.0066388403,
0.0411411934,
-0.0123807471,
0.0356736667,
0.0636688545,
0.0481841527,
-0.0010797094,
-0.0128801949,
-0.0562703535,
0.021391362,
0.0195874572,
-0.0225113686,
-0.0220615361,
-0.0132914418,
-0.0197910089,
-0.008962227,
0.0417616479,
0.0355826057,
-0.0014979338,
-0.0154520897,
-0.001517335,
-0.0099733714,
0.0365759917,
0.0338907689,
0.0545354448,
0.0245536063,
0.01303914,
-0.0008344058,
-0.0092944894,
-0.0249571688,
0.0170071237,
0.0017244982,
-0.01429966,
-0.0016220077,
-0.0039359196,
0.0120010888,
0.0513244085,
-0.0254797116,
0.0028145786,
-0.0154506955,
-0.0147692813,
-0.0087882401,
0.0468198508,
-0.014439051,
0.0538763143,
0.0257978961,
-0.0850648955,
-0.0735868141,
-0.0154286297,
0.0116929151,
-0.0070940484,
0.0381852612,
-0.0043678498,
0.0344942212,
-0.0242547169,
-0.0581092052,
-0.0297994558,
0.0279998723,
-0.0010797448,
0.0188551601,
0.0145344408,
-0.0126983467,
0.0117006246,
-0.0628023967,
0.0624391697,
-0.0028205346,
-0.0474859998,
0.0048980359,
0.0145948483,
-0.006308611,
0.0395385735,
-0.0300601311,
-0.0707919598,
0.0405096412,
-0.1014100984,
-0.0030451259,
-0.0046306672,
0.0030451787,
0.0158240609,
0.028702708,
-0.0300052408,
-0.0288923476,
0.0278042518,
-0.0564974658,
-0.0304838847,
0.0429252908,
0.0194337536,
-0.0020772978,
0.0343199261,
-0.0262469668,
-0.0160285793,
-0.0370603167,
0.0243636835,
0.0255994778,
-0.0483569838,
-0.0708967522,
-0.069082126,
-0.0678276345,
-0.0271034483,
0.0020753648,
0.0036419509,
0.0492903851,
0.0296611749,
0.0353005864,
0.0637266263,
0.0318116583,
0.0239225384,
0.0100982841,
-0.0718295798,
-0.0158274937,
-0.024125699,
-0.0287745651,
-0.0409322791,
-0.0365088843,
-0.0732246861,
0.0166352075,
0.0834097266,
0.0339601897,
-0.0031873451,
-0.0595912971,
0.0523788594,
-0.0563515835,
-0.0331490077,
-0.0026255583,
-0.0396966338,
-0.0250360761,
0.0210630447,
0.00192568,
-0.019823838,
0.0269061532,
0.0014617087,
0.0205798466,
-0.0032825519,
-0.0261123721,
-0.0122220116,
0.0654187053,
0.0139815202,
0.0182891395,
0.0274799876,
-0.026563216,
0.0183373671,
-0.0324064121,
0.0488376692,
-0.0092086457,
0.0355375968,
-0.0010925488,
0.0081030205,
0.0096194167,
0.0144097283,
-0.0087921107,
-0.0362663679,
-0.0781583786,
-0.0452601202,
0.0375106186,
-0.0186048523,
0.0169470739,
0.044298999,
0.0238222051,
-0.0928791091,
0.0057788901,
-0.0184654556,
0.019036226,
-0.0243800562,
0.0201874748,
0.0174963847,
0.0163807999,
-0.0370761976,
-0.0453784242,
0.0504351109,
0.0311938059,
0.0280315615,
-0.0222819764,
-0.0103448192,
0.0088393595,
-0.0125109898,
-0.007015286,
-0.0022566805,
0.0876843557,
-0.0275716539,
0.0493195988,
0.0874443874,
0.0174430255,
-0.0335449018,
0.0069983117,
0.0101321023,
0.0196374934,
0.0363853537,
-0.0031487895,
-0.0988788456,
-0.0167007241,
-0.0073540732,
0.0220871922,
-0.0114387125,
-0.0668098256,
-0.0179848671,
-0.0852129236,
-0.0133398185,
0.0110271126,
0.0289932936,
-0.0041288421,
-0.0126709864,
0.0542808995,
0.0045267441,
-0.0170201156,
-0.0070848917,
0.0182836056,
0.0457236096,
0.030453518,
-0.0644969046,
0.0047388528,
0.0294715576,
-0.0443593226,
0.0860300288,
0.0142616127,
0.0328900665,
-0.0001830529,
-0.0134706097,
0.0272450838,
-0.0224983431,
-0.0185098909,
-0.0373837464,
0.0294534396,
-0.0396721363,
0.0137063032,
-0.0052119326,
0.002207478,
-0.0373145156,
0.0265517086,
0.0197376572,
0.0203459915,
0.0159845166,
-0.0193251353,
-0.0245218389,
0.0205245018,
0.0188597105,
0.0512131974,
0.0349675491,
-0.0298599768,
0.0252489466,
-0.0667982176,
0.0205879174,
0.0169649888,
-0.0867207423,
0.0034928482,
-0.0249864142,
-0.0451997705,
-0.0079935975,
-0.031624537,
0.0296728425,
-0.0070327953,
0.0111182658,
0.0234026406,
0.0203440059,
-0.0438590497,
-0.0358901769,
0.0427537598,
-0.0530066676,
0.0302141476,
0.0554336347,
-0.0399518497,
0.057175789,
0.0332541019,
-0.0448983908,
0.0741002411,
0.007921624,
-0.02032605,
0.0492899716,
0.0620425344,
0.0184926391,
0.0031042541,
0.0227282438,
-0.0384762809,
-0.0018376929,
-0.0048027332,
0.0340138003,
0.030543834,
-0.0182609614,
0.0342994444,
-0.0060377521,
0.0370109305,
-0.0111985365,
0.0810034126,
0.0077120019,
-0.0053056092,
-0.0546766296,
-0.0528848805,
-0.0070247031,
-0.0283220857,
0.0536013432,
-0.0103800362,
-0.0234240219,
0.0084974226,
-0.0258498788,
-0.0157281663,
-0.0203323662,
0.030511193,
-0.0581247546,
-0.024585763,
0.006067934,
-0.0515119247,
-0.0226477832,
-0.0454274155,
0.0569525287,
-0.0067969305,
0.0840636864,
0.069449544,
0.0294985007,
0.0000692848,
-0.0113517912,
0.0175459571,
0.0356506631,
0.0193690956,
0.0512260795,
0.0223966036,
-0.0133587364,
0.0303892326,
-0.0138200969,
0.0118139554,
-0.0360415801,
0.0069511211,
-0.0103532244,
0.0293196533,
-0.0457933098,
0.0256546624,
-0.0323347896,
0.0341958143,
0.0005206015,
-0.0085989321,
0.0247222744,
0.0173862074,
0.0046719741,
0.000402265,
0.0093179783,
-0.0039131995,
-0.0168641377,
0.0461227968,
0.0550971888,
-0.002333279,
0.0242930241,
0.0042428966,
-0.0831912383,
-0.0407587439,
-0.0173026528,
0.0111867636,
-0.0053457464,
0.0006953392,
0.0341993272,
-0.0781227201,
-0.0340066925,
0.0190741066,
-0.0255951658,
0.0207745582,
0.0030102888,
0.0200358145,
0.0359155871,
0.0277507547,
-0.0038181816,
-0.0114607448,
0.0463538393,
-0.0532047339,
-0.0136761591,
-0.0369598269,
-6.31029759e-33,
-0.0315401368,
-0.101754047,
-0.0050076884,
-0.0036506709,
-0.0364423282,
-0.005910879,
-0.0386095718,
0.00485131,
0.010789088,
0.0362047292,
0.0047085844,
0.0150445271,
0.0135658486,
-0.0135848438,
0.0606380403,
-0.0476743281,
0.0277655702,
-0.0210793894,
0.0046814219,
-0.0053893267,
0.0284732003,
0.0188852213,
0.0286050923,
-0.1159260944,
0.0789307952,
-0.0110329408,
-0.037068624,
0.0128013911,
0.0839480385,
-0.0067476071,
-0.0134199718,
0.0366695747,
0.0276760254,
-0.049538929,
0.0058460194,
0.072185941,
-0.0092985416,
-0.0203193687,
0.0269384794,
0.0213265177,
0.0571827888,
0.0273960326,
0.0385371596,
0.0115196882,
-0.0487962291,
-0.0010394939,
0.0592699274,
-0.0292171482,
0.0706932992,
-0.0173233673,
-0.0371845104,
0.037563812,
-0.0113294823,
0.0618718527,
0.027467981,
0.0041298419,
-0.0104344571,
0.048790805,
-0.0513075553,
0.0509540811,
-0.0546581596,
-0.0036303732,
0.0224762969,
0.0439853854,
0.0417107791,
0.0178785548,
0.0613962412,
0.0601239055,
-0.0203443617,
-0.0398647971,
0.0038093729,
-0.0187018197,
0.0055608754,
0.0654092878,
0.0189928655,
0.0176983941,
0.0135140261,
-0.0286833048,
0.0556027852,
-0.0001236896,
0.0322238766,
0.0048505454,
-0.0871559456,
0.0015982548,
-0.0151421111,
-0.069728449,
0.0056498521,
-0.0848369673,
-0.0061457371,
-0.0507951379,
-0.047570724,
0.009924816,
0.047408551,
-0.0115948785,
-0.0551364049,
-0.0241205804,
-0.0112179043,
0.0006394907,
-0.0081909448,
0.0137232793,
-0.0517440327,
0.0227617435,
-0.0252184849,
0.0115575055,
0.042738717,
0.0264939759,
0.0018884963,
-0.002437281,
-0.0747432187,
-0.0082419403,
0.0230779555,
-0.0048362389,
-0.0463121198,
-0.0125098722,
0.0269299336,
0.0489001274,
0.0047590174,
-0.0269562975,
0.0275393054,
-0.000530644,
0.0262333881,
0.0057001277,
-0.0683663711,
0.0187532082,
-0.0363541432,
-0.0207150541,
0.0018732711,
-0.0065002898,
0.019754298,
-0.0222915411,
-0.02127048,
-0.0609407872,
2.542e-7,
0.0663359389,
0.0949638262,
-0.0262059849,
0.0169176031,
0.0338906161,
0.0776726156,
0.0069076992,
-0.0085779298,
0.0358818173,
-0.0330091454,
0.0066609113,
0.0428018719,
0.0171710886,
0.0541442782,
-0.0592534766,
-0.0087401774,
-0.0334254429,
0.0255300552,
0.0055871257,
0.0114342775,
0.0107530123,
0.0154553512,
0.0607430562,
-0.0043193833,
-0.0520222485,
-0.0495009571,
0.0145642208,
-0.0814161301,
-0.0204728339,
0.0533228628,
0.0147653092,
-0.0144106485,
-0.0250875317,
0.045313701,
-0.0159804635,
-0.0020920157,
0.0339919217,
-0.0499064475,
-0.0175113119,
-0.0020162859,
-0.0457777791,
-0.011213134,
0.0144629255,
-0.0180047806,
-0.0034062641,
-0.0345195234,
-0.0373715907,
-0.049619548,
-0.0469978452,
-0.0379389971,
0.0040148464,
-0.0195241291,
-0.0175045729,
-0.0195886549,
0.0218039788,
0.0335663259,
0.0073119691,
-0.0531642176,
-0.0047498932,
0.0032586162,
-0.0273130983,
-0.0272707082,
0.0001995883,
0.0361889303,
-0.0086712986,
0.0008237136,
0.0360819325,
1.980962825e-34,
0.0326328203,
-0.0016335089,
-0.009613445,
0.0292671211,
0.0641723722,
-0.0070811538,
-0.0554972067,
-0.0201256201,
0.0742041096,
-0.0004826673,
-0.0232907292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17935v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17935v1 | Sequential Editing for Lifelong Training of Speech Recognition Models | 2024-06-25T20:52:09 | 2024-06-25T20:52:09 | Devang Kulshreshtha, Saket Dingliwal, Brady Houston, Nikolaos Pappas, Srikanth Ronanki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) traditionally assumes known domains, but
adding data from a new domain raises concerns about computational
inefficiencies linked to retraining models on both existing and new domains.
Fine-tuning solely on new domain risks Catastrophic Forgetting (CF). To address
this, Lifelong Learning (LLL) algorithms have been proposed for ASR. Prior
research has explored techniques such as Elastic Weight Consolidation,
Knowledge Distillation, and Replay, all of which necessitate either additional
parameters or access to prior domain data. We propose Sequential Model Editing
as a novel method to continually learn new domains in ASR systems. Different
than previous methods, our approach does not necessitate access to prior
datasets or the introduction of extra parameters. Our study demonstrates up to
15% Word Error Rate Reduction (WERR) over fine-tuning baseline, and superior
efficiency over other LLL techniques on CommonVoice English multi-accent
dataset. | [
-0.0038060374,
0.0754957274,
-0.0040951218,
-0.0128230946,
-0.0063646515,
0.0147690233,
0.0058789793,
-0.0461251177,
-0.0068528536,
-0.0067533129,
-0.053088285,
-0.0473468229,
0.032614395,
0.0195848104,
-0.0010532161,
-0.0659690648,
0.0322353579,
-0.0364763439,
-0.0274816155,
-0.0237208996,
-0.015273477,
-0.0432790741,
-0.0283735096,
0.0166184343,
0.0114684198,
0.0099376207,
-0.0356602445,
-0.0034671912,
0.030213885,
-0.0195339974,
0.001818084,
0.0323929749,
0.0370677263,
-0.0098624304,
0.0000023612,
-0.0418973677,
-0.042472966,
0.0082348874,
-0.0671636686,
-0.015209497,
0.0253525507,
0.0244912189,
-0.030135937,
0.0222403053,
-0.0226442255,
-0.0191799123,
0.0633772463,
0.0303424466,
0.0535870232,
0.042974636,
-0.0002461514,
-0.0649995059,
0.0234608594,
-0.0378941856,
-0.0323786028,
-0.0273734778,
0.0403918661,
0.001541051,
-0.0695433617,
-0.0465459004,
-0.0379533544,
0.039162457,
0.0046793516,
-0.0100062443,
0.0023354506,
0.0062471759,
0.0140836164,
-0.0156134497,
-0.0048219357,
-0.0030593812,
-0.0079988353,
0.0001714029,
0.0100909686,
0.0298087932,
-0.0171102583,
-0.0455299169,
-0.0159427524,
0.0014978657,
-0.0076226695,
0.0007665373,
-0.0191785619,
-0.0528125055,
0.0176971368,
-0.0243733004,
-0.0538636595,
0.0120887915,
0.0132369995,
-0.0500719771,
0.0097196558,
-0.0330374986,
-0.0462521128,
0.0015985235,
0.0335452855,
0.0146541754,
-0.0016147026,
0.0297246948,
-0.0466605201,
-0.0275751092,
-0.0176772065,
-0.0102228587,
0.0297767296,
0.0436208583,
-0.0195568912,
0.0100811403,
-0.0115576955,
0.0321538784,
0.0548835993,
-0.0507941172,
-0.0183279533,
0.0385812074,
-0.0954967663,
0.0002706271,
-0.0518699028,
0.0748095661,
0.0024518091,
0.0170123298,
-0.0376181379,
0.0200441442,
-0.0150757441,
-0.0077459635,
0.0143363615,
-0.0278455094,
-0.0620956793,
-0.0033981446,
0.0193856172,
0.0439416766,
0.0281181373,
0.0539758615,
0.0050288336,
-0.0097949598,
-0.0252801031,
-0.0247448869,
0.0374187343,
0.0012306595,
0.017837299,
0.0757233128,
-0.0122831818,
-0.0339140221,
-0.0644036904,
0.0039659287,
-0.0224498007,
-0.0371214449,
-0.0175469834,
-0.0229582116,
0.0302018002,
-0.0458627492,
-0.0098726889,
-0.0936692208,
-0.0068903454,
-0.0280372594,
0.0064108875,
0.0921148658,
-0.0202139467,
0.022443166,
0.0564865544,
-0.0083788475,
-0.01688716,
0.0631094798,
0.0013642292,
-0.0372726209,
0.0101804584,
-0.0184415765,
-0.010905805,
0.0349959917,
0.0096286489,
0.0231769886,
-0.0312747583,
-0.0348831937,
0.0260812584,
0.0236294512,
0.0360627808,
-0.0169741362,
-0.0469944291,
0.04074049,
0.06845548,
0.0085041123,
0.0446107201,
0.0326625593,
0.0154320896,
-0.0245209374,
0.0319104828,
0.0099697048,
-0.0560831577,
-0.0294041708,
0.0122813601,
0.0373860933,
-0.0131231183,
-0.0064493357,
-0.0176218487,
-0.0335588865,
0.0059554488,
-0.026793953,
0.0039933091,
0.0086313868,
0.0549761616,
0.0288675018,
-0.0325410478,
0.0557266586,
0.0071785855,
-0.0638872012,
0.0251758695,
-0.0285171047,
-0.0341591872,
0.06756863,
0.0167329125,
-0.0555067919,
-0.0662584677,
-0.0446321815,
0.018471377,
-0.0211225785,
-0.0058669271,
-0.013087838,
0.0771942213,
-0.0660547465,
-0.0361968242,
0.0517301932,
0.0034705356,
0.0319346413,
0.0111420518,
0.0223304052,
0.0048758108,
-0.01691816,
-0.0244281366,
-0.0013622809,
-0.0546141937,
-0.0358801149,
0.0471190214,
0.0188016258,
0.0318702012,
0.0088642407,
-0.051885508,
-0.0272384863,
0.0134876305,
-0.0146923726,
-0.0065703667,
0.0289641581,
-0.0693455413,
-0.0006288521,
0.0790140033,
-0.0011900603,
0.0194191281,
0.0000519871,
0.0030173687,
-0.0794104934,
-0.0061723576,
-0.019884862,
0.05526115,
-0.0353102311,
0.0769281983,
-0.0003703217,
-0.0231708772,
-0.0191576593,
0.0060256091,
-0.0008275844,
-0.0344625078,
0.0096121076,
0.0109750964,
-0.0120546147,
-0.0790121853,
-0.0131430971,
0.0015243499,
-0.0160013791,
0.0215408131,
-0.000043082,
-0.005111461,
-0.0288646352,
-0.0366294235,
-0.0715230554,
-0.0104623288,
-0.0276634023,
0.0326784961,
-0.0012688198,
0.0241008475,
-0.017025508,
-0.0365139544,
0.0135908378,
-0.0025541903,
-0.0587282255,
0.0146141844,
-0.0283302609,
0.0071393638,
-0.0193026345,
-0.0035146528,
0.005023777,
0.0450954288,
0.0061605447,
-0.0580658093,
-0.0233341921,
-0.0773910582,
0.023288846,
-0.0040256903,
0.0353912413,
0.0037324254,
-0.0209731348,
-0.0577860773,
0.0141676925,
0.0578289516,
0.0457561649,
0.0035839695,
0.0119186938,
0.0434676372,
-0.0309594385,
-0.0018602848,
0.0074805133,
-0.0232558008,
-0.012999462,
0.0159490407,
0.0343122296,
-0.0351375937,
0.0219059084,
0.0093508167,
0.0107984552,
-0.0175830387,
-0.0290439464,
-0.028171584,
-0.0152648119,
-0.0474520624,
-0.0285429899,
-0.0475363135,
-0.014842405,
0.0003795728,
-0.028835129,
0.0491927192,
-0.0127013773,
0.0041056094,
-0.0721472502,
-0.0556181855,
0.0010950748,
0.0143386107,
-0.0210060123,
0.0146187395,
0.0451782532,
-0.0592335239,
-0.0315592363,
0.0041570351,
0.0565660447,
-0.0336284824,
0.0758590624,
-0.0571897365,
-0.0032024849,
-0.0128326574,
-0.0430909544,
-0.0504950285,
0.0314181633,
-0.01489098,
0.0176976025,
-0.0279411376,
-0.0114012277,
-0.0478139333,
-0.0014856308,
0.0493385755,
0.089986071,
-0.0027871132,
-0.0159773063,
-0.0053227847,
0.0323266685,
0.0284702983,
0.0606612936,
-0.0180058014,
-0.010887011,
0.0609567203,
0.0034531588,
0.0561922863,
-0.0423066132,
-0.0259092189,
0.0106292898,
0.0102646174,
-0.0323940292,
-0.0026265846,
0.0065228269,
0.0104605611,
-0.054801736,
-0.0158622134,
0.0724772587,
0.023071738,
-0.02535934,
-0.006834208,
-0.0199704245,
0.0438503325,
0.0312910303,
-0.0060715596,
-0.0453738682,
-0.0417462476,
0.0786361471,
0.0729275346,
0.0122208921,
-0.0068213022,
-0.0121095031,
-0.0809386745,
0.0282952711,
0.0362313725,
-0.0347890705,
0.0000844358,
-0.0439651944,
-0.0237060171,
-0.0430615656,
0.034908317,
0.0417311154,
-0.0342805758,
-0.0227920562,
0.0442015678,
-0.0531583577,
-0.0728794783,
-0.0090520084,
-0.0144464346,
0.0561933182,
0.0471589714,
-0.0124071799,
-0.0032289617,
-0.0191577133,
0.0722113103,
0.0052524051,
0.0366576463,
-0.0162409935,
0.0495221801,
0.0398575515,
-0.0083656041,
0.0304450132,
0.0298847426,
0.0149691096,
-0.035807319,
0.0656598434,
0.0580251105,
-0.0264153946,
0.0409592241,
0.0395758338,
-0.0397088006,
-0.0053329444,
0.0037366026,
0.0008214648,
-0.0435549915,
0.0176948048,
-0.0031586955,
0.0203598328,
-0.0236497559,
0.0114762075,
0.0147914262,
-0.0769185349,
-0.0255928021,
-0.0227114242,
-0.0024817775,
0.0145363268,
0.0436747335,
0.0545427054,
0.0077166199,
0.0006135745,
0.0339591764,
-0.0716538206,
-0.0133930938,
-0.0316446684,
0.0078317104,
-0.0815931931,
0.0053044651,
0.0689409897,
-0.0551726446,
-0.0107614687,
-0.0300466344,
-0.0252184905,
-0.0640394986,
0.054717578,
0.0285870656,
0.0134998169,
0.0962645561,
0.0051527284,
-0.0416730195,
0.073958315,
0.0296696834,
-0.0203609858,
0.0541674644,
0.0764406025,
-0.0319536775,
-0.0155573171,
0.0181629416,
-0.0456479341,
0.0219588391,
0.0009595949,
0.0165414549,
0.0157945286,
-0.0246607456,
0.0113969343,
0.0285552274,
0.0456971899,
-0.0108502097,
-0.0035974744,
-0.0421386212,
0.0808893517,
0.0355215371,
0.0337850861,
-0.0227011722,
0.0246364046,
-0.0013301936,
0.0370599814,
-0.0014037594,
0.0233599711,
0.0045949845,
-0.0300723761,
0.001546227,
0.0321775228,
-0.0019370605,
0.0476051755,
0.0417267866,
0.0282953698,
-0.0243985392,
0.0371117294,
0.0409940481,
0.0095834117,
0.0036846602,
0.0276846085,
0.0090541262,
0.0192510746,
-0.0486256815,
0.0259031951,
-0.0361168087,
-0.0331315659,
-0.0399228148,
0.0097473525,
0.06594906,
0.0082392739,
0.0166503806,
-0.003812898,
0.0079833344,
-0.0431070812,
0.0112984134,
-0.0120930448,
0.0184579007,
-0.0007576193,
0.0014872879,
-0.0058191954,
0.0551525354,
0.0622955896,
0.0022045593,
0.0678426027,
-0.0360908285,
0.037901409,
-0.0466219448,
-0.0219999403,
-0.014388714,
0.0029361409,
-0.0267451406,
-0.0318683051,
0.0046333303,
-0.0694441572,
0.046459958,
-0.0337095223,
0.0119492654,
-0.020268729,
0.0360968336,
-0.0117491223,
-0.0397476591,
0.0225950088,
0.018355323,
-0.0119709028,
0.0315956846,
0.0072942022,
0.0361606292,
-6.623224472e-33,
0.002343005,
0.0302606206,
0.0382934995,
0.0282505434,
-0.0713542476,
0.0043960991,
-0.0236267895,
0.0279914718,
0.0363571681,
-0.0154925156,
-0.0275749099,
0.0012016116,
0.0292191133,
0.0019705188,
0.0257435013,
-0.0039677075,
0.1045230851,
-0.0006921923,
0.0015045406,
-0.0152648808,
0.0227948073,
0.0664871633,
0.0358401649,
-0.0580850616,
-0.0420182869,
0.0794253796,
0.0017807945,
0.0143459132,
0.0307010803,
0.0480160378,
0.0182021614,
0.0298557188,
-0.0250858609,
-0.071115844,
-0.0664060637,
-0.0333215483,
-0.1071897745,
-0.0048042531,
-0.0254103895,
0.0306788273,
0.0053603961,
-0.0422319807,
0.0282859374,
0.0197135732,
-0.0326032415,
-0.0166647304,
0.0158953052,
-0.0705501884,
-0.0523580387,
-0.0292552877,
-0.014838893,
0.0373467766,
0.016128758,
-0.0278324429,
0.0485907122,
-0.006926544,
-0.0111467224,
-0.0745299086,
-0.0873370618,
-0.0042480114,
0.0581081547,
0.0458451286,
0.0057636807,
0.016401764,
-0.0010087632,
0.016830273,
0.027388569,
-0.0211887546,
0.0392528884,
-0.0286048446,
0.0249151997,
0.0015992337,
-0.0172859076,
0.0033578759,
0.0462274514,
-0.0734418184,
-0.0194692127,
-0.0042602923,
-0.0335777812,
0.0617450364,
-0.0174744315,
0.036782831,
0.021195177,
-0.0087149832,
-0.0672034025,
0.0394271947,
-0.0371898077,
-0.0028855389,
0.0609019212,
0.0488514602,
-0.0171033125,
-0.0251073595,
0.0410045311,
-0.0185324065,
0.0214876384,
0.009925195,
-0.0008756515,
0.0017571296,
-0.0016885127,
-0.0037432837,
-0.0075350474,
-0.0281788781,
0.0135057224,
0.0391289145,
0.0039357892,
-0.0463282764,
0.0562596992,
0.1119722649,
-0.0493553542,
-0.0033485666,
0.0208219681,
0.0294945166,
0.0404809862,
0.0440779626,
0.0354481339,
0.0202638824,
0.0133925956,
0.0483403355,
0.0519647375,
-0.0224101767,
-0.0495455936,
0.0747946799,
0.0545673333,
0.0535740852,
-0.0067077605,
0.0005505793,
0.0077556241,
-0.0363697372,
0.0121338302,
-0.0665823519,
-0.0117824879,
0.0088519882,
3.139e-7,
-0.0502693914,
0.0208249502,
0.034262605,
-0.0658673495,
0.0433561988,
0.0395589285,
-0.0349522121,
-0.0269785374,
-0.0151862977,
0.0673796833,
0.0376159661,
-0.0164423473,
0.0525201745,
0.0026149598,
-0.1041222811,
-0.0263886768,
-0.0047829556,
0.0265355725,
-0.0160146337,
-0.0013917775,
-0.0260768738,
0.0745787993,
-0.0077281124,
-0.0251417328,
0.0037508346,
-0.0240806788,
0.054505948,
0.0242390782,
0.0399204828,
-0.0312261116,
-0.0335992314,
0.0424221605,
-0.0165071972,
0.0296306815,
-0.0578233711,
0.0181753729,
-0.0213969592,
0.0508393422,
-0.0444666371,
-0.0288656,
0.0367628857,
0.0485913455,
-0.0204233695,
0.0317928754,
0.0516564138,
-0.0539454892,
0.0118640773,
-0.0190692861,
-0.0464281514,
-0.0099954028,
0.0078817345,
0.0081243394,
0.0305311456,
0.0170664713,
-0.0018565687,
0.0547017194,
-0.0304643437,
-0.0626762956,
0.0328896157,
0.0267900787,
-0.0202687476,
-0.0218275618,
-0.0391002186,
-0.0124940844,
0.0292108431,
-0.0652380362,
0.0218095034,
2.749873654e-34,
0.0105550727,
-0.0571407788,
0.0411259718,
0.0554313064,
-0.0128157195,
-0.050433442,
-0.0048785335,
0.0225700289,
0.0150480708,
-0.0703708977,
-0.0459950827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17926v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17926v1 | FASA: a Flexible and Automatic Speech Aligner for Extracting High-quality Aligned Children Speech Data | 2024-06-25T20:37:16 | 2024-06-25T20:37:16 | Dancheng Liu, Jinjun Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) for adults' speeches has made significant
progress by employing deep neural network (DNN) models recently, but
improvement in children's speech is still unsatisfactory due to children's
speech's distinct characteristics. DNN models pre-trained on adult data often
struggle in generalizing children's speeches with fine tuning because of the
lack of high-quality aligned children's speeches. When generating datasets,
human annotations are not scalable, and existing forced-alignment tools are not
usable as they make impractical assumptions about the quality of the input
transcriptions. To address these challenges, we propose a new forced-alignment
tool, FASA, as a flexible and automatic speech aligner to extract high-quality
aligned children's speech data from many of the existing noisy children's
speech data. We demonstrate its usage on the CHILDES dataset and show that FASA
can improve data quality by 13.6$\times$ over human annotations. | [
-0.0487930141,
0.0918982476,
0.0295730419,
0.0281372312,
0.005642016,
-0.0091560995,
0.032152947,
-0.0465188883,
-0.068489112,
0.0548242405,
-0.0614321902,
-0.0502847955,
0.0762623698,
-0.0226770807,
-0.0071440418,
-0.0695271268,
0.0268419944,
-0.0233334042,
0.0245112833,
0.0071112625,
0.0194209963,
0.0185328573,
-0.0335989073,
0.025532987,
-0.0526862256,
-0.0365913808,
-0.0141400648,
0.0328656621,
0.0475027263,
0.0156084625,
0.0125666512,
0.0007459343,
-0.0106707951,
0.0708453357,
0.0000016286,
-0.0134808701,
-0.0022606447,
0.0216676276,
-0.0753996149,
0.0203163233,
-0.0003468308,
0.0096408203,
-0.0472389534,
0.0328874066,
-0.0063861185,
-0.0160987489,
0.0773068592,
0.0073335995,
0.0409200899,
0.0537635162,
-0.0059780842,
-0.0134779811,
0.0257218927,
0.0002008172,
-0.0464719646,
-0.0145982169,
-0.0026594298,
0.0157108735,
-0.0104244426,
-0.067582421,
0.031780567,
0.038054496,
-0.000897722,
-0.0391282216,
0.0206986312,
-0.0418303423,
-0.0650211349,
-0.052478198,
-0.0167127028,
0.0911961719,
0.0008780344,
0.0042435885,
0.0180390421,
-0.0325945131,
-0.0232924782,
-0.0185861047,
-0.0262028426,
0.0254475679,
0.0137039591,
0.0220070612,
-0.0117960628,
0.0034393065,
0.0389485769,
-0.0367854647,
0.0156855043,
0.0263539683,
-0.000647292,
-0.0349667445,
0.0049580135,
0.0064946553,
0.0200817976,
-0.0175525974,
0.0288365688,
-0.0066600447,
-0.0461665131,
-0.0074144877,
-0.1069415435,
-0.0537047498,
-0.0300096199,
0.0051964084,
-0.0104178796,
0.0085121244,
-0.052194275,
0.022032775,
0.0518204793,
0.0553387552,
-0.0423761271,
0.0273945276,
-0.0121772792,
-0.0278544333,
0.03977127,
0.0275173597,
0.0074829273,
-0.0063469438,
-0.0029124699,
-0.0106917853,
-0.0622860678,
0.0177018344,
-0.0402535647,
0.0543564484,
0.0462645441,
0.0252925064,
-0.0468891039,
-0.0367945507,
0.0243608002,
0.0708948448,
0.0046759308,
0.0357860364,
0.0395136774,
-0.0479194671,
-0.0085716825,
0.037426427,
0.0765775591,
0.0118962098,
0.0005134686,
0.0208940469,
0.0114025157,
0.0413919128,
-0.0179450605,
0.0410340354,
-0.0294033568,
-0.0462325364,
0.0092923362,
-0.0479848087,
0.034605626,
-0.0243263748,
-0.0283672363,
-0.067196928,
-0.0163514297,
-0.0383018814,
0.0230092686,
0.0148153612,
-0.0545026287,
0.0306533817,
0.0081215715,
-0.0354879498,
0.0130622797,
0.0305761229,
0.0773182362,
-0.0450853333,
0.0147161316,
-0.0326478109,
-0.0402409546,
0.0970781147,
0.0014545189,
-0.0077172974,
-0.0071248426,
-0.0211930033,
-0.0198246092,
0.0616700538,
0.0634513721,
0.0244252719,
0.0169743616,
-0.002481391,
0.0721408576,
0.0315275453,
0.018206073,
0.0310010482,
-0.0097753899,
0.0282653514,
0.0355955474,
0.0078084334,
-0.0315800682,
0.0272964183,
0.0379243717,
0.0034374883,
0.0384161361,
0.0524222255,
-0.0066091423,
-0.0259198621,
-0.030967772,
-0.0302362442,
-0.018403966,
0.0249454882,
-0.0018545821,
-0.0269479174,
-0.0362763107,
-0.0101445355,
-0.0014658194,
-0.0606495962,
0.0203738138,
-0.023318857,
0.0157586839,
0.0402165949,
-0.0163277946,
-0.0451749228,
-0.0749050304,
-0.0164265335,
-0.0436575264,
0.0425680839,
-0.0253348332,
0.0120665543,
0.0575389042,
-0.0740178823,
-0.0361916646,
0.0608093403,
-0.0069567398,
0.0004448624,
-0.0153196724,
-0.0256793648,
0.0028129995,
0.0162865594,
-0.0005687327,
0.0162277613,
-0.0259286407,
0.0078159664,
0.0203991719,
0.0674765259,
0.0572946407,
0.058018893,
-0.0091007221,
-0.0275941249,
0.0457259491,
0.0024637191,
0.0656665415,
0.0149416858,
-0.0370256007,
0.0244307313,
0.05982868,
-0.0547020175,
-0.0553671159,
0.0744194612,
-0.0034980541,
-0.0736456215,
0.0003138276,
-0.0310283117,
0.0026748332,
-0.0086451387,
0.0506971367,
0.0035802247,
-0.012707633,
0.0117132291,
-0.0025198767,
0.0286221672,
-0.031828858,
0.0159141943,
-0.0280641001,
-0.024677705,
-0.0646145865,
-0.0062694871,
-0.0082343491,
-0.0319810733,
0.0700712875,
-0.0000946878,
-0.0314763412,
-0.0526902862,
0.0134845506,
-0.0510906093,
0.051900059,
-0.0206016991,
0.01398174,
0.0271270089,
0.0197623745,
0.0052923788,
-0.0050898115,
-0.0589406118,
0.0064897486,
0.0011768633,
-0.0298849884,
0.0188228302,
-0.0361656733,
-0.0239994433,
-0.070258528,
0.012734618,
-0.007197483,
-0.0314303115,
-0.0195976589,
-0.0299582388,
0.0059263245,
-0.0061981403,
-0.03043372,
0.0279528089,
0.0111494353,
-0.0262672994,
0.0019835364,
0.0410501473,
0.010560004,
0.0715928525,
-0.0288808905,
-0.0388599299,
-0.017263364,
-0.0020938709,
-0.051032491,
0.0111904787,
0.0262313858,
0.054706417,
-0.0022408024,
0.0282212384,
-0.0192289259,
0.0266375858,
0.0218362324,
0.038792856,
-0.0371180624,
0.0207423959,
0.0215867721,
0.037859764,
0.0179875791,
-0.0518033616,
-0.0480705015,
0.0054899203,
-0.0385050774,
-0.0460101031,
-0.003926761,
-0.0547410399,
-0.0549601242,
-0.0129369861,
-0.0334869623,
-0.0059250602,
-0.0147059979,
-0.0412168317,
-0.0018986049,
-0.0238646958,
-0.0305886846,
-0.0677745715,
0.0018907884,
0.0365188085,
-0.0615837723,
0.0755926594,
-0.0121928006,
0.0122474125,
-0.0309971739,
-0.0433897525,
-0.0536561757,
-0.0100497436,
-0.0367398039,
0.0109372595,
-0.0102323685,
-0.0866370574,
-0.0406210721,
-0.0428865701,
0.0192526337,
0.0546954349,
-0.0101364274,
0.0613182113,
-0.0125537449,
0.0558902845,
0.0492554456,
0.0281409379,
-0.0024153909,
-0.0165441483,
0.0063012582,
0.0132694207,
0.0280750878,
0.0301394574,
-0.0613515191,
-0.0471318737,
0.0241284128,
0.038866885,
-0.0122861043,
-0.0061649629,
0.0674785227,
-0.0382948779,
0.0565799065,
0.0414354019,
-0.0137427263,
0.0111997323,
-0.0285425913,
0.0125521831,
0.0484261885,
-0.009759197,
-0.0633716732,
-0.0476058275,
-0.0266479123,
0.0772471651,
0.0366644897,
0.0528759547,
0.0241324026,
-0.0083704833,
-0.0437378474,
0.0155064436,
0.0368613787,
-0.0407241061,
-0.0559704565,
-0.0165521689,
0.002089683,
-0.0392568037,
0.1111878231,
0.0225190949,
-0.0034982879,
-0.0304766502,
0.0362995453,
-0.0398846716,
-0.0547843836,
-0.0278094653,
-0.0622802265,
0.1344998032,
0.0459377542,
0.0127568636,
-0.0042637107,
-0.0394485891,
0.0240831561,
0.0061182063,
-0.0548374951,
0.0385363288,
-0.0050330232,
-0.006895178,
-0.0477083549,
-0.0102325166,
0.0607875697,
0.0048912466,
0.0353144072,
0.0104977228,
0.0359780975,
0.008308108,
0.0423336513,
0.0012948355,
0.0272631869,
0.0092725521,
0.0638804585,
0.0114041939,
-0.0218222104,
0.0295572318,
0.0260391459,
0.0307958666,
-0.0291252229,
0.001109565,
0.0643772706,
-0.0203757267,
-0.0363570936,
-0.0693764165,
0.0203389209,
-0.0020234885,
-0.0129594551,
0.0247547794,
-0.0623997636,
0.0175003968,
0.0003550025,
-0.0226113051,
0.0587133691,
-0.0046484037,
0.0022016629,
-0.0629151091,
-0.0146921966,
-0.0150915803,
-0.0288534872,
0.0053315177,
0.0300249755,
-0.0865540355,
-0.0641406924,
0.0347619317,
-0.0330237038,
0.0185246654,
0.0657574087,
-0.0040639187,
-0.0125854295,
0.0267804079,
0.0234966837,
-0.0101415161,
-0.0503959432,
0.0469213091,
-0.0254234467,
0.0117609706,
0.0280803237,
-0.064328827,
0.0039738226,
-0.0389463715,
0.0043616388,
-0.0346236229,
-0.068335183,
0.0032984819,
0.0276338831,
0.0689690709,
0.0088640787,
-0.0178478993,
-0.0575524271,
0.0191706661,
-0.022725895,
0.0211916752,
-0.029328391,
-0.0287448149,
0.0164177343,
0.0307721924,
0.0097260969,
0.0253139958,
-0.0273136217,
-0.0223417711,
-0.0245422591,
0.056274958,
-0.0191202275,
0.0142464293,
-0.0035251612,
0.0298459847,
-0.0050562751,
0.0461020954,
0.0303265322,
0.0520353653,
-0.0042949105,
-0.0200415272,
-0.0011941283,
0.0284162257,
-0.0207066946,
0.0175675489,
0.0027831239,
-0.007922112,
-0.0303619727,
-0.0088011278,
0.0311765019,
-0.0123483157,
0.0579075739,
0.0208241828,
0.0178606566,
-0.020882491,
0.0124447839,
-0.0186202116,
0.024319239,
0.0017589176,
-0.0180534385,
-0.0405629575,
0.0276713278,
0.0108779008,
-0.0247054324,
-0.0102536352,
-0.0462716818,
0.0590829737,
-0.0370302275,
-0.0194983725,
0.0055178059,
-0.0378117971,
-0.0478323214,
-0.060916692,
0.034794081,
-0.0345899276,
-0.0191283301,
0.0315312147,
-0.0135999164,
-0.0232024081,
0.0284051821,
-0.01803343,
-0.0908877254,
0.0051898039,
0.043327339,
-0.0614904128,
-0.0040516178,
-0.049447991,
-0.0039112978,
-6.112127243e-33,
0.0090801651,
0.0151291024,
-0.0016604072,
0.0030935116,
-0.0499849096,
0.0377477258,
-0.009163104,
0.0259896424,
-0.0226941109,
0.0035682356,
-0.0039652358,
-0.0060294936,
0.0404066592,
0.0294022448,
-0.025405027,
-0.0406213589,
0.0792637765,
-0.0281649586,
-0.0192734171,
-0.0332029164,
-0.0019229399,
-0.0088431062,
0.0106260171,
-0.0585619472,
-0.0114750909,
-0.013735665,
-0.0284942593,
0.0081457542,
0.0288923979,
0.0705896392,
0.0404421762,
0.0103774518,
-0.0152441142,
0.0190894697,
0.0115344767,
0.0463851616,
-0.0937939137,
0.0276039913,
0.0126845585,
0.0482806005,
-0.0352531411,
-0.0228014309,
0.0766762421,
0.0005938517,
-0.0087662796,
-0.0436848663,
0.0520917289,
-0.0263282936,
0.0050419588,
-0.0319290496,
-0.0138390679,
0.0169943701,
-0.038768217,
-0.0214494094,
0.066177845,
0.0601862296,
-0.0117999166,
-0.0158694647,
-0.0729724914,
0.0186868738,
0.0496985577,
0.0640166253,
0.054890316,
0.0334571823,
-0.0131510934,
0.0421416722,
0.0575328059,
-0.0547025092,
0.011995215,
-0.020269433,
0.0063261609,
0.0202033557,
0.0149997575,
0.0217537973,
0.0375265777,
0.009694634,
-0.0569229908,
0.009131141,
0.0087995054,
0.0049887635,
-0.0354130045,
0.0200913604,
-0.0440165736,
0.0360403396,
-0.0141545571,
-0.020337848,
-0.0172654372,
0.0056081996,
0.0077662421,
-0.0209155884,
-0.0377944782,
0.0009651959,
0.0263446365,
-0.0079185115,
0.0461913869,
0.0075741918,
0.0284863133,
-0.0301668998,
-0.0190438814,
0.0010648256,
-0.0370116383,
-0.060450539,
0.0324191712,
0.0538707003,
0.0433375128,
0.0045473198,
0.0398891233,
0.0413500592,
-0.0667970181,
0.0100075975,
0.0062947604,
0.0489098988,
-0.0438122526,
-0.0006910255,
0.0664245039,
-0.0328910686,
0.0150586022,
0.0554321744,
0.0053936676,
0.0593659617,
0.0025939788,
-0.0069815177,
0.0236089751,
-0.036232993,
-0.0393280312,
0.0255039912,
0.0089976545,
-0.0087693064,
0.0224591568,
-0.0261957664,
0.0160729587,
-0.0356843285,
2.289e-7,
-0.0462582074,
0.0365614295,
0.0689742044,
-0.0265101306,
0.0425062254,
0.0146663981,
-0.0055599953,
-0.0422785543,
-0.0027731098,
0.0162262656,
0.0499926172,
-0.0429198146,
0.1033926681,
0.0352809057,
-0.066541329,
-0.0265943836,
-0.0856194049,
0.0011569122,
0.0081417998,
0.0180255082,
-0.0010864754,
0.0845322311,
0.0084249321,
-0.0572121739,
0.0248831548,
0.0172348246,
-0.045960471,
-0.0076331622,
0.0093147624,
-0.0206720736,
0.0019845779,
0.0163663495,
-0.0086556394,
-0.0092884656,
-0.0268094745,
0.0683218613,
-0.0031347699,
0.0578056835,
-0.0338254273,
-0.0406723358,
-0.02053749,
0.0143784666,
-0.0204018485,
0.002018237,
0.0460871868,
0.003649489,
-0.0011958231,
-0.0194499455,
-0.0720232502,
0.0178810041,
-0.0013652024,
0.0083610751,
0.0167542305,
0.0250033662,
0.028165577,
-0.0287583284,
-0.0382889062,
-0.0020122894,
-0.0321474634,
-0.0038906925,
-0.0429885536,
-0.0128683457,
0.0036317492,
-0.0192516875,
0.0092699304,
-0.000686431,
0.0404278226,
1.356145677e-34,
0.0054440233,
-0.046290163,
0.078837499,
-0.0121735111,
-0.0191320032,
-0.0439183787,
0.0232585017,
0.0148948338,
0.0075106709,
0.0147561012,
-0.0215520505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17923v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17923v1 | PAFT: A Parallel Training Paradigm for Effective LLM Fine-Tuning | 2024-06-25T20:11:37 | 2024-06-25T20:11:37 | Shiva Kumar Pentyala, Zhichao Wang, Bin Bi, Kiran Ramnath, Xiang-Bo Mao, Regunathan Radhakrishnan, Sitaram Asur, Na, Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable abilities in diverse
natural language processing (NLP) tasks. The LLMs generally undergo supervised
fine-tuning (SFT) followed by preference alignment to be usable in downstream
applications. However, this sequential training pipeline leads to alignment tax
that degrades the LLM performance.
This paper introduces PAFT, a new PArallel training paradigm for effective
LLM Fine-Tuning, which independently performs SFT and preference alignment
(e.g., DPO and ORPO, etc.) with the same pre-trained model on respective
datasets. The model produced by SFT and the model from preference alignment are
then merged into a final model by parameter fusing for use in downstream
applications. This work reveals important findings that preference alignment
like DPO naturally results in a sparse model while SFT leads to a natural dense
model which needs to be sparsified for effective model merging. This paper
introduces an effective interference resolution which reduces the redundancy by
sparsifying the delta parameters. The LLM resulted from the new training
paradigm achieved Rank #1 on the HuggingFace Open LLM Leaderboard.
Comprehensive evaluation shows the effectiveness of the parallel training
paradigm. | [
0.0488101691,
0.0250965636,
0.0106262509,
0.0223291386,
-0.0385594629,
0.0245424286,
-0.0273460336,
-0.0146084074,
-0.0161372721,
-0.0584242716,
-0.0560085401,
-0.0193923209,
0.0420057885,
-0.0077187992,
0.0111773619,
-0.0409964249,
0.0575884022,
-0.0023462151,
0.0007668312,
-0.0002799463,
0.0227778088,
0.0332440548,
0.0024456438,
-0.0037975099,
0.0378585197,
-0.0131891966,
0.0073822681,
0.0245596562,
0.035311766,
0.0096805347,
0.0267194435,
0.0653642118,
0.0099994056,
0.0475839898,
0.0000020418,
-0.0627609491,
-0.0340153538,
0.0200814772,
-0.0052147852,
0.0238223113,
0.0406184085,
0.0189314485,
-0.004973053,
0.0319929868,
-0.0266948156,
0.0010140376,
0.0415021777,
0.0699818581,
0.0495666377,
0.0860075131,
-0.0074410546,
-0.0557975248,
0.0364532359,
-0.0274824947,
-0.084112294,
-0.0249321684,
0.0372222662,
-0.0255678482,
-0.0136216087,
-0.007362633,
0.0064674746,
0.0077647911,
-0.0406152159,
0.056325268,
0.023923438,
0.0039142831,
-0.0393882431,
-0.0412660874,
-0.0407707728,
0.0603330061,
-0.0970495418,
-0.0072932998,
0.0155858668,
-0.0330073759,
-0.0247205868,
-0.0081022326,
-0.0250701029,
-0.0188694056,
0.0012435134,
0.066816099,
0.0516792871,
-0.0468604416,
0.0260354616,
0.0280735847,
-0.0539322123,
0.0305568874,
0.0307244435,
-0.0394837782,
0.0131658623,
-0.0364823043,
-0.0782085955,
-0.0206541177,
0.0031298164,
-0.0208490975,
-0.0545137636,
0.0208327491,
-0.0569663309,
-0.0237398241,
0.0532024838,
-0.0915495157,
0.0637378544,
0.0490325317,
0.0058354181,
0.0271429345,
-0.0267784856,
0.041463349,
-0.0148495035,
0.0286271144,
-0.0601825342,
0.0166949052,
-0.0396837369,
0.0048268507,
-0.0029386708,
0.0441493839,
-0.0705359429,
-0.0403656699,
-0.0447106212,
0.0165897738,
0.0166900605,
-0.0045281942,
0.0610538274,
-0.0178247057,
-0.0143927485,
-0.0160039905,
-0.0246609971,
0.0710852668,
0.0126876496,
0.0252942927,
-0.0524130054,
-0.035407234,
-0.001414785,
0.0068647587,
-0.0065217875,
-0.0286721773,
0.0202661846,
0.0346422344,
0.0025287685,
-0.0269947052,
-0.0511443056,
0.0205528736,
-0.0084929122,
-0.0763862506,
-0.0283422545,
-0.0488008149,
0.0436927564,
-0.0194854308,
0.0294382758,
-0.0280498788,
0.018894827,
0.0007980717,
-0.0491028801,
0.0729407296,
-0.0420761183,
0.0171116572,
0.0152374534,
-0.0202159416,
0.0446619764,
0.095615983,
0.020951394,
0.0089380136,
0.0343264565,
-0.023041524,
-0.0639968961,
0.0374096483,
-0.0178612974,
0.0059394906,
-0.0447936244,
0.0018840708,
0.0387408175,
0.0085763941,
0.0319754258,
0.0538571551,
-0.0105617242,
-0.0053708991,
0.0458657332,
0.0154143907,
0.0643359348,
-0.0026363709,
-0.0165740866,
0.0286353789,
-0.0205480307,
0.0433749408,
-0.027293548,
-0.0183793977,
-0.0563576035,
0.0377307534,
0.0587081574,
0.0848836601,
-0.005582741,
-0.0177912619,
-0.0341919176,
-0.0005926471,
-0.0456833057,
0.0018836643,
0.0456351899,
-0.0190230776,
-0.0762778893,
0.0360028818,
0.0473018363,
-0.0057357764,
-0.033247143,
-0.0251756292,
-0.0235039201,
0.0783035681,
0.0232683085,
-0.0283784475,
-0.05548447,
-0.0071203583,
-0.0403521284,
0.0346825533,
0.0431613401,
0.0228629801,
0.0171411559,
-0.0649141073,
-0.0576779135,
0.0154250106,
0.0025874958,
0.0026677095,
0.043441847,
-0.0132520227,
0.0141549157,
0.0224207416,
-0.0536523163,
0.0486173071,
-0.00253856,
-0.0265629087,
0.0223072246,
0.0052949702,
0.0676868707,
0.023493249,
-0.0035800899,
-0.0077567827,
0.0616709925,
-0.0044843503,
0.0022131682,
-0.0293146521,
-0.0144174658,
-0.0103345364,
0.0724674463,
0.030415263,
-0.0096261092,
0.0509036034,
-0.0592727996,
-0.054518681,
-0.0476924665,
-0.005341935,
0.0453339592,
-0.0331872776,
0.0659220889,
-0.0072900192,
0.0215302389,
-0.0772379264,
0.0558092929,
0.0000105668,
0.0343971215,
-0.0057216324,
0.0143984435,
0.0184800588,
-0.0294567253,
-0.0354020819,
0.0214028899,
-0.0069785826,
0.015778495,
-0.0029096992,
-0.0011647249,
-0.0551204421,
-0.0468136668,
-0.0713018179,
0.0673218668,
-0.0107008014,
0.0282436684,
0.0351245329,
0.0300814435,
-0.0075064725,
-0.0052051358,
0.0130747044,
0.0105577894,
0.0127052255,
0.0088191302,
0.0212744121,
0.0059947786,
-0.0467958674,
-0.04074331,
-0.0088062407,
0.0132304672,
0.0058153365,
-0.0250680484,
-0.0287654009,
-0.0617507808,
0.0467313528,
-0.0125915427,
0.0516883172,
0.0063255499,
-0.0173378289,
-0.0179293398,
-0.0145365437,
0.0303593203,
0.056879852,
0.0190750696,
-0.0147323282,
0.0365445055,
-0.0019057693,
-0.0320100896,
0.0066701146,
-0.0424016491,
-0.0061433506,
-0.0541774258,
0.0054225815,
0.0023417412,
0.064424485,
-0.0108924452,
-0.0022544998,
-0.0429321565,
-0.0335826762,
0.0081676077,
-0.0011193223,
0.0208584387,
0.0028699669,
-0.0255864132,
0.0062159849,
-0.0314056091,
-0.0688884184,
0.0553615279,
-0.0440455563,
0.0170503873,
-0.0744398534,
-0.0214820355,
-0.0569027551,
0.0145689286,
-0.0135768866,
0.0055369381,
-0.0349292867,
-0.0266448706,
-0.0341230147,
-0.0231826752,
0.0055511096,
-0.0207252167,
0.0357349589,
-0.0312334597,
0.0274127163,
-0.0475865752,
-0.0247418042,
-0.0319773145,
-0.0690810308,
-0.021751849,
0.0138409436,
0.0338538811,
-0.0321257226,
-0.0376533493,
0.0311577935,
-0.02415286,
0.0226190779,
-0.0122839808,
0.0163497608,
-0.0463130958,
0.0140904235,
0.067066133,
0.0138175515,
0.0134707661,
0.0113060763,
0.0006708107,
0.0119573548,
0.037698932,
-0.0268367622,
-0.0301702078,
-0.0104809534,
0.048838567,
-0.0750219077,
-0.0234878715,
-0.0121864323,
0.0064378558,
-0.0533288643,
0.0444827862,
0.1204554513,
0.0359320529,
-0.0058424524,
-0.0076826662,
0.0198567566,
0.062066067,
0.0327012241,
0.0228652712,
-0.0538119376,
-0.0365699306,
-0.0083653871,
0.0120523777,
-0.0016710021,
0.0366432555,
-0.0359760746,
-0.1214028075,
-0.0028881358,
0.0439311005,
-0.0200209673,
-0.0072063622,
-0.0595495328,
0.0057896953,
-0.0327958129,
0.0379303955,
0.0098020695,
-0.0339166783,
-0.0084982831,
0.0101083666,
0.0237932466,
-0.0517931283,
-0.0168811549,
-0.0307166558,
0.0537410602,
0.0433699004,
0.0067839515,
0.0189539194,
-0.0327290446,
0.0634151101,
-0.0179552324,
0.0121510299,
-0.0653660074,
-0.0015904038,
-0.0391601957,
0.0046954434,
-0.0191750396,
0.0075850752,
-0.0235282499,
-0.0120239882,
-0.0198424459,
0.0696180537,
-0.0102303997,
0.0198076218,
0.015516852,
-0.0032176787,
-0.03392848,
0.0414697826,
-0.0361599736,
-0.0252739787,
-0.0275094751,
0.0315205194,
-0.0309760422,
-0.0123867048,
0.0184648521,
0.0219158828,
-0.0585426651,
-0.0328964256,
-0.0209287573,
0.0315966979,
0.0376749709,
0.0171017144,
0.0304051507,
0.061596293,
-0.013926723,
-0.0047137002,
-0.0344590209,
0.0371033065,
0.0001513219,
0.0035125511,
-0.0734866485,
0.0113186985,
0.0597171411,
0.0029266763,
-0.0071967044,
0.0118701318,
-0.0658268929,
-0.092867516,
0.0029449826,
0.0293257982,
0.0165851284,
0.0576520488,
0.0074257446,
-0.0543720536,
-0.0088231936,
0.0607448928,
-0.0390360169,
0.0200483408,
0.0051503587,
-0.0340832844,
-0.0062217726,
0.0086517297,
-0.0091706607,
-0.0099465912,
0.0086318124,
0.0195136182,
-0.0106265275,
-0.0935209319,
0.0125747928,
0.0328312069,
0.0639614761,
-0.0237634387,
-0.0088596055,
-0.0513111316,
0.0551320463,
0.0245444365,
-0.0046095098,
-0.0168445781,
-0.0185883623,
0.022392856,
-0.0107175224,
-0.0040594698,
0.0232927613,
-0.0178776849,
0.0014588143,
-0.0165088624,
0.0161978193,
-0.0212753434,
-0.0412360243,
0.0155543648,
0.0184206087,
-0.014724724,
0.0510926619,
0.033929348,
0.0167311877,
-0.0343485959,
0.0275545567,
0.0181349125,
0.0496816635,
-0.0516624115,
0.0346366577,
-0.0417302251,
-0.0605214685,
-0.0399361774,
-0.0175496619,
0.0785600394,
-0.0251757652,
0.0828139335,
0.0110498648,
-0.0217183623,
-0.0163510479,
0.0157611351,
-0.0262373984,
0.0363842733,
0.024975596,
0.0106149353,
-0.0444401838,
0.0223952997,
0.0650156364,
0.0008202376,
0.0335798673,
-0.0024419264,
-0.0096623925,
-0.0461587422,
-0.0443981104,
0.0214212816,
0.0647088364,
-0.0449380614,
-0.0104492567,
-0.0035177523,
-0.0262279436,
-0.0000931169,
-0.0224476475,
-0.0071171816,
-0.0205516312,
0.035874825,
0.0179465059,
-0.0248461775,
-0.0089784861,
-0.0220948942,
-0.0409489572,
0.0241845641,
-0.0218235329,
0.006083773,
-6.887474133e-33,
-0.0468988307,
0.0095565375,
0.0000814014,
-0.0106574716,
-0.0632919222,
-0.0234631076,
0.0372545086,
-0.022038538,
-0.0193136502,
-0.036777515,
-0.0249363538,
-0.0009905412,
0.0279280618,
0.0067372289,
-0.0074182646,
0.0267379154,
0.0748298839,
-0.0011878884,
0.0192656014,
-0.0276841316,
0.0233726706,
0.0523007698,
0.0358649604,
-0.0446120128,
-0.0280794036,
0.0215384141,
-0.0204021372,
0.0170752387,
-0.0399284773,
0.0375888981,
-0.0129332943,
0.0082480283,
0.0236038491,
-0.0147961415,
-0.0232446864,
0.0174267925,
-0.060452044,
0.011901414,
0.0778970867,
0.0258640796,
0.0016320888,
-0.0096185468,
0.0561232641,
0.0072666588,
-0.0090595307,
-0.0295576863,
0.0256718509,
-0.0484226719,
-0.0318166092,
0.033285819,
-0.0562576987,
0.0433762893,
0.0117827067,
0.0087268706,
0.064250946,
-0.0303006582,
-0.0039755395,
0.0418865792,
-0.0264484622,
0.0095359143,
0.037336763,
0.0768663362,
0.0584282726,
0.0492265262,
0.0085741775,
0.0395636559,
-0.0060921442,
-0.0336435698,
0.0496573485,
-0.030262826,
0.01838989,
0.0807249323,
0.0085809464,
0.0264023989,
0.0444977582,
-0.0347943082,
-0.0647360608,
0.0222476516,
0.0043032514,
0.0096368799,
0.0219686199,
0.0576546751,
0.0045451587,
-0.0185968261,
-0.0440505408,
0.0019431156,
-0.045289658,
-0.0027612497,
0.0157696959,
0.03492634,
-0.0062910109,
0.0265521854,
0.0069342782,
-0.0618059412,
0.0221508797,
-0.0131013179,
-0.0174533576,
0.0136338919,
-0.0165476687,
0.005578767,
-0.0862689763,
-0.0816387907,
-0.0058751665,
-0.0026576568,
-0.0097605996,
-0.0238104276,
0.0280502234,
-0.0163357705,
-0.0801641569,
0.0338140093,
-0.0038854249,
-0.0012930349,
0.0136831859,
0.0711198747,
0.0434631184,
-0.0216123443,
-0.0014360111,
0.0535097271,
0.0232626405,
-0.0006833659,
-0.0236328822,
-0.0117195779,
0.002972147,
0.028088782,
0.0086151054,
0.0351312645,
0.0098934853,
0.0062155193,
0.0111309495,
-0.0245700553,
-0.0304995161,
0.0283803642,
2.837e-7,
0.0280751809,
0.0468679816,
0.0227152761,
-0.010996162,
-0.0087143974,
0.018396467,
-0.0070536421,
0.0137697104,
0.0107788872,
0.0248669051,
0.0235539172,
0.0031925722,
0.0334991813,
-0.0193716548,
-0.0890473053,
-0.0118696224,
-0.0382314734,
0.0388551466,
-0.0625109226,
0.0033825659,
0.0350501612,
0.1087398604,
0.0139166089,
-0.0146325976,
-0.0051445798,
0.024970999,
0.035676986,
-0.028202571,
-0.0070031751,
0.0570965521,
-0.0196586065,
0.0032857261,
-0.0361485705,
0.0269641783,
-0.0378036648,
0.053933695,
-0.0290708356,
0.1036699116,
-0.026758248,
-0.02087388,
0.0385037251,
0.0149213756,
-0.0230368562,
-0.0644438341,
0.075370416,
-0.0191807449,
-0.049057737,
-0.0600327253,
-0.0136487409,
-0.0192297753,
0.046433188,
-0.0185430218,
0.0064450931,
0.029532101,
0.0298984032,
-0.0071128407,
-0.0726207346,
-0.0688439459,
-0.020518614,
0.0243469644,
-0.0348394252,
-0.0332418978,
-0.0113680894,
0.0180627052,
0.0402134322,
-0.0353845395,
-0.0029623068,
3.095333306e-34,
0.0322080404,
-0.0107728858,
0.0299658291,
0.0292717218,
-0.0097444942,
-0.0213100389,
-0.0201153997,
0.05504217,
-0.0177241117,
-0.09423244,
0.0016246982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17911v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17911v2 | X-ray Made Simple: Radiology Report Generation and Evaluation with Layman's Terms | 2024-06-25T19:52:01 | 2024-06-30T21:53:56 | Kun Zhao, Chenghao Xiao, Chen Tang, Bohao Yang, Kai Ye, Noura Al Moubayed, Liang Zhan, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Radiology Report Generation (RRG) has achieved significant progress with the
advancements of multimodal generative models. However, the evaluation in the
domain suffers from a lack of fair and robust metrics. We reveal that, high
performance on RRG with existing lexical-based metrics (e.g. BLEU) might be
more of a mirage - a model can get a high BLEU only by learning the template of
reports. This has become an urgent problem for RRG due to the highly
patternized nature of these reports. In this work, we un-intuitively approach
this problem by proposing the Layman's RRG framework, a layman's terms-based
dataset, evaluation and training framework that systematically improves RRG
with day-to-day language. We first contribute the translated Layman's terms
dataset. Building upon the dataset, we then propose a semantics-based
evaluation method, which is proved to mitigate the inflated numbers of BLEU and
provides fairer evaluation. Last, we show that training on the layman's terms
dataset encourages models to focus on the semantics of the reports, as opposed
to overfitting to learning the report templates. We reveal a promising scaling
law between the number of training examples and semantics gain provided by our
dataset, compared to the inverse pattern brought by the original formats. Our
code is available at \url{https://github.com/hegehongcha/LaymanRRG}. | [
0.0326596238,
0.0697698519,
0.04039184,
-0.0080308663,
-0.0059832004,
0.016530158,
0.0300583523,
0.044964999,
-0.0607360452,
-0.0212373529,
-0.0389189273,
-0.053448271,
0.0179487541,
0.0552173816,
0.0476547964,
-0.1057390347,
0.0117679909,
0.0049078311,
-0.0065812082,
-0.0065234411,
0.0157306567,
0.0250960495,
-0.009090892,
0.0328540802,
-0.0711000115,
-0.006267868,
0.0247434638,
0.0209767446,
0.0234123711,
-0.0376102738,
-0.0365312696,
0.0519200303,
0.0217153933,
0.0116172424,
0.0000019898,
-0.0203792192,
-0.0051795887,
0.0353621058,
0.0420644954,
-0.005050221,
0.0891581029,
-0.0814994648,
-0.0122551555,
-0.0100933183,
-0.0154539822,
-0.0507804602,
0.0464903675,
0.0475497916,
0.0576882474,
0.0545061454,
-0.0279188938,
-0.0162619911,
-0.0092548849,
-0.0505453721,
0.0482215099,
-0.024717195,
-0.0102070291,
0.0239418074,
-0.0161302704,
0.0178739671,
-0.0441663638,
0.0414984189,
0.0109527791,
0.0103395032,
0.0237873718,
0.0713847727,
0.0239761993,
-0.0194914564,
0.0054188739,
0.0751728788,
-0.0028597796,
0.0183082893,
-0.0086201811,
-0.0142463967,
-0.0061240513,
0.0041199368,
-0.0644726381,
0.0518641435,
-0.0103330947,
-0.006909959,
-0.0278090276,
0.0081090499,
0.0076817428,
0.0268214699,
0.0235243905,
-0.0422680676,
0.0182069819,
0.016117394,
-0.0077872528,
0.0102848569,
-0.0044799754,
-0.0510888696,
0.0001519489,
0.0265023541,
-0.0384015031,
0.0183927976,
-0.058351405,
0.0110215368,
0.0668488368,
-0.013914898,
0.0133366343,
-0.0110492045,
-0.0576294139,
0.0454552993,
-0.0099301822,
0.001344008,
-0.0096936543,
0.0500111692,
-0.0319028087,
0.0058272802,
-0.0269341301,
-0.0118450355,
-0.0364740826,
-0.0002211722,
0.0068817884,
-0.0191086363,
-0.0876915157,
-0.0153953675,
0.0028386093,
0.0140217654,
0.0336703137,
0.077983737,
-0.1156738102,
0.0200706962,
-0.0260861907,
0.0353918113,
-0.0272716004,
-0.0056636767,
0.0418019742,
-0.0245076697,
0.0106685814,
0.037897151,
-0.0071052727,
0.0035085224,
-0.0183406323,
0.0400986783,
-0.0258247964,
-0.0025410245,
0.034138713,
-0.0790545121,
-0.0289110057,
-0.0439592749,
0.0446162224,
-0.0875725523,
0.0340748355,
-0.0042150449,
0.0149546014,
-0.0076293671,
0.003847006,
0.0066061341,
-0.0124818487,
0.0648498386,
-0.0052479994,
-0.0133484732,
0.0335883461,
0.0357722417,
0.023732448,
0.0295647848,
0.0205424,
0.0330370963,
0.0125644263,
0.0019706448,
0.0097710285,
0.0098279472,
0.0102910586,
-0.0080595994,
-0.0325504951,
-0.026409857,
-0.0197879188,
0.0899358913,
0.0632881448,
0.0535698719,
-0.0457929447,
-0.0204698835,
0.0201333892,
0.0111605767,
0.0161749683,
0.0192265045,
0.0653691888,
-0.025344152,
-0.030596476,
0.0191927403,
0.0019768062,
0.0530083254,
0.016935125,
0.0185522344,
0.0044847974,
0.0110087246,
-0.0532657579,
-0.0244063362,
0.0017195082,
0.0032933846,
-0.0063768867,
-0.0302047953,
0.0422699451,
0.0314026102,
-0.0506465212,
0.0442138314,
0.0536453612,
-0.0459061116,
0.0052323705,
-0.064914681,
-0.0109609012,
0.035841167,
0.0997848809,
0.0158700477,
-0.0315390825,
0.0127125261,
0.0329892635,
0.0696505383,
0.0256773978,
-0.0150722954,
0.0281909741,
-0.0527207591,
-0.0436354652,
-0.0039319484,
0.0109173553,
0.0301231183,
-0.0028435593,
0.0095787644,
0.0102286311,
-0.0550979599,
-0.0356623828,
0.0321641751,
-0.0304800924,
-0.0246875621,
0.0077253608,
-0.001561156,
0.0136776697,
-0.0052799019,
-0.0314311199,
0.0172454081,
-0.0005588214,
-0.0207976699,
0.007807401,
0.0132870749,
-0.0527298525,
-0.0307710487,
-0.0001255444,
-0.0807981119,
0.0087707592,
0.0017379125,
-0.0558654293,
-0.009271102,
-0.0167258196,
-0.0483860224,
0.0117115825,
-0.0456500463,
-0.0139551656,
0.0879335478,
0.0047790748,
-0.0037891753,
0.0547918454,
-0.0288757514,
0.011377519,
0.0259940289,
0.0270593744,
-0.0010450453,
-0.0446723141,
-0.0032208927,
0.0205255914,
0.0042192093,
0.0139055839,
0.0018617217,
0.0361710154,
-0.0297581628,
0.0014894814,
-0.0641607717,
-0.0215456206,
0.0228373706,
-0.0316363126,
0.0421298929,
0.0078545911,
0.025565993,
-0.019347908,
-0.0528881736,
-0.0016395779,
0.052152399,
0.0169767346,
0.0523375086,
0.0226017814,
0.0156400539,
-0.0262590684,
-0.0266027432,
-0.0001068166,
0.0137180462,
0.0371488817,
0.0012845208,
-0.0151659744,
0.0286828391,
-0.0614108108,
-0.006723308,
-0.0024540068,
-0.0732776895,
0.0476669557,
-0.0422228724,
-0.0078230118,
0.0336822718,
0.0381031409,
0.0287832301,
0.0231452715,
-0.011929065,
-0.0297604129,
-0.01413419,
-0.0540264286,
-0.0174500253,
0.0445222706,
-0.0818722025,
-0.0083278324,
0.0386196487,
0.0246476028,
0.0374531038,
-0.0297651254,
0.0004250582,
-0.0054225014,
-0.0480100624,
-0.0297708008,
0.0356542096,
-0.0151440399,
0.0196523033,
-0.0075688544,
-0.0387418009,
0.0610251538,
-0.0050274571,
0.004011048,
-0.0342217647,
0.0185851604,
-0.0041462919,
0.0489026196,
-0.0000929506,
0.0540505797,
0.0262772217,
-0.0143679623,
-0.0567617863,
0.0004726454,
0.0568711832,
-0.0425808467,
-0.0139995776,
-0.0164176896,
-0.0050297803,
-0.0267831124,
-0.0254274495,
-0.0331644267,
-0.0259486735,
0.0523788519,
-0.0004945352,
0.0021754378,
-0.0192459002,
-0.0596188791,
0.0373344533,
0.0070184744,
0.0239184443,
-0.0121340696,
-0.0388200916,
0.0091412812,
0.0754652619,
0.0475756191,
0.0200112574,
-0.0408721939,
-0.0466067977,
-0.0338311866,
0.0708560124,
-0.0112052867,
0.0320923664,
-0.0189839825,
-0.0026235017,
-0.017817378,
0.0488238074,
0.0126127554,
0.027218651,
0.0385007747,
-0.0343756974,
-0.0399208814,
0.0669189692,
0.0204136949,
-0.0062238341,
-0.0019100734,
0.0439305194,
0.0284489002,
-0.0054787174,
-0.0050017978,
-0.0362307578,
-0.0089442916,
-0.0271440372,
0.0445540175,
-0.0116603533,
0.0076512224,
-0.0022187007,
-0.0560057722,
0.0588056035,
0.0122677535,
-0.0648724064,
-0.0362517461,
-0.0156208808,
-0.0181572977,
-0.0053086714,
-0.0361426696,
-0.0069057909,
-0.016456373,
0.0036205321,
0.0378658064,
-0.0318874903,
-0.0899583846,
0.0147926034,
-0.04451897,
-0.0121545102,
0.0692969188,
0.036799226,
-0.0194679461,
-0.0387190506,
-0.0131681105,
0.0537258051,
0.0042469404,
-0.0008202875,
0.0791086406,
0.0042704483,
-0.0218666401,
-0.034192957,
0.0520461984,
0.0124132233,
-0.0015030493,
-0.0426786952,
0.0112009924,
-0.0140956352,
-0.0022670629,
-0.0821725652,
0.0591771677,
0.0254915375,
0.0444763936,
0.0065086391,
0.0003069112,
-0.0289584491,
-0.0142255733,
0.085766457,
-0.0736360326,
-0.0404476188,
0.0260631498,
-0.0639773086,
-0.0773215666,
-0.0834090337,
-0.0448250547,
0.0129503747,
0.0646844432,
-0.0414588079,
-0.0330589935,
-0.052566085,
-0.0151640447,
-0.0338522941,
0.0414735377,
0.0135138091,
-0.0123778116,
-0.0344222821,
-0.0672798604,
0.0375222452,
-0.008994434,
-0.0279773176,
0.0687617958,
-0.0645189658,
0.0080365231,
-0.0190578979,
0.0583439693,
0.0223134644,
0.0095977159,
0.0024855218,
-0.0173213221,
0.0890026167,
0.0883928388,
-0.0003640794,
0.0088005951,
0.0129812183,
-0.0143369697,
-0.0250814166,
0.0061807181,
-0.0404447503,
0.029648371,
-0.001055083,
0.046066951,
-0.0206436273,
-0.0199340377,
0.0366200954,
0.0147346584,
0.0165752117,
-0.0872292966,
0.0070102429,
-0.0357646644,
-0.0408938229,
-0.0308672953,
-0.0050108023,
-0.0555012263,
0.0160854124,
0.0337316282,
-0.0058030086,
-0.0037812614,
0.0234996267,
-0.038363684,
0.034273088,
-0.0512624495,
0.0040493379,
0.0257971268,
-0.0491344221,
0.0122383488,
0.0052425587,
-0.027565347,
-0.0386851989,
-0.0249951612,
0.0008987592,
-0.0099000223,
0.0593087748,
0.0394243374,
0.0520984679,
-0.0138760684,
0.0285850875,
0.0057513691,
-0.023739269,
-0.0730499402,
0.0220923256,
0.0344996788,
0.0227427743,
0.0190065075,
-0.054551281,
-0.0167220309,
-0.0218015723,
0.0568928011,
-0.0078588072,
-0.0165253375,
0.0475889668,
0.0021742065,
0.047523506,
-0.0321679935,
0.1156670004,
-0.0035620003,
0.0246661436,
-0.0309461225,
-0.0460138321,
-0.0570167191,
-0.0266614966,
0.0249739476,
-0.0108848019,
0.0021775507,
0.0168196335,
-0.0602719784,
-0.0606548898,
-0.0370510779,
0.0164757296,
-0.0137338713,
0.006379921,
0.0836929902,
0.0688549131,
-0.0022909169,
-0.000930028,
-0.0197660886,
0.0400470421,
-0.0123150107,
-0.0303677656,
0.0273075607,
-5.890094727e-33,
-0.0208832622,
-0.0279828552,
0.0287729483,
-0.0537797324,
-0.0017802154,
0.0399895124,
-0.0293314755,
-0.0059413263,
0.042955298,
0.0223674048,
-0.0051221279,
-0.0279699434,
0.0193370264,
0.0469821319,
0.0163120888,
0.0341902338,
0.0392194018,
-0.0236015469,
-0.0437734835,
0.0418399647,
0.0071021216,
0.0133838682,
0.0608067513,
-0.0843214393,
-0.0276090074,
0.0226693992,
-0.0372061618,
-0.0319472738,
0.0294249263,
0.0594987087,
-0.0506711602,
0.0128429541,
0.0122805266,
-0.0288359467,
-0.0232398082,
0.0012175165,
-0.084375307,
-0.0016143617,
0.0020401308,
-0.0028487339,
-0.0970471203,
-0.0004129441,
0.0373791978,
-0.0347171314,
0.0087427031,
-0.0417411514,
0.0398667417,
-0.0107522411,
-0.0231949016,
-0.0194094963,
-0.0484233983,
0.0429819599,
0.0079279216,
-0.0347039849,
-0.0206760149,
0.0060550435,
-0.0271884352,
0.0150659857,
-0.0226209015,
0.0219855681,
0.0493340902,
0.044035241,
0.0516274869,
0.0042296341,
-0.0284537878,
0.0426568277,
0.0329115205,
-0.0190765094,
0.0150436414,
0.0314829685,
-0.0232841652,
0.0598015152,
-0.0110304775,
0.0678119361,
0.0596593805,
0.0056084571,
-0.0585301705,
0.069584094,
-0.0122488132,
0.0663748085,
0.0296793636,
-0.0201696567,
-0.0276666991,
0.0043757483,
0.020996701,
-0.006866328,
-0.0174011402,
-0.0457250401,
0.0299281497,
0.0387456231,
-0.021948779,
0.0256858785,
0.0299334303,
0.010864675,
-0.0099731386,
-0.015894223,
-0.0027391356,
0.0259364378,
-0.0368129313,
-0.0319990702,
-0.0372035988,
-0.01260876,
0.0579276942,
0.0100087021,
0.0320814885,
0.0218433458,
0.0409208126,
0.0319405869,
-0.0449843928,
0.0153443813,
-0.0245431643,
-0.0192315821,
-0.0293153524,
0.0167239457,
0.027834814,
-0.0185981542,
-0.0519835949,
0.0019302196,
-0.0258922055,
0.00108042,
-0.0220607333,
-0.0815738514,
0.0058104065,
0.0218103211,
-0.0612894148,
-0.0006392267,
-0.0332904719,
-0.0626904368,
0.0929208919,
-0.0103430031,
-0.0414802581,
0.0198993832,
2.629e-7,
0.0415119044,
0.0135627082,
0.0153077114,
0.0442495085,
0.0094490992,
0.0180165023,
-0.0172584895,
0.0529555045,
-0.0254128315,
-0.0260425713,
0.0212230235,
-0.004179344,
0.0063605825,
0.0455699265,
-0.0352129526,
-0.0026970666,
-0.0601326786,
0.0173158124,
-0.0028184357,
-0.0441204384,
0.0539884306,
0.0668671206,
-0.0308713056,
-0.0673664734,
0.0258016437,
-0.010595141,
0.0665925294,
-0.0054885675,
-0.0190442614,
-0.0008930743,
0.0275030155,
0.036553666,
0.0081613539,
0.0080253175,
-0.0041070343,
-0.0602515265,
0.0580834225,
0.0435130075,
-0.024133414,
-0.0226589423,
0.0294642095,
0.0021042086,
0.0032824841,
-0.0162343103,
0.0182597116,
-0.0138279833,
-0.0087055787,
-0.0142535381,
-0.0234485883,
0.040616177,
0.0345826522,
-0.063874647,
-0.0748023465,
0.0245781392,
0.034471117,
0.0182889961,
-0.0396420136,
-0.059893325,
-0.0087284958,
0.0224074908,
-0.0306117851,
-0.0601006374,
0.0079459967,
0.0020226983,
-0.0159054417,
-0.0555042401,
-0.0450378954,
2.340498563e-34,
0.0399243869,
0.0202187207,
-0.0204838291,
-0.0272339229,
0.0124089662,
-0.0038151888,
-0.00546609,
-0.0060143569,
0.0127997398,
-0.0325972848,
-0.0457595252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17903v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17903v1 | Mapping the Past: Geographically Linking an Early 20th Century Swedish Encyclopedia with Wikidata | 2024-06-25T19:34:00 | 2024-06-25T19:34:00 | Axel Ahlin, Alfred Myrne, Pierre Nugues | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL | In this paper, we describe the extraction of all the location entries from a
prominent Swedish encyclopedia from the early 20th century, the \textit{Nordisk
Familjebok} `Nordic Family Book.' We focused on the second edition called
\textit{Uggleupplagan}, which comprises 38 volumes and over 182,000 articles.
This makes it one of the most extensive Swedish encyclopedias. Using a
classifier, we first determined the category of the entries. We found that
approximately 22 percent of them were locations. We applied a named entity
recognition to these entries and we linked them to Wikidata. Wikidata enabled
us to extract their precise geographic locations resulting in almost 18,000
valid coordinates. We then analyzed the distribution of these locations and the
entry selection process. It showed a higher density within Sweden, Germany, and
the United Kingdom. The paper sheds light on the selection and representation
of geographic information in the \textit{Nordisk Familjebok}, providing
insights into historical and societal perspectives. It also paves the way for
future investigations into entry selection in different time periods and
comparative analyses among various encyclopedias. | [
0.0591724627,
0.0051166122,
-0.0146976244,
-0.0019436193,
-0.0237176362,
0.0152775366,
0.0243367609,
-0.0066446629,
0.0446033999,
-0.0588803291,
0.0279927552,
0.0093387347,
0.0501387492,
-0.0422386341,
-0.0170748532,
-0.0373417437,
0.0136391399,
-0.0089685852,
-0.0435534753,
-0.0143202031,
-0.0490040369,
0.0495739952,
-0.0328537077,
0.0290863533,
0.0571129471,
0.0265788306,
0.0034146726,
0.010928072,
0.0215153154,
-0.0327285491,
0.016832402,
-0.0058322344,
0.0079965191,
0.0178657323,
0.0000017788,
-0.0222058073,
-0.013399832,
-0.0315536745,
-0.0081419405,
0.033338327,
0.0030031209,
0.0014394129,
-0.0082709948,
-0.0815456882,
0.0363776125,
-0.0268428773,
0.0251474977,
-0.008555118,
-0.0268905498,
0.013240464,
0.0121107632,
-0.0517607629,
0.0407899916,
0.0473405421,
0.0216983799,
0.0100543918,
0.0057421732,
0.0576406121,
0.0563375615,
0.0393606164,
0.0000919438,
0.05081762,
-0.0434091054,
0.011777509,
0.0124524841,
0.048538696,
-0.0394583903,
-0.0014770584,
0.0182606019,
-0.0184469335,
0.1108962744,
-0.0319136307,
0.0429294705,
0.0343072861,
-0.034162119,
0.0562147871,
-0.0083520161,
-0.0394839495,
-0.0356653929,
0.0050281622,
0.0315228291,
-0.018469112,
0.004771187,
0.0375945605,
-0.0129760299,
0.0861075893,
-0.0192382503,
-0.0020159425,
0.0069552725,
-0.0067330897,
-0.0051060892,
-0.0771214813,
-0.0042352402,
0.0201961882,
0.0519081652,
-0.0097607374,
0.0184811223,
0.0049284454,
0.0093791429,
-0.0224671587,
-0.0648418367,
-0.0289897174,
-0.0099171596,
0.0495029315,
0.0592182018,
-0.0125100007,
0.0189744793,
-0.0275990386,
-0.0201823507,
0.0060864924,
-0.0530153476,
-0.010476023,
0.0035322858,
-0.0009582182,
0.0190605968,
-0.0145148896,
-0.0092555014,
-0.022363754,
0.0404239669,
0.036875315,
-0.0498236679,
-0.0178614333,
0.0105094351,
-0.0123629821,
-0.0534498394,
0.0014474316,
-0.0370989479,
0.0167399663,
-0.0814953595,
0.0808106437,
0.0793038458,
0.0107671581,
0.0620340593,
-0.016261762,
0.0070392489,
-0.0045047989,
0.0373566709,
-0.0002894134,
-0.0537088066,
-0.0112317745,
0.0231289789,
-0.0108646322,
0.0310556162,
-0.0428551771,
0.0094885966,
0.035348583,
-0.0162080657,
-0.0531633236,
-0.0116749983,
-0.0121047981,
-0.0863194168,
0.0133353313,
-0.035649363,
0.0184362382,
0.0986382589,
-0.0080994852,
0.0278911926,
0.016261179,
0.0127059575,
0.010780273,
0.0633966774,
0.0420938767,
0.0348712169,
0.0144246882,
-0.0044670291,
0.0058506653,
-0.0018844672,
0.0184005201,
-0.0582294092,
-0.0165593755,
0.0069679064,
-0.015300462,
-0.0233432241,
0.0266775955,
0.043565575,
0.0639067665,
0.0403759107,
0.0045610289,
0.0072782869,
0.0345950387,
-0.034429796,
-0.0280737448,
-0.0267018415,
-0.0354643464,
-0.0042911554,
0.0149691356,
0.006532887,
-0.0046313745,
0.037942443,
-0.0134903817,
-0.0018979186,
0.0457510948,
-0.0006394027,
0.0079640821,
0.0389243476,
-0.0395779572,
0.0069454126,
0.0885064378,
0.0082779545,
0.0202107746,
0.0433309451,
0.0698144659,
0.0253884103,
0.070771277,
0.0452266708,
0.0114892544,
0.0257742405,
-0.0058520017,
0.0261212308,
0.0173391812,
0.0350175947,
-0.0068716407,
-0.0190984011,
-0.0076922132,
-0.023914203,
0.0515750572,
-0.0029205235,
0.000074659,
0.0097147254,
0.0864883885,
0.0119564747,
-0.0702692196,
0.0213833433,
-0.0152684394,
-0.0105899395,
-0.0072419946,
-0.0457061492,
0.0203709342,
-0.0447817668,
0.051471509,
-0.0120561952,
0.0093358094,
0.0304026827,
-0.0440978631,
0.0125438143,
0.0063041691,
0.0816569477,
0.0589123964,
0.0074594668,
-0.0543911271,
-0.0080700237,
-0.0440912545,
0.032070566,
-0.0217058416,
-0.0025562071,
-0.0000419336,
0.0076382617,
0.043412637,
0.009977215,
0.0041862046,
0.0038189266,
-0.0287201479,
0.0711458027,
-0.0154957594,
0.0209791977,
-0.0160639677,
-0.0720884874,
0.0135590266,
-0.0090075238,
0.0113674784,
-0.0010999864,
-0.0132363224,
0.0141936643,
0.0300705116,
-0.0619888902,
-0.0011693212,
-0.0070846705,
-0.0408012681,
0.0071075256,
-0.0213811416,
0.0298092999,
-0.0069355322,
-0.0187990144,
0.0037584347,
0.0271253753,
0.0016535702,
0.0510458723,
-0.032393977,
0.0003755543,
-0.0017114874,
-0.0038610646,
0.0076461276,
-0.0181553811,
-0.0112029221,
-0.0142690176,
0.0311926883,
0.0302167777,
-0.0478040017,
-0.0613837428,
-0.0037129875,
-0.059794087,
0.0017462507,
-0.019661082,
0.0035465143,
-0.0010184224,
-0.0044434476,
-0.008710552,
0.0100737456,
-0.0281515419,
-0.0528782904,
0.0039677899,
-0.0464929007,
-0.0297552943,
0.0085102869,
-0.0214661658,
0.0890257806,
-0.0198821351,
-0.0560387932,
0.0143024949,
-0.0662309602,
-0.0132195828,
0.0230190121,
0.0250237398,
0.0189856663,
-0.0490810759,
0.0379628651,
-0.0842703283,
-0.0538627654,
0.0184958633,
0.1469365954,
0.0129862474,
-0.0035235973,
-0.0321450643,
-0.0033706864,
0.0554016195,
-0.0447697155,
-0.0137445563,
0.0127441734,
0.0935602337,
0.0108591197,
0.0334751122,
-0.0205922034,
-0.0379888229,
0.0063280705,
-0.0172118768,
0.0237316657,
-0.0174328536,
0.0215551052,
0.0146854157,
-0.0133577418,
-0.0019383559,
-0.0186579265,
0.0019069563,
-0.0308182687,
-0.0421720333,
-0.0475054421,
-0.0015378533,
-0.0363183469,
0.0022555517,
0.0491416827,
0.028672589,
0.0349162668,
0.0302302819,
0.0243134927,
-0.0038438684,
0.0248346832,
0.0478777438,
0.0274691992,
-0.0254395958,
0.0563447364,
-0.085299924,
-0.0168561209,
-0.0229965169,
0.0196028017,
0.0787365586,
-0.0155426729,
0.0289102271,
-0.0637461618,
-0.0963201821,
-0.0478446297,
0.0124547193,
-0.0452247597,
0.0161850248,
0.0343051888,
0.0574776419,
-0.0295516718,
0.0003483579,
0.0129485782,
-0.0569410026,
0.0125454403,
0.0220364574,
-0.0490897149,
0.0724384114,
0.006327318,
0.0036920842,
-0.0532894135,
-0.0322399214,
0.0076237922,
-0.0486020781,
0.0137055591,
0.0052173533,
-0.0544821434,
-0.0348925516,
-0.0165435411,
-0.0481414758,
-0.0245559514,
-0.0587041713,
-0.0036948607,
-0.0062912703,
0.0169658232,
-0.0358921587,
-0.0968062654,
-0.0007632059,
0.0238159727,
-0.0431069285,
0.0287798643,
-0.003807443,
0.084514901,
-0.028407542,
-0.0489213839,
-0.0098648928,
-0.012547317,
-0.0332490467,
-0.0144951185,
0.0943357199,
0.0052762018,
0.0138845732,
-0.0295978449,
0.0124175688,
0.0251644943,
-0.0247673243,
0.025230933,
0.0133127915,
0.0309453439,
0.0200066492,
0.0250241775,
0.0151581401,
0.0734773353,
-0.0177616887,
-0.0190492757,
0.0085784616,
0.0054616015,
-0.0483907983,
0.0462952405,
0.0190635715,
-0.030205017,
0.0392520763,
-0.0157379359,
-0.0806402117,
-0.0704666227,
-0.0499925688,
-0.022533454,
0.0787707493,
0.0558598824,
0.0094265519,
0.0331962742,
-0.0260935146,
-0.0507999025,
-0.0139829256,
-0.0055796737,
-0.0166130997,
0.0349331722,
0.0043282066,
0.0491466895,
-0.0026972799,
-0.0169641674,
0.0028359678,
0.0387553722,
-0.0415870175,
0.0289934017,
-0.0015629889,
0.0251961891,
0.0293022897,
-0.0276057683,
-0.030066127,
0.0405984558,
0.0068518147,
-0.020056881,
0.0083287805,
-0.0246355105,
0.063576825,
-0.0086578457,
0.0003803447,
-0.0359106138,
0.0282286014,
-0.0255701672,
-0.0485900827,
-0.0246196128,
0.0131204426,
-0.0337043852,
0.0021967033,
0.048648078,
-0.0473556817,
-0.0002229451,
-0.006555398,
-0.0095143421,
0.0197923928,
0.0030278941,
0.0334250107,
-0.0345841721,
0.0162563231,
-0.0261473916,
-0.0554152802,
0.0534440503,
-0.0137578491,
0.0494627021,
-0.0594188198,
0.0122487573,
0.0569033846,
0.0649541765,
0.0009450549,
0.0089661879,
-0.0223818738,
0.0273374859,
0.0249004401,
0.0793788061,
-0.0362172313,
-0.0383216739,
0.0043538804,
-0.0366010517,
-0.0490056314,
-0.0375933684,
-0.0598258823,
-0.0000265186,
0.0362374894,
-0.0117845573,
0.0397271141,
-0.0294423886,
0.0661099255,
0.0082053943,
-0.0245984942,
0.022815302,
-0.0015686987,
0.0171444248,
-0.037075229,
-0.0072430149,
0.0132691078,
-0.0242502578,
0.0698698685,
-0.0385842696,
0.0005214157,
0.0256481823,
0.0602429993,
-0.051617533,
-0.0208541956,
0.014969686,
0.0201033354,
-0.0230999868,
-0.0158218574,
-0.0041536526,
-0.066457741,
-0.0066872747,
-0.0169687066,
0.0133325569,
-0.038131848,
0.0168243255,
-0.0038724309,
0.0147327501,
0.0266175307,
-0.0302129183,
-0.0588219538,
0.0471304171,
-0.1471533328,
-0.0311244912,
0.0010320625,
-5.874102861e-33,
0.0147966035,
-0.0547721274,
0.0420462787,
-0.0016552036,
-0.0314440057,
-0.0467905328,
0.0109436894,
-0.0069084363,
-0.0398361795,
-0.0084278835,
-0.0260155946,
-0.0348033831,
0.0181116015,
-0.041771654,
-0.0216054302,
0.0010310574,
-0.0171182118,
0.0281668976,
-0.0119089903,
-0.0171875115,
0.0409288183,
-0.0172569808,
0.0763664618,
-0.087428242,
0.0383785516,
-0.0066709695,
-0.0236281622,
-0.0116434135,
0.1176822856,
0.0248860102,
-0.0201434288,
-0.0180081073,
0.0046214634,
-0.0199835654,
0.036813058,
-0.0093944017,
-0.0679851547,
-0.0161182173,
0.0193611849,
0.039798338,
0.0872881263,
-0.0410667844,
0.0425403602,
0.0122781862,
0.0021557971,
0.0345980451,
0.0442378782,
0.0192389637,
-0.0669061169,
0.032262411,
-0.0307170469,
-0.0032152093,
-0.0178067237,
0.0392824784,
0.0325360037,
0.0255874582,
0.029003853,
-0.0431593433,
-0.0801890939,
0.0272573084,
0.0468755886,
0.000724104,
0.02117927,
-0.0527540781,
0.0105637992,
0.0318569355,
0.0040636752,
0.0224902257,
-0.0672060549,
-0.0079311831,
0.0446993671,
-0.008298791,
-0.0312986933,
0.0638510585,
-0.015461552,
-0.0306200758,
-0.0461017676,
0.0356971361,
-0.0338843241,
-0.0005796164,
-0.0062437616,
-0.0289588403,
-0.0571950078,
-0.0294879135,
-0.0097208358,
-0.0465715416,
-0.0005503994,
-0.0279842485,
0.0065016085,
-0.0326648727,
-0.0486485809,
0.0509826243,
-0.0299462397,
-0.0458063632,
-0.1041404381,
0.03639796,
-0.0291065127,
0.0034786295,
-0.0336219445,
-0.0212681554,
-0.0201789271,
-0.0224990528,
-0.0261277221,
0.0589838587,
0.0105052972,
0.0415234417,
-0.0169558153,
0.025094239,
-0.0318352394,
-0.0073773949,
0.0277332012,
-0.0291579477,
-0.0195654351,
-0.0614839345,
0.0406847633,
-0.0120932236,
0.0322133973,
-0.0471519567,
0.0723896623,
0.0221413914,
0.0216613766,
-0.0412159264,
0.0110309403,
0.0180715844,
-0.0047274185,
0.003520113,
0.0152403945,
0.0559027046,
0.0251238886,
0.0254176017,
0.0127194552,
-0.041965805,
2.601e-7,
0.0385089293,
0.0674271956,
-0.0087180845,
-0.0210227612,
-0.0136908712,
-0.026726678,
0.0370424837,
0.0109229172,
-0.0411059372,
-0.0101824943,
0.0536074936,
-0.0057619046,
-0.0115442602,
0.087102659,
-0.1131827086,
-0.0186802354,
0.0115247723,
0.0079361564,
-0.07639727,
0.0009274231,
0.026358027,
0.0192267541,
0.014696015,
-0.0053009288,
-0.0093065221,
-0.0185666867,
-0.0222727768,
-0.072269477,
0.0070476225,
-0.0064697801,
0.0548385307,
0.0060316995,
0.0169896483,
-0.0230409708,
-0.0112977521,
-0.0020612644,
0.0071677356,
0.0057373662,
0.0056663905,
0.0129411761,
-0.0253876243,
-0.03893907,
0.0087549686,
-0.0838002563,
0.0513436832,
-0.0045106537,
-0.0284794662,
0.0575672984,
-0.0104215918,
0.0252963547,
0.0207781214,
-0.0070194234,
-0.0180137567,
0.0059376913,
0.0027568834,
0.0196052939,
0.0217520986,
-0.0269604437,
0.0023656513,
0.0308504794,
0.0146281477,
-0.0199183244,
-0.0261820164,
-0.0129289217,
-0.0333978944,
0.0143502885,
0.0313260034,
1.825513454e-34,
-0.0224836916,
-0.0251316447,
-0.0698371083,
-0.0062403791,
0.0111057861,
-0.0026393004,
0.007071605,
0.0290585682,
0.0173150022,
-0.0169268008,
0.0039116726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17901v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17901v1 | Script-Agnostic Language Identification | 2024-06-25T19:23:42 | 2024-06-25T19:23:42 | Milind Agarwal, Joshua Otten, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language identification is used as the first step in many data collection and
crawling efforts because it allows us to sort online text into
language-specific buckets. However, many modern languages, such as Konkani,
Kashmiri, Punjabi etc., are synchronically written in several scripts.
Moreover, languages with different writing systems do not share significant
lexical, semantic, and syntactic properties in neural representation spaces,
which is a disadvantage for closely related languages and low-resource
languages, especially those from the Indian Subcontinent. To counter this, we
propose learning script-agnostic representations using several different
experimental strategies (upscaling, flattening, and script mixing) focusing on
four major Dravidian languages (Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, and Malayalam). We find
that word-level script randomization and exposure to a language written in
multiple scripts is extremely valuable for downstream script-agnostic language
identification, while also maintaining competitive performance on naturally
occurring text. | [
0.0125886351,
0.0672392622,
-0.0227795467,
0.044929076,
-0.0620190911,
0.0291641112,
0.0140951481,
0.0629899427,
0.0490732715,
-0.0039109141,
-0.0120157097,
-0.0493549965,
0.0245351661,
0.0436066799,
0.0406960174,
-0.0015853018,
0.0034534528,
0.000812636,
0.018357465,
0.0246229675,
0.0109806089,
0.0269647073,
-0.0132283652,
-0.0038538955,
-0.0284002945,
-0.0074507166,
-0.0072534159,
0.0229743607,
-0.0044486518,
0.007331138,
-0.0147718461,
0.0498419814,
0.0425235368,
0.1029859632,
0.0000012312,
-0.0325564817,
-0.0100997221,
-0.0392885022,
-0.0054197279,
0.0013721384,
0.0732859075,
-0.0153160607,
0.0149607621,
0.0199782047,
0.0006500719,
-0.0094711026,
0.102123566,
-0.0155163463,
-0.0164624192,
0.0818453208,
-0.0257604737,
-0.0197753068,
-0.0279421248,
-0.012280684,
-0.0100325942,
0.0231912117,
0.0065926868,
-0.0226198621,
0.0051273811,
-0.0437050685,
-0.0383498445,
0.0077328808,
-0.0252730884,
-0.0140751265,
0.0002871257,
0.0153225884,
-0.0233234074,
-0.0056639458,
0.0679637343,
0.0404772125,
-0.0692716315,
-0.0597712249,
-0.0007605724,
-0.0132549526,
-0.053994596,
-0.0087085804,
-0.0270951968,
0.0269849002,
-0.048022192,
0.0727127269,
0.0407132655,
0.0261740871,
0.0345058106,
-0.0049300799,
0.0414117165,
0.0293280054,
0.0188029166,
0.0010407034,
-0.0575476624,
0.031677831,
0.0338158235,
-0.0314828679,
0.0119115338,
-0.0007612469,
0.0139245382,
0.0095193833,
-0.0046304329,
-0.0544311814,
0.0099592982,
-0.0011075112,
0.0788965076,
0.0624227338,
-0.0321396664,
0.0126980534,
-0.0545313135,
0.0517836325,
-0.0097895376,
0.0264044199,
0.0120593412,
0.023386851,
0.0526572429,
-0.0402095877,
0.023409389,
-0.0143657755,
-0.0192068834,
0.0393606126,
0.0103154862,
0.0266110692,
0.0178749189,
-0.0274757836,
-0.0170620792,
-0.0547167547,
-0.044388365,
-0.0019582375,
0.0205089878,
0.0085579744,
-0.017794719,
0.0326403752,
-0.000715443,
-0.0949489176,
-0.0455739312,
0.0700245798,
0.0084040323,
0.0183015577,
-0.0095763821,
0.0738385543,
-0.0622387417,
-0.0553084426,
-0.0545440242,
0.0442409404,
0.0047837514,
-0.0270234291,
0.0196326952,
-0.078990601,
0.0674337298,
0.0206218343,
-0.0015740274,
-0.0580365658,
-0.0002824829,
0.0146006523,
-0.0051446166,
0.0452377088,
0.0392707475,
-0.0193245057,
0.0349397473,
0.0067938669,
0.0578517988,
0.0447941609,
0.0020450065,
0.0229275413,
0.0292237476,
-0.022073254,
0.0193672888,
0.0321778506,
-0.0323271453,
0.0290421844,
-0.0319843553,
-0.0238261297,
0.0562519506,
0.0116462884,
0.0133335553,
0.0161667876,
0.0061926791,
-0.0119760977,
0.0080541978,
0.0324864946,
-0.0235302635,
0.0100447619,
0.0053564017,
0.0080310404,
0.0085065737,
0.0627244189,
0.0008423703,
0.0197888948,
0.02033774,
-0.0090490095,
0.0379527099,
0.0109273149,
-0.0370942988,
0.0334451459,
-0.0209477674,
-0.0403849967,
0.0400951132,
-0.0354927555,
0.0550198406,
0.0295486506,
-0.0331373028,
-0.0527220145,
0.0991255641,
-0.038776394,
0.0560318157,
-0.0353690311,
0.0358996727,
0.0088665374,
0.0226339437,
-0.0548191965,
0.020398844,
0.0190686863,
-0.0012176713,
0.1026594713,
-0.0360881165,
-0.0162038039,
0.0489048772,
-0.03841535,
0.0308882929,
0.0372761413,
-0.0039711529,
0.0471615121,
-0.0209438577,
0.01088522,
0.0024058712,
-0.031050114,
-0.0214998052,
0.0490767993,
-0.0584775619,
-0.0250905417,
0.0199834928,
0.0063149328,
0.0308894347,
-0.0308721159,
-0.0420416519,
-0.0164709184,
-0.0075554824,
-0.0399095118,
-0.0019326443,
-0.008036945,
-0.0222822744,
-0.039676331,
-0.0013004108,
-0.0448628329,
0.0140312295,
0.0454208851,
-0.0086639682,
-0.0515925176,
0.0395992547,
-0.0199877862,
0.0376842245,
-0.0249026604,
0.0261729397,
-0.0538670532,
-0.0173484422,
-0.0474234149,
0.0477898158,
0.0213089958,
0.0348855406,
-0.0076852585,
-0.0325066708,
0.072865583,
-0.0432591327,
-0.0207194127,
0.0128404731,
-0.0054746089,
0.036986541,
0.0023645137,
-0.0172674712,
-0.0241760258,
-0.0587257855,
-0.0695287511,
-0.050183367,
-0.023270322,
0.0107286917,
-0.007230212,
0.0246492028,
0.0102128917,
-0.0492005534,
-0.0490580127,
-0.0135029592,
0.0677396134,
0.0221393332,
0.0341019705,
-0.0206550099,
0.0242856294,
-0.0100107891,
-0.0661434531,
-0.0355167724,
0.094615981,
0.0002387474,
-0.0343078896,
-0.0571353026,
-0.0061087795,
-0.0332007036,
-0.0036265089,
-0.0283444524,
-0.0466762036,
-0.0109792436,
-0.0282426942,
-0.0117539074,
0.0554016121,
-0.0183619503,
-0.0392575376,
0.0449764989,
0.0001076852,
0.0223621987,
-0.067018196,
0.003048443,
0.0166050531,
-0.0043468792,
-0.0363676473,
-0.0186210088,
0.0493310317,
0.0060269446,
0.005648599,
-0.0424250551,
-0.0404495522,
-0.0191435292,
0.0464418717,
-0.0065083634,
0.0146071687,
-0.0437029563,
0.0569422878,
-0.0157252513,
-0.0629601926,
0.0817690343,
-0.0380897112,
-0.0230077673,
-0.0670573115,
0.0029951015,
-0.0250931606,
-0.0126290433,
0.0331466608,
0.017533876,
-0.0486597419,
-0.054027766,
-0.0688587055,
0.0414324068,
0.0204459541,
-0.0155305332,
0.0331437439,
-0.0093907556,
0.0199460611,
-0.0443044789,
-0.0482109301,
-0.0390185304,
-0.0922212452,
0.0376261361,
0.0134799294,
0.0226883236,
-0.0413681455,
0.0156810861,
0.0323665254,
0.0072313841,
0.0655715689,
-0.0041611036,
0.0243397243,
-0.0156189473,
0.0390026793,
0.0125249159,
-0.0084071355,
-0.002844695,
0.0088886339,
0.0080662584,
-0.0235254709,
0.0567425527,
0.0005518994,
0.0223509576,
0.0361059532,
0.0172312893,
-0.0162165686,
0.001659988,
-0.0088293487,
-0.0058911,
0.0494174436,
-0.0044554793,
0.0326211266,
0.0155284265,
-0.0676728487,
-0.0100941351,
-0.0580380894,
0.0329591669,
0.0228163321,
0.0221276544,
-0.0493759178,
0.014354052,
0.0137222847,
-0.0008716084,
0.0104319379,
-0.0202590842,
-0.0153318252,
-0.0729457662,
-0.0373359285,
0.0165294204,
-0.025928909,
-0.0282647572,
-0.0458827801,
-0.010557821,
0.0007352571,
0.0003091134,
0.0611632094,
-0.0436004698,
-0.0240248591,
0.0338651985,
-0.0067094155,
-0.0319127329,
-0.0318538919,
-0.0239808634,
-0.0193422511,
-0.0128111495,
-0.0285467096,
-0.0676928088,
-0.0008206586,
-0.0158793926,
-0.0518214442,
-0.0293450635,
0.0083950618,
0.0625158921,
0.0247176718,
-0.0469556153,
-0.021561997,
0.0148103191,
-0.0409174673,
-0.0369842276,
-0.0566939712,
0.041812636,
0.009565792,
-0.0282387324,
0.0484146886,
-0.0123056257,
0.0089505408,
-0.0150476331,
0.0451466627,
-0.0401926562,
0.0099980487,
-0.0335157551,
0.0408995934,
0.0264291819,
-0.026008945,
0.0524454229,
-0.0015223235,
-0.0575502478,
-0.037865486,
-0.0327422135,
0.0002936648,
0.0414094776,
0.0428466722,
0.0238572508,
0.0005928421,
-0.0429574773,
-0.0544294231,
-0.0296085086,
-0.0329999141,
0.0039043839,
-0.0402064994,
-0.0282827169,
0.0256963577,
-0.0315437093,
-0.0130127687,
-0.0199981276,
-0.0759255514,
-0.0905880108,
0.0383351147,
-0.0123511329,
0.0235018786,
-0.0088668196,
-0.0222469233,
-0.0505723655,
0.0460569449,
0.001100434,
0.0002584844,
0.0319548063,
0.0057785315,
-0.0264385883,
-0.0245696772,
0.0508199707,
-0.029875936,
-0.0154658714,
0.0248598009,
-0.0472370647,
-0.0362820104,
0.0160323121,
0.0090655647,
0.0487015881,
0.0284348764,
-0.0610979423,
0.0178662986,
-0.0598132573,
-0.00244742,
0.0131625086,
0.0072863121,
0.0080157733,
-0.0437251553,
0.0310699921,
0.0530420542,
-0.0022701581,
0.0522877909,
0.0211791378,
0.0255378354,
0.0202150568,
0.0440109633,
0.0198973566,
0.0702780932,
0.0092705479,
0.0471519604,
-0.0148414308,
0.053436961,
-0.0561106019,
0.0384671427,
-0.0005328879,
0.0225243699,
0.0188526921,
0.021945063,
0.0077018477,
0.0243430343,
0.0304658189,
-0.0194980055,
-0.0146533307,
-0.0211425442,
0.045191884,
-0.0633305535,
0.0269102845,
-0.0214316342,
0.0257981736,
-0.0455319844,
0.0223257877,
-0.0060305977,
-0.0238075126,
0.0157229826,
-0.0086525222,
-0.0442607626,
0.0232780632,
0.1139028594,
0.0371311679,
-0.0145842014,
0.0136444448,
0.0157420617,
-0.0150121199,
-0.02841435,
0.0225043651,
0.037392199,
0.0328845531,
-0.00462831,
-0.0220121108,
-0.071203351,
-0.0045090942,
-0.0530658066,
0.0371228494,
-0.0299303606,
0.013983367,
0.0395559706,
0.0430177897,
0.0527780131,
-0.0158261638,
0.0343219414,
0.0052063353,
-0.0168540981,
-0.0123856701,
-5.115143831e-33,
0.0072113955,
0.0009606826,
-0.0725122765,
0.0286535751,
0.0373505689,
0.0109591335,
-0.0347441621,
0.0270650722,
-0.021454243,
0.0032129525,
-0.0264004599,
0.0376354009,
0.0120504694,
0.0251782872,
0.0188299939,
-0.0306295492,
0.0227676816,
0.0241980776,
-0.0357562229,
0.0166768786,
0.098780565,
-0.0260109827,
0.1023291945,
-0.0351121165,
-0.0115553001,
-0.0785356089,
0.0030869243,
0.0144030219,
-0.0065239784,
0.0079973657,
-0.0453645363,
0.0310540721,
0.039982006,
0.0419684835,
-0.016018413,
0.0167381633,
-0.0185746029,
-0.014143521,
-0.0026889448,
0.0782342479,
-0.0272081252,
-0.0276482254,
0.0399163701,
-0.0591169037,
-0.0383740924,
0.016736703,
0.0101680057,
0.0278179627,
-0.0224971101,
0.0110290358,
-0.0578281097,
0.0418616049,
0.0110105025,
0.0051140506,
0.0381270088,
0.0118159456,
0.0249925256,
0.0108016627,
-0.0556283668,
-0.0119501017,
-0.0667924955,
0.0590129234,
0.038750302,
0.0468269102,
-0.0579907447,
0.0497799814,
0.0047351792,
-0.0234221984,
0.0010640983,
-0.0179913174,
0.0284151267,
-0.0357408896,
0.0221385639,
0.0166796874,
0.0391397849,
-0.0821524858,
-0.0360265002,
0.0104900356,
0.0711107776,
-0.0386074707,
0.0339880362,
0.0053818515,
-0.0383900218,
-0.0496330522,
0.004132736,
-0.0558025055,
-0.0294580422,
-0.0157051422,
0.0182733368,
-0.0235652402,
0.0188202914,
0.0001954884,
0.0559586771,
-0.0339899324,
0.0324285328,
0.0283290111,
-0.0469285809,
0.0454745404,
0.0311330333,
-0.0102807954,
-0.0300766956,
-0.0503616706,
-0.0130789317,
0.003242424,
0.0130556915,
-0.0085105887,
0.058320865,
0.0059374124,
-0.0688009486,
0.0239437427,
-0.016163392,
0.0228585955,
0.0545125343,
0.0599531271,
0.0328087583,
-0.0149806077,
0.0139148608,
-0.0303982366,
0.0803074539,
0.0213413667,
0.0108609386,
0.0239775237,
-0.0414954051,
0.0160205625,
-0.0198727399,
0.0025496248,
-0.0430019312,
0.0245893765,
0.0169373881,
-0.0140248425,
0.0211329982,
0.0207031704,
2.087e-7,
-0.0119505329,
0.0060001491,
0.053180676,
-0.0384884998,
0.0300149824,
0.013523953,
-0.0543212369,
0.0256321095,
-0.0396243855,
-0.0099389823,
-0.0437944569,
0.0056870701,
0.0790551305,
0.02973474,
-0.0763279125,
0.0271252319,
-0.1026995331,
0.0264312569,
-0.0254849438,
-0.0311947651,
-0.0512029156,
0.0958590806,
0.0157014541,
-0.0169883501,
-0.0109408256,
-0.0537552498,
0.0616714358,
0.0097793266,
0.0227393713,
0.008433287,
-0.0503843129,
-0.0248887409,
-0.0220720824,
-0.0031934418,
-0.0233953185,
-0.0081735728,
0.047245957,
0.0330807492,
-0.0342856608,
0.0478722565,
0.0120694321,
0.0100179259,
-0.0134295439,
-0.0425028354,
0.0264015645,
0.0836032778,
-0.0672332942,
-0.007403546,
0.0200614575,
0.0016941852,
0.0493345186,
0.0189028811,
-0.0310375988,
0.0337487422,
0.0169260669,
-0.0334165804,
-0.0072156503,
-0.0232914928,
-0.0545862541,
0.0317225568,
-0.0385108516,
-0.0414337292,
-0.0051310244,
-0.0049638227,
0.0700996369,
-0.0286115482,
0.0265639387,
1.95660851e-34,
0.0096403072,
0.0131272236,
0.0046610953,
0.0039756219,
0.0133946883,
-0.0218466371,
-0.0047543463,
0.0285217818,
0.0243552662,
-0.0762094185,
-0.0015471104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17888v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17888v1 | CTBench: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Evaluating Language Model Capabilities in Clinical Trial Design | 2024-06-25T18:52:48 | 2024-06-25T18:52:48 | Nafis Neehal, Bowen Wang, Shayom Debopadhaya, Soham Dan, Keerthiram Murugesan, Vibha Anand, Kristin P. Bennett | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | CTBench is introduced as a benchmark to assess language models (LMs) in
aiding clinical study design. Given study-specific metadata, CTBench evaluates
AI models' ability to determine the baseline features of a clinical trial (CT),
which include demographic and relevant features collected at the trial's start
from all participants. These baseline features, typically presented in CT
publications (often as Table 1), are crucial for characterizing study cohorts
and validating results. Baseline features, including confounders and
covariates, are also necessary for accurate treatment effect estimation in
studies involving observational data. CTBench consists of two datasets:
"CT-Repo," containing baseline features from 1,690 clinical trials sourced from
clinicaltrials.gov, and "CT-Pub," a subset of 100 trials with more
comprehensive baseline features gathered from relevant publications. Two
LM-based evaluation methods are developed to compare the actual baseline
feature lists against LM-generated responses. "ListMatch-LM" and
"ListMatch-BERT" use GPT-4o and BERT scores (at various thresholds),
respectively, for evaluation. To establish baseline results, advanced prompt
engineering techniques using LLaMa3-70B-Instruct and GPT-4o in zero-shot and
three-shot learning settings are applied to generate potential baseline
features. The performance of GPT-4o as an evaluator is validated through
human-in-the-loop evaluations on the CT-Pub dataset, where clinical experts
confirm matches between actual and LM-generated features. The results highlight
a promising direction with significant potential for improvement, positioning
CTBench as a useful tool for advancing research on AI in CT design and
potentially enhancing the efficacy and robustness of CTs. | [
0.0341914855,
0.0756905526,
-0.0192269702,
-0.024224611,
-0.0243775062,
0.020801127,
0.071753785,
0.0120807057,
-0.0111408876,
0.0038926338,
-0.0147846425,
-0.050528992,
-0.0056777014,
0.0771828592,
0.0144704785,
-0.0309538897,
0.0131591018,
0.0019572317,
0.0563207231,
0.0140008964,
-0.0389234684,
0.0025511177,
-0.0222866628,
0.0511494055,
0.0047053155,
-0.0197427776,
0.0430521183,
-0.0079397205,
-0.0176839605,
-0.0628404543,
0.0042569726,
0.0680394173,
-0.0148774348,
0.0306352805,
0.0000022159,
-0.0905336887,
-0.0238325745,
0.0547323935,
-0.0360464565,
-0.0155102508,
0.0427501723,
-0.0020905808,
0.0230113827,
0.0073267026,
-0.0024876187,
0.0003001001,
0.0544231199,
0.0217079408,
0.0090541262,
0.0622982308,
-0.0286918767,
0.0118649323,
0.031755913,
-0.0489570722,
0.0172999725,
-0.0188161824,
0.0177911948,
-0.0292122308,
0.0303079896,
-0.0133354357,
0.0137721114,
0.020176487,
0.0203935895,
0.0151913688,
0.0276606828,
0.0364012606,
-0.0563330464,
-0.0421244986,
-0.0049047712,
0.0363325216,
0.0382072292,
0.025306033,
-0.0038294606,
-0.0277356766,
0.0505187958,
-0.0031451993,
-0.0419027619,
-0.0174985025,
-0.0268248655,
-0.0285738315,
0.0098455874,
-0.023091929,
0.0008203526,
-0.0370461941,
-0.0042560273,
0.0300339665,
0.0061177011,
-0.0091308737,
0.0297157355,
0.0128258402,
-0.0010675465,
-0.0330138579,
-0.0131121315,
0.0064102896,
-0.0487550646,
0.0058370586,
0.0343899541,
-0.0448624603,
0.0949405208,
-0.0560828932,
0.0462405011,
0.0061939675,
-0.0482289232,
0.0035554853,
-0.0240444839,
0.0763537139,
0.0032353802,
0.0477878526,
-0.0383026972,
0.0480201244,
-0.0162976217,
0.0065170224,
-0.0124134691,
0.0227757189,
0.0028059615,
0.006227525,
-0.0632433072,
0.0036531093,
-0.003978529,
-0.000579351,
0.0035000748,
0.0110395905,
-0.0352547765,
0.0295529198,
0.0077499319,
-0.0174645092,
-0.0123401936,
0.0293434951,
-0.0030779457,
-0.0987271741,
0.0205085967,
-0.0103252735,
-0.0103519727,
-0.0558442585,
0.0313966833,
0.0536379442,
0.0111975474,
-0.0169239361,
0.0030645861,
-0.0054606604,
-0.0385302827,
-0.0598364621,
0.003276624,
-0.0941651762,
0.0411215797,
0.0087011252,
0.0120144095,
-0.0554232821,
-0.0360451788,
-0.0061836718,
-0.0432339497,
0.0336932018,
-0.0424055271,
-0.00844952,
0.0114945583,
-0.002280877,
-0.0268960688,
0.0356979594,
0.046695251,
0.005648728,
-0.0059435861,
-0.0248402469,
-0.008371884,
0.0142145362,
0.0412222669,
-0.007748649,
-0.0300929733,
0.0128193069,
0.027032448,
0.0557815284,
-0.0480367392,
0.0299959704,
-0.0050452631,
0.0108647142,
0.0432560667,
0.045550812,
0.0356092975,
0.0631712154,
0.0012603832,
-0.0749338344,
0.0159760695,
-0.0269900635,
-0.02757941,
-0.00304228,
-0.0255354475,
-0.0154132061,
-0.002177903,
0.0109326588,
-0.0270922352,
-0.0367941931,
-0.0276353173,
-0.0144672338,
-0.0062330221,
-0.0064842859,
0.0297724437,
-0.0417864621,
-0.023711862,
-0.0400949828,
0.0065094791,
-0.0044937148,
-0.0495747849,
-0.06181252,
-0.0302423518,
0.0464180522,
0.0348661207,
-0.0353996642,
-0.0229005925,
-0.0335838012,
0.0123057589,
-0.0015011586,
0.0361298546,
0.0177206397,
0.0314263031,
0.0202323813,
-0.0281008091,
-0.0118231503,
0.0136341499,
0.017088037,
-0.0206420049,
0.0101929177,
-0.0473299548,
-0.0436324254,
-0.0488524586,
0.0602572262,
-0.0547512658,
-0.0503049195,
0.0188190863,
-0.0303502642,
0.0491723865,
0.0043440554,
-0.030760821,
0.0343802087,
0.0035605009,
-0.0275610238,
-0.0110013001,
-0.0094609857,
0.0293559842,
-0.0431034043,
0.007804594,
-0.0347343422,
0.0088998135,
-0.0080178985,
-0.0420459434,
0.0050070286,
0.0173088927,
-0.0336006731,
0.0147885382,
0.029813109,
0.0308394562,
-0.0187671501,
0.023527557,
-0.0579841919,
0.0207700692,
-0.0038989456,
-0.0069883466,
0.0399638452,
-0.0732381791,
0.0248552077,
-0.0382074453,
-0.0442322753,
0.031096939,
-0.020093767,
-0.0193506312,
-0.0019814502,
0.0258230306,
-0.0257091001,
-0.0356350951,
-0.1033574268,
0.0326190889,
0.0189346466,
0.0266638231,
-0.0135425851,
-0.0200984739,
-0.018453382,
-0.016517207,
-0.032364592,
-0.0308479313,
0.0327148251,
0.0482349917,
0.0201402418,
0.0525330119,
-0.0573511831,
-0.0796043947,
-0.032013528,
-0.0595776141,
0.0646182001,
0.0512916856,
-0.0407880135,
0.0396053381,
0.0088945413,
-0.0085240081,
-0.0060056751,
0.0080750734,
-0.0010195936,
0.0344351679,
0.0176458266,
0.0147691509,
0.0623742901,
-0.0280000698,
-0.0043081995,
0.0431654155,
-0.0137036387,
-0.0313623995,
0.0013860842,
-0.0262915846,
-0.0636612028,
0.0123758074,
-0.07413885,
0.0274785925,
0.0729548186,
0.0199269205,
0.0152566703,
-0.0522183813,
-0.0081972415,
0.0128726205,
-0.0090255477,
-0.0529496036,
-0.0030897388,
-0.047212109,
0.0384673774,
-0.0346123725,
-0.08083646,
0.1035536975,
0.0002450609,
0.0443494245,
-0.0628963336,
0.0452455617,
-0.037418738,
-0.0201958437,
0.0119231772,
-0.0068483413,
0.0525164157,
0.016533047,
0.0103894733,
-0.0143350158,
0.0101523306,
-0.0367063209,
0.0631595626,
-0.0483478867,
0.0450502597,
0.01738666,
-0.0202427674,
-0.030576054,
-0.0182378627,
-0.01058394,
0.0193493254,
0.019389648,
0.0352930948,
-0.0223300308,
-0.0052200388,
-0.0123137515,
0.0463409126,
-0.0271056257,
-0.0006254839,
0.0224356148,
-0.0466905981,
0.0311738551,
-0.0229706317,
0.0305348039,
-0.0333810709,
0.0521252491,
0.0001658028,
0.0093610408,
0.0280123446,
-0.0325393677,
0.0652260557,
0.003465618,
-0.0252065249,
-0.028817866,
0.0579074994,
0.023368204,
-0.0258229338,
0.0118531883,
0.110652633,
0.0211081896,
-0.0722102076,
-0.0091026146,
-0.0147434836,
0.0187582634,
-0.0165532418,
0.0035468885,
-0.0455975384,
0.0014794505,
-0.002036778,
0.054122787,
-0.0436603166,
-0.0300530884,
-0.0132447593,
-0.0304994844,
0.0319438726,
0.0041996338,
-0.077060461,
0.015407268,
-0.0690118372,
0.0185477361,
-0.0430560671,
-0.0254639611,
0.0014483818,
0.0228520036,
-0.0220091976,
0.0217810646,
-0.0889975801,
-0.0824804083,
0.0368411019,
-0.0273499936,
0.0878796577,
0.067174688,
0.0049946825,
-0.0139297275,
0.0031669717,
0.0173491389,
-0.005021668,
-0.0077113481,
-0.0068503181,
0.0956522375,
0.0318542011,
0.0342151597,
-0.0309072677,
0.0406908579,
-0.0361609943,
-0.0067142672,
-0.0064736777,
0.0983502418,
-0.0457407273,
-0.01560714,
-0.0203657076,
0.0090382248,
0.0162936486,
0.0409341678,
0.0449333601,
-0.0157973394,
-0.0042780857,
-0.0232685748,
0.0228319168,
-0.0398058668,
0.0068755462,
0.0124187898,
-0.037025921,
-0.0190034453,
-0.0379893072,
-0.0461801998,
0.0565834828,
-0.0489615574,
0.0035964996,
0.0442168228,
-0.0349595323,
-0.022009043,
-0.0182007048,
0.0687083229,
0.0355311185,
0.0321626365,
-0.0726945549,
-0.0313823633,
-0.0002444311,
-0.0212368108,
-0.0050862958,
0.0458461717,
-0.0345279202,
-0.0271770693,
0.0031926944,
0.0754669011,
0.0202781111,
-0.0232528429,
0.0082981465,
-0.0212221425,
0.0406701267,
-0.0089315064,
0.030735597,
-0.0398688875,
-0.031763833,
-0.0282075666,
-0.0156782251,
-0.0207753889,
-0.0307490136,
0.0322595537,
-0.0083072521,
0.0089117596,
0.0106616123,
-0.0222781282,
0.0553138033,
0.0616064481,
0.0532696098,
-0.0310325436,
-0.0064472174,
-0.0322667323,
-0.0078242458,
-0.0256713778,
0.0358223319,
-0.0238614809,
-0.0051272647,
0.0242600217,
0.0027545157,
-0.0289360918,
-0.0301052891,
-0.1251944155,
-0.011087765,
-0.0684925988,
0.098083362,
-0.0006627614,
0.0376045406,
0.0399936922,
0.018071657,
0.0076282765,
0.0111388713,
-0.0190309323,
0.0315917768,
-0.0078556966,
0.0305204354,
-0.0113922181,
0.0271962807,
0.010768556,
0.0648810342,
-0.0213851761,
-0.0287875514,
-0.0435417145,
-0.0156445447,
0.031637568,
0.0136683397,
0.0570890084,
-0.0133510642,
0.0152646452,
-0.0680920109,
-0.0022023213,
0.0094582811,
0.019434968,
0.0283526517,
-0.0017783847,
-0.0143052414,
-0.0773367509,
0.0899097621,
0.0396234617,
0.0210704636,
-0.0418829732,
-0.021816168,
-0.0414394364,
-0.0182632245,
0.0482946113,
-0.0211968031,
-0.0707647055,
-0.0179786868,
-0.0617099777,
-0.0257832464,
0.0307007078,
-0.0228679087,
0.0076618814,
0.0060350583,
0.0022275168,
0.0344769247,
-0.016442908,
-0.0138578508,
-0.011873343,
0.0118301138,
0.0066035283,
-0.0645272359,
-0.0278992467,
-5.820620072e-33,
0.0115501294,
0.0046300571,
0.0075724348,
0.0002020671,
0.0010943924,
0.0118921408,
-0.0705951378,
0.018112516,
0.0196319614,
0.0265095811,
-0.0125047509,
0.0013854423,
-0.0040022526,
-0.0028043115,
0.0154594947,
-0.0380485319,
0.0037852973,
-0.0164682288,
-0.015361771,
0.0047535971,
-0.0681377575,
0.0169006437,
0.0490210801,
-0.0585143641,
0.0531467125,
0.0374943949,
-0.0050116279,
-0.0219605751,
-0.0304576401,
0.0720743537,
-0.0030661982,
0.0411762632,
0.0460861064,
-0.0267426856,
0.0033618961,
-0.0155361481,
-0.0216871593,
-0.0322021246,
0.0178321153,
-0.0229581241,
-0.0005361531,
-0.0260038227,
0.0421955958,
0.0039652972,
-0.0464432985,
0.0124372495,
0.0225448143,
-0.0490762144,
0.0063230754,
0.0048472402,
-0.021338582,
0.0274428185,
-0.0438211076,
-0.0235038046,
-0.0026953635,
0.0582640953,
-0.0181511082,
0.0356329158,
-0.0133104818,
0.0239277631,
0.0548643209,
-0.0259485226,
0.0250193123,
-0.0012587663,
0.0035307216,
0.032447055,
0.0132546844,
0.0109170135,
-0.0130642997,
-0.0028402656,
0.0086344201,
0.0498254336,
0.0836992413,
0.0226290021,
0.0235914197,
0.0013618552,
-0.089821972,
0.0507240184,
-0.0288616214,
0.0028742526,
0.0290762819,
-0.0163115673,
-0.020475965,
-0.0300283935,
-0.053893961,
-0.0248083267,
-0.0490957238,
-0.0263212323,
0.0452760495,
-0.0207088757,
-0.0062280158,
-0.0313947648,
0.0726859123,
-0.0064642904,
0.0061050048,
-0.017087996,
0.0144208679,
0.0268941708,
0.01654494,
0.0317944661,
-0.0372809395,
0.0004072533,
0.0486673303,
0.0109065836,
0.0823583528,
-0.0112432055,
0.020691609,
-0.0301338453,
-0.0445904545,
0.0169636365,
-0.0193724241,
0.017592039,
0.0230549965,
0.0098173451,
0.0230437759,
0.0288995914,
0.0081186416,
0.070215784,
0.00683568,
-0.0323043652,
-0.0465688594,
-0.0149562499,
-0.0084647527,
0.0158194695,
-0.01193674,
0.016065307,
-0.0110352933,
0.040310584,
0.0499127321,
-0.0284722336,
-0.0265627839,
-0.0185811911,
2.905e-7,
0.0890007839,
0.0616091378,
0.0047758492,
-0.0196721498,
0.0349562652,
0.0008644628,
-0.022386685,
0.0131485602,
0.0439569093,
0.0200796593,
0.0714660287,
-0.000516536,
0.0571873747,
0.0094717713,
-0.0191357173,
-0.0362533294,
-0.0678237155,
-0.0112517606,
-0.0610965267,
-0.0053683766,
0.0736559704,
0.0303546246,
-0.0498163179,
-0.0348764919,
-0.0053779162,
0.0171405002,
-0.0147947073,
-0.0751244351,
-0.0154549247,
0.0580585487,
0.0060740188,
-0.021094704,
0.0364276767,
0.0844011828,
-0.015852049,
-0.0174407382,
-0.0131283542,
0.0756082609,
-0.0364638045,
0.0071738451,
0.0433897451,
-0.0026269413,
0.0240555536,
-0.0594065674,
0.0395386517,
-0.0175944529,
-0.0403840169,
-0.0094487052,
-0.023612963,
-0.0213909373,
0.1411234438,
-0.065197058,
0.0181204099,
0.0233953577,
0.0302590095,
0.0385865308,
-0.01561967,
0.0250628963,
-0.0103597166,
0.0560761429,
-0.053170532,
-0.0224675406,
-0.013658721,
-0.0198018868,
-0.0296954159,
-0.0481719598,
0.0407176204,
2.906223356e-34,
0.0561637357,
-0.0214478634,
0.0563319474,
0.0171795152,
0.0594046153,
-0.0118416157,
0.0143288625,
0.0260344595,
-0.0143203558,
-0.0827704743,
0.0127318166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17876v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17876v1 | ET tu, CLIP? Addressing Common Object Errors for Unseen Environments | 2024-06-25T18:35:13 | 2024-06-25T18:35:13 | Ye Won Byun, Cathy Jiao, Shahriar Noroozizadeh, Jimin Sun, Rosa Vitiello | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.RO | We introduce a simple method that employs pre-trained CLIP encoders to
enhance model generalization in the ALFRED task. In contrast to previous
literature where CLIP replaces the visual encoder, we suggest using CLIP as an
additional module through an auxiliary object detection objective. We validate
our method on the recently proposed Episodic Transformer architecture and
demonstrate that incorporating CLIP improves task performance on the unseen
validation set. Additionally, our analysis results support that CLIP especially
helps with leveraging object descriptions, detecting small objects, and
interpreting rare words. | [
-0.0058590597,
0.0476428345,
0.0302291717,
0.0426887535,
0.0322623774,
0.0193085894,
0.0040638233,
0.001659315,
-0.0820649937,
-0.0119091077,
-0.0096783172,
-0.0144342948,
-0.0140031995,
0.0565626025,
0.0352806896,
-0.0633810088,
0.0085049588,
-0.021015808,
0.0001233676,
0.0106850183,
0.0009321595,
-0.0275526755,
-0.005661482,
0.0338738896,
-0.0252960324,
0.0080806902,
-0.0569069535,
0.0081202844,
0.0450532772,
-0.018232163,
0.0072900532,
0.0079391543,
0.0105254306,
0.0236811507,
0.000001856,
-0.0130678965,
0.0088431789,
0.0079126274,
-0.0175492149,
-0.0663062483,
-0.0119431335,
-0.0617702492,
0.0075720004,
0.0061127911,
0.0030647237,
-0.0523499511,
0.0553189591,
0.0779811889,
0.0334511884,
0.0650432631,
-0.0309928898,
-0.0010678207,
0.0060898447,
-0.0288361255,
0.0465875417,
-0.02208855,
0.0251954794,
-0.0503251776,
-0.0425805748,
-0.0023273027,
-0.0242542215,
0.0046990202,
0.059975341,
0.0135478312,
0.0490400866,
0.0358971208,
-0.0653231516,
-0.0491094701,
-0.0229510907,
0.0265581217,
-0.0528271832,
0.0234084614,
-0.0352841094,
-0.0146044632,
0.0265281387,
-0.0251830388,
-0.0237568226,
0.0422032885,
-0.006854991,
-0.0015868107,
-0.0678268075,
0.0253258497,
0.0065785907,
-0.0223791227,
-0.0499863997,
-0.0152908564,
0.019661624,
-0.0135684777,
0.0294908583,
0.063463591,
-0.0476477779,
-0.0472240858,
0.0496834219,
0.0164854582,
-0.0112443799,
-0.0305165667,
-0.0596553236,
-0.0035807195,
-0.0210541878,
-0.0131341191,
0.0617155582,
-0.0079298783,
-0.0709771514,
0.0457268767,
-0.0526038408,
0.0636739805,
-0.0222747419,
0.0294911452,
-0.0052840812,
0.0170778017,
0.0101403426,
0.0110764187,
-0.0497486182,
0.0210584365,
-0.0303634778,
-0.0294464882,
0.0191057008,
-0.0423060916,
-0.0352143236,
0.0263810214,
0.0259345919,
0.0330663212,
-0.0568425991,
-0.0226434004,
0.0077684475,
-0.0172750074,
-0.0274503343,
0.0416720994,
0.0022503946,
-0.0515902489,
-0.028609924,
0.0138182687,
0.0303374901,
-0.0127787385,
-0.0030728565,
0.0839445144,
-0.0021195256,
-0.0866383538,
0.0015846147,
0.0433670059,
-0.0251635499,
-0.0045129373,
0.0578058474,
-0.0191474929,
-0.0097709233,
-0.0309429094,
0.019134853,
-0.0252351407,
0.0124573382,
-0.002859557,
0.0042927591,
0.0612508804,
-0.0333042741,
-0.0260289721,
-0.0110600311,
0.026177749,
-0.0207421817,
0.0522333644,
-0.0197465047,
0.0402528048,
-0.0069752997,
0.0621905699,
0.0709079579,
0.0342890993,
0.0008031724,
0.0083519667,
-0.0390455127,
-0.0241713934,
-0.0431800745,
0.0081605567,
0.0621961094,
0.0368131623,
-0.0308959968,
-0.0381775275,
0.026161911,
-0.0021082102,
-0.0223617777,
0.0078949705,
0.0529970378,
0.0048594223,
-0.0116330488,
0.0167888012,
-0.0246312581,
0.0199972279,
-0.0362257026,
-0.0215242393,
-0.0315488242,
0.002290925,
-0.0581254028,
-0.0133334426,
-0.0031782233,
-0.025249185,
-0.0218906626,
-0.0098445313,
0.0755767748,
0.0364586711,
-0.0411690585,
0.0172891058,
-0.037867371,
-0.0254703667,
-0.0199723598,
-0.051012788,
0.0208895542,
0.0031188,
0.0070196763,
0.0196302105,
-0.0278711244,
0.0021681166,
-0.0113205211,
0.0580071062,
-0.0058054826,
-0.0230763238,
0.0733067021,
-0.020107599,
-0.0576668195,
-0.0345538966,
0.0163595416,
0.0096926084,
0.0525832362,
0.0319006816,
0.0261359066,
-0.0435988866,
-0.0004420702,
0.0446521156,
0.0013388114,
-0.0274307914,
-0.0332363844,
0.0298142433,
-0.0031030651,
-0.0064470451,
-0.02595862,
-0.0188950561,
0.0181481317,
-0.0326270573,
-0.0048465561,
0.0066032684,
-0.053840328,
-0.04892103,
0.0034215755,
-0.095077388,
-0.0113067338,
0.0617238879,
-0.019207133,
-0.0362348184,
-0.0215407386,
-0.0325594842,
0.0666570216,
-0.0121924179,
0.0142734433,
-0.0128722973,
0.0322881266,
0.0277617611,
0.0285999868,
-0.0183656197,
-0.015396391,
0.0107460655,
-0.0116838412,
-0.0081713246,
-0.0314739011,
-0.0515999533,
-0.0226830076,
0.0026091896,
-0.0133998618,
0.0368864238,
0.0408567712,
-0.022658525,
0.0182929859,
-0.0532135814,
-0.0099452604,
-0.0272051711,
-0.029247988,
-0.0036541545,
-0.0151001364,
-0.0122387623,
-0.0389347784,
0.0191583149,
0.0098241186,
-0.0157290716,
-0.0002315848,
-0.0186601281,
0.0099902591,
0.0097293518,
-0.0047304938,
-0.0185486153,
0.0549677163,
0.04508036,
-0.0011790256,
-0.0502041206,
-0.0322899483,
0.0617644489,
0.0073161614,
0.0144267762,
-0.0018966503,
0.0368481949,
0.0240362771,
-0.0346306339,
0.0289362073,
0.0646704584,
-0.0174001344,
0.0437927991,
-0.0365720093,
-0.003281713,
-0.0269860812,
-0.0128203547,
0.0231296625,
-0.0208692979,
0.0037252367,
0.0207303595,
-0.0029017508,
0.0256907828,
-0.059019018,
0.001788837,
-0.0490911044,
0.0159839783,
-0.0181860197,
-0.0829573348,
-0.0888500065,
-0.0274018291,
0.0019772935,
0.0006412117,
-0.0564637855,
-0.0048189727,
-0.0145262163,
-0.0140392315,
-0.0073359376,
0.0170050338,
0.0255414527,
0.01663501,
0.0325482413,
0.0460107774,
0.0044049337,
0.0163090415,
-0.0538687743,
-0.0267265085,
0.0145214032,
-0.0436406806,
-0.0034280503,
0.0236875787,
-0.0278039835,
-0.0090632224,
-0.0184908286,
-0.0151433283,
-0.0355259515,
0.0048960731,
-0.0234447382,
0.0085448027,
-0.0512207635,
-0.0118332561,
-0.0622676648,
0.0187476464,
-0.0159549732,
0.0819793046,
-0.0288200825,
-0.0399805941,
-0.0146224899,
0.0419653468,
0.0318071358,
0.0021442105,
0.0477197021,
-0.1030852497,
0.0186023954,
0.0495555922,
-0.0148154208,
-0.0064074066,
-0.0834607109,
0.0357939042,
0.0186942127,
0.0212731753,
-0.003593198,
0.0119337663,
0.0650520176,
-0.0496351644,
-0.0280677471,
0.0356311053,
-0.0013052311,
-0.0877301618,
-0.0333459601,
-0.0180768576,
0.0032265368,
0.0442554541,
0.0183306783,
-0.0245207213,
-0.033524923,
0.0434935652,
-0.0257158149,
0.0312874094,
0.0057078991,
0.0115036694,
-0.0776394308,
0.0506484024,
-0.0110655539,
-0.0655328482,
-0.0543327518,
0.0368545577,
0.0510062054,
-0.0443151779,
0.0011979778,
-0.0004144654,
-0.0163603313,
-0.0196988732,
0.0020161804,
0.0389190279,
-0.0622370206,
-0.0433345847,
-0.0375590138,
-0.0268090293,
0.0315473378,
-0.0018599479,
-0.0177903119,
-0.0302644689,
0.0073871305,
0.0270627905,
0.0129329991,
0.0343589298,
0.0713569894,
-0.0328564979,
-0.0094006276,
0.0277958121,
0.0096129319,
-0.0175246838,
-0.051228147,
0.0047309217,
0.0170685872,
-0.0040037548,
-0.0293038283,
-0.0510948487,
-0.024599459,
0.0369719975,
0.0415150784,
0.0301278066,
0.0127845313,
-0.0160140395,
0.0234250538,
0.0135611417,
-0.0445655771,
-0.0156376809,
0.0031170358,
0.0217738487,
-0.0445170105,
-0.021342976,
-0.0316404216,
0.0734134912,
0.0756184384,
0.0055775996,
-0.1113067344,
-0.0213394929,
0.0101593435,
-0.0488208458,
0.0394898951,
-0.0314741842,
0.0003378666,
-0.0180479586,
0.0420456603,
0.0158523228,
0.0034267753,
-0.0165355783,
0.0192644838,
-0.0529552214,
0.0082837464,
0.0175168328,
0.0778193921,
0.0219456237,
0.0463962145,
-0.0235192291,
-0.0109635061,
0.1054010317,
-0.006600346,
0.0017994791,
0.0377750881,
0.0579068251,
-0.0978184342,
-0.0245549027,
-0.0035366768,
-0.0388954766,
0.0412897915,
-0.006518248,
-0.0020230873,
-0.0112092933,
0.0149077652,
0.0159839988,
-0.0801366568,
0.0457225293,
-0.018969588,
0.0568469465,
-0.0424034335,
0.0300642531,
0.0419743955,
0.0397636481,
-0.0528090037,
0.0595798492,
-0.004341776,
0.0307917912,
-0.0007000323,
0.0619124249,
0.0045667468,
-0.0176754724,
-0.0670015514,
-0.0368333124,
0.0199399889,
-0.0136466641,
-0.0069349497,
0.0318191424,
0.0040633925,
0.0139202084,
-0.003908338,
0.049248945,
0.0044138762,
0.0170521103,
0.0212404914,
0.0107213492,
-0.0070471135,
0.0153061207,
0.0081552453,
-0.0154556977,
-0.0980331302,
0.0710370168,
0.026124822,
-0.0481540114,
0.0345465243,
-0.0145326685,
-0.0274495147,
0.0034205553,
-0.0228923224,
0.0086613717,
-0.0568254441,
0.0125854723,
0.0053818622,
0.0192832947,
-0.0339183398,
0.0292629208,
-0.0074928892,
0.026660407,
-0.0267985314,
0.0169364307,
-0.0386014022,
-0.0078612641,
0.0720255151,
-0.0274994448,
0.0149927568,
0.0041822451,
0.0441332534,
-0.0448608696,
-0.0282822885,
0.0247806069,
-0.0052052522,
0.0310321208,
0.0452881306,
0.0280292667,
-0.0028674451,
-0.021805767,
0.0299507733,
-0.0370137542,
0.0147931874,
0.0407404825,
0.0227607191,
-5.68702367e-33,
-0.0575507917,
-0.000453965,
0.024058165,
-0.0089885565,
0.0006734235,
0.0360801145,
-0.0231388845,
0.0143351136,
0.0305931028,
0.043151509,
-0.0117081515,
0.0627011508,
0.0280143227,
0.0161307137,
0.0296102688,
0.0026872468,
0.0627245009,
0.0062583,
-0.0206860509,
-0.0192591213,
-0.0052289311,
0.0520241074,
0.0905458853,
-0.018169634,
-0.0084009189,
0.0426569842,
-0.033025004,
0.0068645654,
0.0197343715,
0.0027790002,
-0.0169251729,
-0.0318986885,
-0.0121774646,
-0.0593230836,
-0.0551581308,
0.0211686939,
-0.0680046827,
-0.0163856428,
-0.0360217653,
0.0510112941,
-0.0742492378,
-0.0333922543,
0.0461363941,
0.0129175996,
0.0291973297,
-0.0059876321,
0.034234494,
-0.0354707427,
0.0173581634,
-0.0184092578,
-0.0471647829,
0.0220119394,
-0.0025996,
-0.0148859899,
0.0589755177,
0.0615088977,
0.0105354264,
-0.048754856,
-0.0309741572,
0.0079777157,
0.0394008122,
0.0026547876,
0.0071486714,
0.0497719944,
-0.0325419605,
0.0945792049,
0.0064183595,
-0.061353121,
0.0011150637,
-0.028640585,
0.0131338462,
0.0390463918,
0.0068949927,
0.0084697027,
0.070496276,
0.0388560332,
-0.0032449914,
0.0438794047,
-0.0944678709,
0.0837186947,
0.042251125,
-0.002690637,
0.0197724961,
0.0067578149,
0.0137579357,
-0.0105225267,
-0.0253769346,
-0.0131859612,
0.0379200205,
0.0704567358,
-0.0436133407,
0.058242958,
0.0430394486,
-0.0128251286,
0.057397373,
-0.0066733244,
-0.004415181,
0.0345669873,
0.0003675496,
0.0008059383,
-0.0314287618,
-0.0319296271,
0.0603198782,
0.0516065061,
0.0151500935,
0.0095740259,
0.0724225566,
0.0688320696,
-0.0230987519,
-0.0226523429,
-0.0384718031,
0.0291059762,
0.0110370265,
0.0558664985,
0.0448998883,
-0.0032474231,
-0.0321233086,
0.0414417498,
-0.0555318035,
-0.0032734356,
-0.0522192009,
0.0208328106,
0.0299388003,
0.0523220412,
-0.0281480998,
-0.024568554,
-0.0431197174,
-0.023776345,
0.0296761952,
-0.0793264806,
-0.0229089782,
0.0117705418,
2.595e-7,
-0.0139925955,
-0.0201848671,
0.0694056377,
-0.0121351629,
-0.0048574498,
-0.0037279769,
-0.0158208385,
0.0446805023,
-0.0208268072,
-0.0042553595,
0.0493604839,
0.0603349917,
0.0192538444,
0.0205218159,
-0.0469459556,
-0.0162255988,
-0.0453689061,
0.004248335,
-0.0385795049,
-0.0411136299,
0.0209736917,
0.0997318476,
-0.0134475222,
-0.0248124134,
0.0346751176,
0.0110245841,
0.0674108341,
-0.0006444243,
0.0481313542,
-0.0213684179,
0.0056747128,
0.1082251295,
0.0218989663,
0.0296167918,
0.0050981636,
0.019910641,
0.0686118305,
0.02550718,
-0.0258099083,
0.0025936444,
-0.0001835945,
0.0867765397,
0.0053484766,
-0.0099605219,
0.0615141019,
-0.0954507962,
-0.0001008047,
-0.0359956324,
-0.0569212288,
0.0048223478,
-0.0183536299,
-0.0211498272,
0.0258202814,
-0.0041182558,
0.0324820466,
0.0043481463,
-0.0502831452,
-0.063959606,
0.0236049388,
0.030310059,
-0.0077085528,
-0.0119372765,
-0.0480992123,
-0.0587833896,
-0.0191954635,
-0.0366029702,
-0.0739639997,
1.535976453e-34,
0.007096488,
0.0293728188,
-0.0134003889,
0.0004146517,
-0.0021844287,
-0.0323920026,
0.0027019905,
-0.0362818912,
-0.0321221277,
0.0145933172,
-0.0454047099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17875v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17875v1 | Cloaked Classifiers: Pseudonymization Strategies on Sensitive Classification Tasks | 2024-06-25T18:30:25 | 2024-06-25T18:30:25 | Arij Riabi, Menel Mahamdi, Virginie Mouilleron, Djamé Seddah | cs.CL | cs.CL | Protecting privacy is essential when sharing data, particularly in the case
of an online radicalization dataset that may contain personal information. In
this paper, we explore the balance between preserving data usefulness and
ensuring robust privacy safeguards, since regulations like the European GDPR
shape how personal information must be handled. We share our method for
manually pseudonymizing a multilingual radicalization dataset, ensuring
performance comparable to the original data. Furthermore, we highlight the
importance of establishing comprehensive guidelines for processing sensitive
NLP data by sharing our complete pseudonymization process, our guidelines, the
challenges we encountered as well as the resulting dataset. | [
0.0286637042,
0.0843037292,
-0.0416712314,
0.0251110699,
-0.0303871222,
0.0110881906,
0.117831111,
0.0075701624,
-0.002210953,
0.002794151,
0.0077895867,
-0.0021993823,
-0.0090569789,
-0.0005184879,
0.0124300998,
-0.0414646119,
0.0256094486,
-0.0175567586,
-0.0316865854,
-0.0526925176,
-0.0174158663,
0.0143422773,
0.0078617223,
0.0444941446,
0.0150797255,
-0.0150805498,
0.0113267312,
-0.0488065854,
0.037702024,
0.0279430635,
0.0077438187,
0.0369535573,
0.0093374532,
0.078242369,
0.00000149,
-0.0294723045,
-0.0291775409,
0.0043807854,
-0.0211193077,
-0.0483114533,
0.0406261459,
-0.0383507088,
0.025858311,
0.0079258652,
-0.0677995831,
0.0081373155,
0.0189645048,
0.0531776957,
0.0558720455,
0.051129289,
-0.0037703617,
-0.0540777557,
0.0036945126,
0.0196278449,
0.0131264478,
0.0373435281,
0.0172985811,
-0.0748507977,
-0.0823167041,
0.0068248357,
0.0279814582,
0.0528869554,
-0.0086359568,
0.019729726,
-0.0303486306,
0.0054177218,
-0.0223093368,
-0.0091576409,
0.0402846076,
0.0244445279,
-0.0142903673,
-0.027626479,
0.0328151733,
0.0440795347,
0.023245953,
0.006561141,
0.004344611,
0.0219720956,
-0.0077710203,
0.0038343633,
0.0118336463,
0.0242367871,
0.0409043692,
0.0244282112,
0.0221148077,
0.0072504487,
-0.0342852585,
0.0210528988,
-0.0322686359,
-0.0534581728,
-0.0289234258,
-0.0219774079,
0.0422558635,
-0.0063613299,
0.0151515314,
-0.0025512837,
-0.0914601013,
-0.0802786946,
0.0158970989,
-0.0821173191,
0.0168129466,
0.0128929494,
0.0429932252,
0.0046928404,
-0.0378267802,
0.0034388995,
0.0104714362,
0.0515506789,
-0.0067255949,
-0.0025776068,
-0.0570002608,
-0.004392379,
-0.0106795337,
0.0586642995,
-0.032706771,
0.0262618251,
-0.0711530671,
0.0044082282,
-0.0708789378,
0.0081353169,
-0.0345160477,
0.0079235444,
0.0026461082,
0.0104924506,
0.0169007685,
-0.0425488465,
0.0030111107,
0.0315952301,
-0.0152374683,
-0.0366511792,
0.0261703786,
0.0031339221,
-0.0106842052,
-0.0011893822,
0.0088110203,
0.0790124759,
0.0321188122,
0.0061667771,
-0.0289559066,
-0.0425272174,
0.0381068438,
0.0072139809,
-0.0059902519,
-0.0228400528,
0.0551721305,
-0.04261126,
0.0048238239,
-0.0596017838,
-0.00061577,
0.0113485223,
0.014680149,
0.1195304766,
0.0085085379,
-0.015207951,
0.0180084687,
0.0126059409,
-0.0042503267,
0.0133057451,
0.0210203733,
0.0185696874,
0.0463668406,
-0.0280226674,
0.0527287722,
-0.0158993695,
0.0243805312,
-0.0162458196,
0.0037245399,
0.0041758898,
-0.0092562595,
-0.0320812128,
0.005458869,
0.0121293636,
-0.0117726475,
-0.0799926072,
0.0276446119,
0.0422087759,
-0.0080423104,
0.0200883206,
-0.0304380208,
0.0384652242,
-0.0468209572,
-0.0322402194,
-0.0072364742,
-0.0171400029,
-0.0848953724,
-0.0473309308,
-0.0533078536,
0.048210796,
-0.0221269596,
-0.036004629,
-0.0019175257,
-0.0276557766,
0.0667206272,
0.02518465,
-0.0193492193,
0.0353356414,
0.035133563,
0.0146736633,
0.0138228294,
-0.0294749364,
0.0191078261,
-0.0544701554,
-0.0421287678,
0.0464717485,
-0.0108803287,
-0.0150539773,
0.0220662896,
-0.0836320892,
0.0283352919,
0.0033037276,
-0.0503403284,
-0.0155246239,
0.0514366664,
-0.0187758729,
-0.0353564508,
0.0172279831,
-0.0053076944,
0.0255994461,
0.0480984189,
-0.0203644615,
0.0036999127,
-0.0526933782,
-0.0269787554,
0.0205982495,
-0.0167414639,
-0.0613086,
0.0467581823,
0.0330003351,
0.0500947535,
0.0326161347,
0.0025147782,
-0.0083040576,
0.0080857249,
-0.0086806174,
-0.0420622565,
-0.0227196701,
0.0805999562,
0.0163147934,
-0.0208224766,
-0.0440624095,
0.0141025716,
0.0606332272,
-0.0178765673,
0.0094339075,
0.0295233931,
0.0022945707,
-0.0237836037,
-0.0019016047,
0.007148637,
-0.0281858947,
0.0826634988,
-0.0121785756,
0.0198154002,
-0.0351847522,
0.0395070314,
-0.0453862138,
-0.0526359081,
0.0329819806,
0.0001658619,
-0.0038245027,
-0.0216688011,
-0.0286654774,
0.0352897532,
-0.0023749587,
-0.0275542885,
0.0153922103,
-0.035720773,
0.0014827374,
-0.0110069923,
-0.0094786063,
0.0074625816,
-0.0136041986,
0.0016465189,
-0.0061124549,
-0.0150822708,
-0.018904008,
-0.038261544,
-0.0417176336,
0.0426715128,
0.0179805327,
-0.01529832,
-0.0325961262,
0.0571581125,
-0.0104653724,
0.007113569,
0.0536271147,
-0.0187748261,
-0.0707048774,
0.0122016119,
-0.0261209998,
-0.0387447737,
0.0296755377,
-0.0419147126,
-0.0144066364,
0.0177575164,
0.0299310628,
-0.0286736935,
0.0230583008,
0.0310675092,
0.0386614613,
0.048545368,
0.0630347207,
-0.0345118418,
-0.0312618501,
-0.0235757586,
-0.0048196767,
-0.0326587148,
-0.0464059971,
-0.0015358997,
-0.0445298813,
0.0349981301,
-0.0457608849,
-0.0260872934,
0.0226078238,
-0.0368602164,
-0.0552544594,
-0.0510871597,
-0.0035038125,
0.0058269384,
0.0047368603,
-0.000553592,
-0.0256013833,
0.0622024722,
0.010260025,
0.0397013575,
0.0151173957,
-0.0480328128,
-0.001454705,
0.0298904851,
0.0054738289,
0.0373868234,
0.0490513071,
-0.041278027,
0.0370820239,
-0.0014908032,
0.0211679954,
-0.0397659391,
-0.0454191342,
0.0303949192,
-0.0035631459,
0.0126185315,
-0.0186858978,
-0.0705191419,
-0.0673143268,
0.0243049432,
-0.0048599979,
-0.0048987777,
-0.0469163023,
-0.038629692,
-0.0067768451,
0.0633766428,
0.0150819235,
0.0237761345,
-0.0066995081,
-0.0097703217,
-0.0342244804,
-0.0456798933,
-0.0545615964,
0.0326415114,
-0.00155894,
0.0031502913,
0.0605944507,
0.0461442247,
-0.0151691549,
0.0147857433,
-0.0115905842,
0.0297439862,
-0.0425279252,
-0.0049517141,
-0.0251864623,
-0.0025804513,
-0.0013965621,
0.0494553037,
0.0515254177,
0.0057808799,
-0.0187510531,
0.0123331891,
0.0624213368,
-0.01343155,
0.0190500431,
-0.0173614472,
-0.0940780118,
0.0388188809,
0.0192901809,
0.0768906251,
-0.1098002493,
-0.0631254688,
-0.0091112778,
-0.0168103222,
-0.0071652588,
-0.0114435293,
-0.0533401668,
-0.0113127837,
-0.0685254633,
-0.021233974,
0.009205685,
0.0232964568,
-0.0742084607,
0.0122565757,
-0.0075782621,
0.0126949772,
-0.0479869433,
-0.0289219897,
-0.030479515,
-0.0137309572,
0.0405111164,
-0.0291281808,
0.0344149843,
-0.0109197171,
0.0033906393,
0.0029944654,
0.0015804179,
-0.0209912714,
-0.0300174896,
0.1108132973,
0.0040682293,
-0.0285936315,
-0.0142414682,
0.0519394949,
-0.0215678737,
-0.0165654961,
0.0157057066,
-0.0055136732,
-0.0190999899,
-0.0111121107,
0.0170443915,
-0.0054988661,
0.0422020257,
0.0380749516,
-0.0225477237,
-0.0162556432,
0.0376773626,
-0.0460580774,
0.0177049898,
-0.0430509821,
-0.0472363569,
0.0130936475,
-0.0104338042,
-0.0652060658,
-0.0012302431,
0.0019899551,
0.0016601034,
0.0326735303,
0.0333106592,
0.0285102688,
-0.005893081,
-0.005021025,
-0.0643273592,
0.0039722417,
-0.0054430915,
0.0358877815,
-0.0045546959,
-0.0262426306,
0.0034351179,
0.0077825645,
-0.0089057256,
0.0166780204,
-0.0414440148,
-0.0634801388,
0.0605707243,
-0.0102690058,
0.0185198449,
0.0393723808,
-0.0308334008,
-0.0677413344,
0.1039874032,
0.0556978434,
0.0200239718,
-0.0105246138,
0.0555391721,
0.0084991595,
-0.0151715577,
0.0237592384,
0.034754917,
0.0007835893,
0.0561480448,
-0.0760898963,
-0.0981067121,
0.0307384171,
-0.0115706632,
0.0102186706,
0.0299340989,
-0.0110599641,
-0.018396439,
-0.0082068034,
-0.0026430152,
-0.0289334115,
-0.0241702888,
0.0398320444,
-0.026621284,
0.0604222156,
0.0247150995,
0.0255642273,
0.0289542694,
-0.0134573551,
-0.0164179895,
-0.0530795418,
0.0115966033,
0.0118695227,
0.0368992724,
-0.0067963563,
0.029840596,
-0.0083135143,
0.0679019317,
0.0329015404,
0.0188835841,
-0.0076532313,
-0.0499306358,
0.0165531989,
0.0255841818,
-0.0201235283,
0.0316445678,
-0.0477120243,
-0.0580053404,
-0.0262460336,
0.0267956015,
-0.0364169255,
0.032136552,
-0.0141012259,
-0.0055076675,
-0.0149556147,
0.0050891326,
0.0089726532,
-0.0334716588,
-0.0475268327,
-0.0082975579,
-0.0078744311,
-0.0301967841,
0.0596188083,
0.048861362,
0.01092037,
0.0209410209,
0.0248473529,
-0.0388918258,
-0.025434535,
-0.0106680766,
-0.0065317182,
0.0524678454,
-0.0174681135,
0.0137487752,
-0.0062407004,
-0.0485519804,
0.0182738826,
-0.0317317583,
0.01930614,
0.0084753353,
-0.0103991693,
0.0135910567,
-0.004634032,
-0.0039953114,
-0.0959377661,
0.0288439766,
0.0138618201,
-0.044768326,
0.0235628653,
-4.645823671e-33,
0.0350010768,
-0.0169872269,
-0.0282254964,
0.0387013033,
0.0448394455,
0.0279635936,
0.0512541458,
0.0140947532,
-0.0181740467,
-0.00636813,
-0.0223217327,
-0.0007024148,
0.0016992568,
0.0317466147,
-0.0422676317,
-0.0393149741,
0.0363112316,
0.0026883823,
-0.0089392141,
-0.000732203,
0.0946629718,
0.0162640922,
0.0508309677,
-0.1160299256,
0.0648703724,
0.050706774,
-0.0501870066,
0.0114909504,
-0.0229751244,
0.0460812151,
-0.0265388563,
0.0683043823,
0.0057995645,
0.0284537077,
-0.0036355963,
0.0420344174,
-0.0525442064,
0.00518823,
-0.0281840898,
0.0452137217,
0.0555102155,
-0.0676903054,
0.0281564482,
-0.0455848575,
-0.0369190574,
0.0049515273,
0.0251107328,
-0.0213808883,
-0.0188626628,
-0.0382095128,
0.0092747621,
-0.0201335754,
-0.0468104035,
0.0286644325,
0.0594156347,
0.0271427874,
0.0384325832,
-0.0257023852,
-0.1110614911,
0.0283252504,
-0.0350169241,
-0.0338645093,
0.0485190898,
0.0172001459,
0.027983889,
0.0359956138,
0.0451359898,
0.0387456082,
-0.0036375748,
0.0380831994,
0.0071894797,
-0.0007949742,
0.0578450523,
0.074846074,
0.0024431739,
-0.0570871457,
-0.0219486039,
0.0115937702,
0.0163836703,
-0.0492545962,
0.0500821769,
-0.0009278083,
-0.0679831505,
-0.0227185749,
-0.0529620573,
-0.0649236217,
-0.0320264548,
0.0098118614,
-0.0296399947,
-0.016428411,
-0.0683402196,
0.0046474943,
0.0038377696,
-0.0189768001,
-0.038276542,
0.0002876284,
0.0670480207,
0.0547350347,
0.0151789971,
0.0039304104,
0.0389254726,
-0.0216603465,
0.0369272754,
-0.0339387469,
0.0571753792,
-0.0348486118,
0.0788780898,
0.0084314728,
-0.0637873635,
-0.0179293379,
0.0058785575,
0.0692078099,
0.0377342999,
0.047630772,
0.0135881081,
0.0267655943,
-0.0113146994,
-0.0306285955,
0.0476528592,
0.030362606,
0.0101770554,
0.0191221945,
-0.0384435654,
-0.0094584571,
0.028935574,
-0.0106727267,
-0.0050063864,
0.027530754,
0.0795484409,
-0.031397447,
-0.0138306757,
-0.0482963137,
2.383e-7,
0.0065869512,
-0.0090426765,
-0.0038544196,
-0.0258636959,
-0.0198953003,
0.0405578278,
0.0789901242,
0.0603710823,
-0.0189356618,
-0.0248707533,
-0.042175822,
0.0160697307,
0.0279393531,
0.0120083932,
-0.0611237101,
-0.086052008,
0.0606393181,
0.0197432935,
-0.0704536587,
0.0402725562,
0.0021386789,
0.057108894,
0.0822603703,
-0.0150136491,
-0.0312350616,
-0.0192325953,
-0.012309148,
-0.0633616447,
-0.0470507629,
-0.004882989,
0.0509572253,
0.0149727305,
0.0382555835,
0.0244344864,
-0.0319169611,
-0.006750131,
-0.0079666227,
0.0279389005,
0.0303093251,
0.0006747295,
-0.0303174313,
-0.0677560493,
-0.0117059834,
-0.0144625222,
0.0403375588,
0.0196858849,
-0.0529067069,
-0.0024014048,
-0.0202689972,
-0.0109123942,
0.0679592192,
-0.0122871026,
-0.0086983722,
0.0249867532,
0.0498036705,
0.0074879616,
0.0170174278,
-0.0545215495,
-0.0058326521,
-0.042827893,
-0.0292660091,
0.0090988316,
0.0564833283,
0.0316014178,
0.0244572163,
0.0280039441,
0.0418997072,
2.247809685e-34,
-0.0170217361,
0.0193876848,
-0.0075546452,
-0.0092212632,
0.0386792943,
0.0128901852,
0.030233983,
-0.0019721768,
0.008068338,
-0.0392566249,
-0.0029937334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17873v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17873v1 | Improving Arithmetic Reasoning Ability of Large Language Models through Relation Tuples, Verification and Dynamic Feedback | 2024-06-25T18:21:00 | 2024-06-25T18:21:00 | Zhongtao Miao, Kaiyan Zhao, Yoshimasa Tsuruoka | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Current representations used in reasoning steps of large language models can
mostly be categorized into two main types: (1) natural language, which is
difficult to verify; and (2) non-natural language, usually programming code,
which is difficult for people who are unfamiliar with coding to read. In this
paper, we propose to use a semi-structured form to represent reasoning steps of
large language models. Specifically, we use relation tuples, which are not only
human-readable but also machine-friendly and easier to verify than natural
language. We implement a framework that includes three main components: (1)
introducing relation tuples into the reasoning steps of large language models;
(2) implementing an automatic verification process of reasoning steps with a
local code interpreter based on relation tuples; and (3) integrating a simple
and effective dynamic feedback mechanism, which we found helpful for
self-improvement of large language models. The experimental results on various
arithmetic datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in improving
the arithmetic reasoning ability of large language models. The source code is
available at https://github.com/gpgg/art. | [
-0.0099420762,
0.0940594375,
-0.0183505658,
0.0657866821,
-0.0298240315,
0.0135783525,
0.0059477999,
-0.0123023754,
0.0020911035,
-0.0503075793,
-0.0013968281,
0.0207605604,
0.0270042717,
0.0233551245,
0.0229209755,
-0.0526955575,
0.0293316822,
-0.0704473034,
0.0272787139,
-0.0042703599,
-0.0098028369,
0.0133560933,
-0.0205897037,
0.0024449686,
0.0009834321,
-0.0713910982,
0.0068692756,
-0.0533824712,
0.0093613444,
-0.0050564706,
-0.0396549329,
0.0566132143,
0.0053731604,
0.0308041107,
0.0000021459,
-0.0413536392,
-0.0330906324,
0.0301221013,
-0.0680427551,
0.0401594676,
0.0096551329,
-0.0074395398,
0.0004056041,
0.0319126137,
-0.0564103797,
-0.0115170926,
0.0284209959,
-0.0150741702,
0.1012681201,
0.0664177835,
-0.0003364806,
-0.0674352944,
0.0230751354,
0.0374477841,
0.0142688276,
-0.0203711111,
0.0182046592,
0.1094552726,
0.03619859,
0.0131493239,
0.0050013554,
-0.0077720731,
0.0506078564,
-0.0394605733,
-0.0299694147,
-0.0020290969,
-0.0171240214,
-0.0041389666,
0.0003969038,
0.0275228433,
0.0196878314,
-0.0326567218,
-0.016373517,
0.0148084452,
-0.0023698972,
0.0200581066,
-0.0561947785,
0.0342758484,
-0.001478983,
0.0190902762,
0.0129613876,
-0.0107972156,
0.0204981137,
0.0016016974,
-0.0773796886,
0.0851325765,
0.0042318003,
-0.0294485334,
-0.0410152376,
-0.0436658747,
-0.0459771976,
-0.0518444888,
0.0280545838,
0.0943562165,
-0.0278082825,
0.0290452912,
-0.0131817851,
-0.0159437153,
0.0065158377,
-0.0886808485,
0.0210325178,
0.0633715168,
0.0182781704,
0.054914847,
-0.0163652543,
0.076493904,
-0.0285291839,
0.0019157433,
-0.0079883812,
0.0330255106,
-0.018450262,
-0.0180602986,
-0.0515900217,
0.0270115696,
0.0202766936,
0.0350233503,
-0.0396309681,
0.0232145879,
-0.0340712816,
0.0568479225,
0.0101211164,
-0.059478879,
0.0491641089,
-0.0237091798,
-0.019012427,
-0.0088166827,
-0.0417317674,
-0.0315781496,
-0.0265607405,
-0.0413414687,
0.006437141,
-0.0259276889,
-0.0052860565,
-0.0270935968,
0.007415582,
0.0708791167,
0.0393850394,
0.0103746904,
0.0149759781,
-0.0359145403,
0.0427272245,
-0.0519980863,
-0.0018605012,
-0.096118547,
0.0072848448,
0.041242063,
0.0004711674,
-0.0474839769,
0.0000293143,
0.0217550062,
-0.0089775166,
0.0597145744,
-0.0206187535,
0.0234994888,
-0.0280345287,
-0.0105805947,
0.0085164094,
0.0091404431,
0.077032052,
-0.0429639854,
0.030530639,
-0.0208283085,
0.0081850169,
0.0350560173,
0.0127347307,
-0.0237265229,
-0.0809006318,
0.0261476059,
0.0017594941,
-0.001917486,
-0.0339509062,
0.0484144613,
-0.0304878131,
-0.0259141605,
-0.0246873647,
0.0038613838,
0.023930084,
0.045054283,
0.0281580482,
0.0166830961,
0.0366311967,
-0.0111220824,
-0.0387283489,
0.0206760988,
-0.0411820449,
0.0054813586,
-0.0010404458,
0.0138193984,
0.0140294041,
-0.0795672759,
-0.0318076797,
0.0092581259,
0.0350532867,
0.0266764835,
0.0579081103,
0.0030262244,
-0.0008087559,
0.0553901084,
0.0301478896,
-0.048011627,
-0.0398230851,
-0.0602919273,
0.0543500222,
0.0241026841,
0.0482323729,
-0.0642251149,
0.0028169327,
-0.0223552398,
-0.0171637312,
-0.0149813341,
0.0118373735,
-0.0237915833,
-0.0396452732,
-0.0298137758,
-0.013975394,
0.0170500223,
0.0117360875,
-0.0146511998,
0.0364935473,
-0.014262937,
0.0089022797,
-0.029961748,
0.0181330368,
0.0043320046,
-0.017272044,
-0.0086981962,
-0.0246722065,
0.0209606029,
-0.0129171852,
0.0357132517,
0.0020086551,
0.059348654,
0.0283705443,
-0.0023525874,
-0.004146114,
-0.0049033025,
-0.0146397119,
-0.0264008343,
0.062251389,
0.0188460909,
-0.0496941656,
0.0078304578,
-0.0383040942,
0.0038624262,
0.0563972928,
-0.0483557917,
0.0043026614,
0.0071386327,
0.0275291018,
-0.0111438883,
-0.0381516926,
0.0020175874,
0.0723070428,
0.0025166639,
0.0187785365,
-0.0012214236,
0.0132007627,
0.0301572978,
-0.0003377083,
0.0244033951,
0.0251876768,
-0.0065393378,
0.019806942,
0.025620155,
0.0069468967,
0.0023358536,
0.0093491077,
-0.0154872583,
-0.0246918257,
-0.0112205502,
0.048829481,
0.0123750232,
-0.0046342118,
0.0020667431,
-0.0141428579,
-0.0174565949,
-0.0203636736,
0.0076474138,
-0.0107312743,
0.0354430303,
-0.0182343498,
-0.0532228276,
-0.0056733117,
-0.0448066331,
-0.0618923157,
0.0757725835,
0.014361226,
0.0128818685,
-0.046871271,
0.0314045213,
-0.0129668396,
0.0028697439,
0.0016665801,
-0.0120100426,
0.0138853956,
-0.0351205431,
0.0231140889,
0.0286631603,
-0.0294453856,
0.0348904319,
0.0367350467,
-0.0040725577,
-0.0459405966,
0.0028097248,
0.0119690057,
-0.0059155417,
0.0080672493,
-0.0283797253,
-0.0515964255,
0.0855588391,
-0.0335771777,
-0.0153733669,
-0.0282962844,
0.0364831723,
-0.0039643985,
0.0612907559,
-0.0439041816,
-0.0020375287,
0.0080741774,
0.0504160784,
-0.000161664,
-0.0660745353,
0.0545534343,
-0.0039217942,
-0.013696257,
-0.0512778796,
0.008296039,
-0.0668043196,
0.098727636,
-0.0015830497,
0.0169595312,
-0.0302773956,
-0.0192604754,
-0.0081912344,
-0.0284664296,
0.0576133318,
-0.0425174795,
0.0624827258,
-0.0268692374,
0.0190416146,
0.0034560319,
-0.0208702609,
-0.0457202829,
0.0325637199,
-0.0565068126,
0.0321567655,
-0.0268625561,
-0.0164352227,
0.0273447745,
0.0090367515,
0.0350040905,
0.0222027861,
-0.0048317639,
-0.0154360356,
-0.0230404753,
-0.0079240128,
-0.0139259752,
-0.0054172841,
0.0079575572,
-0.0135832531,
0.0306090601,
0.0087363767,
0.0506700315,
0.0096575469,
-0.0598605685,
0.009664976,
0.0152841881,
-0.0364987254,
-0.0152102616,
0.0516640916,
-0.0188962556,
-0.0906685516,
-0.0021334295,
0.1117873564,
0.0435141586,
-0.0033418029,
0.0369960405,
-0.0614653602,
-0.0090034558,
0.0508022234,
0.0558036827,
-0.0921758711,
-0.0023102222,
-0.0123587484,
-0.0383588299,
0.0253682472,
-0.0344570577,
-0.0001727755,
-0.1087221131,
0.0288130175,
0.0389038995,
-0.0218467806,
-0.0489924662,
-0.0388964154,
-0.0284090172,
0.0042956425,
-0.035924986,
0.0698548853,
-0.0278351884,
-0.0023291921,
0.0037408138,
-0.0198189002,
-0.0212981738,
0.0537297204,
-0.0112967202,
0.0055720494,
0.0527743325,
0.0252342653,
-0.0041137896,
-0.0311313439,
0.0346703008,
0.0676260963,
-0.0201268941,
-0.0165798683,
-0.013809449,
0.0170742646,
-0.0147515796,
-0.0141558051,
0.0140249934,
-0.058522027,
-0.0381692499,
0.0062345737,
0.1213040277,
-0.0102321561,
-0.0001296104,
-0.0162020531,
-0.01533869,
-0.0121492567,
0.0260833148,
0.0075177643,
0.0231563877,
-0.0347099788,
-0.0670409426,
-0.0428140201,
0.0036239382,
-0.0377927423,
0.010602857,
0.0219921526,
-0.0155880926,
-0.027961256,
0.0093500316,
0.0515243001,
0.0232236031,
-0.0119328192,
-0.0191612877,
0.0807411075,
0.0009626361,
-0.066362083,
-0.0044321944,
-0.0423134826,
0.0548442267,
0.0021238106,
0.0093560256,
-0.0048478371,
0.005084666,
-0.0291071758,
-0.0234594997,
-0.0543748625,
-0.0263188798,
-0.0313341506,
0.065797098,
0.026272051,
-0.0085755736,
-0.0129495589,
-0.0448595658,
-0.0274150521,
0.0015675623,
-0.0566088557,
-0.0338968299,
0.0138736721,
0.0105979322,
0.0095384512,
0.0204733275,
-0.0151997572,
0.0055350713,
-0.022822937,
0.0304017048,
-0.0603231378,
0.0133514749,
0.0533376075,
0.0534953997,
-0.0159919094,
0.0373919383,
0.0059140208,
-0.0013078295,
0.0200130288,
-0.0761136413,
-0.0446331389,
-0.0595538355,
0.0702522472,
-0.0189372804,
-0.0288887639,
0.0025972461,
-0.0585766546,
0.0051878365,
0.0010812576,
0.0217802096,
0.0688000023,
-0.0012934499,
0.0324116088,
0.0467366315,
-0.0462197959,
0.0181563031,
-0.0067338347,
-0.0090193544,
0.0111318631,
-0.0087298919,
0.0473740399,
0.025750326,
0.014002447,
-0.0276586674,
-0.0403793044,
0.0189509634,
-0.0898103192,
0.0071254633,
0.0172909461,
0.0318037532,
0.0401665159,
0.0129466653,
-0.0601922236,
-0.0048715314,
-0.0117192445,
0.0540152416,
0.0351585969,
-0.0371804088,
0.0093992734,
0.0526581518,
-0.0011542111,
-0.0507022254,
0.0575412735,
-0.0361633152,
0.0092179514,
0.0119832465,
-0.0309367403,
-0.0445787273,
-0.04742321,
-0.0249845143,
-0.0345939435,
-0.02925268,
0.0158779733,
-0.0694619492,
-0.1090311036,
-0.0588663481,
0.0348308831,
0.0176198743,
-0.0041200784,
0.0331691168,
0.0485240743,
0.0012215942,
-0.0055861343,
-0.0278765261,
0.0327534638,
-0.0487136245,
-0.0289971493,
-0.0231963806,
-5.372772153e-33,
-0.0324483104,
-0.0360320136,
0.0461373776,
-0.0334482417,
0.0435740761,
-0.0362235457,
-0.0470619164,
0.0260575879,
0.0015239236,
0.02319091,
0.0192858409,
0.0336296186,
-0.0044693714,
-0.0313004553,
-0.0052749435,
-0.0112737715,
0.031563282,
-0.0065453104,
-0.0304328017,
-0.0184219852,
0.0159480777,
-0.0232945923,
0.0649286583,
-0.0682596341,
0.0353479609,
-0.0274862554,
-0.0240320228,
0.0548152626,
-0.0550762005,
0.080201149,
0.0111247739,
0.0053859721,
-0.0045302827,
-0.0131467739,
-0.0322608612,
0.012341802,
-0.0672327131,
-0.0249192491,
0.0260691512,
0.014550237,
-0.0314192139,
-0.025673762,
0.0295602959,
0.0036529729,
-0.033459194,
-0.013334359,
0.0155235855,
-0.0440392233,
0.0040132133,
0.0127251744,
-0.0520100445,
0.0426411033,
-0.0371782407,
-0.0088081528,
0.0138116749,
0.0133654745,
-0.0391982719,
-0.0248968024,
-0.0064796885,
0.0220084842,
0.0523773655,
0.0138830282,
0.0530026294,
-0.0348609462,
0.0134764155,
-0.0012997293,
-0.0031078891,
-0.0110948225,
-0.0242879,
0.017270796,
0.0147183035,
0.0511307642,
0.0483605042,
-0.0010906527,
0.0763414353,
0.0125176273,
-0.0568266436,
0.0014032873,
0.0213947576,
0.0565804839,
0.0238139015,
0.0046839253,
-0.0527581349,
-0.0239771381,
-0.0356227346,
0.0375786871,
-0.056764178,
-0.0462311208,
-0.0089207282,
-0.0246078856,
-0.0451055691,
0.0359880254,
-0.0021772927,
-0.0579576865,
-0.0650912151,
0.0421688668,
-0.0172464028,
0.0013458714,
-0.0143791884,
0.0344747417,
0.022302011,
-0.015132118,
-0.0463520288,
-0.0531301461,
0.0461919717,
0.0587289333,
0.0018436266,
0.0325785689,
-0.055955641,
-0.0141305057,
-0.0346329324,
-0.0318699777,
0.0169231407,
0.0091855312,
0.0292231012,
0.017935263,
0.0240598023,
0.0683300868,
-0.002553161,
-0.0229367968,
-0.0211733561,
0.0717357621,
-0.0054512471,
0.0286924858,
0.0185173694,
-0.0771688297,
-0.0547884665,
0.022962587,
0.0525100455,
-0.0146515146,
-0.0135743963,
0.0085105561,
2.776e-7,
0.0366674885,
0.0731463656,
0.0432369076,
0.0979199558,
0.0226311199,
0.0246897824,
-0.0047992081,
-0.0108597185,
0.0174239818,
-0.0360070542,
-0.0075083431,
0.0300335195,
0.0281471908,
0.0365226455,
0.0050697997,
0.0022151174,
-0.0218872279,
-0.0393370613,
-0.0538468137,
0.0141593525,
0.0490969978,
0.043681182,
0.0525032729,
0.0314688347,
-0.0025375299,
-0.0336407945,
0.0283162482,
-0.0055014314,
0.0083917966,
0.0147487279,
-0.0119492868,
-0.0312854312,
0.0169922914,
-0.0083732614,
0.0163577553,
0.0275875013,
0.0087714372,
0.0874570757,
-0.0085342461,
0.0811577067,
-0.0166601092,
-0.0633482561,
-0.007731603,
-0.0324155614,
0.0484223552,
-0.0552490763,
-0.0493526608,
-0.0249434151,
0.0298184678,
-0.0376664139,
0.0049098078,
0.012884385,
0.0090047857,
0.0146821933,
0.0200771224,
-0.0269545261,
-0.0012740883,
-0.0421417803,
-0.0544915423,
0.0178398844,
-0.0333555005,
-0.0276467316,
-0.0142296096,
-0.0054911016,
-0.0001378635,
-0.0255249087,
0.0186309181,
2.886586172e-34,
0.0603624396,
-0.0072483746,
0.0242708623,
0.0482465327,
0.0773725659,
-0.0275059659,
-0.0187129527,
0.0589585006,
0.0690758228,
-0.0343117639,
-0.0247288495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17764v1 | BMIKE-53: Investigating Cross-Lingual Knowledge Editing with In-Context Learning | 2024-06-25T17:48:56 | 2024-06-25T17:48:56 | Ercong Nie, Bo Shao, Zifeng Ding, Mingyang Wang, Helmut Schmid, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) possess extensive parametric knowledge, but this
knowledge is difficult to update with new information because retraining is
very expensive and infeasible for closed-source models. Knowledge editing (KE)
has emerged as a viable solution for updating the knowledge of LLMs without
compromising their overall performance. On-the-fly KE methods, inspired by
in-context learning (ICL), have shown great promise and allow LLMs to be
treated as black boxes. In the past, KE was primarily employed in English
contexts, whereas the potential for cross-lingual KE in current English-centric
LLMs has not been fully explored. To foster more research in this direction, we
introduce the BMIKE-53 benchmark for evaluating cross-lingual KE on 53 diverse
languages across three KE task types. We also propose a gradient-free KE method
called Multilingual In-context Knowledge Editing (MIKE) and evaluate it on
BMIKE-53. Our evaluation focuses on cross-lingual knowledge transfer in terms
of reliability, generality, locality, and portability, offering valuable
insights and a framework for future research in cross-lingual KE. Our code and
data are publicly accessible via the anonymous repository at
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/MIKE. | [
0.012926816,
0.0136744734,
-0.0068948083,
0.0735103115,
-0.0556188039,
-0.0002736666,
0.0008471308,
-0.0184002165,
-0.0261767413,
-0.0463827364,
-0.1156246588,
-0.0150086377,
0.0343142152,
-0.0085986517,
0.0282921977,
-0.0518577471,
0.0536368154,
-0.0349563435,
-0.043535687,
0.0162140112,
-0.0345839672,
-0.0001707176,
0.0014453297,
0.0151356701,
0.0122707468,
-0.0188727714,
-0.003319981,
0.0270483084,
0.0475719534,
0.0034822568,
0.0349639542,
0.0410274304,
-0.0069998675,
0.0379902311,
0.0000022439,
-0.0545279831,
-0.0270662792,
0.0015824089,
0.0134093231,
0.037368156,
0.0127144204,
-0.0536686406,
-0.0490065329,
-0.023344826,
-0.0249580573,
0.0202858318,
0.0505827591,
0.0115881981,
0.0559503734,
0.0882433355,
-0.0064757084,
0.0202060882,
0.0370704345,
-0.051583901,
0.0123514701,
-0.0316406041,
0.0565739051,
0.0103545673,
-0.0678579211,
0.0021741772,
-0.0415992588,
0.068003282,
0.0112993792,
-0.0144894719,
0.0125936707,
-0.0074425307,
-0.0283117928,
0.0161854457,
-0.0227177572,
0.0730098709,
-0.0334761404,
-0.0049538203,
-0.026921656,
-0.0010221393,
0.0117747122,
-0.0200353134,
-0.0406565256,
-0.0098296441,
0.028004149,
0.0076924372,
-0.0081442753,
-0.0560396984,
0.061482951,
-0.0026384857,
0.0013316016,
0.0499646366,
0.0360387936,
-0.0277769398,
0.0009248033,
0.009740727,
0.0066240155,
-0.0826529339,
-0.0219070241,
0.0156048676,
-0.0086326664,
0.0109578585,
-0.0671219751,
-0.0068305698,
-0.0045545436,
-0.060036093,
0.0538394488,
0.0465140939,
-0.0431286022,
0.0696598887,
-0.0164947491,
0.0263901502,
-0.0003429631,
0.0187209658,
-0.0271582846,
-0.0111049954,
-0.0490654074,
0.0180919673,
-0.0179016013,
-0.0089339726,
-0.0546402372,
0.0202341434,
-0.0605770051,
0.0156504307,
-0.028033847,
0.0068358076,
0.0125410911,
-0.0423079282,
-0.0357550308,
-0.013548445,
-0.0094823427,
0.0414065011,
0.0179670937,
0.0203105081,
-0.0015237863,
-0.0295169167,
0.0025675481,
-0.0147337532,
0.0010501783,
-0.0677988753,
0.0351673812,
0.0668000281,
-0.0557731688,
-0.0271677841,
-0.062952809,
-0.0172167718,
-0.0096442709,
-0.0773203,
-0.0145550109,
-0.0711513162,
0.0408545472,
-0.019457398,
-0.0130583309,
-0.0578064881,
0.0029529934,
-0.0077357367,
-0.029044833,
0.084265165,
-0.0013147168,
0.0250400323,
0.0312952027,
0.0224619135,
-0.0474391915,
0.0879601091,
0.017082775,
-0.0284430329,
0.0790090188,
0.00302859,
-0.0208742153,
0.0582698286,
0.0389529318,
0.0492477827,
-0.020154478,
-0.0018863134,
0.0469475277,
0.0226853862,
0.0365022719,
-0.0031112691,
-0.0218834188,
0.0078960797,
0.0988916755,
0.0117721409,
0.0177253429,
0.0217169672,
0.0514738373,
-0.034456674,
0.0069894148,
-0.0245215781,
-0.0568380021,
0.0285214912,
-0.0192756131,
-0.0011322151,
0.0138246762,
0.0434776023,
-0.0191678349,
-0.0292245056,
0.0196791962,
-0.0088604204,
0.0127321538,
0.006867798,
0.0596751161,
0.038185209,
-0.0178639926,
0.0330377817,
0.0480085611,
-0.0195699427,
0.0217871591,
-0.008845428,
-0.0067242594,
0.0597305931,
0.0272560362,
-0.0224199705,
-0.0416843519,
-0.0258302186,
0.0188666005,
0.0057191583,
0.0320316292,
-0.0301813558,
0.0403115153,
-0.0345151238,
-0.0205995552,
-0.0446359366,
0.0136097595,
0.0080581531,
0.0559160411,
0.0503301322,
0.0213287584,
-0.0415970683,
0.0172680542,
0.0074669775,
-0.0717876479,
-0.0080043329,
0.0039637256,
0.0137530109,
0.0105167776,
-0.0143790245,
-0.010485813,
-0.0237847473,
-0.012005535,
-0.0283588748,
0.0028402763,
0.0286445692,
-0.0353062339,
-0.0564282611,
0.0524023958,
-0.0194200557,
-0.0373305939,
-0.0014587322,
-0.0430792831,
-0.0217162017,
0.0005268003,
0.024970511,
0.0538528189,
-0.0379202329,
0.0351800993,
-0.0042712023,
-0.0054908935,
0.0175275393,
0.0303805992,
-0.001045396,
-0.0202045552,
0.0346631482,
-0.0146720009,
-0.0147780925,
-0.0099787265,
-0.0068072467,
0.0340951793,
-0.019472722,
-0.0134948343,
-0.0143756866,
0.0333083272,
-0.0407699645,
0.0156408846,
-0.1171921194,
0.010548166,
-0.0191725343,
0.0077508786,
0.0420049503,
0.0487001576,
-0.0145526379,
-0.0134005854,
-0.0162523612,
-0.0034687642,
-0.020377947,
0.0458700769,
0.0125588682,
0.0187901985,
0.0251070857,
-0.0486699417,
0.0039332304,
0.0310512055,
0.0397251844,
-0.0310616586,
-0.0205784813,
-0.0520436428,
0.0316991843,
-0.0705444217,
-0.001158733,
-0.0119143864,
-0.0242111962,
-0.0468299873,
0.0018380162,
0.0901577845,
0.0507329591,
-0.0402478799,
-0.0179536529,
0.0667926595,
-0.0612336509,
-0.0274334028,
0.022125287,
0.0289077647,
-0.0190799758,
-0.0538576953,
-0.0187543333,
0.0061414177,
0.0627427995,
-0.0181930084,
-0.039371673,
-0.0510151461,
0.0008311504,
-0.0115822572,
-0.023784088,
-0.0891912431,
0.0248494744,
-0.00523833,
0.0409953892,
-0.0511773266,
-0.0364497043,
0.058365263,
-0.0191154983,
0.0121573918,
-0.028209351,
-0.0230309498,
-0.0163464695,
0.0536243021,
-0.0516748801,
0.0361446403,
-0.0356319025,
0.0222774427,
-0.0788481385,
-0.0199557506,
0.0373590961,
-0.00392775,
0.0613143332,
-0.0897916183,
0.0044070524,
-0.0076917736,
-0.0365119725,
-0.0124798333,
0.0165748522,
-0.0113482904,
0.0073623946,
-0.0031664826,
-0.032081265,
-0.0152113875,
-0.0259195045,
0.0677707642,
0.069373332,
-0.0003442996,
-0.0136091327,
-0.0021299648,
0.0205838084,
0.0146830082,
-0.0008714876,
0.0031157755,
-0.0205274355,
0.0113683343,
0.0464840122,
0.0129757049,
-0.0547165312,
0.0094113508,
0.0068198815,
0.0049830275,
-0.0447921157,
-0.0161464941,
-0.0149220983,
0.0787095204,
-0.0616702139,
-0.031591583,
0.0618826561,
0.0070643038,
-0.0493285097,
0.0149233714,
-0.0455505215,
-0.0138494251,
0.0343143418,
0.0373160094,
-0.0820666403,
-0.0338804573,
0.0249862839,
0.0049133818,
0.0182987321,
-0.0375966467,
-0.0123205781,
-0.1097575054,
0.0186768081,
0.0146713546,
-0.0971476361,
-0.052549243,
-0.0449287295,
0.0167866256,
-0.0081106992,
0.0142590133,
0.0187952146,
0.0092662405,
-0.0139330402,
-0.034076713,
-0.0008682794,
-0.0933343694,
0.0480528325,
-0.0347039364,
0.0313446485,
0.0216919277,
0.0282220263,
0.0122157801,
-0.0322187506,
0.0538033023,
-0.0042233486,
-0.0058144885,
-0.0240657087,
0.0275207609,
-0.00653505,
-0.0118701821,
0.0435182489,
0.0316716284,
-0.0265031867,
-0.0401419848,
0.0400554612,
0.100626871,
0.0163244437,
0.0109925717,
0.0370574109,
-0.0495768376,
0.0327909142,
0.0585995428,
0.0180761926,
-0.0319716856,
0.0150691625,
-0.0360043496,
-0.0335135348,
-0.0208260193,
-0.0022467887,
-0.0209817067,
-0.0670365244,
0.0018961509,
-0.0912339613,
-0.0453682393,
0.0474555343,
0.0021280367,
0.0351379849,
0.0123925256,
-0.0091297105,
-0.0075356611,
-0.0438754782,
0.008731884,
-0.0551848486,
0.0406106636,
-0.0359108075,
-0.0169389267,
0.0241934862,
-0.0376653001,
-0.0053073396,
0.0036949329,
-0.0511025041,
-0.0726489052,
-0.0251081511,
0.0838304162,
0.0076966626,
0.0858085528,
0.001522331,
-0.0069580553,
0.0593065843,
-0.0024663408,
-0.0039378908,
0.0585649386,
0.0384121388,
0.0294038057,
-0.0023129873,
0.0597515665,
-0.066741161,
-0.0161086824,
0.0522999391,
0.0413268767,
-0.0182505213,
-0.0126197152,
-0.0190213751,
-0.0144382287,
0.0039944137,
0.0148147261,
-0.0336834379,
-0.0390313864,
0.0534804054,
-0.0209455024,
-0.0296041463,
-0.0329252407,
0.0001271116,
0.0337412544,
-0.0068254163,
-0.0123456521,
0.0409600437,
0.014893177,
-0.0074057463,
-0.0114856996,
-0.0093413992,
0.0168270208,
0.0420214348,
0.0418183245,
0.0259223636,
-0.0007961008,
0.0200527105,
0.0078560906,
0.0168464053,
-0.0398268029,
0.0188268982,
0.0171445664,
-0.0239125881,
-0.0254565831,
0.0260070786,
-0.0433795936,
-0.0057489616,
-0.0245597232,
0.0194690935,
0.0917146504,
0.0085083405,
0.0625837073,
-0.0329486504,
-0.0521864407,
-0.032256972,
0.0543420501,
-0.0054729059,
-0.0028451588,
0.0180707518,
-0.0204491969,
-0.004372844,
0.0516195484,
0.0895608887,
-0.0328165218,
0.0967167318,
-0.0109207099,
-0.0067698816,
-0.0406799316,
-0.0212753788,
0.0319260471,
0.0142983999,
-0.0301070996,
-0.0144613516,
0.0027002704,
-0.0727328137,
0.0149159562,
-0.00602521,
-0.0572096705,
0.0296728443,
0.0050602956,
0.0666476637,
0.0121158995,
0.0009812738,
-0.0253079813,
0.0048207492,
-0.0032726408,
-0.0157715976,
0.0191411618,
-6.48869796e-33,
-0.0078528542,
0.0215491392,
0.0341056027,
0.0131819583,
-0.0281029865,
-0.0004869325,
-0.0481043905,
-0.0013986541,
0.0131035503,
0.0115895551,
-0.0078795729,
0.0014520049,
0.0003327779,
0.0224602409,
0.0132703343,
0.0011554032,
0.0565353855,
0.0327698104,
-0.0118932053,
0.0340260193,
0.0335505269,
0.0606387146,
0.1133025512,
-0.0340800434,
0.0459763259,
0.0341550037,
0.0025149726,
0.029007148,
-0.020237172,
0.0308950525,
-0.0080419416,
0.0190203581,
0.0117107369,
-0.0143733704,
-0.0265167132,
-0.0327448435,
-0.0582902469,
-0.0127946958,
0.0069286688,
0.0369148441,
-0.0213371031,
-0.0713731274,
0.0227054842,
-0.0102894306,
-0.0018849128,
-0.0250093993,
0.0161065329,
-0.0543414392,
-0.0070625269,
-0.0240550023,
-0.0803412944,
0.0062355497,
-0.0062564863,
-0.0240455307,
0.008720533,
0.0283378903,
0.0179832503,
-0.027683394,
-0.0919314697,
0.0137781119,
-0.013692528,
0.0410737246,
0.0888793394,
-0.0091586821,
0.0079723028,
0.0120241512,
-0.0007797573,
0.0051070214,
0.0302161276,
-0.0112588061,
0.0340163521,
0.046857547,
0.0173839796,
0.0852610767,
0.0102544772,
0.0038743294,
-0.0847146511,
0.0285372511,
-0.018975025,
0.0246551204,
-0.0204791781,
0.0442798138,
0.0367589369,
-0.0002872615,
-0.0436708853,
-0.0196832549,
-0.0315844379,
-0.0342321396,
0.0282626469,
0.0060903593,
-0.0122667653,
0.0164363366,
0.0431451723,
-0.0274838451,
-0.0143137164,
0.0328019559,
-0.0077724583,
0.0368259102,
0.00790824,
-0.0155027751,
-0.0604646988,
0.0076900879,
0.0072857621,
0.0120673468,
0.0157095231,
-0.0146916788,
0.0784153938,
0.0371325687,
-0.0488558188,
0.0077986633,
-0.0300206542,
0.0400294252,
0.0005022789,
0.0309066735,
-0.0026576496,
0.0078527331,
-0.0248443298,
0.0187478568,
0.0551220775,
-0.0195114836,
0.0088837296,
-0.0061250199,
-0.005204218,
0.0189131238,
-0.0105438177,
0.0141802318,
-0.030380033,
-0.0072092786,
0.0414636508,
-0.0371499211,
-0.0142056374,
0.0215905588,
2.903e-7,
0.0418476649,
0.0355919711,
-0.007265667,
-0.0243998934,
0.0243860688,
0.0261847787,
-0.0596393235,
0.0171551295,
0.0055122897,
-0.0002715895,
0.0109398803,
0.0517614856,
0.0632026419,
0.0357839465,
-0.0583711714,
-0.0061268522,
-0.0330330543,
0.0118421325,
-0.0446741544,
-0.0220911503,
-0.033731278,
0.0385683551,
0.0234077554,
-0.0156037286,
0.0015986777,
-0.0311228782,
0.088385731,
-0.0825952962,
-0.0091644377,
0.0057229712,
-0.0052544051,
0.0505463704,
0.0069588497,
0.026351342,
-0.0514926463,
-0.0097243888,
0.0080382135,
0.0798617303,
0.0121105611,
0.0005240341,
-0.0096696047,
0.0435067974,
-0.0161014907,
-0.0720801055,
0.0630304366,
-0.0432199389,
0.0204653125,
-0.0364681967,
-0.0014213277,
-0.0054854746,
0.0472816601,
-0.0450179018,
-0.0173305627,
0.0265006628,
0.0487569608,
0.0488134027,
-0.0665087327,
-0.0235324558,
-0.0274328124,
0.0210771635,
0.0036278267,
-0.0585648529,
-0.0489405952,
-0.0251591597,
0.0009006499,
-0.0570557266,
0.0110329324,
2.334821981e-34,
-0.0092857424,
-0.002300746,
0.0172630195,
0.0272370894,
0.0182883106,
-0.0180828143,
-0.0273450688,
0.0008335124,
-0.0275747664,
-0.0464671962,
-0.0072400677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17761v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17761v2 | CaLMQA: Exploring culturally specific long-form question answering across 23 languages | 2024-06-25T17:45:26 | 2024-07-03T16:33:55 | Shane Arora, Marzena Karpinska, Hung-Ting Chen, Ipsita Bhattacharjee, Mohit Iyyer, Eunsol Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are used for long-form question answering
(LFQA), which requires them to generate paragraph-length answers to complex
questions. While LFQA has been well-studied in English, this research has not
been extended to other languages. To bridge this gap, we introduce CaLMQA, a
collection of 1.5K complex culturally specific questions spanning 23 languages
and 51 culturally agnostic questions translated from English into 22 other
languages. We define culturally specific questions as those uniquely or more
likely to be asked by people from cultures associated with the question's
language. We collect naturally-occurring questions from community web forums
and hire native speakers to write questions to cover under-resourced,
rarely-studied languages such as Fijian and Kirundi. Our dataset contains
diverse, complex questions that reflect cultural topics (e.g. traditions, laws,
news) and the language usage of native speakers. We automatically evaluate a
suite of open- and closed-source models on CaLMQA by detecting incorrect
language and token repetitions in answers, and observe that the quality of
LLM-generated answers degrades significantly for some low-resource languages.
Lastly, we perform human evaluation on a subset of models and languages. Manual
evaluation reveals that model performance is significantly worse for culturally
specific questions than for culturally agnostic questions. Our findings
highlight the need for further research in non-English LFQA and provide an
evaluation framework. | [
0.0680054799,
0.0485052317,
-0.0244154166,
0.0313690156,
-0.0218670014,
0.0153665412,
0.0361575559,
-0.009073629,
0.0032182822,
-0.0394330509,
-0.0150776561,
-0.0798302963,
0.0132622812,
-0.0034613442,
0.0227079969,
-0.0490896627,
0.0014458473,
-0.0313457251,
0.0301847905,
-0.0137475729,
0.0173514765,
0.0219932888,
0.0246106256,
0.0206966773,
-0.0046968372,
-0.0257608443,
0.0084738936,
-0.0217556432,
0.0055976082,
-0.0157133304,
0.0223739296,
0.0527569614,
-0.0382161364,
0.0042216224,
0.000001951,
-0.0540453829,
0.0549769923,
-0.0217018742,
0.0075704586,
0.0829428285,
0.0212359522,
0.0102171134,
0.0245481618,
0.0143630812,
-0.0280493628,
-0.0003962899,
0.0259902254,
0.0202390645,
0.0458642952,
0.0321945623,
0.0178339202,
0.0062599028,
0.0112963747,
-0.0303004812,
-0.001233234,
-0.0149901258,
0.0245845802,
0.0281166118,
0.0114745181,
-0.011108594,
-0.025735734,
0.0240758099,
0.0485972725,
-0.0120803602,
-0.0127198389,
-0.0201032143,
-0.0493803956,
-0.0326399542,
0.0434928574,
0.0594396554,
0.0159368925,
-0.0270471554,
0.0064634816,
0.0244135093,
-0.029107498,
0.0160103105,
-0.0527282506,
0.0437106676,
0.0016949942,
-0.0173923168,
0.0181638692,
0.011507418,
0.0015196948,
0.0325369611,
0.0295943134,
0.057478752,
0.0254988242,
-0.004043913,
-0.0425218977,
-0.0195281599,
0.0014724733,
-0.0952441767,
0.014349008,
0.0514711663,
-0.0254463367,
0.0114194043,
0.0026176928,
0.0002610089,
0.0729003102,
-0.0541200005,
-0.013609807,
0.0240979213,
-0.0326260328,
0.0412068702,
-0.03794026,
0.0590881817,
-0.0271980036,
-0.0186691638,
-0.0428234674,
-0.0433537103,
-0.0022413123,
-0.0600700602,
0.0084020626,
-0.0278214402,
-0.0078859441,
0.0099165644,
-0.0265632365,
0.0027177879,
-0.0186531357,
-0.0267717838,
-0.0193900093,
-0.0019624738,
-0.0048511941,
-0.0127947582,
-0.0283856168,
0.0605845228,
-0.0775983557,
0.0104289921,
0.0012568162,
-0.0803330839,
0.0220587812,
0.0147835556,
-0.0460508354,
-0.0253535286,
0.0141335335,
0.0052041602,
0.0012916834,
0.0223082379,
-0.0452031009,
-0.0204331838,
-0.0039041641,
-0.0433495566,
-0.0214081313,
-0.1198404804,
0.0457248464,
0.0190437138,
-0.0055763554,
-0.0339207314,
0.034444049,
0.0445746258,
-0.024765376,
-0.0007118484,
0.0260636117,
0.0551550575,
0.1107416525,
0.0287636518,
0.043496754,
0.0369911343,
0.0343728662,
-0.0028628046,
0.0838601589,
-0.0206000619,
0.0217065662,
0.0477470532,
0.0050322511,
0.0208202377,
0.0086613512,
0.0924832225,
0.0230480023,
-0.0157922413,
0.0493925065,
0.0558524281,
0.0145782465,
-0.0034030483,
0.0130978702,
0.0622491688,
-0.059462212,
0.036256168,
0.0520629212,
-0.0122952573,
0.0342773162,
0.0031055934,
-0.022955399,
0.04594009,
0.0134565383,
-0.0123480512,
0.0155671854,
0.0708353445,
-0.0529419482,
-0.043609716,
-0.0180133544,
-0.0013167199,
0.0163343698,
0.0396959484,
0.0019140783,
0.0098937582,
0.0241999719,
0.0541538149,
0.0265439656,
-0.0519655421,
0.025019154,
-0.0263199303,
0.0718368515,
0.0349130519,
0.0041071246,
-0.0066807205,
0.0182130672,
-0.0275784805,
0.0810784996,
0.035870824,
0.0479276925,
-0.0132809971,
-0.0086309509,
-0.008975069,
0.0040637031,
0.0216693059,
-0.0119972387,
-0.0043819747,
0.0564901866,
0.0480832979,
0.0501096174,
-0.0476236753,
-0.0338168964,
0.0064473185,
-0.0517774522,
-0.0251379944,
0.0117020439,
-0.0069989036,
0.0194836129,
0.0294966679,
-0.0014387221,
0.0230911877,
-0.0027721184,
-0.0388243981,
-0.0350305699,
-0.0143523673,
-0.0527939983,
-0.002944835,
0.039872434,
-0.042041339,
-0.0151003627,
0.0274892878,
-0.0201736335,
-0.0351572819,
-0.0041704318,
-0.0384702235,
-0.017140124,
-0.0571447425,
-0.0397467278,
-0.0008521096,
-0.0055526742,
-0.0413827337,
0.0600956678,
-0.0049903402,
0.03732346,
0.0338096656,
-0.0276357736,
0.0347604752,
-0.0380175523,
-0.0166399181,
0.022568617,
0.0002892,
-0.0213840716,
0.0600279607,
0.0210454874,
-0.0358440466,
-0.0168900732,
-0.1017870009,
-0.0018489513,
-0.0173385143,
0.0245835911,
0.0186753552,
0.0402431227,
-0.021613244,
-0.0185631774,
-0.0992295146,
-0.0481578559,
0.0482004248,
0.022048641,
0.0254620854,
0.0026350974,
0.0019169311,
-0.0325649753,
-0.0376896188,
0.0112519078,
0.03534979,
-0.0009567698,
-0.0032823193,
-0.0418754555,
-0.0169396009,
-0.0660461187,
-0.0415597148,
0.0063049467,
-0.0713022426,
-0.0488849916,
0.0204474665,
0.0448152348,
0.0524202697,
0.0404967256,
-0.083080925,
0.0136884395,
0.0172069632,
-0.0227277391,
-0.0112898191,
-0.0037891592,
-0.0027640185,
0.0093755508,
-0.0822702497,
0.0094967969,
0.0405713618,
0.0104326839,
-0.0055526793,
-0.0110350521,
-0.0063718553,
-0.0548602007,
-0.0242292304,
-0.0163561869,
-0.0237224195,
-0.0055035376,
0.074193716,
-0.017676238,
-0.0190355591,
0.0631868467,
-0.0051219254,
-0.026972888,
-0.0217647292,
0.0130628077,
-0.0730437189,
0.0486608706,
-0.0314406566,
0.0362269804,
-0.0211586803,
-0.0009315385,
-0.0395297334,
-0.0231286176,
0.0282457452,
-0.0434430689,
0.0346592516,
-0.0276939757,
-0.0110125355,
-0.0321458392,
-0.0460616909,
-0.0372643098,
-0.0454756878,
-0.0223871022,
0.0071451971,
-0.0052863848,
0.014458009,
0.0400114544,
0.0052959747,
0.0434655249,
-0.0611277111,
-0.0417473204,
0.0194927827,
0.0295942705,
0.0866020694,
0.0632470623,
0.0151215196,
0.0421982631,
-0.0146746859,
0.0334351212,
0.0180241894,
0.0431787707,
0.0103433002,
0.0358096398,
-0.021778889,
0.0176944453,
-0.005983483,
-0.0434002504,
0.0053471508,
0.0725440681,
-0.0615821593,
0.0040972875,
0.0957089886,
0.0402588621,
0.0086760791,
0.0012366992,
-0.0837906152,
0.0568697341,
0.0313712396,
0.0626029,
-0.0790596977,
-0.0041374774,
-0.0145518836,
0.0244265031,
-0.0071681249,
-0.0019491105,
0.0270605963,
-0.1280364394,
-0.0029125446,
0.0099356277,
-0.0310816895,
-0.0087523032,
-0.0358029418,
-0.0407471918,
0.0005743647,
-0.0118070738,
0.0301214419,
-0.0458963402,
0.0195051935,
0.0210036356,
-0.0686697289,
-0.0107152183,
0.0513554886,
-0.0244652461,
0.023011608,
0.0396568514,
0.0082305074,
-0.0411034524,
-0.017725531,
0.0211280715,
-0.062955074,
-0.0246740431,
0.0129433693,
-0.0109639475,
0.0481578633,
-0.0284703225,
-0.053248018,
0.0550816022,
-0.0200370252,
0.0091345971,
0.0668587759,
0.0845395476,
0.0233758055,
-0.020886099,
-0.0134933749,
-0.0089087896,
0.0123388097,
0.0808904767,
0.0359817296,
-0.0630904064,
-0.0431808084,
-0.005922372,
-0.0358501077,
-0.0186719969,
-0.0615755245,
0.0278423987,
0.0040035779,
0.0065925415,
-0.072726354,
-0.0778523758,
0.0277001411,
-0.0165417045,
0.0096077798,
-0.0017041507,
-0.0199949089,
0.007091769,
-0.0327418819,
0.0350722522,
-0.0397142842,
0.0461736806,
-0.0511601381,
0.0107690748,
-0.0119592929,
-0.0263654124,
0.009065859,
0.0009834913,
-0.0980503261,
-0.0130108763,
0.00080519,
0.0674286485,
0.0065768594,
-0.0285822172,
0.0088395951,
-0.0650175214,
-0.0071627474,
-0.0178928711,
-0.0313768871,
0.0120154917,
0.0091660311,
0.0235832166,
0.0042745112,
0.0564682633,
-0.0470031165,
0.0220101718,
0.0188171752,
0.0383548997,
-0.0161861461,
-0.0356806926,
0.000008113,
0.028326489,
-0.0676925406,
-0.0262521766,
-0.003741682,
-0.0156760588,
-0.0147370221,
-0.0093769142,
-0.0148280254,
-0.0099308975,
0.0191280078,
0.014015005,
-0.0186284371,
0.0176470522,
0.0066759856,
-0.0063726678,
0.0150328837,
-0.0502872579,
0.0407951735,
0.0500676706,
-0.0071511436,
-0.0164069887,
-0.0007097826,
-0.0373410806,
0.0158774294,
-0.0188545752,
0.0499510728,
-0.0281306878,
0.0630206019,
-0.0089817513,
-0.0080170576,
0.0251934752,
-0.0237192791,
-0.0153008103,
-0.0572548322,
0.0447912775,
0.0265656319,
0.0575807467,
-0.0219379831,
0.0479356125,
0.0260740612,
-0.023034513,
-0.035916917,
-0.0069670794,
0.0254717413,
-0.0290121473,
0.0439489782,
0.0252149049,
-0.0482743233,
0.0115302606,
0.0847780257,
-0.0069088852,
0.0189054366,
0.0234274343,
-0.0103949867,
-0.0058994736,
-0.0107194949,
-0.0019501711,
-0.0172644276,
-0.0129038431,
0.0073673055,
-0.0609457716,
-0.0380356908,
-0.0039919694,
-0.0155298458,
-0.0097126579,
-0.0052469755,
0.0069111288,
0.0517340899,
0.0108641861,
-0.0123563297,
-0.0767665431,
0.0423984304,
-0.0445562787,
-0.0034306727,
-0.0063508349,
-6.135199258e-33,
0.0042775348,
-0.0361681394,
-0.0083557935,
-0.0054670405,
-0.0011983975,
-0.0185674001,
-0.0233704522,
0.0026842419,
-0.03255428,
0.0392220952,
-0.0337153673,
-0.0258717164,
0.0030818435,
0.0502881259,
0.0410905667,
-0.0197581071,
0.0035643382,
0.0178605895,
-0.0316020548,
0.0346759595,
0.0275731403,
-0.0015769706,
0.006632084,
-0.0140734538,
0.0542029999,
-0.0745315328,
0.0183745753,
0.0354406424,
0.015169614,
0.1071388498,
-0.0251920354,
0.0313142948,
0.0402747616,
-0.0148920631,
-0.0054969429,
0.0515173711,
-0.100929141,
-0.0207224991,
0.0276429728,
-0.0029260246,
-0.0363617726,
-0.0440464132,
0.0086235832,
-0.0161285866,
0.008637635,
-0.004494851,
0.0340597071,
-0.0459828563,
0.0311132334,
-0.0416712128,
-0.0377136283,
0.0323842354,
0.0117860148,
-0.0101489229,
-0.054068841,
0.1229932681,
-0.0425558984,
-0.010572629,
-0.0280907378,
-0.0149365133,
-0.0168662369,
0.04538792,
0.0592430905,
0.0131676393,
-0.0108693633,
0.0294481069,
0.0083222482,
0.0023388017,
-0.0063362359,
-0.0009822662,
-0.03411505,
-0.0276684798,
0.0597113036,
0.0790739805,
0.0140602952,
-0.0159697123,
-0.0738138333,
0.0013330939,
0.0177935921,
0.014029487,
0.0121789165,
-0.0482370183,
-0.0123843253,
-0.0257082824,
-0.0456869379,
0.0352569148,
-0.023768533,
-0.0222974718,
0.0576695763,
-0.0031912092,
-0.0135996435,
-0.0211155433,
0.0552567989,
-0.028311858,
0.0107815694,
0.0343848951,
-0.0036462056,
0.0009503262,
0.0452609733,
0.0405884385,
-0.0400634706,
0.0577564016,
-0.0227500573,
-0.021691313,
-0.0014694014,
0.0102694845,
0.0311182328,
0.0038974038,
-0.0772892237,
0.0133896219,
-0.0088965427,
0.0284485184,
-0.023996558,
0.0311521478,
0.0217389166,
0.0124170603,
-0.0088149635,
0.0069528548,
0.0093537457,
-0.0201935042,
-0.0344369076,
-0.0473675653,
-0.0015924543,
0.0202170666,
-0.046569515,
0.0194900278,
-0.043385677,
0.0582792461,
-0.0395665541,
-0.0129171088,
0.0015482719,
0.0234149825,
2.437e-7,
0.0415504426,
0.0165869463,
0.0019050245,
0.0155603252,
0.0288725086,
-0.0129147507,
0.0089911958,
-0.0155099342,
0.0057046148,
-0.0017200593,
-0.0308272522,
0.017013805,
0.0737769753,
0.0464595072,
-0.0895253271,
-0.0088266833,
-0.0875120237,
0.0087885894,
-0.0487364903,
-0.0482421033,
-0.0003641229,
0.0780459121,
-0.0055831899,
-0.0171708185,
-0.0673211589,
-0.0585587248,
0.0616971292,
-0.003710093,
-0.02253915,
0.019117048,
0.0146636786,
-0.0078723542,
0.0538386889,
-0.0092366925,
-0.0272182804,
-0.0146646472,
0.0531303249,
0.0819675103,
0.0172267593,
-0.0041130628,
-0.013538003,
-0.0234755818,
-0.0052393144,
-0.1104891077,
0.0834636316,
0.0115561215,
-0.0177173242,
-0.0308226254,
0.008900187,
-0.0232530292,
0.0428505167,
-0.0059146336,
-0.0061380477,
0.0331206731,
0.0340407528,
-0.0117852902,
0.00571047,
-0.0062028938,
-0.0370972976,
0.0020357266,
-0.0127818557,
-0.0313028842,
-0.0141151566,
-0.0033030938,
-0.0469135679,
-0.0073697544,
0.0201421902,
2.016199875e-34,
0.0291310735,
0.0076501262,
0.0042157141,
0.0336701274,
0.0272346903,
-0.0244322121,
-0.0059001422,
0.0003295639,
0.0284264199,
-0.0616571568,
-0.0024667645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17755v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17755v1 | Accelerating Clinical Evidence Synthesis with Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T17:41:52 | 2024-06-25T17:41:52 | Zifeng Wang, Lang Cao, Benjamin Danek, Yichi Zhang, Qiao Jin, Zhiyong Lu, Jimeng Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic medical discovery by AI is a dream of many. One step toward that
goal is to create an AI model to understand clinical studies and synthesize
clinical evidence from the literature. Clinical evidence synthesis currently
relies on systematic reviews of clinical trials and retrospective analyses from
medical literature. However, the rapid expansion of publications presents
challenges in efficiently identifying, summarizing, and updating evidence. We
introduce TrialMind, a generative AI-based pipeline for conducting medical
systematic reviews, encompassing study search, screening, and data extraction
phases. We utilize large language models (LLMs) to drive each pipeline
component while incorporating human expert oversight to minimize errors. To
facilitate evaluation, we also create a benchmark dataset TrialReviewBench, a
custom dataset with 870 annotated clinical studies from 25 meta-analysis papers
across various medical treatments. Our results demonstrate that TrialMind
significantly improves the literature review process, achieving high recall
rates (0.897-1.000) in study searching from over 20 million PubMed studies and
outperforming traditional language model embeddings-based methods in screening
(Recall@20 of 0.227-0.246 vs. 0.000-0.102). Furthermore, our approach surpasses
direct GPT-4 performance in result extraction, with accuracy ranging from 0.65
to 0.84. We also support clinical evidence synthesis in forest plots, as
validated by eight human annotators who preferred TrialMind over the GPT-4
baseline with a winning rate of 62.5%-100% across the involved reviews. Our
findings suggest that an LLM-based clinical evidence synthesis approach, such
as TrialMind, can enable reliable and high-quality clinical evidence synthesis
to improve clinical research efficiency. | [
0.0550547577,
0.0644918084,
-0.0041427715,
-0.0219923742,
0.0029928877,
0.0059361611,
0.0023058124,
0.0114285005,
-0.0313055702,
-0.0095003312,
-0.0119622536,
-0.0142991478,
0.0104143405,
0.0804185942,
0.0102917962,
-0.0268384963,
0.0067767729,
-0.0020999003,
0.1029759124,
0.0202546343,
-0.0355502665,
0.0010604402,
0.0005743278,
0.0633113757,
0.0166085977,
-0.0167300534,
0.0265075509,
-0.0382069834,
0.0156212738,
-0.0750550926,
-0.0272807851,
0.0393086188,
0.0069866935,
0.0401470624,
0.0000020001,
-0.0505708605,
0.00009215,
0.0606065467,
0.0006987774,
-0.0169238988,
0.0670269281,
-0.0194532368,
0.001973507,
0.0039141732,
-0.033817485,
-0.0549294837,
0.0575953797,
0.0414005667,
0.0128267659,
0.0465287156,
-0.0194334034,
-0.0155058103,
0.0484548137,
-0.0412949845,
0.0361283347,
-0.0116995024,
0.0434019007,
0.0197143313,
0.0543342903,
0.003994077,
0.0423807502,
0.0224934593,
-0.0030083021,
-0.0363843217,
0.0089933444,
0.0710001364,
-0.0415872075,
-0.0356467441,
0.0221183803,
0.0635187775,
-0.0020227323,
-0.0329512581,
0.020981973,
-0.0001483286,
0.012388899,
0.045708131,
-0.0662181675,
0.0552720763,
-0.0283759162,
-0.0211970061,
0.0423250087,
-0.0144180544,
0.0438114293,
-0.0090854671,
-0.0032924477,
0.0203911066,
0.0053047463,
-0.0004582735,
0.0105297621,
0.0194622055,
-0.0053654145,
-0.0638783351,
0.0012859799,
0.0121016158,
-0.041553773,
-0.0067828042,
0.0222986154,
-0.0340596326,
0.0911435261,
-0.0343614481,
0.034067627,
-0.0218067523,
-0.0195443165,
0.049453795,
-0.0103370277,
-0.0323536135,
-0.032526847,
0.0351160355,
-0.0279481374,
0.0154039813,
-0.0535065718,
-0.0224463381,
-0.0206488203,
0.0129119912,
-0.0120693324,
0.0010222312,
-0.0522515923,
-0.0019623139,
-0.0267625432,
0.0107581289,
0.0355080813,
0.0229804516,
-0.0494975597,
0.000220733,
-0.0155829694,
0.0230108872,
-0.0130519848,
0.0372199379,
-0.007903819,
-0.0144946305,
0.0076482929,
0.0041680606,
0.0058453181,
0.0039318092,
0.0224683862,
0.0358627699,
0.0226136148,
-0.0243682805,
0.0114394464,
-0.0275208782,
-0.0281524789,
-0.065498583,
0.0013241447,
-0.0965854079,
0.0456601642,
-0.0046943659,
-0.0031482715,
-0.0289723948,
-0.0092358217,
0.0219175797,
-0.0283760428,
0.0334952921,
-0.0891310275,
-0.0063038124,
0.0302335098,
-0.0041265478,
-0.0337827988,
0.0285881329,
0.0344321206,
0.0123580331,
-0.0023707091,
-0.0133550679,
0.0258268211,
-0.0216613431,
0.0157396067,
-0.0196701046,
0.0023302303,
0.0118929995,
-0.0003150338,
0.071034275,
-0.026492903,
0.0595916919,
-0.0403593443,
0.0010627764,
0.0316106714,
0.0720630065,
0.0099648219,
0.0494478233,
0.0322581306,
-0.053114336,
0.0306953192,
-0.0553855821,
-0.0106203565,
0.0253571682,
-0.0120501509,
0.0058960426,
-0.0041694869,
0.0199404322,
-0.0059164343,
-0.040199209,
-0.015421981,
-0.004715967,
-0.0392222889,
-0.0176894404,
0.036349196,
-0.0084529957,
0.0050658281,
-0.0345766135,
0.0493211821,
0.002328272,
-0.0250664372,
-0.0399213061,
-0.0016785365,
0.0393091217,
0.0689347535,
-0.049225606,
-0.0014625281,
-0.0455069579,
-0.0055086082,
0.0202570986,
0.0215229988,
-0.031654425,
-0.0051146005,
-0.0114138126,
-0.0290749986,
-0.0213375166,
0.0158173405,
0.0100923795,
-0.0040265708,
0.0207137689,
-0.0389164053,
-0.0861637518,
-0.0639463291,
0.0352456942,
-0.0626108795,
-0.0189014338,
0.0413144194,
-0.0633190051,
0.0466164276,
0.0194165651,
-0.0414737575,
0.0449287631,
0.040318571,
-0.0484329425,
-0.0496834889,
0.0224642009,
0.0288414601,
-0.0240907613,
0.0357783288,
-0.0671430528,
-0.0206414312,
-0.0427000709,
-0.0589163117,
-0.0251448937,
0.0008661564,
-0.0252442174,
0.0267368238,
0.0149692791,
-0.0112945503,
0.0171347968,
-0.0036506916,
-0.0428536609,
0.0534241125,
0.0081539201,
-0.0392213762,
0.0428227894,
-0.0838759318,
0.0126858735,
0.0025779193,
-0.0212739948,
0.0495152362,
0.006287328,
-0.004941673,
0.0209364388,
-0.0134427221,
-0.0052312138,
-0.0161993373,
-0.1014909893,
0.0282659084,
0.0317766815,
0.004887132,
0.0060609742,
-0.0133573953,
-0.0050995024,
-0.0068672411,
-0.0326247029,
-0.0275395308,
0.008195634,
0.0207072701,
0.0389551371,
0.0729281083,
-0.0130866468,
-0.0949262083,
-0.0239678081,
-0.0351079591,
0.064074479,
0.0528371222,
-0.0057523563,
-0.0042938776,
0.0097458363,
-0.0121412259,
0.0245248713,
-0.005149968,
0.0183414575,
0.0331363045,
-0.0256355722,
0.0111079216,
0.0450922213,
-0.0176765323,
0.01138034,
0.0906406939,
0.007360593,
-0.03036003,
0.0112653663,
-0.0308201555,
-0.0118542509,
0.0234984625,
-0.0374577157,
0.0432268642,
0.0457149148,
0.0142202899,
0.0088104568,
-0.0201052986,
0.0077762045,
0.0002182122,
-0.0057754074,
-0.0295982063,
-0.0184045751,
-0.0043126177,
0.0305334367,
-0.0186742693,
-0.0571767949,
0.1122331992,
-0.0098101255,
0.0371509455,
-0.0688710734,
0.0251759328,
-0.0326051638,
0.0023283614,
0.0133711435,
0.0044148671,
0.0065290891,
0.0289827865,
-0.0010834245,
-0.0089978315,
0.0359138958,
-0.0213955157,
0.0469339974,
-0.0542842187,
0.0468730219,
0.0082451068,
-0.0251877122,
-0.0239046887,
-0.0074480367,
-0.041966226,
0.0042395396,
0.0305320267,
-0.0070624324,
-0.0680645481,
0.005816184,
0.0319884494,
0.0641167313,
-0.02148352,
-0.0204703175,
-0.0024414305,
-0.0316540115,
0.0652840063,
-0.06675791,
0.0134036634,
0.0006884665,
0.0616201647,
0.0567225814,
-0.0093389973,
0.0334663279,
-0.0455706269,
-0.0107430071,
-0.0349224545,
-0.0610146299,
-0.0083393604,
0.0207396392,
-0.0155800134,
-0.0259434897,
0.0037004463,
0.1036733836,
0.0236148629,
-0.1070361882,
-0.0150884623,
-0.0345005281,
-0.016034767,
-0.0163538791,
0.0262683164,
-0.0731342658,
-0.0195284802,
-0.0071975663,
0.0163016766,
-0.0065117502,
-0.0406273976,
0.0074968659,
-0.0486292467,
0.0467557237,
0.0084036794,
-0.0299595185,
-0.0253141969,
-0.0698087364,
-0.0010757312,
-0.0349819362,
-0.0426284112,
-0.0114180548,
-0.0006220645,
0.018000422,
-0.0100889364,
-0.0422496945,
-0.0995017812,
0.0327536166,
-0.0533736125,
0.0685955286,
0.0466049574,
0.0421773009,
-0.0169882774,
-0.0016128687,
0.0031136046,
0.0063601341,
-0.0052638524,
-0.0093372054,
0.0970463678,
0.0308023971,
0.0346443392,
-0.0256785583,
0.0363642313,
-0.0469552837,
-0.0356840864,
0.0357986428,
0.1093226597,
-0.0427466556,
-0.0461233854,
-0.0630160943,
0.0108513292,
0.0033099155,
0.0519247204,
0.0115978383,
0.0086000757,
-0.0025119008,
-0.0118511179,
0.0420819856,
-0.0045676073,
-0.0165810473,
0.025661841,
-0.0164188668,
0.0102775292,
-0.0646490976,
-0.0245130733,
0.0781356841,
-0.016626047,
0.0272563193,
0.0382298678,
0.0237904396,
-0.0227167606,
-0.0417551063,
0.0660204142,
0.0267981533,
0.0193458684,
-0.0373746864,
-0.0382321365,
0.0672149658,
-0.0055556931,
0.0126969852,
0.0454642661,
-0.0115180369,
-0.0125205582,
-0.0456663072,
0.0664248094,
0.0188014843,
0.003703855,
-0.0051527629,
-0.0213952977,
0.0307485647,
0.0153786866,
0.0157868546,
-0.0679203644,
-0.0186285023,
-0.0304897968,
0.0036990156,
-0.0364818983,
-0.046441935,
0.0393252447,
-0.0110239414,
0.0093375137,
-0.008305667,
0.0067960019,
0.0701873899,
0.0417666622,
0.0527350977,
-0.0519346111,
0.0048134224,
-0.0317691378,
-0.0254073478,
-0.0555386171,
0.0141911982,
-0.0359728858,
0.0308889542,
0.0265498199,
-0.0029110154,
-0.0053907908,
0.0086082323,
-0.0781565309,
-0.0172408558,
-0.0470248796,
0.0503653884,
0.0036038847,
0.043386098,
0.0639300644,
-0.0257479362,
-0.0095241098,
-0.0356723107,
-0.0428453721,
0.0186656266,
-0.0243400503,
0.0119466223,
0.0058397548,
0.00317882,
-0.0272411052,
0.0479375385,
-0.0545858145,
-0.0357718691,
-0.0256977882,
-0.0079066195,
0.0403588265,
0.0169940107,
0.0454714261,
-0.0418099761,
0.0019314218,
-0.0457261838,
0.0189198982,
0.002441854,
0.0146983825,
0.0170968417,
0.0158959161,
-0.0384905376,
-0.0620862432,
0.0977501273,
0.0154285422,
0.0378483646,
-0.0196318962,
-0.0618828461,
-0.0265497323,
-0.0340341702,
-0.0136242332,
0.0331226699,
-0.0459138304,
-0.0169456769,
-0.0598367751,
-0.0221532695,
-0.0152652282,
0.0197501909,
-0.0182718206,
0.0036394983,
-0.0105440337,
0.0399226546,
0.0087934798,
-0.0284096804,
-0.0323444158,
0.0408280119,
-0.0155777577,
-0.0555168167,
-0.0328604728,
-5.442027504e-33,
0.0338255391,
-0.0265162569,
0.0144347325,
-0.0219768025,
0.0253557675,
0.0225048494,
-0.075468123,
-0.0095652631,
0.020228263,
0.0862068385,
-0.0309866481,
0.0089875087,
-0.0109587954,
0.0122154141,
0.0441203415,
0.021765247,
0.0414545164,
-0.0096063744,
-0.0060549406,
0.0479482152,
-0.0243332945,
-0.0091471635,
0.0222917479,
-0.0396263562,
-0.0079636266,
0.0548369698,
0.0073827473,
-0.0205230005,
-0.0258626044,
0.0720872357,
-0.0266087167,
0.0373300053,
0.0248081256,
-0.0103882449,
-0.0286492445,
-0.0305870213,
-0.0531232581,
-0.0267118961,
0.0091813765,
-0.0603527091,
-0.0171098113,
-0.0132471062,
0.0365527011,
-0.0102072274,
-0.0077622449,
0.014811689,
0.0389842279,
-0.059959989,
-0.0447406918,
-0.0533732362,
-0.0615028702,
0.0490253456,
-0.0167928152,
0.0145596806,
-0.0213791765,
0.0184988994,
-0.0071306163,
0.030315727,
-0.0279153362,
0.0361935124,
0.0238951966,
-0.0054356637,
0.0052600936,
-0.0395082273,
-0.0021735299,
0.0734420717,
-0.0033880859,
0.0253275037,
-0.001828821,
0.0159823745,
-0.0282545276,
0.043088004,
0.0430368893,
0.0227540322,
0.0304067861,
0.0132007226,
-0.0809401423,
0.0772810876,
-0.059227895,
0.037105754,
0.0520222858,
-0.0055682389,
-0.006884397,
-0.0222487841,
-0.014822511,
-0.034178447,
-0.0221430343,
0.0047450024,
0.0247161016,
0.000949391,
0.0113721173,
-0.03258463,
0.043167457,
-0.0158125404,
0.0133337295,
0.0369070135,
0.0015336401,
0.0267659016,
-0.0039267442,
-0.0153786261,
-0.04611798,
-0.0091949096,
0.0365304351,
0.0156449899,
0.0446388535,
0.0207407568,
0.0188301131,
-0.0222072173,
-0.050551258,
0.0017922854,
-0.0153449504,
0.0161985289,
0.000248982,
-0.0149226366,
0.0004864162,
0.0194252711,
0.0080850925,
0.0451753549,
0.0187424812,
0.0003838809,
-0.0233298931,
0.0112179816,
-0.0057684118,
-0.011763759,
-0.0134519823,
-0.0009418,
-0.0293151997,
0.0173536465,
0.0624234863,
-0.0629820675,
-0.0087868934,
-0.0134372171,
2.746e-7,
0.0971681699,
0.0602273494,
0.0005854038,
-0.0175344143,
0.0497567095,
0.0198042765,
0.0040449966,
-0.0286217537,
0.0301738083,
0.0225128513,
0.0619613715,
0.0177953951,
-0.0028237738,
0.0492420904,
-0.0468548834,
-0.0284849796,
-0.0687858462,
-0.0421124175,
-0.0543609113,
-0.0473671556,
0.0219211113,
0.0525635555,
-0.0276081543,
-0.0128616998,
0.0066108238,
-0.0319198668,
0.0226722639,
-0.0399575904,
0.0176414009,
0.0563249514,
0.0432646014,
-0.0138182919,
0.0306230187,
0.0371638164,
-0.0357293561,
0.0058781072,
-0.0194194354,
0.0497085303,
-0.0273004789,
0.0621694587,
0.0436175801,
-0.0177793466,
0.0624557547,
-0.0402474254,
0.0355095603,
-0.084798269,
-0.0549285486,
-0.0500103943,
-0.0183344278,
-0.0083648907,
0.0707739294,
-0.0360788926,
-0.0020886692,
0.037769787,
-0.0064732013,
0.0432787351,
-0.0283975005,
-0.0381741971,
-0.0046509691,
0.0635048375,
-0.0482436903,
-0.0111071318,
-0.0046620406,
-0.069467999,
-0.0089819375,
-0.0480484553,
0.0526917242,
2.517123936e-34,
0.0663231462,
-0.0109795183,
0.016910227,
-0.0051803938,
0.0709240586,
0.0065249018,
-0.0188908987,
0.0171854943,
0.0145796016,
-0.085267745,
-0.0078071766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17753v1 | Measuring and Benchmarking Large Language Models' Capabilities to Generate Persuasive Language | 2024-06-25T17:40:47 | 2024-06-25T17:40:47 | Amalie Brogaard Pauli, Isabelle Augenstein, Ira Assent | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We are exposed to much information trying to influence us, such as teaser
messages, debates, politically framed news, and propaganda - all of which use
persuasive language. With the recent interest in Large Language Models (LLMs),
we study the ability of LLMs to produce persuasive text. As opposed to prior
work which focuses on particular domains or types of persuasion, we conduct a
general study across various domains to measure and benchmark to what degree
LLMs produce persuasive text - both when explicitly instructed to rewrite text
to be more or less persuasive and when only instructed to paraphrase. To this
end, we construct a new dataset, Persuasive-Pairs, of pairs each consisting of
a short text and of a text rewritten by an LLM to amplify or diminish
persuasive language. We multi-annotate the pairs on a relative scale for
persuasive language. This data is not only a valuable resource in itself, but
we also show that it can be used to train a regression model to predict a score
of persuasive language between text pairs. This model can score and benchmark
new LLMs across domains, thereby facilitating the comparison of different LLMs.
Finally, we discuss effects observed for different system prompts. Notably, we
find that different 'personas' in the system prompt of LLaMA3 change the
persuasive language in the text substantially, even when only instructed to
paraphrase. These findings underscore the importance of investigating
persuasive language in LLM generated text. | [
0.0463254973,
0.048329208,
-0.0057436177,
0.0175687484,
-0.0338355228,
0.0024270066,
0.0135555593,
0.000910816,
0.0085552372,
-0.0441886857,
-0.0078761624,
-0.0268836226,
0.0130817844,
0.0037754411,
0.0435895212,
-0.0739563778,
0.0070382534,
-0.0023451841,
0.0669152066,
-0.015384445,
0.0461261086,
0.0313907042,
0.0206090137,
0.0629093647,
-0.012849492,
-0.0395358093,
0.0418510884,
0.024779696,
0.0143961301,
-0.0439762808,
0.0206793733,
0.041358985,
0.0157612078,
0.0109674707,
0.0000018508,
-0.0503958315,
0.0256023444,
-0.0084854942,
-0.0315633714,
0.0665245131,
0.1282641739,
-0.0024529828,
-0.0168586094,
0.0216978565,
-0.0307355579,
0.0365238413,
0.0609529167,
0.0474782698,
0.0581615493,
0.0629293248,
-0.0078612389,
-0.0110185621,
0.0120600024,
-0.0321217552,
-0.0161887854,
0.0045274929,
0.0215580314,
-0.0318384804,
-0.0270065516,
0.0523269139,
0.0253276452,
0.0247087218,
-0.0049915886,
-0.0064096581,
-0.0016764712,
-0.000240285,
-0.0085325297,
-0.0062135682,
-0.0173853226,
0.0381937027,
-0.0074076224,
-0.0245259125,
0.0349188484,
0.003152132,
0.0362112559,
0.0330476165,
-0.0273726843,
0.0349612907,
0.0198238455,
0.017792413,
0.0110575063,
0.0145620108,
0.0404247791,
0.0230488423,
0.0091075366,
0.0343118235,
0.0066824229,
-0.0355601013,
0.0488608629,
-0.0181212071,
0.0020758514,
-0.0724312365,
-0.0333016999,
-0.0234612599,
-0.0182342678,
0.0397104397,
-0.0317252167,
-0.0184246097,
0.0499057733,
-0.1132889092,
0.0444492549,
-0.0005265783,
0.0080898665,
0.012893456,
-0.0124579407,
0.0129446918,
-0.0256261881,
0.0228489786,
0.0096824495,
0.0387320593,
-0.0371368974,
-0.0227698516,
-0.0254671592,
0.0015375981,
0.015552287,
-0.0121285152,
-0.0710593164,
-0.0027691375,
-0.0331476368,
0.0074144639,
-0.0487015359,
0.0121345744,
-0.0135936979,
-0.0256081931,
-0.0072330539,
0.0637979284,
-0.046597641,
0.0225691833,
0.0228142589,
-0.0300420355,
0.0310359392,
0.0383792818,
-0.0175515134,
-0.0046492042,
0.0096621057,
0.0408283137,
-0.0068845963,
0.0047536371,
-0.0451456159,
-0.0238773022,
-0.0376970991,
-0.0518176295,
-0.0216725748,
-0.062917009,
-0.0046274648,
0.0098258937,
0.0276517589,
-0.0653775334,
0.0314471088,
0.0174556896,
-0.0298534352,
0.0443854146,
0.0193648003,
0.0295343436,
0.0374185145,
0.0309771877,
-0.0158241484,
0.0617362969,
0.0480844676,
0.0847966745,
0.051496014,
0.0043967487,
0.033917129,
0.0348198116,
0.0015678745,
0.0245800428,
0.0178785827,
-0.0178519618,
-0.0284161977,
0.003858441,
-0.0165099259,
0.0667005181,
-0.0035811632,
0.0218247641,
0.0997238681,
0.0438504405,
-0.0118756322,
-0.0012848721,
0.0321294367,
0.0295263939,
0.0109018125,
0.005804861,
-0.026412392,
-0.0274082031,
-0.0316458642,
-0.009184639,
0.0373408124,
0.0175942779,
-0.0178082809,
-0.0367857181,
-0.015969472,
-0.0137442974,
0.0120603098,
-0.0114712417,
0.0076680137,
0.0082368935,
-0.0521117896,
0.0143622756,
0.0549348928,
-0.0432908833,
-0.0105356658,
-0.0254520793,
0.0125657488,
0.040666718,
0.0112564219,
0.0091876267,
0.0566828586,
-0.0556290187,
0.0475982614,
0.082492888,
0.0496921316,
-0.022987958,
-0.0468677208,
-0.0175506882,
-0.0144188069,
-0.0626869351,
0.0295980796,
0.0491317101,
0.0055808756,
0.019807484,
0.0220407452,
-0.0071253618,
-0.0475952923,
0.0155800814,
0.0051087877,
-0.0187817533,
-0.0093057808,
0.0229365155,
0.0416598991,
0.0173247401,
-0.0317328908,
0.0027519981,
0.0114811789,
-0.0413719937,
-0.0273940302,
-0.0043428983,
-0.0075649926,
0.0356717184,
0.0080097718,
-0.0219705477,
-0.0110161779,
0.0221885107,
0.0086445343,
0.0207118485,
0.0250686742,
-0.0620040521,
0.0736528039,
-0.0075468281,
0.0179199278,
-0.0300841071,
-0.0054339166,
-0.0332825184,
0.0322012194,
0.0335587859,
-0.0257337168,
0.0263678525,
-0.02712637,
0.0143593578,
0.0192680284,
-0.0043944824,
-0.0281905867,
0.0087097697,
0.0140521601,
0.044736933,
-0.048061341,
-0.0251509249,
-0.0555698052,
-0.0585023835,
-0.0378789231,
-0.0149238426,
0.0064546117,
0.0142357955,
-0.0138344225,
0.0015862414,
0.0542315617,
-0.0691582039,
-0.0503935069,
-0.0093472879,
0.0429900587,
0.0261960868,
-0.0002786797,
-0.0202928334,
-0.0187664665,
0.0285812505,
-0.0217014439,
0.0438078083,
0.0552522354,
-0.0372922719,
-0.0346576013,
0.0414691679,
-0.0326928012,
-0.049584195,
-0.0210167319,
-0.0505375788,
0.0151742091,
0.0408898219,
0.0837626085,
0.0521663837,
0.0403047539,
0.0257389452,
0.0187864006,
0.0453534089,
-0.0646405444,
-0.037086565,
-0.0430675372,
-0.001028512,
-0.0626973137,
-0.0818268061,
0.0520766303,
0.0132547943,
0.0411814079,
0.0219012294,
-0.0395994,
0.0678254068,
-0.0050249202,
-0.0458820686,
-0.0134773906,
-0.0348490924,
-0.0139864562,
0.0472897217,
-0.0217719711,
-0.0800902471,
0.0431800336,
-0.0341919102,
0.0164195374,
0.0127807911,
-0.0188811403,
-0.0110786799,
0.0219180807,
-0.0161333997,
0.0427050218,
0.0038798191,
-0.0100221774,
-0.0083405357,
-0.0711459219,
0.0243739448,
-0.0458491221,
0.0373894125,
-0.0161487963,
0.0011645566,
0.0539220087,
-0.0446291864,
-0.027271565,
-0.0877831578,
-0.02192045,
-0.0273366868,
0.0518246591,
-0.0187727921,
-0.0346585177,
-0.0225458611,
0.0524766482,
-0.0039776037,
-0.0177332833,
0.0002430193,
0.0027237532,
-0.0218321569,
0.0285462402,
-0.0232950076,
0.002027425,
-0.0709234402,
0.0138410283,
0.0024183344,
-0.0245460458,
-0.022456916,
-0.0445036367,
-0.0479470417,
-0.0156703033,
-0.0143072866,
0.0084773796,
0.0107683307,
0.0382652692,
-0.03595924,
0.0469030887,
0.0714117214,
0.0058472203,
-0.0267017931,
0.0163605865,
-0.0092725111,
0.0330643505,
0.0066368547,
0.0116720079,
-0.0596021675,
-0.0090028848,
0.0004761594,
0.0192135461,
-0.0376049168,
0.0291014891,
-0.0297883675,
-0.0869438946,
0.0477899015,
0.0270125717,
0.0414227732,
0.0005437014,
-0.0479148403,
-0.0236408096,
-0.0003869775,
-0.0122346533,
-0.0299135894,
-0.0152034694,
-0.0182003267,
-0.0056587891,
-0.0350614227,
-0.0297086872,
-0.0295832679,
-0.0152503243,
0.038451869,
0.0944782868,
0.0474640206,
-0.0111003676,
-0.053042613,
0.039370548,
0.0279955156,
-0.0126683144,
0.0006862227,
0.0608565509,
-0.009235125,
-0.0053559337,
-0.0261712782,
0.0307303704,
0.0169236064,
-0.018493209,
0.0218445901,
0.0318196528,
0.0248927809,
-0.0452831946,
0.0119301928,
0.0280079879,
0.0410583206,
0.0827812105,
0.0370479561,
-0.053575445,
-0.000665138,
-0.0545264035,
0.0007323786,
0.0049608937,
-0.0729220808,
-0.0521771684,
-0.0307824891,
0.0121297892,
-0.0584550276,
-0.0242099427,
-0.0157758538,
0.0059220754,
0.0574281812,
0.0325324088,
-0.0090077613,
0.009301859,
0.0254229829,
0.0140524469,
-0.0554548688,
0.0477956384,
-0.0599029288,
-0.0373837613,
0.0017176074,
-0.0205411445,
-0.0173588432,
-0.0141479662,
-0.0200265944,
-0.0770379975,
-0.0135446517,
0.0363132469,
0.0224675145,
0.0222720243,
0.0389278792,
-0.0491112769,
0.0748934671,
0.0526525564,
-0.0175442956,
0.0308692064,
0.0369897671,
0.0428484976,
0.0189882945,
0.0153097184,
-0.0036383301,
0.0435369983,
0.0467519052,
-0.017719442,
-0.0317023546,
-0.0165379085,
0.0320627727,
0.0539821871,
0.018787941,
-0.0284900256,
-0.0108279837,
-0.0242008623,
-0.0129778078,
-0.0295571983,
-0.0305560548,
-0.0208268035,
0.0108727999,
0.0382998101,
0.0060056867,
0.0057889563,
0.0008182938,
-0.0535315536,
0.0274145287,
-0.0233338177,
0.0140499417,
-0.0640883818,
0.0418928601,
0.0231724028,
0.0017822989,
-0.0130988443,
0.0503062867,
-0.014463759,
0.0280582067,
0.0212310012,
0.0289583132,
0.0133746387,
-0.0179576576,
0.0086098863,
0.029556077,
-0.0424433276,
-0.042788621,
0.0058534825,
-0.0081171356,
0.0072290637,
0.0104882913,
0.0801901966,
-0.0316774286,
-0.0034608284,
-0.0235150065,
0.026418604,
0.0035510811,
-0.0310987979,
0.0226415936,
-0.0217091031,
-0.0540933535,
0.0075323619,
0.0479934663,
-0.0561311245,
0.0369182415,
0.0264356453,
-0.0251190327,
-0.043410182,
-0.0480257086,
0.0365954265,
0.0125525929,
-0.0013721586,
-0.01219102,
-0.0691613033,
-0.0112328315,
-0.0039769714,
0.0003454755,
0.0005131478,
-0.0341205634,
0.0148449922,
0.0244790372,
-0.0587368645,
0.0201972537,
-0.0555304401,
0.0088142017,
-0.0172088649,
-0.0050881067,
-0.0017453526,
-5.879909436e-33,
0.0082404064,
-0.0110102482,
-0.0331444703,
0.0283314176,
-0.0184541102,
0.0049705193,
-0.0134107014,
0.0378752798,
-0.0016119418,
0.0713287443,
-0.0008390468,
-0.010114043,
0.0073884577,
-0.0060136099,
-0.034136381,
-0.0113013182,
0.0621060804,
-0.0039410843,
-0.0557524897,
0.0450157411,
0.0388614126,
-0.0199362133,
-0.0135305952,
-0.0998440832,
0.0576931611,
-0.0149732837,
-0.054495085,
-0.042057965,
-0.0050752158,
0.0217743143,
-0.0036689504,
0.0491489246,
0.0130059021,
-0.0370002128,
-0.0062200013,
0.1169186831,
0.021853758,
-0.0086143557,
0.0773452297,
-0.0551035441,
-0.0186659452,
-0.0651714951,
0.0197074618,
-0.0258633271,
-0.0437327027,
0.0295187626,
0.0319905467,
-0.0362289995,
0.0157611091,
-0.0105811469,
-0.0730112046,
0.0046721892,
-0.0268587917,
-0.0171116889,
-0.0417598039,
0.0701295659,
-0.016807355,
0.07585942,
-0.0093760174,
0.0523976982,
0.0196677577,
0.0237076581,
0.0330987535,
-0.0168239176,
0.0036275273,
0.0871365815,
0.0007049519,
0.0214482248,
-0.0345811732,
-0.0065156678,
-0.0077945152,
0.0274003055,
0.0727309585,
0.0903863087,
0.0120912762,
-0.0314172581,
-0.0554405972,
-0.0069438196,
0.051112961,
-0.0525934398,
0.0502492487,
-0.0363160484,
-0.0247395001,
-0.0372186638,
-0.0631626099,
-0.0406754017,
-0.020282967,
-0.0683585629,
0.0238208696,
0.0147867557,
-0.032177981,
0.0298045501,
-0.0094840284,
-0.0395905264,
-0.0332130119,
0.0165149122,
-0.0298495945,
0.0189573132,
-0.0097062765,
-0.0125809982,
-0.0644396991,
0.0242633931,
-0.0126858074,
0.0069289771,
0.0329146646,
-0.0021396568,
0.0449802093,
-0.0260793343,
-0.0877990201,
0.0148651907,
-0.0208087638,
0.0219435208,
0.004524875,
-0.0325048119,
0.0171947889,
0.0029492136,
0.009006341,
-0.0006949361,
-0.0127838207,
-0.0469031855,
0.0037995218,
-0.0140646109,
-0.0204340927,
0.0465853624,
-0.0557472259,
-0.0213670116,
-0.0369017869,
0.0163504519,
0.0450768135,
-0.0602327958,
-0.0174147245,
-0.0650661811,
2.57e-7,
0.0119793089,
0.0898202509,
-0.0228937995,
0.0267453007,
0.0031667566,
0.0536252931,
-0.0149793522,
0.0028252238,
0.0150468955,
-0.0647202432,
-0.0340207182,
-0.0037353144,
0.0503877215,
-0.0051109609,
-0.1048540771,
0.0010537565,
-0.0550784133,
0.0026908345,
-0.0759747475,
0.0072378959,
0.0664748624,
0.0595696345,
0.0456294306,
-0.006442233,
-0.0155119607,
-0.0221178122,
0.0825791284,
-0.0870044604,
-0.0288469549,
0.0468592644,
0.0023461836,
-0.0306049343,
-0.0047843289,
0.0161592923,
-0.0108942259,
-0.0099147707,
-0.0307821836,
0.0933076218,
0.0351752155,
-0.010388216,
-0.0071280589,
0.0014254451,
-0.0305243228,
-0.0239810254,
0.0257981438,
-0.0389676429,
-0.0363917649,
-0.0518488735,
-0.0226508472,
-0.0087760091,
0.0171917602,
-0.0382094346,
-0.0329057239,
-0.0173684228,
0.0133182658,
0.0096937073,
-0.0018588172,
-0.0331669599,
-0.0015707877,
-0.0198730584,
-0.0137137882,
-0.080869101,
-0.0372140817,
0.0327103436,
0.0123602683,
-0.0633338615,
0.0304676313,
2.213585121e-34,
0.0657182559,
-0.0388681255,
0.0208666455,
-0.01683468,
0.0369582772,
0.0326648504,
0.0368766338,
-0.0084683634,
0.0090680411,
-0.0754501745,
0.0280448105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17746v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17746v1 | Recite, Reconstruct, Recollect: Memorization in LMs as a Multifaceted Phenomenon | 2024-06-25T17:32:16 | 2024-06-25T17:32:16 | USVSN Sai Prashanth, Alvin Deng, Kyle O'Brien, Jyothir S V, Mohammad Aflah Khan, Jaydeep Borkar, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, Jacob Ray Fuehne, Stella Biderman, Tracy Ke, Katherine Lee, Naomi Saphra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Memorization in language models is typically treated as a homogenous
phenomenon, neglecting the specifics of the memorized data. We instead model
memorization as the effect of a set of complex factors that describe each
sample and relate it to the model and corpus. To build intuition around these
factors, we break memorization down into a taxonomy: recitation of highly
duplicated sequences, reconstruction of inherently predictable sequences, and
recollection of sequences that are neither. We demonstrate the usefulness of
our taxonomy by using it to construct a predictive model for memorization. By
analyzing dependencies and inspecting the weights of the predictive model, we
find that different factors influence the likelihood of memorization
differently depending on the taxonomic category. | [
-0.014543348,
0.0112045258,
-0.0447326563,
0.0228190664,
-0.0550800674,
0.0135329776,
-0.0640933812,
0.0061804452,
-0.0227598734,
-0.026027061,
-0.0129065132,
-0.053065069,
0.0602273829,
-0.0132455584,
0.0318234563,
-0.044000119,
0.0341428071,
-0.0599134788,
-0.018064823,
-0.0135713648,
-0.0230452083,
-0.0385360196,
-0.0273864977,
-0.0050677275,
-0.0050716228,
0.0120856166,
-0.0145892305,
-0.0298843812,
-0.0304768048,
-0.0297067054,
-0.0083533749,
0.0358020365,
0.0241961647,
-0.0084914993,
0.0000016356,
-0.0615269989,
-0.0082351342,
-0.0565353185,
-0.0256765522,
0.0171526987,
-0.0099303657,
0.0168427471,
0.0055453898,
-0.0198186561,
-0.0088826306,
-0.011056032,
0.0236744005,
0.0108402725,
-0.0317378603,
0.0348056555,
0.0094937831,
-0.0040853978,
0.0158643071,
-0.0084233107,
0.0431177355,
0.0289205778,
0.0284760613,
0.019954849,
-0.0239461027,
-0.0318229906,
-0.0388106853,
0.0266063344,
0.000330989,
0.0849446207,
0.0262862016,
0.0409160815,
0.0809480771,
0.0151673807,
0.0001306398,
-0.0030294524,
0.0394906737,
-0.0389516465,
0.0175743569,
0.0252960566,
0.003012504,
0.0395300724,
-0.0729059502,
0.0404628068,
-0.0143862823,
-0.0002889515,
0.0149271842,
-0.0013056847,
0.0343974195,
0.0007031055,
0.0019194024,
0.020446118,
0.0241614133,
-0.0286566839,
-0.0270957872,
0.0104134083,
0.0349694118,
-0.0464873277,
-0.0033360212,
0.0638260841,
0.008267385,
0.0564926006,
0.0350644179,
-0.0220849607,
0.0665486157,
-0.0069626342,
0.0674850792,
0.0207923036,
0.016072562,
-0.0141364187,
-0.0627926961,
0.0733458996,
0.0169793181,
0.0032461635,
-0.0125877205,
0.0311934091,
-0.0762259215,
-0.0326761156,
0.0063003995,
0.0620809346,
0.0912993997,
0.0094414111,
-0.0439214259,
0.0221662726,
0.0273301564,
-0.0278847013,
-0.0275859889,
-0.0101296743,
0.0003849887,
0.0099604009,
-0.0363084376,
0.0046033533,
-0.0306890011,
0.0479337387,
0.0307580251,
-0.0426923148,
-0.0270554032,
-0.0143391173,
-0.0233355593,
0.003938247,
-0.0267457236,
0.0121884784,
-0.0058480836,
-0.0413234532,
-0.0588211752,
-0.0584228933,
-0.0226033423,
-0.0429569222,
0.0354481451,
-0.0535642691,
-0.0161019526,
0.015174415,
0.0210370403,
-0.0163505692,
-0.0247050598,
-0.0016751144,
-0.0079923598,
0.0188380573,
0.0886571407,
0.0350961909,
0.0222517345,
0.0345922485,
-0.0016237493,
0.0212667361,
0.0235452484,
-0.0001319822,
0.0095382705,
-0.0267216824,
0.0351033062,
0.0363708921,
0.0059005953,
-0.0099483887,
-0.0297150183,
-0.0485516153,
0.0178103875,
0.0235046707,
0.072617434,
0.0394853018,
-0.0410720073,
-0.023138687,
0.0579612963,
0.0851102769,
0.0313197933,
0.005664398,
0.0256777201,
-0.035747245,
0.0336954147,
0.0689772144,
-0.0149305752,
0.039622888,
-0.0043454682,
0.0562883653,
0.0021500939,
0.0075540361,
-0.0438480675,
-0.0025269629,
-0.0198593289,
-0.0374496877,
-0.0086517716,
-0.0100610033,
0.0209715255,
0.0195461884,
-0.0421593897,
0.0681140572,
0.0040486879,
-0.0541402437,
0.0230106115,
-0.0562499948,
0.0567550436,
0.0556509271,
0.0351249464,
0.0123912422,
-0.0057871714,
0.0347317457,
-0.0374897048,
-0.0259573888,
0.0053683384,
-0.0113620339,
0.0018429336,
-0.0413064435,
-0.0157282203,
0.0381749161,
0.0290417653,
0.0468487479,
0.001541384,
-0.0033343669,
-0.0140239857,
-0.0168255083,
0.0115540223,
0.0183038544,
-0.0455946065,
-0.0437605456,
-0.0237734821,
-0.0068872194,
0.0398500897,
-0.0001009678,
0.0409251563,
0.03947974,
0.0631930381,
0.0086470116,
0.0055386168,
-0.0050610262,
-0.101507552,
-0.027393138,
0.0205459222,
0.0148268752,
0.0301707592,
0.0240546241,
0.0242139176,
-0.0675623864,
0.0356088653,
-0.0400051996,
0.1018435135,
-0.0219935365,
0.0416410752,
0.0048044217,
-0.0032762692,
-0.0450566523,
0.0517901331,
-0.0593685061,
0.0390799977,
0.0202138927,
-0.0245501343,
-0.0142481057,
-0.0766101629,
-0.0116659896,
0.0101380423,
-0.0150318872,
0.020526981,
0.0071030669,
-0.0697810799,
-0.0671711043,
-0.0291889478,
-0.0351609401,
-0.0226253476,
0.0026628217,
0.024016276,
0.014850609,
-0.0248970464,
-0.0130203133,
0.0036977206,
-0.0305945948,
0.0123134172,
-0.0010924545,
0.0726721957,
-0.0005763381,
-0.0276903603,
-0.0131901372,
-0.0362313427,
-0.0288712084,
-0.0150993625,
0.0235801842,
-0.0258468539,
-0.0088986987,
-0.0344087593,
0.0251492392,
-0.0347298309,
-0.0337134451,
-0.0146824364,
0.0225956757,
0.0339179523,
-0.0015644919,
0.1079012603,
0.0583263598,
0.0067898813,
0.0146043459,
0.0576369241,
-0.0514966361,
-0.0408653244,
-0.0637618452,
-0.0591282621,
-0.0416217931,
0.0035305184,
-0.046764642,
-0.0038549555,
0.0893549398,
0.0597361326,
0.0152828908,
0.0116950795,
-0.0408488698,
-0.0158144962,
0.0103184013,
-0.0243256353,
-0.0330555886,
-0.0919920877,
0.0464947373,
0.0010003453,
-0.066423893,
0.0246144217,
-0.0352092795,
0.0207513869,
0.0056705484,
0.0213154312,
0.0186044294,
0.0413812883,
-0.0016529342,
-0.0160640888,
0.0144898165,
-0.0540470444,
-0.0495895967,
-0.0151821375,
0.035702724,
-0.0589111038,
0.0405667238,
-0.0391607247,
-0.0183787607,
0.0244930945,
0.0249196514,
-0.0583576262,
0.0841586068,
-0.0054794536,
0.0068721822,
-0.0390325971,
0.0167068504,
-0.0430599339,
-0.0194010567,
0.0557139032,
-0.013203498,
0.0029402571,
-0.010783839,
-0.0071483837,
0.0466954187,
0.0454416052,
0.0031817427,
-0.0047094156,
-0.0364944525,
-0.0129552791,
0.0403885208,
0.0549423844,
0.0275875516,
-0.0029457647,
0.0392335318,
0.0424408354,
-0.0352505445,
-0.027177766,
0.0755461529,
-0.0146175092,
-0.0410485566,
0.0090897651,
0.0756595731,
0.0076712114,
-0.0476876907,
0.0107336687,
-0.0327439867,
0.0887401178,
0.0034330089,
-0.0442018546,
-0.0230517276,
0.0123872012,
0.038004566,
-0.0022623835,
-0.0138489921,
-0.0094630038,
0.0025489754,
-0.0817269087,
-0.0206625182,
0.0322897807,
-0.065912582,
-0.015786184,
-0.0603747293,
-0.0150022414,
0.0114245564,
0.0066279368,
0.0589837246,
-0.0392024592,
0.0253467802,
0.0507110544,
-0.0613976978,
-0.021433847,
0.0283146389,
-0.0107170669,
0.0421703048,
0.0458932333,
-0.0180952232,
0.0180945601,
-0.0660913736,
0.0122547485,
-0.0479949303,
0.0227606501,
-0.0103922943,
0.0278350729,
0.018038176,
0.0220388249,
-0.0453908741,
0.0307717714,
-0.0351690985,
-0.0180435143,
0.0068187234,
0.0878808424,
-0.0114495158,
-0.0083056809,
-0.0008738737,
-0.0138049247,
-0.0287989769,
0.0890121758,
0.0672697797,
0.0082223946,
0.0077293408,
-0.0068591791,
0.0394849628,
-0.0329969153,
-0.0401397943,
0.0043372456,
-0.0291899331,
-0.0240602009,
-0.0984918326,
-0.0435063057,
0.004342101,
0.0202816539,
0.0297738034,
0.0559199043,
0.011211562,
-0.0600482747,
-0.051654879,
0.0035884609,
-0.0523311608,
-0.0081293574,
-0.0617239811,
-0.049987793,
0.0286947191,
-0.0311286282,
0.0004429763,
-0.008886694,
-0.0709356144,
-0.0469534025,
0.0269321799,
0.0690722317,
0.0317300893,
0.0423779078,
0.0697188079,
-0.0223479234,
0.0471179821,
-0.0512611419,
-0.0027520712,
0.037885122,
-0.0056730667,
-0.0044648158,
-0.0169102922,
0.0059283995,
-0.0076110307,
-0.0077058771,
0.0122015597,
0.0180674028,
-0.023924889,
-0.0352323428,
0.0247802082,
-0.0080102049,
0.0458447635,
-0.0019291088,
-0.0086970609,
-0.0059366026,
-0.0168423709,
0.028517412,
0.0334037803,
0.0176506359,
0.0099814953,
0.0321087502,
0.0332025886,
-0.0059102806,
-0.0865213647,
-0.0295067299,
0.0298511088,
0.0110345082,
-0.0268683881,
-0.0134967342,
-0.0058643306,
0.005665224,
0.046672646,
-0.0247362312,
0.0293246359,
-0.0618020035,
0.0326366015,
0.0261872616,
0.0255252533,
-0.0198270921,
0.0277543832,
-0.0325901583,
-0.0371514857,
-0.0397474207,
-0.0161580797,
0.0057823793,
-0.0275194664,
0.0291068517,
-0.0711598024,
0.0463249646,
-0.0552192666,
0.0497338735,
-0.0597003885,
-0.0034757017,
-0.0116042402,
0.0064884997,
0.0284103453,
0.027994385,
-0.0036745355,
0.0167116076,
0.1001646891,
-0.0174232982,
0.024596585,
-0.0131078241,
-0.0065506706,
-0.0323607177,
-0.0540034138,
0.0533726476,
0.0221887697,
-0.0250038207,
-0.05430023,
-0.0532222949,
-0.0520386994,
0.0483600199,
-0.0279793404,
0.0582044683,
-0.0442179479,
0.0527799204,
0.0429022051,
-0.0532420799,
0.0309323892,
-0.0268049259,
0.0404720865,
-0.005804026,
-0.0194906108,
-0.0181749891,
-5.698405394e-33,
-0.0067925234,
-0.0058940756,
0.0594297312,
0.02425397,
-0.0205825567,
0.0148251094,
-0.0463015139,
0.0570461825,
-0.0016694736,
-0.0453825369,
0.0066631758,
-0.0428523719,
0.020174671,
0.0259042121,
0.0607209019,
0.0014638253,
0.0128235286,
-0.0099973828,
-0.0320286527,
0.0043721432,
0.0607328825,
0.0349644497,
0.0487132408,
0.0127388677,
0.0363282152,
-0.0335340649,
0.0439648703,
-0.0201541111,
-0.0454652943,
0.0649954379,
-0.0499371216,
0.0321154185,
0.0512276888,
-0.0380765498,
-0.0700193867,
0.0150426226,
-0.0706628039,
-0.0239146277,
0.0622177683,
0.0030143717,
-0.0114461137,
-0.0373875387,
0.0646689385,
-0.0334269106,
-0.0313425809,
-0.0042754035,
0.0272248946,
-0.035683617,
-0.0976982713,
-0.0003601119,
-0.0217240136,
-0.0210911278,
0.0326189809,
-0.0350292809,
0.0088173682,
0.0030190446,
-0.0215513185,
0.037164066,
-0.0603735521,
0.0715048835,
-0.0192519911,
0.0805681124,
0.0314284191,
0.0509696938,
0.0258853119,
0.057386972,
0.0485032052,
-0.0365242995,
0.0056499052,
0.0050357771,
0.0350710526,
0.0015690661,
0.0225290284,
0.003808764,
0.0805866867,
-0.0103470655,
0.0194115285,
0.0154457819,
0.0056278021,
0.0309772845,
0.0379895754,
0.0276459157,
-0.0252970178,
-0.0321873799,
-0.0233504754,
0.0332625061,
-0.0288560167,
-0.0206585508,
0.019969603,
0.0030773648,
0.0147810886,
-0.0312113743,
0.0605429262,
0.0079152584,
-0.0034002925,
-0.0262541492,
-0.0048912698,
-0.0022524002,
-0.0142807644,
-0.0076905866,
-0.0703209713,
-0.0028250131,
0.0014714926,
-0.0052236933,
-0.0239547044,
0.0537226088,
0.0166382864,
0.018826209,
-0.0441939309,
-0.022965584,
-0.0338881575,
-0.040354941,
0.022241747,
-0.0227266867,
0.0428084582,
-0.000376781,
-0.0058190469,
0.0359925479,
-0.0227732733,
-0.0712835863,
-0.0271902625,
-0.0011250332,
-0.0623873509,
0.0315273106,
-0.0198065992,
-0.0082495287,
-0.0264040064,
0.0149402078,
0.0454607159,
0.017574789,
0.0340614468,
-0.0138576915,
2.371e-7,
-0.0019806577,
-0.0057415282,
0.017405007,
-0.0171439387,
0.0342964269,
-0.0038826133,
-0.0544987954,
-0.007928662,
0.0300936513,
-0.0324397869,
0.0196980126,
0.0444137827,
0.050453119,
-0.0291144252,
-0.0483122133,
-0.023594724,
-0.0470330268,
0.0214265008,
-0.0196201149,
0.0120974919,
-0.0020869747,
0.0258573908,
0.0161519926,
-0.0259676948,
-0.0133842099,
-0.0146851307,
0.0642909408,
-0.054506395,
-0.008677071,
-0.0224457923,
0.0467158258,
0.0284263454,
0.023235403,
0.029317379,
-0.0036703367,
-0.0206484981,
-0.001717579,
0.0146992803,
0.0380423814,
-0.0595624261,
0.0054465863,
0.0062772795,
-0.0271917265,
-0.0169072878,
-0.0001537171,
-0.0084019154,
-0.0067219646,
0.0169846173,
0.0016689579,
0.0292834956,
0.0207677875,
0.0307486579,
-0.017152369,
0.0110446597,
-0.0241228342,
0.0412067734,
-0.0003080869,
-0.0481240824,
0.0052501997,
0.0111498917,
-0.0548401177,
-0.0601724237,
-0.0249340925,
-0.0303139202,
0.0230600704,
-0.0733152777,
-0.0447654203,
1.664587015e-34,
-0.0020747685,
-0.018842509,
0.0482756868,
0.0585234687,
-0.0079895863,
-0.0649355873,
-0.0089699337,
0.0714004487,
0.0190412197,
-0.0578757375,
-0.0298308842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17744v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17744v1 | Following Length Constraints in Instructions | 2024-06-25T17:29:52 | 2024-06-25T17:29:52 | Weizhe Yuan, Ilia Kulikov, Ping Yu, Kyunghyun Cho, Sainbayar Sukhbaatar, Jason Weston, Jing Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aligned instruction following models can better fulfill user requests than
their unaligned counterparts. However, it has been shown that there is a length
bias in evaluation of such models, and that training algorithms tend to exploit
this bias by learning longer responses. In this work we show how to train
models that can be controlled at inference time with instructions containing
desired length constraints. Such models are superior in length instructed
evaluations, outperforming standard instruction following models such as GPT4,
Llama 3 and Mixtral. | [
0.0547591299,
0.0268305745,
-0.003077701,
0.0122395838,
-0.0112567227,
0.013735258,
0.0047924062,
-0.0039303512,
-0.0043463637,
-0.0281171389,
-0.0217548497,
-0.058169134,
-0.0092038121,
-0.0192985199,
0.0044334098,
-0.077267386,
0.0421232358,
-0.0250414703,
-0.0038787741,
0.0091280136,
0.0266779009,
-0.002060947,
-0.0251885671,
0.0199007373,
0.0051579103,
-0.0201220922,
-0.0629594401,
0.0225042459,
-0.0176678188,
-0.0394131802,
0.0337836742,
0.042222444,
0.0162983425,
0.0106620081,
0.0000017722,
-0.0395868309,
0.0022150239,
-0.0151593834,
-0.0609531812,
0.0436426662,
0.0056137084,
-0.0011182779,
0.0088779833,
0.0343738832,
-0.0201310664,
0.0371109955,
0.0563199557,
0.0533879176,
0.0404976867,
0.068957381,
0.0110471938,
-0.0239136629,
0.0070812879,
-0.0679877326,
0.0403513312,
-0.038413018,
-0.0089470232,
-0.0212658402,
0.0480699427,
0.0522763096,
-0.0369908772,
-0.0081060817,
0.0466685556,
0.030686507,
-0.028602872,
0.0158015899,
0.0136066601,
-0.000981049,
-0.0459891446,
0.0719851777,
0.0011894396,
0.0223736465,
0.0117878458,
-0.0349588245,
0.0319846869,
-0.0208327118,
-0.0284614302,
-0.017222777,
-0.0267132577,
-0.008655414,
-0.0204481371,
0.0385137759,
-0.013741238,
-0.0514743887,
-0.0023816018,
0.0699893758,
-0.0137235168,
-0.0619359761,
-0.0190510266,
-0.0229128655,
0.0096647758,
-0.0311194398,
-0.0262407456,
0.0562996119,
-0.0332572758,
0.0213231314,
-0.0261611808,
0.0250506029,
0.0297110621,
-0.030874392,
0.0470282286,
0.0628958642,
-0.0072626164,
0.006023658,
-0.0232824683,
0.0869209468,
-0.025305761,
0.0184792448,
-0.0651944354,
0.0880912021,
-0.0400717743,
-0.0023066145,
-0.0348854475,
0.0233663954,
-0.0591067635,
-0.006462988,
-0.055734396,
0.0449015908,
0.0028941731,
0.0327160209,
0.019031547,
0.0097998967,
-0.0491165631,
0.0070654624,
-0.0525145866,
0.0253489707,
-0.0593959652,
0.0034761294,
0.0029594486,
-0.0238218531,
-0.0129028521,
0.0006652419,
-0.0201768372,
-0.0228320062,
0.025840722,
0.1005897596,
-0.0054091983,
-0.0116139781,
-0.025858527,
-0.0362491943,
-0.0089597218,
-0.0528324693,
0.0214640331,
-0.0273575615,
0.0396924913,
-0.016131917,
-0.0057728798,
0.0161003135,
0.0080228196,
0.0406833254,
-0.0027999524,
0.0623783991,
0.0572841726,
0.0005098755,
-0.0133999651,
0.0225373898,
0.0121477563,
0.0442411415,
0.0238386653,
0.0561820641,
0.0327056162,
-0.0318367705,
0.0339926593,
0.0394489728,
0.011697053,
-0.0048328904,
0.0286339037,
0.0265575405,
0.0078321183,
-0.009439568,
0.0440551601,
0.0477864929,
0.0038578038,
-0.0442875475,
0.025703717,
0.0468816943,
0.0298995003,
-0.0332631543,
0.0813705921,
0.0006639119,
-0.0379131921,
0.0786674768,
-0.0726015493,
0.0347480848,
0.0032745884,
0.0493115336,
0.0267182011,
0.0032484168,
-0.0458174273,
-0.0498444661,
-0.0120873228,
-0.0201330651,
0.0006179514,
0.0079504102,
0.0080780573,
-0.0426694192,
-0.0889063925,
0.0191085339,
0.0125814592,
-0.0209922716,
-0.0421628617,
-0.0663393289,
0.0109478934,
0.0872298703,
0.0095185572,
-0.0233619213,
-0.0375082195,
-0.0100023178,
0.0012263343,
0.0195762869,
0.0333994813,
-0.0219691936,
0.0272160303,
-0.0365811177,
-0.0342939831,
-0.0287030935,
0.0063378839,
0.0252292771,
0.0242046788,
-0.0140872765,
0.0366982669,
0.0029743931,
-0.0043301447,
0.0323336795,
-0.0005545969,
-0.1076067016,
-0.043624498,
0.0368498676,
0.0364540629,
-0.0050237183,
0.0149654336,
0.0113127381,
0.02990794,
-0.0102171786,
0.039541129,
-0.0323248655,
-0.0787420347,
-0.0342358723,
0.021765681,
-0.0003210596,
0.0476997234,
0.0093040224,
-0.0373909473,
-0.0277664661,
0.0089184977,
-0.049742844,
0.0432868041,
0.0393858589,
0.0191996545,
0.0304277316,
-0.031599652,
-0.0497907251,
0.0326821581,
-0.0402565747,
0.0192725789,
0.0321685225,
-0.0180684775,
0.0212540366,
-0.0647594258,
-0.0018237391,
0.0133449957,
0.0001659507,
-0.0221906342,
0.0188232586,
0.0153597444,
-0.0174016412,
-0.0305258669,
-0.0816255882,
0.0188310593,
-0.0115098748,
0.045695886,
0.0034688488,
0.0243280474,
-0.0130356168,
-0.0424809866,
-0.0401519611,
-0.0669034347,
0.0029464671,
0.0059771412,
0.0103260754,
0.0535546653,
-0.0771089494,
-0.0505495369,
-0.0210959278,
-0.028077865,
-0.0040313937,
-0.0197609831,
-0.0067317975,
-0.064030841,
0.0010943561,
0.0097903488,
0.0555444434,
-0.0316679738,
-0.047662776,
0.026130341,
0.0149898054,
0.0330469683,
0.1064897776,
0.0009608618,
0.0414623022,
0.0066007287,
0.0060655824,
-0.0407809131,
0.0594900809,
-0.0397712626,
-0.0310591608,
-0.009473633,
-0.0482122414,
0.023264803,
0.0820238441,
-0.0006352536,
0.0387527347,
-0.0887126923,
-0.0390306562,
0.0206679069,
-0.0094421962,
0.0194658749,
-0.0169560611,
-0.0392881185,
0.0092307441,
-0.0316219367,
-0.0928779915,
0.0612648353,
-0.054409489,
0.0014290577,
-0.0200745519,
-0.0056966059,
-0.0137932533,
0.057160154,
0.0263809878,
0.0043381434,
-0.0138500175,
-0.0142870918,
-0.0462908819,
0.01710237,
0.0172188301,
-0.038248267,
0.0318447016,
-0.0288037173,
-0.0188083109,
-0.0325391442,
-0.0239475928,
-0.0292357225,
-0.0460814424,
0.0248635877,
-0.0189192574,
0.0437341332,
-0.0104816835,
-0.005566848,
0.0224842895,
0.0158027541,
0.0421594605,
-0.0295695495,
0.0197287723,
-0.0311283898,
-0.0476171076,
0.0581241585,
-0.0148248859,
-0.0462993495,
-0.0557188392,
0.0201528184,
0.0232900381,
0.0361844189,
-0.0166620538,
-0.0370780528,
0.0053553702,
0.0146568296,
-0.0315549076,
-0.0155701078,
0.0742675215,
0.0870371461,
-0.0316779688,
0.0248600338,
0.082797192,
0.0267625209,
-0.0302267447,
0.0197492763,
-0.0115502179,
0.0409023687,
0.0181277581,
0.0444479585,
-0.0779809281,
-0.0284879506,
-0.0122839464,
0.0609829798,
-0.0011415873,
0.010522658,
-0.0201325342,
-0.112738058,
-0.0033669807,
0.0039057385,
-0.0166122653,
-0.0532690063,
-0.0261940323,
-0.0085913511,
0.0125544192,
0.0112278797,
0.0216789078,
-0.0478988625,
0.0026869217,
0.0576262847,
-0.0164174512,
-0.0224494711,
0.0342849083,
-0.0115855029,
0.0646041259,
0.0774798691,
-0.0332638398,
0.0279809646,
-0.0433490649,
0.0114404298,
-0.017199602,
0.035657201,
0.0040300111,
0.0615562648,
-0.0233274046,
0.0146984411,
-0.0140911685,
0.040705651,
-0.0043468033,
0.0260559898,
0.0300265495,
0.0499537736,
-0.0147161195,
0.0093260193,
-0.0378110781,
0.0065407557,
0.0348811261,
0.0463701859,
0.015512025,
-0.035867326,
-0.0480302013,
-0.0357514434,
-0.0363990515,
-0.0705287978,
0.0328095183,
0.0052267937,
-0.0564364046,
0.0119944867,
-0.0333675146,
-0.0745993182,
-0.0061690961,
0.0515521094,
0.0272128154,
-0.0182629284,
-0.0032405779,
0.0109001976,
-0.0134025933,
0.0032076011,
0.0134874946,
0.0330154151,
-0.0982082263,
-0.0236415435,
0.0095343199,
-0.0111312186,
0.0108257681,
0.0107951304,
-0.0883337855,
-0.0656496435,
-0.0396759547,
0.1065542102,
0.0289581288,
0.0652515739,
0.0147537645,
0.0056224284,
-0.0425310433,
-0.002998007,
-0.0256212857,
0.0160264131,
0.0310832448,
0.0063291308,
-0.0215724781,
-0.0207807925,
-0.044613719,
0.0422836021,
0.0066408464,
0.0116142342,
-0.0541089252,
-0.0348374993,
0.0193965062,
0.0021286879,
-0.0178605355,
-0.0144353667,
-0.0092766527,
0.0126336459,
0.0729631186,
-0.0165144596,
0.0159831513,
-0.0223046299,
0.0056671649,
-0.0104058562,
-0.0250034258,
0.0196982305,
-0.0781973377,
-0.0446623676,
-0.0183670577,
-0.0614189319,
0.0523646958,
-0.00884749,
0.0047818441,
0.0155651793,
0.0061615901,
-0.0248564277,
0.0244759489,
0.0095971366,
0.0550717935,
0.0207282156,
0.0799008757,
0.0273882356,
0.0437122695,
-0.0320937857,
0.0403441824,
-0.0223626792,
0.0049425834,
-0.0455135442,
-0.025415916,
0.0138509031,
-0.0427446105,
-0.0161831658,
0.0371395759,
0.0384222306,
-0.0193689559,
0.0556934923,
-0.0078254985,
-0.0092754755,
0.0169363786,
0.0535639077,
0.0180995483,
-0.0404518992,
0.0758238956,
0.0152233243,
0.0499733984,
-0.0160827301,
-0.0189223997,
-0.0630433708,
-0.0374673083,
0.0263969451,
0.014983966,
-0.0032347818,
-0.0063487259,
-0.017493559,
-0.032214731,
-0.0347607434,
0.0272962786,
0.0466342978,
-0.0219151843,
0.0660392493,
0.0385113806,
-0.0068858885,
-0.0689945966,
-0.0008863662,
-0.0421900824,
-0.0087036546,
0.005856955,
-0.0493832193,
-5.499215304e-33,
-0.0296285339,
-0.0020107832,
0.0457202196,
-0.0078873206,
-0.0432191715,
-0.0086276457,
-0.0094763506,
-0.0007928445,
0.0015483709,
-0.0421495251,
-0.0058616628,
-0.0210441183,
0.0234062616,
-0.0159866419,
0.0224527959,
-0.0149193602,
0.0432872251,
-0.0173171312,
-0.0605230443,
0.0236596521,
0.0120979398,
-0.0173291937,
0.0226688832,
-0.0221017357,
0.0290190019,
-0.0086580226,
0.0145926503,
-0.0089180311,
-0.0427253768,
0.0901856571,
-0.0009751756,
-0.0043500527,
0.0391562097,
-0.0245072823,
-0.0061901291,
0.0516868569,
-0.0326823369,
-0.0371278934,
0.0359580964,
0.0215011071,
-0.0364401229,
-0.0438754037,
0.0132545084,
-0.0050037303,
-0.0341527797,
-0.0026997596,
0.0281200949,
0.012677935,
0.0179009512,
0.0271542929,
-0.0554227531,
-0.0060152337,
0.0019288423,
-0.0584005155,
0.0077808634,
0.060523808,
0.0262075048,
-0.0206652675,
0.0045088194,
0.0015374644,
0.0641283169,
0.0704762861,
0.0516081341,
0.0472306646,
-0.0080393422,
-0.0047208997,
-0.0288143158,
-0.0084146494,
-0.0371370502,
-0.0098905843,
-0.0237176623,
0.0173854493,
0.0165075343,
-0.0264626965,
0.0598077253,
-0.002711484,
-0.0294059981,
0.0355996042,
0.0257095303,
0.0584999695,
0.0160185024,
0.0064448486,
-0.0965977833,
-0.0084548537,
-0.0025101814,
0.0146990381,
-0.0039093192,
-0.0627394244,
0.0689534619,
0.0520737432,
-0.0059043998,
0.0071860119,
0.0656661242,
0.0256023519,
-0.0105039617,
-0.0115723023,
-0.0033038862,
0.0305788442,
-0.0201293882,
-0.0154882669,
-0.0404159538,
-0.0364308991,
0.0488713942,
0.0005481659,
0.0222008955,
0.0053335759,
0.0109511884,
0.0322041102,
-0.0619177334,
0.0013999424,
-0.0307486635,
0.0211018547,
0.0024278327,
0.0207582712,
0.0439736992,
0.0049529104,
-0.0254739784,
0.0768847466,
-0.0647576526,
-0.06850373,
-0.0433811918,
-0.0280660894,
0.0179503821,
0.0231819265,
-0.0503422581,
0.0028855177,
-0.010688792,
0.020473564,
-0.0520959683,
-0.0455548801,
-0.0109631689,
0.0251281224,
2.54e-7,
-0.0078487154,
-0.0096171275,
0.0865138918,
0.0414143093,
-0.0153256608,
0.0089356769,
0.0165675431,
0.0255413856,
-0.0156280585,
-0.0355128385,
0.0099359313,
0.0133623341,
-0.0040469463,
-0.0133439666,
-0.0428534597,
-0.0051577073,
-0.0424131863,
0.047579091,
-0.0454269163,
0.0005398907,
0.0677705929,
0.0580672249,
-0.0008515464,
0.0321142264,
0.0050604795,
0.0093149254,
0.004456107,
-0.0078591714,
0.0219557658,
0.0021106189,
0.020258449,
-0.0282525849,
-0.0177231152,
0.0412731767,
-0.0111933881,
0.0101622371,
-0.0371063165,
0.0898389667,
-0.02326479,
-0.0282765403,
0.0175014213,
0.0005217168,
-0.0153052397,
-0.0203328598,
0.0394347347,
0.0073850648,
0.0153308343,
0.0046956218,
-0.0181353819,
-0.0148154851,
-0.0234462712,
0.0071542682,
0.0354757831,
-0.000405919,
0.0188553967,
-0.0327749588,
0.010191448,
-0.058573626,
0.0114918938,
0.022429293,
-0.0289943963,
-0.0458670333,
-0.056472268,
0.0108736586,
-0.0076037426,
-0.0818823949,
-0.0485118367,
2.350898932e-34,
0.0097311754,
-0.0501371995,
0.0498564057,
0.0349404961,
0.0094233816,
-0.0152918594,
-0.018449042,
0.0466655418,
0.0938932225,
-0.0747403875,
-0.0513251834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17739v1 | Find Parent then Label Children: A Two-stage Taxonomy Completion Method with Pre-trained Language Model | 2024-06-25T17:25:02 | 2024-06-25T17:25:02 | Fei Xia, Yixuan Weng, Shizhu He, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Taxonomies, which organize domain concepts into hierarchical structures, are
crucial for building knowledge systems and downstream applications. As domain
knowledge evolves, taxonomies need to be continuously updated to include new
concepts. Previous approaches have mainly focused on adding concepts to the
leaf nodes of the existing hierarchical tree, which does not fully utilize the
taxonomy's knowledge and is unable to update the original taxonomy structure
(usually involving non-leaf nodes). In this paper, we propose a two-stage
method called ATTEMPT for taxonomy completion. Our method inserts new concepts
into the correct position by finding a parent node and labeling child nodes.
Specifically, by combining local nodes with prompts to generate natural
sentences, we take advantage of pre-trained language models for
hypernym/hyponymy recognition. Experimental results on two public datasets
(including six domains) show that ATTEMPT performs best on both taxonomy
completion and extension tasks, surpassing existing methods. | [
0.0416951105,
0.0355267785,
-0.0172756892,
0.0041202544,
-0.0252685454,
-0.0118327299,
-0.0441421643,
0.0247970037,
-0.0021549528,
-0.09035597,
-0.0187543035,
-0.0174772404,
0.0044078296,
0.0076411176,
-0.0121472999,
-0.0710083619,
0.0509655662,
-0.0018890505,
0.0137187662,
-0.0128507437,
-0.034961082,
0.0282886494,
0.0062614847,
0.0155878179,
-0.0362039953,
-0.0263139624,
-0.0389848091,
0.0194722209,
0.0017319643,
-0.0500302501,
0.0141509799,
0.0414500274,
0.0201083198,
0.0777638927,
0.0000017823,
-0.0924236029,
-0.0376767293,
-0.0309792794,
-0.0110519473,
-0.0317522362,
0.0441919863,
0.0008453069,
0.0307447482,
-0.0253432114,
0.0035673212,
-0.0309745092,
0.0336745791,
0.0247527733,
0.0224696863,
0.0057899295,
0.0129904328,
-0.052994743,
0.0334860496,
-0.0047068326,
0.0028746012,
-0.0456250757,
0.0171817858,
0.0352960005,
0.011353856,
0.0280532129,
0.0012554241,
0.0086604599,
-0.0173596758,
-0.03135892,
0.0189223904,
0.0010595667,
0.0173195451,
-0.0240433533,
-0.0088426815,
0.0728394687,
-0.0494076945,
-0.0013639722,
0.0164734423,
-0.0158028938,
-0.0043265237,
0.0346213393,
-0.0162775423,
0.0212253593,
0.0004136586,
-0.0364395864,
0.0277924333,
-0.0392591693,
0.0455115698,
0.0289867762,
-0.0093187122,
0.1065070406,
0.0483163707,
-0.0221142098,
0.0032725793,
0.0091376845,
-0.0000428827,
-0.0855170563,
0.0181249566,
0.0625716299,
-0.0207170453,
0.0614954755,
-0.0598257482,
0.0416123606,
0.0267861933,
-0.0370951854,
-0.026531918,
-0.0050107278,
0.0067016715,
0.0519218333,
-0.0202281717,
-0.0398138389,
0.0161549486,
-0.010568752,
-0.0488345288,
-0.0161423013,
-0.0651840046,
-0.026355885,
-0.0641713291,
0.0542701446,
-0.0366426595,
-0.0209308248,
-0.0449252874,
0.0150613505,
0.003301349,
0.0069364053,
-0.0050575882,
-0.0279274993,
-0.0355482846,
-0.0305771362,
-0.0402534045,
-0.0104988702,
-0.0449412316,
0.061758928,
0.0220469199,
0.031865824,
0.0172224417,
0.0240024757,
0.0475510135,
0.0327374339,
0.0015108766,
0.0393242761,
0.0592288189,
-0.0385026596,
-0.0691844597,
-0.0510645658,
-0.0155461524,
-0.0160229225,
0.0095009645,
-0.0634508878,
0.0039268057,
-0.0392925069,
-0.0095765805,
-0.0032784496,
0.0265811365,
0.0176651031,
-0.0460140593,
0.0767250881,
-0.0951022506,
-0.0081698904,
0.0739182979,
-0.0031821697,
0.0112226028,
0.0304633994,
0.021630805,
0.0303591564,
0.0799278393,
-0.0046383212,
0.0080910018,
0.0045025377,
0.0002571509,
-0.0117380945,
-0.0009531442,
-0.0342481956,
-0.0454618558,
0.0609103702,
-0.0150593519,
0.0312949754,
0.0134411529,
0.0351252146,
0.0326782018,
0.0501552448,
0.0296991393,
-0.0097482223,
0.0725806952,
-0.0097470004,
-0.0367275067,
-0.0128324935,
-0.0309683494,
-0.0257866997,
-0.0616703667,
0.0307889543,
-0.014277163,
0.0112160565,
-0.0151670892,
-0.044332929,
-0.0223228745,
-0.0279729851,
-0.0241007768,
-0.0212648716,
0.092786029,
0.0594816431,
0.0096173901,
0.040606603,
0.0636410639,
-0.0071654371,
0.0604081079,
-0.0093106851,
0.041356504,
0.0636132881,
0.0132914754,
-0.0650144219,
-0.0404372476,
0.009687678,
-0.0107741114,
0.044206731,
-0.0126105994,
-0.0494299904,
-0.0387718007,
-0.0170699134,
-0.0273470059,
0.0302367527,
0.0165758338,
0.027463777,
0.0117499139,
0.0146489469,
0.0523665659,
-0.0638053864,
-0.0288771521,
0.0462570488,
-0.0206142962,
0.0021149553,
0.0112323659,
0.027190255,
-0.0183426235,
0.0380876064,
-0.01339244,
-0.0007366934,
0.0216055252,
0.0229838472,
-0.0752818584,
-0.0193575937,
-0.0095691737,
-0.0561771579,
0.0483628958,
-0.0034407426,
0.0033156814,
-0.0149065396,
-0.0206236672,
-0.0283814594,
-0.0009524099,
-0.0056568882,
0.0481552593,
-0.049079027,
0.0568140857,
-0.0039896728,
-0.051997114,
-0.0304146092,
0.0898912624,
0.0195128918,
0.0449750423,
-0.0601390377,
-0.0012632248,
0.0010624563,
0.0284583513,
-0.027051691,
0.020530533,
-0.0317354389,
0.0258516539,
0.0324155912,
0.0154004712,
-0.0586382411,
0.0317687392,
-0.0604432859,
-0.0070258123,
0.0163413007,
0.0265012328,
0.0029125982,
-0.0006257609,
-0.0074098464,
-0.0293438416,
0.0169974994,
0.0771961585,
-0.0151786385,
0.015754655,
0.0340979807,
-0.0013828813,
-0.0457711555,
-0.0280791745,
-0.0035085822,
-0.0091777686,
0.0505561866,
0.0360308737,
0.0113222701,
-0.0137415156,
-0.0122582428,
-0.0665590018,
0.0239050761,
0.04188288,
0.0087847076,
-0.0142830424,
-0.0049616708,
0.0025197165,
-0.0294775143,
-0.0112343431,
-0.0201767087,
0.063345395,
0.0188479759,
0.0002997602,
-0.0260951258,
-0.0407428555,
-0.0224383734,
0.0196954366,
0.0228360463,
0.0277287886,
0.0938919634,
-0.0262526963,
-0.0354479142,
0.0031202557,
0.0180886276,
-0.0342714824,
0.0317110568,
-0.0594294593,
-0.0350252613,
-0.0147334551,
0.0711569116,
-0.0091091208,
-0.0532673895,
0.0667503551,
-0.034191791,
0.0114686973,
-0.0318757221,
-0.0100645376,
-0.0198696479,
0.0803416818,
0.0117678447,
0.0596237443,
0.0868443325,
-0.0922103003,
-0.0332004428,
0.0451253504,
0.010576318,
0.0009746514,
0.0334092602,
-0.0500633866,
0.0134798111,
0.0195393339,
0.0273284037,
-0.0380179882,
-0.022200359,
-0.0076133977,
0.0293399747,
0.000174994,
-0.0274163503,
0.0231047012,
-0.0167682953,
-0.0106161898,
0.0731428564,
0.0298569966,
-0.0297927111,
-0.0376334824,
0.0683137327,
0.0445977487,
-0.0043791174,
-0.016088903,
0.0185765307,
0.0200854801,
0.0116318157,
-0.0179573428,
0.0016973248,
-0.0036289585,
-0.0032925487,
0.0218651071,
-0.0944198295,
-0.0525153019,
0.0126156956,
-0.028419096,
-0.0131001351,
0.0056013125,
0.1174455211,
0.0700430945,
-0.0172382966,
0.0264023896,
-0.0216211081,
0.0210223049,
0.0558581911,
-0.0065480103,
-0.0816676691,
0.0139065562,
0.0238331426,
-0.008872414,
0.0243033953,
-0.0397045612,
0.0300303157,
-0.1048875377,
-0.0056968979,
-0.008522776,
-0.054940287,
0.0139294956,
-0.0212740507,
-0.0081936819,
0.0614542104,
-0.0279534981,
-0.0046601081,
0.0061366693,
-0.01081031,
-0.0106286202,
-0.0161515251,
-0.0401866324,
0.0641755313,
-0.0416194163,
0.0124500431,
0.0544310696,
0.0409575365,
-0.0406168737,
-0.0000311838,
0.0198166855,
-0.0141884079,
-0.0315866508,
-0.0065320693,
-0.0075653917,
-0.0094997119,
0.012287328,
0.0101698348,
-0.0129195731,
-0.0455756038,
-0.0055294512,
0.0480960682,
0.1031811833,
0.0220134482,
-0.013972952,
-0.0147005673,
-0.0039030614,
0.0093316641,
0.0559468754,
0.0121572269,
-0.0342465937,
0.0286400821,
-0.0175536796,
-0.0082362406,
0.0247282702,
0.0170000196,
0.0302142855,
-0.0729933009,
-0.010860363,
-0.1002536714,
-0.0435816422,
0.0598264337,
0.0392035954,
0.0266898461,
-0.0001446784,
0.0133311069,
0.0101346755,
-0.0504929386,
0.0349131599,
-0.0215179399,
0.0015958563,
-0.0240586828,
-0.0211566556,
0.0612448864,
-0.0108098127,
-0.0487076864,
-0.0057916176,
0.0410140418,
-0.0389171131,
-0.0438459888,
0.0138592273,
0.0140058659,
0.0144848106,
-0.0423793383,
-0.0293520149,
0.0214150921,
0.0089468202,
-0.032487154,
-0.0137804225,
0.0094816722,
0.0335246436,
-0.0134161403,
0.0484023355,
-0.0569392778,
0.0408921577,
-0.0032589324,
0.057693366,
0.0125144813,
-0.0583741069,
0.0423119478,
-0.0040538535,
0.0765933767,
-0.0595418774,
-0.0049384208,
-0.0190399773,
-0.0094649987,
-0.0158677995,
-0.0613469519,
-0.0016646779,
0.0013354376,
0.0233951472,
0.0219520014,
0.0188014582,
-0.0276941825,
-0.032945551,
0.016155649,
-0.0007810334,
-0.0519553684,
0.0068542492,
0.0486084782,
0.013979461,
0.0053617302,
-0.0181947928,
-0.0481087342,
-0.0319268852,
0.006501853,
-0.0691377223,
0.0230578072,
-0.0102924192,
-0.0187538452,
-0.0715842247,
0.0019544505,
0.005857477,
-0.0197963659,
-0.0436962545,
0.0340125002,
0.0773245692,
0.0201944653,
-0.0424262621,
-0.0411010459,
-0.0291897394,
-0.0081423763,
0.0192301925,
-0.0002085297,
-0.0900573656,
0.0365140885,
0.0158664677,
-0.0408526137,
-0.0046664714,
0.0589995384,
0.039769005,
0.0357645862,
-0.0115942489,
-0.0076097501,
-0.0019494937,
0.0057771266,
-0.0187783539,
0.0642958358,
-0.0466069989,
0.0278453063,
-0.0454056486,
-0.0745212138,
0.0031396893,
0.0181657225,
-0.0117548276,
0.0472408943,
0.0664808229,
0.0658273995,
0.0079341587,
-0.0266258754,
-0.0358489119,
0.0086538466,
-0.0102259554,
0.0051218853,
0.0098066078,
-5.48316246e-33,
-0.0606189072,
-0.0722756311,
0.0159315392,
-0.0121574271,
-0.0011987026,
-0.0003318351,
-0.0300740842,
0.0454742312,
0.0155793549,
0.0401504375,
0.0293309819,
-0.0105695045,
0.0033655425,
0.0379551351,
0.0311429333,
0.0214895234,
0.0122338422,
0.0097171944,
0.0074967314,
0.0139633659,
0.0225860551,
0.0279139187,
0.0757007673,
-0.039230518,
0.0145004056,
0.0046979664,
0.0216531474,
0.019867098,
0.0011204286,
0.0406598039,
0.0009075677,
0.0772267133,
0.0119596031,
-0.0115708066,
0.0105550932,
0.0102598704,
-0.0679410324,
-0.0292704329,
-0.0088768387,
-0.0177023076,
-0.0461680293,
-0.0181755349,
0.023738889,
-0.0015921236,
0.0278697759,
0.0156212654,
0.0424591787,
-0.0197625719,
-0.0570088141,
-0.0469356366,
-0.108300887,
0.0124152992,
0.0239443816,
-0.0050705872,
-0.0103288917,
0.0240940172,
0.0100629758,
-0.0029769761,
-0.0226641558,
0.0367540121,
0.0409560166,
0.0160761997,
0.0314428508,
0.0412329324,
-0.026402913,
0.0483786128,
0.0023637922,
0.0075008236,
0.0087198429,
0.0544813909,
0.0181963798,
0.0319157243,
-0.004194391,
-0.0101405457,
-0.0090867607,
-0.014809195,
-0.0241002012,
0.0117868437,
-0.0505558625,
-0.0107829841,
-0.0364463553,
0.0125488844,
-0.0075151324,
-0.0138001479,
-0.0559978895,
-0.0074082767,
-0.0409343354,
-0.0525302812,
0.0128754769,
0.0033196893,
-0.0099844541,
0.0181694981,
-0.0413754769,
-0.0016324603,
-0.0575368665,
-0.0284532588,
0.0293838885,
0.0401785038,
-0.0380913019,
0.0699756593,
-0.0196519662,
-0.0768764094,
-0.009596861,
-0.0231263787,
-0.0188387334,
0.0070756092,
-0.0126972282,
-0.0014614998,
-0.0470059365,
0.0243471172,
0.0127536822,
-0.0542446934,
-0.0015864248,
-0.0269195586,
0.0486155227,
0.0136342207,
0.0073826318,
0.0602919981,
0.0498779826,
-0.0310181938,
-0.0336921252,
0.0365425609,
-0.007558757,
0.0135719534,
-0.0062256139,
-0.0081755528,
-0.0080607245,
-0.028066922,
0.0208906997,
-0.0297254212,
0.000876803,
-0.0325483643,
2.606e-7,
0.0171873495,
0.0490323119,
-0.0240897648,
0.007659914,
0.0152825434,
-0.0080395686,
0.031360805,
0.0228096414,
-0.0328974873,
-0.0430662036,
-0.0106422147,
-0.0722049996,
-0.0035960227,
0.0035417539,
-0.1092090979,
-0.0382921621,
0.0119851716,
0.0013682001,
-0.0844780207,
0.0061839805,
0.0598282814,
0.0788268149,
0.015656244,
0.0021343739,
-0.0433655865,
-0.0488353893,
0.0346694477,
0.0131515078,
-0.0029701998,
0.0572510511,
0.0046967478,
0.0610029772,
-0.0000748392,
0.034597151,
-0.0349886492,
0.0391532853,
0.0162148271,
0.0263505969,
-0.0240166169,
0.0151451537,
-0.0045314436,
-0.0130490186,
0.0327499211,
-0.0682789013,
0.0333611779,
-0.0610891171,
0.009178305,
0.0195141323,
-0.0206489507,
0.0050584115,
-0.0378971472,
-0.0469167493,
-0.0099832295,
0.0023273765,
0.0076512089,
0.023550313,
-0.0129322559,
-0.0949984267,
0.0345759802,
0.0768938661,
-0.0431291126,
-0.0312617347,
0.0349239781,
-0.0210400615,
0.0021838031,
-0.0244928803,
0.0097479261,
2.152454364e-34,
0.0094201127,
0.0021328621,
-0.0096861348,
0.0531571358,
0.025023967,
-0.0081912484,
0.0180920977,
0.0153339067,
0.0295983367,
-0.0532089807,
-0.0012547707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17737v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17737v1 | LLM Targeted Underperformance Disproportionately Impacts Vulnerable Users | 2024-06-25T17:24:07 | 2024-06-25T17:24:07 | Elinor Poole-Dayan, Deb Roy, Jad Kabbara | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | While state-of-the-art Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown impressive
performance on many tasks, there has been extensive research on undesirable
model behavior such as hallucinations and bias. In this work, we investigate
how the quality of LLM responses changes in terms of information accuracy,
truthfulness, and refusals depending on three user traits: English proficiency,
education level, and country of origin. We present extensive experimentation on
three state-of-the-art LLMs and two different datasets targeting truthfulness
and factuality. Our findings suggest that undesirable behaviors in
state-of-the-art LLMs occur disproportionately more for users with lower
English proficiency, of lower education status, and originating from outside
the US, rendering these models unreliable sources of information towards their
most vulnerable users. | [
0.0385592803,
0.076650314,
-0.038800586,
0.0200502686,
-0.0161413848,
0.0119042872,
0.054907538,
-0.0089852456,
0.0416241251,
-0.0577895604,
0.0055669853,
-0.0481768548,
0.0063178465,
-0.01927929,
0.0007331223,
-0.0280754473,
0.0347205065,
-0.0204158947,
0.0160220228,
-0.0462333448,
-0.0063822763,
0.0299924333,
-0.007522081,
0.0658017471,
-0.0087618455,
-0.0293981135,
0.0380068198,
-0.0054268106,
-0.0117420312,
-0.0253776144,
0.040806029,
0.0710853338,
-0.0165564064,
0.0544663034,
0.0000019642,
-0.0494065993,
0.0199376065,
-0.0060038697,
-0.0416780673,
0.0381377228,
0.0424570888,
-0.0036437951,
-0.0004450494,
0.046990104,
-0.03268262,
0.0101448605,
0.021266209,
0.0431817621,
0.0182559844,
0.0253603347,
-0.0012094522,
0.0006457296,
0.0165177919,
-0.0029185899,
0.0260118973,
-0.0049311044,
0.0232065022,
-0.0003241842,
-0.0235188436,
-0.0469876528,
0.0178937223,
0.0373334847,
0.0017042075,
-0.0006152046,
-0.0348822288,
0.0225410014,
-0.0516662635,
-0.0421068259,
0.0082739666,
0.0499824211,
0.0033914854,
-0.0154941184,
-0.0043009352,
-0.0140058864,
-0.0019319975,
0.0331655778,
-0.023533294,
0.03721999,
-0.0156104369,
0.0039980463,
-0.0040369458,
-0.0286650434,
0.0432984494,
0.0217237696,
-0.0076274672,
0.0582721569,
0.00296021,
-0.0407273509,
-0.0015232641,
0.0046287803,
0.0315011479,
-0.0616421662,
0.0280755684,
-0.0231216773,
-0.057437364,
0.0154352514,
-0.0191536266,
0.0063612754,
0.0569959767,
-0.0727650821,
0.0161906481,
0.0433334298,
-0.0207864437,
0.0212777127,
0.0025894952,
0.0317027718,
0.0016636701,
0.0393500626,
-0.0003154265,
0.0137629909,
-0.0029420934,
-0.0107962657,
0.0228742603,
-0.0150777642,
-0.0207401514,
0.0231017005,
-0.0555073582,
0.0193988718,
-0.0110718068,
0.0146453129,
-0.0212132111,
-0.0022275446,
-0.0133654103,
-0.031363111,
-0.0755030513,
0.0650473237,
-0.0202622619,
0.0293204896,
0.0108184842,
-0.0800098255,
0.0334234536,
0.0020332558,
-0.0362805948,
-0.0323130228,
0.0025007993,
-0.0014401986,
0.0219909903,
-0.0173068307,
-0.0705942437,
-0.0222001057,
-0.0233794693,
-0.0678900108,
-0.0280944984,
-0.0622243322,
0.0147744184,
0.0405702293,
-0.0040146876,
-0.0757967755,
0.0091012167,
0.0432154126,
-0.0432842188,
0.0359873325,
-0.0099736014,
0.0295182094,
0.0414451063,
0.029975472,
0.008173109,
0.0679320022,
-0.000225368,
0.0340306647,
0.0319705009,
-0.0508118235,
0.0286621675,
0.0417059697,
-0.0083728796,
0.0402937122,
-0.0135115078,
-0.0075587509,
-0.0228584465,
-0.0001522595,
0.0403304994,
0.037432503,
0.0058941022,
0.0147438729,
0.1142865866,
0.0498903431,
0.0163970627,
0.0095970482,
-0.0249680616,
0.042113658,
0.0103118327,
-0.0079568233,
-0.0647414923,
-0.0147760678,
-0.0291885138,
0.0014964144,
0.0478200391,
0.0643143728,
-0.0149041666,
-0.0386890136,
-0.0252313018,
-0.0133423693,
0.0207195766,
0.0696633086,
0.0064308145,
-0.0312831849,
-0.0135444971,
0.059149798,
0.0547493957,
-0.0288224425,
-0.0048241839,
-0.0623375475,
0.0153972181,
0.0773385093,
0.022317091,
0.0041002617,
0.0348035879,
-0.0381499976,
0.032964047,
0.0834962949,
0.0635315776,
0.0249533243,
-0.0170799866,
-0.0396437682,
-0.0150277298,
0.0327718407,
0.0114619983,
0.0118453391,
0.0192637853,
0.0196588933,
0.0199150685,
-0.046671018,
-0.0539470054,
0.0150594702,
-0.0268938392,
-0.0101134805,
-0.0262549296,
0.0019492503,
0.0190708395,
-0.004640264,
0.0051523224,
0.0069469814,
-0.0082673552,
0.0079514859,
0.001399079,
-0.0172684621,
-0.0522819348,
0.0123701897,
0.024096312,
-0.013172294,
-0.0003774455,
0.0212439783,
0.0162032042,
-0.0044478015,
0.0184292682,
-0.0224597007,
0.0640704334,
-0.0367606878,
0.0321337804,
-0.0194922872,
0.0218875483,
-0.0291609503,
0.0630491748,
-0.0550472289,
0.034312062,
-0.0093029002,
-0.0465504527,
-0.0176357664,
-0.0161931422,
-0.0518580601,
0.0309407525,
-0.001900211,
0.0314246006,
0.0210341699,
-0.0070821051,
-0.0436444804,
0.0043178322,
-0.0652660206,
-0.0133820074,
-0.0220543798,
0.0015854625,
0.007216936,
-0.0155109726,
-0.033670716,
0.004092331,
-0.0464524738,
-0.0239317901,
0.0256718434,
0.0410994627,
-0.0178496223,
-0.0138349095,
-0.013956422,
-0.0307358205,
-0.018549053,
-0.0101133129,
0.0053222855,
-0.0112735275,
-0.040537294,
-0.0338271111,
0.0086862948,
-0.032617189,
0.0127881421,
-0.0145599889,
-0.0235077851,
0.012684009,
0.0369688608,
0.0236601196,
0.0163680092,
0.0207737666,
0.028941134,
0.0584760718,
0.0074803778,
-0.0844141841,
-0.0123628583,
0.0133747188,
-0.0194642562,
-0.0395372957,
-0.0798400268,
0.0098975897,
0.064944163,
0.0505980477,
0.0286252182,
-0.0363346301,
-0.0043168138,
-0.0590297729,
-0.0581600703,
-0.0044539059,
0.0069766026,
-0.0449415445,
0.0437223054,
0.0021061252,
-0.061960157,
0.0564920828,
-0.0176246557,
0.0188740436,
-0.0112205716,
-0.0168280657,
0.014040295,
0.0206254423,
-0.0013430653,
0.0398287587,
0.0152434194,
-0.0415677764,
-0.0199063756,
-0.0259025898,
0.0093716178,
-0.0642712563,
0.0601357892,
-0.0313876756,
0.00245021,
0.0227807742,
-0.030959785,
-0.0545639768,
-0.0878409147,
-0.0263710748,
-0.0444527939,
-0.0016621515,
-0.0327266492,
-0.0517654829,
-0.0212456007,
0.0490457974,
0.0263603367,
-0.013624941,
-0.0177825559,
0.0096703516,
-0.0541317835,
0.0506170876,
0.022344552,
0.0730973408,
-0.0415143073,
0.0374416634,
0.0527502522,
0.0375222191,
0.0206134357,
0.037808571,
-0.0355056599,
0.0456213541,
-0.0093826456,
-0.0356841087,
0.0540907346,
0.0483602136,
-0.0458413959,
0.013800255,
0.0988990068,
0.0296736639,
-0.0463890731,
0.0049239323,
-0.0818336233,
0.0589330196,
0.0356856659,
0.0050042649,
-0.0918267965,
-0.0106954537,
0.002945456,
0.0558525659,
-0.0482058972,
-0.0020343899,
-0.0079619093,
-0.1006294116,
0.0210229866,
0.006234101,
0.0313549638,
0.0038842279,
-0.0211384073,
-0.009414224,
0.0409513712,
0.0884428769,
-0.0192228183,
-0.0044933427,
-0.0279076621,
0.0089658238,
-0.1034289375,
-0.0639335811,
0.0502178743,
-0.0151243247,
0.0496193059,
0.0453462377,
0.0107268142,
-0.0394472294,
-0.0589398034,
0.0525574163,
0.0008914281,
-0.0146996761,
-0.0064812312,
0.0279487893,
0.0096866367,
0.006510233,
-0.0557849258,
0.019161094,
-0.0096275043,
0.0014034796,
0.0287156627,
0.0410354733,
-0.0243347473,
-0.0175969061,
0.0102629485,
0.0092630479,
0.0198432375,
0.0775540173,
0.0286171231,
-0.0723688379,
-0.01846065,
-0.053271804,
-0.0173958354,
0.0092287753,
-0.0590152033,
0.0801246241,
0.0293686539,
-0.0120603377,
-0.0375929363,
-0.0419940948,
0.0286764447,
-0.0081178211,
0.0070278584,
0.0114725502,
0.0196802299,
-0.0411192514,
0.0390443169,
0.0432997048,
-0.0452717654,
0.0473413281,
-0.0698991641,
0.0159076452,
-0.0200362653,
-0.0195005089,
0.0225270614,
-0.0069625308,
-0.0183559228,
-0.0521368831,
0.0580313355,
0.0170672182,
0.0307614822,
0.0302186944,
-0.0045291055,
-0.077835016,
0.0462429821,
0.0135093704,
-0.0386787578,
0.0151976943,
0.0289066769,
0.0060414546,
-0.0182829928,
0.0413116962,
-0.0104990313,
-0.0063809115,
0.0041190651,
0.021916708,
-0.0422721989,
-0.0143399853,
0.0349683948,
0.0232629925,
0.0192302465,
-0.0234235656,
-0.0064004343,
-0.0216946416,
-0.007115067,
-0.0284131356,
-0.0136479344,
0.005502718,
-0.034934476,
0.0219423212,
-0.0153065929,
0.0203483496,
-0.0247406494,
-0.0519290082,
0.002358732,
-0.0588824637,
0.0530017056,
-0.0304820724,
0.0189979244,
0.0302125197,
-0.0126037393,
-0.0378074236,
0.038568031,
0.0184036754,
0.0537071563,
0.008423863,
0.0920078307,
-0.0260119643,
-0.022627987,
0.008891426,
-0.0033244528,
0.0100638373,
-0.0787945688,
0.0046051885,
0.0112589048,
0.0139591787,
-0.000363555,
0.0668616071,
0.0010366202,
0.0107896449,
-0.0218658689,
-0.0198766477,
0.0304998625,
-0.027995443,
0.0494882353,
-0.0103067067,
-0.0422792099,
0.0035636344,
0.0620524585,
0.0097270813,
0.029668631,
-0.0262393821,
-0.0128485877,
-0.0263960343,
-0.0592465177,
-0.0216308758,
0.0195526052,
-0.0649673641,
-0.0343907997,
-0.0946376994,
-0.0449581109,
-0.0434655733,
-0.0016099347,
-0.01883935,
-0.056874007,
-0.0113835791,
0.0567377768,
-0.0167401657,
-0.0267667715,
-0.0579354838,
-0.011121463,
0.0025989132,
0.0003552379,
-0.0076011117,
-6.39230228e-33,
-0.0021700247,
-0.028457161,
-0.0004444233,
-0.0557574816,
0.0114530977,
-0.0057829311,
-0.0009402434,
0.0457382947,
-0.0419811308,
-0.0123099089,
-0.0147545673,
0.0044590915,
0.027054131,
0.0223893374,
0.0120386826,
-0.016731685,
0.0324554667,
0.0196159314,
-0.0309127029,
0.0178814512,
0.0290970132,
-0.0121715525,
0.0460593365,
-0.0708892047,
0.084418565,
-0.020546563,
-0.0152584137,
-0.0076394165,
-0.0284608435,
0.0573001392,
-0.0260632169,
0.0871214122,
0.0129225999,
-0.0454883203,
-0.0097216712,
0.0286770202,
-0.0097906552,
0.0006595275,
0.0559545867,
0.0112146921,
0.0250311103,
-0.0276538488,
0.0343547873,
-0.0068552042,
-0.0372507647,
0.0063841431,
0.0213820301,
-0.0150742903,
0.0054815481,
0.0204199217,
-0.0390576757,
0.009167769,
-0.0086205006,
0.0268834699,
-0.0587159544,
0.1052614599,
-0.0217615403,
-0.0076289838,
-0.0614831485,
0.0278696939,
0.0263321307,
0.0081257895,
0.091798991,
-0.0231549572,
0.0043822732,
0.0850317627,
0.0148482947,
0.018275775,
-0.0197209064,
-0.0412856154,
0.0366865173,
0.0098603964,
0.0219210032,
0.0579020642,
-0.0062595913,
-0.0608080514,
-0.0393904187,
0.0048943362,
0.0334256217,
0.0337494574,
0.0655050129,
-0.0254546814,
-0.0799443126,
-0.0635517091,
-0.0392564796,
0.0324942097,
-0.0271959193,
-0.0417501293,
0.0626204684,
-0.0086871991,
-0.002245459,
-0.0079709087,
0.0309884176,
-0.0280103944,
-0.0604677722,
-0.0130079463,
-0.0075709219,
-0.0039622062,
-0.0046182447,
0.0517445765,
-0.062932834,
0.0015207331,
-0.0491661057,
-0.000684215,
0.0165443588,
0.0307217017,
0.0045991298,
-0.0148476586,
-0.0866910666,
0.0188337006,
-0.0173535459,
0.0390584171,
0.0229267515,
-0.0084357103,
0.0602227561,
-0.0317794792,
-0.0118159475,
0.0272722691,
0.0086214226,
-0.022805471,
-0.0536086112,
-0.0310489796,
-0.0228235014,
0.062177591,
-0.0365749337,
-0.0113348095,
-0.0527864844,
0.0144887427,
0.0665855557,
-0.028977247,
-0.021372553,
-0.0405675173,
2.499e-7,
0.0226733722,
0.061177969,
-0.045470234,
0.0112017766,
-0.0143097583,
0.0413782299,
0.0107904328,
0.0126789818,
0.0549441352,
-0.0010478988,
-0.035699185,
-0.0076829772,
0.0429353006,
0.0468265377,
-0.0612021089,
0.0125879841,
-0.0601613596,
0.041419521,
-0.0781517848,
0.0178880282,
0.0232046396,
0.068896316,
0.0029074412,
-0.027061848,
-0.0251136795,
-0.0599670149,
0.0344608873,
-0.0491343774,
-0.044226855,
-0.0035727869,
0.0563436672,
0.0116556529,
0.0339898467,
0.038027361,
-0.0157618616,
0.0014482551,
-0.0210555159,
0.0489161126,
0.0150259808,
-0.0226280354,
-0.0164819211,
-0.0294773933,
0.0149986967,
-0.0837155208,
0.061967954,
0.002200213,
-0.0156574901,
-0.004786334,
0.0131055303,
-0.0437764376,
0.0394898877,
-0.0422095098,
-0.0324099287,
0.0027093105,
0.0316108987,
0.0051902286,
-0.0062939976,
-0.0133195594,
-0.0176369641,
0.00581162,
-0.012134634,
-0.0742815435,
-0.0160591379,
0.0457255691,
-0.0277264118,
-0.0339827798,
0.0353042968,
2.319889759e-34,
0.0305302236,
0.0475695468,
0.0473625287,
-0.0115177492,
0.0440441109,
0.0481585748,
0.0668870434,
0.0130462851,
-0.0026551378,
-0.0551494434,
-0.0031499832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17716v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17716v2 | ViANLI: Adversarial Natural Language Inference for Vietnamese | 2024-06-25T16:58:19 | 2024-07-01T15:19:51 | Tin Van Huynh, Kiet Van Nguyen, Ngan Luu-Thuy Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The development of Natural Language Processing (NLI) datasets and models has
been inspired by innovations in annotation design. With the rapid development
of machine learning models today, the performance of existing machine learning
models has quickly reached state-of-the-art results on a variety of tasks
related to natural language processing, including natural language inference
tasks. By using a pre-trained model during the annotation process, it is
possible to challenge current NLI models by having humans produce
premise-hypothesis combinations that the machine model cannot correctly
predict. To remain attractive and challenging in the research of natural
language inference for Vietnamese, in this paper, we introduce the adversarial
NLI dataset to the NLP research community with the name ViANLI. This data set
contains more than 10K premise-hypothesis pairs and is built by a continuously
adjusting process to obtain the most out of the patterns generated by the
annotators. ViANLI dataset has brought many difficulties to many current SOTA
models when the accuracy of the most powerful model on the test set only
reached 48.4%. Additionally, the experimental results show that the models
trained on our dataset have significantly improved the results on other
Vietnamese NLI datasets. | [
0.0532222465,
0.0701498538,
-0.0249648672,
0.0434883907,
-0.0438763052,
0.0248614959,
0.0128460536,
-0.0255510285,
0.0743760169,
-0.0404475518,
-0.0222141426,
-0.0131932953,
0.0185943339,
0.0178447198,
0.0355065949,
-0.0456947051,
0.0325399674,
-0.0056112916,
0.0033133137,
-0.0118832346,
0.001459355,
0.0047119376,
0.0049158363,
0.0253731646,
0.0059419735,
-0.0139832851,
-0.0060318131,
0.0284283608,
0.0020874967,
-0.0544022098,
-0.0028405369,
0.0551858433,
-0.0097632213,
0.0501221418,
0.0000020416,
-0.0368092507,
0.010703072,
-0.0180564784,
-0.0306928921,
0.0184844118,
0.0436071493,
-0.0590621009,
-0.001639284,
0.0228053033,
-0.0521699116,
-0.0513469987,
0.0514575094,
0.0573855229,
0.0588482209,
0.0575133786,
-0.02362689,
-0.0492214151,
0.0101142153,
-0.062451046,
-0.0429762043,
-0.0369725041,
0.0353823826,
-0.0106291417,
-0.026840182,
-0.0336872153,
-0.0132722445,
0.0327576473,
0.0484840758,
0.0253242403,
-0.0456601866,
0.0150650628,
-0.0221807379,
-0.0238147769,
-0.0079592625,
0.0693180859,
-0.0151586281,
-0.0287249535,
-0.0332102738,
0.0036379753,
-0.0040757759,
0.0167799033,
-0.0044014831,
0.0172865707,
-0.0182644799,
0.0290462729,
0.0908903033,
0.0199039988,
0.0260289758,
0.039395906,
0.0106559685,
-0.0199245792,
0.0006226203,
-0.0357300118,
0.0276009701,
0.0146661652,
-0.0879526287,
-0.0340187438,
0.0079854485,
-0.011932293,
0.0090379715,
0.0109603405,
-0.0288131312,
-0.0300876051,
0.0452547707,
-0.0846699029,
0.0239568502,
0.014909775,
-0.0644500107,
0.0511030555,
-0.012234401,
0.0040317392,
-0.045079425,
0.0129325595,
-0.0379268974,
-0.0300539117,
-0.0027149383,
0.0038639784,
-0.0375389904,
0.035951443,
-0.0356832221,
-0.0033454015,
-0.0407221429,
-0.0027714449,
-0.0180610884,
-0.0113134356,
-0.0049487255,
0.0249956623,
-0.0683238581,
-0.0108406087,
-0.0027132069,
0.0021919273,
-0.033616025,
0.0662657991,
-0.015340236,
-0.083521679,
-0.0067121182,
0.0509020388,
-0.0107174758,
-0.0430516787,
0.0183066968,
0.0646057054,
0.0116878236,
0.0076368796,
-0.0566419885,
0.0154277692,
0.0105418544,
-0.0582282208,
0.0036833333,
-0.0445577353,
0.0172620621,
-0.0054449318,
0.0204166453,
-0.0580402426,
-0.0000664347,
-0.0008069361,
-0.0178434234,
0.1101502627,
-0.0062425621,
-0.0194659568,
0.0262390822,
0.0075514195,
-0.0165077839,
0.0804732218,
-0.009046304,
0.0463888161,
0.0315877534,
0.0054080235,
-0.0210336242,
0.0248828828,
0.0152025567,
-0.0024882697,
-0.0094326427,
0.0361020081,
-0.0179190636,
0.0227862578,
-0.0020573991,
0.0626069009,
-0.0231829304,
-0.0341207311,
0.034084972,
0.0270838868,
-0.0058323098,
0.0340522528,
0.0447002426,
0.0083143888,
0.0323030204,
0.0176931079,
-0.0524635315,
0.0107915699,
-0.0487769246,
-0.020246923,
0.0219621323,
0.0312383007,
-0.0328596383,
-0.0747493804,
-0.015651498,
-0.0386597551,
0.0066333963,
-0.0032209861,
0.056872759,
0.0675906762,
-0.0146119632,
0.0145025849,
0.0495519973,
-0.0224728063,
-0.0359597504,
-0.0435851701,
0.0045798011,
0.0031525707,
0.0285402779,
-0.025931675,
0.027058458,
-0.0015568774,
0.0088190334,
0.0790495053,
0.0597154461,
-0.0235213004,
0.0173828062,
-0.0209497251,
0.0237570107,
0.0042256457,
0.0489619896,
0.0703914315,
0.0219679847,
0.0166138355,
0.0228122249,
-0.0139605617,
-0.0376323499,
0.0531693548,
-0.0144894719,
-0.0329101048,
0.0249158833,
0.0347959362,
0.0471992791,
0.0150784375,
-0.0144892959,
-0.0020270054,
0.037513189,
-0.0536923632,
0.0158065483,
0.0033591995,
-0.0003241311,
-0.0887214243,
-0.0087055247,
-0.0612463281,
-0.0279828366,
0.0806176588,
-0.0679379553,
0.0000570263,
0.020370353,
-0.0080110338,
-0.0136940656,
-0.0794047862,
-0.0206617899,
0.0174935572,
0.0627068207,
-0.0063817883,
0.083771579,
-0.0230182502,
-0.0082186563,
0.041475527,
0.018650718,
0.0194912627,
-0.0276250839,
-0.0381206572,
0.0436126925,
-0.0023925458,
-0.0085303355,
0.0010981392,
-0.0158873294,
0.0090573141,
-0.0172721073,
-0.0914942846,
0.0081261154,
-0.0423905589,
0.0000844165,
0.0172419045,
-0.0053308303,
-0.0296078194,
-0.0661575198,
0.0073039955,
-0.020209454,
0.0042828955,
0.0287249964,
0.0070420615,
-0.0154457632,
0.0171256401,
-0.0322194658,
-0.0257819388,
0.0012566033,
0.0431444682,
0.0069765858,
-0.0571139865,
-0.033161141,
-0.0105213644,
-0.014808978,
0.0312269479,
-0.0206279848,
-0.0611150041,
0.0178037379,
0.0048321239,
-0.0385157242,
0.0939797461,
-0.0062813852,
0.0201198719,
0.0252691247,
0.0137885613,
-0.0042278627,
0.011822545,
-0.0143459411,
0.0095256101,
-0.0329622962,
-0.0254322812,
-0.0422460213,
0.0651000962,
0.0298702922,
-0.0089602731,
-0.0260407124,
0.0215928331,
-0.0275179036,
-0.0210394897,
0.015541357,
0.0114863273,
-0.0169243719,
0.0102737183,
-0.0229542907,
-0.0316587016,
0.1175079867,
0.0096536707,
0.0054116235,
-0.0541392602,
-0.0002354374,
-0.0372162834,
0.0961871967,
0.0305671729,
-0.0182861164,
0.0225226078,
-0.012216026,
-0.0257200822,
0.0135847069,
0.0378352255,
-0.024063766,
0.0234462209,
-0.0384950452,
-0.0124700163,
-0.0133611904,
-0.0290306993,
-0.0787529871,
-0.0285004992,
-0.044832658,
0.0002641633,
-0.008874082,
0.0304744765,
0.0020247169,
-0.0075015319,
-0.0573977493,
0.0174781363,
0.0061585722,
0.0272041988,
-0.0353982747,
0.0383114666,
0.0422788747,
-0.0259983651,
0.0085939411,
0.015192044,
0.0619816333,
0.0561135337,
-0.0335540287,
0.0192007646,
-0.0137502756,
0.0179499388,
0.0170090217,
-0.0133764651,
-0.0052575725,
-0.0020476119,
0.0045614541,
-0.0437360778,
0.0322058648,
0.0720449537,
0.0168457832,
0.006009643,
0.0292130858,
0.0334439427,
0.0147663169,
0.0036340551,
0.004135652,
-0.079225935,
-0.0406254157,
-0.0056554368,
-0.0095803617,
-0.0188485701,
-0.0199481808,
-0.0205658805,
-0.1146164536,
0.0118183447,
-0.022234749,
-0.0358556621,
-0.023827387,
-0.0555989593,
-0.0017762994,
-0.0622338988,
0.0257282574,
-0.0160556268,
0.0242196918,
-0.0081600584,
0.0125552081,
-0.0285377428,
-0.044188261,
0.0435548723,
-0.0376506411,
0.0199462008,
0.0458144769,
0.0465440601,
-0.0093860086,
0.0004093397,
0.0320482589,
-0.0209358484,
0.0058084168,
-0.0082958993,
0.0707199946,
-0.0034666462,
-0.001555852,
-0.0231732186,
0.0531149432,
-0.0344461314,
-0.0098450379,
0.0166155454,
0.0663337409,
-0.0064996802,
-0.0152602633,
-0.0019866629,
0.0242973417,
0.0046453914,
0.0824966282,
0.0277880188,
-0.0411396101,
-0.0359233692,
-0.0377694331,
-0.0236973446,
-0.0344448984,
-0.0304348581,
0.0420298018,
-0.0132641615,
-0.0760505497,
-0.0754291788,
-0.0829653069,
-0.000507708,
0.0390183888,
0.0113496557,
0.0380634777,
-0.0099485759,
0.0035249204,
-0.0158083364,
0.0292018186,
-0.0092461808,
0.0036829656,
0.0387158096,
-0.0239851624,
0.0186399408,
-0.0392639525,
-0.0031900886,
0.0293717124,
-0.0768173262,
-0.0741761923,
0.0284060966,
0.0427105539,
0.0221875999,
0.0853423625,
-0.0395302624,
-0.0307533666,
0.0022934561,
0.0524672195,
0.0053016325,
-0.0389283262,
0.0467063859,
-0.0324949399,
0.0064707915,
0.065897353,
0.0112222712,
0.0132089155,
0.0490097813,
-0.0095804846,
-0.0369304381,
-0.0022787093,
0.0268497188,
0.0180386454,
0.0873137563,
-0.019649066,
-0.0434935875,
-0.048704356,
0.0222246256,
-0.028172506,
-0.0349148735,
-0.0132065909,
0.0119407969,
0.0175464414,
0.0173355862,
-0.0383851193,
-0.0227535293,
-0.0224709585,
0.009240713,
-0.0049853846,
0.0232750718,
0.0487397723,
0.0880600959,
-0.004267199,
0.0019518008,
-0.0285146032,
-0.0052411472,
0.0038465234,
0.0563819557,
0.0082889581,
0.034923166,
0.0290323775,
-0.0069449283,
0.0126010524,
0.0036055828,
-0.0430395901,
-0.013513905,
-0.0447015688,
0.0303534362,
0.0674112812,
-0.030051453,
0.0220830627,
-0.0547787175,
0.009635116,
0.0022812376,
0.0339325555,
-0.00300134,
-0.0372125544,
0.0236320551,
-0.0141595788,
-0.0162226576,
0.0047379062,
0.0526013821,
0.0187668037,
0.0686153024,
0.0171637367,
-0.007238538,
-0.0461308509,
-0.0373573862,
0.0243537407,
0.0127528673,
-0.0301333014,
0.0305708181,
-0.0336306654,
-0.0900589153,
-0.0043848786,
0.0254910346,
0.0242461003,
0.0427690893,
-0.0018056552,
0.0658719093,
0.0263909902,
-0.0227202214,
-0.0505728237,
0.0144060729,
-0.0488795415,
0.0008401904,
-0.0223523006,
-6.562610106e-33,
-0.0285680965,
-0.0099051809,
0.0009170183,
-0.0296406467,
0.0089159943,
-0.0047330335,
-0.0382688157,
-0.0053609032,
-0.0531264953,
0.0094457036,
-0.0172119886,
0.0123563213,
0.0290586855,
0.0289105512,
-0.0060178461,
-0.0463648364,
0.0061354097,
0.0344627239,
0.0092768967,
-0.0348618999,
0.0027438879,
0.0224655177,
0.0843596682,
-0.0713451207,
0.0436625741,
0.0050389371,
-0.0102042044,
0.0057619461,
-0.0497304574,
0.0463547595,
-0.0244078338,
0.0420095511,
0.0256617218,
0.0025318791,
0.0111299101,
-0.0221355129,
-0.081082873,
-0.0653789565,
0.0497630797,
0.0632084608,
-0.0528411604,
-0.0276812576,
0.0109545263,
-0.0176831149,
-0.0007084826,
0.0140584102,
0.0236288514,
-0.0534117892,
0.0293701012,
0.026975926,
-0.0400071479,
0.0381636694,
0.0227914434,
-0.0066244099,
-0.0079216957,
0.0597865954,
0.0078717507,
-0.0399739332,
-0.0977505147,
0.019249469,
0.0016969849,
-0.0129261836,
0.0326165184,
-0.0068673538,
0.0448873304,
0.0268014185,
0.0465275459,
-0.0161330942,
-0.0493009277,
0.0070817377,
0.0015173595,
0.0455190763,
0.0669098124,
0.0833397359,
0.0931436121,
0.0055927252,
-0.0948718935,
-0.0119802542,
0.0242768489,
0.0271151848,
0.005669164,
-0.0038992574,
-0.0857218355,
-0.0375025943,
-0.0175409131,
-0.10292238,
-0.0162331741,
-0.0605633743,
-0.0019333115,
0.0219083056,
-0.0563741028,
0.028695425,
0.0124753974,
-0.0598940887,
-0.0018593564,
-0.0030855245,
-0.010232551,
-0.0351025723,
-0.0065852152,
0.0436370634,
-0.0585320629,
-0.0074221129,
0.0141202165,
-0.0182185881,
0.0185102802,
0.0079835868,
0.0723985061,
-0.0049639666,
-0.0396874733,
0.0106081944,
-0.0298399478,
-0.0088897599,
0.0021502459,
0.0140918205,
0.0546739474,
0.0382592753,
-0.0000492256,
0.0137731452,
0.0275020301,
0.0199705139,
-0.0679306015,
0.0164786465,
-0.001170955,
0.0063353451,
-0.0332958736,
-0.0064290529,
-0.0224201716,
-0.01358217,
0.0082301823,
-0.0674963817,
-0.0140824495,
0.0168717373,
2.668e-7,
0.0463004336,
0.0027634038,
0.0548869111,
0.0100778863,
-0.0102758696,
0.0305736959,
0.0003646807,
0.0024477174,
0.0072250343,
-0.0187412966,
0.0276928023,
0.0424131267,
0.0651179627,
0.0423473082,
-0.0866612643,
0.0101986192,
-0.0584563389,
0.0153593654,
-0.0306063276,
-0.0374208838,
0.0506559163,
0.1298654079,
0.0071230922,
-0.0132118547,
-0.029020384,
-0.021501068,
0.0478152595,
0.0135597466,
-0.0208163653,
0.0072326423,
0.0431726985,
-0.0136270514,
0.0063664108,
0.0265203621,
-0.0195492189,
-0.0376178212,
0.0339724794,
0.0163792539,
-0.0090472344,
-0.0277131442,
-0.0308867712,
-0.0134507557,
-0.0118109705,
-0.0267723612,
0.0920796618,
-0.0251341127,
-0.0552655831,
-0.0151283378,
-0.0043873992,
0.0414395109,
0.0586065799,
-0.0062387018,
-0.0274964739,
0.0125306323,
0.04218743,
-0.0315079279,
-0.0286680423,
-0.01492994,
-0.0387463942,
-0.034479104,
-0.031924542,
-0.0000983419,
-0.0055137379,
0.0231464859,
0.0411032923,
-0.016291162,
0.0053443131,
2.065350921e-34,
0.0235221088,
0.0062209647,
0.0052044806,
-0.0205017291,
0.0559040047,
-0.029437229,
-0.0028765637,
-0.0067832014,
0.0056237821,
-0.0440899469,
-0.0149436686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17706v1 | FedBiOT: LLM Local Fine-tuning in Federated Learning without Full Model | 2024-06-25T16:45:47 | 2024-06-25T16:45:47 | Feijie Wu, Zitao Li, Yaliang Li, Bolin Ding, Jing Gao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC | Large language models (LLMs) show amazing performance on many domain-specific
tasks after fine-tuning with some appropriate data. However, many
domain-specific data are privately distributed across multiple owners. Thus,
this dilemma raises the interest in how to perform LLM fine-tuning in federated
learning (FL). However, confronted with limited computation and communication
capacities, FL clients struggle to fine-tune an LLM effectively. To this end,
we introduce FedBiOT, a resource-efficient LLM fine-tuning approach to FL.
Specifically, our method involves the server generating a compressed LLM and
aligning its performance with the full model. Subsequently, the clients
fine-tune a lightweight yet important part of the compressed model, referred to
as an adapter. Notice that as the server has no access to the private data
owned by the clients, the data used for alignment by the server has a different
distribution from the one used for fine-tuning by clients. We formulate the
problem into a bi-level optimization problem to minimize the negative effect of
data discrepancy and derive the updating rules for the server and clients. We
conduct extensive experiments on LLaMA-2, empirically showing that the adapter
has exceptional performance when reintegrated into the global LLM. The results
also indicate that the proposed FedBiOT significantly reduces resource
consumption compared to existing benchmarks, all while achieving comparable
performance levels. | [
-0.0048591848,
0.0779442638,
-0.0237358678,
0.056091819,
-0.0504147708,
-0.0037646494,
0.0498327538,
-0.0111038415,
0.0086029097,
-0.00846365,
-0.076182276,
-0.0275226999,
0.0204451419,
0.032380335,
-0.0073936116,
0.0083681587,
0.0415510423,
-0.0152878733,
-0.0308810305,
-0.0401249751,
-0.035972178,
-0.0017087271,
0.0250069685,
0.0040307213,
0.0306915212,
-0.0414599851,
-0.015184612,
0.0177128818,
0.0048979949,
0.0266801938,
0.03987699,
0.0411745533,
0.0135127949,
0.0768393055,
0.0000021781,
-0.0275452211,
-0.0444030836,
0.0214961022,
-0.0315661579,
0.0884731337,
0.0171573721,
-0.0026802032,
-0.0230312124,
0.0357158519,
-0.0339746252,
-0.0118508507,
0.0291574541,
-0.013328963,
0.0836292505,
0.078393504,
0.0020799595,
-0.0354282595,
0.0054081716,
-0.0394620784,
-0.1231549531,
-0.0456108488,
0.0142975263,
-0.0244601239,
-0.0418291911,
-0.0257882513,
-0.0311600827,
0.0070526307,
0.0142368376,
0.0308112726,
-0.0118654501,
-0.0013838749,
-0.0614461079,
-0.0292152725,
-0.022282647,
0.04694492,
0.0056479047,
-0.008420283,
0.0130262934,
-0.018795887,
-0.0224418957,
0.0046699652,
-0.0011252521,
0.0161447916,
0.0269678459,
0.0424503163,
0.0122225517,
-0.0290237442,
0.0319492035,
0.0071174828,
-0.011021696,
0.0940016434,
0.0018400997,
0.0144025162,
-0.0529506989,
-0.0101598809,
-0.0166083854,
-0.0614273176,
0.0328903608,
0.0411407277,
-0.0254514143,
-0.0144901043,
-0.0879802108,
-0.0629331321,
0.0198128447,
0.0206349269,
0.077003397,
0.009216317,
0.0016888028,
0.049253691,
-0.0204693042,
0.0113523016,
-0.0314116366,
0.0315205418,
-0.0171666108,
0.0071278759,
-0.0166100785,
0.0290495083,
-0.0032895515,
0.0390895195,
-0.0660324171,
0.0027491702,
-0.016372323,
0.0320257694,
0.0079858834,
0.0360128284,
0.008644239,
-0.027308248,
-0.037661735,
-0.0077328365,
0.012309744,
0.0249084774,
-0.0340063609,
0.0110372817,
0.0330291912,
-0.0531444252,
-0.012155531,
-0.0089877294,
-0.0347755589,
-0.012046067,
0.0175984465,
0.0558258481,
0.0130969724,
-0.0018284902,
0.0069968146,
-0.0522624515,
0.0560681596,
-0.083925657,
0.0021035022,
-0.0376314893,
0.0185860489,
-0.0069952151,
0.0144037101,
-0.0440674797,
-0.0205747969,
-0.0313473344,
-0.0283818226,
0.0520656109,
-0.0467091314,
0.0020855202,
-0.0069499779,
0.0073287962,
0.0156223252,
0.1055157408,
0.0208958648,
0.0044787251,
0.0431455448,
0.0073680338,
-0.0485515483,
0.0382863581,
0.0635784864,
0.059134014,
-0.0257362369,
0.0102038626,
0.0004083732,
0.0444412492,
0.0009015489,
0.0209668186,
-0.0055425526,
-0.0196575671,
0.0447392836,
0.056253802,
0.0580508225,
0.0135324774,
-0.0525691658,
0.0194785763,
0.0042491159,
0.0319096111,
-0.0671754554,
0.0241221674,
-0.0199646316,
-0.0287271254,
0.0232304838,
0.1122396961,
-0.0285616182,
-0.0313866623,
-0.0145038776,
-0.0438197106,
-0.0483160391,
0.015620999,
0.0208958965,
-0.0010727104,
-0.0122613981,
0.0757944137,
0.0447094478,
-0.0228977334,
-0.0194397233,
-0.0339147523,
-0.0090482282,
0.0621905774,
0.0779167786,
-0.002294133,
-0.0512865968,
-0.0066783717,
0.0301498175,
0.0212613679,
0.0175523032,
0.0213818885,
0.0186304748,
-0.0539131798,
-0.0708050728,
0.0230709258,
0.0120268138,
-0.0045922217,
-0.0049790544,
-0.0065308656,
-0.0317543633,
-0.0229081791,
-0.0008113382,
0.0306892619,
0.0111068478,
-0.0055415751,
0.0104770595,
0.0237824097,
0.048553165,
-0.0292618405,
-0.0143924737,
-0.0387563445,
0.0127568953,
-0.0096647162,
-0.0123731708,
-0.0386433452,
-0.0017100903,
0.0002778826,
0.0216006022,
0.0136302309,
0.0361969918,
0.0430855453,
-0.088509202,
-0.0310971979,
-0.0037948224,
0.0083531998,
0.0246819891,
-0.0140170408,
0.0243662111,
-0.0233891625,
0.0448676348,
-0.0248881057,
0.0036469747,
-0.0412857942,
-0.0237967651,
-0.0133484788,
-0.0189353768,
0.0243788064,
-0.0172537565,
0.0345636047,
0.0091963019,
0.0141121224,
0.0167898294,
-0.0264852587,
0.0235959962,
-0.0066431775,
-0.0009206815,
0.0170837194,
0.0384967662,
-0.0348162577,
0.056648124,
0.0293682683,
0.0200860538,
-0.0211647693,
-0.020338444,
-0.012931671,
0.0693890378,
-0.0432379469,
0.0264469218,
0.0201309137,
0.0092244279,
-0.0490336269,
-0.0167273656,
-0.0307609979,
0.0319129378,
0.0136636393,
-0.0329365991,
-0.0078114062,
-0.0808898509,
0.0256010704,
-0.0613693558,
0.0443866514,
0.0028519761,
-0.0382315554,
-0.0192874596,
0.0319681801,
-0.0112804938,
0.0824697167,
-0.0276307482,
-0.0103338761,
0.065003261,
0.0266649593,
-0.0786961913,
0.009745406,
-0.0152013702,
-0.0422890857,
-0.0609007776,
0.0421498194,
0.0149005102,
0.0659608021,
-0.0595748462,
-0.0298260637,
-0.0223426484,
0.0407281369,
-0.0156034268,
-0.0216618571,
-0.025958959,
0.0358872339,
0.0047325743,
0.0566601716,
0.0142476941,
-0.0942550004,
0.0891349241,
-0.030235203,
0.0142117292,
-0.0083092321,
-0.0475892015,
-0.0642460212,
0.0148714203,
-0.0132498182,
0.0265214797,
-0.0220166519,
-0.0445896164,
-0.0478586107,
0.0274894387,
0.0341458209,
-0.0379616395,
0.0063717356,
-0.003775086,
-0.0107953595,
-0.0505428575,
-0.0617613047,
0.0147716859,
-0.0257611871,
-0.0456287712,
0.0161952227,
-0.0168666486,
-0.0327722393,
-0.038027063,
0.0087737134,
-0.0095961001,
0.005505268,
-0.0121820299,
0.0199069697,
-0.0367223099,
-0.0247369781,
0.0114835408,
0.0021572728,
-0.0066580363,
-0.028966004,
-0.0295327269,
0.0387945212,
0.0394981541,
-0.022533644,
0.0336841904,
-0.0328572579,
0.0605951101,
-0.0177509207,
-0.0229444858,
-0.0111629507,
0.0599131547,
-0.0471420959,
-0.0091595035,
0.0727721825,
0.0090728262,
-0.0452685505,
-0.0000766338,
-0.0353846028,
0.0668171123,
0.0148673737,
0.0398141593,
-0.0799084231,
-0.0312825143,
0.0467523932,
0.0550565459,
0.0321979858,
-0.0207434334,
-0.0217898879,
-0.1102538481,
0.0181704592,
0.0236415602,
-0.0030314703,
-0.0363989472,
-0.0365218632,
0.0219419319,
-0.0031644057,
0.0230117328,
-0.0165316425,
0.0290210526,
-0.0072053415,
0.0156077165,
0.0076189996,
-0.04936314,
-0.0080258129,
-0.0153990313,
0.0794083551,
0.0261315964,
0.001214502,
0.0348806567,
-0.0742888898,
0.0166075937,
0.0417421907,
-0.0169340186,
-0.038824223,
-0.012507027,
0.0042924578,
-0.0218080934,
0.0196294412,
0.0127569363,
0.0172999911,
-0.0016436549,
0.0068158903,
0.0948340446,
-0.0098849749,
0.0257968605,
0.0034181569,
-0.0416125283,
0.0153706465,
0.0410055816,
0.0276146773,
-0.0182291064,
-0.0220053084,
0.011702463,
-0.0107076485,
-0.0042504566,
0.0038277558,
0.02490291,
-0.0255647972,
0.0208410323,
-0.0115132108,
0.0324248709,
0.0050406707,
0.0528996959,
0.0146063501,
0.010039025,
0.0276722703,
-0.0039447765,
-0.0449175201,
0.0010107636,
-0.0874509439,
0.0329597071,
-0.0721437186,
-0.0289233718,
0.0392431244,
0.0162815657,
-0.0180756282,
0.0164516829,
-0.0643320903,
-0.0785220042,
0.0214662142,
0.0251253955,
0.021960875,
0.0493227206,
-0.0185845215,
-0.0693140179,
0.0637907386,
0.058919102,
-0.078017965,
0.0477843471,
0.0372642502,
-0.0751656964,
0.0167381074,
0.0599391721,
-0.0646960586,
-0.0015001553,
0.0570605658,
-0.00061346,
0.0080879321,
-0.0982146636,
-0.0481443368,
0.0663151219,
0.0581548624,
-0.0112431878,
-0.0274476595,
-0.0067507569,
0.0649567395,
0.0103620673,
0.0104435012,
-0.031957183,
-0.0220330786,
-0.0061641582,
-0.0272179209,
0.0287409946,
0.0083018281,
0.0561128929,
0.0091601629,
-0.010808385,
0.0121895792,
-0.0102972249,
-0.0434983373,
0.0641679987,
0.0173855498,
0.0269009117,
0.023477871,
0.0564440526,
0.0709505454,
-0.0361748338,
0.0090670707,
-0.0135993976,
0.0545612089,
-0.0602390058,
0.0403406769,
-0.0141523536,
-0.1076711193,
-0.0028640628,
0.0346512571,
0.0353397019,
0.0429203287,
0.0102020772,
-0.0178970229,
-0.0107923634,
-0.0141525501,
0.0025052796,
-0.0439040177,
-0.0308106821,
0.0427478887,
-0.0168477464,
-0.0049832072,
0.0513196848,
0.0826515481,
-0.001709819,
0.0411212482,
-0.0548186265,
0.0315980539,
-0.0474952534,
-0.0204734392,
0.0020064912,
0.0325231999,
-0.0332047977,
-0.0225548036,
-0.0267668404,
-0.0611490048,
0.0047201472,
0.0047008954,
-0.0089828167,
-0.026159687,
0.0151256286,
0.0285031386,
0.0067162868,
-0.0018642333,
-0.0539518893,
0.0010385291,
0.0130746262,
-0.0025105476,
0.0446324199,
-6.80466276e-33,
-0.0471461564,
0.0095692296,
0.0080268672,
0.0319262035,
-0.0238636602,
0.0302441362,
-0.002894605,
-0.0235801879,
0.0178912766,
-0.0246592574,
-0.053120587,
0.0157247204,
0.0334450155,
0.0160577279,
-0.0147411954,
-0.0284286104,
0.0347482376,
-0.0521971136,
-0.0527257137,
0.0173565801,
0.0329854302,
0.0475543849,
0.0223673657,
-0.0337275341,
-0.0335300528,
-0.0178137776,
-0.0060019353,
0.0450638123,
-0.0376977436,
0.023596989,
-0.0167744141,
0.018808715,
-0.0020198806,
-0.0265491996,
-0.0250989981,
-0.0334345885,
-0.0460327975,
0.0043060174,
-0.0071305232,
0.0189931467,
-0.0391189381,
-0.0395536348,
0.0539483838,
0.016543543,
-0.0352658778,
-0.0247118287,
0.0015344587,
-0.0078818202,
-0.0365006067,
-0.0275616255,
-0.0277978461,
-0.0100370608,
0.0305564925,
-0.0052451626,
0.0465166681,
-0.0335891247,
0.015402426,
-0.0062637576,
-0.0397628956,
0.0112922601,
0.0202231146,
0.0371573046,
0.0808152258,
0.0221233685,
-0.0040774294,
0.0399142541,
0.0472314395,
0.0107018454,
-0.0128892334,
0.0328079574,
0.0275288913,
0.0214244481,
-0.0144751109,
0.0462500714,
-0.0133843804,
-0.0380246229,
-0.0457194857,
-0.0072702812,
0.0410923138,
-0.0165008046,
-0.011540846,
0.0350688845,
0.0048564645,
-0.0087651582,
-0.0352449045,
0.0181171931,
-0.0197049472,
0.0066689844,
-0.0123264519,
0.0113642411,
-0.0279489066,
-0.0516183116,
0.0350867435,
-0.0392209105,
-0.0011246712,
-0.0034280859,
0.0586569235,
0.0049328622,
0.0169472564,
0.0232064202,
-0.0731454045,
-0.0469096974,
-0.0289867353,
-0.0360322036,
0.0272656139,
0.0071756998,
0.0670188442,
0.0304992013,
-0.0654753223,
0.0053105964,
-0.0352407657,
0.0118604507,
0.0251016691,
0.023380816,
0.0530020297,
-0.03070914,
0.0171631481,
0.0218624715,
0.0083921812,
0.0050579701,
-0.0116727138,
-0.0090181399,
0.0061502601,
0.0201351028,
-0.0060270056,
0.0034673584,
-0.0532444939,
0.0355967432,
0.0389979184,
-0.0261360686,
-0.0052366736,
-0.0379410461,
2.951e-7,
0.0230781697,
0.0459816679,
-0.0163958333,
-0.0325500406,
0.0329613648,
0.0350381657,
-0.0435266979,
0.0375269614,
0.0031408772,
0.0275102239,
0.0053067347,
0.0284657907,
0.055885423,
0.0031728123,
-0.0434295759,
0.0308244117,
-0.0300399158,
0.0530871041,
-0.0502500981,
-0.0587281026,
-0.0531337745,
0.081748113,
0.039936237,
-0.0442282036,
0.0181043278,
-0.0143603077,
0.0293186754,
-0.0330685526,
-0.0522383228,
0.0131102633,
0.0201983973,
0.1027902737,
-0.0298428256,
-0.0360503085,
-0.0110679585,
0.0236746315,
-0.0617405996,
0.0843556225,
0.0336946659,
0.0243072473,
-0.0029612759,
-0.0398774147,
-0.0484066829,
0.0243484676,
0.0469119735,
-0.0270132571,
-0.0257130396,
-0.0182041246,
0.0392556526,
-0.0676035136,
0.0409304872,
-0.0040403525,
0.0201132707,
0.0275082029,
-0.0004583378,
-0.0254763979,
-0.0420671627,
-0.0688579008,
-0.0054213954,
-0.0199031774,
-0.0243356247,
-0.0499996915,
-0.0333599187,
0.0229147542,
0.0205625258,
-0.0317941234,
0.0116256252,
2.836497256e-34,
0.0240344983,
-0.025370717,
0.02832748,
0.0407823697,
-0.0251190402,
-0.0362560898,
0.0010291032,
0.0181054138,
-0.0129285278,
-0.03793367,
0.0079593621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17692v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17692v1 | From Distributional to Overton Pluralism: Investigating Large Language Model Alignment | 2024-06-25T16:32:33 | 2024-06-25T16:32:33 | Thom Lake, Eunsol Choi, Greg Durrett | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The alignment process changes several properties of a large language model's
(LLM's) output distribution. We analyze two aspects of post-alignment
distributional shift of LLM responses. First, we re-examine previously reported
reductions in response diversity post-alignment. Our analysis suggests that an
apparent drop in the diversity of responses is largely explained by quality
control and information aggregation. Alignment suppresses irrelevant and
unhelpful content while shifting the output distribution toward longer
responses that cover information spanning several responses from the base LLM,
essentially presenting diverse information in a single response. Finding little
evidence that alignment suppresses useful information, it is natural to ask the
opposite question: do aligned models surface information that cannot be
recovered from base models? Our second investigation shows this is not the case
and the behavior of aligned models is recoverable from base models without
fine-tuning. A combination of in-context examples and lower-resolution semantic
hints about response content can elicit responses from base LLMs that are as
similar to alignment-tuned LLM responses as alignment-tuned LLM responses are
to each other. Taken together, these results indicate that current alignment
techniques capture but do not extend the useful subset of assistant-like base
LLM behavior, providing further evidence for the Superficial Alignment
Hypothesis. They also show that in-context alignment can go surprisingly far as
a strategy for imitating aligned LLMs without fine-tuning. Our code and data is
available at https://github.com/thomlake/investigating-alignment. | [
0.0208503418,
0.041046124,
-0.0365810096,
0.0338489786,
-0.055195339,
-0.0038789629,
-0.0095025925,
-0.0201321971,
-0.0649216324,
-0.0211254936,
-0.0502667315,
-0.0430250801,
0.0366390608,
-0.0142103676,
0.0351996645,
-0.0137910806,
0.0539602078,
-0.0134565588,
-0.0012004093,
-0.0293154791,
0.0103800595,
0.0274328347,
-0.0043067541,
0.0366837084,
0.008557329,
-0.0236731339,
-0.0238661263,
0.0122575508,
0.0172105264,
0.0053221136,
-0.0181067009,
0.0378015786,
0.0068998989,
0.0395847447,
0.0000016722,
-0.0660361275,
0.0102967992,
0.0050028064,
-0.0382374227,
0.0360614583,
0.0003742042,
-0.0172513202,
-0.0017390547,
-0.0059662317,
-0.0343357436,
0.004941484,
0.0760043934,
0.0121422485,
-0.0125820283,
0.0515366979,
-0.0002210257,
-0.0467796214,
0.0380872376,
0.0003867399,
-0.0155455954,
-0.0044935658,
0.000098412,
-0.0022730411,
0.0051726629,
0.0124341529,
-0.0348500647,
0.0186481792,
-0.0003012042,
0.0094309282,
0.0105056129,
0.0251221899,
-0.0177083779,
-0.0567025878,
0.001435418,
0.0542086922,
0.0175981559,
-0.0210974663,
-0.0324239768,
-0.0347287171,
0.0341577418,
0.0425495505,
-0.0409240574,
0.026824588,
0.0106904246,
0.0346472077,
0.0209690221,
-0.0327729993,
0.0166461598,
0.0040681823,
-0.0196625087,
0.0683160275,
0.0321324989,
-0.049507305,
-0.0173618458,
0.0077703265,
-0.0242383573,
-0.0551988147,
-0.0363948271,
0.0201319959,
-0.032705348,
0.0323303603,
-0.0221975613,
-0.0194709133,
0.042186439,
-0.0221219268,
0.0554125942,
0.0699386001,
-0.016775772,
0.0073492359,
0.0166646931,
0.072594665,
-0.0634132698,
0.0269606616,
-0.0499267429,
0.0151434634,
-0.0038123326,
-0.0364057459,
0.0267358609,
0.0341106132,
-0.0393144414,
-0.0142624089,
-0.0389534421,
0.0563028902,
0.0067611854,
0.0132018151,
-0.0257427804,
0.0039033091,
-0.0237116814,
-0.0037489298,
-0.0260384269,
0.0959757045,
-0.0370902345,
0.0286955759,
0.0156647507,
-0.0382838622,
-0.001996675,
0.0241885297,
-0.027041031,
-0.0486921072,
-0.0256935507,
0.0348318666,
-0.0145107079,
-0.0049582804,
0.013905325,
-0.009274397,
-0.0456473827,
-0.0617478639,
-0.0071664397,
-0.0766205937,
0.0371082574,
0.0636866689,
-0.0221193619,
-0.0502081811,
-0.0059205098,
-0.0205273964,
-0.0323378853,
0.0299008768,
0.0045682932,
0.0585635267,
0.0129387565,
-0.0224921517,
0.0157930888,
0.0747436285,
0.0125176702,
-0.0245922115,
0.0329641104,
-0.0411867313,
0.0026179168,
0.0544020981,
-0.0118411956,
0.0159851555,
-0.0290665869,
0.0058329739,
0.0091256946,
0.0338252522,
0.0788363442,
0.0300156511,
0.0058484315,
-0.0248450898,
0.0865386575,
0.0464152806,
0.0135763781,
0.0072593391,
0.0045694481,
0.0062965001,
-0.0035105709,
0.0616623089,
-0.0729219615,
0.0127910515,
-0.0374829024,
0.0627677739,
0.0190025903,
0.0561929122,
-0.0309861321,
-0.0217643324,
-0.0518724322,
0.024349058,
-0.0092807394,
0.0100910356,
0.0361107923,
-0.0278712567,
-0.0087050088,
0.0450880565,
0.0429246165,
-0.0355517529,
-0.0045323465,
-0.0421328545,
0.0578463413,
0.0106047885,
0.0148628419,
-0.0144028682,
-0.0457501449,
0.0310500152,
-0.0283576176,
0.0972952247,
0.0573906526,
0.0251754411,
0.0105369585,
-0.0231297687,
-0.0233825035,
-0.0337591022,
0.0086604357,
0.0004604809,
-0.0067385738,
-0.0266847163,
-0.0195211023,
-0.041853562,
-0.0098628923,
0.0247526988,
-0.0106290216,
-0.0063329251,
-0.0612291396,
0.0090959035,
0.0314220786,
0.0050576474,
-0.0002006503,
0.02873303,
0.0146253267,
0.0003736564,
0.0251825601,
-0.0027153979,
-0.0375932716,
-0.0091425758,
0.0505595915,
0.0146089932,
-0.0185633134,
0.0428925827,
-0.0000459522,
-0.0330460407,
0.006874633,
-0.0100841401,
0.0447241478,
-0.0038538349,
0.0540025495,
-0.0193478726,
0.025437016,
-0.0599036813,
0.0489343777,
0.0111266412,
0.0232095178,
0.0060283775,
-0.0023749606,
-0.007239229,
-0.0190555938,
-0.0187088549,
0.0320775695,
-0.0271735583,
0.0065167197,
0.0405569784,
-0.0453318506,
-0.0492518432,
-0.0272729546,
-0.0552696548,
0.0419532098,
-0.0116373459,
0.0376812816,
0.0614576004,
0.0208428726,
-0.0172197707,
0.0391605422,
-0.0491861515,
-0.0027184179,
0.0286800284,
0.054617852,
0.038277559,
-0.0173877161,
-0.0395479351,
-0.0640740395,
-0.0134185534,
-0.0262477193,
0.0324501321,
-0.017377615,
0.0014267021,
-0.0823405012,
0.0168036278,
-0.0657658502,
-0.0012659446,
-0.0121856295,
-0.0447704941,
0.0217402708,
0.0173270479,
0.0631330609,
0.0388721898,
0.009939624,
0.0300410483,
0.0587584972,
0.0200667325,
-0.0764453039,
-0.0045871218,
-0.0436014831,
-0.046212323,
-0.0610981807,
-0.0496175922,
-0.0130082304,
0.0903572887,
0.0279721133,
0.0028509146,
-0.0490370579,
-0.0080316663,
0.0000285754,
-0.0479758456,
-0.0043390468,
-0.0370753966,
-0.0398857296,
0.0434291959,
-0.0280360654,
-0.0791531429,
0.0427758656,
-0.0125269899,
-0.0245892499,
-0.0150917927,
-0.0028983389,
-0.0338053219,
0.0538208596,
-0.018448187,
0.0159888957,
-0.0131337037,
-0.0310667176,
-0.0890111402,
-0.0229841713,
0.0084594795,
-0.0252678823,
0.1113637984,
-0.0422107726,
-0.0025077437,
-0.035411343,
-0.0276030321,
-0.0321173407,
-0.0483438,
0.0068785376,
0.0226777084,
0.0002949074,
0.0055235843,
-0.0609727539,
0.009565061,
0.0662076771,
-0.0121955946,
-0.0330403745,
0.0190635696,
-0.026491195,
0.0168014951,
0.0644613951,
0.0639755353,
0.0441538766,
-0.0429942049,
0.0030360003,
0.0204771347,
0.0133413933,
0.0204207525,
-0.0238449685,
-0.0384101644,
0.0688051134,
-0.03554276,
-0.0365612395,
0.0261200164,
0.0942706093,
-0.008615844,
0.0100418609,
0.1040039435,
0.0223014597,
-0.0267395228,
0.0166364629,
-0.0537147745,
0.0619781911,
0.0136521934,
0.0028504608,
-0.0519204736,
0.0156205734,
0.0065245535,
-0.0309118498,
0.0004192892,
0.0148893334,
-0.0113604497,
-0.1476613879,
-0.0002591468,
0.0256497134,
-0.0640689507,
-0.0269542448,
0.0018552151,
0.0653943196,
0.0164082125,
0.0514136478,
0.0492325723,
-0.0201213304,
-0.0081002973,
0.0134565383,
0.0154567547,
-0.0361021869,
-0.0207530782,
-0.0537290759,
0.0612235703,
0.0601336583,
0.0082308836,
-0.0186215583,
-0.0345043875,
0.0433240421,
-0.0357429124,
0.0236427914,
0.0224101041,
-0.0063384296,
0.0210634526,
0.0169018414,
-0.0185308866,
0.0169398654,
-0.0101668714,
-0.0116438949,
-0.0067265737,
0.0495238565,
-0.0118979653,
-0.0092266565,
-0.0423175544,
0.0116017917,
-0.0252789725,
0.077793166,
0.0318572707,
-0.0306661371,
-0.0104379486,
-0.0023578885,
-0.0151961697,
0.0390701927,
-0.0193968546,
0.0324431024,
-0.0040860716,
-0.0177710466,
-0.0429043248,
-0.0484387688,
-0.0209233239,
-0.0086203311,
0.021877462,
-0.0022821438,
-0.0348139107,
-0.0463088304,
0.0166085679,
0.0461026877,
-0.0077484995,
0.0220214427,
-0.0481983311,
0.0008452333,
-0.015112076,
-0.0440656319,
0.0013992283,
-0.0144792786,
-0.0508498736,
-0.1121155471,
0.0200855732,
-0.0125633981,
0.0314468741,
0.0415874235,
0.0396146886,
-0.0405945592,
0.0189115703,
0.0407689214,
-0.0201353841,
0.0716517568,
0.0023135552,
-0.0003957758,
-0.0057446812,
0.0451032482,
-0.041999016,
-0.0053470689,
0.0528347753,
0.0618474223,
-0.0065655871,
-0.0514384769,
0.0298018996,
0.0178369433,
0.0479648374,
-0.0142804729,
0.0050513251,
-0.0208402947,
-0.0050053219,
-0.0260278918,
-0.0127161881,
0.0078477198,
-0.0551756956,
0.0311871618,
0.0019513139,
0.0176472366,
0.0356609412,
-0.0071320217,
0.0622177348,
-0.0603221729,
-0.0013843232,
-0.0217703059,
-0.0336729325,
0.0178555194,
0.0553295314,
-0.0303749498,
0.0350539312,
-0.0295235869,
0.0330884419,
0.0132580567,
0.070300661,
0.0137092378,
0.0077567641,
-0.0358885154,
0.0123798773,
-0.0482161231,
-0.0225909371,
0.0152465068,
-0.0119322585,
0.0256731082,
-0.019138258,
0.0741498321,
-0.0044668685,
-0.0042239651,
-0.0354264677,
0.0318193473,
-0.0239496641,
0.017334586,
0.066897288,
0.0317682698,
-0.0349109322,
-0.0304632429,
0.0351455621,
-0.033162389,
-0.0010977595,
-0.0218369029,
0.0174788013,
-0.0068661007,
-0.0484238081,
0.031373743,
-0.0016816778,
-0.037505541,
-0.0121549144,
-0.0805229247,
-0.0459704436,
0.0098187402,
0.003937481,
-0.0051324465,
-0.0496963263,
0.0090554319,
0.0789121836,
-0.0201565251,
-0.0382419899,
-0.0149101354,
0.0060919644,
-0.0413216129,
0.0179209113,
-0.0462340042,
-5.960456145e-33,
-0.0347836986,
-0.0066757267,
0.017610088,
-0.0521510094,
-0.0603334121,
-0.0011599876,
-0.016819438,
0.0465368517,
-0.0535397083,
0.0077966074,
-0.0119874375,
-0.0128134042,
0.0122957677,
0.0073721213,
0.0307678673,
-0.0199361593,
0.0177653655,
0.0313471593,
-0.057849776,
-0.0309012383,
0.0302208569,
-0.0334943682,
0.0713022128,
-0.0499660783,
0.0365485698,
-0.0245193131,
0.0021997739,
-0.0020288825,
-0.0309371203,
0.0843579471,
-0.0100660231,
0.0694456697,
0.0334584378,
-0.0143422391,
-0.010866805,
0.0403449349,
-0.0058467165,
-0.037241552,
0.113078177,
0.0031079901,
-0.0078074788,
-0.036486268,
0.0529242866,
-0.00620521,
-0.0433909893,
-0.042264387,
0.0383023359,
-0.0263678301,
-0.0258787237,
0.0112815602,
-0.1014884785,
0.0033544006,
-0.0039219484,
0.0026816803,
-0.035553284,
0.0287378486,
0.019576231,
0.0469313189,
-0.0255194567,
0.0177870505,
0.0245078225,
0.040883109,
0.1011369303,
0.0541198142,
0.0119711915,
0.0331236608,
-0.0130722597,
0.0087182913,
-0.0282636713,
-0.0475127622,
0.0213988125,
0.0012256728,
0.028978793,
0.0691116303,
0.0016141752,
0.0074449149,
-0.0234694574,
-0.003331491,
0.0130541185,
0.017702084,
0.0370838828,
0.0506150462,
-0.0520856418,
-0.0113746831,
-0.0316471308,
0.008935404,
-0.045021791,
-0.0264529958,
0.0247631278,
-0.0391138159,
0.0203212071,
0.0129728317,
0.0430274345,
-0.0227586553,
-0.0130746793,
0.0212263502,
-0.0405852757,
0.0392897725,
-0.0070841708,
0.0104590114,
-0.0443307683,
-0.0168488063,
-0.0212657414,
0.0054790243,
-0.0024077201,
0.0498510934,
0.0116939712,
0.0065402505,
-0.0686344802,
0.0050022677,
-0.0371096022,
-0.0290113911,
0.0031913281,
-0.0538116805,
0.0565835014,
0.0005553465,
-0.0124805644,
0.0443657227,
0.0373341255,
-0.0142319445,
-0.0472383648,
0.0044398103,
-0.0299766194,
0.0067036529,
-0.0332679227,
0.0090148579,
-0.0146175548,
0.0173139181,
0.0420181938,
-0.0163607243,
-0.0399884991,
0.0144194011,
2.381e-7,
0.0713907033,
0.0052163932,
0.0269725733,
0.0353016593,
0.0106407413,
0.0096564805,
-0.0122171361,
0.0310438983,
0.0335452817,
-0.0196575616,
-0.0170700252,
0.0064980001,
0.0407030545,
0.0055901967,
-0.0237304047,
0.0393054895,
-0.082726486,
0.0397056341,
-0.0513903163,
0.0522447377,
0.0186159518,
0.092175208,
0.0035204913,
0.0088892309,
-0.0322229639,
-0.0230080318,
0.0576788597,
-0.0378372781,
-0.006623215,
0.0435363129,
-0.0209785439,
-0.0334315225,
0.023727335,
0.0045188493,
0.0218678117,
0.048147548,
-0.0214359798,
0.0557246469,
-0.0108366758,
-0.0017892403,
-0.0105595328,
-0.0261545535,
-0.0052122269,
-0.0895145014,
0.0410461426,
-0.0514144637,
-0.0502230078,
-0.0391989648,
-0.0215049759,
-0.0070217489,
0.0169722326,
-0.02219164,
0.0224323608,
0.0322514623,
0.0270697474,
-0.0060418411,
-0.0484828986,
-0.0383243896,
-0.0722208172,
0.0253342222,
-0.0536781922,
-0.0729991421,
-0.0007642813,
0.000696099,
0.0120698148,
-0.0686958954,
-0.011343848,
2.189606414e-34,
0.0067587919,
-0.0054057394,
0.040015094,
0.0487550497,
-0.0018235877,
-0.0428137332,
-0.0132044479,
0.0463403948,
0.0280351657,
-0.0843844563,
-0.0190648045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17681v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17681v2 | VarBench: Robust Language Model Benchmarking Through Dynamic Variable Perturbation | 2024-06-25T16:13:53 | 2024-06-26T15:21:49 | Kun Qian, Shunji Wan, Claudia Tang, Youzhi Wang, Xuanming Zhang, Maximillian Chen, Zhou Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models achieve impressive scores on traditional benchmarks,
an increasing number of researchers are becoming concerned about benchmark data
leakage during pre-training, commonly known as the data contamination problem.
To ensure fair evaluation, recent benchmarks release only the training and
validation sets, keeping the test set labels closed-source. They require anyone
wishing to evaluate his language model to submit the model's predictions for
centralized processing and then publish the model's result on their
leaderboard. However, this submission process is inefficient and prevents
effective error analysis. To address this issue, we propose to variabilize
benchmarks and evaluate language models dynamically. Specifically, we extract
variables from each test case and define a value range for each variable. For
each evaluation, we sample new values from these value ranges to create unique
test cases, thus ensuring a fresh evaluation each time. We applied this
variable perturbation method to four datasets: GSM8K, ARC, CommonsenseQA, and
TruthfulQA, which cover mathematical generation and multiple-choice tasks. Our
experimental results demonstrate that this approach provides a more accurate
assessment of the true capabilities of language models, effectively mitigating
the contamination problem. | [
-0.0150005706,
0.1116496176,
-0.0259464327,
0.0310791526,
-0.0432360619,
-0.0094744945,
0.0038597921,
-0.0031801132,
-0.0331641473,
-0.0497521572,
-0.0142905461,
-0.036225196,
0.0062289215,
0.0440837108,
0.059324827,
-0.0316395015,
0.0546100847,
-0.0316566229,
-0.0094251586,
0.0012431518,
-0.01563555,
-0.0292780567,
0.0090763476,
0.0307900663,
-0.0153251514,
-0.0120109171,
-0.0029631399,
-0.013427983,
0.0042276564,
-0.0157259572,
0.0189361889,
0.0868117437,
-0.0110086482,
0.0482972041,
0.0000022189,
-0.0321116336,
-0.0042703399,
0.0181183908,
-0.0277917944,
0.0383180454,
0.0553713478,
0.013947268,
-0.0041151843,
0.0350959003,
-0.0287874043,
-0.0367511064,
0.0255647302,
-0.0523133688,
0.0598447844,
0.0645266771,
0.0037368534,
0.041020263,
-0.014912203,
-0.0381702632,
-0.0146474447,
-0.0618139803,
0.0127279023,
-0.0004120956,
-0.0059972126,
-0.0083907051,
-0.0222581513,
0.0350563899,
0.0339753963,
0.0123624587,
-0.0268246215,
0.0291573089,
-0.0801340267,
-0.0134306317,
-0.0034993812,
0.0695848241,
-0.0181837101,
-0.0374907777,
0.003914346,
-0.0177208837,
0.0041732197,
0.013403709,
-0.0381792001,
0.0042415275,
0.0120575447,
-0.0080447104,
-0.0103896875,
-0.010641275,
0.0357470661,
-0.0037155258,
0.0020603463,
0.0562814586,
0.0436856337,
-0.0294029806,
-0.008176933,
0.0133023718,
-0.0318605117,
-0.0433262698,
0.0073524206,
-0.0070650121,
-0.0054865419,
0.0342294574,
-0.0742054209,
-0.0759078115,
0.0258021317,
-0.0513422266,
0.0580790564,
0.0304987058,
-0.0060030823,
0.0090436833,
-0.0019927057,
0.0913252681,
0.0209992826,
0.0464648493,
-0.0423918553,
0.027693307,
-0.0105054751,
-0.0127305258,
-0.0009873114,
0.0197684616,
-0.0116957007,
0.0144218393,
-0.0401749238,
0.0053563621,
-0.0272722878,
0.0126510356,
-0.0033804255,
0.0029988762,
-0.040775843,
0.0072350316,
0.0133593325,
-0.0039467243,
-0.0419856049,
0.0213803519,
0.0241100267,
-0.0727919787,
-0.0171163958,
0.0075604185,
-0.0194918513,
-0.0231603626,
0.0076423548,
0.0796656832,
0.014020781,
-0.0182951968,
0.013087702,
-0.0481301174,
-0.0205754135,
-0.0652957782,
-0.0056565665,
-0.0713842586,
0.017087616,
0.005363855,
-0.014434319,
-0.0217530485,
-0.001492776,
0.0315453075,
0.0095184911,
0.0254118908,
0.0198675599,
-0.008595624,
-0.0159869157,
0.0056999405,
-0.005187517,
0.081269674,
0.0357738622,
-0.0073501267,
0.0464624316,
-0.0226261355,
0.0052493121,
0.0692391917,
0.0445082113,
0.0039487514,
-0.0591361858,
0.0092503838,
0.0571269579,
0.0227361917,
-0.0041710185,
0.0511348918,
-0.0397167914,
-0.0145758754,
0.0794371292,
0.0466596745,
-0.0194981899,
-0.0054037236,
-0.0152543336,
-0.0271312334,
0.0318849534,
0.0019630529,
-0.0595036484,
-0.0337958597,
-0.0190618243,
0.0166722946,
-0.001329603,
0.0307437517,
-0.0157106351,
-0.0487569422,
-0.0280640684,
-0.011261099,
0.0142906373,
0.0103841322,
0.052818168,
0.0059428173,
-0.0223862827,
0.0632253587,
-0.0008274588,
-0.0750767589,
0.0162018035,
-0.0420055315,
0.004044069,
0.0346975029,
0.0695381612,
-0.0071122991,
-0.026738191,
-0.0125446673,
0.0255316235,
0.0312471446,
0.0666941255,
-0.0147052426,
0.0348662138,
-0.0269140359,
-0.0240795258,
-0.0003537204,
0.0305933021,
0.0204889923,
0.0300960355,
0.0123301549,
0.013690087,
-0.0749322698,
-0.0388797037,
0.0503801666,
-0.0443049222,
-0.0373188965,
0.0174803454,
-0.0235055089,
0.0199482087,
-0.0019413113,
-0.0239248797,
0.0275620408,
0.024217505,
-0.0101986462,
0.0096383058,
0.0066680615,
-0.0392043926,
-0.0295260064,
0.0524619073,
-0.026466934,
-0.0065035978,
0.084154129,
-0.0427382998,
-0.02291869,
0.0350478664,
-0.0034978963,
-0.0251780264,
-0.0241257921,
0.0456495546,
-0.0427286103,
0.0220367927,
-0.0303267762,
0.0493191443,
-0.0090149809,
0.03644903,
-0.0278344285,
0.0563286096,
0.0222728401,
-0.0095287384,
-0.0361311324,
0.002985283,
-0.0220506284,
0.0386709124,
0.0079149464,
0.0072433264,
-0.0369621366,
-0.0291347448,
-0.0627688393,
-0.0023151457,
-0.0274256784,
0.0292570945,
0.0220630039,
-0.0132725146,
0.0028586846,
0.0084824469,
-0.0335274152,
-0.0308154318,
0.0241933558,
0.0193805397,
0.0153885558,
0.0090158992,
-0.0069368007,
-0.0581393056,
-0.0253978763,
-0.03179897,
0.083615981,
-0.0035789942,
0.0469658747,
-0.0263228659,
0.0255531427,
-0.0412241444,
0.0174809191,
0.0055799806,
-0.0268051401,
0.0249293782,
-0.0010886671,
0.0323594809,
0.0793884173,
-0.0044901241,
-0.0056865732,
0.0586037301,
-0.0097452933,
-0.0669041052,
-0.0116389049,
-0.0105077829,
-0.0229575895,
-0.0049871304,
-0.0223276094,
0.0178447701,
0.0442577712,
0.0088173067,
-0.022271242,
-0.0438296981,
0.0621283799,
-0.0390918776,
-0.0305798519,
-0.0461938456,
0.0054722307,
-0.0585680604,
0.0391399078,
-0.0287081469,
-0.0784890875,
0.070437558,
-0.0293859541,
0.0172852725,
-0.0449134894,
0.0200428106,
-0.0207151696,
0.0273029357,
-0.0038484447,
-0.0101985987,
0.0007816392,
0.0032524567,
-0.0383763835,
-0.0073073362,
0.0412639901,
-0.066391319,
0.053301353,
-0.0565831177,
0.0044654696,
0.0038820989,
-0.0571076274,
-0.0476159453,
-0.0338936262,
0.0211411845,
0.0241322573,
0.0338170566,
-0.0107840933,
-0.0023634499,
-0.0079765497,
0.0032453272,
0.0692456514,
-0.0394908674,
0.0068585644,
-0.0188614689,
0.0194277614,
0.0429303907,
-0.0222207978,
0.0229375269,
-0.0656190738,
0.0128953373,
0.0498628244,
0.0735425651,
0.0287000556,
-0.024273172,
0.0154653955,
0.0074511319,
-0.0032718144,
-0.0014088955,
0.0344440751,
0.0290938132,
-0.0641912967,
-0.0453309231,
0.0856520087,
0.0280428901,
-0.0004436965,
0.022102965,
-0.0321916342,
0.0829609558,
0.0348059461,
0.0314081758,
-0.0857224762,
0.0059146974,
0.022814149,
0.0603388809,
-0.0028602825,
-0.0324148126,
-0.0151161086,
-0.1450094283,
0.0116185043,
0.0201666299,
-0.0665871128,
0.0245359298,
-0.0340635143,
-0.0015109068,
-0.02369624,
0.0456112139,
0.0153512098,
0.0148344561,
0.0076166452,
0.0332733393,
-0.025789123,
-0.1098464057,
0.0232538991,
-0.0434703678,
0.046134118,
0.0525780097,
0.0106808655,
-0.037490271,
0.0034539592,
0.0537255742,
0.0032031969,
-0.0367178172,
0.0269100871,
0.0451413617,
0.0158351418,
-0.02311299,
0.0106365634,
0.0117321601,
-0.02828243,
0.004852477,
0.0111027434,
0.0656312704,
0.0245219637,
-0.0241198093,
-0.0002721437,
-0.0308362059,
-0.0015874604,
0.0752604604,
0.0464575738,
-0.0471015088,
-0.0282278992,
-0.0458849333,
-0.0070635341,
-0.0587450974,
-0.015491127,
0.0079395473,
0.0195700563,
-0.0317193903,
-0.0685616359,
-0.04036019,
0.0249529909,
0.0630459338,
-0.0030967635,
0.0086337058,
0.0060258931,
-0.0195679404,
-0.0422464795,
0.0445066541,
-0.0140153486,
0.024050869,
-0.0608028807,
0.0034713058,
0.0024863742,
0.0351435132,
-0.035793025,
0.0577672273,
-0.1281450242,
-0.1100882143,
0.0172838941,
0.0823279321,
0.0225048121,
0.0308031794,
-0.0069826692,
-0.0595959574,
0.0351918153,
0.0099933967,
-0.0132712433,
0.0363402516,
0.0181009844,
-0.0719899982,
0.0099422345,
0.0174751971,
-0.032864932,
0.0036349902,
0.0163812619,
0.0319962837,
-0.0061945939,
-0.0110225314,
0.0125455726,
0.0315394625,
0.0158416014,
-0.0152011085,
-0.0167123917,
-0.0161840841,
0.0084763886,
-0.0483587459,
-0.017313512,
-0.0351204723,
0.0167513993,
0.0117349895,
0.0063688136,
-0.0061713737,
-0.0149577148,
-0.0128816636,
0.0673577413,
-0.0355792157,
0.0131307216,
-0.0160299689,
0.0580479763,
0.0303623397,
-0.0019974478,
-0.014381269,
-0.0009966764,
-0.0293052811,
0.073018305,
-0.0363870449,
-0.0026131137,
0.0135957906,
0.0220568515,
0.0205709003,
0.0099403979,
-0.0618358143,
-0.0522265956,
-0.0445397831,
0.0077645397,
-0.0015300931,
0.0339977257,
0.0404692478,
-0.0266770851,
-0.0178928133,
-0.0418184884,
-0.0121920705,
-0.0077181617,
-0.0409083478,
0.0268821456,
0.018557338,
-0.0202850197,
0.0148645286,
0.0827505514,
0.0503537618,
0.0343275182,
-0.0239906795,
0.0314178206,
-0.0459287018,
-0.0099594975,
0.003214549,
0.0004113218,
-0.0247242916,
-0.0241437033,
-0.0543032736,
-0.1045504436,
0.0388551168,
0.0342499167,
0.0284438189,
-0.0035191497,
0.0039269682,
0.053232234,
-0.0227503516,
0.0066461279,
-0.0282312538,
0.0042715049,
0.0066057895,
-0.0296054464,
-0.0278172009,
-6.910798145e-33,
-0.0222537816,
-0.0154749714,
0.0054915929,
-0.0465563871,
0.0007611905,
0.0180234406,
-0.0308356006,
0.0306542777,
-0.0116138952,
-0.0030870421,
-0.0166510865,
0.0158966761,
0.0183380339,
0.0249071978,
-0.0017875294,
-0.0297643859,
0.0368947573,
-0.0434813723,
-0.0650424883,
0.0154188592,
0.0120654423,
0.0324322022,
0.0761905611,
-0.0734236464,
0.0070096129,
0.0062833885,
-0.0356108584,
-0.001254832,
-0.0349100828,
0.0728232414,
0.008506529,
0.0352372862,
0.0026712636,
-0.0296842828,
-0.035773281,
-0.0121857543,
-0.0310466141,
-0.032136932,
0.0122338207,
0.0258731358,
-0.0064754561,
-0.0063077928,
0.0523440279,
-0.0150974402,
-0.0487431698,
-0.0108552026,
0.0080656642,
-0.0329450592,
-0.0599128455,
-0.0148727121,
-0.0272395276,
0.0278572049,
-0.0052410131,
0.022927342,
-0.0019272908,
0.0690585449,
-0.0257264059,
-0.0026433109,
-0.0414127894,
0.0104251532,
0.0567869954,
0.0530617572,
0.0722322613,
0.031620495,
0.0221053585,
0.0767420158,
0.0231789611,
0.0143849095,
0.0325136296,
-0.0094374325,
0.090106301,
0.0139185553,
0.0755576938,
0.0668180883,
0.0455976427,
-0.0196038075,
-0.0600700565,
0.0129183615,
0.0146272993,
-0.0055950242,
0.0357813202,
-0.0328718163,
-0.0679443553,
-0.0336699225,
-0.0915003717,
-0.0103012156,
-0.0581916198,
-0.0171520561,
0.0721701533,
0.0035162957,
-0.0374182798,
-0.0106078694,
0.0328541473,
-0.0325018652,
-0.0368002914,
0.0517482273,
-0.0209370088,
0.0290527008,
-0.0121189831,
0.0429820865,
-0.0294723026,
-0.0144447004,
0.0038709952,
0.0274845008,
0.0403112434,
-0.0025197195,
0.0069389483,
0.0322791748,
-0.0646598041,
0.010835168,
-0.034546271,
0.0203094035,
0.0334128737,
0.0459102951,
0.0577238314,
-0.028344661,
0.0100845583,
0.0376649685,
0.0263838898,
-0.0000474877,
-0.0441730134,
0.0094200214,
0.0289062634,
0.0441186428,
0.0055846474,
-0.0242366083,
-0.0242096279,
-0.0091111325,
0.0557927079,
-0.0309463572,
-0.0053840117,
0.0112893619,
2.868e-7,
0.0447458886,
0.0598571301,
0.0054182317,
0.0286996458,
-0.021824779,
0.0181656126,
-0.0606484041,
0.0191355757,
0.0081975702,
0.0041463668,
-0.0282914247,
-0.0023386534,
0.0758820847,
0.0366705284,
-0.0560131148,
-0.0156421065,
-0.0640190467,
0.0174477901,
-0.06503582,
-0.0344630443,
0.0198294912,
0.0890927017,
0.0057085152,
-0.0154089639,
-0.0226286687,
-0.0388958901,
0.0551089644,
-0.0261650011,
-0.0302051362,
0.0303665046,
0.0260090996,
0.0287681706,
0.0177735481,
-0.0143785821,
-0.0397435203,
0.0201772582,
-0.0224491358,
0.0696376935,
0.0176258683,
-0.0310600344,
0.0110109225,
-0.0245178267,
-0.0246251188,
-0.0357716568,
0.042904187,
-0.0298956987,
-0.0044120629,
-0.0465602539,
-0.0277455878,
-0.0330224857,
0.0551450513,
-0.0442583673,
-0.0182515699,
0.0222013108,
0.0243553873,
-0.0024606525,
-0.0070953816,
-0.0405334495,
-0.0491663441,
-0.0017936695,
-0.0454338677,
-0.0376821905,
-0.0282491818,
0.027763702,
-0.011224133,
-0.0277185123,
0.0282794777,
3.183853081e-34,
0.0538517796,
-0.0300196651,
0.0319730975,
0.0254127774,
0.0408509895,
-0.009360156,
0.0028013368,
0.0049259588,
0.0074428245,
-0.0610949844,
-0.0179279447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17675v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17675v1 | Quantifying AI Psychology: A Psychometrics Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T16:09:08 | 2024-06-25T16:09:08 | Yuan Li, Yue Huang, Hongyi Wang, Xiangliang Zhang, James Zou, Lichao Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional task-solving
capabilities, increasingly adopting roles akin to human-like assistants. The
broader integration of LLMs into society has sparked interest in whether they
manifest psychological attributes, and whether these attributes are
stable-inquiries that could deepen the understanding of their behaviors.
Inspired by psychometrics, this paper presents a framework for investigating
psychology in LLMs, including psychological dimension identification,
assessment dataset curation, and assessment with results validation. Following
this framework, we introduce a comprehensive psychometrics benchmark for LLMs
that covers six psychological dimensions: personality, values, emotion, theory
of mind, motivation, and intelligence. This benchmark includes thirteen
datasets featuring diverse scenarios and item types. Our findings indicate that
LLMs manifest a broad spectrum of psychological attributes. We also uncover
discrepancies between LLMs' self-reported traits and their behaviors in
real-world scenarios. This paper demonstrates a thorough psychometric
assessment of LLMs, providing insights into reliable evaluation and potential
applications in AI and social sciences. | [
0.018837668,
0.0682794005,
-0.0549192131,
0.0054752496,
-0.0668005496,
0.0313297398,
0.016898891,
-0.025966011,
0.0317785442,
0.0036778471,
-0.0636041909,
-0.0316018909,
-0.0074516241,
0.0451933108,
0.0032755591,
-0.0282987189,
0.0187541954,
-0.0011429549,
0.0543668121,
0.005254983,
-0.0359095186,
0.0400601737,
-0.0093162768,
0.0200012326,
-0.0027238978,
-0.0212626792,
0.0079687312,
-0.0319207162,
0.0359672941,
-0.0366268754,
0.0033264593,
0.0271658096,
0.00861686,
0.0217129719,
0.0000019374,
-0.0861850008,
0.0136568453,
-0.0117822057,
-0.0201844722,
-0.0258198213,
0.0583158582,
0.0296978354,
-0.0015603792,
0.0352091379,
-0.0715777352,
0.0071732313,
0.0068808091,
0.0469818339,
0.0233231001,
0.060669668,
-0.0166185051,
-0.0017599147,
0.0409489237,
0.003466587,
0.0119263977,
-0.0397578888,
0.0309807044,
-0.0276461057,
-0.0300207548,
-0.0433659889,
0.0297681708,
-0.0154328812,
0.0231373515,
0.0168541521,
-0.0290817209,
-0.0015909307,
-0.0561724268,
-0.0231601633,
0.0031790801,
0.0506765544,
0.0327131338,
0.0017713322,
-0.009141217,
-0.0075631933,
0.0182351973,
-0.0029004826,
-0.0319816619,
0.0300639793,
0.0017071412,
-0.0123768952,
0.0646201894,
0.0302181318,
0.0206522699,
0.0101796789,
-0.0211365856,
0.0615188032,
-0.0045302915,
-0.0420655943,
0.0350857042,
-0.0065416573,
-0.0169478171,
-0.0597178712,
-0.012485099,
0.0264140051,
-0.039295584,
0.0274491571,
-0.0377974398,
-0.0156919919,
0.0218868498,
-0.0474747233,
0.0662584081,
0.0273527913,
-0.0258134156,
0.0258389656,
0.0374330841,
0.0923016816,
0.0384026542,
0.0319671258,
-0.0333315693,
-0.0169094596,
-0.0722775236,
0.0088230865,
0.0236004256,
0.0172546413,
0.0539114065,
0.0014065707,
-0.0395429507,
0.0185039565,
-0.0303148981,
0.0087828822,
-0.0076632844,
-0.012824188,
0.015345199,
-0.0038279141,
-0.0558357202,
0.0147903031,
-0.0441085361,
0.0115996609,
0.0188892949,
-0.0463979803,
0.0482561328,
-0.001153169,
0.0183448829,
-0.037750788,
0.0575547889,
0.0592981577,
0.0305856671,
-0.0595479459,
-0.0413034745,
-0.015720915,
0.0213517677,
-0.0882495642,
-0.0031143578,
-0.036542505,
0.0401210971,
0.0323088504,
-0.0211844426,
-0.0588943511,
-0.0098054428,
0.0273781251,
0.0003135614,
0.035904251,
0.0276830625,
0.0215643663,
0.0211240239,
0.0172229484,
-0.0082306815,
0.0294226911,
0.0280622132,
0.0078881998,
0.0656713918,
-0.0331558213,
0.0300429966,
0.0122879995,
-0.0433081873,
0.0029725572,
-0.0252570957,
0.0136388773,
-0.0171026476,
0.0123591069,
0.0256499965,
0.0552342199,
0.0180507731,
-0.0164122432,
0.0621292256,
0.0863106772,
0.0069460948,
0.0287919845,
0.0163364615,
0.0082025072,
0.0744947866,
-0.0044374811,
-0.0556252487,
0.0225505326,
-0.0302228536,
-0.0077565606,
0.0042881947,
0.0462411121,
-0.0208816286,
-0.0611510351,
-0.0210275073,
-0.0185776148,
0.0247254595,
0.0394943245,
0.0349551737,
-0.0545622073,
-0.0073014502,
-0.0504014827,
-0.0050343452,
-0.0572161563,
-0.0274583343,
-0.0743573084,
0.0125048235,
0.0797366351,
0.0238517951,
-0.0249077119,
-0.0256708246,
0.0069541563,
-0.0314445384,
0.0145725291,
0.0579032786,
-0.0228946693,
-0.0096394634,
-0.0210897774,
0.0138038546,
-0.0044707237,
0.0083329445,
0.0108553898,
-0.0174205247,
0.0303760469,
-0.0050077997,
-0.0368505903,
-0.0312413685,
0.0296842176,
-0.0829395428,
-0.0369887315,
-0.0126102734,
0.0133419586,
0.0590054356,
0.0310675222,
-0.0125941988,
0.0139673101,
0.0245873518,
-0.0050360439,
0.016220212,
0.0276842061,
0.0092219254,
0.0612687021,
0.0430428609,
0.0251291599,
-0.0089296494,
0.0579525977,
0.0294688083,
-0.022475021,
0.0027236093,
-0.0192202777,
0.0222836584,
-0.0069917305,
0.0512621328,
-0.0571732968,
0.0514675751,
0.0004744348,
0.0584812164,
-0.0170547981,
0.0329642147,
0.0193191841,
-0.0074555939,
0.0360282175,
-0.0330524817,
-0.008506163,
-0.025230689,
0.0016065789,
0.0168650784,
0.0292824619,
-0.0103134634,
-0.0608037449,
-0.0395763777,
-0.0898557007,
-0.0129352156,
0.0147470459,
0.0231220108,
0.0125614535,
-0.0197972283,
-0.0520494692,
0.0274453666,
-0.054489065,
0.0085249925,
0.0485477187,
0.0463723764,
0.0135664931,
-0.0282219183,
-0.0121163605,
-0.070433706,
0.0033004608,
-0.0318737999,
-0.0143819889,
0.0030142257,
0.055894535,
-0.0316339023,
0.0503299199,
-0.044241555,
0.0119649051,
-0.0270672124,
-0.0589866079,
0.0479677506,
0.0070008482,
0.0320193321,
0.1233094186,
-0.0010626751,
0.0282171108,
0.0636031479,
0.0175687913,
-0.0411227718,
-0.0123545201,
0.0113971485,
0.0056726234,
-0.0335662626,
-0.0678235888,
0.0182233714,
0.0532616824,
-0.0060890182,
0.0148147838,
-0.0207009781,
0.0473426208,
-0.0191905759,
-0.0512557589,
0.0048076822,
0.0116618359,
-0.0210710671,
0.1059692129,
0.0032477968,
-0.0500656404,
0.0545117371,
0.003943162,
0.0235124938,
-0.017732095,
-0.0476438254,
-0.0359088778,
0.084400557,
-0.0018221042,
-0.0173305217,
0.0126990862,
0.0187254883,
-0.0535471588,
-0.0165338404,
-0.0361936688,
-0.0569807924,
0.0128757516,
-0.0184709933,
-0.0336365327,
0.023922205,
0.0061511016,
-0.0502444319,
-0.0399410017,
-0.0503911413,
0.0034560787,
0.0253854655,
-0.0649185628,
-0.0374028198,
-0.0513493009,
0.0651984662,
-0.0117092375,
-0.0049130232,
-0.0214833412,
0.0174817517,
-0.0329124816,
0.0880290493,
-0.0000494386,
0.0572115071,
-0.0411590077,
0.0356282964,
-0.011355008,
0.0194196086,
0.0223866478,
0.004844273,
0.004970728,
0.019250961,
-0.0015087241,
-0.0047763321,
0.0435683243,
0.0202009808,
-0.0082863197,
-0.011892912,
0.1442836523,
0.0383723713,
-0.0462394655,
0.0200268272,
-0.0172129497,
-0.0035922544,
0.0396333598,
0.0367093347,
-0.029312443,
0.0204934143,
0.0006664949,
0.0188948289,
-0.0549142808,
-0.0543462411,
-0.0057548969,
-0.098421447,
0.016221175,
-0.0220627803,
-0.005681193,
-0.0277906433,
-0.0532018021,
0.0296839382,
-0.0072018583,
0.0173034221,
-0.0341135971,
0.0071253413,
-0.0298641343,
-0.004394317,
-0.0402004719,
-0.0518030003,
0.1095785797,
-0.0354112685,
0.0721290857,
0.0675022826,
0.059454225,
-0.0295667313,
-0.0556334592,
-0.0390499532,
0.0242337938,
-0.0090929307,
0.0443409756,
0.0460974649,
-0.0285363197,
0.013232423,
-0.0337150022,
-0.0019653309,
-0.0545907877,
0.0037825548,
0.0150309345,
0.0789054483,
0.007037831,
-0.0379006155,
-0.0016683111,
-0.0278082639,
0.0016029754,
0.1022463292,
-0.0016060348,
-0.0673030913,
0.0064908126,
-0.0022711419,
-0.0039477539,
-0.0198322125,
-0.0625922978,
0.0247611236,
0.0096558342,
0.0085434485,
-0.0338900052,
-0.0851332769,
0.0397213176,
-0.0195514131,
-0.0116766328,
-0.0109167704,
0.0179886986,
0.0040349374,
-0.058051642,
0.0018308888,
0.0017470067,
0.0274617746,
-0.0422483385,
-0.0209506024,
0.0324231535,
-0.0386115909,
0.0025473547,
-0.0192641504,
-0.0293510128,
-0.0298524443,
0.0483219065,
0.01905098,
0.0221724529,
-0.0287244972,
0.0010418394,
-0.0532843135,
-0.0068558129,
-0.0304011162,
-0.0421909504,
0.0382949226,
-0.0072398875,
0.0521970019,
0.0086745555,
0.0315121897,
-0.0503329001,
0.0222766493,
-0.0078900522,
-0.0308431797,
-0.0084033487,
-0.0793432966,
0.0183414612,
0.0423684269,
-0.0021774382,
-0.010821308,
-0.0080683306,
-0.0190314073,
-0.0505895391,
-0.0638416782,
-0.0221845154,
-0.0249961745,
-0.0665363967,
0.0396379605,
0.0150904292,
-0.0156395361,
-0.0411743373,
-0.0257732812,
-0.0134890648,
-0.0304470528,
0.0242648125,
-0.0417451039,
0.0362599753,
-0.0053681256,
0.0191971436,
-0.016143335,
-0.0352124982,
-0.0147790955,
0.0468479134,
0.0235627815,
0.0766034275,
-0.0136354109,
-0.0008287561,
0.0167288352,
0.0475025959,
-0.0551339723,
-0.0454797484,
0.0519781187,
-0.0044666454,
0.0016951784,
-0.0145391971,
0.0569383241,
-0.0442783982,
0.0287828594,
-0.0377192758,
-0.0083268313,
0.0045656422,
-0.0106352586,
0.0044584791,
0.0147586996,
-0.0164066255,
0.0022735831,
0.0590231307,
0.005835338,
0.0375576019,
-0.0160908829,
-0.0175704136,
-0.0358795114,
0.0275862589,
-0.0198448412,
0.0391011871,
-0.0320066288,
-0.0087437779,
-0.0797637999,
-0.082599178,
0.0337442122,
0.0079607265,
0.0070458637,
-0.0407322273,
-0.0022411458,
0.0739539564,
-0.0448741391,
-0.0085645765,
-0.027126696,
-0.0362380967,
-0.0654638335,
-0.0127176382,
-0.0370288529,
-6.094006997e-33,
-0.0008659455,
-0.0159471389,
0.0173426084,
-0.0003975847,
-0.0092071155,
-0.0256825183,
-0.0276742298,
0.0320179462,
-0.0558067448,
-0.0086140353,
-0.0478286371,
0.0196017437,
0.004113839,
-0.008507831,
0.0295873787,
0.0025049183,
0.0027404751,
-0.0561720543,
-0.0231778678,
0.0019435316,
0.0064098872,
-0.0210419632,
0.0603493936,
-0.1006532758,
0.0425844565,
-0.0130532375,
0.0174812134,
0.0143864425,
0.0001641668,
0.0576640405,
-0.0126800444,
0.0553973503,
0.0528014973,
0.0039398195,
0.0035457651,
0.0213676803,
0.0001251884,
-0.0661022514,
0.0163043514,
0.0143801756,
0.0008083323,
-0.0624884777,
0.0015846165,
-0.0093092155,
-0.059591271,
-0.0140292607,
0.0363631397,
-0.0239283275,
0.0541363582,
0.0229339879,
-0.0507730618,
-0.0101824487,
-0.0140966624,
-0.0337934308,
-0.006637475,
0.0343163684,
-0.0301645678,
-0.0128457192,
-0.0585328974,
0.0286975503,
-0.0094877779,
-0.0089343451,
0.0610179491,
-0.0159052368,
0.0188496839,
0.0546835847,
0.0861287639,
0.0555898435,
-0.0127712376,
-0.012937801,
0.0418459736,
0.0582273453,
0.0418459736,
0.0385346375,
-0.0002677777,
-0.0173542071,
-0.0062291883,
0.0303761344,
0.0810101405,
-0.0103477528,
0.0440656617,
0.0000960108,
-0.0449654385,
-0.0202341489,
-0.0266957488,
-0.0072589107,
-0.0211289953,
-0.0113952039,
0.0489711873,
-0.0295317061,
0.0334721096,
-0.042815946,
0.0436331518,
-0.0329576284,
0.0151187228,
0.0321496017,
-0.0485798307,
0.0661664233,
0.0188804716,
-0.0079834452,
-0.066390574,
-0.0002711305,
-0.0076056812,
0.0480997562,
0.0672387779,
0.0014475442,
-0.0052706953,
0.0356653631,
-0.0402551778,
-0.0107645579,
-0.0075629102,
0.00881055,
0.0296100266,
0.0034634045,
0.0061657531,
-0.0112984776,
0.0024285535,
-0.0134810349,
0.0093828859,
-0.0186878107,
-0.0621935539,
-0.0015671665,
-0.0086017745,
-0.0103451153,
-0.0084186746,
-0.0142997187,
-0.0674015507,
0.0093361102,
0.0345470309,
-0.0031362041,
0.0138309384,
-0.0212512352,
2.742e-7,
-0.0218456276,
0.076909177,
-0.0273201652,
0.0582003221,
-0.0064140996,
0.0544417985,
-0.025234336,
-0.0061751492,
0.0323981233,
-0.0169244222,
0.0160548203,
0.0203158557,
0.0523779206,
0.0222431757,
-0.0401504524,
-0.0081101367,
-0.008166803,
0.0122647574,
-0.0402798466,
0.026042996,
0.0643900186,
0.0400401689,
0.0289019123,
-0.0077565559,
-0.0290513374,
-0.0091282688,
0.0085327066,
-0.0412416905,
0.0054502031,
0.0100738658,
0.0214843899,
0.0231666211,
0.0139302714,
0.0486599244,
0.0092330612,
0.0183049962,
-0.023143746,
0.0442724824,
-0.0214534178,
-0.0344703905,
0.0137911709,
-0.0017562129,
-0.0311294813,
-0.0462793708,
0.0617787279,
-0.0302550383,
-0.0868686885,
-0.0465793759,
-0.0081063109,
-0.0198704936,
0.0345642753,
0.0036338598,
-0.0197123531,
0.004609379,
0.0240686107,
-0.0375384614,
-0.0080001093,
-0.0436089337,
0.0224651955,
0.0055554169,
-0.0066833263,
-0.0599409416,
-0.0407823808,
0.0193076041,
0.0162325632,
-0.0657705069,
0.0245939437,
2.2513628e-34,
-0.0118006645,
0.0214720368,
0.0236880332,
-0.0004796075,
0.0752017871,
0.0055571673,
-0.0435977876,
0.03058731,
0.0185544472,
-0.0956120417,
0.0060741906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17667v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17667v1 | This Paper Had the Smartest Reviewers -- Flattery Detection Utilising an Audio-Textual Transformer-Based Approach | 2024-06-25T15:57:02 | 2024-06-25T15:57:02 | Lukas Christ, Shahin Amiriparian, Friederike Hawighorst, Ann-Kathrin Schill, Angelo Boutalikakis, Lorenz Graf-Vlachy, Andreas König, Björn W. Schuller | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Flattery is an important aspect of human communication that facilitates
social bonding, shapes perceptions, and influences behavior through strategic
compliments and praise, leveraging the power of speech to build rapport
effectively. Its automatic detection can thus enhance the naturalness of
human-AI interactions. To meet this need, we present a novel audio textual
dataset comprising 20 hours of speech and train machine learning models for
automatic flattery detection. In particular, we employ pretrained AST,
Wav2Vec2, and Whisper models for the speech modality, and Whisper TTS models
combined with a RoBERTa text classifier for the textual modality. Subsequently,
we build a multimodal classifier by combining text and audio representations.
Evaluation on unseen test data demonstrates promising results, with Unweighted
Average Recall scores reaching 82.46% in audio-only experiments, 85.97% in
text-only experiments, and 87.16% using a multimodal approach. | [
0.0346567929,
0.0612476431,
-0.0273232106,
0.0237244815,
-0.0117347166,
0.0053102779,
-0.0082539292,
0.0070892489,
-0.0374903493,
-0.0513357781,
-0.084453553,
0.0055534807,
0.0026811098,
0.0130112469,
0.03805108,
-0.0165572967,
0.0247216485,
0.02742544,
0.0277221147,
-0.0114603667,
0.053284537,
0.0120180007,
-0.0008517239,
0.0321613066,
-0.0576926246,
-0.004152202,
0.0071665761,
0.0324978009,
-0.0200461987,
0.0024123124,
0.017162919,
0.0479908176,
0.0304582324,
0.0490994938,
0.0000017853,
-0.0130144358,
0.0162866376,
0.0043925862,
0.0064802417,
-0.0146151371,
0.0847164392,
0.0108249197,
-0.0128203658,
0.0310336407,
-0.0184742603,
0.0131998807,
0.0223175548,
0.0357416496,
0.1126412749,
0.0594555549,
0.0006896375,
-0.0071795899,
0.007935524,
-0.0104558356,
0.0330123566,
-0.0156122129,
-0.0112420022,
-0.0360557735,
-0.0063788067,
-0.0039477851,
-0.0033986818,
0.0255345441,
-0.0385139026,
-0.0234138705,
0.0421034582,
0.0276977271,
-0.0190422554,
-0.0345099196,
-0.0230303444,
0.0436813496,
0.024939023,
-0.0260380823,
-0.0074810181,
0.0330764577,
0.0216794237,
-0.0299005341,
-0.0172616076,
-0.0251518078,
0.0233477652,
-0.0159411039,
-0.0815043822,
0.0187241063,
0.0004754316,
0.0286474302,
0.0505968928,
-0.0119411331,
-0.039147187,
-0.0465850011,
0.0413844138,
0.0031046029,
0.0256782509,
-0.0475502051,
0.027203856,
0.0216565412,
0.0270123146,
-0.0568902344,
-0.0343775339,
-0.0535660982,
0.0282311626,
-0.0135011841,
0.0506004356,
-0.0129817305,
-0.0832482055,
0.0101513276,
-0.004494471,
0.0326464027,
-0.0015504009,
-0.0315166526,
-0.0019697554,
-0.0100634936,
-0.0383429229,
0.013346252,
-0.0146307517,
0.015724184,
-0.0053422642,
-0.0297660045,
-0.0133367712,
-0.0151961697,
-0.0612339452,
0.0200876482,
0.0012367954,
-0.0004803922,
-0.0168732796,
0.0209693611,
0.0284116585,
0.0358100533,
-0.0314365029,
0.0312559083,
-0.0374171883,
-0.0135101955,
-0.0107492041,
0.0349663496,
0.0526159517,
0.0035065298,
0.0307147987,
0.0377818644,
-0.001004721,
-0.0854148269,
0.0141344601,
0.0142129632,
-0.0504761487,
-0.0723424405,
0.00937689,
-0.0093856892,
0.0497713536,
-0.0328722484,
-0.0412810482,
0.0505698808,
0.0163539145,
0.0068106535,
-0.0323478058,
0.0303633679,
-0.0263924878,
0.0293016341,
0.0368035249,
0.0222274698,
-0.0256675165,
0.0004289512,
0.0515821688,
0.0371742621,
0.059133634,
0.0001539815,
0.050828658,
0.0303586535,
0.0300932862,
-0.0113409711,
0.0306729376,
-0.0111774961,
-0.0721366554,
-0.0077794907,
0.0443340912,
0.0242826454,
0.0139177004,
-0.023174949,
0.083311826,
0.0370218381,
-0.0186141264,
0.0512506962,
0.0140866302,
0.0735870972,
-0.0143025024,
-0.0230634902,
-0.0280210953,
-0.0087529579,
-0.062484175,
-0.0533588827,
0.0539978929,
-0.0285279192,
-0.0048915595,
-0.0193991773,
-0.0077849468,
-0.0429431796,
0.0049562026,
0.005373504,
0.0285561476,
0.0093300762,
-0.0521655381,
-0.0046583042,
0.0280009862,
-0.0806776658,
0.0068857791,
-0.0239010286,
0.043182198,
0.0459621884,
-0.0009782391,
-0.0211009048,
0.0461180694,
-0.0599498525,
-0.0232750364,
0.0118163172,
0.0202840958,
-0.0152033856,
0.034810435,
-0.0099132042,
0.0301936418,
0.0114336591,
0.00783055,
0.0088179493,
-0.0105591407,
0.0508203246,
-0.026411226,
-0.0106044263,
0.0084735546,
0.0036261373,
0.0728844777,
-0.0098014707,
0.0280490592,
0.0237925891,
0.0309772007,
0.0651343465,
-0.0627780929,
-0.0409167856,
0.0099525591,
-0.0003087988,
-0.0441909768,
0.0167911388,
-0.0317334086,
-0.0110584041,
-0.007745876,
0.0031359799,
-0.0101636089,
0.0484530143,
-0.0029990012,
0.0029022319,
0.0674158931,
-0.0434384458,
0.0624520928,
-0.0139819076,
0.0113313412,
-0.0404214859,
0.0349740274,
0.027946867,
-0.0167390388,
0.010780707,
-0.0445234291,
-0.0294297356,
0.0064816978,
0.0267776456,
0.0265276562,
-0.0710620433,
-0.0172999166,
0.0117504662,
0.0155165624,
-0.0039944523,
-0.002600824,
0.0070589138,
-0.0431971848,
-0.13439551,
-0.0226410348,
0.0002777586,
-0.0357557759,
-0.0124383643,
-0.0217290092,
0.0324077718,
0.012715443,
-0.051034119,
0.0140414592,
0.0138455322,
-0.0293697417,
-0.0243292898,
-0.0196608175,
0.0071506482,
-0.0450209044,
0.0197476111,
-0.0268044323,
-0.0006331143,
0.0036952186,
-0.0016513478,
-0.0034641176,
-0.0186391696,
-0.0279018115,
0.0702793449,
-0.0148783214,
-0.0362484977,
-0.0118850144,
0.0151184639,
-0.0000210394,
0.0546087585,
0.0646405071,
0.0315547846,
0.0404205658,
0.0079636499,
-0.0103114434,
0.0391867235,
0.0183795281,
0.0225414615,
-0.0520406887,
-0.0227578878,
-0.0134883244,
-0.0011945771,
0.0413785763,
0.0331585743,
-0.0153995799,
-0.0135807581,
0.0162313264,
-0.0262625962,
0.008919715,
-0.0284600444,
0.0022368997,
0.0031017167,
0.0264512114,
-0.0521407053,
0.024038773,
-0.0631123781,
-0.0766334906,
0.0003655512,
-0.0181443598,
0.0087706512,
0.0560607761,
-0.0210449528,
0.0285352059,
0.0207880344,
-0.0026008664,
0.0139692379,
-0.0549430028,
0.0222909935,
-0.021893952,
-0.0378444456,
0.018171506,
-0.0101329712,
0.0414085202,
-0.0489813015,
-0.0228468943,
-0.0281004384,
-0.0267392639,
-0.0245592538,
-0.0344981439,
-0.0330502987,
-0.026523741,
-0.0028851447,
-0.0075092944,
-0.0130109759,
-0.0196781382,
0.0090910345,
-0.0095328856,
0.0260313991,
0.05045541,
0.0252214856,
-0.0199561529,
-0.0025396685,
-0.0414280109,
0.0141014084,
0.0019955947,
0.0510431379,
-0.0174896829,
-0.0377130285,
0.0256081354,
0.0358028263,
0.024839662,
-0.0312447511,
0.0223897044,
0.0309144333,
-0.0201262943,
0.0946215242,
-0.0003396735,
-0.0545745678,
0.0161391869,
0.0496268794,
0.0051376349,
0.0203707665,
0.0038989768,
-0.0733345151,
-0.0273118038,
0.0251002386,
0.0150597543,
0.0040237159,
0.0255877748,
-0.0083873486,
-0.0919764861,
0.0269542448,
-0.0087240264,
-0.0493086316,
-0.0262600482,
0.007786877,
-0.0427260622,
0.0086817145,
0.0049834773,
-0.0082709743,
-0.003837459,
-0.0207932387,
-0.0251436792,
-0.0377874784,
0.0006735506,
0.0641744509,
-0.0409569554,
0.0686524659,
0.0503225289,
0.0861469954,
-0.0253268257,
-0.0247116555,
-0.0323926993,
0.0514810607,
0.0100215189,
-0.0040877019,
0.0751825497,
-0.0359357782,
0.0266139023,
0.0108482996,
-0.0107395183,
0.0045996537,
0.0572722554,
0.0437745526,
0.0141565194,
-0.0303728208,
-0.0516615883,
-0.0244450755,
0.0776313022,
0.0301801283,
0.0613423288,
-0.0017104065,
-0.0707283169,
0.0073777945,
0.0492903888,
0.0122846439,
0.0043424675,
-0.0355532095,
-0.0040322985,
0.0250812154,
-0.0441083051,
-0.0802098289,
-0.0243743565,
-0.0663032457,
-0.0068049356,
0.0146441888,
-0.0147930998,
-0.0055665532,
0.0297584068,
-0.0448296443,
0.0128880972,
0.0336807147,
0.054762274,
-0.0273988377,
-0.059950795,
0.0274219383,
-0.03003552,
-0.0235344805,
-0.0076318369,
-0.0436674841,
-0.014940545,
-0.0300909281,
0.0594785996,
0.0150454976,
0.0690073967,
-0.0109649925,
-0.0493041761,
0.025976412,
0.0026851611,
-0.0733643398,
0.0316022001,
0.0589102618,
-0.0059375092,
-0.0202230997,
0.0216871295,
-0.0320683047,
0.0462089516,
0.0033939616,
-0.069184728,
0.0536766052,
-0.0354131423,
-0.0384643264,
-0.0541239493,
0.0322218649,
0.0128915794,
0.0084776813,
-0.0119103184,
0.0015918472,
0.0044004419,
0.0124278488,
-0.0706255585,
-0.014971545,
-0.0273618586,
0.0233898759,
-0.0324265063,
-0.091909945,
-0.0534453765,
0.0105132032,
-0.0476112291,
0.0518327355,
0.0366875269,
0.0039015785,
0.0146740368,
0.0164743531,
-0.0253990814,
0.003809958,
0.0463468134,
-0.0155400801,
0.0075956094,
0.0531346686,
0.0154553279,
-0.0233389717,
-0.0038606974,
0.0712936893,
-0.0122837676,
0.0207227767,
-0.0446739905,
0.0047602388,
0.0259284526,
0.0047485302,
0.0659581348,
0.0015790095,
0.0280855224,
0.0108974995,
0.066853784,
-0.0719483644,
-0.0444400907,
-0.0043937857,
-0.0074634901,
-0.0230133925,
0.0329101458,
0.0081882589,
-0.0616391972,
0.0030497604,
0.0089491978,
-0.009086295,
-0.0413512886,
-0.0142597258,
0.0445525348,
0.0470646322,
0.0118004922,
0.0295429751,
-0.0366594791,
-0.0674947873,
0.0468110032,
-0.0209458899,
0.0193225555,
0.0005800001,
0.0503994897,
0.0433806255,
-0.0006087006,
0.0136105828,
-0.0129716815,
-0.0685857162,
-0.0305191204,
0.0008855978,
-0.0275032371,
-5.057806523e-33,
0.0279757343,
-0.0051728631,
-0.0354736708,
0.0849834681,
-0.0477224588,
0.0074919327,
-0.0230368096,
0.0077168364,
0.0176292472,
-0.0010909998,
-0.0162718911,
0.0320150927,
-0.0120792054,
-0.0084959054,
-0.0037539953,
0.0242586806,
0.0550196804,
-0.032119628,
-0.0311388187,
0.0513817593,
0.0480896346,
0.0335990228,
0.0622879602,
-0.1261321902,
-0.0136731826,
0.0030221376,
-0.0507756062,
-0.0212196335,
0.0187483151,
0.031444449,
-0.0311427098,
0.0740615055,
-0.0162898246,
0.0432824753,
0.0330359414,
0.0557153635,
-0.0423667543,
0.0037964105,
-0.0151384203,
0.013405811,
-0.0006654222,
0.0048354748,
0.0272497535,
-0.016449783,
-0.0582583137,
0.0188494902,
0.0621978976,
0.0118138008,
0.0620768853,
-0.0375140719,
-0.0819505155,
-0.0261358507,
-0.0142875807,
-0.0660875142,
-0.0052730981,
0.0433642082,
0.0338805988,
0.0070885443,
-0.0674664229,
0.0556309558,
-0.0198929515,
-0.0073787291,
-0.0241105631,
-0.0347632691,
0.0229549073,
0.088793613,
0.0704820827,
-0.0057444205,
0.0433750153,
0.0067534032,
0.0455397889,
0.047317449,
0.0496052355,
0.0191991683,
0.0068619214,
-0.0624972284,
0.0025004728,
0.0022005211,
0.0637353808,
-0.0302368272,
0.0139228078,
-0.0204751939,
-0.0592391454,
-0.0103549212,
0.0009975185,
-0.0560242943,
-0.033697851,
-0.0234747846,
0.0240188222,
0.0170601271,
0.0197769832,
-0.0005096974,
0.0252494421,
-0.0603965595,
-0.0328422077,
-0.0015617621,
-0.019733442,
0.0017071966,
0.0050742999,
-0.0485010743,
-0.015369474,
-0.0330327675,
0.0379700102,
0.0161169581,
0.0407453738,
-0.0093125813,
0.0456443578,
0.0644740686,
-0.0518803485,
0.0043749041,
0.0069970982,
0.0310712904,
-0.0148372911,
0.0282131117,
-0.0000825436,
0.0260226745,
-0.0259409547,
0.0321540087,
-0.0280225482,
0.0444862582,
-0.0828767046,
0.0085538365,
-0.0020717913,
-0.0117124422,
-0.0705751181,
-0.0372374915,
-0.0066951429,
-0.0676874816,
0.0129105672,
-0.0450550355,
0.0118874349,
-0.0606046878,
2.536e-7,
-0.0543984883,
0.057565894,
0.011030945,
-0.0155103942,
0.0474034473,
0.0671140403,
-0.0260569882,
0.026540067,
0.001320135,
0.0735046938,
0.0179869719,
-0.0501055457,
0.0522938855,
0.0424769036,
-0.0795988217,
-0.0288759638,
-0.1009272784,
-0.0208912045,
-0.022627227,
-0.0525135696,
0.0442122146,
0.0677066594,
0.0488703251,
-0.0474769473,
0.0059292912,
-0.0111896256,
0.0146125732,
-0.0413870327,
0.0317375138,
-0.0466466732,
-0.0291560441,
-0.0457462482,
-0.0277523436,
0.0331960768,
-0.0183044784,
0.0186759662,
0.0003710793,
0.0748940706,
-0.0162241366,
-0.0581857711,
-0.0155447191,
0.0709403008,
-0.0225386284,
-0.0047587808,
0.0087218992,
-0.0133438259,
-0.0232634004,
-0.0376148559,
-0.0222902205,
-0.0159911439,
-0.0069234669,
0.0263922177,
-0.0078116418,
0.0411743671,
-0.0024111434,
0.0078148954,
0.0003171788,
-0.0817073584,
0.0572997965,
-0.0110549964,
-0.0350479186,
-0.0455179624,
0.0147855636,
0.0042042253,
-0.0213296879,
-0.0295781139,
0.0297691692,
1.824294338e-34,
0.0071105636,
-0.0504165366,
0.0388724655,
-0.0057344884,
0.0362524502,
0.0257872846,
0.0575264916,
-0.0476298928,
0.0224139187,
-0.0172226969,
-0.0209356099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17663v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17663v1 | LLM-ARC: Enhancing LLMs with an Automated Reasoning Critic | 2024-06-25T15:52:15 | 2024-06-25T15:52:15 | Aditya Kalyanpur, Kailash Saravanakumar, Victor Barres, Jennifer Chu-Carroll, David Melville, David Ferrucci | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LO | We introduce LLM-ARC, a neuro-symbolic framework designed to enhance the
logical reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs), by combining
them with an Automated Reasoning Critic (ARC). LLM-ARC employs an Actor-Critic
method where the LLM Actor generates declarative logic programs along with
tests for semantic correctness, while the Automated Reasoning Critic evaluates
the code, runs the tests and provides feedback on test failures for iterative
refinement. Implemented using Answer Set Programming (ASP), LLM-ARC achieves a
new state-of-the-art accuracy of 88.32% on the FOLIO benchmark which tests
complex logical reasoning capabilities. Our experiments demonstrate significant
improvements over LLM-only baselines, highlighting the importance of logic test
generation and iterative self-refinement. We achieve our best result using a
fully automated self-supervised training loop where the Actor is trained on
end-to-end dialog traces with Critic feedback. We discuss potential
enhancements and provide a detailed error analysis, showcasing the robustness
and efficacy of LLM-ARC for complex natural language reasoning tasks. | [
0.0237939693,
0.0593536086,
-0.0096962582,
0.0518842749,
-0.0394435897,
0.0131506538,
0.0250257254,
-0.0232799463,
0.0368763693,
-0.0266831983,
-0.0021258446,
0.0128379175,
-0.0612237118,
0.0480502434,
0.0215275958,
0.0144498907,
0.0680711493,
-0.0413533971,
0.0419452377,
-0.0144788465,
-0.0166395381,
0.0328988247,
-0.0151121756,
0.0038510675,
-0.0223175548,
-0.020820044,
-0.021368539,
-0.004962367,
-0.0062569785,
-0.0473691784,
-0.0118929138,
0.0370745398,
0.0401354805,
0.0255272668,
0.0000021432,
-0.0506645814,
0.0097161774,
0.0021786231,
-0.0580818988,
-0.0016658835,
-0.0080970563,
0.0403855443,
0.005485971,
0.0261460375,
-0.0331608392,
0.0125130489,
-0.0065818806,
0.0468524359,
0.0842826888,
0.0870032907,
0.0137134455,
-0.0314922519,
0.0213992149,
-0.0102162501,
0.0204511601,
-0.0328380093,
0.017044222,
0.0356874503,
0.0295919087,
-0.0105529511,
0.0000948257,
0.0116414716,
0.0815070942,
-0.030323064,
-0.0362405814,
0.031792514,
-0.0370994546,
0.0042620949,
-0.0178368166,
0.0659455061,
0.0306752548,
-0.0282540396,
-0.0414783396,
-0.0047213063,
0.0002832573,
-0.0413908474,
-0.004015971,
0.0391886905,
-0.0211550724,
-0.0015951269,
0.0410050377,
-0.028587006,
0.0337206759,
0.0305599049,
-0.0475301668,
0.0908560976,
-0.0093489187,
-0.0374148898,
0.0504582711,
-0.0031051703,
-0.0224896744,
-0.0428983755,
0.0236603729,
0.0716748014,
-0.0649793446,
0.0298812501,
-0.0049855122,
0.0013391013,
0.0245146118,
-0.0142309712,
0.0499116406,
0.0587275475,
0.01894987,
0.0550040007,
-0.0470745824,
0.0589636602,
-0.0024208294,
0.0811350942,
-0.0241862349,
0.0090380562,
-0.0418754034,
-0.0273810178,
-0.0183107238,
0.0430319943,
-0.0377566144,
0.0084474916,
-0.0144644789,
0.0239560809,
-0.0162730478,
0.0405591056,
-0.0041612554,
0.0264071506,
0.0274577942,
-0.0237452984,
-0.0822956041,
0.0226452965,
-0.0715906247,
0.0211015567,
0.0234669056,
-0.0274731182,
-0.021716401,
-0.0025148985,
-0.0275758412,
-0.0280565564,
0.0535941385,
0.0882518142,
-0.0140860099,
-0.0073708096,
-0.0382504091,
-0.0292537808,
0.007703511,
-0.0806385875,
0.0026642254,
-0.0660256818,
0.0488545559,
-0.0141264647,
-0.0480648279,
-0.0418292508,
0.0160960928,
0.0201078076,
0.0414310247,
0.0766749457,
-0.0091025345,
-0.0059402813,
0.0247410592,
0.0115326708,
-0.0186591446,
0.052448757,
0.0357292816,
0.0030934042,
0.0034612124,
0.0025182341,
-0.01000652,
0.0185818523,
0.0328313783,
-0.0035952323,
-0.0097049866,
0.0530482195,
-0.0566132218,
0.0451470017,
-0.0022090632,
0.0481527783,
-0.0388024375,
-0.0632359535,
-0.0044950559,
0.035794843,
0.0133792236,
0.0104878871,
0.0167113226,
-0.0207253695,
0.026290834,
-0.049758479,
-0.0792068914,
0.0438891128,
0.0017519911,
-0.0063311821,
-0.0236567631,
0.000890741,
-0.0254598968,
-0.0676762164,
0.0185455754,
0.0286574606,
0.0104825087,
0.0332379676,
0.0288316961,
0.0217524264,
-0.0466673747,
0.0519597642,
0.0039736629,
-0.041971229,
-0.0246499553,
-0.0620875917,
0.06122756,
0.0425279997,
0.046922788,
-0.038945552,
-0.0627787113,
-0.026845498,
-0.0140455123,
0.0406194367,
0.0178946108,
-0.0126517294,
0.0168842264,
-0.0261144638,
-0.008327811,
-0.0459527858,
0.0042952411,
0.0517332777,
0.0352074653,
-0.0151249729,
-0.0012237084,
-0.0079216165,
-0.0036560786,
0.037823461,
-0.0294428654,
-0.0432857014,
0.0076870527,
-0.0075542489,
0.0325729437,
0.0082039312,
0.0046956083,
0.0162559561,
0.0132201938,
-0.01063025,
-0.0551229082,
-0.0235958211,
-0.064832598,
-0.0504130088,
0.0813225806,
0.0076141539,
-0.0462160036,
0.0139166834,
-0.0707495511,
-0.0335634984,
0.0311949644,
-0.0109923817,
-0.0302960258,
-0.0470340401,
0.0041411854,
0.0311509166,
-0.0272231437,
-0.0373278148,
0.066817604,
0.0033969798,
-0.0082104513,
-0.0035175579,
0.0810733661,
0.0310281403,
-0.046648737,
0.0191589817,
-0.0034198873,
-0.0306779314,
-0.0046091471,
-0.0012039256,
0.0297306031,
-0.0551673993,
-0.0306936987,
-0.0442420244,
0.0121199079,
0.0031574417,
0.0129096536,
-0.0053898729,
-0.0303073637,
-0.0039226501,
0.001936381,
-0.0359586291,
-0.0130500412,
0.0464958623,
-0.0068419939,
0.0242166463,
-0.0065603256,
-0.0194520149,
-0.0152319307,
-0.0111552812,
-0.041818127,
0.0060737254,
0.0267962012,
0.0493569039,
-0.022823574,
-0.0228469167,
-0.0559843071,
0.0300865658,
0.0063537629,
-0.0268365536,
0.0526331812,
-0.0112373112,
-0.0374538004,
0.0831261501,
-0.0145309288,
-0.0084603811,
0.0350902751,
-0.0018959243,
-0.0559090711,
0.0923991203,
0.0064264722,
-0.0006622257,
-0.031136984,
-0.0068654106,
-0.0263646767,
0.0523491651,
-0.0051736194,
0.0204835534,
-0.0190842729,
0.0370793715,
0.0195913184,
-0.0343291722,
-0.0176066868,
-0.0256393086,
-0.0078488402,
0.0438669883,
-0.0330077,
-0.0087576108,
0.0952281281,
-0.0024477667,
-0.0107193282,
-0.0475758389,
-0.0079277186,
-0.0637593344,
0.0854667202,
-0.0046066255,
-0.017198395,
-0.0120299486,
-0.0092059011,
-0.0184893087,
-0.0622415766,
0.0120465895,
-0.0406645723,
0.0706610829,
-0.0355814695,
0.0047189491,
0.0131401671,
-0.0475621149,
-0.0459754243,
-0.0169165786,
-0.0666894466,
-0.0085829133,
-0.0395723023,
-0.010238911,
0.0212061238,
-0.0267398804,
-0.0165988095,
0.0232241154,
-0.0157676376,
-0.0126872305,
-0.0233613048,
-0.0003582579,
0.0089233834,
0.0407686383,
0.0228288136,
-0.0074265269,
0.0532927923,
0.0481795333,
0.0122882957,
-0.0137596717,
-0.0697419718,
0.0439213999,
-0.0262870453,
-0.0287559759,
0.0355696604,
0.0045410073,
0.047246743,
-0.0973452404,
-0.0061011282,
0.1136375293,
0.0377192497,
0.0135675827,
0.0055253934,
-0.0435846858,
0.0421971306,
0.0423379131,
0.0650299788,
-0.0905273706,
-0.0480147861,
-0.0025607869,
-0.0018641065,
0.0034509141,
-0.0487142093,
-0.0122985011,
-0.1097633317,
0.0313720852,
0.0068548964,
-0.0222157128,
0.0100730527,
-0.0376228094,
0.0051450711,
-0.0197391696,
0.0007839114,
0.0524009094,
0.0048083914,
0.0041124914,
-0.0080721108,
0.0072760372,
0.0423381105,
0.0842638165,
-0.0318476073,
0.0512278043,
0.03680747,
0.0025139658,
0.0025389427,
-0.0102788405,
0.0548583753,
-0.0168812498,
0.0278512985,
-0.0540377535,
0.0359101072,
0.0073270407,
-0.0068012974,
-0.0240108054,
0.0262724832,
-0.0337999016,
-0.0307299662,
0.0337146297,
0.0698427111,
-0.0163573194,
-0.0126064215,
-0.026420569,
0.0173249934,
-0.0273074377,
0.0410809703,
0.0137925092,
0.0025709816,
-0.0830768496,
-0.0562538579,
-0.0437442325,
-0.075407818,
-0.0098836655,
-0.0000538571,
0.0195078366,
0.0265782382,
-0.0230068564,
-0.0367693491,
0.0287079457,
0.0199138504,
-0.0221185219,
-0.033624433,
-0.0114704669,
-0.0116048064,
-0.0273952689,
0.0205017738,
-0.0472857244,
0.0457580239,
0.0012117499,
0.0379645564,
-0.010284692,
-0.0278547816,
-0.0215033311,
0.0292991064,
-0.0547096431,
-0.0494134612,
-0.0296017099,
0.0557507165,
0.0211706311,
0.0450750776,
-0.0230225604,
-0.0106030563,
0.0235920884,
-0.0026489245,
-0.0347885229,
-0.0105577502,
0.0463286713,
0.0196265671,
-0.0058962884,
0.0203261562,
-0.0273462608,
0.0286530964,
0.007563055,
0.0695623383,
-0.016319735,
-0.0242572781,
0.0462111272,
0.0367301069,
-0.0299495533,
0.0309545733,
0.0263048112,
-0.0245539863,
0.0295297727,
-0.033063665,
-0.0107563641,
-0.0103584612,
0.0172454994,
-0.0044610715,
-0.0621830188,
0.0052136215,
-0.0544038489,
-0.0073369839,
0.0261353459,
0.0232953075,
0.0138149429,
0.0357824527,
0.0174125098,
-0.0146911666,
-0.0214363355,
-0.0287551284,
0.0164555032,
0.006578628,
0.0536546484,
-0.0106117781,
0.0632528141,
0.0489104725,
0.0062456974,
-0.0387793221,
-0.0291982722,
-0.0529527515,
-0.04535212,
0.027602043,
0.0071971891,
0.0273446664,
0.0206393991,
-0.0178531334,
-0.0449142121,
0.0016904094,
0.0204239897,
0.0029880574,
0.0030965221,
-0.0272097792,
0.0663806871,
0.0327802524,
0.0196204744,
-0.0487795956,
0.0192182399,
0.0077149337,
0.0471569933,
0.0184427276,
0.0258865748,
-0.0641208738,
-0.0615622364,
-0.0514093302,
-0.025030449,
-0.0103121828,
-0.0058727753,
-0.0235825256,
-0.0958912373,
-0.0032074656,
0.0543603487,
-0.0043544224,
0.0041949325,
0.0056874682,
0.0423052199,
0.0323596597,
-0.0574882925,
0.010488498,
0.0136905704,
-0.0319357254,
-0.0177082587,
-0.0356963463,
-5.909315161e-33,
-0.0240136012,
-0.0342744067,
0.0861507952,
-0.0150460647,
-0.0244650226,
-0.0305774212,
-0.0599071346,
-0.0108702471,
-0.0188931916,
0.0350810103,
-0.0229347218,
0.0375137106,
0.000505714,
0.0156137357,
-0.0000222215,
-0.0413553827,
0.0036016351,
0.0071503557,
-0.0194866043,
0.0079267099,
-0.0266578533,
-0.0129058035,
0.0054386603,
-0.0512193292,
-0.0263307001,
0.0208770093,
-0.0204655472,
0.0554875508,
-0.1006832868,
0.0479050539,
0.0288070217,
0.0206331033,
0.0164778586,
-0.0239498466,
0.0066978335,
-0.0050227037,
-0.0884276628,
-0.069556959,
0.0401047952,
-0.029913418,
-0.0721425265,
-0.0221133195,
0.0292644762,
0.0046656979,
-0.0026101973,
-0.0272053406,
-0.0135908527,
-0.0188209973,
0.0159552675,
0.0085051358,
-0.0144961635,
0.0161234364,
-0.0292821899,
-0.015084289,
-0.0278706159,
0.0324906856,
-0.0035153718,
-0.023908712,
-0.0379816145,
-0.0066713193,
0.0196481086,
-0.019025676,
0.0521157123,
0.0266994312,
-0.0148628615,
0.0308359526,
0.0261713639,
0.0028587205,
-0.0744841471,
0.0092272805,
0.0041521308,
0.0690468773,
0.0575262867,
0.0227978136,
-0.006464866,
0.0220603738,
-0.0694405586,
0.0019599595,
0.0237373058,
0.0919936299,
0.0127491765,
0.0054682931,
-0.0222673193,
-0.0010560945,
-0.0672857836,
0.0393342599,
-0.0365063883,
-0.0403572805,
0.0331211351,
0.0028056677,
-0.0135878827,
-0.0295301378,
-0.0182482246,
-0.0244377349,
0.0109220548,
0.039037507,
0.0002700299,
-0.0063593313,
-0.0030618205,
0.0425726175,
-0.0433116555,
0.0146248192,
0.0058302013,
-0.0065444559,
0.0078104413,
-0.0021122622,
0.0180758573,
0.0257047936,
-0.0487170331,
-0.0086518154,
-0.0407811403,
0.0299498066,
-0.0033399598,
0.0210187119,
0.0108956005,
0.0355296619,
-0.0197857469,
0.0371944755,
-0.0215191096,
-0.0062053618,
-0.0367096327,
0.030239502,
0.0252264235,
0.0448310487,
-0.0216464419,
0.005343128,
-0.0457991324,
0.0122157745,
-0.0214745849,
-0.0932767093,
0.0066490942,
0.0287544094,
2.752e-7,
0.0396967568,
0.0457961112,
0.0459674373,
0.0931871608,
0.0295904521,
0.0328971297,
-0.0137670133,
-0.0250345096,
0.0295181405,
-0.0530381016,
0.0037350189,
0.0896767229,
0.0118344761,
0.0429147631,
-0.016747335,
0.0262707528,
-0.048680719,
0.0052905413,
-0.0546237268,
0.0226029418,
0.0846205801,
0.0790662542,
0.0306748673,
-0.0468197241,
0.0014566004,
-0.057682801,
0.0422333442,
0.0086366227,
0.0062460033,
0.0196862016,
-0.0016033618,
-0.0022636161,
0.0301222615,
0.0620620921,
0.0126541024,
0.0074059321,
-0.0572094582,
0.0569161512,
-0.0082016541,
-0.040179275,
-0.026175769,
-0.0352849141,
0.0195667986,
-0.0508653373,
0.0772218257,
-0.0446220189,
-0.0346603878,
-0.0111268116,
-0.0145793566,
-0.0362063088,
0.0075221863,
-0.0037406867,
0.0033737852,
0.0065793027,
0.0088864435,
-0.0143982973,
0.0001979903,
-0.072024554,
-0.0506649539,
-0.0014696451,
-0.0230796449,
0.015560274,
-0.0426952951,
0.0250486601,
0.0275782514,
-0.0655626655,
-0.0088137267,
2.590950491e-34,
0.0354650058,
-0.0279021654,
0.0215025544,
0.0422590747,
0.0773367435,
0.0145078432,
-0.0234273802,
0.0090011917,
0.0298096202,
-0.0574819185,
-0.0272742547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17650v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17650v1 | ELIZA Reinterpreted: The world's first chatbot was not intended as a chatbot at all | 2024-06-25T15:41:40 | 2024-06-25T15:41:40 | Jeff Shrager | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | ELIZA, often considered the world's first chatbot, was written by Joseph
Weizenbaum in the early 1960s. Weizenbaum did not intend to invent the chatbot,
but rather to build a platform for research into human-machine conversation and
the important cognitive processes of interpretation and misinterpretation. His
purpose was obscured by ELIZA's fame, resulting in large part from the
fortuitous timing of it's creation, and it's escape into the wild. In this
paper I provide a rich historical context for ELIZA's creation, demonstrating
that ELIZA arose from the intersection of some of the central threads in the
technical history of AI. I also briefly discuss how ELIZA escaped into the
world, and how its accidental escape, along with several coincidental turns of
the programming language screws, led both to the misapprehension that ELIZA was
intended as a chatbot, and to the loss of the original ELIZA to history for
over 50 years. | [
0.0888183042,
-0.0070734452,
-0.0291803312,
-0.0199835617,
-0.0197573286,
-0.0003069338,
0.0046123918,
0.0191156771,
0.0572040528,
-0.0238992665,
0.0013818681,
0.0083404016,
0.0065135593,
0.0213212576,
-0.0206557158,
-0.0360484198,
-0.0072699548,
0.0196643174,
-0.0036677362,
0.0302545372,
0.0118348226,
0.0305656735,
-0.0300253425,
0.0825071633,
-0.0500980392,
-0.0405421853,
-0.0471258573,
0.0079449611,
-0.0197997689,
0.0275954474,
-0.0109831505,
-0.0161994882,
0.0004314849,
0.0135388747,
0.0000018336,
-0.0337222964,
0.0111815687,
-0.0014693683,
-0.0762032121,
-0.0667979121,
0.0124924649,
0.0320892334,
-0.015839301,
0.0077248514,
-0.0392715856,
0.0680469871,
0.0435343385,
-0.0001346698,
0.0348381735,
0.0636758283,
-0.0145490495,
0.0547722504,
0.0209111739,
0.0265627895,
0.059330292,
-0.0771634504,
-0.011122426,
0.0210459903,
0.0502225868,
-0.0146347191,
-0.0140170818,
-0.0045288876,
0.0304576904,
-0.021731019,
-0.0225095488,
0.0194236077,
-0.0010517901,
-0.0782817751,
-0.0218767226,
0.0125892619,
0.0614685491,
-0.0041532083,
0.0322114006,
0.0555459745,
0.0209339615,
0.0010396164,
0.0074724755,
0.0064857318,
-0.0069756554,
-0.0339758098,
0.0063109673,
-0.0513132252,
-0.0017989136,
0.0215849113,
-0.0222924389,
0.0264604371,
-0.0195717737,
0.0251750872,
-0.0154929096,
-0.0191945173,
0.0293122213,
-0.0561218821,
0.0168169346,
0.0582649596,
-0.0151918884,
-0.0221809745,
-0.0193631686,
0.019136291,
-0.037317425,
-0.0521319136,
-0.0445962287,
0.0476782508,
0.0191543084,
0.0459530503,
0.0547032766,
0.0768170357,
-0.0094399033,
0.0277754981,
-0.0263926182,
-0.0097664269,
-0.0649436861,
-0.0196878389,
-0.0481027737,
0.0459012389,
0.0419589356,
-0.0210553557,
-0.005619884,
0.0580989122,
0.0166080184,
-0.0157383569,
-0.0674841926,
-0.0111051761,
-0.0118407086,
-0.0013989054,
-0.0289957542,
-0.0310568456,
-0.0433499739,
0.0079125194,
0.0253800303,
-0.0837153271,
-0.028538879,
-0.0059397053,
-0.0322814025,
-0.0144358678,
-0.0116994232,
0.0802351609,
0.0122120036,
-0.0560678877,
0.0150965666,
-0.0096925711,
-0.014692178,
-0.0736381039,
0.0067330617,
-0.0152589986,
-0.0104617253,
0.029236773,
0.0206739251,
-0.0483151041,
0.0090965647,
-0.0160060264,
-0.0230116453,
0.0002213452,
-0.0289678667,
0.0040837298,
0.0601454377,
0.0263109114,
-0.0556666441,
0.0284922998,
0.0326062292,
0.0256867968,
0.0133304661,
0.0241779033,
0.0838552043,
0.0136839859,
-0.0307560712,
-0.0514675304,
0.0307231732,
0.0006229717,
-0.02779595,
-0.0013013433,
-0.0186752956,
0.0019338366,
-0.0276062153,
0.0495568588,
0.0064559937,
0.0768327862,
-0.0465292372,
0.0428945497,
0.0430448987,
-0.0048487452,
0.0342738107,
0.0123435957,
-0.0307062548,
0.0041833073,
-0.0423229486,
-0.0507313758,
-0.0239055585,
-0.02966314,
-0.0068136081,
-0.0423677899,
0.0421604402,
-0.0243876092,
0.0221311226,
-0.0088051772,
0.0274969023,
0.0123603363,
0.0055661029,
-0.014707244,
-0.0249343701,
-0.0350558013,
-0.0510503948,
-0.0833599642,
-0.0297483746,
0.1099418923,
0.0450396799,
-0.0058230301,
0.0147668393,
0.0059462893,
-0.0049504992,
0.0362176336,
0.0325581729,
0.0165935792,
-0.0078023742,
0.0105974916,
0.0060168561,
-0.0118704336,
-0.0095690433,
0.0130548524,
-0.0587452352,
0.0232340507,
-0.0166883301,
0.0699494034,
0.007306254,
0.0058254753,
-0.0100487806,
-0.0290496405,
-0.0680754259,
0.0054184264,
-0.0029420594,
0.0433426052,
-0.0179385059,
0.0228866283,
0.026064368,
0.006519638,
-0.0005810878,
0.0369556062,
0.0085309455,
0.0246324595,
0.0249395277,
-0.0954691544,
-0.0148810372,
0.080126375,
0.0167981237,
-0.0055694147,
0.0410287268,
-0.0744426474,
0.0610819831,
-0.0096499901,
0.0436020568,
-0.0428608321,
0.0003537175,
-0.0225765202,
0.0260002725,
-0.0043208962,
-0.045534119,
0.025695052,
-0.0011854121,
-0.0142165441,
-0.0210967511,
-0.0322669186,
0.0236553289,
0.0188525412,
0.0168000348,
0.0262101404,
-0.0322925672,
-0.0488787852,
0.0012873322,
-0.0851641148,
-0.0253168419,
0.0163165629,
-0.0288797617,
0.015911622,
0.0087815942,
0.0009501418,
-0.0504590869,
0.0058674999,
0.056280788,
-0.036614798,
0.0083290832,
0.0577369519,
0.0093946187,
-0.0546824597,
-0.0455018803,
0.0212544985,
-0.029849397,
0.0089338711,
0.0586789139,
-0.0441381782,
-0.0371799618,
0.0403164178,
-0.0158737879,
0.0174310226,
-0.0267759934,
-0.0134305861,
0.0415732935,
-0.0141520659,
0.0035043359,
0.0390091836,
-0.0002316624,
0.1051970944,
0.0309668817,
0.0316287838,
-0.0121744238,
-0.0005012772,
0.0191378202,
0.0060110735,
-0.0010545562,
-0.042046532,
-0.0114798984,
0.0268671215,
-0.0292973258,
0.0297328942,
-0.0151932351,
0.0722380355,
-0.0047219135,
-0.039728228,
-0.0263437089,
-0.0331414863,
-0.0234280881,
0.0647395551,
-0.0099287108,
-0.031911388,
0.060196843,
0.0103278663,
-0.0102749821,
-0.0045965868,
-0.0275072102,
0.0247784909,
0.0827722326,
-0.0532323904,
0.0099871652,
0.0122773126,
-0.0046779797,
-0.0321461558,
0.0031425389,
0.0093965856,
-0.0596259125,
-0.0252601802,
-0.019261159,
0.0166497566,
0.0192772802,
-0.0161613151,
-0.0365900137,
-0.0692883134,
-0.048509378,
-0.0226295013,
0.0362408012,
-0.0063419961,
-0.0646349937,
-0.0121686272,
0.006179607,
0.0420231596,
0.0455735698,
-0.0204364769,
-0.0100553446,
-0.0895814821,
0.0101169711,
0.034124516,
0.0111070853,
0.0245522428,
0.0562956668,
0.0282018092,
0.0143716633,
-0.0100213438,
0.0211306997,
-0.0441143066,
0.0010938491,
-0.0053158239,
-0.0484656394,
0.0118845552,
0.0236376766,
-0.0470008776,
-0.0214002747,
0.0634113625,
0.021467302,
-0.0590408035,
-0.0021198182,
-0.0237867273,
-0.0465842746,
0.0209896695,
0.0535979308,
-0.0853899941,
0.0183822904,
0.0277044456,
-0.0097481422,
-0.0339739807,
-0.0325338356,
-0.010739631,
-0.077920936,
-0.0013004121,
-0.0188204218,
-0.0417315327,
-0.0339030884,
-0.0190242566,
-0.0410566889,
0.026276648,
0.0142769599,
0.0255091116,
0.0078328568,
0.0089419298,
-0.0235490799,
-0.0264800079,
0.0633795336,
0.0285960454,
-0.0158070549,
0.0752830058,
0.0563875921,
0.0588972531,
0.0077751619,
0.0673372075,
-0.0179978963,
0.0737306178,
0.0247323774,
0.0167568941,
0.0453200862,
0.0017017559,
-0.0255146492,
-0.0278766938,
-0.0217538364,
0.0098310784,
0.0296039209,
0.0495076589,
-0.0107184853,
-0.05796111,
0.0041834074,
-0.027718205,
-0.0089244489,
0.0286835767,
0.006927541,
0.0262876283,
-0.0347120203,
-0.0741492808,
-0.0402064808,
0.0295446105,
0.0264917482,
-0.0934232101,
0.0120706521,
0.0030725598,
-0.0734496787,
-0.0921212062,
-0.0417195633,
0.0042310422,
0.04336375,
0.0682950914,
-0.0280854553,
0.0052671819,
0.0453993268,
-0.0264346674,
-0.0021844516,
0.0105508827,
-0.0276646204,
-0.0155942058,
-0.0048352364,
-0.0043089828,
-0.0672971159,
0.0045046359,
0.0157257859,
0.0253679957,
-0.0031435806,
0.0227126069,
0.0307031274,
0.0359033234,
0.0003026737,
-0.0226186235,
0.0062869489,
-0.0059293848,
-0.0041943402,
-0.0144908456,
0.0247869231,
0.0292322598,
0.0665143058,
0.0023269744,
0.0306818597,
-0.0726236776,
-0.0242084712,
-0.0273399483,
-0.0193471797,
-0.0083113154,
-0.0254477728,
0.0492032506,
0.0430410393,
-0.0008983535,
0.0129668852,
0.0383186303,
0.0468453802,
0.000673503,
-0.0356720723,
0.000673781,
-0.0168098398,
-0.0112948474,
-0.0352385975,
-0.0129901478,
0.0633360371,
0.0122080706,
-0.0332402773,
0.0129423272,
0.006514743,
-0.0012858125,
-0.0100046946,
0.0949237496,
-0.0098225288,
-0.0002017962,
0.0019345294,
0.0577733219,
0.0022598966,
0.0521666631,
0.0354036726,
0.0535974056,
-0.0038178603,
-0.0163231734,
-0.0129197789,
0.0279776454,
-0.1191446036,
-0.1191550121,
0.0593911745,
0.0717958659,
0.0329326466,
0.0350687504,
0.0441464707,
-0.0134030199,
0.0106759695,
-0.0163495298,
0.0211346596,
0.0210356936,
-0.0073712845,
-0.0656151325,
0.0087052695,
-0.0001630798,
-0.0032731532,
0.005454557,
-0.0397017002,
0.0770922527,
0.0162853245,
-0.0162953697,
-0.0378323235,
-0.0632820576,
-0.007987339,
-0.0380125605,
0.0372319371,
-0.0211093705,
-0.0197241846,
-0.0267197173,
-0.0180619471,
0.0232693311,
0.0112315733,
-0.0290351342,
0.0517122708,
0.0230505057,
-0.0027202468,
-0.0330218449,
-0.0511985905,
0.010332346,
-0.0247641541,
0.0185589213,
-0.0006754124,
-5.455179082e-33,
0.0149232047,
-0.0274733175,
0.0434405841,
0.0451220348,
-0.0308301747,
-0.0243879668,
-0.0481502451,
0.0442650169,
-0.0675293058,
0.0028168734,
-0.0546453707,
0.0537495837,
0.0094619673,
-0.0568944477,
0.0118021481,
0.0045388755,
0.0258968864,
0.00187468,
-0.0287906099,
0.0196054038,
0.0321452692,
0.0064808414,
0.0006252704,
-0.0300503131,
0.0673742294,
-0.0185010657,
-0.0295363422,
-0.0095847715,
0.0044968892,
0.0108585861,
0.0068419729,
-0.0017790389,
0.0112333922,
0.02743873,
0.0025422517,
0.0366650373,
0.0008539447,
-0.0356118605,
-0.015729323,
0.0183387939,
-0.0326932222,
-0.0446989574,
0.0182342883,
-0.0115566282,
-0.0309516415,
0.0289684143,
0.030757701,
-0.0100208065,
0.0305424854,
0.0647943541,
-0.0571052209,
-0.0377157256,
-0.0721902624,
-0.0868159533,
0.0296652503,
0.0248540733,
-0.0133990794,
-0.0400987305,
-0.0091387946,
0.0638730302,
-0.0504511669,
-0.0412930809,
0.0215111263,
-0.0062736981,
0.0330959931,
0.0702103078,
0.1075878516,
0.0444043651,
-0.0408697613,
-0.0350401774,
-0.0044243759,
0.0245405771,
0.0038838957,
0.0228432212,
-0.0237847473,
-0.0233209301,
-0.0581538118,
0.0085148858,
0.0465201251,
0.0041203089,
0.0142196594,
-0.0105650611,
-0.1152542531,
0.0022211461,
0.0090769473,
0.0277820546,
-0.0210058708,
-0.0365711041,
-0.0074943928,
-0.0219990462,
-0.0118724247,
-0.0449898168,
-0.0141371163,
-0.0911441818,
0.013415331,
-0.0249508284,
-0.0225137603,
-0.0034830847,
0.0243013147,
-0.0073991003,
0.0257990006,
-0.0359591208,
0.0039168755,
0.0468691438,
0.0679185688,
0.0174421035,
-0.0342595689,
0.0355861858,
0.0384376496,
-0.0445190892,
-0.0161121488,
0.0000349085,
0.0162539613,
-0.0622873306,
0.0012250458,
0.0073318775,
-0.0194625016,
0.0535416529,
0.0369975455,
0.0286442991,
-0.038380079,
0.0320257731,
-0.0105376942,
-0.0169422645,
-0.0339277573,
-0.0412727967,
-0.0468156263,
0.0877517462,
0.0221436154,
-0.0595715307,
-0.0351612084,
-0.0103526125,
2.623e-7,
-0.0119255884,
0.0351881795,
0.066390425,
0.0165696181,
-0.0014298481,
0.0198225044,
-0.029440159,
0.0390429124,
0.008705915,
0.0280188415,
0.0084559433,
0.0238481443,
0.0141904065,
-0.0210372079,
-0.0597985499,
-0.0467435569,
-0.0246574227,
-0.0337421671,
-0.0253981035,
0.0316066444,
0.063520737,
0.0285414625,
0.0190543216,
-0.0211963058,
0.0224222187,
0.011430732,
-0.0165588167,
-0.0334101282,
0.0256469902,
0.0091985026,
-0.0671070218,
0.0494672097,
-0.0142031964,
0.0162114017,
0.0272765532,
-0.017884478,
0.0168736372,
0.0364914387,
-0.0091378288,
0.0024745949,
0.0208063275,
0.0180063024,
-0.0033485866,
-0.0035070656,
0.0472287871,
-0.0335435048,
-0.0665096641,
-0.0079505416,
0.0079211006,
0.0147793358,
0.039728146,
0.0081020277,
-0.0176644176,
0.011416805,
-0.0279066395,
0.0013869203,
-0.0044358997,
-0.0209321212,
0.0202112161,
-0.0130852722,
-0.0461454913,
-0.101346463,
-0.0197093133,
-0.0095706582,
0.0375377163,
-0.0169218984,
0.0327012353,
1.25369572e-34,
-0.0175665598,
-0.0207649693,
0.0229218397,
0.0789197832,
0.0263353121,
0.0321657322,
0.033972878,
-0.0006001894,
0.0553038865,
0.016263403,
-0.0385346301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17647v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17647v1 | Variationist: Exploring Multifaceted Variation and Bias in Written Language Data | 2024-06-25T15:41:07 | 2024-06-25T15:41:07 | Alan Ramponi, Camilla Casula, Stefano Menini | cs.CL | cs.CL | Exploring and understanding language data is a fundamental stage in all areas
dealing with human language. It allows NLP practitioners to uncover quality
concerns and harmful biases in data before training, and helps linguists and
social scientists to gain insight into language use and human behavior. Yet,
there is currently a lack of a unified, customizable tool to seamlessly inspect
and visualize language variation and bias across multiple variables, language
units, and diverse metrics that go beyond descriptive statistics. In this
paper, we introduce Variationist, a highly-modular, extensible, and
task-agnostic tool that fills this gap. Variationist handles at once a
potentially unlimited combination of variable types and semantics across
diversity and association metrics with regards to the language unit of choice,
and orchestrates the creation of up to five-dimensional interactive charts for
over 30 variable type-semantics combinations. Through our case studies on
computational dialectology, human label variation, and text generation, we show
how Variationist enables researchers from different disciplines to effortlessly
answer specific research questions or unveil undesired associations in language
data. A Python library, code, documentation, and tutorials are made publicly
available to the research community. | [
0.0099772941,
0.1126901284,
-0.0519387871,
0.0076595452,
-0.0335743837,
0.0143539635,
0.0160572138,
-0.0157431979,
-0.0061775311,
-0.0265450533,
0.0033157591,
-0.0197177734,
0.0396965183,
0.0560765453,
0.0286747441,
-0.064242363,
0.0418245345,
0.0294444542,
0.029006375,
0.0229830258,
0.0264994353,
0.0397438966,
-0.0169565976,
0.0445908047,
-0.0587831661,
-0.027115861,
-0.0087941736,
0.0092726853,
0.0413097814,
-0.0254123751,
0.0438211337,
0.0711932033,
-0.0201794989,
0.0308029894,
0.0000021604,
-0.0527968481,
-0.004078805,
-0.0254290849,
0.0037992212,
0.0137398429,
0.1156984717,
-0.0053891614,
-0.0034531674,
0.0198233277,
-0.0309159867,
-0.002912052,
0.0780918226,
0.0031632842,
0.024599541,
0.0046648877,
-0.0096471068,
0.0119525678,
-0.0667434856,
-0.0058189426,
0.0037291476,
0.055902943,
-0.0001634477,
-0.0437219776,
0.0062819482,
-0.0021609014,
-0.017439073,
0.0049812328,
-0.0093860636,
-0.0064049219,
-0.012307955,
0.0014669251,
-0.0390342288,
-0.0502581261,
0.0149610564,
0.0315552019,
0.0405504629,
-0.0350428447,
0.0124172652,
-0.0307777729,
0.0157679692,
0.0271962639,
-0.039121706,
0.0096365334,
0.0044807787,
-0.0175318401,
0.0159860607,
-0.002430476,
-0.0154968295,
0.0253232215,
-0.0025814269,
0.0227472018,
0.0347137824,
0.0090336604,
0.0159334764,
0.034687914,
-0.0120419143,
-0.0629330948,
0.0089671118,
-0.012988722,
-0.0700021535,
0.0039552068,
-0.020552624,
-0.0908234119,
0.0529415756,
-0.0090053929,
0.0527805537,
0.0022359884,
-0.0379363336,
-0.0331751592,
0.0678007156,
0.0257669501,
0.0105719585,
-0.0115342485,
-0.0030060618,
-0.0201311,
0.00381163,
-0.0353927538,
-0.0048333132,
-0.0618591681,
0.0218614377,
0.0504728332,
-0.0360060781,
-0.0083380854,
-0.0676568151,
-0.0099482909,
-0.0042764181,
0.04690082,
-0.0317598544,
0.0215611886,
-0.0378010944,
0.0378518701,
-0.0899940282,
0.0295215026,
-0.0127085568,
-0.0437125154,
0.0010460638,
0.0431030989,
0.0028010071,
-0.0449240878,
-0.014857254,
0.0015298181,
0.0095351236,
0.0060631246,
-0.0076126941,
-0.0341514423,
-0.0737481415,
-0.0190549958,
-0.03303013,
-0.0963981599,
0.0204511713,
0.0368605182,
-0.0000427575,
-0.0484731607,
-0.0180586576,
0.0266925171,
-0.034827359,
0.0219310615,
-0.0204965509,
-0.0074621029,
0.0285265222,
-0.0171126593,
0.0030978089,
0.0552779585,
0.0271108244,
-0.0117576849,
0.0417736731,
-0.0382655822,
-0.0239581484,
0.0233261772,
-0.0041269381,
0.0069237128,
-0.0713358745,
-0.0381513201,
-0.0254869647,
0.014546426,
0.0390028171,
0.0527332872,
-0.0089296689,
-0.0364202708,
0.0514973179,
0.0526288003,
0.0253312644,
-0.0121203968,
0.02512547,
0.0453856848,
-0.0038548494,
-0.0008164039,
0.0161027387,
0.0113632921,
0.0453315601,
-0.0042995852,
-0.0253138617,
0.0730857328,
0.0170302894,
-0.0480890498,
-0.0422183871,
0.0144705521,
0.029205475,
-0.0357249863,
-0.0022764916,
0.0267666802,
0.0372104533,
0.0510705896,
0.0592323728,
-0.066134803,
0.003124892,
0.0130792661,
0.0217155851,
0.0497686639,
0.0056077042,
-0.0199558455,
0.030289337,
-0.0254432298,
0.0188031346,
0.0826788396,
0.06058589,
-0.0098425988,
-0.0072517153,
-0.0449796841,
0.0013448985,
-0.0297011733,
0.0282194726,
0.0355054811,
0.0057035196,
0.0285078082,
-0.0083457828,
-0.0818261057,
-0.0243947487,
0.0322940089,
0.0105009051,
0.0151347984,
0.0335051529,
-0.0095759919,
0.009499873,
0.046623975,
-0.0237388331,
0.0340303332,
-0.0124045564,
-0.01511914,
0.0060177865,
0.055618111,
0.0213365871,
-0.0061357799,
0.023427153,
-0.0831537247,
-0.0358041525,
-0.0029453158,
-0.0036691658,
-0.0339149311,
0.038803149,
-0.0629651994,
0.0255148876,
-0.0184110049,
-0.033639323,
0.0002166548,
0.0441139936,
-0.0481088199,
0.0547108725,
0.0100433063,
0.0167629756,
0.0176894236,
0.0123169189,
0.0418244675,
0.0211883113,
0.0115378341,
0.0059290221,
-0.0126764849,
0.0027988411,
0.0424813144,
-0.0122896489,
-0.0681780055,
-0.0188824069,
-0.125356704,
-0.0008616657,
-0.0203503761,
0.0051729712,
0.013224991,
0.0017387185,
-0.0107897148,
0.0092142951,
-0.0242140703,
-0.0046266969,
0.0108660497,
0.0341410488,
0.0603421405,
-0.0464342088,
0.0290929787,
-0.0289675687,
0.0091657797,
-0.0317376964,
0.0333167799,
0.0233497247,
0.0331865363,
-0.0120272385,
-0.0338958763,
-0.0578644052,
-0.0567121692,
0.0215900559,
-0.02398411,
0.05284632,
0.0334641263,
0.1148019731,
0.0230471585,
0.0447097719,
0.0577564798,
0.0633214414,
-0.0319248885,
-0.0385580584,
-0.0251023546,
-0.0275716297,
0.0394297503,
0.0363854505,
-0.0681823939,
0.0057445923,
0.0896073729,
0.0633188188,
-0.0115524381,
-0.0461250059,
0.0544050559,
-0.0372588225,
-0.0163772088,
-0.0160527267,
0.0148647223,
-0.0406564474,
0.0484002642,
0.0061819288,
-0.0510833785,
0.0460805744,
0.0123339351,
0.0169820879,
-0.0327182524,
-0.0421727933,
-0.0296843816,
0.0532877482,
0.0030749233,
0.0122912247,
0.0018579122,
-0.0378912725,
-0.0567217954,
0.0262996592,
0.0398302115,
-0.0157724265,
0.035173811,
-0.0853289589,
-0.0194976572,
0.0057017412,
-0.0125960773,
-0.0257222503,
-0.0305062514,
-0.0139705967,
-0.0347441919,
0.0618497357,
-0.0438920446,
0.014597646,
-0.0496926121,
0.030506786,
0.016677361,
-0.0302560534,
0.0075361948,
-0.0012809674,
0.0062714065,
0.0465723686,
0.0360672027,
0.0100855241,
-0.0192986466,
-0.0287401807,
0.0436217599,
-0.0505202599,
0.0548345745,
-0.008844858,
0.023532765,
0.0007190396,
-0.0186904445,
-0.014141893,
0.0248035751,
0.0577859096,
-0.0190431233,
-0.0032970845,
0.0805718154,
0.032082215,
-0.0253732707,
0.0387313925,
-0.0686283186,
0.1109674349,
0.0246534515,
0.014256292,
-0.1043068394,
0.0029011073,
-0.0297429841,
0.0203599818,
-0.0374646075,
-0.0435431786,
-0.0225078389,
-0.0829179436,
0.0328940116,
0.0112681994,
-0.0527309924,
0.0424183793,
-0.0432502814,
-0.0004832386,
-0.0187154394,
0.0156175559,
-0.0264020413,
0.0170317385,
0.0290121716,
0.0385963842,
-0.0174175333,
-0.0509816855,
-0.0307245795,
-0.0311838258,
-0.0016885368,
-0.0091249347,
0.0528111979,
-0.036052987,
-0.0167529099,
0.0068871919,
-0.0032096172,
-0.0238715839,
-0.0073064435,
0.072942175,
0.0274074934,
-0.0284480322,
-0.0651622042,
0.0245587882,
-0.0116173327,
-0.0368755721,
-0.0042035379,
0.0435302667,
-0.0076878751,
-0.0070012258,
-0.0480861403,
-0.0036924605,
0.0088928742,
0.0577376038,
0.0530005023,
-0.0564286299,
-0.0041929828,
-0.0421687067,
0.0292036962,
-0.0383852497,
-0.0477768183,
0.0439976342,
0.0018198624,
-0.0768123567,
-0.0664748549,
-0.0454332083,
0.0239130463,
0.0072702146,
0.0115451431,
-0.0305059291,
0.0053958935,
-0.0405241065,
-0.0921955481,
0.0431968197,
0.0207328275,
0.0272661261,
0.0104258377,
-0.0632235855,
0.0039342172,
-0.0125879366,
-0.0101234261,
0.042924013,
-0.0982782468,
-0.0684482381,
0.0560513213,
-0.0078879623,
0.0152371163,
0.0285516698,
0.016001733,
-0.0535584614,
0.001816463,
0.0519730821,
0.0323498547,
0.0101838019,
-0.0434647687,
-0.0086961929,
0.0007765902,
-0.0092178965,
-0.0091677988,
0.0012530058,
-0.0268450547,
0.0133789768,
-0.0385486111,
-0.0144529985,
0.0144773666,
-0.040811047,
0.0033355928,
-0.0404607989,
-0.022073485,
-0.0644271076,
-0.0651125163,
-0.0360304043,
-0.0520465747,
-0.0078950562,
-0.0348311104,
0.011468594,
-0.0086097224,
-0.0406776443,
0.0224117227,
-0.0368252881,
0.045520559,
-0.0070393267,
0.0435381606,
-0.0039719646,
0.0591139942,
0.015484699,
0.0078863632,
-0.0053010411,
0.0442634262,
-0.0370611101,
0.0842681751,
0.0159445368,
0.0371500291,
0.0040663467,
-0.0167303868,
0.0342434421,
-0.0034226894,
-0.0282298848,
-0.0390065759,
0.011346315,
-0.0365844071,
-0.0018933163,
-0.0456390083,
0.0921281204,
-0.0301720109,
-0.0088699255,
-0.0128176985,
0.034659978,
0.012011447,
-0.0087275375,
0.0158395879,
-0.0025628989,
-0.0433763936,
-0.0282844771,
0.0637251586,
-0.0019671256,
0.0136227496,
-0.0351977386,
-0.0315185487,
-0.018144425,
-0.0147052091,
0.0296645164,
0.0322775468,
0.009513339,
-0.0073134839,
-0.0967418849,
-0.0700723976,
0.0059249778,
-0.0147907948,
0.0294784345,
-0.0007842144,
0.017231375,
0.0520120151,
-0.0231697671,
-0.0131980786,
-0.0208023507,
0.0243880972,
0.0030398841,
-0.0333985649,
-0.0361025222,
-6.696483484e-33,
-0.0304057356,
-0.1019662991,
-0.0279525742,
-0.0750388354,
-0.0033561238,
-0.0144951697,
-0.024175141,
0.048284024,
-0.0112971496,
0.0414833128,
0.0160102751,
0.0111724166,
0.0169498473,
0.019580869,
0.0669104978,
0.0087083774,
0.025560407,
0.0189480968,
-0.0113470424,
-0.0163207278,
0.0492277332,
-0.0162406284,
0.0750032738,
-0.0726421773,
0.0660719126,
0.0152343744,
-0.0041637658,
-0.0128081646,
0.0011611686,
0.0142397657,
-0.0000577182,
0.0764535144,
0.0232406221,
0.0025651401,
-0.0277060252,
-0.0028217472,
-0.0045013339,
-0.0953772813,
0.0124446414,
0.033834517,
-0.0043410249,
-0.0253679901,
0.0400316231,
-0.0066419472,
-0.0307020284,
0.0097831255,
0.0525618494,
0.0072803334,
0.0252144244,
0.0259737037,
-0.0455825292,
0.0316603892,
-0.0450718813,
0.0385822207,
-0.0278825387,
0.0078312326,
-0.0102341026,
0.0165544562,
-0.0385867991,
0.0503799655,
0.0308540277,
-0.0032036742,
0.0511492416,
0.013316174,
-0.0081964107,
0.0454665422,
0.0256909821,
0.0277833436,
0.0102525959,
0.0149671296,
0.0317824855,
0.0176211074,
0.0232139938,
0.0948631614,
0.018054001,
-0.0349539146,
0.0003341233,
-0.0014807594,
0.0467628017,
-0.0191368889,
-0.0339218974,
-0.0082646897,
-0.039548032,
-0.0486160591,
-0.0233048387,
-0.0465040319,
-0.0217778888,
-0.0270943549,
0.0369358025,
-0.0583141409,
-0.0001069356,
-0.0099451179,
-0.0019730101,
0.008215188,
-0.039190881,
0.0281022042,
-0.0475487113,
0.0175721627,
0.017866889,
0.0060328245,
-0.0273861121,
0.0087092016,
0.0068778987,
0.0238657389,
0.0543930195,
0.0198607426,
-0.0020830818,
-0.0187847912,
-0.0587567873,
0.0171909314,
0.0081066731,
-0.0217698794,
-0.0247542541,
0.0088403029,
0.0330494568,
0.0089921225,
-0.0187505521,
0.0342309587,
0.0566396192,
0.0085914284,
-0.0437444597,
-0.0472757816,
-0.0313764364,
0.0165666547,
-0.0100682136,
-0.0156649947,
-0.0131292362,
-0.0255528912,
0.0662664324,
-0.0283234734,
0.001172713,
-0.0569250658,
2.8e-7,
0.0525891632,
0.0829609782,
-0.0095907431,
0.0502250344,
0.0212496743,
0.0201285854,
0.0280167293,
0.0128301848,
-0.0210848711,
-0.0242606625,
-0.0178712439,
-0.0071375524,
0.0593619868,
0.078987658,
-0.0232700165,
-0.0080174115,
-0.038425941,
-0.0046463227,
-0.0790308341,
0.0201041978,
0.0761823952,
0.0448438339,
0.0154010756,
0.0125550842,
-0.0027681803,
0.0183667298,
0.0304865036,
-0.0255172085,
0.000336504,
0.011356052,
0.0134364236,
-0.0443874486,
0.0311809629,
0.0070975632,
-0.031476371,
-0.0144501664,
-0.0052188328,
0.0213218145,
0.0053301798,
-0.0069697201,
-0.006223035,
-0.007169087,
-0.0110056363,
-0.0801482126,
0.0328545533,
0.0303200092,
-0.0161372833,
-0.0317195579,
0.0109422691,
0.0117676184,
0.0518501215,
-0.0463701449,
-0.0293667968,
0.0036835494,
0.0165660251,
0.0056857569,
-0.0320311077,
-0.0155395204,
-0.0624818355,
0.0247769151,
-0.0234865788,
-0.0329165086,
-0.0089146253,
0.0386097096,
0.0190301742,
-0.0173810963,
0.0241864044,
2.711625547e-34,
0.0339374058,
0.0119184293,
0.0352355316,
-0.0149547746,
0.0609359555,
-0.0097238049,
-0.0065265931,
0.0321616493,
0.0317476988,
-0.0189143587,
-0.026143115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17642v1 | Banishing LLM Hallucinations Requires Rethinking Generalization | 2024-06-25T15:31:01 | 2024-06-25T15:31:01 | Johnny Li, Saksham Consul, Eda Zhou, James Wong, Naila Farooqui, Yuxin Ye, Nithyashree Manohar, Zhuxiaona Wei, Tian Wu, Ben Echols, Sharon Zhou, Gregory Diamos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite their powerful chat, coding, and reasoning abilities, Large Language
Models (LLMs) frequently hallucinate. Conventional wisdom suggests that
hallucinations are a consequence of a balance between creativity and
factuality, which can be mitigated, but not eliminated, by grounding the LLM in
external knowledge sources. Through extensive systematic experiments, we show
that these traditional approaches fail to explain why LLMs hallucinate in
practice. Specifically, we show that LLMs augmented with a massive Mixture of
Memory Experts (MoME) can easily memorize large datasets of random numbers. We
corroborate these experimental findings with a theoretical construction showing
that simple neural networks trained to predict the next token hallucinate when
the training loss is above a threshold as it usually does in practice when
training on internet scale data. We interpret our findings by comparing against
traditional retrieval methods for mitigating hallucinations. We use our
findings to design a first generation model for removing hallucinations --
Lamini-1 -- that stores facts in a massive mixture of millions of memory
experts that are retrieved dynamically. | [
0.0063720397,
0.076482214,
-0.0311836377,
0.0300194249,
-0.0202681404,
0.0020635398,
-0.0304014683,
0.0218647607,
-0.0078918608,
-0.0131092006,
-0.0401335992,
-0.0618341826,
0.0037447701,
-0.0091330316,
0.0227005091,
-0.0131437536,
0.0405968167,
-0.0522313453,
0.0236879997,
-0.0233793706,
-0.0123402476,
-0.0069627138,
0.0060313437,
0.0364275798,
-0.0097686779,
-0.0123493103,
0.0017315237,
-0.0157541577,
-0.0191846974,
0.0000513352,
0.0096284617,
0.0430173837,
0.0182079412,
0.0406882428,
0.000002103,
-0.0322698653,
0.0146176713,
-0.0357910842,
-0.0368012674,
-0.0029955183,
-0.0082230298,
0.0037560768,
-0.0001374093,
-0.0047791516,
-0.039848648,
-0.0130322399,
0.0391225442,
0.0684159026,
0.0593386926,
0.0778365061,
0.0132788755,
-0.0457053818,
0.0805976763,
0.0185497422,
0.0762622505,
0.0107165547,
0.0347536914,
0.0295711271,
-0.0197993722,
-0.0437987559,
0.0000016981,
0.0297587942,
0.0211757161,
0.0329441242,
0.0206365641,
0.0433188751,
-0.0935420021,
-0.0299676582,
-0.0172203667,
0.058963567,
-0.0331533253,
-0.0524008349,
0.0203876123,
0.0334027931,
0.0200800113,
-0.0092948526,
-0.0636300072,
0.0515563712,
-0.0186291821,
0.0001997804,
-0.0217600483,
0.0000244197,
0.0811939165,
-0.0018643739,
-0.04707269,
0.0401201323,
0.0014172124,
-0.0404692218,
0.0179784093,
-0.0040770993,
-0.0070266463,
-0.0304956473,
0.0159413274,
0.0219861269,
-0.0263880417,
0.0138087384,
-0.0207953285,
0.0037812174,
0.0248737447,
-0.0984134823,
0.0048951083,
0.0224184226,
-0.0249245092,
0.0439237691,
-0.0429535359,
0.0062293261,
-0.0288142674,
0.0668304786,
0.0257171672,
0.0024870376,
-0.0676332712,
-0.0293007307,
-0.0156109659,
0.0499191992,
0.0479853898,
-0.0274832174,
-0.0142826391,
0.0121173114,
-0.0348507091,
0.0308136586,
-0.0441201627,
0.0385338925,
0.0335647017,
-0.0307769068,
-0.0276789963,
0.0061514894,
-0.0070438394,
-0.0104276203,
0.0397920534,
-0.0827874392,
-0.0263351779,
0.0033096396,
-0.0117001152,
0.0164009333,
0.0140152881,
0.070884712,
0.0057671368,
-0.021011401,
-0.0632882789,
-0.0343425572,
-0.0014233858,
-0.0599677525,
0.0269972328,
-0.0502266958,
0.0337185375,
-0.0021686172,
-0.0106454818,
-0.0483012795,
0.0183842648,
0.0244100001,
-0.0599135682,
0.0604478642,
-0.0023839371,
-0.0038358138,
0.0541948155,
0.0448743403,
-0.0219299812,
0.0535503589,
0.0177851059,
0.0087738791,
0.0194150545,
-0.0072887144,
0.0568821914,
0.0184771176,
0.0294224024,
-0.0214038081,
-0.0435633957,
0.0009369896,
0.0328103192,
0.0218837596,
0.0159836709,
0.0679231435,
-0.0390800349,
-0.0355199948,
0.0950049236,
0.0275764409,
-0.0338073038,
0.053720884,
0.0134265171,
-0.0137083177,
0.02358458,
0.0202439427,
-0.0718837455,
0.0362590365,
-0.0261556655,
0.0143840015,
0.0699487701,
-0.0024498419,
-0.0474876203,
-0.019293474,
-0.0063082045,
-0.0099160681,
0.0063422131,
0.0242447965,
0.0189812891,
0.0120723331,
-0.0407415517,
0.105310075,
0.0212525222,
-0.0196178835,
0.0003699028,
-0.0570218191,
0.0107480008,
0.0658193976,
0.0509282202,
-0.0188330952,
-0.0023683801,
-0.0288277548,
0.0261756275,
0.0260947756,
0.0313751101,
0.0128275696,
0.0257571805,
-0.0655530468,
0.0416023619,
-0.0077194944,
0.0433982685,
0.0020472279,
0.000502389,
-0.0038963915,
-0.0038532307,
-0.01892736,
-0.0314890184,
0.0191849638,
-0.0388205796,
-0.0337856151,
-0.0208454542,
-0.0211571399,
0.0143574933,
-0.0110103134,
-0.0183157958,
0.0394586958,
0.0206828509,
-0.040796496,
-0.0592875779,
-0.0097956527,
-0.0611071028,
0.0022647772,
0.030479731,
0.0005525512,
0.016660491,
-0.0194695704,
0.0044881711,
-0.0279177018,
0.0465908349,
-0.0643122792,
0.0846927688,
-0.0333135463,
0.0352570862,
0.0065798946,
0.0446546152,
0.0157230552,
0.0784094334,
-0.0410397053,
0.0072103259,
0.0201493315,
0.0050397734,
-0.0024757951,
-0.0377877951,
-0.0056522973,
0.0168094523,
-0.0074792011,
0.0483580008,
-0.0067873434,
-0.0670720264,
-0.058296144,
-0.0280416925,
-0.0764869004,
0.0034633861,
-0.0232588574,
-0.0242041256,
0.0126358001,
-0.0318095796,
-0.0026356166,
-0.0123471199,
-0.0382237583,
0.0142648267,
-0.0136865377,
0.0481746942,
0.0106150666,
0.0090748761,
-0.0300385095,
-0.0214438699,
-0.0064707245,
-0.0034700688,
0.0597648174,
-0.0335462689,
-0.0245262459,
-0.0474763289,
0.0132907815,
-0.0649649277,
0.0064917761,
-0.0244076326,
0.0011065141,
0.0176026449,
-0.0435260683,
0.0425499938,
0.0908655226,
0.0169977378,
-0.0224251561,
0.0553336889,
-0.0302094184,
-0.0457296148,
-0.0148540437,
0.0057611424,
-0.0233442299,
-0.0026217052,
-0.0180960465,
-0.0110801132,
0.0483584851,
0.0270808972,
0.031503208,
-0.0489598885,
0.0473325886,
-0.0016837742,
-0.0437611528,
-0.0215040278,
-0.0146159912,
-0.0310030766,
0.0376655012,
-0.0240842365,
-0.0622854792,
0.0796478391,
0.0063930615,
-0.0025035448,
0.0113782622,
-0.0148665626,
-0.004813713,
0.0145742232,
-0.009141597,
-0.0041902228,
-0.0066719009,
-0.0189910997,
-0.0630320087,
-0.0361755081,
-0.0345622078,
-0.0572038181,
0.0347960442,
-0.0216428451,
0.0022270367,
0.0256109666,
-0.0444639102,
-0.0669690296,
-0.0183998644,
-0.0229914859,
-0.0044102906,
-0.0183086358,
-0.0000898934,
-0.0468350612,
-0.031040594,
0.0376212932,
0.0124483602,
-0.0125807403,
-0.0337857306,
0.0222697686,
0.0086144889,
0.0402321182,
-0.0082658418,
0.0398098342,
-0.0362727679,
0.0349646024,
0.0814491808,
0.0322442427,
0.0172573645,
-0.0221349355,
-0.0018532401,
0.0056625945,
-0.0040294784,
-0.0215879567,
0.0350817479,
0.0246479139,
-0.0573704727,
-0.0312258415,
0.0969337597,
0.0242004283,
-0.0672437847,
-0.0108114211,
-0.0291472841,
0.0518224686,
0.0059051798,
-0.0094970847,
-0.0512273014,
-0.0106437728,
0.0051464899,
-0.0029624095,
-0.0151170427,
-0.0256249979,
-0.0044997148,
-0.0814094916,
-0.0105262473,
0.0409995653,
-0.0220602062,
-0.0094041629,
-0.021149056,
-0.0345061384,
0.0155065469,
0.0485139005,
0.012964379,
0.0096656419,
-0.0255382825,
-0.0034143168,
-0.0432223864,
-0.0078303888,
0.0503267907,
-0.0211986881,
0.077502571,
0.0645428374,
0.0196008869,
-0.0052460046,
-0.0775699392,
0.0306005068,
0.000948324,
0.0064826892,
0.0166688934,
0.0681424662,
0.0160848219,
0.001929155,
0.0085292049,
0.0287128892,
-0.048014123,
-0.0213075653,
0.0048641078,
0.0612315945,
-0.0330143683,
-0.0581526645,
-0.004592211,
0.0350471586,
-0.0028797353,
0.0725885108,
0.0254148897,
-0.0200613067,
-0.0391420759,
-0.039875187,
0.0249525048,
-0.0176912639,
-0.0543431975,
0.0340531766,
0.0761759952,
-0.019834213,
-0.0656353086,
-0.0294722058,
-0.0040633073,
0.018366091,
0.0070051295,
0.0123677114,
-0.0128045911,
0.0069714859,
-0.0131773399,
0.0249349307,
-0.0463316962,
-0.028097352,
-0.0338385664,
0.0240466632,
0.0191289335,
-0.0289437044,
0.0243926272,
0.0153866149,
-0.0928305835,
-0.0797464103,
0.026539024,
0.0582476147,
0.0328693613,
0.0441280492,
0.0087343324,
-0.0657137483,
0.0696106851,
0.0492606908,
-0.0541605763,
0.01061159,
0.0221121646,
0.024761904,
0.0255812556,
0.0397333242,
-0.0259965099,
0.0063604135,
0.0199027639,
0.0015883819,
-0.0234633908,
0.0413609929,
0.0401523262,
-0.0154937515,
-0.0069593284,
0.0049975086,
0.0097954199,
-0.0013335164,
0.0149066048,
-0.00136322,
0.0109292082,
-0.0068310793,
-0.0013802176,
0.0370048173,
-0.0131516531,
-0.0020996968,
-0.034880612,
0.0134557579,
0.0045760372,
0.01749002,
-0.0509446971,
0.0084113562,
-0.0021253035,
0.0538268499,
-0.0177691225,
-0.0572175533,
0.0377033055,
-0.018250294,
0.0511983894,
-0.0098920334,
0.0594879575,
-0.0071079265,
-0.0163847394,
-0.0255242959,
0.007843079,
-0.068100132,
-0.1284424812,
0.02505555,
0.0423422195,
0.056278266,
0.0030130476,
0.0042153564,
-0.0341398604,
0.0203901436,
-0.0304699615,
-0.0117097571,
0.0242371876,
-0.0188307818,
-0.0259039085,
0.0264550615,
-0.0500280075,
-0.0066795968,
0.0613240115,
-0.0323241465,
0.0340071954,
-0.0040211347,
-0.0068802065,
-0.0267484616,
-0.0376030914,
-0.0123125091,
0.0217561703,
-0.0184189845,
-0.0340188555,
-0.0512882993,
-0.0663126335,
-0.0012164405,
0.0048897602,
0.0237059556,
-0.0233896449,
-0.0012178241,
0.0566454232,
-0.0205346029,
0.0180275217,
-0.0031550939,
0.0180481691,
0.0196881704,
0.0099274581,
-0.0425179489,
-6.878929024e-33,
0.0387589149,
0.0026133975,
0.0332155898,
-0.0279619042,
0.0084055979,
-0.0154017992,
-0.0251771454,
0.0248589367,
-0.0383043624,
-0.0139509616,
-0.0230400302,
0.0400062688,
0.0123206852,
0.0193478949,
0.0285590924,
-0.0464616865,
0.0317545719,
-0.0100185415,
-0.0124599524,
0.0369621553,
0.0625102073,
0.0337067954,
0.0474417657,
-0.0662762448,
0.0364034362,
-0.018944351,
0.0015644091,
0.0151676042,
-0.0115184225,
0.0236853641,
-0.0412992463,
0.0469923094,
0.0116020907,
-0.0196455345,
-0.0367390476,
0.0001158769,
-0.0119969295,
-0.0235942136,
-0.0048161163,
0.0145922238,
0.0158337895,
-0.0272416044,
0.0727774203,
-0.0388151444,
0.0061278963,
-0.0074375356,
0.0204335507,
-0.0328808539,
-0.0633593053,
0.0145669356,
-0.0177183487,
-0.0098689031,
0.0134292319,
0.0068220333,
-0.0197875742,
-0.0005503771,
-0.0196837224,
-0.0119084902,
-0.1136137843,
0.0330453962,
-0.0337107033,
0.0023231364,
0.029713152,
-0.0040905494,
0.0190406032,
0.0972536802,
0.0903109089,
0.0549101233,
-0.0481310189,
-0.0257933047,
0.0337670483,
0.0497307181,
0.0407070071,
-0.0055051241,
0.0933358446,
-0.0369348712,
-0.0370230414,
-0.0367952958,
-0.0052305455,
0.0133227259,
0.07833606,
-0.0039742626,
-0.0546515621,
-0.0551752113,
0.0028439099,
0.0351752117,
-0.0477394462,
-0.0353906564,
0.0198826939,
0.0210852697,
0.0155597702,
-0.0405647494,
0.0293396097,
-0.0557875112,
0.0271223783,
0.0408548526,
-0.0144074215,
-0.0023687386,
-0.0121505829,
-0.0111935912,
-0.0362255648,
-0.0158410426,
-0.0195240453,
0.0129786329,
0.020821983,
0.0437664688,
0.0435925536,
0.0113237211,
-0.0557709895,
-0.0194412582,
-0.0532590039,
0.0166813675,
0.0263189711,
0.0036451388,
0.0452560633,
0.0087331384,
-0.0115310829,
-0.0158962272,
0.0150730843,
0.0128100486,
-0.0108525222,
0.0267448891,
-0.0201225001,
0.0078684902,
-0.0135755958,
-0.0217626262,
-0.0612862632,
-0.0078934282,
0.0317859612,
-0.0712701157,
0.0044173268,
-0.0136973793,
2.872e-7,
-0.0313469172,
0.040686015,
-0.0063335267,
0.0152073577,
0.0293071009,
0.0159910973,
-0.0164426509,
0.0122725405,
0.0229455102,
-0.0805295035,
-0.014713753,
0.0518012494,
0.0564618036,
0.062219616,
-0.1100767851,
-0.0258377176,
-0.0660861656,
-0.0010490078,
-0.0495676175,
-0.0431121849,
0.0196739137,
0.0778787062,
0.0404218324,
-0.0248570312,
0.0229567029,
-0.0957703069,
0.0982067883,
-0.0138162766,
0.0156286582,
0.0180200059,
0.0625414178,
0.0427555442,
-0.020394763,
0.025766883,
-0.0033516104,
-0.0218093786,
-0.0267420169,
0.0306423977,
0.0081166541,
-0.0639264509,
-0.018548945,
-0.0134553779,
0.0017478711,
-0.028860515,
0.0510729402,
-0.0456211492,
-0.042273365,
0.0090607107,
0.0047845398,
-0.0211422723,
0.0473972298,
0.0065145497,
-0.0068052937,
0.011985586,
-0.0183023959,
0.0375009477,
0.0352189057,
-0.0822376311,
-0.0245981365,
0.0202004183,
-0.055620376,
-0.0529842675,
-0.0245088711,
0.001012471,
0.0132074533,
-0.049443014,
0.03464026,
2.685309397e-34,
0.0400599241,
-0.0167173296,
0.0394766405,
0.053995084,
0.0257029701,
-0.0066775326,
0.0557594895,
0.0187180955,
0.0277404804,
-0.0414204821,
-0.0117426021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17639v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17639v2 | Mitigate the Gap: Investigating Approaches for Improving Cross-Modal Alignment in CLIP | 2024-06-25T15:24:02 | 2024-06-26T10:58:48 | Sedigheh Eslami, Gerard de Melo | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Contrastive Language--Image Pre-training (CLIP) has manifested remarkable
improvements in zero-shot classification and cross-modal vision-language tasks.
Yet, from a geometrical point of view, the CLIP embedding space has been found
to have a pronounced modality gap. This gap renders the embedding space overly
sparse and disconnected, with different modalities being densely distributed in
distinct subregions of the hypersphere. In this work, we aim at answering two
main questions: 1. Does sharing the parameter space between the multi-modal
encoders reduce the modality gap? 2. Can the gap be mitigated by pushing apart
the uni-modal embeddings via intra-modality separation? We design AlignCLIP, in
order to answer these questions and show that answers to both questions are
positive. Through extensive experiments, we show that AlignCLIP achieves
noticeable enhancements in the cross-modal alignment of the embeddings, and
thereby, reduces the modality gap, while maintaining the performance across
several downstream evaluations, such as zero-shot image classification,
zero-shot multi-modal retrieval and zero-shot semantic text similarity. | [
-0.0385551527,
0.0596274622,
0.0174322389,
0.0479889624,
-0.0407168791,
-0.0116671007,
0.0372345001,
-0.0024257761,
-0.0847810134,
-0.0456418023,
-0.0974812731,
-0.0301979128,
0.0268390886,
0.043064326,
0.0218666587,
-0.0384460986,
0.031360928,
0.0069858483,
-0.0323454365,
-0.0017686174,
0.0290400553,
-0.0052949926,
-0.0257307515,
0.0199684966,
0.0036295031,
-0.0019730926,
-0.0294742957,
-0.0015691692,
0.0352342241,
-0.0121283419,
-0.0164365172,
0.0390502028,
0.049158439,
0.0193275958,
0.0000017254,
0.0013124774,
0.0312345549,
0.0222930945,
0.0078272186,
-0.0073232423,
0.0506880023,
-0.0704233125,
0.0219613705,
-0.0158485677,
-0.007182104,
-0.0727281347,
0.0836183429,
0.0420200564,
0.0283044726,
0.0684457496,
-0.0474121086,
-0.0069144736,
0.0114890467,
-0.0317668766,
0.013360993,
0.0141401645,
-0.0063610515,
-0.0131583717,
-0.011245166,
0.0295590311,
-0.0584094077,
0.0416524298,
0.0077565382,
0.0232001618,
-0.0259166081,
0.0500517413,
-0.0241083819,
-0.0267690085,
-0.0290659219,
0.0949219167,
-0.0106874183,
-0.0114301611,
-0.041837506,
0.0007325968,
-0.00086188,
0.0300708078,
-0.0265162718,
0.0320459008,
0.0244021583,
0.044695951,
-0.03434534,
0.0306259412,
0.0163353849,
-0.0359617285,
0.0056366157,
-0.0304381419,
0.0406714156,
-0.0007257436,
-0.0274103321,
0.0194089003,
-0.0019978331,
-0.0250917617,
-0.0079758419,
0.0008486866,
0.0000735644,
-0.0245760344,
-0.0759449452,
-0.0078828214,
-0.0059187911,
0.0268387664,
0.0522572659,
0.052849628,
-0.0591201894,
0.0538148619,
-0.0289978106,
0.0237785541,
-0.0240088962,
0.0776509121,
-0.0357540213,
-0.0180679411,
-0.0118762981,
-0.0069658929,
0.0074811801,
-0.0131244045,
-0.0502359457,
-0.0504870638,
-0.0082779713,
0.0008043845,
-0.0221452639,
0.0082876114,
-0.0088311043,
0.0179733112,
-0.0401923321,
-0.0284525082,
0.0100283548,
0.0730512962,
0.0012608856,
0.0551451072,
-0.0351434238,
-0.0372609049,
-0.0203445069,
0.0526568741,
0.0203496255,
-0.0257803034,
-0.0142848007,
0.0728635937,
-0.0495614596,
-0.0442570746,
0.0022620703,
0.0090734316,
-0.0357887968,
-0.0346338376,
0.0362764001,
-0.0294065382,
0.0469270237,
0.0117988633,
-0.0309870094,
-0.0091933133,
-0.0106329229,
-0.0166995898,
-0.008110282,
0.1020955145,
0.0064513329,
-0.0211410709,
-0.0070400382,
0.0012796947,
-0.0069025084,
0.0590572469,
0.0035462275,
-0.0096334815,
0.0123512624,
0.0293249171,
-0.0115101244,
0.0330005176,
0.0211376082,
0.0202157367,
-0.0728411749,
-0.0245802421,
0.0125097642,
0.0204258673,
0.0602327883,
0.0049933204,
-0.054967884,
-0.0399544723,
0.0316789411,
0.0326724201,
0.0173130818,
-0.0046901917,
0.0219339263,
0.0175266825,
-0.0337174907,
-0.0027797038,
-0.0384936109,
0.0174345244,
-0.0151312314,
0.0160890985,
0.0196626522,
0.0434932336,
-0.0560308546,
-0.0057721529,
0.0201952122,
-0.0269327164,
0.0030975419,
-0.0159143154,
0.0701473728,
-0.0307311248,
-0.0292179994,
0.0559089296,
0.0428476445,
-0.0490898564,
0.0182474349,
0.0062592514,
-0.0244459249,
-0.0185294412,
-0.0161262266,
-0.0125969099,
-0.0509348623,
0.0226365011,
-0.0040295455,
0.0463774018,
-0.0073227626,
-0.0104336049,
0.0514022037,
-0.0491175167,
-0.0851776898,
-0.0558605157,
-0.0056714993,
0.0283110458,
-0.0253865905,
0.0323616676,
0.0193104409,
-0.0172057934,
0.0750669241,
0.0211886466,
0.021452792,
0.022209499,
-0.0428448319,
0.046859514,
0.0251131803,
-0.0140446294,
-0.0436034687,
-0.0090486361,
0.0102552297,
-0.058346618,
0.0207595453,
0.0376248993,
-0.0592223555,
-0.0679617897,
0.0487529859,
-0.0928893909,
0.0204165559,
0.0251019541,
-0.0211431533,
-0.0437157676,
0.017382184,
0.018042773,
0.0578181446,
-0.040784575,
0.0014284182,
-0.0215418153,
0.0051033134,
0.0001615389,
0.024790952,
-0.0009528975,
0.0040954063,
0.0582801402,
0.0420164354,
0.0536888503,
0.0304152556,
-0.0372393616,
0.0139024835,
-0.0084945075,
0.0217858925,
0.0199216772,
0.0007994167,
-0.02566614,
-0.0081371209,
-0.1193065345,
-0.0080174049,
-0.0148731787,
0.0263969321,
0.0354380086,
-0.0046094768,
-0.0142147997,
-0.051850684,
-0.0390518717,
0.0149865923,
0.0131800817,
0.011824565,
0.0169000402,
0.0326341726,
0.0074252663,
0.0033035949,
0.0001010978,
0.0221270025,
0.0517623201,
-0.0245807152,
-0.0016546332,
-0.0221003536,
0.0615608431,
-0.0246052332,
0.0209080819,
-0.027069129,
-0.0287440643,
-0.0003372667,
-0.0079600317,
0.0474515595,
0.0250381455,
-0.0291349534,
0.0056566927,
0.0448757075,
-0.0112827858,
-0.0442839265,
-0.0214474164,
0.0051852488,
-0.0036950533,
-0.0232610498,
0.0405032039,
-0.0327294879,
0.0441114902,
-0.0272428989,
0.0233329032,
-0.0650217161,
0.00820232,
0.0113350376,
-0.0186860319,
-0.0440514423,
0.0213731341,
-0.0132435989,
0.023297796,
-0.0454929173,
-0.044266656,
0.0339690261,
-0.041044604,
-0.0206199531,
-0.0134049924,
0.0014202569,
-0.0078383023,
0.0399076827,
-0.0175280962,
0.0289367251,
0.0126097053,
-0.0454452224,
-0.0679962486,
0.0004919369,
0.0098423809,
0.0109295491,
0.0479493141,
0.0122736013,
0.004682939,
-0.0637919605,
-0.0532379374,
-0.0136397351,
-0.0689247921,
-0.0136089809,
0.0086247046,
-0.0303243883,
-0.0047433032,
-0.0459596701,
0.0127593046,
0.013155832,
0.0306392219,
-0.0393132642,
0.0139670474,
-0.0181556959,
0.0828776211,
0.0118026072,
0.0117809158,
-0.0350550562,
-0.0265529603,
-0.0437973142,
0.037058983,
0.0225244593,
0.0295129288,
-0.0249308515,
0.0222718772,
0.0513255671,
0.0511683859,
-0.0250913613,
0.0208010599,
0.0780705512,
-0.0008559499,
0.0024786326,
0.0622095391,
-0.0089675123,
-0.0859280974,
-0.0517675839,
0.0052966457,
0.0490082465,
0.014804557,
-0.0032948232,
-0.0584728345,
-0.0629200339,
-0.0175173171,
-0.0392427742,
0.0473558158,
0.0431267694,
-0.0220088121,
-0.0889828652,
0.0085395025,
0.0117562944,
-0.0431505479,
-0.054493174,
-0.0192243513,
0.0288482662,
0.0012887334,
0.0104733463,
-0.0407093987,
-0.0213281699,
-0.0194426645,
0.0071254144,
0.074358955,
-0.0901874527,
-0.0319769345,
-0.0335274339,
0.0169721991,
-0.0072968397,
0.0233053956,
-0.0204657484,
-0.082235001,
0.0046938276,
-0.019119883,
0.0021391944,
0.0183577817,
0.0551617593,
-0.035553012,
-0.0238939933,
0.001045435,
0.025130393,
-0.0252778828,
-0.0180769414,
-0.0527519658,
0.0484943874,
0.0000927818,
0.0411735103,
-0.0182747673,
0.0191110037,
0.0060213213,
0.0380194783,
0.0001810073,
-0.0032544944,
-0.0049557439,
0.015690418,
0.0194637254,
-0.0166371688,
-0.0186323114,
0.0067690779,
0.0061337436,
0.0132287936,
-0.0135297831,
-0.0228270032,
-0.0046009263,
0.0581945479,
-0.0084137972,
-0.0571497492,
-0.0448038951,
0.008500481,
-0.0541474372,
0.0583553314,
-0.0391258188,
0.0062084682,
-0.0169656388,
0.0304273181,
0.0325197726,
-0.0191924367,
-0.0280560274,
-0.0253190193,
-0.0730732977,
-0.0642375797,
-0.0563617758,
0.0208327919,
0.0026956305,
0.0817733407,
0.0297749136,
0.0080921147,
0.1050247028,
0.0215158109,
0.0019388223,
0.0158339422,
0.0423012413,
-0.0620292015,
0.0026105461,
0.0194229428,
-0.0368654206,
-0.0059942184,
0.0305879246,
0.0030766437,
0.0282508414,
-0.0419930965,
0.0156906508,
-0.0443436168,
0.0723844618,
-0.0238593202,
0.0582260676,
-0.0477235764,
-0.0137036694,
-0.0300151203,
-0.0000162327,
-0.0325527526,
-0.0138026997,
0.0038915323,
-0.0195966661,
0.0222706664,
0.0791600421,
-0.0022303665,
0.0300996397,
-0.0339520462,
0.0311019309,
0.034643732,
-0.0190042052,
-0.0210639704,
0.0442091823,
0.0018870138,
0.0079767127,
0.0007065999,
0.018842414,
-0.0554482304,
0.0814388841,
0.0337239318,
-0.0120972525,
-0.0577831231,
0.0759395361,
-0.0158049539,
0.0299266335,
-0.0152446134,
0.0054162131,
0.0488435179,
-0.0293324981,
0.018193474,
0.0079637598,
-0.0323745348,
0.0021408091,
0.042896226,
-0.0241623893,
-0.0050471555,
0.0578787513,
0.0009348898,
-0.0096720019,
0.0163510256,
0.0631262735,
-0.038823124,
0.0054998044,
0.0011774797,
0.0156902149,
-0.0180570614,
-0.000500961,
0.0854855552,
0.0233423151,
-0.0276918821,
-0.0136380335,
-0.0120774005,
-0.0479865409,
0.0122420006,
0.0185360797,
-0.0521467477,
0.0384397618,
0.0328463912,
0.0367087126,
0.0018958884,
-0.0137434052,
0.0110870386,
-0.0251569767,
0.017685147,
0.0239035077,
-0.0085762432,
-5.573221857e-33,
-0.0256085712,
0.0368373692,
0.0115707954,
-0.0387414619,
-0.0423778333,
0.0537800118,
-0.0181444362,
0.0154226655,
-0.0113003692,
0.0184387788,
0.0332004838,
-0.0062822108,
0.0160430949,
0.0390450731,
-0.0008171508,
0.0064430479,
0.0413918383,
-0.0102685783,
-0.029012898,
-0.0108799273,
0.0245962646,
0.0055739349,
0.05399023,
-0.0428803153,
0.0018427934,
0.0149367992,
0.0036762438,
0.0130965644,
0.0671936199,
0.0649371073,
-0.024516141,
0.0259664543,
0.0112867439,
-0.0101088518,
-0.0176006146,
0.0339136198,
-0.0356823541,
-0.0283251014,
0.001741944,
0.0276473481,
-0.0602493323,
-0.0200153999,
0.0257274769,
-0.0333458744,
-0.0159992352,
-0.0589568801,
0.0464580394,
0.0110184411,
0.0023545609,
0.0205121431,
-0.052829992,
0.0128830811,
-0.0126599772,
-0.0499222316,
0.0616903827,
0.0610179938,
0.0610297769,
0.0186339095,
-0.0497220159,
0.0347156413,
-0.0340494253,
0.0198141132,
0.0733155161,
0.0579642057,
0.0177070536,
0.0739013627,
0.0074229268,
-0.0693868026,
0.0065039136,
-0.0305771641,
0.0485739261,
-0.0042903489,
-0.0186992902,
0.1028881669,
0.0623428375,
0.0161590949,
-0.0311180558,
0.0262424909,
-0.0500212014,
0.0105764158,
0.0005444593,
0.0458571687,
0.0080700861,
-0.0095743416,
-0.0293612815,
-0.0703542829,
-0.0357648805,
-0.0496190637,
0.0173471663,
0.0216391031,
0.0013194714,
0.0376476459,
0.0980772451,
-0.019211242,
0.0060804402,
0.0366580375,
-0.0278525539,
0.0500884429,
-0.0142295128,
0.0066288975,
-0.0444367081,
-0.0343645699,
0.0574803688,
-0.0099755805,
-0.0011121389,
-0.0056890356,
0.0495224372,
0.0309867896,
-0.0445392467,
-0.0221862923,
-0.0197773017,
-0.0572133362,
0.0074664969,
0.0623514913,
0.0595590174,
0.0296105538,
-0.0242033768,
0.0445410535,
0.0168413352,
0.018812092,
-0.0181368534,
-0.0565546863,
0.0065363846,
0.0142197218,
0.0084845219,
0.0232500508,
-0.0742770284,
-0.0303730797,
0.0178647302,
-0.0532456487,
-0.0280069858,
0.0083239395,
2.459e-7,
0.0130659891,
-0.0084771095,
0.031610284,
-0.0511874594,
0.0147916786,
0.0444585867,
-0.019112708,
0.0388957188,
-0.0145226419,
-0.0447655842,
0.0132945431,
0.0263134819,
0.0243445784,
0.0110545075,
-0.0070011695,
0.037962798,
-0.0456370153,
-0.018213978,
-0.0179987308,
0.0313441157,
0.0799404159,
0.1200528219,
-0.0261917245,
-0.0001989109,
0.0165534727,
-0.0268511213,
0.0870764926,
-0.0261701103,
-0.0175312441,
-0.0034413817,
-0.0580840744,
0.0162428692,
-0.0175801367,
0.0062654321,
0.0058208178,
0.0294847451,
0.0311988685,
0.0279564075,
-0.0228268877,
-0.0281509738,
-0.0306715705,
0.0514018051,
-0.0450681709,
-0.0187798254,
0.0672516897,
-0.0864263177,
-0.0422943011,
-0.0839109868,
-0.0463791043,
0.0356538855,
0.0255331546,
-0.008371246,
-0.0319680385,
0.0169737004,
0.0314646251,
-0.0157443136,
-0.0449555777,
-0.0625920817,
-0.0232636333,
0.0357444957,
-0.0345050767,
0.0147421611,
-0.0229547806,
-0.0629998818,
0.0754748657,
-0.0446874835,
-0.018999543,
1.802984141e-34,
-0.0259150993,
-0.019212367,
0.0230517201,
-0.0387871116,
-0.0115302959,
-0.0286990609,
-0.0113611287,
-0.0314237066,
-0.0090776011,
-0.0300694015,
-0.0067888158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17633v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17633v1 | Knowledge Distillation in Automated Annotation: Supervised Text Classification with LLM-Generated Training Labels | 2024-06-25T15:20:25 | 2024-06-25T15:20:25 | Nicholas Pangakis, Samuel Wolken | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Computational social science (CSS) practitioners often rely on human-labeled
data to fine-tune supervised text classifiers. We assess the potential for
researchers to augment or replace human-generated training data with surrogate
training labels from generative large language models (LLMs). We introduce a
recommended workflow and test this LLM application by replicating 14
classification tasks and measuring performance. We employ a novel corpus of
English-language text classification data sets from recent CSS articles in
high-impact journals. Because these data sets are stored in password-protected
archives, our analyses are less prone to issues of contamination. For each
task, we compare supervised classifiers fine-tuned using GPT-4 labels against
classifiers fine-tuned with human annotations and against labels from GPT-4 and
Mistral-7B with few-shot in-context learning. Our findings indicate that
supervised classification models fine-tuned on LLM-generated labels perform
comparably to models fine-tuned with labels from human annotators. Fine-tuning
models using LLM-generated labels can be a fast, efficient and cost-effective
method of building supervised text classifiers. | [
0.0465122052,
0.0571201667,
0.007725927,
0.0001759428,
-0.0280615706,
0.0340343788,
0.0706858858,
-0.0116423611,
0.0471397527,
-0.1074874848,
-0.0166809,
0.0051544518,
-0.0466480181,
-0.0170024429,
0.0316373706,
-0.0112535907,
0.0275900383,
-0.0109264264,
0.0079099201,
-0.0090947766,
-0.0248458944,
0.0083295936,
0.0451833606,
0.0209163092,
0.0148313586,
-0.0376415402,
0.0031629563,
-0.0110276919,
0.0189660341,
-0.0330046937,
0.0418826006,
0.0886411965,
0.0367598869,
0.0562502742,
0.0000020025,
-0.048191186,
-0.0214555264,
0.0436819084,
-0.0309914611,
0.0448550843,
0.0470426455,
-0.0342158154,
0.011930217,
0.0063522081,
-0.0545496605,
-0.0345804505,
0.0287723877,
0.0312328599,
0.0489581041,
0.0696472451,
0.0079361685,
-0.0631700382,
0.0454626381,
-0.0489745922,
0.0282765552,
-0.0665379614,
0.066791296,
0.0130282193,
-0.0281841941,
0.0739009902,
0.0043466766,
0.0172850396,
0.003583577,
-0.0138927884,
0.0378796682,
0.0299833771,
-0.0527727641,
-0.0005837442,
0.011208347,
0.0248775743,
0.0317541175,
-0.0391694158,
0.0393267348,
-0.0056765606,
0.0063441782,
0.0376281664,
-0.0143906996,
0.0430698283,
-0.0271607414,
0.0113138258,
0.0398393981,
-0.0223867074,
0.0389511622,
0.0320612378,
0.029170407,
0.0455991067,
-0.0164393373,
-0.0280168243,
0.0410777777,
-0.0023766181,
-0.0394845754,
-0.0576023497,
-0.0020085354,
-0.0137917483,
0.0313281529,
0.0094476808,
-0.0326544829,
-0.0267717652,
0.0345959216,
-0.0380372778,
0.003550079,
-0.0053852717,
-0.0064448137,
0.0362989381,
0.0082563702,
-0.0072507965,
0.0090513257,
0.0172594246,
0.0193360578,
-0.0008767424,
-0.093989253,
-0.0230428353,
-0.0170835257,
0.0337460749,
-0.0272119194,
0.0097616138,
-0.0631773248,
0.0189315956,
-0.0115888612,
0.010605366,
0.0233849604,
-0.0161815472,
-0.0178987887,
0.0146062644,
-0.0099661965,
-0.0349548943,
-0.0034338809,
0.02779378,
-0.0099233519,
-0.0359132998,
0.0148665383,
0.015030439,
0.0039725653,
-0.0329899304,
0.0167407729,
0.0252551958,
0.0058765477,
-0.0466761477,
-0.0585462451,
-0.0107951639,
-0.0390789695,
-0.0445786752,
0.0093759242,
-0.05941974,
-0.0061535593,
0.00668226,
0.0055485987,
-0.0818926543,
0.001438355,
0.0128174191,
-0.0240498763,
0.0676328987,
-0.0204614792,
-0.0200954378,
0.0593446195,
0.0199837759,
-0.0004074754,
0.0500469469,
0.019153351,
0.0508406088,
0.0391536802,
-0.0339619815,
0.0542678572,
0.0234842431,
0.000352848,
0.0132002784,
-0.0084404144,
-0.0031146226,
0.0118597588,
-0.0271133762,
0.0176638234,
0.0327286348,
-0.0169010926,
0.0105587011,
0.0812616721,
0.0638249218,
-0.0044247718,
0.0339227058,
0.0248702001,
0.0359457433,
0.0062651327,
-0.0260092486,
-0.0285398178,
-0.0152014839,
-0.0328092091,
-0.0221075565,
0.021404298,
-0.0005766499,
-0.0045478167,
-0.0231011789,
-0.0148519566,
0.0025890397,
0.0052130073,
0.0156473052,
0.073420167,
0.0071842899,
-0.0039782762,
0.006188218,
0.0419809707,
-0.0096941311,
-0.0056055016,
-0.0471742563,
0.0211453699,
0.0440488458,
0.0151865883,
-0.0208367221,
0.0389954299,
-0.0508827567,
0.0482964925,
0.0123106688,
0.0242749825,
-0.0242706668,
-0.0216160584,
-0.0256123953,
-0.0352978855,
-0.0273739621,
0.0422968827,
0.0131578157,
0.0330662504,
-0.00435297,
0.0344836824,
-0.053594403,
-0.0653041601,
0.0689685121,
-0.0196877625,
-0.0572150312,
0.0126865553,
-0.0059413044,
0.052597411,
0.0219955239,
-0.0221048743,
-0.0155576793,
0.0273840614,
-0.0099534718,
-0.0050845998,
-0.0504736938,
0.0354535319,
-0.0137978951,
-0.0044791871,
-0.0085837329,
-0.0068073259,
0.0026119526,
-0.0524448603,
-0.0118934922,
-0.0292208344,
0.0056594601,
0.0211576317,
-0.0867067128,
0.005484032,
-0.0399364419,
0.0040990668,
-0.0622528866,
0.0726016834,
0.0182952639,
0.0090693748,
-0.0522072017,
-0.0442060456,
0.0049097124,
0.0065092975,
-0.0185802896,
-0.023925608,
0.005832864,
0.0153255174,
0.029065419,
-0.0042730877,
-0.0298485607,
-0.0312928706,
-0.0799603686,
0.0239350293,
-0.0201500691,
0.0171419047,
-0.0116361855,
-0.0289257877,
-0.0114279678,
0.0292901173,
-0.0212575812,
-0.0420408547,
-0.0415460467,
0.0267364215,
0.0119236605,
-0.0150380749,
0.0154271396,
-0.0074543245,
0.007972382,
-0.0038919372,
0.0450146273,
0.0151315806,
-0.0091555417,
-0.0348387398,
0.0177220013,
0.0100436928,
0.0088398242,
-0.0153065799,
-0.0188060757,
-0.0038934767,
0.0308709443,
-0.0202815346,
0.0512626432,
0.0105618099,
0.0483616367,
0.0307530724,
0.0376985632,
-0.0326893851,
-0.0021741923,
-0.0255237017,
-0.0363709554,
-0.0330052823,
-0.0149715273,
0.0009117488,
0.0391837321,
0.0058688535,
-0.0295788161,
-0.0267714635,
0.0342976041,
-0.0066628759,
-0.0363633819,
-0.0386586078,
-0.0128638875,
-0.0176959988,
0.0334963538,
-0.0077158832,
-0.0461153015,
0.0250236001,
-0.0098222448,
0.0355741642,
-0.0325242095,
-0.0445954017,
-0.0180740468,
0.0598524883,
0.0125651024,
0.0022036659,
0.0276069883,
0.0088595487,
-0.0165873561,
0.0067508761,
0.0367418416,
-0.0252822228,
0.0026881923,
-0.0319982506,
0.0162834097,
-0.0189359542,
-0.0487347357,
-0.033839155,
-0.0834400803,
-0.0384256244,
0.0352707729,
0.0447607897,
-0.0118642114,
-0.0083756167,
0.018560918,
0.0132753998,
0.0523034744,
-0.011594452,
-0.0298403483,
-0.0126411505,
0.0134533709,
0.0231525693,
-0.0506061837,
-0.0315555744,
-0.0111326249,
-0.0029056629,
0.0321871527,
0.0030874,
0.0247014388,
-0.0147936512,
0.0025032463,
0.0292866547,
-0.0590331703,
-0.0333109945,
0.0090185497,
0.039899338,
-0.0573739782,
-0.0034245397,
0.1094402969,
0.0292256027,
-0.0557743087,
-0.0126972292,
0.0301299561,
0.0114154899,
0.024970524,
0.0076395916,
-0.1021352559,
-0.0189325809,
0.0111726765,
0.0445082895,
-0.0377389379,
-0.051773306,
-0.0150320865,
-0.1083165035,
0.0570128448,
-0.0107210306,
-0.0492438115,
0.0296292361,
-0.0718442202,
-0.0061179949,
-0.0304906014,
-0.0321220979,
-0.0118063828,
-0.0093150511,
0.0274215005,
0.0503101163,
-0.0354731269,
-0.0774137825,
0.0267490558,
-0.0199725628,
0.0578105003,
0.0363713168,
0.0413371138,
-0.023281524,
-0.0288699027,
0.0613984726,
-0.0187508836,
0.0009845819,
0.00621595,
0.0635435805,
-0.028568536,
0.0078134025,
0.0146536538,
0.0806674734,
-0.0122331381,
-0.0347560011,
0.0401863754,
0.0530175492,
-0.0115613602,
-0.0127140833,
0.0095142899,
-0.0361111313,
0.0060831876,
0.0754059181,
0.0121307177,
-0.059217453,
-0.0094015691,
-0.0187321007,
0.0407448635,
-0.0211579949,
-0.0245192591,
0.0453901179,
-0.0594643913,
-0.0642216727,
-0.0385400318,
-0.0289694779,
0.0305230077,
0.0252715349,
0.0290347841,
0.0403009467,
0.013231854,
0.0020462689,
-0.0451013185,
0.0172453765,
-0.072489731,
-0.0217944402,
-0.0117871016,
-0.0325417146,
0.0489110313,
-0.0265064426,
-0.0432583056,
0.0090677561,
-0.0707793161,
-0.0655828267,
0.0211400557,
0.0013739251,
0.0223363321,
0.0275199637,
-0.0044040601,
-0.0820372328,
0.0788381025,
0.1034948379,
-0.0087443152,
-0.0125958771,
-0.0041743503,
-0.0042928015,
-0.020661993,
-0.000803769,
-0.0425185487,
0.0338643119,
0.0383510813,
-0.0256645381,
-0.0570451431,
0.003966324,
-0.0037654771,
0.0135030746,
0.083541289,
-0.0651226565,
-0.0124015175,
-0.0224182196,
-0.0067150476,
0.0017540776,
-0.0194899309,
-0.0101954779,
-0.0094455685,
0.0333827063,
-0.0075030578,
-0.0408499017,
0.0540857762,
0.0059164702,
0.0651043579,
-0.0683683529,
-0.0066630631,
0.0243481304,
0.0329612568,
0.0057202149,
0.0003430478,
-0.0148304394,
0.0141904484,
0.0138718132,
0.0440547876,
-0.0050568953,
0.0276843067,
0.0093551707,
0.0326279663,
0.0099280505,
-0.003214377,
-0.0736090019,
-0.0230993591,
-0.0472258627,
0.0590159521,
0.0522630103,
-0.0088233799,
0.0148660103,
-0.0359358229,
-0.045630265,
-0.0264704861,
0.0213806033,
0.0127610909,
-0.0186941847,
0.0023928578,
0.0049393363,
-0.0753917098,
0.0227785353,
0.0732867867,
0.0720528215,
0.0390678011,
0.0187252313,
-0.0689429417,
-0.0337129608,
-0.0136706317,
0.0007142293,
0.0301619619,
0.0173443165,
-0.0119483648,
-0.0556100383,
-0.0468319096,
-0.0009199151,
-0.0277505554,
-0.0066807284,
-0.0104956897,
0.0134517001,
0.0613368228,
-0.0315298662,
-0.0266477279,
-0.0804136172,
-0.0053580441,
0.0111138299,
-0.0285441149,
-0.0076958742,
-6.880135375e-33,
0.0208677482,
-0.0447402038,
-0.0002580351,
0.0212800074,
-0.0039386065,
-0.0044964822,
0.0144063113,
-0.0329219215,
0.0069599198,
0.0378020927,
-0.0200987477,
-0.0082827518,
0.0048432639,
0.0490807593,
0.0342044532,
0.00501118,
0.0359438658,
-0.0114380298,
-0.0168784149,
0.0380074196,
0.0454745926,
0.0069563738,
0.044116769,
-0.1046309546,
0.0675067753,
0.0005055462,
-0.0185995232,
-0.0067274002,
0.0186182521,
0.027501937,
-0.0262797903,
0.0511712059,
0.0328505374,
-0.0576267727,
0.0431025475,
0.0323343389,
-0.077754885,
-0.0086611547,
0.0139465583,
-0.0278620943,
0.0296200421,
-0.0611190274,
0.0403753929,
-0.0109194405,
-0.0163125079,
0.0222935118,
0.0556774698,
-0.0140306139,
-0.0536017939,
-0.1230171993,
-0.0357834399,
0.0286772698,
-0.0219393037,
0.0148896705,
0.0235092286,
0.0069944123,
0.0009836021,
0.0646994933,
-0.0672384128,
0.0024035743,
0.0281834863,
-0.0129896235,
0.0175570827,
0.0372568294,
0.0194902476,
0.0539235137,
0.0150310956,
0.0253044236,
-0.010364471,
-0.0127662672,
0.0225728601,
0.0058631827,
0.0016743725,
0.0943515226,
0.0481504388,
-0.058419656,
-0.0820355117,
0.0177206825,
0.001286967,
-0.0426096022,
0.0565675423,
0.0046208957,
-0.031437505,
-0.042781353,
-0.0721071586,
-0.0330548212,
-0.0121737188,
0.012984274,
-0.0025249189,
0.000208662,
-0.0517337248,
0.032281138,
0.0165157001,
-0.0265532099,
-0.0541842952,
0.0070822579,
-0.0068762638,
0.0132173067,
-0.0050267647,
-0.0164888483,
-0.0689054355,
-0.0223010592,
0.0153618753,
0.0330439284,
0.0378043465,
-0.0095146578,
0.0897523016,
-0.0051342207,
-0.072766833,
0.0104123987,
-0.0109700682,
0.0498069115,
0.0169483833,
-0.0004328745,
0.0312204212,
0.0099362815,
0.0271278489,
0.0146946041,
0.0756371915,
0.018940039,
0.0248400327,
0.0036879743,
-0.0066180066,
-0.0120282574,
0.0160844419,
0.0045824558,
0.0470863432,
0.0159966853,
0.0441454872,
-0.0313748196,
0.0144802183,
-0.0132637462,
2.839e-7,
0.0610301606,
0.0704687908,
-0.0365063176,
-0.0515830033,
0.0247435123,
0.0503662229,
0.0329140089,
0.0124999927,
0.0013376588,
-0.0616998971,
0.0211704969,
0.0059812181,
0.0743765309,
0.0231405031,
-0.0847544223,
-0.0155923069,
-0.0621509887,
0.0025278411,
-0.0645913631,
0.0103032198,
0.0347769968,
0.067882441,
0.0459001884,
-0.0126910331,
-0.0195465665,
-0.0462584645,
0.0574705675,
-0.0257468764,
-0.0073176152,
0.0386499427,
0.0123901647,
0.0399971642,
-0.002715453,
0.041602198,
-0.043628566,
-0.0001179216,
-0.0137977237,
0.071505338,
0.0026421468,
0.0164278857,
-0.004300788,
-0.0089496644,
0.0132549135,
-0.054495424,
0.0904178321,
-0.0729798079,
-0.0529326871,
-0.0305253826,
-0.0289854445,
-0.0532480218,
0.0360408388,
-0.0233121607,
0.0396175981,
0.0265647639,
-0.0233410783,
-0.0071117012,
-0.0174724255,
-0.0694988593,
-0.0035537137,
0.0240768809,
-0.0364629738,
-0.0513085015,
0.0243199635,
0.0089146569,
0.011403664,
-0.0427058898,
0.0525860749,
2.618553256e-34,
0.0291768312,
-0.0072799237,
-0.0080590723,
0.0024271884,
0.0341612063,
0.039190568,
-0.0125968475,
0.0162350032,
0.0015187702,
-0.0635467842,
0.0305667687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17626v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17626v1 | CoSafe: Evaluating Large Language Model Safety in Multi-Turn Dialogue Coreference | 2024-06-25T15:13:02 | 2024-06-25T15:13:02 | Erxin Yu, Jing Li, Ming Liao, Siqi Wang, Zuchen Gao, Fei Mi, Lanqing Hong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As large language models (LLMs) constantly evolve, ensuring their safety
remains a critical research problem. Previous red-teaming approaches for LLM
safety have primarily focused on single prompt attacks or goal hijacking. To
the best of our knowledge, we are the first to study LLM safety in multi-turn
dialogue coreference. We created a dataset of 1,400 questions across 14
categories, each featuring multi-turn coreference safety attacks. We then
conducted detailed evaluations on five widely used open-source LLMs. The
results indicated that under multi-turn coreference safety attacks, the highest
attack success rate was 56% with the LLaMA2-Chat-7b model, while the lowest was
13.9% with the Mistral-7B-Instruct model. These findings highlight the safety
vulnerabilities in LLMs during dialogue coreference interactions. | [
0.0425912887,
0.0203616433,
0.0000658522,
0.068232201,
-0.0604173392,
-0.0240807198,
0.0278404709,
-0.0208182093,
0.0473102666,
-0.0556697622,
-0.0373936072,
-0.0043935906,
-0.0089428453,
0.0283085816,
0.045269601,
0.0037747496,
0.0826610774,
-0.0772488117,
-0.0167935286,
0.002131178,
0.0198444109,
-0.017572552,
-0.0479324684,
0.0565008633,
-0.0060564294,
-0.0276387986,
-0.0427768864,
0.0224389341,
0.0161089543,
-0.0151159419,
-0.0089931432,
0.0415951312,
-0.0148037393,
0.0640775934,
0.0000020777,
-0.0768809617,
-0.0361885019,
0.0325749479,
-0.0549935251,
0.0188634004,
-0.0089934804,
0.0306453519,
-0.0286506973,
0.0469034202,
-0.007672383,
0.0306208897,
0.0283772666,
0.0658689812,
0.1071688831,
0.0671061426,
-0.0005455082,
0.0166334547,
0.0358735956,
-0.0199530628,
-0.0517949536,
-0.0802627653,
0.0171649903,
-0.005316372,
0.0072124251,
0.0486063138,
-0.0078540621,
-0.0053293663,
0.0174732525,
-0.0372293331,
-0.0763223544,
0.0031660625,
-0.0836029872,
-0.026453279,
-0.0154823242,
0.0703656077,
-0.0081238449,
0.0298666917,
0.0007347955,
0.0203195587,
-0.0029055818,
0.0038275979,
-0.0145240203,
0.0096900212,
-0.0221232511,
-0.0447762758,
0.0035552776,
-0.0182352904,
0.0051629748,
-0.0051640011,
-0.0043173917,
0.0743569434,
0.0232753716,
0.003467428,
0.0190351531,
-0.0479950868,
0.0021507067,
-0.0647435561,
-0.012933909,
0.0003069168,
-0.0633573458,
0.023565514,
-0.0455989875,
0.0333522856,
0.0654324964,
-0.0682930648,
0.0120032001,
0.0390785336,
-0.021915203,
0.0192504749,
0.0242548715,
0.0310969502,
-0.0130245257,
0.0286903288,
0.0261739474,
-0.0072046844,
-0.0023727228,
0.0080404421,
-0.0096109807,
0.0294866376,
-0.0091386195,
0.0052813049,
-0.0381892584,
0.0586608574,
0.0084414771,
0.0668217242,
0.0084951222,
-0.0207193308,
-0.007119827,
-0.0018901838,
0.0207421128,
-0.0001062291,
0.0156141222,
-0.0015570385,
0.0032757258,
-0.1201345623,
-0.0193928275,
0.0292229597,
-0.048258286,
-0.0386570729,
-0.0414880663,
0.1207010746,
0.015095613,
-0.0210749581,
-0.0127168521,
-0.1132553443,
-0.0360564329,
-0.0170962494,
-0.0118296221,
-0.0605115034,
-0.0024060875,
-0.003024942,
-0.0114255836,
-0.0358560421,
0.0379371271,
0.0190220717,
-0.0316825397,
0.0427165069,
0.0048151067,
-0.0134747252,
0.0057613589,
0.0547861457,
-0.0425330326,
0.065981999,
0.0054472643,
0.0175758116,
0.0554991625,
-0.0101935519,
0.0319720991,
0.0684650764,
-0.0113516925,
0.026980916,
0.0309697464,
0.0496021882,
0.0152354138,
-0.0262344629,
-0.0183837768,
0.0816227943,
-0.0050565111,
-0.0620995536,
0.1016765609,
0.0606494062,
-0.0397213958,
-0.00326647,
-0.0129160471,
0.0001021057,
0.007883233,
0.0104555897,
-0.0519065522,
0.0043983427,
-0.067857042,
-0.0439435393,
0.0251799319,
0.019834185,
-0.0194405485,
0.0066358265,
-0.0128754536,
0.0064719738,
-0.0176866427,
0.0010706225,
-0.0031568375,
0.0021788189,
-0.0198543482,
0.0486197881,
0.0011516926,
-0.0477893353,
-0.0534198247,
-0.049828805,
-0.0435872152,
0.0260906275,
0.0654532239,
0.0058047711,
-0.0912823528,
-0.0559950359,
0.0103097865,
0.0269738249,
0.0395541191,
0.0189983957,
0.0251749791,
-0.0171801336,
-0.0217309035,
0.0166144334,
-0.0019066415,
0.0014434153,
0.0079088258,
0.0026939861,
-0.0087592248,
0.0332623608,
-0.0134519562,
0.0049713724,
-0.0014522856,
-0.0261010341,
-0.0066538593,
0.0198327731,
0.0390417278,
0.0066552511,
0.0042176978,
0.0094907256,
0.0457467213,
0.031868916,
-0.0051598614,
0.0286036283,
-0.0430312604,
-0.0126209278,
0.0267589856,
-0.0064209546,
-0.0085414862,
0.0040900968,
-0.0212400798,
-0.004698114,
0.0354493819,
-0.051769387,
0.0240035076,
-0.0069663133,
0.0207812358,
0.0129483696,
0.0050030439,
-0.0209843349,
-0.0133890873,
-0.0292993467,
-0.0051141442,
-0.0113557931,
-0.0043680528,
0.0185001343,
-0.0476352647,
-0.0288103651,
0.0283421669,
-0.0335269347,
0.0236416813,
-0.0053064912,
0.0145154642,
-0.0498575419,
-0.0151243052,
-0.0572470613,
-0.0149638327,
-0.0161766857,
0.0419565141,
0.0177865978,
0.0301569328,
-0.0178368706,
-0.0066626831,
-0.0024709569,
-0.0088460995,
0.0117417583,
0.0337426178,
0.0084089236,
-0.0011119547,
-0.0742120296,
-0.0310946144,
0.0133341104,
-0.016971631,
0.0481778421,
-0.0246970113,
-0.0083468156,
-0.0338698104,
0.032428354,
-0.0094825374,
0.0301827509,
-0.022650566,
-0.0399714783,
0.0317327008,
0.0149714584,
0.0172261465,
0.033760976,
0.0233637001,
0.0340200514,
0.028392978,
-0.0527366996,
-0.063810654,
0.0009805196,
0.0369489603,
-0.0859868973,
-0.0360299125,
0.0070804348,
0.0226915106,
0.050700359,
0.0150330579,
-0.0034943947,
0.0067388779,
-0.024185976,
-0.0135005098,
-0.030600043,
-0.0002494918,
-0.0505549163,
-0.039133016,
0.0309582688,
0.0049834712,
-0.0474271849,
0.0452408828,
-0.0577011108,
0.0076394863,
-0.0327084474,
-0.039914228,
-0.0100494185,
0.0511442013,
-0.0539496578,
0.0051855273,
0.0753074065,
-0.0599066988,
-0.0460051335,
-0.0474723093,
0.0360793397,
-0.03868936,
0.0508874059,
-0.0554201454,
-0.0034702071,
-0.0183475334,
-0.0181685723,
-0.0772599727,
-0.027789196,
-0.0398028716,
-0.0155236879,
-0.0056131724,
-0.0110196052,
-0.0161536448,
-0.004278589,
0.0258382354,
-0.0183585864,
-0.0084632169,
-0.0028380624,
-0.0230705272,
0.0271067396,
0.0301318057,
-0.0469541326,
-0.0016170144,
-0.0188174713,
0.0697157905,
0.1089668572,
0.0327245556,
-0.0171087235,
-0.0092307394,
-0.0449327677,
0.0429041721,
-0.0328152105,
-0.0167510808,
0.0274434425,
0.0607725009,
-0.044409927,
-0.0318725109,
0.0786883906,
0.0299675241,
-0.025469413,
-0.0007136863,
-0.0574380681,
0.0105281295,
0.0040660431,
0.006244747,
-0.0559000596,
-0.0200188495,
0.0305990838,
0.0340373479,
0.0051047858,
-0.0285504088,
-0.0136320293,
-0.1095084399,
0.0239453297,
-0.0089614289,
-0.0436735079,
-0.0086645968,
-0.016339127,
0.0166279301,
0.0239866581,
0.07876122,
0.0062144315,
-0.001206484,
-0.016681714,
0.0126598487,
-0.0576187521,
-0.0071070627,
0.0313429125,
-0.0491914339,
0.0506070778,
0.0698753297,
-0.0007142547,
-0.0134145124,
0.0020067634,
0.0722547844,
0.0011446833,
-0.015509815,
-0.0068191211,
0.0276699197,
0.0052637071,
-0.0077013629,
0.0155007057,
0.0257062949,
0.0163591299,
-0.0061454168,
0.0625104606,
0.0163078867,
-0.0523054488,
0.0271456372,
-0.0211506467,
0.0333474763,
0.0416111052,
0.0562366135,
0.0342543647,
-0.0271813441,
0.0192627311,
-0.0555758364,
0.0072811842,
-0.0179565083,
-0.0584236979,
-0.0082600079,
0.0394764915,
-0.0153671717,
-0.0596318282,
-0.009442878,
-0.0041505746,
0.0173955355,
0.0134514794,
-0.0056627877,
0.0024730242,
0.040409822,
0.0102417301,
-0.0288816821,
-0.0707923397,
0.0532021821,
-0.0902446583,
0.0804683864,
0.034153074,
0.0251460169,
-0.0057414873,
0.066464901,
-0.0465598218,
-0.0812361389,
0.002107617,
0.0613991395,
0.0265851691,
-0.0076227626,
-0.0304376278,
-0.041703783,
0.012827442,
0.0168667957,
-0.0527099073,
0.003038039,
0.0653131679,
0.0208004862,
0.0148065761,
0.0283004008,
-0.0392127931,
-0.0289681051,
0.0102671273,
0.0138732987,
-0.0556704365,
-0.1173601374,
-0.0308425892,
0.0523367077,
0.0456532352,
0.0209492985,
0.074765712,
0.022282986,
0.0530361868,
-0.0455876961,
-0.0298544243,
0.0058515421,
0.0503136404,
-0.0323597491,
-0.0320547894,
0.0497497991,
0.0036922402,
-0.0443091057,
0.0542087182,
-0.0001659885,
0.0330533795,
0.0347468257,
0.0283291787,
0.018472176,
0.0003864543,
-0.0120569589,
0.0256938618,
0.0329408348,
0.0374242887,
0.0125966193,
0.0717415735,
-0.0299792457,
-0.0179179031,
0.0210715663,
0.0470430329,
-0.0520959869,
-0.0748482421,
0.0422763266,
0.0248251762,
0.0266438406,
0.0435738675,
0.0393377654,
0.0002385108,
0.0132349189,
-0.0344690196,
0.0102430601,
-0.0135939671,
-0.0443529822,
0.0336850397,
0.0087821763,
-0.0029714557,
0.0366603769,
0.0776575133,
-0.0039278744,
0.0281746536,
0.0161124915,
-0.0275109168,
-0.0524480045,
-0.0328268781,
0.0412500724,
0.0186010022,
-0.039559789,
-0.0489517562,
-0.0781446323,
-0.0643326715,
0.0422347449,
-0.0129881296,
0.0193478055,
0.0350891426,
0.006759047,
0.0249080528,
0.036989294,
0.0064706481,
-0.0556530505,
0.0032174045,
0.0112884501,
-0.0444383286,
0.0125418212,
-6.08479957e-33,
-0.0007971921,
-0.0423661768,
-0.0033343299,
0.0149205076,
-0.0102679357,
0.0084670475,
-0.0235803742,
0.0329720713,
-0.0484628081,
-0.0172138587,
-0.0096039837,
0.0134578468,
0.0237086862,
0.0122130169,
-0.0184106901,
-0.0259462912,
-0.0044279974,
-0.0011842552,
-0.0069147223,
0.0352462009,
0.0639712214,
-0.0191761162,
0.0197948348,
-0.1256083846,
0.048693005,
0.0089857914,
-0.0307885129,
0.0277841501,
-0.0439356193,
0.0412535444,
-0.0028561563,
0.0352229849,
-0.0220633466,
-0.0462759025,
0.0093448432,
0.0250726659,
0.0003588888,
-0.0391834192,
0.0123692099,
-0.0062983832,
-0.0019916564,
-0.0410876833,
-0.0061034169,
-0.0083638858,
0.0072324341,
-0.0169948228,
-0.0143270167,
0.0145372031,
-0.0084934253,
-0.0035764796,
-0.0118904449,
0.0135270301,
-0.0280911289,
-0.0387598947,
-0.023780195,
0.0542271473,
0.0407515056,
-0.0445927978,
-0.0346957631,
0.0433941931,
-0.0379989669,
-0.0019846079,
0.0583897308,
0.0087011848,
-0.0045878459,
0.0432808474,
-0.0303833261,
0.009573129,
0.0068756053,
-0.0022134031,
-0.0238602459,
0.0657630488,
0.0236724671,
0.0754872486,
-0.0539566539,
-0.0064740796,
-0.0761276633,
0.0294432566,
0.029422231,
0.0688368306,
0.0239864085,
-0.0088600311,
-0.0817769766,
-0.0059795151,
-0.0224750992,
0.0005474007,
-0.0346440412,
-0.0335213989,
0.0204038229,
-0.0116145574,
-0.0099412706,
0.0133441174,
0.046982225,
-0.0202373583,
0.0022542379,
0.0121934563,
0.0050188918,
-0.0261735413,
-0.0182223767,
0.0290661491,
0.0028211591,
0.0213097185,
0.0213979222,
-0.0496325754,
0.0299000908,
-0.0106461421,
0.0038154912,
0.0284152627,
-0.0754739344,
-0.0204143487,
-0.0160289574,
0.046954684,
-0.0213676244,
0.0166887436,
0.0309440754,
-0.0234693214,
-0.0106679872,
0.0379475802,
0.040807344,
-0.014069505,
-0.0536986552,
0.0033824625,
-0.01793647,
0.0112057123,
-0.0073811193,
0.0100960834,
0.0145674823,
0.0058138943,
0.0310299173,
-0.0213918108,
-0.0076067797,
-0.0602001809,
2.857e-7,
0.0137084918,
0.0267161839,
0.0299260374,
0.0357081518,
0.0208392609,
0.0710990056,
-0.0078930743,
0.0603781454,
0.0385155566,
-0.0410165042,
-0.022042064,
-0.0018595024,
0.0355024487,
0.0620078482,
-0.056900721,
-0.0400716513,
-0.0584899709,
-0.0008127929,
-0.0468982533,
-0.0325802788,
0.0596086197,
0.0672671422,
0.0098713823,
-0.0262228381,
-0.0325223543,
-0.0288416743,
0.001067193,
-0.0155209992,
-0.0368277915,
-0.0000135029,
0.0348379761,
0.0263016559,
0.0159439463,
0.0463612676,
-0.0066345204,
-0.0180696826,
-0.0163076967,
0.0603494681,
0.0197347291,
-0.0546133257,
-0.0242815446,
-0.0562540963,
0.0075357431,
-0.0361933932,
0.0556757711,
-0.0294870976,
-0.0098910388,
-0.0142496107,
-0.0307367761,
-0.0203436781,
0.031251736,
-0.0308909696,
-0.007599955,
0.0367669575,
-0.0105594583,
0.0121995956,
0.0044860374,
-0.0321351178,
-0.0331925526,
-0.0398122631,
-0.0010354263,
-0.0732648373,
0.0264973305,
-0.0030374443,
-0.0519276969,
-0.0104679326,
0.0129913576,
2.647623094e-34,
-0.0128077883,
-0.0119173108,
0.0085001029,
0.0266995318,
0.0465674959,
0.0086420719,
0.0046564145,
0.0105221597,
0.0135381911,
-0.0110995574,
-0.0394475162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17624v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17624v1 | Self-assessment, Exhibition, and Recognition: a Review of Personality in Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T15:08:44 | 2024-06-25T15:08:44 | Zhiyuan Wen, Yu Yang, Jiannong Cao, Haoming Sun, Ruosong Yang, Shuaiqi Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As large language models (LLMs) appear to behave increasingly human-like in
text-based interactions, more and more researchers become interested in
investigating personality in LLMs. However, the diversity of psychological
personality research and the rapid development of LLMs have led to a broad yet
fragmented landscape of studies in this interdisciplinary field. Extensive
studies across different research focuses, different personality psychometrics,
and different LLMs make it challenging to have a holistic overview and further
pose difficulties in applying findings to real-world applications. In this
paper, we present a comprehensive review by categorizing current studies into
three research problems: self-assessment, exhibition, and recognition, based on
the intrinsic characteristics and external manifestations of personality in
LLMs. For each problem, we provide a thorough analysis and conduct in-depth
comparisons of their corresponding solutions. Besides, we summarize research
findings and open challenges from current studies and further discuss their
underlying causes. We also collect extensive publicly available resources to
facilitate interested researchers and developers. Lastly, we discuss the
potential future research directions and application scenarios. Our paper is
the first comprehensive survey of up-to-date literature on personality in LLMs.
By presenting a clear taxonomy, in-depth analysis, promising future directions,
and extensive resource collections, we aim to provide a better understanding
and facilitate further advancements in this emerging field. | [
0.0759177953,
0.0330459848,
-0.071810104,
0.0355531685,
-0.0304182321,
0.0176601466,
0.0264313463,
-0.0057423818,
0.0387227871,
-0.0131422719,
-0.0748141557,
-0.0093602743,
-0.0012417985,
0.0085774325,
0.0266640242,
-0.0721409321,
0.02708699,
-0.0183594227,
0.0398286097,
-0.0104236444,
0.0295521114,
0.051314082,
0.021807218,
0.0314039998,
0.0057136626,
-0.048774302,
0.0285250358,
-0.0279498007,
0.020485932,
-0.0319157057,
0.0139395436,
0.0785391182,
0.0041171969,
0.0227443296,
0.0000022138,
-0.0288038421,
-0.0006149355,
-0.0423504412,
-0.0091096442,
0.0180808324,
0.0790667087,
0.0404632799,
0.0185715072,
0.0245595425,
-0.0690362528,
-0.039389506,
0.0070653595,
0.0340219177,
0.05474291,
0.0015506279,
0.0053565875,
-0.0056034881,
-0.0123168407,
0.016903542,
-0.0059883352,
0.003653026,
0.0114724208,
-0.0237401538,
-0.0168427043,
0.0187668651,
0.0284461211,
0.0167230889,
-0.0024460333,
0.0020208,
-0.0000511874,
-0.0061147572,
-0.0259009656,
-0.0218705405,
-0.0113310805,
0.0462103747,
0.0691909865,
-0.0238639656,
-0.0178755093,
-0.0087939091,
0.0240627695,
0.0359670296,
-0.0083341319,
0.0326458961,
0.0145718027,
-0.041221071,
0.0059784795,
0.0473767594,
-0.0182730537,
0.015706731,
-0.0053755948,
0.0146925682,
-0.0098904474,
-0.0094953887,
-0.0176823121,
-0.0064463178,
0.0039100763,
-0.0892639309,
0.0121787833,
0.0342988782,
-0.0060840463,
0.0261734501,
-0.0385022536,
-0.0301657841,
0.0314617418,
-0.0737307966,
0.0069752419,
0.0143698622,
-0.0163953938,
-0.0002530098,
0.056054119,
0.0537739806,
0.029484706,
0.0367746949,
0.001594089,
0.0033475133,
-0.0501834452,
-0.0142915165,
0.0208245441,
0.0044492632,
0.0584483556,
-0.0064234794,
-0.0545528457,
0.0343943983,
-0.0231668856,
-0.0086488975,
-0.0176050793,
-0.0173667949,
0.0192656647,
0.0183846019,
-0.0560007915,
0.0013780779,
-0.0517489463,
-0.0330216214,
-0.023507325,
-0.0503644906,
0.0624198876,
-0.0060507297,
0.0080670509,
-0.0193068832,
0.0304882936,
0.0608531684,
0.0316125937,
-0.0704910383,
-0.0192000512,
-0.0504026636,
-0.030292945,
-0.0704959482,
-0.0233980771,
-0.039617002,
0.0182741527,
0.0354502276,
0.005089195,
-0.0513487495,
-0.0056462465,
0.027841555,
0.0256476123,
0.041911602,
-0.0076203356,
0.0306484718,
0.0199032445,
0.0397074707,
0.0243990552,
0.01773878,
0.0098844618,
0.0065381113,
0.0426952094,
-0.041953437,
0.0350284055,
0.0395352617,
-0.0298143532,
-0.0264288411,
-0.012303099,
0.0045695365,
0.0249874685,
-0.0012486383,
0.0120045608,
0.055226624,
-0.0237576701,
-0.0082448404,
0.1075075269,
0.0714297295,
0.0018008102,
0.0377761349,
-0.022776641,
0.0547189936,
0.0543199703,
-0.0088617494,
-0.0153462905,
0.0355530567,
0.0103709232,
-0.0136029059,
-0.0015128726,
0.0204018001,
0.0000107393,
-0.052473262,
-0.0315233432,
-0.0003523234,
0.0289275497,
0.0533196926,
-0.0232526977,
-0.0042654914,
0.0102626812,
-0.0234744996,
0.0349378549,
-0.0551802069,
-0.0115356678,
-0.0628599152,
0.0100108655,
0.1259111762,
0.0350793041,
0.0083640879,
0.0079494594,
-0.0233882628,
-0.0318859257,
0.0493974574,
0.0356863812,
-0.0219357107,
-0.0227446724,
-0.0170929674,
0.0344242714,
-0.0056619439,
-0.0094552394,
0.0189017504,
0.0090916175,
0.0331547186,
-0.0258441567,
0.0214653853,
-0.020747615,
-0.0106319189,
-0.0680665225,
-0.0624996908,
-0.0080946442,
0.0365652181,
0.0161306467,
0.0343863182,
0.0056585972,
-0.0184623338,
-0.0069693169,
0.0265154541,
-0.0004236363,
0.034654744,
-0.0048514302,
0.0157279186,
0.0084147388,
0.0074668592,
-0.0422703438,
0.0079029426,
0.0567565262,
0.0118173938,
-0.0054300483,
-0.0366002657,
0.0459734611,
-0.0147658559,
0.0129234362,
-0.0703433827,
0.0629008114,
0.0000744557,
0.0351249911,
-0.0015443771,
0.014610569,
0.0405231863,
-0.0212442894,
-0.0311383624,
-0.0469099097,
-0.0396695063,
-0.0352829807,
0.0047849654,
0.0254069176,
0.0067012846,
-0.0109302783,
-0.0503708385,
-0.0454660133,
-0.0922911465,
-0.0293484945,
0.0195075031,
0.0136794029,
0.043766439,
-0.024967961,
-0.0520597249,
0.0072942828,
-0.0334644727,
-0.0203919727,
0.0234192833,
0.023387529,
0.0352851413,
-0.02290456,
0.0004752157,
-0.0518292412,
0.0034628173,
-0.0333636776,
0.0225681812,
-0.0049702739,
0.0298695657,
-0.0189770367,
0.0119184405,
-0.0550454482,
-0.0263664816,
-0.0067057996,
-0.0499168895,
0.039348539,
-0.0015933923,
0.0299851559,
0.0449004918,
0.0543893427,
0.0518252254,
0.0289133228,
-0.0350099243,
-0.0451075435,
-0.0264395066,
0.0034508966,
0.0298539307,
-0.0056745964,
-0.0966644585,
-0.0041639945,
0.0120300697,
0.0116399946,
0.0361767113,
-0.0283899121,
0.0494954214,
0.0007707134,
-0.0575339384,
0.0223608185,
0.0154514946,
-0.0124539211,
0.0490827635,
0.0339898057,
-0.0367216952,
0.0675095096,
-0.0189440083,
0.0115673402,
0.0094280615,
-0.0533865243,
-0.0254307576,
0.0917824283,
-0.0090406677,
-0.0079158861,
0.0418510959,
-0.0187068284,
-0.0267898683,
-0.0533490404,
0.0083154496,
-0.037568327,
0.0152813876,
0.0022809431,
-0.0573327057,
0.0595070012,
-0.0188085213,
-0.0317503177,
-0.0702359304,
-0.039155785,
-0.0400959738,
0.0356240608,
-0.0212105922,
-0.0264484193,
-0.0031900795,
0.0416153148,
-0.0483528897,
-0.0167456456,
-0.0171299465,
-0.0030796907,
-0.0130936978,
0.0490421206,
0.0248087328,
0.0494940206,
-0.055705592,
-0.0010962527,
0.0178751964,
-0.0218206234,
-0.0089830942,
0.0084324088,
-0.0042031319,
0.0434590615,
-0.0014228658,
-0.0199314822,
0.0206201803,
0.0411302485,
-0.0250310358,
0.0165750664,
0.128298521,
0.0323430635,
-0.0187853239,
0.0106544271,
-0.01948555,
0.0182012822,
0.0144162588,
0.042970188,
-0.004477886,
0.0013586922,
-0.0324850269,
-0.0003066169,
-0.0649409294,
-0.0185990185,
-0.0225413051,
-0.0651799813,
0.0133534083,
0.0112303169,
-0.0330564305,
0.0327488706,
-0.0059731202,
0.0185053032,
0.0127011696,
0.0120129753,
-0.0402280614,
-0.0320554636,
-0.0215745717,
-0.0173367634,
-0.0691246837,
-0.0246479772,
0.0760875419,
-0.0446058735,
0.0340682864,
-0.0062326007,
0.0393307284,
0.0073596118,
-0.0563931577,
-0.0792280808,
0.0182138272,
0.0234938264,
0.0242428444,
0.0447036214,
-0.0508593172,
0.0305419657,
-0.1125479788,
-0.023084674,
0.0041451375,
0.0032984652,
0.0225576926,
0.0412845761,
-0.0027206307,
-0.0330275968,
-0.0247973595,
0.0035738433,
0.0340228342,
0.0359984413,
-0.0009262478,
-0.0935707539,
-0.0012738239,
0.0052296184,
0.0189162903,
0.0237503778,
-0.0909099281,
-0.0231091734,
0.043840941,
-0.0144965928,
-0.0348953754,
-0.1043621227,
-0.0158024915,
0.0081414646,
0.0055353828,
-0.0032879005,
-0.0170034375,
0.010985869,
-0.0197936222,
0.0097769229,
-0.0381842107,
0.0499187261,
-0.0298260339,
-0.0286232661,
0.0320190787,
-0.0579087734,
0.0238233339,
0.0152076408,
-0.0369658358,
-0.0312304739,
0.0193911158,
0.0088227382,
0.017167341,
-0.0101398705,
0.0407969132,
-0.0869734809,
0.0273983404,
-0.0063203876,
-0.0282761566,
0.0534920134,
-0.0251509845,
0.0223290548,
-0.0117639154,
0.0169741642,
0.0104419105,
0.019992847,
-0.0114725651,
-0.0405937098,
-0.0202957522,
-0.0974629521,
-0.0029802329,
0.0175762419,
-0.0043704282,
0.0007388059,
-0.0273024794,
0.0018792731,
-0.0429477468,
-0.0391462594,
-0.0243470296,
0.0303831156,
-0.0790168047,
-0.018609101,
0.0097062327,
-0.0223314408,
-0.0171863046,
-0.028618481,
0.0210944042,
-0.035363324,
0.0305285957,
0.005970303,
0.0077300509,
-0.0269976314,
0.0222582649,
-0.0116293188,
-0.0046184938,
0.0062730853,
0.0346915834,
0.0072405138,
0.0869661123,
-0.0331856832,
-0.0244085789,
-0.0084297052,
0.05681438,
-0.0319724455,
-0.0304306056,
0.0324118957,
0.0100893937,
-0.0270134751,
0.0007322478,
0.0560631901,
-0.0414315797,
0.0154801272,
-0.030530693,
0.0160961505,
-0.0252120644,
-0.0548771806,
0.0167319831,
0.0050187246,
-0.0101411333,
-0.0250324979,
0.0072343699,
0.0190492719,
-0.0103920093,
-0.024060633,
-0.0433254763,
-0.0358861424,
0.024826467,
0.0192675237,
0.0179630965,
-0.0254966952,
-0.0304359421,
-0.1035016626,
-0.0935059562,
0.0509764552,
0.0237858612,
0.0050719413,
-0.0575234666,
0.0193374772,
0.0514883958,
-0.0069176992,
-0.0259603001,
-0.0481461622,
0.0228220709,
-0.0405793861,
-0.0052389503,
-0.0159262083,
-5.893427621e-33,
-0.0147954803,
-0.060726814,
0.0285705607,
-0.010449498,
-0.0095076896,
-0.0544572771,
-0.0177438911,
0.0509663671,
-0.0086771334,
-0.0279186424,
-0.0382040963,
0.0024715308,
0.009111505,
-0.03724619,
0.0095678363,
0.0120402845,
0.0484024845,
-0.0108588738,
-0.0294948816,
0.0220790058,
0.0201158915,
-0.0307842642,
0.0439225212,
-0.0792063326,
0.0560141057,
-0.073068276,
0.0052409461,
-0.0284717511,
0.0333616771,
0.0753233135,
-0.0205031671,
0.0452043153,
0.0305164661,
0.0150826499,
-0.0237797424,
0.0768360272,
-0.0389437042,
-0.0461664088,
0.0078109032,
0.0456002541,
-0.0043238257,
-0.0436915383,
0.013959324,
-0.0210682843,
-0.0832714885,
-0.0091675529,
0.0555435903,
0.0161278918,
0.0504891649,
0.0772153735,
-0.0186201707,
0.0073440839,
-0.0115308361,
-0.0120983096,
0.0097631868,
0.0154980477,
-0.0159085914,
0.0018834234,
-0.0838000253,
0.0718208179,
-0.0418598652,
-0.0254018456,
0.0500697009,
0.0275144707,
0.012550652,
0.0553310923,
0.0616321936,
0.0921937749,
0.0223973393,
-0.0301498175,
0.0614302605,
0.0260848664,
0.0261728093,
0.0782231167,
-0.0198466685,
-0.0384630151,
0.0296548679,
0.0040038773,
0.0741862506,
-0.0608597547,
0.0598563738,
0.0006029149,
-0.0604307316,
-0.0376712941,
-0.0070160371,
0.0050947927,
-0.0321407579,
-0.033017125,
0.0243918505,
-0.0358010195,
-0.0231371,
-0.0226317365,
0.0433049574,
-0.0590523072,
-0.0713657141,
0.0167448409,
-0.0598794036,
0.0666495562,
0.0003820072,
-0.0071742833,
-0.0177236088,
0.0074946601,
-0.0115337763,
-0.0003419105,
0.0436213762,
0.0325407982,
-0.0167085994,
0.0260524433,
-0.056966912,
-0.0069287312,
0.0390769616,
0.0095221857,
-0.0098857796,
-0.0061859232,
0.0368014723,
0.0003588078,
-0.0100790244,
-0.0004341476,
0.003184949,
0.0010179206,
-0.0556384511,
-0.000840858,
-0.0133392531,
-0.0182833467,
0.0029625588,
0.0007847141,
-0.071953252,
0.0189979915,
0.0497610271,
-0.0221004505,
0.0314232595,
-0.0143410098,
2.778e-7,
-0.0572995469,
0.0659524351,
-0.0421139263,
0.0446595103,
0.0344117992,
0.0584162436,
0.012646107,
0.0231238976,
0.0572682619,
-0.0343159884,
-0.0165748782,
0.0244178921,
0.0490923077,
0.050819736,
-0.046648521,
0.0309789255,
-0.0196097363,
0.0493256003,
-0.0301303603,
0.0223954897,
0.059132643,
0.0207346957,
0.0407493003,
-0.0009669103,
-0.0311049726,
0.0101505546,
0.0353515521,
-0.0134169655,
-0.0075552766,
0.0255990382,
-0.0176688023,
-0.005512476,
0.0099088559,
0.0575343333,
0.0060715443,
0.006417626,
-0.0137279434,
0.048412364,
-0.0039263237,
0.0300840307,
0.028708281,
0.0155054238,
-0.0205636751,
-0.0454822816,
0.0298049524,
-0.0260196943,
-0.0452952087,
-0.0274553485,
0.0200112984,
-0.0654493719,
0.0461869463,
-0.0014033468,
-0.0402356051,
0.0475113653,
0.0223613344,
-0.045752041,
-0.0076142293,
-0.0457869284,
0.0257546436,
-0.0402299166,
-0.0282055903,
-0.0494446419,
-0.0425454006,
0.0162971988,
0.0235253517,
-0.0564121045,
0.0427341387,
2.261986331e-34,
-0.0333797075,
0.0402149819,
-0.0128675969,
-0.0083437031,
0.0600803047,
0.03235396,
0.0172983482,
0.0186676309,
0.0569714122,
-0.0681179464,
-0.0068110148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17618v1 | Towards Building an End-to-End Multilingual Automatic Lyrics Transcription Model | 2024-06-25T15:02:32 | 2024-06-25T15:02:32 | Jiawen Huang, Emmanouil Benetos | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Multilingual automatic lyrics transcription (ALT) is a challenging task due
to the limited availability of labelled data and the challenges introduced by
singing, compared to multilingual automatic speech recognition. Although some
multilingual singing datasets have been released recently, English continues to
dominate these collections. Multilingual ALT remains underexplored due to the
scale of data and annotation quality. In this paper, we aim to create a
multilingual ALT system with available datasets. Inspired by architectures that
have been proven effective for English ALT, we adapt these techniques to the
multilingual scenario by expanding the target vocabulary set. We then evaluate
the performance of the multilingual model in comparison to its monolingual
counterparts. Additionally, we explore various conditioning methods to
incorporate language information into the model. We apply analysis by language
and combine it with the language classification performance. Our findings
reveal that the multilingual model performs consistently better than the
monolingual models trained on the language subsets. Furthermore, we demonstrate
that incorporating language information significantly enhances performance. | [
0.0027447236,
0.0500481836,
-0.0136723416,
0.0649301037,
-0.0281420052,
-0.0051537384,
0.0532878079,
-0.0430490896,
-0.0271093976,
0.0459813178,
-0.0843025818,
-0.0440554395,
0.0236616973,
0.0006069698,
0.0253491886,
-0.0176939312,
0.0101845693,
-0.0620077923,
0.0408104472,
-0.0292242486,
-0.0321288928,
0.0245579779,
-0.002771236,
0.0344678089,
-0.0345545895,
0.0272170901,
0.0029505137,
0.0212087035,
-0.0092170816,
-0.0103973998,
-0.0419213772,
0.0167883728,
-0.0021691262,
0.0206095111,
0.0000017302,
-0.0476323552,
-0.0246505681,
0.0149333933,
-0.0053120609,
-0.050261382,
0.0241216812,
-0.0164062344,
-0.0227308888,
0.0141939409,
-0.0005586245,
-0.0456005745,
0.0691910461,
-0.0049958392,
0.051536791,
0.0743800104,
0.0070574027,
-0.0669000521,
0.0221720263,
-0.0555575006,
-0.0127462503,
-0.0533340015,
-0.0038944313,
0.0129203983,
0.0211227704,
-0.0382047333,
-0.0096066734,
0.0965586528,
-0.0046369112,
0.0099371709,
-0.0094244583,
0.0174302477,
-0.0732510015,
-0.0549620539,
0.028124515,
0.0121313427,
-0.000945927,
0.0031474752,
-0.0110992435,
0.0121083455,
-0.0046423539,
-0.0281531494,
-0.0151271541,
0.0054097157,
0.0245399177,
0.0079323612,
0.0315563269,
0.0141576072,
0.0498138219,
-0.0218864735,
0.0031107578,
0.0056079328,
0.0305709671,
-0.0607932918,
0.0466615222,
0.0221025739,
0.0386313759,
-0.0387113728,
0.0307590403,
-0.0229890607,
-0.0082518132,
0.0035655119,
-0.0320942476,
-0.0563980788,
-0.0147158243,
-0.0549179167,
0.0560921989,
0.0228184871,
-0.0366083421,
0.0635801554,
-0.0286480654,
0.0139567554,
-0.022280151,
0.005463372,
-0.0395130888,
-0.0560379066,
0.00719039,
-0.0084548173,
-0.05061296,
-0.0393142067,
0.0156455096,
-0.0005741373,
-0.0334440842,
-0.0247655045,
-0.0084557552,
0.0297379009,
0.0190184321,
-0.0660557598,
-0.035509523,
0.0028587696,
0.0637427345,
0.0198543612,
0.0072748512,
0.031605877,
-0.0221178029,
-0.0351988189,
0.0118853636,
0.0110457195,
0.0315887332,
0.0045050564,
0.0749029666,
0.0762347504,
0.0513221584,
-0.0554136746,
-0.0299939997,
0.0139115686,
-0.0529644974,
-0.0667829514,
-0.0017375668,
-0.0925994143,
0.0972236246,
-0.0208257288,
0.007106497,
-0.0173687488,
0.0032576753,
-0.0284016188,
-0.0113370093,
0.0604918562,
0.0177216418,
0.0320592523,
0.0080760671,
-0.0192399435,
-0.0156713985,
0.0531441085,
0.074324958,
0.0007729817,
0.0713888258,
-0.0434704088,
0.0179555118,
0.0988670215,
-0.0008665686,
0.0111911586,
-0.0464927144,
-0.0174423512,
0.0085325213,
0.0322112143,
0.0202130023,
0.0276585817,
0.0320429243,
-0.032869108,
0.0214618836,
0.0194801837,
0.0179226734,
0.059472166,
0.0323369913,
-0.0130302403,
0.0100495508,
-0.0114493007,
0.0196155719,
0.0428426042,
0.0666599199,
0.0256463829,
0.0860086232,
0.0436681807,
-0.0176511481,
0.0185154136,
-0.0251602195,
-0.0274396576,
-0.0168596245,
0.0355429947,
0.0607739799,
0.0103176301,
-0.014966893,
0.0151932118,
0.029087428,
-0.0658993721,
0.0125194257,
-0.0254653282,
0.0012651881,
0.0517739914,
0.0310240686,
-0.006054719,
0.0351341404,
-0.0190372951,
-0.0284990855,
0.0507146306,
-0.0045234822,
-0.0304643195,
0.0561281145,
-0.016043013,
0.007091844,
0.0113809435,
-0.0122238426,
0.0466068983,
-0.0301991049,
0.0312870927,
-0.0263691898,
-0.0265298467,
-0.0244379733,
-0.0267718975,
-0.0224878453,
-0.0009617271,
0.034849558,
0.0406449996,
0.0546562485,
0.0605597235,
-0.0621772856,
0.0177090354,
0.0037491436,
-0.0404345132,
-0.0000256327,
0.0249179192,
-0.0213837102,
-0.0633580759,
0.0525980815,
-0.021527702,
-0.0040482688,
0.0026918412,
0.0161671452,
-0.0728992149,
0.0602189265,
-0.0119616482,
0.0411976054,
-0.0060148663,
0.0109221712,
-0.0286250841,
-0.0126062008,
0.0420214422,
-0.0273047462,
0.0345392823,
0.0270971488,
-0.0218494926,
-0.0622369014,
0.0576580502,
-0.0287940148,
-0.0470744185,
0.0780901611,
0.0202527139,
0.0085922638,
-0.0001044766,
-0.0047678594,
0.0320817716,
-0.0396693274,
-0.082581535,
0.0036139826,
-0.0284103099,
-0.0088331001,
-0.0015564413,
0.0229513198,
-0.0216608178,
-0.0314163938,
-0.0247015674,
-0.0317120329,
0.0125867967,
0.0375931747,
-0.0571245961,
-0.0049793804,
-0.0513390005,
-0.0265274812,
-0.0287670009,
0.0071322438,
-0.0121973567,
-0.031629432,
-0.0379096717,
-0.0211432576,
-0.0256738048,
-0.0514236763,
0.0035389569,
0.009752688,
-0.0035747339,
-0.0268124361,
-0.0295934658,
0.041128654,
0.0243918821,
-0.0676975846,
-0.0447738767,
0.0969569683,
-0.0059717824,
0.0107443668,
0.0254111346,
0.0307264253,
0.0144180162,
-0.0065585794,
-0.0369886644,
-0.0378102362,
0.0381543301,
0.0622191243,
-0.034624584,
-0.0079273405,
-0.0072228676,
-0.0673659295,
0.0280922372,
-0.0304050781,
0.0409638472,
-0.0255523995,
0.0477170758,
-0.0110091269,
-0.0241614394,
0.0575583875,
-0.0543410815,
-0.0483034402,
-0.053871274,
-0.0463184007,
-0.0331095345,
0.0191626512,
-0.0494033508,
0.0323279351,
-0.0320100375,
-0.0121443709,
-0.014172432,
0.0432291292,
-0.0053268461,
-0.0448110774,
0.051390864,
-0.0142982416,
-0.002324682,
-0.0191832595,
-0.0490588173,
0.012083035,
-0.0162866656,
-0.0297601186,
-0.0086084642,
-0.0180185456,
-0.0380871855,
0.0221053641,
-0.0131460642,
0.0286903474,
0.0537379757,
-0.0084787561,
0.0326235704,
0.0200589802,
0.0276074223,
-0.0020823623,
-0.0424302742,
-0.0398316607,
-0.0399116091,
0.0095292302,
-0.0424499549,
-0.0020537397,
0.0135678574,
0.0027289016,
-0.0121446596,
0.0437926091,
0.0475187674,
0.0059657502,
-0.0118739838,
0.0054783286,
-0.0419987924,
0.0236910451,
0.0795392022,
-0.0038363133,
-0.029059926,
-0.0279124305,
-0.0043396568,
0.0220967308,
0.0287072714,
0.0180476084,
-0.0549244247,
-0.0041418639,
0.0318587087,
0.0468131751,
0.0468270928,
0.0303614978,
-0.0266215354,
-0.0492063612,
-0.0113449525,
0.004950311,
-0.0817475542,
-0.0232838877,
-0.0460679457,
-0.0345803648,
-0.0440824442,
-0.0154562313,
-0.0185161382,
0.019046044,
0.0068891267,
-0.0225355774,
-0.002563878,
-0.0480021015,
0.0416126177,
-0.0586879253,
0.0772289857,
0.0573529936,
0.0556462631,
-0.0464717373,
-0.0366932079,
0.0019499253,
0.0268354602,
-0.0172591079,
0.0182211511,
0.0259776786,
0.0511928573,
-0.0232753847,
0.0391193666,
0.0036914772,
-0.0293690171,
0.0374373272,
0.0294869412,
0.0531864241,
0.0142479176,
0.0171806216,
0.024530204,
0.0280097257,
0.0259650052,
0.0794310868,
0.029352244,
-0.0682886317,
0.0241112355,
-0.0038903253,
-0.0058004549,
-0.0922333375,
0.0141765513,
0.0161357876,
-0.0322867185,
-0.0545720905,
-0.0151670128,
-0.0212670751,
-0.0072354102,
-0.019099554,
0.0581968613,
-0.0090138689,
-0.0246682055,
-0.0165339429,
-0.0213789511,
0.0036114345,
-0.0175515823,
0.0639716461,
-0.0271482579,
-0.0544608086,
-0.0025507058,
-0.0238772556,
-0.0145240892,
-0.0135410633,
-0.0673866794,
-0.0421550572,
0.0190227851,
0.0213091001,
0.0125939948,
0.0624366961,
-0.0100912973,
-0.0097198784,
-0.0296643432,
-0.0303263906,
0.0370949395,
-0.0019355942,
0.0589946844,
-0.0094586276,
-0.0046480307,
0.0351367705,
-0.0477374531,
0.0475903787,
0.0285381097,
0.0222290978,
0.0128920302,
-0.0449649841,
-0.0060647568,
0.010168069,
0.0028725541,
-0.0297138561,
-0.0350575522,
-0.0766262263,
-0.0145389307,
-0.0265732314,
-0.0042005521,
-0.0230438598,
-0.0074366173,
0.0913606212,
0.0280400906,
-0.0205505956,
-0.0206810944,
0.0030415226,
-0.0416716821,
-0.0324875712,
0.0476845205,
0.0811596513,
-0.0459588058,
0.0215427931,
0.02665383,
-0.0239993203,
0.0399289913,
0.0412775576,
-0.006160073,
0.0001964942,
-0.0325266942,
-0.0097231213,
-0.0448149107,
0.0135740265,
0.011305158,
0.0052533355,
0.0086194277,
0.0256549679,
0.0135335103,
0.0800170079,
-0.0152076334,
0.0536103509,
0.0179600045,
-0.0129999844,
-0.010005014,
0.0279551223,
0.0070236814,
-0.0428546369,
-0.0207190905,
-0.0003064057,
0.0076479865,
0.0023666092,
0.0718962252,
-0.0186961424,
0.0194500349,
-0.0200756602,
-0.0020132882,
0.0196146518,
0.0246195067,
-0.0214208551,
-0.0318323635,
-0.0175451916,
0.0179050937,
-0.0314679928,
-0.0696814582,
0.0015480107,
0.0190948136,
0.0106598223,
0.0153187755,
-0.0185133405,
0.048379533,
-0.0054887296,
0.0138254417,
-0.0324503109,
-0.0539127551,
0.0147148538,
-0.0074490197,
0.0025996345,
-5.301295851e-33,
-0.0127519397,
0.0552663058,
-0.0192268901,
0.0163714793,
-0.0086051328,
-0.0033657439,
-0.0631377995,
0.0137190986,
-0.0189561583,
-0.0182381216,
0.0068145711,
0.0024738638,
0.0079381317,
0.0032103716,
0.0540994219,
0.0205373429,
0.0548207499,
0.0064538904,
-0.0437703207,
0.0315804109,
0.0764844641,
0.0635910854,
0.0453939065,
-0.0697662383,
0.0399789065,
-0.0104059419,
0.0300000384,
0.0336996503,
0.0188136678,
0.0367595516,
-0.0115800444,
0.0232931189,
0.0150899729,
-0.0348505862,
-0.0318980142,
0.0044628019,
-0.0412790552,
-0.0256976318,
0.0076574972,
0.0703754425,
0.0396090634,
-0.0104633821,
-0.0145670613,
-0.0317213945,
-0.015891578,
-0.005234038,
0.0410812199,
-0.0462972224,
-0.005140407,
-0.046529986,
-0.0311083551,
0.0097335437,
-0.0131695578,
-0.0322171673,
0.0852508396,
0.0643648505,
0.0022797077,
0.011474668,
-0.0396281146,
0.024347024,
-0.0369592756,
0.0235695057,
0.0461865738,
0.0399812125,
-0.0338420197,
0.0139202233,
0.0046180999,
-0.0484336279,
0.0138908084,
0.0347150303,
0.0127781434,
0.0140879108,
0.0185016599,
-0.0026616831,
0.0496141687,
-0.030691972,
-0.0403218344,
-0.0151219666,
-0.0074461773,
-0.0571225695,
0.0032235526,
0.0312592313,
-0.0512853004,
-0.0123848617,
-0.0200104769,
-0.0698694959,
-0.0252165943,
-0.0152002973,
0.0203360133,
-0.0120946718,
-0.0173820723,
0.0180445556,
0.0287416,
-0.0213481151,
-0.0288134012,
0.0196065214,
-0.0255846046,
-0.0056579434,
-0.0098894928,
0.0374398828,
-0.0527269468,
-0.0199223105,
0.0222752448,
0.0123441927,
0.0419884734,
-0.0093818428,
0.0831690803,
0.087624304,
-0.0708325505,
0.002841633,
-0.0311099123,
-0.0002156545,
0.0025898623,
0.0346741006,
0.0463179983,
0.0179917794,
-0.0025346777,
0.0617854521,
0.0513083972,
0.0379094929,
-0.0248320699,
-0.0422020145,
-0.0148125896,
-0.0146978106,
0.0039821467,
0.0114215137,
-0.0013527984,
-0.0284103248,
0.0103510646,
-0.0479997918,
-0.0178466421,
0.0121708112,
2.607e-7,
0.0337843671,
-0.0283075217,
-0.0031498619,
0.0096424008,
0.0289601348,
0.0264155641,
-0.1163787618,
-0.0043699332,
-0.0067065409,
0.0458893031,
0.0054909228,
-0.0280687902,
0.1128008217,
0.0692626759,
-0.1047140807,
0.0022554793,
-0.0667740554,
0.0075954939,
-0.0731684119,
-0.0335383154,
0.0078932336,
0.0855148733,
0.0121764066,
-0.0265166368,
-0.0301460829,
-0.0491995774,
0.0231514238,
-0.0098860506,
0.0011548329,
-0.0666631311,
-0.001723265,
0.0259282645,
-0.000396641,
-0.0005946797,
-0.0799743161,
0.0828908011,
0.0418299995,
0.0420972295,
0.0204839092,
0.0172242541,
0.0556129999,
0.0333434008,
-0.047136303,
-0.0207561851,
0.0400045291,
0.0199469086,
-0.0369271636,
-0.0209495239,
0.0207445398,
0.0436250381,
0.0360827073,
-0.0377565213,
-0.0260054749,
-0.0291518234,
0.0375606194,
-0.0421829373,
0.0161462892,
-0.0136803687,
-0.0098987864,
0.038225811,
-0.0390808247,
-0.0007114736,
0.0093195336,
-0.0199115705,
-0.0127893658,
-0.0555505641,
0.0187241994,
1.852853915e-34,
0.0651147068,
-0.0542197227,
0.0063606361,
-0.0088272244,
0.0217203796,
-0.056627091,
0.019062385,
-0.0186511818,
-0.0429719053,
-0.0194950085,
-0.0620152168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17600v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17600v1 | "Seeing the Big through the Small": Can LLMs Approximate Human Judgment Distributions on NLI from a Few Explanations? | 2024-06-25T14:42:17 | 2024-06-25T14:42:17 | Beiduo Chen, Xinpeng Wang, Siyao Peng, Robert Litschko, Anna Korhonen, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human label variation (HLV) is a valuable source of information that arises
when multiple human annotators provide different labels for valid reasons. In
Natural Language Inference (NLI) earlier approaches to capturing HLV involve
either collecting annotations from many crowd workers to represent human
judgment distribution (HJD) or use expert linguists to provide detailed
explanations for their chosen labels. While the former method provides denser
HJD information, obtaining it is resource-intensive. In contrast, the latter
offers richer textual information but it is challenging to scale up to many
human judges. Besides, large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used as
evaluators (``LLM judges'') but with mixed results, and few works aim to study
HJDs. This study proposes to exploit LLMs to approximate HJDs using a small
number of expert labels and explanations. Our experiments show that a few
explanations significantly improve LLMs' ability to approximate HJDs with and
without explicit labels, thereby providing a solution to scale up annotations
for HJD. However, fine-tuning smaller soft-label aware models with the
LLM-generated model judgment distributions (MJDs) presents partially
inconsistent results: while similar in distance, their resulting fine-tuned
models and visualized distributions differ substantially. We show the
importance of complementing instance-level distance measures with a
global-level shape metric and visualization to more effectively evaluate MJDs
against human judgment distributions. | [
0.069484964,
0.0391089134,
-0.0296425205,
0.0345892385,
-0.0173592437,
0.0082021542,
0.0054564774,
-0.0035156771,
-0.0220301095,
-0.0604306795,
-0.0594497286,
-0.0219274089,
0.0036897541,
-0.0183298923,
0.0408798568,
-0.0561299436,
-0.0036843016,
-0.0395193584,
0.0414502807,
-0.0060824752,
0.0301573034,
0.0045832559,
-0.0121911038,
0.0714194775,
-0.0115247509,
0.0218108259,
-0.0149983671,
0.0056661284,
0.0384291857,
-0.0120437834,
0.0055220458,
0.0670954287,
0.0444224291,
-0.0033256591,
0.00000194,
-0.0258554928,
0.0475187413,
0.0005205342,
-0.017561391,
0.0411838703,
0.0096747018,
0.0035405557,
0.0312835611,
-0.0199479945,
-0.0129164355,
-0.0153753506,
0.0524339266,
0.0297022723,
0.0541703813,
0.0192867797,
0.0169374216,
-0.0528449379,
-0.0454799682,
-0.0277586691,
0.0057185781,
-0.079045929,
0.0020258261,
0.0157314446,
-0.0126705524,
0.0370596796,
0.0029740157,
-0.000868186,
-0.0101937726,
0.0001121911,
0.0219418816,
0.0092473449,
-0.0102232844,
-0.0327605456,
0.0165900178,
0.0682983696,
0.0497385189,
-0.0344328247,
-0.0385565497,
-0.0208042096,
0.0330300964,
0.0407858901,
-0.0023479136,
0.0323792435,
-0.0184046514,
0.0179459695,
0.0129736476,
0.0412070863,
0.0311000049,
0.0234837011,
0.0287759155,
0.0589499176,
-0.0145858051,
-0.0056484579,
0.0030626692,
0.0465276763,
-0.0489852205,
-0.0318453349,
0.0046728649,
-0.0008553261,
-0.04013668,
-0.0093850875,
-0.0024048199,
-0.0213119015,
0.0284090303,
-0.0320023857,
0.0264780596,
-0.000877969,
-0.0180741288,
0.0481818877,
0.0242677499,
0.0256407242,
-0.0083885901,
0.0309845898,
-0.0320079774,
-0.047422681,
-0.0515750498,
0.0139894616,
-0.0039780773,
-0.0078035812,
-0.0392714776,
0.031019995,
-0.0523891337,
-0.0126949409,
-0.067201212,
-0.0340444185,
0.036952205,
0.0324718803,
-0.0027100807,
0.0004842468,
-0.0996373519,
0.013397513,
-0.0966742188,
0.0380537696,
-0.0000325352,
-0.0236431137,
0.0121684438,
0.0280201025,
0.0171783417,
-0.0015886392,
-0.0028241049,
0.0680477098,
0.0297442004,
0.0063970834,
-0.0425661989,
-0.03078009,
-0.0327039436,
-0.0425414406,
-0.0343990698,
-0.0597690679,
0.0211772248,
0.0094462056,
-0.0104157347,
-0.0446235314,
-0.0140904132,
-0.0116321929,
-0.0541289188,
0.0783176348,
-0.0108771622,
0.0203808136,
-0.0036117362,
-0.0089707933,
-0.0389460325,
0.0411936864,
0.0136400051,
0.0207400788,
0.0275007747,
-0.0230473597,
0.0266907103,
0.005090382,
0.0039971224,
0.0383118801,
-0.0253035538,
-0.0050739083,
-0.0395210311,
0.0274947304,
0.0417633504,
0.0439669751,
-0.0361643024,
-0.009951801,
0.0560907498,
0.0597299151,
-0.0010548962,
-0.013097126,
0.055597838,
0.0308114681,
-0.0120819882,
0.0104561513,
-0.0540695824,
0.0270513576,
-0.0285018291,
-0.017944077,
0.048313681,
-0.0011058603,
-0.0119569693,
-0.0491859354,
-0.0241849329,
0.0065103155,
-0.008773488,
0.003245638,
0.0416092351,
-0.0020812242,
0.0374139734,
0.0690881237,
0.0926489234,
-0.0357343592,
0.0004868123,
-0.0589971505,
0.037324626,
0.048243966,
0.0054019312,
0.002290257,
0.0233318694,
0.0237372145,
-0.0425319448,
0.0206862353,
0.0701422915,
-0.0076530324,
-0.0128240073,
-0.0205153469,
-0.0423410982,
-0.0134045519,
0.0492246076,
0.0215153694,
0.0262779091,
-0.0292006321,
0.0216792431,
-0.1264790148,
-0.0261242073,
0.0223615877,
0.0362121798,
0.0117919585,
-0.0059786206,
0.0233131051,
0.0436239727,
0.0094685024,
0.0004155372,
0.010447518,
-0.0044018063,
-0.0055945995,
0.0000427044,
-0.0219818242,
-0.0192484129,
-0.0287841037,
0.0095625529,
-0.0592747815,
-0.0340757594,
-0.0298069492,
-0.0517739318,
-0.0118468497,
-0.012519381,
-0.0190886073,
-0.0297723021,
-0.0445325375,
-0.0134306848,
-0.0130649656,
-0.007989388,
-0.0549127832,
0.0816282853,
0.0219658427,
0.02039125,
-0.0220039058,
0.0309183113,
0.0144007076,
-0.002766239,
-0.0261344276,
-0.0299270805,
0.0114856474,
0.0126332873,
0.0318367407,
0.0079972995,
-0.0311590917,
-0.0316117592,
-0.0736700147,
-0.0260040555,
-0.0050777439,
-0.0163202286,
0.0099947797,
-0.0210911073,
0.0183660835,
-0.0083483346,
-0.0301169958,
-0.0159059167,
-0.0468441136,
0.0426736102,
0.0387858525,
-0.0040110657,
-0.0097864876,
-0.0389753319,
-0.0110676065,
-0.0176070891,
0.0493169539,
0.0529489964,
-0.0320040882,
-0.0962400138,
-0.0055412073,
-0.0559596494,
0.0091202203,
-0.0038006161,
-0.0412630811,
0.0452934578,
0.0190438814,
0.0576687828,
0.0633712187,
0.0127538284,
0.0286236666,
0.0553429648,
0.0126145566,
-0.0587247014,
-0.0023429533,
-0.0111043351,
-0.0337196253,
-0.0427342728,
-0.0562378652,
0.0010940842,
0.0602949634,
0.0139547205,
-0.0173966587,
-0.0717559606,
0.0275420919,
-0.0164122209,
-0.0290995017,
-0.0326842442,
-0.0216219407,
-0.0106494734,
0.0779732391,
0.0034274266,
-0.0588867925,
0.0931687951,
-0.0214305613,
0.0436990671,
0.0038344893,
-0.0317806751,
-0.0513183326,
0.065774031,
0.0063431677,
-0.0076656435,
-0.0298254155,
0.0144444928,
-0.0319552794,
0.0223602355,
0.0668090358,
-0.0050643873,
0.0184846018,
-0.0675739571,
0.0024641715,
-0.0172810331,
-0.027182797,
-0.0057243826,
-0.0574548542,
-0.0729473531,
-0.0167370569,
0.0738038868,
-0.0022414499,
-0.0296714474,
0.0376319513,
0.0270158239,
-0.0136254411,
-0.0018893947,
0.0286371969,
-0.021027917,
-0.0110793784,
0.0143226376,
0.0309134889,
0.0204048902,
-0.0598110482,
-0.0359219015,
0.0189161636,
-0.0200738274,
0.0060743499,
-0.0181894023,
-0.0036023844,
0.026416786,
0.0252814218,
-0.0229859594,
0.0495995246,
0.1088109463,
-0.0126017611,
0.0162682142,
0.0934908837,
-0.0036455749,
-0.071224086,
0.0199646708,
-0.0047537005,
0.0570686907,
0.0115645332,
-0.0226197261,
-0.0485775471,
-0.0642154738,
0.0088840863,
0.0130082155,
-0.0024769327,
-0.0241814423,
0.0202013999,
-0.0920035765,
0.0339971632,
-0.0021726834,
-0.0448960662,
-0.0068385983,
-0.0583824217,
0.0576746911,
-0.0159790777,
-0.031086728,
-0.0143321613,
0.0471128412,
0.0250785481,
0.0361265391,
-0.003419549,
-0.0342336707,
0.0652958006,
-0.0695138648,
0.0582230538,
0.012065188,
0.0207346175,
0.0092684161,
-0.0940503776,
0.0285413042,
-0.0023722034,
0.0444406569,
0.0173466373,
0.0747896135,
-0.0018559359,
-0.0119409924,
-0.0609124862,
0.0268240049,
-0.0094092134,
-0.0095479097,
-0.0115156565,
0.043197453,
-0.0038704439,
-0.0223353915,
-0.0263554137,
0.0147986514,
-0.0203865953,
0.0783982426,
0.0530880205,
-0.0674961284,
-0.0323520862,
-0.0079311319,
-0.0112805162,
-0.0009579228,
-0.0835195258,
0.0533242673,
-0.0067211953,
-0.0757829472,
-0.0191482883,
-0.0182462148,
0.0014919925,
0.0213219542,
0.0104271108,
-0.0166050028,
0.0194639526,
0.0174519867,
0.0390167609,
0.0820974782,
-0.0512715615,
0.0242357366,
-0.0285082031,
-0.0100840861,
0.0216736197,
-0.0040958896,
-0.0322975032,
0.043229375,
-0.0866602883,
-0.0481518842,
-0.0090946741,
0.0046591247,
0.0161778238,
0.0364536196,
0.000938042,
-0.0826205239,
0.000458515,
0.0450690016,
-0.0199257117,
0.0163900256,
-0.0012754691,
0.016785128,
-0.0039856732,
0.041556336,
-0.0325085223,
0.0373103023,
0.0462471992,
0.0145730963,
-0.0357206725,
-0.100160487,
0.0179815516,
0.0143790124,
0.0546100698,
-0.0258422568,
-0.0318252146,
-0.0288668461,
-0.0343967266,
0.0146048944,
-0.0511785001,
-0.028798582,
-0.0279653836,
0.0219428279,
-0.0459106378,
-0.0038211916,
-0.0004596773,
0.0151756611,
0.047868751,
-0.0149725461,
0.0096626673,
0.065543592,
0.0379714556,
0.003329582,
-0.0036555654,
-0.030935932,
-0.0254939049,
-0.0380435288,
0.0492247827,
0.016496323,
0.0367254429,
0.0247571412,
0.0021114815,
-0.0103391465,
-0.0062282598,
-0.0488673002,
-0.0328336917,
0.0013613019,
0.0192885324,
0.0126689617,
-0.0009168502,
0.0243525114,
0.024132831,
-0.0171111207,
0.0007838676,
0.0477847308,
-0.0018091016,
0.0177833717,
0.0538267381,
0.0153684216,
-0.0200837813,
-0.0070882831,
0.0465504378,
0.0254486427,
-0.0109005384,
-0.0385360084,
-0.0325016528,
-0.0207142066,
0.0011732212,
-0.0333837233,
-0.0015944109,
0.0101504894,
0.0245788842,
-0.0818642899,
-0.0563155264,
-0.0414017215,
0.0187202264,
-0.0142999813,
-0.0014628323,
0.0139756445,
0.0737018138,
-0.0190820191,
-0.0465829,
-0.0404632725,
-0.0048040426,
0.033104036,
0.0356560163,
-0.0611983873,
-6.69791024e-33,
-0.0204062741,
-0.0628981069,
-0.0337667242,
-0.0592981502,
-0.0009377212,
-0.0073149954,
0.0099687101,
0.0107115749,
-0.0300503243,
0.0632681176,
0.0157902557,
-0.0012654195,
0.0157928094,
-0.0109202228,
0.0173769668,
-0.0278419666,
0.0316354409,
0.0314366147,
-0.0269902684,
0.0253594611,
0.005001408,
-0.0352488607,
0.0596816316,
-0.1094118953,
0.0900680423,
0.0248856805,
0.0032498138,
0.0353472456,
-0.0249430593,
0.0314772613,
0.0143067455,
0.0510182828,
0.0206917524,
-0.0312245563,
-0.0023302594,
0.0104992529,
-0.0681732446,
-0.014347692,
0.0608612895,
-0.0056483923,
-0.0465822965,
-0.0187174678,
0.0455886945,
0.0157401953,
-0.0102267023,
-0.0070193755,
0.0775970817,
-0.0292913821,
-0.0033355735,
-0.0070859231,
0.0158419032,
0.0426564701,
-0.025700571,
0.0004022403,
-0.0235373471,
0.0182180144,
-0.016751023,
0.0631002709,
-0.0689475909,
0.0270134751,
0.0336783081,
-0.0097297998,
0.0327430964,
0.0099522779,
-0.007819023,
0.0667802915,
0.0056452528,
0.0287804045,
-0.0606276691,
-0.0931282118,
-0.0054765786,
0.0639901683,
0.0498282611,
0.0648486242,
0.0235557165,
0.015633177,
-0.0409887061,
0.0115885371,
-0.0297407657,
0.0153594725,
0.0413095281,
0.0185557306,
-0.0659466386,
-0.0285056774,
-0.0516778491,
-0.0472689532,
-0.050293006,
0.0328005627,
0.0134722963,
-0.0299646333,
-0.0172226764,
-0.0155087495,
0.0097816028,
-0.0302675273,
0.0156754144,
-0.0164368264,
0.0067094881,
0.0027923854,
-0.0072575239,
-0.0028834029,
-0.030587947,
-0.0103282044,
-0.0090723149,
0.017558055,
0.0199721083,
0.0032687183,
0.0553823709,
-0.0337260291,
-0.0238141716,
-0.0036012949,
-0.0370274745,
-0.0484618768,
-0.0510827824,
-0.0226081293,
0.0649963468,
0.0238913521,
-0.0330904834,
0.0451215543,
0.0192943141,
0.0268272385,
0.0268176328,
-0.0245694295,
-0.0205456857,
0.0015110594,
-0.0242799409,
-0.0103097232,
-0.0203233212,
-0.0407260396,
0.0332423113,
-0.0103927162,
-0.0131735615,
0.0322224945,
2.656e-7,
0.0385097414,
0.0407970101,
-0.0105797891,
0.0073963176,
0.0183157232,
0.0797775909,
0.0412601046,
-0.029509183,
0.0538303368,
-0.0673114508,
0.0120143648,
0.0431394912,
0.0394073874,
0.0257419907,
-0.0386047922,
0.0113087287,
-0.0653053001,
-0.0154333785,
-0.0019837399,
0.013900158,
0.0623278953,
0.0612630881,
0.0578660443,
-0.0049222242,
-0.0077988291,
-0.0376417413,
0.0556445122,
-0.0304828379,
-0.0106427055,
0.0325707197,
0.0543429293,
-0.0252752341,
0.0396640263,
0.0568121523,
0.0239007864,
-0.0106358686,
0.0164429788,
0.027214393,
-0.0292903613,
0.003604877,
-0.0347517766,
-0.0265178941,
0.0253717117,
-0.0327381119,
0.0550296307,
-0.0413239524,
-0.0622735471,
-0.0082478868,
-0.0109760975,
-0.0256191175,
0.0024393038,
0.0023095603,
-0.0133085493,
0.0257690735,
-0.0089324424,
-0.0100407526,
-0.0375936814,
-0.0512433983,
-0.0455545336,
0.0191299357,
-0.0510634743,
-0.0518210828,
-0.0016316617,
0.0037760956,
0.0315157101,
-0.0431117751,
0.0321044996,
1.94392511e-34,
0.0450142361,
0.013649134,
0.0136751989,
-0.0135035049,
0.0905401856,
0.0339445435,
-0.0403557979,
-0.025666669,
0.0449777804,
-0.0444294401,
-0.0073674689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17588v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17588v2 | LongIns: A Challenging Long-context Instruction-based Exam for LLMs | 2024-06-25T14:31:26 | 2024-06-26T13:28:04 | Shawn Gavin, Tuney Zheng, Jiaheng Liu, Quehry Que, Noah Wang, Jian Yang, Chenchen Zhang, Wenhao Huang, Wenhu Chen, Ge Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The long-context capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have been a hot
topic in recent years. To evaluate the performance of LLMs in different
scenarios, various assessment benchmarks have emerged. However, as most of
these benchmarks focus on identifying key information to answer questions,
which mainly requires the retrieval ability of LLMs, these benchmarks can
partially represent the reasoning performance of LLMs from large amounts of
information. Meanwhile, although LLMs often claim to have context windows of
32k, 128k, 200k, or even longer, these benchmarks fail to reveal the actual
supported length of these LLMs. To address these issues, we propose the LongIns
benchmark dataset, a challenging long-context instruction-based exam for LLMs,
which is built based on the existing instruction datasets. Specifically, in our
LongIns, we introduce three evaluation settings: Global Instruction & Single
Task (GIST), Local Instruction & Single Task (LIST), and Local Instruction &
Multiple Tasks (LIMT). Based on LongIns, we perform comprehensive evaluations
on existing LLMs and have the following important findings: (1). The
top-performing GPT-4 with 128k context length performs poorly on the evaluation
context window of 16k in our LongIns. (2). For the multi-hop reasoning ability
of many existing LLMs, significant efforts are still needed under short context
windows (less than 4k). | [
-0.008756944,
0.039369382,
-0.0178143084,
0.0712118223,
-0.0639229417,
0.0205875691,
0.0233527422,
0.0000782602,
0.0106024351,
-0.0510865003,
-0.0230490621,
-0.0680123642,
-0.018122647,
-0.0335265808,
0.0272367205,
-0.0160022713,
0.0572473183,
-0.059841264,
-0.0157929659,
-0.0162336901,
-0.0273962151,
-0.0035994209,
-0.008578511,
0.0005072713,
0.0215920564,
-0.040263515,
-0.0179761164,
-0.0050822846,
0.0088023199,
-0.040695101,
0.0073522096,
0.0354670547,
0.0210027099,
0.0204507578,
0.0000020535,
-0.0406385474,
-0.0085576279,
0.0109704249,
-0.0483608618,
0.0430590622,
0.0055205026,
0.0254028197,
-0.0082402946,
0.0291301273,
-0.0297550187,
0.0121528041,
-0.0021587438,
0.0096679507,
0.0562572069,
0.07900206,
0.0193193313,
-0.0399193279,
0.0406697616,
-0.0280306675,
0.0423075706,
-0.0569529906,
0.0136536565,
0.005115808,
0.0463847816,
0.0136249391,
-0.0100099724,
0.0156360567,
0.0630648509,
0.0354490727,
-0.0683070496,
0.0240508225,
-0.0406129621,
0.0421399511,
0.0102070598,
0.0576606616,
0.0107815843,
-0.000196654,
-0.0168569628,
0.0124993036,
-0.0070619634,
-0.0317923352,
-0.0457911566,
0.0542175435,
-0.0074127945,
-0.0000924847,
0.038923081,
-0.0069052852,
0.0358604752,
0.0062818541,
-0.0577939749,
0.0949274004,
0.0383404195,
-0.0461428203,
-0.0020650735,
-0.0134082828,
-0.044447571,
-0.0327093899,
-0.0245983638,
0.0525162444,
-0.0262314733,
0.0269800648,
-0.014922251,
0.0261321384,
0.0346287638,
-0.0086141173,
0.0167036485,
0.03895697,
-0.0190531164,
0.054635819,
-0.0351910554,
0.0745846778,
-0.0127291,
0.0277930815,
-0.0425950289,
-0.0237184931,
-0.0404325351,
0.0128232222,
-0.0191443246,
0.0302745588,
-0.0472916961,
0.0155194113,
-0.0428402424,
0.0286917761,
-0.0297008343,
0.025893487,
0.0110343825,
-0.0289781,
-0.0148341786,
0.0025075832,
-0.0407073386,
0.0085847247,
-0.0414382741,
-0.0027914899,
0.0112986099,
-0.0556815974,
-0.0270706732,
0.0166569725,
-0.0088154301,
-0.0612959675,
0.0372362398,
0.0667759776,
0.0093640164,
-0.0319103226,
-0.0447971448,
-0.032007575,
-0.0203929357,
-0.0976272747,
0.0133393938,
-0.0705431849,
0.0173723642,
0.0109887104,
-0.0113784093,
-0.0055438494,
0.0061324155,
0.0390963964,
0.0235322583,
0.0535474196,
0.0363610536,
-0.0068373932,
0.0020362425,
0.0401367135,
0.0099420305,
0.073429659,
0.0052782879,
0.0242818687,
0.0431579873,
-0.0124984831,
-0.0236450303,
0.033269342,
0.0316878892,
0.0259941369,
-0.0119410232,
0.0626710206,
0.0342071131,
0.0127019184,
-0.0061618695,
0.0653744116,
-0.0180592537,
-0.037504144,
0.0224171281,
0.0591813438,
0.0303450618,
-0.0208323598,
0.0535691455,
0.0100382427,
-0.0015827417,
0.0155601604,
-0.062966533,
0.0137570975,
-0.0375567488,
0.0383378156,
0.0334848836,
0.0108902771,
-0.0307534747,
-0.0290322527,
-0.0228982344,
0.0049041412,
-0.0220701005,
0.0453128666,
0.0462754779,
-0.034722548,
-0.0377041325,
0.0677417219,
0.0228994004,
-0.0481169075,
-0.0253182929,
-0.0553668365,
0.0226770844,
0.0414085612,
0.0386361592,
-0.029084025,
-0.0662818328,
0.0116918255,
0.0305069722,
0.0242536999,
0.0450690389,
-0.0085282186,
0.0179223772,
-0.0309834294,
-0.0172022898,
-0.0402811095,
0.0035677883,
0.0097235432,
0.0527695045,
0.0194609538,
0.0333182774,
-0.0627456009,
0.0244038254,
0.0169769675,
-0.045618277,
-0.0425724275,
-0.0322485454,
0.0144036626,
0.0361790806,
0.0139675513,
-0.0075714104,
0.0147962049,
0.0478153303,
-0.030587567,
0.0172254797,
-0.0395713337,
-0.0656304732,
-0.042002663,
0.0523796827,
-0.0163913462,
-0.0189839732,
0.0223635174,
-0.040651191,
-0.0640550256,
0.0080167959,
-0.0127608003,
0.0225912202,
-0.0288252179,
0.0124930525,
-0.0032043185,
0.0047016912,
-0.0452444628,
0.0739121065,
-0.0011413774,
0.0426856726,
0.0356635191,
0.0488521643,
0.0291293617,
-0.0642825067,
-0.0498281792,
0.0176232234,
-0.0075953007,
-0.0076137278,
-0.0123526808,
0.0305465106,
-0.0620917715,
-0.0302004833,
-0.1167945266,
0.0484376587,
-0.0398167931,
0.0414390005,
0.0153960912,
-0.0107996007,
-0.0033427535,
0.0212249346,
-0.0616352595,
-0.0184136592,
0.013633037,
0.0357365794,
0.0017513187,
0.0257424712,
-0.0261619557,
-0.0216033459,
-0.0338916592,
-0.0224403869,
0.0273798704,
-0.0422618017,
0.0237399228,
-0.0328803025,
0.0320885032,
-0.0157792401,
0.0140580824,
-0.025792677,
-0.0098306024,
0.0276974533,
-0.0425519235,
0.0266566314,
0.0545651577,
-0.0112782586,
0.0098385699,
0.0334460959,
-0.0276276581,
-0.0502928793,
0.0497004762,
0.0224277787,
-0.036918845,
-0.0389242098,
-0.0143154813,
-0.0274098814,
0.0706664473,
-0.0195937287,
-0.0240082145,
-0.0179173239,
-0.009908407,
-0.0224139299,
0.0021644409,
-0.0227805395,
0.0315582454,
0.004690168,
0.0305403862,
-0.0298007447,
-0.0568563379,
0.0591589697,
-0.0508683771,
0.0034233702,
-0.0375570878,
-0.0090691755,
-0.0630840212,
0.0990723372,
-0.0044968748,
-0.0156450104,
-0.0394463651,
-0.0105000865,
-0.0417423397,
0.0055145253,
-0.0055799265,
-0.0470112562,
0.0777600557,
-0.0502385087,
0.0171257388,
-0.0345066041,
-0.0498129912,
-0.0384751298,
0.0251653958,
-0.0052148048,
0.031567879,
0.003853858,
0.000924634,
-0.0086273905,
-0.0035369601,
0.0128963599,
0.0329759605,
-0.0258818269,
0.0272816177,
-0.0181198046,
0.0204582922,
0.0373051576,
0.001549748,
0.0075834095,
-0.0529988669,
0.0442811809,
0.0570833012,
0.0672489181,
-0.0101921177,
-0.0065455162,
0.0091895172,
0.025929084,
-0.0513439998,
-0.0235036854,
0.0457293652,
0.0749292597,
-0.0899500698,
-0.0339888856,
0.1282634288,
0.0231233332,
-0.0457432382,
-0.0056799939,
-0.0066683702,
0.013418626,
0.0332278162,
0.0391867384,
-0.0944440737,
-0.0400458723,
0.0151622575,
-0.0039444538,
-0.0097711897,
-0.0207210518,
-0.0051252656,
-0.1264143586,
0.022326665,
0.0050728554,
-0.0517845489,
-0.0144969504,
-0.0328031145,
-0.0084456289,
0.0231588073,
0.0457157828,
0.0374412797,
-0.0103145745,
-0.013663169,
0.0031536825,
0.003417592,
-0.0258004069,
0.1032355204,
-0.0099879988,
0.0470782667,
0.0125212334,
0.0020875116,
-0.0049354983,
-0.0538559966,
0.0551228002,
-0.0614139065,
0.0089897038,
-0.0048920834,
0.0206169412,
-0.0098983757,
-0.0024374004,
-0.0041046441,
0.0173823927,
-0.0414573289,
-0.003121498,
0.0550138094,
0.1041707322,
-0.0307792276,
0.0034623831,
-0.0220160522,
-0.0203814581,
-0.0127435215,
0.0719383433,
0.0145612117,
-0.0097015547,
-0.0535434186,
-0.033700496,
-0.0420622937,
-0.0497026779,
0.0016004642,
0.0283350833,
-0.0013364133,
0.0353105813,
-0.0211802367,
-0.0433223248,
0.0470888987,
0.0554656722,
-0.0138740465,
0.0149512477,
-0.0109446459,
0.0099835526,
-0.0765535906,
0.0430238284,
-0.0607101433,
0.0396493785,
-0.0847527608,
0.0036611587,
0.0200222172,
-0.0041825152,
-0.0158854891,
0.0318747051,
-0.1109751016,
-0.0474540666,
-0.0306988768,
0.0265130736,
0.0219976846,
0.0418521725,
-0.0137057593,
-0.0144870291,
0.0394381322,
-0.0414318033,
-0.0288320836,
0.0276569519,
0.0245095212,
0.0012769311,
0.0015094717,
0.0295505654,
-0.041216597,
0.0146455485,
0.035448283,
0.0406186655,
-0.0023902105,
-0.0110840909,
0.0138156014,
0.0363672152,
0.0085672922,
0.0309997071,
-0.0142011764,
0.0082803713,
0.0597014055,
-0.0286063496,
-0.008074224,
-0.0147844749,
-0.0045448067,
0.0227550883,
-0.0470863208,
0.016222883,
-0.0130961407,
0.0197781287,
0.0156544168,
-0.0286990572,
0.0419957899,
-0.0038817129,
0.0033645511,
0.0220007356,
-0.011179748,
-0.0307010245,
-0.0221353229,
-0.0095636481,
0.0607822724,
-0.0206315275,
0.0838188604,
0.0044631753,
0.0130870296,
-0.0046661641,
0.0177969057,
-0.0788806602,
-0.021579776,
0.0099528106,
0.020541586,
0.0482550338,
0.0016733105,
0.0131463306,
-0.0053999377,
-0.0002344679,
-0.0305494685,
0.0069304435,
0.0058785914,
-0.0401971266,
0.0354986638,
0.0765486136,
0.0095561901,
0.0250199791,
0.0739615932,
0.02011583,
0.0420428254,
0.0414630398,
0.0122687547,
-0.0377647243,
-0.0450057536,
-0.0130435536,
0.0233245026,
-0.0029126974,
0.0078975363,
-0.0444701761,
-0.0857856348,
0.0075944443,
0.021479046,
-0.0018113927,
-0.0126345642,
0.0184460357,
0.0726207346,
0.0031059922,
-0.0521870852,
-0.0280619431,
0.0089737829,
-0.0109351128,
-0.0116130961,
-0.0042556571,
-6.102022032e-33,
-0.0273646899,
-0.0228336379,
0.0723251626,
-0.0349715017,
-0.0244775321,
0.0185381044,
-0.0258416329,
-0.0102243247,
-0.0150057441,
-0.0097745918,
-0.0289050266,
0.0279488489,
0.0035197823,
0.0435198136,
-0.0071994313,
-0.0297085568,
0.0038655361,
0.0145628396,
0.0010292105,
0.0376650691,
0.0152171999,
-0.0089056222,
0.0403932706,
-0.0086295614,
0.0206867643,
-0.010084006,
0.0307196807,
0.0147227412,
-0.0682725981,
0.0779491365,
-0.0048784479,
0.0398653708,
0.0377700292,
-0.058570873,
0.0033454651,
-0.0145801762,
-0.0583186112,
-0.0399568193,
0.0287233405,
-0.0137059717,
-0.0362796672,
-0.0541314594,
0.0159348547,
0.0131646143,
-0.0199718438,
-0.0454413444,
-0.0033970766,
-0.0330736823,
-0.0276343077,
-0.0040127449,
-0.0157264713,
0.0316472501,
-0.001243711,
0.0013789817,
0.0131282508,
0.0152086737,
0.0004298083,
0.0203957818,
-0.030388359,
0.0066861496,
0.0027966502,
0.064531967,
0.0751879588,
-0.0078831008,
0.0136417877,
0.0304863472,
0.0078054471,
0.0246224925,
-0.0025032749,
-0.020109145,
0.0101222554,
0.0663723648,
0.0362586267,
0.0178632177,
0.0366685241,
0.0078893006,
-0.0879473016,
0.0088394014,
0.0337452367,
0.0451773927,
0.0258324426,
-0.0068587959,
-0.0514773242,
-0.0143019836,
-0.0483028218,
0.0348339267,
-0.0391149968,
-0.0120328357,
0.0558625683,
-0.0137017379,
0.0154420501,
-0.0109029897,
0.0388823748,
-0.0372846127,
-0.0032410452,
0.023819007,
0.0000583543,
0.0105988588,
-0.004040482,
0.0626343414,
-0.0252473392,
-0.0319432132,
0.0024387296,
-0.0144909844,
0.0198961832,
-0.0132811824,
0.0210191458,
0.0087855272,
-0.0569310337,
-0.0371780917,
-0.0763780177,
0.0170005858,
-0.0241308287,
0.0179470647,
0.043952249,
0.0249297954,
0.0221906006,
0.0819630101,
-0.023308659,
-0.0277785193,
-0.0230190828,
-0.0215828847,
-0.0028324502,
0.0029775894,
-0.0116878068,
0.0085522439,
-0.0314331241,
0.0245712399,
-0.0034393817,
-0.042218715,
0.0111653553,
0.0426419303,
2.709e-7,
0.0229737423,
0.0287322979,
0.0237745438,
0.0422877856,
0.0139839211,
-0.0033937455,
-0.0344629027,
-0.0113118514,
0.0015284511,
-0.0271919314,
-0.0080100195,
0.0433213338,
0.0496073812,
0.0400660858,
-0.0641107634,
0.0216659475,
-0.0141195217,
-0.0148741817,
-0.0545942448,
0.0254526548,
0.0642057583,
0.096031338,
-0.0122724092,
-0.0051670396,
0.0042330143,
-0.049732659,
0.0258140173,
-0.045075357,
-0.0322349742,
0.01907341,
0.0146187246,
0.0125944596,
0.0165304337,
0.0283799022,
0.0060107838,
0.0096459044,
-0.03089929,
0.0810730532,
0.0223817993,
-0.0592429526,
-0.0066535883,
-0.0531218462,
-0.0251156073,
-0.0374221765,
0.1145654172,
-0.0271151047,
-0.0390402377,
-0.0204871129,
-0.012386024,
-0.0468808897,
-0.0130816177,
0.0190590322,
0.0130931474,
0.0052369721,
-0.0028999466,
-0.0513741001,
0.0075015947,
-0.0901015475,
-0.0132517954,
0.0248234216,
-0.0415627733,
-0.0637463927,
-0.0555144921,
-0.0058997902,
0.0297820233,
-0.0696131438,
-0.0325226039,
2.970707946e-34,
0.0397830531,
-0.029285403,
0.0302004181,
-0.0005787821,
0.0398381054,
-0.0181042776,
-0.0568653941,
0.0031590327,
0.0015138077,
-0.092845358,
-0.0190568026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17574v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17574v1 | Beyond Text-to-SQL for IoT Defense: A Comprehensive Framework for Querying and Classifying IoT Threats | 2024-06-25T14:14:35 | 2024-06-25T14:14:35 | Ryan Pavlich, Nima Ebadi, Richard Tarbell, Billy Linares, Adrian Tan, Rachael Humphreys, Jayanta Kumar Das, Rambod Ghandiparsi, Hannah Haley, Jerris George, Rocky Slavin, Kim-Kwang Raymond Choo, Glenn Dietrich, Anthony Rios | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recognizing the promise of natural language interfaces to databases, prior
studies have emphasized the development of text-to-SQL systems. While
substantial progress has been made in this field, existing research has
concentrated on generating SQL statements from text queries. The broader
challenge, however, lies in inferring new information about the returned data.
Our research makes two major contributions to address this gap. First, we
introduce a novel Internet-of-Things (IoT) text-to-SQL dataset comprising
10,985 text-SQL pairs and 239,398 rows of network traffic activity. The dataset
contains additional query types limited in prior text-to-SQL datasets, notably
temporal-related queries. Our dataset is sourced from a smart building's IoT
ecosystem exploring sensor read and network traffic data. Second, our dataset
allows two-stage processing, where the returned data (network traffic) from a
generated SQL can be categorized as malicious or not. Our results show that
joint training to query and infer information about the data can improve
overall text-to-SQL performance, nearly matching substantially larger models.
We also show that current large language models (e.g., GPT3.5) struggle to
infer new information about returned data, thus our dataset provides a novel
test bed for integrating complex domain-specific reasoning into LLMs. | [
-0.0100571839,
0.079563275,
-0.0079133529,
0.0268057846,
-0.0587799884,
-0.0195292737,
0.0060460097,
0.0056741606,
0.0422976129,
-0.0695841014,
0.0443085954,
0.022905333,
-0.0243226998,
0.0337019116,
0.0596830025,
0.0150076365,
0.0611095056,
-0.0128849847,
-0.0104581388,
0.0603797995,
0.0039142147,
0.0244474653,
-0.0024858483,
0.0072540417,
-0.0081661558,
-0.0024600995,
-0.0333219953,
0.0215474404,
0.0202800911,
-0.0512565672,
0.0023674271,
0.0156544093,
0.0466859415,
0.01714007,
0.0000016931,
-0.0475456901,
-0.0657954589,
0.0052601909,
-0.0337176658,
-0.042824246,
0.0290580522,
-0.0366327986,
0.0139749926,
0.063057892,
-0.0565735251,
-0.0073320172,
0.0286606196,
0.0790305585,
0.0227332395,
0.1003995538,
-0.0307520311,
-0.0192445815,
0.03405663,
-0.0064707035,
0.0410431437,
-0.0094843451,
-0.0010651583,
-0.0293947551,
0.0271165874,
0.0115040801,
0.0374112315,
-0.0368211493,
0.0046169865,
0.0178671349,
-0.0123883607,
0.0234071705,
-0.0278978944,
0.0669077635,
-0.0419161767,
0.026164189,
-0.0052538994,
-0.0304177441,
0.0408123024,
-0.0065316432,
-0.023409633,
-0.031660784,
0.0025383979,
-0.0297011659,
0.0159756728,
0.0283660796,
0.0054886192,
0.0060044578,
0.0553846173,
0.0244958233,
-0.0495188572,
0.0799290314,
-0.0270498488,
-0.0131987995,
0.0174960252,
-0.0596915595,
0.0129984813,
-0.0301664956,
-0.0201351307,
0.0678004995,
-0.0164882895,
0.0047438806,
-0.0451445058,
0.0126180407,
0.0103826383,
-0.0264860094,
-0.0285412297,
0.0123467473,
0.0214470439,
0.036563877,
0.0172076728,
-0.0007504818,
-0.0064910934,
0.0347232185,
-0.0194419697,
-0.0401917584,
-0.0740602687,
-0.0357091501,
-0.0086759357,
0.054587245,
-0.0023851227,
-0.0062984978,
-0.0177800227,
0.0172865056,
0.0034390276,
0.0282748397,
-0.0314144418,
0.0117052728,
0.0046237814,
-0.0109395757,
-0.0127127804,
-0.0347280949,
-0.0021235263,
0.0513634346,
-0.0274291318,
-0.0853063464,
-0.034720771,
0.0166802593,
-0.0051312093,
-0.0587451532,
-0.0333723649,
0.0972474888,
0.0138819357,
-0.0227332041,
-0.0846804827,
-0.0801815465,
0.0209090039,
-0.0111022964,
0.0035846541,
-0.0299562216,
-0.0020689126,
-0.0085816383,
-0.0056028436,
-0.0599806458,
-0.0126078995,
0.0095936023,
-0.0046358262,
0.0796269402,
-0.04810315,
-0.0005769997,
-0.0047094505,
0.0045084301,
0.0338040255,
0.0360223278,
0.0567820072,
0.0194252171,
0.0009752596,
-0.0031750759,
0.0189110879,
0.0042827274,
0.0529261194,
-0.0169847999,
-0.0326450393,
0.0663025975,
-0.0461758077,
-0.0076637943,
-0.039797388,
0.0119449589,
0.029900264,
0.0021551251,
0.04391592,
0.0228914842,
0.0035010807,
0.0205321945,
-0.0153788412,
0.0842347667,
-0.0141050452,
-0.0330536328,
-0.0767917559,
-0.0032831016,
-0.0579739213,
-0.0262410492,
0.0113115367,
-0.0389820263,
-0.0186853446,
-0.0455603302,
-0.0226521119,
-0.0318535417,
0.0270961393,
-0.0019628492,
0.0285815615,
0.0309406873,
-0.0058632148,
0.0162537713,
-0.0194941722,
0.0000466993,
-0.016262928,
-0.0500896983,
-0.0161798522,
0.0636864081,
0.0320884846,
-0.0863169059,
-0.0050763902,
-0.0244932715,
-0.0049821809,
0.0045876214,
0.0037511673,
0.0151641406,
0.0226185042,
-0.0120579265,
-0.0132770231,
0.0280597489,
0.0551772565,
-0.0429316722,
-0.0230110101,
-0.0096033774,
0.027034102,
-0.0622362904,
-0.045988854,
0.0273485128,
0.0319167487,
-0.0675561875,
0.0508699678,
0.0347840525,
0.0458576269,
-0.0057946551,
0.0133777168,
0.0284787603,
0.0497196727,
0.0007073383,
-0.0836906582,
0.0015713261,
0.0363774449,
0.0240682643,
-0.0122500425,
0.009501853,
0.022283379,
0.0072730291,
-0.0666389614,
-0.0157726258,
0.0585283339,
-0.0427381471,
-0.0031387263,
-0.0140693309,
-0.0543733276,
0.0255926494,
-0.0020913384,
-0.0159217454,
0.0218937974,
0.0254975222,
-0.0457858928,
-0.0095768571,
-0.0367405228,
0.0386646092,
-0.0451524183,
0.0332725272,
-0.0563449301,
-0.0361782387,
0.027520135,
0.0081770103,
0.0403421707,
-0.0109528042,
0.0188961029,
-0.046194315,
0.0307385046,
-0.0231366642,
0.0666038245,
0.0055496115,
0.0261749402,
-0.0150641566,
-0.0269100349,
-0.0625338405,
-0.031869702,
-0.0178541467,
-0.0050899093,
0.0646046773,
0.0133626321,
-0.0012928451,
-0.0098428894,
-0.0047609536,
-0.048537299,
0.0538172498,
-0.0186217241,
-0.0144268246,
0.0189935323,
0.0190157797,
-0.0019056128,
0.0116596734,
-0.0276028384,
-0.0158119202,
0.0143603198,
-0.0420268215,
-0.0311777014,
0.029152723,
0.0253207926,
-0.0176597834,
0.0332708918,
-0.0245108306,
-0.0417215154,
0.027569253,
-0.0362099707,
0.0150448363,
-0.0331231058,
-0.0083144614,
0.037533205,
0.0106184613,
0.0314929299,
-0.0190653838,
-0.0317259394,
0.0351929069,
0.0598068573,
-0.0098559847,
-0.0447336584,
0.0286870021,
0.0262778327,
0.0260068141,
0.0262698904,
-0.0686683357,
0.0818478316,
-0.0027740831,
0.0492419749,
-0.0436101928,
-0.0443302095,
-0.0354634151,
0.0823945254,
0.0097712995,
0.006252754,
0.0127125643,
-0.0358657241,
-0.0234490819,
-0.068253383,
0.0055255848,
-0.0025913017,
0.0300128199,
-0.0564547032,
0.0164551716,
-0.0117834779,
-0.020673899,
-0.0444141179,
-0.0069593354,
-0.0408039615,
-0.0044577797,
-0.0487693325,
-0.0117318565,
-0.0010041208,
-0.0099250004,
-0.01811173,
0.0264489595,
-0.0178451519,
-0.0267632473,
0.0066200639,
-0.0282316003,
0.0339804664,
-0.0029366142,
-0.0379835553,
0.0477743186,
-0.0072710738,
0.0441151559,
0.0619928278,
-0.0247488283,
-0.0647976547,
0.011592689,
-0.0106119411,
-0.0135110579,
-0.007825546,
0.0487758517,
0.0047637466,
-0.0588209145,
-0.0034041707,
0.0884085372,
0.0082562529,
0.0578012057,
0.0005039712,
0.0204393622,
-0.0037088168,
-0.0091176545,
0.0169287417,
-0.0999218822,
-0.0601296872,
-0.004910809,
0.0550436862,
-0.007107208,
-0.052884873,
-0.0538007319,
-0.0913310945,
0.0243168492,
0.015924504,
0.008097453,
-0.0609643832,
-0.0449895747,
-0.0211095065,
-0.0402789041,
0.0141957114,
-0.0261493195,
0.0282066427,
-0.0066169091,
0.0023880475,
-0.0476742387,
-0.0409160964,
0.0007364959,
-0.0048501901,
0.0140413577,
0.0398504771,
0.0522925779,
0.0148186069,
0.0215338618,
0.025978867,
-0.0255480036,
-0.0080287196,
-0.0208689757,
0.0569091104,
0.022137139,
0.037479911,
0.0184085872,
0.0756396651,
-0.0431543738,
-0.0328147672,
0.0461845957,
0.0590120777,
-0.1025707424,
0.0028904632,
-0.0335132219,
-0.0386462323,
0.0468575284,
0.0668923184,
-0.0384168588,
0.002758723,
-0.0577099659,
-0.0361778252,
-0.0226005223,
-0.0234153699,
-0.0328452922,
0.0187896732,
0.0002089454,
-0.0531794094,
-0.0258781631,
-0.0220740885,
0.0087727085,
0.0033046708,
0.0301752128,
0.0475698784,
0.0300780218,
-0.0042492351,
-0.0553471372,
-0.0138485059,
-0.0133975148,
0.0370321535,
-0.0112522552,
0.0258625038,
0.0101356488,
-0.0512558371,
-0.0341581516,
0.0332260989,
-0.0947687104,
-0.04783554,
-0.0118051367,
0.0034953679,
0.0256850757,
0.0347428992,
-0.038414631,
-0.0232327878,
0.0314414836,
0.0760279596,
-0.0536186472,
-0.0834002718,
0.0498580262,
-0.0097238543,
0.0181608386,
0.0424923487,
-0.0616274811,
0.0030600275,
0.0007354349,
-0.0341473855,
-0.0482057407,
0.0127276462,
0.0534041785,
0.0397759713,
0.0772907212,
0.0385720655,
-0.00308658,
-0.0076798284,
0.0281732306,
-0.0220113639,
-0.0197023582,
-0.0058229296,
0.0342943259,
-0.0024336551,
0.0184693057,
-0.0102309249,
-0.0106387855,
0.0077586346,
-0.0049566599,
-0.0270997994,
-0.0086327726,
0.0413281024,
0.0392964594,
0.0411472172,
-0.0424099825,
0.0230724011,
0.0469840579,
0.0272847768,
0.0383513011,
-0.0422488153,
-0.0163944699,
0.0305754878,
0.0058016418,
-0.0472090878,
0.0312241707,
-0.0463276617,
-0.0306638852,
0.0531387143,
-0.0020962688,
0.0186755396,
0.0054361322,
0.0152099868,
-0.0554585084,
0.0263957437,
-0.0248083267,
0.0493054613,
-0.0031044488,
0.0136509268,
0.0321259126,
0.0063252165,
-0.050286606,
0.004917725,
0.0486564226,
0.0171073135,
0.0378072448,
0.0192466639,
-0.0756072998,
-0.0556060746,
-0.016562894,
0.0046421769,
0.0107226372,
-0.0105129443,
0.0081341229,
-0.0350830704,
-0.0187147241,
0.00815925,
-0.0041141072,
0.0015301688,
-0.0009766623,
0.0430853851,
0.068770051,
-0.0005486577,
-0.0203301404,
-0.050507158,
-0.0124780089,
-0.028156478,
-0.0550276823,
-0.0004080369,
-5.538227391e-33,
0.0215802155,
-0.0237337183,
0.0272295643,
0.0176647715,
0.0182008594,
-0.0193436444,
0.0044506416,
-0.0487771556,
-0.0317955278,
-0.0197467078,
-0.029907776,
0.0457448922,
0.01584672,
0.0376289338,
-0.0132221263,
-0.0510898754,
0.0358213745,
-0.0155434338,
0.0041459692,
0.0165648162,
0.0706337169,
-0.0041107265,
0.0498862453,
-0.0744038597,
0.027278319,
-0.0011065347,
-0.0349949077,
0.0338901766,
-0.0510500856,
0.0329038799,
0.0022845655,
0.0629470497,
0.0235721692,
0.0138837807,
-0.0223117135,
0.0076271994,
-0.0313740931,
-0.0280390214,
-0.0235369764,
-0.0050315396,
-0.0005751892,
-0.0619244613,
0.0581642427,
0.003451668,
-0.031880334,
-0.0029906717,
0.0357195139,
-0.0371706747,
0.0203032941,
-0.029790787,
-0.0043680998,
0.0351830386,
-0.049626898,
0.015224319,
0.0053885491,
0.0056986399,
0.0299666859,
-0.000954091,
-0.0859054774,
0.0342497751,
0.0207576342,
0.0472262613,
0.0235309973,
-0.0169737507,
0.0010499897,
0.0099097844,
-0.0013285456,
-0.0534945764,
0.0118469354,
0.0534842499,
-0.0174765214,
0.0637344867,
0.0139572453,
0.0415053181,
0.0439158753,
-0.0427280106,
-0.1307906508,
0.0473757349,
-0.0163567811,
0.0216315128,
0.0270770807,
-0.0252135098,
-0.0453525633,
-0.0220076889,
-0.0020845721,
-0.0135154715,
-0.0088482602,
0.0082085608,
0.0084930472,
0.0000904904,
0.0188841205,
-0.0158680528,
-0.0134700872,
-0.0118697789,
-0.0431006774,
0.032920558,
-0.0333370119,
-0.0586166233,
0.01973534,
0.0417003185,
-0.0205088947,
-0.0223985966,
0.0258545093,
-0.0038041468,
0.0340727605,
-0.0130291134,
0.0399524085,
0.0794264749,
-0.0610436015,
-0.0191790387,
0.0016733183,
0.0675752237,
-0.0544784032,
0.024649309,
0.0145158712,
-0.0033376389,
0.0451475941,
0.0653214976,
-0.0308207553,
-0.0401905589,
-0.0043135514,
0.0338770598,
0.0010065029,
0.0099713234,
0.004670233,
0.0082743028,
-0.0218329523,
-0.0119365864,
0.0528991073,
-0.0338885039,
-0.0046170014,
0.0222983379,
2.67e-7,
0.0406157114,
0.0105257574,
0.0117743416,
0.0759116635,
0.0237420294,
0.0874878243,
-0.0112671368,
0.0660476834,
-0.0024577202,
0.0175352339,
0.024027044,
-0.0215927549,
0.0546423793,
0.0378421359,
-0.0436945669,
-0.0100076385,
-0.0336586647,
-0.0173645802,
-0.076979503,
0.0034353442,
0.1087805554,
0.1130377725,
0.0098885838,
-0.0028852464,
0.0279642921,
-0.0728647411,
-0.0125308577,
-0.0115898103,
0.0092762234,
0.0082462896,
0.0528859049,
0.0303243771,
0.0161842741,
0.0543175302,
-0.0490781069,
0.0266902931,
-0.0641676039,
0.0332870483,
0.0165532045,
-0.0058780033,
-0.0260076616,
-0.067003727,
0.0233129337,
-0.0166284963,
0.0914152637,
-0.020114867,
-0.0117439404,
0.0545173176,
0.0187441614,
-0.0352568142,
-0.0062337113,
0.0051134932,
-0.0239746533,
-0.054189574,
0.0202487577,
0.002382973,
0.0331735536,
-0.0594314374,
-0.000182531,
0.009513217,
-0.0260596294,
0.0193822123,
-0.0250611454,
0.031519793,
0.0469944514,
-0.0023919721,
0.0023906685,
2.435380701e-34,
-0.0120948991,
-0.0021422838,
-0.0174072646,
-0.0220729243,
0.0331128724,
0.0162445661,
0.0013802749,
-0.0144804949,
0.0169456247,
-0.0434066989,
-0.0288989153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17566v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17566v1 | FrenchToxicityPrompts: a Large Benchmark for Evaluating and Mitigating Toxicity in French Texts | 2024-06-25T14:02:11 | 2024-06-25T14:02:11 | Caroline Brun, Vassilina Nikoulina | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly popular but are also prone to
generating bias, toxic or harmful language, which can have detrimental effects
on individuals and communities. Although most efforts is put to assess and
mitigate toxicity in generated content, it is primarily concentrated on
English, while it's essential to consider other languages as well. For
addressing this issue, we create and release FrenchToxicityPrompts, a dataset
of 50K naturally occurring French prompts and their continuations, annotated
with toxicity scores from a widely used toxicity classifier. We evaluate 14
different models from four prevalent open-sourced families of LLMs against our
dataset to assess their potential toxicity across various dimensions. We hope
that our contribution will foster future research on toxicity detection and
mitigation beyond Englis | [
0.0238832161,
0.080567129,
-0.0239410978,
0.0213706568,
0.006538759,
0.027965609,
0.019003598,
0.0162640344,
0.057645075,
-0.0327187218,
-0.0160680991,
0.0070245815,
-0.0272108391,
-0.0009474286,
0.0392999165,
0.0055118897,
0.0530962385,
0.0105435047,
-0.0113281179,
-0.0169098899,
0.0502894446,
0.0494557507,
0.0350458808,
0.0739874244,
-0.0217890292,
-0.0228740908,
0.0623888932,
0.0209639706,
0.0372945741,
-0.0500526018,
0.0062277345,
0.0341526382,
-0.0442352444,
0.0455259793,
0.0000018137,
-0.0221002027,
0.011324822,
0.0023293439,
0.0045083766,
-0.015185385,
0.084321022,
-0.0168582518,
-0.0272402205,
0.0405861847,
-0.0044521997,
0.0014971972,
0.0562103018,
-0.0023618562,
0.056110695,
0.0485026389,
-0.0270924307,
0.0172132142,
-0.0122291697,
0.003575806,
0.0150865149,
0.0474986397,
0.0677750185,
-0.0569194742,
-0.0092170099,
-0.0167807061,
-0.0455537103,
0.0290068351,
0.0166371297,
-0.0340784118,
-0.0390973128,
-0.0203490071,
0.0114408433,
-0.0599271394,
0.0157315806,
0.0717734993,
-0.0172322113,
-0.0244455338,
-0.012634987,
0.0070991805,
0.0111431945,
0.0044110268,
-0.0211794823,
0.0160091128,
0.0229295902,
0.0044513321,
0.0330238193,
0.0056289877,
0.0342244245,
0.0249583367,
0.0326460414,
0.0451916903,
0.0195805375,
-0.0200522821,
0.0518893674,
-0.015266858,
-0.0270847641,
-0.0130119529,
0.0209859274,
-0.0422271565,
-0.038012784,
0.0238703862,
-0.0280046109,
-0.0390676744,
0.0596265197,
-0.0973384455,
0.0044688964,
0.0097161531,
-0.0606461614,
0.0130932778,
0.0061679464,
-0.0269234162,
0.0004848062,
0.0112612946,
-0.0266095176,
0.0284879971,
0.0219009556,
-0.0004208763,
0.0015777402,
-0.0429848209,
0.0100555802,
0.0386833437,
-0.0128118563,
0.0043257312,
-0.0507072024,
-0.0040868255,
0.0322037302,
0.0125163887,
0.0111581534,
0.0230381172,
-0.0006044982,
0.0215906855,
-0.0359363705,
0.0258886702,
-0.0160656832,
-0.0772074834,
0.0178542305,
0.0132409185,
-0.0484339632,
-0.0449158065,
0.0078660799,
0.1001277417,
0.0222459882,
0.0061325687,
-0.0161382928,
-0.0338507034,
-0.0646478534,
-0.0349267013,
-0.055149097,
-0.0697267652,
0.0035911556,
-0.0320219509,
0.0117675355,
-0.0937856808,
0.0266160034,
0.0264373962,
-0.0785806701,
0.0303165503,
-0.048467651,
-0.0123949097,
0.0405644402,
0.0386713594,
-0.038498465,
0.0682226717,
0.0050197351,
0.0006273183,
0.0232440829,
-0.0202527847,
-0.0301644728,
0.0777862519,
0.0162073579,
0.0448942594,
-0.0341742523,
-0.0098733855,
0.0075203283,
-0.0334808901,
0.0159760416,
0.0719192997,
0.0032125972,
-0.014910602,
0.0828988776,
-0.0045526959,
-0.044890359,
0.0265261531,
0.0269647427,
0.0081635453,
-0.0131054362,
-0.022156762,
-0.0565603673,
-0.0385049544,
-0.0475913063,
-0.0566887222,
0.0287736468,
0.0249238815,
0.0157544408,
-0.0513727479,
-0.0063851611,
0.0293073766,
0.0630070642,
-0.0082924115,
0.0167877953,
0.0093393577,
-0.0071974644,
-0.0050210925,
0.0617730692,
-0.0751546472,
0.029181309,
0.045574706,
0.0358123109,
0.08230526,
0.0444686413,
-0.0160235036,
0.0064795734,
-0.0596256405,
0.0032305038,
0.0116394432,
0.0007243524,
-0.0180123635,
0.0026793317,
-0.0102378381,
-0.034705244,
0.0368075073,
0.0075353212,
-0.0170313716,
-0.0205412209,
0.0682438314,
-0.0224788543,
-0.0054530953,
-0.0912386551,
0.0361821391,
-0.0214930195,
-0.0552460998,
-0.0174217355,
0.0237244163,
0.0019565911,
0.0023581306,
-0.0344570801,
-0.0119185392,
0.0204135366,
-0.0227113348,
0.0021410496,
0.0166408308,
-0.0251059011,
-0.0158704817,
0.0398951098,
-0.039009396,
-0.0401839688,
0.036998909,
-0.0113908472,
0.0148758302,
0.0114575326,
-0.0445545428,
-0.0050620325,
-0.0063082925,
0.0046120924,
-0.0106359115,
0.0263426248,
-0.0198269952,
0.036864236,
-0.0211209133,
0.0378889069,
0.0191145614,
-0.0366874002,
-0.0128476704,
-0.0171758365,
-0.0729375482,
-0.0182115138,
-0.024317883,
0.015285816,
0.0461655781,
0.0336286202,
-0.0159372035,
0.0139582781,
-0.0331808291,
-0.0403585173,
-0.0240928698,
0.010773968,
0.0201663654,
-0.0115970047,
-0.0278787129,
0.0056325328,
-0.0435812362,
-0.0504442044,
-0.0092472862,
0.0461940095,
-0.0261157099,
-0.0121503612,
-0.0179188922,
-0.0071926792,
0.0044349264,
-0.0372360162,
0.0583653226,
-0.0128762657,
-0.0281209778,
0.0043867561,
0.0401414745,
-0.0277393404,
-0.0270730089,
0.0235457923,
-0.0677865669,
0.0118768895,
-0.0011035409,
0.0242252536,
0.0388293304,
0.0236424375,
0.0427516811,
0.0473793969,
0.0040565785,
-0.0297956448,
-0.0169839412,
-0.027883159,
-0.0271880068,
-0.030099865,
-0.1002947018,
-0.022253355,
0.0272765569,
0.0135978255,
-0.0043492573,
-0.0245159753,
0.0674822181,
-0.0670204759,
-0.0495900959,
-0.0424081087,
-0.0273641553,
-0.0176602583,
0.007469289,
-0.0118314978,
-0.0252959318,
0.041494403,
0.0166634489,
0.0203003008,
-0.0005784137,
-0.0091470964,
0.0422214419,
0.0069000376,
0.0024316607,
0.0543945394,
0.0532905906,
-0.022067612,
-0.0187539347,
0.0105951251,
0.0556914657,
-0.0077646631,
0.0388093181,
-0.031441357,
-0.0256773122,
0.018857833,
-0.0674176514,
-0.0394950584,
-0.0366491377,
-0.0152120749,
-0.0244186614,
0.0337391086,
0.0142795695,
-0.0022429565,
-0.017872259,
-0.0011887595,
-0.0178364292,
0.0018647583,
-0.0179738142,
0.0404950865,
0.0007304434,
0.0433731452,
-0.0404014513,
0.0553279184,
-0.0193354394,
0.0608471669,
0.0953207389,
-0.0521932058,
-0.0063718469,
0.0140939876,
0.0246957466,
0.0248385686,
0.0094032632,
-0.0191872418,
0.0070386259,
0.0175741091,
-0.0383004695,
-0.0278542303,
0.0623413324,
-0.0016313194,
-0.0153143005,
0.0548748747,
-0.0063727563,
0.0391481295,
0.0191727821,
-0.0337993018,
-0.0993514284,
0.0057638986,
0.0152195571,
0.0051668487,
-0.0366683342,
-0.0221824683,
0.0417607352,
-0.0879072919,
0.0316162556,
0.022182256,
-0.060326796,
0.029136451,
0.0011075976,
-0.0127390102,
-0.0639999881,
0.0198926814,
-0.0298196562,
0.0022699581,
-0.0406620912,
-0.0027098397,
-0.0453584902,
-0.0469133966,
-0.0195931662,
-0.0182365943,
0.0350910686,
0.0240500234,
-0.0003383347,
-0.0309032016,
0.0062407926,
0.0535784923,
-0.0022922114,
-0.033658389,
-0.0097295716,
0.0441445187,
0.0299816336,
-0.0244886186,
-0.0251347534,
0.0406905338,
-0.0080282222,
-0.0193126034,
0.0307870638,
0.0777771994,
0.0140112173,
-0.0005272647,
-0.0358498842,
0.0204513427,
0.0395555608,
0.0760076046,
0.0410172716,
-0.0669370815,
-0.0007002737,
-0.0752360895,
-0.0422965325,
-0.03476521,
-0.0812290609,
0.0100255497,
-0.0286033396,
-0.0788265169,
-0.0656603128,
-0.0137235289,
0.0188755263,
-0.0242023412,
0.034751568,
-0.0054393969,
-0.0312288292,
0.005722112,
-0.0056652259,
0.0451133251,
0.0256075468,
-0.0003111589,
-0.0674322024,
0.0109114079,
-0.0352571905,
0.0073870933,
-0.0145680588,
0.0296620429,
-0.0561565571,
-0.0860622674,
0.0283703804,
0.0824091062,
0.0086115748,
0.0041443189,
-0.0030857679,
-0.0626507178,
0.075911276,
0.0482754484,
-0.0173665378,
-0.0239891037,
0.0352775343,
-0.0223708134,
0.0249618273,
0.0276256967,
-0.046078518,
0.0262999069,
0.0324932374,
0.0317411795,
-0.0465084687,
-0.0120332241,
0.0158833154,
0.0331875645,
0.0344839767,
-0.0614698566,
0.0067477603,
-0.0377702676,
-0.0193602983,
-0.019292336,
-0.01582014,
0.0234786067,
0.0501511581,
0.032324113,
0.0031377138,
-0.0124892732,
-0.0097123347,
-0.0002799331,
0.0206713043,
-0.0506587327,
0.0314154439,
0.0358572863,
0.0179268643,
0.0666544884,
0.0419992656,
0.0021286795,
0.0267679393,
-0.0003628443,
0.0065487828,
-0.0253659375,
-0.0001286396,
0.0212644227,
0.0281632431,
0.0469832346,
0.0322723687,
0.0092347134,
-0.0223901123,
-0.0338659137,
-0.0058389101,
0.0311865974,
-0.0347782075,
0.0803817511,
-0.011976786,
-0.0216785297,
-0.0433790199,
-0.0160651263,
-0.009114855,
-0.0689964145,
-0.0075480901,
-0.0062792213,
-0.0376565233,
-0.0282531753,
0.0650673658,
-0.0125961145,
0.0474826023,
0.0509709232,
-0.0213719588,
-0.0163353216,
-0.0034856051,
0.0304499753,
0.0077152574,
-0.0503030494,
-0.0088520516,
-0.0671933368,
-0.0770882219,
-0.011014373,
-0.0139940847,
0.0041401708,
0.0158475172,
0.0009894707,
-0.0030050892,
0.0107085705,
0.0102063222,
-0.0273481011,
0.0390371457,
-0.0545032136,
-0.043644622,
-0.0042628422,
-5.446779073e-33,
0.0351630785,
-0.0249141976,
-0.0466896035,
0.0242962092,
0.0178127438,
-0.0163077712,
-0.0023049074,
0.0086514987,
-0.0190452263,
0.0610277653,
0.0287274346,
-0.0210654624,
-0.0001172203,
0.0219481345,
0.0361887552,
-0.0318684876,
0.0321715064,
0.0130514624,
-0.034716513,
0.0021778904,
0.0660915598,
0.0403833091,
0.0378066935,
-0.0934776366,
0.0330859125,
-0.0185958631,
-0.0482119434,
-0.0124090193,
-0.0303096604,
0.0835867971,
0.0097203888,
0.0979419649,
-0.0025154147,
-0.0159857757,
-0.0034910908,
0.0553674474,
-0.0300524253,
-0.0350409783,
0.0167944897,
0.0106107648,
-0.0167010259,
-0.055293493,
0.0476221889,
-0.0095298486,
-0.0443476029,
0.0225361306,
0.0270282831,
-0.0523795374,
0.010470707,
-0.0197730027,
-0.0665155724,
-0.0091660833,
0.0038467562,
0.0005918137,
0.0022545683,
0.1081764922,
0.0176536757,
-0.0048850621,
-0.0453440174,
0.0166511908,
-0.0332734436,
0.0213319715,
0.0305376314,
-0.0346070267,
0.0136189628,
0.065460287,
0.0036319441,
0.0186531805,
-0.0030692283,
0.022603713,
0.0339301266,
0.0021805051,
0.0614123605,
0.08148323,
0.0112377424,
-0.0373149812,
-0.0673648119,
0.0123881884,
0.027947668,
0.0117206629,
-0.0084143141,
-0.039664153,
-0.025380468,
-0.0468296111,
-0.0332766026,
-0.014281773,
-0.009988294,
-0.0168114565,
0.0380733162,
-0.0478798784,
0.0045812679,
-0.0357314274,
0.0063061384,
-0.0321126059,
0.0047982438,
0.0251452737,
0.0081001893,
-0.0139228478,
0.0202680472,
0.0447941422,
-0.0500768572,
0.0402542278,
-0.0090816049,
-0.0317663029,
0.0320778042,
0.0135472268,
0.0769346356,
0.0185416825,
-0.0550196394,
0.0149327489,
-0.0145674562,
0.0519797169,
0.040145535,
0.0590081513,
0.0158219188,
-0.0345178768,
0.0254834015,
-0.0051353709,
0.0812277943,
0.0340897813,
-0.0110647716,
-0.0200049318,
-0.0150288558,
0.0190240107,
-0.0318381637,
-0.0122194495,
-0.0256355461,
0.031798739,
0.0590741448,
-0.082563214,
-0.0206278954,
-0.0563547313,
2.444e-7,
0.0640242994,
0.0367868021,
0.0074312515,
0.0232415814,
0.0085292431,
0.0213988144,
-0.0060975174,
0.0370545946,
-0.0132701788,
0.0032511521,
-0.0050282511,
-0.027965229,
0.0524063408,
0.064005889,
-0.0637790337,
0.0103953872,
-0.0986264125,
0.0239528101,
-0.0401668251,
0.0017006266,
0.0204903483,
0.0926970914,
-0.0057326565,
-0.0229335446,
-0.0080707539,
-0.0277067777,
0.0188030731,
-0.0680663213,
0.0056507937,
-0.0061710915,
0.0364918858,
0.0095848087,
0.0179561879,
-0.0106571363,
-0.0187898502,
-0.058253143,
0.01276368,
0.0055525615,
-0.001542013,
-0.0101352669,
0.0237257723,
-0.0657623783,
-0.0022184909,
-0.0597533211,
0.0354242921,
0.0371253788,
0.0208690017,
-0.0365787856,
-0.0458864048,
-0.0326415896,
0.095463939,
-0.0638937652,
-0.0314412527,
0.0052791913,
0.045265872,
0.0243109372,
0.012222846,
-0.0362980552,
-0.0335297175,
-0.0179324932,
-0.0032313268,
-0.0648385361,
0.0173907056,
0.0413777679,
-0.0682061091,
-0.0376515538,
0.0082753943,
1.961264111e-34,
0.0072582331,
-0.0281736068,
0.0007212663,
-0.0281088036,
0.0364546664,
-0.0079240231,
0.014576897,
0.0054314453,
-0.0281868037,
-0.0242991969,
-0.0117317196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17563v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17563v1 | Multi-property Steering of Large Language Models with Dynamic Activation Composition | 2024-06-25T14:00:42 | 2024-06-25T14:00:42 | Daniel Scalena, Gabriele Sarti, Malvina Nissim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Activation steering methods were shown to be effective in conditioning
language model generation by additively intervening over models' intermediate
representations. However, the evaluation of these techniques has so far been
limited to single conditioning properties and synthetic settings. In this work,
we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of various activation steering
strategies, highlighting the property-dependent nature of optimal parameters to
ensure a robust effect throughout generation. To address this issue, we propose
Dynamic Activation Composition, an information-theoretic approach to modulate
the steering intensity of one or more properties throughout generation. Our
experiments on multi-property steering show that our method successfully
maintains high conditioning while minimizing the impact of conditioning on
generation fluency. | [
-0.0118808653,
0.0510781407,
-0.0105659775,
-0.0085758725,
-0.0475663282,
-0.0008930751,
-0.0292725414,
-0.0238879379,
-0.042816624,
-0.0480308793,
-0.0086747529,
-0.0837073624,
-0.0137525527,
0.0119614499,
0.0413064621,
-0.0565765835,
0.0707159042,
-0.0515489429,
-0.0537863635,
-0.0294297617,
-0.0153108407,
-0.0044275145,
-0.01310011,
0.0354350172,
-0.0212832112,
-0.0056855893,
-0.0117568253,
0.0052096667,
-0.0083844252,
-0.0351501666,
-0.0074238149,
0.0573741756,
0.0191630907,
-0.0191581938,
0.0000020137,
-0.0519807488,
-0.0251589045,
-0.0068438202,
0.0192664079,
0.0170147717,
0.0827391446,
-0.005095114,
-0.0315675288,
0.0225589275,
-0.0268171914,
-0.0019674699,
0.0604700372,
0.0344399698,
0.0206157714,
0.0553180948,
-0.0147251822,
-0.0379725806,
-0.0014846365,
0.0006152006,
0.0012133635,
0.001878672,
0.0265740063,
0.0311029032,
-0.0164022669,
-0.0184622575,
-0.0291181263,
0.0123287709,
0.0356709026,
0.0013724562,
-0.0146177644,
0.0381614119,
0.0091385702,
-0.0126669034,
-0.0276679695,
0.068151392,
-0.0211737268,
-0.0219744779,
-0.0075542573,
0.0008593353,
-0.0087667927,
-0.0257333759,
-0.0145668369,
-0.0104863662,
0.0186431408,
0.0346318148,
0.0312548093,
0.0043172408,
0.0109461909,
0.0106049711,
-0.0512047857,
0.0591638573,
0.0522791632,
-0.024090929,
-0.0470318459,
-0.003676476,
-0.0005351111,
-0.0360189304,
-0.0474594533,
0.0113522429,
-0.0112182181,
0.0283488389,
-0.0705499575,
-0.0236606319,
0.0154358502,
-0.0479101948,
0.0432375781,
0.0457392149,
0.0064070593,
0.0056796628,
-0.0334071182,
0.0573165491,
-0.0379275344,
0.0169419814,
-0.0450750701,
0.0145823685,
-0.0443545803,
-0.0062635485,
-0.0441161059,
0.0403505601,
-0.0069728382,
-0.0201984439,
-0.0703709498,
0.0389738791,
0.0111024408,
-0.0471601076,
-0.0333186351,
-0.005678196,
-0.0538690463,
0.0103315152,
0.021125922,
0.0096704112,
-0.0406909361,
0.0012274877,
0.0043871715,
-0.0440976061,
-0.0184234865,
0.0376562066,
0.003268712,
0.0074425712,
-0.0189459883,
0.0759246498,
-0.0331803784,
-0.0263524055,
-0.0644704103,
-0.0539743826,
0.0043391949,
-0.0460453853,
0.0199087504,
-0.0506024174,
0.0127698481,
0.0065691872,
-0.0233071949,
-0.0741673857,
-0.003039113,
-0.0002625601,
-0.0189078767,
0.0273295604,
0.0201990437,
0.0135977007,
-0.0174558274,
-0.0100806998,
-0.0117708892,
0.0988265648,
0.042107366,
0.0053922683,
-0.0124427211,
0.0160675831,
-0.0140066091,
0.0501408167,
0.0359754227,
0.0431751385,
-0.0763537139,
-0.0521096624,
0.0373316035,
-0.0058470727,
0.0494552776,
0.0606762506,
-0.0565885268,
0.0396755561,
0.0519433543,
-0.0317128561,
0.0295560658,
0.033755254,
0.1000781581,
-0.0119614918,
-0.0338671245,
0.0670948774,
-0.0437414199,
0.0002005072,
-0.0488209762,
0.0505305901,
-0.0036615045,
0.0772085339,
-0.0208300855,
-0.03614939,
0.0012947078,
-0.0133192129,
0.0484831259,
-0.0545750223,
0.029121343,
0.0520246774,
-0.0669428781,
0.0228000768,
0.0514833443,
-0.0413284637,
0.0240649264,
-0.0305591393,
0.0141073233,
0.0766869411,
0.0466700271,
0.0304299425,
-0.0163795892,
0.0370790772,
0.0280180145,
0.0452533588,
0.0278865434,
0.0001548103,
0.0157810804,
-0.0880555809,
-0.0217373185,
-0.0042724498,
0.0371700861,
0.0422389731,
-0.0018195505,
-0.0058858478,
0.0073975464,
-0.0015875327,
0.0089616282,
0.0370113924,
-0.0099017946,
-0.0116495639,
-0.0124107599,
-0.0145851132,
0.014279874,
-0.0267630387,
-0.0369632915,
0.0280551799,
-0.005029391,
-0.0362795442,
-0.0150604723,
0.0532074124,
-0.0593285672,
-0.0320720971,
0.013272291,
0.046980232,
0.035125643,
-0.0691404715,
0.0046733697,
-0.0471114963,
0.0607699789,
-0.0240227096,
0.0679000095,
-0.0288303867,
0.0425294116,
0.0118197454,
0.0243347883,
-0.024748398,
0.0666677058,
-0.0203767251,
-0.0261267349,
0.0643577874,
0.0352622718,
0.0022509561,
-0.0339458324,
0.0224300288,
0.0237759911,
0.0040602675,
-0.0085722106,
-0.0047253813,
0.0185870137,
0.0042216661,
-0.0484641008,
-0.0301306657,
-0.0282055736,
-0.0359142572,
0.0239842907,
0.0293560978,
0.0153071824,
0.0109412465,
0.039118994,
-0.0531721301,
-0.016464442,
-0.0092130024,
0.0233683456,
0.002942415,
-0.0119749457,
-0.0696305558,
-0.0298726242,
0.0003524584,
-0.011662717,
0.0505869091,
0.0086316103,
0.0207065437,
-0.0567504168,
-0.0105835367,
-0.0246789642,
0.0523770899,
0.0184055213,
-0.0516183376,
-0.0116756018,
-0.0078636203,
0.0882319883,
0.0078877788,
0.0063059796,
-0.0102293929,
0.0677886978,
-0.0209535453,
-0.0534374677,
0.0061157825,
-0.0576080456,
0.0283827446,
-0.0336827599,
-0.018740667,
0.0048735603,
0.0847428367,
0.0215014573,
0.0025719029,
-0.0901835486,
-0.0008175962,
-0.0299885925,
-0.0568455979,
0.0387111045,
-0.0350748897,
-0.0220703017,
0.0380003639,
-0.018707009,
-0.0566289611,
0.0875501931,
-0.0669336691,
-0.0090054572,
-0.0556633696,
0.0377419181,
0.0003417042,
0.0070930268,
0.0124754189,
0.0353846587,
0.0516357198,
0.014574918,
-0.0627636015,
-0.030260101,
0.0362084433,
-0.007973237,
0.0201408342,
-0.0351359025,
0.0224526897,
0.0359658115,
-0.0164516997,
-0.0554257855,
-0.0476392582,
0.036915943,
0.0183452889,
0.0587583371,
-0.035495501,
0.0183163062,
0.0278465524,
0.0068042562,
0.031271819,
-0.0051677981,
-0.0076465793,
-0.0254304018,
0.0222882479,
0.0610887557,
0.000893166,
0.0197256096,
-0.0380128697,
0.0194524936,
0.0115956888,
0.0461746752,
0.0240325592,
-0.0311273262,
0.0348991826,
0.0236968659,
0.0058225249,
-0.0157585647,
0.0279587843,
0.0281762425,
-0.0358634628,
-0.0313728228,
0.0861331746,
0.031820979,
-0.0346022993,
0.0396252908,
-0.004719316,
0.0980109125,
0.0130144833,
0.01590655,
-0.0817662328,
-0.0100342277,
0.0080291517,
0.0153373973,
-0.0250983369,
0.0170487147,
-0.0236849505,
-0.1076600626,
0.0376732536,
0.0370667353,
-0.013810304,
-0.0276054312,
-0.0175240058,
-0.0112856217,
0.0174049195,
0.0328007638,
0.022078244,
-0.0104104849,
-0.0120561244,
0.0093502682,
0.0188123733,
-0.0659562424,
-0.0161089618,
-0.0164028872,
0.0447651371,
0.1165239066,
-0.0158958733,
0.0244404841,
-0.0467365794,
0.0506536886,
-0.0141327772,
0.0251566619,
-0.0017093916,
0.018618362,
0.0180437192,
-0.0014102269,
0.002050963,
0.0408533141,
0.0042146109,
-0.0315285027,
-0.0578781478,
0.0379525758,
-0.0322692581,
-0.0188531745,
-0.0290112309,
0.0241900105,
0.0400135852,
0.0587361604,
0.0418683738,
-0.0641885474,
0.0061828592,
0.0018051916,
-0.0090215988,
-0.0763639584,
-0.0365541391,
-0.0126843685,
-0.0190349724,
-0.0321465135,
-0.1128859594,
-0.0195213929,
0.0119614555,
0.0394257791,
0.0055340938,
-0.0171548985,
-0.0008495691,
-0.0469416156,
-0.0012570182,
0.0105858129,
-0.0233857743,
0.0068716123,
-0.0446216241,
-0.0442891382,
0.0594560914,
-0.0387173966,
0.0078053777,
0.0267234556,
-0.0258965287,
-0.111315228,
0.0179425627,
0.0269868858,
0.0181915164,
0.0756144375,
-0.0282244757,
-0.0254671406,
0.0277167596,
0.0067001833,
0.0046607037,
0.0331957825,
0.0325851068,
-0.0204828214,
0.0058491868,
0.0340297557,
-0.0365659334,
0.0527007431,
0.0067152409,
0.0417122208,
-0.0125048272,
0.0191362612,
0.0396006517,
0.0044221631,
-0.0110474816,
-0.0578679293,
0.0377138555,
-0.0319494009,
0.0066275424,
-0.0272539519,
-0.0181522444,
-0.0548314415,
0.0252887309,
0.0092834327,
0.0071472549,
-0.001321341,
-0.0250710435,
0.0100747496,
0.0279103033,
0.004761829,
-0.0050079674,
-0.0464688428,
0.0023848,
0.0376028977,
0.0111820688,
0.0124890013,
0.057455074,
-0.0543202795,
0.006058339,
-0.0311434623,
0.0501761809,
0.0436770767,
-0.0097019933,
-0.070834823,
-0.0005904041,
-0.00814634,
0.0149297975,
-0.0571803674,
0.0148056708,
0.0572745875,
0.0166457128,
0.1053875908,
-0.0432491191,
-0.005528254,
0.0135585237,
0.0315690562,
0.0291534122,
-0.0422929861,
0.0239821915,
0.0213570669,
-0.0277578495,
-0.0115622003,
0.0810421333,
-0.0147196837,
0.07022091,
-0.0589932986,
0.0482192561,
-0.0086357705,
-0.0248502102,
-0.0120887486,
0.0090590892,
-0.0142500103,
0.0190919396,
-0.0802673176,
-0.0393838882,
-0.0038230489,
-0.0026394736,
0.0127961859,
-0.016897751,
0.0721838027,
0.0315717235,
-0.0291448776,
-0.0036356864,
-0.0029684594,
-0.0736541376,
0.0243067797,
-0.0035519719,
-0.0339091383,
-6.500311844e-33,
-0.0512353033,
0.0202901233,
0.0190216005,
-0.0160940997,
-0.0249390472,
-0.0208291747,
-0.0357268453,
0.0042767767,
-0.0059182057,
0.0106961094,
0.0234411117,
-0.0211316831,
0.0170762446,
0.0169721805,
-0.0048907637,
0.0166466683,
0.0602633692,
-0.0280045122,
-0.0496627316,
0.0225184858,
0.0336622,
-0.0103498558,
0.0223212335,
-0.0725048557,
-0.0151588377,
0.001549903,
-0.0475120656,
0.0161986127,
-0.0424516797,
0.0620498657,
-0.0080781681,
0.0203544516,
0.0157135166,
-0.0575917624,
-0.0534170829,
-0.0213857722,
-0.0268356483,
-0.0445967019,
0.0228062291,
-0.005220281,
-0.0620357841,
-0.0308635868,
0.0514908992,
-0.0141277155,
-0.0075748051,
0.0138769317,
0.0108916797,
-0.0190395694,
-0.0157670155,
-0.047515057,
-0.1047559008,
0.0216782093,
0.0018863302,
-0.0410869271,
0.0181410629,
0.0418838412,
-0.0086761741,
-0.006599077,
-0.0232054386,
0.0300017875,
0.0182608683,
0.0424048714,
0.054855641,
0.04367074,
0.0290777069,
0.034600623,
0.0279118493,
0.0115389451,
-0.0289203431,
-0.0034149713,
0.0579321235,
0.001924101,
0.0073755248,
0.0214056708,
0.00370098,
-0.0212575141,
-0.0221961085,
-0.016113963,
0.0328347534,
0.0101850955,
0.0300809145,
0.035567373,
-0.0352536477,
-0.0364506207,
-0.0802070126,
-0.0238343365,
-0.016469894,
-0.0561417453,
0.033703506,
0.0240811538,
-0.02952688,
-0.0383961275,
0.059093494,
0.0096691065,
-0.0190723706,
0.0432014763,
-0.0589168854,
0.0382781848,
-0.0406125076,
0.0008041218,
-0.0126107968,
-0.0440173037,
0.0441635884,
-0.0169137865,
-0.0155543284,
0.0250101127,
0.0035543693,
0.0557209775,
-0.0407563038,
-0.0033745712,
-0.0208242554,
0.0225609727,
0.0381735861,
0.0096706375,
0.0373070538,
0.0079005873,
-0.0140227731,
0.0290718116,
0.0453117155,
0.0169208627,
-0.0087383566,
-0.0145790903,
0.0135075124,
0.0795240998,
-0.0461948365,
-0.0019937507,
-0.043463286,
-0.0158887897,
0.0275626685,
-0.0266446713,
-0.0447130874,
0.0294080693,
2.793e-7,
0.0242508575,
0.032647416,
0.0385598876,
0.0568104275,
-0.0065633678,
0.0063556191,
0.0221515354,
-0.0102489535,
0.0151771205,
-0.0203987844,
-0.0125681926,
0.0448026545,
0.0250760745,
-0.0048168539,
-0.0762507543,
0.0214639585,
-0.0318217091,
0.0181287266,
-0.0259845369,
-0.0390883349,
0.0511135198,
0.082907632,
-0.017940484,
-0.0053497846,
0.0297818743,
-0.0053301905,
0.0594900511,
0.0150027471,
0.0064760805,
0.0558467656,
-0.0061836778,
-0.0002961005,
-0.0050119404,
0.0196583308,
-0.0250980351,
0.029264044,
-0.0479948856,
0.0262927301,
-0.0277249161,
-0.0472537503,
0.0329728425,
-0.0131589733,
-0.0377372839,
-0.0144915488,
0.0500734858,
-0.0632298067,
-0.0144410515,
-0.0152677353,
-0.0124186976,
0.0263649393,
-0.0157331377,
-0.0095103225,
-0.0341348387,
0.0410040244,
0.0147279361,
0.0389507525,
-0.0366540179,
-0.0436152294,
-0.0413718224,
0.0155149456,
-0.0300730411,
-0.0434869975,
-0.0166527964,
-0.016824469,
0.0064707771,
-0.0573908314,
-0.0354995281,
3.06314772e-34,
0.0435798876,
-0.0275067966,
0.0376944281,
0.069366321,
0.0313715599,
-0.0117760096,
0.0372329876,
0.0191744827,
0.0356843323,
-0.0731860548,
-0.0151990103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17557v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17557v1 | The FineWeb Datasets: Decanting the Web for the Finest Text Data at Scale | 2024-06-25T13:50:56 | 2024-06-25T13:50:56 | Guilherme Penedo, Hynek Kydlíček, Loubna Ben allal, Anton Lozhkov, Margaret Mitchell, Colin Raffel, Leandro Von Werra, Thomas Wolf | cs.CL | cs.CL | The performance of a large language model (LLM) depends heavily on the
quality and size of its pretraining dataset. However, the pretraining datasets
for state-of-the-art open LLMs like Llama 3 and Mixtral are not publicly
available and very little is known about how they were created. In this work,
we introduce FineWeb, a 15-trillion token dataset derived from 96 Common Crawl
snapshots that produces better-performing LLMs than other open pretraining
datasets. To advance the understanding of how best to curate high-quality
pretraining datasets, we carefully document and ablate all of the design
choices used in FineWeb, including in-depth investigations of deduplication and
filtering strategies. In addition, we introduce FineWeb-Edu, a 1.3-trillion
token collection of educational text filtered from FineWeb. LLMs pretrained on
FineWeb-Edu exhibit dramatically better performance on knowledge- and
reasoning-intensive benchmarks like MMLU and ARC. Along with our datasets, we
publicly release our data curation codebase and all of the models trained
during our ablation experiments. | [
0.0425819457,
0.055994682,
0.0001985202,
0.033883322,
-0.0033952761,
0.0160737839,
0.0158506613,
0.0118710101,
0.0004883267,
-0.0447154976,
-0.0466959365,
0.0206590388,
-0.0241232552,
0.0385839269,
-0.0106557095,
0.0025936707,
0.0235727448,
-0.0191273671,
0.0042935996,
-0.0226322282,
0.0242743399,
0.0251836833,
0.0143513829,
0.0064603845,
0.0316159502,
-0.0161858108,
-0.0028835807,
0.0265131053,
-0.0164601412,
-0.0228681788,
0.0421078987,
0.0414914452,
0.021162536,
0.0624252036,
0.0000022676,
-0.0392809734,
-0.0420425609,
-0.0185254198,
-0.0486188196,
0.0488613769,
0.0191844348,
0.0284037869,
0.0093988916,
0.0366827101,
-0.0409213193,
-0.0160539728,
0.0173360631,
0.0337159298,
0.0623807982,
0.0666938126,
-0.0043202061,
-0.0061543542,
0.0329884477,
-0.0121743241,
-0.0228374638,
-0.0048592766,
0.0380423814,
-0.0085981293,
0.0086521059,
0.0157785527,
-0.014236819,
0.0259227995,
0.0151735367,
-0.0087614208,
-0.0168882478,
0.0121843489,
-0.0714370385,
-0.0290006641,
0.0204358138,
0.1012537703,
-0.0142335743,
-0.0621451251,
0.0284021106,
0.007547745,
-0.0404598899,
-0.0085149035,
-0.0450461246,
0.0326604024,
0.0122458758,
0.0590623803,
-0.0194224641,
-0.0204455592,
0.0500941537,
0.036756251,
-0.0161477607,
0.0382360369,
0.0173061304,
-0.0251792427,
0.011499214,
0.0354463756,
0.0212249625,
-0.0629286543,
0.0357643068,
0.0003400158,
0.0039405655,
0.002832928,
-0.0827368796,
-0.041413866,
0.0566529669,
0.0235415921,
0.0143365311,
0.0217585135,
-0.0418483466,
0.0698577464,
-0.0171592236,
0.0151820611,
-0.006198585,
0.0362696089,
-0.0392317325,
0.0089893052,
-0.0228356663,
0.019538695,
-0.0268586669,
0.0644639358,
-0.0019548328,
0.0029315371,
-0.0198899005,
-0.0001700033,
0.0022009772,
0.0082649663,
-0.0142301405,
-0.0235978961,
-0.0312651247,
-0.0093245404,
0.0056156493,
-0.0064647733,
-0.0300328378,
0.0321265422,
0.0040499219,
-0.0722776726,
-0.0197147112,
0.00649253,
0.0440720171,
-0.0304796863,
0.0413377509,
0.0121522155,
-0.007292218,
-0.0410742909,
-0.0336501896,
-0.040752098,
0.0138319153,
-0.0285144858,
-0.0059675663,
-0.0799419954,
0.0344010927,
0.0033135447,
0.024071347,
-0.0527119599,
-0.0043688603,
0.0244269483,
-0.0168111473,
0.0461349078,
-0.063797839,
-0.0159765966,
-0.0000080594,
-0.0048125065,
0.0116283055,
0.0556412786,
0.0086803427,
0.0611460656,
0.0816875696,
0.015255725,
-0.002746827,
0.0469562002,
0.0530717187,
0.0273829736,
0.0090400558,
-0.0023473061,
-0.0037688522,
0.0061994931,
0.0433780551,
0.0340545885,
-0.062939249,
-0.0222018566,
0.0429609306,
0.0405756794,
0.0127637666,
0.0161039066,
-0.0011340661,
0.0348493531,
0.030650951,
-0.0107657844,
-0.0397070721,
-0.0193451066,
-0.0263722707,
-0.0139379352,
0.0593547784,
0.0461717956,
-0.0318010785,
-0.0431631133,
0.0060114306,
-0.0113939578,
0.0076411553,
0.0291126203,
0.0548358336,
-0.0081018303,
-0.0167606156,
0.0417535715,
0.0472764596,
-0.0596591011,
0.0124646313,
-0.0492117852,
0.0130054671,
0.0752735436,
0.0952104256,
-0.0437466986,
-0.0546801426,
0.0143083436,
0.0760904998,
0.0384267643,
0.0370237827,
-0.0195717681,
0.0243558623,
-0.0711531788,
-0.0863021687,
-0.0147918034,
0.0022801079,
-0.0128307901,
0.0524570979,
0.0138083231,
0.0225695781,
-0.0618724525,
-0.0285536293,
0.0453064516,
-0.0463196412,
0.0004365213,
-0.0422016941,
-0.0128577016,
0.0052627949,
-0.0090675624,
-0.0066653593,
-0.0154098086,
0.0627030879,
-0.0136908954,
-0.000098841,
-0.0529853441,
-0.0058334409,
-0.017177863,
0.0964859873,
-0.0567606501,
0.0123431263,
0.0644510537,
-0.0663616061,
-0.0292796493,
-0.0101843961,
0.0114503186,
0.0474257953,
-0.0222454574,
0.0339156874,
-0.0271569304,
0.0136930263,
-0.0073753297,
0.0179648791,
0.0032603862,
0.0032026994,
-0.0101425489,
-0.0268881992,
0.0355855823,
-0.0237665214,
-0.0520611629,
-0.0157419834,
-0.0360065326,
0.0313678794,
0.0180839524,
0.0294542704,
-0.0816437602,
-0.0016348382,
-0.0832552835,
0.0150583582,
-0.0038103336,
0.0235860944,
0.0132528646,
-0.002001517,
-0.0008602748,
-0.0218228418,
-0.0093522398,
-0.0229425076,
-0.0164079815,
-0.000511121,
0.0173169337,
-0.0143130962,
0.0010400956,
-0.0572260953,
-0.0540553182,
0.0110203885,
0.0215205401,
-0.0111603504,
-0.0224254876,
0.0059430189,
0.0421814322,
-0.0387791358,
0.0086704521,
-0.0205573644,
-0.0477058254,
0.0078185443,
-0.0279981904,
-0.002354725,
0.0402724072,
-0.0262503419,
-0.0004783282,
0.059093371,
0.0074857329,
-0.0686797351,
-0.0042883246,
-0.006184868,
0.0075103766,
-0.0438285284,
-0.0071894345,
0.0017126109,
0.0262166169,
-0.0434938669,
-0.0174371451,
-0.02125399,
0.018216677,
-0.0112761017,
-0.0149189439,
-0.0481885895,
0.0006196052,
-0.0083606308,
0.0302466936,
-0.03016706,
-0.0304783881,
0.0485644601,
-0.0297270417,
0.0252158809,
-0.0423319191,
0.0308716539,
-0.023685595,
0.018700283,
-0.0223829076,
0.0079216044,
-0.0050933934,
0.0127299977,
-0.0317880102,
0.0205615945,
0.0274192281,
-0.0749194399,
0.0219777487,
-0.0196805019,
0.0294911545,
-0.0288963839,
-0.0554471985,
-0.0325403214,
-0.0352578238,
-0.034912765,
-0.0170185287,
-0.0028218955,
0.0033048317,
-0.0744729415,
-0.0305429306,
0.0073013897,
0.0609653294,
-0.0162028819,
-0.0014471246,
-0.0105946632,
0.0381240807,
0.0517391823,
-0.0061946874,
0.0279451385,
-0.0261259172,
-0.0022340715,
0.0966579616,
0.0692931935,
-0.0108876415,
0.0075150095,
0.0019642166,
0.0722484887,
-0.0392045043,
-0.0044101658,
-0.0152871348,
0.0069518522,
-0.050387945,
-0.0151740341,
0.1184980646,
0.0326804779,
-0.0747941285,
-0.0306168739,
0.0067648925,
0.0202449132,
0.006951354,
-0.0052877441,
-0.1019394919,
-0.0501156449,
0.0423969552,
0.0425725169,
0.0328985229,
-0.0191249046,
0.0151128685,
-0.0893964022,
0.0031634541,
-0.0055991039,
0.015807759,
-0.0014798354,
-0.0760980844,
-0.001829367,
-0.0262322854,
0.0020017193,
0.016074447,
-0.0150749572,
0.0246450678,
0.0197762344,
0.0148482537,
-0.0712789074,
0.0344027914,
-0.0326109193,
0.0267022308,
0.0105304699,
0.0557503663,
-0.0002684801,
-0.0284676403,
0.06014717,
-0.0383819975,
-0.0584932268,
-0.020822987,
0.0752868801,
-0.0076269303,
0.0015172882,
-0.0285122339,
0.047581058,
-0.0632671863,
-0.0034049146,
0.0148799196,
0.0624157861,
-0.0093277413,
0.0014133994,
-0.0425807051,
-0.0390964188,
-0.0428430438,
0.0864907205,
0.0184906349,
-0.0364463329,
-0.0270515159,
-0.0222367682,
0.0030434798,
-0.0288123842,
-0.0133562805,
0.0118347248,
-0.0447234884,
0.0127234338,
-0.055193238,
-0.0270657782,
0.0355693325,
0.017915912,
0.0147599606,
0.0059004216,
0.0095566157,
-0.0073265834,
-0.0677181855,
0.0633794665,
-0.0815583393,
-0.00415109,
-0.0963924751,
-0.0116913971,
-0.0116862459,
-0.015665751,
-0.0376119167,
0.0239463225,
-0.0814609677,
-0.0405795015,
0.0273300111,
0.004252031,
0.0233177841,
0.0412486643,
-0.0152629642,
-0.0700158328,
0.0555608757,
0.0001577778,
-0.0454117619,
-0.002816977,
0.029719729,
-0.0471278243,
0.0077603967,
0.0385659076,
-0.0681350231,
0.0183098391,
0.0408801027,
0.0156601407,
-0.004246424,
0.023729397,
0.0019694946,
0.0624073744,
0.0563062131,
-0.0125616994,
-0.0220047608,
-0.0496267788,
0.0399301313,
0.0025547342,
-0.0170355514,
-0.0321118832,
0.0346867777,
0.052464094,
-0.0083787115,
-0.01998448,
0.0402642675,
0.0093656257,
0.0469816141,
-0.0558315441,
0.0188808329,
-0.000694895,
0.0269212779,
0.0403627567,
-0.0344179645,
-0.0205420479,
0.019968532,
-0.0055690496,
0.0254090037,
-0.0539822951,
-0.0188258905,
0.0318574905,
0.0090409638,
-0.0227227956,
0.0610896274,
-0.0468174145,
-0.0244689304,
-0.034239985,
-0.0129530998,
0.0465780385,
-0.0023606666,
0.0742228702,
-0.0062798429,
-0.0244325511,
-0.0312239341,
0.0058343946,
0.0057712728,
0.0005614161,
0.0007071272,
0.017089501,
-0.0261753891,
0.0465677492,
0.1005593389,
0.0006727584,
0.0404436551,
0.0474964418,
0.0055733826,
-0.0242309347,
-0.0109438421,
0.0180404335,
0.0505221486,
-0.0083301701,
-0.0434861891,
-0.0115946112,
-0.0439434424,
0.007069767,
0.0066559725,
-0.0321404077,
0.0041879751,
0.0531143881,
0.0707482472,
0.0217439756,
0.0031385962,
0.0024529868,
0.0065438352,
0.0033525806,
-0.0433929339,
0.0048936559,
-6.934016362e-33,
0.0293860417,
0.0076631163,
0.0139163649,
-0.0080120591,
-0.017766647,
0.0306202658,
-0.0210678335,
-0.0449300893,
-0.0437236615,
0.0067490526,
-0.0374035947,
0.0486938395,
0.019484695,
0.0509156473,
-0.0084453477,
-0.0026602687,
0.0828161761,
-0.0120153502,
-0.058915291,
0.0553967133,
0.0247297883,
0.0376136452,
0.0392140299,
-0.0280179288,
-0.0268795975,
-0.021134343,
-0.0108071119,
-0.0029610284,
0.0157857221,
0.0678668916,
-0.0584818348,
0.0456061848,
0.0144983372,
-0.0094086649,
-0.0158499815,
-0.0172640104,
-0.0951573774,
-0.038458325,
-0.0035840471,
0.0132719716,
0.0116348369,
-0.0265693683,
0.0450968705,
-0.0119007332,
-0.0084453318,
-0.0046578678,
0.0441839434,
-0.0129997833,
-0.0431112014,
-0.0350957774,
-0.015324912,
0.0318863839,
-0.0203129686,
-0.0112903109,
0.0630389675,
0.000521209,
0.0057005687,
0.0665394142,
-0.0628941581,
0.0487825423,
0.0109415082,
0.0450912565,
0.0424528308,
-0.037095353,
0.0180703923,
0.0702176988,
-0.0032951548,
0.0062627848,
0.0486768186,
0.0115899434,
0.0667908937,
0.0401354916,
0.0230487417,
0.0506884009,
0.0510229506,
-0.0217517372,
-0.060813386,
0.0245590378,
-0.0063168914,
0.042200841,
0.0107158674,
0.0036476853,
-0.0113475528,
-0.0225046985,
-0.0442991182,
0.0042613726,
-0.0305608846,
0.0092864288,
0.0239004623,
0.0194637105,
-0.0669819936,
-0.0387920141,
-0.0006128981,
-0.0530981235,
-0.0501324274,
0.0666992217,
0.0006151512,
-0.0040270966,
0.0044503468,
0.0042518103,
-0.0475049838,
-0.0345432237,
0.0271202158,
-0.0463192984,
0.0096609127,
-0.0199977439,
0.0283078998,
0.0284909923,
-0.0544294193,
0.0210711826,
-0.0310980268,
-0.0132383257,
0.0286631808,
0.0184849519,
0.0395966433,
0.0104168309,
0.021982979,
-0.0293845776,
0.0816812962,
0.0206041764,
-0.0438795276,
-0.0076714372,
0.0031984844,
-0.0001622661,
-0.0149948811,
-0.0125898225,
-0.0524316654,
0.0165739115,
0.0163928699,
-0.1007341519,
-0.0134853087,
0.014920231,
2.858e-7,
0.031515535,
0.0728706643,
0.0283607189,
-0.0096990494,
0.0106521249,
0.0198310334,
-0.0256769415,
0.0039713513,
0.0092136823,
0.0167411976,
0.0043064021,
0.0178036056,
0.0499257185,
0.0240751244,
-0.0718401074,
0.0358820558,
-0.0353670716,
-0.0240710396,
-0.0531747676,
-0.050533317,
-0.0020890483,
0.0941209644,
0.0371721797,
-0.0468319729,
-0.0043221274,
-0.0505383275,
0.0111129014,
-0.0255492069,
0.0072317151,
0.0296127107,
0.0359010808,
0.0332252681,
0.0071631875,
-0.0468743183,
-0.0359401964,
0.0145871816,
0.0013374115,
0.0550978482,
0.0096890302,
-0.0076218387,
0.0070969863,
-0.047260832,
0.0005033063,
-0.0714994222,
0.1067777127,
0.0257982202,
0.0076945731,
-0.0116896955,
-0.0615797564,
-0.0441614427,
0.0013741346,
-0.02641082,
-0.019572949,
0.0240940638,
0.0169304684,
-0.006205501,
-0.030746663,
-0.0866890773,
-0.0251312163,
-0.0157107227,
-0.0416684747,
-0.0657656118,
-0.047425501,
-0.0103462711,
0.0158232823,
-0.0444677994,
0.0262427386,
3.059241726e-34,
0.0475488976,
-0.0281007737,
0.032142356,
0.0017611333,
-0.0045093,
-0.0090106111,
-0.0047868895,
-0.017134184,
-0.0240312554,
-0.0871180296,
0.0219109971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17553v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17553v1 | Retrieval-Augmented Code Generation for Situated Action Generation: A Case Study on Minecraft | 2024-06-25T13:43:24 | 2024-06-25T13:43:24 | Chalamalasetti Kranti, Sherzod Hakimov, David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the Minecraft Collaborative Building Task, two players collaborate: an
Architect (A) provides instructions to a Builder (B) to assemble a specified
structure using 3D blocks. In this work, we investigate the use of large
language models (LLMs) to predict the sequence of actions taken by the Builder.
Leveraging LLMs' in-context learning abilities, we use few-shot prompting
techniques, that significantly improve performance over baseline methods.
Additionally, we present a detailed analysis of the gaps in performance for
future work | [
-0.0065323743,
0.0412634872,
-0.0189778935,
0.0150125176,
-0.0291380491,
-0.0141973691,
-0.009763943,
-0.0080054831,
0.0298926234,
-0.0588525943,
-0.0289496277,
-0.0230264552,
-0.0277934,
-0.0063875569,
0.0076684393,
0.0118209552,
0.0164169148,
-0.0424654633,
-0.0086696809,
0.0103846462,
-0.0286227763,
-0.0053983098,
0.0114338137,
0.0929207429,
0.0188883953,
-0.0370766595,
-0.0586678162,
0.0009104174,
0.0048092939,
-0.0342886336,
0.005176262,
0.0507070348,
0.0200929102,
0.0229237378,
0.0000020262,
-0.0475606024,
-0.005978778,
-0.0306757614,
0.0143552143,
-0.032184992,
-0.0534839667,
0.0252651628,
-0.0155504923,
0.0339054763,
-0.0564340539,
-0.0216932148,
0.0572961494,
0.0114295874,
0.0458513424,
0.0477172434,
0.0009053419,
-0.0287484489,
-0.02435592,
-0.0074354536,
0.0564780533,
0.0038140651,
0.0243798066,
0.0592641085,
0.0674018413,
0.0694590658,
-0.0060853292,
0.0241257455,
0.0091789998,
-0.0052569984,
-0.0009355692,
0.0572611056,
-0.0034415466,
0.0295756813,
-0.0062550693,
0.0640099123,
0.0195042789,
-0.0035308369,
0.0561125837,
-0.0046398682,
0.0049377074,
0.0054255244,
-0.0591260232,
0.0446870998,
-0.0052821422,
-0.0010312874,
-0.0200953744,
-0.0259426702,
0.0186579283,
0.0141884889,
0.0242857132,
0.0631907955,
-0.0114792632,
-0.0090136575,
-0.0968593433,
0.0022784972,
0.0279994197,
-0.0231813416,
-0.0337941311,
0.0491547324,
-0.0613343604,
-0.0000312484,
0.0016397358,
0.0246040057,
-0.0177705716,
0.0034387861,
0.076511547,
0.0457307808,
0.0053135836,
0.0604605153,
-0.033854872,
0.0624464452,
0.0091288127,
-0.0063611465,
-0.0508761369,
0.0528136827,
-0.0868843496,
-0.0024563451,
-0.0497886129,
0.0272104926,
-0.0634969398,
-0.019306425,
0.0018842244,
0.0413933434,
-0.0246213749,
0.029189609,
0.0054487102,
0.0268092435,
-0.015574648,
-0.0092622815,
0.0123242922,
-0.0337747894,
-0.0005625476,
0.0091178929,
-0.0092233513,
-0.0539157838,
0.0002381033,
0.0114423763,
0.0029939872,
-0.009959409,
-0.0002092677,
0.05116795,
-0.0209566969,
-0.0212619361,
-0.0090664085,
-0.0598453768,
-0.0056946157,
-0.0462406315,
0.0022212765,
-0.0951136351,
-0.0291018412,
-0.0054338942,
-0.0230374858,
-0.0218810402,
0.0202772468,
-0.0064733117,
-0.0082401726,
0.0591479316,
0.0251159668,
0.0344920158,
0.0255464148,
0.0318893977,
0.019653108,
0.0484890305,
0.0278145317,
0.0729644671,
-0.0082319863,
0.0256535113,
0.0368348546,
0.0442585498,
-0.0433536805,
0.0057531591,
0.0191571657,
-0.0014462518,
0.02624196,
0.0542918295,
-0.0062373732,
0.013727284,
-0.021899147,
0.0444839001,
0.0509972051,
0.0592886135,
0.0211782232,
0.0198609158,
0.0723889619,
0.0281970836,
-0.0507437363,
-0.0456325859,
-0.0218515992,
0.0500913113,
0.0087729897,
-0.007999084,
0.0132188695,
0.0261186324,
-0.0183523148,
-0.0451951809,
0.0065306807,
-0.0070935292,
0.0040651825,
-0.0080350582,
0.0254228227,
-0.0127500389,
-0.070461981,
0.0025112997,
-0.030189814,
-0.0611800216,
0.0103381909,
-0.0624652468,
0.0527514853,
0.0899164677,
0.0259777308,
-0.0360056497,
-0.0007926015,
-0.0089139901,
0.0131487269,
-0.0433966033,
0.0011627263,
-0.0324230678,
-0.0018664795,
-0.0213520732,
-0.0517494231,
-0.0321657732,
0.0132515263,
0.0331077091,
0.0169280358,
-0.016615741,
0.0290742386,
0.0206130929,
-0.0088455733,
0.0185966268,
-0.0236208197,
-0.0752846301,
0.0025856392,
0.0134478714,
0.0145015381,
-0.0051030694,
0.0007986538,
0.0077438601,
0.0492001809,
-0.0392743014,
-0.0320070013,
0.0235341489,
-0.0507114753,
-0.0623326004,
0.0177850164,
0.0156819429,
0.0228069406,
0.001239942,
-0.0280364566,
-0.0207381528,
0.0484569035,
-0.0164435953,
0.0393345356,
-0.0120216319,
0.0116528468,
-0.0054145241,
-0.0567629561,
-0.0594867505,
0.0542146973,
-0.0081624296,
0.0126966983,
0.0335414149,
0.0247179493,
0.004157708,
-0.0204685759,
0.0048453873,
0.0240987819,
-0.0155327804,
0.0473974049,
0.0377190672,
0.0395161882,
-0.0438967906,
-0.0262081791,
-0.1200145409,
-0.0217514746,
-0.044983726,
0.0080159269,
0.0075936071,
0.0145605952,
-0.0139663825,
-0.0235085916,
-0.0133247878,
-0.0148430532,
0.016826693,
0.0137811648,
0.0003832759,
0.0260173921,
-0.0335936062,
-0.0466942787,
-0.0036656444,
-0.0068851947,
0.0538615696,
0.006985737,
-0.0105935056,
-0.0607321411,
0.0796483979,
0.0218338463,
0.0146482587,
-0.0240881201,
-0.0340163074,
0.0617957599,
-0.083408691,
0.0745903328,
0.0589279197,
-0.0374118052,
0.0322388895,
0.0749291852,
-0.022180384,
-0.0892455578,
0.0100039812,
-0.0144992424,
-0.051696673,
-0.0148375826,
-0.0038737976,
0.0428590663,
0.0663810819,
-0.0030133869,
0.0105025088,
-0.0458835028,
0.005663279,
0.0121081797,
-0.0350329801,
-0.0010262135,
-0.0344307609,
-0.0217847358,
0.0272207335,
-0.0092319744,
-0.0655601844,
0.0340420865,
-0.0336648114,
-0.031577576,
0.0046579875,
0.0066081276,
-0.0147470301,
0.1008736715,
-0.0014278674,
0.0083746528,
-0.0030633244,
-0.0445231907,
-0.0431337878,
-0.0294074118,
0.0334078297,
-0.0274289008,
-0.0186841749,
-0.0776280612,
0.0079333466,
0.0148908421,
-0.0619900599,
-0.0396454148,
-0.00562206,
-0.0239542667,
-0.0014302146,
-0.0061161537,
-0.0022579334,
-0.0092070326,
0.0133408336,
0.0400297306,
0.0174007211,
0.0281943083,
-0.0397245772,
-0.0150141623,
0.025388794,
0.0388152488,
0.0326994471,
-0.0735789537,
-0.0089011025,
0.0043400605,
0.0362129062,
0.0546741337,
0.0035231335,
-0.082939513,
0.011635703,
0.0627542511,
0.0174373444,
-0.0208314415,
0.0765715465,
0.0643830895,
-0.0438205078,
-0.0451539867,
0.0830881447,
0.0362502672,
-0.032006301,
-0.0050052446,
-0.0280660372,
0.0162345562,
0.009189236,
0.0117104873,
-0.0268837772,
-0.0331537388,
0.0043535191,
-0.0032368004,
-0.0023943072,
-0.0334838443,
0.0207144041,
-0.1352503151,
0.0418505147,
0.0231205095,
-0.0044967877,
-0.0501866341,
-0.0151211498,
0.022903163,
0.0190658234,
-0.0739411116,
0.0218408946,
0.0017107053,
0.0299284477,
0.0264796186,
-0.0396532156,
-0.0262228865,
0.0433892496,
-0.0469157435,
0.0797577947,
0.1036082879,
0.0170394387,
0.0387231037,
0.0120858783,
-0.0126682278,
0.03862416,
0.0449797474,
-0.0224866718,
-0.0130020482,
0.0062585049,
0.0025646661,
0.0137897199,
0.0369165838,
-0.041459538,
-0.060812436,
0.019136142,
0.0701978877,
-0.0434594117,
0.0116814915,
-0.0156035563,
0.0083089173,
0.0734417364,
0.0260328501,
-0.0043817265,
-0.0224528145,
-0.0306996647,
-0.0194107182,
-0.0046710568,
-0.0510101467,
-0.0385231897,
-0.0382126421,
0.0145881772,
0.0785655677,
-0.0863400623,
-0.0260254685,
0.0361138433,
0.0397579968,
-0.0053452058,
0.004471336,
-0.0011259558,
0.0382765569,
-0.0656005815,
0.0081277704,
-0.0216614679,
0.025409596,
-0.0304608438,
0.0049674069,
0.0328330211,
-0.0641575754,
0.0155612938,
0.013152563,
-0.0611438341,
-0.0584670231,
-0.0186629631,
0.0689921156,
0.0134861283,
0.0319997184,
0.0242920984,
-0.0291485954,
0.0043188799,
0.0270648003,
-0.0308659319,
0.0191863868,
0.0240186043,
0.0279478077,
0.0037983139,
-0.0028989003,
-0.0501680262,
0.0026173976,
0.0081155645,
0.0626024008,
-0.0548540279,
-0.0433434658,
0.0173812415,
-0.0215540957,
0.0433155149,
-0.0203848928,
-0.0035879058,
-0.010193984,
-0.005921883,
0.001927854,
-0.0027025337,
-0.0453476571,
0.0432611816,
0.0149678485,
-0.0003878288,
0.0320153646,
0.0316076055,
-0.0072701639,
0.0359599963,
-0.0035763097,
0.0583415329,
-0.0057775974,
0.0084605366,
0.0744987056,
0.01705084,
-0.0255689006,
0.0289520156,
0.0128245456,
0.0367026217,
0.0037822428,
0.0338944793,
0.0257895738,
0.0104663614,
-0.0338496007,
0.0363224782,
-0.0286598224,
-0.0668516085,
-0.0017955411,
0.0135971401,
0.0751020238,
0.003386793,
0.0071542859,
-0.0397812612,
0.0357201546,
-0.042065382,
0.0408990569,
0.0271940511,
-0.0734468251,
0.0001934466,
0.0546096265,
-0.0098344125,
-0.0058945357,
0.0641074926,
0.0033201627,
0.0163113326,
0.0007921954,
-0.028161427,
-0.0215616561,
-0.0275987256,
0.0429278389,
0.0261530653,
-0.0393853635,
0.0031589877,
-0.0339466929,
-0.012718874,
-0.0306132678,
0.0433694199,
-0.0056935833,
-0.0234193467,
0.0300661922,
0.0835911334,
0.01941007,
-0.0195643883,
-0.0565574802,
-0.009886221,
-0.0260380991,
-0.0177323725,
-0.082401149,
-5.159370337e-33,
-0.0200102124,
-0.0851069018,
0.0740982071,
-0.0073473309,
-0.0023904187,
-0.0179069061,
-0.0656480491,
0.0209368467,
0.0091769062,
-0.0420458987,
0.0011317218,
0.0006626536,
0.0034134744,
0.0126316054,
0.0624895766,
0.0157290492,
0.0402172208,
0.0122069037,
-0.0427347384,
0.0249633081,
0.0021670512,
0.0141429855,
-0.0038990115,
-0.0389515087,
-0.0088742329,
-0.0160968266,
-0.0044714687,
-0.0054581258,
0.0092055025,
0.0175540186,
-0.0110398885,
-0.0016998516,
0.0061448808,
-0.0091351457,
0.0031666039,
0.0346696004,
-0.0410506614,
-0.0049166707,
0.0079938648,
-0.0212593097,
-0.0345842354,
-0.0467509069,
-0.0211599208,
0.000504786,
-0.0538469553,
-0.0069185561,
0.0446785465,
0.0090663815,
-0.05553459,
0.0025529631,
-0.080187887,
-0.0048682634,
-0.0370373875,
-0.0476446636,
0.0158358365,
0.0151863499,
0.0255045611,
-0.016981855,
-0.0413210765,
0.0551414825,
-0.0397536531,
0.0601009503,
0.0406038389,
0.0638067573,
0.0213735048,
0.0562599003,
0.0202160869,
0.0234501939,
-0.0419938937,
0.0007534354,
0.0236404389,
0.071698606,
-0.0001802224,
0.0467484184,
0.0058191158,
0.0573771484,
-0.0351427533,
0.0248747226,
-0.020781666,
0.0682517067,
0.0462126955,
0.0427297987,
-0.0201558415,
-0.0151784383,
-0.0258024279,
0.0232943296,
0.0016290345,
-0.0272718687,
0.042258922,
0.0328765735,
0.0035187625,
-0.0523599908,
0.0607881956,
-0.0174414907,
0.0013607047,
0.0260938928,
-0.0519556589,
0.0117822923,
-0.0413004719,
0.033753112,
-0.0273268241,
-0.053304676,
0.0295955222,
0.0094626844,
0.0151012009,
0.0214807652,
-0.0388533249,
0.0698156804,
-0.0435847938,
-0.019834552,
-0.0536707751,
-0.0245409869,
-0.0227178708,
-0.0113510853,
0.0192463081,
-0.0336991027,
-0.0123622753,
0.0097240033,
-0.0203443356,
-0.0530564934,
-0.0024447148,
-0.0473960117,
-0.0222303923,
-0.0222341046,
-0.0205438416,
0.0025135879,
-0.0783699825,
0.0507829972,
0.0624155067,
-0.0158711839,
-0.0253165383,
-0.0022557203,
2.836e-7,
-0.0212068185,
0.0382679552,
-0.0243439078,
-0.0012382432,
-0.0285751168,
0.0533074476,
-0.0263961535,
0.0109023741,
0.0267519914,
0.0399445929,
0.0556124747,
0.0279354062,
0.0409901738,
-0.0241774358,
-0.1008368731,
0.0249185041,
-0.0355007462,
-0.0083795497,
-0.0646656603,
-0.0123884911,
0.0456774645,
0.0167617574,
0.0002658667,
0.0172357131,
0.0279194955,
-0.094731845,
0.0365550295,
-0.0373192839,
0.0076935622,
0.0111215329,
-0.0226197317,
-0.0132166399,
-0.0161734708,
-0.0627653003,
-0.012507366,
-0.0366861075,
-0.0064107296,
0.0496140011,
-0.0004109262,
0.0204032883,
0.0075498219,
-0.0201979503,
0.0030254973,
-0.0012148685,
0.0165853053,
-0.0735089704,
0.0223457795,
0.0244097617,
0.0068372632,
-0.0117294323,
-0.0394238643,
-0.0013247556,
0.0022844947,
-0.0209039226,
-0.0108610932,
-0.0238377601,
0.0059056762,
-0.0802552551,
-0.0165661797,
-0.0042359629,
-0.0541198254,
-0.0489406697,
-0.0341213681,
-0.0081330482,
-0.0103431698,
-0.0268536545,
0.0014499074,
2.48530615e-34,
-0.0259751175,
0.0064898711,
0.0203277431,
0.0549138896,
0.0346574187,
0.0068736235,
-0.0143452343,
0.0516420938,
0.0481809564,
-0.0612215102,
-0.0152088543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17542v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17542v2 | CDQuant: Accurate Post-training Weight Quantization of Large Pre-trained Models using Greedy Coordinate Descent | 2024-06-25T13:29:14 | 2024-06-26T07:44:42 | Pranav Ajit Nair, Arun Sai Suggala | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have recently demonstrated remarkable
performance across diverse language tasks. But their deployment is often
constrained by their substantial computational and storage requirements.
Quantization has emerged as a key technique for addressing this challenge,
enabling the compression of large models with minimal impact on performance.
The recent GPTQ algorithm, a post-training quantization (PTQ) method, has
proven highly effective for compressing LLMs, sparking a wave of research that
leverages GPTQ as a core component. Recognizing the pivotal role of GPTQ in the
PTQ landscape, we introduce CDQuant, a simple and scalable alternative to GPTQ
with improved performance. CDQuant uses coordinate descent to minimize the
layer-wise reconstruction loss to achieve high-quality quantized weights. Our
algorithm is easy to implement and scales efficiently to models with hundreds
of billions of parameters. Through extensive evaluation on the PaLM2 model
family, we demonstrate that CDQuant consistently outperforms GPTQ across
diverse model sizes and quantization levels. In particular, for INT2
quantization of PaLM2-Otter, CDQuant achieves a 10% reduction in perplexity
compared to GPTQ. | [
-0.0388786085,
0.1333447546,
0.0106212338,
0.0269220918,
0.0173252355,
0.020752646,
-0.0043918192,
0.0395180844,
-0.0370271392,
-0.0139473835,
-0.0425521098,
-0.0373970754,
-0.0010746676,
0.0076222261,
0.0017767872,
-0.0220314823,
0.0374563821,
-0.0056540878,
-0.0332229324,
-0.0251050573,
-0.004951661,
0.0341088809,
0.0248563271,
0.0282600392,
-0.0055454518,
-0.0229030382,
-0.0236134212,
0.0144783529,
-0.0167919863,
-0.0227808263,
0.002835446,
0.0810046792,
0.0398217291,
0.0508287735,
0.0000023644,
-0.0097672101,
-0.0147610418,
0.0152448788,
-0.0457427949,
0.09635593,
0.0272393357,
-0.0109787304,
-0.0199905355,
0.001098366,
-0.0237619914,
-0.048985865,
0.0641435087,
0.0449461862,
0.0432429314,
0.0424425043,
-0.0033746297,
-0.0401005112,
0.0027302667,
-0.0153809022,
-0.021152135,
-0.042119313,
0.0157777127,
0.019793218,
-0.0070869843,
0.016175054,
-0.0052621057,
0.0291949511,
0.0261658207,
0.0328795873,
-0.0318527557,
0.0252840985,
-0.0449304469,
-0.0152804814,
0.0061373198,
0.0530190356,
-0.0494467653,
-0.0403501764,
-0.023625249,
0.0270190593,
-0.0217306893,
-0.0731722862,
-0.0325048789,
0.0000262012,
0.0279840175,
0.0440110527,
-0.0070693763,
-0.0332792513,
0.0628592223,
-0.0169470347,
-0.0626314059,
0.0195344761,
0.0526406914,
-0.0087191174,
-0.0268390607,
-0.0141942604,
-0.0748976171,
-0.0261285789,
0.0142674353,
-0.0282080323,
0.0037704997,
-0.0283995606,
-0.0362455547,
-0.0310592018,
-0.0097472314,
0.0060510002,
0.0585977025,
0.043520391,
-0.0102337394,
0.0245016944,
-0.0088307569,
0.03701666,
-0.0251463968,
0.010012283,
-0.0258451719,
0.0066032228,
-0.0341980532,
-0.0038175709,
-0.0620621294,
0.0344920047,
-0.0273108818,
-0.015989095,
-0.0013709529,
-0.0244154483,
0.0042781453,
-0.063523367,
0.0548690706,
0.0344227292,
-0.025478255,
-0.0074702748,
0.0347938649,
0.0391864143,
0.0202398915,
0.0265696701,
-0.0194747485,
-0.0312237963,
-0.0219356436,
0.0170242842,
0.0213177223,
-0.0330539346,
0.0289211422,
-0.0003211394,
-0.0033291155,
-0.0476263389,
0.0364170745,
0.0235743225,
-0.0118307052,
-0.0471948497,
-0.0458240174,
-0.0622348525,
0.009773192,
-0.044905331,
0.0085328715,
-0.0105164638,
0.017487403,
0.0004684313,
-0.0157660283,
0.0548986085,
-0.0284802578,
0.0072934558,
0.036942523,
0.0195777584,
0.0198086947,
0.0606282912,
0.0087788748,
0.0150069147,
-0.0002321038,
-0.0258411709,
-0.0163879469,
0.0630563647,
0.0310305003,
-0.0040157,
-0.0254817326,
-0.0209376197,
0.0039129616,
0.0352402367,
0.0753244907,
0.0699875653,
-0.0870073885,
-0.0207836833,
0.0332581028,
0.0778674781,
0.0362071432,
0.0327482373,
0.0232154019,
0.0424291268,
0.0054113595,
-0.0320470333,
-0.0406978577,
0.0005437264,
0.0015525437,
-0.0122293765,
0.0162076075,
0.0491502099,
-0.0375557877,
-0.0135061033,
0.0036079923,
-0.0216338076,
0.0224276073,
0.0142750852,
0.0326459892,
0.0206123181,
-0.0237759184,
0.0918908641,
0.020286575,
-0.0642956942,
-0.0076302388,
-0.0583437532,
-0.0174305011,
0.0067740758,
0.0232496709,
-0.0037522656,
0.0000817721,
0.033289548,
-0.0052117757,
-0.0144565953,
-0.0164902527,
0.011726276,
0.0584593937,
-0.049869217,
-0.0174326468,
0.0411600545,
0.0336144082,
-0.006345124,
0.0533284098,
0.0193093829,
-0.0019176661,
-0.0271166693,
-0.0168404281,
0.0275672134,
-0.0129630016,
-0.0578399599,
0.0341891274,
-0.003567603,
0.0219096616,
0.003799526,
-0.0181883443,
-0.0036771933,
0.065255627,
-0.0444114469,
0.0264012516,
-0.0428659916,
-0.0210537389,
-0.0630627051,
0.0695579723,
0.0102330558,
0.0081349639,
0.100505881,
-0.0211418029,
-0.047111921,
0.0193153247,
-0.0000472106,
0.0495120585,
-0.0786499381,
0.0068768053,
-0.0289652888,
0.0233981982,
-0.0191358086,
-0.0008376295,
0.0018238536,
-0.0092372382,
0.0232555773,
-0.0047924803,
-0.0149388956,
-0.05630574,
-0.0013611993,
0.0090249013,
-0.0028909333,
0.0487566069,
0.0039932351,
0.0292289592,
0.0228979271,
0.0088466145,
-0.1436015517,
0.0061353636,
-0.0403260551,
0.004302375,
0.0337039195,
0.0370898843,
0.0022394215,
-0.0070070652,
-0.0219632126,
-0.0318972096,
-0.0058727171,
-0.0072414014,
-0.0208993237,
-0.0230133031,
-0.0154732401,
-0.0374424197,
-0.0505371541,
0.0300157964,
0.0492138229,
-0.067310214,
-0.0322815254,
-0.0462271199,
0.0222960357,
-0.0222490858,
0.0351813063,
0.0164413452,
-0.0565037653,
0.0067013693,
-0.0294839796,
-0.0155346235,
0.0468318611,
0.0138335489,
0.0176386423,
0.057194829,
0.0105234236,
-0.0341811292,
0.0059523415,
-0.040124435,
-0.0485069789,
-0.0238071475,
-0.031151535,
-0.0302429572,
0.0904968902,
-0.0229435395,
-0.017984746,
-0.0537555031,
-0.0339735411,
-0.0161449127,
-0.0102404421,
-0.0512976646,
0.0103021786,
-0.0328296088,
0.0508151464,
-0.0040846886,
-0.0421521775,
0.0397279859,
-0.0455635898,
-0.0066093723,
-0.0370005257,
-0.0081063136,
-0.0274997726,
0.0651559681,
0.0088274302,
0.0474636704,
-0.0229048207,
-0.0047206748,
-0.0433618538,
0.0052353321,
-0.0222318284,
-0.0249759238,
-0.036368832,
-0.0001944651,
0.0153301498,
-0.016392922,
-0.0415021218,
0.0311670732,
-0.0113495644,
-0.0328637287,
0.0357869156,
0.0147797437,
-0.0477733314,
0.0278677028,
0.0329199769,
-0.0083165858,
0.0427911952,
-0.013687443,
0.0301167984,
-0.0047205412,
0.0359753743,
0.024551129,
0.0053322162,
0.0450261347,
-0.0068990602,
0.0264188088,
0.032146994,
0.0204425491,
0.0289610624,
-0.0302440003,
0.0157449115,
0.0463439897,
0.0242411215,
-0.0332473777,
-0.0041191638,
0.0596682057,
-0.0421168804,
-0.0020919861,
0.0926625282,
0.0140274614,
-0.0769260079,
0.0035386994,
0.0170255732,
0.0343697518,
-0.0031176717,
0.0025066289,
-0.0895400569,
-0.0439657979,
0.0139930854,
-0.0059997593,
0.0623551831,
0.0158039816,
0.0103861643,
-0.0626487657,
0.0389699303,
0.0557640493,
-0.0002131761,
0.0099701686,
-0.0181091633,
-0.0188347567,
-0.0247943494,
0.0399520881,
0.0424263217,
-0.0041392371,
0.0222389977,
0.0218272582,
0.0071588475,
-0.0255187936,
0.0423149355,
-0.0211546272,
0.0069596274,
0.0633859038,
0.0236172024,
0.0077716121,
-0.0156426523,
0.0381016061,
0.0076699336,
-0.0390768349,
-0.0002874807,
-0.0167712625,
0.0174277239,
-0.0125958044,
0.0092493175,
0.0395419151,
-0.0198868569,
0.003610959,
-0.0067560612,
0.0810048953,
0.009559554,
-0.0253429133,
0.0126755582,
-0.036670424,
-0.0597907938,
0.063816011,
0.0508796945,
-0.0184971504,
-0.0401284136,
-0.0019419348,
-0.0126371244,
-0.0247109868,
-0.0387568474,
0.0233334117,
0.0066399327,
-0.0765173808,
-0.043954473,
0.0029316244,
0.0210890528,
0.014098227,
-0.0412344709,
0.0032851244,
-0.0101200501,
-0.0002387124,
-0.1012367383,
0.0376275852,
-0.0231147036,
0.0131799961,
-0.0699158534,
0.026032649,
-0.0054036281,
-0.0228287466,
-0.0139021967,
-0.028028883,
-0.0966039523,
-0.0511505716,
0.005821439,
0.0308827702,
0.011286973,
0.0355152376,
-0.0100872386,
-0.0496292375,
0.0220784619,
0.0335984752,
-0.0139781088,
0.0580517165,
0.0459832735,
-0.074446857,
0.0013396306,
0.0565402955,
-0.0170315541,
0.0419634134,
-0.038982451,
0.0285001975,
-0.0428164676,
-0.0767685249,
-0.0026181764,
0.0056644301,
0.0855455473,
-0.0125937862,
0.0160178561,
0.0053237523,
0.0226630289,
-0.0082190642,
0.0173917897,
-0.0584731884,
0.0114323441,
0.0395246744,
0.0214676522,
-0.0207762141,
-0.0087734405,
0.0387175903,
0.0029247296,
0.0021340386,
-0.0006133822,
-0.0501868874,
0.0063973991,
0.0621169098,
-0.0081935227,
-0.0189961065,
0.0184236728,
-0.0382595137,
0.0085847341,
-0.0428446941,
-0.0108969882,
-0.0183424056,
0.0305031892,
-0.0430596247,
0.047714632,
-0.0210993532,
-0.1028636023,
-0.0527546257,
-0.0331329331,
0.06352254,
0.0152428066,
0.0540274754,
0.0363177583,
-0.0496679991,
-0.0380669758,
0.0217292048,
-0.0164842755,
-0.0051740981,
0.0244780462,
0.0119373929,
-0.0261835828,
0.0070413304,
0.0686196163,
0.0424586311,
0.0201870091,
0.0110433362,
0.0012191334,
0.007745828,
-0.0108131589,
-0.0108621055,
0.0358378626,
-0.0314900689,
-0.0350494161,
0.0092807813,
-0.0723171458,
0.0266948845,
0.0020873148,
-0.0483178906,
-0.0176107679,
0.044781357,
0.0019437466,
-0.0063179764,
-0.0071161715,
-0.0149252703,
-0.0331539325,
0.0044243014,
-0.0393208899,
0.0171920881,
-7.026570379e-33,
0.0016612773,
0.041790396,
-0.0001897107,
-0.0209925715,
-0.0389097035,
0.0306670349,
-0.0136433914,
-0.0114023685,
-0.0022808893,
0.005073878,
-0.011410349,
0.0301664602,
0.0035419655,
0.0215298701,
-0.0134807797,
0.0301581435,
0.0810539424,
-0.0260810424,
-0.0026214789,
0.0482275672,
-0.0035704274,
0.0433485173,
0.0609019585,
0.0142580047,
-0.0639158636,
0.0205832142,
0.0043437639,
0.0151330959,
0.0045630201,
0.0420952812,
-0.0616284534,
-0.0143591855,
-0.0206463747,
-0.0004850259,
-0.0292167552,
-0.0168499872,
-0.0685700551,
0.0129896766,
-0.0016963781,
0.0020089487,
-0.0028808354,
-0.019706808,
0.0102053089,
0.0032669173,
-0.0444874465,
-0.0398047939,
-0.024450019,
-0.0136773903,
-0.0475793928,
-0.081058003,
-0.006151062,
0.0349608958,
0.0130104776,
-0.0112615461,
0.0772849247,
-0.0123539316,
-0.0582133047,
0.0215054806,
-0.0476156995,
-0.0276034586,
0.0040005245,
0.0753553286,
0.0349092335,
0.0316851512,
0.0389488041,
0.0394639149,
0.0437360927,
-0.0511696227,
-0.0123558706,
0.0383834504,
0.0604591034,
0.031165557,
0.0566520542,
0.0313667692,
0.0982375443,
-0.0088573303,
-0.076200828,
0.0012750237,
-0.0502209887,
-0.0081089986,
0.0090941535,
0.0500712171,
0.0151679646,
-0.0267356448,
-0.0516468361,
-0.0206870027,
-0.0341937654,
-0.0252694152,
-0.0019780253,
0.0228899978,
-0.0555501059,
0.0140396971,
0.0459447578,
-0.0450551473,
-0.0089964699,
-0.0070127556,
-0.0334215872,
0.0072757369,
0.0183501691,
0.0380752645,
-0.0271665063,
-0.0096192192,
0.0197503008,
0.002969424,
0.0147119407,
-0.0205301289,
0.019485347,
0.0405148007,
-0.0534814186,
-0.023742428,
-0.0287082754,
-0.0246754717,
0.0134347407,
0.0822302327,
0.0269777793,
0.0130447913,
0.0356178619,
0.0532883219,
0.0056792023,
0.0115043027,
-0.0570073314,
0.0143694524,
0.0368505232,
0.0528633855,
-0.008591556,
0.0091091674,
-0.0718747899,
0.0397602469,
0.0371931233,
-0.072009176,
-0.0504511185,
0.0400106385,
2.922e-7,
0.0474847332,
0.0169450119,
0.0130765857,
-0.0555499047,
0.0022137801,
0.0116618676,
-0.0035686197,
0.0178662706,
-0.011313891,
-0.0081968112,
0.030494377,
0.0567066371,
0.0436773151,
0.0173676275,
-0.080160901,
0.0088264579,
-0.0641720593,
-0.0058331173,
-0.0526561961,
-0.0471505448,
-0.0034845644,
0.1345912963,
-0.0097855469,
-0.0244481973,
0.0497996323,
0.0151050463,
0.0491989367,
-0.0112446919,
0.0167298149,
-0.0024673026,
0.0027086823,
0.0047210548,
0.0026322589,
-0.0786552876,
0.0020666346,
0.0115495408,
-0.0118954424,
0.0835891291,
-0.0422750451,
0.0009502866,
0.0163314044,
0.0110317096,
-0.0298153963,
-0.0501452051,
0.054361064,
-0.0234336834,
0.0172933582,
-0.1060630977,
-0.0113858571,
-0.0347103886,
0.0223437417,
-0.0306702927,
0.0336488895,
0.0484728627,
0.0238581989,
-0.016100252,
-0.0114379413,
-0.0840304047,
-0.0296393596,
0.0245586112,
-0.0262591783,
-0.0152734453,
-0.0577025861,
-0.0060048061,
0.0275496803,
-0.021717852,
0.0245038159,
2.999862961e-34,
0.0322520472,
-0.0107609676,
0.02845072,
0.0487391129,
0.0023377214,
-0.051086098,
0.0227555856,
0.0191926435,
-0.0361657217,
-0.0657124072,
-0.0200853553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17535v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17535v1 | Disce aut Deficere: Evaluating LLMs Proficiency on the INVALSI Italian Benchmark | 2024-06-25T13:20:08 | 2024-06-25T13:20:08 | Fabio Mercorio, Mario Mezzanzanica, Daniele Potertì, Antonio Serino, Andrea Seveso | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly
enhanced their ability to generate and manipulate human language, highlighting
their potential across various applications. Evaluating LLMs in languages other
than English is crucial for ensuring their linguistic versatility, cultural
relevance, and applicability in diverse global contexts, thus broadening their
usability and effectiveness. We tackle this challenge by introducing a
structured benchmark using the INVALSI tests, a set of well-established
assessments designed to measure educational competencies across Italy. Our
study makes three primary contributions: Firstly, we adapt the INVALSI
benchmark for automated LLM evaluation, which involves rigorous adaptation of
the test format to suit automated processing while retaining the essence of the
original tests. Secondly, we provide a detailed assessment of current LLMs,
offering a crucial reference point for the academic community. Finally, we
visually compare the performance of these models against human results.
Additionally, researchers are invited to submit their models for ongoing
evaluation, ensuring the benchmark remains a current and valuable resource. | [
-0.0231401343,
0.0242754892,
-0.0489689484,
0.0369844735,
-0.0370732136,
0.0074159382,
0.0325497054,
0.021875497,
0.0260929558,
-0.0096810665,
-0.0339928865,
-0.0337299369,
0.0047557508,
-0.0035595689,
0.0403592363,
-0.0423124358,
0.0448764935,
-0.0352432579,
-0.0343345292,
-0.0049927551,
-0.001266059,
-0.0075117745,
-0.0222726446,
0.0333262533,
0.0052868887,
0.0171386935,
0.0298735853,
-0.0155240409,
0.0101466468,
-0.0195532218,
0.0160217937,
0.0378563255,
0.0007935353,
0.0063259052,
0.0000021896,
-0.0731601939,
0.01256618,
-0.0355190597,
0.0211728755,
0.0462145992,
0.0454389341,
0.0409393013,
-0.0458348021,
0.0100775417,
-0.0314325467,
0.0447844155,
0.0191752594,
-0.0619099364,
0.0158870816,
0.0526705123,
-0.0061017987,
0.0029208364,
0.0349282473,
-0.0182070881,
-0.0383426882,
0.0004567302,
0.0044122352,
0.0193034466,
0.0207885187,
-0.0056175534,
-0.0027199103,
0.0249900967,
-0.0096990438,
-0.0023622664,
-0.0420036316,
-0.0058534271,
0.0046129404,
-0.0233754255,
0.0044893902,
0.0272270497,
0.0197404139,
-0.0184402578,
0.0040965476,
0.0025089982,
0.0101004094,
0.0314739868,
-0.0629304349,
0.0140569825,
0.0150660686,
0.0094182426,
0.050284896,
0.0160397179,
0.0017707552,
0.0059882947,
-0.0006792582,
0.0781994089,
0.0668595359,
-0.0517027304,
0.043592751,
0.0060658138,
-0.0102885254,
-0.0452715345,
-0.0053880354,
0.055459667,
-0.0288289916,
0.0063532018,
-0.0177531876,
-0.0181105305,
0.0728690624,
-0.0509782843,
0.0617253147,
0.0318852514,
-0.0152384248,
0.0262389723,
-0.0049510249,
0.1052015871,
-0.0002942713,
0.0096148523,
-0.0442294516,
0.0114699397,
-0.035663642,
0.0110557275,
-0.0152837699,
-0.0185331926,
-0.0431114845,
0.0300842691,
-0.0821313336,
-0.0039393967,
-0.0452508703,
0.017935317,
-0.0050556031,
-0.0726507381,
-0.003459688,
0.0371504314,
-0.0328783728,
0.0421082601,
-0.0476083271,
-0.002453997,
-0.0179098602,
-0.0632669926,
0.0428747423,
0.025500834,
-0.031530153,
-0.0210023243,
0.0279705916,
0.0448912494,
-0.0018812709,
-0.0137975588,
-0.0192885362,
-0.0214939211,
-0.0342815369,
-0.0861734599,
0.0206499174,
-0.0767357573,
0.0275020842,
-0.0078894738,
0.0066993143,
-0.053192284,
-0.0041630375,
0.034318801,
0.0354385003,
-0.0141936094,
-0.0281259231,
0.0041854125,
0.0264614858,
0.0122447852,
-0.0015417675,
0.0510774367,
0.0578209721,
-0.0066998196,
0.0340448692,
-0.0369115807,
0.0006898035,
0.0998582393,
0.0108806454,
0.0452622324,
-0.0563146919,
0.0043594097,
0.0051186727,
0.0295848958,
0.0378423855,
0.0497964136,
0.0221400391,
0.040623039,
0.0550751686,
0.0668292493,
0.0243199244,
-0.0003256826,
0.0491773002,
0.0109811788,
0.0472383797,
-0.0094664404,
0.0068852566,
-0.0151120955,
-0.0092631206,
0.0156213883,
-0.0303468555,
0.0572358109,
-0.0096564787,
-0.034070909,
-0.010478802,
-0.0246509276,
0.0247840062,
0.003940491,
0.062449351,
-0.0263131876,
-0.0241808817,
0.0242102388,
0.0445989259,
-0.0705720782,
0.0417767614,
-0.0446353853,
0.0248354692,
0.0857625827,
0.0319540873,
0.0042322138,
-0.0154543277,
0.0197303444,
0.0200941041,
0.0792076439,
0.0318368003,
-0.0104276361,
-0.0281230845,
-0.0572576597,
0.0131317033,
-0.001144095,
0.0094899023,
0.0219204463,
-0.0017848214,
0.0313638151,
0.0075187501,
-0.0435543656,
-0.0390820391,
0.0165933762,
-0.0823300257,
0.0004896203,
-0.0409474708,
-0.0059191892,
-0.0135100381,
0.0279316194,
-0.0146114193,
0.0132684894,
0.0417939946,
-0.0287167262,
0.0160927903,
-0.0130017065,
-0.0317518674,
0.0272787232,
0.0423728563,
-0.0412529111,
-0.0133896619,
-0.0074019437,
0.0048016724,
-0.0313185118,
0.0054130056,
-0.0249702409,
0.0108255427,
-0.0163431279,
0.0414814502,
-0.053406097,
0.021349553,
-0.0412902199,
0.0461031087,
-0.0182271823,
0.062962614,
0.0172170065,
0.0209894571,
0.0254888032,
-0.0461649671,
-0.0614652671,
0.0159585644,
-0.0122499112,
0.0137512162,
0.0034129536,
0.0489354208,
-0.0542941578,
-0.0680597574,
-0.0942366868,
0.005558013,
-0.0047572679,
0.0307622775,
0.0171797872,
-0.0225185435,
-0.0336540006,
0.0412287004,
-0.0381360352,
-0.0311975256,
0.0327626467,
-0.0007321402,
0.0308771376,
-0.0291328859,
-0.0581495874,
-0.0562146418,
-0.0114542637,
-0.0049128183,
-0.005318909,
0.0279018711,
0.0196917094,
-0.0114562931,
0.0374889635,
-0.0422005728,
-0.0100244163,
-0.0012926655,
-0.0445329584,
0.0241436865,
0.0133694401,
0.0630600229,
0.0400876887,
-0.0075554634,
0.0103409057,
0.0496022664,
-0.0478651449,
-0.0540028922,
-0.0163362361,
0.0242963787,
-0.0342350714,
-0.0930967256,
-0.1042202637,
-0.0019800607,
0.0494773164,
0.0047941329,
0.0192675292,
-0.021690255,
0.0184111819,
-0.0805713087,
-0.0268387571,
-0.0168678798,
0.0171047729,
-0.0366306268,
0.0704510584,
-0.0184224918,
-0.0265981853,
0.0170457717,
-0.0433462001,
0.0316986293,
-0.0095229158,
-0.0095067769,
-0.0393473022,
0.0310188644,
-0.0141643621,
-0.002482041,
-0.0514991023,
0.0110012311,
-0.0449779816,
-0.0169171728,
0.01580685,
-0.0785628185,
0.0608781688,
-0.0805438161,
0.0026407938,
0.0183252301,
-0.0178457871,
-0.0041787187,
0.0457624309,
0.0073276893,
0.0366641805,
0.0177643914,
-0.0219404157,
-0.0035035217,
-0.0201006159,
0.0112146344,
0.0314205289,
-0.0148992259,
0.0272342879,
-0.0121082542,
0.0195219852,
0.0225000009,
0.0011679337,
-0.0157372914,
-0.0479677208,
0.0294724945,
0.0163212828,
0.0250098221,
0.0273862593,
-0.0219710357,
0.0280395839,
0.039644789,
-0.0442583114,
-0.0289549194,
0.0328225717,
0.0392691717,
-0.0400759503,
-0.0313078575,
0.110715732,
0.0153490696,
-0.0172184575,
0.0169571768,
-0.0313178189,
0.0374013968,
0.0324554481,
0.0199436527,
-0.0773375854,
0.0441707522,
0.0002105494,
0.0294617731,
-0.0341098756,
-0.0092586568,
-0.0040269531,
-0.0947167277,
0.0621762648,
0.0026146639,
-0.0086022709,
0.0053017065,
-0.0343355834,
-0.0113331117,
0.0177236665,
0.0299589951,
0.0112374062,
-0.012053879,
-0.0053453208,
0.0264734626,
-0.0509115756,
-0.0693471581,
0.0550882295,
-0.0252617933,
0.0585060082,
-0.0025563787,
0.0377708636,
-0.0537101403,
-0.0465323254,
0.0392377824,
-0.004245203,
-0.0360478833,
-0.012017603,
0.0059686364,
0.0421904847,
-0.0039686211,
-0.0501463674,
-0.0246724412,
0.0110131558,
-0.0124824969,
0.0643395334,
0.07672631,
0.0068559088,
0.024793148,
-0.0068160598,
-0.0196662303,
-0.0003816379,
0.0547851361,
0.0561179407,
-0.0713691637,
0.0289581716,
-0.0004833252,
-0.0158870388,
-0.0360899977,
-0.058484178,
0.0386662968,
-0.0471651405,
-0.0023562701,
-0.0591964349,
-0.0318397135,
0.0326113887,
0.0105081024,
0.0165892001,
-0.0212231819,
0.0066802674,
-0.0442568697,
-0.0348320492,
0.0402236804,
-0.017293768,
0.0382728651,
-0.1086896732,
-0.0017494065,
0.0233639665,
0.003614862,
-0.0387856588,
0.0023587914,
-0.0845037848,
-0.0542618558,
0.0075357012,
0.0674656406,
0.0277206786,
-0.0190183595,
0.0134575218,
-0.0467328392,
0.0263125449,
-0.0443679094,
-0.0033595553,
0.0556289181,
-0.0205508061,
-0.0111990226,
0.0173282791,
0.0023903409,
-0.0301373638,
0.0247910339,
-0.0055574281,
0.0487663113,
0.002181065,
-0.0520659946,
0.0258222185,
0.0608432852,
0.0033035849,
-0.0610309914,
-0.0134492796,
-0.0238060504,
-0.0096935844,
-0.0372250713,
-0.0019531532,
-0.0182723626,
-0.0121641932,
0.0655032322,
0.0157189704,
0.0078441398,
-0.0212049,
-0.0498277582,
0.0160473362,
-0.0063615977,
0.0469637923,
-0.0216611084,
0.0342417099,
0.0015772041,
0.0187849477,
-0.0150217712,
0.0266157761,
-0.0454542451,
0.078592658,
-0.0144304223,
0.0629701018,
-0.0254042652,
0.0114648361,
0.0221694801,
0.0300318412,
0.0303758774,
-0.0322935022,
-0.0130741261,
0.0333160535,
0.067444317,
0.0250588935,
0.0932454988,
-0.02072726,
0.0075843143,
-0.0388639681,
-0.0136489375,
-0.0275641661,
-0.0284483805,
0.0180533938,
0.0050128275,
0.0105660213,
0.0010355114,
0.018778095,
0.0120210797,
-0.0006768594,
-0.0111606084,
0.0429155789,
-0.0185351521,
-0.0414818488,
-0.000616463,
-0.0158759467,
-0.0324385948,
-0.0366414785,
-0.0855266899,
-0.0736348853,
0.0068674404,
0.0633486137,
-0.0119128674,
-0.0237250738,
-0.0019604731,
0.0268342439,
-0.0379121341,
0.0221823212,
-0.0607706718,
0.0017201725,
0.0092286244,
-0.0419147685,
-0.0389846563,
-6.302465859e-33,
-0.0483882912,
-0.0276767034,
0.0668037012,
0.0071572224,
-0.0197527353,
-0.0225475039,
-0.0065328819,
0.0011172957,
-0.0185111426,
-0.0220539141,
-0.0112543525,
-0.0563936494,
0.0067537585,
0.0029886949,
0.0220605321,
0.0262833461,
-0.0098576453,
-0.0011392642,
-0.0066539748,
-0.0293638241,
-0.016238939,
-0.0301634427,
0.0778452605,
-0.0387060568,
0.0608890057,
-0.046884615,
-0.0356213897,
-0.0026258125,
-0.0027017775,
0.0787523016,
0.0123714041,
0.0341538079,
0.0318369381,
-0.0090260385,
0.0091394363,
0.0132029569,
-0.0318917707,
-0.0449986383,
0.0489899963,
0.0243953243,
0.0239404645,
-0.0330970772,
0.0400785767,
-0.0053953505,
-0.0849154517,
0.0063197315,
0.0241851844,
-0.0251488369,
-0.003120522,
0.0013225154,
-0.0602030121,
0.0146835968,
-0.018247718,
0.0160914976,
-0.018831674,
0.0609380864,
-0.0243266467,
-0.0090000015,
-0.03714744,
0.0379009321,
0.0140072331,
0.0335428379,
0.0777595192,
-0.0007145632,
-0.011722602,
0.0606554709,
0.0536114052,
0.0076037631,
0.0557839386,
-0.0208888091,
0.0853944942,
0.0270426553,
0.057610672,
0.0676229745,
0.0153557546,
-0.0120564643,
-0.0707769543,
0.0157530122,
0.0578989387,
0.0122850072,
-0.0444849543,
-0.0178783443,
-0.0446804352,
-0.0282260105,
-0.0659118146,
-0.0087798992,
-0.0029468904,
-0.0391045064,
0.0787746608,
-0.0698990151,
0.0485804081,
-0.021029586,
0.0228859857,
-0.0203357935,
-0.0294018984,
-0.0222680215,
-0.0110770166,
0.0481115244,
-0.0179511644,
0.0614376478,
-0.0362691954,
-0.0415279195,
-0.0248200428,
0.0179430507,
0.0321864597,
0.0159448273,
0.0069011161,
-0.0228935499,
-0.0556139201,
0.0163807645,
-0.0192712862,
0.0021885424,
0.0107759628,
0.0025948428,
0.0254843198,
-0.0188439991,
0.0062108142,
0.0172249544,
0.037256211,
-0.0247625224,
-0.0205339007,
-0.0269135945,
0.014253892,
0.0401026271,
-0.0151371285,
0.0189512558,
-0.0301706363,
0.0401223116,
0.0388884656,
-0.0214582793,
0.0050839637,
-0.008615654,
2.873e-7,
0.0503000431,
0.0681036189,
-0.0215466265,
0.0188505352,
-0.0215497576,
-0.0152297281,
-0.061076615,
-0.0024118389,
0.0324090384,
0.0284533557,
0.0058384263,
0.0165039208,
0.0503053032,
0.0205796398,
-0.0468199179,
0.024685543,
-0.0415308923,
0.0083597638,
-0.0752430707,
0.0265365094,
0.0180994589,
0.0054837749,
0.0303770434,
-0.041604694,
-0.0653584823,
-0.0494708307,
0.0563595258,
-0.0341734663,
-0.0601383224,
0.0514923595,
0.0311154164,
0.0273923278,
0.0287638884,
0.0304990634,
-0.0123052448,
0.0267565902,
0.0032381788,
0.0866099149,
0.0085561499,
0.0276834667,
0.0448916219,
-0.0593469143,
-0.0408496186,
-0.0539177433,
0.0203703884,
-0.0006853172,
0.0113928895,
-0.0440085866,
-0.0687894002,
-0.0085286163,
0.0222121142,
-0.0595662072,
-0.0289635863,
0.0190872066,
0.0361873545,
-0.02230273,
-0.0053288173,
0.0405570157,
-0.0178679135,
0.0147264535,
-0.0338291191,
-0.1040173471,
-0.0400948338,
0.0408352204,
-0.017656019,
-0.0200436339,
0.001104455,
2.766794803e-34,
0.0246123616,
-0.0038527255,
0.0394318476,
0.0352499112,
0.0343832485,
0.0084142368,
-0.040331807,
0.0406858586,
-0.0405046381,
-0.0295996014,
-0.010315639
] |
Subsets and Splits