id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07820v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07820v1 | On the Analysis of Cross-Lingual Prompt Tuning for Decoder-based Multilingual Model | 2023-11-14T00:43:33 | 2023-11-14T00:43:33 | Nohil Park, Joonsuk Park, Kang Min Yoo, Sungroh Yoon | cs.CL | cs.CL | An exciting advancement in the field of multilingual models is the emergence
of autoregressive models with zero- and few-shot capabilities, a phenomenon
widely reported in large-scale language models. To further improve model
adaptation to cross-lingual tasks, another trend is to further fine-tune the
language models with either full fine-tuning or parameter-efficient tuning.
However, the interaction between parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) and
cross-lingual tasks in multilingual autoregressive models has yet to be
studied. Specifically, we lack an understanding of the role of linguistic
distributions in multilingual models in the effectiveness of token-based prompt
tuning. To address this question, we conduct experiments comparing prompt
tuning and fine-tuning on the decoder-based multilingual model, XGLM, with four
cross-lingual tasks (XNLI, PAWS-X, POS, NER). According to our study, prompt
tuning achieves on par or better performance over fine-tuning across all
languages while updating at most 0.13\% of the model parameters. Moreover, we
empirically show that prompt tuning is more effective in enhancing the
performance of low-resource languages than fine-tuning. Our further analysis
shows that the phenomenon is related to the tokenization scheme of the
multilingual model. | [
-0.0003185376,
0.0120661361,
-0.0354544781,
0.0348597877,
-0.0493243411,
0.0302626267,
0.0263184793,
-0.0130823748,
-0.0704705641,
0.0010225074,
-0.0795303434,
-0.032251168,
0.0582563542,
0.0161769409,
0.0329169855,
-0.0304508246,
0.080723688,
-0.0855377614,
0.0028747569,
-0.0250485409,
-0.0255052503,
0.0050118165,
-0.0120312339,
0.0413562283,
0.0082655158,
-0.0061588869,
0.0107432269,
0.026755482,
-0.007742845,
-0.0009622457,
-0.0439350493,
0.0668352544,
-0.01930907,
0.0110783512,
0.0000019422,
-0.0730918273,
0.007090488,
-0.0206158292,
-0.0252693184,
0.0248067696,
0.0335809514,
-0.0799650624,
-0.038790103,
0.0031244722,
0.0231875256,
-0.036135897,
0.0539330691,
0.0039866907,
-0.006170481,
0.0626958981,
0.0100013139,
-0.0155216558,
0.0131494896,
-0.0206207912,
-0.0385697857,
-0.0457669906,
-0.0048930985,
-0.0178261138,
-0.0054511209,
0.0038853106,
-0.0803038105,
0.0548331141,
0.0177000556,
0.0283201952,
-0.0461827628,
0.0163001884,
0.0205273833,
-0.0311419461,
-0.0368517116,
0.0185566861,
-0.0388504826,
-0.0261833016,
-0.0250666402,
-0.0165306516,
0.0047675325,
-0.0273338165,
-0.017202355,
0.0325951241,
-0.0156740714,
0.0052495771,
0.0806132853,
-0.0265953932,
0.0207253043,
-0.0209390577,
-0.0141272601,
0.0644529909,
0.0340569504,
-0.042555131,
-0.0107494378,
0.0067847827,
0.016022956,
-0.0412743688,
-0.0026386289,
0.0029893401,
-0.0729847401,
0.019442454,
-0.0298483837,
-0.0256426539,
0.0057481783,
0.0148168094,
0.0312371757,
0.0862047002,
-0.0117733097,
0.0060133543,
-0.0013410843,
0.0660995319,
0.0019648965,
0.0145509904,
-0.0453737006,
-0.0313123725,
-0.0185227618,
-0.0026157708,
-0.0572366193,
-0.0049434109,
-0.0386065431,
-0.0007340709,
-0.0231577531,
0.0366564952,
0.0558424629,
-0.031243667,
0.0106543135,
-0.0507148765,
-0.0671530515,
-0.0100970557,
0.0093840128,
0.0746140033,
-0.0514543653,
-0.0152016757,
0.0115121184,
-0.0799940005,
-0.0071660308,
-0.0108693326,
0.005190643,
-0.0519576259,
-0.0113393404,
0.0418627113,
-0.0342839547,
-0.0212956481,
-0.0120972339,
-0.0116488505,
-0.0196678955,
-0.0487695709,
-0.0355598629,
-0.0395791717,
0.0425707623,
0.0514170304,
0.0283768382,
0.0101258736,
-0.0429259427,
-0.0280076209,
-0.033447329,
0.0336605161,
0.0181686897,
0.0343091711,
0.0254314691,
-0.0382327102,
-0.0064866836,
0.1118366644,
0.0025854758,
-0.0270900503,
0.041350726,
-0.0260452311,
-0.0217456166,
0.0731011629,
-0.0195074454,
0.0266955681,
0.0009948231,
-0.0260543395,
0.0687071085,
0.0063900859,
0.0585982352,
0.0257826112,
-0.0333216339,
0.0059941486,
0.0415715724,
0.0358054116,
0.0561880395,
-0.0040430501,
0.0464051627,
-0.0243885163,
-0.0066832583,
0.0458791777,
-0.0098585924,
-0.0011455426,
-0.0036076829,
0.0339783505,
0.0179259926,
0.071830526,
-0.0434552059,
-0.0062730452,
0.0060087903,
-0.0012290446,
-0.0106112482,
-0.0073898723,
0.0583716147,
0.0084761633,
-0.0483049415,
0.0321592577,
0.0334674083,
-0.0177604407,
0.0283273775,
-0.0608934127,
-0.0021314286,
0.0377768278,
0.0214578621,
0.0400390178,
0.0004016166,
0.0090159727,
0.0324751176,
0.0434939861,
0.0889933929,
0.019037202,
0.0354399234,
-0.0401529595,
-0.0278027747,
0.0079000844,
0.0055687628,
0.0731070712,
-0.0389706232,
0.0311295893,
-0.0188144185,
-0.007183312,
-0.0139627233,
0.005194922,
-0.0552876219,
0.0029838441,
0.0099620242,
0.0229799859,
-0.0044533745,
0.0127352383,
-0.0150032369,
0.0156460553,
-0.0134079913,
-0.0324281417,
0.0599883348,
0.0210789423,
-0.0540925302,
-0.019468708,
0.0145354811,
0.0376150757,
0.0109520927,
-0.0097861979,
0.0138223367,
-0.0662786961,
0.0296578128,
-0.0011374356,
0.0606164299,
-0.0256568007,
0.0365383625,
-0.0240497794,
0.0265832804,
-0.0079713715,
0.0223563928,
0.0011420015,
0.0306020975,
0.0405521914,
0.0565074086,
0.0192004461,
-0.0783640444,
-0.0323425494,
0.0384268276,
-0.0249793828,
-0.004726741,
0.0490533635,
0.00127191,
0.0085333064,
-0.0316661894,
-0.0607187077,
-0.0035022998,
-0.0529841445,
0.0142991003,
0.0226529073,
0.0153738745,
-0.0287086125,
-0.0118021695,
-0.0003779834,
-0.007669061,
0.0292889941,
0.0683200955,
-0.0040330738,
0.0146674188,
-0.0335445665,
-0.0146346232,
-0.0314519778,
0.0216634981,
0.0238190312,
-0.0011625196,
-0.0499630794,
-0.0838706642,
0.0263170283,
-0.0036226267,
0.0033821508,
-0.0056912573,
-0.0490317829,
0.0223828498,
0.0194060765,
0.0826658607,
0.0431383401,
-0.036255084,
0.0002908777,
0.0098375669,
-0.0105469096,
-0.0437491313,
-0.0055225338,
-0.0023601383,
-0.0736341625,
-0.0616271086,
-0.0362594053,
0.0226103477,
0.0931126773,
0.0169486962,
-0.0012155937,
-0.0920032635,
-0.0080169626,
-0.0384782702,
-0.0579458773,
-0.0400132127,
-0.0037012303,
-0.0108512826,
0.0457506739,
-0.0337350219,
-0.0582120195,
0.0675299242,
-0.0444777496,
-0.013004587,
-0.0346665047,
0.0204634257,
-0.0237109195,
0.021280162,
-0.0210035257,
0.0314593017,
0.0033969686,
-0.0671369359,
-0.0423780754,
0.0226908345,
0.022270944,
-0.0005310426,
0.0093845576,
-0.0126867499,
-0.0134961391,
-0.0182847343,
-0.0563365594,
0.0035070844,
-0.000241918,
-0.0085735479,
0.0316078849,
0.0429263785,
0.0023334757,
-0.0108883232,
0.0291442238,
0.0349347368,
0.014160946,
-0.0374808945,
0.0129107488,
-0.0315584429,
-0.0204965305,
0.0432303995,
0.0217626821,
-0.0059907185,
-0.043148566,
0.052677013,
-0.0416920334,
0.0183153581,
-0.0055381721,
0.0143204052,
0.0412757881,
0.0566667244,
-0.0111185033,
-0.0437851585,
0.026824832,
0.0554869883,
-0.0291973222,
-0.0253307614,
0.0832448453,
0.0110626426,
-0.0482127778,
0.0020474256,
-0.0481818765,
0.0352826491,
0.0197022147,
0.0273360778,
-0.0840100572,
-0.0155437617,
0.0253916066,
0.0056300159,
0.0071021062,
0.0078166733,
-0.0079702754,
-0.1451069117,
0.0128786974,
0.0126470178,
-0.0917230994,
-0.0393968746,
-0.0472011194,
-0.0314398967,
-0.0063947258,
0.080471836,
0.0481844395,
-0.0054094759,
-0.0001230843,
0.0382407941,
0.0166991465,
-0.0729205385,
-0.0043093329,
-0.0534734167,
0.0575513281,
0.0684322193,
-0.0191129241,
-0.002291328,
-0.0437778197,
0.0499381088,
-0.0205354206,
0.0339772515,
-0.026616862,
-0.0411681868,
0.016625803,
-0.0288445763,
0.0258893538,
-0.0068078539,
-0.0079535972,
0.0054314747,
-0.0276732501,
0.0373071097,
0.0031345128,
0.003711594,
0.0258679744,
-0.0304896254,
-0.0089980438,
0.0689893067,
0.0371072628,
-0.0464429222,
-0.0439589843,
-0.0381724648,
-0.0053235251,
-0.0648780316,
0.0104919439,
0.0137839066,
-0.0331123546,
-0.0782446936,
-0.0312030148,
-0.0299515091,
0.0269583594,
0.0246483516,
0.0165121984,
0.0466883667,
-0.0500050634,
0.001419715,
0.0232159607,
0.0077945804,
-0.0150040751,
0.0155076319,
-0.1129103005,
-0.0135152796,
0.0213145651,
-0.0366422087,
-0.0032048356,
0.001037355,
-0.0280071292,
-0.0692614019,
0.0083180387,
0.0389561579,
0.0191211384,
0.0466740318,
-0.0132105118,
-0.0778350383,
-0.0024722093,
0.0191254336,
-0.0143870115,
0.0557001345,
0.0105237495,
0.0186782237,
-0.0237701386,
0.0441633128,
-0.0427651107,
0.008948978,
0.0111180851,
0.071066916,
-0.003355331,
-0.0520875342,
0.0004697348,
0.0384407751,
0.0432616025,
-0.0376933254,
-0.0574460514,
-0.0309848301,
0.0135560306,
-0.0356803089,
0.0325533375,
-0.0088730492,
-0.0112591367,
0.0282149427,
-0.0219064057,
0.0181010067,
-0.0137281204,
0.0011972926,
0.0262166392,
-0.029390512,
-0.0017503507,
-0.0057537444,
0.0213384926,
0.0325109102,
0.0347835682,
-0.0205113869,
0.0356704891,
0.0168695673,
0.0125766136,
-0.0436990745,
0.0225925464,
0.0042522461,
0.0229151826,
-0.0213761944,
0.0258880947,
-0.0222286582,
-0.0398373641,
0.0273207705,
-0.0108448546,
0.0396334007,
0.0113339815,
0.0561241545,
-0.00705887,
-0.0016097649,
-0.0312370751,
0.0204648916,
0.0398291498,
-0.001814237,
0.0380820706,
-0.0012183489,
-0.0329670049,
-0.0311221089,
0.0659942031,
0.0076140766,
0.0261541214,
-0.0218792483,
0.0192475487,
0.0094601149,
0.0002447962,
-0.0123059861,
-0.0000823295,
-0.0509214327,
0.0114908852,
-0.0497315079,
-0.0570426174,
-0.0258964058,
0.0375958197,
0.0175278801,
0.0029556623,
-0.0024086621,
0.0688470006,
-0.0174832996,
-0.0133224232,
-0.0349745899,
-0.0162414834,
0.033790715,
-0.0181344096,
0.0248416308,
-6.205455249e-33,
-0.0293607861,
0.0431024842,
0.027288828,
-0.0328746252,
0.009088777,
-0.012404249,
-0.0321998969,
0.0242997464,
-0.0249955934,
-0.019921422,
-0.0284275617,
-0.0361853056,
0.0314593874,
-0.0056963624,
0.022990346,
0.0186037105,
0.0623105392,
-0.0115062743,
-0.0292802267,
-0.0027439022,
0.0605571792,
0.0411613323,
0.0617811754,
0.0504474752,
0.0302193239,
-0.0107404692,
0.0114091262,
0.0192244202,
0.0185616966,
0.0676309094,
-0.0081155989,
0.0419304855,
0.0409861356,
-0.0606821962,
-0.0411099866,
0.0218763445,
-0.089768894,
-0.0168082397,
0.0712615252,
0.0347154997,
0.0177239999,
-0.0549714267,
0.0015090355,
-0.0049229092,
-0.0655449778,
0.0241484419,
-0.00096736,
-0.0226075836,
-0.0419914573,
0.0031849758,
-0.0644713268,
0.0033113526,
0.0090303877,
-0.0111433798,
0.0373623706,
0.0502725504,
-0.025696326,
0.0259093828,
-0.0267854743,
0.0300393663,
0.0246404894,
0.0763788074,
0.090234831,
0.0486864485,
-0.0027169778,
-0.0029508525,
0.0593115538,
0.0153186275,
0.0212651212,
0.0111791911,
0.0795336068,
-0.0239464156,
0.0052772011,
0.0274635665,
0.0324988514,
-0.0556291938,
-0.0333723165,
-0.0117315669,
0.0415824652,
0.0286376048,
0.0263336375,
0.0187724642,
-0.0229299124,
-0.035627529,
-0.0545397513,
-0.0260100476,
-0.0458797812,
-0.0173257142,
0.0568795726,
-0.0041292193,
0.0103189377,
-0.0339621939,
0.0978284404,
-0.0091185216,
-0.0259845536,
0.0019096888,
-0.0082210815,
0.0279440675,
-0.0274673235,
0.0335060507,
-0.0453199148,
-0.055950895,
-0.0096773738,
0.0061646593,
0.0103041958,
0.0068148114,
0.0000770839,
0.005442237,
-0.0659426153,
0.0136024104,
-0.0218844954,
0.0277516972,
0.0158719271,
0.0354826972,
0.037341889,
-0.0133521389,
-0.01021994,
0.0433197059,
0.0042051664,
-0.0407139324,
-0.0178560447,
-0.0023800004,
-0.0041744113,
0.029268831,
-0.005742325,
0.0147727448,
-0.0432178527,
0.0470102578,
0.0329502635,
-0.0164520051,
-0.0358971693,
0.0348030478,
2.628e-7,
0.0376214087,
0.0176927727,
0.0352487788,
0.0204151832,
0.0234625619,
-0.0011312455,
-0.0593412928,
0.009454322,
0.0182617661,
-0.0030583551,
-0.0377633534,
0.0096617341,
0.0433616973,
0.0007799884,
-0.0638047308,
0.0211583395,
-0.0541079156,
0.0829348341,
-0.0637981072,
0.0294483565,
-0.0364880785,
0.0673650056,
-0.0478054844,
0.0076729325,
-0.0031188279,
-0.0177236088,
0.0253074691,
-0.0450503677,
-0.028108377,
0.0152085247,
0.0151747195,
-0.0029389455,
0.0212315619,
0.0171374567,
-0.0203178637,
0.0229789931,
-0.0038150998,
0.0446822681,
0.0078404481,
-0.0408330373,
0.0552728809,
0.001665039,
-0.0420107059,
-0.0543394238,
0.0611783899,
-0.0216948222,
0.005403623,
-0.0070444802,
0.0110627692,
0.0276144706,
0.025003748,
-0.0762632713,
-0.0410824344,
0.0403167345,
0.0586314127,
0.0127392365,
-0.011585217,
-0.0120895393,
-0.0080903461,
0.0356848314,
-0.0211832002,
-0.0641696826,
-0.0229046959,
-0.0190981347,
0.038169913,
-0.0477814414,
-0.0016591345,
2.372176299e-34,
0.0635064393,
-0.0210640188,
0.0633481294,
0.0037147121,
0.0171851832,
-0.0360020548,
-0.0305091888,
0.0560026355,
-0.002494399,
-0.0800387114,
-0.0446163714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07811v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07811v2 | In-context Learning Generalizes, But Not Always Robustly: The Case of Syntax | 2023-11-13T23:52:43 | 2024-04-10T15:38:33 | Aaron Mueller, Albert Webson, Jackson Petty, Tal Linzen | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning (ICL) is now a common method for teaching large language
models (LLMs) new tasks: given labeled examples in the input context, the LLM
learns to perform the task without weight updates. Do models guided via ICL
infer the underlying structure of the task defined by the context, or do they
rely on superficial heuristics that only generalize to identically distributed
examples? We address this question using transformations tasks and an NLI task
that assess sensitivity to syntax - a requirement for robust language
understanding. We further investigate whether out-of-distribution
generalization can be improved via chain-of-thought prompting, where the model
is provided with a sequence of intermediate computation steps that illustrate
how the task ought to be performed. In experiments with models from the GPT,
PaLM, and Llama 2 families, we find large variance across LMs. The variance is
explained more by the composition of the pre-training corpus and supervision
methods than by model size; in particular, models pre-trained on code
generalize better, and benefit more from chain-of-thought prompting. | [
0.0325000249,
0.0176551118,
-0.0295592472,
0.0092928084,
-0.02939431,
0.0510690995,
-0.0102666151,
-0.0165809076,
-0.0271587241,
-0.0302455723,
-0.0315641426,
-0.0226475839,
0.0111662699,
-0.0108493175,
0.0424483269,
-0.0622309521,
0.0361949354,
-0.0494260639,
-0.0029985541,
0.005877702,
-0.0102643268,
-0.0187805369,
-0.010551339,
0.0288617201,
-0.0145036131,
-0.0366598591,
-0.0197082683,
-0.0119427377,
-0.0206837505,
-0.0273800194,
0.0049068681,
0.0360808447,
0.0413993262,
-0.0004868835,
0.0000019813,
-0.0802543163,
0.0007021592,
-0.0152336601,
-0.0172190033,
0.0128821991,
0.0199009925,
-0.0199753381,
0.013027411,
0.0331798978,
-0.0543825738,
-0.0241316445,
0.0462715626,
0.0178728886,
0.024945356,
0.0777226761,
0.004875402,
-0.0067685209,
0.0000747755,
-0.0030478211,
0.011924251,
-0.0216026381,
0.0084265564,
0.0122631704,
0.033715792,
0.0206531622,
-0.0364814959,
0.0115489271,
0.0333906822,
0.0066047427,
0.0077147502,
0.0483222082,
-0.0481332317,
-0.0128150526,
-0.0107862353,
0.0434975773,
-0.0419313945,
-0.0336552858,
-0.0211762451,
-0.0015409065,
0.0299534518,
0.0005737941,
-0.0722841248,
0.0622547083,
0.0057759299,
0.0312281772,
0.0196582973,
-0.0353425704,
0.0292459093,
-0.0205174051,
-0.0392381698,
0.0696098134,
-0.0158120934,
-0.0288873222,
0.0265819579,
0.0354172066,
-0.0838200897,
-0.045592621,
-0.0313330442,
0.0380721204,
-0.0459935069,
0.0351770632,
-0.0262409654,
-0.0390412174,
-0.0211210642,
-0.0390574411,
0.0679701939,
0.0481584929,
-0.0207097046,
-0.0003842879,
-0.0405610129,
0.0490883775,
-0.0121996514,
0.0276187416,
-0.041601304,
0.0096052699,
-0.0667149797,
-0.0041114572,
-0.0455634333,
0.0550751425,
-0.0112584727,
0.016663095,
-0.0200529173,
0.0611138009,
-0.0081967609,
0.0322717316,
0.0065527563,
-0.025429843,
-0.0568025596,
0.0082370006,
-0.0189803075,
0.0032550164,
-0.0132158082,
0.0283437409,
0.0055845082,
-0.0592733473,
-0.0320661478,
0.0091591775,
-0.0084629729,
-0.0347174965,
-0.0030411612,
0.0534522571,
-0.0301279519,
-0.0284698438,
-0.0753509477,
0.0173998307,
-0.0276394654,
-0.0439310893,
0.0314818285,
-0.0804080591,
-0.0408991389,
0.0504958183,
0.005176438,
-0.0183065906,
0.0068687089,
0.0056946129,
-0.0149242114,
0.0605697967,
0.0160817485,
0.0103678964,
0.028551776,
-0.0198205318,
-0.051214736,
0.0539124198,
0.0091766259,
-0.0289983489,
-0.0284899306,
-0.0127719892,
0.0199656915,
0.0624032915,
-0.0108122751,
0.0351908319,
-0.0362159349,
0.0074518397,
0.0610640459,
0.0187599733,
0.0445144475,
0.0267370958,
-0.0035670456,
0.0508127026,
0.0548887141,
0.0378160439,
-0.0124556599,
0.0075609689,
0.0812238529,
0.0030535161,
-0.016268231,
0.0458443053,
-0.0915744379,
0.0042649964,
-0.0292080771,
0.0136007732,
-0.0407659821,
-0.0205432288,
-0.0228767507,
-0.0444389693,
-0.0195102971,
-0.0086633423,
0.00377055,
0.026509542,
0.0422251895,
0.0658202395,
-0.0162246451,
0.0063937157,
0.0422598161,
-0.0495431609,
-0.005271412,
-0.0454699732,
0.0010845114,
0.0054586153,
0.0132384393,
-0.0366499759,
-0.0073964065,
-0.0158465672,
0.0419943705,
0.0287208892,
-0.0016591729,
-0.0081472732,
0.0052063065,
-0.0417704284,
-0.0037714639,
-0.0363220237,
0.0223298166,
-0.0044019311,
0.0220169388,
-0.0234115422,
-0.0028632958,
-0.0585004687,
-0.0354088694,
0.0533450097,
-0.018148182,
-0.0489803515,
-0.0173342172,
0.0205468237,
0.0268415399,
-0.0307862964,
-0.0069740927,
0.0021225372,
0.0011087693,
-0.0270608962,
0.0046668975,
-0.008433003,
-0.0864667222,
-0.0614539981,
0.0049923537,
-0.0097329263,
-0.0299774557,
-0.0020208631,
-0.013592694,
-0.0244716313,
0.0245058332,
-0.0257345587,
0.0560809374,
0.0071110008,
0.0431347862,
-0.0018336577,
-0.0171300396,
-0.0574768707,
0.0833046511,
0.0177083779,
-0.0012245129,
0.0106880926,
0.0395309366,
-0.0159863885,
0.0058565415,
-0.0160764083,
0.0178486984,
-0.0112007875,
0.0020579717,
-0.0057147807,
0.0356932282,
-0.0725686476,
-0.0346332155,
-0.1006812975,
-0.0044989996,
-0.0320814103,
0.0035407194,
0.0334656313,
0.0231717285,
-0.0183301978,
-0.0221481565,
-0.0295817051,
-0.00008948,
-0.0308585167,
0.0409748033,
0.0564610362,
0.0350146443,
-0.0534251854,
-0.0319532789,
0.0004299988,
-0.0410540588,
0.0732381865,
-0.008983992,
-0.022181198,
-0.0545753352,
0.084242776,
0.0142825395,
0.027442459,
-0.0032942095,
-0.0171435326,
0.0482337363,
-0.0301932842,
0.0843855739,
0.0987168998,
-0.0266247317,
0.0116383685,
0.0686909258,
0.0063230693,
-0.0686439574,
0.0299052969,
0.0021727709,
-0.0859468803,
-0.0460775681,
0.0000536523,
0.0096991165,
0.0923871845,
0.0017914749,
-0.0189665519,
-0.0548052788,
-0.0259721,
-0.0270405114,
-0.0215743259,
-0.021240579,
-0.0211315602,
-0.0281233341,
0.0447406657,
-0.0110052042,
-0.0538470894,
0.0413306616,
-0.0156114614,
-0.0245106239,
-0.0594197698,
-0.0392815769,
-0.0364762656,
0.0812223777,
0.0267761424,
-0.0027275856,
0.0353124291,
-0.0437774248,
-0.1047876477,
0.023125248,
0.0152657647,
0.0322416499,
0.0717889518,
-0.0824353397,
0.0059222942,
0.0027214456,
-0.0422136001,
-0.0418629907,
0.0113240583,
-0.0199128799,
0.0013980635,
0.0165309086,
0.0058686975,
0.0168059003,
-0.0477289334,
0.0317653641,
0.0555745587,
-0.0008457321,
-0.0432266034,
-0.0188968871,
-0.0144778714,
-0.0178078897,
-0.016394753,
-0.0106415488,
-0.0447538979,
0.0181194842,
0.0123197325,
0.0504713245,
-0.0165280793,
-0.0631508008,
0.0450117923,
0.026741432,
-0.0281670876,
-0.0531543642,
0.0622896962,
0.0787044615,
-0.0327666327,
-0.0479863659,
0.110220246,
0.0431602858,
-0.0801435485,
0.0223647449,
-0.0398585424,
0.0375842936,
0.0566214323,
0.0229867585,
-0.055019442,
-0.016976973,
0.0063259108,
-0.0088859443,
0.0043509607,
-0.0374731086,
-0.0029111099,
-0.1141629666,
0.0183878709,
0.0075401627,
-0.0422749184,
0.0107918698,
-0.0260605495,
0.0228452329,
0.0154597349,
0.0247688331,
0.0029089458,
-0.0294231474,
0.0238807537,
0.0342555419,
0.0267643351,
-0.0276453998,
0.0167011768,
-0.0424860381,
0.0082325637,
0.0657289326,
-0.0224468857,
-0.0067694206,
0.0082406579,
0.0894543827,
0.0020220939,
0.0361691378,
-0.0226726569,
0.0336996466,
0.0250576977,
-0.008099054,
0.0111018242,
0.0424752645,
-0.0330056623,
-0.0160970353,
0.0317652598,
0.0762710422,
-0.0231495034,
-0.0161918234,
0.0204157662,
-0.0339770056,
0.0037030515,
0.044814337,
0.0714999437,
-0.0596409105,
-0.0164290275,
-0.0612423532,
-0.0155422371,
0.0098370751,
0.0080860816,
0.0345054269,
0.017502144,
0.0195321683,
-0.068860054,
-0.0422810614,
0.0614326224,
0.0557084903,
0.0232571196,
-0.0287291836,
0.0172388796,
0.0202439036,
-0.0015949394,
0.0285521299,
-0.028998198,
-0.0081716226,
-0.0491245575,
-0.0177123211,
0.0105070323,
-0.0073622079,
-0.0223147124,
0.0025236483,
-0.0732760057,
-0.0633684769,
0.0183605552,
0.0449806564,
0.0261131916,
0.0617481768,
0.0075869723,
-0.0226251781,
0.005843766,
0.0000286579,
-0.002648955,
0.0444207303,
0.0256122295,
0.0048098806,
0.0309384018,
0.0340022445,
-0.0465167835,
0.0144873643,
0.0359371491,
0.0220262744,
-0.0230721347,
-0.0105157327,
0.0615007058,
0.0060739527,
0.0497381166,
0.0205397103,
-0.0001874753,
-0.0064592483,
0.0147169428,
-0.0000522772,
-0.0147813056,
-0.0296687651,
-0.0097794579,
0.0421974026,
0.0634348169,
0.0231202841,
0.0155848423,
0.0097635426,
0.0635140091,
0.0017303312,
-0.0161807872,
0.026472304,
-0.0006299955,
0.0371630155,
0.044004932,
-0.0248828959,
0.013354498,
0.0161315165,
0.0159827881,
0.0181936491,
0.0543635301,
0.0317462161,
0.0338490531,
-0.0143561354,
-0.0236313362,
-0.0838968009,
-0.0344460458,
0.0024896937,
0.0055533308,
0.0488169305,
-0.0397453494,
0.0292509608,
-0.0322509632,
0.0247832052,
0.0010790667,
0.0363114402,
-0.0226171724,
-0.0245853141,
0.0175971836,
0.0269032829,
0.0131594697,
-0.0248705726,
0.0885879397,
0.0100049926,
0.0459599905,
0.013415521,
0.0326152183,
-0.0344644599,
-0.0339723714,
0.0273713227,
0.0042738803,
0.0072035152,
0.0297779087,
0.0016904117,
-0.0619105697,
-0.0203063246,
-0.0237366371,
0.0048907022,
-0.0580732077,
0.0457632542,
0.0768214986,
-0.0044616642,
-0.0352453142,
0.0080928626,
-0.0162092093,
0.0668010935,
-0.0402277224,
-0.0554058924,
-6.183668931e-33,
-0.0275367815,
-0.0065420233,
0.0110211391,
0.0387836546,
0.0152484719,
-0.0181550402,
-0.0414743945,
0.0419204347,
-0.0325671807,
-0.0027634024,
-0.0070651378,
0.0411380827,
0.0022655921,
0.0156483706,
0.0566551909,
-0.0090433648,
0.0225644149,
-0.022038063,
-0.018949585,
-0.012136599,
0.001935875,
0.0276861265,
0.0590906627,
-0.0245847031,
0.015761327,
0.021229092,
-0.0042789695,
0.0235480219,
-0.0271794293,
0.0139707923,
0.0178262554,
0.041201327,
0.0161472149,
-0.0177742522,
-0.0387249216,
0.0340898857,
-0.0566839017,
-0.068505697,
0.0402752794,
0.0123466458,
-0.0329850279,
-0.0391178653,
0.0521766208,
-0.0128186522,
-0.0230704807,
-0.0233062636,
0.0378256217,
-0.0240567829,
-0.0144969439,
-0.0144302882,
-0.0403262116,
-0.0112889335,
-0.0231306143,
-0.0060374564,
-0.0021564921,
0.041483961,
-0.0120559903,
0.0308472347,
-0.0027450768,
0.0020313505,
0.0106803486,
0.0489599444,
0.0353932306,
0.0173341949,
0.0030722024,
0.0158534609,
-0.0078724567,
0.0288390536,
-0.0171030797,
-0.0242850687,
0.0453679375,
0.0213583745,
-0.0089640087,
0.0236477219,
0.0163887944,
0.0402889512,
-0.0866817757,
-0.0070566018,
-0.0029585147,
0.0380140953,
-0.0054594455,
0.0170002282,
-0.0364009812,
-0.0498906337,
-0.0576403886,
-0.0054578278,
-0.0278757308,
-0.0304640066,
0.0507957526,
-0.0188664179,
0.0288297553,
-0.007376594,
0.0096158013,
-0.0088091837,
-0.0261901151,
-0.0005389767,
-0.0394034497,
0.0592027009,
0.0099974526,
0.0117452722,
-0.0463676974,
-0.0390809029,
-0.0035869973,
0.025225807,
0.0465023853,
0.0210334212,
0.0932522938,
0.0180857293,
-0.0790238157,
-0.0321596377,
-0.0529554635,
0.0291538686,
0.0084776776,
0.0429967493,
0.0281216539,
0.00540902,
-0.0157490708,
0.0530090854,
-0.0065860115,
-0.0345711894,
-0.0636724904,
0.0066776113,
-0.0473462269,
0.0015147376,
-0.0573610179,
-0.0557637624,
-0.0125466054,
0.0357852466,
0.0620533191,
-0.0546869449,
-0.0433617756,
0.0189883579,
2.787e-7,
0.0474412516,
0.0464088209,
-0.0118297329,
0.0216680411,
0.0121493842,
0.0346521363,
-0.0541552752,
0.012796903,
0.0213333592,
-0.0493137091,
0.0083852438,
0.0360741653,
0.0246415678,
0.0076608551,
-0.083289966,
-0.01586443,
-0.043777395,
0.0286036171,
-0.035683088,
0.0212842505,
0.0259549152,
0.0825584456,
-0.013686195,
0.0006174612,
-0.0144315688,
-0.066754058,
0.0607311539,
-0.0460596792,
0.0103803966,
0.0042832391,
-0.05016822,
0.0254491623,
0.0002269349,
0.0429678932,
0.0099434145,
0.0055774031,
-0.0245297905,
0.0607387647,
-0.0019392024,
0.0531624705,
0.0207962319,
0.0104357833,
0.0146936355,
-0.085406594,
0.0361357965,
-0.107169278,
-0.0147775589,
0.0097399801,
0.0111848107,
-0.0243299268,
0.0004838894,
0.0022128436,
0.0448462255,
0.0167662278,
0.0068789986,
-0.0131447567,
-0.0218758583,
-0.0405561663,
-0.0609279387,
0.0603029504,
-0.0293122306,
-0.0275215469,
-0.0436846055,
-0.0019765112,
0.0305585004,
-0.0075078341,
0.0258470885,
2.617366742e-34,
0.0069320812,
-0.0243719872,
0.0610650741,
0.0426326767,
0.0288808029,
-0.0291787852,
-0.0459233895,
0.0288394168,
0.0313410275,
-0.0662285686,
-0.0013424271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07804v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07804v1 | IruMozhi: Automatically classifying diglossia in Tamil | 2023-11-13T23:36:35 | 2023-11-13T23:36:35 | Kabilan Prasanna, Aryaman Arora | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Tamil, a Dravidian language of South Asia, is a highly diglossic language
with two very different registers in everyday use: Literary Tamil (preferred in
writing and formal communication) and Spoken Tamil (confined to speech and
informal media). Spoken Tamil is under-supported in modern NLP systems. In this
paper, we release IruMozhi, a human-annotated dataset of parallel text in
Literary and Spoken Tamil. We train classifiers on the task of identifying
which variety a text belongs to. We use these models to gauge the availability
of pretraining data in Spoken Tamil, to audit the composition of existing
labelled datasets for Tamil, and to encourage future work on the variety. | [
0.0267307051,
0.0678284168,
-0.0241497736,
0.0552974157,
-0.0399680585,
0.0103591662,
0.001229178,
0.0304836594,
0.0392570533,
-0.0385843068,
-0.0253803451,
-0.0128271924,
0.0213359408,
0.0011498022,
0.0035484096,
-0.0577588975,
0.0179428477,
-0.0067534135,
0.0317285545,
0.0083221924,
0.0252638459,
0.0298155118,
-0.0354056805,
-0.0035124102,
-0.0153771071,
-0.0373094156,
0.0065398077,
-0.0018530246,
0.0058005163,
-0.0206685569,
0.0382915661,
0.0574899167,
0.0233246982,
0.0564071238,
0.0000013461,
-0.0353429802,
0.0136756767,
-0.0219765082,
0.0116858548,
0.0020534338,
0.0225621685,
0.0079136724,
0.0319843963,
0.0028932772,
-0.0183961093,
-0.024647044,
0.0727743208,
-0.0248470027,
0.0259413924,
0.1074431539,
-0.0287263077,
0.0020213455,
0.0229265951,
0.0174528491,
-0.0382491127,
-0.0102987252,
0.0169839114,
0.0110641122,
0.0303091444,
0.0206915811,
0.0115669193,
0.0565116107,
-0.0404909253,
0.0140759936,
-0.0465015396,
0.0044008144,
0.0035336534,
0.0016773511,
0.0308436006,
0.0234543402,
-0.0150485188,
-0.0713878274,
0.0197430532,
-0.0051771253,
-0.0609271154,
-0.0288919061,
0.0045994399,
-0.0046409322,
-0.0786957368,
0.0517048016,
0.1045546979,
0.0364942588,
0.0019169318,
0.0267734081,
0.069457382,
0.0070347008,
0.0169605762,
-0.0160904098,
-0.0142145399,
0.010531758,
0.016914079,
-0.0281327106,
0.0337171182,
0.0004015072,
-0.0245740488,
0.01549346,
0.0057335035,
-0.0975390896,
0.0334860459,
-0.0479033887,
0.029081421,
0.0013082051,
-0.0454651117,
0.0007088134,
0.0112733692,
0.0054297727,
0.0288555287,
0.0282884911,
0.0168496184,
0.0037976285,
-0.0137996646,
-0.0254043527,
-0.0191618782,
-0.0110169919,
-0.0106544243,
0.0333297662,
-0.0735085979,
0.0295504406,
0.0017894865,
-0.0261351466,
0.0317403898,
-0.0351763964,
-0.0272896886,
-0.0175069366,
0.0078615462,
-0.0035195628,
-0.0395520441,
0.0428746007,
-0.0237123817,
-0.0710020289,
0.0187494326,
0.0255366154,
-0.0188174341,
-0.0493224189,
0.0009557531,
-0.0169393308,
-0.036135193,
-0.0589409471,
-0.086969696,
0.0188032426,
-0.0336907245,
-0.0375208035,
-0.0539553426,
-0.0807180777,
0.0209662486,
0.0109975403,
0.0155102005,
-0.0621432401,
-0.0077965497,
0.0268575307,
0.0060818843,
0.108127147,
-0.0241364893,
-0.0174179077,
0.0705329329,
0.0153573416,
0.0434264429,
0.0255855396,
-0.0082282536,
0.0021777211,
0.0852341726,
-0.0213682353,
0.0679069161,
0.035314478,
-0.0246859696,
0.0067761228,
-0.0405469872,
0.0313840881,
-0.0123851681,
0.0032213079,
-0.0148122199,
0.0573434047,
0.0357820429,
-0.0150972726,
0.0314952098,
0.0664419308,
0.0421633162,
0.0207210332,
0.0031172254,
0.0143977692,
0.0349047035,
0.0210305564,
0.0298504941,
-0.0179886706,
0.0185069796,
-0.00316251,
0.0148853837,
-0.0133089731,
-0.0171301104,
-0.0197520889,
-0.048805777,
-0.0262337495,
0.0108769899,
-0.0148142446,
0.0471048169,
0.013417582,
-0.0187394563,
-0.0497789271,
0.0735743344,
-0.0470205061,
0.0129949953,
-0.0715206563,
0.0573307872,
0.0313864984,
0.005786384,
-0.0962897912,
0.0100908615,
0.0223060846,
-0.0019772626,
0.0623347796,
-0.0147927422,
-0.0437149331,
0.0168747045,
-0.0425751358,
0.0590511113,
0.0588312782,
0.0322429463,
0.015944032,
-0.0023144621,
0.0278775617,
-0.0367236361,
0.0004877721,
-0.0536586381,
0.0547928475,
-0.0151706692,
-0.017233815,
0.0260204617,
0.0086171571,
0.0509042665,
0.0100581395,
-0.0098610427,
-0.0384647399,
0.0189210847,
-0.0313387513,
-0.0092005832,
0.0121792117,
-0.00241537,
-0.0072629713,
0.0121651897,
-0.0692211762,
0.0200854968,
0.0503815487,
0.0029714969,
-0.0270245355,
0.018713994,
0.0116452184,
0.007824257,
-0.0565923974,
0.0183693357,
-0.0231242888,
0.0008633276,
-0.0546899363,
0.0227225944,
0.0339497738,
0.0265739691,
0.018773539,
-0.0388608463,
0.0657446012,
-0.0475071743,
-0.0190936681,
0.0298000462,
0.021602761,
0.0502501987,
-0.0054497318,
-0.0168092474,
-0.0204475988,
-0.0398820117,
-0.0983400717,
-0.0108870119,
-0.0328696445,
0.0492928624,
0.0097425124,
0.0076501938,
-0.0255357046,
0.005828415,
-0.0108538168,
-0.0013672838,
0.0648929477,
0.0001803073,
0.0640695691,
-0.0354418196,
0.041857142,
-0.0357880704,
-0.0256978106,
-0.0060019074,
0.043768838,
-0.0038748842,
-0.0560957566,
-0.0367329121,
-0.0227576662,
0.0171117578,
-0.0044604866,
-0.0110828467,
-0.0457384661,
-0.0436797738,
0.0030233788,
0.0008894516,
0.0159105547,
-0.0016288094,
-0.0026540169,
0.0066177822,
-0.0211138912,
0.0136940703,
-0.0213213079,
0.0073120538,
0.0294860303,
-0.0084333764,
-0.0141599793,
0.0061164252,
0.087546654,
-0.0064005284,
-0.0337320343,
0.004537398,
-0.0290498622,
-0.0590810105,
0.0481543355,
0.0043502417,
0.0331145599,
-0.0351550691,
0.0609196126,
0.0159955099,
-0.0585183315,
0.0708655417,
-0.0404636525,
0.024832353,
-0.0984012708,
-0.0353942178,
-0.0418357179,
0.0180371869,
-0.0364514925,
0.0029108746,
-0.0012175101,
-0.0375127532,
-0.0317478403,
0.0353395529,
0.0173849817,
-0.0060346336,
0.0920791477,
-0.070519641,
0.0168797448,
-0.0299396813,
-0.0193949081,
-0.0305630397,
-0.0564786345,
-0.0203036889,
0.0079193646,
0.0610936955,
-0.0293739736,
0.007789609,
0.0498926491,
-0.0600032546,
0.0335853435,
0.0004322717,
0.008279724,
0.0213521831,
0.0689262673,
-0.0097981356,
-0.0002514518,
-0.0590337366,
0.0452691317,
0.005300811,
-0.0201067924,
-0.0445230566,
0.0209243484,
-0.0110016791,
-0.0098757977,
0.0344656929,
-0.0431317799,
-0.008378244,
-0.01060584,
0.0042932909,
0.0189327039,
-0.0262537617,
0.0645810887,
0.0461587533,
-0.0506076179,
-0.0145146083,
-0.0329707004,
0.0137340091,
0.0053218827,
0.0313748643,
-0.0758655146,
-0.0068470975,
0.004070038,
-0.0033540106,
0.0073061078,
0.0012090392,
-0.0303705651,
-0.0246093255,
-0.0312636606,
-0.0024938395,
-0.0002380153,
0.014201507,
-0.0079723988,
-0.0275719911,
-0.0414381176,
-0.0053060669,
0.0214420799,
-0.0207124036,
0.0016249629,
0.0475440063,
-0.0296512507,
-0.0266390722,
0.0070571522,
-0.001274547,
0.03158205,
-0.0105956588,
0.0028929741,
-0.0711814463,
-0.0470494777,
0.0222672895,
-0.0722126365,
-0.0504015386,
-0.0043305787,
0.0639828965,
-0.0044680228,
-0.0079840794,
-0.0138774775,
0.0162186027,
-0.037847802,
-0.0186343193,
0.0500119887,
0.0445608161,
0.0432743654,
-0.0030445636,
0.0196638852,
-0.0076801912,
0.0051889978,
0.0058208155,
-0.0009944534,
-0.0446047895,
-0.0124988994,
-0.0414000414,
0.0140448278,
-0.021880459,
-0.0546707511,
0.036850445,
-0.041040305,
-0.0696325079,
-0.0591663346,
-0.0508461334,
0.0122668957,
0.0306171142,
0.0463171899,
0.0138457073,
-0.0219814107,
0.0128527489,
-0.0546364225,
-0.0176707879,
-0.0010028218,
0.0464078933,
-0.1044087932,
-0.0329806283,
0.0490783304,
-0.0373354778,
-0.0217838194,
0.0105887828,
-0.0793635994,
-0.0558426864,
0.0245900135,
0.0045080683,
0.0314819403,
-0.0063444623,
-0.0189435203,
-0.0768443793,
0.0200199801,
0.0252494682,
0.0398729965,
-0.0147354053,
0.0304899476,
0.010116145,
-0.0270740855,
0.0310288705,
-0.0147875957,
0.0233390108,
0.0039737853,
-0.0474499986,
-0.061796587,
-0.0265716389,
0.0261567738,
0.0111362003,
0.0424278341,
-0.0914892331,
-0.0432189256,
-0.0762010589,
-0.0255776476,
0.0337237269,
-0.0138321975,
-0.0023435547,
-0.0090439133,
0.0448217914,
0.0104635032,
-0.0747266337,
0.0015512863,
-0.0122591108,
0.0383560993,
-0.0393851288,
0.0521848649,
0.0984987989,
0.0732949078,
-0.0199128892,
0.011927803,
-0.0048391889,
0.0223388411,
-0.0360414498,
0.0452477373,
0.0021695541,
0.0548663251,
-0.0026477128,
0.0184499696,
0.0164004192,
0.0287855938,
0.0448811688,
0.0422287546,
0.0024329338,
0.0065207565,
0.0729916394,
-0.0301482175,
0.0268216766,
-0.0175886918,
-0.0030465552,
-0.0389314294,
0.0463965163,
-0.0027656767,
0.0169082861,
-0.0090619531,
0.0104809031,
-0.0348721109,
0.0150652723,
0.099251695,
-0.0158382654,
-0.0210537873,
0.0924580172,
-0.0599016808,
-0.0318784676,
-0.0281604305,
-0.0211168416,
0.0638348982,
0.0361117199,
-0.00691297,
-0.0565502197,
-0.0762766525,
0.0434253141,
-0.0001077264,
0.0596212372,
-0.0034545788,
-0.0009915612,
0.0327521339,
0.0543876514,
0.0495218374,
-0.0501556545,
-0.0177626479,
-0.0256311707,
-0.008861077,
-0.0305366069,
-4.919633039e-33,
-0.0101334499,
-0.0101137683,
-0.0433720574,
0.0431465432,
0.0169681925,
0.0286882538,
0.0051189908,
0.0133065302,
-0.0029565748,
0.0264371559,
-0.0306605026,
0.0288412496,
0.0136261489,
0.0130122881,
0.025610555,
-0.0210082345,
-0.0102753276,
0.02114949,
-0.0074835718,
0.0011402484,
0.0610899627,
0.003889075,
0.0827363804,
-0.0426705293,
0.0531790294,
-0.0461549759,
-0.0097941076,
0.0197524577,
0.0046164789,
0.0286803711,
-0.0530880392,
0.0665845871,
0.0468653925,
0.0236825142,
0.0103583308,
0.0191507619,
-0.0704901516,
0.0114615094,
0.0185000747,
0.0628634617,
-0.02318337,
-0.0144975986,
0.0069649592,
-0.0095863976,
-0.0167789124,
0.0229405109,
0.0445123985,
-0.003646519,
0.0010984273,
-0.0243756808,
-0.0596140698,
0.0556629039,
-0.011985153,
-0.0268263128,
0.0717385188,
-0.0053272243,
0.0066465903,
0.0049797762,
-0.0423742719,
0.008459161,
-0.0147509202,
0.0493663475,
0.0203123465,
0.0380380601,
-0.0737491325,
0.0150578823,
0.0305085536,
-0.0494042151,
0.032181602,
0.0010844913,
-0.0052541899,
0.0095517952,
-0.0039265961,
0.0335829258,
0.059086699,
-0.0763450861,
-0.0012970405,
-0.0082641123,
0.0648633167,
-0.0366057754,
-0.004079245,
-0.0120140733,
-0.0668335631,
-0.0487867743,
0.0324689448,
-0.0505887792,
-0.0123300562,
0.0142409848,
0.0252609551,
-0.0350795574,
0.0174098127,
0.0194848124,
0.0132465828,
-0.037874613,
-0.004175052,
-0.0053625852,
-0.0260776542,
0.0289412588,
-0.0094235158,
0.0063295304,
-0.0132175209,
-0.0287290346,
-0.0223309286,
0.0458320156,
0.0328134671,
-0.0063283639,
0.046834901,
0.0020253784,
-0.0879264623,
0.005467556,
-0.0309090111,
0.0343171991,
-0.0194464792,
0.0978560001,
0.0078659477,
0.0085996427,
0.0044778967,
0.0140194204,
0.0526348725,
-0.0002309886,
-0.0045347475,
0.0293324869,
-0.0283268429,
-0.0107177012,
-0.0037652003,
-0.0110085392,
-0.0127810054,
-0.0205281917,
-0.0139160166,
-0.0415556468,
0.0350531228,
0.0009860568,
2.143e-7,
0.0100065824,
0.0542701557,
0.0377020426,
-0.0445232652,
0.014011479,
0.01400718,
-0.0757291988,
0.0069618798,
-0.0396712869,
0.0043865112,
0.0303416848,
-0.0173412692,
0.0544530936,
0.0635157228,
-0.1050512567,
-0.0092722578,
-0.0709970221,
0.0027960909,
-0.0358943641,
-0.0185151901,
-0.0010465073,
0.0522152595,
0.0451883599,
-0.0217820816,
0.0026953693,
-0.0323537514,
0.0211750679,
-0.0155106066,
0.0314267129,
0.0314971358,
0.0248466153,
-0.0310214013,
0.0016740388,
0.0069411644,
-0.0329808891,
0.0037765834,
0.0347498208,
0.0714211836,
-0.0367610753,
0.0276908018,
0.0013099039,
0.0023426213,
-0.028007729,
-0.0175449196,
0.0238771327,
0.0633284375,
-0.0198659133,
-0.0310218409,
-0.0025654875,
0.0059861066,
0.0316766836,
0.0037195995,
-0.0060616443,
0.0276440829,
0.018023679,
-0.0688061193,
-0.0097595034,
-0.0602828041,
-0.0465218611,
0.0068859248,
-0.0392365903,
-0.0184410103,
0.0101409489,
0.0294401404,
0.0392876528,
-0.0610864237,
0.0497217998,
1.730357761e-34,
0.050934054,
0.0134874694,
-0.0204025023,
0.0187212471,
-0.0054210867,
-0.0162241608,
0.0316175632,
0.0276324581,
0.0419182852,
-0.0431832597,
0.008085846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07772v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07772v4 | In-context Learning and Gradient Descent Revisited | 2023-11-13T21:42:38 | 2024-03-31T19:33:50 | Gilad Deutch, Nadav Magar, Tomer Bar Natan, Guy Dar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In-context learning (ICL) has shown impressive results in few-shot learning
tasks, yet its underlying mechanism is still not fully understood. A recent
line of work suggests that ICL performs gradient descent (GD)-based
optimization implicitly. While appealing, much of the research focuses on
simplified settings, where the parameters of a shallow model are optimized. In
this work, we revisit evidence for ICL-GD correspondence on realistic NLP tasks
and models. We find gaps in evaluation, both in terms of problematic metrics
and insufficient baselines. We show that surprisingly, even untrained models
achieve comparable ICL-GD similarity scores despite not exhibiting ICL. Next,
we explore a major discrepancy in the flow of information throughout the model
between ICL and GD, which we term Layer Causality. We propose a simple GD-based
optimization procedure that respects layer causality, and show it improves
similarity scores significantly. | [
-0.0256363563,
0.0498486497,
0.0062271906,
0.0380945653,
-0.0261129998,
0.0358843692,
0.042810116,
0.0173067134,
-0.0639543161,
-0.0534812659,
-0.0367438719,
0.0055981334,
0.0143340668,
-0.0508582145,
0.000395186,
-0.0387238599,
0.0266605075,
0.0320650525,
-0.0275771525,
0.0242084824,
0.0193976089,
-0.014870028,
-0.0134407785,
0.0660414994,
-0.0021515319,
-0.0305011086,
0.0208295193,
0.0307830814,
0.0199023224,
-0.0378034115,
0.0068393978,
0.0380083062,
0.0127056343,
0.0304320529,
0.0000020757,
-0.028751649,
0.0057420754,
0.0126084127,
-0.0353976376,
-0.0318952538,
0.0080129113,
-0.0350279622,
0.0253984649,
-0.0246021431,
-0.043502003,
-0.0205502324,
0.0250377581,
0.0443584435,
0.0185263399,
0.0751729012,
-0.0186583623,
-0.0141516365,
-0.0160674397,
-0.0107144769,
0.0256019142,
-0.0628160164,
-0.0086023528,
-0.024744967,
-0.0353212655,
0.0020540697,
-0.014617675,
0.0388856716,
0.027603304,
0.0475190282,
0.0221208036,
0.0531826243,
-0.033080399,
-0.0124096135,
-0.0015979721,
0.0678548887,
-0.0413634218,
-0.0433237925,
-0.0079501467,
-0.0340879485,
-0.0104522882,
-0.0149905831,
-0.0714456514,
0.0015164972,
0.0038371098,
0.0329239666,
-0.0098978337,
0.0394365527,
0.0496034697,
-0.0133064976,
0.0191791728,
0.0085652815,
-0.0020293314,
-0.0262059104,
0.0025790557,
0.0201639235,
-0.0355959721,
-0.0597935617,
-0.0523524657,
0.0178736895,
-0.0507209003,
0.0122195091,
-0.0322686508,
-0.0003207353,
0.0160524491,
-0.0346238799,
0.0881180763,
0.056049034,
0.0285664741,
0.0481010862,
-0.0198260639,
0.0367206186,
0.0028773779,
0.0017136694,
-0.0018596707,
-0.0029162739,
-0.0828843787,
-0.0154012507,
-0.0162966568,
0.0354186036,
-0.005533508,
-0.032635048,
-0.031507533,
0.0246150084,
-0.0435463153,
0.0098477611,
-0.0155672701,
0.0244518574,
-0.0306885187,
0.0120530277,
-0.0074631362,
0.0084437374,
-0.0520740785,
0.0303960573,
0.0230224207,
-0.0159882661,
-0.0157189425,
-0.0040905676,
0.0230547823,
-0.0168916527,
-0.0051051727,
0.0590372086,
0.0127592068,
-0.0584829375,
-0.0032580507,
-0.0144204739,
0.0035411888,
-0.0454212055,
-0.0136249987,
-0.0625644326,
0.045453988,
-0.0043592062,
0.012904509,
-0.044725664,
-0.021184776,
0.069322288,
-0.0139673781,
0.1112856194,
0.0185937565,
-0.0032391262,
-0.0080558304,
0.0003696915,
-0.013850864,
0.0898779184,
-0.0278535336,
-0.0381420329,
0.0178717654,
0.0133492639,
0.002456357,
0.0060632792,
0.0581226647,
0.0135211134,
-0.0298343748,
-0.0044506164,
-0.0106350137,
0.0311934184,
0.031631995,
-0.0118231112,
-0.0666931495,
-0.0075343661,
0.0524034426,
0.0880407542,
0.0339781418,
-0.0131589593,
0.0372201353,
-0.0014480415,
-0.0357123837,
0.0014452802,
-0.0735054314,
0.019325275,
-0.0278129186,
-0.0096327187,
0.0174242724,
-0.0055552721,
-0.033382453,
-0.0016031545,
-0.0219656322,
0.0052772118,
-0.001378385,
0.0048859469,
0.0003865459,
0.0572154187,
-0.0135772089,
-0.0011232571,
0.0425704196,
0.0008518542,
-0.0470363051,
0.0094772922,
-0.0381197557,
0.0178815201,
0.0271492451,
0.0121843796,
-0.0179362465,
-0.0003703,
0.0408891812,
0.0404086597,
0.0083709816,
-0.0400369018,
0.0514069498,
-0.0189939123,
-0.0306724161,
-0.0450577922,
0.0476882644,
-0.0084470641,
0.0268757269,
-0.0164164733,
0.0057585109,
-0.0375086889,
-0.0099808825,
0.0439567007,
-0.057207305,
-0.0357589796,
0.0130323758,
0.0335046947,
0.0067321523,
-0.0008931596,
-0.0016578818,
0.024725927,
-0.0026616626,
-0.0335666314,
-0.031490963,
0.0039817775,
-0.0823130235,
-0.0982899964,
0.014017093,
-0.0448643491,
-0.004281444,
-0.0187104531,
-0.0388791002,
-0.0015153914,
0.010324318,
-0.0070808469,
0.0667317659,
-0.0200922824,
0.0175241344,
-0.0116154579,
0.0060345582,
-0.0705804527,
0.0745245889,
0.0113874376,
0.0201029405,
0.0392297879,
0.0341113657,
0.016168233,
-0.0038493844,
0.0238631126,
-0.0208962597,
0.0047096796,
-0.0115743307,
0.0152408313,
0.0285019558,
-0.046638038,
0.0411631353,
-0.1053073779,
0.0273473691,
-0.0273407027,
-0.0195524599,
0.0742774233,
0.0271331519,
0.0184596926,
-0.0272116289,
0.0142964674,
0.018946331,
-0.0127856322,
0.038969662,
0.0565240197,
0.0009460515,
0.0132903997,
-0.0318355449,
-0.026548868,
-0.0146755483,
0.0759516582,
-0.0233654659,
-0.0037507389,
-0.0093418937,
0.0387376919,
0.0094189346,
0.0011504043,
-0.0061464193,
0.0275567863,
0.0083196461,
0.0014199388,
0.0043279161,
0.0697945952,
-0.0324427076,
0.0547871776,
-0.0079523204,
0.0204738118,
-0.0998151973,
-0.0089375284,
-0.0422042385,
-0.0097427079,
-0.0285369903,
0.0148931909,
0.0261076353,
0.0742635876,
-0.0229184013,
0.0169863682,
-0.0599103719,
0.0583270229,
-0.0322159901,
-0.031110106,
-0.0736524314,
0.0282831825,
-0.0035072588,
0.0365025066,
-0.0340134762,
-0.0365625583,
0.0551566482,
-0.0032687138,
0.009720929,
-0.046619717,
-0.0151598928,
-0.0258238949,
0.0674521476,
-0.0056401235,
0.0057726372,
0.0242731646,
-0.0001450477,
-0.0440574549,
0.0373075865,
0.0312898308,
0.02880737,
0.0438070521,
-0.0009680947,
0.0253384002,
-0.012011054,
-0.0590754636,
-0.0265235119,
-0.025721617,
0.0003429096,
0.0280774869,
-0.042540554,
0.0070889792,
-0.0023086187,
-0.0126218507,
0.0087531032,
0.0199150946,
0.0112265665,
-0.0639631078,
-0.0181047153,
0.0379230566,
0.0295432955,
-0.04625367,
0.0217206385,
0.0160377417,
0.0614547357,
0.0469024144,
0.05107449,
0.042892959,
-0.0304368753,
0.0305340532,
0.0098284911,
-0.0276243575,
-0.0370374583,
0.022612337,
0.0676036701,
-0.0515587255,
-0.0556727834,
0.0972433388,
0.0210546907,
-0.0976282135,
0.0192474648,
0.0273513254,
-0.0143613704,
0.0369553082,
-0.0123319095,
-0.054977309,
-0.0647743419,
0.0128110088,
0.0110622933,
-0.0182092562,
-0.0283441879,
-0.0170082152,
-0.1173648611,
-0.004129075,
-0.0421069413,
-0.0481484607,
-0.0093139755,
-0.0899812654,
0.0159207061,
-0.0118586132,
0.0391379446,
-0.0150956223,
-0.0283587705,
0.0053466959,
0.016811531,
0.0040878775,
-0.0813471675,
0.0395236649,
-0.0500834063,
0.0119957188,
0.0901363045,
0.02878787,
0.0387226976,
0.0180860888,
0.0648747236,
-0.0256865099,
0.0195461866,
-0.0253128204,
0.0460908562,
-0.0167907141,
-0.0062849401,
-0.0062412992,
0.0440006554,
-0.0445232876,
-0.0350679345,
-0.0216379836,
0.0430625156,
-0.0083439071,
-0.0113691846,
-0.0181819163,
-0.0278075077,
0.0090249516,
0.076026544,
0.0419031978,
-0.0413409509,
-0.0602067895,
-0.0089031393,
-0.0124213593,
-0.0373207107,
-0.0305446312,
0.0216367375,
0.0129972463,
-0.0100296168,
-0.062909022,
-0.0777874663,
0.0092620077,
0.0500669926,
-0.022260651,
0.0021832027,
-0.0223365054,
-0.023254713,
-0.0575313009,
0.0105703901,
-0.0169203039,
0.0123546226,
-0.0083970297,
-0.0027944779,
0.0406453386,
0.0065330616,
-0.0249058492,
0.0005837002,
-0.1039864793,
-0.0431693606,
-0.0220132861,
0.0159472618,
0.0069117341,
0.0903964639,
-0.0170413703,
-0.0415249169,
0.0670307279,
0.050793644,
0.0193957463,
0.0266450271,
0.0038328557,
-0.002866545,
0.0145702483,
0.0554361753,
-0.032534603,
0.0210817792,
0.0567700379,
0.0482552052,
-0.0209396258,
0.0509351194,
0.0509149581,
-0.0514276139,
0.0444200896,
-0.0071801776,
-0.064455241,
0.0249799956,
-0.0178615972,
-0.0062225671,
-0.027624473,
-0.0267607234,
-0.0464439355,
0.0475552641,
0.0390929691,
-0.0132981688,
0.0199038833,
0.0112584792,
0.0541819595,
-0.0520550199,
-0.0103536826,
0.0329576991,
0.0015276966,
-0.0057509872,
0.0370311551,
-0.0239166319,
0.0398858823,
-0.0149516165,
0.0277531501,
-0.0458157249,
0.0158392526,
0.0575734973,
0.0210715663,
-0.0351346545,
0.016407527,
-0.077264823,
-0.0053539281,
-0.0393870696,
0.0026260247,
0.0839282498,
-0.0546220243,
0.0292449128,
-0.0103770597,
-0.0044166585,
0.0143063208,
-0.0108123068,
-0.0059608198,
-0.0233189594,
0.0227993764,
0.0375455506,
0.0150567554,
0.0048405691,
0.0916800797,
0.0103622209,
0.0521191135,
-0.0003198091,
0.0129292663,
-0.0252975319,
0.0078139668,
0.0448125787,
0.0757815763,
0.0142086791,
0.0195700899,
-0.0327386856,
-0.0447767824,
-0.0023367857,
-0.0446171574,
0.0054347324,
0.0218706504,
0.0564297214,
0.0518750474,
-0.0081988992,
-0.0069030076,
-0.0022153845,
-0.0301989336,
-0.02383174,
-0.0241596047,
-0.0339860842,
-6.683184235e-33,
-0.0197537243,
-0.0222621914,
0.0110812811,
0.0001622545,
0.0150340823,
0.0198841654,
-0.0345602669,
-0.0054177651,
-0.0365013592,
0.0176918507,
-0.0051608249,
0.009258219,
0.0051960819,
0.0380277298,
0.0142746568,
-0.0381883383,
0.0168292727,
0.0031043473,
-0.00829357,
-0.0100197997,
0.011666039,
0.0344329365,
0.0428569838,
-0.0374458693,
-0.0086437557,
-0.0008110834,
0.0173815284,
0.0133786201,
0.0330700986,
0.0387970023,
-0.0529295839,
0.0392243341,
0.0505026132,
-0.0507468134,
-0.0212221071,
-0.0001606607,
-0.0747281685,
-0.0434365124,
-0.003202887,
0.00976648,
-0.0179739948,
0.0045665745,
0.0394866653,
-0.0149118714,
-0.0364912227,
-0.0537061766,
0.0243011098,
0.0087987818,
-0.0244767386,
-0.0497176796,
-0.0962757543,
-0.0023113277,
-0.0088994158,
-0.0236003902,
0.0334905311,
0.0031153657,
-0.0231520552,
0.0648506433,
-0.0563782193,
-0.0219479389,
-0.0733336434,
0.0199602917,
0.0487267114,
0.007462021,
0.0263559557,
0.0670813173,
0.0535713881,
0.0107188057,
-0.0129352724,
-0.0271492321,
0.0403329358,
0.0208287518,
0.0056845769,
0.070968166,
0.0882962197,
0.033835277,
-0.0592280924,
0.0050657708,
-0.0115666492,
0.0240584817,
0.0195150021,
0.0276614092,
-0.034492109,
-0.02410312,
-0.0727214515,
-0.0283513963,
-0.0398662612,
-0.0257586166,
0.068771176,
0.0402115881,
0.0165812299,
0.0321814716,
0.0249013677,
-0.0540071689,
-0.0169046801,
0.0231606066,
0.0090108654,
-0.0075672003,
0.0222294014,
-0.0129052429,
-0.0584582128,
-0.0098987808,
-0.0230152812,
0.0517247319,
0.0467062443,
-0.0025885291,
0.0877065733,
-0.0314399824,
-0.0483908616,
-0.0308951363,
-0.0503006428,
-0.0092668189,
-0.009506599,
0.0281356405,
0.046366591,
0.0263827555,
-0.0388519242,
0.0580278002,
0.050743293,
-0.0141317118,
-0.0022795612,
-0.0057896287,
-0.0389657095,
-0.0012892492,
-0.0008277674,
-0.0285219867,
-0.0419523269,
-0.0004722934,
0.0076300129,
-0.0637122989,
-0.0386035666,
-0.0025595643,
2.738e-7,
0.0309881289,
0.0336246789,
0.0132313538,
0.0054515069,
0.0352638252,
0.0319374129,
-0.0070245676,
0.0067148115,
-0.0132785579,
0.0016201342,
0.0013114923,
0.0160168558,
0.0392529592,
0.023620503,
-0.0454120338,
0.0286573302,
-0.052011393,
-0.0092227589,
-0.0351215638,
-0.0069384049,
-0.0077413577,
0.0652062818,
0.01579584,
-0.0151151847,
0.0246613249,
-0.0182491913,
0.0806157291,
-0.0411394089,
0.0317590125,
-0.011173836,
-0.0494635813,
0.0060230605,
0.0308239534,
0.030664783,
-0.0227690563,
0.002211588,
0.0273028295,
0.0289795194,
-0.0079274792,
-0.0684029385,
-0.0357224569,
-0.0121245841,
0.0215968378,
-0.0772231221,
0.0725230649,
-0.0985278934,
-0.0174871385,
-0.0460481085,
-0.0366432741,
0.0100692203,
0.0395289846,
0.0104834232,
-0.0140533736,
-0.0072515416,
0.0189737193,
0.0348247662,
-0.0537144355,
-0.0821782649,
-0.0553754568,
0.0384578966,
-0.0026099321,
-0.0108200628,
-0.032440111,
-0.0013974017,
0.0368518867,
-0.0415130965,
-0.0362613387,
2.563604865e-34,
-0.00864169,
0.0304178502,
0.0532523505,
0.0343679115,
-0.0227282122,
0.0062280782,
-0.0208858829,
-0.0039110696,
0.0321586169,
-0.0398937799,
0.0248178188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07767v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07767v1 | GreekT5: A Series of Greek Sequence-to-Sequence Models for News Summarization | 2023-11-13T21:33:12 | 2023-11-13T21:33:12 | Nikolaos Giarelis, Charalampos Mastrokostas, Nikos Karacapilidis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T07, 68T50, I.2.7 | Text summarization (TS) is a natural language processing (NLP) subtask
pertaining to the automatic formulation of a concise and coherent summary that
covers the major concepts and topics from one or multiple documents. Recent
advancements in deep learning have led to the development of abstractive
summarization transformer-based models, which outperform classical approaches.
In any case, research in this field focuses on high resource languages such as
English, while the corresponding work for low resource languages is still
underdeveloped. Taking the above into account, this paper proposes a series of
novel TS models for Greek news articles. The proposed models were thoroughly
evaluated on the same dataset against GreekBART, which is the state-of-the-art
model in Greek abstractive news summarization. Our evaluation results reveal
that most of the proposed models significantly outperform GreekBART on various
evaluation metrics. We make our evaluation code public, aiming to increase the
reproducibility of this work and facilitate future research in the field. | [
0.0011491353,
0.0314569958,
0.0221338999,
0.0224623494,
-0.0210411232,
0.0138844168,
-0.0289775692,
-0.0091572823,
-0.0282961912,
-0.0274319984,
0.0168335084,
-0.0547228418,
0.0400428548,
0.0332656167,
-0.0131595246,
-0.0965299159,
0.0062107774,
-0.0088759074,
-0.0196142271,
-0.0055691237,
0.0082000513,
0.0139452061,
0.0400729328,
-0.0089540379,
0.0441128947,
0.0065097618,
-0.0023799443,
-0.0320171453,
0.0346587412,
0.0095116636,
-0.0494821332,
0.0047937976,
0.0272207372,
0.0267595276,
0.0000018064,
-0.0220591836,
-0.0118966177,
-0.0089639127,
0.0401374213,
0.0311393663,
0.0330857337,
-0.0833935589,
-0.0011512036,
-0.0110529922,
-0.0278325994,
-0.0386549085,
0.0059865126,
0.0257727858,
0.0720859617,
0.0973093063,
-0.0233399849,
-0.0660707355,
0.0609296374,
-0.029728543,
-0.0184695534,
-0.0264595561,
0.0024783784,
-0.0114966715,
-0.0375532843,
-0.0000674946,
0.0035773842,
0.0602385551,
0.043511577,
0.0339741632,
-0.0801886618,
0.0171195026,
-0.0342071056,
-0.0170408487,
0.0142034404,
0.0255830567,
-0.0181862358,
-0.0053340821,
0.0425245501,
0.0102192564,
-0.0064568087,
-0.0058686775,
-0.0672285333,
0.0491700545,
-0.0195368789,
0.0364064649,
0.0366960093,
0.0227275342,
-0.0139153115,
0.0390946791,
-0.0496561602,
0.0302646831,
0.0304678157,
0.0046070749,
-0.0421593972,
0.0315450914,
-0.0598930903,
-0.033246357,
0.038016025,
0.0593475178,
0.0067905076,
-0.0223431159,
-0.0446742736,
-0.0964583382,
0.0016333141,
-0.0410113074,
-0.0213297959,
0.0292506535,
0.026591491,
0.0173884276,
-0.0486981645,
0.0131544396,
0.0437879339,
-0.0054849968,
-0.026432354,
-0.0086572096,
0.0231917668,
0.0325702168,
-0.028633114,
0.0425273031,
-0.044468265,
-0.0112838643,
-0.0411450975,
0.0135586131,
0.0544291846,
-0.0087323561,
-0.0009919192,
-0.0146872466,
-0.0296949353,
-0.0219664425,
0.0429723151,
0.021347275,
-0.0115378127,
-0.048273053,
0.0175807811,
0.0087668831,
0.013271085,
0.003610482,
0.0437456369,
0.0235223845,
0.0270939078,
0.022198461,
-0.0134700378,
-0.0621597879,
-0.0117095122,
-0.0084478091,
-0.0183788054,
-0.0747163966,
-0.0350762494,
-0.0579680838,
0.024698168,
-0.0156065505,
-0.0094450777,
-0.0035073007,
-0.0110409707,
0.0548608489,
-0.033996053,
0.0331099257,
0.0002497232,
0.0201997552,
0.0174795445,
0.0021522662,
0.0419143513,
0.0277007762,
0.0467742085,
0.0474367216,
0.0390884988,
0.0140290754,
-0.0045909537,
0.0453018881,
-0.0109833321,
0.0069618109,
0.0225033965,
-0.0180770606,
-0.0326142646,
0.0204355977,
0.0234808531,
0.0587817803,
-0.0302199703,
0.0386551544,
0.0784209967,
0.0323316678,
-0.0242894143,
0.0377738178,
0.0404217243,
-0.0053133047,
0.0303803515,
0.0428793989,
-0.0123333558,
0.0137840565,
0.012491825,
0.0908591077,
0.0303613432,
0.0482689515,
-0.0214188397,
-0.0509393439,
0.0231326986,
-0.0470777228,
0.0165771078,
0.0023875209,
0.0448706411,
0.0218345523,
-0.0481975526,
0.0479262099,
-0.0016119968,
-0.0689249709,
0.0288824495,
0.0039427918,
0.0181763601,
0.0249713473,
0.0387902185,
-0.0176084787,
-0.020378124,
-0.0007193116,
0.0032295631,
0.0736934245,
0.0201066509,
0.01183738,
-0.0264207684,
-0.0701522455,
-0.0089137647,
-0.0128893554,
0.0098637175,
0.0024718202,
-0.0292080324,
0.0303765535,
0.0648715869,
0.0439187251,
-0.0843237117,
0.0168091618,
-0.0246254671,
-0.0017360917,
-0.0047187172,
-0.0033170767,
-0.0297993403,
0.0286703706,
0.0376464203,
0.0173954312,
0.0180932134,
-0.0636194944,
-0.0002509795,
-0.0250177737,
-0.0620296821,
-0.0329104364,
0.046949774,
-0.054426562,
0.0076568932,
0.066772528,
-0.0320098847,
-0.0696123317,
0.0513877831,
-0.0494744703,
-0.0047362181,
0.0020289912,
0.0230127629,
0.0308596734,
0.0203349087,
0.0098533621,
0.0688817725,
-0.0141730113,
0.0112881195,
0.059538886,
-0.0436874926,
-0.0283746328,
-0.0100210775,
-0.0394334011,
0.0095610023,
-0.0076795472,
-0.0317980312,
0.0557628125,
0.0019681929,
0.0170465801,
-0.0375611894,
-0.0750795454,
0.021409817,
-0.052098006,
0.0502883792,
0.0494246595,
0.0477311946,
0.0031027135,
0.0122928601,
-0.0623644069,
0.0195776727,
0.0456367508,
-0.0002720427,
0.0427693762,
0.0260209925,
0.0298251789,
-0.0462961867,
-0.0234745666,
-0.0018777233,
0.0531925932,
0.0230809376,
-0.0140984915,
-0.050068453,
0.0092659574,
-0.0203360096,
-0.0246720184,
0.0138527192,
0.0131974844,
-0.0309613664,
-0.0057000411,
0.0865506977,
0.0150236432,
0.0291534271,
-0.0069345431,
0.0191712864,
0.0030516782,
-0.0011925724,
-0.0153718507,
-0.0697094128,
0.0052869488,
-0.0376301073,
-0.0441703126,
0.018562736,
0.0500752702,
-0.0378826447,
0.0227354039,
-0.0335322283,
0.0355760418,
-0.0352700092,
0.0450743698,
0.0079186307,
0.0128594805,
-0.0079692136,
0.027643906,
-0.0140628554,
0.0106274337,
0.0388701335,
-0.0117904479,
0.0201485753,
-0.0897106603,
-0.0254690982,
-0.0953192785,
0.0326541699,
0.0172527954,
0.0328269117,
0.0041794423,
-0.032899119,
-0.0287440717,
-0.0068738679,
0.0271994546,
-0.0226254743,
0.1042247638,
-0.0028962186,
-0.0074977097,
-0.0355545543,
0.0061886352,
0.0431856215,
0.0005458477,
-0.010380676,
0.027687639,
0.0353247486,
-0.0054736687,
-0.0599480681,
0.0315052569,
0.0134222563,
0.0839101374,
-0.0360445306,
-0.0044310293,
-0.0155802276,
0.0944267735,
0.0603505671,
-0.019764062,
0.002970807,
-0.0063097365,
0.0354166217,
0.0266975388,
0.018680511,
0.0009184686,
-0.0283290632,
-0.0413283445,
0.0059871422,
-0.0987016559,
-0.0106322179,
-0.0145870317,
-0.02501834,
-0.0630151555,
-0.010046253,
0.1005616188,
0.0095321368,
-0.07317283,
-0.0023826666,
0.0337444842,
-0.000646451,
-0.0017733976,
-0.0103380801,
-0.0420454666,
0.0024740854,
0.0076003494,
0.0071920347,
0.0471774526,
-0.0194805097,
0.0025588437,
-0.0419752188,
-0.0052920463,
-0.0086621623,
-0.1122810394,
-0.0664086789,
-0.0388853811,
-0.0070126383,
-0.0520854034,
0.0191964526,
0.0056367773,
-0.037548054,
0.0271203145,
-0.001232166,
-0.0603885427,
-0.0386229865,
-0.0572600178,
-0.019979896,
-0.0368148834,
0.0292830188,
0.0429297723,
-0.0470936596,
0.0348809585,
0.0165341217,
-0.0310259014,
-0.0227409545,
-0.0000285381,
0.0431400575,
-0.0160806831,
-0.0071356609,
-0.0074206032,
0.0495681912,
-0.0304931421,
0.0020433262,
-0.0130068092,
0.0240009781,
0.0349190086,
-0.04460942,
-0.0287981387,
-0.0008192488,
-0.0208823849,
0.0397348516,
0.0312074274,
-0.0049667307,
-0.0248210784,
0.0002398226,
0.0028329529,
-0.0797594711,
-0.0643399879,
-0.0311919581,
0.0208287016,
-0.0722732469,
-0.0883530155,
-0.069203876,
-0.0016573818,
-0.0211314708,
-0.0202033538,
-0.0431563333,
-0.045999635,
-0.0336774252,
-0.0298703443,
0.0146269398,
-0.0032204252,
-0.0055620526,
-0.0248666611,
0.0270320792,
0.0532312021,
-0.003427262,
-0.028807424,
0.0584466644,
-0.0539254956,
-0.0465935618,
-0.0098102614,
0.0309111364,
0.0124258688,
0.0474357866,
0.0313539952,
0.0172819551,
0.0365871079,
-0.0054031899,
0.0361906737,
0.012987812,
0.0167316794,
0.0282197651,
-0.0323952064,
0.0351162814,
-0.022209581,
0.0222256519,
-0.0011442042,
0.0564050488,
-0.033819139,
-0.0478497893,
0.0258453209,
0.0183681231,
0.0198224932,
-0.0376923196,
-0.0042560701,
0.0035144344,
-0.0151870009,
-0.0172607172,
0.0331944413,
-0.0241690483,
0.0526178107,
0.0160242766,
0.0143203968,
-0.0077861673,
0.0495357811,
0.031228032,
-0.0126242889,
-0.0335931145,
0.0223377831,
0.00454864,
-0.0531551093,
-0.0521074273,
-0.0063285711,
-0.0518793873,
-0.0108953938,
-0.0470528267,
-0.0031750975,
-0.0351734795,
-0.0184681024,
0.0305100419,
-0.0045150737,
0.0239652935,
0.0545430817,
-0.0656376928,
-0.0050362516,
-0.0649608225,
0.0239500795,
0.0695269704,
-0.0101858266,
0.0813752264,
-0.0204904787,
-0.023280561,
-0.0147621948,
0.0303714573,
0.0089916391,
0.0063128169,
-0.076843895,
0.0005232663,
0.0196153298,
0.0137167051,
0.0750769675,
-0.0388791375,
0.0131885111,
0.061390847,
-0.0290737581,
-0.0305772536,
0.0097651118,
-0.0381332524,
0.0095788296,
-0.0496786758,
-0.0590624064,
-0.0360901542,
-0.0248881672,
0.0259879045,
0.0354035944,
0.00272713,
0.0074541494,
0.0199811626,
0.0348774046,
-0.0054062381,
0.0280590653,
-0.0374082364,
0.0175230782,
-0.0529046915,
-0.0130592398,
-0.0394625291,
-5.31527505e-33,
-0.0225989092,
0.0663091838,
-0.0047689998,
0.0192042626,
-0.0422790125,
0.019751966,
-0.0733371004,
0.0011092656,
0.025904268,
-0.0078198183,
-0.0094207469,
-0.0143152596,
0.0088513624,
0.0542025752,
0.0089964215,
0.0034680238,
0.0377865657,
0.0209601149,
-0.0261816699,
0.0413171798,
0.023000855,
0.0298386198,
0.0894644931,
0.0133663043,
0.0125709884,
-0.0096033718,
0.0119384499,
-0.0346994363,
0.0475968942,
0.0331451669,
0.0085402066,
0.0077585047,
0.0316403806,
-0.0700067058,
-0.0289618168,
0.057127215,
-0.0417101011,
-0.0141188782,
0.0028468582,
-0.0082366653,
-0.0554955974,
-0.0437145494,
0.0189931896,
-0.0133443251,
0.0278899409,
-0.0434869267,
0.0522037968,
-0.0448395498,
-0.0389936566,
-0.0787352324,
-0.0120607726,
0.0445936173,
-0.024680892,
-0.0221396368,
0.0548020266,
0.0596077628,
-0.0060999393,
0.0320599005,
-0.0181510225,
0.0096207066,
0.0145493718,
0.0704081804,
0.0442304686,
-0.0164594818,
-0.0232898109,
0.0019460162,
-0.026447501,
-0.0369730592,
-0.0167141017,
0.0465092026,
0.0012450402,
0.0027506726,
0.0746264681,
-0.0085610319,
0.0047321445,
0.0219582599,
-0.0386713482,
0.0445288792,
0.004155634,
0.0274467766,
-0.0010221396,
-0.0161481556,
-0.0035851703,
0.0216037389,
-0.0282463469,
-0.0495575331,
0.0019776998,
-0.0330947116,
-0.011707128,
-0.0004007282,
-0.0611639544,
0.0516896099,
0.0071118162,
-0.045776993,
-0.0016913381,
0.0273640752,
-0.0262929257,
0.033535365,
-0.0370168127,
-0.0092328433,
-0.0350318849,
0.0064767255,
-0.0109890923,
0.0080722421,
-0.0348665975,
-0.0124439886,
0.0243372452,
0.0265823826,
-0.0275536813,
0.0069114142,
0.0157875251,
0.0127735697,
-0.0421440788,
0.0785165727,
-0.0054914895,
-0.014809276,
0.012366198,
0.0331762433,
0.0140938452,
-0.0116462167,
0.0022130082,
0.0274657793,
0.028745383,
0.0396499187,
0.0079566706,
0.0257096794,
-0.0144721409,
0.0481569879,
0.0550587736,
-0.0001993221,
-0.0111171734,
0.0316116586,
2.403e-7,
0.0399792232,
0.0071300813,
0.0287290346,
0.0067251544,
-0.0219792556,
0.0208088141,
0.0068596848,
0.0448749959,
-0.0027162232,
-0.0142059028,
0.0500056855,
0.0220848918,
0.0320444703,
0.0189830363,
-0.1131046712,
-0.0125436308,
-0.1044635177,
-0.0318688117,
-0.043113824,
-0.0364223979,
0.0408894122,
0.0822906941,
-0.0160375237,
-0.0301740225,
-0.029649375,
0.0006883887,
0.0238754377,
-0.0130425878,
-0.0608424507,
0.0378059335,
0.0510370694,
0.0199881047,
-0.0103085293,
-0.0158271044,
-0.0223217588,
0.0060193064,
0.0684659556,
0.0310085174,
0.022578137,
0.020816559,
0.0090584299,
-0.0224788301,
-0.0108222365,
-0.0098752184,
0.0611928143,
-0.0839110687,
-0.0101453476,
-0.0477411151,
-0.0855807438,
0.0260102134,
-0.0051185968,
0.0188119933,
-0.045196265,
0.08086285,
0.0329947025,
-0.0209093206,
0.0065324083,
-0.0566640496,
-0.0088790404,
-0.002023861,
0.0158294253,
0.0170371048,
-0.0517371148,
-0.0221434627,
-0.00395574,
-0.0354544856,
-0.0390565731,
2.056171734e-34,
0.0773342401,
-0.0005109223,
-0.0281589404,
0.0435843989,
-0.0433188081,
-0.0391419157,
-0.0122719668,
-0.0161802117,
-0.0232466701,
-0.0622251555,
0.0008778994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07766v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07766v1 | Vision-Language Integration in Multimodal Video Transformers (Partially) Aligns with the Brain | 2023-11-13T21:32:37 | 2023-11-13T21:32:37 | Dota Tianai Dong, Mariya Toneva | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Integrating information from multiple modalities is arguably one of the
essential prerequisites for grounding artificial intelligence systems with an
understanding of the real world. Recent advances in video transformers that
jointly learn from vision, text, and sound over time have made some progress
toward this goal, but the degree to which these models integrate information
from modalities still remains unclear. In this work, we present a promising
approach for probing a pre-trained multimodal video transformer model by
leveraging neuroscientific evidence of multimodal information processing in the
brain. Using brain recordings of participants watching a popular TV show, we
analyze the effects of multi-modal connections and interactions in a
pre-trained multi-modal video transformer on the alignment with uni- and
multi-modal brain regions. We find evidence that vision enhances masked
prediction performance during language processing, providing support that
cross-modal representations in models can benefit individual modalities.
However, we don't find evidence of brain-relevant information captured by the
joint multi-modal transformer representations beyond that captured by all of
the individual modalities. We finally show that the brain alignment of the
pre-trained joint representation can be improved by fine-tuning using a task
that requires vision-language inferences. Overall, our results paint an
optimistic picture of the ability of multi-modal transformers to integrate
vision and language in partially brain-relevant ways but also show that
improving the brain alignment of these models may require new approaches. | [
0.0023105501,
0.0604172274,
-0.0354999974,
-0.0072735175,
0.00241602,
-0.0016070695,
0.011016204,
0.0135017456,
-0.0403464362,
-0.0773396865,
-0.0595295094,
-0.0407705195,
0.0586678721,
0.0577492006,
0.0541851744,
-0.0420750901,
0.0143896248,
-0.0133480988,
-0.0225490499,
0.0166899748,
0.0173119716,
0.0007818695,
-0.0371085443,
0.0205037314,
-0.0500122271,
0.0030001469,
-0.0225234013,
-0.021053113,
0.0299301576,
0.0272632483,
-0.0452816486,
0.0508951731,
0.0598509572,
0.0081071556,
0.0000016803,
-0.0511107668,
0.031653706,
-0.0125418492,
0.022681728,
-0.0088374959,
-0.0007199703,
-0.0618275031,
-0.003605969,
-0.0036087183,
-0.0303257797,
-0.0019497343,
0.0900831074,
0.0373130515,
0.0215288214,
0.0152768278,
-0.0435117185,
-0.0320946947,
0.0381410867,
-0.0028136701,
0.0201731361,
0.025363693,
-0.0003143353,
-0.0344395861,
-0.0324312188,
-0.015912937,
-0.0865572989,
0.026789017,
0.0023055361,
-0.0190318301,
-0.0334652588,
0.0548438653,
0.0034865893,
-0.0557335131,
-0.0501169525,
0.0536837168,
0.0144749954,
-0.02210081,
-0.0430991538,
0.0376836844,
0.004219621,
0.0258874167,
-0.0198226199,
0.032486748,
0.0029052224,
0.0118676284,
-0.0278541315,
-0.028649915,
0.0226367712,
-0.0299555678,
0.0252280068,
0.0222317521,
0.0412875414,
0.0070123272,
0.0158801582,
0.008603544,
0.0160923898,
-0.0337351859,
0.0080363415,
-0.0091567216,
0.0003635558,
-0.0186512396,
-0.0311832279,
-0.0343249515,
-0.0431798697,
0.0121751744,
0.0255047362,
0.048214145,
-0.0722943619,
0.0358721763,
-0.0343697891,
0.0644057691,
-0.0781471729,
0.0689601898,
-0.0236657448,
-0.0221921019,
-0.0453603417,
-0.0516457446,
0.0310475193,
-0.0139371138,
-0.0158805251,
-0.04467557,
-0.0162165873,
0.0287120435,
-0.0326768123,
-0.0087158317,
-0.0179791432,
0.0429794192,
-0.0055409735,
-0.0078142807,
-0.0565842278,
0.0769106299,
0.0038001304,
0.0680899546,
-0.0129812323,
-0.0585932508,
-0.0138857476,
0.043615602,
-0.0151177635,
-0.0297088698,
-0.011944457,
0.0692788512,
-0.0422934517,
-0.0233784672,
0.0263735391,
0.0174181033,
-0.017465258,
0.0108460756,
0.0868190601,
-0.0226035975,
0.0502453484,
0.0233253818,
-0.0085389838,
-0.0160668902,
-0.0138653964,
-0.0199590474,
-0.0094849812,
0.0735586211,
0.005449357,
0.0091742473,
0.0335739329,
0.018499393,
-0.0098361643,
0.0082671521,
0.0353420787,
-0.0146812489,
-0.0325708687,
-0.0117821693,
0.0117796017,
0.0515818484,
-0.0184701364,
-0.0027075543,
-0.0506884567,
-0.0497806296,
0.0043396228,
0.0268315449,
0.0476392023,
0.0102011524,
-0.0119877206,
-0.0421198346,
0.0912347287,
0.0219000168,
-0.0086252773,
-0.0126335481,
0.0231749155,
-0.0259591602,
0.0161018316,
0.0288931876,
-0.0483249985,
0.0951367691,
-0.0136122704,
-0.0008066886,
-0.0111931683,
0.0464521125,
-0.0337022208,
-0.0078224847,
-0.0073994594,
-0.0198504701,
0.0069064614,
0.0316744335,
0.0328128114,
0.0008484394,
-0.0532483533,
0.0283315592,
0.0118348403,
-0.0002682871,
0.0394085199,
-0.0149612399,
-0.0021524627,
-0.0141163953,
-0.0413305685,
-0.0080176638,
0.0012839977,
-0.0020358013,
0.0259870533,
0.0561532713,
0.0132663511,
0.0209675469,
0.043586459,
-0.0195400417,
-0.0363748632,
0.0022896179,
0.0119226165,
0.0301682744,
-0.0581090823,
-0.0182183199,
-0.0315994583,
0.0048486912,
0.0524517559,
0.0430648848,
0.0091778208,
0.0116067035,
-0.0791594535,
0.0013239593,
0.0281282943,
-0.0491437726,
-0.0219756421,
0.0108269379,
0.0093462244,
-0.0079104658,
0.0183762889,
0.0642861649,
-0.0369723812,
0.0013962304,
0.0291933436,
-0.0671771616,
0.0025827277,
0.0810264796,
0.0243763495,
-0.0137730679,
0.01842569,
-0.0171392709,
0.0415510908,
-0.0403405875,
-0.0038430756,
-0.0015190466,
0.0381519496,
-0.003703994,
0.0126755321,
0.003890435,
-0.0338416658,
0.0007141585,
-0.0267205406,
0.0195407774,
0.0014444954,
-0.0246260874,
0.0181284174,
-0.0167505927,
-0.0267579593,
0.0091780415,
-0.07676135,
-0.0617661625,
-0.0291484483,
-0.0891194567,
-0.0039030456,
0.0317013338,
-0.0141873145,
0.0233488847,
-0.0210747197,
-0.0070286714,
-0.0121705122,
-0.0135126906,
0.0309960339,
0.0103830621,
0.0304473136,
-0.0143976798,
-0.0040235156,
-0.001197918,
0.00415979,
-0.0077798981,
-0.0375865176,
0.0784626976,
-0.0009750286,
-0.0481108129,
-0.0377335437,
0.0050254306,
-0.0183511283,
0.0118069658,
-0.0186548978,
-0.0182850286,
0.022338938,
0.0274718199,
0.0623764172,
0.0337741375,
0.0270079467,
-0.0039880178,
0.0657475218,
-0.024173405,
-0.0088416534,
-0.0242122505,
0.0046655512,
-0.0145535646,
-0.056697581,
0.0009566908,
-0.0152796032,
0.0462069586,
0.0303756576,
0.0177290589,
-0.0534301512,
0.0015715976,
0.0210521128,
-0.0511598736,
-0.0051115905,
-0.0249432642,
-0.040607404,
0.0560414754,
-0.0266447421,
-0.0605958737,
0.043647185,
-0.0412848219,
-0.0306633245,
0.0389583074,
0.0412983596,
0.0185648855,
0.0286598299,
0.0417991132,
0.0369589888,
-0.0135359243,
-0.0233561248,
-0.1223671362,
0.0121687148,
0.0133632012,
0.0026242204,
0.0544982813,
-0.0073329969,
-0.0202762727,
-0.0037096601,
0.0161128547,
-0.0417263657,
-0.0077570803,
-0.0528513342,
-0.0207508486,
-0.0008724939,
0.0250755791,
-0.0834508687,
-0.0122866165,
0.0741072223,
0.0122111561,
-0.0130744725,
-0.0270559806,
0.0049347398,
0.0484187193,
0.0350255221,
0.0443756208,
0.0033260279,
-0.0496562123,
0.0009790435,
0.0328433849,
0.0188256707,
0.0248154178,
-0.0758283511,
0.0484984331,
0.0389217027,
0.0445361957,
-0.0156642161,
0.0457709879,
0.0285881814,
0.0032796455,
0.0076889824,
0.0807785243,
-0.0085949842,
-0.0655232146,
-0.0206658542,
-0.0014860233,
-0.0145055717,
0.0364456251,
0.0366218947,
-0.0672240108,
-0.0423605256,
-0.0204300936,
-0.0573176146,
0.0461432934,
0.0213437974,
-0.0183759704,
-0.0554104187,
0.027998114,
-0.0056230505,
-0.0068268725,
-0.010375673,
0.0077834195,
0.0158612281,
0.0041819359,
0.0203467552,
-0.0449045524,
-0.0235609654,
-0.0029352363,
0.0329942107,
0.0510013551,
-0.0300995912,
0.0108556142,
-0.0316113308,
0.0473446101,
0.051335074,
-0.0003745007,
-0.0349439941,
-0.0582125485,
0.0104548009,
0.0224483013,
0.029784197,
0.0257128589,
0.0441852361,
-0.0140909217,
-0.0178926531,
0.0128124682,
-0.0116460826,
0.0090079112,
-0.0818030983,
-0.0534685478,
0.0717514381,
-0.0103342207,
0.0037427293,
0.0018777357,
0.0514746159,
-0.0455944687,
0.0118332673,
-0.012739053,
-0.0496462546,
0.05033971,
0.0327558555,
0.01662286,
0.0180631652,
-0.0764084384,
0.0190776251,
0.0112893181,
0.0063970042,
-0.0191810057,
0.0276070852,
0.027777249,
0.0212942641,
0.028032586,
-0.0251353122,
0.0314293876,
-0.0090024443,
-0.0327566043,
0.0764150172,
0.0175071489,
0.0055964566,
-0.0386118889,
-0.0214113072,
0.0282435659,
-0.0695679486,
-0.0111630447,
0.0220123678,
-0.0765548795,
-0.0630055219,
0.032460697,
0.0323564932,
0.0213608369,
0.0459272228,
0.0453651026,
-0.0012465494,
0.0458658636,
0.0270763151,
-0.0117148273,
0.0639631152,
-0.0229013208,
-0.0561420843,
-0.0276886411,
-0.0118210567,
-0.0355415717,
-0.0036437593,
0.0110438103,
-0.0087786401,
-0.014785246,
0.0072332164,
0.0359867141,
-0.0327847563,
0.1099096313,
-0.0413834229,
0.0355624184,
-0.0443858579,
-0.0368540362,
0.0228967872,
0.0388889983,
-0.0271530114,
-0.0404014587,
0.0445823893,
0.0162802171,
-0.0028378719,
0.0418124311,
0.0011318089,
-0.0285185352,
-0.0148589518,
-0.0405048542,
-0.0259612724,
-0.0538754016,
-0.0351635814,
0.0756802931,
0.0553362593,
0.0419781022,
-0.0246547833,
0.0273567922,
0.0232886132,
0.0657252222,
0.0190541428,
-0.0014606892,
-0.019512739,
0.0481213517,
-0.0328913182,
-0.00190312,
0.0315529406,
0.0044820481,
0.011673498,
-0.0505065285,
-0.004676674,
0.0097051412,
0.0104334895,
0.0066521079,
0.0400987193,
-0.0151974959,
-0.0171988886,
0.0824088678,
-0.0031614094,
0.0056414292,
-0.0070285769,
0.0488479324,
-0.0309495479,
0.0023445294,
-0.0160665289,
0.0122311739,
-0.0226072613,
-0.0241373274,
0.0330248028,
0.0150315715,
-0.0645089895,
-0.0137015749,
-0.0185757261,
-0.0698788017,
-0.0072100684,
-0.0228127986,
0.0431935675,
-0.0028027305,
0.0086438674,
0.0139335617,
0.0008026581,
-0.0242271982,
0.0296191964,
-0.0411687344,
0.0135098007,
0.0092637176,
0.0089169126,
-5.460582315e-33,
-0.0529701747,
-0.0059704809,
0.0030531208,
0.0297385473,
-0.0101065272,
0.0296944585,
-0.0045059696,
0.0326857939,
-0.0002923488,
0.0176797528,
0.0346242636,
0.0129551012,
0.0203779824,
0.0074680899,
0.0088526905,
-0.0390746742,
-0.0150089217,
-0.0303404164,
-0.022312222,
-0.0673429146,
0.0379134566,
0.008872048,
0.0970043615,
-0.0819049478,
-0.0241924226,
0.0530444346,
-0.0497004017,
0.0028320593,
-0.0095980968,
0.0603194535,
-0.0367105491,
0.0282596517,
0.0168099888,
-0.015358177,
-0.0066032642,
0.0511456802,
-0.0184542425,
0.0206876956,
0.0381205529,
0.0344620906,
-0.0945388824,
0.0073439572,
0.0433791578,
-0.0383946784,
-0.0020016059,
-0.0380024686,
0.0535723418,
-0.0132814469,
0.0329351053,
0.0233558416,
-0.079933852,
-0.0527635999,
-0.0233649593,
-0.0316233411,
0.0310528725,
0.0212426204,
0.0283782575,
0.0335135795,
-0.0465313829,
0.0390708894,
-0.0559243485,
0.0317752883,
0.0975234732,
0.0282226428,
-0.0054762354,
0.063732028,
0.0642791241,
-0.0633855835,
-0.0442227982,
-0.0549392253,
0.0428679325,
0.0222854465,
0.0001944057,
0.0486081466,
0.0242354348,
-0.0187279955,
-0.0114547089,
0.0188704636,
-0.0540226661,
0.0305815786,
0.003692802,
-0.0138072064,
0.0690420941,
0.0199605916,
-0.0416030623,
0.0045805178,
-0.0446933769,
0.0054539614,
0.0149940578,
0.0013791941,
0.0386152565,
0.0217443313,
0.074402079,
-0.0304605756,
0.0551365353,
-0.0130643928,
-0.0373195149,
0.060278669,
0.0108108409,
0.0178590231,
-0.014029053,
-0.0061766775,
0.073796615,
-0.0077134557,
0.0418242663,
0.0056332406,
-0.0064713657,
0.0464375243,
-0.0263016857,
-0.0141718695,
-0.0170207378,
-0.0286131427,
0.0584708154,
-0.0013939552,
0.0328462422,
0.0416990519,
-0.0680000857,
-0.0585875995,
-0.0014865579,
-0.0013391007,
-0.0337339118,
-0.0139901619,
-0.0425839573,
0.0283166822,
-0.004631924,
0.0214837044,
-0.0454138257,
-0.0612089336,
0.059860412,
-0.0478435867,
-0.041217193,
0.0376741625,
2.631e-7,
0.033158917,
0.0398280583,
-0.0229465645,
-0.022198664,
0.0247001182,
0.0397593938,
-0.0072268755,
0.061854478,
0.0432745852,
-0.0944722369,
-0.0273323283,
0.0289698411,
0.0098590553,
-0.0027063792,
0.0021518518,
-0.0325280167,
-0.0181007423,
0.0203233548,
-0.0285072401,
0.0116505446,
0.0262786429,
0.0627980158,
-0.0198013578,
-0.0253304169,
0.0180240571,
-0.0052819406,
0.1074799299,
-0.0316344015,
-0.0226673149,
-0.0354890227,
-0.0209502429,
-0.041862607,
-0.0086393971,
0.0508467145,
0.000643144,
-0.0191388037,
0.0287295021,
-0.0221543293,
-0.0329923891,
-0.0239877217,
-0.0332676917,
0.0488919728,
-0.0605401546,
0.0104133878,
0.0242467485,
-0.0728954896,
-0.0668481067,
-0.0144408392,
-0.0363435335,
0.0140563054,
0.0174347516,
0.0131927514,
-0.0221522152,
0.0152639411,
-0.0021670875,
0.0455232635,
-0.0531696528,
-0.0440609828,
-0.038942527,
0.0116286194,
-0.0638999119,
0.0021321648,
-0.019760387,
-0.0588012822,
0.0733972192,
-0.0559600145,
-0.0365031809,
1.66363491e-34,
-0.0473896377,
0.0153588299,
0.0449477732,
-0.0311656222,
-0.0133930901,
-0.0233168993,
0.0145840803,
-0.013529269,
-0.0033991316,
-0.0513701402,
-0.0202926751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07723v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07723v3 | Generalization Analogies: A Testbed for Generalizing AI Oversight to Hard-To-Measure Domains | 2023-11-13T20:07:36 | 2023-12-17T21:18:14 | Joshua Clymer, Garrett Baker, Rohan Subramani, Sam Wang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | As AI systems become more intelligent and their behavior becomes more
challenging to assess, they may learn to game the flaws of human feedback
instead of genuinely striving to follow instructions; however, this risk can be
mitigated by controlling how LLMs generalize human feedback to situations where
it is unreliable. To better understand how reward models generalize, we craft
69 distribution shifts spanning 8 categories. We find that reward models do not
learn to evaluate `instruction-following' by default and instead favor personas
that resemble internet text. Techniques for interpreting reward models'
internal representations achieve better generalization than standard
fine-tuning, but still frequently fail to distinguish instruction-following
from conflated behaviors. We consolidate the 15 most challenging distribution
shifts into the GENeralization analogIES (GENIES) benchmark, which we hope will
enable progress toward controlling reward model generalization. | [
0.0372543894,
0.0615083873,
-0.0398223288,
-0.0124295577,
0.0008573278,
0.0200057477,
-0.0390767604,
0.0185126923,
-0.0409273766,
0.0299244858,
-0.0488465093,
0.008405026,
-0.0145656783,
0.0079751909,
0.0360478535,
-0.0802629441,
0.0414929055,
-0.0246533044,
0.0269223209,
0.006902758,
-0.0038915491,
-0.0007026735,
0.0185093395,
0.029711334,
0.0023999647,
-0.0120503753,
0.0011723257,
0.0004942839,
0.0464921147,
-0.0409016684,
0.0120815737,
-0.0068479097,
0.036586687,
0.0055630039,
0.0000020441,
-0.059396185,
0.0083179288,
-0.0120577374,
-0.0012091849,
0.004155573,
-0.029511651,
-0.0269062743,
0.0271897316,
-0.0089034326,
-0.0264151376,
0.0406136774,
0.028603673,
0.0561778769,
0.014961754,
0.0634549782,
0.0070652771,
0.0123617742,
0.0081687234,
0.0019539988,
0.0447147898,
-0.0759040937,
0.004854836,
0.0167819057,
-0.0013879798,
-0.0341849737,
-0.0493816398,
-0.0331748649,
0.0241226684,
0.0229564533,
0.0322595425,
0.019537814,
0.0106817717,
-0.0144221941,
-0.0220782217,
0.0411480591,
0.0047390875,
0.0067938492,
0.0269736182,
-0.0016736512,
0.0716037527,
0.0137355514,
-0.027787663,
0.0478620529,
-0.0304168202,
-0.0150894858,
0.0261690617,
0.0190632902,
0.0464769714,
0.0009262474,
-0.0354388058,
0.0545332953,
-0.0208711345,
-0.0448574014,
0.0159934107,
0.0368497744,
-0.0321548097,
-0.0479671918,
0.0005181426,
0.0616440661,
-0.0577335209,
-0.0022281718,
-0.0221081749,
0.0385230929,
0.0023408602,
0.0365736,
0.0890997797,
0.0226575993,
-0.0387061462,
0.0338349119,
0.0047091837,
0.0958308876,
-0.0033607851,
0.0919206738,
-0.0224081483,
0.0266822726,
-0.038751483,
0.0080218045,
0.0198306926,
0.0439722613,
0.0413645022,
0.0023371966,
-0.011092294,
0.0516266786,
-0.0960595012,
0.0383681841,
-0.0127544608,
0.0391935594,
-0.0199709199,
0.0098294523,
-0.082787618,
-0.0299480055,
-0.0899146944,
0.03877455,
0.0466271043,
0.0293136463,
-0.0322913006,
-0.0210102424,
-0.0015958503,
-0.0042415201,
0.0269926246,
0.1095460355,
0.0305325184,
-0.0386168174,
-0.0001728986,
-0.0215410758,
-0.0051126648,
-0.0330497772,
0.0007683414,
-0.0031816785,
0.0207687635,
-0.0135760745,
-0.0233398173,
0.0032198424,
-0.0179997832,
-0.0114049688,
-0.0200526956,
0.0472630635,
0.0553537533,
0.004572019,
0.0075174761,
0.0236434843,
-0.049451571,
0.0038767937,
0.0239109844,
0.0334762521,
0.0298781414,
0.0185001399,
0.0765934587,
0.0122992219,
0.0111789117,
0.0430946946,
0.0432315394,
0.0121003892,
-0.0125659341,
0.0569275953,
0.0966539979,
0.0349070467,
-0.0319555141,
0.0063284109,
0.0676024333,
0.064096421,
-0.0114325695,
-0.0422852598,
0.042110946,
-0.033791624,
0.0098653054,
0.0600496791,
-0.078959927,
0.0278002098,
-0.0034586394,
-0.0383672118,
-0.0377925672,
-0.0077540344,
-0.0337050185,
-0.0407431573,
0.0233072247,
-0.0180258676,
0.018806722,
0.0269041918,
0.0296565145,
0.0319971032,
-0.0070047835,
-0.0555995516,
0.0253698695,
-0.0085261231,
0.0174790677,
-0.1148805395,
0.0473864116,
0.0640651807,
0.0340803638,
-0.0444644168,
0.0245512426,
-0.0139807286,
-0.0201823711,
-0.0062412727,
0.0427773632,
-0.0488921329,
-0.0011963134,
0.0183518864,
-0.0153586324,
-0.0210814085,
0.0416031964,
0.0475924052,
0.0034597502,
-0.0475712493,
-0.0376847424,
-0.0220783763,
-0.0504731648,
0.0547499768,
-0.0140629821,
-0.0362877958,
-0.013187509,
0.0110060433,
0.0099289026,
0.0016486666,
0.0262631532,
0.006164114,
0.0039981068,
0.0213010684,
-0.0212800484,
-0.0094131939,
-0.0232212003,
0.0448687449,
-0.007557028,
-0.0428113677,
-0.0196917988,
0.0376998112,
-0.0039705294,
0.0002118391,
0.0136608845,
-0.0023345451,
0.0488323122,
0.026776392,
0.0448229685,
-0.0288668238,
-0.0084463172,
-0.0427292883,
0.0323056355,
-0.0313014463,
-0.0351795815,
-0.0169553794,
-0.0122152995,
-0.0277012046,
-0.0585155971,
0.0066273645,
-0.016298119,
-0.0170523226,
0.0450755693,
0.0540908277,
-0.0168446787,
-0.0509709008,
-0.0247640554,
-0.0231731255,
0.0144087328,
-0.0121328067,
0.0137387766,
0.0350703076,
-0.0229929183,
0.0019757885,
0.0027017782,
-0.0387084112,
-0.036614269,
0.0040426273,
0.0180061646,
0.0623241402,
0.0160046406,
-0.0010620751,
-0.0440035425,
0.026818186,
-0.0229014996,
-0.0039290814,
-0.004915243,
0.0657681152,
-0.0836091489,
0.0201225914,
-0.0180343054,
-0.010529099,
-0.0310686324,
-0.020029787,
0.0483076572,
0.0099896342,
0.013621375,
0.1328295916,
0.007238687,
0.0763240457,
0.0419193096,
0.0324559845,
-0.0596645959,
-0.0175994579,
0.0029399088,
-0.0531869046,
-0.0209338814,
-0.0588299632,
0.0340560377,
0.0620678663,
0.0179442856,
0.0224478114,
-0.0495554022,
0.0690959767,
-0.0291255824,
-0.0699554235,
-0.0196896754,
-0.0102812769,
-0.0153492233,
0.0337509103,
-0.0433936268,
-0.0621887669,
0.0694060773,
0.0234052408,
0.039578028,
0.03242632,
-0.0435351394,
-0.0056300042,
0.0392226689,
0.0190502591,
0.0100145917,
0.0152884619,
-0.0341128446,
-0.0904371291,
-0.014444706,
0.0291069224,
-0.0170625132,
0.0667073876,
-0.0320909992,
-0.0425124764,
0.0201673843,
-0.0423812643,
-0.0379330888,
-0.0105233416,
0.0118129607,
0.0113156317,
0.0172624327,
-0.0684645921,
-0.0124817323,
-0.0509133413,
0.053284727,
-0.022865871,
-0.0409799069,
-0.041851867,
-0.0196239613,
-0.050502874,
0.0568309575,
-0.0011703768,
0.0464977473,
-0.0803329274,
-0.0193223804,
0.0294760074,
0.0183115881,
-0.0260212552,
-0.0003038782,
-0.0073503829,
0.0117751034,
-0.0506784953,
0.009510614,
0.0398397185,
0.0763599947,
-0.0262063518,
-0.0161380749,
0.071642004,
0.0254761372,
-0.0624944009,
0.04593293,
-0.0050310185,
0.0068736132,
0.0245429538,
0.025520172,
-0.0829104632,
0.0059766141,
0.0117565729,
0.0442206599,
-0.0587793477,
-0.0549241044,
0.035756819,
-0.0585076883,
0.0028073685,
0.0014607643,
-0.0290645082,
-0.0276577584,
-0.017162988,
-0.006660556,
-0.0370943733,
0.0162305571,
0.0038578822,
0.0087842643,
-0.0180810839,
0.01477456,
-0.0080374498,
-0.0141785247,
0.0379730947,
-0.0741067827,
0.0694548935,
0.0953163952,
0.0225254204,
-0.0367111415,
-0.0185815319,
-0.0277297702,
0.0360426754,
0.035236571,
0.0363447443,
0.0605348274,
-0.0301090702,
0.0184948705,
-0.0136058405,
0.0147368964,
0.0159774292,
0.001929627,
0.0263690054,
0.0633513927,
-0.029273117,
-0.0609826669,
-0.0327473357,
-0.0532162413,
0.0265171826,
0.0513354801,
-0.0069618402,
-0.0540408827,
-0.0293817036,
-0.0345391259,
-0.0291600488,
-0.0278302226,
-0.0505826622,
0.0149682537,
-0.0098273065,
-0.0171581656,
-0.0738625228,
-0.0622931309,
-0.0334392041,
0.0005528781,
0.0294461567,
-0.0837648958,
-0.0406252071,
0.0003885952,
0.0119751804,
0.0267840158,
-0.0135732368,
0.0040155002,
-0.0248446576,
-0.0378768481,
-0.0355633758,
-0.0505624376,
0.0038899323,
-0.0213361643,
-0.0343263708,
-0.0269535463,
0.012805108,
0.0831635296,
0.0272662211,
0.0353845172,
-0.0041755172,
-0.0086159436,
0.0564209297,
-0.0078028282,
-0.0061137215,
0.044378005,
0.0385442451,
0.0225942861,
-0.0266033672,
0.0095710084,
-0.0720953792,
0.0341480821,
0.016179746,
-0.0244886912,
0.0009732636,
0.0340075046,
0.0427787825,
-0.0038929253,
-0.0062159635,
-0.0065679573,
-0.0194904115,
-0.0063298577,
-0.0496633537,
0.0053281127,
-0.0208382308,
0.0004657043,
-0.0431186743,
0.0515692085,
0.0369466133,
-0.0049363826,
-0.0232248716,
0.0103760613,
0.015813861,
-0.0755889341,
-0.0261132978,
0.0310848113,
0.0600994043,
-0.0153053021,
0.0241819043,
-0.0070967511,
0.0242044237,
-0.0172156226,
0.0469876006,
0.0357483774,
0.0344639048,
0.024860017,
0.0357597619,
-0.0322263427,
0.0282671619,
-0.1015515029,
-0.0463486984,
0.0166489184,
-0.0042721736,
0.0331962332,
-0.0088038715,
0.0202911627,
-0.0025717902,
0.011186569,
0.0125512704,
0.0019514492,
-0.0215799976,
0.019601604,
-0.006661877,
0.0286281649,
0.0060722549,
-0.0242322795,
0.0309329387,
-0.0239133406,
0.0800213069,
-0.0928269327,
-0.0179254692,
-0.0131916795,
-0.0116399154,
0.0418754518,
0.0074835205,
-0.0074017756,
-0.0581979603,
-0.0570160486,
-0.0462507159,
-0.0309901219,
0.048924461,
0.0230381992,
-0.0580953471,
-0.0128941461,
0.0239667948,
-0.0353704616,
-0.0105932904,
-0.0207915772,
-0.0585085414,
-0.0294301417,
0.0277920924,
-0.054972969,
-5.890522313e-33,
-0.002583303,
-0.0138605265,
0.0063134949,
0.0183470398,
-0.0137328263,
0.0055079791,
-0.0141564421,
-0.0143362703,
-0.0386863686,
0.0094731599,
-0.0134138819,
0.0235185921,
-0.0150995729,
-0.047137849,
0.0471952818,
-0.0300425049,
0.0405146368,
-0.012759502,
-0.0601120777,
0.0257765632,
0.0200491399,
-0.0017048806,
0.0457691625,
-0.0758187622,
0.0734157041,
0.0270697828,
-0.0642069876,
0.0041912855,
-0.0259074066,
0.0270415153,
0.0136066042,
0.0153082833,
0.0168361273,
0.0032129488,
-0.0108294412,
0.0286765583,
-0.0495724604,
-0.0326891914,
-0.0014963002,
-0.0315121785,
-0.0456958264,
-0.0796343759,
0.0269547086,
-0.0178194121,
-0.033557009,
0.0092756189,
0.0374622345,
0.0077567236,
0.0341298133,
0.0014224414,
-0.0609398074,
-0.0173455011,
-0.0156711228,
-0.0132840723,
-0.0422255546,
0.0509064235,
-0.0282492768,
0.023422122,
-0.040777944,
0.059018746,
0.0133333327,
-0.0349696428,
0.0490242206,
0.0308504459,
-0.0047319261,
0.0577484928,
0.0345340222,
0.0560688786,
-0.0492379479,
-0.0350083783,
0.0042763553,
0.0511749685,
0.0179685503,
-0.0058510965,
0.0349603891,
-0.0469335318,
-0.0243370589,
0.0341768079,
-0.002861761,
-0.0157923214,
0.0322112218,
0.0206754822,
-0.078425929,
-0.0103501864,
-0.0179838389,
-0.0289549027,
-0.0248873215,
-0.027517667,
0.0275791734,
0.0188998599,
0.0148408366,
-0.0297036003,
-0.0144847753,
-0.0599404573,
0.0398220271,
-0.0113609508,
-0.0210421234,
0.0043267147,
-0.0016357766,
-0.0649168715,
-0.0748116821,
-0.0659607798,
0.0043602893,
0.0026245608,
0.0613166168,
0.061293602,
0.048213806,
0.0176616516,
-0.0028207828,
-0.0227714945,
-0.0275487099,
0.0056403303,
0.027575884,
-0.0335883722,
0.0192831103,
-0.0038727773,
-0.010140894,
0.0154489437,
0.0080953017,
-0.0124514848,
-0.0595085584,
0.0508294888,
-0.0311583243,
0.0080112694,
-0.0261537954,
-0.0227160789,
-0.0553528555,
0.0199293979,
0.0161844734,
-0.0752904043,
-0.0283094272,
-0.0290619861,
2.775e-7,
-0.0012106183,
0.0325323753,
0.0103312321,
0.0124446778,
0.0035377385,
0.0528487861,
0.0076167933,
0.0553170554,
0.0064887442,
-0.0255661774,
0.043380484,
0.0265993048,
-0.000868825,
0.0092899883,
-0.0156434681,
-0.0169992987,
-0.0304166079,
0.0141563518,
-0.012523463,
0.0082315933,
0.0174705833,
0.0161666926,
0.0362798944,
-0.0064336332,
0.0323513523,
-0.0274858549,
0.0492194332,
-0.015351614,
0.0116545763,
0.006647069,
0.0048885024,
0.0179710332,
0.0066658407,
0.032768514,
0.0042903968,
0.0219781343,
-0.019597603,
0.0394779071,
-0.0270740464,
-0.0216758382,
-0.0567905381,
-0.000573433,
0.0393552221,
-0.0324786641,
0.0380099714,
-0.0655496269,
-0.0342735276,
-0.0305590928,
0.0280571785,
-0.0110476566,
0.0029090922,
0.011862414,
0.0069536101,
-0.0138675459,
-0.000045089,
0.0556644984,
-0.0004114728,
-0.0735026821,
-0.0106924567,
0.04804717,
0.0091703897,
-0.0853940696,
-0.0135736465,
0.0342360064,
-0.0143187139,
-0.0517876819,
-0.0040023592,
2.334877312e-34,
-0.0158162452,
-0.0092270542,
0.0436748005,
-0.0124964546,
0.0569739379,
0.0028196673,
-0.0334793814,
-0.0017363038,
0.0764122084,
-0.0002956254,
-0.0156043349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07715v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07715v1 | PolyIE: A Dataset of Information Extraction from Polymer Material Scientific Literature | 2023-11-13T19:56:18 | 2023-11-13T19:56:18 | Jerry Junyang Cheung, Yuchen Zhuang, Yinghao Li, Pranav Shetty, Wantian Zhao, Sanjeev Grampurohit, Rampi Ramprasad, Chao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Scientific information extraction (SciIE), which aims to automatically
extract information from scientific literature, is becoming more important than
ever. However, there are no existing SciIE datasets for polymer materials,
which is an important class of materials used ubiquitously in our daily lives.
To bridge this gap, we introduce POLYIE, a new SciIE dataset for polymer
materials. POLYIE is curated from 146 full-length polymer scholarly articles,
which are annotated with different named entities (i.e., materials, properties,
values, conditions) as well as their N-ary relations by domain experts. POLYIE
presents several unique challenges due to diverse lexical formats of entities,
ambiguity between entities, and variable-length relations. We evaluate
state-of-the-art named entity extraction and relation extraction models on
POLYIE, analyze their strengths and weaknesses, and highlight some difficult
cases for these models. To the best of our knowledge, POLYIE is the first SciIE
benchmark for polymer materials, and we hope it will lead to more research
efforts from the community on this challenging task. Our code and data are
available on: https://github.com/jerry3027/PolyIE. | [
0.0386760011,
0.0820443705,
0.0086027896,
0.0281520039,
0.0079369321,
0.0140167037,
0.0025163975,
0.019735232,
-0.0173874516,
-0.0104526151,
0.001717719,
0.0244370289,
-0.0008778797,
0.0263133496,
-0.0057168496,
-0.0197958983,
0.0185951721,
0.0154449549,
0.069730185,
0.0332953781,
0.0191485323,
0.0214266907,
-0.0316620283,
0.0113987951,
0.0236672293,
-0.0153868757,
0.0282328837,
-0.0442388318,
0.0435428657,
-0.0500351749,
0.0376329124,
0.0365052111,
-0.0078717172,
-0.0311406031,
0.0000019634,
-0.0455062948,
-0.0082244221,
0.0325093269,
0.0127507849,
-0.004137889,
0.0540986843,
-0.0696090758,
-0.0058848918,
-0.0292061809,
-0.0169916116,
-0.0532398038,
0.0228659865,
0.0495107323,
-0.0198512208,
0.0065567424,
-0.031566184,
-0.0491049252,
0.0677900016,
-0.0072804228,
0.0422052927,
0.0005384127,
0.047662396,
-0.0049334601,
0.0493763834,
0.0177164022,
0.0440909304,
0.0400505178,
-0.0274126213,
-0.008378542,
0.0229853746,
0.0340312682,
-0.0229906626,
-0.0266490467,
-0.020267101,
0.1184024587,
0.0659373626,
-0.0031627244,
0.0478976183,
-0.0050967578,
-0.0525270998,
0.0674350113,
-0.0298609007,
0.0049791206,
-0.0074068042,
-0.034798082,
0.0317541324,
0.0428005233,
0.0123543218,
-0.0026108436,
0.0112663386,
0.0555254444,
0.0249535758,
-0.0152543867,
0.0233909339,
-0.0140745863,
0.0220112894,
0.005704042,
0.0080049075,
-0.0215681288,
0.0407067686,
0.0138867693,
-0.0162140131,
-0.002741114,
0.0377373807,
-0.0244142301,
-0.0188012831,
-0.0236312654,
0.0258984957,
0.0502620041,
-0.0303705502,
-0.0162025355,
0.0112536335,
0.0216980446,
0.0126628503,
-0.0313402712,
-0.0321869329,
-0.0331339948,
0.0029012489,
0.0422767214,
-0.0263405945,
-0.0432242602,
-0.0102463188,
-0.0409703217,
-0.0147154881,
0.0359277464,
-0.0089040436,
-0.0021153174,
-0.0379174948,
-0.0336377174,
-0.0316404887,
0.0586894713,
0.0027039552,
-0.0025562786,
-0.0418579839,
-0.0246481206,
-0.0308302492,
-0.0092824055,
0.0392336473,
-0.0448996723,
0.0246514231,
0.0844996199,
0.004791772,
-0.0678840727,
0.0319996364,
-0.0395992436,
0.0361123867,
-0.0384965762,
0.031404376,
-0.018829694,
0.0936859027,
0.0136812488,
0.0067361607,
-0.0670214966,
0.0162713639,
-0.0292821676,
-0.0559791885,
0.0709216148,
-0.0541344061,
-0.0506325364,
-0.0002443649,
0.0047473591,
0.059311118,
-0.019401554,
0.0408898033,
-0.0118696857,
0.0261881482,
-0.0125584695,
0.0009128124,
-0.0085611884,
-0.0084591582,
-0.054824397,
0.0379447639,
-0.0274034683,
0.0037881136,
0.0446891412,
0.0053400318,
-0.0159109533,
0.0138238901,
-0.025665924,
0.01487255,
0.010075571,
-0.0057332013,
-0.0075519863,
0.0056104301,
0.0362010859,
0.0594638325,
-0.0287418198,
0.0117735602,
0.0041684709,
-0.0020873165,
0.032686688,
-0.0324764885,
0.0340404622,
0.032829307,
-0.0117308991,
-0.0096454164,
0.0080644386,
0.0011681613,
-0.0242033601,
0.0567849651,
0.0004130345,
-0.0406213179,
0.041631151,
0.0414910764,
-0.0380650871,
0.0102430899,
0.0702486634,
0.0352965742,
0.0509637184,
0.0294509586,
-0.0862667486,
-0.0772477388,
0.0125744445,
-0.0679558665,
0.0372578688,
-0.0305565745,
-0.053652104,
0.0479962379,
-0.0323763192,
-0.0196964797,
0.0045297202,
0.0045610247,
-0.0206845608,
0.0211640149,
0.0123805376,
0.0013294395,
0.0045146616,
-0.0123433582,
0.0660204962,
-0.0834665075,
-0.0306302533,
0.0028832857,
0.0072190501,
0.0090963244,
0.0439669192,
0.0091640241,
-0.0123145804,
0.0941653699,
-0.0689035282,
-0.032503292,
-0.0080158981,
0.0076892991,
-0.0127274022,
0.0219042357,
-0.0511091463,
0.0080987271,
-0.0220113061,
-0.021110395,
-0.0083779404,
-0.0294742361,
0.0601831302,
-0.0035967866,
0.0407767296,
-0.0051514194,
0.0306047909,
0.0496180169,
-0.0410722159,
0.0156829581,
0.0156248407,
0.015528691,
-0.0067139887,
-0.0305596814,
-0.0174066015,
-0.0286094975,
0.0032736466,
0.022671964,
0.0069099707,
-0.0452587046,
0.0295541231,
-0.0080584707,
-0.056260746,
-0.0044881124,
0.0276985224,
0.0216496922,
0.0380475894,
0.03648334,
0.0014195141,
0.0037695323,
-0.0235377662,
0.0139911305,
0.0294957552,
-0.0294258241,
-0.0902593806,
-0.0483992621,
0.0673647374,
0.0404046737,
-0.0073685134,
-0.0336140394,
-0.0351718627,
-0.0362178721,
0.0644414425,
0.0176322684,
-0.0509249642,
-0.0260678157,
-0.0118348813,
-0.0011738114,
0.0133256875,
-0.0120287202,
-0.0160643756,
-0.0186355375,
0.0070039649,
0.0239909012,
0.0433451757,
0.014528729,
0.0557454042,
-0.0063509191,
-0.0320901982,
-0.0176517367,
0.0204991791,
-0.0563607514,
0.1062924713,
0.0428226963,
-0.0134117994,
0.0414348356,
0.0367405973,
-0.0501963086,
0.0451278836,
0.0088713476,
0.0552096777,
0.014915227,
-0.0474768132,
0.0456824936,
0.052530732,
0.0399253517,
-0.0020629989,
0.0294790156,
0.0414453112,
0.0493028164,
-0.0336798877,
0.0031253507,
-0.024674587,
0.0030123212,
-0.0320172124,
0.0297884829,
0.0037367132,
0.0168087613,
0.0056388061,
-0.0330020264,
-0.0026707489,
0.0100355474,
0.0170229506,
-0.0118779195,
-0.0337150805,
-0.049495995,
0.0388585329,
0.0070894896,
-0.0303171854,
-0.0007994205,
-0.0067312713,
0.0023573111,
0.0343983285,
0.0060048094,
-0.0491354726,
-0.0094150389,
0.0343793668,
0.0338164344,
-0.0093303882,
-0.010050809,
0.0167629439,
-0.0443147235,
0.0672827363,
0.0759776533,
-0.0207026675,
0.0263111088,
0.0153707219,
0.0005875453,
0.0544867478,
-0.0663735345,
0.0067616655,
-0.0294388235,
0.0080273049,
-0.0011029355,
-0.0373302922,
0.0210081395,
-0.0306189638,
-0.0158414096,
-0.0598658584,
0.0084876707,
0.0567068048,
0.0295728687,
-0.027800519,
-0.0091926297,
0.049909886,
0.0067468048,
-0.0113978237,
-0.0138036385,
-0.0941515416,
-0.0167115889,
-0.0080522513,
0.0114346882,
0.0026662189,
-0.0731129795,
-0.0140327141,
-0.0724880621,
0.0199957192,
-0.0197234619,
-0.0558335856,
-0.0474771895,
-0.0668452755,
0.0213564206,
-0.0261890627,
0.0029066021,
0.0164841004,
-0.0508670509,
-0.0028137714,
0.0067206291,
-0.024735298,
-0.1062581837,
0.0301397629,
0.0034874468,
0.0143419923,
0.0016438523,
0.0306077935,
-0.0454368517,
0.014287685,
-0.0081664566,
-0.0326058641,
-0.0721423253,
-0.0479917675,
0.0356280059,
-0.0143208746,
-0.0089182509,
0.0161527954,
0.0547365211,
-0.0468782,
-0.0316365846,
0.0254274178,
0.0547925085,
0.0296076238,
0.0280421991,
-0.0497457907,
-0.021945592,
-0.0050567952,
0.059159182,
-0.0247968975,
-0.0286160186,
-0.1068117693,
0.0298521053,
-0.0039550331,
0.0041693565,
-0.0438975245,
-0.01235939,
-0.077192314,
-0.0034692907,
-0.0640586838,
-0.0126632713,
0.0313978232,
0.0229324847,
-0.0063976403,
-0.029196173,
0.0472833999,
0.0448836312,
-0.0850473493,
0.0021664428,
0.0154616088,
0.0010466514,
-0.0271903779,
0.0094477339,
0.0511473157,
0.0206956416,
-0.0426032133,
0.0412723236,
0.0068465173,
-0.0468209535,
0.0181448609,
0.0000503108,
0.0200626645,
0.0146427276,
-0.0118973851,
-0.025677219,
0.0115120001,
0.0561103299,
-0.0502017699,
-0.0247284956,
-0.0107853096,
-0.0128954193,
-0.0182315949,
0.0022174346,
0.0044523431,
0.0291857179,
-0.0593489185,
0.040648289,
-0.00682142,
-0.0598644577,
0.0337889232,
0.0195863396,
0.0298451316,
0.0091549307,
0.0396915525,
-0.0446321853,
0.0169150289,
-0.0104911197,
0.0097186686,
-0.0206126794,
0.0359256305,
-0.0018163216,
-0.0465119556,
-0.0425947793,
0.0183495954,
0.0155401118,
0.06316939,
0.0018116705,
-0.0028714899,
-0.0133237299,
0.0330825374,
0.0464188457,
-0.0533541329,
0.0081440154,
-0.0100094071,
-0.0407537371,
0.0432097837,
-0.0472328402,
0.005761113,
0.0120480824,
0.0217245948,
-0.0488024615,
0.0250360481,
-0.0393001474,
-0.005781088,
-0.0453617387,
0.0121120261,
-0.0189832766,
-0.0019624906,
0.0581095219,
-0.0260242,
-0.0386091471,
0.001917685,
0.055068437,
-0.0403477922,
0.0403815657,
0.0249983575,
0.0277773757,
-0.0318345316,
-0.0197002571,
0.0573415346,
0.0664314777,
-0.0101622501,
0.0085827289,
-0.0237829573,
-0.0543311276,
-0.0380273014,
-0.0391010456,
0.0045240321,
-0.0180690493,
-0.0137293655,
-0.0629240349,
0.0047856071,
0.0080836583,
0.0288627483,
-0.0223204307,
0.0244511329,
-0.0451214984,
0.050782714,
0.0232734662,
-0.0457148477,
-0.0304093659,
0.0365274735,
-0.0242265724,
-0.0378686115,
0.0020088451,
-6.170826655e-33,
-0.0216969345,
-0.0076046539,
-0.0198622961,
0.0337959379,
-0.0207358915,
0.0121806189,
-0.0348414592,
-0.0338086113,
0.019734269,
0.0554833338,
-0.0025207223,
-0.01035548,
0.0085906507,
0.0223473124,
0.0261160657,
-0.008885555,
-0.0121393539,
0.0378861688,
0.0068757255,
0.012664089,
0.0459471457,
0.0606980287,
0.0815802589,
-0.0915955156,
0.0325935632,
0.0195917748,
0.0421281122,
-0.049828086,
0.0150114242,
0.0564655028,
-0.0691582486,
-0.0048964773,
0.002516245,
-0.0604560561,
-0.0004089721,
-0.003653697,
-0.1488973349,
0.0073643881,
-0.0275518969,
-0.0116141867,
-0.0456300564,
0.0062276446,
0.0148814078,
0.0011244471,
-0.0135671366,
-0.0230476931,
0.0556694902,
-0.0439774022,
-0.0283584632,
-0.068336226,
-0.0898205489,
-0.0111107705,
0.0306452196,
0.0678434893,
0.0619067177,
-0.0232734364,
-0.0026364126,
0.0911551043,
-0.0409872606,
-0.0029139179,
-0.0301883351,
0.0528965369,
0.0017724844,
-0.0025764154,
0.0256627146,
0.0059903008,
-0.0226287674,
-0.0162479188,
0.0271546952,
0.0244427491,
0.0011644871,
0.0493370891,
0.015033531,
0.0499505214,
0.0596920066,
0.0367217883,
-0.1005022451,
0.0040871873,
0.0049232896,
0.0215280652,
-0.0186963677,
-0.0125503652,
0.0134879909,
0.0291765686,
-0.0049703694,
0.0214986186,
0.0131652197,
0.0001956056,
-0.0310672894,
-0.007010885,
-0.0977817029,
0.0594724305,
-0.0239409581,
-0.0196053721,
-0.0667623132,
0.0424963795,
-0.0230106004,
0.0327811763,
-0.0076819314,
-0.0082008308,
-0.0933083817,
-0.0420147665,
-0.0269666165,
-0.0085684638,
0.0213948693,
-0.0360738151,
0.0084183859,
-0.0127061792,
-0.0169851072,
-0.0365556702,
-0.0097958073,
0.0213635061,
-0.0182757396,
0.0249915645,
-0.0206851885,
0.0337007716,
-0.0004028317,
0.0128086917,
0.0404222272,
0.0471722484,
0.0170052126,
0.0268490072,
0.0354048535,
0.0083836187,
-0.0038220666,
-0.0126099763,
-0.0320361219,
-0.0115845669,
-0.0081727104,
-0.01732824,
0.0219776537,
0.0146060139,
2.633e-7,
0.0580584146,
0.0305124391,
0.0542729162,
0.0064170966,
-0.0164227411,
0.0035369771,
0.0106232967,
0.02553121,
-0.0541063994,
-0.0406586863,
0.0447029211,
-0.0295001473,
0.0188671947,
-0.000323765,
-0.0878969058,
-0.0191436093,
-0.0068401666,
-0.0837654099,
-0.0826465264,
0.0153887002,
0.0492965318,
0.0403888188,
0.0059274426,
-0.0339843147,
-0.0159443393,
0.0367775075,
0.0328007601,
-0.0271688867,
0.0206873361,
0.0641253814,
0.0414962061,
-0.0073490702,
-0.0137591446,
0.0152108893,
-0.0210448653,
0.0320542976,
0.0046461653,
0.0494174995,
0.0143275764,
0.0019210452,
0.0155114895,
-0.0448584855,
0.0554938652,
0.0194603559,
0.0411904715,
-0.0362051018,
-0.0163777284,
-0.0240506362,
-0.0321751945,
0.0326498523,
-0.0187628381,
-0.0177151449,
0.0014090033,
0.0210304558,
0.0014843155,
-0.0172398854,
-0.0156064052,
-0.088023372,
0.0418049581,
0.0479964986,
0.0033460804,
0.012076037,
0.0370273963,
-0.0212456938,
-0.0010103114,
-0.077749297,
-0.0041099242,
2.514523154e-34,
0.0126763154,
0.0126807354,
-0.0304112472,
0.0761186108,
0.0266158581,
-0.0193782393,
-0.0291195661,
0.0003294542,
-0.0763603374,
-0.0680511147,
0.0260542091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07703v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07703v2 | Measuring Entrainment in Spontaneous Code-switched Speech | 2023-11-13T19:41:34 | 2024-03-26T15:31:34 | Debasmita Bhattacharya, Siying Ding, Alayna Nguyen, Julia Hirschberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | It is well-known that speakers who entrain to one another have more
successful conversations than those who do not. Previous research has shown
that interlocutors entrain on linguistic features in both written and spoken
monolingual domains. More recent work on code-switched communication has also
shown preliminary evidence of entrainment on certain aspects of code-switching
(CSW). However, such studies of entrainment in code-switched domains have been
extremely few and restricted to human-machine textual interactions. Our work
studies code-switched spontaneous speech between humans, finding that (1)
patterns of written and spoken entrainment in monolingual settings largely
generalize to code-switched settings, and (2) some patterns of entrainment on
code-switching in dialogue agent-generated text generalize to spontaneous
code-switched speech. Our findings give rise to important implications for the
potentially "universal" nature of entrainment as a communication phenomenon,
and potential applications in inclusive and interactive speech technology. | [
0.0118280854,
-0.0077555855,
-0.0509768613,
0.0241774395,
-0.028139241,
-0.0030199075,
0.0030917344,
0.013088394,
-0.0260272548,
-0.0380396992,
-0.0756847635,
0.0130798807,
0.0568191186,
0.0215684809,
0.0456638671,
-0.0291549116,
0.0458095931,
-0.0488225929,
-0.0144602023,
0.0170382503,
0.0305935796,
-0.0042617125,
-0.0361074395,
0.0263070166,
-0.0105154933,
-0.0124295354,
-0.0438413844,
0.0380228944,
-0.0314888842,
-0.0152195347,
0.0129838549,
0.0284483172,
0.0205624755,
-0.0248155743,
0.0000017089,
-0.0151201738,
0.0216919407,
-0.0508672185,
-0.0459147468,
0.0051293592,
-0.0096821068,
0.0045725591,
-0.0032328283,
0.0361377746,
-0.0334741846,
0.0047160746,
0.0396148786,
0.0007673251,
0.0096506206,
0.0409656465,
-0.0030428204,
0.0308895502,
-0.0076116472,
-0.0090767406,
-0.0434807576,
-0.018358374,
0.0114037385,
-0.0705219507,
-0.0035363194,
-0.0357543454,
-0.0578425489,
0.0089988848,
0.0119297467,
0.0005941384,
0.0274262372,
-0.0022687968,
-0.0453579761,
-0.015481459,
-0.0283110589,
0.0367643908,
0.0323672444,
-0.0009412081,
0.0189358816,
-0.0032864257,
0.0173817538,
-0.0140672717,
0.0308262054,
0.0105339121,
-0.0110225715,
-0.0031383033,
-0.0264054537,
0.0027772209,
-0.0046739797,
-0.034514714,
-0.0243262276,
0.0716056079,
-0.005220829,
-0.0506540574,
0.0086475248,
0.0022702261,
0.0783737898,
-0.0809461698,
0.0135371713,
-0.0222262014,
-0.018961953,
0.0184222125,
-0.0395788476,
-0.0294237621,
-0.0180847142,
-0.0057033747,
-0.0122410124,
0.0063104839,
-0.0368599147,
-0.0199809447,
0.042075891,
0.0287554637,
0.010322623,
-0.0102676153,
0.0115914298,
0.0413744934,
-0.0323679522,
-0.035517443,
-0.0790657401,
-0.0412037782,
0.015795676,
-0.0074276575,
-0.0244254004,
0.0230453443,
-0.0091232937,
-0.0378023013,
-0.0568453856,
-0.0419739038,
-0.0204363875,
0.0381457321,
0.0059616556,
0.0014670505,
-0.0405845419,
0.0268189125,
0.0178044122,
-0.1110830158,
0.0211221371,
0.0052807587,
-0.0044377893,
-0.0025075453,
-0.0130485231,
0.037186306,
-0.0406423584,
-0.0275106244,
-0.0121576358,
0.0049531655,
-0.0025443416,
-0.051834859,
0.0067123561,
-0.0364030041,
-0.0188345537,
0.0204999615,
0.0315735862,
-0.0483907647,
-0.0179268792,
-0.0025787794,
-0.010334543,
0.0525570922,
-0.0494573228,
0.0512637906,
0.0553613827,
-0.0111252405,
-0.0023507848,
0.0783977732,
0.0593241528,
-0.0735837072,
0.0596352927,
-0.0794506073,
0.0357082523,
0.0452546328,
-0.0074154953,
-0.003528089,
0.0003822717,
-0.0257859807,
0.0593882389,
0.004151687,
0.0523980297,
-0.01797642,
-0.0601044707,
-0.009978571,
0.0311304089,
0.0567156561,
0.0172078256,
-0.0100680226,
-0.0045914357,
0.0361707397,
0.0028176249,
0.0432944372,
0.0005699894,
0.0012444423,
0.0051455381,
-0.0250240322,
0.0461026095,
0.0086215204,
-0.0243659727,
0.0058409674,
0.0009558816,
-0.0165049862,
0.0653598532,
-0.0590167642,
0.0099323066,
0.0267396625,
0.0074758171,
0.0165009703,
0.0197047554,
-0.0561118983,
-0.0007944575,
-0.0471644588,
-0.0497039184,
0.0787281841,
-0.0287834052,
0.0292223059,
0.0211591125,
-0.0185754076,
0.0063281404,
0.0692268014,
0.0053808298,
0.0193866994,
0.0157881454,
-0.0276843477,
0.0389750004,
-0.001054637,
-0.0074394285,
0.0146428617,
-0.0231903233,
0.0630778596,
-0.0440563299,
0.0321690924,
0.0335560441,
-0.0151374303,
-0.0419738069,
0.0530877933,
0.0157899503,
0.0055759945,
0.0172612946,
-0.0220985301,
-0.0630336776,
0.0128101744,
-0.0269447621,
0.0149495192,
-0.0188194476,
0.088767074,
-0.0162773728,
-0.0194952656,
-0.0194052104,
-0.0470418595,
-0.0256582927,
0.0126355924,
0.0664794743,
-0.0443040766,
0.0710967705,
-0.0440135784,
0.0821221098,
-0.0120092016,
0.0424604602,
-0.0117526278,
0.0336978137,
0.0217529237,
-0.0539318323,
0.0224246867,
0.007429726,
0.0051224255,
-0.0058406405,
0.0114679933,
-0.0607347675,
0.0166340899,
0.0687035248,
-0.0391423628,
0.0011174197,
-0.0244903881,
-0.0045968569,
-0.0402703211,
-0.0129960943,
-0.0925765559,
-0.0110491645,
-0.013163168,
0.0130069219,
0.0089819031,
-0.0214930903,
-0.0434049517,
-0.0314586051,
-0.0352343284,
0.0195543449,
-0.0230742879,
0.0281089116,
-0.0061392034,
-0.0207365789,
-0.0146960244,
-0.0294644125,
0.0279382616,
0.0138990581,
-0.0051538288,
-0.018304456,
-0.0232471656,
-0.111014083,
0.0034723196,
0.0187374111,
0.0079819774,
-0.0089276349,
-0.0503384173,
0.0624726005,
0.0492919497,
0.0425510518,
0.0329246558,
0.0353201963,
0.0108794561,
0.0125260605,
-0.0328480825,
-0.0419398546,
-0.0056952853,
0.0544156618,
-0.0235865898,
-0.0402385592,
-0.0411802493,
0.0273501165,
0.0607116632,
0.0324640796,
0.0375411958,
-0.0564735942,
-0.0502616428,
-0.036172308,
-0.0759100318,
-0.0000933794,
-0.0679714903,
-0.0372437648,
0.0769357905,
0.0105671398,
-0.0555797815,
0.0244049765,
-0.0218583029,
-0.0636158884,
-0.0321996324,
-0.0148814013,
0.0351311713,
-0.0159786586,
-0.0312150735,
-0.017696064,
0.074930422,
-0.0557196029,
-0.0064625135,
0.0061912788,
0.0014769525,
0.0128818089,
0.0274302997,
-0.0405867212,
-0.0205627214,
0.0284614246,
-0.070901759,
-0.0152087919,
-0.01888429,
-0.0070150364,
-0.0101391459,
0.0517310798,
-0.0332657173,
0.0639621243,
0.0095320595,
0.0007491096,
0.0369803198,
-0.0061744601,
0.0044765337,
0.0016871018,
0.007347377,
-0.0025134445,
0.0229352452,
-0.0116764717,
-0.0283594094,
-0.0179715361,
0.0136140566,
0.0136588952,
0.0581041351,
0.0041414397,
-0.0039541107,
0.0309016425,
-0.0058576381,
-0.0678539947,
0.0141352927,
0.0579935797,
0.0030107701,
-0.0157558545,
0.0628934801,
0.0153894043,
-0.0652382001,
-0.0011464661,
-0.0294183567,
0.0428523421,
0.0235107951,
0.0212808345,
-0.088210687,
0.0024033084,
0.0320411362,
0.0400860086,
-0.035519626,
0.0183784496,
-0.0173020307,
-0.0758248419,
0.0267292708,
0.0049693114,
-0.0776790008,
-0.0250721276,
-0.0192356165,
0.0256691091,
0.0483483188,
0.0075357966,
0.0135622174,
-0.0426867381,
-0.0037207946,
0.0086415522,
-0.0548841767,
0.0068880673,
-0.0213986486,
-0.00220118,
0.0824043378,
0.0750066563,
-0.0040903548,
-0.029541539,
-0.0297831297,
0.015160053,
-0.0104249837,
0.0487616248,
-0.0080515565,
0.0409334674,
-0.0227625277,
-0.0231616292,
-0.0035336639,
0.0328140222,
-0.0070225266,
-0.0103283878,
0.0457619764,
0.0060291039,
-0.0343238488,
-0.0347152129,
0.0355319232,
0.0354642719,
0.0516118556,
0.0029241929,
0.0565518923,
-0.1103261709,
0.0155451829,
-0.0173042398,
0.0516317263,
0.0135976309,
-0.0164620019,
-0.0011818876,
0.0080935722,
-0.0510763042,
-0.0791606456,
-0.0410784185,
-0.0098120365,
0.0334444754,
0.0026704276,
0.00067591,
0.0425624251,
0.0123709682,
0.0013296232,
-0.042587176,
0.0169266574,
0.0584234111,
-0.0575521812,
-0.0859673321,
0.0095287804,
-0.0487681367,
0.0071726488,
-0.0480786413,
-0.0177947469,
-0.04080927,
0.0393779427,
-0.0424639918,
0.0217720065,
0.0580935515,
0.0073592146,
-0.0396345481,
-0.0400470234,
-0.0187496506,
-0.0475799404,
0.0822718069,
0.0755764246,
0.0102374339,
-0.0064522536,
0.012706033,
0.0233919751,
-0.0201461632,
-0.0238959827,
-0.0436728559,
-0.051866807,
-0.056543529,
-0.0311981905,
-0.0343349241,
0.0404445603,
0.0005264183,
0.0148761114,
-0.0244777277,
0.0479343645,
0.0305356663,
0.0050549721,
-0.0437324569,
-0.0656750128,
0.0048312587,
0.03931446,
-0.0148373768,
0.0118070422,
-0.0688891858,
0.0012783129,
0.0311919283,
0.0482482128,
0.0420703478,
0.0969794691,
0.0199418887,
0.0498972572,
0.0205237679,
0.0357217863,
0.0081448862,
0.0244314056,
-0.0152705833,
0.0845999122,
0.0334078334,
-0.0429492146,
0.0432390794,
0.0356710814,
-0.0298289172,
-0.0179235581,
0.0718698055,
0.0045836815,
0.0210350417,
0.0292538851,
0.0495984592,
0.0029228958,
0.0402727015,
0.0189153571,
0.0362438746,
-0.0477684326,
-0.0127824312,
0.0157812554,
-0.0185371637,
-0.0343647674,
0.016628515,
0.0513431728,
-0.0098737972,
0.0239243209,
-0.0380189382,
0.0433951169,
-0.0097847786,
-0.0011332859,
0.0375211537,
0.0076285577,
0.0078814123,
0.0009461367,
-0.0140061034,
-0.0490257218,
0.0341679156,
-0.0002033488,
0.0467009023,
-0.0462724902,
0.0277193394,
0.0496449582,
-0.0203779098,
-0.0125612561,
-0.0316814557,
-0.0126119861,
0.0469938964,
-0.0027015219,
-0.0209244024,
-5.299214859e-33,
-0.0245852191,
-0.0132639715,
-0.0101662725,
0.0328351296,
-0.0478011668,
-0.0504094325,
-0.0375525691,
0.0387418531,
0.0202202834,
-0.004763592,
-0.0454477221,
0.0264343191,
0.0162250511,
-0.0103716431,
0.0567394234,
-0.0115308808,
0.0334206149,
-0.0049327612,
-0.0170563497,
0.0165601,
0.0134053556,
-0.0029601506,
0.0340714827,
-0.0503552258,
0.0124923782,
0.0012185482,
-0.0087756654,
-0.0555312634,
-0.0036966105,
-0.0213435479,
0.0176946744,
0.0183032379,
0.0336493514,
-0.0295299776,
-0.0149805872,
0.0853471756,
0.0046740533,
-0.016513614,
0.0126837287,
0.0609935746,
-0.0331326276,
-0.0247784741,
0.0273219906,
-0.0159867834,
-0.0168189872,
0.0269043073,
0.0331284404,
0.0122322962,
0.0394013003,
0.0405226946,
-0.0630554184,
0.0099558942,
-0.0320762731,
-0.0313808136,
-0.0227346718,
0.0680502355,
-0.0333490707,
-0.0904566422,
-0.0576367117,
0.0662007555,
0.0130852377,
-0.0023535357,
-0.0095557878,
0.0199908819,
0.0234831963,
0.0235145129,
0.0961964056,
0.0430170782,
0.0474484935,
-0.0082547255,
0.0717236251,
0.0018572072,
0.0059785824,
0.0421825796,
0.0016556322,
-0.0572873317,
0.0185508691,
-0.0579406619,
0.0411664434,
-0.0260791965,
-0.0295103341,
0.0349892862,
-0.0227842852,
-0.0580858551,
-0.0331837982,
-0.0250849873,
0.010495632,
-0.0417076685,
0.0530420728,
-0.0183827579,
0.0494909883,
-0.010690527,
0.0474223197,
0.0013585307,
-0.0185650457,
0.0070965867,
-0.0271188039,
0.0623404495,
0.014034898,
0.008525826,
-0.0890297592,
0.0016932624,
0.0347828083,
0.0403941497,
0.0633242279,
0.0170596745,
-0.00949251,
0.0231556036,
-0.0592316762,
0.0014620201,
0.0041583888,
0.023332132,
-0.0015671242,
-0.0189792514,
0.0193238575,
0.036413461,
-0.0317760035,
0.0338734724,
-0.0485589616,
-0.0467619784,
-0.0954689011,
-0.0341374315,
-0.024303278,
0.0471362732,
-0.0413246155,
0.0058879205,
-0.0495402142,
0.0207848009,
0.0415729731,
-0.035743203,
-0.0091332253,
-0.0169127584,
2.502e-7,
-0.0223088302,
0.0262225419,
0.0140598649,
-0.0006607929,
0.0612646267,
0.0101360418,
-0.0405166,
0.0350287631,
0.0619571507,
0.0358219557,
-0.0456750058,
-0.016182445,
0.065994069,
0.0094543202,
-0.0745565146,
-0.0643019304,
-0.020829577,
0.0364980772,
-0.0035457646,
-0.0053338152,
0.0383403413,
-0.0054464387,
-0.0178490151,
0.0156752728,
0.0060071531,
-0.0019499557,
0.0033223741,
-0.0351328552,
0.0502933264,
-0.0199020002,
-0.0901438072,
0.0036715718,
-0.0134084374,
0.0755541027,
-0.0081412653,
0.0194444936,
0.0102671506,
0.0498398729,
-0.0322579071,
-0.0218853503,
-0.0150787542,
0.0330330245,
-0.092087388,
0.0091634095,
0.0366013423,
-0.0156443845,
0.0069148554,
0.012697394,
-0.0132984621,
0.0074566761,
-0.0023731627,
-0.0259181354,
-0.0310298018,
0.0606967583,
0.0101180794,
0.0486767925,
-0.0059453864,
-0.0077225491,
0.0186636094,
-0.011960784,
-0.0359716676,
-0.0628280416,
-0.0385024101,
0.0045584599,
0.0092045553,
0.0107346093,
0.0079377042,
1.246710712e-34,
0.0136499759,
0.0169036165,
0.0535829253,
0.0515444353,
0.0108724935,
-0.0178955682,
0.0579198897,
0.0487129018,
0.0332120061,
0.0000250153,
0.0049947482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07700v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07700v1 | AuthentiGPT: Detecting Machine-Generated Text via Black-Box Language Models Denoising | 2023-11-13T19:36:54 | 2023-11-13T19:36:54 | Zhen Guo, Shangdi Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have opened up enormous opportunities while
simultaneously posing ethical dilemmas. One of the major concerns is their
ability to create text that closely mimics human writing, which can lead to
potential misuse, such as academic misconduct, disinformation, and fraud. To
address this problem, we present AuthentiGPT, an efficient classifier that
distinguishes between machine-generated and human-written texts. Under the
assumption that human-written text resides outside the distribution of
machine-generated text, AuthentiGPT leverages a black-box LLM to denoise input
text with artificially added noise, and then semantically compares the denoised
text with the original to determine if the content is machine-generated. With
only one trainable parameter, AuthentiGPT eliminates the need for a large
training dataset, watermarking the LLM's output, or computing the
log-likelihood. Importantly, the detection capability of AuthentiGPT can be
easily adapted to any generative language model. With a 0.918 AUROC score on a
domain-specific dataset, AuthentiGPT demonstrates its effectiveness over other
commercial algorithms, highlighting its potential for detecting
machine-generated text in academic settings. | [
0.055114314,
0.0912391692,
-0.0081440406,
0.0478408299,
-0.0429851338,
0.0096669141,
0.0553811044,
0.0448503867,
-0.0095243109,
-0.0292756222,
-0.0009272179,
-0.0014085894,
-0.0048604687,
0.0465693809,
0.0335539356,
0.0404771268,
0.0049430938,
0.0162489116,
0.0521758161,
-0.0102641713,
0.0080796517,
0.0296248328,
0.0318215899,
0.0390835479,
-0.0087750889,
-0.0264133625,
0.0342046618,
0.0118220923,
0.0188344046,
0.0161807314,
0.0142699331,
0.0606213771,
-0.0131778,
0.0907343253,
0.0000020211,
-0.0296230763,
-0.0260313284,
0.0198887456,
-0.0218060147,
0.0324031189,
0.0869685784,
0.0332976691,
-0.0138632609,
0.0333844461,
-0.0383271463,
0.005219264,
0.0114000663,
0.045940388,
0.0233743377,
0.0845039561,
-0.0383534282,
0.0062756371,
0.0526888967,
-0.0070279585,
0.0008875614,
0.0214785319,
0.0445045047,
-0.0178282633,
-0.0222989246,
0.0355174951,
0.0303147957,
0.0274043456,
0.0014394107,
-0.0493158102,
0.0075184805,
0.0098081306,
-0.0154193267,
-0.0310158674,
0.0229287874,
0.024030637,
-0.0302083176,
-0.0529406406,
0.0586110316,
0.0089826565,
0.0201549605,
0.036857672,
0.0307774562,
0.071454972,
-0.0323750973,
0.0036917324,
0.0067618517,
0.0018656671,
0.0243827011,
0.06493368,
0.0717508271,
0.0058867126,
0.0168904215,
-0.0380311087,
-0.0305286981,
-0.0071550021,
0.0318114348,
-0.0443180688,
0.0455128476,
0.026741147,
0.0237640422,
-0.0073997113,
-0.0718178898,
-0.0624955706,
0.0387814641,
-0.0027992765,
0.0134772332,
-0.0108223418,
-0.0141119761,
0.0269593075,
-0.0619621575,
0.0285622068,
-0.0157901645,
0.0260760747,
-0.0050662742,
0.043966271,
0.0290578082,
-0.0091196746,
-0.0023296878,
0.0107307332,
-0.0287201721,
-0.0192920342,
-0.0639569238,
0.002941848,
-0.0192939136,
0.0284144878,
-0.0447362438,
0.0074922126,
-0.0245870426,
-0.0177940074,
0.0195350144,
-0.0521367043,
0.0265737362,
0.0424525216,
-0.0178300459,
-0.0283994451,
-0.0013399391,
0.0725120381,
0.0199823193,
0.0209013801,
0.0145166162,
0.0690919086,
-0.005601482,
-0.0106076999,
-0.0306976531,
-0.0743487254,
-0.0272192694,
-0.0495423265,
0.0114154583,
-0.0347496122,
-0.035418734,
-0.0292639714,
-0.0204511266,
-0.0815277621,
0.0137490109,
0.017464174,
0.0207449272,
0.0412879623,
-0.0181889031,
-0.0139578423,
0.0521806441,
0.014769678,
0.0121468566,
0.0117765479,
0.0322465114,
0.0862436518,
0.036254853,
0.0023319679,
0.035291601,
0.0445997007,
0.0494840927,
0.018281972,
-0.0178935006,
-0.0499785207,
-0.0066527254,
0.0103599727,
0.0289076529,
0.0548191667,
-0.005487253,
-0.0438484326,
0.0840724409,
0.0467176326,
-0.0274577383,
-0.0016617209,
0.0222974773,
0.0334657282,
0.0024303384,
0.0150459679,
0.0071417163,
-0.0396416113,
-0.0664866343,
-0.020560788,
0.0355830379,
0.0073775165,
0.0221256744,
-0.0552915819,
0.0017997026,
-0.0401741229,
-0.0043537277,
-0.0283286031,
0.0216555893,
0.0232941881,
-0.049565997,
-0.0481046699,
0.008696937,
-0.0403769426,
0.0050504734,
-0.0904441103,
0.0882534161,
0.0402728096,
0.06839782,
-0.0121756149,
0.0815349817,
-0.0832197815,
-0.0398759432,
0.0890279338,
-0.0405576937,
-0.0064304811,
-0.0253216811,
-0.0389088169,
-0.0437767357,
-0.0130274603,
0.005351156,
0.0149555551,
0.0364026017,
0.0065664491,
0.0293942466,
-0.0073323655,
-0.0875652358,
0.0336438119,
-0.0462170094,
-0.0491824672,
0.0281502381,
-0.0150763439,
0.0223605167,
-0.0053086146,
-0.0320214294,
0.0193198342,
0.0349491276,
-0.0585911646,
-0.0457312837,
-0.0369613506,
0.0061235274,
0.0113384575,
0.0177699402,
-0.0517752245,
-0.0093818875,
0.0294251088,
-0.0144463237,
0.0135843996,
0.0099274954,
-0.0373953171,
0.0032147837,
-0.0807861984,
0.0234032404,
-0.02026066,
0.0415333584,
-0.0264246743,
0.0496191196,
-0.0237085596,
0.0148186609,
0.0213925652,
-0.0186438505,
0.0176188461,
0.0086021982,
-0.0207219794,
-0.030911684,
-0.0328329019,
0.0132407285,
0.02482583,
0.0124031818,
-0.011898906,
-0.0185150485,
0.0050267084,
-0.0166363437,
-0.0099462233,
-0.0182601567,
0.0185328349,
-0.0282530691,
0.0035256802,
0.0026967383,
-0.0255350992,
-0.0386953168,
0.0271065645,
-0.0250129085,
0.0385391451,
-0.0415070318,
0.0226184446,
-0.0175429322,
0.0181313735,
0.0069126314,
0.0278443489,
0.0629575253,
-0.0049715312,
-0.078156136,
0.0829340145,
0.0066794655,
-0.0132273789,
0.0016414475,
-0.0289666206,
-0.0199402571,
-0.0065596765,
-0.0004295828,
0.0735752061,
0.0379708894,
0.010444616,
0.0285736732,
0.0696852356,
-0.0089154169,
-0.0252028573,
-0.0080128945,
0.032054849,
-0.0108221965,
-0.0786193684,
0.0305796601,
0.0205165725,
0.0129126376,
-0.0011221681,
-0.0089739272,
0.0491363369,
-0.0124769006,
-0.0544025823,
-0.0049018743,
-0.0436662696,
-0.0421888381,
0.027588414,
-0.0297703687,
-0.0630908981,
0.0477135293,
-0.0442977883,
0.0333851725,
0.0102689825,
-0.0283514671,
0.0184141938,
0.0001999108,
0.026346283,
0.0327030085,
0.0208829511,
-0.0043270518,
-0.0115092378,
0.0034151387,
0.0847131759,
-0.0508013368,
-0.0141864009,
-0.0203800816,
0.0116190268,
-0.0100464644,
-0.0048612286,
-0.0509604625,
-0.0338402651,
0.0247816686,
-0.0126618985,
0.0233645327,
-0.0436220691,
-0.0469653234,
-0.0188823678,
0.014609348,
0.0537267029,
-0.0407895185,
0.0007049174,
-0.0090309372,
0.078775458,
0.0429674983,
-0.0597249866,
0.0008954212,
-0.0295789521,
-0.0150377434,
0.0593147837,
-0.0384542421,
0.0494915396,
0.0172235351,
-0.0504311733,
0.01086454,
0.0154210236,
0.0180288367,
0.008290126,
0.0087755211,
-0.0413905941,
-0.0009210389,
0.1028363332,
-0.0238216575,
-0.0373373404,
-0.0154687287,
-0.0025333548,
0.0337719619,
-0.0107577201,
-0.0247012842,
-0.0976604074,
-0.0087043662,
-0.0041009281,
0.0320288688,
-0.0648945048,
-0.0257382002,
-0.0030927001,
-0.0791624114,
0.0384880602,
0.0178287402,
-0.0228182934,
-0.0112032583,
-0.0460468754,
-0.0215381347,
0.0013924323,
0.0007107808,
-0.0397145338,
0.0086754179,
-0.0112784859,
0.0132517871,
-0.0357954763,
-0.0500831641,
-0.029769253,
-0.0008755101,
0.0487741455,
0.0353006199,
0.0348476619,
-0.0457698517,
-0.0698505342,
-0.0039516459,
0.0315962248,
-0.0299968421,
-0.0126521001,
0.0691972449,
-0.0166630968,
-0.0201950464,
-0.0144178346,
0.0710232854,
-0.0278051309,
-0.0068555563,
0.016355399,
0.0472708642,
0.0017728526,
-0.0437781923,
-0.0479990989,
0.0007596678,
0.0243498906,
0.0660936609,
0.0213448498,
-0.0378213003,
-0.0516128577,
-0.0364673808,
0.0308502614,
-0.0499346107,
-0.0370377265,
0.0052546184,
-0.0144933797,
-0.0669220313,
-0.0642898753,
-0.0192431305,
-0.0332013182,
-0.0185587071,
0.0333593786,
0.0078092469,
0.0071197459,
-0.0391420349,
-0.0805856436,
-0.0162639096,
-0.0409620814,
0.0323405005,
-0.0244541578,
-0.0224368144,
-0.0157224853,
-0.0202725977,
-0.0133188143,
0.0516746305,
-0.0380468406,
-0.0502548702,
0.0262309127,
0.0184101816,
0.0171627197,
0.0219819304,
-0.0066905143,
-0.0310763661,
0.0904523879,
0.0374346711,
-0.030614011,
0.0050268029,
0.0329711251,
-0.0506173633,
-0.0093630971,
-0.0060153613,
-0.0209054332,
0.0549150743,
0.0452681147,
-0.055979684,
-0.06472978,
-0.0202082638,
0.0249261167,
0.043709401,
0.0119242817,
-0.0577715151,
0.0138323745,
-0.0392316878,
-0.0334305316,
-0.0098028108,
-0.016508013,
-0.0333617479,
0.0103841303,
0.0553935431,
0.0014027376,
-0.0030087219,
0.009585374,
-0.0683778748,
0.0243539587,
-0.0088198604,
-0.0002471899,
-0.0128575917,
0.086721994,
0.0099365646,
-0.0207714904,
0.0017491438,
0.0691809505,
0.0084211547,
0.0382578783,
0.0122048939,
0.0285443384,
0.0148033649,
0.0221459325,
0.0411528982,
0.0265523661,
-0.0528277382,
0.0281107817,
-0.0557683744,
-0.0004749867,
0.010645912,
0.0134180952,
0.0359117389,
-0.0316736177,
-0.0098447306,
-0.0263421349,
0.0484542251,
0.0072365524,
-0.0230714567,
-0.0257600546,
0.0006241424,
-0.0381706804,
0.0464558862,
0.0726990625,
0.043267291,
0.0539586321,
-0.0101169487,
-0.0233344436,
-0.0500904843,
-0.0331652053,
0.0356194004,
-0.0096945921,
0.0021225824,
0.0197700262,
-0.0284016412,
-0.0595331751,
0.0033157237,
0.0083608907,
0.0397679806,
-0.0205589943,
-0.0232295059,
0.030628629,
-0.0399670787,
0.0176316071,
-0.0548203066,
0.0500704572,
0.0090639964,
-0.0293292366,
-0.0216448829,
-5.64232917e-33,
0.0093646711,
-0.1083384603,
-0.0416787341,
0.0017667158,
0.0131239183,
0.0355158225,
0.000190729,
-0.0143376328,
0.0084576197,
0.0500797853,
-0.0008065294,
0.017345665,
-0.003061567,
0.0306877717,
-0.0221927948,
0.0212486517,
0.0549895652,
-0.0145222247,
-0.0252339561,
0.0392654911,
0.0130572841,
0.0054939995,
-0.011118371,
-0.0866850466,
0.0588495955,
-0.0547939166,
-0.0725557804,
-0.0222878251,
-0.037091773,
0.0335009806,
-0.0346903428,
0.0520066619,
0.0091648521,
-0.0056260624,
0.0024322541,
0.0279147886,
-0.0165739432,
-0.0082409652,
-0.0180915054,
-0.0067237122,
-0.0506941043,
-0.0691856071,
0.065119274,
-0.0223081615,
-0.0503540672,
0.0104725296,
0.0629977733,
-0.0446299873,
-0.0215496849,
-0.0558044985,
-0.0483904816,
0.0339867584,
-0.0048864884,
0.0078341495,
0.023939468,
0.0359542184,
-0.0011242079,
0.0010939206,
-0.0418835729,
0.0407044142,
0.0270806346,
-0.0072892806,
0.0086416323,
0.0090516601,
-0.014432,
0.0413561687,
0.026489811,
0.0017909796,
-0.0056032026,
-0.014742082,
-0.0008880817,
0.028646661,
0.0860372335,
0.1014764234,
0.0217687339,
-0.0532012694,
-0.0341742486,
0.0521486998,
-0.026511617,
-0.008583378,
0.0261977017,
-0.0433379114,
-0.0165159386,
-0.0148618659,
-0.0045670513,
-0.0877183676,
-0.0141034592,
0.0079496717,
0.0137046976,
0.0335049741,
-0.056462273,
-0.0496743768,
-0.0195296407,
-0.0530174598,
0.0237963907,
0.0286055021,
-0.0198250562,
-0.0292691104,
0.0047216574,
0.0118613718,
-0.0219505746,
-0.0101965312,
0.0436808653,
0.004224692,
0.0341750756,
-0.0191745516,
0.0481809713,
-0.000392544,
-0.0456917286,
0.0223653894,
-0.0150396153,
0.0440424681,
0.0396580473,
0.0148219541,
-0.015223749,
-0.0416485518,
0.0049632778,
-0.033067856,
0.0068778419,
0.024011774,
-0.0171203502,
0.0029744098,
-0.0060991058,
0.0160184391,
-0.052338019,
-0.0202108789,
-0.0126718748,
0.0236313678,
0.0572652146,
-0.0598959029,
0.028256081,
-0.0374276675,
2.631e-7,
0.0251221582,
0.024274407,
0.0128761418,
-0.0221368559,
0.0151812211,
0.0434907451,
0.0265810993,
0.0051073153,
-0.0115244417,
-0.0323674306,
-0.0068329056,
-0.0077391779,
0.0807605237,
-0.0102151493,
-0.0536157601,
0.0039509875,
-0.0707863793,
0.0107804677,
-0.0513710491,
0.0218798015,
0.0525167584,
0.0492432453,
0.0317840129,
-0.0666795,
0.0020115082,
-0.0750065967,
0.0306181684,
-0.0052077174,
-0.0100000966,
0.0056400103,
0.0543155782,
-0.0174813475,
0.0244855564,
-0.0039339345,
-0.041033037,
-0.0160956476,
0.0018412152,
0.0988198072,
0.0009523828,
0.0333722234,
-0.007417779,
-0.0073691322,
0.0224402938,
-0.0339783765,
0.0453473404,
0.0551294163,
-0.0024822662,
-0.0955464914,
-0.0278987307,
-0.0515174866,
0.0569216385,
-0.032517761,
-0.0143832741,
0.0023830738,
0.0044361721,
0.0282780714,
-0.0010553367,
-0.0279860273,
-0.0120228045,
-0.0524712838,
-0.0393103026,
-0.0076805009,
-0.0288863797,
-0.0169304069,
0.0330170728,
-0.0312062576,
0.0549882352,
2.60296464e-34,
0.0436995551,
-0.0315654799,
0.0014576187,
0.0188054163,
0.0113494191,
0.0263379253,
-0.002731401,
0.0100058746,
-0.0006584884,
-0.0159723014,
0.0248925835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07692v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07692v1 | On The Truthfulness of 'Surprisingly Likely' Responses of Large Language Models | 2023-11-13T19:21:25 | 2023-11-13T19:21:25 | Naman Goel | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GT | The surprisingly likely criterion in the seminal work of Prelec (the Bayesian
Truth Serum) guarantees truthfulness in a game-theoretic multi-agent setting,
by rewarding rational agents to maximise the expected information gain with
their answers w.r.t. their probabilistic beliefs. We investigate the relevance
of a similar criterion for responses of LLMs. We hypothesize that if the
surprisingly likely criterion works in LLMs, under certain conditions, the
responses that maximize the reward under this criterion should be more accurate
than the responses that only maximize the posterior probability. Using
benchmarks including the TruthfulQA benchmark and using openly available LLMs:
GPT-2 and LLaMA-2, we show that the method indeed improves the accuracy
significantly (for example, upto 24 percentage points aggregate improvement on
TruthfulQA and upto 70 percentage points improvement on individual categories
of questions). | [
0.0678273141,
0.0809806883,
-0.021564953,
0.0327264667,
-0.0827640295,
-0.0033016899,
-0.0076739071,
0.0184583459,
0.0088765528,
-0.0368304513,
-0.0230807494,
-0.0191658232,
0.0184219033,
0.0019217922,
0.0094267987,
0.0213970654,
0.0199642442,
-0.0325372294,
0.0577649772,
-0.0641911626,
-0.0221638773,
-0.0160782244,
-0.0222894065,
0.0217895079,
0.0167267639,
0.023298366,
0.0136639802,
-0.0209266599,
-0.003755962,
-0.0081910314,
-0.0162992626,
0.0280966181,
-0.0242857002,
0.0160550736,
0.0000020119,
-0.0593341291,
-0.0140180532,
-0.0272778925,
-0.0348151252,
0.0189049095,
0.0012810251,
0.0335008428,
0.0342541039,
0.0197243448,
-0.0606824681,
0.0103594083,
0.0534212664,
0.0007283891,
0.0123073328,
0.0673125684,
0.0163248479,
0.0004830095,
0.0547714084,
-0.0025952221,
0.0356890336,
-0.0661667213,
0.0238896031,
0.0180566367,
-0.0071320343,
0.0008238227,
0.0014042705,
0.0181951541,
-0.0151017541,
0.0184917804,
-0.0241411291,
0.0452861041,
-0.0166595392,
-0.018507624,
0.0148413936,
0.0262896381,
0.0176159386,
-0.0162238702,
-0.021870086,
-0.0379558168,
-0.0006227492,
0.0609845184,
-0.0388644934,
0.0350482091,
-0.010234395,
0.0308804121,
0.0672262162,
0.0193112157,
0.0360723957,
0.0131509025,
-0.0209383201,
0.1535608023,
0.0011804037,
-0.0069523468,
0.0005038352,
0.0350366682,
-0.0427711792,
-0.0800556988,
-0.0510616787,
0.0243770406,
-0.0196343716,
0.0408661813,
-0.0059221718,
0.038467221,
0.0474719778,
-0.0468302332,
0.0273433216,
0.0277249869,
0.0200667568,
0.0451407284,
-0.0013495918,
0.0345052145,
-0.0109261144,
0.0146258073,
-0.0155821145,
-0.0232852809,
0.0024570592,
0.0026372799,
0.0138137331,
0.0465639755,
0.004321327,
0.0225977805,
-0.0421657152,
0.0149188712,
-0.025102688,
0.0258699693,
0.004269578,
-0.0002174294,
-0.041955851,
-0.0355220139,
-0.0918621123,
0.0162349008,
-0.029472908,
0.0615307316,
-0.0006631011,
-0.1029982641,
0.0108531918,
-0.0040876386,
0.0272755865,
-0.0247471854,
0.0261986274,
0.0536270775,
0.0154259326,
-0.0363935046,
-0.0253171735,
-0.02598699,
-0.0074555269,
-0.0570568927,
-0.0214542095,
-0.0576664023,
0.014792501,
0.0037668059,
0.0019529436,
-0.0164672006,
0.0046776859,
-0.0157172401,
-0.0458338521,
0.0646349937,
0.0372764505,
0.0226082448,
0.0194119215,
-0.0019230749,
-0.0571779236,
0.0779907703,
0.0449817479,
0.0248778742,
0.0578735545,
-0.0013390956,
0.0373951085,
0.0363974012,
0.0192619674,
0.0460847393,
0.0225756243,
0.0382731594,
0.0445260443,
0.018627828,
0.0129455142,
0.0257720817,
-0.0214153212,
-0.0433076061,
0.0982400924,
0.0355360843,
-0.0079165194,
-0.039013125,
-0.014451161,
0.0037840954,
0.0222852509,
0.0373996869,
-0.0325411744,
0.0207390599,
-0.0638646632,
0.0192165114,
0.0569824912,
-0.0045917081,
-0.0168531109,
-0.0496839657,
-0.0123540312,
-0.0185014214,
0.0099434443,
0.0929095596,
0.0396913216,
-0.0679903924,
-0.038413804,
0.031210389,
0.0555042289,
-0.0142695801,
0.0037824395,
-0.1131680757,
0.0576897599,
-0.0080818683,
0.0427705981,
-0.0144811245,
-0.0125865182,
0.0042501632,
-0.0457523651,
0.0407177098,
0.059166614,
0.0022551271,
0.0264931656,
-0.0121170711,
-0.0063559106,
-0.0148155969,
0.0287138633,
0.0480297059,
-0.0013048027,
0.019008141,
-0.0366691761,
-0.0327384919,
0.0335103311,
0.0115573183,
-0.0086825266,
-0.0346699394,
0.0116805742,
-0.0199696124,
0.0661242157,
-0.022146415,
-0.022309849,
0.0436306745,
0.0165248457,
-0.0109064626,
-0.0129822344,
-0.0423613749,
-0.0134140421,
-0.0131546604,
0.033231616,
0.0038737853,
0.0216068998,
0.0296524577,
-0.0022664159,
-0.0162548181,
0.008418736,
0.0083067445,
0.0297152512,
-0.0282779802,
0.0271911956,
-0.0278374739,
0.0089724157,
-0.0454512797,
0.0627772212,
-0.0133504448,
0.0413489863,
-0.0014259579,
-0.0356244259,
0.0224575363,
-0.0413506925,
0.0057093445,
0.0093801245,
0.0306312367,
0.0350778811,
0.0666862205,
-0.0191085991,
-0.0242195111,
-0.0479949228,
-0.0675215274,
-0.0004156317,
-0.0083397739,
0.0040085572,
-0.0056148204,
-0.0166725367,
-0.0089539336,
0.0274593607,
-0.0713388696,
0.0002461464,
0.0369280092,
0.0524790622,
0.0187968928,
0.0079702344,
0.0027548131,
-0.0487709679,
-0.0071158041,
-0.0008771245,
0.0062929839,
0.0249204859,
0.0138375033,
-0.0404097103,
0.003555123,
-0.0760302097,
0.0247832052,
-0.032780651,
-0.0321262851,
0.0019794342,
-0.0245241951,
-0.0000439455,
0.0699950382,
0.001850546,
-0.0176110342,
0.0501816943,
0.0088371793,
-0.0625395477,
0.0035589873,
-0.0381830186,
-0.0592374615,
-0.0751492381,
-0.0816656724,
0.023552509,
0.0536525398,
0.0390749909,
-0.0434547365,
-0.0621082261,
0.0229428951,
-0.0180046484,
-0.0444839858,
-0.0043659913,
-0.0199885927,
-0.0126094669,
0.0866020471,
0.0002318782,
-0.0544924475,
0.0629936233,
-0.032683555,
0.0138770957,
-0.0501764677,
-0.0082439352,
-0.0128447032,
0.0507319011,
0.0193574242,
-0.0046136579,
0.0212049931,
0.0031434307,
-0.0548724197,
-0.0503873453,
0.0543733314,
-0.061615508,
0.0391701274,
-0.0490995497,
0.022421727,
-0.0221464727,
-0.0245819557,
-0.0174752269,
-0.074434191,
-0.0478837453,
-0.025674887,
-0.0207099579,
0.0033714827,
-0.05107335,
-0.0090935035,
0.0238520671,
-0.0278527252,
-0.0218715705,
-0.0061246832,
0.0063554877,
0.0173158646,
0.0617587492,
0.03471753,
0.0589973591,
-0.036909733,
-0.0197135843,
0.0620007478,
0.0136510385,
0.0483042859,
0.0230238643,
-0.0289524253,
0.0613852069,
-0.0217792932,
-0.0406362861,
0.0530339554,
0.0234817881,
-0.0089429086,
0.0077665905,
0.1008134484,
0.015303486,
-0.0078588678,
-0.0110243373,
0.0033492448,
0.0106885629,
-0.002955447,
0.0084073301,
-0.0727951005,
-0.0133978873,
-0.0081151109,
-0.0110685341,
-0.0451022387,
-0.0510880314,
-0.0113491751,
-0.0987557918,
0.0206834953,
-0.0122834584,
0.0224623773,
0.004607127,
-0.0493558533,
0.0075057256,
-0.0167865884,
0.0010817241,
0.000874674,
0.0586475544,
0.0011758643,
0.0079213372,
-0.0161667075,
0.0111156311,
0.0322328024,
-0.0229112282,
0.0669440553,
0.0473136455,
0.028344661,
-0.0446679778,
-0.0767859444,
-0.0102922404,
-0.0017804317,
-0.0377596766,
0.0152445622,
0.0090077156,
-0.0083764317,
0.0053228564,
0.0142629892,
-0.0100894161,
0.0058830963,
0.0123723876,
0.0250866953,
0.0367817506,
-0.0191546716,
-0.0445246659,
-0.0008024377,
0.0037448974,
-0.0000089257,
0.0782837048,
-0.0044449084,
-0.0385727026,
0.0152091673,
-0.0399062261,
0.001992686,
0.0211724751,
-0.0311828293,
0.0159824677,
0.0180061702,
0.0085235946,
-0.0466741621,
-0.0337806605,
-0.0076416461,
0.0064310399,
-0.025660146,
0.0251258928,
0.0078581069,
0.0207721908,
0.0263800472,
0.0070127398,
-0.0647513866,
0.0131793087,
-0.0284204185,
0.0011428503,
0.0405791216,
-0.0574632585,
-0.0001640059,
-0.005282057,
-0.0786421821,
-0.0704294965,
0.0020620762,
0.0294961669,
0.0317916274,
0.0048864535,
0.0078638028,
-0.0393316709,
0.0202269629,
-0.0323425569,
-0.0350742601,
0.0489421524,
0.0301799066,
0.0617778189,
-0.0009357136,
0.0305000003,
-0.0463869572,
-0.0018793178,
0.0322221778,
0.0488353595,
-0.0063239993,
-0.1016790345,
0.0262398832,
0.0190299675,
0.0501679741,
0.0122288717,
0.0085004484,
-0.0068496373,
0.0221480522,
-0.0050626537,
-0.0217108764,
-0.0051369597,
-0.0317720771,
0.0440206602,
-0.0093514407,
-0.0067548663,
-0.0239331294,
-0.0399184413,
0.0392085575,
-0.023101842,
-0.020865079,
0.03026071,
-0.0156854447,
0.0359050706,
-0.0227437988,
-0.0321579613,
0.0040833745,
0.0196083784,
0.0609237365,
0.037918292,
0.0396589227,
0.0070013199,
-0.0368687473,
0.0156894773,
-0.0269973949,
-0.0666315034,
-0.0801013857,
0.0260208566,
0.0763612241,
0.0269916784,
0.0483789407,
0.0126461796,
-0.0460881479,
-0.0144103393,
-0.0226726141,
-0.0197133776,
0.0417768434,
-0.0234591402,
0.0674468055,
-0.0095557282,
-0.0259686895,
0.0273073073,
0.0549580455,
0.0183201004,
0.0442688912,
-0.0062027914,
0.005486188,
-0.0240282379,
-0.0473477356,
-0.0076406733,
0.0409709103,
-0.0176988281,
0.0107133109,
-0.0773094967,
-0.0332748629,
0.000174931,
0.0413874239,
-0.0168840177,
-0.0473802239,
-0.0156020345,
0.0721264333,
0.0145562924,
-0.0140546663,
-0.0780479759,
0.0245589633,
-0.0221489239,
0.0124609144,
-0.0193835441,
-6.745312785e-33,
0.0025080801,
-0.0233549122,
0.0191592891,
-0.0268506836,
0.028049143,
0.0084851077,
0.0070794607,
0.0133815166,
-0.0613738373,
-0.0072194785,
-0.0245939475,
-0.0030008908,
0.0092307245,
0.0028065466,
-0.0290493481,
-0.0376632512,
0.004163723,
-0.0146551104,
-0.0486019179,
-0.0166942813,
-0.0217466801,
-0.0603214465,
0.0601065643,
-0.0264725573,
0.08088319,
-0.0277757309,
-0.0193922892,
0.059524022,
-0.047264237,
0.0567459464,
-0.0105083454,
0.0418515876,
0.0077780178,
-0.0245093964,
0.0345497616,
-0.0375015996,
0.0038490349,
-0.0372823402,
0.0550074838,
-0.0163279753,
-0.0276766773,
-0.0152386567,
0.0051015043,
0.0219399929,
-0.0463894531,
-0.0260866079,
0.0058465772,
-0.0015520721,
-0.0385617279,
-0.0146236187,
-0.0073297676,
0.0166674778,
0.0179192573,
0.0233476497,
-0.0185751971,
0.0079238759,
0.0148904864,
0.0391402431,
-0.0255350024,
0.048686903,
0.0473004244,
0.0080198608,
0.0448890142,
0.0067962217,
0.0316587426,
0.0555836931,
0.0438462794,
0.0294714868,
0.0036654705,
-0.0394819453,
0.0112193711,
0.0060271393,
0.0482757688,
0.0829310417,
0.0168164987,
0.0015156389,
-0.0725677758,
0.0327096656,
0.0717566833,
-0.0378773883,
0.0483709238,
0.0128095774,
-0.0673195794,
-0.0484768637,
-0.0658481345,
0.0472446792,
-0.0371574424,
-0.0061953715,
0.0116675058,
0.0005774532,
-0.0049319295,
-0.0437332578,
0.0440560803,
-0.0448568985,
-0.0337033197,
-0.0137708336,
0.0071107806,
0.0141233252,
-0.0159994587,
0.0495660044,
-0.0524057597,
0.0239782222,
-0.0253856555,
-0.0414588489,
-0.0131093115,
0.0180260129,
-0.03988811,
0.0131284175,
-0.0507160388,
0.0128862923,
-0.0168056525,
0.0221452769,
0.0165440906,
-0.0374334678,
0.0299917236,
-0.0303093847,
0.0044809314,
0.0033533266,
-0.0133399665,
-0.0210878234,
-0.022074135,
0.0137639819,
-0.0252622664,
0.0229194853,
-0.0432964489,
0.0158166066,
-0.0257668775,
0.0181724746,
0.0025684955,
-0.0085431496,
-0.0333497785,
0.0080717029,
2.725e-7,
0.023297444,
0.0248696357,
-0.0411814675,
0.0474043339,
0.0084605599,
0.0695177764,
-0.0190950241,
0.0090750819,
0.0574302077,
-0.040308062,
0.0014594877,
0.0126829343,
0.0340039693,
0.0528122783,
-0.0482768677,
-0.0052761012,
-0.0296056625,
-0.0056983,
-0.01505889,
-0.0037386636,
0.0330542512,
0.0756190941,
0.0310076959,
0.0020842154,
0.0042525847,
-0.0358377174,
0.0381384939,
-0.0599148273,
-0.0568588637,
0.0431333221,
0.0255643483,
-0.0038640436,
0.012912605,
0.0242571887,
0.0170971584,
0.0015704371,
-0.0300872345,
0.0526974909,
0.0043699858,
-0.0723505542,
-0.0476565696,
-0.0705118254,
0.0202158447,
-0.0659311637,
0.090776071,
-0.0004216283,
-0.0678290874,
-0.0466676019,
-0.011881155,
-0.0506881438,
0.0307349116,
-0.0327664539,
-0.0421291031,
0.0097043766,
0.0028035624,
0.0276527144,
-0.0076756622,
-0.0155332414,
-0.0293519739,
-0.0280594695,
-0.0252991468,
-0.1275832504,
0.0332061388,
0.0056818901,
0.0126920175,
-0.0809726194,
0.0285976082,
2.447228399e-34,
0.0243957359,
0.0095117101,
-0.001900172,
0.0102455709,
0.0541351438,
0.015841119,
-0.0216155369,
-0.0017164566,
0.0660878196,
-0.0774587169,
-0.0242523383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07689v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07689v1 | MART: Improving LLM Safety with Multi-round Automatic Red-Teaming | 2023-11-13T19:13:29 | 2023-11-13T19:13:29 | Suyu Ge, Chunting Zhou, Rui Hou, Madian Khabsa, Yi-Chia Wang, Qifan Wang, Jiawei Han, Yuning Mao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Red-teaming is a common practice for mitigating unsafe behaviors in Large
Language Models (LLMs), which involves thoroughly assessing LLMs to identify
potential flaws and addressing them with responsible and accurate responses.
While effective, manual red-teaming is costly, and existing automatic
red-teaming typically discovers safety risks without addressing them. In this
paper, we propose a Multi-round Automatic Red-Teaming (MART) method, which
incorporates both automatic adversarial prompt writing and safe response
generation, significantly increasing red-teaming scalability and the safety of
the target LLM. Specifically, an adversarial LLM and a target LLM interplay
with each other in an iterative manner, where the adversarial LLM aims to
generate challenging prompts that elicit unsafe responses from the target LLM,
while the target LLM is fine-tuned with safety aligned data on these
adversarial prompts. In each round, the adversarial LLM crafts better attacks
on the updated target LLM, while the target LLM also improves itself through
safety fine-tuning. On adversarial prompt benchmarks, the violation rate of an
LLM with limited safety alignment reduces up to 84.7% after 4 rounds of MART,
achieving comparable performance to LLMs with extensive adversarial prompt
writing. Notably, model helpfulness on non-adversarial prompts remains stable
throughout iterations, indicating the target LLM maintains strong performance
on instruction following. | [
0.0181221571,
0.0355475359,
-0.0066249422,
0.0303425379,
-0.028008746,
-0.0030367859,
0.0109398076,
-0.0339563265,
0.0185049158,
-0.0653860718,
-0.0268962122,
-0.0275350884,
-0.0200136304,
0.0031449494,
0.0431242026,
-0.0095518967,
0.0898486674,
-0.0790308863,
-0.0258281156,
-0.0072270189,
0.0119437128,
-0.0125063537,
-0.0090225711,
0.0288718566,
0.0062335795,
-0.0235099606,
-0.0497773699,
0.026690159,
0.0208007116,
-0.0384992398,
0.0427850075,
0.0545309186,
-0.0059368303,
0.0602800027,
0.0000023575,
-0.0375734158,
-0.0326377228,
0.0067997091,
-0.0211533345,
0.0585247725,
-0.0142678954,
-0.0355766751,
-0.0465966277,
0.0441637933,
-0.0255149771,
0.0064200102,
0.036188174,
0.0242143143,
0.090140745,
0.0897659585,
0.0241024811,
0.0259401668,
0.0579719841,
-0.0310746897,
-0.0235506222,
-0.0810367018,
0.0252353474,
-0.0173918623,
-0.0124459621,
0.0281696673,
-0.0148309395,
0.0017280427,
0.0296257734,
-0.0138108684,
-0.0743056983,
0.0053816624,
-0.0155891245,
-0.0045520156,
-0.0271505825,
0.0576140918,
-0.0567681864,
-0.0133095011,
-0.0112130148,
-0.0067859096,
-0.0052902345,
-0.0122681968,
-0.0050877184,
0.0242286399,
-0.0103515377,
-0.0020057275,
0.0045478847,
-0.0302737225,
0.039341744,
0.0105493972,
0.0077205813,
0.0443613604,
0.0144321108,
-0.0445696302,
-0.0033723097,
-0.0076848483,
-0.0099200495,
-0.0555414706,
-0.0255321767,
0.0330447927,
-0.0524929836,
0.0223553311,
-0.0715165585,
-0.0512252972,
0.0700224414,
-0.0165398251,
0.051977884,
0.0151409125,
-0.0095377043,
0.0132462867,
-0.0288927443,
0.0265179947,
-0.024207795,
0.0591506772,
-0.0082906876,
0.0247002151,
-0.0043690116,
0.0035266005,
-0.0074190623,
0.0108811297,
0.0047004828,
0.0370551236,
-0.0365881026,
0.0541602969,
-0.0280069076,
0.0534609668,
-0.0273451488,
-0.0195836779,
-0.0207418185,
-0.0046829046,
0.0145346439,
-0.0347371139,
-0.0267141424,
-0.0205914676,
-0.0034454102,
-0.0648838803,
-0.0305305738,
0.0216894802,
-0.0717895851,
-0.0449815579,
-0.0062504909,
0.1301979423,
-0.0073278686,
-0.0020779083,
-0.0447211415,
-0.0544489659,
-0.019707704,
-0.0511364862,
0.0243490059,
-0.0607729666,
-0.0084240641,
-0.0109547563,
-0.0446631536,
-0.0392139554,
0.0248229913,
0.0126355281,
-0.0225820858,
0.0675892904,
0.015951626,
-0.0217298288,
-0.0154103274,
0.0346839614,
-0.0273996703,
0.0634497106,
0.0216607712,
0.0144535797,
0.0309224073,
-0.0044846707,
0.0162613448,
0.0626292005,
0.0379823707,
0.0395245478,
-0.0181394648,
0.0087744379,
0.0528552756,
0.0082790237,
0.0093214801,
0.07971894,
-0.0030442651,
-0.0472965427,
0.0689572021,
-0.0103477892,
-0.0413563848,
0.0253070686,
0.0196412224,
0.0178644918,
-0.0303233843,
0.0314549468,
-0.0805419013,
0.0355676338,
-0.0809444115,
-0.023280669,
0.00460468,
0.03645356,
-0.0317332819,
-0.0244002305,
-0.0021897485,
-0.007779032,
0.0158575345,
0.0220233407,
0.0140281087,
0.0060245893,
-0.0635656416,
0.0240543373,
0.0215931591,
-0.0333666056,
-0.0384574495,
-0.081599392,
0.0201459955,
0.0446736962,
0.0598834157,
-0.0460766368,
-0.0573595166,
-0.0384414308,
-0.0058841906,
0.0245297756,
0.0362194479,
0.0080930097,
0.01131217,
-0.0526062325,
-0.0368482545,
-0.0107677095,
0.004418429,
0.0242492035,
0.0533604883,
-0.0169526711,
-0.0120303705,
0.0360864811,
-0.0458082668,
0.0551194847,
-0.0158236939,
-0.05609091,
0.0030500263,
0.0271751061,
0.0358354449,
-0.0213922877,
-0.0164824203,
0.0255168062,
0.0535358004,
-0.0014370651,
0.0037478055,
-0.0294997767,
-0.0432980917,
-0.0344801247,
0.0365098715,
0.0116016045,
-0.0422810391,
0.0721477643,
-0.062997587,
0.0029019052,
0.0068381377,
-0.0281485859,
-0.0261510033,
-0.002128626,
0.0269435123,
0.0061020064,
0.0181493089,
-0.0441400334,
0.0382999331,
-0.0327022783,
-0.0201561749,
0.0052385051,
0.0215331241,
0.0032883526,
-0.0391882882,
-0.0452277213,
0.0062383763,
-0.0273905061,
0.0611810759,
0.0084920675,
0.0234913975,
-0.0164855849,
-0.0327745266,
-0.0104912566,
0.0113122556,
-0.0261490252,
0.0189429037,
0.0257975869,
-0.0255185273,
-0.0042052213,
0.0009073353,
0.0023560321,
0.0086967405,
0.0092243925,
0.0359812714,
0.0145454844,
-0.0017202806,
-0.0415281691,
-0.0484823957,
-0.0142056886,
-0.0089801084,
0.016037127,
-0.013528795,
-0.0313669369,
-0.0519659892,
0.0453768857,
-0.0070525804,
0.0552951209,
-0.0202906355,
-0.0682918355,
0.038742356,
-0.0028716631,
0.0018175375,
0.0765106156,
0.0187999327,
0.0097100446,
0.0941099152,
0.0197030548,
-0.0696492046,
0.026339829,
0.0161384102,
-0.0606083609,
-0.0125686033,
-0.0227418579,
0.0078972913,
0.0754616186,
0.0123769855,
-0.0284614526,
-0.0152205443,
-0.0153861688,
0.013934453,
-0.0460161865,
-0.0069098538,
-0.0507538095,
-0.0357448645,
0.0052977945,
-0.035282433,
-0.065928556,
0.0898262039,
-0.0238905717,
0.0149861686,
-0.0238163844,
-0.0197209548,
0.0089207338,
0.0451625437,
-0.0104039097,
0.0161732566,
0.0190292858,
-0.0072261547,
-0.0718820468,
-0.051438503,
0.029658908,
-0.0217521526,
0.0657698661,
-0.0539853089,
0.006087793,
-0.0196078941,
-0.021063609,
-0.0834681913,
-0.0606226586,
-0.0109903794,
0.0124172829,
-0.0095333224,
-0.0004258371,
-0.0316245742,
-0.0162148215,
0.0329040587,
0.0019837124,
-0.0257229265,
0.0117102582,
-0.0244262535,
-0.0003600462,
0.0495334417,
-0.0623780303,
0.0124980593,
-0.0607379563,
0.0697703362,
0.1162539423,
0.0277672037,
0.0242229495,
-0.0379937924,
-0.0348617956,
0.0283452068,
-0.0054762932,
-0.013081857,
0.0314189792,
0.046699293,
-0.0667627156,
0.0001324675,
0.0512736365,
0.0123466598,
-0.0138510987,
0.0210440196,
-0.0038651482,
0.0553256199,
0.0017591501,
0.0206270423,
-0.0668724999,
-0.0250713285,
0.0236591082,
0.0389713608,
0.0007708474,
-0.0214522127,
-0.0005539409,
-0.1397984624,
0.0032730137,
0.0107371025,
-0.030270284,
0.00186196,
-0.0052356417,
-0.0081129251,
0.0181753207,
0.0794935375,
0.0174827725,
0.0122518083,
-0.0222694166,
0.0271026976,
-0.0090240873,
-0.0279320385,
0.0334028825,
-0.0626613125,
0.0743644312,
0.0891866684,
-0.0038501646,
-0.0171046779,
-0.0055716336,
0.0560029484,
-0.0002752143,
0.0196381789,
0.0086330865,
0.042780485,
-0.0110566942,
-0.0081321374,
-0.0033627774,
0.0181974992,
0.0110334633,
-0.014787646,
0.0689669549,
0.047400713,
-0.0186405946,
-0.002651318,
-0.0407287963,
0.0292925909,
0.0405099131,
0.0682140589,
0.0168385524,
-0.0590733998,
-0.0287607461,
-0.0506144837,
-0.012174475,
-0.0849513263,
-0.0380667485,
0.0140658207,
-0.0152101489,
-0.0115711223,
-0.0561243631,
-0.0331601985,
0.0116055021,
0.005851903,
0.0173036586,
-0.018981494,
-0.0566136874,
0.0165386051,
-0.015677901,
0.0051445649,
-0.0206146725,
0.0540277027,
-0.0710603893,
0.0265596882,
-0.0091705406,
-0.0058788974,
-0.0055643101,
0.0419724546,
-0.0555858165,
-0.1077130064,
0.0091964975,
0.1016653776,
0.0162103176,
0.0259987079,
-0.0259152744,
-0.0552966967,
0.0462718047,
0.0463550389,
-0.0202635881,
0.0105139855,
0.0712341294,
-0.0211500451,
0.0053829076,
0.0253917091,
-0.0427746251,
0.00301492,
0.066938363,
0.0280077923,
-0.0647194982,
-0.037244048,
0.0115506649,
0.0368065387,
0.0462276712,
-0.020334648,
0.013009985,
0.0147444187,
0.0332542881,
-0.0083807679,
-0.0268169381,
-0.0136724943,
0.0467384383,
0.0103187244,
-0.0487464443,
0.0229981486,
-0.0103127398,
0.0045050466,
0.0242209956,
-0.020642966,
0.0461996607,
0.0040317508,
0.0615265109,
0.0591308139,
0.0222688243,
-0.0276313405,
0.0331603922,
0.0232497789,
0.0081573343,
0.0064881379,
0.0484111831,
0.0148173133,
0.0175936036,
0.001987763,
0.0404388607,
-0.0420159288,
-0.0635954514,
0.0127326129,
0.0393233709,
0.0490133725,
0.0424401499,
0.0146152591,
-0.0110530471,
-0.0098242555,
-0.0409600027,
0.018027408,
-0.0046117231,
-0.0506878458,
0.0428395122,
0.0289262198,
0.0147565426,
0.0131363338,
0.0794874728,
-0.0043831775,
0.0708035529,
0.0174828991,
0.0032203349,
-0.0395200253,
-0.0223562531,
0.0420190394,
-0.0128679201,
-0.0353567228,
-0.0118252775,
-0.0478533283,
-0.0709254295,
-0.0058806306,
0.0421420895,
0.0025325241,
-0.0065031471,
-0.0065248697,
0.0240992364,
0.005452381,
0.0274958685,
-0.0364859663,
0.0299485661,
0.007263782,
-0.053660132,
-0.0127627803,
-6.139418548e-33,
-0.0181567967,
-0.0275148377,
-0.0087846462,
-0.0171715897,
-0.0100868233,
0.0088911476,
-0.0295621473,
0.0065152063,
-0.0269981418,
-0.0175213907,
-0.0081702126,
-0.0037841541,
-0.0021350328,
0.0074448804,
-0.0024329808,
-0.0487404205,
0.0206349529,
-0.0250437502,
-0.0221140012,
0.0181073137,
0.0269843545,
0.0012972663,
0.0238120835,
-0.0614949688,
0.0246123318,
-0.0251934398,
-0.0417255796,
0.025801355,
-0.0679430217,
0.064744167,
0.0224231891,
0.0311284456,
-0.0032983774,
-0.0211076047,
-0.0110282786,
0.0477534533,
-0.0182058476,
-0.0183067881,
0.0020918683,
-0.0208594762,
-0.0608027577,
-0.04718614,
0.0294140894,
-0.007127597,
-0.0043528485,
-0.030513892,
-0.0118181463,
0.0024378793,
-0.0353366397,
0.0082821762,
-0.0387719795,
0.0150091778,
-0.0035711948,
-0.0671043992,
0.0042281258,
0.0434847884,
0.0416095853,
-0.0130355963,
-0.0496732071,
0.0038012401,
-0.0037735724,
0.0130382357,
0.0695888251,
0.0242475662,
-0.0134801157,
0.064884387,
-0.0182093903,
0.0240652468,
-0.0163992979,
-0.0172679648,
-0.001653114,
0.0540106818,
0.0578800477,
0.0543700829,
-0.0020147096,
-0.0223099049,
-0.0860188082,
0.0330296792,
0.0520173497,
0.0516539738,
0.0265505537,
0.0131408889,
-0.0582810864,
-0.009260796,
-0.019839555,
-0.0083365031,
-0.0201708879,
-0.034056168,
0.0310590342,
0.016248785,
-0.0474621989,
-0.0244023148,
0.0162806213,
-0.0092245853,
0.0103892619,
0.0362090655,
-0.0032313359,
-0.0218793377,
-0.0235976819,
0.0287513621,
-0.0353982635,
-0.0078898128,
0.0019259828,
-0.0732694343,
0.0338756181,
0.0225754492,
0.0550627746,
0.0464589447,
-0.0676867962,
-0.0064188754,
-0.0394037887,
0.0744863898,
0.0168948248,
0.0008228697,
0.0246928409,
-0.0123388041,
0.0019066053,
0.0398242474,
0.0235351995,
-0.0386319049,
-0.0326165035,
0.0263611209,
-0.0278902482,
0.0193728525,
-0.0210340302,
0.0167531576,
-0.0001921426,
-0.0016603344,
0.0357009061,
-0.0696364865,
-0.0031094518,
-0.02314182,
2.929e-7,
0.0014426135,
0.0318301171,
0.047921259,
0.0367600806,
0.0244577993,
0.0764197856,
-0.0392907858,
0.0657515973,
0.0182173476,
-0.0118766986,
-0.0143054584,
0.0331994109,
0.0417221151,
0.0640652776,
-0.0337846242,
0.0136868358,
-0.079066202,
0.0265496261,
-0.0459934287,
-0.0109599736,
0.0387489684,
0.0735773593,
0.0067756413,
-0.023236502,
0.0071419664,
-0.0538744219,
0.035727296,
-0.0234419815,
-0.0260557421,
0.0081641469,
0.0157308318,
0.0049692742,
-0.0029980559,
0.0452147499,
-0.0187758543,
-0.0359955281,
-0.033039134,
0.0727139786,
0.0143593168,
-0.0323495083,
0.001995672,
-0.0412108302,
-0.0119104628,
-0.0247440822,
0.0776047558,
-0.0176103264,
0.0029500464,
-0.0243122615,
0.003421315,
-0.0253073387,
0.0179279447,
-0.0295407381,
-0.0077978265,
0.0156358387,
0.0089365859,
-0.0045687226,
-0.0003866386,
-0.0442911573,
-0.0462936163,
-0.0235684197,
-0.0153831076,
-0.0543801002,
-0.0037410439,
0.0286500249,
0.0011276099,
-0.0584676042,
-0.002736144,
3.02629115e-34,
0.0091386549,
-0.0560297556,
0.0194591489,
-0.0018925976,
0.0321717076,
0.0031983559,
-0.0305208769,
0.0245312937,
0.0331789702,
-0.0055645453,
-0.0424864739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07687v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07687v1 | Language Model-In-The-Loop: Data Optimal Approach to Learn-To-Recommend Actions in Text Games | 2023-11-13T19:12:49 | 2023-11-13T19:12:49 | Arjun Vaithilingam Sudhakar, Prasanna Parthasarathi, Janarthanan Rajendran, Sarath Chandar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated superior performance in
language understanding benchmarks. CALM, a popular approach, leverages
linguistic priors of LLMs -- GPT-2 -- for action candidate recommendations to
improve the performance in text games in Jericho without environment-provided
actions. However, CALM adapts GPT-2 with annotated human gameplays and keeps
the LLM fixed during the learning of the text based games. In this work, we
explore and evaluate updating LLM used for candidate recommendation during the
learning of the text based game as well to mitigate the reliance on the human
annotated gameplays, which are costly to acquire. We observe that by updating
the LLM during learning using carefully selected in-game transitions, we can
reduce the dependency on using human annotated game plays for fine-tuning the
LLMs. We conducted further analysis to study the transferability of the updated
LLMs and observed that transferring in-game trained models to other games did
not result in a consistent transfer. | [
0.0172198266,
0.0435252339,
-0.0204494167,
0.0576462559,
0.0036675725,
0.0270788446,
-0.0320914723,
0.0010061226,
0.0305672735,
-0.0239349585,
-0.0682168156,
-0.0156940278,
-0.0101992162,
0.0231441632,
0.0056989733,
-0.0423426665,
0.0065007047,
-0.0700451285,
0.0194218382,
0.0058193631,
-0.0366395153,
-0.0102948118,
-0.0199191105,
0.0485155657,
0.0593569018,
-0.0079133352,
-0.0166436974,
0.0242516454,
0.0283807553,
-0.0721593574,
-0.0113727581,
-0.0158464834,
0.0332843065,
-0.0240283832,
0.0000020451,
-0.0087968996,
0.0122538144,
-0.073499538,
0.0355499052,
-0.0049966308,
0.0274305232,
0.0437982939,
0.0286032464,
-0.023160575,
-0.0203009192,
-0.0038492468,
0.0714515001,
0.0462994985,
0.0693022683,
0.0405120142,
-0.0113617973,
0.0012378524,
-0.0309156068,
-0.0258106943,
0.028993465,
-0.059253104,
-0.0126578314,
0.0152456006,
0.0547686927,
0.0371628404,
-0.0224740021,
0.0055414094,
-0.023885807,
0.0208466966,
-0.0250713807,
0.05997435,
0.0377692692,
0.0625019297,
-0.0010632932,
0.0715213269,
-0.045196753,
-0.0195871536,
0.0177722163,
0.0011208991,
0.0094619347,
0.003974149,
-0.0221171435,
-0.0040834616,
-0.0163956229,
0.0268581714,
-0.0130987754,
-0.044826407,
0.0589836985,
-0.0017244933,
0.006499236,
0.0995274782,
-0.0148330582,
-0.0266720299,
-0.0219359528,
0.0259423368,
-0.0308461785,
-0.0622679889,
-0.0160675365,
0.030764902,
-0.0967593715,
0.024863502,
-0.026231043,
0.0432697907,
-0.0333682671,
-0.0286282115,
0.0440051816,
0.0420270003,
-0.0067740967,
0.0809915289,
-0.0050341357,
0.0270741433,
0.0351626761,
0.028260937,
-0.0484176166,
0.0429077409,
-0.0561160333,
-0.0147383353,
-0.0546737909,
0.0569449477,
-0.0278106313,
-0.0560833178,
-0.0035117725,
0.0289005246,
0.0029496376,
0.0346913151,
0.0145288929,
0.0202920511,
-0.0112222228,
-0.0049509788,
-0.0501606166,
-0.0134488856,
-0.0353152417,
0.0267839506,
-0.0142092444,
-0.0171311591,
-0.0000851656,
-0.0266624615,
-0.0199587904,
-0.0199205969,
0.037534032,
0.0708510578,
-0.0194842126,
-0.0366617739,
-0.0321578346,
0.0296635125,
-0.0038690346,
-0.0477725007,
-0.0457517095,
-0.052149225,
0.0321612135,
-0.0113493418,
0.0412864611,
-0.0404346734,
0.0028886031,
0.0461715832,
-0.0348508954,
0.0838375911,
0.0187201612,
0.0295305233,
0.0254292507,
0.0035078584,
-0.0188276302,
0.0807221085,
0.0529493205,
0.0438316949,
-0.0061563714,
0.011761304,
0.007815524,
0.0526211932,
-0.0352408364,
0.0087310625,
-0.0406447798,
-0.0124553395,
0.0470934287,
0.0778174698,
0.0373363011,
0.0426214077,
-0.0660729557,
-0.0325292535,
0.1099917293,
0.0500858463,
-0.0090199523,
-0.0115635078,
0.0657002106,
0.0479167998,
0.005080374,
-0.013411467,
-0.0174671188,
0.0306696445,
0.0195091944,
-0.0360306874,
-0.018666096,
0.0204710513,
-0.0107563194,
-0.0599329136,
0.0205081664,
-0.0140223633,
0.0149052162,
0.0457841493,
0.0070473268,
-0.0105831707,
-0.0787591413,
0.0362021066,
0.0315063521,
-0.0082322517,
0.0254042856,
-0.036150191,
0.0334436633,
0.0817300156,
0.0289391857,
-0.0470801741,
-0.0562128797,
-0.0405110121,
0.00063397,
0.0077563436,
0.0004520611,
-0.0311662517,
0.0434163958,
-0.0430593938,
-0.0485617816,
-0.0134346839,
-0.0101895658,
0.0734883621,
-0.0243390966,
0.0215452854,
-0.0180718731,
-0.0112540638,
-0.0177357327,
0.0231462996,
0.0040466608,
-0.0900953338,
0.0177910831,
-0.0086996304,
0.0285410117,
-0.0210845619,
-0.002381389,
-0.0286412146,
0.0098610325,
-0.0149059659,
-0.0048614698,
0.0248256829,
-0.0177871194,
-0.0057715005,
0.0507048778,
-0.0110530043,
0.0114630926,
0.0087036239,
0.003850515,
0.0024049832,
-0.004436038,
-0.0195394754,
0.0360797271,
0.0008162541,
0.0092223147,
-0.0033346869,
0.0036364193,
-0.0471434966,
0.0565052293,
-0.0109690083,
-0.0171402581,
0.0178940706,
-0.0319082253,
-0.0091082528,
-0.0276691504,
0.0228377208,
0.0652796403,
0.004192499,
-0.025546154,
0.0413377695,
0.0169957727,
-0.0594065599,
-0.0257957634,
-0.0701929331,
0.0049481844,
-0.0036862472,
0.002692193,
-0.0029225196,
0.0043617422,
-0.0270015467,
-0.0213116296,
-0.0354995467,
-0.0078916596,
0.0072680856,
0.0116167227,
0.0110412231,
0.0368284695,
0.017828811,
-0.0148003362,
0.0043757851,
0.0099714762,
0.0287277438,
-0.0122430436,
0.0046404013,
-0.0445942245,
-0.000415863,
-0.0278000608,
0.0118851205,
-0.0485787727,
-0.0358167514,
0.0363202393,
-0.0309380181,
0.0576745085,
0.0465178043,
0.0222120155,
-0.0223948117,
0.084878169,
-0.0353634879,
-0.0199500751,
0.0414552651,
0.0138994707,
-0.079813987,
-0.0784468949,
-0.0018897593,
0.0425697155,
0.0487937108,
-0.0358126201,
0.0178009532,
-0.0814104676,
-0.0245759096,
-0.0193474274,
-0.0395229347,
-0.0694223121,
-0.0412289426,
-0.0441704392,
-0.0333063193,
-0.0320786498,
0.0209420454,
0.0350349359,
-0.0304463822,
-0.0281192958,
-0.0749812797,
0.0197694618,
-0.01026366,
0.0322271697,
0.0463542752,
0.0278480146,
-0.0619705506,
-0.0397110134,
-0.0373342261,
-0.0652414039,
0.0540545881,
-0.0172782354,
0.0213452969,
-0.0314888358,
0.0045631872,
0.0321326852,
-0.0197857115,
-0.0141395554,
-0.0158297587,
-0.0642600507,
-0.0625886023,
0.011375838,
-0.015770182,
-0.0359675512,
-0.0327677429,
0.0402141847,
0.0096265832,
0.0086579137,
-0.0340601653,
-0.0100419903,
-0.0106498394,
0.102576144,
-0.0150968656,
-0.0280908961,
-0.0619177446,
0.0483350866,
0.0410872996,
-0.0152561301,
-0.0696917847,
-0.0156556312,
0.0380817577,
0.0602021776,
-0.0196952987,
-0.0298532546,
0.0777004585,
0.0203356426,
-0.0246931389,
-0.0116333729,
0.1005145386,
0.0211623255,
-0.0724628866,
0.0189350806,
0.0120522641,
0.0156478714,
0.0155455219,
0.0050735972,
-0.0307428669,
-0.033679001,
0.0141521497,
0.0139084756,
0.024042882,
-0.034591496,
-0.0058302912,
-0.0979078934,
0.0064849504,
0.0143594816,
-0.0548555627,
0.0397346392,
-0.005410728,
0.0251837708,
-0.0233661886,
-0.0214104056,
-0.000636042,
-0.0070592402,
0.0129280444,
0.0105153639,
0.0023332771,
0.0012420794,
0.020981146,
-0.0376506224,
0.0610653237,
0.0154499207,
0.0681283846,
-0.006593104,
-0.0279583558,
0.0387955606,
0.0460754186,
-0.0189471077,
-0.0072412174,
0.0527603179,
-0.0255127866,
-0.0074928459,
0.0231909286,
0.007523173,
-0.0021070479,
-0.0470302999,
0.0172324758,
0.0714946166,
0.0054163639,
-0.009494354,
0.0300711691,
0.0245446004,
0.0591768101,
0.0485942364,
-0.0254593343,
-0.0645155385,
0.0181466695,
0.0096801315,
-0.0289000571,
-0.0691135749,
-0.036139641,
-0.0527195372,
0.0414656959,
0.0224829223,
-0.0673852935,
-0.0561882369,
-0.0054197679,
0.0673054531,
0.0134927509,
0.0811837837,
-0.0173297841,
0.021784313,
0.0438690148,
0.0290212724,
-0.0510077626,
-0.000673755,
-0.0601449944,
-0.029384084,
0.022535339,
-0.092806749,
0.0079549355,
0.0387231931,
-0.0710018352,
-0.0178781338,
0.0240293704,
0.0482529812,
0.0138699366,
0.0536390506,
0.0076066931,
-0.0598802865,
-0.0067343013,
0.0152541762,
-0.0506517813,
-0.0071703298,
0.0128126722,
0.0127913533,
-0.0006155911,
0.005625295,
-0.0355145112,
-0.0077083833,
0.0221092813,
0.038039498,
-0.0317127071,
-0.0492538847,
0.0093149962,
-0.0368246734,
0.0447695665,
-0.0479957424,
-0.0372603536,
-0.0122041954,
0.0137727354,
-0.024899371,
-0.0057557374,
-0.0413853116,
0.0055700261,
0.0612079315,
0.0171506684,
-0.0360712484,
-0.019997295,
-0.003964229,
-0.0084524453,
0.0091394121,
0.0045957253,
0.0668347701,
0.0145480102,
0.0276886318,
0.0154402312,
0.0197547972,
0.013996372,
0.0222830176,
0.0459901728,
0.0338449739,
0.0385964587,
0.0308242645,
-0.0585337393,
-0.0222150926,
0.0157819036,
-0.0157588813,
-0.0545378365,
-0.0128800599,
0.0099237738,
0.0692486167,
-0.0205831807,
0.021490261,
-0.022421211,
0.0016738847,
-0.0134529518,
-0.0267228205,
0.0067175245,
-0.0630813316,
-0.0057697077,
0.0481425524,
-0.0172362272,
0.0482559875,
0.0398882851,
0.0165613256,
0.038318228,
0.0173288658,
-0.0339763612,
-0.0248866584,
0.000050409,
-0.0052109202,
0.0697706714,
-0.058872249,
0.0249279775,
-0.0206852667,
-0.0343789421,
-0.014408296,
0.0395101048,
-0.0145279076,
-0.0176595207,
0.0264080651,
0.0456648581,
0.0161326062,
0.0060739075,
-0.0719654262,
0.0227777064,
-0.0040560458,
-0.0273117889,
-0.048936557,
-5.490074366e-33,
-0.0154154515,
-0.017105585,
0.0524316095,
-0.0036296586,
-0.0336113274,
-0.0166849196,
-0.0440181755,
0.0079090288,
0.0135035701,
0.0248552822,
-0.0092707444,
0.0171880014,
-0.0034939053,
0.005248514,
0.0185906496,
-0.0645436347,
0.0349153243,
0.0178184323,
-0.0681608319,
0.0409139283,
0.0312486142,
0.008407685,
0.050819546,
-0.0693428293,
-0.0168827213,
0.0023584801,
-0.0329191387,
0.0182176642,
0.0284185838,
0.0456643291,
0.0022452001,
-0.0033347975,
0.0024630185,
-0.0321985893,
0.0143162934,
-0.0227076877,
-0.0481697805,
-0.0240262169,
0.0042255935,
0.0092626354,
-0.0110351061,
-0.0442538969,
-0.0245528743,
0.0101756202,
-0.0129445465,
-0.0284189675,
0.0469742268,
-0.0245659128,
-0.032418821,
0.0115950815,
-0.0595661998,
0.006806355,
-0.0530516915,
-0.021882154,
0.0466179885,
0.047898706,
-0.0167012103,
0.0075108139,
-0.0364219658,
0.030017985,
0.0061676628,
0.0134307966,
0.0361108594,
0.0501808748,
0.0147344749,
0.0370065346,
-0.0128686354,
0.0164378025,
-0.0218360368,
0.0061559663,
0.0378803648,
0.0274714548,
0.0275700502,
0.0242680684,
0.0096195526,
0.0138344225,
-0.0479112864,
0.0293058474,
0.0113183679,
0.0638561025,
0.0071655139,
0.0476096682,
-0.0442356952,
0.0101258066,
-0.0316008031,
-0.0164202973,
-0.0061872709,
-0.0486545973,
0.0326980874,
0.00675742,
0.0052748844,
-0.0276028123,
0.0512020476,
-0.0050006565,
-0.0151890852,
0.0470849052,
-0.0153976362,
0.0014566981,
-0.0016315184,
0.0086478377,
-0.0260630772,
-0.0253736954,
0.040991798,
-0.0054160333,
-0.000946647,
0.007157112,
-0.0052426364,
0.0735363215,
-0.0462092645,
0.0083832787,
-0.0109947594,
-0.0111299418,
-0.0120666111,
0.0159288254,
0.0475745238,
-0.0505786724,
-0.0249390472,
0.0480019711,
-0.0165595151,
-0.0789316297,
0.0015147555,
-0.025499329,
-0.0254843887,
-0.0139114615,
-0.014327989,
-0.0021801859,
-0.0184067208,
0.0107444059,
-0.0019352725,
-0.0381365344,
-0.0234204307,
-0.0011202092,
2.919e-7,
-0.0183060318,
0.0417777933,
-0.0519905575,
-0.0076044076,
-0.0316518433,
0.0345371477,
-0.0257507898,
0.0059474828,
0.0664965063,
0.0029624987,
0.0818496495,
0.0605358519,
0.0355103314,
0.0144964987,
-0.1050457805,
-0.0213798489,
-0.0447849371,
0.0330636278,
-0.0283568222,
-0.020279957,
0.0399326943,
0.061225187,
0.0453708768,
-0.0105520226,
0.0332016237,
-0.0524657518,
0.0521292239,
-0.0870440751,
-0.0004619258,
0.030139206,
0.0314644799,
-0.0193435214,
-0.0396552645,
-0.0345954075,
-0.0393375903,
0.0188496076,
0.0573176444,
0.0485232994,
-0.0037471964,
-0.0060694371,
-0.0575627126,
0.0265483335,
0.0219021998,
-0.0625614077,
0.0809344798,
0.0170169156,
-0.0146505637,
-0.010866086,
-0.0535147004,
-0.054514356,
-0.0198026001,
-0.0245622098,
-0.0361958183,
-0.0134971347,
0.0117737008,
0.0201547872,
-0.0155479014,
-0.0672834963,
-0.0009179408,
0.045155298,
-0.035006389,
0.0071812742,
-0.0481570661,
0.032771796,
0.0024393492,
-0.0544072427,
0.0244987421,
2.175404054e-34,
-0.0248493254,
-0.0402759947,
0.0233183578,
-0.039652165,
0.039730113,
0.0271519925,
0.0159709584,
0.0223926008,
0.0571861751,
-0.0755170956,
0.0142678935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07682v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07682v1 | Fuse to Forget: Bias Reduction and Selective Memorization through Model Fusion | 2023-11-13T19:02:56 | 2023-11-13T19:02:56 | Kerem Zaman, Leshem Choshen, Shashank Srivastava | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Model fusion research aims to aggregate the knowledge of multiple models to
enhance performance by combining their weights. In this work, we study the
inverse, investigating whether and how can model fusion interfere and reduce
unwanted knowledge. We delve into the effects of model fusion on the evolution
of learned shortcuts, social biases, and memorization capabilities in
fine-tuned language models. Through several experiments covering text
classification and generation tasks, our analysis highlights that shared
knowledge among models is usually enhanced during model fusion, while unshared
knowledge is usually lost or forgotten. Based on this observation, we
demonstrate the potential of model fusion as a debiasing tool and showcase its
efficacy in addressing privacy concerns associated with language models. | [
0.037178155,
0.0794772506,
-0.0270805229,
0.0209348612,
-0.0309571493,
0.0116611402,
0.0670968592,
-0.0377956554,
0.0254277233,
-0.048542425,
-0.0557304025,
-0.02437222,
0.0340661667,
0.012849818,
0.0311218724,
-0.0233243089,
0.0366801098,
-0.0202236027,
-0.0015417233,
-0.0378021002,
-0.0110868774,
0.0164746009,
0.0145468852,
0.0356050394,
0.0074165352,
0.0219361912,
0.020739926,
-0.0115199797,
0.0254231226,
0.0246204231,
0.0259857867,
0.077059105,
-0.0079538459,
0.0764521584,
0.0000017262,
-0.0595608689,
-0.0319961458,
0.0124512557,
-0.0356270857,
0.029885618,
0.027266115,
0.0132271294,
0.0196718704,
0.0255968347,
-0.0349677689,
0.0060493792,
0.0264332723,
0.0352147296,
0.0235727411,
0.0317180678,
0.002235698,
-0.0079778256,
0.0161851868,
-0.0612131022,
-0.0002860685,
-0.0263363197,
0.0361938514,
-0.0353821367,
-0.0636644587,
-0.029835552,
0.0306634232,
0.0342402197,
0.0084743993,
0.0354473703,
0.0487108715,
0.0807164386,
0.0018264356,
-0.0379080549,
-0.0202794373,
0.0285958517,
-0.0065911813,
-0.0579966977,
0.0325442329,
0.0128021352,
0.0583894961,
0.0318563692,
-0.031610135,
0.0101250103,
-0.0253522061,
-0.0028030251,
0.0063021453,
-0.0360709876,
0.0554460287,
0.0254285075,
-0.0001551625,
0.0164462533,
0.0192937814,
-0.0050156042,
-0.0192063544,
-0.0066564111,
0.005401161,
-0.0886989385,
0.0245680455,
0.0028437087,
0.0493719764,
0.0116319032,
-0.0883118734,
-0.0134767862,
0.0401100926,
-0.0427333489,
0.0133725442,
-0.0085389446,
0.0240498949,
0.0501457304,
-0.0526741631,
-0.0000193897,
0.0053677987,
0.0373145305,
0.007658883,
0.0197741389,
-0.0518738106,
-0.0352854766,
0.0201994888,
0.0519082174,
-0.0209720004,
0.0040005264,
-0.028473977,
0.0134006562,
-0.0193621423,
0.0121119032,
-0.0339860916,
0.0263755769,
-0.0102656242,
-0.0082995445,
-0.0225193668,
-0.0036749993,
-0.0337859318,
0.0327189378,
0.0312508158,
-0.0476364307,
-0.0278619081,
-0.0327788666,
-0.0096995924,
-0.0026262347,
-0.0150139984,
0.0399113931,
-0.0489516407,
-0.0511885025,
-0.0372640416,
-0.0688059554,
-0.0175592322,
-0.0573619083,
0.0054227901,
-0.0570152737,
0.0577268936,
0.0241029784,
0.0006588234,
-0.0724334195,
-0.0207394939,
0.0006833685,
-0.0664065033,
0.050293602,
-0.0026810421,
0.0002103906,
0.060512118,
0.0420282558,
0.0116492156,
0.0636190549,
-0.0158220492,
0.0257396996,
-0.0068987575,
-0.0024343135,
0.0219172146,
-0.005024048,
0.065367423,
0.0284677073,
-0.0259136353,
-0.0291744471,
0.0075829844,
-0.0565814003,
-0.0070487866,
0.0612910837,
-0.0401856937,
-0.0070536966,
0.0744681358,
0.043963436,
-0.0070479973,
0.0516719818,
-0.0351755843,
-0.0225742329,
-0.014225387,
0.0235874727,
-0.077520363,
0.0201156139,
-0.0832264274,
-0.0152958287,
0.0214279927,
0.0652945563,
-0.0195541903,
-0.0193538442,
-0.0019344137,
-0.0310306437,
0.0342180207,
0.0231499784,
0.0135007948,
0.0271078385,
-0.0035377727,
0.0896248817,
0.0315193236,
-0.0849134326,
0.0169848036,
-0.0472175144,
0.0238482617,
0.0303166155,
0.0269113332,
0.0002368895,
-0.0032193859,
-0.0200287644,
-0.0529528707,
-0.020313751,
0.083435975,
-0.0148144383,
0.0263454076,
-0.0406835154,
-0.0566203035,
0.0073026591,
0.0287185721,
0.0402572639,
0.0043847789,
-0.0244615451,
0.0367985889,
-0.0084822634,
-0.0182793774,
0.019761391,
-0.0496166907,
-0.0291574635,
-0.0375548564,
0.0109786512,
0.0042295586,
0.0005006429,
-0.0054420591,
0.0226855967,
0.0349945202,
0.0210784692,
-0.0361675657,
0.0201633386,
-0.0534148738,
-0.0100113554,
-0.0003208635,
0.0094474591,
0.0271716304,
0.0050454489,
0.0113759311,
-0.0456702374,
0.0115652131,
-0.0070879986,
0.0896414369,
-0.0106524965,
0.0357750505,
-0.0353790186,
-0.0157288853,
-0.0397708416,
0.0873029307,
-0.0502684005,
-0.0373095609,
-0.0038240731,
-0.0656471625,
0.0055976505,
-0.0044980342,
0.0057500256,
-0.0111945029,
-0.0001349295,
0.018734565,
0.0461617336,
-0.0711129457,
-0.0386507362,
-0.055659052,
-0.0711775273,
0.0109484997,
0.000378633,
0.0040357588,
0.0002252051,
-0.0124392696,
0.0017029152,
-0.0117377304,
-0.0514440499,
-0.0446913354,
-0.0414870046,
0.0564200655,
-0.02606171,
0.0315011069,
-0.0105350139,
-0.0191763323,
-0.0269092601,
-0.0265453551,
0.0436097048,
0.009879943,
-0.0014128413,
-0.0260927808,
0.0045715636,
-0.0452320501,
0.0198130067,
-0.01600549,
-0.0031492189,
-0.0016950392,
0.0247552898,
0.0225215871,
0.0885036141,
0.0015632737,
0.0254846364,
0.0889072418,
0.0114627834,
-0.0380791053,
-0.010295446,
-0.030938169,
-0.0078107682,
-0.0286409762,
-0.0029759246,
-0.0140823359,
0.0444614477,
0.0292416755,
-0.0258308183,
-0.0452305377,
0.0507232286,
-0.0019399234,
-0.0717195645,
-0.0125334905,
-0.0622131079,
-0.0052860887,
0.0277591329,
-0.0428983346,
-0.0684627965,
0.0782397613,
-0.0124719189,
0.0184935369,
-0.0009811616,
-0.0141265485,
0.003574766,
0.0176098645,
0.016808074,
0.0447062105,
0.0245867819,
-0.0085960859,
-0.0485294051,
-0.0221690368,
0.0626316369,
-0.0364032499,
0.0362922773,
-0.0159173533,
-0.0128500117,
-0.0024887682,
-0.0349986106,
-0.0419711955,
-0.0716706365,
-0.0267901868,
0.0127118882,
-0.0029884758,
-0.042821832,
-0.0409224741,
-0.0449544489,
0.0496390313,
0.0053260494,
-0.0037780756,
-0.0159274992,
-0.0109593859,
0.015778115,
0.0197716206,
-0.03628527,
0.0316135325,
-0.0544355623,
-0.0026147203,
0.0637183934,
0.0871558562,
0.0319147408,
-0.0044971672,
-0.0355545394,
0.0290211439,
0.0136324922,
-0.0346842371,
0.0210356917,
0.0375727005,
-0.0270416457,
0.0342756808,
0.0745126531,
0.0178215522,
-0.0505981185,
-0.034012232,
0.0290307924,
0.0856289566,
0.0379001833,
-0.0207059681,
-0.0375362635,
-0.0053428346,
0.0371716768,
0.036309015,
-0.030169148,
-0.0239209179,
-0.0053354902,
-0.1156530306,
-0.0399601907,
0.0353181623,
0.0100870924,
0.0185804926,
-0.0366185308,
-0.0021462752,
-0.0150029082,
-0.0113423364,
-0.019975761,
-0.0069008321,
-0.0081153186,
0.0247600023,
0.0197647084,
-0.0524061657,
-0.0095620565,
-0.0204805229,
0.0509027429,
0.072933048,
0.0323385634,
-0.0114133544,
-0.0728153884,
0.0572745912,
0.0080746012,
0.0120578036,
-0.0068094507,
0.0775969252,
-0.020419877,
0.0113007249,
-0.0006020241,
0.0749168843,
0.0029930209,
-0.025173476,
-0.0235734303,
0.0222409386,
0.0147352275,
-0.0395918898,
0.0096364114,
-0.0361815989,
-0.0054197628,
0.0795081928,
0.0346432254,
-0.0047014896,
0.0313937962,
-0.0169539731,
0.0202096868,
0.0049382015,
-0.0132579207,
0.043516729,
0.0040197205,
-0.0466092713,
-0.0607763194,
0.0069318926,
0.0007555266,
0.031078238,
0.0500719398,
0.0208149422,
-0.0023525015,
-0.0210470762,
-0.0130005293,
0.03858798,
-0.0310453232,
0.0013569243,
-0.0368205346,
-0.0045611742,
0.0005304757,
-0.0191755332,
-0.0210845508,
0.0078545921,
-0.085569784,
-0.1147488132,
0.0330366492,
0.0500137396,
0.0277874321,
0.045722425,
0.0140755698,
-0.0766423792,
0.06618765,
0.0729004219,
-0.0163565297,
0.0216401685,
0.0405499935,
-0.0613328032,
-0.0323729776,
0.0051283566,
-0.0187106691,
-0.0230792668,
0.0481730513,
-0.0590923466,
-0.0531083234,
-0.0322617069,
0.0097138938,
-0.0011446225,
0.0594209842,
-0.0390751287,
0.0318756104,
-0.0338984355,
0.0044681313,
0.0152491191,
0.000586672,
0.0029593222,
-0.0399573296,
0.030856885,
0.0158773754,
0.0436647907,
-0.0092315115,
0.0488471873,
0.0300743822,
-0.0572089143,
-0.0148343565,
0.0387365632,
0.0248201452,
0.0251504686,
0.0163390413,
-0.0267612264,
0.0723662749,
-0.0261707064,
0.0165165998,
-0.0216160472,
0.027266968,
0.0182433538,
-0.0040485994,
-0.0138681103,
0.0277785826,
-0.0681366548,
-0.0654422119,
-0.0151572255,
-0.0110057555,
0.0266940221,
-0.0330856219,
0.0366097242,
-0.0178059116,
0.0006020384,
-0.0200003423,
-0.0059426082,
-0.0142055051,
-0.0216698553,
-0.0032449178,
-0.0016489704,
-0.0179025754,
0.0300566368,
0.1013445929,
-0.0075433343,
0.0593481772,
-0.0340886153,
-0.0274667069,
-0.0221585054,
-0.0299312659,
0.0438756645,
0.0238266811,
-0.0225202683,
-0.0024691429,
-0.0647393689,
-0.0625792146,
0.006514682,
0.0113499966,
0.0232762415,
-0.0240208786,
0.039543543,
0.0537062846,
-0.0471275896,
-0.0286580008,
-0.0294701811,
-0.0049067293,
0.0179753974,
0.0279440228,
0.0223239101,
-6.658171919e-33,
-0.0036007187,
-0.0093907407,
-0.0248192344,
-0.0120846434,
-0.0023908175,
-0.0033373623,
-0.0000946316,
0.0161482152,
-0.0200406555,
-0.0233763959,
-0.0161215588,
0.022807572,
0.0042170463,
-0.0014581288,
0.0034595325,
-0.0168156717,
0.082111001,
0.012516343,
-0.0274816249,
0.041504845,
0.0668171942,
0.0170102566,
0.0175956711,
-0.0692480952,
0.0344563983,
0.0225128122,
-0.0424112789,
-0.0040131481,
-0.0949830115,
0.0451170839,
-0.0051353346,
0.0102217095,
0.0082207806,
-0.0144807221,
-0.0301143751,
0.0365928449,
-0.0495385453,
-0.0081330035,
0.0062247408,
-0.0600801073,
0.0121369315,
-0.0566581711,
0.0650054291,
-0.0032390004,
0.001085183,
-0.0165041741,
0.0217780061,
-0.0055752816,
-0.0508776866,
-0.0159723721,
-0.0201200303,
-0.0034537488,
-0.0128942328,
-0.0205517896,
0.0273587033,
-0.0185094345,
0.0297214743,
-0.0214433335,
-0.0382381119,
0.0124193281,
0.0649727806,
0.0147583736,
0.0680512562,
0.037039388,
0.0181535147,
0.0737974942,
0.022276029,
0.0605318621,
0.0094226338,
-0.0429555476,
0.0355987884,
0.043815162,
0.0363569222,
0.0336334705,
0.0011161151,
-0.0373134613,
0.000628264,
0.0164231677,
-0.011885955,
0.001892245,
0.0385158658,
0.0067278058,
-0.0187168382,
-0.0277711712,
-0.0907841176,
-0.0251823086,
-0.0444392636,
0.0253448077,
-0.001219983,
0.0595780686,
-0.0419794247,
0.0004311948,
0.0016646894,
-0.0209391695,
-0.0173484311,
0.042549599,
0.0329106338,
-0.0092763025,
-0.0220140535,
-0.0233147368,
-0.080312416,
-0.0045871879,
-0.010627252,
0.0209072139,
0.0098615699,
0.0219518188,
0.0528532825,
0.0077664992,
-0.0599339865,
0.0038792973,
-0.0363996588,
0.0312351752,
0.0612262413,
-0.0138967624,
0.0562801212,
0.0263228752,
-0.0079895724,
0.0005915419,
0.0281031094,
0.0192393605,
-0.0684431791,
0.0570325591,
-0.0223399084,
0.0152729023,
0.0200916119,
-0.034515366,
-0.0072371769,
0.0026512088,
0.0950565711,
0.010395512,
-0.0060781441,
-0.0396427661,
2.525e-7,
-0.0270279068,
-0.0033025073,
-0.0017428002,
-0.0345240682,
-0.0126467785,
0.0879793018,
-0.0045165061,
0.0453906022,
0.0272349007,
0.0047385599,
-0.0497226939,
0.0299116578,
0.045969937,
0.0313090272,
-0.0347322971,
-0.021737054,
-0.0685872436,
0.031126108,
-0.032323949,
0.0047159041,
-0.0046976935,
0.0694967434,
0.0616234355,
-0.0243520513,
-0.0108900657,
-0.0394945219,
0.0773894563,
-0.0333563834,
0.0005276391,
0.0160394609,
0.0493164249,
0.0383119956,
0.0065102298,
0.0380972214,
-0.0311133042,
0.002950371,
-0.0450902209,
0.0348665006,
0.0131605072,
-0.0233331192,
0.0075803977,
0.0014617298,
-0.0215552058,
-0.0506721437,
0.0548326857,
-0.0370718688,
-0.0005152762,
-0.0198140014,
0.0304039586,
-0.0285538025,
0.0443324074,
0.0025657236,
0.0103685092,
0.0131095359,
-0.0323763937,
0.0355778299,
0.0111223916,
-0.0969576016,
-0.0292500444,
0.007265815,
-0.0359630808,
-0.0500514098,
0.0078480272,
-0.0050815651,
-0.0027273679,
-0.0499036759,
0.028796142,
2.200885649e-34,
-0.0230200384,
-0.0191363655,
0.0244860779,
0.0032045895,
0.0348476768,
-0.0352336951,
-0.0213797502,
0.0027090684,
0.0383438841,
-0.0686818138,
-0.0028105027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07575v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07575v1 | SPHINX: The Joint Mixing of Weights, Tasks, and Visual Embeddings for Multi-modal Large Language Models | 2023-11-13T18:59:47 | 2023-11-13T18:59:47 | Ziyi Lin, Chris Liu, Renrui Zhang, Peng Gao, Longtian Qiu, Han Xiao, Han Qiu, Chen Lin, Wenqi Shao, Keqin Chen, Jiaming Han, Siyuan Huang, Yichi Zhang, Xuming He, Hongsheng Li, Yu Qiao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | We present SPHINX, a versatile multi-modal large language model (MLLM) with a
joint mixing of model weights, tuning tasks, and visual embeddings. First, for
stronger vision-language alignment, we unfreeze the large language model (LLM)
during pre-training, and introduce a weight mix strategy between LLMs trained
by real-world and synthetic data. By directly integrating the weights from two
domains, the mixed LLM can efficiently incorporate diverse semantics with
favorable robustness. Then, to enable multi-purpose capabilities, we mix a
variety of tasks for joint visual instruction tuning, and design task-specific
instructions to avoid inter-task conflict. In addition to the basic visual
question answering, we include more challenging tasks such as region-level
understanding, caption grounding, document layout detection, and human pose
estimation, contributing to mutual enhancement over different scenarios.
Additionally, we propose to extract comprehensive visual embeddings from
various network architectures, pre-training paradigms, and information
granularity, providing language models with more robust image representations.
Based on our proposed joint mixing, SPHINX exhibits superior multi-modal
understanding capabilities on a wide range of applications. On top of this, we
further propose an efficient strategy aiming to better capture fine-grained
appearances of high-resolution images. With a mixing of different scales and
high-resolution sub-images, SPHINX attains exceptional visual parsing and
reasoning performance on existing evaluation benchmarks. We hope our work may
cast a light on the exploration of joint mixing in future MLLM research. Code
is released at https://github.com/Alpha-VLLM/LLaMA2-Accessory. | [
0.037656635,
0.069480136,
0.0175520238,
0.0872719735,
0.0048605404,
0.0297638681,
-0.0006043366,
-0.0262579918,
0.0117579661,
-0.0718330964,
-0.0513859913,
-0.0107218139,
0.0004657173,
0.0313907191,
0.0402374715,
-0.0408478417,
0.0204376709,
-0.03890986,
-0.0170898438,
0.0094518121,
0.0450019129,
0.0259675384,
0.0088226246,
0.0178113226,
0.0063086455,
-0.0400165953,
-0.0248181149,
0.0292853005,
0.0290583633,
0.0056816046,
-0.0092628319,
0.0404611938,
0.0829189792,
0.0370557308,
0.0000017445,
-0.0036258129,
0.0246573258,
0.0087492988,
-0.0003491074,
-0.0112149911,
0.0245978907,
-0.0404187404,
0.0040266793,
-0.0324659012,
-0.0382454135,
-0.0290694125,
0.0472743325,
0.0655351877,
0.0766911879,
0.0635844544,
-0.0162716527,
-0.0284961052,
0.0043543694,
-0.0296157543,
0.0108261062,
-0.0485357605,
0.0024179306,
0.0412861891,
-0.0121125197,
0.0192289725,
-0.0276343133,
0.0255325492,
0.0371841937,
-0.0204916392,
-0.0300098117,
0.0312898755,
-0.0012058706,
-0.0335911363,
-0.022458747,
0.0947907642,
-0.0389647558,
0.0017214526,
-0.0324494317,
0.0050383601,
0.0170058366,
-0.0279895179,
-0.0329790153,
0.0301525127,
-0.0019149861,
0.039153982,
-0.0156770777,
-0.0198391285,
0.015905302,
0.0295367576,
-0.0282422118,
0.0020970698,
0.0098767234,
0.0316192284,
-0.0119687077,
0.0237993356,
-0.0502250828,
-0.0327400155,
-0.0096995831,
0.0500020087,
-0.0323019959,
0.0014214055,
-0.0352922231,
-0.0470024571,
-0.0020190962,
-0.0275318157,
0.0390445851,
0.0172940381,
-0.0664472878,
0.089193888,
-0.0350490846,
0.0613507517,
-0.0520667359,
0.0380040668,
-0.0608113334,
-0.0163569115,
-0.0088016074,
-0.0107484981,
-0.0251112264,
0.0033795056,
-0.0683625787,
-0.0483604111,
0.0031247826,
0.0246821288,
-0.0098196007,
0.019549625,
0.0161554459,
0.0303935688,
-0.0405848473,
-0.0346429944,
-0.0053807981,
0.0495720096,
-0.0321832262,
0.0499159731,
-0.0028901976,
-0.0264144167,
-0.0129570952,
0.0380721316,
0.0079369666,
-0.0263995398,
0.0045654527,
0.0672848895,
-0.0522712469,
-0.011102723,
-0.0258946605,
-0.0069669345,
-0.0089797843,
-0.0761454925,
0.0393477157,
-0.0488980487,
0.0489100963,
-0.0280087031,
-0.0022593185,
-0.0000170526,
0.0008675409,
0.0003678294,
-0.0085530616,
0.1132635251,
0.0046207216,
-0.032445237,
-0.0035400223,
0.0142793525,
0.004632853,
0.1053327546,
0.0123390993,
0.0498942919,
0.0018530611,
0.0177891832,
-0.0238357093,
0.033111617,
-0.0138494624,
0.0048723198,
-0.0230009761,
0.02967331,
0.0376610644,
0.0230416954,
0.0552373491,
0.028413564,
-0.0315462872,
-0.0089074085,
0.0731825382,
0.0159002524,
-0.0023151832,
-0.0033403824,
0.0337885879,
0.002884269,
0.008582266,
0.0026902,
-0.0876586139,
0.0382481888,
-0.0087869531,
0.0019038577,
-0.013945939,
0.0691594556,
-0.0408528037,
-0.0271336548,
-0.0048507755,
-0.0254152548,
0.0113620097,
0.0241391081,
0.0428949855,
0.0148522323,
-0.0411312431,
0.0240273569,
0.0280592125,
0.0032092957,
-0.0125962729,
-0.0311110914,
0.0190481581,
0.059858568,
-0.0078112697,
-0.0222146008,
-0.0170051251,
0.0078234142,
0.0589350052,
0.0559991859,
-0.0031748225,
0.0011532957,
0.0402712375,
-0.0701717958,
-0.0459448621,
-0.0397941098,
-0.0099024102,
0.0146291638,
0.0107294293,
-0.0070672072,
0.0168396309,
-0.0433288887,
0.0075990125,
0.0470719375,
0.0357349999,
-0.0015175327,
-0.0466357358,
0.028696835,
-0.0083507942,
-0.0084789861,
-0.0073222881,
-0.0110055301,
0.0176806506,
-0.0476191714,
0.0092493817,
-0.0096659437,
-0.0548531674,
-0.0613281503,
0.0309433285,
-0.0255050994,
-0.0439091846,
0.0371505171,
-0.069799833,
-0.0218910426,
-0.0128127746,
-0.014412351,
0.015216195,
-0.0548562668,
-0.0334965549,
0.0338197649,
0.0312204901,
-0.0542786568,
0.0525366999,
-0.0065181693,
-0.0145732509,
0.0191679895,
-0.0005410484,
-0.0076728831,
-0.0118834795,
-0.0428288393,
0.0084411101,
0.0042776056,
0.0166188609,
-0.0316721052,
0.0254594535,
-0.0408948623,
-0.0476301759,
-0.0926778466,
0.0030121186,
-0.0422408693,
-0.0061599957,
0.0215867665,
0.00186462,
0.0151495095,
-0.0535535887,
-0.0373724885,
0.018692812,
0.0064086537,
0.0036468774,
0.0176974908,
0.0203725826,
0.0177841019,
-0.0199696738,
0.0051117288,
0.0030570561,
0.0624683499,
0.0254534092,
-0.0021720529,
-0.0501639917,
0.0007069641,
-0.0166702494,
0.0462298729,
-0.034482941,
-0.0312722027,
0.0078076329,
-0.0340166651,
0.0449917689,
0.1237703264,
-0.0139210876,
0.0282078143,
0.0302800871,
-0.0057284948,
-0.0295250379,
0.013130568,
0.0245146975,
-0.0197993182,
-0.0524572283,
0.0113291023,
-0.0489618778,
0.0516330525,
-0.0518427156,
0.001600574,
-0.0409308672,
0.0090304632,
-0.0036751644,
-0.0427396446,
-0.0397247598,
0.0229164455,
0.018934885,
0.0142454039,
-0.0650813729,
-0.0587366596,
0.0458784588,
-0.0279029589,
-0.0386797115,
-0.0090362113,
-0.0233171042,
-0.0438406803,
0.0639833137,
0.0351088084,
0.0296497755,
-0.0080451826,
-0.0087082461,
-0.0635517165,
-0.0180256814,
0.0067500737,
-0.0101117482,
0.0565027855,
-0.0458270684,
0.0148290992,
-0.0626850054,
-0.0333248638,
-0.0140702259,
-0.0251027811,
-0.0385263227,
0.0089214817,
-0.0358353369,
-0.0104501257,
-0.0270779412,
0.0155215841,
0.0174564235,
0.0273094866,
-0.0309199933,
0.0124932826,
-0.0405419767,
0.0413156226,
0.0723649487,
0.0896708369,
-0.0059375097,
-0.041251298,
0.0101510547,
0.0489036888,
0.0216109697,
-0.0154658882,
-0.0556896701,
0.0460634045,
0.029635461,
0.0447722152,
0.0009149362,
0.0172028076,
0.0625122041,
-0.0714091137,
-0.0009763212,
0.0798671991,
0.0063739987,
-0.0381257087,
-0.0460208394,
-0.0021098168,
0.04915905,
0.0396501496,
0.0334969498,
-0.0760462359,
-0.0558025539,
-0.0033003839,
-0.0368103683,
0.0565677844,
0.019584069,
-0.0134792095,
-0.0697934479,
0.0405738018,
0.0026439019,
-0.0244176593,
-0.0386114419,
0.021130925,
-0.0136659034,
0.0032008772,
0.0155031485,
-0.0255368352,
-0.0039534364,
-0.0207557958,
0.0112365857,
0.0485302769,
-0.0250628088,
0.0117337089,
-0.0446560979,
-0.0100980308,
0.0221197419,
0.023155855,
-0.0123412609,
-0.0475224294,
0.0315005817,
0.0131256776,
-0.0115722828,
0.0184304267,
0.0295290723,
-0.0289750639,
-0.0459591597,
-0.0095150741,
0.0295665506,
-0.0345915593,
-0.0189296361,
-0.0203415379,
0.0430084616,
-0.0029424629,
0.0131125106,
-0.0102950865,
-0.0141972778,
-0.0063814973,
0.0483268574,
0.0367318876,
-0.0285581611,
-0.03377904,
-0.017466763,
-0.0239853133,
-0.0440656021,
-0.0202822927,
0.0266322326,
0.0060102688,
0.0154632414,
-0.0399072953,
-0.0335627757,
0.0470791459,
0.0437504612,
-0.0177719053,
-0.0304748882,
-0.0071735037,
0.0004344165,
-0.0573703051,
0.0820739716,
-0.0463834964,
0.0267281029,
-0.0400681943,
0.0027648744,
0.0558088422,
-0.0290816668,
-0.024291344,
0.0108082248,
-0.1086296067,
-0.0513596945,
-0.0169070791,
0.0464205965,
0.0090763373,
0.0622950047,
0.0005139394,
-0.0305826869,
0.0176141001,
0.0115500959,
0.0089785475,
0.0191170089,
0.0198807977,
-0.0457039773,
0.007188695,
0.0399176031,
-0.0459045097,
-0.0019507274,
0.0105880648,
0.0036694848,
-0.0165331252,
-0.0107056303,
0.0060509327,
-0.006734679,
0.005179482,
-0.0041033044,
0.0221125353,
-0.0447155461,
0.0261313189,
0.0034385293,
-0.0283780936,
-0.0815133825,
-0.0149271991,
0.0141045945,
-0.0006583203,
0.0264138076,
0.0415604785,
0.0479993075,
0.0367891267,
-0.0358137563,
0.0189156402,
-0.0059239743,
-0.0248697624,
0.0166300926,
0.0238575246,
-0.0078036548,
0.0213223584,
-0.0115385596,
0.0420766398,
-0.0177204795,
0.0413781367,
0.0475434549,
-0.0365312994,
-0.0447804257,
0.0525215045,
-0.0378557593,
-0.0493598133,
-0.0301821642,
0.0372153558,
0.066104643,
-0.0217105672,
0.0135607785,
0.0109541062,
-0.0394168124,
0.0011608105,
0.0346557051,
0.0168457683,
-0.0286344197,
0.0852226764,
0.0330228657,
0.0012103727,
-0.004667249,
0.0626296774,
0.0331643149,
0.0351937115,
0.0083436687,
0.0148956161,
-0.0499709547,
-0.0430184491,
0.0403190777,
0.0023352758,
-0.0187365692,
0.0173478704,
0.0030917977,
-0.0694336519,
-0.0262352321,
0.0287497733,
-0.0606220998,
0.0187966526,
0.0410086028,
0.0431581736,
0.0246947911,
-0.0142972544,
0.0024263496,
-0.0033060857,
0.0176004544,
0.011166024,
0.0160675142,
-5.760449087e-33,
-0.0496284515,
-0.0193241034,
0.0338348113,
-0.0302457381,
-0.028737599,
0.0371187441,
-0.0239054114,
-0.0028985494,
-0.0457782894,
0.0213531777,
0.0284279343,
0.0005589628,
0.019087879,
0.0457702652,
-0.0277881566,
-0.0100677731,
0.013812854,
-0.0089830589,
0.0037371409,
-0.0072711776,
-0.0090946313,
0.0068653268,
0.0391801521,
-0.0164224356,
-0.0103773344,
0.0113681667,
-0.0232750867,
0.0546889082,
-0.0199281909,
0.0798012614,
-0.0317170173,
0.0078089354,
0.0236491356,
-0.0118710725,
-0.0409686752,
0.0444353409,
-0.091602616,
0.0004118021,
0.0387134627,
0.0531595014,
-0.0742437318,
-0.0061718798,
0.0379809178,
-0.0163342226,
0.0516349636,
-0.0412340872,
0.0485881679,
-0.0131563405,
0.0059679472,
0.0052923495,
-0.0548722371,
-0.0116434563,
-0.0037741039,
-0.0284170769,
0.0297191162,
0.0022320577,
0.0354860052,
0.0513681918,
-0.0265196431,
-0.0157876778,
-0.0093792025,
0.0371011794,
0.0642247126,
0.0846298859,
-0.004806242,
0.0453507341,
-0.0014417082,
-0.0227288101,
-0.0414144695,
-0.0230182204,
0.0301366523,
0.0621076263,
0.0428188629,
0.0358071513,
-0.0116456142,
0.0598080531,
-0.0773284063,
0.0044739963,
-0.0147389211,
0.0630124509,
-0.0108168954,
0.0275959,
0.0290605761,
0.0095464876,
-0.0415867567,
0.0234623812,
-0.0457458347,
0.0217011869,
0.0474950336,
0.0340180211,
-0.0197989177,
0.0259541944,
0.0675283223,
-0.0506818555,
-0.0034183948,
0.018396575,
-0.0094509413,
0.0392034501,
0.0023335277,
0.0458412282,
-0.0182235744,
-0.0286707729,
0.0524364822,
-0.018366877,
-0.0062130746,
0.0088967877,
0.0573849156,
-0.0007239535,
-0.047901053,
0.0048848302,
-0.0617178455,
-0.0141260466,
0.0053331004,
0.0666383579,
0.0516876392,
-0.0137964329,
-0.0564990491,
0.0202175174,
-0.0115019344,
-0.0111802733,
-0.0244297646,
-0.0026999225,
-0.0015972755,
0.0368479751,
-0.0347695947,
0.0022098981,
-0.0502935313,
-0.0281714778,
0.0272025894,
-0.0636725873,
-0.011853369,
0.047128018,
2.39e-7,
0.0477906242,
0.0023427377,
0.0209880769,
0.0121088047,
0.0211534016,
0.0571776405,
-0.023802327,
0.0339631774,
-0.0037433307,
-0.0579548329,
-0.0254486389,
0.0819233954,
0.0347022191,
-0.0014349541,
-0.0544148311,
0.0401685275,
-0.0216350667,
-0.010160584,
-0.0561757386,
-0.0127880657,
0.0275218152,
0.1218324155,
-0.0404825658,
-0.0120874895,
0.0463315025,
-0.0655492097,
0.0785600096,
-0.0227255877,
-0.0178697612,
-0.012261359,
-0.0063162609,
0.0374101065,
-0.0371831171,
0.0121642565,
0.0140674273,
-0.0064438456,
0.0628956109,
0.06821087,
-0.0191966891,
0.0051964764,
-0.0264981482,
-0.0060437154,
-0.0209122561,
-0.0455852263,
0.0693343058,
-0.0581142902,
-0.033068575,
-0.0564199872,
-0.0250609387,
-0.0272412524,
0.0107622398,
-0.0124584539,
-0.0072563002,
0.0253049061,
0.0390380509,
-0.0439248383,
-0.0402683727,
-0.0897703841,
-0.041805435,
-0.0189784765,
-0.0587913319,
-0.0168154687,
-0.0662704632,
-0.0228734352,
0.0684771165,
-0.0600516535,
-0.0284670014,
2.10507712e-34,
0.0163514242,
-0.011529495,
0.025098592,
0.0404540002,
0.0319129191,
-0.0021272805,
-0.0740935355,
-0.0110530034,
-0.0123753799,
-0.0904721469,
-0.0064355601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07564v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07564v3 | Can Authorship Attribution Models Distinguish Speakers in Speech Transcripts? | 2023-11-13T18:54:17 | 2024-06-13T19:54:53 | Cristina Aggazzotti, Nicholas Andrews, Elizabeth Allyn Smith | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Authorship verification is the task of determining if two distinct writing
samples share the same author and is typically concerned with the attribution
of written text. In this paper, we explore the attribution of transcribed
speech, which poses novel challenges. The main challenge is that many stylistic
features, such as punctuation and capitalization, are not informative in this
setting. On the other hand, transcribed speech exhibits other patterns, such as
filler words and backchannels (e.g., 'um', 'uh-huh'), which may be
characteristic of different speakers. We propose a new benchmark for speaker
attribution focused on human-transcribed conversational speech transcripts. To
limit spurious associations of speakers with topic, we employ both conversation
prompts and speakers participating in the same conversation to construct
verification trials of varying difficulties. We establish the state of the art
on this new benchmark by comparing a suite of neural and non-neural baselines,
finding that although written text attribution models achieve surprisingly good
performance in certain settings, they perform markedly worse as conversational
topic is increasingly controlled. We present analyses of the impact of
transcription style on performance as well as the ability of fine-tuning on
speech transcripts to improve performance. | [
0.0155013679,
0.0755893737,
-0.0363067649,
0.0286110248,
-0.0610989816,
0.0153438048,
0.0832210481,
-0.0153327463,
-0.0367746018,
-0.0084901508,
-0.02354775,
-0.0279645845,
0.0872655809,
-0.0059820213,
0.0354085714,
0.0159207843,
-0.015083923,
0.0220426768,
0.0581219681,
0.0059056394,
0.0186164323,
-0.0014563106,
-0.0116915116,
0.0272775926,
-0.0275744312,
-0.0381808095,
0.0464172624,
0.0361638293,
0.0416589044,
0.0481103584,
0.029688837,
0.0893032998,
-0.0412120782,
0.0927990675,
0.0000015952,
-0.0362430029,
0.017539721,
-0.0259862784,
-0.0172690302,
-0.0015120786,
0.0335899368,
0.0858850926,
-0.0140660619,
0.0203551482,
-0.0144514153,
-0.004777588,
0.011486318,
0.0770587623,
0.0214204937,
0.0722316578,
-0.0259604901,
-0.0331033058,
0.0455820635,
-0.0046288045,
-0.0080031985,
0.0186686888,
0.0192751028,
-0.0351346023,
-0.0281877909,
-0.020463746,
0.0295317862,
0.0622051321,
-0.0090506505,
-0.0108192032,
0.0098469881,
0.0183232743,
-0.0315480717,
0.0134727135,
0.0214871615,
0.0484176651,
0.0169998091,
-0.046294678,
0.0213150717,
0.0193257574,
0.0064454954,
-0.004406054,
-0.000745988,
0.0178717375,
-0.039201986,
-0.0322230794,
-0.0177867059,
0.0109254308,
0.0224293061,
0.0237318315,
0.0369903818,
0.0055823536,
0.003276678,
-0.0235738121,
-0.0220269337,
0.0185932945,
0.0324693173,
-0.0545961522,
0.0651846007,
-0.0371439792,
0.0130862128,
-0.0423295349,
-0.0382976755,
-0.0389216803,
0.0007613497,
-0.0247623175,
0.0239325482,
-0.0095514571,
-0.0346472785,
0.0254597925,
-0.0206222832,
0.0734245256,
-0.0261944849,
0.0219918825,
0.0051247622,
-0.0358746834,
-0.0413970873,
-0.0087457765,
-0.0201383084,
-0.0224206615,
0.0302513782,
-0.0089167235,
-0.0529344231,
-0.0187780447,
-0.007391925,
0.0128672207,
-0.0445158854,
-0.012043206,
-0.000653146,
0.0354946107,
0.014343881,
-0.0052233739,
-0.0273169596,
0.0469935536,
0.0078020883,
-0.0395335145,
-0.020368401,
0.0671669617,
0.0457947925,
-0.0432429649,
0.0132079851,
-0.0081011448,
-0.0201820154,
-0.0076665394,
0.0402135141,
-0.045683261,
-0.0280007366,
-0.0427102111,
-0.0211250726,
-0.0481254384,
0.0381366536,
-0.0014729155,
-0.0205869693,
-0.0560338311,
-0.0427946746,
0.0153363952,
-0.0244779512,
0.0529946536,
0.0352859385,
0.0246370919,
0.060698431,
0.0076466403,
-0.0058965008,
-0.0674062818,
0.0732576996,
0.020099286,
0.0107954424,
0.0100217657,
0.0589262955,
0.0316488668,
0.0170182995,
-0.0097163972,
0.0024718109,
-0.0230558757,
0.0321272016,
0.0328280106,
0.0171316583,
0.0574679226,
-0.020667769,
-0.0454141311,
0.0970189199,
0.0710892454,
-0.0149902049,
0.0188348535,
0.0060005677,
0.020346811,
0.0237514712,
-0.0020364099,
-0.0406562239,
0.0187586006,
-0.0062135691,
-0.0247757453,
0.0293581355,
-0.002755617,
-0.029231282,
0.0142564736,
0.0008953497,
-0.0033928188,
0.017434014,
0.0043482436,
-0.0327138789,
-0.0124966623,
-0.0034123347,
0.0106127374,
-0.0222052988,
-0.0759193078,
-0.003224028,
-0.029265007,
-0.0132963601,
0.031314753,
0.0424495414,
0.0096903145,
0.0184855629,
-0.0830783099,
-0.01107876,
0.0621166639,
0.0086008944,
-0.0064409627,
0.0636684597,
-0.0286829267,
0.0132711204,
0.0406045057,
0.005588254,
0.0457355455,
0.0285061784,
0.0062954631,
0.0304232873,
-0.0125695104,
-0.0043877224,
0.0161380302,
-0.0065998742,
-0.0322189741,
0.033981815,
0.019529961,
0.0456739962,
0.0193237122,
-0.0442976207,
-0.0085118469,
0.0025012444,
-0.0438018776,
-0.017427111,
0.0394130424,
-0.0382502042,
-0.0360270627,
0.0153320711,
-0.0383666828,
-0.0385833792,
0.0402407162,
0.0164527856,
-0.0680468008,
0.0186727438,
-0.0384173319,
-0.0264861472,
-0.0618203394,
0.0324109755,
-0.0482232794,
0.0100022405,
-0.027073361,
0.0187479164,
0.0521484502,
0.0176142789,
-0.0031772598,
-0.0330717973,
0.0527847074,
-0.0697839409,
-0.0451155715,
-0.0436563529,
-0.0328941531,
0.0413745344,
0.0207073912,
-0.0281138998,
-0.0012691884,
-0.0687966868,
-0.0806644633,
0.0025234029,
-0.0036918034,
0.023228813,
-0.0098851742,
0.0019183625,
0.002628786,
-0.0060988725,
-0.052561298,
-0.0614702776,
-0.0286685862,
0.0066947355,
0.0356291234,
0.0097127315,
-0.0287484732,
-0.039805185,
-0.0021954221,
-0.0328273475,
0.0313633792,
0.0381919965,
-0.0163710043,
-0.0139057226,
0.0155402627,
-0.0106177852,
-0.0041759163,
-0.0006129567,
-0.0022432245,
0.0245317407,
0.0145641658,
0.0454317443,
0.084304966,
0.0092505235,
-0.0590818897,
-0.0172750615,
-0.0096083181,
-0.043488469,
0.0002573495,
0.0178818386,
0.0326245762,
-0.0004173578,
-0.0542285368,
0.0066674948,
0.0403967015,
0.0279234685,
0.0057436763,
-0.0206312966,
0.0177710354,
0.0393084809,
-0.0151162576,
0.0246669408,
-0.051178176,
-0.0191465579,
-0.003125275,
-0.0624406338,
-0.0216697212,
0.0553765595,
-0.0850563571,
-0.011908954,
0.0179322958,
-0.0234575272,
-0.0340506397,
0.0358478464,
0.0105403243,
0.0238965936,
0.0190672446,
-0.0560255796,
-0.0125319911,
-0.0155206565,
0.0563533753,
-0.0220384467,
0.0018157098,
0.0235169828,
0.0221907962,
0.0010935441,
-0.0573163256,
-0.0252675284,
-0.0793020874,
-0.0172634851,
0.0277434625,
-0.0082974099,
-0.0428174138,
-0.0413958505,
-0.0588200837,
0.0516726077,
0.0378451049,
-0.0304326974,
0.0142724765,
-0.0248772409,
0.0715866312,
-0.0308093652,
0.0001135137,
-0.0156229837,
-0.0285075381,
-0.012288806,
-0.0326660052,
0.0212382395,
0.0654872879,
-0.0117347324,
-0.0457074381,
-0.0143301217,
-0.0007607297,
-0.0612670444,
0.0052189366,
0.0708469748,
-0.0125237983,
-0.0051492113,
0.1438837498,
-0.0213487074,
-0.0434657075,
-0.0587275103,
0.0098972628,
0.0218094699,
0.0022579778,
0.0131702628,
-0.035411302,
-0.0231370963,
0.0055869571,
0.0088931425,
-0.0184162688,
-0.0183389187,
-0.0324978642,
-0.0412580073,
0.0281013139,
-0.014066956,
-0.0788138509,
0.016991511,
-0.0376325101,
-0.0086702444,
-0.0106406473,
0.0026325653,
-0.0213796888,
0.0246279184,
-0.0110748028,
0.003365742,
-0.0203533098,
-0.0304286703,
0.0431069247,
-0.0667596236,
0.062088158,
0.042929288,
0.0824164823,
-0.0259630028,
-0.0304029565,
-0.0277297348,
-0.0262712799,
-0.0062268833,
0.009398195,
0.0764844418,
-0.0233551431,
0.0022955541,
-0.0574962236,
0.0405526496,
0.0198541358,
-0.0140960673,
0.0015582839,
0.0143517619,
-0.0178291872,
-0.0353708751,
0.0199934226,
0.033463724,
0.034233693,
0.0932724476,
0.0461450815,
-0.0421033055,
-0.0436165929,
-0.0031583442,
0.0459268801,
-0.0565210544,
-0.0315993428,
0.0064054062,
0.0173056219,
-0.0382289924,
-0.0728474408,
-0.0345294625,
-0.0539915264,
-0.0269031003,
0.0255548265,
0.0208500903,
0.0015620168,
-0.0318728425,
-0.047391098,
0.010904911,
-0.0428747237,
0.0554520935,
-0.0360869952,
0.0280973632,
0.0201192852,
-0.0365311876,
0.0009968438,
0.0424966142,
-0.0988116488,
-0.0382864997,
0.0341590196,
-0.0383442082,
0.0176582094,
0.0509625822,
-0.0233057141,
-0.0831512213,
0.037291836,
0.0260717776,
-0.0097040348,
0.041546382,
0.0186748151,
-0.0076939389,
-0.0399796963,
0.0137173058,
-0.0010029911,
0.0320269726,
0.0630508065,
-0.054168161,
-0.0399428234,
-0.0503382795,
-0.0451213382,
0.0134464251,
0.0382571407,
0.0122464849,
0.0175059177,
-0.022950951,
0.000273435,
0.0067478879,
0.0225420315,
0.0092417374,
-0.0448905788,
0.029540129,
0.0018358103,
-0.0241143927,
0.0083083026,
-0.0200788099,
0.0624906383,
-0.0441225469,
0.0038081529,
-0.0152283031,
0.0370833613,
-0.0374592915,
0.019441057,
-0.0115015013,
0.0554079749,
0.012785662,
0.0788691416,
0.0033920191,
-0.0034146921,
0.003424718,
0.0103554735,
-0.0011168375,
-0.0018299513,
-0.1228211895,
0.0067391726,
0.0095776515,
-0.0066181682,
0.0137763713,
-0.0170996785,
0.0502707548,
0.0084895957,
0.0423457697,
-0.0309350993,
0.038214542,
-0.0257141739,
0.0067771263,
-0.038224604,
-0.0104185548,
-0.013673665,
0.0488599278,
0.0540087745,
0.0365605243,
0.0105818631,
-0.023833489,
-0.0259614214,
-0.0247739311,
-0.0410615653,
0.0086088749,
0.0051619844,
0.0055016559,
-0.0200059284,
-0.0278888121,
-0.020278275,
0.0781512037,
-0.0110165635,
0.0663589835,
-0.0107067898,
-0.0070763715,
0.0242116991,
-0.0395869091,
-0.0303449109,
-0.0032296283,
0.0171761774,
0.0102291787,
-0.0589857437,
-0.0235842708,
-5.166253958e-33,
0.0007358224,
0.0005806259,
-0.0093470588,
0.0634652227,
-0.0050526587,
0.0043436741,
-0.052530475,
-0.0253599081,
-0.0130387451,
0.006653701,
-0.0353197865,
0.0381986573,
0.0223735236,
0.0223928597,
0.0040287953,
0.0171251968,
0.0819740072,
-0.0024010143,
-0.028323384,
0.0399518833,
0.0518729761,
-0.0045724274,
0.0034840738,
-0.0859188586,
0.0282288473,
-0.0628657788,
-0.0386392437,
-0.0039905636,
-0.0116475429,
0.0387584455,
-0.0099593531,
-0.016266685,
0.0106040705,
-0.017566815,
-0.0135386121,
0.0827626958,
-0.0877783075,
-0.0255870316,
-0.0182033554,
0.0171559919,
0.0282989405,
-0.0682688281,
0.0532100536,
-0.0430262312,
-0.0170198735,
-0.0212917607,
0.0764234141,
0.0235667918,
0.0157255549,
-0.0731664822,
-0.0140172094,
0.0175841022,
-0.0183019005,
-0.0161680356,
0.0281227492,
0.0260983706,
-0.0037335816,
-0.0492533371,
-0.0891045034,
0.0310325064,
-0.0302670747,
0.00940054,
-0.0070242221,
0.0434832014,
-0.033362411,
0.0547590777,
0.0548052043,
0.0466130748,
0.0022348533,
-0.0342188254,
0.0396996103,
0.0143587915,
0.0714217573,
0.0953222364,
0.0055453228,
-0.0198793802,
-0.0432974137,
0.0251713302,
0.0372307785,
-0.0534244291,
0.0272680596,
-0.0150446901,
-0.0526190735,
-0.0492453948,
-0.0760906786,
-0.0420857407,
-0.037103869,
0.0332620069,
0.0183981657,
-0.0136277433,
0.0234869458,
-0.034763623,
0.0506577492,
-0.0410482436,
0.0093191098,
0.0112778852,
-0.0298646837,
0.0538057983,
-0.0048446893,
0.0055448613,
-0.0174887087,
-0.0234646145,
0.0512529016,
0.0611504987,
0.0531567633,
0.0092307646,
0.0946959406,
0.0052870051,
-0.0645112023,
-0.0083323577,
0.0245418623,
0.0258665215,
-0.0046615074,
-0.0123294927,
-0.0087937899,
0.039299164,
0.0322310701,
0.0124046076,
0.0167723875,
0.0172200035,
-0.0221114662,
-0.0438505821,
0.0033511487,
-0.0013441204,
-0.0385124572,
-0.0031885228,
0.0105550364,
-0.0045518805,
0.0094170719,
-0.0105230687,
0.0236080885,
-0.015028608,
2.197e-7,
-0.0178718157,
0.0333469696,
0.0507501177,
-0.0229931064,
0.035885632,
0.0373566709,
0.0308838114,
0.0287053138,
0.000168087,
-0.0083799837,
0.0142158354,
0.0129130119,
0.1041557044,
0.0234564748,
-0.086849995,
-0.0112419259,
-0.0799441263,
0.0251785964,
-0.0388433039,
-0.0021816746,
0.0348857269,
0.0212142654,
0.0398106538,
-0.0417313576,
-0.0296226889,
-0.0636822283,
0.0611552559,
-0.0092656063,
0.0080178399,
0.0361615308,
0.0450107194,
-0.0439971201,
0.0129158916,
0.0593035258,
0.0009255941,
0.0222059656,
-0.0047433781,
0.0591643378,
-0.0051136068,
-0.0253362507,
-0.051416751,
-0.0206475761,
-0.0123627018,
-0.0246815402,
0.0157868583,
0.0377456844,
-0.0270617902,
-0.006350006,
0.0005956644,
-0.0284080207,
0.0473460332,
0.0078102155,
-0.0012735242,
0.0146358972,
0.0002625772,
0.0034498582,
-0.0100949071,
-0.0536685847,
-0.0305288415,
0.0050154855,
-0.0512680188,
-0.0151458867,
-0.0101742875,
-0.0237404536,
0.0534623973,
-0.0634065568,
0.0350504592,
1.62020556e-34,
-0.0006522009,
0.0252761114,
0.0225368273,
0.0008172718,
0.0397184379,
0.0098189665,
-0.0084200781,
0.0033316247,
0.0285466351,
-0.0590882413,
-0.005647636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07556v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07556v2 | Using Natural Language Explanations to Improve Robustness of In-context Learning | 2023-11-13T18:49:13 | 2024-05-20T16:24:58 | Xuanli He, Yuxiang Wu, Oana-Maria Camburu, Pasquale Minervini, Pontus Stenetorp | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies demonstrated that large language models (LLMs) can excel in
many tasks via in-context learning (ICL). However, recent works show that
ICL-prompted models tend to produce inaccurate results when presented with
adversarial inputs. In this work, we investigate whether augmenting ICL with
natural language explanations (NLEs) improves the robustness of LLMs on
adversarial datasets covering natural language inference and paraphrasing
identification. We prompt LLMs with a small set of human-generated NLEs to
produce further NLEs, yielding more accurate results than both a zero-shot-ICL
setting and using only human-generated NLEs. Our results on five popular LLMs
(GPT3.5-turbo, Llama2, Vicuna, Zephyr, and Mistral) show that our approach
yields over 6% improvement over baseline approaches for eight adversarial
datasets: HANS, ISCS, NaN, ST, PICD, PISP, ANLI, and PAWS. Furthermore,
previous studies have demonstrated that prompt selection strategies
significantly enhance ICL on in-distribution test sets. However, our findings
reveal that these strategies do not match the efficacy of our approach for
robustness evaluations, resulting in an accuracy drop of 8% compared to the
proposed approach. | [
0.0343503803,
0.0569394305,
-0.0215441119,
0.0588763617,
-0.0414118655,
0.0046796175,
0.0217539519,
-0.0019488573,
0.0101780165,
-0.0541759729,
-0.0249405857,
-0.0155513752,
0.0053475038,
-0.0183282401,
0.0591858402,
-0.0550432242,
0.0320311971,
-0.0351115279,
0.0065395269,
0.020387888,
-0.0095857931,
0.0238044057,
0.0229159519,
0.0372018814,
0.0385405608,
-0.0034420353,
-0.0098516885,
0.0284430198,
-0.0008030956,
-0.0093099764,
0.0388062932,
0.0210916474,
0.0391724482,
0.0391527265,
0.0000021513,
-0.0459625162,
-0.0089418171,
0.011251932,
-0.0504176281,
0.0577009544,
0.0563236959,
-0.0410730727,
0.0179013424,
0.0085729929,
-0.0205154121,
0.0188143961,
0.0270329136,
0.0208488721,
0.0597377717,
0.0792335272,
-0.0004200189,
-0.0277679134,
-0.0021637457,
-0.0361420698,
-0.0143873524,
-0.0647290722,
0.0133662894,
-0.039251674,
0.0033081493,
0.0191247314,
0.0022017797,
0.0378772318,
0.0463209413,
0.002163304,
-0.0329195186,
0.0094330637,
-0.0037948687,
-0.0074716769,
0.0006681771,
0.0818224549,
-0.043150533,
-0.0344136283,
-0.0112399394,
-0.0228045397,
-0.0015460589,
0.0100455787,
-0.0430895537,
0.0065045436,
-0.0066771726,
0.0001497008,
-0.0137623372,
0.0336979702,
0.052459307,
0.0397840403,
0.0011831806,
0.0028762382,
0.011547232,
-0.0062771928,
-0.0182795431,
-0.0230562501,
-0.0630801171,
-0.0198807996,
-0.0177611168,
0.0004997362,
-0.0458587073,
0.0192368738,
-0.0820808336,
-0.0328463241,
0.0340592787,
-0.0111063346,
0.0550316162,
0.0189428404,
-0.0322693698,
0.0463123657,
-0.0307804439,
0.0653466955,
-0.0217312314,
0.0606784634,
-0.0311223827,
-0.028946314,
-0.0222708378,
-0.0072026113,
-0.0132450806,
-0.0130932629,
-0.0521198884,
0.0081429593,
-0.0377658606,
0.0225612614,
-0.0054229829,
0.0146072628,
-0.0176045708,
0.019345941,
-0.0314482115,
-0.0069801374,
-0.0120244129,
-0.0135753816,
-0.026647089,
0.0137651507,
0.0007612911,
-0.0798833743,
-0.0629722252,
0.0394863933,
-0.0095953168,
-0.0551675335,
0.0157179236,
0.1029207334,
0.018058911,
-0.0694030002,
-0.0433416031,
-0.0185010713,
-0.0347972773,
-0.0727887228,
0.0061971699,
-0.0258036256,
0.001974269,
-0.0022232428,
-0.0189068858,
-0.0645792484,
-0.0033401565,
0.0422055759,
-0.0352043472,
0.0909164324,
0.0029621124,
-0.0236008819,
-0.0157252364,
0.0079047279,
-0.0078293411,
0.0426268168,
0.0009541623,
-0.0014192988,
0.0460583121,
0.0086981012,
0.0143642286,
-0.0027818538,
0.0578094721,
0.028948212,
-0.0389461555,
0.0224393327,
0.0059141954,
0.0035096165,
0.0123790558,
0.0469681732,
-0.008984182,
-0.0345483571,
0.1033719704,
0.0355646908,
-0.0304260422,
0.0131627452,
0.0433619656,
0.0135739567,
0.0177888274,
0.0160675906,
-0.0878128484,
0.0214173142,
-0.0622883774,
0.0180579126,
0.0128500108,
0.0170045272,
-0.0063301758,
-0.0663374513,
-0.0498223193,
-0.0107323164,
0.0071110968,
0.029937733,
0.0246857423,
0.0325395353,
-0.0561913028,
-0.0177368019,
0.0252123084,
-0.0198526513,
-0.0397704579,
-0.0541710109,
0.0130230207,
0.0558800101,
0.0597736351,
-0.0293636844,
0.0220218655,
-0.0510738008,
0.0323378146,
0.0352917872,
0.0167562757,
0.0053665009,
0.0466098264,
-0.0340123065,
-0.0279799793,
-0.07767988,
0.0323591009,
0.0186525825,
0.0594948046,
-0.0119479969,
0.0264246147,
-0.0546203367,
-0.0466692522,
0.0504296459,
-0.0166559927,
-0.0664680973,
0.0193036571,
0.0128883729,
0.0306457896,
0.0216529947,
-0.0174367614,
0.0142813446,
0.031898912,
-0.025669653,
-0.0111193694,
0.0172218997,
-0.0556946583,
-0.050913997,
0.0144430613,
-0.0026442527,
-0.0419201031,
0.0195660926,
-0.0543738417,
-0.0037163335,
-0.0066302926,
-0.043412555,
0.0021142438,
-0.039440468,
-0.005475821,
-0.0137436362,
0.0387640744,
-0.0439306349,
0.0806559622,
-0.0035106044,
-0.0035858066,
0.0426473543,
0.0363326631,
0.0181735829,
-0.0120285088,
-0.0044410443,
0.015938051,
-0.0171723515,
-0.0084819077,
-0.0083346814,
0.0045553437,
-0.0203170739,
0.0172758941,
-0.0548782684,
-0.0070125447,
-0.0551130809,
-0.0129063083,
0.0378802307,
-0.0077706305,
-0.0146968355,
-0.022459371,
0.0157710966,
-0.0174395572,
0.0057158074,
0.0067955982,
0.0548142828,
-0.0016461061,
-0.0214296132,
-0.045903597,
0.0097325156,
-0.0142608685,
0.0627611279,
0.0259904172,
0.0006358676,
-0.0298627503,
0.0155583546,
0.0039043636,
0.019603502,
-0.0495281294,
-0.0375198089,
0.0079496093,
0.0106741376,
-0.0241025649,
0.0810259208,
-0.0055488665,
0.0401127115,
0.0390090905,
0.0408447534,
-0.02730437,
0.0080207828,
0.0040234216,
-0.0436767153,
-0.0154001322,
-0.0107628405,
0.0118066212,
0.0555079915,
0.0337228738,
-0.0128972186,
-0.0313898362,
0.0413456783,
0.0161833484,
-0.0000589594,
-0.0350256599,
-0.0403972752,
-0.0119742686,
0.0258033462,
-0.0412449427,
-0.0765786618,
0.1125724614,
-0.0480276421,
-0.0205049459,
-0.0579083115,
-0.0629598796,
-0.0276534837,
0.0519990698,
-0.0213892274,
0.0092603071,
0.0239270218,
0.012054231,
-0.0534716658,
-0.0621492155,
0.0367978401,
0.0083140545,
0.0365187116,
-0.0571464971,
0.0152461454,
0.0176583119,
-0.0332559235,
-0.0662266091,
-0.0774183124,
-0.037033353,
0.0188825391,
-0.0160044134,
-0.0111391144,
0.005969733,
-0.0368086211,
0.043233227,
0.0533864424,
-0.0088136615,
0.0022229629,
-0.029534189,
0.0209756456,
0.0379209109,
0.0099998415,
0.0379578359,
-0.0323303565,
0.0341137052,
0.0252679735,
0.0077511868,
0.019613754,
-0.0371707566,
-0.0028475355,
-0.0124456966,
-0.0176996551,
-0.0044170097,
0.0360717848,
0.0599963628,
-0.0546111614,
-0.0003590121,
0.0778449476,
0.0048840549,
-0.0195337776,
0.0165638104,
0.0110349664,
0.0230013803,
0.0163304247,
0.0024769332,
-0.0510269292,
-0.0697600693,
0.015218853,
0.0361060984,
-0.002224565,
-0.0072370749,
-0.0185965132,
-0.1178377941,
0.0256060809,
-0.0086378409,
-0.0541697815,
-0.0574781038,
-0.0486571714,
-0.0067749587,
0.0056867828,
0.0583561026,
-0.0099464701,
0.0058785668,
0.0090345275,
-0.0071203737,
0.0231479704,
-0.0940063596,
0.0192723852,
-0.0420376547,
0.0148794446,
0.0721079111,
0.0336320139,
0.0166895781,
-0.0133049516,
0.0575209074,
-0.0454984717,
0.0077263932,
0.0052425498,
0.0848679617,
-0.0057426128,
-0.0214305557,
-0.000258481,
0.0680419058,
-0.0223467611,
-0.0115262866,
-0.003190716,
0.0155951791,
0.0103088897,
-0.0082262224,
0.0060635023,
-0.000117455,
0.041132994,
0.0917222276,
0.0340556391,
-0.0222545322,
-0.038116768,
-0.0394326895,
-0.016806731,
-0.0429712646,
-0.0447172076,
0.0278902426,
0.0031977843,
0.0073021059,
-0.0558781102,
-0.0459508374,
-0.00935023,
0.0185484365,
-0.0010211787,
0.0258806292,
-0.049781315,
0.0185524914,
-0.0103803538,
0.0470621474,
-0.0333146639,
0.04135089,
0.008673952,
-0.0131910983,
0.0197402127,
-0.0372082815,
-0.0198113974,
0.0721345395,
-0.0630744696,
-0.0584382452,
-0.0274910759,
0.0545854606,
0.0188854281,
0.0727417022,
-0.0242066178,
-0.0425370671,
0.0746333897,
0.0473637618,
-0.0163134597,
0.0074335425,
0.0636889935,
0.0141541064,
0.0179329272,
0.0515853427,
-0.0292264801,
-0.0215541888,
0.0533238612,
-0.0058248919,
0.0021196464,
-0.0101287263,
0.040272627,
0.0113593563,
0.0587712005,
-0.0281302799,
-0.0281762164,
0.0165351145,
0.0224956572,
-0.0156837944,
-0.0309799798,
-0.0220274106,
0.0287986193,
0.0197360013,
-0.0086178705,
0.0075187059,
-0.0055153677,
-0.0144217303,
0.0320982933,
-0.0058205244,
-0.0067546358,
-0.0003026833,
0.021540463,
-0.0051704915,
0.022480594,
-0.0063727475,
0.0507050119,
-0.0493123978,
0.0494575687,
-0.0096519673,
0.0567470305,
0.0190414023,
-0.0298738778,
-0.0220037792,
0.019810915,
-0.0970406756,
-0.0047262376,
-0.0240083989,
0.0525210723,
0.0468749851,
-0.0355877392,
0.0489968583,
-0.0224550627,
-0.0175712854,
-0.0046977769,
0.041654598,
0.0141089084,
-0.0126915742,
0.0191514287,
0.0152760427,
-0.0176714007,
0.0153049603,
0.0654258132,
0.0612524375,
0.0374874696,
0.0186519884,
-0.0015013235,
-0.0364644043,
-0.0464821756,
0.0383947156,
0.0300358236,
-0.0012139461,
0.0220283456,
-0.0401479341,
-0.0760658234,
0.0052923704,
0.0065084221,
-0.0084989974,
-0.024208555,
0.0206048451,
0.0649664104,
-0.005129443,
-0.0096384203,
-0.0133289536,
0.0282976981,
0.0230583306,
-0.0243990738,
-0.0452307723,
-6.513793295e-33,
-0.0268165618,
-0.029614212,
-0.0206792969,
-0.059358336,
0.021199109,
-0.0071711368,
-0.0685095564,
-0.0208616219,
-0.0377791598,
0.0050435741,
0.0014920533,
0.0043877116,
0.0016821277,
0.0326458067,
-0.0250605531,
-0.0781402886,
0.0244056638,
0.003882037,
-0.0274840817,
-0.0106352568,
0.0268077534,
0.0218067802,
0.0640448928,
-0.0824239478,
0.0460732132,
0.0070944973,
-0.0124070635,
-0.0111826276,
-0.0388354398,
0.0189978462,
-0.0091920085,
0.0462129153,
0.0045207208,
0.0021030174,
-0.0013968116,
0.0148589686,
-0.0673581064,
0.0098203775,
0.0396751538,
0.0023549211,
-0.0398164876,
-0.0415113159,
0.0459393747,
-0.0391914435,
0.006087224,
-0.006598636,
0.0257163178,
-0.0158083644,
-0.007839635,
0.0116222212,
-0.0288531668,
0.0154877687,
-0.0159761906,
-0.0198930614,
-0.020496957,
0.0349756852,
0.0188642852,
0.0721569285,
-0.0600136258,
-0.0319027714,
-0.0161022097,
0.0112493243,
0.0444919355,
-0.0102822538,
0.0034476018,
0.0553618483,
-0.0036003347,
0.0101684537,
-0.0534446016,
-0.0404090993,
0.020654697,
0.0093816146,
0.0938947201,
0.1141828075,
0.0297521986,
0.0240491927,
-0.0901709944,
0.0048832549,
0.0129010575,
0.0142515367,
0.0266893245,
0.0106561165,
-0.0811027884,
-0.0281129088,
-0.023299275,
-0.0846461281,
-0.0254318584,
-0.0246202536,
0.0491426624,
0.0035929135,
-0.0511682443,
-0.0014376648,
-0.003641156,
-0.0487091877,
0.0024332944,
0.0418861061,
-0.0354340039,
-0.0077002621,
0.0081412606,
0.0097257867,
-0.0072898162,
-0.0038469473,
0.0141973058,
0.0266722962,
0.0473214313,
-0.020673193,
0.0684839562,
0.0297666322,
-0.0463835448,
0.0151147721,
-0.0474861525,
0.0233409312,
-0.0100640459,
-0.0021091197,
0.0348675288,
0.0365254618,
-0.021250492,
0.0091810068,
0.0261113308,
-0.0199837293,
-0.0078705354,
-0.0043611825,
-0.0282205045,
0.0039865728,
-0.0116267204,
-0.0391514339,
-0.0008650369,
-0.0001557104,
0.0156053044,
-0.0860787183,
0.0130898664,
-0.0251804814,
2.826e-7,
0.0207013804,
0.0350226127,
0.0205227248,
0.0108803147,
0.0170396939,
0.0482872352,
-0.0081373835,
0.0202694237,
-0.0137128085,
-0.0438939743,
0.0023941156,
0.0339011997,
0.0786234587,
0.0033383507,
-0.081349805,
0.005665476,
-0.0749141574,
0.0078065833,
-0.040482264,
-0.0023417757,
0.0467539206,
0.1199135855,
0.0370848216,
-0.0040513738,
0.0000068934,
-0.0893560871,
0.0549487248,
-0.0379030965,
0.0087615019,
-0.0124901524,
0.0109560825,
0.0204728916,
0.016626263,
0.0095058195,
-0.0041323397,
0.0217627659,
0.0044221925,
0.0719143823,
0.0309211425,
-0.0309104919,
-0.0462825224,
-0.023442978,
0.0149613554,
-0.085667111,
0.1057139859,
-0.0452555232,
-0.0041881376,
0.0014895253,
-0.0038291598,
-0.0361560732,
0.0348677076,
-0.0058911452,
-0.0198217407,
0.0154465586,
-0.0052820537,
-0.0136573426,
-0.0014218007,
-0.0721358955,
-0.0616823435,
0.0016414669,
-0.0439986549,
0.0080723958,
-0.028856406,
0.0072088595,
0.0826644227,
-0.0338985063,
0.0069406051,
2.849692869e-34,
0.0193370897,
-0.0050963624,
0.017740773,
0.0209445301,
0.0481436402,
0.0233733803,
-0.0005722754,
-0.0077837282,
0.0440940857,
-0.0235265512,
-0.0092583075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07547v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07547v1 | GPT-4V(ision) as A Social Media Analysis Engine | 2023-11-13T18:36:50 | 2023-11-13T18:36:50 | Hanjia Lyu, Jinfa Huang, Daoan Zhang, Yongsheng Yu, Xinyi Mou, Jinsheng Pan, Zhengyuan Yang, Zhongyu Wei, Jiebo Luo | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM | Recent research has offered insights into the extraordinary capabilities of
Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) in various general vision and language tasks.
There is growing interest in how LMMs perform in more specialized domains.
Social media content, inherently multimodal, blends text, images, videos, and
sometimes audio. Understanding social multimedia content remains a challenging
problem for contemporary machine learning frameworks. In this paper, we explore
GPT-4V(ision)'s capabilities for social multimedia analysis. We select five
representative tasks, including sentiment analysis, hate speech detection, fake
news identification, demographic inference, and political ideology detection,
to evaluate GPT-4V. Our investigation begins with a preliminary quantitative
analysis for each task using existing benchmark datasets, followed by a careful
review of the results and a selection of qualitative samples that illustrate
GPT-4V's potential in understanding multimodal social media content. GPT-4V
demonstrates remarkable efficacy in these tasks, showcasing strengths such as
joint understanding of image-text pairs, contextual and cultural awareness, and
extensive commonsense knowledge. Despite the overall impressive capacity of
GPT-4V in the social media domain, there remain notable challenges. GPT-4V
struggles with tasks involving multilingual social multimedia comprehension and
has difficulties in generalizing to the latest trends in social media.
Additionally, it exhibits a tendency to generate erroneous information in the
context of evolving celebrity and politician knowledge, reflecting the known
hallucination problem. The insights gleaned from our findings underscore a
promising future for LMMs in enhancing our comprehension of social media
content and its users through the analysis of multimodal information. | [
0.0153206838,
0.0882208049,
0.0040857182,
0.051054731,
-0.0275270976,
0.0342811495,
-0.012629889,
0.0107649798,
-0.0017108078,
-0.0685033724,
-0.0286626108,
-0.0519920588,
-0.0248996839,
0.0159636587,
0.0147855273,
-0.0618720725,
0.0558852144,
0.0410888493,
0.0227971449,
-0.0238303263,
0.046869088,
0.0578419082,
-0.0122360345,
0.0183796659,
-0.0543678701,
-0.0273982864,
0.0109080365,
0.020005893,
0.0718151778,
0.0015915559,
0.0082657235,
0.0457400233,
0.0512452573,
0.0834241584,
0.0000018874,
-0.0016286792,
0.0167182144,
-0.017074788,
0.0475355051,
-0.0134134125,
0.0780658647,
-0.04525619,
-0.009615683,
0.0024531728,
-0.0444851816,
0.0214465819,
0.0570590608,
0.0539820567,
0.0727059245,
0.0620495901,
-0.0389120467,
-0.0533405878,
0.016871687,
-0.0035802748,
0.0125028081,
-0.0637573376,
0.0143252024,
-0.0007919762,
-0.0393382013,
0.0265178457,
-0.0339081511,
0.0350415856,
0.0194838028,
0.0111230593,
-0.0334234647,
-0.0026800719,
-0.026826892,
-0.0400838144,
-0.0135085797,
0.0666236505,
-0.005330673,
-0.0096973497,
0.0048896857,
0.0074372524,
-0.0140932146,
0.0185644086,
-0.0274854042,
0.0120839942,
-0.039696712,
0.0321122967,
-0.0168474745,
-0.0152118802,
0.0296409577,
0.0324262455,
0.0035099117,
0.0031952194,
-0.0126072941,
-0.0012177333,
0.0402776748,
0.004080846,
-0.0434420221,
0.0118926456,
0.0025112405,
-0.0136571405,
0.0125105986,
0.0121905627,
-0.058497563,
-0.0107008312,
0.0109738093,
-0.080739975,
-0.0062809484,
0.0107484572,
-0.0359734967,
0.0770658404,
0.0282951705,
-0.0107249301,
-0.0503671356,
0.0086314464,
0.0296710823,
-0.0334974006,
-0.0702087954,
-0.0057922886,
0.0271263048,
-0.0199707653,
-0.0279419776,
-0.0282626916,
-0.0344242863,
0.0137459682,
-0.0415262617,
0.0054112552,
-0.0476134196,
0.0062215743,
-0.0089559816,
-0.0030298901,
-0.0392146036,
0.0677623078,
-0.0118313143,
0.0264507923,
-0.0348344631,
-0.0578056984,
0.0216074102,
0.040053077,
0.0050026299,
-0.0393443927,
0.0275782924,
0.0203471165,
-0.0209425073,
-0.0212564953,
-0.0252180565,
-0.0116417632,
-0.0100622661,
-0.0964894369,
0.0565188266,
-0.0624150448,
0.0451024361,
0.0097427163,
-0.0053654113,
0.0023167175,
-0.0080805523,
0.0321418941,
-0.0514808372,
0.0910555571,
0.0553514138,
0.0076448363,
0.0469513647,
0.0426352881,
0.0032342782,
0.100746721,
-0.0148380715,
0.0532752909,
0.0405725949,
-0.019122906,
0.0166390352,
0.057173349,
-0.0012970237,
0.0146193905,
-0.0352414995,
-0.0002205527,
-0.0364833474,
-0.0223376881,
0.0317383818,
0.0291672293,
-0.0067290957,
-0.0396249406,
0.0837229937,
0.0080144191,
-0.0424188972,
0.0200002454,
0.0336884148,
0.0043217158,
0.01340135,
0.0122532276,
-0.0615859888,
0.0656220168,
-0.0246684793,
-0.0410915762,
0.044438567,
0.0662211403,
-0.021411309,
0.0133753298,
0.0119374143,
-0.015772175,
0.0392705649,
-0.0042664777,
0.0243538413,
-0.0373325236,
-0.0402262099,
-0.0058953189,
0.0284905508,
-0.0115844011,
-0.0144611364,
-0.0266093463,
0.0057126614,
0.0468620993,
0.0093249483,
-0.0158954319,
0.0020398751,
-0.0288031977,
0.0374007486,
0.0556196794,
0.0234271046,
0.0049629607,
0.0071636382,
-0.0359278023,
-0.0177924149,
-0.0119129755,
0.0152961174,
0.04879383,
0.0384882838,
0.0306754839,
0.0005349659,
-0.0059009227,
0.0264903158,
-0.0261395555,
0.0326605439,
-0.0038678199,
-0.0330153704,
0.0324771367,
0.0392645262,
0.0458652712,
-0.0112437941,
-0.0645373762,
0.0128788473,
0.007374594,
-0.0309949052,
0.0118851671,
-0.0283904914,
-0.020894926,
0.0350494795,
-0.0687077865,
-0.0459553674,
0.0859692842,
-0.0502260029,
0.011291801,
0.0865027308,
-0.0134404935,
0.0011488261,
-0.0839973763,
-0.0745605156,
-0.0277589653,
0.0465420038,
0.0434914231,
0.07968124,
-0.0132892588,
-0.0401181467,
0.0011192119,
-0.0226324275,
0.0252524409,
0.0126267225,
-0.0458188653,
0.006158222,
0.0274864435,
0.0317821912,
-0.0019782365,
-0.0426950827,
-0.0344875641,
0.0010064456,
-0.1193365604,
0.0030223627,
-0.0336832181,
-0.0094303628,
0.0091929883,
-0.0043115285,
-0.0155621506,
-0.0191970449,
-0.0186898988,
-0.0019976408,
0.0203868821,
0.0460612662,
0.0035608069,
-0.0010224843,
0.0292793959,
0.0148731032,
-0.00255686,
-0.0185978822,
0.0250860583,
0.0112804994,
-0.0496533103,
0.0429068655,
-0.0489383899,
-0.078188546,
0.0379253998,
-0.0497858413,
-0.0290693026,
0.0133340023,
0.0007484648,
0.0377157405,
0.0156376231,
0.0493506491,
0.0707595274,
-0.0090125185,
0.0147853624,
-0.0070013232,
0.0049431017,
-0.0187932719,
-0.000491597,
-0.0204831846,
-0.0218196064,
-0.029320078,
0.0158611406,
0.0172021613,
0.0237242822,
-0.0452629514,
0.0429478623,
0.0035723217,
-0.0236830618,
-0.0080240853,
0.0059026098,
0.0007573441,
-0.0052454025,
-0.0249323174,
-0.0397263691,
0.0606255941,
0.0023318399,
0.0078297732,
0.0144798439,
-0.0369565412,
-0.0091219004,
0.0608833544,
0.0218748655,
0.0498493873,
-0.0312789269,
0.0030968341,
-0.0161682386,
-0.0193755701,
0.0261989087,
-0.028124677,
0.032083489,
-0.0118292775,
0.0172161032,
-0.0047057187,
-0.0410388745,
-0.0128559591,
-0.0687941015,
-0.0246246681,
-0.0332747288,
-0.0333783478,
-0.0266795997,
-0.0127385622,
-0.0128723308,
0.040060252,
-0.0375487879,
-0.0147231203,
0.0012408048,
0.0198820308,
0.0442890599,
0.0494468473,
0.0018945001,
-0.0079034222,
-0.037338458,
-0.01984814,
0.0468464009,
-0.0219710283,
-0.0282110628,
-0.0592945181,
0.0085749654,
-0.0239566825,
0.0583533831,
-0.0134960003,
-0.0350043364,
0.0605262928,
-0.0268322844,
0.06481269,
0.0916866064,
-0.0184620693,
-0.0585613325,
-0.0163372979,
0.0429066792,
-0.0390184298,
0.0361815616,
-0.0015363978,
-0.1105782837,
-0.0341241583,
-0.0404030681,
-0.0051231449,
-0.0165098403,
-0.013722511,
-0.0212164409,
-0.0849581957,
0.0576152578,
-0.0184848085,
-0.0346238241,
-0.0286858026,
-0.0184464026,
0.006373513,
-0.0338254347,
0.0200529974,
-0.0279588625,
0.0216793884,
-0.0083413906,
-0.0212453622,
-0.0045933085,
-0.0684032142,
0.0293695293,
-0.0219230913,
0.0128496634,
0.0266786069,
0.0376477353,
-0.0338554047,
-0.065199703,
0.0246234294,
0.0042860229,
-0.0043751188,
-0.0328485146,
0.0639900938,
-0.0457249843,
-0.0247989167,
-0.0119108073,
0.0295301341,
0.0142464815,
-0.0098959217,
-0.0235568229,
0.0771172494,
-0.0114814797,
-0.0374214873,
-0.0634029359,
0.0386582203,
0.030308241,
0.0471165739,
0.0161744952,
-0.011874306,
-0.0295811128,
-0.0249643233,
0.0240516998,
-0.046006009,
-0.0092459191,
-0.0040009269,
0.0030658105,
-0.0225673523,
0.0013372807,
-0.0241287202,
0.0135253053,
0.0112791937,
-0.0528625287,
0.0070591192,
-0.0145657063,
0.0011197494,
-0.0652099997,
0.0491752401,
-0.0097125191,
0.0305008758,
0.0051201559,
-0.0363347307,
0.006128768,
-0.0403061099,
-0.0140358424,
0.0293159317,
-0.0811858922,
-0.0384725221,
-0.0256997254,
0.0239586215,
0.0202767923,
0.0530313887,
0.0087762726,
-0.0246965084,
0.0345718227,
0.0635371208,
-0.0157095436,
0.0179501455,
0.0275313184,
0.0256786663,
-0.0003303252,
0.0293112993,
-0.0033079472,
0.0371889919,
0.0058618165,
-0.0526549779,
-0.0460033715,
0.0140236048,
-0.0177170932,
-0.0079142982,
0.0494771972,
-0.0080486014,
-0.0143441996,
-0.0293951817,
-0.0697229356,
0.0150872879,
-0.0184138939,
-0.0235334542,
0.0050165877,
0.0289459042,
-0.0154043501,
-0.051437106,
-0.0146098835,
-0.013156468,
0.0212719198,
-0.047593195,
0.0005469648,
0.0199358314,
-0.0309998933,
0.0111875264,
0.0034468181,
0.0139328633,
0.0143096363,
0.0341068469,
0.0031200948,
-0.0021663741,
0.074162595,
0.0090627866,
-0.022472024,
0.0507548675,
0.0108632352,
-0.0076018805,
0.0021954679,
-0.0275089573,
0.0405025408,
0.0493436232,
-0.0207562391,
0.0108032273,
-0.0004767377,
-0.0219124872,
-0.0024719392,
0.0044197794,
-0.006925826,
-0.0619267896,
0.0385665782,
0.0198008008,
-0.0125007275,
0.0321226455,
0.0703027621,
-0.0276312903,
0.012801541,
0.0302820988,
-0.0533591993,
-0.0462051742,
-0.0210252255,
0.0414971597,
0.0333251245,
0.0020988446,
0.0383732989,
-0.0553664193,
-0.0651792511,
0.0141793545,
-0.0515637361,
-0.009491506,
0.0329845957,
-0.0011539418,
0.0940371454,
-0.001340779,
0.0109457979,
-0.0208132379,
-0.0254563801,
-0.0471493378,
-0.0216538198,
0.05379292,
-6.750196964e-33,
0.0014936451,
-0.0176485218,
-0.0013733719,
-0.001130913,
-0.015687285,
-0.0112344334,
-0.0222114064,
-0.0087570064,
-0.0115176104,
0.023908915,
0.0329816267,
0.0251754541,
-0.0055931746,
0.0189528801,
-0.0009792314,
-0.0203449428,
0.011250658,
-0.0003295667,
-0.0270643011,
0.0270115323,
0.0494467542,
0.0110985106,
0.0724774674,
-0.06254673,
-0.005163637,
0.0118571622,
-0.0288498309,
0.0035733939,
-0.0074772532,
0.0523908399,
-0.0413053855,
0.0660005584,
0.0612725355,
-0.0321409218,
0.0081851026,
0.0511563309,
-0.0298607945,
0.0043201093,
0.0043760589,
0.0110783335,
-0.0510481074,
0.0075972755,
0.0329720229,
-0.0216507427,
-0.026841186,
-0.010541182,
0.0494704358,
-0.0085518928,
0.0669916719,
-0.0119636571,
-0.0582928546,
0.0210740082,
-0.0165132191,
0.0063848649,
-0.0138707384,
0.022162348,
0.0483979173,
0.0602554716,
-0.084210746,
0.0236170441,
-0.0583185963,
-0.0543629155,
0.0437085591,
-0.0355365761,
-0.0114498939,
0.0644144267,
0.0124744521,
-0.0145907011,
-0.0677467138,
0.0269822795,
0.0240821186,
0.0288224407,
0.0190833174,
0.0782372206,
0.0252604634,
-0.048362188,
-0.0453560539,
0.0072308038,
0.0375322402,
-0.0049951458,
0.0147781773,
-0.009957429,
0.0019421683,
0.0092075523,
0.0096300542,
-0.0378708914,
-0.0451023243,
-0.0317856371,
-0.005646043,
0.0007062907,
0.0041767713,
0.0683885664,
0.0633255616,
-0.0359699726,
-0.018053405,
0.0361730196,
-0.0322909877,
0.0413522422,
0.0443397798,
0.051448971,
-0.029669499,
0.009893842,
0.0381738991,
-0.0044800607,
0.0045979028,
-0.0249973796,
0.037454702,
0.0596860722,
-0.0423571318,
0.0011375129,
-0.0380008258,
0.0455427393,
-0.0562634803,
0.0174819417,
0.0196679235,
0.0214379858,
-0.0270861704,
-0.0145413037,
0.0158782825,
0.0302609615,
-0.0044500935,
-0.0426558666,
-0.040142376,
-0.0090414584,
-0.0154544059,
-0.0135789076,
-0.00146344,
-0.0453721248,
0.0012318557,
-0.0885488689,
-0.0011723964,
0.0324432552,
2.744e-7,
0.0205693785,
0.0527671203,
-0.0066549769,
-0.0146201579,
0.0447448827,
0.0471324474,
-0.0117797107,
0.0314356461,
-0.0363822691,
-0.0720975474,
-0.0004373352,
0.0713463351,
0.0412222072,
0.0488492996,
-0.022279894,
0.0184297282,
-0.038364768,
-0.0174855199,
-0.0883917287,
0.0479745418,
0.0099570248,
0.079047896,
0.0382833667,
-0.0598570183,
0.0146142701,
-0.0182230659,
0.0845416412,
0.0080888197,
-0.0531610474,
-0.0486773513,
0.038230855,
0.0097393077,
0.0084085669,
0.0249975007,
0.0012831242,
-0.0089370161,
0.0188302211,
0.0424497724,
0.0285602249,
-0.0440121405,
-0.0263760705,
0.0194490869,
-0.009496904,
-0.0471539795,
0.0867531449,
-0.010725786,
-0.044722598,
-0.0692446306,
-0.0558897182,
-0.0082881758,
0.0404516794,
0.0078882175,
-0.0517230891,
0.0157570541,
0.0017779318,
-0.0275502503,
-0.0345409364,
-0.0765732974,
0.0634982213,
0.0137282889,
-0.0835277662,
0.0004425636,
-0.0042521614,
-0.0045130118,
0.0817532241,
-0.0124091171,
-0.0069341725,
2.043702769e-34,
0.0390113965,
-0.0377967916,
0.0102963205,
-0.0782859921,
0.0006059555,
0.0399824083,
-0.0547342449,
-0.0224592052,
-0.0104436837,
-0.0228427984,
0.0126024513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07538v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07538v1 | Leveraging Multiple Teachers for Test-Time Adaptation of Language-Guided Classifiers | 2023-11-13T18:28:25 | 2023-11-13T18:28:25 | Kangda Wei, Sayan Ghosh, Rakesh R. Menon, Shashank Srivastava | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent approaches have explored language-guided classifiers capable of
classifying examples from novel tasks when provided with task-specific natural
language explanations, instructions or prompts (Sanh et al., 2022; R. Menon et
al., 2022). While these classifiers can generalize in zero-shot settings, their
task performance often varies substantially between different language
explanations in unpredictable ways (Lu et al., 2022; Gonen et al., 2022). Also,
current approaches fail to leverage unlabeled examples that may be available in
many scenarios. Here, we introduce TALC, a framework that uses data programming
to adapt a language-guided classifier for a new task during inference when
provided with explanations from multiple teachers and unlabeled test examples.
Our results show that TALC consistently outperforms a competitive baseline from
prior work by an impressive 9.3% (relative improvement). Further, we
demonstrate the robustness of TALC to variations in the quality and quantity of
provided explanations, highlighting its potential in scenarios where learning
from multiple teachers or a crowd is involved. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/WeiKangda/TALC.git. | [
0.042798344,
0.0417518988,
-0.0342931747,
0.0267980099,
-0.0068553449,
0.0299200099,
0.0606641918,
-0.0468069874,
-0.012353655,
-0.0811557993,
0.037174318,
0.0032141313,
-0.0060169254,
-0.0153563358,
0.0346865207,
-0.0940781981,
0.0040527908,
-0.0496749133,
-0.0000236223,
0.0088108182,
0.0016847071,
0.0264485832,
-0.0379186049,
0.0559525937,
0.0102462182,
0.0232981145,
-0.031530451,
-0.0140079018,
-0.0053049396,
-0.0107869217,
0.0213691387,
0.0689165145,
0.0545774586,
-0.0015652993,
0.0000019723,
-0.0565785021,
0.0125680221,
-0.0300073959,
-0.0354540981,
-0.0351391137,
0.0213463251,
0.0050359434,
0.0230737198,
-0.0148673793,
-0.0376721993,
-0.047326155,
0.0634981841,
-0.0029641192,
0.0552751869,
0.087508142,
0.0203845464,
0.0034225087,
-0.0383912884,
0.030456366,
0.0597467162,
-0.0115682669,
0.0058396431,
-0.0034311777,
0.0279604197,
0.0057041114,
-0.017406879,
0.0095705763,
0.0253536273,
-0.0269237645,
0.006221822,
0.0182109922,
-0.0515673906,
-0.0131956907,
-0.0345137268,
0.0877340734,
0.0383381359,
-0.0321793668,
0.0003577485,
0.0046093124,
0.0303811394,
0.0145333717,
-0.034819942,
-0.0009093015,
0.0194407199,
0.0112487646,
0.001618177,
-0.005631295,
0.0251364224,
0.0357090198,
0.0321785733,
0.0373620465,
-0.0431725159,
0.0113935899,
0.0085617872,
0.0404296666,
-0.0101060681,
-0.0639679134,
0.0026129747,
0.0738467053,
-0.0596728101,
0.0377827957,
-0.0423493646,
-0.0680936947,
-0.0128641538,
-0.0152782584,
0.0231279079,
0.0504000634,
-0.0494114347,
0.0428441502,
-0.0076288776,
0.0464006476,
0.0359565578,
0.0057828291,
-0.0152629605,
-0.0122980867,
-0.0969523787,
-0.0030801937,
-0.0367484726,
-0.0078240056,
-0.0055084443,
0.0300172567,
-0.0048383125,
0.0222448371,
-0.0385201126,
0.0120858634,
-0.0214411728,
0.0022939777,
-0.0394093394,
0.0302240178,
-0.011878836,
0.0473065935,
-0.053154707,
0.0050455751,
0.0184669085,
-0.0600592196,
-0.0272081345,
0.0187453665,
0.0049025244,
-0.0025958933,
0.0204211418,
0.0434256829,
-0.02657157,
-0.01254973,
-0.0257392023,
-0.0238415208,
-0.0125137996,
-0.049478054,
-0.0029529717,
-0.0617920943,
0.0224255808,
0.0170508958,
-0.0038851022,
-0.0281882584,
0.0132985916,
0.0077228206,
-0.0088102957,
0.1061729342,
-0.0059462469,
-0.0053799725,
0.0290494412,
0.0180148501,
-0.0406873524,
0.0896487385,
0.017932158,
-0.0250409655,
0.0258019641,
-0.0329540931,
0.039435707,
0.007554647,
0.0024472605,
0.0104542207,
0.0014130286,
0.0161726587,
0.0212181825,
0.030760631,
0.0257718973,
-0.0064861532,
0.0007189066,
0.0229584873,
0.0196292438,
0.0482018702,
-0.0315912887,
0.0069432994,
0.0536066182,
0.0400613099,
-0.0090896487,
-0.0006811684,
-0.0851358548,
0.0094659356,
-0.0442979112,
-0.0331544466,
-0.0154386256,
-0.0061084144,
-0.0239051692,
-0.0613432825,
-0.0005877775,
-0.0265537333,
0.0476556607,
0.0368961506,
0.076731354,
0.0292864945,
-0.0034321425,
-0.0009069574,
0.0660894215,
-0.0637773126,
0.0167268515,
-0.0555360653,
0.0188207012,
0.0550410822,
0.0083084488,
-0.0563596003,
-0.0246542767,
0.0109665897,
0.0667810962,
-0.0014586247,
0.062224742,
-0.0385288745,
0.0206629522,
-0.0345355608,
-0.0269682184,
-0.0002828717,
0.0001451871,
0.0367677994,
0.0401296392,
0.016887391,
-0.0054878145,
-0.0235173833,
-0.0563117974,
0.0481298007,
-0.0009854697,
-0.0639537498,
0.0280131064,
0.0165585056,
-0.0039094798,
0.0115018561,
0.011256502,
-0.0573569462,
-0.0119222999,
-0.0063824556,
0.0130724227,
0.0055398778,
-0.0300782584,
-0.0808420926,
0.0380866006,
-0.0144745735,
-0.0634983853,
0.0138000054,
-0.0428900942,
-0.0310390536,
0.0382583626,
-0.0212802701,
-0.0065301913,
-0.016036801,
-0.008087378,
-0.0214864966,
-0.0006527503,
-0.0129320035,
0.0393187925,
0.0626930073,
0.0107542751,
0.0291957576,
-0.0409033522,
-0.0071453112,
-0.0374427997,
0.021599872,
0.0108391792,
-0.0021097241,
-0.0003376936,
0.0008465918,
0.0554769412,
-0.0698713437,
0.0148839345,
-0.0582779124,
-0.0209069885,
-0.043598149,
0.0087810624,
-0.0203871708,
-0.0124433432,
-0.0074456786,
-0.0496367887,
-0.0740865245,
-0.0071758935,
-0.025108777,
-0.0047350414,
0.0321980529,
-0.0020058416,
-0.0296832751,
-0.0031524468,
0.0179057103,
-0.0378440432,
0.0266855527,
0.0431168973,
-0.0187429767,
-0.0735791475,
-0.0025192329,
-0.0213830248,
0.0151752299,
-0.0032207989,
-0.0004167094,
0.0054682088,
-0.0277930424,
0.0155792264,
0.0478887446,
-0.0457408763,
0.0650358722,
0.0515411943,
-0.012911058,
-0.0650163591,
0.0403891318,
0.0118727749,
-0.0047845948,
-0.0318690911,
-0.0158324912,
-0.0248074699,
0.056130074,
0.0046501006,
-0.0378549397,
-0.0565295592,
0.0081203207,
-0.0412602909,
-0.027864486,
-0.0351673067,
0.0092203254,
0.0120838778,
0.0344942473,
0.0078352168,
-0.0423848741,
0.1318335682,
0.0065424829,
-0.0422514826,
-0.050987076,
-0.0279101282,
-0.0122442003,
0.0715240613,
-0.0073049241,
0.0027681226,
0.0215718057,
-0.0196591783,
-0.0287095644,
0.0048751775,
0.00431062,
-0.0214890763,
0.02679573,
-0.1084152535,
-0.0153468493,
0.0122119375,
-0.0255479943,
-0.0374137536,
-0.0224031042,
-0.0419760048,
0.0262270235,
-0.0154798245,
-0.0435503349,
-0.0322907716,
-0.0280819479,
0.0141350804,
0.0068179206,
0.005432467,
-0.0228325296,
-0.0057712081,
-0.0210275855,
-0.0046297181,
0.0515695661,
-0.0378325209,
-0.0274646748,
0.0280674454,
0.0333446153,
0.0535362326,
-0.0209444985,
-0.0236547012,
0.0232363157,
0.0549984686,
-0.0193281472,
0.0127318371,
0.0411265492,
0.0665730163,
-0.096734412,
0.0085428767,
0.0963521972,
0.039836321,
-0.032004308,
-0.0035590641,
-0.0070837219,
0.0182825718,
0.0166605636,
0.0301827639,
-0.0862051919,
-0.0747264177,
-0.0089439293,
0.0545597896,
0.0116410134,
-0.0157309175,
-0.0286186561,
-0.0736964941,
0.0309278704,
0.0190389194,
-0.0718111321,
0.0202310216,
-0.071418643,
0.0195281673,
-0.0436494201,
-0.0063789194,
-0.0380917452,
0.0370806269,
0.0289304163,
0.0286446679,
-0.0255459938,
-0.0574685596,
0.029607771,
0.0002909628,
0.0521098524,
0.0354420133,
0.0158346333,
-0.0026457866,
-0.027879579,
0.0010727114,
0.0332138687,
0.0192622207,
-0.0411800258,
0.0650954545,
0.0123678865,
-0.024616003,
0.010925102,
0.0791695192,
-0.048226539,
-0.0078402832,
0.0553896166,
0.0862315893,
0.0049811113,
-0.0300498549,
-0.000173039,
-0.0058989916,
0.0743779689,
0.0805423036,
0.0458873138,
-0.0689451024,
-0.0169187766,
-0.0708737373,
-0.042598471,
-0.0593751073,
-0.0498896092,
0.0241434667,
-0.0187842678,
0.0040839561,
-0.0224612709,
-0.0438974388,
0.0925080404,
0.0250878837,
0.0295751076,
-0.0325645395,
-0.0077320207,
0.0345671549,
-0.0334759578,
0.0422783978,
-0.0019423739,
0.0187505893,
-0.0216214471,
-0.0959492922,
-0.0089221643,
-0.0280103497,
0.0208763648,
0.0604612641,
-0.0638696402,
-0.0784397125,
0.0007159715,
0.040497683,
0.0165880099,
0.0499871783,
-0.0104469284,
-0.0569470115,
0.0225278549,
0.0401015803,
-0.0152552528,
-0.0210514702,
0.037843734,
0.0276172142,
0.0079380469,
0.035160657,
-0.0388770774,
0.0039477791,
0.0037440944,
-0.0153674325,
-0.0483079851,
-0.0068294345,
0.0285932124,
-0.0054168021,
0.0476338491,
-0.026173519,
-0.0226376187,
-0.0164427739,
-0.0161258075,
-0.0078751873,
-0.0599179454,
-0.035155993,
-0.0005386653,
-0.0044944175,
-0.0235267803,
0.0086673861,
-0.0067041819,
-0.0060155867,
0.0029042666,
-0.045517832,
0.0454823449,
0.0639144927,
0.0154152624,
0.020648431,
0.0192935318,
-0.0131465895,
-0.0210389141,
0.0307570007,
0.0513306223,
0.0043015019,
0.0591760315,
0.0234814901,
-0.002621474,
-0.0011074909,
-0.0399898067,
-0.0533604734,
-0.0101919239,
0.0255378876,
0.0216141269,
0.0018294797,
-0.0155330477,
0.0309087373,
-0.0255170856,
0.0003518136,
0.0043140585,
0.0233973693,
0.0005202558,
-0.022904925,
0.016298743,
0.010100293,
-0.0016628442,
-0.0052141203,
0.0547596775,
0.0048012235,
0.021224631,
0.0173033644,
0.0081996564,
-0.0480397306,
0.0126204304,
0.0389438979,
0.0241194386,
0.0046526706,
0.0367409885,
-0.0016181774,
-0.0332556181,
-0.0414349325,
-0.014992266,
-0.0062554856,
-0.0076064593,
0.0202471539,
0.0618211664,
-0.0554452203,
-0.0439718254,
-0.0322032347,
0.0032630106,
0.0103073902,
-0.0167719852,
-0.0184530281,
-5.773657971e-33,
-0.0352225825,
-0.0373993516,
-0.0085879928,
0.0585005917,
0.0633070618,
0.0182029437,
-0.0366947278,
0.0042377771,
0.0042325468,
0.0440727286,
0.0271903947,
0.0230004229,
0.0130398218,
0.0133229066,
0.0393676944,
-0.0375255905,
0.0254352931,
0.0157335196,
-0.0220573414,
0.0406254381,
0.0644372329,
0.0003064759,
0.0928513333,
-0.0833573788,
0.1104733571,
0.0223086812,
-0.0064691091,
0.0144118564,
-0.0138895605,
0.0140106138,
0.0149699319,
0.0733102188,
0.021069089,
-0.0310410522,
-0.0127746006,
0.0365129076,
-0.0807644874,
-0.0689958036,
-0.0056430143,
0.0421007685,
-0.0698930472,
-0.0376480445,
0.0329548903,
-0.0130159287,
-0.0038827427,
-0.0117641781,
0.0838609189,
-0.0189850666,
0.0159208067,
0.0108516691,
-0.0201417934,
0.0182138924,
-0.076936245,
-0.0541909114,
0.0202581566,
0.0685195476,
-0.0174333211,
-0.0340113305,
-0.0435030498,
0.0497163348,
0.0588571802,
0.0117970798,
0.0482666418,
0.0329309218,
-0.01260514,
0.0443704464,
0.0424691774,
-0.0151424268,
-0.0010291401,
-0.0274302568,
-0.0003114969,
0.0091274707,
0.0420322306,
0.0486520231,
0.0289006252,
0.0351211801,
-0.0477105677,
0.056137573,
0.0502120256,
-0.0226939265,
-0.0204110425,
-0.0210167784,
-0.0631634071,
-0.0323968083,
-0.0168014169,
-0.0040994384,
-0.0228029992,
-0.029947577,
0.0282606464,
-0.0078604659,
-0.0458197482,
0.0184017345,
-0.0019915567,
-0.0483933724,
-0.0221139584,
-0.0039078118,
-0.0160590652,
-0.0216657706,
-0.0025604218,
-0.0266605653,
-0.0247103106,
-0.0130542396,
0.0310464967,
-0.0020417778,
0.0458473191,
0.0104791056,
0.0748796612,
0.0529151708,
-0.0605436377,
-0.0114474548,
-0.0220271554,
0.0049106413,
0.0050686621,
0.0130859558,
0.0245790742,
0.014870923,
-0.0328413285,
0.0216418114,
0.0564489625,
-0.0487626866,
-0.0396536775,
-0.0132074663,
-0.0631550923,
-0.0175433122,
-0.036715772,
-0.0390997939,
-0.0176532473,
-0.0384492353,
0.0164551474,
-0.0403859578,
0.0082458854,
-0.0042420295,
2.582e-7,
0.0240205061,
0.0494774319,
-0.0328527875,
0.0030747564,
-0.0162542257,
0.0403173044,
-0.0400581136,
0.0123099722,
0.0104151703,
-0.0133687761,
0.0009138375,
0.0509855263,
0.0358423516,
0.0420287661,
-0.0830480158,
0.0031843702,
-0.006398371,
0.0290871654,
-0.0402834974,
0.0433134064,
0.0828209519,
0.0477219783,
0.0436730087,
0.0054042949,
-0.0009411589,
-0.0562086068,
0.0144540388,
-0.0268179253,
0.0044186008,
0.0102156904,
0.030447986,
-0.0257980507,
0.0124064106,
0.0435500368,
-0.0248654094,
-0.0034357081,
-0.0274514388,
0.0307423696,
-0.022057198,
-0.0032319915,
-0.000429823,
-0.0048253499,
0.009549994,
-0.0206784233,
0.0534165576,
-0.0435778238,
-0.027532937,
0.0213450454,
0.0147250229,
-0.0486337207,
0.0117800944,
0.0145439385,
-0.0029334871,
-0.0003560288,
-0.0105716623,
-0.0198520981,
-0.0167004056,
-0.0606115088,
-0.0333992615,
-0.0063353102,
-0.0051589455,
-0.0137638832,
0.002861517,
-0.0098347142,
0.0028753777,
-0.067030564,
0.0290177874,
1.950832517e-34,
-0.0000418121,
0.0298133828,
0.009092059,
0.0176630113,
0.0248198081,
-0.0003828854,
-0.0310451351,
-0.0048065982,
0.0933127999,
-0.0217246022,
-0.0253673922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10757v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10757v1 | How Contentious Terms About People and Cultures are Used in Linked Open Data | 2023-11-13T18:25:20 | 2023-11-13T18:25:20 | Andrei Nesterov, Laura Hollink, Jacco van Ossenbruggen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.1 | Web resources in linked open data (LOD) are comprehensible to humans through
literal textual values attached to them, such as labels, notes, or comments.
Word choices in literals may not always be neutral. When outdated and
culturally stereotyping terminology is used in literals, they may appear as
offensive to users in interfaces and propagate stereotypes to algorithms
trained on them. We study how frequently and in which literals contentious
terms about people and cultures occur in LOD and whether there are attempts to
mark the usage of such terms. For our analysis, we reuse English and Dutch
terms from a knowledge graph that provides opinions of experts from the
cultural heritage domain about terms' contentiousness. We inspect occurrences
of these terms in four widely used datasets: Wikidata, The Getty Art &
Architecture Thesaurus, Princeton WordNet, and Open Dutch WordNet. Some terms
are ambiguous and contentious only in particular senses. Applying word sense
disambiguation, we generate a set of literals relevant to our analysis. We
found that outdated, derogatory, stereotyping terms frequently appear in
descriptive and labelling literals, such as preferred labels that are usually
displayed in interfaces and used for indexing. In some cases, LOD contributors
mark contentious terms with words and phrases in literals (implicit markers) or
properties linked to resources (explicit markers). However, such marking is
rare and non-consistent in all datasets. Our quantitative and qualitative
insights could be helpful in developing more systematic approaches to address
the propagation of stereotypes via LOD. | [
0.0553982779,
0.0388309471,
-0.0294507109,
0.0459768064,
-0.0049780388,
0.0158572476,
0.0205958895,
0.0127763534,
0.0477286726,
-0.083709158,
-0.0357426032,
0.0308218375,
0.0442277156,
-0.0174244922,
-0.0270816945,
-0.0480884276,
0.035746146,
0.0513261333,
-0.0012597403,
-0.0290105417,
0.0193527658,
0.0533491932,
0.0238648057,
0.0357051268,
-0.0410828702,
-0.0270106923,
0.0775327608,
-0.009557127,
0.0126355533,
-0.0528308377,
0.0398927778,
0.035375528,
-0.0356594175,
0.0267189294,
0.0000017746,
-0.0528333001,
0.0312126372,
-0.0106788557,
0.015986003,
0.0026386178,
0.0701559708,
0.0150609324,
0.0200595502,
-0.0304570775,
-0.0216450468,
-0.0550810359,
0.0371150523,
-0.0079019777,
0.0213364065,
-0.0286427028,
0.0078153741,
-0.028279895,
-0.0564705655,
0.0263670366,
-0.0126300948,
0.0397290103,
0.0301715955,
0.0126984175,
-0.0475334562,
0.0010191654,
-0.0386201181,
0.0111298207,
-0.0347482301,
0.0287287682,
0.0133619122,
-0.0204451308,
-0.0625527352,
-0.0291178394,
0.0546839796,
0.0687892362,
0.0921534002,
0.0170634668,
0.0067635402,
0.009341266,
-0.031983044,
0.0724388957,
-0.0035908441,
0.0150096323,
-0.0441086702,
-0.0081367297,
-0.0241818279,
-0.0104784882,
0.0374395475,
0.0767654181,
-0.0181710273,
0.0588004664,
-0.0161960404,
0.0084930239,
0.0085104592,
-0.037970975,
0.0054715346,
-0.0217427835,
-0.0022275324,
-0.0066921441,
0.0129675902,
0.0594826862,
-0.0134614846,
-0.0107767275,
0.03584693,
-0.0827290267,
-0.0315713361,
0.0159294866,
-0.0550267212,
0.0183415096,
0.0324202664,
-0.0080671636,
-0.0026223767,
-0.0006866417,
0.0359827839,
-0.0155333187,
-0.0333844945,
0.0001489542,
0.028089663,
-0.0105357114,
0.0316105075,
0.0387718566,
-0.0138920564,
-0.0087749101,
-0.0796235353,
0.0072797965,
-0.0063738688,
-0.0096029155,
-0.0116072698,
0.0049656392,
-0.0848827064,
-0.0203531366,
-0.0402410924,
0.0025912765,
-0.0704578981,
-0.0594550818,
0.0635553598,
0.0074862596,
-0.0099866446,
-0.020417558,
-0.0057853493,
0.0425189324,
0.060168013,
0.0339082852,
-0.0249836445,
-0.0671341494,
-0.0161004327,
-0.0007760773,
0.0059489617,
-0.0587667711,
0.0113769397,
0.0205700491,
-0.0065202303,
-0.1013408229,
-0.0109519307,
0.0366057046,
-0.1122465879,
0.0607028902,
-0.0532876588,
-0.0252465233,
0.056660641,
0.0381369255,
-0.0561798029,
0.0381590948,
0.0074651418,
0.0025214194,
0.0796846524,
0.0475176238,
-0.0660256147,
0.0089984825,
0.00854534,
0.0029113179,
-0.0298190583,
0.0575325303,
0.0037103808,
-0.0030414001,
0.0146865202,
0.0512974001,
-0.0495917648,
-0.0390139185,
0.018595105,
0.0627280474,
-0.0194829348,
0.0360316969,
0.0101379501,
0.0203060769,
0.0035124749,
-0.0116508165,
-0.0509700663,
-0.0159670711,
0.0329091325,
-0.042599503,
-0.0101616848,
0.0568540022,
-0.0058491146,
-0.0408553109,
-0.0116102966,
0.0176700056,
0.0489785708,
-0.0463244058,
0.0086389882,
0.0172125772,
0.0234195497,
0.0575554706,
0.0384239294,
0.0199565217,
0.0122731943,
0.0032065972,
-0.0169463474,
0.0748684183,
0.0420711972,
-0.0033488781,
0.0062410273,
-0.0130496481,
0.0240088236,
0.0227339864,
0.0707772374,
-0.0242766589,
-0.0679586381,
-0.0160851758,
-0.032890629,
0.0243790466,
-0.0126380492,
0.0009928931,
0.0389493257,
0.0668997318,
0.0274604503,
-0.0537412241,
-0.0430222452,
-0.0041198269,
0.0218744371,
0.0143408477,
-0.0615183525,
0.0190685149,
-0.0080155693,
0.0498899855,
-0.0068680164,
-0.0353726372,
-0.0380808935,
0.0297032371,
0.0003617321,
0.041950874,
-0.0026012976,
0.0608518384,
0.0417024307,
-0.0805906653,
-0.0245738886,
0.0095768934,
0.0101125399,
0.0096372748,
0.0207681879,
-0.005856358,
0.0064509278,
-0.0000182743,
-0.0454909652,
-0.0229848679,
0.0032595978,
-0.0421383977,
0.0282695983,
-0.0433487259,
0.0246061627,
0.0058279573,
-0.0488503985,
0.0584660321,
0.0418772623,
-0.0548183583,
0.0420281142,
0.0187333375,
0.0174055602,
0.0268614348,
-0.0231438763,
-0.0532637499,
0.0659245029,
-0.0663865209,
-0.0352045149,
0.0027369806,
0.0101690535,
-0.0046675568,
-0.0120886462,
-0.0045897695,
0.0002800133,
-0.0013722286,
0.0070323274,
-0.030527249,
0.0454920568,
0.0364324674,
-0.0241862573,
-0.0076252017,
0.0088466415,
-0.016541319,
0.0028013354,
0.0540425591,
-0.0110942824,
-0.0304475781,
0.0127925072,
-0.0377456285,
-0.1290763766,
-0.0311822165,
-0.0023454488,
0.0156034408,
0.0257220883,
0.0483776778,
0.0009909123,
-0.026442375,
0.0124526825,
0.0347118489,
0.0413228758,
-0.0282990169,
-0.0286100022,
-0.0529408306,
-0.0026485005,
0.023722114,
0.0318658575,
-0.047140874,
-0.0033110846,
-0.0174103696,
0.0435349159,
0.0087382877,
-0.0064221299,
0.0585399643,
-0.0880921781,
-0.0206164978,
-0.0248268042,
-0.016147051,
-0.003663505,
0.0556704476,
-0.0076350202,
-0.0370991826,
0.0185292177,
0.0458212607,
0.0678888783,
0.013676147,
0.0141593292,
-0.0213932749,
0.0401294827,
-0.0492993221,
0.0505949631,
0.0062852637,
-0.0212955177,
-0.0302131195,
-0.0141252289,
0.050420139,
-0.0736658871,
0.0290305763,
-0.0224094801,
-0.0188391656,
-0.016784206,
-0.0141386138,
-0.0233342741,
0.0227811094,
-0.0323029645,
-0.0184450708,
0.038795732,
0.001883173,
0.0616996586,
0.0123165799,
-0.0130931949,
-0.0291414037,
0.0337925367,
-0.0086281216,
0.0187823176,
-0.0153326988,
-0.0159472488,
0.0056803371,
0.0099439761,
0.0610875487,
-0.0270584989,
0.0318744406,
-0.0257149879,
-0.0712351501,
0.0241353232,
0.0066788248,
0.0200306177,
-0.0361097977,
-0.0522721484,
-0.0072195493,
-0.0104822973,
-0.0502657145,
0.0322190598,
0.0367214456,
0.0551117323,
-0.0354269631,
-0.0055913804,
-0.0224909894,
-0.0173696298,
0.0292067416,
-0.0164111089,
-0.1239123121,
0.0297287311,
-0.0137182176,
0.0306635424,
-0.0394207351,
-0.0702795684,
-0.0034923446,
-0.0765576214,
0.0058432487,
-0.0027216373,
-0.0477002785,
-0.0118275322,
-0.0155174481,
0.0054319324,
-0.0064278077,
0.0085677402,
-0.0445129648,
0.032406304,
0.0325000845,
-0.014626218,
-0.0625922382,
-0.0013865674,
0.0135819819,
-0.0341172405,
0.0413403958,
-0.0219245329,
0.0625126064,
0.0088293171,
-0.0383472405,
0.0351556651,
-0.0118174003,
-0.0261255465,
-0.0609479509,
0.0407274589,
-0.0149230678,
-0.0154415034,
-0.0168334339,
-0.0205869284,
0.0021494548,
0.0009019769,
-0.0299119093,
0.0605766363,
0.002282684,
0.0049857209,
-0.0345345698,
-0.0127416756,
0.0236973595,
0.0353221335,
-0.0015185318,
0.0001499748,
0.0094689913,
-0.0683356971,
0.0139218289,
0.0258236676,
-0.0776312277,
0.0336254202,
-0.0624179728,
-0.0189130493,
-0.0573772117,
-0.0816332847,
-0.0077151437,
0.0131127685,
0.0437392406,
-0.0246205628,
-0.0035315242,
-0.0055261734,
-0.0935622379,
0.0249974821,
-0.0293784365,
0.0130559783,
0.0422035046,
-0.0142654087,
0.0388410278,
0.0035881856,
-0.0087446626,
0.038472645,
0.05192554,
-0.0201515537,
0.0581495948,
0.0258359574,
0.0196266267,
0.0113831302,
0.0284043401,
-0.0326284654,
0.0230815914,
0.0376458243,
0.0029652743,
-0.0518336557,
0.0150240902,
0.0628000498,
0.0046611642,
0.0402904861,
-0.0314255022,
0.0131246075,
0.0122862188,
-0.0322843902,
-0.045017384,
-0.0119153354,
0.0066674729,
0.0099797919,
0.0322688818,
-0.043448247,
0.0144595411,
0.0000434673,
-0.0541445389,
0.0138634713,
-0.0308344215,
0.057136938,
-0.001847696,
-0.0249246769,
-0.0031666781,
-0.0350156911,
0.090728946,
0.0132963955,
0.0494339839,
-0.0263521485,
-0.0000759984,
0.0596242845,
0.0204702541,
-0.0196666978,
0.0139553826,
-0.0184879955,
0.0409177132,
-0.0016344277,
-0.000739911,
-0.0220611151,
0.0190849807,
0.027021654,
0.0156729445,
-0.0087002283,
-0.0153896799,
-0.0107213752,
-0.0691940635,
0.021627469,
-0.0487021729,
0.005915347,
-0.0051622135,
0.017442394,
0.0135821113,
-0.0410468169,
0.012135094,
-0.003641326,
0.0185523238,
-0.0258028675,
0.0440196432,
0.002532555,
-0.0308007356,
0.0165262762,
0.0342747048,
-0.032378573,
0.0425784476,
-0.0184300859,
-0.0785661638,
-0.0126389135,
-0.0202855766,
0.0322705954,
0.0024646479,
-0.0060289432,
-0.0384426638,
-0.0876322836,
-0.0618176237,
0.0047113919,
-0.0251949895,
0.0349119529,
-0.0008794622,
0.0159744099,
0.0338317193,
0.0510031208,
-0.012255556,
-0.0072124028,
0.0135758966,
-0.0600550696,
-0.0271697491,
-0.0013212801,
-5.686543186e-33,
0.008247721,
-0.0593882948,
0.0111765657,
0.0250446536,
-0.0450141989,
-0.0240622219,
0.0157784037,
0.0020101252,
-0.0639008731,
0.0277469419,
0.0072651496,
0.0154754091,
0.013256398,
-0.0309233796,
0.028424019,
-0.0070350636,
0.0103464518,
0.0117683616,
-0.030697206,
-0.0222882852,
0.0776865408,
-0.0260712691,
0.0289215129,
-0.0952851474,
0.1043990627,
0.0018713638,
-0.0241600145,
0.0016208733,
0.0745577887,
0.0203506611,
-0.0106612332,
0.0850644708,
0.0310040098,
-0.0031878497,
-0.0077363513,
0.0231244341,
-0.0771534741,
-0.0068979347,
0.0302915666,
0.0496827811,
0.0579270087,
-0.0266388338,
0.0283012427,
0.0282220226,
-0.0569317341,
0.032193318,
0.0563076846,
-0.0193489436,
-0.0157993287,
-0.0111827711,
-0.0051770746,
0.0358864926,
-0.0141760353,
0.0775000826,
0.006232928,
-0.0075879195,
0.0124777798,
0.0283328909,
-0.1048764437,
0.0349574573,
-0.0445353538,
-0.0275973994,
0.0544852875,
0.0217375178,
0.0058017448,
0.0422664694,
-0.0034784232,
0.0690490603,
0.0270009581,
0.002730391,
0.0242882613,
0.007962808,
-0.0315438211,
0.0866314918,
0.0203427114,
-0.0683744624,
-0.0075864512,
-0.0069679283,
0.0085998308,
0.0108467424,
-0.0311070178,
0.0067889928,
-0.0504068658,
-0.0285209306,
-0.0214631632,
-0.022234885,
-0.0364787243,
-0.0477187335,
0.0159466248,
-0.0465602204,
-0.0217626113,
0.0278496705,
-0.0289327428,
-0.0585260913,
-0.0222124476,
-0.0099394545,
-0.0159546342,
-0.0280709583,
0.0205272399,
-0.0052542738,
-0.0371674448,
0.0111436257,
-0.0333000831,
0.0285263844,
0.0169867631,
0.0313657783,
0.0089880489,
-0.0018086147,
-0.053331811,
-0.003183679,
0.0111886524,
-0.0417184196,
-0.0133673968,
-0.0325490125,
0.0425219834,
0.0042715161,
-0.0034330243,
-0.0254326817,
0.0974828228,
0.0267938618,
-0.0064144107,
-0.0537899211,
-0.0306845121,
-0.0067374827,
-0.0063935341,
-0.013824,
-0.0067802202,
0.0229108017,
0.0163077675,
-0.0235005524,
0.0011108812,
-0.0449795239,
2.566e-7,
0.0575778484,
0.0655959398,
-0.0251610056,
0.0672554672,
0.0240535438,
-0.0252940077,
0.0516785793,
0.0479552858,
-0.0525326207,
-0.0538264401,
0.0104000159,
-0.0074426541,
0.0169512723,
0.0859765783,
-0.0245967954,
-0.0346974581,
-0.0043520792,
0.0082480721,
-0.0488042049,
0.0079104435,
0.0211065207,
0.0042558564,
0.0157596935,
-0.0126354378,
-0.0676289722,
-0.0097128209,
0.0049858456,
-0.0366779864,
0.0091213901,
-0.0069678938,
0.0591906942,
0.0168881454,
0.0216149669,
0.0006367808,
0.0056220246,
-0.0145180225,
0.0444833152,
-0.026677819,
0.0215817429,
0.0318154208,
-0.0272643529,
-0.0596575923,
0.0348019488,
-0.0384187736,
0.0310165975,
0.0657750368,
-0.0221387576,
0.0257363077,
-0.0197121594,
-0.0019405421,
0.0538075753,
-0.0451102182,
-0.0404426232,
0.0053066202,
0.0061294236,
0.0208665412,
0.016492011,
-0.0596562773,
-0.009799663,
-0.0068632117,
-0.0033267313,
-0.0600599349,
0.0226444975,
0.0104120839,
-0.0096294433,
0.0416879468,
0.0204022229,
1.675497531e-34,
0.0198652688,
-0.0052668289,
-0.0143774161,
-0.033344835,
0.0383851044,
-0.0051681297,
0.0194112062,
-0.0121819181,
0.0232706517,
0.0139664058,
0.015328059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07536v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07536v2 | A Comprehensive Evaluation of GPT-4V on Knowledge-Intensive Visual Question Answering | 2023-11-13T18:22:32 | 2024-01-27T14:16:54 | Yunxin Li, Longyue Wang, Baotian Hu, Xinyu Chen, Wanqi Zhong, Chenyang Lyu, Wei Wang, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The emergence of multimodal large models (MLMs) has significantly advanced
the field of visual understanding, offering remarkable capabilities in the
realm of visual question answering (VQA). Yet, the true challenge lies in the
domain of knowledge-intensive VQA tasks, which necessitate not just recognition
of visual elements, but also a deep comprehension of the visual information in
conjunction with a vast repository of learned knowledge. To uncover such
capabilities of MLMs, particularly the newly introduced GPT-4V, we provide an
in-depth evaluation from three perspectives: 1) Commonsense Knowledge, which
assesses how well models can understand visual cues and connect to general
knowledge; 2) Fine-grained World Knowledge, which tests the model's skill in
reasoning out specific knowledge from images, showcasing their proficiency
across various specialized fields; 3) Comprehensive Knowledge with
Decision-making Rationales, which examines model's capability to provide
logical explanations for its inference, facilitating a deeper analysis from the
interpretability perspective. Extensive experiments indicate that GPT-4V
achieves SOTA performance on above three tasks. Interestingly, we find that: a)
GPT-4V demonstrates enhanced reasoning and explanation when using composite
images as few-shot; b) GPT-4V produces severe hallucinations when dealing with
world knowledge, highlighting the future need for advancements in this research
direction. | [
0.0235822275,
0.0445602871,
-0.0161911007,
0.0553363077,
-0.0001235521,
0.0171313491,
0.0179827213,
0.0077312691,
0.0208215471,
-0.042301286,
-0.036504969,
-0.0001681115,
-0.0215219352,
0.028468065,
0.048132319,
-0.06932313,
0.0320047475,
-0.028877385,
-0.0113901449,
-0.0132307364,
0.0216677599,
-0.0014146916,
-0.0157302395,
0.0443489142,
-0.0301124752,
-0.0506572686,
-0.0117829498,
0.005310447,
0.0404832251,
-0.0092358887,
-0.0255571492,
0.0250102244,
0.0653346404,
0.0134336604,
0.0000018317,
0.005239998,
0.0228868425,
0.0115901157,
-0.0088053774,
0.0248728693,
-0.0454349779,
-0.0326286778,
0.0213584285,
-0.0327538736,
-0.0404588208,
0.0105859004,
0.0571905263,
0.0421576202,
0.0717376843,
0.0071457569,
-0.0161320753,
-0.042998746,
0.0293485019,
-0.0003336736,
0.0248418208,
-0.0566385053,
-0.0073312777,
0.0743671954,
-0.0025110675,
-0.0241726544,
-0.0619082041,
0.0342383049,
0.0362775326,
0.0128448857,
-0.0158323292,
0.0548594259,
-0.0223935805,
-0.0070574055,
-0.0029771696,
0.0718922392,
0.001787645,
0.0107306596,
-0.0228139926,
0.0197235346,
0.0187264327,
0.0382751785,
-0.064535521,
0.0208182577,
-0.0247126184,
0.0085278833,
-0.055160813,
-0.005470993,
-0.0013276524,
0.0246213507,
-0.0179973152,
-0.0078135654,
0.0141748255,
0.0179497674,
0.0086422246,
0.0139790382,
-0.0837082043,
-0.0122353109,
-0.0330036357,
0.0653600991,
-0.0057093273,
-0.0067937607,
0.0115487743,
0.0310521647,
-0.0103511317,
-0.0285911765,
0.0426980294,
0.025222633,
-0.0555108115,
0.0718368813,
-0.0226125009,
0.0570478812,
-0.0563436598,
0.0430477522,
0.0119033447,
-0.0322201923,
-0.0817132592,
-0.0495275632,
-0.0450381748,
0.0184328873,
-0.0436006486,
-0.0673656985,
0.0024967212,
0.0029907359,
-0.0216133911,
0.011451358,
-0.0121929934,
0.0359537303,
0.002088496,
-0.0257263202,
-0.0639292821,
0.0576219,
-0.0551004484,
0.0002544494,
-0.0126697887,
-0.0130536016,
-0.0166818388,
0.0142081389,
-0.012712514,
-0.0285471808,
0.0042813164,
0.0580082051,
-0.028927641,
-0.0075887409,
-0.0358453728,
-0.0189978015,
-0.0139494035,
-0.069196716,
0.0430741124,
-0.005687037,
0.0057202191,
-0.002824239,
0.0045488449,
0.017186014,
-0.003590795,
-0.0085209059,
-0.0260653943,
0.0964653194,
-0.0242424216,
-0.0050428356,
0.0114093088,
0.0428788699,
-0.0291416384,
0.065941371,
-0.0087749669,
0.0274793748,
0.0177624132,
-0.0343898349,
0.0603249148,
0.0130747808,
-0.0177452452,
-0.0073921988,
-0.0408619381,
0.0322940946,
-0.0261621308,
0.0085481657,
0.0488223024,
0.0205589645,
-0.0409093872,
-0.013926723,
0.0834701434,
0.0054445164,
0.006276248,
0.0172513146,
0.0282712057,
-0.0134430109,
0.0229462851,
0.0343772881,
-0.0778854117,
0.1038109958,
-0.0286060143,
-0.0064817364,
-0.0102926623,
0.0214293413,
-0.0267771184,
-0.0122222612,
0.0101626283,
0.0115909753,
-0.0056974622,
0.0427656807,
0.0278722681,
-0.0210348461,
-0.0143285543,
0.0127467019,
0.0064434507,
-0.0006452965,
-0.0254913867,
-0.0466449894,
0.0640079379,
0.0578058846,
0.0341197364,
-0.0096968031,
-0.0252021514,
0.0168998558,
0.0205250643,
0.0229546875,
-0.0017947595,
0.0279473476,
0.0479578339,
-0.0404016785,
-0.0225089137,
-0.0575471334,
0.0089298654,
0.0141879944,
0.0147400778,
0.0059659593,
-0.0020785185,
-0.0293623563,
0.0326497443,
-0.0023502735,
0.0489711203,
-0.0051673078,
-0.0616250858,
0.0161159635,
0.0024480701,
-0.0116307372,
-0.001068744,
-0.022470925,
-0.004983231,
-0.0074283504,
0.0056663733,
0.0213283263,
-0.0337950923,
-0.0331473909,
0.0062782569,
-0.0664609,
-0.0200206265,
0.0380320847,
-0.0444648936,
-0.0077669076,
0.0203865897,
-0.0140222544,
-0.0201547574,
-0.0697468519,
-0.068352513,
0.0349857919,
0.0358304083,
0.0084080193,
0.0855852589,
-0.0036079339,
-0.0283447299,
0.0034262545,
-0.0009289249,
0.0162293501,
-0.0062828567,
0.010381029,
0.0117891524,
0.0088553168,
0.0087022241,
-0.0482032076,
-0.0015550569,
-0.0514412932,
0.0045670625,
-0.0830289274,
-0.0041512125,
-0.0129116438,
-0.0256496184,
0.00715855,
-0.0177481603,
-0.0114413118,
-0.0345519073,
-0.0370834135,
0.0633725896,
0.0090341186,
0.0292031281,
0.0284242816,
0.0156594645,
0.0137461452,
0.0020491525,
0.0213703439,
0.0215443093,
0.0675482899,
0.0153655708,
0.0162246432,
-0.0365624838,
-0.036910288,
-0.0745140091,
0.044999551,
-0.01994518,
-0.0545940511,
0.0374978669,
-0.0212793723,
0.01861763,
0.0724235922,
0.0062745195,
0.0348697007,
0.013990188,
-0.0178479627,
0.0005891955,
0.0164297707,
0.0204365142,
-0.0326343551,
-0.001437907,
0.012931372,
-0.043327488,
0.015634967,
-0.0191450957,
-0.0116555355,
-0.0694410652,
0.0342877209,
0.039472267,
-0.0498659424,
-0.0472248867,
0.0092696995,
0.020587638,
0.0254306607,
-0.035542164,
-0.0602870248,
0.0547563173,
-0.0083626723,
-0.0372707918,
0.0373995081,
-0.0053503481,
-0.0103311678,
0.0900782198,
0.011371918,
0.0209362619,
-0.0447028168,
-0.0017936331,
-0.0505602434,
-0.0374423862,
0.0208913591,
0.0194310583,
0.0376684405,
-0.0637122616,
0.0128224734,
-0.0260382518,
-0.0156088825,
-0.016831303,
-0.0065071834,
-0.0406488143,
0.0156927966,
-0.0447350182,
0.0032730058,
0.0112557597,
0.0260602105,
0.0521200001,
-0.0133156143,
-0.0262631644,
-0.0123781208,
-0.0106367553,
0.0511912741,
0.0640702024,
0.0678530633,
0.0076111695,
-0.0416009575,
0.031598188,
0.0794014484,
0.0041163526,
-0.0267563052,
-0.0694630519,
0.0416596383,
-0.019735679,
0.0415720716,
-0.0329367444,
0.019163765,
0.0838839859,
-0.0680786967,
0.024909867,
0.0682624951,
0.0026516579,
-0.0142684933,
-0.012429391,
-0.0192962196,
0.0180032533,
0.0248895027,
0.0246674679,
-0.0743021443,
-0.0619465224,
-0.0362152345,
-0.0059546037,
0.0191522725,
-0.0103033502,
-0.0050374288,
-0.0411032438,
0.079022266,
-0.0118354624,
-0.044096224,
-0.0433329046,
0.0454571843,
-0.0129698683,
-0.0066772196,
-0.0200272985,
-0.01158881,
0.0141323023,
0.0059388266,
0.0018957054,
0.0146740321,
0.00092671,
0.0548849367,
-0.0415457487,
-0.0204063859,
0.0374710932,
0.0062503293,
-0.0182759725,
-0.0647033304,
-0.017077513,
-0.010042375,
0.0426870324,
0.0002122307,
0.0600153878,
-0.0234299656,
-0.0532965139,
-0.0153976046,
0.0295205507,
-0.0079353889,
-0.0307765901,
0.0000693705,
0.0740167499,
-0.0309287179,
-0.0348624885,
-0.0269347988,
0.0288224425,
-0.0178015847,
0.0492015891,
0.0539077148,
0.011395202,
-0.0656454936,
-0.001232931,
0.0074370774,
-0.0419826806,
-0.015608131,
0.0220788717,
0.0852833763,
0.0127144475,
-0.048383113,
-0.0154558998,
0.0381841548,
0.0652439967,
-0.046490375,
0.0036329345,
-0.0381850973,
0.0404063016,
-0.0208161417,
0.0776545256,
-0.0245275274,
-0.0067778802,
-0.0126108425,
-0.0171533115,
0.0317781158,
-0.0586963817,
-0.024030339,
0.035177432,
-0.0374137983,
-0.0123530775,
-0.0414436683,
0.0638209134,
0.0262831319,
0.0201762952,
0.0351561084,
-0.0333701037,
0.0004046878,
0.0176791437,
0.0113270208,
0.021558525,
0.019424919,
-0.0129562598,
0.0041769291,
0.0169686079,
-0.0107190767,
0.0086914031,
0.0037644904,
-0.0049905153,
-0.0022911066,
0.018537676,
0.0102067878,
0.0072779916,
0.0074735163,
-0.0159489699,
0.0087210825,
-0.0026583462,
0.0018655256,
0.0179962572,
0.0233245529,
-0.0772264525,
-0.0043588961,
0.0207837373,
-0.0129397642,
0.0017037137,
-0.0412547775,
0.0180928577,
0.0074240896,
-0.0493298881,
-0.0358077548,
0.0262029916,
-0.0415828824,
-0.0128877284,
0.0102224695,
-0.0256545153,
-0.0180314854,
-0.0200485159,
0.0352973305,
0.0144367134,
0.1203678027,
0.0407331437,
-0.0432367958,
-0.0147662582,
0.0495915972,
-0.0571147017,
-0.0930961296,
0.0113595231,
0.0539159551,
0.0485059284,
0.0189834032,
-0.0067613763,
-0.0291846879,
-0.0146154957,
0.0048600095,
0.0377696343,
0.0361597054,
-0.0314166807,
0.0554531105,
0.0397857688,
0.00102537,
-0.0318975262,
0.0853511691,
0.0029011343,
0.0333118215,
-0.00871523,
-0.0108853579,
-0.034144327,
-0.0510411821,
0.0341130383,
0.0064968024,
0.0161963198,
0.0459749028,
-0.0470427684,
-0.0488696583,
-0.0409479998,
0.0229164883,
-0.041238755,
0.0074783135,
0.0282035321,
0.0529375449,
0.0232022796,
-0.0623691976,
0.0151953958,
-0.0006739309,
-0.0131329363,
0.062136177,
0.0343070962,
-5.993098521e-33,
-0.0287660658,
-0.0273346864,
0.0547834635,
-0.0481870025,
-0.0348052904,
-0.0050831367,
-0.0317876711,
-0.0129871126,
-0.0324539132,
0.0190912988,
0.0230041686,
0.0028474315,
-0.0080949087,
0.0320504718,
-0.0087868506,
-0.0433659814,
-0.024315767,
0.0153469034,
-0.0214152988,
0.0263924468,
0.0118668443,
0.0090426197,
0.0591196865,
-0.0028599899,
-0.0387289822,
0.0299720187,
-0.0361053459,
0.0051622451,
-0.0664802343,
0.0677657127,
-0.0573840812,
0.0091456585,
0.039618995,
-0.0147010051,
-0.0127138151,
-0.0073343315,
-0.0515358746,
-0.0170355476,
0.0487810448,
0.0048392732,
-0.1022902057,
-0.0058172811,
0.029566111,
-0.0096160667,
0.0426722616,
-0.054165747,
0.0249742921,
-0.0422415473,
0.0184472073,
0.022738304,
-0.0234079771,
-0.0109372623,
-0.0205469802,
-0.0303633828,
0.0030687044,
0.0171290431,
0.0059677833,
0.0366412252,
-0.0127411773,
0.0020436686,
-0.0012056825,
-0.0055662771,
0.0841433182,
0.0140223959,
0.0194450598,
0.040811453,
0.0298659839,
-0.0564002246,
-0.0810993984,
-0.0259070825,
-0.0043059145,
0.0659511834,
0.055877652,
0.0555687919,
0.0278729014,
0.0469719581,
-0.0453412458,
-0.0032624325,
-0.0847360268,
0.0639284626,
0.0098519521,
-0.0089472076,
0.0114171803,
0.0090910336,
-0.0188648142,
0.0079632476,
-0.0362783037,
0.0032532783,
0.0496755913,
0.0037665493,
-0.0115514491,
0.0573850945,
0.0580736734,
-0.0463499166,
0.033935748,
0.0271177087,
-0.0339336991,
0.047104612,
0.0275682826,
0.0276189782,
0.0081961798,
-0.0054145693,
0.0610253252,
-0.0169125367,
-0.0073760077,
0.0171381515,
0.0217720475,
0.0252471156,
0.0057930332,
-0.0156652853,
-0.0518751591,
0.0239510741,
-0.0257135797,
-0.0225066338,
0.0094031803,
0.0083533656,
-0.047861848,
-0.0344998725,
-0.0347837768,
-0.0001560523,
0.0039452803,
-0.0278860852,
-0.0220201164,
0.0294556357,
-0.0142846424,
0.0107320044,
-0.0337284319,
-0.1024967059,
-0.0058496632,
-0.0489677265,
-0.0171311088,
0.0656731501,
2.518e-7,
0.0254041869,
0.008927878,
-0.0127906995,
-0.010171813,
0.0420357734,
0.0405295901,
-0.0287759714,
0.011657184,
0.0016844429,
-0.0622866154,
0.0144025153,
0.0957429409,
0.0382628925,
0.0211498868,
0.024547264,
0.004146595,
0.0002268195,
-0.0410119146,
-0.0767714307,
0.0039125211,
0.0717586502,
0.0411132053,
-0.011750632,
-0.0263303332,
0.0846934319,
-0.0560607351,
0.0889412537,
-0.0141408369,
0.0153578613,
-0.056266509,
0.0141166598,
0.0035826056,
-0.0073154359,
0.0534256622,
0.0250548571,
-0.0518721268,
0.0268849358,
0.018726401,
-0.0080276048,
-0.0299109947,
-0.0218461212,
0.0166079514,
0.0119730746,
-0.0959901884,
0.1071526781,
-0.0419414565,
-0.0402857214,
0.0280148312,
-0.0466665588,
-0.0702098235,
0.0141135957,
-0.0153993666,
-0.023559358,
-0.002029852,
-0.0067941733,
-0.0233090352,
-0.0120556103,
-0.0653028786,
0.0357515812,
-0.0104405796,
-0.062243212,
-0.0193234999,
-0.0539713241,
-0.0455235131,
0.0710760579,
-0.0431570262,
-0.0698807836,
1.726618104e-34,
0.0046016281,
-0.0104860207,
0.0504579507,
0.0021670375,
0.0311695952,
0.0103396084,
-0.0037272386,
-0.0432596058,
-0.0061923685,
-0.0605980977,
-0.0190175213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07532v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07532v3 | It's Not Easy Being Wrong: Large Language Models Struggle with Process of Elimination Reasoning | 2023-11-13T18:18:22 | 2024-06-07T23:01:20 | Nishant Balepur, Shramay Palta, Rachel Rudinger | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chain-of-thought (COT) prompting can help large language models (LLMs) reason
toward correct answers, but its efficacy in reasoning toward incorrect answers
is unexplored. This process of elimination (PoE), when used with COT, can
enhance self-consistency, interpretability, and tasks such as medical diagnoses
of exclusion. Thus, we propose PoE with COT, where LLMs must reason toward
incorrect options on multiple-choice questions. We evaluate the ability of
GPT-3.5, LLaMA-2, and Falcon to perform PoE with COT on a total of four
commonsense and scientific reasoning datasets. We find that the strategy of PoE
always underperforms the strategy of choosing the correct answer. The agreement
of these strategies is also lower than the self-consistency of each strategy.
To study these issues further, we conduct error analyses and give suggestions
for future work. | [
0.0424904861,
0.0619545095,
0.0006628152,
0.012945543,
-0.0399128385,
0.046519883,
0.0280199684,
0.0035116677,
0.0361563154,
-0.0244437493,
-0.0108141387,
0.0221366193,
0.000060614,
-0.0099779526,
0.0114681637,
-0.0217079762,
0.0396826901,
-0.0497362092,
0.0345094465,
-0.0476122424,
-0.017759461,
0.0078189019,
-0.0272442233,
0.0289943907,
0.0463298745,
-0.0531882644,
0.0079437802,
-0.0421622023,
0.0302156899,
-0.0551687479,
-0.0209283642,
0.0778673813,
-0.0238961224,
0.046492666,
0.0000022397,
-0.0391576625,
0.0198565405,
-0.005036776,
-0.0770151764,
0.0325797386,
-0.0266672783,
0.0381944403,
0.0182506628,
0.0307789017,
-0.0013038263,
-0.0316946357,
0.0367724486,
0.0320253484,
0.0692280456,
0.0202563219,
0.0189847667,
-0.0263082143,
-0.0064388169,
-0.0207602289,
0.0248565711,
-0.034113843,
0.0385522917,
0.0037004543,
0.0253062882,
0.0099178543,
-0.030916702,
0.0373731218,
0.0388463214,
0.0072798817,
-0.0483656302,
0.0642859638,
-0.0223522875,
-0.0305300765,
0.001780108,
0.0656885356,
0.0326034315,
-0.0547780767,
-0.0096753156,
0.0052017989,
0.0026420767,
0.0216039307,
-0.0334532596,
0.0277231317,
-0.0126084983,
0.0180983171,
0.0467936434,
-0.0057276525,
0.0221729651,
0.0193155818,
-0.0109819602,
0.0851781443,
0.0276318416,
-0.040617425,
0.0353275798,
0.0333000533,
-0.0060049072,
-0.0773429722,
0.0066873753,
0.0267320573,
-0.0678755119,
0.024127366,
0.0103114452,
-0.0106178317,
0.0332728364,
-0.0064940737,
0.0300477892,
0.0408106036,
-0.0124628963,
0.049818825,
-0.0134828268,
0.0309345294,
-0.0498869196,
0.0338348038,
-0.0218386203,
-0.0091861123,
-0.0320664495,
-0.0206175633,
-0.0049045058,
0.0555372722,
-0.0031589668,
0.0353575274,
-0.0446492061,
-0.0301199201,
-0.0506152958,
0.0301769357,
0.012336107,
0.026170956,
0.024255015,
-0.0305460691,
-0.0709596649,
0.0677774176,
-0.022359157,
0.0474398248,
0.0270041283,
-0.0105100442,
-0.012516683,
-0.0199290439,
0.0035482491,
-0.0228127874,
0.0442452841,
0.0326836407,
-0.0213986114,
-0.0028374428,
-0.0079465387,
0.0033278915,
-0.0258134715,
-0.07884074,
-0.0022761414,
-0.072932519,
0.0201964006,
0.035993576,
0.0004373138,
-0.0042592138,
0.0213527009,
0.0234924965,
-0.0539372899,
0.0831626728,
-0.0229304098,
0.0171567909,
0.0547266901,
0.0396575518,
-0.0036400622,
0.0424881093,
-0.009392661,
-0.0091760755,
0.0136320861,
-0.038593892,
0.0286006629,
0.0105054034,
0.0283628143,
-0.0121765351,
0.0200132132,
0.0122275604,
-0.0309239347,
0.0324399211,
-0.0105750747,
0.0676464662,
-0.0260489881,
-0.012127188,
0.05487765,
0.0631489828,
-0.0198477954,
0.002850018,
0.0266076811,
-0.0358086489,
0.0260480363,
0.0243940372,
-0.0536122508,
0.0282703005,
-0.0445316844,
-0.0093121007,
0.0232957304,
0.0106395613,
-0.037193466,
-0.038605459,
-0.0223248117,
0.0194618721,
-0.0155756576,
0.0388316698,
0.0294702835,
-0.0307567175,
-0.0000944828,
0.0443557128,
0.0208648704,
-0.0301316958,
-0.0336723477,
-0.0431057326,
0.0615188889,
0.018380532,
0.0577748157,
0.0104779629,
-0.051587753,
-0.0007018324,
0.0030278524,
0.0265194885,
0.0210391954,
-0.0318093933,
-0.0189211704,
-0.0233428665,
-0.0080591263,
0.0464501977,
0.0047042025,
-0.0225641914,
0.0050770743,
0.0060599702,
-0.0292917769,
-0.0329006985,
0.0090731028,
0.0237174314,
-0.0338957384,
-0.0243600179,
-0.0332372971,
0.0016812338,
0.0478119776,
-0.0096094524,
0.0016301257,
0.0256581418,
0.0106384428,
-0.0204322599,
-0.0347161032,
-0.0060461885,
-0.0347944573,
-0.0527623221,
0.0333914272,
-0.0326426663,
-0.0963891447,
0.0393355452,
-0.0448614545,
-0.0467629619,
0.0070768176,
-0.0348721966,
-0.0038945815,
-0.021630168,
-0.0050957915,
0.0110601271,
-0.0298035946,
-0.0142128021,
0.0872626454,
-0.0238583237,
0.0377009399,
0.012069257,
-0.0003794115,
0.0096291658,
-0.0418062322,
-0.038115263,
0.0274522323,
0.0314338319,
-0.0223484281,
-0.0023185092,
0.0252277907,
-0.0864399895,
-0.0027921468,
-0.1015255377,
-0.010577797,
0.0106869545,
0.0098257158,
0.0133882109,
-0.0284280982,
0.0108201606,
-0.0170677472,
-0.0308211185,
0.0324743129,
0.0444119759,
0.0364427231,
0.0362069048,
-0.0319937058,
-0.007915264,
-0.0117633455,
-0.0122150471,
-0.042157758,
0.0332205482,
-0.0269555673,
0.0332673565,
-0.0293341763,
0.0354933068,
-0.0602782518,
0.0125616081,
0.0134603288,
-0.0122142723,
0.0285696499,
-0.0097566023,
-0.0036613345,
0.0444279425,
-0.0252594389,
0.0065630442,
0.1006741002,
-0.0034560151,
-0.0536620952,
0.0127723208,
0.0067574843,
0.0004103076,
0.009843939,
-0.0179220922,
-0.0425279923,
0.0603059381,
0.0151423095,
-0.0154504376,
-0.0388314463,
0.0320635661,
-0.0130689647,
-0.0163110197,
-0.0509301834,
-0.032298699,
-0.0133437039,
0.0714156106,
-0.0037480176,
-0.0200544335,
0.1043514982,
-0.0092035942,
-0.0000533527,
-0.0827429518,
0.0312753022,
-0.0143764373,
0.0382947437,
-0.0260172784,
-0.0136333946,
0.0123549523,
0.003761878,
-0.058051426,
-0.0439831465,
-0.0053100088,
-0.036263857,
0.0763514042,
-0.0969435275,
0.0139503861,
0.0155593473,
-0.0702215657,
-0.0473777838,
-0.0175473448,
-0.0651325509,
-0.022204265,
-0.024506161,
0.0104297874,
-0.0326996855,
-0.0512156188,
0.0512212962,
0.0188475754,
0.0132408375,
-0.0211010613,
-0.0067595891,
0.0272733569,
0.043587558,
0.038880866,
0.0521381758,
0.0091695944,
0.0419383086,
0.0821896046,
0.0358000994,
0.0194910299,
0.0001091386,
0.0279354658,
0.0037066736,
-0.0102174757,
-0.0032328542,
0.0144113945,
0.0428941436,
-0.0304507744,
-0.0293156113,
0.1093981713,
0.0397588648,
-0.0543463528,
0.0001147899,
-0.0423003957,
0.0069492189,
0.0092677232,
0.0203671455,
-0.0769030601,
-0.0488795862,
0.0177544095,
0.0018211905,
-0.0093428604,
-0.0321319401,
0.0187016949,
-0.1312884837,
0.03768811,
-0.002598095,
-0.0196403097,
-0.0195293128,
-0.0501200184,
0.0193317719,
-0.0051270006,
-0.0144805983,
0.0380336493,
0.0270490255,
0.0150108533,
0.0055769566,
-0.0138630662,
-0.0278251134,
0.0779495612,
-0.0120647252,
0.050680913,
0.0030972774,
0.021012079,
-0.0097440481,
-0.0779412016,
0.0231578071,
-0.0622915216,
-0.0396166667,
-0.0428328365,
0.0138459122,
0.0413100608,
-0.0081366459,
-0.0637956411,
0.0539941192,
-0.0260523427,
-0.0327360779,
0.0287422333,
0.1387133151,
-0.0385210179,
-0.0561787523,
-0.0109642642,
0.032448303,
-0.033608377,
0.0747705996,
0.0201663226,
-0.0230219495,
-0.0423355363,
-0.042880442,
-0.0277218856,
0.0193462223,
-0.0435314029,
0.02659446,
0.0391996168,
0.0000673176,
-0.0208153334,
-0.0431391001,
0.0530827492,
0.021640867,
-0.0174143128,
0.0183862317,
-0.0002663103,
0.0321681499,
0.0195050947,
0.0060128802,
-0.0196523219,
-0.0133973192,
-0.0272450894,
0.0287504941,
-0.0049548415,
-0.0015533089,
-0.0260317121,
0.0596926734,
-0.0442090854,
-0.0311547797,
0.0107420646,
0.043004442,
0.0355320014,
-0.0048096986,
-0.0177988876,
-0.061927028,
0.0155048305,
0.0104972161,
0.0285147559,
0.0259742141,
-0.0144530553,
0.0046715853,
0.0126036666,
0.0351367779,
0.004554172,
0.0365882702,
0.0134113217,
0.0408397652,
-0.033006493,
0.0168151148,
0.0296917781,
0.0444723442,
0.0308322459,
-0.0089710737,
0.0008571703,
-0.0391025431,
0.0340567008,
-0.0269878395,
-0.0337052234,
0.0180642661,
-0.0030040292,
0.0214315206,
-0.0199093055,
-0.0135703618,
-0.069421038,
-0.0164246932,
-0.0085269427,
0.0021286414,
0.0306614675,
0.0446836837,
0.0338966213,
0.0359141901,
-0.0340797454,
-0.0203701649,
-0.0163141042,
0.0209274516,
0.04586602,
-0.0110506834,
0.0938546658,
0.0458075665,
-0.0265944526,
-0.0063458327,
-0.0158017743,
-0.0651414096,
-0.0517004915,
0.0339666791,
0.0319572054,
0.0249389317,
0.0043618693,
0.0239339508,
-0.0311446209,
-0.0296614524,
-0.0289486069,
0.0004471787,
0.0150264986,
-0.0012176547,
0.0773191899,
0.0155560207,
-0.0014871848,
-0.0266052615,
0.0461825915,
-0.0038263216,
0.0270915944,
0.0226292927,
-0.0243393611,
-0.0328032859,
-0.0368126146,
-0.0785766244,
-0.0181509182,
-0.0249044392,
0.007587296,
-0.0941395611,
-0.0765960142,
-0.0157876629,
0.0263212714,
0.0087452149,
-0.0285044387,
0.0129294069,
0.0705391467,
0.0207146835,
-0.0375289991,
0.0094460081,
0.0672165751,
-0.043912489,
-0.0228866693,
-0.0490085371,
-6.971145086e-33,
-0.0248027015,
-0.0606119595,
0.0435756519,
-0.0161304586,
0.0207975376,
0.0024422819,
-0.0584483445,
0.0149336904,
-0.0214912817,
0.0547884926,
-0.0316689499,
0.0128662977,
0.0049209548,
0.0148064056,
0.0397401527,
-0.0188591275,
0.0079501402,
-0.0031001135,
-0.0331389941,
0.0134681957,
0.044675041,
-0.0070054345,
0.0278299451,
-0.0404654332,
0.0153871952,
0.0174527727,
0.0219834037,
0.0216529369,
-0.1108314097,
0.0419121571,
-0.041236531,
0.035955295,
0.0197770316,
-0.0390255153,
0.028444875,
0.015030738,
-0.0680820718,
-0.0716967061,
0.0581205562,
-0.0431851037,
-0.0352954008,
-0.0245263223,
0.0090095084,
0.0206584409,
-0.0574308522,
-0.0161568206,
-0.0098420335,
-0.0228643492,
0.0105580483,
0.0466212034,
-0.0292296689,
-0.0106595457,
-0.0053284625,
-0.0097612478,
-0.011726235,
0.0152285434,
-0.0493789874,
0.010853691,
-0.0528785549,
0.0118858963,
0.0353313312,
-0.0079812128,
0.0694318935,
-0.0544501282,
-0.0298711713,
0.046868246,
-0.000151582,
-0.027752623,
-0.0757325366,
-0.0096075786,
-0.0242954865,
0.0386032052,
0.1056272462,
-0.000196381,
0.0161132589,
0.0139894243,
-0.1036138162,
0.0133550344,
-0.0408159345,
0.0650392771,
0.0277830288,
-0.0120440461,
-0.018587159,
-0.029615758,
-0.0564304367,
-0.0116440067,
-0.0440511815,
0.0015625479,
0.0333681665,
-0.0273417346,
-0.0192861184,
0.0018457702,
0.0201539099,
-0.0048544887,
-0.0378208756,
0.0288390331,
0.0165972002,
0.0232893787,
0.0201021656,
0.0248718373,
-0.0684135631,
0.0416823365,
-0.0019712523,
0.0177835394,
0.0223854855,
0.0104608368,
0.0207533017,
-0.0302366894,
-0.0415969007,
0.0038532871,
-0.0671136156,
0.0152673209,
-0.0099588959,
-0.0118997525,
0.0475348346,
0.0100214835,
0.0133543778,
-0.0055085961,
0.007524346,
0.0035785858,
-0.0514781401,
0.0281835273,
-0.0146448659,
0.0021447842,
-0.017445799,
0.0162255429,
-0.030445464,
0.0038149203,
-0.0030668902,
-0.0395198464,
0.0134598343,
0.0219312981,
2.858e-7,
0.0506463125,
0.0559906885,
0.0144705074,
0.0045078001,
0.0383893549,
0.0521247312,
-0.0408212766,
-0.0029420473,
0.0431429334,
-0.024298368,
-0.0007191044,
0.0296091735,
0.047738377,
0.0673649907,
-0.022126805,
-0.0029090664,
-0.0324357003,
-0.0217998493,
-0.0446009226,
-0.0166836847,
0.0540993847,
0.0606395714,
0.0223880745,
-0.0161790214,
0.0001172466,
0.024384303,
0.0232743677,
-0.0164365787,
0.0065842951,
-0.0206876416,
0.0072869775,
-0.0236356948,
0.0302587915,
0.0644643605,
0.001610392,
-0.0236431994,
0.0011190056,
0.0415033661,
-0.0097944466,
-0.0246511027,
-0.0336667709,
-0.0010792168,
0.0250440408,
-0.0864923745,
0.0937155858,
-0.0557602085,
-0.0527895577,
0.0102206748,
0.0079747792,
-0.0122768609,
0.0228919275,
0.0021217917,
-0.0158688817,
-0.0069105998,
-0.0111485235,
0.0029753796,
0.015346501,
-0.0632743388,
-0.0148780495,
0.0493378192,
-0.0226342585,
-0.0622078255,
-0.029234428,
-0.0097834533,
0.0279336497,
-0.0854546055,
-0.0186478198,
2.644672419e-34,
-0.002088214,
0.00385959,
0.0407137759,
0.0018059269,
0.0223385878,
-0.0027375491,
0.011510931,
0.0126383649,
0.0252089892,
-0.1010957807,
-0.0000456902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07509v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07509v1 | A Benchmark to Understand the Role of Knowledge Graphs on Large Language Model's Accuracy for Question Answering on Enterprise SQL Databases | 2023-11-13T17:54:50 | 2023-11-13T17:54:50 | Juan Sequeda, Dean Allemang, Bryon Jacob | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DB | Enterprise applications of Large Language Models (LLMs) hold promise for
question answering on enterprise SQL databases. However, the extent to which
LLMs can accurately respond to enterprise questions in such databases remains
unclear, given the absence of suitable Text-to-SQL benchmarks tailored to
enterprise settings. Additionally, the potential of Knowledge Graphs (KGs) to
enhance LLM-based question answering by providing business context is not well
understood. This study aims to evaluate the accuracy of LLM-powered question
answering systems in the context of enterprise questions and SQL databases,
while also exploring the role of knowledge graphs in improving accuracy. To
achieve this, we introduce a benchmark comprising an enterprise SQL schema in
the insurance domain, a range of enterprise queries encompassing reporting to
metrics, and a contextual layer incorporating an ontology and mappings that
define a knowledge graph. Our primary finding reveals that question answering
using GPT-4, with zero-shot prompts directly on SQL databases, achieves an
accuracy of 16%. Notably, this accuracy increases to 54% when questions are
posed over a Knowledge Graph representation of the enterprise SQL database.
Therefore, investing in Knowledge Graph provides higher accuracy for LLM
powered question answering systems. | [
0.0456575751,
-0.0125405174,
-0.0084767779,
0.0741582066,
-0.0207836702,
0.0067847231,
-0.0158483498,
0.0292612556,
0.0809553638,
-0.0529160127,
-0.0004772547,
0.0006661471,
-0.0517815799,
0.0274048448,
0.0154566169,
0.0129015157,
0.0050482643,
-0.0069882968,
-0.0007270597,
-0.0065504634,
0.0208687484,
0.0413910411,
-0.0015447732,
-0.0120726824,
-0.0055974936,
0.0025224781,
-0.0060265111,
0.0199634843,
-0.0141303055,
-0.0238494761,
-0.0203666911,
0.0116893267,
-0.0091171423,
0.0343262255,
0.0000017528,
-0.0769495368,
-0.0248356257,
0.0258883443,
-0.0690110251,
0.0157369003,
-0.0124027943,
0.0015110008,
0.0455700196,
0.0422198474,
-0.047224313,
0.0045995577,
0.0151871005,
0.0089042634,
0.0174775906,
0.0381813496,
-0.0142399427,
-0.0525884852,
-0.0187102146,
0.0067877756,
0.0256542731,
-0.0960511044,
0.0223428365,
0.0717851818,
0.0363237038,
-0.009805941,
-0.0224098153,
0.0221586544,
-0.006650378,
0.0225023646,
0.0051241256,
0.0129109519,
-0.0180869605,
0.0582053475,
0.0036202148,
0.0587884486,
0.0620149598,
0.0084568411,
-0.0193643905,
-0.0073040961,
-0.007887356,
0.0190354027,
-0.0222305488,
-0.0075572017,
-0.031073004,
-0.0229899697,
-0.0386242531,
-0.045180764,
0.0276654754,
-0.010778022,
-0.0484961458,
0.1046306118,
0.0077874642,
-0.0175815262,
0.0506857969,
-0.0292062424,
-0.023614699,
-0.0352354981,
0.0192692429,
0.0916793868,
-0.0408498421,
0.0496573672,
0.0022139275,
0.0309964996,
0.0449759141,
-0.052018635,
-0.0154924095,
0.031208422,
0.0384177864,
0.0774866194,
0.0011139037,
0.0472033583,
0.0061374372,
-0.0125268484,
-0.0413416252,
-0.0853235275,
-0.078587994,
-0.0285584256,
-0.0439067818,
0.0295461752,
-0.0292352624,
-0.0431771763,
-0.0354458243,
0.0574046895,
0.0281611718,
0.0356283858,
0.0141983544,
0.0306607019,
0.0299970414,
-0.0291666929,
-0.0868761092,
0.0123126423,
-0.0331092924,
0.0040156208,
-0.0101619698,
-0.0578924194,
0.0224214196,
-0.0020124801,
0.0104430448,
-0.0221650228,
0.0292427726,
0.053346321,
0.033566609,
0.0049207709,
-0.0709004104,
-0.0784970447,
-0.011041549,
-0.0050227498,
-0.0418020189,
-0.066893138,
0.0141717764,
0.0524820574,
-0.0423066802,
-0.0133863781,
0.0167129263,
-0.0019353231,
-0.0276781507,
0.0435753874,
-0.0452225953,
0.0255620163,
0.0346371494,
-0.0077481843,
0.0025094463,
0.0629012957,
-0.0002144488,
-0.0110928463,
0.0512070581,
-0.0043277224,
-0.0225974228,
0.0168363508,
0.0232163779,
0.0167889223,
-0.022914391,
0.0886680558,
-0.0226780362,
0.0319894291,
-0.0030452271,
0.0325954445,
-0.0035501788,
0.0065720263,
0.0418293215,
0.0509239212,
0.0113586765,
-0.001190915,
0.0042439778,
0.0159057826,
-0.0036984228,
-0.0349600799,
-0.0206254832,
0.0109660439,
-0.0542046763,
0.0382880196,
0.0176141858,
-0.0396747366,
-0.0373008586,
-0.0080461698,
-0.0026321749,
0.0344596319,
-0.0162017979,
0.0449343324,
0.0195439644,
-0.0217754748,
-0.0279795118,
0.0582210384,
-0.0130033139,
-0.0094697531,
-0.00664176,
-0.0187144708,
-0.0128292963,
0.1118011028,
0.0345066972,
-0.038902007,
-0.0459228568,
0.0371641554,
-0.012573828,
0.0187543612,
0.0294181779,
-0.0202409308,
-0.0153781315,
-0.015340548,
-0.0151137877,
0.0001292459,
-0.0108153978,
-0.0165586155,
0.0300578345,
0.0414647609,
0.0113478247,
-0.0886231214,
-0.0055444073,
-0.0086730309,
-0.0016249963,
-0.0136456704,
-0.0234586187,
0.0062000612,
-0.0084040659,
0.0496870689,
0.0011734318,
0.0510613918,
0.0254948176,
0.0072918143,
-0.0494685732,
-0.0510642193,
0.0011979842,
-0.0083763311,
0.0343879834,
0.009976306,
-0.0022046731,
-0.0162183102,
-0.0290072951,
-0.0557689108,
-0.0132732363,
-0.0284844823,
0.0473713502,
-0.0436708294,
-0.0234908182,
-0.0023677647,
-0.0464557111,
-0.047951594,
0.0312744603,
0.0246313903,
0.0500309765,
-0.0054684472,
-0.0280649476,
0.0475623459,
-0.0577282868,
0.0358033292,
0.0066845077,
0.0343833752,
0.0376684181,
-0.0030109626,
-0.0337339789,
-0.0856459066,
0.0472427495,
-0.1286820918,
0.0282481797,
-0.020806469,
0.057089068,
0.0428445637,
0.0366984457,
-0.0074411961,
-0.0356614031,
-0.0818030611,
0.0148703894,
0.0263753906,
0.0237156153,
0.0353136957,
0.0231720582,
-0.0007447051,
-0.0200612079,
-0.0145700509,
-0.0168082882,
0.0224151965,
-0.0061674556,
-0.0062860567,
0.0001625425,
0.0165105257,
-0.0587815195,
0.0305463877,
0.0090518212,
0.032798592,
-0.0119643426,
-0.0154177956,
0.0045758453,
0.0220704917,
-0.018602008,
-0.037633907,
-0.0297181066,
-0.0125425467,
-0.0355885886,
-0.0191282295,
-0.0281549059,
-0.0121347038,
-0.0355606563,
-0.0080357548,
0.0201180391,
-0.0249695014,
0.0318179131,
-0.0244863741,
-0.0119643994,
0.0214924701,
-0.0010036681,
0.0279494952,
-0.0925369784,
0.0027372788,
0.0149015365,
0.040127445,
0.0021012593,
0.0063988152,
0.0225614365,
0.0022272004,
0.0272437874,
-0.0049918462,
-0.0241416283,
-0.050697051,
0.0900216773,
-0.0102579314,
0.0370957479,
-0.041819416,
-0.0518260933,
-0.0221399982,
-0.0363411121,
0.0375956632,
-0.0382321924,
0.0525636487,
-0.0344371051,
0.0264466535,
0.011891705,
0.0005191207,
-0.0244859103,
0.0197519884,
-0.0673630536,
0.052809611,
0.0374274924,
-0.0073654102,
0.0258559454,
0.0128987357,
0.0064400444,
0.0095758354,
-0.0070005935,
-0.0365401916,
0.0012023948,
0.0250507351,
0.0394043215,
0.0254415236,
0.0361666754,
0.0118674003,
0.0450456142,
0.0507517979,
0.0266002938,
-0.0613662824,
-0.0047572157,
-0.0193849392,
-0.0047462941,
-0.0713992044,
-0.0069398922,
0.0099034552,
0.0010750965,
-0.0464604385,
0.0120819788,
0.1019566953,
0.0319779254,
0.0340719968,
-0.0074077384,
-0.009951273,
-0.011603687,
0.0430110954,
0.0479926579,
-0.1150592566,
-0.0311820433,
-0.028300073,
0.0255692415,
0.0332169272,
-0.044641491,
-0.0080281198,
-0.1055094004,
0.0116627514,
-0.0441635475,
-0.0449937843,
-0.0343285538,
0.0006851414,
-0.0152412998,
-0.0053410563,
0.0050498885,
0.0621387437,
-0.0290456582,
-0.0234130379,
0.0119714616,
-0.0066381288,
-0.0115969274,
0.0382966883,
-0.0318649374,
-0.0093127843,
0.0129156951,
0.0054117013,
-0.0045623831,
-0.0010672386,
-0.0073957103,
-0.0110650379,
0.014010123,
-0.0108864736,
0.0482660048,
0.0005084787,
0.0158716068,
-0.0194200501,
-0.0125461556,
-0.0465680026,
0.0499471277,
0.0472848192,
0.0827093646,
-0.0436192714,
0.0072807986,
0.0155720944,
-0.0234674662,
-0.0258749519,
0.0565453134,
-0.0034149657,
0.0068952949,
-0.0670615062,
-0.0024797393,
-0.0205087326,
-0.0225822926,
-0.0042066225,
0.0494229905,
-0.0124625098,
0.0248283334,
-0.0373623036,
-0.0475694276,
0.0749191344,
0.007398441,
-0.006442029,
0.0466844253,
0.0145031596,
0.0040548407,
-0.0488316417,
-0.0315765887,
-0.0588733181,
0.052114334,
-0.0217637252,
0.0123872142,
0.0058007669,
-0.0350059122,
-0.0317647979,
-0.0402600653,
-0.0367771834,
-0.0177655797,
-0.0247651134,
-0.0317884237,
0.0242006462,
-0.0059154071,
-0.0002725927,
-0.0344207622,
0.0442614146,
0.0203032475,
-0.0558555461,
-0.0206966791,
-0.0214292221,
0.0220692884,
-0.0077966806,
0.0399882421,
-0.1042721719,
-0.0208782665,
-0.0217216499,
0.0353070423,
-0.0272186007,
-0.0570604838,
0.0187821183,
0.0541028343,
-0.0443373583,
0.0495652892,
-0.0152180847,
-0.0138587039,
0.0460137688,
-0.0431980938,
-0.0120029813,
0.0082423408,
-0.0116872313,
0.0098701194,
-0.0247385334,
0.0177105088,
-0.0152237369,
-0.0212652329,
0.0060863961,
-0.0441595949,
-0.0215330012,
0.0357050039,
-0.0254161153,
0.0381339081,
-0.0228471477,
-0.0289190821,
0.0035774887,
0.0506248176,
0.0477736518,
0.0006094723,
0.0493890308,
0.0140569005,
-0.0348159447,
-0.0471528322,
-0.0065550939,
-0.0759200603,
-0.094278276,
0.027565958,
0.0026726471,
0.0431972481,
0.0082785701,
-0.0018212794,
-0.0394999608,
-0.0115282964,
0.0007074561,
-0.0141864894,
0.0634444505,
-0.0239077304,
0.0674328953,
0.0297839921,
-0.0140260123,
0.0115514919,
0.0804921985,
0.0542448424,
0.037769217,
-0.0072107404,
-0.0581524521,
-0.0367052108,
-0.04216161,
0.0594102256,
0.0252300203,
-0.0366615616,
-0.0094264802,
-0.064113982,
-0.042959936,
0.010543705,
0.0102408603,
-0.037369851,
-0.0295049753,
0.0814126283,
0.0624519475,
0.0858089253,
-0.0430696979,
-0.0393603817,
0.042393025,
-0.1146978512,
0.0157927331,
0.0031540776,
-5.62110011e-33,
0.0014215193,
-0.0631345436,
0.0527413264,
0.0045536817,
-0.0028612399,
-0.0190237891,
-0.0041630259,
-0.0096603325,
-0.0572369434,
0.0042566778,
-0.0257773325,
0.0379524976,
0.0089539653,
0.012463185,
0.0028057175,
-0.0405582972,
-0.0099981204,
-0.0025537384,
0.0210949257,
0.0139056938,
0.0485952571,
0.0376903415,
0.0199776515,
-0.0074463002,
0.0311268605,
-0.0291460082,
0.0146349054,
0.0342655256,
-0.0073290011,
0.0542325117,
-0.0093762828,
0.0583848655,
0.0345902555,
-0.0385614857,
0.0179081708,
-0.0143855438,
-0.0501765832,
-0.0397929624,
0.0519017614,
0.0143038891,
-0.030865144,
0.0242568366,
0.0356068909,
-0.0153401801,
0.024642216,
-0.0048379567,
0.0207764395,
-0.0151554011,
-0.0295280647,
-0.0794415623,
-0.0288201962,
0.0047712135,
0.0076805172,
0.0430760607,
-0.0106760897,
-0.0053551304,
-0.0316632204,
0.0182125438,
-0.032987792,
-0.0171992779,
0.020023359,
0.0260419007,
0.0328621641,
0.0512511991,
-0.007591066,
-0.0051424624,
-0.0127589479,
0.0035378947,
0.0110192765,
0.0269124545,
-0.0327967703,
0.0548086613,
0.0223666318,
0.016834531,
-0.027923828,
0.0048762667,
-0.1016031876,
0.0315227956,
-0.0259410497,
0.0023917509,
0.0068436959,
0.003801865,
-0.0459641181,
-0.03818921,
-0.0571928918,
0.0779617429,
-0.0581651367,
-0.0143971546,
0.037244875,
-0.0267794058,
0.0259499494,
0.0152163403,
-0.0024437415,
-0.0442070067,
-0.0325406604,
0.0471879095,
-0.0048704282,
-0.0279615913,
0.0165264178,
0.0404775627,
-0.0645743012,
0.0284260269,
-0.0204208493,
-0.0066380328,
-0.0226002913,
0.0322785564,
-0.0027718535,
-0.0088756448,
-0.0480759852,
0.0110757183,
-0.0400269106,
0.0069154236,
-0.0582359359,
-0.0264655352,
0.0085083079,
0.0260039773,
0.0311537106,
0.0487243496,
0.0254189018,
0.0054140757,
-0.0139076132,
-0.0116662579,
-0.0006375079,
0.0117689902,
-0.0140489945,
0.0273080729,
-0.0013402588,
-0.0070845732,
-0.0032111499,
-0.0160076562,
-0.0130153848,
0.0195163526,
2.418e-7,
0.0899637565,
0.0313191377,
0.0015728964,
0.0864441916,
0.0259953905,
0.0254920591,
0.0284326654,
0.0054265177,
0.0352880135,
-0.0118760504,
0.0324145332,
-0.0001668337,
-0.0026349125,
0.0555647314,
-0.0502677932,
-0.0194199923,
-0.017320076,
-0.0522086322,
-0.0555579923,
0.0251045302,
0.0638371855,
0.0287362449,
-0.0277092569,
-0.0015334322,
0.0080145374,
-0.0652654096,
0.0297072828,
-0.0067736302,
0.0198662486,
0.0153495185,
0.0467616916,
0.0284779593,
0.0036492008,
0.0730708241,
0.0108714262,
0.0044494881,
-0.0073428298,
0.0192627944,
-0.0328851715,
-0.0006426533,
-0.0103554418,
-0.1139796823,
0.0569572411,
-0.0714972094,
0.0855213553,
-0.0308064856,
-0.0123532275,
0.048796583,
-0.0418776087,
-0.0449641608,
-0.0267841592,
-0.0206029881,
-0.0165633839,
-0.0314813331,
0.0188237149,
0.0219395813,
0.0401445143,
-0.0117810909,
0.0212682728,
0.0572428554,
-0.0028374831,
-0.0382231325,
0.0091274315,
0.014745255,
-0.0048208558,
-0.0280661844,
-0.0055725831,
1.874984662e-34,
0.0341234542,
0.0357941911,
0.0301560033,
0.0026152935,
0.0485535897,
0.01669023,
-0.0045373444,
-0.0110386275,
0.0142594827,
-0.1014172658,
-0.0133329583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07497v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07497v2 | Multilingual Nonce Dependency Treebanks: Understanding how Language Models represent and process syntactic structure | 2023-11-13T17:36:58 | 2024-06-12T13:41:16 | David Arps, Laura Kallmeyer, Younes Samih, Hassan Sajjad | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce SPUD (Semantically Perturbed Universal Dependencies), a
framework for creating nonce treebanks for the multilingual Universal
Dependencies (UD) corpora. SPUD data satisfies syntactic argument structure,
provides syntactic annotations, and ensures grammaticality via
language-specific rules. We create nonce data in Arabic, English, French,
German, and Russian, and demonstrate two use cases of SPUD treebanks. First, we
investigate the effect of nonce data on word co-occurrence statistics, as
measured by perplexity scores of autoregressive (ALM) and masked language
models (MLM). We find that ALM scores are significantly more affected by nonce
data than MLM scores. Second, we show how nonce data affects the performance of
syntactic dependency probes. We replicate the findings of M\"uller-Eberstein et
al. (2022) on nonce test data and show that the performance declines on both
MLMs and ALMs wrt. original test data. However, a majority of the performance
is kept, suggesting that the probe indeed learns syntax independently from
semantics. | [
0.0474628992,
0.0558039695,
-0.0429892577,
0.0538661107,
-0.0701755956,
0.0224640463,
0.0109440489,
-0.013802113,
-0.0166018922,
-0.045705691,
-0.0168082397,
-0.0673289672,
0.0080300067,
0.0276024006,
0.0266951919,
-0.0271158572,
0.0623393767,
-0.0099338461,
-0.0319091119,
-0.0014395798,
0.0055104694,
-0.0039156983,
0.0058517829,
0.0101956092,
-0.0803191438,
-0.0493185595,
0.0095759546,
-0.0041878843,
-0.0027312371,
-0.0192081686,
0.001229952,
0.0566374213,
-0.0131883901,
0.0253138002,
0.0000019792,
-0.0558865108,
-0.0144976275,
-0.009136742,
-0.020754993,
0.0027146956,
-0.0040301778,
-0.0494212769,
-0.0130625274,
-0.0050834501,
-0.031141337,
-0.0208004117,
0.0439991541,
-0.002893087,
0.0436412692,
0.063727729,
-0.0221897252,
-0.033995986,
0.0277059134,
-0.0558282882,
0.0040754923,
-0.0022594826,
0.0091571063,
0.0257224962,
-0.0391499214,
-0.0145218708,
-0.0536546037,
0.0299054347,
0.0135598406,
-0.0111600291,
-0.0206584651,
0.0134561686,
-0.0417548753,
-0.0298170764,
0.0437072143,
0.0168526433,
-0.0151466765,
-0.0379145332,
0.0091936868,
0.0199914444,
-0.0328437388,
0.0498208292,
-0.0297881011,
0.0357439741,
-0.0060784859,
0.0345799737,
0.0965728834,
-0.0016513079,
0.005308975,
-0.0423775949,
-0.0211551655,
0.107233949,
0.0097989812,
-0.0356697813,
-0.0084194513,
-0.0003436589,
-0.0279069729,
-0.0526224114,
0.0088252407,
-0.071701549,
0.0096912272,
0.0349189043,
-0.0108980015,
-0.0422998145,
0.0219846033,
-0.0246018898,
0.0413222834,
0.0235353988,
-0.0429035649,
0.047795441,
-0.0488541685,
0.0140375998,
0.0022726774,
-0.0281924196,
-0.0195611343,
-0.0247746408,
-0.0276524108,
-0.0085297599,
0.0085944124,
0.0386294425,
-0.0126629965,
-0.0064926785,
-0.037007343,
-0.0107669979,
0.0005249064,
0.0051020044,
-0.0227621943,
-0.0255250055,
-0.0314474143,
0.0146575645,
-0.0113355992,
0.0081572738,
-0.0290019512,
-0.0248223338,
-0.0591580532,
-0.0719238892,
-0.0304381624,
0.0466339327,
0.0285101216,
-0.0318370201,
-0.0045349193,
0.0296443328,
0.0234507322,
-0.0304791015,
0.0309207384,
-0.015293817,
-0.0323527902,
-0.0250265766,
0.0228580628,
-0.0553022139,
0.0056888852,
0.0370986834,
0.0196882673,
-0.0052736863,
0.0105474461,
0.0387852043,
-0.0199048091,
0.0269426163,
0.0310867671,
-0.0201644301,
-0.0397103615,
-0.0423954204,
0.010688182,
0.0583421104,
0.002268994,
-0.0449740589,
0.0401108265,
-0.0130336825,
-0.0158208422,
0.0092024915,
-0.0156359728,
0.0073447004,
-0.0109066628,
-0.0411468595,
0.0205388907,
-0.0171644986,
0.0271543544,
0.0501782894,
-0.0306773186,
-0.0246348809,
0.0005556609,
0.0363760367,
-0.0050571281,
-0.0016274549,
0.0476202518,
-0.0054272246,
0.0121274488,
0.0629876032,
0.0073854714,
-0.0078438437,
-0.0232545231,
0.0070447042,
-0.0365633294,
0.0279705264,
-0.0040359008,
-0.0352985747,
-0.0153541025,
-0.0566086508,
0.0376072973,
-0.0324468762,
0.0650861934,
0.0089004906,
-0.0089442348,
0.0120810419,
0.031691771,
-0.0563342497,
-0.0219690111,
0.015309494,
0.0022072995,
0.0070895636,
0.0364334174,
-0.0012876499,
-0.0342460349,
0.0057159686,
-0.0327298231,
0.0519463383,
-0.0255545229,
0.0023703773,
0.0489156805,
-0.0247531496,
-0.000935074,
-0.0337744132,
0.0230776686,
0.0363240279,
-0.0427882858,
-0.0248969868,
0.0368061848,
-0.0024397655,
-0.0036143591,
0.0250072554,
-0.0433843061,
0.0498134196,
0.0126721133,
-0.0101701235,
0.0503007658,
0.049875848,
-0.0315183289,
0.0426401086,
0.0277649239,
-0.0972805396,
0.0096864337,
0.0171671808,
-0.0836356953,
-0.0342226289,
0.0191830825,
-0.0455801114,
0.0011608764,
0.0535178334,
0.0240270551,
-0.0642444268,
0.050037656,
-0.0232060999,
0.0925676301,
-0.0402735434,
0.0273210146,
0.006146132,
0.0691797286,
-0.0008542126,
0.0689105466,
0.0055568186,
0.0784444138,
-0.0332993045,
0.0172923692,
0.1017300636,
0.030502893,
-0.0150704887,
-0.0060290177,
0.0279537048,
-0.0381783135,
0.0570640974,
-0.027717527,
-0.0137734246,
-0.0017981146,
-0.0696618706,
-0.0156411827,
-0.0331212506,
0.0508342721,
0.0179768912,
0.0134524964,
-0.0088391127,
-0.0389944166,
-0.0085382052,
0.0011827672,
0.0022058638,
0.0244392026,
0.0183546655,
-0.0352573842,
-0.0068188622,
-0.0377547853,
-0.0310091861,
-0.0222598426,
0.0601687357,
-0.0164151229,
-0.0728779808,
-0.011955481,
0.0410817936,
-0.0329690315,
0.0348170549,
0.0014963548,
-0.0307144523,
0.0328969695,
0.0165105723,
0.0446766354,
0.0323850214,
-0.044986397,
-0.0161160957,
0.0470654592,
-0.0203067437,
-0.0276958607,
-0.0068859449,
0.0284719449,
0.0328734517,
-0.0050702263,
-0.0283403955,
-0.015014274,
0.0968859196,
0.0067388811,
-0.0488913245,
-0.0131295789,
-0.0098750908,
-0.0391766429,
-0.0267855134,
0.0142645733,
-0.0402472317,
-0.032548286,
0.0478331074,
-0.0240565706,
-0.0441300832,
0.0337898135,
-0.0360654444,
-0.0324780792,
-0.0580039583,
0.0241691563,
-0.0521423891,
0.0730648264,
0.077469267,
-0.0048650992,
0.0147948926,
-0.0581758954,
-0.0128757628,
0.0280757658,
0.0428691655,
0.0215119291,
0.005757411,
-0.0402028859,
-0.0016458961,
0.0011309939,
-0.0351217389,
-0.0217109714,
-0.0514970236,
-0.0289133731,
0.0093939556,
0.0173603185,
-0.0045193634,
0.0226369128,
0.0125964312,
0.0398001187,
0.0631466955,
-0.0101209236,
0.0180228408,
-0.0351089463,
0.0243834443,
0.0326203443,
0.0070616161,
-0.017269494,
0.0020314029,
0.0105687119,
0.0187241994,
-0.0232503098,
0.0292405598,
-0.0015906534,
0.0173394028,
0.0231837966,
0.0173139293,
-0.113359727,
-0.0251892898,
-0.0312964357,
-0.014538778,
-0.0130907921,
0.0918680653,
0.0673149452,
-0.0167612005,
0.0327216275,
-0.0531720147,
0.0644440427,
0.0449996591,
0.0032958756,
-0.0928280279,
-0.0184038412,
0.0059124627,
-0.0536310486,
-0.0078710485,
-0.0453837477,
0.0152039099,
-0.0960116014,
-0.0059932568,
-0.0019743571,
-0.0064326762,
0.001710353,
-0.0454342254,
-0.0023675752,
0.0078377565,
-0.0140576269,
-0.0076215933,
0.0012598828,
0.0119282631,
0.0311443545,
-0.0854095742,
-0.0903847888,
-0.0067602876,
-0.0321143903,
0.0092559224,
0.0847315043,
0.0276891813,
-0.0456281304,
-0.0034127531,
0.0427230895,
-0.0466987789,
0.0229105428,
-0.0310337506,
0.0372936577,
0.0225280952,
-0.0358750671,
0.0029347655,
-0.011047001,
-0.044551421,
0.0145151876,
-0.0100581981,
0.0617706813,
-0.0131756645,
0.0226403195,
0.0125828804,
-0.0263195559,
-0.0192327406,
0.0421298407,
0.0301165115,
-0.0362508781,
-0.0179223772,
-0.0386495702,
0.0300504658,
-0.0186283533,
-0.0002867146,
0.0238099396,
-0.0219568089,
-0.061780978,
-0.0781952515,
-0.0542806201,
0.0059965188,
0.0118180458,
-0.0055531333,
0.0703893229,
0.0338619351,
-0.0358413607,
0.0288461968,
-0.0062285592,
0.0159277227,
-0.0136058955,
-0.0274710748,
-0.0160981119,
0.0313795395,
0.0327966064,
-0.0081237564,
-0.009003289,
-0.0187172573,
-0.0405543596,
0.0380418934,
-0.0123301027,
0.0156771298,
0.0202156398,
-0.0050266143,
-0.0350050665,
-0.0426211655,
0.0044813533,
-0.0051613906,
0.0333010703,
0.0212200116,
-0.0519106723,
0.019442562,
0.0403083824,
0.009647782,
0.009114543,
-0.0050056651,
0.0608966686,
-0.0363896415,
0.0062910235,
0.0479329973,
0.0018351448,
0.0342825726,
0.0017226672,
0.0227864627,
-0.0438420922,
0.0360300355,
-0.087462239,
-0.0174745861,
-0.0289088022,
0.0108672976,
0.0192090459,
-0.0114526311,
-0.0222357884,
0.0169627815,
-0.0609904416,
0.0392235294,
0.0069849649,
0.0192274675,
0.0299419556,
0.0131642595,
-0.0160093065,
-0.0085821869,
0.0058136783,
-0.0217112899,
0.0004517364,
0.0250593983,
-0.0348826237,
0.0199183151,
-0.029711945,
-0.0228968598,
0.0146824345,
0.0130718201,
-0.0254090633,
0.0363545381,
0.0407523401,
-0.0127820391,
0.0784017071,
-0.0626718998,
0.1191087812,
-0.0670478269,
0.0188495927,
-0.0042869863,
0.0227167886,
0.0150004355,
-0.0272955112,
-0.005028008,
-0.0033248872,
-0.0311410036,
0.0644851848,
0.1236708835,
0.008838906,
-0.0073776152,
0.0190365072,
-0.0121433344,
-0.0250293277,
0.0075771064,
0.0442212597,
0.0106228171,
-0.0270168204,
0.0276429672,
-0.0593717098,
-0.074296087,
0.0053648981,
-0.0032467591,
0.0015417049,
-0.0297566801,
0.029654853,
0.0830494538,
0.0089083053,
-0.0215138551,
-0.0710624009,
0.0358268768,
0.0111404024,
-0.0191981979,
-0.0048159943,
-6.307901786e-33,
-0.0030287001,
0.0024229675,
-0.0553442016,
0.0339172147,
0.0474827439,
0.0377359837,
-0.0327408575,
0.037290521,
-0.013467594,
0.0102177551,
-0.0357654169,
0.0211699028,
0.0132655082,
0.0112312483,
0.0752067342,
-0.0067420905,
-0.0054305866,
-0.0065641655,
0.0154205523,
-0.0004273461,
0.0435722694,
0.0364192687,
0.0812296048,
-0.0847109556,
0.0507514589,
-0.0077112089,
0.0362562276,
-0.0080874944,
-0.0041889553,
0.0468091592,
-0.0178318415,
0.0358309485,
0.0289862901,
-0.0003054531,
-0.0252847634,
-0.0009323068,
-0.050572712,
-0.0481162854,
0.0397598334,
0.0007877663,
-0.0374758914,
-0.015343383,
0.024093857,
-0.0255551375,
0.0067824982,
0.0633674562,
0.0168154836,
-0.0138730109,
-0.0417089574,
-0.0055257184,
-0.0701350421,
0.0429656319,
-0.0046773995,
0.014592763,
0.0162843205,
0.0798190609,
0.0030860372,
-0.0044990689,
-0.0423934646,
0.0175583139,
-0.03771846,
0.0808971897,
0.0416937359,
-0.0053493325,
0.0031533053,
0.05707293,
0.0135481553,
0.0087053049,
0.0558508225,
0.0158662796,
0.0471916758,
-0.0235062391,
0.0247211065,
0.0346771963,
0.0542444214,
0.0372852869,
-0.0825708136,
-0.0016672171,
0.0563208833,
0.0618737638,
-0.0142395841,
-0.0260638501,
-0.0450943112,
-0.0533975251,
-0.0035320939,
-0.0105785318,
-0.0078988476,
-0.0338783115,
-0.0153911058,
-0.0449053161,
0.0104021272,
0.0205863919,
0.0184121616,
0.0125133349,
-0.0546400473,
0.0027198517,
0.0071325679,
0.046726916,
0.015844319,
0.0630607381,
-0.0594799593,
-0.0266141016,
-0.0293522961,
-0.0043901228,
0.0576463751,
0.0064109229,
0.0294751916,
0.0299613997,
-0.0555312447,
-0.0262348596,
-0.0223903283,
-0.0192132127,
-0.0360596739,
-0.0178672466,
0.031580206,
0.0028786475,
-0.0002299704,
0.0172916725,
0.0639099777,
-0.0080021126,
-0.045455914,
-0.0105636325,
-0.0286298394,
0.0240035951,
0.0111374818,
-0.022113502,
-0.0356062911,
0.0308335517,
0.0668784752,
-0.0422443748,
-0.0031652367,
0.02671225,
2.813e-7,
0.0404720381,
0.0321808755,
0.0065268604,
-0.0233338028,
0.0523894988,
0.0249292143,
-0.0545942783,
0.0244008377,
-0.005337955,
-0.0280595515,
-0.0397193283,
-0.0534245744,
0.0370228998,
0.0221010987,
-0.0961248353,
0.0124362083,
-0.0176328439,
-0.0214031599,
-0.0416939147,
0.0237524901,
0.0097668041,
0.0841676816,
-0.023198707,
0.0012943215,
-0.0454599299,
-0.0106383897,
0.0462305509,
-0.0076682311,
-0.0681966841,
-0.007127577,
0.0370165147,
-0.0109549593,
0.0292481724,
0.0554767475,
-0.0323245339,
0.052460216,
0.038648352,
-0.0086770998,
0.0100775687,
0.0021886639,
0.0230966769,
-0.0128379604,
-0.0328674465,
-0.0471889935,
0.0857933685,
0.0029064796,
-0.0417788438,
0.0318400301,
-0.0376048051,
0.0795509815,
0.0229070075,
0.0179935154,
-0.066569075,
0.0095450347,
0.0529342555,
-0.0277941748,
-0.0276271291,
0.0104336208,
-0.0313111357,
0.0480613932,
-0.0244638454,
-0.0257671457,
0.0006193765,
-0.0106217936,
0.0015568672,
-0.0012249567,
-0.0088077066,
3.008323995e-34,
0.028354764,
-0.0051572602,
0.0648258403,
0.0098627526,
0.0401647873,
-0.0411063135,
-0.0611421056,
0.0637521148,
-0.0228877738,
-0.0642812774,
-0.0239715073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07491v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07491v1 | A Step Closer to Comprehensive Answers: Constrained Multi-Stage Question Decomposition with Large Language Models | 2023-11-13T17:28:03 | 2023-11-13T17:28:03 | Hejing Cao, Zhenwei An, Jiazhan Feng, Kun Xu, Liwei Chen, Dongyan Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models exhibit remarkable performance in the Question
Answering task, they are susceptible to hallucinations. Challenges arise when
these models grapple with understanding multi-hop relations in complex
questions or lack the necessary knowledge for a comprehensive response. To
address this issue, we introduce the "Decompose-and-Query" framework (D&Q).
This framework guides the model to think and utilize external knowledge similar
to ReAct, while also restricting its thinking to reliable information,
effectively mitigating the risk of hallucinations. Experiments confirm the
effectiveness of D&Q: On our ChitChatQA dataset, D&Q does not lose to ChatGPT
in 67% of cases; on the HotPotQA question-only setting, D&Q achieved an F1
score of 59.6%. Our code is available at
https://github.com/alkaidpku/DQ-ToolQA. | [
0.0027559728,
0.0636808425,
-0.0227794852,
0.0253669415,
-0.0329224169,
0.023928564,
-0.0203785598,
-0.0001567784,
0.0515199676,
-0.033268813,
-0.0290604252,
-0.0263721552,
-0.0218570698,
0.0213475544,
0.012551358,
-0.0261009876,
0.0617771111,
-0.0127180032,
-0.0473664738,
0.0129783256,
0.0072428482,
0.0254299082,
-0.0042099492,
0.0535616986,
0.0070018554,
-0.0560478196,
-0.0241332371,
-0.0095753269,
-0.0067974012,
0.0118838018,
0.0083286976,
0.0725029856,
-0.001759485,
0.0447056256,
0.0000020255,
-0.0241663214,
0.0077103842,
-0.0089630727,
-0.0175255109,
-0.012080322,
-0.0118426206,
0.0158453211,
0.0368798859,
0.0285595339,
-0.0459037386,
-0.0303502809,
0.0267691556,
0.0542275533,
0.089286834,
0.0545508713,
0.0103117414,
-0.0417723395,
0.012425771,
0.0184977166,
0.0174747985,
-0.037099719,
0.0234023128,
0.0054463428,
0.0204768721,
-0.0067949588,
-0.0309915636,
0.0277168434,
0.0629457757,
0.0176889785,
-0.0283848643,
0.020621635,
-0.0681312606,
-0.0048706112,
0.0039821705,
0.0916369855,
-0.0132548111,
-0.0208733212,
0.003473805,
0.0340273269,
0.0336967558,
0.0249691289,
-0.0756645128,
-0.0003887997,
-0.0218081102,
-0.0169588905,
0.0079035433,
-0.020007804,
0.0235667694,
0.0008293467,
-0.0307622384,
0.0641011149,
0.0274351761,
-0.0198336281,
0.0009700086,
0.0045253783,
-0.0348535217,
-0.031386435,
0.0207143743,
0.0584938414,
-0.0547758229,
0.0287499316,
-0.0070087179,
0.0009354029,
0.0327653587,
-0.0620179214,
-0.0427748784,
0.033332184,
-0.0138343684,
0.0513207465,
0.0183251575,
0.0310898665,
-0.0348818228,
0.0012798929,
-0.0642720312,
-0.0504003055,
-0.0361106098,
-0.0549430922,
-0.0540008172,
0.0516636036,
-0.0457774512,
-0.0252683666,
-0.0193717871,
0.0310720354,
0.0057193409,
-0.0373326726,
0.0045591746,
0.0314582698,
-0.0085865231,
0.0026485305,
-0.0169287641,
0.0633443445,
-0.0575439446,
-0.0003051106,
0.0375723578,
-0.0395252183,
-0.0342036858,
0.0071911169,
-0.0068161315,
-0.035053622,
-0.0248417538,
0.039988365,
0.0013606733,
-0.0195798203,
0.0189891383,
-0.0421199538,
-0.0083752749,
-0.0398115441,
0.0009604201,
-0.0541071035,
0.0607064255,
-0.0059138113,
-0.0175943989,
-0.0022099351,
-0.003404483,
0.0412617065,
-0.0133913327,
0.0591659844,
0.031474214,
-0.0064049023,
0.0058427462,
0.0668909624,
0.0085983248,
0.095701322,
-0.0272275321,
-0.0054746652,
0.0295263939,
-0.0108010974,
0.0361540169,
0.0418874733,
0.0109296124,
0.0152170984,
-0.0128235342,
0.0465701483,
0.0144760702,
0.0013205892,
-0.0126964003,
0.0489659421,
-0.022233421,
-0.0248398408,
0.0268986616,
0.0316248462,
-0.0108505394,
0.0524531603,
-0.0025865643,
0.0299065281,
0.0126770036,
0.0562731475,
-0.0424070656,
0.0312636271,
-0.0405328088,
-0.014416771,
0.0209800303,
0.04382753,
-0.0490251668,
-0.0347925723,
0.0131714987,
0.0084935455,
-0.0015418353,
0.0385618694,
-0.0060054725,
0.0038136437,
-0.0245427284,
0.0422040783,
0.0213059448,
-0.0108359857,
0.0261287745,
-0.0535125695,
0.004452392,
0.0361598991,
0.073375687,
-0.0484248362,
-0.0341798142,
0.0132880984,
0.0108460998,
0.0274796877,
0.0270701163,
-0.0287185051,
0.0317691043,
-0.0170571674,
-0.0087743402,
-0.0040573524,
0.0098311547,
-0.0474483669,
-0.0021640009,
0.0022429507,
-0.0150714293,
-0.0014117759,
0.0489904284,
0.0210471023,
-0.0051770238,
-0.0254521649,
-0.0000933159,
-0.011655407,
0.0138873244,
0.0092405332,
0.027354328,
0.0245250408,
0.0300875176,
-0.0460097454,
-0.0283949338,
0.0006144334,
-0.0341233946,
-0.0941042751,
0.0438931994,
0.0046733473,
-0.0244771875,
0.0561372712,
-0.0427571014,
-0.0198587831,
0.008965685,
-0.0371232592,
0.0227252189,
-0.0477527604,
-0.0258269925,
0.0134411519,
0.0193821769,
-0.0442947559,
0.0751204491,
-0.0242544524,
0.0062667201,
-0.0104451654,
-0.033233054,
-0.0072593889,
0.0211455952,
0.0014957817,
-0.0009587719,
0.0061584553,
0.0259683523,
0.0009723317,
-0.004802159,
-0.0851133615,
-0.0160089117,
-0.0589924455,
0.0203123093,
-0.0315047912,
0.0130984439,
0.0454288684,
0.0323169716,
-0.002811518,
-0.0046833144,
-0.0764487684,
-0.0064282976,
0.0394527577,
0.0341363959,
0.0299786646,
0.0014519304,
-0.0050721988,
-0.0014229437,
-0.0220458899,
-0.0315059237,
0.0657601058,
-0.0405006371,
-0.0401386581,
-0.020912338,
-0.0031036893,
-0.0431346633,
0.00672107,
0.0010813172,
-0.0240273383,
0.0127560897,
-0.0222619604,
0.0575864129,
0.0204787757,
-0.0005735885,
-0.0140091125,
0.0447263718,
-0.0150605273,
-0.0332899541,
0.0338252224,
-0.0541822277,
0.0123015372,
-0.0202783104,
-0.0119918268,
0.0239994098,
0.0782521218,
0.0069442689,
-0.0243871696,
-0.0585630983,
0.043506965,
-0.0291970596,
-0.0188170932,
-0.0612704903,
-0.0140491091,
-0.0115729058,
0.0167197455,
-0.0288944636,
-0.0126256533,
0.0955035537,
-0.0013789608,
-0.0101190256,
-0.0580894537,
0.0136504509,
-0.0536205061,
0.0833177939,
-0.0263515282,
0.0041675372,
-0.009282846,
-0.0167639107,
-0.0753181055,
-0.0313800722,
-0.0320874825,
-0.0394469239,
0.0166616365,
-0.0075196628,
-0.0081865201,
-0.0007718828,
-0.0334848985,
-0.0425914451,
-0.0348306224,
-0.0019130794,
0.0121690044,
-0.0221809484,
0.017033577,
-0.0154956542,
0.012619378,
0.0238809809,
0.0121115856,
-0.0336893685,
-0.0051285652,
-0.0063878046,
0.0844654962,
0.0999810398,
0.0253566001,
0.051595062,
-0.0313581638,
0.0944696665,
0.0805276409,
0.0635455698,
-0.005368595,
0.0479538143,
-0.0196646862,
0.0152171822,
-0.0116684623,
-0.0031764761,
-0.0074901832,
0.0594825037,
-0.0627448559,
-0.0444321223,
0.102620177,
0.0438178778,
-0.0592991151,
0.0075723431,
-0.0354578122,
0.0459270701,
0.0087864324,
0.0412926078,
-0.0856473148,
-0.0403622873,
-0.0166442692,
0.0032968391,
0.0202359613,
-0.0305709448,
0.0126239099,
-0.0779123232,
0.0214015357,
-0.0135263121,
-0.0673356205,
-0.0344055966,
-0.0441232361,
0.0037255236,
0.0317916609,
0.0388881192,
0.0289955921,
0.0131259495,
-0.0182272103,
0.0065011731,
-0.0125282342,
0.0396537296,
0.0307376776,
-0.0290919747,
0.0029831259,
0.0378923304,
0.0232332461,
0.0243424363,
-0.0123484666,
0.0313333012,
-0.0796664506,
-0.0259437244,
-0.0138531188,
0.0020917698,
0.0122304158,
0.0052984203,
-0.0505198836,
0.0452195629,
-0.0590144731,
0.0107562421,
0.0191791225,
0.1251976788,
-0.0416778624,
-0.0499406122,
-0.036589615,
-0.0022959844,
-0.0247542132,
0.0741616413,
0.072722517,
-0.0306000803,
-0.0603101104,
-0.0044621867,
-0.0049854745,
-0.0527725443,
-0.0475533865,
0.0442116857,
0.0405559577,
0.0132934041,
-0.0698600411,
-0.0669916272,
0.0452522151,
0.0316885225,
-0.0503169522,
0.045389805,
-0.0165725611,
0.0321098566,
-0.0056028338,
0.0508227125,
-0.0264525972,
-0.0277092811,
0.0006208837,
0.0071794782,
0.0264172647,
-0.0067509175,
-0.021432912,
0.0143244304,
-0.0763923675,
-0.0243981536,
0.0107636601,
0.0219812077,
0.0200856961,
-0.0008558101,
-0.0508466847,
-0.0314580575,
-0.0117074084,
0.0306984279,
-0.040367838,
-0.006689223,
-0.0063082534,
-0.0106108515,
-0.0043537649,
0.0574184135,
-0.0403118581,
0.0111168325,
-0.0112528028,
0.0791367292,
-0.0293212105,
-0.0365753435,
0.050482545,
0.012861196,
-0.0263560992,
0.0112805143,
0.0314113796,
-0.0135291703,
-0.0072890921,
-0.0152731966,
-0.013870663,
-0.0349147618,
0.0151167531,
0.0323667526,
-0.039311789,
0.0054812576,
-0.0371671021,
-0.0095087206,
0.0245002788,
-0.0323691517,
-0.0166623071,
0.039625667,
-0.0129555836,
0.0456394069,
-0.0224902276,
-0.0218927953,
-0.0053887847,
-0.0014184808,
0.0351929776,
-0.0098754382,
0.0546608828,
0.0260159839,
-0.0273579992,
-0.0375364088,
0.0175703689,
-0.0637415946,
-0.0753331408,
-0.0004948379,
0.0197592732,
0.0072487481,
0.0328688622,
0.0107139861,
0.0064977682,
-0.0236692503,
-0.0030327549,
-0.0014112812,
0.031981837,
-0.0035780414,
0.0304611791,
0.0350574739,
-0.0320155621,
-0.0131359873,
0.0785817131,
-0.0119616222,
0.0409829989,
0.0229165349,
0.003135677,
-0.0228739921,
-0.0586089455,
-0.066305697,
0.0278343614,
-0.0288488138,
0.0232127961,
-0.0736646205,
-0.0627836511,
-0.0550782233,
-0.0193046369,
-0.0102370093,
-0.0033427472,
0.0299196243,
0.050304886,
0.0209595244,
-0.0458223894,
-0.0006484972,
0.0453181788,
-0.0156370085,
-0.0517270416,
0.0391767807,
-6.320532473e-33,
0.0135961138,
-0.0211768672,
0.0461746976,
-0.0638139844,
-0.0293812901,
-0.0049250019,
-0.0381647758,
0.0057085268,
-0.0357552394,
-0.0246895365,
-0.0265624039,
0.0277504958,
-0.0116704609,
0.0416876785,
-0.0008036025,
-0.0525365919,
0.0095221093,
-0.0189516544,
-0.0222846046,
0.0558814816,
0.0409182161,
0.0199849848,
0.033087343,
0.0440884344,
-0.014517081,
-0.0435607135,
0.0083710253,
0.0819032416,
-0.0237461664,
0.050218299,
-0.0553299151,
0.02104312,
0.0421162359,
-0.026462134,
0.0109968642,
0.0541459545,
-0.0921172202,
-0.0463354774,
0.0125032151,
-0.0100630084,
-0.0513471849,
-0.0175810866,
0.03745538,
0.0101297926,
0.076113455,
-0.0236491635,
-0.0027591065,
-0.0178370401,
-0.0134944245,
-0.0324954577,
-0.0184695255,
0.0151762292,
-0.0264714547,
-0.0270661712,
-0.0349730104,
0.1076432467,
-0.006226995,
0.0326272622,
-0.009634099,
-0.0144209918,
-0.0107518127,
0.0318772011,
0.0366760306,
0.0079094227,
0.0206844993,
0.0646201596,
0.0326354727,
0.0162612945,
-0.0476008728,
-0.015183229,
0.0106919967,
0.0233146884,
0.0589095987,
0.0105411131,
0.0236282218,
0.0036033413,
-0.1060886756,
0.0292132311,
0.02589182,
0.000883024,
0.018556118,
-0.0214820765,
-0.0078944154,
-0.0238007661,
-0.0147509808,
0.0672583207,
-0.0341116935,
-0.0048351791,
0.0318820253,
-0.0022417426,
-0.0321384147,
-0.0139689231,
0.0608763918,
-0.0416562669,
0.0342886113,
0.0271576084,
-0.0079713399,
0.0120232459,
0.0286646485,
0.0527137034,
-0.0102020903,
0.0253464337,
0.0003917056,
-0.0208844393,
-0.0013704875,
0.0246711317,
-0.0102849249,
-0.0214010589,
-0.0446967594,
-0.0039140172,
-0.0523626246,
0.0486267395,
-0.0229405463,
0.0237727519,
0.0374898203,
0.0410288982,
-0.0029132983,
0.005669225,
0.035162691,
0.0189031642,
-0.0221299436,
0.0459137,
-0.0232268199,
0.0124215866,
0.0101000164,
-0.0252139457,
-0.0387884714,
0.0085617295,
0.0019883879,
-0.0944631025,
-0.0139313024,
0.0241435301,
2.648e-7,
0.0517962426,
0.0346009806,
0.0089826602,
0.0162744988,
0.017092986,
0.0139917601,
0.0163019132,
0.0048589734,
0.0121533591,
-0.0101038432,
-0.0027182493,
0.0333647393,
0.0437283926,
0.0661423281,
-0.1084325016,
-0.031159969,
-0.0731539354,
-0.0291410256,
-0.0715230107,
-0.0209828969,
0.0170052554,
0.0997069404,
0.002364944,
-0.0293144323,
-0.0216021892,
-0.0267922487,
0.0269963965,
0.0222515874,
-0.0465861112,
0.0312795527,
0.0086712828,
-0.010614397,
0.0324325785,
0.0142821213,
0.0062565976,
-0.0010883589,
0.0192138366,
0.0474556237,
0.0199209936,
-0.0747573897,
0.0084201368,
-0.0411454029,
0.0225874428,
-0.0715361536,
0.0870858058,
-0.0503419377,
-0.0221622065,
0.0036835286,
-0.0449759103,
-0.0249215867,
0.0220203921,
-0.0143452901,
0.0060219141,
0.0330668762,
-0.0153336283,
-0.018310219,
0.044494465,
-0.0674910769,
-0.0205167085,
0.0076467842,
-0.0394257717,
-0.0526169054,
-0.0186642557,
-0.0332910009,
0.0119346678,
-0.044414144,
0.017870117,
2.593366912e-34,
0.0230940599,
0.0005170483,
0.0296842642,
0.0571371093,
0.0238526687,
-0.0312475506,
0.0222097971,
-0.0107381605,
0.0248742104,
-0.1083179861,
-0.0047321459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07484v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07484v3 | Psychometric Predictive Power of Large Language Models | 2023-11-13T17:19:14 | 2024-04-15T12:12:24 | Tatsuki Kuribayashi, Yohei Oseki, Timothy Baldwin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Instruction tuning aligns the response of large language models (LLMs) with
human preferences. Despite such efforts in human--LLM alignment, we find that
instruction tuning does not always make LLMs human-like from a cognitive
modeling perspective. More specifically, next-word probabilities estimated by
instruction-tuned LLMs are often worse at simulating human reading behavior
than those estimated by base LLMs. In addition, we explore prompting
methodologies for simulating human reading behavior with LLMs. Our results show
that prompts reflecting a particular linguistic hypothesis improve psychometric
predictive power, but are still inferior to small base models. These findings
highlight that recent advancements in LLMs, i.e., instruction tuning and
prompting, do not offer better estimates than direct probability measurements
from base LLMs in cognitive modeling. In other words, pure next-word
probability remains a strong predictor for human reading behavior, even in the
age of LLMs. | [
0.0465478152,
0.0325376056,
-0.0341825001,
0.0062659974,
-0.0486408882,
0.0245202202,
0.0389644839,
0.0087232757,
0.030123692,
-0.0176328924,
-0.0465973541,
-0.0514010601,
0.0334500261,
0.0095904255,
0.0408061072,
-0.0469314307,
0.0424867906,
-0.0581886359,
0.0053647449,
-0.0052479375,
-0.0112951985,
0.0221485943,
-0.0126306321,
0.0312666297,
0.0481526889,
-0.012306097,
0.0162199531,
-0.0034822309,
0.0087409895,
-0.041616749,
0.0024467113,
0.0592393465,
0.0239826888,
0.0007370063,
0.0000020255,
-0.0479795597,
0.0257928837,
-0.0205926914,
-0.0082156118,
0.0492679775,
0.0536563508,
0.0119310571,
0.0152231082,
0.0062195053,
-0.0116370516,
0.0374106057,
0.0115754157,
0.0349691473,
-0.0302374288,
0.0190085508,
0.0102485623,
0.0103183305,
0.0453619063,
-0.0028217593,
0.0400960408,
-0.0014309206,
0.0096470425,
-0.0026299087,
0.0273355786,
0.056284342,
-0.0141476383,
0.009546808,
-0.0034526221,
0.0266748834,
-0.0073255505,
0.043507345,
0.0359739214,
-0.0099666957,
-0.0256789438,
0.023459686,
0.0320856459,
-0.0327350497,
-0.0144039262,
-0.025266476,
-0.0116659459,
0.0718292519,
-0.0274423882,
-0.0002476166,
-0.0088574057,
0.0008616957,
0.057201799,
0.0108425869,
0.0269465409,
0.0198256262,
0.0221571457,
0.0826896504,
0.0269661713,
-0.0604202971,
0.033157438,
0.040454492,
-0.0039069024,
-0.0332069024,
0.0130276578,
-0.020670034,
-0.036955148,
0.0316058472,
-0.0347500332,
0.006135677,
0.0246992391,
-0.0182186551,
0.0828068405,
0.0732112899,
-0.0082475627,
0.0062630293,
0.0211225599,
0.062156152,
0.0198442806,
0.0083549814,
-0.039999038,
0.0711406618,
-0.0244049635,
-0.0162367877,
0.0079192799,
-0.0217367075,
-0.0292814765,
-0.0623774603,
-0.0749618486,
0.029426679,
0.0579177216,
-0.0497311763,
-0.0047477772,
-0.0093194637,
-0.0312547088,
0.0016511119,
-0.0460857823,
0.0169696473,
-0.0408994406,
0.0319190994,
-0.003444524,
-0.0441308618,
0.0227961,
0.000110739,
-0.0330292434,
-0.047714144,
-0.0008386078,
0.042828355,
-0.0279159304,
-0.0318911895,
-0.016010778,
-0.0237523988,
-0.0120908311,
-0.0322245322,
-0.0140093537,
-0.0562170818,
0.0056128222,
0.0562482402,
-0.008891644,
-0.0318311341,
-0.0135720298,
0.0243435334,
-0.0291882455,
0.0323234871,
0.0367269851,
0.0266951974,
0.0260190461,
0.0090294536,
-0.0200691484,
0.0582751594,
0.0254149269,
-0.0047300863,
0.0223103501,
-0.0085424045,
-0.0195047092,
0.0605920516,
-0.0390912667,
0.0259966254,
-0.027942298,
-0.033127781,
0.0248787925,
0.01699364,
0.0625201687,
0.041750297,
-0.035826616,
-0.0087331133,
0.1048481911,
0.0742256567,
0.0135136191,
-0.002042691,
0.043505162,
0.043121919,
0.0338849016,
0.05000294,
-0.0365290008,
-0.0011557866,
-0.0430870019,
0.0287774056,
0.0372216366,
0.0187796578,
0.0063547972,
-0.0329206176,
0.01107735,
0.0287873559,
0.0016694417,
0.0036398165,
0.036926318,
-0.058218915,
-0.0319670662,
0.0101123722,
0.0561816171,
-0.0191734936,
-0.0104870647,
-0.0427983962,
0.0314094052,
0.0983110443,
0.0379445329,
0.0065149437,
0.029635787,
0.0275961496,
0.0019233586,
0.062871404,
0.0403387882,
0.0098809358,
0.017267419,
-0.0403689854,
0.0048772306,
0.0400281399,
-0.0061998833,
0.0190744419,
0.0174671561,
0.0060704239,
0.0109860962,
-0.0185622703,
-0.0549703278,
0.0390164517,
-0.09926828,
-0.0209063422,
-0.0502333157,
-0.01283665,
0.0134457266,
-0.0085946387,
0.0055185524,
0.0231765956,
-0.0054874523,
0.0209917761,
0.0483278073,
-0.0008112083,
-0.0558711141,
0.0033925867,
0.0181172267,
0.0274773967,
0.0212937444,
0.0015726173,
0.0422082283,
-0.0015867894,
-0.0070490334,
-0.0347154066,
0.0585351996,
-0.0099773519,
0.0387282968,
-0.0142308827,
-0.010295528,
-0.0448398069,
0.040984422,
-0.0203396697,
0.0450651608,
0.0446529202,
-0.0063614501,
-0.0288265776,
-0.0387071036,
-0.0201545097,
-0.0122770304,
0.0144797638,
0.0042586802,
0.0377474986,
-0.0055311462,
-0.0640812665,
-0.0241129827,
-0.0823233575,
-0.023238359,
0.0158378407,
0.0167088527,
0.0084965043,
-0.0098922886,
-0.0578423403,
0.0256231744,
-0.0091566443,
-0.0280314628,
-0.0200351868,
0.0505175442,
-0.0003173592,
-0.0042141941,
-0.0176613163,
-0.0642614365,
-0.0275438037,
-0.0414580069,
0.0143925482,
0.0130024198,
0.0113737108,
-0.0710472241,
0.0415235311,
-0.010054281,
-0.0024597528,
-0.0327657461,
-0.0218529515,
0.0338710956,
-0.0023957007,
0.0802499726,
0.1078308672,
0.0182466824,
0.0212997794,
0.0399318449,
-0.0205401145,
-0.0799259543,
-0.0136051532,
-0.0267278105,
-0.0364969335,
-0.0216548406,
-0.1002471149,
0.0094884317,
0.0430249721,
0.021359263,
0.014097292,
-0.0435210504,
0.0337313339,
-0.0399762653,
-0.070964314,
-0.0302463379,
-0.0016262158,
-0.0473202504,
0.0649473816,
-0.0176962316,
-0.082081154,
0.0684613436,
-0.0189472511,
0.034289781,
-0.047894787,
0.0230433811,
0.0040152706,
0.0302236006,
0.0151257413,
-0.0004105161,
-0.0078807473,
-0.0045781122,
-0.0731228516,
-0.0051190094,
0.0146500804,
-0.0106958663,
0.0306601878,
-0.0735635981,
-0.0154112475,
0.0342891999,
-0.0027033861,
-0.0314697921,
-0.042723354,
-0.0346241444,
-0.0431197472,
0.0230386648,
-0.0178818218,
-0.0572474636,
-0.0150257098,
0.0402538776,
0.0175211839,
-0.0394034795,
-0.0209623929,
0.0128107201,
-0.0193797126,
0.0670480728,
-0.024644861,
0.00867608,
-0.0963958427,
0.0214596149,
0.0148455203,
-0.0057682316,
0.0030644434,
0.0014634229,
0.0148754353,
0.0444814488,
-0.0181216765,
-0.0414706022,
0.0735363066,
0.0510023646,
-0.0295517948,
0.01043058,
0.1361755282,
0.0362140499,
-0.0517055504,
0.0054373373,
-0.0316945203,
0.0571397655,
-0.0214167777,
0.0203779712,
-0.0240339674,
-0.0272633322,
0.0008199553,
0.0347967297,
-0.0400464386,
-0.0305025242,
-0.0067983223,
-0.0932819322,
-0.0083904834,
0.0186879933,
0.0038968339,
-0.0010565073,
-0.0432543866,
0.0336072594,
0.0156120146,
0.0116796475,
0.0098525994,
-0.0303239804,
0.019509431,
-0.0081132716,
-0.0242757592,
-0.0307933502,
0.0254838262,
-0.0156963412,
0.031734623,
0.0488536693,
0.015405098,
-0.0056485198,
-0.0507626496,
0.0018650009,
0.0044010635,
0.0304726847,
0.0131096011,
0.0335847884,
-0.0113377823,
0.0489852279,
-0.0731699169,
0.0155278826,
-0.0071962569,
-0.0260169618,
0.0119677316,
0.0290131308,
0.0131851966,
-0.0276061911,
-0.0253467914,
0.0345241204,
0.0241586678,
0.0769970268,
-0.0007681948,
-0.0845880434,
-0.0045535574,
-0.0288828667,
0.0067997845,
0.0003138998,
-0.0522085428,
-0.0130739221,
-0.0118093938,
-0.0180027764,
-0.0644683316,
-0.0674390271,
0.0108802691,
0.0025766555,
0.0321645215,
0.0400423259,
0.0188626666,
-0.0371741727,
-0.0091885244,
0.0270291045,
-0.017601056,
0.0284824278,
-0.0924289972,
-0.0231810603,
0.0283988751,
-0.0368304178,
-0.0157559998,
0.0115019754,
-0.0712779611,
-0.0830971673,
-0.0017001977,
0.0203573387,
0.0313748568,
0.0103087053,
0.0370711461,
-0.051882904,
0.0038885267,
0.0035009668,
-0.0342409909,
0.0456413217,
-0.0198655315,
0.0314488895,
-0.0003987454,
0.0040617124,
0.0125765968,
0.0192628745,
0.0252137557,
0.0345801041,
-0.0153732598,
-0.0948309079,
-0.0096459594,
0.0112119839,
0.0464584231,
-0.0323038436,
-0.0034602073,
-0.0517652407,
-0.0424764566,
-0.0367267132,
0.0115192011,
0.0141125685,
-0.0306523144,
0.0359395333,
0.0065125693,
-0.0438711941,
-0.0297130812,
-0.029597288,
0.011912032,
-0.0662500933,
0.0238910727,
-0.0158983786,
0.021621231,
0.0382320248,
-0.0041444139,
-0.020093957,
0.0004357095,
-0.033077579,
0.0689967871,
0.0439889617,
0.0997536108,
0.0048224102,
-0.0269831549,
0.0137238074,
-0.0026514963,
-0.0460973531,
-0.0299078971,
0.0083405701,
0.0093854032,
-0.0291418638,
-0.0414486788,
0.0273465235,
-0.0403474718,
0.0187056698,
-0.0474107526,
0.0107678035,
0.020342432,
-0.0004443005,
0.0277536251,
0.0142683359,
-0.004262086,
-0.0059474539,
0.0779614151,
0.030422803,
-0.0170425735,
0.0188410692,
-0.0487682894,
-0.0283259433,
-0.0077385916,
0.0158912409,
0.0490600318,
-0.0242989063,
0.0249518622,
-0.086533092,
-0.0502827354,
0.017768668,
0.0162460785,
0.0109038111,
-0.0498228781,
0.0133532062,
0.0611628033,
-0.0632334873,
-0.0246988498,
-0.0450021587,
0.0248241853,
-0.0352021046,
-0.0338263139,
-0.0581582785,
-6.244852677e-33,
-0.02682372,
-0.0036498751,
0.0232724939,
-0.0089057498,
-0.0234362185,
-0.0360155068,
-0.024499096,
0.0353880003,
0.0041335928,
-0.0076829414,
-0.031360168,
-0.0151208732,
0.0220977738,
-0.0199401211,
0.0367822051,
0.0025798148,
0.0251882225,
0.0027073422,
-0.063545242,
-0.0213082451,
0.0161389727,
-0.007450019,
0.0299582798,
-0.0295204204,
0.0610791035,
-0.0266114846,
0.0271876547,
-0.0233830176,
0.0309748724,
0.0403937213,
-0.0407741033,
0.0563340224,
0.0225299764,
-0.0105132274,
-0.0189624317,
0.0621524155,
-0.0194261651,
-0.0472360626,
0.083550103,
0.0026326613,
-0.0111757172,
-0.0302051064,
0.0060850144,
-0.0063762851,
-0.0748588443,
-0.0075876429,
0.0380658396,
-0.0279329494,
-0.0309875235,
0.0230923668,
-0.062241789,
0.0149618555,
0.001805569,
-0.0076626502,
-0.0117808394,
0.0666161701,
-0.0189453214,
0.0090440856,
-0.0437390432,
0.0572198071,
0.043067418,
0.0315380692,
0.0501797535,
0.0463065654,
0.0219520759,
0.0604296736,
0.0335998237,
0.0111334575,
-0.0174917802,
0.0079683429,
0.072469376,
-0.0079634693,
-0.007118525,
0.0086497823,
0.0220878851,
-0.0268941354,
-0.0076755849,
0.031495709,
0.0502941757,
-0.0132310791,
0.0846519768,
-0.0013711115,
-0.0944373086,
-0.0746580213,
-0.0227824636,
-0.0050243456,
-0.0161303729,
-0.0393577367,
0.0519134291,
-0.0368612297,
-0.0078592664,
-0.0480397195,
0.0414085612,
-0.0100646988,
-0.0373211242,
0.0094261672,
-0.0360380299,
0.0414257012,
-0.0203652997,
0.0224134326,
-0.0851566792,
-0.0086829076,
-0.0069273976,
0.0302107465,
0.0108752865,
0.011472662,
-0.0245344546,
-0.014719964,
-0.0621498786,
-0.0180099327,
-0.0209772196,
-0.0154749807,
0.0541247278,
0.0069111567,
0.0704097822,
-0.0139595382,
-0.0086039687,
0.0165413059,
-0.0169293229,
-0.049997326,
-0.0406476557,
-0.0142510049,
-0.0356910452,
-0.0026899439,
-0.0131490445,
0.0001733239,
-0.0403431989,
0.0097020296,
0.0020178133,
-0.0364772268,
-0.0237479433,
0.0269913599,
2.74e-7,
0.0127392728,
0.0792489424,
-0.035932146,
0.0418640785,
-0.0067984536,
0.0223492309,
0.011233733,
-0.0107740918,
0.0935810208,
-0.0312214904,
0.0068480242,
0.0236241017,
0.035777919,
-0.0216919761,
-0.0783712417,
-0.0232198276,
-0.0384725071,
0.0685815066,
-0.0482425839,
-0.0014000296,
0.0513671674,
0.0183308572,
-0.0023458835,
0.0057421676,
-0.0251501407,
-0.0170899387,
0.0495492704,
-0.0627446994,
-0.0389611386,
0.0111868083,
0.0160703938,
0.0142602539,
0.0163918342,
0.0567827597,
-0.0084339045,
0.0110522509,
0.015845336,
0.0455661416,
0.00182802,
0.0141093899,
0.0002888281,
-0.002739978,
-0.0133939972,
-0.0496275835,
0.0475562774,
0.0048807189,
-0.0117120184,
0.0133917965,
-0.0263880361,
-0.0252103899,
0.011091332,
-0.043297369,
-0.0238068569,
0.0215842947,
0.0202398226,
-0.0220052898,
0.0117004653,
-0.0191390291,
-0.0339321494,
0.0105611514,
-0.0255008154,
-0.0850117728,
-0.0651782528,
0.0154089388,
-0.0049302885,
-0.0642729178,
0.0114996461,
2.500913593e-34,
0.0411249548,
0.0162003841,
0.0422665849,
-0.0301686395,
0.0374750271,
0.0050721471,
0.0313695483,
0.0440525673,
0.0558637939,
-0.1231618226,
-0.0176380202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07470v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07470v2 | Finding and Editing Multi-Modal Neurons in Pre-Trained Transformers | 2023-11-13T17:03:02 | 2024-06-11T12:30:02 | Haowen Pan, Yixin Cao, Xiaozhi Wang, Xun Yang, Meng Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding the internal mechanisms by which multi-modal large language
models (LLMs) interpret different modalities and integrate cross-modal
representations is becoming increasingly critical for continuous improvements
in both academia and industry. In this paper, we propose a novel method to
identify key neurons for interpretability -- how multi-modal LLMs bridge visual
and textual concepts for captioning. Our method improves conventional works
upon efficiency and applied range by removing needs of costly gradient
computation. Based on those identified neurons, we further design a multi-modal
knowledge editing method, beneficial to mitigate sensitive words or
hallucination. For rationale of our design, we provide theoretical assumption.
For empirical evaluation, we have conducted extensive quantitative and
qualitative experiments. The results not only validate the effectiveness of our
methods, but also offer insightful findings that highlight three key properties
of multi-modal neurons: sensitivity, specificity and causal-effect, to shed
light for future research. | [
0.0354609154,
0.0715854391,
-0.0225818343,
0.0371381529,
-0.0025383015,
0.0038662108,
0.0293130651,
-0.0169439316,
-0.0260677468,
-0.0883115232,
-0.0940984413,
-0.0234714858,
0.0094147706,
0.0369583778,
0.0335078984,
-0.0290160477,
0.0723837316,
-0.0211870782,
-0.0331442021,
0.0214226767,
0.0085301977,
-0.0004594434,
-0.0179435331,
0.0638420656,
0.0004461585,
-0.0250828192,
-0.0117258364,
-0.0170027018,
-0.0078787887,
-0.0019148858,
-0.0131999133,
0.084986113,
0.0604902096,
0.0444227308,
0.000002086,
-0.0216960441,
-0.0302642677,
0.0038333323,
0.0251968503,
0.0245282687,
0.0655489415,
-0.0361198001,
0.0008425625,
-0.0266310778,
-0.0077211396,
-0.0378062911,
0.0728369579,
0.0822002292,
0.0742498711,
0.050125353,
-0.0214042794,
-0.0435705706,
0.016375199,
-0.0124803474,
0.0179018602,
-0.0301037878,
0.0313606896,
0.0293749105,
-0.037067391,
-0.0066603231,
-0.0578235798,
0.0453156121,
0.006195459,
-0.0368337631,
-0.0189508703,
0.0198342428,
0.0169898793,
-0.0434139296,
-0.020526588,
0.0874985531,
0.0193784498,
-0.0014455817,
-0.0268319584,
0.0066714669,
0.0071967291,
0.0158865321,
-0.0316062458,
0.0043022363,
0.0323233344,
0.0125203375,
-0.0286638588,
-0.0334458165,
0.0237804633,
0.0358595699,
-0.0263303444,
0.003108182,
0.0314211026,
0.0277181249,
-0.0238321014,
0.0208570883,
-0.040831022,
-0.039884869,
0.0333356448,
0.0202482566,
-0.0144511564,
0.0240037143,
-0.0429206714,
-0.0368330628,
-0.0003282885,
-0.0243066773,
0.046156805,
0.017319968,
-0.0603774525,
0.04802683,
-0.0244805515,
0.0006952901,
-0.0563691072,
0.0953717604,
-0.0055628316,
0.0100820158,
-0.0536710434,
-0.0394645296,
-0.0214359611,
-0.0016482455,
-0.0449948981,
-0.0406189002,
-0.0235603452,
0.0164982285,
-0.0123508833,
-0.028176073,
-0.0104134092,
0.025306141,
-0.0360144265,
-0.0203571506,
-0.0222378839,
0.0710443258,
-0.000532424,
0.042253565,
-0.0229106713,
-0.0311776828,
-0.0081553031,
0.0242935419,
0.0233946107,
-0.022636231,
0.0043272125,
0.0829747766,
-0.0428270251,
-0.0417108051,
-0.0336581431,
-0.0616161823,
-0.0399097763,
-0.0207322482,
0.0368567705,
-0.0110136904,
0.0071262345,
-0.003887088,
0.0040009487,
-0.0345818251,
0.0037862251,
0.0014681616,
-0.0178855415,
0.1104564667,
-0.0100848675,
-0.0017647733,
0.0102475574,
0.0201347843,
-0.0290369391,
0.0551632643,
0.0319882333,
0.0222963747,
0.0287532713,
-0.0175451804,
0.0294074547,
0.0287025385,
0.0207705088,
-0.0269090682,
-0.0118555678,
-0.0560387783,
-0.0010594589,
0.0169886686,
0.040140301,
0.0009365187,
-0.029582819,
0.0212406162,
0.1016090512,
0.006666474,
0.0307076294,
0.0551530533,
0.0064277425,
-0.0050209728,
0.002098189,
-0.0096856579,
-0.0602590516,
0.0543010607,
-0.014099271,
-0.0101850023,
-0.0197833721,
0.0223051459,
-0.004686146,
-0.0269638486,
0.0191625115,
0.0145805413,
-0.0015893047,
-0.0188113265,
0.0549409874,
0.0357353874,
-0.0668461472,
0.0707790107,
0.0236399155,
-0.0213277638,
0.0305652246,
-0.059614379,
-0.0184683967,
0.0023793099,
0.0290529095,
-0.0470644124,
-0.0221575703,
-0.0334889628,
0.0290800985,
0.0469027422,
0.0225850232,
0.0040545184,
0.0136497654,
-0.049501393,
-0.0261565279,
-0.0411963463,
0.0327601954,
0.0282298457,
-0.035334345,
-0.0209484324,
-0.0075559309,
-0.035075482,
-0.0049752807,
0.0460557751,
0.0407646447,
-0.0109617785,
-0.0404895656,
0.0079999575,
-0.0123303793,
-0.0109913666,
-0.0324950479,
0.014291835,
-0.0141204605,
-0.019175943,
-0.0142912287,
0.0541868433,
-0.0622943528,
-0.0170209873,
0.0159735233,
-0.0328032151,
-0.0311060026,
0.0105438996,
-0.016473975,
-0.026055593,
0.0193217583,
-0.0447756313,
0.0448532142,
-0.0650637671,
0.0004417209,
-0.0109651256,
0.0324463062,
-0.0078866426,
0.0396309495,
0.0154549563,
-0.0243170448,
0.0503483079,
-0.0052804905,
0.0017148997,
0.0188321099,
-0.0669717863,
0.0376958512,
-0.0041917986,
0.0129081784,
-0.0247609597,
-0.0091994964,
-0.0471319519,
-0.0248520337,
-0.0986949876,
-0.0193608943,
-0.0098806834,
-0.0060979538,
0.0503444821,
-0.0170528851,
0.0083551044,
-0.0129117751,
0.0102138389,
0.0215830281,
-0.0035705692,
0.0211557522,
0.0309353229,
0.0225070156,
-0.0162328817,
-0.0284425076,
0.0040617995,
-0.0281969272,
0.1031583026,
0.028485233,
-0.0148948682,
-0.0401813611,
0.0345700756,
0.0015978725,
0.0056105899,
-0.0012784746,
-0.0651115626,
-0.0054346938,
0.006475382,
0.0359954946,
0.0373407416,
0.0096066017,
0.037173152,
0.0650653839,
-0.0528493151,
-0.0206723996,
0.0024913205,
-0.0012929209,
-0.0545552038,
-0.0359208733,
0.0060434733,
-0.0231916774,
0.0923081487,
0.0135241086,
-0.0090764333,
-0.0414859541,
0.0170238651,
-0.0243607964,
-0.0612466373,
-0.037698891,
0.0223642457,
-0.0269982386,
0.0350075364,
-0.029070925,
-0.0397237279,
0.0541057475,
-0.0192007683,
-0.0277221724,
-0.0129858181,
0.0349347256,
-0.0121879121,
0.0875863358,
-0.0042449632,
0.0227797292,
-0.0000046427,
-0.0473178849,
-0.0648957863,
0.0108225336,
0.0159469843,
-0.0124119148,
0.072920762,
-0.0484786741,
-0.0211807173,
-0.0186954904,
0.0082757054,
-0.006553649,
-0.0593968965,
-0.0229034424,
-0.0185647234,
0.0232728068,
0.0076944069,
-0.0446259156,
0.0133597376,
0.0447173603,
0.0422547087,
-0.0315684713,
-0.0081675891,
-0.0387301929,
0.0338995159,
0.0230289623,
0.0636135563,
0.0184715502,
-0.0271708295,
0.002563983,
0.0346553028,
-0.020984469,
-0.00959507,
-0.0370408408,
0.0264418628,
0.0031827907,
-0.0204999465,
-0.0077867052,
-0.009428978,
0.076281026,
-0.0693809763,
0.0060845702,
0.0866444185,
0.0004148725,
-0.0981219187,
-0.004029491,
0.0085247718,
-0.0127537958,
0.0209420864,
0.0109820105,
-0.0573532246,
-0.0618843921,
-0.0133223198,
-0.0199219771,
0.020518247,
-0.0058570788,
-0.0193117149,
-0.0711227059,
0.0266252682,
-0.0138275251,
-0.0544357076,
-0.0330599695,
0.0006361783,
0.0033191927,
0.0101129403,
0.0175416432,
-0.0032189405,
-0.0057380549,
-0.0243979041,
-0.0003569633,
0.0488678515,
-0.041712705,
0.0106680002,
-0.0325973369,
0.033286348,
0.057919398,
0.0311769415,
-0.0306717809,
-0.0305986833,
0.0216932967,
-0.0111449081,
0.0092587247,
0.0145690739,
0.0510248318,
-0.0131010832,
-0.0297331009,
-0.0074908594,
0.0254125316,
-0.0124014672,
-0.0605209246,
-0.0383540355,
0.0552220717,
-0.0052717337,
0.0047541778,
0.0047670123,
0.0310119539,
-0.0104221171,
0.0632954314,
0.0473107696,
-0.0518133603,
0.0029295967,
-0.011610006,
0.0059128702,
-0.0393963046,
-0.0628191307,
0.0119116111,
0.0062708473,
-0.0307101533,
-0.0391751416,
-0.0215422027,
0.0187847074,
0.0167364962,
0.0349990167,
-0.0145162912,
-0.003979166,
0.0082870424,
-0.0210160725,
0.0658153445,
-0.0353668369,
0.0090803616,
-0.0535566173,
-0.0051658656,
0.0759321824,
-0.0481517874,
-0.0441156179,
-0.0018144849,
-0.0632926896,
-0.0454042405,
0.0103390645,
0.0391184539,
0.0127895325,
0.0209568031,
0.0261733327,
-0.070344232,
0.0426771007,
0.0356897078,
-0.0105459588,
0.0415267609,
0.0373980738,
0.0014898999,
-0.0288736317,
0.0214043576,
-0.0168582462,
0.0141918231,
0.0299634188,
0.0258105174,
0.0283946563,
-0.0113467844,
0.0152317928,
-0.002170525,
0.0512627847,
0.0009927429,
0.0318186097,
-0.0763743669,
0.0014912444,
-0.0009540518,
-0.0079573002,
-0.0480023809,
0.0031269223,
0.0258788932,
-0.0132333431,
-0.0301106405,
0.0324686505,
0.0154193472,
0.0073712426,
-0.0002587688,
0.0311814845,
0.0390202887,
-0.0242193155,
-0.0205091853,
0.0243154019,
-0.0196998026,
0.0269788578,
-0.0193573479,
0.0135936821,
-0.0193339828,
0.09291327,
0.0175924823,
-0.054981228,
-0.0516811609,
0.0685901567,
-0.0468383692,
-0.027247889,
-0.0283425692,
0.0495336987,
0.0458922237,
0.0111415591,
0.0491871014,
-0.0149601195,
-0.0277274903,
0.011603605,
0.0542973876,
0.0076081082,
-0.0003724152,
0.0625943318,
0.0007643364,
0.0166392401,
-0.0181187857,
0.06039083,
-0.0451631621,
0.0740050301,
-0.0151623432,
-0.0225017387,
-0.0215879418,
-0.0297762994,
0.0165650677,
-0.0152715286,
-0.037997961,
-0.0103324912,
-0.0295835026,
-0.0525331832,
0.0267625283,
0.0007745118,
-0.0104499543,
0.009871169,
0.0117878849,
0.052737195,
0.0230853744,
-0.0240955073,
-0.0232810974,
-0.0070768255,
0.0190894734,
0.0455308631,
-0.0137873907,
-6.253707088e-33,
-0.0511028692,
-0.0299720019,
0.0109506221,
-0.0350295976,
-0.0199695081,
0.0275576506,
-0.0451323241,
0.0235838965,
0.0076284865,
0.0181774572,
0.0148440767,
0.00563059,
0.0123096993,
0.0235820878,
0.0012014537,
-0.029396316,
0.0516831242,
0.0087285889,
-0.0064635398,
0.0111671118,
0.0205287281,
0.0151288854,
0.0828680918,
-0.0447618999,
0.0366639979,
0.0358812399,
-0.0411380343,
0.0152078848,
-0.01373058,
0.0765886903,
-0.0374185443,
0.011536222,
0.0291466024,
-0.0385308713,
-0.0336663797,
0.0249413867,
-0.0366586596,
0.00442323,
0.026428001,
0.0587185547,
-0.0374121517,
-0.0395180248,
0.0429487079,
-0.0302562267,
0.0116359098,
-0.0203005038,
0.0469813459,
-0.013582482,
0.0176264979,
0.0096522672,
-0.087652348,
-0.0107912961,
0.0102092549,
-0.0410211347,
0.0164972581,
0.0164835118,
0.0150828883,
0.0397334173,
-0.0531354845,
0.0201778244,
-0.0073667425,
0.0150383459,
0.0755947232,
0.0419590995,
0.0093025314,
0.0634961277,
0.0300214887,
-0.0040000794,
-0.0457922406,
-0.0330945626,
0.054574389,
0.0401213057,
0.0178518519,
0.1013342962,
0.0289041866,
0.0091649685,
-0.0304131173,
-0.0162776802,
-0.0767365023,
0.0326657668,
0.0441103466,
0.0172981229,
0.057092648,
0.0212836806,
-0.0708293244,
-0.0120352255,
-0.046099361,
-0.0098614264,
0.0273034833,
0.0048009194,
-0.0455834232,
0.0238824282,
0.0743755847,
-0.0502902567,
0.0088255936,
0.0171355046,
-0.015197698,
0.0671154484,
-0.0139549244,
-0.0129524162,
-0.0187897962,
-0.0181361604,
0.0463515781,
-0.0356692895,
0.0287680868,
-0.0115492512,
0.0191575512,
0.0199608635,
-0.0296724923,
0.0001103325,
-0.028841475,
-0.0326566286,
0.0063017244,
0.035875544,
0.0350010358,
-0.0017799954,
-0.0641127527,
0.0090015512,
0.0427252203,
0.0476721935,
-0.0134600401,
-0.0103365183,
-0.0006157726,
0.0482293293,
-0.0275477357,
-0.0027098998,
-0.0372291021,
-0.0499963909,
0.0251237638,
-0.0812001154,
-0.0246160142,
0.0236803666,
2.851e-7,
0.0609867461,
0.0442075133,
0.0102726677,
0.0015005853,
0.0313353054,
0.0536581203,
0.0010249775,
0.0211139247,
0.0053746267,
-0.0512788333,
0.015955992,
0.0165178627,
0.0247127898,
0.0119093908,
-0.0315954275,
-0.0429134034,
-0.0171766579,
0.0433105975,
-0.042686075,
-0.0280033108,
0.0809362009,
0.0806516036,
-0.0386006609,
-0.023587402,
0.0185001493,
-0.0683783218,
0.0984197706,
-0.0493451618,
-0.0033231382,
0.022410728,
0.0136950314,
0.0179718994,
-0.0292992163,
0.0244846158,
-0.0095520634,
-0.0057930611,
0.0196957123,
0.044495143,
-0.0072437851,
-0.0262205228,
-0.0358258933,
0.0314932913,
-0.0144445961,
-0.024553081,
0.0521791987,
-0.109251745,
-0.0484148525,
-0.0463318229,
0.0188933853,
-0.0427461229,
0.0293050483,
-0.0467536598,
-0.0173699725,
0.0245083924,
-0.002461781,
0.0124184657,
-0.0538413338,
-0.076517418,
-0.0145619269,
-0.0027225004,
-0.0455386974,
-0.0316638686,
-0.0551057458,
-0.0785262957,
0.0623944849,
-0.0827063397,
-0.0151749812,
2.427554021e-34,
0.0110971825,
-0.0318537168,
0.0162201822,
0.022005314,
0.0501104072,
0.0214623511,
0.0309902895,
-0.0349231809,
-0.0265958626,
-0.1020787209,
-0.0212017279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07469v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07469v2 | InCA: Rethinking In-Car Conversational System Assessment Leveraging Large Language Models | 2023-11-13T17:02:06 | 2023-11-15T22:10:34 | Ken E. Friedl, Abbas Goher Khan, Soumya Ranjan Sahoo, Md Rashad Al Hasan Rony, Jana Germies, Christian Süß | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The assessment of advanced generative large language models (LLMs) poses a
significant challenge, given their heightened complexity in recent
developments. Furthermore, evaluating the performance of LLM-based applications
in various industries, as indicated by Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), is a
complex undertaking. This task necessitates a profound understanding of
industry use cases and the anticipated system behavior. Within the context of
the automotive industry, existing evaluation metrics prove inadequate for
assessing in-car conversational question answering (ConvQA) systems. The unique
demands of these systems, where answers may relate to driver or car safety and
are confined within the car domain, highlight the limitations of current
metrics. To address these challenges, this paper introduces a set of KPIs
tailored for evaluating the performance of in-car ConvQA systems, along with
datasets specifically designed for these KPIs. A preliminary and comprehensive
empirical evaluation substantiates the efficacy of our proposed approach.
Furthermore, we investigate the impact of employing varied personas in prompts
and found that it enhances the model's capacity to simulate diverse viewpoints
in assessments, mirroring how individuals with different backgrounds perceive a
topic. | [
0.0356275178,
0.003898313,
-0.0187610947,
0.0365463272,
-0.0162424184,
0.019982079,
0.0547292493,
-0.0136423595,
0.0042821616,
-0.0673489347,
-0.0335304849,
-0.0404765531,
-0.0122168818,
0.0128468778,
0.0288288295,
-0.0226170011,
-0.010289955,
-0.0740031898,
0.00379817,
-0.0185739081,
0.0037222451,
0.0273675416,
-0.0272192042,
0.0550213829,
-0.0117620397,
-0.0401995294,
0.0183557961,
-0.0035299936,
0.0553201102,
-0.026424218,
0.0036661001,
0.0483939573,
0.0260035563,
0.0273966566,
0.0000018109,
-0.0452795513,
0.0590899251,
0.0062850602,
-0.0383097008,
0.0210669897,
0.0251628458,
0.090700008,
-0.0166096035,
0.0664217398,
-0.0369433314,
-0.016426973,
-0.0154210273,
0.0005613216,
0.0373150446,
0.0387686379,
-0.0133113889,
-0.0210701153,
-0.0230184253,
0.0140507249,
-0.010776679,
-0.0513506196,
0.0228278283,
0.0452836417,
0.0037198083,
-0.0214837044,
0.0041960636,
0.0310306568,
0.0461674072,
-0.018873468,
0.0205024295,
0.0214498155,
-0.0162090473,
-0.0004131989,
-0.0190425031,
0.0774247944,
0.032351125,
-0.0274150558,
-0.0286467951,
0.0097072711,
0.0059842863,
-0.0228883922,
-0.0540731885,
-0.0104953907,
0.0027966802,
-0.0263533127,
-0.0421694219,
0.0374175385,
0.0118115572,
-0.0028054714,
-0.0170519892,
0.0563714355,
0.0392752178,
-0.0431988612,
0.0313827358,
-0.0053306534,
-0.0181656964,
-0.044168856,
-0.0201279595,
0.0406085104,
-0.0568864942,
0.0083197933,
0.0397276096,
0.0102297366,
0.0168341231,
-0.0692706406,
0.0304086581,
-0.0048520351,
-0.0094214594,
0.0483209454,
0.0187257957,
0.0552821718,
0.0444408059,
-0.0327173397,
-0.0363435224,
-0.0270543247,
-0.0187758468,
-0.0202895831,
-0.0337626152,
-0.0172324833,
-0.0367188267,
-0.0177073199,
-0.0256928802,
0.0429601856,
0.0111429058,
0.0016365731,
-0.0181935094,
0.047669366,
0.0227744617,
0.0097299581,
-0.011374007,
0.0053706723,
-0.043910265,
0.0413289107,
0.0293835178,
-0.087115325,
0.0457349718,
0.025040755,
-0.0113040963,
-0.0165444706,
0.0169601161,
0.0535538793,
-0.0121019734,
-0.0230203997,
-0.0236611106,
-0.015989257,
-0.0387089923,
-0.0737733245,
-0.0391900167,
-0.0732348412,
0.0215647891,
0.0344161429,
-0.0256544594,
0.0000658773,
-0.0050652465,
0.0176098142,
0.0168017335,
0.0294215381,
0.0305619594,
0.0436837561,
0.0655084103,
0.0393194743,
0.0137581211,
0.0797028244,
0.0597131662,
-0.0026488709,
0.0726067871,
-0.0347263329,
0.0188308228,
0.0467750803,
-0.0400766246,
0.0191101581,
0.0118289404,
0.0322286673,
-0.0176781379,
0.0275936592,
-0.006014782,
0.0445181765,
-0.0133297564,
0.010286551,
0.0766957402,
0.0765880942,
0.0093789538,
0.0144088231,
0.026900908,
0.0312244277,
0.0091178128,
-0.0419154167,
0.0106824823,
-0.0016888536,
-0.0422193483,
0.008610677,
0.0385408923,
0.0589605942,
-0.0434368141,
-0.0216553435,
0.0010068696,
0.0060713165,
0.0054615051,
0.0240524784,
0.0277898517,
-0.0376160704,
-0.021727778,
-0.0040357728,
-0.0217109509,
-0.0297624189,
0.0184558798,
-0.0402437821,
0.0200519226,
0.0777131245,
0.0406533033,
0.0204274543,
-0.0068972064,
-0.0189577714,
-0.0120563516,
0.0053927801,
0.0172933489,
-0.0266958531,
0.0133052627,
-0.036897894,
-0.0254045781,
0.0371235535,
-0.0163153242,
-0.019424336,
0.0149382604,
0.0488944724,
0.0555510782,
-0.0289726555,
0.0066555487,
0.0005340449,
-0.041580148,
-0.0172847994,
-0.0233556014,
0.0158986077,
-0.0030290456,
0.039411474,
-0.0321489722,
0.0114528183,
0.0342773534,
-0.0105545036,
0.0008430804,
0.0289610028,
-0.0503728166,
0.037733838,
0.0261806175,
-0.0424944647,
0.0069966749,
0.045701202,
0.0078994352,
-0.0387000255,
-0.0394428819,
-0.0541424043,
0.0111687705,
-0.0590337478,
0.0011993841,
0.0232871789,
0.0126205031,
-0.02392493,
0.0193006564,
0.0275410991,
0.0460197665,
0.0335531235,
0.0043965094,
0.0315058157,
-0.0665871575,
-0.0337983929,
0.0003923012,
-0.019424038,
0.0087001733,
0.0103351912,
-0.0234171506,
-0.0701291412,
0.006617561,
-0.1106921434,
-0.0098043848,
-0.0317161493,
-0.0001022249,
0.0284434184,
0.0278992262,
-0.0348950773,
-0.0038832307,
-0.0306875501,
-0.0129040293,
0.0770471171,
0.0112863155,
-0.0084106866,
0.0176658891,
-0.0377541669,
-0.0010586894,
0.0009537687,
-0.0118033439,
0.0544902161,
0.0197537988,
0.0302309021,
-0.0650209635,
0.0031686772,
-0.012644832,
0.0166994464,
0.0049503762,
-0.0492478535,
0.010244241,
0.0499519408,
0.0463691764,
0.0734042674,
0.0634130239,
-0.0289350078,
-0.0337893628,
-0.0264820904,
-0.0504377671,
-0.0051753405,
-0.0113916593,
-0.0588344112,
-0.040909797,
-0.0482207462,
-0.0125368219,
0.0103762094,
-0.0112528699,
0.0255406573,
-0.0210801456,
0.0185252912,
-0.0433042496,
-0.0798785836,
-0.065208137,
0.012308564,
-0.0180019494,
0.0563604534,
0.0134409396,
-0.0079740388,
0.0236386564,
-0.0483463928,
-0.0067739715,
-0.0223654527,
-0.010243197,
-0.0215557534,
0.0555451252,
-0.0420839265,
0.0086904652,
0.0030576754,
0.0034550517,
-0.0179462507,
0.0072417138,
-0.0468311571,
-0.0317832194,
0.0324385129,
-0.0408626981,
0.0003983682,
0.0090922443,
-0.0612812899,
-0.0430628806,
-0.0355753042,
-0.0393993668,
0.0191363916,
0.0274747778,
-0.0139584932,
-0.0118957721,
0.0578877069,
0.0181654841,
0.027612295,
-0.0062016533,
0.013620751,
-0.0093320366,
0.0072415755,
0.0960837752,
0.0691468269,
0.049805969,
-0.0199586507,
0.0815150663,
0.0205875132,
0.0631649345,
-0.0131088225,
-0.03109443,
-0.0329834297,
0.0420196652,
-0.0082029095,
0.0004941901,
0.042807065,
0.0215084292,
-0.0269995816,
-0.0123394867,
0.0960645601,
0.0052951248,
-0.0159757715,
0.014447541,
-0.0301407278,
0.0383576825,
-0.0012313484,
0.0309396628,
-0.0786172226,
-0.0163592268,
0.0004097646,
0.0338043161,
-0.0209432635,
-0.0022351702,
0.0248473473,
-0.1195249483,
0.0519973375,
-0.0317332409,
-0.0534962565,
-0.0086421575,
-0.0313060284,
-0.009063947,
-0.0037302868,
0.0726550296,
0.0344735458,
-0.0279745404,
-0.0296805967,
0.0207771659,
-0.0338851064,
-0.067661792,
0.0638573989,
-0.0160164628,
0.0473222919,
0.0652079284,
-0.008494067,
-0.0184435397,
-0.0585672446,
0.0047484497,
-0.0320909396,
-0.007509138,
0.0020214457,
0.0047289981,
-0.0363258347,
0.0048838006,
-0.0423738137,
0.0167677961,
-0.023897754,
0.0008804564,
0.0219328273,
0.0507050902,
-0.0243286397,
0.0042336448,
-0.0146412719,
0.0331789032,
0.0199877005,
0.0960871726,
0.0162317082,
-0.0726264268,
-0.0036621368,
0.0164503772,
-0.0096747549,
-0.0200579036,
-0.0335684679,
-0.0174032189,
0.0348259695,
-0.0121949948,
-0.0149891358,
-0.0592132136,
0.026589321,
-0.0056231897,
-0.0035902392,
0.0315581784,
0.0030167899,
0.0393876657,
-0.0220702384,
0.0087524056,
-0.0145696132,
0.0550350957,
-0.049373772,
0.0215540696,
0.0346609652,
-0.0224834047,
-0.0588358231,
0.0274806954,
-0.0445369035,
-0.0314845331,
0.0252785608,
0.019600926,
0.0277104359,
-0.0119175818,
-0.0268093366,
-0.0999114364,
0.0478475615,
-0.0137188816,
-0.0429821946,
0.0474041589,
-0.014519765,
0.0311708078,
-0.0018685207,
0.0338225439,
-0.073563017,
0.0062047769,
-0.0006870095,
0.0060051996,
-0.0098204222,
-0.070951663,
-0.0226502568,
0.017148301,
0.0016715076,
-0.0025179971,
0.0045227595,
-0.0019656748,
0.0724121705,
0.0021780855,
0.0089519722,
-0.0415381342,
-0.0019209967,
-0.0203011278,
0.0124290036,
0.0069044959,
-0.0045051435,
-0.0121481214,
0.0129352016,
-0.0426541232,
0.0279386155,
0.0502884276,
-0.0307073649,
0.0036621066,
-0.0468863845,
-0.0332559906,
-0.0214947928,
0.0110593112,
0.0374789126,
0.0159131773,
0.107046172,
0.0106364815,
-0.0284596439,
0.0131327016,
0.0599507019,
-0.0348567553,
-0.0692924336,
-0.025501471,
0.0757152066,
0.035025727,
0.0214684587,
0.0276231319,
-0.0107478127,
0.0115645789,
-0.0483351573,
-0.0020575235,
0.0189373568,
-0.0169525407,
0.0620177239,
0.0101526864,
-0.0286785178,
0.0000195735,
0.0604856722,
0.0148171689,
0.0145849539,
-0.0214406177,
0.0055045048,
-0.0414009988,
-0.0409553312,
0.0092590395,
-0.0089657512,
-0.0233924016,
-0.0162847694,
-0.0759774446,
-0.0625744835,
-0.0206600074,
0.0387368202,
-0.0066753086,
-0.0092215575,
0.0411895886,
0.0445207842,
0.0138545139,
-0.0668914765,
-0.00468258,
-0.0038022154,
-0.0641115457,
-0.003745178,
-0.0198297184,
-6.288907267e-33,
-0.028486602,
0.0119802626,
0.0256355684,
-0.0142244371,
-0.03225201,
-0.0265485719,
0.0089307018,
0.0150292655,
-0.0074165417,
-0.0103190262,
-0.0292827487,
-0.0123388898,
0.0211442821,
0.0179790519,
-0.0175132882,
-0.0340366624,
0.018152589,
0.0036555415,
-0.0326834023,
0.0424527116,
0.0218092371,
0.0160587896,
0.0271221418,
-0.0575865097,
0.0280532632,
-0.0588321313,
0.0029410738,
0.0320921429,
-0.0091519561,
0.0739041641,
-0.0142365415,
0.0582218766,
0.0407706909,
-0.0688738525,
0.0256563984,
0.0993296355,
-0.0329191014,
0.0151027953,
0.0741453841,
0.0312519111,
-0.009875196,
-0.022035338,
0.0139218653,
0.0031066986,
-0.0529191867,
0.0175135788,
0.044311434,
-0.0227933638,
0.0198488608,
-0.0137318755,
-0.0564952493,
-0.006125092,
-0.0112890424,
-0.0298131444,
-0.0166942757,
0.0855320394,
-0.0305804741,
0.0020855407,
-0.0248702355,
-0.0117664821,
0.0257160086,
0.0294269044,
0.095887132,
0.0439604111,
0.0048331963,
0.0324351713,
-0.0042308439,
-0.0307828523,
-0.0595093891,
-0.0810770243,
-0.0031547421,
0.0226450376,
0.0273192115,
0.0447749533,
-0.0376919024,
-0.0076142969,
-0.0834116489,
0.0252187364,
0.0142823579,
0.0227218382,
0.0725742802,
-0.0414523371,
-0.0656734407,
-0.0102854623,
-0.0692903772,
0.048670534,
-0.0429746546,
-0.0389231071,
0.0693627223,
0.0000421191,
-0.0172841419,
-0.0074768248,
0.0516048521,
-0.0588829294,
-0.010911773,
-0.0072945436,
0.0023199762,
0.0035915789,
-0.0067342166,
0.0303015597,
-0.0920004323,
0.0383003205,
0.0244487971,
0.0358243547,
0.0114057921,
-0.0338356607,
-0.0354748741,
-0.0259093679,
-0.0430751182,
0.0049945451,
-0.0193476249,
0.0321678445,
-0.0002926122,
0.0223891139,
0.038453225,
0.0373430476,
-0.0180279855,
-0.000412567,
-0.0108040757,
-0.0034771946,
-0.023304563,
-0.055287689,
-0.0068571488,
-0.0075790896,
-0.0456724688,
0.0191030763,
0.0131433746,
-0.0200951323,
0.0103740953,
-0.0009157612,
-0.0110255359,
-0.012730306,
2.434e-7,
0.0265588295,
0.0071534859,
-0.0235406607,
0.0287446864,
0.0391260944,
0.0497288145,
0.0064550973,
0.0306834113,
0.0536639132,
-0.013640265,
-0.0319877379,
0.0190187339,
0.0523449853,
-0.0118232658,
-0.0638542622,
-0.0045086211,
-0.0705216452,
0.0110706342,
-0.0405394807,
0.0244295839,
0.0669128448,
0.0760262087,
-0.0528147072,
-0.0151112163,
-0.0177032761,
-0.0317155123,
0.0297739599,
-0.0695596486,
-0.0248710625,
0.0202782247,
0.0754845813,
0.0315972567,
0.0324775763,
0.0680322722,
0.0158235282,
0.0113229826,
-0.0028313391,
0.0507117584,
0.0017333068,
-0.0728472024,
-0.0071571767,
-0.0289155282,
0.0059902016,
-0.0921971798,
0.0589386635,
-0.040247649,
-0.0039357352,
-0.0556610487,
-0.0548188835,
-0.0326536819,
0.0024986113,
-0.0177527852,
-0.0185365472,
0.0024288266,
0.0206502452,
-0.0368156545,
0.0106630605,
-0.044717446,
0.0190137811,
-0.0046820384,
-0.0288903788,
-0.0917289034,
-0.0294226948,
0.0262739304,
-0.0020358036,
-0.0389041267,
0.0104918499,
1.593873224e-34,
0.0119349072,
0.0319364332,
0.0107739149,
0.0567640588,
0.0410808399,
0.003076822,
0.0005284485,
-0.0013566084,
-0.0107267443,
-0.1047028229,
0.0091992542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07468v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07468v2 | Are We Falling in a Middle-Intelligence Trap? An Analysis and Mitigation of the Reversal Curse | 2023-11-13T17:01:12 | 2023-11-16T08:35:05 | Ang Lv, Kaiyi Zhang, Shufang Xie, Quan Tu, Yuhan Chen, Ji-Rong Wen, Rui Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent studies have highlighted a phenomenon in large language models (LLMs)
known as "the reversal curse," in which the order of knowledge entities in the
training data biases the models' comprehension. For example, if a model is
trained on sentences where entity A consistently appears before entity B, it
can respond to queries about A by providing B as the answer. However, it may
encounter confusion when presented with questions concerning B. We contend that
the reversal curse is partially a result of specific model training objectives,
particularly evident in the prevalent use of the next-token prediction within
most causal language models. For the next-token prediction, models solely focus
on a token's preceding context, resulting in a restricted comprehension of the
input. In contrast, we illustrate that the GLM, trained using the
autoregressive blank infilling objective where tokens to be predicted have
access to the entire context, exhibits better resilience against the reversal
curse. We propose a novel training method, BIdirectional Casual language
modeling Optimization (BICO), designed to mitigate the reversal curse when
fine-tuning pretrained causal language models on new data. BICO modifies the
causal attention mechanism to function bidirectionally and employs a mask
denoising optimization. In the task designed to assess the reversal curse, our
approach improves Llama's accuracy from the original 0% to around 70%. We hope
that more attention can be focused on exploring and addressing these inherent
weaknesses of the current LLMs, in order to achieve a higher level of
intelligence. | [
0.0587826259,
0.0759234428,
-0.0198960714,
0.048892241,
-0.0020143942,
0.0282011349,
-0.009414508,
-0.0035936902,
-0.000062512,
-0.0601967983,
-0.0098621426,
-0.0440101139,
-0.012359268,
0.0234447066,
0.0512561537,
-0.0342909247,
0.0755403787,
-0.0329162851,
0.0295379572,
-0.0353442356,
-0.0271247793,
-0.0244656503,
0.0153642455,
0.0346489288,
-0.0061944062,
-0.0162118562,
0.0206200872,
0.0159327611,
-0.0073262248,
-0.0225946251,
0.0237063598,
0.0543819405,
-0.0062195142,
0.0358495116,
0.0000024334,
-0.0666834414,
0.0227880999,
-0.0128347408,
-0.0247266814,
0.0004892784,
-0.0289330762,
0.0316037908,
0.0339393914,
0.0221616384,
-0.0465180278,
0.0004730856,
0.017378537,
0.0560140833,
0.0243946239,
0.0898047388,
-0.0023091566,
-0.0702445582,
0.0208936185,
-0.0522044599,
0.0166639462,
-0.0477458946,
0.0329491384,
-0.0215596743,
-0.0331105255,
0.0078035556,
-0.043485038,
0.0558239259,
0.032014925,
0.0386372581,
0.04790565,
0.0462548733,
0.0446040481,
-0.0236954577,
-0.0131392339,
0.0657216385,
0.0057935701,
-0.0395275205,
-0.0132513419,
-0.0008844521,
0.017347781,
-0.0060556754,
-0.0423509888,
0.017207671,
0.0387926437,
0.0109797595,
0.0443685614,
-0.0087329596,
0.0510898866,
0.0131752547,
-0.0704117119,
0.0846447796,
0.0112454239,
-0.0521160215,
0.0075971833,
0.005006819,
0.0006021707,
-0.0381563753,
-0.022807315,
0.0139368884,
-0.0281806234,
0.0261845291,
-0.0051682345,
-0.0272847731,
0.0267768316,
-0.0151263298,
0.0120920818,
0.0256668162,
-0.0204029083,
0.0406937748,
-0.0215424597,
0.0270193461,
-0.0224065725,
0.0475957841,
-0.0296667702,
0.0033309062,
0.020076694,
-0.0382561795,
-0.0267357882,
0.0119087426,
-0.0547612123,
-0.0083208196,
-0.0068628187,
0.0124452766,
-0.0233515706,
-0.0423916094,
-0.0192394052,
0.0266509522,
-0.0261322726,
-0.0223935489,
-0.0189873837,
0.0142844794,
-0.0394840725,
0.0655797273,
-0.0255416855,
-0.0338619091,
-0.0256043971,
0.0191074666,
-0.0210855417,
-0.0315571614,
-0.0123289237,
0.0988883823,
-0.0184290204,
-0.0265433919,
-0.032592576,
-0.0242194533,
-0.0073866318,
-0.0713216886,
0.0276955366,
-0.035978701,
0.0088278241,
0.0222701412,
-0.0035126728,
-0.087418817,
0.0181710925,
-0.0095763151,
-0.0881977975,
0.057449393,
0.0076901908,
0.0141859651,
0.0184257906,
0.0045782309,
0.0266184658,
0.091759868,
0.0160826333,
-0.0105685508,
0.0116457231,
0.0197100919,
-0.0156381894,
0.0386988856,
0.0590475909,
0.0310830325,
-0.0449730419,
0.0139275771,
0.0141305607,
0.0230042841,
0.0442777872,
0.0197772589,
-0.0069280923,
-0.0294278618,
0.0638647899,
-0.0125054521,
-0.0192058552,
-0.0013955797,
0.0133463452,
-0.0165385548,
-0.0353908688,
0.0269737169,
-0.0901096836,
0.030761281,
-0.038594529,
-0.0098791374,
0.0225843433,
-0.0016286533,
-0.0269952361,
-0.0593940653,
0.0015704089,
0.0286777709,
0.033826787,
0.0306767579,
0.0437857546,
0.02014778,
-0.0532155596,
0.0258163325,
0.0303867757,
-0.0169829782,
-0.0238474011,
-0.0703796744,
0.0064258678,
0.0225570798,
0.0250777192,
-0.0224738233,
-0.0657856986,
0.006492164,
0.0033063516,
0.0357588157,
0.0125522539,
0.0155984843,
0.0056797001,
-0.0138058402,
-0.0333069824,
0.0225609206,
0.0161052309,
0.0169010386,
-0.0083574532,
0.0093831876,
0.0210037138,
-0.0063826805,
-0.0171548668,
0.0652444512,
-0.0416732244,
-0.0392851122,
-0.013919523,
0.015506587,
0.0634880215,
0.0011795101,
0.009361486,
0.0225032382,
0.0561903939,
-0.0390862375,
-0.0166050438,
0.0318184532,
-0.0752529949,
-0.0320839621,
0.0370423831,
-0.042272795,
-0.0151813272,
0.0910055935,
-0.021859007,
-0.0500426628,
0.0533551089,
-0.019510245,
0.0701475516,
-0.0282586869,
0.0252393205,
0.0001434559,
0.00866233,
-0.0441236012,
0.0469889976,
-0.0353975184,
0.0086902352,
-0.0157266427,
-0.0390948094,
0.0056009158,
-0.0217659306,
-0.0104760649,
-0.0179932974,
-0.0011024561,
-0.0196381528,
0.0066219997,
-0.0049741371,
-0.0486772507,
-0.0174563117,
-0.0731144771,
-0.0009739004,
-0.047153499,
-0.0120750191,
0.0210017879,
0.0095337424,
-0.0236787368,
-0.0418222547,
-0.027249068,
0.0020687217,
-0.0142437685,
0.0077325921,
0.020266939,
0.0257912595,
-0.0024985271,
-0.03418345,
-0.0008056255,
-0.0398476459,
0.0255050249,
0.0105462587,
-0.0210313499,
-0.0388293639,
0.0279765669,
-0.0096201664,
0.0326526873,
-0.0434478708,
-0.0466481335,
-0.015306673,
-0.0084645227,
0.0154243177,
0.0748987347,
0.0077244639,
0.0086758528,
0.0395917408,
0.0160413533,
-0.0677368715,
0.0323390961,
-0.0176094361,
0.0024607198,
-0.0243752748,
-0.028134251,
-0.0240640435,
0.1005523354,
-0.0071388823,
-0.0230980609,
-0.0374675654,
0.0223753434,
-0.0300521422,
-0.063758187,
-0.0278519187,
-0.0114518944,
-0.0382176824,
0.0396647863,
-0.0471001491,
-0.0350325033,
0.0557624884,
-0.0019166115,
-0.0259897783,
-0.0315514058,
0.0505869873,
-0.0257633515,
0.0414231196,
0.0412185416,
0.0078779133,
0.0035276443,
-0.0192164369,
-0.0864265338,
0.0095035313,
-0.0066980026,
0.0059871268,
0.0264532305,
-0.0212554727,
0.0074383267,
0.0002603856,
-0.0518940501,
-0.0576868765,
-0.0627608001,
-0.0096922955,
0.0053638094,
0.0328137428,
0.0243210066,
-0.0368410684,
-0.0009571401,
0.0141635835,
0.0282678995,
-0.0300104171,
-0.0027722809,
-0.0136683416,
-0.0000744128,
0.0546811931,
-0.0084715299,
0.05407013,
-0.0360687897,
0.0072864946,
0.025671659,
0.0191343855,
-0.0069776382,
0.0156693701,
-0.0100043463,
0.035062097,
-0.0349202044,
-0.0453792438,
0.0339473635,
0.05286403,
-0.0442259498,
-0.005636455,
0.1150533631,
0.02607283,
-0.0439071544,
0.0112801474,
-0.0113290632,
0.0479425378,
0.0629542843,
0.0051171831,
-0.0871053562,
-0.038549602,
0.0311579648,
0.0339871198,
0.0033517815,
-0.0311800241,
0.0103622302,
-0.1054096892,
0.0323000476,
0.0018092321,
-0.0465983562,
0.0022492034,
-0.043004021,
-0.002450329,
0.0044406164,
0.0191189628,
0.0232844818,
-0.0203532614,
0.0131836087,
0.0171069857,
-0.0048313043,
-0.0072195926,
-0.0048634615,
-0.0070070885,
0.0517470539,
0.0428191125,
0.0138933733,
-0.0202727411,
0.0095370673,
0.0425101109,
0.0108361626,
0.0112991342,
-0.0277386438,
0.0483378433,
-0.0434358716,
-0.0036502432,
0.0014815544,
0.0381674021,
-0.021846151,
-0.0018409989,
0.0173666123,
0.0660186335,
0.0183219202,
-0.024827458,
-0.0260060709,
0.0130854957,
-0.0015602154,
0.0920425504,
0.0405079983,
-0.0273822788,
-0.0537035652,
-0.0191358384,
0.0329984389,
-0.0271123163,
-0.0312936567,
0.0098453406,
0.0472388752,
-0.0169873815,
-0.0518284515,
-0.0967708752,
0.0168618169,
0.0153138647,
0.0229934566,
0.0301135629,
-0.0224853419,
-0.044359494,
-0.0476198792,
0.010543406,
-0.0323973224,
-0.0022572433,
-0.073135376,
-0.0155042494,
-0.0142634381,
-0.0296433475,
-0.028005382,
0.0309898704,
-0.0688899532,
-0.0664688125,
0.0386280231,
0.0824466124,
0.0227128472,
0.0797445476,
-0.0169528238,
-0.0616937801,
0.0196680091,
0.0099612605,
-0.0574613847,
0.0534291752,
0.0581603721,
-0.0220176205,
0.0213377699,
0.0580538064,
-0.0511606708,
0.0300529338,
0.0542761087,
0.0433668345,
-0.0282408986,
-0.008414519,
0.0141249374,
0.0147941802,
0.0795026198,
-0.0384587944,
0.0039129462,
-0.0433438532,
0.0459942929,
-0.026834989,
-0.0264410302,
-0.0223057847,
0.0065392172,
0.0230686441,
0.0251936018,
-0.0186054781,
-0.002882346,
-0.026297627,
0.010890848,
-0.0539155453,
0.047442276,
0.0015616235,
0.0107078534,
0.0274984371,
0.0271813143,
-0.0031952013,
0.0144610358,
0.0335927345,
0.0443346724,
0.0081138918,
0.0434773751,
0.0279026646,
0.0235810783,
-0.0625513792,
-0.0113912532,
-0.0829743668,
-0.0285794456,
0.0102096461,
0.0170772653,
0.069471024,
-0.0198336523,
0.0643891916,
0.0285747088,
0.0050552594,
-0.0033133382,
0.0129139032,
-0.0132290293,
-0.0379567184,
0.0063620331,
-0.0010815668,
-0.0299498662,
0.0306882374,
0.0937609524,
0.0343181118,
0.0642581284,
-0.001381244,
0.0299683549,
-0.0259759706,
-0.0495648496,
0.0651150867,
0.0436679423,
-0.0062496471,
0.032252375,
-0.0692289621,
-0.0794656351,
-0.0026154621,
-0.0315546244,
0.001364613,
-0.0319754966,
0.0229008384,
0.0381510109,
0.0016432347,
-0.0584937483,
-0.0343925618,
-0.0014308463,
0.0028000074,
-0.0139925862,
-0.0324085914,
-7.693908073e-33,
-0.0339791663,
-0.0102751656,
0.0090807742,
-0.010117962,
-0.0152985742,
-0.0091548376,
-0.034181349,
0.0032422994,
-0.0394354016,
0.03650124,
-0.0305701792,
0.0272335131,
0.0167796724,
0.0123416884,
0.0147726201,
0.0192399174,
0.0382017046,
-0.0111860074,
0.0109269796,
0.0101833241,
0.0240464751,
0.0609346218,
0.0462711565,
-0.071249947,
0.0179396067,
-0.0316698402,
0.0148407221,
0.0413470007,
-0.026816627,
0.0188157037,
-0.0343641117,
0.0198704898,
0.0421402119,
-0.0549690016,
-0.018107608,
0.0232209042,
-0.0706111714,
-0.0644076318,
0.0490945764,
0.0125685865,
-0.0278175622,
-0.0341822654,
0.0564939007,
0.0007013207,
-0.0269094687,
-0.003256955,
0.0511440374,
0.004290631,
-0.0288525503,
-0.0035016278,
-0.0883679017,
0.0058359522,
-0.0256271362,
-0.0042518945,
-0.0080927471,
0.0285887625,
0.0037613544,
-0.0157449543,
-0.0429521315,
-0.0010497681,
0.0107642272,
0.0149314608,
0.0295017734,
0.066315718,
-0.0008446471,
0.0435361452,
0.031563174,
0.013637742,
-0.0250193104,
-0.0264537018,
0.0453076549,
-0.0110227931,
0.0055683423,
0.0126924841,
0.0375709645,
-0.0361952335,
-0.1005233079,
-0.0159344058,
-0.0243052784,
0.0505551249,
0.015175405,
-0.0112662921,
-0.0351487584,
-0.0376194827,
-0.0556025691,
-0.0352490172,
-0.0196884573,
-0.0051252679,
0.054648038,
0.0087959049,
-0.0012301229,
-0.0499649234,
0.0296337549,
-0.0605967641,
-0.0134311216,
0.0431130044,
-0.01002644,
0.0006671293,
0.0211050119,
0.0598534048,
-0.0918902457,
-0.0118236328,
0.0034220184,
0.0357886255,
0.0162065141,
0.0015598505,
0.0634152517,
-0.0173101127,
-0.0517686978,
-0.0233232826,
-0.0436225422,
0.0099765286,
0.0169510413,
0.0065269265,
0.0634122714,
0.0226635747,
0.006387549,
0.028654471,
0.0524516068,
0.0122934757,
-0.0437659472,
-0.0118432362,
-0.0087873712,
0.0262839105,
-0.0483820364,
-0.0255843587,
-0.0106199402,
0.0205039661,
0.0083031245,
-0.0722201392,
-0.0353841446,
0.0167028606,
3.089e-7,
0.0654939041,
0.0678814501,
0.0041586594,
0.0205264352,
0.0093650986,
0.010934216,
-0.0121606058,
0.0377037562,
0.0315822661,
0.0527933016,
0.0300148763,
0.0319689475,
0.0106134834,
-0.0266005006,
-0.1023239717,
-0.0073903878,
-0.0672975481,
0.0198006388,
-0.0170670804,
-0.0180374309,
0.0343890935,
0.0947647542,
0.0101733981,
0.0019710166,
-0.0167589784,
-0.0307580736,
0.0619040579,
-0.0387254208,
0.0247079115,
0.0073986021,
0.0057350351,
0.0309686959,
-0.0024355287,
0.0127758933,
0.0071439501,
0.0522643328,
-0.0508726984,
0.0455674864,
-0.0563589185,
-0.0509890877,
-0.0085923495,
0.0227598753,
0.0021033233,
-0.0743118003,
0.0801480711,
-0.0464643836,
-0.0368947126,
0.0179797057,
-0.059435688,
0.025191471,
0.0111340648,
0.0002515557,
-0.0251672827,
0.0081670731,
0.0170201473,
-0.0092860218,
-0.0080875335,
-0.0888948813,
-0.0414785221,
-0.0060833911,
-0.0339979418,
-0.0219408479,
-0.0418272726,
-0.0019526014,
0.0203163605,
-0.0376656465,
-0.0035817849,
3.070205737e-34,
0.0438540578,
-0.0124333054,
0.0254204255,
0.0137024457,
0.0101101287,
-0.0286009237,
-0.028160613,
0.0443970896,
0.0308566503,
-0.0681472272,
-0.0065552332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07466v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07466v3 | On Measuring Faithfulness or Self-consistency of Natural Language Explanations | 2023-11-13T16:53:51 | 2024-06-01T07:57:52 | Letitia Parcalabescu, Anette Frank | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68Txx, I.2.7; I.2.10 | Large language models (LLMs) can explain their predictions through post-hoc
or Chain-of-Thought (CoT) explanations. But an LLM could make up reasonably
sounding explanations that are unfaithful to its underlying reasoning. Recent
work has designed tests that aim to judge the faithfulness of post-hoc or CoT
explanations. In this work we argue that these faithfulness tests do not
measure faithfulness to the models' inner workings -- but rather their
self-consistency at output level. Our contributions are three-fold: i) We
clarify the status of faithfulness tests in view of model explainability,
characterising them as self-consistency tests instead. This assessment we
underline by ii) constructing a Comparative Consistency Bank for
self-consistency tests that for the first time compares existing tests on a
common suite of 11 open LLMs and 5 tasks -- including iii) our new
self-consistency measure CC-SHAP. CC-SHAP is a fine-grained measure (not a
test) of LLM self-consistency. It compares how a model's input contributes to
the predicted answer and to generating the explanation. Our fine-grained
CC-SHAP metric allows us iii) to compare LLM behaviour when making predictions
and to analyse the effect of other consistency tests at a deeper level, which
takes us one step further towards measuring faithfulness by bringing us closer
to the internals of the model than strictly surface output-oriented tests. Our
code is available at \url{https://github.com/Heidelberg-NLP/CC-SHAP} | [
0.0256336108,
0.0519284271,
-0.0308628492,
0.0274815988,
-0.0529965088,
-0.0081370827,
0.019539332,
-0.0068948478,
-0.0137846572,
-0.0292619821,
0.0082287667,
-0.0086134104,
0.0295432694,
0.0272099078,
0.0207615439,
-0.0163559355,
0.0473321676,
-0.0184854642,
-0.0453542285,
0.0081176348,
0.0088016903,
0.0109666921,
0.0062802411,
0.0635977164,
0.0241344552,
-0.0179442428,
-0.0481196158,
-0.0336412527,
-0.0088223023,
-0.0068431809,
-0.0221699085,
0.0334762931,
0.0172123052,
0.0414376184,
0.0000021089,
-0.0648831278,
0.0008756436,
0.0265176985,
-0.0596270077,
0.0353534594,
-0.0503276438,
-0.0038386516,
0.0232376326,
0.0040335506,
0.0025491659,
0.0739196017,
0.0464588366,
0.0318786055,
0.0625158846,
0.0409687273,
0.0249507781,
-0.0489789583,
0.017512057,
-0.0106949685,
0.0190001503,
-0.0102059543,
-0.0008959838,
0.0204393584,
-0.0252425373,
0.0179672595,
-0.0081927534,
0.0053403019,
0.0313811116,
-0.0289137345,
0.0037049665,
0.0192767885,
-0.0186699182,
-0.0542329587,
0.0110901007,
0.0337112471,
0.0162560958,
-0.0784588605,
-0.0057228832,
-0.0122829806,
-0.0330200829,
0.0485106781,
-0.0347264819,
0.0152724283,
0.0070384452,
0.0185515415,
0.0387445539,
0.0191373918,
0.0749418437,
0.0114282034,
-0.011662228,
0.0763786957,
-0.0059627974,
-0.0235469751,
-0.0423150361,
0.0108218277,
-0.0144825317,
-0.0918882117,
-0.0083577922,
0.0400767624,
-0.0358058996,
0.0216853619,
0.0209431946,
0.0517619066,
0.0287786517,
-0.0348141789,
0.0492360368,
0.0493857488,
-0.0394240543,
0.0360897593,
-0.0407979898,
0.0835707113,
-0.0203956086,
0.0209309626,
-0.013785311,
-0.0050533074,
-0.0754065812,
-0.0256389696,
0.0270473342,
0.0174296852,
0.0196758676,
-0.0137305763,
-0.0246627238,
-0.0020644311,
-0.0498080254,
0.0098002627,
0.0425045975,
0.0046431976,
0.0031950579,
-0.0070955395,
-0.0599305071,
0.0277324319,
-0.0580597185,
0.0188524015,
0.0093403542,
-0.0455212072,
-0.0193068422,
-0.0204625186,
-0.0262992475,
-0.0137794465,
0.0055967085,
0.0676763803,
0.0486775786,
0.0003233262,
-0.0385367237,
-0.0385498479,
-0.0609756969,
-0.0860661268,
-0.0093287379,
-0.0459797829,
0.0183811225,
0.0146028567,
0.0007756693,
-0.0255938359,
0.0046008783,
-0.0201863926,
-0.0247477051,
0.0741105303,
-0.0202179383,
0.0333493613,
-0.0410930105,
0.0058234921,
-0.0142008895,
0.0256712418,
0.021323666,
-0.0022631905,
0.0438022316,
-0.051670555,
0.0213244725,
0.0013651547,
0.0285641532,
-0.026138559,
-0.0086424025,
0.0246256776,
-0.0273747463,
0.0371364392,
0.0086760307,
0.0246698745,
0.0085960347,
-0.0008289882,
0.0522462316,
0.0487638861,
0.0380623527,
0.0281080175,
0.0554570369,
-0.030339608,
-0.005500434,
0.0880594626,
-0.0796399415,
0.025625607,
-0.0405344479,
0.0020561649,
0.0413430929,
-0.0030725864,
-0.013081817,
-0.0825373828,
-0.0454987325,
0.0245468244,
-0.0122661162,
-0.0013863284,
0.0406207144,
-0.0065632416,
0.0138736116,
0.0396546721,
0.027704319,
-0.032687705,
0.0005386269,
-0.0754043087,
0.0743082166,
0.0446826033,
0.0214981195,
0.0011594823,
-0.0076815607,
0.0025342668,
0.001318162,
0.0257720519,
0.0286729932,
0.0167165659,
0.0268328898,
0.0113584828,
-0.0193540026,
-0.0500301383,
0.0467416197,
0.0062100836,
0.0015298566,
-0.0468347184,
-0.0069005135,
-0.0328425728,
-0.0325573646,
0.0475672483,
-0.0129173286,
-0.0054037385,
-0.0157873947,
0.0062362794,
0.0273771323,
0.022714613,
-0.0038633032,
0.0402241386,
0.0311140697,
-0.0010237206,
-0.0101480298,
0.0269060601,
-0.0332727954,
-0.0040961481,
0.0324761234,
-0.0207236726,
-0.0221804027,
0.0197077375,
-0.0228528213,
-0.0462096222,
0.0563910417,
-0.0449742042,
0.0167845953,
-0.0300086346,
0.049125988,
-0.0166384894,
0.0061390512,
-0.0018381048,
0.0423115529,
0.0099824853,
0.0509499498,
-0.0361417197,
0.0096082604,
0.0270841438,
-0.0122839669,
0.0213245582,
0.0248359609,
-0.0192176662,
-0.0314331315,
0.0567939393,
-0.0229994785,
-0.0430329703,
-0.0018291214,
-0.0221112501,
0.003375476,
-0.0131555703,
0.0153419506,
0.0480706468,
-0.0221457835,
0.0171614867,
-0.0024486962,
0.0000322192,
0.008252766,
0.0331570916,
0.0076222457,
0.0507995114,
-0.0256364178,
-0.026115207,
-0.0431178361,
-0.0102342106,
-0.0417901352,
0.0761409998,
0.0060982117,
0.0172931459,
-0.0752631649,
-0.0039152307,
-0.0627736896,
-0.0156584587,
-0.0058723469,
-0.0402519964,
0.0601113774,
0.025782628,
-0.0044851266,
0.0356356017,
0.0096369712,
0.0189866982,
0.0624045432,
0.0210531354,
-0.0561018959,
-0.026118679,
-0.046135433,
-0.0303289033,
0.0079365755,
-0.0717779174,
-0.0092949886,
0.0925680399,
0.0184570551,
-0.0103832074,
-0.0668080747,
0.0141992671,
-0.0009079885,
-0.0227926001,
-0.0380593203,
-0.0420429632,
-0.0042895097,
0.0736233443,
-0.0151056629,
-0.0786521211,
0.071785152,
-0.0745087191,
0.0252784155,
0.0307907611,
-0.0287684761,
-0.0447538681,
0.099278003,
-0.0035017219,
-0.0118570412,
0.0450691134,
0.0286785048,
-0.0085844155,
-0.040420223,
0.0590390787,
0.0097851409,
0.0315447934,
-0.0644502044,
0.0007761819,
0.031003803,
-0.0201911237,
-0.0278166644,
-0.0272137821,
-0.0465845428,
0.0272373464,
-0.0079716174,
-0.0230231304,
-0.0092573501,
0.0296139847,
0.0393600762,
-0.0022595094,
-0.0097675025,
-0.014817345,
-0.021387605,
0.0095775127,
0.0274187643,
0.0479588546,
0.0657823011,
0.0057332017,
0.0207769312,
0.030615624,
0.0044700839,
0.0610155314,
-0.0575284399,
0.0213469472,
-0.0257656388,
-0.0176685005,
-0.0303636845,
-0.0013040919,
0.0579367764,
-0.0661663786,
-0.0263390299,
0.1224660948,
0.0290710442,
0.0084060207,
0.0346155986,
-0.029859079,
0.0021853372,
0.0443571731,
-0.001548591,
-0.0375436358,
-0.0282277577,
0.0135973366,
-0.0040433472,
-0.0106956121,
-0.0231602676,
-0.0202630572,
-0.0851431787,
0.0198194124,
-0.021603439,
-0.0176093206,
-0.0034638345,
-0.1217669845,
0.0127657512,
-0.0257678218,
-0.0059277294,
0.0003880286,
0.0302295536,
0.0190052465,
0.0258940123,
-0.0510519221,
-0.016779663,
0.049452059,
-0.0519503467,
0.0582288504,
0.0782209784,
0.0424215049,
-0.0011364282,
-0.0619259067,
0.0327422693,
-0.0364482328,
0.0152115012,
-0.0040926449,
0.0201332532,
0.0091016693,
-0.0071555236,
-0.0348701477,
0.0020677936,
-0.0093596643,
-0.027542172,
-0.0065379282,
0.0580898337,
-0.0149475867,
-0.0821930468,
-0.0032844162,
0.0243053958,
-0.0482773744,
0.1173513085,
0.0462002382,
0.0067803534,
-0.0532168038,
-0.0308111142,
-0.0113543058,
-0.0004307858,
-0.0815665275,
0.0177195892,
0.0222271215,
0.0354589671,
-0.0351145901,
-0.0276856534,
-0.0163658839,
0.0103600239,
-0.0009482018,
0.0143919876,
-0.0148080233,
-0.0162968449,
0.0004112355,
0.0405682325,
-0.0198350716,
0.0124293659,
-0.0085531119,
0.0056550363,
0.0003785273,
-0.033521492,
-0.0002561829,
-0.0040526041,
-0.0286791343,
-0.0570834763,
0.0016118964,
0.0164081417,
0.0313250311,
0.0356005393,
0.0077504367,
-0.0439071618,
-0.0209798012,
-0.0043268241,
-0.0499795415,
0.0021855573,
0.0151160313,
0.0076113911,
0.0145600615,
0.0542893633,
-0.0277773309,
-0.0016009387,
-0.0101671163,
0.0641067848,
0.0314628258,
-0.0139681213,
0.0692439452,
0.0131052965,
0.0522335768,
-0.0257297307,
0.0101741208,
-0.0119784605,
-0.010756406,
-0.007294246,
-0.0283770561,
-0.0253030285,
0.0369727835,
0.0148402778,
-0.005629262,
-0.0163114909,
-0.0319017805,
-0.0423665643,
-0.0028277519,
-0.015178632,
-0.0266482662,
0.0103876423,
0.0134558538,
-0.0414716452,
0.0220878795,
-0.0183904786,
0.027227072,
-0.0462143198,
0.0571875162,
0.0096071176,
0.0532697588,
0.0225947276,
0.0025929564,
-0.0216976646,
0.0010457352,
-0.1000809148,
-0.0359607339,
0.016494425,
-0.0006586171,
0.0215821192,
-0.0273771007,
0.0497652404,
-0.0303440616,
-0.0061476463,
-0.0098410053,
0.0594530702,
0.026222093,
-0.0046953671,
0.0052261632,
0.0143376999,
-0.0416599028,
-0.008889256,
0.037619058,
0.0129419863,
0.0293385629,
0.0134070516,
-0.0209355336,
-0.0108056013,
-0.0457374826,
-0.0526541211,
0.0272360519,
-0.0123326434,
-0.0013205608,
-0.0564129874,
-0.0682669431,
-0.0154667879,
0.0378623232,
0.0201858319,
-0.0088050682,
-0.0107806362,
0.0791161954,
-0.0026994892,
-0.0043464839,
-0.0163951535,
0.0167211778,
-0.0143827843,
0.0426966436,
-0.0147330659,
-6.580032402e-33,
-0.020035116,
-0.0638787821,
0.0055685723,
-0.0523669012,
-0.0054752002,
0.0021975664,
-0.0770582631,
-0.0043868707,
-0.024905527,
0.0365972109,
0.0121598821,
0.0175382998,
0.0076310113,
-0.0216579493,
0.0242295209,
-0.0382223316,
0.0268187728,
0.0278411787,
-0.0450530872,
-0.0225742999,
0.0451434106,
-0.0275322776,
0.0653598905,
-0.045892749,
0.0774380937,
0.0001840848,
-0.0196320023,
0.0305958409,
-0.0522168688,
0.0602822155,
-0.0427457765,
0.0288397148,
0.0382927656,
-0.0286028907,
0.012483011,
-0.0143312262,
-0.0597239658,
-0.0257333778,
0.0665954649,
-0.0157121997,
-0.0739233941,
-0.0040882421,
0.0462437235,
-0.000874092,
-0.0535747409,
-0.0101686604,
0.0220410787,
0.0034165466,
0.0159345102,
0.0438172407,
-0.0300611481,
0.0127443476,
-0.0380478986,
-0.0384463891,
-0.0180602893,
0.0252071023,
-0.0047440575,
0.0123821208,
-0.0300356094,
-0.0002992103,
-0.0013120781,
0.0093051102,
0.0988069549,
-0.0287641361,
0.0073013818,
0.0929423645,
0.0367928371,
-0.0061964965,
-0.077317059,
-0.0394079015,
0.0077577238,
0.0462373309,
0.1178581119,
0.0446203835,
0.0517201126,
0.0436556116,
-0.0595176108,
0.0190678891,
-0.0020986134,
0.0332325771,
0.0227582343,
0.0083168512,
-0.0441590622,
-0.0152058471,
-0.0562440343,
-0.038182009,
-0.0388403982,
-0.0341127105,
0.0296319425,
-0.0148950294,
-0.0248043444,
-0.0060044266,
0.0136649888,
-0.0629565269,
0.0164491013,
-0.0023086159,
-0.0301403813,
-0.0209304579,
0.0295954123,
0.0121573023,
-0.0247342028,
0.0126732383,
-0.0261804536,
0.0432889424,
0.0499886423,
-0.0096113347,
0.010343438,
-0.0087224264,
-0.006796571,
-0.0078230072,
-0.0786654204,
-0.0464545265,
-0.0273438431,
-0.0504557639,
0.0639704317,
0.0408500284,
-0.0415136516,
0.0215416327,
0.0181300025,
0.0138200857,
-0.0083908234,
0.0460674465,
-0.0141568147,
0.0269704666,
0.0025541862,
-0.024704637,
-0.0540686585,
-0.0005762865,
0.0274224319,
-0.0335290767,
-0.0222866684,
0.0093630264,
2.708e-7,
0.0280567855,
0.0386608392,
0.0341849662,
-0.0030275125,
0.0352358669,
0.0147960195,
-0.0245831758,
-0.0260478295,
-0.0267596338,
-0.0735541508,
-0.0295380373,
0.0321863964,
0.0615688488,
0.0143479267,
0.0291878562,
-0.0119601171,
-0.1167177632,
-0.0276288893,
-0.028943073,
0.0212963615,
0.0319625027,
0.0483092815,
0.0421993956,
0.0081637101,
0.0044168411,
-0.0014417784,
0.044044584,
-0.0329978429,
0.0235308055,
0.0056063305,
0.0141788339,
-0.0070701684,
0.0127271181,
-0.0185364075,
0.0128261345,
0.0132919792,
-0.008859395,
0.0180375725,
-0.0054421928,
-0.0172985829,
-0.0603608973,
-0.0498553142,
0.0388160683,
-0.0965232775,
0.082047835,
-0.0361092016,
-0.0503688492,
-0.0197355542,
-0.0031508035,
-0.0287701581,
0.0492505617,
0.0159749389,
0.0094334735,
0.034036044,
-0.0086232871,
0.0065890034,
-0.0308501907,
-0.0719990134,
-0.091111809,
-0.000776727,
-0.0330216959,
0.0021413353,
-0.031003356,
-0.006217184,
0.0542096421,
-0.0862384737,
-0.025102431,
2.396476889e-34,
0.0036520311,
0.0228700619,
0.0282167848,
-0.0075909947,
0.0571377948,
-0.0060068788,
0.0152919488,
0.0085775582,
0.0403531827,
-0.0642436147,
-0.0333326459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07463v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07463v2 | MEGAVERSE: Benchmarking Large Language Models Across Languages, Modalities, Models and Tasks | 2023-11-13T16:45:37 | 2024-04-02T21:18:00 | Sanchit Ahuja, Divyanshu Aggarwal, Varun Gumma, Ishaan Watts, Ashutosh Sathe, Millicent Ochieng, Rishav Hada, Prachi Jain, Maxamed Axmed, Kalika Bali, Sunayana Sitaram | cs.CL | cs.CL | There has been a surge in LLM evaluation research to understand LLM
capabilities and limitations. However, much of this research has been confined
to English, leaving LLM building and evaluation for non-English languages
relatively unexplored. Several new LLMs have been introduced recently,
necessitating their evaluation on non-English languages. This study aims to
perform a thorough evaluation of the non-English capabilities of SoTA LLMs
(GPT-3.5-Turbo, GPT-4, PaLM2, Gemini-Pro, Mistral, Llama2, and Gemma) by
comparing them on the same set of multilingual datasets. Our benchmark
comprises 22 datasets covering 83 languages, including low-resource African
languages. We also include two multimodal datasets in the benchmark and compare
the performance of LLaVA models, GPT-4-Vision and Gemini-Pro-Vision. Our
experiments show that larger models such as GPT-4, Gemini-Pro and PaLM2
outperform smaller models on various tasks, notably on low-resource languages,
with GPT-4 outperforming PaLM2 and Gemini-Pro on more datasets. We also perform
a study on data contamination and find that several models are likely to be
contaminated with multilingual evaluation benchmarks, necessitating approaches
to detect and handle contamination while assessing the multilingual performance
of LLMs. | [
0.0027680984,
0.0451851226,
-0.0070024924,
0.0717384294,
-0.0289431531,
0.0113708507,
0.0062314095,
0.0065586921,
-0.0215718281,
-0.0375720635,
-0.0920934975,
-0.0838852152,
0.0457868762,
0.0058707562,
0.0565058812,
-0.0526759699,
0.0311889052,
-0.0728785619,
-0.0647531077,
-0.0043933359,
-0.0014416147,
0.0176534783,
0.0087374719,
0.039455425,
-0.0181535147,
-0.0104974275,
0.0098437993,
0.0213696249,
0.0244424008,
-0.0282172561,
-0.0319651477,
0.0097157229,
-0.0017027383,
0.0398768373,
0.0000020653,
-0.0464435555,
0.0280820224,
0.0016137175,
-0.008748767,
0.0421062224,
0.0744123608,
-0.0300211329,
-0.046553269,
0.0192381125,
-0.021257529,
0.0021136492,
0.0502866097,
-0.0170235354,
0.0085318806,
0.0475955643,
-0.0047741514,
-0.0130587863,
0.0519897491,
-0.0256470628,
-0.0415486991,
-0.0125542833,
0.010642753,
0.0005644351,
0.0178891961,
-0.0081150401,
-0.016496053,
0.0477951393,
0.0319405831,
0.0084785437,
-0.0374013036,
0.0189412199,
-0.0244919062,
-0.0485740937,
-0.0338546485,
0.0590070039,
-0.0048045791,
-0.0036108166,
-0.024657378,
0.0019463383,
-0.0394978598,
-0.0220780652,
-0.041517403,
0.0502610132,
0.0055500562,
0.027086271,
0.0191073883,
-0.0072671957,
0.0555542074,
-0.0146920532,
-0.0338330716,
0.0523916706,
0.0567193106,
-0.0015900652,
0.018195942,
0.0101045063,
-0.0017537902,
-0.0281417295,
-0.013629877,
-0.0018324711,
-0.0090181576,
0.007808357,
-0.022879567,
0.0058796164,
0.0239743441,
-0.0344212055,
0.0834947303,
0.0354477055,
-0.0601962693,
0.0332742631,
-0.0324691087,
0.0536746308,
-0.0474455766,
0.0385255106,
-0.0316718295,
-0.0344956294,
0.0096365605,
0.0064022965,
0.0239399225,
0.0070650615,
-0.0596930869,
0.0021205291,
-0.0475108325,
0.0072367922,
0.0199199487,
-0.0010410398,
0.0390412919,
-0.0494867824,
-0.0238833725,
-0.0238221902,
-0.0062366701,
0.0219126008,
0.0158382412,
0.0230008904,
-0.0309264455,
-0.1229728833,
0.0465229489,
0.0322632156,
-0.0373619907,
-0.0073818658,
0.0190592576,
0.1333342195,
-0.0074243592,
-0.0567604303,
-0.0554575585,
0.0291665252,
-0.0188000128,
-0.0908114761,
-0.0137031479,
-0.0590770692,
0.0011068343,
0.0096557252,
0.0268459804,
-0.0068600615,
-0.0066321632,
-0.0126067828,
0.0309306476,
0.0607961006,
-0.0292334817,
0.0030454618,
0.0234464817,
0.0172096938,
0.0097485092,
0.113083221,
0.0295298025,
-0.0022368846,
0.0322710238,
0.0055885189,
-0.0105897393,
0.1180266142,
-0.0227480307,
0.0350698903,
-0.037662033,
-0.0095721977,
0.0147640416,
0.024938615,
0.0341905542,
0.0626454651,
-0.0084523214,
-0.0061450624,
0.0700775087,
0.040842779,
0.0332843401,
0.0077407584,
0.0354530625,
-0.0377133489,
0.0193999,
-0.006790332,
-0.0228480492,
0.0017414917,
-0.0202293843,
-0.0023491669,
-0.0041160281,
0.0698458776,
-0.0277908333,
-0.0083487015,
-0.0422752015,
-0.0273111463,
-0.008755249,
0.0127135292,
0.0635945126,
-0.0359462015,
-0.0250589475,
0.0487915054,
0.0264399573,
-0.055956047,
-0.0062457407,
-0.0770483091,
0.0064410511,
0.0317424051,
0.0173710398,
0.0063601192,
-0.0354941972,
0.0096151112,
-0.01586641,
0.0620446056,
0.0254471358,
-0.0008206501,
0.0560927205,
-0.0689883605,
-0.008772267,
0.0050189747,
-0.009859453,
0.0629122108,
-0.007394956,
0.0511333607,
0.0131621324,
-0.0528326333,
0.0063127181,
0.0358963721,
-0.0418186188,
0.0358645506,
-0.0051459423,
-0.0015957997,
0.0416715927,
0.0255196653,
-0.0086217737,
-0.016591819,
0.0163823888,
-0.0493530557,
0.048629038,
0.0383787565,
-0.0302293245,
-0.0030433605,
0.0768585652,
-0.0220022779,
0.0101499995,
0.040282812,
0.0182069298,
-0.0561388917,
0.0127226235,
-0.023449285,
0.0197966546,
-0.0528714955,
0.0253699757,
-0.0086014597,
0.0238689706,
-0.0062751262,
0.043766465,
-0.013511477,
0.0153299933,
0.045627486,
0.0019867693,
0.0517686419,
-0.0328539982,
-0.0431926996,
0.0670043975,
0.0036364719,
0.0065841326,
-0.0034891111,
0.0194784887,
-0.0399593785,
-0.0370367542,
-0.0997615978,
0.0020361689,
-0.0422858894,
0.0412469655,
-0.0003807985,
0.0186583642,
-0.032503631,
0.0036329946,
-0.0196649302,
0.0132939965,
0.0133874938,
0.0245327018,
-0.0103490492,
-0.0023138663,
-0.0452427305,
-0.0291269794,
-0.0075019058,
0.0413670242,
0.0288081672,
-0.0313591026,
-0.0298959874,
-0.0576311611,
0.0132519435,
-0.0312397853,
0.012562491,
-0.0169244055,
-0.0522950217,
0.026902061,
-0.0298710745,
0.0457022004,
0.0106555643,
-0.0400920361,
0.0039696074,
0.054058291,
-0.0274360422,
-0.0389432311,
-0.014465631,
0.0414001495,
-0.0373994596,
-0.0500559881,
-0.035548117,
-0.0289255232,
0.0748204887,
-0.0097686043,
0.0132454494,
-0.0393263027,
-0.0319809206,
-0.0362824611,
-0.0417184941,
0.0077920132,
0.0380428545,
-0.0342157334,
0.0524641611,
-0.0077778706,
-0.0657165721,
0.0282449424,
-0.072349973,
-0.0395407006,
-0.003266461,
-0.0134874433,
-0.0550893955,
0.0407696664,
-0.0134470696,
0.0008769104,
-0.0402112827,
-0.0332692713,
-0.0242103785,
0.0079646735,
0.0270028636,
-0.0203856472,
0.0803127959,
-0.0760210454,
0.0194799006,
-0.0434494503,
-0.024843568,
-0.0032831521,
0.0004367548,
-0.0516689457,
0.0019264185,
-0.0032840427,
-0.0084687909,
-0.0182712395,
0.0328958482,
0.0132258451,
0.0436698161,
0.009142383,
0.0128380759,
-0.0111843683,
0.0119258594,
0.0071766512,
0.0278336722,
0.0258626752,
-0.0477495827,
0.0211858824,
0.017540751,
0.0076050572,
-0.0183892027,
-0.0566770025,
0.0243768897,
0.0717104226,
0.0263692699,
-0.0725810975,
0.0268308502,
0.0543338433,
-0.0402214937,
0.0227121282,
0.0633256957,
0.0077295029,
-0.0278996304,
-0.0085960012,
-0.0204276424,
0.0420142114,
0.0171762686,
-0.017808089,
-0.0891141817,
-0.0418335274,
0.0059763025,
-0.0177939683,
0.0217080768,
0.0029361248,
-0.0025319404,
-0.1011864543,
0.0395017825,
0.0077947658,
-0.0326176845,
-0.0080730524,
-0.012073826,
-0.0105504273,
-0.0263476558,
0.0294495877,
-0.0017191599,
-0.0046876972,
-0.0264386404,
0.0165015273,
-0.0216843318,
-0.0750044957,
0.0042054798,
-0.0240014847,
0.042326279,
0.0374334604,
-0.0004376309,
-0.0294606891,
-0.0497814082,
0.0475163199,
-0.0135202473,
0.0002661337,
-0.0184898358,
-0.0138578583,
0.0385736115,
-0.0367196947,
0.0058674742,
-0.0054406771,
-0.0304502118,
0.0045864657,
-0.0239948109,
0.0460935645,
-0.0233727619,
0.0098764887,
-0.0033534637,
-0.0344415382,
-0.0260024369,
0.0350463763,
0.0199195351,
-0.0185201224,
-0.0157967433,
-0.0172544606,
-0.0063047046,
-0.0239624083,
-0.0104383295,
0.0285450201,
-0.0080970004,
-0.020883007,
-0.037001539,
-0.0394419953,
-0.0069172895,
0.017171897,
0.0166378114,
0.0223935284,
-0.0256165862,
0.0034813606,
-0.0118672214,
0.0304286927,
-0.0199960005,
0.0533021316,
-0.0841313452,
0.0305565,
0.0453886688,
-0.0179694984,
0.0162989218,
0.0212304518,
-0.0974571854,
-0.071940884,
-0.026853472,
0.0338592976,
0.024971785,
0.0198356938,
0.0060691093,
-0.0721745193,
-0.0034415892,
-0.0102676377,
0.0034355463,
0.0443639271,
0.0273667723,
0.0035201507,
0.0018352813,
0.0439798608,
-0.0288582109,
-0.002244737,
0.0057343449,
0.0287643932,
-0.0302143767,
-0.034874469,
-0.0276606698,
0.0239062514,
0.0450517274,
-0.0835663155,
-0.0248243921,
-0.0272762366,
0.018983243,
-0.0365166552,
0.0394019373,
-0.0525556989,
0.0032276744,
0.0396763198,
0.0061491574,
-0.0162602011,
0.0167772882,
-0.020504076,
-0.0029728822,
-0.0269444659,
0.0669657364,
0.0395444669,
-0.0172156245,
0.023182692,
0.0344114527,
-0.0115488954,
0.0142709902,
-0.0045553488,
0.0359298289,
-0.0139078153,
0.046271015,
-0.0246637259,
-0.0140907979,
0.0305596869,
0.0409202576,
0.0098508261,
-0.0185790863,
-0.0108337104,
0.0718921348,
0.1084626615,
0.0355133638,
0.0888996199,
-0.0180220678,
-0.0064648022,
-0.0411478691,
0.0508208014,
-0.0247136261,
0.0064924783,
0.0657745004,
-0.005539902,
-0.0283054374,
0.0172880255,
0.0588232316,
0.0318590812,
0.0137943104,
0.0124218659,
0.0480408408,
-0.0291135218,
-0.0188037697,
0.0213363115,
-0.0258122459,
-0.0273190495,
0.0139149418,
-0.051855024,
-0.0669869706,
0.0165888723,
0.0180736389,
-0.0240480024,
-0.0184478033,
0.0113155637,
0.0421244726,
0.0149616636,
0.0178972743,
-0.0261309929,
-0.0424545966,
0.0065189977,
-0.0160303507,
0.036003314,
-6.282602943e-33,
-0.0212151781,
0.0051299925,
0.0251055975,
-0.0161846895,
-0.0363331661,
0.0179465245,
-0.0225111023,
0.011968499,
-0.0320148431,
-0.007958062,
-0.0060019344,
-0.008655237,
0.0236164723,
0.0143543351,
0.0039332486,
0.0062050722,
0.0109484354,
0.0078480169,
-0.0009403063,
-0.0260258913,
0.0018161502,
0.028618617,
0.0984896794,
-0.0283637214,
0.0080667408,
-0.0100592598,
-0.0333545394,
0.0017654264,
-0.0154835526,
0.0893552527,
-0.0397744365,
0.055559922,
0.0136437081,
-0.0165756363,
-0.0317453779,
-0.027860919,
-0.0305224173,
-0.0067860819,
0.0509650558,
0.0597867891,
-0.040200185,
-0.0215211175,
0.0406080261,
-0.0050086705,
-0.0620246753,
0.0157469828,
-0.0114974268,
-0.0470355935,
-0.0501311272,
0.0020145406,
-0.0488856137,
0.0568839088,
0.0199679062,
-0.0088578006,
0.0618462972,
0.0054374482,
-0.0319185592,
0.0126138292,
-0.0550141521,
0.0122953942,
0.0193399526,
0.0501722172,
0.1118200645,
0.0428323597,
-0.0252248477,
0.0472651608,
0.0307712536,
-0.0530594848,
0.0292257313,
-0.0186959468,
0.0552278608,
0.0248260256,
0.0451960266,
0.0805964991,
-0.0075566145,
-0.005555687,
-0.0590866208,
0.0235712156,
0.013655955,
0.0331463963,
-0.0095134443,
0.0247483663,
-0.0173140652,
-0.0196018778,
-0.0289500486,
-0.0174774546,
-0.0357497483,
-0.0121595012,
0.0559463277,
-0.031902954,
0.0253416356,
0.0198863205,
0.0513918735,
-0.0298598222,
-0.0358700678,
-0.0056639472,
-0.0221527796,
0.0473955199,
0.008674914,
0.060367398,
-0.0584449768,
-0.0076698437,
-0.0138466656,
0.0353190862,
0.0129530821,
-0.0178964715,
-0.0157033615,
0.0216750391,
-0.0716144294,
0.0222537648,
-0.0318403728,
0.0095054433,
0.0076592285,
0.0347174294,
0.0572502837,
-0.0711069703,
-0.0133369509,
0.0631991625,
-0.0063175033,
-0.0139265237,
-0.02858283,
-0.0281340629,
0.0185412671,
0.0402810574,
-0.0249995161,
0.024649227,
-0.0433731861,
-0.0035872036,
0.033656735,
-0.0106024742,
-0.0132660149,
0.0448525809,
2.665e-7,
0.0312991925,
0.0097479951,
0.0173404831,
-0.0169868041,
0.0182623044,
0.0336498991,
-0.0552438311,
-0.0075137019,
-0.0103999563,
-0.0116258515,
-0.0309288148,
-0.0035952185,
0.1003461853,
0.0310650766,
-0.0512077622,
0.0424098819,
-0.0309998617,
0.0161138773,
-0.0409785248,
0.0007905714,
-0.0042644227,
0.1122174859,
-0.0402945243,
-0.0363002568,
-0.0300851241,
-0.0434602238,
0.0663271546,
-0.0622200854,
-0.0467099845,
0.0003542644,
0.0460925885,
0.0615218803,
-0.0151762627,
-0.0056422316,
-0.0160514805,
0.0009650016,
0.0314292945,
0.0424984246,
-0.007790288,
-0.0254139621,
0.0405791849,
-0.0092954822,
-0.0514850579,
-0.0503815114,
0.0695202425,
0.040762309,
-0.0180388838,
-0.0195021089,
-0.007175161,
-0.0235702153,
0.0317996591,
-0.070718646,
-0.016617734,
0.0352585949,
0.0347544141,
-0.0680278614,
-0.0593413115,
-0.0281120595,
-0.0185958482,
0.0110704768,
-0.029044643,
-0.0406134985,
-0.0447277427,
0.0051154778,
0.009907241,
-0.0417332426,
-0.0241845604,
2.331593504e-34,
0.0322855748,
-0.0398925208,
0.0320706069,
0.0329226851,
-0.0231107231,
-0.0121137435,
-0.0200587157,
0.0097389081,
-0.0431078188,
-0.0545562804,
0.0104889758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07453v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07453v2 | ChartCheck: Explainable Fact-Checking over Real-World Chart Images | 2023-11-13T16:35:29 | 2024-02-16T12:14:05 | Mubashara Akhtar, Nikesh Subedi, Vivek Gupta, Sahar Tahmasebi, Oana Cocarascu, Elena Simperl | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Whilst fact verification has attracted substantial interest in the natural
language processing community, verifying misinforming statements against data
visualizations such as charts has so far been overlooked. Charts are commonly
used in the real-world to summarize and communicate key information, but they
can also be easily misused to spread misinformation and promote certain
agendas. In this paper, we introduce ChartCheck, a novel, large-scale dataset
for explainable fact-checking against real-world charts, consisting of 1.7k
charts and 10.5k human-written claims and explanations. We systematically
evaluate ChartCheck using vision-language and chart-to-table models, and
propose a baseline to the community. Finally, we study chart reasoning types
and visual attributes that pose a challenge to these models | [
-0.0167215597,
0.0617382936,
-0.0035344895,
0.059511248,
-0.0135222822,
0.0276905466,
-0.0144952023,
-0.0098252464,
0.0387213565,
0.0219821017,
0.0033378731,
0.0076721907,
0.0419150963,
0.0562707894,
0.0349062346,
-0.0660176203,
0.0320312604,
0.0135528753,
0.0643391237,
0.0251016486,
0.0177594628,
0.0201432947,
-0.0297087897,
0.0706211478,
-0.056141153,
-0.0647267401,
0.0148720136,
0.01985934,
0.021494111,
-0.0443895832,
-0.0489482731,
0.0122033926,
0.0164419319,
0.0270500481,
0.0000018723,
0.0078453477,
0.017476771,
0.0147540374,
-0.0626214519,
-0.0268527698,
0.0165970176,
-0.0776764899,
0.0112256175,
-0.0099373795,
-0.0298680961,
-0.0049780644,
0.0447137877,
0.0571966246,
0.1195069999,
0.0333833098,
-0.011291137,
-0.0023775012,
-0.0265797917,
-0.0042386157,
0.0098364856,
-0.0306290425,
0.0062155677,
0.039261438,
-0.0196241941,
0.0267808978,
-0.0179228429,
0.0202677846,
0.0210975092,
-0.028368108,
-0.0183208287,
0.0150587633,
-0.0250774268,
-0.02708189,
0.0125725679,
0.0823384225,
-0.0204054415,
-0.0216538403,
0.0377854519,
-0.0170467664,
-0.0088945068,
0.0381287187,
-0.0566163473,
-0.0112074753,
-0.02958313,
-0.0179895088,
-0.0232675839,
0.0105180014,
0.0347980596,
0.0053447327,
0.0138299102,
-0.0038562724,
-0.0537971258,
-0.0175279938,
0.0025443307,
-0.0117767286,
-0.0275137555,
-0.0601285733,
-0.0228866264,
0.013445151,
-0.0130768288,
0.0069879778,
-0.0208046362,
-0.0130505105,
0.001979107,
-0.0376945399,
0.0398117676,
-0.0066308854,
-0.034694206,
0.0608917028,
0.0075536743,
0.0271079671,
-0.0033423093,
0.0218160991,
0.0178848021,
-0.0211838596,
-0.0113512632,
0.0061355489,
-0.0146063203,
-0.0490272343,
-0.02528584,
-0.0012741541,
-0.0184709579,
-0.0342709497,
-0.0683222711,
0.0911014006,
0.0162704904,
0.0301750526,
-0.0171750318,
-0.0367578417,
-0.0568099357,
0.027150061,
-0.0381132774,
0.0193031151,
-0.0162330195,
-0.0358290039,
-0.0121484613,
0.0378552228,
0.020720711,
0.0202527698,
0.0030360427,
0.0279656556,
0.0371895321,
0.0394855328,
-0.0349015594,
-0.0585698672,
-0.0206128471,
-0.0427904464,
0.0010593692,
-0.0472593419,
0.0072275777,
-0.0353148542,
-0.0082278512,
-0.0232756156,
-0.0042895153,
0.0580252483,
-0.0459318869,
0.0797565207,
-0.0124348281,
-0.0147359045,
-0.0155520141,
0.0015336589,
-0.0322263315,
0.0318350643,
0.0518023968,
0.0350006968,
0.0307501033,
-0.0085271932,
0.0316957496,
0.0048699733,
0.0600108765,
-0.0043575717,
0.0094340807,
0.0246819798,
-0.0714603737,
-0.0027892359,
0.0023247076,
0.006458845,
-0.0141343819,
-0.0436481535,
0.0533767566,
0.0315594189,
0.0258546006,
-0.0288640056,
0.0227254108,
0.0021601014,
0.0231092535,
-0.0172087532,
-0.0441242568,
0.0465451404,
0.0428746082,
0.0120894443,
-0.038200032,
0.0024166484,
0.0032928402,
-0.0416518748,
-0.0202861335,
0.0145525057,
-0.0000538781,
-0.0139397439,
-0.0097690132,
0.0436880998,
-0.0346453711,
0.0239253584,
0.0063990182,
-0.0178468544,
-0.0300878603,
0.0019459848,
0.0291651227,
0.0247411113,
0.0403317064,
-0.0202360507,
0.0258958526,
-0.0524401665,
0.0463274568,
0.0337386467,
0.0610636361,
-0.0207159631,
-0.0396641046,
-0.012769754,
-0.0280907918,
-0.0210350063,
0.0290849358,
-0.013844599,
0.0430372246,
0.0018332674,
-0.020785911,
-0.1056256071,
-0.0352466516,
0.0062050154,
0.0590585507,
0.0102781085,
-0.0037284684,
0.0208748635,
-0.0014979398,
0.0313681103,
0.0025234702,
0.01480221,
0.0242540296,
0.0034928052,
-0.0002152872,
0.0376484059,
-0.0086328294,
-0.0360076316,
0.0154639008,
-0.0779583231,
-0.0717288107,
0.0223575979,
-0.0690113455,
-0.0217287745,
0.0034520957,
-0.0563854538,
-0.0289992411,
0.0081805186,
-0.0547363348,
0.0070440355,
0.0179245099,
0.0249407608,
0.0701854005,
-0.0277129151,
-0.0167380497,
-0.0422087759,
0.0141721945,
0.0465300009,
-0.0141515816,
0.0596138686,
0.0264361594,
-0.0012245605,
0.0239538401,
-0.0028337827,
-0.0385041088,
-0.0417112857,
0.0513159335,
-0.0638600588,
-0.0247418713,
-0.0013784376,
0.0128018958,
0.0235233381,
-0.0462749191,
0.0078366315,
-0.0377330445,
-0.0407299995,
0.0080448184,
-0.0078277886,
-0.0148295853,
0.0752893835,
-0.0615494028,
-0.0002623686,
-0.0094571728,
0.0013575625,
-0.0283102486,
0.0663462132,
0.0516868271,
0.0066582542,
-0.0218214355,
-0.0140272584,
-0.0584631935,
-0.0018478656,
0.0021623569,
0.0318674445,
0.0326852761,
0.0327239968,
0.0124490252,
0.0411437638,
-0.0099614682,
0.0473122038,
-0.0157801192,
0.0324510038,
-0.0179820769,
-0.0051754415,
-0.0190940462,
0.0470136479,
0.0138214305,
-0.0554782227,
0.0158688184,
0.036144115,
0.0287007503,
0.0167763364,
-0.0333161019,
0.0359640941,
-0.0085543469,
0.0089073358,
-0.0624134541,
-0.0011532069,
0.0139455367,
0.041819226,
-0.0373079032,
-0.0486258157,
0.0680419654,
-0.0321501568,
0.0253558178,
0.021966964,
-0.0211573914,
-0.0307968426,
0.0519337095,
0.0065733334,
-0.015558783,
0.0037726159,
0.0057560005,
-0.0074694273,
-0.0245594867,
0.0716663897,
-0.0217305198,
0.0171227809,
-0.0642702356,
0.000332422,
0.0073277317,
-0.0066338871,
-0.0343703292,
-0.0635017529,
-0.0376678593,
-0.0030873551,
-0.0147070466,
-0.044320818,
-0.0507019423,
-0.0477350764,
0.053628996,
0.0102978963,
0.0217748564,
0.0033684531,
-0.0106017264,
0.0159391519,
0.0200015362,
0.0428305231,
0.0279393028,
-0.0263701752,
0.0044228984,
0.0680652857,
0.002817082,
0.0223007649,
-0.0425600335,
-0.0157833677,
-0.0710369498,
0.0451674536,
0.0156906415,
0.0063041593,
0.0310826115,
-0.0566322431,
0.0307622179,
0.0360506624,
-0.0080853971,
0.0434869975,
0.013650422,
0.0479852892,
0.0075995144,
0.0150001021,
0.0023473739,
-0.1159653217,
-0.0199476667,
-0.0160957649,
0.0177767556,
0.0188024342,
-0.0343736447,
-0.0417881496,
-0.0926720947,
0.0660777688,
-0.0030238202,
0.0109397266,
-0.0469919555,
-0.0581994876,
-0.0187382251,
-0.0279917698,
-0.021753164,
-0.0161806438,
0.0260222908,
-0.001356584,
-0.001886013,
-0.0553954728,
-0.0146883186,
0.0327176936,
-0.0187941175,
-0.0256638657,
-0.0202462748,
0.0775535777,
0.0040466087,
-0.054401692,
-0.0325728282,
0.0312539786,
-0.0132682873,
0.0305375084,
0.1009706035,
0.0068807658,
-0.0348496325,
-0.0304303803,
0.0510092154,
-0.0154640665,
-0.037874829,
-0.0385774337,
0.0754891708,
-0.0206839591,
-0.0344061516,
-0.0095003042,
0.0384050794,
0.0049926573,
0.0751281753,
0.049501501,
0.0451414175,
-0.04960512,
-0.0602103695,
0.0051828846,
-0.0875630304,
-0.0376834683,
0.0310925469,
0.0303940866,
-0.0309550911,
-0.0562389195,
-0.0108768046,
-0.0129708992,
0.041348815,
-0.0354932509,
-0.0279670414,
0.0481255203,
-0.0285441317,
-0.0477969199,
0.0459750965,
-0.0262215436,
0.0653655455,
0.036942143,
0.0089394487,
-0.0369187258,
0.0089892959,
-0.0247625373,
0.0418302156,
-0.0900791734,
0.0082583614,
-0.0279250573,
0.0125897909,
0.0232325457,
0.041700393,
-0.0189606845,
0.007604362,
0.0344434753,
0.0567390993,
-0.0274227951,
-0.0428348891,
0.0033843527,
0.0020386227,
0.0161111727,
0.0117797656,
0.0073100254,
0.02500806,
-0.0019803375,
-0.0129514076,
-0.0702128187,
0.0433686636,
-0.0001157043,
0.0088301338,
0.0296248794,
0.0212229267,
-0.0196862072,
-0.0387161821,
-0.0121497493,
-0.0238123164,
-0.0372898057,
0.0111207534,
0.0022576426,
-0.0005954801,
-0.0438714586,
-0.0191981588,
-0.0012481139,
-0.0109500075,
-0.0055205747,
-0.0358224809,
-0.00086104,
0.0290442314,
0.0081955334,
-0.0044468185,
0.0007810852,
-0.0248806085,
0.017523028,
-0.033648748,
0.0473954715,
0.0396267585,
0.0240768082,
0.0230713636,
-0.0225816537,
0.0094410209,
-0.0224474948,
-0.0616674721,
-0.0690506175,
0.0267587341,
0.0102032004,
0.0099110948,
-0.0085391365,
0.0176306423,
-0.007002899,
-0.0255868491,
0.0269058309,
0.0288722534,
0.0245297309,
-0.0128295897,
0.0519273728,
0.0043827905,
-0.0322719365,
-0.0362405367,
0.0432141162,
-0.0060806577,
0.0151035655,
-0.0308311246,
-0.0526233539,
-0.0361686312,
-0.0111401761,
-0.0365791172,
-0.002159748,
0.0483471826,
0.0039385092,
-0.1008568555,
-0.0887142345,
0.0310423728,
0.0351233631,
0.0205561332,
0.0349117219,
-0.0184283573,
0.0370424204,
0.0446371101,
-0.0110051343,
-0.0134977177,
0.0280815735,
-0.0184172895,
-0.0103599988,
-0.0288367234,
-5.582906829e-33,
0.0121347336,
-0.0940049589,
0.0017703203,
-0.0266115107,
0.0287120454,
0.028910473,
-0.0490306132,
-0.0433820598,
-0.0266640559,
0.076752983,
0.0280261394,
0.079844296,
0.0032043173,
0.010595018,
-0.0242072176,
-0.0262632277,
0.0620310642,
-0.0029953329,
-0.0383179858,
-0.011214206,
0.066923961,
-0.0183186196,
0.0174085479,
-0.1013389528,
0.0736996755,
0.0220720973,
-0.0195251014,
-0.0013386396,
-0.0167024676,
0.0341630876,
0.0063607595,
0.033532057,
0.0212520715,
-0.0277714897,
-0.027583519,
0.0287651177,
-0.0787800699,
-0.033404097,
0.0165511798,
0.0009850278,
-0.0500486493,
0.0360350013,
0.0474378727,
0.0082939044,
-0.0064136721,
-0.0597617514,
0.043589849,
-0.0294303186,
0.0143254343,
0.0531077832,
-0.00132875,
0.0338337943,
-0.0092335651,
-0.0068408391,
-0.0036344491,
0.0723319724,
0.0129824681,
0.043039266,
-0.0911953896,
0.0393072926,
-0.0308592636,
-0.0685486346,
0.0581085794,
-0.0543319173,
0.0001266969,
0.0668372959,
-0.0116934273,
0.0304655284,
-0.1014245749,
0.0439791158,
-0.0308599211,
0.0847856626,
0.0970529169,
0.0627119392,
0.0154591035,
-0.0258660503,
-0.0532279313,
0.0234751217,
-0.036227718,
0.0305234883,
-0.040379297,
-0.0117978426,
-0.0640900731,
-0.0140601257,
-0.0088803815,
-0.000134596,
-0.0297992695,
0.0349816382,
0.0041541425,
-0.0025380861,
-0.0108914049,
0.0742308423,
-0.0370779634,
-0.0322552472,
0.0100226048,
0.0087954123,
0.0052329577,
-0.0117185963,
0.0310727973,
-0.0117790438,
-0.0238445066,
0.042956695,
0.0308826249,
0.016804276,
0.0349633396,
0.0152115505,
0.0847554281,
-0.0132664554,
-0.0520276725,
0.0126210367,
-0.0289910957,
0.0020055398,
-0.0162658356,
-0.0366066508,
0.040637292,
0.0135619836,
-0.0393974558,
0.0050835381,
-0.0001361036,
0.0330775902,
0.0041392376,
0.0015750434,
-0.0659254864,
0.0287102815,
0.013757295,
-0.0375616997,
-0.0233324822,
-0.0378754437,
0.0183210783,
-0.0766195506,
0.0157071166,
-0.0013528281,
2.406e-7,
0.0297829565,
0.0271407515,
0.0524550788,
0.0312182177,
0.0345801897,
0.0567488447,
-0.0068859272,
-0.0042131967,
-0.0587984063,
-0.0823300034,
-0.0144650489,
0.0262197331,
0.0536612272,
0.074094899,
0.0074799806,
-0.0138403783,
-0.0347976722,
-0.0243885294,
-0.0536265187,
0.018488843,
0.0679090023,
0.0191303585,
0.0359150395,
-0.0202081092,
0.0198337622,
-0.0204755012,
0.0456552394,
0.0077040624,
-0.0050775884,
-0.0405490361,
0.0363817737,
-0.0157062579,
0.0207172707,
0.0236565806,
-0.0402001068,
-0.0270436164,
0.014612278,
0.0280737281,
0.0166427437,
0.043516919,
-0.0543632098,
-0.0335831344,
0.0143216345,
-0.0543672703,
0.0391312875,
-0.0441587977,
-0.0547378063,
-0.0096775861,
-0.0145524517,
0.0381396078,
0.0339862257,
0.0207813215,
-0.0244117752,
-0.0158375576,
0.0111015923,
-0.0031357526,
0.0351491496,
-0.0150648169,
-0.0298057422,
0.0379765928,
-0.0249413736,
0.0068086581,
0.005891283,
0.0060870051,
0.0439541414,
0.0000648723,
-0.0336656533,
1.917641102e-34,
0.0252608545,
-0.0148354573,
0.0034306296,
-0.070272617,
0.0897056684,
-0.0156307686,
0.0168897845,
-0.0079899607,
0.0538263209,
-0.027885465,
-0.002466521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07445v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07445v2 | Think Before You Speak: Cultivating Communication Skills of Large Language Models via Inner Monologue | 2023-11-13T16:19:42 | 2024-03-15T08:30:30 | Junkai Zhou, Liang Pang, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The emergence of large language models (LLMs) further improves the
capabilities of open-domain dialogue systems and can generate fluent, coherent,
and diverse responses. However, LLMs still lack a crucial ability:
communication skills. This limitation renders them more like information
seeking tools rather than anthropomorphic chatbots. Communication skills, such
as topic transition, proactively asking questions, concept guidance, empathy,
and summarising often should be taken into consideration, to make LLMs more
anthropomorphic and proactive during the conversation, thereby increasing the
interest of users and attracting them to chat for longer. However, enabling
these communication skills in black-box LLMs remains a key challenge because
they do not have the same utterance formation mode as real people: think before
speaking. Inspired by linguistics and cognitive science, we empower LLMs with
communication skills through inner monologues. To evaluate various
communication skills, we construct a benchmark named Cskills, which can also
more comprehensively evaluate the dialogue generation ability of the model.
Experimental results show that the proposed CSIM strategy improves the backbone
models and outperforms the baselines. | [
0.0631202683,
0.0228645075,
-0.0335405692,
0.0194887575,
-0.0346123278,
-0.0056710015,
0.0163660292,
-0.0326493829,
0.0364369228,
-0.0153128877,
-0.0513523296,
-0.0359229632,
-0.0175359361,
0.0440933928,
0.0142006548,
-0.0680153295,
0.0240630861,
-0.0465272665,
0.0130027998,
-0.0064536422,
0.0133868279,
0.0099397115,
-0.0171485804,
0.0538149066,
-0.0105901267,
-0.0173264816,
-0.0387177989,
0.0268515479,
-0.0087633096,
-0.0354275443,
0.012241438,
0.0235626325,
0.0078451317,
0.024482986,
0.0000020331,
-0.0430372544,
0.0109285358,
-0.0391779356,
-0.0101915598,
-0.0152724907,
0.0273460411,
0.0379228629,
0.0081762038,
0.0446568877,
-0.0392018817,
0.0217654128,
0.0292216726,
0.0620400235,
0.0785487965,
0.0652642027,
-0.0096538831,
0.0197818317,
0.0179388952,
-0.0146501819,
-0.0270514339,
-0.0317463763,
-0.0172776431,
0.0304276329,
0.025042193,
-0.0056207543,
-0.0140132448,
0.0329191349,
0.0358279645,
-0.0635991171,
0.0165222455,
0.0201627556,
-0.0269520469,
-0.0532634147,
-0.0137717677,
0.086308375,
0.00874501,
0.0149514843,
0.0053374227,
0.0072058872,
0.0290000308,
-0.0468364097,
-0.0550553165,
0.0292723309,
-0.0044986638,
0.0049093459,
-0.0113836108,
0.0234628916,
-0.0007284353,
0.0222345721,
0.0026188423,
0.0184178278,
-0.0085546812,
-0.014029773,
0.0021236804,
-0.0043438915,
-0.0161756985,
-0.0932186395,
0.0108451191,
0.0673563182,
-0.0597660616,
0.0468330868,
-0.0242390707,
0.0237596519,
-0.0096282847,
-0.0512913056,
0.0206404552,
0.0366487391,
-0.0077024242,
0.0411866494,
0.0027247467,
0.0486242808,
0.0050071944,
0.0237105638,
-0.0265314505,
-0.0066362061,
-0.0240399484,
-0.0392352231,
-0.0516320094,
0.0384253673,
-0.0210582651,
-0.0465335809,
0.001685812,
0.0583894923,
0.0282041356,
-0.0124769555,
-0.0318696834,
0.0113419509,
-0.0002151987,
-0.0167714469,
-0.0399283133,
0.0218675639,
-0.0221126322,
-0.0302051511,
0.0571180545,
-0.0920316353,
0.0038383633,
0.0299945921,
-0.0344768502,
-0.0151652005,
-0.0142183062,
0.0473308228,
-0.0191977955,
-0.0068249404,
0.0107657816,
-0.0318869948,
-0.0218915623,
-0.0759966299,
-0.0025214157,
-0.0393256918,
0.0058874916,
0.0153187811,
-0.0106436694,
-0.0473345481,
0.0320427828,
0.0041885641,
0.0024291538,
0.0362086892,
-0.0318392105,
0.0329904705,
0.0523028336,
0.0351300873,
0.0191730503,
0.0608597547,
0.0283303317,
0.0163861811,
0.022808129,
0.0028164028,
0.0075758919,
0.0369058773,
-0.0060658036,
0.0055638785,
-0.0190106593,
0.0121032959,
-0.0045290724,
0.0415243469,
0.0234702602,
0.0791074634,
-0.0328959227,
0.0019607993,
0.0821285918,
0.0576541051,
-0.0159103405,
0.0199029855,
0.0361022279,
0.0358837843,
0.0305430572,
-0.0055735265,
0.0076393583,
0.0343803465,
0.0072660749,
-0.0047934591,
0.0430753157,
0.012374565,
-0.0401678681,
-0.0356234387,
-0.0017329125,
-0.0069568306,
0.0085943127,
0.018072024,
0.0107706217,
0.0264349226,
-0.0202197172,
0.0352748223,
0.0114241242,
-0.0542110279,
-0.0335594118,
-0.0618921965,
0.017767854,
0.0518781021,
0.0509495884,
0.0096476711,
-0.0735030547,
-0.0028521332,
-0.0054054051,
0.1073288545,
0.0636255443,
-0.030048443,
-0.0153902024,
-0.0358082689,
0.0180782788,
-0.0087754689,
-0.0140444851,
0.0278065559,
-0.0121845631,
0.0155596044,
0.016083315,
0.0100653926,
-0.0120814014,
0.0107881417,
-0.0614797883,
0.0272970032,
-0.0124663692,
-0.0146974502,
0.02709678,
0.0106737902,
-0.0046673263,
0.0039210767,
0.0010769087,
-0.0133039067,
-0.0334440619,
0.0770318359,
-0.0776290894,
-0.0174150076,
0.044694826,
0.0114158578,
0.0166525226,
0.0124311959,
0.0288568586,
-0.0376517065,
0.0253601391,
-0.0620074458,
0.0364503339,
-0.0214229207,
0.0521836244,
-0.020273827,
0.0093505243,
-0.0090802815,
0.0158083942,
0.0092027076,
-0.0080263624,
0.054273773,
0.0249912664,
0.0064134309,
-0.0626118556,
0.0060662571,
0.0369037464,
-0.0011585832,
0.0064070076,
0.0322038084,
0.0266494695,
-0.0696389377,
-0.038076628,
-0.1395786703,
-0.0082743764,
0.0040685534,
-0.0184716098,
0.0204736423,
0.0165971778,
-0.0155584626,
-0.0077636023,
-0.0792667866,
0.0384182259,
0.0327739753,
0.0115932347,
0.0359031372,
0.0006561893,
-0.0248670671,
-0.0444730446,
0.0308190361,
0.0043763868,
0.0363486372,
0.0106301671,
-0.0207868628,
-0.0433239639,
0.0340064391,
-0.0426593684,
0.0095604975,
-0.0294340253,
-0.0622280985,
0.0377710015,
-0.0077373204,
0.0641430095,
0.0736394599,
0.0689682811,
0.02686272,
0.0169109423,
-0.0263816733,
-0.0695721656,
0.0343877263,
0.0111982487,
0.0027211402,
-0.0703868344,
-0.016017003,
0.0218653008,
0.0570899546,
-0.008415726,
0.0352933072,
-0.0483551845,
0.0391157828,
0.0103093581,
-0.0671178475,
-0.0122363456,
-0.0105723292,
-0.0386808217,
0.0611234233,
-0.0138190361,
-0.0199920014,
0.0459153391,
-0.0255872142,
-0.0208443869,
-0.0128504615,
-0.0115654077,
-0.0485210419,
0.0798991323,
-0.0156669654,
0.0270774178,
0.0355215594,
-0.0305482745,
-0.0560434945,
-0.014376835,
-0.0025961008,
-0.0353835188,
-0.0038406649,
-0.0147356559,
-0.0162135083,
0.0199405793,
-0.0501387119,
-0.0600904748,
-0.0127967279,
-0.0426311456,
0.0107344901,
0.0455733947,
-0.0331710614,
-0.0346274748,
0.0270672273,
0.0437773876,
0.029418394,
-0.0379583277,
-0.0064557767,
-0.0060814377,
0.0121201202,
0.0582247376,
0.0226661619,
0.0232416261,
-0.0655399486,
0.1163297147,
0.0443007573,
0.0036045536,
-0.0028268397,
-0.0157517493,
-0.0324453488,
0.0268697795,
-0.0049109901,
-0.025361618,
-0.0019965309,
0.0923811346,
-0.0330689214,
-0.0406327434,
0.1463609636,
0.0132038044,
-0.0405380763,
0.0098319156,
-0.0606141537,
0.0398012474,
0.0240652245,
0.0344839059,
-0.0253411345,
-0.0162207913,
0.0076347725,
0.0025045907,
-0.0364467613,
-0.0372660272,
-0.0182276014,
-0.1245935485,
0.0239763595,
0.0004442018,
-0.0395902395,
0.0132401567,
-0.002102924,
0.0062990594,
0.0179662555,
0.0153652439,
0.0240401477,
0.0010464204,
-0.0269448403,
0.0042655491,
-0.0509693474,
0.0085922517,
0.0118579296,
-0.0336292088,
0.0815910622,
0.0418761708,
0.0558779947,
0.02584913,
0.0440905839,
0.0377943069,
0.0181687642,
0.0105649531,
0.0083074337,
0.04134956,
-0.0166983753,
-0.0133334082,
-0.0371914692,
0.0167856365,
-0.0004160703,
-0.0068236175,
0.0086115859,
0.0294591784,
-0.0342467539,
-0.0151319588,
-0.0209145602,
0.0538243391,
0.0083374241,
0.0656897575,
0.0437791497,
-0.0789991394,
-0.0252883844,
-0.0171979573,
-0.0399287902,
-0.0080054021,
-0.0711475313,
-0.0130747315,
0.0270938966,
-0.0285251774,
-0.0833766237,
-0.0466433689,
0.0165611282,
0.0342491977,
0.0106051732,
-0.0120168561,
-0.0134931887,
0.0315286815,
-0.0040429924,
0.0057419031,
-0.040153455,
0.0073691024,
-0.088044107,
0.0034932746,
0.0497073568,
-0.0737543851,
-0.0065197423,
0.0221681744,
-0.0340751186,
-0.0763013363,
-0.032256566,
0.02088999,
0.0213162638,
0.0274272133,
-0.0295085721,
-0.0617300011,
0.0237188488,
0.046554938,
-0.0517952815,
0.0001719023,
0.0208933726,
0.0344118737,
-0.0024876709,
0.0408051461,
-0.0337258317,
0.0138528319,
-0.0144290542,
0.0418004207,
-0.0110201184,
-0.0939911231,
0.0123892631,
0.039551679,
-0.0182534289,
0.0180834234,
0.0271689463,
-0.018105831,
-0.014523196,
-0.0381621793,
-0.0252936557,
-0.0471986942,
0.0202732608,
0.0083591901,
0.0150038283,
0.0316235311,
-0.0106268516,
-0.0360260196,
0.0417395756,
0.026548693,
-0.0103695141,
-0.0108961742,
0.0113385906,
0.0116746956,
-0.0250776187,
-0.02489773,
-0.0000552636,
-0.009667255,
0.0181217175,
0.0130858049,
0.091763556,
0.0011439277,
-0.0585057065,
0.0423833318,
0.0463347621,
-0.0613074861,
-0.0972308293,
0.0109119918,
0.0367333218,
0.0433343463,
0.0378553495,
0.0569438376,
-0.068724215,
0.0162281301,
-0.0156230368,
0.0314242728,
-0.0030573076,
-0.050930813,
0.030012941,
0.0178072117,
-0.0100962976,
0.0007213562,
0.028630916,
-0.007257896,
0.0120505122,
0.019887099,
0.0023764146,
-0.0387513712,
-0.0184631776,
0.0001129776,
0.0179060809,
-0.0021582767,
0.0316472501,
-0.0434112996,
-0.0452081971,
0.0003811009,
0.0039187395,
-0.004450724,
-0.0235437807,
0.0319831334,
0.0354208089,
-0.0024386875,
-0.0076941913,
-0.0567157306,
0.0087868329,
-0.0412665084,
-0.0025219782,
-0.0117950942,
-6.371499704e-33,
-0.035220433,
-0.0243702903,
0.0190811865,
0.0177818015,
-0.0857750028,
-0.0479547344,
-0.0681999028,
0.0425286777,
-0.0005654612,
-0.0012467135,
-0.0261682291,
0.0358407497,
-0.0011005086,
0.0106726494,
-0.0031360236,
0.0030375579,
0.0492728837,
0.0039191139,
-0.019183293,
0.0540756509,
0.0082626436,
0.021022439,
-0.0007848855,
-0.0451448299,
-0.0019729941,
-0.0103588551,
0.0089150649,
0.0335249752,
0.0182389338,
0.0545590594,
-0.0083181662,
0.0206669476,
0.0181734674,
-0.0127920303,
-0.0294802487,
0.0145572955,
0.0014055459,
0.0055855303,
0.0394385718,
0.0154603133,
-0.0446221419,
-0.0523838997,
-0.0039981562,
-0.0252016895,
0.0169070065,
-0.0082677901,
0.0118285092,
-0.0362710953,
0.0173599031,
0.0128618851,
-0.0639358908,
0.0224550571,
-0.0326104909,
-0.0775125176,
-0.0189008191,
0.0728065148,
-0.0172604229,
-0.0260176677,
0.0294997003,
0.0589326173,
0.0101656616,
0.0106060272,
0.0516609997,
0.0475993343,
0.0269166045,
0.0750786737,
0.0251114294,
0.0433690622,
-0.0057421988,
-0.0105033256,
0.013393282,
0.0410483889,
0.0266180951,
0.0370991975,
-0.0130752278,
0.0086436439,
-0.0226182062,
-0.0081979958,
0.0400778092,
0.0197174475,
0.0518562756,
-0.0018851651,
-0.0323801637,
-0.0084065096,
-0.041713804,
-0.0290598031,
-0.0179521553,
-0.0691347644,
0.0293473378,
0.0044739055,
0.0060136011,
-0.0503550246,
0.0348177589,
-0.0140672605,
0.0102115953,
0.0257439502,
-0.0509234592,
0.0522914194,
-0.0228447877,
0.0198548511,
-0.0475258641,
-0.0183529481,
0.0237204898,
0.0276577063,
0.0148287388,
0.0484095961,
-0.0250509996,
0.0070764748,
-0.0434012823,
-0.0280445609,
-0.03711804,
0.039101664,
-0.0418798812,
0.0078528589,
-0.0049571586,
-0.017685581,
-0.057615187,
0.0726002455,
-0.0189620499,
-0.0331756435,
-0.0636926591,
-0.0209232084,
0.0089271413,
-0.0063268766,
-0.0374561138,
0.0098934621,
-0.0480832867,
0.0210183375,
0.0283517446,
-0.0571735539,
-0.0261536203,
-0.0188369881,
2.858e-7,
-0.0390212648,
0.022944184,
0.0056460691,
0.0498534888,
0.0353059135,
0.0363715738,
-0.0102586504,
0.0115789762,
0.0357367583,
-0.0310535692,
-0.0123478649,
0.0527790114,
0.080045782,
0.0103459023,
-0.1240528449,
-0.0047403779,
-0.0751073435,
-0.0301684327,
-0.0369239338,
-0.0209176075,
0.0317594111,
0.043883346,
-0.0054191393,
-0.0182733219,
-0.0010591561,
-0.021163607,
0.0533916391,
-0.0480224192,
-0.0294254962,
0.041900415,
0.0263248272,
0.0348014794,
0.0069472557,
-0.014965646,
0.0265209805,
0.0156251043,
0.0012427566,
0.0520452596,
0.0210239999,
-0.0512669645,
0.0317489877,
0.0362742878,
-0.0132178208,
-0.0296242889,
0.0368115976,
-0.0733375102,
-0.0483456887,
-0.0485667773,
0.022628203,
-0.0445409641,
-0.0083355634,
-0.0611094385,
-0.0335770883,
0.0265691355,
-0.0050291815,
-0.0289678108,
0.0306607224,
-0.0398824327,
-0.0069984463,
-0.0189181119,
-0.0494763516,
-0.0908844694,
-0.0478853136,
0.005613442,
-0.014062359,
-0.0148421768,
0.0230870098,
2.359926132e-34,
0.029714115,
-0.0036793426,
0.0186472479,
0.0573081337,
0.0529334918,
-0.0011296212,
0.0296801552,
0.0000091747,
0.0491237827,
-0.0632412434,
-0.0281810891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07439v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07439v3 | Investigating Multi-Pivot Ensembling with Massively Multilingual Machine Translation Models | 2023-11-13T16:15:20 | 2024-04-28T08:26:11 | Alireza Mohammadshahi, Jannis Vamvas, Rico Sennrich | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Massively multilingual machine translation models allow for the translation
of a large number of languages with a single model, but have limited
performance on low- and very-low-resource translation directions. Pivoting via
high-resource languages remains a strong strategy for low-resource directions,
and in this paper we revisit ways of pivoting through multiple languages.
Previous work has used a simple averaging of probability distributions from
multiple paths, but we find that this performs worse than using a single pivot,
and exacerbates the hallucination problem because the same hallucinations can
be probable across different paths. We also propose MaxEns, a novel combination
strategy that makes the output biased towards the most confident predictions,
hypothesising that confident predictions are less prone to be hallucinations.
We evaluate different strategies on the FLORES benchmark for 20 low-resource
language directions, demonstrating that MaxEns improves translation quality for
low-resource languages while reducing hallucination in translations, compared
to both direct translation and an averaging approach. On average, multi-pivot
strategies still lag behind using English as a single pivot language, raising
the question of how to identify the best pivoting strategy for a given
translation direction. | [
-0.0198421404,
0.0129657649,
-0.0043596723,
0.0423175618,
-0.0576752424,
0.0235482957,
-0.008392754,
-0.0012922888,
-0.0514684282,
-0.0125531824,
-0.0249990188,
-0.0561269075,
0.0514933318,
-0.039345134,
0.0438914225,
-0.0640173852,
0.0241048764,
-0.0472528487,
-0.0783979222,
-0.0054829628,
-0.0296040569,
0.0097251618,
0.0199663416,
0.0399721451,
0.0075079389,
-0.0171239711,
-0.0106411902,
0.0599149093,
0.044160828,
0.0085246023,
-0.0409898162,
0.0469579063,
-0.0123288548,
0.0919816718,
0.0000023568,
-0.0199926663,
-0.0438767597,
-0.0081615131,
0.035778936,
0.0117740491,
0.0464885645,
-0.0654083118,
-0.0120818038,
0.0077174264,
-0.0023573807,
0.0184027608,
0.0415347107,
0.0013010486,
0.0298028421,
0.0584984384,
-0.0141551914,
-0.0651752651,
-0.0037565795,
-0.0191059168,
0.0050530341,
-0.0182885658,
-0.0028551167,
-0.019204136,
-0.0687280223,
-0.0377318822,
-0.0167702455,
0.0295234229,
0.033290606,
0.0001610558,
-0.0337074772,
0.0112265674,
-0.0403487869,
-0.0411108062,
0.0029739246,
0.0472169518,
-0.1105634421,
-0.0254890677,
-0.0173163731,
-0.0118775396,
0.0047124415,
-0.0197470002,
-0.0380897932,
0.0375086889,
-0.015334568,
0.0010143025,
0.0469995998,
0.0426670052,
0.041536402,
0.005689926,
-0.0858953148,
-0.0058932714,
0.0337426029,
-0.0220307838,
0.032400582,
0.0447645001,
0.0192128941,
-0.0135604003,
0.0322943181,
-0.0543088391,
-0.0393993855,
-0.0046587321,
-0.0110651739,
-0.0093960715,
0.0206847787,
-0.0845953822,
0.0120374653,
0.0381531119,
-0.020628782,
0.0349127129,
0.0112431971,
0.0184021667,
-0.0568391792,
0.0228915866,
-0.0801676214,
-0.0106903752,
-0.0005285263,
0.0416273735,
-0.0260596275,
-0.0346881486,
-0.0800994411,
-0.0150229065,
-0.0563838035,
0.0045145676,
0.0093190195,
-0.0111189457,
-0.0041805883,
-0.0069776797,
-0.0268821828,
-0.0495794602,
0.0372254364,
0.093145974,
0.0031971207,
-0.0379258581,
0.0190591272,
-0.052237682,
-0.0270623527,
0.039476227,
-0.0682141557,
-0.0412040837,
-0.0014050738,
0.0509711727,
0.0033696413,
-0.0106603382,
0.0074848509,
-0.0242512766,
-0.0242080633,
-0.0705523416,
0.0305675678,
-0.0659531802,
0.0799669996,
0.0155151952,
0.02303968,
-0.0113362093,
-0.0004392733,
-0.014459054,
-0.0324736908,
0.0639719144,
0.0374772511,
0.0181803945,
0.0300452728,
0.0039669527,
-0.0239934642,
0.0949325413,
-0.0004673942,
0.0577622131,
0.0168502033,
-0.0087629911,
0.024548104,
0.0539210327,
-0.0277625266,
0.055060301,
-0.0138558401,
0.0046926769,
0.0516763739,
0.0151743582,
0.0107956398,
0.0519702286,
-0.0436961614,
0.0208068863,
0.0547980852,
-0.0124203973,
-0.0251159631,
0.0078626592,
-0.0014529221,
-0.0071587237,
-0.0117830709,
0.0198637377,
-0.0336084664,
0.0319089368,
-0.0167879816,
-0.0120386239,
0.087403588,
0.0701014996,
0.0047009229,
-0.0199442413,
0.0199316051,
-0.0110319331,
-0.026483139,
0.0147676272,
0.0464143306,
-0.0130706588,
-0.0756192133,
0.040492814,
0.0261501968,
-0.0325534828,
-0.0044854255,
0.0062897881,
-0.0948342904,
0.0829679221,
0.0309521388,
0.0426355675,
-0.0116694905,
-0.0147173461,
0.0068798875,
0.0531018786,
0.0317870043,
0.0136666838,
0.0464968421,
-0.0461415797,
-0.017403109,
0.0654991642,
0.0215905197,
0.0489404164,
-0.0403949991,
0.0249415394,
0.0025855838,
-0.022666689,
-0.0454388745,
0.0164838955,
-0.004954325,
0.0321914181,
-0.0011494396,
-0.0042061079,
0.0225765165,
0.0086559923,
-0.0259961449,
0.0148998555,
0.0225453898,
-0.0342791453,
-0.0298617929,
0.0443299972,
-0.0163695626,
-0.0129425181,
0.0246751979,
-0.0379002169,
-0.0231667701,
-0.039937079,
-0.0127706099,
-0.0401198715,
-0.0110269431,
-0.0274532661,
-0.0211125016,
-0.0164999962,
0.0775072426,
-0.0155832339,
0.0305744056,
-0.0379827507,
0.0545961894,
-0.0088534402,
0.0425563715,
0.009455977,
-0.0462218523,
0.015060571,
-0.0557517745,
-0.0091034146,
0.0648906603,
0.0433214046,
0.0075603658,
-0.0002953731,
-0.0266883206,
-0.0389130972,
-0.0415515937,
-0.0733347312,
0.0146651398,
-0.0160019454,
0.0211553182,
0.0258699004,
-0.0000792997,
0.0143534672,
0.0022738271,
0.0175585467,
-0.0161815174,
0.0096050352,
0.0478243642,
-0.0176875945,
-0.0279779937,
-0.0133994389,
0.0138002299,
-0.002329187,
0.0231248848,
0.0587059818,
0.0013640643,
-0.0485511497,
-0.0835781321,
-0.0181528628,
-0.0245386083,
-0.0395972468,
0.0005521995,
-0.0328071676,
-0.0186825916,
-0.0149963358,
0.0484282523,
0.0178134013,
-0.0087652467,
-0.0345050097,
0.0612464622,
-0.042921979,
-0.0154071627,
-0.0172408484,
0.0096978443,
-0.012154757,
-0.039696265,
-0.0745518059,
0.011710274,
-0.0018972424,
0.020890886,
0.0290269777,
-0.0554944687,
-0.0234659798,
-0.0239182692,
-0.0176637899,
0.0082486561,
0.0044979085,
0.0223431513,
0.0646466911,
-0.0190529134,
-0.0204237029,
0.0422974527,
-0.0209937636,
-0.0359163955,
-0.0417296663,
0.0275896601,
0.0154735455,
0.0377057083,
-0.0002644692,
0.0358921178,
-0.043358501,
0.0228740294,
-0.0336078219,
0.017695114,
0.0140508162,
-0.0476504527,
0.0405984931,
-0.040030174,
-0.0026565986,
-0.0053703575,
-0.0445412509,
-0.0079139573,
-0.0085645877,
0.0029265897,
-0.031481497,
0.0058830786,
-0.0038421073,
-0.0739137009,
0.017238928,
0.02585187,
0.0363266766,
0.0024844755,
-0.0212333351,
0.0130613735,
-0.0056133652,
0.0136080338,
-0.038969636,
0.0325872079,
-0.0882298201,
0.0194741134,
0.0459214076,
0.020330444,
-0.0041412129,
0.0213311445,
-0.0381186344,
0.0396627039,
0.0073759099,
-0.0549384505,
-0.0139867747,
0.0126920212,
-0.0276593361,
0.0062857694,
0.0993241221,
0.0291464664,
-0.0618130155,
0.0020435834,
-0.0064680916,
0.049288854,
-0.0154966814,
0.0232366677,
-0.0599376932,
-0.014476059,
0.0035474228,
0.0186578538,
0.0410792902,
0.025255641,
0.018432714,
-0.1060363874,
0.0480675511,
0.0651181415,
-0.0590455048,
-0.0914861336,
-0.0288703125,
-0.0452164151,
-0.0292785931,
0.0576014593,
0.0132796522,
0.0511062257,
-0.0242827293,
-0.0030766493,
0.0166658107,
-0.025813831,
-0.0157527272,
-0.0422383025,
-0.0106742671,
0.0257560387,
0.0333103277,
0.0051092268,
-0.0652924478,
0.0295526013,
-0.01117134,
-0.0133339036,
0.0016887871,
0.0476154499,
0.0503328517,
0.0059160343,
0.0247400943,
-0.0287457816,
-0.0457344167,
-0.0086263642,
0.0089545222,
0.0482358001,
-0.0380813256,
-0.043274723,
0.0276311487,
-0.0140595175,
0.0150193805,
0.0525744185,
-0.0165839978,
-0.0324699096,
-0.0169658959,
-0.066846922,
0.0211693756,
-0.0372531898,
-0.0046890229,
0.0292137451,
-0.0224233009,
-0.0690893829,
-0.072657533,
-0.0194346216,
0.0011976368,
0.0572794676,
0.0155411167,
0.0369057916,
-0.0089629441,
-0.0119838463,
-0.0000507623,
-0.0018212087,
-0.0246942528,
0.0281212144,
-0.0117487023,
0.0157960448,
0.0302804876,
0.0129575413,
0.013449843,
0.0532647222,
-0.0621203035,
-0.0979505479,
-0.0018590015,
0.0085076243,
0.0292955451,
0.0386282951,
-0.0082382914,
-0.0113792019,
0.0154851759,
0.0212662499,
0.0355388038,
-0.0041841893,
0.0207743794,
0.0108320946,
-0.0149673615,
0.0448914729,
-0.0010259517,
-0.0231012851,
-0.0288348738,
0.025897989,
-0.0504861772,
-0.0373882279,
0.0017929379,
0.0171138588,
0.0274411589,
-0.0704448596,
-0.0392684452,
0.0005864443,
0.0028808529,
-0.0361506008,
-0.0465514138,
-0.0164643228,
-0.015491941,
0.0936073363,
-0.0123795355,
0.0334644318,
0.0335968062,
0.0014565927,
-0.1062034592,
-0.0273835119,
-0.0433051512,
-0.0200182609,
0.0245632604,
0.0487224236,
0.000349242,
-0.000988254,
-0.0011529326,
-0.0044884454,
0.0325840712,
-0.0157916211,
0.0186437033,
0.0167909842,
0.0035022069,
-0.015497813,
0.0192573238,
-0.0167989824,
-0.0450076014,
-0.0272649787,
0.0271507986,
0.0901834667,
0.0239431243,
0.1502727419,
-0.0137429815,
-0.0070828092,
-0.0115177361,
0.0302103255,
0.0589956567,
-0.0161613412,
-0.0400977805,
-0.0203831382,
-0.0190594494,
-0.0038330264,
0.0673028305,
-0.0342494547,
0.0025570774,
0.0068123364,
-0.0307011418,
-0.0114468234,
-0.0452838354,
-0.0579106472,
-0.0151542779,
0.0002581342,
0.0000635147,
-0.042789381,
-0.0368111171,
-0.0062362999,
0.0186662097,
0.0165911783,
-0.0097549977,
0.0040231189,
0.0859515741,
-0.026393082,
0.0207701009,
-0.0215152763,
-0.0115827257,
0.0323194861,
-0.0206974261,
-0.0262485947,
-6.832910624e-33,
0.0241046008,
-0.0115204798,
-0.022176804,
-0.0392836072,
-0.0092719365,
-0.0523108467,
-0.0195247699,
0.0013483498,
0.0175931659,
0.0054607308,
0.0083395839,
0.010498723,
0.0349140167,
0.0077884845,
0.0337674953,
0.0190748703,
0.0351476856,
0.0143193984,
-0.0435378477,
0.0104192961,
0.0250716899,
0.0023469671,
0.0753940791,
-0.056906078,
0.0241776109,
-0.0346398093,
-0.0321881399,
0.0186943021,
0.0050533344,
-0.0169470031,
0.0122275418,
0.0034821157,
-0.0024558853,
-0.0506078303,
-0.0255169943,
-0.0532515347,
0.0124322269,
0.0155808209,
0.0111004664,
0.0589717999,
0.0076169949,
-0.0388524607,
0.0399797633,
-0.0128892194,
0.0039145011,
-0.0062655415,
-0.0030734849,
-0.043420516,
-0.0534209982,
0.039353136,
-0.0341330618,
0.0199502874,
0.0096336165,
-0.0085939923,
0.0173552372,
0.0622842908,
-0.0042244419,
-0.0308781583,
-0.0854795054,
0.0176819526,
-0.0184752177,
0.0190048907,
0.0825286731,
0.0133179501,
-0.0039080153,
0.0442898609,
0.0571556613,
0.0153694702,
0.0160316862,
0.0070706303,
0.0000103432,
-0.0024070926,
0.0477731004,
0.0365703478,
0.0591411814,
0.0030496779,
-0.0330015868,
0.0449578539,
-0.0013088887,
-0.045699846,
0.080257684,
0.0315553509,
-0.0397089012,
-0.0515606143,
0.0001048482,
-0.0389539599,
-0.0192556009,
-0.0005243656,
-0.0122792404,
0.0060894038,
-0.0007111199,
0.0280338805,
0.0751043484,
-0.0087400395,
-0.0044070072,
0.0468847565,
-0.0367324799,
0.0369036533,
-0.0167408455,
0.0349407829,
0.0378256813,
-0.0519547015,
0.0154860998,
0.0290181488,
0.000206198,
-0.0146824922,
0.0414414853,
-0.0160005707,
-0.0605850704,
0.0244862549,
-0.042436935,
-0.0156888533,
0.0139810322,
0.0157130025,
0.0411163531,
-0.009106434,
-0.0069212471,
-0.0219883341,
0.0423348509,
0.0241059139,
-0.0021409965,
0.0350511484,
-0.0066510132,
0.0040407162,
-0.0284590945,
0.0356440954,
-0.0283660181,
-0.0321140438,
0.062083751,
-0.0433870144,
-0.0605016612,
-0.004196296,
3.053e-7,
0.0523237064,
0.058751598,
-0.0143396882,
0.0268559791,
0.0117859365,
0.0206862446,
-0.0159429777,
-0.0002516335,
0.0379277319,
0.0215902813,
-0.0036837922,
0.0337730199,
0.097947441,
0.0623692721,
-0.0756262243,
-0.0652294531,
-0.0099293999,
0.0377915874,
-0.0568060577,
-0.004032841,
0.0109670069,
0.1082495004,
-0.0101484908,
-0.0350727923,
0.0092680799,
-0.0442070737,
0.0767861754,
-0.0103999209,
-0.0133080976,
0.0123996548,
-0.0251897573,
0.0214116257,
-0.0360810719,
0.0251684114,
-0.0061839512,
-0.0146661857,
0.0535468012,
0.0357622765,
-0.0318199769,
-0.0283822175,
0.0089984769,
-0.0192865711,
-0.0143232262,
-0.052822534,
0.0321870334,
-0.0244902186,
-0.0137496805,
0.0340475403,
-0.0312579684,
0.0211726576,
0.0961595401,
0.0052290163,
-0.0468341373,
0.0490624681,
0.0293124057,
0.0231629517,
-0.0108388113,
-0.001691864,
-0.0560207851,
0.0184136145,
-0.0032637431,
-0.0343255438,
0.0042424146,
-0.0215301327,
-0.0017420718,
-0.0279323068,
-0.0065635736,
2.902172493e-34,
0.0608699471,
0.0020204568,
0.0297077298,
-0.03066043,
0.0356992148,
-0.0424502082,
0.0232903268,
0.0051571429,
-0.0375734568,
-0.0364941508,
-0.0174962748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07430v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07430v2 | Controlled Text Generation for Black-box Language Models via Score-based Progressive Editor | 2023-11-13T16:03:23 | 2024-06-08T04:35:07 | Sangwon Yu, Changmin Lee, Hojin Lee, Sungroh Yoon | cs.CL | cs.CL | Controlled text generation is very important for the practical use of
language models because it ensures that the produced text includes only the
desired attributes from a specific domain or dataset. Existing methods,
however, are inapplicable to black-box models or suffer a significant trade-off
between controlling the generated text and maintaining its fluency. This paper
introduces the Score-based Progressive Editor (ScoPE), a novel approach
designed to overcome these issues. ScoPE modifies the context at the token
level during the generation process of a backbone language model. This
modification guides the subsequent text to naturally include the target
attributes. To facilitate this process, ScoPE employs a training objective that
maximizes a target score, thoroughly considering both the ability to guide the
text and its fluency. Experimental results on diverse controlled generation
tasks demonstrate that ScoPE can effectively regulate the attributes of the
generated text while fully utilizing the capability of the backbone large
language models. Our codes are available at
\url{https://github.com/ysw1021/ScoPE}. | [
0.0338191055,
0.0663880408,
-0.0077670622,
-0.0079829544,
-0.0365497842,
0.0029099451,
0.0286406148,
0.0089368727,
-0.040438503,
-0.0474379025,
-0.016028963,
0.0043428279,
-0.0134418644,
0.077810064,
0.0579426438,
-0.0605554618,
0.047246065,
-0.0080970675,
-0.0175522752,
0.0008546953,
0.0090001849,
0.0165603254,
0.0287097916,
0.0540740378,
-0.0138575379,
-0.0059850276,
-0.0038529083,
0.0117881028,
-0.0033768595,
0.0116668632,
-0.0004086593,
0.0685329959,
-0.0201515742,
0.0181285199,
0.0000019583,
-0.0214204527,
-0.0672475472,
0.0050912187,
-0.0111919865,
-0.0208072942,
0.0505030751,
0.0306611247,
-0.0304162558,
0.0258447733,
-0.0276953485,
-0.02211022,
0.0623829141,
0.0384516381,
0.0669715926,
0.0610892028,
-0.0162397735,
-0.0032045012,
0.0018116154,
-0.0375350751,
-0.0160708968,
-0.0050407122,
0.0064899679,
0.0092184562,
-0.001444367,
0.0279310681,
-0.0118070636,
0.0327887274,
0.044584915,
-0.0340361297,
0.0442121401,
0.0472951494,
-0.0345872641,
-0.0431430638,
0.0076568769,
0.0388966873,
-0.0289745741,
-0.0383887887,
0.0130563006,
-0.0148036052,
0.0084109586,
-0.0326446593,
-0.0513325036,
0.0269000456,
0.0001732381,
0.0036720214,
-0.0130153177,
-0.0301599335,
0.0172080994,
0.0040344028,
-0.0056886096,
0.0293317474,
0.0444402769,
-0.033311896,
-0.022783922,
0.0000222072,
-0.0525828563,
-0.0861130208,
0.0014098971,
0.022210123,
-0.0377471,
0.0373916589,
-0.0862519145,
-0.0410861373,
0.0211353358,
-0.0219043624,
0.0236534867,
0.0043062228,
-0.0027742474,
0.0250455588,
-0.0458410084,
0.0575421564,
0.013655928,
0.0011571505,
-0.0171773303,
0.0019910098,
-0.0413306132,
-0.0417985693,
-0.0548146516,
0.036505267,
-0.0282444879,
-0.0138936127,
-0.038488619,
0.0182147566,
0.0147428466,
0.0248654056,
0.0274122301,
-0.0168858077,
-0.0620601922,
-0.009187066,
0.0401917472,
-0.0161422063,
-0.0318181068,
-0.0108143818,
0.0227403473,
-0.0296572056,
-0.0031948057,
0.0408715568,
0.006503263,
-0.0328592807,
-0.0133475065,
0.0401525497,
-0.0251201093,
-0.0043748897,
0.0113312406,
-0.0741941556,
-0.0233644899,
-0.0495949797,
-0.0273427907,
-0.0550359078,
-0.0128189465,
0.0199215133,
-0.019441843,
-0.091530025,
0.0239035543,
0.0263791084,
0.0045342483,
0.0215726085,
-0.0345811211,
-0.0143627534,
0.0130374003,
0.0033505259,
0.0215876885,
0.0630822554,
0.0287763085,
0.0561900437,
0.0360978208,
0.0066067716,
-0.0073473682,
0.0619843602,
0.0483181141,
0.0184667166,
-0.0798927099,
-0.0151677588,
0.0634370968,
0.0056947595,
0.0003031928,
0.044495102,
-0.0272531789,
0.0181641914,
0.0566462167,
0.0080391327,
0.0256986804,
0.0350986421,
0.0845651552,
-0.0068046539,
-0.0028282029,
0.0172979981,
-0.0120312525,
-0.0168915708,
-0.0151666552,
0.0264861472,
0.0090786843,
0.0289802272,
-0.005654058,
-0.0485220626,
0.0011757688,
-0.0068721347,
-0.0152641973,
-0.0206117965,
0.0427422039,
0.0459146127,
-0.056053292,
0.0277332813,
0.0331542268,
-0.0514560528,
0.0379454345,
-0.0537173189,
0.0072736884,
0.0371616147,
0.0799908862,
0.0103267329,
-0.0506999083,
-0.0141150281,
0.0170444865,
0.0778636783,
0.0388620049,
-0.0204860009,
-0.0230245534,
-0.0536858439,
-0.0587197356,
-0.0294713024,
0.0057074581,
0.0183614381,
0.0155423908,
-0.0161415935,
0.0327607878,
-0.0187781639,
-0.0807443112,
0.0460002236,
-0.0642123744,
-0.0127725331,
0.0104438914,
-0.0084062619,
-0.0126004871,
-0.0048196684,
-0.0297144298,
-0.0004310203,
-0.0005395717,
-0.0245892908,
-0.034763284,
0.0341985859,
-0.0347335935,
-0.0152933132,
0.0131460829,
-0.0063570552,
0.0045611556,
-0.0108225644,
-0.0255256463,
-0.0683889985,
-0.0182318706,
-0.0552261882,
-0.0012569537,
-0.0322910659,
0.0486244373,
-0.0186624136,
-0.0086665843,
-0.0631110519,
0.0524337925,
-0.0005982966,
0.0026937532,
0.0351322405,
0.0315746069,
0.0001892691,
-0.0216022581,
-0.0042941999,
0.0182078239,
0.0058490424,
-0.0239107758,
0.0665529668,
0.0369941704,
-0.0125336507,
-0.0364840776,
-0.0698621795,
0.0117569799,
-0.0380765423,
0.00053085,
0.0356046706,
0.044767715,
-0.0159611907,
-0.0065884707,
-0.0326169282,
-0.0183197614,
0.0182521213,
0.0018793454,
0.0301966015,
0.0247128159,
-0.0235819183,
-0.0399946235,
-0.0099345772,
0.004298131,
0.0555787981,
0.0535035394,
-0.0106479321,
-0.0525915585,
0.0439804457,
-0.024286937,
0.0227602795,
0.030883342,
-0.0320829414,
-0.0063629854,
-0.0169922858,
0.0755376741,
0.0432886295,
0.0234692786,
0.0403363779,
0.0410132185,
0.0160968136,
-0.0435757972,
0.0039707101,
-0.0443502329,
0.0194867309,
-0.022184493,
-0.0438508987,
0.045017004,
0.1023274139,
0.0144436713,
0.0058807465,
-0.0741667747,
0.0362725109,
-0.0242927317,
-0.0434045084,
-0.0026344061,
0.0083356574,
-0.0210225228,
0.0160478316,
-0.0390340835,
-0.0548858382,
0.080793567,
-0.0330955759,
-0.000639723,
-0.0382958986,
0.0194996856,
-0.0382155478,
0.0379725657,
0.0204945225,
0.0280918907,
0.0303681549,
-0.0271674246,
-0.0649931729,
-0.0010366366,
0.0185081959,
-0.0126073444,
-0.0004744323,
-0.0505612493,
-0.0053783176,
-0.004777716,
-0.0300063305,
-0.0484358966,
-0.0256721508,
0.003104791,
0.0337567329,
0.0235365406,
-0.0243320297,
-0.0342156701,
-0.0006795607,
0.0302487686,
0.0625369772,
-0.060177885,
0.0032374407,
-0.0348186269,
0.0143132647,
0.0846858472,
-0.0392708406,
-0.015163295,
-0.0526924245,
0.0257513747,
0.0320325755,
0.0155207878,
0.0168527011,
0.0149149671,
-0.0180504415,
0.029849939,
-0.0564036407,
-0.0508833341,
0.0066338242,
0.0391486138,
-0.0594702438,
-0.0542132482,
0.1353813857,
0.0395681076,
-0.0082207685,
0.0038752339,
-0.0348765925,
0.077052027,
0.0229297355,
0.0477201566,
-0.0543533489,
-0.018464053,
0.0223423243,
0.0512401387,
-0.0104525918,
-0.0050209919,
-0.0290165972,
-0.109715566,
0.0300995409,
0.0049125482,
-0.0021628079,
-0.0058549801,
-0.0055057388,
-0.0080170501,
-0.0033930566,
0.0081609404,
0.0246741995,
0.0025977136,
0.0236752424,
0.0415180326,
0.0126533099,
-0.0390528068,
-0.0363385081,
-0.0239113197,
0.0403478071,
0.1098553911,
0.0213728808,
-0.0020593617,
0.0226372108,
0.0397944376,
0.0203306992,
0.0085158218,
-0.0180272758,
0.0361905582,
-0.0055461442,
-0.0245425608,
0.0125323199,
0.033077769,
0.0472273417,
-0.0089040399,
0.0146217942,
0.0584677532,
-0.0157010444,
-0.0013498497,
-0.0062993062,
-0.0297602732,
0.0207551867,
0.0526008755,
0.0623901561,
-0.0722151473,
-0.0479255803,
-0.037032593,
-0.0085741682,
-0.081232883,
-0.0367582552,
-0.0038966597,
-0.0268010832,
-0.0462649167,
-0.0784289092,
-0.0406035185,
0.0489919223,
0.0660456568,
0.0249248184,
0.0064100558,
-0.0116776843,
-0.0519318767,
-0.0544149093,
-0.0156173715,
-0.0495764129,
-0.0033612887,
-0.094048284,
-0.0418546386,
0.039907407,
-0.062459249,
-0.0227997787,
0.0061681592,
-0.0246519521,
-0.0548895225,
0.0141677316,
0.0674779266,
0.0214708205,
0.0635188669,
-0.0209374465,
-0.0769717321,
0.0391562618,
0.0457135737,
-0.0265176818,
0.0044741691,
0.0195081495,
-0.0373460352,
-0.0088096587,
0.0364327431,
-0.056510631,
0.038166713,
0.0457894392,
0.0483305492,
0.0257865191,
0.0175405554,
0.0344243757,
0.0120739676,
0.0036859079,
-0.0535024293,
-0.0133574679,
-0.0392641611,
0.0213067271,
-0.0446465127,
-0.0356398374,
-0.0569129847,
0.0580644198,
-0.0176136624,
0.0093594762,
0.0117378961,
0.0215496551,
-0.0539836548,
0.0773983374,
-0.0572879538,
0.027384188,
-0.0483491905,
0.033371523,
0.058314696,
-0.0179897696,
0.0004105991,
0.0178344212,
0.015263184,
0.0046878359,
-0.0294977017,
0.0298708566,
0.0366932414,
0.0004828413,
-0.0189121887,
0.0359710939,
-0.0250650086,
0.0175477918,
-0.0510889776,
0.0178924389,
0.0296114665,
0.0399766751,
0.0593193807,
-0.0432237089,
-0.0314031914,
-0.012897931,
0.0320894606,
0.0483849905,
-0.0650225505,
0.0081851194,
-0.0000495423,
-0.0325034149,
-0.0177203398,
0.0850214064,
0.0286836922,
0.0499895513,
-0.0255416669,
-0.0055079916,
-0.0516413897,
-0.0129127828,
0.0204829071,
-0.0272089038,
-0.0205473918,
0.0184556991,
-0.0456642173,
-0.0585362501,
0.0265992396,
0.0202696919,
-0.0028489854,
0.0002187094,
0.0253776386,
0.0379516892,
-0.0312576555,
0.0010385213,
-0.0453807227,
0.0192281753,
0.0177775063,
-0.0134976283,
0.0009763619,
-5.817715866e-33,
-0.0680500045,
-0.0370152593,
0.0175795164,
-0.007442384,
-0.035287533,
0.0023313053,
-0.0441727452,
-0.0187019072,
0.0634019971,
0.0046869623,
-0.0097822687,
-0.0206655432,
0.0111110713,
0.0470844097,
-0.0009549381,
0.0092455223,
0.0913296491,
-0.011053225,
-0.0420410484,
0.0742084309,
0.0275446419,
0.0400362089,
0.0405772254,
-0.0286160447,
0.0171832778,
-0.0078049628,
-0.0387878716,
0.0018326524,
-0.002704358,
0.068745248,
0.0101241656,
0.0113237239,
0.0054297107,
-0.0639098957,
-0.0606119446,
0.0061334209,
-0.0327950455,
-0.0196623001,
0.0054805209,
0.0161666088,
-0.0403378494,
-0.0537149087,
0.0423678719,
-0.0317461826,
-0.0068334457,
0.0100728236,
0.0449781716,
-0.032111235,
-0.0131891025,
-0.0524432994,
-0.0696288124,
0.0410521254,
-0.0068619223,
-0.0061862683,
0.0169526786,
0.028416682,
0.003132533,
-0.0278582461,
0.0318754837,
0.0294428337,
0.0361746289,
0.0582340546,
0.0482075177,
0.0646099076,
0.0199536774,
0.0522676148,
0.031421259,
0.0073124794,
0.0077162473,
-0.001898147,
0.0314912088,
0.0196712501,
0.0378735587,
0.0249307398,
-0.0351313017,
-0.0092456099,
-0.033874996,
0.0112642869,
-0.0181328543,
0.02631923,
0.0228481963,
0.000461939,
-0.0068602036,
-0.0160173457,
-0.0572430827,
-0.0454411954,
-0.0269270875,
-0.024205802,
0.0397481658,
0.0230788738,
-0.0814252049,
0.0017843974,
0.0325631611,
0.0009596909,
-0.0166591909,
0.0496577099,
-0.0575838909,
0.0531568937,
-0.0113619771,
0.030833561,
-0.026681941,
-0.0334100574,
0.0553748645,
0.0030709989,
0.0190953929,
0.0283036493,
0.0357252508,
0.0333367623,
-0.0630420968,
0.0162165426,
-0.0276232269,
0.0402926989,
0.0099506238,
0.0022240442,
0.0224900059,
-0.0070121447,
-0.0142080551,
0.0436098725,
0.0417048931,
-0.0301971119,
-0.0345720164,
-0.0053197066,
0.0242736787,
0.0388264321,
-0.0601130202,
0.0073536905,
-0.0203852933,
0.0087824808,
0.0327204354,
-0.0183942243,
-0.0136773875,
-0.0084345229,
2.485e-7,
0.0280071478,
0.0483101606,
0.040110264,
0.0284436364,
0.0069649005,
0.0136094065,
0.0102789812,
0.0092900125,
0.0174418539,
0.0176390763,
-0.0042574177,
-0.0165555049,
0.0524596572,
-0.0014383123,
-0.0871690139,
0.0545004234,
-0.0495751239,
0.0197201576,
-0.0743364543,
-0.0190997496,
0.0377128273,
0.0697619244,
0.0058530509,
0.0034397554,
-0.0169747919,
0.0080195647,
0.0575876832,
0.0027169692,
-0.0129596079,
0.0353677906,
0.0208418295,
0.0086456351,
-0.0108253323,
0.0025769095,
-0.0354413614,
-0.005701662,
0.013699187,
0.0889697,
0.0023423876,
0.0302098412,
0.0306152925,
-0.0069713583,
0.009113078,
-0.0319936872,
0.0702942461,
-0.0350505821,
-0.0092091653,
-0.0490916297,
-0.0198472701,
-0.0004405947,
-0.024177948,
-0.0551914014,
-0.0436412655,
0.0400204845,
0.0218358226,
0.0117529435,
-0.01857627,
-0.0422202908,
-0.0550243184,
-0.0450563654,
-0.0325675569,
-0.0385742523,
-0.061441835,
0.0189262312,
-0.021005759,
-0.069738552,
-0.0070199198,
3.122972346e-34,
0.0245216619,
-0.0052328017,
-0.0087946374,
0.0123871872,
0.0131267756,
-0.0152933514,
0.0398824438,
0.0381872915,
0.0275981072,
-0.0573511645,
-0.0480059385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07424v1 | Hallucination Augmented Recitations for Language Models | 2023-11-13T15:58:18 | 2023-11-13T15:58:18 | Abdullatif Köksal, Renat Aksitov, Chung-Ching Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Attribution is a key concept in large language models (LLMs) as it enables
control over information sources and enhances the factuality of LLMs. While
existing approaches utilize open book question answering to improve
attribution, factual datasets may reward language models to recall facts that
they already know from their pretraining data, not attribution. In contrast,
counterfactual open book QA datasets would further improve attribution because
the answer could only be grounded in the given text. We propose Hallucination
Augmented Recitations (HAR) for creating counterfactual datasets by utilizing
hallucination in LLMs to improve attribution. For open book QA as a case study,
we demonstrate that models finetuned with our counterfactual datasets improve
text grounding, leading to better open book QA performance, with up to an 8.0%
increase in F1 score. Our counterfactual dataset leads to significantly better
performance than using humanannotated factual datasets, even with 4x smaller
datasets and 4x smaller models. We observe that improvements are consistent
across various model sizes and datasets, including multi-hop, biomedical, and
adversarial QA datasets. | [
0.0058112,
0.0550233461,
-0.0095279207,
0.0218791943,
-0.039408002,
0.0085672773,
-0.0019701787,
-0.0223538969,
0.0093589295,
-0.0409148224,
-0.0455217287,
-0.0156559795,
-0.0052166795,
-0.0010723545,
0.0392585024,
0.0023618755,
0.0329990201,
-0.0335315913,
-0.0179255009,
-0.0306285154,
-0.0112254079,
0.0151261771,
-0.0208251923,
0.0022431829,
0.0143068926,
-0.0238469522,
0.0118772089,
-0.0073962342,
0.0284526087,
0.0146163357,
0.005817519,
0.0559046566,
0.0194210541,
0.043614693,
0.0000018968,
-0.0439793169,
-0.0091352267,
-0.0070302226,
-0.0779641122,
0.0145951454,
-0.0206592809,
0.0175738875,
0.0163607933,
-0.0029770513,
-0.0311477352,
0.0067642136,
0.0342473388,
0.0883806199,
0.0642065778,
0.0656288117,
0.0090339975,
-0.04175134,
0.0564160421,
-0.0157274082,
0.0527512655,
-0.003663158,
0.0181177277,
0.0492451265,
-0.0221526232,
0.0183843561,
-0.0377588198,
0.0474828742,
0.063588962,
0.0127149038,
0.0320542753,
0.0303756166,
-0.0361897126,
0.0089466562,
0.0006040818,
0.114930138,
0.008686983,
-0.0490185767,
-0.0122952098,
-0.0035510359,
0.0121499402,
-0.0026732709,
-0.0723330155,
0.035049744,
-0.0093292072,
0.0163322743,
0.0034944196,
-0.0128746424,
0.0516166836,
0.0313249528,
0.0101169804,
0.0400322527,
0.0129857762,
-0.0310457367,
0.023383595,
0.0075453254,
-0.0222853068,
-0.0391140804,
-0.0020746505,
0.0203805435,
-0.011173795,
0.022449689,
-0.0309721995,
-0.0096312454,
0.053046722,
-0.0357998013,
0.028523976,
0.0191814937,
-0.0653469041,
0.0454980135,
-0.0402154326,
0.0363847315,
-0.0343452618,
0.1115396097,
-0.0198555533,
-0.0214322526,
-0.0282633062,
-0.0248226169,
-0.0302595459,
0.0227977745,
-0.0205667783,
0.0206953268,
-0.0189831685,
-0.0177317448,
-0.045304589,
0.0107816178,
-0.0236651283,
0.0387873538,
-0.029229708,
-0.0094829667,
-0.0278328061,
0.0331285037,
-0.0507173352,
0.0383175872,
0.0303123277,
-0.0837077349,
-0.0479318947,
0.0148911811,
-0.0072506471,
-0.0251547974,
0.0242130142,
0.043339476,
0.0205888413,
-0.0188515484,
-0.0082756225,
-0.0449163988,
0.0022959458,
-0.0853371769,
0.0046772077,
-0.0548201315,
0.021882806,
-0.004366579,
-0.0121370964,
-0.0368234888,
0.0057870611,
0.0364534929,
-0.0093864109,
0.0775154233,
0.0257243048,
-0.0236406457,
0.0272894464,
0.0325227641,
-0.0201766584,
0.0606993027,
0.0142075038,
0.0206595547,
0.0180025045,
-0.0114313839,
0.0455784909,
-0.0051449342,
0.0709415376,
0.0093502151,
-0.0193350054,
0.0386230275,
0.0396350063,
0.0274968147,
0.0330293588,
0.0464871973,
-0.0289756414,
-0.0561832041,
0.0529643521,
0.0162879676,
-0.0131641151,
0.0173941925,
-0.0072864033,
-0.0147434073,
0.0224666726,
0.0170069076,
-0.0713558868,
0.075916335,
-0.0114326477,
0.0156747997,
0.0374565758,
0.0039823544,
-0.047070805,
-0.0424166285,
0.0092959646,
0.0002710339,
0.0062746243,
0.055906862,
0.0160484109,
0.0452265777,
-0.0442936271,
0.0552742109,
0.0376649313,
-0.0400755964,
0.0284808669,
-0.0598136559,
0.0376617201,
0.0308364853,
0.0518238395,
-0.0402137898,
0.0118884649,
-0.0470000915,
0.0444543101,
0.0432598405,
0.0579207093,
-0.0214077123,
0.0030706793,
-0.0449367687,
-0.0084587522,
-0.0407472961,
0.0212070271,
0.0288035795,
0.0142405946,
0.0208775643,
0.0063889679,
-0.0267124865,
-0.0476501919,
0.0317667797,
-0.0160054788,
-0.0352322124,
-0.0079562357,
-0.0144975455,
0.020377731,
0.0238084998,
-0.0017404086,
0.0155665344,
0.0309413187,
-0.0380643643,
-0.0325756706,
-0.0069558066,
-0.0410427675,
-0.0324867927,
0.0400357023,
-0.0190717261,
-0.0261138026,
0.0462927744,
-0.0363671258,
-0.0376652554,
0.0303509403,
-0.0217879992,
0.0372875109,
-0.0355152227,
-0.0084252628,
-0.002651382,
0.0242503174,
-0.0301863831,
0.040743418,
-0.0212627538,
0.0230466034,
-0.0000720681,
-0.0137338741,
0.0028086307,
-0.0329296477,
0.0058782049,
0.0025919359,
0.0031746805,
0.0350176021,
-0.006148831,
-0.0356454551,
-0.0548984706,
-0.0091901729,
-0.071709156,
0.0006126279,
-0.0399956219,
-0.0169810541,
0.0282076374,
-0.0038465392,
0.0142235011,
-0.0284535065,
-0.0753988102,
-0.032478407,
0.0133735212,
0.0294475872,
0.0064360905,
0.0128475903,
0.0170127824,
-0.0262526628,
-0.0081226453,
-0.0138964439,
0.0182796791,
0.0123951379,
0.0252761319,
-0.0511044376,
-0.0007731289,
-0.0545488484,
0.0012878772,
-0.0318434127,
-0.0127855772,
0.0175295621,
0.0238576178,
0.0347069986,
0.0837687254,
-0.0106345573,
0.0086192898,
0.0618308149,
0.0192040615,
-0.0565704331,
0.0180460513,
-0.0175976735,
-0.0159052014,
-0.0263574999,
-0.0438053682,
-0.0357368402,
0.0249954108,
0.0361084044,
-0.0016939318,
-0.0454002731,
0.0280457363,
-0.0061019347,
-0.04658629,
-0.0524295121,
-0.0086890161,
-0.0251322798,
0.0289944131,
-0.0366391353,
-0.0451491214,
0.1002337858,
-0.023459658,
-0.0006378281,
-0.0355379209,
0.0250559058,
-0.0370181203,
0.0268924609,
-0.0232689846,
-0.0104430951,
-0.0314418264,
0.0026908037,
-0.0511535965,
-0.0152437175,
0.0000309979,
-0.0568167008,
0.0367448777,
-0.0211689919,
-0.0055122096,
-0.0013613439,
-0.0141039686,
-0.0636489093,
-0.0114133907,
-0.012126944,
-0.0020321121,
-0.0822396576,
0.0064719836,
-0.0461156964,
-0.0409709364,
0.055972673,
0.020286737,
-0.0273030829,
0.0226868615,
-0.0055513233,
0.0075259982,
0.0996710807,
0.0502143577,
0.0386509076,
-0.0483789034,
0.0089595607,
0.0486644395,
0.0496287569,
0.0135680996,
0.043442037,
-0.00298867,
-0.0051916884,
-0.0161541943,
0.0021042058,
0.0002280036,
0.040424902,
-0.0492881238,
-0.0156004736,
0.0782128498,
0.0065813563,
-0.0347659439,
-0.0054863496,
-0.0450561121,
0.0443390757,
0.0013805218,
-0.0089817746,
-0.1293073893,
-0.0349825174,
-0.0361032337,
0.0246595405,
0.0046993755,
-0.0125140054,
-0.0007385316,
-0.1042824611,
0.0099974498,
0.006875826,
-0.0493751429,
-0.0509644039,
-0.0450454168,
-0.0108487494,
-0.0218389388,
0.014616753,
0.0093979128,
0.0418259501,
-0.0142412148,
0.0191465132,
0.0304445866,
-0.0033680622,
0.0709093735,
-0.0275351964,
0.0530656613,
0.0726208389,
0.02044072,
-0.0048506986,
-0.053379003,
-0.0177324116,
-0.0405904166,
-0.0267563891,
0.0172265973,
0.0813475177,
-0.0177249964,
-0.0118724033,
0.0061077788,
0.0550142229,
-0.0332054161,
-0.0219397657,
-0.0057617379,
0.0975801721,
-0.0092366589,
-0.0072860238,
-0.0319935083,
0.0180309173,
0.0157668665,
0.1075223237,
0.0415412784,
-0.0257156342,
-0.0492755808,
-0.0304896776,
0.0053017251,
-0.0597120896,
-0.0304567255,
0.0414654948,
0.0554215051,
-0.0229388997,
-0.0764394179,
-0.060930185,
0.0087448955,
0.0009306278,
-0.0069672656,
0.0327149555,
-0.0262062829,
0.0011570551,
-0.0316118188,
0.0414285213,
-0.0856104642,
0.0169288218,
-0.0264838692,
-0.0500233285,
0.0358080938,
-0.0364449956,
-0.0156745389,
0.0310085285,
-0.0889551714,
-0.0379914492,
0.032820344,
0.0586729124,
0.0250951443,
0.0742594302,
-0.0219674781,
-0.0287293047,
0.0476096645,
0.0036553661,
-0.0454536229,
0.0254942626,
0.0528409556,
-0.0043641296,
0.009393462,
0.0428147465,
-0.0269807689,
-0.0019741331,
0.034126427,
0.0266752914,
0.0043284893,
-0.0165138729,
0.0149848936,
-0.008073125,
0.0191622544,
0.0185621697,
0.0003717734,
-0.0123179322,
0.0339526273,
-0.0185258072,
-0.0044388496,
-0.0074359947,
-0.001808297,
0.0468518659,
-0.0341816209,
0.0078075123,
-0.0394144878,
-0.0357859731,
0.0556014329,
-0.0312224291,
0.0231196955,
0.0176278297,
0.0023742109,
0.0039372519,
0.0006742781,
-0.0314020105,
0.0077797091,
0.0075813783,
0.07146772,
0.0073789163,
0.0321582258,
0.0223004501,
-0.0250037294,
-0.0001704977,
-0.0042270548,
-0.0897487327,
-0.0073575247,
-0.0181579478,
0.0165178087,
0.0095727984,
0.0067376886,
0.0357162841,
-0.0056941304,
-0.0036487721,
0.003845098,
0.0238792226,
0.0134171899,
-0.0282997657,
0.0466772057,
0.024266649,
-0.0061604506,
0.0346548334,
0.0642362982,
0.0070545664,
0.0772007629,
-0.0159943718,
0.0100577306,
-0.0222594477,
-0.0830426887,
-0.026247073,
-0.0243010595,
-0.0009150182,
0.0234864969,
-0.0853471681,
-0.0727312043,
0.0225344952,
0.0226443987,
-0.0035284925,
-0.028308589,
0.0256343856,
0.0384100489,
-0.023144871,
-0.0422891714,
-0.0413427502,
0.0517451763,
0.0321503021,
-0.0426331721,
-0.0141548133,
-6.164172622e-33,
-0.0146945361,
-0.0150845302,
0.0140455551,
-0.0302347243,
-0.0164955296,
-0.0001323011,
-0.0258366223,
-0.0087835975,
-0.0462489054,
-0.0016155207,
-0.0125137838,
0.0371141136,
0.0147391288,
0.0431759134,
-0.0106365122,
-0.0681497827,
0.0440588705,
-0.0188446511,
-0.0245517809,
0.0675374866,
0.0251182616,
0.0104269888,
0.0891852677,
-0.0367478132,
0.0692924112,
-0.0436436236,
-0.0102642309,
0.0046480536,
-0.0518640131,
0.0464947931,
-0.0419708043,
0.036114946,
0.0112657519,
-0.0590934418,
-0.0059655127,
-0.0007933474,
-0.0808649287,
-0.0100938296,
0.0321255699,
0.0136616733,
-0.0398196578,
-0.037176311,
0.0367805287,
-0.0233968571,
0.009982802,
-0.0210307445,
0.0134439487,
-0.0335759297,
-0.0270201247,
0.0372111872,
-0.0376625285,
-0.0036191817,
-0.0026757827,
-0.0176263936,
-0.0223941617,
0.0335911214,
0.0092869541,
0.0095290309,
-0.0794950947,
0.0079350313,
0.02810633,
-0.0128104212,
0.0386836752,
-0.006456641,
0.0255944058,
0.0534910746,
0.0113079371,
0.0037033372,
-0.0424305014,
-0.0024016891,
0.0215262156,
0.0059151831,
0.1037970036,
0.0717709512,
0.047647614,
0.0099489978,
-0.0758956224,
-0.0032188592,
-0.0392630771,
0.0185740311,
0.034418948,
-0.0058406163,
-0.0392279588,
-0.0097072795,
-0.0619815029,
0.0024797295,
-0.0252696816,
-0.0227789897,
0.0338296145,
0.0016050007,
-0.0406949222,
-0.0061366213,
0.0304011963,
-0.0513909347,
-0.0043486878,
0.0643535107,
-0.0007567994,
0.0116619812,
-0.0065461402,
0.0018274874,
-0.0680094361,
0.0426114835,
0.0408787243,
0.0185269229,
0.0393386222,
0.0214233436,
0.0577727966,
0.0102384174,
-0.0480839387,
0.0201512445,
-0.0254929252,
0.0235923044,
0.0228505507,
-0.0013018936,
0.0193269271,
0.0324395783,
-0.0205436684,
0.0358050242,
0.0098260883,
-0.0150336456,
-0.0280584265,
-0.0064826179,
-0.0267952494,
0.010866683,
-0.0564095713,
-0.0147567941,
-0.0038178351,
0.0002340918,
-0.0020681615,
-0.0747276619,
0.0137821408,
0.0088547943,
2.539e-7,
0.0127257407,
-0.0046842285,
0.047990799,
0.0278626215,
0.0029545671,
0.0235721897,
0.0098401522,
0.0247246698,
0.0195986573,
-0.062303327,
-0.0017021768,
0.0579473488,
0.0621752962,
0.0255458299,
-0.093509987,
0.0097049288,
-0.0909490138,
0.0051964726,
-0.0326941572,
-0.0547678582,
0.0057870289,
0.1129189953,
0.0293695536,
-0.0127408421,
0.0053038471,
-0.0071952203,
0.0623248555,
-0.0211831126,
-0.0005721065,
0.0059604221,
0.052780997,
0.0140729174,
0.0032587335,
-0.0048927041,
-0.0021615615,
-0.0137485368,
0.0180524755,
0.0334005728,
0.0233341008,
-0.1122596338,
-0.0529429801,
-0.020587191,
0.0244139675,
-0.0554837622,
0.0622560754,
-0.0087514352,
-0.0184599273,
0.0117313424,
-0.0199062154,
-0.0157005694,
0.0545748845,
-0.0156671349,
-0.0341473557,
0.0160366371,
-0.004678173,
0.0094261663,
0.0278596655,
-0.0624509677,
-0.0440514348,
-0.0039303456,
-0.0221269019,
-0.0386485085,
-0.0111733619,
-0.044838395,
-0.0068775117,
-0.0758027583,
0.0057610455,
2.27381589e-34,
0.0449699424,
-0.0179310329,
0.0363076068,
0.0399590097,
0.0174465459,
0.0127811851,
0.0382411517,
-0.0257226974,
0.0418785736,
-0.0510503575,
-0.0287347604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07418v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07418v1 | Speech-based Slot Filling using Large Language Models | 2023-11-13T15:54:30 | 2023-11-13T15:54:30 | Guangzhi Sun, Shutong Feng, Dongcheng Jiang, Chao Zhang, Milica Gašić, Philip C. Woodland | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recently, advancements in large language models (LLMs) have shown an
unprecedented ability across various language tasks. This paper investigates
the potential application of LLMs to slot filling with noisy ASR
transcriptions, via both in-context learning and task-specific fine-tuning.
Dedicated prompt designs and fine-tuning approaches are proposed to improve the
robustness of LLMs for slot filling with noisy ASR transcriptions. Moreover, a
linearised knowledge injection (LKI) scheme is also proposed to integrate
dynamic external knowledge into LLMs. Experiments were performed on SLURP to
quantify the performance of LLMs, including GPT-3.5-turbo, GPT-4, LLaMA-13B and
Vicuna-13B (v1.1 and v1.5) with different ASR error rates. The use of the
proposed fine-tuning together with the LKI scheme for LLaMA-13B achieved an
8.3% absolute SLU-F1 improvement compared to the strong Flan-T5-base baseline
system on a limited data setup. | [
0.0261902492,
0.0304026622,
0.0027509278,
0.0158948489,
-0.0003049927,
0.0061352579,
0.0021827812,
-0.0153557304,
-0.0182375517,
-0.0275106207,
-0.029679548,
-0.0278660972,
0.0440598987,
0.0330544859,
0.0414988808,
0.0076417518,
0.0069792583,
-0.1057049632,
-0.0127334259,
-0.0230075046,
-0.0138186077,
-0.0043390002,
-0.0342871919,
0.0408462733,
0.027204724,
0.0189725515,
-0.0011361999,
-0.0120316781,
0.0057820072,
-0.007875382,
-0.0049505262,
0.0385833867,
0.0346754156,
0.0523097105,
0.0000023144,
-0.032693889,
-0.0021919287,
0.0177878831,
-0.1210707352,
0.0256609414,
-0.0325084738,
-0.0007549745,
-0.0453204736,
0.0339696072,
0.0275498442,
-0.0301949829,
0.0623266809,
-0.0156296529,
0.0093819126,
0.0357352458,
0.0096652862,
-0.0229058396,
0.023906121,
-0.0230578259,
0.0013604417,
-0.0358919464,
0.0537478961,
-0.0049284012,
0.0214250665,
0.0051711383,
-0.0149112679,
0.0375549681,
0.0104635935,
-0.0544704236,
0.0285756718,
0.016146021,
-0.0331729501,
-0.0348495729,
-0.0530180931,
0.0515665151,
-0.0041561602,
-0.034324497,
0.0005399491,
-0.0237804092,
-0.035820052,
-0.0014637108,
-0.0330222212,
0.0290450584,
-0.0033466178,
0.0022143347,
0.0465527996,
-0.0073428233,
0.0176339876,
-0.0229555443,
-0.036898423,
0.0398979969,
0.0321752243,
-0.0794908106,
0.0498989709,
-0.028931953,
0.0078315241,
-0.0345497765,
0.0176066011,
0.0269577876,
-0.063433364,
0.0235777721,
0.0116255451,
-0.0073859333,
0.0261417907,
-0.0421859585,
0.0343433321,
0.0780699849,
-0.0504030734,
0.0059401528,
-0.0014619085,
0.070939742,
-0.025623912,
-0.018738078,
-0.0302492809,
0.0175106097,
0.0036867314,
-0.0302180126,
-0.0185604673,
0.0072451215,
-0.0425812416,
-0.026448166,
-0.0421978012,
0.021507442,
0.0332632437,
0.0327968299,
0.0510363095,
-0.0438002236,
-0.0471820422,
0.0031516696,
-0.0125947958,
0.0459355339,
0.0454048514,
0.0079332925,
-0.0399405658,
-0.0666439161,
-0.0136482054,
0.0232443027,
-0.0007164024,
-0.0550564267,
0.0023583188,
0.0384091176,
0.0145734837,
0.0033313292,
-0.0292575173,
0.0263390914,
-0.0189635325,
-0.0733381137,
-0.0376918018,
-0.0388896465,
0.0042485599,
0.0195556004,
0.0038539402,
0.0025151761,
0.015258125,
0.037946526,
0.0185785294,
0.0684700161,
-0.0098011391,
0.0263112839,
0.0384666286,
-0.0148996664,
0.0101648141,
0.0838323236,
-0.0048284908,
0.0000924031,
-0.024926221,
-0.0471979417,
-0.0221177191,
0.0639449358,
-0.0012652964,
-0.008889907,
0.0136698047,
-0.0044689728,
0.0759818852,
0.027002437,
0.0519593805,
0.0484120622,
-0.0056124921,
0.0000438952,
0.0473448224,
0.0465401039,
0.0537555218,
-0.0066791801,
0.0260513872,
0.0236644913,
0.0074915565,
-0.01603234,
-0.0149186533,
-0.0089646792,
0.0059361751,
0.0220173672,
0.0436009206,
0.060907159,
0.014381825,
0.0142643955,
-0.0235901643,
-0.0294781663,
-0.0396097116,
0.0460833423,
0.0647794008,
-0.030086752,
-0.0480480604,
0.0666506439,
0.0383181311,
0.0028239244,
-0.0137613621,
-0.0452025533,
-0.0030103833,
0.0312391091,
0.009696749,
-0.0350764059,
-0.0485859476,
-0.058029376,
-0.0613656305,
0.0481600799,
0.0144337555,
0.0151873967,
-0.0034342213,
-0.0714349449,
0.0029976869,
0.0639044642,
-0.0213629156,
0.0637984574,
-0.008684936,
-0.0024197903,
0.0165800732,
0.0133133018,
0.029573312,
-0.0028867864,
-0.0208952557,
-0.0176349673,
0.0027177199,
0.01430004,
0.0581384152,
0.0353456847,
-0.0180988982,
-0.0155497696,
0.0355802104,
-0.0364642031,
0.0253796354,
0.0141487895,
-0.0973627344,
-0.0068445913,
0.0585367382,
0.0645470023,
-0.0321258046,
-0.0032281925,
0.0328246616,
-0.0451573357,
-0.0117313126,
-0.0080041708,
0.0166113749,
-0.0722514838,
0.0578441322,
0.0319443531,
-0.0007297598,
-0.0192829296,
0.0395634174,
0.0320126191,
0.0274895467,
0.0767576993,
-0.0036537095,
0.0298314188,
-0.1292381436,
-0.0277199149,
0.0454613045,
-0.014981227,
-0.0160535742,
-0.0058479365,
-0.008788418,
-0.0138917202,
-0.0254269559,
-0.0719174743,
-0.0011233825,
-0.0025385621,
0.0155155826,
-0.0019966576,
0.0043968866,
-0.0017924114,
-0.007622465,
-0.0332572833,
-0.0602118857,
-0.0127893519,
-0.0012827475,
-0.0317221843,
0.0196032785,
-0.0297131017,
-0.0004027886,
0.01609415,
-0.0085999323,
-0.0006221364,
-0.0089200325,
-0.0451061428,
-0.0677555352,
0.0204579756,
0.0477292985,
0.0205455851,
-0.0204518382,
-0.0381706618,
-0.0144360252,
-0.0057326686,
0.0087588951,
0.0329181664,
-0.0543251149,
-0.0225112755,
0.0183772203,
-0.013812162,
-0.0363801457,
0.0232773628,
0.0393426195,
0.0089182388,
-0.0510434881,
0.0451020673,
-0.035627719,
0.0381156653,
0.0175222848,
0.0375364982,
-0.0315108821,
-0.00524153,
-0.0366642326,
-0.0281907115,
-0.0370177813,
-0.0381829776,
-0.066398479,
0.0101228477,
-0.0274109673,
-0.0228134971,
0.0170159098,
-0.0737681836,
-0.0487694964,
-0.0560009927,
-0.0232512075,
-0.0363088883,
-0.015848672,
-0.002044633,
0.007368031,
0.0148530509,
-0.0542457402,
0.0164237097,
0.022365598,
-0.0333970673,
-0.0256340783,
0.0477722473,
-0.0410130359,
0.0392183512,
-0.0273523815,
-0.0733699277,
-0.0198961031,
-0.00503068,
-0.0370450541,
0.0154492958,
0.028077811,
-0.0374906659,
0.0276846141,
0.0500413999,
0.0109018907,
0.0442177691,
-0.0024400915,
0.0351564847,
-0.0242811535,
0.0281031579,
0.0397637151,
0.0502734371,
-0.0242503807,
0.0283576753,
0.0429908894,
-0.0271016806,
0.0087346695,
0.0065628877,
-0.0004753419,
0.0440136865,
0.0506535396,
-0.0112670679,
-0.0161974765,
0.0373396948,
0.0352623574,
-0.0509529002,
0.0275948402,
0.0956179351,
0.0073564984,
-0.0202141646,
-0.0307172853,
-0.0038008578,
-0.0000343245,
-0.0003721314,
0.0294238012,
-0.0688286424,
-0.0048249722,
0.0562347993,
0.0111086089,
-0.0105057787,
0.0269778706,
-0.0200365465,
-0.1394128054,
0.0704684034,
0.0244689006,
-0.0496550426,
-0.0184455961,
-0.0378101915,
0.0123833753,
-0.0052129757,
0.0561788864,
0.0580653436,
-0.0143449372,
-0.0430405624,
0.0545126423,
-0.0546767302,
-0.0726687014,
-0.0104952781,
-0.000497474,
0.1469380856,
0.0184701011,
-0.0088091334,
-0.02626222,
-0.0145980353,
-0.00509226,
-0.0114853997,
-0.0165331904,
-0.024806818,
-0.0031025254,
0.038454704,
-0.0132407257,
0.0045738323,
0.0192316342,
0.0051604267,
0.0082988488,
-0.0189068411,
0.0586752631,
-0.0279141795,
0.028478289,
0.0535224676,
-0.0236180238,
0.0016547319,
0.0643085539,
0.0243338197,
-0.0271616075,
0.0079294331,
-0.021022344,
0.0214033891,
-0.007910545,
-0.0169523805,
0.0542660132,
0.0028464224,
-0.0691537261,
-0.0052220528,
0.0069483295,
0.0461864546,
0.032256633,
0.0617689304,
0.0842761174,
0.0165531207,
0.0103154788,
0.007499482,
-0.0347964205,
-0.0433907509,
0.0351215936,
-0.0735785291,
-0.0434228778,
0.0290132463,
-0.0617477186,
-0.0244731456,
0.0130428663,
-0.0559392795,
-0.0675988495,
0.0422853045,
-0.0111501934,
0.0332653001,
0.0179559235,
-0.0336364545,
-0.0667262748,
0.063820824,
0.0043218513,
-0.0552516915,
0.02799193,
0.019241035,
0.013773269,
0.0084463358,
0.0208068229,
-0.0434403308,
-0.0282662213,
-0.022622915,
0.011043746,
0.0164775271,
-0.0235664751,
0.0262291916,
0.0644504204,
0.0255072936,
-0.009237458,
-0.0193602983,
-0.0446619466,
0.0705984682,
-0.0362160355,
0.0351861864,
-0.0187519994,
-0.021837363,
0.0296811331,
0.025320895,
-0.0024272301,
-0.0624026768,
-0.0205507465,
0.0099308724,
-0.01113436,
0.0290437266,
0.0250837971,
-0.0135236364,
0.0589417666,
0.016074948,
-0.0253582709,
0.029677337,
0.0529412106,
0.0218559708,
-0.0171229169,
0.0377329625,
-0.0218016803,
-0.0242774561,
0.0304672401,
0.0247125067,
0.0023859623,
-0.0790277198,
-0.0058177002,
0.0294316914,
0.0381852053,
-0.0110276751,
0.0241791736,
-0.0118025299,
0.0029839652,
-0.0262790248,
-0.001009379,
0.0025020577,
0.0442627221,
0.0601653457,
0.0038850361,
-0.0207417682,
0.0378449745,
0.0549603067,
0.0341178961,
0.0607102066,
-0.0065326714,
0.0262353458,
-0.0267334338,
-0.0255237166,
-0.0133547951,
0.0172880348,
-0.0487684272,
-0.0079919547,
-0.0365828201,
-0.0695909783,
-0.0042669149,
-0.0066269883,
-0.0153541919,
-0.0084931813,
-0.0267833415,
-0.0060362504,
-0.0161340348,
-0.0191257391,
-0.0068466794,
-0.0587796681,
0.0029066761,
-0.0262324177,
0.0055772201,
-7.186149615e-33,
-0.0288061518,
0.038350489,
0.0038134125,
0.0153885931,
-0.0367981121,
0.0058769481,
-0.0007143579,
-0.0192947425,
0.0140226977,
-0.0265206099,
-0.0204242487,
-0.0576129258,
0.0435421318,
-0.0102430275,
0.0156449191,
0.0162613392,
0.0632441416,
0.0034584885,
0.0157687142,
-0.0145998634,
0.0113803931,
0.0259919055,
0.0317960642,
-0.0233174935,
-0.0244262479,
0.0170526206,
0.0056367582,
0.0229794532,
-0.020848019,
0.0510677993,
-0.009130354,
0.0731844902,
-0.0024976844,
-0.0485881418,
0.0092894826,
0.0520145148,
-0.0837441832,
-0.0083407843,
0.0588462204,
0.0499436855,
0.0799756572,
-0.0378293134,
0.0189967565,
-0.0083723105,
-0.0365177505,
0.0219736677,
-0.0150322607,
-0.0083461208,
-0.0176971443,
-0.0274257995,
-0.0035870557,
0.0142903542,
-0.0053050541,
-0.0237825755,
0.0580292344,
-0.0213818699,
-0.0135747558,
-0.0379300006,
-0.0466250703,
0.0311636291,
0.0282366388,
0.0715186745,
0.0265427493,
0.0323368832,
0.0209331121,
0.028300222,
0.0272164606,
-0.0456198156,
0.0307616554,
-0.0322124399,
0.0055853184,
-0.0078901565,
-0.0343202949,
-0.0090409657,
0.0604127757,
-0.0338734947,
-0.029033469,
-0.0182760954,
0.0206748638,
0.0478944033,
0.0518966243,
0.0358221717,
-0.0733951479,
-0.0468611345,
-0.0568730161,
0.0126547841,
-0.0413487181,
-0.0332481638,
0.0614180788,
-0.0101614296,
0.0179235581,
0.0105812056,
0.0438069142,
-0.0177692883,
0.0219886228,
0.0003863078,
0.0036591298,
0.0001940604,
-0.0389244594,
0.011208252,
-0.0820024908,
-0.0410174802,
0.0483617187,
0.0360474251,
0.030242715,
-0.0176443532,
-0.0372685939,
0.0770817101,
-0.071676366,
0.0128999315,
-0.0388614275,
0.015209781,
0.0581096299,
0.0118186222,
0.0399821028,
-0.0275147185,
0.0043015471,
0.0232651774,
0.011038892,
0.0064531611,
-0.0242652092,
-0.0389666483,
0.0319212191,
0.0150084216,
-0.0478959046,
0.0280526653,
0.012272981,
-0.0047811707,
0.0067769201,
-0.0073125972,
0.0057302653,
-0.0047411895,
3.19e-7,
-0.00681538,
0.0557309017,
0.0083233006,
-0.027505558,
0.0048288731,
-0.0136937471,
-0.02899356,
-0.0166226514,
0.0390863605,
0.0032302935,
-0.0041597197,
-0.0033945625,
0.0441062935,
0.0184608623,
-0.1254006922,
0.0099842343,
-0.0495536365,
0.0090211229,
-0.0754375756,
-0.0003474875,
0.0222871564,
0.1096575856,
-0.0263548493,
-0.0445950441,
0.0407107063,
-0.0582770295,
-0.0067774327,
-0.024320066,
-0.0255290549,
0.00942956,
0.0357603133,
0.0141721126,
-0.0310150906,
0.0485081971,
0.0027443257,
0.0313589722,
-0.0094928332,
0.0348464809,
-0.0098261042,
-0.0301917028,
0.0201042611,
0.0261772573,
-0.011649658,
-0.0688843429,
0.0358421579,
-0.0161858797,
-0.0276294444,
-0.0346084461,
-0.0319872238,
-0.0634412691,
0.0028307973,
-0.0311620869,
0.030973468,
0.002725075,
-0.0035203034,
-0.0054608551,
-0.0283687301,
-0.0411601365,
-0.0463850684,
0.0002377609,
-0.0695948228,
-0.045166444,
-0.0070075807,
-0.0833943561,
-0.0016036341,
-0.0146204745,
0.0066076191,
3.113114954e-34,
0.0299281813,
-0.0124467965,
0.022604486,
0.0650869831,
0.0442708321,
-0.0224091113,
-0.0102392146,
0.0396778584,
-0.0149814738,
-0.1036544368,
-0.0417236574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07397v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07397v2 | AMBER: An LLM-free Multi-dimensional Benchmark for MLLMs Hallucination Evaluation | 2023-11-13T15:25:42 | 2024-02-23T07:54:11 | Junyang Wang, Yuhang Wang, Guohai Xu, Jing Zhang, Yukai Gu, Haitao Jia, Jiaqi Wang, Haiyang Xu, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang, Jitao Sang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Despite making significant progress in multi-modal tasks, current Multi-modal
Large Language Models (MLLMs) encounter the significant challenge of
hallucinations, which may lead to harmful consequences. Therefore, evaluating
MLLMs' hallucinations is becoming increasingly important in model improvement
and practical application deployment. Previous works are limited in high
evaluation costs (e.g., relying on humans or advanced LLMs) and insufficient
evaluation dimensions (e.g., types of tasks and hallucinations). In this paper,
we propose an LLM-free multi-dimensional benchmark AMBER, which can be used to
evaluate both generative task and discriminative task including existence,
attribute and relation hallucination. Based on AMBER, we design a low-cost and
efficient evaluation pipeline. Additionally, we conduct a comprehensive
evaluation and detailed analysis of mainstream MLLMs including GPT-4V(ision),
and also give guideline suggestions for mitigating hallucinations. The data and
code of AMBER are available at https://github.com/junyangwang0410/AMBER. | [
-0.0096720885,
0.0651064515,
0.0036791761,
0.0826130286,
-0.0611185879,
0.0290949121,
0.0159293413,
-0.0064300294,
-0.0038557374,
-0.0323535316,
-0.0573089235,
-0.0549753271,
-0.0067922166,
-0.0204500277,
0.0225278828,
-0.0073213596,
0.0526357777,
-0.0573983639,
-0.0335081667,
-0.0116974851,
-0.0183747932,
-0.0094188293,
-0.0120065361,
0.0311490707,
-0.0139611354,
-0.0447326191,
-0.0021936707,
-0.0035788743,
0.0197059233,
0.0068930797,
-0.0292974375,
0.0602224767,
0.0052703605,
0.058978729,
0.0000018659,
-0.0679086894,
-0.000679313,
-0.0013558782,
-0.0021129779,
0.0225986615,
0.0278709866,
0.0148428539,
0.0050079934,
-0.0038365799,
-0.0117093306,
-0.0393564068,
0.0512085408,
0.0831451342,
0.0429730862,
0.0665046424,
-0.02088161,
-0.0593572557,
0.0471181832,
-0.0008681982,
0.0618086532,
-0.0320078023,
0.0490353815,
0.0017016255,
0.0004689297,
-0.0262499377,
-0.0060857222,
0.0558963418,
0.0333566926,
0.0217068251,
-0.0107936878,
0.0410953574,
-0.0473683476,
-0.0353383906,
0.0208966229,
0.0699228719,
-0.025331825,
-0.0353415832,
0.0065977378,
0.0102666682,
0.0109792836,
-0.0131503865,
-0.028418161,
0.0321554653,
-0.0089710997,
0.0223061666,
0.0334530957,
0.0028484324,
0.0514492691,
0.0098565258,
-0.0490448624,
0.0486007258,
0.0398009233,
-0.0499080643,
0.0294042192,
0.0061092898,
-0.0328253508,
-0.0258170776,
-0.0044190143,
-0.015898576,
-0.0489917062,
-0.0153543996,
-0.0456549637,
0.0011589411,
0.0230757371,
-0.0676804259,
0.0463014729,
-0.0021021937,
-0.0523718894,
0.0665151849,
-0.0498395376,
0.0476019494,
-0.0336019434,
0.0521938801,
-0.0101111028,
0.0010035157,
-0.0237921514,
0.014369118,
-0.025381688,
0.0048619043,
-0.0184317902,
-0.0272346288,
-0.0231244545,
-0.0119150979,
-0.0394039303,
0.0192393269,
-0.0335837491,
0.0044002607,
0.0260860045,
-0.0235999152,
0.0182609037,
0.0002694129,
-0.0255360194,
0.0038845479,
-0.0058630905,
-0.0716867223,
-0.0221855994,
0.0619451441,
-0.0112825623,
-0.0331293792,
0.021256553,
0.0671229884,
0.0128864236,
-0.0493101776,
-0.031532269,
0.0012038704,
-0.0379445814,
-0.1155351847,
0.032028906,
-0.061518278,
0.0108836787,
0.0074026762,
0.0011034703,
-0.0396671779,
0.0018739378,
0.00191584,
-0.0071450435,
0.1039022729,
0.0086577162,
0.0006146384,
0.0165089611,
0.0352030098,
-0.0019198621,
0.0775191113,
0.0263029579,
0.0298947114,
0.0020554538,
-0.0265999287,
0.0588649847,
0.0366703682,
-0.0115277627,
0.0169600043,
-0.0514806658,
0.0007411608,
0.0103722811,
0.0657654628,
-0.0065852697,
0.0751403719,
-0.0395777188,
-0.0381433442,
0.053761255,
0.0136846462,
0.0243761651,
0.0330418721,
0.0408818163,
0.004532035,
0.0095441816,
0.0164180119,
-0.0688489601,
0.0240021124,
-0.0598163977,
0.0176349189,
0.0328863487,
0.0230334233,
-0.0411871225,
-0.0300903823,
-0.0246160179,
-0.0195933543,
-0.021293534,
0.0135308392,
0.062229082,
-0.0116636464,
-0.0612780862,
0.0238345284,
0.0157633256,
-0.0337533094,
-0.0087728854,
-0.0709539726,
0.0120424824,
0.0645779446,
0.0394481309,
-0.0468322635,
-0.0122363465,
-0.0276669078,
0.0302718673,
0.0449491702,
0.0162970573,
0.0084200278,
0.0353884958,
-0.062520124,
-0.0089923702,
0.0182994828,
0.0499198362,
-0.0024672623,
0.0061940425,
-0.0132511714,
0.0099735167,
-0.0496174954,
-0.0237549823,
0.0414656997,
-0.0029526656,
-0.0197870377,
-0.005770796,
-0.0226921905,
0.0391697288,
0.0084539568,
-0.022475088,
0.0256567243,
0.0384002887,
-0.0567460768,
-0.0288834516,
0.015774345,
-0.0431429259,
-0.0160597339,
0.0385920107,
-0.0064510098,
-0.0339988992,
0.0223805793,
-0.0191520359,
-0.0450696833,
0.0102498652,
-0.042745173,
0.0190506056,
-0.0595522262,
0.0416793637,
-0.0020681613,
0.0566198491,
-0.0165875144,
0.0861425772,
-0.0197327882,
0.0377022065,
0.0179245453,
0.020566294,
-0.0052178032,
-0.0234863125,
-0.0658187345,
0.0253544208,
-0.0060152011,
0.0439300314,
-0.0401339419,
-0.0178279355,
-0.0522907265,
-0.0378894806,
-0.0757931992,
0.004783418,
-0.0259047151,
0.00318931,
-0.0153098386,
-0.018940663,
-0.0147337038,
0.0061923317,
0.0042539779,
-0.003572328,
-0.0011430935,
0.0478007123,
-0.0144724883,
-0.0122819394,
-0.0550258532,
-0.0046929829,
0.0031497546,
-0.0012508222,
0.0663319528,
-0.0220512357,
-0.0248104353,
-0.0630704165,
0.0360377394,
-0.003779063,
0.0189659689,
-0.0100378143,
0.0157237202,
0.0003338068,
-0.0340035222,
0.072538577,
0.05860167,
0.0048964699,
0.0215237811,
0.0712316185,
-0.036372073,
-0.0307919439,
-0.0000733915,
0.016791191,
-0.0014202439,
-0.0242092069,
-0.0070725265,
-0.0214901417,
0.0610413998,
-0.0122695211,
0.0039918851,
-0.0403083749,
0.0064989603,
-0.0308778267,
-0.0677395463,
-0.0083670244,
0.034179803,
-0.0445103049,
0.0227656811,
-0.016047148,
-0.0552013032,
0.0411153436,
-0.0524009354,
-0.0323616415,
-0.0192425922,
0.0016617948,
-0.0223032478,
0.0461542048,
-0.0029906018,
0.0096714664,
-0.0132684298,
-0.0246364418,
-0.0126781808,
0.0111210058,
-0.0322281159,
-0.0419690087,
0.0714442283,
-0.0378046818,
0.0364850201,
-0.0113495393,
-0.0180707928,
-0.0337581597,
-0.0337844566,
-0.0213849004,
-0.0205828827,
-0.0473781303,
0.0009744419,
-0.0446126349,
0.0163512714,
-0.0027498198,
0.0411515757,
-0.0198170729,
-0.0140348068,
0.0046807416,
0.0178827867,
0.0482943915,
0.0105570555,
0.0466891713,
-0.042677138,
0.0062727341,
0.0370236151,
0.0117638865,
0.0417592451,
-0.0496755019,
0.0135746002,
0.0336151719,
0.0024093627,
-0.023931114,
0.0174515583,
0.0276900269,
-0.0286741871,
-0.0258326251,
0.1081807464,
0.0177605506,
-0.080330506,
0.0001095078,
-0.0173433032,
0.0677176863,
0.0031083957,
-0.0111051183,
-0.0731897429,
-0.0368492715,
-0.0034651225,
-0.0179946441,
0.0003836806,
-0.0304236412,
0.002148553,
-0.0826688558,
0.0602737367,
0.0184315909,
-0.0430111475,
-0.0257753767,
-0.0239511579,
-0.0023891097,
-0.0091987317,
0.0307712145,
-0.0128031485,
-0.0043604197,
-0.0414305441,
0.0114207827,
-0.026479695,
-0.0707387105,
0.0524621233,
-0.0380546972,
0.072644785,
0.0597130992,
0.0382987075,
-0.0195423365,
-0.0736141875,
0.0354016647,
-0.0087739406,
-0.0338405035,
0.0029260321,
0.019989416,
0.0145111419,
-0.0107139498,
0.0032735269,
0.0295841731,
-0.0507964976,
-0.0124061964,
-0.0017305613,
0.0790420026,
-0.0299991965,
-0.0473995879,
-0.0000804859,
-0.0002380834,
-0.0076896446,
0.1122180149,
0.0361919254,
-0.0357635096,
-0.0496410504,
0.0013090534,
0.0343645886,
-0.0322290212,
-0.0544781983,
0.0224626083,
0.0356176496,
-0.0044270568,
-0.0388437025,
-0.0205908939,
0.0397560485,
0.0331733301,
-0.0228348039,
0.023040494,
-0.0542164221,
-0.0119353039,
-0.0313017257,
0.0299904887,
-0.0433486328,
0.0364413559,
-0.0404876918,
0.0125297215,
0.0532277301,
-0.0160659868,
0.0098921629,
0.0699889287,
-0.108459577,
-0.0514790714,
0.0238948595,
0.0163875502,
0.0324969403,
0.05179758,
-0.0298670474,
-0.049380634,
0.0093211122,
0.020777721,
0.0143541396,
0.0330060199,
0.0347136669,
-0.0030347742,
-0.0007803992,
0.0415529646,
-0.0028366556,
0.0105266757,
0.0278741773,
0.0137257781,
0.0113140149,
0.000523173,
0.0036653331,
0.0034509946,
0.0142894099,
-0.0361946858,
-0.0126983635,
-0.0235252138,
-0.0032741907,
-0.0148110362,
0.0006419478,
-0.0450709984,
-0.0187938716,
0.0651760474,
-0.0099653061,
0.0020348991,
0.0084004775,
0.0201095399,
-0.0129873389,
-0.0484984517,
0.0001290486,
0.0245545171,
-0.0249084327,
0.0461616181,
-0.0072999005,
-0.0344861746,
0.0001118187,
-0.0032630132,
0.0402281396,
0.0025997125,
0.0749978647,
-0.009318213,
-0.0088351918,
-0.0210535396,
0.0333888978,
-0.0226637274,
-0.0462805852,
-0.04261351,
0.0662206113,
0.0723391399,
-0.0048377612,
0.09854123,
-0.0217562523,
0.008137159,
-0.0581541769,
0.0378035195,
0.0126677388,
-0.0219745524,
-0.0062371041,
0.0406682752,
-0.0279405322,
0.0062152073,
0.0810774714,
0.0269548148,
0.0527032539,
0.0117791565,
0.009474325,
-0.0579369403,
-0.0695869997,
-0.0358903259,
0.0027317784,
-0.0497382209,
-0.0256333258,
-0.0661926344,
-0.0764310583,
0.0034293632,
-0.000503037,
0.009733296,
0.0120561132,
0.0076609715,
0.0647635013,
-0.0377919935,
-0.008415929,
-0.0171733666,
-0.0433768034,
0.0646316111,
-0.0176384132,
-0.0133573785,
-6.232388029e-33,
-0.0054277079,
-0.0149773024,
0.0464143157,
-0.0192300472,
-0.0111407405,
0.0042643202,
-0.01756173,
0.0357011892,
0.0053490913,
0.0112430742,
0.0111649111,
0.000831876,
0.0249023046,
0.0227126423,
0.0097343773,
-0.018846143,
0.0342849307,
0.0019109403,
0.0012203699,
0.0233419277,
0.0032855158,
0.0023731852,
0.0383669361,
-0.06328208,
0.0260217469,
-0.0158520639,
-0.0479949713,
0.0217957608,
-0.065374434,
0.0500415005,
-0.0674679577,
0.0577546097,
0.0299506579,
-0.0305459779,
-0.0407613218,
-0.023003174,
-0.0450042263,
-0.0086307414,
-0.0014458809,
0.0159774292,
-0.0527200811,
-0.0145165157,
0.0482946709,
0.0108305737,
-0.0170733221,
-0.0059170886,
0.018146392,
-0.0398459062,
-0.0372915231,
0.0247815624,
-0.0636532158,
0.023347402,
0.0119582219,
-0.0002268171,
0.0501173213,
0.017592039,
-0.0130327363,
-0.0057204389,
-0.0694650114,
0.0026357961,
-0.0016709927,
-0.0058261822,
0.074060455,
0.0205318946,
0.0200909749,
0.0708244145,
0.0939159915,
-0.02319034,
-0.0186027642,
-0.0008263335,
0.0454900041,
0.0782654956,
0.0387823395,
0.0319322348,
0.006087543,
0.0335603394,
-0.0347593874,
-0.0148006845,
-0.0312076043,
0.017978996,
0.0755589828,
0.0268202163,
-0.0366443135,
-0.0453557894,
-0.0211418346,
0.0232911594,
-0.0504212789,
0.0098317815,
0.049574323,
0.0084781814,
-0.0288841743,
-0.0118844174,
0.051980909,
-0.0428277478,
-0.0030775836,
0.0024320863,
0.0010068885,
0.0374999642,
0.0021747162,
0.0160636511,
-0.0066343201,
-0.0448669903,
0.0160358045,
-0.0166515391,
0.0385442041,
-0.0147598209,
0.0163857397,
-0.0002864341,
-0.0649357215,
0.0012823994,
-0.0400521383,
-0.0061954758,
0.0269683693,
0.033957541,
0.0410185568,
-0.0271389429,
-0.0101184621,
0.0453533493,
0.032322824,
0.0518268198,
0.0008047544,
0.0100943847,
-0.0144888554,
0.0113793407,
0.0037760094,
0.0060100057,
-0.0288048126,
-0.0433227308,
0.0618123636,
-0.0374476053,
-0.0024168652,
0.0048423922,
2.606e-7,
0.0027258829,
0.0351985507,
0.0290649887,
-0.0110172508,
0.0107857659,
0.0444010161,
-0.0084968526,
0.001904145,
0.0016388005,
-0.0228078626,
-0.0227844417,
0.0334040448,
0.0848501772,
0.0333153792,
-0.0902961865,
0.0005610506,
-0.0239576027,
0.0376448557,
-0.065973483,
-0.0106399236,
0.0376158357,
0.0754273608,
0.0156418383,
-0.0212054104,
0.0191120338,
-0.0624157824,
0.0633144826,
-0.0520065948,
-0.015796192,
0.0259111933,
0.054652039,
0.0087800771,
0.0343778245,
0.0407312065,
0.0261803046,
-0.0302652884,
0.0441688299,
0.0679415762,
0.0030105575,
-0.0348821282,
-0.0128977178,
-0.0028575754,
-0.0055591217,
-0.0560329035,
0.0916226208,
-0.0133610759,
-0.0322701223,
-0.02273155,
-0.0354697667,
-0.0339570716,
0.0606594756,
0.0077024275,
0.0014407912,
-0.0033368473,
-0.0008702942,
0.0004880432,
-0.0197639931,
-0.0664755255,
0.0025779528,
-0.0169855431,
-0.0715563223,
-0.0214992203,
-0.0318256505,
0.0158649236,
0.0243239775,
-0.0702830926,
-0.0119272415,
2.679859879e-34,
0.0280438736,
0.0063113929,
0.0530718081,
0.0415797941,
0.0321120732,
-0.0081977956,
-0.0129301213,
0.011185376,
-0.0568517298,
-0.0926507041,
-0.001643199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07387v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07387v2 | Assessing Logical Puzzle Solving in Large Language Models: Insights from a Minesweeper Case Study | 2023-11-13T15:11:26 | 2024-04-16T22:51:51 | Yinghao Li, Haorui Wang, Chao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable proficiency in language
understanding and have been successfully applied to a variety of real-world
tasks through task-specific fine-tuning or prompt engineering. Despite these
advancements, it remains an open question whether LLMs are fundamentally
capable of reasoning and planning, or if they primarily rely on recalling and
synthesizing information from their training data. In our research, we
introduce a novel task -- Minesweeper -- specifically designed in a format
unfamiliar to LLMs and absent from their training datasets. This task
challenges LLMs to identify the locations of mines based on numerical clues
provided by adjacent opened cells. Successfully completing this task requires
an understanding of each cell's state, discerning spatial relationships between
the clues and mines, and strategizing actions based on logical deductions drawn
from the arrangement of the cells. Our experiments, including trials with the
advanced GPT-4 model, indicate that while LLMs possess the foundational
abilities required for this task, they struggle to integrate these into a
coherent, multi-step logical reasoning process needed to solve Minesweeper.
These findings highlight the need for further research to understand the nature
of reasoning capabilities in LLMs under similar circumstances, and to explore
pathways towards more sophisticated AI reasoning and planning models. | [
0.0166515131,
0.0195116382,
-0.0471733697,
0.0191508569,
-0.0809451491,
0.0121391108,
0.0205012988,
-0.0170490872,
0.0232322831,
0.000302585,
-0.0023211224,
0.0211984776,
-0.0501876809,
0.0367863663,
-0.0098803518,
0.0058367946,
0.0370117016,
-0.0844264925,
-0.0127038397,
0.0057234471,
-0.0557799898,
-0.0040630964,
-0.0400747359,
0.0065419343,
-0.0037342971,
-0.0104442481,
-0.0540319309,
-0.0276653487,
0.023487946,
-0.0578378625,
-0.0472506136,
0.0189101268,
0.0218486562,
0.0461952686,
0.0000019602,
-0.0419036038,
-0.0438430756,
-0.0136497086,
-0.0494766533,
-0.045163881,
-0.0521387868,
-0.0477926359,
-0.0289267972,
0.0240983889,
-0.0613645092,
0.0207628626,
0.0470547602,
0.027429102,
0.0678289533,
0.0483723097,
0.009997963,
-0.006724034,
0.0271601733,
0.0020155655,
0.0187055729,
-0.0716050118,
0.0067827292,
0.0647988766,
0.0495678112,
0.0264033917,
-0.0117246397,
0.0074873618,
0.052161552,
0.0040252018,
-0.0631678924,
0.0333824456,
0.0196131226,
0.0226879418,
-0.0094260499,
0.0351434425,
-0.0212529767,
-0.0046256827,
-0.0027853455,
-0.0110954642,
-0.0116904443,
-0.011028816,
-0.0561524779,
0.0683485046,
-0.0368788093,
0.0108194575,
0.0036099292,
-0.0050162366,
0.0326127931,
0.0166811682,
-0.0340351537,
0.1607932746,
-0.0497098193,
-0.0349057056,
-0.0112407357,
-0.007302233,
-0.0037009704,
-0.0475380495,
0.0255442355,
0.0855061337,
-0.0398936383,
0.0248335842,
-0.0007054218,
0.0114367651,
0.000583732,
-0.0023513408,
0.0154881636,
0.0671261698,
-0.0078611132,
0.062670961,
-0.0271060746,
0.0615731664,
0.0042502042,
0.0452158749,
-0.0144968536,
0.0053073429,
-0.0554767027,
-0.0354412571,
-0.046374809,
-0.0045713265,
-0.0081380168,
-0.0146031007,
0.0280076675,
0.0324562937,
-0.0114420513,
0.0379218608,
-0.0040692887,
-0.0122181242,
0.0153654283,
-0.053245794,
-0.0404170528,
-0.0229982585,
-0.0541543774,
0.0159412585,
0.0111749806,
-0.0394721478,
-0.0265670717,
-0.0024949862,
0.0032154482,
-0.0253294501,
-0.0038498032,
0.0692093745,
-0.0053070458,
-0.0144942896,
-0.0628500506,
-0.0281384811,
-0.0275836885,
-0.0879015028,
0.0388876051,
-0.0555130914,
0.0144863613,
0.007291052,
-0.0129879527,
-0.0198186077,
0.0228386875,
-0.0242336411,
0.0148521243,
0.0744512677,
0.0413052961,
0.0153218303,
0.0025333567,
0.0278663691,
0.0059001758,
0.0598572418,
0.0458003059,
0.0810622722,
-0.0367493257,
0.0154363317,
0.0110880695,
0.0204591397,
-0.0391073897,
-0.0276913568,
-0.0028483353,
-0.0020796198,
-0.0044648643,
0.0354126953,
-0.0151039083,
0.0016743162,
-0.007853711,
0.0041724686,
0.039802555,
0.0584151112,
-0.0017154935,
0.0190479737,
0.0461920239,
-0.0169264805,
0.0000433365,
-0.0010055453,
-0.0464886948,
0.0476038568,
-0.0153009342,
-0.003134487,
-0.017906921,
0.0333186612,
0.0185608789,
-0.058901187,
-0.024525281,
0.0198835731,
0.0210662559,
0.0097109061,
0.0534394309,
-0.0194349177,
-0.0389228947,
-0.0127366269,
-0.0230295267,
0.0111544169,
-0.0151621178,
-0.070174858,
0.0092280339,
0.0643651038,
0.0265630949,
-0.0665390566,
-0.0775179043,
0.0201911442,
-0.0154064372,
0.0236830264,
0.0095661022,
0.0105902897,
-0.0165064819,
-0.0355470069,
-0.0315368548,
-0.0389519483,
0.0295511652,
0.0233895015,
0.0273336414,
-0.0077455593,
-0.0175507255,
-0.0197007116,
0.0276411809,
0.0250910725,
0.0168350041,
0.0107039986,
-0.0450512879,
0.0111109102,
0.0177918542,
-0.0244732536,
0.0036328465,
0.0054245139,
0.0316564701,
-0.0118407765,
0.0018582266,
0.0006280737,
-0.0323474519,
0.0002666984,
0.032681983,
-0.0174583308,
-0.0279187448,
0.0147507396,
-0.0547955818,
-0.0274242051,
0.0286802184,
-0.0367636532,
0.0080348942,
-0.0232756361,
0.0357878096,
-0.016661318,
-0.0404219739,
-0.0541937761,
0.074111864,
0.0044229063,
-0.0487327687,
-0.0204097833,
-0.0111147547,
0.0453370847,
-0.0574743636,
0.0271460935,
0.0343419313,
-0.0079414276,
0.0004159337,
-0.0176391397,
0.0011265529,
-0.0330339335,
-0.073863253,
-0.0297036059,
0.0015829236,
-0.0027227278,
0.0135828517,
0.0187321324,
-0.0347984098,
-0.0155382333,
0.005629966,
-0.0140701244,
0.0118091926,
0.0391769111,
-0.0151144946,
0.0112486836,
0.0187042542,
-0.0125058265,
-0.0095346393,
-0.0199122243,
-0.0472906381,
-0.0108847385,
0.0246040095,
-0.000803722,
-0.0437765941,
0.0502977408,
-0.0081814174,
0.0107018091,
-0.0313857757,
-0.0293912943,
0.0378786437,
-0.0201314613,
0.0255890787,
0.0755364299,
-0.029792456,
0.0606391281,
0.1078205183,
-0.0263935681,
-0.0402833894,
0.0462502129,
0.001093552,
-0.0039712801,
-0.0401928239,
-0.035667073,
-0.0392724834,
0.0509901866,
-0.0154954353,
0.0179616734,
-0.0142956479,
0.0321157575,
0.0233185794,
-0.0297675002,
-0.0047053429,
-0.0181248169,
0.008758191,
0.078269884,
-0.0502601489,
-0.0320815928,
0.0636343583,
-0.0318280831,
0.000847508,
-0.0445474349,
0.0006042242,
-0.0199073162,
0.0968822688,
0.0012908352,
0.0160764754,
0.0539951324,
-0.0114404066,
-0.0518664494,
-0.0287662446,
-0.0144031644,
-0.0210145973,
0.0095479498,
-0.0602998547,
0.0145370821,
0.0182696544,
-0.0420595147,
-0.0418501608,
0.026280025,
-0.0562332161,
0.0447760373,
0.0003269913,
-0.0477687977,
-0.0594908819,
0.0376898162,
0.0777045265,
-0.0040005734,
0.0062394203,
-0.0058138166,
-0.0452914461,
0.016129991,
0.0554113425,
0.0690426007,
0.0342285223,
-0.017407814,
0.0280617196,
0.0144947944,
0.0093781156,
0.0238672774,
-0.0368558951,
0.0378627256,
0.0130865164,
0.0259141531,
0.0146181695,
0.0305187069,
0.0094875628,
-0.0583855286,
-0.0402965285,
0.0537235588,
0.0456404388,
0.0333407484,
-0.0114821168,
-0.0275609586,
-0.0045225192,
0.0055874567,
0.0450911187,
-0.0131290928,
-0.0244934373,
0.0352282822,
-0.04467934,
-0.0150108449,
-0.0407037102,
0.0016838756,
-0.1083878502,
0.065819189,
-0.0131223109,
-0.0414040573,
-0.0328348801,
-0.0215337183,
-0.024989428,
0.0296420641,
-0.0169486571,
0.0044133733,
0.0188432317,
-0.0093115754,
0.0140693951,
-0.0164439175,
-0.0096743191,
0.0208592564,
-0.0205764994,
0.0543837287,
0.10748294,
0.0042976532,
-0.0137937507,
-0.0149901118,
0.0125780618,
0.075351879,
0.0399496257,
-0.0092927823,
0.0049880459,
0.0343549326,
-0.0020287368,
-0.0022207622,
-0.0249515288,
-0.0203827061,
-0.0504532717,
-0.0040665795,
0.1167981923,
-0.0566822253,
-0.0073290858,
-0.0019117342,
0.0343794711,
-0.0278137363,
0.0351437144,
0.0030770516,
0.0166089609,
-0.0743247047,
-0.0488122329,
-0.0063409028,
-0.0669189394,
-0.0126803536,
0.0640143007,
0.0424443111,
0.0291193519,
-0.0305413119,
-0.0417414941,
0.0566443652,
0.0323742591,
0.0164581407,
-0.0266467407,
-0.0018634931,
0.0296569318,
-0.0488008186,
0.0240108799,
-0.0299415309,
0.033328034,
0.002702828,
-0.0004049439,
-0.003871531,
-0.1091401055,
-0.0149966963,
0.0196597185,
-0.049746681,
-0.0140177533,
0.0097486647,
0.0381140634,
0.0301280431,
-0.0414185077,
-0.0341702551,
-0.0166055206,
0.0117457109,
0.0037289367,
-0.0421987958,
-0.0030135796,
0.0068772654,
0.0247782655,
0.0035052137,
0.0010187253,
0.0041944566,
0.0270064753,
0.039915368,
0.0421503335,
-0.0625764653,
-0.0064642224,
0.0311439913,
0.0045599672,
0.0269661732,
0.0420377366,
-0.0019231812,
-0.0192664471,
-0.0015761991,
-0.0055149384,
-0.0238434169,
-0.0303443708,
-0.0063545867,
0.027401818,
0.003689545,
0.0353351831,
0.0073819333,
0.0335401781,
-0.00570584,
0.0363624096,
0.0212842654,
0.0203262363,
-0.0157356765,
0.0317942426,
0.0026329882,
0.0031415273,
0.0366376303,
-0.000295898,
0.03932596,
0.032473322,
0.0503095277,
0.0315240324,
-0.0397202559,
-0.0484799407,
0.0181998815,
-0.0827941969,
-0.1095023081,
0.0451499075,
0.0321874432,
0.0934616327,
0.0077082021,
-0.0226196852,
-0.0693393424,
0.0225713886,
0.0120986933,
-0.038286645,
0.0749858096,
-0.0144471144,
0.0391279198,
0.0565582737,
-0.0091328891,
-0.0611686446,
0.0096224481,
0.0072027696,
0.0695414245,
0.0010752986,
-0.035567984,
-0.0096295262,
-0.0450812392,
-0.0064222729,
0.0487201884,
-0.0217805672,
0.0082682008,
-0.0578381829,
-0.0467190333,
-0.0097018285,
0.0728520453,
0.0218134671,
-0.0030508686,
0.0034606948,
0.0586466193,
0.0087326495,
-0.0488808081,
-0.0094394814,
-0.0362188406,
0.029501278,
-0.006711714,
-0.0232281182,
-5.582108595e-33,
-0.0257148109,
-0.0736093447,
0.0659311712,
-0.0198643394,
-0.0024665461,
-0.0445623733,
-0.0488010496,
0.0177130606,
-0.0383566916,
-0.0066485824,
-0.0239692237,
0.0289440714,
0.0207212269,
-0.0222225618,
0.0006577093,
-0.0011909313,
0.0205700453,
0.0263181515,
-0.0355346724,
-0.0213477109,
0.0221780874,
-0.0147817787,
0.0072582262,
-0.0214396585,
-0.0188086871,
0.0482751876,
-0.0280610584,
0.0303176306,
-0.084251672,
0.0454628356,
-0.0202213991,
-0.0175842997,
0.0398052335,
-0.035967309,
-0.0017132041,
0.0306792781,
-0.0408105366,
0.0009744109,
0.0015375967,
-0.005907678,
0.0072615612,
-0.0537515096,
0.0092745936,
-0.0034545485,
0.0078988019,
-0.0149977729,
0.0222253297,
-0.0423111431,
0.0401349775,
0.048438292,
-0.0523034669,
0.0183007605,
-0.0234083105,
-0.0453184694,
0.054822877,
-0.0043500327,
0.0279711597,
0.0016417052,
0.0061879274,
0.0588501282,
0.028976677,
0.0008404754,
0.0627862588,
0.0283857603,
-0.0306025781,
0.0681461245,
0.0459476598,
-0.0013345529,
-0.0160121769,
-0.0237930343,
0.0054660495,
0.0756076649,
0.0184427481,
0.0212546345,
0.0360653363,
0.0392129123,
-0.0765829012,
0.0106899375,
-0.0200122818,
0.0602612272,
0.0687609985,
0.0106824096,
-0.016760543,
0.0074471273,
-0.0260860771,
0.0563666932,
-0.0249766782,
-0.0117727742,
-0.0011719654,
0.0050848713,
-0.0153404586,
0.0020093694,
0.0322293788,
-0.0269501936,
0.0492970236,
0.009266017,
0.0054942509,
0.0360143147,
-0.0149069661,
0.0462881811,
-0.0192745663,
-0.0410527475,
-0.007388223,
-0.0355271697,
0.0077304565,
0.0238975529,
-0.0316507034,
0.0311221853,
-0.0254277308,
-0.006616645,
-0.0718392506,
-0.004679821,
0.0173846856,
-0.0550039224,
0.0256489441,
-0.0079299416,
-0.0104196658,
-0.0400520526,
0.0216474999,
-0.0766279101,
0.0005216204,
-0.0093276203,
-0.0516036488,
0.0014133838,
0.0235229488,
-0.0232481733,
-0.0479498692,
-0.001214117,
-0.0086396411,
-0.0267158393,
0.0041577867,
0.0407623388,
2.8e-7,
0.0211853683,
0.0333681963,
-0.0063771633,
0.0615518577,
0.0230168831,
0.0178347472,
-0.0614890568,
-0.0448549762,
0.0074756173,
-0.0177319013,
0.0118276058,
0.0974871069,
0.0353774913,
0.0447139554,
-0.0345800333,
0.0516512692,
0.0200526994,
-0.0537681915,
-0.0797123462,
0.0368719921,
0.0761461854,
0.0370969102,
-0.0072633848,
0.0015502498,
0.0019618075,
-0.0785668269,
-0.0025294807,
-0.0240429528,
0.050931368,
0.0226377323,
-0.012740924,
-0.0391747728,
-0.0473254733,
0.0485787094,
0.0296571888,
-0.0234946441,
-0.0067861937,
0.0587989725,
0.0187837798,
-0.0091332197,
-0.0314033404,
-0.0434872322,
-0.004923061,
-0.0686541796,
0.0518726595,
-0.0415337011,
-0.031984847,
0.0274258088,
0.0281756576,
-0.0423878208,
-0.0529674031,
0.0135257021,
0.0016008661,
-0.0144027565,
-0.0231553409,
-0.0029976254,
0.0291672368,
-0.0342522301,
0.0083253533,
0.0257117227,
-0.0448827818,
-0.0593502969,
-0.049974516,
-0.0107809259,
0.0412570797,
-0.0249043182,
-0.0304464176,
2.364232528e-34,
0.0053829853,
-0.0105211437,
0.0090287561,
0.0279144999,
0.0486176088,
0.0366656631,
-0.0055253515,
0.0160797928,
0.0198210794,
-0.0797575116,
-0.0125183128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07383v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07383v1 | LM-Polygraph: Uncertainty Estimation for Language Models | 2023-11-13T15:08:59 | 2023-11-13T15:08:59 | Ekaterina Fadeeva, Roman Vashurin, Akim Tsvigun, Artem Vazhentsev, Sergey Petrakov, Kirill Fedyanin, Daniil Vasilev, Elizaveta Goncharova, Alexander Panchenko, Maxim Panov, Timothy Baldwin, Artem Shelmanov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advancements in the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have
paved the way for a myriad of groundbreaking applications in various fields.
However, a significant challenge arises as these models often "hallucinate",
i.e., fabricate facts without providing users an apparent means to discern the
veracity of their statements. Uncertainty estimation (UE) methods are one path
to safer, more responsible, and more effective use of LLMs. However, to date,
research on UE methods for LLMs has been focused primarily on theoretical
rather than engineering contributions. In this work, we tackle this issue by
introducing LM-Polygraph, a framework with implementations of a battery of
state-of-the-art UE methods for LLMs in text generation tasks, with unified
program interfaces in Python. Additionally, it introduces an extendable
benchmark for consistent evaluation of UE techniques by researchers, and a demo
web application that enriches the standard chat dialog with confidence scores,
empowering end-users to discern unreliable responses. LM-Polygraph is
compatible with the most recent LLMs, including BLOOMz, LLaMA-2, ChatGPT, and
GPT-4, and is designed to support future releases of similarly-styled LMs. | [
0.0207504537,
0.0866440907,
-0.0088011948,
0.0335185863,
-0.0592209995,
-0.0216906816,
0.0116148079,
-0.0184634086,
0.018400427,
-0.0554508008,
0.0082711466,
-0.0985409394,
0.0320973396,
0.0391038768,
0.0315411501,
-0.0263062734,
0.0271639973,
-0.0348070972,
0.0310091302,
0.0042788368,
0.0137738483,
0.0176267084,
-0.0041048918,
0.0581431314,
-0.0236419011,
-0.0061972952,
-0.0115708467,
0.0278846119,
0.020173138,
-0.0329309478,
-0.0069262278,
0.073106952,
0.0029044778,
0.0489339903,
0.0000022688,
-0.045715794,
-0.0273113213,
-0.0096912701,
-0.0051387674,
0.050065957,
0.0725758374,
0.0230904333,
-0.0341534615,
0.0443230122,
-0.0082526617,
0.026098527,
0.0497089252,
-0.0231159981,
0.0253829546,
0.0422750749,
0.0021066451,
0.0315574631,
0.0063371891,
-0.0128979934,
-0.0018688221,
-0.0198507346,
0.0225784574,
-0.0202225801,
0.0121260406,
-0.011293062,
0.0095302658,
0.0310663357,
-0.0027434435,
-0.0203482714,
-0.0445210114,
0.0214855969,
-0.0078951614,
-0.0642142519,
0.0010653679,
0.036607828,
0.0080861142,
-0.0191012211,
-0.0087438533,
-0.0146390665,
-0.0118876742,
0.03178408,
-0.0534611195,
0.0559869446,
-0.0065596756,
-0.0062314766,
0.0170231108,
-0.0047575724,
0.0127901761,
0.0109601561,
-0.012123581,
0.0663907006,
0.0426116548,
0.0124027263,
-0.0209062621,
0.0128298169,
-0.0324780568,
-0.0655930266,
0.0341527797,
0.0314503349,
-0.0514313765,
0.023270499,
-0.0644892305,
-0.0166841447,
0.0436216146,
-0.0087475711,
0.0015297831,
0.0348522551,
0.0146276448,
-0.0216913354,
0.0151002696,
0.0354056172,
0.0109681739,
-0.0379575789,
-0.0244397689,
0.0193412211,
0.038220413,
-0.0163102616,
-0.0237241834,
0.0018274285,
-0.0130751757,
-0.0177840237,
-0.0725930184,
0.0328874104,
-0.015465647,
0.0247330498,
-0.0170999244,
-0.0000261575,
-0.0268113241,
-0.0190463513,
-0.0049714134,
0.0253376178,
0.0000207794,
0.0084798792,
0.0225782432,
-0.0879931897,
-0.0058384598,
0.0429012477,
0.0055842213,
-0.0078997631,
-0.0204847343,
0.04779635,
-0.0063342662,
-0.0275688525,
-0.0176634137,
-0.0528479479,
-0.0453361012,
-0.0581040084,
-0.0251708683,
-0.0951845199,
-0.0082905022,
0.0206406862,
0.0080710072,
-0.0489786528,
0.0275783986,
0.0244494546,
-0.0127512971,
0.0394084528,
-0.0432753898,
0.0282303169,
0.0247996505,
0.0222652964,
0.0101730218,
0.0699156001,
0.0595871769,
0.0230055694,
0.0467516929,
0.0158970356,
0.0269859489,
0.0406210274,
0.01045385,
0.0020773441,
-0.0181242321,
-0.0511916727,
-0.0196379609,
0.0360931717,
-0.0247545354,
0.093300961,
-0.0088078743,
0.0128955953,
0.0954528749,
0.0258194078,
-0.0262916051,
-0.0346346349,
0.0453450754,
0.0163900852,
0.0396407209,
0.0267350469,
-0.0023900429,
0.0119194295,
-0.0329748429,
0.0501371138,
0.0486040339,
0.0697489753,
0.0140981656,
-0.0512876883,
-0.0579276346,
-0.0150944088,
-0.004194662,
0.0048404434,
0.0259308387,
-0.0254339613,
-0.0447581746,
0.036352206,
0.0245544314,
-0.066234149,
0.0130372019,
-0.062024042,
0.0364808552,
0.0564565696,
0.0806251764,
-0.0184355509,
-0.0161421578,
-0.0101002697,
-0.0065383581,
0.0688256323,
0.0295836385,
0.0013768842,
-0.0020831176,
-0.0602054708,
0.0020009864,
0.008448232,
0.0247601252,
-0.0021437209,
0.036428608,
-0.0023190733,
0.0539635047,
-0.0324364789,
-0.0216296744,
0.0163098183,
-0.0324164554,
0.0040891776,
-0.0194672924,
-0.0299720485,
0.0310235862,
0.0201056562,
-0.0288826004,
0.0431314707,
0.0237557404,
0.0063573765,
-0.001651039,
0.0099499226,
-0.0106561622,
-0.0041374043,
0.0659772158,
0.0012130897,
-0.0041712271,
-0.0102026891,
-0.0129345879,
-0.0371289179,
0.0144970575,
-0.0461864769,
0.0064413566,
-0.0442190915,
0.0545413382,
0.0195593107,
0.0106348693,
-0.0449521765,
0.0416593812,
-0.0074703372,
0.0200877264,
0.0402108841,
0.0020569204,
0.004857501,
-0.0297922827,
-0.0328876786,
0.0026807862,
-0.0063936003,
0.018369237,
0.0420686528,
0.0289746001,
-0.0201642867,
-0.0349025726,
-0.0746494904,
0.0258141328,
-0.015063704,
0.0330277532,
0.011419476,
0.0071806093,
-0.0303695165,
0.0380176641,
-0.0346542783,
-0.0108828312,
0.0207457002,
0.0169934742,
0.0411758535,
-0.0164494645,
-0.0249008033,
-0.0575303696,
-0.0091070859,
-0.0134554096,
0.0368817151,
0.0292396247,
-0.0260935556,
-0.0607264042,
0.0399075672,
-0.0618244633,
-0.0170843005,
0.0186271891,
-0.0525462665,
0.0129363397,
-0.0071450998,
0.0707409009,
-0.0031486533,
0.0338486843,
0.0335394703,
0.0662198365,
-0.0455663688,
-0.0211769715,
-0.0057140714,
-0.0495402627,
-0.0217617266,
0.0230066311,
-0.0734173283,
0.0205429681,
0.0548512079,
0.0204619262,
-0.0296915323,
-0.0392848998,
0.0310137104,
-0.0185705964,
-0.019274421,
0.0071547013,
-0.0211942866,
-0.0209585242,
0.037646804,
0.0030134581,
-0.0597591586,
0.0537679754,
-0.0782664642,
0.0229454692,
-0.015358598,
-0.0095692752,
-0.0045284806,
0.0314271599,
0.0226658043,
0.0267412607,
0.0254210066,
-0.0110215945,
-0.0543619916,
0.0305772014,
0.0312842987,
-0.0689291805,
0.0112928208,
-0.0822168514,
0.0068219714,
0.0039310893,
0.0066383095,
-0.0403432921,
-0.0424858481,
-0.0346864723,
-0.017354209,
0.0438618436,
-0.0361049995,
0.0187938288,
0.0200058818,
0.008146476,
0.0181176495,
-0.0307325665,
-0.0044979178,
-0.0152529348,
0.0166360475,
0.0570290089,
-0.0045508747,
0.087089099,
-0.0557260476,
-0.0145858228,
0.070054017,
-0.0064736279,
0.034595225,
-0.0025264802,
-0.0421008989,
0.036638435,
-0.0212435573,
-0.0227775127,
0.0570349284,
0.0708834454,
-0.0302212536,
-0.016260989,
0.1378688663,
0.0414143205,
0.0004620359,
0.0137245096,
-0.0300333053,
0.1036120802,
0.0031789895,
0.0090349568,
-0.0903320611,
-0.0231897533,
0.0191429444,
0.0354489647,
-0.0547779612,
-0.0113953091,
-0.0276946463,
-0.1309239566,
0.0535631068,
0.0315859355,
-0.0073971772,
-0.0194474179,
-0.0170078892,
0.00921336,
0.0278113596,
0.0369052589,
0.0282494258,
-0.0093133803,
0.0209171344,
0.0265037585,
-0.0724680051,
-0.0622492507,
-0.0583583303,
-0.0511483327,
0.0739301071,
0.0003846267,
0.0383680202,
0.010993531,
0.0116149578,
0.043208126,
-0.0067285914,
-0.0249088015,
-0.0143526606,
0.0264736954,
0.031720724,
-0.007937043,
-0.0329457186,
0.0112549663,
-0.0293483939,
-0.0383431874,
-0.0067352043,
0.0294684879,
-0.0176933911,
-0.0053922571,
-0.0111285951,
0.0403421484,
0.020883467,
0.0684575662,
0.0273621939,
-0.0112426132,
-0.0372451507,
-0.0473694578,
0.0383870415,
-0.0130067756,
-0.0159697179,
0.0076123192,
-0.0066812458,
-0.0307857841,
-0.0935624316,
-0.0004511476,
0.0159327667,
-0.000915214,
-0.0010642862,
-0.0189765505,
0.0274780635,
-0.0204651318,
-0.038121108,
-0.0183897428,
-0.0211270172,
0.0392223001,
-0.0598830953,
0.0255543627,
0.0050110989,
-0.0099041229,
0.0076040146,
0.08645197,
-0.1170005277,
-0.1044876054,
-0.0043955049,
0.0414726585,
0.0320552625,
0.0047040796,
-0.0116070993,
-0.0491340347,
0.0382027216,
0.047924608,
-0.0129525969,
0.0161836408,
-0.0033589299,
0.0232082233,
-0.0144234579,
0.0146659603,
-0.007031553,
-0.0228399727,
-0.0444353521,
0.0591179542,
-0.0064772367,
-0.0900185853,
0.0114341546,
0.0540981069,
-0.0148686608,
-0.0558044575,
0.0086463122,
-0.0444291607,
-0.0049338969,
-0.0557867326,
-0.0269130655,
-0.0463382564,
-0.0000457124,
-0.0047166785,
-0.0238879286,
-0.024575524,
-0.0218896475,
-0.0239055436,
0.0605876632,
-0.0063310852,
-0.0139991436,
-0.0348996036,
0.0050548483,
0.0398180783,
-0.0586308874,
-0.0159316584,
0.0212992094,
-0.028247701,
0.0364994295,
0.016928453,
0.0362246409,
-0.0158629753,
-0.0424352139,
0.0217009317,
0.0137904007,
-0.0417913347,
-0.0553940721,
-0.0589854904,
0.0521867946,
0.0428918563,
0.0349276811,
0.0872283131,
-0.0671983734,
0.006183702,
-0.0423725806,
0.0630182102,
0.0256556366,
-0.0112061277,
0.0337981582,
-0.0091392677,
-0.0434333198,
0.0046856524,
0.086394988,
0.029137833,
0.0236239228,
-0.0128419269,
-0.0781686604,
-0.0252500921,
-0.0589199886,
-0.0349538065,
0.0240000952,
-0.0236607362,
0.0015751758,
-0.0694288909,
-0.0669101253,
-0.000400642,
0.0357136726,
0.0164492466,
-0.034981776,
-0.007383354,
0.0472858399,
-0.0012828568,
0.0174828693,
-0.0324662849,
0.021243941,
-0.0116341859,
0.0186343361,
0.0001446423,
-7.005057363e-33,
-0.0524140149,
-0.0917528421,
-0.0278312452,
-0.044340346,
-0.0180516392,
-0.010022644,
-0.0391076356,
0.0447545089,
0.035774909,
0.0069971061,
0.0141987177,
-0.0035029419,
0.0224258211,
0.0123562608,
-0.0127938334,
0.0151100382,
0.036546912,
0.0188998226,
-0.0298170019,
0.0059851296,
0.0577606671,
-0.0037385051,
0.0444437936,
-0.0504166521,
0.0344375595,
-0.0203549284,
-0.0553356744,
0.0199042652,
-0.0316718929,
0.0357591882,
-0.0143873161,
0.0475943759,
-0.0145163452,
-0.0059041702,
-0.0263784211,
-0.0098193679,
-0.012637876,
-0.0228320304,
0.0130881518,
0.0162278954,
-0.0149569027,
-0.0186565202,
0.0192507617,
-0.0149281835,
-0.0301555302,
0.0100718252,
0.0078776609,
-0.0256236233,
-0.0210337639,
-0.0321468227,
-0.057939183,
0.039177347,
0.0014532891,
-0.0076939403,
-0.0213595815,
0.042033609,
-0.0183933508,
-0.0212212838,
-0.0225352664,
0.0229683965,
0.0339579992,
0.0464151315,
0.0744355321,
0.0075296285,
-0.0225448459,
0.0380499326,
-0.0189750083,
-0.0138670634,
-0.0164489076,
0.0022161452,
0.0040054945,
0.0173498727,
0.034033224,
0.0770520493,
-0.0079767276,
-0.0198156126,
-0.057432726,
0.0331888124,
0.0383082032,
-0.0016459195,
0.0435788259,
-0.0068193553,
-0.0197129156,
-0.0454203635,
-0.0415280908,
0.0014242296,
-0.0214587245,
-0.0109831691,
0.0019371357,
0.0112364078,
-0.0417567194,
-0.0255984012,
0.0298977569,
-0.0103568844,
-0.0346286558,
0.004939077,
-0.0565200709,
0.0214425437,
-0.0217697285,
0.0494951494,
-0.0240811519,
-0.0046003973,
0.0283968858,
-0.0213153902,
-0.0011111118,
0.0278205164,
-0.0184548348,
0.0289394222,
-0.0633287504,
0.0279197469,
-0.0474274643,
0.0330376141,
0.0077295695,
-0.0364992134,
0.0359100997,
-0.0458119661,
-0.0269046873,
0.0464751124,
0.0256217383,
0.0293931533,
-0.0240850206,
0.0032187006,
-0.0053997175,
-0.003995853,
-0.0493050776,
-0.0006498049,
-0.0101241479,
-0.0283177197,
0.0337223783,
-0.0252099894,
-0.0293417778,
-0.0247038044,
2.93e-7,
0.052223105,
0.0575659536,
0.0260439645,
0.0638016909,
0.0153473755,
0.0190085601,
0.0103270439,
-0.0031175462,
0.0232579298,
-0.0062929709,
-0.002961687,
-0.0079262676,
0.0786990151,
0.0497680716,
-0.034393888,
-0.0261108596,
-0.0443759263,
-0.0023212067,
-0.0491957814,
-0.0181882121,
0.0682502538,
0.0712999478,
-0.0060074995,
0.0122358873,
-0.006349457,
-0.0306503419,
0.0758353248,
-0.0292027891,
-0.0608380064,
0.0518838875,
0.0794663802,
-0.0128216473,
0.005935675,
0.0078596044,
-0.0164656844,
-0.0327450037,
0.0145914732,
0.0538350716,
0.0410050191,
0.0038574308,
0.0245199278,
-0.0156443194,
0.0314424112,
-0.0630551428,
0.0588221811,
-0.0216803346,
-0.0278591216,
-0.0597712845,
-0.0000400574,
-0.0478704199,
0.0214263722,
-0.0426341146,
-0.0155057982,
0.0335234404,
-0.0041438527,
0.0261716228,
-0.0222578142,
-0.0104474211,
-0.0604693256,
-0.0055261892,
-0.0352645442,
-0.0584688187,
-0.0095157996,
-0.0054679322,
-0.0039196792,
-0.0777747333,
0.0110122152,
3.189826751e-34,
0.0507608615,
0.0062529533,
-0.0037703523,
0.0467673317,
0.0632464513,
0.0076385164,
0.0167232547,
0.0168302879,
0.0127919232,
-0.0570257418,
-0.0246517062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07635v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07635v1 | Past as a Guide: Leveraging Retrospective Learning for Python Code Completion | 2023-11-13T14:40:33 | 2023-11-13T14:40:33 | Seunggyoon Shin, Seunggyu Chang, Sungjoon Choi | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | This work presents Past as a Guide (PaG), a simple approach for Large
Language Models (LLMs) to improve the coding capabilities by integrating the
past history with interactive and iterative code refinements. To be specific,
inspired by human cognitive processes, the proposed method enables LLMs to
utilize previous programming and debugging experiences to enhance the Python
code completion tasks. The framework facilitates LLMs to iteratively refine the
Python code based on previous execution and debugging results and optimize
learning and reasoning capabilities. The proposed methodology achieved a 92\%
pass@1 on HumanEval, demonstrating the potential to advance the field by
leveraging retrospection from past experiences and interactive and iterative
refinement processes without external correctness indicators. | [
0.0296102501,
0.0633765906,
-0.0180220436,
-0.0441053733,
0.0166538768,
0.0371103026,
-0.0464880131,
0.0096814306,
0.043908447,
0.0043338239,
0.0107178623,
0.0450269729,
0.0162825435,
0.0059126355,
0.0109805316,
-0.0398137569,
0.0370322429,
-0.0305570345,
-0.0143170459,
0.0153558273,
-0.0408760607,
0.0145588201,
-0.0123405112,
0.0597099178,
0.0028009405,
-0.0300909858,
-0.0277093984,
-0.0090555251,
-0.0269267969,
-0.0492356122,
-0.0083816797,
0.0028404291,
0.0363461263,
0.0125978198,
0.0000025048,
-0.0107283937,
0.0005856943,
-0.0004871123,
-0.0213575661,
0.0445149839,
0.031566415,
0.0749416351,
0.0191939697,
0.0115163354,
-0.035399802,
-0.0151429288,
0.0267329328,
-0.0206799414,
0.093189612,
0.0216729548,
0.0390705019,
0.0053217374,
0.0202566329,
0.0260437243,
0.0257409513,
-0.0271790437,
0.0032511586,
0.054430645,
0.0380487926,
-0.060367655,
0.0283333939,
0.0288018603,
0.0327769741,
-0.0222098995,
0.0095978016,
0.0144503666,
0.0039897589,
-0.0106780641,
0.0192270223,
-0.0053963372,
-0.0531691201,
-0.066210486,
-0.0458836108,
-0.0064726048,
-0.0572859831,
-0.0470869318,
-0.078778781,
-0.0013372893,
-0.0135605931,
-0.0104712462,
-0.0029904994,
-0.0905943587,
0.0336293019,
0.0183124524,
-0.0360755473,
0.0948477238,
0.0040640063,
-0.00115175,
-0.0394625999,
0.0099961041,
0.0274383891,
-0.0121529792,
0.0348283611,
0.0775587112,
-0.0441202335,
-0.0171761885,
0.0091151921,
0.0104394518,
0.0016250247,
-0.0046709683,
0.0207637642,
0.0344615318,
-0.0064368346,
0.0210405681,
-0.0584361181,
0.0634381771,
-0.0242691152,
-0.0256727189,
-0.0528574847,
0.0281454548,
-0.0575212277,
-0.018895939,
-0.0348588116,
0.0344486572,
0.055894345,
0.0749639273,
-0.0135187525,
0.0444170795,
-0.0123127876,
0.0593344197,
-0.0598974116,
-0.0093634995,
-0.0056410977,
0.0034021763,
-0.0003754655,
-0.0067247916,
-0.0106138801,
-0.0281463359,
-0.0010410273,
-0.0225976668,
-0.0131155597,
-0.0217260215,
-0.0591586381,
-0.0527911484,
0.0261737611,
0.045155108,
-0.0031171716,
0.04671048,
-0.0721501485,
-0.0406579189,
0.0548501685,
-0.0241203718,
0.0217554513,
-0.0939029455,
-0.0713061616,
0.0214186944,
0.0116776507,
-0.0627182797,
-0.0025041997,
0.0005597168,
-0.0150975017,
0.0369368121,
-0.0293401126,
0.0110857049,
0.0487972796,
0.0194661114,
0.0090317195,
-0.011449581,
0.0155962314,
0.0168310404,
-0.0092464061,
-0.0639977083,
0.0484169126,
-0.0307712741,
0.0049090399,
-0.0026517576,
-0.0444324501,
0.0080753881,
0.0299201272,
-0.0116973668,
-0.0050129411,
0.0048822975,
-0.0103229415,
0.049195461,
-0.009072952,
-0.0106304502,
-0.0081711095,
0.0249727126,
0.046443224,
0.004944602,
0.0402605124,
0.0166641455,
-0.0448572747,
0.0373008326,
0.0055950661,
0.0055040382,
-0.0387318991,
0.0432924666,
-0.0059247487,
-0.0489820279,
0.0292363539,
-0.0019700809,
0.0157142561,
0.0153499795,
0.0647912621,
0.0048830849,
-0.0338916071,
0.0465504825,
0.0368248671,
-0.0727758408,
-0.0237283166,
-0.0452905223,
0.0715024844,
0.0598459914,
0.0727555454,
-0.0692133829,
-0.0270954315,
-0.0427096784,
-0.0179262217,
-0.0565070994,
0.0237448961,
-0.0134357791,
-0.0137128308,
-0.037145786,
-0.0250973534,
-0.0060277143,
0.0115430914,
0.0286840182,
0.046802789,
-0.0394358523,
0.0237901509,
0.0230274908,
-0.0475726128,
0.0697958246,
-0.0250707641,
-0.0256505795,
-0.0252577439,
-0.0219038688,
0.0172387343,
-0.0173114967,
-0.002373812,
0.0341373384,
0.0569798686,
0.0196770635,
0.0131530855,
-0.0315589458,
-0.0630955845,
0.0172889289,
0.0358019993,
-0.0065943184,
-0.0540418848,
0.0507723466,
-0.0051980373,
-0.0073638856,
0.0415096767,
-0.0013632049,
0.0596200563,
0.0012859928,
0.0784817338,
-0.0593669489,
-0.0326810591,
-0.0379648581,
0.0220396966,
0.0474976674,
0.034833923,
0.0077029467,
0.0025578071,
0.0338863395,
-0.0035714828,
-0.0387228839,
0.0101078199,
-0.0009981915,
0.0477768369,
0.021911798,
0.0380177125,
-0.0480038561,
0.0037315884,
-0.0753670484,
-0.0105785551,
0.0028585044,
-0.0218675695,
-0.0040046205,
-0.0108563192,
0.0064599086,
-0.0361944996,
0.0430131108,
-0.0117777279,
-0.0352626629,
0.0187056288,
0.0155003909,
0.0198609121,
-0.0613548346,
-0.0723649487,
-0.0233429242,
-0.0284126643,
0.0577486865,
0.0056013451,
0.0009698019,
-0.0563228205,
0.0477618687,
-0.0045156088,
0.0328133181,
-0.0264565516,
-0.047643058,
0.0388325676,
-0.0327551775,
0.0562577993,
0.0523213185,
-0.0359230079,
-0.0194224659,
0.0813797042,
-0.0138130859,
-0.0586467087,
0.0200567618,
0.0027522102,
-0.0765030682,
0.0204133745,
0.0377664454,
-0.0292741898,
0.0394272953,
-0.0336755365,
-0.0299924109,
-0.0213634931,
0.0185602773,
-0.0025228364,
0.0064962716,
-0.015743725,
-0.0449800342,
-0.0031336462,
0.0240545385,
-0.0244665742,
-0.1195855439,
0.0826724246,
0.0258802939,
-0.0072001042,
-0.00336061,
-0.0389123522,
-0.010682649,
0.1121267825,
0.0320012942,
0.011086883,
-0.0213990007,
-0.0617453605,
-0.03177955,
0.0124772275,
0.0046178605,
-0.014588207,
0.0517775044,
-0.0546316691,
-0.0057732314,
0.03449158,
-0.0067760171,
-0.0462686904,
0.016597895,
-0.0622975677,
-0.0012318795,
-0.0087722791,
-0.0059853066,
-0.0118612424,
0.0015330676,
0.0584026054,
0.0124401655,
0.0519115217,
-0.0328000784,
0.0210938901,
-0.0555300526,
-0.0660633445,
-0.071137391,
-0.0083630504,
-0.0071982061,
0.0280270129,
0.0058489814,
0.0716374665,
0.0330954008,
-0.0577271283,
0.0074280384,
0.0225460455,
-0.0503512919,
-0.0625727847,
0.043233607,
0.0028326351,
-0.1208159775,
-0.0366081856,
0.0529307388,
0.0399923585,
-0.0446814932,
0.0287614688,
-0.0293779783,
0.0017979856,
0.0541728549,
0.0506945066,
-0.0326321274,
-0.0149084777,
0.0062967618,
0.0171980057,
-0.0065935976,
-0.0080460608,
-0.0026422055,
-0.0833166093,
0.0074665337,
0.0423167646,
0.0198663287,
-0.0215680823,
-0.0392699689,
-0.0299546849,
0.0137367751,
-0.047534205,
0.0984635428,
-0.0030205473,
0.0330746472,
0.0038000795,
-0.0427742302,
0.0225324109,
0.0600172132,
-0.0048256423,
0.0045462111,
0.0590897202,
0.0009610869,
-0.0170519501,
-0.0028813162,
0.0324694328,
0.0024076521,
0.0239304006,
-0.0311316028,
0.0300659388,
0.0355431661,
-0.008724167,
0.0306564048,
-0.0241644047,
-0.035343796,
-0.0459288284,
0.0295957085,
0.0781371742,
-0.0160486624,
-0.0041722655,
-0.0024762929,
-0.0458810292,
-0.0325177945,
-0.0043995511,
0.0284610931,
-0.0034761732,
-0.0490667671,
-0.0526862293,
-0.0289056655,
0.0069979141,
0.0021140822,
0.0009591207,
0.0017862829,
0.0203749873,
-0.0160037689,
0.0301959179,
0.0459937155,
0.0230522398,
0.0158294719,
0.000635936,
-0.0181724485,
-0.0131782228,
-0.0890820771,
0.0178671777,
-0.001987393,
0.034149278,
-0.0499266759,
-0.0237384327,
0.0102280946,
-0.0222493969,
-0.0228344761,
0.0460539013,
-0.0661119819,
-0.0175330583,
0.0211667214,
0.0488992445,
0.0275147315,
0.0277242176,
-0.0281728487,
-0.042762436,
-0.0157652646,
-0.0059757787,
-0.0202955361,
0.0004054965,
0.0007996508,
0.0201352872,
0.0293382965,
-0.0212552045,
-0.0318463966,
-0.0589531884,
0.0211302433,
-0.0139395772,
0.0028013049,
-0.0235456061,
0.044660002,
0.0705030859,
0.0227457993,
0.0132592665,
-0.05361389,
-0.0203116499,
0.0102474401,
0.0068127504,
-0.0103655215,
-0.0573929921,
0.0144655649,
0.0018794601,
-0.0231142137,
0.0673329607,
-0.0301338229,
-0.0038858899,
0.0737101212,
-0.0388027355,
0.0681658685,
0.0032312686,
0.0472026952,
0.1111886576,
0.0046223737,
-0.0206312332,
-0.0142280599,
0.0104610249,
0.0532700494,
-0.0162653197,
0.035381306,
0.0052250074,
0.0128591172,
-0.0024372782,
-0.0108174216,
-0.0558915436,
-0.0945908278,
-0.0177380033,
-0.0017503788,
0.0487679504,
0.0291343946,
0.0261917915,
-0.0168059636,
0.0046997997,
-0.0309564937,
0.0390144028,
0.0075520966,
-0.0571761802,
-0.0253581572,
0.0359723233,
-0.0069987834,
0.0138468333,
0.0700200722,
-0.0396997482,
0.0682948902,
-0.043056719,
-0.0255974382,
-0.0116002187,
-0.0065679015,
0.0619464852,
0.0034620147,
-0.0182628576,
-0.0054088878,
0.0006208272,
-0.0601347648,
-0.0255568456,
0.0319559723,
-0.0007974382,
-0.0272991452,
0.0351538807,
0.0630478933,
-0.008920894,
-0.026018206,
-0.0120004704,
0.0127668902,
0.0348022096,
-0.0352616496,
-0.0524087884,
-5.841232733e-33,
-0.0401588604,
-0.0322889797,
0.0349927805,
0.0091548506,
-0.0358008333,
-0.0406408384,
-0.0369660594,
0.038250275,
-0.0015711415,
-0.0137114339,
-0.0096279988,
0.0284379404,
-0.0108002843,
-0.032813482,
0.0476039127,
0.04486553,
0.0479745902,
0.0489478111,
-0.0166736543,
0.028531855,
-0.0118274959,
0.0540681854,
0.031733945,
-0.041761674,
-0.0421551876,
0.0329110995,
0.0010394842,
0.0049617048,
-0.0380822383,
0.0567577444,
0.0148380427,
-0.0322621502,
-0.0045348154,
-0.0257117096,
-0.0348783396,
-0.0431445725,
-0.017183423,
-0.0200731717,
-0.009072952,
0.0144832702,
-0.0054206196,
-0.0292517599,
0.0516976006,
-0.0087152692,
0.0028183907,
0.0071671596,
0.0007662216,
-0.0407814644,
-0.0237110835,
0.0177390538,
-0.0484700203,
0.0352818817,
-0.0455318019,
-0.0137792584,
-0.0135456342,
-0.0021592486,
-0.0421470106,
0.0142892748,
0.0109182326,
0.0085323006,
0.0301574338,
0.0423503332,
0.0526969843,
0.0057854671,
-0.0002428511,
0.0053963885,
0.0526163988,
0.0101317363,
-0.0345052853,
0.0238916855,
0.0195954554,
0.0277180206,
0.0037988762,
-0.0265339874,
-0.0279081445,
-0.043790713,
-0.0386865921,
0.0077335145,
0.0119101861,
0.0960971937,
-0.0022241012,
0.03405267,
-0.0092480117,
-0.0198318679,
-0.089526549,
0.039476525,
-0.0066247811,
-0.0224167593,
-0.0014296953,
-0.0175775364,
-0.0503072813,
-0.0310339443,
-0.0063867513,
-0.0040533212,
0.004755504,
-0.0166204181,
-0.0678285882,
0.0350565203,
-0.0099449437,
0.0302155893,
-0.0115490993,
0.0152909784,
-0.0248087123,
-0.0485878773,
0.0906941444,
-0.0102464342,
0.0006123345,
0.0611829571,
-0.0589534342,
-0.000330179,
-0.0433317982,
-0.0573273078,
0.0177126937,
0.0055516781,
0.0362519696,
0.0036136978,
-0.0041472828,
0.0288940221,
-0.0166151244,
-0.0282401498,
-0.0474241376,
0.0048140287,
0.0493320301,
-0.0070698657,
-0.0196033735,
-0.0369618051,
-0.0504876263,
0.0271913018,
0.0512557253,
-0.001870187,
-0.0363145992,
0.044624839,
3.129e-7,
-0.0135134924,
0.0640513599,
0.0080706282,
0.0402783304,
-0.0135606192,
0.027678147,
-0.0475611538,
-0.0609556027,
0.0162735041,
0.0272059143,
-0.0008249732,
0.0014712991,
0.0497370474,
0.0309072603,
-0.024973698,
-0.021921644,
0.0080535393,
-0.0223668143,
-0.0543712564,
-0.0373000354,
0.0251607299,
0.0360151082,
0.0588996485,
-0.0047953208,
0.0408715717,
-0.0559541136,
0.0115417941,
-0.0058743577,
0.0029745875,
0.0356306471,
-0.0217646137,
0.040651124,
0.0098552229,
0.0030323535,
0.0063463314,
-0.0791627094,
0.0046151406,
0.0404995531,
-0.0018098496,
0.0717367679,
0.0190644898,
0.0061115371,
0.0192008,
-0.0818821043,
0.0114656733,
0.0254212823,
-0.0170357339,
-0.0104782833,
-0.0279470403,
-0.0031768221,
0.0038240014,
0.0243877489,
0.0237970222,
0.0055826991,
-0.0148290331,
0.0431520082,
-0.0544562563,
-0.0311536267,
-0.0568098761,
0.0180743337,
-0.0351419486,
-0.0349747613,
-0.0258001741,
-0.0326245762,
0.0086272117,
-0.053664811,
0.0471821427,
2.950204064e-34,
0.0315466709,
-0.0471218117,
0.0313570201,
0.0376227647,
0.0261853784,
-0.0100731626,
-0.0039216671,
0.0174969584,
0.04028235,
0.0215992257,
-0.0252436735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07362v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07362v4 | Volcano: Mitigating Multimodal Hallucination through Self-Feedback Guided Revision | 2023-11-13T14:26:24 | 2024-04-02T04:12:43 | Seongyun Lee, Sue Hyun Park, Yongrae Jo, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Large multimodal models suffer from multimodal hallucination, where they
provide incorrect responses misaligned with the given visual information.
Recent works have conjectured that one of the reasons behind multimodal
hallucination is due to the vision encoder failing to ground on the image
properly. To mitigate this issue, we propose a novel approach that leverages
self-feedback as visual cues. Building on this approach, we introduce Volcano,
a multimodal self-feedback guided revision model. Volcano generates natural
language feedback to its initial response based on the provided visual
information and utilizes this feedback to self-revise its initial response.
Volcano effectively reduces multimodal hallucination and achieves
state-of-the-art on MMHal-Bench, POPE, and GAVIE. It also improves on general
multimodal abilities and outperforms previous models on MM-Vet and MMBench.
Through qualitative analysis, we show that Volcano's feedback is properly
grounded on the image than the initial response. This indicates that Volcano
can provide itself with richer visual information through feedback generation,
leading to self-correct hallucinations. We publicly release our model, data,
and code at https://github.com/kaistAI/Volcano}{github.com/kaistAI/Volcano | [
0.009302781,
0.0511425361,
0.0030269129,
0.0346363187,
-0.0142444624,
-0.0126773836,
-0.0095948176,
-0.0011152488,
0.0098848734,
-0.0570115037,
-0.0587496907,
-0.009395781,
0.0081467293,
0.0328070484,
0.0338539779,
-0.0809100866,
0.0230353065,
-0.0300891828,
-0.0399292894,
-0.0227658581,
0.0040664459,
-0.0266394671,
-0.0267118923,
0.0401343293,
-0.0281948037,
-0.0511284508,
-0.0628694668,
0.0257649198,
-0.0030242421,
-0.0183063038,
-0.0101224277,
0.0708125457,
-0.0015472909,
0.0305511486,
0.0000022412,
-0.0420609675,
0.0079326853,
-0.0287374463,
0.0528605916,
-0.0087897507,
0.0268456973,
-0.0256459285,
-0.00125755,
-0.0337144993,
-0.0213965513,
0.0044506826,
0.093583554,
0.0414709933,
0.1119066253,
0.044171501,
-0.0118828751,
-0.0627864227,
0.0078340452,
0.0368151702,
0.0556114726,
0.0547828339,
0.0015787968,
0.0256886221,
-0.0187254511,
-0.0286042243,
-0.0639442131,
0.0308149476,
0.0182027239,
0.0019495132,
0.0511800312,
0.0067009032,
-0.0257029664,
-0.0760606676,
-0.0373470709,
0.039995648,
-0.0216332339,
-0.022798663,
-0.0152100502,
0.0306638554,
0.0153745618,
0.0015774587,
-0.0290218145,
-0.0043185879,
-0.024665745,
0.0017602638,
-0.0684986636,
0.0093091773,
0.0182655919,
-0.0439637788,
-0.0016640233,
-0.0079955682,
0.0312008057,
0.0003372248,
0.0009880508,
0.0033662431,
0.0060355235,
-0.0479275398,
0.0368060432,
0.0187529661,
-0.0549112074,
-0.0494922735,
-0.0498423688,
-0.0140495496,
0.0100758867,
-0.0776163042,
0.0363404639,
0.0114466567,
-0.0822757855,
0.0470345356,
-0.003042199,
0.0395532474,
-0.0234450772,
0.077912271,
0.0071345209,
0.0270227157,
-0.0423144922,
-0.0108594066,
-0.0529142618,
-0.0145102143,
0.0241713058,
-0.0327082612,
-0.0237075631,
-0.0079181185,
-0.0381905288,
0.0379736833,
-0.057802964,
0.0396203324,
-0.0158002712,
-0.0281773712,
-0.0160624292,
0.0435173064,
-0.0070600412,
-0.0329978168,
0.0136403115,
-0.0485819504,
-0.0054076714,
0.0191698838,
-0.0252047721,
0.0076194648,
-0.0252616331,
0.0931064859,
0.0116158603,
0.0041125729,
-0.0169772394,
-0.0177280437,
-0.0295553356,
-0.0393730849,
0.0458264425,
-0.0250204988,
0.0301029962,
-0.0408104211,
0.0032900267,
-0.0303345397,
0.0230058599,
0.0066545359,
-0.0014392422,
0.1103996858,
-0.0588066764,
-0.0176200904,
0.0357897617,
0.032139685,
-0.0414541736,
0.0400564969,
0.0361162908,
0.0318491049,
0.0227530655,
-0.0474165007,
0.0800986066,
0.0202907883,
-0.0186258107,
-0.0098492717,
-0.0419951081,
-0.0301917382,
0.0020636348,
0.0549134053,
0.024479704,
0.044063922,
-0.019832436,
-0.0474843085,
0.0724268928,
-0.0183679946,
-0.0090844641,
-0.0024772235,
-0.0083494866,
-0.0082718106,
-0.0111237522,
0.0124339312,
-0.0676280335,
0.0956599712,
-0.0254195184,
-0.003231094,
0.0615261681,
-0.0107458839,
-0.0330616273,
-0.0495289527,
0.0012623339,
0.007616464,
0.0042149024,
0.0123661011,
0.0075523476,
0.0478546992,
-0.0523227043,
-0.021546552,
-0.004300694,
-0.0543146096,
0.01839393,
0.0012992603,
0.0115683302,
0.0837795213,
0.0545684285,
-0.0177188087,
0.0002138008,
-0.0379079543,
0.0088504301,
0.0587500036,
-0.0093122851,
0.0207376946,
0.0322269127,
-0.059006393,
-0.0308680907,
-0.0262248795,
0.0216624532,
-0.0005873823,
-0.0375064313,
-0.0110908858,
-0.0283076856,
0.004750351,
0.0216381419,
0.0409137085,
0.0697388947,
-0.0153790778,
-0.0390761867,
-0.0169183351,
0.0135274641,
0.0081061311,
0.0026058562,
0.0140036121,
0.0025628272,
-0.0160759836,
-0.0268146452,
0.0324550942,
-0.047334902,
-0.0245057028,
0.0447681285,
-0.0381208137,
0.0112123042,
0.0014923512,
-0.0016899786,
-0.0152188176,
0.0420009196,
-0.0141068585,
0.0022447465,
-0.0373883471,
0.0138581628,
0.0266552847,
0.0264387056,
0.0041038329,
0.0210949015,
-0.0404341929,
-0.0181441419,
0.0043310756,
0.0183172766,
-0.0060623921,
0.0027627656,
-0.0269127991,
0.0266394839,
-0.0073271333,
0.0043298341,
-0.0200334229,
-0.0358144753,
-0.0619993061,
0.0136992922,
-0.0577007085,
-0.0276310109,
-0.0412893072,
-0.0418490693,
0.0374289379,
-0.0138087198,
0.0136130853,
-0.0585844554,
-0.0029149614,
0.0455464274,
-0.0127832154,
0.0451130792,
0.0012172216,
-0.0185295679,
0.0042064912,
-0.0291475374,
-0.0034760956,
0.0242546815,
0.0418989956,
-0.0012212869,
-0.058327131,
-0.0614464134,
-0.0151864188,
-0.0441129766,
0.0200691298,
0.00282972,
-0.0221378114,
0.0300969798,
-0.0092446376,
0.0845581517,
0.0367646962,
0.0181506667,
0.0142342234,
0.0709464997,
-0.0411855318,
-0.0116373617,
-0.0131539628,
0.0117657371,
-0.0212476589,
0.019231325,
-0.0039107734,
-0.0014849554,
0.0402678922,
0.019010352,
0.0280830767,
-0.0671991333,
0.0367418341,
0.0021528881,
-0.0759723186,
-0.0105543882,
-0.0121399481,
-0.0115185371,
0.0022053411,
-0.0156010892,
-0.0577594005,
0.0690566003,
-0.027433617,
-0.0312011372,
0.0419103317,
0.0599346161,
0.0474037081,
0.0635954365,
0.0423207469,
0.0234037414,
0.0074642058,
0.0089321733,
-0.0172770135,
0.0018012412,
-0.0016275585,
-0.0192000587,
0.0138929896,
-0.0365255326,
-0.011937188,
0.0123598007,
0.0082929293,
-0.0421852916,
0.017837815,
-0.0144109698,
-0.0292921085,
-0.077845715,
0.0297718626,
-0.0271757133,
0.0064539681,
0.0291261654,
0.0106911026,
-0.0092827035,
-0.0454893485,
0.0085911341,
-0.0198060293,
0.0250744112,
0.0399149358,
0.0051505291,
-0.0464874022,
0.0282496866,
0.0918512642,
0.046914693,
0.0004144934,
-0.048678115,
0.0360333882,
-0.0049296748,
0.0145930806,
0.0095962249,
0.0156358294,
0.0822912827,
-0.063811034,
-0.0159203298,
0.0545090362,
0.0291919019,
-0.0909920633,
0.0103398459,
-0.056145981,
0.045008935,
0.0231365617,
-0.0074128332,
-0.0632843971,
-0.0491968654,
-0.0009261459,
-0.0083990041,
0.0247035716,
0.0031127152,
-0.008947744,
-0.041988045,
0.0626602322,
0.0396136157,
-0.0027407189,
-0.0230495017,
0.0184448939,
0.0084931692,
0.0050629419,
-0.0038574936,
0.0312138833,
0.0187977925,
-0.0168948341,
-0.0082496339,
0.0120342309,
0.0107384315,
0.0060812999,
-0.0331010297,
0.0255200099,
0.0762344748,
0.0002508529,
0.0254979059,
-0.0702355281,
0.0143875359,
0.0253818203,
0.0305855572,
0.00449264,
0.0626411363,
-0.0031232939,
-0.0009813632,
0.014370664,
0.0219334923,
-0.028647,
-0.0319110602,
0.025190454,
0.023072958,
-0.0651459098,
-0.0197950453,
-0.0404979475,
0.0477461442,
-0.0180270039,
0.0134648932,
0.0316787884,
-0.0499391109,
-0.0518941805,
-0.0368261226,
0.0723514259,
-0.0448869318,
-0.0660684109,
-0.0028425385,
0.076634638,
-0.0102518685,
-0.0639377758,
-0.0435578711,
0.0180348884,
0.0222296789,
-0.0026498947,
-0.011915219,
-0.0332315825,
-0.0050302469,
-0.0093231359,
0.0404509604,
-0.0130029144,
-0.0189358387,
-0.0350428149,
0.009237566,
0.023483187,
0.0048268014,
0.0261969846,
0.0539814979,
-0.0466698781,
-0.0452447049,
0.0321681723,
0.0998991802,
0.0212020986,
0.0605003797,
0.0016988976,
-0.0344576314,
0.0079615302,
0.0315133706,
-0.0129135773,
0.0227570534,
0.0212339703,
0.0095008025,
-0.0097465115,
0.0047722575,
-0.0231995005,
-0.0158104412,
-0.010932358,
0.0316916592,
0.0206664298,
0.0000429197,
0.0267767143,
-0.0499849804,
0.0387024246,
-0.0433319993,
0.0540688038,
0.004488125,
-0.0076371818,
-0.0162932463,
-0.0054570339,
-0.0422714166,
0.0353890657,
-0.0006544523,
-0.0355816633,
0.0197845008,
-0.0305226073,
-0.0287827458,
-0.0342951864,
-0.0550195873,
-0.0441569462,
0.0288017783,
-0.0313253626,
0.0025365984,
0.0137514081,
-0.0079666628,
0.046963159,
0.0005731226,
0.0123685738,
-0.0032072638,
0.0883211792,
0.0035673555,
-0.0305693652,
-0.0257518701,
0.0556157269,
-0.0169279296,
-0.0474721529,
-0.0331049934,
0.0214026291,
0.0537593849,
0.0618810765,
0.0178734977,
-0.0063444278,
0.0023417021,
-0.0289583355,
0.0475865677,
0.039174445,
-0.0558073781,
0.0087198019,
0.0042320928,
-0.0101086786,
-0.0114972554,
0.029830331,
-0.0261535645,
0.0212040655,
-0.0018397124,
0.0112580387,
-0.0501873568,
-0.0333686396,
-0.0477259271,
0.0327524133,
-0.0270663314,
-0.0213940348,
-0.0119980173,
-0.0225994196,
-0.0166989714,
0.0211121701,
0.000740418,
0.0023420285,
0.0558891967,
0.0269555729,
-0.023852922,
-0.0407093875,
0.0089326696,
-0.0014807887,
0.0280728471,
-0.0123352055,
0.0271121003,
-6.188574416e-33,
-0.0270186476,
-0.0132269096,
0.0412111022,
-0.034283828,
-0.0170798507,
-0.0532849431,
-0.013402394,
0.0390970185,
0.0217941143,
0.0017370416,
0.0327582248,
-0.0081411237,
0.0054857065,
0.0200285483,
0.0540878214,
-0.0095955888,
0.0531596057,
0.0018125841,
-0.0359138064,
0.0152139049,
0.0007556572,
0.0281765908,
0.0671873614,
-0.0695743263,
0.0026570805,
0.0126470309,
-0.0534164347,
-0.0019335561,
-0.0225309692,
0.0272442643,
-0.0737299025,
0.0379063748,
0.0024929713,
-0.0173541047,
-0.0448092446,
-0.0097429603,
-0.0054792515,
-0.0209790599,
-0.0544980355,
0.0510061868,
-0.119231455,
-0.0037264135,
0.0846684054,
-0.0120438747,
-0.0135748973,
-0.0189176742,
0.0403177626,
-0.0133728618,
-0.017730888,
0.0665492862,
-0.0421965867,
-0.0268690605,
0.0035041512,
-0.0661511347,
0.0214595851,
0.0731023699,
0.0106339548,
-0.0120090982,
-0.1137776077,
0.0185225494,
-0.0399626531,
-0.0076317815,
0.0660869256,
0.0258393288,
0.0245046858,
0.069075942,
0.0706688389,
-0.0059719831,
-0.0441805162,
-0.0054746685,
0.0102731567,
0.0385191552,
0.0477182902,
0.0169063713,
0.058307562,
0.0069658812,
0.0110985562,
-0.0063753426,
-0.102352187,
0.0418628119,
0.0563900732,
0.039886035,
-0.0042106165,
-0.0002861062,
-0.0009053195,
-0.0073882234,
-0.0480070673,
-0.0342499465,
0.051939752,
0.0194151588,
0.0108100921,
-0.0004034113,
0.0655571967,
-0.0024451504,
0.0086416313,
-0.0030369682,
-0.0375646167,
0.0713093877,
-0.0064963857,
-0.0147892404,
0.0388729237,
0.0309019387,
0.0594972335,
-0.0231863093,
0.0295153446,
0.0043775677,
-0.0352561213,
0.026465835,
-0.0435447991,
-0.007424945,
-0.0288758986,
0.0250268206,
0.0335174836,
-0.0191310328,
0.0151050296,
-0.0068665841,
-0.0466465503,
0.0280180331,
0.0007989421,
0.0013441201,
-0.0293827541,
-0.0013193036,
-0.0352084786,
0.0047497349,
0.0006355437,
0.0205668062,
-0.0464190431,
-0.0475019626,
-0.0122468788,
-0.0549178869,
-0.0273161065,
-0.0000624725,
2.883e-7,
-0.0311622396,
0.0518135391,
0.0211535301,
-0.0369966812,
0.0300787296,
0.0500071682,
0.0000143284,
0.0519332215,
0.0250386968,
-0.1083743349,
-0.01617782,
0.0376222692,
0.0346559808,
0.0561883822,
-0.0242870878,
-0.0262052268,
0.00216502,
0.041877754,
-0.0611524805,
-0.0389020965,
0.0496899188,
0.0144163007,
0.0211450383,
-0.0222942233,
0.0554381199,
-0.025250122,
0.079087548,
-0.0083406717,
-0.0125931595,
-0.0057278061,
0.0453350469,
0.0408939905,
-0.0015210032,
-0.004237731,
-0.0146207847,
-0.0853965208,
0.0181916077,
-0.0055905231,
-0.0581611358,
-0.0590416566,
-0.0092918808,
0.0579074994,
0.0040434375,
-0.0334506147,
0.0422393233,
-0.0115086362,
-0.0246012751,
0.0077780006,
-0.0232459586,
-0.0310474131,
0.0772173554,
-0.0272472333,
-0.0515865535,
0.0028102451,
0.0250872429,
0.0507106893,
-0.0540012643,
-0.041665595,
-0.0178411286,
0.00058856,
-0.0291291103,
0.0529001802,
-0.0412405357,
-0.0237392858,
-0.017225422,
-0.0667545944,
-0.0401152596,
2.230305839e-34,
0.0124956183,
-0.0142750572,
0.072542876,
-0.0014966849,
0.0282053556,
-0.010965812,
0.0573637635,
-0.0052049733,
-0.0032061336,
-0.0202267487,
-0.0527624227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07361v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07361v2 | The Impact of Large Language Models on Scientific Discovery: a Preliminary Study using GPT-4 | 2023-11-13T14:26:12 | 2023-12-08T06:30:12 | Microsoft Research AI4Science, Microsoft Azure Quantum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, groundbreaking advancements in natural language processing
have culminated in the emergence of powerful large language models (LLMs),
which have showcased remarkable capabilities across a vast array of domains,
including the understanding, generation, and translation of natural language,
and even tasks that extend beyond language processing. In this report, we delve
into the performance of LLMs within the context of scientific discovery,
focusing on GPT-4, the state-of-the-art language model. Our investigation spans
a diverse range of scientific areas encompassing drug discovery, biology,
computational chemistry (density functional theory (DFT) and molecular dynamics
(MD)), materials design, and partial differential equations (PDE). Evaluating
GPT-4 on scientific tasks is crucial for uncovering its potential across
various research domains, validating its domain-specific expertise,
accelerating scientific progress, optimizing resource allocation, guiding
future model development, and fostering interdisciplinary research. Our
exploration methodology primarily consists of expert-driven case assessments,
which offer qualitative insights into the model's comprehension of intricate
scientific concepts and relationships, and occasionally benchmark testing,
which quantitatively evaluates the model's capacity to solve well-defined
domain-specific problems. Our preliminary exploration indicates that GPT-4
exhibits promising potential for a variety of scientific applications,
demonstrating its aptitude for handling complex problem-solving and knowledge
integration tasks. Broadly speaking, we evaluate GPT-4's knowledge base,
scientific understanding, scientific numerical calculation abilities, and
various scientific prediction capabilities. | [
0.0153887989,
0.0469170958,
-0.0198383592,
0.0321744457,
-0.0423095562,
-0.0086249746,
0.0115860607,
0.0078074196,
0.0196167305,
-0.0169450454,
-0.0090603381,
-0.0470544174,
-0.0301369075,
0.0635901466,
0.0136743253,
0.0004994795,
0.0334740654,
-0.0531397201,
0.0291927084,
-0.0284421053,
0.0032625434,
-0.0143600777,
0.0051372168,
0.014071268,
0.0237147491,
-0.0155626619,
0.0221184827,
-0.0341113545,
0.0069079595,
-0.0492720716,
-0.0056644417,
0.0702486858,
0.023412345,
0.0905288011,
0.0000019351,
-0.0788705945,
-0.0214715768,
0.0740606636,
0.0173646696,
0.0526088178,
0.0515700318,
-0.043196246,
-0.0027558305,
-0.0134659205,
-0.0256241541,
0.0006066173,
0.0489119142,
-0.0004466173,
0.0071894159,
-0.0076536965,
-0.0024937873,
-0.0404279344,
0.0882763043,
-0.0103957029,
0.0214047115,
-0.0344078876,
0.0623664036,
0.0553403907,
0.0598465279,
0.0060359458,
-0.0103344265,
0.0450527184,
-0.0055544088,
-0.0143852113,
0.0300789662,
0.0512996353,
-0.0282402448,
-0.0012641693,
-0.0255608112,
0.0608192571,
0.0144396229,
-0.0287659634,
-0.0404392257,
0.0022695875,
-0.052938588,
0.050011415,
-0.0691948682,
-0.0174159221,
0.0261140019,
0.0065563479,
0.0348474048,
0.0149889104,
0.0408992581,
0.0275733043,
-0.0108899381,
0.1101986691,
0.0483830124,
-0.0333950557,
0.0107054589,
-0.0048080026,
-0.0576777756,
-0.0208275449,
0.0310491137,
-0.010404136,
0.0221693292,
0.0156063372,
0.0297940131,
-0.0150238657,
0.0480001532,
-0.0335968249,
0.0170075651,
0.0186922494,
0.0434305854,
0.0410368517,
-0.0216072239,
0.024640182,
-0.0698466524,
-0.0426737554,
-0.0102527654,
-0.0010090295,
-0.0977581665,
-0.0474381298,
-0.0205146782,
0.0163338054,
-0.0231837071,
-0.0372222513,
-0.038456697,
0.0121507859,
0.0135620227,
-0.0492423102,
0.0187641829,
0.0122927967,
-0.0253839269,
-0.0238171015,
-0.039105814,
0.0489296764,
0.0127286799,
0.0057988651,
-0.0174283348,
-0.0231680684,
-0.0312782489,
-0.0153026991,
-0.0385837369,
-0.0458235405,
0.0065250848,
0.084855862,
0.0136903739,
-0.0174659025,
0.0630129501,
-0.0334051289,
-0.0416252054,
-0.0876575559,
0.0040541543,
-0.0632852167,
0.0254170168,
0.0381140225,
0.0066709146,
-0.037047945,
0.0127651682,
-0.0316270515,
-0.0313045271,
0.0799318105,
-0.0426535942,
-0.0267778765,
0.0490777418,
0.0268978104,
0.0484790765,
0.0250784978,
0.0148919104,
-0.0394268967,
-0.0053098071,
-0.0303648282,
0.0104990713,
0.0022496425,
-0.0253553353,
-0.0133479619,
-0.0224620812,
0.0046576443,
0.0071484428,
0.0632519946,
-0.0232735928,
0.0282911696,
-0.0104215909,
-0.0065657138,
0.0514157079,
0.0677516386,
-0.00900752,
0.0674586743,
0.0006325281,
0.0021663716,
0.0286084637,
-0.0469204672,
0.0169671942,
0.033021342,
-0.0661429465,
-0.0058952672,
0.0520000421,
0.0411862135,
0.022499375,
-0.0066422019,
-0.0151694091,
0.0181178935,
0.0086947456,
-0.0595905259,
0.0678326711,
-0.0746631846,
-0.0511580296,
0.0115026906,
0.0190613717,
-0.0310246982,
-0.0067374581,
-0.0212747455,
0.0033250253,
0.0516069047,
0.0631275773,
-0.0389344953,
-0.0702500269,
0.0173103493,
-0.0252119899,
0.0214396417,
0.0269291252,
0.0296530761,
-0.0387692973,
-0.0110821463,
-0.0088712936,
-0.0287308674,
0.0136312824,
-0.0152311763,
0.0017923369,
0.0274806842,
0.0058281287,
-0.0176850911,
-0.0271713678,
-0.0081692608,
-0.0409366526,
-0.0175355505,
0.0104594594,
-0.0573732369,
0.0478798673,
0.0169212259,
-0.0031110586,
0.0324805118,
0.0631626919,
-0.0607240051,
-0.0432736799,
0.0024991978,
0.0382210389,
0.0120211318,
0.0400047489,
-0.0214431919,
0.028754618,
-0.0049861097,
-0.012600393,
-0.0269970968,
0.0745384097,
-0.010340468,
0.0125863161,
-0.055353567,
-0.000142398,
-0.0340901986,
0.0531331562,
-0.0247947406,
0.0720921382,
0.0202872623,
0.0214638542,
-0.0085072611,
0.0021215121,
0.0311071258,
-0.0256752968,
-0.0387180001,
0.0141593358,
0.0459793173,
-0.0010241999,
0.049765341,
-0.0453203805,
-0.0179665852,
-0.0169387292,
-0.0304447599,
0.0092143863,
0.0145091191,
0.0367064103,
0.0112947533,
-0.0146845467,
-0.0151680931,
0.0426893979,
0.0074935965,
-0.0331022739,
0.0093566533,
-0.0288601723,
0.0472677946,
0.0177875534,
-0.0588201843,
-0.0526325703,
-0.0293905009,
-0.062195763,
0.045339141,
0.0323817655,
-0.0188351795,
-0.0205304101,
0.0298880357,
-0.0201379303,
0.0197483469,
-0.0255019572,
-0.022169007,
0.0410037152,
-0.0064600836,
0.0479517728,
-0.0021597513,
-0.0168723632,
0.0226231758,
0.0409133807,
-0.0291788895,
0.0068758936,
0.0123257861,
-0.0399475209,
-0.0028627634,
0.0040087341,
0.0122817522,
-0.0138103683,
0.0550463609,
-0.020802848,
-0.0269290023,
-0.0230743513,
0.0330082625,
-0.0443655476,
-0.0366548002,
-0.0012402834,
-0.0102779204,
0.0089503415,
0.0189408287,
0.029859338,
-0.0409345627,
0.0811350495,
-0.0417625234,
-0.002345341,
-0.0743411705,
0.0004203249,
-0.0116370255,
0.051657021,
-0.0036184369,
0.0101665482,
0.0146025307,
0.0216704868,
0.0277181901,
-0.0093311705,
-0.0325173326,
-0.0105978027,
0.0193618499,
-0.0547212958,
0.0335856155,
0.0194039457,
-0.0278115589,
0.0249350183,
-0.0137832304,
-0.0418228768,
0.0490272827,
0.0411042348,
-0.0556821972,
-0.0115644112,
0.0404564515,
0.0526923276,
-0.0174132679,
-0.039722126,
0.0041196411,
-0.0393460505,
0.012927115,
0.0504630618,
-0.03557932,
0.0379390903,
-0.0273166057,
0.0412333384,
0.0209304653,
-0.0178412814,
0.0216827728,
-0.0605292805,
0.0145866573,
0.0173596945,
-0.0118665118,
-0.0300316755,
0.0047515398,
0.0048626941,
-0.0407540351,
0.0094320187,
0.0949744135,
0.0183641519,
-0.0396441408,
0.012651843,
0.021629503,
-0.0236457698,
0.0125921955,
0.0315685421,
-0.0742246583,
-0.0070883306,
-0.0270714685,
-0.0344024785,
-0.0110314013,
-0.0439504646,
-0.0175841115,
-0.0753913224,
0.0677481666,
0.0290530547,
-0.0255013052,
-0.0243512485,
-0.0857961178,
-0.0078325002,
-0.0141317379,
-0.0011529698,
0.0274421666,
0.0094050774,
-0.0081516327,
0.0237472467,
-0.018560661,
-0.0861327201,
0.0654120743,
-0.0107222255,
0.004685706,
0.048136007,
0.0258279406,
-0.0410993211,
-0.008420296,
-0.0147978524,
0.0225640647,
0.0168472361,
-0.005495551,
-0.0185498744,
0.0512744598,
0.0036516145,
-0.0311665144,
0.0372805707,
-0.0473295636,
-0.0153586594,
-0.0176807065,
0.1382255703,
-0.0118343001,
-0.009871034,
-0.0519671813,
-0.0155778909,
-0.020315377,
0.0842799768,
-0.0168435927,
-0.0209137574,
-0.0839606896,
-0.0082451617,
0.0221487563,
-0.0031977394,
-0.0407261588,
-0.0486318506,
0.0261105616,
0.0071655386,
-0.008226472,
0.0336960182,
0.0312329475,
-0.0183085743,
0.0060103019,
0.0452751704,
-0.0004468275,
-0.0163224172,
-0.0271939877,
0.0280960314,
0.0086649135,
0.0405089185,
-0.0480236523,
-0.0065911324,
0.0663551167,
-0.0212034136,
-0.0193877816,
0.0717101917,
-0.0440019034,
-0.0779130384,
-0.0487791449,
0.0109810969,
0.0262805894,
-0.0084573878,
-0.0352570862,
-0.077491872,
0.0312553942,
0.0425622016,
-0.0052496255,
-0.0127693471,
-0.0331169032,
0.0018497773,
-0.0017035557,
-0.0314111486,
0.011800929,
0.0205091536,
-0.0281024594,
0.0321273208,
-0.0041564624,
-0.0411937647,
0.0236115679,
0.0524016023,
0.0760720745,
-0.0199380666,
-0.0030728029,
-0.0009911396,
-0.0206017159,
-0.0269183572,
-0.003256263,
-0.0367784388,
-0.0106814746,
0.0485764071,
0.0000985978,
-0.0195889249,
-0.0163900964,
-0.0019502477,
0.0053892573,
-0.0353377461,
0.0302122124,
0.0138550596,
-0.0112102954,
0.0895753875,
-0.0186542552,
-0.0110082189,
-0.0302815326,
-0.0708810091,
0.0370154306,
-0.0383390188,
0.0301758535,
-0.0168630555,
0.0399913937,
-0.0182272904,
0.0294418018,
-0.0713134855,
-0.0704675838,
-0.0470821373,
0.0316824727,
0.0272700563,
0.0331712514,
0.0400880277,
-0.0839915946,
-0.0226735845,
-0.0379763097,
0.0097503532,
-0.0041656564,
0.0131812785,
0.0537713766,
0.0507312156,
-0.0335616469,
-0.0341860615,
0.0708057135,
0.0592064895,
0.0139189577,
-0.0027905745,
-0.0500728078,
0.0066290474,
-0.0347642004,
-0.023378538,
0.0054086205,
-0.0262050033,
0.0080251275,
-0.0825492442,
-0.0244341549,
0.0137629984,
0.034089759,
-0.0009214144,
-0.0043449295,
0.0198609382,
0.0755280331,
-0.0301214121,
-0.0622166172,
-0.0072340649,
-0.0034466838,
-0.0116666658,
-0.0355306678,
0.0085911565,
-6.078319658e-33,
-0.002138441,
0.0083908914,
0.005809722,
0.011754794,
-0.0166374743,
-0.0099921543,
-0.0723833367,
0.0036951802,
0.0274326839,
0.0569407195,
0.0036939112,
-0.0020694498,
-0.013647438,
-0.0182307139,
0.0272282194,
0.0373808146,
0.0112671396,
0.008593102,
0.0339823477,
0.0289254915,
0.0210541245,
0.0374356844,
0.0520956554,
-0.0312619768,
0.012335619,
0.0192433987,
0.0029467179,
0.0007051121,
-0.0681294799,
0.0481490642,
-0.0651475191,
0.0321679004,
-0.021159023,
-0.0611551441,
-0.0175915323,
-0.0476699732,
-0.0009789092,
0.0250724684,
0.0398104042,
-0.0533262454,
0.0074503883,
-0.0066836812,
0.0176568739,
0.01270652,
-0.0756987706,
-0.001986993,
0.0284978915,
-0.0359875783,
-0.0080584446,
-0.0287510157,
-0.0808086023,
0.0099118296,
-0.0028602595,
0.0405344255,
0.0342153832,
-0.0358695164,
-0.020486841,
0.0402591191,
-0.0057159238,
0.0364972576,
0.0592038296,
0.0166188981,
0.0686401725,
-0.0171820316,
0.0303243641,
0.0403691158,
0.0035035452,
-0.0054651694,
0.0062555396,
-0.0086115766,
0.0284742024,
0.0715026557,
0.0417669713,
0.0294930339,
0.0349523574,
0.0158073027,
-0.0944653973,
-0.0141682178,
-0.0166208353,
0.0034419824,
0.048941236,
0.0342350826,
-0.0026527802,
-0.0316888876,
-0.0190224014,
0.0366079137,
0.002044525,
-0.0232865382,
-0.022193633,
-0.059681125,
-0.0402794108,
0.0395752713,
0.0457036607,
-0.0568684079,
-0.0074678026,
0.020658819,
-0.0146736493,
0.0379939862,
-0.0065552662,
0.0495689064,
-0.0655270815,
-0.0345558785,
-0.0378087424,
-0.0069290465,
0.0041271616,
-0.0385294259,
-0.0520130768,
0.0240538418,
-0.0081464974,
0.0114082042,
-0.0367875509,
-0.0121629331,
0.0517104119,
0.0295404401,
0.0005321103,
-0.0043426203,
0.0053342208,
0.0034706078,
0.0306222476,
0.0191008653,
0.0191270504,
0.0448246859,
0.0061335848,
-0.0013008442,
-0.0249918997,
-0.0242524538,
-0.0185848065,
-0.0016928411,
0.0432195738,
-0.0435848422,
-0.0231169574,
0.0345539823,
2.834e-7,
0.0709899962,
0.0799903125,
-0.0011976584,
-0.0152354408,
0.0310423039,
-0.0031011417,
-0.0279739071,
0.015560138,
0.0051115053,
-0.0319800079,
0.0295365322,
0.0125959171,
0.0379148424,
0.0131220277,
-0.0397888981,
-0.016536111,
-0.0349154994,
-0.0402101129,
-0.0788739473,
-0.009850123,
-0.0092750443,
0.0594446398,
0.0331274271,
-0.00222803,
0.0199399665,
-0.025690889,
0.0671762004,
-0.0360888578,
0.0282164048,
0.0787370279,
-0.0226644389,
-0.0342004448,
-0.005525514,
0.0569517203,
-0.001637009,
0.0101688793,
0.0215309151,
0.0352683663,
-0.0032308903,
0.0367841013,
0.0343609601,
-0.0152503233,
0.0170676615,
-0.0720251128,
0.0272014681,
-0.0467274971,
-0.0575334467,
0.0180764962,
-0.0103556439,
-0.0487325713,
0.0409459062,
-0.0132584041,
0.0203542318,
0.0177083183,
-0.0302502345,
0.0105988402,
-0.0243047196,
-0.0300959498,
-0.0053132451,
0.0282200612,
-0.0902960673,
-0.0193546824,
-0.0324779674,
-0.0314833261,
0.0424800366,
-0.0223880615,
0.030398557,
2.835013424e-34,
0.0753152445,
0.0002577166,
0.0148953442,
-0.0057448582,
0.0432437435,
0.0128143141,
-0.0118530672,
0.0119400453,
-0.0337162092,
-0.1174379736,
-0.0161180776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07314v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07314v1 | Semi-automatic Data Enhancement for Document-Level Relation Extraction with Distant Supervision from Large Language Models | 2023-11-13T13:10:44 | 2023-11-13T13:10:44 | Junpeng Li, Zixia Jia, Zilong Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Document-level Relation Extraction (DocRE), which aims to extract relations
from a long context, is a critical challenge in achieving fine-grained
structural comprehension and generating interpretable document representations.
Inspired by recent advances in in-context learning capabilities emergent from
large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, we aim to design an automated
annotation method for DocRE with minimum human effort. Unfortunately, vanilla
in-context learning is infeasible for document-level relation extraction due to
the plenty of predefined fine-grained relation types and the uncontrolled
generations of LLMs. To tackle this issue, we propose a method integrating a
large language model (LLM) and a natural language inference (NLI) module to
generate relation triples, thereby augmenting document-level relation datasets.
We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach by introducing an enhanced
dataset known as DocGNRE, which excels in re-annotating numerous long-tail
relation types. We are confident that our method holds the potential for
broader applications in domain-specific relation type definitions and offers
tangible benefits in advancing generalized language semantic comprehension. | [
0.0492726415,
0.0396130532,
0.0118403379,
0.1113831624,
-0.0136900572,
0.0334129632,
-0.0063513806,
-0.0100382688,
0.0205874555,
-0.0568794459,
-0.0331094302,
0.003197354,
-0.028588172,
0.0043749474,
0.0096698701,
-0.0493539311,
0.0259025563,
-0.0183565877,
0.0197650567,
0.0321184285,
-0.0024017547,
0.0369481742,
0.0128152315,
0.0015114226,
-0.0260627009,
-0.0429111384,
0.0140390834,
-0.0244954657,
-0.0019266275,
-0.0622150116,
0.0043427856,
0.0444901511,
0.0630817935,
0.0143974274,
0.0000019697,
-0.076218769,
-0.0387404338,
0.0140325259,
-0.0478357896,
-0.0160776749,
0.0197479054,
-0.0454386398,
0.0352091566,
-0.0201426391,
-0.0408953018,
-0.0358281322,
0.0020968413,
0.0426245406,
0.0103215715,
0.0526502691,
-0.0275392067,
-0.0494141169,
0.0226495173,
-0.0352084711,
0.0397611111,
-0.0497582145,
0.0279458892,
0.0577453859,
0.0151566248,
0.0253163688,
0.0083665987,
0.0039737062,
0.0117731886,
-0.0179425813,
0.0309335589,
0.025698442,
-0.0595172308,
-0.012646528,
0.0050899084,
0.0771633312,
0.0467308126,
0.0078772977,
0.0011093038,
0.0262354761,
-0.0135658029,
0.0289786812,
-0.016456103,
-0.0067548696,
-0.0496539511,
0.0164371561,
0.0591622442,
-0.0137152793,
0.0489442796,
0.0220898762,
-0.0286784898,
0.0423658229,
-0.003520645,
-0.0355920009,
0.0353750661,
0.0112010669,
-0.0246043988,
-0.0255964454,
0.0003560625,
0.0336675495,
-0.0149741462,
0.0530809164,
-0.0198692903,
-0.0051601445,
0.025266055,
-0.0594013967,
-0.038730327,
-0.0040378906,
-0.0226543266,
0.0950710773,
-0.0280793123,
-0.0060141692,
-0.0267736372,
-0.0363264084,
-0.0265463404,
-0.0290353578,
-0.0201528762,
0.0033874682,
-0.0316410512,
0.0260610711,
-0.0461311527,
-0.0164139438,
-0.0360624902,
0.0251271632,
-0.0007511927,
0.0386381447,
0.0097119045,
-0.0188893266,
-0.0407849848,
-0.0267260578,
-0.0170993134,
0.0009407849,
-0.0258819126,
0.0003642123,
-0.0526441745,
-0.0265622921,
-0.0001207203,
-0.0225347616,
0.0252336878,
-0.0589800552,
0.0003289325,
0.1120937169,
0.0083930735,
-0.0501701795,
-0.0361419097,
-0.0329836495,
0.0382958017,
-0.05356526,
0.0356017277,
-0.0410241857,
0.0319079123,
0.0473944135,
-0.0266058762,
-0.0160144586,
0.0445766002,
-0.012378498,
-0.065947555,
0.0712196231,
-0.0411789827,
-0.0210479144,
-0.0134090502,
0.0122196814,
-0.0064772065,
0.0740078688,
0.0361294486,
-0.0149801672,
0.0639824718,
0.0041376888,
-0.0317722782,
0.0252266489,
0.0023987587,
-0.0085595837,
0.0055772034,
0.0174158141,
0.0343576409,
-0.000733119,
0.0221048426,
0.0120000727,
-0.0180806778,
-0.0218120962,
0.0043825973,
0.0138314907,
0.014638653,
0.0568039194,
0.0534143932,
-0.0000244979,
0.0239039864,
0.0114863161,
-0.0526989289,
-0.0007128177,
-0.0010988335,
0.0231541395,
-0.0358779319,
0.0305399429,
0.0074643679,
-0.0257817376,
-0.0290721562,
0.0006498771,
-0.0173867252,
-0.006027949,
0.0996846482,
0.0402626917,
-0.0230674688,
0.0335109979,
0.0863308534,
-0.0273844544,
0.0060121487,
0.0024148975,
0.026293477,
0.0454731286,
0.0595775545,
-0.0798462853,
-0.0496154092,
-0.0075106509,
0.00530389,
0.0399029702,
0.017630171,
-0.0305944197,
0.0276660863,
-0.0391639248,
-0.0371848382,
0.0040184651,
0.0094441865,
-0.0030549245,
0.0459855162,
-0.0161109827,
0.0204120167,
-0.0736261755,
0.0188552253,
0.0322564207,
-0.0591909513,
-0.0445174314,
-0.0073561398,
0.0137501508,
0.009885855,
0.0268482585,
-0.0026124492,
-0.0263906475,
0.0426721536,
-0.0508409254,
0.0238761269,
0.0263896696,
-0.0359181724,
-0.0254437104,
0.0246336255,
0.0015842777,
-0.0625212789,
-0.0620919801,
-0.0497892834,
0.0061293738,
-0.0110293115,
0.0264826566,
0.0900496095,
-0.0245684162,
-0.0257957373,
0.0379532948,
0.0047674705,
-0.0139716426,
0.1085392982,
0.0175852757,
-0.0136752548,
0.038134791,
-0.034900263,
-0.0177556854,
0.0485307202,
0.0073067746,
0.0017844699,
-0.0090988977,
-0.0338618495,
0.0160322953,
0.0240212418,
-0.0551947653,
-0.0125528071,
-0.0451019928,
0.0232114475,
0.0133312512,
0.0445691124,
0.0120424628,
0.0172548015,
-0.0043781069,
-0.0118471486,
0.0048802649,
0.0069595356,
-0.0351506434,
-0.0180104859,
0.0523212291,
-0.0035458398,
-0.0213042703,
-0.0417045839,
-0.0022235627,
-0.0377263241,
0.0778811723,
0.0256875157,
-0.0154061709,
-0.0025033292,
0.037159469,
-0.0308704842,
0.0377976932,
-0.029800307,
0.0045378152,
-0.0234840028,
-0.03172962,
0.0276657585,
0.0244661681,
-0.0013890294,
0.0782607943,
0.0250704791,
-0.0089874854,
-0.0230327807,
0.0177429896,
-0.0112008881,
0.01057023,
-0.0160071086,
0.0233592428,
-0.042716682,
0.0544228666,
-0.0397221334,
0.0088125728,
0.011920861,
0.0137733873,
0.0025027404,
0.0146458242,
-0.0172131397,
0.0215088949,
0.0279721934,
-0.0017520437,
-0.0326583758,
0.0106478874,
0.0621702448,
-0.0164007042,
-0.0138448235,
-0.0337323435,
-0.0071662003,
-0.0604751743,
0.1144867763,
-0.0137673076,
-0.0057451185,
-0.0137520535,
-0.0221079569,
-0.0319045968,
-0.0288751218,
0.0467435829,
-0.0009835328,
0.0267482717,
-0.059671618,
0.0332671627,
-0.0195984542,
-0.0107518043,
-0.0442711264,
-0.0151862381,
-0.0495823175,
0.0109723462,
0.0000521762,
-0.0040547699,
0.02237246,
-0.0039394991,
0.0006348438,
0.038237039,
-0.0130216172,
-0.0328266509,
-0.0254794136,
0.0690041408,
0.056201566,
-0.0109076938,
-0.0094477506,
0.0076911673,
0.0274531581,
0.0443498902,
-0.043425791,
-0.0312804282,
-0.0295010377,
0.0237931404,
-0.0175231341,
-0.0310069509,
0.0091462368,
-0.0327285565,
0.0033916947,
-0.1087205932,
-0.0351544544,
0.1060102731,
0.0234738681,
-0.052427981,
0.0091370232,
-0.0051907483,
0.0297333878,
0.0303404331,
0.0078758243,
-0.108763881,
-0.0401442386,
-0.0068521169,
-0.0394426249,
0.0288013872,
-0.0567075387,
-0.0055629495,
-0.0767032206,
0.0129858041,
-0.0162536651,
-0.0650643483,
-0.0035517297,
-0.0568180904,
0.0241635162,
-0.0055817384,
-0.0036827428,
-0.000115704,
-0.0490037464,
-0.0056872354,
-0.0242529772,
0.0072697587,
-0.0484102741,
0.0414935499,
-0.0150098996,
0.0237541851,
0.0209352933,
0.0310336035,
-0.0071598273,
0.0305908192,
0.0580732971,
-0.0026680301,
-0.0115176812,
-0.0314912945,
0.0646619201,
-0.0163161699,
0.0009078099,
-0.0343199,
0.0433970839,
-0.0684442669,
-0.0097181303,
0.0120308828,
0.0735242739,
0.0105229234,
-0.0125929862,
-0.0125257373,
-0.013410287,
0.0052567772,
0.0765603259,
0.003619723,
-0.0028409634,
-0.0200553071,
-0.0043127462,
0.0170100871,
0.0045897872,
0.0302004199,
-0.0114785666,
-0.0717401654,
0.0034106472,
-0.0373816602,
-0.0615350194,
0.0576631911,
-0.0226286557,
0.0062526725,
0.0230874382,
0.0468496233,
0.0133565497,
-0.0650573075,
0.0354819,
-0.0260818265,
-0.0115997521,
0.04800855,
0.0019230269,
0.0296111517,
-0.0313968211,
-0.0315537788,
-0.0117550911,
-0.0575780086,
-0.0124325184,
-0.0138083696,
0.0038312313,
0.0185718033,
0.0811235905,
0.0008712339,
0.0198056456,
-0.0028095292,
0.0795543641,
-0.0509971157,
-0.0333502777,
0.0285395011,
0.0235801116,
0.0244587883,
0.0576068535,
-0.0572151542,
0.0054533961,
-0.0075097149,
0.022434799,
-0.0262196586,
-0.0247719977,
0.026465591,
-0.0097797597,
0.0278076753,
0.0108072208,
0.0351607762,
-0.044947736,
0.0365127623,
-0.0612547584,
-0.0216115396,
-0.0434563644,
0.0387778021,
-0.0138510363,
-0.0127788512,
-0.0176750887,
-0.0183065385,
0.0158907324,
0.0574956201,
-0.0077514979,
0.0089929122,
0.0325649828,
-0.0167505983,
0.0066777417,
-0.0418666527,
-0.0150464289,
-0.0019465239,
-0.0153574534,
0.0173276775,
-0.0467046499,
0.0431560762,
0.0192505028,
-0.0218058061,
-0.0207635202,
0.0010061307,
-0.0273758173,
-0.0002311178,
-0.0127843535,
0.0593469515,
0.0715075955,
-0.0437312834,
0.0409413688,
-0.0425378345,
-0.0120860683,
0.0358329453,
0.0696600229,
-0.0213366896,
-0.0024060118,
0.0103804292,
0.0302386601,
-0.0361490622,
0.0351941139,
0.0791493058,
-0.0127075529,
0.0602331385,
0.0516614802,
-0.0253444593,
-0.0439713262,
-0.0195112079,
0.0008017666,
0.0060991133,
0.0017377784,
0.0295513663,
-0.0663576126,
-0.0918857306,
-0.0380793884,
-0.0180135071,
-0.0372541212,
0.001763507,
-0.00095883,
0.0527695119,
0.0159390923,
-0.0583878458,
-0.0337730385,
0.0261349361,
-0.054770343,
-0.0276014525,
-0.0258627459,
-6.272011739e-33,
-0.0404965281,
-0.0404374003,
0.0064140935,
-0.0014100628,
-0.0450967103,
0.0458254628,
-0.0470538177,
-0.0468802974,
-0.0207929742,
0.0472914763,
-0.0287807826,
0.0099935671,
-0.0097827977,
0.0154308667,
-0.0206591859,
-0.0215751864,
0.0100429943,
0.023547966,
0.0397984646,
0.0246818457,
0.0518023372,
0.0294297729,
0.076800704,
-0.1016351059,
0.0235276688,
-0.0159903783,
-0.00252551,
0.0331865586,
0.0206037685,
0.0416625664,
-0.0453519672,
0.0065251933,
0.0430743247,
-0.0058033559,
0.0337993987,
0.0045538791,
-0.1544398367,
-0.0204105675,
0.00286864,
-0.0183349606,
-0.0374807566,
-0.009660868,
0.0289619192,
0.0116181569,
0.0516838543,
-0.0481275916,
0.0419135801,
-0.0444361828,
-0.0283683259,
-0.0687344596,
-0.0897501633,
0.0426026955,
0.0013957099,
-0.0219726488,
0.0175426975,
0.0067046187,
0.0077783531,
0.0198342185,
-0.0225550923,
-0.0443157591,
0.000506065,
0.0076222816,
0.016880773,
0.0026590482,
0.0200965945,
0.0325061493,
-0.0327834487,
0.0188575126,
-0.0118483398,
-0.006807094,
-0.0010048143,
0.0512281582,
-0.0478393994,
0.0352161564,
0.0380535275,
0.0257017054,
-0.0908299237,
0.0124108111,
0.0420265347,
0.0571806692,
-0.0275097843,
-0.0049786866,
-0.0103050126,
0.0000324919,
-0.020914156,
-0.0036302567,
-0.0234666374,
-0.0253615752,
-0.0013574872,
-0.0279361978,
-0.023391882,
0.0168830305,
-0.0044697793,
-0.0399015099,
-0.0477640443,
0.0552339181,
-0.0138743613,
-0.0185105242,
0.0114959683,
-0.0016420051,
-0.0142960735,
-0.0556283072,
-0.0201880429,
-0.0099766897,
0.0214928482,
0.0280323811,
0.0575687774,
-0.0279918332,
-0.0301252641,
-0.0136983413,
-0.0458323173,
-0.0101364013,
-0.0201272741,
0.0253752358,
0.0211788286,
0.0434399247,
-0.0004553888,
0.0740758106,
0.0625380576,
0.0401466563,
-0.0287688784,
0.0416138172,
-0.0211116169,
0.0109193204,
0.0172180738,
-0.031184176,
-0.0239653289,
-0.0026454481,
0.0521394983,
-0.0686336756,
0.0061366628,
-0.0089831455,
2.681e-7,
0.0362069681,
0.0696761459,
0.0366749428,
0.0558984578,
0.0149710122,
0.037582431,
0.032975778,
0.0370344892,
0.0174950566,
-0.0288851634,
0.020526439,
0.0091845831,
0.0062734326,
0.0392992906,
-0.0637067035,
-0.0170335025,
-0.0706139281,
-0.0564454161,
-0.0732233077,
-0.0084676873,
0.0807558969,
0.0732935667,
0.0224227216,
0.0042988616,
-0.0390253998,
-0.0423440449,
0.0579222962,
-0.0478094667,
-0.022247117,
0.0398810953,
0.0102175903,
0.0135181686,
-0.0040860008,
0.0308233555,
-0.0140171731,
0.0361862443,
-0.0071333167,
0.0570578128,
0.0005824834,
0.0510302782,
0.0133567229,
-0.0314452052,
0.0237593018,
-0.0287672039,
0.0709987432,
-0.0761199966,
-0.012380233,
-0.0300291274,
-0.0184832122,
-0.0159575455,
-0.025007138,
0.0112350155,
0.0139480745,
0.0421031937,
0.0034778537,
-0.0299815703,
-0.0191824678,
-0.0437921509,
0.0099645834,
0.0589402653,
-0.0072697266,
-0.0060375007,
0.0016189357,
-0.0181418043,
-0.0038193853,
-0.0221567992,
0.0261592548,
2.440570325e-34,
0.0094902078,
-0.0089841466,
-0.0017031654,
0.0418746136,
0.0711048171,
-0.0356736444,
-0.0100964932,
0.0187746007,
0.009744579,
-0.0695970729,
0.040317405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07311v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07311v1 | Do large language models and humans have similar behaviors in causal inference with script knowledge? | 2023-11-13T13:05:15 | 2023-11-13T13:05:15 | Xudong Hong, Margarita Ryzhova, Daniel Adrian Biondi, Vera Demberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.2.0 | Recently, large pre-trained language models (LLMs) have demonstrated superior
language understanding abilities, including zero-shot causal reasoning.
However, it is unclear to what extent their capabilities are similar to human
ones. We here study the processing of an event $B$ in a script-based story,
which causally depends on a previous event $A$. In our manipulation, event $A$
is stated, negated, or omitted in an earlier section of the text. We first
conducted a self-paced reading experiment, which showed that humans exhibit
significantly longer reading times when causal conflicts exist ($\neg A
\rightarrow B$) than under logical conditions ($A \rightarrow B$). However,
reading times remain similar when cause A is not explicitly mentioned,
indicating that humans can easily infer event B from their script knowledge. We
then tested a variety of LLMs on the same data to check to what extent the
models replicate human behavior. Our experiments show that 1) only recent LLMs,
like GPT-3 or Vicuna, correlate with human behavior in the $\neg A \rightarrow
B$ condition. 2) Despite this correlation, all models still fail to predict
that $nil \rightarrow B$ is less surprising than $\neg A \rightarrow B$,
indicating that LLMs still have difficulties integrating script knowledge. Our
code and collected data set are available at
https://github.com/tony-hong/causal-script. | [
-0.0006313593,
0.0397509113,
-0.0394362323,
0.0049070753,
-0.0644682571,
0.031777855,
0.0239896588,
0.0375458859,
0.0487786271,
-0.0291026719,
0.026852617,
0.0297411773,
-0.0296913907,
0.0466341488,
0.0362646841,
-0.0020254836,
0.0270543844,
-0.0324780382,
0.057302244,
-0.0081963325,
-0.0183087718,
0.0030651102,
-0.0117157213,
0.0092971632,
0.0221364498,
0.0072799753,
-0.0116913347,
0.0096947374,
0.0038266741,
-0.0260733515,
-0.043701686,
0.0594558232,
-0.0138257416,
0.0683444515,
0.0000019073,
-0.0654009804,
0.0380141698,
-0.0169363562,
-0.0307547916,
0.0142905088,
-0.007301284,
-0.0102571789,
0.0164460037,
0.0009560537,
-0.0288413856,
-0.0051932405,
0.0231933389,
0.03909133,
-0.0343734547,
0.0901095718,
-0.0136333415,
-0.0051034945,
0.0090589132,
-0.0225081649,
0.0673205182,
-0.0360038131,
0.0165528283,
0.0255481265,
0.0304100588,
-0.0563113689,
-0.023117315,
0.004323124,
0.0418740697,
-0.0083621321,
-0.0296444707,
0.0683983862,
-0.0274276268,
0.0063428902,
0.0196310878,
0.0508950837,
0.032887239,
-0.0579063557,
0.0049674534,
-0.0324239433,
0.0297694802,
0.0595762283,
-0.042622935,
0.0343998484,
-0.0150771206,
0.0050981096,
0.0575441197,
0.0290700085,
0.0510850511,
-0.0036959196,
0.0075882953,
0.1013418064,
0.0271147974,
-0.03668667,
-0.0336530171,
0.0337708704,
0.0028399883,
-0.0815231428,
-0.0431234241,
0.0242160149,
0.0053950483,
0.018698873,
-0.0255806874,
0.024850592,
0.0291444529,
-0.0440150909,
0.0585885309,
0.0572392307,
-0.0171715971,
0.0483011566,
-0.0407402441,
0.0405199081,
-0.0362796858,
0.0442982391,
0.0224315058,
0.0614924096,
-0.0067477515,
-0.0214141365,
0.0140551617,
-0.0096445689,
-0.0130614107,
0.009938404,
0.012742524,
0.0338399671,
0.0023691182,
-0.0052904929,
-0.0324934833,
-0.0239944104,
-0.0291444436,
-0.0296879392,
-0.0494895279,
0.0392033719,
-0.0457921922,
0.0287788194,
-0.0340191908,
-0.0343265049,
-0.0234320387,
-0.0007553926,
-0.0066811931,
-0.0204353891,
0.0006627743,
0.1168756559,
-0.0281319357,
-0.0277571045,
-0.0674362406,
-0.0311874114,
-0.013069612,
-0.0494781174,
-0.0143200504,
-0.0458465293,
0.0178726148,
0.0470860712,
-0.0211024638,
-0.0351829529,
0.0068811746,
0.0125783496,
-0.051755283,
0.0527097136,
0.0449166857,
-0.004618925,
-0.0245793071,
0.016669374,
0.0035454801,
0.0563543476,
0.0162110887,
0.0030261723,
-0.0046930844,
-0.000669052,
-0.0254185684,
0.0225746091,
-0.0068075745,
0.0334897786,
-0.0451340042,
-0.029210737,
0.0341344327,
0.0005375477,
0.0423788503,
0.0181437675,
-0.0404938757,
-0.0473988205,
0.0707194507,
0.0131592983,
-0.0385019332,
-0.0115763294,
0.0544347242,
-0.0047530099,
0.0068479474,
0.0636373907,
-0.060840629,
0.0238646343,
-0.0399565585,
0.0030719547,
-0.0026299928,
-0.0241284221,
-0.0129533894,
-0.0052147084,
-0.005866711,
0.0026353572,
-0.0177695807,
-0.0004804492,
0.0383336358,
-0.015135006,
-0.065597713,
-0.0414923765,
0.0425839983,
-0.0406352393,
0.0052257762,
-0.0137379682,
0.0284728501,
0.0394471847,
0.0611710809,
-0.0316966288,
-0.0423629098,
0.0013618642,
-0.0250325017,
0.0328015536,
0.0063317041,
-0.0042752568,
0.0028520511,
0.0003032107,
0.0387437753,
-0.0035541747,
0.0173994247,
0.0594166815,
-0.0235146377,
0.0054314178,
-0.0089406362,
0.0094641764,
0.0131435189,
0.0544261411,
-0.0846227631,
-0.0293457471,
-0.0667207539,
-0.0101769418,
0.0560715646,
-0.0297536794,
-0.0385092236,
-0.0062816585,
0.0171040222,
-0.0309944265,
-0.0245434474,
0.040287938,
-0.0659497604,
-0.0425775647,
0.0164288878,
-0.0298673809,
-0.029610781,
0.0298528168,
0.0087474249,
-0.0395835303,
0.0306982845,
-0.0199194551,
0.0332836024,
-0.0076861023,
0.0164593235,
-0.0257265531,
-0.0256735813,
-0.0458038226,
0.054378245,
0.0054808785,
0.0203895196,
-0.0273156278,
-0.0058157891,
0.022927193,
-0.0118936058,
0.0004577141,
0.039968513,
0.0234474596,
-0.0467553809,
0.0230004061,
-0.0475697666,
-0.0478238761,
-0.0400586948,
-0.062946856,
-0.0049912115,
-0.0013091037,
-0.0000255244,
0.0344986133,
-0.01417768,
-0.0449608937,
-0.002731767,
0.0046729129,
0.0061839633,
0.03326362,
0.028688496,
0.012361492,
0.0062351096,
-0.0198985692,
-0.0433930308,
-0.0089426162,
-0.0845524818,
0.0382871591,
0.0629902184,
0.0117236739,
-0.0343155675,
0.0588798486,
-0.0050911182,
0.0206561629,
-0.0468568541,
-0.0294354856,
0.0294333231,
-0.0034077924,
0.046637591,
0.0826347545,
-0.0235456675,
0.0203412417,
0.0803996101,
-0.0182772465,
-0.0304047875,
-0.0117037632,
-0.0139725972,
-0.0016490468,
-0.0683780685,
-0.0725528747,
-0.036051102,
0.0913295075,
0.0411574058,
-0.0042913593,
-0.050751742,
0.0228266809,
0.0046462324,
-0.0489950553,
0.0217927862,
-0.0734740719,
-0.0450646058,
0.0621685386,
-0.0195495673,
-0.0777451843,
0.0744425207,
-0.0230080914,
-0.0047798757,
-0.008890246,
0.038722802,
-0.0239928644,
0.0780664235,
0.0570404008,
-0.0151420934,
0.0199420676,
-0.0372903012,
-0.0715376064,
-0.0262613781,
0.0372435115,
0.0398341753,
0.021278711,
-0.0284609832,
0.0203251038,
-0.0069454419,
-0.0330952071,
-0.0573491827,
-0.0668123588,
-0.0429283306,
-0.0173587911,
-0.0211876761,
0.0025512725,
-0.0168546773,
-0.0179701187,
0.0249379389,
0.0318243355,
0.0044141305,
-0.0149585912,
-0.02210108,
-0.0287547577,
0.000377084,
-0.0884655192,
0.0087938169,
-0.030778937,
0.025750244,
0.0351076834,
0.0017287073,
-0.0035450042,
-0.0284233298,
0.0129356831,
-0.0072122812,
-0.0370775051,
-0.0032785791,
0.0336378105,
0.0120086977,
-0.0293807276,
0.0159550328,
0.1099892408,
0.0226175822,
-0.0325467102,
0.0116703911,
-0.0560025498,
0.0367413238,
0.0389488526,
0.0161045901,
-0.0774278492,
-0.021425562,
0.0346661769,
0.0063693225,
-0.039963875,
-0.0760031939,
-0.0033923632,
-0.091056481,
0.0156274848,
-0.0037832854,
0.0220641419,
0.0194850564,
-0.0247456618,
0.0082183359,
-0.0175399799,
-0.0519796051,
0.0253125746,
-0.0198241789,
0.0075122546,
-0.0233950876,
0.0139569314,
0.014302508,
0.0127340285,
0.0143153835,
0.0415107459,
0.0255693439,
0.003946499,
-0.0454517789,
0.0209033471,
0.0273515619,
-0.0034636259,
0.0037242235,
0.0107286088,
0.0720130578,
-0.0013371856,
-0.0012635902,
-0.0572858155,
0.0465759076,
0.0116849151,
-0.0509513617,
-0.0014592085,
0.0555501692,
-0.0255854148,
-0.0475480668,
-0.0119056404,
0.0277084261,
-0.0382680893,
0.0526677482,
0.0159533937,
-0.0047651334,
-0.0596756414,
0.0213038549,
-0.0264430549,
-0.0087562371,
-0.0535703152,
-0.0315119587,
0.0306070466,
-0.0333355367,
-0.0538557991,
-0.079071641,
0.0020207916,
0.0201912113,
0.0228932258,
0.0182145648,
0.0362636857,
-0.0230839811,
-0.0228393227,
0.0062571452,
-0.0204138979,
-0.0270907655,
-0.0199108794,
-0.0065977089,
-0.0310795456,
-0.0144119533,
-0.0077299224,
-0.0160722677,
-0.0779426172,
-0.0632967949,
0.0507564768,
-0.0128465174,
0.0357001387,
0.0366570354,
-0.0086148111,
-0.0091387099,
-0.0029369714,
0.0032923224,
-0.0013361846,
0.0675875023,
0.0082347998,
-0.0042155487,
0.0201507472,
0.0274583418,
0.0051554604,
0.0160764791,
0.0299766008,
0.0115833851,
-0.055512812,
-0.0000877149,
0.0110339671,
0.0230187885,
0.0419046432,
-0.0134217273,
0.0183190629,
-0.0466041714,
-0.0124188848,
-0.0528314896,
0.0001706769,
0.0145521238,
-0.043944817,
0.029149713,
0.014995235,
-0.0197213106,
-0.0327748656,
-0.0692127943,
0.0191902723,
-0.0084177013,
0.0478185713,
0.0553702265,
0.0240817852,
0.0366813727,
0.0005047208,
-0.0110239163,
0.0191549603,
-0.0121676624,
0.0637387186,
-0.0117521985,
0.0758363307,
0.0510137156,
0.0077819307,
-0.0229698755,
-0.0432099253,
-0.0905929059,
-0.0289039537,
0.0610331707,
-0.0277563334,
0.0324109942,
-0.0551038757,
0.0479258075,
-0.0509352088,
0.0204869341,
0.0075625093,
0.0202079341,
0.022575248,
0.0156398118,
0.0072865542,
0.0172958579,
-0.0257626958,
0.0464209318,
0.0831259862,
0.0430919379,
0.0698882043,
0.0057375939,
-0.0022783186,
0.0118933348,
-0.0666693971,
0.0392634198,
0.0095598847,
-0.0082997223,
0.00903109,
-0.097060889,
-0.0489712246,
-0.0200933069,
-0.0183683913,
0.0309109911,
-0.0551217012,
-0.0136824781,
0.0314334109,
0.0124562653,
-0.0093927272,
-0.0149912145,
0.0875326544,
-0.0089930966,
-0.0232155137,
-0.0256061032,
-6.305792508e-33,
-0.0371333882,
-0.0079215476,
0.0028610858,
0.0403031893,
0.0013482693,
0.0002202075,
-0.0660302192,
0.0302744787,
-0.0144751715,
0.0459477529,
-0.0012202389,
0.0387715399,
0.011987512,
-0.0244607572,
0.0278406087,
-0.0373826027,
0.0104078948,
0.0314059705,
-0.0466023833,
0.0077634663,
0.0557536818,
0.015836522,
0.0183112323,
-0.077032961,
0.0442977026,
-0.0330515057,
0.0228269883,
-0.0278650559,
-0.0223323796,
0.0070465719,
-0.0143125625,
0.0194513407,
0.0471754633,
-0.0277156774,
0.0029919597,
0.0485704653,
-0.0005258216,
-0.0411405154,
0.0864518881,
-0.0068023405,
-0.0068044243,
-0.0315979943,
-0.0051270346,
-0.0328196362,
-0.023270173,
-0.0219114199,
0.0207412392,
-0.0146962749,
0.0093385484,
-0.0042321649,
-0.1087691933,
0.0257037673,
-0.01608897,
-0.0064253402,
-0.0108700134,
0.0179363973,
0.0193264876,
0.0319860168,
-0.0169501398,
0.0080788182,
-0.018425351,
-0.0008708867,
0.0128763746,
-0.0042600287,
-0.0089568933,
0.0665827468,
0.023918435,
0.041625876,
-0.0461981818,
0.0118960319,
0.0057554333,
-0.0004296447,
0.0216702931,
0.0385607034,
0.0462494977,
0.0013810116,
-0.0836168006,
-0.0075731645,
0.0124047799,
0.0370586179,
0.0699848235,
-0.0128643475,
-0.0395049118,
-0.0335900001,
-0.048042994,
-0.0407822914,
-0.0110871084,
-0.016389735,
0.0171119049,
-0.0230031647,
0.041185949,
-0.0319212079,
0.043020498,
-0.0162053965,
0.0533993505,
0.0421952903,
-0.0501848981,
0.0130878482,
0.0001463665,
0.0242380872,
-0.0598973148,
0.0091071008,
0.0046839602,
0.0263575725,
0.0629840046,
0.0103158392,
0.0493086614,
-0.0077203284,
-0.057677526,
-0.0107250707,
-0.049017556,
-0.0143585419,
0.0355088525,
-0.0430264361,
0.0585732013,
0.0118160369,
0.0017881958,
-0.000429586,
0.0367457494,
-0.012730143,
-0.023936931,
-0.0075233104,
-0.0387537628,
0.0041814661,
-0.0378188677,
-0.0008302407,
-0.0261478499,
0.0610341579,
-0.0018336541,
-0.0368295833,
-0.0005540486,
-0.0080633778,
2.704e-7,
0.0638307109,
0.0502076298,
0.0179266743,
0.0374163464,
0.0424695909,
0.0474565029,
-0.0059015085,
0.0175468624,
0.0560397245,
0.0250433199,
0.0119697182,
0.0192311052,
0.025017703,
0.0186335463,
-0.0274934769,
-0.0154855447,
-0.0526406467,
-0.0227178019,
-0.0399388894,
0.003067143,
0.0800595731,
0.0266453065,
0.0405191593,
0.0000783731,
0.0064422744,
-0.0635676384,
0.0465967953,
-0.012589165,
-0.0038008657,
-0.0140606668,
-0.0264428388,
-0.0092764962,
-0.0130546382,
0.05861146,
0.0037043933,
-0.0096725933,
-0.0508014001,
0.0377223156,
-0.0047996556,
0.0353825688,
-0.0039439965,
-0.0379382372,
-0.00044167,
-0.0657272264,
0.0973847508,
-0.0280693769,
-0.0825705156,
0.0683248788,
-0.022610154,
-0.026743738,
0.0031781883,
0.0504208095,
-0.0266047213,
0.0069432799,
0.0083433967,
0.0087416805,
0.0079551889,
-0.0686725751,
-0.0591946356,
0.0688677952,
-0.0193692204,
-0.0665871352,
-0.0233229771,
-0.0198534373,
0.0277905501,
-0.0464671738,
0.0015971413,
2.744556608e-34,
0.0148421871,
0.0272554699,
0.0316638835,
-0.0037019402,
0.030228449,
0.0056730877,
-0.0250474121,
0.0293437447,
0.050649263,
-0.0898828357,
-0.0078165438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07296v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07296v1 | BIDRN: A Method of Bidirectional Recurrent Neural Network for Sentiment Analysis | 2023-11-13T12:36:53 | 2023-11-13T12:36:53 | Dr. D Muthusankar, Dr. P Kaladevi, Dr. V R Sadasivam, R Praveen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Text mining research has grown in importance in recent years due to the
tremendous increase in the volume of unstructured textual data. This has
resulted in immense potential as well as obstacles in the sector, which may be
efficiently addressed with adequate analytical and study methods. Deep
Bidirectional Recurrent Neural Networks are used in this study to analyze
sentiment. The method is categorized as sentiment polarity analysis because it
may generate a dataset with sentiment labels. This dataset can be used to train
and evaluate sentiment analysis models capable of extracting impartial
opinions. This paper describes the Sentiment Analysis-Deep Bidirectional
Recurrent Neural Networks (SA-BDRNN) Scheme, which seeks to overcome the
challenges and maximize the potential of text mining in the context of Big
Data. The current study proposes a SA-DBRNN Scheme that attempts to give a
systematic framework for sentiment analysis in the context of student input on
institution choice. The purpose of this study is to compare the effectiveness
of the proposed SA- DBRNN Scheme to existing frameworks to establish a robust
deep neural network that might serve as an adequate classification model in the
field of sentiment analysis. | [
0.0155707374,
0.0198221207,
-0.0173202697,
0.0580458343,
-0.0396342203,
0.019030137,
-0.0082111685,
-0.0372228809,
0.0064257002,
-0.074823752,
-0.0163120795,
-0.0403419845,
-0.0354339704,
0.0574013107,
-0.0146518098,
-0.0294437874,
0.0292976331,
0.0348061249,
0.0316780806,
0.0058629285,
-0.0150515391,
0.0111038722,
-0.0258522201,
-0.0246363003,
0.0223075803,
-0.0122333122,
0.0080201188,
-0.0015995183,
0.0118987635,
-0.0617435649,
0.029937027,
-0.0066216546,
-0.0464027934,
0.0511084087,
0.0000021823,
-0.0144907515,
-0.0006820758,
-0.0139140822,
0.0220308136,
0.0181891695,
0.0640638024,
0.0262461659,
-0.0005156337,
0.0226826482,
-0.0534645803,
-0.0587660372,
0.0323277712,
0.0667814091,
0.0166910645,
0.0569708161,
-0.0092772264,
-0.0871185586,
-0.0182798896,
-0.0230506305,
-0.0467608757,
0.0118695134,
0.0443623886,
-0.0688694268,
-0.0224462599,
0.0302105322,
-0.0237671789,
0.0144794527,
-0.0015424604,
-0.0130105233,
0.0292884335,
-0.0076694386,
0.019331228,
0.0001450914,
0.0082959328,
0.0227738749,
0.0147847561,
-0.0094559304,
0.0020858147,
-0.0273290649,
-0.0207619853,
-0.0182158202,
0.0034590785,
0.0149959726,
0.0043944134,
0.0377783515,
-0.023468785,
0.0488852412,
0.0447948053,
0.0426210351,
-0.0364472605,
0.0219757147,
-0.0297990628,
-0.0592685044,
0.0063966657,
0.0521736853,
0.0336042233,
-0.0146673238,
0.034992218,
0.0048802909,
0.0428276695,
-0.0120403897,
0.0656232536,
-0.038096413,
0.0314080454,
-0.0747090876,
-0.028597353,
-0.0020344125,
-0.0287960768,
0.0044346326,
0.0072198296,
-0.0317276269,
-0.0059831101,
-0.0232631806,
0.0129057188,
0.0286288559,
-0.034235999,
0.0127984053,
0.058679983,
0.0686397478,
-0.025617741,
0.0130313812,
-0.0622998103,
-0.0334293246,
-0.022461731,
-0.014840967,
-0.000734824,
0.0397273749,
0.028132407,
0.0509395115,
-0.0640253723,
0.0519490503,
-0.0179882906,
0.0329004377,
-0.0477047116,
0.0161197856,
0.0326139443,
0.0543012619,
0.0284641366,
-0.0023724723,
-0.0078717861,
0.0617571957,
0.044115603,
-0.0027227837,
-0.0862665921,
-0.0247915331,
-0.0032140736,
-0.0647891313,
0.0210750587,
-0.0387965627,
0.0004837259,
-0.0350421853,
-0.0301698111,
-0.0037066885,
-0.0128811281,
0.0075305593,
0.0245856512,
0.0450747125,
-0.0343163721,
-0.0575800426,
0.0096469074,
0.0020309952,
0.0355859809,
0.0127235297,
0.0146406069,
0.1070962548,
0.0219663866,
-0.0178062189,
0.0165253486,
-0.0180644263,
0.0351135731,
-0.0488141105,
-0.0179006327,
0.0126490323,
-0.0293442328,
-0.0073189181,
-0.0204446521,
0.0302806348,
0.012089245,
-0.0085656261,
0.0337345526,
-0.0131649794,
0.0238949079,
0.0485959947,
-0.0111670727,
-0.0199499894,
-0.0225337911,
-0.0189021062,
0.0237756334,
0.0189110283,
-0.0092236325,
-0.0012302571,
0.0290260818,
-0.0126295108,
-0.020361986,
-0.0783803314,
0.0021105013,
0.0009169563,
0.0152906971,
0.0115913153,
0.0577861257,
-0.0224173944,
-0.0476003177,
-0.0251039304,
0.0446402207,
-0.0610613488,
0.0010182976,
-0.0427498519,
0.0679926574,
0.0341293402,
-0.0044279001,
-0.0364191942,
-0.0052333586,
-0.0566897243,
-0.0051785326,
0.0424940027,
0.0449236631,
0.0255208965,
-0.0038337358,
-0.0669660121,
0.0090423767,
0.0196066871,
0.0022835289,
0.020859478,
-0.0486753546,
0.0612271912,
-0.0002725322,
0.0476667881,
-0.0523266904,
0.0176456571,
0.0101664066,
-0.001140701,
0.0492880382,
0.0378105119,
0.0571321324,
0.0518323965,
0.0031269402,
-0.0048820344,
0.0434167236,
-0.0232390761,
-0.0543119125,
-0.0435938537,
-0.0218933169,
-0.0415071398,
0.016782105,
-0.0589598678,
0.0031238724,
0.011156451,
-0.0404810123,
-0.0273583233,
0.074388966,
-0.0103352554,
0.0049970471,
-0.0264978763,
-0.0115430225,
-0.017691426,
0.0239808373,
-0.0101878168,
0.047998704,
-0.0086470284,
0.0167606249,
-0.0291916486,
-0.0553417355,
0.0198828354,
-0.0015541847,
-0.084562175,
0.0171130523,
-0.0023564424,
-0.0085719982,
0.0072558923,
0.0032708279,
-0.0074429847,
-0.0383875817,
-0.0366546437,
0.0144781563,
0.0022379474,
0.0322995782,
-0.0177498106,
-0.004295425,
0.0300336219,
0.0230348147,
-0.0183899533,
-0.0055220202,
-0.0478047431,
0.0023301209,
0.0698148757,
0.0242229085,
0.0161615033,
-0.0421901718,
-0.0386803858,
-0.0111330673,
-0.0124327466,
0.0652608722,
-0.0489054434,
0.0153519763,
0.0706034973,
-0.0135417711,
0.0025153612,
-0.0143994903,
-0.054120753,
-0.0041296757,
-0.0142637445,
-0.0213084389,
0.0147737479,
0.0399498269,
0.001305035,
-0.0039340616,
0.0076600099,
-0.0207864773,
0.0288259871,
-0.0563777462,
0.0390934646,
0.0227482021,
0.0005020479,
-0.0072778119,
-0.0091645531,
0.0096189072,
-0.0277836919,
-0.0226270258,
-0.0067275651,
-0.01396544,
0.0082828291,
0.0102257906,
0.0004981526,
0.0112878075,
0.0091387276,
0.0453228466,
0.0015372322,
0.0441574082,
0.0073222429,
0.0246501639,
-0.0694628432,
-0.0372324809,
-0.0721764266,
0.0237645861,
-0.0032594413,
-0.0390468985,
-0.0329509638,
0.0132643497,
0.0177908,
-0.054473497,
-0.0162469354,
-0.0232929941,
0.0445407145,
0.0242730752,
0.0004837365,
-0.0434646159,
-0.0177667048,
-0.003997718,
-0.0084770834,
-0.0229054783,
-0.0352816582,
0.0331791416,
-0.0334841348,
-0.0128645031,
-0.0060263737,
-0.0184576791,
-0.0154993525,
-0.0058855838,
-0.0148517517,
0.0169453193,
0.0120953703,
0.0110762306,
-0.0345758609,
0.0358363874,
0.0373335555,
0.0091152564,
0.0306886788,
-0.0566265024,
0.0234827343,
-0.062216673,
-0.0464197174,
-0.0116994008,
0.0075311079,
0.0002159503,
-0.0281567946,
-0.0295026153,
-0.0548861437,
0.0283235237,
0.0855684727,
-0.0061420528,
-0.0636669174,
-0.0349413864,
0.0120980898,
-0.0247546099,
0.0024013931,
-0.0151097961,
-0.0485384502,
-0.0387268513,
-0.0518967733,
0.0273455251,
-0.01877301,
-0.0381560288,
0.0227188244,
-0.0781421587,
0.0231062155,
-0.0450890251,
-0.0150875738,
-0.0531982183,
-0.0352656692,
-0.0282881297,
-0.0354675055,
0.0091436189,
-0.0310823247,
0.0065344144,
0.0084620882,
0.0258868523,
-0.1001123339,
0.0017493953,
0.0207692403,
-0.0292760953,
-0.0014487162,
0.0226839688,
0.0781764612,
-0.0697752759,
-0.010488404,
0.0191708189,
-0.0416164137,
-0.0063711447,
-0.0214221552,
0.081570223,
-0.037234623,
-0.0312161092,
0.0053973221,
0.0066496334,
-0.0871568099,
0.0541392975,
0.0242372062,
0.0751077682,
-0.0193090215,
-0.0441399105,
-0.0686473027,
0.0453993715,
0.0326591842,
0.0678444132,
-0.0030790537,
-0.0468797125,
-0.0276036188,
0.0162288509,
0.001788134,
-0.0675404444,
0.0020373713,
-0.0337999873,
0.0123173678,
-0.0208570603,
-0.0385008454,
-0.0666689947,
0.0251119249,
-0.0004351923,
-0.0015712893,
0.0352017991,
0.0418497436,
-0.0044509536,
-0.0388615467,
0.009464954,
0.0303982198,
0.0232605152,
-0.0422862209,
-0.0379792862,
0.0706752688,
0.0014473277,
-0.0031224999,
-0.0246281978,
-0.009425289,
-0.0247805845,
0.0116478438,
0.0257140845,
0.0044669914,
-0.0100056194,
-0.0114853317,
-0.0254511721,
0.0374077186,
0.0987442955,
-0.0175882485,
-0.0177736115,
0.0731739178,
0.050264176,
0.0054133898,
-0.0082666334,
-0.0018990203,
0.0495579876,
0.0198582206,
-0.0417324416,
-0.0219555255,
0.0021983266,
-0.0249680467,
0.0226442497,
0.0767546594,
0.0429861173,
-0.0597696044,
-0.0604919717,
0.0052143778,
-0.0005987462,
-0.0005986522,
-0.0217114836,
-0.0015966354,
0.019465182,
0.0087572774,
-0.0775438249,
-0.0275630672,
0.0096636675,
-0.0489508249,
0.0199871957,
0.1089413017,
0.054804489,
0.0465313308,
0.0092821196,
0.032136336,
-0.0314462408,
-0.0087712705,
0.0337454006,
0.0059877471,
0.00230231,
0.0286076907,
0.0254924949,
0.0430298708,
-0.0036184848,
0.0215440299,
-0.0255795643,
0.0185985006,
-0.0129764313,
0.0054754643,
-0.0023271048,
-0.001033401,
0.001904311,
0.0026841729,
0.0376511775,
-0.023939861,
0.0326652713,
-0.0206723288,
0.0051125321,
0.0157015286,
-0.0118136033,
-0.0557426624,
0.0099432636,
0.022818787,
-0.0465445817,
0.0225485526,
0.0295418464,
0.0009600139,
-0.0130769201,
-0.0157615133,
0.0686857104,
0.0147339934,
-0.0022265608,
0.004876398,
-0.0234738365,
-0.0434638523,
0.0635199621,
0.0026527566,
0.0443314128,
-0.0181381591,
0.0254547652,
0.0242736116,
0.04788284,
0.071748808,
-0.0372578464,
0.0687704682,
-0.0295059904,
-0.0289606117,
-0.0604716614,
-6.548664335e-33,
0.0045725591,
-0.0277103242,
-0.0308992844,
0.0290080681,
-0.0210289098,
-0.0085456502,
-0.0453008525,
0.0008457646,
-0.0314752012,
0.0500999279,
0.0030055714,
0.0388417765,
0.0037799536,
0.0663559958,
0.0603755862,
-0.0619551763,
0.048277244,
0.0040259818,
0.0610719286,
0.0127850007,
0.0612305887,
0.0281017795,
0.0291782171,
-0.086115174,
0.0350002572,
-0.050101012,
-0.0165195838,
-0.0039710039,
0.0030957393,
0.0414758325,
-0.0356166959,
0.0613395683,
0.0335653052,
-0.0181996543,
0.0195156913,
0.0250051301,
-0.0120201893,
-0.0712443143,
-0.0355490968,
0.0210349243,
-0.0397383757,
-0.0126926107,
0.0553045981,
0.0496362224,
-0.0283082891,
0.024188403,
0.0466158837,
0.0214761272,
-0.0131824892,
-0.0390851088,
-0.0232790299,
0.0244527608,
-0.018270079,
0.0350295044,
0.0245891232,
0.0196530726,
-0.0032540937,
0.0606792234,
-0.119956769,
0.0060294834,
-0.0294621252,
0.0098635396,
-0.0262896866,
-0.0276029967,
-0.0037212861,
0.0576160848,
0.0430091545,
0.0029088233,
-0.0268527362,
0.0346308239,
-0.0022449775,
-0.0209289994,
0.0672329143,
0.0599855594,
0.0699886531,
-0.0747149438,
-0.0651343465,
0.0027888105,
0.0697914734,
-0.000122003,
0.0443391465,
-0.0444434173,
-0.025415916,
-0.0067981444,
0.0628905892,
-0.0736530796,
-0.0214643553,
-0.0183271207,
0.0138415257,
-0.0143785141,
-0.0012908939,
0.019354878,
-0.0138732968,
-0.0765150711,
-0.0219907016,
0.0178449452,
-0.018725507,
0.0294577908,
0.0039808103,
-0.0144871222,
-0.0525258519,
0.002759672,
-0.040062733,
0.0389988981,
0.0125176432,
0.0166935958,
0.0520265214,
0.0088583212,
-0.0310369264,
-0.0399946868,
0.007274671,
0.0192179475,
0.0009498542,
0.0467129312,
-0.0537240542,
0.0094139706,
-0.0027403892,
0.0625437945,
0.0068812128,
0.0769412741,
-0.0188748799,
-0.0245840084,
0.0309023913,
-0.0162515156,
-0.0305734221,
-0.0650485456,
0.0074600391,
-0.0035137574,
-0.0121025546,
-0.0877572373,
0.004252993,
-0.0094838599,
2.907e-7,
0.0464258716,
0.0497143455,
0.0045044809,
-0.0316070579,
0.0059177945,
0.066708304,
0.0056131049,
0.0114624081,
0.0117232949,
0.0135562867,
0.0191336237,
-0.0103379572,
-0.0042503574,
0.0182624292,
-0.1139507815,
-0.0201024842,
-0.0521528684,
-0.0172045212,
0.0010267082,
0.0293177888,
0.1047197431,
0.0766680017,
0.0480827577,
-0.0075620394,
-0.018182667,
0.0329888538,
-0.0074836961,
-0.023535898,
0.0277884081,
0.006900826,
0.0167790409,
-0.0153948795,
-0.0272477455,
-0.0207759701,
-0.0125496183,
0.0394977555,
-0.008164553,
-0.0025956964,
0.0174489617,
-0.0445771888,
0.0292649921,
-0.0046573537,
0.0298676398,
0.0174739119,
0.0553659759,
-0.056382101,
-0.0428792201,
-0.0437142253,
-0.0181428883,
0.0240291581,
0.0823105946,
0.0149851497,
0.0048767603,
0.0070653483,
-0.0205249358,
-0.0498363487,
-0.034782853,
-0.0943291858,
0.0426490828,
-0.0325459726,
-0.0376745649,
0.0157540534,
0.0337520614,
0.0754444823,
0.0920981169,
0.0082693733,
0.0157619622,
2.027202915e-34,
0.0838124081,
-0.0337010846,
-0.0114030233,
-0.0090945726,
0.0190519057,
0.0208691675,
-0.0496461727,
-0.0242044777,
0.0120210815,
-0.0333833769,
-0.012510011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07277v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07277v2 | AdaCCD: Adaptive Semantic Contrasts Discovery Based Cross Lingual Adaptation for Code Clone Detection | 2023-11-13T12:20:48 | 2024-03-06T17:46:50 | Yangkai Du, Tengfei Ma, Lingfei Wu, Xuhong Zhang, Shouling Ji | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Code Clone Detection, which aims to retrieve functionally similar programs
from large code bases, has been attracting increasing attention. Modern
software often involves a diverse range of programming languages. However,
current code clone detection methods are generally limited to only a few
popular programming languages due to insufficient annotated data as well as
their own model design constraints. To address these issues, we present AdaCCD,
a novel cross-lingual adaptation method that can detect cloned codes in a new
language without annotations in that language. AdaCCD leverages
language-agnostic code representations from pre-trained programming language
models and propose an Adaptively Refined Contrastive Learning framework to
transfer knowledge from resource-rich languages to resource-poor languages. We
evaluate the cross-lingual adaptation results of AdaCCD by constructing a
multilingual code clone detection benchmark consisting of 5 programming
languages. AdaCCD achieves significant improvements over other baselines, and
achieve comparable performance to supervised fine-tuning. | [
-0.0212888159,
0.0646254793,
-0.0308326613,
0.0943434238,
-0.0110028917,
0.0007988136,
-0.0300580841,
0.0369649343,
-0.0095422277,
0.0057519735,
-0.033324603,
0.0495762415,
-0.018643463,
-0.0099644167,
0.0457882248,
0.025509838,
0.0481183752,
0.0018510742,
-0.0481383204,
0.0008670395,
-0.0187719427,
0.0218220223,
0.041698996,
0.0056168162,
0.0480762981,
-0.0217928104,
0.0208507087,
0.0288960375,
0.024491705,
-0.0461409986,
0.0046607135,
0.0191135351,
-0.0087020593,
0.0410968959,
0.0000021295,
-0.0305127501,
-0.0447020456,
-0.0033219655,
0.0279138628,
0.040375106,
0.0686809495,
-0.0093208738,
0.0183531772,
-0.0205559358,
-0.018121371,
-0.0629240274,
0.0600608699,
-0.0244308487,
0.0400760621,
0.0248520933,
-0.0040467395,
0.0263321977,
-0.0020912306,
0.0163894072,
0.0139561184,
-0.0228850041,
-0.0094739022,
0.0388385579,
0.0168442093,
0.0109559307,
0.023109002,
0.0345614254,
-0.0067454642,
0.0349644907,
-0.0368276201,
0.0003191382,
-0.0554854013,
0.0496610552,
0.0087170424,
0.0327987783,
-0.1007370651,
-0.0792495385,
0.0311899167,
-0.0232212357,
-0.0080822492,
-0.0328123458,
-0.0164608322,
-0.0021116096,
0.0180465207,
0.0320243239,
0.046062436,
0.0197740346,
0.0101033254,
-0.0318045765,
-0.0031361491,
0.0081354147,
0.018486416,
0.0037889166,
-0.0069287769,
-0.0348053873,
0.0149222137,
-0.0306050051,
-0.0078496803,
0.0117671769,
-0.0022116462,
-0.024754893,
-0.0461600348,
-0.0566159561,
0.0263885334,
-0.0209117625,
0.0243061874,
0.0573108681,
-0.0888515115,
0.0175383389,
-0.0992488414,
0.0858835205,
-0.0254586805,
0.0072990726,
-0.0086220866,
-0.0183513798,
-0.0505617708,
0.0269761309,
-0.0362877548,
0.0356955566,
0.0126756998,
0.040880803,
0.0038603854,
0.0077128918,
-0.0209613871,
0.037809629,
-0.0583111644,
-0.0558221862,
-0.0108792698,
0.027809985,
0.0547454171,
-0.0172825418,
-0.0017698542,
-0.047410924,
-0.0668861121,
-0.0600048676,
-0.0032082603,
0.0331408866,
-0.0335923545,
-0.0387897454,
0.0178631395,
0.0522608981,
0.016786024,
0.0383840427,
-0.0779968575,
-0.0001704207,
0.0402609743,
0.0326889157,
-0.0091203889,
-0.0878041908,
-0.04377231,
-0.0262051318,
0.0299184918,
-0.0813717693,
-0.0195652544,
-0.0478788428,
0.0001063404,
0.0645865574,
-0.0957317352,
-0.0115445266,
-0.0342159346,
-0.0076161567,
-0.039668534,
0.0130668394,
-0.0484168977,
-0.0405635908,
0.035520032,
-0.0247410703,
-0.0084254062,
0.0107938005,
-0.0282610897,
0.0295209642,
-0.0215391312,
0.0126941083,
0.0447234921,
-0.0594921485,
0.0461640768,
0.0081116315,
-0.0176812932,
-0.0474353507,
-0.0161347557,
0.0254293922,
-0.0044970941,
0.05255007,
0.0417985134,
0.0363726318,
-0.0560757704,
0.0146743711,
-0.0156838968,
0.014954322,
-0.0136091374,
0.006895931,
-0.0384589247,
0.0266456753,
-0.0108882319,
0.0003677064,
-0.0056684921,
-0.0048498511,
-0.022458462,
-0.0362644419,
0.0081884442,
0.022494195,
0.0015919082,
0.0240782369,
0.0328725092,
-0.0332202874,
-0.0395874679,
-0.0670153499,
0.0415545851,
0.0076830708,
0.0193060953,
-0.0653890967,
0.0460454486,
0.0306711867,
-0.0290653072,
-0.0311183967,
0.0314094275,
-0.011657536,
0.0496040583,
-0.0393076241,
-0.0401547812,
-0.0719401091,
-0.0051410235,
0.0664178729,
-0.0116524175,
0.0340692215,
0.0411775075,
-0.0149244182,
-0.0459431298,
0.0222074222,
-0.0221797749,
-0.0040351637,
0.0461424887,
-0.0031457725,
-0.0048010694,
-0.027410334,
-0.0424092226,
0.0164981633,
0.0227389261,
-0.0295611247,
-0.0018572091,
-0.017427139,
-0.004484965,
-0.0398907103,
0.0371060967,
-0.0484967381,
-0.0078630056,
0.0483425148,
-0.0459573455,
0.0103758983,
0.074900724,
-0.0341656357,
0.0547111481,
0.0049280319,
0.049469851,
-0.0460197851,
0.0147718852,
0.0071418551,
0.0552780181,
0.0102837095,
0.0183348786,
0.0416410975,
0.0561486781,
0.0762103572,
0.0146843344,
-0.0241405144,
-0.0341317281,
-0.0447343476,
0.0212754998,
-0.026098486,
0.0530620962,
0.0003075428,
0.0372739509,
-0.0285333171,
0.0218710862,
-0.0037610927,
0.0303515345,
0.0568195619,
0.0190438498,
0.0299641527,
-0.0513336249,
-0.0040357085,
0.0025877887,
-0.0396256112,
0.0086056106,
0.027831858,
-0.0279077739,
-0.0373495705,
-0.030916011,
0.0133657856,
-0.0043231118,
0.0634981021,
-0.0398970135,
-0.0349819809,
-0.0947882906,
0.0733731091,
-0.006790332,
0.0480339751,
-0.0178825855,
-0.0115939612,
-0.0106983744,
-0.0246376302,
0.027663298,
0.0355165601,
-0.0235386677,
-0.0518637262,
0.0645026341,
0.0341259614,
-0.0544008613,
-0.0109727476,
0.0506714284,
-0.0191979203,
0.0095550241,
-0.0317108072,
0.054373268,
0.0409565009,
-0.010232483,
-0.003162544,
-0.0087543279,
-0.0201029368,
0.0146570262,
0.0097790444,
-0.0011700972,
-0.0227547195,
0.0051812683,
0.0355722532,
-0.0201142151,
-0.0373632573,
0.0537662059,
-0.0257191025,
0.0154260295,
-0.0314741805,
-0.0124418093,
-0.034069147,
0.0394424163,
-0.0266820565,
0.0260612257,
0.0229506269,
-0.0328952596,
-0.0235324521,
-0.0164700486,
0.0113555836,
-0.0175081026,
0.0538916551,
-0.0370271951,
0.0108609507,
0.0088604866,
-0.0277742669,
-0.0147486683,
0.012128355,
-0.0236856584,
0.0046163537,
0.0377341434,
-0.0017769762,
0.0188683961,
0.0324023776,
-0.0249607675,
0.1043056622,
0.0695444643,
-0.0229867361,
-0.0072282339,
0.0053191003,
-0.0402267091,
-0.0745197535,
0.0217217393,
0.0021937124,
-0.0090213325,
-0.0041620308,
-0.0033758725,
0.0012710495,
-0.0569831915,
0.0237428676,
0.0160463098,
-0.0039096735,
-0.045256298,
0.0288520716,
0.0037745174,
-0.0176836476,
-0.0077952975,
0.0523879007,
0.0003718651,
-0.0534977503,
0.015411295,
-0.0701297298,
0.0180903953,
0.0735679343,
0.0124109481,
-0.0671990439,
-0.0468435809,
-0.0211090725,
-0.0127857914,
0.0120094633,
0.0081000607,
-0.0064080707,
-0.0823281407,
-0.0031203949,
0.0137655595,
-0.1034649685,
-0.0509933196,
-0.0169008225,
-0.0185571313,
-0.0160277765,
-0.0504377857,
-0.0174621474,
-0.0204995032,
0.0145354718,
-0.032170441,
-0.0361777768,
0.0046925307,
0.0133100124,
-0.0389291346,
0.000630991,
0.0612556376,
0.0313617848,
0.0237880927,
-0.0483768024,
0.0520961843,
-0.0665271953,
0.0020739217,
-0.0288068391,
0.0636769235,
0.0408064276,
-0.0387269668,
0.0471629798,
-0.013345168,
-0.0121260444,
-0.022409061,
0.0218394808,
0.0332331136,
-0.0028292206,
-0.0178251211,
0.0049262033,
-0.0143699069,
0.0061142612,
0.0101608755,
0.0763698742,
0.00900832,
-0.0148972049,
0.0002646476,
-0.0106386924,
-0.0468866974,
-0.0263397507,
-0.00102709,
-0.0621760115,
-0.0094582252,
-0.0441542678,
0.0493579432,
-0.0379715487,
-0.0345313214,
0.0305723492,
-0.0141498465,
-0.0022592756,
-0.0278726947,
-0.0776817799,
-0.0092781577,
-0.0497418717,
0.0183736347,
0.0025150294,
0.0003583468,
0.013866947,
0.0028112009,
-0.0261433255,
-0.0138313398,
-0.0724356696,
-0.0071273237,
-0.0704478547,
0.0363353752,
0.0005572705,
0.0363728702,
-0.0264823884,
-0.0184280351,
-0.0456101857,
0.00075532,
0.007221486,
-0.0112614119,
0.0276663713,
-0.0746804401,
0.0235347282,
0.0133133149,
-0.0630309805,
0.0253168866,
0.0767066404,
-0.045521196,
-0.0078541944,
0.0204507709,
0.0270750746,
0.0487263352,
0.040458668,
0.0373921581,
-0.0188888162,
0.0094085634,
-0.0110409483,
0.0366303697,
-0.0172906425,
-0.0331805125,
0.0379358679,
0.0168944746,
0.0137837995,
0.025777448,
0.019852588,
-0.009133243,
0.0216699019,
-0.0322544985,
0.0330226123,
0.0176174045,
0.0950872079,
0.0263102408,
0.002485632,
-0.0161218122,
0.0235645622,
0.0216325987,
0.0570325144,
-0.0328168906,
0.0348746814,
0.0015903574,
0.0233850442,
0.0113319503,
0.027426308,
-0.0141966799,
-0.0657953992,
-0.0053059924,
-0.0308161844,
0.0621339418,
0.0032554034,
0.058816351,
0.033889465,
0.0063706939,
-0.0368259773,
0.0328615308,
-0.0356563963,
-0.013031167,
-0.0062617883,
0.0025486788,
-0.0286389012,
0.0045300038,
0.0774667338,
-0.0462861992,
0.0076149399,
-0.0229494888,
0.0037747112,
-0.0171090905,
0.0200001113,
0.0835141018,
-0.0086267078,
-0.0289184265,
-0.022979347,
-0.0074634408,
-0.0465527587,
0.000695386,
0.0460839234,
0.0029662238,
0.0536284037,
0.0076720174,
0.0726219565,
-0.0137410415,
-0.0342332162,
-0.0065235598,
0.0060964036,
0.0206268895,
-0.0396044813,
-0.0282148402,
-5.518048561e-33,
0.0263849497,
0.0172053687,
-0.0567994788,
-0.0081804385,
0.0146212662,
0.0241924729,
-0.0650797486,
-0.0310807042,
-0.0358416475,
-0.0370334685,
0.0498912483,
0.0133710634,
-0.0100600664,
-0.0626453683,
0.026439542,
0.0107567506,
0.0399098769,
0.075203836,
-0.0399941579,
0.0345840976,
-0.013767207,
0.003262233,
0.0490075983,
-0.0716536418,
-0.0505333394,
-0.0060354588,
0.0562106855,
-0.0054610604,
0.0361681692,
0.058183156,
0.00836627,
0.0055859196,
0.0081002191,
-0.0244323965,
-0.0750331953,
-0.0947354585,
-0.0145379882,
-0.0334769487,
0.0135252401,
-0.0134145776,
0.0185377579,
-0.0431627892,
0.0303580929,
0.0222412404,
-0.0070474958,
0.0091891875,
0.0537797548,
-0.0346693657,
-0.0124487504,
0.0011234075,
-0.0624967292,
0.0374712944,
-0.0432613567,
0.0443852544,
0.01745658,
0.0598113053,
0.0056147892,
0.0741916895,
-0.0174292978,
0.0291235056,
-0.0336764194,
0.0337158293,
0.0694384724,
0.0090250531,
0.0046171295,
0.0085288724,
0.010888502,
-0.0192505065,
0.0914869383,
0.0023713983,
0.0320153087,
0.0355796702,
0.0504780523,
0.052586522,
0.0577842779,
0.0049477126,
-0.0119661558,
0.0209017582,
-0.0134210717,
-0.003968583,
-0.0116047189,
0.0664333999,
-0.0180643499,
0.0084195137,
0.0072589749,
-0.0448794514,
-0.049098637,
-0.0432370193,
0.0387612991,
-0.0310794916,
-0.0454841293,
0.0403847136,
0.0176553205,
-0.0490173027,
-0.002572851,
-0.0013459064,
-0.0329560414,
-0.0172917917,
-0.0151900146,
0.0210072882,
0.0040124999,
-0.0618371777,
0.0150922425,
-0.0051132939,
0.1018618569,
0.0013767756,
0.0617649779,
-0.0056175087,
-0.065688394,
0.0187652186,
-0.0067419135,
-0.0523908474,
-0.0465144664,
0.0204070639,
-0.0381061062,
-0.0100297006,
0.036476694,
0.0189667065,
0.0437689796,
-0.0677454174,
-0.057447996,
-0.0218619537,
0.0011194847,
0.0351209082,
-0.0287521165,
-0.0063353945,
-0.0440742001,
0.0564694256,
-0.0091704866,
-0.0364638641,
-0.052107662,
0.0232432298,
2.774e-7,
-0.0126655539,
-0.031188691,
0.0161477253,
-0.0460325256,
0.0017877077,
0.0313043073,
-0.0345749781,
0.0363295339,
-0.009558606,
0.0106725907,
-0.0212525148,
0.0028389792,
0.0413488224,
0.0288173221,
-0.0296249054,
0.0449662842,
-0.0702590421,
-0.0033866093,
-0.0578857176,
-0.0017473953,
0.0644199476,
0.0619651638,
-0.0113715231,
0.0015798735,
0.0471227542,
-0.0400376134,
-0.0072105979,
-0.0195684321,
0.041741807,
0.0093605099,
-0.0873700604,
-0.0062048822,
-0.0191992316,
-0.0022474783,
-0.0315067843,
0.006470087,
0.0114537738,
0.0381647907,
0.0043771495,
0.0478242114,
0.0291774459,
-0.0127000008,
0.0110812457,
-0.0737437308,
0.0521945842,
-0.0071372148,
0.030879207,
-0.0165528283,
-0.0366754644,
0.0212576184,
0.0206602495,
0.0035390852,
-0.0206495579,
0.0284419954,
0.0308417473,
0.0091275536,
-0.071448274,
-0.0194460806,
-0.0208646413,
0.0291385558,
0.0083436565,
-0.0181522667,
-0.0201542899,
0.0235412084,
0.0308085866,
-0.001321277,
0.0895227194,
2.173125616e-34,
0.0394547768,
-0.0217846762,
0.0274266545,
-0.0108631616,
0.0266448744,
-0.0066488944,
-0.0436681136,
0.0077123311,
-0.0212583356,
0.0379447266,
0.0150882192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07264v1 | Danish Foundation Models | 2023-11-13T12:03:52 | 2023-11-13T12:03:52 | Kenneth Enevoldsen, Lasse Hansen, Dan S. Nielsen, Rasmus A. F. Egebæk, Søren V. Holm, Martin C. Nielsen, Martin Bernstorff, Rasmus Larsen, Peter B. Jørgensen, Malte Højmark-Bertelsen, Peter B. Vahlstrup, Per Møldrup-Dalum, Kristoffer Nielbo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models, sometimes referred to as foundation models, have
transformed multiple fields of research. However, smaller languages risk
falling behind due to high training costs and small incentives for large
companies to train these models. To combat this, the Danish Foundation Models
project seeks to provide and maintain open, well-documented, and high-quality
foundation models for the Danish language. This is achieved through broad
cooperation with public and private institutions, to ensure high data quality
and applicability of the trained models. We present the motivation of the
project, the current status, and future perspectives. | [
0.0339371338,
0.0944220349,
-0.0161517914,
0.0134982346,
-0.0549090616,
0.0010577929,
0.0078940596,
-0.0201195758,
-0.0315612257,
-0.0182967409,
0.0266576037,
-0.0953854397,
0.0239711348,
0.0282006711,
0.0393800102,
-0.0687576309,
0.0796785876,
-0.0208499264,
-0.0242332574,
-0.0240253173,
0.0470444709,
0.0052630384,
-0.0098872334,
0.0366235673,
0.000851627,
0.0246549882,
-0.0296480246,
-0.0132859303,
-0.0128747551,
0.0171096586,
0.0030720113,
0.0584589578,
-0.007726681,
0.0461386926,
0.0000019158,
-0.0676109493,
-0.0101399105,
0.0003070454,
-0.0427552685,
0.0642925724,
0.0596026331,
-0.0249807574,
-0.0285173152,
-0.0132885873,
0.0163913611,
-0.0388268568,
0.0756250024,
0.0015085983,
0.0299595986,
0.0163865183,
-0.005827324,
-0.0788943768,
0.0115679912,
-0.0410092585,
-0.0990550593,
0.034077622,
0.0456497073,
0.0425176322,
0.0129314074,
-0.0231275763,
-0.0295617823,
0.034408994,
0.016866168,
0.0109628569,
-0.0061971471,
0.0345587768,
-0.0169956442,
-0.0486820117,
-0.003686937,
0.0405078046,
0.0524370261,
-0.0509275235,
0.0240699686,
-0.0091927424,
-0.0099942302,
0.0054022418,
-0.0444563143,
0.0420080647,
-0.0079965889,
0.0040224232,
0.0732751265,
-0.0341574289,
0.0214949436,
0.0191770606,
-0.0140678557,
0.0745122358,
0.0200408008,
-0.0439722799,
0.0452663563,
0.0100159422,
-0.0287403595,
-0.0642937571,
-0.0232240111,
-0.0207568966,
0.0461129323,
-0.0027331098,
-0.0245390926,
-0.0312706679,
0.0400000177,
-0.0263783056,
0.0221291073,
-0.0107505247,
-0.0301760416,
0.0171040036,
0.049676545,
-0.0051424233,
-0.0218128972,
0.0094703287,
-0.0356942564,
0.0240046345,
-0.0350243486,
0.0102384025,
-0.0722546354,
0.0069502206,
-0.0412755683,
-0.0063167554,
-0.0347892568,
-0.0047505489,
0.0394316912,
-0.0385193452,
0.0193803627,
-0.0175468829,
-0.0261524431,
0.0277163591,
-0.026528839,
0.0266599711,
-0.0153666735,
0.028442435,
-0.057477966,
-0.0415928513,
0.0503802299,
-0.0101045528,
-0.001097951,
-0.0306294113,
0.0291961953,
0.0114932973,
0.0247461144,
0.0092411041,
-0.0229499135,
-0.016207112,
-0.0006650528,
-0.0651468262,
-0.0122000854,
-0.0761488676,
-0.0042243605,
0.0190733206,
-0.0012537447,
-0.0431310423,
-0.0050627501,
-0.0225964319,
-0.0495307334,
0.0130916601,
-0.0684025511,
0.0285267532,
-0.0147442315,
-0.0239708144,
-0.0259968024,
0.0389378369,
-0.0120007051,
-0.0518925898,
0.0297320038,
-0.0362646803,
-0.0237045251,
0.0802503973,
0.0143964458,
0.0003236604,
-0.0160757899,
0.0162742492,
-0.0033930461,
-0.0062430319,
0.0287728496,
0.0440198742,
-0.0007198956,
-0.0135547798,
0.0640852526,
0.0430515297,
0.0373923033,
0.0133983316,
0.0132111236,
0.0223503597,
0.0253619943,
-0.0641085804,
-0.0105111301,
-0.0494180135,
0.0052505923,
0.0217721611,
-0.0528587401,
0.0496460013,
0.0153715378,
0.003199212,
0.0231587291,
0.0096987439,
0.0212602578,
0.0196867157,
0.0493102781,
-0.0181537792,
-0.0102858543,
0.082218647,
0.027576942,
-0.0611958914,
0.0214433502,
0.0048600123,
0.0286691524,
0.0142927952,
0.0340447389,
0.0324229747,
-0.0202107932,
-0.0591414645,
0.0340998434,
-0.006801595,
0.0539833456,
-0.0199199244,
0.029584419,
-0.0243645795,
0.0295249876,
0.0373872034,
0.034556672,
0.0460581146,
-0.0375615843,
0.0203220211,
-0.0202537905,
-0.0160289854,
-0.0279346239,
0.0123512391,
-0.0566608235,
0.0394851565,
-0.0743314475,
-0.0033132341,
0.0313191973,
0.064970091,
-0.0600590147,
0.0307966471,
0.0328325033,
-0.0421924181,
0.0183369368,
0.0420701839,
0.013094699,
0.0321810544,
0.0396781117,
-0.0048092967,
0.0229391791,
0.0149343535,
0.0140877375,
-0.0174900834,
0.0480544269,
-0.0284808744,
0.0252764672,
-0.0000944888,
0.0474672168,
-0.0465126261,
0.020752836,
0.0065160259,
0.0468754172,
-0.030742513,
0.0415416695,
0.0115026981,
-0.0031064858,
0.0285809953,
-0.089573212,
-0.0140025998,
0.0222265758,
-0.0527228154,
0.0378830694,
0.0445544645,
-0.0062064445,
-0.0106355939,
0.0360554792,
-0.0505500548,
0.0034206025,
-0.0207385756,
0.0414953977,
0.018221695,
0.023407869,
-0.0251904633,
0.0096284421,
-0.012159748,
-0.036892511,
0.0320635177,
0.0137523795,
-0.0290241111,
-0.0236046463,
-0.0663801208,
-0.0542289242,
-0.0347241126,
-0.0028546134,
0.0398936607,
-0.0173702873,
-0.0757934451,
-0.0232994221,
0.0409121104,
-0.023144206,
0.0578532778,
0.001948052,
-0.0357135683,
-0.0032195798,
-0.0179746784,
0.0302239377,
0.0095429923,
-0.0490750447,
0.0065880455,
-0.0089442721,
-0.0461555943,
-0.0395893902,
-0.0220024753,
-0.0278342403,
0.0385067388,
-0.0605510026,
-0.0461100675,
-0.0156471226,
0.0709147677,
0.0337511227,
0.0066113318,
-0.0289787278,
0.0272449795,
-0.0565738976,
0.0093311928,
-0.0346979462,
-0.0194257796,
-0.0065007787,
0.0965959206,
-0.049362652,
-0.0298711136,
0.0262369104,
-0.0254300758,
-0.0013929764,
-0.0066521456,
-0.0194371548,
-0.0289460067,
0.0403031297,
-0.000096602,
0.0184333716,
0.045865912,
0.0072709816,
-0.0080381893,
0.013534951,
0.0545875803,
-0.0163548961,
0.0661078766,
-0.0367434584,
0.0207965858,
0.0101018911,
-0.0325239487,
-0.0055649574,
-0.0592553429,
-0.0813788474,
0.0232481584,
-0.0102379657,
-0.0079857847,
-0.0416579284,
0.0165221598,
-0.0046552462,
0.0052837706,
0.0199787524,
0.0475947894,
-0.0198811963,
0.0098414673,
-0.008055375,
-0.0238497611,
0.0222945586,
-0.0396135375,
0.0002254045,
-0.0025191414,
0.0185301378,
0.0475970656,
-0.011703264,
-0.0096574062,
0.0400194041,
-0.0273519289,
-0.0599894449,
-0.0263024773,
0.0344756059,
-0.0288418457,
-0.0122136958,
0.0675465316,
-0.0045269341,
0.0481960885,
0.0319903493,
-0.0055872025,
0.0455526151,
0.0379411913,
-0.0051333797,
-0.1000422835,
0.0064707031,
0.0219374988,
0.0112232864,
-0.0143164415,
-0.0101794759,
-0.0017050611,
-0.0741559118,
0.0480827577,
0.0436968394,
-0.0595611334,
0.0222453475,
-0.0335124731,
-0.0170541015,
-0.0573806576,
-0.0109619116,
0.025640063,
-0.0033727563,
0.020849729,
0.0377348475,
-0.0232111514,
-0.0809584111,
0.0214895681,
-0.0591501519,
0.0634339005,
0.0578517988,
0.0116497632,
-0.0503306426,
-0.063741371,
0.0200909562,
-0.0323676653,
-0.0389759429,
-0.0037692832,
0.029856788,
0.0345696211,
-0.0029292363,
-0.0500872768,
0.0338792205,
-0.0137542235,
-0.0376330279,
0.0045264144,
0.0533896647,
0.000917376,
-0.0012429701,
0.0189629681,
0.008001986,
-0.0003474203,
0.0441707112,
0.0374163836,
-0.0366386212,
-0.0163101703,
-0.0307809394,
-0.0313906968,
-0.007422768,
-0.0230246428,
0.019221805,
-0.0138820717,
-0.0203789994,
-0.0176894478,
-0.0312226061,
0.018351553,
0.0390390158,
0.0307317227,
-0.0041499636,
0.0338116735,
-0.0384710617,
-0.0707828104,
0.0601404719,
-0.0027129261,
0.0471976697,
-0.1068857387,
-0.0109032467,
0.0413979329,
-0.0049711955,
-0.0365044326,
-0.0103420829,
-0.0365945622,
-0.0968209207,
0.0683091655,
0.040484719,
0.033022102,
0.0262700785,
-0.0131898252,
-0.0486499667,
-0.0276959725,
-0.0099843433,
-0.0264415145,
0.0451931171,
0.0399772339,
-0.0733300671,
0.0128154866,
0.007727386,
-0.0103948051,
0.0576269068,
-0.0256323423,
0.0091092838,
0.0155333821,
0.0012721979,
0.0096422099,
0.0539301522,
0.0331976749,
-0.0374524854,
-0.0024402549,
-0.0709303021,
-0.0170669649,
-0.0036624302,
-0.0092053022,
-0.0139264138,
0.0091539025,
0.0452802591,
0.0558870845,
-0.0184539892,
0.0065017217,
-0.045080699,
0.0480042361,
-0.025960777,
0.0557247624,
0.0471838638,
0.0630215257,
0.0603364035,
-0.0002840836,
0.0160348341,
0.0275057871,
-0.0230099373,
0.0482420698,
-0.020318782,
0.0253233965,
-0.0230831001,
-0.0159392785,
-0.0062127942,
-0.0053642783,
-0.0230227262,
-0.0454152115,
-0.0237215459,
-0.0339904465,
0.0561611317,
0.0031568913,
0.0771018341,
-0.0541654341,
0.0127921756,
-0.0250770766,
0.0239240676,
0.0037469035,
-0.0727882236,
0.0185537376,
0.0119777964,
-0.0288091991,
0.0202207807,
0.0090063391,
0.0385713987,
0.0684909672,
-0.0025873003,
0.0172998626,
-0.0228224322,
-0.0063925246,
0.0160356946,
-0.0055869953,
-0.0451464355,
-0.0033551329,
-0.1117095649,
-0.0483199321,
-0.0019504402,
0.0317573957,
-0.001366073,
0.0069561545,
0.0208738651,
0.0209799185,
0.0184521936,
-0.0190368108,
-0.0613245405,
0.0210454278,
-0.0738429129,
-0.0446941964,
0.0125323636,
-6.165359872e-33,
0.0083528003,
0.0430085734,
-0.0004218334,
-0.0352527238,
-0.0327071436,
0.0099205784,
0.0003619347,
0.0278490949,
-0.0307358541,
0.0024820147,
-0.0109718461,
-0.0132621191,
0.0175872501,
0.006317351,
-0.0018252294,
0.0089122262,
0.0303680301,
-0.0118160555,
0.0257721841,
-0.0210427437,
-0.0011267526,
0.021815611,
0.1078820974,
-0.085422568,
0.0403857641,
-0.0215492565,
-0.0236400478,
0.0233583711,
0.0303538442,
0.0547369644,
-0.0077457447,
0.0147486217,
0.0247899592,
-0.0462478921,
-0.0040226462,
-0.0032092738,
-0.0806470439,
0.0139390472,
0.0418280661,
0.0525449403,
-0.0117214052,
0.0013289853,
0.0109800147,
-0.0257494785,
-0.0439953916,
0.0473850295,
-0.01295947,
-0.0200403817,
-0.0016800914,
0.0510003753,
-0.0441297777,
0.0007771326,
-0.0025137621,
0.0329296403,
0.0444295444,
-0.0014742911,
-0.0166463219,
-0.0579563864,
-0.0058536739,
0.0382613204,
0.0671691,
0.0035594082,
0.0645752028,
-0.0231105816,
0.0017676206,
0.038643606,
0.0324971266,
0.0120820496,
0.0080285547,
-0.0028694835,
0.0642033815,
0.0623501539,
0.0472740941,
0.0971937701,
0.0354434662,
-0.0063642645,
-0.0675562546,
-0.0249010008,
0.0666551292,
0.0148519762,
-0.0210580099,
-0.0318473838,
-0.0459511988,
-0.0365726277,
-0.0814243555,
-0.0943104178,
0.0040033446,
-0.0157562941,
0.0728089362,
-0.0216342732,
0.016149411,
-0.0072568851,
0.0422133841,
-0.0485813357,
-0.0642281845,
-0.0039305896,
0.0001783786,
0.032285545,
-0.0273687411,
0.0532750562,
-0.0937762484,
-0.0307267904,
-0.0194630045,
0.0345168225,
0.0102521218,
0.0103106741,
-0.0019868237,
0.0004621794,
-0.0298795402,
0.0251469407,
-0.0179877933,
0.0406922214,
0.0325848982,
-0.004518514,
0.0379813574,
-0.0143764988,
0.0134063326,
0.0438245162,
0.0529682711,
-0.0349316224,
-0.0342306904,
-0.0231332015,
-0.0024160915,
0.0511892214,
-0.01186716,
-0.0025742652,
-0.030103026,
-0.0073114713,
0.0686415732,
-0.0180636719,
-0.012562532,
-0.0070349318,
2.521e-7,
0.0529818088,
0.0376621634,
0.0270471126,
-0.0255554207,
0.0027549644,
0.0125225335,
-0.0125348186,
0.0279347468,
-0.0421119444,
0.0194871202,
-0.0117159458,
-0.0157770608,
0.0413657725,
0.0129278451,
-0.0608359575,
-0.0129374908,
-0.0638856664,
0.0247357506,
-0.0819302723,
-0.0325387716,
-0.0383914821,
0.1022962779,
-0.0067518153,
-0.015466122,
-0.034950044,
-0.0288731195,
0.0383329764,
-0.0310054459,
0.018092446,
0.0127613051,
0.0104776574,
0.0142883686,
0.0270660184,
-0.0131906355,
0.0215713084,
0.0091954442,
0.0021644521,
0.0420302302,
-0.0102007966,
0.039324142,
0.0281776842,
-0.0335808359,
-0.0407170877,
-0.0451132432,
0.016512569,
-0.026289843,
-0.0336842649,
-0.0120777143,
-0.0770092979,
0.0373766162,
-0.0072807083,
-0.0044196555,
0.0232488848,
0.0039263447,
0.0417561047,
-0.0204543192,
-0.0419211239,
-0.0049501201,
-0.0526796728,
0.0037295234,
0.008509119,
-0.0441264622,
0.0276465379,
0.0151646761,
-0.0253885351,
-0.0419646539,
0.0006010283,
2.338766775e-34,
0.0341517404,
-0.0194507856,
0.0157587491,
0.023232013,
0.0408884659,
-0.041798003,
0.0252381191,
0.0038520254,
-0.0179431103,
-0.0194143355,
-0.0098224282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07237v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07237v2 | In Search of the Long-Tail: Systematic Generation of Long-Tail Inferential Knowledge via Logical Rule Guided Search | 2023-11-13T10:56:59 | 2024-02-27T22:28:52 | Huihan Li, Yuting Ning, Zeyi Liao, Siyuan Wang, Xiang Lorraine Li, Ximing Lu, Wenting Zhao, Faeze Brahman, Yejin Choi, Xiang Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | State-of-the-art LLMs outperform humans on reasoning tasks such as Natural
Language Inference. Recent works evaluating LLMs note a marked performance drop
on input data from the low-probability distribution, i.e., the longtail.
Therefore, we focus on systematically generating statements involving long-tail
inferential knowledge for more effective evaluation of LLMs in the reasoning
space. We first propose a novel framework Logic-Induced- Knowledge-Search
(LINK) that generates factually correct and long-tail knowledge statements
grounded on symbolic rule templates; LINK effectively generates data in the
longtail distribution that zero-shot prompted LLMs are unable to reach, and
outperforms zero-shot GPT4 on factual correctness by 5%. We further use the
data generated by LINK to construct a dataset Logic-Induced-Long-Tail (LINT)
that can be used to evaluate downstream models on the long-tail distribution;
LINT contains 108K knowledge statements spanning four domains. We use LINT to
test LLMs on an entailment classification task and find that model performances
drop by as high as 5% in the long-tail distribution compared to head
distribution. Our work shows the utility of evaluating models in the long-tail
distribution, and calls for more research on generating evaluation data in the
long-tail distribution. | [
0.02916025,
0.0153485201,
-0.0190429408,
0.0566172116,
-0.0690437183,
0.0183587633,
-0.0347544514,
0.0191243254,
0.0140939821,
-0.0150648225,
0.0128676612,
0.0180987027,
-0.0437198952,
0.0112071279,
0.0147543559,
0.0006224971,
0.0374038033,
-0.0091322027,
0.0279142763,
-0.0065421211,
-0.0284175929,
0.0041779098,
0.0048296517,
-0.0038011651,
-0.0445443802,
0.0054888539,
-0.0012115779,
0.0314932652,
0.0320362039,
-0.0308899246,
0.0019595639,
-0.0073105791,
0.0262127593,
0.0279881489,
0.0000019166,
-0.0699047968,
0.0201297309,
-0.0040993933,
-0.0356132239,
-0.0338563137,
-0.0365980454,
-0.0136575866,
0.0242086239,
0.010123211,
-0.0195571464,
0.0448392071,
0.0218473431,
0.044096455,
0.0231530368,
0.0838435516,
0.0168218166,
-0.0583184399,
-0.0032082181,
-0.0332253054,
0.0632648543,
-0.0220804084,
0.0081617367,
0.0242615789,
0.021065142,
-0.0501319841,
-0.0060971361,
0.0228136927,
0.0584901758,
0.018555915,
-0.0347805917,
0.0597862974,
-0.0345018357,
0.0020588918,
0.0357267186,
0.0629402697,
-0.016582679,
-0.0529016741,
-0.0051344573,
-0.0123893451,
0.0378650576,
0.0117077855,
-0.0166995581,
0.0451542139,
-0.0640843883,
0.0036573976,
0.0634056479,
0.0030320366,
0.0422420017,
0.0060357181,
-0.0472005829,
0.1088522822,
-0.0173156392,
-0.0565712564,
0.0230069403,
-0.0083357459,
-0.0661479905,
-0.0233251322,
-0.0315719321,
0.0167073719,
0.002549201,
0.0238414388,
-0.021857636,
0.0217781253,
0.0333736315,
-0.0086347731,
0.0463728942,
0.0390158817,
-0.0183458067,
0.0585707389,
-0.0726006776,
-0.0173409339,
-0.0195972063,
0.0219038632,
-0.0071993484,
-0.056351196,
-0.046522636,
-0.0093948459,
0.0215899479,
0.0402664877,
-0.0197684355,
0.0086512389,
-0.0259053819,
0.0248639118,
-0.0103608249,
0.0201370176,
-0.0244374759,
-0.0063672354,
-0.0008482334,
-0.0232501756,
-0.0820584595,
0.0132302605,
-0.0519747622,
0.0262931101,
0.0125828329,
-0.0051562726,
-0.0198696367,
0.0237227883,
-0.0095376009,
-0.0189379901,
0.0543593578,
0.0857938454,
0.0239406638,
-0.020756118,
-0.0466891788,
-0.0580674186,
0.0023634657,
-0.0878449306,
0.0298914816,
-0.0670190305,
0.0118461186,
0.0171654038,
-0.0421693139,
-0.0037692487,
0.0095851636,
0.0438270569,
0.0242650043,
0.0468365662,
0.00159833,
-0.0101340096,
-0.0095774708,
-0.0027323007,
-0.056113176,
0.0714999065,
0.013533948,
0.0488625132,
0.0199953653,
0.0280623659,
0.0087525798,
0.0129168322,
0.0399757996,
0.0200211611,
-0.0175658241,
0.0476673469,
-0.0318350345,
0.019820055,
0.0229300559,
0.0192453638,
-0.0280278455,
-0.020708112,
0.0249358322,
0.0366639718,
0.0522956364,
-0.0419492684,
0.0593158938,
-0.0466794036,
-0.0133370589,
-0.0123659968,
-0.079665862,
0.0137912985,
-0.0627341866,
0.0197292585,
-0.0579635873,
0.0056307074,
0.0024253721,
-0.0635754615,
-0.0177920163,
0.0125809032,
-0.0383859649,
0.0364911258,
0.0468834341,
0.0092527447,
0.0001594653,
0.0447342172,
0.0262756813,
-0.029028656,
-0.0198713038,
-0.0574937984,
0.0507836714,
0.0287148859,
0.0393883809,
-0.0240586475,
-0.0364745855,
0.0085156243,
0.0087611303,
0.017732244,
-0.0264541786,
0.0068022083,
0.004295819,
0.0053528151,
-0.0084045194,
0.0013139138,
0.026147021,
-0.0052779699,
0.0334783904,
0.0121659338,
0.0375151113,
-0.1009538025,
0.0197066739,
0.043316789,
-0.0156437494,
0.0075967927,
-0.0015578482,
-0.0003376899,
0.0428154059,
-0.0208049603,
-0.0024228692,
0.0087007014,
0.0301897228,
-0.0163251478,
-0.0706638917,
-0.0056942259,
-0.0111539215,
-0.0454830825,
0.0358103737,
-0.1015431136,
-0.0226741545,
-0.0172821246,
-0.0666832477,
-0.0026070117,
-0.0064276364,
-0.0447187014,
0.0125990268,
-0.0371516608,
-0.0400792137,
0.015462338,
-0.0232113432,
-0.0255709551,
0.1070948392,
0.0106678568,
-0.0083728153,
0.0094711091,
-0.0298670419,
0.0142891379,
-0.0368910581,
0.041733399,
-0.0168045256,
-0.0055541396,
-0.0341078006,
0.009898969,
0.0322212726,
-0.0316389576,
-0.036541719,
-0.0545065701,
0.0420048609,
-0.0212099589,
0.0274372939,
-0.0301369578,
-0.0375538394,
-0.026084967,
-0.0043096775,
-0.0137322284,
-0.0265779141,
0.0164789315,
0.0150295412,
0.039362222,
-0.0207174122,
-0.0265949871,
0.0102359084,
0.0074509792,
-0.0361603983,
0.0203866754,
0.0184636135,
0.0102381511,
-0.0449144766,
0.0126425829,
-0.0446017422,
0.0081599848,
-0.0363997072,
0.0127838999,
0.0250106435,
0.0026353102,
0.0169635136,
0.079716444,
0.0119425701,
-0.0143414382,
0.0287577175,
0.0118329749,
-0.0266854614,
0.020571284,
-0.0352386534,
0.0123394728,
-0.0345061682,
-0.0002703247,
0.0056377482,
-0.0079228263,
0.012522853,
-0.0042873197,
-0.0388141908,
0.0489560999,
0.0419980995,
-0.0123106819,
0.0022610943,
0.0218177307,
0.0129923522,
0.0796650872,
0.0074283304,
-0.0608497858,
0.0675689057,
0.0257319529,
0.0219683237,
-0.0136109581,
-0.0142854583,
-0.0582386367,
0.0819188878,
0.0126989046,
-0.0350102969,
0.0363113694,
0.0241642259,
-0.0434942804,
-0.0121571543,
0.0392009765,
-0.0052044685,
0.0509264395,
-0.0527200587,
0.0047269268,
-0.0076674027,
-0.036127124,
-0.0320441648,
-0.0272417534,
-0.0332345106,
0.0001889948,
-0.0565095209,
0.0054832213,
-0.0107638799,
-0.0179360155,
0.0224021506,
-0.0015237334,
0.0069558639,
-0.019683795,
-0.0451155789,
-0.013503368,
0.0543312952,
-0.033227995,
0.0301095583,
-0.0296648853,
0.0031486503,
0.0405056216,
-0.0394680239,
-0.00042535,
-0.0023410227,
-0.0171226673,
-0.0208775364,
-0.0199946407,
-0.0222414993,
0.0552729107,
0.0002355113,
-0.0584238134,
0.0339518525,
0.0972290114,
-0.0030998925,
0.026402561,
0.0070694303,
-0.0264891274,
0.0432055704,
0.0207757577,
-0.008382828,
-0.1225951985,
-0.0695848539,
0.0333814658,
0.0058543542,
-0.0249286368,
-0.0347447619,
0.0169060621,
-0.1053387597,
0.0497969687,
-0.0155639984,
0.0009010501,
-0.0464059077,
-0.0562964417,
0.0187604595,
-0.0274340194,
-0.0520988628,
0.0328844376,
-0.0137115791,
0.0269798432,
-0.0097632725,
-0.0006788215,
-0.0068552382,
0.0776145086,
-0.055371318,
-0.022403026,
0.0363116525,
0.0227369945,
0.0040722876,
-0.0562809445,
-0.0094772968,
-0.0248346757,
0.0141940974,
-0.0325123407,
0.0180999599,
-0.0229395442,
0.0241481904,
-0.0406642221,
0.0614698008,
-0.0496035144,
0.0204735491,
0.0734142959,
0.10472022,
-0.0577849448,
-0.0593590662,
-0.0557989813,
-0.0152368778,
-0.039336957,
0.0893428177,
0.0004312095,
0.0111383377,
-0.0495783389,
-0.0116870729,
-0.0372874029,
-0.0047412701,
-0.0121099409,
0.0060789161,
-0.014505635,
-0.0023068991,
-0.0325378664,
-0.0067833532,
0.0037799422,
0.0581813641,
-0.029122049,
-0.0014497908,
-0.0091311829,
-0.0003607094,
-0.0331516936,
0.0116682006,
-0.0582710952,
-0.0018833597,
-0.0199664962,
0.0598080456,
0.0092412978,
-0.0360969119,
-0.0334379561,
0.0739981011,
-0.0740221515,
-0.04247972,
-0.0474645793,
0.0251896139,
0.0264491662,
0.0432028212,
0.0005208718,
0.0367455371,
0.036775101,
0.0691557452,
0.0197062623,
0.0048497436,
0.0342432745,
-0.0099308761,
0.0285605323,
0.0379121266,
-0.0265864041,
0.0287605282,
0.0298729613,
0.0141157359,
-0.0284917355,
-0.0433473289,
0.0293934941,
0.0401436985,
0.0384543985,
-0.0145660611,
-0.0603255667,
-0.0025379029,
0.0267200787,
-0.0423161946,
-0.0192151703,
-0.0100303758,
0.0099810986,
0.0217762254,
0.0025157847,
-0.0237062126,
-0.0226471052,
0.0121851554,
0.0494021848,
-0.0343561657,
0.0017684002,
0.0234669764,
-0.009586608,
0.0131831085,
-0.0690902695,
-0.0083372248,
-0.0077929972,
-0.0370638631,
0.0583831556,
-0.0170052387,
0.0292039663,
0.0799275935,
0.0183396842,
-0.0141427815,
-0.0313977301,
-0.0530367866,
-0.0105133494,
0.0126588894,
0.0157199148,
0.0682938918,
0.0278443098,
-0.0142475674,
-0.0545369051,
0.0024467567,
0.0276532583,
0.0576322637,
-0.0117245158,
-0.0373583622,
0.0334178135,
0.02209091,
-0.0381406769,
-0.0510428697,
0.0297414027,
0.0094011286,
0.0760614201,
0.0060408195,
-0.0129821235,
-0.0340156183,
-0.0505911782,
-0.0126943812,
-0.0274538714,
0.0323520079,
0.0281226132,
-0.0878336951,
-0.064568691,
0.0338439494,
0.035288278,
-0.0125833536,
0.0001510854,
0.0359000899,
0.0646073073,
0.0244573001,
-0.0960255042,
-0.0003635584,
-0.0100436946,
-0.0158977956,
0.005284633,
-0.0561947301,
-6.170634168e-33,
-0.0147947269,
-0.0307799857,
0.0479119495,
0.0353071392,
-0.0095527722,
-0.0257882532,
0.0021369159,
-0.0281884279,
-0.0165556595,
0.0192549955,
0.0074945069,
0.0294029862,
-0.0002173075,
0.0008092902,
0.0091772238,
-0.0299489368,
-0.0155011239,
0.0228460692,
-0.0163202472,
-0.0073479097,
0.0412221849,
0.0010050918,
0.0439561717,
-0.0130601116,
-0.0182942674,
0.0149915284,
0.0062767542,
0.0465991162,
-0.0879988074,
0.0109115429,
0.0406492576,
0.0355072469,
0.016158849,
-0.0247224458,
0.0373602062,
-0.0132319191,
-0.0490663275,
-0.0410737544,
0.0385442004,
-0.0462889709,
-0.0298600011,
-0.028297266,
0.0402100086,
0.008314752,
-0.0075584799,
-0.0398334675,
0.0338663049,
-0.0373136029,
0.0200035051,
-0.0709526166,
-0.0509659052,
0.0417211391,
0.0189414602,
-0.0166390706,
-0.0394449979,
0.0339243077,
0.0183576774,
-0.0109313568,
-0.0581323169,
-0.0105283009,
0.023378823,
0.0078405952,
0.0624382757,
0.0059133777,
0.0079656485,
0.0369078815,
0.0076625943,
0.0281622708,
-0.0676946938,
0.00564986,
0.0192251392,
0.0580830611,
0.0249988362,
0.0151435444,
0.0742151141,
0.0240876544,
-0.1014521569,
-0.0018284557,
0.0384472646,
0.0629331619,
0.0263393614,
-0.0031869214,
-0.0631868467,
0.0102102496,
-0.0372109488,
0.0392182842,
-0.0098448778,
-0.0181036964,
0.0230999775,
0.0072380202,
0.0547724254,
-0.0314550996,
0.0029800613,
0.0139648514,
0.0323232412,
0.0196990985,
-0.0108912829,
-0.0247904863,
0.0077937162,
0.0190501064,
-0.0477875248,
-0.0211900286,
0.0216416605,
0.0016232702,
0.0181016084,
-0.0240121484,
0.0490945987,
0.0042871474,
-0.0274984539,
-0.0256033093,
-0.0374381058,
0.0382476002,
-0.009559623,
-0.0330329798,
0.0405184552,
0.0580308288,
0.0004329786,
-0.0007162049,
-0.0022084247,
-0.0337056406,
-0.0411710888,
0.0447752625,
-0.0013313945,
-0.0074207745,
-0.0233217347,
0.0073047206,
-0.013451037,
0.0040853089,
-0.0132576553,
-0.0536376126,
0.0003108823,
0.0695548132,
2.809e-7,
0.0525612347,
0.0264550839,
0.0181648545,
0.1228731051,
0.0103681413,
0.0359089784,
0.0040325969,
-0.0100449929,
0.0311147477,
-0.0682865828,
-0.0101455841,
0.0304184258,
0.0107025225,
0.0524267405,
-0.0996863768,
0.0007282918,
0.0004260739,
-0.0560694262,
-0.012098195,
0.0207108669,
0.0779389888,
0.0775277242,
0.0248557124,
-0.0316620767,
0.0313935429,
-0.038811028,
0.0483519733,
-0.0000370933,
-0.0030658024,
-0.0094491756,
0.0510213338,
-0.0070450529,
0.045244135,
0.0741409063,
0.0413830988,
0.0164089967,
-0.0488844067,
0.0218327027,
0.0141058946,
0.0034069123,
-0.017996246,
-0.0372641534,
-0.003144671,
-0.0353058539,
0.0909390002,
-0.0721121058,
-0.0282295458,
-0.0052443077,
-0.0299778655,
-0.0173571389,
0.0028884283,
0.0126602333,
0.0096482784,
0.0001359272,
0.0151444292,
-0.0104608517,
0.0006910589,
-0.0423605032,
-0.008329927,
0.0312144887,
-0.0519031547,
-0.0396529548,
-0.0272744559,
0.0148318997,
0.044696942,
-0.0764687285,
-0.015710311,
2.629065666e-34,
0.020564504,
-0.0278981291,
-0.0056664073,
-0.0035846324,
0.0647327825,
0.0217911284,
-0.0533247665,
-0.010835412,
0.0184795521,
-0.0363086499,
-0.0221652873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07230v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07230v2 | How are Prompts Different in Terms of Sensitivity? | 2023-11-13T10:52:01 | 2024-06-20T22:41:35 | Sheng Lu, Hendrik Schuff, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning (ICL) has become one of the most popular learning
paradigms. While there is a growing body of literature focusing on prompt
engineering, there is a lack of systematic analysis comparing the effects of
prompts across different models and tasks. To address this gap, we present a
comprehensive prompt analysis based on the sensitivity of a function. Our
analysis reveals that sensitivity is an unsupervised proxy for model
performance, as it exhibits a strong negative correlation with accuracy. We use
gradient-based saliency scores to empirically demonstrate how different prompts
affect the relevance of input tokens to the output, resulting in different
levels of sensitivity. Furthermore, we introduce sensitivity-aware decoding
which incorporates sensitivity estimation as a penalty term in the standard
greedy decoding. We show that this approach is particularly helpful when
information in the input is scarce. Our work provides a fresh perspective on
the analysis of prompts, and contributes to a better understanding of the
mechanism of ICL. | [
-0.0028635534,
0.0080707343,
0.0033314547,
0.0255193189,
-0.0013583072,
0.0202271026,
0.023386199,
-0.0074913455,
-0.0298274402,
-0.021444181,
-0.0345225185,
-0.0126543548,
0.0021831521,
0.033790987,
-0.0106918728,
-0.0550465956,
0.0581112951,
-0.0248485673,
0.0365265682,
0.0014143353,
-0.0335687436,
-0.0114289261,
-0.028642416,
0.0616677776,
-0.0355151929,
-0.0324194469,
-0.0194377583,
0.049670618,
0.0209604725,
-0.0192347895,
0.0106933014,
0.0568948016,
-0.0002934539,
0.0397393517,
0.0000021301,
-0.0827583,
-0.031393338,
-0.0256315228,
-0.0516449325,
-0.0066971164,
0.0463795252,
-0.0404135287,
-0.0342008136,
-0.0064958553,
-0.0194635559,
0.0261482485,
0.0759578645,
-0.0027253367,
0.0285309777,
0.0817726925,
-0.0010069208,
0.0160458945,
-0.0053423634,
-0.006026533,
0.0251810532,
-0.0616218112,
-0.0082264375,
-0.0882910863,
-0.0282183178,
0.0065373848,
-0.0458903909,
0.0477724299,
0.0400759764,
0.0090946732,
0.0507287458,
0.0469366834,
0.013569071,
-0.0076345657,
-0.0429207496,
0.0365599506,
-0.0462416522,
0.0001324667,
-0.0392316096,
-0.0400993787,
0.0344639793,
-0.0779975802,
-0.024554003,
-0.0029452844,
-0.028351834,
0.0248147249,
-0.0180945918,
0.0551433526,
-0.017505601,
-0.0103570009,
-0.0144713661,
0.0397285074,
-0.0121463342,
-0.0102730216,
-0.0031365936,
0.0032951464,
-0.0030576997,
-0.0343242735,
-0.0013247312,
0.0262667388,
-0.0804087073,
-0.0116579356,
-0.0483673178,
-0.0243380778,
0.0140921129,
-0.0128084775,
0.0502212457,
0.0573658161,
-0.0532803051,
0.0247895196,
-0.0212499145,
0.0600833483,
0.002394503,
0.0371168293,
-0.0158294924,
0.0102875931,
-0.0086915866,
-0.0013630243,
-0.0193893574,
0.0101518435,
-0.0529523939,
-0.0074673542,
-0.0269570798,
0.0493162796,
0.0032419898,
0.0073149921,
-0.0353143774,
0.0086944327,
-0.0794140548,
-0.0042815134,
0.0096952775,
0.0197387952,
-0.0432193577,
0.0224613491,
0.0234632622,
-0.0524753779,
-0.0207267627,
-0.0064132828,
0.0298110601,
-0.0208357889,
-0.0174806844,
0.0565794483,
-0.0476277582,
-0.0303530525,
-0.0105840266,
-0.025675904,
-0.0000369825,
-0.0053387722,
-0.0107194819,
-0.0495440513,
-0.0125515442,
0.0256487895,
0.0155254556,
-0.0401061773,
-0.0282846764,
0.0141261974,
0.0262692384,
0.0826298669,
-0.0023762549,
-0.0236798543,
0.032143265,
-0.0093433252,
-0.0492330976,
0.0832015872,
-0.0417793393,
0.049175553,
0.0222571623,
-0.0300305486,
0.018013265,
0.0067973882,
0.0203453992,
0.0069539486,
0.019782491,
0.0206224248,
0.0328456536,
-0.0011039487,
0.0902007893,
0.0136056729,
-0.0131619032,
-0.0262945574,
0.070412077,
0.051236596,
0.0277396236,
-0.025936231,
-0.0076188301,
0.0357787758,
-0.027339777,
0.0230702609,
-0.087226063,
0.0210838057,
-0.040669471,
0.0228780974,
0.0181817245,
-0.0211084131,
-0.0140345637,
-0.0498103574,
0.0183340181,
0.0173035003,
-0.0151032871,
0.0128733283,
0.0511590056,
0.0333228931,
-0.0626693517,
-0.0089808814,
-0.010066919,
-0.021106448,
0.0002474026,
-0.0538517609,
0.0208666436,
0.0346242711,
0.0058565689,
-0.0361336991,
0.0413689986,
-0.0059860381,
0.0277733468,
0.0246992465,
0.0158968884,
-0.0017870428,
0.0547414608,
-0.0196868014,
-0.0549696945,
-0.0060574366,
0.020516267,
0.056843441,
-0.0273614675,
-0.010660504,
-0.0218979046,
0.0065928469,
0.015179093,
0.0313166343,
0.0535497665,
-0.0747466013,
0.022161264,
0.0333705507,
0.0186905917,
0.0082461936,
0.0195906833,
0.0340633467,
0.0016227341,
-0.0349811837,
0.0502266325,
-0.0368525684,
-0.096076943,
-0.022180222,
-0.0128657976,
-0.0061391015,
-0.0176313892,
0.0271433368,
-0.0258551631,
-0.0118064843,
0.0146810431,
-0.0343836993,
0.049990207,
-0.0070131505,
-0.0001100234,
-0.0213080253,
0.0224862974,
-0.0481173508,
0.0735649616,
-0.0132490089,
0.0198457837,
0.0441720001,
0.0519748479,
0.0074256444,
-0.0678625852,
0.0054866555,
-0.0028362654,
-0.0517206937,
-0.0141693475,
0.0237632282,
0.0268005412,
-0.0383574106,
0.0311809108,
-0.0674786493,
-0.0226902384,
-0.0489101969,
0.0301741902,
0.026391916,
0.0166970193,
-0.0190031882,
-0.0643631592,
0.0095521258,
-0.0063324026,
-0.0343432762,
0.0328442566,
0.0191230569,
0.0183826908,
-0.0418566316,
-0.0400413834,
-0.0253012329,
0.0109313708,
0.0292111654,
0.0283077862,
-0.0307811555,
-0.036206767,
-0.000708372,
0.0795230865,
0.0065565594,
0.000230919,
0.0063169557,
0.0482447483,
0.001872852,
0.0237230286,
0.1126438826,
0.0227820221,
0.0541761108,
-0.004670376,
0.0221823473,
-0.054743398,
0.0136386584,
-0.0289261583,
-0.0518707745,
-0.0302292872,
-0.0219770167,
0.0407396592,
0.0514550693,
0.0096788621,
0.0151681257,
-0.0987550169,
0.022299774,
0.0080054523,
-0.0577144288,
-0.096797578,
0.0107408576,
-0.0294653755,
0.0798811391,
-0.0048156134,
-0.070578374,
0.0766185522,
0.0049574561,
-0.0070641795,
-0.0219268948,
0.0004151273,
0.0195501484,
0.0398766957,
-0.026369229,
0.0016924908,
0.0223653428,
-0.1019419357,
-0.0353298672,
0.005330536,
0.0177438203,
-0.0065690605,
0.0273288749,
-0.0166189931,
-0.0407670587,
-0.0287431981,
-0.0384201445,
-0.0538995117,
-0.0335151367,
-0.00683092,
0.0244776178,
-0.0006208695,
0.0019823723,
-0.014774261,
-0.0143135162,
0.0005845326,
0.0349280015,
0.0015952446,
-0.0333290696,
-0.0291803423,
-0.0012704321,
0.0097135566,
0.012077203,
0.0159294046,
-0.0039420696,
0.029946303,
0.0355679318,
0.0347586796,
0.020451447,
-0.0231757928,
0.0444672592,
0.0485768989,
-0.0222609676,
0.0173299704,
0.0741964877,
0.0518706404,
-0.0521618873,
-0.0376981646,
0.0550888851,
0.0183785129,
-0.0913391486,
0.0093429545,
-0.0356621854,
0.0136109125,
0.0284403674,
-0.0088661173,
-0.0365103148,
-0.0534794293,
0.024810914,
0.0662651584,
-0.0255951043,
-0.0057082004,
0.0055926307,
-0.0753263682,
0.0299758445,
-0.0043189907,
-0.0756082013,
-0.0832096487,
-0.0514744222,
0.0206847508,
-0.0134849306,
0.0095789488,
0.0202582888,
0.0003130396,
-0.0167262908,
0.0459671877,
0.0136053422,
-0.076975964,
-0.0159361456,
-0.0275672413,
0.0058016349,
0.0987753123,
-0.0274946708,
0.0183733515,
-0.0114069553,
0.0240339953,
-0.0396823995,
0.0229347516,
-0.0153021701,
0.0179897528,
-0.0200833939,
0.0227542091,
-0.0002702682,
0.0654744506,
-0.0380218104,
-0.0297604408,
0.0210707001,
0.0245443713,
-0.0231985226,
0.036687497,
-0.0402790308,
-0.041819904,
0.0611262396,
0.0542974398,
0.0344876461,
-0.0458393507,
-0.0214719512,
-0.0704302415,
0.0325492881,
-0.035850741,
-0.011245775,
0.0213877596,
-0.0066833552,
-0.0772229582,
-0.0481759086,
-0.0134195248,
0.0068062218,
0.0100095375,
-0.0268917177,
-0.0472403653,
-0.0552667454,
0.0218669251,
-0.0451622419,
0.0463092513,
0.0133885033,
0.0365816988,
-0.087818414,
0.0164930038,
-0.0218938515,
-0.0457203276,
-0.0315072387,
0.0057048094,
-0.0470245034,
-0.0296438094,
0.0324770175,
0.0204040017,
0.0208451357,
0.0605877861,
-0.0501243323,
-0.0367950834,
0.0658877566,
0.0635739118,
-0.032418862,
0.0246819463,
0.0782849342,
-0.0089452015,
-0.037624266,
0.0100412928,
-0.070119068,
-0.0021996894,
0.0527972281,
0.0246803034,
0.0003806833,
-0.0171398483,
0.0621778667,
-0.0424017832,
0.0701263398,
-0.0268001556,
-0.0722837001,
-0.0147433653,
0.0218018815,
0.0334655344,
0.0027926902,
-0.0103582013,
-0.0448503867,
0.0089269551,
-0.0150532518,
0.0299866162,
-0.0028106722,
-0.0177880339,
0.0256160982,
-0.0385157764,
0.0291402023,
0.0538233146,
0.0346057005,
0.0169127416,
0.0062572178,
-0.0559160784,
0.0215520244,
-0.0012897636,
0.0199028626,
0.0117360894,
0.0265513752,
0.033268515,
0.0068224934,
-0.004128796,
0.0343351252,
-0.0694138706,
0.0077769663,
-0.0352949016,
-0.0043510851,
0.0285710953,
-0.0126772663,
-0.01762731,
-0.0193605516,
0.0040757461,
-0.0518548526,
0.0141874244,
0.0368562415,
-0.0157511793,
0.0228293668,
0.0224552862,
0.0243001375,
-0.0259117894,
0.0629288331,
-0.044875592,
0.0233434327,
-0.0208333097,
0.0117324535,
-0.0552282818,
0.0039318441,
0.0568746738,
0.0820831954,
-0.0308703538,
0.0435746796,
-0.0434371717,
-0.0107906451,
-0.0127871931,
-0.0036097518,
-0.0062842593,
0.0105145173,
0.0788882002,
0.039124649,
-0.017051775,
-0.0634971038,
-0.0051450892,
0.0169566385,
-0.0228148885,
-0.006210695,
-0.0402183533,
-6.128514736e-33,
-0.0238853041,
-0.0273772087,
-0.0356692225,
0.0290967878,
0.0321392566,
0.0196242146,
-0.0296120644,
0.0117060877,
-0.0066367425,
-0.0056827189,
-0.0135349454,
-0.0000353731,
0.0265533198,
0.0397670567,
-0.0010533835,
-0.0272714011,
0.0320651866,
0.0205543004,
-0.0519258417,
-0.0063467529,
0.0312062874,
0.0184554085,
0.0242836978,
-0.0499033034,
0.0277418792,
-0.0065162727,
-0.0365841128,
0.0046026688,
0.0107759908,
0.0662409663,
-0.0284954924,
0.0628293455,
0.0124634514,
-0.0634989887,
-0.0324561521,
0.0640652478,
-0.0730422959,
-0.0143727148,
-0.0163982138,
0.037189547,
-0.0225042067,
-0.0596366115,
0.006151842,
-0.0050412863,
-0.0235946663,
-0.0414215326,
0.0331838764,
-0.0415554233,
-0.0294826329,
-0.0311855767,
-0.0605561621,
0.0084367422,
-0.0131770447,
-0.0377521813,
0.0282689296,
0.0775670782,
0.0123692704,
0.0222647637,
-0.0190291274,
0.020939447,
0.0063134041,
0.0381559059,
0.0588226728,
0.0612004288,
-0.0098023918,
0.0348417908,
0.0424293727,
-0.0311725028,
0.0296392348,
-0.0527023301,
0.0110452836,
0.0103893522,
0.0342965238,
0.0626916066,
0.0560076348,
0.0021294008,
-0.0301608834,
0.0258943308,
-0.0082432339,
0.0228631105,
0.040149007,
0.0306485035,
-0.036957033,
-0.0107007176,
-0.0335156992,
-0.0043179141,
-0.0255744066,
-0.0104622366,
0.0705253109,
0.0026651165,
-0.0023736886,
-0.0064223274,
0.0590292215,
0.0037528323,
0.0439411476,
-0.0001366037,
0.0307025071,
0.0325700119,
0.0089285169,
-0.0125587042,
-0.0006781882,
0.0026101335,
0.0418807715,
-0.027991794,
0.0332955085,
-0.0181149226,
0.0188417379,
0.0141798705,
-0.04399639,
-0.0163480323,
-0.0114386072,
0.0251559094,
0.0125187552,
0.0274507161,
0.0518549271,
-0.0372479297,
-0.0300095286,
0.0523608588,
-0.0503257588,
0.0204672161,
-0.0203119423,
-0.0134542948,
-0.0393830538,
0.0282182004,
-0.0355660841,
-0.0169361066,
-0.0291877203,
0.0347288474,
0.0116475541,
-0.0176848061,
-0.0395413116,
0.0483344495,
2.739e-7,
0.0258485451,
-0.0066359187,
0.0458313413,
0.00125671,
0.0130077731,
0.0652820989,
-0.0175499078,
0.0533924289,
0.0078712376,
-0.0098161101,
-0.0030387512,
-0.0198440067,
0.0405002981,
-0.0036634663,
-0.0733397752,
-0.017956797,
-0.0210721884,
0.0631792098,
-0.0363132283,
0.0505361483,
0.0360733829,
0.0705653429,
-0.0126595497,
-0.0012715148,
0.0574030057,
0.0065496434,
0.0031781334,
-0.0735060945,
0.0543473586,
-0.0248083491,
0.0048464853,
-0.0489328951,
0.0323767103,
0.0564938448,
0.0026694366,
-0.0225181784,
0.0133170979,
0.0165675264,
-0.000187294,
-0.0711051151,
-0.017515637,
0.0229536835,
0.0234485529,
-0.0902830288,
0.0441051237,
-0.0511079915,
-0.0203339439,
-0.0049862987,
-0.0169984214,
-0.0004465129,
0.018410584,
-0.0002324008,
-0.0168767031,
-0.0244099554,
0.0279617459,
0.0372665115,
-0.0155873094,
-0.0591681674,
-0.0204307046,
0.0175180715,
-0.0335925408,
-0.0463669524,
-0.0365128592,
0.0432804674,
0.0588808283,
-0.0756107941,
-0.0114306873,
2.255424225e-34,
0.0056763012,
-0.002502592,
0.0327773988,
0.0330829956,
-0.0177826229,
0.0079804007,
-0.0255754385,
0.0257098004,
0.0842153803,
-0.0367289111,
-0.0176665969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07217v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07217v1 | Troubles and Failures in Interactional Language. Towards a Linguistically Informed Taxonomy | 2023-11-13T10:24:51 | 2023-11-13T10:24:51 | Martina Wiltschko | cs.CL | cs.CL | The goal of this talk is to introduce a systematic research agenda which aims
to understand the nature of interaction between humans and artificial
conversational agents (CA) (henceforth humanmachine interaction, HMI).
Specifically, we shall take an explicit linguistic perspective focusing on
linguistically defined variables that are known to influence the flow of
conversations among humans (henceforth human-human interaction, HHI). | [
0.0704256073,
-0.0164368544,
-0.0652806237,
0.0039908364,
-0.0285017435,
0.0006303845,
0.0016242886,
0.0106484182,
-0.0032499484,
-0.0476900712,
-0.0048855552,
-0.0141103407,
0.0615898035,
0.0052485955,
0.0318309441,
-0.0734134763,
0.0392402858,
-0.032729093,
0.0010972919,
0.0297506526,
0.0140821869,
-0.0192881133,
-0.0190481674,
0.0343209133,
-0.045850765,
0.015346596,
-0.0723177716,
-0.0375476517,
0.0047477912,
0.0291427262,
-0.0155022722,
0.008859708,
0.0299766716,
0.0230209809,
0.0000017135,
-0.0622150078,
0.0731312335,
-0.0148224263,
-0.0367030166,
-0.0736690015,
0.0406923741,
0.0273520015,
-0.0253200606,
-0.0154945143,
-0.0541002639,
0.0293021537,
0.0409794524,
0.0215150584,
0.0137112429,
0.0325383171,
-0.0212690141,
0.003318771,
0.0142036062,
0.0060866717,
0.0159059931,
-0.0334131867,
0.0282865353,
0.0252102707,
0.037756782,
-0.0280528553,
-0.0174264573,
0.0153695922,
0.0025970098,
-0.0280515589,
0.0048381798,
-0.0009128846,
-0.0095649334,
-0.0630577058,
-0.0068272138,
0.0712486207,
0.0713410005,
-0.0027832924,
-0.0166567955,
0.0035601701,
0.0456142016,
0.0290936101,
-0.0135573037,
-0.0207521245,
-0.0031878683,
-0.0223997366,
-0.0263356157,
0.0060168398,
-0.0179707464,
0.028189132,
0.0001734097,
0.0723934993,
-0.027271457,
0.0021966984,
0.0205363277,
-0.0136125302,
0.0354457907,
-0.0532973409,
-0.0158565734,
0.0213655885,
-0.0602320023,
0.0217100568,
-0.0287072714,
0.045094423,
0.0372056887,
-0.0850964338,
-0.0205529314,
-0.0127529576,
0.0194639228,
-0.0085631488,
0.0844931081,
0.0299869273,
0.0027631412,
-0.037651062,
0.006177614,
0.0128301401,
-0.0405035838,
-0.0160976425,
-0.0292210169,
0.0212944169,
-0.0192330834,
-0.0154236276,
-0.000559616,
0.0635765791,
-0.0283431429,
0.0349638537,
-0.0385927111,
-0.0188784711,
-0.0728569254,
0.0119644888,
-0.0319884792,
-0.0395317301,
-0.0466890968,
0.0349273123,
-0.0231803227,
-0.109359242,
0.0341511033,
0.0338648781,
-0.0104286019,
-0.0128268497,
-0.0652122796,
0.0635569766,
0.0111674862,
-0.0440699831,
0.02297437,
0.0022704485,
0.0010865753,
-0.0494587682,
-0.0441416092,
-0.0046579512,
0.0164843537,
-0.0199322607,
-0.0240598153,
-0.026092967,
0.0067743859,
-0.0001985679,
-0.0145611279,
0.0632970035,
-0.0298423432,
0.0148248123,
0.0358991288,
0.0180347431,
-0.0072596627,
0.0186022408,
0.0322376043,
-0.0208718088,
0.0436894447,
-0.017283164,
0.0696940348,
0.0097393868,
-0.0248424038,
-0.0468207039,
0.0199766383,
-0.002727299,
-0.0241575893,
0.0180692114,
0.0195156857,
0.0421374105,
-0.0350767821,
-0.0159661416,
0.0347821377,
0.0772638097,
-0.0170836039,
0.0377430692,
0.0649110675,
0.0328196883,
-0.0302335564,
0.0538673736,
-0.0196097307,
-0.0186910164,
-0.0116230296,
-0.0079724882,
-0.034609016,
-0.0045316946,
-0.0193212964,
-0.0500927083,
0.0210329238,
-0.0332147181,
0.0408889018,
-0.0407907441,
0.0125766676,
0.0162427016,
0.0290714931,
-0.0209881738,
0.0085394727,
-0.0327923521,
-0.008915036,
-0.0335477516,
0.0003327066,
0.0575464591,
0.0115011549,
0.0140644573,
-0.0165196452,
0.0089208968,
-0.006793634,
0.0826827213,
0.0086451648,
-0.0399052128,
0.03054877,
-0.0091118757,
0.0491847396,
-0.0007427926,
-0.0105867637,
0.0253863689,
-0.0487394147,
0.0107724052,
-0.0062880288,
0.0537118204,
-0.016712971,
0.0095194848,
0.0173943564,
0.0099539347,
-0.0338280685,
-0.0006766645,
0.0300107561,
0.0286897663,
-0.0391945615,
-0.0013684845,
0.0098453434,
0.0335816741,
0.0058924151,
0.0744112507,
0.0209678505,
-0.0105629144,
-0.0067617972,
-0.0236360095,
-0.010757016,
-0.0182240419,
0.0491843745,
-0.0224311147,
0.0315009914,
-0.071039781,
0.0843747929,
-0.005703974,
0.0399289839,
0.0095972009,
0.0400884375,
-0.0027791879,
0.0007833642,
0.0168662276,
-0.0103418669,
-0.0156328361,
0.0261912383,
0.0083445637,
-0.0531766899,
-0.0100754956,
0.060625717,
-0.0238272734,
-0.0031019817,
0.0443605706,
-0.0241163261,
-0.0620782115,
0.0074860961,
-0.0981907472,
-0.0549527034,
0.0191232376,
0.0049100686,
-0.0269831046,
0.0104323728,
0.0010957514,
-0.0178592652,
0.0001992588,
0.0135146063,
0.0111695509,
-0.0034458935,
0.0589076616,
0.0319021307,
-0.0772154704,
-0.0424940549,
0.0318059325,
0.0080518257,
-0.0024393431,
0.0312995948,
-0.039704714,
-0.0472544506,
0.0021722701,
-0.0418542996,
0.0280982833,
-0.0248790774,
-0.0412044525,
0.0379662886,
0.0445706509,
0.0019387803,
0.0512492247,
0.0261180587,
0.0724756867,
-0.0153308269,
-0.0638025403,
-0.0394316651,
0.0020310641,
-0.0236825645,
-0.0036689383,
-0.0467735603,
-0.0363504812,
0.0227815248,
0.0473463237,
-0.0022369083,
0.0441293456,
-0.0391673818,
0.0374285541,
0.0069978335,
-0.0755281672,
-0.001142047,
-0.0469795242,
-0.0502925403,
0.0673534721,
0.0166255049,
-0.0255631451,
0.0754015371,
-0.0216281135,
-0.0295270476,
-0.0179731883,
-0.0306367613,
0.0054918691,
0.0263816286,
-0.0377537869,
-0.0286127944,
0.0496908873,
-0.0593242012,
-0.0240704399,
-0.0468069054,
-0.007128675,
0.0136415698,
-0.0134982225,
-0.084917374,
0.0223629698,
0.0283934921,
-0.0212668739,
-0.0114367809,
0.0212684255,
0.0108276019,
-0.0024985224,
0.0322320573,
-0.0297787618,
-0.0040867059,
0.0217558891,
0.018170923,
-0.0114626037,
0.0183512904,
-0.0110454513,
-0.0398247615,
0.0161888078,
0.0478734002,
0.0770407021,
-0.0240448844,
0.0519396029,
0.0688726828,
0.0244396906,
0.0080126459,
0.0006638753,
0.0028913734,
0.0070971772,
0.0204057451,
0.0103211757,
-0.0575016625,
0.0449290238,
0.0171832033,
-0.001374284,
-0.0231596828,
0.0692540705,
0.0231059901,
-0.0289386064,
0.0366786793,
-0.0539266914,
-0.0088625001,
-0.0433011129,
0.0132109141,
-0.0354191773,
0.0374027379,
-0.0021459584,
-0.0139795896,
-0.0724917799,
-0.007174483,
-0.003865045,
-0.0507768244,
0.0309068542,
-0.0011462404,
-0.036369551,
-0.0231420435,
-0.0115410713,
0.0389348678,
0.0050340774,
0.0587585345,
-0.010558513,
0.0090463739,
-0.0173922479,
-0.0015371599,
-0.0352833271,
-0.025787333,
-0.0039850511,
-0.0043295869,
0.082676664,
0.0793484449,
0.0638122931,
-0.0100156041,
-0.0164190549,
0.0219495501,
0.0020356602,
0.026664678,
-0.0284100883,
0.0021262828,
-0.0424184501,
0.0255436767,
-0.0674312189,
0.0147007108,
-0.0038011346,
-0.0054498478,
0.0220358428,
0.0359154753,
-0.0772400424,
0.000359467,
0.0119065475,
0.0259377565,
0.0231244136,
0.0095885303,
0.0381661505,
-0.05422296,
-0.0092791244,
0.0012470782,
0.0143612688,
0.0488551892,
-0.0296728425,
-0.0163149834,
0.0137304561,
-0.0975637883,
-0.0599043965,
-0.1305658966,
-0.0100730089,
0.0200190488,
0.005867383,
0.0038939819,
0.0503193922,
0.0341017097,
0.0214666333,
0.022651542,
0.0239962731,
0.0077149901,
-0.0220253356,
-0.0231639761,
0.0182018001,
-0.0320844613,
0.0023089589,
0.0027562624,
0.0218514558,
-0.0750224367,
0.0245140661,
0.0376010947,
0.0368794352,
0.0591089614,
0.0043475935,
-0.0530239567,
-0.0701342598,
-0.0167562328,
-0.0480834134,
0.0623173788,
0.0349523723,
0.0292235203,
0.0023060697,
0.0459812731,
0.0099635813,
0.0073917229,
-0.0577230193,
-0.0230478272,
-0.0824492574,
-0.0854598805,
0.0076544667,
-0.0119424993,
0.0344152488,
0.0290556941,
0.0021615743,
0.0214575138,
-0.0031040646,
-0.0180946719,
-0.0129957953,
-0.0485313796,
-0.0152047118,
-0.0420263484,
0.0688334331,
0.0227716621,
-0.0507297553,
-0.1002825648,
0.014671091,
0.0567136295,
-0.0060518445,
-0.0129621858,
0.0485876352,
-0.0142890187,
0.0310889892,
0.024159044,
0.0447951742,
-0.0042285523,
0.0521217361,
0.0314757079,
0.0888526216,
0.0175032243,
-0.041994866,
0.0221439358,
0.0272164643,
-0.0326553285,
-0.0476791821,
0.0183022991,
0.0068305819,
-0.002777349,
0.0420442224,
0.0276378542,
-0.0285650603,
0.0315585583,
0.0130365146,
0.0635620803,
-0.0096677467,
-0.0301579665,
0.0091617098,
0.017634809,
-0.0557041094,
0.0267684553,
0.0286786444,
-0.047139287,
-0.0164041035,
-0.0342640467,
0.0159012266,
-0.0488522723,
-0.0441925749,
0.0376590565,
0.0070938957,
-0.0086191641,
0.018435169,
-0.0649840012,
-0.0541500449,
-0.0221140403,
0.0090647861,
0.0285692886,
-0.0546107218,
0.0532586798,
0.0476929881,
-0.0014237796,
-0.0350293443,
-0.0488581732,
-0.0032968025,
-0.03506919,
0.0124122305,
-0.0400755741,
-5.587434319e-33,
-0.0731064081,
-0.0640336424,
0.0254328791,
0.0483388789,
-0.0479409397,
-0.0413595513,
-0.011662215,
0.0368480496,
-0.0320350565,
0.0007964026,
-0.005828368,
0.0268487465,
0.0089054164,
-0.0203369372,
0.0166777,
0.009945428,
0.0074010245,
0.0048039705,
-0.0071973521,
0.0167394225,
0.0006619373,
-0.0243492927,
-0.0008451889,
-0.0885581747,
0.0959837809,
0.0047620162,
-0.0215890482,
0.022457581,
0.0204255003,
-0.004619889,
-0.0174595863,
0.0406241827,
0.0364049375,
0.0215975419,
0.010237989,
0.0763332099,
0.0038259279,
-0.0628563836,
0.0518248715,
0.0513450578,
-0.0028962346,
-0.0089065656,
0.0180190727,
-0.0316819139,
-0.0760951191,
0.0754656568,
0.027278576,
-0.0012275863,
0.0119421547,
0.0654247701,
-0.0735661089,
0.0118509736,
-0.0302492641,
-0.023945149,
0.0271935929,
0.0224404391,
-0.0277622622,
-0.0603779778,
-0.0142821455,
0.0421317928,
-0.0283550154,
-0.0185567364,
0.0290780999,
0.0052635861,
0.0309968013,
0.0203272402,
0.0738201737,
0.0408073477,
0.004140629,
0.0015758895,
0.0229930915,
0.0588084944,
-0.0245550107,
0.0565296561,
-0.0752682909,
-0.0048823957,
0.0301286615,
-0.0080990056,
0.0448288247,
0.0480083004,
-0.0688293353,
0.0287215803,
-0.0957063064,
-0.0159131605,
0.014796597,
-0.0010214816,
0.0046078046,
-0.0786610171,
-0.0050088987,
-0.0421529636,
0.0528153069,
-0.0111950655,
0.0156946648,
-0.0346722864,
0.0035051005,
-0.0386588015,
-0.0251692403,
0.0215219054,
0.0132583482,
-0.012231661,
-0.0277751051,
-0.0355393328,
0.0051439106,
0.0205243975,
0.0466417633,
0.0123594645,
-0.0538019426,
0.0100343022,
0.024697952,
-0.0189179704,
0.0000094989,
-0.0052545313,
0.0051080938,
0.0125169642,
0.0225233324,
0.0228188243,
-0.0529015288,
0.035334859,
-0.0053437115,
-0.016460808,
-0.0593067221,
0.0049981191,
-0.0480168574,
0.0011090947,
-0.0651617721,
-0.0423182435,
-0.0288913138,
0.0239878725,
0.0528215915,
0.0005373329,
-0.0074407468,
-0.0688800141,
2.654e-7,
-0.0278454777,
0.045480419,
0.0200146027,
0.0100647714,
0.0197799075,
0.0291181989,
0.0021829491,
0.0309566502,
0.0042692111,
0.0086682253,
0.0529749356,
-0.0274036936,
0.0246569961,
-0.0060020131,
-0.0272642095,
-0.0348164327,
-0.0178519599,
-0.0318293162,
-0.0153948022,
0.0213211589,
0.0530873276,
0.0199171752,
0.0181936603,
0.014853999,
-0.0368928686,
-0.0113952504,
-0.0108754514,
-0.0693408251,
0.0038167599,
0.0422421545,
-0.0172337424,
0.0135669913,
-0.0148400944,
0.0493120998,
0.0370247513,
0.0349579901,
-0.0217237826,
0.0429613404,
-0.0320151821,
-0.0392570682,
0.0012302866,
0.0084984293,
-0.0160634294,
-0.0320849903,
-0.0098989448,
-0.0441761017,
-0.0649857596,
0.0192900188,
0.0098157674,
-0.002605611,
-0.035792727,
-0.004883843,
0.0053085946,
0.0080080312,
0.0095304064,
-0.0275167432,
0.0109492159,
-0.0276738219,
0.0330554135,
-0.0045660832,
-0.0545961298,
-0.0937921032,
0.0008168453,
-0.005629078,
0.0094168298,
-0.0148762437,
0.0103284372,
1.423061841e-34,
0.0106216958,
0.0082937619,
0.0364649333,
0.0848017335,
0.0667755008,
0.0312674232,
0.0158900581,
0.0725753605,
0.089235276,
-0.0295652281,
-0.0087113315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07215v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07215v3 | Coffee: Boost Your Code LLMs by Fixing Bugs with Feedback | 2023-11-13T10:15:19 | 2024-02-23T06:56:16 | Seungjun Moon, Hyungjoo Chae, Yongho Song, Taeyoon Kwon, Dongjin Kang, Kai Tzu-iunn Ong, Seung-won Hwang, Jinyoung Yeo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | Code editing is an essential step towards reliable program synthesis to
automatically correct critical errors generated from code LLMs. Recent studies
have demonstrated that closed-source LLMs (i.e., ChatGPT and GPT-4) are capable
of generating corrective feedback to edit erroneous inputs. However, it remains
challenging for open-source code LLMs to generate feedback for code editing,
since these models tend to adhere to the superficial formats of feedback and
provide feedback with misleading information. Hence, the focus of our work is
to leverage open-source code LLMs to generate helpful feedback with correct
guidance for code editing. To this end, we present Coffee, a collected dataset
specifically designed for code fixing with feedback. Using this dataset, we
construct CoffeePots, a framework for COde Fixing with FEEdback via
Preference-Optimized Tuning and Selection. The proposed framework aims to
automatically generate helpful feedback for code editing while minimizing the
potential risk of superficial feedback. The combination of Coffee and
CoffeePots marks a significant advancement, achieving state-of-the-art
performance on HumanEvalFix benchmark. Codes and model checkpoints are publicly
available at https://github.com/Lune-Blue/COFFEE. | [
0.0230920967,
0.0476345457,
-0.0257445648,
-0.0074959868,
0.003052834,
-0.0017827863,
-0.0917860493,
0.0101834228,
0.0145140085,
-0.0208014902,
-0.0157784633,
0.0373837501,
0.0076002954,
-0.0110688116,
0.0277523994,
-0.0251168497,
0.0536735877,
-0.0367113054,
-0.0402274504,
0.0357216187,
-0.0066886041,
-0.0024584078,
-0.0200481545,
0.0231203102,
0.0290697664,
-0.0332238413,
-0.0171578825,
0.0655837879,
0.0225572083,
0.0140644293,
0.0164677948,
0.0488199331,
-0.0678149685,
0.030957561,
0.0000023216,
-0.0410818681,
-0.0034382013,
0.010336265,
0.0157073047,
0.0461287238,
-0.0165042132,
-0.0076842848,
-0.0368613265,
0.031889122,
0.0104449168,
0.0184542481,
0.0387687385,
-0.026618842,
0.0739758909,
0.0632951409,
0.0345540009,
0.0386550315,
0.0136594092,
0.0160009842,
0.0828178898,
-0.0013721739,
-0.0024976565,
0.0164755657,
0.0156497173,
0.0041057887,
0.0209335033,
0.011546189,
0.0058426936,
-0.0382899605,
0.0272102654,
0.0070734709,
-0.0465065055,
-0.019899793,
0.0158794392,
0.0243535545,
-0.0423400775,
-0.0423385054,
-0.0110755358,
-0.0294565819,
-0.0190545395,
-0.0255487468,
-0.0298510119,
0.0011007416,
-0.014161407,
0.0078914249,
0.0012801733,
-0.0740171671,
0.0197524205,
-0.0149115501,
0.0340782106,
0.0156843923,
-0.007784294,
-0.0184008852,
-0.036357265,
0.0006434598,
0.0030948236,
-0.0306135491,
-0.0034457634,
0.0144517738,
-0.0306425449,
-0.0151837217,
-0.0225169435,
0.0314879268,
0.0484725572,
-0.0197221804,
0.0151843196,
0.0216258392,
-0.0501297526,
-0.0171896424,
-0.0407575294,
0.0008658744,
-0.0138335153,
0.0491713509,
0.0138756987,
0.0461746156,
-0.015374219,
0.0241552945,
0.0030273658,
0.024968097,
0.0224018209,
0.1302960068,
-0.0552358851,
0.0425672531,
-0.0163694993,
0.1129242629,
0.0108001009,
-0.0052566654,
-0.0136996116,
0.0045570638,
0.0186916292,
-0.0340888686,
0.0014459697,
-0.0371984169,
-0.0051818956,
-0.0583005138,
-0.031118501,
-0.0045546046,
-0.0604498833,
-0.0247159451,
0.0138004851,
0.0775805712,
0.0115516279,
0.0477329828,
-0.0492021814,
-0.0230386779,
0.005468287,
-0.0171136856,
-0.0573049784,
-0.0634898618,
-0.0510723405,
-0.0215523262,
0.012748017,
-0.0551676005,
-0.0004764915,
-0.0148040261,
-0.0171073973,
0.0458760597,
-0.0795526952,
0.032394141,
0.001725674,
0.0483452231,
-0.0284131225,
0.0232644398,
0.0441409126,
0.0041703382,
0.0511763245,
-0.0492211394,
0.0697594583,
0.0171496551,
-0.0122955535,
0.0307206865,
0.0259337611,
0.0191105306,
0.0075441441,
0.0271896683,
0.0079301968,
0.0175006259,
0.0026297076,
0.0086266855,
0.0293158498,
0.0083885388,
0.0186005402,
0.0413986742,
-0.0108542331,
-0.0023047593,
0.0019586293,
-0.0281306449,
-0.053568121,
0.0607750528,
-0.0592453033,
0.0418620594,
0.0046978039,
0.0304297805,
-0.0038338292,
-0.0642131642,
-0.0374002941,
0.0418432057,
-0.0719967335,
-0.009527293,
0.0192426071,
-0.0240283608,
-0.0458283499,
0.0259634629,
0.0166103393,
-0.0787824094,
-0.0535285883,
-0.0440643989,
0.0623509251,
0.0649074763,
0.0376580432,
-0.0862362757,
-0.0692054182,
-0.044566948,
-0.0100013046,
-0.0471146666,
0.0598350056,
-0.0244802665,
0.0135793909,
-0.0232982747,
0.010956889,
0.013631911,
-0.0000808623,
0.0262305699,
0.0193581805,
-0.0559464358,
0.0078348778,
-0.0085554319,
-0.0618372448,
0.0285658967,
0.0594495386,
0.0134550743,
0.0248274561,
-0.0366417095,
0.0145135317,
-0.0103356279,
-0.0379127525,
-0.0195895266,
0.037121851,
0.0236828718,
-0.0077734278,
0.0311316848,
-0.0002679699,
-0.0194770172,
0.0187446177,
-0.043082431,
-0.0671583116,
0.0548744127,
-0.088325128,
0.0089672171,
0.0432008728,
0.0194939561,
-0.006883902,
-0.0111031625,
0.0315819979,
-0.0335427299,
-0.0543905087,
-0.0013885037,
-0.011673904,
-0.0059194425,
0.0313041061,
-0.0469700471,
0.0744431987,
-0.0159517638,
-0.009373663,
-0.0006528372,
0.0178636611,
0.0041290596,
0.0270880926,
-0.0208284948,
0.0776481479,
-0.0309470333,
-0.048145324,
-0.0751627088,
0.0268188231,
-0.0090225097,
0.0189549271,
0.0176262408,
0.0137575492,
-0.0109837782,
-0.004887668,
0.0151723092,
0.0013750928,
0.013649907,
-0.0162832942,
0.044864621,
-0.0138210887,
-0.0575241484,
-0.0703862384,
0.0080497833,
-0.0310238395,
-0.015950175,
-0.016057374,
-0.0246781539,
-0.0811968222,
0.0750253499,
0.0282984171,
0.0199613106,
-0.008559728,
-0.0250253994,
-0.0167714898,
-0.0298845917,
0.0280349217,
0.0421658531,
-0.0124158245,
-0.0021813186,
0.0358677618,
0.0162311792,
-0.0590355508,
0.0115187112,
0.0358580314,
-0.0730239078,
0.024421012,
-0.007379191,
0.0476085879,
0.0528965779,
-0.0260880422,
-0.0437890217,
-0.0188279357,
0.0403438769,
0.0448880009,
0.0272303857,
0.0043352377,
-0.0068213698,
-0.0233337935,
0.0356345028,
-0.0440752171,
-0.119165279,
0.0467654504,
-0.0241405033,
-0.0018528039,
0.0187900104,
-0.007370349,
-0.0484980866,
0.019326672,
-0.0199484155,
-0.002415979,
0.001451053,
-0.0195969548,
0.0154261114,
0.0125740096,
0.0260404702,
-0.0335609764,
0.0600462481,
-0.0691420138,
0.0001328507,
-0.0204927213,
-0.042038627,
-0.0338286012,
0.0156313833,
-0.0211884789,
-0.0254705977,
0.0104708886,
0.004495393,
0.0109776985,
-0.0095747551,
-0.0065147793,
0.0128732519,
0.0171801578,
-0.0576481037,
0.0065887631,
-0.077755101,
-0.0765214488,
-0.0395249873,
0.0159808565,
-0.0123785343,
-0.0242403299,
0.0630709752,
0.069148235,
0.0253639575,
-0.0218063574,
-0.0123882256,
0.0399195999,
-0.0326283127,
-0.0211783443,
-0.0070986911,
0.0767161325,
-0.0065585133,
-0.0444057621,
0.0470600203,
0.021790918,
-0.0483340584,
0.0332562365,
-0.0157785323,
0.0509953834,
0.0674946606,
0.0581223145,
-0.0988192111,
-0.0341416933,
0.0267319493,
0.0618502498,
-0.0222496353,
-0.0180400405,
-0.0028870825,
-0.0711812153,
0.047859937,
0.0413617566,
-0.0184924286,
-0.0287493654,
-0.0072081913,
0.006688721,
-0.0305814873,
-0.0444022305,
0.053034924,
0.0020303132,
0.0165750254,
-0.0048631714,
-0.0264706034,
0.0086819958,
0.0276390277,
-0.0354074463,
0.0475914776,
0.0536668152,
-0.0124167101,
0.0219638627,
-0.0021964435,
0.0768048763,
0.0232286211,
0.0034845138,
-0.0424914621,
-0.0042592869,
-0.0134604378,
0.012362658,
0.0329186432,
0.0181128234,
-0.0481168665,
-0.0441047251,
0.0457534306,
0.0127961403,
-0.0208609626,
0.0047073015,
-0.0166784786,
0.0024555644,
-0.0132850008,
0.0035198582,
0.0370814204,
0.0274429247,
-0.0139844082,
-0.0881193727,
-0.0380019955,
-0.080262132,
-0.0100633632,
-0.0418201163,
-0.016601542,
0.0354589336,
-0.0204960685,
0.0271129999,
0.0146662509,
0.0170767438,
0.0203261059,
-0.0668470338,
-0.0358349569,
0.0132102398,
-0.0334877521,
0.0204821322,
-0.0074244477,
0.0143944817,
-0.0349514596,
-0.0056247409,
0.0063182618,
-0.0033778169,
0.0095855286,
0.0270235557,
-0.0539041087,
-0.0555342361,
-0.0310146995,
0.1293859929,
0.0227012858,
0.0499566682,
-0.0509072244,
-0.0622134805,
-0.0479534678,
0.0402851552,
0.0094829202,
0.0211570021,
0.0202328824,
-0.0010898395,
0.0225085691,
-0.0271039344,
-0.032340087,
-0.0205866992,
0.0272591002,
-0.0179457311,
0.0298783537,
-0.0088994503,
0.0202909783,
0.0409667343,
0.0188438073,
0.0265706908,
-0.0215554088,
-0.0282667801,
0.0302349869,
0.0171013512,
0.0052169655,
-0.0238259677,
0.0789249763,
-0.0140872356,
-0.081678167,
-0.007094298,
0.010006764,
-0.0929802284,
0.0594615117,
-0.0163802989,
0.0302436426,
-0.0073417285,
0.0311475731,
0.0961364582,
0.0202586241,
-0.0009775867,
0.0447025448,
0.0317842364,
0.0339114778,
0.0047285091,
0.0136578102,
0.0130526153,
0.0717488527,
-0.0046636839,
0.0245728306,
-0.0427497104,
-0.0591036119,
-0.0390855111,
0.0346576683,
0.0530186146,
0.0669468641,
0.018271273,
0.0089838458,
-0.015873827,
-0.027140798,
0.0525395609,
-0.0295036025,
-0.0095540332,
-0.0051502832,
0.0190904066,
-0.0041449917,
-0.0549085513,
0.0439250171,
-0.0631657839,
0.0416689329,
-0.0282550938,
-0.0105132163,
-0.0218243692,
0.0092737935,
0.0203187168,
-0.01320579,
-0.0005831675,
-0.1087647453,
-0.0220454093,
-0.0385745429,
0.007869957,
0.0776815936,
0.0435471237,
0.0108213183,
-0.0200532135,
0.0418506451,
0.0223216061,
0.0018281649,
0.0143385585,
-0.0288927443,
0.0047658845,
-0.0435850956,
0.0039323741,
-5.986643221e-33,
-0.0253687333,
0.0044327704,
-0.0239255521,
0.0467991047,
-0.0151069453,
-0.0679661632,
-0.027236715,
0.0158456061,
0.0659813583,
-0.0295703374,
-0.006213163,
0.0110559845,
-0.0186547656,
-0.0671294257,
0.0712944567,
0.0275265351,
0.0527615882,
0.0569214858,
-0.0852773637,
-0.0063168206,
-0.0400537364,
0.0422106236,
0.0095671732,
-0.0112265777,
0.0091152322,
0.010246031,
-0.0034305134,
0.0356980488,
-0.0311474539,
0.0217135139,
0.0551140048,
0.0136558032,
-0.0178908017,
0.0139990803,
-0.0263409428,
-0.0582732335,
-0.0106697995,
-0.0289395787,
0.015216276,
-0.0100397086,
0.0066926093,
-0.0599817783,
0.0493461937,
0.0371105596,
-0.0331372693,
-0.0139779663,
-0.0271886252,
-0.0033359854,
0.0214502327,
-0.0160126705,
-0.0216650181,
0.0332599543,
-0.0548820309,
0.011983064,
-0.0470717922,
-0.0070773857,
0.0160860941,
0.0274420027,
0.0293136034,
-0.000818873,
0.0471893325,
0.0015815084,
0.0564549118,
-0.0255473759,
-0.0206111241,
0.0124662714,
0.0342864282,
0.0432803258,
-0.0223198906,
0.0202962793,
0.0316681452,
0.0218356773,
0.0387233309,
0.0735499263,
-0.0003725859,
-0.0264080837,
-0.0093183191,
0.0629846528,
-0.0591415279,
0.0134537593,
-0.024197787,
0.0445469059,
-0.0087975198,
0.0020608145,
-0.0620836653,
-0.0013173103,
-0.0257172044,
-0.0283656456,
0.028895922,
0.0026949637,
-0.0258925371,
-0.0206764992,
-0.0254729949,
0.0150736878,
0.039511662,
-0.0564147942,
-0.0371164866,
0.0101559153,
-0.0545508452,
-0.049195502,
0.0076421229,
-0.0170594379,
-0.0144256679,
0.0054413546,
0.0757990628,
-0.0164056495,
0.0343086235,
0.0165158194,
-0.06368348,
0.0395230688,
-0.0494825244,
0.0294198152,
-0.0224378482,
-0.0189883877,
-0.0433252603,
-0.0237900149,
0.0151070748,
0.0682828799,
-0.0092966342,
-0.0028634863,
-0.0605788454,
0.0232176073,
0.0235096775,
0.0461031049,
-0.0098720444,
-0.0284272116,
0.0201526061,
0.0034260221,
0.0356128551,
-0.0419082232,
-0.0472104438,
0.0058063031,
2.96e-7,
0.0160709545,
0.0526597276,
0.0313351713,
-0.0053572156,
-0.016866466,
0.0465308167,
-0.0273786727,
0.0250291564,
0.0260020476,
0.0397949368,
-0.0034786286,
0.0144538078,
0.0481495373,
0.0371158011,
-0.0087439483,
-0.0135706365,
0.0054017771,
0.0172411017,
-0.0366147682,
-0.0305266753,
-0.0081562484,
-0.0149777541,
0.0492778644,
-0.0044617932,
0.0304010566,
0.0244110916,
-0.0019372279,
-0.0629402623,
-0.0247684065,
0.0392228961,
-0.0060193152,
-0.005106579,
0.0134880105,
-0.0349029116,
-0.0226761904,
-0.0736061856,
-0.0362483449,
0.0587833747,
-0.0146620767,
0.026801819,
0.0137846014,
0.0082450649,
0.0077850525,
-0.03599957,
0.0120177139,
0.0041788784,
0.0263214204,
-0.0161179155,
0.0207706094,
-0.0334295668,
0.016685063,
-0.0413448475,
0.0231382325,
0.0155931385,
-0.0133032538,
0.0375132561,
-0.0500804372,
-0.0258434899,
-0.0478430316,
-0.0082371021,
0.0112487534,
-0.054451976,
0.021148514,
0.0424050726,
-0.0079332655,
-0.0369551182,
0.008910493,
2.69598734e-34,
0.0441836789,
-0.0218822099,
0.0472252257,
0.0161489714,
0.0603314675,
-0.019238364,
0.0166300256,
0.0019373372,
-0.0051229196,
0.0453330278,
-0.0552113056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07194v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07194v3 | Exploring the Factual Consistency in Dialogue Comprehension of Large Language Models | 2023-11-13T09:32:12 | 2024-04-01T16:37:50 | Shuaijie She, Shujian Huang, Xingyun Wang, Yanke Zhou, Jiajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | LLMs (Large Language Models) usually interact with users in the form of
dialogue and generate responses following their instructions, which naturally
require dialogue comprehension abilities. However, dialogue comprehension is a
general language ability which is hard to be evaluated directly. In this work,
we propose to perform the evaluation focusing on the factual consistency issue
with the help of the dialogue summarization task. Besides evaluating and
analyzing the dialogue summarization performance (DIAC-Sum) of different LLMs,
we also derive factual questions from the generated summaries and use them as a
more flexible measurement of dialogue comprehension (DIAC-QA). Our evaluation
shows that, on average, 26.8% of the summaries generated by LLMs contain
factual inconsistency. Even ChatGPT, the strongest model evaluated, has such
errors in 16% of its summaries. For answering the factual questions, which is
more challenging, the average error rate of all evaluated LLMs is 36.1%. Both
results indicate serious deficiencies. Detailed analysis shows that the
understanding of subject/object of the conversation is still challenging for
LLMs. Furthermore, to stimulate and enhance the dialogue comprehension ability
of LLMs, we propose a fine-tuning paradigm with auto-constructed multi-task
data, which achieved a relative error rate reduction of 11% on DIAC-QA. | [
0.0541405752,
0.0070551937,
-0.0138740139,
0.0514252521,
-0.026840521,
0.0305176601,
-0.0332780331,
-0.0539026372,
-0.0007842422,
-0.028245654,
-0.0257691573,
-0.0486206375,
0.0329534113,
0.013123584,
0.004679515,
-0.0565943345,
0.0589797609,
-0.032523524,
-0.005087018,
-0.0090114838,
-0.0029531275,
0.0025244066,
-0.022922894,
0.0357151255,
0.0366376005,
-0.0068368567,
-0.0206746552,
-0.0152066862,
0.0218993761,
-0.0141841024,
-0.0015814134,
0.0145937577,
0.0090126516,
0.0351366289,
0.0000019806,
-0.0693757012,
0.0163834654,
-0.0379588269,
-0.0623580851,
0.0414910726,
0.0179592837,
0.0305761769,
0.0246222019,
0.0127204424,
-0.0138595141,
0.0102196364,
-0.0004699222,
0.0780139342,
0.0972432271,
0.0564126782,
0.0159952436,
-0.0254155993,
0.0188934002,
0.0034994946,
-0.0052896244,
-0.0716067255,
-0.00264851,
0.098790437,
-0.0041255248,
0.0147689162,
-0.0069866888,
0.0346259139,
0.006614517,
-0.009271238,
-0.016075803,
0.0246525519,
-0.0338488966,
-0.0367127769,
0.0029621511,
0.0919197574,
0.0341687724,
0.0158620253,
-0.0119957877,
0.0259976462,
0.0166289154,
-0.0048147333,
-0.0903903022,
0.0383632071,
-0.0277929474,
0.0180371236,
-0.0218461063,
-0.0069786012,
-0.0003949851,
0.0058120857,
-0.0167970546,
0.0396719351,
-0.0139126824,
-0.0276053604,
-0.0423863605,
-0.0082595432,
-0.0288578644,
-0.0566739738,
0.0117202103,
0.0616010204,
-0.0950056762,
0.0318110436,
-0.034848772,
-0.0002956128,
0.028583169,
-0.067323342,
0.0223752428,
0.0365583934,
-0.0126396986,
0.0819436759,
-0.0126090813,
0.0903768241,
0.0305498242,
0.0326896459,
-0.0575703494,
-0.0122100431,
-0.0485163145,
-0.0032323231,
-0.0311190244,
0.0193216521,
-0.0302045643,
-0.034657307,
-0.0265854448,
0.0383040644,
0.0313871019,
0.0242740475,
0.0041256086,
0.0006424278,
-0.0159832686,
-0.0001622838,
-0.0480845012,
0.0289590564,
-0.0371046625,
0.0042763869,
0.0338096917,
-0.0633628219,
-0.0185270421,
0.0199333951,
-0.0195620079,
0.0019559998,
-0.0292783417,
0.0380765684,
-0.02158756,
-0.0356027037,
-0.0076405434,
-0.0259543043,
-0.0225481633,
-0.0685333759,
-0.0223563183,
-0.0478827879,
0.0227099247,
0.0078274058,
-0.0175186154,
0.0113889193,
0.0101133697,
0.0064209653,
-0.021240674,
0.0475257561,
-0.0056957011,
0.0419006497,
0.0563666709,
0.0138379596,
-0.0254822727,
0.0474277027,
0.0571476966,
0.0064666984,
0.0439923294,
0.0061887843,
-0.0193838477,
0.0089058643,
-0.0108824084,
0.0050302572,
0.0227258038,
0.0135043766,
-0.0111824162,
0.0155526632,
0.0376350097,
0.0759070367,
-0.0397693738,
-0.0048834044,
0.0921676755,
0.0293601882,
0.009951191,
0.006967613,
0.0106822392,
0.0399801545,
0.0614392608,
0.0682511404,
-0.0468432531,
0.0223549847,
-0.0261041746,
0.0568021946,
0.0733503103,
0.0375120565,
-0.0252562482,
-0.0561947227,
-0.0133728106,
0.0203669798,
0.0233876873,
0.0353884809,
0.0310020689,
0.0170830525,
-0.0410849154,
0.0667741299,
0.0196893997,
-0.0500159971,
-0.0153424554,
-0.0681260675,
0.0412711762,
0.0508258455,
0.0407757945,
-0.0010842786,
-0.0657791123,
0.0022633697,
0.0156022171,
0.0286026765,
0.0628583133,
-0.0134475986,
0.0133534856,
-0.0412286855,
-0.0144553492,
-0.018728558,
0.0070641218,
0.0069494518,
-0.0112716304,
-0.0347656906,
0.0166863576,
-0.0269863252,
-0.0107045416,
0.0151710389,
-0.0413566381,
0.0023289397,
-0.0228908788,
-0.0214927476,
0.030434275,
0.0292343572,
-0.0168436132,
-0.0027875379,
0.0189906526,
-0.0144550055,
0.0004620228,
0.0157959647,
-0.0652293116,
-0.0415237024,
0.0547104292,
-0.0092618065,
-0.0389555357,
0.0232792795,
-0.0255698971,
-0.0691678524,
0.0155121377,
-0.0753443837,
-0.0116883144,
-0.0583757609,
0.0194179695,
0.0052922592,
0.0101400521,
-0.0344417542,
0.064770624,
0.0032591808,
0.0207433049,
0.0490104705,
0.0192014873,
0.0159849264,
-0.0584233254,
-0.0029353627,
0.0136750471,
-0.006221306,
0.0043732994,
0.0215031225,
-0.0028760436,
-0.0695128068,
-0.0307666715,
-0.113835156,
0.0183203984,
-0.0258291587,
0.0140325418,
0.0361841843,
0.0075169667,
-0.0204404946,
-0.0147442333,
-0.0365230292,
-0.0057439301,
0.0396039449,
-0.0130848307,
0.0266319178,
0.0162900146,
-0.0109950164,
-0.055299025,
0.0150762601,
0.0086003579,
0.0113293305,
0.0104917521,
-0.0000867342,
-0.0626288205,
0.0422653183,
-0.0412693173,
-0.0190719813,
-0.0123021342,
-0.0366269685,
0.02444412,
0.0220381506,
0.0775054991,
0.0767349675,
0.0399445668,
0.0191973634,
0.0377110243,
-0.0421472713,
-0.0356144197,
0.0208573304,
-0.0068513043,
-0.022418458,
-0.0201483276,
-0.0387381762,
0.0107765533,
0.0577723794,
0.0341960713,
0.0357917175,
-0.014388592,
0.0025008603,
-0.0170505084,
-0.0095659178,
-0.0450536795,
-0.0018602279,
-0.0438186824,
0.0514059849,
-0.034423355,
-0.0034591651,
0.0772601888,
-0.0572315305,
-0.011052086,
-0.044386629,
-0.0295084789,
-0.0306958444,
0.0403227918,
-0.0050635752,
0.0264056865,
-0.0220823158,
-0.038087599,
-0.0476451591,
-0.0337852314,
0.0430421755,
-0.0498869978,
0.0885669142,
-0.0409845449,
0.0017755205,
-0.0068669263,
-0.0033804483,
-0.0504292808,
-0.0397536121,
-0.0341445841,
0.0128367636,
-0.0050130859,
0.0062421439,
-0.0599771291,
0.0225266106,
0.0557777882,
0.0121216811,
-0.0306906104,
-0.0154926684,
-0.0251420438,
0.0347937383,
0.0491612554,
0.0645997673,
0.0342565291,
-0.0469602421,
0.0660287589,
0.0307935737,
0.0088891368,
0.0076610479,
0.0000327444,
-0.0111805452,
-0.0061072749,
-0.0105153657,
0.0099686394,
0.0003730117,
0.1039211676,
-0.0317621082,
-0.0204829238,
0.1372590661,
0.0235487148,
0.0123300469,
-0.0174823646,
-0.0358233117,
0.0216189623,
0.0171524081,
0.0024655196,
-0.0643364713,
-0.0335930623,
0.0175403785,
0.0235898513,
-0.000988562,
-0.014355801,
-0.0271850284,
-0.0990362167,
0.0219396278,
-0.0031876876,
-0.0341039561,
-0.0237311237,
-0.030178206,
0.029316647,
-0.0029557266,
0.092278786,
0.035712149,
0.0055651013,
-0.0083246455,
0.0087463595,
-0.0376138464,
-0.0061261239,
0.0304659382,
-0.0052148225,
0.060614612,
0.0508842915,
0.0376665369,
0.0099966154,
0.0199127868,
0.0513842814,
-0.0059259781,
-0.0132072521,
0.0092625106,
0.0403408445,
0.0009468713,
-0.0070135365,
-0.0530059896,
0.0149750337,
0.014393013,
-0.0166006442,
0.0114193028,
0.0168644432,
-0.026993528,
0.0015135625,
-0.0148122562,
0.0554827414,
-0.0263132043,
0.0960422009,
0.0662565604,
-0.0105543761,
-0.016908491,
-0.032190688,
-0.0347771198,
-0.0419656038,
-0.0062956768,
0.0184263531,
-0.0082001844,
0.0262668096,
-0.0603480004,
-0.0511013642,
0.0180885363,
-0.028298784,
-0.0216952562,
0.0025258989,
0.0308125876,
0.004150908,
0.0128084887,
0.0040363977,
-0.0420538485,
0.0222711563,
-0.0378704071,
-0.0068208911,
0.0185105782,
-0.0318641663,
-0.0076622847,
0.030805489,
-0.097268939,
-0.0493586361,
-0.018015977,
0.0444514267,
0.0256185532,
0.0249088984,
0.0067527154,
-0.032013543,
-0.0132311424,
-0.002870918,
-0.0277299155,
0.0262251962,
-0.0034595612,
0.0527220815,
-0.0151987774,
0.0216662195,
-0.0425526872,
0.0127727771,
-0.0536122546,
0.0568404533,
-0.0485266037,
-0.1028902829,
0.0227225572,
0.0478835888,
0.0187017806,
0.0333007388,
0.0162058156,
-0.018078221,
-0.0048598521,
-0.0241526105,
-0.0093454598,
-0.0451939292,
0.020372374,
-0.0154608171,
-0.0437658094,
0.0262628756,
-0.0050762184,
-0.0518201962,
0.0283676889,
-0.0288936142,
-0.0122256167,
-0.0303940047,
-0.0342824981,
-0.0133142173,
-0.0228795018,
-0.0477501005,
-0.0134571958,
0.0017530221,
0.0317354426,
0.047849264,
0.0836676881,
0.0110899759,
-0.0277143531,
0.0086026089,
0.0224021282,
-0.0785552636,
-0.0393104963,
0.0100079738,
0.062406037,
0.0205958914,
0.0074306526,
0.057698682,
-0.0196885001,
0.0147195663,
-0.042751614,
0.0299242362,
0.003672515,
0.0025812252,
0.0292116441,
0.0287936255,
0.0047865133,
-0.0124435462,
0.0755828246,
-0.0125834243,
0.0025967595,
0.0019382855,
0.0162195265,
-0.0553508028,
-0.0464941263,
-0.0286942516,
0.0182262156,
-0.0216715876,
0.0042254943,
-0.0414515808,
-0.0513032712,
0.0201744642,
0.0353336334,
0.0301883016,
-0.0486321934,
0.0129690254,
0.0484384894,
-0.0081265867,
-0.0182302725,
-0.0308937598,
-0.0118842097,
-0.0171996932,
0.0280715637,
-0.0247702468,
-6.282092338e-33,
-0.0613574125,
-0.0434116013,
0.0164511297,
-0.0003585739,
-0.0413197689,
-0.0098702302,
-0.0722854733,
0.0308524128,
-0.0232337415,
-0.0096598072,
-0.0000462145,
0.0339572094,
0.0100621972,
0.0259146206,
-0.0277853776,
-0.0369170196,
0.0402561203,
0.0039790943,
-0.0485217609,
0.0218755677,
0.018528061,
-0.0100915544,
0.0078987312,
-0.0478865542,
0.0578767546,
-0.0419123136,
-0.0150176808,
0.0376411304,
-0.0029907776,
0.073616907,
-0.0224895906,
0.0500510633,
0.0296893511,
-0.037190821,
-0.051631052,
0.0279544517,
-0.0531381518,
-0.0321104899,
0.0802054256,
-0.0024639748,
-0.0333345681,
0.0063567138,
0.0369325131,
0.0002069223,
0.0111687612,
-0.0472333953,
0.0207975395,
-0.0371524207,
-0.0342031159,
0.0133260805,
-0.0355442613,
0.0214340426,
-0.031881161,
-0.0804292411,
-0.0100074317,
0.0519317985,
-0.004173167,
-0.0125295855,
-0.0244201943,
0.0193349887,
0.0152126662,
-0.0069793533,
0.0606142879,
0.0386979952,
0.010687124,
0.0590952225,
-0.0107817193,
0.0235620476,
-0.0470466837,
-0.0448318236,
-0.0077267159,
0.0220102314,
0.0118137412,
0.0380489789,
-0.0018353239,
0.0270570479,
-0.0361336246,
0.0411869511,
0.0236059465,
0.0602039583,
0.0350662842,
0.0177701507,
-0.0256564859,
-0.0105172535,
-0.0746719167,
0.0691890195,
-0.0401904546,
-0.0131910266,
0.0242533758,
-0.0207750574,
-0.0037772714,
-0.0583286695,
0.0382277817,
-0.0380217731,
0.0237090774,
-0.0037744327,
-0.0255556945,
0.0162082687,
-0.013683686,
0.0273767412,
-0.0234469213,
-0.0003962434,
0.0173663627,
0.0306146275,
-0.017822342,
0.0138185546,
0.0077510937,
-0.0422617383,
-0.0225798301,
0.008651603,
-0.0033525252,
0.0245488156,
-0.0479428247,
0.040377792,
0.02644144,
0.0007449461,
-0.0457971953,
0.0634953901,
-0.0343336686,
-0.0222730152,
-0.0423055626,
-0.0083543686,
-0.0035939855,
0.0138317151,
-0.048571527,
0.0120043559,
-0.0341038704,
-0.0174037293,
-0.0042837537,
-0.0339768529,
0.0022013418,
0.0089720776,
2.606e-7,
0.0132612633,
0.0524807647,
0.0245509483,
0.0499155,
-0.0123844901,
0.0438916534,
-0.0249501802,
-0.0005032517,
0.060970474,
-0.0465039983,
-0.0105216308,
0.0710980445,
0.0648544058,
0.0077416883,
-0.0838174894,
-0.0228588954,
-0.0840627551,
-0.0232885052,
-0.0178489201,
0.0165144932,
0.0849621892,
0.0654740408,
-0.0245368015,
0.0036452697,
-0.0040846197,
-0.0349327475,
0.047616262,
-0.0270572603,
-0.0778111815,
0.0183369294,
0.0605270565,
0.026077481,
0.0099027343,
0.0143912695,
0.0268877037,
-0.006980727,
0.0208912063,
0.0511993691,
0.0279633775,
-0.0275739431,
-0.0290696602,
-0.0202541742,
0.0357562006,
-0.0363315456,
0.0466310978,
-0.0653318092,
-0.0426768735,
-0.0367294066,
-0.0100825345,
-0.0118722813,
0.0165449176,
-0.0122482739,
-0.0278434884,
0.0230242833,
0.0037828772,
-0.0228170827,
0.0188599918,
-0.0467464589,
-0.0199451353,
0.0146906534,
-0.0449503399,
-0.0660441592,
-0.0328667983,
-0.0338436775,
0.0408342034,
-0.0492956154,
0.0131216766,
1.994068439e-34,
0.0578523166,
-0.0127840005,
0.0315151513,
0.0103640715,
0.0465525426,
-0.0232793074,
0.0024202,
0.0056087035,
0.0227721985,
-0.0825802386,
-0.0035383655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07172v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07172v1 | VerityMath: Advancing Mathematical Reasoning by Self-Verification Through Unit Consistency | 2023-11-13T09:06:58 | 2023-11-13T09:06:58 | Vernon Toh, Ratish Puduppully, Nancy F. Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.PL | Large Language Models (LLMs) combined with program-based solving techniques
are increasingly demonstrating proficiency in mathematical reasoning. However,
such progress is mostly demonstrated in closed-source models such as
OpenAI-GPT4 and Claude. In this paper, we seek to study the performance of
strong open-source LLMs. Specifically, we analyze the outputs of Code Llama
(7B) when applied to math word problems. We identify a category of problems
that pose a challenge for the model, particularly those involving quantities
that span multiple types or units. To address this issue, we propose a
systematic approach by defining units for each quantity and ensuring the
consistency of these units during mathematical operations. We developed Unit
Consistency Programs (UCPs), an annotated dataset of math word problems, each
paired with programs that contain unit specifications and unit verification
routines. Finally, we finetune the Code Llama (7B) model with UCPs to produce
VerityMath and present our preliminary findings. | [
-0.0367112979,
0.1303593665,
-0.0053211586,
0.0466454737,
-0.0675184429,
-0.013951702,
0.0376553722,
-0.0016579112,
-0.0416408516,
0.0017702872,
0.0223538075,
-0.0217436869,
0.0114876051,
0.0186780989,
0.0036686566,
-0.0038265847,
0.0612508766,
-0.0554271229,
-0.0104713934,
0.0029260421,
-0.0179189686,
-0.0219058413,
-0.0310554802,
0.0023850217,
-0.0602797791,
-0.0725947171,
0.0111925146,
-0.0656825677,
-0.0114252558,
-0.0290708747,
-0.0221357234,
0.0291886739,
0.0101229921,
0.054228887,
0.000002389,
-0.0568624437,
-0.0014011405,
0.0425964035,
-0.0499667786,
0.0511002168,
0.0172217768,
-0.020093793,
0.0025798799,
0.0290968213,
-0.0359091163,
0.025821887,
0.0111403177,
0.0017210327,
0.06036596,
0.053844858,
-0.0058471784,
-0.0187825169,
0.0149414167,
-0.0191312432,
-0.0120660765,
-0.0523496047,
0.0241644382,
0.0638998598,
0.0549831167,
0.0408452936,
-0.0225903187,
0.0368083827,
0.0652092844,
-0.0059927842,
-0.0346128531,
-0.0150155034,
-0.0298296809,
0.0023892573,
-0.0134069482,
0.0330629013,
0.0444318205,
-0.0181283541,
-0.0253940858,
-0.0056383987,
-0.0348108448,
0.0154724745,
-0.0354323275,
0.0357003845,
0.0287408791,
0.0226868968,
-0.0208474603,
0.0022092923,
0.0266505219,
0.0118590333,
-0.0575805083,
0.1154379845,
0.0194322821,
-0.0344216451,
-0.0246933829,
-0.0381012596,
-0.0704210177,
-0.0669537708,
0.0378727652,
0.0561980568,
0.014313668,
0.019528104,
-0.0322518945,
-0.0151283378,
0.0162064359,
-0.0886594951,
0.0192308463,
0.0696741566,
-0.0179023389,
0.0342277326,
0.006224656,
0.106762439,
-0.0264450163,
0.0303623267,
-0.018965954,
0.0490318276,
0.0150830233,
-0.0113749607,
-0.0402129851,
0.0220242832,
0.0233925562,
0.0190251414,
-0.0494191833,
0.0096836202,
-0.0532205179,
0.0520113893,
0.010613244,
-0.0411339216,
0.0157979373,
-0.0445332415,
-0.0248865802,
0.0164811816,
-0.0456076041,
-0.0013046591,
-0.0259459913,
-0.063976869,
-0.0126574188,
0.0017422627,
-0.0463457853,
-0.0327537134,
0.0497842357,
0.0464317165,
0.0247755665,
-0.0003772406,
-0.0149567388,
0.003215936,
0.0094230119,
-0.0862735808,
-0.0256282818,
-0.103859812,
0.0289956536,
0.0134242997,
-0.0174772665,
-0.0300715119,
0.0209775791,
0.0055031297,
0.0410805643,
0.0737718046,
0.0192035213,
0.0289565697,
0.0353353955,
0.0191879235,
0.0085598482,
0.0361861847,
0.0402811058,
-0.0451066643,
0.0284165163,
-0.0101228328,
-0.0015965768,
0.047572121,
0.0104841106,
-0.0166077875,
-0.0684138909,
0.0185147133,
0.0219822992,
0.0460455306,
-0.0590879507,
0.072847724,
-0.0201452728,
-0.0009716775,
0.019683741,
0.047277458,
0.0135290856,
0.0143429115,
0.0065975552,
-0.0402541049,
0.0467335433,
-0.0167243406,
-0.051851172,
0.0174123514,
0.0154582467,
-0.0004122083,
0.020715788,
0.0274996404,
-0.0267225858,
-0.0782324523,
-0.0585605875,
-0.0135108633,
-0.049299404,
-0.0132498005,
0.0715427175,
-0.038658388,
0.0141762309,
0.0197128691,
-0.0091763875,
-0.0492782295,
-0.0019818645,
-0.0183909219,
0.0612180009,
0.0048210118,
0.0811482742,
-0.0575425178,
0.0002847667,
0.0165209621,
0.0043856287,
0.0153298574,
0.0273058135,
-0.0019515686,
-0.0117600309,
-0.0494559631,
0.0322392359,
-0.0263029598,
0.0241569877,
-0.0367059186,
0.0443628132,
0.0348564461,
0.014042126,
-0.050652016,
0.0182271227,
0.0277283229,
-0.0035729932,
-0.0691055357,
0.0069612735,
-0.0000678141,
0.0084204823,
0.0012069482,
0.0010179267,
0.0529029854,
-0.0030221136,
-0.0217519253,
-0.0360916071,
-0.0330355018,
-0.0520351008,
0.0399815626,
0.0867073238,
-0.0031717597,
-0.0255255625,
0.0256115086,
-0.0289153438,
-0.0066263331,
0.0790137574,
-0.000573871,
-0.0342318416,
-0.014305193,
0.0286207721,
0.0069650915,
-0.0176034439,
0.0068652788,
0.0379163511,
0.0179249775,
0.0068737394,
-0.0087848501,
0.0108679617,
0.0387974009,
0.0228669718,
-0.0108471978,
-0.0043466478,
-0.0136578493,
0.0228908304,
-0.0452700928,
-0.0032499516,
0.0073984265,
-0.01992248,
-0.0297998022,
0.0067273621,
-0.0113738701,
0.0557333902,
-0.0014878064,
-0.0200684462,
0.0052425526,
0.0039270143,
-0.0090806847,
-0.0329478942,
0.0266433991,
-0.0127196405,
0.0130327092,
0.0021722903,
0.0023230177,
-0.0411831141,
-0.0344786569,
-0.0614869818,
0.0356353857,
-0.0029757335,
0.0462633632,
-0.02533333,
0.0251628309,
-0.0597490221,
0.0301968548,
-0.0053603342,
0.0337517038,
0.0384165943,
-0.0119319921,
0.0587718748,
0.0394268371,
-0.0230451263,
0.0533678308,
0.0429579653,
-0.0552250966,
-0.0497407429,
0.0163775515,
-0.0125643797,
-0.0255770274,
0.0478551872,
-0.02347962,
0.0033936603,
0.0701321736,
-0.0137117039,
-0.0253632832,
0.002591758,
0.032028731,
-0.048212789,
0.0314123854,
-0.0134749273,
0.0033391556,
-0.0026721179,
0.0164805334,
0.0162190273,
-0.0556178093,
0.0340484492,
-0.022913605,
0.0076275496,
-0.0352908075,
-0.0114543391,
-0.0844151005,
0.0457226671,
-0.0265937801,
-0.010450067,
-0.0706641451,
0.0239806809,
0.0170565359,
0.0177146401,
0.0241025332,
-0.0108752828,
0.0674538538,
-0.0340651646,
0.0268381257,
-0.0055621518,
-0.0455372892,
-0.0377953313,
0.0322958082,
-0.0202441141,
0.021220332,
-0.0423804447,
-0.0229076147,
0.0182121471,
0.0305082798,
0.0213460904,
0.0111627746,
-0.0289183557,
-0.0175332278,
-0.015172312,
0.0017556601,
0.0024882436,
0.0321842693,
0.0474462844,
-0.0244188458,
-0.0076039373,
0.0185785871,
0.0584858619,
0.0041643013,
-0.0409620292,
0.003573803,
0.0126683358,
-0.041274488,
-0.0068386504,
0.0452726223,
-0.0026357882,
-0.0564508848,
-0.0352775082,
0.0698156357,
0.0613663383,
0.0104682278,
0.000942034,
-0.0926241577,
-0.0103938123,
0.0195772797,
0.0369671136,
-0.0904430673,
0.0041925255,
0.0077201016,
-0.0310514979,
0.0210920833,
-0.0032970938,
-0.0206516925,
-0.088191703,
0.018651519,
0.0392516963,
-0.0229123533,
-0.0118538933,
-0.038965065,
0.0002105323,
-0.0053801835,
-0.0125563554,
0.0435030907,
0.01905315,
0.0091416137,
-0.0144668426,
0.0270299129,
-0.0007300711,
0.0242227651,
-0.0092256973,
0.0105965314,
0.0308767557,
-0.0017780248,
-0.0425230935,
-0.104056865,
0.0521579124,
0.0410081483,
-0.0421739109,
0.0073861699,
-0.0378888845,
0.006038174,
-0.0127453683,
-0.0184119903,
0.0219665971,
-0.0359329358,
-0.0477926508,
0.0374762788,
0.0884353369,
-0.0171540584,
-0.0006771708,
-0.0226559024,
-0.0274982192,
-0.0326012634,
0.0558854565,
-0.0099102575,
0.0010273381,
-0.0667272583,
-0.017061498,
-0.0108133387,
0.0078450153,
-0.0138467578,
-0.009773422,
0.0638154969,
-0.0151106762,
-0.011162621,
0.0120453192,
0.0359755158,
0.0306442883,
0.0128979953,
-0.0678511709,
0.0620297231,
-0.0023010247,
-0.0357585587,
0.0171005316,
-0.0634571835,
0.0642168149,
-0.0717647523,
0.0697796643,
-0.0148784686,
-0.0088731823,
-0.0031349515,
0.0489210673,
-0.0887314156,
-0.0369844548,
0.0120218052,
0.0428316221,
0.0248321276,
-0.0506897494,
0.0037942398,
0.000203549,
-0.0399922356,
0.024323225,
-0.0633340105,
0.035987854,
-0.008502638,
0.0148549974,
0.0228141807,
-0.0001380098,
0.0290236473,
0.0234080926,
-0.0376996659,
0.0550071597,
-0.0047149239,
-0.0253690928,
0.0129389223,
0.0697115064,
-0.0293924436,
0.0567393713,
0.0824737474,
-0.0268401392,
0.0111177526,
-0.0462235957,
0.016983252,
-0.0417016037,
0.0054724626,
-0.0226971488,
-0.0078364462,
-0.0087836068,
-0.0417552181,
0.0235164091,
0.0047738976,
0.0530760847,
0.0290876012,
-0.0114543298,
0.0641861558,
0.0274560917,
-0.0430507287,
0.0188899357,
0.0076787779,
-0.0108810226,
0.04517515,
-0.0036455418,
0.06035823,
0.005136217,
0.0207357705,
-0.0428050272,
-0.0160634853,
0.0134451622,
-0.0915554836,
-0.0088920835,
0.0272046626,
-0.0257716402,
0.0293344744,
-0.0384966023,
-0.0721263215,
-0.0066156504,
-0.0128969112,
0.0101856636,
0.0234440435,
0.0133509794,
0.026086282,
0.0450074747,
0.010723711,
-0.0365573801,
0.0293874927,
-0.0450126454,
0.026548855,
0.0136601962,
0.0028014155,
-0.0101237837,
-0.04788284,
-0.0257930066,
-0.0008960182,
-0.0245274045,
-0.0114885587,
-0.1075729728,
-0.0586541779,
-0.0036543531,
0.0374325141,
-0.0119494246,
0.0064410591,
0.0253026132,
0.0672245696,
-0.0114415977,
0.027603602,
0.0439671502,
0.0345189013,
-0.0504820459,
-0.0170683693,
0.0183116514,
-6.117236235e-33,
-0.0383814313,
-0.0565216169,
0.0644781068,
-0.0071392176,
0.0246624388,
-0.0114419153,
-0.0223456994,
0.0261213575,
-0.0297654308,
-0.0186649524,
-0.0120370975,
0.0255652573,
0.008813045,
-0.0180605743,
0.0322347432,
0.0176312942,
-0.0105484687,
-0.00917642,
-0.0584191307,
-0.0468346849,
0.0030800258,
-0.0410548374,
0.0538244396,
-0.0547868311,
0.0272007473,
0.0039791982,
-0.0269481484,
0.0546031035,
-0.0870078951,
0.0550855286,
-0.0267719887,
0.027245041,
-0.005235686,
-0.0202164799,
0.0042412505,
0.0006909161,
-0.0380198956,
-0.0713735074,
0.0149534009,
-0.0103861596,
-0.0623211339,
-0.0178042259,
0.0199830923,
0.0309538357,
-0.0661524832,
-0.0032851077,
-0.0074589085,
-0.0040869843,
0.019492263,
0.0131010981,
-0.0272090007,
0.0356637761,
0.0068905316,
-0.0161439367,
0.026466582,
-0.045263093,
-0.0549309365,
-0.004740655,
-0.0063147736,
0.0002747998,
0.0584996156,
0.036288403,
0.0362488069,
-0.0605863817,
-0.0302391537,
0.0070027853,
0.0236805305,
-0.0492079444,
-0.0416012481,
-0.0345379114,
0.0337937884,
0.0545735247,
0.0902048796,
0.0205842592,
0.0472095907,
0.0067720446,
-0.0549140386,
-0.0062344912,
-0.0040918496,
0.0250026286,
-0.0267644655,
-0.018330384,
-0.0551243946,
-0.0001127911,
-0.021532448,
0.0033680883,
-0.0856620967,
-0.0165025871,
0.0246124044,
-0.0104332343,
0.0157817155,
0.0105846906,
0.0063712467,
-0.00960714,
-0.0181384422,
0.0013834471,
0.0100392951,
0.023584472,
0.0066392743,
0.0278476868,
-0.0555649102,
0.0209322926,
-0.0414904021,
0.0118891355,
0.0384342074,
0.0320793353,
-0.0144117326,
0.0550547913,
-0.0538383722,
-0.0024668842,
-0.0267601963,
-0.0204165541,
0.0476060733,
-0.0056697996,
0.0338033959,
-0.0033990098,
0.010520882,
0.0287111811,
-0.0375710279,
-0.0684022978,
-0.0310492516,
0.0522625633,
0.0104446821,
0.0210782886,
-0.0044575413,
-0.0300368387,
-0.0395982675,
0.047854133,
0.0162028875,
-0.0470584258,
-0.0057797912,
-0.0045897635,
3.137e-7,
0.0288729854,
0.049339477,
0.0527050085,
0.0274866577,
0.0041867653,
0.0276858173,
-0.0451267287,
-0.0235881712,
-0.0401595831,
-0.0150949713,
0.0188317802,
0.0412899666,
-0.0007141753,
0.0503979363,
0.0414830968,
0.0599149726,
-0.0176835041,
0.0008295437,
-0.0772659555,
-0.003749351,
0.0335366353,
0.0280505233,
0.0520435274,
0.0026918906,
-0.0083532939,
-0.0453486964,
0.0360707901,
0.0144321425,
-0.0117616132,
0.0378692299,
-0.0046075764,
0.0078629712,
0.0071819304,
-0.0353562944,
0.0159405973,
0.0241604894,
0.0361503065,
0.1048187092,
0.0223063752,
0.0304727014,
-0.0267799851,
-0.0211660322,
-0.0439674109,
-0.0649707243,
0.0527307093,
-0.007052592,
-0.0283499435,
-0.0396620221,
0.0463167205,
-0.0313535966,
0.0237917025,
0.0218364801,
0.0467704646,
0.0009540014,
0.0099916607,
0.0099862963,
-0.0187959969,
-0.0559894033,
-0.0459218547,
-0.0125915613,
-0.0424906686,
-0.0201474372,
-0.0474003851,
0.0483173169,
0.0230399407,
-0.0195605922,
-0.0149648422,
3.042338255e-34,
0.0349239521,
-0.0195084214,
0.020326484,
0.0354164317,
0.0214812551,
0.0138170868,
-0.0569083616,
0.0253448449,
0.0041026543,
-0.031797912,
-0.0266778506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07171v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07171v1 | calamanCy: A Tagalog Natural Language Processing Toolkit | 2023-11-13T09:06:43 | 2023-11-13T09:06:43 | Lester James V. Miranda | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce calamanCy, an open-source toolkit for constructing natural
language processing (NLP) pipelines for Tagalog. It is built on top of spaCy,
enabling easy experimentation and integration with other frameworks. calamanCy
addresses the development gap by providing a consistent API for building NLP
applications and offering general-purpose multitask models with out-of-the-box
support for dependency parsing, parts-of-speech (POS) tagging, and named entity
recognition (NER). calamanCy aims to accelerate the progress of Tagalog NLP by
consolidating disjointed resources in a unified framework. The calamanCy
toolkit is available on GitHub: https://github.com/ljvmiranda921/calamanCy. | [
0.0731250644,
0.018517239,
-0.0184298735,
0.0360413864,
-0.0204492006,
0.044003062,
-0.0391762145,
0.006355748,
0.0630743429,
-0.0467555448,
-0.0281125959,
-0.0139155909,
0.0221363958,
0.0271706712,
-0.0064257081,
-0.0899398476,
0.0145841446,
-0.0005918865,
0.0614819936,
0.0443805084,
0.0312099252,
0.0435238332,
-0.0273477323,
0.0549722016,
-0.0043703318,
-0.0308413859,
0.0098160543,
0.0115318438,
0.0032088107,
-0.0634573027,
0.0141432052,
0.0200507659,
-0.092299208,
-0.0034832843,
0.0000022569,
-0.0488706976,
-0.0324396491,
-0.0124739595,
-0.0099434359,
-0.0304080937,
0.0471767522,
0.017587008,
0.0023230044,
-0.0062778182,
-0.0573159158,
0.0158454701,
0.0642476007,
0.0827617645,
0.0272645894,
0.0562225319,
-0.0137991114,
-0.043127913,
0.0222417433,
-0.0204818435,
0.0059377518,
0.0016902656,
-0.015805278,
0.011364908,
0.0682084039,
0.0027955568,
0.0216874741,
0.0030127054,
-0.0241978504,
-0.000166097,
0.0351361185,
0.0001483696,
-0.0226565972,
-0.075450331,
0.0039669806,
0.0324141905,
0.0159943216,
-0.0281144101,
0.0238359924,
-0.0027947058,
0.0096894717,
-0.0088992417,
-0.0555083863,
-0.0060716546,
-0.0349424593,
0.0165126529,
0.075657621,
-0.0213632304,
0.0195562337,
0.0102171013,
0.0059963041,
0.0509558469,
-0.0122178383,
0.0049860287,
-0.0013296906,
0.0318242535,
-0.0311277173,
-0.0618280768,
0.0303744636,
-0.0071205273,
0.0357547589,
0.0120305661,
0.0163069181,
-0.0230564103,
0.0220930222,
-0.0387373045,
-0.0688785166,
0.0376024432,
-0.0600179993,
0.0308578908,
-0.0202692784,
-0.0237914901,
0.0202690437,
-0.0106530115,
-0.0079937298,
-0.0355642177,
-0.0909732729,
-0.0305499043,
-0.0388169996,
0.0595614426,
-0.0554859228,
0.0044950601,
-0.0367012955,
0.0057783243,
-0.0449531637,
-0.0343503505,
0.0248321276,
0.0078868605,
-0.0007994903,
-0.0011701972,
-0.0270617418,
0.0541752912,
-0.0562348031,
0.025152497,
0.0153243467,
-0.0787390098,
0.0220321026,
-0.0142235477,
-0.0037443768,
-0.0254249368,
0.0339668989,
0.0324980095,
0.0377947614,
-0.0365104079,
-0.0796164721,
-0.0227116197,
-0.0358427577,
-0.0660820231,
-0.0388421975,
-0.0841715634,
0.0410306491,
0.035330195,
0.0455496721,
-0.031250935,
0.0329877399,
0.0143688871,
-0.0197538845,
0.0733761266,
-0.0065206545,
-0.0281310398,
0.0125277098,
0.0390657075,
0.03469925,
0.0554096624,
0.0357718505,
-0.0048675542,
0.0496040098,
0.0033567415,
-0.0528094731,
-0.0048643923,
-0.0374130607,
-0.0309204459,
0.047038123,
-0.0116244834,
0.0021686889,
-0.039059639,
-0.0092113391,
0.0064089838,
0.0066339266,
0.0577143244,
-0.0015781762,
0.0682202503,
-0.0124034807,
0.0009795977,
0.0220782869,
0.0052570831,
0.005984514,
-0.0028502638,
-0.0287367254,
0.0288513992,
-0.0026342564,
-0.0054479977,
-0.0275952909,
0.0487195514,
0.0095632812,
-0.0483001024,
-0.0095151514,
-0.0197482575,
-0.0015375139,
-0.0287939515,
0.0371173397,
0.0390634909,
-0.0390347838,
0.0370998718,
0.0428814515,
-0.0583831146,
-0.012375378,
0.0043253275,
-0.0033069851,
0.0571416318,
0.0445539914,
0.0028569566,
-0.0191766769,
-0.0186386015,
-0.0602689087,
0.0251622275,
-0.0260468908,
-0.0238205343,
0.0027968409,
-0.0311327539,
0.0294448193,
0.0299704541,
0.0152805746,
0.0139466822,
0.0365114436,
0.0438343808,
0.0105102537,
0.0288116187,
-0.0148138748,
0.0419701971,
0.0130748171,
-0.0413757078,
0.0154345362,
-0.0143125169,
0.0200362578,
0.0778692141,
0.0004640695,
-0.0010737376,
0.0233682618,
-0.0067533678,
-0.0166650768,
0.0758643001,
0.0018851752,
-0.0090474058,
0.0048112548,
-0.0363484211,
-0.0132974805,
-0.0182775799,
0.0087340763,
-0.0480666533,
0.0033709011,
0.0288013369,
0.0260458607,
-0.0492080003,
0.0528631136,
-0.0134462407,
0.0430606641,
-0.0162054244,
0.0296404418,
0.0327142291,
-0.0019329636,
0.0029234726,
0.0228370354,
0.0385525934,
-0.0138666239,
-0.032203231,
0.0201940425,
-0.008154612,
-0.0289979242,
-0.0111516397,
0.0353171751,
-0.059297476,
-0.0237038732,
-0.1368415654,
0.0316116177,
-0.0106407981,
0.0544535667,
0.0323797837,
0.0367739275,
-0.0358953103,
-0.0189248398,
0.0816686526,
-0.0110296803,
0.0106639639,
-0.032450866,
0.0127284015,
0.006678273,
0.0056827581,
-0.0222545918,
0.0396334827,
0.0001817334,
0.0066847741,
0.0461544804,
-0.1075634435,
-0.0187164582,
-0.0353743993,
-0.009514519,
-0.0078223022,
0.0453606881,
-0.0276109055,
0.0025565263,
0.0125827761,
0.0193409454,
0.0255151335,
-0.0557371154,
-0.00190712,
-0.0110296002,
-0.0349511951,
0.0097434167,
-0.006900725,
0.0201277398,
0.0352577977,
0.0097243665,
-0.0371701866,
0.025932746,
0.0822179168,
0.0003086584,
0.015172041,
-0.0007854651,
-0.047607176,
-0.0512606315,
-0.0242995713,
0.0617600344,
0.0071293805,
-0.0386045799,
-0.0199094787,
0.0024116775,
-0.0104733389,
0.0562386252,
-0.0209560879,
-0.0433339253,
-0.0773110166,
0.0052040624,
-0.047344178,
0.0754814893,
-0.0064542224,
0.0014466327,
0.0427399091,
-0.0527083427,
0.0229498409,
0.0453139879,
0.0073729423,
-0.0009866698,
0.0166654456,
-0.0684988201,
0.0128286732,
-0.0088529391,
-0.0173302088,
0.0011603303,
0.0829185918,
-0.0698697418,
0.0060970667,
0.005814122,
0.0050937487,
0.0472400337,
0.0249455944,
-0.0307740886,
-0.0137599902,
0.0054088091,
-0.0004189265,
0.0081230225,
0.0640186891,
0.0054302909,
-0.0525691621,
-0.0066987472,
0.0390616469,
0.0053373938,
0.0598305799,
0.0071441554,
-0.0079716193,
0.0174619202,
-0.0178388469,
0.0022227771,
-0.0518145822,
-0.0432476811,
-0.0081614451,
0.0039270772,
-0.0545781665,
-0.0053925491,
0.0838261321,
0.0444035232,
-0.0238087922,
-0.0124379853,
-0.0326557048,
0.0194374062,
0.0139099136,
0.0176407248,
-0.0773663372,
-0.0436966531,
0.018464053,
-0.0266086534,
-0.0225846395,
-0.0399688184,
0.0031702814,
-0.1062783748,
0.0431808084,
-0.0063457098,
0.050738018,
-0.0215006191,
-0.0181008596,
-0.0240121242,
-0.0209598076,
-0.0595227815,
-0.0200498495,
-0.033522062,
-0.0016887786,
0.0162411556,
-0.0408973619,
-0.0031331237,
0.017674055,
-0.029816851,
0.0472416356,
0.0616673827,
0.0374368094,
-0.0213831216,
0.0537305027,
0.0205874555,
-0.0119010201,
-0.0292137843,
-0.0363230668,
0.0145888953,
0.0056188409,
-0.0125272572,
-0.0387525298,
0.0174464397,
-0.0320045277,
-0.0245547835,
0.0096384129,
0.0702360794,
-0.0208223574,
0.012725994,
0.0084746936,
0.0050648698,
0.0490637533,
0.0535689071,
0.0222802535,
-0.0384305343,
-0.0638762191,
-0.0399323441,
-0.0256051309,
-0.0568786301,
-0.0030209504,
0.0671784803,
-0.0323632509,
-0.0482090674,
-0.0750782937,
-0.0548222102,
0.047971759,
0.0201549735,
0.0273100846,
0.0369926393,
0.0237618927,
0.0035600339,
-0.0241079386,
0.0209232606,
0.0028896993,
0.0148917856,
-0.0613480583,
-0.0448697805,
0.0110368347,
0.042017933,
-0.0022281872,
0.0281583983,
-0.1000961214,
-0.0408843532,
0.0045870072,
0.0025767731,
0.0230730064,
-0.0135402093,
-0.0357002579,
-0.0288719013,
-0.0678820908,
0.0208169632,
-0.0926511139,
-0.0165344384,
0.0015121194,
0.0313548632,
0.020631304,
0.0334227048,
0.0130917542,
0.0028937634,
-0.0384204276,
0.0341073684,
-0.0054733213,
-0.0065323249,
0.0033822537,
-0.0011752121,
0.0303287152,
-0.0451687314,
0.0016622521,
-0.0746490881,
-0.0043653934,
0.0135873044,
-0.0028989287,
-0.0239750445,
0.009542807,
0.040720325,
0.0069961217,
0.0163898729,
0.0225534085,
-0.0303912424,
0.0149396639,
-0.003559836,
0.0464769453,
0.0453704558,
0.0051608807,
-0.0144348545,
-0.0287347659,
0.0145214899,
-0.0245879553,
-0.0195162091,
0.0493900664,
-0.0519365668,
0.065702118,
-0.0189758278,
-0.009368971,
0.0335810259,
0.0107597793,
0.0263345838,
-0.0044808094,
-0.0088968351,
0.0203768015,
0.0678259432,
-0.0382626504,
0.0666183084,
-0.0465420596,
0.0015996768,
-0.0069734682,
0.0345934518,
-0.0328216664,
-0.0061102295,
0.0082982676,
-0.0156291071,
-0.0138139855,
-0.0049483497,
0.0423788242,
-0.0031895177,
0.0375239961,
0.0552312396,
-0.0039413036,
-0.0200272538,
-0.0613883398,
-0.0122878617,
0.0062755411,
-0.0351670533,
0.0147193633,
-0.0556500666,
-0.0437276587,
-0.0173815787,
-0.030086752,
-0.0012229836,
-0.0034263053,
0.0260615889,
0.0143778948,
0.033980716,
-0.0050282385,
-0.0670107231,
0.0034773347,
0.002653989,
0.0117390305,
0.0006596007,
-6.715968038e-33,
-0.0555271618,
-0.0507750399,
0.0066418443,
0.0162764341,
0.004652739,
-0.0384194851,
-0.0256347749,
0.0095358817,
-0.0031112768,
-0.0065743821,
-0.0212682448,
0.003330145,
0.0373077951,
-0.0094342325,
0.0721866563,
0.0149070779,
0.0170877036,
0.0526512526,
0.0164645407,
-0.0007001499,
0.0553457998,
0.0665258616,
0.0935920402,
-0.0813052654,
0.0740433335,
0.0291250758,
-0.0109852292,
-0.0448089428,
0.0627014861,
0.0470666848,
-0.0113644712,
-0.0039665508,
0.0393571444,
-0.0111680087,
-0.0067118071,
0.0348758288,
-0.1236640736,
-0.0262677576,
0.0315186679,
0.0467149578,
0.0063636671,
-0.0332743898,
0.027488973,
-0.0110964645,
0.0257295929,
0.0389049314,
0.0122725982,
-0.0507445857,
0.0285394974,
0.0416736118,
-0.0843640938,
0.0474152416,
-0.0020341855,
0.0323923044,
0.0336438082,
0.0492729284,
-0.0401761942,
0.0008248048,
-0.0575605519,
-0.0216415096,
-0.0065962011,
0.0300057642,
0.0198625941,
0.0184351299,
-0.036824163,
0.0194877274,
0.0197991468,
-0.0766653046,
0.0012358231,
0.0570714697,
0.0129923839,
0.0408281609,
0.0216958374,
0.002086458,
0.0118070403,
-0.0453751869,
-0.0357522666,
0.0027820922,
0.0516402461,
0.0183380395,
-0.0333216526,
0.0079446044,
-0.0453045703,
-0.022093866,
0.0408787504,
-0.0483068191,
-0.0157714188,
-0.0244377106,
0.0262458809,
-0.0091661485,
-0.0291378126,
0.0681357682,
0.0183975976,
-0.0498061888,
0.0079271561,
0.0036425868,
-0.0071960008,
0.0318791196,
0.0010314148,
0.0236119721,
-0.0712663382,
-0.0254304633,
-0.0135545842,
0.0043837661,
0.0190199055,
-0.0143989623,
0.0387276597,
-0.0182558019,
-0.0647638217,
0.0261649713,
-0.0302662291,
0.0285057686,
-0.0090596229,
0.0792909265,
-0.0158278886,
-0.0074877744,
-0.0069864229,
0.0365750529,
0.0549062081,
0.0342064574,
-0.0481778905,
0.0105591966,
0.0084621925,
-0.0388130546,
-0.0361725539,
0.0003083317,
-0.0205577966,
0.0064976094,
0.008003965,
-0.0135506568,
-0.0143382009,
0.0124674542,
2.952e-7,
0.0384368263,
0.0291496813,
0.0475529507,
-0.0242394228,
-0.0212539732,
0.034808103,
0.0082144476,
0.0198878627,
-0.0411466546,
-0.0083015952,
-0.0336030759,
-0.0224569049,
0.0390854776,
0.0517527349,
-0.1458099782,
0.0085415281,
0.020513108,
-0.0409430526,
-0.072142005,
0.0159814507,
-0.0121635702,
0.0822596028,
0.0034725557,
-0.0035463769,
-0.0191257466,
-0.0436700359,
0.0272999983,
0.0070687449,
0.001471333,
0.050809253,
0.0570024997,
0.059470892,
-0.0030004634,
-0.034386199,
-0.0345361009,
0.011106886,
0.0062866574,
0.063776806,
-0.0297876578,
0.0072970558,
0.0132312346,
-0.057627514,
0.0031519884,
-0.0702392459,
0.0563185625,
0.0271739904,
-0.008989756,
-0.019457791,
0.0104642846,
0.0060342196,
-0.0338845477,
-0.0051134299,
-0.0570061952,
0.0263415929,
0.0360446982,
-0.0632400811,
-0.0554437414,
-0.0252158884,
-0.0099752918,
0.0189267043,
0.0062706461,
0.0087516895,
-0.0058823302,
-0.005412397,
-0.0114969313,
-0.0557780787,
-0.0139428591,
2.682897797e-34,
0.0107080936,
0.0283973664,
0.0067053023,
0.0662405267,
0.0415421501,
-0.0238864552,
-0.049673751,
0.0134889651,
-0.0187301151,
-0.0385843143,
0.0119873341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07167v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07167v1 | STEER: Unified Style Transfer with Expert Reinforcement | 2023-11-13T09:02:30 | 2023-11-13T09:02:30 | Skyler Hallinan, Faeze Brahman, Ximing Lu, Jaehun Jung, Sean Welleck, Yejin Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While text style transfer has many applications across natural language
processing, the core premise of transferring from a single source style is
unrealistic in a real-world setting. In this work, we focus on arbitrary style
transfer: rewriting a text from an arbitrary, unknown style to a target style.
We propose STEER: Unified Style Transfer with Expert Reinforcement, a unified
frame-work developed to overcome the challenge of limited parallel data for
style transfer. STEER involves automatically generating a corpus of
style-transfer pairs using a product of experts during decoding. The generated
offline data is then used to pre-train an initial policy before switching to
online, off-policy reinforcement learning for further improvements via
fine-grained reward signals. STEER is unified and can transfer to multiple
target styles from an arbitrary, unknown source style, making it particularly
flexible and efficient.
Experimental results on a challenging dataset with text from a diverse set of
styles demonstrate state-of-the-art results compared to competitive baselines.
Remarkably, STEER outperforms the 175B parameter instruction-tuned GPT-3 on
overall style transfer quality, despite being 226 times smaller in size. We
also show STEER is robust, maintaining its style transfer capabilities on
out-of-domain data, and surpassing nearly all baselines across various styles.
The success of our method highlights the potential of RL algorithms when
augmented with controllable decoding to overcome the challenge of limited data
supervision. | [
0.0353181697,
0.1038958952,
0.0083977403,
-0.0023172738,
-0.0223738682,
0.0020715764,
-0.0203864742,
0.0092006214,
-0.0616553649,
-0.0033828942,
-0.0460401773,
-0.020621622,
-0.0019146038,
0.0176679194,
0.0067443154,
-0.065491192,
-0.0055861692,
-0.0392713435,
0.0576247759,
0.0053841495,
0.0535988174,
0.0408264622,
-0.0111964932,
0.0113321627,
-0.0116863949,
0.0128306774,
-0.0061074477,
0.0513022058,
0.0352242962,
0.0049380031,
0.045563668,
0.0449989624,
0.0355799012,
0.0047861994,
0.0000018845,
-0.017783951,
-0.0471593067,
-0.0111883087,
0.0750667453,
-0.0014216871,
0.0630941242,
-0.0369635038,
-0.0370627791,
-0.0060177376,
-0.0242156256,
-0.0141143976,
0.0720449984,
0.0761405379,
0.082698606,
0.1140625104,
-0.022637574,
-0.0643098205,
0.0127456179,
-0.0268497691,
0.0199078489,
-0.0133570116,
0.015351628,
-0.0161803793,
-0.0250745192,
-0.0109107411,
-0.0347286388,
0.0363901369,
-0.0072379964,
-0.0115928389,
-0.0108139645,
-0.0228893161,
-0.0361488573,
0.0202428792,
-0.0239857752,
0.0843528062,
-0.0208710078,
-0.0027708078,
0.0097764432,
-0.0106808562,
0.0061651487,
-0.0020361838,
-0.0222655721,
0.0262308419,
-0.0020160223,
0.0459518209,
-0.0197127815,
0.0102092661,
0.0026507864,
-0.0378666297,
-0.0292487238,
0.0033662273,
0.0007528834,
-0.0427699164,
0.0308382548,
0.0321158282,
0.0017240724,
-0.0006022392,
0.0341089554,
-0.0148660457,
-0.0390199423,
0.0200420227,
-0.0771351457,
-0.0397685021,
-0.0408152603,
0.0274221878,
0.0791203901,
0.0261961669,
0.019942373,
0.0139054004,
-0.0306267478,
0.0136308465,
-0.0347928554,
0.027971128,
-0.0362403318,
-0.0051427088,
-0.095063813,
0.0063611302,
-0.0789191276,
-0.0124631356,
-0.0087142056,
-0.0306595564,
-0.0044231396,
-0.0179822259,
-0.0189341363,
-0.0033561173,
0.0321641602,
0.0074715321,
-0.0650923103,
-0.0304343812,
0.0080244178,
0.0524434336,
-0.0030428476,
-0.0049886391,
0.0168956015,
-0.0242220033,
-0.0312240887,
0.0096292812,
0.0503395163,
-0.0249404702,
-0.001863932,
0.0583310686,
-0.0969985947,
0.0145816319,
-0.0351767354,
-0.0102117732,
0.0018968623,
-0.0100424848,
0.0121117644,
-0.0679477602,
-0.0026795843,
-0.0419866703,
0.0188867673,
-0.0482742339,
0.0016703658,
-0.0088322982,
-0.0456341282,
0.0594223067,
0.0010585204,
-0.010268122,
-0.0033467331,
-0.0155582596,
0.0052298536,
0.0604507551,
0.0274566077,
0.0473252162,
0.0069914171,
-0.0084712747,
-0.0032485772,
0.0471850336,
0.0402007364,
0.0624685101,
-0.0380895995,
-0.0574511588,
0.0241725612,
0.0507363118,
0.0900086761,
0.0209270976,
-0.0297720078,
0.021175174,
0.0811521336,
-0.0425491482,
0.0604888238,
0.0279202815,
0.0340604708,
0.0507052839,
-0.0090477969,
0.0036590358,
-0.0149141429,
0.0094422242,
0.0241469666,
0.032673575,
0.0110893762,
0.0216978788,
-0.0143061439,
0.0043252204,
0.0652059168,
0.0061015817,
-0.003860574,
-0.0323318318,
0.0142115448,
0.0844153985,
-0.0875142366,
-0.036989335,
0.0159468316,
-0.0204243325,
-0.0024799698,
-0.0145733031,
-0.0008455524,
0.1133463308,
0.0394120589,
0.0139107816,
-0.0043158666,
-0.0091591664,
0.0081115654,
0.0350697301,
0.0097580254,
-0.0022768392,
0.0488715358,
-0.0546325259,
-0.0282205846,
0.0010238121,
-0.0011774395,
0.0522575825,
-0.0011433657,
0.0462541059,
-0.0310426075,
0.0238497853,
-0.0237065703,
0.032709863,
0.019722702,
-0.053172756,
0.0511620194,
-0.0198328756,
-0.0085883178,
-0.0258668941,
-0.0742600486,
-0.0119916983,
-0.0455444418,
-0.0560330153,
-0.0154225873,
-0.0019819257,
-0.0859640539,
-0.044745557,
-0.0483501256,
-0.0821784064,
-0.0013295026,
0.0281746183,
-0.0511434302,
-0.0461628996,
-0.0332229361,
-0.03779063,
0.0336342901,
0.0012742823,
-0.0258608088,
0.0215952415,
0.0122364331,
-0.0421510637,
0.0000238875,
0.0187254231,
-0.034090694,
0.006320518,
-0.003789084,
-0.026844129,
-0.021287661,
0.0291977879,
0.0020967906,
-0.0046055792,
0.016153207,
-0.0001324567,
0.0787106827,
-0.031497024,
-0.0508800521,
-0.0019813797,
-0.0113936886,
-0.0327719338,
0.0113262571,
0.0357698202,
0.0003750829,
-0.0484111793,
-0.0286784396,
-0.0461302809,
0.0082799271,
-0.0363315605,
0.0007684589,
0.0438216552,
-0.0130224563,
-0.009939353,
-0.0281480085,
-0.0303038415,
0.0388026945,
-0.002525426,
-0.0057834946,
0.0086696623,
-0.061914593,
-0.0287187006,
-0.0021777553,
0.0014753047,
0.0292224512,
-0.0428405888,
-0.0104514603,
-0.0674118325,
0.0502741933,
0.0627398416,
0.0291300211,
-0.0042688577,
0.0149670215,
-0.035182789,
-0.0350189693,
0.0173793975,
-0.0078067598,
-0.0309908818,
-0.0487133116,
-0.0134693747,
0.0564376973,
0.0364013053,
0.0286838505,
0.0099778529,
-0.06340608,
-0.0093147783,
0.0300930589,
-0.0580425747,
0.0217647906,
0.0392523631,
-0.0155431442,
0.0043220003,
-0.0079113664,
-0.0398269929,
0.0596722625,
0.0025464362,
-0.0281611364,
-0.0123706693,
-0.0267201513,
-0.0111665977,
0.0117100067,
-0.0140610607,
0.028683804,
-0.0197558273,
-0.0529044494,
-0.0216253083,
-0.0136541966,
0.0828597397,
0.0069751567,
0.0038778316,
-0.0467042178,
0.0135128302,
-0.0167743657,
-0.0264381655,
-0.0220136791,
-0.0282932781,
0.0050076526,
-0.0301198214,
0.0667392984,
-0.0748590752,
-0.0058717853,
-0.0192682389,
-0.0056558605,
0.0730081424,
-0.0252811573,
-0.0344484933,
-0.0215163529,
0.0366594046,
0.0207199845,
0.0178658981,
-0.0397007689,
-0.0239557587,
-0.0247993097,
0.0355682299,
0.0270194188,
-0.0028451979,
-0.0448561907,
0.0348507911,
0.0393396914,
-0.0333256237,
-0.0020205923,
0.033114329,
0.0729908645,
-0.0681945458,
-0.0304976851,
0.0824847817,
0.0266634747,
-0.0545108542,
-0.0366283357,
0.0201058872,
0.0681269243,
-0.016631918,
0.0500895567,
-0.0766546652,
-0.0524107553,
0.0022672387,
0.042011112,
0.0158010405,
-0.01206649,
-0.0197613277,
-0.0722677335,
0.0337721743,
0.0304074846,
-0.0628878251,
-0.0226937383,
-0.0124741849,
-0.0082902806,
-0.001760071,
-0.0169722717,
0.0012078417,
-0.0152432686,
-0.0050683781,
0.0059594489,
0.0128679192,
-0.03524708,
-0.0113648707,
-0.0018262982,
0.0519349389,
0.1004157662,
0.0288973618,
-0.0007332156,
-0.0448518507,
-0.0235289782,
-0.0199198667,
0.0190191492,
-0.0298263002,
0.0406713486,
0.0002374367,
-0.0130062867,
-0.0258088447,
0.0357812718,
-0.0040271706,
0.0308210421,
0.0291032586,
0.0060318494,
0.0047473619,
-0.0703205019,
-0.0134578114,
-0.0285242666,
0.0593610033,
0.0317568928,
0.0069764173,
-0.0539894216,
-0.0666739717,
-0.0560380481,
-0.0076112594,
-0.0976617411,
-0.0377020389,
-0.0167824235,
-0.0411853381,
-0.0023318392,
-0.1036322191,
0.0000465497,
-0.012227674,
0.0703466758,
-0.0011933916,
-0.0467516519,
0.0080014942,
0.0067918045,
-0.0461612269,
-0.0455517359,
-0.0323482566,
0.0208837464,
-0.0148032159,
-0.0339515321,
0.0015000772,
-0.0281769242,
0.0081866169,
0.0203152727,
-0.0213306211,
-0.0268063061,
0.0240388755,
0.0597326122,
0.006156337,
0.0463582985,
-0.0117979608,
-0.0617838241,
0.0792943165,
0.0651483238,
-0.0056161634,
0.0040598121,
0.0740270391,
0.0135499528,
0.0166992471,
0.0327991135,
-0.005610771,
0.05047087,
0.0098590637,
0.0339486301,
0.0263695437,
0.0323856659,
0.0443657152,
-0.0106630521,
-0.010784083,
0.0090991026,
0.0148512432,
-0.0018394738,
0.0152004967,
0.0087094493,
-0.0060703196,
-0.0585150793,
0.0006548083,
0.0625017136,
0.0116012795,
-0.0021075227,
0.0319054425,
0.0621969849,
0.0040567894,
-0.0437588543,
-0.0166018996,
0.0321268551,
0.0693271086,
-0.0113627398,
0.0279279333,
0.0017045073,
0.0626967326,
0.0195800643,
0.0524448454,
-0.0129141305,
0.0353175327,
0.0666791424,
0.0075303158,
-0.0164329335,
0.0025888216,
-0.0531464107,
-0.0083566513,
-0.0278230533,
-0.0140112797,
0.0377513021,
0.0020455779,
0.0939046517,
-0.0149330059,
0.0041560354,
0.0055464171,
0.0299873538,
-0.0335945487,
0.005885371,
-0.0130205946,
0.0019519642,
0.0274623949,
-0.0207774956,
0.0664749965,
0.0122923115,
0.0015225552,
-0.0039433669,
0.0247720703,
-0.0180184226,
-0.0181068201,
0.0221890602,
0.0107426895,
0.0434599519,
-0.031716112,
0.0321060382,
-0.0263586231,
-0.0096631041,
-0.0343241021,
0.0107800439,
0.0009043663,
0.0382839628,
0.0172211714,
-0.0284082778,
-0.0122487405,
-0.0216454323,
-0.0115755619,
0.03244441,
-0.0103647122,
-0.0245692246,
-6.065566646e-33,
-0.0113240583,
-0.0128202373,
0.0039762375,
-0.0224102624,
-0.0416975692,
-0.0292441137,
-0.0301917531,
-0.0399714261,
0.0237907078,
0.0513023473,
-0.0357614905,
-0.008870542,
0.0255306549,
0.056850154,
0.0235456917,
0.0254155099,
0.0566078462,
-0.0017381673,
-0.0541367121,
0.0469077714,
0.0404978506,
0.0411971658,
0.0855836049,
-0.077042602,
-0.000903663,
0.0157448743,
-0.0515765063,
-0.0031469786,
0.0366917104,
-0.0102320891,
0.0262213442,
0.0148994382,
-0.0092665022,
-0.0835345834,
-0.0429163687,
0.0081686908,
-0.0983844995,
-0.0595272407,
-0.0081917457,
0.0027062346,
-0.0388532989,
-0.0006393674,
0.0410040095,
-0.0001041485,
0.0391068719,
-0.0242324807,
0.0377883501,
-0.0299305711,
-0.0035870194,
-0.0633057654,
-0.0555612519,
0.0118735591,
-0.0125443507,
-0.0009395971,
0.0429477654,
0.0010316484,
-0.0124576036,
-0.0262143109,
-0.0315675624,
0.0169211999,
-0.017180318,
0.0192523673,
0.0172818359,
0.0294238999,
-0.0173318759,
0.0183196347,
-0.028408071,
0.0328504518,
-0.0332260504,
-0.0110789472,
0.0403523594,
0.0609973744,
-0.0280455705,
0.0600455329,
0.0417554751,
-0.0095554302,
0.0203963947,
0.0210416503,
0.0342558213,
0.0134766204,
-0.0007830378,
0.0638353378,
-0.0267830845,
-0.0070481147,
-0.0468620211,
-0.0186057016,
-0.0057639107,
-0.0267107375,
0.0251246374,
0.0284993108,
-0.011685824,
0.0136915892,
0.0203433055,
0.0035740985,
-0.0398906991,
-0.0241442546,
-0.0613430478,
0.0383720472,
-0.0379257612,
-0.0439630039,
-0.0386879779,
-0.0250770152,
0.0666067749,
-0.0054932339,
-0.0091737611,
-0.0203070007,
0.047982242,
0.0496957377,
-0.0969696194,
-0.0149323922,
-0.0048461687,
0.042973347,
0.0049479161,
-0.0140034026,
0.0242659058,
-0.0112889493,
-0.0360006541,
0.0423347093,
0.0151499622,
0.0032244236,
-0.0039726067,
-0.0161950942,
-0.0005281027,
0.0144076534,
-0.0533016138,
0.0134653775,
-0.0293669775,
-0.0605759397,
-0.0014590669,
-0.0760555714,
-0.0216140021,
0.0010430405,
2.599e-7,
0.0036279978,
0.0562578663,
0.0587237068,
0.0274683256,
0.0199706126,
0.0216280036,
0.0010231456,
0.0653100163,
-0.0078633334,
0.0127077028,
0.0322624892,
0.0312385373,
0.0489839837,
0.0032331834,
-0.0643549338,
-0.0261300094,
-0.0281416867,
0.0245682299,
-0.0527440645,
-0.0462600179,
0.0358402021,
0.0395318717,
0.0298867114,
-0.0341530629,
0.0756282136,
0.0292589162,
0.0430622697,
-0.0037269036,
0.0428905115,
-0.0002490607,
0.0248974133,
-0.0204353984,
-0.0532786585,
0.0142144356,
-0.0047369525,
-0.0217606444,
-0.0034413687,
0.084241733,
0.0248580407,
0.0150408577,
-0.0042381566,
0.0327150226,
0.0218281522,
0.0144570181,
0.0341619477,
-0.0257670265,
-0.0068910974,
-0.0144638168,
-0.0564281531,
-0.0241180323,
-0.0049220934,
-0.0180137772,
-0.0050061019,
0.0374210142,
0.0266007278,
0.0666055307,
-0.0278619286,
-0.0710580721,
-0.0033404997,
-0.0054801758,
0.0067709764,
-0.0050552012,
-0.0499176718,
0.0514364578,
0.0026491771,
-0.0606879443,
0.0125170825,
2.289100302e-34,
0.014139655,
-0.0412903167,
0.0330080576,
0.0078922231,
0.0091164839,
0.0413055196,
0.0023631151,
0.0264634974,
0.025887806,
-0.0597346574,
-0.0185603518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07161v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07161v1 | Developing a Named Entity Recognition Dataset for Tagalog | 2023-11-13T08:56:47 | 2023-11-13T08:56:47 | Lester James V. Miranda | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present the development of a Named Entity Recognition (NER) dataset for
Tagalog. This corpus helps fill the resource gap present in Philippine
languages today, where NER resources are scarce. The texts were obtained from a
pretraining corpora containing news reports, and were labeled by native
speakers in an iterative fashion. The resulting dataset contains ~7.8k
documents across three entity types: Person, Organization, and Location. The
inter-annotator agreement, as measured by Cohen's $\kappa$, is 0.81. We also
conducted extensive empirical evaluation of state-of-the-art methods across
supervised and transfer learning settings. Finally, we released the data and
processing code publicly to inspire future work on Tagalog NLP. | [
0.0310824458,
0.0311850756,
0.0260883644,
0.024731392,
0.0198707189,
0.0491538756,
-0.0129470285,
0.0128478575,
0.0356860571,
-0.017034458,
-0.0475999229,
0.0071587558,
0.0075940713,
-0.0102434652,
0.0005172691,
-0.0513457097,
0.0138035696,
0.0218077302,
0.0457573645,
0.0339832045,
0.0123190759,
0.0142448293,
-0.0150805889,
0.0128792785,
-0.0083066253,
-0.0042303228,
-0.0138537604,
0.0318977572,
0.0511451475,
-0.0871986672,
0.0127624627,
0.0417307876,
-0.0590356812,
0.0247732103,
0.000001772,
-0.0368586741,
-0.0507695526,
0.0171287544,
-0.0465089753,
-0.0147472229,
0.009333333,
-0.0352859236,
-0.0107371444,
-0.0059073088,
-0.0447087623,
-0.069064118,
0.0544890165,
0.0963523835,
0.0242266376,
0.105748862,
-0.0172812957,
-0.0404028669,
0.0171706751,
-0.0440364294,
-0.0058467011,
-0.0335180424,
0.029556917,
0.0067050057,
-0.0166884828,
0.028352851,
0.0230469164,
0.0054975199,
-0.0305078775,
0.0046096169,
0.0195829049,
0.0008296804,
-0.0483898222,
-0.0062919073,
0.0108386911,
0.057905186,
0.0085887481,
-0.0264283773,
0.0256952923,
-0.0060060299,
-0.0166987721,
-0.0213628262,
-0.0275470987,
-0.0131663783,
-0.0447491333,
0.0312997848,
0.0365161747,
0.0112281684,
0.0298570413,
-0.0141563062,
0.0110736266,
0.0034605747,
0.0065300232,
-0.0294048097,
0.0420448743,
0.0693831146,
-0.0290690977,
-0.0392009169,
0.0131173609,
-0.0111792749,
0.046986796,
0.0235833861,
-0.019824842,
-0.0034316783,
-0.0031578047,
-0.049186185,
-0.0244026277,
0.0144923879,
-0.0016350574,
0.0421757139,
-0.0432697013,
0.0058534555,
-0.0015868861,
0.0185019653,
0.0380303189,
-0.0327864699,
-0.0846530125,
0.0187557526,
-0.0259162504,
0.0464754999,
-0.0393102616,
0.032458812,
-0.0378289931,
0.0065135038,
-0.0113546327,
0.0126072057,
0.0102090584,
-0.0383095518,
-0.0037192078,
0.0017723523,
-0.0093192039,
0.0442968942,
-0.0252839997,
0.0336308405,
-0.0120608453,
-0.0661555976,
0.0064511881,
-0.0345883034,
0.0096126357,
-0.0490233898,
0.0390668213,
0.0211075731,
-0.0017705642,
-0.0829954296,
-0.0918612629,
0.0178874917,
-0.0101770805,
-0.0584947243,
-0.0009564267,
-0.0346656032,
0.0794995502,
0.0029690678,
0.0354478136,
-0.0456631929,
0.0133576039,
0.0050637424,
-0.0168599151,
0.0900063813,
-0.0415092483,
-0.00916092,
0.0264885873,
0.0071699405,
0.048942592,
0.0495630018,
0.0387567319,
-0.0063437214,
0.0429361612,
0.0114155887,
-0.0433100723,
0.0013872758,
0.0141983004,
0.0292508602,
0.0619460903,
0.0018209616,
-0.0008967463,
-0.0043903063,
0.0152890692,
0.0151936449,
-0.0000943916,
0.0166042056,
0.0179741848,
0.0387043506,
-0.0147253517,
0.006890411,
0.0057025948,
-0.0186368246,
0.0153648527,
-0.0129607627,
-0.0240329094,
0.0122752525,
-0.047496438,
0.0081773978,
0.013221344,
0.0346203297,
-0.0464993678,
-0.0046805753,
0.0026771929,
0.0022163363,
-0.0150611894,
0.0064256256,
0.0434240066,
0.0301190093,
-0.0336192884,
0.0018960376,
0.0388164409,
-0.0354188234,
0.0017537234,
0.0052869292,
0.0244568326,
0.0215789545,
0.0374712236,
-0.0111701963,
-0.0190151427,
-0.033086963,
-0.0275850464,
0.0425228886,
-0.0010928857,
-0.0201457888,
0.0323295817,
-0.0306381937,
0.0215621945,
0.0633950382,
-0.0015009124,
0.0451265424,
0.0417498834,
0.0698169544,
-0.0000945532,
-0.0239645205,
-0.047731597,
0.0581378341,
-0.0339937434,
-0.0300992988,
0.0244764257,
0.0022217149,
0.036152672,
0.0628746897,
-0.0004144669,
-0.050830368,
0.0134900687,
-0.0122060953,
-0.0141459536,
0.0077591771,
0.0028891279,
-0.0507581197,
-0.0170280915,
-0.0516393594,
-0.0252430364,
-0.0318272114,
-0.0447831862,
-0.0598626547,
-0.034028437,
0.0644772425,
0.0099592879,
-0.0595411658,
0.0361176059,
0.0113274585,
0.0386382714,
-0.0302837472,
0.0272799749,
0.0117141763,
0.0165551156,
0.0087715238,
0.0057694605,
0.0412948988,
-0.0210194103,
-0.0460402481,
0.0222169645,
-0.0035229579,
-0.0229487624,
-0.0043634865,
0.034516491,
-0.0451867282,
-0.0234333165,
-0.1207607239,
0.0357799567,
-0.0019643439,
0.0521437526,
0.0315876715,
0.0293968413,
-0.0426161997,
-0.0141028389,
0.0231837817,
-0.027389152,
-0.0252343621,
0.0020436454,
0.040916279,
0.0065340274,
0.0234132763,
-0.0219190195,
0.0084585138,
-0.0038240782,
0.0141311521,
0.0452251174,
-0.1119334623,
-0.0627469718,
0.0081195822,
-0.0182766467,
-0.0072465749,
0.0247582328,
0.0070584873,
0.0017868256,
0.02345296,
-0.0272236615,
0.0485464334,
-0.026662821,
0.0316531546,
-0.0207942706,
0.0037856933,
-0.0171705391,
0.0227305461,
0.0021025119,
0.0201717,
0.0041850121,
-0.0374835841,
0.0099119637,
0.0935179964,
-0.0198053066,
0.0254273564,
-0.0357224569,
-0.0490137376,
-0.0266980492,
-0.024227174,
0.0232009254,
0.0353713818,
0.0047994452,
0.01984079,
-0.0098727774,
0.01206565,
0.0655715093,
-0.0386953205,
-0.0099570556,
-0.0330970138,
0.0290533397,
-0.0310600605,
0.0585986115,
-0.0166303292,
0.0005583955,
0.0394954123,
-0.0609539486,
0.0134230061,
0.0553830937,
0.0035105457,
-0.0104097389,
0.0327396467,
-0.0372069553,
0.0456657745,
-0.0289945565,
-0.0258341506,
-0.0037412008,
0.0079076756,
-0.0376873054,
0.0081922337,
-0.0047669979,
-0.0038195259,
-0.0017495692,
0.0569415949,
-0.0131682297,
-0.0051004468,
0.0132756848,
-0.0254994556,
-0.0020852336,
0.0499059558,
0.0101816999,
0.0052806209,
-0.0025752273,
0.0081519783,
-0.0423481055,
0.0316196568,
-0.002994769,
0.0301810279,
0.0141259022,
-0.0256640334,
-0.0011414188,
-0.0612296201,
-0.0143866809,
-0.0622673631,
0.0443432182,
-0.0096713547,
-0.0115577802,
0.0952676758,
0.0256657861,
-0.0469282717,
-0.0360947549,
0.0068317098,
0.0204095095,
-0.0004944414,
0.0317635499,
-0.0934539735,
-0.0347146988,
0.0033842134,
-0.0318242945,
-0.0121314162,
-0.0855967328,
-0.0152541623,
-0.1372490972,
0.0119507201,
-0.0116243875,
-0.0189145226,
-0.0133194346,
-0.0705718026,
-0.0022492986,
-0.045574218,
-0.0043072458,
-0.0410834365,
-0.0326128565,
0.0108145531,
0.0408458598,
-0.0091535887,
-0.03325307,
0.0309751406,
-0.0417468175,
0.0398828499,
0.0661165044,
0.0397050194,
-0.0197394509,
0.028996788,
-0.0076583917,
-0.0079122437,
-0.0372805148,
-0.0112729231,
0.0611817427,
-0.0547982492,
-0.0209408551,
-0.0179281794,
0.0229216684,
-0.0348694623,
0.0201626867,
0.0234043356,
0.0296221338,
0.0064003612,
0.0036780357,
0.0264596771,
-0.0236375295,
0.0294737164,
0.0766169131,
-0.000164456,
-0.0536197275,
-0.0254047439,
0.0030980825,
0.0009083359,
-0.0112635782,
0.0145156141,
0.0658331662,
-0.0748379976,
-0.0294695254,
-0.0625531971,
-0.0814796388,
0.0658284873,
0.0381545834,
0.0254353788,
-0.0117972549,
0.0239365511,
-0.0104728313,
-0.0346729122,
0.0127659906,
-0.0526873879,
-0.0101850266,
-0.0565743595,
-0.0139148738,
-0.012183236,
0.0524852015,
-0.0119938208,
0.0068695238,
-0.0734924451,
-0.0465326458,
0.0097339395,
-0.0229233745,
0.0166280735,
0.0303539,
-0.0273007192,
0.0059874263,
-0.0323527865,
0.0425285101,
-0.0428719372,
-0.0161965713,
0.0144207543,
0.0369936004,
0.0017723957,
0.0240196921,
-0.0124626374,
0.0123738199,
0.0275060087,
0.015434674,
-0.0347141549,
-0.0137531012,
-0.0127146626,
0.0306826998,
0.0713585764,
-0.0418486409,
-0.0140987597,
-0.0961329341,
0.0122238146,
0.0131034506,
0.0284295082,
-0.0154911391,
-0.0330013968,
0.0674596131,
-0.0058927522,
-0.0226326603,
0.0593057349,
-0.0216201674,
0.0145212561,
-0.0312247016,
0.0027264783,
0.0271010492,
0.0559092462,
-0.0159607865,
-0.0183069892,
-0.0113590173,
0.0247447342,
0.0551054329,
0.0421607718,
-0.0321523771,
0.0307010692,
0.0095270956,
0.0460954122,
0.0363427959,
0.0173378866,
0.0054905433,
0.0252322908,
-0.0432880409,
0.0316198096,
0.0605101399,
-0.0216844473,
0.0728861764,
-0.0269417483,
0.0098793013,
-0.03291969,
0.0308889858,
-0.0375440083,
0.0073420103,
0.0152556924,
-0.0196361635,
-0.0262094866,
0.0516831614,
0.0611039847,
0.0145815564,
0.0227159988,
0.0427472554,
0.0220687743,
-0.0224547964,
-0.0082613481,
-0.0075470181,
-0.0082119694,
-0.0161830392,
-0.0142905079,
-0.0336346291,
-0.0428476706,
-0.0046682376,
-0.0575705059,
-0.0174942613,
0.0421002135,
-0.015416679,
0.0080732824,
-0.0090597728,
0.0159637611,
-0.0582196601,
-0.0325082876,
-0.0021129097,
-0.0038012215,
-0.0016229302,
-6.070716781e-33,
-0.0725861639,
0.0070908377,
0.0085047008,
-0.0218852405,
-0.003373096,
-0.0028431304,
-0.0275659505,
-0.0031596746,
-0.0226213038,
-0.0198793896,
-0.0573434234,
0.0232333224,
0.0509366505,
0.03151628,
0.0141208842,
-0.0162825752,
0.0420935452,
0.0613773838,
0.0028817463,
0.0086487429,
0.0515936725,
0.0486720353,
0.1106479913,
-0.0871451721,
0.0798804909,
0.0259932987,
-0.031920772,
-0.064008899,
0.08659067,
0.0287141446,
-0.0282176901,
-0.021815611,
0.0338653624,
-0.0338564888,
0.0107183736,
0.0220286902,
-0.155401662,
-0.0209208969,
-0.0256089009,
0.0721626058,
-0.0024802522,
-0.0149620902,
-0.0088930679,
-0.0163684208,
0.0476046614,
-0.0062149409,
0.0189182274,
-0.0199726038,
-0.0082351295,
-0.0099567641,
-0.0515423194,
0.0564591102,
0.0136534786,
0.0561398752,
0.040884383,
0.000420465,
-0.0113852601,
-0.0098556355,
-0.09963952,
-0.0267539844,
0.0093780039,
-0.0148452381,
-0.0000672222,
0.0215343218,
-0.0140752932,
0.0255703703,
0.041817639,
-0.0060131224,
0.0117258793,
0.0247498043,
0.0374949723,
0.0171573777,
-0.045674786,
0.0359788723,
0.0192727,
-0.0482086353,
-0.0636327863,
0.0368621014,
0.0272387043,
-0.0269379243,
-0.0233130921,
-0.0222393759,
-0.0545785539,
0.0005676622,
0.0098400079,
-0.0610498115,
-0.0193258431,
-0.0395969078,
0.0323700644,
-0.0103235738,
-0.0277846958,
0.066862762,
0.0253355354,
-0.0561694019,
-0.045281712,
-0.0066610277,
0.0070140907,
0.0274231024,
-0.0177934114,
0.0013255666,
-0.1025307477,
-0.0449407734,
-0.0145841343,
0.0147616202,
0.0047677271,
-0.0194850229,
0.0903516561,
-0.0383057259,
-0.0833637938,
0.0034854943,
-0.0137851741,
0.0290196203,
-0.0195943806,
0.0546616316,
-0.0176370554,
-0.005275175,
0.0094110472,
0.0169011578,
0.0625288263,
0.0163364038,
0.0004451677,
0.0057620816,
0.0128485868,
-0.0211492684,
-0.0001459581,
-0.0030786034,
0.0054262578,
-0.0077504483,
-0.0018512399,
-0.0264200382,
0.0085207094,
0.0036009941,
2.424e-7,
0.0323721692,
0.0029897168,
0.0651903674,
-0.0273544993,
-0.0338693708,
0.0165993348,
0.0191748906,
0.0627464131,
-0.0423240922,
0.0004230274,
0.0352529511,
-0.0286036525,
0.0529667549,
0.0359433629,
-0.1372021437,
-0.017419219,
-0.0004527681,
-0.0163570661,
-0.0452403165,
0.0016557388,
-0.0127377464,
0.0644169748,
0.0158059206,
-0.0004667433,
-0.0189877227,
-0.0235396661,
0.0737315938,
0.022561878,
0.0087760892,
0.0617123172,
0.0600667559,
0.077776812,
-0.0267261267,
0.0107821925,
-0.0239344146,
-0.0011150328,
0.007597045,
0.0737524405,
-0.0213592816,
-0.0168680828,
-0.0030705419,
-0.0525291972,
-0.0015879463,
-0.0350733846,
0.0787328035,
-0.0126670366,
-0.0326716676,
0.0260109901,
-0.0335105099,
-0.0065560248,
0.0037111733,
0.0268861186,
-0.0334938988,
0.0582519211,
0.0428779833,
-0.0385159962,
-0.0674501657,
-0.0322135277,
0.04244918,
0.0356809907,
0.0323654935,
-0.0016160742,
0.0130216246,
0.0067786947,
0.0033093931,
-0.0403661765,
-0.0028875002,
1.609322594e-34,
-0.0121806748,
0.0172765534,
-0.0117034661,
0.0345185734,
0.0131538529,
-0.0281031989,
-0.0469098091,
-0.0067029549,
-0.0297421999,
-0.0373507366,
0.0507214256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07150v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07150v1 | Interaction is all You Need? A Study of Robots Ability to Understand and Execute | 2023-11-13T08:39:06 | 2023-11-13T08:39:06 | Kushal Koshti, Nidhir Bhavsar | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | This paper aims to address a critical challenge in robotics, which is
enabling them to operate seamlessly in human environments through natural
language interactions. Our primary focus is to equip robots with the ability to
understand and execute complex instructions in coherent dialogs to facilitate
intricate task-solving scenarios. To explore this, we build upon the Execution
from Dialog History (EDH) task from the Teach benchmark. We employ a
multi-transformer model with BART LM. We observe that our best configuration
outperforms the baseline with a success rate score of 8.85 and a
goal-conditioned success rate score of 14.02. In addition, we suggest an
alternative methodology for completing this task. Moreover, we introduce a new
task by expanding the EDH task and making predictions about game plans instead
of individual actions. We have evaluated multiple BART models and an LLaMA2
LLM, which has achieved a ROGUE-L score of 46.77 for this task. | [
0.026396798,
0.0277013462,
-0.0196384098,
0.0049119312,
-0.0254541766,
-0.0017601702,
0.0180290099,
-0.0283050034,
0.0308791567,
-0.0436390005,
-0.0465993397,
-0.0092208246,
-0.0063300352,
0.0495387726,
-0.0131684132,
-0.0725461394,
0.0591357276,
-0.0533460826,
-0.034550909,
0.0112668294,
-0.0303532835,
-0.0232414603,
-0.0529644005,
0.0636783391,
0.0044712303,
0.014521217,
-0.085379608,
-0.0194211826,
0.019143533,
-0.0297680702,
-0.0135881389,
0.0391757227,
0.0548533089,
0.0135526201,
0.0000019669,
-0.0511188507,
-0.0066673299,
-0.0258782078,
-0.0446744598,
-0.0554250069,
-0.022575004,
0.0218183734,
0.0163596384,
0.0235921256,
-0.0526650958,
0.0118838632,
0.0048125261,
0.0704915971,
0.0705857575,
0.0598732755,
0.0209477171,
-0.0151756024,
0.0131794997,
0.0072900173,
0.0268764831,
-0.0930180848,
0.0060439808,
0.0565938875,
0.0516941622,
-0.0080860304,
-0.0341912135,
-0.0013634737,
0.0440263972,
-0.0462927446,
-0.034654744,
0.0291623622,
0.0441363379,
-0.0319935717,
-0.0160934553,
0.0390550122,
0.0287142564,
0.0338183977,
0.0001046892,
0.0202104636,
0.0300338715,
0.0012790449,
-0.0355110541,
0.0134235509,
-0.0265216567,
-0.019926969,
-0.0495648123,
-0.028087426,
-0.0062341504,
0.0043267221,
-0.0170962829,
0.1020064205,
-0.0294981562,
-0.0035188312,
0.0006664763,
-0.0002800865,
0.0133984843,
-0.0729936585,
0.0124414191,
0.0851712525,
-0.095109947,
0.0395302251,
-0.0287233796,
0.0214714911,
-0.0078330282,
-0.002581533,
-0.0034173781,
0.048712004,
0.017583644,
0.0247011371,
-0.0203465782,
0.117766656,
-0.0121113406,
0.0470701605,
-0.0161775183,
0.0212458875,
-0.0719609037,
0.0038335144,
-0.0447024666,
0.0363881551,
-0.0366919115,
-0.0232859962,
-0.0207854025,
0.0437961705,
-0.0048958473,
0.0198468026,
-0.0100354534,
0.0191568714,
-0.0392187759,
0.000528196,
-0.0754122958,
-0.0173862353,
-0.0069480385,
0.0374463722,
0.0308598503,
-0.0155283753,
-0.034125559,
0.0060220021,
-0.0206903964,
-0.0153547945,
-0.0072234077,
0.115374133,
-0.0232803524,
-0.0259374641,
0.0039379369,
-0.0179305952,
0.0091758939,
-0.0752319396,
0.0498495512,
-0.0275840554,
0.011949975,
-0.0157445353,
-0.0026225245,
-0.0029750932,
0.0122865047,
-0.0005430366,
0.0414529331,
0.0691797733,
0.0593777932,
0.0008335487,
0.0336526111,
0.0413983427,
-0.0607395917,
0.0542171113,
0.0376044288,
0.0366533324,
-0.010059759,
0.018450927,
0.0340016559,
0.0288287736,
-0.0418578126,
-0.0271649584,
0.047246255,
-0.0075675049,
-0.0120969443,
0.0714082494,
0.0066050701,
0.0166342929,
-0.0332849398,
0.0102820108,
0.0199252833,
0.0247290023,
0.0017222754,
-0.0218591969,
0.0223760121,
0.0277627949,
0.0128047718,
-0.0072890944,
-0.048300337,
0.0428102724,
-0.0128562981,
0.0010418851,
-0.0441241339,
0.0191158615,
-0.0106530068,
-0.0508606471,
0.0316583104,
0.022377437,
0.0219609961,
-0.0153956814,
0.0413349643,
0.0178490467,
-0.0880755484,
0.036744196,
-0.0156585295,
-0.0319910049,
-0.0058074142,
-0.0765120611,
0.000844887,
0.0276394673,
0.0317272209,
-0.0276802443,
-0.0719626844,
-0.0071458928,
-0.0213680789,
0.0555308163,
0.0033733654,
-0.0075473059,
0.0446725786,
-0.0184445623,
-0.0581388734,
-0.0333121568,
0.0074494239,
0.0425096899,
0.0253199954,
-0.0120827779,
-0.0089063291,
-0.0033730355,
0.036358498,
0.0527011231,
-0.0044930796,
-0.0018384295,
-0.027906457,
-0.0029819722,
0.0653146878,
0.0095306607,
-0.005335141,
-0.009310808,
0.0473147333,
0.0010201477,
-0.0375318602,
0.0359582976,
-0.0508009791,
-0.03206091,
0.0278464146,
-0.0360093303,
-0.0333348289,
0.0514305085,
-0.0158592612,
-0.0432297848,
0.0096313814,
-0.0424130671,
0.0309531055,
0.0215181466,
0.0370214768,
-0.0008252339,
-0.0415419005,
-0.0329068527,
0.0189084373,
-0.0148533061,
-0.0172923803,
0.0132280188,
0.0077778329,
0.0190172624,
-0.0411255956,
-0.0191390999,
0.0121990424,
-0.0091120703,
-0.0211309027,
-0.0024105308,
0.0372860916,
-0.0587860271,
-0.0415951237,
-0.0675294325,
-0.0237409696,
0.00600588,
-0.0099191424,
0.0068822931,
-0.0448592082,
-0.0046622963,
-0.007446487,
0.0077104326,
0.0119416872,
0.0111076953,
-0.0205623247,
0.0378054716,
0.0539808385,
-0.0757413059,
-0.0365047604,
0.0258859973,
-0.0140179014,
-0.0209375396,
0.0473792218,
-0.0028743504,
-0.0596081018,
0.0582294948,
-0.0221240148,
0.0276645888,
-0.0527215675,
-0.0344095938,
0.0813283995,
-0.008763575,
0.03915295,
0.0767607912,
0.0037074026,
0.0354675092,
0.0711725205,
-0.0248413961,
-0.0541039966,
0.0440183766,
-0.0107593322,
-0.0109433345,
-0.0512670204,
-0.0222903788,
-0.0055591944,
0.0475971811,
0.0059394231,
0.0587627776,
-0.0387665294,
-0.0346128419,
0.0285445806,
-0.063697122,
-0.0257603843,
-0.0176247247,
-0.0538871437,
0.0383072086,
-0.0195490252,
-0.0264151562,
0.0810471624,
-0.0233570319,
-0.0004293931,
0.0106313787,
0.0176568683,
0.0026137419,
0.092984274,
-0.0042693974,
-0.0099399919,
0.0222680755,
-0.0717743263,
-0.0439593792,
0.0004190112,
0.0066104159,
-0.0169382636,
0.0473678894,
-0.0738704205,
-0.0082727354,
0.0067661339,
-0.0235110372,
-0.0661324859,
0.0184926093,
-0.0189160574,
0.0015076882,
0.0226208735,
-0.0585723333,
-0.0712093189,
-0.0067121033,
0.0525013916,
0.0201515406,
-0.0062552169,
-0.0209791418,
-0.0536125489,
-0.0006899204,
0.0413946994,
0.0595147163,
-0.0184938256,
-0.0260394197,
0.0510008112,
0.0265780073,
0.070192717,
-0.038015455,
-0.048380442,
-0.0181235205,
-0.0020088248,
0.0112117268,
0.0252250396,
0.036216177,
0.0680161491,
-0.0372312441,
-0.0249428898,
0.0736644268,
0.0058411793,
0.0053033689,
-0.0098139821,
-0.0264073294,
-0.0009000799,
0.0102193272,
0.0167738013,
-0.0637215152,
-0.0404406488,
0.0066001946,
0.0175316837,
0.0175765231,
-0.0522306971,
0.0206218623,
-0.10048417,
0.0067211352,
-0.0215183068,
-0.0162235349,
-0.0605239682,
-0.0227687564,
0.0133512132,
-0.0245083328,
0.0213028342,
0.0170350466,
0.0239907037,
-0.0364700183,
0.0212479047,
0.0034500079,
0.0153841367,
0.0599623583,
-0.0153806154,
0.0361262038,
0.0571319088,
0.0235929899,
-0.0060068364,
0.0127457557,
0.0051547159,
0.0459092222,
0.037588872,
-0.0023262575,
0.0162519198,
-0.0320859291,
-0.0056616007,
-0.0212606639,
0.0090400679,
-0.0087011298,
-0.0345612131,
0.0117780706,
0.066534549,
-0.0736898929,
-0.0041422998,
-0.000953494,
0.0103427544,
0.0084322812,
0.0499735661,
0.0010366641,
-0.0142585505,
-0.0244264975,
-0.01862856,
-0.035341721,
-0.0416883267,
-0.0388416201,
-0.0082084378,
-0.0040823859,
0.010577159,
-0.0393347368,
-0.0525208265,
0.0488931425,
0.0339329764,
0.0081936941,
-0.062357381,
0.0072469651,
0.0396004543,
0.0091678714,
0.0203766674,
-0.0065314658,
0.0157464109,
-0.0477097817,
-0.0081482017,
0.0173531082,
-0.032813482,
-0.0222120509,
0.0329801887,
-0.0410607718,
-0.0402438864,
0.0308035538,
0.0716494918,
0.027254818,
0.0202756934,
0.0164631959,
0.0277928468,
-0.0057268068,
0.0072751744,
-0.0141818644,
0.0216782652,
0.0377957635,
0.053498324,
-0.0022129279,
0.0174698234,
-0.0412407182,
-0.0059739021,
-0.0291607585,
0.0392261222,
-0.0591945723,
-0.0836296752,
0.0302042495,
-0.0195511673,
0.0408717431,
-0.015853297,
-0.0065130605,
-0.0306960084,
0.024331376,
-0.0250114575,
0.0044079218,
-0.0424088947,
-0.014220329,
0.0030624487,
-0.0168957021,
0.0690360889,
0.0120936157,
-0.0247932859,
0.0155042727,
0.0041123,
0.0220694356,
0.0316343084,
0.0258447826,
0.0076875868,
0.0264376998,
-0.0011911442,
-0.003799397,
0.0193891767,
0.0487345196,
0.0451213978,
0.1147852466,
0.0044162623,
-0.0128946882,
-0.0093274713,
0.0151404962,
-0.086860016,
-0.072247602,
0.0161790829,
0.0077095754,
0.0300968215,
0.029267421,
0.0161013994,
-0.0623395517,
0.0399338678,
0.0005248701,
0.054069452,
0.0063361251,
-0.0206229351,
0.0646391511,
0.0462041311,
0.03491202,
0.0319306813,
0.0393613167,
-0.0521627367,
0.0701941773,
-0.0146662919,
0.030485481,
-0.066604428,
-0.0729632452,
0.032615602,
0.0121325869,
-0.0076119462,
-0.0437461995,
-0.0385480784,
-0.0201335642,
-0.0114610661,
0.0398527719,
0.0025121102,
-0.0309111103,
0.064210318,
0.010374302,
-0.00707751,
-0.0513693504,
-0.0138279842,
0.008813912,
0.0204130467,
0.010665779,
-0.0257376414,
-5.545467334e-33,
-0.0754621625,
-0.0822036788,
0.0590134785,
0.0056244312,
-0.0213725399,
-0.0299176443,
-0.0627221838,
0.0212254636,
-0.0595354401,
0.0087106526,
0.0006524696,
0.0116010727,
0.0179911535,
-0.0143448077,
0.0141758034,
-0.016822597,
0.0110985506,
-0.0169489104,
-0.0257270839,
0.0115417549,
0.0472526737,
0.003447772,
0.0115339542,
-0.0418360457,
0.0355309993,
-0.0066074943,
-0.0460528694,
0.0286129154,
-0.0420357101,
0.041328229,
-0.0071685519,
-0.0157261342,
0.0107139489,
-0.0466984324,
-0.0159563906,
0.0202972386,
-0.0368527919,
-0.0291782804,
-0.002934308,
0.031077655,
-0.0297350995,
-0.0179992281,
0.0170487817,
-0.0034081331,
-0.0323315747,
-0.0072834413,
0.0098910723,
0.0042891181,
0.0000190982,
0.0402576737,
-0.0402670167,
0.0029376301,
-0.0352802724,
-0.1006662697,
-0.0042680576,
0.0766483471,
0.0136231203,
-0.0209463965,
-0.0216926523,
0.0180228706,
0.0042903209,
-0.0137763238,
0.0738836229,
0.0069156792,
0.0213441979,
0.0800920054,
0.0112987366,
-0.0241127685,
0.00282887,
-0.0224052034,
-0.0059930822,
0.0810104385,
0.0077020181,
0.0180851799,
-0.0193360616,
0.029906394,
-0.0322023928,
0.0590362959,
0.0274944771,
0.1093738824,
-0.013943023,
0.0201813783,
-0.0167575404,
0.0202567559,
-0.0268490836,
-0.0003893266,
0.0211395752,
-0.039199166,
0.0101453718,
0.0204983596,
0.0443766601,
-0.0525903627,
0.0508151986,
-0.0178773832,
0.0399726108,
-0.0047688042,
-0.0132922977,
0.0399331897,
-0.0320657454,
0.0180315357,
-0.0200965852,
-0.0399632491,
0.050566148,
-0.0023193483,
0.0180673525,
-0.0036303776,
-0.0406251885,
0.0464348644,
-0.0263953693,
-0.0298595931,
-0.053496886,
-0.0034528738,
0.0283258334,
0.0066883219,
0.0451464318,
-0.0133409537,
-0.046560917,
0.0491132811,
-0.0402804092,
-0.0486366563,
-0.0385531746,
-0.0021703057,
0.0023554123,
-0.0085397754,
-0.0221209042,
-0.024464488,
-0.0390164964,
0.0076571777,
-0.01815046,
-0.0273435339,
0.0035790554,
0.0166815631,
2.789e-7,
0.0006529333,
0.0134139787,
0.038249027,
0.0467734672,
-0.001935594,
0.0593679473,
-0.0405510068,
0.007289384,
0.0042288583,
-0.0260883681,
0.0173731577,
0.0365384929,
0.0253373962,
0.0010014508,
-0.0656871647,
-0.068600215,
-0.0018062784,
-0.0586492047,
-0.0353442021,
0.0067938059,
0.0878227651,
0.0647518113,
-0.0210948922,
0.0087195076,
-0.000360458,
-0.0019436169,
0.0229048543,
-0.028202774,
-0.01236099,
0.0072965035,
-0.00178973,
-0.0330820158,
-0.0044201156,
0.019797571,
0.0138278343,
0.0024646164,
-0.0441337004,
0.0894580409,
0.0004650391,
-0.0623521917,
-0.0087004816,
0.0229602568,
-0.0021550683,
-0.0075663086,
0.0253483243,
-0.0572912246,
-0.0098727392,
0.0228967704,
-0.0108742574,
-0.024115026,
-0.0170576368,
0.0130703291,
0.0150697902,
0.0102248639,
-0.0293437559,
0.0065734652,
0.0033135877,
-0.0521333851,
0.0215471312,
-0.0110648414,
-0.0789506733,
-0.0426147245,
-0.0179861318,
-0.0493990704,
0.0233705882,
-0.0274909567,
-0.0115828943,
1.923475296e-34,
-0.0117983464,
-0.0170526132,
0.0220080931,
0.09324231,
0.0284397285,
0.0104438532,
-0.0317595676,
0.0280880593,
0.0563496314,
-0.0730135143,
-0.0415551886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07138v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07138v2 | WaterBench: Towards Holistic Evaluation of Watermarks for Large Language Models | 2023-11-13T08:09:01 | 2024-07-01T03:17:42 | Shangqing Tu, Yuliang Sun, Yushi Bai, Jifan Yu, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | To mitigate the potential misuse of large language models (LLMs), recent
research has developed watermarking algorithms, which restrict the generation
process to leave an invisible trace for watermark detection. Due to the
two-stage nature of the task, most studies evaluate the generation and
detection separately, thereby presenting a challenge in unbiased, thorough, and
applicable evaluations. In this paper, we introduce WaterBench, the first
comprehensive benchmark for LLM watermarks, in which we design three crucial
factors: (1) For benchmarking procedure, to ensure an apples-to-apples
comparison, we first adjust each watermarking method's hyper-parameter to reach
the same watermarking strength, then jointly evaluate their generation and
detection performance. (2) For task selection, we diversify the input and
output length to form a five-category taxonomy, covering $9$ tasks. (3) For
evaluation metric, we adopt the GPT4-Judge for automatically evaluating the
decline of instruction-following abilities after watermarking. We evaluate $4$
open-source watermarks on $2$ LLMs under $2$ watermarking strengths and observe
the common struggles for current methods on maintaining the generation quality.
The code and data are available at https://github.com/THU-KEG/WaterBench. | [
0.0009325965,
0.0689557344,
-0.0347379036,
0.0494271964,
-0.0265458804,
-0.0043270583,
0.0175116416,
0.0590785854,
0.0217274446,
-0.0426122844,
-0.0430794768,
-0.0223004911,
0.0239846483,
-0.0048859012,
0.0688602328,
-0.0510606505,
0.0628932714,
-0.0469563343,
-0.0082531851,
0.0228369944,
0.0118443836,
-0.0073093702,
0.065963611,
0.0399530903,
-0.0035428356,
-0.023919167,
-0.0012750181,
-0.0041227192,
0.0050933282,
-0.0341828354,
-0.026001865,
0.0566580258,
-0.0049904375,
0.1016192436,
0.0000022199,
-0.0281254444,
-0.031614095,
0.0264242049,
-0.0119792856,
0.0859823227,
0.0243893526,
-0.0078929011,
-0.0441393815,
0.0231948793,
-0.023358224,
0.0337088555,
0.0535752587,
0.0097239753,
0.0853438228,
0.0666536912,
-0.0042550592,
0.0346691087,
0.0537196621,
0.0069667827,
0.0123457266,
-0.0171292033,
0.0108952252,
0.0430282727,
-0.0156169422,
0.0099536721,
-0.00822601,
0.058617942,
0.0107783666,
-0.0464070924,
-0.059627153,
-0.0013839448,
-0.0248347018,
0.007973724,
0.0013527402,
0.0377614014,
-0.0825581849,
-0.0139184026,
-0.009931406,
-0.0179694723,
0.0087658651,
0.0198970139,
-0.0497301333,
0.0380077474,
0.0175297409,
0.0124000078,
0.0153602483,
-0.0125900358,
0.0486748815,
-0.0099746464,
0.0174865834,
0.0639756173,
0.0419051424,
-0.0172899812,
-0.0329035074,
-0.0130717838,
-0.0368786715,
-0.0647252277,
0.0405284837,
0.0022120546,
0.0195617955,
0.0061810515,
-0.084233582,
-0.0542900972,
0.0192660093,
-0.0364648812,
0.0954313427,
0.0337825455,
-0.0263085775,
0.0295298137,
-0.080454953,
0.1132705808,
-0.0384205729,
0.0208411831,
0.0100608142,
0.0202712882,
0.0036320889,
-0.0132954419,
-0.0517404974,
0.018737575,
-0.0232259165,
-0.0083589675,
-0.0211079363,
0.0486166589,
-0.0068585095,
0.0304542929,
-0.0123927472,
-0.0655095652,
0.0145802805,
0.0164013449,
0.0409065597,
-0.0276619866,
0.0142220603,
-0.0010235512,
-0.0070036505,
-0.0577581003,
-0.0011899732,
0.0328025408,
-0.004748553,
-0.0135990968,
0.0060208789,
0.0937131271,
0.0256766789,
-0.0219914485,
-0.0138070667,
-0.0368011966,
0.001596651,
-0.0219287109,
0.0101438211,
-0.057915967,
-0.0169280674,
-0.0267051682,
0.0240675025,
-0.0535521992,
0.0151371565,
0.0235811099,
0.0159469768,
0.0080631776,
-0.0302548204,
-0.0088710655,
-0.0181789603,
0.0195666235,
-0.0320346318,
0.0561143644,
0.0474351645,
0.0213685911,
0.0736140013,
-0.041627571,
0.0069839982,
0.0747953579,
-0.0090671601,
0.041134879,
0.0074763126,
-0.0370493494,
0.06323006,
-0.0114351604,
0.014109862,
0.0561628081,
-0.0234734099,
-0.0362077579,
0.0702138692,
0.0297694635,
-0.0313272588,
-0.0302079394,
0.013928527,
0.0089596799,
0.0422045477,
0.0178415366,
-0.0110003455,
-0.0152458372,
-0.0236154757,
-0.0127173988,
0.0077814106,
0.0060465951,
-0.0087361876,
-0.0065844017,
-0.0347460397,
-0.0217254683,
-0.0105165159,
-0.0021416217,
0.021027606,
0.010609271,
-0.0706297681,
0.0344845913,
-0.0309751406,
-0.0415593684,
0.0289444178,
-0.0835797116,
0.021027917,
0.0549283512,
0.0765469894,
-0.0060548172,
0.0396550708,
0.0038919095,
-0.0267209169,
0.0265340526,
-0.021912802,
-0.0082843723,
0.0237464141,
-0.0385703072,
-0.0346815698,
-0.0416433699,
0.0116930557,
0.028656885,
0.0271185189,
0.0202056225,
0.0438053124,
-0.0568818897,
-0.0360723585,
0.0322289355,
0.0237766597,
-0.0099964757,
-0.0246025827,
-0.0298319757,
0.0150888823,
0.0294678137,
-0.0237875748,
0.0207932964,
0.013167955,
-0.0033164432,
0.0180675313,
-0.031771373,
-0.0290696099,
0.0015706531,
0.0425756499,
-0.0410302505,
-0.0190554839,
0.0744300038,
-0.0050882958,
-0.0400491096,
-0.0114096422,
-0.0602873079,
0.0141756991,
-0.021443693,
0.0783782452,
-0.0224395357,
0.0246077031,
-0.0187835488,
0.0152143845,
-0.0095069362,
0.0093360143,
0.0373932682,
0.0499192737,
0.001946579,
-0.026513081,
-0.0726904646,
-0.00370773,
-0.0306360032,
0.0036132636,
0.0093614887,
0.0154212676,
-0.0361474603,
0.0014443382,
-0.0644909814,
0.0260645356,
-0.025999615,
0.0611464866,
0.0295858141,
-0.0206122044,
0.0139870793,
0.002210702,
-0.0269275755,
-0.045067817,
0.0085152211,
0.0328529589,
0.0071415245,
-0.0196519103,
-0.0538800173,
-0.0245448817,
-0.0183034223,
0.0093958154,
0.0534304567,
-0.0170665458,
-0.0475425869,
-0.0728022978,
0.0507093556,
-0.0105460668,
0.0170816369,
0.0036589848,
-0.0200379714,
0.0168876667,
0.0031055065,
0.0114529654,
0.0423670113,
-0.0084654242,
-0.0146204904,
0.0699056461,
0.0161321815,
-0.0354776606,
-0.0295275096,
-0.0036718552,
-0.0287653729,
-0.0190768167,
-0.0514127277,
0.04387578,
0.036412064,
-0.0018653078,
0.0050624199,
-0.0276138596,
0.0088789761,
-0.0327043831,
0.009936492,
-0.0148857944,
-0.0441443659,
-0.0364945978,
0.0004874453,
-0.0255167689,
-0.0865050405,
-0.0002010005,
-0.0679880753,
-0.0030977719,
-0.0006425406,
0.0044926098,
0.0047296938,
0.0514417738,
0.0040885946,
0.0311014168,
0.0114475144,
-0.0469064787,
0.0009950239,
0.0086143343,
0.0471578911,
-0.0569857806,
-0.0039135567,
-0.0458681546,
-0.0015290435,
-0.0083832862,
0.0064715506,
-0.0298224203,
0.0017315806,
0.0171764977,
0.0120304637,
0.0459938012,
-0.0323030762,
0.023996545,
0.0033439077,
0.0303514712,
0.055950515,
-0.0175369401,
0.0156444199,
-0.033176899,
0.0705914646,
0.0255395584,
-0.069395937,
0.0105086062,
-0.0237988494,
0.0280009694,
0.0725362152,
0.0472674631,
0.0066611427,
-0.0077501344,
0.0109197851,
0.0517554469,
0.0050575407,
-0.0514902174,
0.0242194086,
0.0555510446,
-0.0779693127,
0.0110018225,
0.0743684694,
0.0415247642,
-0.0037123386,
0.004916511,
0.0019977214,
0.0263503194,
0.0221682861,
-0.0177878384,
-0.0806605071,
-0.0165656693,
0.0399498045,
0.0311877243,
-0.0300005432,
0.0086339936,
-0.0235078204,
-0.0901516899,
0.0321052521,
0.0302433968,
-0.0327781662,
0.0063679526,
-0.0615631863,
-0.0233949218,
0.052645877,
0.0276766196,
-0.0247585736,
0.0245648734,
-0.0215605777,
0.0270870831,
-0.0414905772,
-0.069382444,
0.0271820929,
-0.0135555835,
0.0418118872,
0.0692844093,
0.025546914,
-0.0125641767,
-0.0474744476,
0.0605299138,
-0.0179312658,
-0.006597138,
-0.0035014313,
0.0507346317,
0.0032000514,
-0.0323374569,
-0.0070594526,
-0.0195821039,
0.0184050016,
0.0019071939,
0.0110956207,
0.0733349547,
-0.0094273835,
-0.012025238,
0.0042753159,
-0.0584281124,
-0.0055226563,
0.0566937365,
0.0267091431,
-0.0205418393,
-0.0151486294,
-0.0552897826,
0.0145247458,
-0.0578459799,
-0.0358347148,
0.0078897532,
-0.0617895536,
-0.035139326,
-0.0545308627,
0.0008323531,
-0.010594707,
0.0043714084,
0.0401048884,
0.0459859185,
0.0096352631,
-0.0527385101,
-0.0413114019,
0.0163754914,
-0.0878458396,
0.0537760817,
-0.0866189599,
-0.0138842491,
-0.0121388454,
0.0185102932,
-0.0164051708,
0.0587290749,
-0.0832161978,
-0.0816746205,
-0.0151487933,
0.0554623939,
0.0165888332,
-0.0313020423,
-0.000755877,
-0.0420782417,
0.0085639413,
-0.0137406103,
-0.007121935,
0.027452562,
0.0633109212,
-0.0735003725,
-0.0038377382,
0.01554948,
-0.0437341891,
-0.0085724033,
0.0537326485,
0.0049957745,
-0.0130149787,
0.0224985722,
0.0179398786,
0.0728799105,
0.0182991978,
-0.0340234786,
0.0085134581,
0.0197841674,
0.0020272613,
-0.0465166867,
-0.0200923327,
-0.0339122899,
0.0227663163,
0.0348697081,
-0.0250656828,
0.0137213273,
0.0108542154,
-0.0163230449,
-0.0130890319,
-0.0388734005,
0.0405017175,
-0.0231926683,
0.0323949829,
0.02333894,
0.0030133598,
0.0016648322,
0.0192736145,
0.0001969638,
0.0217437074,
0.0056921234,
0.0166567508,
-0.0016686668,
-0.0019339221,
-0.00324617,
0.0615069754,
-0.0527901873,
-0.0050963527,
-0.0423906185,
0.0203402266,
0.0627940744,
0.0172610004,
0.070093587,
-0.0360503644,
0.0015606344,
-0.0460616238,
0.0182018168,
-0.0039026481,
-0.0762063712,
-0.0164835267,
0.0005782791,
-0.0247772783,
0.0077677625,
0.0484774709,
0.0363140926,
0.0436303243,
0.0113924053,
-0.0339908749,
-0.0236911662,
-0.0163175818,
0.0454699732,
0.0134214396,
-0.0450930856,
-0.0397203006,
-0.0397888608,
-0.0739871338,
-0.0280577559,
0.0127451466,
0.0237694364,
0.0005865394,
-0.024869753,
0.0092676571,
0.0000142426,
-0.0119231706,
-0.0457884334,
-0.0151534053,
0.0021425418,
-0.0135703729,
0.0055719842,
-5.73926374e-33,
-0.0266882181,
-0.0491079651,
-0.0268970449,
-0.0521915108,
0.0108532086,
0.0716954619,
-0.0419580266,
0.0038939577,
0.0027879614,
-0.0223967899,
0.0104075354,
-0.0057623684,
0.0061211814,
-0.0252538323,
-0.0330855735,
0.0373997055,
0.0619997829,
0.0147277694,
-0.0508771911,
0.0106546925,
0.0270399749,
-0.0400992446,
0.0400426537,
-0.0496575758,
0.0161427315,
-0.0370722339,
-0.0584187917,
-0.0365250632,
-0.0439419225,
0.0761951208,
-0.0061711301,
0.0387765691,
-0.0104505531,
-0.0262723863,
-0.0698929206,
0.0040434664,
-0.0431526899,
-0.0213353951,
0.0163743291,
0.0490037166,
-0.0181855448,
-0.0629093722,
-0.0070019364,
-0.0117091388,
-0.033011023,
0.0149557935,
-0.0168862399,
-0.0011996689,
-0.0277933534,
0.005494799,
-0.0223355815,
0.0286021847,
-0.0221980494,
0.0037854079,
0.0430042073,
0.0262666307,
0.0455214567,
-0.0108695058,
-0.0750129744,
0.0337826423,
0.0191913787,
0.0389373302,
0.0916977897,
-0.0077337106,
0.0029313215,
0.0343897417,
-0.0128443008,
0.0170470942,
0.069420211,
-0.0058947164,
0.0439485125,
0.0340374149,
0.0813518241,
-0.0146154799,
0.0511981063,
-0.0280363392,
0.0034435512,
0.0467898101,
-0.0261058975,
-0.0039190562,
0.0406806916,
0.0249250066,
-0.0631672293,
-0.0131639494,
-0.0608826056,
-0.0236782338,
-0.0146891139,
-0.0129576661,
0.0771946311,
-0.0105793932,
-0.028230058,
-0.0307115912,
0.0409900099,
-0.0404628515,
-0.0213528965,
0.0145581793,
-0.0429454483,
0.054653015,
-0.005125877,
0.0478112958,
0.0206214152,
-0.0323563628,
0.0571678244,
-0.0471421033,
0.0491981842,
-0.0099923462,
0.0358887576,
0.0233841762,
-0.0780681074,
0.0211412255,
-0.0289759822,
0.0085917721,
0.0151903341,
-0.0009028622,
0.0209126342,
-0.0479457565,
0.0032517533,
-0.012514702,
0.0385324992,
-0.0305170901,
-0.0444446988,
-0.0024975864,
-0.0273054484,
0.0056827669,
-0.0119045461,
0.0255731922,
-0.0353169069,
0.0561152697,
0.045830816,
-0.0117251799,
-0.0499831289,
-0.0015927994,
2.715e-7,
0.0168423373,
0.0330077782,
0.0455065444,
0.0454945378,
0.0130414348,
0.0312146805,
-0.0261416882,
-0.0028031075,
-0.0025364407,
0.0125841703,
-0.0416184776,
-0.0136351986,
0.0587789305,
0.0095100282,
-0.0220418628,
0.0147191025,
-0.0208376143,
-0.0052786204,
-0.0640907735,
0.020724684,
0.0270056967,
0.0813551545,
0.0120354844,
-0.0225897599,
0.008906465,
-0.0454006828,
0.028849218,
-0.0145822363,
0.0095531214,
0.0041237841,
0.0082831942,
0.0260169245,
0.0068693371,
0.0226947945,
-0.0341890454,
-0.007413174,
0.0264208615,
0.0588610023,
-0.0230398364,
0.0311862268,
-0.0154098514,
-0.024062559,
-0.0263433792,
-0.0620757602,
0.0573072173,
0.104856059,
-0.0149175385,
-0.0838940293,
-0.0348907635,
-0.0561637916,
0.0305879693,
-0.0309139658,
-0.0001364699,
0.0133395577,
0.0070568682,
0.0031768621,
-0.0252274964,
-0.0201958492,
-0.0379275233,
-0.0403933451,
-0.0099133449,
-0.0635102093,
-0.0698515028,
0.0040893224,
0.0242835153,
-0.0635078549,
0.0075547691,
2.814638342e-34,
-0.0041037793,
-0.0676233321,
0.0482396223,
0.0284876674,
0.051948294,
0.021703776,
-0.0283686426,
0.0089185312,
-0.0074434304,
-0.0373152792,
-0.0159362145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07115v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07115v1 | Gen-Z: Generative Zero-Shot Text Classification with Contextualized Label Descriptions | 2023-11-13T07:12:57 | 2023-11-13T07:12:57 | Sachin Kumar, Chan Young Park, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language model (LM) prompting--a popular paradigm for solving NLP tasks--has
been shown to be susceptible to miscalibration and brittleness to slight prompt
variations, caused by its discriminative prompting approach, i.e., predicting
the label given the input. To address these issues, we propose Gen-Z--a
generative prompting framework for zero-shot text classification. GEN-Z is
generative, as it measures the LM likelihood of input text, conditioned on
natural language descriptions of labels. The framework is multivariate, as
label descriptions allow us to seamlessly integrate additional contextual
information about the labels to improve task performance. On various standard
classification benchmarks, with six open-source LM families, we show that
zero-shot classification with simple contextualization of the data source of
the evaluation set consistently outperforms both zero-shot and few-shot
baselines while improving robustness to prompt variations. Further, our
approach enables personalizing classification in a zero-shot manner by
incorporating author, subject, or reader information in the label descriptions. | [
0.0276158862,
-0.0032986933,
0.0199396145,
0.0253512021,
-0.0305741671,
0.0237927511,
0.0656841099,
-0.0098095099,
0.0084232502,
-0.1102209091,
-0.0138776917,
-0.0123007512,
-0.0202173311,
0.0227946918,
0.0109541025,
-0.0341276452,
0.0255439579,
0.0110223321,
0.024635205,
0.0132146077,
0.0025231133,
0.0260340385,
-0.0220068153,
0.019240981,
-0.007944474,
-0.0437516905,
-0.00867722,
0.0174077712,
0.0082300426,
-0.0342307352,
0.0068955896,
0.0896477625,
0.0182462484,
0.0362327062,
0.0000018617,
-0.0560751185,
0.0038161317,
-0.0207786523,
-0.052353248,
-0.0561822429,
0.062362656,
-0.0242918227,
0.0117616644,
0.0009316539,
-0.0028983653,
-0.0583250709,
0.0221821908,
0.0585556068,
0.0111862719,
0.071292907,
-0.0135366274,
-0.0175739136,
-0.0019581451,
-0.0031114048,
0.0861987099,
-0.0326359347,
0.0117731607,
-0.0561154149,
0.0202577412,
0.093832083,
-0.0050539612,
0.0182185154,
0.008761202,
-0.0128315734,
0.0686931908,
0.0579444245,
-0.0038205271,
-0.0226011164,
-0.0088500604,
0.0872291774,
0.0480532907,
-0.0351030193,
0.0012762642,
-0.0129848281,
-0.0077088224,
-0.0165624637,
-0.0501723625,
0.0324161015,
0.0076407422,
-0.0063537708,
-0.0062302058,
0.0347463228,
0.0121932998,
-0.010511443,
0.0486212932,
0.0346567854,
0.0086273029,
-0.0310951658,
-0.0424118452,
0.0017605727,
0.0120540168,
-0.1061847806,
-0.0558808632,
0.0267976187,
-0.0246383585,
0.0026579315,
-0.0693172589,
-0.037156973,
0.0406302027,
-0.0131244939,
0.01196694,
0.0032620914,
-0.0233804267,
0.0536130443,
-0.0157911871,
0.0368667729,
0.0517350771,
-0.0134754507,
-0.040319968,
-0.0065464126,
-0.0853749886,
-0.0018886515,
-0.0096893329,
0.0239987988,
0.0065180203,
-0.0200379789,
-0.0431606621,
0.0342116281,
0.0060635777,
0.0268580783,
-0.0326094516,
0.0327315517,
-0.0345097147,
0.0088545419,
-0.0299622081,
0.0124772312,
-0.0570184477,
0.0239982847,
-0.0101505695,
-0.0260395631,
-0.0207673032,
0.0360054076,
0.0291768964,
-0.0261595249,
-0.0072917021,
0.0233404096,
-0.0065026255,
-0.0663119033,
-0.0315526947,
-0.0403221138,
-0.0254990421,
-0.0318808109,
-0.0235269796,
-0.0337097086,
0.0114875352,
0.0184420422,
-0.0182561744,
-0.0123813227,
-0.002070263,
0.0391469114,
-0.0147925252,
0.0939576924,
0.0011181535,
-0.0406271219,
0.0211384129,
0.0119529832,
0.0136365695,
0.0554940552,
-0.0099762781,
-0.0008654479,
0.0392475016,
0.0302394573,
0.0524764396,
-0.0144637395,
0.0063485457,
0.0154512981,
0.0027318415,
0.0050955354,
0.0357803367,
0.0223382898,
0.035736829,
-0.0109345634,
-0.0174594037,
-0.0244389661,
0.0459109619,
0.0796814561,
0.0137784882,
-0.0149678485,
0.0352929272,
0.0285153408,
-0.038340386,
-0.0213599578,
-0.0297867414,
0.0233257543,
-0.0549229346,
-0.0040046396,
0.01792611,
-0.0244090222,
-0.044978939,
-0.0282378905,
-0.0326070413,
-0.0170340501,
-0.0003568805,
0.011958533,
0.0448941067,
0.0155644091,
-0.0436087064,
-0.004412083,
0.0099464841,
-0.0417904519,
-0.016362194,
-0.03754149,
0.0675987154,
0.0771124512,
0.0411817767,
-0.0312720127,
-0.0115889786,
-0.0515655167,
0.0279447269,
0.0250894371,
0.0138748623,
-0.026251357,
0.0178014934,
-0.0233620349,
-0.0573099032,
-0.0235315934,
0.0202691238,
0.0118118599,
-0.0138819506,
0.0071098693,
0.0375360511,
0.0122970622,
0.0081578325,
0.0410862602,
-0.0157171916,
-0.0873797387,
0.0759139657,
0.0107857212,
-0.0125974771,
0.0410409234,
0.0012788859,
-0.0111017022,
0.0147188427,
-0.0187794566,
-0.0201571677,
-0.0235104337,
-0.0266244933,
-0.0658527911,
0.0010263672,
0.0235230494,
0.0212791152,
-0.0456017703,
-0.0516638309,
-0.0484481305,
0.009063961,
0.0339053199,
-0.0179710574,
-0.0571321584,
-0.0067540044,
0.0206762161,
-0.0023471827,
-0.0520610847,
0.072016865,
0.0513793379,
0.031386178,
0.0157109145,
0.0355058685,
0.0362571776,
-0.0379089527,
-0.0271134637,
-0.0151253575,
-0.0066903485,
0.002321203,
0.0215388909,
0.0138164368,
-0.0469862744,
0.0035014455,
-0.1046521813,
0.0189401265,
-0.0108296778,
0.0051477966,
0.0004992123,
-0.0024171786,
0.0044716368,
-0.0168303847,
-0.0465792008,
-0.0195050854,
-0.0040696682,
-0.0002877854,
0.0536068194,
0.0018326518,
0.0076728906,
0.0051459684,
0.0112534733,
-0.0358470343,
0.0689497441,
0.0454845577,
0.0098652104,
-0.0288732592,
0.0211776011,
-0.0220125634,
0.0096710538,
-0.0029522923,
0.025330741,
-0.00420549,
0.0052622231,
0.0084440643,
0.0497728847,
-0.0282145943,
0.0023116837,
0.0047334838,
0.0247287937,
-0.0384199433,
0.0053849956,
-0.0327001624,
-0.0129937958,
0.0463175438,
-0.0108144889,
0.0276834294,
0.0656828582,
0.0072624022,
-0.0349382423,
-0.0663306341,
0.0326480307,
-0.0013105288,
0.0118528586,
-0.0660061538,
0.0272538625,
0.0067218253,
0.0279762708,
-0.0267476533,
-0.0350032523,
0.066798076,
-0.0328940526,
-0.0132856974,
-0.0315124355,
-0.0150918402,
-0.0283840988,
0.0539533198,
-0.0110175628,
-0.0045993044,
0.0901354253,
0.0071136248,
-0.0092516346,
0.000099371,
0.0102159493,
-0.0000742418,
0.0078741107,
-0.025669245,
0.0513734631,
-0.0188443139,
-0.0345654823,
-0.0319620967,
-0.054811392,
-0.0040103863,
0.0240188893,
-0.0392454304,
0.0037203436,
-0.0066974396,
-0.0049121855,
0.0273975506,
0.062429551,
-0.0336418971,
-0.0379443653,
-0.0081753228,
0.0536303744,
0.0228552036,
-0.0426754206,
-0.0486070029,
-0.0044848584,
0.0084257387,
0.0210540146,
0.0166851971,
0.0605014935,
0.0020493693,
-0.0114070764,
0.0278345477,
-0.0210883748,
-0.0443193354,
0.0322865956,
0.0311905835,
-0.0249530245,
-0.0048401752,
0.1260090321,
0.0516810976,
-0.0887565538,
-0.0247964785,
-0.0206015464,
0.0139254285,
0.0318853594,
0.0299782474,
-0.122732237,
-0.0606447719,
-0.0136685325,
0.0239092112,
-0.0243089721,
-0.0066692978,
-0.02546864,
-0.0960761607,
0.0198016427,
-0.0269922502,
-0.0273679756,
0.027048355,
-0.0644959137,
0.0023505334,
-0.0029534278,
-0.0372746661,
-0.0173622929,
-0.0029122634,
-0.0008578346,
0.0211998355,
0.0097998008,
-0.0775748044,
0.036425706,
-0.0081615057,
0.0708052516,
0.0410237014,
0.0135006811,
0.0103309639,
-0.0134934811,
-0.0070082466,
-0.0166103262,
-0.003114745,
-0.0226850249,
0.0721435174,
-0.0492222868,
0.0313774236,
-0.0189862717,
0.0289751161,
-0.0170644298,
-0.0379150957,
0.0101304073,
0.0541097894,
-0.0054414449,
0.0092864679,
-0.0417551249,
-0.0053886604,
0.0277510639,
0.1004092544,
0.021736294,
-0.0485200211,
-0.0358026065,
-0.0450673066,
0.0009226684,
-0.0704750791,
-0.0051748627,
-0.0054776259,
-0.0199545417,
-0.0570912212,
-0.0477737598,
-0.0447285883,
0.0437451005,
0.006283958,
0.0090646511,
0.0046999124,
-0.0533211827,
-0.0083862683,
-0.0261660181,
0.0110977618,
-0.0192243829,
0.0157245137,
-0.0663525239,
-0.0069892788,
0.0694157034,
-0.0448863134,
-0.0176859759,
0.0163574908,
-0.0633030981,
-0.0364498645,
-0.0560796037,
0.0360742025,
0.0132941613,
0.0275759175,
-0.0169695057,
-0.0741494372,
0.0709575042,
0.0754955932,
0.0198439192,
0.0098220306,
0.0038516289,
0.0535287336,
-0.0075027756,
0.0223408993,
-0.0357853472,
0.055571679,
-0.0068360921,
-0.0108253397,
-0.0392541885,
-0.0239471477,
-0.0112888562,
-0.0132196657,
0.0610096976,
-0.0271228589,
-0.0136135202,
-0.0329751968,
-0.0016517596,
-0.0335434042,
-0.0387557596,
-0.0133667719,
-0.0008682145,
0.0135392491,
-0.0366043039,
-0.0128414938,
0.0196104087,
-0.0760241374,
0.0842902511,
-0.0707092732,
-0.0318937264,
0.0571312308,
-0.0055867322,
-0.0087016504,
0.0081371637,
-0.0246705711,
0.0066013299,
0.0042495923,
0.0307634119,
-0.0288734268,
0.0655000135,
0.0160854738,
0.0113236522,
-0.0392652564,
0.0051437067,
-0.0576983653,
0.0325524881,
-0.0013912087,
0.0386179797,
0.0280743632,
0.0049731843,
0.00921492,
0.0049657328,
-0.0168257579,
-0.0091878874,
0.0571398064,
0.0198256392,
-0.049137909,
0.0190782826,
0.0289000962,
-0.0195109416,
0.0119157005,
0.0785293505,
0.0185828134,
0.0174816046,
0.0082999449,
0.0054031028,
-0.0438755713,
0.04430319,
0.0190577731,
0.0223816689,
0.0120171774,
0.032392513,
-0.0661344603,
-0.0282127019,
0.0616491623,
-0.0206826907,
-0.0032366498,
0.0019764754,
0.0374002345,
0.037893258,
0.0003042613,
-0.0368343182,
-0.0471024998,
0.0038522545,
0.0184538141,
-0.0354918279,
-0.0390476249,
-6.165741907e-33,
-0.0137872836,
-0.041317977,
0.0109203057,
-0.0085061463,
0.0119655197,
0.0277326107,
-0.0168983545,
0.0064407485,
0.0085684918,
-0.0017978885,
-0.0232308786,
-0.0184510015,
-0.0024297817,
0.0619087592,
0.014172879,
-0.0294235256,
0.0364490077,
-0.025748048,
-0.0342238024,
0.0368649364,
0.0581925213,
0.0197285116,
0.0234080479,
-0.0546210669,
0.087585479,
-0.0525682904,
-0.0116518121,
0.0088577839,
0.0579304025,
0.0453683659,
-0.0370371491,
0.0515383072,
0.0428608656,
-0.0418627486,
0.0234763231,
0.0526392348,
-0.0663882419,
-0.0476441048,
-0.0130587714,
-0.0034835741,
-0.0277911127,
-0.0377897583,
0.0032191465,
-0.0000536613,
-0.0348114707,
-0.0231012162,
0.0758058503,
0.0066101258,
-0.0617366694,
-0.0506551638,
-0.0518585183,
0.0078698061,
0.0046938136,
-0.0466794893,
0.0285519641,
0.1000961885,
0.008200055,
0.0638310984,
-0.0514726415,
0.0096022636,
-0.0022745326,
0.0105719911,
0.0229586512,
0.0441785716,
-0.0058876779,
0.038722001,
0.0120003065,
0.01369486,
-0.0667678863,
-0.0169032011,
0.0107928617,
-0.0152907036,
0.0121432934,
0.0765178651,
0.0627917722,
0.0118880793,
-0.0532960594,
0.0408178642,
0.0076011037,
-0.041586183,
0.0212905332,
-0.0105087133,
-0.0341339149,
-0.0409290604,
-0.0374047235,
-0.052950751,
-0.0646658316,
0.0055281757,
0.0199800618,
0.0286164396,
-0.0260736737,
-0.0155827785,
0.023628762,
-0.0077013415,
-0.0339850448,
0.0173512232,
-0.0003587803,
0.0375844166,
0.0016266615,
-0.0185242575,
-0.0533225872,
-0.011543043,
0.0503405258,
0.0179323144,
0.0313568227,
-0.0052632117,
0.0816490576,
0.000145093,
-0.0405286029,
-0.009913858,
-0.0005030584,
0.0296449717,
-0.0110478904,
0.0634671748,
-0.0093042487,
0.0366166271,
-0.0082874959,
0.0760323256,
0.0295816027,
-0.0062659723,
0.0234963708,
-0.0230985805,
-0.0255613606,
-0.0196229592,
-0.0345606245,
0.0119527746,
0.0223392025,
0.0203815922,
0.0212171525,
-0.0506251194,
0.0013070948,
0.015192166,
2.563e-7,
0.008819323,
0.0642853081,
-0.007140825,
-0.0093853297,
0.0223512687,
0.0846160129,
0.019653691,
0.0470159501,
0.0034391305,
-0.0103106927,
0.0160701927,
-0.0003201552,
0.02485683,
0.0046570902,
-0.0953769237,
0.0033576093,
-0.027303651,
0.037266504,
-0.0466127656,
0.0187342335,
0.1039550379,
0.0612209439,
0.0263218433,
0.0070717977,
0.0185555425,
-0.0336998291,
0.0622506924,
-0.0093365936,
0.0143818045,
-0.0064211646,
0.0361135639,
0.0028380782,
-0.0047928253,
0.0043703523,
-0.0244796984,
-0.0101301856,
-0.0144622158,
0.0694643781,
-0.0243706442,
-0.0513011217,
0.0036301038,
0.0142110307,
0.0193983056,
-0.0229211394,
0.1105849221,
-0.0411763564,
-0.0083645573,
-0.0065431502,
-0.0358239226,
-0.001326711,
0.0501885936,
-0.0067598578,
-0.0431505963,
0.0267929789,
0.0241987929,
-0.0101622213,
-0.0317631103,
-0.0945406854,
-0.0159120541,
-0.0080916807,
-0.0211295914,
0.0252195261,
0.0015283766,
-0.0056883008,
0.0298757087,
-0.0661105365,
0.0205939002,
2.361939396e-34,
0.0093726348,
0.0158799756,
-0.0130550554,
-0.0109924665,
-0.022087181,
0.012202342,
-0.0315372385,
-0.0236282405,
0.042925857,
-0.0729481429,
-0.013686141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07102v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07102v2 | Fovea Transformer: Efficient Long-Context Modeling with Structured Fine-to-Coarse Attention | 2023-11-13T06:24:27 | 2024-01-11T14:24:54 | Ziwei He, Jian Yuan, Le Zhou, Jingwen Leng, Bo Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The quadratic complexity of self-attention in Transformers has hindered the
processing of long text. To alleviate this problem, previous works have
proposed to sparsify the attention matrix, taking advantage of the observation
that crucial information about a token can be derived from its neighbors. These
methods typically combine one or another form of local attention and global
attention. Such combinations introduce abrupt changes in contextual granularity
when going from local to global, which may be undesirable. We believe that a
smoother transition could potentially enhance model's ability to capture
long-context dependencies. In this study, we introduce Fovea Transformer, a
long-context focused transformer that addresses the challenges of capturing
global dependencies while maintaining computational efficiency. To achieve
this, we construct a multi-scale tree from the input sequence, and use
representations of context tokens with a progressively coarser granularity in
the tree, as their distance to the query token increases. We evaluate our model
on three long-context summarization tasks\footnote{Our code is publicly
available at: \textit{https://github.com/ZiweiHe/Fovea-Transformer}}. It
achieves state-of-the-art performance on two of them, and competitive results
on the third with mixed improvement and setback of the evaluation metrics. | [
0.0333635882,
0.0328359194,
0.006088716,
0.0508526266,
-0.0108760167,
-0.0001394532,
-0.0361170806,
-0.0425688848,
-0.0404907465,
-0.0448635593,
-0.0247844309,
-0.02871654,
0.0226623304,
0.0506553017,
-0.0007097346,
-0.0927379727,
0.0171021931,
-0.0245983545,
-0.0179936215,
0.0114123896,
0.0153694386,
-0.0150460955,
0.0345540904,
0.0258698352,
-0.0361486003,
-0.0337227881,
-0.0242794696,
-0.0077795452,
0.0426092036,
-0.027113229,
-0.0093631139,
0.0312506445,
0.0160142332,
-0.0066077244,
0.0000021231,
-0.0232163742,
-0.0400773846,
-0.0129190609,
0.0206543952,
0.0143935159,
0.0230758302,
-0.0346697494,
0.0042549907,
-0.0253025927,
-0.0118824365,
0.0217282549,
0.0246362016,
0.0619121939,
0.0604564212,
0.0608400889,
-0.0187904444,
-0.055802539,
0.0268813204,
-0.0622374676,
0.0167830717,
-0.06125075,
0.011023296,
-0.0221152771,
-0.0239463504,
0.0142264748,
-0.056804467,
0.0305799358,
0.0406927355,
-0.002914499,
0.0229525939,
0.0484515466,
-0.0378152244,
0.0138235213,
0.0091607152,
0.0794936344,
-0.044669915,
-0.0051434231,
0.010783894,
0.0188345928,
0.0085755587,
-0.0351814367,
-0.0806098655,
0.0359008759,
0.0124305896,
0.0165168904,
0.014885081,
0.0329185948,
-0.0194470491,
0.0059418189,
-0.075858213,
0.0227040816,
-0.002405186,
0.0026529557,
-0.0612079464,
-0.0063058762,
-0.0369231515,
-0.0569375977,
0.0365381166,
0.06752415,
-0.0167532936,
-0.012716718,
-0.0395963676,
-0.0255921017,
-0.0023655654,
-0.0085556386,
-0.0342157632,
0.0217915121,
-0.0209102277,
0.0644810498,
-0.0345779285,
0.0407327004,
-0.0184533577,
0.0170212686,
-0.0433847792,
-0.0304123703,
-0.0120061534,
0.0192454699,
-0.05950813,
0.0469725356,
-0.0783674419,
-0.0154728293,
-0.0253168494,
0.0372295715,
-0.00734358,
-0.0280819423,
-0.0036392799,
0.0233561732,
-0.0298185162,
0.0119351586,
0.037434075,
0.0352109745,
-0.0587295741,
-0.0296278764,
0.0277846325,
0.0018597303,
-0.0489732511,
0.0363192447,
0.0375947058,
-0.0168036278,
-0.011448917,
0.0451089814,
-0.014729389,
-0.060759604,
0.0007981136,
-0.023040697,
-0.0684035793,
-0.0350438394,
-0.0186992642,
-0.0542672984,
0.0134261101,
0.0034759322,
0.0150238927,
0.0199746061,
-0.0097078755,
0.036727611,
-0.0080146631,
0.0293103773,
0.0295131896,
-0.0152754756,
-0.0123736076,
0.0220045466,
0.0317686722,
0.0513086878,
0.0297418684,
0.066771999,
0.0134156896,
0.0035834392,
-0.006360718,
0.0238562599,
0.0150652016,
0.0175934304,
-0.0174022224,
0.0161860436,
-0.0496564209,
-0.0287593007,
0.0736235827,
0.0551026985,
-0.0144810611,
-0.0123391347,
0.0349138305,
0.0653349757,
0.0239428207,
0.021814419,
0.0336207524,
0.0047915485,
-0.0407914519,
0.0396767892,
-0.047035832,
0.0783755481,
-0.002634608,
0.0535724051,
0.0447490141,
0.0226838142,
-0.0302093662,
-0.0180036705,
0.0321281478,
0.0002922329,
0.0001065733,
-0.0047910232,
0.0099454168,
0.016303774,
-0.0386192165,
0.0571606047,
0.0010847619,
-0.0628990605,
-0.0023582911,
-0.0190847963,
0.025165081,
0.0251825321,
0.0272525903,
-0.0393172354,
-0.0208443832,
-0.0088342568,
-0.0045311642,
0.0334465541,
-0.0153097631,
0.0019179609,
-0.0064580794,
-0.0299058612,
-0.0216115769,
-0.0153563097,
-0.0041922596,
0.0011126875,
0.0132739851,
-0.0081263399,
0.0486719422,
0.0036884476,
0.0116537157,
0.0144006833,
0.0191481505,
-0.0132969981,
-0.0197881591,
0.0016257637,
0.0445707738,
0.0269000381,
0.0129536921,
0.031789232,
0.0552836619,
-0.0395474136,
-0.0053513474,
-0.0003626377,
-0.0902029499,
-0.0438772924,
0.0193052702,
-0.0347158574,
-0.0011260262,
0.0128576774,
-0.031409245,
-0.0516969003,
0.0151212672,
-0.0515034497,
0.0277887583,
0.0020194687,
0.0117403474,
0.0199694782,
0.056173753,
-0.0490551963,
0.077589862,
-0.0172613524,
0.0077723092,
0.041430667,
0.0172351226,
-0.0132627981,
-0.0186431352,
-0.016588401,
-0.0140739623,
-0.0209788214,
-0.0093588978,
0.0368352719,
0.0018236759,
-0.0508933291,
-0.0269757006,
-0.0899122059,
-0.0149944406,
-0.0321144611,
0.0279523414,
0.0475312695,
0.0411726497,
0.0008941719,
0.0038996572,
-0.053863205,
-0.0004385365,
-0.0158421975,
0.0298353322,
0.0171635952,
-0.0129604805,
0.0191670936,
-0.0662231445,
-0.0286052208,
0.0048779785,
0.0503560752,
-0.0042963559,
-0.0464875884,
-0.0121969841,
0.0013206741,
-0.0085557839,
-0.0090578198,
-0.0288109705,
-0.0011058296,
-0.0151013359,
-0.0286594108,
0.0902857706,
0.062345054,
0.0447251126,
0.0084644426,
0.0178236943,
-0.0256155953,
-0.0065949657,
0.023358874,
-0.0274548307,
0.0323671885,
-0.0002727257,
0.0042211069,
0.0449754782,
0.0738265887,
-0.0168323368,
-0.0082493704,
-0.0161850806,
-0.0110924551,
-0.0012282345,
0.0013082019,
-0.0192523822,
-0.0067800879,
-0.0316009112,
0.0118878223,
-0.0411242731,
-0.0004603324,
0.0668337569,
-0.0311157908,
0.0135922488,
-0.0210785419,
0.0220708549,
-0.0958734751,
0.0745329857,
0.0098455362,
0.0179241411,
-0.028600784,
-0.0280458052,
-0.0285138469,
0.0164449848,
-0.0180159416,
-0.0059611504,
0.1235865429,
0.0280423779,
0.0243842453,
-0.0376445912,
-0.0037305974,
-0.0089540733,
-0.0245209057,
-0.0236896388,
0.0236343686,
0.0735741928,
-0.0049983896,
-0.0575193614,
0.0508855619,
0.0439796597,
0.0872111619,
-0.0417268202,
-0.0063892924,
-0.0132568004,
0.0805081278,
0.0395188779,
0.0322558507,
0.0293255039,
-0.0277103335,
0.035216514,
0.0787672848,
0.0638045818,
-0.0225814562,
0.0048112161,
-0.0022593339,
0.0002408429,
-0.0284419451,
0.0067225858,
-0.0072868946,
0.0665845796,
-0.0709494054,
-0.0324604921,
0.0973160043,
0.0086306036,
-0.0669118986,
0.0112074614,
-0.0141028836,
0.0360862948,
0.0282733943,
-0.0076959319,
-0.0675579309,
-0.0564381033,
0.0033355122,
0.0039058758,
0.0415135026,
-0.0393767953,
0.0231346004,
-0.07185103,
0.0256765373,
-0.0041643339,
-0.0634659901,
-0.0460626446,
-0.0388688706,
0.0402881019,
-0.0021711767,
0.0040567671,
0.0339189805,
-0.0375888236,
-0.0034380066,
-0.0104767177,
0.0103041083,
0.0193595812,
0.0250777341,
-0.020456735,
-0.0252178684,
0.0263445992,
0.0234492086,
0.0213345215,
0.031453196,
0.0387147442,
-0.0495008975,
0.0094763171,
0.0142735075,
0.0471971668,
-0.0239762831,
-0.0196708031,
-0.0190433562,
0.0157946497,
-0.0380124152,
-0.0215652101,
-0.0059798071,
0.0702346787,
0.0258150399,
-0.0013283772,
-0.0614175014,
-0.0033404517,
-0.0440268181,
0.0571473651,
0.0554272644,
-0.0044218916,
-0.0429761596,
-0.0157997534,
-0.0209495947,
-0.0433645137,
-0.0397254676,
0.0002480416,
0.0147715304,
-0.0494371429,
-0.0732883736,
-0.0466429181,
0.0324136466,
0.0227748826,
-0.0353727005,
-0.0151519366,
0.003803266,
-0.015067759,
-0.0625432506,
0.03464818,
-0.0508059971,
-0.0019368783,
-0.0358565748,
0.0366739407,
0.0594837107,
0.01043633,
-0.0159606487,
0.0463224053,
-0.0939821973,
-0.0197030567,
-0.0096764145,
0.0313333608,
0.0095953308,
0.0466597378,
-0.002122493,
0.0035736787,
0.0431688912,
0.0410788693,
-0.0497428328,
0.035397701,
0.0057719415,
0.0054050251,
-0.0126863541,
0.0338539109,
-0.0609333254,
0.0304703768,
-0.010553549,
0.0702824667,
-0.0331088006,
-0.0419814847,
0.0213204864,
-0.008721103,
0.0230350252,
0.0248354245,
0.0154919019,
0.0110935615,
0.0166300237,
-0.014297273,
-0.0229321197,
-0.0329973288,
0.0219907686,
-0.0359060615,
-0.0152238691,
0.0131098982,
0.0432891175,
-0.0131403999,
-0.0238275249,
-0.0570964813,
0.0115635684,
-0.0242941119,
-0.0370872766,
-0.0263309982,
0.0097442754,
-0.0242908336,
-0.0627659485,
-0.0071247467,
0.0042865956,
-0.024079537,
0.0227569304,
0.0077526565,
0.016553415,
-0.0355482884,
0.0298055541,
-0.0901913494,
0.0383005664,
-0.0398724601,
-0.0230878573,
0.0445961207,
-0.0639059842,
0.0550924838,
0.0327671543,
-0.0024072039,
-0.0208614301,
0.0259037204,
0.0171476807,
-0.0260375924,
0.0003622218,
0.0453529321,
0.026026424,
0.0173035786,
0.1018249318,
-0.0303669479,
0.0026996767,
0.0375865214,
-0.006709428,
-0.0399064235,
-0.0269642211,
-0.0380329601,
0.0358188078,
-0.0026245504,
-0.0153538175,
-0.0404273756,
-0.068826966,
0.0313018896,
-0.0390068404,
0.0108231558,
-0.0184491072,
0.059520293,
0.0276008733,
0.0163467042,
-0.0260172728,
-0.0071919514,
0.0376026817,
0.0215031467,
-0.0220272671,
-0.0092036771,
-6.441162438e-33,
-0.0281256177,
-0.0224227719,
-0.0132884197,
0.0138342306,
-0.0574337952,
0.0393823124,
-0.0764378533,
-0.0055676415,
0.0150331017,
0.0081238365,
-0.0240202062,
0.0106311785,
-0.004997768,
0.0491770171,
-0.0000276079,
-0.0095820073,
0.0329053365,
0.0115897767,
-0.0136040878,
0.0605599582,
0.0389137231,
0.0127047775,
0.0368260443,
-0.0418694057,
-0.0115989055,
0.007503232,
-0.00183269,
-0.008183917,
0.0349403284,
0.0496544279,
-0.0154101755,
0.0212007202,
0.0545728542,
-0.0561347045,
-0.0558891855,
0.0443217568,
-0.0868186504,
-0.0127167553,
0.0085709775,
-0.0500549562,
-0.0407378227,
-0.0500576012,
0.0694144443,
0.0069447346,
0.0591855906,
-0.0712731928,
0.0300145131,
-0.0340419486,
-0.0586731285,
-0.0569302253,
-0.0511565022,
0.0352396294,
-0.0335619785,
-0.0295079071,
0.026055593,
0.0429722741,
0.0151082445,
0.0682992339,
-0.0102954004,
0.0047343215,
0.0081728892,
0.0654214174,
0.0531845167,
0.0214384049,
0.0181167331,
0.0329056233,
0.0110693974,
-0.0039897761,
-0.0485695228,
-0.0331416763,
-0.0110691655,
0.0361891165,
0.0341518521,
0.0072744424,
0.0276699793,
0.0504442155,
-0.061307475,
0.0279652663,
-0.0565488078,
0.0860275179,
0.0226393584,
0.0243165251,
0.0183917116,
0.0024863449,
-0.026057519,
0.0254101083,
-0.0402965099,
0.0333402902,
-0.0051670074,
0.0298360083,
-0.0318002701,
-0.0002969949,
0.0319167487,
-0.0167055484,
0.0217510313,
0.0405837223,
-0.0115882847,
0.0389148965,
0.0227992684,
-0.0022959684,
-0.0170754604,
0.0310001336,
0.0248046629,
-0.0107510583,
-0.0044798166,
-0.004758724,
0.0450918935,
0.006475877,
-0.0602886826,
-0.0395385884,
-0.0175960399,
0.0070226099,
-0.0690071061,
0.0480553098,
0.0249108244,
0.0053789783,
-0.0094496645,
0.0886030197,
0.0028448582,
0.0116264699,
-0.0096449051,
0.0140393777,
0.0142821642,
0.0359266475,
-0.0211552177,
-0.0060740327,
-0.0527935475,
0.0367593728,
0.0443241373,
-0.0792775601,
-0.0272917505,
0.0230016243,
2.725e-7,
0.0294030979,
0.0347762145,
0.0642084107,
-0.0227120444,
0.0267992076,
0.0263721086,
0.0169019569,
0.0464093648,
0.0089851748,
-0.0076783709,
0.0028341459,
0.0255575329,
0.0099430084,
0.0064327987,
-0.0908826068,
0.0120656742,
-0.0847936049,
-0.0199471321,
-0.0119024953,
-0.0275040455,
0.017039923,
0.1142252833,
-0.0249301866,
0.0057705143,
0.0118819661,
-0.0077957613,
0.0331187285,
0.0002760205,
-0.0093191732,
0.0145708807,
-0.0158937778,
-0.004031322,
-0.0072813313,
-0.0237290524,
0.004500201,
0.020310333,
0.0413593426,
0.0697707757,
-0.007310899,
-0.0420307256,
0.036290817,
-0.0134111336,
0.0097344927,
-0.0460451394,
0.057852,
-0.089319706,
-0.0086730355,
-0.0160525665,
-0.0336951129,
0.0466219895,
-0.0548652858,
0.0312147848,
-0.0298320688,
0.0408076458,
0.0016685856,
-0.0035997273,
-0.0233786181,
-0.1169617474,
-0.0333119594,
-0.009769477,
-0.0287247058,
-0.0010008005,
-0.0640688837,
-0.0420073755,
0.0274222922,
-0.0173694156,
-0.0229106601,
2.921458636e-34,
0.0577037744,
-0.0169415642,
-0.0331741348,
0.0009945922,
0.0034983673,
-0.0434267893,
-0.0310043339,
0.0009171459,
0.0228950679,
-0.0975882933,
-0.0432165302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07099v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07099v1 | Explanation-aware Soft Ensemble Empowers Large Language Model In-context Learning | 2023-11-13T06:13:38 | 2023-11-13T06:13:38 | Yue Yu, Jiaming Shen, Tianqi Liu, Zhen Qin, Jing Nathan Yan, Jialu Liu, Chao Zhang, Michael Bendersky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in various
natural language understanding tasks. With only a few demonstration examples,
these LLMs can quickly adapt to target tasks without expensive gradient
updates. Common strategies to boost such 'in-context' learning ability are to
ensemble multiple model decoded results and require the model to generate an
explanation along with the prediction. However, these models often treat
different class predictions equally and neglect the potential discrepancy
between the explanations and predictions. To fully unleash the power of
explanations, we propose EASE, an Explanation-Aware Soft Ensemble framework to
empower in-context learning with LLMs. We design two techniques,
explanation-guided ensemble, and soft probability aggregation, to mitigate the
effect of unreliable explanations and improve the consistency between
explanations and final predictions. Experiments on seven natural language
understanding tasks and four varying-size LLMs demonstrate the effectiveness of
our proposed framework. | [
0.0029042766,
0.0460396074,
0.0034428912,
0.0508559495,
0.0274109393,
0.0362007059,
0.0059344741,
-0.0535488091,
-0.0457694679,
-0.0367349759,
0.0208745394,
-0.0416421033,
0.0241317172,
-0.0009599753,
0.0232845098,
-0.043937508,
0.0175628122,
-0.0317437723,
-0.0259297937,
0.0155002922,
-0.0006111245,
0.0353655964,
-0.0083012432,
0.0699788854,
0.0678340644,
-0.0179053675,
-0.0368256643,
0.0048045255,
-0.0056738951,
-0.0065391138,
-0.002339056,
0.0441935845,
0.0762261748,
0.0108117834,
0.0000018893,
-0.0435250513,
-0.0443617031,
0.0142293172,
-0.0810562819,
-0.0011510507,
-0.0523341857,
-0.0294526126,
0.023370361,
0.017149834,
0.0160048828,
-0.0149775827,
0.0710211247,
0.0359874032,
0.0301411599,
0.0543696359,
0.026759183,
-0.0298936199,
-0.0312053151,
-0.0275230706,
0.0271451212,
-0.0668579862,
0.003076877,
-0.0208035912,
-0.0266589504,
-0.0100171547,
-0.009984714,
-0.0003994203,
0.0185782332,
-0.0175803658,
0.0343694128,
0.0448256806,
-0.0051230588,
-0.0279164985,
-0.0240261424,
0.0559579134,
-0.0155991167,
-0.0061547714,
-0.0151213584,
-0.0234891437,
-0.0047100619,
0.0015499509,
-0.0445858389,
0.0208313428,
-0.0231659692,
0.0379173942,
0.0014653498,
0.0143940998,
0.0813392326,
0.0605311804,
-0.0405098833,
0.0505541265,
-0.031758476,
0.0292523652,
-0.0272757225,
0.0203245822,
-0.0537784062,
-0.0373757817,
-0.0114456927,
0.0669578016,
-0.0634235889,
0.0328870527,
-0.0011372478,
-0.022245435,
-0.0022166958,
-0.004273654,
0.0611950569,
0.0439523906,
-0.0067956541,
0.084981516,
-0.0111783789,
0.0340180323,
0.002704392,
-0.0304757226,
-0.0473587587,
-0.037580438,
-0.046865236,
-0.0185266268,
-0.0107586067,
0.0128979711,
-0.0466962121,
-0.0077368543,
-0.0343744867,
0.0294537861,
-0.0176644493,
0.0197580662,
0.0217571799,
0.0193030257,
-0.0495722666,
-0.0417831354,
-0.020662101,
0.0509432442,
-0.0173171461,
0.0312458538,
0.0234331042,
-0.0362188853,
-0.0391918421,
-0.0102865193,
0.0122188125,
-0.0093369419,
-0.0139562273,
0.0294956993,
-0.0198905505,
-0.0208227914,
-0.0215373393,
-0.0376934074,
-0.010283608,
-0.0606992617,
-0.0451779738,
-0.0253092851,
0.0413057916,
0.0108180055,
0.0188486949,
-0.0337220281,
0.0091269147,
-0.0122460183,
-0.0185574796,
0.1179911271,
-0.0022841222,
0.0252774693,
0.0130696064,
0.0271058064,
-0.035000816,
0.0841914564,
-0.0203793645,
0.0049981209,
0.0086156074,
-0.0269100089,
0.0419710726,
-0.0018903054,
0.0282412767,
-0.0207954086,
0.0094138309,
0.0107998848,
0.0029365674,
0.0314185359,
0.0292791761,
0.0042901677,
-0.0236324426,
0.0158616509,
0.0471882746,
0.0065949075,
0.0239944011,
0.0211202465,
-0.001406191,
-0.0074520768,
-0.0092801405,
0.0026055733,
-0.0809240267,
0.0493887253,
-0.0549015105,
0.0048076473,
0.0355198868,
0.0199691318,
-0.0134057561,
-0.061342489,
-0.0219582226,
-0.021586867,
-0.0085952869,
0.0645920336,
0.0713952184,
-0.0130110523,
-0.0378387682,
0.0283484086,
0.0526071377,
-0.0072863116,
0.0055836178,
-0.05469919,
0.0860884041,
0.0913086832,
0.0251139384,
-0.0452549793,
-0.0114014903,
-0.0232558046,
0.0140990252,
-0.0021473041,
0.0155955441,
-0.0272431578,
0.0627792776,
-0.0484547392,
-0.0434524678,
-0.0042139366,
0.0249065235,
0.0031749893,
0.0097621353,
-0.0270595532,
0.0116600906,
-0.0257966518,
-0.0230779275,
0.0330052674,
-0.0060071805,
-0.0414790735,
0.0321405306,
0.0044592107,
0.0317054093,
0.0042563248,
-0.0097624371,
-0.0046322062,
0.0086868135,
-0.0199426338,
-0.0403077975,
0.0089909155,
-0.0635833368,
-0.0739062801,
0.0073252125,
0.0380983613,
-0.0361368284,
-0.0542222708,
-0.0609595329,
-0.033037886,
0.0015834472,
-0.0276154671,
0.0368787944,
-0.0457802042,
0.0015260234,
-0.0121991411,
0.0334465168,
-0.0407074504,
0.0507959872,
0.0103722671,
-0.0157373995,
-0.0077809477,
-0.0103653856,
-0.0158420019,
0.0109511092,
0.0043300358,
0.0375602804,
-0.0039323908,
0.0015171812,
0.0053269845,
-0.0439444035,
-0.0502336696,
-0.0097518116,
-0.0792379454,
-0.0009060824,
-0.0296361186,
-0.0278470386,
0.0173044596,
0.0263204947,
0.0092886295,
-0.021509422,
0.0032183549,
0.006943346,
0.0052080853,
0.0084572006,
0.0107947374,
0.024840856,
-0.0410351269,
-0.0221947357,
0.0093311798,
-0.0045305579,
0.0683786348,
0.0002299679,
-0.0290900804,
-0.0851047859,
-0.0179197118,
-0.0293411352,
-0.0114514763,
-0.032306999,
-0.0159870982,
-0.0026249643,
-0.0392273515,
-0.007470239,
0.0684291869,
-0.0001324404,
0.0711906031,
0.0687281787,
-0.004379645,
-0.0589095429,
0.0101732491,
-0.0381514058,
-0.0390414707,
-0.0308152717,
0.0036919196,
-0.0416383184,
0.0562752858,
0.0057810373,
-0.0178539809,
-0.0459737144,
-0.0056568449,
0.0036040386,
-0.0220616069,
-0.0610303469,
-0.0381142199,
0.0321045406,
0.0164842047,
-0.0313841216,
-0.0472389832,
0.0935550854,
-0.0133992862,
-0.0223879181,
-0.0490447655,
-0.0385309458,
-0.0317263976,
0.0772667378,
-0.0307135377,
0.0154818716,
0.0418380499,
-0.0233957935,
-0.0210110974,
-0.0579716302,
0.0263177566,
-0.0247346256,
0.0736365467,
-0.050719101,
0.0052653472,
0.0004766776,
-0.0128846569,
-0.0379130282,
-0.0714655071,
-0.0373857729,
0.0160147976,
-0.0209069271,
-0.0312478747,
-0.0456953533,
0.0022493401,
0.0499681681,
-0.0032183521,
-0.0158767998,
-0.0173412487,
-0.0045511872,
0.0143400151,
0.0173721835,
0.0525384769,
0.0276217144,
-0.0571783148,
0.0623336397,
0.0225459784,
0.020744808,
0.0118715018,
-0.044340577,
-0.0134127159,
0.0128662745,
-0.0011435041,
-0.0065222532,
0.0332454219,
0.058974959,
-0.101304628,
0.0039915759,
0.1378819048,
0.0174501427,
-0.0477604829,
-0.0010316992,
0.0032822248,
0.0194774885,
0.0203861464,
0.0196462777,
-0.0176291764,
-0.072781302,
0.0169553366,
0.0212983955,
0.0225597806,
-0.015481662,
-0.0182891395,
-0.0617901757,
0.0196621194,
0.0248714294,
-0.0437331311,
-0.0324355029,
-0.0724423528,
0.0195500124,
-0.0043658107,
0.0319320112,
0.0125597008,
0.0465508848,
0.0197798815,
0.0497110933,
-0.0025874279,
-0.0695586652,
0.0074219112,
-0.0489202291,
0.0486929193,
0.0968944132,
0.0226112232,
-0.0040631373,
0.0162985735,
0.0049904766,
-0.0308847707,
0.0359157287,
-0.0014740808,
0.0572392903,
0.0252026152,
-0.0147165973,
-0.0046704668,
0.0658200756,
-0.0538371429,
-0.005915341,
0.002247096,
0.0689547136,
-0.0440153889,
-0.0437454432,
0.0190278087,
-0.0634506866,
0.0404638909,
0.0885349587,
0.0164307579,
-0.0198013633,
-0.0048476649,
-0.0446793362,
-0.0413438901,
-0.0025117269,
0.0384976342,
0.0198282413,
0.0307194125,
-0.0218581557,
-0.0093885735,
-0.0391355567,
0.0505166762,
0.0257354677,
0.0097899679,
0.0535189025,
0.016078325,
0.0334150568,
-0.0350130349,
0.0304192379,
0.0058936747,
0.045139946,
0.0262388214,
-0.0329166353,
0.0532811992,
-0.0110803088,
-0.0001740707,
0.0225715097,
-0.0286282953,
-0.0571367778,
-0.0008881984,
-0.0107650394,
0.0166653302,
0.0726264119,
-0.0047134068,
-0.0841292292,
0.0657325312,
0.0501774065,
0.0134451948,
0.0165773015,
0.0147975441,
-0.008246704,
0.0033770273,
0.0486390144,
-0.0379177965,
-0.0174573865,
-0.0106009366,
0.0215663649,
-0.0293840691,
-0.0006517307,
0.0301813222,
-0.0461772941,
0.0071138605,
-0.0399298072,
-0.0367762782,
-0.0106289797,
0.0144380778,
0.0138838477,
-0.0502914004,
-0.0203858111,
0.0076015107,
0.0432552025,
-0.0653609112,
0.0157547202,
0.02138827,
0.0400578156,
0.0157932062,
-0.0183353182,
0.033404313,
0.0338547006,
-0.015732808,
0.0343731046,
0.0252510868,
-0.0162016265,
0.0106746238,
-0.0024274979,
0.0391416997,
0.0053222072,
0.0514601804,
0.0260220673,
-0.0082438355,
-0.0416130088,
-0.0094076758,
-0.077646099,
-0.0500809923,
-0.0154809486,
0.0532556549,
0.034763284,
-0.0094087059,
0.0409088656,
0.0021388095,
-0.0128997453,
-0.0207485836,
0.0422742069,
-0.0105537269,
-0.0113100251,
0.0383856632,
0.0223334227,
-0.0195428114,
0.0016055637,
0.0843643323,
-0.019935688,
0.0415111445,
0.0086273579,
-0.0161568131,
-0.0155324629,
-0.0035477055,
0.0166679546,
0.0555225536,
-0.0184335802,
0.038427081,
0.0096072601,
-0.0531197526,
-0.0231031589,
-0.0276350807,
-0.0144983828,
-0.0326083861,
-0.0109730978,
0.0659815073,
-0.0138232429,
-0.0164407101,
-0.0317107663,
0.0317426212,
-0.0482070781,
0.0301665347,
-0.0115571227,
-6.301594524e-33,
-0.0342561901,
-0.043074023,
-0.0079864571,
-0.0602692999,
0.017033672,
0.0259792134,
-0.0490038879,
-0.0145035265,
-0.0133275846,
0.0363457575,
-0.0102554932,
0.04661192,
0.0068737245,
0.0449272767,
0.0037053686,
-0.0320453234,
0.0461667478,
0.0215712078,
-0.0223544128,
0.036728248,
0.0600399338,
0.0295038726,
0.0554585308,
-0.0690460131,
0.0303216185,
0.028062081,
-0.0456622913,
0.0133813787,
-0.016111901,
0.0445944332,
-0.0129051199,
0.0344584212,
0.017423654,
-0.0261551756,
-0.0352779292,
0.0332592055,
-0.064218685,
0.011545172,
0.0280135144,
0.029137576,
-0.0039556683,
-0.0149973892,
0.0262283497,
0.010811788,
0.0478433631,
-0.0483054779,
0.0190352201,
-0.0373116955,
-0.014263236,
-0.0431013741,
-0.0025356631,
0.0292934179,
-0.0357291847,
-0.0421070307,
0.0090905,
-0.0152879711,
0.0095852073,
0.0410910845,
-0.0381470174,
-0.0325374119,
0.0085184453,
0.0249058027,
0.0590872243,
0.0459879078,
-0.0154676121,
0.0431745313,
-0.0133743687,
-0.0175901912,
-0.0745789856,
-0.044486668,
-0.0143979648,
0.0343389101,
0.0555360802,
0.0312147718,
0.0614675283,
0.0586929992,
-0.0642167479,
0.0424710251,
0.0262850747,
-0.0085605867,
0.0566226244,
0.0393752381,
-0.0359514058,
-0.0313066281,
-0.0659708604,
-0.0013476147,
-0.0379118137,
0.0061959326,
0.0196367316,
0.0116641819,
-0.0392431132,
0.010254086,
0.0235073324,
-0.0773330256,
-0.0447744168,
0.0355187654,
0.0074523841,
-0.0240131319,
0.0081091365,
0.0016667208,
-0.0162293706,
-0.0044020619,
0.0019644834,
0.0020806168,
-0.0059713102,
0.0042925328,
0.0563963652,
0.0244764294,
-0.0440585203,
-0.0164416227,
-0.056630753,
-0.0271525607,
-0.0260131378,
0.012092025,
0.0249848757,
0.0374156907,
-0.0377613232,
0.0181221589,
0.0117382305,
0.0121842623,
-0.001427362,
0.0047482508,
-0.0174833741,
0.0158083662,
-0.0174129046,
-0.0284891073,
-0.0062906351,
-0.0746417791,
0.0834244937,
-0.0285652634,
-0.0141484011,
0.0232562181,
2.521e-7,
0.0280604325,
0.025046749,
-0.0089780428,
-0.0155404955,
0.0255031753,
0.0675479546,
-0.0142032979,
-0.0188760869,
0.0028909568,
-0.0470765345,
0.0233069956,
0.0545390137,
0.0340506136,
0.0239003319,
-0.0392863639,
-0.0132889338,
-0.0097920401,
0.0014800773,
-0.0431849025,
-0.0101203183,
0.0419668816,
0.1274861544,
0.0348512307,
-0.0081926482,
0.038020432,
-0.0367011763,
0.045587346,
-0.0154755022,
0.0426575877,
0.0244072955,
0.0142090842,
0.0106060905,
0.0165984891,
0.0261921734,
-0.0103758723,
0.0129593797,
-0.0158610307,
0.0435515009,
-0.0298627447,
0.0037707912,
-0.0478707328,
-0.0183581226,
0.0496037044,
-0.0665327311,
0.0720001236,
-0.067784138,
-0.0313818529,
-0.0412788205,
0.0036701048,
-0.0434777029,
-0.0079075042,
0.025853496,
0.0162573289,
0.0370884463,
-0.0285846889,
-0.0348164327,
-0.0056734178,
-0.1260695606,
-0.065413177,
0.0028179488,
-0.0466891602,
-0.0126979332,
-0.0064661484,
-0.0153569998,
0.0430841036,
-0.0783622339,
0.0011323709,
2.220451891e-34,
0.0044360533,
0.0220432207,
0.0004544196,
0.068467319,
0.0381838009,
-0.0028581745,
-0.0186531916,
-0.0159335565,
0.0453286283,
-0.0684091896,
-0.0016408111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07093v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07093v2 | On the Effectiveness of ASR Representations in Real-world Noisy Speech Emotion Recognition | 2023-11-13T05:45:55 | 2023-11-14T13:09:51 | Xiaohan Shi, Jiajun He, Xingfeng Li, Tomoki Toda | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | This paper proposes an efficient attempt to noisy speech emotion recognition
(NSER). Conventional NSER approaches have proven effective in mitigating the
impact of artificial noise sources, such as white Gaussian noise, but are
limited to non-stationary noises in real-world environments due to their
complexity and uncertainty. To overcome this limitation, we introduce a new
method for NSER by adopting the automatic speech recognition (ASR) model as a
noise-robust feature extractor to eliminate non-vocal information in noisy
speech. We first obtain intermediate layer information from the ASR model as a
feature representation for emotional speech and then apply this representation
for the downstream NSER task. Our experimental results show that 1) the
proposed method achieves better NSER performance compared with the conventional
noise reduction method, 2) outperforms self-supervised learning approaches, and
3) even outperforms text-based approaches using ASR transcription or the ground
truth transcription of noisy speech. | [
-0.008768592,
0.0550070331,
0.0026476181,
0.0392741151,
0.0218235403,
0.0182217192,
0.0371294245,
-0.0287831351,
0.0299853217,
-0.0291079748,
-0.0585246757,
-0.0035902113,
-0.0198789127,
0.0030931446,
-0.0187731292,
-0.0640042201,
-0.0335339084,
-0.0202139523,
0.0769125447,
-0.0296792276,
0.0241189394,
0.0256589707,
-0.0186172761,
-0.0002953965,
-0.0508573502,
0.0232480559,
-0.0184295271,
0.0053342241,
0.0219729804,
-0.0139675569,
-0.0044025532,
-0.0038776444,
0.0384327359,
-0.0210261922,
0.0000021893,
-0.0072096465,
-0.0140878921,
0.0362802222,
-0.063214764,
-0.022290282,
0.064154759,
0.0352354906,
-0.0230691098,
-0.007827674,
0.0029816085,
-0.0024634115,
0.0244546123,
0.0830775499,
0.052068416,
0.0318829417,
-0.024373522,
-0.0002275252,
-0.0098812189,
0.0240817964,
0.0119931353,
-0.04412641,
-0.0233355854,
-0.0272976235,
-0.0058912211,
-0.0501466021,
-0.0160328597,
0.0187530722,
-0.02678564,
-0.0265249107,
0.0307820681,
-0.0089670401,
-0.0227557924,
-0.063550517,
-0.0231538303,
0.0447090939,
-0.0121249845,
0.0188564882,
0.0263035595,
-0.0135499993,
-0.0124213211,
-0.0122133223,
-0.0001921257,
0.0046368986,
-0.0029019963,
0.0056470861,
-0.0124488929,
0.067078419,
-0.0089073712,
-0.0049021561,
0.0221169777,
-0.0126811238,
-0.0493475199,
-0.0403450318,
0.0635385886,
-0.0371865146,
-0.0081661288,
0.0274195764,
0.0363553092,
-0.0112941796,
0.0188507531,
-0.0145059107,
-0.043860428,
-0.0435193665,
-0.0601136796,
-0.0725505799,
-0.0343446881,
-0.0052978117,
-0.074513793,
0.0211797338,
0.0199477375,
0.0271127,
0.0471881628,
-0.0384949595,
0.003697237,
0.0134903807,
-0.0033194369,
0.0483321287,
-0.0238603707,
0.096351251,
-0.048089534,
-0.0613823347,
-0.0485351831,
-0.0000955709,
-0.0708593279,
0.0262670591,
0.0272373725,
0.0137053961,
0.0032257356,
-0.0010727706,
0.0315915048,
-0.0172771085,
0.0313868187,
0.0402661227,
-0.0147162322,
-0.04661474,
0.0135252178,
0.0143756019,
0.0701549724,
-0.0083934264,
0.0500377342,
0.0739020035,
0.0250572003,
-0.0128520047,
-0.0376155339,
0.0389952511,
-0.0148684001,
-0.0451856926,
-0.0135480845,
0.010313632,
0.0371805765,
-0.0321982652,
-0.0087410556,
-0.0372965075,
0.0157407895,
-0.0632766709,
-0.0059104264,
0.0562520437,
0.00108786,
-0.0263686962,
0.0558401272,
-0.0142309759,
0.0174870864,
0.0049719489,
0.0319747739,
0.0171427932,
0.0374290571,
-0.0472748689,
0.0446285382,
0.0265559778,
-0.0302937254,
-0.0633059293,
-0.0035792363,
-0.0403012149,
-0.0289934743,
-0.0228540935,
0.0507757552,
0.0401572175,
-0.0088327192,
-0.010415134,
0.0119350925,
0.0292380843,
-0.013083783,
0.0375891775,
-0.0396175981,
0.0535731465,
0.0529736541,
-0.0174658857,
-0.0099246027,
0.0305063277,
-0.0897836834,
-0.0012446208,
0.0129134664,
0.0234949086,
-0.0363890044,
-0.0412935466,
-0.0091281738,
-0.0351776965,
-0.0197991394,
0.1075592563,
0.0454130396,
-0.029522879,
-0.0312273726,
0.0155587867,
-0.010876948,
-0.0674025193,
0.0143127246,
-0.035158366,
0.0212599915,
0.03226557,
-0.0042170486,
-0.0801266506,
-0.048609104,
-0.0489165261,
-0.0496625863,
-0.0018474666,
-0.0386893339,
0.0118457554,
0.087114282,
-0.0982769504,
-0.0314559154,
0.0449699089,
0.0000335091,
0.019884821,
-0.0385693833,
0.0126359854,
0.0173605811,
0.0012626143,
-0.0153487166,
-0.0177979879,
-0.0097284727,
-0.066829443,
0.0253357701,
0.0109253172,
0.0730418563,
0.0355809033,
-0.0416092724,
-0.0426115207,
0.0385397077,
0.0048640608,
0.0057212804,
0.0402561389,
-0.0415659584,
-0.0042167748,
0.0508196652,
0.0268447902,
-0.002086797,
0.0416254513,
-0.0170954894,
-0.0351057947,
0.0625092238,
-0.0102904597,
-0.0096469829,
-0.0249871556,
0.0477133654,
0.0265980456,
0.0413144156,
0.0147021301,
-0.0228132308,
0.0352192968,
-0.033599142,
-0.0156071698,
0.0285895746,
-0.0131509136,
-0.0640716627,
-0.0609758198,
-0.0161624625,
-0.0148104504,
0.0364015847,
0.0152658829,
-0.0277053472,
-0.0051508173,
-0.0427924134,
-0.0427166447,
-0.0176303461,
-0.0119840987,
-0.0341954194,
-0.0152837178,
0.0273226369,
-0.0177072342,
-0.0081795901,
-0.0237198919,
0.0255190767,
0.007692344,
-0.0571911037,
-0.0585504882,
-0.0197562929,
-0.0010615006,
-0.0575489216,
0.0472107418,
0.0049423035,
-0.0314410254,
-0.0112468246,
-0.0879461467,
-0.0121254176,
0.0477384776,
0.0182737894,
0.0721501261,
-0.0110965306,
-0.0331146866,
-0.0261185728,
-0.0125927059,
-0.0044108629,
0.0174414515,
0.0058938684,
0.0684115514,
0.0173635408,
-0.0106411995,
-0.0322739407,
0.053860072,
0.0065850043,
0.0651150346,
0.0024765546,
0.0204817764,
-0.0432631671,
-0.005784208,
0.0366369337,
0.0366560668,
0.0013373345,
-0.022459859,
0.0149603374,
-0.0585576706,
-0.0434054919,
-0.0238749646,
-0.0261714067,
-0.004089403,
0.0253061876,
0.0238981284,
-0.0067437221,
-0.0205416698,
-0.0570108965,
-0.0476254113,
-0.0764682814,
-0.0051393234,
0.0321283899,
-0.0431072302,
-0.0111345556,
0.0087383492,
-0.0431200229,
0.0216709618,
-0.038838964,
-0.0271398947,
-0.0745752975,
-0.0117948344,
-0.0222669486,
-0.0192260798,
0.0605848655,
-0.0133077232,
-0.0269418173,
-0.0358853601,
-0.0385676362,
0.0072664358,
-0.0139395799,
-0.022791991,
0.031317614,
0.0037314598,
0.0365439355,
0.0102608185,
0.0187682454,
0.0104541667,
-0.0121460781,
0.0848367438,
0.0734818131,
0.0468038283,
0.0061781649,
0.0451006182,
0.0376048759,
0.0000952767,
0.0310796145,
-0.0173204262,
-0.0213567261,
0.0274140667,
0.011047571,
0.037532609,
0.028484419,
0.0003495399,
0.003876545,
-0.0211869534,
0.0440856032,
0.1245002151,
0.0311697349,
-0.0119692255,
-0.0089624254,
-0.042613335,
-0.044987645,
0.001744586,
0.0094765602,
0.0181013942,
-0.0107746627,
0.0341545083,
0.0310088992,
0.0064017195,
0.0181407165,
0.0252758097,
-0.0616557933,
0.0612150058,
0.0083597135,
0.0048357742,
-0.0591619909,
-0.01689649,
0.0208883565,
-0.0686177462,
0.0340004899,
-0.0685608163,
0.0256117377,
-0.0357007459,
0.0408766791,
-0.0748785734,
-0.0562105514,
0.0085832542,
-0.0173331872,
0.1016201004,
-0.0105929775,
0.0232942607,
-0.0550620072,
-0.0129432613,
0.0403413028,
0.053343799,
-0.0058004777,
-0.0111622596,
0.0391048007,
0.0392374508,
-0.0300178155,
-0.0042077643,
-0.0083897421,
0.0064013284,
0.0250473637,
0.021176042,
0.0402476825,
-0.0459040292,
-0.0271197911,
0.0070203035,
0.0221040398,
0.0354851745,
0.0489624515,
0.004061372,
-0.0324444883,
-0.0269281622,
0.0106729362,
0.0489351004,
0.0390106738,
-0.0578516759,
0.0060477038,
0.0030912298,
-0.06889534,
0.0054561947,
-0.0721228421,
-0.0030859963,
0.0332631059,
-0.006562456,
-0.0381354503,
0.0302367155,
0.020798726,
-0.0169084594,
-0.011639744,
0.0376037396,
-0.026436884,
-0.0123153366,
-0.0025263911,
0.036160253,
-0.0249267407,
-0.0141650457,
0.0000153874,
0.017094193,
-0.0584730543,
0.0780459419,
0.008787306,
0.0077873096,
0.0162039753,
-0.0003519972,
-0.0277896654,
0.0550791956,
0.028766701,
-0.0331334546,
-0.0139505211,
0.0866421238,
-0.0027684197,
-0.0325524323,
0.0137220267,
-0.036692474,
0.0668497607,
-0.018762676,
-0.0075001344,
-0.0522177555,
-0.036264699,
-0.0186995678,
0.0576851442,
0.0685514212,
0.0425762907,
-0.0398877114,
-0.0430674516,
0.0097707948,
-0.0149805974,
0.0418860577,
-0.0600771494,
-0.0195342321,
-0.003692759,
0.0418113284,
-0.0325200818,
-0.0220519118,
-0.017796943,
-0.0500041507,
0.0255746283,
0.0539712757,
0.0029525377,
0.0150668779,
-0.0167050697,
0.0417998359,
0.0097237565,
0.0573154502,
0.0782346129,
-0.0318907946,
0.0063349237,
-0.0176596418,
-0.0305393748,
-0.0268712528,
0.0124513255,
0.032943055,
-0.0013353422,
-0.0051820897,
-0.0385054424,
0.0295093209,
-0.0039318935,
-0.0501693226,
0.0309197437,
-0.0238606017,
0.0244270414,
-0.027089078,
-0.0065677669,
0.0086503252,
0.0065056859,
0.0206843317,
-0.0115970802,
-0.0203982629,
0.0019272064,
0.0143164713,
-0.0338050202,
0.0237265993,
-0.0112076811,
0.0199788231,
-0.0693372115,
-0.0047205966,
0.0196304135,
-0.049224779,
-0.0026953893,
0.0596884154,
0.0223932154,
-0.0626832023,
0.0404812992,
-0.0826074183,
0.009515726,
-0.0476910323,
0.0062421276,
0.009161748,
-0.045151934,
0.0777097642,
0.0165380687,
-0.0298114493,
-0.02968245,
-0.0254816059,
0.0054449555,
-6.257401079e-33,
0.0047083613,
0.0000355809,
-0.0317989588,
0.0099720545,
-0.0284760688,
0.040255934,
0.0052830651,
0.035577599,
0.0332267843,
0.0241542179,
-0.0259790681,
0.0090603307,
0.0272074174,
-0.0071321605,
-0.0068827793,
-0.0132436138,
0.0609441437,
-0.0162318274,
0.0415060967,
-0.0187738575,
0.019435754,
0.0577666536,
0.0430418141,
-0.1372022927,
-0.0278173946,
0.0436819233,
-0.0203736126,
-0.0625871345,
0.1019393578,
0.0044025257,
-0.0057442966,
0.0394446515,
-0.023574736,
-0.0035834571,
-0.0088499123,
-0.0312068462,
-0.0667410418,
-0.014943352,
-0.0344423652,
0.0475522317,
-0.0060458081,
-0.0259444769,
0.0561326295,
0.0198860001,
-0.0613979213,
-0.0431707092,
0.0153758656,
-0.0169842765,
0.0064238263,
-0.0445962399,
-0.0089488365,
0.0343515761,
-0.0262803435,
0.0082076965,
0.1171590164,
0.0144288875,
-0.0373681858,
-0.0449617468,
-0.0445357263,
-0.0244430192,
0.0165123995,
0.0075320737,
-0.0152542619,
-0.0193668138,
-0.0069006551,
0.0168712977,
0.0649453774,
-0.0511926301,
-0.0323689096,
0.0126953395,
0.02963043,
0.0527695566,
0.0131927021,
-0.002409619,
0.017551465,
-0.0118981386,
-0.0194944572,
0.0260489974,
0.0466728993,
0.0067853997,
0.0272457656,
0.0019190263,
-0.0496703871,
0.0168074723,
0.000438502,
-0.0086497217,
-0.0195839535,
-0.0046174843,
0.0409324244,
0.0041429838,
0.0066712685,
-0.0136477621,
-0.0095156394,
0.0109954104,
0.0450757034,
0.0582854114,
0.013592436,
0.0240464993,
0.0312055387,
0.0066767717,
0.0136395656,
-0.041317746,
0.0433378294,
0.0575526319,
0.0505010411,
-0.0197957009,
-0.0414828472,
0.0886054263,
-0.0290736221,
-0.0244424362,
0.0046782414,
0.0437329933,
0.0199077874,
-0.0058623049,
-0.0230201986,
-0.0066223708,
-0.0075169173,
-0.017360704,
-0.0194715429,
0.0709838942,
0.0027189329,
0.0314010903,
-0.0007180729,
0.0217027813,
-0.0622636676,
-0.0027176209,
0.0243490748,
-0.0525527112,
0.0059540365,
-0.0020496219,
0.0291705262,
-0.0243270099,
2.98e-7,
-0.1129552573,
0.0278056953,
0.0179475434,
-0.0514954962,
0.0027869311,
0.0302198809,
0.0122925462,
-0.0150289265,
0.0251605976,
0.0006449538,
0.061608769,
-0.0124481348,
0.0475395098,
0.038450934,
-0.0828711987,
-0.042282518,
-0.0129158432,
0.0138603942,
0.0457167029,
0.0487053059,
0.0590209477,
0.0815828964,
0.0273538977,
-0.0167206284,
0.0040165693,
0.0025691341,
-0.0003165443,
-0.0227892008,
0.0068278876,
-0.0163758658,
-0.008096694,
-0.0330818817,
-0.0118219396,
-0.0231585316,
-0.0104040978,
0.0245535206,
0.0332429148,
0.035796348,
-0.0066124247,
-0.0866506025,
0.0179532263,
0.0940367207,
0.00110834,
0.0454974882,
0.0276970081,
0.001499566,
-0.0275954343,
-0.0523574427,
-0.0521401726,
0.0131805157,
0.0088203773,
0.0019436264,
0.0100860437,
-0.0033338682,
-0.0089159962,
-0.036544878,
-0.0345611125,
-0.0769212767,
0.0285335574,
0.0196545329,
-0.0557280183,
0.0215653032,
-0.0005199126,
0.0349244662,
0.0261634942,
0.0042473925,
0.0220470317,
1.839819014e-34,
0.0320291556,
0.0152275432,
-0.0091963978,
0.0239170063,
0.0131626939,
-0.0017811698,
-0.0167029072,
-0.019463459,
0.0170528255,
-0.0375006124,
-0.0302983169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07092v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07092v3 | To Tell The Truth: Language of Deception and Language Models | 2023-11-13T05:40:11 | 2024-04-08T05:54:40 | Sanchaita Hazra, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text-based misinformation permeates online discourses, yet evidence of
people's ability to discern truth from such deceptive textual content is
scarce. We analyze a novel TV game show data where conversations in a
high-stake environment between individuals with conflicting objectives result
in lies. We investigate the manifestation of potentially verifiable language
cues of deception in the presence of objective truth, a distinguishing feature
absent in previous text-based deception datasets. We show that there exists a
class of detectors (algorithms) that have similar truth detection performance
compared to human subjects, even when the former accesses only the language
cues while the latter engages in conversations with complete access to all
potential sources of cues (language and audio-visual). Our model, built on a
large language model, employs a bottleneck framework to learn discernible cues
to determine truth, an act of reasoning in which human subjects often perform
poorly, even with incentives. Our model detects novel but accurate language
cues in many cases where humans failed to detect deception, opening up the
possibility of humans collaborating with algorithms and ameliorating their
ability to detect the truth. | [
0.0741562992,
0.0675549135,
-0.0409502052,
0.0395930596,
-0.0768654123,
0.0141981514,
0.016337024,
0.0392775051,
0.0203525089,
-0.039269343,
-0.0047316425,
-0.0035997168,
0.0363085791,
0.0454785489,
0.0340378024,
-0.0021338458,
0.0348617956,
-0.0186910592,
0.106965363,
-0.0283991452,
0.0531433709,
0.027194228,
-0.0094065806,
0.0019516327,
-0.0619113185,
-0.0071986667,
0.0297186524,
-0.0166554544,
0.0135611659,
0.0207954608,
-0.0154209379,
0.0789376497,
0.0362450741,
0.067177996,
0.0000018487,
-0.0250999108,
0.0091327066,
-0.0375429615,
-0.0883107185,
0.0211877432,
0.0487770848,
-0.0375132822,
0.0060767503,
0.0140451891,
-0.0415917784,
0.027563544,
0.0433372222,
0.0302926973,
0.0703346655,
0.0956592485,
-0.0002273711,
0.0212673154,
0.0084097357,
-0.0190806016,
-0.0069071362,
-0.0467050932,
0.0260314755,
-0.0094626732,
-0.0461922549,
-0.0039300565,
0.0056092525,
-0.0102282101,
-0.011456375,
-0.0199758299,
-0.0416951962,
0.0445880517,
-0.0545628108,
-0.023491405,
-0.0083423117,
0.0319446288,
0.0262046121,
-0.0350796692,
0.0190027151,
0.0020497181,
-0.0016799408,
0.0267602336,
0.0147916386,
0.0726340488,
-0.0372712426,
-0.0153162619,
-0.0202094726,
-0.0037229022,
0.0264247209,
0.0263407249,
0.0780097321,
0.0541012064,
-0.0211107489,
0.0006975533,
0.0004834306,
0.0020841029,
-0.0090441229,
-0.0766831636,
-0.0136110503,
0.0012231624,
-0.0523234233,
0.0315804146,
-0.0597274899,
0.0100853909,
0.0420286544,
-0.0795131922,
0.0046515786,
-0.013542546,
0.0306042973,
0.0339809209,
0.0151440213,
0.0522209257,
-0.0316652246,
0.0193027407,
-0.0142146563,
-0.0144571383,
0.0313670225,
-0.0037038988,
-0.0007863995,
0.0101828882,
0.0111631295,
-0.0090746563,
-0.045180358,
-0.0257752258,
-0.0674165189,
0.0351798125,
-0.0157337505,
0.0008362239,
-0.0096547483,
-0.0242327061,
-0.0447187535,
0.0334430002,
-0.0202764999,
0.0461379886,
-0.0010343428,
-0.0673140958,
-0.0139221838,
0.010953987,
0.0006891534,
0.0057694074,
0.0177947041,
0.0028315161,
-0.0108309863,
0.00121423,
0.0046563637,
-0.0178919602,
-0.0334366001,
-0.0591810048,
-0.0259669311,
-0.0526278317,
0.0426408537,
0.0001589343,
-0.0186397899,
-0.0181609336,
0.0130881499,
0.0353114791,
-0.0512015894,
0.0508468635,
-0.0143869063,
0.0243373569,
0.0455949679,
0.0442424007,
-0.0538354702,
0.0607882366,
0.0151809445,
0.0847160965,
0.0683986247,
0.0073104077,
0.0383618362,
0.0281508919,
0.0326598585,
0.0303347632,
0.0233858097,
-0.003942119,
0.0119352536,
0.0324666686,
0.0098948805,
0.0184383988,
-0.0456223711,
-0.0493086651,
0.1168480814,
0.0190650858,
-0.017644804,
-0.0245390162,
0.0055487291,
0.0358903073,
-0.0007690872,
0.012394717,
-0.0180479921,
0.0280884523,
-0.0570921376,
-0.0235444866,
-0.0101010408,
0.0203562602,
0.0028500198,
-0.0028226797,
-0.0167854298,
-0.0101824626,
0.011120636,
0.0544351377,
-0.0150156086,
-0.02073415,
-0.0564931743,
0.0307618678,
0.0582535118,
-0.0103329839,
-0.0015545518,
-0.0688360259,
0.0320041291,
0.0303633586,
0.0264274459,
0.0444085412,
0.0574836843,
-0.0565240234,
0.0381702371,
0.038848225,
0.0461888984,
-0.0022936885,
-0.0180936642,
0.0153742554,
-0.0037605285,
-0.010985096,
0.017689012,
0.030741021,
-0.0127136596,
0.005538323,
-0.0170941353,
-0.0253627077,
0.0538437963,
0.0356012061,
0.0047883941,
0.0188379921,
-0.0315669365,
0.0160934925,
0.0095740445,
-0.0273842737,
-0.0157361478,
-0.0243205745,
0.0110505549,
-0.0029403497,
-0.0209352132,
-0.0272582006,
-0.0140593303,
-0.003421413,
0.0052214796,
-0.0430409871,
-0.0386966802,
0.0293679088,
0.0243749619,
0.0290742628,
0.0330194272,
-0.058132194,
-0.009264539,
-0.0266215187,
-0.0145158172,
-0.0412395038,
0.0148646683,
0.0222497284,
0.0865888819,
-0.0397347696,
0.0221540034,
-0.0351101421,
-0.0614693575,
-0.0023127426,
-0.0408850014,
0.0484661199,
-0.0007310502,
0.01835558,
0.0142372018,
0.0453513861,
-0.0069948924,
-0.0189643763,
-0.0405293293,
-0.091158852,
-0.0347332954,
0.0011512523,
-0.0237340387,
0.011054161,
-0.0410522297,
0.000914458,
0.0421354398,
-0.0229337234,
-0.0009849495,
0.0002492306,
0.0060441745,
-0.0050275824,
-0.0202290975,
-0.0047212681,
0.0107623367,
0.0152495028,
-0.0201610662,
0.0467351489,
0.0348118059,
-0.0358007699,
-0.0470420197,
-0.0079073915,
-0.0652842373,
0.0391663499,
-0.0243108291,
-0.0340642557,
-0.0069827246,
0.0321879461,
-0.0307134744,
0.0581795201,
0.06510818,
0.052099321,
0.0268973187,
0.0002917937,
-0.0162099358,
-0.0154415304,
-0.0152435172,
0.0291653425,
-0.0558164641,
-0.0822834522,
0.0297754928,
0.0497932397,
0.0354207717,
0.0077977097,
-0.0309394635,
0.0538088605,
-0.0034302245,
-0.0493621491,
-0.002521208,
-0.0749367326,
-0.0244265199,
0.0568628535,
-0.0241194237,
-0.043390885,
0.093785882,
-0.0245981645,
0.0353216007,
0.0169293173,
-0.0183181148,
0.0069935215,
0.0194678567,
0.0087946123,
0.0330690779,
0.050381925,
0.000641356,
-0.0327359661,
-0.0300461575,
0.1023404449,
-0.0515417047,
-0.0059551871,
-0.0472803563,
0.0172033403,
0.0355723202,
-0.0410990268,
-0.0523116961,
-0.0895986855,
-0.031626489,
-0.0403298549,
0.0041336282,
-0.0153084071,
-0.0876706317,
-0.0547712222,
0.0137589695,
-0.0109730475,
0.0305259209,
0.0046602818,
0.0088575408,
0.0092834178,
0.0609903969,
-0.0016648291,
0.0492009111,
-0.0597464964,
-0.0110897673,
0.0646385849,
-0.0311799403,
0.011579195,
0.0176643617,
-0.0104199508,
0.0259263348,
0.0263258684,
0.0019856007,
0.0321193524,
-0.0111586051,
-0.0132918423,
-0.0007479212,
0.0891822428,
0.0016996431,
-0.0161379874,
-0.003900202,
0.0185085461,
0.0091389166,
0.015423188,
-0.0319692828,
-0.1143002808,
-0.0162232593,
0.0028579608,
-0.0143155092,
-0.0576031953,
-0.0393078625,
-0.0414979681,
-0.0763496235,
0.0178063046,
-0.0028207705,
-0.0114288721,
-0.0198505707,
-0.0325618088,
-0.0191579461,
-0.0099532977,
0.0063666888,
-0.0279907715,
0.0671932995,
-0.015209185,
-0.0346128903,
0.0016056874,
0.0153467609,
0.04102505,
-0.0204263255,
0.0907540992,
0.0035405708,
0.0781472698,
-0.0169655401,
-0.1048210636,
-0.0104179597,
0.0326259509,
-0.0501307659,
0.0020955852,
0.0670858622,
-0.0367623083,
0.0091042342,
-0.0265020467,
0.0083554378,
0.0150374761,
-0.0246326178,
-0.0106945541,
0.0356300063,
0.0400030985,
-0.0858904645,
0.0223067794,
0.0102798818,
0.0545719154,
0.0409846455,
-0.0202275328,
-0.0183802079,
-0.0120908972,
0.0001096161,
0.0122626917,
0.0040291823,
-0.0590956435,
0.0117305722,
0.0517353527,
-0.0027345016,
-0.0486775897,
0.0182293374,
-0.0306094289,
-0.0011679057,
-0.0099957185,
-0.0180372931,
0.0248188078,
0.0246733408,
-0.0033289061,
-0.0009021469,
-0.0542836562,
0.0545540191,
-0.0177207272,
-0.0221989285,
-0.0450129099,
-0.0594564974,
0.0069813146,
0.0362031795,
-0.0618892945,
-0.0171147995,
0.0167694017,
-0.0077222753,
0.0234504864,
0.0448298007,
-0.0115098814,
-0.0082570808,
-0.0203826036,
-0.0190034062,
-0.0881281048,
0.0391970985,
0.0053084912,
-0.0120550282,
0.0217181668,
0.0147622582,
0.0023216086,
0.0375940651,
0.0282627996,
-0.0080175977,
-0.0667280257,
-0.0175320674,
0.0572287217,
0.000810748,
0.0163697712,
-0.0025941213,
0.008988902,
-0.0399950109,
-0.0313758776,
0.0029279911,
-0.003805914,
-0.0027756514,
-0.0286144987,
0.0146028856,
0.005922575,
0.0065006549,
-0.0118111987,
-0.0233280528,
-0.0007123341,
-0.0374854729,
-0.0314809233,
0.0434655771,
0.0044741752,
-0.0015881279,
-0.0266971327,
0.029080471,
0.057192456,
-0.0221480448,
0.053139735,
0.0201639216,
0.0456555821,
0.0359526277,
-0.0695082769,
0.0161898024,
-0.021836536,
-0.0234314781,
0.0025619161,
0.0201841351,
0.0212195367,
0.0268869121,
0.0030214754,
-0.0131069776,
-0.0082972161,
-0.0141574992,
0.0158060268,
-0.0225712545,
-0.0442741662,
-0.067700699,
0.0081840772,
0.0175315309,
-0.0402291119,
0.0303410068,
0.0474670269,
0.0114321345,
0.0162503496,
-0.0053317258,
-0.0456589051,
-0.0096661989,
-0.0361089744,
0.0053096819,
0.0318696871,
-0.007184362,
0.0369603112,
-0.0962529406,
-0.0379413441,
-0.0258322619,
0.0106717097,
0.0446890034,
0.0006758033,
-0.0071206014,
0.0732641295,
-0.0063156825,
-0.0080278069,
-0.0568283498,
0.0425947569,
0.0068505928,
-0.0010518668,
-0.0101088481,
-6.111490271e-33,
0.0101789543,
-0.0778070986,
-0.0266951863,
0.0256485641,
0.0009389509,
0.0581657477,
0.0196800921,
0.020159496,
-0.0590976849,
0.0396579094,
0.0264439825,
0.0612299629,
-0.0045517613,
-0.0145855695,
-0.0606852211,
-0.0154210692,
0.0231326427,
-0.0289608929,
-0.0704518482,
-0.016155757,
0.0258603804,
-0.0442922078,
0.0466829315,
-0.0751713589,
0.0391198695,
0.0049916958,
-0.0628089681,
0.0405275151,
-0.0244473051,
0.0178471636,
0.0071315574,
0.0416818298,
-0.003023643,
-0.0443346463,
0.0141651239,
0.054107286,
-0.0001265668,
0.0147891734,
0.0728121325,
0.001298563,
-0.0204836912,
0.0004337372,
-0.022350926,
-0.0242677573,
-0.039262753,
-0.0046945829,
0.0191601627,
-0.0096061882,
0.0089811627,
0.0096877255,
-0.0248451382,
0.0024242448,
-0.0244419184,
-0.0144488327,
-0.0127423834,
0.023925228,
-0.0015495502,
0.0080311671,
-0.0949692801,
0.0693401918,
-0.0070832297,
-0.0032329545,
0.0304337572,
-0.0203489214,
0.0057854056,
0.0794438347,
0.0526584201,
0.0514423214,
-0.0450380445,
0.0042417226,
0.0085959807,
0.034749046,
0.0846542194,
0.0620858856,
-0.0007112626,
-0.0955366939,
-0.0393938385,
-0.0450480841,
0.0354855582,
-0.0184082277,
0.0396142229,
-0.0080042696,
-0.0288034417,
-0.0348643661,
-0.0424485095,
-0.0025168962,
-0.0493736491,
0.0118680755,
0.0014393219,
0.0497857518,
-0.0012218249,
-0.010670634,
0.0091819316,
-0.0489369482,
0.0104861604,
0.0213475768,
0.0367281735,
-0.009038046,
0.0054805642,
0.0149336923,
-0.0519296564,
0.0210210122,
0.0294741802,
0.0269980859,
0.0345032141,
-0.0371964872,
0.0403407291,
0.0025233065,
-0.0118347211,
0.0213752128,
-0.0237777121,
0.0494828783,
0.0055920323,
-0.0489486828,
0.0322172344,
-0.0198909976,
-0.0423986167,
-0.0342629626,
0.0082207499,
-0.0185466614,
-0.0422847085,
0.0270809643,
-0.0553810187,
0.0035688828,
-0.034121491,
0.0046753748,
-0.0267147683,
0.0232146811,
0.0122924466,
-0.0112648141,
-0.0248828698,
-0.0398435444,
2.679e-7,
-0.0463454239,
0.0563190579,
-0.0428005867,
0.0262094364,
0.0351047069,
0.0859740078,
0.0214796457,
0.010708916,
0.0207168665,
-0.118187733,
-0.0234482512,
0.0040984498,
0.0551485755,
0.0395833962,
-0.027838584,
0.025286885,
-0.0399842076,
-0.0308527816,
-0.0322839618,
-0.02708707,
0.0349856317,
0.0353215151,
0.0677531362,
-0.0225745626,
-0.0146609377,
-0.0137992613,
0.0273092967,
-0.0195944868,
-0.0289900471,
-0.0076848092,
0.0019610834,
-0.0599471666,
-0.0216247439,
0.0562765338,
-0.0066434667,
0.0088259485,
-0.0199298132,
0.0176031347,
-0.0136542749,
-0.0035651156,
-0.0534849577,
-0.0238125641,
-0.0044355299,
-0.0591473579,
0.0460591651,
0.0148495929,
-0.0731822997,
-0.0744379312,
0.0134010185,
-0.0313425697,
0.0133632589,
-0.0070188344,
-0.027246071,
0.012105844,
0.022434637,
0.033835236,
0.0091699995,
-0.0179919805,
-0.0201290138,
0.0282463748,
-0.0467346236,
-0.0385549963,
0.0099824285,
0.0255421456,
0.0378437266,
-0.0432684571,
0.054002896,
2.22110002e-34,
0.0026413521,
-0.0013139608,
-0.0055579711,
0.0104426295,
0.0722233877,
0.028758822,
0.0025538539,
-0.0201725438,
0.0471160561,
0.0079424055,
0.0171297081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07076v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07076v1 | On the Discussion of Large Language Models: Symmetry of Agents and Interplay with Prompts | 2023-11-13T04:56:48 | 2023-11-13T04:56:48 | Qineng Wang, Zihao Wang, Ying Su, Yangqiu Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | Two ways has been discussed to unlock the reasoning capability of a large
language model. The first one is prompt engineering and the second one is to
combine the multiple inferences of large language models, or the multi-agent
discussion. Theoretically, this paper justifies the multi-agent discussion
mechanisms from the symmetry of agents. Empirically, this paper reports the
empirical results of the interplay of prompts and discussion mechanisms,
revealing the empirical state-of-the-art performance of complex multi-agent
mechanisms can be approached by carefully developed prompt engineering. This
paper also proposes a scalable discussion mechanism based on conquer and merge,
providing a simple multi-agent discussion solution with simple prompts but
state-of-the-art performance. | [
0.0650111213,
0.0077487049,
-0.0419471413,
0.0562435389,
-0.0573773049,
-0.0195029601,
0.0534972735,
-0.0252467934,
-0.0036784126,
-0.0416314639,
-0.0442439057,
-0.0342008993,
0.0070186821,
0.0068026781,
-0.0077694501,
-0.0376823992,
0.0305367634,
-0.0572273843,
0.0163801108,
-0.0467574745,
0.004828386,
-0.0275535248,
0.0042189201,
0.0279195234,
0.0264519434,
-0.0135104936,
-0.0651488304,
-0.0337241068,
0.0065431478,
0.0061299163,
-0.0584248714,
0.0502624922,
-0.0005415665,
0.061657656,
0.0000020789,
-0.0567861348,
-0.0100723635,
0.002499236,
-0.0452691205,
0.0104730334,
0.0512012504,
0.0275497492,
-0.0139894029,
0.0090218522,
-0.0347276554,
0.0000830189,
0.050206963,
0.0468507521,
0.0700855777,
0.0475979634,
0.0071382872,
-0.0355253629,
-0.0127110379,
-0.009923283,
-0.0404995531,
-0.0708478913,
0.0453108326,
-0.0164125729,
0.0693804771,
0.0268454552,
-0.006027136,
0.0260826796,
0.0140312864,
-0.0586768053,
-0.0415373258,
0.0177552048,
0.0056650438,
-0.0458656959,
-0.0232928805,
0.0471595116,
0.0443372913,
0.0100124385,
-0.0119277481,
-0.0101087475,
0.0450492762,
0.0662624836,
-0.0451282784,
0.0467557013,
-0.0122134369,
0.0034025828,
0.0285871625,
-0.0039679697,
0.0124487011,
-0.001842093,
-0.0530200973,
0.0858677551,
0.0191792566,
-0.0066408771,
-0.0426265933,
-0.040202111,
-0.0165757835,
-0.0918370187,
-0.0296376329,
0.0459161066,
-0.1097114906,
0.0301756877,
0.0005047061,
0.0010548922,
0.0100493953,
-0.0578998476,
0.0294783469,
0.017660195,
0.0372352637,
0.056062527,
0.0325485021,
0.0441251509,
-0.0154608572,
0.0167719796,
-0.0245575551,
-0.0169623476,
-0.0347348936,
-0.0256087761,
-0.0507032312,
0.0458589867,
-0.0321452059,
-0.0038896492,
0.0019462642,
0.0446766168,
-0.0216640662,
0.0478402004,
-0.0290832128,
-0.0291345678,
-0.0016031859,
-0.0408153236,
-0.0384786762,
0.0248903129,
-0.0427092575,
-0.000026655,
0.0270422511,
-0.0818476453,
0.0162511915,
-0.0125923697,
-0.0166263487,
-0.0097432546,
-0.0409828536,
0.0528677851,
0.0007750727,
0.0171448272,
0.0354688503,
-0.0428136364,
-0.0036320018,
-0.0724252388,
-0.0499209538,
-0.0515491143,
0.0430536643,
0.0009573663,
-0.028262591,
-0.0150956344,
0.0069519631,
-0.0178393107,
-0.0123336371,
0.0800356567,
-0.0089605246,
0.0460585281,
0.0319207534,
0.0191507526,
-0.0550086424,
0.082556963,
0.0077482285,
0.0068919733,
0.0290138051,
0.0010171094,
0.0305455364,
0.0355744548,
-0.0009685609,
0.0161255524,
0.021799678,
0.0088035092,
0.0156575534,
0.0173007622,
-0.0536095574,
0.0721641779,
-0.0243904069,
-0.0314203016,
0.0519242771,
0.0468723886,
-0.0478040837,
0.0132380845,
0.0268409625,
0.0308416989,
-0.0046232501,
0.0527858473,
-0.0131701073,
0.0039579473,
-0.0121202646,
-0.0086154351,
0.0066062799,
0.0084078619,
-0.049735222,
-0.0302687436,
0.0109654209,
0.0108324122,
0.0101982616,
0.0432785191,
0.032489825,
-0.0032579855,
-0.0088996813,
0.0522554405,
0.0322403088,
-0.0381468013,
-0.0275790449,
-0.0874163285,
0.0589033253,
0.031135112,
0.0376289785,
-0.0048340927,
-0.0304964911,
0.0020413683,
0.0248178523,
0.0581254251,
0.0738707408,
-0.0186939668,
-0.03961806,
-0.0368532166,
-0.0210783798,
-0.0063679004,
0.0014610509,
0.038708616,
-0.0482870229,
-0.0203639511,
-0.0112102116,
0.0587544888,
0.0092828721,
-0.0231553093,
-0.0177747216,
0.0542664379,
-0.0280313361,
0.0241273902,
0.0348499045,
0.0170131531,
-0.0195988994,
0.026767429,
0.0233538952,
-0.0025021862,
-0.0300361458,
0.0380037911,
-0.0253437962,
-0.0217072815,
0.0209910348,
0.0130744725,
-0.0126554966,
-0.0082270941,
-0.0025133453,
-0.0363529734,
0.03053887,
-0.0144577026,
0.0455653034,
-0.0244357139,
0.0640357584,
-0.0386045687,
-0.0023887197,
-0.0443013273,
0.0573562644,
0.0269568637,
0.0054867626,
0.0583578423,
0.029479105,
0.026883658,
-0.0514270477,
-0.0399112776,
0.0704881549,
0.0198420379,
-0.0034785189,
0.0493549407,
-0.0377412476,
-0.0200833455,
-0.0561987348,
-0.078109704,
-0.0170964673,
-0.007112084,
0.0104644112,
0.0176816117,
0.0226356052,
0.0210056547,
0.0116007896,
-0.0331759602,
0.0258495715,
0.0488541909,
0.0470729992,
0.0373983569,
0.0518641397,
-0.0873408914,
0.0003338041,
-0.0050749658,
-0.0186578389,
0.0438951105,
0.0509404205,
0.0074094813,
-0.068534717,
0.0313700028,
-0.0596192107,
0.0391404592,
-0.0261020064,
-0.0062930421,
0.0528635606,
-0.033994697,
0.0010621625,
0.0459018797,
0.0193174258,
0.046627,
0.0132569754,
-0.0348248072,
-0.0610861667,
0.0003901262,
-0.0031814962,
-0.0089783045,
-0.057685066,
0.0003627444,
-0.0050778212,
0.069696635,
-0.0017435624,
-0.0301702619,
-0.0459909439,
0.0177680887,
0.007139801,
-0.0147286374,
-0.0175393783,
-0.0658597425,
-0.0051203179,
0.0594245158,
-0.0306092966,
-0.0065107262,
0.0689089969,
-0.0203472394,
-0.0183045585,
-0.0509969331,
0.005157182,
-0.0411501937,
0.0895938203,
-0.0318312682,
0.0159421042,
0.0097742826,
-0.0435201563,
-0.0591113903,
-0.0758717284,
0.0530325286,
0.0044015027,
0.0215447415,
-0.0556893423,
0.0256415978,
-0.03020202,
-0.0520629585,
-0.0333179496,
-0.0554534011,
-0.0323038548,
0.0169239324,
0.0191906877,
-0.0131031098,
-0.0425912216,
0.0275401492,
0.0127103142,
-0.0324748121,
0.0025260763,
0.0193018485,
-0.046504695,
-0.0091706794,
0.0226941984,
0.0418632925,
0.0008112915,
-0.04942232,
0.1024181098,
0.051922895,
0.0053923079,
0.0089256903,
0.006732842,
-0.0393361896,
0.0293388162,
-0.0257652495,
-0.0288143605,
0.0153010199,
0.0055173873,
-0.0428310335,
0.0303333402,
0.1023321971,
0.0417631716,
-0.0212279521,
0.0025371974,
-0.0402191766,
-0.0093385046,
-0.0005902954,
0.0288568046,
-0.0662291795,
0.0206858609,
0.0096170409,
-0.0768413693,
-0.0183455441,
-0.0354963392,
-0.0315243453,
-0.0980444103,
0.0233670548,
-0.0020739883,
-0.0326510631,
0.0101921875,
0.0063960957,
0.020444883,
0.0182291269,
0.0186120011,
0.0382409059,
0.0273454916,
-0.0100385463,
-0.0210656691,
0.0302800331,
0.0116361752,
0.0182872657,
-0.0435614996,
0.0545198619,
0.0365754515,
0.0412701406,
0.0033366461,
-0.0379863121,
0.0559839047,
0.0329142734,
0.0069227936,
-0.0021240271,
-0.0211914591,
0.0195086244,
-0.018387422,
-0.0333143547,
-0.0092474911,
0.0405584276,
-0.0107732154,
0.0349082798,
0.0499928445,
-0.0259906352,
-0.034456268,
0.0147767728,
0.010762847,
0.0133112697,
0.0731213763,
0.022553077,
-0.034933731,
-0.0326261483,
-0.0325890742,
-0.0555432811,
-0.0025759791,
-0.013144142,
0.0146806939,
0.0430481173,
-0.0169819649,
-0.0238637254,
-0.0716708973,
0.0197110418,
0.0183307212,
0.0199590567,
0.0403113626,
0.0528887287,
0.0077670547,
0.052838698,
-0.0136754373,
-0.0325713828,
0.021849161,
-0.0234793164,
0.0130975703,
0.0246460643,
-0.0382832475,
-0.0153128076,
-0.0330375433,
-0.0180345122,
-0.0900207609,
-0.0153624201,
0.0128385862,
0.0323303714,
0.025895508,
-0.0291701164,
-0.0511014275,
0.0321863592,
-0.02777569,
-0.0032283724,
0.0087314453,
-0.0027813583,
0.024215294,
0.0104619646,
0.068765603,
-0.0093925446,
0.0073538753,
-0.0048961663,
-0.0014826531,
-0.0617453754,
-0.0479863547,
0.0102330111,
0.0319592841,
-0.0300209858,
0.0263255741,
-0.0317276344,
-0.0087396009,
0.033937566,
-0.0786513984,
-0.0395762287,
-0.0416678712,
0.0134991882,
-0.0292822793,
-0.0306353029,
0.0500431433,
-0.010196588,
-0.0069696303,
0.0198123008,
0.0376325995,
0.0352580398,
-0.0181799252,
-0.0064022909,
0.0491986424,
0.0282950979,
0.0044428906,
0.0126300436,
0.0197489168,
0.0481201336,
0.0140403174,
0.0670697689,
0.0355959125,
-0.0306629837,
-0.0027666227,
0.0418827012,
-0.0893990323,
-0.1005833298,
0.0755903348,
0.0422747247,
0.0197352972,
0.0586403124,
0.0086686872,
-0.0192174911,
0.005432439,
-0.0083880443,
0.0447481759,
0.0356661379,
-0.0753212422,
0.0358068496,
0.0203799643,
-0.0056152469,
-0.0047658603,
0.0388177745,
-0.0518160164,
0.0114867631,
-0.0022716417,
0.0029507631,
-0.0452090874,
-0.0153332893,
-0.0088245338,
-0.0102639971,
-0.0281464774,
0.0252767764,
-0.0674102157,
-0.0238909423,
-0.033407025,
0.0157314949,
-0.0053539351,
-0.0034408397,
0.0315657556,
0.0524438918,
0.0074153473,
-0.029408453,
-0.0673432946,
0.0293284897,
-0.0144666368,
-0.0097244838,
0.0004674623,
-5.890433783e-33,
-0.0467175394,
-0.0260558669,
0.060974285,
-0.0044328202,
-0.0244326368,
-0.0450464338,
-0.0514692403,
0.0137676094,
-0.0495978296,
0.016595168,
-0.0176146943,
0.0069989562,
0.0228173919,
-0.0074895546,
-0.0088872239,
-0.0058157495,
0.0423566438,
0.0155993188,
-0.013920377,
0.0047179945,
0.0118010389,
-0.024315495,
-0.0004159689,
-0.0146614667,
0.0410487093,
-0.0204771999,
-0.0141744604,
0.0448269099,
-0.06778346,
0.0283734724,
0.0027699338,
0.0177382119,
0.0077970647,
-0.0561954565,
-0.0298072025,
0.0489602201,
0.0156681053,
-0.0378964283,
0.0671199486,
0.022834463,
-0.0013832643,
-0.0441145562,
-0.0131131792,
-0.0177462455,
0.0083935522,
0.0114369774,
0.0044175251,
-0.0044623916,
-0.0076754689,
0.0640086234,
-0.0542816855,
0.021267686,
-0.0146392919,
-0.0083123399,
0.032567963,
-0.010007997,
0.0133737912,
-0.0424960032,
-0.0080287084,
0.0674099326,
0.0462294295,
-0.0072510168,
0.0235560108,
0.0307876766,
0.0366071165,
0.030918479,
0.0386092179,
0.0722585395,
-0.0293127969,
-0.0156533122,
-0.0295011476,
0.0567022301,
0.0231805407,
0.0498443432,
-0.0468539335,
0.0205592718,
-0.0247224271,
0.0044701057,
0.0523119606,
0.0377144516,
0.0359394848,
0.0083756186,
-0.0561388768,
-0.0480679534,
-0.043522764,
0.0112418551,
-0.0430645272,
-0.038003251,
0.0138577186,
-0.0030893099,
-0.006345286,
-0.0123983147,
0.0474290475,
-0.0883649215,
-0.0700094476,
0.0054939962,
0.0188354924,
0.0124608623,
-0.0027139317,
-0.0040366328,
-0.0036246157,
-0.0144770723,
-0.0158043765,
0.0042463453,
-0.0130518135,
0.0473720655,
-0.0337432995,
0.0041250619,
-0.0280594844,
0.0158977527,
-0.0264216084,
-0.0148179485,
-0.0022919574,
-0.0200496074,
0.0103249894,
0.0071307509,
-0.0192052275,
0.011201865,
0.0029319169,
-0.025447702,
-0.0274913274,
0.0548201576,
-0.012441501,
-0.0013215052,
-0.0089687863,
-0.0032098258,
-0.0400327891,
0.0365589038,
0.0737518296,
0.0170439761,
-0.0194017608,
-0.0357935391,
2.758e-7,
0.0042632357,
-0.0195172392,
0.0149359358,
0.047990784,
0.0253862347,
0.0484961383,
-0.007227926,
0.0060893525,
0.0341390371,
-0.0158347636,
0.0152166178,
0.042350281,
0.0212133732,
0.0314837955,
-0.0892964378,
-0.0172248986,
-0.057212092,
-0.0409495123,
-0.0444389544,
0.0030515071,
0.0581856817,
0.0478734225,
0.0142934946,
0.0240218639,
-0.0157070551,
-0.0373925045,
0.018292997,
-0.0155938044,
-0.0207577869,
0.0512364693,
-0.005087323,
-0.0612839833,
0.0149064846,
0.0475369506,
0.0560833476,
0.0280771069,
-0.0473350883,
0.0189454891,
-0.0119198123,
0.0028274439,
-0.0075782784,
-0.0619352907,
-0.0122954715,
-0.0572831258,
0.0468365327,
-0.0423628502,
-0.0689208508,
-0.0293687247,
0.0286899358,
-0.0316830017,
0.0069324938,
-0.0154420901,
-0.0065722228,
0.0006666431,
-0.0125412699,
-0.0119289076,
0.0376673006,
-0.0642994791,
-0.0088718021,
-0.0262841806,
-0.0686531141,
-0.0768334344,
-0.0067536221,
-0.0128550166,
0.0090081235,
-0.0498705544,
0.0178759377,
2.237235057e-34,
0.0241531748,
0.0112819141,
0.0212794188,
0.0631833598,
0.0324174725,
0.0210797079,
-0.0400970615,
0.0129984878,
0.0718046501,
-0.0801896602,
-0.0412009135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07070v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07070v1 | Explain-then-Translate: An Analysis on Improving Program Translation with Self-generated Explanations | 2023-11-13T04:28:49 | 2023-11-13T04:28:49 | Zilu Tang, Mayank Agarwal, Alex Shypula, Bailin Wang, Derry Wijaya, Jie Chen, Yoon Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL | This work explores the use of self-generated natural language explanations as
an intermediate step for code-to-code translation with language models. Across
three types of explanations and 19 programming languages constructed from the
MultiPL-E dataset, we find the explanations to be particularly effective in the
zero-shot case, improving performance by 12% on average. Improvements with
natural language explanations are particularly pronounced on difficult
programs. We release our dataset, code, and canonical solutions in all 19
languages. | [
-0.0222192816,
0.0282856319,
-0.0228093434,
0.0554898158,
-0.0012162854,
0.0076909987,
0.0231786426,
-0.0433967784,
-0.0378625654,
-0.001086204,
0.0353392586,
0.0582719594,
0.0233647358,
0.0334475413,
0.039292559,
-0.0302145816,
0.0281370003,
-0.0424359366,
-0.0235874839,
0.0372471288,
-0.0011792685,
0.0503750928,
-0.0094429189,
0.0524165407,
0.049065154,
-0.010318609,
-0.0183319915,
0.0438425764,
-0.020837266,
-0.0225039087,
-0.0589252524,
-0.0060474435,
0.0376608185,
-0.0322130844,
0.0000022258,
-0.030162327,
-0.0154118985,
0.0210482981,
-0.0416582115,
0.0661590844,
-0.006909234,
-0.0440094434,
0.0188767239,
0.0103462646,
0.0070786267,
-0.0089895278,
0.0607392378,
-0.0528773405,
0.08188425,
0.0490833186,
0.0175787415,
-0.0367301702,
-0.0417479686,
0.0154110482,
0.0309675336,
-0.0435983203,
-0.034030702,
0.0381056108,
-0.012451129,
0.0251089409,
0.0138985645,
0.0175221562,
0.0116475429,
-0.0242091753,
0.037640892,
0.0264544487,
0.0002930584,
-0.0507314838,
-0.0047383732,
0.039503295,
-0.0325080417,
-0.0475175045,
0.0139761483,
-0.0181534924,
-0.0313750021,
-0.0217275601,
-0.0556997545,
0.0011124439,
0.021378627,
-0.026122028,
0.0147230271,
0.012236041,
0.0246832017,
-0.0245203972,
-0.0402487926,
0.0237367898,
-0.0072323941,
0.0299577583,
-0.061380446,
-0.0440732986,
0.0281054564,
-0.053936772,
0.0228877924,
0.0862086937,
0.0140133742,
0.01933668,
0.0031511544,
-0.0120196827,
-0.0060642208,
-0.0386199355,
0.0241504293,
0.0781017244,
-0.0157062951,
0.0361352228,
-0.0498989932,
0.0871980935,
0.0067607588,
-0.0223314576,
-0.0480946302,
0.0036736487,
-0.0761824772,
-0.0141708897,
-0.0691911802,
0.0025102911,
-0.0060867523,
0.0293330681,
-0.0223009381,
0.0332021043,
0.0294264685,
0.0335117131,
-0.004146874,
-0.020249486,
-0.0723947808,
-0.0143803237,
0.0001551225,
0.0440573432,
-0.0583354235,
-0.0867883861,
-0.0040454175,
-0.0579442494,
-0.0379884429,
0.006364957,
-0.0280098747,
-0.0242996681,
-0.0052852733,
0.1077834144,
0.0098942267,
0.0433056727,
-0.0197691154,
-0.0228810981,
-0.0027221711,
-0.0282811597,
-0.0410457477,
-0.0850228742,
0.0015344542,
0.0395624526,
0.0110796597,
-0.0545014255,
0.0040434198,
-0.0067597511,
-0.0210689213,
0.0909471139,
-0.0708026811,
0.0517520793,
0.039705094,
0.0005694909,
-0.0116477283,
0.0402526706,
0.0209091306,
-0.0310034975,
0.001838222,
-0.0792075768,
0.0457671434,
-0.013991232,
0.0105224689,
-0.0204842892,
-0.0164329186,
0.0328109302,
-0.009683663,
0.0292300116,
0.025002623,
-0.0360478126,
-0.0007447075,
0.0355878696,
-0.0335007459,
0.0419008285,
0.0173756387,
0.0403862856,
0.0659771338,
0.0423967093,
-0.0174057186,
-0.0393277146,
-0.0381667614,
0.0908888727,
0.004696433,
0.0183186773,
0.0020283486,
0.0429596044,
-0.001275995,
-0.0774649009,
-0.0057034111,
0.0113601824,
0.0087870657,
-0.0061490568,
0.0414187722,
0.0168694146,
-0.0109940767,
0.032600563,
0.007870554,
-0.0478228815,
-0.0150311328,
-0.0499839149,
0.0086168293,
0.083108291,
0.0328361876,
-0.0206534881,
-0.0258296784,
-0.0096211145,
0.0097197872,
-0.0124469679,
0.0370347649,
0.0054622078,
0.0343076028,
-0.0264798943,
-0.0126733324,
-0.0617735907,
0.0102957785,
0.0503036864,
-0.0095316032,
-0.0228282325,
0.0504130535,
-0.0263462458,
-0.0612558536,
0.0152459163,
-0.0114816129,
-0.0444572456,
0.0548801087,
-0.0029042223,
-0.0309153683,
0.0099498732,
-0.0147393029,
0.0236660931,
0.0170288309,
-0.0025401311,
0.0018137256,
0.0324193202,
-0.0114242435,
-0.036273893,
0.0137975393,
-0.0421997532,
-0.010597948,
-0.0029129917,
-0.0400921889,
-0.0342578255,
0.065780744,
0.0032655632,
0.0176003538,
0.0327994749,
0.0259253532,
0.0029407532,
-0.0295022521,
-0.0033287094,
0.0303239934,
0.0588137284,
0.0026548905,
0.008500291,
0.0228126552,
0.0370835178,
0.0047052996,
0.0553245656,
0.0122650135,
-0.0470724851,
-0.0095492201,
0.0156077361,
0.0366138443,
0.0003031374,
0.0182112902,
-0.0230571814,
0.0157738384,
-0.0005255915,
0.0257218946,
0.0599726811,
0.0364548154,
0.0230291933,
-0.0189202651,
-0.0181641262,
0.0023889055,
-0.0291085374,
-0.0310145523,
0.0395028517,
0.0040769731,
-0.0547931269,
-0.0466703922,
0.000042517,
-0.0405389331,
0.0487435311,
-0.0069500022,
-0.0377084278,
-0.0751549155,
0.0396851413,
-0.0112823751,
-0.0543295816,
-0.0359784476,
-0.0566294268,
0.0068947333,
-0.0513800569,
0.0185628496,
0.0268606711,
-0.0340446308,
0.038192641,
0.0482252911,
-0.0107700638,
-0.0671139732,
0.0082302243,
0.0141485156,
-0.0446693376,
0.0313708782,
-0.0546522811,
0.0217967015,
0.0988688022,
-0.012322573,
0.0034714227,
-0.0447001532,
0.0103008337,
0.0148785478,
0.0277869757,
-0.0109648034,
-0.0266641453,
0.0540762059,
0.0742392763,
-0.0148715377,
-0.0488614812,
0.0732595399,
-0.0501648709,
-0.0144606205,
-0.0238613207,
-0.0110879345,
-0.0393066108,
0.067275092,
-0.0385082103,
0.0278593171,
0.0059845103,
-0.0237082299,
0.0227953326,
-0.0093422607,
0.0336992517,
0.0197583474,
0.0172753185,
-0.0680377036,
-0.0074214586,
0.0122941723,
0.0218479149,
0.0091543319,
-0.0020982444,
-0.028991051,
-0.0399479456,
0.0214022193,
-0.0270237755,
0.0405504704,
0.009767388,
0.0071995407,
0.0293742754,
0.0264963284,
-0.047269322,
0.0035988321,
-0.074733831,
-0.0584636033,
-0.0272054616,
-0.01570067,
-0.0243314579,
0.0352520347,
-0.0171984416,
0.0323943794,
0.0298174638,
-0.0505229123,
-0.0338025428,
0.0039913347,
-0.0250069033,
-0.0507791191,
0.0420810729,
0.0642558932,
-0.0606843233,
-0.0124320174,
0.0901542604,
0.0288076401,
-0.0165678244,
0.0089804316,
-0.0394954979,
0.0216836613,
0.0690784082,
0.0457019769,
-0.0814170316,
-0.0453095622,
-0.0339441188,
0.0307950992,
0.0362451524,
0.02598284,
-0.0406810977,
-0.0679176822,
0.0335716084,
0.0255689044,
-0.0527946502,
-0.0575601831,
-0.0327413604,
-0.0539608076,
-0.0160070062,
-0.024461668,
-0.0035057934,
0.0316402093,
0.0431367904,
0.0073021678,
-0.0543343797,
-0.0092354203,
0.0254005976,
-0.0126875248,
0.051696308,
0.0845711902,
0.0464306101,
0.0361063592,
0.0196354054,
0.0139628537,
0.0068055191,
0.029902149,
-0.041126091,
0.0437012203,
0.0200857222,
-0.0394581184,
0.0507958308,
0.0144431684,
-0.0615131147,
-0.016509831,
0.0242063925,
0.0273798108,
-0.0090889502,
-0.0040303734,
0.0017309927,
0.0048468905,
-0.0150321899,
0.0561433025,
0.0557589866,
0.0176491439,
-0.0148719996,
-0.0749387592,
-0.0253552999,
-0.0714685693,
-0.0336782038,
-0.0379921831,
0.0183837153,
-0.03277345,
-0.0047548208,
0.0071631446,
0.0331038684,
0.0440425538,
0.0267126653,
-0.0239278059,
-0.0047240299,
-0.0001908647,
-0.0414234586,
0.0265391637,
-0.0179844704,
0.0049636615,
0.0096400529,
-0.0234615393,
-0.0097111119,
-0.0294663608,
0.0205868315,
0.0167422406,
-0.0627334192,
-0.0294817965,
-0.0435705781,
0.0738752857,
0.027424315,
0.0548434965,
-0.0296017397,
-0.0525767282,
-0.0623967648,
0.0045342944,
-0.0451054722,
-0.035961166,
0.022695208,
0.0258442983,
0.0336585529,
0.0133358669,
-0.0409477688,
-0.0078202132,
-0.0159091577,
0.0080227153,
-0.0299211778,
-0.0172368903,
0.0627726987,
0.0420719199,
0.0325138085,
0.0133289285,
-0.0151947327,
0.0154159497,
0.0082225613,
-0.0441600345,
-0.0258738827,
-0.0557378754,
0.0351322554,
0.0242602341,
-0.0306073874,
0.058839079,
-0.0388375781,
-0.0693586022,
-0.0125979073,
0.0000340469,
0.024062451,
0.0079647861,
0.0353869312,
0.004169622,
0.0230255667,
-0.0031269817,
0.0257372968,
-0.0030135843,
0.0381001867,
-0.0432622544,
0.0468288995,
0.008783062,
0.0383785181,
0.0096351504,
0.0001408088,
-0.0182914995,
-0.0792811289,
0.0237534996,
-0.0209573098,
0.0229144674,
0.0258408803,
0.0626413897,
0.0172278099,
0.0094182761,
0.0102609899,
0.1186621338,
0.0107974922,
-0.0381458551,
-0.009122408,
0.0187422149,
-0.0094765574,
-0.0724082813,
0.0592622571,
-0.0240509994,
-0.0226536896,
0.0169408079,
-0.00983709,
-0.0132422801,
0.0354508534,
0.0225867275,
-0.0076155257,
-0.0029670568,
-0.0406539403,
-0.0285526477,
-0.0479742549,
-0.0568087362,
0.0428985953,
-0.0012020277,
-0.0179551635,
0.0080920877,
0.1063669398,
0.0074630519,
-0.0305370744,
0.0013716775,
0.0370029733,
-0.0074756048,
-0.0110196043,
-0.0137147913,
-6.088086914e-33,
-0.0548509434,
-0.026529029,
0.0167392772,
-0.0143215442,
0.0480137877,
-0.0275590476,
-0.0790176094,
-0.0079230927,
-0.0153781706,
-0.0158140771,
0.0444077887,
0.0237541273,
-0.0072191553,
-0.0454456694,
0.0359497517,
-0.0008217477,
0.0359933339,
0.0467236713,
-0.0688814968,
0.0339246206,
-0.0139478445,
0.0149375387,
0.042574238,
-0.0471417569,
0.0384413302,
0.0034230719,
0.0071174367,
0.0064489986,
0.0456808284,
0.021630533,
0.0034414248,
0.0001802331,
-0.0088172313,
-0.0283766836,
-0.0199741516,
-0.0476447232,
-0.0760950744,
-0.0172860567,
0.0517811403,
0.025237456,
-0.0134026408,
-0.0691217929,
0.0290165786,
-0.007431196,
0.0036794827,
-0.010049561,
0.0419745892,
0.0019591069,
-0.0136597827,
0.0176917147,
-0.0672818199,
0.0019783187,
-0.0897044912,
-0.0320696346,
0.0258835629,
0.0565480925,
-0.0324752927,
0.0217610281,
0.0222341325,
-0.0139584802,
0.0390244871,
0.0498875976,
0.1031425074,
-0.0208370797,
-0.0067539723,
-0.0314628445,
0.0352042988,
0.0128435735,
-0.0559662916,
0.0373300314,
0.0272110458,
0.0226892158,
0.0561379939,
0.0183897987,
0.0372100547,
0.0241732765,
-0.045251403,
0.0479074381,
-0.0323945209,
0.0054654907,
0.0013821113,
0.027365908,
-0.0339900739,
-0.0149388146,
-0.032531701,
-0.0280487239,
-0.02919369,
-0.0648419857,
0.0180423558,
-0.0314970054,
-0.0771117583,
-0.0098780338,
0.0047952449,
-0.0293839015,
0.0106139369,
-0.0055174064,
-0.0541861095,
-0.0051011811,
-0.0146960393,
0.0298012272,
0.0058691963,
0.0071109482,
-0.0084137078,
0.0357219279,
0.1014570445,
0.0176156424,
-0.0013198904,
0.021849256,
-0.0196218938,
-0.00777651,
-0.0783150569,
-0.0483169667,
-0.0658607855,
-0.0040046386,
-0.0333496816,
0.0132107325,
-0.0216120612,
0.0214338284,
0.0029351397,
-0.0435558297,
-0.015224738,
0.0167741235,
-0.00239234,
0.0102286544,
-0.0296780057,
-0.0379255265,
-0.0438021012,
-0.0029078156,
0.0442868583,
-0.026898697,
-0.0712544844,
0.0247349888,
2.762e-7,
0.0358517095,
0.0426655635,
0.0247851722,
0.0346287973,
-0.0332836956,
0.0279289018,
-0.0365927108,
-0.0178006664,
0.0261815693,
0.0020503122,
-0.0079305414,
0.0572053269,
0.0357708931,
0.0102624223,
0.0006606376,
0.0066008861,
0.0157248825,
0.0247021653,
-0.0596417785,
0.0147448806,
0.0900866985,
0.0361246094,
-0.0246969219,
0.0350298584,
0.0147300726,
-0.0203868821,
-0.0055109924,
-0.0357417278,
0.0250483006,
0.0133640748,
-0.0300166495,
0.0286329165,
-0.0316673256,
-0.0220720712,
-0.021305507,
-0.0293119214,
-0.0050986852,
0.0573097505,
-0.0195787791,
0.0238627214,
0.0052860142,
-0.0581598766,
0.0101643577,
-0.0681891143,
0.034412574,
-0.0533975139,
0.0045158113,
0.0200794749,
-0.0340027139,
0.0336249992,
-0.0229838155,
-0.0016762726,
0.0219100323,
0.0104477145,
0.0140850851,
-0.0339250378,
-0.0226359945,
-0.0352548324,
-0.0640562028,
0.0059188954,
0.0364095941,
0.0322584063,
-0.028282987,
0.0045799003,
0.0384751223,
0.0102229714,
-0.0008068336,
2.404138725e-34,
0.0096753454,
-0.008392035,
0.0228009131,
-0.0099397739,
0.0636615679,
-0.0075492794,
-0.0428266674,
0.0058451383,
0.0390388519,
0.01858644,
-0.0286003891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07066v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07066v1 | Context Consistency between Training and Testing in Simultaneous Machine Translation | 2023-11-13T04:11:32 | 2023-11-13T04:11:32 | Meizhi Zhong, Lemao Liu, Kehai Chen, Mingming Yang, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Simultaneous Machine Translation (SiMT) aims to yield a real-time partial
translation with a monotonically growing the source-side context. However,
there is a counterintuitive phenomenon about the context usage between training
and testing: e.g., the wait-k testing model consistently trained with wait-k is
much worse than that model inconsistently trained with wait-k' (k' is not equal
to k) in terms of translation quality. To this end, we first investigate the
underlying reasons behind this phenomenon and uncover the following two
factors: 1) the limited correlation between translation quality and training
(cross-entropy) loss; 2) exposure bias between training and testing. Based on
both reasons, we then propose an effective training approach called context
consistency training accordingly, which makes consistent the context usage
between training and testing by optimizing translation quality and latency as
bi-objectives and exposing the predictions to the model during the training.
The experiments on three language pairs demonstrate our intuition: our system
encouraging context consistency outperforms that existing systems with context
inconsistency for the first time, with the help of our context consistency
training approach. | [
0.014741255,
0.0254635811,
-0.0208600648,
0.0215216875,
-0.015917249,
0.0291977972,
0.0445630737,
0.0209981147,
-0.056791123,
-0.0006564163,
-0.0361992717,
-0.0571295395,
0.0502776913,
-0.0420380235,
0.0240323674,
-0.0729973167,
0.0528360717,
0.0096090958,
-0.0601869859,
-0.0150164478,
0.0168304518,
-0.0035941247,
0.0029071211,
0.0231908895,
-0.0421462283,
0.0116187036,
-0.0180253666,
0.0306787044,
0.0695136413,
-0.0419333689,
0.0011312786,
0.0503384471,
0.0197526366,
0.0582953654,
0.0000021602,
-0.030740805,
-0.0198659617,
0.0113063203,
0.0154144596,
0.0143704545,
0.0288245138,
-0.0873548239,
-0.0252377708,
0.0573456623,
-0.0147999879,
-0.0057694246,
0.0420865268,
-0.005875716,
0.0479207039,
0.0663727745,
-0.0014949342,
-0.0029055611,
-0.0279181246,
-0.0686182007,
0.0103330631,
-0.0558395572,
-0.0206118282,
0.010502954,
-0.0548882484,
-0.0073418394,
-0.0053576515,
0.0571223535,
0.0623477846,
0.0301910006,
-0.0621134378,
0.0294794999,
0.0123937707,
-0.0138159348,
-0.0171596054,
0.0287684146,
-0.0407976396,
-0.0252967607,
-0.0080529889,
-0.0303744804,
-0.0347988829,
-0.0564429648,
-0.0006125692,
0.0317501575,
-0.0094210478,
-0.0184651501,
0.009429317,
0.0337057225,
0.0218561962,
-0.0093135936,
-0.0381966084,
-0.0141799627,
0.0240461603,
-0.071099475,
-0.0263463799,
0.0504471734,
-0.0405960046,
-0.0317040347,
0.0382341892,
-0.0161291491,
-0.0455795974,
0.0373493955,
-0.0304731373,
-0.0771702304,
0.0382854864,
-0.0400116742,
-0.0419524834,
0.0822241679,
-0.0337015651,
-0.0128786676,
-0.0148864845,
0.0681359917,
0.0183086153,
0.025223162,
-0.0727811307,
0.0132698789,
-0.0163287148,
0.029528331,
-0.0412104651,
-0.0428176783,
-0.039456673,
-0.0016030151,
-0.0438077226,
0.0424647667,
-0.0268724319,
0.0295995288,
0.0248734429,
-0.0343199596,
-0.1229796857,
0.0132209249,
0.0256954953,
0.0242134072,
-0.0167730134,
0.0197161622,
-0.001633659,
-0.0323425457,
-0.0295606386,
-0.0004555778,
-0.0241326187,
-0.030372588,
-0.0331178233,
0.0597738847,
-0.0070111998,
-0.0302237347,
-0.0000146373,
-0.0292887464,
-0.0140850889,
-0.0505127758,
-0.0288689397,
-0.0262725092,
0.049357269,
0.0001695196,
0.0283551235,
-0.0012998503,
-0.031559106,
-0.0195456818,
0.0558659136,
0.080669038,
0.0164950714,
-0.0028884348,
0.0338983238,
0.0404246747,
0.0067324922,
0.1125666872,
0.0286054984,
-0.0129785193,
0.0346248038,
0.0163917672,
-0.0613503195,
0.0639302582,
0.0588762201,
0.0573778525,
-0.0140182283,
0.0152631411,
0.0262283888,
0.053290382,
0.0417322554,
0.0284024011,
-0.0319330767,
0.0161254779,
0.063257657,
-0.0018060495,
0.0239360128,
0.0204737168,
0.0618427061,
-0.0089991633,
-0.0282787886,
0.0552163422,
-0.0338970758,
-0.0182711128,
0.0168592725,
0.0493040681,
0.0456416085,
0.0279364344,
-0.0210760552,
-0.0224803928,
-0.0248169526,
-0.025989946,
-0.0144940661,
-0.0168419052,
0.0516710766,
0.0198297575,
-0.0516783744,
0.0299786795,
0.0109773427,
-0.0331455059,
0.0144522525,
-0.011200835,
-0.0478574783,
0.058916226,
0.0294241924,
0.007996955,
0.0025677413,
-0.0044401055,
-0.0028473514,
0.0280086454,
0.0671432838,
-0.0025583284,
0.0298167001,
-0.0045195739,
-0.0318442769,
0.0495739728,
0.0014700195,
0.0282604303,
0.0176135637,
0.0832605958,
0.0605694093,
0.0031086421,
-0.0041648205,
0.0578837059,
-0.0532979071,
0.0121046621,
-0.0045122416,
0.0280838776,
0.0255347304,
0.006820824,
-0.0355959162,
-0.0260424837,
0.0419409052,
-0.0117348926,
0.0108650876,
0.0716534704,
-0.0806285366,
-0.0800701752,
0.0137059474,
0.0099296942,
-0.0058670631,
0.0202197563,
-0.0271600951,
-0.035289757,
-0.018069949,
0.0093274312,
0.0427009836,
-0.0353033766,
0.0346769616,
-0.0114319576,
-0.0100624524,
-0.0523603894,
0.0304949079,
-0.0116094835,
0.019111339,
0.0073102745,
0.020427037,
0.0113717606,
-0.058559075,
0.0075301421,
0.0716736391,
0.0179359205,
0.0398860537,
0.0214758925,
0.0283768978,
-0.0574707463,
-0.0230919663,
-0.1264800876,
0.0334259942,
-0.0404883325,
0.0548636504,
0.0313336179,
0.0350516178,
-0.005609619,
-0.0155762481,
0.0016846935,
0.0014159014,
0.0254402943,
0.0054037101,
-0.0056255111,
0.0297322143,
0.0154840881,
-0.0150932353,
-0.0006465004,
-0.0008513229,
0.0390202887,
0.0087492988,
0.0292396471,
-0.0798077509,
0.0241167173,
0.0102183111,
0.0148944426,
0.0196998343,
-0.0362165794,
0.0322141945,
-0.0059600198,
-0.0057484847,
0.0171804111,
0.0221216101,
0.0173129942,
0.000863293,
0.011032558,
-0.0730527267,
-0.0014567138,
-0.019587446,
-0.0417209268,
-0.0207964443,
-0.0437442325,
-0.0100129303,
0.0452044755,
0.008097413,
0.0003914972,
-0.0584288016,
-0.0173161663,
-0.0308502112,
-0.0164828207,
-0.024428539,
0.0056580505,
-0.0112354783,
-0.0004385415,
-0.0121572679,
-0.0471271239,
0.0681415945,
-0.044601474,
-0.0014790188,
-0.0804855824,
0.0002782138,
-0.0162883569,
0.0497552082,
-0.0332018994,
0.0095128687,
-0.0357239284,
-0.0040184041,
-0.0427621752,
0.0119844098,
0.038878262,
-0.0153042739,
0.0038791846,
-0.0399720222,
-0.0134401284,
-0.0379536562,
-0.0442452654,
-0.030095011,
0.0124821356,
-0.0112796538,
-0.0013431259,
0.0194764994,
-0.0134493355,
0.0268002078,
0.0055857748,
-0.0070651653,
0.0838701054,
-0.0074942755,
-0.0454379432,
-0.0069523421,
0.0047729104,
-0.0190149285,
-0.0131795863,
0.0117736133,
-0.0885475129,
0.0312222261,
0.0222778823,
0.0859795585,
0.0014854303,
-0.0558490008,
-0.0390326343,
0.0217293818,
-0.0123568522,
-0.0003796533,
0.0100035146,
0.031442631,
-0.0632099286,
-0.0076745497,
0.0848932639,
0.0118989069,
-0.0302514192,
0.0174117032,
-0.0119505301,
0.0335581005,
0.0026064324,
0.0204135198,
-0.0994454771,
-0.0328694992,
0.0164388008,
0.0481553525,
0.0085370224,
0.0524237826,
-0.0373282023,
-0.0547285303,
-0.0276569128,
0.0332382247,
-0.1145634949,
-0.0418643095,
-0.0015319664,
-0.030538233,
-0.034761548,
0.0896401331,
0.0077517587,
0.0278589427,
0.0145450225,
0.0203091856,
0.046517957,
-0.0780064613,
0.0076484596,
-0.072670579,
0.0415208675,
0.0571767054,
-0.0229312908,
0.015276798,
-0.0331492722,
0.0468900986,
-0.0600783899,
0.0069082361,
-0.0212032646,
-0.0087024588,
-0.0088372324,
-0.0073612598,
0.034670081,
-0.0393141806,
-0.0032489859,
0.0179181565,
0.0439425446,
0.0026526577,
0.0163678937,
-0.0148320114,
0.0079710148,
-0.0159868766,
0.0522724241,
0.0278622992,
-0.0133340778,
-0.0641819909,
0.0045598401,
-0.0143480618,
0.0104035223,
-0.0468049161,
-0.0002016057,
-0.0074663991,
-0.0623625368,
-0.0365636759,
-0.0693627894,
-0.0393796451,
-0.0248461906,
0.0669029132,
-0.0007447691,
0.0193456318,
-0.0473190919,
0.0061933277,
-0.0268681757,
0.0404290147,
0.0131312022,
0.0355750658,
-0.0397982188,
0.0374095738,
-0.0184239894,
-0.0496745221,
-0.000749649,
0.0453890562,
-0.0888149366,
-0.0735128745,
-0.0175686199,
0.0320099071,
0.0219126325,
0.073454082,
-0.0141609777,
-0.045955047,
0.0116629126,
0.010870154,
-0.0280730203,
0.0291259941,
0.0500757247,
-0.0382346883,
-0.0066791023,
0.0208278894,
-0.0264710654,
-0.0023623991,
-0.004566262,
0.0293333922,
0.0053361198,
-0.0171456933,
0.0176159218,
-0.007519966,
0.0476423167,
-0.0183029231,
-0.027205687,
-0.0289315227,
0.0433363989,
0.0054876418,
-0.0058473977,
-0.0068846704,
0.0030158565,
0.0004305552,
0.0078204274,
0.0224483237,
0.0184087027,
0.011978833,
-0.0363516659,
0.0033282235,
-0.0111507066,
-0.0250810217,
0.0467514284,
0.02084505,
0.0368309803,
-0.0113087315,
-0.0219387244,
-0.0161703415,
0.0344563425,
-0.0448804125,
0.0480624773,
0.030873714,
0.0013609789,
0.0400156155,
0.0344186276,
-0.033690691,
0.0163922943,
-0.0423595905,
-0.0043667611,
0.06137003,
0.0180852953,
0.0842950642,
-0.0270155873,
0.0070591001,
-0.0106080966,
0.019146245,
-0.0092054596,
-0.0165510513,
-0.0194238722,
-0.0165376738,
0.0074719554,
0.0357577689,
0.0424099304,
0.0052103344,
0.026030656,
-0.0344419032,
-0.0195996687,
-0.0088003436,
0.0112677664,
-0.0048515485,
0.0117769828,
-0.0226994734,
-0.0341567621,
-0.0143510262,
-0.0697036237,
-0.0081373071,
0.0545175374,
-0.0021635331,
0.0074550719,
0.0082575511,
0.0799615011,
-0.0242367256,
-0.0157528743,
-0.0149917519,
-0.0136172017,
0.0271541663,
-0.0147428699,
-0.0046001887,
-6.290752058e-33,
-0.0379369371,
-0.0205125678,
0.0218746979,
-0.0709598064,
-0.0503925271,
0.0404252857,
-0.0220996086,
-0.023781212,
-0.0060066334,
-0.0019655128,
-0.0182137508,
0.0280094501,
0.0257526916,
-0.035123799,
-0.0018820703,
0.0169248562,
0.0676905215,
0.002524565,
-0.0525843799,
0.0035250543,
0.0259549934,
0.0009997436,
0.067112729,
-0.0559051074,
0.0300422795,
-0.0081247436,
-0.0467633568,
-0.0163170677,
-0.0479398444,
0.0453372598,
0.0158529524,
0.0421783365,
0.0127760349,
-0.0661816075,
-0.0425335355,
0.0022414618,
-0.0666336417,
0.0013382097,
-0.0042638113,
0.0616583973,
-0.0555364974,
-0.0046479627,
0.0387467779,
-0.0541522764,
-0.0175738446,
0.0014032471,
-0.015173506,
-0.0175272468,
-0.0510743447,
-0.0346492827,
-0.0400209092,
0.0297770239,
-0.0076302551,
0.0061629703,
0.050811775,
0.0385028906,
0.0235458184,
-0.0452224426,
-0.0743516684,
-0.0035563568,
0.0060301116,
0.0399080701,
0.0702815652,
0.0063315006,
-0.0113397054,
0.0070709218,
0.0123677738,
0.0117238937,
0.0518007353,
-0.0551015101,
0.0419440009,
-0.0367605463,
0.0472864918,
0.0383311287,
0.0601424277,
-0.0648481473,
-0.0578708872,
0.0375061221,
0.0101895891,
-0.0100384364,
0.0281809308,
0.0104110735,
-0.0499412157,
-0.0062526232,
-0.0637712479,
-0.0279266443,
-0.0266825445,
-0.0283118822,
0.0356715173,
0.0703813881,
-0.0004900805,
0.0079774093,
0.0499393977,
-0.0157551952,
0.0221369341,
0.0027808025,
-0.0489080995,
-0.0049981135,
-0.0338969678,
0.0203763675,
-0.0023365582,
-0.0472810119,
0.0164211225,
0.041978132,
0.0173772555,
-0.0393132307,
0.0637628362,
0.0178688783,
-0.0337751545,
0.0284439344,
-0.0359946527,
0.039463874,
0.0096419156,
-0.0631880984,
0.0449557267,
-0.0206857827,
-0.0024541055,
0.0399198085,
0.0574358739,
-0.0608052053,
-0.0501871966,
0.0434591919,
0.0057231663,
0.0535881259,
-0.0276679546,
0.0148201874,
-0.0022351923,
0.0128787877,
0.0685458258,
-0.0571370125,
-0.0503287129,
-0.0002224196,
2.714e-7,
0.0133127673,
0.0304581746,
-0.0081047723,
0.0276609007,
0.0367640406,
0.0287741255,
-0.0286808088,
0.0550624505,
-0.012109926,
0.0441284776,
0.0242315196,
0.0113330558,
0.0685099959,
0.0136841098,
-0.0334187262,
-0.0594680421,
-0.0462168604,
0.0556067936,
-0.0390447862,
0.0336348824,
0.0334039144,
0.0585144795,
-0.0205737222,
0.0008492632,
0.0143129285,
-0.0135836359,
0.06713406,
-0.0027840496,
0.0412473567,
-0.0020781474,
0.0242108982,
0.0162624214,
-0.0039368779,
0.0032690091,
-0.0471606441,
-0.0100736944,
0.0043041096,
0.0563839711,
0.0140660172,
-0.0136796292,
0.0481721573,
-0.0140080703,
-0.0212314744,
-0.0388381444,
0.0717142522,
-0.0443403237,
0.033593189,
-0.0132578677,
0.0146573531,
-0.0123507353,
0.0304209534,
-0.008613267,
-0.026642289,
0.0216769353,
0.0329612158,
0.0270754434,
-0.0319395289,
-0.0540605746,
-0.0438290499,
0.009453021,
-0.0157017726,
-0.0452938266,
-0.0254295338,
0.0106158461,
-0.0166323315,
-0.0369570479,
-0.009000645,
2.548746111e-34,
0.0438536555,
-0.0317271836,
0.023306543,
-0.0040462953,
0.0138002224,
-0.0445493534,
0.0180104822,
0.0073481076,
0.0017371227,
0.0090769734,
-0.0379739143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07064v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07064v2 | Prompt have evil twins | 2023-11-13T04:08:49 | 2024-04-29T12:57:55 | Rimon Melamed, Lucas H. McCabe, Tanay Wakhare, Yejin Kim, H. Howie Huang, Enric Boix-Adsera | cs.CL | cs.CL | We discover that many natural-language prompts can be replaced by
corresponding prompts that are unintelligible to humans but that provably
elicit similar behavior in language models. We call these prompts "evil twins"
because they are obfuscated and uninterpretable (evil), but at the same time
mimic the functionality of the original natural-language prompts (twins).
Remarkably, evil twins transfer between models. We find these prompts by
solving a maximum-likelihood problem which has applications of independent
interest. | [
0.0488673821,
0.0616909824,
-0.0402201451,
0.0543047413,
-0.0499961562,
0.0206183381,
0.0039991774,
0.042666845,
0.0116149597,
-0.0367120653,
-0.0439625569,
-0.0346220061,
0.0084515521,
0.0234890729,
0.0455605462,
-0.0439473055,
0.057115797,
-0.0588102862,
0.0095284199,
-0.0292705186,
-0.0334522687,
0.0004192186,
0.0234443843,
0.041614078,
0.0376933999,
-0.0176450126,
-0.0170348827,
0.0268838592,
-0.039571438,
0.000427614,
-0.0373227112,
0.0273049455,
-0.0065434454,
0.0833797976,
0.0000018535,
-0.0591837242,
0.0084637934,
-0.0130469035,
-0.0917881951,
0.0055358908,
0.0247319154,
0.0102733672,
0.0096815974,
0.0005753711,
-0.0182657037,
-0.0005091224,
0.055453036,
0.0319273286,
0.0299163889,
0.038257394,
0.0104898475,
-0.0043825624,
0.0072264308,
-0.028255472,
0.0575985424,
-0.0325726308,
0.027026087,
-0.064158015,
0.0340249389,
0.0278558303,
0.0179000124,
0.0108754691,
-0.0054409266,
-0.0002039127,
-0.0514546745,
0.0177961383,
0.0166564472,
-0.0234740842,
-0.022972364,
0.0474470109,
-0.0214066096,
-0.0215892233,
0.0183010418,
0.0084314598,
0.0366729014,
0.0353661589,
-0.0070681232,
0.0410506129,
-0.0049289493,
0.0146341473,
0.040091712,
-0.011017248,
0.0392133109,
-0.0071190004,
-0.0083124917,
0.0837234557,
0.0282686725,
-0.0135794571,
0.0047946349,
-0.0173876788,
-0.0486782156,
-0.0765155107,
-0.0006381514,
-0.0039344542,
-0.034536913,
0.0123850238,
-0.0604971685,
0.0047340207,
0.0172098726,
-0.0215037223,
0.0517770015,
0.0261883419,
-0.037035428,
0.0805048645,
-0.0327753201,
0.0352829918,
-0.0168757495,
0.041703593,
-0.019537257,
0.0313523859,
-0.0120283617,
-0.0378607474,
-0.050759919,
0.0266009476,
-0.0349017233,
-0.0115012527,
0.0489917621,
0.0296308324,
-0.012921649,
0.0295408629,
-0.0311173312,
-0.0189028718,
-0.0165823344,
-0.0273657404,
-0.0163348783,
-0.028713068,
-0.0363657884,
-0.010026183,
0.0162672065,
-0.083666943,
-0.0013308492,
-0.0037925448,
-0.011183016,
-0.0054751225,
-0.0206660554,
0.0972765163,
-0.0123894336,
0.0065380475,
-0.0058676982,
-0.0212389864,
-0.0220660903,
-0.0049329754,
-0.0355740041,
-0.0435542651,
0.0182635318,
-0.0002929082,
-0.0058829412,
-0.0954428837,
0.0170503668,
-0.0052699936,
-0.0711349025,
0.1305449456,
-0.0593766421,
-0.0034145589,
0.0127468919,
0.0148927988,
-0.0286417324,
0.0413793623,
-0.0245829821,
0.0237576831,
0.0569800735,
-0.0117662959,
0.0503236912,
0.0454680473,
-0.0061997664,
0.0248011984,
0.0041978117,
-0.0257057603,
0.0580078475,
-0.0110363811,
-0.0068276715,
0.0402575806,
-0.0142311696,
-0.0229040477,
0.0583504662,
0.0493251756,
-0.0676744655,
0.001203982,
0.0658358186,
0.0019541222,
-0.0489582121,
0.0916627198,
-0.0554394051,
-0.0189373121,
-0.0657846779,
-0.0026881997,
0.0030647421,
-0.0217806064,
-0.0178233199,
-0.0123791462,
-0.0034962823,
-0.0199784338,
0.0119359568,
-0.0338885188,
0.0245981589,
0.0264437664,
-0.0475205705,
0.010730681,
0.0209116321,
-0.0091283005,
0.0184841659,
-0.071230039,
0.0195714124,
0.0534752235,
0.0362907611,
-0.00684743,
0.0430150814,
-0.0052084192,
-0.0192279629,
0.0348223299,
0.0391873643,
0.0079320641,
0.0154369697,
-0.0023910389,
-0.0094350846,
-0.0131701175,
0.0428907648,
0.0463412777,
-0.0838839188,
-0.0098234825,
0.0040717009,
0.0050950036,
0.0270081852,
0.0227726884,
-0.0566725247,
-0.0187108219,
-0.0065888185,
0.0013562238,
-0.0048228926,
-0.0130767124,
-0.0077130878,
0.0487162992,
0.0171557218,
-0.0239046551,
-0.0173839219,
0.0048481245,
-0.020921912,
-0.0103841247,
0.0178165082,
-0.0288157854,
-0.0055478248,
0.0576749891,
0.0287412796,
-0.0352029353,
0.0317700356,
-0.0407349356,
0.0588758439,
-0.0179066341,
0.0816507563,
-0.0217988025,
0.0165734272,
-0.0155044431,
0.0444259755,
-0.0047507128,
0.0358961411,
0.0280636232,
-0.0400383249,
0.0065089618,
-0.054345537,
-0.0212860107,
0.0135285025,
-0.0117039653,
-0.0022365111,
0.0324035436,
-0.0160385109,
-0.0090041123,
-0.0531861968,
0.0001659357,
-0.0209740177,
0.0048239459,
0.0035786417,
0.0589066781,
-0.0036592318,
-0.0104290387,
-0.0167000089,
-0.0381628722,
-0.0068329521,
0.0062134122,
0.0212736856,
0.0274938606,
-0.0024992074,
-0.0368989073,
-0.0081728678,
-0.0040243962,
-0.0103851976,
0.0431119539,
-0.0174319111,
-0.036359176,
-0.1094371974,
0.0571942739,
-0.0020125897,
0.0304346792,
-0.0077704978,
-0.012998784,
0.0223783702,
-0.0320806801,
0.0224746652,
0.0589373745,
-0.0283410437,
0.0284912102,
0.0335705727,
-0.0016058809,
-0.0466145724,
-0.0339052901,
-0.0166046452,
-0.0294332076,
-0.0437661409,
-0.0771107003,
-0.0033091628,
0.0721948966,
0.0244466253,
-0.0034942147,
-0.038252335,
0.049081333,
-0.0139964735,
-0.0665639788,
-0.0461155288,
-0.0750219524,
-0.0121214064,
0.0790971369,
-0.027867537,
-0.0537056103,
0.0630713999,
-0.0548733659,
-0.0101414593,
0.0030690194,
0.0049559772,
0.0324456505,
0.0712152123,
0.015603343,
0.0038745296,
0.0584777892,
-0.045050811,
-0.044856213,
-0.0046111336,
0.0253202319,
-0.0174697768,
-0.0164908227,
-0.0477271639,
-0.0036002004,
0.0226724669,
-0.0557957701,
-0.0310929287,
-0.0913257599,
-0.0098033873,
-0.0069407788,
0.0077147689,
-0.0123106642,
-0.0425554514,
0.0185134672,
0.0174641423,
0.0129789021,
-0.00248237,
-0.0090967845,
-0.0592074916,
0.0372714363,
0.0515307002,
-0.002347707,
0.0025630207,
-0.0514394231,
0.0480472147,
0.0179370213,
0.0096185198,
0.0532718711,
0.0365665816,
0.023398567,
0.0589396618,
0.0100047253,
-0.0491386391,
0.0452263206,
0.0358444825,
-0.0009830744,
-0.026794361,
0.1072835028,
0.0245592128,
-0.0306422003,
0.0283537842,
-0.0392162688,
0.0108347842,
0.0188463684,
-0.0129655087,
-0.0647748113,
-0.025074156,
0.051793389,
0.0164388306,
-0.0306540392,
-0.0429750308,
-0.0244358275,
-0.1097973213,
-0.0102361925,
0.0075580589,
-0.0077926232,
-0.0393476449,
0.0036755756,
0.0151851885,
0.0197732225,
0.0145318173,
0.0065947049,
0.0051552546,
0.0241141394,
-0.0072615705,
0.0242988616,
0.0206564926,
-0.0077363318,
-0.0047045574,
0.0742403492,
0.0802520514,
-0.000795922,
-0.0092380801,
-0.04899453,
-0.0077996277,
-0.0411040708,
0.0158470999,
-0.0003323954,
0.0157195572,
0.0374702625,
-0.0461509675,
-0.0326800048,
0.042880442,
-0.0161933564,
-0.0220143888,
0.0117801866,
0.0442479663,
-0.0122773796,
-0.0806283876,
0.0228105132,
-0.0083934227,
0.0394989997,
0.0860549137,
0.0496097133,
-0.059092056,
0.0076826229,
-0.0498868637,
0.0461701453,
0.0251933672,
-0.0503485017,
0.0189398155,
0.0105867116,
-0.0401228629,
-0.0634841174,
-0.0127146896,
0.0006513749,
0.0382367074,
0.0555574857,
0.0261091441,
-0.0006797005,
-0.0348516926,
0.0273530204,
-0.024778977,
-0.064520143,
0.0163076017,
-0.0496565923,
-0.0047330079,
-0.011857952,
-0.0328831449,
-0.0383521467,
0.0043269894,
-0.0358952805,
-0.0517839417,
0.0146529237,
0.0175410472,
0.0359165594,
0.026585022,
-0.0394454598,
-0.0459871553,
-0.0138644259,
0.0158454105,
-0.0285254661,
0.010319504,
0.0397173874,
0.0197129194,
-0.0040476504,
0.0555265397,
-0.0065985504,
-0.0047167288,
0.0305421669,
-0.0128114559,
-0.0676484257,
-0.0410817191,
0.0598773435,
0.0549527332,
0.0571299903,
0.0017293283,
0.0217053201,
-0.0023662839,
0.0045229676,
0.0085748378,
-0.0047627194,
-0.0378002673,
-0.0123066595,
0.0446363352,
0.0076676584,
0.0344157554,
-0.0358153097,
0.0036149195,
0.026981432,
-0.0402041078,
-0.0090985624,
0.0190249085,
0.0871050358,
0.0148742376,
0.0064944974,
0.0219419654,
0.097274363,
0.0104816975,
0.0478682443,
-0.0206646901,
0.0674225166,
0.0104935141,
-0.0163930021,
0.0113724908,
0.0451525711,
-0.0625509247,
-0.0804786906,
0.0400187448,
0.0336020403,
0.0119704744,
-0.0049423054,
0.0290718898,
-0.0178354848,
-0.0061204433,
-0.0232473779,
0.0167113598,
0.0517151579,
-0.0245575048,
-0.0091056414,
0.0182836633,
-0.025722485,
-0.0100323288,
0.0697167069,
-0.0518989712,
0.043675527,
-0.013160645,
0.0055234022,
-0.0276686084,
0.0129457638,
0.0362115651,
0.0413446054,
-0.0077396417,
0.0287357233,
-0.0416552648,
-0.0500319041,
-0.053690128,
0.0059563466,
0.0297836326,
-0.0074198283,
0.0122855827,
0.0595200285,
-0.0200935323,
-0.0028639222,
-0.0414975211,
0.0540248305,
0.0393972844,
-0.0189329293,
-0.0257357396,
-6.060194269e-33,
-0.0258757509,
-0.0229829308,
-0.0608240142,
-0.0023719652,
0.0387974791,
-0.0135313803,
-0.0409003459,
0.0227395538,
-0.0379153378,
-0.0085945269,
-0.0191466641,
-0.0143335741,
0.0182402283,
-0.0223771017,
-0.0079562478,
-0.0133334696,
0.0352487266,
0.0134767434,
-0.0225061905,
-0.0027346106,
0.0614320673,
-0.0008415997,
0.0388615355,
-0.0462417006,
0.082430996,
-0.0314875953,
-0.0474101752,
0.0224462971,
-0.0223536212,
0.02128122,
-0.030898381,
0.0077432413,
0.0017464262,
-0.0608071424,
-0.0349021517,
0.0467040278,
-0.034362562,
-0.0301837828,
0.0675452501,
-0.0166160837,
-0.0246531907,
-0.0473812893,
0.0367538705,
-0.0491380654,
-0.0420381464,
0.0306931138,
0.0077557918,
-0.0273606759,
0.00319866,
0.0740031675,
-0.0548374429,
-0.0191791505,
-0.0265276842,
-0.034422759,
0.0341633074,
0.0276393071,
-0.0017928001,
-0.0315177664,
-0.0433045514,
0.0571008697,
0.0226343311,
0.0333795771,
0.0363352895,
-0.0118248295,
-0.0124454219,
0.0583365075,
0.0749266297,
-0.0157163311,
-0.0193582475,
-0.0005479035,
0.0094179809,
0.0404167622,
0.0540920235,
0.0362684689,
0.0256831516,
-0.0344940461,
0.0005788932,
0.0311731119,
0.0032217756,
-0.026774168,
0.0158945043,
-0.0101745585,
-0.0499206558,
-0.0294538904,
-0.0456234105,
-0.0656163096,
-0.0381703377,
-0.0215329044,
0.0124157816,
-0.0311303847,
-0.0137323095,
-0.0244267192,
0.022567885,
-0.0442978144,
-0.0306914728,
-0.0290002134,
0.0290530045,
0.0059087276,
-0.0010477969,
0.0105632236,
0.0221941862,
-0.0367035754,
0.0092109963,
0.0140778795,
0.0409540236,
0.0493215285,
0.0127231898,
-0.0072903028,
-0.086425133,
0.0077665481,
-0.0338292904,
-0.0010294446,
0.0210901853,
-0.0282804836,
0.0627167374,
-0.026550917,
-0.0157117322,
-0.0067021037,
0.0241217185,
-0.0406789146,
-0.0388894454,
0.0366128273,
-0.0510640442,
0.0220804978,
-0.0430416726,
-0.0053202133,
-0.0513520129,
0.0135886576,
0.0564749688,
-0.0050478801,
-0.0123030394,
-0.0199923292,
2.567e-7,
0.0339186527,
0.0011423056,
0.0217857584,
0.0127108367,
0.055239182,
0.074568063,
-0.0341675058,
0.0542942472,
-0.0053339549,
-0.0537656881,
-0.0180674233,
-0.0189028941,
0.0221975781,
-0.0051682508,
-0.0832140967,
0.0407860652,
-0.0738614425,
0.0109128319,
-0.044735536,
0.002376494,
0.0705656782,
0.0872836187,
0.0387686901,
-0.0077105369,
0.0154757686,
-0.0622539259,
-0.0117749786,
-0.0694306195,
0.0151993381,
-0.0055526919,
-0.0090473173,
-0.0188015122,
0.0098494273,
0.0407927483,
0.0006371941,
-0.0371574052,
0.0313227437,
0.0269646924,
0.0156817641,
0.0151069136,
-0.0257104691,
-0.0216592029,
-0.0031678372,
-0.0490475968,
0.0749092698,
0.0131602185,
-0.0484026708,
-0.012861087,
-0.005722566,
-0.0002443922,
0.0027703778,
0.0035506471,
-0.0323037729,
0.0151907643,
-0.0047540343,
0.0574488901,
0.0034371852,
-0.0185052957,
-0.0046518357,
-0.0360927656,
-0.0238898657,
-0.0661484152,
-0.0438224673,
0.0119831637,
0.0191301517,
-0.0848327503,
0.0081042172,
2.293245985e-34,
0.0155904423,
0.0213035196,
0.0431054607,
0.0183268823,
0.0250797346,
-0.0018463226,
0.0007669607,
0.0396843329,
0.0398970395,
-0.05608394,
-0.0160656199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07052v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07052v1 | Towards the Law of Capacity Gap in Distilling Language Models | 2023-11-13T03:36:18 | 2023-11-13T03:36:18 | Chen Zhang, Dawei Song, Zheyu Ye, Yan Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Language model (LM) distillation is a trending area that aims to distil the
knowledge resided in a large teacher LM to a small student one. While various
methods have been proposed to push the distillation to its limits, it is still
a pain distilling LMs when a large capacity gap is exhibited between the
teacher and the student LMs. The pain is mainly resulted by the curse of
capacity gap, which describes that a larger teacher LM cannot always lead to a
better student LM than one distilled from a smaller teacher LM due to the
affect of capacity gap increment. That is, there is likely an optimal point
yielding the best student LM along the scaling course of the teacher LM. Even
worse, the curse of capacity gap can be only partly yet not fully lifted as
indicated in previous studies.
However, the tale is not ever one-sided. Although a larger teacher LM has
better performance than a smaller teacher LM, it is much more
resource-demanding especially in the context of recent large LMs (LLMs).
Consequently, instead of sticking to lifting the curse, leaving the curse as is
should be arguably fine. Even better, in this paper, we reveal that the optimal
capacity gap is almost consistent across different student scales and
architectures, fortunately turning the curse into the law of capacity gap. The
law later guides us to distil a 3B student LM (termed MiniMA) from a 7B teacher
LM (adapted LLaMA2-7B). MiniMA is demonstrated to yield a new
compute-performance pareto frontier among existing 3B LMs on commonly used
benchmarks, and its instruction-tuned version (termed MiniChat) outperforms a
wide range of 3B competitors in GPT4 evaluation and could even compete with
several 7B chat models. | [
0.0395007506,
0.03597074,
-0.0321810916,
0.0375814661,
-0.0425004773,
-0.0100343702,
0.0019651779,
0.0010949227,
-0.0209379084,
0.0102928579,
-0.0381377935,
-0.0783794895,
-0.006645727,
0.0217396859,
0.0112850266,
-0.0656033829,
0.0317762159,
-0.0691280216,
-0.0061834846,
-0.0312189776,
0.0009681194,
-0.0143466117,
0.0202036761,
0.002557979,
0.0436984226,
-0.0110454476,
-0.0260690376,
-0.0028054016,
-0.0199818648,
-0.0005942407,
0.0140516758,
0.0300438888,
0.0178252421,
0.0053793346,
0.0000025807,
-0.0489621647,
-0.0011383403,
-0.0093323691,
-0.0010773549,
0.0966870412,
0.0608064756,
0.0079461737,
-0.022276599,
0.033980906,
-0.0162057504,
0.0156271961,
0.0326156095,
-0.0429926328,
0.0658095255,
0.0439257249,
0.0055331313,
-0.0574761815,
0.0382551551,
-0.0168012325,
-0.0365319587,
-0.0505502373,
0.0127909044,
0.0179656222,
0.0447116345,
0.0067579495,
-0.0589728281,
0.0139501356,
0.0187104866,
-0.0074358974,
-0.0378377996,
0.0360220447,
-0.027353676,
-0.0195544902,
-0.0114544248,
0.041599147,
-0.010521289,
0.0071735443,
0.0098110074,
0.005992014,
-0.0332293808,
-0.03873422,
-0.0518849455,
0.0204530507,
0.0023650334,
0.0334337838,
0.0162763949,
-0.0179265197,
0.0276806001,
0.0063646752,
-0.0297622047,
0.0602243096,
0.020870233,
-0.0169891249,
-0.0294523593,
-0.0153501481,
-0.0549831316,
0.0017214552,
0.0131926164,
0.0400848985,
-0.0034355726,
0.030931022,
-0.0549317673,
0.0060660001,
0.0172870439,
-0.030905189,
0.0472455397,
0.0428044945,
0.0242607538,
0.0138122011,
0.002806067,
0.0579708144,
-0.0148932198,
0.0156324729,
-0.0463080518,
0.0120725809,
-0.0112231607,
0.0153895495,
-0.0490437075,
0.0369377472,
-0.0251110457,
-0.0211274587,
-0.0439650491,
0.0074993172,
-0.0085370801,
-0.0215832181,
0.0352007896,
-0.0464684069,
-0.0425703079,
-0.0035224652,
-0.0306695141,
0.0671650693,
-0.0286369212,
-0.0050707092,
0.0054979064,
-0.1131838113,
-0.009387699,
-0.021996906,
-0.0288998131,
-0.0213088989,
0.0278056934,
0.0489994325,
-0.0201028567,
-0.0189810954,
-0.0404005721,
-0.0027735108,
0.0003458189,
-0.1102393568,
-0.0122982068,
-0.0628459677,
0.0218781736,
0.0072937026,
-0.001332465,
-0.0336821303,
0.008861688,
0.0102662947,
-0.0307959784,
0.0018307754,
-0.0034899039,
0.0183084365,
0.0267523658,
0.0483898185,
0.0083834482,
0.0908894241,
0.058004804,
0.0245484635,
0.0127093885,
-0.0092377504,
-0.0561979525,
0.037189059,
0.0603525527,
0.0447545573,
-0.0363025479,
-0.0143764708,
0.006040174,
-0.0079297265,
0.043620415,
0.1225161999,
-0.0307593532,
-0.0175779965,
0.040520519,
0.0450681224,
0.0167196281,
0.0117084961,
-0.0099968724,
0.0299974438,
0.0218183249,
0.0173931159,
-0.0093594994,
0.003990788,
0.0427087136,
0.0019320982,
0.1073380187,
0.0711159483,
-0.0060397433,
-0.047744073,
-0.0205879509,
-0.0056095123,
-0.0182705838,
-0.017309187,
0.0772300884,
-0.035326764,
-0.0337429084,
0.1000325382,
0.0373633243,
-0.0485963933,
-0.0027156174,
-0.0974509865,
-0.0048721656,
0.0361018069,
0.0217951201,
-0.002413396,
0.0000345572,
0.0327419154,
0.0169494376,
0.0201377925,
0.0534165278,
0.028370712,
0.0132325366,
-0.0511789583,
-0.0098116891,
0.0070534013,
-0.0019110657,
-0.0174804069,
0.0364229046,
0.0393553413,
0.0235671327,
-0.0372307338,
-0.0478112437,
0.0068357233,
-0.0076582306,
0.0039020758,
-0.0183105152,
-0.0164357647,
0.0336022973,
-0.0046482976,
-0.018398229,
-0.0127689634,
0.025065776,
-0.037302874,
0.0248080976,
-0.0287828315,
-0.0739295706,
-0.0015009891,
0.0339222215,
0.003247841,
0.0779294968,
0.0228569508,
-0.0556973107,
-0.0663667172,
0.0812820569,
-0.0214305986,
0.0567945465,
-0.0164824855,
0.0846144333,
-0.0317992307,
0.0180350337,
-0.0153661706,
0.0598752163,
-0.0376813747,
0.0020778563,
-0.0146548878,
0.0695240349,
0.0062837182,
0.018417526,
-0.0552404746,
0.0280628521,
0.0178635456,
0.0293170828,
-0.0302808341,
0.003909871,
-0.0231448989,
-0.0314196832,
-0.0415765904,
0.0237612519,
-0.0290845837,
0.0548200719,
0.0168763883,
0.0275402144,
0.0068909163,
0.0068683168,
0.0056854887,
0.0074301716,
-0.0165459812,
0.0168804508,
-0.0070887771,
0.0189804472,
-0.0652841777,
-0.0326527841,
-0.0452179946,
0.0053410134,
0.0031216319,
-0.0099249119,
0.0082811257,
-0.0152419209,
0.0624886155,
-0.0226298738,
0.0312608033,
-0.0267459005,
-0.0414088853,
0.0092384033,
-0.0456338003,
0.0451238528,
0.0447542816,
-0.032497894,
0.0213688277,
0.0753509626,
0.0044508018,
-0.0585069731,
0.0407620482,
0.0170702692,
-0.0533270091,
-0.0243152659,
-0.0317097344,
-0.0205906406,
0.0935673788,
-0.0171984863,
-0.0258817375,
-0.0386192203,
-0.0288460813,
-0.0284816679,
0.024072405,
0.0043778201,
0.0359092653,
-0.0310251266,
0.0146277528,
-0.0347370766,
-0.0967908427,
0.0200068075,
-0.0340537839,
-0.0008118633,
-0.0623126291,
-0.0308531877,
-0.0409124978,
0.0508037657,
0.0144290272,
0.0184865724,
-0.0563992113,
-0.0214660577,
-0.0218754932,
0.0531376749,
0.0140911685,
-0.0536740348,
0.0531976372,
-0.0581898578,
0.0190610141,
-0.0474283025,
-0.0327564068,
0.0092144515,
0.0584515631,
-0.0050049494,
0.0104355114,
0.0924360901,
-0.0241368301,
0.0179717652,
0.0277617089,
-0.0161807891,
0.0348438993,
-0.0063398331,
0.0050567538,
-0.0084675811,
0.0118574109,
0.0004094314,
-0.0066071041,
-0.0102108363,
-0.0191546753,
0.0295769945,
0.0353373177,
0.0808577612,
-0.0103020491,
-0.0088953041,
-0.0195794031,
0.0650524125,
-0.0025330768,
-0.056194514,
0.0629318133,
0.0541032329,
-0.0588308237,
-0.0180192553,
0.0782219693,
0.0045976937,
-0.0123596881,
0.0167242978,
0.0097361701,
0.0712373182,
0.0149696935,
0.0254731532,
-0.0802534446,
0.0092518385,
0.0046385829,
0.0096667875,
0.0140496641,
0.0180065632,
-0.0614637621,
-0.1109717414,
0.0135903601,
0.0083339596,
0.0088761328,
-0.0027930269,
-0.0555680878,
-0.0034782679,
0.0075271255,
0.0309810434,
0.0267011635,
-0.0262778942,
0.0142179839,
0.038534984,
-0.0058470168,
-0.0600795485,
-0.0009884913,
-0.0047165244,
0.0532298051,
0.0059397742,
0.0108713526,
-0.0306395441,
-0.0739022419,
0.0422189794,
-0.003018731,
-0.0109615214,
-0.0164068397,
0.0132941091,
0.0303345416,
-0.0285072532,
0.0062450571,
-0.0250552408,
0.0144317606,
0.0336823799,
0.0174089074,
0.0516632833,
0.0185140502,
-0.0259352122,
-0.0038890897,
-0.0269736256,
-0.0229055341,
0.0652924776,
0.0152060883,
-0.0161873773,
-0.0523981676,
-0.0208863001,
-0.0264867414,
-0.0360354409,
0.001916049,
0.0191730503,
-0.0092203524,
0.0132368002,
0.0188694634,
0.0324446298,
-0.026573766,
0.0366856456,
0.0124316365,
0.0346337259,
0.0152112199,
0.0320608877,
-0.0440223441,
-0.0442525633,
-0.0242634658,
0.02203664,
-0.0917178616,
-0.0197191387,
0.0053965147,
0.0182385873,
-0.0210249405,
-0.0135478564,
-0.1240278259,
-0.0868856236,
-0.0154761411,
0.0460603163,
0.019973224,
0.0000039464,
0.0312000457,
-0.0618068054,
0.0471973494,
0.0191277564,
-0.0127001898,
0.0557926372,
0.0205060206,
-0.0268560331,
0.022411095,
0.0211765971,
-0.0176590718,
0.0242396928,
0.0052397279,
0.0555087142,
-0.0194556229,
-0.0127869183,
-0.0181692187,
0.0504925735,
0.0015580762,
0.0133880107,
-0.0103485379,
0.01255327,
0.0280175228,
-0.004467559,
0.0292121693,
-0.0420654528,
-0.0321115665,
0.0187790599,
-0.000046558,
-0.0091433451,
-0.0170674343,
0.0602130592,
0.0080822129,
-0.0194983315,
0.039672479,
-0.0254571326,
-0.0049640415,
0.064762108,
0.0024067904,
-0.003045894,
-0.0107010482,
0.0204409994,
0.0614197478,
-0.0300075356,
0.0516093485,
-0.0133870412,
0.0165120009,
0.0127259474,
0.035565421,
-0.0295362677,
-0.0783414543,
-0.0341013409,
0.0239753276,
0.0022104082,
0.0564084686,
0.0483645648,
-0.0234751236,
0.0225905403,
-0.0264287051,
-0.0123646315,
-0.040583916,
-0.0327775292,
0.0137274349,
0.001421526,
0.0120661957,
0.0200744681,
0.0792305693,
0.0159934051,
0.0336800888,
0.0000179576,
0.0467853919,
0.0028354905,
-0.0401913337,
-0.0206815936,
0.0366831869,
0.0378097557,
-0.0124831218,
-0.0405613109,
-0.0400243178,
-0.0547825508,
-0.0101547968,
0.0271851905,
-0.0506334454,
0.0195264891,
0.0570148118,
-0.0185743421,
-0.0298970882,
-0.0289970431,
-0.030277729,
0.0119897518,
0.0089709563,
0.0505464561,
-7.244912577e-33,
-0.0374518111,
0.0341682546,
0.0255481303,
0.0086195106,
-0.0170280542,
0.0175115503,
-0.0143822925,
-0.0184671655,
-0.0501177348,
-0.0257550459,
-0.0314727724,
0.0231204536,
0.0292851832,
0.0194698405,
0.0046303901,
0.0399296246,
0.0632646754,
-0.0042640376,
-0.0148288961,
0.06413991,
-0.0179791935,
0.0256959163,
0.0253102444,
-0.008598092,
-0.0341216102,
-0.0566423684,
0.0118265003,
0.0033930733,
-0.008370324,
0.0223387089,
-0.0160220601,
0.0679833069,
0.0212385692,
-0.0832957849,
-0.0149842706,
-0.0326731242,
-0.0387180187,
-0.0443973243,
0.0412006825,
0.0128665501,
-0.00506191,
-0.0318023339,
0.0317991823,
0.0389985032,
-0.0397865623,
-0.0289897285,
-0.0113972407,
0.0101041216,
-0.0321935415,
0.004599676,
-0.0225087795,
0.0148755182,
0.0391487144,
0.0150620202,
0.0150832757,
-0.0471410751,
-0.0358993486,
-0.0154797379,
-0.0334357135,
0.0325566679,
0.0589944422,
0.0941976383,
0.0735784099,
0.0399862006,
-0.0238942932,
0.0277793687,
0.0153408321,
0.0027130691,
0.0004905066,
-0.0540512651,
0.0592101887,
0.0539068282,
-0.0412839428,
-0.0275207013,
0.065593034,
-0.0328114331,
-0.06124264,
-0.0357705541,
0.0610460378,
0.0292955153,
-0.0050969264,
0.0103935897,
-0.0580321476,
-0.0725104362,
-0.0324057899,
-0.0157058798,
-0.0279453453,
-0.0400138833,
0.0302921608,
0.0015677594,
-0.0399191864,
-0.0428182036,
0.0201510694,
-0.0453784578,
-0.0349131562,
0.0133754844,
-0.0200176425,
0.0208120067,
-0.0259019304,
0.0329091921,
-0.0835662186,
-0.0709478259,
-0.0267836545,
0.0016206822,
0.0013367392,
-0.0041134907,
-0.0174586512,
0.0050850352,
-0.059477482,
-0.0103950994,
-0.0436150618,
0.0059102406,
0.0199662298,
0.019778451,
0.0249128081,
-0.0129544837,
0.0004390986,
0.0026947078,
0.022351075,
-0.0131476084,
-0.0202578548,
-0.005099874,
-0.0056590443,
-0.0021088445,
-0.0160609409,
0.0357302502,
-0.0508015864,
0.0384222642,
0.0322600864,
-0.061077781,
-0.0536281578,
0.0074835722,
3.251e-7,
-0.0138983289,
0.0270871148,
0.0063504716,
-0.0017273355,
-0.0005284277,
-0.0174762793,
0.0056396611,
0.0127955908,
0.0136698447,
-0.0038860405,
-0.0155992256,
0.0542324148,
0.0250844788,
0.0380818173,
-0.0266575776,
0.0297820847,
-0.0660739392,
-0.0187413562,
-0.0352772437,
-0.0357198454,
0.0039965971,
0.0500391945,
0.0174463857,
-0.0368578061,
-0.0350556374,
-0.0459599271,
-0.0051286113,
-0.0035439224,
0.0248412658,
0.0545668267,
0.0120000914,
0.0373257101,
-0.0296174083,
0.0182641502,
0.0147331981,
-0.0033374408,
-0.0316092372,
0.0871578753,
0.0134436926,
0.0198605359,
0.0516214818,
0.0100237895,
-0.0361041464,
-0.0343728736,
0.0648833662,
0.0195420515,
0.0063000768,
0.0103981281,
0.0181505121,
-0.0564582944,
0.0005276279,
-0.002996963,
0.0294573084,
0.0286770407,
-0.0161516685,
-0.0440441445,
-0.0255504679,
-0.049249582,
-0.0163555183,
-0.022811057,
-0.0190925952,
-0.1070847884,
-0.0733212009,
0.0018919788,
-0.014748361,
-0.0093802214,
0.0143718934,
3.149524743e-34,
0.0504029207,
-0.0505464002,
0.0605344512,
0.0267711934,
0.0006134263,
0.0213915017,
-0.0363390222,
0.0209048428,
-0.0222627185,
-0.0762277022,
-0.0365692489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07037v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07037v1 | Phonological Level wav2vec2-based Mispronunciation Detection and Diagnosis Method | 2023-11-13T02:41:41 | 2023-11-13T02:41:41 | Mostafa Shahin, Julien Epps, Beena Ahmed | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL | The automatic identification and analysis of pronunciation errors, known as
Mispronunciation Detection and Diagnosis (MDD) plays a crucial role in Computer
Aided Pronunciation Learning (CAPL) tools such as Second-Language (L2) learning
or speech therapy applications. Existing MDD methods relying on analysing
phonemes can only detect categorical errors of phonemes that have an adequate
amount of training data to be modelled. With the unpredictable nature of the
pronunciation errors of non-native or disordered speakers and the scarcity of
training datasets, it is unfeasible to model all types of mispronunciations.
Moreover, phoneme-level MDD approaches have a limited ability to provide
detailed diagnostic information about the error made. In this paper, we propose
a low-level MDD approach based on the detection of speech attribute features.
Speech attribute features break down phoneme production into elementary
components that are directly related to the articulatory system leading to more
formative feedback to the learner. We further propose a multi-label variant of
the Connectionist Temporal Classification (CTC) approach to jointly model the
non-mutually exclusive speech attributes using a single model. The pre-trained
wav2vec2 model was employed as a core model for the speech attribute detector.
The proposed method was applied to L2 speech corpora collected from English
learners from different native languages. The proposed speech attribute MDD
method was further compared to the traditional phoneme-level MDD and achieved a
significantly lower False Acceptance Rate (FAR), False Rejection Rate (FRR),
and Diagnostic Error Rate (DER) over all speech attributes compared to the
phoneme-level equivalent. | [
-0.0210305005,
0.0441260226,
0.0112321852,
0.0044170492,
0.003041388,
0.0262020621,
0.0192232281,
-0.0306139756,
-0.0010730383,
-0.0077964277,
0.0035208671,
-0.0614495911,
0.0915930867,
-0.0135892788,
-0.0197001006,
-0.0102568697,
0.0367162377,
-0.0156080388,
0.0514064319,
-0.0264628921,
0.0241745207,
0.0090950262,
-0.0979151502,
0.0377051793,
-0.0417357795,
0.0094599538,
0.0187486485,
-0.0024295235,
0.0032488194,
-0.0493108965,
-0.0011341292,
0.0254635457,
-0.0385898836,
0.0337054245,
0.0000021387,
-0.0285779368,
-0.002360659,
-0.0101491427,
-0.0407942683,
0.0137884738,
0.0299965069,
0.0832752809,
-0.0141958781,
0.0374998897,
0.0100945774,
-0.0568880178,
0.0753979087,
0.0360250026,
0.0002942711,
0.016997749,
0.0030543981,
-0.0267732553,
0.0413610078,
0.0026419305,
0.0005130597,
-0.0355667397,
0.0263457578,
-0.0194293056,
-0.001712635,
-0.067870222,
-0.0362574868,
0.0371854268,
-0.0516710989,
0.0266894009,
-0.0026853792,
0.0184110887,
-0.0005386728,
-0.065054819,
-0.0291496255,
0.03773164,
0.0023444258,
-0.0119866859,
0.0153138116,
0.0097070402,
-0.0396360196,
-0.0016068319,
0.0338118784,
-0.0307861548,
-0.0255412553,
-0.0142741706,
0.0521823689,
0.0027874669,
0.0083428761,
-0.0097889677,
0.0021467183,
0.0296320524,
0.0011673752,
-0.0446429886,
0.0038713941,
0.0402039625,
0.004131027,
0.021501258,
0.0196101889,
-0.0024919685,
-0.062462993,
-0.0010244119,
0.007183454,
-0.0713848621,
-0.0233754907,
-0.0034784295,
0.0154034393,
-0.0018148731,
-0.0591225065,
-0.0283860937,
-0.0264970213,
0.0344306715,
-0.0117753046,
0.0104874736,
-0.0139819561,
0.0033644594,
-0.0391891152,
-0.0043558944,
-0.0059579238,
0.0234709643,
0.0402694568,
0.0568452589,
-0.066495873,
-0.0372649543,
-0.0585034378,
-0.0268734973,
0.0180999432,
0.0039158589,
-0.0374369062,
0.0262603555,
0.0046452349,
0.0697710216,
0.0399244353,
0.0551592559,
-0.0660779178,
-0.0358712338,
0.0250234194,
0.0115905795,
0.0410655439,
0.0102818776,
0.0476495177,
0.0253682565,
-0.0179825276,
-0.023388667,
-0.0312918983,
-0.0018987062,
-0.0387300551,
0.0025289643,
-0.0521520227,
-0.0504478142,
-0.0164791141,
-0.0320550166,
0.0395414643,
-0.0480064042,
-0.0265643392,
-0.0408987962,
-0.0110024614,
0.0670752898,
-0.0149964681,
0.0226965901,
0.082852833,
0.0010381194,
0.062503539,
0.0129649183,
0.0416889042,
-0.0721190125,
-0.0066303546,
-0.0047827968,
0.0259139724,
0.0260024946,
0.0472758263,
-0.0060885232,
-0.0445277169,
-0.0667778775,
0.0094543127,
0.0230881944,
0.02147617,
0.0268870275,
-0.0234600566,
-0.0127346246,
0.0330430306,
0.0123736169,
0.0900508165,
-0.0580379292,
0.0671244413,
-0.0039133718,
0.0038842233,
-0.0324896649,
0.0042829793,
-0.0468469337,
-0.0503980257,
0.0061246864,
-0.010218394,
0.0351901688,
-0.0245556068,
-0.0125770904,
-0.0152822062,
-0.0370445214,
-0.005922073,
0.019119611,
0.049679514,
0.004170455,
-0.0274692532,
0.0004198174,
-0.0028692421,
0.0009633586,
0.0207144096,
-0.0304636192,
0.0255581941,
0.0383925922,
0.0118623395,
-0.036257498,
-0.0310835131,
-0.0361623019,
-0.0404695421,
-0.0270426888,
0.0371176638,
-0.0279595256,
0.0339894928,
-0.0411227047,
0.0067206952,
0.1088950783,
-0.0062841098,
0.0189409126,
-0.0434455387,
0.0522471406,
-0.0200461932,
-0.0173305739,
-0.0197146535,
-0.0079350704,
0.0180438589,
-0.0176126733,
0.0218443889,
0.014176745,
0.0390715748,
0.0501802415,
-0.0145129114,
-0.0317799151,
-0.0085009737,
0.0193302892,
0.0149342157,
0.0323080793,
-0.0280837808,
-0.0571199991,
0.0674565732,
0.0188314747,
-0.0129331667,
-0.0070384406,
0.0275750626,
-0.0972186849,
0.0167247932,
-0.0148315728,
0.0303340144,
-0.0509583168,
0.043948289,
-0.0055554938,
0.039057482,
0.0312622488,
-0.0083969757,
-0.0223935097,
-0.0183940753,
0.0088445684,
0.0221619457,
-0.0240372755,
-0.0733978078,
-0.0753948167,
0.0097798929,
-0.0247529279,
0.0366424583,
-0.0310611054,
0.0193071458,
-0.029029604,
0.0123143746,
-0.0396632515,
-0.012393021,
0.0072534094,
0.0047857207,
-0.0656444654,
0.016487835,
-0.0038038662,
-0.0322990604,
-0.0017610518,
-0.0287605729,
-0.0019739233,
-0.0166512914,
-0.0239313096,
-0.0084373103,
-0.0464107357,
-0.0121152159,
0.0080264779,
-0.0406166986,
-0.0157858264,
-0.0077774809,
-0.0063127433,
-0.0451953597,
-0.0280260742,
0.0500439145,
0.0287118219,
0.0601606853,
0.0002735087,
-0.0151274949,
-0.0040533636,
0.0090149632,
-0.0019336002,
-0.0312681869,
0.0477555878,
0.0184864067,
-0.0256342646,
-0.0162375011,
-0.0019816726,
0.0012947203,
0.0302551165,
-0.0115078604,
-0.0114251086,
-0.0641558915,
0.0659659579,
0.0329606533,
0.0469332412,
-0.0479255766,
0.0004414764,
-0.048688665,
-0.0482061617,
-0.003330905,
-0.0498035178,
-0.0303994399,
0.0004516772,
0.0081837233,
0.000414317,
0.0591998249,
-0.0985305831,
-0.0625817999,
-0.0446633585,
-0.0382779911,
0.0237829592,
-0.0215236936,
-0.0060795918,
-0.0088721216,
0.03099446,
-0.0892705396,
-0.00670511,
-0.0024816121,
0.0541726202,
-0.0487809554,
-0.0006572905,
-0.0515626371,
0.0007945466,
0.023188943,
0.0142825013,
-0.0064846394,
-0.0105532408,
-0.0167769659,
-0.0241590906,
-0.0662343577,
-0.0444603376,
0.035845764,
0.0205829535,
-0.0426886082,
0.0290578753,
0.0130854864,
-0.0126509853,
0.0210752394,
0.0834405422,
-0.0013025803,
0.0512639806,
-0.0474924035,
-0.0260601174,
0.0210478771,
-0.0356934965,
0.0298628639,
0.0595952123,
-0.0197266899,
0.0475141928,
0.0491805896,
0.0154758617,
-0.0207074899,
0.0187453162,
0.0396692976,
-0.026636621,
-0.0324913189,
0.0583896339,
0.0151733523,
-0.0310982168,
-0.0155206835,
0.0467587337,
-0.0253245905,
-0.0307359975,
-0.0344378054,
-0.0225874465,
-0.0128026614,
0.0327107012,
0.0529146269,
-0.0441047363,
0.0187083073,
0.004728917,
-0.041329354,
0.0080371024,
0.0150891207,
-0.0329320394,
0.0007747237,
0.0306876898,
-0.0026504474,
-0.0329038836,
0.0198158845,
0.0069738212,
-0.0012159161,
-0.0292929187,
0.0646845251,
-0.0813335031,
-0.099644959,
0.0418325923,
0.0018107621,
0.1243124008,
0.0515878983,
-0.0256102793,
-0.0450328179,
-0.0652675554,
0.0177147184,
0.000463282,
-0.0252820626,
-0.0623036474,
0.0039231614,
0.0203114841,
-0.0246288124,
0.0093831876,
0.0359907635,
-0.0038686551,
0.0172641221,
0.005069742,
0.084331058,
-0.0234561209,
0.0113703804,
0.0115451152,
0.0183142535,
0.0285403188,
0.0342892446,
-0.0005243791,
-0.0701235607,
-0.0259279609,
0.0453305505,
-0.0028820648,
-0.0140387211,
-0.0385355763,
0.0547270998,
0.0244000219,
-0.0743792951,
-0.0292113461,
-0.0332444571,
-0.0111771785,
0.0195171162,
0.0155074457,
0.0283843614,
-0.0353774168,
0.0487215146,
-0.0331114829,
-0.0130337803,
0.0329677984,
0.0987038091,
-0.0544655882,
0.016715657,
0.0069912905,
-0.0272944719,
-0.0308703762,
-0.000113551,
-0.0157693457,
-0.0400530025,
0.0321406238,
-0.0105412798,
0.0128364433,
0.0704709738,
-0.0755391046,
-0.0816133395,
0.0237272289,
0.0045124707,
-0.0258536004,
-0.0042266841,
0.0727890357,
-0.0355631411,
-0.0093882475,
-0.0133450041,
-0.0004535319,
0.0195876528,
-0.0343860462,
-0.0103885643,
-0.0395227745,
-0.0150675485,
0.0107491743,
0.0279786009,
0.0478728935,
-0.0310442988,
0.0274407491,
-0.0589520149,
-0.0086893905,
0.0540121756,
0.0563729517,
0.0127325105,
-0.0055804956,
0.0246725213,
0.0022926584,
-0.0323089845,
-0.0858357325,
-0.0051046768,
-0.050951492,
0.0230235122,
0.0860715359,
0.047815267,
0.062225014,
0.001663618,
0.0046521118,
-0.0089661321,
0.0011828782,
0.0116586201,
0.0347989164,
0.0062230341,
0.0006357975,
-0.0055428352,
-0.0063763633,
0.009701428,
-0.0131723573,
0.0535175167,
0.0416621305,
-0.0174669139,
0.0028011603,
0.0644118264,
-0.0024756587,
0.0641138777,
0.0006627255,
0.0634849072,
-0.0520416275,
-0.0097903591,
-0.0332526825,
0.0326131061,
0.0562276281,
-0.0012210252,
-0.0036164196,
-0.0270386562,
0.0310303736,
0.048520986,
-0.0114841666,
-0.0896167457,
-0.0051928605,
-0.0250674654,
-0.0237073563,
-0.0527352281,
0.0007386781,
-0.0768568367,
0.0010033455,
-0.0917339027,
-0.052671019,
0.0376925953,
0.0222673044,
0.0511156023,
0.0388939232,
-0.051868435,
-0.0022673542,
-0.0191320721,
0.0262887552,
-0.0000421319,
-0.0788119137,
0.0580707043,
-0.0030257974,
0.0144769428,
-5.857294026e-33,
-0.0201013498,
-0.0475917608,
-0.0017559949,
0.0252104048,
-0.023602454,
0.0255083367,
0.0116503322,
0.022102328,
-0.0175993051,
0.0181524046,
0.0092518684,
-0.0032422263,
0.030631423,
-0.0302042142,
0.0362031721,
0.0411850624,
0.0737279505,
0.0217866637,
0.015938526,
-0.0102530904,
0.0470027588,
0.0401430875,
0.0640273169,
-0.0679129362,
0.0393238328,
0.0224108342,
-0.0014385065,
-0.0092161614,
0.029146323,
0.0390660018,
0.0022765177,
0.0892710388,
-4.35e-7,
-0.0297474749,
-0.0179404039,
-0.0312775299,
-0.1129677519,
-0.0355903916,
0.0226262305,
0.0677545294,
0.0317043439,
0.0192768853,
0.0121592535,
0.0394945852,
-0.0281857867,
0.0078988839,
0.0425201245,
-0.0371197611,
0.0130479718,
-0.0357842818,
0.0112568643,
0.0490320288,
-0.0078673931,
-0.0018125577,
0.0605860315,
-0.0187131763,
-0.034752734,
-0.0664848983,
-0.0960320383,
0.0254048221,
0.0251240246,
0.0058703921,
0.0192650538,
0.030993389,
-0.0419800766,
-0.0145641612,
0.074067086,
-0.0674298778,
0.0581175424,
0.0261059329,
0.0490149558,
0.0056363512,
0.0309856236,
-0.0000741079,
0.0070565552,
-0.0844073072,
-0.0194521062,
-0.0098516569,
0.0425751023,
0.0018580136,
-0.0151629662,
-0.0077652731,
-0.0634254143,
-0.0196532812,
-0.0173120573,
0.0039622812,
-0.0245348886,
0.0174822751,
0.061965961,
-0.004261673,
0.0121986382,
0.0464194641,
0.0383267179,
-0.0045148153,
0.0097860293,
-0.0347946845,
0.0104626836,
-0.003854797,
-0.0196220223,
-0.0030620282,
-0.0078656347,
-0.0328046717,
0.023840338,
0.0054732081,
0.0384607725,
-0.0297389217,
-0.0180280246,
0.0318618529,
-0.0541441217,
0.0113635082,
0.0086607961,
0.0057992744,
-0.0206797868,
-0.0015759399,
0.054680299,
0.0007159735,
-0.0259094257,
0.0286365729,
-0.0025342326,
0.0196115859,
-0.0416196249,
-0.0264923554,
-0.0092427526,
0.0525388792,
-0.0089683216,
-0.0119729377,
0.0306763966,
-0.0435949489,
0.006963653,
-0.0301023759,
0.0180831291,
0.0151234968,
2.818e-7,
-0.0286747385,
-0.0005681565,
0.0157768521,
-0.0304000601,
0.0178056322,
0.0193064269,
-0.0337359197,
-0.0276527591,
-0.0233902447,
0.0630553737,
0.0556020774,
-0.0303875823,
0.0614213943,
0.0307725966,
-0.0009567172,
0.0036745747,
-0.0311354697,
0.0767233968,
-0.0276497845,
-0.0066886083,
0.02963618,
0.0077781505,
0.0109358681,
-0.0792140961,
0.0006038315,
0.0183042344,
-0.0064528575,
0.0267681908,
0.0252784118,
-0.008480737,
0.0723860636,
-0.0179978833,
0.0388969705,
0.0629633144,
-0.0405411124,
0.0295276754,
-0.0154914707,
0.0014625145,
-0.0443193018,
-0.017783979,
0.0059350184,
0.0332714431,
-0.0637081638,
0.0365543552,
0.0344941989,
0.0325426348,
0.0019787021,
0.0337914713,
-0.0141537581,
0.0138569139,
0.0389090963,
0.0032487945,
0.005045915,
0.015619739,
-0.0186059512,
-0.0207519736,
-0.0176288765,
-0.022202868,
0.0394951217,
0.081740208,
-0.0043594763,
-0.0232033487,
0.0495954752,
-0.0138094714,
0.0079416968,
-0.0398432836,
-0.0253855661,
2.138836996e-34,
0.0146247987,
-0.0652136877,
0.0517694764,
0.0446270965,
-0.0333805718,
-0.0072281687,
0.0680627748,
0.0139585556,
0.0189188756,
-0.0025229584,
-0.0309403297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07032v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07032v1 | ExpNote: Black-box Large Language Models are Better Task Solvers with Experience Notebook | 2023-11-13T02:31:16 | 2023-11-13T02:31:16 | Wangtao Sun, Xuanqing Yu, Shizhu He, Jun Zhao, Kang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Black-box Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown great power in solving
various tasks and are considered general problem solvers. However, LLMs still
fail in many specific tasks although understand the task instruction. In this
paper, we focus on the problem of boosting the ability of black-box LLMs to
solve downstream tasks. We propose ExpNote, an automated framework to help LLMs
better adapt to unfamiliar tasks through reflecting and noting experiences from
training data and retrieving them from external memory during testing. We
evaluate ExpNote on multiple tasks and the experimental results demonstrate
that the proposed method significantly improves the performance of black-box
LLMs. The data and code are available at
https://github.com/forangel2014/ExpNote | [
0.0188310556,
0.0310066398,
-0.0084256483,
0.0229991749,
-0.0098483469,
0.0380865484,
0.0050349017,
-0.0074729435,
0.0189269837,
-0.0504800826,
-0.0254524052,
-0.026088208,
-0.0176514573,
0.0409420468,
0.0218851268,
-0.0174778979,
0.0337439254,
-0.050833907,
-0.0303580817,
0.0051181922,
-0.0211303663,
0.0035313561,
-0.0251736008,
0.0380606912,
-0.0100118471,
-0.0139225051,
-0.053449288,
0.0075942022,
0.0127072055,
-0.0215427931,
0.0245045479,
0.02519642,
0.0371002071,
0.0222770441,
0.0000020804,
-0.0368909873,
-0.0222691465,
-0.0286070127,
-0.0537477657,
-0.021764366,
0.0005961157,
0.019015504,
-0.0193012301,
0.0535418913,
-0.0394691452,
-0.0594212674,
0.0101622958,
0.0398987383,
0.0656337962,
0.0897318274,
0.0024374228,
0.0262637306,
-0.0020476154,
-0.0206598528,
0.065024972,
-0.0358498022,
0.0341052301,
0.0281672347,
0.013904606,
-0.0352788083,
-0.0105560748,
0.0183161236,
0.0427723378,
-0.0080411546,
-0.0164084509,
0.0580445603,
-0.0127536496,
0.01705263,
-0.0343708694,
0.0529135801,
-0.0357802883,
0.0005955145,
-0.008309368,
-0.0053397156,
-0.014506585,
-0.0322453752,
-0.0406108275,
0.0162820388,
-0.019137729,
0.0026367044,
-0.0032185034,
-0.0294224042,
0.0294645596,
0.0063586216,
-0.0107633118,
0.1027062163,
-0.0005915698,
-0.0464829952,
0.0449536927,
-0.0057471129,
0.0167734548,
-0.0594468601,
0.0391380265,
0.0688171759,
-0.025429016,
0.0293133836,
-0.0324958041,
-0.0564418249,
-0.0041236943,
-0.0193995759,
0.0858158097,
0.0487916805,
-0.0380383022,
0.0845598504,
-0.0703138113,
0.0690450743,
0.0012517615,
0.0149351051,
-0.0367144011,
-0.0085881576,
-0.0930871069,
-0.0019723854,
-0.0641350448,
0.0378919952,
-0.0229080468,
-0.0217691548,
0.0007752329,
0.0328977667,
-0.0114330789,
0.0310276188,
0.0069422172,
-0.000703593,
-0.0376767814,
-0.0052023255,
-0.0186582822,
0.0018068751,
-0.0175185353,
-0.0049119866,
-0.0208005123,
-0.0158179794,
-0.0108479355,
-0.0009393282,
0.0026520521,
-0.0415001735,
0.0398313664,
0.0818677768,
0.0022843077,
-0.0319642276,
-0.0322636627,
0.0259191077,
0.0090834564,
-0.0691926107,
0.0075722169,
-0.060531158,
0.0276740286,
0.0043323869,
-0.006466513,
-0.0209563505,
0.0147910267,
0.0233359151,
0.0081915809,
0.0796191916,
0.0227792412,
0.0042537558,
0.0416869558,
0.0093948105,
-0.0061155902,
0.0767257437,
0.0279605836,
0.0205931272,
-0.0020249889,
-0.0021450222,
0.0149885779,
0.0607662685,
-0.0022271734,
0.0142141245,
-0.0149343368,
0.0073035713,
0.0469508097,
0.0335014127,
0.0300496146,
0.0276549254,
-0.0137416357,
0.0301401448,
0.0563496426,
0.0307095498,
-0.0201613326,
0.0054839752,
0.0285355542,
-0.0292091127,
0.0029231431,
-0.0200138576,
-0.0644028857,
0.036509186,
0.0225118045,
-0.010733773,
-0.0006476377,
0.0260407738,
-0.0164899863,
-0.0306052789,
-0.0207128767,
-0.0110780969,
0.0266119614,
0.0164408982,
0.0621312708,
-0.0047574844,
-0.0601402931,
0.0601809435,
0.0133206705,
-0.0178331379,
-0.01280009,
-0.063332051,
0.0267611779,
0.0731486231,
0.0380442105,
-0.0497110449,
-0.0518816113,
-0.019483421,
0.0166945122,
0.0065457048,
0.0344670229,
-0.0143974554,
0.0010275786,
-0.0658062249,
-0.0396206155,
-0.0259541497,
0.000265625,
0.0462272651,
0.0679728761,
0.0021637592,
0.0268251393,
-0.0090542901,
-0.0703286156,
0.0340013057,
-0.029062558,
-0.0522175878,
0.0043828678,
-0.016479155,
0.0100893704,
-0.0219736788,
0.0031485904,
-0.0010959591,
0.03871198,
-0.0634254888,
-0.0284463819,
0.0024060782,
-0.0384566747,
-0.0354912467,
0.0611777306,
-0.0171414949,
-0.0175387766,
0.0442666784,
-0.0398573466,
-0.0737291947,
-0.0118802665,
-0.0483212247,
0.0578721762,
-0.0004979177,
0.0373652764,
-0.0099200616,
0.007953885,
-0.0451579913,
0.0345617905,
0.0195527766,
0.0118182413,
-0.0041385554,
0.0218834355,
-0.0113392565,
-0.0203748085,
-0.0389143154,
0.0023512121,
0.0095085017,
0.029817475,
0.0001214252,
0.0291463919,
-0.0796659365,
-0.0231656414,
-0.0995584503,
0.0492079072,
-0.0195802934,
0.0230454728,
0.0258691255,
-0.0071683694,
-0.0142273623,
-0.0457341149,
-0.0323601291,
0.0231176112,
0.0130386846,
-0.0173901785,
0.0016263706,
0.0387294516,
-0.0098685212,
-0.0292338151,
-0.0004316479,
-0.0106131248,
-0.0010043845,
-0.033515878,
0.0057004751,
-0.0829342753,
0.0580297038,
0.0011901825,
0.049875658,
-0.0183390174,
-0.0272231065,
0.0024038488,
-0.0197135769,
0.0602860227,
0.0929118395,
-0.0217033215,
0.0276534948,
0.0769508705,
-0.0297274478,
-0.0793315098,
0.0379605182,
0.0001151117,
-0.0355267413,
-0.0322767422,
-0.0221635439,
-0.0239409525,
0.0751586556,
-0.0288403723,
0.0213643871,
-0.0345739201,
0.0159809086,
-0.0274756625,
-0.0095230816,
-0.0175681375,
-0.0195913054,
-0.0532590114,
0.0080731269,
-0.0458275378,
-0.0521225594,
0.0661681667,
-0.0101818163,
-0.0266226996,
-0.0418799259,
-0.0246080998,
-0.0354438275,
0.0980067328,
-0.0027158679,
0.0039727641,
-0.0214147717,
-0.02269396,
-0.0446590446,
-0.0009365496,
-0.0257802717,
-0.0376410149,
0.0510935001,
-0.0447937809,
0.0004352402,
-0.003838853,
-0.0615599938,
-0.0617223196,
0.0044696336,
-0.0403575338,
0.0197096653,
-0.0169796403,
-0.0080986461,
-0.0408732481,
0.0094804233,
0.0412585586,
0.0653347746,
-0.0240843035,
-0.0180796441,
-0.0338915326,
-0.0260878652,
0.064234145,
-0.0014387803,
0.0305836275,
-0.0501390509,
0.0020420318,
0.0358583964,
0.0801281705,
-0.0077259378,
-0.0270477422,
-0.0061506378,
0.0282579362,
-0.0315452777,
-0.003424075,
0.0287141539,
0.0113345049,
-0.092333816,
-0.0469877459,
0.1085612401,
0.0333081447,
-0.0548513532,
-0.001893734,
-0.0414523855,
0.0093992017,
0.0424758196,
0.0450761989,
-0.0501370877,
-0.0335122459,
0.0039060209,
0.0121300723,
0.0078844083,
-0.0226723757,
-0.004396813,
-0.1645969748,
-0.0083740251,
0.0217691734,
-0.0381788686,
0.0032346295,
-0.0194964502,
0.000821204,
-0.0149416141,
0.0183848049,
0.0227422453,
-0.0263022389,
-0.0193117913,
0.030943552,
0.0082320729,
-0.0364513732,
0.0493322089,
-0.0250502229,
0.0417711213,
0.0551117957,
-0.0067581767,
-0.0085714478,
0.0081454311,
0.0421014614,
0.0321191922,
0.0069045541,
-0.0040191994,
0.0462713726,
-0.0102373641,
-0.0195131768,
0.0212557781,
0.0239715744,
-0.07749708,
-0.0036331152,
0.0366387367,
0.0678652599,
-0.0298378244,
-0.0172873754,
0.0153221218,
-0.0418663733,
0.0197937451,
0.0703536719,
0.0238930155,
-0.0537057221,
-0.0559689067,
-0.0044643045,
-0.0259584673,
-0.062574245,
0.0097336741,
0.0579715408,
-0.0217518322,
0.0137615371,
-0.0301096812,
-0.0357463174,
0.0711267292,
0.0791446418,
0.0193679575,
-0.0044367849,
0.0045785145,
-0.0158961453,
-0.041446764,
0.0309574101,
-0.0190018583,
0.0312805288,
-0.0450042486,
-0.0169373546,
0.0377039798,
-0.0145003023,
-0.00198245,
0.022648992,
-0.1091527492,
-0.048747275,
0.0191675387,
0.0777189881,
0.0304456726,
0.0601782054,
-0.0172500424,
-0.0548081435,
-0.0014829717,
-0.0177606679,
-0.0408426039,
0.0013880705,
0.0054611168,
-0.0032524904,
0.0030425815,
0.0340487398,
-0.062165048,
-0.0026461629,
0.0355101153,
0.0125220241,
-0.018792795,
-0.0053306846,
0.0194055252,
-0.0035818904,
0.0222961586,
-0.009387224,
-0.0220012888,
-0.0216432977,
0.0477604829,
0.0058176424,
-0.0092507619,
-0.0472572483,
0.0203987975,
0.0021411979,
-0.0122671137,
0.0340270847,
-0.0224073231,
0.0039305389,
0.0136022782,
-0.0350175723,
0.0063250079,
0.0232899878,
-0.0168316085,
0.0960220769,
-0.008248887,
-0.0257040821,
0.0236434881,
0.0465476513,
0.046779193,
-0.003975891,
0.0685112402,
0.0272145588,
-0.0136043169,
-0.0387671553,
0.0228587445,
-0.044619482,
-0.0697261021,
-0.0154426806,
0.0065801772,
0.0929391682,
-0.0358283669,
0.0349475145,
-0.0366559885,
-0.0045519434,
-0.0098046008,
-0.0174589064,
-0.0116181551,
-0.0237558801,
0.0319055542,
0.0321586281,
0.009143074,
0.0280704685,
0.0765053406,
0.0045583006,
0.0632369816,
0.0241479073,
0.0348642431,
-0.0383060835,
0.0010192102,
0.0245229509,
0.0106249489,
-0.0235932712,
0.0084934607,
-0.0075970218,
-0.0891349986,
0.0057484279,
0.012486944,
-0.0215651598,
-0.0369219929,
0.0385640338,
0.0547281727,
-0.0056180912,
0.0106819002,
-0.009929209,
0.0075610881,
-0.01207403,
-0.0290038623,
-0.0109704267,
-6.281921891e-33,
-0.0473942459,
-0.0517448932,
0.0374528281,
0.004256234,
-0.0032942819,
0.0293205958,
-0.0346721597,
0.0030278889,
0.0397774801,
0.0023804558,
-0.0258188359,
0.0000146818,
0.0245406926,
0.0027776281,
0.0438638963,
0.0082003484,
0.0400264747,
0.0091475137,
-0.0365569219,
0.0137159936,
0.0435235985,
0.0526250228,
0.0525378138,
-0.0488106571,
0.0080186529,
0.0041291048,
0.0027581411,
0.0366504975,
-0.0062170168,
0.0665639341,
0.0018655043,
0.0169082899,
0.0265329219,
-0.0687478036,
-0.035266187,
0.00308243,
-0.0484785102,
0.0014115033,
0.0175934676,
0.0135530066,
-0.0381863229,
-0.0041573313,
0.0229327418,
-0.0020911926,
0.0055708019,
0.0121045085,
0.0128698498,
-0.0378930047,
-0.0357544906,
0.0070876586,
-0.0366861932,
0.0122022163,
-0.0067675146,
-0.0366358906,
0.0250781458,
-0.0005560108,
-0.0178536419,
-0.0632788688,
-0.0133359963,
-0.0191222988,
0.0124037443,
0.0255971402,
0.059077695,
0.0426922068,
-0.0049960567,
0.0547958054,
0.0164099634,
0.0079408772,
0.0196251888,
-0.0388777703,
0.0402703322,
0.0172667634,
0.0182870571,
0.0056757224,
0.0180105995,
0.0106582819,
-0.051160261,
0.0242121145,
0.0265892688,
0.0504058227,
0.0335701406,
0.0164052006,
-0.0245179702,
-0.01613646,
-0.0420381576,
0.0362676643,
-0.0331032798,
-0.0340352282,
0.0410175584,
0.0363458283,
-0.0167357977,
-0.0312095359,
0.0303203575,
-0.0305532124,
0.0274364762,
0.0093880612,
-0.0233389195,
0.0066183885,
-0.0077974349,
0.0527567416,
-0.055945728,
-0.0698109418,
-0.0240107235,
0.0141770272,
0.0277714543,
0.0188469775,
0.0320639089,
0.0251914002,
-0.0918747336,
0.0054006786,
-0.0639098585,
0.0301550012,
0.0309138931,
0.0421055295,
0.0317469686,
0.0023135305,
-0.0111163007,
0.0598718785,
0.0004776224,
-0.0589544252,
-0.0194429792,
-0.0287419148,
0.0193632636,
-0.0012778152,
-0.0386997908,
0.0015824926,
-0.018854579,
-0.0134953596,
0.0292680562,
-0.0045751203,
0.0044165938,
0.0147068584,
2.705e-7,
0.0180421621,
0.044818636,
-0.0028254795,
0.0203287024,
0.0210683048,
0.0300509054,
-0.0593430139,
0.0149927195,
0.0009100307,
-0.0130993137,
-0.0069311946,
0.0477443822,
0.0652879328,
0.0350940451,
-0.0967915803,
-0.0398183204,
-0.0426906422,
0.0106450394,
-0.0707379505,
0.0130739855,
0.0086477352,
0.0849718004,
0.0071257842,
-0.0103169763,
-0.0067057568,
-0.0563232452,
0.0522557124,
-0.0318139866,
0.0084253056,
0.0134801446,
-0.0280869454,
0.0570594333,
-0.0215859767,
0.0446626134,
-0.0102376817,
0.0147877876,
0.0085008154,
0.0887552053,
0.0086963987,
-0.0355513021,
0.0221195612,
0.0161201414,
-0.0050115208,
-0.0516240597,
0.0516276099,
-0.0670858696,
-0.0180815943,
-0.0457513407,
0.0311547071,
-0.0391914062,
0.0039337492,
-0.008524878,
0.0139319431,
0.014613552,
-0.0013313198,
-0.0205295105,
-0.0363566875,
-0.0935647562,
-0.0294646844,
0.0236844644,
-0.0115033025,
-0.0427480079,
-0.0509091131,
0.0020632248,
-0.0214159209,
-0.0756967142,
0.01111966,
2.578051277e-34,
0.0228388533,
0.0005103278,
0.0082290787,
0.065537937,
0.038643416,
-0.0103464806,
-0.0231616553,
0.013218238,
0.0270716734,
-0.0603870489,
-0.0292291082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07022v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07022v1 | ViLMA: A Zero-Shot Benchmark for Linguistic and Temporal Grounding in Video-Language Models | 2023-11-13T02:13:13 | 2023-11-13T02:13:13 | Ilker Kesen, Andrea Pedrotti, Mustafa Dogan, Michele Cafagna, Emre Can Acikgoz, Letitia Parcalabescu, Iacer Calixto, Anette Frank, Albert Gatt, Aykut Erdem, Erkut Erdem | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | With the ever-increasing popularity of pretrained Video-Language Models
(VidLMs), there is a pressing need to develop robust evaluation methodologies
that delve deeper into their visio-linguistic capabilities. To address this
challenge, we present ViLMA (Video Language Model Assessment), a task-agnostic
benchmark that places the assessment of fine-grained capabilities of these
models on a firm footing. Task-based evaluations, while valuable, fail to
capture the complexities and specific temporal aspects of moving images that
VidLMs need to process. Through carefully curated counterfactuals, ViLMA offers
a controlled evaluation suite that sheds light on the true potential of these
models, as well as their performance gaps compared to human-level
understanding. ViLMA also includes proficiency tests, which assess basic
capabilities deemed essential to solving the main counterfactual tests. We show
that current VidLMs' grounding abilities are no better than those of
vision-language models which use static images. This is especially striking
once the performance on proficiency tests is factored in. Our benchmark serves
as a catalyst for future research on VidLMs, helping to highlight areas that
still need to be explored. | [
0.0005520538,
0.0305521265,
0.0012496096,
0.0513777547,
-0.0101596881,
0.0077519096,
0.019627329,
-0.0193734113,
-0.0439324789,
-0.0662543699,
-0.0312316176,
-0.0492021479,
0.0173792765,
0.0162890013,
0.012113397,
-0.052197367,
0.0219920501,
-0.0247173924,
-0.0201479997,
0.0129944207,
0.0166361611,
-0.0101855267,
-0.0228372682,
0.0201607775,
-0.0472283252,
-0.0076185577,
0.0218295604,
0.0214376952,
0.0495874025,
-0.0174087193,
-0.0152742965,
0.0459298491,
0.0468067117,
0.0060989349,
0.000001935,
-0.0167998653,
0.0315087102,
-0.0339944959,
-0.0018562953,
0.038588725,
0.0064918622,
-0.0537164621,
-0.019346185,
0.0045104562,
-0.0472203009,
-0.032567542,
0.0333047323,
-0.0334905498,
0.0690055639,
0.0334464982,
-0.0339795798,
-0.0347410217,
0.0112748537,
-0.0426127389,
0.0084063634,
-0.0387761518,
0.0066016731,
0.0534617715,
-0.00637567,
-0.0440568663,
-0.0651981607,
0.0355225243,
0.0459300764,
-0.0085983574,
-0.012974848,
0.0448839962,
-0.0447078943,
-0.0211500265,
-0.0225637686,
0.0685325786,
-0.0058136615,
-0.0373990312,
-0.0400216244,
-0.0005310961,
-0.0014250698,
-0.0078980597,
-0.0432397462,
0.0411912091,
0.038017638,
0.016461147,
-0.0287615638,
0.0423370488,
0.0205796454,
-0.0040619937,
0.0206927806,
0.0016416404,
0.0367647223,
0.0135452878,
0.0015058611,
0.0278118551,
-0.002651914,
-0.0597382113,
0.0028666826,
0.0058853868,
0.0056662634,
-0.0213021003,
-0.0417682305,
0.0087341964,
-0.0340358093,
-0.0623400025,
0.0649519414,
0.0358896255,
-0.0675724149,
0.063712433,
-0.0328715816,
0.0851619616,
-0.0234236848,
0.0383111238,
-0.0051015993,
0.0069154375,
-0.0278322622,
0.0227932334,
-0.0174996946,
-0.0278008152,
-0.0658711791,
-0.0224449635,
0.0000303591,
-0.009698038,
-0.0242214631,
-0.0116901528,
-0.0315874554,
0.0390823968,
-0.0007184413,
-0.0292017013,
-0.0140717691,
0.0273776837,
-0.0200162027,
0.0596636273,
-0.0305899885,
-0.0838348567,
-0.0058318391,
0.0379022807,
-0.0159206316,
-0.0216760021,
0.0217021164,
0.0332309864,
-0.0362091772,
-0.0403680913,
-0.0116649279,
0.0388413295,
-0.0169067215,
-0.0703280419,
0.0309403613,
-0.0695872754,
-0.0010956705,
0.0070182756,
0.0272021648,
-0.023798449,
-0.001380177,
-0.0134153925,
-0.005490134,
0.0739735216,
0.010947803,
-0.0089565357,
-0.004412509,
0.0165560469,
0.0201340783,
0.0656587407,
0.0130052408,
0.0055332542,
-0.0209920742,
0.0319433548,
0.0356292166,
0.028896397,
-0.0147982566,
0.0408567488,
-0.121316202,
-0.0060992041,
0.0063737757,
0.0003014114,
0.034843266,
0.0513007492,
-0.012893592,
-0.0496043824,
0.0884840637,
0.0310365148,
-0.0503935143,
-0.0541628934,
0.0803489611,
-0.0308526997,
0.0115539031,
0.0208272133,
-0.0360748619,
0.0299284402,
-0.0111160381,
0.0078006075,
-0.0571101345,
0.0325669572,
-0.0674105361,
-0.0326263867,
-0.020484928,
-0.0143148396,
0.0520322099,
0.0227749906,
0.0391078889,
0.0148347579,
-0.0398978703,
0.0270299893,
-0.007493061,
-0.0070160897,
0.0284859166,
-0.0098717231,
-0.0160547569,
0.0581659675,
0.0055303345,
0.0215255041,
-0.0654371679,
0.0090557355,
0.0753790513,
0.0738161877,
0.0107577648,
0.0072835623,
0.0556420386,
-0.0566682369,
-0.0378150381,
-0.0186975375,
0.0424124487,
0.0324463993,
-0.0012371684,
0.0128490338,
0.0084774029,
-0.0249763895,
-0.0157123078,
0.051438313,
0.0408452302,
0.0136325872,
-0.0338867567,
0.0010101218,
0.0040635117,
-0.0016809213,
-0.0423849486,
-0.0111001069,
0.0365102217,
-0.0364272781,
0.0435030796,
0.044850599,
-0.0491147824,
-0.0165022686,
0.0422190279,
-0.0521472208,
0.0050000926,
0.0603808202,
-0.0195631292,
-0.0165935475,
0.0249882378,
0.0138948942,
0.0054673473,
-0.0523781888,
0.0125011355,
0.0178020261,
0.0161680691,
0.0091327233,
0.020192612,
-0.029935332,
-0.0149589963,
0.026243858,
0.0193302166,
0.0133825336,
-0.0615610667,
-0.0339430049,
-0.0267019495,
-0.0042373212,
-0.000461498,
-0.0049651102,
0.0181900132,
-0.0488868244,
0.0003154382,
-0.0946930051,
-0.0240170415,
-0.066678606,
-0.0096783703,
-0.0142261265,
-0.0412378833,
-0.010187407,
-0.0575173944,
0.0113642178,
0.0148555581,
0.0242598783,
0.007648054,
0.015674483,
0.0190273914,
-0.0069166133,
-0.0372728147,
-0.0045933635,
0.0327696055,
0.0302998982,
-0.0039599175,
-0.0369273499,
0.0096051339,
0.0021921783,
-0.0225693937,
0.0449328683,
-0.0275632888,
-0.0316831283,
0.0205256864,
0.0110105835,
0.0125147402,
0.0595640503,
0.0002941622,
0.0380613357,
0.0217373092,
-0.0276197959,
0.0133991139,
-0.0054683252,
0.0016091531,
-0.0481672138,
-0.0486408249,
0.0004372472,
-0.0534387268,
0.0244636722,
-0.0234566834,
0.0530964248,
-0.0979055911,
0.0276526231,
-0.0298158564,
-0.0374998152,
-0.0405474491,
0.008527481,
-0.005738894,
0.0596309341,
-0.0690636039,
-0.0710453987,
0.0093345223,
-0.0721666738,
-0.0431294963,
0.0221964587,
0.0081622107,
0.0001137972,
0.0621131025,
0.0303071495,
-0.0008328682,
-0.0323644094,
0.0013593331,
-0.0613456033,
-0.0275924336,
0.0111084646,
0.0181923993,
0.0516665205,
-0.0747252107,
0.0259637684,
0.0016641471,
0.0000827751,
-0.0430399477,
-0.0167124365,
-0.0449944399,
0.0069103381,
-0.0683648735,
-0.0042907866,
0.007387694,
0.0359054841,
-0.0088028032,
0.0394654647,
0.0123816794,
0.0165128578,
-0.0080141816,
0.0076703448,
0.0610772297,
0.0141199194,
-0.0340521,
-0.0612350926,
0.0338067375,
0.0383839868,
0.0447298363,
-0.0063233431,
-0.0837037563,
0.0805797204,
0.0202235729,
0.036425963,
-0.021970652,
0.0323808827,
0.0411611162,
-0.0375873558,
-0.0047913878,
0.0788094178,
0.0150056835,
-0.0012270259,
0.0002787681,
0.0292716101,
-0.0017195557,
0.0481675789,
-0.0180282108,
-0.0910600498,
-0.0393755138,
-0.0098590301,
-0.0203826334,
0.0480422042,
0.0108411582,
-0.0282620843,
-0.0922228992,
0.0591594987,
0.0324787013,
-0.0204690509,
-0.0165300239,
0.0406278819,
-0.0149429962,
-0.0253184624,
0.0185795221,
-0.0366553329,
0.0018344676,
0.0011344246,
0.0229988396,
-0.0143744675,
-0.0849181786,
0.0732297972,
-0.0399998054,
0.0232964344,
0.0326439813,
-0.0193080176,
-0.0085432474,
-0.0738054663,
0.0456137098,
-0.0239623822,
0.0072152982,
-0.0033142669,
0.0386321843,
-0.0430326909,
-0.0530035794,
0.0664411411,
0.0001318455,
-0.0042724498,
-0.0361568145,
-0.0403650664,
0.0230294243,
-0.0139226308,
0.0125004947,
-0.0103205359,
0.0065721069,
0.007357589,
0.0472432934,
0.022265248,
-0.0204883981,
-0.0080078449,
0.0454802178,
-0.0162487142,
-0.0332893915,
-0.05276509,
-0.0277199727,
0.0422913022,
-0.0070770676,
-0.0493363068,
-0.0375246629,
0.0384517945,
0.0710801557,
-0.0218231678,
-0.012456663,
0.0063184989,
0.0175127238,
-0.0781942233,
0.1029958352,
-0.0027436796,
0.0370922349,
-0.0746138245,
-0.0279516727,
0.0333975405,
0.0048838155,
-0.0236946605,
0.0104980543,
-0.0584158152,
-0.0368281007,
-0.0116551099,
0.0710207745,
0.0259641018,
0.0647265017,
-0.0266205184,
0.0034463922,
0.0112447431,
-0.0139266867,
-0.0120138722,
0.0646196082,
0.0172498878,
-0.0815937892,
-0.0222677607,
0.0197503772,
-0.0167607237,
0.0470524281,
0.0328684747,
0.010554512,
-0.0232837163,
-0.0057659559,
0.0091198487,
-0.0548999049,
0.0895930082,
-0.0206857603,
-0.0022525506,
-0.0252477601,
0.018152535,
-0.006186456,
0.0170342233,
-0.0857234746,
-0.0213443637,
0.0396147184,
0.0304896552,
0.0041010901,
0.0193140004,
-0.0492768809,
0.0135093657,
-0.0237530246,
-0.0151011143,
-0.0090494175,
0.019765662,
-0.0134168761,
0.0341006368,
0.0218335632,
0.0212743785,
-0.0214947574,
0.038421642,
0.0186176002,
0.037098933,
0.0118019646,
0.0301293172,
0.0015503194,
0.0383808799,
-0.0079481751,
0.0040067253,
-0.043726407,
0.0517196879,
0.0727880076,
-0.054776378,
0.031759195,
-0.0013710719,
-0.0137133645,
-0.0406766906,
0.0352228172,
0.0288092718,
-0.0619833842,
0.053770043,
0.0112183839,
-0.0112671526,
0.0332670696,
0.0495405234,
0.0277134944,
0.0432692654,
0.0062835016,
0.0367236771,
-0.0145964613,
-0.0566948093,
0.0088259978,
-0.0223739985,
-0.0026822472,
0.0383821651,
-0.0752113238,
-0.085286133,
-0.0018364232,
0.0353186391,
0.0033897359,
0.0308565963,
0.0332495607,
0.0323823206,
0.0163159873,
0.009422211,
0.0096837385,
-0.0634461418,
0.0060384963,
0.005451242,
-0.0217583999,
-6.082437929e-33,
-0.0561700873,
0.0007953649,
0.0560526103,
-0.0295778178,
0.0122778174,
0.0461214855,
-0.0243926346,
0.0326081067,
-0.0238486622,
0.0441138633,
0.0255659893,
0.0235086009,
0.0271303505,
0.0164807029,
-0.0230252128,
-0.0342803486,
0.0291464366,
-0.0257432852,
-0.0299493801,
-0.0344918072,
-0.0123889325,
0.0064073103,
0.0528525934,
-0.0661212355,
-0.0309556648,
0.0004351972,
-0.0499976315,
0.0130433124,
0.0064723687,
0.0783606321,
0.0055276966,
-0.0346296206,
0.0117782149,
-0.0187400002,
-0.0398734845,
-0.020941494,
-0.0335942172,
-0.0025234839,
0.0370525718,
0.0735999718,
-0.0522946157,
0.0439757966,
0.026352182,
0.0042560943,
-0.0270140693,
-0.0017144126,
0.0226525106,
-0.0460997634,
0.0197685584,
0.017338939,
-0.0448308177,
0.0090273703,
-0.0111122886,
-0.0601606108,
0.0386293456,
-0.0148463426,
-0.0107492516,
-0.0377927236,
-0.0488694683,
-0.0016223744,
-0.0248904619,
0.0242112689,
0.1172160581,
0.0161567423,
-0.0129745277,
0.0548272915,
-0.00034701,
-0.0544604808,
-0.0046986118,
-0.0115421722,
0.0521149226,
0.0396232381,
0.0410893187,
0.0316450559,
0.0244205128,
0.0149435299,
-0.0521692261,
0.0052663502,
-0.0451936498,
0.0720108226,
-0.022113001,
0.0185995717,
0.008097183,
-0.0148376208,
-0.0373939723,
-0.0173483472,
-0.0144342147,
-0.0031276201,
0.0638281107,
0.0190084688,
0.0020665897,
-0.0064658406,
0.06290856,
-0.0205500908,
0.0220105145,
0.0434700027,
-0.0201137271,
0.0577708706,
0.0207536668,
0.0280828048,
-0.0497721434,
0.0101032285,
0.0549131259,
0.0430592224,
0.0064103808,
-0.0189967491,
0.0080681909,
0.0448484868,
-0.013384087,
-0.0096219033,
-0.0175915435,
0.0160314199,
-0.0042175204,
0.0556857288,
0.0646841303,
0.0191157535,
-0.0570350587,
0.0574405789,
-0.0494019426,
-0.0344264023,
-0.0054324018,
-0.0250255894,
-0.001027514,
0.0543973111,
-0.0311053004,
0.0116880415,
-0.0211816002,
-0.0078067393,
0.0284284428,
-0.0020494612,
-0.008522898,
0.0292337034,
2.61e-7,
0.0411204994,
0.0090817455,
0.0228380766,
0.011718398,
-0.007909175,
0.028292276,
-0.061631199,
0.0093831057,
0.0166979898,
-0.0500447154,
0.0111494763,
0.0904010683,
0.0578075759,
-0.0354674459,
0.0103552388,
0.0295928866,
-0.057349205,
0.0017781119,
-0.0343603268,
-0.032222975,
0.0030531734,
0.0797690973,
-0.0023938504,
-0.0039822748,
0.029862985,
-0.0573628247,
0.0608608313,
-0.0247251112,
-0.0101721203,
-0.0312407147,
0.0065833242,
0.0228348617,
-0.0431192592,
0.025294574,
-0.0104534635,
-0.0008948629,
0.0166774932,
0.0326154232,
-0.0552631952,
-0.0427065194,
-0.0428505056,
0.0287494753,
-0.0503149368,
-0.0121767223,
0.0727712885,
-0.0194959901,
0.0103683611,
0.0010156148,
-0.0404142663,
0.0318870842,
0.0306409281,
0.010658158,
-0.0477035753,
0.0048896689,
0.0461497791,
-0.007946955,
-0.0789711326,
-0.0882979929,
-0.0004190101,
0.0156378355,
-0.015450174,
-0.0025512085,
-0.0329110585,
-0.0067985938,
0.0302727912,
0.0104718311,
-0.0534131303,
1.805221598e-34,
0.0217003822,
0.0040201931,
0.017815562,
-0.0384458229,
-0.008106933,
0.0058427849,
-0.0329384506,
0.0156360418,
-0.0216390323,
-0.0142565705,
0.0236232728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07014v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07014v1 | Teach me with a Whisper: Enhancing Large Language Models for Analyzing Spoken Transcripts using Speech Embeddings | 2023-11-13T01:53:12 | 2023-11-13T01:53:12 | Fatema Hasan, Yulong Li, James Foulds, Shimei Pan, Bishwaranjan Bhattacharjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speech data has rich acoustic and paralinguistic information with important
cues for understanding a speaker's tone, emotion, and intent, yet traditional
large language models such as BERT do not incorporate this information. There
has been an increased interest in multi-modal language models leveraging audio
and/or visual information and text. However, current multi-modal language
models require both text and audio/visual data streams during inference/test
time. In this work, we propose a methodology for training language models
leveraging spoken language audio data but without requiring the audio stream
during prediction time. This leads to an improved language model for analyzing
spoken transcripts while avoiding an audio processing overhead at test time. We
achieve this via an audio-language knowledge distillation framework, where we
transfer acoustic and paralinguistic information from a pre-trained speech
embedding (OpenAI Whisper) teacher model to help train a student language model
on an audio-text dataset. In our experiments, the student model achieves
consistent improvement over traditional language models on tasks analyzing
spoken transcripts. | [
-0.0223083682,
0.0868759826,
-0.0253145434,
0.0432540439,
-0.0240211803,
-0.0010283462,
0.0154543091,
-0.0070432774,
-0.0179644134,
-0.0595186874,
-0.0264170319,
-0.0069727669,
-0.0015250475,
0.0212828722,
0.0274134558,
-0.0891584679,
0.0178930536,
-0.0580028184,
0.0443046503,
0.0126210209,
0.0315885171,
0.0143258683,
-0.0357457288,
0.036642503,
-0.026365241,
-0.0174926575,
-0.044145301,
0.0181658007,
0.0044939085,
0.0342388824,
-0.0083674742,
0.0306927655,
0.0683406442,
-0.0048351572,
0.0000017745,
-0.0052841334,
0.0239492208,
-0.0060334709,
-0.0293783192,
0.0233168285,
0.0302884858,
0.0077194595,
0.0120706698,
0.0558500551,
-0.023422407,
-0.0331828669,
0.0138005847,
0.02480077,
0.0747605786,
0.0581240989,
-0.0261351448,
-0.0185374953,
0.0325709879,
-0.0129111791,
0.0160486922,
-0.0150567777,
0.0017176113,
-0.0019701084,
0.0067308848,
-0.0012149416,
-0.0419810414,
0.0694315135,
0.0112411492,
-0.0052740625,
-0.0097872028,
0.0044007972,
-0.0489701889,
-0.037591517,
-0.0143831838,
0.0910521597,
-0.0192970484,
0.0018770986,
0.0137027297,
0.0147569962,
-0.0095597794,
0.0052440879,
-0.02268962,
0.0024193744,
0.0479680225,
0.0122539802,
-0.0477415659,
0.0165954102,
0.0040573413,
-0.00858323,
-0.0058025494,
-0.0195041113,
-0.00744884,
-0.0143629955,
0.0067363097,
-0.0234914403,
-0.0217799079,
-0.0136466213,
-0.0018531313,
-0.0024320942,
0.004058287,
0.0085439766,
-0.0297943242,
-0.0465604961,
-0.0161467567,
-0.0042911256,
0.0032924598,
0.0337346382,
-0.0802955255,
0.0336159468,
0.0053412816,
0.0434118882,
0.0267161764,
0.0020543118,
-0.0433973372,
-0.0250968169,
-0.0424758419,
0.0100338031,
-0.0240342598,
0.0072081448,
-0.0381559767,
-0.0537277684,
-0.0139131192,
-0.0116272336,
-0.0332445465,
0.0293403398,
0.0230092891,
-0.0064374083,
-0.0220650826,
0.0037163089,
0.0179619286,
0.0449374914,
0.0055935052,
0.062340159,
-0.0244237967,
-0.0488004871,
-0.0150736477,
0.0309428144,
0.0406708196,
0.0297091976,
-0.0146187767,
0.0284342952,
-0.0135670295,
-0.0348284617,
-0.0298858806,
-0.0222220905,
-0.0449781343,
-0.0557566546,
0.0056523508,
-0.05515806,
0.0361699276,
-0.032688953,
-0.0035864641,
-0.0268218685,
0.0091858096,
-0.0258203913,
-0.019349955,
0.069883287,
0.0142780188,
0.042803511,
0.0252218079,
0.0471533351,
-0.0072384975,
0.0956513137,
0.0605968423,
0.0045265201,
0.0386759527,
-0.0234403424,
-0.0108612068,
0.072662428,
0.0305134915,
0.0252174512,
-0.0399352387,
-0.0104977079,
-0.0047563976,
0.0105469478,
0.0329570323,
0.0512807965,
-0.0333838277,
-0.0090968031,
0.0572264455,
0.0693158731,
0.0152157731,
-0.0168032069,
0.0252471678,
0.0496125072,
-0.0066123316,
0.0135370744,
0.0073352791,
-0.0325816981,
0.0106698414,
0.0053985789,
0.0417474732,
0.0172361005,
-0.0400782004,
-0.010111439,
-0.0038576764,
-0.0613024905,
-0.0000349155,
0.0550640076,
0.0090199653,
0.011561445,
-0.0218966305,
0.0683624074,
0.0278352983,
-0.0845188275,
0.015858613,
-0.0327367149,
-0.0017989307,
0.0565546006,
-0.0000963149,
-0.0537919514,
0.0177761801,
-0.0330948681,
0.03059569,
0.0175290313,
0.0090619195,
-0.0236089677,
0.0693063214,
-0.0824408904,
-0.0073651955,
-0.0028581487,
0.0262174644,
0.0041603553,
-0.0151108149,
0.0262733903,
0.0150260255,
-0.0461303517,
-0.0117909238,
-0.0075135469,
-0.038141001,
-0.0448283516,
-0.024174599,
0.0426937751,
0.0431963354,
0.0172822569,
-0.0333145447,
-0.0158291478,
0.0497893542,
-0.0281511806,
0.0419366695,
0.0323182456,
-0.052014485,
-0.0639487058,
0.0480481535,
-0.0290685669,
0.023023596,
0.0467181839,
-0.0325424038,
-0.0640514046,
0.0417009555,
-0.0251155011,
0.0846069232,
-0.0326746702,
0.0025026768,
-0.0183083564,
0.0240315665,
0.0218820833,
-0.0287555847,
0.0010959426,
-0.030227989,
-0.0054913475,
0.0052503068,
0.0054720794,
-0.0172604974,
-0.0661590099,
0.0344697759,
-0.0007783281,
0.0474434644,
-0.0141360322,
-0.0459401906,
-0.0354024507,
-0.0312033501,
-0.1131955385,
-0.009285626,
-0.0215653554,
-0.0149273081,
-0.0073021255,
0.0203918125,
-0.005244236,
-0.0277116559,
-0.019848071,
-0.014693276,
0.0034521797,
-0.0185345877,
-0.0452629887,
-0.0055845771,
-0.0078766076,
-0.0423263982,
0.0160751343,
0.0078200977,
0.0474386886,
-0.0369584896,
0.0334381834,
-0.0078449203,
0.0395927541,
-0.0161860511,
0.059133295,
-0.0000298881,
-0.0333979428,
-0.0152719514,
-0.027362749,
0.0654571205,
0.0449560136,
0.0002116395,
0.0403067619,
0.0161536764,
-0.0352488682,
-0.0745744109,
0.0332440212,
0.0264834575,
0.0225514267,
-0.0364663862,
0.0027404742,
-0.0465750732,
0.0176227819,
0.0359221511,
0.0045070564,
-0.0434040688,
-0.0379861034,
-0.0045943549,
-0.029883422,
-0.0164080914,
-0.0615177602,
-0.0273745283,
0.0086671757,
0.0053714281,
-0.0405488312,
0.0422484055,
-0.0778529942,
-0.0379369296,
-0.0440557636,
-0.0456027351,
-0.0179719795,
0.0714044124,
-0.0310587212,
-0.0016274469,
-0.009249148,
-0.0014278321,
-0.0324430875,
-0.0238719694,
0.0274821371,
-0.0690781623,
0.0362920426,
-0.0262675229,
-0.0250814985,
0.0133217797,
-0.0409364738,
-0.0470214598,
-0.0257790443,
-0.0317564681,
-0.0070461733,
-0.0282104369,
-0.0220837258,
-0.0442600325,
-0.0001195624,
0.0275847688,
0.0232585426,
-0.0036431851,
0.0341866538,
-0.0233623162,
0.0581527576,
0.0468916632,
0.0151432296,
-0.0531422161,
-0.0146250706,
0.0860926509,
0.0171539746,
0.0946653634,
0.0105215367,
-0.0522354469,
0.0020069827,
0.0184633266,
0.0368211009,
-0.0314956494,
0.0398881659,
0.0338876247,
-0.0410609357,
0.0145882759,
0.1098151654,
0.0104650799,
-0.0011935899,
-0.0208909865,
0.0424361192,
0.0506564565,
-0.0101138493,
0.0072611137,
-0.0614638478,
-0.0486822538,
0.0235281866,
0.0205854326,
0.0422335714,
0.0169783588,
-0.0140645662,
-0.0738764107,
0.018276792,
0.015191623,
-0.0069102501,
-0.0435925834,
-0.0355920866,
-0.0071663582,
-0.0097849034,
0.0498082712,
-0.0387408435,
-0.0124866683,
-0.0000544596,
0.0207852423,
-0.0281207152,
-0.0693243071,
0.0494547896,
-0.0358761214,
0.066938445,
0.0196563844,
0.0655518696,
-0.0265892074,
-0.0618362129,
-0.0282674208,
0.0227043815,
-0.0205609519,
0.0216773301,
0.0758301243,
-0.0197289307,
-0.0183831714,
0.0248991139,
0.0556032844,
0.0069392938,
-0.0130043365,
0.0045295623,
0.0567621663,
-0.0083934413,
-0.016062377,
-0.0171395987,
0.0417967848,
0.0350559726,
0.0795059428,
0.0343568027,
-0.0579950586,
0.0299080014,
0.0117350398,
0.0204506088,
-0.0392293558,
-0.0224346574,
-0.0107280081,
0.0168390796,
0.0168850105,
-0.035499502,
-0.0189179461,
0.0303668585,
0.0002171862,
0.0273670424,
-0.0016705078,
0.0457462892,
0.0065690652,
-0.0556298867,
0.0476467162,
0.0116603989,
0.0350648016,
-0.0071417405,
-0.035253834,
0.0607518852,
-0.0262411274,
-0.0201215707,
0.0218807496,
-0.1037403047,
-0.0576224998,
0.0041739098,
0.0146350088,
0.0166662987,
0.0681671277,
-0.0202503465,
-0.0294861048,
0.0506603196,
-0.010730139,
-0.0799847171,
0.007711282,
0.0628397614,
-0.014339962,
-0.0023897148,
0.0224147551,
-0.0320524424,
0.0167271588,
-0.0027108123,
-0.0216620602,
-0.0347465128,
-0.0513333604,
-0.0357659049,
0.0213194322,
0.0661807507,
0.0225107409,
-0.0165912323,
-0.0546048321,
0.015482096,
0.0081757847,
0.0369574986,
-0.0632466152,
0.0243750587,
0.030645635,
0.0069030505,
-0.0250397604,
-0.0053707068,
-0.0030677153,
-0.0291426387,
-0.0462663025,
0.0592253059,
0.0344778411,
-0.0253723077,
0.0216977242,
0.0175061487,
0.008056609,
0.0397049151,
-0.0073991437,
0.0070037353,
-0.0048174839,
0.044364132,
-0.0001538459,
0.0033118953,
0.029782651,
0.0013413356,
-0.0530203506,
-0.0085204318,
-0.010791067,
0.065714471,
0.0155881559,
-0.0301863626,
0.0289118234,
0.0009199221,
0.0335258506,
-0.005844661,
0.0476509742,
-0.0609531812,
-0.0281491261,
0.0329204388,
0.0119759776,
-0.0240381639,
0.0414188355,
0.0672186241,
0.0294298511,
0.0610997975,
-0.038074933,
0.048312746,
-0.0516077206,
-0.0164192375,
0.073717609,
0.0497696474,
-0.0201546848,
0.0389358625,
-0.0175358355,
-0.0859263539,
0.0077291471,
-0.0188869331,
-0.0108588571,
-0.0080260364,
0.0283200108,
0.0106016723,
-0.0358062759,
0.0057384931,
-0.0029861359,
-0.033442419,
-0.0019937782,
-0.0413830504,
0.0334363617,
-5.533432476e-33,
-0.0075943968,
0.0042472961,
-0.0042855167,
0.0371133536,
-0.0124071194,
0.0325325131,
0.0066982959,
0.0063941297,
-0.0239883065,
0.0105828205,
-0.0039528436,
0.0481908172,
0.0123511981,
0.0508540012,
-0.0063654804,
0.0098926248,
0.0499347076,
-0.0445404388,
0.0169696826,
0.0220944136,
0.0208902899,
0.0456183366,
0.0349274948,
-0.0444308221,
-0.0185031649,
-0.0182597749,
-0.0229256433,
-0.0010660933,
0.0234998353,
0.0453518294,
-0.0165784843,
0.031679526,
-0.0298403203,
-0.0139098959,
-0.0400549062,
0.0579227917,
-0.0712545961,
-0.0004663442,
0.0292288475,
0.042447079,
-0.0323904604,
0.0125194658,
0.0083009591,
-0.0027631402,
0.0237786584,
-0.0269664992,
0.0401986986,
0.0038185897,
-0.0060285861,
-0.0245449524,
-0.0270799845,
0.0130881611,
-0.0489221066,
-0.0687292889,
0.0885945037,
0.0336563662,
0.031379886,
-0.045336213,
-0.0680457652,
0.0430121161,
0.018676158,
0.0242602192,
0.0262024421,
0.0166042391,
-0.0371501632,
0.0809366927,
0.0135150105,
-0.0914969072,
-0.0021060077,
-0.008287197,
0.0807952583,
0.0673463866,
-0.004170035,
0.0227080826,
-0.0189995077,
-0.056731727,
-0.0340373106,
-0.0009520756,
0.0288155898,
-0.0008695058,
0.0140712308,
0.0218026862,
-0.0200205874,
-0.0137814833,
-0.0711388066,
-0.0394231603,
-0.0112583237,
0.00289762,
0.0574577413,
0.031322144,
-0.0067971447,
-0.0123461802,
0.0572642721,
-0.0640518069,
0.0073735667,
0.0188287422,
-0.0478290468,
0.0035645254,
-0.0305912048,
0.0494193435,
-0.0500556156,
-0.0086624632,
0.1091095507,
0.0197016466,
0.0390050411,
-0.004343715,
0.0320815034,
0.0475301743,
-0.0540331379,
0.0008358915,
-0.0155179594,
0.0022879911,
-0.0044682529,
0.0232047904,
0.018212989,
0.0273969099,
-0.0363059193,
0.0094225444,
-0.0102225384,
-0.0025426047,
-0.0472155511,
-0.0438355915,
-0.0127481762,
0.0126478281,
-0.0645380542,
-0.0178051218,
-0.0067165722,
-0.0586235337,
0.0386472754,
-0.0277325865,
0.0124936961,
0.0315104872,
2.561e-7,
0.0011505452,
0.0238603633,
0.0067997659,
-0.0260779876,
0.0304092616,
0.0290737487,
-0.027551854,
0.0054662735,
0.0377890654,
-0.0287155211,
0.013506013,
0.0279025231,
0.0941978619,
0.0247422624,
-0.1221979931,
-0.0313579962,
-0.0648644567,
-0.0228403881,
-0.0308511797,
-0.0399143174,
0.06138926,
0.1159385741,
0.0241958331,
-0.0065167123,
0.006636383,
-0.0113938004,
0.0300496966,
-0.0132289948,
-0.0190008469,
-0.0099722883,
0.0174388159,
-0.0004515504,
-0.0334365293,
0.0191019736,
-0.0347892083,
0.0358110629,
0.0239747558,
0.0882202238,
0.0116956439,
-0.0483754985,
-0.0470672101,
0.0462105386,
-0.0609517768,
-0.0172782429,
0.0519593172,
0.0024604131,
-0.0126526039,
-0.0309817512,
-0.0245302208,
-0.0045059095,
0.0206140019,
0.0009055575,
-0.0047123753,
0.0413506664,
-0.0002297013,
-0.0461219959,
-0.0258416645,
-0.0806104913,
-0.0148974694,
0.0039787549,
-0.0603670664,
-0.0312418193,
-0.0250596534,
-0.0591618717,
0.0333060585,
-0.0633605346,
0.0088967066,
1.926314506e-34,
0.0188092552,
-0.0273435358,
0.0108440351,
0.0116004543,
0.0333625078,
-0.028364107,
0.0100987069,
0.0015523147,
0.0138366353,
-0.0771117359,
-0.0265812445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07006v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07006v1 | Context-dependent Instruction Tuning for Dialogue Response Generation | 2023-11-13T01:25:30 | 2023-11-13T01:25:30 | Jin Myung Kwak, Minseon Kim, Sung Ju Hwang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent language models have achieved impressive performance in natural
language tasks by incorporating instructions with task input during
fine-tuning. Since all samples in the same natural language task can be
explained with the same task instructions, many instruction datasets only
provide a few instructions for the entire task, without considering the input
of each example in the task. However, this approach becomes ineffective in
complex multi-turn dialogue generation tasks, where the input varies highly
with each turn as the dialogue context changes, so that simple task
instructions cannot improve the generation performance. To address this
limitation, we introduce a context-based instruction fine-tuning framework for
each multi-turn dialogue which generates both responses and instructions based
on the previous context as input. During the evaluation, the model generates
instructions based on the previous context to self-guide the response. The
proposed framework produces comparable or even outstanding results compared to
the baselines by aligning instructions to the input during fine-tuning with the
instructions in quantitative evaluations on dialogue benchmark datasets with
reduced computation budget. | [
0.0475737117,
0.0299619492,
-0.0016876733,
0.0302204918,
-0.0194464084,
0.005208422,
0.0198392272,
-0.0380951948,
-0.0110688629,
-0.0643324405,
-0.0446025543,
-0.0239309929,
-0.0050676907,
0.011326069,
0.0269442629,
-0.0520837866,
0.0356987491,
-0.0374027528,
-0.0000239857,
-0.01142684,
-0.0055252463,
0.0146756927,
-0.0478068925,
0.0523490906,
-0.0032138801,
-0.019716613,
-0.0429677144,
0.0419513695,
0.0077690375,
-0.0118980557,
0.045805864,
0.0427093431,
0.0106628081,
0.0002925499,
0.000001698,
-0.02059054,
0.0078202458,
-0.0243993849,
-0.0284060929,
0.009900325,
0.0200950038,
-0.0057211719,
0.0010793654,
0.0307020247,
-0.0440257005,
-0.0060586743,
0.039501939,
0.0523216054,
0.0888472348,
0.1028084531,
0.0067125233,
-0.0369290523,
-0.0118681611,
-0.0281580538,
0.0099415565,
-0.0519334674,
-0.0246300865,
0.0052368608,
0.0122284396,
0.0352075174,
-0.025273351,
0.0156802516,
0.0323215313,
-0.018396806,
-0.0386467054,
0.0180555675,
-0.0306571443,
0.0108455922,
-0.0468578152,
0.0934714451,
0.0165300127,
0.0181517415,
0.0147347003,
-0.0063544437,
0.0092656016,
-0.0506985113,
-0.0206592102,
0.0380191021,
0.0131717809,
-0.0091402745,
0.0124344816,
0.011119389,
-0.0280082915,
0.018122578,
-0.0209208019,
0.0530455671,
0.0097863926,
-0.0205525942,
-0.0440056212,
-0.0036684622,
-0.0100021884,
-0.0535598509,
-0.0131624267,
0.0379371084,
-0.0985984132,
0.0166827869,
-0.0766706392,
0.0515275411,
0.0195266008,
0.0319895297,
0.0617106929,
0.0526464731,
0.0015481089,
0.0136336498,
0.0027400497,
0.0740166232,
-0.0141261527,
-0.0026231778,
-0.0319698006,
0.0097294319,
-0.0436736941,
0.0145212598,
-0.0506629534,
0.0006347309,
-0.0969542861,
-0.0377601497,
-0.0322221443,
0.0683082044,
0.0151945734,
0.0019362743,
0.0302731842,
0.0188569836,
-0.0538187101,
0.00227866,
-0.0117448159,
0.0097976774,
-0.0408312455,
0.0120918909,
0.0552007966,
-0.0704985559,
-0.0349892192,
0.0367441475,
0.0151476609,
-0.0234362856,
-0.0022693651,
0.0665444061,
-0.0277020112,
-0.0243766382,
-0.0001573409,
-0.0585586838,
-0.0488987379,
-0.0821491033,
-0.016962124,
-0.025780851,
0.0392472222,
-0.0000562069,
-0.0210632924,
0.0123882229,
0.0079348972,
0.0109356111,
-0.0185841136,
0.0357625559,
0.0217005443,
0.021665873,
0.0162312202,
0.0084580518,
0.0036965345,
0.0587487891,
0.0487154201,
0.0083821779,
0.0191222597,
-0.0068203066,
-0.0058271866,
0.0080809733,
0.0312966481,
0.0027586841,
0.0362053066,
0.0386148989,
-0.0383373424,
0.0350839421,
0.0336096883,
0.0570798703,
-0.0468906388,
0.0000614824,
0.0377395414,
-0.0016443423,
0.0208705869,
0.0000160835,
0.0729921088,
0.0390093215,
-0.0274602268,
0.0424536578,
-0.0394064002,
0.0390020385,
0.0105047375,
0.0499712303,
0.0733151883,
0.0051829647,
-0.0425925553,
-0.0292505231,
0.0328968726,
0.0159274414,
0.0029931732,
-0.0022409228,
0.0055045057,
0.0457080044,
-0.0953615457,
0.0228994917,
0.0042788219,
-0.053147696,
-0.035029944,
-0.0337499492,
0.0224416777,
0.0676311925,
0.057229802,
0.0156561118,
-0.0620539859,
-0.0102022309,
0.0222663488,
0.0573059805,
0.0414829068,
-0.0226426944,
0.0589468442,
-0.0609706938,
-0.0066072918,
-0.0438183956,
-0.0028460883,
0.0352434069,
0.0173715763,
-0.0262999069,
0.0395595245,
0.0235655885,
0.0241525657,
0.0104540708,
-0.0010502625,
-0.0254777092,
0.0222251751,
0.0159229506,
0.0377129242,
0.0090190917,
-0.0121452799,
0.0177281089,
0.0154015031,
-0.0156258121,
0.0369053558,
-0.0014927667,
-0.0743683502,
-0.081222631,
0.0001087227,
-0.0243275426,
0.0041765454,
-0.0070817415,
-0.0389970168,
-0.0648737252,
0.0225775875,
-0.0321779288,
0.0101250894,
-0.0429109484,
0.0110314824,
0.0640349388,
0.0325267054,
-0.0344986357,
0.0315476172,
0.00179266,
0.0147960521,
0.0652837083,
0.0690117776,
-0.0008465902,
-0.0633504689,
0.0174543802,
-0.0189401116,
-0.0334171541,
0.0055479407,
0.0304155517,
0.059055347,
-0.0460686758,
-0.0501878448,
-0.0875863358,
0.0271549337,
-0.0266210325,
0.0046493704,
0.0384007841,
0.0138666332,
-0.0108910482,
0.0006996546,
-0.0352015905,
-0.0073229154,
0.0595111027,
0.0157869719,
0.0269536655,
0.001986417,
-0.0178387128,
-0.0532775819,
0.0103398561,
0.027725989,
0.0091463346,
-0.0007648654,
0.0647608936,
-0.066143848,
0.0153133832,
-0.0262953136,
0.0310649723,
-0.0132456906,
-0.0739764497,
0.0270956997,
0.0196576007,
0.0601375848,
0.0606322922,
0.0255246852,
0.0202445332,
-0.0091916043,
-0.0543447025,
-0.0541418381,
0.0579719543,
-0.0369100682,
-0.0122624375,
-0.0161796436,
-0.0297872163,
0.0148842819,
0.0490454249,
0.0437789299,
0.0358464494,
-0.0606702231,
0.0073096645,
0.0401885398,
-0.0347278938,
0.0207760558,
-0.008145866,
-0.0335270762,
0.0134722786,
-0.03306932,
-0.027883254,
0.0549636371,
-0.049820248,
-0.0262757782,
-0.0429574288,
0.0153032765,
-0.0218004268,
0.0341657475,
-0.0075129899,
0.0137209352,
-0.0161248427,
-0.0185913295,
-0.0486469455,
0.0148396036,
0.0273999646,
-0.026044827,
0.0538259149,
-0.0366753861,
-0.0179012958,
-0.0246000998,
-0.0419868343,
-0.0580424741,
-0.0369761735,
0.0319011658,
0.0081165759,
0.0787242278,
-0.0387448333,
-0.0066775386,
0.0204062704,
0.0095551545,
0.0503226705,
-0.0307153389,
0.0010951242,
-0.042201139,
0.0328433327,
0.050742574,
0.0191440172,
-0.0135933487,
-0.0143793281,
0.0662910268,
0.0096068168,
0.0523456782,
-0.0038603023,
-0.0188777354,
0.0001962574,
0.0177424271,
0.001724228,
0.0098467004,
0.0502107479,
0.0966130346,
-0.0371085815,
-0.0573117211,
0.1149197519,
0.0062827379,
0.0100135682,
0.0011512347,
0.0097026043,
0.0575441904,
0.0082498994,
0.0234172326,
-0.0735449344,
-0.0262299981,
-0.0035254606,
0.0321843177,
-0.0017451958,
-0.0137006044,
-0.0259476695,
-0.1063218936,
0.0565847121,
0.0044420687,
-0.0475102998,
-0.0460079014,
0.0001006681,
0.008668554,
0.0256092902,
0.0416728482,
0.0246718973,
-0.0101039475,
0.0079800552,
0.0199034177,
0.0081961146,
-0.0470817983,
0.0193703119,
-0.0116167283,
0.0672057942,
0.0629734322,
0.0246890597,
0.0595068187,
0.0224580262,
0.0177824181,
-0.0526820906,
0.0265939422,
-0.0103712454,
0.0434066169,
-0.0053322567,
-0.0248283576,
0.0025753379,
0.0371470265,
-0.0214677267,
-0.0072870897,
0.012550991,
-0.0036579499,
-0.0432187729,
0.0090270275,
-0.0084870849,
0.0389850661,
0.0512712672,
0.0753322467,
0.046529226,
-0.0318708792,
-0.048155237,
-0.0199055765,
0.0067394311,
-0.127383247,
0.0183292516,
-0.0041058036,
0.0219416302,
0.0094386842,
-0.095167987,
-0.061969433,
0.016755892,
0.0359413177,
-0.024639545,
-0.0322429687,
-0.0105678467,
-0.0178051554,
-0.0156710614,
-0.0108842785,
-0.021240538,
0.010985001,
-0.0716965348,
-0.0483725853,
0.047311902,
-0.0301757939,
0.0098307822,
0.048434265,
-0.0807898268,
-0.0655114651,
-0.0192125048,
0.0709988326,
0.0134198386,
0.0678020641,
0.0035782326,
-0.0014688249,
-0.004899173,
0.0088195466,
-0.0535888039,
-0.0001414758,
0.0337303691,
0.0371292159,
-0.0191538781,
0.0356347561,
-0.0268307067,
0.0454212837,
0.0054298099,
0.0725360289,
-0.0345707349,
-0.0920453891,
0.0107864849,
-0.0092730699,
0.0243233629,
-0.018930478,
0.0113095473,
0.0083759902,
0.0298387986,
-0.0330105349,
-0.0239496864,
-0.0541055836,
0.0008677919,
-0.0140430303,
-0.0362592116,
0.0049793208,
-0.0295989588,
-0.0310871713,
0.0436752625,
-0.0525427051,
0.0211204886,
0.0116274375,
0.0066506984,
0.0045938324,
0.0053647794,
-0.0225059912,
0.010655622,
0.0007487893,
0.0295261405,
0.0093631288,
0.1108377054,
0.0126750758,
-0.0113803726,
-0.0072857137,
0.0266842339,
-0.0443687737,
-0.0025712023,
-0.0158640482,
-0.0208147895,
0.0189219564,
0.0043960689,
0.0597312339,
-0.0095217247,
0.0059435004,
-0.0189036988,
0.0673000216,
-0.0031030381,
-0.0347656645,
0.0338615328,
0.0267558824,
-0.0075422344,
0.011035217,
0.0815040991,
-0.001693959,
0.0220047142,
0.0112568177,
0.0402072296,
-0.0704828575,
-0.0701842159,
-0.0242306814,
0.0138782859,
0.0088636493,
0.0246375185,
-0.0005741672,
-0.0373763666,
-0.0279948097,
0.0266425088,
0.0179392248,
-0.0049731387,
0.0559353232,
0.0381119847,
-0.0112706143,
-0.0277386177,
-0.0498075336,
0.0180942863,
-0.0149237011,
-0.0296311602,
-0.0543145947,
-5.885825111e-33,
-0.0633700043,
-0.0256704651,
0.0441913754,
-0.0270863827,
-0.0281238481,
-0.0258203801,
-0.0606458522,
-0.0043201805,
-0.0145852687,
-0.0016435798,
-0.0104217026,
-0.0145764053,
0.0086217476,
0.0579169095,
-0.0230787806,
-0.0262208991,
0.0465411954,
-0.0126281548,
-0.0406645462,
0.0600179099,
0.0173752997,
0.0014671183,
-0.0038643442,
-0.0561260283,
-0.0075868475,
-0.0245693494,
-0.0432722569,
0.0049419128,
-0.0094659282,
0.065009892,
-0.0105457157,
0.0025742901,
0.0161655918,
-0.0463552028,
-0.0317746513,
0.0459681042,
-0.043093577,
-0.0142554818,
0.0296498984,
-0.0072527938,
-0.0569166876,
-0.0349143595,
-0.006117939,
-0.0278219618,
-0.0035642637,
0.002254091,
-0.0165997744,
-0.0174747594,
-0.0215699356,
-0.0148153752,
-0.0545235276,
0.0128199486,
-0.0282581318,
-0.0974893793,
-0.0166963618,
0.0800112113,
0.0167482682,
-0.0347139053,
-0.0253903531,
0.0259292983,
0.0080321999,
0.0271998979,
0.0357791893,
0.0353656299,
-0.0059868572,
0.031902384,
0.0174641293,
-0.0059320186,
0.0024435634,
-0.0127084404,
-0.0250785127,
0.0655271709,
-0.0227467529,
0.0443664566,
-0.017818559,
0.0045609893,
-0.0404352546,
0.0137335919,
0.0044062375,
0.0150979785,
0.0366230048,
-0.0098645175,
-0.0266684014,
-0.0157380607,
-0.02194231,
-0.0020334837,
-0.0149836121,
-0.0124323228,
0.0513809174,
0.0387616344,
-0.0147472415,
-0.0220040083,
0.0616190024,
-0.0165600143,
0.0071775643,
0.0286369435,
-0.0549642034,
0.0017756447,
-0.0253914502,
0.0111511415,
-0.039334327,
-0.0463994555,
0.0842506364,
0.0133550391,
-0.0052053165,
0.0283477828,
0.0077178259,
0.0278849322,
-0.0717807934,
0.0094924318,
-0.0400242433,
0.082934238,
-0.061718192,
0.0083270697,
-0.0167177599,
-0.0160257742,
-0.0394893773,
0.0738755614,
-0.0059163789,
-0.0406635217,
-0.0243478213,
-0.0302596092,
0.0171809532,
0.0184889287,
-0.0439817123,
0.0398182571,
-0.0015571832,
-0.0215818863,
-0.0135690216,
-0.0126445694,
-0.0155312782,
0.0235550683,
2.38e-7,
-0.0176861566,
0.0318283178,
0.0401863977,
0.0407550745,
0.02364197,
0.0165555999,
0.0070347823,
0.0137650026,
0.0235324204,
0.0027808947,
0.0224368237,
0.0153969908,
0.0515270978,
-0.027402591,
-0.0599103943,
0.0122074606,
-0.0835646465,
0.0090698274,
-0.0336019136,
-0.0271248017,
0.0353954621,
0.0654198751,
-0.0280305389,
0.0165891685,
-0.0064742388,
0.0269768685,
0.0352393501,
-0.0227985326,
-0.015981961,
0.0422982089,
-0.0061798003,
0.0043612472,
-0.0131502654,
0.0147047769,
-0.0039573447,
0.0212372057,
-0.0353122763,
0.0736875385,
0.0206636582,
-0.0739799887,
0.0140628964,
-0.020857349,
0.0192255713,
-0.0295569766,
0.0434026718,
-0.0498825796,
0.0010929679,
-0.0149400923,
-0.0171005446,
0.0213874839,
-0.017818369,
-0.0351466089,
-0.0317415856,
0.0161223579,
0.0236209109,
0.0013259748,
0.0215774886,
-0.0727115273,
-0.0154839167,
0.0008923779,
-0.0569526404,
-0.0199389104,
-0.0236840528,
-0.0180779435,
0.0067316149,
-0.0262846574,
-0.0158355664,
2.064340272e-34,
0.0190114193,
-0.0283330083,
0.0208197627,
0.0185486153,
0.0342998803,
-0.0093662292,
-0.0307043046,
0.0005994988,
0.0495227315,
-0.075115189,
-0.0572598875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06985v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06985v2 | Large Language Models are In-context Teachers for Knowledge Reasoning | 2023-11-12T23:14:43 | 2024-06-17T05:57:38 | Jiachen Zhao, Zonghai Yao, Zhichao Yang, Hong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting teaches large language models (LLMs) in
context to reason over queries that require more than mere information
retrieval. However, human experts are usually required to craft demonstrations
for in-context learning (ICL), which is expensive and has high variance. More
importantly, how to craft helpful reasoning exemplars for ICL remains unclear.
In this work, we investigate whether LLMs can be better in-context teachers for
knowledge reasoning. We follow the ``encoding specificity'' hypothesis in
human's memory retrieval to assume in-context exemplars at inference should
match the encoding context in training data. We are thus motivated to propose
Self-Explain to use one LLM's self-elicited explanations as in-context
demonstrations for prompting it as they are generalized from the model's
training examples. Self-Explain is shown to significantly outperform using
human-crafted exemplars and other baselines. We further reveal that for
in-context teaching, rationales by distinct teacher LLMs or human experts that
more resemble the student LLM's self-explanations are better demonstrations,
which supports our encoding specificity hypothesis. We then propose Teach-Back
that aligns the teacher LLM with the student to enhance the in-context teaching
performance. For example, Teach-Back enables a 7B model to teach the much
larger GPT-3.5 in context, surpassing human teachers by around 5% in test
accuracy on medical question answering. | [
0.0305596143,
0.0059533142,
-0.0150410496,
0.0346708745,
-0.0219363235,
0.009025842,
0.0543233752,
-0.013394163,
-0.0051868367,
-0.0376259387,
-0.0141347451,
-0.0204282012,
-0.047989089,
-0.02022098,
0.0537290052,
-0.0795945004,
0.0273272097,
-0.0479545742,
0.0156892575,
-0.0159799382,
-0.0409611911,
-0.0056605176,
-0.0310844164,
0.0085424548,
-0.000250823,
-0.0236020014,
-0.0333314762,
-0.0130450176,
0.0089342156,
-0.036180336,
-0.0110357944,
0.0452947542,
0.0675490499,
-0.021429535,
0.0000021748,
-0.0557685085,
-0.0117809903,
-0.0167755112,
-0.0776956305,
0.0156061854,
-0.0392596088,
0.03179444,
0.0208983384,
0.0136811659,
-0.0354051664,
0.0301183444,
-0.004193251,
0.0420785286,
0.0478670597,
0.0426125601,
0.0144340042,
-0.0322999619,
0.0069223964,
-0.0058430382,
0.0604768246,
-0.0436891206,
0.001113519,
0.028583426,
0.029632125,
0.0629583001,
-0.0212297961,
0.017830655,
0.0600834973,
0.0079805236,
-0.0024159162,
0.0386385508,
-0.0026324987,
0.0196599811,
0.0075379503,
0.0327388681,
0.04963677,
-0.0425883308,
-0.0195839386,
0.0231054369,
0.039679274,
0.0284141283,
-0.0621351078,
0.0351213403,
-0.0177122373,
0.0184081532,
0.0115897665,
0.0268100426,
0.0379040837,
0.0383001752,
-0.0320044793,
0.0234051161,
-0.0301479455,
-0.0392852239,
0.0063987388,
-0.0059960163,
-0.0227962248,
-0.008258759,
-0.0191197246,
0.0706306621,
-0.0323222019,
0.0420713983,
0.0113824913,
-0.0038968381,
0.0098196864,
-0.0059000691,
-0.0077775647,
0.0517538376,
-0.019569112,
0.0558439866,
-0.0428696461,
0.078790091,
0.0013166078,
0.0556465425,
-0.0265959948,
-0.0068045533,
-0.0929336995,
-0.030672567,
-0.0545615256,
0.0177446678,
-0.0108808177,
0.0141095892,
-0.0253752805,
0.0230936781,
-0.035339579,
0.0107497051,
-0.0170991793,
0.0135404905,
-0.0005193254,
-0.0309764314,
-0.0466585681,
0.0275840741,
-0.0545604154,
0.0002593594,
0.0487993322,
-0.0483081788,
-0.0305090491,
-0.0144378729,
-0.0137390886,
-0.0098097911,
0.023441501,
0.0200105458,
-0.0336963646,
-0.0293548293,
-0.0478896089,
-0.0383829474,
0.0045675873,
-0.0630703866,
-0.0058218553,
-0.063999325,
-0.0015292586,
0.0181150604,
0.0004207498,
-0.0344019569,
0.0141242752,
0.0156133529,
-0.0081573045,
0.0753075704,
-0.0000875618,
0.0259732977,
0.0311291721,
0.0439986102,
-0.0484824814,
0.0627558678,
0.008509269,
-0.0113922665,
0.0007548287,
-0.0319730937,
0.0075074472,
-0.0298006013,
0.0553364567,
-0.0039558401,
-0.0369161218,
0.0281133875,
0.0122016845,
0.0693369284,
0.0269675441,
0.0420110337,
-0.0373250023,
0.0134110227,
0.0406441763,
0.0742363855,
0.0369434729,
0.0085720317,
0.0255182367,
-0.0088243745,
0.0355257727,
0.007084121,
-0.0588878877,
0.0337083749,
-0.0119583961,
0.0294071455,
0.0275974702,
-0.0284385551,
-0.0462844856,
-0.0376356579,
-0.0134854242,
0.0171268396,
-0.0160355456,
0.0425113887,
0.0574292205,
0.0132453386,
-0.0291199852,
0.0417746678,
0.010867591,
-0.0310795754,
0.006063052,
-0.0912424549,
0.0485677496,
0.0522277504,
0.0312434677,
-0.0090104351,
0.008941262,
-0.0110165933,
0.0453853942,
-0.0052417601,
0.0218779463,
-0.0267308,
-0.0327664614,
-0.0257940535,
-0.0251566656,
-0.0628578961,
0.0072613531,
-0.0179776251,
0.0432707593,
0.0095297331,
0.0125691099,
-0.0425584987,
0.0076181721,
0.012538271,
-0.0676258206,
-0.0610450394,
-0.0456361659,
0.0160081536,
-0.0090923943,
0.0228028018,
0.0271732621,
0.0168077741,
0.0289085433,
-0.0182017665,
-0.0166220777,
-0.0056292214,
-0.0916312486,
-0.0517387763,
0.0033776718,
-0.0069007413,
-0.0154610993,
-0.0603505857,
-0.0254768673,
-0.0529575273,
-0.0037681973,
-0.022794066,
0.0722015947,
-0.0419514813,
-0.0111194802,
0.005798534,
-0.0459006354,
-0.0242155958,
0.0942667499,
0.0072696088,
0.0029530989,
0.0429076701,
0.0378484502,
-0.0143915983,
-0.0415051803,
0.0253535509,
0.0127130589,
0.0071935812,
0.0167565849,
-0.0226249527,
0.008126664,
-0.0898823887,
0.0130013861,
-0.0906427726,
-0.0197052993,
-0.0127476947,
-0.0153773297,
0.0219982844,
-0.0059657712,
0.0012204213,
-0.0229349751,
-0.0406645611,
-0.0314394459,
-0.0082345903,
0.0338135585,
0.0144868502,
0.0330457017,
0.010015199,
0.0023561546,
0.0086489106,
-0.0301837474,
0.0552945957,
0.0188740101,
0.0289464183,
-0.0392683782,
0.0251390692,
-0.0012609352,
-0.0013900555,
-0.0289656073,
-0.0120630926,
0.0408752859,
-0.023597775,
0.0125124184,
0.0972495452,
0.0080997804,
0.0419932678,
0.0471483916,
0.0284786094,
-0.0776683018,
0.0364547782,
-0.0042252587,
-0.0456529111,
-0.0150900781,
-0.0014382625,
-0.0200437065,
0.0399579667,
0.0057295947,
0.0077573671,
-0.0620307028,
0.014991045,
0.0100291595,
-0.0085492842,
-0.0830728039,
-0.0389514938,
-0.0139959063,
0.0657952577,
0.002284874,
-0.0312746875,
0.0891995504,
0.0237045456,
0.0108959302,
-0.0135980872,
0.011485911,
-0.0279265083,
0.0824654251,
-0.0438516177,
0.0154332211,
-0.0212062802,
-0.005676677,
-0.051846385,
0.0042540659,
0.025485253,
-0.0479083993,
0.0335288793,
-0.0590140596,
-0.0007707372,
0.0158661716,
-0.0499240234,
-0.0750961378,
0.0096882135,
-0.0584610626,
0.0101578403,
-0.0369228646,
-0.0007038195,
0.0042361035,
-0.0036672468,
0.0612775497,
0.0177975725,
0.0138341729,
-0.0241059028,
0.0190370362,
-0.0120526096,
0.002918601,
0.0363121852,
0.0107674049,
-0.0418788493,
0.0876756012,
0.0453720614,
0.0812980384,
-0.0421036854,
-0.0031929899,
0.0246468671,
0.0033527256,
-0.0108544007,
-0.002494432,
0.0521701463,
0.0433341824,
-0.0765111744,
-0.031915091,
0.1250621676,
0.0221763197,
-0.0503126122,
0.0032415101,
-0.055187352,
0.0189204104,
0.0248311404,
0.0252212044,
-0.0676034838,
-0.0397808254,
0.0077983588,
0.0144365858,
-0.0171442535,
-0.009145027,
0.0044418108,
-0.1302283406,
0.0167043936,
0.0207497794,
-0.0421776921,
-0.0198310055,
-0.0487740301,
-0.008054086,
0.0132048717,
0.021103682,
0.0469437987,
-0.0090730768,
0.0142971678,
0.0338902026,
0.0418650471,
-0.0695548281,
0.0463990048,
-0.0179387499,
0.0223716795,
0.0134541523,
-0.0069003082,
0.0105787804,
-0.0687494874,
-0.0076143197,
-0.0194675662,
0.0595606193,
-0.004046205,
0.0633399636,
-0.0080197081,
-0.0046493667,
-0.0310958996,
0.0797428638,
-0.0330746099,
-0.0310487729,
0.0062657953,
0.0936251059,
-0.0267854109,
-0.0052483897,
-0.0052527445,
-0.0117182322,
-0.0086938236,
0.0976279676,
0.0304964483,
-0.0207406823,
0.0037562356,
-0.0154779339,
-0.0150926923,
0.018891111,
-0.0387654342,
0.0362794399,
0.0272822268,
0.0384452865,
-0.026607478,
-0.0353295282,
0.048832126,
0.0824370608,
-0.0013412664,
0.034023229,
-0.0430874266,
0.0294978432,
-0.0138986008,
0.0494534001,
-0.0292625073,
-0.0119602829,
-0.0444286354,
-0.0162882023,
0.0218697656,
-0.0549513437,
-0.0026079321,
0.0013398913,
-0.0178312641,
-0.0288470108,
-0.0155149307,
0.0416062921,
0.0315736756,
0.0849632546,
0.0283362251,
-0.0385395773,
0.049101416,
0.0173933227,
-0.0489114784,
-0.0136255715,
0.0320757218,
0.0129389204,
0.0112472204,
0.0386445522,
-0.0393435359,
-0.0254809968,
-0.0031131404,
0.0375224724,
-0.006764356,
-0.003921458,
0.0753260702,
-0.0130586447,
0.0310687926,
-0.018878283,
-0.0089664152,
-0.0032537547,
0.0244295169,
-0.0309088919,
-0.0154389916,
-0.0065378402,
0.0080525689,
0.0143517107,
-0.0198616348,
0.0262434073,
-0.0700456277,
0.0291263331,
-0.0096512344,
0.0088873375,
0.0070232875,
-0.00072022,
0.0074650799,
0.0097714216,
0.009497839,
-0.0134881781,
-0.0122448187,
0.0178070664,
0.0545299686,
-0.0037488458,
0.1236916259,
0.0476114154,
-0.0068233674,
-0.009988579,
-0.0066640442,
-0.1000169963,
-0.0558173507,
0.0119499816,
0.0100146458,
0.0092045637,
-0.0129670277,
-0.0214113407,
-0.0488808751,
-0.0003345194,
0.0255981777,
0.0155710727,
-0.0046465937,
-0.0126087898,
0.0334591195,
0.0439074375,
0.0179330986,
0.0078094276,
0.0626410469,
-0.0075096921,
0.0467878729,
-0.0124070747,
-0.0115518002,
-0.0106111225,
-0.0057947692,
0.0066208253,
0.0249339137,
0.0095611326,
0.0163189899,
-0.0606787503,
-0.0781429932,
-0.0392346755,
0.01499072,
-0.0250654798,
-0.0298652109,
0.0583734661,
0.0684628263,
-0.0298840962,
-0.0400744192,
-0.0033888153,
0.0561083741,
-0.0093365302,
-0.0149638383,
-0.0314171687,
-6.528654482e-33,
-0.0153605994,
-0.0371339396,
0.0504054874,
-0.016262453,
0.022070894,
-0.0155475261,
-0.0532134213,
0.00275694,
-0.0443678163,
0.0261958055,
-0.0303121433,
-0.00073912,
-0.0032242327,
0.0256961472,
0.0239441618,
-0.0190407578,
0.0086409133,
0.0106897652,
-0.0178502239,
0.0368870981,
0.0173510984,
0.0152861718,
0.0478004962,
-0.0466107689,
0.0407689437,
-0.0207968596,
0.0178498607,
0.0288173724,
-0.0661121756,
0.0357534289,
-0.0088255061,
0.0257715005,
0.0248935018,
-0.0613752007,
0.0130141536,
0.0146039817,
-0.0855788887,
-0.0504009798,
0.0357639007,
-0.0300285425,
-0.0774773434,
-0.0475171395,
0.0363774076,
-0.0222682413,
-0.0273559615,
-0.0131108416,
0.0173208676,
-0.0150114298,
-0.0171708278,
0.000116885,
-0.0116441278,
-0.0138401659,
-0.0268379617,
-0.017144179,
0.0081130117,
0.0529357083,
-0.0397954732,
0.0208594706,
-0.0151147172,
0.0142567009,
0.022125978,
-0.0068868957,
0.0753617659,
0.0086353319,
0.0045255739,
0.0455028675,
0.0040652971,
0.005328238,
-0.0537475795,
-0.0358871706,
-0.0067626843,
0.0582612902,
0.0639951825,
0.0533224456,
0.0399930887,
0.0338504724,
-0.0693045706,
0.0139827104,
-0.0182023216,
0.0361370593,
0.0120122526,
0.015883008,
-0.0712119192,
-0.0383531265,
-0.0575571172,
-0.0046492796,
-0.029483119,
-0.0530887805,
0.0420798808,
0.0052329102,
-0.0216939393,
-0.0282114856,
0.0004473731,
-0.0361583456,
-0.0001547221,
0.024279844,
-0.0067786742,
-0.0108596664,
-0.0237481911,
0.0142485294,
-0.0315127671,
-0.0088916356,
0.0049229204,
0.0337073989,
0.0293007307,
0.0291515365,
0.0519842468,
0.0024840757,
-0.0379375666,
-0.0225332025,
-0.0687249005,
-0.0183498319,
-0.0014470833,
-0.070687376,
0.0309315808,
0.0458697565,
-0.0208224636,
0.0298720114,
0.0095261335,
-0.0614573881,
-0.018254023,
-0.0128702978,
-0.0475421995,
-0.0407667197,
-0.0010900646,
-0.0094946157,
-0.0138866697,
0.0221819952,
0.0300169289,
-0.0546786115,
-0.0109214112,
0.0477246307,
2.883e-7,
0.0042893947,
0.0321717709,
0.0080622621,
-0.0269876979,
0.0105066514,
0.0390953273,
-0.0135398284,
-0.0383404754,
0.0465253703,
-0.0881720111,
0.0162934382,
0.0715583414,
0.0252950657,
0.0127326474,
-0.0597333461,
0.0066139386,
-0.0487410203,
-0.0132132517,
-0.022403691,
-0.0037118038,
0.0781004429,
0.0343583487,
0.0182283316,
-0.015025923,
0.0152119603,
-0.0443571359,
0.060886167,
-0.0477582887,
0.024231378,
-0.0158223975,
-0.0071922829,
0.0284316335,
0.0284802299,
0.0637177378,
0.0080197714,
-0.0014647588,
-0.0338468738,
0.0352327339,
0.0101415198,
-0.0205177683,
-0.0263236985,
-0.0047205132,
0.0218272489,
-0.0950536132,
0.0685922951,
-0.0445625745,
-0.0139970919,
0.0430967659,
0.0133937839,
-0.041945342,
-0.0012067282,
-0.0009972348,
0.0106027741,
-0.0037830907,
-0.0133105302,
0.0065298183,
0.0231623854,
-0.0752456933,
-0.0424729735,
0.0139150526,
-0.0420188941,
-0.008549016,
-0.0226345491,
0.0149970576,
0.0215623416,
-0.0265946649,
-0.0012100092,
2.323068645e-34,
-0.0034952222,
0.0005802626,
0.0569717996,
0.0470556691,
0.0301739201,
0.0123177776,
-0.0147575773,
0.011080198,
0.0705751553,
-0.0506016836,
-0.0193865411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06899v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06899v6 | Flames: Benchmarking Value Alignment of LLMs in Chinese | 2023-11-12T17:18:21 | 2024-05-22T06:18:41 | Kexin Huang, Xiangyang Liu, Qianyu Guo, Tianxiang Sun, Jiawei Sun, Yaru Wang, Zeyang Zhou, Yixu Wang, Yan Teng, Xipeng Qiu, Yingchun Wang, Dahua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The widespread adoption of large language models (LLMs) across various
regions underscores the urgent need to evaluate their alignment with human
values. Current benchmarks, however, fall short of effectively uncovering
safety vulnerabilities in LLMs. Despite numerous models achieving high scores
and 'topping the chart' in these evaluations, there is still a significant gap
in LLMs' deeper alignment with human values and achieving genuine harmlessness.
To this end, this paper proposes a value alignment benchmark named Flames,
which encompasses both common harmlessness principles and a unique morality
dimension that integrates specific Chinese values such as harmony. Accordingly,
we carefully design adversarial prompts that incorporate complex scenarios and
jailbreaking methods, mostly with implicit malice. By prompting 17 mainstream
LLMs, we obtain model responses and rigorously annotate them for detailed
evaluation. Our findings indicate that all the evaluated LLMs demonstrate
relatively poor performance on Flames, particularly in the safety and fairness
dimensions. We also develop a lightweight specified scorer capable of scoring
LLMs across multiple dimensions to efficiently evaluate new models on the
benchmark. The complexity of Flames has far exceeded existing benchmarks,
setting a new challenge for contemporary LLMs and highlighting the need for
further alignment of LLMs. Our benchmark is publicly available at
https://github.com/AIFlames/Flames. | [
0.033491239,
0.0723736361,
-0.0291677956,
0.0506161898,
-0.0343026035,
-0.0110121127,
-0.0029969059,
-0.0159394946,
0.0149815138,
-0.0100001534,
-0.0317722298,
-0.0357679315,
0.0210928153,
0.0101024359,
-0.001228994,
-0.0505375303,
0.0682428852,
0.0061253328,
0.0331352167,
-0.0130670508,
0.046792753,
0.0007377143,
0.0361416079,
0.0283797737,
-0.0045684362,
-0.009287335,
-0.0132527705,
0.0314499587,
0.0642207786,
-0.0247232467,
0.0148802912,
0.0452365316,
-0.0257742405,
0.0655752122,
0.0000021079,
-0.0745367706,
-0.008902628,
0.0016165958,
0.025643263,
0.0426353961,
0.0704947785,
-0.0254310258,
-0.0373332463,
0.0226617381,
-0.0517774373,
0.0079564862,
0.0482767858,
0.0375897214,
0.0650278777,
0.0814616159,
0.0037381372,
0.0011739942,
0.0061086607,
-0.0142669389,
-0.0079944702,
-0.0736544877,
0.0190616138,
0.0201322306,
-0.0438631736,
-0.0050427169,
-0.0198734701,
0.0247302689,
0.0252353922,
-0.0101931533,
-0.0496087149,
-0.0275417343,
-0.0351727866,
-0.0188594293,
-0.0180250444,
0.0804539621,
-0.0057567987,
-0.0253147706,
-0.0096342387,
-0.0183495134,
0.0093521141,
-0.0348954014,
0.0056823655,
0.0068429084,
-0.0078356965,
0.0071044029,
0.0190489348,
0.0192529541,
0.0369497873,
0.0349700637,
0.0286813043,
0.0226009712,
0.0109887188,
-0.0417593643,
-0.0023844133,
-0.0235862751,
-0.002677561,
-0.0631736889,
-0.0019641593,
0.0076953606,
-0.0425041988,
0.0173648633,
-0.0569068827,
0.0028944949,
0.0621238202,
-0.0807770714,
0.0327265449,
0.0435334072,
-0.0123670474,
0.0244115423,
0.0175172072,
0.0428696685,
-0.0062761558,
0.0410414524,
-0.0455893129,
0.0228062812,
0.0195892751,
-0.0087422356,
0.0040935497,
-0.0087274658,
-0.0050838394,
0.0295654349,
-0.0523199327,
0.0030999377,
-0.0595326871,
0.0349675529,
-0.0200529061,
-0.0078203883,
-0.0152614936,
-0.0051969877,
-0.0078996774,
0.0029351567,
-0.0665629655,
0.0038983373,
-0.0107111176,
-0.0441304743,
0.0083969915,
0.0138953179,
-0.0447244458,
-0.0225183927,
0.0038402171,
0.1036461368,
0.0114186658,
0.0030534654,
-0.0200606287,
-0.0101707969,
-0.0492176861,
-0.0678491518,
-0.016082665,
-0.0505399182,
-0.007668647,
-0.0363352634,
-0.0218960904,
-0.065140903,
0.0278939456,
0.0065798904,
-0.0066439263,
0.0396605991,
0.0341564007,
-0.0017993037,
-0.0146044837,
0.0385798439,
-0.0281567778,
0.0691925958,
0.0350051709,
0.0435909107,
0.0663900003,
-0.0341113545,
0.0019165074,
0.0438334271,
0.0125386436,
0.0348876677,
-0.0558539107,
0.014810713,
0.0268914998,
0.0353121497,
-0.0038150914,
0.0705563501,
-0.0020165148,
-0.0374093913,
0.0872162506,
0.0193028729,
-0.0496861376,
-0.0002819215,
-0.0107427351,
-0.0039758147,
-0.0001940896,
0.0228590183,
-0.07679151,
0.0134726921,
-0.0737241283,
-0.0039722919,
0.0024218995,
0.0454450622,
-0.0251031499,
-0.0534362309,
-0.0288362075,
0.0029568432,
0.064895533,
0.0113691911,
0.0010396602,
0.0014203544,
-0.0207960699,
-0.0416178331,
0.017224187,
-0.0757732689,
-0.0259465445,
-0.0188670307,
0.0127854627,
0.0965591893,
0.0516427942,
0.0025414806,
0.0144472653,
-0.0118544493,
-0.0028223814,
0.0434747115,
0.0504098125,
-0.0096714497,
-0.0005359167,
-0.0470798649,
-0.0214876551,
-0.0094196917,
0.0053466754,
0.0164394435,
0.0166275445,
0.001198625,
-0.0074528251,
-0.0230980124,
-0.0754313543,
0.0354409702,
-0.031823393,
-0.0189415049,
-0.0412080474,
0.0285277404,
0.0259786062,
0.0127858669,
-0.0282546729,
-0.00115551,
0.0150508229,
-0.0195063334,
-0.0031296459,
0.0210542344,
-0.0464814603,
0.015945388,
0.0685470402,
-0.0594426282,
-0.0415693782,
0.062644735,
-0.0493889712,
0.0203382727,
-0.0091348644,
0.0110284714,
-0.0298774391,
-0.0485977754,
0.0364923105,
-0.0499256551,
0.0156415012,
-0.0317950137,
0.0433531702,
-0.0313219465,
0.0153510058,
-0.0281156898,
-0.0116421822,
0.0225169044,
-0.0179387387,
-0.0794118419,
0.003064665,
-0.0256696958,
0.0690705553,
0.0258827265,
0.0390056558,
-0.0149955014,
-0.0262888167,
-0.0575873032,
-0.0037261287,
-0.020963883,
-0.0014665059,
0.0362310968,
-0.0081257513,
-0.0099874269,
0.0176568199,
-0.053038083,
-0.0189095158,
0.0132953189,
0.0233344436,
0.0227818172,
-0.0315278545,
-0.0395918041,
-0.0346891917,
0.0086699715,
-0.0258949343,
0.0056031691,
-0.020727586,
0.0021654195,
-0.0103591038,
0.008468614,
-0.0307908393,
0.0142989838,
-0.0170726366,
-0.0924095362,
0.0246296674,
0.0535874255,
-0.0006397394,
0.0747426897,
0.0563913472,
0.0381330438,
0.0613081791,
0.0212290939,
-0.0558540896,
-0.0085184667,
0.0122061763,
-0.0333346017,
-0.0269533582,
-0.0713625476,
-0.0065974998,
0.0601013601,
0.0289395638,
0.0090487693,
-0.0700326636,
0.0372059457,
-0.0204082467,
-0.0732362419,
-0.0103892675,
-0.0273971632,
-0.0484687053,
0.0125003858,
-0.0353886262,
-0.0591583699,
0.0884666443,
-0.0168891158,
0.0245381352,
-0.0016434238,
0.0064885891,
-0.0050202762,
0.0683043897,
-0.0265379231,
0.0452284664,
0.0188511703,
-0.0051032477,
-0.0514810272,
-0.0189697016,
0.0514788628,
-0.0594974458,
0.0469470359,
-0.0210614055,
-0.0073571117,
-0.0163158961,
-0.0392656662,
-0.0581993386,
-0.0620806217,
-0.0074168369,
0.009833565,
0.0106456634,
-0.0027001977,
0.0058458927,
0.0104791503,
0.0064552948,
-0.0147223193,
-0.0190260764,
0.0289644115,
-0.0180159993,
-0.0527389906,
0.0421973206,
-0.0324639641,
0.0328621194,
-0.0198285822,
0.0602662154,
0.0827397034,
0.0020021528,
0.0297456831,
0.0122481408,
0.0048345788,
0.0270972624,
0.001974683,
0.0191973131,
0.0252486859,
0.0593063943,
-0.0283740945,
0.0223382525,
0.0703359097,
0.0078485114,
0.015328289,
0.0378034189,
-0.023979798,
0.0412199982,
0.014061885,
-0.0057063648,
-0.1138770208,
-0.0012853816,
0.0055336272,
0.0483561903,
-0.0359579064,
-0.0322456993,
0.0144587234,
-0.1098109856,
0.00630019,
0.0422154628,
-0.0274278875,
-0.0158618111,
0.0053917412,
-0.0036851151,
-0.004593574,
0.0752913132,
-0.0006423898,
0.0171214901,
-0.0530394204,
-0.0001070075,
0.0026105081,
-0.0245146118,
0.0453922227,
-0.0507773198,
0.0552617423,
0.0796479806,
0.037546806,
-0.0133604528,
-0.0396603607,
-0.0124197342,
0.0335354097,
-0.0279019829,
0.0225461181,
0.0185290463,
-0.0103620365,
-0.0115543539,
-0.0267380774,
0.0127190705,
0.0175071806,
-0.0103626801,
0.047547292,
0.0297530945,
0.0079093417,
-0.0355093442,
-0.0250791572,
0.025469007,
0.0245202351,
0.0985081345,
0.0182853118,
-0.0560426265,
0.0006436708,
-0.0645310134,
-0.0384656861,
-0.0531768389,
-0.0827016309,
0.0404081233,
-0.0017860924,
-0.0241605081,
-0.0855446011,
-0.0498244539,
-0.0430880673,
0.0245650336,
0.0409535654,
-0.0393544622,
-0.0407804772,
0.0083586294,
-0.0087645585,
-0.0204326771,
-0.0148711326,
0.0455950238,
-0.0377911292,
0.0329150036,
-0.0211927053,
-0.0339557678,
0.014171523,
0.0224996004,
-0.0255911946,
-0.0882969499,
0.0381481387,
0.058379408,
0.0205715131,
0.0197292939,
-0.0242554378,
-0.0025387113,
0.019332258,
0.0418078415,
-0.0050994223,
0.0335976593,
0.0545797274,
-0.0296979621,
0.0146031454,
0.015711816,
-0.0398998149,
0.0033504085,
0.0368192941,
0.0525974482,
-0.0304612927,
-0.041377753,
0.0360040031,
0.0501657575,
0.0007082432,
-0.0288238227,
-0.0301775746,
-0.0087844525,
0.0008516278,
-0.0220175553,
-0.0669649765,
-0.019193368,
-0.0205006599,
0.0394599512,
0.0112738302,
0.0042084865,
0.0235129315,
-0.0146651957,
0.0190325063,
-0.0373570584,
0.0043596905,
-0.0007141104,
0.0938032418,
-0.0031798012,
0.0146903116,
-0.0486332551,
0.0421172865,
-0.0044254796,
0.0411381796,
0.010275322,
0.0487017222,
0.027101405,
0.0223268624,
-0.0004235681,
0.0373320095,
-0.0440930463,
-0.037417952,
-0.0304603539,
-0.0173377302,
0.0316370912,
0.0193586051,
0.043699339,
-0.0188098494,
-0.0002213256,
-0.0436613709,
0.007493733,
-0.0003385156,
-0.0724798366,
0.0194614306,
0.0181080606,
-0.0226016715,
-0.0141249606,
0.0340886228,
-0.0237785336,
0.0427839421,
0.0340487547,
-0.0000337547,
-0.0160520934,
-0.0447541177,
0.0564657897,
-0.0079702791,
-0.0304650478,
-0.0469054617,
-0.108664684,
-0.0639467016,
-0.021398209,
0.0387152955,
-0.0008648232,
-0.017258808,
-0.0095520001,
0.0418434255,
0.0001864486,
0.0296607837,
-0.0338822231,
-0.0149740903,
-0.0205984171,
-0.0140407449,
-0.0241321698,
-6.443126983e-33,
-0.0240740012,
-0.0327633508,
-0.0203832798,
-0.0342433974,
-0.0148443794,
-0.0275848545,
-0.0203893613,
0.0294922553,
-0.0665717274,
0.0019648264,
0.0025388,
-0.0138712171,
0.005839007,
-0.0185023732,
-0.005450401,
-0.0416375436,
0.0154483505,
-0.0041902345,
-0.0346077532,
-0.0174157787,
0.0472760797,
-0.016718125,
0.057137832,
-0.0804891288,
0.0718673617,
0.0019831059,
-0.0614914708,
0.0243510734,
-0.0211012028,
0.0566276796,
0.0223021489,
0.0609999448,
0.0003777862,
0.0059615839,
0.0016843927,
0.0129953958,
-0.0243449304,
-0.0184528455,
0.0588237047,
0.0026107312,
0.0029844516,
-0.0412692912,
0.0174616855,
-0.0339889601,
-0.0221919641,
-0.0284712128,
0.0126368729,
-0.0192819312,
-0.0107145496,
-0.0065278392,
-0.0781772733,
0.0123378923,
-0.0355299041,
-0.0064087552,
-0.0312383808,
0.0317502841,
0.0106709823,
0.0159392618,
-0.0657020733,
0.0106034726,
0.0088938586,
0.0095202653,
0.0616620444,
0.0079106027,
0.0274108425,
0.0873197615,
-0.0015893971,
0.0341036357,
-0.010677278,
-0.0058765849,
0.0515148118,
0.0522117503,
0.048736345,
0.1087869331,
0.002057394,
-0.0446738303,
-0.0636225939,
0.0313723199,
0.0307079479,
0.0146790445,
0.005941961,
0.017299071,
-0.0883746371,
-0.0249149837,
-0.0151586235,
-0.0346939191,
-0.0212996025,
-0.0480707735,
0.035656184,
-0.0239426605,
-0.0381280594,
-0.0615141168,
0.0301781949,
-0.0516538136,
0.0114914831,
0.0498451218,
0.0101133315,
-0.0126314694,
0.0031961824,
0.0413584448,
-0.0344238952,
-0.0140905827,
-0.002675517,
-0.0175252669,
0.0320933647,
0.0181831103,
0.0444007963,
0.0127771357,
-0.039995674,
0.0131420996,
0.0000110581,
0.0137899993,
0.0041638841,
-0.0013432695,
0.0376877747,
-0.0228885747,
-0.0091954404,
0.0018179014,
0.0493060164,
-0.0012891048,
-0.077953957,
0.0251362231,
-0.0252539143,
0.0270654652,
-0.0070322999,
0.0131782303,
-0.0245775022,
0.0011873121,
0.0676791668,
-0.050255172,
-0.0188197941,
-0.0006303662,
2.79e-7,
0.0092165153,
-0.0094216764,
0.0398408137,
0.0466751046,
-0.0150082391,
0.0905511156,
-0.0190734733,
0.062116757,
0.0091346418,
-0.0165174939,
0.020779049,
0.0172609109,
0.0898506716,
0.0603668876,
-0.0437110104,
0.0376484022,
-0.0765029117,
0.0006968805,
-0.0081664054,
0.0180163756,
0.0131666176,
0.0605879724,
0.0102522206,
0.0139320893,
0.0204234291,
-0.0183385368,
0.0256191157,
-0.0413061008,
-0.0119729964,
0.0289712697,
0.000717012,
-0.0219946802,
0.0122795887,
-0.0221136324,
0.0208166726,
0.0238625146,
0.007115915,
0.0868874416,
-0.0037489256,
-0.0413592346,
-0.0307853576,
-0.0404153988,
-0.0104675237,
-0.0593046695,
0.039508,
0.0218517892,
-0.0297798049,
-0.0203422271,
-0.004770733,
-0.0114566507,
0.0326978751,
-0.0061081704,
-0.0256849006,
0.0177291017,
0.0260120016,
0.0231543202,
0.0090619018,
-0.0142554175,
-0.0497279055,
-0.0291412603,
0.0099243689,
-0.0831529275,
0.0150767146,
0.0580220744,
-0.0197069272,
-0.0288783237,
0.005188942,
2.557981089e-34,
0.008267181,
-0.0484422892,
0.0287230238,
-0.0067141927,
0.0510795787,
0.0326845013,
0.0086884731,
0.0019797746,
0.0188307371,
-0.0289211627,
-0.0269601662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06898v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06898v1 | Retrieval and Generative Approaches for a Pregnancy Chatbot in Nepali with Stemmed and Non-Stemmed Data : A Comparative Study | 2023-11-12T17:16:46 | 2023-11-12T17:16:46 | Sujan Poudel, Nabin Ghimire, Bipesh Subedi, Saugat Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The field of Natural Language Processing which involves the use of artificial
intelligence to support human languages has seen tremendous growth due to its
high-quality features. Its applications such as language translation, chatbots,
virtual assistants, search autocomplete, and autocorrect are widely used in
various domains including healthcare, advertising, customer service, and target
advertising. To provide pregnancy-related information a health domain chatbot
has been proposed and this work explores two different NLP-based approaches for
developing the chatbot. The first approach is a multiclass classification-based
retrieval approach using BERTbased multilingual BERT and multilingual
DistilBERT while the other approach employs a transformer-based generative
chatbot for pregnancy-related information. The performance of both stemmed and
non-stemmed datasets in Nepali language has been analyzed for each approach.
The experimented results indicate that BERT-based pre-trained models perform
well on non-stemmed data whereas scratch transformer models have better
performance on stemmed data. Among the models tested the DistilBERT model
achieved the highest training and validation accuracy and testing accuracy of
0.9165 on the retrieval-based model architecture implementation on the
non-stemmed dataset. Similarly, in the generative approach architecture
implementation with transformer 1 gram BLEU and 2 gram BLEU scores of 0.3570
and 0.1413 respectively were achieved. | [
0.0879669785,
0.0174558032,
-0.0472554937,
-0.0258111339,
-0.0279332437,
0.0117185498,
0.0019146204,
0.036077939,
0.0637667999,
-0.0355569385,
0.0237540845,
-0.0695413351,
-0.0194958039,
0.0161706023,
-0.0386257172,
-0.0846357644,
0.0147151873,
0.0395199955,
0.0348761491,
0.0069410689,
-0.000822755,
0.0107404161,
-0.0297982395,
0.0755745322,
-0.071963802,
0.004885884,
-0.0020233432,
0.0094103096,
0.0044810665,
-0.058121331,
0.0323665701,
0.0550833866,
-0.0040317993,
0.0358876251,
0.0000019872,
-0.0352665111,
-0.0530569516,
0.0351793692,
-0.0374742448,
-0.1111067086,
0.050396245,
-0.0010586965,
-0.0250789709,
0.0497785509,
-0.0178394653,
0.037617553,
0.074213177,
0.0692640021,
0.0461692326,
0.0879406109,
-0.0169637557,
-0.0788923129,
0.0075676357,
0.0322731845,
0.0227098092,
-0.0151575208,
0.0053239511,
0.0142020937,
0.0637831613,
0.0020936776,
-0.0097995298,
0.0128628742,
-0.0146423224,
-0.0198471174,
-0.0160326045,
0.0067975959,
-0.0460409485,
-0.0777888447,
-0.0009795886,
0.0421932004,
-0.0094920229,
-0.0091102151,
-0.0001630896,
0.0217579659,
0.003080429,
0.0043240585,
-0.0409418382,
0.0048845704,
-0.0392568931,
0.0055268826,
0.003467788,
-0.0011519361,
-0.0366400704,
-0.0120960549,
0.0175677836,
-0.021272609,
0.0343479402,
-0.0579554997,
-0.0257442109,
-0.0085065681,
0.0187465027,
0.0184687842,
0.0414836928,
0.0212649256,
-0.0047444482,
0.0306520611,
-0.0064555993,
-0.0674198046,
0.039838437,
-0.088118583,
-0.0293943826,
0.0422798172,
-0.0326934345,
-0.0035856906,
0.0012380688,
0.0392631851,
0.0383714363,
0.0161771551,
-0.0466422029,
0.0134870615,
-0.0816775709,
-0.037866123,
-0.0660112575,
0.0453924425,
-0.0053409357,
0.014741974,
-0.0985004976,
0.0230827034,
0.0052029989,
-0.0649676472,
0.0212322623,
0.0216389857,
-0.032609269,
0.0396494232,
-0.0316249579,
-0.0088512907,
0.0056184102,
-0.0140756648,
0.008357035,
-0.0735053644,
0.0276047494,
-0.0057993112,
0.0041732569,
0.006660712,
0.009804477,
0.0633565933,
0.0059010573,
-0.0636874735,
-0.0032888998,
0.0223011989,
-0.0148189729,
-0.0500977151,
0.0095346402,
-0.0300595108,
0.0393789746,
0.0362812579,
-0.0297837257,
-0.0368247814,
0.0502135865,
0.0337249413,
-0.0179377254,
0.0231897887,
-0.0162771773,
0.0138668772,
0.0569005981,
0.0236552339,
0.0259871762,
0.0682147592,
0.016446121,
0.0002697133,
0.0291964188,
-0.0350169912,
0.0149975037,
0.010701973,
-0.0074238279,
-0.0646425039,
0.0198374037,
0.0142514789,
-0.0254099686,
0.0165505633,
-0.0439891666,
0.0474253967,
-0.0237975232,
0.0464959107,
0.0037626717,
0.0625112355,
0.0424559899,
0.0519806556,
0.02900365,
0.0111909471,
0.0345363617,
0.0282284822,
0.0124841938,
-0.0243255123,
-0.047682561,
-0.0352735445,
-0.0154303238,
0.0206010658,
-0.0384591036,
-0.0378464274,
-0.0449125357,
-0.0495809168,
0.0250854008,
-0.0361118466,
0.0549543463,
0.0321297534,
-0.0310408827,
0.0639840886,
0.0664708614,
-0.0606902651,
-0.0694238022,
-0.0694526508,
-0.0293050203,
0.0651422516,
0.0248403717,
-0.0485427305,
-0.0598729923,
-0.0174788665,
-0.0847747698,
0.0324274711,
-0.0004587564,
0.0117485691,
-0.0252173003,
-0.018364789,
0.0031384071,
0.0667214915,
0.0045335582,
0.0050383979,
-0.009938932,
0.0293473881,
0.0079110516,
0.0303344131,
0.0014701141,
0.0364053287,
-0.0246568844,
0.0021638658,
-0.0060815108,
0.0109774899,
0.0555695556,
0.0330824256,
-0.0079881288,
0.0042567509,
0.041720774,
-0.0188245196,
-0.0329096206,
0.0378673375,
0.0132305892,
-0.0778893083,
-0.0122058438,
-0.0199422017,
-0.0127732605,
0.0060557812,
0.012490714,
-0.0330246054,
-0.0171600692,
-0.0788219497,
0.0476133302,
-0.0517976657,
0.0715530366,
-0.0146914665,
0.0240020305,
-0.0358151011,
0.0269933101,
0.0123124653,
0.0255759787,
-0.0174252167,
-0.0317387693,
0.0117931245,
-0.0316977389,
-0.0252090003,
0.0278012455,
-0.006988463,
0.0264038108,
0.0442288443,
0.0406560749,
-0.034792807,
-0.0637212247,
-0.1050335169,
-0.0348851234,
0.0195871871,
-0.0002053909,
-0.0150747923,
0.0329289399,
0.0004139324,
-0.0367192961,
-0.034795858,
0.0375047028,
0.0234785415,
0.000192678,
0.0251743272,
-0.0003794331,
-0.0251276772,
-0.0075587626,
0.021608457,
-0.0156239765,
0.0230648499,
0.0320387036,
-0.0201409087,
-0.0035990872,
-0.0157415308,
-0.0298996586,
0.0302060321,
0.0176431853,
-0.0483341999,
0.0138836736,
-0.012599186,
0.0766222849,
0.0123926466,
0.0328517817,
0.019146204,
-0.0383904576,
0.026197277,
-0.0388439707,
0.0142424684,
-0.029502023,
0.0076242695,
0.0304696336,
0.0105547942,
-0.0134010687,
0.0413126834,
-0.0266431104,
-0.0283608977,
-0.0232672878,
-0.01907124,
0.0030106318,
0.0020431075,
-0.0110548111,
0.0226045325,
-0.0323668495,
0.0402310304,
0.0337805264,
-0.0340726674,
0.0602131449,
-0.0197850801,
0.0044552167,
-0.0751167834,
-0.0274452623,
-0.0000632057,
0.024872236,
0.0127736991,
0.0278131571,
-0.0111802034,
-0.0319638737,
-0.0280137807,
0.0445885025,
-0.0106639359,
-0.0848237649,
-0.0319641456,
0.0031705347,
0.0001514364,
-0.0191388521,
-0.0658103302,
-0.0812534466,
-0.0393882468,
0.0194303896,
0.0101905735,
0.0529183857,
0.0391429067,
-0.0526514202,
0.0571210235,
-0.0459904186,
0.0021057252,
0.0261097103,
0.0019232107,
0.0229959749,
0.0073652021,
-0.0028913957,
0.0058378484,
-0.023767719,
0.0151140941,
0.0104213636,
-0.0072230762,
-0.0306107774,
0.016571017,
0.0034240645,
-0.0255475007,
0.0435832664,
-0.0273896847,
-0.0413788557,
0.0013414538,
-0.0167925283,
-0.0507864133,
0.0004002131,
0.0655756295,
0.0255954172,
0.0165098552,
-0.0140885646,
-0.0464752056,
-0.0621260069,
-0.0263388474,
0.0734367073,
-0.0813331157,
0.0160804521,
0.0207972731,
-0.023424767,
-0.0345787741,
0.0096497787,
0.0212356336,
-0.0712606311,
0.0153445285,
-0.0176287685,
-0.0313624851,
-0.056272123,
-0.0484584384,
-0.0388845392,
0.0155490218,
0.0098459106,
0.0158907324,
-0.0100942301,
-0.0321755856,
0.0034003288,
-0.035463918,
-0.0670697838,
0.0130981356,
-0.0228909496,
0.0179663803,
0.0833433345,
0.0693724826,
-0.004773878,
-0.0263100751,
-0.0127266105,
0.0384402275,
-0.0109060705,
-0.0066552497,
0.0358995833,
0.0010281403,
-0.0031804317,
-0.0525588281,
-0.0156484023,
0.0352365412,
0.0053658732,
-0.0255554542,
0.0315208808,
-0.0264850818,
-0.0019019467,
-0.0642855763,
0.0408700556,
0.0341059975,
0.0261859912,
-0.0300206393,
-0.0571270883,
-0.0348700993,
-0.0104951682,
0.0374673419,
0.0344537869,
-0.0339712761,
0.0392137617,
-0.0975533798,
-0.058343295,
-0.0779125467,
-0.0280927923,
-0.0064145443,
0.0527024232,
0.027577538,
0.0130095575,
0.0620761402,
0.0588935092,
-0.0054217055,
0.0012413083,
0.0456257835,
-0.0354093425,
-0.0720072389,
-0.0461301878,
0.0250989404,
-0.0402017571,
-0.0104836458,
-0.03179463,
0.0270039327,
0.0028487702,
0.0237776265,
0.0376856662,
0.0151602589,
-0.0181575511,
-0.0286157131,
-0.0147603191,
0.0192984119,
0.0896036327,
-0.0250870194,
-0.0627726242,
0.0297959838,
0.0597355254,
-0.0085858284,
0.0082943207,
-0.0099389907,
0.0477533191,
-0.0073486301,
-0.0023630778,
0.0111853573,
-0.0287616141,
0.02144913,
0.0699059889,
0.0453987457,
-0.0286231972,
-0.0132674342,
-0.015714433,
0.0337364376,
-0.0281464737,
-0.0102939848,
-0.0235880762,
-0.0039760168,
0.0151775777,
-0.0078039221,
0.0069803041,
-0.0076401066,
-0.0702691302,
-0.0121942544,
-0.0314176455,
0.0572227761,
0.0253680591,
0.0532204993,
-0.0223704726,
0.001217392,
0.0215694681,
-0.0187238976,
0.0341526009,
0.0133532258,
-0.034946166,
0.0756280795,
-0.0348831452,
0.0028585761,
0.0263498705,
0.0514654331,
0.0109963492,
0.0081339097,
-0.0411114469,
0.0439610779,
0.0366084352,
-0.0013380217,
0.0087856129,
-0.0085542304,
-0.0013755502,
-0.0152575541,
0.0039975294,
-0.0093816593,
-0.003883091,
0.0180294383,
-0.0312677696,
-0.0208205078,
-0.0491098426,
0.0484253205,
-0.0098876925,
0.0118132364,
0.001697999,
-0.0517285764,
-0.0457581244,
-0.022809945,
0.0477772057,
-0.0266199205,
-0.0061954949,
0.0183986146,
-0.0457599089,
-0.021794552,
-0.0089652343,
-0.0287481006,
0.009955206,
0.011753994,
0.0582570657,
0.0496831909,
-0.0070759212,
-0.0252676085,
-0.0472295843,
-0.0135872103,
-0.0106295543,
0.0365094617,
0.0467463061,
-5.952758861e-33,
-0.044173751,
0.0070255371,
0.0239478666,
-0.0222348664,
-0.0037771976,
-0.0010862367,
0.0221225303,
0.0188106671,
0.0023782677,
0.0081471885,
-0.0448382162,
-0.0198656283,
0.0151388505,
0.0243509375,
0.0166252647,
0.0148097929,
0.0262049902,
0.0055297394,
-0.0041781641,
0.0018307926,
0.0409536511,
0.0831404701,
0.0404410809,
-0.0552867651,
-0.0018897898,
-0.0546052679,
0.0129551422,
0.003435672,
0.0433540866,
0.0197417401,
-0.0167639181,
0.0343242548,
0.0154965771,
-0.0083008707,
-0.0081855254,
0.0279075876,
-0.0739459619,
-0.0166599844,
-0.0093383091,
0.0414415896,
-0.0151952952,
-0.0189286415,
0.0462563597,
-0.0442868583,
-0.0237003267,
0.0372446403,
0.0249488,
-0.04234346,
0.0219328403,
-0.027403079,
-0.0693558306,
0.0098301955,
-0.024271911,
-0.0422728062,
0.018778434,
0.0471927673,
-0.0264304969,
-0.0097894268,
-0.0438330881,
0.0120059773,
0.0088189403,
0.0017229146,
-0.0116470261,
-0.0168992113,
0.0314506218,
0.0193731338,
0.026119912,
0.0048910002,
-0.0343731269,
-0.0422179587,
0.0095188022,
0.0715551302,
0.0206725802,
0.0115849823,
0.0743389204,
-0.0804232359,
-0.0684272274,
0.0623257011,
0.0270669498,
0.0314866006,
0.0104947137,
0.0018068312,
-0.0719551817,
0.0185217429,
0.027431421,
-0.0047123171,
0.0093799829,
-0.0615484416,
0.001122864,
0.0081415167,
0.0102534248,
-0.03340175,
0.0128633473,
-0.0548833273,
0.0205253996,
-0.0260679629,
-0.0010960649,
-0.0170088466,
-0.0162916742,
0.0160208363,
-0.0018780325,
-0.0975941345,
0.0454748943,
0.0117879007,
0.0220320486,
0.0118214535,
0.0088794883,
-0.0198793802,
-0.0655170307,
0.0157329589,
-0.0100029958,
0.0247225072,
0.0314082764,
0.032862477,
-0.004976891,
0.0135036046,
-0.0035084523,
0.0268537942,
0.0428522117,
0.0626911372,
-0.0282052942,
0.0225792099,
0.0206274781,
-0.0266669448,
-0.0351978615,
0.0066649592,
-0.0311607365,
0.0668336451,
-0.0097810896,
-0.0778370798,
0.0037877453,
0.0021435858,
2.862e-7,
0.0655618161,
0.0752553344,
-0.0053425585,
-0.0119044967,
0.0166278984,
-0.0101064621,
0.0094635375,
0.0019441725,
0.0148765817,
0.0617062859,
0.009791973,
-0.0163663421,
0.0129562002,
0.0276469495,
-0.1177543253,
-0.0254556816,
-0.0679420978,
-0.0399671346,
-0.0001490859,
0.0146426903,
0.0598415099,
0.0886382461,
-0.0184818674,
-0.0359587073,
-0.0025861629,
0.0106372377,
0.0453133136,
-0.0071870261,
0.0197889768,
0.0363844484,
0.0038550764,
0.0703460053,
0.0475234874,
0.0022274952,
0.0015269049,
0.0377373993,
0.0343202464,
0.0383502804,
-0.0274743792,
0.0191075318,
0.0985651612,
0.031350974,
-0.0142897712,
-0.0255398508,
0.0506532118,
-0.0369978026,
-0.0402035043,
0.0065380754,
-0.004451415,
-0.0311213192,
0.0612303093,
-0.0286413487,
-0.0064027612,
0.046243567,
0.006485906,
-0.0312257521,
0.0017774019,
-0.0259446409,
-0.0178011209,
0.029302204,
-0.0233268272,
-0.0496715084,
0.0303668994,
-0.030819498,
0.0151733207,
-0.0181552265,
0.0272869617,
2.438219336e-34,
0.0390434675,
0.0018383797,
-0.0001668978,
0.0474112555,
0.0249604098,
-0.0088530444,
0.0763701349,
0.0218174141,
-0.002629166,
-0.0354963504,
-0.0027827362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06858v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06858v1 | Can Large Language Models Augment a Biomedical Ontology with missing Concepts and Relations? | 2023-11-12T14:20:55 | 2023-11-12T14:20:55 | Antonio Zaitoun, Tomer Sagi, Szymon Wilk, Mor Peleg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Ontologies play a crucial role in organizing and representing knowledge.
However, even current ontologies do not encompass all relevant concepts and
relationships. Here, we explore the potential of large language models (LLM) to
expand an existing ontology in a semi-automated fashion. We demonstrate our
approach on the biomedical ontology SNOMED-CT utilizing semantic relation types
from the widely used UMLS semantic network. We propose a method that uses
conversational interactions with an LLM to analyze clinical practice guidelines
(CPGs) and detect the relationships among the new medical concepts that are not
present in SNOMED-CT. Our initial experimentation with the conversational
prompts yielded promising preliminary results given a manually generated gold
standard, directing our future potential improvements. | [
0.0341646746,
0.0664472207,
0.0129101779,
0.0063846014,
0.0000974704,
-0.0069335257,
-0.0046121841,
0.0668898597,
-0.0217904244,
-0.0123335449,
-0.0096198991,
-0.0171967074,
0.0036711979,
0.0221897569,
-0.0384460688,
-0.0353997499,
0.0122406995,
0.0324432142,
0.0025106929,
0.0062588775,
-0.0172503553,
0.0410175696,
-0.0213029329,
0.027680343,
0.0079586636,
-0.0167982858,
-0.0016704679,
-0.0233039055,
-0.0122362841,
-0.067287758,
-0.0426177159,
0.0504479595,
-0.0065527782,
0.003629175,
0.0000019705,
-0.081086725,
-0.0314959027,
0.0371880792,
-0.03628508,
-0.047011286,
0.0724591911,
-0.0117467521,
0.0113037908,
-0.0153171616,
-0.0130016785,
-0.0137903988,
0.0473174602,
0.0410589501,
-0.0026784665,
0.03290217,
-0.0108653316,
-0.0044054561,
0.0352232642,
0.0020089992,
0.022532301,
-0.0257904269,
0.0612798221,
0.0545794368,
0.0470525995,
0.0262704827,
0.0291242059,
0.0266719051,
-0.0469185412,
-0.0250605829,
0.0213408861,
0.018529918,
-0.0084475074,
-0.0100831985,
0.0265312381,
0.0358981527,
0.0411896855,
0.0160101149,
0.0306309704,
0.0040430757,
-0.0179058351,
0.0466700867,
-0.0264503956,
-0.0065886891,
-0.0213335268,
-0.0181143116,
0.0147111379,
-0.0031071757,
0.039949961,
0.0241278317,
-0.0126730055,
0.0534243695,
0.0024416286,
0.0081637353,
0.0082177334,
-0.0403030813,
0.0047925296,
-0.0438495837,
0.0025787023,
0.0337251462,
-0.0638916045,
0.0319872089,
0.0223362334,
0.0169758908,
0.0926773101,
-0.0446778759,
0.006963626,
-0.0176907554,
-0.0029569163,
0.0390506983,
0.0231700428,
-0.0335776657,
-0.0048583196,
0.0091866311,
-0.0431108512,
0.0160778016,
-0.075164713,
-0.0113579351,
-0.026962433,
0.0332177021,
-0.0029450415,
-0.0235701334,
-0.0863336399,
0.014656161,
-0.0189871434,
0.0122170849,
0.0398839675,
0.0264844913,
0.0167815872,
-0.0113221891,
-0.0568281487,
-0.0205473676,
0.0580926351,
0.0081513533,
-0.0245910343,
-0.0419751815,
0.0521321073,
-0.0097096246,
0.0291213356,
0.0190459341,
-0.0006447662,
0.0770863369,
0.0430324785,
-0.0190871246,
-0.0021847819,
-0.0763774365,
-0.0404186957,
0.0162573028,
-0.0030979516,
-0.0853538662,
0.0097284792,
0.0058417064,
0.0151499398,
-0.0504180826,
0.0304327887,
0.0227330476,
-0.0765387192,
0.0619191341,
-0.0790383816,
-0.0014498287,
-0.0109757381,
0.0365763456,
0.0219886433,
-0.0163368899,
-0.0148870284,
-0.0629809722,
0.0433507226,
0.0083631473,
-0.0510489494,
-0.0212903377,
0.0136742881,
-0.024979163,
-0.0273149498,
0.0067623369,
0.0126878507,
0.0919780061,
-0.0458850786,
0.0388839394,
0.006819732,
-0.0320600308,
0.0082603125,
0.0361932255,
0.0413617268,
0.0588029474,
0.032837633,
-0.0270284601,
0.011658268,
-0.0486103892,
-0.0126926498,
-0.0107330866,
-0.0153420754,
0.0064110425,
-0.0294243451,
-0.011367986,
-0.020843951,
-0.0357484743,
-0.0462370068,
-0.0191025324,
-0.0401509963,
-0.024975786,
0.0444637686,
0.004095125,
0.0140351066,
0.0735749304,
0.0603376813,
-0.0104088904,
-0.0045594443,
-0.0327985734,
0.0027946194,
0.0865652785,
0.074616909,
-0.0578248054,
-0.0505502895,
-0.008011424,
-0.0102657732,
0.0276202336,
0.0182115585,
-0.038646102,
-0.0184433572,
-0.020085834,
0.0229850896,
0.0495840758,
0.024492031,
-0.0049482952,
0.0050998125,
0.0205882993,
-0.0254926514,
-0.0417334698,
-0.0041260351,
0.0160531607,
-0.0337008871,
0.0214737933,
-0.0037088881,
-0.0264792852,
0.0253841169,
0.0700530559,
0.0053246841,
0.0527574271,
0.0386196822,
-0.0254055467,
-0.0717648938,
-0.0124182831,
-0.0637799501,
0.0099782636,
0.0368519835,
0.0044720541,
-0.0018169603,
-0.0494414903,
-0.0008924993,
-0.0107155219,
-0.0212942027,
0.0089646606,
0.0623741485,
-0.0060178014,
0.0155994892,
0.0563121438,
-0.0152457915,
-0.0398758911,
0.0159788188,
-0.0133560393,
0.0149081554,
0.0374259688,
-0.078901805,
0.0063237725,
-0.0164591316,
0.014366325,
0.0111992219,
-0.0178607386,
0.0114917075,
0.0011579476,
0.0283886343,
-0.0214644726,
0.0082698027,
-0.0961259753,
-0.0160342734,
0.0358833671,
0.029248964,
0.0360096917,
0.0188510288,
0.0141139906,
-0.0098581938,
-0.0513820909,
0.0174848568,
0.0183123611,
0.0096303495,
0.0504251905,
0.0324387215,
-0.0199411511,
-0.0129717337,
-0.0227255616,
-0.029438816,
0.0477225333,
-0.011441458,
0.002964111,
0.0267154742,
0.0264471173,
-0.0883469582,
0.0109983394,
0.0256078951,
-0.0010074364,
0.0058548884,
-0.0256331433,
-0.0462209806,
-0.0026149231,
-0.0075108884,
0.0450282544,
0.0407707803,
-0.0013836243,
-0.0139917927,
-0.0350145884,
-0.0206767451,
-0.0499676056,
-0.0190879814,
-0.0250978153,
0.0053095743,
0.0575665012,
0.0047525414,
-0.0104063628,
-0.0137261283,
0.0082345912,
-0.035836868,
0.0485571064,
-0.079063423,
0.0171296895,
-0.0049321917,
0.0471215993,
0.0297119897,
0.0046421136,
0.0754224807,
-0.0173316989,
0.040226955,
-0.0378596745,
-0.0265140571,
-0.0485522971,
0.038081523,
-0.0218477156,
0.0648768172,
0.0383654125,
-0.0213700533,
-0.0198190585,
-0.042559538,
0.0183190871,
-0.0339866132,
0.0487730689,
-0.0442168228,
0.0271862391,
0.0267963242,
-0.0060885092,
-0.0555404648,
0.0585801899,
-0.0312209707,
0.0485282764,
0.0241115354,
-0.0273995474,
-0.0307265241,
0.0147639345,
-0.0404354781,
0.0568997078,
0.0549191684,
-0.0345600434,
-0.0047125653,
0.0326643027,
0.0192903057,
-0.0313087478,
0.0058843545,
0.0365003869,
0.0670758784,
0.0522753708,
-0.0632513613,
-0.0275475401,
-0.0031535646,
0.0002800778,
-0.0016518008,
-0.0647350773,
0.0082706669,
0.02735628,
-0.0478948019,
-0.0278316028,
0.0031909836,
0.1128804907,
0.067277208,
-0.0356337614,
0.0245429259,
-0.0060336646,
-0.057744734,
-0.0051465114,
0.0030206223,
-0.0843308493,
-0.0100319218,
-0.0500867926,
-0.0140334899,
-0.0312366448,
-0.0515744649,
0.0090269763,
-0.0030757815,
0.0098274304,
0.0027755294,
-0.0767427087,
0.0293744616,
-0.0209632218,
0.0133061735,
-0.0334805325,
-0.0326612704,
-0.0117381262,
-0.0224744603,
-0.0368618555,
-0.0276094507,
-0.0474105738,
-0.0804246962,
0.0628278852,
0.0103718583,
0.0492492765,
0.0136259114,
0.0539112166,
-0.029729275,
-0.0146451313,
0.0472125486,
0.0030825157,
0.0084897736,
-0.0087781614,
0.0550102852,
0.0077631031,
0.0275221746,
-0.0720620975,
0.0251028165,
-0.0408889614,
-0.0317840427,
-0.0425826944,
0.0712639093,
-0.0175794195,
-0.0301314555,
-0.0361162908,
0.0212998334,
0.0136395749,
0.0384629406,
-0.0437223688,
-0.002573373,
0.0547930934,
0.0204641335,
-0.0029724922,
0.0684344023,
-0.0187173635,
0.0242639277,
-0.0488572791,
-0.0371258929,
-0.0444075316,
0.0063148113,
0.0166709889,
-0.0573844612,
0.0069617396,
0.025238473,
0.0504593477,
0.0027937675,
-0.0678557828,
0.0493186936,
0.0013878756,
0.0254035145,
-0.0204379652,
-0.032131847,
0.0751020685,
-0.0089974608,
-0.0198190007,
-0.0197641551,
0.0149732539,
-0.0166589003,
-0.0257678535,
0.0104949633,
0.0204545222,
-0.0207942706,
-0.011701311,
0.0031705673,
0.0299144685,
0.0641305745,
-0.0588411279,
-0.0205234047,
-0.0280526374,
0.0445795953,
-0.0015632369,
0.0386854149,
-0.0087868925,
0.0321138911,
-0.0451152325,
0.0164397676,
-0.0557442158,
-0.0807391927,
0.0611672327,
0.03052596,
0.0234459396,
0.0072095357,
0.0147035308,
-0.0090343598,
0.0168634914,
-0.0467811599,
-0.0055187717,
-0.0208636113,
0.010038781,
-0.0126474593,
-0.0107098296,
-0.0045280331,
-0.0081254775,
-0.0739901364,
-0.0193198863,
0.0142539712,
0.0289898906,
0.0067386273,
-0.0000103354,
0.0526272394,
-0.0250531007,
-0.0002548471,
-0.0076181684,
-0.0683267713,
-0.0135073271,
-0.042935174,
0.0628434196,
0.0038115929,
0.0097854417,
-0.0432269648,
0.0449394584,
-0.0038059002,
-0.0717089027,
-0.0068209516,
0.0445381962,
0.0350015834,
0.0143382438,
0.0057686898,
-0.0689928904,
-0.003282343,
-0.0409875698,
0.0270386543,
-0.0347345993,
-0.0011854857,
0.064151153,
0.0262809973,
0.0100943474,
-0.0384925455,
0.0595892929,
-0.0227710046,
0.023403177,
0.0199470297,
-0.0711379424,
-0.0228662957,
-0.0192411635,
0.0575493164,
0.0385482013,
-0.0694020763,
0.0074673383,
-0.0834052861,
-0.0543340296,
0.0089279786,
0.0103669129,
-0.017795641,
-0.002095242,
0.0675672591,
0.0224757809,
0.0270677656,
-0.0457606651,
-0.0188359208,
0.017311506,
-0.0934903473,
-0.0247120634,
0.0234172214,
-5.557450764e-33,
0.0157101844,
-0.0923923254,
0.0297469348,
-0.0061123054,
0.0055713812,
0.0080189491,
-0.0231088474,
0.0215676557,
0.0005200569,
0.0775113851,
0.0200111177,
0.0005526415,
-0.0127997985,
0.0216982402,
0.0033564402,
-0.0063970126,
0.0358736068,
0.0215341058,
0.0243936349,
0.0080779837,
0.018541364,
0.0007925718,
0.0103001362,
-0.0929338187,
0.0055927923,
0.0274458956,
0.031131031,
0.0224302821,
-0.0087168133,
0.0920718014,
-0.0053563924,
0.0636154115,
0.0392031036,
0.021660164,
0.0173067134,
-0.0346158408,
-0.0636040419,
-0.0309355557,
0.0158689097,
-0.0440851301,
-0.0256527904,
-0.0367784239,
0.008338945,
-0.0013922958,
0.0034738688,
-0.0102012008,
0.0151042594,
-0.0243730713,
-0.0487615801,
-0.019243801,
-0.0140655171,
0.0475403778,
0.0336326994,
-0.0008735816,
-0.0334713385,
-0.0615118556,
-0.0225658137,
-0.0316802934,
0.0142281801,
0.0359278731,
0.0385829993,
0.0128232436,
0.0099259475,
-0.0180345718,
-0.0326432325,
0.0273727123,
-0.0629227534,
-0.006991405,
0.017147921,
0.0227926075,
-0.0519657396,
0.0694246665,
0.0004055114,
0.0106644863,
-0.0323818102,
0.0100204721,
-0.0671196803,
0.0120655345,
-0.0708658472,
0.0575971231,
0.0060417959,
0.0070418632,
-0.0226251893,
-0.0100218402,
-0.0448108725,
0.0266547091,
-0.0439999886,
-0.0561921224,
0.0255161338,
-0.0166928042,
0.0101631507,
0.0151281599,
-0.0214170329,
-0.0309956651,
-0.029031761,
-0.0267684031,
0.0362662338,
-0.0200654399,
-0.0447269529,
-0.0050727916,
-0.0694202855,
-0.0041967724,
0.0110118194,
-0.0126667637,
0.0191056468,
0.0561907552,
0.0072940974,
-0.01755183,
-0.0478814915,
0.025687987,
0.0235213377,
-0.0507145524,
-0.0342211239,
-0.0155273378,
0.0252791606,
0.0238251109,
0.0006073588,
0.0520238876,
0.027071353,
-0.0172065794,
-0.0573927388,
-0.0197384469,
0.0022841704,
-0.0007061802,
-0.0300876182,
-0.0016375122,
-0.031416744,
0.0108676115,
0.0767868534,
-0.0052799582,
-0.0046351226,
-0.0308374465,
2.846e-7,
0.0677076355,
0.0634549186,
-0.0200305991,
0.047520563,
0.0598252453,
-0.0111078825,
0.0367210805,
-0.0040827827,
-0.0305723399,
-0.0170688592,
0.0429604799,
-0.0053711776,
-0.0271640662,
0.0366663225,
-0.0551287495,
-0.0338212587,
-0.0189000517,
-0.058008939,
-0.0456837974,
-0.0256922189,
0.0841683075,
0.0315644592,
-0.0253027063,
-0.0180836134,
-0.0000962132,
0.0027989396,
0.0202579796,
-0.0406856388,
0.0049774479,
0.0294745807,
0.0330213122,
-0.0206076056,
0.0340093039,
0.0591564886,
-0.0027280676,
-0.0285620987,
-0.0112414965,
0.0650457665,
-0.0777473673,
0.0563849434,
0.0379105136,
-0.0333254151,
0.0223387349,
-0.0475513972,
0.0056928601,
-0.062025439,
-0.037022911,
0.000597677,
0.0201853849,
0.001426,
0.0373746306,
-0.0205933843,
-0.0099937562,
0.0209411271,
0.0152263902,
0.0475185215,
-0.0080279699,
-0.0516103767,
0.0104866121,
0.0905715749,
-0.0026817548,
-0.0692211017,
0.0323638618,
-0.0405009054,
0.0048770448,
-0.0868722051,
0.0147146275,
2.347724179e-34,
0.019000072,
0.0499537103,
-0.0105205337,
0.0163789243,
0.0265696291,
-0.0120185222,
0.033441633,
0.0303210337,
0.0147477724,
-0.0676164478,
0.0037315479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06855v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06855v1 | DialMAT: Dialogue-Enabled Transformer with Moment-Based Adversarial Training | 2023-11-12T14:12:19 | 2023-11-12T14:12:19 | Kanta Kaneda, Ryosuke Korekata, Yuiga Wada, Shunya Nagashima, Motonari Kambara, Yui Iioka, Haruka Matsuo, Yuto Imai, Takayuki Nishimura, Komei Sugiura | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.RO | This paper focuses on the DialFRED task, which is the task of embodied
instruction following in a setting where an agent can actively ask questions
about the task. To address this task, we propose DialMAT. DialMAT introduces
Moment-based Adversarial Training, which incorporates adversarial perturbations
into the latent space of language, image, and action. Additionally, it
introduces a crossmodal parallel feature extraction mechanism that applies
foundation models to both language and image. We evaluated our model using a
dataset constructed from the DialFRED dataset and demonstrated superior
performance compared to the baseline method in terms of success rate and path
weighted success rate. The model secured the top position in the DialFRED
Challenge, which took place at the CVPR 2023 Embodied AI workshop. | [
-0.0000826944,
0.0702778548,
-0.0258461591,
0.0370732248,
0.0042426386,
0.0016203242,
0.0358411707,
-0.0325554796,
-0.0054991301,
-0.0198594369,
-0.0602390729,
-0.0197089817,
-0.0035539432,
0.0386045873,
0.0293196738,
-0.0818739757,
0.0000969897,
-0.0129135679,
-0.0589827746,
0.0104789715,
0.0260495376,
-0.0039245593,
-0.0714363083,
0.0314048491,
-0.0602849834,
-0.0194088463,
-0.0728275701,
0.0132726654,
0.0482262708,
-0.025183361,
0.0024798582,
0.0236194432,
0.0001961036,
0.072234638,
0.0000021165,
0.0239718426,
0.0256739967,
-0.0055162618,
-0.0325912125,
-0.0280373469,
0.033350978,
-0.0282893106,
-0.0263031833,
-0.0053587751,
-0.0274184979,
-0.0514793657,
0.0364524573,
0.1026185527,
0.0681963563,
0.0902049616,
-0.0284679644,
0.0180994533,
0.0348566994,
-0.0119310413,
-0.0341414846,
-0.0116998479,
-0.037016619,
0.0138725927,
0.0102810524,
0.0155119775,
-0.0501251742,
0.0421267524,
0.0585226007,
-0.0208260026,
-0.0115720052,
0.0564167798,
-0.0037549739,
-0.0517321825,
-0.0391949043,
0.1085485518,
0.0085552363,
0.0335342959,
-0.0063823727,
-0.0042686099,
0.0011836134,
-0.0057912394,
-0.0216570795,
0.007964571,
0.0306949839,
0.0083327275,
-0.0475712195,
0.0177406855,
-0.0125760054,
-0.0075991219,
-0.0277097709,
0.002921615,
0.0016122841,
-0.0201765392,
-0.0058553298,
-0.0289252624,
-0.0020338753,
-0.0450698882,
0.0166273359,
0.0165129434,
-0.0120206606,
-0.0041089263,
-0.0448773988,
-0.0217187367,
-0.0140221026,
-0.0346930921,
0.0298776682,
0.0071761468,
-0.0427849479,
0.0161903817,
-0.0170281492,
0.0758780688,
-0.0170606989,
0.034849979,
-0.0314510316,
0.035016451,
-0.032657817,
0.0111759203,
-0.0376328118,
-0.0054467786,
-0.0723466352,
-0.0427631326,
0.0109535623,
0.020557709,
-0.0206524245,
-0.0047566602,
-0.0295718685,
0.0374039412,
-0.0365612879,
-0.0153308092,
-0.0140081048,
0.0256900936,
-0.0125958491,
0.0648512244,
0.025237022,
-0.063331686,
-0.055515673,
0.03038368,
-0.0053766547,
-0.019171698,
0.0076157334,
0.0784227327,
-0.0392319374,
-0.0190748628,
-0.0036020009,
0.0310823768,
-0.0046737948,
-0.0346046723,
0.0331987962,
-0.0191843193,
0.0254646838,
-0.0496046878,
0.0123103419,
-0.0209421292,
0.0170472786,
-0.0384560451,
0.0497511476,
0.0909628272,
0.0715799779,
0.0038307277,
0.0721732154,
0.0044399463,
-0.0334202424,
0.0630307198,
0.0307125542,
0.0281665903,
-0.0092619853,
-0.0087250462,
0.0248582121,
0.0584843457,
0.0045317453,
0.0274312571,
0.01656604,
-0.0206409823,
0.0040101353,
0.0884554982,
0.015340005,
0.0477875099,
-0.0440525599,
-0.0110257519,
0.0712200701,
0.0034330401,
-0.0180497672,
-0.031517148,
0.0146413948,
0.0094582904,
-0.011333053,
-0.0349759087,
-0.0411265716,
0.0597493201,
0.0210093092,
-0.029252464,
-0.0337456651,
0.0247801542,
-0.0650974214,
-0.0148782143,
0.0579804704,
0.0069669648,
0.0239142738,
-0.0084926635,
0.0314873494,
0.0688819289,
-0.0488342717,
0.0401066318,
-0.0275616273,
-0.0283391196,
-0.0325754918,
-0.0314195231,
-0.0109521132,
-0.0087975329,
-0.0008857892,
0.0001892958,
-0.0439654142,
-0.0455132499,
0.0593569428,
0.0522400923,
-0.0253134668,
-0.0103801303,
0.0708850324,
-0.0262495764,
-0.007185969,
-0.0178378541,
0.0141127845,
0.0241244435,
0.0109658856,
0.0043205549,
-0.0009834393,
0.032799989,
0.0085075805,
0.0436890982,
-0.0101745054,
-0.0225335583,
0.0156546459,
0.033803124,
0.045019377,
-0.0140713938,
-0.0324063748,
-0.0082590748,
0.0193497781,
-0.0434140153,
-0.0290030688,
0.0492099039,
-0.0472205617,
-0.0600983724,
0.0503725447,
-0.0443920679,
-0.0269074254,
0.0219267439,
-0.0279338658,
-0.0209112111,
0.0479131117,
-0.0243891738,
0.0147017026,
-0.0077074743,
0.0018911221,
0.0485599712,
0.0078058238,
-0.0183827225,
-0.0339287929,
-0.0351084098,
-0.0399397388,
0.0066386042,
0.0341725834,
0.0033018247,
-0.0594704188,
-0.0142036909,
0.0528581142,
-0.0030746274,
0.0215577241,
-0.0160910077,
0.0222628806,
-0.0457129218,
-0.0580171421,
-0.0802021921,
-0.0151525903,
-0.0045434502,
-0.0251538996,
0.0207300708,
0.0100604864,
-0.0065402305,
-0.003025722,
-0.0158739518,
0.0299489163,
0.0108244345,
-0.0149078937,
0.0113693606,
0.0321361199,
-0.002737656,
-0.0230710506,
0.0157174636,
0.030249672,
0.0394066423,
0.007153214,
0.0231693946,
0.0185910799,
-0.0030250119,
0.0126614152,
0.0525471047,
-0.0465388447,
-0.061987862,
0.0309984256,
-0.0121293478,
0.023251893,
0.0749671161,
0.027517017,
0.0454299748,
-0.0102595706,
-0.0016617485,
-0.0325441398,
0.0233768057,
-0.0152348438,
0.0064378581,
-0.0293658692,
-0.008690997,
0.0172746852,
0.0221077092,
0.023892602,
0.0476565249,
-0.0545871593,
0.0093696984,
0.0063839671,
-0.0896797031,
0.0059989542,
0.0652946904,
-0.0464400053,
-0.0246901643,
-0.067065455,
-0.0393398926,
0.0351784453,
-0.0365895405,
-0.0500066169,
0.0417561755,
-0.0141360555,
0.0125577636,
0.0602412932,
-0.0044823568,
0.0260946397,
0.00759392,
-0.0221693106,
-0.0780254528,
-0.009158832,
0.0253497269,
-0.0155111179,
0.0447005332,
-0.0285585634,
-0.0064579351,
-0.0121558029,
-0.0307077263,
-0.0573058315,
-0.0137207638,
0.0112686362,
-0.0043197442,
-0.0375176258,
-0.0077511193,
-0.0690073967,
-0.0111834174,
0.0108358078,
0.0481587239,
-0.0237433743,
0.0120248897,
-0.0019912589,
0.0282397885,
0.0570439212,
0.0529753193,
-0.0100817271,
-0.0218210295,
0.1078370437,
0.0531452522,
0.0278973505,
-0.047747016,
-0.0840604156,
0.0010236942,
-0.0168124177,
0.0285472479,
0.0254039112,
-0.010467954,
0.0716408342,
-0.0145213483,
0.0026329055,
0.0506482795,
-0.0146475108,
0.0023821034,
0.0079387734,
0.0132649709,
0.0125878574,
0.0213490948,
0.0100959809,
-0.0709304661,
-0.021900462,
-0.009824682,
0.014299972,
0.0186481699,
-0.0064283158,
0.0154122012,
-0.0791303292,
0.0388859473,
0.0157046802,
-0.0370350927,
-0.036327742,
0.0324919522,
0.0097979596,
-0.0217755754,
0.0390035287,
0.007508724,
0.0203094669,
0.0054097297,
0.029334411,
0.0444835871,
-0.0119599747,
-0.007217587,
-0.0321237966,
0.0630058274,
-0.0056698364,
0.0544217676,
-0.028858114,
-0.029661024,
0.0029423055,
-0.0008905965,
-0.0103177866,
0.0137536805,
0.0483531989,
-0.0208451543,
-0.0236993134,
0.0184929129,
0.068105258,
0.0096100951,
-0.0147830667,
0.0373719074,
0.0456799641,
-0.0632660836,
0.0174424164,
-0.0040364927,
0.0062744799,
0.0383909717,
0.023826465,
-0.020992998,
-0.0319638662,
-0.0066109165,
-0.033440318,
-0.0028626218,
-0.0289673414,
-0.0519877151,
-0.0267836545,
0.0021645001,
-0.0012014186,
-0.0671333149,
-0.011437038,
0.0497933477,
0.0660657734,
-0.0140942466,
-0.0994188562,
-0.0447578616,
0.0436264239,
-0.0160619747,
0.0287497025,
0.012844787,
0.0285102371,
-0.0599872209,
-0.0224048533,
0.0631882027,
-0.0383532159,
0.0140434243,
0.0211077966,
-0.0551590696,
-0.0485902466,
-0.0228385739,
0.0491680615,
0.0102204494,
0.0957874507,
0.0071409573,
0.035838306,
0.0583092347,
0.0186461918,
-0.0598360002,
0.0198936556,
0.0915543959,
-0.0052878386,
-0.0105636287,
0.0256863907,
-0.0220788196,
0.0234585889,
0.0104971277,
0.0085926037,
-0.0385973938,
-0.0353505798,
0.0196068212,
-0.0006813111,
0.0553992726,
-0.0254246294,
-0.0052871821,
-0.0781527609,
0.0264723115,
0.0139509952,
0.0282824431,
-0.0865028203,
-0.0083983336,
0.0244679619,
0.0481066331,
0.0238942802,
-0.0207374152,
-0.0081880381,
0.0279006697,
-0.0010830703,
0.0209344272,
0.0235020369,
0.0142873125,
-0.0162977837,
0.0432650298,
0.0260219574,
0.0500282608,
0.0029573322,
0.0268147085,
0.0161977801,
0.0873583108,
0.0303043909,
-0.0114015723,
0.0018570534,
0.0300228409,
-0.0375468209,
-0.0196694173,
-0.020816369,
0.0004595869,
-0.0107690981,
0.0095817521,
0.0114767635,
-0.0214695185,
0.0003252494,
0.0146170007,
0.0583213158,
-0.0049799592,
-0.0121432776,
0.0500573292,
-0.0043436405,
0.0119844032,
0.0124241263,
0.0352450535,
-0.0321655534,
0.0699849725,
0.0197476149,
0.0290912967,
-0.0766958147,
-0.0760947913,
-0.0106994277,
-0.047219079,
0.0163921025,
0.0451562814,
-0.0145722283,
-0.0487357192,
-0.0173261259,
0.0253421552,
-0.052412834,
-0.0253054295,
0.047516685,
-0.0061573051,
0.0152551346,
0.01014145,
-0.0502544306,
-0.0006054144,
0.0266354382,
-0.0173813943,
-0.0111887213,
-5.713785635e-33,
-0.0642439201,
0.019423034,
0.030269362,
0.0130146211,
-0.0579062328,
0.0215549525,
-0.0545467064,
0.0254146922,
-0.0120412586,
0.0423509516,
0.0137742627,
-0.011473964,
-0.0094437832,
0.019560419,
0.010452887,
-0.0226761419,
0.0307185184,
-0.0269158948,
-0.0222721901,
0.0105365524,
0.0233014338,
0.0059535713,
0.0339436755,
-0.0637042075,
-0.0432426371,
0.0198358037,
-0.0631505102,
0.0250439011,
-0.0030225688,
0.0371269695,
0.0094637806,
-0.0177588854,
-0.0268093217,
-0.048926305,
-0.005623207,
-0.0366566777,
-0.0678808689,
-0.0028743853,
-0.016822625,
0.0490446165,
-0.0421102457,
-0.0152309872,
0.0016242954,
-0.0298111849,
-0.0042869677,
-0.044226151,
-0.0043308851,
-0.0236053038,
0.0110853193,
-0.0045749969,
-0.0306261964,
0.0077950559,
-0.049233079,
-0.0670862496,
0.0238583665,
0.0395867601,
0.0038806056,
-0.0472512171,
-0.035067793,
0.0139743295,
-0.0062224166,
-0.0014671932,
0.0497518331,
0.0590305403,
0.0424575098,
0.065326564,
0.0460107103,
-0.0311784111,
-0.0342363417,
0.0122516174,
0.0406479165,
0.0660483465,
0.0223205891,
0.0610591471,
-0.0229160506,
-0.0062426273,
-0.0214745589,
0.0520798787,
0.0226408858,
0.0526227057,
-0.0520145409,
0.0214230958,
0.0117989751,
0.0111453393,
-0.0325381905,
-0.0387852862,
0.0096945511,
-0.0381644741,
0.0245846491,
0.0432127155,
0.0207073316,
-0.026499467,
0.0555293187,
-0.0273888893,
0.0374434106,
-0.0164909363,
-0.0288113561,
0.0266060773,
-0.0046605901,
-0.0125522157,
-0.039095927,
-0.0073615946,
0.0820264667,
-0.0057763457,
0.0433043726,
0.0039935159,
0.0258872602,
0.07789509,
-0.0142670497,
-0.0501070656,
-0.0312394444,
0.0669310465,
0.0276856478,
0.0376631506,
-0.0128990505,
-0.0202064645,
-0.0666401237,
-0.0019397378,
-0.047572881,
0.0017200264,
-0.0438091382,
0.0026381232,
0.001105112,
0.0315712914,
-0.0862107426,
-0.0150142787,
-0.0349414274,
-0.0272988118,
0.0419716239,
-0.1109297946,
-0.0108584035,
-0.0098058078,
2.867e-7,
-0.0221486688,
-0.0132524306,
0.035527952,
-0.0241919681,
0.0435641706,
0.0558209568,
-0.0752555579,
0.0167336632,
-0.0270488933,
-0.0309879631,
0.0482216626,
0.0390836112,
0.0741628036,
0.0073011671,
-0.0637817681,
-0.0372616947,
-0.0355455279,
-0.0371273905,
-0.0350380205,
-0.0239929482,
0.00516597,
0.1174858809,
0.0135913352,
0.0017143511,
0.0167874563,
0.0020729967,
0.0644916892,
-0.0454793945,
0.002375836,
-0.0291275159,
0.011459046,
-0.0023273474,
-0.0157588329,
-0.0162330046,
-0.0282972045,
-0.0120140435,
0.0138600077,
0.0636341274,
-0.0119684925,
-0.0654991195,
-0.0123580061,
0.0316007957,
-0.0324547216,
-0.0048619322,
0.0542196631,
-0.0514352694,
-0.0388685614,
-0.0668380037,
-0.068177551,
0.0304068942,
0.0147701809,
-0.0148388222,
-0.0146914078,
0.0130274715,
0.0328234136,
-0.0155296689,
0.0078867655,
-0.0632140636,
-0.0024616923,
-0.0211057346,
-0.0660309196,
-0.0265324656,
-0.023230914,
-0.0089794369,
-0.012225261,
0.0188930575,
-0.0348092206,
2.152898159e-34,
-0.0097267227,
0.0124774426,
0.0032170466,
0.0410426855,
0.0210919231,
0.0031469688,
0.0441088416,
-0.0151064778,
-0.002015397,
-0.0539990216,
-0.0207192972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06851v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06851v3 | Automatic Textual Normalization for Hate Speech Detection | 2023-11-12T14:01:38 | 2023-12-04T15:34:29 | Anh Thi-Hoang Nguyen, Dung Ha Nguyen, Nguyet Thi Nguyen, Khanh Thanh-Duy Ho, Kiet Van Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social media data is a valuable resource for research, yet it contains a wide
range of non-standard words (NSW). These irregularities hinder the effective
operation of NLP tools. Current state-of-the-art methods for the Vietnamese
language address this issue as a problem of lexical normalization, involving
the creation of manual rules or the implementation of multi-staged deep
learning frameworks, which necessitate extensive efforts to craft intricate
rules. In contrast, our approach is straightforward, employing solely a
sequence-to-sequence (Seq2Seq) model. In this research, we provide a dataset
for textual normalization, comprising 2,181 human-annotated comments with an
inter-annotator agreement of 0.9014. By leveraging the Seq2Seq model for
textual normalization, our results reveal that the accuracy achieved falls
slightly short of 70%. Nevertheless, textual normalization enhances the
accuracy of the Hate Speech Detection (HSD) task by approximately 2%,
demonstrating its potential to improve the performance of complex NLP tasks.
Our dataset is accessible for research purposes. | [
0.0429380946,
0.0758203492,
0.0183124915,
0.0075153443,
-0.0220250115,
0.0193830431,
0.0133724883,
0.0217099842,
0.0097813169,
-0.0535007864,
0.0043712594,
-0.0539182164,
0.0181512684,
0.0333149619,
-0.0372333825,
-0.0400850922,
0.0194119532,
0.0292334817,
0.0373981036,
0.000583426,
0.0781643242,
0.0105142156,
0.018761266,
0.05923675,
-0.0573029555,
0.024463363,
0.0307300873,
0.0123420199,
0.0203231666,
-0.0236879475,
0.0378027745,
0.0836139843,
-0.0112268059,
0.1014102772,
0.0000017896,
-0.0348108076,
0.0113501446,
-0.0484043397,
0.036746949,
0.0129987746,
0.0809774771,
-0.0811768025,
-0.0148564233,
0.041570209,
-0.043181695,
-0.0242485832,
0.0647287518,
0.0763405487,
0.0809880123,
0.0828616917,
-0.0119383149,
-0.0642244071,
0.003686938,
-0.0101773869,
-0.0252087601,
0.0154781081,
0.0361080244,
-0.0208727904,
-0.0367088541,
-0.0241780113,
-0.0054114065,
0.0163600389,
0.0315530337,
-0.0077608009,
0.0116042197,
-0.0425860249,
-0.0198132079,
-0.0310217328,
0.0087139998,
0.0618458092,
-0.0485762134,
-0.0246064905,
-0.0125298016,
0.0038715352,
-0.0146175679,
-0.0224838387,
-0.0089494651,
0.0135782724,
0.0037350759,
0.0271205865,
0.0255861972,
-0.0037219257,
0.04758453,
0.0503433496,
0.0242882762,
-0.0037040724,
-0.0266867671,
-0.0296386387,
-0.005734677,
-0.0052010063,
-0.0451828055,
0.0031320082,
0.0669294,
0.007709689,
-0.0284126438,
0.0015758503,
-0.0330719501,
-0.0600052848,
0.0307953879,
-0.0852862522,
0.0033194546,
0.0236288961,
-0.0270623825,
-0.0085205901,
-0.0037988562,
0.015023699,
-0.0055426359,
0.0096374769,
-0.0252036043,
-0.0155018317,
-0.0176233798,
0.0286134612,
-0.0151243489,
0.0099804811,
-0.0243764967,
-0.0107657937,
-0.0502616093,
-0.0384670608,
-0.028992625,
-0.0215662532,
0.0212151986,
0.043322131,
-0.0382758826,
0.0101155676,
-0.0199680422,
0.0407213308,
-0.037163686,
0.0455192477,
-0.0218552575,
-0.0452034324,
0.021993041,
0.0488922223,
0.0061641112,
0.0017529507,
0.0342666544,
0.0270401631,
0.0097615467,
-0.0174267571,
-0.0685552061,
-0.0316685699,
-0.0189562272,
-0.0201499406,
-0.0221325476,
-0.0836579129,
-0.0053200633,
-0.0297444351,
-0.027114585,
-0.0348524898,
0.0078772577,
0.0401276164,
-0.0409992114,
0.0860861987,
-0.0034961731,
-0.0278674234,
0.0335752741,
0.0420776084,
0.0305790771,
0.0453610197,
0.0328218751,
0.0345429257,
0.0421511158,
-0.0191178564,
-0.008149595,
0.0623194724,
0.0230630804,
-0.0086296992,
-0.0327270702,
-0.0213290695,
-0.064324528,
0.0082675135,
0.0180947464,
0.0921384022,
-0.0094933482,
-0.0681348592,
0.0157545302,
0.0749174356,
-0.0447544605,
0.0114876721,
0.0580456965,
0.0308896881,
-0.0229194034,
-0.0106071467,
-0.0589633808,
-0.0196738951,
-0.031221455,
-0.033780776,
0.0180972293,
0.0492156297,
-0.0207326505,
-0.0499973595,
-0.0025013012,
-0.0191460811,
0.0627051294,
-0.0520208925,
0.0136711067,
0.0276561324,
-0.0104932329,
0.0132297417,
0.0278206859,
-0.0144457836,
0.0063068089,
0.0049261674,
-0.013658395,
0.0488276146,
0.0285039973,
0.0105674248,
0.0082349898,
-0.0698922724,
0.0001674686,
0.0693511888,
0.001376757,
-0.018742092,
0.0078036236,
-0.0590399504,
0.0028340553,
0.0526567921,
0.0209576841,
0.0139676062,
0.0555614196,
-0.0086408481,
0.0293642115,
0.0326013714,
-0.0638688728,
0.0383954197,
-0.0000429467,
-0.0517954193,
0.0099669266,
0.0180603806,
0.0196119696,
0.0745103434,
-0.0238583218,
-0.0501132645,
0.0318350606,
-0.0189071577,
-0.0449307486,
-0.0018317204,
-0.0472475849,
-0.0226642974,
0.0326655433,
-0.0702554956,
-0.0154760219,
0.1002165601,
-0.0177374333,
-0.0238093119,
0.0354176573,
-0.0135023631,
-0.0222714841,
-0.041346617,
-0.0189245697,
-0.0381009914,
0.0751253366,
0.0017345108,
0.0214411542,
-0.0494431965,
-0.0153759858,
0.0599787608,
-0.0578228571,
0.0262049064,
0.0200351644,
-0.0728005543,
-0.0078440038,
0.0048837843,
0.0535499565,
0.0224568136,
0.0303619243,
-0.021988092,
0.0290002991,
-0.1167529449,
0.0178027023,
-0.0503621623,
-0.0166742187,
0.0318380482,
0.0149096707,
0.0021974361,
-0.0191377271,
-0.0328496434,
-0.0553664193,
0.0596225895,
0.0167360269,
0.0335726216,
-0.0584382191,
-0.0335702896,
-0.0450766273,
-0.0298055578,
-0.0125191482,
0.0017585977,
-0.007530869,
-0.0430945829,
0.02320637,
-0.0078762388,
-0.0186057147,
0.0302544329,
0.0164026674,
-0.0537302271,
-0.0016845287,
0.0401927605,
-0.0325436704,
0.0681696236,
0.0486895703,
0.0612237006,
0.0140277846,
0.0057452046,
-0.0228612218,
-0.0243583024,
-0.016082868,
0.0268848017,
-0.0208461117,
-0.0379246213,
-0.0359316468,
0.0929548815,
0.0086745191,
0.0145935751,
-0.0461827144,
-0.0046044211,
-0.0324636437,
-0.0310953446,
0.0223334692,
-0.0303694122,
-0.0137623511,
-0.0119553003,
-0.0339479409,
-0.0347430296,
0.0815187544,
-0.0024940979,
0.0021389283,
-0.0456718728,
-0.0214838777,
-0.0082125608,
0.0548361912,
-0.0006126945,
0.030683836,
-0.0528223775,
-0.0302433334,
0.0213586874,
-0.0191358216,
-0.004970639,
-0.031413503,
0.016893452,
-0.0186074339,
-0.0080315052,
-0.0107724359,
-0.0016943398,
-0.0605350845,
-0.0229404569,
-0.065620482,
0.0097806016,
0.0162562858,
-0.0244822539,
-0.0156621784,
0.0291114766,
-0.0147989327,
0.0150955189,
0.020380171,
0.0258982666,
-0.0017545521,
0.0250075161,
0.0187027007,
-0.0024908381,
0.0112992115,
0.0171243176,
0.0305101778,
0.0494126193,
0.0005521202,
0.0350401253,
-0.0277896989,
-0.0141887395,
-0.0031325466,
-0.010489461,
0.0256831497,
-0.0205342229,
0.0326515697,
-0.0168077499,
0.011959454,
0.1143211275,
0.0085561564,
-0.0495322235,
-0.0031252927,
0.0164053477,
0.0128069334,
0.0028349643,
-0.0423432067,
-0.1001202986,
-0.0391101018,
-0.009958039,
-0.0064580548,
-0.0162985437,
-0.0394102968,
0.0090584951,
-0.0385450125,
-0.0387600027,
-0.0081408862,
-0.0691992342,
-0.0426559784,
-0.0073623927,
0.012914245,
-0.0288580395,
0.1044830382,
-0.0318667144,
0.0205759145,
-0.0294795334,
0.0171631891,
-0.0651201308,
-0.0405758172,
0.0206066053,
-0.057094492,
0.0815551579,
0.0401904993,
0.0222181454,
-0.0051479638,
-0.0129834078,
0.040183682,
0.0343604647,
-0.0250885263,
-0.0376570709,
0.0146842059,
-0.0183364712,
-0.0288538914,
-0.020094851,
0.0330324098,
-0.0591908321,
0.0368536264,
-0.0134827783,
0.0569135509,
0.0397376083,
-0.0437718555,
-0.0610864535,
0.0440616868,
-0.0174428616,
0.0774005279,
0.0130683733,
-0.0701352581,
-0.0018468418,
-0.0389774069,
-0.0375721008,
-0.0564898662,
-0.0800383762,
0.0092668086,
-0.0305615906,
-0.0227169842,
-0.0637412667,
-0.0792988613,
0.0111112827,
0.0047557256,
0.0047532455,
-0.005882083,
0.0253529139,
-0.0230061114,
-0.0513797589,
0.0109568061,
-0.0135390246,
0.039984066,
-0.0008498835,
0.019703107,
-0.04148148,
0.0075973324,
-0.005808712,
0.0062290658,
-0.0582152046,
-0.0408321843,
0.0477550775,
-0.0163668692,
0.0157981012,
0.0063413777,
-0.0076013524,
-0.0653976947,
0.0095104426,
0.0674618408,
-0.0163419638,
-0.0371631123,
0.029219266,
0.0012258819,
-0.0001765529,
0.0420143344,
0.0201995187,
0.0344073698,
-0.0034549451,
0.0129587026,
-0.040211685,
-0.0355154797,
-0.0217572413,
0.0032007792,
0.0499434322,
0.0004629088,
-0.0277093332,
-0.0243837927,
-0.036649622,
-0.0119690541,
-0.0143699776,
-0.0112162819,
0.0334570669,
0.0202498399,
0.0138961803,
-0.0437895842,
-0.0209112074,
-0.0379545465,
-0.0026391023,
-0.0133394655,
0.0310999025,
0.0404542722,
0.0546053536,
0.0221680403,
0.0043841158,
-0.0195263736,
0.0344470702,
-0.0077647492,
0.0083730444,
-0.0154426778,
0.0025052328,
0.0241191126,
0.03622967,
0.0129892668,
-0.0163262915,
0.0200959463,
0.00961011,
-0.060752254,
-0.01479699,
0.0488157086,
-0.0307579245,
0.0587126948,
-0.0117578544,
0.0147937052,
-0.0304932818,
-0.0021923457,
-0.0333348773,
-0.0318260379,
-0.0111024799,
0.0100768348,
-0.0315829143,
0.0377699696,
0.0459590964,
-0.0149783865,
0.0399962403,
0.0391840339,
-0.0384983383,
-0.024364125,
-0.0115692457,
0.066949971,
0.0521222614,
-0.0384533815,
-0.023406215,
-0.0191167761,
-0.0724645332,
0.0020261772,
-0.0256539825,
0.0224614851,
0.0365208983,
0.0119385822,
0.0652347431,
-0.0048576188,
0.0215352327,
0.0064954152,
0.0090159317,
-0.0087132715,
-0.0691694766,
0.0078238621,
-5.868534324e-33,
-0.0115967803,
-0.0243467148,
-0.0181506202,
-0.0181275718,
0.0197687354,
-0.0062278728,
0.0193217788,
0.0291533824,
-0.0177645758,
0.0324435867,
0.0006725582,
0.027733339,
0.0126030734,
0.0127612809,
0.0257934593,
-0.0193192828,
0.0462298393,
0.0075819958,
-0.0043309303,
0.0006267256,
0.0401066914,
0.0182079207,
0.063004829,
-0.0602195933,
0.0566036329,
0.0104667433,
-0.0122416858,
0.0187784676,
0.0460664481,
0.0532824434,
-0.0277773198,
0.0900662094,
0.0372600332,
-0.0001914439,
-0.0207142383,
0.0419588648,
-0.081748195,
-0.0019557525,
0.0176845603,
0.0353986993,
-0.0210332256,
0.0034891332,
0.0744443163,
-0.0017152984,
-0.0497947522,
0.015151687,
0.0225206297,
-0.0063547487,
0.0396411046,
-0.0118895546,
-0.0856515691,
0.0429696143,
-0.0086108185,
-0.0054275976,
0.0056913714,
0.0207977574,
-0.0091718538,
-0.0183959063,
-0.0707694814,
-0.0091101015,
-0.0389847867,
0.0250624362,
0.0050917231,
0.0019406677,
-0.0233651884,
0.0461238846,
0.0380840115,
-0.0027120307,
-0.0407279879,
0.0461509973,
0.0653060377,
-0.005971096,
0.0387703925,
0.0396806709,
0.0358789265,
-0.0631149709,
-0.0664696321,
0.0207387283,
0.0807526633,
0.0315696001,
0.0059355744,
-0.0216360465,
-0.0485590622,
-0.023680767,
-0.012380668,
-0.0552671179,
-0.0211018752,
-0.0390938856,
0.0177105982,
0.0171983447,
-0.0168316457,
0.025721278,
0.0349626057,
-0.0378516391,
0.0041935625,
0.052048184,
-0.0201441161,
-0.0278962087,
0.0085283052,
0.0444539748,
-0.0689295605,
-0.0154991914,
0.0162106659,
-0.025640035,
0.0159651153,
-0.0067751515,
0.0488533229,
0.0045796824,
-0.0770061389,
0.0179791357,
-0.0027648001,
0.0316601135,
-0.0284940712,
0.0566115677,
0.0137190577,
0.0074128448,
-0.0115586277,
0.0083929216,
0.0162439886,
0.0024910176,
-0.0478882715,
-0.0003157762,
-0.0121242385,
-0.0293333028,
-0.021349756,
0.018063724,
-0.0192139931,
0.0035553467,
-0.0009761098,
-0.0634238198,
0.0230182894,
-0.03466627,
2.41e-7,
0.0014809278,
0.0476017334,
0.0538582169,
-0.0074145952,
0.003512552,
0.0365672521,
0.0501240715,
0.0350830816,
-0.0327396579,
-0.0163417459,
-0.0092222607,
0.0380189195,
0.0276811477,
0.0228155348,
-0.0430562124,
-0.0503548793,
-0.0926284418,
0.015562837,
-0.0275052674,
-0.0069098091,
-0.0264916904,
0.1037668958,
0.0210048202,
-0.0534062833,
0.0050935606,
-0.0352810845,
0.0004741298,
-0.0040817647,
-0.0058190301,
-0.0096688103,
0.090839833,
0.0115278559,
0.0276833177,
-0.0303461496,
0.0254810601,
0.0307182688,
0.0226870514,
0.0720937923,
-0.0033146304,
0.0176213514,
-0.0258408021,
-0.0397219025,
-0.0032361173,
-0.0354281254,
0.0274478868,
0.0250431541,
-0.0057628481,
-0.0613777339,
0.0019513723,
0.0189549513,
0.0627454445,
-0.0016659279,
-0.0211753529,
0.015954148,
0.0706990063,
0.0071885032,
-0.0222134534,
-0.0611945428,
-0.0415094122,
-0.0119747985,
-0.0081560491,
-0.0005551438,
-0.0205867402,
-0.000506779,
0.006660297,
0.0320193768,
0.0471183993,
1.753027008e-34,
0.0524435081,
-0.0315654799,
0.0001354433,
-0.0192734674,
0.0329210199,
-0.0065885182,
-0.026130598,
-0.0181570444,
0.0225916859,
-0.0538380258,
-0.0080434438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06838v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06838v1 | GIELLM: Japanese General Information Extraction Large Language Model Utilizing Mutual Reinforcement Effect | 2023-11-12T13:30:38 | 2023-11-12T13:30:38 | Chengguang Gan, Qinghao Zhang, Tatsunori Mori | cs.CL | cs.CL | Information Extraction (IE) stands as a cornerstone in natural language
processing, traditionally segmented into distinct sub-tasks. The advent of
Large Language Models (LLMs) heralds a paradigm shift, suggesting the
feasibility of a singular model addressing multiple IE subtasks. In this vein,
we introduce the General Information Extraction Large Language Model (GIELLM),
which integrates text Classification, Sentiment Analysis, Named Entity
Recognition, Relation Extraction, and Event Extraction using a uniform
input-output schema. This innovation marks the first instance of a model
simultaneously handling such a diverse array of IE subtasks. Notably, the
GIELLM leverages the Mutual Reinforcement Effect (MRE), enhancing performance
in integrated tasks compared to their isolated counterparts. Our experiments
demonstrate State-of-the-Art (SOTA) results in five out of six Japanese mixed
datasets, significantly surpassing GPT-3.5-Turbo. Further, an independent
evaluation using the novel Text Classification Relation and Event
Extraction(TCREE) dataset corroborates the synergistic advantages of MRE in
text and word classification. This breakthrough paves the way for most IE
subtasks to be subsumed under a singular LLM framework. Specialized fine-tune
task-specific models are no longer needed. | [
0.0651414022,
0.0567419417,
0.0337861665,
0.0887068957,
-0.0439000241,
0.0721324757,
-0.0280997269,
0.0533962846,
0.0124233169,
-0.0342840329,
-0.0681127831,
-0.0200528372,
-0.0368206911,
0.0182044487,
-0.010595317,
-0.0387930349,
0.040491838,
0.0156815611,
0.0308572669,
0.0196290538,
0.0213827118,
0.0009698633,
0.0170121696,
-0.0161983687,
-0.0217148401,
0.0148169445,
0.0368690416,
-0.0068132817,
0.0199135933,
-0.0532413498,
0.0207147617,
0.0133172078,
0.0049105529,
0.0183428563,
0.0000022148,
-0.0281419158,
-0.0264283363,
-0.0188754499,
0.0143553587,
-0.014363273,
0.0128245186,
-0.0398078188,
0.0000260391,
-0.0117193088,
-0.0506193899,
-0.0767777711,
0.0205890387,
0.0927115604,
0.0416933633,
0.1133795604,
-0.0356615074,
-0.0601659715,
0.0274048075,
-0.0462548733,
0.0124759804,
-0.0049941079,
0.04501196,
-0.0318423174,
-0.0130251097,
0.000258124,
0.0133649204,
-0.0118999891,
0.0088454382,
0.0179074556,
-0.0007755871,
0.0330906771,
0.0100098262,
-0.0122797759,
-0.0204869471,
0.0501107424,
-0.0083808498,
0.0274639484,
0.0197030082,
0.0060222745,
-0.0176434256,
-0.0051245363,
-0.0161815863,
0.0143202981,
-0.0390685722,
0.0564798042,
0.0611749738,
0.0177561417,
0.0155273573,
0.0099687567,
-0.0404069051,
0.0726289228,
0.0106989928,
-0.0865629688,
0.0142924227,
0.0482450873,
-0.0165468603,
-0.0005616009,
0.0045848018,
0.0185496174,
0.0096829617,
0.0388375744,
-0.0119963344,
-0.0234145615,
0.010188967,
-0.0993028581,
-0.0147034619,
0.0230763517,
-0.0106569547,
0.05176723,
-0.0268470198,
0.0196479801,
-0.0161795262,
0.0105968136,
-0.0065079546,
-0.0049599777,
-0.0504671708,
-0.0045754141,
-0.0055386578,
0.0733494684,
-0.0333033875,
-0.0290644728,
-0.0262173116,
0.0209027641,
-0.0146302702,
0.0252674837,
0.0432357937,
-0.0361719392,
-0.0230811387,
0.0014696735,
-0.023913715,
-0.003266742,
-0.0301022846,
0.0316573381,
-0.0277017243,
0.0015921971,
-0.0139877852,
-0.0060303044,
0.0424748734,
-0.0320920087,
0.0367604494,
0.0776636451,
-0.0040399213,
-0.0683291405,
-0.0669042394,
-0.0014916975,
0.0004191535,
-0.0385981128,
0.0297549963,
-0.0165219214,
0.0800978169,
-0.0171625391,
0.0093351202,
0.0039604655,
0.0410990231,
-0.0219075698,
-0.0498004369,
0.0605376437,
0.0017463381,
-0.0053624818,
-0.0113453083,
0.0116059855,
0.0304330885,
0.0716067627,
0.0306219403,
0.0093004899,
0.0698703155,
0.0246942546,
-0.0002652786,
0.0654402673,
-0.0134455562,
-0.0000980583,
0.0147088617,
-0.0234632175,
-0.0034172195,
-0.0203413107,
0.0622242987,
0.0139701329,
-0.0156677365,
0.0134220114,
0.0491895452,
0.0137292957,
-0.0309702195,
0.0469412245,
0.0058657997,
-0.016456034,
-0.010183515,
0.0196596216,
-0.0375356749,
-0.0033809617,
-0.0412062518,
0.0321078636,
0.0201351419,
0.0218227413,
-0.0156932864,
-0.0315437466,
0.0061228382,
-0.0401095711,
-0.0004472164,
0.0166327916,
0.0840922967,
-0.0097210985,
-0.0492818244,
0.0078493282,
0.0900170207,
-0.0273828432,
0.0148250395,
-0.0287426785,
0.0498146415,
0.0485588685,
0.0171695203,
-0.0446036756,
0.0071101515,
0.0154444296,
-0.035765741,
0.0663607791,
0.0222859867,
-0.0131494142,
0.0132111404,
-0.0078166509,
-0.0260574445,
0.0219656974,
0.0085168574,
0.0176527984,
0.0535364412,
0.0403051265,
0.0038275835,
0.0469813235,
-0.0037011418,
0.030428417,
0.0001525072,
-0.0539240763,
-0.0095080072,
0.0117562851,
0.0518418774,
-0.0037849988,
-0.0668857545,
-0.0216069147,
0.0392614044,
-0.0610121861,
-0.0562477708,
-0.0098939305,
-0.0215287078,
-0.0801219419,
0.0024109834,
0.0542018823,
-0.0289091654,
0.0319247805,
-0.041806262,
-0.002268634,
-0.0727254152,
0.03693863,
0.0521281734,
-0.0517857932,
0.0244332738,
0.0023553022,
0.0082055805,
-0.0295042209,
0.0507561415,
-0.0216458142,
-0.0267067533,
-0.0357804075,
-0.0554524362,
-0.0237094518,
-0.0118699083,
-0.0776766688,
0.0682540759,
0.0213806387,
-0.0146606304,
0.0121063814,
0.0282903798,
-0.0255473219,
-0.0647285134,
-0.0937931836,
0.0224450678,
-0.0076218373,
0.0539685562,
0.0072301226,
0.0090782167,
-0.0598262139,
0.0051211487,
-0.0054117204,
-0.0279222857,
0.0074448581,
0.0104667088,
0.0327829905,
0.0184118096,
0.0346442498,
-0.0603798777,
-0.0024827309,
0.0027800752,
0.0268543661,
0.0134962304,
-0.0636119694,
-0.029646311,
0.0540400036,
-0.0160558391,
0.0158800445,
0.0025797738,
-0.0297715534,
-0.0380117223,
-0.0512081608,
0.0301012918,
0.0332935899,
-0.0022717973,
0.0338691548,
-0.0192597937,
-0.0437739752,
-0.0183170382,
0.0388786942,
-0.0598230101,
-0.0010276315,
-0.0061208098,
-0.0177502949,
0.0246026739,
0.0767331645,
0.0181066338,
0.0359266363,
-0.0016314241,
-0.0249899589,
-0.0332305692,
0.0050621764,
-0.0169737525,
0.0134988911,
-0.0116093671,
-0.0355505124,
-0.0636468977,
-0.0128116747,
0.0926069096,
-0.0076153311,
-0.010978858,
-0.0741868988,
-0.0046930821,
-0.0721871033,
0.0567487255,
-0.015743304,
-0.0016068126,
0.0033553129,
-0.0113500087,
0.0371333137,
0.0004122537,
-0.0069640372,
-0.0243541375,
0.0394008756,
-0.0109763937,
0.0063314489,
-0.0052565732,
-0.0363148972,
0.0032043017,
-0.0461470187,
-0.0155436257,
-0.0149211576,
0.0092990911,
-0.0067545855,
0.0413625576,
0.0468283333,
0.0200703368,
0.0040882067,
-0.0348060057,
-0.0110431379,
-0.0053453511,
0.0442724265,
0.0443076342,
-0.0142843686,
-0.0472660102,
-0.0101663722,
0.0021167228,
0.0600469559,
0.0410000645,
0.0074905055,
-0.0132093411,
0.0115974983,
0.0245292932,
-0.0442876481,
-0.000252403,
-0.0611818694,
0.0159192421,
-0.088245824,
0.0047234576,
0.1270098686,
0.0127419056,
-0.0521535613,
-0.0268185139,
0.0039042442,
0.0075475876,
-0.0007849933,
0.0087174466,
-0.0273855384,
-0.0380178764,
-0.0046674307,
-0.0028605531,
-0.0063858633,
-0.0349549651,
0.0344506279,
-0.1299005002,
0.0133454259,
0.0080080274,
-0.0260559246,
-0.063740015,
-0.0678154528,
0.021720143,
0.0028356202,
-0.0259851981,
-0.0117178783,
-0.0044856654,
-0.0235755183,
-0.0222845096,
-0.0046456847,
-0.0582242273,
0.0202613883,
-0.0180546697,
0.0101926047,
0.0483802669,
0.0186134223,
-0.0177567471,
0.041860722,
0.0331208818,
-0.0237202384,
-0.0046866774,
-0.0611171387,
0.0483383425,
-0.0385625847,
-0.0224883817,
-0.0103093889,
-0.0120990779,
-0.0175460614,
0.0225408264,
0.042537313,
0.0529219694,
0.0353939906,
-0.0315606967,
-0.0087675676,
-0.0366774388,
0.0227115769,
0.0635375455,
-0.0066178981,
-0.0616515875,
-0.0152476812,
0.0358421691,
-0.0373051763,
-0.0395720415,
0.0009205386,
-0.0370784327,
-0.055371467,
0.015789194,
-0.0728591681,
-0.0931334421,
-0.0005717301,
-0.0020952066,
-0.0003543752,
-0.0199870523,
0.026793031,
0.0092928689,
-0.0233792532,
0.0207784977,
-0.0180934407,
-0.0254423618,
-0.030826984,
-0.0179125369,
0.017879745,
-0.0063966103,
-0.0160549134,
-0.0201767385,
-0.026309805,
-0.030053135,
-0.0499926321,
0.0483210422,
0.0019880896,
0.0395300277,
0.0339690745,
-0.0025142762,
0.0177462325,
0.0268839449,
-0.0588530041,
0.0241978336,
0.0355886854,
0.0376172923,
0.0019708883,
0.0160818491,
-0.0299275145,
0.0439503193,
0.0108765215,
0.0176905524,
-0.0255814176,
-0.00245054,
-0.0046271887,
-0.0096228234,
0.0852680802,
0.0290602148,
0.0178156123,
-0.0897141173,
0.0104779685,
-0.0201089755,
-0.0206239689,
-0.055592414,
-0.0002635449,
0.0374092348,
0.0013831137,
-0.0585970171,
0.0353721566,
0.0168633331,
0.039846275,
-0.0442020297,
-0.0268711243,
0.0055662571,
0.0351185314,
-0.0161339846,
-0.0024040127,
-0.022549225,
-0.0024687911,
0.042909652,
-0.0380179435,
-0.0278861392,
0.062390089,
0.0121648768,
-0.0352927521,
0.0154729625,
0.0113163386,
-0.0254068952,
0.0435623042,
-0.0174891036,
0.032497745,
0.0645533055,
-0.0064121843,
0.053351827,
-0.023955144,
-0.0262227375,
0.0152648259,
0.0172404293,
-0.0356460065,
0.0210149195,
0.02077627,
0.0093554901,
-0.0268412996,
-0.0181740429,
0.05418244,
-0.0053120139,
0.0503466502,
0.0189100616,
-0.0020982295,
-0.0307405051,
-0.0154978214,
0.0570638292,
-0.0018284041,
-0.0082052331,
-0.0204576794,
-0.0328645185,
-0.0171116497,
-0.001516593,
-0.0157653037,
-0.0196639933,
0.0093189795,
0.0147036407,
0.0616821349,
0.0086885644,
-0.0027539432,
-0.0435804166,
-0.0073641478,
-0.0089828065,
0.0068004364,
0.0013218693,
-7.23649016e-33,
-0.0485500991,
0.0108501902,
0.0162859429,
0.0660661608,
-0.0383351892,
0.0382984392,
-0.0324054547,
-0.003608041,
-0.0117530087,
0.0006285597,
-0.0105247339,
-0.0229836702,
0.0090822391,
0.0281044599,
0.0093581965,
0.0000797949,
0.0317078605,
0.008493484,
-0.0005050974,
0.0233714078,
0.0338284671,
0.0469048321,
0.05716452,
-0.0808137134,
0.0338884741,
0.0150125166,
0.0023503457,
0.0179599132,
0.0211899094,
0.0517445691,
-0.0448842421,
0.0609828644,
0.0439895913,
-0.039082244,
0.0078274114,
0.0411089472,
-0.1334924251,
-0.0124452394,
-0.0187336933,
-0.0220240727,
-0.0045161429,
-0.0004208271,
0.0049583996,
0.0217266921,
0.0324582644,
-0.0199911669,
0.0242880359,
-0.0195228178,
-0.0053379782,
-0.0698933154,
-0.0745771229,
0.0421963073,
0.0679426268,
0.0287573934,
0.0481523275,
-0.0190631151,
0.0305845831,
0.0556019656,
-0.0428721905,
-0.0075691063,
-0.0297844596,
0.0028877598,
-0.0126656713,
0.0036673397,
-0.0067798202,
0.059432745,
0.0062298938,
-0.00959442,
-0.0414255224,
0.0031355352,
0.0022643774,
0.0253929887,
-0.0200644843,
0.0414177626,
0.0198294092,
-0.0368853398,
-0.0787289441,
0.0152862798,
0.0591038093,
0.0038475459,
0.0338449292,
0.0110065071,
-0.0753611699,
-0.009047742,
0.024587268,
-0.0086071445,
-0.0433346257,
-0.0213205591,
0.0208928287,
0.0368203893,
-0.0267226286,
0.036602322,
0.0057030455,
-0.017294107,
-0.0186741147,
0.0493734144,
-0.0181085058,
0.0331953727,
-0.0396622457,
-0.0265184212,
-0.0629060492,
-0.0835921988,
-0.0445206352,
-0.0079144472,
-0.0186029635,
0.012596339,
0.0345636234,
-0.0043341587,
-0.0717091262,
0.0099710403,
-0.0256163739,
0.0160550307,
0.0270578247,
0.0201007649,
-0.016445851,
0.0006393153,
0.0118961409,
0.0678499416,
0.0639704242,
0.0434542373,
-0.0427549146,
-0.0131380679,
-0.0111649912,
0.0135115786,
0.0432175212,
0.0165508837,
-0.0030918848,
0.0137102129,
-0.0076037887,
-0.0547643006,
0.0007854134,
-0.0059186844,
2.938e-7,
0.0190666374,
0.0268793683,
0.001127527,
0.0103065874,
0.0099835647,
0.0504123941,
0.0028912465,
0.0314009003,
0.0369986109,
0.0320732221,
0.0095812418,
0.0401753597,
0.0120961061,
0.0091937445,
-0.0722479522,
-0.022453174,
-0.0488088503,
-0.0401083156,
-0.0807335973,
-0.0009962643,
0.0735341311,
0.0866914168,
0.0444293469,
-0.0014014784,
-0.0383093841,
-0.0584133491,
0.0713033006,
-0.015768541,
-0.0344853401,
0.0638973564,
-0.0003110344,
0.0479865335,
-0.0394774862,
0.0160361975,
-0.0042567574,
0.0496119708,
0.0127562871,
0.0891057625,
0.0046306034,
-0.0173542313,
0.0250555314,
0.0290745422,
0.0046234941,
-0.0512375422,
0.0892228857,
-0.0866584703,
0.0091670062,
0.006120827,
0.001105169,
-0.0179256983,
-0.0065054237,
-0.017768709,
-0.0357553177,
0.0404496044,
0.0232978687,
-0.0216194317,
-0.0693376884,
-0.0776660293,
-0.0046956236,
0.0310554374,
-0.0233396832,
-0.0365015864,
-0.0202877242,
-0.007022107,
-0.006705666,
-0.0534193777,
0.011470004,
2.8156219e-34,
-0.0231139492,
-0.0030898491,
-0.0323651209,
0.0423133597,
0.0249301773,
-0.016908342,
-0.0793790966,
0.0250378959,
-0.036631532,
-0.0171891991,
0.0190287251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06818v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06818v1 | Cricket Player Profiling: Unraveling Strengths and Weaknesses Using Text Commentary Data | 2023-11-12T11:51:05 | 2023-11-12T11:51:05 | Swarup Ranjan Behera, Vijaya V. Saradhi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, I.2.7 | Devising player-specific strategies in cricket necessitates a meticulous
understanding of each player's unique strengths and weaknesses. Nevertheless,
the absence of a definitive computational approach to extract such insights
from cricket players poses a significant challenge. This paper seeks to address
this gap by establishing computational models designed to extract the rules
governing player strengths and weaknesses, thereby facilitating the development
of tailored strategies for individual players. The complexity of this endeavor
lies in several key areas: the selection of a suitable dataset, the precise
definition of strength and weakness rules, the identification of an appropriate
learning algorithm, and the validation of the derived rules. To tackle these
challenges, we propose the utilization of unstructured data, specifically
cricket text commentary, as a valuable resource for constructing comprehensive
strength and weakness rules for cricket players. We also introduce
computationally feasible definitions for the construction of these rules, and
present a dimensionality reduction technique for the rule-building process. In
order to showcase the practicality of this approach, we conduct an in-depth
analysis of cricket player strengths and weaknesses using a vast corpus of more
than one million text commentaries. Furthermore, we validate the constructed
rules through two distinct methodologies: intrinsic and extrinsic. The outcomes
of this research are made openly accessible, including the collected data,
source code, and results for over 250 cricket players, which can be accessed at
https://bit.ly/2PKuzx8. | [
0.0024184515,
0.0238717031,
-0.027732227,
0.0365724862,
-0.0251456853,
-0.0177713428,
-0.0385339409,
0.0215514358,
-0.0361815803,
0.0214102529,
0.0661487356,
0.0022496274,
0.0154598802,
0.0556898713,
0.0435804464,
-0.0616069883,
-0.0235810075,
-0.0425490662,
0.0355732851,
0.0149686886,
0.0498600528,
-0.01016792,
-0.0340155885,
0.031398125,
-0.0106630046,
0.0079865586,
0.0112727573,
-0.0371735543,
-0.0126117291,
-0.0383159816,
-0.0161658525,
0.0054970738,
0.0196493492,
-0.0384317152,
0.0000018572,
-0.0557648651,
0.017816931,
-0.0623591095,
0.0082198363,
0.044175297,
0.0541574769,
0.0144099407,
0.0794249326,
-0.0085922927,
-0.0499965139,
0.044872947,
0.0251456406,
-0.0062705684,
0.0599412955,
0.0794231743,
-0.0193716586,
-0.0034879632,
-0.0211644117,
-0.0039731269,
-0.0294035468,
-0.0697375685,
0.0192441065,
0.0146466205,
0.0031631943,
0.0042722863,
-0.0251339301,
-0.0266188048,
-0.0149394637,
0.0424723923,
0.0355782323,
0.0174590778,
-0.020837808,
0.0214278195,
0.0303305294,
-0.0065751956,
-0.0087807253,
-0.0160035696,
0.0070702662,
-0.0241095759,
0.0071829357,
0.0239111204,
-0.016349053,
0.0041827853,
-0.0146514615,
-0.0307558794,
-0.0284600835,
0.0584541522,
0.0163624994,
0.0178161394,
-0.0087246913,
0.0023348024,
-0.0041262507,
-0.0318722539,
-0.0370198376,
0.0079347789,
0.029911058,
-0.0878634974,
-0.0095630595,
-0.0003110882,
-0.0173429344,
-0.0080723297,
0.0514439642,
-0.0677137896,
0.0105940597,
-0.0410090089,
0.0464918576,
0.0117356097,
0.0626189411,
-0.0212967638,
0.043389339,
-0.0223260894,
0.0019176434,
-0.0488914996,
-0.0034201394,
0.0620428436,
-0.0667856336,
-0.0439169109,
0.0648030639,
0.0538334809,
0.0298539177,
0.0077321781,
-0.0482385531,
0.0315229781,
-0.0018606214,
-0.0196083933,
0.0048336848,
0.0300691463,
0.054625608,
0.0165066384,
-0.0185260829,
-0.0316842943,
-0.0767201111,
0.0075131045,
0.0253571961,
-0.027146427,
-0.0024687836,
-0.0101112891,
0.0124965739,
-0.0134798549,
0.0414672941,
0.0392168872,
0.0317606814,
0.0282098986,
0.0058624968,
-0.0475444384,
-0.0319463424,
-0.0650267974,
-0.055885233,
-0.0874145031,
0.0291254837,
-0.0266053975,
-0.005263777,
-0.0091426596,
-0.0135151912,
0.0201945249,
-0.0172340944,
0.0511949807,
0.0235041752,
0.0575742871,
0.035310287,
0.0179089513,
0.0001815013,
-0.0064674881,
-0.0011230481,
-0.0171399638,
0.0202135183,
0.0113001568,
0.0279074982,
0.0412494056,
-0.0425422564,
-0.0019746718,
-0.0445803292,
0.0110538015,
-0.0306340065,
0.011833976,
-0.0354966968,
-0.0153931957,
-0.0234360136,
-0.0012610945,
0.0199568328,
0.0354153514,
0.0840956718,
0.0497427545,
0.0359158665,
0.0371311381,
0.0395334922,
-0.0061572408,
0.0183342993,
0.004465234,
0.0537541583,
0.0129051646,
-0.0088896649,
0.0155147985,
-0.0260129794,
-0.0400704667,
-0.0211293269,
-0.0033055895,
0.0311219543,
-0.0183916837,
0.0731409416,
-0.0346760489,
0.0630958304,
0.036402192,
0.0078536887,
-0.0440655388,
0.0085159671,
-0.0814885423,
0.0126548875,
0.0239377618,
0.0200796034,
-0.0703532621,
-0.0058966931,
0.0083987582,
0.0069953878,
-0.029627014,
-0.0125226546,
-0.0298546683,
0.0091075543,
-0.001103918,
0.0038028404,
0.0428885147,
0.0322524793,
0.0144402841,
-0.0588984638,
-0.0133383451,
-0.0146043086,
0.0203466415,
-0.0773821697,
0.0337094776,
-0.0070692743,
-0.0646665394,
0.0323403664,
-0.0167973284,
0.0315621607,
0.0568175875,
-0.0050257971,
0.0048445375,
0.029956907,
0.0112051722,
-0.0241316184,
0.0577160493,
0.0420851186,
0.0379393138,
0.0069736284,
-0.0712025687,
0.0450023338,
0.025392998,
-0.0002574465,
-0.0401100293,
0.000336934,
-0.0110098002,
0.0301102698,
-0.0037519024,
0.0140000191,
-0.0224029142,
0.0024161057,
0.0132839242,
0.0208099838,
0.0041425223,
0.0012814276,
-0.0205809567,
-0.0279964358,
0.0475245044,
-0.0597378202,
0.0298556611,
-0.0429234169,
-0.0372112244,
0.0268847197,
0.0752006024,
0.0555950738,
-0.0477211997,
-0.0144088184,
-0.0671366379,
-0.0156846736,
-0.005566305,
0.0433737002,
-0.0190980602,
0.0011631004,
-0.0346414447,
-0.0017196182,
0.0144495098,
-0.0621732846,
0.0141420905,
-0.0251803547,
0.0351709984,
0.0267732255,
-0.0074323863,
-0.0176971871,
0.0008158825,
-0.0325678848,
0.0598081648,
0.0104378993,
0.0030410949,
-0.0632037222,
0.0106790019,
-0.0388456695,
-0.027307298,
-0.0238018129,
-0.0048513617,
-0.0001098614,
-0.0143400673,
-0.0493645594,
0.0294714458,
0.0213078223,
0.0084297126,
0.0273196399,
-0.0955711007,
0.0268310253,
0.0283399001,
-0.0195966512,
0.0159803368,
-0.0451574288,
-0.0505007133,
0.0627005771,
0.015192057,
-0.0116009694,
0.0090680663,
-0.0157449394,
0.0436403714,
-0.0064648055,
0.0149044925,
-0.0402372293,
-0.017951116,
-0.0211898554,
0.0280944183,
0.0031360539,
0.0150630735,
0.0215534288,
0.0069471677,
0.0604491979,
-0.0670119822,
-0.0312040858,
-0.0008844054,
0.0031954774,
0.0197104122,
0.0417732261,
0.0103586921,
-0.0111003444,
0.0247096308,
0.0124068242,
0.0462002717,
0.0018770627,
-0.0316647515,
-0.0054759388,
-0.0048405123,
0.0343566537,
-0.0232826583,
-0.0059150048,
-0.0357681401,
-0.006223138,
-0.0159204882,
0.053539142,
-0.0445516072,
-0.0142260296,
-0.0229645688,
0.0263547953,
-0.0364873707,
-0.0109522371,
-0.047773134,
0.0895138308,
-0.0067949304,
-0.0212673247,
0.017892478,
0.0068554943,
-0.0560864955,
-0.0061362339,
0.019939648,
0.0000194483,
0.0321532786,
0.0249136891,
0.0039368202,
-0.0264277253,
-0.0194667261,
-0.021892352,
0.0490559675,
0.0268510804,
-0.0367505997,
-0.0217374023,
0.0797474533,
0.0587537959,
-0.0008010342,
0.0167154018,
-0.0259763263,
-0.0587100461,
0.0014935131,
0.0076578245,
-0.0559538305,
-0.0033547033,
-0.0339830332,
0.0521627367,
-0.0560238101,
-0.0323462747,
0.0018134019,
-0.0763151646,
-0.0040950286,
0.0160018429,
-0.0265341476,
-0.0512935221,
-0.025546886,
-0.0226559378,
-0.0541216806,
-0.0243713185,
0.0071026199,
-0.0173571091,
0.0291228779,
0.0260237195,
-0.0987902433,
-0.0175815076,
0.0379816927,
-0.0367735252,
0.0013964413,
0.0143987387,
0.0221783035,
-0.0383791141,
-0.0525567867,
-0.048918616,
0.0325161368,
0.0183929056,
-0.0058843824,
0.1036738232,
-0.0366569199,
0.0216974616,
-0.0538414195,
0.035439305,
0.0065442203,
0.0002424533,
0.0840085223,
0.036940977,
0.0464447699,
0.0140576875,
0.0301410109,
-0.003875056,
0.0690223426,
-0.0290203281,
0.0085051069,
-0.0602954216,
-0.0251950156,
-0.0181008,
0.0412650891,
-0.0619810969,
-0.120357804,
-0.0359679833,
0.0292681791,
-0.0081684785,
-0.0044034482,
-0.0631628931,
-0.0083647193,
0.0154763674,
0.0396988094,
0.0763781816,
-0.0672335327,
-0.0059104185,
-0.0559787452,
-0.036900986,
0.0247678552,
-0.0229923874,
0.0046692723,
0.006333895,
0.0944687054,
-0.0151273161,
-0.0164355505,
-0.0302898306,
-0.0101174153,
-0.0194542874,
0.0355007052,
0.0641086921,
0.0263310745,
-0.0264056381,
0.0005821756,
-0.053432636,
0.0220714509,
0.0088670561,
-0.0467726476,
0.0250048377,
0.0146299051,
0.0188136902,
-0.0349084064,
0.0268787798,
0.0114074368,
0.0211657006,
-0.0341282636,
-0.0421699695,
-0.0903416499,
0.0114001995,
-0.0132647483,
0.0209963452,
0.0572109967,
0.0027612352,
-0.0571697503,
0.0130831907,
-0.0141623653,
-0.0293978658,
-0.0159265436,
0.017883759,
-0.0152665591,
-0.0206708983,
0.0386089571,
-0.0271873996,
-0.0001368443,
-0.0543143041,
-0.0025634239,
-0.0892080367,
0.0787010416,
0.0673592687,
0.0284882467,
-0.0055856816,
0.0129507165,
0.0349377953,
-0.0455103554,
-0.004178707,
0.0360568948,
0.0278617572,
-0.0183145851,
0.0085676555,
0.0098072803,
0.0224407911,
-0.0002967258,
0.0205419622,
0.0531690381,
0.0076973913,
-0.0272340141,
0.0344652347,
-0.029567305,
0.0045917123,
-0.0213158689,
-0.0176424701,
-0.0196029209,
0.0290209409,
-0.0514007099,
0.0113649517,
-0.0036201677,
0.0203672051,
-0.0340754986,
0.0086591011,
0.0431409962,
0.0128722629,
0.0038609032,
0.0020582308,
-0.0784761086,
-0.0414353311,
-0.0072177853,
0.007826997,
0.0763504431,
-0.0027034578,
0.0005566466,
-0.1041429043,
0.0362374596,
0.0352967121,
-0.0426189639,
0.0594345704,
0.000931712,
0.0100429598,
0.034234181,
-0.0256802142,
0.051427938,
-0.0212307703,
0.0165711045,
-0.074543789,
-0.013888984,
0.0264520496,
-5.557148441e-33,
0.0324174725,
-0.0503258258,
0.020184122,
0.018437786,
-0.0312469546,
0.0120973429,
-0.0073002884,
-0.0299137812,
0.0119381128,
0.0193318632,
-0.0164114274,
0.0138372853,
-0.0011133194,
-0.0251165461,
0.0728680566,
-0.0424673595,
0.0288941413,
-0.0166912302,
-0.0101902755,
0.0010858681,
0.0598151833,
0.0176098291,
0.0073883524,
-0.0884866267,
0.006535464,
-0.0539097674,
-0.0636756197,
0.0229620934,
0.0149010159,
0.0043995725,
0.0187849924,
-0.01985991,
0.0526067875,
-0.0210801028,
0.0070583397,
0.0507540368,
-0.007245054,
-0.0261912923,
-0.0642139539,
0.0078661917,
0.0447001047,
-0.0069328803,
0.0605235063,
-0.0100901192,
-0.0253977031,
-0.0557347722,
0.059084814,
-0.0084120054,
0.0274889432,
-0.0293468256,
-0.0040652133,
0.0526594371,
-0.0282121673,
0.0145270564,
0.0188601315,
-0.0050421585,
-0.007426593,
-0.0221531186,
-0.0289420877,
0.0385369509,
0.0370082781,
0.0522788838,
0.0252754278,
0.0545455143,
-0.0186230987,
0.0115580903,
0.0218626615,
-0.0389590561,
0.0068940884,
-0.0392423309,
-0.0241958201,
0.0403226279,
-0.0187058207,
0.0257192571,
0.0750189871,
-0.0206052139,
-0.1001843289,
0.0536590293,
0.0410848781,
0.0401713625,
-0.042666845,
0.0079105953,
-0.072082378,
0.0011972976,
0.0423594229,
-0.0034924068,
-0.0051869024,
-0.0615054332,
0.0071096029,
-0.0364158638,
-0.0527051091,
-0.0010386545,
0.0055809091,
0.0413827337,
0.0199910719,
0.0090324329,
-0.0493368357,
0.0968516096,
-0.0163762532,
-0.0706202015,
-0.0525903665,
-0.0338137597,
-0.0213112086,
0.0310415234,
0.0358948223,
-0.0400446653,
0.0145765208,
0.0440202691,
-0.0506160222,
-0.0409310423,
0.045362927,
-0.0225527734,
-0.0233081356,
0.0399784893,
0.0072640735,
0.0446145125,
0.0038119731,
-0.0082872538,
-0.0010467162,
-0.0443243384,
-0.0242628511,
-0.0032646968,
0.0038335477,
-0.0333182402,
0.0169286095,
0.007846362,
0.0383263864,
0.0171952769,
0.0253492519,
0.0069309524,
-0.0544071533,
-0.042340219,
2.663e-7,
0.0569310375,
0.072496891,
-0.0256097075,
-0.0604926236,
-0.030710984,
0.0465730503,
-0.0702321753,
0.0534638427,
-0.037096031,
0.0552620254,
0.0963963196,
0.028198041,
0.0106662232,
0.0595806651,
-0.0575936548,
-0.030699946,
-0.0306644309,
-0.0060169236,
-0.0197093654,
-0.0238481052,
0.0334052183,
0.001369542,
0.0196871776,
0.0006344072,
0.0053782603,
-0.0413857177,
0.0257003568,
0.0132858986,
0.0064219404,
0.009564423,
0.0063518086,
-0.006689488,
-0.0395677052,
0.020320937,
-0.0290217362,
0.0649157017,
0.0045761396,
0.0471012704,
-0.0235653184,
0.025855599,
-0.0120557752,
0.0024260208,
-0.0187920108,
0.0576953702,
0.0056219497,
0.0135160508,
-0.0481853634,
-0.019328149,
-0.046270173,
-0.0185577851,
0.0371155106,
-0.010811138,
-0.0034331609,
0.0260674115,
-0.0503530391,
-0.0069043213,
0.0141947446,
-0.0395341069,
-0.0279119797,
0.0233012699,
-0.0238521136,
-0.030349724,
0.0209739674,
0.0434586667,
-0.0190626364,
-0.0751667097,
0.0538088046,
2.155172695e-34,
-0.0137321614,
0.0546343885,
-0.0470306315,
-0.0388989486,
0.0079497602,
0.0050722063,
-0.000506365,
0.0666949227,
0.0678106472,
-0.03781588,
0.0259985402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06815v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06815v1 | Evaluation of GPT-4 for chest X-ray impression generation: A reader study on performance and perception | 2023-11-12T11:40:57 | 2023-11-12T11:40:57 | Sebastian Ziegelmayer, Alexander W. Marka, Nicolas Lenhart, Nadja Nehls, Stefan Reischl, Felix Harder, Andreas Sauter, Marcus Makowski, Markus Graf, Joshua Gawlitza | cs.CL | cs.CL | The remarkable generative capabilities of multimodal foundation models are
currently being explored for a variety of applications. Generating radiological
impressions is a challenging task that could significantly reduce the workload
of radiologists. In our study we explored and analyzed the generative abilities
of GPT-4 for Chest X-ray impression generation. To generate and evaluate
impressions of chest X-rays based on different input modalities (image, text,
text and image), a blinded radiological report was written for 25-cases of the
publicly available NIH-dataset. GPT-4 was given image, finding section or both
sequentially to generate an input dependent impression. In a blind randomized
reading, 4-radiologists rated the impressions and were asked to classify the
impression origin (Human, AI), providing justification for their decision.
Lastly text model evaluation metrics and their correlation with the
radiological score (summation of the 4 dimensions) was assessed. According to
the radiological score, the human-written impression was rated highest,
although not significantly different to text-based impressions. The automated
evaluation metrics showed moderate to substantial correlations to the
radiological score for the image impressions, however individual scores were
highly divergent among inputs, indicating insufficient representation of
radiological quality. Detection of AI-generated impressions varied by input and
was 61% for text-based impressions. Impressions classified as AI-generated had
significantly worse radiological scores even when written by a radiologist,
indicating potential bias. Our study revealed significant discrepancies between
a radiological assessment and common automatic evaluation metrics depending on
the model input. The detection of AI-generated findings is subject to bias that
highly rated impressions are perceived as human-written. | [
0.0221851766,
0.0422763377,
-0.0123596527,
-0.0112778731,
-0.0382161662,
0.0134715186,
0.035048116,
0.0268002059,
-0.0277332719,
-0.0065776375,
-0.0437859558,
-0.0601998344,
0.0467561334,
0.0172446202,
0.0321064629,
-0.0919695646,
-0.0269599464,
0.0293227434,
0.015631998,
0.0012665592,
-0.0085882116,
0.0031797141,
-0.0286739022,
0.0229702275,
-0.0495573282,
-0.0299321674,
0.0296003707,
0.0264288429,
0.0209162794,
-0.0325221345,
-0.0547878891,
0.0591185689,
-0.0286468025,
-0.0028207609,
0.0000021828,
-0.0296910722,
-0.0081046131,
0.0242294427,
0.0370210446,
-0.0076162084,
0.1421320587,
-0.0076531754,
-0.0237153247,
-0.0304385331,
-0.0485667065,
-0.0324600339,
0.0604356341,
0.0477183498,
0.0596982464,
0.0325043648,
-0.0272292923,
-0.0033466234,
-0.0074866689,
-0.0016781078,
0.0051477966,
-0.0017940319,
-0.0283031482,
0.0092258761,
-0.0011290772,
0.0335954204,
-0.0042524026,
0.023882525,
0.0036908041,
0.0287033822,
0.0371882841,
0.0686353371,
0.0151995448,
-0.020637285,
-0.0283309557,
0.0500929877,
0.0071882578,
0.017215224,
-0.0344702825,
-0.0396300778,
-0.0013502471,
0.0241196081,
-0.0142050833,
0.022761628,
-0.0189188439,
-0.0035261074,
-0.063432768,
0.0170658883,
0.0026751233,
-0.0128023606,
0.009997664,
-0.0282110963,
0.0202377215,
-0.016527202,
0.026721159,
0.0163286887,
-0.0001141016,
-0.0416248068,
0.0182993282,
0.0140711386,
-0.0108734732,
0.0200634915,
-0.0166621767,
-0.0097793117,
0.0591877028,
-0.0245981291,
0.00311046,
-0.0027421596,
-0.054204192,
0.0451599061,
-0.0045787152,
0.0626479834,
-0.0431794152,
0.0445439853,
-0.0502405576,
0.0566256233,
-0.0334816612,
-0.0228470545,
-0.0066004451,
-0.017915247,
0.0212153438,
-0.0309656058,
-0.1044531316,
-0.0653724074,
-0.0074370373,
-0.005081878,
0.0444136895,
0.0753733441,
-0.0573763065,
0.0536048114,
-0.0354119353,
0.0191713534,
0.0021662042,
-0.0027337079,
-0.0263135452,
-0.0118272398,
0.0323101021,
0.0529868044,
-0.0001650549,
0.0110963574,
-0.0063261837,
0.00662807,
-0.0200549569,
-0.02827668,
0.0178222004,
-0.0494505949,
-0.0188444406,
-0.0544962473,
0.0499504842,
-0.0375032239,
0.0178380385,
-0.0015831548,
0.0100744879,
0.0023032713,
-0.0055660247,
0.008497077,
0.0195589103,
0.0396385305,
-0.0286392439,
0.0042329226,
0.0251602679,
0.0407221839,
-0.0090218838,
-0.0260089058,
0.0080205761,
0.0627844483,
-0.0152841043,
-0.0258609615,
0.0205297284,
0.0043508294,
-0.0257439762,
-0.0343908332,
-0.0148878936,
-0.0249973498,
-0.0355430916,
0.0860914588,
0.0176401678,
0.075119257,
-0.0136582898,
0.016651744,
0.060196761,
0.0243048426,
0.0351919346,
0.0281635839,
0.047234077,
-0.003005222,
0.0160921719,
0.035875719,
-0.007967677,
0.0187380519,
0.0257287677,
-0.0081343073,
-0.0316110663,
0.0222561471,
-0.0034705335,
-0.0178024825,
-0.0187105015,
-0.0198988151,
0.0264198594,
-0.0312558524,
0.0315335132,
-0.0063828002,
-0.0722740591,
-0.0468071327,
-0.0022264719,
-0.0259546135,
-0.0315118767,
-0.069306083,
-0.0106851142,
0.0997428671,
0.0543091446,
0.0226023812,
0.0204701982,
0.0054962295,
-0.014769664,
0.0405835286,
0.031654451,
0.0090283304,
0.0040581259,
-0.0395912044,
-0.0383948237,
-0.0042243716,
0.0233578626,
0.0351487584,
-0.0200868677,
0.0383585766,
0.0026008047,
-0.0271370672,
-0.0060204887,
0.0163544137,
-0.0180654861,
-0.019454198,
-0.0255601965,
0.0067709652,
0.0305531938,
0.0406553745,
-0.0354577191,
0.0160634983,
0.0066117779,
0.0581563897,
-0.028692577,
0.0298184082,
-0.0334049165,
0.037003044,
-0.003025284,
-0.0726926401,
0.0214229133,
-0.0056840242,
0.0021491146,
-0.0252647419,
-0.0302101448,
-0.0803708732,
0.0203046799,
-0.0318521,
0.0153722679,
0.0359172486,
0.0048856717,
0.0138187623,
0.0656201616,
-0.014716086,
-0.0073391008,
0.0312249288,
0.0219305865,
-0.01788776,
-0.0417699888,
-0.0253888462,
-0.0248972531,
0.0270420201,
0.0321148224,
-0.0119613679,
0.0379672311,
-0.0473162234,
0.0139963413,
-0.0803050324,
-0.0372028276,
0.0287576187,
-0.0458025448,
0.0360836163,
-0.0528531186,
-0.001159455,
0.0149468547,
-0.026767822,
-0.0232382119,
0.0306125488,
0.0087372698,
0.030161906,
0.0031829597,
0.0219593532,
-0.0421007723,
0.000637393,
-0.0145352827,
0.0150692379,
0.0851766989,
-0.0285431761,
-0.0258336961,
0.0475520343,
-0.0373465493,
-0.0140182478,
0.0080094766,
-0.0626320392,
0.0408826098,
-0.0149528962,
-0.0321185589,
0.0573555976,
0.0138159506,
0.0239133798,
0.0069059194,
-0.0092960186,
0.0147516299,
-0.0196384341,
-0.0052428655,
0.0284328181,
0.0719907954,
-0.0951006636,
-0.0318291225,
-0.0036512013,
0.062495783,
0.0461491272,
-0.0327353477,
0.0277461,
-0.0082502486,
-0.035372071,
0.0068095056,
0.0092564765,
-0.0233470574,
0.0598289184,
-0.0085038152,
-0.0543470308,
0.0525519848,
-0.0222822167,
0.0188781172,
-0.0478028692,
0.043585293,
0.0235139206,
0.029125154,
0.0189056713,
0.0534776747,
0.0458133295,
-0.0014486278,
-0.0418722667,
-0.0022354561,
0.0438887253,
-0.0709699392,
-0.0697001666,
-0.0125203244,
-0.031817738,
0.0163944177,
0.0107097737,
-0.0035467106,
-0.0010658491,
0.0241840128,
-0.018382581,
0.023106955,
0.0161862038,
-0.0207756869,
0.0417283922,
0.012745209,
-0.0098478254,
-0.0257776808,
0.0088444036,
0.008203472,
0.0486475043,
0.0071642613,
0.0082352133,
-0.01889305,
-0.0459814705,
-0.0407156721,
0.0436814502,
-0.0669661388,
0.0265344121,
-0.0779306963,
-0.0065166359,
-0.0180354826,
0.0498007238,
-0.0254024882,
-0.0027613025,
0.0438056886,
-0.0124257337,
0.0308648869,
0.0613433942,
0.0241857097,
-0.0244658217,
-0.0193662159,
0.0357057154,
-0.074181065,
-0.0249228999,
-0.0251229741,
-0.0140246311,
0.0042404383,
-0.0245998558,
0.0506616347,
-0.0483704247,
-0.0111549785,
0.0089548472,
-0.0501614623,
0.0826684758,
0.0050084447,
-0.0482830554,
-0.0063695149,
-0.0242676139,
0.020556204,
0.0088072596,
-0.0383119956,
-0.0007025349,
0.0187375136,
0.0092304815,
-0.0124375941,
0.0049728998,
-0.0600377955,
0.0215327162,
-0.017663423,
-0.0256950669,
0.0610489808,
0.0672788173,
-0.0150836939,
-0.0834808424,
-0.0531340986,
0.0559018329,
0.0527341627,
0.0054393373,
0.0906704962,
0.0132011948,
0.0268756319,
-0.0777448863,
0.0229885243,
0.0415082239,
0.0225942396,
-0.0329464078,
0.0100185797,
-0.0218224786,
-0.0167137738,
-0.0753438175,
0.0519229546,
0.0299023297,
0.0047056689,
0.0165911969,
-0.0022117279,
-0.0477920584,
0.0149028599,
0.1405208111,
-0.0418268181,
-0.0349037759,
0.0319535211,
-0.0408090726,
-0.0421240889,
-0.0800130293,
-0.0516856052,
-0.0300315656,
0.036637146,
0.0017040203,
-0.0053219162,
-0.0368037596,
0.0126030287,
-0.0556097291,
0.0344119184,
0.0328074694,
0.0033384818,
0.0114864307,
-0.0414806902,
0.0506237037,
-0.0505928956,
-0.0046280487,
0.0573664308,
0.0104057807,
0.0321334638,
0.0054433579,
0.075074777,
0.0316080488,
-0.0684392303,
0.0149677088,
-0.012700309,
0.0828824788,
0.0037294938,
-0.02739935,
0.0080240509,
-0.0145628918,
-0.0218254104,
-0.0244068075,
-0.0252105631,
0.0194372237,
0.0332566686,
-0.0092665143,
-0.0098645473,
-0.0013540579,
-0.0417008922,
0.0059533017,
0.0314951316,
0.0107489582,
-0.0781500265,
0.0145831015,
0.0028848576,
-0.0320253186,
-0.0579593182,
0.0015928214,
-0.0079959426,
-0.0142154871,
0.0252529681,
0.006611336,
-0.0185303353,
-0.0398833454,
-0.0780402869,
0.0177695677,
-0.0554072224,
0.0144442944,
0.0326492973,
-0.0136863487,
0.0233606696,
-0.0201638807,
-0.0062881862,
-0.0616157651,
-0.0256559718,
0.0110722035,
0.0389231145,
0.0734764785,
-0.0012378278,
0.0008103102,
-0.0010802712,
0.0497474894,
0.0033293273,
-0.0115958042,
-0.0795147642,
0.028214775,
0.0261332914,
0.0229399949,
0.0238881204,
-0.0349891894,
0.0079496028,
-0.0116266152,
0.0448407978,
0.0077191698,
0.0080095213,
0.0224752519,
-0.0232178494,
0.0348692723,
-0.0400766954,
0.0557555519,
-0.032558918,
0.0028745534,
-0.0520509444,
-0.0818703175,
-0.0655883327,
-0.0204966944,
0.009679568,
0.0018910259,
-0.0075692837,
0.0041030431,
-0.0765165463,
-0.0340686515,
0.0011208376,
0.0103238365,
0.0169523861,
-0.0438105129,
0.0591780208,
0.0645851791,
-0.0404890142,
-0.0250847451,
-0.0021447947,
0.0353484303,
-0.028677674,
0.0091212243,
0.0188501105,
-5.741064818e-33,
-0.0050717774,
-0.0418197885,
0.0173968952,
-0.0368686542,
-0.0210851654,
0.0267479625,
-0.0248489454,
0.0145261604,
0.0314722434,
-0.0002091816,
-0.0101476377,
-0.0397370048,
0.0184141435,
0.0179206599,
-0.0132910404,
0.0362257697,
0.0288114678,
-0.048209466,
-0.0468960404,
0.0240854714,
-0.0264911,
-0.0043928074,
0.0535011701,
-0.1050795317,
-0.0108601283,
-0.0203417931,
-0.0439674929,
-0.0670823157,
0.0053814645,
0.0224006902,
-0.0246772896,
0.0196143612,
0.0283387508,
-0.0581576824,
0.0142050525,
0.0229580719,
0.000486862,
0.000343982,
0.032679759,
0.0036221088,
-0.0611541085,
0.0051867096,
0.0156691503,
-0.0438446328,
-0.0182138756,
-0.0053597693,
0.057395868,
-0.0309865512,
0.0439804159,
-0.0052501992,
-0.0359548219,
0.0248103067,
0.0196756758,
-0.0382523835,
-0.012242957,
-0.0029119791,
-0.0192436818,
0.0648382902,
-0.0316918306,
0.0242893994,
0.0658422485,
-0.022206882,
0.0198176429,
-0.0137179447,
0.0036033706,
0.0216835681,
0.0999764204,
-0.0300790779,
-0.0155788539,
-0.0085959462,
-0.01348643,
0.0490969718,
0.0512076356,
0.0851564705,
0.0349318534,
-0.0175582413,
-0.0042711413,
0.0485493802,
-0.0348178335,
0.033594504,
0.0159877874,
-0.025639575,
-0.0407402255,
0.0067819711,
0.0210968554,
-0.0827511922,
-0.0210362077,
-0.0446617566,
0.0241691992,
0.0001727199,
-0.0162548348,
0.0193672311,
0.0189732835,
0.0314413533,
0.0403502285,
-0.042012766,
-0.0311448649,
0.0722003803,
-0.0426110141,
-0.0396128111,
0.0086417375,
-0.0026091274,
0.0583981313,
0.0624684989,
0.0494293459,
-0.0009933126,
-0.0186827257,
0.0090750884,
-0.0235118233,
0.0083024176,
0.0116840424,
-0.0160183907,
-0.0277366601,
-0.0126935281,
0.040760763,
-0.0122611634,
-0.0239160731,
-0.0006242779,
-0.0147150764,
0.0639733747,
-0.0503376462,
-0.0718374252,
-0.0152026182,
-0.0214727856,
-0.0476368554,
0.0007470223,
0.0077844467,
-0.0643201023,
0.0275116526,
-0.0440295711,
-0.0315435864,
0.0102359541,
2.788e-7,
0.0227607377,
0.04355992,
0.0043555107,
0.0045666052,
0.0290042423,
0.0153258061,
-0.0289104395,
0.0136520378,
0.0360581987,
-0.0564738773,
0.0323975496,
8.506e-7,
-0.0089014145,
0.0398984514,
-0.0271739122,
0.0020222804,
0.0001441587,
0.0119561339,
-0.0007756348,
0.0371320955,
0.0985079333,
0.0034337526,
-0.037753731,
-0.0791435614,
0.0042395201,
0.0056762174,
0.0512152463,
-0.0155879036,
0.0397960283,
-0.0223531239,
0.0363161452,
0.0089473194,
-0.0065712361,
0.0620549992,
0.0106460741,
-0.0414520241,
0.0666752011,
0.0408775248,
-0.0461161882,
0.0011570553,
0.0567114055,
0.0198409632,
0.0079949116,
-0.0611827597,
0.0294623598,
-0.0022224456,
-0.0255575087,
-0.0022160704,
-0.0707540289,
0.0085809911,
0.0587732345,
-0.0633115023,
-0.0451681204,
0.017972799,
0.0142325684,
0.0253512226,
-0.03345621,
-0.0306060333,
0.0024480631,
-0.0056575909,
-0.0241584722,
-0.0453753136,
0.0310569499,
-0.046070978,
-0.0035761911,
-0.1136110872,
-0.0242659133,
2.177387242e-34,
0.0327838771,
0.0008917986,
0.0270225573,
-0.059392307,
0.0159431957,
0.026075026,
-0.0068993494,
-0.0069055408,
0.0302794445,
-0.0144891841,
-0.0168865547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06807v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06807v1 | On the Robustness of Question Rewriting Systems to Questions of Varying Hardness | 2023-11-12T11:09:30 | 2023-11-12T11:09:30 | Hai Ye, Hwee Tou Ng, Wenjuan Han | cs.CL | cs.CL | In conversational question answering (CQA), the task of question
rewriting~(QR) in context aims to rewrite a context-dependent question into an
equivalent self-contained question that gives the same answer. In this paper,
we are interested in the robustness of a QR system to questions varying in
rewriting hardness or difficulty. Since there is a lack of questions classified
based on their rewriting hardness, we first propose a heuristic method to
automatically classify questions into subsets of varying hardness, by measuring
the discrepancy between a question and its rewrite. To find out what makes
questions hard or easy for rewriting, we then conduct a human evaluation to
annotate the rewriting hardness of questions. Finally, to enhance the
robustness of QR systems to questions of varying hardness, we propose a novel
learning framework for QR that first trains a QR model independently on each
subset of questions of a certain level of hardness, then combines these QR
models as one joint model for inference. Experimental results on two datasets
show that our framework improves the overall performance compared to the
baselines. | [
0.0378937833,
0.0278427266,
-0.0222579371,
0.0263815224,
-0.0472900271,
0.0312693976,
0.0055975243,
-0.0063778935,
0.0052857175,
-0.0387530327,
-0.0028694547,
0.0104489168,
-0.0069994652,
-0.009504511,
0.0354814641,
-0.0679060668,
0.0198061336,
0.000866827,
-0.0204977989,
-0.0112686791,
0.0169137139,
-0.0090289861,
0.0079002315,
0.0273919441,
-0.0041635931,
-0.0004676503,
-0.0169633105,
0.0375238061,
0.0021046426,
0.0173583124,
0.0636061281,
0.0791430026,
0.0123636806,
0.043989893,
0.0000017416,
-0.0932950974,
-0.0667879954,
0.0101256231,
-0.0563670322,
-0.0228762049,
-0.0036269994,
-0.0045941174,
0.0389106497,
0.0487357937,
-0.0408142656,
0.0209779143,
0.0326604173,
0.0281781033,
0.0892799497,
0.0583269931,
-0.0009313487,
-0.0299546886,
0.0029930379,
-0.0188699123,
0.0440600142,
-0.0717066005,
0.0086598312,
0.059130419,
-0.010825118,
0.0146227488,
-0.0304390509,
0.0148726916,
0.0570758283,
0.0072591845,
-0.0119257029,
-0.0192738548,
-0.0448313504,
0.0311949346,
0.011742224,
0.1076757684,
-0.034423504,
-0.0297563914,
-0.0026826989,
0.0071710316,
0.0482330471,
0.0186095145,
-0.0287448689,
0.0008967167,
-0.0244459081,
-0.0324443355,
-0.0381118171,
0.0448013879,
-0.0080796471,
-0.0102960803,
-0.0146248294,
-0.0010566567,
0.0163379032,
-0.0363802239,
-0.0015664409,
-0.0001200794,
-0.0221821368,
-0.0564180948,
0.0111291334,
0.0581079498,
-0.0593417771,
0.0207892973,
-0.0596687235,
0.0054161935,
0.0354278907,
-0.0189974401,
-0.0035491965,
0.0246986933,
-0.0044383272,
0.0655327588,
-0.0304583684,
0.0744681656,
-0.0008530508,
-0.0202919785,
-0.0619982183,
-0.0125559941,
-0.0374564826,
-0.0008215848,
-0.060364645,
0.0586356744,
-0.0390362702,
0.0173993446,
-0.0738402456,
0.0551299453,
0.0084039243,
-0.0047997986,
-0.0102917133,
0.0224584956,
-0.0472782291,
-0.026015481,
-0.0242836773,
0.0245528836,
-0.055453565,
0.0368186571,
0.0090214014,
-0.0414087139,
-0.0014740378,
0.0016513524,
0.0551976785,
-0.0243675299,
-0.0083316136,
0.0552605018,
-0.0319344141,
-0.0293370783,
-0.0088729085,
-0.0421946757,
-0.0107075945,
-0.0136292921,
-0.0459707864,
-0.0583374314,
0.0518399924,
-0.0003314358,
-0.0305482112,
-0.0199299883,
-0.0148514695,
0.0373888388,
0.0311990362,
0.0912404656,
0.0421965979,
-0.00565363,
0.0776051581,
0.0268805176,
-0.0560958944,
0.0252604038,
0.0077947117,
0.0007060948,
0.0670242831,
-0.0094596772,
0.0763796568,
-0.0153509472,
0.0066619427,
0.0116015812,
0.0166029315,
0.0572166555,
0.0105807148,
0.0282985419,
0.0009403157,
0.0556484722,
-0.026419105,
-0.060372185,
0.0569951124,
0.0162991788,
0.0211312436,
0.0223754626,
0.0428240784,
0.0124122472,
0.0022665868,
0.074984394,
-0.0568434224,
0.0192685593,
-0.0221463479,
0.0203908738,
0.0088605192,
0.0047753532,
-0.0395408124,
-0.0785558894,
0.0352732129,
0.009301791,
0.0296457354,
0.013330726,
-0.0050753551,
0.0404156111,
-0.0454625562,
-0.0174598396,
-0.0014425337,
-0.0500012897,
0.010345839,
-0.0599298738,
0.0468734205,
0.0053711645,
0.0301100463,
-0.0517226346,
-0.0315864235,
-0.0302158315,
0.016826706,
-0.0098038996,
0.0407946631,
-0.031027589,
0.0467707403,
-0.040925201,
-0.0005438172,
-0.0296524037,
0.0176859107,
0.013916973,
0.0611191653,
-0.0164106302,
0.0266877934,
-0.0427123606,
0.0178593136,
0.0275770184,
-0.0045263856,
-0.0442689173,
0.0339954421,
0.0199849531,
0.0082897292,
-0.024048999,
0.0210722387,
0.0104096103,
0.0172878634,
-0.0480960272,
-0.0463227518,
0.013183441,
-0.0280642565,
-0.090361841,
0.0036647024,
-0.0420218557,
-0.0244145039,
0.037209738,
-0.0598198771,
-0.0389510095,
0.0045935512,
-0.0483123548,
0.0000131907,
-0.0409657657,
-0.0091139879,
0.0077857082,
-0.0020751492,
-0.0938549638,
0.0700411275,
0.0188516974,
0.0166230612,
-0.0064018602,
-0.0342921466,
-0.0111043863,
-0.0647736639,
-0.0160182156,
-0.0583303906,
-0.0342857726,
0.0199474823,
0.0428961366,
0.003269966,
-0.0645090938,
-0.0221253131,
-0.0904674083,
-0.0005594714,
-0.0238244887,
0.0135816103,
0.0601292141,
0.0293606017,
-0.0032794068,
-0.0394405089,
-0.0661992878,
-0.0189699121,
-0.0011206445,
0.0211323872,
0.0716765448,
0.0263465606,
-0.0091492329,
-0.0287453383,
-0.0213606302,
0.0039445879,
0.0197443124,
0.0010906527,
0.051204823,
-0.059212774,
0.000726325,
-0.0440655351,
0.0030029309,
0.0055574789,
0.0036162876,
-0.0092378343,
0.015613772,
0.0632865056,
0.0775815994,
0.0053977752,
0.0183707997,
-0.0074771042,
0.0011897417,
-0.0241369512,
0.037251845,
-0.0466096215,
-0.0383127369,
0.0086732199,
-0.081730105,
0.0380696282,
0.0344043933,
0.0170900021,
-0.0096977018,
-0.0148118874,
0.0374860726,
-0.0174061935,
0.0020099154,
-0.0751792341,
0.0130548747,
0.0007890465,
0.0462069064,
-0.014001728,
-0.0324560478,
0.0891483724,
0.0165341049,
-0.0011924912,
-0.0497992374,
-0.0273678582,
-0.0597726777,
0.0653399006,
-0.0203319639,
0.0249549448,
0.0169194136,
-0.0229166597,
-0.0884386003,
-0.0369791538,
0.0312950686,
-0.0411958359,
0.0334305689,
-0.0631773621,
-0.0196132716,
-0.0122977365,
-0.0704545602,
-0.036985524,
-0.0375604145,
0.0142497113,
0.0040060352,
-0.0143945254,
-0.0020860429,
0.0126597323,
0.0117648644,
0.0196839441,
0.0616132244,
-0.0349341519,
-0.0119623281,
-0.0141219459,
0.1236681938,
0.0589558259,
0.0706573576,
0.0255742297,
-0.0128093632,
0.0664644763,
0.0365639366,
0.028717991,
0.0029406964,
0.0164689627,
-0.0059140306,
-0.0107059684,
-0.049112834,
0.0094277142,
0.0228462033,
0.0552813113,
-0.0626762509,
-0.0375667959,
0.0772035718,
0.0386755317,
0.0010651579,
-0.0028684915,
-0.0367787294,
0.0261714924,
0.0412813798,
0.0466309264,
-0.0589534864,
-0.0458933711,
-0.0066143586,
0.0232078526,
-0.0270713605,
-0.0266086981,
0.027648855,
-0.0735732019,
0.0366385318,
-0.0378944315,
-0.0657016635,
-0.0151338223,
-0.0369904116,
0.0008493726,
-0.0083430456,
0.0264594238,
0.0140017169,
0.0019848051,
-0.0063060103,
0.0090229446,
-0.0124760605,
-0.0129764359,
0.0134324636,
-0.0216613282,
0.0195669774,
0.0369647704,
0.0008467475,
-0.0140117686,
0.0168155599,
0.0372073017,
-0.0579533167,
-0.0267374851,
0.0051645967,
0.009706513,
0.028176995,
0.0037042068,
-0.0313913487,
0.0388353057,
0.0163046643,
0.0131866811,
0.0391556732,
0.0285039861,
0.0031563123,
-0.0117943306,
0.0143636651,
-0.0141150812,
-0.0000233433,
0.0842538103,
0.0575910173,
-0.0274568871,
-0.0380558483,
-0.0401676185,
0.0070006577,
-0.070541136,
-0.0211042464,
0.0112637384,
0.0076659149,
0.0411827266,
-0.0987715274,
-0.0490438938,
0.0309093017,
0.0199361108,
-0.0267063398,
0.007425298,
0.0325063244,
0.0143360822,
-0.0612812229,
-0.0175333228,
-0.0351472348,
0.0038226221,
-0.0420505777,
-0.0036839743,
-0.0027702188,
-0.0435027406,
-0.0214157067,
0.0162451752,
-0.0738038346,
-0.0281123295,
-0.0224742647,
0.054400146,
0.0298162811,
0.0084551219,
-0.0127051286,
-0.0442897566,
0.0164427366,
-0.0165389087,
-0.0243338775,
0.0127674704,
0.0284326859,
0.0477749482,
-0.0048805499,
0.0455540791,
-0.0518617108,
-0.0041947956,
0.0059343544,
0.0367011093,
-0.0620993935,
-0.0389894731,
0.0529518835,
-0.0182124823,
-0.0644765347,
0.0288581103,
-0.0165875163,
0.0037832323,
0.0681161731,
-0.0002216889,
-0.0243112966,
-0.0323281623,
0.0285372175,
0.0277153589,
0.0137069561,
0.0159861911,
-0.0162065905,
-0.0157370362,
0.0257543568,
-0.0603853986,
-0.0173361562,
0.0166585092,
0.0042364397,
0.0120077021,
-0.0024255244,
-0.0204577167,
0.0287105534,
0.009107288,
0.0637606978,
0.0242875516,
0.0530400239,
0.0241670329,
-0.0045864801,
-0.045319058,
0.0148751484,
-0.0671836287,
-0.0189404693,
-0.0022883054,
0.041954603,
-0.0022454192,
0.0365875065,
-0.0177598838,
0.0010349002,
-0.0283722561,
-0.0145425238,
0.0208240002,
0.0149449259,
-0.0044812299,
0.0648455247,
0.0347859897,
-0.0041992092,
0.0281145312,
0.0894435123,
0.0123099945,
0.0467601679,
0.0188039318,
-0.0112819187,
-0.0674959645,
-0.0351644829,
0.0271697901,
0.0320530571,
-0.0047912141,
0.0124268634,
-0.0308514815,
-0.0699573979,
0.0336379334,
-0.0009814756,
0.0222399663,
-0.0093020434,
0.0222841483,
0.0555887446,
0.003160709,
-0.0444064103,
-0.026934348,
0.0520695522,
-0.0333735719,
-0.0502826162,
-0.0074047656,
-5.961423724e-33,
-0.0015116044,
-0.017541863,
0.0036814713,
-0.0546075404,
0.0277581289,
0.0283718053,
-0.0485549979,
0.0069775539,
-0.0350087099,
0.0039781351,
-0.0086123412,
-0.007474279,
0.0008146543,
0.0337812342,
-0.0348162875,
-0.0520120263,
0.0333490819,
0.0177885164,
-0.0382508934,
0.0120365759,
-0.0063332622,
-0.0055145705,
-0.0030017723,
-0.0146627109,
-0.0008897641,
-0.0533494465,
-0.0312324632,
0.0722642541,
-0.0121186227,
0.0632953942,
-0.0123202978,
0.0005193596,
0.0481873304,
-0.0475008897,
0.0240383949,
0.038837675,
-0.0916417539,
-0.0068081743,
0.0031341817,
-0.0090412349,
-0.0746147484,
-0.0219039153,
0.0410433747,
-0.0193028152,
0.0557852983,
-0.0254692975,
0.0138835572,
-0.0055543589,
0.0151063474,
-0.0141450586,
-0.0253706742,
0.0020703368,
-0.0207217764,
-0.0631882027,
-0.0729522854,
0.0542422496,
-0.0042349966,
0.0186217576,
-0.021617813,
-0.0379635878,
-0.030412931,
0.034019839,
-0.0139787532,
0.011498698,
-0.035155423,
-0.0093016839,
0.0060976455,
0.0004885618,
0.0017587877,
-0.0408416353,
-0.0178989731,
0.0370108448,
0.0747124478,
0.0848013982,
0.0488288663,
0.030941451,
-0.0617616065,
0.0677687451,
0.0224689189,
-0.0026472714,
-0.0009534594,
0.0042670979,
-0.0452912524,
-0.0185394529,
-0.0492045432,
0.0415810309,
-0.0518480539,
0.0035658986,
0.0539138205,
0.0323164538,
-0.0299901757,
0.0177051798,
0.0302545559,
-0.0230332222,
0.006152391,
0.0093037216,
-0.0050769155,
0.03592816,
0.0109967934,
0.0339181162,
-0.0052418937,
0.045393154,
0.0373690017,
0.0050465576,
0.0131559186,
0.0079903929,
0.0621442422,
0.0153024914,
-0.0620740913,
0.0084119877,
-0.0143778073,
0.0422332659,
-0.0372673348,
0.0335252658,
0.0040036896,
0.044748541,
-0.0157995448,
-0.016531622,
0.0121109216,
0.0048508849,
-0.0609601811,
-0.0018651927,
-0.0085553471,
0.031958539,
-0.0128973899,
-0.0198818259,
0.007163607,
0.0252453499,
-0.0324120298,
-0.0549015291,
0.0017752467,
-0.0095962817,
2.465e-7,
0.0466151088,
0.0231414195,
0.0392395481,
0.0057094065,
0.0022655781,
0.0393052846,
0.0376267433,
0.0121212769,
0.028278267,
-0.0257388446,
0.0189808104,
0.022028422,
0.0328273885,
0.0025652784,
-0.099250935,
-0.0049738283,
-0.0537799522,
-0.0110169994,
-0.0083249537,
-0.0110273026,
0.0704759508,
0.0835017785,
0.0015484282,
-0.0084736357,
-0.0045118709,
-0.0462428257,
0.0260091592,
-0.0061721005,
0.0071181646,
0.0061988616,
0.0154561354,
-0.0016490048,
0.0349068195,
0.0339930505,
-0.0027662492,
0.0095720375,
0.0159000698,
0.0502304584,
0.0025127488,
-0.0594452769,
-0.0268456284,
-0.0022834088,
0.030301543,
-0.0718119368,
0.0660782307,
-0.0296589099,
-0.0133404369,
0.0246415678,
-0.0036117486,
-0.0131009566,
0.0373466685,
-0.0070149009,
-0.0313524455,
0.0150219901,
0.0365343578,
0.0199570283,
0.0144170281,
-0.0760999992,
-0.0252766032,
0.0197445601,
-0.0129377814,
-0.0168834552,
-0.0473112836,
-0.0306910016,
0.0020162659,
-0.0710333884,
0.0035697725,
2.250092945e-34,
0.0440036692,
0.0263442267,
0.0224673729,
0.0410169996,
0.0460026786,
-0.0193782207,
-0.0240215827,
-0.0008253623,
0.0277435165,
-0.079064548,
-0.0179859586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06805v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06805v1 | Tunable Soft Prompts are Messengers in Federated Learning | 2023-11-12T11:01:10 | 2023-11-12T11:01:10 | Chenhe Dong, Yuexiang Xie, Bolin Ding, Ying Shen, Yaliang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Federated learning (FL) enables multiple participants to collaboratively
train machine learning models using decentralized data sources, alleviating
privacy concerns that arise from directly sharing local data. However, the lack
of model privacy protection in FL becomes an unneglectable challenge,
especially when people want to federally finetune models based on a proprietary
large language model. In this study, we propose a novel FL training approach
that accomplishes information exchange among participants via tunable soft
prompts. These soft prompts, updated and transmitted between the server and
clients, assume the role of the global model parameters and serve as messengers
to deliver useful knowledge from the local data and global model. As the global
model itself is not required to be shared and the local training is conducted
based on an auxiliary model with fewer parameters than the global model, the
proposed approach provides protection for the global model while reducing
communication and computation costs in FL. Extensive experiments show the
effectiveness of the proposed approach compared to several baselines. We have
released the source code at
\url{https://github.com/alibaba/FederatedScope/tree/fedsp/federatedscope/nlp/fedsp}. | [
0.0391677842,
0.0827346817,
-0.0224397071,
0.0217920151,
-0.0450007543,
-0.0027225069,
0.1205453426,
-0.0279165003,
0.0465877429,
-0.0274388604,
-0.0562340021,
0.0098468764,
0.0053500314,
0.0445421375,
-0.0033636021,
-0.0482159592,
0.0574763305,
-0.029356461,
-0.0020475276,
-0.0533908084,
-0.0289916117,
0.0017288115,
0.0017440938,
0.0112003097,
0.0020015745,
-0.0684539527,
-0.0428777672,
-0.0209705457,
0.0000474153,
0.0309137721,
0.0397701152,
0.0666890293,
0.0094434517,
0.0714887604,
0.0000022572,
-0.0169354901,
-0.065966405,
0.043766059,
-0.0384923108,
0.042163182,
-0.0148055442,
0.0103996843,
0.0176214445,
0.0150839165,
-0.0390579961,
-0.0193302259,
0.0575808249,
0.0142131019,
0.0729269758,
0.0441523045,
0.0144945998,
-0.0186745897,
-0.0085204216,
-0.0196042247,
-0.0944473967,
-0.0291236769,
0.0075146854,
-0.0410366505,
-0.0387812033,
0.0217126142,
-0.0013499849,
0.0256285928,
0.0240656361,
0.0504234396,
-0.0050559095,
0.0085294042,
-0.0376018882,
-0.035810221,
-0.0493857637,
0.0554240495,
0.0447331816,
0.0070377924,
0.0062512229,
-0.0112224147,
0.0274372641,
0.0631398261,
-0.0061897933,
0.0211199801,
-0.0138675179,
0.0153476214,
-0.0139571084,
-0.0224759839,
0.0033398073,
0.0229515545,
0.0212110486,
0.0958003402,
-0.0231857523,
0.0112104295,
-0.0448680446,
-0.0175537188,
0.000912376,
-0.0482135005,
0.0559738874,
0.0203556158,
-0.0058610644,
-0.0152482679,
-0.0568423569,
-0.0409741662,
0.0136694033,
-0.0000881912,
0.0233384762,
-0.046144221,
0.0113634989,
0.0453982465,
0.0042387871,
-0.0218590014,
-0.0004354424,
0.0527324788,
0.0292884409,
0.010343058,
-0.064810589,
0.0019749172,
-0.0071993098,
0.0638964325,
-0.0546866246,
0.010962694,
-0.0097875781,
0.0235790182,
-0.0431401208,
0.0411254801,
-0.0266296491,
0.0073899524,
-0.0103943078,
0.0069125202,
-0.0237684976,
0.0189786851,
-0.0333395042,
0.0050394577,
0.0275109764,
-0.0641128495,
-0.002662272,
-0.0314780436,
-0.0231219474,
0.0088522928,
-0.0230972823,
0.0526969358,
0.0256616995,
0.0101661915,
-0.0005369397,
-0.0836306885,
0.0402683504,
-0.0579094589,
-0.0071303044,
-0.0396930017,
0.0165146869,
-0.0154486271,
0.0125075513,
-0.0329321735,
-0.0170824695,
0.0005076628,
-0.0218101442,
0.0703575388,
-0.0408176966,
-0.0186746065,
0.0173388608,
0.0286409613,
-0.0292925965,
0.0766514689,
-0.0196582843,
0.0144251157,
0.0795621648,
-0.0264271852,
-0.0102266865,
-0.0167602655,
0.0515083075,
0.0137152188,
0.008718824,
0.0055538774,
0.0134608215,
-0.0122668492,
-0.0687045231,
0.0161781162,
-0.0121857459,
-0.0186300557,
0.0779729262,
0.0797714218,
0.0406296998,
-0.0138804363,
-0.0393109769,
0.0611452907,
0.0084256623,
0.0214443784,
-0.0568019003,
0.0009972797,
-0.0631363541,
-0.0328615196,
-0.0391433947,
0.0688863769,
-0.0365909748,
-0.0332656056,
0.0138851432,
-0.058284305,
-0.0217727143,
0.043976184,
0.0168630667,
0.0081378669,
0.0291310288,
0.0430490561,
0.0360986888,
-0.0255643986,
-0.0323216468,
-0.0347647965,
0.0273300242,
0.0445702709,
0.055970259,
-0.0080215074,
0.0017222508,
-0.0583935827,
0.0036243647,
0.0057750046,
0.0446464457,
-0.0095073562,
0.0473373234,
-0.0273630507,
-0.0745829344,
0.0380583182,
0.0102816755,
-0.0037341507,
-0.0214891955,
-0.0156973414,
-0.0346166119,
0.0506788269,
-0.0147739388,
0.0267140679,
0.02014127,
-0.012209259,
0.0157547854,
0.053440582,
0.0512052961,
0.0302020721,
0.0129252123,
-0.019973835,
0.0108895209,
0.0514942668,
-0.0285499673,
-0.0397996828,
-0.0132759884,
0.0128944451,
-0.0231096614,
-0.0056177438,
0.0142587246,
0.0124811614,
-0.0559589006,
-0.0059866388,
-0.0267207436,
0.0224302672,
0.0095912479,
0.0010707355,
-0.0082818829,
-0.0231130123,
0.0352003649,
-0.0380480699,
0.0052976636,
-0.0261739008,
-0.011776044,
-0.0245237853,
-0.0299580861,
0.0370906107,
-0.0365452692,
0.0240930077,
0.0257583354,
0.0049856794,
0.0055726962,
-0.0038132195,
0.0231358428,
-0.0108850375,
0.026021041,
-0.0198811311,
-0.0127134696,
-0.0264587831,
0.0156759918,
0.0222000778,
0.0311767515,
-0.022604527,
-0.0595060736,
-0.0142163057,
0.0283313058,
-0.0544121675,
0.0447994024,
0.0039522252,
0.0189309604,
-0.020814307,
0.0180125777,
-0.0307214372,
0.0140022598,
0.0485998914,
0.0053250566,
-0.053456001,
-0.0756111667,
-0.015747387,
-0.0606712103,
0.0195474457,
0.0345474295,
0.0001117084,
0.0085357828,
0.0452669896,
-0.0388275236,
0.0599754564,
-0.0066770753,
0.0156425294,
0.052708026,
0.0159779545,
-0.0569560938,
0.001838045,
-0.042216558,
-0.0314545371,
-0.0373105779,
0.0360692143,
0.0572996214,
0.0240698718,
0.0148073025,
-0.0540932566,
-0.014687689,
0.0852501169,
-0.0077731512,
-0.0491146073,
-0.0726010799,
0.0139297238,
0.0201605428,
0.0334175602,
0.0298860706,
-0.0822526291,
0.0995235443,
-0.0035320097,
0.0214423463,
-0.0381944627,
-0.0623475872,
-0.0344724245,
0.0517142043,
-0.0478495657,
0.0350958183,
0.0362158939,
-0.0557722226,
-0.015976768,
0.022730941,
0.0704686493,
-0.029509183,
-0.038873937,
-0.0125690522,
-0.0313742682,
-0.0209760088,
-0.0580143854,
-0.0014759561,
-0.0547150597,
-0.0278872494,
0.0115250191,
-0.0400173999,
-0.0069264784,
0.005920419,
0.008443228,
0.0213963594,
0.0048038666,
-0.0385682918,
0.0179093201,
-0.0310847722,
-0.0263142847,
-0.0191062409,
-0.0414838977,
-0.0319910049,
-0.0396054536,
0.0129922433,
0.0644087344,
0.0478406549,
-0.0218217615,
0.0464941822,
-0.0289241727,
0.0359420255,
-0.0350618921,
-0.0170958638,
-0.0080131628,
0.0698327646,
-0.0439339541,
0.0094937114,
0.0735234395,
0.0233134665,
-0.0704259798,
-0.0186186768,
-0.019544404,
0.0583099946,
-0.0080651604,
0.0176420063,
-0.0742664114,
-0.0166032296,
0.0272982083,
0.0696767196,
-0.0108413305,
-0.0363768078,
-0.0255480725,
-0.0721081197,
0.0222790744,
0.0057927477,
-0.0203296021,
-0.0414204337,
-0.0284600314,
0.0120530203,
0.0077248975,
-0.0005238472,
-0.0551658645,
0.0168518424,
0.0060314541,
0.0207372736,
-0.0092084352,
-0.0354992785,
-0.040208105,
-0.03889779,
0.0525349379,
0.0334443636,
-0.0183502659,
0.0199482851,
-0.0486226417,
-0.0117618833,
0.0451766215,
-0.0105260853,
-0.0371788777,
0.0406438187,
-0.0291501228,
-0.0232175142,
-0.0022104904,
0.0525274798,
0.0463373698,
0.0102859931,
0.0353310853,
0.0823906064,
-0.0154020656,
0.0201921836,
0.0020447786,
-0.017918665,
0.0495182201,
0.0439867005,
0.0032586851,
-0.0576078855,
-0.0114293378,
-0.0116560496,
0.0259244479,
0.0423565246,
0.0119004026,
0.0328091383,
-0.036061164,
-0.0005885379,
-0.0470617302,
-0.0043523284,
0.0225566756,
0.0287386738,
0.0371125229,
0.0104551474,
0.0706160963,
0.0038893973,
-0.0113609899,
0.0447058976,
-0.0663443357,
0.0272300132,
-0.0696712583,
-0.0503858253,
0.0217621382,
0.0144353099,
-0.031982813,
0.0383114479,
-0.0390274562,
-0.0653931201,
0.018895207,
0.026067473,
0.0179841984,
0.0178751219,
-0.0266967267,
-0.0509529486,
0.0605384782,
0.048884131,
-0.0869087726,
-0.004057623,
0.0672650188,
-0.0500336103,
-0.0043368582,
0.0190452635,
-0.0294704046,
-0.0289822314,
0.0565129258,
-0.0341376252,
0.0039011068,
-0.0687639713,
0.0024937324,
0.0418618657,
0.0773902833,
0.0235290639,
-0.0108054187,
-0.0331185609,
0.032604333,
0.0115175787,
-0.0163957365,
-0.0410976298,
0.0076264585,
-0.0007100587,
-0.0331995375,
0.0607283115,
-0.0121133765,
0.0642630979,
0.0108786114,
-0.0296262875,
0.0278786961,
0.0229674634,
0.0081925597,
0.0326145329,
0.0047949366,
-0.0249368008,
0.0512244254,
0.0359869972,
0.0292071216,
-0.0197418779,
0.081537433,
0.0028774622,
0.0220613629,
-0.0175751392,
0.0390174426,
-0.0645647421,
-0.1330815554,
0.0037151026,
0.058566846,
-0.0086033689,
0.0659970641,
-0.0337882824,
-0.0325096995,
-0.0083922744,
-0.0266890917,
0.0242556389,
0.0001375337,
-0.0472912118,
0.0034738176,
-0.0071890843,
-0.0116776899,
0.0413170308,
0.0712297186,
-0.0216332097,
0.0198049843,
-0.0481013581,
-0.026457252,
-0.0705267191,
-0.0073117451,
0.0386422276,
0.044928968,
-0.0560291559,
-0.0065485961,
-0.007870961,
-0.0474460833,
-0.0295430552,
-0.009777965,
-0.0043585836,
0.0023303006,
0.0240224637,
0.0209062546,
-0.0065814895,
-0.0262221154,
-0.0847348273,
0.0257368702,
0.0411635488,
0.0042451215,
-0.0067935465,
-6.027170592e-33,
-0.0328665562,
-0.0026442404,
-0.0245378315,
0.0250713825,
0.0155801494,
0.0441118814,
0.0269630495,
-0.0041682092,
0.0093194665,
-0.0086674634,
-0.0225033183,
0.0084075667,
0.0273717679,
0.028248515,
-0.009699503,
-0.0303017758,
0.0490603335,
-0.0499824546,
-0.0066722217,
0.0406635031,
0.0598295704,
0.0422499888,
0.0385111198,
-0.0648459047,
0.0448472276,
0.0049478677,
-0.0220644362,
0.0076212338,
-0.0825740993,
0.0229013842,
-0.0232309364,
0.0072425199,
-0.0061751739,
-0.028515622,
-0.0363717675,
0.0259444546,
-0.0614228249,
-0.010456834,
-0.0342495628,
0.0168664083,
-0.0236029699,
-0.0150558325,
0.0294719879,
-0.040553432,
0.0262862612,
-0.0059865355,
0.0214437433,
0.0144553259,
-0.0462627299,
-0.0019456695,
0.0286174882,
-0.0030219019,
-0.0029352054,
0.024494553,
0.024325965,
0.0499727465,
0.0111524751,
-0.0401511453,
-0.0319189876,
0.0321393386,
0.0482990965,
-0.0302161593,
0.0365171507,
0.0131935477,
0.0176491756,
0.029130172,
0.0727265254,
-0.0095097423,
-0.0222475827,
-0.003061896,
-0.0042809155,
0.0464015976,
0.0170927215,
0.0264362507,
-0.0341400988,
-0.02836187,
-0.0141837588,
-0.0160161275,
0.0457798615,
-0.0194800775,
0.0025870693,
0.0082670767,
-0.0321374126,
-0.0158972386,
-0.0521031879,
-0.0355008952,
0.0025209549,
-0.0005838249,
-0.0006990831,
-0.0025904381,
-0.024793556,
-0.0143323727,
0.0180235878,
-0.0479468517,
-0.0322998986,
0.0060428358,
0.098195143,
0.0111149615,
0.0051309583,
-0.0149617242,
-0.0598836616,
0.0047796252,
-0.019659685,
-0.0497616567,
0.0222998261,
0.0139799286,
0.0720395595,
0.0169356633,
-0.0457625873,
-0.0125306575,
-0.0219576899,
0.0160581544,
0.0199487079,
0.0219227653,
0.0538047478,
-0.0387372933,
0.0040470152,
0.0297509786,
0.0113646435,
0.0030103826,
-0.0477031767,
-0.0046301004,
-0.0250708498,
0.0120862741,
0.0185597092,
-0.0200188365,
-0.0354244411,
0.0126551688,
0.0722802281,
0.0070298454,
0.0219345037,
-0.0359973125,
2.86e-7,
-0.0192850456,
0.0154205272,
-0.0215907153,
-0.0311052706,
0.0165359173,
0.062236134,
0.0031569658,
0.0627520755,
0.001172729,
0.0267024171,
-0.0202960856,
-0.0022609928,
0.0503649786,
0.0231061447,
-0.0755432248,
-0.0459598824,
-0.0342121199,
0.0324250683,
-0.0679142773,
0.0028758543,
-0.0217982251,
0.0263089892,
0.0762036294,
-0.0175473727,
0.0309039652,
0.0055638077,
0.0179783199,
-0.0538003296,
-0.0463090427,
-0.0182514787,
0.0549968705,
0.0482773334,
0.024623841,
0.0233236197,
-0.0138132721,
0.004381544,
-0.0555870458,
0.0581184402,
0.0391440205,
0.0388102606,
-0.0254162662,
-0.0335340239,
-0.0344219059,
0.003071252,
0.0640223324,
-0.0328618139,
-0.0464173518,
-0.0131595517,
0.0364051424,
-0.0913599879,
0.0448655672,
-0.0010709879,
0.0024374216,
0.0126076238,
-0.004292164,
-0.0009894178,
-0.0278267153,
-0.0506336428,
0.01255346,
-0.0593336411,
-0.0152999843,
-0.0517114662,
0.0051672063,
0.0117168054,
-0.0001472304,
-0.0394654274,
0.0271227378,
2.601702132e-34,
-0.0044095302,
-0.0059436504,
0.0051326845,
0.0290230513,
0.0109736361,
-0.0313189961,
0.0239017289,
-0.0260281842,
0.0304906126,
-0.0117991054,
0.0000677235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06771v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06771v1 | Learning Globally Optimized Language Structure via Adversarial Training | 2023-11-12T08:21:43 | 2023-11-12T08:21:43 | Xuwang Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent work has explored integrating autoregressive language models with
energy-based models (EBMs) to enhance text generation capabilities. However,
learning effective EBMs for text is challenged by the discrete nature of
language. This work proposes an adversarial training strategy to address
limitations in prior efforts. Specifically, an iterative adversarial attack
algorithm is presented to generate negative samples for training the EBM by
perturbing text from the autoregressive model. This aims to enable the EBM to
suppress spurious modes outside the support of the data distribution.
Experiments on an arithmetic sequence generation task demonstrate that the
proposed adversarial training approach can substantially enhance the quality of
generated sequences compared to prior methods. The results highlight the
promise of adversarial techniques to improve discrete EBM training. Key
contributions include: (1) an adversarial attack strategy tailored to text to
generate negative samples, circumventing MCMC limitations; (2) an adversarial
training algorithm for EBMs leveraging these attacks; (3) empirical validation
of performance improvements on a sequence generation task. | [
0.0060789082,
0.1128780842,
-0.0166887622,
-0.0041565411,
-0.0293535851,
0.0017561321,
-0.0080078142,
-0.0017058934,
-0.0341662765,
-0.0454408824,
-0.003218197,
-0.0575668216,
0.0196402911,
0.036213696,
0.0891522393,
-0.0017458297,
0.026142057,
-0.0348992161,
0.022499647,
-0.0078163827,
-0.0227009393,
-0.0326466933,
-0.0021813859,
-0.0068982369,
-0.0406124406,
0.0308830179,
-0.0141971968,
0.0004160911,
0.0187321957,
-0.0462931246,
0.0353017077,
0.0557263121,
0.016146943,
0.0500267968,
0.0000021383,
0.0096372981,
-0.0193642844,
-0.0153992223,
-0.0147934975,
0.0124335065,
0.0305879377,
-0.0544259883,
-0.0240451731,
0.0107477345,
-0.0364457928,
-0.0049656751,
0.0394192487,
0.001875888,
0.0558004379,
0.100667432,
-0.0075491969,
-0.0181446001,
0.0296998657,
-0.0965154171,
0.0257317591,
0.0122858975,
0.0310165118,
0.0097578019,
-0.0343248658,
0.0145252552,
-0.0134974923,
0.0278111305,
0.0401908159,
0.0204782281,
0.0085652471,
0.0464793593,
0.0113811679,
0.0012441727,
0.0152947409,
0.0526301228,
-0.0196549185,
-0.0332396291,
0.0231627934,
-0.0238609631,
-0.0287393369,
0.0087292967,
-0.031545911,
0.0283036511,
0.0193229038,
0.0243240371,
-0.0215338096,
-0.0200474039,
0.0543191284,
0.0152263269,
-0.0019680352,
0.0142022474,
0.0223132633,
-0.0449891835,
-0.0182369482,
-0.0028600923,
-0.0374405868,
-0.0476047881,
0.0041934508,
0.0158826262,
0.0352794752,
0.0235034283,
-0.0920195356,
-0.0685062483,
0.0144701619,
-0.0391528718,
0.0574178956,
0.0102447132,
0.0838221833,
-0.0371243954,
-0.032435298,
0.0254798178,
-0.0255385023,
-0.0280403104,
-0.0317449756,
0.0645057335,
-0.025154816,
-0.0009379924,
0.0106466636,
0.0089739086,
-0.0280212332,
-0.0091711776,
-0.0724897459,
0.0034705491,
0.0066157416,
0.0150394477,
-0.0098813465,
0.0267812293,
-0.0484759063,
-0.0045862659,
0.0049095987,
-0.0371784195,
-0.0108729918,
-0.0054937075,
0.0212739073,
-0.042204313,
-0.035728585,
0.0228804443,
-0.0370436199,
-0.0032411893,
-0.0174193084,
0.1094182059,
0.0148518132,
-0.0039174128,
-0.0306860283,
-0.0415956378,
-0.016585581,
-0.0520732105,
0.0753980055,
-0.04454346,
-0.0141329477,
-0.0119881527,
-0.0220999699,
-0.02997192,
0.0481828377,
-0.0186295845,
0.0017538838,
0.0550333373,
0.0153746782,
-0.0345629826,
0.0611672439,
-0.0096310461,
0.0403302237,
0.0665891021,
0.062168207,
0.0118433805,
-0.0093543893,
0.0112797068,
0.0102632726,
0.0480570272,
0.0579420663,
0.0326309279,
-0.0308803562,
-0.050560765,
-0.0222742558,
0.0366533957,
0.024763504,
0.0326941349,
-0.0175299663,
-0.0305465721,
0.0789355934,
-0.0433171093,
-0.0102057951,
0.0455089062,
0.0266058948,
-0.0247654822,
-0.0320609622,
0.0330156051,
-0.0207723267,
0.0404862687,
-0.0384086668,
0.0243912581,
0.0521636195,
-0.0269761216,
-0.0322693661,
-0.0409802459,
0.0223484579,
-0.0423789807,
0.0233257301,
-0.034404479,
0.0433588997,
0.0139028747,
-0.066675432,
0.0169643648,
0.0043514315,
-0.039394591,
-0.0109111667,
-0.0317185707,
-0.0000783239,
-0.0004352515,
0.0687643513,
-0.0130408099,
0.0287520178,
-0.0399081185,
-0.0280911159,
0.0505630299,
0.0039104624,
0.0192295853,
-0.0126982108,
-0.0591434166,
-0.0174249765,
-0.0597488284,
0.0214194767,
0.0265878662,
-0.0063481666,
-0.0056869015,
0.0561856702,
-0.0153800938,
-0.0517850071,
0.0260363035,
-0.0545181632,
-0.075686641,
0.0263300575,
0.0092151538,
0.0318054296,
-0.0296674222,
-0.0236995071,
0.0751442984,
0.0240256879,
-0.0673983693,
-0.0307248496,
-0.0332407579,
-0.0823234916,
-0.0433261059,
0.0369304195,
-0.0216510165,
0.0335368663,
0.012297105,
-0.0233237874,
-0.0361072719,
0.0549549162,
-0.0817673877,
0.0183528624,
-0.0260620844,
0.0132065369,
0.0330015235,
0.0268028006,
-0.0306937043,
0.0783018917,
-0.0535421744,
0.0145024164,
-0.0097524524,
0.030102456,
0.0215876531,
-0.0274080951,
0.0192370526,
-0.013877904,
0.0197175592,
-0.0157977715,
0.0386991613,
-0.0173507296,
-0.0179911181,
-0.0075758835,
-0.0184962768,
0.0066252425,
-0.0290076155,
0.0300002098,
0.0361279957,
-0.0275171511,
0.0053485096,
0.0246239118,
-0.0362549722,
0.0037140355,
-0.000291121,
0.0120287957,
0.0302273016,
0.0093267327,
-0.0020477471,
-0.0462410413,
-0.0372553207,
-0.0100971311,
0.0654142499,
-0.0060716234,
0.0071520642,
-0.0084623042,
0.034023758,
-0.012169173,
0.0208933279,
-0.0265603606,
-0.0580882467,
-0.0034949228,
-0.0159375314,
0.0655858889,
0.0614937358,
0.0344001651,
0.0083344849,
-0.0061097764,
0.0149669303,
-0.003724366,
-0.0085813291,
-0.031096207,
0.0531643517,
0.0158824697,
-0.0711192638,
0.0237445924,
0.0987588018,
0.0344779044,
0.013725468,
-0.0411380492,
0.0626504123,
0.0188214947,
-0.0591003969,
0.0096042221,
0.0061092488,
-0.0226444025,
-0.0360477492,
-0.0347237848,
-0.0650691986,
0.060521327,
-0.0412831046,
0.0206525642,
-0.021496607,
-0.0003017827,
0.0263967086,
0.0113963513,
0.0512162372,
0.0069470447,
0.0259220246,
0.0042128116,
-0.042240914,
0.0152543262,
0.0599300116,
-0.0262494572,
0.0167087484,
-0.0443812609,
0.0110671017,
0.0004163526,
-0.0069510182,
-0.0606539212,
-0.0037975518,
0.0332750566,
0.0382574573,
0.0352653377,
-0.0002800172,
-0.0583700016,
0.0044778809,
0.0154065127,
0.0203454904,
-0.0428154543,
0.0126855141,
-0.0042603058,
0.0646155924,
0.0658383965,
-0.0484677665,
0.0184123497,
-0.083225809,
0.0138980178,
0.0319803953,
-0.0044650822,
0.0567630716,
-0.0174841173,
0.0010162498,
-0.0325700939,
-0.0124418158,
-0.0244900752,
0.0254901331,
0.0262371022,
-0.0500325784,
-0.0261011813,
0.087090075,
0.0004597424,
-0.0004926817,
0.0384265967,
0.0472271517,
0.0621345676,
-0.0018232166,
-0.0255058371,
-0.0320072323,
-0.0070254477,
-0.0132441586,
0.0314775258,
-0.0200404227,
-0.0420891009,
-0.0152987372,
-0.094369404,
-0.0187253989,
0.0446129106,
-0.026464805,
-0.0347407758,
-0.0169089101,
-0.0314502083,
-0.0055370652,
-0.0028234269,
-0.0005120173,
0.0080169039,
0.0435216539,
0.045403596,
0.0065160203,
-0.040927168,
-0.06219621,
-0.0249333903,
0.0304139368,
0.1152541786,
0.0209129471,
-0.0128581589,
-0.0137255881,
0.0299317464,
-0.0008158945,
0.013773432,
-0.004443144,
0.0101492349,
0.0050030872,
-0.0083037661,
-0.0030500237,
0.0548209026,
-0.037637271,
0.0069689769,
0.0080518918,
0.0215511899,
-0.0163272992,
-0.0189028196,
-0.0135310544,
0.021102624,
0.0611422546,
0.0606145896,
0.0284845643,
-0.0371639542,
-0.0489014611,
-0.0648955256,
0.0527395383,
-0.0947520584,
0.0059552244,
0.0036875182,
0.0334892794,
-0.0426791795,
-0.0917531475,
-0.0650731847,
-0.0104698036,
0.0518820956,
0.0048379549,
0.0026862901,
-0.0154782664,
-0.0346403643,
-0.053463161,
-0.036450766,
-0.0155374836,
0.0321748741,
-0.0281724613,
-0.0734094754,
0.0046590515,
-0.0128377825,
0.0039711595,
0.0042943456,
-0.1169544458,
-0.1079947427,
-0.0169983748,
0.1016361937,
0.0117077501,
0.0467798822,
0.0475803614,
-0.0278266072,
0.063959077,
0.0433431715,
-0.0536407046,
0.0324132517,
0.0493980683,
-0.0232009664,
-0.0077472641,
0.0360256843,
-0.0056787478,
0.0295254923,
0.0453573614,
0.0734723136,
-0.047194507,
-0.0093070846,
0.0259125773,
-0.0108726071,
0.0168468077,
-0.0471412502,
-0.0166082364,
0.0093745999,
0.0114038428,
-0.0335559025,
0.0266708694,
-0.0489589013,
0.0116015309,
0.0188073441,
0.0317803845,
0.0033266067,
0.0178317353,
-0.0084389672,
0.0256071202,
-0.0049342443,
0.047433611,
-0.0102092093,
0.0832706168,
0.0310745016,
-0.0081218025,
-0.0106025673,
0.0374126136,
-0.0068415641,
0.0128033692,
-0.0194148999,
0.0453086011,
0.0183821153,
0.0402002484,
-0.0000512796,
0.0108171394,
-0.0280928127,
0.0258185584,
-0.0467037447,
-0.0061479858,
0.049479764,
-0.0050602821,
0.0151784606,
-0.0519861616,
0.0122749722,
-0.0302272309,
0.0295566227,
-0.0040134541,
0.0033605257,
0.0249664523,
0.0149692763,
-0.0187868141,
-0.0006201561,
0.1069457829,
0.0475195237,
0.0443347581,
0.0216140095,
0.0161366109,
-0.0532575436,
-0.0351114832,
0.0096780779,
-0.0449333377,
-0.0033553676,
0.0203888286,
-0.0002163688,
-0.0754742697,
-0.0261736047,
0.0357435346,
0.0151726278,
-0.0024957384,
0.0785732791,
0.0244958866,
-0.0680807829,
0.031196719,
-0.0468189642,
0.0605961047,
-0.012407301,
-0.0418456458,
-0.0208003689,
-6.060931157e-33,
-0.0213283803,
-0.0552272275,
-0.0082930606,
-0.0158439502,
-0.0022301713,
-0.0120518273,
-0.0536853373,
0.013678709,
0.0273469798,
-0.0221683867,
0.0215361249,
-0.0038915253,
-0.0190271381,
0.0512132607,
-0.0031007132,
0.0065911091,
0.078111276,
-0.0359171182,
-0.0111005846,
0.023407802,
0.0038871602,
0.0480796136,
0.0335428044,
-0.019838931,
-0.0033557296,
-0.0328791291,
-0.021920545,
-0.0314475931,
0.0066556893,
0.0285943765,
-0.0235938542,
0.01191328,
0.0099362452,
-0.0090335282,
-0.0168190803,
-0.0104016569,
-0.0266774911,
-0.0136291534,
-0.0175887942,
-0.0216282923,
-0.0452057943,
-0.0605877154,
0.0335276686,
-0.0292785633,
-0.0179550163,
0.0233563278,
0.0061295205,
-0.006718541,
-0.0719454661,
-0.0264902208,
-0.0307643544,
0.0280381218,
-0.0022452993,
-0.0022494202,
-0.0105364053,
0.0023121636,
0.0105066318,
-0.0075306138,
-0.0565231629,
0.0297881514,
0.0482592247,
0.0630304366,
0.0246997885,
0.0413065813,
0.0570661165,
0.0419013612,
0.0160359424,
-0.0074642794,
-0.0263397451,
0.0409255326,
0.0301047601,
-0.0032586965,
0.0551411957,
0.0239138156,
0.0514083207,
-0.0251914822,
-0.0681064054,
0.0191001743,
0.0128014311,
0.023321921,
0.0094870906,
0.0103372941,
0.0004792183,
0.0039526755,
-0.0363395289,
-0.0413049795,
-0.0103064422,
-0.0369632952,
0.0214971956,
0.0271917451,
-0.018689556,
-0.0273211878,
0.0029982009,
-0.0129089961,
-0.0163946934,
0.0496883467,
-0.0218462963,
-0.0286938101,
0.0163581073,
0.0052547902,
-0.0580835231,
-0.016809931,
0.0215276368,
0.008436719,
0.0233804397,
0.005010616,
0.0006419185,
0.0218839627,
-0.0230690315,
-0.007445408,
-0.0460321568,
0.060802374,
0.0662148595,
0.0068194028,
0.0287460666,
-0.0328818858,
-0.0093964972,
0.0213473979,
-0.0260950699,
-0.009392756,
-0.0099465083,
0.022332238,
-0.0003500521,
0.0670219511,
-0.0185569339,
-0.0464666374,
-0.0226202905,
0.0111604203,
0.0476606861,
-0.1012706235,
-0.0201184489,
-0.0099828737,
2.748e-7,
0.0000233832,
0.0417733975,
0.0224707425,
-0.0153921423,
0.0413792394,
0.0600965433,
-0.0376629867,
0.0155333132,
-0.0445437357,
-0.0336996615,
0.0069744182,
-0.013540755,
0.066787377,
0.0148463342,
-0.0385722034,
0.0118741672,
-0.0562728606,
0.0451001674,
-0.0297729764,
-0.0171589572,
-0.0035033075,
0.0755678192,
-0.0387067124,
0.0013816681,
0.0141217345,
-0.0444768444,
0.0950628519,
-0.012408793,
-0.0124224201,
0.0055495575,
-0.012105111,
-0.0227626432,
-0.020531578,
-0.0155838579,
-0.068507351,
-0.0187063273,
-0.0002745292,
0.0302978326,
0.0135948611,
-0.0614595152,
0.0262644459,
0.006904115,
-0.0118448529,
0.0047940314,
0.0414653271,
-0.0245861355,
-0.0230557658,
0.001972117,
-0.0435213782,
0.0390547141,
0.015534427,
-0.0447127633,
-0.0180080086,
-0.0035600816,
0.0201262794,
0.0159480255,
0.0391444191,
-0.0101282252,
0.0043420033,
0.0005835671,
-0.0609473251,
-0.0027627498,
-0.083188042,
0.0219133049,
0.026606923,
0.028643636,
-0.0269715469,
2.618317239e-34,
0.0123948157,
-0.066580236,
-0.0044882959,
-0.0195041969,
0.0259231012,
-0.0156284068,
-0.0280795824,
0.0371677428,
0.0104298135,
-0.0435339697,
-0.0619201809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07618v1 | Large Language Models' Understanding of Math: Source Criticism and Extrapolation | 2023-11-12T07:52:32 | 2023-11-12T07:52:32 | Roozbeh Yousefzadeh, Xuenan Cao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.HO | It has been suggested that large language models such as GPT-4 have acquired
some form of understanding beyond the correlations among the words in text
including some understanding of mathematics as well. Here, we perform a
critical inquiry into this claim by evaluating the mathematical understanding
of the GPT-4 model. Considering that GPT-4's training set is a secret, it is
not straightforward to evaluate whether the model's correct answers are based
on a mathematical understanding or based on replication of proofs that the
model has seen before. We specifically craft mathematical questions which their
formal proofs are not readily available on the web, proofs that are more likely
not seen by the GPT-4. We see that GPT-4 is unable to solve those problems
despite their simplicity. It is hard to find scientific evidence suggesting
that GPT-4 has acquired an understanding of even basic mathematical concepts. A
straightforward way to find failure modes of GPT-4 in theorem proving is to
craft questions where their formal proofs are not available on the web. Our
finding suggests that GPT-4's ability is to reproduce, rephrase, and polish the
mathematical proofs that it has seen before, and not in grasping mathematical
concepts. We also see that GPT-4's ability to prove mathematical theorems is
continuously expanding over time despite the claim that it is a fixed model. We
suggest that the task of proving mathematical theorems in formal language is
comparable to the methods used in search engines such as Google while
predicting the next word in a sentence may be a misguided approach, a recipe
that often leads to excessive extrapolation and eventual failures. Prompting
the GPT-4 over and over may benefit the GPT-4 and the OpenAI, but we question
whether it is valuable for machine learning or for theorem proving. | [
-0.002577038,
0.1068048999,
-0.0153494375,
0.0508306548,
-0.066081278,
0.0303250495,
-0.0095082223,
0.010638494,
-0.0324981622,
-0.0152030801,
-0.0202407092,
-0.0210831668,
0.0148093617,
0.0222611073,
0.0318827964,
-0.0617539398,
0.0201170873,
-0.0279441569,
0.005694842,
-0.0305046123,
-0.0439357571,
-0.0313527472,
-0.0064449385,
0.0145339975,
-0.0313411765,
-0.0525299273,
-0.003671845,
-0.0734034181,
-0.0082442742,
-0.013622134,
-0.0377183519,
0.0288693588,
0.0184170213,
0.1187521815,
0.0000020595,
-0.0575614981,
0.004175311,
0.0338618681,
-0.032845743,
0.0403670594,
-0.0351065248,
-0.0337530188,
0.0339895636,
0.0127122365,
-0.0801867917,
-0.0232778993,
0.0398708507,
0.0483344309,
0.048756443,
0.0693447664,
-0.0044238777,
-0.0905647799,
0.0796164349,
-0.0392903574,
0.0389656164,
-0.0847858265,
0.0305079166,
-0.0047381576,
0.0048018713,
0.0156226549,
-0.0288559683,
0.0456591919,
0.0737390295,
0.0512509644,
-0.0329414792,
0.0638124421,
-0.0602474026,
0.0187796485,
-0.0080568278,
0.0410484523,
0.0060281856,
-0.0417677015,
-0.0076759397,
0.0008026454,
-0.0125343716,
0.0545389913,
-0.0774225295,
0.0308827385,
-0.0100051155,
0.0179782696,
-0.0267651454,
-0.0148001267,
0.0585446171,
0.0145167159,
-0.0301213618,
0.1197987795,
0.0174018275,
-0.0603255816,
0.0004185138,
0.0168209374,
-0.0800112039,
-0.0433832705,
-0.0009795222,
0.0285308659,
0.0753847286,
0.0396478102,
-0.0207193717,
-0.0247904584,
-0.0229089465,
-0.0229650699,
0.009611574,
0.0647237748,
0.010800424,
0.0157823022,
-0.0321986564,
0.0400674194,
-0.0436222851,
0.0274023935,
-0.0086147524,
0.0109776678,
-0.0738424137,
-0.0368866809,
-0.0299688354,
0.0659609661,
0.0298624709,
-0.0019870927,
-0.0308432244,
0.030043399,
-0.0323365144,
0.0235049389,
-0.0236149468,
-0.0507932529,
-0.0135224489,
-0.022551734,
-0.0587084331,
-0.0070354375,
-0.0255720876,
0.01748579,
-0.0204338431,
-0.0610662624,
-0.0105544245,
-0.0010165526,
-0.0148923658,
-0.0068946998,
0.0065022772,
0.0606478341,
0.0259288922,
-0.0063994541,
0.0030634296,
-0.0144569743,
-0.0000779658,
-0.0771006048,
0.0110117318,
-0.059881188,
0.0321181379,
0.0238164328,
-0.0324583836,
-0.0206596944,
-0.0216414947,
0.0162155367,
-0.0197394881,
0.0959465951,
-0.0099804606,
0.0169228371,
0.0509904549,
0.0181081165,
-0.0189478267,
0.0094617074,
0.0435549766,
-0.0045313681,
0.0308406372,
-0.0067511601,
0.0290434062,
0.0313478373,
0.0280175433,
-0.0008961571,
-0.0032727527,
0.0248671062,
0.0111888694,
0.0550723523,
-0.0572982095,
0.0614571609,
-0.0326386578,
-0.0084747383,
0.0566243567,
0.0728668794,
-0.0243359916,
0.0495335199,
0.0194331985,
-0.0325360633,
0.0507776402,
0.0418990031,
-0.0671820864,
-0.0097634783,
-0.0453493446,
0.0119261006,
0.0145504568,
-0.0319897681,
-0.023354169,
-0.058345791,
-0.0134863555,
-0.0070793517,
-0.020257676,
-0.006343056,
0.0867225528,
-0.038037505,
0.0135165602,
0.0313057899,
-0.0048772758,
-0.0252882708,
-0.0122786602,
-0.0625956506,
0.0461426228,
-0.0478951558,
0.0530625656,
-0.0366495661,
0.0036755886,
-0.0134583861,
0.0135373939,
0.0106024211,
0.0734790042,
0.0119644767,
-0.0525457673,
-0.0222665835,
0.0039362893,
-0.0363455527,
0.0228672046,
-0.0145955589,
0.0154313277,
0.0379286669,
0.0291132666,
-0.0389036499,
0.0021059336,
0.0243105534,
-0.0199123286,
-0.0481272712,
-0.001534086,
-0.0113556022,
0.0526806787,
-0.0225696582,
0.0001202289,
0.0362541489,
0.0202971268,
-0.005492378,
-0.0266339444,
-0.0133097749,
-0.0208171215,
0.0125294821,
0.0441052169,
-0.0613687634,
-0.0193070136,
0.0502063781,
-0.0549775511,
-0.0392679758,
0.0612100475,
-0.0454157144,
0.0498985462,
-0.0384161286,
-0.0105011147,
-0.005945385,
0.0207414292,
0.0095412759,
0.0751587674,
0.0306933429,
-0.0073661772,
-0.0273091551,
-0.0080192117,
0.0333453156,
-0.0140740527,
-0.0021124783,
-0.0104700066,
0.0122910207,
0.0342429243,
-0.0009674837,
-0.0080586281,
-0.0121888323,
0.0021970812,
-0.0311326049,
-0.0088415863,
-0.0115358001,
0.0528666861,
0.0162432119,
-0.0356763192,
-0.0063783261,
-0.0251143873,
-0.0010681666,
0.001882883,
0.0114394166,
-0.0005231337,
0.0478961691,
0.0146347145,
-0.0142659545,
0.000123451,
-0.0280223936,
-0.0583210178,
0.0273505487,
0.0194034837,
0.0340894945,
-0.0009358332,
-0.0001933011,
-0.0565939769,
0.0080243004,
-0.0203099549,
0.0242561251,
0.0516204126,
-0.0135926949,
0.0018604243,
0.0589844212,
0.0042672679,
0.0559422597,
0.0299250092,
0.0036554395,
-0.0055249035,
0.0082295462,
-0.0558086634,
-0.0327177458,
0.0015309379,
-0.0045346036,
0.0108951405,
0.0046141078,
0.0198767837,
-0.0324851908,
-0.0594244823,
0.0755604208,
-0.023408087,
0.0157749802,
-0.0393046923,
0.0063306526,
-0.0350861512,
0.0471908972,
0.0125763612,
-0.0707264021,
0.0333468392,
0.0037199405,
0.0095602861,
-0.0705160499,
0.0184920188,
-0.0373109244,
0.0830991417,
0.0139440447,
-0.0110707385,
0.0154329687,
0.0166329648,
-0.0294163376,
-0.0113363592,
0.0181967709,
-0.0170229021,
0.0551733673,
-0.0621840432,
0.0302588269,
0.0000992217,
-0.0439950675,
-0.0188662559,
0.0056232857,
-0.0306517277,
0.0282542147,
-0.0378900543,
-0.0363979004,
-0.0047481204,
-0.0125697488,
0.0548943542,
0.0236348081,
-0.0256912243,
-0.0314481556,
-0.0151532115,
0.0134730013,
0.0433961488,
0.0073492238,
0.0341889523,
-0.0776920021,
-0.0144723672,
0.026679365,
0.0341326222,
0.0382672548,
-0.0200050157,
-0.0065506804,
-0.0169732198,
-0.0323331468,
-0.0450864136,
0.0367238447,
-0.0365695097,
-0.0497792438,
-0.0067504975,
0.0925713256,
0.0283266623,
-0.0155259967,
-0.0045290468,
-0.0240901113,
-0.0185358562,
-0.0013100147,
-0.014086022,
-0.0912709907,
-0.0041578468,
0.0117169116,
0.0041645966,
0.0001032103,
-0.0050747967,
-0.0180281084,
-0.1114869714,
0.0368613824,
0.0001348262,
-0.0550296605,
0.0069751539,
-0.0454270691,
0.0079985308,
0.0061507863,
0.0017881362,
0.0057076751,
0.0075358502,
0.0449100211,
0.0063034296,
-0.0421993397,
-0.0590194389,
0.0272576362,
-0.0169178471,
-0.0290716738,
0.023777172,
0.0619296096,
-0.0742566884,
-0.0760933161,
0.0234274175,
0.031366758,
-0.0290442947,
0.0097507033,
0.0354832709,
0.0073498939,
-0.0067563443,
-0.0270254742,
0.0443821549,
-0.0558519214,
-0.0166312717,
0.0421189964,
0.1218609065,
-0.005687329,
-0.0680936426,
-0.0053634234,
-0.0294267572,
-0.0635742769,
0.0711033344,
0.0243849438,
0.0212327093,
-0.0541748665,
-0.0276693925,
0.026066022,
0.0049925819,
-0.0341399498,
-0.0121158222,
0.0716681778,
-0.023377914,
-0.0291285142,
-0.0357575826,
0.0082904799,
0.0464404747,
0.0176815316,
0.006274574,
0.03165235,
0.0240839981,
-0.0297266711,
0.0238818992,
-0.0391238853,
-0.0003919735,
-0.0476605222,
0.0138761243,
0.0222378206,
-0.0200271513,
-0.0427330919,
0.0281460527,
-0.0669766292,
-0.0598365068,
-0.0207102131,
0.0306772124,
0.0329202004,
-0.0049099349,
-0.0079826852,
-0.018376248,
0.0202191751,
0.0180355031,
-0.0259615872,
0.0152139701,
0.0482851006,
-0.0135093955,
0.0269345641,
0.0248725172,
0.0074560568,
0.0068222391,
0.0026115146,
0.0058952416,
-0.0166861042,
-0.0024264266,
0.0239612982,
0.0700792968,
0.0417852849,
0.036031954,
-0.003499174,
0.0193626359,
0.0188646521,
-0.0117035005,
0.0120288413,
-0.0349993482,
0.0208566673,
0.0250278618,
0.050526347,
-0.0456282683,
-0.0259075891,
0.017725382,
0.001782693,
-0.0057522655,
0.0036033543,
0.0038833518,
0.0214505233,
0.0361714289,
-0.0389059745,
0.0065460834,
-0.0317108408,
-0.024806669,
0.0395000391,
-0.0137128979,
0.0301819034,
0.045018699,
0.0261355564,
0.014318821,
-0.0026132115,
-0.0896662027,
-0.1034539118,
0.0140422974,
0.0224847849,
0.0299237967,
0.0214007311,
-0.0139275501,
-0.0851729065,
-0.0173105355,
-0.0109398393,
0.0151609741,
0.003225463,
-0.0342652425,
0.0330405086,
0.018039478,
-0.0346215665,
-0.0368514508,
0.0562147573,
-0.0234638751,
0.035168685,
0.0083313296,
-0.0052941497,
-0.0037868284,
-0.0159425959,
0.0145587828,
0.0109280413,
-0.0089831827,
0.010375279,
-0.0593877099,
-0.0924145952,
0.0047628419,
0.0110201612,
0.0052715386,
0.0027859223,
0.0265668631,
0.0848810822,
-0.0326436758,
-0.0209751762,
0.0080715325,
0.0454428308,
-0.0176919159,
-0.0329244845,
-0.0027156034,
-5.920761538e-33,
0.0063155615,
-0.0237584226,
0.0198197495,
0.0378025994,
0.0109918648,
-0.026946811,
-0.0452513918,
-0.0092740711,
-0.0582180992,
0.0128331119,
-0.015177995,
0.0299045388,
0.0001055448,
0.0113626057,
0.0362949707,
-0.0121173142,
-0.0094027221,
-0.038493149,
-0.0338724926,
0.0108974921,
0.0298903119,
-0.0026625397,
0.1094246358,
-0.0379016735,
0.0220220368,
-0.0132286344,
-0.0069336612,
0.0044418592,
-0.079836674,
0.0429992229,
-0.0379638933,
0.0324987397,
0.0207281653,
-0.0220073387,
0.0135997292,
-0.0054057357,
0.0061177691,
-0.0558591187,
0.0269747209,
0.0061682286,
-0.037968196,
-0.0157475844,
0.0526842177,
-0.0026556798,
-0.0581278875,
0.0003656093,
0.0418275371,
-0.0188365541,
-0.0063939253,
0.022328509,
-0.0312341619,
0.0209793039,
0.0105552785,
0.0087224599,
0.0188544095,
0.0038434346,
-0.0110870022,
-0.0213725753,
-0.0404753238,
0.0088820308,
0.0237901937,
-0.0029377132,
0.017963564,
-0.0439104103,
0.0321519822,
0.0290517844,
0.0363075212,
-0.0430800207,
-0.0265201386,
-0.0196142774,
0.0416234471,
0.0343745612,
0.0473574325,
0.0140763391,
0.063828975,
0.0165009648,
-0.0440462232,
-0.0232856926,
-0.0054246481,
0.0201682057,
0.0415095687,
-0.0191126503,
-0.0516720451,
-0.004302734,
-0.0102236019,
0.0067779282,
-0.0562805124,
-0.0139769837,
0.0364416167,
-0.0122446921,
0.0185588058,
0.0308262259,
0.0031076618,
-0.0513440929,
-0.0254935697,
0.0024960912,
-0.0063803559,
0.0135075916,
0.0127857588,
0.0328451172,
-0.0576527528,
-0.0099427784,
-0.0554631129,
0.0311799534,
0.0281590633,
0.0106066493,
0.0234416761,
0.0466304943,
-0.0089141158,
-0.0202296246,
-0.0300713051,
-0.0221308824,
0.054835692,
-0.0176272951,
0.0479249395,
0.045730751,
0.0114724943,
-0.0070432588,
-0.0031567146,
-0.0166622568,
-0.056828104,
0.0414097421,
-0.0066381246,
-0.0049142446,
-0.0024379785,
-0.0227018613,
0.0010539448,
0.0249380842,
0.0486035608,
-0.0764905512,
-0.0112476898,
0.0269219484,
2.887e-7,
0.0485591069,
0.0335797928,
0.0051772441,
0.024071835,
0.0316852964,
0.0285646804,
-0.0594053827,
-0.0180227254,
-0.0019446563,
-0.006788787,
0.025973741,
0.0372263677,
0.0426366553,
0.035372477,
-0.0546751469,
0.0190715734,
-0.0674768686,
-0.0137248477,
-0.0490287505,
0.0350884162,
0.0453837663,
0.0835107565,
0.0696811527,
0.0067044841,
-0.0160633139,
-0.0454274006,
0.0902983993,
-0.0103053311,
0.0266888365,
0.0134412199,
0.0000179065,
0.0101363789,
-0.0001556101,
0.0248429682,
-0.0089288298,
0.040523231,
0.0249694157,
0.0479552299,
0.0177872051,
0.0127280885,
-0.0414487571,
-0.0326150507,
-0.0013674052,
-0.0879413486,
0.0652280673,
-0.0551990457,
-0.0573724061,
0.0136027327,
-0.0016537667,
-0.0266303476,
0.0432990156,
0.0147422701,
0.0007046248,
-0.0118382145,
0.0008608768,
-0.003042578,
0.0226256009,
-0.0612745956,
0.0214648116,
0.0289526656,
-0.0955388695,
-0.0300761238,
-0.0503943115,
-0.0058378773,
0.0504900664,
-0.0046086079,
-0.0179852359,
2.593394693e-34,
0.0374970585,
-0.0306923203,
0.0318907052,
-0.0052882819,
0.0245577488,
0.0025188774,
0.0462403819,
0.005623966,
0.0274690725,
-0.0635540634,
-0.0435297452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07617v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07617v1 | CLAMP: A Contrastive Language And Molecule Pre-training Network | 2023-11-12T07:45:35 | 2023-11-12T07:45:35 | Neel Redkar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, 8.2.D.2.5 | This paper highlights a shift in how to approach material generation. Instead
of material-to-material, we propose a language-to-material generation
architecture that utilizes millions of untapped data points. Using a web
scraper to collect crystal text pairs from open-source research papers, a
contrastive model can be trained using a convolutional graph neural network
encoder and a language encoder. This would allow unsupervised zero-shot
classification which can be trained by taking advantage of linguistic
structure. Without any specific training data, an ~82\% accuracy was achieved
and ~75\% accuracy for photocatalyst prediction with an extremely small
dataset. This novel network could ideally be cross-applied to any reaction that
can be described via text, opening completely new methods to think about 3D
chemical framework generation. In the full experiment diffusion models would
likely be incorporated to fully exploit the latent space. | [
-0.0033100802,
0.0926024541,
0.0037929746,
0.0489782244,
-0.0139967324,
-0.0258908886,
0.0250425003,
0.0241201241,
0.0261049028,
0.0080710547,
-0.0215291958,
-0.0249383338,
-0.0252664685,
0.0673727021,
0.0501491427,
-0.0300759636,
0.0039182827,
-0.0085140802,
-0.0062427912,
-0.0417563468,
0.0036484241,
0.0056443699,
0.0169645082,
0.0076115327,
0.0316441804,
0.0048958561,
-0.0413716994,
0.0311108772,
0.012919927,
-0.0569853298,
0.0199718978,
0.0295739025,
0.0327860415,
0.0081253415,
0.0000019296,
-0.0599867031,
0.0042663445,
0.0133391917,
0.0233373512,
-0.0242051221,
0.0477649942,
-0.073918134,
-0.0152970767,
-0.0104505336,
-0.0302009303,
-0.014092247,
0.0563546233,
0.0408410467,
0.0039813127,
0.0205137655,
-0.0326615013,
-0.0175327118,
0.0619485825,
0.0151944393,
0.067420356,
-0.0056372499,
0.0181625318,
0.0225233398,
-0.0039564907,
0.008600465,
-0.0294716414,
0.0480038784,
-0.0006668101,
-0.0108992076,
0.0651036128,
0.0157357492,
-0.0472907647,
-0.0315611921,
-0.0156655759,
0.1125977784,
-0.0349835306,
-0.0448068678,
-0.078652814,
-0.0393493772,
-0.0859775245,
0.0244648736,
-0.0263323169,
-0.0087058982,
0.0188570395,
0.0372676998,
-0.0076653725,
-0.0177681502,
0.0282505266,
0.0186527185,
0.0277913976,
-0.0037560828,
0.0010405009,
-0.011160695,
0.0250970554,
0.0261250529,
0.0057038004,
0.0149020357,
-0.0257627573,
-0.0034449901,
0.0226259641,
-0.0156181743,
0.0264317561,
0.0061517544,
0.0074737817,
-0.063526392,
0.0462141037,
0.0239929128,
0.0053205267,
0.0301424712,
-0.0711121038,
-0.0013486095,
-0.022747213,
0.0207006149,
-0.0790053606,
-0.0013480415,
-0.026915079,
-0.0091560977,
-0.0347851515,
0.0210355315,
-0.012647232,
-0.0431663133,
-0.0366439149,
0.0214738008,
0.0043758391,
-0.0234326702,
-0.0080688866,
0.0782683119,
-0.0045790952,
0.000716173,
-0.0104548847,
0.0108690923,
0.0486682653,
0.0075104213,
-0.0234717168,
-0.0450216085,
-0.0553258397,
0.0124387797,
0.026083637,
0.0061998102,
0.0077424715,
0.095998995,
-0.033726342,
-0.0192981753,
-0.006799086,
-0.0424941853,
0.0297589041,
-0.0137993284,
0.0398034453,
-0.0587920584,
0.0702626333,
0.0642126873,
-0.0025105956,
-0.0870811492,
0.0072141681,
-0.029319074,
-0.0099467114,
0.1244420186,
-0.0209398493,
-0.0850068778,
-0.0029109744,
0.0032012681,
0.0309654884,
0.0025364282,
0.0149363987,
0.024270935,
-0.0346524119,
0.0158128403,
-0.0239315256,
0.0111182807,
0.0303318854,
-0.0281708222,
-0.0450087674,
-0.0327132083,
-0.024673745,
0.0449393317,
0.0320608839,
0.0062768189,
-0.0202202089,
-0.0211187694,
0.0015566719,
0.040361017,
0.0271679554,
0.0474264994,
0.013579458,
0.032368701,
0.01072409,
-0.0501936376,
-0.0156198945,
0.0368837155,
-0.0091108335,
-0.0322563797,
0.0346075594,
-0.0128579652,
-0.0204372946,
-0.0154712535,
-0.0079614148,
-0.009678361,
0.0391329303,
-0.0660170168,
0.0566198267,
-0.0384688415,
-0.1032942235,
0.0314605944,
0.0168956369,
-0.0155865159,
-0.0206438825,
-0.0143661695,
-0.0121295704,
0.069632642,
0.0474472977,
-0.0424664393,
-0.0306077786,
0.0462632366,
-0.0375774801,
0.0011346644,
0.0011864367,
-0.0092272637,
0.0298989285,
-0.0076074991,
-0.0461256132,
-0.0600834489,
-0.012746037,
0.0013924877,
-0.0226885527,
-0.0011836271,
0.0171519686,
0.0047813863,
-0.0349645838,
0.0046391306,
-0.0020031396,
-0.0325936936,
0.0156203471,
-0.0104612801,
0.0447314866,
0.0094441408,
0.0231413078,
0.0061800489,
0.0660736561,
-0.0473792702,
-0.003520071,
-0.0411405042,
-0.0359767564,
-0.0911120698,
0.0438264757,
-0.0469664261,
0.0714613274,
-0.0162228961,
-0.0232150555,
-0.0166985281,
0.0898613408,
0.028742902,
0.0559512228,
0.0006892263,
-0.0287964754,
0.0233816206,
0.0780483708,
-0.0225304253,
0.0387513302,
0.0059796469,
0.0196280628,
-0.0075335698,
0.0383467227,
0.0290511735,
-0.009797385,
0.0446011722,
-0.0156903882,
0.0533476435,
0.0358104967,
0.0289866012,
-0.0049036536,
-0.0034347887,
0.0186964814,
0.0218825992,
-0.02008464,
-0.0181711912,
0.0203605145,
0.0409386419,
-0.0414573736,
0.022899067,
-0.0083368104,
0.0114943497,
0.0186939631,
-0.0446745418,
-0.0698087364,
0.03876362,
0.0024174198,
-0.0238320883,
-0.0341767631,
-0.0590579771,
-0.0498299673,
0.0847851709,
0.0441362448,
-0.0564525872,
0.025136847,
0.0448296145,
0.0276349243,
0.0530769899,
-0.013953574,
-0.012249996,
0.0122667961,
-0.0401763953,
-0.0019405439,
0.0086352993,
-0.0011278227,
0.022075519,
0.0395714864,
0.0168024842,
-0.0218746867,
-0.0249267016,
-0.0355037786,
0.0417590588,
0.0530602597,
-0.039568726,
-0.0322302543,
0.0258359965,
0.0001339378,
0.0384984016,
-0.0282881111,
0.0232667215,
0.0455279797,
-0.0288229976,
-0.0147658996,
0.0059717419,
0.034523923,
-0.0405414589,
-0.0162070598,
-0.0329233967,
0.0485145375,
-0.0151398275,
0.0027113629,
-0.0236213636,
-0.0162320193,
0.0117146708,
0.0153100202,
0.0650466084,
0.0473683141,
0.0248843823,
0.0264051482,
-0.0314577036,
-0.0439270362,
0.0441604666,
0.0081069525,
-0.0221145134,
-0.0202791411,
0.0380702727,
0.0075843791,
-0.0243421402,
-0.0138783241,
0.0028127083,
0.0077691698,
0.0611535795,
-0.0030424981,
-0.0037034974,
0.0303424094,
0.0232622121,
0.0196664333,
-0.0001306876,
-0.0020417515,
-0.0131113287,
-0.0552184694,
0.0692789629,
-0.0173934158,
-0.040680211,
0.0075162244,
-0.0320562199,
0.0287183858,
0.0466668196,
0.0105716642,
-0.0139723718,
-0.0670227259,
0.0303456113,
0.0141678285,
0.074843429,
0.0031563458,
-0.0139413485,
-0.0057582115,
-0.0276949108,
-0.0075692888,
0.0240619462,
0.0169752445,
-0.0443075895,
-0.0051381933,
0.0611235686,
-0.0129310293,
-0.011451927,
0.002941875,
-0.0767402574,
-0.0396482162,
-0.0657409057,
0.0302696265,
0.0094618807,
-0.0032990589,
-0.022060357,
-0.0591589957,
0.0267726667,
-0.0008023009,
-0.0593885779,
-0.0170262419,
-0.0549273081,
-0.0560901091,
-0.0107731475,
-0.0164515618,
0.0243985858,
-0.0205321014,
-0.0288425013,
0.0210047998,
-0.0110287033,
-0.0650071725,
0.0150193749,
0.0044022338,
-0.0572304204,
0.0188050605,
0.0084605571,
-0.0195036884,
0.0076770177,
0.031738922,
-0.0112391124,
0.0164595749,
-0.0464318432,
0.0545582995,
0.0473575071,
-0.0158027336,
0.021868296,
0.0532312468,
-0.0436065644,
-0.0661248341,
-0.0726689696,
0.0692093819,
-0.0235822089,
0.0108942138,
-0.0356778726,
-0.0017802274,
0.0285224207,
0.0022108625,
-0.0196843557,
-0.0115945814,
-0.1193195283,
-0.024116708,
0.0326454379,
-0.0829721093,
-0.0198144,
-0.0439153872,
-0.0124323685,
-0.000316536,
-0.0155329555,
0.0058989637,
-0.0345286652,
0.0125575904,
-0.0575340018,
-0.0256380551,
0.024984682,
-0.0425120629,
-0.0811273828,
0.0191741996,
0.0183931105,
-0.0093784984,
-0.0190771651,
-0.0818667039,
0.028208049,
-0.0597719997,
-0.0115218172,
0.0536524542,
-0.0459318981,
-0.0447116531,
-0.020393515,
0.0445061252,
0.0129397148,
0.0527292453,
0.0012079212,
-0.0182056688,
0.0961689427,
0.0606484003,
-0.0156519059,
-0.015080343,
0.0021729842,
-0.0149115138,
-0.0400536507,
-0.0097131841,
-0.0211355761,
0.0431585498,
-0.0069989837,
-0.0223611277,
-0.0124061694,
-0.0276288539,
0.0308120884,
0.0067148912,
0.0451708622,
0.038101539,
0.0444774628,
-0.0226700082,
-0.0433915891,
0.0545218252,
0.0238958858,
-0.0519315749,
-0.0109055927,
0.0376846977,
-0.042776756,
-0.0084392186,
-0.0177893955,
-0.0064710444,
-0.0080089718,
-0.0020700968,
0.0399097018,
0.0373165384,
0.0295432471,
0.0959720612,
-0.0201046132,
-0.0099050831,
-0.0023066802,
-0.0539642982,
0.0181635376,
-0.0252633691,
-0.0194389876,
0.0192286931,
0.0981752276,
-0.0488376953,
0.0393772721,
-0.0175419301,
-0.0520103797,
-0.1023938954,
0.0035733629,
0.0585537218,
0.0141708087,
0.0372955762,
-0.0144002642,
-0.0304222554,
-0.0104074972,
0.0532819293,
-0.0203776229,
-0.0317467451,
0.0344298296,
0.0254041087,
-0.0062492513,
-0.0096428711,
0.0793273225,
0.0284037888,
0.0025092852,
0.0019415722,
-0.0287216417,
-0.0297713783,
-0.0128439125,
-0.0472152829,
-0.0144695891,
0.0204201061,
0.0147661418,
-0.0193116907,
-0.0310170501,
0.0198876895,
0.0403745584,
-0.0164037216,
0.0188805722,
0.0461365283,
0.0497769043,
0.0039498443,
-0.0454305112,
0.0014229263,
0.0115363644,
0.0019059611,
-0.0257471651,
-0.0155610479,
-5.743703068e-33,
0.0207242463,
-0.0157635063,
-0.0220662113,
0.0241618045,
0.009006354,
-0.0112312632,
-0.1008650064,
-0.0406572185,
0.00242849,
0.0431646854,
0.023749182,
0.0047192285,
0.0271682609,
-0.0249710009,
0.0122466376,
0.0413331799,
-0.00760007,
0.0241244175,
0.0064464863,
0.0563931242,
0.0374257006,
0.0423534103,
0.0427367054,
-0.0281853657,
-0.0086864671,
0.0304072667,
0.0051547983,
-0.0384563617,
0.0083530014,
0.0387249701,
-0.0350802168,
0.0541417561,
-0.0286543183,
0.0004867894,
-0.0064517567,
-0.0193278659,
-0.0497745685,
-0.014267344,
-0.0206087902,
-0.0018375106,
-0.0568034835,
0.0296870098,
0.0140705397,
-0.002710735,
-0.0679131299,
0.0044337302,
0.0465607196,
-0.0075842356,
0.0481587984,
-0.0188915059,
-0.0702736229,
0.0045945668,
0.0131606469,
0.0090195118,
-0.0002342805,
0.0325952731,
-0.0029250721,
0.0302721784,
-0.0587361157,
0.0524868704,
0.0144058699,
-0.0042195669,
0.0351888202,
0.0645947829,
0.0108240191,
0.018523382,
0.0159673281,
-0.0009127053,
0.0250331108,
0.0234563518,
0.0099934619,
0.070656009,
0.0514038168,
0.0153173702,
0.0283718221,
-0.0073035532,
-0.1352588832,
-0.014724032,
-0.0513830855,
0.0182547495,
0.0097764144,
0.0402595922,
0.0435786024,
-0.0774146914,
0.0205852017,
0.0007701447,
0.016550364,
-0.0307666007,
-0.0414910242,
-0.0106471255,
-0.0759709477,
-0.0232018568,
-0.0047487714,
-0.0540747084,
-0.0238196757,
0.0959772542,
-0.0289708916,
0.0330821909,
-0.0088142091,
0.011979213,
-0.0901369676,
-0.0584724471,
-0.0318693593,
0.0286325328,
0.0276581496,
-0.0151663786,
-0.0043793442,
0.0686254129,
0.018354496,
-0.013149647,
-0.081246525,
-0.0135108689,
0.0329122655,
0.0242321324,
0.0025176525,
-0.004434526,
-0.0225615446,
0.031888321,
-0.0265357774,
0.0147151481,
0.0538680479,
0.0205685124,
0.0045603211,
0.0552326404,
-0.0730761886,
-0.0047638626,
-0.063915804,
0.0486108959,
0.0469041876,
-0.0772320405,
-0.0025564767,
0.0170189515,
2.751e-7,
0.077395685,
0.023507813,
0.0480443016,
-0.0081973393,
-0.0340070389,
0.0118832616,
0.0250126161,
0.0217135828,
-0.0431725532,
-0.0059670932,
0.03928243,
0.033510264,
-0.0077524302,
0.0132605573,
-0.0269846469,
0.0669166669,
-0.0020989045,
-0.008558467,
-0.0236904789,
0.0161781069,
0.0027230433,
0.0606936775,
-0.0036050398,
-0.0256949645,
0.0230783559,
-0.0262077451,
0.0432423912,
-0.0074009951,
0.0050794971,
0.0435007513,
-0.0356903486,
-0.0515542515,
-0.0469526984,
0.0357654728,
-0.0293114595,
-0.0072125145,
0.0206032898,
-0.0240388494,
-0.0318723023,
-0.0117895249,
0.0257555339,
-0.0301637091,
0.0266219433,
0.0065289745,
0.0261333473,
-0.0239985939,
-0.0265300665,
0.0372574814,
-0.0170200951,
0.0138173802,
0.0346094705,
-0.0151167614,
0.0240348,
-0.0163502134,
-0.0216819718,
-0.0027598904,
-0.0039372472,
-0.0329507142,
-0.0204454362,
0.0340192579,
-0.0000604194,
0.0007623966,
-0.02532617,
-0.0335653163,
0.0222710986,
0.0219571237,
0.0252336636,
2.10709796e-34,
0.0713238716,
-0.0054887775,
0.0023370446,
-0.0278636664,
0.0066269175,
-0.0212468039,
-0.0122378254,
-0.000852584,
0.0098159006,
-0.0392517149,
-0.023721952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06761v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06761v1 | Learning Knowledge-Enhanced Contextual Language Representations for Domain Natural Language Understanding | 2023-11-12T07:37:24 | 2023-11-12T07:37:24 | Ruyao Xu, Taolin Zhang, Chengyu Wang, Zhongjie Duan, Cen Chen, Minghui Qiu, Dawei Cheng, Xiaofeng He, Weining Qian | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge-Enhanced Pre-trained Language Models (KEPLMs) improve the
performance of various downstream NLP tasks by injecting knowledge facts from
large-scale Knowledge Graphs (KGs). However, existing methods for pre-training
KEPLMs with relational triples are difficult to be adapted to close domains due
to the lack of sufficient domain graph semantics. In this paper, we propose a
Knowledge-enhanced lANGuAge Representation learning framework for various
clOsed dOmains (KANGAROO) via capturing the implicit graph structure among the
entities. Specifically, since the entity coverage rates of closed-domain KGs
can be relatively low and may exhibit the global sparsity phenomenon for
knowledge injection, we consider not only the shallow relational
representations of triples but also the hyperbolic embeddings of deep
hierarchical entity-class structures for effective knowledge fusion.Moreover,
as two closed-domain entities under the same entity-class often have locally
dense neighbor subgraphs counted by max point biconnected component, we further
propose a data augmentation strategy based on contrastive learning over
subgraphs to construct hard negative samples of higher quality. It makes the
underlying KELPMs better distinguish the semantics of these neighboring
entities to further complement the global semantic sparsity. In the
experiments, we evaluate KANGAROO over various knowledge-aware and general NLP
tasks in both full and few-shot learning settings, outperforming various KEPLM
training paradigms performance in closed-domains significantly. | [
0.0210555512,
-0.0074446811,
0.0087843621,
0.047699552,
-0.0121527221,
-0.0029704596,
-0.03711408,
-0.022243537,
0.0472267643,
-0.1027551964,
-0.0293814465,
-0.0115196863,
-0.0192830879,
0.0368997753,
0.0339929536,
-0.0402762443,
0.0356878452,
0.0200787075,
0.0022739468,
-0.0026367616,
0.0034700441,
0.0136328749,
-0.0165864751,
0.0021242276,
-0.0116726412,
-0.0130805681,
-0.0000339636,
0.0115222177,
0.0317374729,
-0.0558510758,
0.0022115833,
0.0212860033,
0.0604788437,
-0.0098527959,
0.0000020162,
-0.0652466714,
-0.0225728434,
-0.0065057739,
-0.0440898351,
-0.0131628439,
0.0028660086,
-0.0649626702,
0.0408637226,
-0.0127215609,
-0.0417751335,
-0.0715854391,
0.0094569735,
0.0797327235,
0.0473184958,
0.0782252252,
-0.0255211946,
-0.0367345065,
0.0361701511,
-0.0312466342,
-0.0065960963,
-0.0426215641,
0.0173505805,
0.0399456918,
0.0097592399,
0.0134908967,
-0.0272621959,
0.0045271441,
0.0207470413,
-0.0080421837,
0.0537351109,
0.0459716804,
-0.0302994531,
0.0227033347,
0.0095597822,
0.1112990081,
-0.0132853305,
0.0074114259,
-0.0305659734,
-0.0264840107,
-0.003852091,
0.0110992584,
0.0125650233,
-0.0229041111,
0.0070470977,
0.0152108362,
-0.0171541292,
0.0155950515,
0.03974903,
0.0024528753,
-0.0135092894,
0.0413421839,
0.0152802635,
-0.040562097,
0.0294270366,
0.0256131217,
-0.0551372133,
-0.0185603257,
-0.0061724447,
0.0239193086,
0.0224614628,
0.0297480766,
-0.0193206817,
0.0101021063,
0.0046750456,
-0.0338489674,
-0.0039452435,
0.0322438702,
-0.0079693086,
0.066658102,
-0.0533460602,
0.015462894,
-0.0196115244,
0.0229793452,
-0.0309304968,
-0.0220121946,
-0.0557483584,
-0.0016899636,
-0.0273559988,
0.0684531778,
-0.0239655189,
-0.0284505319,
-0.0326911956,
0.025696842,
-0.0296872333,
0.0017527698,
0.0141175017,
0.0431818701,
0.0084534967,
-0.0308302157,
-0.0340683274,
0.0464883149,
-0.0340130404,
0.0469525829,
-0.042307429,
0.0014393989,
-0.0118406806,
-0.0020386255,
0.0306429509,
-0.0260991454,
0.0033445465,
0.0727965087,
0.0305646658,
-0.0512239933,
-0.0548928939,
-0.0198330097,
-0.0045599998,
-0.0295954328,
0.0209124964,
-0.0398524739,
0.0279237181,
0.0025199524,
-0.01046969,
-0.0580546111,
0.0184658356,
-0.0290343612,
-0.0205306914,
0.0829715282,
-0.0517363362,
-0.0478511676,
-0.0186517686,
0.0081387619,
-0.0352894925,
0.0679251775,
0.0066802092,
-0.0252825674,
0.0081913564,
0.0022070331,
-0.0539910644,
-0.0334530249,
0.0643889084,
0.0279418472,
0.0124860695,
0.0092271054,
-0.0103368983,
0.0260447282,
0.0786828697,
0.0141042722,
-0.0203139894,
0.0021111604,
0.0147069301,
-0.0131534953,
-0.0091029666,
-0.0130905043,
0.0516900681,
0.0152484244,
-0.0104454998,
0.0173144713,
-0.0467565507,
0.0018423229,
-0.0211401079,
0.0160329472,
0.015883347,
0.0069865552,
-0.0211100373,
-0.011233083,
0.0282432288,
-0.0339011513,
0.0479619205,
0.0136398962,
0.0536776595,
0.0173228383,
-0.0552372225,
0.0456227362,
0.0565710701,
-0.0099204835,
0.0099732773,
0.0469577461,
-0.0164500717,
0.0537366308,
0.0055191997,
-0.026513692,
-0.0341098718,
-0.0080218408,
-0.0225935336,
0.0188197717,
0.0262153372,
-0.0126662878,
0.0222316515,
-0.0397059955,
-0.075093165,
-0.0526361801,
-0.0070820535,
0.039715372,
0.0151100745,
0.0158250965,
0.0566077642,
-0.0552813113,
0.024216393,
-0.0048630387,
-0.0404698513,
-0.0090038972,
0.0062724664,
0.0467044078,
-0.0146254469,
0.0349780209,
-0.0066061295,
0.0053971321,
0.0258388389,
-0.0527187251,
-0.0695174783,
-0.0123444451,
-0.058949437,
-0.1056497097,
0.0394760929,
-0.0176465809,
-0.0152644385,
-0.0060711713,
-0.0197411887,
-0.0423980765,
0.0027595493,
0.015644297,
0.0958713293,
-0.0282007679,
-0.0219833385,
0.0275597945,
-0.001834569,
-0.0136508849,
0.1000614986,
0.0002535208,
0.0068006506,
-0.0064169313,
0.0022673155,
0.0111892121,
0.0238271225,
-0.014284594,
-0.0476348177,
0.0187778082,
0.0027045417,
0.0209315885,
-0.008018787,
-0.0779768378,
0.0508425981,
-0.0700787455,
0.0184738301,
0.0112916837,
-0.0035388428,
-0.0028740014,
0.0011521442,
0.0349025242,
-0.0222827885,
-0.0243282579,
0.0010188147,
-0.0347098447,
0.0074478285,
0.0331326164,
0.0124202874,
-0.0027213206,
-0.0027793415,
0.0031951354,
-0.0294626355,
0.0516759045,
-0.0164091848,
0.0099739702,
0.0214380492,
0.1001657918,
-0.0144909825,
0.0448767915,
-0.0136782397,
0.013544526,
-0.0319605917,
0.0020740225,
0.0137282629,
0.0330851898,
-0.0400290787,
-0.0004949964,
0.0147746354,
-0.0018502915,
-0.0311000999,
0.0130455736,
-0.0241850335,
0.0231118277,
-0.0298963767,
0.0525966473,
-0.020453915,
0.0524003245,
-0.0055216043,
-0.054012306,
-0.0639740676,
-0.0324583389,
-0.018076757,
-0.0304023251,
-0.0185398962,
-0.0086021302,
0.0029281136,
-0.0088815847,
-0.0589862876,
0.0004941141,
0.0712337047,
-0.0063143121,
0.0112799434,
0.0071270838,
-0.0134795727,
-0.0551053099,
0.0380563363,
-0.0049586887,
0.0070330654,
0.0248734467,
-0.0260119494,
-0.0416591205,
0.0103406748,
0.0073463446,
-0.0053122458,
0.0270041432,
0.0111198081,
0.0248213988,
-0.0096848672,
-0.0378560349,
-0.0515076667,
-0.0187252909,
-0.013249564,
0.0418800265,
0.0064653065,
0.0122769391,
-0.0166550037,
-0.0068305512,
-0.0048191738,
-0.0009721892,
0.029679561,
-0.0254251137,
-0.0199624151,
0.0739912987,
0.02507516,
0.0165957101,
0.0146829737,
0.0279119182,
0.0306021683,
0.0286270734,
0.0039061266,
-0.0082043344,
-0.001925857,
0.0110408524,
-0.018548036,
-0.0066264076,
-0.0447996296,
-0.0231091548,
0.0322531164,
-0.0134171918,
0.0155150509,
0.1217849627,
0.0201299079,
-0.0219062064,
-0.0046182498,
0.0214652326,
-0.0004832128,
0.0465607494,
-0.0114050778,
-0.1046076342,
-0.0396145619,
-0.0233794916,
-0.0301920511,
0.0262068603,
-0.0588936619,
-0.012429351,
-0.1623147577,
-0.0509182215,
0.0059142755,
-0.0086445929,
-0.0404943042,
-0.0175964031,
0.016920276,
0.0099646309,
-0.0078454698,
-0.0737114176,
-0.0003038495,
-0.0023771722,
0.0177037995,
0.0205578413,
-0.0395770632,
0.0298917945,
-0.06016206,
0.0264213216,
-0.0378316008,
0.0401612595,
-0.0052839913,
-0.0029234509,
-0.0005376961,
-0.0117416438,
-0.0028825002,
-0.0023497655,
0.0397975519,
-0.0477533489,
-0.0047526858,
0.0059854076,
-0.0123180235,
-0.0823712721,
-0.0160328094,
-0.0285974294,
0.0979223475,
-0.0190219339,
0.010641994,
-0.0197906829,
-0.0191887282,
0.0135113318,
0.0517736189,
-0.0129374256,
-0.0102469968,
0.0280448142,
0.011554718,
0.0191322323,
-0.026585618,
-0.0089879995,
0.0515359491,
-0.0171739776,
0.0225117225,
-0.0485287234,
-0.0560809709,
0.0500657856,
0.0107125966,
0.0167295597,
0.0226675663,
0.0143780326,
-0.0057152212,
-0.0685172826,
0.0052512311,
-0.0217277799,
0.0216650907,
0.0048447838,
-0.0042507951,
0.0510666817,
-0.0016253183,
-0.0394499265,
-0.0218299422,
-0.0335113667,
-0.0677182078,
-0.0298447926,
0.0049124891,
-0.000604438,
0.0623875856,
-0.0269770175,
0.010795489,
0.0480298735,
0.0451065004,
-0.0855176598,
-0.0101760551,
0.0392549522,
-0.0118716862,
0.0080009252,
0.0298103373,
-0.0579717271,
0.0098682493,
0.0350254551,
0.0374000333,
-0.0294493139,
-0.0564896613,
0.0138320709,
-0.0118703339,
0.0571779758,
0.010225594,
0.0132508827,
-0.0469736122,
0.0004467331,
-0.0458653122,
-0.003766781,
-0.0417730361,
-0.0287679527,
0.0149419252,
-0.0020562597,
0.0084547838,
0.006690016,
0.0199774206,
0.0508532561,
-0.0079149446,
-0.0027469133,
0.0656554699,
-0.0148880919,
0.0238449275,
0.0122724837,
-0.0009829955,
0.0275838282,
0.0163640864,
-0.0166648217,
-0.0413698852,
0.0132974116,
0.0138500966,
-0.0114868125,
-0.0501485206,
0.000641101,
-0.0223938804,
0.0210336503,
0.0166714434,
0.0110079078,
0.0831942931,
-0.0208059009,
0.0192660112,
-0.0105906175,
0.0023508477,
-0.006088302,
0.0351109244,
-0.0341981575,
-0.0204320177,
0.0514065214,
0.0307729281,
-0.0164224338,
0.0283003636,
0.0617482029,
0.0264316462,
0.0624554716,
-0.0073372764,
0.0152129047,
-0.0344512798,
0.0063406937,
0.044836577,
0.0780805126,
-0.013140576,
0.0821856558,
-0.0656739026,
-0.1109347641,
0.0109898746,
-0.0570231862,
-0.0714078397,
0.0309577156,
0.0439210832,
-0.0009986162,
0.0100260768,
-0.0310913566,
-0.0180500783,
0.0372951068,
-0.0198197793,
0.0276632905,
0.0165277254,
-6.472185203e-33,
-0.040668115,
-0.0305813272,
-0.0022555995,
-0.015337212,
-0.0389325656,
0.0246863812,
-0.0209104437,
-0.0171973985,
-0.0305884015,
0.0150529379,
0.0103189889,
0.0214011669,
-0.0119370092,
0.0269546025,
-0.0387097783,
-0.0111787105,
0.0374349616,
0.0421520993,
0.0375628956,
0.0124279317,
0.0666863024,
0.0572054833,
0.0653778017,
-0.0830465555,
0.0186978746,
0.0019855972,
0.0182533599,
0.0442504138,
0.0474223681,
0.0253294092,
-0.0300719924,
0.0702674612,
0.0308368169,
-0.0505716652,
0.0105627505,
0.008699487,
-0.1136799529,
-0.0460790098,
0.0271745156,
-0.0034346574,
-0.0214664433,
-0.038060341,
0.0422237255,
0.0234424323,
0.0781937838,
-0.0416316465,
0.0310261622,
-0.0120435227,
-0.0375813358,
-0.0438352525,
-0.054567039,
0.0211803485,
0.001283791,
0.0118767889,
-0.0160334203,
-0.006934213,
0.0414645374,
0.004275464,
-0.0896254703,
-0.0043347692,
-0.0450355224,
-0.0105948402,
0.0032580039,
0.0027071754,
0.0174077619,
0.0649930686,
-0.0166059006,
0.0270862449,
0.0079674991,
0.0190593135,
0.0276748016,
0.0390545949,
-0.0337896198,
0.0654196814,
0.0180582795,
-0.0247694477,
-0.0694619343,
0.0105724623,
-0.0351682752,
0.01436501,
-0.0271239281,
0.0284159053,
-0.0381887592,
-0.0223672614,
-0.0265909266,
0.0185507704,
-0.015470095,
-0.0538786165,
0.0047313576,
0.0010612225,
-0.0172540303,
0.031219501,
-0.0093316315,
-0.0644302666,
-0.0118534258,
0.060560111,
0.0096881632,
0.0080750817,
-0.0095574623,
0.0298866034,
-0.0508975424,
-0.0420089588,
0.0319717377,
-0.0144110806,
0.0101477476,
0.0041052275,
0.0644870251,
-0.0108858803,
-0.0600800402,
-0.0192087255,
-0.0302215386,
-0.0278601535,
0.0022810129,
0.0277993679,
0.0355445705,
0.0593514852,
-0.0239879247,
0.0472709984,
0.044442758,
-0.019161405,
0.0012795965,
0.0344845057,
0.0208601337,
0.035926085,
-0.0139117222,
-0.0358562171,
-0.0186305065,
-0.023510078,
0.0311746541,
-0.077507481,
-0.0355214365,
-0.0508969724,
2.781e-7,
0.0516419709,
-0.0021366784,
0.012310504,
0.0144086042,
-0.007176382,
0.0570115335,
0.0092189787,
0.0427438579,
0.0043745562,
-0.0406066291,
0.0106027722,
0.0277082119,
-0.0439782888,
0.0374844261,
-0.0976252854,
0.0403345488,
0.0299953446,
-0.0331027135,
-0.0068880054,
0.0349784344,
0.0909982547,
0.0904959142,
0.046993494,
-0.0059916587,
-0.0109444521,
-0.0668425411,
0.0646101162,
0.0407053009,
-0.0179450065,
-0.0276230127,
-0.0241418555,
0.0457516126,
-0.0229219943,
0.0738761574,
-0.0249966793,
0.0443044826,
0.0319163464,
0.0121225491,
-0.0004971919,
-0.0261163544,
-0.0076539321,
-0.020187486,
0.0054704412,
-0.0058611943,
0.1038895175,
-0.0879265592,
-0.0346090868,
0.0096102906,
-0.0424884334,
-0.0232065655,
-0.0096007548,
0.0274894852,
-0.0004936592,
-0.0098233549,
0.0090730907,
-0.006136918,
-0.0148425037,
-0.0829647779,
-0.0005891022,
0.0521529876,
0.004961059,
-0.0302042719,
0.009245717,
-0.0262598507,
0.078071028,
-0.032869719,
0.0398494303,
2.620007242e-34,
0.0271877199,
0.0150261316,
0.0195279736,
0.0169658083,
0.0197879896,
-0.0368097425,
-0.0291794874,
-0.0411046185,
0.0605788454,
-0.073894538,
0.0300933123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06758v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06758v1 | Sharing, Teaching and Aligning: Knowledgeable Transfer Learning for Cross-Lingual Machine Reading Comprehension | 2023-11-12T07:20:37 | 2023-11-12T07:20:37 | Tingfeng Cao, Chengyu Wang, Chuanqi Tan, Jun Huang, Jinhui Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In cross-lingual language understanding, machine translation is often
utilized to enhance the transferability of models across languages, either by
translating the training data from the source language to the target, or from
the target to the source to aid inference. However, in cross-lingual machine
reading comprehension (MRC), it is difficult to perform a deep level of
assistance to enhance cross-lingual transfer because of the variation of answer
span positions in different languages. In this paper, we propose X-STA, a new
approach for cross-lingual MRC. Specifically, we leverage an attentive teacher
to subtly transfer the answer spans of the source language to the answer output
space of the target. A Gradient-Disentangled Knowledge Sharing technique is
proposed as an improved cross-attention block. In addition, we force the model
to learn semantic alignments from multiple granularities and calibrate the
model outputs with teacher guidance to enhance cross-lingual transferability.
Experiments on three multi-lingual MRC datasets show the effectiveness of our
method, outperforming state-of-the-art approaches. | [
-0.0074256775,
0.0024982286,
-0.0194971878,
0.0837834999,
-0.0301421117,
0.00350034,
0.0118535357,
-0.0797564015,
0.0131040392,
0.0345279723,
-0.0359880887,
0.0017099554,
-0.0045534526,
0.028621411,
-0.0009476222,
-0.0427826084,
0.0580227636,
-0.0312375706,
-0.0449166857,
0.0002410781,
0.0058003054,
0.0249693561,
-0.0019757801,
-0.0226526558,
0.0272070188,
-0.0335416086,
-0.0127291055,
-0.0224854928,
0.0784127489,
-0.0038163264,
-0.0027853337,
0.0143194459,
0.011679749,
0.0213474799,
0.0000019963,
-0.0199933518,
-0.0514761843,
0.0039836718,
-0.0071530365,
-0.0227243826,
-0.0328098722,
-0.0784607232,
0.0251835212,
-0.0250553768,
-0.0176593233,
-0.0025673709,
0.0417395905,
0.0247667134,
0.0817869529,
0.0466607809,
-0.0160813238,
0.0028828257,
0.0231336821,
-0.0287787952,
0.0603283867,
-0.0865937769,
0.0201644413,
0.0621118248,
-0.0201875586,
0.057970982,
-0.0838322416,
0.0943172723,
0.0540203452,
-0.0078741629,
0.011455114,
0.0051729344,
0.0287180115,
-0.0027537376,
-0.0252821147,
0.1130540818,
-0.0067687873,
0.0072397995,
-0.0358662121,
-0.0152310645,
-0.0182637852,
0.0350485668,
-0.0419294685,
-0.0230046175,
0.004389456,
0.0389967524,
0.0284541491,
0.0167886466,
0.0196573865,
0.0075699273,
-0.0164756402,
0.0558637828,
-0.0028702267,
-0.0068393531,
-0.0112049635,
0.045300588,
0.0167721529,
-0.0020107613,
0.0280098021,
0.0403782465,
-0.0012349265,
0.0256182253,
-0.0388291441,
-0.0738788173,
-0.0233181287,
0.0222864263,
0.0136210723,
0.0668808818,
-0.0399432592,
0.0631981641,
-0.0600374602,
0.030720491,
-0.0585960671,
0.0310533345,
-0.0576831102,
-0.0652357638,
-0.0144734988,
-0.0181658026,
-0.0027435946,
0.0085096117,
-0.0831236541,
-0.0311826859,
-0.0154615073,
0.0161208995,
0.0105702635,
0.0069955667,
-0.0121303573,
-0.0005092348,
-0.0579047054,
-0.0275246594,
-0.0173218492,
0.0836718827,
-0.0636472106,
-0.0031132894,
-0.0163810905,
0.0053447592,
-0.0265674163,
0.0088452091,
-0.0338547938,
-0.0682162493,
-0.0262833592,
0.0525918119,
-0.0603965484,
0.0136010479,
-0.0119279251,
-0.0016583541,
0.0190888029,
-0.0430055,
0.0214971453,
-0.0397987925,
0.0764811262,
0.0227970202,
0.0087259598,
-0.0257986002,
-0.0083175655,
-0.0187394544,
-0.0358223394,
0.0885075778,
0.0025379818,
-0.0186427105,
0.0148825729,
0.0016311844,
-0.0060763839,
0.0822905675,
-0.0073535345,
0.0074871331,
0.0378231592,
-0.0185848046,
-0.0441439673,
-0.0017580529,
0.0545916185,
0.014870218,
-0.0014124563,
0.0415755697,
0.0210152641,
0.0121311033,
0.0222679954,
0.0222119261,
-0.0123219118,
-0.0361963622,
0.0563590787,
0.0222777631,
0.0172994211,
0.060056258,
0.0056719459,
0.0131176105,
-0.0524182059,
0.05167358,
-0.0163847823,
0.0717986524,
0.0094109233,
0.008777,
0.0207867976,
0.025622854,
-0.0251624212,
-0.0369414501,
0.0616987571,
0.0193747059,
0.0191937108,
0.0555628128,
0.0504771024,
0.0181564596,
-0.0417711549,
0.0508340821,
0.0264894702,
-0.0323951654,
0.0443195403,
-0.0047169477,
0.0639923662,
0.0527084433,
-0.0008638102,
-0.0179938059,
-0.0386821032,
0.0136520062,
0.0340441763,
0.0281036291,
0.0396770053,
-0.0053335344,
0.041293256,
-0.0490855724,
-0.019432744,
-0.0104265455,
-0.0324920826,
0.0457263328,
0.0053666425,
0.0558852851,
0.0131043941,
-0.0196397994,
-0.005406538,
0.0092197871,
-0.0686634257,
-0.0254083332,
-0.006169104,
0.0289625898,
0.0016658414,
0.0200997517,
0.0324062966,
-0.0222272202,
0.0171153806,
-0.0578791797,
0.0184374098,
-0.0003872116,
-0.0365772508,
-0.0361615755,
-0.0022752564,
-0.0674965158,
-0.0424168594,
0.0311669484,
-0.0277376324,
-0.0580725297,
0.0286132954,
-0.0095388889,
-0.0088721933,
-0.0285275001,
-0.0146088526,
0.0084599322,
0.047006391,
-0.032508526,
0.0247936733,
0.0199144688,
0.0182881262,
0.0196562968,
0.0094981389,
0.0158169307,
0.0229388755,
0.0140040908,
0.0175872892,
0.0126236267,
-0.0202834383,
0.0074436236,
0.0186267141,
-0.0509119891,
-0.0176081862,
-0.0263575576,
0.0296582803,
0.0014234609,
0.0351498723,
0.0343987867,
0.0425211787,
0.0265189167,
-0.0211579446,
-0.0602907054,
0.0067809573,
0.0022962864,
0.0062721167,
0.0507221594,
0.0153422495,
0.0392013453,
-0.031458836,
-0.0211564135,
0.02351317,
0.0212037023,
0.0047842138,
0.0125961909,
-0.0617135353,
0.0025961148,
-0.0320140272,
0.015627902,
-0.0188183486,
-0.0301231891,
-0.0120119993,
-0.0148661081,
0.0111571141,
0.085429199,
-0.0276289005,
0.0123389186,
0.0451185144,
-0.0479548685,
-0.0589781292,
0.0538929589,
-0.0150928078,
-0.0003784319,
-0.0366045423,
-0.0213404279,
-0.0351212136,
0.0652275905,
-0.0085625658,
-0.0343656279,
-0.0595075898,
-0.0322823413,
0.0154322414,
-0.0304546785,
-0.0617044792,
0.0653085262,
0.0179547556,
0.0567682013,
-0.0406454727,
-0.0053472482,
0.1062297076,
-0.0110640628,
-0.0245878287,
-0.0708742887,
0.0165916886,
-0.0486964732,
0.0197033845,
-0.0472425893,
0.0191931576,
-0.0628141314,
-0.0211457573,
-0.0584106036,
-0.0231072642,
0.0488492809,
0.0019598536,
0.0007864179,
-0.0453250781,
-0.009309575,
-0.0239464082,
0.0006403298,
-0.0271958783,
-0.005352058,
-0.0067468071,
-0.020718839,
0.0200182125,
-0.0139013585,
-0.0491454452,
0.0027599765,
0.0641084686,
-0.0134607796,
-0.0293708351,
0.0020275186,
-0.0266118888,
0.0569427609,
0.0436090641,
0.0201181304,
-0.0123951221,
-0.0424277484,
0.0079169339,
0.0436394177,
-0.0352913216,
0.0063865106,
0.0299290437,
0.0319669247,
0.0602799132,
0.0249140393,
0.031293381,
-0.0600220896,
0.0864734948,
-0.0601948984,
-0.0153560368,
0.0311431047,
0.0070882961,
-0.014501119,
-0.034514688,
-0.040254429,
0.0312396679,
-0.0066003297,
0.043867372,
-0.0925890282,
-0.0435575172,
-0.0203305855,
-0.0031560063,
0.0449488163,
0.0082254559,
-0.0131279742,
-0.0894002542,
-0.0263904613,
0.0152556924,
-0.1152642071,
-0.1023263708,
-0.0271879993,
0.0158761386,
-0.0046123229,
0.0546413809,
-0.026520025,
0.0493942127,
-0.0035994891,
-0.0230963957,
0.0716611594,
0.0030410802,
-0.0086200573,
-0.028039556,
-0.0161120873,
0.0591583923,
0.0509874448,
0.0110344803,
-0.0484329499,
-0.0171785988,
-0.0565806143,
-0.0515665002,
-0.001477723,
0.0369232111,
-0.0221065879,
-0.0428583585,
-0.0059660692,
0.0632147491,
-0.0311101191,
0.0268922932,
0.0194709934,
0.0719211921,
0.0636707693,
-0.0133770835,
-0.0131089017,
0.0067106211,
0.0349690206,
0.0675879642,
0.0038589269,
-0.0396603197,
-0.0344554931,
-0.0176436864,
0.0020360979,
-0.0637579188,
-0.0050318656,
0.0449699722,
-0.0316404924,
-0.0067950906,
-0.0517238788,
-0.0747584924,
0.0336360224,
-0.0047836225,
0.0373560749,
0.0154451365,
0.0255346559,
-0.014470241,
-0.0053070914,
0.0379178375,
-0.0222723894,
0.0200598389,
-0.0116186664,
-0.0032092666,
-0.0231254715,
-0.064942345,
0.0160477143,
0.0159150511,
-0.06966272,
-0.0580211729,
-0.0344132856,
0.0183408316,
0.0027931163,
0.0766085833,
-0.0267386772,
0.0081535289,
0.0389778614,
-0.0378556997,
-0.0402311981,
-0.0157666262,
0.0200928021,
0.0083325366,
0.0043522227,
0.0393420793,
-0.0019195636,
0.0034374746,
0.0036769041,
0.0172516871,
-0.0371502973,
-0.0111643616,
-0.005310263,
-0.0117872041,
-0.0058394037,
0.0307002645,
-0.0101190042,
-0.0358348154,
0.0345917046,
-0.03448027,
-0.0049736202,
-0.0251850113,
-0.026260132,
0.0623590201,
-0.0940146074,
0.0061484706,
0.0232708119,
0.0309862066,
-0.0058798282,
-0.0422422253,
0.0224762391,
0.0021452063,
0.0399207957,
-0.0177023858,
0.0262492336,
-0.0118650924,
-0.0108591486,
0.005650966,
0.0662503541,
0.0069405637,
0.0362890102,
0.0459649786,
-0.0217345003,
0.0275629889,
-0.0007291767,
-0.0387579575,
-0.0025699134,
0.0103636775,
0.0054939166,
0.009717416,
-0.0199813731,
0.0572929494,
0.001537209,
-0.0297683533,
0.0121706882,
0.0570539236,
-0.0116842166,
0.0193641949,
0.0222619437,
-0.0007195318,
0.0451760031,
-0.0098737953,
0.0483998545,
-0.0099148443,
-0.0039054651,
0.0015589216,
-0.0056266496,
-0.0508458689,
-0.0012800767,
0.014225278,
0.0070764655,
-0.0072354707,
0.0506392345,
-0.0250912663,
-0.0659064651,
-0.0174242575,
0.0156806465,
-0.0300786607,
0.0104534291,
-0.013397011,
0.0770087689,
-0.0017971693,
-0.0335657485,
-0.0410948209,
0.0211059786,
0.0008990826,
-0.0280906875,
-0.0105860028,
-6.09512886e-33,
-0.0175895095,
-0.0130837774,
-0.0001186682,
0.0059686988,
-0.03215551,
0.003809616,
-0.0395560823,
-0.0432321988,
-0.0520206802,
0.0163614508,
0.0000899165,
0.0251082759,
0.0102230981,
0.0713338703,
-0.0168588646,
-0.0079701366,
0.0187244136,
0.0207520276,
-0.0128440978,
0.0534358509,
0.0652070269,
0.0403491668,
0.0678998753,
-0.0599816293,
0.0700803325,
-0.0283213295,
0.0238166656,
0.024787562,
0.0059765209,
-0.0118213473,
-0.0364031643,
0.0152808251,
0.0112364087,
-0.0242035873,
-0.0030477468,
0.0435848683,
-0.1274328381,
-0.0586665906,
0.0455896631,
0.012526989,
-0.0730756819,
-0.0283605922,
-0.0150689082,
-0.0018997062,
0.103200078,
-0.0649689659,
0.0239915811,
-0.042316623,
-0.0097897118,
0.0187679715,
-0.0605849139,
0.0001141523,
-0.0321728438,
-0.0471604429,
0.0682899579,
0.0829071328,
0.0327934921,
0.0157664455,
-0.0422274731,
0.0026872298,
0.0028666887,
0.0447788835,
0.0690934733,
0.0114422143,
-0.0124929296,
0.0033021285,
-0.013857861,
-0.0329898857,
0.011525752,
0.0149904424,
0.0120879561,
0.0230149012,
0.0300073009,
0.0803095177,
0.0289725699,
0.0209730044,
-0.0668509305,
0.014343732,
-0.0299620628,
0.0452629551,
0.0048873341,
-0.0170219652,
-0.0143009424,
-0.0036817959,
-0.0361085497,
-0.0252708886,
-0.0370220914,
-0.0293519124,
-0.0024729734,
-0.0299183317,
-0.0766256824,
0.0194060132,
0.0550116263,
-0.0163226016,
-0.0134167271,
0.0462903604,
0.017130021,
-0.0184768829,
0.0021699211,
0.0446206853,
-0.0358141139,
-0.0242162123,
-0.0154058263,
-0.0158521533,
0.0100551862,
0.0278537553,
0.0311513282,
-0.0375658982,
-0.0173937827,
-0.0041396297,
-0.057518363,
0.0281992201,
-0.030519411,
0.0484366119,
0.0033083609,
-0.0031945563,
-0.0470268913,
0.0500277393,
-0.0072385748,
0.0151289413,
-0.0203905925,
-0.0382802151,
-0.0037418986,
0.0217049271,
-0.0377079584,
-0.0117023652,
-0.0384808034,
0.0070122271,
0.022532491,
-0.0683852658,
0.0121184466,
0.0558956601,
2.659e-7,
0.0286837853,
-0.0168107171,
0.031363897,
0.0086374832,
-0.0040416475,
0.0249343216,
-0.0287778582,
0.0473975986,
0.026472073,
-0.0541415401,
0.003212308,
0.0530390851,
0.0748009235,
0.0327980183,
-0.0565746538,
-0.0402323268,
0.0072149467,
0.0125016887,
-0.0116748894,
-0.0101168929,
0.0442196541,
0.0402993225,
0.0012866714,
0.0011147525,
0.0292941406,
0.0166728888,
0.0430089571,
-0.0283385105,
-0.0128800413,
-0.0022972708,
0.000669406,
-0.0103171412,
-0.0180019494,
0.025936747,
-0.0146839218,
0.0147250565,
0.0174509529,
0.0332611464,
0.0530455001,
-0.0643836856,
-0.0444927216,
0.0076855384,
0.0016267708,
-0.0620565787,
0.0605519935,
-0.0644093379,
-0.0093969852,
0.0427260287,
-0.0445977412,
0.0045452667,
0.0341846272,
-0.0000897484,
-0.0212720316,
0.0282608457,
0.0296716243,
-0.0183061063,
-0.0071779825,
-0.0172090847,
-0.0208389368,
-0.0033109591,
-0.0192393009,
-0.0078293234,
-0.019720979,
-0.0639898106,
-0.0035952115,
-0.0317849293,
0.0263557341,
1.673484612e-34,
-0.018698452,
-0.028839387,
0.009247642,
0.0006740383,
0.0157364346,
-0.0401920639,
-0.0212985426,
-0.0059597683,
0.015103396,
-0.0482125059,
-0.0212191362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06754v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06754v1 | From Complex to Simple: Unraveling the Cognitive Tree for Reasoning with Small Language Models | 2023-11-12T06:56:21 | 2023-11-12T06:56:21 | Junbing Yan, Chengyu Wang, Taolin Zhang, Xiaofeng He, Jun Huang, Wei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Reasoning is a distinctive human capacity, enabling us to address complex
problems by breaking them down into a series of manageable cognitive steps.
Yet, complex logical reasoning is still cumbersome for language models. Based
on the dual process theory in cognitive science, we are the first to unravel
the cognitive reasoning abilities of language models. Our framework employs an
iterative methodology to construct a Cognitive Tree (CogTree). The root node of
this tree represents the initial query, while the leaf nodes consist of
straightforward questions that can be answered directly. This construction
involves two main components: the implicit extraction module (referred to as
the intuitive system) and the explicit reasoning module (referred to as the
reflective system). The intuitive system rapidly generates multiple responses
by utilizing in-context examples, while the reflective system scores these
responses using comparative learning. The scores guide the intuitive system in
its subsequent generation step. Our experimental results on two popular and
challenging reasoning tasks indicate that it is possible to achieve a
performance level comparable to that of GPT-3.5 (with 175B parameters), using a
significantly smaller language model that contains fewer parameters (<=7B) than
5% of GPT-3.5. | [
0.0264326409,
0.0076057478,
-0.0309422556,
0.0419544466,
-0.0782476589,
0.0428590849,
-0.0258575678,
0.0100122709,
0.0104676494,
-0.0386630222,
0.0010439929,
-0.0125975143,
-0.0095325392,
0.0238359869,
0.0086408043,
-0.0544740744,
0.0466098525,
-0.0716876909,
0.0781213939,
-0.0289304424,
-0.0206516944,
0.0153901698,
-0.0068586883,
0.0054089241,
0.016157575,
-0.0369095393,
-0.0304385889,
-0.0091226185,
0.0005778978,
-0.0403872877,
-0.0440134406,
0.011053795,
0.0259924103,
0.037823353,
0.0000022648,
-0.0468164645,
-0.0058647199,
-0.0035987454,
-0.0601177961,
-0.0137878759,
-0.0083079515,
0.0392989703,
0.0171742532,
0.0107171703,
-0.0363696031,
-0.0193934608,
0.01077032,
0.0514746942,
0.0291813836,
0.0153009202,
-0.0120416898,
-0.0613480397,
-0.0247700661,
0.0033379686,
0.0139584588,
-0.0462784991,
0.0130279073,
0.0346317627,
0.0336234756,
0.011459644,
0.0225346219,
-0.0148649691,
0.0370218866,
0.0064927242,
-0.0732285529,
0.0635299906,
-0.0129538327,
-0.0365650877,
-0.0010466552,
0.0400563516,
0.0155191263,
-0.0074751368,
-0.0182734001,
-0.0039427262,
0.0077268421,
-0.0118492888,
-0.0684020519,
0.0274713766,
-0.0324089639,
0.0075270301,
0.037987493,
-0.0137514435,
0.0094629331,
-0.0106408494,
-0.0558222234,
0.1051653996,
0.0040688659,
-0.0328582898,
0.0364744179,
-0.0134975426,
-0.0519269705,
-0.0374093018,
-0.0223285202,
0.0632620975,
-0.0027816421,
0.0329715796,
0.0050262883,
0.0015581603,
0.0008289904,
-0.0310985874,
0.050665997,
0.0623476356,
0.0363332145,
0.075965181,
-0.0398171768,
0.052295953,
-0.0034118758,
0.0322443172,
-0.0285603683,
-0.0171731655,
-0.0575013719,
-0.0346650891,
-0.0638716221,
0.0794326961,
-0.0497416742,
-0.014136347,
-0.0160884224,
0.0107820015,
-0.0063086683,
-0.0118202688,
0.005966757,
-0.0187490061,
-0.0150398016,
-0.0169453751,
-0.0382463597,
0.0093801832,
-0.0453442149,
0.0288939252,
0.0195259787,
-0.0464100428,
-0.0228119381,
0.0087647596,
0.0343265869,
-0.0387972817,
-0.0009884187,
0.0584422648,
-0.0269119516,
-0.0108137392,
-0.0405833237,
-0.0352603756,
0.003638129,
-0.0866515934,
0.008369307,
-0.0596573912,
0.0164702404,
0.0442972817,
-0.0259433091,
-0.0354429223,
0.0121618882,
0.022432223,
-0.037555676,
0.0725195706,
0.0152181676,
0.0139540518,
0.0203850437,
0.0123101473,
-0.0321160853,
0.0520227477,
0.0256822351,
0.029701177,
0.0129733291,
0.0172466263,
-0.0195638277,
0.0200986899,
-0.0110724196,
-0.0266005825,
-0.0100566484,
0.0321770497,
-0.0388843864,
-0.0189615339,
-0.0128433257,
0.0578607321,
-0.0283252988,
0.0082599167,
0.0451718122,
0.0773883238,
0.0009502875,
0.0225154702,
0.0618763976,
0.001845264,
0.0335876197,
0.0046869884,
-0.0379693098,
0.024543494,
-0.0734999925,
0.0081827333,
-0.0526816957,
0.0173752997,
-0.019564027,
-0.0288546439,
-0.0284622125,
0.0238325316,
0.0297622196,
0.0183875952,
0.0572593957,
0.0012545974,
-0.0205927007,
0.0322433338,
0.0061734389,
-0.0403914973,
-0.0395343639,
-0.0750365108,
0.0370643698,
0.0016523363,
0.0208678804,
-0.0195916239,
0.0101286424,
0.0408763364,
-0.0355469733,
0.0230782256,
0.0538001247,
-0.0118657751,
-0.0086625135,
-0.0195300113,
-0.01084325,
-0.0179228764,
0.0209192187,
0.0116787627,
-0.0027540603,
-0.0209339764,
0.0170390941,
-0.0043944516,
0.0118660871,
0.0021337611,
-0.0411459021,
-0.0135769891,
-0.0409327485,
-0.0003775959,
0.028148802,
-0.0038392181,
0.0215818025,
0.0437680818,
0.0310794991,
-0.0152071761,
-0.0130582545,
0.0390652306,
-0.0625688508,
-0.0519470572,
0.02679432,
0.0115514025,
-0.017009886,
0.0129043479,
-0.0059571578,
-0.0494895205,
0.0385307744,
-0.0463479497,
0.0235203598,
-0.0425232947,
0.0254874025,
0.0095149651,
-0.0398306511,
-0.0404173844,
0.1242097467,
0.0135591403,
0.0179044958,
0.0143528963,
-0.0227122791,
0.0398260579,
-0.0522448085,
-0.0070776516,
0.0096240332,
-0.0087735718,
-0.0243852921,
-0.0027868582,
-0.0042065098,
-0.0612117276,
-0.0012773989,
-0.049102053,
-0.0204640459,
-0.0072990037,
0.0107975053,
0.016964728,
0.0108509269,
-0.0127194403,
0.0028465255,
-0.0149327992,
0.0469094813,
-0.0008872927,
0.0483813845,
0.0213286914,
0.0003288334,
-0.012837274,
-0.0204529446,
-0.0073045595,
-0.0478830263,
0.0328489207,
0.018716231,
-0.0214150511,
-0.0065166908,
0.0245793238,
-0.0172724016,
0.0170877222,
-0.0069540469,
-0.0100401193,
0.045844771,
-0.0563681386,
0.0358529836,
0.0651003644,
-0.0230207723,
0.0251330305,
0.0193639677,
-0.0464469269,
-0.0560349934,
0.0392773598,
-0.0349423625,
-0.0066335998,
-0.0123647507,
-0.0306895468,
-0.0214019306,
0.0798885673,
0.0203541033,
0.0101000722,
-0.048519019,
0.0670311674,
-0.0013815663,
0.0031418519,
-0.0531795025,
-0.0217378233,
0.0009211309,
0.0577523299,
-0.0525868572,
-0.0098641729,
0.085010536,
-0.0142079461,
-0.0068216533,
-0.0547783934,
0.0158947129,
-0.0153951487,
0.1127149761,
0.0259195026,
0.016048912,
0.029549785,
-0.020226663,
-0.0625074655,
0.0028981522,
0.0415080041,
-0.0287403148,
0.039990712,
-0.0654636398,
0.0235541034,
-0.0307389852,
-0.0447418205,
-0.0287015289,
0.004521647,
-0.0213053878,
0.0596952215,
0.0004400313,
-0.005425116,
-0.0158107076,
0.0336781964,
0.0592943393,
0.0431263708,
-0.0134747643,
-0.0210523792,
-0.0343817659,
0.0175966471,
0.0417023823,
0.0454987697,
0.0271163248,
-0.0292367712,
0.0755672008,
0.0590536743,
0.0773685873,
-0.0175494682,
-0.0060345833,
0.0374576114,
0.0207071137,
-0.0288723521,
-0.0146953966,
0.0204447135,
0.0582113862,
-0.0563725792,
-0.0336810239,
0.1137610152,
0.0342634618,
-0.030429408,
-0.0031416421,
-0.0690235049,
0.0225198325,
0.0613930747,
0.0210953057,
-0.0099915667,
-0.0255075973,
0.0261985622,
-0.0089645423,
-0.0117630959,
-0.0550411604,
-0.0066269534,
-0.1302832365,
0.0493601337,
-0.020747181,
-0.0136289671,
-0.0201549716,
-0.0213139765,
0.0137280505,
0.0408840925,
-0.0619845763,
0.0456311852,
-0.0085642459,
0.0074323211,
0.0053864908,
0.0101750493,
-0.0000938176,
0.0555247404,
0.0090933815,
-0.0317101367,
0.0116973724,
0.0382821709,
0.0109795844,
-0.0244393051,
0.0451019183,
-0.0656859726,
0.0105930697,
-0.0383320041,
-0.0105835591,
0.0608234294,
0.0111081097,
-0.0103993211,
0.0319859833,
-0.0294169132,
-0.034522187,
0.0051908726,
0.1035418585,
-0.0226604398,
-0.03443994,
0.0188632254,
-0.00305736,
-0.0354551822,
0.0959684029,
0.0352196172,
-0.0073338896,
-0.0614207946,
-0.0241367351,
-0.0128304604,
-0.0003864387,
-0.0466635153,
0.0394363776,
0.0470431633,
0.018437,
-0.0110540297,
-0.0313760079,
0.0408039577,
0.0565344058,
-0.0158206113,
0.0121017527,
0.0086591896,
0.009958108,
-0.0381490104,
0.0143875135,
-0.0183766298,
-0.0106633687,
-0.0010847249,
0.0062902626,
0.0069474792,
-0.0150755066,
-0.0551567711,
-0.007305399,
-0.0265240334,
-0.047334183,
-0.0132338936,
0.022512503,
0.0355190895,
0.0237549879,
-0.0214314144,
-0.0170558188,
-0.030372981,
-0.021385951,
-0.0467462912,
-0.0167847816,
0.0115851117,
0.0309682246,
0.0228343029,
0.0577115305,
-0.0040159156,
0.0559364967,
0.0274313409,
0.0659253448,
-0.0571963899,
-0.0135088395,
0.0733951479,
0.0694032609,
0.0325507186,
0.0318667889,
-0.0026828989,
-0.0334712714,
0.0098741129,
-0.0511780232,
-0.0408003852,
-0.0334145352,
-0.0129581019,
-0.0129295606,
-0.0080403956,
-0.0110316295,
-0.0560620166,
0.0367009193,
0.0379995145,
-0.0287591126,
-0.0028688442,
0.0589757077,
0.018716488,
0.0074395919,
-0.043760024,
-0.0047661802,
-0.022271309,
-0.0202121884,
0.0332075469,
-0.0350863785,
0.0880521983,
0.0308627654,
-0.0214394983,
-0.0412492566,
-0.0303198956,
-0.0555033758,
-0.0651717559,
0.0254650023,
0.0361231416,
0.0299654622,
0.0044658976,
0.0064299344,
-0.0483648144,
-0.0119871646,
-0.0090293121,
0.0081853652,
0.0527814999,
-0.0456015989,
0.0389233679,
0.049414061,
-0.0146177756,
-0.0199579354,
0.0467874445,
-0.0110908458,
0.0037279841,
-0.0141724292,
-0.0143885184,
-0.0342979804,
-0.0272756051,
-0.0104597779,
0.0297270399,
0.0069930484,
0.0593728945,
-0.0876484811,
-0.0691642016,
-0.0300630238,
0.0207421463,
0.0252358858,
-0.0179953296,
0.044061739,
0.09958864,
-0.002229529,
-0.0782696679,
-0.012266065,
0.0324924998,
-0.0497859903,
-0.0059630964,
-0.0351572111,
-6.931573538e-33,
-0.0349881649,
-0.0102863023,
0.0409429222,
-0.0005179428,
0.0028021021,
-0.0338393673,
-0.0790651217,
0.014387588,
-0.0424583368,
0.0199031439,
-0.0216674414,
-0.0143231321,
0.0059374021,
-0.0005687482,
0.0006729595,
0.0301496685,
0.0073401025,
-0.0010994748,
-0.0260468926,
-0.003601026,
0.0384212881,
-0.0100026233,
0.0172931142,
-0.0386544243,
-0.0367260911,
0.0159072429,
0.0276953448,
0.0319874026,
-0.0581108145,
0.0536935963,
-0.006070869,
0.0115237292,
0.044317659,
-0.0102435946,
0.0104390215,
0.0132959001,
-0.1083323881,
-0.0583052449,
0.0432471633,
-0.0354158916,
-0.0444038175,
0.0037599753,
0.0350648388,
-0.0226506181,
-0.0018580498,
-0.0147965066,
0.0204519425,
-0.0226183869,
-0.0047185938,
0.0023836954,
-0.0579984672,
0.0207698327,
0.0074668298,
0.0228972882,
0.0150302052,
0.0650821179,
-0.0233678706,
0.0434557199,
-0.0549568832,
-0.0130524226,
-0.0022229222,
0.020602297,
0.0497907139,
0.0185219944,
0.0086307656,
0.0353834853,
-0.0116245383,
-0.0066992645,
-0.0345329717,
0.0116536869,
-0.0003097311,
0.0805343464,
0.0294048078,
-0.0013410355,
0.0402492695,
0.0037068911,
-0.099580884,
0.0054341108,
0.0277906042,
0.0833649784,
0.0610900074,
0.0065401946,
-0.0338767245,
-0.0171118546,
-0.0539839044,
-0.013012155,
-0.0562247746,
-0.0151778124,
0.0265870262,
-0.0271849334,
-0.013990582,
-0.0247063432,
0.0264281109,
-0.020018464,
-0.0156802703,
-0.0246040542,
-0.0085448362,
0.0131084789,
-0.0141707156,
0.0435722768,
-0.0427209437,
-0.0456787571,
-0.0420661271,
0.0265186448,
-0.0029597208,
0.0366230756,
0.0120348362,
0.0068874918,
-0.0284851827,
-0.0291083809,
-0.0657103807,
0.0139906295,
-0.0314429775,
0.0235494412,
0.0407448113,
0.0343803316,
0.0095719341,
-0.035252016,
0.0196358301,
-0.0181324258,
-0.0112061426,
0.0029176797,
-0.0095531167,
0.011132081,
0.0202535857,
-0.0165309999,
-0.0128908185,
-0.0099210758,
0.0082908766,
-0.0273253694,
-0.0023276489,
0.0709653944,
3.04e-7,
0.0285922736,
0.0333284661,
-0.0046042241,
0.0358091481,
0.0540213175,
0.0347992852,
-0.0081659919,
-0.0405777022,
0.0302968323,
-0.0404413715,
-0.0133114224,
0.0418581814,
0.030140711,
0.0523312315,
-0.0761765465,
-0.0024291223,
-0.0373920202,
-0.0289777908,
-0.0213676896,
0.0138019361,
0.0822079554,
0.0643337369,
-0.0044874591,
-0.0010877106,
-0.0313809328,
-0.0440782122,
0.0587528609,
-0.0027683668,
0.0229439884,
0.0038027512,
0.0261437781,
-0.0060226195,
0.0264540203,
0.0476358235,
0.011802081,
0.03429446,
0.0141807711,
0.0556766279,
-0.0268225819,
-0.0101292701,
-0.0059210756,
-0.026031686,
0.0235784985,
-0.0615438968,
0.0835701898,
-0.1169757843,
-0.0599956028,
0.0423645042,
-0.0148068527,
-0.0081584053,
-0.0302337725,
0.0300036371,
-0.0403840728,
0.0056914305,
0.0063170525,
-0.0402633436,
-0.0099824667,
-0.0779106915,
0.0029701379,
0.0065957117,
-0.0405505411,
-0.0244724751,
-0.0413807891,
-0.0155717097,
0.0179181006,
-0.0072050598,
-0.0209663957,
3.036084488e-34,
0.0229951218,
-0.0069578355,
0.0094624013,
0.0223534498,
0.0375433341,
-0.0059827529,
0.0123393182,
0.0303891171,
0.023454044,
-0.1042185202,
-0.0273277368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06753v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06753v2 | AudioChatLlama: Towards General-Purpose Speech Abilities for LLMs | 2023-11-12T06:56:14 | 2024-04-12T18:55:22 | Yassir Fathullah, Chunyang Wu, Egor Lakomkin, Ke Li, Junteng Jia, Yuan Shangguan, Jay Mahadeokar, Ozlem Kalinli, Christian Fuegen, Mike Seltzer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we extend the instruction-tuned Llama-2 model with end-to-end
general-purpose speech processing and reasoning abilities while maintaining the
wide range of original LLM capabilities, without using any carefully curated
paired data. The resulting end-to-end model, named AudioChatLlama, can utilize
audio prompts as a replacement for text and sustain a conversation. Such a
model also has extended cross-modal capabilities such as being able to perform
spoken question answering (QA), speech translation, and audio summarization
amongst many other closed and open-domain tasks. This is unlike prior
approaches in speech, in which LLMs are extended to handle audio for a limited
number of pre-designated tasks. On both synthesized and recorded speech QA test
sets, evaluations show that our end-to-end approach is on par with or
outperforms cascaded systems (speech recognizer + LLM) in terms of modeling the
response to a prompt. Furthermore, unlike cascades, our approach can
interchange text and audio modalities and intrinsically utilize prior context
in a conversation to provide better results. | [
-0.0039360947,
0.0285727251,
0.0020925577,
0.0373908244,
-0.0028098715,
-0.0194537882,
0.0216625277,
-0.0354938619,
-0.0024654411,
-0.024144128,
-0.0793379918,
-0.0236224607,
0.0049369596,
0.0172940735,
0.0524442308,
-0.0256312452,
0.0448371321,
-0.0627701506,
-0.005137146,
-0.0252828952,
-0.0048409081,
0.0027561435,
-0.0234122537,
0.0161401331,
0.0161185469,
-0.0086358283,
-0.0150377685,
0.0118291918,
0.0187431145,
0.0118893152,
-0.0211535636,
-0.0214986205,
0.0434199385,
-0.0265387427,
0.0000017795,
-0.0492718928,
0.0146611547,
-0.0153213227,
-0.0389938578,
-0.0331928954,
-0.0040995376,
0.0409291871,
-0.0141471084,
0.0569187701,
-0.0073917704,
0.0400732085,
0.0053354525,
0.0110732447,
0.0501535162,
0.0681019053,
0.0062381229,
-0.0614264049,
0.0623458102,
-0.0281844083,
0.0310140084,
-0.0581882633,
-0.0274004992,
-0.0375364013,
0.0606570132,
-0.0111511266,
-0.0041722246,
0.060652148,
0.0116786668,
-0.0153769301,
0.0025674794,
0.0083252098,
-0.0121258078,
-0.0119947791,
-0.03295644,
0.0818555281,
0.0342854932,
0.0126120439,
0.0365228653,
0.0238838736,
0.0050526154,
-0.0350186974,
-0.0599372871,
0.0524311736,
0.0080974102,
0.0110140666,
-0.0270036757,
0.0174988341,
0.0184494145,
-0.0025794504,
-0.0158654712,
0.0519621782,
-0.003320907,
-0.0102366433,
0.0179140363,
-0.0381589308,
-0.0161818806,
-0.055700589,
0.0262731407,
0.0979044065,
-0.0444322899,
0.0177900605,
-0.0323761217,
0.0192724969,
-0.0003738864,
-0.0012988242,
0.0171596501,
0.0497591794,
-0.064638041,
0.0486145243,
-0.028546121,
0.0355148613,
-0.0013965484,
0.0327825435,
-0.0206020661,
-0.0190851111,
-0.0050788946,
-0.010008852,
-0.0165187363,
0.0339227132,
-0.0540952198,
-0.033504568,
-0.0244168397,
0.0623756498,
-0.0180517714,
0.0085666068,
0.013592382,
0.0074602985,
-0.01134241,
-0.0112773515,
-0.0345548987,
0.0037752574,
0.0004259172,
0.098730363,
0.0399940014,
-0.0607117414,
-0.0165744964,
0.023107009,
0.0158606004,
0.0287068859,
0.0391396396,
0.113961421,
-0.0403693095,
-0.0497100018,
-0.0333323814,
-0.0062999637,
0.0061849039,
-0.0776428208,
0.0304559283,
-0.0353246257,
0.0425920188,
-0.0168747995,
-0.0261964686,
0.013439686,
0.0016735371,
0.0212004147,
0.0072222995,
0.0768287852,
0.0099282349,
0.0495503061,
0.0704626888,
0.0160589628,
-0.002309686,
0.0417032316,
0.0738983825,
-0.006912949,
0.0082355766,
-0.0005446356,
-0.0047872127,
0.0628854111,
-0.0054884106,
-0.0217520967,
-0.0294761192,
0.0140495785,
-0.0320482031,
0.0160650127,
0.0320144519,
0.0443292186,
-0.0203068238,
-0.0088324947,
0.0673974752,
0.0753840357,
0.0194914993,
-0.0176316127,
0.0145776048,
-0.0036128296,
0.0259105675,
0.0154501796,
-0.0536448918,
0.0712747499,
-0.0463919453,
0.0309831221,
0.0585447736,
0.0021341655,
-0.05206763,
-0.0426098295,
0.0185719132,
-0.0208560079,
-0.0136111462,
0.0593947209,
-0.0098318988,
0.0068129199,
-0.0624958128,
0.0445441343,
-0.0287656635,
-0.0639406219,
-0.0003497366,
-0.0779148117,
0.0494509004,
0.0616437458,
0.0120938094,
-0.0514782928,
-0.0237985309,
-0.0229803324,
0.01806565,
0.0617776215,
-0.0274132192,
-0.0022625355,
0.0397209637,
-0.0526254997,
-0.0038331454,
-0.0192960426,
-0.0107846735,
0.0238272753,
-0.0273886602,
0.0002100551,
-0.0033714562,
-0.0093600843,
0.0790784881,
-0.0060340711,
-0.0315511003,
-0.0013663924,
0.0169491395,
-0.0058793742,
0.0339664221,
0.0299214944,
-0.016106274,
0.0170001183,
0.0461347476,
-0.044833336,
-0.0187201221,
0.0155605078,
-0.0781418309,
-0.0141379237,
0.0447627865,
-0.0212895311,
0.0238888655,
0.0285772271,
-0.0073656091,
-0.0876639262,
0.0096141603,
-0.0523597412,
0.0334970392,
-0.0667066798,
0.0256834887,
0.0447126366,
0.0146129979,
0.0101761995,
0.0123680588,
-0.0208016373,
-0.025652675,
0.0503716245,
0.0325295478,
-0.0160524491,
-0.0620913878,
-0.0295991879,
0.0220514555,
-0.0053675696,
0.0371104106,
-0.049544245,
-0.0106240865,
-0.042457372,
-0.0544467494,
-0.0714942217,
0.0327029526,
-0.0030658459,
0.0386546664,
0.021081809,
0.0030751366,
-0.0182347614,
-0.0137823038,
-0.0597516559,
-0.0033839475,
0.0402568206,
-0.0208079536,
-0.0142230159,
-0.0019684937,
-0.0157466568,
-0.0420732126,
0.0206595249,
0.0299323536,
-0.0042014662,
-0.0371142216,
-0.0150125967,
-0.037998341,
0.0374561325,
-0.0248744357,
0.0380147807,
-0.0278150607,
-0.0188222937,
-0.0037600647,
0.0078880088,
0.0299474318,
0.0693228766,
0.0160572939,
-0.0439369678,
0.0347992182,
-0.0130828479,
-0.0338587984,
0.0362560153,
0.0339062549,
-0.008728723,
-0.0175490063,
0.0206654053,
-0.0222884696,
0.0276930947,
0.0130143855,
0.0249525383,
-0.0157697778,
-0.0215608943,
0.0382984541,
-0.0277155451,
-0.0267795976,
-0.025791401,
-0.0604871102,
0.0540297404,
-0.0295365136,
-0.0324187763,
0.0186618883,
-0.0659818426,
-0.0257350914,
-0.0058532171,
-0.0526502393,
-0.0486381873,
0.0116353976,
-0.0470806062,
-0.0241137128,
-0.0087479558,
-0.0184550602,
-0.0466640815,
-0.0142780626,
-0.0213633794,
-0.0719055161,
0.0722391978,
-0.0267578661,
0.0119442716,
-0.0144470586,
-0.0093531096,
-0.0405152962,
0.0290714297,
-0.0350864567,
0.0430453755,
-0.0373492651,
0.0175234117,
-0.0455443636,
0.0089017991,
0.0313429199,
0.0345328823,
-0.0053708241,
0.0226368625,
-0.0558212362,
0.0577489361,
0.0209591836,
0.0696997941,
-0.0188956,
-0.0137559371,
0.0764057338,
0.011907056,
0.0329547077,
-0.0308082439,
-0.0114303287,
0.0225843005,
0.033324305,
0.0187314581,
-0.0247599855,
0.050452847,
0.0802752301,
-0.0332173146,
0.020794943,
0.0874216557,
0.0036817843,
-0.0171914175,
-0.0301872622,
-0.0046366975,
0.0016279006,
0.0404892676,
0.0180298947,
-0.0742607936,
-0.0405573994,
0.0551896431,
0.02872793,
0.015459111,
0.0241820794,
-0.0345443599,
-0.0832812861,
0.0461052433,
0.0024974304,
-0.0386375226,
-0.0093117626,
0.0091419816,
0.0126894908,
0.0216360502,
0.0515402518,
0.0091683352,
-0.0304612108,
-0.035290435,
0.0129808253,
-0.0261677727,
-0.007049737,
0.0554140359,
0.0010388122,
0.063289322,
0.0592390671,
0.0265272763,
-0.0074984231,
-0.0380091444,
0.0412167087,
-0.0249780379,
0.018604001,
0.0246197898,
0.0084068673,
0.0061409865,
-0.0171184894,
0.0180530697,
0.0581707768,
0.0008008085,
-0.0146092353,
-0.0005981029,
0.0509323962,
-0.0247510485,
0.0212133955,
-0.030798072,
0.0517296344,
-0.0219897013,
0.0487857424,
0.0296124518,
-0.0326592252,
-0.0265580658,
-0.0036654961,
-0.0391150899,
-0.0537543632,
-0.0147482576,
-0.0004748565,
0.0053851199,
-0.0020535986,
-0.0286998618,
-0.0114286738,
-0.0060066688,
0.0141716832,
0.0003604095,
0.0077943928,
-0.0069389772,
0.0159642193,
-0.0322922878,
0.0099319611,
-0.0170740113,
0.0546558239,
-0.0640809983,
0.0018932149,
0.0561395697,
-0.0855827481,
-0.0177280661,
0.0374369025,
-0.0766659975,
-0.0645502508,
-0.0554656424,
0.0316766761,
0.0246795118,
0.0469947234,
-0.0059879655,
-0.0469927862,
0.0566729531,
0.0063014543,
-0.0587441213,
0.0879698768,
0.0507127829,
0.0458245315,
-0.0200556852,
0.0361752212,
-0.070567131,
0.0450841859,
-0.0092831757,
0.0162943974,
-0.0273145437,
-0.0768198743,
-0.0269807652,
0.0035875801,
0.0093458407,
0.015578514,
0.0258286558,
-0.0251987223,
0.0625934154,
0.0113875391,
0.0403069556,
-0.043266125,
-0.0101350499,
-0.0074608182,
-0.0288004931,
0.0029030207,
-0.0112966746,
-0.0278026778,
0.0108468318,
-0.0199009851,
0.0545083806,
-0.0089326529,
-0.0040924242,
-0.0444144234,
0.0016131394,
0.0079878727,
-0.0018842451,
0.0123529611,
0.0208615717,
0.0272405911,
0.0424025357,
-0.0389370658,
0.0049361638,
0.0006521403,
0.0546348803,
-0.0812654719,
-0.0419250391,
0.0006448207,
0.0730594546,
0.0391130671,
0.0375084653,
-0.0073082838,
0.0606346354,
0.0185428858,
-0.0274888426,
0.0298423171,
-0.0183010865,
-0.0133541441,
0.0621843673,
0.0074528437,
0.0011083009,
-0.0066439197,
0.0168052986,
-0.0374714099,
0.037310008,
-0.0447062291,
0.0686478168,
-0.0377858542,
-0.0643277019,
-0.0045741722,
0.0173472762,
0.0070342603,
-0.0260881688,
-0.0191471055,
-0.0673287436,
0.0362384915,
0.0077937748,
0.0032971413,
-0.0376783088,
0.0149195911,
0.0150958514,
0.0089332275,
-0.0189863294,
0.0087171961,
-0.0501543023,
-0.0122417388,
-0.0071445699,
0.0339564011,
-5.772651086e-33,
-0.0587514155,
0.0050209337,
0.0498818234,
0.0008955835,
-0.0397063456,
0.0037739198,
-0.039969746,
-0.0020200035,
-0.034522444,
-0.0595265329,
-0.0477551073,
0.0170539971,
0.0245342068,
0.0185791496,
-0.0134752896,
-0.0123908017,
0.0344785303,
-0.0394117683,
0.0013886836,
0.0280374922,
0.0301878862,
0.0347966664,
0.0249020532,
-0.02548212,
-0.0211759992,
-0.0144827478,
-0.0435617566,
-0.0008115737,
-0.0312233604,
0.0523606166,
-0.0192849264,
0.0198785458,
0.0067466968,
-0.0338180438,
-0.0287191309,
0.0800542831,
-0.0764483884,
0.0044710552,
0.0512285829,
-0.0164514855,
-0.032045573,
-0.0702381656,
0.0499581955,
0.0115603115,
-0.0029797372,
-0.0413547643,
0.01895798,
-0.0248108879,
0.0071845176,
-0.0178800635,
0.0003530758,
-0.0075682239,
-0.0215989389,
-0.056645453,
0.0102003887,
0.0447207168,
-0.0041010501,
0.0200973656,
-0.0253916234,
0.0542068854,
0.0024621645,
-0.0059939679,
0.0752305612,
0.0189636834,
-0.0353372432,
0.0406180508,
0.0215504933,
-0.0570258461,
-0.0188443642,
-0.0511193462,
-0.0019694455,
0.0529182889,
0.0075170291,
0.0093899136,
-0.032188382,
-0.0061353925,
-0.0391010679,
0.0296886992,
0.0309597179,
0.0183606949,
0.0053264191,
0.0379232764,
-0.0088992678,
0.0165720563,
-0.0635233372,
0.0346788764,
-0.0438051783,
-0.0073572253,
0.069610931,
0.0103609208,
0.0198750962,
-0.0561674237,
0.0468474068,
-0.0348514989,
0.0424521975,
0.0074595991,
-0.0112449769,
0.0244358256,
0.0038491581,
0.0172131192,
-0.0308101866,
0.0071988232,
0.0836386085,
0.006684023,
0.001197304,
-0.0120759727,
-0.0246991273,
0.0635790452,
-0.0644272119,
0.003998037,
-0.0152275907,
0.0333570316,
0.0040302156,
0.0479206927,
0.0080734808,
-0.0182544142,
-0.0212697163,
0.0418629758,
-0.0881031081,
-0.0164049584,
-0.039130196,
-0.0261292085,
-0.0303126089,
0.0453169718,
-0.0502156615,
0.0398658589,
0.0048445784,
0.0080175456,
-0.0143721476,
-0.0261447001,
0.0045167836,
0.0250759199,
2.639e-7,
-0.0106702959,
-0.0431951918,
0.0149268657,
0.0356502309,
0.0366745219,
0.0009691181,
-0.0452207848,
0.0195071511,
0.0243845265,
-0.0239506066,
-0.0011480669,
0.0365721174,
0.0649008006,
-0.0297398735,
-0.1023159325,
0.005727327,
-0.040775314,
0.0102868006,
-0.0131857116,
-0.036253605,
0.0579056069,
0.0916204825,
-0.0346474685,
-0.0382585824,
-0.0344868414,
-0.0227525644,
0.0393524393,
-0.0192215014,
-0.0235207882,
-0.0336210541,
0.028545253,
0.0123824868,
-0.0373507738,
0.0144266794,
-0.0176994335,
0.0546243899,
-0.0047486387,
0.0837510377,
0.0315885954,
-0.1084639654,
-0.0048145372,
0.0403694138,
0.0025067648,
0.0096923318,
0.0839802921,
0.008003315,
-0.0185608547,
-0.0174795575,
-0.0348455012,
-0.0180763807,
-0.009184164,
-0.0045364462,
0.0305481385,
-0.0119312443,
-0.0183400549,
-0.0285609458,
-0.0049976292,
-0.1032427847,
-0.0043665618,
0.0044883755,
-0.071269162,
-0.0328795314,
-0.0553747006,
0.000595098,
0.0212582573,
-0.0625995994,
-0.0201931726,
1.728430937e-34,
0.0185275935,
-0.0342701115,
0.0006357199,
0.0370082036,
-0.0238964148,
-0.0119576594,
-0.0019603097,
0.0169745795,
0.0226464514,
-0.0625687838,
-0.0171001367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06752v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06752v1 | BeautifulPrompt: Towards Automatic Prompt Engineering for Text-to-Image Synthesis | 2023-11-12T06:39:00 | 2023-11-12T06:39:00 | Tingfeng Cao, Chengyu Wang, Bingyan Liu, Ziheng Wu, Jinhui Zhu, Jun Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, diffusion-based deep generative models (e.g., Stable Diffusion)
have shown impressive results in text-to-image synthesis. However, current
text-to-image models often require multiple passes of prompt engineering by
humans in order to produce satisfactory results for real-world applications. We
propose BeautifulPrompt, a deep generative model to produce high-quality
prompts from very simple raw descriptions, which enables diffusion-based models
to generate more beautiful images. In our work, we first fine-tuned the
BeautifulPrompt model over low-quality and high-quality collecting prompt
pairs. Then, to ensure that our generated prompts can generate more beautiful
images, we further propose a Reinforcement Learning with Visual AI Feedback
technique to fine-tune our model to maximize the reward values of the generated
prompts, where the reward values are calculated based on the PickScore and the
Aesthetic Scores. Our results demonstrate that learning from visual AI feedback
promises the potential to improve the quality of generated prompts and images
significantly. We further showcase the integration of BeautifulPrompt to a
cloud-native AI platform to provide better text-to-image generation service in
the cloud. | [
0.0259493217,
0.0568892546,
0.011878022,
-0.00530315,
-0.0095330449,
-0.0010512511,
0.0167056359,
-0.0002733665,
0.0151266744,
0.0296396837,
-0.0010335695,
-0.0361268371,
0.0163479447,
0.0862624496,
0.0157364365,
-0.1109591052,
-0.0380381942,
-0.0377670154,
-0.0304457322,
-0.0300423242,
-0.0024996544,
0.0073175626,
-0.0090581831,
0.0109751355,
-0.0452015512,
-0.0436057076,
-0.0255929399,
0.0487078093,
0.0158798266,
-0.0504200868,
-0.0390669852,
0.0405354239,
-0.0157495197,
0.0030321218,
0.0000020827,
-0.0349345021,
0.0315049998,
-0.011642714,
0.0087729553,
-0.0313949995,
0.0825063586,
-0.0104708634,
-0.034823902,
-0.02742959,
-0.0095381038,
0.0655725226,
0.0750743225,
0.0617640391,
0.0989352986,
0.0316150114,
-0.0196229015,
-0.0249000993,
-0.0013769238,
-0.0454233438,
0.0456848368,
0.0182006825,
-0.0126571506,
-0.0334614553,
0.025984535,
0.0159531701,
-0.0398372225,
0.0338404924,
0.0503029153,
-0.0331332088,
0.0395057462,
0.0860888883,
0.0451023504,
-0.0469325259,
-0.0429476984,
0.0619080998,
-0.0375687256,
0.0413112491,
-0.010613977,
-0.0519992821,
0.0275877528,
-0.0009464948,
-0.0218365751,
0.0037316431,
-0.0080592697,
0.0125833023,
-0.0639681369,
0.0209436025,
-0.0029117072,
-0.0347487144,
0.0311931446,
-0.0478301272,
0.0328717232,
-0.0104893437,
-0.0231672786,
0.0337264054,
-0.0226013549,
-0.080000177,
0.0472800843,
0.0120038455,
-0.0084487032,
-0.0180351082,
-0.0337281935,
-0.0255314354,
-0.0041035814,
0.0516369268,
0.0729066655,
0.0027254864,
-0.0520294644,
0.0332526937,
-0.0262592211,
0.0147796916,
-0.0168763325,
0.0036141989,
-0.0389874727,
0.0249243528,
0.0015305886,
-0.007740953,
-0.0072084842,
-0.0099659991,
-0.0476063266,
-0.0454119071,
-0.0535132401,
0.0020747744,
-0.004797983,
0.0342602171,
0.042243015,
0.0801234767,
-0.0724480972,
-0.000969359,
-0.0730869696,
-0.0287236776,
-0.0343550295,
-0.0120742312,
0.0614228509,
-0.0185995903,
-0.0052948995,
-0.0128465751,
0.0530486405,
0.029476963,
0.0106138764,
0.0426081941,
-0.0522805415,
0.0236520693,
0.0140930815,
-0.0065563028,
-0.0145597756,
-0.0149603672,
0.0199411642,
-0.0417495891,
0.0268244185,
-0.0530962832,
0.0033060235,
-0.043463219,
-0.004877721,
0.016181048,
0.0068808724,
0.0435375795,
-0.0147978943,
-0.0041679689,
0.0380664915,
-0.0097114416,
-0.0312321242,
-0.008441112,
0.0322805718,
0.110153459,
0.0045750747,
-0.0227573682,
0.075970903,
0.0378246345,
0.0343188234,
0.0280490555,
0.0057977661,
-0.0340923555,
-0.0133661442,
0.0477237999,
0.0676906183,
0.0617218949,
-0.005625498,
0.0089072883,
0.090821892,
0.0369283333,
0.0163323507,
-0.0065481132,
0.0470930934,
0.0277386159,
-0.0357373133,
0.0022646564,
-0.0310921501,
0.0634053871,
0.0362278186,
0.0370423086,
0.0366107449,
0.0281594303,
-0.0417630076,
-0.0496819578,
0.0503714122,
-0.0279059801,
0.001185828,
0.0055215582,
0.0227798261,
0.0392140411,
-0.0675098225,
-0.0459441915,
-0.013887913,
-0.0439058803,
0.0052037486,
-0.034093786,
0.0737810582,
0.1265283674,
0.0040893913,
0.0345153734,
0.0582546033,
-0.0210860241,
0.0104798665,
0.0628938749,
0.0023243807,
0.0177082997,
0.0374425687,
-0.028255647,
-0.0247776955,
-0.0194645803,
-0.0167422462,
0.0132855847,
-0.0483878963,
0.0324510746,
-0.0063540563,
0.0520648807,
-0.0540836342,
0.0339602195,
0.0233763698,
-0.0519404486,
0.0400324874,
0.0311919078,
-0.0179045685,
-0.0092417309,
-0.0070352624,
0.0165657736,
-0.0035229488,
-0.0240410957,
-0.0013710795,
0.0133784059,
-0.0481466204,
-0.0298788752,
-0.0291192587,
-0.0438234098,
-0.0269940626,
0.0006043315,
-0.0427611321,
-0.0340470858,
0.0019313506,
-0.0194508601,
-0.0304862037,
-0.0216946285,
-0.0183182135,
0.0407951847,
0.0356077254,
-0.0005412247,
0.0495607108,
-0.0282819103,
-0.0149228983,
0.0061038188,
0.0465666056,
-0.0294489507,
-0.0485912599,
0.0083988383,
-0.0500627756,
-0.0133966282,
0.013678222,
0.0185260624,
0.0402916856,
-0.0726849064,
-0.0152290482,
-0.0630885139,
-0.0255333334,
0.0082841376,
-0.0378103517,
-0.0069612782,
0.0336576328,
-0.0106035434,
-0.0136423334,
-0.0698197037,
0.0067734905,
0.018785689,
0.0134019069,
0.0377819873,
-0.0247871839,
0.0251348764,
-0.0414112657,
-0.0073023788,
0.0345678143,
0.0262239221,
0.052863799,
0.0334207043,
-0.0488633439,
0.0026933239,
-0.0086833788,
0.0151860146,
0.0209281631,
-0.0081419274,
0.0237397701,
-0.0240325946,
0.0579788834,
0.1262519658,
0.0240652394,
-0.0131777572,
-0.0152860535,
0.0047165272,
-0.0481816158,
0.0272261389,
-0.0316946134,
-0.0053325398,
0.041086968,
-0.0307400376,
0.0220300667,
0.011902784,
0.0113216517,
0.0375518985,
-0.0647740215,
0.075427033,
0.0137555161,
-0.044989109,
-0.0458380766,
0.044259876,
-0.0115358252,
0.0324826762,
-0.0416990407,
-0.0856216922,
0.0611493625,
-0.0186355338,
-0.0208080076,
0.0084552923,
0.0165627692,
0.0518461056,
0.0326494277,
0.003815524,
0.0301629398,
0.0124601517,
0.0171212945,
-0.0395871699,
0.0045168241,
0.0281807277,
-0.018399572,
-0.0158327818,
-0.0291159227,
-0.024389673,
-0.0332761481,
-0.0526766144,
-0.0500420518,
-0.031267006,
-0.0168394689,
-0.0238344464,
-0.0108409924,
-0.0285397079,
0.0333342701,
-0.0008163071,
-0.0130375605,
0.0074116699,
-0.0159588177,
-0.0386803001,
-0.0183140133,
0.0455157384,
0.0700910166,
0.0090176761,
-0.0289694034,
-0.0554091781,
0.0093358112,
0.0058882856,
0.0239401273,
0.0223570392,
-0.0246065743,
0.0234008208,
-0.001803692,
0.041958563,
0.0043118596,
0.0549922846,
0.0435995236,
-0.0494919047,
-0.0027439909,
0.0436544679,
0.0013761451,
-0.0321732908,
0.0098377028,
0.0261605959,
0.0461201742,
-0.0168357417,
0.0295250341,
-0.0689976662,
-0.030173786,
0.0087162964,
0.0048399684,
-0.0011540821,
0.0081898691,
-0.0299442746,
-0.0922996476,
0.0902754515,
-0.0100268126,
0.036863856,
-0.0070647579,
0.0075409007,
0.014597985,
0.033674527,
-0.0450112596,
0.0082518859,
0.0033798139,
0.0120621687,
0.0028810955,
0.0582973994,
-0.0316207297,
0.0013262323,
-0.0313685015,
0.0080877114,
0.1191086844,
0.0155231319,
0.0158743225,
-0.0783483163,
0.0011665587,
0.046203278,
0.0077575166,
0.0015819486,
0.03824009,
0.0361200832,
-0.0137117477,
-0.0148545168,
0.0670035928,
-0.0150959864,
0.0072585219,
0.0262182821,
0.0067542633,
0.0048390478,
-0.032773532,
-0.0654598624,
0.001307533,
0.0502245948,
0.0330587588,
0.0158084016,
-0.070125252,
-0.0703005493,
-0.0590827465,
0.04690139,
-0.0902501196,
-0.041800417,
0.0088001071,
0.0028576641,
-0.0488790236,
-0.080547452,
-0.0155276824,
0.0212665908,
0.029591402,
-0.0082831485,
-0.0457579382,
-0.0279818922,
0.029270472,
-0.0236011483,
0.0102992374,
-0.0267605782,
0.0164604764,
-0.0539744198,
-0.0109945377,
-0.0048274877,
-0.0542069003,
-0.0294780023,
0.0222263504,
-0.0575948767,
-0.0075323093,
-0.0279146582,
0.0886233672,
0.0060744393,
0.0098102503,
-0.0124483295,
-0.0435445905,
0.0925510898,
0.0517968796,
0.018210372,
-0.0236058049,
-0.0034823436,
0.036615964,
-0.0062727304,
-0.0119978189,
-0.0573595911,
0.0190828852,
0.0110986317,
0.0027981191,
0.0392820053,
-0.0081625227,
0.0130032012,
-0.0063570524,
-0.0083220126,
-0.0742556229,
0.0175869931,
-0.0250113681,
0.0002012866,
0.0244006626,
-0.0055233706,
-0.064744927,
0.0167610645,
0.0104018012,
0.0091507761,
0.0052951584,
-0.0244436339,
0.0104842717,
0.0216222573,
-0.0558223315,
-0.0275904033,
0.019562671,
0.0123000443,
0.028815981,
-0.0062202639,
0.0273710713,
0.0512883663,
-0.0360126756,
0.039806623,
0.0116437217,
0.0256124232,
0.0227545071,
-0.0095621739,
0.0006998366,
0.047583349,
-0.0179311652,
-0.0622698069,
-0.0583839864,
0.0215472355,
0.0478685759,
0.0371901281,
0.0122353155,
-0.0004462159,
-0.0026224973,
-0.0198167544,
-0.004099369,
0.0156331491,
-0.0440595262,
0.0141501287,
-0.0049058376,
0.0266226102,
-0.0544998385,
0.0439717807,
-0.0619460568,
0.0108775571,
-0.0269856323,
0.0102965022,
-0.0335272104,
0.0131385,
-0.0278072413,
-0.0128661199,
0.0280547719,
0.0355144031,
-0.0036445139,
-0.0528466776,
0.0172293037,
0.0539225079,
-0.001342447,
0.0149961226,
0.082157895,
0.00629924,
-0.0331760459,
0.0111655612,
-0.0044977157,
0.0096594496,
-0.0462519601,
-0.0301391352,
-0.0337952264,
-6.054050842e-33,
-0.0210100729,
-0.0284391381,
0.0005171201,
0.0033483284,
-0.0073153009,
-0.0311266705,
-0.041691456,
-0.0040103337,
0.0325606689,
0.0331825726,
-0.0219554137,
-0.0141592203,
0.0107165389,
0.0730843395,
-0.0119651789,
0.0100087039,
0.0554007143,
0.0118907923,
-0.0672732368,
0.0650539622,
0.0011911606,
0.0157566667,
-0.0094372453,
-0.0587980486,
-0.0125832371,
-0.0044063772,
-0.0441453233,
-0.0124181416,
0.0285055507,
0.0284745414,
-0.0328553058,
0.0147387292,
-0.0081438003,
-0.0332697406,
-0.0055302526,
0.0438043438,
-0.0468059853,
-0.0328606926,
-0.0460843444,
-0.0521527417,
-0.1199799851,
-0.0585896261,
0.0248177089,
-0.0020082442,
-0.012992179,
-0.005325783,
0.0618702173,
-0.0268728752,
0.0060475036,
-0.0500112586,
-0.0475738868,
-0.0168780517,
-0.0244464297,
-0.0625065714,
0.0178297311,
0.020521054,
0.0313098095,
0.0515713356,
-0.0271334853,
0.0545186624,
0.0431664474,
0.018607907,
0.0433338247,
0.0276111457,
0.0203903131,
0.0267726574,
0.0382618308,
-0.0209144782,
-0.0124393674,
0.0108278058,
0.0039606509,
0.0556042083,
0.0418613255,
0.0358674899,
0.0184203777,
-0.0024859908,
0.0007033463,
0.0529416874,
-0.0284018479,
-0.0124574052,
0.0242541861,
0.0007485655,
0.0177581161,
0.0003909751,
-0.0341606736,
-0.0465892889,
-0.0467351265,
-0.0271411724,
0.028840594,
0.0223704334,
-0.0379711874,
-0.0223216452,
0.0247293115,
0.0013229318,
-0.0143486755,
-0.0407920666,
-0.0394214466,
0.0399780348,
-0.003960216,
-0.0415736958,
-0.0076570683,
-0.0236898344,
0.0437328108,
0.0189347118,
-0.0043593855,
0.0459052771,
-0.0047504911,
0.0093605975,
-0.0372515209,
0.0261516832,
-0.0210422408,
0.0659546629,
0.0018745391,
-0.0207425691,
-0.0053274943,
-0.0284608603,
-0.0617964976,
0.0166300014,
-0.0163602643,
0.0404678658,
-0.0351067297,
-0.0075097815,
0.0083234822,
0.0190716218,
-0.0612429641,
0.0037101293,
-0.02892082,
0.0143793374,
0.059966892,
-0.0495741256,
-0.0411387682,
0.0234932266,
2.673e-7,
-0.0100836493,
0.0193292815,
0.0004087932,
0.0457456075,
0.0045204256,
0.0721079186,
-0.0082157003,
0.0138007756,
0.0080415169,
-0.0290805642,
0.0064641857,
0.0186597817,
0.0564084351,
-0.01773794,
-0.0534223802,
0.0347612649,
-0.0610505864,
0.0455107093,
-0.001869111,
0.0082722334,
0.0508682989,
0.0506049953,
-0.0100202737,
-0.0418014303,
0.0743039325,
0.0189862289,
0.0592746995,
-0.0240424108,
0.0315624364,
-0.0222074613,
-0.0140869059,
-0.0192272514,
-0.0008712422,
-0.0178589709,
-0.024278786,
-0.0235325824,
0.0283215065,
0.023842603,
-0.0200231131,
-0.0198322739,
-0.0098612066,
0.0308721997,
0.0283956826,
-0.02537328,
0.0386412293,
-0.0385562889,
-0.005266638,
-0.0511442609,
-0.0229042489,
-0.0087936474,
0.0519742034,
-0.0559023879,
-0.0703351349,
-0.0082211327,
0.0435320847,
0.0196582209,
-0.0072451192,
-0.0416793823,
-0.0321427248,
-0.0419794321,
-0.010292735,
-0.0216754936,
-0.0757420808,
0.0352333672,
-0.0101586413,
-0.0078763189,
-0.0246892665,
2.027342505e-34,
0.0318824872,
-0.0050971643,
0.0296549238,
-0.0035854683,
0.0147656817,
0.0116631621,
0.0341408923,
-0.0063819061,
0.031395629,
-0.0481341109,
-0.0439858995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06737v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06737v1 | Detecting and Correcting Hate Speech in Multimodal Memes with Large Visual Language Model | 2023-11-12T05:20:20 | 2023-11-12T05:20:20 | Minh-Hao Van, Xintao Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recently, large language models (LLMs) have taken the spotlight in natural
language processing. Further, integrating LLMs with vision enables the users to
explore more emergent abilities in multimodality. Visual language models
(VLMs), such as LLaVA, Flamingo, or GPT-4, have demonstrated impressive
performance on various visio-linguistic tasks. Consequently, there are enormous
applications of large models that could be potentially used on social media
platforms. Despite that, there is a lack of related work on detecting or
correcting hateful memes with VLMs. In this work, we study the ability of VLMs
on hateful meme detection and hateful meme correction tasks with zero-shot
prompting. From our empirical experiments, we show the effectiveness of the
pretrained LLaVA model and discuss its strengths and weaknesses in these tasks. | [
0.0643030405,
0.0382034555,
-0.0204289332,
0.0478599221,
-0.008535333,
0.0423829332,
0.012509102,
0.0458372459,
0.034679234,
-0.0959739089,
-0.0396224782,
-0.0437504351,
-0.0298516285,
0.0270182956,
0.0088652577,
-0.0869271606,
0.0276954211,
0.0196252316,
0.0348083526,
-0.0171419065,
0.0601422414,
0.0162310619,
-0.0063259616,
0.031519711,
-0.0678348988,
-0.0135151101,
0.0464748144,
0.03196989,
0.0219529532,
-0.0166237745,
0.0215032864,
0.0335896797,
0.0258174259,
0.0370468795,
0.0000017391,
-0.0183196105,
0.0475597084,
-0.0292532071,
0.0440974236,
-0.0150899403,
0.0814216956,
-0.0663141236,
-0.0190777667,
0.0244239122,
-0.0183611251,
0.0014136453,
0.0809182674,
0.0493255928,
0.0801835135,
0.0637421384,
-0.0060237129,
-0.0449133925,
0.0225434918,
0.0063304994,
0.0321042351,
0.0075033517,
0.0193601176,
-0.0325603411,
-0.0434465222,
0.0200332627,
-0.0490750559,
0.0415391922,
0.0130071491,
0.0112738479,
0.0092285043,
-0.0072773048,
-0.0112004923,
-0.0448389165,
-0.0327748097,
0.0574306324,
-0.0552094243,
0.0123079633,
-0.0126081053,
-0.0005032948,
-0.0136561031,
-0.0379337892,
-0.0468996167,
0.0093848351,
0.0013200979,
0.0231469274,
-0.0429977439,
-0.0276197009,
0.0396595299,
0.0684653372,
0.0161260664,
-0.0166128799,
0.0175580047,
-0.0051487423,
0.0040910821,
0.0197611321,
-0.0409482978,
-0.0037305965,
0.0045146267,
0.021982722,
-0.0129496492,
0.009951802,
-0.0679106489,
-0.041382201,
-0.002229257,
-0.0653926805,
0.0610344633,
0.0136978813,
-0.0547853746,
0.0409488939,
-0.0101473005,
0.0444262996,
-0.0384256244,
0.0293352883,
0.0303412117,
-0.0185138732,
-0.0034789168,
-0.0053048939,
-0.0140820956,
-0.0364625938,
-0.0225130022,
-0.0180587079,
-0.0444723107,
-0.0056996178,
-0.043286372,
-0.024732409,
-0.0387484059,
0.0028270152,
-0.0087152077,
-0.0296956804,
-0.0499029607,
0.0509219095,
0.0122054331,
0.0185742229,
-0.0533208214,
-0.0910174623,
0.0038207718,
0.0482228734,
0.000975428,
-0.0273342896,
0.0431979708,
0.0834910497,
0.0048262491,
-0.0472900681,
-0.0544793494,
-0.0131262382,
-0.0536647551,
-0.0611393116,
0.0325924084,
-0.0788204819,
0.0047730692,
-0.0299704187,
0.0002801656,
-0.0270997752,
0.016773222,
0.025711745,
-0.0566193685,
0.1008291617,
-0.0026143845,
-0.0239132512,
0.0097885653,
0.0052317944,
0.0136057446,
0.0463878587,
0.0087989587,
0.0271965954,
0.0519186221,
-0.0121125048,
0.0089107323,
0.0669144168,
0.0118259676,
0.0167907476,
-0.0729836076,
0.0020304979,
-0.0546186343,
-0.0032133316,
0.0282909162,
0.0684382841,
-0.0246526562,
-0.0414803065,
0.098295249,
0.0589921437,
-0.0212076865,
-0.0046569156,
0.0556549095,
-0.005822307,
-0.0007866637,
-0.0405856669,
-0.0626893193,
0.0212207586,
-0.0371093079,
-0.0350338221,
0.031355612,
0.0720733777,
-0.0297184959,
-0.0285473894,
-0.0171486232,
-0.0419227742,
0.0364421643,
-0.0436964147,
0.0490948968,
0.0132745383,
-0.0302704964,
-0.0368415788,
0.0256046318,
-0.0118532386,
-0.0028455937,
-0.0263353642,
0.0307801552,
0.0728988349,
0.0332749858,
0.0113327317,
-0.0099103376,
-0.0408388376,
0.000863473,
0.068321161,
-0.0115840146,
0.0172673147,
-0.001185624,
-0.0523270182,
-0.0054931776,
0.0192410909,
-0.0001216471,
0.0149605386,
0.0627888441,
0.0165819321,
-0.008187349,
0.0516282544,
-0.0111804437,
0.0202882271,
0.0368140265,
-0.017151108,
-0.0085824588,
0.0339770429,
0.0347859338,
0.0148838665,
-0.0296586622,
-0.0547513627,
-0.0167760812,
-0.026724577,
-0.041676119,
0.0139929047,
-0.0597958378,
-0.0209593084,
0.0526877046,
-0.0633105636,
-0.0054951669,
0.0811146274,
0.0029214069,
0.0347209238,
0.0648304895,
-0.01970274,
0.0023414488,
-0.0409730412,
-0.0328255855,
-0.0173755065,
0.0389666595,
-0.0061612288,
0.0460416637,
-0.0052109142,
-0.0314860269,
0.0303952992,
-0.0088779014,
0.0064168596,
0.0156781562,
-0.0625131205,
-0.0085540405,
0.0171931293,
0.0288938321,
-0.0093160262,
0.0294468999,
-0.0375668444,
0.0054135718,
-0.1127416492,
-0.0076720938,
-0.0312342625,
-0.0479925908,
0.0117705436,
-0.0173586961,
-0.0135647543,
-0.0482277758,
-0.0309939608,
0.0320978537,
0.0669957921,
0.0302270781,
0.0131238652,
-0.0561423711,
-0.0082756821,
-0.0382278599,
-0.0164362863,
0.0130247511,
0.0138197951,
0.0164380167,
-0.053485591,
0.0217390731,
-0.0096498271,
-0.0384197123,
0.0498581789,
0.0037194788,
-0.0531659424,
0.0316805542,
0.023396289,
0.0658126771,
0.0570376217,
0.0597284548,
0.0946412906,
0.0034880294,
-0.0071068131,
-0.0067281565,
0.012371568,
-0.0176561773,
-0.0190528575,
-0.0226950832,
-0.0101569248,
-0.0199975632,
0.0571563058,
0.0143849505,
0.0307361912,
-0.0820792615,
0.0503938347,
-0.0146415159,
-0.0481612086,
-0.0112532312,
-0.0388961472,
-0.0125306528,
-0.013466021,
-0.0520646609,
-0.0985096171,
0.0287947115,
-0.008423063,
-0.0075551476,
0.0282881316,
0.0013325543,
-0.0013336933,
0.0904568061,
0.0421934016,
0.0478480011,
-0.049406331,
0.0081905844,
0.0001793385,
-0.0444499925,
0.0052026329,
-0.0112665743,
0.001783347,
-0.0360754952,
0.0060777459,
0.0034368392,
-0.0287097152,
-0.0437754914,
-0.050657738,
-0.050096754,
-0.057083454,
-0.0115229078,
-0.0252565537,
0.0050223977,
0.0052173231,
0.0449070074,
-0.0425933897,
0.0116888927,
0.0088722026,
0.0152454926,
-0.0131165981,
0.0353653319,
-0.005652213,
0.0024415685,
-0.0235305633,
-0.0192617252,
0.0639455244,
-0.0030591348,
0.0029387192,
-0.0449768528,
0.0121143684,
0.0151106315,
0.0470395312,
-0.006988958,
-0.0210888945,
0.0551888794,
-0.0252644196,
0.0186088905,
0.0794585273,
-0.0026218356,
-0.0267686509,
-0.0041316696,
0.0312179904,
-0.0201963373,
0.0250207558,
-0.0214452688,
-0.1074935496,
-0.0472455584,
-0.0522781536,
-0.0023177776,
-0.0388214365,
-0.0021214045,
-0.019563498,
-0.0927042738,
0.0299456324,
0.015538211,
0.0071245218,
-0.0292147528,
0.0423337333,
0.0321384929,
-0.0066184262,
0.0360079743,
-0.0257145353,
0.002245964,
-0.0087160273,
-0.0101370178,
0.0095669199,
-0.0202022791,
0.0007751362,
-0.0382134467,
0.0389044955,
0.0466811322,
0.0261481814,
-0.0182287972,
-0.0594335161,
0.0201752186,
0.0102039082,
-0.0015830857,
-0.0546913929,
0.0694141909,
-0.0245477632,
-0.059784662,
-0.011633751,
0.0042289882,
0.0009542718,
-0.0044691507,
-0.0160602313,
0.0281178411,
0.0004634206,
-0.0101672737,
-0.0505993329,
0.0295669883,
-0.0281541925,
0.0404497646,
0.0378908515,
-0.0642197058,
-0.012854537,
-0.0358156003,
-0.0299971234,
-0.0496417731,
-0.100895457,
-0.0233547147,
-0.019616982,
-0.008258543,
-0.0426252522,
-0.0347931832,
0.0359544568,
0.0385779217,
0.0059808162,
-0.0206800252,
-0.0105154738,
0.0094989883,
-0.017466059,
0.0414614268,
-0.0253236648,
0.058439143,
-0.0516540557,
-0.0023119645,
-0.0091495179,
-0.0204379745,
-0.0043232795,
0.0131645659,
-0.0798246637,
-0.0368001945,
0.0093677118,
0.0851736516,
0.0173909124,
0.0282683931,
0.0010240551,
-0.0670267567,
0.0548317283,
0.0663441867,
-0.0061613964,
0.030070141,
0.0131370518,
0.0039964262,
0.0228025652,
0.0253228098,
0.012871488,
0.0500196591,
0.0496121645,
-0.0325384475,
-0.0300466772,
-0.0075118891,
-0.0201102775,
-0.0140165715,
0.060540691,
-0.0136775691,
-0.0259614531,
-0.0095597981,
-0.0212776102,
-0.0030188037,
-0.0278513245,
-0.0450524017,
0.0096472623,
0.0064400383,
0.0065245982,
-0.0453103893,
-0.0479829907,
-0.0148943765,
0.0226562098,
-0.0302545074,
-0.0018272834,
0.0449393094,
-0.012109532,
0.0262108967,
0.0314626656,
-0.0072162151,
0.0635967776,
-0.000601036,
-0.0252556987,
0.0022272633,
0.0460382588,
0.0054212161,
-0.0315148346,
-0.0054142959,
0.0213619545,
0.0287132263,
-0.032965064,
0.0003353743,
0.0095646121,
0.037829496,
-0.0265467707,
0.0279328711,
-0.0083705559,
-0.0231529977,
-0.0339943357,
0.0002909424,
-0.0283170473,
-0.0260139313,
0.0295875613,
0.0175947268,
-0.0129868649,
-0.0128427343,
0.0528760999,
-0.0141723705,
0.0446750671,
0.0464409664,
-0.0155107621,
-0.0180176906,
0.0041870945,
0.0479516685,
0.0016935809,
0.0126178516,
0.0495034456,
-0.026510004,
-0.048896037,
0.0052523804,
-0.0277318936,
0.0048610661,
0.0171914529,
0.0250478312,
0.069676891,
0.0199499708,
0.0278653949,
0.0111078275,
-0.0079854634,
0.0147164101,
-0.0347099788,
0.0253959857,
-5.96443152e-33,
-0.033620663,
-0.0328796729,
0.0004605411,
-0.018517714,
-0.0037528789,
-0.0168497022,
0.0274884589,
0.0279886406,
0.0095778489,
0.0163942613,
0.0278363042,
0.0127571365,
-0.0016548713,
0.0035753069,
0.000486587,
0.0028770622,
0.0325066745,
-0.0181281902,
-0.0017091704,
-0.023320131,
0.0366398506,
0.0219019074,
0.0332813226,
-0.0481334627,
0.0124474438,
0.0012230416,
-0.0380957164,
0.0353003331,
0.0137539171,
0.0825126395,
-0.0236424506,
0.0717079192,
0.049360171,
0.0280792154,
-0.0341361687,
0.064591907,
-0.0407910459,
0.0062506674,
0.0371222608,
0.0389515087,
-0.0490619503,
-0.007993957,
0.0823178142,
-0.0098479148,
-0.0381443128,
-0.0101905186,
0.0292239711,
-0.0355034098,
0.0365377888,
0.0030507604,
-0.0753866062,
0.022451058,
0.0030295611,
-0.0351423621,
0.0107913027,
0.003465689,
0.0271770824,
0.0387830883,
-0.0353573263,
0.0408842564,
-0.0243070517,
-0.0199150778,
0.0316856615,
0.0288874712,
0.0191019643,
0.0837452039,
0.0056197173,
-0.0035617759,
-0.0292142201,
0.0157563277,
0.0351893269,
0.0296380725,
0.0501838997,
0.0690549538,
0.0222544074,
-0.0460855961,
-0.0500551313,
-0.01865343,
-0.013704245,
0.0235818382,
0.0057298793,
-0.0248957817,
-0.024665527,
0.0108316978,
-0.0095314253,
-0.0504709706,
-0.0381214879,
-0.0525865033,
0.0308711436,
0.0049426761,
0.0030518377,
0.0072818315,
0.0484905839,
-0.0147530166,
-0.0238693617,
0.0094878161,
-0.0185813494,
0.0311424714,
0.0217154175,
0.0453779399,
-0.0469972827,
0.0161764566,
0.0312131401,
-0.0195930246,
-0.0077761402,
0.0059765927,
0.0600029938,
0.0382621773,
-0.1023546681,
0.0157249924,
-0.0335887,
0.0389782526,
-0.018881809,
0.0528263934,
0.0293062311,
0.0425649248,
-0.0344625972,
0.0065623508,
0.0108456081,
-0.0522904582,
-0.0346015207,
-0.0488110855,
-0.0408388376,
0.0108928876,
-0.0154383508,
-0.0116224065,
-0.0328866988,
-0.021021815,
-0.008942957,
-0.0917922258,
0.0128072863,
-0.0367874652,
2.361e-7,
-0.0035528229,
0.051856596,
0.0180346388,
0.0337128453,
0.0300279241,
0.0521616191,
0.0000821618,
0.0105563393,
-0.0318707377,
-0.0138350101,
-0.01195243,
0.0823864266,
0.0054975972,
0.0023125601,
0.0268066134,
0.0112124514,
-0.0377202407,
0.0021202108,
-0.0600893758,
-0.0160918999,
0.0247420538,
0.0674006715,
0.0542802252,
-0.0499136932,
0.0077570998,
-0.045766063,
0.0662510395,
-0.0286222734,
-0.0224209037,
-0.0588365197,
0.0389264524,
0.0363802649,
0.0108041307,
-0.0245224778,
0.0254764538,
-0.0226387419,
0.0087231351,
0.0484276116,
-0.0132829882,
0.0066050687,
0.0005591773,
0.0224660859,
-0.0313513428,
-0.0096299034,
0.0493966378,
-0.0034550321,
0.0060650101,
-0.0653710514,
-0.0202158652,
-0.0108179385,
0.0638529509,
-0.0380673595,
-0.0414109416,
-0.0055768751,
0.0560816564,
-0.0054007242,
-0.0145519571,
-0.0969981626,
0.003944092,
-0.0149683189,
-0.0431151688,
-0.0212572683,
-0.0647349507,
-0.0040453603,
0.0436379313,
0.0336401872,
-0.0045389542,
1.528360306e-34,
0.0269278586,
-0.0500733182,
0.0225364584,
-0.0322494172,
0.0105784452,
0.0314656422,
-0.0241913032,
-0.0144015783,
0.0356085226,
-0.0475930907,
-0.0014582077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06736v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06736v1 | Are LLMs Rigorous Logical Reasoner? Empowering Natural Language Proof Generation with Contrastive Stepwise Decoding | 2023-11-12T05:12:49 | 2023-11-12T05:12:49 | Ying Su, Xiaojin Fu, Mingwen Liu, Zhijiang Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Logical reasoning remains a pivotal component within the realm of artificial
intelligence. The recent evolution of large language models (LLMs) has marked
significant progress in this domain. The adoption of strategies like
chain-of-thought (CoT) has enhanced the performance of LLMs across diverse
reasoning tasks. Nonetheless, logical reasoning that involves proof planning,
specifically those that necessitate the validation of explanation accuracy,
continues to present stumbling blocks. In this study, we first evaluate the
efficacy of LLMs with advanced CoT strategies concerning such tasks. Our
analysis reveals that LLMs still struggle to navigate complex reasoning chains,
which demand the meticulous linkage of premises to derive a cogent conclusion.
To address this issue, we finetune a smaller-scale language model, equipping it
to decompose proof objectives into more manageable subgoals. We also introduce
contrastive decoding to stepwise proof generation, making use of negative
reasoning paths to strengthen the model's capacity for logical deduction.
Experiments on EntailmentBank underscore the success of our method in
augmenting the proof planning abilities of language models. | [
0.0256739967,
0.0496746525,
0.0094429301,
0.0474026613,
-0.0602257363,
0.0173149444,
0.0182822142,
-0.0586013198,
0.0028205975,
-0.0090966169,
0.0442868695,
0.0341383852,
0.0077115172,
0.0403600857,
0.0356781632,
-0.0381301157,
0.0074375961,
-0.0420516878,
-0.001445789,
-0.00498003,
-0.0092200432,
0.0246991664,
-0.0206542015,
0.020904528,
0.0074154832,
-0.0311451424,
-0.0367789231,
0.0270346887,
0.0194244422,
-0.0464449897,
-0.0309817046,
0.0153524559,
0.0170720816,
0.0525681116,
0.000002145,
-0.0635810494,
-0.0098240441,
0.031276986,
-0.0809377134,
0.0004956441,
-0.0529915057,
-0.0507523268,
0.0069245296,
0.0280783679,
-0.0158014819,
0.0195383728,
0.0099270325,
0.0721839219,
0.0705015063,
0.0867944881,
0.00905181,
-0.0941926762,
0.0404632688,
-0.0075516556,
-0.0109962067,
-0.0262637995,
-0.0102163265,
0.0370200649,
0.0483357385,
-0.0059585636,
-0.0006078151,
0.0271828435,
0.0570224747,
-0.0012140671,
-0.0552957207,
0.0432577506,
-0.0260035228,
-0.0365148969,
0.0154376607,
0.0378273092,
0.0083441641,
-0.057754755,
-0.0147246951,
-0.0029922717,
-0.0432254784,
0.0067490651,
-0.0157293044,
0.0969325379,
-0.0352315567,
0.0133038107,
0.065074645,
-0.0114208916,
0.0563037992,
0.0140202548,
-0.0593466572,
0.1021739766,
-0.0232635345,
-0.054716818,
0.0328345522,
0.0230125189,
-0.01986368,
-0.0890932828,
0.0196350813,
0.0492838509,
-0.0345202349,
0.0311306417,
0.0125791095,
0.0011500519,
0.0054772347,
-0.0051284907,
0.005919076,
0.0473545641,
0.015167824,
0.0325539634,
-0.0627083555,
0.0067839883,
-0.0350411832,
0.0121211354,
-0.0043504708,
-0.034171842,
-0.0399381593,
-0.0017859259,
-0.0072683012,
0.0529287048,
-0.0299853757,
0.0121464645,
0.0035299896,
0.0223937444,
-0.022586843,
0.0611340888,
0.0134380898,
-0.0061375783,
0.0311843138,
-0.0603168048,
-0.0377345793,
0.0132477107,
-0.0629017353,
0.0133202393,
0.0521539077,
-0.0068408381,
-0.0307336785,
0.0216067359,
-0.011875717,
0.0061659249,
0.0211289637,
0.0474468581,
0.0123652536,
0.0063418006,
-0.069535993,
-0.0583702512,
-0.0153333377,
-0.0756348595,
-0.0010775746,
-0.0767365173,
0.0065673469,
0.0264025684,
-0.0194589589,
0.0030470064,
0.0152670192,
0.0362664834,
-0.0062579084,
0.0810386017,
-0.0191182382,
-0.0199247841,
-0.0048894486,
0.0144735863,
-0.0498397164,
0.0269239023,
0.0450626053,
0.040562883,
0.0074655786,
0.040882878,
-0.0007286106,
-0.0179901645,
0.0119234445,
-0.0364426933,
-0.0157498177,
0.0017038021,
-0.0309918709,
0.0222752988,
0.0056568598,
0.0392274633,
-0.0428066403,
0.0118319849,
0.0290802475,
0.0290011801,
0.026369689,
0.0036206702,
0.0628123581,
-0.0172791556,
-0.0237231907,
0.0036950565,
-0.0468980223,
0.0249917302,
-0.0659956858,
0.0141731305,
0.0136889331,
0.0128925284,
-0.0150235668,
-0.0659036636,
-0.0251097083,
-0.0051659327,
0.0138421459,
0.0132116061,
0.0409684442,
0.0106562125,
-0.0394837633,
0.0244606994,
0.0082832705,
-0.0754803643,
-0.025902763,
-0.0412273668,
0.0586782359,
0.0355369933,
0.0637055561,
0.0176716503,
-0.007319984,
-0.027937429,
0.0184701551,
0.0857515559,
0.0061780293,
-0.0122254295,
-0.0004359267,
-0.036526002,
-0.0234882161,
-0.0255748089,
0.017950695,
0.0045856,
0.0192436948,
-0.0068494147,
0.0235971268,
0.0003625173,
0.0061023524,
0.031869974,
-0.0419969112,
0.0053410199,
0.0046306718,
0.0243071597,
0.0327937379,
0.0181311909,
0.0037300263,
0.032478299,
0.0109764505,
-0.0459965914,
-0.0492711775,
0.0358434319,
-0.0236705597,
-0.0937352777,
0.0379358716,
-0.0549263656,
-0.0062453882,
0.0098383576,
-0.0564619005,
-0.0223546829,
0.0435922332,
-0.0359698758,
-0.0049210358,
-0.0347449854,
0.0172720533,
0.0333193131,
-0.0384292677,
0.0078655928,
0.079768613,
-0.0074570272,
-0.020091895,
-0.0119676627,
0.0035699769,
0.0079370262,
-0.0250663701,
0.0424141176,
0.0317559578,
0.012525849,
-0.0150590092,
0.028987214,
0.0205596834,
-0.0337629542,
-0.0218027271,
-0.0438641086,
0.020205114,
-0.0216230396,
0.0318138041,
0.0178684425,
-0.0425979868,
0.0372759514,
0.0226850603,
-0.0016380715,
0.0046461592,
0.0294962972,
-0.0049138567,
0.0379194729,
-0.0070209592,
-0.0510364696,
0.0027886946,
0.0062069707,
-0.0253552347,
0.0347625986,
-0.0204102099,
-0.0313605294,
-0.0266972054,
0.0346806422,
-0.0264725666,
0.0038120535,
-0.007465519,
0.0014702911,
0.0503400825,
0.0095354691,
-0.0178616345,
0.078856267,
-0.0094527556,
0.0134217804,
0.0332872905,
-0.0127837379,
-0.0104338164,
0.0424500816,
-0.0146080386,
0.0154475225,
-0.0231799614,
-0.0550585128,
-0.0135539658,
0.0406955592,
-0.0317627974,
0.0128893396,
-0.0557428896,
0.017096607,
0.0145505555,
-0.0016208418,
0.0196067486,
-0.0385538079,
-0.0077626384,
0.0821052045,
-0.0226515997,
-0.0297673922,
0.0656292513,
-0.0225925036,
-0.0042936783,
-0.0213413425,
-0.009387386,
-0.0487354361,
0.0629533753,
0.00887735,
0.0143180229,
-0.0064051705,
0.0199416447,
-0.0127499634,
-0.0526705161,
0.0484625474,
-0.0025488618,
0.0358134545,
-0.0642969534,
-0.0050735427,
-0.0029375898,
-0.0480436571,
-0.0539526008,
0.0173776504,
-0.056672439,
0.0093280012,
-0.0561205447,
-0.0061339643,
-0.0162397772,
-0.0036153174,
0.0428855643,
0.0192598905,
0.0248607639,
-0.0327028148,
-0.0283679366,
-0.0032614211,
0.0060873413,
0.0255501512,
0.0691629946,
-0.0136415856,
0.0648380443,
0.0525854304,
0.0003194445,
0.0093343621,
-0.0263140053,
0.0220354069,
-0.012687793,
-0.0060155308,
-0.0279652923,
0.0264120027,
0.0327088572,
-0.0700171366,
-0.0148660829,
0.1197408214,
0.0247129705,
0.0118673481,
0.001424695,
-0.0311758555,
0.0513072871,
0.0125889285,
0.0187692158,
-0.0660154447,
-0.0543654561,
0.0384076275,
0.0237969216,
-0.0103123114,
-0.0464721732,
-0.0289716404,
-0.126488179,
0.0446429811,
0.0191721581,
0.0012819066,
-0.0196751542,
-0.0592028834,
-0.004090162,
0.0083956346,
-0.0201941859,
0.024242755,
0.0298792496,
0.0029781887,
0.0097482437,
-0.0269073471,
-0.0155861015,
0.0098908022,
-0.0503323004,
0.0203691423,
0.0489785112,
0.0195542742,
0.0224668551,
-0.0394015275,
0.0161887687,
-0.034557756,
0.0018463676,
-0.0356834047,
0.0021207316,
-0.0044346969,
0.0274453927,
-0.0348387808,
0.0466535762,
-0.0580253936,
-0.0615951233,
0.0256978162,
0.0982723907,
-0.0294920504,
-0.0485999025,
-0.0190577228,
0.0338446125,
-0.0342775695,
0.0808668733,
0.0168584399,
0.0073968046,
-0.0478905439,
-0.0444378555,
-0.0304748565,
-0.0540593415,
-0.0000042496,
0.0074790958,
0.0371575803,
-0.0009591221,
-0.0506363772,
-0.0467058942,
0.0123809716,
0.0521033518,
-0.0360982604,
-0.0083145462,
0.0185795035,
-0.0090422202,
-0.0286316462,
0.0148434294,
-0.0384871475,
0.0239977911,
-0.0149449017,
0.0288533326,
-0.0137771489,
-0.0362556912,
-0.0127631417,
0.0518438555,
-0.0436279923,
-0.0641753227,
-0.0447857007,
0.0348752253,
0.0287204571,
0.0493870154,
-0.0049695321,
-0.0248561502,
0.000617787,
0.0306375623,
0.0122797145,
0.0060617798,
0.0703628436,
0.0156256594,
0.0168204419,
0.0416657887,
-0.0174635164,
0.0084808404,
0.009725784,
0.08869268,
-0.0146652898,
-0.0187297259,
0.030458672,
0.0300313979,
0.0085748648,
-0.0068318499,
-0.023274662,
-0.0171426218,
0.0390016027,
-0.060059946,
-0.0206962153,
-0.0351315774,
0.022931572,
-0.0020164368,
-0.0112011675,
-0.0152198104,
-0.0336345583,
-0.0015787944,
0.0026109109,
0.0197264291,
0.0272589419,
0.0048281793,
0.0245067924,
0.0115395822,
-0.0411396287,
-0.0322618298,
-0.0082149627,
-0.0194448512,
0.0394355506,
-0.0169412922,
0.0681444556,
0.051532615,
0.0056072199,
-0.0431536809,
-0.0028021729,
-0.0555641614,
-0.0385395847,
0.0294753928,
-0.0303655975,
0.0474416092,
0.0210349858,
0.0425316952,
-0.0420034826,
-0.0156458281,
0.0147280823,
0.0445834845,
0.0258072931,
-0.0534238778,
0.0127343209,
0.0227999371,
-0.028228743,
-0.0375062376,
0.0293917898,
-0.0471685566,
0.0292542744,
0.0135763139,
-0.0107798716,
-0.0288809929,
-0.0712136403,
-0.0684449896,
0.0242681112,
-0.0122729363,
0.0018427257,
-0.0706025213,
-0.0863411352,
-0.0110664852,
0.0305420477,
0.0106025888,
0.0244677123,
0.0063589895,
0.04522058,
0.0336973593,
-0.0649787411,
0.0051767593,
0.0288211908,
-0.0077461894,
-0.0246960167,
0.0000725395,
-6.233750868e-33,
-0.0267248023,
-0.0421686023,
0.0590373315,
-0.0085515175,
-0.0104438653,
-0.0286333878,
-0.0898627862,
0.0021706859,
-0.012660264,
0.059945561,
-0.0104688527,
0.0248381626,
0.0110804178,
0.0267596003,
-0.0195960458,
-0.0025850795,
0.019015288,
0.0295703448,
-0.0262084603,
0.00156292,
0.0420249403,
-0.0203987751,
0.016096523,
-0.0350152999,
0.0052468702,
-0.0158686787,
-0.0240998827,
0.0572027303,
-0.0641205609,
0.0202150233,
0.0044394955,
0.0027038453,
0.0229634345,
-0.0234978907,
0.0085904915,
0.0099225417,
-0.0768630952,
-0.0123294778,
0.0426155478,
-0.0250374284,
-0.0620941445,
-0.057331156,
0.0237143785,
0.0217694435,
-0.0133281965,
-0.0198379606,
-0.0169218499,
-0.0191892311,
0.0095773097,
-0.0136104599,
-0.0622800365,
0.0318467282,
-0.0224621315,
-0.0229626521,
0.0256111622,
0.0291957334,
-0.0149727697,
-0.0126938252,
-0.0513793305,
-0.0094665727,
-0.0052570105,
-0.0305935927,
0.1063116565,
-0.0165966749,
-0.0280426145,
0.0488117412,
0.0108707584,
-0.0088104336,
-0.0648099631,
0.0394493937,
-0.0250554029,
0.0557714291,
0.0702932328,
0.0001666372,
0.0156410411,
0.0413747765,
-0.1014194414,
0.0026303569,
-0.0094775883,
0.0495571792,
0.0588580072,
-0.0108680958,
-0.0421576835,
-0.0103669232,
-0.0344016775,
-0.02069401,
-0.0206233915,
-0.0129501456,
0.0229988117,
0.0191620179,
-0.0185190905,
-0.0184588991,
0.0059586819,
-0.0293559786,
0.0086075207,
0.0573991165,
-0.0096663134,
-0.0190118738,
-0.0017663203,
0.0380908027,
-0.0449390411,
0.0194975939,
-0.0015301675,
0.0277306605,
0.0176996551,
-0.0029022447,
0.0411299616,
-0.0057444433,
-0.0246713329,
0.0019427345,
-0.0835782886,
0.0282315239,
-0.0205571894,
0.0187781733,
0.057662122,
0.0247803535,
-0.0155561231,
0.0133522302,
-0.0114027867,
-0.0253277589,
-0.0323475897,
0.060860198,
0.012016234,
0.006986748,
0.0067892191,
-0.0065605752,
-0.0258489698,
0.0293967426,
0.0356431641,
-0.0561280698,
-0.014508686,
0.0365914442,
2.835e-7,
0.0035399876,
0.0536973253,
0.0278041307,
0.0812181085,
0.0250721052,
0.0469492897,
-0.0141226267,
-0.0463431403,
0.0166747198,
-0.0755970106,
-0.0136777051,
0.0657350197,
0.0435755588,
0.0605379529,
-0.0188137498,
-0.0099585513,
-0.0194203872,
-0.061971765,
-0.0406707525,
-0.0012469993,
0.1121768206,
0.0574558862,
0.0366013274,
-0.025478825,
0.0222121198,
-0.0015287859,
0.0359480977,
-0.0029753256,
0.000389577,
-0.04103975,
0.0234459955,
-0.0222968087,
0.0185218528,
0.0407515951,
0.0124244541,
0.0130680883,
-0.0739718974,
0.0418942347,
-0.0045158272,
-0.0263976157,
-0.0391134359,
-0.0374596566,
0.0304838307,
-0.0496818163,
0.0962098613,
-0.0372137651,
-0.0317760222,
0.0028310958,
-0.024742391,
-0.027768489,
-0.0268571787,
-0.0021349099,
0.0010718862,
0.0079896934,
0.0003380025,
-0.0075994353,
0.0089152418,
-0.0960853845,
-0.0346753038,
0.0463721044,
-0.022013424,
-0.0038439129,
-0.0004156598,
0.0447215959,
0.048706498,
-0.0708312318,
-0.0297798794,
2.902118998e-34,
0.0248394925,
0.0016261267,
0.0251154546,
0.006323244,
0.0787395164,
0.0118817808,
-0.0474706255,
-0.0034367,
0.0321863256,
-0.0980387181,
-0.0355826542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06729v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06729v1 | Comprehending Lexical and Affective Ontologies in the Demographically Diverse Spatial Social Media Discourse | 2023-11-12T04:23:33 | 2023-11-12T04:23:33 | Salim Sazzed | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study aims to comprehend linguistic and socio-demographic features,
encompassing English language styles, conveyed sentiments, and lexical
diversity within spatial online social media review data. To this end, we
undertake a case study that scrutinizes reviews composed by two distinct and
demographically diverse groups. Our analysis entails the extraction and
examination of various statistical, grammatical, and sentimental features from
these two groups. Subsequently, we leverage these features with machine
learning (ML) classifiers to discern their potential in effectively
differentiating between the groups. Our investigation unveils substantial
disparities in certain linguistic attributes between the two groups. When
integrated into ML classifiers, these attributes exhibit a marked efficacy in
distinguishing the groups, yielding a macro F1 score of approximately 0.85.
Furthermore, we conduct a comparative evaluation of these linguistic features
with word n-gram-based lexical features in discerning demographically diverse
review data. As expected, the n-gram lexical features, coupled with fine-tuned
transformer-based models, show superior performance, attaining accuracies
surpassing 95\% and macro F1 scores exceeding 0.96. Our meticulous analysis and
comprehensive evaluations substantiate the efficacy of linguistic and
sentimental features in effectively discerning demographically diverse review
data. The findings of this study provide valuable guidelines for future
research endeavors concerning the analysis of demographic patterns in textual
content across various social media platforms. | [
0.0559741482,
0.0764642283,
-0.0061711348,
0.0142208114,
-0.0287374966,
0.0328602791,
0.0076255002,
-0.0035704367,
-0.0148487044,
-0.1017828658,
-0.0297341067,
-0.0378471874,
0.0487308055,
0.0329805501,
-0.0470378064,
-0.0303964056,
-0.0136702787,
0.0378169976,
0.0289824158,
-0.0115429861,
-0.0241053477,
0.0860789493,
0.0354665443,
0.0546533503,
-0.0065351855,
-0.0087019559,
0.0561255254,
0.0146522988,
-0.0141817266,
0.0230777916,
0.0411875322,
0.0456408933,
-0.0656873509,
0.0216141678,
0.0000020116,
-0.0206233654,
-0.0070725628,
-0.0100460714,
0.0491929725,
-0.0445089601,
0.1274219453,
-0.0253121853,
-0.0075055566,
-0.001639111,
-0.0253768954,
-0.0184990037,
0.0338660479,
0.0359599292,
0.0239015147,
0.0392765887,
-0.0136582563,
-0.0494695678,
-0.0376611389,
0.0489283837,
-0.0127858259,
0.0681188926,
-0.0004756138,
-0.031744767,
-0.00706456,
0.0025170625,
-0.0034632976,
0.0079473052,
-0.0264335349,
0.0013864534,
0.0174453761,
-0.0070639746,
-0.0070753316,
-0.0008713694,
-0.0009223498,
-0.0002506433,
0.0322424918,
-0.0105545307,
0.0135876518,
0.021246193,
-0.0120605147,
0.0291815195,
-0.0294968076,
0.0066463365,
-0.0170545001,
0.0393415727,
-0.0319485553,
0.0296347123,
0.0115262065,
0.0449124612,
0.0148108238,
0.0910458267,
-0.0168795437,
-0.0014697224,
-0.0114732673,
0.0810587481,
0.0269478783,
0.005395527,
0.0515363105,
-0.0149268471,
0.0102577806,
0.0320656672,
-0.0148371998,
-0.0326446556,
0.0129460972,
-0.0777615756,
0.0275171753,
-0.0426646024,
-0.0343850665,
0.0205118656,
0.0394218005,
-0.0297462456,
0.0560582876,
-0.0145713435,
-0.0094207795,
-0.0242031645,
-0.0723331273,
0.0102648856,
0.0419995077,
0.0447076522,
0.0002246683,
0.0325600766,
-0.0690514222,
-0.0216686968,
-0.0472973734,
-0.0228300691,
-0.0142099094,
0.0333427638,
0.020377351,
0.0054153162,
-0.0170470383,
0.02203466,
-0.0130389305,
0.0054937014,
-0.0739976168,
-0.0335504599,
0.0810629278,
0.0248652641,
0.0510737412,
-0.0183145013,
-0.0234867744,
-0.0124787344,
0.0516826548,
-0.030001821,
-0.043924585,
-0.0351155885,
-0.037094716,
-0.0182232577,
-0.0069338595,
-0.0604250729,
0.0149117997,
0.0355551317,
0.0052391416,
-0.0281695724,
-0.0210483707,
0.0125652207,
-0.0615209527,
0.0379198492,
0.0088016689,
0.0205534697,
0.0502225943,
-0.0050973846,
0.0337697454,
0.0715160072,
0.0012078281,
0.028630415,
0.1043594405,
-0.0205406863,
0.0042378693,
-0.0129618496,
-0.0276717879,
0.0053506596,
-0.0341054536,
-0.0084326863,
-0.0405642949,
-0.0364878662,
0.0199728664,
0.0640866384,
0.0435926653,
-0.0106952405,
0.0668256134,
0.0815192908,
0.0006130065,
0.0620524883,
0.0441087261,
0.0690341592,
-0.005796677,
-0.0108535569,
-0.0125303278,
-0.0168543514,
-0.0365100168,
-0.0618606545,
0.0033474257,
0.0553834923,
-0.0146862753,
-0.0643735155,
-0.0416868664,
-0.0061457632,
0.032011494,
-0.0092034256,
0.0516939536,
-0.0119126514,
0.0241002087,
0.0281671099,
0.0522462986,
-0.0346422903,
-0.0040844446,
-0.0183739644,
0.0130326338,
0.0507235378,
-0.02675521,
0.0256245751,
0.0061349631,
-0.0319663882,
-0.0126503855,
-0.0174374375,
0.0437312461,
0.0234628525,
-0.0039073313,
-0.021145476,
-0.0062371008,
0.0010853498,
0.0224360265,
-0.0114122368,
0.052365046,
0.0651276633,
0.009049545,
-0.0183861945,
-0.0244463887,
-0.0005879659,
0.0417336263,
0.0076637785,
0.0352630354,
0.0193494186,
0.0186812803,
0.0464811809,
0.0085878577,
-0.0278290417,
-0.0224126503,
0.0233483743,
-0.0340025164,
0.0395816267,
-0.0120644746,
0.0027734111,
0.0028116181,
-0.0421360917,
-0.0336979441,
-0.0088817049,
-0.0143309357,
0.0165555067,
0.0482263789,
-0.0507343858,
0.0157373771,
0.0051322239,
-0.0107164886,
-0.031389527,
0.0026565921,
-0.0255878996,
0.0661980584,
-0.0156930871,
0.0045196828,
-0.0664432794,
-0.0893026143,
-0.0058503891,
0.0017839941,
-0.0137307113,
-0.0290880706,
-0.0269783046,
0.0104400422,
-0.0083419159,
0.0023979531,
-0.0321576037,
-0.0548418202,
-0.0902537704,
-0.0391878225,
-0.0483937822,
0.0154466974,
0.0020557148,
-0.0421706699,
-0.0176642481,
0.0191017278,
-0.0152999219,
0.0005259851,
-0.0066420431,
0.006991419,
0.025377132,
-0.0425140373,
0.0557798259,
-0.0147680379,
-0.0304376278,
-0.0350281708,
0.0706560016,
0.0225696005,
-0.0331575759,
-0.0057094567,
-0.0494281687,
-0.0659851953,
-0.0274535529,
0.0287835579,
-0.0147133153,
0.0079940464,
-0.0108191334,
-0.0099043651,
0.0051225452,
0.0374495648,
0.064140372,
0.0118659511,
-0.0235990137,
0.0036232867,
-0.0029380978,
-0.0323338807,
0.0427869819,
-0.0143370321,
-0.0649760589,
0.0428821407,
0.0390445404,
0.0071344497,
-0.0136799971,
-0.0250523239,
0.0290255062,
-0.0728221759,
-0.0150909238,
-0.0107301427,
0.0079485271,
0.0255789366,
-0.0035570529,
-0.0120775001,
-0.0168446619,
0.028826613,
0.0248364452,
0.0250825118,
-0.0540056787,
-0.0393125974,
-0.0458929799,
0.055624526,
-0.0228543095,
0.0240981076,
0.030812921,
-0.032020431,
0.0383405499,
-0.0327848643,
-0.0115766209,
-0.0377700441,
0.088651821,
-0.0243017375,
-0.0205033757,
0.071647875,
-0.056334272,
0.0073431791,
-0.0533051565,
-0.0523605458,
-0.0318164714,
0.032408502,
-0.0478529148,
0.0149652576,
0.026443271,
-0.0339686722,
-0.0304080341,
-0.024134811,
-0.0315884799,
0.0314605087,
0.0197364762,
0.0553072467,
0.0081993882,
0.0187451839,
0.0162730198,
-0.0463216901,
0.0037982929,
-0.0557089224,
-0.0058421665,
-0.0096358256,
0.0023464758,
0.0404835306,
-0.0453892648,
-0.0623190366,
-0.0177972652,
0.0435700677,
-0.0174989887,
0.0213577319,
0.0851659551,
0.0437949225,
-0.0433219746,
0.0088985516,
-0.0217090435,
-0.0055428641,
-0.0111815287,
0.0401040167,
-0.0228646621,
0.0122780502,
-0.0241958536,
0.0110429879,
-0.0173456464,
-0.0105996002,
0.0004161113,
-0.0907457471,
0.0263970234,
-0.0035727639,
-0.039622847,
-0.0192817561,
-0.0060874615,
-0.0017526315,
-0.0206540432,
0.0087444549,
-0.0735021979,
-0.0539253168,
0.0120500112,
0.0210419074,
-0.056139268,
-0.026710853,
0.0262661781,
0.0020197302,
0.0236695539,
-0.0169609543,
0.0815776736,
-0.0191522166,
-0.0214516968,
0.0002864311,
0.0059478413,
0.0257652067,
-0.0405029617,
0.0463683978,
-0.004561217,
0.0215446986,
-0.0528223552,
-0.0105296308,
-0.0321150906,
0.0004447678,
0.0033319842,
0.0071939332,
-0.0295397621,
-0.0478611998,
-0.0452222638,
0.0584307723,
0.0166535676,
0.0342945233,
0.0126831634,
-0.045467902,
-0.0079251574,
-0.0616483614,
-0.0000635832,
-0.0215959381,
-0.0484746844,
0.021984037,
-0.0121225445,
-0.0592305437,
-0.0328885987,
-0.0412143096,
-0.0183516182,
0.0055039916,
-0.0120902024,
-0.0462353118,
0.0414507985,
0.0011127801,
-0.0537755303,
0.0533093922,
-0.0189587474,
0.0090327961,
0.0084322691,
-0.0361801162,
0.0375603028,
-0.0084230816,
0.0059351148,
-0.0641919002,
-0.0304620378,
-0.0054351944,
0.0444822162,
0.0191709772,
0.0089782299,
-0.0109099401,
-0.028453825,
-0.0499338843,
0.0620042086,
0.0395303406,
0.0101198014,
-0.0158974286,
0.0200082473,
0.0514005013,
-0.0028333003,
0.0203801934,
0.0033588165,
0.0165574178,
0.0238571819,
-0.0728658214,
-0.0626776665,
-0.0026881113,
-0.031120846,
-0.0366560854,
0.0412986353,
0.0024119969,
-0.0118128508,
-0.0088371076,
-0.0662902966,
0.0046724291,
-0.0010643773,
-0.0335141793,
-0.064814873,
0.0155547494,
0.0363429822,
-0.1053580865,
0.0058418829,
-0.0011553351,
0.0342190452,
-0.069160156,
0.0642252862,
0.0129965432,
-0.0119967777,
-0.0139932074,
0.0205589347,
-0.0348640606,
0.0096920589,
0.0302677378,
0.0082471604,
0.0076466822,
0.0214062128,
-0.019780999,
0.0210178588,
-0.0467250459,
0.0251364224,
0.0036507116,
0.0374136753,
-0.0168884192,
-0.0061154999,
0.0264383368,
-0.0626053959,
0.0356797986,
-0.0242805202,
0.0029347127,
0.0069952211,
0.0179762337,
0.0074890908,
-0.0357996933,
0.009804491,
-0.0126695074,
-0.0176696107,
0.0024572648,
0.0437907614,
-0.0544350259,
-0.0266739614,
0.0498479269,
-0.058895532,
-0.0214222111,
0.0082074804,
0.0266620126,
-0.0211217813,
0.0127694793,
0.0163389202,
-0.0668813512,
-0.0257610511,
0.0652308762,
-0.087650165,
0.0546872616,
-0.0097265048,
0.01916904,
0.0545397736,
-0.001339486,
0.004215823,
-0.0887053981,
-0.0237361658,
-0.0165341385,
-0.0081523955,
-0.0108442204,
-6.533145605e-33,
0.0040940116,
-0.0856105387,
-0.0463390015,
0.0105557516,
-0.0173445158,
0.0054753521,
0.0152104292,
0.0112633593,
0.0272280294,
0.0306150597,
-0.018718347,
0.0259933136,
0.0178523883,
0.0332607105,
0.0687312558,
-0.0171525814,
0.0241951756,
0.0144994631,
0.0256046467,
0.0042517171,
0.0260993224,
0.0120010292,
0.0370321386,
-0.0819786787,
0.0654983371,
0.0301379934,
-0.0114021534,
-0.004331904,
0.0356608145,
0.0403072797,
-0.0067431936,
0.0819010586,
0.0370526016,
-0.0130801164,
0.0164373331,
0.041928973,
-0.0514410622,
-0.0325853452,
0.0072002197,
0.0335692093,
0.0365382992,
-0.0435387865,
0.0452346429,
0.0396037325,
-0.0219107829,
-0.0308976211,
0.0776343048,
0.0180096403,
0.0228638574,
-0.063304536,
-0.0503322594,
0.0518940352,
-0.0117494939,
0.0381399021,
0.0307102166,
0.0168218706,
0.0013696713,
0.0238808803,
-0.0603542514,
0.0349585861,
-0.0060497369,
0.0075867372,
0.0124304229,
0.0027225025,
-0.0170193445,
0.0445403643,
-0.0168652236,
0.0334299654,
-0.0588581339,
0.0093462132,
0.0451637805,
-0.0018406499,
0.0004868795,
0.0455010459,
0.0219909213,
-0.0538051873,
0.012185039,
-0.0002499609,
0.054801099,
-0.0078895651,
0.0336520635,
-0.0464281887,
-0.0491355099,
-0.0182580445,
0.0259464011,
-0.0420021452,
-0.0182416476,
-0.0147824707,
-0.04308993,
-0.0193213616,
-0.0494188592,
0.0162222572,
-0.0268415064,
-0.0590211712,
-0.0614134707,
-0.0013956686,
-0.0150170643,
0.0357953608,
0.0007255196,
0.0180514771,
-0.0134766847,
-0.0049541686,
-0.0352099054,
0.0159102064,
0.0226399731,
0.014093875,
0.0503537729,
0.0594633669,
-0.0798274428,
-0.0038046904,
0.0215818528,
0.0030170924,
-0.0302033387,
0.0332979597,
0.0190052707,
0.0381106846,
0.0014361155,
0.0127603346,
0.0179669503,
0.0891178772,
0.0358767956,
-0.0235831514,
-0.0304234941,
-0.0015121095,
-0.024863502,
-0.0201826151,
-0.0011746793,
-0.0509067327,
0.0228977203,
-0.0077683083,
-0.0056664892,
-0.0352893025,
2.712e-7,
0.0634544492,
0.1005534828,
-0.0426110551,
-0.0497534499,
0.0405614004,
0.019911157,
0.0597117804,
-0.0121676615,
0.0162990429,
0.0070349625,
0.031918373,
0.0088681942,
0.055033315,
0.0696829334,
-0.118644163,
0.0580568872,
-0.0420736447,
0.0077445782,
-0.0360383466,
0.0554907918,
0.0285351351,
0.051894784,
0.0314241126,
-0.0163831059,
-0.0336047746,
0.0219945796,
-0.015340222,
-0.0704534873,
-0.0119900154,
0.0164869707,
0.0643618181,
-0.0477751009,
0.0198015254,
-0.0125173479,
-0.0440997966,
-0.0175515078,
0.0313072279,
0.0503400341,
-0.0040240847,
-0.0304877944,
0.0168912616,
-0.0027552804,
-0.0145609574,
-0.0416231379,
0.0566006228,
-0.0299279317,
-0.0535388254,
-0.0833466873,
0.006891232,
0.0064503201,
0.0487252064,
-0.0238453355,
-0.0291238688,
0.030654069,
0.0247026011,
-0.047176417,
-0.0287708528,
-0.0605521165,
0.0206048749,
0.0417714939,
0.0261450652,
-0.0071493792,
0.017351944,
0.0175549202,
0.0208195075,
0.0023097217,
0.031887982,
2.106440877e-34,
0.0079241674,
0.0314088762,
-0.0031147264,
-0.059883561,
0.0190818794,
0.0429566167,
-0.0375022963,
0.0003761676,
-0.0036435772,
-0.0059021343,
0.0432113521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06724v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06724v1 | Controllable Topic-Focused Abstractive Summarization | 2023-11-12T03:51:38 | 2023-11-12T03:51:38 | Seyed Ali Bahrainian, Martin Jaggi, Carsten Eickhoff | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Controlled abstractive summarization focuses on producing condensed versions
of a source article to cover specific aspects by shifting the distribution of
generated text towards a desired style, e.g., a set of topics. Subsequently,
the resulting summaries may be tailored to user-defined requirements. This
paper presents a new Transformer-based architecture capable of producing
topic-focused summaries. The architecture modifies the cross-attention
mechanism of the Transformer to bring topic-focus control to the generation
process while not adding any further parameters to the model. We show that our
model sets a new state of the art on the NEWTS dataset in terms of
topic-focused abstractive summarization as well as a topic-prevalence score.
Moreover, we show via extensive experiments that our proposed topical
cross-attention mechanism can be plugged into various Transformer models, such
as BART and T5, improving their performance on the CNN/Dailymail and XSum
benchmark datasets for abstractive summarization. This is achieved via
fine-tuning, without requiring training from scratch. Finally, we show through
human evaluation that our model generates more faithful summaries outperforming
the state-of-the-art Frost model. | [
0.032882046,
0.0151006561,
0.0253702495,
0.013849902,
-0.012588759,
-0.0041447231,
-0.0112999203,
-0.0178683121,
-0.0620736405,
-0.0142978365,
-0.0157574657,
-0.0150178662,
-0.0080991043,
0.0497131273,
0.0167681985,
-0.0931820944,
-0.0073832232,
0.0133976797,
-0.023127852,
0.0089765862,
0.0271305591,
-0.0004954537,
0.0507377237,
0.0137298731,
0.0254249442,
0.0008581137,
-0.0061408025,
-0.0160532929,
0.0344810449,
0.0063606179,
0.0254965406,
0.0270527396,
0.0242932439,
-0.0148813203,
0.0000018143,
0.0106479935,
-0.0169840567,
-0.0069746529,
0.0687940344,
0.0164667331,
0.0696929321,
-0.0742677078,
0.0222918466,
0.0051274034,
0.0014281683,
0.0016312262,
0.0242280923,
0.1100415662,
0.1010015234,
0.0680164397,
-0.0262114182,
-0.0506531522,
0.069208771,
-0.0450706333,
-0.0245781895,
-0.0250763092,
-0.0126497401,
0.00035093,
-0.0267845895,
0.045259241,
-0.0137407826,
0.0398938581,
0.0314954221,
-0.0227475632,
0.0515506379,
0.0261273105,
-0.0458575264,
-0.0196757391,
0.0191255007,
0.0602829307,
-0.0080836713,
-0.0354868062,
0.0398675911,
0.0015478489,
0.0004615833,
-0.0158399865,
-0.0773222446,
0.0471854694,
-0.0186507143,
0.0132380081,
0.0184164122,
0.0252622906,
-0.0357364453,
0.0386756249,
-0.0312341973,
-0.0061314655,
0.0094003929,
-0.0035611261,
-0.0570658259,
0.0157198459,
0.0003528452,
-0.0541030057,
0.0161450114,
0.0301752556,
-0.006550163,
-0.0350082405,
-0.0489394441,
-0.0812264457,
-0.0062921601,
-0.017452566,
0.0053183227,
0.0133296456,
0.0118448772,
0.0139751304,
0.0121361157,
0.0072124288,
-0.030452555,
0.0110108349,
-0.0556899235,
-0.0250570178,
-0.0007633494,
0.0202933978,
-0.0437152535,
0.0281895883,
-0.0201733578,
-0.0207548104,
-0.0334220082,
0.0327993445,
0.0011883511,
-0.0313154347,
0.0035947522,
0.0135454247,
-0.0620441362,
-0.021773424,
0.0269087739,
0.0226702206,
-0.0334622748,
-0.0247382019,
0.0510316528,
0.0211867001,
-0.0097748498,
0.0310324803,
0.020171145,
0.0230204668,
-0.0200168546,
-0.00298663,
-0.0601038933,
-0.0301294234,
-0.0145266717,
-0.0141075691,
-0.0018033104,
-0.0269008055,
0.0254221726,
-0.0672559664,
0.0017788729,
0.0019633197,
-0.0215818901,
0.0171652548,
-0.0119887516,
0.0269982647,
-0.0543888956,
0.0015977868,
0.0176573824,
-0.016920561,
0.0498612486,
0.0211175941,
0.0261135139,
0.0430076718,
0.0185256116,
0.0699806735,
0.0043513426,
0.02968877,
0.0158067681,
-0.0147489188,
0.0384999402,
0.0303306822,
0.039167095,
-0.0124619305,
-0.0912070274,
-0.0012253855,
0.053791184,
0.0547007993,
-0.0340018757,
0.0131430179,
0.0734156296,
0.0262356866,
0.0052817576,
0.0852590278,
0.0374983512,
0.0373751298,
-0.000005735,
0.0603532381,
-0.014604602,
0.068965055,
0.0158650149,
0.0593616068,
0.0767289996,
0.0180175751,
-0.0505319536,
-0.0270604175,
0.0417971499,
-0.0096485866,
-0.0201847646,
-0.0260659996,
0.0368094407,
0.0471951514,
-0.0299597178,
0.075684242,
-0.0075836009,
-0.037853267,
0.0110035399,
-0.0149741787,
0.0273155663,
0.0137648163,
0.0291653033,
-0.0157581829,
-0.0328992084,
-0.006111668,
0.0314551927,
0.0763837844,
0.03608758,
0.0120573444,
-0.0317509882,
-0.038835343,
-0.0252560899,
-0.0386094563,
-0.0115077514,
-0.0079607954,
0.0029554998,
-0.0244164839,
0.0322009064,
0.005037175,
-0.0219636373,
0.021395063,
-0.0220641084,
0.00233708,
-0.0099757751,
-0.0397229753,
0.0245133564,
0.0033091789,
-0.0130109582,
0.0177502036,
0.0046561058,
-0.0327895284,
-0.034960065,
0.0108721424,
-0.0397282392,
-0.0117572788,
-0.0030867981,
-0.10350959,
-0.011997981,
0.0442463942,
-0.0398894288,
-0.0500952154,
0.0578321144,
-0.0607446134,
0.0204426926,
-0.0356995016,
-0.0002449954,
0.023609383,
0.0012168334,
-0.0135251051,
0.0526406728,
-0.0339780673,
0.0004506268,
0.0587081425,
-0.0421185531,
-0.0282760691,
-0.0206956025,
0.0190682504,
-0.0269893277,
0.002384709,
0.0019288807,
0.0492125191,
-0.0151428757,
-0.0055550523,
-0.0327361524,
-0.0607571118,
0.0090581011,
-0.0348253213,
0.0033082794,
0.0821876675,
0.042216327,
0.0144884791,
0.0028811961,
-0.0534730405,
0.0007960246,
-0.0085385274,
0.0129118171,
0.0285271108,
0.0049425117,
0.0413457081,
-0.0347288437,
-0.0264031105,
0.0030364476,
0.040440321,
-0.0010444494,
0.0039473171,
-0.0550749153,
0.0202426538,
-0.0107204728,
-0.025218403,
-0.0146740489,
0.0036482096,
-0.0198143851,
-0.0188648216,
0.0697593093,
0.0413604677,
0.0616236515,
-0.0001255905,
0.0286030825,
0.0120549956,
-0.0190647058,
-0.0195593592,
-0.0514115691,
0.0322582759,
0.0207926109,
-0.0460757613,
0.0384107865,
0.0662012994,
0.0162270851,
0.0283076223,
-0.0206351783,
0.011761087,
-0.0001301742,
0.0094096223,
-0.007826671,
0.0009104417,
-0.0096318079,
-0.0022094753,
-0.0418009572,
-0.0183130857,
0.0656916499,
-0.0021506336,
0.0227558538,
-0.0583244748,
0.0113205398,
-0.0507683866,
0.00592385,
0.0185740609,
0.0260283761,
0.0176789425,
-0.0212956797,
-0.0477678962,
-0.019136399,
0.014817372,
-0.0065584444,
0.1065994948,
0.0023676953,
0.0228641815,
-0.039378237,
-0.0213137288,
-0.0024149006,
-0.0452100262,
0.021737095,
0.0458923802,
0.0521135591,
-0.0265160613,
-0.0651214346,
0.0191151071,
0.0676426739,
0.07251966,
-0.0454885326,
-0.0335733071,
-0.0092981318,
0.0805265456,
0.0769560561,
-0.0128550772,
-0.0031228366,
-0.0421633907,
0.0253447387,
0.0681238621,
0.0065966169,
-0.0179502126,
-0.013417555,
-0.0221242551,
-0.0047804355,
-0.0676080659,
-0.0007115637,
-0.0348888598,
0.0591570474,
-0.0376079567,
-0.0357631929,
0.0813348517,
0.0076977056,
-0.0495849326,
-0.0273949336,
0.0259052925,
0.0419571698,
-0.0023271358,
0.0106683057,
-0.063491933,
0.0212155916,
-0.0133501897,
0.0503194742,
0.0381821766,
0.0011757524,
0.0082878051,
-0.0354712121,
0.0188867878,
0.0047851978,
-0.088452585,
-0.0536943302,
-0.0103949225,
0.0164010618,
-0.0240175668,
-0.0096819634,
0.0170974359,
-0.0244702604,
-0.0040833228,
0.0055393116,
-0.0533231497,
-0.0040042624,
-0.0382583812,
-0.0276244823,
-0.0260070395,
0.0159917362,
0.0254383311,
-0.0080015762,
0.0064250613,
-0.0011152728,
-0.0487751253,
-0.0151085686,
0.0002141339,
0.0704264417,
-0.0167787168,
0.0109393569,
-0.0312937014,
0.0520880111,
0.019000113,
-0.0123959547,
-0.0085130297,
0.0280970372,
-0.0147316223,
-0.014346621,
-0.0548084676,
0.0225338489,
-0.0161233544,
0.0580204427,
0.0589135028,
-0.0187255479,
-0.03959186,
-0.0259989966,
-0.0157159865,
-0.0959589183,
-0.0483057275,
-0.0279538017,
-0.0357082598,
-0.0480801649,
-0.0781630948,
-0.0568137318,
-0.0228210725,
-0.0177484918,
-0.0300486051,
-0.0691356957,
0.0112244459,
-0.0352701582,
-0.0416907743,
-0.0001049934,
-0.0075570219,
-0.0286430158,
-0.0176099278,
-0.0392807834,
0.0730398297,
-0.0297062583,
-0.0206918698,
0.04342952,
-0.0507574454,
-0.0378346555,
0.0019981004,
0.0351684764,
0.0136052677,
0.072427623,
-0.0005311658,
-0.0193445403,
0.0650248677,
-0.0016136483,
0.010810636,
0.0215529278,
0.0082529513,
0.0115590356,
-0.0030152283,
0.0236827303,
-0.0453279056,
0.0733981282,
-0.0032322414,
0.0322633348,
-0.0431963801,
-0.0056759887,
0.0043896926,
-0.0216350388,
-0.0060745585,
-0.0218250174,
0.0318095237,
-0.0404808819,
-0.0180524401,
-0.0103487913,
-0.0046838555,
-0.0377471335,
0.0361846834,
-0.0055062696,
-0.0082101924,
-0.017180359,
0.0976879448,
-0.0085241022,
0.0046537826,
-0.0643239394,
0.0121662021,
-0.0609772019,
-0.0085824216,
-0.0624173693,
-0.0009945988,
-0.0658014864,
-0.0449535511,
-0.0278708059,
0.0203107223,
-0.0086102821,
0.0223115329,
0.0373086408,
0.0067847804,
-0.0233813003,
0.0306020658,
-0.1183923036,
0.0085135587,
-0.0572143011,
0.016859429,
0.0289545488,
-0.0420802161,
0.0759081468,
-0.0006894201,
-0.0246472917,
-0.0107105542,
0.030705981,
0.0219125357,
0.0061738142,
-0.0307445787,
0.0130577106,
0.0216663573,
-0.0164272711,
0.074395664,
-0.0334785394,
-0.0196228027,
0.0259937011,
-0.0133327749,
-0.0386812203,
-0.0023658799,
-0.0066876207,
-0.0022324105,
0.0184144042,
-0.0338288397,
-0.0260262489,
-0.0198573079,
0.0500622466,
0.0086826412,
0.016656328,
-0.0227378327,
0.0412313342,
0.0346475132,
0.0065675252,
-0.0259262007,
-0.0603732094,
0.040575657,
0.0123388451,
-0.0101013435,
-0.035845723,
-6.179544415e-33,
-0.0301534347,
0.0322050117,
-0.0200040024,
0.0537615642,
-0.0499949753,
0.0371982902,
-0.1014145091,
-0.0196635015,
0.0007147624,
0.0074939821,
-0.0131345363,
0.0299703404,
0.00253544,
0.0411714576,
0.0147253377,
0.0262497235,
0.0549879894,
-0.0047991583,
-0.0423934683,
0.0924706832,
0.0358736813,
0.0071427678,
0.0404774658,
-0.0307999831,
-0.0024343296,
-0.02978356,
0.0073174532,
-0.0312953368,
0.0706705227,
0.0408800319,
0.0066121644,
-0.0040289429,
0.0521535501,
-0.0724154636,
-0.0587297045,
0.0407496579,
-0.0677138492,
-0.0122631146,
-0.0008183626,
-0.0377990007,
-0.0550664105,
-0.0392047241,
0.0708204731,
-0.0248860922,
0.0227232911,
-0.0731636509,
0.0618864521,
-0.0281276442,
-0.0052070785,
-0.1041733548,
-0.0375426859,
0.0248270594,
-0.0159605425,
-0.0293966681,
0.0048250002,
0.0245505329,
0.0099897804,
0.0466190502,
-0.0190899838,
0.0413200818,
0.0288055111,
0.0783113912,
0.0414469764,
0.0101888105,
-0.0271622129,
0.0309063233,
-0.027638562,
0.0173505209,
-0.0292288177,
0.009122326,
-0.0028510368,
0.0245086048,
0.0577444434,
0.0062709893,
0.0159997046,
0.0386664346,
-0.0276190713,
0.0684771538,
-0.0178369787,
0.0446885787,
0.0338963531,
0.0229618605,
0.0353189595,
0.0058277161,
0.0088611431,
0.0081542889,
-0.0191819649,
-0.0021439353,
-0.0188420098,
0.0419513844,
-0.0504852757,
0.0279520061,
0.0408556163,
-0.0270121638,
0.0382683054,
0.0189400706,
-0.0132177407,
0.0354820751,
0.0152324131,
-0.0355056822,
-0.0714296922,
0.0073284204,
0.0152681293,
0.0280575976,
-0.0316499434,
0.006455448,
0.0580946617,
0.0166232605,
-0.0462194085,
-0.018530719,
-0.0125908917,
-0.0040266425,
-0.0456507578,
0.0433359742,
-0.0182400029,
0.0091615198,
-0.0027144419,
0.0258703902,
-0.0173079148,
0.0122637786,
-0.0031947356,
0.0219701231,
0.0384450257,
0.0616815649,
-0.00852759,
0.0306076854,
-0.0487809256,
0.0293438695,
0.0374141186,
-0.0662293285,
-0.0405169167,
0.0114575289,
2.474e-7,
0.0402501784,
0.0203195643,
0.0327002332,
0.0014617435,
0.0051640631,
-0.0014207031,
0.0236828029,
0.0695279688,
0.0241769589,
-0.0235496443,
0.0367917269,
0.0321687832,
0.0230946038,
0.0245804489,
-0.0945099592,
0.0163984038,
-0.0816377327,
-0.0037564202,
-0.0066573108,
-0.015707694,
0.0291418936,
0.065988183,
-0.0238199532,
0.020355003,
0.0239514224,
0.0013567128,
0.0530007817,
0.0158612467,
-0.0407056734,
0.0463679917,
0.0385150723,
0.0105687883,
-0.0184597299,
-0.0545477979,
-0.0370382369,
-0.0237230062,
0.0285114422,
0.0463934168,
0.0293899179,
-0.0117295729,
0.0325900875,
-0.0245828088,
0.023248272,
-0.0200976245,
0.0190877263,
-0.0880293697,
-0.0030029186,
-0.0454643033,
-0.0572252348,
0.051708281,
-0.0270752646,
-0.0036856008,
-0.0455542877,
0.047357738,
-0.0099458741,
0.0063541606,
0.0042194463,
-0.0498584323,
-0.0421660803,
0.0148174269,
-0.0178383775,
-0.0284939297,
-0.0417600088,
-0.0428979322,
-0.0103085376,
-0.040236026,
-0.0334351696,
2.296963027e-34,
0.0856940225,
-0.0079803709,
-0.041089274,
-0.0050222944,
-0.0112176035,
-0.0250267927,
-0.0150249908,
-0.0016512445,
0.0025782264,
-0.0477051884,
-0.0181146134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06720v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06720v1 | Cappy: Outperforming and Boosting Large Multi-Task LMs with a Small Scorer | 2023-11-12T03:25:34 | 2023-11-12T03:25:34 | Bowen Tan, Yun Zhu, Lijuan Liu, Eric Xing, Zhiting Hu, Jindong Chen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) such as T0, FLAN, and OPT-IML, excel in
multi-tasking under a unified instruction-following paradigm, where they also
exhibit remarkable generalization abilities to unseen tasks. Despite their
impressive performance, these LLMs, with sizes ranging from several billion to
hundreds of billions of parameters, demand substantial computational resources,
making their training and inference expensive and inefficient. Furthermore,
adapting these models to downstream applications, particularly complex tasks,
is often unfeasible due to the extensive hardware requirements for finetuning,
even when utilizing parameter-efficient approaches such as prompt tuning.
Additionally, the most powerful multi-task LLMs, such as OPT-IML-175B and
FLAN-PaLM-540B, are not publicly accessible, severely limiting their
customization potential. To address these challenges, we introduce a pretrained
small scorer, Cappy, designed to enhance the performance and efficiency of
multi-task LLMs. With merely 360 million parameters, Cappy functions either
independently on classification tasks or serve as an auxiliary component for
LLMs, boosting their performance. Moreover, Cappy enables efficiently
integrating downstream supervision without requiring LLM finetuning nor the
access to their parameters. Our experiments demonstrate that, when working
independently on 11 language understanding tasks from PromptSource, Cappy
outperforms LLMs that are several orders of magnitude larger. Besides, on 45
complex tasks from BIG-Bench, Cappy boosts the performance of the advanced
multi-task LLM, FLAN-T5, by a large margin. Furthermore, Cappy is flexible to
cooperate with other LLM adaptations, including finetuning and in-context
learning, offering additional performance enhancement. | [
0.0321573876,
0.037837483,
0.0165355094,
0.0545642339,
0.0054280604,
0.0361654647,
0.0395070463,
-0.0538928844,
-0.0062268823,
-0.0446077883,
-0.0924342871,
-0.0450048819,
-0.0201938227,
0.0087058721,
0.0201598257,
-0.0242611691,
0.0540267304,
-0.0448004529,
-0.0017172963,
0.0136013953,
-0.0146237947,
0.0414881557,
-0.0129962536,
0.0428344421,
0.0112763308,
-0.0194512177,
-0.0178648494,
0.0338158086,
0.0172408763,
-0.0092048934,
0.0435534529,
0.053053394,
0.0561331362,
0.0628904551,
0.0000022885,
-0.0260472242,
-0.0121860411,
-0.0248596836,
-0.0506573021,
0.0281602349,
0.0555658303,
-0.0081167221,
-0.0094115082,
0.0157721434,
-0.0240132287,
-0.0193612985,
0.0410634726,
0.029797677,
0.0605853051,
0.0817852393,
0.0120128663,
-0.009662278,
0.0111004934,
-0.0529981852,
-0.0142997093,
-0.074387975,
0.0205238368,
-0.049478054,
-0.0025198848,
0.0113518275,
-0.0007613451,
0.0352577157,
0.0291248243,
-0.0045916466,
-0.0232708566,
0.0334780701,
-0.018536061,
-0.0405319035,
-0.0307897925,
0.073485449,
-0.0377513617,
-0.0276226122,
-0.0087330453,
-0.0076182508,
0.0046893344,
-0.0400885269,
-0.0400949344,
0.0321800932,
0.0035801849,
0.0044214269,
0.0376894884,
-0.0333991423,
0.0588197596,
0.0271580201,
-0.018410394,
0.0378709398,
0.005740704,
0.0055232607,
0.0126782535,
0.0262370706,
-0.0518055037,
-0.0470618531,
-0.0047030514,
0.0312375389,
-0.0775988847,
0.0034562945,
-0.066681087,
-0.0278232899,
0.0109319156,
-0.0069128657,
0.0718893185,
0.0420504399,
-0.045886416,
0.0664835051,
-0.0269191004,
0.0287701003,
-0.0277005527,
0.0394216739,
-0.0583655611,
-0.0038160717,
-0.0419432297,
0.0013215163,
-0.0246577561,
0.0121260006,
-0.0291931182,
-0.0117503479,
-0.0279568154,
0.0474884808,
-0.0051111742,
0.0107672866,
0.0336348601,
-0.0101931021,
-0.0535160229,
-0.0053289384,
0.0124749467,
0.0421625003,
-0.0255141705,
0.0405254662,
0.0076442822,
-0.0595578812,
-0.0349070169,
0.0207759105,
0.0099459151,
-0.0332980789,
0.0589679889,
0.0399285667,
-0.0126991225,
-0.0595674217,
-0.027217079,
-0.0054282919,
0.0005916186,
-0.1039771885,
-0.0135442996,
-0.0456264615,
0.0357612073,
0.0032611662,
0.0057806754,
-0.0130559383,
0.0104445526,
0.0318621993,
-0.0098662181,
0.0781975314,
0.0152116427,
-0.0057751331,
0.0119763166,
-0.000443466,
-0.0343364775,
0.0753525645,
-0.0145635335,
0.0482509769,
0.0247134604,
0.0078821583,
-0.0019619218,
0.0346470997,
0.0156254526,
0.0069957268,
0.0164875574,
0.0108931204,
0.0440692082,
0.0214020163,
0.0560583398,
0.0248812512,
-0.0013864385,
-0.0039565726,
0.0790849552,
0.0302544292,
0.0022201864,
-0.0338986255,
0.0824945942,
0.0129211536,
-0.02013693,
-0.012803507,
-0.0903433561,
0.0274338145,
-0.0222708508,
-0.0173379108,
-0.0019272031,
0.0443350375,
-0.0573999844,
-0.0326095112,
0.0110292956,
-0.0084149232,
-0.0505682342,
0.0689712018,
0.058339227,
-0.0170036834,
-0.0360310376,
0.0289056338,
0.0405738503,
-0.0178874359,
-0.0032617045,
-0.0631592348,
0.018835105,
0.0704733506,
0.0016222943,
-0.0558516942,
-0.0412160344,
-0.0256495625,
0.038450852,
0.0288670827,
0.0520489067,
-0.0203628093,
0.0468155406,
-0.0660337508,
-0.0031086144,
-0.0309049115,
0.0131372064,
0.0249056704,
0.0234222133,
-0.0101566976,
0.0117760245,
-0.0061529111,
-0.0154416338,
0.0464076288,
-0.0154939648,
-0.058670409,
0.0095043126,
0.0231823754,
0.0245061032,
-0.0048999009,
-0.005822558,
-0.0098690307,
0.0438247845,
-0.0358873606,
0.0282801837,
-0.0375152007,
-0.0666032732,
-0.0339875706,
0.0221263673,
0.0446506068,
-0.0288209636,
0.0457598493,
-0.0640417114,
-0.0618279241,
-0.0074872412,
0.0039631566,
0.0049535749,
-0.0360788777,
0.0365166739,
0.013343418,
0.0294130072,
-0.0094790645,
0.03281039,
0.0121983364,
-0.0141410921,
0.0256160405,
0.0047383588,
0.0043362938,
-0.0391563028,
-0.0417934693,
-0.0151748974,
-0.0048084082,
0.0092755044,
-0.0157072879,
0.0311511327,
-0.0202612393,
-0.0308608226,
-0.0908030644,
0.0400469601,
-0.056546621,
0.0129292607,
0.0270673111,
0.0140357157,
0.0031802231,
-0.0429012887,
0.0043558958,
-0.0002856559,
-0.0164417643,
0.0253182072,
0.00357481,
0.0417353734,
-0.0334180854,
-0.0426005498,
-0.026197087,
0.0141689349,
0.0144594191,
-0.0215801504,
-0.017997466,
-0.055129651,
0.0030293367,
0.0189339444,
0.0385040715,
-0.0210893787,
-0.0206299871,
0.0094578778,
-0.0439823754,
0.0346556604,
0.0930207819,
-0.0180196408,
0.0310784895,
0.0434998758,
-0.0087677846,
-0.0537403822,
0.0446579158,
-0.0009696774,
-0.0535299443,
-0.0273799822,
0.0308023244,
-0.0171892364,
0.0843821466,
-0.0215140581,
-0.0132522462,
-0.0554178283,
-0.0066194595,
0.0055970373,
-0.0386387147,
-0.0547775552,
0.0189588945,
-0.0057673119,
0.005528267,
-0.0373331867,
-0.0433831289,
0.0494849458,
-0.0345863402,
-0.0330853127,
-0.0127204079,
-0.0486505255,
-0.0337636918,
0.0763169676,
0.0072942227,
0.0082910117,
0.0172223132,
-0.0498531908,
-0.0790028721,
0.0237990264,
-0.0047944868,
-0.0044414843,
0.0708846375,
-0.0569539368,
0.004931902,
-0.0409884267,
-0.0554506443,
-0.0252513159,
-0.0371952429,
-0.0412810817,
0.0216596741,
-0.0019040164,
-0.0274463091,
-0.0374460407,
-0.0234924834,
0.0284319874,
0.0589297228,
-0.0244974103,
0.0078379577,
-0.0364218615,
-0.0045926264,
0.0134668732,
0.0096826544,
-0.0063357046,
-0.0636939853,
0.0170094501,
0.0411542691,
0.0356712602,
-0.0205839742,
-0.0168370027,
0.0069269678,
0.047187943,
-0.0341633558,
-0.0408632047,
0.0194938499,
0.0732561275,
-0.1009863839,
-0.0035319908,
0.1168560386,
0.0030030138,
-0.0677804053,
-0.0268247239,
0.0164487548,
0.0097227208,
0.0374634117,
0.0184692778,
-0.0603366271,
-0.0584589504,
0.018720217,
0.0161987506,
0.0165085718,
0.0032930993,
-0.0204796754,
-0.0862981901,
0.0381166786,
-0.0048368834,
-0.044834096,
-0.0168160051,
-0.0255016685,
-0.0038349736,
-0.0064072502,
0.04125816,
0.0180441644,
-0.012076702,
-0.0196478423,
0.0083430232,
0.0137728667,
-0.0448357575,
0.0511693805,
-0.0464087799,
0.0436349064,
0.0353348367,
0.0077841766,
0.007086941,
-0.0071064453,
0.048907306,
-0.0325644612,
0.0019840708,
-0.0253024865,
0.0308791995,
-0.0269358475,
-0.0220688079,
0.0187882427,
0.0301074702,
-0.0384057276,
0.0184484869,
0.0008907042,
0.0723110065,
-0.0190163981,
0.0129332962,
0.0222319514,
-0.0250085089,
-0.0034145173,
0.0676348507,
0.0328109786,
-0.0509041324,
-0.0515040942,
-0.0108465459,
-0.0814441368,
-0.0526705459,
-0.012990932,
0.0158802327,
-0.0028792729,
-0.031627126,
-0.019537786,
-0.0399038643,
0.0461627506,
0.0347100981,
0.0008702811,
0.0148043744,
-0.0197171792,
0.0010666086,
-0.0632903054,
0.0440241285,
-0.0391507447,
0.0292528383,
-0.0744494945,
-0.0233725589,
0.0500227511,
-0.014720398,
-0.0004055247,
0.0223376546,
-0.1090707481,
-0.0583587624,
-0.0103479819,
0.0563983321,
0.0175998658,
0.0331916772,
-0.0311843399,
-0.0353930295,
0.0134101585,
0.006298346,
-0.029290352,
0.023813488,
0.050599657,
-0.0151356049,
-0.0015151654,
0.0537503883,
-0.04407949,
0.0330076069,
0.022363469,
0.0192051232,
-0.0209920742,
-0.0342219248,
-0.00182247,
-0.007229134,
0.0504423231,
-0.0109683741,
-0.0200598687,
-0.0345269777,
0.0219907649,
-0.0057885898,
-0.0244253222,
-0.0362542756,
0.0078627542,
0.0405130871,
-0.025419658,
-0.0079810349,
0.0085606454,
0.0366344005,
0.0215116069,
-0.0633047074,
0.0160701741,
-0.0147996712,
0.0121103488,
0.032926552,
0.005530715,
-0.0385776795,
0.0215932224,
0.0303662848,
0.0402651578,
-0.0412144735,
0.0452657267,
0.006035666,
0.012381522,
-0.0513947234,
0.0592347309,
-0.0729127824,
-0.0565565191,
-0.0330598727,
0.029882811,
0.0821512118,
0.0045459587,
0.0289486609,
-0.0075506894,
-0.0193059184,
-0.0355001166,
0.0191005357,
0.0145534007,
-0.0201182663,
0.0422240756,
0.0261143167,
-0.0102576884,
0.0199293979,
0.0737838224,
-0.0167145524,
0.0468724929,
0.0283421446,
0.0337322056,
-0.044483602,
-0.0202140491,
0.0092442157,
0.0012221056,
-0.0233005863,
0.0215930399,
0.0127334762,
-0.0370415263,
0.0008717473,
-0.006272628,
-0.0324720666,
-0.0241819713,
0.0162379947,
0.0429930836,
0.008287386,
-0.0199590214,
-0.0408996828,
-0.0103411302,
0.018755449,
-0.0005273739,
0.0001171961,
-7.093412661e-33,
-0.0476789698,
0.0113867503,
0.0462725013,
0.024043059,
-0.0093132546,
0.0086108036,
-0.0223740395,
-0.0191738531,
-0.0340362303,
-0.0084426878,
-0.0170878973,
0.0249099284,
0.0379720218,
0.024811415,
0.0320673659,
-0.0329738259,
0.0677470192,
-0.0139976749,
-0.0011161463,
0.0429304019,
0.0388576537,
0.0414257646,
0.0590794012,
-0.0356233343,
0.0070450781,
-0.0160085205,
-0.0061719758,
0.0405849367,
-0.0230570976,
0.0364656486,
-0.0035358209,
0.0431038663,
0.0228265934,
-0.0495024063,
-0.0263111312,
0.0433467031,
-0.0906251594,
-0.0076541086,
0.0017844109,
0.0205846224,
-0.022007348,
-0.0307411551,
0.0116111292,
0.0043154405,
0.0340321325,
-0.0125984568,
0.0112488838,
-0.0144075565,
-0.0184863284,
-0.0194679294,
-0.0287684612,
-0.0080802282,
0.0192774665,
-0.0325847268,
0.0404088199,
0.0438153222,
-0.0060155983,
0.0123256501,
-0.0593127199,
-0.0132877128,
-0.0400236882,
0.0526180305,
0.0572087616,
0.0589599907,
-0.0062243282,
0.0357354693,
0.0150366491,
-0.0038433727,
0.0083752871,
-0.0131615987,
0.0331129581,
0.0800239891,
0.0090169171,
0.0129751163,
0.0108345365,
0.0119607495,
-0.0662574619,
0.0039276537,
0.0758978724,
0.0203939397,
0.0414840542,
0.0130765671,
-0.0282521732,
-0.0094202971,
-0.0304005928,
0.011957787,
-0.047088474,
0.0175600126,
0.0330512039,
0.036031235,
0.0017838385,
-0.0012080136,
0.049734246,
-0.0263396017,
0.0135611109,
-0.013901432,
0.0204017684,
0.0085035581,
-0.0021137325,
0.043558117,
-0.0600713901,
-0.0497791171,
0.0202059131,
-0.0190925971,
0.0152102597,
0.0143000372,
0.0603045188,
0.0293954909,
-0.0481722355,
-0.0285068098,
-0.0464392193,
0.0291454121,
-0.0003099592,
0.0568997003,
0.0305373576,
0.0004117037,
-0.0105596241,
0.0695975423,
-0.0132935727,
-0.0195451528,
-0.0102990121,
-0.0363161862,
0.0058170543,
0.0101543684,
-0.0364797488,
0.0077516921,
-0.0463570729,
0.0064798705,
-0.0011630037,
-0.0568547472,
-0.005264801,
0.0268430822,
2.966e-7,
0.0324699059,
0.0306021404,
-0.0044081784,
0.0175382979,
0.0120675322,
0.0414421298,
-0.037701454,
0.0228283089,
0.005583493,
-0.0225369595,
0.0181862507,
0.0616479032,
0.0684451088,
0.0226454381,
-0.0769852549,
-0.0091444608,
-0.0197624974,
0.0362550616,
-0.0566149391,
-0.0040279212,
0.0287571419,
0.120058462,
0.0030208973,
-0.0267801527,
0.0375567153,
-0.0276864003,
0.0489167683,
-0.0185659211,
-0.010248173,
0.0123247942,
0.0282408819,
0.0337608904,
-0.0143201388,
0.031259492,
-0.023086071,
0.0242128037,
-0.0305396114,
0.0989301428,
-0.0007944554,
-0.0309618395,
0.0040929648,
-0.0097270031,
0.0193287507,
-0.0416590497,
0.0877614096,
-0.0589049645,
-0.017022673,
-0.043404948,
0.0189798754,
-0.0341628268,
0.0032820629,
-0.0033603655,
0.0119528789,
0.0387890115,
0.0219471827,
-0.0585784204,
-0.0600786917,
-0.1266981512,
-0.0222944599,
0.023469992,
-0.0483457036,
-0.0381370075,
-0.0429528914,
-0.0322401971,
0.0295889266,
-0.0650465414,
-0.019322332,
2.882453804e-34,
0.029758079,
-0.035944216,
0.0182434674,
0.0348957814,
0.0143684866,
0.0054967902,
-0.0707045794,
0.0036738438,
0.0210456774,
-0.0730573535,
-0.0232087728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06714v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06714v1 | What factors influence the popularity of user-generated text in the creative domain? A case study of book reviews | 2023-11-12T02:54:11 | 2023-11-12T02:54:11 | Salim Sazzed | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | This study investigates a range of psychological, lexical, semantic, and
readability features of book reviews to elucidate the factors underlying their
perceived popularity. To this end, we conduct statistical analyses of various
features, including the types and frequency of opinion and emotion-conveying
terms, connectives, character mentions, word uniqueness, commonness, and
sentence structure, among others. Additionally, we utilize two readability
tests to explore whether reading ease is positively associated with review
popularity. Finally, we employ traditional machine learning classifiers and
transformer-based fine-tuned language models with n-gram features to
automatically determine review popularity. Our findings indicate that, with the
exception of a few features (e.g., review length, emotions, and word
uniqueness), most attributes do not exhibit significant differences between
popular and non-popular review groups. Furthermore, the poor performance of
machine learning classifiers using the word n-gram feature highlights the
challenges associated with determining popularity in creative domains. Overall,
our study provides insights into the factors underlying review popularity and
highlights the need for further research in this area, particularly in the
creative realm. | [
0.0682661384,
-0.0203778297,
-0.0238731951,
-0.0074925958,
-0.0373805687,
0.0105674705,
-0.0014898528,
-0.0054288912,
-0.0067508589,
-0.0579056926,
-0.0450509004,
-0.0027199511,
0.0299798176,
0.0711577088,
-0.015773382,
-0.0023587141,
-0.0348042063,
0.0136865554,
0.0516662262,
0.0215352327,
0.0120553775,
0.0480740704,
0.0235855859,
0.0501580015,
0.0116714872,
-0.0197763015,
0.0539775789,
0.0206164829,
-0.003670604,
-0.0215893537,
-0.0198381208,
0.0768425018,
-0.0090286769,
0.0149166947,
0.0000017433,
-0.0094545661,
0.0159309879,
-0.0173655748,
0.0457956754,
0.0219181534,
0.1168438345,
-0.0047419262,
-0.0258817133,
-0.0078381849,
-0.0089540463,
-0.0054843244,
0.038330052,
0.0938783735,
0.0315133929,
0.0375371128,
-0.0132701406,
-0.0614886247,
-0.0101156794,
0.0076116365,
0.0114870733,
0.0228842888,
-0.0173256751,
0.0304305721,
0.0189702604,
0.0028012402,
-0.0076368367,
0.0125571415,
-0.025704274,
-0.0350568295,
0.0288244858,
0.0195447206,
-0.0106672058,
-0.0337193459,
0.0010461767,
0.0365747996,
0.0234931093,
-0.0461897887,
0.0064290836,
-0.0005401353,
-0.0048393789,
0.0731148198,
-0.0653792545,
-0.0205136072,
0.0156022776,
0.0138283847,
-0.0260286927,
0.0260172728,
0.0163826477,
-0.0165458694,
0.065933384,
0.0122018205,
0.0076440526,
-0.0105966991,
0.0295713507,
0.0289812293,
-0.0159239173,
-0.0467932485,
-0.0064474926,
-0.0269448757,
0.0501178391,
0.0009640346,
-0.0167260654,
-0.0387273654,
0.0229471289,
-0.0840717778,
0.0764534622,
-0.0357656889,
0.0135334674,
0.0564665943,
-0.01960898,
-0.0256050155,
0.0275526028,
-0.0171822868,
-0.0029652892,
0.0550471544,
-0.0527166314,
-0.0118637644,
0.0107464148,
0.0278953165,
0.0186000783,
-0.0491108783,
-0.0655627996,
-0.0189326163,
-0.0052220118,
-0.0234300401,
0.0231146272,
0.0352549106,
0.020999806,
0.0352217667,
-0.0201097894,
0.0182538927,
-0.0226190407,
0.0203486066,
-0.0320495144,
0.0273108073,
0.0744371042,
0.0037852915,
0.0305690188,
-0.01125878,
0.0076486166,
0.0259930249,
0.0262425169,
-0.0256587323,
-0.0353231169,
-0.0149129927,
-0.0142515237,
-0.0063723144,
-0.0314170718,
-0.0497143567,
-0.0073672091,
0.0451226011,
-0.0003447844,
0.0071198447,
-0.02261623,
0.0393836498,
-0.049290888,
0.016384067,
0.0036265978,
0.0060148546,
0.0277449843,
0.0113296891,
0.0256828796,
0.0081295874,
0.029743189,
0.0413969122,
0.0908214003,
-0.0373008437,
0.0736511946,
-0.0073454981,
-0.0543985702,
-0.040918313,
-0.0109889675,
-0.0219843071,
-0.0680655465,
-0.0162010416,
-0.0193344764,
0.0581207201,
-0.008809072,
0.0162340961,
0.0951666534,
0.048182182,
0.0129473573,
0.0708959475,
0.0374861434,
0.0412969589,
0.0054050516,
0.0188284256,
0.0239098333,
0.0399476252,
-0.0030537331,
0.0083348183,
-0.0126225138,
0.0268037692,
-0.0022313932,
-0.056369286,
-0.0257323254,
-0.0015641204,
0.0325106867,
-0.0365788825,
0.039119795,
0.0236444864,
-0.0496368147,
-0.0255384333,
0.0091346875,
-0.074375473,
0.0024448712,
0.0105281919,
0.0436048433,
0.0881209895,
0.045540832,
0.0347983092,
0.0613509864,
-0.028927397,
-0.0121080149,
-0.0179008823,
0.0170895346,
0.002342545,
-0.0474268943,
-0.0262412466,
0.0060456777,
-0.0247754343,
0.025617145,
0.004173948,
-0.0286720507,
0.0464649759,
0.0140895825,
-0.0265622754,
-0.0901964158,
0.0077097556,
0.003662819,
-0.0386513248,
-0.0073846914,
-0.0104100835,
0.0246801842,
0.0472158939,
-0.037576776,
0.0233199261,
0.0167512801,
0.0041389796,
-0.046206858,
0.0425706767,
0.027615197,
0.0144023001,
-0.0214189179,
-0.0723745376,
0.0192779507,
0.028270172,
0.0309941377,
-0.0028045503,
0.0331697278,
-0.0272062439,
0.0367193781,
0.0028859545,
0.0300169494,
-0.0243327264,
-0.0154896127,
-0.0396966152,
0.0231463779,
0.0230541006,
0.0340374708,
-0.0543498285,
-0.0661070198,
0.0030318242,
0.0385638438,
-0.060674686,
0.0091099404,
0.024233954,
0.0114347721,
0.0351648405,
-0.0345501006,
-0.008888145,
-0.0410547815,
-0.1131393537,
-0.0617309026,
-0.000322862,
0.0022287576,
0.0117711062,
-0.0512719415,
-0.0098867444,
0.027855048,
-0.0099527203,
-0.0216964893,
-0.0260400493,
0.0112208193,
-0.0006842797,
0.0147806667,
-0.0004610644,
-0.0600096695,
-0.0368168615,
0.0012475154,
0.0714926645,
0.0787750706,
0.0086728213,
-0.0144673418,
0.025224356,
-0.0339785963,
-0.0482067727,
-0.0111046694,
-0.0282820165,
-0.0244819745,
0.0195106007,
0.002578214,
0.0150963105,
0.0258827712,
0.0219082367,
0.0448580049,
-0.0171187688,
-0.0015898031,
-0.0303063765,
-0.0263524652,
-0.0044538099,
0.0087104226,
-0.05239195,
0.0707212314,
0.0232516415,
0.0225711036,
-0.0123480214,
0.0080114072,
0.0435398892,
-0.0347136892,
0.0009401921,
-0.0257854536,
-0.0449602343,
0.0197026785,
0.0258763302,
0.0046260608,
-0.0125702797,
0.0250037089,
-0.0335866883,
0.0196709018,
-0.0629366487,
0.0109086633,
-0.0441378765,
0.0141140977,
-0.0131255426,
0.026280703,
-0.0139935734,
0.0104092099,
-0.0086374665,
-0.0212754402,
0.0586583018,
-0.0234836433,
0.0163341016,
0.0060702842,
-0.0192373041,
0.0470414422,
-0.0164688099,
0.0136968456,
-0.0493783429,
-0.0297830589,
-0.0481731892,
0.0728748217,
-0.0263759997,
0.0085434848,
0.0167274624,
0.0152102532,
-0.0311631076,
-0.015081251,
-0.0347681716,
0.0455850661,
0.0515757762,
0.091608353,
-0.0446656235,
-0.001212444,
-0.0357835405,
-0.0182900336,
0.0265329834,
-0.0497931354,
0.0094223637,
-0.029324526,
-0.0315159447,
0.0002371246,
-0.0331021361,
-0.0322759338,
0.0014255276,
-0.0108753387,
-0.04112041,
0.0443739556,
0.0875540897,
0.0405747034,
-0.0432478562,
-0.0233909078,
0.0082474183,
-0.0256609879,
0.0035511809,
0.0144702923,
0.0021662039,
0.0053589926,
-0.0213990919,
0.0161901675,
-0.0108619137,
0.0235090684,
0.0038438344,
-0.0688379779,
0.032238774,
-0.0014741647,
0.0196558777,
0.0035687592,
0.0137529382,
-0.0219828319,
0.0006654346,
-0.0530666262,
-0.0291385353,
-0.0466848873,
0.0399342775,
-0.0215812549,
-0.0233938843,
-0.0220853444,
0.0083692754,
-0.0148365423,
0.019840017,
0.0833583176,
0.058615271,
-0.0406084023,
-0.0377705917,
0.020943854,
0.0192301217,
0.0104238987,
-0.0103711821,
0.0641668737,
-0.0125746867,
0.0304991174,
-0.0602467693,
0.0016043484,
-0.0224953238,
0.0074638575,
0.0077716974,
0.0239984971,
0.0273508877,
-0.0636907443,
-0.0668391734,
0.05046653,
0.0081269909,
0.0763293058,
0.0241530705,
-0.0559851229,
-0.0315728039,
-0.0082856286,
0.0214143191,
-0.0288998857,
-0.0865041763,
-0.0541143455,
-0.0198039189,
-0.0489983037,
-0.1105535701,
-0.0007815583,
-0.0074625998,
0.0426077917,
0.0637910441,
0.0407244898,
0.0226300657,
-0.006561934,
-0.0431223102,
-0.0051014917,
0.0452748723,
-0.0259693973,
-0.0472959839,
-0.0295224525,
0.0721354932,
-0.0246316623,
-0.0221720804,
-0.0186489988,
-0.0196815692,
-0.0010689108,
-0.006461415,
0.0204608776,
0.0193252526,
-0.0501792282,
-0.0040462678,
-0.0592656024,
0.0380123407,
0.0191917736,
-0.0127683543,
0.0106001087,
-0.0106162485,
0.0457262099,
-0.0029276619,
-0.023550082,
-0.0316569321,
0.0353468433,
0.0190233421,
-0.0489863046,
-0.0036163758,
-0.0370926149,
-0.0267393682,
-0.0017908193,
-0.0088582812,
-0.0133404071,
0.05216977,
-0.0276431423,
-0.0287203323,
-0.0086893961,
0.0026066515,
-0.050364621,
0.017879758,
0.0232317429,
0.0196807757,
-0.0868843049,
0.0270246547,
0.007428458,
0.0468060598,
-0.0619243346,
0.051152911,
0.01107301,
-0.0225427151,
-0.0135107394,
0.0016601167,
-0.0304209795,
0.0093498956,
0.0058573014,
0.0160267558,
0.0290968884,
0.0441512018,
-0.000399444,
-0.0112085417,
-0.0090555986,
0.061653465,
-0.0296615232,
0.0038815869,
-0.0348224044,
-0.0127785942,
0.0225801244,
-0.0470718667,
0.0297271013,
-0.0367237218,
-0.0054058502,
-0.0094401408,
0.0307708662,
-0.0011648375,
0.0044687088,
-0.016422119,
0.0155742811,
0.000265623,
0.0059580305,
0.0704691634,
-0.0484799482,
-0.0678892806,
0.0308990702,
-0.0879160166,
-0.0216515865,
0.0411808752,
0.0015633152,
0.0204641763,
0.0426230393,
0.0099302195,
-0.0874050483,
-0.0308793001,
0.0569968484,
-0.0134034576,
0.032988105,
-0.0269238017,
0.0267435815,
0.0886511654,
-0.0043325862,
0.0321912952,
-0.0669510663,
-0.0147503428,
-0.0644395873,
0.0039776769,
-0.0175036341,
-5.267826588e-33,
0.0028359764,
-0.0515161417,
-0.061954543,
0.0477995053,
-0.0161740966,
-0.0057359268,
-0.0222578216,
0.0217826981,
0.0421463437,
0.0452368669,
-0.0149797751,
-0.0101584708,
-0.0084244553,
-0.0066880556,
0.0340665467,
-0.0211817063,
0.0632176027,
0.0072982865,
-0.0210511163,
0.0141093461,
0.0242499914,
0.0044520441,
0.0072810915,
-0.0959857181,
0.0272892602,
-0.0300315227,
-0.00976713,
-0.0692046508,
0.0559170507,
0.0552107804,
-0.0092565911,
0.0198162291,
0.0227224715,
-0.0271708462,
0.0189490449,
0.0192073323,
-0.0326464288,
0.0068461485,
0.0336447507,
-0.0103733363,
0.0247058272,
-0.0044635064,
0.0799338892,
-0.0073579112,
-0.0372378528,
0.0327327773,
0.0809045583,
-0.0173278283,
0.0100594889,
-0.0881658196,
-0.0663583353,
0.0057462649,
-0.0016211892,
0.009141787,
0.0119806528,
0.0306309797,
-0.0111943549,
0.0426008552,
-0.0740560442,
0.0269246958,
-0.0079649948,
0.0307705551,
0.0349492319,
-0.0362231061,
0.0067311064,
0.0891019627,
-0.0125090526,
0.0307070669,
-0.0338119306,
0.0332095139,
0.0168739539,
0.0092522977,
0.0390529111,
0.0874747112,
0.0515387319,
-0.0434770733,
0.0068485774,
0.0620519742,
0.0090440148,
-0.0411143266,
0.092667833,
-0.02694517,
-0.08230488,
-0.0279784296,
0.0223576855,
0.0022236763,
-0.041102089,
-0.0613497198,
-0.0099433446,
-0.0193358641,
-0.0381062739,
-0.0201880801,
-0.0265706964,
-0.0311152823,
-0.0534426495,
0.0165046565,
-0.0521712638,
0.0848791227,
-0.0136469798,
-0.0360156223,
-0.0057080328,
0.0464534722,
-0.0403292701,
0.0320578739,
0.016463181,
-0.0181626901,
0.0275993664,
0.0282298457,
-0.0866977349,
-0.0222886261,
0.0375022367,
-0.006057628,
0.0241964515,
0.029651206,
-0.0104643665,
-0.0028093725,
-0.0161204338,
-0.0145802014,
-0.0139039224,
0.0302943252,
0.0016639631,
-0.0252717715,
-0.0326237157,
-0.0077033537,
-0.0104293991,
-0.0352722704,
0.0164395366,
-0.0241654683,
0.0206699353,
-0.0500145406,
-0.0261408444,
-0.0410483666,
2.616e-7,
0.0473081879,
0.0601840131,
-0.0299832672,
-0.034844134,
0.0537581965,
0.0539971404,
0.0181046408,
-0.0081157712,
0.0112957051,
0.0111166537,
0.0207750015,
-0.0184770469,
-0.003409686,
0.0449091904,
-0.1316010952,
0.0312938169,
-0.0562840626,
0.025677273,
-0.0300465878,
-0.0091258837,
0.0483126678,
0.0168054812,
0.015505827,
-0.0066696294,
-0.038368471,
-0.0206921063,
0.0310350154,
-0.0655491874,
-0.0126371039,
0.0118793473,
0.0575784855,
0.003957449,
-0.0216991398,
-0.0153469397,
-0.0609363057,
0.0132776042,
0.0627643019,
0.0142346919,
0.0350129157,
-0.0419726223,
0.0497907326,
0.0296730511,
0.0034379757,
-0.0294362716,
0.0373084843,
-0.0071485578,
-0.0454178751,
-0.0704723001,
-0.0142298648,
-0.032637056,
0.053636048,
-0.0300445911,
-0.0377918482,
0.0164523274,
0.0089391656,
-0.0549354628,
-0.0067675463,
-0.0441889316,
0.0283651203,
0.0452406555,
-0.0010606924,
-0.0207263976,
-0.0362938978,
-0.018367596,
0.0058174743,
-0.0271471292,
0.033053942,
2.05956781e-34,
0.0777853727,
-0.0136792399,
-0.0133143691,
-0.012485791,
0.0325222053,
0.0195427984,
-0.0041028778,
-0.0127002131,
0.0063073575,
-0.041928187,
0.0235393215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06697v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06697v1 | Trusted Source Alignment in Large Language Models | 2023-11-12T00:25:25 | 2023-11-12T00:25:25 | Vasilisa Bashlovkina, Zhaobin Kuang, Riley Matthews, Edward Clifford, Yennie Jun, William W. Cohen, Simon Baumgartner | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are trained on web-scale corpora that inevitably
include contradictory factual information from sources of varying reliability.
In this paper, we propose measuring an LLM property called trusted source
alignment (TSA): the model's propensity to align with content produced by
trusted publishers in the face of uncertainty or controversy. We present
FactCheckQA, a TSA evaluation dataset based on a corpus of fact checking
articles. We describe a simple protocol for evaluating TSA and offer a detailed
analysis of design considerations including response extraction, claim
contextualization, and bias in prompt formulation. Applying the protocol to
PaLM-2, we find that as we scale up the model size, the model performance on
FactCheckQA improves from near-random to up to 80% balanced accuracy in
aligning with trusted sources. | [
0.0465133265,
0.0438669994,
0.0185510386,
0.0380827002,
-0.0699622706,
-0.0177629422,
0.0044137947,
-0.0419627428,
0.0018866296,
-0.0610142797,
-0.0155654307,
-0.0154729662,
0.014151386,
0.0474118516,
-0.027432818,
0.0278467666,
0.0700084791,
0.0269426629,
0.0632235706,
-0.0079387799,
0.0288098864,
0.0372356623,
-0.0293414425,
0.0157985669,
-0.0245237108,
-0.0389375649,
0.0191264339,
-0.0138908634,
0.0506846309,
-0.0236630868,
0.0136873778,
0.0415435545,
-0.0016346333,
0.0941636115,
0.0000014397,
-0.0604924932,
-0.0189724378,
0.0263624229,
-0.0565886535,
0.0196175966,
0.0046516163,
-0.0051536653,
-0.0087150382,
0.0119658811,
-0.02275417,
0.0021231037,
0.0334583744,
0.0516771078,
0.0644843504,
0.0725524873,
0.0183148645,
0.0201887712,
0.0210628323,
-0.0054299873,
-0.0671446919,
-0.0348677225,
0.0402007513,
0.0025174718,
-0.0476424433,
0.0530665442,
0.012189352,
0.009040066,
0.0170407463,
-0.0146237276,
0.0095502799,
-0.0003483225,
-0.0679687485,
-0.0264151972,
-0.0005313469,
0.0442325138,
0.0586659797,
-0.051162906,
-0.0034186915,
-0.0076275961,
-0.0095102377,
0.0650422797,
0.012010674,
0.0279245619,
-0.0306201875,
0.0016858585,
0.0073112473,
-0.0201271493,
0.0287672617,
0.0247807242,
0.0149177248,
0.0788543522,
0.0115201985,
-0.0402585901,
0.0169251859,
0.026853241,
0.0376018174,
-0.0662491545,
0.01028674,
-0.0040925932,
-0.0199554712,
0.035896413,
-0.0358461179,
0.0349545963,
0.0636017174,
-0.0611493662,
-0.0207090713,
-0.000625073,
-0.0683891699,
0.0660275146,
0.0099231368,
0.0056637344,
-0.0242255609,
0.0016547162,
0.01512763,
-0.0113862865,
-0.0063150674,
0.040090926,
0.025296567,
-0.0066611851,
-0.0158180203,
-0.001044224,
-0.041154664,
0.0071647284,
-0.0116104316,
0.0569954887,
0.0308810249,
-0.0076488801,
-0.0143824322,
-0.0164683498,
-0.0415398553,
0.0801805705,
0.0108021088,
0.0441023894,
-0.0106430752,
-0.0616874881,
-0.0213353019,
-0.0091147041,
-0.0315089747,
-0.0317248926,
-0.0221567489,
0.0166985057,
0.0068907016,
-0.0016955978,
-0.0297839791,
-0.0089313313,
-0.0328814983,
-0.0669695437,
-0.0181753375,
-0.060593456,
0.0283728354,
-0.0174603127,
-0.0129535533,
-0.0273140147,
0.0010589174,
0.0357053354,
-0.0357261337,
0.0284945946,
-0.0226735771,
-0.0029974335,
0.0496674329,
-0.0195941664,
-0.012819076,
0.0569908433,
0.0244333241,
-0.0052403356,
0.0627789572,
0.0277324934,
-0.0290769842,
-0.004990919,
0.0456977934,
0.0200509131,
0.0370495208,
0.0296889767,
0.0022337092,
0.0070257708,
0.0010815779,
0.0610081777,
-0.0097182132,
-0.0484398827,
0.084077999,
-0.0023097263,
-0.0251350142,
-0.0345301032,
0.0218811855,
-0.0033057181,
0.0216554236,
0.023879135,
-0.0605276003,
0.0124476422,
-0.0446336791,
0.0144706275,
0.0156790372,
0.0820074528,
0.0092851743,
-0.0229744501,
-0.0380403511,
0.0042822878,
-0.0288211014,
0.0158678796,
0.0057205763,
-0.0295561925,
-0.0179866701,
0.0299655516,
0.0420264751,
-0.0225105416,
-0.0087415874,
-0.0128319561,
0.0548854358,
0.0160002559,
0.0241697412,
0.0071994648,
-0.0156626608,
-0.0436798185,
0.0084411679,
0.0497331768,
0.0445867702,
-0.0256056916,
0.0023711312,
-0.0184291042,
-0.0389434732,
-0.0028326188,
0.0221731868,
0.0060872952,
0.0475992076,
0.0248454195,
0.0025697476,
-0.0164148938,
-0.0379219092,
0.0305268839,
0.0024838566,
0.0079307677,
-0.0134367896,
0.0156964287,
0.0517909639,
0.025014475,
-0.0243958142,
-0.0204349607,
0.0351846144,
0.0277118925,
-0.0050343014,
0.005597529,
0.0049045472,
-0.0096189128,
0.0713582337,
-0.0248973742,
-0.0572860949,
0.0416950472,
-0.0297059454,
-0.0218821224,
-0.025054086,
-0.0008154979,
-0.0191105492,
-0.0202012043,
0.0098722884,
-0.0057851193,
-0.0026433957,
-0.0206393097,
0.0480140038,
-0.0180885587,
0.0154541675,
-0.023744924,
-0.0081362091,
0.0355881043,
-0.0168353692,
-0.0027407964,
0.0232690237,
0.0045708003,
0.0189928319,
0.0624871626,
-0.0297903102,
-0.0245464277,
-0.0252855401,
-0.0348683745,
0.024698291,
-0.0028304067,
0.0282881297,
0.0383290909,
-0.0357394181,
0.0097960606,
0.0060564699,
-0.0429507829,
-0.0346584693,
0.0075696944,
0.0164888632,
0.0470999554,
-0.0145103671,
0.0023813997,
-0.0541780889,
0.0092413081,
-0.0270162504,
0.0396101847,
0.0464655645,
0.0109892879,
-0.0627608448,
-0.0025081502,
-0.0676644668,
0.0191502515,
0.0027187048,
-0.0127801942,
0.0293890908,
0.0624871068,
-0.0419036001,
0.0755929947,
0.0376531966,
0.0057841968,
0.0492970161,
0.0285428446,
-0.049572818,
-0.0158286244,
-0.0081028659,
-0.0325861461,
-0.0224941429,
-0.0413928144,
0.0262217652,
0.0536747873,
0.0196223091,
-0.0185706764,
-0.0052456805,
-0.0117413476,
-0.0085256966,
-0.0003888371,
0.0463664755,
-0.0571831204,
-0.0338762812,
0.0614830516,
-0.0320518874,
-0.0278768372,
0.092555806,
-0.0620489344,
0.0565025918,
-0.0738458708,
0.0044118026,
-0.0007742231,
0.0097483434,
-0.0339095183,
0.0276857857,
0.0159380008,
0.0079082074,
-0.0416184589,
-0.0330945142,
0.078296341,
-0.0316130519,
0.0087191928,
-0.0386449955,
0.0275546908,
0.003234193,
-0.0434309617,
-0.0521206185,
-0.0649015009,
-0.0277870428,
-0.0076345545,
-0.0126966266,
-0.0278944373,
-0.0706300735,
-0.0338395499,
0.054810375,
0.0307362247,
0.0002600634,
0.0104682334,
0.0031064232,
0.0253227092,
0.062906459,
0.0147331543,
0.0735586733,
0.012209042,
-0.0210680477,
0.0846307352,
-0.0215579644,
0.0063062273,
-0.0342992507,
-0.0720945969,
0.0139119485,
-0.0403821208,
0.0142082572,
-0.0233561769,
0.0315213688,
-0.0251684114,
0.0226744302,
0.0939723477,
0.0353380293,
-0.0011957416,
-0.029836392,
0.0024954695,
0.0001007172,
0.0337459631,
0.0005914699,
-0.0987550244,
0.0223191548,
-0.0042521241,
0.0096383132,
-0.0130205452,
-0.0109506203,
-0.0176437255,
-0.1059545949,
0.0183923133,
-0.0133567788,
0.0103355208,
-0.0367336683,
-0.0608590357,
0.0378609113,
-0.0116208252,
0.0299914144,
0.0332277752,
0.0328274295,
-0.0086487141,
0.0133952303,
0.0027627451,
-0.0640523285,
0.0376826562,
-0.036764361,
0.053770829,
0.0303222686,
0.0194833968,
-0.0144267371,
-0.0513106808,
-0.0118115144,
-0.0181954745,
-0.0695251971,
0.0078557087,
0.0369758643,
-0.0475986451,
0.0103328777,
-0.0211035535,
0.0365501903,
0.0290303882,
0.0138801029,
0.0119318021,
0.0367129333,
0.0182420518,
0.0235055778,
-0.0246805269,
0.0074282223,
0.0133759622,
0.0798216835,
-0.0077496879,
0.0029457086,
0.0061891521,
-0.0097921295,
-0.0394237153,
0.01764993,
-0.0071414392,
0.0609572791,
-0.0232326575,
-0.0282384288,
-0.1072890311,
-0.0110985842,
-0.0380213894,
0.0391877294,
0.0076387837,
-0.0149987163,
0.0672519729,
-0.0082227532,
-0.0138846487,
0.0247534644,
-0.0297904667,
0.0244308859,
-0.0172718298,
0.0503546298,
0.0172848068,
-0.0158698391,
-0.0147086978,
0.0445376933,
-0.0528306179,
-0.0882704109,
-0.0146717308,
-0.0062495931,
0.0237312112,
0.0615626313,
-0.051188726,
-0.0023760521,
-0.0052854605,
-0.0031928802,
-0.0823868364,
0.0211284608,
0.0110597033,
-0.003238088,
0.0015785894,
-0.0048511932,
-0.038631469,
-0.0037410527,
-0.0018124534,
-0.006381257,
-0.0510575548,
-0.0665007979,
0.05168714,
0.0222219825,
0.0788728893,
0.0023374388,
0.0516432971,
-0.0464959778,
0.0273441337,
-0.0275270101,
-0.0407645889,
0.0156494267,
0.0230131876,
0.0088345176,
-0.041210901,
-0.0097257923,
-0.0110493638,
-0.0359693058,
0.0805787966,
-0.0172991659,
-0.0189379342,
0.0025302516,
0.0148660736,
-0.0159760881,
-0.0147608407,
-0.0539119504,
-0.0102071948,
-0.0045493688,
0.0312784351,
0.0141258566,
0.047686439,
0.0310850404,
-0.0116476715,
0.0521160066,
-0.0370174609,
-0.0997161046,
0.0085601602,
-0.0144245923,
-0.0116568292,
0.0114887273,
-0.0188168027,
0.0487424918,
-0.0083102677,
-0.0403999016,
-0.0207069591,
0.0107789636,
-0.0137593988,
0.0086416677,
0.060868904,
-0.0028799535,
-0.0406346768,
0.0574461631,
0.0359359533,
-0.0036584856,
0.0360311307,
-0.0214582719,
-0.0520708151,
-0.0377919935,
-0.0565539338,
-0.0318612903,
0.0119108148,
-0.0255423002,
-0.0329802446,
-0.0737413168,
-0.0461962223,
0.0476773642,
0.0374000855,
0.0220361259,
-0.0091173314,
-0.0041369898,
0.0978759602,
-0.0077053574,
0.0203603189,
-0.0412510075,
-0.0098722028,
0.0173377767,
-0.0121005829,
-0.0331809036,
-5.755682458e-33,
-0.0139668342,
-0.0145951323,
-0.0134323146,
-0.0256794859,
-0.012972258,
0.0327397808,
-0.0161870085,
-0.0071482253,
-0.0801341608,
0.0527155064,
0.0073461132,
0.0325076543,
0.0120832492,
-0.0032710934,
-0.0086709829,
-0.0056218496,
0.0416932143,
-0.0088029373,
-0.0401578434,
-0.0136623373,
0.0503419563,
-0.0249079503,
0.0533650294,
-0.101674661,
0.0842219219,
-0.0222305898,
-0.0341429226,
0.0001300035,
-0.0232032966,
0.0762116164,
-0.0131994663,
0.0068426514,
0.0082755564,
-0.0300614703,
0.0434085205,
-0.0112523725,
-0.0480896905,
0.002547225,
0.0814340562,
0.0131955026,
-0.0008950831,
0.022526443,
0.0167768672,
-0.0181609336,
-0.0198836774,
-0.0247903429,
0.026504349,
-0.0499700978,
-0.0282402486,
-0.052078113,
-0.0422701202,
0.035986647,
-0.0028353729,
-0.0055830618,
-0.04899434,
0.0445833281,
0.025233753,
0.0257212911,
-0.0529015996,
-0.0052476535,
-0.0172411427,
0.0111734355,
0.0412803702,
-0.0393392555,
-0.0338959098,
0.0617624894,
-0.0667781457,
-0.0404489264,
-0.0170088504,
-0.0016868706,
-0.0053380635,
0.011943955,
0.0378053933,
0.1379194856,
-0.0286631919,
-0.0021273999,
-0.1106796116,
0.0180944614,
0.0223004967,
0.0200469662,
0.0190825947,
-0.0207797159,
-0.0272254087,
0.0329656154,
-0.0382960364,
-0.0074979798,
-0.0302695855,
-0.0003615761,
-0.0112590967,
0.0132396594,
-0.0122537194,
0.0327028073,
0.0141031025,
-0.047722131,
-0.0092624379,
0.0501417518,
-0.0484142266,
-0.0046809954,
0.0039867493,
0.0345726945,
-0.0738746226,
0.0437062047,
-0.0135974539,
0.0451458395,
-0.0205796603,
0.0172758028,
0.0664833635,
-0.0366869047,
-0.0711802021,
0.0401303396,
-0.025603937,
0.0169306044,
-0.0164813027,
0.0138551658,
0.0551400185,
-0.0089244759,
-0.0163095258,
0.0294158179,
-0.0196022503,
-0.0019327368,
-0.0213240776,
0.0086975479,
-0.0198335443,
0.0361051485,
-0.0244646501,
-0.0048045879,
0.0131915314,
0.0484582894,
-0.0112893367,
-0.0385481492,
0.0323412642,
0.0094996653,
2.294e-7,
0.0202080198,
0.0297820475,
0.0086098267,
-0.0324137099,
0.0046197549,
0.0231883209,
0.0064865085,
0.0394206829,
-0.0062133712,
-0.1053173766,
-0.0383832902,
0.0030338056,
0.0403334163,
0.0492556021,
-0.0550453737,
-0.0200640615,
-0.0974365696,
0.0013250023,
-0.0307795759,
0.0016585889,
-0.0048352447,
0.0810964331,
0.0234241504,
-0.0038346774,
-0.0020166012,
0.0011120195,
0.0580490455,
0.0278869383,
-0.0463283062,
0.0098357359,
0.0733676106,
-0.013475311,
-0.0072805663,
0.0078407982,
-0.0106727956,
0.0340512879,
-0.0311501194,
0.0742913261,
0.0215170961,
0.0149115715,
-0.0297372732,
-0.0385115072,
0.0065786885,
-0.0747845471,
0.0228191875,
0.0023908296,
-0.0259480663,
-0.0813463703,
-0.0600397252,
-0.0185281709,
0.0381479263,
-0.012390526,
0.0110312151,
0.036678303,
-0.0363425761,
0.0027056308,
-0.011056155,
-0.0306237005,
-0.0330275297,
-0.0066764471,
-0.0096739633,
-0.0751252696,
0.0636945888,
-0.0304445028,
0.0314988121,
-0.0596979596,
0.0386612937,
1.775390788e-34,
0.0510769337,
-0.0332184583,
0.0001535445,
-0.0077826688,
0.0561959408,
0.0082605882,
-0.0088816443,
-0.0125200348,
0.013743341,
-0.0101651819,
0.016511539
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.