id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08590v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08590v3 | PEMA: An Offsite-Tunable Plug-in External Memory Adaptation for Language Models | 2023-11-14T23:20:51 | 2024-03-29T11:24:46 | HyunJin Kim, Young Jin Kim, JinYeong Bak | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained language models (PLMs) show impressive performance in various
downstream NLP tasks. However, pre-training large language models demands
substantial memory and training compute. Furthermore, due to the substantial
resources required, many PLM weights are confidential. Consequently, users are
compelled to share their data with model owners for fine-tuning specific tasks.
To overcome the limitations, we introduce Plug-in External Memory Adaptation
(PEMA), a Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) method, enabling PLM
fine-tuning without requiring access to all the weights. PEMA integrates with
context representations from test data during inference to perform downstream
tasks. It uses external memory to store PLM-generated context representations
mapped with target tokens. Our method utilizes weight matrices of LoRA-like
bottlenecked adapter in the PLM's final layer to enhance efficiency. Our
approach also includes Gradual Unrolling, a novel interpolation strategy to
improve generation quality. We validate PEMA's effectiveness through
experiments on syntactic and real datasets for machine translation and style
transfer. Our findings show that PEMA outperforms other PEFT approaches in
memory and latency efficiency for training, and also excels in maintaining
sentence meaning and generating appropriate language and styles. | [
0.0383161716,
0.0662075877,
-0.0287676584,
0.0388555378,
0.0074810134,
0.0095872246,
-0.0009596503,
-0.0251376629,
-0.0121043995,
-0.0320876911,
-0.0771423727,
-0.021311868,
-0.0143478587,
0.0198053606,
0.039877411,
-0.0495458096,
0.0319493636,
-0.033618357,
-0.0057689445,
0.0069163423,
0.022017872,
0.02589049,
0.0275259353,
0.0040839701,
0.0239208657,
-0.0078661675,
-0.0167666897,
0.0512599982,
0.0280459821,
0.0017570016,
0.0269945636,
0.0463269465,
0.0037736404,
-0.0230780654,
0.0000023331,
-0.044310879,
-0.0396587327,
-0.036018189,
0.0097674895,
0.0280575603,
0.0656535551,
-0.0167178102,
-0.0091860509,
0.0345827825,
-0.0259023663,
-0.0425977446,
0.0602914728,
0.028207574,
0.057975132,
0.0941566974,
-0.0283239502,
-0.0123057766,
0.0023201308,
-0.051492434,
-0.0143775567,
-0.0322584249,
0.0109226778,
-0.0352800786,
-0.0537202656,
-0.0149594992,
-0.0136561254,
0.0187629722,
0.0116485767,
-0.0014664918,
0.0128007559,
0.0029859431,
-0.0544740148,
-0.0107934019,
-0.031021256,
0.0888375863,
-0.0337575674,
-0.0562269501,
-0.0017968339,
-0.0306591745,
-0.0157861374,
-0.016141085,
-0.0247476138,
0.0152734993,
0.0282772612,
0.0399249941,
0.0355221443,
-0.0008932578,
0.0179881994,
0.0078087207,
-0.0454883389,
-0.0026768777,
0.0462964661,
0.0149922045,
-0.0089407032,
0.0028782887,
-0.0313626081,
-0.0456070602,
0.0317655951,
0.0153174633,
0.0107473861,
0.0343040191,
-0.1059075594,
-0.0450666733,
0.0273124203,
-0.0349433683,
0.0999467075,
0.0686328337,
-0.0050476207,
0.0172060076,
-0.0724328905,
0.0207196306,
-0.0344498381,
0.0412310585,
-0.0477016903,
-0.0088568078,
-0.0274817534,
0.0137937721,
-0.0659487396,
0.0169703085,
-0.0524510741,
-0.0241163541,
-0.0134651726,
0.0459105596,
-0.0019323508,
-0.0328919888,
0.0104422141,
-0.0102940081,
-0.0532989576,
-0.01973157,
-0.0172268916,
0.04587036,
-0.0086163506,
0.0169981606,
-0.0053289756,
-0.0645468086,
-0.0442244597,
0.014894492,
0.0292440578,
-0.019419603,
0.0210824423,
0.071109958,
-0.0139331557,
-0.0540994853,
-0.0465252101,
-0.0055553881,
0.0163390897,
-0.0748316273,
0.0000602835,
-0.0527613238,
0.0276593119,
0.0053548934,
0.0126703978,
-0.0380412005,
0.0002776724,
0.0406385362,
-0.0284721851,
0.0482603535,
0.0033361176,
-0.0113298791,
-0.0068420824,
0.0010760707,
0.0205322932,
0.0822065845,
0.0348950177,
0.0223238319,
0.0094433678,
-0.0112264846,
-0.040276926,
0.0603268109,
0.0571718328,
0.0223053861,
-0.0724853128,
0.0263312515,
0.0566938259,
0.0047885203,
0.0660246462,
0.0414956287,
-0.0078187864,
0.0326780118,
0.0647409409,
-0.0068361056,
0.0328206085,
-0.0009824289,
0.0234934837,
-0.0136883827,
-0.0083004702,
-0.0186352525,
-0.0407485478,
0.0339489244,
-0.0148801738,
0.0123378132,
0.0545917191,
0.0743043721,
-0.0157367904,
-0.0017637115,
-0.0009234102,
-0.01297676,
0.0128625426,
0.0003347301,
0.0052484516,
0.063133806,
-0.0443182923,
0.1045510098,
0.0449702889,
-0.0332727134,
-0.0095667141,
-0.0330264755,
-0.0105382083,
0.1049959511,
0.0115574058,
0.0001254518,
-0.0268119108,
0.0066658421,
0.0397140905,
0.0426879227,
0.022590179,
0.0206894558,
0.0359305628,
-0.0640467405,
0.0186795369,
-0.0234908219,
0.0103388941,
0.0341608264,
0.0288072731,
0.0327289551,
0.0407667831,
-0.0177125689,
-0.029765835,
0.0442429334,
-0.0533068553,
-0.0278440434,
0.045779027,
-0.0086078169,
0.0109266099,
-0.0160500724,
-0.0158163253,
-0.0088489829,
0.0258669127,
-0.0406280272,
0.0374303199,
0.0046251584,
-0.0854110196,
-0.0293828994,
0.015227085,
-0.0069424217,
0.044355426,
-0.0129581839,
-0.0395316966,
-0.0739669651,
0.0312106721,
-0.007454955,
0.0724127516,
-0.0415948927,
0.0313419513,
0.0011279534,
0.0665139854,
-0.0069471542,
0.0193389151,
0.0021175493,
-0.0203056149,
0.0281950869,
0.0723831952,
-0.00259003,
-0.0133927707,
-0.0058801291,
0.008926766,
0.0278873742,
0.002186147,
-0.01613844,
0.0411637686,
-0.0559284613,
-0.0402318984,
-0.0799961239,
0.0404628068,
-0.0227233097,
0.0144960005,
0.0650418475,
0.0369725488,
-0.0194931701,
-0.0231805984,
-0.0235232748,
0.0509924851,
-0.0148324585,
0.024593167,
0.0034202866,
0.009775403,
-0.0055152238,
-0.0409671739,
0.0006848546,
0.0204786025,
0.0492772646,
-0.0305524413,
-0.0061937487,
-0.0442641154,
0.006836033,
-0.0114048114,
0.0230930783,
-0.000026655,
-0.0404498465,
-0.0268544275,
-0.0334135592,
0.0747641549,
0.0389688946,
0.0008529148,
-0.010932737,
0.0453397855,
-0.0171192139,
-0.0413524285,
0.0040387032,
-0.0074666571,
-0.0260054264,
-0.0311262645,
0.0076250043,
0.0072043724,
0.045890484,
-0.0032041247,
-0.0116129918,
-0.0483073555,
0.0266652033,
-0.0028506266,
-0.0187308975,
0.0436283946,
-0.0013158685,
-0.0192442182,
0.0099800956,
-0.0289595369,
-0.0620261654,
0.0519680567,
-0.062808603,
-0.0014224967,
-0.0320691876,
-0.0345469676,
-0.0551254079,
0.0489473119,
0.0164657589,
0.0199945178,
-0.0133096958,
-0.0107112043,
-0.017766729,
0.0185569841,
0.0047030114,
-0.0226538498,
0.0327267535,
-0.0457177572,
0.008551253,
-0.0161089357,
-0.020971274,
-0.0193379112,
-0.0580778047,
0.0027608224,
-0.0049749273,
0.0211998858,
-0.0059459088,
0.0072874548,
0.0048266617,
-0.0136081632,
0.0818812326,
-0.037077859,
0.0027537802,
-0.025860263,
-0.0150596686,
0.0633090734,
0.0321006402,
-0.0015684405,
-0.023066083,
-0.0037030277,
0.0053271651,
0.0097290818,
-0.0372916982,
-0.0196038634,
0.0333283357,
0.0372140296,
-0.0075939451,
-0.0191303175,
0.0125708403,
0.0723523572,
-0.0694054887,
-0.0445710644,
0.1015693247,
0.0131022688,
-0.0864635035,
-0.0103574125,
0.0021295145,
0.0364595018,
0.0183534138,
0.0509851575,
-0.0709783733,
-0.0485701337,
0.0033239501,
0.0182692204,
-0.0109206811,
-0.008946795,
-0.0393661335,
-0.1256061047,
-0.0081905108,
0.0210166406,
-0.0630250722,
0.007611522,
-0.0344440266,
-0.0151384268,
0.0190277081,
0.0382180065,
-0.0191112626,
-0.0233988781,
-0.0000189496,
0.0018534447,
0.0210933052,
-0.0588823073,
-0.0058519929,
-0.0197606999,
0.0481772274,
0.0469738171,
-0.0228010379,
0.0120552052,
-0.0336755849,
0.056102749,
-0.0622921214,
0.0091547323,
-0.043659538,
0.0038092951,
0.0007222652,
-0.0200969987,
0.0193490237,
0.0220653936,
-0.0286045428,
-0.0114235962,
0.0016822729,
0.0388639197,
0.011306365,
0.0048224838,
0.0053045233,
-0.0262097903,
0.0136028379,
0.0517423414,
0.0451432802,
-0.0567639358,
0.0032899491,
-0.0181297436,
-0.0445156395,
-0.0440512374,
0.0141909076,
0.0068064225,
-0.0177497696,
-0.0055456492,
-0.0488776639,
-0.0096652275,
0.0366310701,
0.0726344362,
0.0173714384,
-0.0065395017,
-0.0337830633,
-0.0016245684,
-0.0679903403,
0.0252681095,
-0.0431540832,
-0.0277577844,
-0.0141715817,
-0.0418740734,
0.0469383635,
-0.0291460026,
0.0114613799,
0.0286363289,
-0.0652283356,
-0.0725910589,
0.0151048228,
0.0887599885,
0.0150990104,
0.0489801206,
0.0020503355,
-0.0682922378,
0.0435328484,
0.0499434881,
-0.0595403202,
0.0378280655,
0.0113716945,
-0.0107747838,
0.0243947972,
0.0404813699,
-0.0463562161,
0.0285351556,
0.051071316,
0.0491163023,
0.0430522412,
-0.0520865098,
0.00676656,
0.0043899356,
0.0072112381,
-0.004628635,
-0.0338769592,
-0.0366288126,
0.0581615195,
-0.0482247211,
0.0030112353,
-0.043927379,
-0.0169518273,
0.019969685,
0.0198715366,
-0.0236625299,
-0.0262652505,
0.0149571076,
0.0001298215,
-0.0023292741,
-0.0027165092,
0.0036407223,
0.0060781995,
0.011698029,
0.0299506113,
-0.0328908414,
-0.0134132477,
0.0041046035,
0.0239953417,
-0.0632658526,
0.0208898485,
0.0173050482,
0.0062266043,
-0.0483454764,
0.0422637165,
-0.0304899812,
-0.01429612,
-0.0524226874,
-0.0048330887,
0.0255163629,
-0.0325586423,
0.096177429,
0.0075550503,
0.001494291,
-0.0027841555,
0.0307553485,
0.0097803008,
-0.0398897827,
-0.0013426839,
-0.0070982934,
-0.0145920906,
-0.0105118221,
0.0474809408,
0.0118804593,
0.0309900809,
-0.0094096102,
0.0338260159,
-0.0217180364,
0.0102578402,
-0.0212798975,
0.0207885075,
0.0114809182,
-0.0076882984,
-0.002619555,
-0.0668324381,
-0.0019283475,
-0.0169591513,
-0.0130871823,
-0.0079570394,
0.015466867,
0.0476466827,
0.0124791563,
-0.0072926697,
-0.0246011615,
-0.004117847,
0.0059740474,
0.0040929047,
-0.0068148864,
-7.829054659e-33,
-0.0592543483,
-0.029835267,
0.0234857984,
-0.025227204,
-0.0288020149,
0.0125281028,
-0.0627052337,
-0.0223513003,
0.0048414809,
-0.0321287178,
-0.0305514969,
0.0052693281,
0.0186862946,
0.0372028872,
0.0027006012,
0.0139645645,
0.0525197499,
0.0050205365,
-0.0174406543,
0.0488218069,
0.0382152386,
0.0455823019,
0.0668338388,
-0.0082729189,
-0.0262645725,
0.0087533593,
-0.0050053098,
0.0052638692,
0.0258252025,
0.0303082764,
-0.0143302092,
0.0384209603,
0.0144943967,
-0.03858288,
-0.0317410156,
-0.0126912715,
-0.0962634757,
-0.0321948864,
0.0620478354,
0.011567343,
0.0073450687,
-0.0532032512,
0.0697702393,
-0.0005175236,
0.0176296104,
-0.0112502202,
0.0071137617,
-0.0263775997,
-0.0159430318,
-0.0148673365,
-0.0743074715,
0.0050803311,
0.0183554199,
0.0362231545,
0.0177476946,
-0.0144469226,
-0.0223005619,
0.018347837,
-0.0787152126,
-0.0103834281,
-0.0067619034,
0.0498805828,
0.0485087261,
0.0554054566,
0.0190058537,
0.0551293902,
0.0117565105,
0.0059157941,
0.0006058809,
0.0066204481,
0.0719306991,
0.0233607106,
0.0038263155,
0.0167958327,
0.0445048474,
-0.0356489047,
-0.0413244255,
-0.0136832297,
0.0214154758,
-0.0111904256,
0.0489797667,
0.0238964427,
0.0099536087,
-0.0150822485,
-0.0552894399,
-0.0126365311,
-0.0454561077,
-0.034661293,
0.0441137664,
0.0439823046,
-0.0250027217,
0.0001224177,
0.0248101503,
-0.0114190141,
-0.0141400415,
-0.0217168499,
-0.0259628966,
-0.0119611416,
-0.0195507575,
0.0275220405,
-0.0467620343,
-0.0666896254,
0.0324122719,
-0.02451027,
0.0153779481,
-0.0133333877,
0.0415437967,
0.0408296846,
-0.1086955816,
0.0053663463,
-0.0386805125,
0.0513338298,
0.009981364,
0.0328802653,
0.0181203801,
0.0040656324,
-0.0340011679,
0.0458270535,
0.033332672,
-0.0127258589,
-0.0099465409,
-0.0316594616,
0.0287689362,
0.0414381288,
-0.0584108569,
0.008772945,
-0.0095726959,
0.0162966717,
0.0237734057,
-0.0880785882,
-0.0223296229,
0.0123605467,
3.159e-7,
0.0247502308,
0.0477018431,
-0.0069924714,
-0.0118902745,
0.0148334596,
-0.0136215873,
0.0088610891,
0.0512373634,
0.0262469109,
0.0034276983,
-0.0118915299,
0.0485735983,
0.0357122533,
0.0116689745,
-0.0850366876,
0.0235706419,
-0.0237597469,
0.0425268374,
-0.0471218936,
-0.0054161786,
0.0206396785,
0.1067309156,
-0.0013714557,
-0.0053998278,
0.0071364432,
-0.0350672193,
0.0638033226,
-0.0415953994,
-0.0031221688,
0.0032406568,
0.0406013541,
0.0463075899,
-0.0464555137,
0.00674327,
-0.0264667515,
0.0419168361,
-0.043419119,
0.0735142827,
0.0161395278,
-0.0374863967,
0.0363049842,
0.0041955682,
-0.0063581937,
-0.0396978669,
0.0844838694,
-0.0560528636,
-0.0430337042,
-0.0433670804,
0.0008131425,
-0.0167971794,
0.0096462891,
-0.0103018489,
-0.0083961673,
0.0451264828,
0.0443066731,
0.0028281624,
-0.0571140274,
-0.1104929,
-0.0362635963,
0.0001065047,
-0.0210932363,
-0.0282195024,
-0.0730861053,
-0.0269548614,
0.0176401082,
-0.0447083674,
0.0455173589,
3.323382883e-34,
0.0376103334,
-0.0332553871,
0.0242271926,
0.0200122483,
0.0347988419,
-0.0081675034,
0.0215671454,
0.0303070843,
-0.0034003451,
-0.1343663633,
-0.0264746863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08588v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08588v3 | CodeScope: An Execution-based Multilingual Multitask Multidimensional Benchmark for Evaluating LLMs on Code Understanding and Generation | 2023-11-14T23:18:52 | 2024-06-07T04:34:16 | Weixiang Yan, Haitian Liu, Yunkun Wang, Yunzhe Li, Qian Chen, Wen Wang, Tingyu Lin, Weishan Zhao, Li Zhu, Hari Sundaram, Shuiguang Deng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance on
assisting humans in programming and facilitating programming automation.
However, existing benchmarks for evaluating the code understanding and
generation capacities of LLMs suffer from severe limitations. First, most
benchmarks are insufficient as they focus on a narrow range of popular
programming languages and specific tasks, whereas real-world software
development scenarios show a critical need to implement systems with
multilingual and multitask programming environments to satisfy diverse
requirements. Second, most benchmarks fail to consider the actual executability
and the consistency of execution results of the generated code. To bridge these
gaps between existing benchmarks and expectations from practical applications,
we introduce CodeScope, an execution-based, multilingual, multitask,
multidimensional evaluation benchmark for comprehensively measuring LLM
capabilities on coding tasks. CodeScope covers 43 programming languages and
eight coding tasks. It evaluates the coding performance of LLMs from three
dimensions (perspectives): length, difficulty, and efficiency. To facilitate
execution-based evaluations of code generation, we develop MultiCodeEngine, an
automated code execution engine that supports 14 programming languages.
Finally, we systematically evaluate and analyze eight mainstream LLMs and
demonstrate the superior breadth and challenges of CodeScope for evaluating
LLMs on code understanding and generation tasks compared to other benchmarks.
The CodeScope benchmark and code are publicly available at
https://github.com/WeixiangYAN/CodeScope. | [
-0.0286821183,
0.0495981053,
-0.0346621983,
0.0490399972,
-0.0272425879,
0.0332665332,
-0.0121121323,
-0.0010346842,
0.0058091013,
0.0063308715,
-0.0389803126,
-0.002295803,
0.0049370709,
0.0394440815,
0.0463407375,
-0.015759699,
0.0464071445,
-0.0665072575,
-0.0577130951,
0.033086542,
-0.0130581791,
0.030434547,
0.0035497027,
0.06566903,
0.0163649414,
-0.0169386119,
0.0063922871,
0.0407826044,
-0.0072943238,
-0.0129795084,
0.0116089527,
0.0202723481,
0.0125428317,
0.0162736122,
0.0000023639,
-0.0505680628,
0.012270608,
0.0099234888,
0.0156153254,
0.0362903737,
0.0124044754,
-0.0237284023,
-0.0041004955,
0.0129254637,
-0.0242737457,
-0.0065262946,
0.0464233086,
-0.0971923545,
0.0461454801,
0.0293846745,
0.0132411178,
0.001478409,
-0.0128069976,
0.0090703657,
0.0056768232,
-0.0349626057,
-0.0091492068,
0.0398886651,
0.0259391442,
-0.0257077962,
0.0127185052,
0.0175138842,
0.0351095758,
-0.0010507103,
-0.0278281774,
0.0188004542,
-0.021707207,
-0.0385614112,
-0.0156697258,
0.0196495596,
-0.0549506992,
-0.015503413,
0.026940573,
0.0045812442,
-0.0342423879,
-0.0662487671,
-0.0288118776,
0.0487806574,
-0.0004190431,
-0.0179661624,
0.0175794512,
-0.0029748164,
0.010116674,
-0.0011340872,
0.002308571,
0.055421032,
0.018846957,
0.0096045183,
-0.0268110279,
0.001224624,
0.031691201,
-0.0563076735,
0.005531915,
0.0636185631,
-0.0319835842,
0.0112913838,
-0.028971931,
-0.0455411151,
0.0381174423,
-0.0628613979,
0.0411638059,
0.0757918358,
-0.0133068021,
0.0094848685,
-0.0420173369,
0.0830092803,
-0.0112410001,
-0.0207147188,
-0.048408214,
0.001027621,
-0.0485528894,
-0.0069581675,
-0.0282964297,
0.0155740054,
-0.0184720978,
0.034118481,
-0.0631426275,
0.0617335252,
-0.0095033478,
0.0722842142,
-0.0359535366,
-0.0423067622,
-0.0253653191,
0.0160762705,
0.0449733548,
0.0058415048,
-0.0357497856,
-0.0398176871,
0.0128383031,
-0.0819577053,
0.0206587818,
0.0471751541,
-0.0508949235,
-0.0273209624,
0.0259688366,
0.1010011882,
-0.0004603211,
0.0407027416,
-0.0206611846,
-0.0428025834,
0.0098794168,
-0.0522446744,
-0.0268509835,
-0.1170508713,
0.0122874985,
0.0479143895,
-0.0132972402,
-0.0542563014,
0.0067469338,
-0.0227071736,
0.0376521386,
0.0083498508,
-0.0231439285,
0.029633807,
0.0350799635,
0.0353862084,
-0.033922527,
0.0779192001,
0.0266501419,
0.0134294406,
0.0076966868,
-0.0368289053,
0.0278220084,
0.0657176971,
-0.0352132581,
0.0145464595,
0.0033424725,
0.0325144194,
0.0474842228,
-0.0078267651,
0.0001359976,
0.0395151526,
-0.011275176,
0.0359757841,
-0.0183216128,
0.0366465859,
-0.0045499569,
0.0175699852,
0.1126196086,
0.0205194149,
0.0062304498,
-0.027429929,
-0.0187184047,
0.0635723472,
-0.0034864552,
0.0087009398,
-0.0095366817,
0.0637533069,
0.0055628126,
-0.0491998792,
-0.0145180095,
-0.0189314876,
-0.004935775,
-0.0077388487,
0.0338319801,
-0.0238164198,
-0.0404382385,
0.0654403269,
-0.015050061,
-0.1028465182,
-0.0205662884,
-0.0387304351,
-0.00169071,
0.0647693723,
0.0315078236,
-0.0294494387,
-0.0475367941,
0.00418542,
0.0132368067,
-0.0029660964,
0.0339254476,
-0.0114172557,
0.0204887222,
-0.0312170796,
-0.0101835867,
-0.027358735,
-0.0092734369,
0.082327269,
0.0284922123,
-0.0354708843,
0.0241564717,
-0.025885107,
-0.0707710832,
0.015365012,
-0.0611604229,
0.0111764586,
-0.0032463248,
-0.0006149595,
0.003909566,
-0.027579559,
-0.050060302,
0.0038640872,
0.0352829061,
-0.0279150549,
0.0150258495,
0.0059434273,
-0.0171469022,
0.0189407002,
0.0283454619,
-0.0133753289,
-0.0580456927,
0.0195267498,
-0.0096003488,
-0.0240759049,
0.0580240451,
-0.0048613767,
-0.0086446973,
0.0105901742,
0.0341732092,
-0.0614137053,
-0.0033969074,
-0.0043355376,
0.0346645862,
-0.0136324093,
0.031015614,
0.0170037653,
0.0548820682,
0.0234157406,
0.0310668629,
-0.0232971292,
0.0082376488,
-0.0343453772,
0.0317313112,
0.0038998178,
0.0647388101,
-0.0263762698,
-0.06312038,
-0.0807925761,
0.042159643,
-0.0221457202,
0.03949086,
0.0345928408,
0.0295683257,
0.0114741577,
0.0204039868,
-0.0127083631,
0.0125129884,
0.0122382892,
0.0119074704,
0.0179112572,
-0.0311799124,
-0.0635003746,
-0.0142368926,
0.0096221212,
-0.0274742469,
0.0354079902,
-0.0277510863,
-0.003778334,
-0.0736370161,
0.0464451015,
-0.0094561512,
-0.0200435314,
-0.0050506964,
-0.0406140722,
0.0129845589,
-0.0369286127,
0.0563965552,
0.0244067647,
-0.0277735684,
-0.0028303452,
0.0615502261,
-0.0119168498,
-0.0322681889,
0.0053268299,
0.0469950102,
-0.0316504128,
-0.0209624339,
-0.0697726533,
0.0105344392,
0.0920719951,
-0.0026635898,
0.0006675976,
-0.0404369049,
-0.0025439889,
-0.0167673994,
-0.0129663367,
-0.0030359323,
-0.0236639772,
-0.0084725516,
0.0665137619,
-0.0318952426,
-0.0856431276,
0.0394269563,
-0.0353914201,
-0.0275894254,
-0.0163547397,
-0.0298301205,
-0.0559836328,
0.0635688677,
-0.0235346537,
0.0353084207,
-0.0573284887,
-0.0267003532,
-0.0118733915,
0.0124981385,
-0.0324988998,
-0.0296121147,
0.0800556466,
-0.0767358467,
0.000930627,
-0.0389944986,
-0.0120863738,
-0.0151837161,
0.0552872308,
-0.0154346898,
-0.008391859,
0.036070738,
-0.0041964995,
0.0376156308,
-0.0098257037,
0.0243569724,
0.0175139792,
0.0266789161,
-0.0286083277,
0.0060781636,
-0.0374530815,
-0.0580241345,
-0.0443034358,
-0.0449115448,
-0.019702889,
0.0106051899,
0.0357932262,
0.0306310151,
0.0352239162,
-0.0614690371,
0.0002730973,
0.0469200499,
-0.0132155223,
-0.035174828,
0.0602364615,
0.0744833946,
-0.0589222237,
-0.0240422189,
0.0762000903,
0.0136390757,
-0.0407243036,
0.014093942,
-0.0365782864,
0.0290133357,
0.0897097141,
0.052960299,
-0.0999581814,
-0.0122871017,
-0.017531462,
0.0209991243,
0.0038103461,
-0.0090978527,
-0.0113271717,
-0.1019625068,
0.035832379,
0.014307227,
-0.0330335274,
-0.0276934411,
-0.0154000092,
-0.0082878238,
0.0313633755,
-0.027363129,
0.0488021076,
0.026633013,
0.0048531634,
0.0076143136,
-0.0365962461,
-0.0077370955,
0.0481599011,
-0.0119839804,
0.0031843949,
0.0742564872,
0.0217412747,
-0.0017813303,
-0.0220647026,
0.0121712117,
0.0084452704,
0.0092381975,
-0.0454980731,
-0.0064574396,
0.0432199948,
-0.0371380262,
0.0363298617,
0.0049967384,
-0.0535913594,
-0.0187951755,
0.0492602773,
0.0530714914,
-0.0095265945,
-0.0125481775,
-0.0110419914,
-0.0013522666,
0.0027419445,
0.0287421644,
0.0237185787,
-0.0234902874,
-0.0360745899,
-0.0899374709,
-0.03247099,
-0.0858052447,
-0.0079944255,
-0.0169819035,
0.0287168976,
-0.0198912323,
-0.0030039866,
0.040776711,
0.0206804667,
0.0351368822,
0.0323016383,
-0.0370623879,
0.0061303056,
-0.013576434,
-0.0811656564,
-0.0324501395,
0.0022040976,
0.0463857017,
-0.0242169276,
-0.0230837595,
-0.0088463053,
-0.0240790267,
-0.0017196139,
0.0282095093,
-0.0961281806,
-0.0519629791,
-0.0232025627,
0.0733345672,
0.0161405858,
0.0163483433,
-0.0100246277,
-0.0050146519,
-0.0658853129,
-0.0114802951,
-0.0294347852,
0.0323202163,
0.020139439,
0.0297629219,
0.028633317,
-0.000134798,
-0.0738723725,
0.0094773974,
0.008173856,
-0.0123501197,
-0.0137485741,
-0.000718442,
0.006691542,
0.0406383052,
-0.0485027507,
-0.0168532692,
-0.0400847085,
0.015564071,
-0.0391687527,
-0.0207244344,
-0.0355979726,
-0.0552289113,
0.0034771713,
0.0081504919,
-0.028688753,
0.055280339,
0.0199772902,
-0.0115794111,
0.0072570015,
-0.013220543,
0.0704777017,
-0.0265740361,
0.0392399095,
0.082096234,
0.0148390774,
-0.0240910891,
0.0147814248,
-0.01928702,
0.0302468278,
-0.0444257557,
0.0248754192,
-0.0074612028,
0.0354166292,
0.0297355652,
0.0199647397,
-0.00121185,
-0.0586703718,
0.017968744,
-0.0010732409,
0.0554267541,
0.0400701128,
0.0510951802,
-0.0263417531,
0.0127138365,
-0.0131777832,
0.0509854145,
-0.028200997,
-0.042891968,
-0.0170193277,
0.0158357434,
-0.007915399,
-0.0415303521,
0.1054006293,
-0.0290182121,
0.0026374974,
0.0029679798,
-0.0115203205,
-0.0483130254,
-0.0027211297,
0.046380356,
-0.034218885,
-0.0227863416,
-0.0205587763,
-0.0354920588,
-0.0513828881,
0.0219807085,
0.0565758534,
0.0326471068,
-0.0251837112,
0.0352966338,
0.0991560519,
0.028868204,
0.0033682066,
-0.0247665308,
0.0130671868,
0.0071165133,
-0.0252699126,
0.0256540664,
-6.159602153e-33,
-0.0262906346,
-0.0254234318,
0.0312351342,
0.032751359,
0.0120248916,
0.0068682898,
-0.0669114217,
0.0000923288,
0.0158789698,
-0.0518522672,
0.066732116,
0.0021146971,
-0.0234580953,
-0.0376751795,
0.0600721873,
0.039576862,
0.0247725081,
0.0228863172,
-0.0456660576,
0.006781857,
0.0053506149,
0.0252472404,
0.0282524414,
-0.0326270275,
0.0010562736,
-0.0034903318,
0.015539851,
-0.0150165325,
0.0095243948,
0.0247128699,
0.0084951809,
0.0170703456,
0.0002628999,
-0.0128535563,
-0.0295931343,
-0.0201691557,
0.0014972556,
-0.0208093151,
0.0180919878,
0.0121627841,
-0.0235577431,
-0.069999747,
0.0749382377,
0.0186683126,
-0.0583753139,
0.0220252015,
-0.0108628338,
-0.0072780596,
0.009080058,
-0.0277160965,
-0.0875272602,
0.0379861295,
-0.0593678728,
-0.0098413965,
-0.0010252416,
0.0492266417,
-0.0308904145,
0.0504618809,
0.0029855971,
0.0100728562,
-0.0185677335,
0.037872877,
0.102629438,
-0.0180859715,
0.0032722985,
0.0149525013,
0.0523477606,
0.0336153768,
-0.0114520453,
0.0620234944,
0.0284963604,
0.0430388972,
0.0011314569,
0.0301074423,
-0.0349515751,
-0.0249730255,
-0.0526815355,
0.0294715147,
-0.0069718864,
0.0117576085,
0.0011318254,
0.0113375457,
-0.0100930436,
-0.017517088,
-0.027557129,
0.0044568107,
-0.0204114988,
-0.0234644488,
0.0250198599,
-0.0313212164,
-0.0340455882,
-0.0022631357,
0.0164237544,
-0.0308830161,
0.0039248294,
0.0342047699,
-0.0523233414,
0.0299352836,
0.0144150201,
0.0668837503,
0.014245173,
-0.0279437043,
-0.0225321334,
0.0151489228,
0.0892267898,
0.0168854855,
-0.0026015434,
0.0130634857,
-0.0401640348,
0.0069729765,
-0.0691044256,
0.0058649145,
0.002914198,
0.0261817668,
0.0056162337,
-0.0295265689,
0.0124740936,
0.0242168847,
0.0036221955,
-0.0541505888,
-0.0399264395,
-0.0313944258,
0.0244017746,
0.0362861007,
-0.0454387143,
-0.0111349719,
-0.0863320678,
0.0208755527,
0.0425532535,
-0.0049655796,
-0.0635626912,
0.0359058231,
3.079e-7,
0.0337331034,
0.034912508,
0.008168838,
0.0600248761,
0.0135288248,
0.0247595757,
-0.0507364534,
-0.0173239484,
-0.0071403496,
0.0187001396,
-0.0613987111,
0.035633985,
0.0535607859,
0.0463300161,
-0.0157283526,
0.0376776271,
0.0202753786,
0.0307158269,
-0.0623454563,
0.0513365045,
0.0376920365,
0.0008090678,
-0.0330238529,
-0.0048072021,
0.0303075276,
-0.0363980345,
0.0010399951,
-0.0110765519,
0.0035967059,
0.0324274935,
-0.0760901943,
0.0276100896,
0.0178824961,
-0.0059195855,
-0.0075960346,
-0.0311263725,
0.0113001568,
0.0761381462,
-0.0012601831,
0.0635158122,
0.0617685132,
-0.0506177694,
-0.0139580434,
-0.0705216751,
0.0369142629,
-0.0019948469,
-0.0005547453,
-0.0411556959,
-0.0067701126,
0.0123604024,
-0.0109042879,
-0.0383530967,
0.0210484192,
0.0042760833,
-0.0024511321,
-0.0418210328,
-0.0373102017,
0.0177303441,
-0.0437279008,
0.0060644597,
-0.0104659498,
-0.0597342774,
-0.0663085207,
0.0235471204,
0.0009311283,
-0.0210129227,
0.0083183125,
3.213064346e-34,
0.0157704353,
-0.0224724002,
0.0288965516,
0.0188227836,
0.0491681509,
-0.0226002559,
-0.0768306628,
0.0083021037,
-0.0241593178,
0.0212397724,
-0.0282537378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08584v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08584v1 | Asking More Informative Questions for Grounded Retrieval | 2023-11-14T23:13:27 | 2023-11-14T23:13:27 | Sedrick Keh, Justin T. Chiu, Daniel Fried | cs.CL | cs.CL | When a model is trying to gather information in an interactive setting, it
benefits from asking informative questions. However, in the case of a grounded
multi-turn image identification task, previous studies have been constrained to
polar yes/no questions, limiting how much information the model can gain in a
single turn. We present an approach that formulates more informative,
open-ended questions. In doing so, we discover that off-the-shelf visual
question answering (VQA) models often make presupposition errors, which
standard information gain question selection methods fail to account for. To
address this issue, we propose a method that can incorporate presupposition
handling into both question selection and belief updates. Specifically, we use
a two-stage process, where the model first filters out images which are
irrelevant to a given question, then updates its beliefs about which image the
user intends. Through self-play and human evaluations, we show that our method
is successful in asking informative open-ended questions, increasing accuracy
over the past state-of-the-art by 14%, while resulting in 48% more efficient
games in human evaluations. | [
0.0218541864,
0.0280407369,
-0.0078538638,
0.0298264474,
-0.0272555649,
0.0003531607,
0.0050469986,
-0.0121375611,
0.0300233476,
-0.0337845981,
-0.0385684036,
-0.0246607475,
-0.0138282608,
0.0132907741,
0.0222610347,
-0.0521604195,
0.0375762507,
-0.0162830427,
0.0011912871,
-0.0210451093,
-0.0100966021,
-0.0135063482,
-0.0113413678,
0.0083468445,
-0.0361466743,
-0.0021838036,
-0.0519676208,
0.0295906942,
0.011862183,
-0.0545920096,
-0.0071189343,
0.0273399893,
0.0496841334,
-0.0327682607,
0.0000022321,
-0.0163927339,
-0.0135645643,
-0.0486483537,
-0.010995172,
-0.0282874871,
-0.0277887695,
0.0537576936,
0.0583859086,
-0.0015481964,
-0.0386571214,
-0.0213965699,
0.071431838,
0.0865390673,
0.0604210347,
0.0143839484,
-0.0135047333,
-0.0180289838,
-0.0318537578,
0.0122186523,
0.0636097789,
-0.0219508726,
0.0289454833,
0.03460804,
0.0061679725,
0.0025104941,
-0.0519938469,
0.0430652015,
0.038271118,
0.0140604367,
0.0166440494,
0.0661558285,
-0.0208182745,
-0.0317241102,
-0.0119666774,
0.0780305341,
-0.0004406798,
-0.0140998345,
-0.0023840563,
-0.0009864958,
0.0405417047,
0.0463300757,
-0.0472404212,
0.0213407315,
-0.040895056,
-0.0092590759,
-0.091761142,
0.021180423,
-0.0035083494,
0.01181655,
-0.0193952378,
0.0442156866,
0.0130392415,
-0.0026347234,
0.0315492041,
0.0386852659,
-0.0545300283,
-0.0385668203,
0.0091115991,
0.0135044595,
-0.0091235414,
-0.0039325827,
0.0050860606,
0.0772426277,
-0.0208105836,
-0.0244472995,
0.0431508161,
0.0175406821,
-0.0543330722,
0.0942003876,
0.0111334892,
0.0053472719,
-0.037906602,
0.0245483946,
-0.0478282981,
0.0262278561,
0.0064820456,
0.0023566002,
-0.0751143247,
0.0298179146,
-0.0300985258,
-0.0336351842,
0.0225120019,
0.0274811387,
-0.0120051932,
0.0001879565,
-0.0114298956,
0.0680111721,
-0.016561402,
0.0145175187,
-0.0673796162,
0.0510772727,
-0.0605028048,
0.0207059551,
-0.0102372374,
-0.0477829501,
-0.0260175057,
0.0239521526,
0.0245781466,
-0.0213676803,
0.0147674549,
-0.0116123753,
-0.020264769,
-0.0498396605,
-0.0204865541,
-0.0243470203,
-0.0087888204,
-0.0519519746,
0.0697495639,
-0.0138143618,
0.0336126722,
-0.0200315714,
-0.013976763,
-0.0144212311,
-0.0040576141,
0.0283814315,
-0.0169053394,
0.1108366847,
0.0251485538,
-0.0115251541,
0.0261918269,
0.0141656585,
-0.0203270707,
0.0516108871,
-0.0106577417,
0.0666420758,
0.0519784316,
-0.0103507675,
0.0561065152,
0.0016308813,
0.0213324036,
0.0062296959,
0.0104968846,
0.0606878586,
-0.0128841922,
0.0218239482,
-0.0212942008,
0.0327504016,
-0.0332021788,
-0.0347979851,
0.0677296743,
0.0182338376,
-0.0339386649,
-0.0479063131,
0.0144542344,
-0.0099794576,
-0.0018084244,
0.0378809087,
-0.0502921566,
0.078149043,
-0.0485780276,
-0.0067394138,
-0.0218904875,
0.0166362412,
-0.0697213188,
-0.0428869016,
0.0152771203,
0.0283924304,
0.0594355389,
0.0809312463,
0.0205778647,
0.0030998639,
-0.0529989302,
0.0141459052,
-0.0101379734,
-0.0407441631,
-0.0006315522,
-0.0340039991,
0.0786968544,
0.0080475155,
0.0595211387,
-0.0279849395,
-0.0097401012,
0.0089680152,
0.0585828982,
0.0268625952,
0.0025759514,
0.000985871,
0.0245126057,
-0.0220459364,
-0.0458478369,
-0.0260882434,
-0.0137921218,
0.0230221134,
0.0265277065,
-0.0214651991,
0.0052105403,
-0.0531134121,
0.0596155412,
0.0215028096,
0.0482945144,
-0.024153484,
-0.0160713103,
0.0437207222,
-0.0082091168,
-0.0055184839,
0.022892328,
-0.0101817818,
0.0314477906,
0.0267302766,
-0.0105043175,
-0.000733392,
-0.0355097912,
-0.0171963908,
0.0168513097,
-0.0642894357,
-0.0323349386,
0.0140830539,
-0.0223350432,
0.00160301,
0.0065619797,
-0.0122213271,
-0.0070967604,
-0.0201188195,
-0.0208798181,
0.0383180827,
-0.0075714868,
-0.0299086645,
0.0584363937,
-0.020609688,
-0.0238696486,
-0.0290310066,
-0.0383842848,
0.0249006078,
-0.0730328932,
-0.011717598,
0.0179800745,
0.0023941295,
-0.0294634309,
0.0511243492,
0.0047574849,
-0.0797047094,
0.0262775887,
-0.082445018,
-0.0343557186,
-0.0257478561,
-0.0393692665,
0.0010116843,
0.0013938936,
-0.0193507914,
-0.0692037046,
-0.0408061519,
0.0066733737,
-0.0374658145,
0.0443251953,
0.0244183652,
0.0298136789,
0.0126291197,
-0.0344311744,
0.0010419977,
0.0270772986,
0.0662611574,
0.0408704169,
0.023876762,
-0.0189352781,
-0.0115907369,
-0.1005017385,
0.0529490113,
-0.0000090629,
0.0205427762,
0.0345030054,
-0.0394428521,
0.0088527584,
0.0772225186,
-0.0036936053,
-0.0012447382,
0.0307976026,
-0.0067184432,
-0.0384349301,
0.0169687811,
-0.0250922572,
-0.0305305216,
0.0345307738,
-0.0389130041,
-0.0049663261,
-0.006743928,
-0.0039108326,
-0.0043144515,
-0.0746297613,
0.0384349115,
0.0246036034,
-0.0286943763,
-0.0827470943,
0.0105315363,
0.0227586143,
0.0385298096,
-0.0501319356,
-0.0461271554,
0.0882729292,
-0.0085708098,
-0.0125308279,
-0.0037552759,
0.0524287112,
-0.0027827851,
0.0727202594,
0.0257253647,
0.0057343612,
0.0294207279,
0.0156880245,
-0.05318968,
-0.0404128022,
0.0337519571,
-0.022584701,
0.0398618504,
-0.0509764999,
0.0140669383,
0.0013381352,
-0.0540424585,
-0.0473194644,
-0.0539734103,
0.0039705387,
-0.0407819711,
-0.0697084218,
0.0199970715,
-0.0053268201,
0.013900877,
0.0555828102,
-0.0065693106,
-0.0204163175,
-0.015343532,
0.0042958469,
0.0203666836,
0.0671998635,
0.0375449583,
-0.0104164481,
-0.0275550783,
0.0367143117,
0.044037208,
0.0196372997,
-0.0164821744,
-0.0107460441,
0.0217307527,
0.0097655617,
0.0207320675,
-0.0038137466,
0.0382513069,
0.0613228157,
0.0124314558,
-0.029290542,
0.0809415802,
0.0424518622,
-0.0142737636,
-0.0278051924,
0.00512391,
0.0080698114,
0.0261972342,
0.0241796151,
-0.0561820343,
-0.0226503145,
-0.0118025178,
0.019325776,
0.01938444,
-0.0144251911,
0.0002523314,
-0.0847516656,
0.0504416265,
-0.0006869911,
-0.0133642368,
-0.0429288335,
-0.0224173609,
-0.0165298637,
0.0021301785,
-0.0249107238,
0.0094729522,
-0.0134734781,
0.0316647999,
-0.0217579659,
0.0374882445,
-0.0029642389,
0.002030819,
-0.047367543,
-0.0537112057,
0.0373128727,
-0.0161164068,
-0.0070374561,
-0.0861424953,
-0.0063721463,
0.0018361046,
0.013412212,
-0.0259732734,
0.0703687295,
-0.028078543,
-0.0271141715,
0.0024556967,
0.0365446806,
0.0070383465,
-0.0231362917,
-0.0155179854,
0.0539425723,
-0.0524608269,
-0.0016715912,
-0.0070282472,
0.0161107518,
0.0267415568,
0.0513387658,
0.0222203713,
-0.0112975109,
0.0013642353,
-0.0053840419,
0.0202972963,
-0.0298018511,
-0.0296892095,
-0.0319785252,
0.0243149474,
0.0448057503,
-0.0827490315,
-0.0101674981,
0.0537137426,
0.0507488623,
-0.039297469,
-0.0357281864,
-0.0069990261,
0.0384894758,
-0.0542368032,
0.0702101365,
-0.027129136,
-0.0080548823,
-0.0232567918,
-0.003144654,
0.0285860691,
-0.0598191433,
-0.0085634524,
-0.0121190166,
0.0019092953,
-0.0031177225,
0.0118738022,
0.0868375376,
0.0111024641,
0.0061932001,
0.0067356834,
-0.0174749792,
-0.0134055819,
0.0087653529,
0.0272744149,
0.008477238,
0.0120245488,
0.0236612353,
-0.0243868958,
0.0057023484,
-0.0527423769,
0.0180254932,
0.0497632809,
0.00323528,
-0.045637209,
-0.0633435547,
0.0379498638,
0.0286446828,
0.0981865004,
0.0236766487,
0.0434843265,
0.0084285829,
0.0124861486,
-0.0030217096,
-0.0148508651,
-0.0294702612,
-0.0015853596,
-0.0068760877,
-0.0063233352,
-0.0075389384,
0.0312791839,
-0.0190735292,
0.0513160042,
-0.0608134754,
-0.0637174621,
0.0343265571,
-0.0114360508,
-0.0321488157,
-0.0084043359,
-0.0305658132,
0.0127613554,
0.0244872998,
0.0610745735,
0.0571809076,
0.1025410146,
0.0298804194,
-0.0363414101,
-0.077823855,
0.0385383181,
-0.0440710746,
-0.0454884283,
-0.0137622291,
0.0349958912,
0.0398677513,
-0.0038236836,
-0.0581426509,
0.0195365455,
-0.0078245234,
0.0003661884,
-0.0288730338,
0.0567304045,
-0.0610809103,
0.0870953277,
0.0333183147,
0.002716843,
0.0054463339,
0.0232054107,
-0.0190958176,
0.036252398,
-0.047515817,
-0.0247110017,
-0.0274174232,
-0.0295741744,
0.0087869503,
0.0328638032,
-0.0075881314,
0.0532139316,
-0.0560733899,
-0.0358889401,
-0.0293063354,
0.0529754944,
-0.0154294558,
0.0048391167,
0.0699423701,
0.035385102,
0.0194197707,
-0.0636657402,
0.0044763135,
0.0279035959,
-0.0634463876,
0.014271426,
-0.0330790691,
-6.924641795e-33,
-0.0353572369,
-0.0184657127,
0.0418909565,
-0.0248829257,
-0.0143382903,
-0.0177074149,
-0.0225708541,
0.0183412358,
-0.0414793603,
-0.0162919536,
-0.0045974287,
-0.0051437323,
0.0042227595,
0.0293520316,
-0.0270251967,
-0.0483523235,
0.0375459567,
0.0083626695,
-0.0571764149,
-0.0021998333,
0.0167529508,
0.0088022472,
0.0161646493,
-0.0576237068,
-0.0201204959,
0.0009475798,
-0.0316378437,
0.0436271913,
-0.0268855989,
0.0215805136,
-0.0238937475,
-0.0243016351,
0.0076426473,
-0.0331032798,
0.023654284,
0.0220995564,
-0.0634264052,
-0.0396931954,
0.0215383209,
-0.0002235026,
-0.0744345114,
0.0118714329,
0.0137571506,
-0.0176925529,
0.0094747674,
-0.0010006584,
0.0148921134,
0.0031636967,
0.0342428498,
0.026803216,
0.0188374221,
-0.0300480463,
-0.0120604858,
-0.0584669299,
-0.022721203,
0.0718974769,
0.0361345932,
0.0286434535,
-0.0611039475,
0.0337822773,
-0.0369602665,
-0.0111484677,
0.0667458847,
0.047135625,
0.0229391642,
0.0452496,
0.0127541656,
-0.0423034467,
-0.0889902264,
-0.0625246614,
-0.0119802784,
0.0456434675,
0.0739754066,
0.0303658843,
0.0272175167,
0.0322931297,
-0.0295895915,
0.0391104482,
-0.0322818756,
0.068580769,
-0.0177654643,
0.0128571615,
-0.0408650376,
-0.0117737828,
-0.0506578647,
0.0088369846,
-0.0487069152,
-0.0240876004,
0.0588405393,
0.0242067389,
-0.0600860044,
0.0332750678,
0.0493150987,
-0.0100635337,
0.0061182766,
-0.0031896974,
-0.0094840331,
0.031413503,
0.0065555866,
0.0077735689,
-0.0059537692,
0.0323427096,
0.0909169391,
-0.0394502804,
-0.0362298489,
0.0152731761,
-0.0134353759,
0.0277836695,
-0.0396762714,
-0.0174586214,
-0.0158411264,
0.0088944985,
-0.005950463,
-0.028101135,
0.0117725274,
0.0525630862,
-0.0477755517,
0.0096941693,
0.002236343,
0.0124745052,
-0.0455792509,
-0.055554077,
-0.0165141374,
0.0262288786,
0.0064595519,
0.0139967352,
-0.0203026421,
-0.0235391352,
-0.0305441394,
-0.0692810118,
-0.0427033864,
0.0686430112,
2.984e-7,
-0.0033369765,
-0.005882978,
0.0160467662,
0.0194001067,
-0.0224227626,
0.0354396552,
-0.0283700377,
-0.0121261217,
0.0421381108,
-0.0742970333,
0.0204737075,
0.072649613,
0.0138065042,
0.0049508028,
-0.037208613,
-0.0018541777,
0.016350368,
0.0133293858,
-0.0344421677,
-0.0275523998,
0.0399202555,
0.0416305624,
0.0074435589,
0.0331822671,
0.0389408916,
-0.0288994554,
0.0757231936,
-0.0300951879,
0.0213059746,
-0.0467708223,
0.03403382,
-0.0188510083,
-0.0187136363,
0.019774884,
-0.0135607934,
-0.0208014417,
0.023313785,
0.0007302254,
-0.0005169604,
-0.057134226,
-0.0562788546,
0.0490775108,
0.0224261507,
-0.0644935742,
0.1158307418,
-0.0612639338,
0.0004519095,
0.0127464235,
-0.0425537899,
-0.0076070642,
0.0447321087,
0.0024465804,
-0.0821866989,
-0.0230951123,
0.024705898,
0.0131389303,
-0.0037157084,
-0.0850424841,
0.0164979901,
-0.0315103196,
-0.0280751903,
-0.0124584436,
-0.0187332742,
-0.0456982255,
0.0009216485,
-0.0185233559,
-0.0454848185,
2.12136736e-34,
0.0237764064,
0.0064097899,
0.0267178472,
-0.0094799306,
0.0494397618,
-0.008875126,
-0.015951639,
-0.0350061171,
0.032776583,
-0.0510175899,
0.0148831727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08579v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08579v1 | Graph-Induced Syntactic-Semantic Spaces in Transformer-Based Variational AutoEncoders | 2023-11-14T22:47:23 | 2023-11-14T22:47:23 | Yingji Zhang, Marco Valentino, Danilo S. Carvalho, Ian Pratt-Hartmann, André Freitas | cs.CL | cs.CL | The injection of syntactic information in Variational AutoEncoders (VAEs) has
been shown to result in an overall improvement of performances and
generalisation. An effective strategy to achieve such a goal is to separate the
encoding of distributional semantic features and syntactic structures into
heterogeneous latent spaces via multi-task learning or dual encoder
architectures. However, existing works employing such techniques are limited to
LSTM-based VAEs. In this paper, we investigate latent space separation methods
for structural syntactic injection in Transformer-based VAE architectures
(i.e., Optimus). Specifically, we explore how syntactic structures can be
leveraged in the encoding stage through the integration of graph-based and
sequential models, and how multiple, specialised latent representations can be
injected into the decoder's attention mechanism via low-rank operators. Our
empirical evaluation, carried out on natural language sentences and
mathematical expressions, reveals that the proposed end-to-end VAE architecture
can result in a better overall organisation of the latent space, alleviating
the information loss occurring in standard VAE setups, resulting in enhanced
performances on language modelling and downstream generation tasks. | [
0.0247679036,
0.0870144293,
-0.0032052954,
0.0509442762,
-0.0309818182,
0.0110956086,
-0.0005471037,
-0.0619143173,
0.00164454,
-0.0332881957,
-0.0297368988,
-0.0551758371,
-0.0129242847,
0.0653067082,
0.0765393525,
-0.0554173738,
0.0138608068,
-0.0116776889,
-0.0456601121,
-0.0263123047,
-0.0120275607,
-0.0218230784,
0.0371663496,
0.0150394486,
0.0062333071,
-0.0039214077,
-0.0355743803,
-0.0022694152,
0.0224407781,
0.0239350628,
-0.0002385455,
-0.0009813826,
0.0488135293,
0.0202276688,
0.0000018008,
0.0138007645,
-0.0040625986,
-0.0000174149,
-0.0371463858,
-0.0122772455,
0.0516214631,
-0.0462191813,
0.0045000599,
0.0096954051,
-0.0137040438,
-0.0816393048,
0.0394716449,
-0.0024861353,
0.08091221,
0.0740927532,
-0.0270002205,
-0.0389998369,
0.0575834587,
-0.0462891869,
0.0251089763,
-0.030835744,
0.0301639959,
-0.0182335842,
-0.0063453731,
0.0059423395,
-0.0737596154,
0.0527135134,
0.0618039034,
-0.0210144054,
0.0470695049,
0.0292155109,
0.0221346449,
-0.0147522315,
-0.0645832717,
0.039827425,
-0.0471263677,
-0.0085154716,
-0.0246187076,
-0.0275844559,
-0.0172486659,
0.0255371295,
-0.0385118388,
0.0520524718,
0.0149662076,
0.0100666946,
0.0181598775,
-0.0013522771,
0.0335309096,
-0.0371245146,
-0.0259585716,
0.0252770297,
0.0518395267,
-0.0319646746,
0.0130640473,
0.0490601771,
-0.0544776209,
0.0057381457,
-0.0073773381,
0.0237446986,
-0.0022414133,
-0.0100226579,
-0.0390327573,
-0.0878958106,
-0.0714819133,
0.0019217427,
0.0602629147,
0.031914629,
0.0114459116,
-0.0120465523,
-0.0093230149,
0.0762913376,
-0.0729652792,
0.0344448648,
-0.0809613392,
-0.0007413193,
0.0088443914,
-0.0217074081,
-0.0035722393,
0.0380911045,
-0.0355223082,
-0.0571393147,
-0.0409329496,
0.0611685477,
-0.0187459886,
-0.008913693,
0.0401047021,
0.0734652802,
-0.0439025499,
0.0183296595,
0.0164176226,
0.011636409,
0.0046797125,
0.0109060351,
-0.0001441847,
-0.0279650819,
-0.0482789874,
0.0769896656,
0.0666943043,
-0.0136520024,
-0.019279249,
0.0515750088,
-0.030790614,
-0.0207230542,
-0.0224828012,
0.007548552,
-0.0059225741,
-0.0158212818,
0.073647134,
-0.0344050415,
0.0467232578,
0.0192726161,
-0.0228913203,
-0.0269182604,
-0.0082183713,
-0.0002907933,
-0.0167354234,
0.0578943975,
0.0328408629,
-0.0207237527,
0.0150873931,
-0.0282472074,
0.003082701,
0.0202720203,
0.0331571549,
0.0492746495,
-0.0342356153,
0.0079536689,
-0.0227964222,
0.0316292048,
-0.0014750385,
-0.0358660817,
-0.0275870878,
-0.0421104208,
-0.0264400374,
-0.0080889761,
0.0621058568,
0.069386892,
-0.0449146479,
0.0041736579,
0.005817343,
0.0077346526,
0.0459629148,
0.0104731778,
0.0851253271,
0.0246752743,
-0.0213176459,
0.0121403867,
-0.0161042828,
0.0297485795,
0.0425346233,
0.0299963858,
-0.0118703218,
0.0112326443,
-0.0056333281,
-0.0177239757,
0.0121877836,
-0.0528378934,
0.0536929369,
-0.0310000833,
0.051433567,
0.027946258,
-0.0673732981,
0.0599962696,
0.0187070034,
-0.0144212591,
0.0203083027,
0.0079609267,
-0.0375328846,
0.0489642471,
-0.0147849834,
0.0127354553,
-0.0101611335,
-0.019397907,
-0.0418218002,
0.0394582078,
-0.0183775611,
-0.0088454923,
-0.0133626675,
-0.05165058,
-0.0697659552,
-0.0699563473,
-0.0003603731,
0.0398232453,
0.0101165175,
-0.0303636473,
0.0193644278,
-0.0092683611,
0.0433442406,
0.0168549418,
-0.0347851701,
0.00664555,
0.0107797505,
-0.0004102899,
0.0242877603,
0.0000205368,
0.0072403695,
0.0514789633,
0.0060362457,
-0.0663921759,
-0.020443147,
0.0060722479,
-0.0615647025,
-0.0658753812,
0.0028672284,
-0.0425884314,
0.0155020878,
0.0535523221,
-0.0257104188,
-0.0495017618,
0.054479003,
-0.0769644007,
-0.0066154585,
-0.0343768336,
-0.0188920144,
0.0337554589,
0.0391749293,
-0.0019198533,
0.0630837679,
-0.0280703343,
0.0090689659,
0.021564411,
0.0566725656,
-0.0107736206,
-0.0100996587,
0.0022797086,
-0.0221398119,
0.0212617759,
0.037251547,
0.0336737707,
0.0081306985,
-0.0025500942,
-0.0291268621,
-0.0677413195,
0.000467048,
-0.0518853255,
0.0312459413,
0.0175621901,
0.0544815511,
0.0375865325,
0.0131508149,
-0.0277823694,
0.0504794419,
-0.0056326161,
0.0071642119,
0.0371924713,
-0.0224167891,
0.0159134604,
-0.0021057425,
-0.048860345,
-0.018989116,
0.1013415679,
-0.0071213823,
-0.0231659655,
0.0028077168,
0.0248755869,
0.0157085564,
-0.0037220935,
-0.0120312441,
-0.0193222873,
0.014253729,
-0.02102465,
0.0785584077,
0.0401942246,
-0.0311208759,
0.0796228349,
0.0328572169,
-0.0213506054,
0.0023225807,
0.0168419257,
-0.0638818517,
0.0266226847,
-0.0206669718,
0.0227157213,
0.0005376772,
0.0598698631,
0.0220419373,
-0.0015937588,
-0.0814381912,
0.0192114376,
-0.0001326512,
-0.014280743,
0.025447946,
-0.0233214349,
-0.0679334179,
-0.0204019733,
-0.04213107,
0.0066005145,
0.0466534235,
0.0328478962,
-0.0174363498,
-0.0110893389,
-0.0011297893,
-0.0385393947,
0.0193200707,
0.0734763518,
0.0008220226,
-0.0272919852,
-0.0563986972,
-0.0458316505,
0.0512067527,
0.0235318933,
0.0070567429,
0.0416227803,
0.0185970534,
-0.0017355117,
0.0088546751,
-0.0400487371,
-0.0502553768,
-0.0395636596,
0.0104713896,
0.0449432023,
0.058156319,
-0.0459513292,
-0.0110333906,
-0.0364147015,
-0.0127875078,
0.0311095528,
-0.0267875195,
0.0069147698,
-0.0515028425,
0.0826132819,
0.0524934158,
0.0276332647,
-0.0055495058,
-0.0455456488,
-0.0395271145,
0.010846192,
0.008337901,
-0.0158632733,
-0.0327433012,
0.0477510765,
-0.0002733623,
0.0053015645,
-0.0191422906,
-0.0070902333,
0.0228856411,
-0.0167460889,
-0.0415993147,
0.0718078613,
-0.0016467214,
-0.0312990807,
-0.0012001612,
-0.0178484414,
0.0567226671,
0.0281396117,
-0.0018124325,
-0.0627039894,
-0.0222660974,
-0.0595059097,
0.0062119192,
0.0274642557,
0.0013211122,
-0.0260430872,
-0.0534886047,
0.0067119682,
0.0276057329,
0.0002302637,
0.0000382269,
-0.0049243253,
-0.0041805161,
-0.0039788662,
0.0091101956,
-0.0260849278,
-0.0128892725,
-0.0031043496,
0.0579100959,
-0.0011763275,
-0.05300254,
-0.0458984338,
-0.0141802877,
-0.0270699561,
0.0416728184,
0.0118029872,
-0.0150840199,
-0.0127844568,
0.0220390316,
-0.0313052572,
-0.0039332807,
0.0201657675,
0.0364000611,
-0.008917463,
-0.0126517247,
0.0002192359,
0.0161570627,
-0.0755965188,
-0.0190540645,
-0.0467070602,
0.0956653208,
-0.0131692505,
-0.0286384933,
0.007654977,
-0.0343308635,
-0.0332026295,
0.0011687796,
0.0596531443,
-0.0223033298,
-0.0345305987,
-0.0322999321,
0.0258657653,
-0.0466876775,
-0.0261869021,
0.006192585,
0.0389796495,
-0.081902422,
-0.0370856784,
-0.0518445373,
-0.007004586,
-0.0001720502,
-0.0331584699,
-0.0300074648,
0.0654330775,
-0.0581307746,
-0.0843822137,
-0.0158142522,
0.0077689677,
0.0053388025,
0.0175732076,
-0.0066086715,
0.0085196756,
-0.0246738624,
-0.0287458822,
-0.0063681672,
-0.1106455922,
-0.0816328451,
0.0164597146,
0.0311059058,
0.0057222182,
0.0627269596,
-0.0050644786,
0.0200069528,
0.0823970884,
0.0221696552,
-0.0116264308,
0.0238014329,
0.0476447493,
-0.0270257127,
-0.004975812,
0.0276094377,
-0.0308847502,
-0.011797498,
0.009200179,
0.0234295968,
-0.0221611019,
-0.0456809811,
0.0004635203,
-0.0185020454,
0.0273650307,
0.015028907,
0.0175154228,
-0.0496426225,
-0.0072454079,
-0.0243479144,
-0.0191162229,
-0.072397612,
-0.0260115303,
0.0405007675,
0.0339937098,
-0.0349242911,
0.0312931426,
0.0574142635,
0.0363693684,
-0.0301136374,
0.0065578385,
0.0238614418,
0.0000878264,
0.0033490846,
0.0309568457,
0.003030037,
-0.0065040723,
0.0170984045,
0.0089218523,
-0.0177201983,
0.0341553316,
0.0152989887,
-0.0046632187,
-0.0288529284,
0.0165772587,
-0.0647009835,
-0.0275784079,
-0.0455351025,
-0.0378040634,
0.0144609958,
0.0219764691,
0.0845844448,
-0.0276484489,
-0.0202056281,
0.0023489937,
0.0433324128,
-0.0090598548,
-0.0560504459,
0.06722866,
0.0111684687,
0.0091185272,
-0.0277617667,
0.0468401164,
0.0137854908,
-0.0182531439,
-0.0187839717,
0.0002029603,
-0.0600096658,
-0.0333703421,
0.0020217099,
0.0104726395,
0.0130835967,
0.0093314415,
-0.0153430216,
-0.0575749725,
0.0428105742,
-0.0012141278,
0.0014583969,
-0.0244775116,
0.0500174202,
0.0515073016,
0.005683769,
-0.0336565897,
-0.0168344472,
0.030612452,
0.0222662762,
-0.0247599166,
-0.0244887602,
-6.249035968e-33,
-0.0341679491,
-0.0404636972,
-0.0094423713,
-0.0025204169,
-0.0508043729,
0.0381087288,
-0.0676562712,
-0.0171119515,
0.0156849865,
0.0212415904,
0.0352990292,
0.033826746,
0.002829026,
0.0542468354,
0.0123781813,
-0.0370429084,
0.0500945114,
-0.0028316067,
0.0104287779,
0.0290977005,
0.0121743055,
0.0534945689,
0.0525181554,
-0.0132476194,
0.0236152336,
-0.0038899723,
0.0394150726,
0.0074527822,
0.022454517,
0.03918273,
-0.0338271633,
0.0860081762,
0.0157886259,
-0.0232120156,
-0.0203815438,
0.0267698802,
-0.059962213,
-0.0644756556,
-0.0214266106,
0.024396928,
-0.0576229915,
-0.0522896163,
0.0816803426,
-0.0087939929,
0.0193597525,
-0.047100056,
0.0202030372,
0.028080456,
0.002200068,
-0.0360442214,
-0.0600488819,
-0.0076040761,
0.0079638148,
-0.0024858406,
0.03963219,
-0.0062570376,
0.0000623294,
0.0231868178,
-0.0406298004,
0.0080479607,
-0.0466078967,
0.0198443476,
0.0355085023,
0.0507217385,
-0.0075604855,
0.0209342614,
0.0102197463,
-0.0560497567,
-0.0360804759,
0.0195663776,
0.0351295546,
0.0304392129,
0.0071152281,
-0.0343900993,
-0.0205018949,
0.0488544814,
-0.047300186,
-0.0080716703,
0.0019382264,
0.0469785519,
-0.0077020368,
0.0479352213,
0.0040659024,
-0.0661786348,
0.0086690681,
-0.0157838352,
-0.0206003524,
-0.0144618824,
0.012134037,
-0.0143788569,
-0.0127678365,
0.0335768871,
0.0221931562,
-0.0409315564,
0.0226378385,
0.0669859499,
-0.0263589527,
0.0695954114,
0.001502167,
0.0455225669,
-0.0666852817,
-0.0019637165,
0.026250409,
-0.0133491736,
-0.0134020736,
0.0123089775,
-0.0192826632,
0.0812215209,
-0.0304801967,
-0.0309337601,
-0.0639403686,
-0.0362781994,
-0.0382081829,
0.0584872738,
0.046932824,
0.0533144064,
-0.0329085849,
0.0752174035,
0.0163935162,
0.0435771905,
-0.0190501008,
0.0010350519,
0.0417922698,
0.0607775412,
-0.0393627249,
0.0044086436,
-0.0238655042,
0.0451929942,
0.0280379076,
-0.0691052079,
-0.0123850582,
0.011200537,
2.617e-7,
0.0847962126,
0.0092652682,
0.0522432216,
0.0295697376,
0.0125700627,
0.0305327661,
0.0104239453,
0.0289144274,
-0.0082369419,
-0.0083412565,
0.0220918749,
0.0491207689,
-0.0164537393,
-0.0179610718,
-0.0531733558,
0.0455287136,
-0.0386182554,
-0.0292784311,
-0.0056535667,
0.0102862706,
0.0598354526,
0.0863837376,
-0.0138670718,
-0.0042954953,
-0.0331459939,
0.014551905,
0.0876140818,
0.0353924893,
-0.056837365,
-0.0111994091,
-0.0014253727,
-0.0413372144,
-0.0144656477,
0.0072577028,
-0.026316626,
0.0268205628,
0.0311001334,
0.0011985194,
0.0031695256,
-0.0317786708,
-0.0185286682,
-0.0086145531,
-0.0171499066,
0.0151825622,
0.0308937933,
-0.1042974591,
-0.0709752515,
-0.0037592081,
-0.0496559143,
0.0387355797,
0.0051217047,
-0.003744296,
-0.0138392728,
-0.0202190876,
0.0419670343,
0.00082561,
-0.0099970978,
-0.0409352258,
0.0155284358,
0.0444110818,
-0.0533122532,
-0.0014368778,
-0.0276985914,
0.0092190988,
0.0508666076,
-0.0046948036,
-0.0385540649,
2.661231507e-34,
0.0163508356,
0.0290077906,
0.0156998653,
0.0334021412,
0.0149172014,
-0.025299063,
-0.0384117477,
0.021628648,
0.0239114948,
-0.0678251833,
-0.0538875461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08576v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08576v1 | Towards Evaluating AI Systems for Moral Status Using Self-Reports | 2023-11-14T22:45:44 | 2023-11-14T22:45:44 | Ethan Perez, Robert Long | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | As AI systems become more advanced and widely deployed, there will likely be
increasing debate over whether AI systems could have conscious experiences,
desires, or other states of potential moral significance. It is important to
inform these discussions with empirical evidence to the extent possible. We
argue that under the right circumstances, self-reports, or an AI system's
statements about its own internal states, could provide an avenue for
investigating whether AI systems have states of moral significance.
Self-reports are the main way such states are assessed in humans ("Are you in
pain?"), but self-reports from current systems like large language models are
spurious for many reasons (e.g. often just reflecting what humans would say).
To make self-reports more appropriate for this purpose, we propose to train
models to answer many kinds of questions about themselves with known answers,
while avoiding or limiting training incentives that bias self-reports. The hope
of this approach is that models will develop introspection-like capabilities,
and that these capabilities will generalize to questions about states of moral
significance. We then propose methods for assessing the extent to which these
techniques have succeeded: evaluating self-report consistency across contexts
and between similar models, measuring the confidence and resilience of models'
self-reports, and using interpretability to corroborate self-reports. We also
discuss challenges for our approach, from philosophical difficulties in
interpreting self-reports to technical reasons why our proposal might fail. We
hope our discussion inspires philosophers and AI researchers to criticize and
improve our proposed methodology, as well as to run experiments to test whether
self-reports can be made reliable enough to provide information about states of
moral significance. | [
0.038094312,
0.1005968675,
-0.0398967229,
0.0096005723,
-0.0644913837,
-0.0102329804,
0.0346929356,
-0.0101298504,
0.0473733544,
-0.0245136693,
-0.0272586402,
0.0205634516,
-0.0127519863,
0.0115982145,
-0.0087956125,
0.0139770973,
0.021024501,
0.0070374086,
0.0418738872,
0.0069758673,
-0.0221321099,
0.0092015909,
0.0324758291,
0.0099462662,
-0.0340436772,
-0.0305561777,
0.0014324391,
-0.0136299385,
0.0201291535,
-0.0215670001,
-0.0256002191,
0.019069083,
0.0219147634,
-0.0068544969,
0.000001861,
-0.0576610751,
-0.0062432997,
0.0113044176,
-0.011334518,
0.0035563728,
0.0384083129,
0.0007019879,
0.0180681646,
-0.00644508,
-0.0653474405,
0.0239314511,
0.0058000544,
0.025330523,
0.0081495391,
0.0516068116,
-0.0176130179,
0.0387039594,
0.0107767358,
0.0149184074,
-0.0115532978,
-0.0044942419,
0.021019591,
0.0323655158,
-0.020167511,
-0.0421473347,
-0.01092631,
0.0247674249,
0.0408570319,
-0.01123669,
-0.015833037,
-0.0021698582,
0.0147430571,
-0.0344992131,
0.0078727026,
0.0042816931,
0.0554017574,
-0.0271760449,
0.0422802567,
0.0074583166,
0.0508109741,
-0.0446924195,
0.0278121997,
0.0376207978,
-0.0133320699,
-0.0031185157,
0.0486855321,
0.0786649287,
0.028556386,
0.0221531987,
-0.0116910934,
0.0252147242,
-0.0414740518,
-0.0268184599,
0.0081303678,
-0.0033399758,
0.0065656304,
-0.0555774122,
-0.0075769653,
0.0261946283,
-0.0048600147,
0.0064572636,
-0.051969178,
0.0381910168,
0.0106133809,
-0.0261375532,
0.0273048077,
0.016011795,
-0.0290332604,
0.0077622551,
0.0378506072,
0.0556997992,
0.0298962481,
0.0435374714,
-0.0536756106,
0.0213178918,
-0.009702554,
0.0229009297,
-0.0174192153,
0.0577286296,
0.0378614925,
0.0470660552,
-0.0125773465,
0.0165488645,
-0.0787791237,
0.017930964,
-0.0631700978,
0.0153897954,
-0.0011600956,
-0.02211334,
-0.0318443924,
-0.0354593955,
-0.0555146448,
-0.0066796858,
0.0091097057,
-0.020653218,
0.0272588748,
-0.0352949873,
-0.0167313572,
-0.0061614471,
0.0351903737,
0.0964111686,
0.0633150935,
-0.0279542431,
0.0056908606,
-0.0362214856,
-0.0125499805,
-0.0774062276,
-0.0077814613,
-0.0038718986,
0.0149535546,
-0.0119523713,
0.0080810236,
-0.0588583015,
0.0197791792,
-0.0156736169,
0.0118034538,
0.0568104759,
0.00603018,
0.0177406669,
-0.0046971627,
0.0284894276,
0.017966833,
0.035059724,
0.0342491604,
0.041845087,
0.0635607243,
-0.0311441701,
0.0410268828,
-0.0542000309,
0.0028380544,
-0.0187720321,
-0.0263539683,
0.0268523935,
-0.0598564483,
0.0212842729,
-0.0097732805,
0.0433906056,
0.0107456278,
-0.034761183,
0.0479338095,
0.1003365666,
-0.0093358783,
0.0323844664,
0.0446135513,
-0.032369867,
0.0344624706,
0.0286585242,
-0.0576231182,
0.0291093476,
-0.0079672942,
-0.0195330121,
-0.0269335546,
-0.0035168589,
-0.0178944264,
-0.0936382115,
0.0044574705,
-0.0365490951,
0.0102252867,
0.0629250482,
0.0254337844,
-0.0134474533,
0.0238492601,
-0.1098991632,
0.0129813431,
-0.053288009,
0.0024760712,
-0.1251073182,
0.0880495533,
0.0793449283,
0.0470195189,
-0.0505413674,
0.0053589931,
-0.0077312277,
-0.0214643646,
-0.0224834047,
0.0449773781,
-0.0142448926,
0.0258608162,
0.0001705071,
-0.0011372329,
-0.0401543863,
0.0126088718,
0.0019070402,
-0.0399119556,
-0.0190261081,
-0.0099692345,
-0.0246866066,
-0.0472413078,
0.0450500846,
-0.0168019552,
-0.0104262428,
0.0046462789,
0.0221626386,
0.0308321416,
0.0035652595,
-0.0225272328,
0.0042661233,
0.0188371688,
0.0132824089,
-0.0251242872,
0.029044088,
-0.0241515525,
0.0445455685,
-0.0021291235,
-0.0453913435,
-0.0227477681,
0.0372479931,
0.0195730198,
0.0112156412,
-0.0194072053,
-0.0603123866,
0.0090008723,
-0.0375204384,
0.0154500837,
-0.0534792282,
-0.0250570811,
0.0056223241,
0.0302839186,
-0.016659664,
-0.0136553925,
-0.0390927158,
-0.0485701412,
0.0424368419,
-0.0125234677,
-0.0440695286,
-0.0268099867,
-0.047128696,
0.0318403728,
0.0349733233,
0.0062786448,
-0.0282106474,
-0.016347507,
-0.0992058739,
-0.0125963651,
0.0111479815,
-0.0210089535,
-0.0138872638,
-0.0296735894,
0.0129112955,
0.0092491461,
-0.0215163864,
-0.0055062342,
0.0298168808,
0.0091736354,
0.0336716995,
-0.0085551739,
0.002930508,
-0.0496444702,
0.0234492347,
-0.0451044403,
-0.0143976808,
0.0368991531,
0.0322039798,
-0.0317339227,
0.0280729886,
-0.0709924102,
0.0170458909,
-0.0073697409,
-0.0625848845,
0.0150659066,
0.0346331596,
-0.034150999,
0.1340153664,
0.0308121778,
0.0543681867,
0.0577238724,
0.0488043539,
-0.0321404189,
-0.0096606575,
0.0172195211,
0.016205579,
-0.0205203909,
-0.0750542879,
-0.0054910504,
0.0434352048,
0.0208163336,
-0.0005501384,
-0.0410107039,
0.0680777878,
-0.0413151495,
-0.1077368185,
0.0226761699,
-0.0173439682,
0.00389926,
0.0744857416,
-0.0191076342,
-0.0796541721,
0.0924186781,
0.0417290516,
0.0194536913,
0.0549763702,
-0.0197158214,
-0.0003447358,
0.0786279663,
0.0112793893,
0.0321729928,
0.0497325249,
0.0332088545,
-0.0105122561,
-0.014112195,
0.0003714764,
-0.0573853366,
0.0235985462,
-0.0301837325,
0.0047607925,
0.0513648205,
-0.0687361211,
-0.0514076874,
-0.0517642312,
-0.0275704656,
-0.0430689938,
-0.0207454748,
-0.0042907456,
0.0414878651,
-0.0059544756,
0.0423997603,
-0.0305559039,
-0.0246853158,
-0.0356609002,
0.013274272,
-0.0864042491,
0.0381917544,
0.0150635,
0.0743183643,
0.0300176162,
0.0460647121,
0.0235734303,
0.0250864476,
0.0403630994,
-0.0183469988,
0.0068204529,
-0.024305949,
-0.0151484124,
0.0266415086,
0.0359002538,
0.0377915837,
-0.008850201,
-0.0462674052,
0.0861542225,
0.0082110548,
-0.030546302,
0.0363344848,
-0.0200288557,
-0.0643749982,
0.0267904662,
0.0136540905,
-0.0496111847,
0.0144451801,
-0.0250938591,
0.0171359126,
-0.1055731252,
-0.050464645,
0.021769667,
-0.0657257661,
0.0317022279,
-0.002626146,
0.0007636789,
-0.0554883182,
-0.0144099165,
-0.0115997726,
-0.0286174063,
-0.0092221415,
-0.0199614707,
0.0050582732,
-0.0274451673,
-0.0111662131,
-0.0341218747,
0.0168935638,
0.0561471991,
-0.0296758357,
0.0861781314,
0.081543088,
0.0549708679,
-0.0452589802,
-0.0410121009,
-0.0421984382,
0.0510926358,
0.0118855014,
0.0386445709,
0.0289920121,
-0.040722277,
-0.0060935104,
-0.0371419042,
0.0120640704,
0.0000093767,
0.0095300274,
0.0296904761,
0.053586375,
-0.0246872697,
-0.0636542439,
-0.0037636771,
-0.006181905,
0.0134938089,
0.0696935207,
0.0016243291,
-0.0395385288,
-0.0239625182,
-0.0263484139,
0.0030409752,
-0.0117512541,
-0.0531191379,
-0.007478911,
0.0387501605,
-0.0012022238,
-0.0700861961,
-0.0764003843,
-0.0280349981,
-0.0086726313,
0.0187702253,
-0.0629884005,
0.0103964973,
0.0190462153,
-0.0435025692,
-0.0084249526,
-0.0290364288,
-0.0326722972,
-0.0026963213,
0.020094078,
0.0232651979,
-0.0259404406,
0.0211688429,
-0.0041988185,
0.0214574616,
0.0056809098,
0.0421530157,
0.0870356038,
0.0165149085,
0.0063714623,
-0.0463691466,
0.0138206705,
0.0046012797,
0.0384466313,
-0.0730215237,
0.0196159426,
0.0867902115,
0.0144192213,
-0.0179208256,
0.0221963804,
-0.0150264455,
0.0196145717,
0.0058657238,
-0.0474867783,
-0.0052690487,
-0.0236479416,
0.0400829203,
0.0319386236,
-0.0131677669,
0.0038717096,
0.000935503,
0.0011966542,
-0.0450725295,
-0.0337957554,
-0.0284161307,
-0.0262690466,
0.0016840065,
0.0417898446,
0.0293183904,
0.0027283512,
0.0063210395,
-0.0521075316,
-0.0355313942,
-0.0101654958,
-0.0297267418,
0.0080630137,
0.0594260208,
-0.0577659085,
0.0108341221,
-0.042688854,
0.0394164398,
0.0260809083,
0.0380570143,
-0.0080357697,
0.0474453904,
0.0083005168,
0.0164253581,
0.0109707927,
0.0479913838,
-0.0797807798,
-0.0192321856,
0.0073704142,
-0.0076363869,
0.0237839408,
0.0474126413,
-0.0002318906,
-0.0168764647,
0.0133898975,
0.0035226233,
0.0275828354,
0.0318400189,
-0.0175215863,
-0.0516567193,
0.017409021,
-0.0361261591,
-0.0003083957,
0.0251850374,
-0.0181200746,
0.0540003218,
0.0044283262,
-0.0223515369,
-0.027746249,
-0.0449639857,
-0.0131750479,
-0.0336871184,
-0.0100118481,
0.0004758561,
-0.0634265691,
-0.0739032254,
-0.0116589041,
0.0492058732,
0.0255190786,
-0.043142993,
-0.0354599431,
0.0623124167,
-0.0170003772,
-0.0015843365,
-0.0449680649,
0.0008451221,
-0.0232781991,
0.0262517929,
-0.0361574106,
-5.05082078e-33,
-0.0097628161,
-0.0385624431,
-0.0067230063,
-0.0089973463,
-0.000095621,
-0.0036921203,
-0.0138293812,
0.0037580961,
-0.0603128709,
0.0449714586,
-0.0198838748,
0.0271107052,
-0.012677989,
-0.0387919508,
0.0340165421,
-0.0431384742,
0.0188662093,
-0.0198218115,
-0.0249946453,
0.0207647644,
-0.02972815,
-0.0300606173,
0.0249591321,
-0.1009236425,
0.0339562856,
0.016411189,
-0.0243116636,
0.0104034254,
-0.0696636885,
0.0184749868,
-0.0267514475,
0.0363493003,
0.028204428,
0.0116223572,
0.0099550309,
0.0042167637,
-0.0030974129,
-0.0222717766,
0.0069375811,
-0.0351844206,
-0.0664916337,
-0.0344228484,
-0.0042252732,
-0.0112390537,
-0.0447660498,
0.0034403822,
0.0349854045,
0.0083078453,
0.0632283092,
-0.0369717516,
-0.0426756442,
-0.0344574824,
-0.0170629751,
-0.0498739332,
-0.0257529933,
0.0390200876,
-0.0243612379,
-0.0101233348,
0.0280934479,
0.0065742801,
-0.0141526749,
-0.0578653961,
0.0378677323,
-0.0498732254,
0.0258632712,
0.0441829078,
0.0485164337,
0.0565880425,
-0.0351090059,
-0.0152917169,
0.0277716033,
0.0455272682,
0.0631348118,
0.052089721,
-0.0196870603,
-0.043553777,
-0.0081591662,
-0.0041466379,
0.0268970393,
-0.0284358431,
0.026055906,
-0.0262185037,
-0.0654620007,
0.0179667082,
-0.0150227053,
-0.1030308008,
-0.0245035421,
-0.0181093775,
0.0112550054,
-0.031734556,
-0.0342846625,
-0.0079125147,
-0.0142919999,
-0.0799046233,
0.0561935492,
0.0067598703,
0.0176885407,
0.0131493574,
0.0107097793,
0.0120743802,
-0.0211865995,
-0.0084986556,
0.0043617166,
0.0182278063,
0.0874377936,
-0.0037088506,
0.0446240418,
0.0162167717,
0.0032189868,
-0.0038071841,
-0.0276425052,
0.0401035771,
0.0112078553,
-0.0651975051,
0.0177137628,
0.0403676778,
-0.0095528914,
-0.0025474227,
-0.0052725375,
0.0065433029,
-0.0901842862,
0.0235523656,
-0.0291718487,
0.0214784816,
-0.0009171318,
-0.02402151,
-0.0559984446,
0.0504973605,
0.0203286037,
-0.0216465313,
-0.0164044928,
0.0087857023,
2.627e-7,
-0.0403734744,
-0.0085443454,
0.037360318,
-0.0082049714,
-0.0013351568,
0.077465497,
0.023813054,
0.0501286425,
0.0511152558,
-0.0483590141,
0.0238944925,
0.0236099213,
0.0497985668,
0.0114298947,
0.018654611,
-0.009013202,
-0.004202038,
-0.0058347844,
-0.0176996756,
0.0461013317,
0.0229859389,
0.0414743945,
0.0616965592,
0.0035146188,
0.0384581834,
0.0038638744,
0.012938126,
-0.0543908067,
-0.0015287696,
0.0097923176,
0.00107634,
0.0164803658,
0.0185366105,
0.0032895985,
0.0215432048,
-0.000224024,
-0.0167727005,
0.0660291091,
-0.0140057141,
-0.0460231118,
-0.0475213975,
0.0247648936,
0.0242623836,
-0.0194396731,
0.0688384995,
-0.0416975543,
-0.0048416764,
-0.0499334671,
0.0623379797,
-0.0223430153,
0.023493303,
0.0099656386,
-0.0198834781,
0.0306948666,
0.0358548723,
0.0131188193,
0.0244854949,
-0.0512702279,
0.0002020569,
-0.0376807116,
0.005956091,
-0.0458070524,
0.0303891841,
0.0424521826,
0.0281787105,
-0.0652569458,
0.016267797,
1.885149933e-34,
-0.0062841228,
-0.0022558267,
0.0169364791,
0.0049770484,
0.0733834431,
0.0341023169,
-0.0393008552,
-0.0164019,
0.0402469859,
-0.0059061525,
-0.029266553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08572v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08572v2 | Low-Rank Adaptation for Multilingual Summarization: An Empirical Study | 2023-11-14T22:32:39 | 2024-03-31T17:01:34 | Chenxi Whitehouse, Fantine Huot, Jasmijn Bastings, Mostafa Dehghani, Chu-Cheng Lin, Mirella Lapata | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Although the advancements of pre-trained Large Language Models have
significantly accelerated recent progress in NLP, their ever-increasing size
poses significant challenges for conventional fine-tuning, especially in
memory-intensive tasks. We investigate the potential of Parameter-Efficient
Fine-Tuning, focusing on Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA), in the domain of
multilingual summarization, a task that is both challenging (due to typically
long inputs), and relatively unexplored. We conduct an extensive study across
different data availability scenarios, including high- and low-data settings,
and cross-lingual transfer, leveraging models of different sizes. Our findings
reveal that LoRA is competitive with full fine-tuning when trained with high
quantities of data, and excels in low-data scenarios and cross-lingual
transfer. We also study different strategies for few-shot cross-lingual
transfer, finding that continued LoRA tuning outperforms full fine-tuning and
the dynamic composition of language-specific LoRA modules. | [
0.0331469923,
0.0400080346,
0.0220897924,
0.0381414704,
0.0349747501,
0.0175445806,
-0.0229056273,
-0.0171605702,
-0.0153758517,
-0.0426761545,
-0.0508010834,
-0.0202342253,
0.0118093891,
-0.015521287,
0.0199819338,
-0.0703638941,
0.0343983732,
-0.0663143918,
-0.0145815751,
-0.0191886276,
0.0098084351,
0.010191489,
0.029478116,
0.006269522,
0.061538171,
-0.0052927788,
-0.0008772225,
-0.0050547491,
0.0447671115,
0.0136885131,
0.0033134739,
0.0387721919,
0.0279395934,
0.0259941686,
0.0000018763,
-0.0607466809,
-0.0525790192,
-0.0308192987,
-0.0027553344,
0.03378262,
0.0082225045,
-0.0421113893,
0.0070088538,
0.0083722435,
0.0060056578,
-0.0006814275,
0.0361614674,
0.0221717879,
0.0616412275,
0.0791427791,
-0.0036051378,
-0.0269164648,
0.0219447222,
-0.0659628287,
-0.0548322834,
-0.0670541525,
0.0049363258,
0.0089248298,
-0.0518725179,
-0.0213095788,
-0.0331320986,
0.0310919806,
-0.0209995192,
0.0184431709,
-0.0347150639,
0.0080622416,
-0.0689821467,
0.0006944332,
-0.0024673967,
0.0897195563,
-0.071062021,
0.0071462118,
0.0108969491,
-0.0056296447,
0.0045551462,
-0.0474120714,
-0.0596402101,
0.0382015184,
0.0502906777,
0.0241137426,
0.0139492396,
0.0205640309,
0.0051952335,
0.0145224566,
-0.0714008287,
-0.0100934561,
0.0272733029,
-0.01306892,
-0.0180920251,
0.0017815442,
-0.0258087814,
-0.0252879467,
-0.0008971776,
0.0270797797,
-0.0223123878,
-0.008065735,
-0.0658736452,
-0.0648605675,
0.0289714038,
-0.0377861261,
0.0504922383,
0.0253552794,
0.0027774484,
0.0571459234,
-0.0433122516,
0.0339755714,
-0.000652138,
0.0203630403,
-0.041688785,
-0.0264431592,
-0.0054015983,
0.017153332,
-0.0203731507,
0.0208390784,
-0.0555197336,
-0.0006148478,
-0.0288490616,
0.0180111844,
0.0095072091,
-0.002324159,
-0.0101619922,
-0.0240251347,
-0.014566578,
-0.0299691651,
0.0077589811,
0.0831683055,
-0.0156421792,
-0.021414211,
0.0089329295,
-0.0152769173,
-0.0329783894,
0.0072530257,
0.0479140766,
-0.0369733013,
0.0427965969,
0.0473196171,
-0.0414706767,
-0.03981198,
-0.0045327949,
0.0159438085,
-0.019442495,
-0.0855133235,
0.0093074953,
-0.0612878725,
0.0400365889,
0.0037245997,
0.043135535,
-0.010881206,
-0.0124715427,
0.0115580531,
-0.0693006814,
0.0306537282,
0.0199547634,
-0.0039427574,
-0.0202802643,
-0.0248698406,
0.0445882529,
0.0652883276,
0.0240307208,
0.016613517,
0.0456772745,
-0.0018595145,
-0.0490918308,
0.0574870035,
0.001488617,
0.0323695466,
0.007160394,
0.011049998,
0.0113858674,
-0.0189138688,
0.0531478748,
0.0222490691,
-0.019421028,
0.0101491231,
0.0549597181,
0.035022866,
0.0583255515,
0.0388917811,
0.0257931482,
-0.0273053981,
0.0059478809,
0.0404390916,
0.0011326197,
0.0487947203,
-0.056440223,
0.0394351706,
0.0865893513,
0.0996451005,
-0.0313664339,
-0.0376808792,
-0.0027146649,
-0.0069903624,
-0.0065531088,
0.0200246293,
0.0315366499,
0.011031366,
-0.0231328309,
0.0446180813,
0.0333382264,
-0.0402039438,
0.0191533882,
-0.040474683,
0.0033446075,
0.0477202311,
0.0123536959,
-0.0444497056,
-0.02161243,
-0.0080951573,
0.0333096534,
0.0251931623,
0.0679924563,
0.0072397059,
0.0454189666,
-0.0509147421,
-0.0036383502,
-0.0215552375,
0.0175248124,
0.0434495062,
-0.0277632643,
0.0144727957,
0.030600382,
-0.0100771459,
-0.062868014,
-0.0081621055,
-0.0561172441,
-0.0185730476,
0.0034448672,
-0.0009718965,
0.0064616883,
0.0082073333,
-0.0175054427,
-0.0079115452,
0.0103970133,
-0.0479095578,
0.0298019741,
-0.0165791977,
-0.0319317579,
-0.0329825655,
0.0202171449,
-0.0080655236,
0.0147078065,
0.0453454405,
-0.0378341153,
-0.0408410244,
0.0215524733,
-0.0071260692,
-0.0059982045,
-0.0325852893,
0.0224083792,
0.0146700945,
0.0779116973,
-0.0236155018,
0.047820501,
0.0247907862,
0.0255567711,
0.0714029372,
-0.0151623553,
0.0177025925,
-0.0236157421,
-0.0524640642,
0.071477741,
0.0054029152,
0.0313850492,
0.0444981493,
0.0405500755,
-0.0215122942,
-0.0147750499,
-0.0782857314,
0.0306047164,
-0.0375561677,
0.0190347247,
0.037254937,
0.0391231738,
0.0099958461,
-0.0105645675,
-0.0388015397,
0.0011500943,
0.0226497538,
0.0279147103,
0.0169213656,
0.0047560292,
0.0616688542,
-0.0584454499,
-0.0310462136,
0.0433765613,
0.0630815327,
-0.0552966669,
-0.0324987918,
-0.0360369794,
0.028013017,
-0.0589252859,
-0.0033790146,
-0.0091298185,
-0.028814327,
-0.0646435097,
-0.0238667317,
0.0912131518,
0.0106269475,
0.0138894152,
-0.0311289113,
0.0654491931,
-0.0188198704,
-0.017711306,
0.0114592779,
0.0209938604,
-0.0284368601,
-0.0305504277,
0.0143402489,
0.0095156468,
0.042879682,
-0.027816778,
-0.0255726278,
-0.0468540266,
-0.0033268342,
-0.0187302865,
-0.0012063432,
-0.0384556241,
0.0356856734,
-0.0047453232,
0.0004471688,
-0.025577968,
0.0283703599,
0.0483680293,
-0.0190307572,
-0.0097504482,
-0.054678157,
-0.0265805535,
-0.0782033652,
0.0044901636,
0.0011681877,
0.0275031291,
-0.0433373451,
-0.0024761001,
-0.0437695161,
-0.0174312815,
0.001772103,
-0.0107107582,
0.0655735061,
-0.0356945731,
-0.0099201091,
-0.069484815,
-0.0391012542,
0.0337345339,
-0.0494164191,
-0.0080066947,
0.0280751213,
0.0224805269,
0.0020405988,
-0.0211816244,
0.0044423188,
0.0575196855,
0.0907234251,
-0.0315704457,
0.0052491347,
-0.0325935297,
0.069748804,
0.0661830306,
0.0621705651,
0.0307235047,
-0.0456190668,
0.0429615527,
0.0091909012,
0.0377366096,
-0.0185517054,
0.0209820643,
0.0220782757,
0.039890714,
-0.0229217559,
-0.0034415573,
-0.0133049879,
0.0675156191,
-0.0245656017,
-0.0076163481,
0.076906167,
-0.0128461579,
-0.057166297,
-0.0136917653,
-0.0233939681,
0.0481991731,
0.018254146,
0.0355675779,
-0.0476913564,
-0.0155188078,
-0.0115009025,
-0.0049737929,
0.0325680673,
-0.0233527981,
-0.0082524046,
-0.102641426,
-0.0098810215,
0.0126540773,
-0.0626568124,
-0.0424738117,
-0.027527174,
0.0104783922,
-0.0087115401,
0.0572751984,
-0.0026846931,
-0.0461062752,
-0.0097595686,
0.015441196,
-0.0490804166,
-0.0236629546,
0.0048482507,
-0.0382577665,
0.0122679351,
0.0381003432,
0.0419169217,
-0.023267908,
0.037989594,
0.0323047265,
-0.061841771,
-0.0040211771,
-0.0058484166,
0.0500472337,
0.0267701298,
-0.0316713229,
0.0330748744,
-0.0008752788,
0.012218765,
-0.0133218961,
0.0115008894,
0.0364108197,
0.0467007011,
-0.0119095575,
0.0191167351,
0.0116975568,
-0.0413683616,
0.0513668396,
0.0223702975,
-0.0175074153,
-0.0196807701,
-0.0047706733,
-0.0134813217,
-0.0752766132,
-0.0463180542,
0.0076175751,
-0.0552848987,
0.0142827798,
-0.0529340245,
-0.0473026559,
0.0355110653,
-0.0024850371,
-0.0111254314,
0.0134574566,
-0.0342688747,
0.006570952,
-0.0070024566,
0.0113387583,
-0.0477553383,
-0.0311832633,
-0.0286600366,
0.0024306173,
0.0362961516,
-0.0336170755,
-0.0094529213,
0.0007499867,
-0.0475703701,
-0.0471490771,
-0.0273988564,
0.066397436,
0.0092151649,
0.0449132547,
0.0182385221,
-0.0573845468,
0.0481914654,
0.0083755711,
0.0304688793,
0.0611189455,
0.041264493,
0.021709634,
-0.0205383841,
0.0576543063,
-0.0726337135,
0.0149373477,
0.0046749446,
0.058558628,
-0.0053211423,
-0.0453936458,
-0.0061391508,
0.0507406928,
-0.0105225649,
0.0021772829,
-0.0351855755,
-0.0474485382,
0.0195923354,
-0.0416495502,
-0.0168889128,
-0.0307673607,
-0.0016833526,
0.008293923,
-0.0182962324,
-0.0234492049,
0.0501104482,
0.0329226069,
-0.0035837744,
-0.0818086788,
-0.0105767716,
-0.0052761612,
-0.0372972637,
-0.004561231,
0.0215415042,
-0.0558006391,
-0.0129000666,
0.0132497977,
-0.0058161076,
-0.0485349298,
-0.0234776139,
0.0061170566,
-0.0113617051,
-0.0394294225,
0.0429798774,
-0.055925969,
-0.0362651162,
-0.0408541001,
0.0120617636,
0.0709918737,
-0.0311261807,
0.1122058928,
0.0306186434,
-0.0281612948,
-0.0192937888,
-0.0076468545,
0.0306349769,
0.0220478494,
-0.0469556674,
0.0120479343,
0.0101975054,
0.039895393,
0.0939364359,
-0.0023313407,
0.0364493802,
0.0003486837,
0.006081935,
-0.0434143506,
-0.0270189214,
-0.0306942817,
0.0200536866,
0.0105235167,
-0.0066114655,
-0.0114652719,
-0.0288384594,
0.0034373575,
-0.0242855344,
-0.005946049,
-0.0209027287,
-0.00542551,
0.0464480594,
-0.0020630963,
0.0214604996,
-0.0365555696,
-0.0445843413,
0.0495780297,
0.0248640981,
0.035985779,
-6.266226103e-33,
-0.0308610983,
0.0505979508,
0.0022626382,
-0.0136421304,
-0.022283297,
0.0026438367,
-0.0453888439,
-0.0155926915,
-0.0265407003,
-0.0183933135,
-0.0274584498,
-0.0093192803,
0.0106171062,
0.0393885635,
0.0185125992,
0.0179765858,
0.0518133603,
0.0189810991,
-0.0273698922,
0.0382976457,
0.0427857228,
0.0255157501,
0.07769081,
0.0129875056,
0.0045878296,
-0.0029992161,
-0.0210224967,
-0.0125617227,
0.0219070315,
0.0243837889,
-0.0229736194,
0.0328136086,
0.0355357453,
-0.0329181775,
-0.0410461575,
-0.0097322715,
-0.0973282829,
-0.0442634337,
0.0356865451,
-0.0281790867,
-0.0205042399,
-0.0487934053,
0.0312257167,
-0.0123533811,
0.0381475575,
-0.06351991,
0.0425396487,
-0.0639098883,
-0.0189790856,
-0.0604040027,
-0.0632177442,
0.0205237847,
-0.0239057466,
-0.0111932606,
0.0381738432,
0.0765267834,
-0.008066982,
0.0352176614,
-0.0425892062,
0.0245751683,
0.0018051402,
0.0731767416,
0.0338737853,
-0.0009827283,
-0.0378508791,
0.0480148904,
-0.0194845069,
0.0178609714,
0.0554129072,
-0.0009208129,
0.0018577512,
0.0154008502,
0.0032326656,
0.051930286,
0.0118021248,
0.0214821417,
-0.0651521385,
0.0166055206,
-0.0202653334,
-0.0104870759,
0.0398703218,
-0.0061044851,
0.0130264666,
-0.0142335566,
-0.0369898379,
0.0199825242,
-0.0356807597,
0.006536331,
0.0001196212,
0.0456409827,
-0.0320832804,
0.0055049052,
0.063120544,
-0.0123270089,
-0.0012106813,
0.0222887322,
-0.0164150987,
0.0033189263,
0.0192877315,
0.0121572046,
-0.023336323,
-0.0195099711,
0.0153449746,
-0.0396981798,
-0.0047390335,
-0.0090440884,
0.060538955,
0.0207526386,
-0.063159138,
0.0056883949,
0.0026561804,
0.0297560655,
-0.0388863534,
0.0669459328,
-0.0365900919,
-0.0133566316,
-0.0049996828,
0.0725065544,
0.0402927324,
-0.0130945556,
0.0332145803,
-0.0208494514,
0.0359013975,
0.0415114537,
-0.0243627243,
0.0173427723,
-0.0255749561,
0.0285973437,
0.032573428,
-0.0509321615,
-0.0165085383,
-0.0070999856,
2.574e-7,
0.0309275798,
0.0402601399,
0.0079206033,
-0.0306400005,
-0.0011978371,
0.0033788469,
-0.034624286,
0.062480092,
0.030758556,
0.0539590344,
0.017090695,
0.0296525173,
0.0461710468,
-0.0052633616,
-0.0587101504,
-0.0255160201,
-0.0774310455,
-0.0067031141,
-0.04416316,
-0.0693568289,
0.0179599635,
0.0988923907,
-0.0267744381,
-0.0086035337,
-0.0141695477,
-0.0293443259,
0.0584468022,
-0.0428222679,
-0.0566645525,
0.0099084806,
0.0571954548,
0.0126174148,
-0.0328698754,
-0.0437324792,
-0.0188348405,
0.0441806205,
0.0360492282,
0.0612996854,
0.0143353259,
-0.0229143575,
0.0562037751,
0.0147027466,
-0.0015081698,
-0.0198488142,
0.0855610222,
-0.0680906698,
-0.0151518751,
-0.018069068,
-0.0277973805,
0.0063029523,
0.0236917548,
-0.0363903306,
-0.0363625847,
0.0362588838,
0.0110030556,
0.0293385722,
-0.0337547772,
-0.0814258158,
-0.0352782197,
0.0377612896,
-0.0084885331,
-0.0517704934,
-0.0048366901,
-0.0760428384,
0.021457253,
-0.0844075903,
0.0268187243,
2.355386933e-34,
0.0862919167,
-0.0156997424,
-0.0162016898,
-0.0203164164,
0.0292683765,
-0.05021175,
-0.0065097311,
-0.0005567913,
-0.0015175847,
-0.090324752,
-0.0231609512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08562v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08562v2 | MAgIC: Investigation of Large Language Model Powered Multi-Agent in Cognition, Adaptability, Rationality and Collaboration | 2023-11-14T21:46:27 | 2023-11-16T11:40:26 | Lin Xu, Zhiyuan Hu, Daquan Zhou, Hongyu Ren, Zhen Dong, Kurt Keutzer, See Kiong Ng, Jiashi Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have marked a significant advancement in the
field of natural language processing, demonstrating exceptional capabilities in
reasoning, tool usage, and memory. As their applications extend into
multi-agent environments, a need has arisen for a comprehensive evaluation
framework that captures their abilities in reasoning, planning, collaboration,
and more. This work introduces a novel benchmarking framework specifically
tailored to assess LLMs within multi-agent settings, providing quantitative
metrics to evaluate their judgment, reasoning, deception, self-awareness,
cooperation, coordination, and rationality. We utilize games such as Chameleon
and Undercover, alongside game theory scenarios like Cost Sharing, Multi-player
Prisoner's Dilemma, and Public Good, to create diverse testing environments.
Our framework is fortified with the Probabilistic Graphical Modeling (PGM)
method, enhancing the LLMs' capabilities in navigating complex social and
cognitive dimensions. The benchmark evaluates seven multi-agent systems powered
by different LLMs, quantitatively highlighting a significant capability gap
over threefold between the strongest, GPT-4, and the weakest, Llama-2-70B. It
also confirms that our PGM enhancement boosts the inherent abilities of all
selected models by 50% on average. Our codes are released here
https://github.com/cathyxl/MAgIC. | [
0.0515515134,
0.0368859023,
-0.0399328507,
0.0573925003,
-0.1074261218,
-0.0040244861,
0.0192048326,
0.0060306215,
0.0388351232,
-0.0270902235,
-0.0269610025,
-0.0151221659,
0.0083112158,
0.0419279486,
0.0104085431,
-0.0227919258,
0.031115124,
-0.0497023761,
0.0308821779,
-0.0074280812,
-0.0212490093,
-0.0112148058,
-0.0138471844,
0.04636994,
-0.0016321419,
0.0007485184,
-0.0168577842,
-0.0215960089,
0.0481168889,
-0.0308869295,
-0.0624061562,
0.0391795337,
-0.0066417037,
0.0389654301,
0.0000022887,
-0.0844817162,
-0.0288874302,
-0.01771589,
0.0189759303,
0.0050241505,
0.0554731339,
0.0166728068,
0.0059881303,
0.0070811519,
-0.0751432925,
0.0254610479,
0.0144623341,
0.0124706961,
0.0491004325,
0.082914412,
0.0030291029,
-0.0164461154,
0.0201252997,
-0.0333107412,
-0.0401997752,
-0.108076416,
0.0318783522,
-0.0071997182,
0.0209305808,
-0.0398015641,
0.0120017612,
0.0011456873,
-0.0065924614,
-0.0220749993,
-0.0586386807,
0.0384076163,
-0.0136002144,
-0.0202980228,
-0.0086530773,
0.0515396744,
-0.0007163921,
0.0354309045,
0.0005363324,
0.0014553546,
0.008525894,
0.0580417104,
-0.0136616817,
0.0450259969,
-0.0007260005,
0.0098383166,
-0.0245572906,
0.0181810502,
0.0495262034,
0.0175980292,
-0.0154370377,
0.1019210964,
0.0071174041,
0.0050989459,
0.0074632131,
-0.0296753794,
-0.0699471533,
-0.0719883069,
-0.0219190065,
0.0429216176,
-0.0502178818,
0.0194479227,
-0.0109566832,
0.0061630094,
0.0268424135,
-0.0523378216,
0.0466067158,
0.0077067832,
0.0540317297,
0.0719723627,
0.0040054489,
0.0727247149,
-0.0039967219,
0.019628074,
-0.0048666894,
-0.0042811031,
-0.0517162085,
-0.0088901808,
-0.0264943782,
0.0299802702,
-0.0203962196,
-0.0495920666,
-0.0143861864,
0.0217846315,
-0.0503999218,
0.037129391,
0.0264528301,
0.00683627,
0.0072800624,
-0.0295844954,
-0.066830121,
-0.0034561781,
-0.0407805219,
0.0269898437,
0.0065472545,
-0.044229839,
0.0024343561,
-0.0181961693,
0.0106398165,
-0.02765017,
0.0071414704,
0.1142052636,
0.0039886972,
-0.0379479825,
-0.0012467479,
-0.0111095961,
-0.0141585767,
-0.1041648984,
-0.0259928349,
-0.0529575571,
0.0173046123,
-0.0127385855,
0.0119535597,
-0.0293136183,
0.0208858382,
-0.0118788145,
-0.0442935973,
0.0652599633,
0.0300979614,
0.0280437879,
0.0109795434,
0.0292889476,
-0.0252116323,
0.0506051779,
0.053494174,
0.0417011529,
0.0385502875,
0.0274131242,
0.0379230417,
0.0425825231,
-0.0291257892,
0.0122467643,
0.0067746262,
-0.0033791559,
0.0343341418,
0.0417790189,
-0.0112958308,
0.0645281151,
-0.0237400047,
-0.0588278323,
0.0924547687,
0.0727740899,
0.0059582074,
-0.0123127755,
0.0089395558,
0.0401732624,
0.0128888441,
-0.0450495556,
-0.0392351821,
0.0340511836,
-0.0514946915,
-0.003719649,
-0.0045112739,
0.0606846288,
0.0106797079,
-0.0028381783,
-0.0124525176,
-0.0237349793,
0.0618659295,
-0.0057380409,
0.0362015478,
-0.0417214669,
-0.0675068945,
-0.0514847562,
0.0285109133,
-0.02359467,
-0.0333715826,
-0.1060316563,
0.0302851442,
0.0780628622,
0.0681934506,
0.0145679265,
-0.0091186604,
0.001329367,
-0.0227402039,
0.0394890234,
0.0251256153,
0.0159743838,
0.0088303406,
-0.0383222252,
-0.023791045,
-0.015156568,
0.0126239927,
0.0714982748,
-0.0009154776,
0.0175335575,
-0.0109053049,
-0.0071349125,
0.0461761393,
0.0200922415,
-0.0106094899,
0.0143962493,
-0.038024798,
-0.011251362,
0.0706162229,
-0.0128664896,
-0.0337936245,
0.0169831831,
0.0256986078,
-0.0023138681,
-0.0136865051,
0.0239480101,
0.020009188,
0.0054486254,
0.0281988382,
-0.0217202567,
0.0318263732,
0.0233144201,
0.0170952193,
-0.0129017532,
0.0553601831,
-0.0316316895,
0.0310796089,
-0.0289503448,
0.0210683104,
-0.0354431495,
0.0065480089,
-0.0097849667,
0.0610949993,
-0.0073385737,
-0.0268323291,
-0.0335884206,
0.0056151394,
0.036091052,
-0.0372895934,
0.0214312095,
0.0215011798,
0.0282024033,
0.0149906976,
0.0100355465,
0.0090108579,
-0.0298581608,
-0.0810398161,
-0.0920598134,
0.0042864638,
0.0008286735,
0.0013327147,
-0.0207475405,
-0.0430816561,
-0.0355152637,
0.0373041555,
-0.0206077397,
0.0456296168,
0.0212191865,
0.0146347396,
-0.0188131146,
0.0247502513,
-0.0470941402,
-0.0230839383,
0.0190317258,
-0.0026395652,
0.0532803908,
0.0399022028,
-0.0062121195,
-0.0007131763,
0.0120172109,
-0.0706764236,
0.0159501918,
-0.0474810526,
-0.0750413984,
0.0388067849,
-0.0131754838,
0.0264960304,
0.0464535989,
0.0158693958,
0.0121592777,
0.0574340709,
-0.0487598926,
-0.0510783494,
0.0263078194,
-0.0337737463,
-0.011558597,
-0.0853555128,
-0.0645810068,
-0.0139655862,
0.0807518736,
-0.0100660436,
0.0064460235,
-0.0429851189,
0.0282059126,
0.0092343967,
-0.0549197458,
0.0079526659,
-0.0471198782,
-0.0028875479,
0.0206948332,
-0.0200193208,
-0.0247358903,
0.0808146298,
-0.0335968807,
0.0252435599,
-0.016983252,
-0.0047203256,
-0.0288153887,
0.1105214208,
0.0299221836,
0.003896645,
-0.0157488082,
0.0228142031,
-0.0286554173,
-0.0455873832,
0.0558700487,
-0.0405868888,
-0.0175838973,
-0.0743888095,
0.0140701486,
0.0200201813,
0.0135809416,
-0.0132570649,
-0.0040146918,
-0.0769330487,
0.0059516015,
0.0233099107,
-0.0425950438,
-0.0608202443,
0.0379355438,
0.0367223956,
-0.0164386518,
0.0052158777,
-0.0047822227,
-0.0220199358,
-0.0265044272,
0.034596242,
0.0148975262,
0.0220111199,
-0.0483454429,
0.0271100383,
0.0455827862,
-0.0006144034,
-0.0272012167,
0.0168624464,
-0.0044288943,
-0.0032545782,
0.0004566704,
-0.0073289443,
0.0269999541,
0.0149005679,
-0.0357655957,
0.0069154012,
0.0828998536,
0.0359119959,
-0.0328977406,
0.0002247129,
-0.0276562329,
-0.0020899572,
0.0186835304,
0.0016607688,
-0.0526576489,
-0.0327113904,
0.021966802,
-0.0068326066,
-0.0215873383,
-0.0834960863,
-0.0009530293,
-0.1024833694,
0.0244846698,
-0.0016113675,
-0.0035738798,
0.0000877393,
-0.0536788814,
0.0041078241,
-0.0291767754,
-0.0040991181,
-0.017163584,
0.0412356295,
-0.0164209586,
-0.0002211466,
-0.0274426453,
0.0156301893,
0.0281249601,
-0.0441768132,
0.0617384464,
0.0655387193,
0.0388553478,
-0.0105515169,
-0.0567881986,
0.0050454326,
0.0491601378,
0.0101662073,
0.0184140038,
0.0239927731,
-0.0103077451,
0.0186420027,
-0.0027180174,
-0.0189038273,
0.0047482359,
-0.0481549315,
0.0473666675,
0.04578631,
-0.0093901642,
-0.059446726,
0.005985647,
0.022152992,
0.0216470286,
0.0860691816,
-0.0046540536,
-0.021320885,
-0.0406713597,
-0.0270961057,
-0.0020107611,
-0.0559043884,
-0.0550332107,
-0.0100152493,
0.0574390665,
0.0153834987,
-0.0379824489,
-0.0388897397,
0.0243714415,
0.0121130487,
0.004447828,
-0.001053819,
0.004728172,
0.0343556628,
-0.0171591211,
-0.0155458683,
-0.0313855745,
0.0349007919,
-0.0309670381,
-0.0175593104,
-0.012463077,
-0.0304705892,
-0.0048857764,
0.0306573771,
-0.0864051282,
-0.0527512655,
0.0221315902,
0.0392643437,
0.0294117667,
-0.0286090225,
-0.0246743597,
-0.029221246,
-0.0033458446,
-0.0026776972,
-0.0443839617,
0.0589218698,
0.0005702341,
0.0410176069,
0.0309742019,
0.0395482555,
-0.0165673178,
0.0131013142,
0.0156487562,
0.0643245503,
-0.0565323345,
-0.0604921207,
-0.011037251,
-0.002287714,
-0.0134893656,
-0.0136223435,
-0.0093114125,
-0.0124735255,
0.0016218266,
-0.0665241554,
-0.0069871866,
-0.0322079509,
-0.042927146,
0.0359581597,
0.0040515205,
0.0261743609,
0.0142820645,
0.0008855356,
-0.0147031462,
0.0278083924,
-0.0143717239,
0.0340176858,
-0.0407104604,
0.0183330718,
0.0040760697,
0.0036655965,
-0.021592373,
-0.032708887,
0.0412468426,
0.0435722768,
0.0623075776,
0.0059653441,
-0.0775966868,
-0.0127929784,
0.0231822114,
-0.0516925901,
-0.059524104,
0.0814789757,
0.0892337635,
0.0525123067,
0.037028119,
0.0371941552,
-0.0636826456,
0.01836651,
-0.0253767874,
0.0174680576,
-6.978e-7,
-0.0564760193,
0.0168200713,
0.028479686,
-0.032176964,
0.0301240813,
0.0495005026,
0.0065533943,
0.0414467789,
-0.0071528498,
-0.0325544551,
-0.0280808844,
-0.036795225,
-0.0105716055,
0.0468705371,
-0.0276569519,
0.0014815285,
-0.1025776789,
-0.0242996998,
-0.0188578703,
0.0388618782,
0.0247328188,
-0.0153875351,
0.0133746807,
0.0492452569,
-0.0075275586,
-0.0152723147,
-0.0537576154,
0.0241666641,
-0.0174657162,
0.0107792839,
0.0109410211,
-6.623040801e-33,
-0.0211151745,
-0.0476411469,
0.0300832875,
-0.0192751735,
-0.0079464316,
-0.0322770216,
-0.0362816304,
0.0178413875,
-0.0413575992,
-0.0008432592,
0.0042483341,
-0.0064456826,
0.013199768,
-0.0250342302,
-0.0467101634,
0.0007643185,
-0.0124836443,
-0.0007871679,
-0.0505274273,
-0.0046066805,
0.0132423891,
-0.0029893962,
0.0174750127,
-0.0593436807,
-0.000404765,
0.0095909797,
-0.0424909852,
0.0201959275,
-0.0268585701,
0.0392266251,
-0.025990732,
-0.0231802333,
0.019671455,
0.0134406369,
0.0164992716,
0.002892463,
0.0123730516,
-0.0031293558,
0.0319074169,
-0.0248137899,
-0.0135506988,
-0.0437481664,
-0.005543103,
0.0230097696,
-0.0445965156,
0.0038184295,
0.0279776715,
-0.0321215577,
-0.0253805611,
0.0333934538,
-0.031623885,
0.0327688232,
-0.0333622135,
0.001752296,
-0.0343077853,
-0.0336649492,
-0.0132720191,
0.0140780592,
-0.0487557352,
0.0504409522,
0.0118212812,
-0.0364711843,
0.0577888153,
0.0225602984,
0.0382684581,
0.0899606571,
0.0229405072,
0.0307841636,
-0.0517468452,
-0.0123982504,
0.0192018412,
0.0658719465,
0.0637179613,
0.0749225542,
-0.0427259319,
-0.0179772265,
-0.0824720338,
0.0271806195,
0.0713402107,
0.0239901859,
0.0646741912,
0.0231373701,
-0.025408471,
-0.0046902685,
-0.0305068232,
0.0327795409,
-0.0211873408,
-0.0365256965,
0.0250359178,
0.0054733362,
0.0040792199,
-0.0033501887,
0.0416578054,
-0.0299061313,
-0.0159198865,
0.0164495017,
-0.0061803688,
0.0290050898,
-0.0108010862,
0.0334172621,
-0.0589025468,
-0.0140953427,
0.0137203829,
-0.0016148009,
0.0323738158,
-0.0142619926,
-0.007133028,
0.0068904916,
-0.0320627652,
0.0100339809,
-0.031726189,
0.0265219826,
0.0168260634,
-0.0214679465,
0.0290484801,
-0.0380196832,
-0.0054966928,
-0.0535514876,
0.0128385322,
-0.0446914174,
-0.016628379,
0.0246978384,
-0.0242120288,
-0.006536901,
-0.0038142365,
0.0216904152,
-0.0470191538,
0.0145907542,
0.0056969523,
-0.0009825664,
-0.0243041161,
-0.0231065378,
3.071e-7,
0.0227018874,
0.0445180014,
-0.0247174781,
0.0141209858,
-0.0056593381,
0.067786999,
-0.0565206222,
0.0331990458,
0.0086409859,
-0.0198356733,
0.018913148,
0.0634324923,
0.0403185561,
0.0426089875,
-0.0254265927,
0.0174437761,
-0.0102196019,
-0.0269086603,
-0.0551912002,
-0.0090377554,
0.0381688885,
0.0544999465,
0.0812727883,
0.0307673719,
-0.0064889286,
-0.0919781774,
0.034444239,
-0.079843916,
-0.0233579464,
0.0266848281,
0.0043395949,
-0.0138580259,
-0.0242913309,
0.0225966629,
0.0331348032,
0.0171403885,
-0.0374209099,
0.0434672721,
-0.0085472129,
-0.0380893871,
-0.007230957,
-0.056676995,
-0.0002748093,
-0.0654721856,
0.0705457777,
-0.0130515611,
-0.0601858757,
0.0234938152,
-0.0169703811,
-0.0316586159,
0.0142101152,
-0.0070835347,
-0.0416516922,
0.0171447806,
0.0059941458,
0.0007627101,
0.020618869,
-0.0422365218,
0.0022819166,
-0.0257100854,
-0.0410083197,
-0.0857267231,
-0.0353690162,
0.0407758392,
0.0337307379,
-0.0193430986,
0.018373467,
2.754259717e-34,
0.0247373115,
0.0010100149,
-0.0231619999,
0.0018820819,
0.0770101175,
0.0157079212,
-0.0342647173,
0.0211619418,
0.0214464497,
-0.0858237222,
0.0127794603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08552v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08552v1 | UT5: Pretraining Non autoregressive T5 with unrolled denoising | 2023-11-14T21:28:10 | 2023-11-14T21:28:10 | Mahmoud G. Salem, Jiayu Ye, Chu-Cheng Lin, Frederick Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in Transformer-based Large Language Models have made great
strides in natural language generation. However, to decode K tokens, an
autoregressive model needs K sequential forward passes, which may be a
performance bottleneck for large language models. Many non-autoregressive (NAR)
research are aiming to address this sequentiality bottleneck, albeit many have
focused on a dedicated architecture in supervised benchmarks. In this work, we
studied unsupervised pretraining for non auto-regressive T5 models via unrolled
denoising and shown its SoTA results in downstream generation tasks such as
SQuAD question generation and XSum. | [
0.011320821,
0.0824822709,
0.0102110058,
0.0108367084,
0.0106433313,
-0.0008007138,
0.048929885,
-0.0226244889,
-0.0448077805,
-0.0254666861,
-0.0396759249,
-0.0391185917,
0.0011110666,
0.0696718842,
0.0240908433,
-0.0148296151,
0.0288573932,
-0.0360507704,
-0.0026787079,
-0.0305049047,
-0.0365873016,
-0.0024143842,
-0.0184461176,
0.0438230969,
-0.0079327663,
-0.0250456054,
-0.0298939794,
-0.0015092178,
-0.0212607738,
-0.0115643628,
0.013600098,
0.0884145573,
0.0147610018,
0.0208863597,
0.0000020483,
-0.0024186119,
-0.0201668385,
-0.0292885844,
-0.018761849,
0.0310304668,
0.005864332,
-0.004380838,
0.0182034187,
0.0402247831,
-0.0212211851,
-0.0660652295,
0.0486381501,
0.047112599,
0.1107781753,
0.0764019787,
0.0043091998,
-0.0457119532,
0.0137466127,
-0.0572506525,
-0.0207662359,
-0.0438887216,
-0.0108286589,
-0.0245669689,
-0.0145355435,
0.0136529561,
-0.026795039,
0.0306874532,
0.0477286242,
-0.0067467224,
0.0108722169,
0.0315439329,
-0.0046667997,
-0.046392519,
-0.0052649155,
0.0635707229,
-0.0011211762,
-0.0235242285,
0.0089518921,
0.0051603401,
-0.0253506973,
0.0045587262,
-0.0063902591,
0.0360373557,
0.0214614086,
0.0155251613,
0.0251902826,
0.0183997713,
0.0159965158,
0.0108788284,
-0.0344738923,
0.0148737384,
0.027737068,
-0.0262015387,
-0.0192438103,
0.0224697422,
-0.0180444457,
-0.0515596606,
0.0144417686,
0.0226244573,
-0.0848874524,
-0.0089229299,
-0.0653923675,
-0.0217990074,
-0.0013014551,
0.0583863892,
0.0587098412,
0.0276638959,
0.0039069322,
-0.0127940485,
-0.0157111716,
0.0271707457,
-0.0347179621,
-0.0178279374,
-0.0694810674,
-0.0009718258,
-0.003242698,
-0.037795715,
-0.04731654,
0.0415405892,
-0.0678564459,
-0.0302486848,
-0.0522504263,
0.0205958653,
0.0345200859,
-0.0626288131,
0.0388068296,
0.0175966416,
-0.0906937197,
-0.00325513,
0.0201128311,
0.0338548608,
-0.011407855,
-0.0114591783,
0.0227246638,
-0.0509090647,
-0.0237665046,
0.0022800346,
0.0118102515,
-0.0198781677,
-0.0158806071,
-0.0164249111,
-0.0397365019,
-0.0128422836,
-0.0190726817,
-0.0605811179,
-0.0225061271,
-0.0728667825,
0.0332679749,
-0.0472639911,
0.0152016068,
0.0114091616,
-0.0022376175,
0.0061795646,
0.0053198864,
0.0138682351,
0.0085905623,
0.0309249051,
-0.0035353198,
0.0152546978,
-0.0063562142,
0.0008455642,
0.0681279749,
0.0530511141,
0.0137316762,
0.0573835187,
-0.0216338206,
0.0048712115,
-0.0056147203,
0.0243865177,
0.0509758405,
-0.0174500756,
-0.0445970818,
-0.0179363675,
-0.01575334,
0.037506748,
0.0517085418,
0.0526870489,
-0.0157058034,
-0.0114044966,
0.0671605915,
0.0228932276,
0.0776399672,
0.0011163364,
0.0681717545,
-0.0077869166,
-0.0265935734,
0.0242319312,
-0.0223194379,
0.0393110067,
0.012107526,
0.0285629835,
0.0209210888,
0.0675080419,
-0.0651605725,
-0.017614739,
0.037935771,
-0.0069877184,
-0.0095477188,
0.0036422203,
0.0431454964,
0.0444048271,
-0.0502312705,
0.0659255385,
-0.0144800907,
-0.0758493915,
0.0268271193,
-0.0434031896,
0.0579917766,
-0.0053843805,
0.0589458458,
0.0185828172,
-0.0464087203,
-0.0137818167,
-0.0106260031,
0.0821271539,
0.0384079255,
0.0112230694,
0.0326985493,
-0.061916925,
-0.0215521473,
-0.0330909304,
0.0091966456,
0.0215974469,
-0.0260940716,
0.0120898951,
0.0427615158,
-0.0161844306,
-0.0126767131,
0.0451460779,
-0.0422128923,
-0.0392546803,
0.0462320596,
0.014015872,
0.0255623162,
0.0105373655,
-0.0156623423,
0.0194635354,
0.0312751494,
-0.0457185619,
0.0070448555,
0.0008532819,
-0.1440568566,
-0.0837878585,
0.0225132518,
-0.0265785009,
-0.0039268979,
0.0830664709,
-0.0153876143,
-0.0491997302,
0.0604013875,
-0.0231179092,
0.0332576036,
-0.0764619708,
0.0120301181,
0.0534695573,
0.0437978245,
0.002759242,
0.0570757799,
-0.0093409345,
-0.0152839376,
0.014094715,
0.0289429799,
-0.0077940635,
0.0041262661,
-0.0266409405,
0.0053640958,
-0.0079944693,
-0.0219404418,
0.0219460037,
0.0305677932,
-0.033916384,
-0.0232369527,
-0.0770726874,
0.0068292776,
-0.035258878,
-0.0142403021,
0.0109882504,
0.0610367991,
0.0032914653,
-0.0244565178,
-0.0539215393,
-0.002136895,
0.0695282146,
0.0130599365,
0.0059590936,
0.0140160723,
0.0104222428,
0.0004165213,
-0.0209399369,
0.0105903847,
0.0364520475,
0.0161698647,
-0.0098896427,
-0.015658142,
0.049277328,
-0.0078927539,
0.0090218335,
0.0196688939,
-0.0582923852,
0.0268211421,
-0.0038076732,
0.0928886905,
0.0376583487,
0.043481674,
0.0327731781,
-0.011643488,
-0.0273799505,
0.0009320724,
0.0150830057,
-0.0530146323,
-0.0286552347,
-0.0007037036,
-0.016908465,
0.0367943794,
0.0890920311,
0.0295194555,
0.0043321997,
-0.0727326274,
0.0221314039,
-0.0232203137,
-0.0490540117,
-0.0187541731,
-0.0116513669,
-0.0317277126,
0.0323974192,
-0.0220700372,
-0.0063118841,
0.0434491672,
-0.0308397897,
-0.0455549359,
-0.0497345887,
0.0245305002,
-0.0274523199,
0.0361728556,
0.0559100658,
0.0184830446,
0.0452280492,
-0.0598963685,
-0.0124421241,
0.0371508077,
-0.0026544328,
-0.0246442016,
0.0444334447,
-0.0149194645,
-0.0002116062,
0.000749802,
-0.0248321109,
-0.0454223342,
-0.0621644892,
0.0392570533,
0.0036567966,
0.0307159685,
-0.015075339,
-0.0256590266,
0.0071556028,
0.0057318946,
0.0701679513,
-0.0407580286,
-0.0018468075,
-0.0308580138,
0.0983226299,
0.0567853861,
0.0106768161,
0.007265849,
-0.0652590021,
0.0383864678,
0.0089158388,
0.0425631963,
0.0068144454,
-0.0252276175,
0.0098682307,
0.0134522319,
-0.0233378224,
0.0147135369,
0.0373551063,
0.0464698523,
-0.0360353515,
-0.0620460287,
0.0937941,
0.0084828837,
-0.0061110021,
0.0148675283,
0.0398070179,
0.0656038821,
0.0083155483,
-0.0191068258,
-0.0584132001,
-0.0310251378,
-0.0090047931,
0.0323800817,
0.0001043861,
-0.0282296967,
-0.0323370919,
-0.1124674752,
0.0617601201,
0.0205705557,
-0.0814208835,
0.0144660454,
-0.0091535719,
-0.0459084511,
-0.0218881164,
0.0401029624,
0.0204812344,
-0.0238320567,
0.0295359548,
0.040736828,
-0.0286218449,
-0.0632007942,
-0.0193664823,
-0.0414113402,
0.0329187587,
0.0291453134,
0.0060547213,
0.0006998235,
-0.0353737995,
0.0382436551,
-0.0375571474,
0.0275860503,
-0.0236890372,
0.0365610495,
-0.0128035462,
-0.0321761705,
-0.0148907937,
0.0320585482,
-0.0571171381,
0.0145566212,
-0.0400056951,
0.0611357316,
-0.0095981807,
-0.0340742841,
0.0066164415,
0.0273263399,
0.0043396968,
0.0613105372,
0.0382346362,
-0.0363698304,
-0.0274077449,
0.0037860638,
0.0654344708,
-0.0842224583,
-0.0500773601,
-0.0070859469,
0.0126188938,
-0.0567653477,
-0.085438244,
-0.079388395,
0.0098423222,
0.0638671443,
-0.0240189712,
-0.0036015336,
-0.0140124159,
-0.0254528038,
-0.0357950926,
0.0178396571,
-0.0161080379,
-0.038438268,
-0.0570711717,
-0.0280479044,
0.0288993679,
-0.0109349126,
-0.0114654079,
0.0065606227,
-0.0954321027,
-0.0435629599,
0.0348047912,
0.0613969751,
0.018759001,
0.0224697832,
0.0047176233,
-0.0084096715,
0.0891698226,
0.043995209,
-0.0595083572,
-0.0072690914,
-0.0032739479,
-0.0696185455,
-0.0003202659,
0.0184469298,
-0.0270210505,
0.044293005,
0.0020035354,
0.0490072966,
0.0162825808,
-0.0335263237,
0.0582496673,
0.0064200633,
0.0196910929,
-0.0244185515,
0.0178695805,
-0.0174806565,
-0.0099615678,
-0.0366492234,
-0.003085979,
-0.0492218435,
0.0203405079,
0.0454994366,
0.0200216826,
-0.0021761211,
0.0333772972,
-0.0215080697,
0.0674472079,
-0.0126566561,
-0.0037125743,
0.0343721025,
0.0119438963,
0.0075792354,
0.0037069989,
-0.0241853762,
-0.0200739428,
0.0157809835,
0.0378784947,
-0.0084202616,
0.0605235547,
-0.0009025601,
0.033425834,
-0.024221424,
0.0245501511,
-0.0469044074,
-0.0350129642,
-0.0435086675,
-0.0547132194,
0.0306199063,
-0.0108760176,
0.0477731787,
-0.0311399158,
0.0247186758,
-0.01189363,
0.0309625771,
-0.0140726194,
-0.0091997907,
0.0153534226,
-0.0062425067,
-0.0252487399,
0.0088457111,
0.097474128,
-0.0012356497,
0.0236864872,
0.034473259,
0.0279348753,
-0.0568449721,
-0.0443663262,
0.016479481,
-0.0059944061,
-0.0353506543,
0.0122668566,
0.0250128824,
-0.0457626656,
0.0030427356,
-0.0138241518,
0.0115168598,
-0.0053228573,
0.0340841003,
0.0503560826,
-0.0121045746,
-0.025948802,
-0.0419149138,
0.0263164844,
0.0181845129,
-0.0044844514,
-0.0144957602,
-7.339351794e-33,
-0.0392267257,
-0.0229217317,
0.0173322726,
-0.0231746994,
-0.0489595197,
-0.0020723459,
-0.0353378952,
-0.0046312483,
0.0245174188,
-0.003355253,
-0.0163927991,
0.0108072544,
0.0171972755,
0.0470334664,
0.0071156714,
0.0195084028,
0.0847809166,
-0.047413785,
-0.0159506518,
0.0637197942,
0.0050156009,
0.0430942364,
0.0034718437,
-0.0088821519,
-0.0302084424,
-0.0174960457,
-0.005289604,
-0.0152991591,
0.0150251202,
0.0272145756,
-0.0447416343,
-0.0075708339,
0.0243558791,
-0.0501524955,
-0.0293688923,
0.0337001719,
-0.0511994734,
0.0147452932,
-0.0177851785,
0.0092080366,
-0.0369857475,
-0.0173161477,
0.0210741088,
-0.0094717285,
-0.0123946769,
0.0024758142,
0.0022321336,
0.0126239369,
-0.0107233664,
-0.0445876233,
-0.0739910826,
-0.001522789,
-0.0145902028,
-0.0537776239,
-0.0086822528,
0.1059238017,
-0.0189113244,
0.0040377062,
-0.0327886268,
0.0176403038,
0.0157506932,
0.0472602956,
0.0347111449,
0.0355106667,
-0.0062468708,
0.0242021978,
0.0325943083,
-0.0260456223,
-0.0316253938,
-0.0153937656,
0.040949747,
0.0221046638,
0.0116011463,
0.0026110481,
0.046294596,
0.0045240568,
-0.0462508872,
0.0229442194,
-0.0114551615,
0.0488650613,
0.0244045351,
-0.0048463284,
0.0135354046,
-0.017757412,
0.0032994917,
-0.0417166315,
-0.0260577537,
-0.0319881327,
0.0537968315,
0.0390254483,
-0.0203756075,
-0.032144174,
0.0669180453,
-0.0136649627,
0.0524285436,
0.0391936153,
-0.0031877856,
-0.0071450649,
-0.0397783481,
0.0330398567,
-0.0807975456,
0.0009529517,
0.0493678302,
0.0295337494,
-0.0099266609,
-0.0025097707,
-0.0229744781,
0.0503111556,
-0.0586714484,
0.0015504792,
-0.0222486984,
0.0405843966,
-0.0100827841,
0.0006626908,
0.0696635097,
-0.0403811559,
-0.0193165224,
0.0318914056,
-0.022327181,
-0.0034303509,
-0.0120543083,
0.0117097432,
0.050599061,
0.0248755924,
-0.0085050622,
0.003149336,
-0.028617166,
0.0387497991,
0.0200703871,
-0.0276136268,
-0.0141743599,
0.0204690546,
2.777e-7,
-0.0011202965,
0.0392991304,
0.0515331887,
0.0053350874,
0.0020625039,
0.0266674589,
0.0046830191,
0.0181779899,
0.0324522033,
0.0347373597,
0.0218062121,
-0.0129974978,
0.0568969287,
0.0129929334,
-0.0528352596,
0.0206116457,
-0.1062098816,
0.0311861038,
-0.0560009331,
-0.0614803508,
0.0137226135,
0.0755145252,
-0.042366419,
-0.024554193,
0.0022121642,
-0.032456167,
0.0749461874,
0.0120305447,
-0.0734070614,
0.0117797302,
0.0110438215,
-0.0024958814,
-0.0040369146,
-0.0118261548,
-0.023142688,
0.0147699425,
0.0017299332,
0.021229621,
0.0241842214,
-0.0537233241,
0.0418795608,
0.0459654853,
-0.0046441904,
-0.0338189751,
0.043814037,
-0.0514081977,
-0.024542138,
-0.0042092898,
-0.0556410551,
0.0207351726,
0.0094291996,
-0.0516340956,
-0.0259983409,
0.0319446698,
0.0410241783,
0.0166550092,
-0.0132827302,
-0.0412784405,
-0.0140519971,
0.0149776926,
-0.0748421624,
-0.0066462825,
-0.0514992028,
-0.0088778213,
0.0052981991,
-0.0081189806,
-0.0028860411,
2.527848714e-34,
0.0244148076,
-0.0348419845,
0.0147475963,
0.0082234219,
0.0138080083,
-0.0290128551,
-0.0030928431,
0.0092639849,
-0.005227664,
-0.0891265273,
-0.045057252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08545v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08545v1 | Efficient Continual Pre-training for Building Domain Specific Large Language Models | 2023-11-14T21:19:14 | 2023-11-14T21:19:14 | Yong Xie, Karan Aggarwal, Aitzaz Ahmad | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable open-domain
capabilities. Traditionally, LLMs tailored for a domain are trained from
scratch to excel at handling domain-specific tasks. In this work, we explore an
alternative strategy of continual pre-training as a means to develop
domain-specific LLMs. We introduce FinPythia-6.9B, developed through
domain-adaptive continual pre-training on the financial domain. Continual
pre-trained FinPythia showcases consistent improvements on financial tasks over
the original foundational model. We further explore simple but effective data
selection strategies for continual pre-training. Our data selection strategies
outperforms vanilla continual pre-training's performance with just 10% of
corpus size and cost, without any degradation on open-domain standard tasks.
Our work proposes an alternative solution to building domain-specific LLMs from
scratch in a cost-effective manner. | [
-0.0050469185,
0.1034066156,
-0.0037318692,
0.0167815946,
0.0120255686,
0.0367470644,
0.0535102487,
0.0176428389,
-0.0024502769,
-0.0450931378,
-0.0711023957,
-0.0711422563,
-0.0569193847,
0.0399545692,
0.0460263193,
-0.0109462673,
0.0272385851,
-0.0417791903,
-0.017662134,
-0.0317014828,
0.0069298176,
-0.0001881832,
0.0096266931,
-0.0004641319,
-0.0084819933,
-0.0392427705,
0.0126185194,
-0.0465410911,
-0.0369758457,
-0.039077621,
0.0460878387,
0.0346841142,
0.0555077568,
0.0300090257,
0.0000022406,
-0.042011939,
-0.0400669426,
-0.0141885057,
-0.0700926855,
0.0215727016,
0.0567389391,
-0.0079854904,
0.0314166956,
0.0119988704,
-0.0662066117,
-0.0324368738,
0.0386102721,
0.0582185127,
0.0677301511,
0.054617092,
-0.0139007643,
-0.0711938739,
-0.0036893548,
-0.103223294,
-0.0541350693,
-0.0891572386,
0.0409933552,
0.0108342236,
-0.0311123524,
-0.0114458362,
-0.0304463934,
0.0141204447,
0.0142140193,
-0.0094655827,
0.0147131113,
0.0324416123,
-0.0156089198,
-0.0179807618,
-0.0181038119,
0.0713977814,
-0.0094678383,
0.0103946486,
0.0252028611,
-0.0150417462,
-0.0396403223,
0.0031323971,
-0.0398951843,
0.0395037681,
0.045409169,
0.0160458498,
0.0232358761,
-0.0027481508,
0.0275303442,
0.0439028032,
-0.0724619031,
0.0103588123,
0.0089061828,
-0.0198890623,
0.0424981304,
0.0121426219,
-0.0605175532,
-0.0484573133,
0.0039905822,
0.0060534473,
0.0015581463,
-0.0030021141,
-0.0598707572,
-0.0191476922,
-0.0185076948,
-0.0539960116,
0.043317914,
0.0252190381,
-0.0225681979,
0.0725844204,
-0.0379635803,
0.0305581465,
-0.0042387904,
-0.0434229337,
-0.0212252904,
0.0220405702,
-0.0415578745,
0.0118534304,
-0.0601804443,
0.0727122352,
-0.039038796,
-0.0384967439,
-0.0527559705,
0.0180744007,
-0.0081374925,
-0.0168688558,
0.0274425764,
-0.034115389,
-0.0295537822,
-0.025196394,
0.0051464667,
0.0151920496,
-0.0177268777,
0.0303338487,
-0.0268272068,
-0.017532818,
-0.0043110489,
0.0503597818,
-0.0385519043,
-0.0321635902,
0.0159347262,
0.085175097,
0.0255328082,
-0.0310998652,
-0.0525708534,
-0.0164906606,
0.008783211,
-0.0523004569,
0.0087185828,
-0.0232588984,
-0.0075815739,
-0.0132286325,
0.0156478342,
-0.0303467736,
0.0033115556,
-0.0231675804,
0.005493782,
0.062998645,
0.009280799,
0.0049890713,
-0.0133273946,
-0.0338963345,
0.0378468521,
0.0942432508,
-0.0114745051,
-0.0059476425,
0.0315850973,
-0.0034846391,
-0.034528248,
0.0560760461,
0.0240929592,
0.0000046591,
-0.0203472134,
0.032501854,
0.0406195484,
0.002798764,
0.0651764348,
-0.0222162809,
-0.035015624,
0.0073240055,
0.0480660088,
0.0217581224,
0.0958427116,
0.0238649044,
0.0342347436,
0.0229721759,
0.0452331938,
-0.0181206707,
-0.0269228369,
-0.0196573827,
0.0023075875,
0.0217488576,
-0.0415399559,
0.0060815681,
-0.0525141582,
-0.0062546013,
0.0109415306,
-0.0214567874,
-0.040927045,
0.0246856548,
0.0577657744,
-0.0081643527,
-0.0259121004,
0.0995533243,
0.0434129946,
-0.0199866854,
-0.0047664694,
-0.0239291843,
0.0440151244,
0.0461584143,
0.029320946,
-0.0549452454,
-0.0156752374,
-0.0243465602,
0.0281904992,
0.068224296,
0.041839812,
-0.0100280512,
0.0021040768,
-0.0831268951,
-0.0120652942,
0.0144721167,
0.0302947294,
0.02460864,
0.022553619,
0.0209477432,
0.0176092051,
-0.015496158,
-0.01224826,
0.0267576035,
-0.0520290695,
-0.0489307232,
0.0073082172,
-0.0168738384,
0.0025130771,
0.0065746536,
-0.0447285064,
0.0020447965,
0.0189399403,
-0.0342231169,
0.005134902,
-0.0066397642,
-0.0472225249,
0.0162255466,
0.0323380083,
0.0382054783,
-0.0161950067,
0.0009057757,
-0.0504833944,
-0.005973767,
-0.0226359982,
0.0095330738,
0.0436370969,
-0.0667833835,
0.0296823997,
0.0024259747,
0.0436714329,
-0.0253460817,
0.046339944,
0.0118113775,
-0.0052557811,
-0.0146851279,
0.0219121985,
0.0102592781,
-0.0535917841,
0.0170105137,
0.0019678171,
-0.0167850349,
0.0530165955,
0.0158716664,
0.0192394182,
0.0042615687,
-0.0279213209,
-0.0494006872,
0.0014906717,
-0.0230315886,
0.0363751054,
-0.0158369336,
-0.0006408696,
-0.0335487388,
-0.0107693896,
-0.0038906618,
0.0215284377,
-0.026668502,
0.0127287759,
0.0208506435,
-0.0181424934,
0.010657778,
-0.0477182567,
-0.0339111909,
0.0359803513,
0.0593088418,
0.0016760881,
0.0004767846,
-0.0380102769,
0.0236282777,
0.0070317881,
0.0316190273,
-0.005299096,
0.0020300159,
-0.0260873064,
-0.030132683,
0.0193704199,
0.022952484,
0.0186594166,
0.0330034606,
-0.0029401912,
-0.0043142661,
-0.0300289262,
0.0075275796,
-0.0183201209,
-0.0305288527,
-0.025870448,
0.0591279455,
0.0227829609,
0.0825489685,
-0.0581145398,
-0.018440906,
-0.0379564464,
0.0352035984,
-0.0320043229,
-0.0043494892,
-0.0562142543,
0.0344027989,
-0.0070600184,
0.0293362904,
0.0162853803,
-0.0351057574,
0.0252313446,
0.0048677749,
-0.0020460703,
-0.0371135958,
-0.0217277706,
-0.0596145205,
0.0317366049,
-0.0323683247,
-0.0112435082,
0.0483393781,
-0.0492869616,
-0.0367988721,
-0.0164983012,
0.0412332751,
-0.0078794425,
0.0925332308,
-0.0166995414,
0.0665677935,
-0.0097231111,
-0.0325496718,
-0.0416174121,
-0.0895132422,
-0.0259549916,
0.0181214865,
0.0019113593,
-0.0112748062,
-0.0540768318,
0.0210995357,
-0.0066421051,
0.0200206451,
-0.0058148764,
0.0069169663,
0.0009222917,
0.0303875487,
0.0504653156,
0.035483595,
0.0135256648,
-0.0515251756,
0.0409064107,
-0.0087309498,
0.0304168891,
-0.007570684,
-0.0096018538,
0.0161264576,
0.0092501156,
-0.063540794,
-0.016379796,
0.015085862,
-0.015757937,
-0.0636801049,
-0.0044155824,
0.1241468117,
-0.0033047628,
-0.0261560827,
-0.0097913556,
0.0102315303,
0.0240155924,
0.0004314248,
0.0443529263,
-0.1115918085,
-0.0370901749,
-0.0115985936,
0.0095796753,
0.0463456735,
-0.0273195971,
-0.0259019304,
-0.1252537668,
0.0481323823,
-0.0005984828,
0.0146045741,
0.0209168401,
-0.0121982917,
-0.0148906307,
-0.0521749221,
0.0196352992,
0.0271964353,
-0.050673034,
-0.0031953037,
0.0234170351,
-0.0178784784,
-0.0229442343,
0.0290797614,
-0.0411395468,
-0.0172878839,
0.0463103168,
0.0147199333,
0.0046988181,
-0.0181243699,
0.021705756,
-0.0186983328,
-0.0173909105,
-0.0130064255,
0.0498612337,
0.0163768418,
-0.0516514704,
0.0176766664,
0.0181752946,
-0.0309867375,
0.0092769973,
0.0011776591,
0.0167929139,
-0.0054878155,
0.0035082023,
0.0202556066,
0.0035723667,
-0.0099658147,
0.0593055263,
0.0079859002,
-0.0765705332,
-0.0261583235,
-0.0027269477,
-0.0380750448,
-0.0327712707,
-0.0247836523,
-0.0092804227,
-0.0387220271,
-0.0203188546,
-0.0750176087,
-0.03904704,
0.0166034251,
0.0716694519,
0.0083336458,
-0.003244024,
0.0414660983,
-0.018543141,
-0.0487143844,
0.0334927067,
-0.077554144,
0.0171516668,
-0.0833292454,
0.0122713642,
0.0556230284,
-0.0234609004,
-0.0425314642,
0.0360580869,
-0.0567094535,
-0.0418460295,
0.038906198,
0.0016030979,
0.0225329399,
0.0094415676,
-0.0292735025,
-0.0173487719,
0.0489550307,
0.0233239029,
-0.0764583349,
0.0133570116,
0.0687433928,
-0.0417879336,
-0.0148015618,
0.0401786268,
-0.0341131836,
0.0528628938,
0.0289636794,
0.0428880118,
0.0101514785,
0.001558768,
0.0047432263,
0.0163479373,
0.0339566022,
0.0109246857,
-0.0042866124,
-0.0426876321,
0.006030824,
0.0173140969,
-0.0074886172,
-0.0442772284,
0.0096582873,
0.0340065956,
-0.0021924896,
-0.0173051395,
0.0236388426,
-0.0041788751,
0.0211530328,
-0.0221679788,
0.0268852487,
-0.0266198665,
0.0195253044,
0.0460666157,
-0.0215150937,
0.0046825171,
0.0125221256,
0.0248800181,
0.0137822665,
-0.0363315865,
0.0397044867,
0.0016918698,
0.0324832872,
-0.032362543,
-0.0125016849,
0.0009367975,
-0.0603396073,
-0.0167993046,
0.0253265295,
0.07934995,
-0.0549228936,
0.0259672515,
-0.0404636711,
0.0048211506,
-0.0262444355,
0.0216403864,
0.0137358299,
-0.0177491605,
0.0219544359,
0.0051430417,
-0.043073725,
-0.0042294371,
0.1148337498,
0.025134651,
0.0299874507,
-0.0179730877,
0.034435045,
-0.0337277651,
-0.0282456651,
0.038744729,
0.000071048,
-0.0321555771,
0.0439221673,
-0.05775702,
-0.0526225939,
0.0147262085,
-0.0229354929,
-0.0360543542,
0.0033585888,
0.0530681349,
0.046435792,
-0.012658163,
0.0237915553,
-0.0279640611,
0.0270340536,
0.0040447237,
-0.0114897955,
-0.0469226204,
-6.710933248e-33,
-0.020237051,
0.0106523335,
0.0467108488,
-0.0062736091,
-0.0328464843,
0.0257830676,
-0.0114767989,
-0.0131911682,
0.0005326736,
-0.0005192558,
-0.0036955585,
0.0148178916,
0.0206618421,
0.0318644531,
0.0038768665,
-0.015051404,
0.0463232547,
-0.02098215,
0.0113527076,
0.0111387568,
0.0091219321,
0.0606657341,
0.0399851911,
-0.0613605753,
-0.0163894966,
0.0295348726,
-0.0156541802,
0.0054142214,
0.0575556904,
0.0599266887,
-0.015252131,
0.0338450894,
-0.0002866464,
-0.1099086553,
-0.0394687057,
-0.0227933265,
-0.0504947715,
-0.027976092,
0.0098499488,
0.0188592616,
0.034130346,
-0.0130276121,
0.0173446666,
-0.0130531536,
-0.0031084432,
-0.0300338957,
-0.0049178679,
-0.0231996626,
-0.0187371224,
-0.0242573321,
-0.0832118243,
0.0444192737,
0.0355172828,
0.0180543493,
0.0502605215,
0.0041746586,
-0.0202505421,
-0.003515834,
-0.0222699977,
0.0161344633,
0.0374458097,
0.034332443,
0.0097042182,
0.0075694364,
0.0184690058,
0.0545614921,
-0.0040916465,
0.006912298,
0.0369160511,
0.0130108614,
0.0227721948,
0.0446687527,
0.0146748386,
0.0321649164,
0.0329410918,
-0.0442517288,
-0.0691597611,
-0.0125767561,
0.0050945305,
0.0248407349,
0.019584164,
0.0350895524,
0.0106133251,
-0.0290105343,
-0.0424441434,
0.0488664545,
-0.0264087729,
0.0059520877,
0.0240250211,
0.022300519,
-0.0159855261,
0.0229945704,
0.0270533077,
-0.0484589003,
-0.0595255569,
0.0108342515,
-0.0077961106,
0.0006042263,
0.0063220356,
0.0301281568,
-0.0368007161,
-0.0658569857,
-0.0258063879,
-0.0246374551,
-0.004235391,
-0.0132547868,
0.0157455336,
0.0192443561,
-0.0576827936,
-0.0220989436,
-0.001582806,
0.004693679,
0.0508467183,
0.0664942637,
0.0275756493,
0.0431415625,
0.0126070175,
0.0488113351,
0.0039970782,
-0.060214106,
-0.0150261102,
0.0151768448,
0.0533021688,
0.0814244077,
-0.0196340084,
0.0079925638,
-0.0255443417,
0.0186399315,
0.0602983311,
-0.0612655208,
-0.0243221167,
0.0049955901,
2.832e-7,
0.0281402338,
0.0730184838,
-0.0215510651,
0.0067187622,
0.0166070443,
0.0390545726,
-0.032760106,
-0.0006661064,
0.0038314951,
0.0422054604,
-0.0009014275,
0.0193771441,
0.0853640959,
-0.0164387096,
-0.0862081945,
-0.0306519791,
-0.0033650307,
0.0240546428,
-0.0527641028,
-0.0074740271,
-0.0033017469,
0.1272585392,
0.0015695862,
-0.0240491722,
0.0087458408,
-0.0893561691,
0.0770251304,
-0.0054220371,
-0.0070363884,
0.0162428562,
-0.0384392478,
0.0492629074,
-0.0266874414,
0.0108611453,
-0.0327465683,
0.0324459113,
0.0269817542,
0.0744070634,
0.0350459255,
0.0396168381,
0.0171150751,
-0.0112223811,
-0.0272490326,
-0.017687412,
0.0350271948,
-0.107060872,
-0.0390597209,
-0.0538331456,
-0.0132736182,
-0.0083425809,
-0.0129486741,
0.004759917,
0.0193333756,
0.0142559614,
0.039590925,
-0.0047117998,
-0.0219326913,
-0.0603939258,
0.0080982558,
0.038093999,
-0.0472961403,
0.0046394332,
-0.0437268205,
-0.0085369376,
0.0488062724,
-0.0654055327,
0.031447012,
2.695478801e-34,
0.0543888472,
-0.0153218368,
-0.0239445474,
0.0556884743,
0.0297300275,
-0.0128327636,
0.0121236602,
0.0165444985,
-0.0013777961,
-0.1114968583,
0.0107976291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08538v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08538v1 | Extending Multilingual Machine Translation through Imitation Learning | 2023-11-14T21:04:03 | 2023-11-14T21:04:03 | Wen Lai, Viktor Hangya, Alexander Fraser | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the growing variety of languages supported by existing multilingual
neural machine translation (MNMT) models, most of the world's languages are
still being left behind. We aim to extend large-scale MNMT models to a new
language, allowing for translation between the newly added and all of the
already supported languages in a challenging scenario: using only a parallel
corpus between the new language and English. Previous approaches, such as
continued training on parallel data including the new language, suffer from
catastrophic forgetting (i.e., performance on other languages is reduced). Our
novel approach Imit-MNMT treats the task as an imitation learning process,
which mimicks the behavior of an expert, a technique widely used in the
computer vision area, but not well explored in NLP. More specifically, we
construct a pseudo multi-parallel corpus of the new and the original languages
by pivoting through English, and imitate the output distribution of the
original MNMT model. Extensive experiments show that our approach significantly
improves the translation performance between the new and the original
languages, without severe catastrophic forgetting. We also demonstrate that our
approach is capable of solving copy and off-target problems, which are two
common issues existence in current large-scale MNMT models. | [
0.0434965156,
0.0465686694,
-0.0186331458,
0.0547495186,
-0.0381596722,
0.0158551019,
0.0045965859,
0.0175971519,
-0.0118321544,
-0.0062433584,
-0.0457358025,
-0.04693041,
-0.0050457045,
-0.0498859286,
0.0377959684,
-0.0237931479,
0.0152101899,
-0.0288934391,
-0.0376173742,
-0.0401424244,
-0.0040390175,
0.0133717069,
0.0260151438,
0.0213200673,
-0.0122996466,
0.031681221,
-0.0082371142,
0.0302928425,
0.0135968225,
-0.0110131204,
-0.0170860309,
-0.0041526454,
0.0620683879,
0.048348818,
0.0000018992,
-0.0188396107,
-0.0178275015,
-0.0135674588,
0.0427484363,
-0.0415502489,
0.0683241189,
-0.0557095297,
0.0148691237,
0.0201165415,
-0.0455787294,
-0.0160191618,
0.0469674692,
0.0012591488,
0.0503439046,
0.0886144191,
-0.0157991052,
-0.0167018957,
0.0036872074,
-0.0429859161,
0.0046120505,
-0.0311249569,
-0.0205830578,
0.0207168479,
-0.0090538226,
0.0105851572,
-0.0017518273,
0.0429584831,
0.0252760388,
0.0245514419,
-0.05607659,
0.0397083797,
0.0403347351,
-0.0449801199,
-0.0332285278,
0.035826467,
-0.0983832479,
-0.0421634614,
-0.0096616093,
-0.0099307792,
0.0054016924,
-0.0083000222,
-0.0474220365,
0.0298715532,
0.0145257758,
0.0168900955,
0.0528439097,
0.0151152657,
0.0316111371,
-0.0053689606,
-0.0257093348,
-0.0210922584,
0.0142938606,
-0.0393012166,
0.0069615431,
0.0156199662,
-0.0311449524,
0.0291209519,
0.0331827998,
-0.0080109062,
-0.0298110787,
0.0264668372,
-0.0358658321,
-0.0692444965,
0.0098259142,
-0.0280373394,
0.0793616846,
0.0544411354,
-0.0141989915,
0.0656656399,
-0.0436019637,
0.0591882356,
-0.0490671769,
0.0266087707,
-0.0837951154,
-0.018826725,
-0.05703298,
0.0128520783,
-0.0461775325,
0.0017645971,
-0.0320706405,
-0.0180885475,
0.0323626064,
0.0033814858,
-0.0015212599,
0.0180257466,
0.0183269735,
-0.0256136637,
-0.0705927014,
-0.0381463543,
0.0195492394,
0.0338063911,
-0.0118550118,
-0.0074284398,
-0.0158227328,
-0.0580908023,
-0.0439699143,
0.0044918475,
-0.0187746007,
-0.0485310145,
0.0371638797,
0.0806980953,
-0.0404211804,
-0.0621220209,
0.002917937,
0.02040671,
0.0085997051,
-0.0495102406,
0.0582182109,
-0.0672408342,
0.1127245873,
-0.0278859455,
0.0168310851,
-0.0292847268,
-0.0102884052,
0.002657647,
-0.0096677337,
0.0674298927,
0.0109438831,
0.0030656944,
0.0271768086,
-0.024493156,
0.0143291801,
0.0682629421,
0.0160101838,
-0.0159902982,
0.0180057716,
0.0358662084,
0.0066799917,
0.0683231354,
0.0225572269,
0.0649639741,
-0.0052767936,
-0.0235098638,
-0.0033869641,
0.0667180419,
0.0378296487,
0.0468322448,
-0.0353545435,
-0.0002600908,
0.0528775118,
0.0052360659,
-0.0295456704,
0.0400348715,
0.0583488606,
-0.003784511,
-0.0362178721,
0.0060144057,
-0.0416436419,
0.0477369167,
0.0274059046,
0.0143940765,
-0.002963102,
0.0439868197,
-0.0140312593,
0.0050836457,
0.025838336,
-0.0249868352,
-0.0008851161,
-0.0136362128,
0.0328744352,
0.0526090562,
-0.0451779887,
0.0170145035,
0.0078323502,
-0.0234115962,
0.0341337621,
-0.0310422312,
-0.0231729001,
0.0385994092,
0.0181533433,
-0.0249800645,
-0.0037434429,
-0.0267173443,
-0.0092521766,
0.0526022203,
0.0792690739,
0.0173925739,
0.0190778784,
-0.0563262515,
-0.0008785274,
-0.0008149614,
0.0125098675,
0.0585814603,
0.0115200393,
0.0229692347,
0.0023805874,
-0.0128789749,
-0.0555306152,
0.0451380126,
-0.0911456645,
-0.0124044772,
0.0181282256,
0.0101742726,
0.0229559764,
0.0160524081,
-0.0072734114,
0.0033414557,
0.015229743,
-0.0504476875,
-0.0377072841,
0.0502353422,
-0.05394236,
-0.0503627285,
0.0683377162,
-0.0684024692,
-0.010530849,
0.0366323143,
-0.0289722104,
-0.0505012125,
-0.0043148356,
-0.031636849,
0.0476690158,
-0.039682202,
0.0211300198,
0.0116814673,
-0.0096877515,
-0.0340183303,
0.0287877377,
-0.0324642286,
0.0213519298,
0.0358305834,
-0.046802029,
-0.0003967217,
-0.0604556389,
-0.0198432859,
0.017236704,
0.0344313905,
0.0480745658,
0.0229937732,
0.0414079577,
-0.020675404,
-0.0379771627,
-0.0780336335,
0.005437573,
-0.0148503287,
0.0048854812,
0.0271656141,
0.0524790511,
0.0106259445,
-0.0320466645,
-0.0497015342,
0.0099261841,
0.0040954757,
0.0161451399,
0.0039624446,
-0.0113008479,
0.0261581019,
-0.0007423206,
-0.008188352,
0.0201926101,
0.0383659266,
-0.0305040739,
0.0152045591,
-0.0771444589,
-0.0351089127,
-0.0089219352,
0.0434869304,
-0.025787672,
-0.0174668804,
-0.0041878093,
-0.0640812963,
0.0012432572,
0.0426826105,
-0.015775742,
-0.0057586678,
0.0166339967,
0.0193245951,
-0.0784236714,
0.0221351311,
-0.0247902963,
-0.0241235588,
-0.0369069055,
-0.0500639603,
-0.0012391721,
0.0365886763,
-0.0086048953,
-0.0073761684,
-0.0590052195,
0.001927434,
0.0131668113,
-0.0465802997,
-0.0069079618,
0.0397866517,
0.0115951095,
-0.0201644264,
-0.0362213738,
-0.0242260583,
0.0683465451,
-0.0148229804,
-0.0261358563,
-0.0543901101,
0.0287263542,
-0.0160497874,
0.0698199198,
0.0127614336,
0.0434996448,
-0.0388657115,
-0.0030875257,
-0.0474159569,
0.0320560858,
0.0022461796,
-0.0209809337,
0.0266254712,
-0.0639251843,
-0.0058796331,
-0.0028507097,
-0.034635026,
-0.0090783881,
-0.0054537221,
-0.0177021679,
-0.0088125132,
-0.0125061823,
-0.0301293526,
-0.0640352741,
-0.0156026203,
0.0231919046,
0.0972500071,
0.0239228737,
0.0093220733,
-0.028919585,
0.0135371536,
0.0115373638,
0.0281112548,
-0.0056540677,
-0.074959822,
0.0116860336,
0.0139533738,
0.0369249247,
-0.0422888249,
-0.0311903413,
0.0083275326,
0.0280412715,
0.0056371605,
-0.0181697309,
-0.0210333951,
0.0103445202,
-0.0198085681,
-0.0259671081,
0.0546360575,
0.0256244987,
-0.0613014847,
-0.0131513197,
-0.0042542927,
0.0440088101,
0.028337406,
0.0476173311,
-0.0796528608,
-0.0334424451,
-0.0007008238,
0.0249262713,
0.0204288512,
0.0048728753,
-0.0310471989,
-0.1380407959,
-0.0139474627,
0.0497937724,
-0.1106800959,
-0.0459363461,
-0.0125291077,
-0.0425977707,
-0.0382915251,
0.0241093319,
0.0123327691,
0.0446060225,
-0.0257747341,
-0.019210251,
0.0614111722,
-0.064869836,
-0.0145011572,
-0.034733545,
0.0425204374,
0.0349123329,
0.0219283141,
-0.0120819714,
-0.0329739042,
0.0219079368,
-0.0024405627,
0.0078129712,
-0.0159249231,
0.0085713277,
0.0025060559,
-0.0088545177,
0.0569504648,
0.0453204215,
-0.0347519815,
0.0253236834,
0.0106648887,
0.0594376847,
-0.005256501,
-0.0192904528,
0.0339311734,
-0.0654051453,
0.026134856,
0.0298725497,
-0.0014032958,
-0.0492491759,
0.0030222021,
-0.0188824497,
-0.0231157094,
-0.0796251222,
0.0055788439,
0.0274917595,
-0.0309984665,
-0.0233168509,
-0.0866860598,
-0.0395728163,
0.0103995251,
0.0510093346,
0.0461519659,
-0.0120511232,
0.0334565789,
-0.0288160387,
-0.0185886752,
0.0258513875,
-0.056140881,
0.0002955422,
-0.0144178607,
0.0026843026,
0.0355347209,
-0.0727142245,
0.0154053727,
-0.0009443568,
-0.0831040815,
-0.0676237047,
-0.0249937866,
0.1032438129,
0.0162529945,
0.0916650146,
-0.0201912206,
-0.0206230134,
0.0182700101,
0.0005662041,
-0.0065413327,
-0.008971679,
0.0237903222,
-0.0249039494,
-0.0109692337,
0.0475007482,
0.0101948008,
-0.002264841,
0.0160298645,
0.0539810807,
-0.0185732413,
0.0056307507,
0.0575378239,
0.0081021013,
-0.0000557869,
-0.0368113667,
0.0135928132,
-0.0465671271,
0.0031707711,
0.0198510364,
-0.0415593348,
-0.0563562959,
-0.0052467841,
0.0346466452,
0.0248661637,
0.0256461389,
-0.0660223067,
-0.0009686619,
-0.0167801771,
-0.0105066542,
-0.0351964906,
0.0048904927,
0.0269717984,
0.0088966675,
0.0211204719,
-0.021235954,
0.0348562561,
-0.0248121619,
0.0549222119,
-0.0229431111,
0.044112049,
0.0270168558,
-0.0418117382,
0.0001533488,
0.0209870022,
-0.0144540099,
-0.0318091214,
-0.0243031029,
0.0476365052,
0.1006261855,
-0.0284425206,
0.0925166905,
-0.0304488819,
0.0048800558,
0.0222981237,
0.0134965302,
0.0143785235,
-0.0471830182,
0.0213166811,
0.0101033766,
0.0311997849,
0.0241507813,
0.066060178,
-0.0259483457,
0.0140831675,
-0.0137798088,
0.0447788611,
-0.0231482498,
-0.0138013875,
0.0178363416,
0.0011266287,
-0.0123516014,
0.0164329689,
0.0080533568,
-0.0498169176,
-0.0227205381,
0.0357620306,
0.0005681025,
-0.0079165203,
0.0355967507,
0.0725469217,
-0.0277477615,
0.0248782616,
-0.0496239811,
-0.0116101718,
0.0251047611,
-0.03398256,
-0.0247993618,
-5.696903332e-33,
0.0055732755,
-0.0018411746,
0.0455894098,
-0.0525010228,
-0.0339091271,
-0.0284275357,
-0.0155845853,
-0.0054649482,
-0.0096756089,
0.0023430483,
-0.0141998269,
0.0001438064,
0.0145632913,
0.0262554456,
0.0333638005,
0.0195843261,
0.0191911925,
-0.0127867656,
-0.0258708615,
0.0069255386,
0.0257692747,
0.0150253465,
0.0939162523,
-0.0405290201,
0.0304515921,
-0.0154678049,
-0.0273026582,
0.0340387709,
-0.0360305049,
0.0212654974,
0.0074218842,
-0.0178245008,
0.0239852052,
-0.0117800776,
-0.0205076262,
-0.0322884396,
-0.0460392497,
0.0210532546,
0.0173570346,
0.0520150624,
-0.0412297063,
-0.0016899027,
0.0519342385,
-0.0538583212,
0.0068557728,
0.0027510128,
0.0067494898,
-0.0538039915,
-0.0250131842,
0.0504592061,
-0.0402079858,
-0.0083326483,
0.0311824381,
-0.0237632524,
0.0478109345,
0.0608117245,
-0.0209968742,
-0.0288732555,
-0.0733055994,
0.0261482168,
-0.0533714965,
0.0205223281,
0.0550440848,
0.0269957036,
-0.0013630337,
0.0106454426,
0.0170712695,
-0.0067230589,
0.0624313429,
0.0201118886,
0.0500159785,
-0.012553907,
0.0647327676,
0.0377786197,
0.0355566256,
-0.008782763,
0.0263112169,
0.0159792043,
0.0175999962,
0.0158594921,
0.030974282,
0.0002867578,
0.0062093702,
0.0073042256,
-0.0469856746,
-0.0264023691,
-0.0367206186,
-0.0149832349,
0.0022751132,
0.0465366393,
-0.0277134161,
0.0025305469,
0.076845035,
-0.0095620751,
-0.0133493552,
-0.0277257897,
-0.0241731685,
0.0310826153,
-0.039953284,
0.0365740657,
-0.0174505897,
-0.1058494449,
-0.0215283614,
0.0053694779,
-0.0035999392,
0.0206614472,
0.0700073168,
0.0391649939,
-0.0511211306,
0.0064120837,
-0.0394096375,
-0.0051135602,
0.0126679027,
0.010203626,
0.0230385456,
0.0014263213,
-0.0182172488,
0.019804433,
0.0745967254,
-0.069940038,
-0.0460473597,
-0.0003697861,
-0.000560976,
0.0270381607,
-0.0476332791,
0.0203828439,
-0.0439620912,
-0.0277802255,
0.0107490048,
-0.0714198127,
-0.0121459281,
0.0032672414,
2.638e-7,
-0.0008370203,
0.0315576196,
-0.0113909999,
0.0079383999,
0.0069329278,
0.0328414626,
-0.063268356,
0.0263333917,
-0.0067473655,
0.0381014757,
0.0357885361,
0.0196361784,
0.0551850609,
-0.0108028911,
-0.1039327607,
-0.0178875532,
-0.0382044204,
0.0516981967,
-0.0433140397,
-0.0154169789,
-0.0199635439,
0.1074944884,
0.0080295224,
-0.0037640366,
-0.017003404,
-0.0529126562,
0.1130745709,
-0.0008116427,
-0.0418656766,
-0.0277824011,
0.0258161351,
0.0447841138,
-0.0590951927,
-0.0032675702,
-0.0281120092,
0.0060497671,
0.0476632826,
0.0442212373,
0.0171638243,
-0.0066153281,
0.0475645922,
-0.0019408494,
-0.0145975249,
-0.0239350833,
0.0188816693,
-0.0432618856,
0.0337985046,
-0.0080685997,
-0.0092868386,
0.016961284,
0.0328346267,
-0.0462708026,
-0.0372131355,
0.0354007632,
0.0610895343,
0.0231524948,
0.0007467686,
-0.0263122059,
-0.0402632467,
-0.0095575461,
-0.0237639155,
0.00316355,
-0.0156067042,
0.0153456451,
-0.0180155952,
-0.0422976017,
-0.0065212981,
2.079885496e-34,
0.0472786799,
-0.011064765,
0.0315250456,
0.029637849,
0.0121185705,
-0.0442512631,
0.0113892276,
0.0305202585,
0.0061212233,
-0.022594966,
-0.044992581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08533v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08533v1 | Natural Language Processing for Financial Regulation | 2023-11-14T20:58:21 | 2023-11-14T20:58:21 | Ixandra Achitouv, Dragos Gorduza, Antoine Jacquier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, q-fin.CP | This article provides an understanding of Natural Language Processing
techniques in the framework of financial regulation, more specifically in order
to perform semantic matching search between rules and policy when no dataset is
available for supervised learning. We outline how to outperform simple
pre-trained sentences-transformer models using freely available resources and
explain the mathematical concepts behind the key building blocks of Natural
Language Processing. | [
0.0380112752,
0.0307702199,
0.0003623451,
0.0038486666,
-0.0266339239,
0.0041706851,
0.0034799518,
0.0471620373,
0.0059970408,
-0.0569715314,
0.0088918079,
-0.0008924237,
-0.0036251617,
0.0472911894,
0.0125548663,
-0.0259901863,
0.0134083712,
0.0209483579,
0.0583907217,
0.0495678261,
0.0326543078,
0.0123806885,
0.0106537361,
0.0463168249,
-0.0230279677,
0.0195027255,
0.0119806798,
-0.0460795127,
-0.0080870455,
-0.0180450715,
0.0110473959,
-0.0038590792,
0.0132438531,
0.0133738406,
0.0000016398,
-0.0618232638,
-0.0727703646,
0.0070501552,
0.0245017745,
-0.0221891589,
0.0265055466,
-0.064499341,
0.0069132256,
0.0318438523,
-0.0726580322,
0.0354834944,
0.0481774732,
0.0667791814,
0.0921735093,
0.1046984792,
-0.0234646648,
-0.1013219953,
-0.0070050941,
-0.0166883375,
-0.038526617,
-0.0450530574,
0.0340203941,
-0.0082832258,
-0.0184098259,
-0.0347815566,
-0.0247246381,
0.0248327628,
-0.0223735087,
-0.0096888077,
-0.000478984,
-0.0362926163,
-0.0543193668,
-0.0010321133,
-0.0634507909,
0.0446093567,
-0.0011314515,
0.0114728967,
0.0435084887,
-0.0387805663,
-0.0072161048,
0.0407718383,
-0.0135087222,
0.0596784465,
-0.021744838,
0.0119517623,
0.0179047417,
0.0250977296,
-0.0140874134,
-0.0180831328,
-0.0326285362,
0.0462421887,
-0.0069235703,
-0.072303541,
0.0218087118,
0.0038310322,
0.0110196713,
-0.0360983722,
0.0703784823,
0.0329916626,
-0.0004416669,
0.0223579202,
-0.0228335354,
-0.0081807496,
0.0051903585,
-0.0604799576,
0.0294607729,
0.026778983,
0.0017727842,
0.0265164841,
-0.0290386342,
0.0303868148,
0.0009096308,
0.0301029962,
-0.0442298912,
0.0310065951,
-0.0526693724,
-0.0211687777,
-0.0690008029,
0.0732732341,
-0.0795971751,
-0.0307689179,
-0.082939744,
0.0015085565,
0.0022806323,
-0.0147332083,
0.028469108,
-0.0174427181,
0.0125924805,
0.0034030864,
-0.0871247947,
-0.0040252567,
-0.0104444502,
0.0156495534,
-0.0282768868,
0.0083886525,
0.0271439422,
-0.0016013595,
0.0240517817,
0.0199396685,
0.0006605967,
0.0854689404,
0.0585673973,
-0.0238448363,
-0.0532102138,
-0.025710864,
-0.0018895171,
0.0048968904,
-0.013598619,
0.000922104,
-0.0101416837,
-0.0512778834,
-0.0169630591,
-0.0217634048,
-0.0092066182,
0.0108847525,
-0.0202980656,
0.0778092965,
0.0018679602,
-0.0308926255,
-0.0458430797,
-0.0434232056,
0.0558177456,
0.0121987369,
0.0060862233,
-0.0265130457,
0.0305311587,
0.0136214299,
0.0485506654,
0.0223122127,
-0.0192119721,
-0.0860901102,
0.0252286773,
0.0082578957,
-0.0275416579,
0.0020943501,
-0.0087012211,
0.0047980249,
-0.0093587358,
0.0011319937,
0.003430811,
0.092049934,
0.0612757802,
-0.0041844677,
0.0333032832,
0.0585331731,
0.0149703389,
0.0005588432,
0.0187947508,
-0.0149196871,
-0.0422656126,
0.0180545244,
-0.0721190274,
0.0207539201,
-0.0208238605,
-0.0630035549,
0.0009870235,
-0.001092667,
-0.0106831556,
-0.0361171253,
0.0238425843,
0.020558428,
-0.0700160265,
0.0512539707,
0.0066858102,
0.0072138868,
-0.0216569398,
-0.0373055413,
0.0089955125,
0.0653698519,
0.0469692238,
-0.0537713431,
0.0268403552,
-0.0375331417,
0.0098720714,
0.0672302023,
0.0246414989,
0.0156534929,
-0.0145402281,
-0.0382777937,
-0.0197776258,
0.0347744487,
0.0214371644,
0.0010762332,
-0.0283366479,
-0.0224293452,
0.0049806186,
0.0516576469,
-0.0194508545,
0.0657525361,
0.0456234142,
-0.0463012792,
0.0011429356,
-0.003874145,
0.0053061577,
0.0231457017,
0.0071301409,
0.0167482533,
0.0203011576,
0.00562956,
-0.0518039614,
0.0095593119,
-0.0314823128,
-0.0057985922,
0.0206062384,
-0.0919135734,
-0.0201055724,
0.0118083348,
-0.0263576359,
-0.0201804284,
-0.0293387044,
-0.0096268207,
0.0275798645,
-0.0421283133,
0.0267519094,
0.0139275491,
-0.0240274761,
-0.0297095664,
0.058610227,
0.0207866486,
0.0107247503,
-0.0476057306,
-0.0346460566,
0.0308292564,
-0.0204481818,
0.0346103162,
-0.0317132734,
-0.0889600217,
0.0090442887,
0.0706442147,
0.0325043164,
0.0160322748,
0.0117696803,
0.0314904042,
0.0199022256,
0.0196164474,
0.0221710224,
0.00462968,
0.0023748882,
-0.0180923585,
-0.0345228091,
-0.039551165,
-0.0157539453,
-0.007229941,
-0.0494121835,
0.0629955158,
-0.0084215682,
-0.0637928098,
-0.039994847,
-0.0109637268,
-0.0492338538,
0.0142193399,
0.0487020798,
-0.042594891,
-0.0531185195,
0.025895359,
0.0163998101,
0.0315350071,
0.0037469608,
0.0104265166,
0.0241333097,
0.0015535315,
-0.0111985924,
0.004566961,
0.00587341,
0.0592268109,
-0.0097345095,
0.0075693787,
-0.031529557,
0.0207408983,
-0.0369992852,
0.0131945098,
-0.0452588759,
0.0265375879,
0.1092817858,
0.0480527394,
-0.0117078032,
-0.0054792417,
-0.0601040237,
0.0457994416,
0.0053875376,
0.0131591372,
-0.0503053553,
-0.0154430186,
-0.0090527302,
0.0490805209,
0.0261410866,
0.0035698232,
0.0430157855,
-0.0064566731,
0.0032599107,
-0.0839896426,
-0.0195290782,
-0.0570959114,
0.0381585546,
0.0022291641,
0.0270707719,
0.0287113395,
-0.0185220521,
-0.0004499489,
-0.031153027,
0.08123447,
0.0101168733,
0.0212855749,
-0.0229451638,
0.0445151851,
-0.0192611683,
-0.0242991783,
-0.0221628044,
-0.1071105748,
0.0051935059,
0.0003848166,
0.0640838966,
-0.0132777579,
-0.05827168,
0.0402634516,
-0.0446154885,
0.030407995,
0.0322524719,
-0.0463933982,
-0.0210253745,
0.0256111398,
0.0402930193,
-0.0399357416,
0.0300380625,
0.0048169838,
0.0376033038,
-0.0001125341,
-0.0334226862,
-0.0084326342,
-0.0052167177,
0.0171293709,
-0.0296756327,
-0.0731742978,
0.0383212566,
0.0618138537,
-0.0414950289,
-0.0594249517,
0.0287246052,
0.0882816017,
0.0508581512,
0.0679188967,
0.0008711604,
0.0106007811,
-0.0635625198,
-0.0007342032,
0.0522233881,
-0.0908045918,
-0.000317579,
-0.0163018834,
-0.0129379341,
-0.0307269339,
-0.0316456072,
-0.0435950682,
-0.0728982985,
0.0539854467,
-0.0148811368,
-0.0088289892,
-0.0412048846,
-0.0076921484,
-0.0568967238,
-0.0462307967,
-0.0135022374,
-0.031048771,
-0.0377725177,
-0.0113038048,
0.0084016891,
-0.0717400089,
-0.0054361424,
-0.0411841199,
-0.0549777746,
0.0151224341,
0.05604361,
0.0334021822,
-0.0053755483,
-0.0029098515,
-0.0157921091,
0.0214281268,
-0.0134700732,
-0.0097601162,
0.0141584724,
0.0114619387,
-0.0297387335,
-0.0352695212,
0.0255380236,
-0.0272997655,
0.0238615461,
0.0185115933,
0.011337447,
-0.0255627148,
-0.0210876502,
0.0062737069,
0.0448292531,
-0.0038444677,
0.0762582794,
-0.0158649851,
-0.0001046813,
-0.0539023951,
-0.0507329367,
0.0156608131,
-0.0662768036,
-0.0421001613,
-0.0125994347,
-0.011541496,
0.0016753176,
-0.0767115802,
-0.0084897773,
-0.0011643564,
0.0284906887,
0.01727755,
0.0010580572,
0.1137228087,
-0.0216457527,
0.0054333042,
0.0073619396,
-0.0599358864,
0.0095554926,
-0.0279956684,
0.0323067196,
-0.0007278263,
0.051457189,
-0.0532256179,
0.0072608842,
0.0069617718,
-0.0219002906,
0.012587361,
0.0066919513,
0.0144233694,
0.0003953027,
-0.0263915882,
0.0569274761,
0.0104306834,
0.0531586036,
-0.0752903894,
-0.0583491176,
0.0494731367,
-0.0174345914,
0.0051861834,
0.0033939164,
-0.0036512248,
0.0392549224,
-0.0354429036,
0.0285369139,
-0.0221573152,
0.0075197699,
0.0733839199,
0.0238770824,
0.0391656756,
0.028555641,
-0.0226404145,
-0.0189222582,
-0.0184130538,
-0.0228643455,
0.0129896505,
-0.0420319997,
-0.0477339029,
0.0510278642,
0.0083907181,
-0.031165773,
0.0493559651,
-0.0424559377,
0.006017827,
0.0145833725,
0.0391666628,
0.0237063933,
0.0188034493,
-0.0177547485,
-0.0509828739,
0.0522822514,
0.0358195901,
0.034610901,
0.0065830029,
0.0111754006,
0.0053997762,
0.0216541346,
0.0108944075,
-0.0404006541,
-0.0102583766,
-0.0217952263,
-0.0033110643,
-0.0048722648,
0.006343402,
0.0203695875,
-0.0473816246,
-0.0440693535,
-0.0409820899,
0.0303691309,
0.0538325459,
0.0224742927,
-0.0029337707,
-0.0063838083,
0.0284335427,
-0.0233794618,
-0.0392362252,
-0.0483167432,
0.0671181232,
0.0289912056,
0.0139997322,
-0.0177574847,
-0.0366026759,
-0.0229995493,
-0.0452526547,
0.015612023,
0.0030426695,
0.0057879183,
-0.027649451,
-0.0605974384,
0.0051072119,
-0.0267191418,
0.0165205467,
-0.0114192357,
-0.0079727089,
0.0352062732,
0.0147830527,
0.0138158621,
-0.0096162148,
0.0196037833,
-0.0325961784,
0.0010049661,
-0.0118493605,
-0.0498057641,
-5.419119691e-33,
-0.0440008342,
-0.0398809426,
0.0461423583,
0.0398372114,
0.0327929668,
-0.0390494987,
-0.0048132245,
-0.0401042439,
0.0225802194,
0.0022844519,
-0.002197651,
0.057350561,
0.0264522303,
-0.0121499039,
0.0017768029,
-0.0106425406,
0.0612493791,
-0.0307260938,
-0.0119717065,
-0.0723070055,
-0.0180314351,
0.0488358028,
0.0503915437,
-0.0524877906,
0.0215836018,
0.0659452155,
-0.0234973058,
0.0129013462,
0.0403300636,
0.0526631363,
0.0094398912,
0.0190281402,
0.0126611646,
-0.1198220327,
-0.0295202695,
0.0482575782,
-0.0575915053,
-0.0588176548,
0.0101499846,
0.0355101489,
0.032753855,
-0.0142070418,
0.0685007423,
-0.0198643655,
-0.0434886925,
0.030614024,
0.0113751106,
-0.0134782316,
0.0512415394,
-0.026785044,
-0.1081440151,
0.025078604,
-0.0144535536,
0.0519042797,
0.0379030518,
0.058497075,
-0.0012488303,
-0.0180612989,
-0.0033199775,
0.0210850537,
0.0086133117,
0.0159268174,
-0.0036796201,
-0.0051239068,
-0.0237834379,
0.0401736014,
-0.0359896943,
-0.025713332,
-0.0075003635,
0.0072181472,
0.0289928745,
0.0569159761,
0.0134956716,
0.0390892066,
0.0454451181,
-0.0124064479,
-0.0823176056,
0.0605104789,
-0.0230357237,
0.0342201293,
0.0103889247,
-0.0081465356,
-0.0301097482,
-0.0221649203,
-0.0171801317,
0.0229300167,
0.0180997718,
0.0225933604,
0.0360429101,
0.0269446168,
0.0026277895,
0.0341650136,
-0.0196707789,
-0.0555364192,
-0.0098109776,
-0.0276257917,
0.0253553484,
-0.017297633,
0.0032694137,
0.0128387641,
-0.0463416763,
-0.0394772775,
0.0173642337,
0.0024110428,
0.0167433508,
-0.0362648964,
0.005350878,
0.0274988618,
-0.061932072,
0.0142777376,
0.0236247852,
-0.0067161033,
0.022313742,
0.0291378628,
-0.0082394304,
0.0360341556,
-0.0062458431,
-0.0246079285,
-0.014701291,
-0.0175801869,
0.02403377,
-0.0162418354,
0.0092578139,
0.0332142375,
0.0034864657,
-0.0110076014,
-0.0301813651,
0.0341555513,
0.0527913347,
-0.0404382199,
-0.0240228549,
0.0365118086,
2.312e-7,
0.05825698,
0.0721879005,
0.0042425077,
-0.0102968654,
-0.0129944151,
0.0059969891,
0.0056100534,
0.0325657092,
-0.0217973255,
0.0052501783,
0.0452941656,
-0.0403898843,
0.0137943719,
-0.0128590269,
-0.0947232023,
-0.0383939408,
-0.0199153442,
-0.001267708,
-0.0708169416,
0.035131216,
0.0485207252,
0.0695021451,
0.0043400992,
-0.0329306722,
0.0085799927,
-0.0480521023,
0.0279105045,
-0.0272642262,
0.003750568,
0.0041751596,
0.0829374567,
0.0161874276,
0.0046296404,
0.0243158247,
-0.0087884776,
0.0671842471,
-0.0150087522,
0.0688216537,
0.0117141623,
0.0390423387,
-0.0035162177,
-0.0216446314,
-0.0235577188,
0.0392443351,
0.0157883428,
-0.0718039125,
-0.033333201,
-0.0205464773,
-0.0383822881,
-0.0006992941,
-0.0000552384,
0.0227254126,
-0.0220082067,
-0.0005395523,
0.0351817682,
-0.0044691344,
0.0217644125,
-0.026014572,
0.0282391571,
0.016577648,
0.0129591068,
0.0623839088,
-0.0501265824,
0.0317398682,
0.0489139967,
-0.0631994829,
0.0144615145,
2.129644952e-34,
0.0052827997,
-0.0389001891,
0.0038757587,
0.0033736688,
0.0426476002,
0.0408829749,
-0.0118096648,
0.0582494922,
-0.0180475712,
-0.0869702324,
0.0211460367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08526v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08526v1 | GLiNER: Generalist Model for Named Entity Recognition using Bidirectional Transformer | 2023-11-14T20:39:12 | 2023-11-14T20:39:12 | Urchade Zaratiana, Nadi Tomeh, Pierre Holat, Thierry Charnois | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Named Entity Recognition (NER) is essential in various Natural Language
Processing (NLP) applications. Traditional NER models are effective but limited
to a set of predefined entity types. In contrast, Large Language Models (LLMs)
can extract arbitrary entities through natural language instructions, offering
greater flexibility. However, their size and cost, particularly for those
accessed via APIs like ChatGPT, make them impractical in resource-limited
scenarios. In this paper, we introduce a compact NER model trained to identify
any type of entity. Leveraging a bidirectional transformer encoder, our model,
GLiNER, facilitates parallel entity extraction, an advantage over the slow
sequential token generation of LLMs. Through comprehensive testing, GLiNER
demonstrate strong performance, outperforming both ChatGPT and fine-tuned LLMs
in zero-shot evaluations on various NER benchmarks. | [
0.0344035774,
0.0381435901,
0.0321854576,
0.0537447855,
-0.009807514,
0.0636913627,
-0.0055966154,
0.0057101473,
0.0087287957,
-0.0574715771,
-0.0262573343,
-0.0289529599,
-0.0204022266,
0.0184932426,
0.0336074121,
-0.018706508,
0.0245194118,
-0.0160583947,
0.0178226549,
0.0240876935,
-0.0223879758,
0.0145343048,
-0.0160832927,
0.0225656331,
0.0142840035,
0.0056877169,
-0.0172915272,
0.0126273111,
0.0288110115,
-0.068407245,
0.0140382396,
0.0132939387,
-0.0098068118,
0.0363954306,
0.000002006,
-0.0121902516,
-0.0656106248,
0.0220872108,
-0.0409650318,
-0.0391817428,
0.0083266497,
-0.0343366079,
-0.0171877109,
0.0077807968,
0.0059041814,
-0.0794042274,
0.0322605409,
0.079562895,
0.0301918369,
0.0868056193,
-0.020960683,
-0.0560238436,
0.0496450588,
-0.0172999036,
-0.0378379636,
-0.0311708953,
0.0339817964,
-0.0359179713,
-0.0295874216,
0.041134458,
0.0042417613,
0.0152667696,
0.0083308164,
0.0405785255,
0.0083305659,
0.0355647877,
-0.0397643931,
0.0004932334,
-0.0378961302,
0.0729499608,
-0.0498833694,
0.0116825635,
0.0464740731,
-0.0068154009,
-0.0306057502,
-0.0221540369,
-0.0222230963,
0.0329015665,
-0.0310986564,
0.0020702137,
0.0216379873,
0.0246666577,
0.0106503805,
-0.0214465559,
-0.0121612111,
-0.0083095748,
0.0341454707,
-0.0353729054,
0.0020071012,
0.0056949519,
-0.0174772665,
-0.0480471216,
0.0402418636,
0.0277219135,
0.0205171499,
0.0139265563,
0.008010936,
-0.0187585391,
0.0008830974,
-0.0393205844,
-0.0098262308,
0.0321822092,
-0.0036894511,
0.0457950197,
-0.0722380355,
0.0422994122,
-0.0133811533,
0.0248952974,
0.0332566909,
-0.0555871241,
-0.0230476726,
-0.014283929,
-0.0349985845,
0.0625938997,
-0.0516606607,
-0.0157793332,
-0.0077602714,
0.0141367167,
0.0116272867,
0.0101248641,
0.054061193,
-0.0000761099,
-0.007541318,
-0.0209732652,
-0.0028924278,
0.0389221311,
-0.0129115898,
-0.0180060379,
-0.016136365,
-0.0607750639,
-0.0121227484,
-0.0050068609,
0.0448910482,
-0.052991204,
0.0385723598,
0.0941738337,
0.0113363024,
-0.1004324928,
-0.0698966309,
0.0140935406,
0.0226927754,
-0.0384845473,
-0.0009652298,
-0.0303738397,
0.0579292849,
0.0249119867,
0.0248569567,
-0.0501208529,
0.0114815217,
0.0059689009,
-0.038978599,
0.0785367414,
-0.0173715912,
-0.0172234531,
0.0106913,
-0.0015496089,
0.0181422327,
0.0482679904,
0.0546195321,
0.0331592001,
0.0324678794,
-0.029632289,
0.0074503454,
0.0397538021,
-0.0025803742,
-0.0406922214,
0.023180766,
0.0079937987,
0.0121714128,
0.0050751404,
0.0302151777,
0.0888175145,
-0.0079863863,
-0.0188952219,
0.0258221794,
0.0492539927,
0.0028587275,
0.0340729803,
0.0506933145,
0.0115010515,
-0.0299257189,
-0.044939585,
-0.0141518898,
0.0273234621,
-0.0022851201,
0.0046336106,
0.0285257269,
0.0703155026,
-0.0336468816,
0.0120536461,
0.0082529336,
-0.0196113382,
0.0126432404,
-0.0180037767,
0.0517110638,
0.0222106483,
-0.0972707942,
0.0815368816,
0.0237520952,
-0.0339854062,
-0.0010010472,
-0.0407471508,
-0.0019579993,
0.0246957298,
0.0516347848,
0.0071720905,
-0.050008066,
-0.0458248146,
-0.0558930412,
0.080663234,
0.0118011571,
-0.0105541032,
0.0286634509,
-0.045884151,
0.0065457514,
0.0317868553,
0.0111585483,
0.0424891151,
0.0426268838,
0.0471250042,
0.0247190762,
0.0031627067,
-0.0026070345,
0.0505199283,
-0.0444323234,
-0.0486087464,
0.0144301653,
0.013975393,
0.0148826176,
0.0295948032,
0.0023802188,
-0.030909216,
0.0384715386,
-0.0409807041,
-0.045072563,
-0.0065817763,
-0.0038703925,
-0.0559318103,
-0.0041208728,
-0.0110811964,
-0.0020548708,
0.0363582373,
-0.0363499485,
-0.0450737998,
-0.0535686202,
0.0117117045,
0.0605365708,
-0.017898988,
0.0312451888,
0.0446447991,
0.0415346026,
-0.0012574991,
0.0487244464,
-0.0197200961,
0.017843917,
-0.0058184452,
-0.0201181658,
-0.0147112329,
-0.0287438594,
-0.0669511184,
0.0376041271,
-0.0108730411,
-0.0284877177,
0.0058325464,
-0.0029609164,
-0.0291154478,
-0.039441403,
-0.1079064757,
0.0280464906,
-0.0249729492,
0.0562975369,
0.0181419626,
0.0444968157,
-0.022602221,
-0.0131843854,
0.0035542573,
-0.0130113689,
-0.0065466706,
-0.0004081431,
0.0279923361,
-0.0054054656,
-0.0404319428,
0.0156808998,
0.0051943394,
-0.0190296713,
0.0392185859,
0.028748164,
-0.0385383032,
-0.0647943839,
0.0226376336,
0.0014500367,
0.009963071,
0.0074848644,
-0.0266026836,
-0.0236328058,
0.0325973481,
0.0159447249,
0.0454351455,
0.0249305759,
0.0267623123,
-0.0685692504,
-0.0243492387,
-0.0340448506,
0.0399113148,
-0.0397196822,
0.018464515,
-0.005491876,
-0.0296251811,
0.0400702953,
0.0938221887,
-0.0306720175,
0.0208285935,
-0.0395026021,
-0.0128596509,
0.0077248258,
0.0086393263,
0.0196791794,
0.0298623294,
-0.0220085215,
-0.0269797947,
-0.0202600379,
0.0011666378,
0.0367711112,
-0.0696778595,
-0.0296894107,
-0.0049640117,
0.0133397393,
-0.066267617,
0.0575953834,
0.0369945057,
0.0058743502,
0.0074536889,
-0.0776714534,
0.0334062055,
0.0530736707,
-0.0406698547,
-0.0294982642,
0.0401899479,
0.0157422386,
0.0233996715,
-0.0379240774,
-0.0414607786,
-0.054114949,
-0.0262771975,
-0.0424038246,
0.0245330259,
0.0327045061,
-0.0198072065,
-0.03433799,
0.0569115728,
-0.0091822995,
0.0585823953,
-0.0079035768,
-0.0019574307,
-0.0386440307,
0.0403585285,
0.0347192809,
0.0084635895,
0.0196502227,
0.011167313,
0.0097232955,
0.0509070493,
-0.0214470625,
-0.0160679519,
-0.0135838035,
-0.0200292356,
0.0084917592,
-0.0740173012,
0.0263826922,
-0.0130099561,
0.040022891,
-0.0404489823,
-0.0051214164,
0.1246059835,
-0.0123711247,
-0.040941231,
-0.0277680904,
0.0297423117,
-0.0091993259,
0.0048725875,
0.0168149825,
-0.074137561,
-0.0742305517,
0.0207071658,
-0.0068340716,
0.0025427954,
-0.0602040999,
-0.0105323605,
-0.119266279,
-0.0070508053,
-0.0249324143,
-0.0599946491,
-0.0015021522,
-0.0550152101,
-0.0004334116,
-0.0457000434,
0.0025482993,
0.000170899,
-0.0472263694,
-0.0180756301,
-0.001005633,
-0.0101801306,
-0.0244329628,
0.0244716741,
-0.0552158915,
0.0388334394,
0.0023313768,
0.0174848307,
-0.0173302535,
-0.0186800007,
0.0208334792,
-0.0528842844,
-0.033462774,
-0.0075586671,
0.0388484634,
-0.0887982398,
-0.0098590869,
-0.0101899412,
-0.0019368542,
-0.0590840951,
-0.0052047912,
-0.0043050023,
0.0609956942,
0.0118660014,
0.0115860645,
0.0085540777,
-0.0490229726,
-0.0017288919,
0.0988362506,
-0.0088896696,
-0.0231968183,
-0.0319668166,
-0.0191268492,
-0.0081589809,
-0.0272561125,
-0.0349205397,
0.0036282919,
0.0014556649,
-0.0598170608,
-0.0225495528,
-0.0285402332,
0.0437489003,
0.0185448769,
0.0121204909,
-0.0036168431,
0.0494690686,
0.0212405752,
-0.0612805411,
0.0382092521,
-0.0456111394,
-0.0090651605,
-0.1005121842,
-0.0134258214,
0.0469049998,
0.0084398128,
-0.0524881594,
0.0334996991,
-0.0854636878,
-0.048140727,
-0.0144147761,
0.0318510123,
0.0098228464,
0.0299718268,
-0.0070166793,
0.0117490767,
0.0152781056,
0.0742737129,
-0.0789276436,
-0.022350356,
0.0039468659,
0.0243256968,
-0.0235233381,
0.0197096523,
-0.0283253286,
0.0086381445,
0.0120785506,
0.0473893881,
-0.0355178192,
-0.0222186875,
-0.0047401064,
0.025334876,
0.0567293353,
-0.0053746155,
0.0038799213,
-0.0466608778,
0.0149058122,
0.0046225125,
0.0398845412,
-0.0292537734,
-0.0215041135,
0.0033858325,
-0.0051348228,
-0.0226322114,
0.0438645184,
-0.0068344357,
0.007154204,
-0.0354797132,
0.0099642137,
-0.0162315089,
0.0076787574,
0.0169502757,
-0.0337527916,
0.0046145623,
0.0127662448,
0.0593781583,
0.0341828205,
-0.0408596471,
0.0405930206,
0.0070754215,
0.0276469495,
-0.0302725527,
0.0374900624,
-0.017417416,
-0.0052092113,
-0.0444753096,
0.0543208905,
0.0480009913,
0.0105128502,
0.0485976525,
0.0081351902,
0.0060755722,
0.0092145605,
0.0269869845,
-0.0181348473,
-0.0183812845,
0.0346140265,
0.0169667322,
-0.0317125544,
-0.0308815893,
0.0607625283,
-0.0128852939,
0.0384890214,
0.0255618747,
-0.0063553215,
-0.0591526069,
-0.0218780432,
0.0320545696,
-0.0402959809,
-0.0004307161,
0.0133704748,
-0.0160702486,
-0.0510080606,
0.0350384191,
-0.0399378911,
0.0081139114,
-0.0219137613,
0.0303278565,
0.0087159881,
0.0133903399,
-0.0556088015,
-0.030169569,
0.0232873131,
-0.0142549658,
-0.0193821024,
-0.0174375195,
-6.557490828e-33,
-0.0507034175,
-0.0273130126,
0.0318178833,
0.0044827461,
-0.0094997771,
0.0330683067,
-0.020941183,
-0.0146598192,
0.029125059,
-0.0416964144,
-0.0059396029,
-0.0026684371,
0.0318334661,
0.0489893407,
-0.0162369851,
-0.0377836414,
0.0728723481,
0.0214094352,
-0.0072188573,
0.0170913171,
0.0379525572,
0.0634059906,
0.0726601258,
-0.0435215868,
0.0021407467,
-0.0199797694,
0.0146352816,
-0.0215551443,
0.0742755085,
0.0506586321,
-0.0572286956,
-0.0238170624,
0.0253690146,
-0.0906279236,
0.0256801751,
0.0265691653,
-0.1420883536,
0.0154335676,
-0.0307102334,
0.0512195826,
-0.0159671865,
-0.0368089788,
0.0467694215,
-0.0109783402,
0.0145198861,
0.0124987764,
0.010083938,
0.0033881853,
0.009294902,
-0.0188356061,
-0.0540060662,
0.0449830703,
0.0159133449,
0.0222386643,
0.0541667417,
-0.0146188857,
0.0250749066,
0.017434353,
-0.0819421038,
-0.0366653427,
0.0010753069,
-0.0210431702,
0.0216760188,
0.0176093765,
0.007523099,
0.0527563803,
0.012829897,
-0.0328627117,
-0.0420526192,
0.0219949447,
-0.0219929796,
0.013940786,
-0.0051899138,
0.0199421626,
0.0758209452,
-0.0389224365,
-0.0648711249,
0.0318986289,
0.0138766048,
0.0268054083,
0.017432306,
-0.0137606338,
-0.0421556309,
0.025448313,
0.0294345096,
-0.0501043051,
-0.0218385682,
-0.0136836991,
0.0430141389,
0.0390614942,
-0.0331103578,
0.0300983954,
0.0573471226,
-0.0281189717,
-0.016457092,
0.0255734548,
0.02487568,
0.009483465,
-0.0119962916,
0.0152475862,
-0.0597984791,
-0.0656974465,
0.0116566233,
-0.0035210866,
0.0207749363,
0.0021398866,
0.0402840525,
-0.0012442365,
-0.0867309347,
0.0026403903,
-0.0159389712,
0.0536822118,
-0.0319820382,
0.0523157418,
0.0211981498,
0.0134594627,
-0.0174966007,
0.0412281342,
0.0348911732,
-0.0023426653,
-0.0201432314,
0.0389282592,
0.033982344,
0.0228635669,
-0.0222538076,
0.0079286834,
-0.0117304474,
0.0058078766,
-0.012784414,
-0.070545502,
-0.0015321657,
0.0053287698,
2.748e-7,
0.0054458412,
0.0189544782,
0.0330950134,
-0.0025475568,
-0.002063748,
0.0088736583,
0.0400869139,
0.0438691489,
-0.0054930132,
0.0072279917,
-0.0274297502,
0.0015463192,
0.0191921573,
0.0217704754,
-0.1336086839,
-0.0121723153,
-0.047666274,
0.0089607704,
-0.0594164766,
0.0379108898,
0.0552492701,
0.0814476013,
-0.0175710954,
-0.0013624101,
-0.0415922776,
-0.0306677818,
0.0609513745,
0.0066392845,
0.0253238026,
0.0490113795,
0.0044947402,
0.0845166892,
-0.025506584,
0.0198787395,
0.0027451271,
0.0467209518,
0.0092804478,
0.0753227919,
-0.0116434395,
-0.0178066082,
0.0183163751,
-0.031327825,
-0.0059764963,
-0.0117454734,
0.1050660536,
-0.0528858602,
-0.0254293941,
0.0034211348,
-0.0336007513,
0.0205071494,
-0.0242251102,
0.0078044971,
-0.0180623941,
0.0309938081,
0.0426778123,
-0.0476007275,
-0.0204370786,
-0.08618588,
0.032323923,
-0.0089973062,
-0.0445805527,
0.0119673964,
-0.0286394712,
-0.0219724532,
0.0218065027,
-0.028973924,
-0.0013941772,
2.681783832e-34,
0.0068573439,
0.0167069491,
-0.0375875235,
0.0513456687,
0.0329389982,
-0.020657504,
-0.0126157962,
-0.0139520261,
-0.0543599054,
-0.0575188994,
-0.0064334227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08516v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08516v3 | LLMs cannot find reasoning errors, but can correct them given the error location | 2023-11-14T20:12:38 | 2024-06-04T10:25:13 | Gladys Tyen, Hassan Mansoor, Victor Cărbune, Peter Chen, Tony Mak | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | While self-correction has shown promise in improving LLM outputs in terms of
style and quality (e.g. Chen et al., 2023b; Madaan et al., 2023), recent
attempts to self-correct logical or reasoning errors often cause correct
answers to become incorrect, resulting in worse performances overall (Huang et
al., 2023). In this paper, we show that poor self-correction performance stems
from LLMs' inability to find logical mistakes, rather than their ability to
correct a known mistake. Firstly, we benchmark several state-of-the-art LLMs on
their mistake-finding ability and demonstrate that they generally struggle with
the task, even in highly objective, unambiguous cases. Secondly, we test the
correction abilities of LLMs -- separately from mistake finding -- using a
backtracking setup that feeds ground truth mistake location information to the
model. We show that this boosts downstream task performance across our 5
reasoning tasks, indicating that LLMs' correction abilities are robust.
Finally, we show that it is possible to obtain mistake location information
without ground truth labels or in-domain training data. We train a small
classifier with out-of-domain data, which exhibits stronger mistake-finding
performance than prompting a large model. We release our dataset of
LLM-generated logical mistakes, BIG-Bench Mistake, to enable further research
into locating LLM reasoning mistakes. | [
0.0242327545,
0.0125582442,
0.005819859,
0.045028206,
-0.0068230424,
0.0291331057,
-0.0006631331,
0.0035648246,
0.0288141035,
-0.0369235948,
-0.0266978964,
0.002657186,
0.0023898182,
-0.0389428884,
0.052423656,
0.0204727389,
0.0705984458,
-0.0407956913,
-0.0083366847,
-0.0098476699,
-0.0233379118,
-0.0129290568,
-0.031844072,
-0.0121491542,
-0.0402539335,
-0.0603319854,
-0.044059962,
0.0416446328,
0.0271347538,
-0.0167303514,
0.0182416085,
0.0127928816,
-0.0036780967,
0.0336977616,
0.0000018732,
-0.0385936722,
-0.0191313662,
-0.026372144,
-0.0501646996,
0.0147060137,
-0.0491959676,
0.0265401043,
-0.0357437059,
0.0395037755,
-0.0175798889,
0.029390445,
0.006779389,
0.0705315471,
0.0673245564,
0.0944866836,
0.0392543413,
0.0111127142,
0.0182282589,
-0.0114100231,
0.0617091581,
-0.0343479849,
0.0078503937,
0.0195406508,
-0.0362115577,
-0.0066358191,
-0.024916321,
0.010132025,
0.0193826295,
-0.0189180784,
-0.0304291584,
0.007064336,
0.0066917138,
0.006060536,
-0.0337303914,
0.0232284069,
0.0057023503,
-0.02495059,
-0.0247220583,
-0.0192311052,
0.0395591035,
-0.0212020241,
-0.0077716429,
0.0393413305,
-0.0247084983,
0.0079475138,
0.0073179938,
-0.0674579367,
0.0484367982,
-0.003930938,
-0.0066895112,
0.1182367802,
-0.0297737215,
-0.0637403503,
0.0035277165,
0.0203790963,
0.0107442643,
-0.0604196079,
-0.0017448348,
0.0519850701,
-0.0345412157,
0.0104985442,
-0.0291300025,
0.0144068766,
0.0302246585,
-0.0136148483,
0.0458959937,
0.0178231914,
-0.0417990014,
0.032300815,
-0.033724755,
0.0486917049,
0.0043382398,
0.0904319137,
-0.0036066978,
0.001862572,
-0.0007934629,
-0.0332340114,
0.0044568228,
0.0545648113,
-0.0048541576,
0.0377860703,
-0.0591868944,
0.0118460637,
-0.0434456468,
0.0725951642,
-0.0084621944,
0.0285444707,
-0.0030917334,
-0.0380258225,
-0.0694459453,
-0.0051655839,
0.0133100413,
0.0461960621,
0.0491543822,
-0.0609124452,
-0.0389822386,
0.0151747623,
-0.015246205,
0.0153258163,
0.0357558578,
0.0669962019,
-0.0073378403,
-0.0094295563,
-0.0877150595,
-0.022089215,
-0.0179468505,
-0.0532551147,
0.0122933388,
-0.0662693158,
-0.0073077166,
-0.0275570955,
-0.0037571276,
-0.0391822532,
0.0261341501,
0.0124141313,
0.0062390994,
0.0956499949,
-0.0245523266,
0.0171352644,
0.0310769789,
0.0099102752,
-0.0146244681,
0.0312441885,
0.0322236903,
0.0109164286,
0.0456805862,
-0.003278499,
0.0360926986,
-0.0108314417,
0.0231790319,
-0.0141171142,
-0.0219256636,
0.0010578958,
-0.0458310246,
0.051567506,
0.0436384343,
0.0364514105,
-0.0159675274,
0.0094394712,
0.0373499356,
0.0305903107,
0.0349284522,
-0.002186578,
0.0020535195,
-0.0536450893,
0.004710021,
0.010385232,
-0.0844897479,
0.0270422455,
-0.052021157,
0.0003573147,
0.0404315218,
-0.0295044947,
-0.012584134,
-0.0804297924,
-0.0218711104,
0.0016513063,
-0.0415853485,
0.0175677482,
0.0304181017,
0.0319057144,
-0.0259587001,
0.0926970616,
-0.0099514313,
-0.0619540922,
-0.0280498508,
-0.067153953,
0.0391043052,
0.0385636836,
0.0180527829,
-0.0328743644,
-0.0671021193,
-0.0181470122,
0.0144826723,
0.0307915434,
0.0502420329,
0.0074363276,
-0.0098211197,
-0.0221453961,
0.0038014529,
-0.0512517877,
0.0249993131,
-0.0319208801,
0.0335475728,
0.0020481206,
0.0025356086,
-0.0600066446,
0.0290333461,
0.0266763475,
-0.0328501277,
-0.028453039,
-0.0043910882,
-0.0004812676,
0.0066646873,
-0.0031977682,
0.0055513601,
0.0305936355,
0.0010945835,
0.0139676975,
-0.0687980279,
-0.0452933758,
-0.0294242725,
-0.0437217467,
0.0705854744,
-0.0386279114,
-0.0697406605,
0.0055413442,
-0.0874256715,
-0.0190204829,
-0.0059878295,
-0.0225376114,
-0.0516053624,
-0.0302479304,
0.0296819191,
0.0180196278,
-0.0352409072,
-0.00509405,
0.0544339307,
-0.0348033123,
0.0149161136,
-0.0147101777,
0.0271871705,
-0.0113182245,
-0.0609667227,
0.0386850126,
-0.034838248,
-0.0204981845,
0.0296898913,
-0.0348539501,
0.0096866982,
-0.0567766502,
-0.0501325913,
-0.0184517484,
0.0198703408,
-0.0106233275,
0.0322853923,
0.0075483285,
-0.0354638956,
-0.0153153995,
-0.0304387584,
-0.0175333787,
0.0191584751,
0.0229210127,
-0.0135016246,
0.045971632,
-0.0429259501,
0.0165217109,
-0.0295438766,
0.0071650022,
-0.0351545922,
-0.0286324415,
-0.0338341929,
-0.0006726048,
-0.0891226083,
0.0597083978,
-0.0467627496,
0.0065367119,
0.0041110399,
-0.0285887141,
0.0316725411,
-0.0252674613,
-0.0307672806,
0.0695555285,
-0.0053600627,
0.0014374516,
0.0580262765,
-0.0438757204,
-0.0532274097,
0.0582964458,
0.0297713168,
-0.0106901368,
-0.0298583992,
-0.0195596311,
-0.0316195041,
0.0268861055,
-0.0003079403,
0.0023722118,
0.0035182966,
0.0224178322,
0.0233696215,
-0.0208545402,
-0.0008366099,
0.0101937819,
-0.0084413271,
0.0663944706,
-0.0179280471,
-0.0479000323,
0.0691347048,
0.0124908583,
0.0287250783,
0.0314237438,
-0.0123251099,
-0.032765016,
0.0203167945,
-0.0401673019,
-0.0201995503,
-0.0001104311,
-0.0355132408,
-0.0513806753,
-0.0469066054,
0.0436348692,
-0.0558538996,
0.0885065049,
-0.0546422265,
-0.0039584269,
-0.019262692,
-0.0654245839,
-0.0552571192,
0.0090816608,
-0.0341666378,
-0.0395435393,
-0.0616226308,
-0.0042536203,
-0.0218095202,
-0.0591810606,
0.0078849327,
-0.0018528069,
-0.0188626945,
-0.0243838672,
-0.0241573527,
-0.0206206348,
0.0062630191,
0.0833026767,
0.0840433314,
-0.043771714,
0.0219304506,
0.0775589347,
0.0152576659,
0.0065865638,
-0.0213243384,
0.0137501433,
0.0135713099,
-0.0189204328,
-0.0247966424,
0.0066427831,
0.0694136694,
-0.0692436844,
-0.028006902,
0.0836380348,
0.0236682054,
0.0264536776,
-0.0149666257,
-0.0384920128,
-0.0479654148,
0.0302569941,
-0.0055092601,
-0.055355452,
-0.0455815569,
0.0559803583,
0.0388969146,
0.0058589755,
-0.0056938361,
0.0152707556,
-0.1217604503,
0.0620337203,
0.0390207134,
0.0030911819,
-0.0443549454,
-0.0158614218,
0.0012330364,
0.0124063538,
0.0381500572,
0.0481758602,
-0.0082486477,
-0.023715226,
0.0183391199,
-0.0467509963,
-0.045743119,
0.0116323456,
-0.0289621074,
0.0455843285,
0.0480021983,
0.0218934417,
0.0044592414,
-0.0593908057,
0.072248213,
0.0239236243,
0.0267423708,
-0.0303235296,
0.048089508,
-0.0049584424,
0.0028446247,
-0.029245371,
0.0165615287,
-0.0358503684,
-0.0299800411,
-0.007720625,
0.0719880164,
-0.0583477765,
-0.0124896951,
-0.0177326947,
0.0243016239,
-0.0239731483,
0.0207903329,
0.0199052226,
0.0179877933,
-0.0908667222,
-0.0584968925,
-0.0059997099,
-0.0278083645,
-0.0019335435,
0.0613623746,
0.0331129581,
0.0221121162,
-0.0213555265,
-0.044397261,
0.0034104148,
0.0254383553,
-0.0259353649,
-0.0278006271,
-0.0467557013,
0.0001466337,
-0.0368627198,
-0.0064428225,
-0.0247558616,
0.0202333368,
-0.0369103849,
0.0611134395,
0.0044370773,
0.0145036727,
0.0271367673,
0.019579513,
-0.0706386045,
-0.0514541194,
-0.0070706229,
0.0694559067,
0.0181902125,
0.0323107056,
-0.0154199358,
-0.0438994355,
0.0238109063,
0.0737876371,
0.0120595274,
0.0582161173,
0.0413755998,
0.0090064108,
-0.0037649979,
0.0439037643,
-0.0447599292,
-0.0147192813,
0.0184873175,
0.0495580323,
-0.0388891213,
-0.0317150615,
0.031735789,
0.0309625491,
0.0556375943,
0.0267341025,
0.0368709266,
-0.0239876546,
0.0614471361,
-0.0164655615,
-0.0247122701,
-0.0000193996,
0.0209649429,
0.0131033119,
-0.0565268174,
0.0120735699,
-0.0011228622,
-0.0106913252,
0.0264508557,
-0.0118081309,
0.0177866928,
0.0150209656,
0.0061494531,
0.0036600612,
-0.012880601,
-0.0205670726,
0.011554867,
0.0412402973,
0.0529094078,
0.051740773,
0.0407666452,
0.0206084121,
0.0319151767,
-0.0293742791,
-0.0320142247,
-0.0673391446,
-0.0699363053,
-0.004765342,
0.0285849702,
0.0809175596,
0.0346740223,
0.0136330333,
-0.0198050551,
-0.0282397233,
-0.0036959639,
0.0170580968,
0.0261188317,
-0.012969791,
0.0620149709,
0.022149682,
-0.0017116629,
-0.0466996655,
0.0194829069,
-0.0137305865,
0.0595484786,
-0.0156116616,
-0.0086319642,
-0.0360133611,
-0.0362378135,
-0.0198300928,
-0.0319626778,
0.0143235214,
-0.0343376361,
-0.0408742651,
-0.0847816393,
0.0426438712,
0.0756698325,
0.0134483054,
-0.0356962718,
-0.0315396488,
0.0520155542,
0.0495328829,
-0.0501998775,
-0.0109491255,
0.0128197009,
-0.0068908473,
-0.0028685916,
-0.0067621344,
-5.779875968e-33,
-0.0631965697,
-0.0745938718,
0.053064663,
0.0059173536,
0.0134751787,
-0.0222000442,
-0.0145811886,
0.0095790233,
0.0003560866,
0.0547751635,
-0.0404384024,
0.0816985443,
0.0104807317,
-0.0038498314,
0.0461645126,
-0.0318182297,
0.0429463461,
0.001128472,
-0.0264303535,
-0.0421479903,
0.0318629891,
0.0134970183,
0.0575525016,
-0.0658333153,
0.0109087611,
0.0252524242,
-0.0487249382,
0.0434472412,
-0.0780332163,
0.0415735729,
0.0376038291,
0.0201864652,
-0.0126494458,
0.0119598387,
-0.0167401284,
-0.0328289084,
-0.0588354617,
-0.0669988766,
-0.038754452,
0.008373159,
-0.0442191437,
-0.0388664305,
0.0588280074,
0.0313072242,
-0.0256277882,
-0.0452995524,
-0.0126586948,
-0.0278647095,
0.0095692007,
0.0039145583,
0.0165710971,
0.0193042886,
0.0028216534,
-0.025832301,
-0.0100758178,
0.0057990411,
0.0030670527,
-0.0264397226,
-0.0896330327,
-0.0154218869,
0.0432290509,
0.0010184188,
0.0591051169,
0.0081255976,
-0.0419643708,
0.0520456061,
0.038278006,
0.0377998427,
-0.0166877247,
-0.0217625238,
-0.0246740449,
0.055840753,
0.0601927079,
0.0327876098,
0.0379771851,
-0.0072801965,
-0.0574235283,
0.0219493378,
-0.034062393,
0.0503265411,
-0.0054308348,
-0.002227308,
-0.0230954811,
0.0129766138,
-0.0362004824,
0.0435077958,
-0.0307264347,
-0.010225323,
0.0277498942,
0.0300073829,
0.0307254624,
-0.0184062477,
-0.0420286693,
-0.0119175734,
-0.0155253056,
-0.0369205289,
0.013577803,
-0.0100066354,
-0.0156959761,
-0.0027841702,
-0.0301811993,
-0.016438853,
-0.0163463224,
0.0045394697,
0.0279482193,
0.0083160447,
0.0242816489,
0.0266892891,
-0.0995350778,
-0.0079027824,
-0.0031693163,
0.0348486379,
0.0050963629,
-0.038776949,
0.0296226405,
-0.0221988261,
0.0024454817,
0.0250606555,
-0.0184666291,
-0.0038786856,
-0.001090784,
0.0216852855,
-0.0102864262,
0.0174246449,
-0.0015218161,
0.0058061872,
-0.0177514404,
0.0116858128,
0.0037579648,
-0.0506249107,
0.0122773908,
0.0303648282,
2.63e-7,
0.0268037822,
0.0253384579,
0.0244522151,
0.0763081759,
0.0301579442,
0.0596385449,
-0.0505466685,
-0.0006972938,
0.0210571531,
-0.0264808517,
0.0044491552,
0.0502908006,
0.0666150749,
0.053360939,
-0.0245609973,
0.0359401889,
-0.0080571268,
-0.0100375311,
-0.003313632,
-0.0137864389,
0.0337762535,
0.0405439474,
0.0209640041,
-0.032805074,
0.0046853428,
-0.0145006347,
0.0654056147,
-0.0069029978,
-0.0016308882,
0.0275089573,
0.0683262274,
0.0039112102,
0.0115904147,
0.0437635183,
-0.005940129,
-0.0318619385,
-0.0298260022,
0.0294195842,
-0.0106824404,
-0.0486223064,
-0.0658495203,
-0.0015802255,
0.0519155078,
-0.0106539074,
0.0408232808,
-0.0113806464,
0.0031760682,
-0.0541358627,
0.0172909368,
-0.0312018059,
0.0353552178,
0.0040428811,
-0.0048063155,
0.0019761778,
0.0011958337,
0.0177634079,
-0.0099834939,
-0.0774952248,
-0.0241008587,
0.0313756019,
-0.0040682862,
-0.0396322012,
0.005980372,
0.067178227,
0.0387098193,
-0.0494391248,
-0.0301507004,
2.1491127e-34,
0.0224341154,
-0.0265756156,
0.0078924485,
0.0362273008,
0.0430078059,
0.020594405,
-0.0294876099,
0.0035802226,
0.0083393855,
0.0133522106,
-0.0250309557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08511v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08511v1 | CoRE-CoG: Conversational Recommendation of Entities using Constrained Generation | 2023-11-14T20:07:34 | 2023-11-14T20:07:34 | Harshvardhan Srivastava, Kanav Pruthi, Soumen Chakrabarti, Mausam | cs.CL | cs.CL | End-to-end conversational recommendation systems (CRS) generate responses by
leveraging both dialog history and a knowledge base (KB). A CRS mainly faces
three key challenges: (1) at each turn, it must decide if recommending a KB
entity is appropriate; if so, it must identify the most relevant KB entity to
recommend; and finally, it must recommend the entity in a fluent utterance that
is consistent with the conversation history. Recent CRSs do not pay sufficient
attention to these desiderata, often generating unfluent responses or not
recommending (relevant) entities at the right turn. We introduce a new CRS we
call CoRE-CoG. CoRE-CoG addresses the limitations in prior systems by
implementing (1) a recommendation trigger that decides if the system utterance
should include an entity, (2) a type pruning module that improves the relevance
of recommended entities, and (3) a novel constrained response generator to make
recommendations while maintaining fluency. Together, these modules ensure
simultaneous accurate recommendation decisions and fluent system utterances.
Experiments with recent benchmarks show the superiority particularly on
conditional generation sub-tasks with close to 10 F1 and 4 Recall@1 percent
points gain over baselines. | [
0.0867598131,
0.038666077,
0.0098203886,
-0.0201024525,
0.0023027635,
-0.022835115,
0.0146648055,
-0.0160363782,
0.0288720578,
-0.0321902707,
-0.0143014314,
-0.0107909543,
-0.0325211585,
0.0699937865,
-0.0023208065,
-0.0298810303,
0.0455964282,
-0.0068759643,
0.014928652,
0.004670376,
0.0237436313,
0.0134238936,
-0.0245655794,
0.0689419061,
-0.0121200178,
-0.0090583349,
-0.0223603472,
-0.0163701493,
-0.0112250159,
-0.0047662486,
0.0329051539,
0.0461774208,
0.0236115791,
-0.0017869179,
0.0000020325,
-0.037037693,
-0.0158281624,
-0.047216665,
-0.0352979489,
-0.0489838943,
-0.0110757099,
0.0615666993,
0.0025941161,
-0.0034249797,
-0.0428067818,
0.0315323062,
0.0387367979,
0.0386705063,
0.0106483828,
0.0667097867,
-0.0158448275,
0.0383025482,
0.013026109,
-0.02179428,
0.0281054154,
-0.0146886064,
-0.0174357574,
-0.0205769036,
0.0450489111,
0.0191695113,
0.0277128238,
0.0047371858,
0.0030764928,
-0.050412111,
0.0684384555,
0.0468037948,
-0.0261985399,
-0.0229987632,
0.0069163274,
0.1179858744,
0.0440510474,
0.0053640199,
0.0248723105,
0.0052605229,
0.0084716743,
-0.0568759181,
-0.0189251248,
-0.0389901474,
-0.0418196879,
-0.0060073929,
-0.0470433943,
0.013533188,
-0.0109367492,
0.0011664334,
-0.0002681,
0.0381018892,
0.0113084028,
-0.0257163551,
0.012558355,
-0.0001345903,
-0.0015862641,
-0.077461414,
0.0402710773,
0.0361803323,
-0.1133611277,
-0.0056683691,
-0.0453383811,
0.0448898338,
0.0039209155,
-0.0076610097,
-0.024858214,
0.0395104513,
0.0249696784,
0.0111445803,
0.0091569545,
0.0431719199,
0.0174597297,
-0.0427196175,
-0.0327931345,
-0.0089653181,
-0.0215593595,
-0.0154051753,
-0.0402647108,
0.0724079162,
-0.0677804798,
-0.0414370708,
-0.0538704619,
0.0421070792,
-0.0199693274,
0.0202694014,
-0.0131802503,
0.0887110606,
-0.0344016664,
0.0162995309,
-0.0741886571,
0.0204055421,
-0.060559202,
0.0088044722,
0.0591198467,
-0.0484814011,
0.0088100536,
0.0093550822,
0.0100267138,
-0.0422858745,
-0.0062557762,
0.0459434278,
-0.0299482085,
-0.0432890281,
-0.0141487531,
-0.0285539944,
-0.0577241406,
-0.071655646,
-0.0300749652,
-0.061555136,
0.0053114258,
0.0253509842,
-0.0394541733,
-0.025074482,
0.0432772748,
0.0219698157,
-0.000895322,
0.0348124579,
-0.0022913141,
-0.0179691985,
0.0052973544,
0.0210976508,
-0.0369539112,
0.0361463949,
0.0315394029,
0.0449736975,
0.0202546753,
0.0249309484,
0.0243522096,
-0.0107642654,
0.0101230033,
-0.0077477088,
0.0069814939,
0.0307234861,
-0.0498108864,
0.0325764157,
0.0701316372,
0.0504425913,
-0.053913679,
-0.0267440025,
0.0514098629,
0.001447571,
0.0016636787,
0.0583233573,
0.0504277982,
0.0310162492,
-0.034517359,
0.0121223312,
-0.0556860529,
0.0337917805,
-0.0230217557,
-0.0254423171,
0.0400943905,
0.0152436672,
-0.0200010389,
-0.0329817161,
0.0597793534,
-0.0045103682,
0.0052574798,
0.0062006204,
0.0069574658,
0.015143862,
-0.0569708087,
0.0527328663,
0.0128590576,
-0.0628109053,
-0.0146770719,
-0.0198125672,
0.0647443905,
0.1106930599,
0.0691769123,
0.0178271439,
-0.0424473174,
0.010079666,
-0.0275670569,
0.0390077643,
0.0398917496,
-0.0227439888,
0.0407862626,
-0.0355603769,
-0.010273912,
0.0258928128,
-0.0112251565,
0.0453718938,
0.0220653396,
0.0342021137,
0.0273330025,
0.004845547,
0.016123645,
-0.0256359205,
0.0127129881,
-0.0111727053,
0.0411436036,
0.0094217891,
-0.0041002752,
0.0171617419,
0.0274807811,
0.0193642993,
0.016928792,
-0.0045273681,
-0.0248707198,
0.0249495506,
-0.0919649377,
-0.0334791951,
0.0062236278,
-0.0098120281,
-0.003748406,
-0.0112411669,
0.0199409034,
-0.0693264157,
0.0431310758,
-0.0263174959,
0.0571785606,
-0.0288751833,
0.001186027,
0.0604061149,
0.0042253453,
-0.0244380794,
0.0709392056,
0.0230140705,
-0.0077530337,
0.0510526076,
-0.0034568049,
0.0074325143,
-0.0868772343,
0.000287872,
-0.0081393644,
-0.0049288995,
-0.0123014953,
0.0387145057,
0.0117737837,
-0.0666077584,
-0.0253502894,
-0.1138567328,
0.0108519206,
0.0150428275,
-0.0158472061,
-0.0195456613,
0.0466623753,
0.0198241509,
-0.0296570603,
-0.0452013016,
0.0340446122,
0.0354153737,
0.0090770051,
0.0027360369,
0.038453754,
-0.0249378961,
-0.0521050431,
0.0339957885,
0.016517235,
0.0313322544,
-0.001149631,
0.0045138393,
-0.0264502633,
0.0288178381,
-0.059440203,
0.0472658835,
-0.0229852572,
0.0045067696,
0.0236887503,
-0.0002291862,
0.0665078908,
0.0126330927,
0.0286614895,
0.0127344849,
-0.009302265,
-0.0391439945,
-0.0985526368,
0.0515996553,
-0.0324894488,
0.0013719773,
-0.0220477302,
0.0167254899,
0.0044325446,
0.0108033847,
-0.0028399795,
0.0078435261,
-0.0610632077,
0.0213313028,
0.0701525062,
-0.0232709143,
-0.0311799403,
-0.0083441511,
-0.0293692891,
0.0223551821,
-0.0335636698,
-0.0171073638,
0.0451557189,
-0.0053358749,
-0.0303941946,
-0.0058785412,
-0.0189761184,
-0.0054278928,
-0.0004169495,
0.012240828,
0.0139470734,
0.0147234937,
-0.0448946804,
-0.0476770923,
0.0245196112,
-0.0124809556,
-0.0266679581,
0.06087799,
-0.0272688642,
0.0315584317,
0.0207466986,
-0.059378624,
-0.0812252387,
0.0149220088,
-0.0183400977,
0.0071374504,
0.040901728,
-0.0482262373,
-0.0405250527,
-0.0057054656,
0.0039031324,
0.0419904031,
0.0019057558,
-0.0153509192,
-0.0153467543,
0.0316115804,
0.0687493682,
0.0389959924,
0.0302474424,
0.0482548662,
0.0413222015,
0.0500992723,
0.0296441484,
-0.0416062772,
-0.0380723625,
-0.0112469178,
0.0101414369,
0.0047610262,
-0.0183203705,
0.0284083486,
0.0336209498,
0.0039120866,
-0.0506243818,
0.089333199,
0.0205425136,
-0.0593247525,
0.0169036295,
-0.0039892192,
0.0798707083,
0.0201387294,
0.0348320268,
-0.054426413,
-0.0352936275,
0.0199076086,
0.0478014089,
-0.0020893363,
-0.0598632842,
-0.0304224603,
-0.0979219452,
0.0182400066,
-0.020241186,
-0.0432324149,
-0.0223720446,
-0.0193985291,
-0.0050776065,
0.0049586818,
0.0014104554,
0.0234844573,
0.0092669474,
0.0207494702,
0.0062517771,
-0.0095133325,
-0.0037028433,
0.0306570381,
-0.0048217741,
0.0637596846,
0.0576162897,
0.0400610752,
0.0832593143,
-0.005113095,
-0.0101910522,
0.0000491155,
0.0090754004,
-0.0276834834,
0.0290449727,
-0.0153835285,
0.0133828055,
-0.042515181,
0.0168713294,
-0.0175224897,
-0.027614912,
0.0057966267,
0.0301003568,
-0.0520717017,
0.0054398021,
-0.035062898,
0.0560672358,
0.0713625252,
0.0674304292,
0.050659433,
-0.0393050835,
-0.036596749,
-0.0283105969,
0.0091534872,
-0.0822471753,
0.0263239983,
-0.0212265793,
0.0264022909,
0.0145440949,
-0.0903427377,
-0.038691856,
-0.0080124382,
0.0225926097,
-0.0101216044,
0.0002134997,
-0.0166283511,
0.0078258915,
0.0063087009,
0.0086714886,
0.0042191506,
-0.0104015106,
-0.0772000924,
-0.0193730928,
-0.00719018,
-0.066277124,
-0.0173995085,
0.05076617,
-0.0472889952,
-0.0560107306,
-0.0507919043,
0.0689048916,
0.0284624733,
0.0655971617,
-0.0301483814,
-0.0304601714,
0.0043198662,
0.0519591682,
-0.0687655509,
0.0080694985,
0.0232071094,
0.0479573123,
-0.0133551946,
0.0467397794,
-0.0615926497,
0.0086252643,
-0.0207858831,
0.0449955985,
-0.0059041884,
-0.0885727704,
-0.0016502149,
-0.014699447,
-0.0069685052,
-0.0327663161,
0.0130053647,
-0.0051508611,
0.0320234038,
-0.0032853459,
-0.0018668761,
-0.0650519654,
-0.0084157996,
-0.0089233797,
0.0072193216,
0.0208857525,
-0.0285767559,
-0.0409696773,
0.0919954106,
-0.0052779606,
-0.0279141366,
0.0277553648,
-0.0321402326,
0.0623656772,
-0.0071824957,
-0.0136456415,
0.0491959862,
0.0248968359,
0.0391205326,
-0.03435909,
0.0570196286,
0.000427626,
-0.0464688502,
-0.0031461744,
0.0040093926,
-0.0562853254,
-0.0282233283,
-0.0167624354,
0.0302619226,
0.0161747057,
0.0120151294,
0.0497920662,
-0.0269403923,
0.0198133308,
-0.0316874273,
0.0398501419,
-0.0036016649,
-0.0499796718,
0.0302888211,
0.0155207701,
-0.015750045,
0.0208186246,
0.0476908796,
-0.0514433123,
0.0248619318,
-0.0029691227,
0.000247181,
-0.0548832752,
-0.0505813062,
-0.0229023453,
0.0299659744,
-0.0104758982,
-0.0110452604,
-0.0449299403,
-0.0238120575,
0.0299882572,
-0.024667073,
-0.019194223,
-0.0213964395,
0.0710100234,
0.0385363474,
0.0026105912,
-0.042398911,
-0.0370207988,
0.0172473174,
-0.0477757268,
-0.0268731378,
-0.0641083866,
-5.875350354e-33,
-0.0267644227,
-0.0267346967,
0.0479545221,
-0.014970934,
-0.029845478,
-0.0324914753,
-0.0435225852,
0.0094294418,
0.0252936967,
-0.0130900545,
-0.0260850154,
-0.0179428514,
-0.0064442512,
0.025625078,
-0.0229519196,
-0.0101880273,
0.0482669771,
0.0172107667,
-0.0317748152,
0.0839815885,
0.0859654993,
0.0614195801,
0.0215689894,
-0.0571625084,
-0.0035968386,
-0.0077800304,
0.0014286658,
0.0093910601,
-0.0006528044,
0.0625041425,
-0.0246291086,
0.0542925037,
-0.0002316291,
0.0011086784,
-0.0009718898,
0.0284669604,
-0.0779844001,
-0.0222054403,
0.0252031125,
-0.0274445601,
-0.0134411491,
-0.0435189977,
0.0012259709,
-0.0241246317,
-0.002504857,
0.0302370004,
0.0327015929,
-0.0115766535,
-0.0436918959,
-0.0210352205,
-0.0255834479,
-0.0055226609,
-0.0078092483,
-0.0125644375,
-0.0618056655,
0.1371243745,
-0.0085962415,
-0.0174739305,
-0.0165499877,
0.0496333726,
0.0087641962,
0.0242662914,
0.0073204306,
-0.0041508153,
-0.0366179571,
0.0536375493,
0.007770265,
-0.0385598987,
-0.0244953427,
-0.0023359959,
-0.0044567105,
0.0600885972,
-0.0010283116,
0.0684779584,
0.0071505164,
-0.0077378876,
-0.0235464144,
0.041290015,
-0.0129402047,
0.0343550816,
0.007186735,
-0.000789197,
-0.0474152863,
-0.0209748056,
-0.0078321965,
0.0166380331,
-0.0409208126,
-0.0634897575,
0.0520793684,
0.0544249453,
-0.0061791111,
-0.0346238278,
0.0427508987,
-0.0063499645,
-0.0131965121,
0.0297155753,
-0.0320109539,
-0.0378160588,
0.0235365424,
-0.016356511,
-0.0757658705,
-0.0079743117,
0.1011598632,
-0.0118993688,
-0.033616472,
0.0293618143,
0.001732566,
0.0092572244,
-0.0132022994,
0.0218206402,
-0.0342402123,
0.060458988,
-0.0432960764,
0.0188955236,
0.0137106841,
0.0044596335,
-0.0540687367,
0.0334562697,
-0.0269084144,
0.0295250397,
-0.0363911353,
-0.0514289849,
0.0434324294,
0.0322259627,
-0.035422571,
-0.0137928445,
-0.002380609,
-0.0085541504,
0.0051781,
-0.046631813,
-0.0071659116,
-0.0088557797,
2.809e-7,
-0.0304292236,
-0.0031813346,
0.0139058372,
-0.0117133316,
-0.0011078682,
0.0246123746,
0.0489174761,
0.0305554196,
0.0170371942,
0.0004634661,
0.0094081182,
-0.0010700296,
0.0215257052,
0.0226185191,
-0.071357362,
-0.0114089306,
-0.039216239,
-0.0190389995,
-0.0359633751,
-0.0341800228,
0.0288199503,
0.055742424,
0.0172648672,
-0.0074133351,
0.0318089873,
-0.0238187108,
0.0423365012,
-0.0519716814,
0.0001270168,
-0.0184465181,
0.0597664118,
0.0003134146,
-0.020231368,
0.0161519013,
-0.014368061,
0.0089112697,
0.0038613537,
0.0421247296,
0.0046842438,
-0.0906857923,
-0.0034941568,
0.0095478278,
0.0230577774,
-0.0297960788,
0.0481367931,
-0.0214858092,
0.0246543027,
-0.0042109098,
-0.0490500033,
-0.0121083017,
-0.0319858789,
-0.0098637436,
-0.0154735791,
-0.0208659507,
-0.0017764706,
0.0238889791,
0.0100465538,
-0.0726474524,
0.0175056607,
-0.0128737362,
-0.0492749549,
-0.0510922,
-0.0545577295,
-0.0120073445,
-0.0224741511,
-0.0390024036,
0.0044637346,
2.494183429e-34,
-0.0037664883,
0.0519835427,
-0.0004241313,
0.0173068289,
0.0280497875,
0.013024562,
-0.0093479324,
0.0036003531,
0.0702244788,
-0.0583600886,
-0.055909466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08505v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08505v2 | Semi-Structured Chain-of-Thought: Integrating Multiple Sources of Knowledge for Improved Language Model Reasoning | 2023-11-14T19:53:53 | 2024-04-02T03:36:32 | Xin Su, Tiep Le, Steven Bethard, Phillip Howard | cs.CL | cs.CL | An important open question in the use of large language models for
knowledge-intensive tasks is how to effectively integrate knowledge from three
sources: the model's parametric memory, external structured knowledge, and
external unstructured knowledge. Most existing prompting methods either rely on
one or two of these sources, or require repeatedly invoking large language
models to generate similar or identical content. In this work, we overcome
these limitations by introducing a novel semi-structured prompting approach
that seamlessly integrates the model's parametric memory with unstructured
knowledge from text documents and structured knowledge from knowledge graphs.
Experimental results on open-domain multi-hop question answering datasets
demonstrate that our prompting method significantly surpasses existing
techniques, even exceeding those that require fine-tuning. | [
0.0373838022,
0.018207144,
0.0039557922,
0.045052398,
-0.0477768108,
0.0205056425,
-0.0115685929,
-0.0346116126,
0.0678864717,
-0.0901753902,
-0.0256655738,
-0.0146569936,
-0.0228490308,
0.0184356365,
0.0251106117,
-0.008710023,
0.0440196022,
-0.0694081411,
0.0120381629,
-0.0231722053,
-0.0140556274,
0.0336849876,
-0.007622865,
-0.0191053525,
0.0134744085,
-0.0334741212,
-0.0226648357,
0.0230203029,
-0.0025414871,
-0.0188137908,
0.0025555354,
0.0598431937,
0.0202128403,
0.0280555226,
0.0000019237,
-0.0543395355,
-0.0205387753,
-0.0171196032,
-0.0426966175,
-0.020823,
-0.0098677138,
0.0251879469,
0.029250171,
0.0143612744,
-0.036771901,
0.012166583,
0.0047725355,
0.0516841374,
0.0767432973,
0.0491750315,
0.0055226162,
-0.0010455429,
0.0178015083,
0.0028454368,
0.0175879505,
-0.0033024934,
0.0474506952,
0.0407037549,
0.0289647374,
0.0424188264,
-0.0056344173,
0.0459260382,
0.0213362705,
0.0009841606,
0.009612116,
0.0368239023,
-0.0308359731,
0.0201488733,
-0.0227156468,
0.0909004286,
0.0184600819,
-0.025559172,
0.0033384131,
0.0087450789,
-0.0006088006,
0.0568622276,
-0.0669514313,
0.0054308739,
-0.0229664333,
-0.0141897183,
0.0019616913,
0.0138929645,
0.0353409648,
0.008902858,
-0.0056906207,
0.0833910853,
0.0367792919,
-0.0525114462,
0.0151033374,
0.0114342878,
0.0074350243,
-0.0692880303,
-0.0111773396,
0.0482194647,
-0.0309125148,
0.0471685603,
-0.0301243979,
-0.0121279294,
0.0252607502,
-0.0337818787,
0.0120096346,
0.0252546929,
-0.0193741657,
0.090831019,
-0.0632755384,
0.0200084895,
-0.0449779257,
-0.0098685669,
-0.0518052988,
-0.0375329554,
-0.0880504996,
-0.0243331436,
-0.021974409,
0.0383674577,
-0.0075134677,
-0.0291904658,
-0.0008033577,
0.042772226,
0.0001001333,
0.0152872987,
0.0400728807,
0.0220686588,
0.0250370875,
-0.0115504591,
-0.0332622044,
0.0430629067,
-0.0423637331,
0.0124934539,
0.0109298835,
0.0013292708,
-0.026638085,
0.0000393248,
0.0190844759,
-0.0309708305,
0.0038890974,
0.0493989773,
0.0140488558,
0.0054169479,
-0.048141744,
-0.0625815615,
0.001041888,
-0.0463246889,
0.0369651727,
-0.0730080605,
0.0467355289,
0.0284794345,
-0.0229786746,
-0.0078543713,
0.0122233601,
0.0348742381,
-0.0543618724,
0.0659184828,
-0.0321369953,
-0.0051841415,
0.0062950593,
0.0200760756,
-0.0096926661,
0.0667899176,
-0.0178788938,
-0.0140988687,
0.031327121,
0.0313308612,
-0.0268200506,
0.0098766135,
0.0467249379,
0.0200208705,
0.0095682126,
0.0394997671,
0.0201609898,
-0.0099140108,
0.0123743135,
0.0355722196,
-0.0198480412,
-0.0252122972,
0.0257386584,
0.0293003358,
0.0101022646,
-0.022029154,
0.0591652021,
-0.008807864,
0.001754149,
0.0236178245,
-0.0421099067,
0.017783815,
-0.0686075687,
0.0294888262,
0.0263668634,
0.0460226648,
-0.0410842933,
-0.0002337104,
-0.0223103184,
-0.0014472781,
0.013065218,
0.0490691029,
0.044461906,
0.0303261988,
-0.0371500514,
0.0732935071,
0.0246875677,
-0.0058645215,
-0.0141824381,
-0.0234425738,
0.0398671068,
0.068403028,
0.0477253459,
-0.0231474899,
-0.0165434927,
-0.003672272,
0.0499260202,
0.0097772088,
0.0188439917,
-0.0398182161,
-0.0199654009,
-0.0466149934,
-0.0378440097,
-0.0191485062,
-0.013113251,
0.0203242954,
0.0309478901,
-0.0006798499,
0.0337701887,
-0.0398135781,
0.0271040071,
-0.0020845239,
-0.0395086072,
-0.0074417312,
-0.0204908047,
-0.001107576,
-0.0071638077,
0.0444498025,
0.0064886906,
0.0329100825,
0.030313991,
-0.0211090054,
-0.0657918975,
-0.0165982023,
-0.0543783195,
-0.0711316392,
0.0364043452,
0.0285442472,
-0.0372671857,
-0.0415926762,
-0.0366916135,
-0.0704478398,
0.0117893275,
0.0125775617,
0.0675674528,
-0.0290336013,
-0.0076633664,
0.0614766069,
-0.0271990914,
-0.045271229,
0.0999418944,
0.0003007468,
0.0364769027,
0.0365101323,
0.0096631981,
0.0130945379,
-0.0085711377,
-0.0028169102,
0.0145751135,
0.0041150628,
0.0024293009,
0.0049432847,
-0.0064034723,
-0.109285228,
-0.0000273704,
-0.0925002173,
0.0006311542,
-0.0005211528,
0.0188646335,
0.0222898033,
0.0265502986,
-0.0042930329,
-0.0305716954,
-0.0729182661,
-0.0141294235,
0.0055064633,
0.0323344246,
0.0111543899,
-0.0092072049,
0.000017358,
-0.0107491836,
-0.0265502632,
-0.0454509594,
0.0625071749,
0.0057898075,
-0.016949106,
-0.046050366,
0.0160343219,
-0.0708886161,
0.0353066251,
-0.0169891343,
0.00609176,
-0.0130276158,
-0.0229679774,
0.0740497634,
0.0457561687,
-0.0363973863,
-0.0464277491,
0.0627538711,
-0.0258541759,
-0.0516297258,
0.0090695117,
-0.0127506973,
0.0146901505,
0.0128395613,
0.0073279631,
-0.0036203167,
0.0455184355,
0.017954044,
-0.0180427432,
-0.0401131883,
0.0113058854,
-0.010016623,
0.0121077131,
-0.0605935007,
-0.0323459767,
0.0202169362,
0.0423402674,
-0.0205311514,
-0.0045968364,
0.092096433,
-0.0443672948,
0.0046899947,
-0.0151572628,
0.0018295151,
-0.0475307815,
0.0557108968,
-0.0076484601,
0.0183197763,
0.0012289027,
0.005852499,
-0.0480816066,
-0.0168389548,
0.0137812095,
-0.0260168836,
0.0200658031,
-0.0304501038,
0.048565153,
0.0210815631,
-0.0200916361,
-0.0609824397,
-0.0241403077,
-0.0543227233,
0.0236331727,
-0.0333004445,
-0.0246484,
0.0299525969,
-0.0018260956,
0.0199895222,
0.0236175973,
-0.0272644088,
-0.0084204441,
-0.0103097484,
0.0831658766,
0.0735513791,
-0.0144668473,
0.009649789,
-0.0189774521,
0.0541983768,
0.0517756604,
0.0497285463,
-0.0219281875,
-0.0064410875,
0.004063685,
0.007034759,
-0.038462393,
-0.010561415,
-0.0065591303,
0.0281220563,
-0.0314886719,
-0.0066519743,
0.1387101859,
0.04287415,
-0.0524436459,
-0.0212503038,
-0.0593044385,
0.050569091,
0.0299471598,
0.0387434922,
-0.0903420076,
-0.0476186089,
-0.0122755049,
-0.0071338192,
0.0170470644,
-0.0481548905,
0.0023048976,
-0.1058323979,
-0.005041095,
-0.0059120441,
-0.0142012527,
-0.0255627073,
-0.034950491,
0.0045727333,
0.0465082414,
-0.0568353161,
0.0151109826,
-0.021657005,
-0.0054918411,
0.0035369853,
0.0221382733,
-0.0187232569,
0.0515974537,
-0.0114773996,
0.0295720063,
0.011244827,
0.0082725137,
0.0434216298,
-0.0323867649,
0.0247131009,
-0.0174869169,
-0.0004427529,
-0.0251753759,
0.0266750418,
-0.0094695482,
0.0108069582,
-0.033431951,
0.0331386253,
-0.0759226903,
-0.0262087081,
0.0148927998,
0.1112667769,
-0.0017169779,
0.0061549949,
-0.0137128355,
0.0089481976,
0.0190369301,
0.0900582373,
0.0253494084,
0.00663818,
-0.0133745838,
-0.0315117501,
-0.0215543136,
-0.0014680462,
-0.0213640798,
0.0492792018,
-0.0006639691,
0.0400559567,
-0.0846285373,
-0.0368223712,
0.044284489,
0.0343029089,
-0.0149377454,
0.0429215133,
0.0192948468,
0.0004185122,
-0.0373031832,
0.0437663272,
-0.0691778883,
0.0074696927,
-0.0020644946,
-0.0219143275,
0.0264097899,
-0.0213869512,
-0.0333988816,
0.0114711998,
-0.0812129304,
-0.060077522,
-0.0384913571,
0.0316007659,
0.0258019641,
0.05552027,
-0.0363025926,
0.0101606706,
0.0375452191,
-0.0166069362,
-0.0371442847,
-0.0069604339,
0.0156045994,
0.0154769588,
0.007763159,
0.0500638634,
-0.0778207704,
-0.0168008059,
-0.0086621642,
0.0529269427,
-0.0241151806,
-0.0465782098,
0.026928382,
0.0223935358,
0.0111383302,
0.0200822279,
0.0173101574,
-0.023366848,
0.0176612176,
-0.0324487202,
-0.0490606241,
-0.0277946722,
0.0351677798,
0.0015991462,
-0.0599326342,
0.0109176766,
-0.0495898649,
-0.0203058887,
0.0458128415,
-0.034870863,
-0.0583257899,
0.043662291,
-0.0072879586,
0.0476895198,
-0.0392569415,
-0.0214632098,
0.0196902081,
0.0110059846,
0.0296319369,
-0.0341237746,
0.0813518465,
0.0239488427,
-0.0181028228,
-0.0460691079,
0.0036660463,
-0.1014622673,
-0.0784307793,
0.0208961572,
0.009064178,
0.0509916581,
-0.0219178796,
0.0413486324,
-0.0179236606,
-0.0258084685,
0.0219536442,
0.0199068878,
0.0397001207,
-0.0205492657,
0.0585456304,
0.0478968136,
0.0019203351,
0.0253931545,
0.0769595951,
0.0059407372,
0.0460666828,
0.0088862823,
-0.0221851282,
-0.035683319,
-0.03493746,
0.0017047538,
0.0148086632,
-0.0257394556,
0.0287619364,
-0.0580959432,
-0.0927438885,
-0.0324942544,
0.0033724229,
-0.0225699861,
0.0095469067,
0.0545844845,
0.0438089408,
0.0189437419,
-0.0145474579,
-0.033643052,
0.0250638723,
-0.0160805508,
-0.0499383211,
-0.0119318524,
-6.538521288e-33,
-0.0204028655,
-0.0359629653,
0.0441044718,
-0.0368050672,
-0.0054687639,
0.0109211598,
-0.037968602,
-0.0128465863,
-0.0392447449,
0.0024756591,
-0.0148665728,
0.0120144393,
-0.0010119678,
0.0262081493,
-0.0013014008,
-0.0379629619,
0.0119586838,
0.009381921,
0.0068491329,
0.0207993351,
0.0579000935,
0.0146728437,
0.0275390744,
-0.0351365954,
0.0533510931,
-0.0229872148,
0.0185554177,
0.0334286056,
0.0019562098,
0.0520895906,
-0.0173648596,
0.0249161981,
0.0310323816,
-0.0129985651,
-0.0013516183,
0.0327657759,
-0.0853869691,
-0.0545631275,
0.0422504842,
-0.0451976396,
-0.0630546659,
-0.0179642849,
-0.0128076067,
-0.02651117,
0.0837515742,
-0.0343893021,
0.02600291,
0.008247382,
-0.0416656807,
-0.041199971,
-0.0282708686,
0.0194318183,
0.0025877682,
-0.0351281464,
-0.0352330431,
0.0809274763,
0.0176219661,
0.0269199759,
-0.0335550308,
0.0112385806,
-0.0141299143,
0.0062079234,
0.0528470352,
0.0142939519,
-0.0108233318,
0.054885406,
-0.0329664014,
-0.0100829164,
-0.0526330099,
0.0126179848,
-0.0334729329,
0.0102784047,
0.0177241936,
-0.0066234074,
-0.0132546211,
0.0364484936,
-0.0576838367,
0.0059211948,
0.0088602174,
0.0094086993,
-0.0076261698,
-0.0139702652,
-0.0042525623,
-0.0347406976,
-0.0507637076,
-0.0131576704,
-0.0312361009,
-0.013188608,
0.0202770382,
-0.0234934557,
-0.0179849677,
-0.0364840552,
0.0149588259,
-0.0352102257,
-0.0194999613,
0.0844014511,
0.0078008985,
0.0168428142,
-0.0175368208,
0.0525147542,
-0.0426148474,
0.0040681255,
0.0138294427,
-0.0000331352,
-0.0130932732,
0.0458634794,
0.0372274965,
-0.0140961409,
-0.0390541032,
-0.0099441269,
-0.0573314317,
0.0015342179,
-0.0359207168,
-0.001045698,
0.0498373695,
0.0595881008,
0.0043043108,
0.0726710558,
0.0346259885,
-0.0177771617,
-0.0074220346,
0.0186467785,
-0.0143517461,
0.0093480945,
-0.0014987825,
0.0037807247,
-0.034699928,
0.0115368208,
0.0144833978,
-0.057605017,
0.0086874394,
0.0411026105,
2.651e-7,
0.030869754,
0.0230606552,
0.0033155805,
0.0526332743,
-0.0018630439,
0.0217576977,
-0.0019050967,
0.0007685185,
0.03542969,
-0.0639063939,
-0.0094520673,
0.0592861287,
0.0091523314,
0.0274519771,
-0.1113702953,
-0.0394016989,
-0.0478984714,
-0.0359325707,
-0.0468615219,
-0.0182420854,
0.0745778009,
0.0624753162,
0.0110786399,
-0.0089111384,
-0.0300094187,
-0.0585263744,
0.0599995777,
0.0127287488,
-0.0139020188,
-0.0254413895,
0.029923195,
-0.0212404057,
0.0092199175,
0.0683021694,
-0.002438959,
0.0103676543,
0.0081221806,
0.0425579958,
0.0216862969,
-0.0187928267,
-0.0204067491,
-0.0463516079,
0.0174210612,
-0.0460780635,
0.095197171,
-0.0330657437,
-0.0054289852,
-0.0006789182,
-0.0166587792,
-0.0120259169,
0.0201823376,
-0.0002657731,
-0.0236119609,
0.0319139957,
0.0078157866,
-0.0125814592,
0.024270067,
-0.0645844266,
-0.01792996,
0.010429915,
-0.0210084915,
-0.0390646718,
-0.0002318063,
-0.0112918392,
0.0311644468,
-0.0529778451,
-0.0032131558,
2.675313103e-34,
0.0448364243,
-0.0121825524,
0.0179848112,
0.0296160914,
0.0373236015,
-0.0371191613,
-0.0210063364,
0.0045274841,
0.0320694074,
-0.1346816719,
-0.0238078218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08487v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08487v1 | Alignment is not sufficient to prevent large language models from generating harmful information: A psychoanalytic perspective | 2023-11-14T19:28:51 | 2023-11-14T19:28:51 | Zi Yin, Wei Ding, Jia Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are central to a multitude of applications but
struggle with significant risks, notably in generating harmful content and
biases. Drawing an analogy to the human psyche's conflict between evolutionary
survival instincts and societal norm adherence elucidated in Freud's
psychoanalysis theory, we argue that LLMs suffer a similar fundamental
conflict, arising between their inherent desire for syntactic and semantic
continuity, established during the pre-training phase, and the post-training
alignment with human values. This conflict renders LLMs vulnerable to
adversarial attacks, wherein intensifying the models' desire for continuity can
circumvent alignment efforts, resulting in the generation of harmful
information. Through a series of experiments, we first validated the existence
of the desire for continuity in LLMs, and further devised a straightforward yet
powerful technique, such as incomplete sentences, negative priming, and
cognitive dissonance scenarios, to demonstrate that even advanced LLMs struggle
to prevent the generation of harmful information. In summary, our study
uncovers the root of LLMs' vulnerabilities to adversarial attacks, hereby
questioning the efficacy of solely relying on sophisticated alignment methods,
and further advocates for a new training idea that integrates modal concepts
alongside traditional amodal concepts, aiming to endow LLMs with a more nuanced
understanding of real-world contexts and ethical considerations. | [
0.0406816453,
0.0897466615,
-0.0499068834,
0.0221620686,
-0.058003094,
0.0152477268,
0.0063615451,
-0.0006443608,
-0.0109840557,
-0.0388686322,
-0.0304863788,
-0.0371668749,
0.0167960208,
-0.0236457326,
0.0321851224,
-0.0402730256,
0.0435371883,
0.0271553826,
0.0047144676,
-0.0241875928,
0.0210288297,
0.0075696423,
0.0297383182,
0.011635853,
0.016647527,
-0.0295235198,
0.0128099937,
0.0014619041,
0.031047672,
-0.0322462693,
0.0051368847,
0.0328863449,
0.0086798556,
0.0695809275,
0.0000018354,
-0.0561392643,
-0.001465462,
0.0076419483,
-0.0079950467,
0.0102379052,
0.0593313985,
-0.0533898994,
-0.0023578964,
-0.026764499,
-0.0514644608,
0.0135123478,
0.0320736878,
0.0689776167,
0.0583882481,
0.0853002667,
0.0012020299,
-0.040824879,
0.0626191646,
-0.0109104346,
-0.0242331177,
-0.0263450947,
0.066675812,
-0.0046258955,
-0.0549828447,
0.0382410027,
-0.025808908,
0.0255080238,
-0.0088160783,
0.0357452706,
-0.006205291,
-0.0043508168,
-0.0011619355,
-0.0510767922,
0.00018415,
0.0483371168,
0.0087745823,
-0.0210175682,
0.0146470945,
0.0076346821,
-0.0081785629,
-0.028276436,
-0.0149790542,
0.0337696336,
0.0006207975,
0.0079424279,
0.0442105308,
-0.0434958376,
0.0302812662,
0.0435893685,
0.053601779,
0.0243857484,
0.0195223987,
-0.0356243551,
0.0096049951,
-0.0158165675,
-0.0369270965,
-0.0746878535,
-0.0310129952,
-0.0020395261,
-0.0201767888,
0.037310157,
-0.0768572539,
-0.0344484374,
0.0376433246,
-0.0736388564,
-0.015690824,
0.0393573567,
-0.0161180217,
0.0005722098,
0.0304079819,
0.0355769917,
-0.0410871655,
0.0630883873,
-0.034769915,
0.0525800921,
-0.0081639998,
-0.0225941166,
0.0219039712,
0.0156859905,
-0.0062596002,
0.0038473427,
-0.0620260574,
0.0016559622,
-0.0551192015,
0.0307168365,
-0.10047362,
0.0275182314,
-0.0095929354,
0.0024809707,
-0.0110428268,
0.0089256698,
-0.0251579601,
0.0232838169,
-0.0205162857,
-0.0400000699,
-0.0093831932,
0.0390645564,
-0.0678990707,
-0.0268625338,
-0.0182279628,
0.0443226062,
0.0015813133,
-0.0174334981,
-0.0318628401,
-0.0317107104,
-0.0590885915,
-0.0650306568,
0.0121660102,
-0.0233724713,
0.0022504237,
0.0030313705,
-0.0393877216,
-0.0984527618,
0.0115798302,
0.0034820419,
-0.0540270247,
0.0827547684,
-0.0003098343,
-0.0070239343,
0.011472716,
0.0524491072,
0.0254299827,
0.0623278953,
-0.0036511577,
0.00202953,
0.0250055492,
-0.006780121,
-0.0063375803,
0.0079689352,
0.0175305512,
0.0137108434,
-0.0663691536,
0.0229788739,
0.0052361954,
0.0364808664,
0.0055471403,
0.048285678,
-0.0047726957,
-0.0274571739,
0.0912686065,
0.0219251998,
-0.0460013114,
0.0657811612,
-0.00105249,
-0.0202497635,
-0.002227477,
0.0511066541,
-0.0860482305,
-0.0332571007,
-0.0846664533,
-0.0360084623,
-0.0399562269,
0.0333942473,
-0.0054907817,
-0.0038559479,
-0.0135394605,
0.0066691367,
0.018722482,
-0.0028350353,
-0.0084274132,
0.0078638187,
-0.0059710215,
0.0117612593,
0.0633099154,
-0.0119535746,
-0.0039165234,
-0.0375796668,
0.0001637415,
0.0312812179,
0.0473059453,
-0.011733816,
0.006437595,
-0.0209691003,
-0.0006335115,
0.0327046998,
0.0508765876,
0.0101718046,
-0.0354135633,
-0.0262851343,
-0.0247277375,
-0.0405533575,
0.0123306513,
-0.0104691489,
-0.0201475304,
0.0076497882,
-0.0040221503,
0.0255771056,
-0.0343480632,
0.0581029989,
-0.0003995647,
-0.0599639975,
-0.0660959557,
0.0175935701,
0.0264250096,
-0.0043171677,
-0.0270110071,
0.0030765831,
0.0382459015,
0.0015877136,
0.009236088,
0.033343982,
-0.0444012359,
0.0262379292,
0.0301891696,
-0.0124611408,
-0.0336815156,
0.0533993579,
0.0007040169,
0.0153161446,
0.0154269496,
-0.0324629769,
0.0696534738,
-0.0084615136,
0.0262766257,
-0.0528171249,
0.0333703235,
-0.0519265495,
0.0624923371,
-0.0056947651,
0.0077433791,
-0.0039715073,
-0.0153706521,
0.0043171351,
0.0189980064,
-0.046980463,
0.0172078218,
-0.0061209206,
0.0128003499,
0.0169133954,
-0.0475899428,
-0.0354714133,
-0.0138267493,
-0.0662621781,
0.0078504579,
0.0060734279,
0.0111909322,
0.0287333261,
-0.0427902415,
-0.0176590625,
0.0318190828,
-0.0093758833,
0.0165031236,
0.0001435368,
0.0507045947,
0.0010614084,
-0.0105715934,
-0.0452502854,
-0.0112194633,
0.0173520204,
-0.05313164,
0.0497294664,
-0.0098503698,
-0.0083594443,
-0.0374092832,
0.0237538107,
-0.0403172374,
0.0148155233,
-0.0257707182,
-0.0471620448,
0.0284421723,
0.0809158981,
0.0474402793,
0.0643065274,
0.0537855513,
0.0614524744,
0.0580714755,
0.0466047004,
-0.0264230408,
-0.0321949385,
0.0105736302,
-0.0496201105,
-0.0541408658,
-0.062792629,
-0.0290876999,
0.0741560683,
0.0475639999,
0.001003367,
-0.0257122591,
0.065995425,
-0.0502619036,
-0.0563246012,
0.023060536,
-0.0846410096,
-0.0440420024,
-0.0096836528,
-0.0402709171,
-0.0553698279,
0.0798468366,
0.0184405483,
0.0191806071,
-0.0211110152,
-0.0266901907,
0.0258268714,
0.0701683015,
0.0045681829,
0.0577669889,
0.0781481341,
-0.0071052304,
-0.0900309011,
-0.0716005415,
0.0310616829,
-0.0327856354,
0.0373191796,
-0.0246692859,
0.000129577,
0.0157369245,
-0.0401806198,
-0.0815769881,
-0.0791088343,
-0.0317148715,
-0.0001671142,
0.0091623208,
0.0338708386,
-0.0468182005,
-0.0367911234,
0.0491135679,
-0.051589217,
-0.0110705644,
-0.0128536904,
-0.0146587351,
0.0089126797,
0.0718915537,
-0.0354994461,
0.0606348999,
-0.0243407767,
0.0133444676,
0.0564522929,
-0.0357542448,
0.0592275374,
-0.0321497694,
-0.0039497716,
0.0084061017,
0.0014836403,
-0.0052113538,
0.0161835197,
0.049834393,
-0.0181718655,
-0.0027234792,
0.0546330698,
0.01802334,
-0.0098734805,
0.0423769169,
-0.0005861174,
-0.0082305782,
0.0039370758,
-0.016438568,
-0.0661862716,
0.0092827175,
0.0167164877,
0.0085141184,
-0.0542048961,
-0.0264250673,
-0.0072443057,
-0.0794778764,
-0.0041093198,
0.0283030812,
0.0030186523,
-0.0221732408,
0.013030746,
0.0015207948,
0.0023480954,
0.057842683,
0.0162775703,
0.0037059491,
-0.0241408627,
0.0102259666,
-0.0088986056,
-0.0258744713,
-0.0133068627,
-0.0373161584,
0.0972101316,
0.0566910915,
0.0519209877,
-0.0164463799,
-0.057217747,
0.049187135,
0.0007127674,
-0.02689985,
0.0275433622,
0.017471347,
-0.0197364539,
-0.0090193888,
-0.0412655473,
0.0322501846,
0.0401622802,
-0.040478725,
0.0102368006,
0.0601249598,
-0.0101208901,
-0.026341306,
-0.0330697261,
0.0344550833,
0.0050981729,
0.0752721131,
-0.0112553136,
-0.0401431322,
-0.0030978427,
-0.0333960503,
0.0261943806,
0.0486113504,
-0.0531159565,
0.0319997817,
-0.0074918368,
0.0013742086,
-0.0613338873,
-0.0393211953,
-0.0522948429,
-0.0035345897,
0.050328698,
-0.0223597717,
-0.0539256744,
-0.0246429928,
-0.0295477342,
0.0349437632,
-0.0080798659,
0.0019007704,
0.0220743623,
0.0122008985,
0.0042008222,
-0.0421419255,
0.0170330033,
-0.0175401736,
-0.0581097938,
-0.1001117453,
0.0518963747,
0.0175599642,
0.0293477997,
0.0618268214,
0.013088149,
-0.0351263359,
0.0334905498,
0.0492280461,
-0.0334371515,
0.0414709672,
0.0185677111,
0.0020797295,
0.0084656812,
0.0327499956,
0.0035027908,
0.0028958553,
0.0882815719,
0.0038293698,
-0.0475919545,
-0.0254376978,
0.076423578,
0.0239539128,
0.0365529396,
-0.0569361225,
-0.0299078748,
-0.0038974204,
-0.0343364999,
-0.0120178694,
-0.0501383208,
0.0253097359,
-0.0341722071,
0.0559962876,
0.0427179672,
0.0026662583,
0.0183545537,
-0.0338842049,
0.0233348738,
-0.0082997065,
0.0022721635,
0.0030622464,
0.0000595986,
0.0155739458,
0.0408517979,
-0.0297779385,
0.0396669768,
-0.0318042599,
0.044694297,
-0.0010829256,
0.0599971525,
0.0470996685,
-0.0016750353,
-0.0174897984,
-0.0084488792,
-0.0356449969,
-0.0297742989,
-0.0110929916,
-0.0176223032,
-0.0029909487,
-0.0180322118,
0.0158207975,
-0.0381116904,
-0.0132119861,
-0.0077653145,
0.0053150072,
-0.0287508164,
-0.0384102091,
0.0341525637,
0.0222922266,
-0.0388095193,
0.0202103257,
0.0216540564,
-0.0502641127,
0.0455614701,
0.0090232864,
-0.0296179652,
-0.0188967567,
-0.0362804271,
0.0609621406,
-0.0045008129,
-0.0301857609,
-0.0101807928,
-0.0900543854,
-0.0469668768,
0.0072072325,
0.0016971737,
-0.0043944092,
-0.0521209091,
-0.0000830079,
0.0595336743,
-0.0024368674,
-0.0045377067,
-0.0046357522,
0.0195510499,
-0.0013679273,
0.0050543346,
-0.0174998604,
-5.630627124e-33,
-0.01733597,
-0.013487272,
-0.0061716242,
-0.0262184162,
-0.0833610818,
-0.0002879559,
0.0019790726,
0.0252800528,
-0.0346922055,
0.021736268,
0.0233857222,
-0.0048742671,
-0.013154977,
-0.0091363238,
-0.013201816,
-0.0464195758,
0.0188523494,
-0.0022262607,
-0.0365041681,
-0.0394218713,
0.0098729627,
0.007795684,
0.0340472013,
-0.0548050962,
0.0620528534,
0.0046253186,
-0.0408771336,
-0.003480956,
-0.0240870845,
0.0205745976,
-0.0177185889,
0.0524568669,
0.0135836955,
-0.0024287866,
0.0226337388,
0.0680103451,
0.0323200114,
-0.014363613,
0.0837610587,
0.013835635,
-0.0180587526,
-0.0119917616,
0.04645532,
-0.0334400088,
-0.0319964439,
0.0167918205,
0.0251567401,
-0.0269193426,
-0.0067167096,
0.012341097,
-0.0913701281,
-0.0180035029,
-0.0158721805,
-0.0146435061,
-0.0163294338,
-0.0115051158,
0.0203932524,
-0.0141657628,
-0.0730123892,
0.0034903574,
0.0336322337,
0.0122921448,
0.0341108888,
0.0322076939,
0.0286842007,
0.0983921587,
0.051909741,
0.0402022675,
-0.0242299363,
0.0047667683,
0.0357446969,
0.0114263613,
0.0366851576,
0.0619709417,
-0.0124686034,
-0.0462930501,
-0.0449340008,
-0.0425509028,
0.0144255264,
0.0179920942,
0.0364551619,
0.017839767,
-0.0239033606,
-0.0115322564,
-0.0441936143,
-0.032535661,
-0.0225389451,
-0.0228346381,
0.0031257246,
-0.0020714302,
-0.0246456489,
0.015117255,
-0.0146806315,
-0.042500481,
0.017464852,
0.0050309384,
-0.0189365633,
-0.0138442451,
0.0147477416,
0.0277442597,
-0.0271817036,
-0.0186571945,
-0.0065480974,
-0.0394114256,
0.04812802,
0.0046236739,
0.0509402193,
0.0074062045,
-0.0306273904,
-0.0169745125,
-0.0183185935,
0.0218076576,
0.0166416466,
-0.0352446064,
0.067124784,
0.055405736,
-0.0242041387,
-0.0097847302,
0.0942829102,
0.018783018,
-0.0494955741,
0.0519136041,
-0.0183611307,
0.0256201979,
-0.0208161324,
-0.0166072715,
-0.002691963,
0.0609710403,
0.0655766875,
-0.0827072784,
-0.0292755105,
-0.0384376831,
2.65e-7,
0.0010304196,
0.0486384109,
0.0004195984,
-0.0190924518,
0.0224262774,
0.0658589676,
-0.0054437434,
0.0666214228,
0.0143164005,
-0.0757416189,
0.0040670098,
-0.0048212204,
0.0504494794,
0.0378575958,
-0.0011936229,
0.0349398255,
-0.0499143936,
-0.0003185011,
-0.0655443817,
0.0409017913,
0.0460412502,
0.0717363954,
0.0449915789,
-0.0102136908,
-0.0145013072,
-0.0200852267,
0.0661971346,
-0.0219903793,
-0.0086691864,
0.0063311839,
0.0044744881,
0.002286427,
0.007611698,
0.0175203346,
0.0175902564,
-0.0035969426,
-0.0231082346,
0.05842508,
-0.0297434647,
-0.0339905098,
-0.0364103839,
-0.0047276509,
-0.0456358045,
-0.0472730845,
0.0504613444,
-0.0721766204,
-0.040276058,
-0.0462685749,
-0.0438257083,
-0.0033024007,
0.0419514515,
0.0070530018,
-0.0457663462,
0.0143987667,
0.0198532343,
0.0288805831,
0.0020058334,
-0.0491539724,
-0.0114757093,
0.0597115904,
-0.0240703728,
-0.0270455331,
0.006483682,
0.0355053097,
0.0105413226,
-0.0622671768,
0.0198014826,
2.256509491e-34,
-0.0050511942,
-0.0283415318,
0.0298111849,
-0.0170863178,
-0.001932229,
0.0127093205,
-0.0134505676,
0.0367128849,
0.0179733839,
-0.0264457017,
0.0070813387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08481v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08481v1 | Functionality learning through specification instructions | 2023-11-14T19:15:55 | 2023-11-14T19:15:55 | Pedro Henrique Luz de Araujo, Benjamin Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL | Test suites assess natural language processing models' performance on
specific functionalities: cases of interest involving model robustness,
fairness, or particular linguistic capabilities. They enable fine-grained
evaluations of model aspects that would otherwise go unnoticed in standard
evaluation datasets, but they do not address the problem of how to fix the
failure cases. Previous work has explored functionality learning by fine-tuning
models on suite data. While this improves performance on seen functionalities,
it often does not generalize to unseen ones and can harm general performance.
This paper analyses a fine-tuning-free approach to functionality learning.
For each functionality in a suite, we generate a specification instruction that
encodes it. We combine the obtained specification instructions to create
specification-augmented prompts, which we feed to language models pre-trained
on natural instruction data to generate suite predictions. A core aspect of our
analysis is to measure the effect that including a set of specifications has on
a held-out set of unseen, qualitatively different specifications. Our
experiments across four tasks and models ranging from 80M to 175B parameters
show that smaller models struggle to follow specification instructions.
However, larger models (> 3B params.) can benefit from specifications and even
generalize desirable behaviors across functionalities. | [
0.0651933104,
0.0622451566,
-0.0222906228,
0.0128565682,
-0.0331492424,
0.0256915949,
0.006294867,
-0.0382431373,
0.0103770802,
-0.0863858461,
-0.0296700075,
-0.0237464271,
0.0001662033,
0.0832845271,
0.0377781093,
-0.05082798,
0.0712154359,
-0.0136144925,
-0.0086299665,
0.0124358758,
-0.012504125,
0.0148155792,
-0.0006812025,
0.0557369851,
0.0134284617,
0.0089404499,
-0.0021648165,
0.0033218486,
-0.0362193994,
-0.010621543,
0.0361366235,
0.0636946037,
0.0011167048,
-0.0068550208,
0.0000019651,
-0.079694964,
-0.00604903,
0.0040993774,
-0.0348250121,
-0.0105573265,
0.0624218471,
0.0089448635,
-0.0018246322,
0.0388550423,
-0.0226854738,
0.0008793379,
0.0366013832,
0.0050948514,
-0.0084877098,
0.0796564221,
0.0023170097,
-0.0016408118,
-0.0047515244,
-0.0120139802,
0.0178466942,
-0.014378638,
-0.0107733486,
-0.0286933761,
0.0458032042,
-0.0071084816,
-0.0124799544,
0.0232390147,
0.0175956599,
0.0234152544,
-0.0141591318,
0.0247039758,
-0.0427430831,
-0.0440987349,
-0.0300132539,
0.047750853,
-0.0149698136,
-0.0162472185,
-0.0025831494,
-0.0189979561,
0.0122706415,
-0.0311411992,
-0.0135074435,
0.0045763566,
0.0147009939,
-0.0321458653,
0.0187207293,
-0.0269534737,
0.0148751196,
0.0043298304,
-0.0191012472,
0.0948177204,
-0.0016628338,
-0.0427747928,
0.0025394617,
-0.0028213446,
-0.0513217263,
-0.0215502996,
-0.0243090037,
-0.0011541883,
-0.0284136571,
0.0367733799,
-0.0318563357,
-0.0130590275,
0.0372294225,
-0.0418286435,
0.0148001267,
0.0314644575,
-0.023961097,
0.0285683982,
-0.0459464453,
0.0672232434,
0.0283509046,
0.0280616898,
-0.0350889079,
0.0127199925,
-0.0741877332,
-0.0155379139,
-0.0158953927,
0.0503495149,
-0.0323064588,
-0.0148899248,
0.0164727662,
0.0227550585,
0.0041600722,
0.0466462001,
-0.0071765026,
0.0267971456,
-0.0633550137,
0.0022591951,
-0.0557080209,
-0.0118186455,
-0.0179633927,
-0.0004967408,
-0.0087466342,
-0.0597987883,
-0.001925473,
-0.0132923275,
0.0149086257,
0.0068315296,
0.030537203,
0.0442950092,
0.0109412586,
-0.0440009795,
-0.0063896091,
-0.0268153027,
0.0046005854,
-0.0570807867,
0.0056718732,
-0.0530458651,
0.0054057217,
0.0189437233,
0.0082176197,
-0.0184692163,
-0.0142675238,
0.0053647268,
-0.0189812519,
0.0767479166,
0.0308895893,
0.0026285914,
-0.0097953053,
-0.0106151393,
0.0218857285,
0.0846161917,
0.0168880541,
-0.0170803964,
0.0281490516,
-0.0029191677,
-0.019073749,
0.0356508382,
-0.0170095731,
-0.0045634946,
0.0102390051,
0.0180994272,
0.0191979781,
0.0160095096,
0.0341491811,
0.0022164178,
0.0106967017,
0.0038974378,
0.0116907042,
0.0699938387,
0.0100931469,
-0.0034102744,
0.0787694082,
0.0153724169,
-0.0123642674,
0.0084178569,
-0.0957004651,
-0.0162536409,
-0.0296047684,
0.0210247114,
-0.0332243107,
0.0107416296,
-0.0332919955,
-0.0573480055,
-0.0191754308,
-0.0349155851,
0.0415309817,
0.0147037385,
0.0428298675,
0.0352494456,
-0.0374256298,
0.0225668419,
0.0293293558,
-0.0358796604,
0.0112306755,
-0.0540361479,
0.0247670263,
0.0955825001,
0.0767525509,
-0.052109275,
0.0088191982,
0.0054436345,
-0.0141501958,
0.0303493943,
0.0848978683,
-0.0146642262,
0.0232087057,
-0.0266034752,
-0.0460579246,
-0.0518130995,
0.0359098986,
-0.0025512925,
0.0178130399,
-0.0461903214,
0.0094537074,
-0.0346549451,
-0.0901511833,
0.0386052877,
-0.0286958031,
-0.0537431166,
0.0174834412,
0.0017157567,
0.0179081075,
-0.0088818055,
0.008110459,
0.0207244772,
-0.0072922236,
0.0063793864,
0.0309852231,
0.0073591284,
-0.0590137914,
-0.0070699621,
0.0000902003,
0.0084460247,
-0.003278139,
0.0990427509,
-0.0229227878,
-0.0353194959,
0.0154774012,
-0.0209415425,
0.0079678418,
-0.0120728426,
0.0299128592,
-0.0083956691,
-0.0317196921,
-0.0117133576,
0.0357299373,
0.0013298495,
0.0325229354,
-0.0451225154,
0.0082059884,
-0.0017036538,
-0.0017285402,
-0.0733352229,
0.0081699844,
-0.0386889763,
0.0128658284,
0.0186757836,
0.0221326537,
-0.0394777432,
0.0058758943,
-0.1152957082,
0.0260200035,
-0.0334584638,
0.0207738504,
0.0257855691,
0.0123155769,
0.0148912128,
-0.0237489417,
-0.0163348578,
-0.0363912657,
-0.0111384774,
0.020656582,
0.0226365551,
0.0223866832,
-0.0259617232,
-0.0394513868,
-0.0040647234,
-0.0404370129,
0.0472857356,
-0.0084265554,
0.0365238935,
-0.0693907216,
0.0322851278,
-0.0063715931,
0.0637497008,
-0.0101404702,
-0.0349747017,
0.0111338431,
0.0163871497,
-0.0144893108,
0.0947819501,
-0.011886932,
0.0048937029,
0.0655758753,
0.0605220459,
-0.0727269873,
0.0232801363,
-0.0470002256,
-0.0147247138,
-0.0358497277,
-0.0202088002,
0.0331737436,
0.0497752093,
-0.0084433174,
0.0129178017,
-0.0487567671,
0.0044736224,
-0.0302731879,
-0.056220144,
0.0033261981,
-0.0151033383,
-0.0224208478,
0.0165182948,
-0.0311155096,
-0.0610672794,
0.0679505989,
-0.017793145,
-0.0282633975,
-0.091990225,
0.0074834633,
-0.0261713918,
0.0897524133,
0.0183693133,
0.0109185334,
0.0385260656,
-0.0592624918,
-0.0614805147,
-0.0111835459,
0.0296679288,
-0.0215729922,
0.0433776453,
-0.0603469573,
-0.0009660478,
-0.0032753686,
-0.0500283912,
-0.0632350445,
-0.0410040617,
-0.0035857302,
0.0614330471,
0.0204273183,
-0.0069237598,
-0.0128572378,
-0.012997007,
-0.0003491141,
0.0624311529,
0.012215212,
0.0016024536,
-0.032087341,
-0.0458803028,
0.0402710028,
0.0120960027,
0.0149212359,
0.0052959812,
0.0074745947,
-0.0119453222,
0.0079368427,
0.002255125,
-0.0190110151,
0.0074447975,
0.0276131183,
-0.0519214906,
-0.0191618819,
0.0548711009,
0.0768255666,
-0.0696729869,
-0.0363646112,
0.0931983218,
0.0474275723,
-0.0205494054,
0.0165185742,
0.0059610461,
0.0483717434,
0.0671670511,
0.0384639837,
-0.062790595,
-0.0224598646,
0.0159256775,
0.0378520563,
-0.0382680669,
0.0001253895,
-0.0243588462,
-0.1395227462,
0.028085446,
-0.0149347177,
-0.014133567,
-0.0101988371,
-0.0257168319,
0.0007383041,
-0.026678266,
0.0430952236,
0.0036555752,
-0.0272431411,
-0.0054205195,
0.0300082043,
-0.0710431561,
-0.0852769688,
0.0632351637,
-0.0374801904,
0.0298473854,
0.079415299,
-0.0287781972,
0.0093934005,
-0.0107981218,
0.0486868881,
-0.0150897019,
0.0515683219,
-0.0129546719,
0.0532537214,
-0.0004927804,
0.0085042063,
0.010955424,
0.0405607112,
-0.0029129589,
-0.008009851,
-0.0191199295,
0.0098716328,
-0.0194373894,
-0.0114207715,
-0.0010888712,
-0.0057396819,
0.0220347736,
0.0765238777,
0.0378956683,
-0.0557103641,
-0.0493672676,
-0.0234479159,
-0.0426806994,
-0.0726869926,
-0.055182945,
-0.0049122572,
0.0059213093,
-0.0112501774,
-0.069448702,
-0.0354060158,
0.04801929,
0.0060102814,
0.0350618921,
-0.0085233524,
0.0086651538,
0.0083307037,
-0.0353811085,
0.0451001711,
-0.0049174177,
0.0089344662,
-0.0563851669,
-0.0381424353,
0.0329067223,
-0.015730558,
-0.0181309935,
-0.0086941486,
-0.0436462536,
-0.0642645881,
0.003548126,
0.0841043964,
0.016992854,
0.0674146935,
-0.0544097908,
-0.0597556122,
-0.0164565369,
0.0492916293,
-0.0609752424,
-0.0006637185,
0.0509206913,
-0.0256604068,
-0.0108206403,
0.0389315225,
-0.0469034873,
0.0123558939,
-0.0114805354,
0.0125063751,
0.0297159031,
0.0188991372,
0.0407400131,
0.0193191208,
0.0376243107,
-0.0339848213,
-0.0208726861,
-0.0388114005,
0.0169926379,
0.0194392744,
-0.031759616,
-0.0319925062,
0.036101453,
-0.0062796292,
0.0059488527,
-0.0001522204,
-0.0225174315,
-0.0168309156,
0.0647746995,
-0.018671751,
0.0312268604,
0.0096721752,
-0.0128981238,
0.0068210089,
-0.0000213014,
-0.0461106747,
0.0202408787,
-0.033603508,
0.0430895425,
-0.002184761,
0.021133529,
0.0048010522,
0.0368900783,
-0.0321008787,
0.0301388465,
-0.0429869816,
-0.0816819668,
-0.031847924,
-0.035640534,
0.0090507735,
-0.0480402783,
0.0237346403,
-0.0412753038,
0.0124815945,
-0.0233573969,
0.0194902737,
-0.0095051043,
-0.0119095473,
0.0360759869,
0.0310978256,
-0.0309521258,
-0.0613641553,
0.0608436987,
0.0135560669,
0.075162679,
-0.0355023369,
0.0206256825,
-0.0346329771,
-0.0377666056,
0.0322874822,
0.0285832621,
-0.0539271459,
0.0088258395,
-0.0430554524,
-0.0506410003,
-0.0289438833,
0.014400756,
0.02377492,
-0.0178691279,
0.04586225,
0.0744461939,
-0.0095982654,
0.001384145,
-0.024127895,
-0.0710474998,
0.0132586081,
-0.0133061018,
-0.0219563302,
-6.107673221e-33,
-0.0074397954,
-0.0060598059,
0.0015641106,
0.0364834741,
0.0576626323,
-0.0062174262,
-0.0114375744,
0.0092289578,
-0.0132945953,
-0.0219087321,
-0.0010917541,
0.0099855112,
0.0101932809,
-0.0056532556,
0.038436383,
-0.0225940887,
0.0558759309,
-0.0337996446,
-0.0711784884,
-0.0002277549,
0.0409312099,
-0.0042876108,
0.0764798149,
-0.0451672412,
0.0272637084,
0.0178234838,
-0.0002094815,
0.0060224645,
-0.0391852185,
0.0710682124,
0.0139582893,
0.0516970269,
0.040758837,
-0.0251844693,
-0.0283682849,
0.0220303666,
-0.0654903054,
-0.0264944583,
0.0544782467,
0.0119402269,
-0.0385844186,
-0.0131578185,
0.0635285079,
-0.0189903509,
-0.0312150177,
0.0128360465,
0.0387815423,
-0.0003163025,
-0.0047619641,
0.0018130357,
-0.0628205016,
0.0185334329,
0.0077418052,
-0.0347699299,
0.0116746146,
0.073540315,
0.0019158942,
-0.0384249762,
0.0061339941,
-0.0102489619,
0.0204179734,
0.0687424615,
0.058513131,
-0.0015673677,
-0.0076608891,
0.0570353903,
-0.0244117137,
0.0369895399,
0.0278688092,
-0.015224346,
0.0830487087,
0.0575171374,
0.0262490902,
-0.0012462927,
0.030171236,
-0.0144268796,
-0.0141808391,
0.0136959655,
-0.0075421277,
0.0394804291,
0.0212117415,
-0.0021849337,
-0.0661184415,
-0.0221162327,
-0.0699446499,
0.0270826146,
-0.0367640816,
-0.0135071548,
0.0535663851,
0.0419144146,
-0.0265451502,
0.0198779441,
0.0223740377,
-0.0280179102,
0.0028874287,
0.017707102,
-0.0158751477,
0.0328958519,
0.0083426405,
-0.0067896009,
-0.055538021,
-0.0428538024,
0.0196214002,
0.0103783654,
0.0321385637,
0.0014866964,
0.0344963036,
0.0575264096,
-0.0627591908,
0.0188469365,
-0.0391602404,
0.0408383645,
-0.0141606508,
0.0056745899,
0.045682393,
0.021329606,
-0.0180755798,
0.0298087802,
-0.0226406343,
-0.0498537794,
-0.0667006448,
0.0121681476,
0.0029682114,
0.043839179,
-0.0425217077,
-0.0349641219,
-0.0303076562,
0.0052532665,
0.0318016335,
0.0152496109,
-0.014065722,
0.0386694781,
2.723e-7,
0.0365553275,
0.0259652622,
-0.0153925335,
0.0379916988,
0.0158549827,
0.0425950512,
-0.0180059765,
0.0349865295,
0.0296460018,
-0.0102011571,
-0.0007034504,
0.0066696028,
0.0432778336,
0.0030950843,
-0.1053261459,
-0.0128080621,
-0.0124101434,
0.024201734,
-0.0713828281,
-0.0412455611,
0.0493754633,
0.091522947,
-0.0136957569,
0.0235444158,
-0.0148636112,
-0.0402768403,
0.0194755867,
-0.0267829783,
0.0092962766,
0.0115280356,
-0.0215598252,
0.0474744365,
0.0251032244,
0.0252539869,
-0.0446278863,
0.0263549536,
-0.0415520631,
0.0738113001,
-0.0025715022,
-0.0299018789,
-0.0051519778,
-0.0163282026,
0.0046389573,
-0.066376105,
0.0644701943,
-0.0325836539,
-0.0034479876,
-0.021126695,
0.0088017853,
0.0213353746,
-0.0028330146,
0.0061419676,
-0.0008651453,
0.0196255948,
0.0055230083,
-0.0382931791,
-0.0141929062,
-0.0686298385,
-0.0276703518,
0.0466520675,
0.00948097,
-0.0498987995,
-0.0448241532,
-0.0054861451,
-0.0157090146,
-0.1053017005,
-0.004192621,
2.749572892e-34,
0.0300898943,
0.0244817734,
0.0446569994,
0.0284982659,
0.0335627608,
0.0036833358,
-0.0060177306,
0.0200642347,
0.0462138541,
-0.0448544659,
-0.0032987576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08472v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08472v1 | Selecting Shots for Demographic Fairness in Few-Shot Learning with Large Language Models | 2023-11-14T19:02:03 | 2023-11-14T19:02:03 | Carlos Aguirre, Kuleen Sasse, Isabel Cachola, Mark Dredze | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, work in NLP has shifted to few-shot (in-context) learning, with
large language models (LLMs) performing well across a range of tasks. However,
while fairness evaluations have become a standard for supervised methods,
little is known about the fairness of LLMs as prediction systems. Further,
common standard methods for fairness involve access to models weights or are
applied during finetuning, which are not applicable in few-shot learning. Do
LLMs exhibit prediction biases when used for standard NLP tasks? In this work,
we explore the effect of shots, which directly affect the performance of
models, on the fairness of LLMs as NLP classification systems. We consider how
different shot selection strategies, both existing and new demographically
sensitive methods, affect model fairness across three standard fairness
datasets. We discuss how future work can include LLM fairness evaluations. | [
0.0478029437,
0.0989922211,
-0.0289539397,
0.012760818,
-0.0349582992,
0.0326904096,
0.0543079153,
0.0100543313,
-0.0338423438,
-0.1044576913,
-0.0254488401,
-0.0556802377,
0.0309956409,
-0.0675134286,
-0.0081617925,
-0.0328584872,
0.0161345713,
0.029349491,
0.0282655805,
-0.0378778018,
-0.0126623483,
0.0165518876,
0.0199118517,
0.0464276299,
0.0225822199,
-0.0027152956,
0.072518751,
0.0036232241,
0.0205821488,
0.0064612436,
0.0413612984,
0.078483656,
-0.0103681013,
0.0736631528,
0.0000015664,
-0.0668203905,
0.0277273934,
0.0439784154,
-0.0489331521,
0.0143093877,
0.0474439114,
-0.0412999615,
0.0096474057,
0.0265667997,
-0.0225376748,
-0.0025711444,
0.0242401771,
0.0046199653,
-0.0076518487,
0.0165352728,
0.0136226136,
-0.0321391486,
-0.0323275998,
-0.035847079,
0.0248189326,
-0.0386647321,
0.039379444,
-0.0302859712,
-0.0397981405,
-0.0087991711,
-0.0313102975,
0.015327638,
0.014257485,
0.0160164498,
0.0312131792,
0.0204911903,
-0.0588987805,
-0.0212092269,
0.002862131,
0.0523252934,
-0.0179708153,
-0.022790689,
-0.022818571,
-0.018686384,
0.0167652648,
-0.0006094328,
-0.058922343,
0.0462202504,
0.0184090324,
0.0335014202,
0.0059413542,
0.0129140988,
0.0486112423,
0.0441823453,
-0.0022139081,
0.0352036841,
0.0102594318,
-0.0369674824,
-0.0062416587,
0.0763377622,
-0.0103862667,
-0.02758196,
-0.0036234809,
-0.0085397018,
0.0037668741,
0.0046485849,
0.0033222605,
-0.0097973989,
0.0524239168,
-0.0152782938,
0.0571182258,
0.0342020243,
-0.0014729196,
0.028332578,
0.0051674042,
0.0051364,
0.0648231208,
0.0315683782,
-0.002001273,
-0.0198737346,
-0.0390430279,
0.0028034279,
0.0076851542,
-0.0043434747,
-0.0198096428,
0.0543366745,
-0.0909224451,
-0.0053071859,
-0.040814776,
-0.022938557,
0.0321848318,
0.0008470651,
-0.0315567143,
0.0169586111,
-0.0223490559,
0.0231550559,
-0.0206573568,
0.0233569462,
-0.0467581674,
-0.0467408039,
-0.0191248599,
-0.0151002752,
-0.0224511363,
-0.0497089289,
0.0209258553,
0.0413654633,
0.0455927104,
-0.0610225238,
-0.0340778828,
-0.0032461679,
-0.0282300171,
-0.065187566,
-0.0080385553,
-0.0536118783,
0.0193811748,
0.0005322429,
0.0276070889,
-0.0321355164,
-0.0248366296,
0.0153479492,
-0.0708304867,
0.0819198564,
0.0728016049,
-0.0041970355,
0.0150645226,
-0.0121895801,
0.0113963466,
0.121335268,
0.0039249305,
-0.0457489304,
0.0407354943,
0.0205509737,
-0.0111838905,
0.0324308053,
0.0208208449,
0.0293688308,
-0.0367830172,
-0.0054078195,
0.0230494514,
0.0012049059,
0.0655699149,
-0.0102721155,
-0.0033481331,
-0.0405567549,
0.0310634021,
0.0711306408,
0.0207161643,
-0.0175074209,
0.0193879046,
-0.0149835581,
-0.0499198027,
0.0230104383,
-0.0730859488,
-0.0146463281,
-0.0475098677,
-0.0522963814,
-0.002116377,
0.0431762487,
-0.0354529358,
-0.0063614589,
-0.0230432674,
0.0188031755,
0.0103115598,
0.0337593332,
0.0301047806,
0.0127290729,
0.0368215628,
0.0313067324,
0.067005977,
0.0145528018,
0.0066286735,
-0.0490767881,
-0.0351130217,
0.0365700014,
0.0074474509,
-0.0177424047,
0.0087318756,
-0.0020607156,
-0.0035280616,
0.0262772925,
0.0485235155,
-0.0077742916,
0.0367662534,
-0.0342616998,
-0.0354731977,
-0.0091646304,
0.0580006018,
-0.0077794902,
0.0313864388,
0.0298464093,
0.0063361651,
-0.0326034352,
-0.0099597853,
0.0573804118,
-0.0260818601,
-0.0675325319,
0.0511817858,
-0.0010937675,
-0.0008101027,
0.0025881114,
-0.0296450574,
-0.0088484474,
-0.0453124493,
-0.0033425393,
0.0208133943,
-0.0255108308,
-0.0294706393,
-0.0755825117,
0.018957641,
-0.0007153052,
-0.015610205,
0.0063989419,
-0.0531938113,
0.0125235636,
0.0359092765,
0.0173945334,
0.0132809626,
-0.0072469632,
0.0473836325,
-0.0464727208,
0.0353919528,
-0.0853221864,
0.0225336794,
-0.0014439834,
0.0070596472,
0.0149007766,
-0.0294501223,
-0.0112157939,
-0.0442767255,
-0.0299919341,
0.022126006,
0.0084451362,
-0.0085259732,
0.0202542972,
0.0104425121,
-0.0091422573,
0.0153130013,
-0.0668734834,
0.027654646,
-0.0361830667,
-0.0015834549,
-0.0008524511,
0.0063992445,
-0.0148203829,
-0.0298809893,
-0.0014508447,
-0.0015677059,
0.0062860358,
0.0577136986,
0.0010682743,
-0.0153293069,
0.0194245838,
-0.0008567056,
-0.0706215203,
-0.0229772944,
0.0797871351,
0.0071389438,
0.016783217,
-0.0386284217,
-0.0003365084,
-0.0309576094,
0.0155503433,
0.0103140734,
-0.0056642583,
-0.0119706783,
0.0362238586,
-0.0218909811,
0.0740160793,
0.0053979694,
0.0504923239,
0.0557118468,
0.0124739064,
-0.0401354209,
-0.0168009605,
-0.0026400816,
-0.0170582738,
0.0025258437,
-0.0368162543,
0.0052606333,
0.0676772147,
0.0083918674,
-0.0436685868,
-0.0626483262,
0.03837163,
-0.0740663707,
-0.0282258149,
-0.0482979827,
0.0100984564,
-0.0042285896,
-0.0042644073,
-0.035876438,
-0.0470524542,
0.0471933112,
0.0177157391,
0.0265278686,
-0.0246373247,
-0.0142408125,
-0.0573587157,
0.0341505557,
0.0021005627,
0.0085235909,
0.0242749769,
-0.0148071917,
-0.0627401099,
-0.0213326737,
0.0425679721,
-0.0267368648,
0.0475992598,
-0.0261761509,
0.0051377122,
-0.027452562,
-0.0803083405,
-0.0364667401,
-0.0901039317,
-0.0274363011,
0.0266954731,
-0.0250968467,
-0.0037285264,
-0.0301378239,
-0.0085279224,
-0.0094497604,
0.0160525367,
-0.024340529,
-0.0039441935,
0.0121464692,
0.0076730805,
0.0386427231,
-0.0371177122,
0.0189347547,
-0.0170838293,
0.0301559027,
0.0258055851,
0.0206804182,
0.0532943793,
0.0488831438,
0.0394502208,
0.0629276484,
-0.0464051031,
-0.027646143,
-0.0006619116,
0.0689035431,
-0.0573276505,
0.0108310273,
0.0971622989,
0.0232922193,
-0.0527545512,
0.0120444233,
-0.0114946542,
0.0044113761,
0.0444063507,
0.0085520092,
-0.0713293105,
-0.0344770923,
0.0266883206,
0.0347821862,
-0.0690838248,
-0.0489964411,
-0.0065008323,
-0.1359711736,
0.0241082199,
0.0125588458,
-0.0453664884,
0.0101899421,
-0.0355643965,
0.0392836705,
-0.0352013446,
0.0661348552,
-0.0145286024,
-0.027518874,
0.004309556,
0.0116038853,
0.0003522836,
-0.050749056,
0.0548815392,
-0.0638672486,
0.0543721467,
0.0376014896,
0.0295065641,
-0.0177772604,
0.0156640634,
0.0298518874,
-0.0483284518,
0.0002707991,
-0.0331973955,
0.0552266166,
-0.0331142657,
-0.0118968682,
-0.0433962382,
0.0145898107,
0.0190475434,
-0.0015832976,
-0.0195699874,
0.0053778547,
0.017709557,
-0.0575226061,
-0.042600967,
0.0065507237,
-0.0248451643,
0.0871548802,
0.0132639231,
-0.0515240543,
-0.0206439868,
-0.0713415965,
-0.0423186347,
-0.0409687608,
-0.058163777,
0.071690172,
0.0015891863,
-0.0595317408,
-0.0117049124,
-0.0287162755,
0.0415343717,
0.0018814177,
-0.0021388575,
0.0025482511,
-0.015488646,
-0.0131715983,
-0.0255570877,
0.0227029193,
-0.057911057,
0.011174486,
-0.0084624626,
-0.0154676763,
0.0030008021,
-0.0125620598,
-0.0154428072,
-0.0475013554,
-0.0660336986,
-0.0475422852,
0.0263433307,
0.0088122822,
0.0147378044,
0.0341058671,
0.0025444503,
-0.069293797,
0.0827234834,
0.0821290612,
0.0255743992,
0.0219176058,
0.0042266943,
-0.0183513463,
-0.0012654351,
0.0293325875,
-0.034468554,
0.0051004803,
0.0646026731,
0.0298969205,
-0.0161769073,
0.0126102166,
-0.017102059,
0.0230738036,
0.0533315241,
-0.0403293073,
-0.0679927394,
-0.0144156953,
-0.0163991153,
0.0164866392,
-0.0321047269,
0.0111191301,
-0.0557778589,
0.0194183495,
0.028287584,
-0.0611732975,
-0.0046828147,
-0.0198310111,
0.0491411388,
-0.0489864722,
0.0227419622,
-0.0019583218,
-0.010222639,
0.0008415684,
0.0354538746,
-0.0073378184,
0.0304756612,
0.0080351811,
0.0409275182,
-0.0096168546,
0.0273693241,
0.0104674743,
0.0410144478,
-0.0565605313,
-0.0069539146,
-0.0622969493,
0.0254715271,
-0.0169774089,
0.0180920698,
0.057633277,
-0.0620965362,
-0.0038439257,
0.0046291454,
-0.0221807901,
-0.0099518793,
-0.0169928055,
0.0180936176,
-0.0033720641,
0.0377043001,
0.000820799,
-0.0035952956,
0.0144518074,
0.0737568215,
0.0455405526,
0.063465789,
-0.0030637376,
-0.0274919011,
0.0112090632,
-0.0088526309,
0.04605579,
-0.0032415269,
-0.0022622505,
0.0119719105,
-0.0987493396,
-0.0442944057,
-0.0139945522,
-0.0310711749,
0.022420872,
-0.0012969323,
-0.0062203798,
0.0430020727,
-0.0115672695,
-0.0414652489,
-0.0482052788,
-0.0242575426,
-0.0073600211,
-0.0259201024,
-0.020149108,
-5.931248784e-33,
-0.0144549794,
-0.0041624154,
-0.0308309216,
-0.0493222885,
0.0010591398,
-0.0064053219,
0.0204617847,
-0.0155984731,
-0.0268952698,
0.0149738714,
-0.0144281369,
0.0012737463,
0.0109592564,
0.0263973884,
0.03563039,
-0.0450770073,
0.0592537187,
0.0174531266,
-0.0075325686,
-0.0251649395,
-0.0368259661,
0.0311167222,
0.0534609407,
0.0304827671,
0.0469487645,
0.0276609287,
0.0352303945,
0.0351740941,
-0.0040878574,
0.0386911817,
-0.0154824052,
0.0995447785,
0.0582474358,
-0.0160882268,
0.0144388285,
0.0179112032,
-0.0566917099,
-0.0257357843,
0.008634421,
0.0350320712,
0.0420503281,
-0.0234932099,
0.040266186,
0.0285373311,
-0.0531593151,
-0.0741942525,
0.0349027105,
-0.0044227922,
0.0002477423,
-0.0121720275,
-0.0290933046,
0.0339178182,
-0.0218526032,
0.0042255172,
0.0105200382,
-0.0139910048,
0.0035426433,
0.0823915079,
-0.0246020108,
-0.0171611588,
-0.0013219302,
-0.0013515678,
0.0270975009,
0.0398515873,
0.0219463147,
0.0408480354,
0.0117310723,
0.0476194993,
-0.0245486405,
-0.0687475875,
0.057133276,
-0.0310954507,
-0.0045500686,
0.0800572187,
0.0958783999,
0.0137537709,
-0.0817186534,
-0.0086885309,
0.016600363,
0.0305952802,
0.02518191,
-0.0027212906,
-0.054867629,
-0.0541919582,
-0.046946235,
-0.0571033917,
-0.0337930396,
0.01044524,
0.0109288106,
0.0268650185,
-0.0143352114,
0.0145005481,
0.0278118085,
-0.0579782575,
-0.065230377,
0.0216596797,
-0.0000171296,
-0.0336255059,
0.0121741733,
0.0046021105,
-0.0533746965,
-0.0085930526,
0.0086284652,
0.0147310076,
0.0362104066,
0.0074454579,
0.0605694465,
0.0061296183,
-0.0690067112,
-0.0057568285,
-0.0248256475,
0.020662399,
0.0255307332,
0.0280900374,
0.0259809885,
0.039422527,
0.0076878904,
0.0228289701,
0.0414108448,
-0.0248171929,
-0.004131421,
0.0131262802,
-0.0265759211,
0.000654404,
-0.0108437603,
-0.0081425542,
0.0442818813,
0.0135407485,
0.0447727405,
-0.0366623625,
-0.0287277848,
-0.0431280546,
2.217e-7,
0.0493077785,
0.0684433207,
-0.0348020978,
0.0070251599,
0.0082309991,
0.0387179554,
0.0022955483,
0.0424710475,
0.0460476391,
0.0255142115,
-0.0190132316,
0.0280234534,
0.0267297532,
0.0161720943,
-0.068991065,
0.0279986281,
-0.0737427026,
0.0039952919,
-0.0101060886,
0.0088256923,
0.0343318135,
0.0755213574,
0.03113552,
-0.0243587308,
0.0022581066,
-0.0466029905,
0.0344898663,
-0.0393657722,
-0.0016187873,
0.001396374,
0.006516607,
0.0029256917,
0.0442502797,
0.0540879779,
-0.0238918029,
0.0390625224,
-0.0192807112,
0.032730937,
-0.0324967131,
0.0098956022,
-0.0429453813,
0.00064228,
-0.0174776446,
-0.0477332324,
0.0909609795,
-0.0292437598,
-0.0610035509,
-0.063527517,
0.0109480694,
-0.0135231307,
0.0630244091,
-0.0134464353,
-0.0147672454,
0.0224891212,
0.042481862,
0.0107294684,
-0.037533503,
-0.0984609425,
-0.0358890444,
0.0073549328,
-0.0154881291,
-0.0348063223,
0.0318968073,
-0.0118777091,
-0.0034112465,
-0.0549621247,
0.0234155934,
1.931301632e-34,
0.0215387065,
0.0327272676,
0.0420758799,
-0.0246125031,
-0.0186440535,
0.0352378413,
0.0131843537,
-0.0038336725,
0.0259299539,
-0.014686197,
0.0088059185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08469v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08469v2 | UNcommonsense Reasoning: Abductive Reasoning about Uncommon Situations | 2023-11-14T19:00:55 | 2024-05-01T05:12:07 | Wenting Zhao, Justin T Chiu, Jena D. Hwang, Faeze Brahman, Jack Hessel, Sanjiban Choudhury, Yejin Choi, Xiang Lorraine Li, Alane Suhr | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language technologies that accurately model the dynamics of events must
perform commonsense reasoning. Existing work evaluating commonsense reasoning
focuses on making inferences about common, everyday situations. To instead
investigate the ability to model unusual, unexpected, and unlikely situations,
we explore the task of uncommonsense abductive reasoning. Given a piece of
context with an unexpected outcome, this task requires reasoning abductively to
generate an explanation that makes the unexpected outcome more likely in the
context. To this end, we curate and release a new English language corpus
called UNcommonsense. We characterize the performance differences between human
explainers and the best-performing large language models, finding that
model-enhanced human-written explanations achieve the highest quality by
trading off between specificity and diversity. Finally, we experiment with
several imitation learning algorithms to train open and accessible language
models on this task. When compared with the vanilla supervised fine-tuning
approach, these methods consistently reduce lose rates on both common and
uncommonsense abductive reasoning judged by human evaluators. | [
0.0446918719,
0.049906373,
-0.0063435552,
0.0239994451,
-0.0348100141,
0.0099104429,
0.0064426819,
0.0003003951,
-0.0203434825,
-0.0522246659,
0.0436660424,
-0.030416511,
0.0097022261,
0.022074135,
0.0289077163,
-0.0507552326,
0.0234151892,
-0.0349807516,
0.0427759178,
0.0004176882,
-0.0103317136,
0.0341871716,
-0.0203319509,
0.0662556738,
0.0232530739,
0.0036830907,
-0.0396395363,
-0.0000914299,
0.0394913107,
-0.0141614946,
-0.0092354342,
0.0473825745,
0.0651594922,
0.0494271293,
0.0000020676,
-0.05098195,
0.0147202965,
0.0020173502,
-0.039700225,
-0.0083334604,
0.0086576547,
0.0203200858,
0.0001148765,
0.0269340519,
-0.0332397074,
0.0401529558,
0.0553535745,
0.0420091078,
0.0318875723,
0.0756247714,
0.0079424586,
-0.0332420506,
-0.0131891184,
0.0017427952,
0.051396817,
-0.0398763604,
-0.013401635,
0.0134221045,
0.0269554779,
-0.0280251913,
-0.0070144734,
-0.0171159469,
0.0471942574,
-0.025754394,
-0.034318164,
0.0629473403,
-0.0290654451,
-0.0207084827,
-0.0186792891,
0.0714770108,
0.0066759977,
-0.0503556356,
-0.0026525375,
-0.0047761374,
0.0190855619,
0.0342267193,
-0.0283572711,
0.0359028131,
0.0005912053,
0.0368653052,
0.0356711857,
0.0332301594,
0.041286625,
0.0505326353,
-0.0055345953,
0.0537879877,
-0.0023616755,
0.0157590732,
-0.0164814219,
-0.0096109789,
-0.0477105789,
-0.049685549,
0.0026241939,
0.0505656376,
-0.045977287,
0.0156505983,
-0.0071101114,
-0.0319610387,
0.0133141344,
-0.029808823,
0.0552821942,
0.0421516523,
-0.012325896,
0.0542063676,
-0.0037454665,
0.0220252592,
-0.0216320865,
0.026868755,
-0.018299656,
0.0024923107,
-0.0603069812,
-0.0044225706,
0.0015501162,
0.0006577804,
-0.0719159096,
-0.010214434,
0.0154930754,
-0.0233744662,
-0.0255284421,
0.0106311515,
0.0012631544,
0.0599567406,
-0.0406490378,
-0.0649163127,
-0.0535946302,
-0.0088763917,
-0.0533078946,
0.0460008159,
0.0585892573,
-0.0568489097,
-0.0437870361,
-0.0028219703,
0.0327372551,
-0.0258167889,
-0.021757897,
0.0200593751,
-0.0212479085,
-0.0032960402,
-0.0315495916,
-0.0167460628,
0.0113628451,
-0.0569250286,
-0.0344575346,
-0.0557815433,
0.0216800813,
-0.0047904681,
-0.0272758901,
-0.0321081281,
0.0243476387,
0.0166152064,
-0.0226480383,
0.0719025061,
-0.023477776,
0.0152911441,
-0.0004707925,
0.016881397,
-0.0153125469,
0.0627508834,
0.0211494658,
0.0053964453,
0.0081192553,
-0.0039907335,
0.0832972527,
-0.012766039,
0.0126125067,
-0.0180045944,
0.0036220818,
0.0140874414,
-0.0643798262,
0.0398553871,
0.0512845218,
0.006837545,
-0.0338453799,
-0.0021966866,
0.0455425009,
0.0814110264,
-0.0549756289,
0.0224489532,
0.0393431224,
0.0280553903,
-0.030317897,
-0.0078578452,
-0.0555075817,
0.0514298379,
-0.0278944895,
-0.0055034002,
-0.0240333881,
0.0078697391,
-0.0202879962,
-0.0174789652,
-0.024350917,
-0.0281778499,
0.0406971909,
0.0045629116,
0.0423354506,
0.0219110269,
-0.0364829823,
0.0694257542,
0.0401565321,
-0.0406127907,
-0.0303959195,
-0.0666202679,
0.0365910977,
0.0581445545,
0.0294706244,
-0.0246489476,
-0.0000473741,
-0.0390446447,
0.0092475647,
0.0477453135,
0.0475258753,
0.010960008,
0.024901472,
-0.0442464501,
-0.0186513644,
-0.0143445553,
0.0372934341,
0.0213450324,
0.0198721439,
-0.0006263829,
0.0037986357,
-0.075514175,
-0.027444968,
0.0311721675,
-0.0675120428,
-0.0169210602,
-0.0356607661,
-0.0076570348,
-0.0047878651,
0.0180102084,
0.0120739387,
0.0047363718,
0.0006896284,
-0.0234011505,
-0.0380619057,
0.0641720369,
-0.0386699513,
-0.0368989967,
0.0249071456,
-0.0840367079,
-0.0506710447,
0.0338735022,
-0.0400493369,
-0.043959748,
0.0344227925,
-0.0364978127,
0.0607677251,
-0.0580254495,
-0.0299824942,
-0.0180639308,
-0.0172653515,
0.0193334334,
0.1096505746,
-0.0214140546,
0.0018256964,
-0.0163878947,
-0.0093256114,
-0.0175294057,
-0.0414739661,
0.0065259021,
-0.0124857537,
-0.0126511622,
0.0021776112,
0.0143815475,
-0.0201783068,
-0.0522669032,
-0.004734206,
-0.0716369376,
-0.0154391769,
-0.0255512688,
-0.0017371331,
0.0243976917,
-0.0001482634,
0.0104273725,
-0.0241048653,
-0.0206596665,
-0.0352288336,
0.00138997,
0.0113411751,
0.0217490681,
-0.0122933863,
-0.0163897332,
-0.030525269,
0.0230769645,
-0.0187066253,
0.0611916967,
0.0169424769,
0.0790775344,
-0.047749836,
-0.0070845331,
-0.0192542914,
0.0036830918,
-0.0238834918,
-0.0415021554,
0.0307364948,
-0.0082261628,
-0.0471440703,
0.0536656454,
0.0157476217,
0.0400279649,
0.0368989967,
0.0225181077,
-0.0592638478,
0.0019806088,
-0.0212817267,
0.0059847808,
-0.0428022332,
-0.0347991288,
-0.0481569618,
0.0515559241,
0.0166937038,
0.0130083086,
-0.0721985027,
0.0164723042,
0.0137850298,
-0.0440470874,
-0.0475621521,
-0.0501873754,
-0.0260970164,
0.0753984898,
-0.0338612907,
-0.0280052815,
0.0879482776,
0.0184182581,
-0.002870902,
-0.0335955732,
0.0108973403,
-0.0043367036,
0.0785728246,
-0.0393210277,
0.0112198899,
0.0055743987,
-0.0082096644,
-0.0221646447,
-0.0321392454,
0.0372656435,
-0.0297003295,
0.0329846591,
-0.059952803,
-0.0078088632,
0.0224089567,
-0.0332797132,
-0.0460681282,
-0.0734828562,
-0.0563078709,
-0.0020105969,
-0.0197384879,
-0.0424414501,
-0.0460057929,
-0.0046883184,
0.0312690511,
0.0250617154,
0.0096328547,
-0.0148245692,
-0.0124670938,
0.0144741777,
0.0552639812,
0.0717913806,
0.0399810001,
-0.0195222236,
0.0333027132,
0.0492633283,
0.0498091243,
-0.0191608686,
-0.0489660837,
0.0369570293,
-0.0213160235,
0.0106518352,
0.0044512623,
0.0392839313,
0.0714882836,
-0.0529441386,
-0.0118156737,
0.1170828715,
0.03317976,
-0.0020378022,
0.0213518962,
-0.0461253077,
0.0569483936,
0.0172019135,
0.0110856472,
-0.0683100969,
-0.0416101068,
0.0283001326,
0.0242862515,
-0.0052275835,
-0.0602554902,
0.0055132043,
-0.1296204031,
0.0443859622,
0.0019163699,
-0.0433554724,
-0.013935863,
-0.0649797395,
0.0075984728,
-0.041285973,
0.0018226338,
0.0018003141,
0.0408084653,
0.0245815068,
0.0123242242,
-0.026309127,
-0.0683656037,
0.0458600298,
-0.0128715001,
0.0419631898,
0.041256126,
0.0475496985,
-0.012245344,
-0.0523765907,
-0.0251466148,
-0.0101842191,
0.0325078703,
0.0020047361,
0.0207357239,
0.0427704975,
-0.0013896842,
-0.0511403605,
0.0952752233,
-0.0678024143,
-0.0668113679,
-0.0066197957,
0.108009167,
-0.0256768223,
-0.023586737,
0.0115478244,
-0.0279243253,
0.0467886515,
0.0942391604,
0.0303946976,
-0.0120822387,
-0.0267569907,
-0.0267110635,
-0.0099182874,
-0.055751089,
-0.0246521868,
0.0136030242,
0.0509258322,
-0.0361848772,
-0.0423218161,
-0.0218145773,
0.0115453871,
0.0605184771,
0.0071530016,
-0.0137200598,
-0.0034752754,
0.0026369935,
-0.0150349205,
0.0568499342,
0.0038290066,
0.0160304736,
0.0438533612,
0.0043131961,
-0.0133710532,
-0.0368820354,
-0.0255300514,
0.0036898656,
-0.0147170704,
-0.0650846735,
0.0158710238,
0.0247997828,
0.036430873,
0.0646071658,
-0.0327536948,
-0.0532382913,
0.0223682821,
0.0103369737,
-0.0088571701,
-0.0089314338,
0.0432304963,
-0.0147891697,
0.0187116619,
0.0585559979,
-0.0077026794,
0.0011044355,
-0.0006548265,
0.0466619618,
-0.0491986722,
0.0015277963,
0.0250304453,
-0.0153699238,
0.0208071638,
-0.0526392274,
-0.0251075067,
-0.0252291262,
0.000349023,
-0.0077455826,
-0.0103357062,
-0.0330875851,
0.0239431802,
0.026175119,
-0.0087098703,
0.0031810612,
-0.0084165223,
-0.02077353,
0.0269748997,
-0.0212228354,
0.0139685394,
0.0634844974,
0.0373167507,
0.0009949193,
0.0059751328,
-0.0168735422,
0.0100605674,
-0.057276424,
0.0832489207,
-0.0009150082,
0.0758660883,
0.0298982058,
-0.0313808993,
0.006437717,
-0.0327439718,
-0.0745302811,
-0.0311337225,
0.0091304807,
0.042689871,
0.0316029154,
-0.0514835529,
0.0417938679,
-0.0223041121,
0.0214319918,
0.0307434369,
0.0629428849,
0.0179414172,
-0.0302922875,
0.0143319685,
0.0195739679,
-0.0186837241,
0.0129932016,
0.0512060076,
-0.0791849717,
0.0432730727,
-0.0218430348,
-0.0106290737,
-0.0079583423,
-0.0139121106,
0.0121161118,
0.0628645346,
0.0221019462,
0.0162482895,
-0.064361766,
-0.044096902,
-0.0361442827,
0.0233233292,
-0.0073765051,
-0.0081932321,
0.0203187689,
0.0587982759,
-0.0291727576,
-0.0185263604,
-0.0278075151,
0.0179653615,
-0.0338286385,
0.0198966283,
-0.0529488474,
-6.719357869e-33,
0.0134454966,
-0.0435325503,
-0.0237462893,
-0.0571331754,
0.008789652,
-0.0194128435,
-0.0644644126,
-0.0040941206,
-0.0194847211,
0.0576834306,
0.00128825,
0.0376529172,
0.0117462287,
0.0281256679,
0.0049993559,
-0.0056834328,
-0.0105600143,
0.0282108691,
-0.0301961899,
0.0074833813,
0.0611226186,
0.0039056195,
0.0552451946,
-0.068357259,
0.0558470748,
-0.0282453261,
-0.0271314681,
0.0331887752,
-0.0204690937,
0.0306572616,
-0.021965418,
0.0226950236,
0.0047720931,
-0.0350367911,
-0.0005743474,
0.029052753,
-0.043434076,
-0.0374389365,
0.0527858622,
-0.0084555866,
-0.0151996743,
-0.0256774109,
-0.0032138922,
-0.0038611579,
-0.0059675234,
0.0088502467,
0.0335168652,
-0.0322420374,
0.0144571401,
0.0416372046,
-0.0306267291,
0.0141104972,
-0.0416386351,
-0.0400429145,
-0.0105379447,
0.0269531924,
-0.0199333932,
-0.0485436842,
-0.0463997759,
0.0085611409,
-0.0092401179,
-0.0308680106,
0.0540012158,
-0.0268274583,
-0.0212424044,
0.0767961517,
-0.0123289684,
-0.0189107079,
-0.064818956,
0.0251369122,
-0.0192198586,
0.0957093909,
0.0566892028,
0.0651171356,
0.032349214,
0.0123941107,
-0.0348105542,
0.023994768,
-0.0334278829,
0.0261887833,
0.0733594894,
0.0161799975,
-0.0614671223,
-0.0155663919,
-0.0408646353,
0.0139168883,
-0.0283686537,
-0.0253211427,
0.0077046095,
-0.0045563956,
-0.0404299311,
-0.0072585777,
0.0055079684,
-0.0396424942,
0.00211533,
0.0055946899,
0.008279182,
-0.0095024854,
-0.0039225221,
0.0149932411,
-0.0174839422,
-0.0237531308,
0.0342639349,
0.0313843563,
0.0229121279,
0.0106868558,
0.0444724746,
0.0275720488,
-0.0271279011,
0.0084020859,
-0.0630967319,
0.0057310574,
0.0001712398,
-0.0383197181,
0.0306650884,
0.0324723348,
-0.0360239521,
0.0069434098,
0.0174403749,
0.025432203,
-0.0148420008,
0.0068324902,
-0.0286352877,
0.0052771298,
-0.0225374736,
0.0034289947,
-0.0212976765,
-0.0363405272,
0.0226804707,
-0.0203371532,
-0.0125933476,
0.0267801434,
2.688e-7,
0.0122784562,
0.0293828957,
0.0200663842,
-0.033871077,
0.0186092183,
0.0680804625,
-0.0131560257,
0.0011569066,
0.0020400276,
-0.0562814437,
0.0103344405,
0.056097459,
0.0584696755,
0.0228894614,
-0.029566301,
-0.0074099293,
-0.0813614577,
-0.014350405,
-0.037944667,
0.0032530872,
0.0661739111,
0.0692986771,
0.0487124957,
-0.0143821128,
0.0286890436,
-0.0486830212,
0.0346592441,
-0.0352623723,
0.0059482981,
-0.0323918387,
0.0370602682,
0.0253398586,
0.0154716335,
-0.0112036699,
-0.0196139459,
-0.0140721928,
-0.038470272,
0.0290355962,
-0.0551157296,
-0.0273191798,
-0.0280309487,
-0.0438922197,
0.0145216202,
-0.0863320678,
0.0742680356,
-0.0491339862,
-0.0387396514,
-0.0197382309,
-0.0162786208,
-0.0058722128,
-0.0276225079,
0.0074213413,
-0.0006585731,
0.0097118765,
-0.0102368696,
-0.0111387903,
0.006677004,
-0.0838552043,
-0.0638095662,
0.0306769907,
-0.0265405998,
-0.0252561197,
-0.0205700416,
-0.0067256815,
0.0337762237,
-0.0642092079,
-0.0021373131,
2.276373509e-34,
0.0276637282,
0.047095038,
-0.0179431103,
0.0619911775,
0.0669127628,
0.019609889,
0.0280928966,
-0.0119638983,
0.072642833,
-0.0257402826,
-0.0114779305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08402v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08402v1 | Retrieve and Copy: Scaling ASR Personalization to Large Catalogs | 2023-11-14T18:59:24 | 2023-11-14T18:59:24 | Sai Muralidhar Jayanthi, Devang Kulshreshtha, Saket Dingliwal, Srikanth Ronanki, Sravan Bodapati | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.SD, eess.AS | Personalization of automatic speech recognition (ASR) models is a widely
studied topic because of its many practical applications. Most recently,
attention-based contextual biasing techniques are used to improve the
recognition of rare words and domain specific entities. However, due to
performance constraints, the biasing is often limited to a few thousand
entities, restricting real-world usability. To address this, we first propose a
"Retrieve and Copy" mechanism to improve latency while retaining the accuracy
even when scaled to a large catalog. We also propose a training strategy to
overcome the degradation in recall at such scale due to an increased number of
confusing entities. Overall, our approach achieves up to 6% more Word Error
Rate reduction (WERR) and 3.6% absolute improvement in F1 when compared to a
strong baseline. Our method also allows for large catalog sizes of up to 20K
without significantly affecting WER and F1-scores, while achieving at least 20%
inference speedup per acoustic frame. | [
0.0240670256,
0.085814096,
0.0027990849,
0.0196107756,
0.0034116567,
-0.0191859938,
0.0535305142,
-0.0306018163,
-0.0000189476,
-0.0434511267,
-0.0570371076,
-0.0191787668,
-0.0117126079,
0.0132660735,
0.0028849749,
-0.0687272549,
0.0189820174,
-0.0398629978,
0.0207062084,
-0.023034567,
0.0086600501,
0.0147009743,
0.0026654804,
0.0222153086,
0.0301357564,
-0.0196486004,
-0.0060998509,
0.0342550501,
0.0254872814,
-0.0310594849,
-0.0196056329,
0.0321141295,
0.0266543329,
0.0229075998,
0.0000018732,
-0.0586529784,
-0.0539890155,
0.0053112549,
-0.0686114207,
0.0145349307,
0.0526567884,
0.0526042581,
-0.0149725685,
0.0324961543,
0.023240814,
-0.0286933985,
0.0356533453,
0.046709314,
-0.008046397,
0.0463891067,
-0.0030297327,
-0.0150453085,
0.0040212297,
-0.0320512541,
0.0371675976,
-0.0623303801,
0.0039812499,
-0.0438798517,
-0.0049895099,
0.0033805806,
-0.0345110968,
0.0419650376,
0.0059159021,
0.0202113856,
0.0776046515,
0.0216033477,
-0.0253080335,
0.0058010346,
-0.0245839674,
0.083958149,
0.0235800352,
-0.0241885316,
-0.0070250453,
-0.0110011762,
0.005505919,
-0.0429666974,
-0.037913166,
0.0038683722,
-0.0108442316,
-0.0065016067,
-0.0211915765,
0.0082820738,
0.0263217855,
-0.0121382615,
-0.0119314687,
-0.02820432,
0.0134952199,
-0.0551245436,
0.0074296426,
-0.0277293269,
-0.0183559116,
-0.0304824561,
0.0543306284,
-0.0078363568,
-0.0238735378,
0.008606432,
-0.0578975417,
-0.0298675783,
-0.0041034264,
-0.0229782388,
0.0302335452,
0.0328463167,
-0.0667715222,
0.0485886969,
0.0127652474,
0.040731132,
0.0114713106,
-0.0181953851,
-0.0347973518,
-0.0012588426,
-0.0337348171,
0.0134577835,
-0.0485020466,
0.0522165895,
0.0124206897,
-0.0300393514,
-0.0507710762,
-0.0072559076,
-0.0180396885,
0.003521523,
0.0213565473,
0.0177794155,
-0.0607722737,
-0.0054022772,
0.0101935593,
0.0017260181,
-0.032738477,
0.0370730422,
-0.0063476316,
-0.0243786164,
-0.0208138227,
-0.004672342,
0.0656783506,
-0.0283111408,
0.018011475,
0.0439166501,
0.0028772692,
-0.0426940396,
-0.0458389483,
-0.0103580235,
-0.031839259,
-0.0384775549,
-0.0501073413,
-0.0310652889,
0.0273663774,
0.0066392045,
-0.0131409112,
-0.0089337863,
-0.0114946552,
-0.0196897201,
0.0065455823,
0.0702210441,
0.0335973054,
0.0164735876,
0.0162294731,
-0.0140354624,
0.003616493,
0.0239742678,
0.036890585,
0.0131210089,
0.0570920557,
-0.0197987128,
-0.0305526648,
0.0285365637,
0.0038536256,
-0.0212528463,
0.012342588,
-0.0079806624,
0.0022468569,
0.0327122137,
0.0568463393,
0.0377534851,
-0.0437123515,
-0.012384695,
0.0408387594,
0.0376466177,
0.026999319,
0.0282450859,
0.0121694868,
0.04599718,
-0.0365715511,
-0.0434942059,
-0.0456934422,
0.0131258098,
0.0267650541,
0.0334088169,
0.0822674632,
0.0124194911,
-0.0187476613,
0.0156367663,
0.0227190871,
-0.0244718343,
-0.0013993836,
0.0530522317,
0.032900162,
0.0319815055,
-0.0226731058,
0.0844044983,
0.0115996273,
-0.0605917461,
0.0260068644,
-0.0160587505,
-0.0114001948,
0.097425282,
0.0424493365,
-0.039000988,
0.0156883821,
-0.0171103124,
-0.0299428292,
0.024692012,
0.0035396258,
-0.0063813594,
0.0386915579,
-0.0743111745,
-0.0232666954,
0.0252082907,
-0.0177864581,
0.0748549998,
0.019595813,
0.0517215244,
0.0398674048,
-0.0250851996,
-0.0006493054,
-0.0171445999,
0.0105625223,
-0.0933675542,
0.0343024097,
0.0393640511,
0.0718579516,
0.0466522127,
0.0089045139,
-0.016413318,
0.0259543825,
-0.0160045307,
-0.0042622932,
0.0086099897,
-0.0639111921,
-0.022936279,
0.0396259539,
-0.0044390406,
0.0179754011,
0.0409003645,
-0.0113650458,
-0.0496815294,
0.0506444909,
-0.0406805202,
0.0510697328,
-0.0209654104,
0.0523556434,
0.0344059244,
0.0344545469,
-0.0076430202,
0.0136372745,
0.0238263123,
-0.0053785527,
0.0102030691,
-0.0185189396,
-0.0178556629,
-0.1020898893,
0.0192812979,
-0.0068883123,
-0.0062126894,
0.0260271952,
0.0234292243,
-0.0293641035,
-0.045168791,
-0.0049529467,
-0.0802757591,
-0.0112609779,
-0.0035006204,
0.0144372704,
-0.0192625485,
0.042078726,
0.0155616915,
-0.0356366411,
-0.0098541817,
-0.038213402,
-0.0444911085,
0.011228255,
-0.0345964171,
-0.007889539,
-0.0560509823,
-0.0078731133,
0.0033402462,
0.0140489349,
-0.0018386851,
-0.0146301892,
-0.0254098456,
-0.069097735,
0.0094390484,
-0.0084250253,
0.0368394293,
-0.0117096547,
0.0411143713,
-0.021439366,
-0.0185279194,
0.007679258,
0.062591739,
-0.0091129234,
-0.016902633,
0.0153702982,
-0.0139419818,
-0.0788126737,
0.0266115852,
-0.0128686139,
0.0109358998,
0.0071542542,
0.0101917041,
-0.0008100513,
0.0181505177,
0.0041796062,
0.026615588,
-0.0329816639,
-0.025645325,
0.0085704345,
-0.0261626597,
-0.0251408163,
-0.0169084817,
-0.0401262343,
0.0013920558,
-0.0177150425,
-0.0170511082,
0.0524897203,
-0.0315677412,
-0.0165921412,
-0.0513062179,
-0.0050133509,
-0.0260185599,
0.0284680668,
-0.0175888725,
0.0206509512,
-0.0021179647,
-0.0800126418,
-0.0369121805,
0.0116435876,
0.0340016186,
-0.0455855243,
0.0282229427,
-0.0014193272,
0.008407915,
-0.0035831619,
-0.056907706,
-0.0376792923,
-0.0156638529,
-0.0157607775,
-0.0101326657,
0.0287541114,
-0.0339109078,
-0.0664810389,
0.0221809018,
0.0330370665,
0.0598298237,
0.005303131,
0.0016850805,
-0.0015055091,
0.0215483755,
0.0250646397,
0.0456420854,
-0.0047393516,
-0.0148073109,
-0.0364477448,
0.0288339145,
0.100111194,
-0.0341957174,
-0.014556732,
-0.005165793,
0.0602331609,
-0.0282272585,
0.0127869602,
0.0145082539,
0.0239454713,
-0.0421797968,
-0.0094475774,
0.0804216936,
-0.0025577461,
-0.0761439949,
-0.0057766777,
0.0139694801,
0.0196568333,
0.0131166233,
0.015711261,
-0.051676929,
-0.0441912487,
0.060550008,
0.0863218233,
0.0096012689,
0.0027212049,
-0.029301146,
-0.1299000829,
0.0244359914,
0.0217051357,
-0.0600399524,
-0.0414186865,
-0.052968163,
-0.0223624185,
-0.0015339061,
0.0666443408,
0.0182220042,
-0.015551975,
-0.0278744046,
0.033908654,
-0.0127984965,
-0.0689800531,
0.0293053575,
-0.0134317279,
0.0683773682,
0.0464372337,
0.0280926675,
0.0186006837,
-0.0043302914,
-0.0135876937,
0.0075529902,
-0.0052661137,
-0.0041401982,
0.065879859,
-0.0480089337,
0.0144172972,
0.0120003372,
0.0396324396,
-0.0071668052,
0.0092073204,
0.0325301439,
0.0287102275,
0.0041321358,
0.0036151451,
0.0096690599,
-0.0269415844,
0.004529078,
0.0704180449,
0.0263125487,
-0.0400500931,
0.0221013762,
-0.0031144433,
0.0239330251,
-0.0433910787,
-0.0028962453,
0.0024511667,
-0.0268771462,
-0.0540638156,
-0.0510336757,
-0.0383694656,
0.00646273,
0.0299883056,
0.0212441161,
0.0011177341,
-0.0200457796,
0.0323848762,
-0.0713644251,
0.0258436482,
-0.058275599,
0.0191404335,
-0.07459867,
-0.0085015893,
0.0051183878,
-0.0666121989,
-0.0418486111,
0.0267759226,
-0.0612569861,
-0.0688726306,
0.0328303054,
-0.0101246983,
0.0152620897,
0.0977934748,
-0.0211728942,
-0.1138911322,
0.0625840724,
0.0568653084,
-0.0428536609,
0.0215802453,
0.0457944311,
0.0106250262,
-0.0165160075,
0.0319267325,
-0.0954514965,
0.0184453819,
0.0075426502,
0.0480335467,
0.0120626139,
-0.0700360164,
-0.0114228278,
0.0567682646,
0.0340773016,
-0.0165810976,
0.0202354155,
-0.0251118857,
0.0875409767,
0.0271993075,
0.0193218328,
-0.016443992,
-0.0179458484,
0.0220798012,
-0.0111106224,
-0.0175666679,
0.0080170361,
-0.0207615588,
-0.0622939132,
-0.0331665315,
0.0311962646,
-0.0098906122,
-0.0136169102,
0.0403168015,
-0.0041262279,
-0.0351186059,
0.0263770148,
0.0744414479,
0.0600330606,
-0.0068679233,
-0.0051961462,
0.0141118057,
0.0129307527,
-0.0503947064,
0.012429039,
-0.0580343902,
-0.0333087556,
-0.019162247,
0.0239927545,
-0.0003471757,
-0.0133267157,
0.0422463045,
-0.0100752879,
0.0106205195,
-0.036743775,
0.019092869,
-0.0090678772,
-0.0255097169,
-0.0089780213,
0.0199783258,
0.0021541985,
0.0484011248,
0.0530677252,
-0.0086580534,
0.0176742841,
-0.0412786007,
0.0099684726,
-0.0642858669,
-0.0178911593,
-0.03362545,
0.0165247526,
-0.0211804826,
-0.0265442915,
-0.0129216518,
-0.0754012838,
0.0480966046,
-0.0391459055,
0.0069092149,
-0.0233753026,
0.0555024222,
0.0209870934,
-0.0306559578,
-0.0187807176,
0.0137252565,
-0.0162756629,
-0.0331357867,
-0.0334349647,
0.0136592546,
-6.121173774e-33,
-0.0184195414,
0.0226009171,
-0.0139792431,
-0.0042438391,
-0.0184311345,
0.009079989,
-0.0274944175,
-0.0000221775,
0.0312696248,
-0.0280198231,
-0.0337225832,
-0.0145387119,
0.0412173979,
0.0263894815,
-0.0099568721,
0.00153148,
0.1036185399,
0.0088606542,
-0.0220799204,
0.0301035848,
0.0547093414,
0.0552144572,
0.0357814841,
-0.066098094,
-0.0287387092,
0.0050331247,
0.0130808521,
-0.0081404662,
0.0518703945,
0.0826907977,
-0.0070543466,
0.0545517355,
-0.0317728557,
-0.039735008,
-0.0261246227,
0.0073375721,
-0.1033933312,
-0.0021422775,
-0.0109160198,
0.0452010185,
0.0608248226,
-0.0418172814,
0.0442460403,
0.0150500629,
-0.0229078457,
0.0025827107,
0.034560997,
-0.0114671066,
-0.0586041361,
-0.0476296768,
-0.0155196385,
0.0182188824,
-0.0100519489,
0.021716414,
0.0814443678,
0.012299981,
-0.0078808544,
0.0540279411,
-0.0465326272,
0.0018747866,
0.0133979656,
0.0122234738,
0.0258298907,
0.0603042133,
0.0019068778,
0.0370833352,
0.0649482682,
-0.0337613039,
0.0213875324,
-0.047337424,
0.0300896764,
0.0200971793,
-0.0050291857,
0.0493814684,
0.065186739,
0.0228114445,
-0.0163740292,
-0.0021651038,
0.0013343436,
0.0187396444,
0.0481533818,
0.0341467522,
-0.0874584541,
0.000644752,
-0.0454248302,
-0.0187917631,
-0.0587161817,
-0.0090572638,
0.0565246455,
0.0533160307,
-0.0500339381,
-0.0127809579,
0.043317724,
-0.0182832237,
-0.04063287,
0.0004641353,
0.0176835712,
-0.0002967057,
0.002158843,
-0.0166972596,
-0.0839354843,
0.0015601747,
0.0551683865,
-0.0099632889,
-0.0061585815,
-0.0326853953,
0.011726086,
0.0477872044,
-0.068256937,
0.0036341443,
0.0248938128,
0.0161016993,
-0.0301121119,
0.0313221253,
0.0630249754,
0.0053459997,
-0.0147260362,
0.0394621789,
0.0259162188,
0.0370348915,
-0.0031879307,
0.0005235619,
0.0177673474,
-0.0034535036,
-0.0549943596,
0.0083142621,
0.0174937639,
-0.0051611429,
0.0368949324,
-0.0615533777,
-0.0350125656,
-0.011619064,
2.77e-7,
-0.0428339615,
0.0204044189,
0.0317075215,
-0.007007855,
0.0120260473,
0.0348961875,
0.0287554953,
0.0294193346,
0.0206459444,
0.0168383475,
0.0294208974,
0.0276929159,
0.0789882615,
-0.0024111266,
-0.1169730052,
-0.0273190849,
-0.0371519811,
0.050465811,
-0.0080659362,
-0.0249223672,
-0.0333145522,
0.1082428023,
0.0253115743,
-0.0273392424,
0.0563488565,
-0.0432517491,
0.0282090697,
-0.027250763,
0.0205921046,
-0.0207209811,
0.0027888392,
0.0285730809,
-0.0434505343,
0.0041041248,
-0.0258361567,
0.0176898185,
0.0040804534,
0.0384304598,
-0.0312190745,
-0.0742986798,
-0.0348784178,
0.0424213,
-0.0117744943,
-0.0104369977,
0.036277622,
-0.0205583833,
-0.0065508117,
-0.0188419018,
-0.0589110218,
-0.0118588712,
-0.0295139905,
-0.0022455705,
0.0114522744,
0.0069788634,
0.0142755033,
-0.0106398948,
-0.0190962348,
-0.1081648618,
0.0354956761,
-0.0073155789,
-0.0293010585,
-0.038392026,
-0.0294783786,
-0.0063913157,
-0.0107186837,
-0.0421987735,
0.0057157385,
2.367716537e-34,
0.0651774481,
0.0002264164,
0.0290892944,
0.0082900999,
0.0091394959,
-0.0320742987,
0.0136471819,
0.0031603498,
0.0492723212,
-0.1025539488,
-0.0456984453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08401v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08401v1 | Fine-tuning Language Models for Factuality | 2023-11-14T18:59:15 | 2023-11-14T18:59:15 | Katherine Tian, Eric Mitchell, Huaxiu Yao, Christopher D. Manning, Chelsea Finn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The fluency and creativity of large pre-trained language models (LLMs) have
led to their widespread use, sometimes even as a replacement for traditional
search engines. Yet language models are prone to making convincing but
factually inaccurate claims, often referred to as 'hallucinations.' These
errors can inadvertently spread misinformation or harmfully perpetuate
misconceptions. Further, manual fact-checking of model responses is a
time-consuming process, making human factuality labels expensive to acquire. In
this work, we fine-tune language models to be more factual, without human
labeling and targeting more open-ended generation settings than past work. We
leverage two key recent innovations in NLP to do so. First, several recent
works have proposed methods for judging the factuality of open-ended text by
measuring consistency with an external knowledge base or simply a large model's
confidence scores. Second, the direct preference optimization algorithm enables
straightforward fine-tuning of language models on objectives other than
supervised imitation, using a preference ranking over possible model responses.
We show that learning from automatically generated factuality preference
rankings, generated either through existing retrieval systems or our novel
retrieval-free approach, significantly improves the factuality (percent of
generated claims that are correct) of Llama-2 on held-out topics compared with
RLHF or decoding strategies targeted at factuality. At 7B scale, compared to
Llama-2-chat, we observe 58% and 40% reduction in factual error rate when
generating biographies and answering medical questions, respectively. | [
0.0748573765,
0.0659747198,
0.0147813568,
0.0182904061,
-0.0185916889,
0.000060794,
-0.0120841693,
-0.0063846363,
0.0057192375,
-0.066556938,
-0.0139266094,
-0.046092473,
-0.0008607185,
0.020945508,
0.0086616278,
-0.0141071975,
0.0423083678,
0.0272597484,
0.0508631021,
-0.0139498068,
-0.0059559951,
0.033506427,
-0.0185446404,
0.0272142552,
-0.0092009958,
0.0015930367,
0.0394324996,
-0.0250391364,
0.0250818115,
-0.0268105101,
0.0271853972,
0.0694553852,
0.0007885348,
0.0273214299,
0.0000019717,
-0.0524409674,
0.0052657947,
-0.0012392097,
-0.0496724248,
0.0260385424,
0.0574582815,
0.0328214243,
0.0059699486,
0.0317138173,
-0.0458443239,
-0.00436843,
0.0297391005,
0.0620808639,
0.0576253198,
0.0849152356,
0.0083065443,
-0.0271373037,
0.0288266689,
-0.0252684597,
0.029279612,
-0.0104054874,
0.0400763452,
0.0070074415,
-0.0277945455,
0.0345866382,
0.0185575522,
0.0154460073,
-0.0143879252,
-0.0232442133,
0.0487915017,
0.0503765345,
-0.0511680171,
-0.0398928672,
0.0386207253,
0.0778232142,
-0.0057399971,
-0.0546945184,
0.0165136885,
-0.0130262934,
-0.023002103,
0.0113159548,
-0.0097502088,
0.0732309446,
-0.0203608908,
0.0234663747,
0.0535878465,
0.0042376211,
0.02773243,
0.0412047803,
0.0041786549,
0.0590202883,
-0.0045540743,
-0.0298178066,
0.0343837105,
0.0145348059,
0.0033886158,
-0.0773068741,
0.013216923,
0.0085932557,
-0.0328491926,
0.0288861133,
-0.0341648012,
0.0369827971,
0.0666804388,
-0.0935192108,
0.0116735939,
0.0264474042,
-0.0403928123,
0.036048051,
-0.0131536024,
0.0018771702,
0.0011119642,
0.0320155583,
-0.0134008406,
0.022323003,
0.0189611278,
0.0072932686,
0.0081524746,
0.0148333116,
-0.0230307598,
0.0063637695,
-0.0493532047,
-0.0240838602,
-0.0057871784,
0.017878741,
0.0000749168,
0.0514197648,
-0.0547248013,
-0.0181913227,
-0.0802063048,
0.0189582035,
-0.0082315793,
0.0374038592,
-0.0076260655,
-0.0559436381,
-0.0047752745,
0.0111969765,
-0.0202275496,
-0.0041550156,
0.0285320487,
0.0038498119,
-0.0039489982,
-0.0272779968,
-0.0145053249,
-0.0213630404,
-0.0113238255,
-0.0666875616,
0.0107778674,
-0.0454658195,
0.0225323178,
-0.0037931227,
-0.0136575326,
-0.0445911884,
0.0328264646,
0.064606227,
-0.0565901771,
0.0577146709,
-0.0111610368,
-0.0089303274,
0.0368047357,
0.0036169337,
0.0089188162,
0.0430034362,
0.0194156095,
0.0511137247,
0.0464774594,
0.048637975,
0.0051026451,
-0.0235585105,
0.0329769701,
-0.0134862522,
0.0324180201,
0.0223792754,
-0.0110112587,
0.0380728468,
0.0260237027,
0.0485231206,
-0.0317627341,
-0.0527936108,
0.0748246908,
-0.0061103036,
-0.0074945437,
0.0074801552,
0.0404750071,
-0.0031718276,
0.0530984588,
0.0198058244,
-0.0600272641,
0.0374480784,
-0.0404904857,
-0.0120039852,
0.0495348424,
0.0543783084,
0.0074727,
-0.066980876,
-0.0091483081,
-0.0157532878,
-0.0103607727,
-0.0017847198,
-0.006029366,
0.0257835165,
-0.031150911,
0.041265633,
0.0667960197,
-0.0425084122,
-0.0002718501,
-0.0545783862,
0.0336544029,
0.061210297,
0.0670373067,
-0.0175795667,
-0.0131172901,
-0.0168471448,
-0.0021672274,
0.0576280691,
0.0632697344,
-0.0164081659,
-0.0110526802,
-0.0321632884,
0.0017433556,
-0.0230651852,
0.0395043939,
-0.0023027456,
0.036626894,
0.0066612815,
0.0114948628,
-0.0316832438,
-0.0541068763,
0.0432818793,
-0.0415919833,
-0.0232026801,
0.0358193107,
-0.0006001738,
0.0200072546,
-0.0033044529,
-0.0208780691,
0.0226679444,
0.019954728,
-0.0117783397,
-0.0433603637,
-0.0156327747,
-0.0184554644,
-0.0409507304,
0.020590771,
-0.014242488,
-0.0329574868,
0.0308823735,
-0.0350497738,
0.017852949,
-0.0330917388,
-0.0252777115,
0.0109461443,
-0.0581639111,
0.0023579809,
0.0306679755,
0.0197739396,
-0.0405290537,
0.0871491209,
-0.0257296618,
0.0210013799,
-0.0069427169,
-0.0241384264,
-0.0016388029,
-0.0414603278,
-0.0036792143,
0.0150574269,
0.0313580185,
0.0394552089,
0.034276139,
0.0054528704,
-0.0284937937,
-0.0005250796,
-0.0937585458,
0.0256069005,
-0.0302668456,
-0.004984186,
0.0221184269,
-0.0319711752,
0.0092325676,
-0.0009134908,
-0.0446585938,
-0.0342429765,
0.0072640362,
0.0049414183,
0.0445023142,
0.0083250757,
0.0325915106,
-0.0367579311,
0.0152627025,
-0.005376765,
0.0161527004,
0.0277666952,
0.0209933054,
-0.0240454171,
0.02620418,
-0.0868293419,
0.0164599754,
-0.0161755513,
-0.0201947019,
-0.0026768737,
0.0251853652,
-0.0100235408,
0.0731011704,
0.0549046136,
0.0150570339,
0.0640421361,
0.0556833968,
-0.027957378,
-0.0124185616,
-0.0526105054,
-0.0073526953,
0.0088683935,
-0.0563396662,
0.0197369698,
0.0236877576,
0.0349876396,
-0.0058675264,
-0.0395039767,
0.023742836,
-0.0162475035,
-0.0284410883,
0.0042927875,
0.0186335556,
-0.0179144014,
0.0621090196,
-0.0233394224,
-0.0294816904,
0.1034340188,
-0.0288298186,
0.0450673625,
-0.0476901084,
0.0102387313,
-0.0278367382,
-0.0271601677,
0.0153027112,
0.0298641268,
0.0215728637,
0.0264361165,
-0.0227934886,
-0.003539372,
0.0571603142,
-0.072993882,
0.0172560103,
-0.0414858051,
0.0096418904,
0.0298106894,
-0.0681319609,
-0.0732487664,
-0.1032028496,
0.0124016916,
-0.0309159085,
-0.0210461505,
-0.0148419142,
-0.0593174212,
-0.0675997064,
0.0337558091,
0.020289408,
-0.0070140762,
-0.0112384604,
0.0088678543,
0.018586887,
0.0630976781,
0.0157931708,
0.0568573885,
-0.0109946402,
-0.0236333888,
0.0746071935,
-0.0267022662,
0.011202394,
0.0168400127,
-0.0254424978,
0.0111573189,
-0.0272029843,
-0.0210360046,
0.0200606622,
0.0312835015,
-0.0253978502,
-0.0292743556,
0.1085054427,
0.0405490622,
0.0008169853,
0.0061672125,
-0.0067203823,
0.0073008575,
0.0109039666,
0.0273539089,
-0.0628659055,
-0.0021450988,
-0.0156227229,
0.028952498,
-0.0341297239,
-0.0292511452,
-0.0243673436,
-0.1128855571,
0.0401217788,
-0.009669207,
0.0085258633,
-0.0185554791,
-0.0619189627,
0.0049891942,
-0.0226381943,
-0.0039804005,
0.0009089992,
0.0159077402,
0.0117068077,
-0.0009095417,
-0.0236089472,
-0.0594381243,
0.0449480452,
-0.0031530587,
0.0588893555,
0.0592912547,
0.0449310839,
-0.0081008188,
-0.0454396829,
-0.0194913335,
0.0083178021,
-0.0313799679,
-0.0153708039,
0.064992249,
-0.021197848,
-0.0014614125,
-0.0269315094,
0.0272424109,
0.0213716291,
-0.0207660869,
-0.0400447883,
0.0351769887,
-0.0189937726,
-0.0343714207,
-0.0144257853,
0.0394433774,
0.0304634329,
0.0853331462,
0.0009668785,
-0.0155391367,
-0.0031326269,
-0.0690833032,
0.0123044979,
-0.0264358725,
-0.0804626793,
0.0449668802,
-0.002287539,
-0.0205252841,
-0.0931433067,
-0.0238348804,
-0.0112275537,
-0.0045456826,
-0.024403926,
-0.0105209881,
0.0449300483,
-0.0253141988,
-0.0258607399,
0.0163455699,
-0.0491585545,
0.0032606258,
-0.0218392685,
-0.0156080369,
0.0589114726,
-0.0545393489,
-0.0167557951,
-0.0287213605,
-0.0361048207,
-0.0486000851,
0.0188910831,
0.0443421602,
0.0153612206,
0.0543438829,
-0.0228900127,
-0.0672561154,
0.0573117882,
0.0674479902,
-0.0508223958,
0.022277873,
0.0210981183,
0.0027902555,
0.0098857982,
0.0242172126,
-0.0246586464,
0.0272978693,
-0.0039066393,
0.0271665044,
-0.0086006401,
-0.0703925639,
0.0498466194,
0.0428700335,
0.0364520997,
-0.0162731651,
0.0095386151,
-0.059537027,
0.0062354286,
-0.0356122106,
-0.0386879817,
-0.0000432724,
0.0070062056,
0.0215251837,
0.0130443051,
-0.024517443,
-0.0228943098,
-0.0732858554,
0.0272769276,
-0.0283722673,
-0.0199907664,
-0.0180896055,
0.0195023995,
0.0182126891,
-0.0306268614,
-0.0533019453,
0.0185652338,
0.0172889978,
0.073804684,
-0.0139721455,
0.0221629869,
0.0161093343,
0.0034819529,
0.0048510619,
-0.0031629768,
-0.0569500923,
-0.0296849869,
-0.0670370087,
0.0132274237,
0.0343818627,
0.0016057719,
0.0425219052,
-0.0430689156,
-0.0216120705,
-0.0070920037,
0.0121162068,
0.0161090903,
-0.0236228984,
0.0126308687,
-0.011001843,
-0.0258740596,
0.02042602,
0.0654737949,
0.0165276434,
0.0614969656,
0.0028439364,
-0.0431338698,
-0.0435081385,
-0.0768400803,
-0.036145445,
0.0186073352,
-0.0101417098,
-0.0005389924,
-0.0835453421,
-0.0535994545,
0.0323876627,
0.0165620316,
-0.0015712563,
-0.021922892,
0.0172259733,
0.0581610203,
0.0059362594,
0.0006080073,
-0.0826833099,
0.0094745113,
-0.0043153288,
0.009308028,
-0.0013187362,
-7.286888011e-33,
-0.0091368165,
-0.0515715219,
0.0064688688,
-0.0152540328,
-0.0059951837,
0.0081928857,
-0.0090638166,
-0.0114198467,
-0.0474969521,
0.0469003543,
-0.0061892793,
0.0290240087,
-0.000568962,
0.0127989864,
-0.0354844108,
0.0068098209,
0.044665955,
-0.0111146308,
-0.0666942894,
0.0281944219,
0.0382655151,
-0.0063223587,
0.02591208,
-0.0763711929,
0.0512498356,
0.0069374023,
-0.0215011388,
0.0314067751,
-0.0782766715,
0.0477675907,
-0.0283732191,
0.061395999,
0.0284668859,
-0.0377479643,
0.0153043373,
-0.0163400453,
-0.0603458695,
-0.0344477482,
0.029832501,
-0.0292490404,
-0.0104314908,
0.0087567307,
0.0359434299,
-0.0030699996,
-0.0220973287,
-0.0070491531,
0.0281451382,
-0.0284460261,
-0.0030167152,
-0.0192824025,
-0.0369225442,
0.0106536662,
0.0345396139,
-0.0177597348,
-0.0516804382,
0.0092559056,
-0.0093329092,
0.0354339927,
-0.0714951456,
0.0372990333,
-0.0220543519,
0.0061795246,
0.0192974284,
-0.0567870066,
-0.0245064422,
0.0747417808,
-0.0308982804,
0.020244984,
-0.0493961312,
0.0180036258,
-0.0152854966,
0.052780807,
0.0234180074,
0.101323396,
0.0332730599,
-0.0229092985,
-0.1022513956,
0.038245108,
0.0096424129,
-0.0034832899,
0.0208191089,
-0.0344272293,
-0.0434893072,
-0.0163744893,
-0.05156653,
0.038820181,
-0.040153686,
-0.0114853838,
0.0112809315,
0.0292217471,
-0.0367130823,
-0.0189295691,
-0.0172042791,
-0.0236723255,
0.0054323934,
0.0113923829,
-0.0532738678,
-0.0144021399,
-0.0052695582,
0.0086555798,
-0.0692094564,
0.0189443212,
0.0118628601,
-0.0197399557,
0.0041845208,
0.0215836,
0.0408867188,
-0.0179413985,
-0.0505457222,
0.0380775109,
-0.024780089,
0.0242069326,
0.0401465297,
-0.0012229322,
0.0379373617,
0.0081255259,
-0.028005071,
0.0370293073,
0.0145089282,
0.0318517163,
-0.0530088395,
-0.0626634136,
0.0239336621,
0.0237253923,
-0.0392151587,
0.0254971907,
-0.0231184717,
0.0240004808,
-0.022308534,
-0.0835036114,
-0.0203920696,
-0.0086837169,
2.828e-7,
0.0402515829,
0.0768848211,
-0.0207060874,
0.046021428,
-0.0026989696,
0.0545473322,
0.011755323,
0.0186524056,
0.0218838491,
-0.0509874523,
-0.0224886108,
0.0366567448,
0.0207945425,
0.0363597795,
-0.0511395335,
-0.0136629455,
-0.0469716005,
-0.0243332591,
-0.0282409284,
-0.059526585,
0.0661816671,
0.0776476413,
0.0026826938,
-0.0154455118,
-0.0043918574,
-0.0044947839,
0.0928777978,
0.0192886572,
-0.0656816587,
0.0205044486,
0.0743721873,
0.0166027453,
-0.0062685548,
-0.0210140496,
-0.0450000949,
-0.0056882054,
-0.004701497,
0.0628651828,
-0.0005730854,
-0.0573306903,
0.0074010817,
-0.0091210613,
0.0099462727,
-0.0553551055,
0.0799067616,
-0.0278031528,
-0.0257209931,
-0.0261657536,
-0.038520433,
0.0297313742,
0.0374571532,
-0.0440063514,
-0.0347239599,
0.0147468187,
-0.0031804477,
0.0526118204,
-0.0218432471,
-0.0506056622,
-0.0401192605,
-0.0031226866,
-0.0398634076,
-0.0624331273,
0.040776331,
-0.0074645439,
-0.0071370704,
-0.0529686213,
0.0400078259,
2.708861987e-34,
0.0423578024,
0.0199324898,
0.0234462526,
-0.0299455095,
0.0311571695,
0.0380829796,
0.0504861698,
-0.0082832268,
0.0187126417,
-0.0472677127,
-0.0126634296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08398v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08398v2 | Are Large Language Models Temporally Grounded? | 2023-11-14T18:57:15 | 2023-11-16T09:41:28 | Yifu Qiu, Zheng Zhao, Yftah Ziser, Anna Korhonen, Edoardo M. Ponti, Shay B. Cohen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Are Large language models (LLMs) temporally grounded? Since LLMs cannot
perceive and interact with the environment, it is impossible to answer this
question directly. Instead, we provide LLMs with textual narratives and probe
them with respect to their common-sense knowledge of the structure and duration
of events, their ability to order events along a timeline, and self-consistency
within their temporal model (e.g., temporal relations such as after and before
are mutually exclusive for any pair of events). We evaluate state-of-the-art
LLMs (such as LLaMA 2 and GPT-4) on three tasks reflecting these abilities.
Generally, we find that LLMs lag significantly behind both human performance as
well as small-scale, specialised LMs. In-context learning, instruction tuning,
and chain-of-thought prompting reduce this gap only to a limited degree.
Crucially, LLMs struggle the most with self-consistency, displaying incoherent
behaviour in at least 27.23% of their predictions. Contrary to expectations, we
also find that scaling the model size does not guarantee positive gains in
performance. To explain these results, we study the sources from which LLMs may
gather temporal information: we find that sentence ordering in unlabelled
texts, available during pre-training, is only weakly correlated with event
ordering. Moreover, public instruction tuning mixtures contain few temporal
tasks. Hence, we conclude that current LLMs lack a consistent temporal model of
textual narratives. Code, datasets, and LLM outputs are available at
https://github.com/yfqiu-nlp/temporal-llms. | [
0.0196960531,
0.0539919771,
-0.0225271881,
0.033133287,
-0.0374158211,
0.0090087699,
0.0092278291,
-0.0131895514,
0.0145981526,
-0.0561176874,
-0.0090997349,
-0.0381640978,
0.0319480263,
0.0203716364,
0.0005590513,
-0.0447173789,
0.047794044,
-0.0167716667,
-0.0188269615,
0.0190618299,
-0.0241503585,
0.0020545325,
-0.0341838375,
0.0299197678,
0.0203999579,
-0.0388892256,
-0.0258359313,
-0.0336070694,
0.0319219902,
-0.0486179888,
-0.0179536603,
0.0450657532,
0.0342848003,
0.0333737284,
0.0000019314,
-0.0413646847,
0.0436510071,
-0.049069047,
-0.0078852708,
0.068279013,
-0.0214862358,
0.0029180725,
0.0009584186,
-0.0068663922,
-0.0542143993,
-0.0090675112,
-0.0215310026,
0.060549926,
0.0363648683,
0.0899282768,
-0.000543135,
-0.0078877024,
0.0390552767,
-0.0389888361,
0.0184262563,
-0.024209071,
-0.0040690787,
-0.0216465816,
0.014976616,
0.0420327447,
-0.0204550214,
0.0038845313,
0.0360464826,
0.0173730645,
0.0097292941,
0.0900685862,
-0.0147121586,
0.0174708329,
-0.0397362225,
0.0483830683,
0.0327905118,
-0.033645492,
0.0032382242,
-0.0001387972,
-0.002711839,
-0.0328846015,
-0.0520453751,
0.0410446934,
0.0200459678,
0.0472450107,
0.0368203931,
0.0189661067,
0.0305888671,
0.0121823112,
0.0019850156,
0.1008870676,
-0.0075177611,
-0.0288338438,
-0.0336999074,
0.0212682188,
0.0155772865,
-0.0779415816,
-0.0031125948,
0.0531021543,
0.0050283889,
0.0139893638,
-0.0353885181,
0.0573937334,
-0.013825411,
-0.0520108677,
0.0329660997,
0.0606064536,
-0.0226338916,
0.026134342,
-0.0326762684,
0.0744204298,
-0.0227364954,
0.0223173406,
-0.004427461,
0.0556686185,
-0.0415342636,
-0.0061243558,
0.018172361,
0.0148578761,
-0.0519143566,
0.0058129225,
-0.0422472209,
0.0507833995,
0.024744764,
-0.0279600136,
-0.0120229954,
0.0074784062,
-0.0237065442,
-0.0021348905,
-0.0719338134,
0.0024455253,
-0.0226210728,
0.0297043603,
-0.0014254936,
-0.0416653231,
-0.0225797202,
0.0018531814,
-0.0158399008,
-0.0169176608,
-0.0080524841,
0.0230629705,
-0.034226384,
-0.0314823799,
-0.0834281668,
-0.0144914696,
-0.0227818359,
-0.0600178987,
0.0039215568,
-0.0445722379,
0.0082935989,
0.0261989553,
-0.0017222911,
-0.0214738585,
0.0297466423,
0.0223030783,
-0.0367601886,
0.0587607808,
0.048718255,
0.0378992856,
0.0112272231,
0.0175847858,
0.0462762043,
0.0199399889,
0.0599238575,
0.0003151533,
0.0053747604,
0.0169346184,
-0.0143252611,
0.0197617095,
0.0002472522,
0.0004257573,
-0.0565180443,
-0.0086835846,
-0.0147316465,
0.0463574044,
0.0532620698,
0.0277212206,
-0.0077847382,
-0.0147220287,
0.1035812274,
0.0432102531,
-0.0288238488,
-0.0346988887,
0.0698013827,
-0.0309118815,
0.012777348,
0.0538011566,
-0.0744411796,
0.0094313147,
0.007162482,
0.0010205507,
0.0015235363,
0.0267607942,
-0.040165659,
-0.0314747877,
-0.0202170014,
-0.0153323095,
-0.0154937571,
0.0015150208,
0.016643459,
-0.0053566275,
-0.0533256419,
0.049861148,
0.0220101699,
-0.0210465435,
-0.0035606797,
-0.0213040188,
0.0309881903,
0.0796264559,
0.0229126289,
-0.0164071545,
-0.0640454963,
0.0090182219,
0.0557180233,
0.0460463315,
0.0189229399,
-0.008064948,
0.0028822052,
-0.0256221648,
-0.0017788741,
-0.043458432,
0.0069581671,
0.0104987733,
0.0448929444,
0.0203208122,
-0.0063495836,
-0.0159421936,
-0.0167022143,
0.0664239675,
-0.0766533241,
-0.0386062786,
-0.0400198549,
0.0074577043,
0.0132498611,
-0.0033432774,
0.0032174839,
-0.0014066107,
0.0620017014,
-0.039247632,
-0.0169945639,
0.0541463867,
-0.1151686832,
-0.0560374893,
0.0316337459,
0.0306050014,
-0.0200441908,
0.0340624675,
-0.0328454487,
-0.0407059789,
0.0348441973,
0.0208638161,
0.0380794406,
-0.0173256435,
0.0259388238,
0.0213312991,
0.0087076947,
-0.0381470509,
0.0635702014,
-0.0368931033,
-0.000122459,
-0.0015302505,
0.0393210053,
-0.0234869812,
-0.0300259013,
-0.0036580067,
0.0359069742,
0.0276565179,
-0.0273648165,
-0.0106443651,
0.008476208,
-0.0479955673,
-0.0327535085,
-0.1041816622,
0.0093726385,
-0.0080001354,
0.0148077365,
0.0436475575,
-0.0206665006,
-0.0231681187,
-0.0201592632,
-0.0268094782,
-0.0049145031,
0.013841765,
0.0240781847,
0.0600912832,
0.032399144,
-0.0081144981,
-0.0345791541,
0.0052946247,
-0.0530191697,
0.0503365248,
-0.0097476719,
-0.0380417667,
-0.0597356111,
0.0459333733,
-0.0328255557,
0.0231830701,
-0.0319623016,
-0.0198370107,
0.0392592251,
0.0083544003,
0.1051802561,
0.0902227908,
0.0096023194,
0.0730044991,
0.086447686,
-0.0161075126,
-0.0426940322,
0.0172292944,
-0.02795971,
0.0048851599,
-0.043994084,
-0.0063821892,
-0.0365965068,
0.1027681381,
0.011664697,
0.0174014159,
-0.0471902564,
0.0048940652,
-0.0290249083,
-0.0173863396,
-0.0191761758,
-0.0309961159,
-0.0601575635,
0.0450763777,
-0.0428505093,
-0.0573218614,
0.0448441803,
-0.0236717835,
-0.0009909687,
0.0157715604,
-0.0286019519,
-0.0564574525,
0.0910502002,
0.0200973153,
-0.0138479359,
-0.0087949,
-0.0379230678,
-0.0882192925,
-0.0035628204,
-0.00184094,
-0.0075460183,
0.0596668348,
-0.0418536775,
-0.0012086876,
0.0012020731,
-0.0424691029,
-0.0591366664,
-0.0691233724,
-0.0196415689,
-0.02649609,
-0.0545841418,
0.0057642986,
-0.0323388129,
-0.007291446,
0.0176997576,
0.0398953035,
-0.0299115423,
-0.0211070124,
-0.0180351194,
0.047682859,
0.0167206768,
-0.0133480448,
-0.0005220786,
-0.0472625829,
0.043719057,
0.0268619247,
0.0685390234,
-0.0159811359,
-0.0349138081,
-0.0068411641,
0.0101293372,
-0.0228424463,
-0.0369423293,
0.0345223472,
0.0561128482,
-0.053036917,
-0.0248933192,
0.1319866925,
0.0427082442,
-0.0159466248,
0.0295603946,
0.0012284491,
0.0173604023,
0.0421104766,
-0.0114075514,
-0.0530457012,
0.006169037,
0.0218960159,
0.0099110175,
-0.0124495653,
-0.0314517394,
-0.0208176598,
-0.1005861014,
0.0053220852,
0.0094643999,
-0.0296415798,
0.0081813447,
-0.0236065164,
-0.0163602326,
0.0215509105,
0.0282079037,
0.025354255,
-0.0189793762,
0.0078599285,
0.0143240951,
-0.0263820272,
-0.0417470746,
0.0570525676,
0.0102134496,
0.0731142238,
0.0288801584,
0.0362749808,
-0.0037397721,
-0.0246668197,
0.0500772931,
0.0174969584,
0.023760682,
-0.0085037462,
0.0221518856,
-0.0233964287,
-0.0038898792,
-0.0163208004,
0.033788573,
-0.0213269126,
-0.0317617469,
-0.0100782989,
0.0925488397,
-0.0291625503,
-0.0415566266,
0.0077198441,
0.0092330603,
-0.0225683358,
0.0668921024,
0.0397072658,
-0.0260574967,
-0.0522249304,
0.0039935517,
0.0021345688,
-0.0195557531,
-0.0601708367,
0.0016582005,
0.0321043767,
0.0276377574,
-0.0675715134,
-0.0791197345,
-0.0244149733,
0.0254091155,
0.0111882947,
0.0136687113,
0.0140771763,
-0.019846784,
-0.0374120101,
0.0563038029,
-0.0274350084,
-0.0060429028,
-0.0722538233,
-0.0039024642,
0.0210139155,
-0.0077218912,
-0.0085825697,
0.015280325,
-0.0794462636,
-0.0807950944,
0.0153969331,
-0.0018320009,
0.0197800957,
0.064423129,
0.0336690061,
-0.0210181698,
0.0435599051,
0.0174894538,
-0.0363433659,
0.0760767758,
-0.0129890693,
0.0199052934,
0.0039626081,
0.0329887755,
-0.0267205276,
0.0359993353,
-0.0070616174,
0.0321501791,
-0.0129098352,
-0.0091751702,
0.0133736534,
-0.0195258036,
0.0803106278,
-0.0048859064,
-0.0228651315,
-0.0559052341,
-0.0026065831,
-0.0376051627,
0.0050937175,
-0.0131315468,
-0.0073276693,
0.0326101184,
0.0361859798,
-0.0247603171,
-0.011776899,
-0.0020381138,
0.0508642085,
-0.0377378203,
-0.0175120905,
0.0012548232,
-0.0012847102,
0.0086181667,
0.0375760011,
-0.0253103357,
0.0173807964,
-0.0352841839,
0.0255382024,
-0.0062825861,
0.052943781,
0.00595725,
0.0221955162,
0.0010024979,
0.0097692991,
-0.1216491312,
0.0242531225,
0.0145120714,
-0.0036962205,
0.0721709281,
-0.0335009098,
0.0746542737,
-0.0270283371,
0.0113091338,
-0.0067926748,
0.0151913706,
0.0288376305,
-0.0109400237,
-0.0023548615,
0.0193544962,
-0.0319134705,
0.0536047071,
0.0872413218,
0.0363131724,
0.0790432245,
0.0596866719,
0.0034700625,
-0.009143319,
-0.0403733179,
-0.0121346181,
-0.0125970375,
-0.0259849932,
-0.0000240258,
-0.0661860779,
-0.0313687734,
0.0410232954,
-0.0025991935,
-0.0123851309,
-0.0707714409,
-0.0004006916,
0.0343965702,
0.0180578977,
-0.001015643,
-0.0263485573,
0.0183570515,
0.0239886772,
-0.0394919664,
-0.0511009507,
-6.586760637e-33,
-0.0571477637,
-0.0464193597,
0.0243179761,
0.014946254,
-0.0284258388,
0.0391636528,
-0.0490601212,
0.0076169297,
0.0015239849,
0.0002267156,
-0.0200013146,
0.0364400707,
0.0139089487,
-0.0167800151,
0.0371077694,
0.0056594936,
0.0285960585,
-0.0439578742,
-0.0294634923,
0.0248283856,
0.0601237416,
0.0305525381,
0.0490721427,
-0.0392509885,
0.0149527611,
-0.0147045171,
0.0106678046,
0.0202709772,
-0.0112672513,
0.0411586985,
-0.0324417315,
0.0274870005,
0.0465300642,
-0.0374291092,
-0.0172013175,
0.022288058,
-0.0625585988,
-0.0525095649,
0.0384954251,
-0.0128614688,
-0.0273926817,
-0.0335635729,
0.0205630325,
-0.0118686017,
-0.0388318896,
-0.0121250795,
0.0226775911,
0.0019900261,
-0.0063209897,
-0.0229922999,
-0.0625308529,
0.0093926899,
-0.0063698897,
-0.0268531628,
-0.0071328529,
0.0115065984,
0.0206124466,
0.0297932401,
-0.0549304448,
0.0087356614,
-0.0314312838,
0.0447715037,
0.0222756956,
0.008996225,
-0.0115891341,
0.0714064315,
0.0141156223,
0.0595258102,
-0.0625618696,
0.0169003271,
0.0349718481,
0.0005932194,
0.001635254,
-0.0155956512,
-0.0068315757,
0.0053013056,
-0.0840137824,
0.0063391086,
0.0331350863,
0.0137479082,
0.0292497873,
0.0020619729,
-0.0319915637,
-0.0026777091,
-0.0312853009,
-0.0026482928,
-0.0166615844,
0.0045937607,
0.0530119203,
0.0212761723,
0.0383796468,
-0.0149806617,
-0.0025858702,
-0.0087409485,
-0.0231774766,
0.0158281624,
-0.063613236,
0.0222299416,
0.009096073,
0.0419652276,
-0.0881124288,
-0.0053206645,
0.0085893525,
0.0161444657,
0.0326430425,
-0.00307274,
0.0328234024,
0.0139667606,
-0.0580111742,
-0.0140831228,
-0.0243495479,
0.0208915304,
0.0061418843,
-0.0239258092,
0.0604107194,
-0.0159265064,
-0.0267376173,
0.0473719016,
0.0095996233,
-0.0126518486,
-0.0131724747,
-0.0379902534,
-0.0135682989,
0.0223482028,
-0.005600078,
-0.0141020352,
-0.0297819898,
0.0596277453,
0.0225649998,
-0.0272131134,
-0.013890163,
0.0108479867,
2.65e-7,
0.0002654557,
0.0594491139,
0.0295797084,
0.0421533845,
0.0251532048,
-0.0096252514,
-0.0319389254,
0.0209719371,
-0.0080211265,
-0.0264615156,
-0.002804385,
0.0494879298,
0.0565913394,
0.0109086158,
-0.0422411487,
0.0009411813,
-0.0888631865,
0.0075424477,
-0.0781392083,
-0.0452148207,
0.0276240837,
0.0475326851,
0.0238862503,
0.0157021731,
-0.0223491713,
-0.0439037532,
0.0897567794,
-0.0213147085,
-0.0380379781,
-0.0052264975,
0.0099805156,
0.0170643255,
-0.0388070829,
-0.0101608234,
0.0145914024,
0.0192191936,
-0.0479679741,
0.0698350593,
0.0017603689,
-0.0293773599,
-0.0104266405,
0.0056934054,
-0.0292736758,
-0.0437320247,
0.0842156783,
-0.0556839183,
-0.0507776439,
0.0095024463,
0.0168738626,
-0.005035047,
0.0125373304,
0.020978028,
-0.0220232252,
0.0147508327,
-0.0106357392,
-0.0146245211,
-0.0093722371,
-0.0918437988,
-0.0489710718,
0.0424393788,
-0.0256019048,
-0.0395301841,
-0.0531608611,
0.0106896376,
0.0272497293,
-0.0349041075,
-0.0183911026,
2.666700082e-34,
-0.0011576044,
0.0016428924,
0.0204902515,
0.0175872482,
-0.0021378766,
-0.0053691245,
0.014422738,
-0.0058261356,
0.0260367822,
-0.0634553581,
-0.0122825867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08396v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08396v1 | Zero-shot audio captioning with audio-language model guidance and audio context keywords | 2023-11-14T18:55:48 | 2023-11-14T18:55:48 | Leonard Salewski, Stefan Fauth, A. Sophia Koepke, Zeynep Akata | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD | Zero-shot audio captioning aims at automatically generating descriptive
textual captions for audio content without prior training for this task.
Different from speech recognition which translates audio content that contains
spoken language into text, audio captioning is commonly concerned with ambient
sounds, or sounds produced by a human performing an action. Inspired by
zero-shot image captioning methods, we propose ZerAuCap, a novel framework for
summarising such general audio signals in a text caption without requiring
task-specific training. In particular, our framework exploits a pre-trained
large language model (LLM) for generating the text which is guided by a
pre-trained audio-language model to produce captions that describe the audio
content. Additionally, we use audio context keywords that prompt the language
model to generate text that is broadly relevant to sounds. Our proposed
framework achieves state-of-the-art results in zero-shot audio captioning on
the AudioCaps and Clotho datasets. Our code is available at
https://github.com/ExplainableML/ZerAuCap. | [
-0.0292573031,
0.0208685789,
0.0162466709,
0.0174581259,
0.0301651284,
0.0049740192,
0.0419797041,
-0.0284408554,
-0.0610149577,
-0.0759142712,
-0.0546531714,
0.0003560034,
0.0206024796,
0.0342012085,
0.0120978821,
-0.0811046362,
-0.0064728567,
-0.0660747141,
0.0024681839,
-0.0098591279,
0.0028337729,
0.0244720411,
-0.0331091098,
0.0372686535,
-0.0033411025,
0.0030357698,
-0.0051169083,
0.0178198814,
0.0152344657,
-0.016940264,
-0.0373931937,
0.049477201,
0.0675959289,
0.0153126782,
0.0000014549,
-0.0230314322,
-0.0012661323,
0.0194442961,
0.0374293327,
-0.0093559548,
0.0360849053,
-0.0306409374,
-0.0300270133,
0.0398670807,
0.0109228101,
-0.0334547125,
0.0736952573,
0.0398980007,
0.0499061495,
0.055366572,
-0.0223003328,
-0.0800428912,
-0.0129720522,
-0.046222683,
0.0296361484,
-0.0069580497,
-0.0255801212,
0.0483174473,
0.038496688,
0.0021984396,
-0.0001214598,
0.0396422744,
-0.0249103829,
-0.013259992,
0.0036542425,
0.057546109,
-0.066758059,
-0.0266509205,
0.0020880788,
0.1033177525,
0.0321681723,
0.0154662961,
0.0010919492,
0.0300479643,
-0.0181556176,
-0.0366261825,
-0.086537011,
0.0749644041,
0.0503235906,
0.0167059116,
-0.0291698724,
0.0486828834,
0.0354669876,
-0.0188055616,
-0.0001109805,
-0.0162038058,
0.0266833417,
0.0310559217,
-0.0340246744,
-0.060673885,
-0.0186689291,
-0.0779528618,
0.0040219044,
0.0316603258,
0.0156912953,
-0.0275248662,
-0.0338513218,
-0.0097774975,
0.0040866286,
0.0012970086,
0.0040281261,
0.0040755509,
-0.0408161134,
0.1005966663,
-0.0128779309,
0.0103137353,
0.020155618,
-0.0357447714,
-0.0495540276,
-0.0154177323,
-0.027745463,
-0.0090473145,
-0.0313396975,
0.0152298929,
-0.0342319459,
-0.0489379391,
-0.0276966579,
-0.0266691837,
-0.0527840368,
0.029382227,
-0.0356376693,
0.0022519391,
-0.0017317988,
-0.0112443212,
0.0363519751,
0.0240295622,
0.0075983047,
0.0617360733,
-0.0361515842,
0.0131799374,
-0.0296915285,
0.0398213752,
0.046664685,
0.0142471949,
0.0248780958,
0.0628487095,
0.004296795,
-0.0223128218,
0.0069761085,
-0.0257549677,
-0.0476032235,
-0.0324631967,
-0.0539125875,
-0.0622967966,
0.0115675107,
-0.0277592931,
-0.0167236682,
-0.0093976278,
0.0115839783,
0.0376298539,
0.0185826346,
0.0946400911,
-0.0279155225,
0.0436254553,
0.0241408646,
0.0185436476,
0.0178429913,
0.0598724671,
0.0665524453,
-0.0058803754,
0.0257891342,
-0.0270305891,
0.0274500791,
0.0659625828,
0.0066712294,
0.0116280587,
-0.0335902274,
-0.048201263,
0.0125731602,
0.0109321941,
0.0446525216,
0.0300445426,
-0.0063905544,
0.0338310227,
0.0633720905,
0.0540497676,
-0.0118158301,
0.0056830761,
0.0366752408,
0.010296532,
-0.0129170623,
-0.029332608,
0.000266447,
0.0472304225,
-0.0077590831,
0.047863625,
0.0569836907,
-0.01194565,
-0.0451047607,
-0.0101479692,
-0.0132269543,
-0.0460333489,
0.009183649,
0.0112893125,
0.0211262666,
0.0197456721,
-0.0459289327,
0.051563289,
-0.0101795774,
-0.0669717342,
0.0072265188,
-0.0243713185,
0.0210708883,
0.0411094017,
0.023159422,
-0.0560723729,
-0.0040719523,
-0.0496209301,
0.036990907,
0.0528446063,
0.0089006489,
-0.0188012682,
0.0319284126,
-0.027300721,
-0.0464201048,
-0.0090741878,
-0.0108449897,
0.0045117931,
-0.0439575426,
0.024951024,
0.0455137901,
0.0090334872,
-0.0337165184,
-0.0063950107,
0.0189667512,
-0.0627497509,
0.0209624544,
-0.0008452432,
0.0168801639,
0.0662183464,
-0.0560994968,
0.0179507863,
0.0216101166,
-0.0121786306,
-0.0021574481,
0.0578751564,
-0.0672108606,
-0.033926826,
0.0382278785,
-0.0318165831,
0.0259714909,
-0.0171931647,
-0.0078359153,
-0.0738700479,
0.0454729833,
-0.0081638768,
0.024488559,
-0.0479189903,
0.0029119309,
0.0089656524,
0.0108996807,
0.0126124145,
0.0019088759,
0.056435287,
-0.0339424908,
0.0195862018,
0.0073025851,
-0.0032128016,
-0.0473274924,
-0.0508563854,
0.0350839794,
0.009674184,
0.0284895394,
0.0206078589,
0.0299023185,
-0.040417444,
0.0087265465,
-0.1069494411,
0.0067976699,
-0.0160678048,
-0.0328438655,
-0.004426708,
-0.011748218,
0.0107260682,
-0.040145047,
-0.0349255949,
-0.0207988732,
0.0258291513,
-0.0124174003,
-0.0389357544,
0.0171195101,
-0.0583709329,
-0.0230683833,
0.014205399,
0.0337827802,
0.0256694537,
0.0198364947,
0.0013005509,
-0.000171091,
0.0327616408,
0.0030426017,
-0.0011762894,
-0.0018553206,
0.0168644171,
-0.0109691937,
0.0127859116,
0.0110382186,
0.0030501185,
-0.0032700014,
-0.0109638972,
0.0453480668,
0.0011275347,
-0.0070839967,
-0.0068906895,
0.0114113344,
-0.0390448123,
0.0003266756,
0.0195281263,
-0.0305895377,
0.0293671004,
0.0297430325,
0.0170142427,
-0.0247113016,
-0.0079290988,
-0.0213737991,
-0.0127721112,
-0.047154732,
-0.0290223844,
-0.0315665118,
0.0349704288,
-0.0158375092,
-0.0372321457,
-0.0012099458,
-0.0717516318,
-0.0630066246,
-0.0157717708,
-0.046205651,
-0.0434718803,
0.0736388117,
-0.033673726,
0.0426269062,
0.0151074762,
-0.027487427,
0.017109992,
-0.0312676542,
0.0138417697,
-0.0509709194,
0.0441735871,
-0.0332597829,
-0.00525758,
-0.0202977471,
0.0011734512,
-0.0016366682,
-0.0229977351,
-0.0466989316,
0.0278005283,
-0.0780540034,
-0.0069465865,
-0.0352409557,
0.0348612182,
0.0464761071,
0.058272887,
-0.0026037558,
0.0194464773,
-0.0138185611,
0.0373126157,
0.0312344786,
0.0107376166,
-0.0592361949,
-0.0137437806,
0.0518091172,
-0.0088446625,
0.0471324213,
0.0347696766,
-0.0494304523,
0.0133763188,
0.0256913025,
0.0142154936,
-0.0150870522,
0.0347363949,
0.0415529013,
-0.0168336127,
0.0314041153,
0.1434684545,
0.0091023892,
-0.0414551683,
-0.0038157646,
0.0343871079,
0.0136409495,
0.0386556797,
-0.0188093111,
-0.0695828795,
-0.0561546199,
0.030718226,
0.0289028995,
0.0772787258,
0.04261709,
-0.0351745486,
-0.0644955933,
0.0373829529,
0.0430990532,
-0.0868386477,
-0.0259778909,
-0.0269592926,
-0.0200755484,
-0.0193135235,
0.0164094046,
-0.010491835,
-0.0388076603,
-0.003923581,
0.0051825573,
-0.0061690076,
-0.0484693125,
0.030150665,
-0.0596431457,
0.0870982409,
0.069698602,
0.0404105298,
-0.0509269834,
0.0293652806,
-0.0230374765,
0.0014883109,
-0.0214627795,
0.0308391713,
0.0374325961,
-0.0115927542,
-0.0164238065,
0.053420119,
0.0537971407,
-0.0373563878,
-0.0335708447,
0.0419408157,
0.0069509395,
0.0241850317,
0.0348437168,
-0.0295349825,
0.0713538378,
0.0126366038,
0.0840207562,
0.0229310822,
-0.0117672822,
0.0350576304,
-0.0135636879,
-0.0303264037,
-0.060103748,
-0.0272686109,
-0.0196448732,
-0.001519304,
-0.029083157,
-0.0527509712,
-0.0028263121,
0.0609135702,
-0.0018171043,
0.0422138609,
0.0052690539,
-0.0111566745,
0.0174285825,
-0.06880299,
0.055513829,
-0.0220785607,
0.0364695378,
-0.0461942479,
-0.0465128794,
0.0756605491,
-0.0523652211,
-0.0129461875,
0.025589373,
-0.0352273434,
-0.0265985429,
-0.0356775112,
0.0160579551,
0.0196347591,
0.0373067968,
0.0219185948,
-0.0295600034,
0.04102448,
0.0243420806,
-0.0111509776,
0.0442880578,
0.0377824381,
-0.0027516168,
-0.02198877,
0.0033777822,
-0.0893970057,
0.060845837,
-0.0180255622,
0.0135086747,
-0.0131868683,
-0.0563450269,
-0.0242644269,
-0.0231824424,
0.0077052671,
-0.0543594062,
0.0416572876,
-0.0274880771,
-0.027639823,
-0.0139322877,
0.0190892126,
-0.0554311462,
0.0218941718,
0.0232924465,
0.0130359624,
-0.0004762511,
0.0137066124,
-0.0415142179,
-0.0165552329,
-0.010305265,
0.0346195512,
0.0319201872,
-0.0796948448,
-0.0054402109,
-0.0017100121,
0.0061090146,
0.00467816,
-0.0163887199,
0.0051621054,
0.0010267113,
0.0127828866,
-0.0235909186,
0.0016734679,
-0.0124473171,
0.0425451137,
-0.0093167601,
0.0183941051,
-0.0203704629,
0.029445691,
0.0774097741,
-0.0318612009,
0.0392142832,
0.0172698274,
0.0151446536,
-0.0201609973,
0.0578003153,
-0.0373229869,
-0.0454030074,
0.0197374728,
0.0136445202,
0.0039018695,
0.0459761061,
0.0640876293,
-0.0027069333,
-0.0002246812,
0.0007292622,
0.0317142867,
-0.0166208819,
0.0077596991,
-0.0110853277,
0.0135847805,
-0.0330565423,
0.0267337821,
-0.0073647164,
-0.0792607442,
0.0102374787,
-0.0155384177,
0.0072767972,
0.0152259916,
0.0505517125,
-0.0033778967,
0.0024953214,
0.0455631018,
0.0120855346,
-0.0479471125,
-0.0271977652,
0.0180864893,
-0.0087337568,
-4.568822179e-33,
-0.0580992699,
-0.0454534143,
-0.0088291736,
-0.0144154094,
-0.018510323,
0.0298833027,
-0.0510532595,
0.0293215141,
0.0252987109,
-0.0136325583,
0.0291418526,
-0.0266486108,
0.0098019764,
0.0465679243,
0.0061928346,
0.0054591573,
0.0587619655,
-0.0277688801,
-0.0061148778,
0.0355728008,
0.0225776602,
-0.0031763427,
0.0050437995,
-0.0560965277,
-0.0021330388,
-0.0333255567,
-0.0538174957,
-0.0117273657,
0.0636222214,
0.0422973223,
-0.0133844586,
0.0281471144,
-0.0286200922,
-0.0249467772,
-0.0327923335,
0.0297087412,
-0.0578980893,
0.0013175781,
0.0355100967,
0.0223136507,
0.0292214714,
-0.0228966214,
0.0148592712,
-0.020875087,
-0.0094929747,
-0.0329432972,
0.0561513044,
-0.0381192677,
-0.008036511,
-0.0529984646,
-0.0613435842,
0.0018201974,
-0.0468179695,
-0.0674608797,
0.0642406493,
0.0307730306,
-0.0003063037,
0.0286756903,
-0.0302357357,
0.0664280504,
0.0181492399,
0.0111645386,
0.0704401508,
0.0530846342,
-0.0185698234,
0.0634759963,
0.002555127,
-0.0605299957,
-0.0345015489,
0.0259524137,
0.0102219321,
0.0313278921,
0.0148495827,
0.0265076719,
0.0333869904,
0.0224094111,
-0.0239544902,
0.0326288156,
-0.0798366815,
-0.0171049666,
0.0246760231,
0.0459676273,
-0.0170629341,
0.02402444,
-0.0860405713,
0.0097108521,
-0.0487625562,
-0.0155774485,
0.0249929335,
0.0141206635,
-0.0069332058,
-0.0090739457,
0.0552218705,
-0.0279318057,
0.0350011401,
0.0049223597,
-0.0291360654,
0.0189213902,
-0.0167193096,
-0.0142409634,
0.0048491899,
-0.0206631422,
0.1075462922,
0.0081509724,
0.0432798974,
0.0037928019,
0.0237001516,
0.0847904235,
-0.0453725606,
-0.0102181286,
0.0188640617,
-0.0032879112,
-0.0097323712,
0.0409230068,
-0.0024002322,
0.0399401337,
-0.0435087793,
0.0340524986,
-0.0403243937,
0.0008525857,
-0.0097199772,
-0.0388510153,
-0.044008404,
0.0259473007,
-0.0406858847,
0.0550567694,
0.0018770254,
-0.0214839429,
0.0337765142,
-0.0263159499,
-0.0513705872,
0.0180403665,
2.198e-7,
-0.0177349057,
0.0001176824,
0.0027308133,
0.0262858011,
0.0239593405,
0.0435177945,
-0.0492155924,
0.0260097384,
-0.0049974448,
0.0092937266,
0.0528902225,
0.0164469462,
0.0531456992,
-0.022756936,
-0.1052836105,
-0.0098509043,
-0.0440281853,
0.0137402546,
-0.0385927223,
-0.0180678293,
0.0652100593,
0.1068137959,
0.0007356766,
-0.0250903573,
0.0160302389,
-0.09267544,
0.0517837442,
-0.0241146311,
-0.0102589633,
-0.0534301586,
-0.0059155216,
0.030950224,
-0.0466115735,
-0.0147407036,
-0.0354065821,
0.0100514889,
0.0677823871,
0.0510882437,
-0.0164320357,
-0.0295199696,
-0.0268588886,
0.0629326627,
-0.0081420783,
0.000802324,
0.0871361122,
-0.0368956402,
-0.0311196055,
-0.0343028307,
-0.0465670601,
0.0005032283,
0.0020208722,
-0.0393108428,
-0.0174325947,
-0.0123565365,
0.0351095572,
-0.0150036411,
-0.0370996483,
-0.0517423227,
-0.0275088977,
0.0040764399,
-0.0384613872,
-0.0042027729,
-0.0269273575,
-0.0488358103,
-0.0049025281,
-0.028512083,
0.0128072277,
1.500111248e-34,
0.0616805814,
-0.0531467609,
-0.0260162931,
-0.016096089,
0.0026814693,
0.009126924,
-0.0053507863,
-0.0156624354,
0.005567967,
-0.0423775539,
-0.0198725741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08391v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08391v1 | A Material Lens on Coloniality in NLP | 2023-11-14T18:52:09 | 2023-11-14T18:52:09 | William Held, Camille Harris, Michael Best, Diyi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Coloniality, the continuation of colonial harms beyond "official"
colonization, has pervasive effects across society and scientific fields.
Natural Language Processing (NLP) is no exception to this broad phenomenon. In
this work, we argue that coloniality is implicitly embedded in and amplified by
NLP data, algorithms, and software. We formalize this analysis using
Actor-Network Theory (ANT): an approach to understanding social phenomena
through the network of relationships between human stakeholders and technology.
We use our Actor-Network to guide a quantitative survey of the geography of
different phases of NLP research, providing evidence that inequality along
colonial boundaries increases as NLP builds on itself. Based on this, we argue
that combating coloniality in NLP requires not only changing current values but
also active work to remove the accumulation of colonial ideals in our
foundational data and algorithms. | [
0.0650214925,
0.0980448723,
-0.0520919114,
0.0297210701,
-0.0261131898,
-0.0203545578,
-0.0044320561,
-0.0034355544,
-0.0011918858,
-0.0658880845,
0.0497276857,
0.0024127983,
0.0299360566,
0.0198758841,
0.0280302316,
-0.0148606757,
-0.0121957194,
0.0703319535,
0.0063583036,
0.0091758566,
0.0230468605,
0.0315540358,
0.0149860289,
0.0798905566,
-0.0016564418,
0.0316930488,
0.0465233102,
-0.0542957634,
0.0070548696,
-0.03195462,
0.0194080845,
0.0409536287,
-0.0349454693,
0.021323815,
0.000001936,
-0.0433356874,
0.008011207,
0.0219698567,
0.0021850953,
0.0082401689,
0.0208601318,
-0.0195449442,
-0.0088518076,
0.0065763909,
-0.0874714181,
-0.0196004473,
0.051748842,
-0.004370301,
0.0290949401,
0.0219099112,
-0.0258885529,
-0.0175298098,
-0.0109683471,
0.0296766572,
-0.0292259958,
0.0321462601,
0.0250843782,
-0.0086154416,
0.0752390921,
-0.0049458961,
-0.024012709,
0.0347015224,
-0.000941128,
-0.0048176073,
0.0367219634,
0.0120749502,
0.0151667381,
-0.0212884601,
0.0390189923,
0.0451371707,
0.1148346737,
0.023929378,
0.0211328808,
0.0245105959,
-0.0039709276,
0.0487576649,
-0.008424609,
0.0645587817,
-0.0281742383,
0.014523319,
-0.0037786791,
0.0090092691,
0.0270477012,
0.0464384928,
-0.0023981803,
0.0911488757,
-0.0357175954,
-0.0290037002,
-0.0174846202,
0.0229948014,
0.0204795059,
-0.0117864236,
0.0505457185,
-0.0052387659,
-0.0086909756,
0.0219341107,
0.0172080025,
0.0010124681,
0.0236492604,
-0.0576847643,
0.0130055835,
-0.0133844381,
-0.007589398,
0.0066513722,
0.0245287921,
-0.0420828052,
-0.0323084705,
0.0323578902,
-0.0074033337,
0.0133419354,
-0.0535787381,
-0.0240862295,
0.0169729944,
-0.010521939,
-0.0641877502,
0.0124579649,
0.0284679681,
0.0028453241,
-0.0426594354,
0.0258851741,
-0.0287894756,
0.0271523744,
0.0402440317,
0.014981525,
-0.0333241895,
-0.0162109844,
-0.0635523796,
0.0213651657,
-0.0336304978,
-0.0672681555,
0.0233653896,
-0.035387814,
-0.0053668153,
-0.0358507894,
-0.0223940331,
0.0833959952,
0.0329026133,
-0.003420315,
-0.0838642344,
-0.0400712825,
0.026237553,
0.0060360976,
-0.0005174708,
-0.0504831336,
0.004797271,
0.0381520651,
-0.000351674,
-0.0211526193,
-0.0013586828,
0.0128604379,
-0.0738629252,
0.082415618,
-0.0343683362,
-0.007212881,
0.0403312594,
0.0394726992,
0.0318385102,
0.0461465158,
0.0372444689,
-0.033666186,
0.0636248961,
-0.010140473,
-0.0041366429,
0.0315792598,
-0.0442500859,
-0.039168451,
0.0125546353,
-0.0127001768,
0.0048899185,
-0.0208252538,
-0.0154912258,
0.0162159484,
-0.014538792,
-0.0088245897,
0.0415138192,
0.0462909974,
-0.03400103,
0.0322208926,
0.002376158,
0.0085858237,
-0.0460116751,
-0.0159428287,
-0.0476450026,
-0.029298855,
-0.0080532003,
-0.061218109,
-0.0220980886,
0.0204391666,
0.0082277693,
-0.0453275591,
-0.0096408632,
0.0424332172,
0.0615092926,
-0.0451580398,
0.0146189043,
-0.0050868494,
0.0074483971,
0.0053634364,
0.0294290371,
-0.0198682137,
0.0168344956,
-0.0056813895,
-0.0365950018,
0.0515584052,
0.0413896255,
-0.0271493979,
0.0582337081,
-0.0111521734,
-0.0480769984,
0.034897998,
-0.0026270214,
0.0034483487,
-0.0268897023,
-0.0114012333,
-0.0141449971,
0.0246913135,
0.0132184904,
0.0074181324,
0.0140416138,
0.037248712,
-0.0049296352,
0.0019896775,
-0.0324413069,
0.0314129554,
0.0037755549,
-0.0204181671,
-0.0338915549,
0.0273493901,
0.0067098732,
0.0605013222,
-0.0096192537,
0.0172874536,
0.023430625,
-0.0502965711,
-0.0326436274,
0.0129818534,
0.0136174401,
0.0419870578,
0.0293071344,
-0.1052583233,
-0.0024951198,
0.0489247181,
0.0307059698,
-0.0113211544,
0.097999759,
-0.0198813584,
0.0782865211,
0.0134144807,
-0.0289962888,
-0.028060589,
0.0227328837,
-0.0709826425,
0.0009943027,
-0.0130429193,
0.0005397112,
-0.0383229367,
0.0247924309,
0.0185619742,
0.0824919194,
-0.0367702059,
0.0378260352,
-0.0048388233,
0.0013404497,
0.0822762549,
-0.0226625651,
-0.0320975296,
-0.0041264333,
-0.0450767316,
-0.0432024896,
0.0003977186,
0.0078257695,
-0.000016085,
0.0079792887,
-0.0153625859,
0.0136977928,
0.0137362797,
-0.0234651305,
-0.0276535042,
0.0231291912,
0.0335975997,
0.0078181708,
-0.0143026728,
-0.0182620101,
-0.0348566324,
-0.0277376324,
0.0497075133,
-0.0261256397,
-0.0777821168,
-0.0242004525,
-0.0372428,
-0.0271806139,
-0.0058278576,
-0.0168543011,
-0.0023093717,
0.0396624282,
0.0237829313,
-0.0129905818,
0.0160975698,
-0.0175809935,
0.086675562,
0.0403356589,
-0.0137804039,
-0.0271356329,
-0.0047232374,
-0.0002587796,
0.0132020395,
-0.0068050679,
-0.0648910999,
0.0116310176,
0.0693204179,
0.0054970612,
0.0053515383,
-0.0098236091,
0.0011301105,
-0.0868681818,
-0.0211726129,
0.0056541669,
-0.0449079573,
-0.0391137153,
0.0257962048,
-0.0119305784,
0.012373534,
0.0236944426,
-0.0060398113,
-0.011664249,
-0.0081538558,
-0.0567834675,
-0.0050693979,
0.1219353005,
0.0293526147,
0.0247880518,
0.0579839945,
-0.0823012069,
-0.0233412124,
0.0029818779,
0.0414365083,
-0.0371148586,
0.0176705141,
-0.0290165916,
0.0279435869,
-0.00294872,
-0.0379482284,
-0.0158273503,
-0.0030993146,
-0.0424379073,
0.0182227027,
0.0617740862,
-0.0283605717,
-0.022655813,
0.0068115909,
0.0284948852,
0.0168919843,
0.0575326607,
-0.020943949,
-0.0060723717,
0.0238482188,
-0.0169275459,
-0.0185704008,
0.0557468757,
0.0665114224,
-0.0361426212,
0.0561313257,
-0.0272204019,
-0.0084133046,
0.0059832176,
0.0109419124,
0.0192723032,
-0.0438767448,
-0.0104451049,
-0.0142057939,
0.0418548957,
-0.0247017853,
0.0115033453,
0.046657756,
0.020198131,
-0.0298061203,
0.0453615822,
0.0369275808,
-0.0168199632,
0.0455496386,
0.02297391,
-0.1194428876,
0.0447768085,
-0.0109480806,
-0.0150769306,
-0.0672921762,
-0.0758566931,
-0.0261709094,
-0.1222629845,
-0.0016913626,
-0.0095692528,
-0.0304086581,
0.0211354513,
-0.055162631,
-0.0000803403,
-0.0217925068,
0.0116847819,
-0.0504448302,
0.0304541178,
0.0172396079,
0.019702157,
-0.0451856628,
-0.0027231888,
-0.0262371637,
-0.0518442951,
0.0427709296,
0.0151026361,
0.0366462246,
-0.0416420549,
0.0259815399,
0.0172757693,
0.0044024023,
0.0055052848,
-0.0152047807,
0.0164862406,
0.0162882339,
-0.0156723149,
0.0130373584,
-0.0208886545,
-0.0524224229,
0.0065634483,
0.0130254943,
0.0717436597,
-0.0031948334,
-0.0288627502,
-0.0507340916,
-0.0194841474,
-0.0046022097,
-0.0001412876,
0.0059852935,
-0.0163836908,
-0.0092586111,
-0.0843086317,
0.0078611616,
-0.0059815533,
-0.1192803457,
0.0288318712,
0.038529858,
-0.0145647544,
-0.0524098836,
-0.0765511021,
0.0262767859,
0.0324966349,
0.0289061498,
-0.0376687944,
0.0411587358,
-0.0328121446,
-0.0692354813,
0.0102958987,
-0.0138070257,
0.0086778989,
0.0256075189,
-0.0512527563,
-0.0253649689,
0.0353884958,
0.0073372405,
-0.0357567891,
-0.0012833078,
-0.0517922416,
0.0303236488,
0.0128218578,
0.0282112267,
-0.0098237516,
0.0006352388,
-0.0529911406,
-0.004330379,
0.0696901232,
-0.0404937454,
-0.0046998723,
0.0085311141,
-0.056206502,
-0.0039890232,
0.0055951714,
-0.0012231701,
0.0236901715,
0.0191109274,
0.0389155895,
-0.0158805884,
0.0122162383,
0.0356984846,
-0.0146773458,
0.071257107,
-0.0366514325,
0.0316543356,
-0.0138855232,
-0.0673898384,
0.0111511704,
-0.0175608937,
-0.0173131339,
-0.021947749,
-0.0254035797,
0.0211125501,
-0.034352906,
0.0266555343,
-0.0026488167,
0.0368690416,
-0.0046344739,
0.0633632988,
0.0260111429,
0.0145019777,
0.0407028161,
0.0237027872,
0.0018436963,
0.0413116291,
0.0164667647,
0.053118296,
0.0220641438,
-0.0030611078,
0.0180265885,
0.0041046878,
-0.0104839038,
0.0166653972,
-0.0403481163,
-0.0299511142,
0.0309436657,
0.0083315047,
0.0258004479,
-0.0888036415,
0.0202259123,
-0.0087834634,
0.0202234015,
0.0152610317,
-0.0419899411,
-0.0053766095,
-0.0234347619,
-0.0085230479,
0.0151236253,
-0.0192778297,
0.0348077416,
0.0531286933,
-0.0295009632,
0.0300197396,
-0.0002094304,
-0.0242963117,
-0.0032788168,
-0.0608729683,
0.0281357374,
-0.0077232807,
-0.0259698592,
0.0158289894,
-0.0742394254,
-0.0503746048,
-0.0733315349,
-0.0244729444,
0.0225765202,
-0.0025459966,
0.008288309,
0.0351743922,
0.0275438912,
-0.0264955554,
-0.035178002,
0.0368604735,
-0.0584225543,
-0.0096767638,
0.0398176424,
-6.361438941e-33,
0.0071536894,
-0.0805739313,
0.0157155767,
0.0098778252,
-0.0373649821,
-0.0158865061,
-0.0159153044,
0.0474512391,
-0.0489240438,
0.0297593214,
-0.0324096568,
-0.0099945571,
0.0111063272,
0.0010271985,
0.0620633028,
0.0117028737,
0.0057323743,
0.0436094515,
0.0139066819,
-0.0213039257,
-0.0094091268,
0.0162964892,
0.0561246611,
-0.0944353119,
0.0746934339,
0.0216703173,
-0.0240195319,
0.0146530475,
0.0292436983,
0.00333025,
0.0018124001,
0.0634746924,
0.0224058386,
-0.0724582151,
0.0054274765,
0.0643907189,
-0.0434738435,
-0.0118474159,
0.0235554185,
0.0265165772,
0.0176428929,
-0.0194337051,
0.0244858973,
-0.0134611139,
-0.0496334694,
0.0275494251,
0.0449444428,
-0.0127694178,
0.0024009778,
0.0069370316,
-0.0418322459,
0.0152981058,
-0.0548531823,
0.0906039402,
0.0080180475,
-0.0090042036,
0.0074702143,
-0.0281409174,
-0.0612366498,
0.026674252,
-0.0228339527,
0.0180085246,
0.0405039564,
0.0289334226,
-0.0081501873,
0.0536820479,
0.0173263401,
0.0630776957,
-0.0181870125,
0.0014823874,
0.0198187809,
0.0244379099,
-0.0113710416,
0.031237863,
0.008827542,
-0.0193971358,
-0.0022273234,
0.0033505149,
-0.0122212805,
-0.002858435,
-0.0314259343,
0.003206887,
-0.0241920464,
-0.0556090958,
-0.0010665989,
-0.0613724925,
-0.002895846,
-0.0354729407,
-0.0262990743,
-0.0218455456,
-0.0023925342,
0.049074918,
-0.0136232916,
-0.0795127973,
-0.030648211,
-0.0348956026,
0.0075859143,
-0.0075908075,
0.0095484713,
-0.0283551533,
-0.0683896542,
-0.0020918122,
-0.079154335,
0.0273063462,
0.0309915897,
0.0087783122,
-0.0153546054,
-0.0187260564,
-0.0341892429,
-0.0363821723,
-0.0192317497,
0.0192842185,
-0.0086685764,
-0.0272867456,
0.0325246044,
-0.0073538981,
0.0121483095,
0.0130805708,
0.0789994374,
0.0455670096,
0.0062555354,
0.0462638438,
-0.0423310027,
-0.0394514911,
-0.0440504588,
-0.0353237167,
-0.0605623536,
0.1103836969,
0.0656485781,
-0.0448607504,
-0.0340707339,
-0.0886007324,
2.639e-7,
0.0443291478,
0.0711855739,
0.0229924135,
-0.0409443006,
0.016883051,
0.0267941691,
0.04058972,
0.0498395748,
-0.0854907408,
-0.0690079778,
0.0071440125,
-0.0058978656,
-0.000020087,
0.0565813296,
-0.1082154065,
-0.0264262296,
-0.0658993274,
0.0051663066,
-0.0611670874,
0.0228754673,
0.033093255,
0.0139386635,
0.0336431153,
0.0071816188,
-0.0711360127,
-0.0558395199,
-0.023697326,
-0.0315323062,
0.027094258,
0.0115455044,
0.0009206607,
-0.0121420389,
0.0125105074,
0.0009441579,
-0.0068781339,
0.0137363113,
0.0020568287,
0.0108423727,
-0.0039082286,
0.0405391678,
-0.0204637442,
-0.0473193973,
0.0062912204,
-0.0278720669,
0.0370006971,
0.0308100227,
-0.0525761843,
0.0223186333,
0.0049909544,
-0.0168384518,
0.0296240319,
0.0055644549,
-0.011609124,
0.0214249808,
0.0007298666,
-0.0433046781,
0.0016188434,
-0.0918307304,
-0.0345578156,
0.0027610869,
0.0182874054,
-0.0002216724,
0.0169141069,
0.0434535965,
0.0057238513,
0.0581674725,
0.031561479,
2.036737736e-34,
-0.0160563923,
-0.0116859013,
0.0599940047,
0.0134597681,
0.0361119695,
0.0173482727,
0.0151262973,
0.0050311657,
0.0112632457,
-0.0169425663,
-0.0025684529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08390v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08390v2 | Predicting Text Preference Via Structured Comparative Reasoning | 2023-11-14T18:51:38 | 2024-07-01T16:57:56 | Jing Nathan Yan, Tianqi Liu, Justin T Chiu, Jiaming Shen, Zhen Qin, Yue Yu, Yao Zhao, Charu Lakshmanan, Yair Kurzion, Alexander M. Rush, Jialu Liu, Michael Bendersky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Comparative reasoning plays a crucial role in text preference prediction;
however, large language models (LLMs) often demonstrate inconsistencies in
their reasoning. While approaches like Chain-of-Thought improve accuracy in
many other settings, they struggle to consistently distinguish the similarities
and differences of complex texts. We introduce SC, a prompting approach that
predicts text preferences by generating structured intermediate comparisons. SC
begins by proposing aspects of comparison, followed by generating textual
comparisons under each aspect. We select consistent comparisons with a pairwise
consistency comparator that ensures each aspect's comparisons clearly
distinguish differences between texts, significantly reducing hallucination and
improving consistency. Our comprehensive evaluations across various NLP tasks,
including summarization, retrieval, and automatic rating, demonstrate that SC
equips LLMs to achieve state-of-the-art performance in text preference
prediction. | [
0.0427212715,
0.0470084473,
0.0139174089,
0.0004245908,
-0.051780723,
0.0271831788,
0.0043721227,
0.0036536511,
0.026598813,
-0.0565592423,
-0.0331535786,
-0.0228732992,
0.004391707,
-0.0145245725,
-0.0219167303,
-0.0818138719,
0.0166267753,
-0.0323723219,
0.0078009921,
-0.0192114357,
0.0383794568,
0.0473771095,
0.0246182047,
-0.0015138395,
0.0560955182,
-0.0304301474,
0.0216440763,
-0.0080383299,
0.0314307548,
-0.0662139505,
0.0202679541,
0.061319381,
0.0183236394,
-0.0157062765,
0.0000023753,
-0.0475186929,
-0.0352784581,
-0.0314037167,
0.0261072852,
0.0133433146,
0.0511352345,
0.0197489727,
0.0625921711,
-0.0042474903,
-0.0315002799,
0.0067218556,
-0.0171860531,
0.0602238178,
0.0288587436,
0.0284384117,
-0.0075606988,
-0.0379318409,
-0.0254034698,
-0.0225047525,
-0.0151695553,
-0.0022971984,
0.0016494474,
0.0018938371,
0.0219573565,
0.075689353,
0.0357376635,
0.0123199252,
0.0076049622,
0.0118705258,
0.0497475527,
0.0426715575,
-0.0238848981,
0.0173579678,
0.0045785112,
0.0551564395,
0.022616474,
-0.0613009483,
0.0109129492,
-0.0322697833,
-0.0219936166,
0.0013696873,
-0.041090358,
0.0114188222,
-0.043635916,
0.0500928797,
0.0484708212,
0.0652586147,
0.0163031388,
0.039579615,
-0.0239162836,
0.088197425,
0.0083660586,
-0.0379261672,
0.0241214354,
0.0337991826,
-0.0192060433,
-0.074113369,
0.0385375693,
-0.0145627651,
-0.0673015639,
-0.0160255805,
-0.0009469806,
0.0098605854,
0.0119387079,
-0.0728841051,
0.0222734455,
0.0133700408,
-0.0075968206,
0.0376601592,
-0.0282082781,
0.0387832187,
0.0209460985,
0.0180654321,
-0.0692184716,
0.0494117029,
-0.0424047075,
-0.0014319376,
0.0167414472,
0.0483087972,
-0.0305112284,
-0.0055198157,
-0.0306545608,
-0.0070229257,
-0.0290073287,
0.0199997965,
0.0193541534,
0.0427120365,
-0.0041395058,
0.0059301145,
-0.0788525492,
0.0157682374,
-0.0590907224,
0.0109592918,
0.0016938706,
0.0340053551,
0.0243809186,
-0.0079957545,
-0.0159284547,
-0.0453607291,
0.0139357261,
0.0114531815,
-0.0170338955,
-0.0048665432,
-0.0185328014,
-0.0094409334,
-0.0109996758,
-0.0335050039,
0.0001002378,
-0.0767348036,
0.0166228656,
0.0295351148,
0.0039520739,
-0.026807161,
0.0267847534,
0.0427068174,
-0.0477252454,
0.0549516827,
0.0079029966,
-0.0342752971,
-0.0005596961,
0.0099583827,
-0.0195936225,
0.0248963479,
-0.0301597901,
0.0421743542,
0.0278575886,
0.0282113533,
-0.0407330915,
-0.0157256182,
-0.0454752669,
-0.0114155794,
-0.0482197665,
0.0422241986,
-0.0286376663,
0.0266942829,
-0.0109143304,
0.0599616468,
-0.0046018469,
-0.0100024026,
0.0588639453,
0.0264603291,
0.0286470614,
0.0195583422,
0.0062370142,
0.0120045571,
0.0045183734,
0.0728732571,
-0.0161545333,
0.0532575585,
-0.0459163785,
-0.0066278744,
0.0659355521,
0.0234797914,
-0.0269627366,
-0.0708085448,
-0.0253201518,
0.028181877,
0.0232386254,
0.005578435,
0.031069912,
0.0046548122,
-0.0467318036,
-0.0150696775,
0.0571079217,
-0.0307978448,
0.0062227598,
-0.0065441411,
0.0285660718,
0.143937543,
0.0498202927,
-0.0386197306,
0.0125402492,
0.0042873109,
0.0149067165,
0.0046899463,
0.0283797923,
-0.017260829,
-0.0336245634,
-0.0643627271,
-0.0161819123,
-0.0261177551,
-0.0015362995,
0.0183277261,
-0.012863175,
0.0037036825,
0.0153073911,
0.0103158336,
-0.0461786836,
0.0276553538,
0.0005319086,
-0.0271085203,
0.0184598826,
0.0069826501,
0.0097843269,
0.0129205696,
0.0229495466,
0.0138703082,
-0.0208781287,
-0.0465287827,
-0.0484877042,
0.0122218793,
-0.0704758316,
-0.0462325662,
-0.0007614263,
-0.0087828673,
-0.0092705386,
-0.0157444589,
-0.0252506938,
-0.0046234289,
-0.0306966621,
0.012176225,
0.0451932698,
-0.0147515275,
0.0210632328,
0.0147017371,
-0.0401791856,
-0.0487094,
0.0946394131,
0.0073068668,
0.0432403982,
0.0432555526,
-0.0306207146,
-0.0248666499,
0.0155955013,
-0.0333313309,
0.0208232421,
0.0469134226,
-0.0012184164,
0.0189533792,
0.021788314,
-0.0403272994,
-0.0161495414,
-0.0652866885,
-0.0164509043,
0.0077946531,
0.0013119739,
0.0228968654,
-0.019423835,
0.0237385277,
0.0105088679,
-0.0360743962,
-0.0215662662,
-0.0082211485,
0.0301798545,
0.0280928388,
0.0019173558,
0.0412931331,
-0.0533901677,
-0.0252251085,
-0.0307565946,
0.0662604496,
0.0095273275,
0.0122354003,
-0.0505149774,
0.0563606098,
-0.062101461,
-0.0071022501,
-0.0067030559,
0.014694415,
-0.000097038,
-0.0379466638,
0.0208971072,
0.0418715999,
0.0548908412,
-0.0193462707,
0.1117061153,
-0.0132484008,
-0.0924080834,
-0.022002209,
-0.0117359469,
0.0252388697,
0.0214067381,
-0.044865787,
-0.0091458987,
0.0416438952,
0.0086964816,
0.0068138069,
-0.0678777024,
0.0237834677,
-0.0299483109,
0.0272334516,
-0.0513813719,
-0.0165737979,
0.0197645612,
0.0725122541,
-0.011846385,
-0.0109005999,
0.1196962819,
-0.0199011061,
0.0471841395,
-0.0837858617,
0.0083526997,
-0.0474854484,
0.0317788459,
0.0015342893,
0.0185775515,
-0.024786396,
0.0201717597,
-0.05568932,
-0.0271393638,
0.0496572517,
-0.0415241495,
0.0733269975,
-0.0467127785,
0.0000122676,
0.0162043571,
-0.0654299781,
-0.035782285,
-0.0367071331,
-0.041422762,
-0.0298003964,
0.035106428,
0.0155842118,
-0.0080964118,
-0.006968928,
-0.0057168189,
0.0195883363,
-0.0229158327,
-0.048338443,
0.0213386212,
0.0284924135,
0.045742508,
-0.0440031625,
-0.0061974479,
-0.0358285755,
0.0373959541,
0.060670469,
0.0093764532,
0.0189721528,
-0.0383094437,
-0.0034939698,
0.02827131,
-0.0309076011,
-0.0294142794,
-0.0306653287,
0.0034707226,
-0.0434942693,
0.0075957752,
0.1426790506,
0.0709045678,
-0.0842168257,
-0.0124001587,
-0.0306866951,
0.0460233316,
0.0115620876,
0.0426643714,
-0.0567640737,
-0.0091348942,
0.0160565227,
0.0188374817,
-0.0109943608,
-0.0091774631,
0.0109439213,
-0.0886352882,
-0.0205500219,
-0.0003077763,
0.0028926153,
0.0475433543,
-0.0267083142,
0.0156161329,
0.0030538039,
-0.0337864757,
0.0152128888,
-0.0214587916,
0.0258468557,
-0.0053666905,
-0.0203487594,
0.0004114706,
0.0531047359,
-0.0261886623,
-0.0051540127,
0.0579230823,
0.0314261764,
0.0056484342,
-0.0429427549,
0.0240885206,
-0.0086267916,
-0.0016268381,
-0.0409928001,
0.0364429764,
0.0099648638,
0.0317944884,
-0.0668667927,
0.0126958592,
0.0331999473,
-0.0303557608,
0.0170469191,
0.0191814043,
0.0155404219,
-0.0478911065,
-0.0085236719,
0.0671190619,
-0.0366296507,
0.0709739476,
-0.0142263267,
-0.0512359329,
-0.0189209692,
-0.0741576478,
-0.0073045348,
-0.0237683076,
-0.0396444164,
0.0162297636,
0.0251773857,
0.0404175855,
-0.0974284783,
-0.0267479345,
-0.0038903377,
-0.0211503077,
0.0158534013,
-0.0072420295,
-0.0177376103,
-0.0157064795,
-0.0159543175,
0.0208931118,
0.0240058899,
0.0049345642,
-0.0198703371,
0.0237008967,
0.0585491545,
-0.0402074084,
-0.0308006331,
-0.0221340787,
-0.0443515033,
-0.0296627153,
-0.0420346223,
0.0392856561,
0.010137164,
0.0366225019,
-0.0055151954,
-0.035637293,
-0.0005296399,
0.0479879491,
-0.0013304469,
-0.0021827365,
0.0217728913,
0.0425335765,
0.0298555996,
0.0197113808,
-0.0356968343,
0.0196253806,
-0.015267997,
0.0270938743,
0.0042122505,
-0.0398994908,
0.0419986956,
-0.0026632405,
0.0029322889,
0.0007751457,
0.0093609076,
-0.0449118651,
0.0175891221,
0.0010919141,
-0.0568633005,
-0.0148110176,
0.0293312334,
0.0202485789,
0.0087605277,
-0.0502048098,
0.0439580306,
0.003123482,
0.0430037417,
-0.0368534103,
0.0041342988,
0.0239207,
0.0105820866,
-0.0045089652,
-0.0089154057,
-0.0490821935,
-0.0137859806,
0.0140744662,
0.0707158521,
-0.0526268743,
0.065901354,
0.0438826233,
-0.020451406,
-0.025159806,
0.0414536633,
-0.0749083981,
-0.0319454446,
-0.0386711173,
-0.0602603853,
0.0022776441,
-0.0502808914,
0.0461963117,
-0.0141501902,
-0.0106379203,
0.0101958979,
0.0186840296,
-0.0050700372,
-0.0124351447,
-0.0294358935,
0.0338060819,
0.0027482146,
0.0262562744,
0.0681685135,
-0.0368270166,
-0.0197375603,
0.0482077152,
-0.0481885858,
-0.0305870231,
-0.028410228,
-0.0596745424,
0.0648320317,
0.005006101,
-0.0285248589,
-0.0577034242,
-0.0122827459,
0.039229881,
-0.0150006739,
-0.0000516137,
0.0087430077,
0.0278611369,
0.0498825535,
-0.0158404596,
0.016338449,
-0.0274689142,
-0.0233750399,
0.017728176,
-0.0440569259,
-0.0736252591,
-7.121670811e-33,
-0.0011134379,
-0.0165042393,
-0.0082513597,
-0.0192986876,
-0.0010113808,
-0.0134586506,
-0.0061378991,
-0.0226498768,
0.0192985293,
0.0168507583,
-0.025026666,
-0.0071831536,
-0.000575036,
0.0175674073,
0.053807158,
-0.0289144982,
0.0421527363,
0.0189735852,
-0.0337281488,
0.0068156216,
0.0387454107,
0.0234755296,
0.0249313712,
-0.0748275891,
0.0227539707,
0.0055366419,
-0.014504292,
-0.0202133376,
-0.027553115,
0.0402618982,
0.0051999083,
-0.000325564,
0.0222148933,
-0.0234355032,
0.0076031396,
0.0198584329,
-0.0457409993,
-0.0309114009,
0.0283419359,
-0.0403701961,
-0.0126549238,
0.0034561614,
-0.0127093317,
-0.00694978,
0.0031096675,
-0.0271513481,
0.0698431656,
-0.0530063137,
0.0014925061,
-0.0263775904,
-0.013757742,
0.0117310798,
-0.0150975529,
0.0221850555,
0.0132117849,
0.1004133523,
-0.0107186418,
0.1117583439,
-0.0738561526,
0.0684204623,
-0.0195456464,
0.0290730055,
0.0255881269,
-0.0397537798,
-0.0095298607,
0.0783888325,
0.0092106322,
-0.0180316027,
-0.0191248786,
-0.0082962168,
-0.0284752417,
0.0078121615,
0.0317790397,
0.0314296372,
0.0507368036,
0.0214567892,
-0.0186863728,
0.032164719,
-0.0119022243,
-0.0173089523,
0.0537831001,
0.0054947804,
-0.046903003,
-0.0529779382,
-0.0434709378,
-0.0301328488,
-0.0755412579,
-0.0278936345,
0.0272084977,
-0.0022885203,
-0.034787681,
-0.0221855808,
-0.0226629619,
-0.0263112709,
-0.0693531036,
0.0148068145,
-0.0400423817,
0.0101948995,
0.0015378291,
0.020173911,
-0.0248562023,
0.0154689746,
-0.0033389623,
0.0056757117,
0.0049929093,
0.0027912911,
0.047158774,
-0.040108677,
-0.0648765638,
-0.0033279543,
-0.0251695793,
-0.025761459,
-0.0228452478,
-0.0028871521,
0.0221089367,
0.0240213294,
-0.00326346,
0.085644953,
0.01603329,
-0.0279720351,
-0.0589133576,
-0.0258483496,
0.0101761911,
0.0261249766,
0.0346012153,
0.0215954352,
-0.0168309212,
0.014944273,
0.0198869985,
-0.0437197052,
-0.0206944253,
0.0272027012,
3.011e-7,
0.0205460023,
0.0879757032,
-0.0117488075,
0.0141148139,
-0.029562166,
0.0371486172,
0.0166379083,
0.0008652316,
0.0409350917,
-0.0013202836,
0.0134781264,
0.0280870683,
0.050993681,
0.0671175122,
-0.0708087757,
-0.0427400023,
-0.0910498425,
-0.0807222798,
-0.0415639095,
-0.0828703344,
0.0994290486,
0.034950126,
0.0511506945,
0.0009866355,
0.0085314838,
-0.0127138058,
0.0588206463,
-0.0473227315,
0.0234236065,
0.0014124253,
-0.0063006603,
-0.0328696482,
-0.0172000099,
0.0128639406,
-0.0120080132,
-0.0187717844,
0.040441107,
0.0411032103,
0.0348966084,
-0.0412408486,
0.0053719799,
0.0220135432,
-0.0073752706,
-0.0638978183,
0.0845371187,
-0.0225204285,
0.0231702831,
-0.0012410297,
-0.0526439808,
-0.0115506984,
0.0267565586,
-0.0001975037,
-0.0217658784,
0.0478495359,
-0.0256413557,
0.0247429218,
-0.0207834058,
-0.0824528709,
-0.0329430886,
0.0382054672,
-0.0214972887,
-0.0111178271,
-0.0363424234,
0.0548350029,
-0.0255702939,
-0.042440623,
0.0064943614,
2.781498584e-34,
0.0608151928,
0.0018623833,
0.011276505,
-0.0163673181,
0.0270580351,
0.0242292434,
0.0065371725,
0.0001273517,
0.0307533313,
-0.0768926591,
0.0071363952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08389v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08389v1 | TSST: A Benchmark and Evaluation Models for Text Speech-Style Transfer | 2023-11-14T18:50:51 | 2023-11-14T18:50:51 | Huashan Sun, Yixiao Wu, Yinghao Li, Jiawei Li, Yizhe Yang, Yang Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Text style is highly abstract, as it encompasses various aspects of a
speaker's characteristics, habits, logical thinking, and the content they
express. However, previous text-style transfer tasks have primarily focused on
data-driven approaches, lacking in-depth analysis and research from the
perspectives of linguistics and cognitive science. In this paper, we introduce
a novel task called Text Speech-Style Transfer (TSST). The main objective is to
further explore topics related to human cognition, such as personality and
emotion, based on the capabilities of existing LLMs. Considering the objective
of our task and the distinctive characteristics of oral speech in real-life
scenarios, we trained multi-dimension (i.e. filler words, vividness,
interactivity, emotionality) evaluation models for the TSST and validated their
correlation with human assessments. We thoroughly analyze the performance of
several large language models (LLMs) and identify areas where further
improvement is needed. Moreover, driven by our evaluation models, we have
released a new corpus that improves the capabilities of LLMs in generating text
with speech-style characteristics. In summary, we present the TSST task, a new
benchmark for style transfer and emphasizing human-oriented evaluation,
exploring and advancing the performance of current LLMs. | [
0.0012196944,
0.0721413419,
-0.0241731163,
0.0034978106,
-0.0460487865,
-0.0183003321,
-0.0045700832,
-0.0273843016,
-0.0365946293,
-0.0275025982,
-0.0891469494,
-0.0478453934,
0.0122905532,
0.0170903448,
0.0286311228,
-0.1039973423,
0.0101411976,
-0.0231784619,
0.0272773486,
0.0098894313,
0.0423993655,
0.040450111,
0.0114130443,
0.00329726,
-0.0209792648,
-0.0051440587,
-0.0026862335,
0.0354681052,
0.054960385,
0.0123986853,
0.0253239777,
0.0329352766,
-0.0004847189,
-0.028488908,
0.0000018699,
-0.0261628833,
0.0004956835,
-0.025952559,
0.0356739089,
0.0306960288,
0.1053124592,
0.026920639,
-0.0145123247,
0.0231774319,
-0.0262636822,
-0.0281546563,
0.0204816908,
0.0714620799,
0.0863151774,
0.0976619497,
-0.0351581611,
-0.0412951447,
0.0275173523,
-0.0111277374,
0.0062570623,
-0.0149720097,
0.0356658064,
-0.02526577,
0.005041095,
-0.0211372413,
0.0059509883,
0.0158563945,
-0.0207971614,
0.0009271178,
0.0135243274,
-0.0462331548,
-0.0730277151,
0.0497191772,
-0.01466271,
0.0735656768,
0.0257369243,
-0.0099414261,
0.024633253,
0.0167542975,
-0.0023671247,
0.007678078,
-0.0345259644,
-0.0160567369,
0.0148294428,
0.0017098082,
-0.006327833,
0.0459086075,
-0.0014526044,
0.0019265157,
0.0011620831,
0.0258511994,
0.0145361349,
-0.036974363,
0.0330869593,
-0.0071496456,
0.0137034394,
-0.0256958008,
0.0529521368,
-0.0263664704,
0.0303734764,
0.0153826512,
-0.0812032819,
-0.0298398584,
-0.0358354747,
-0.0339148827,
0.0367395692,
-0.0028345059,
-0.0116963359,
0.0028955122,
-0.0106478082,
0.0280242749,
-0.004283404,
0.0174968895,
-0.0348450132,
-0.0060885386,
-0.0811462328,
0.0160819478,
-0.0254434124,
-0.0111591062,
0.0284722671,
-0.0214798283,
-0.0348421,
-0.0220074095,
-0.0195090249,
-0.0353711247,
0.0000315396,
-0.0060922028,
-0.021837933,
-0.0208370332,
-0.0187502597,
0.0261448026,
-0.0029379157,
0.034405563,
0.0325321034,
-0.0053324383,
0.0105200149,
0.0528643169,
0.0472864099,
-0.0431070365,
0.0357969813,
0.0021300651,
-0.0307553466,
-0.001599058,
-0.0746702105,
-0.0002129503,
-0.0151127577,
-0.0400224887,
-0.0181792863,
-0.0574099869,
0.0215765685,
-0.0464608818,
-0.0039359941,
-0.0561592616,
-0.0122129172,
0.018077543,
-0.0209398065,
0.0337465927,
0.0178832449,
0.0364018381,
0.0380951241,
-0.0008238961,
-0.0017704461,
0.0048984829,
0.0548728816,
0.0680558905,
0.015014532,
-0.0497946329,
0.0248009358,
0.0578873828,
0.0030162032,
0.0203730464,
-0.0380263925,
-0.0524832197,
0.0074577676,
0.0626441762,
0.0965666249,
0.0740135312,
-0.0189728625,
-0.0026484537,
0.1152590886,
0.0055027134,
0.0297896098,
0.0342414118,
0.0490107164,
0.052749496,
0.0397589169,
0.011402973,
0.0000721203,
-0.0138930799,
-0.0282272734,
0.0201589596,
0.0185729284,
0.0312030781,
-0.0245709959,
-0.0055167973,
0.0013053237,
-0.0114674224,
-0.0022251813,
-0.0387657955,
-0.0128481286,
0.0285679512,
-0.0351941548,
0.0145867737,
0.0222521722,
-0.0561099388,
0.0307940654,
-0.0163203273,
-0.0007661489,
0.1046347767,
0.0210821461,
-0.0004753818,
0.0114061385,
-0.0059842491,
-0.0177348498,
0.0264149811,
0.0191484001,
-0.0149327628,
0.0457670689,
-0.0740507171,
0.0529506989,
-0.0054299193,
-0.0172682479,
0.0290190447,
-0.0354763009,
0.0487914421,
0.0067510656,
-0.0180448461,
-0.0000260959,
0.0113164848,
-0.0558779761,
-0.0468335003,
0.0401151255,
-0.0055178585,
0.0036193661,
0.0015244089,
-0.0280587804,
-0.0024266928,
-0.0121064289,
-0.033551529,
-0.000435026,
0.0593546517,
-0.0564077646,
-0.0093965027,
-0.0277757645,
-0.0272124708,
0.0378869846,
0.0403175578,
-0.004910137,
-0.0614297017,
0.0164385457,
-0.0245127883,
0.0082254056,
-0.0248496737,
0.0477896631,
0.0165496785,
0.0474617705,
0.0016921026,
0.0116553931,
0.0359135494,
-0.0547506064,
0.0162008796,
0.0153127667,
-0.0306236576,
-0.0492184162,
-0.0090267826,
-0.0199839622,
0.005789116,
0.0466876924,
-0.0335802734,
-0.0265238229,
-0.049110502,
-0.0493273251,
-0.0595972016,
0.0154913813,
0.0114806443,
0.0214881971,
0.0244479831,
-0.0022996678,
-0.0325147249,
0.029508438,
-0.0947281569,
-0.0326448232,
-0.0161307398,
-0.0152995456,
0.0203656591,
-0.0261631217,
0.0048525468,
-0.0762092322,
0.0114564449,
-0.0042907996,
0.0253004022,
-0.0463211201,
0.0130623225,
-0.0273983441,
0.0166960005,
-0.0049037114,
0.003529781,
0.0267869756,
-0.0599546619,
-0.0243053474,
-0.0113151325,
0.0504800342,
0.0801567882,
0.0641691685,
-0.0472633168,
-0.0034482626,
-0.0431653969,
-0.0238872841,
0.0069130417,
-0.000990243,
0.0565542392,
-0.0238533951,
-0.0530918725,
0.044165995,
0.0237945933,
0.0476789139,
0.0346396416,
-0.0572017245,
0.0165766776,
0.0523801856,
-0.0474223346,
0.0555543974,
-0.013644536,
-0.0529318526,
0.0127580557,
-0.0035332288,
0.0067381742,
0.0324705429,
-0.0736003965,
-0.0166454185,
-0.0171469189,
-0.0227596629,
-0.0321472138,
0.0245983899,
-0.0289650708,
0.0041708639,
0.02041745,
-0.0063335183,
-0.0216290113,
-0.0339907147,
0.042921558,
-0.0525871478,
0.0041042347,
-0.0345550142,
-0.0448036902,
0.0473231077,
-0.0256894697,
-0.0130243609,
-0.0413767472,
-0.0254088026,
-0.0032203135,
0.0492135994,
-0.0360660926,
-0.0102126915,
-0.0114152022,
0.0018195102,
0.0237038527,
-0.0207392406,
-0.005372121,
-0.0033948363,
0.0598436557,
0.0391071364,
0.019508535,
-0.0282027964,
-0.020373363,
0.0052213161,
0.0045678718,
-0.0019866512,
0.0456469804,
-0.0341697894,
0.0155301243,
0.021842625,
0.0015559982,
-0.0296685211,
-0.0077020149,
0.0707688332,
-0.0179081112,
-0.009288189,
0.0944283828,
0.0188356899,
-0.0049694423,
-0.0164501257,
-0.0064416099,
0.0478205904,
-0.0274425056,
0.048926916,
-0.0269544777,
-0.0397339091,
0.0094695296,
0.0387939177,
-0.03543064,
-0.0126559669,
-0.0247123968,
-0.0909321308,
0.0350810513,
0.0272524562,
-0.0488419794,
0.0219677743,
-0.0285962187,
0.0153563889,
-0.0291131716,
-0.0038092143,
-0.0383702293,
-0.0143313389,
-0.0189948697,
0.0330492929,
-0.0617034622,
-0.0448479056,
0.0555790849,
-0.0069876835,
0.0770934895,
0.0465221107,
0.058230482,
-0.0213077944,
-0.0755122826,
-0.043295946,
0.0045316932,
0.0072691604,
0.022771664,
0.053897161,
-0.015826866,
0.0017646315,
-0.0633556694,
0.0537971221,
0.0082429517,
0.0175160933,
0.0329404622,
0.0228765495,
0.0037457149,
-0.0447166264,
-0.0048456416,
0.0412747823,
0.0209916309,
0.0622053146,
0.0223170463,
-0.0823048726,
-0.0140031874,
0.0083816005,
0.0207009222,
-0.0607357956,
-0.0699830353,
0.0115393447,
-0.0316151045,
0.0020266098,
-0.1267371327,
-0.006192836,
-0.022253532,
0.0467833616,
0.0052386369,
-0.0400477797,
-0.0101780705,
-0.014206918,
-0.0195408389,
-0.002432426,
-0.0012081028,
0.0327031016,
-0.0527935624,
-0.0153677948,
0.0291012656,
-0.0793479756,
0.009066375,
0.0242631137,
-0.0419392027,
-0.0397269465,
0.0245129503,
0.0236881487,
0.0121321892,
0.0377305895,
-0.005801992,
-0.0808512568,
0.0475100391,
0.0283478703,
0.0118364468,
0.0028362577,
0.0644320995,
0.0184402019,
-0.0072315321,
0.0157311,
0.0144134006,
0.0484441668,
-0.0017747107,
-0.0051769591,
0.0038657505,
-0.0761260837,
-0.012804281,
0.0280834734,
0.0057430477,
0.0222651251,
-0.0008281494,
-0.0013284112,
-0.0146855591,
-0.0173284002,
0.0090646604,
-0.0633381307,
-0.0546896085,
0.0492883809,
0.0638116524,
-0.0294073038,
-0.0480519682,
0.0134911491,
-0.0070451009,
-0.0318627842,
-0.0054405658,
0.0257099811,
0.0492106006,
-0.0017586616,
0.0361360312,
-0.0301112179,
-0.0036129358,
0.009958853,
0.0583717935,
-0.0227583926,
0.0375140086,
0.0078970334,
-0.0267630164,
0.0232267957,
0.0168588497,
-0.0513004996,
0.0277608596,
-0.0453458987,
-0.0300399084,
-0.0011050669,
-0.0366521366,
0.0997693837,
-0.0266461559,
0.0419582576,
-0.0243618675,
0.0309390724,
-0.020845715,
0.0173649229,
-0.0276311096,
-0.0041075936,
-0.0020553537,
0.0015197803,
0.0339567028,
-0.0179184228,
0.0238035135,
-0.0304664783,
-0.009493662,
-0.0286079105,
0.0127263283,
0.0283269957,
-0.0175741669,
0.0187003668,
-0.0329689495,
-0.0560416803,
-0.0450756736,
0.0980161205,
-0.0484973192,
0.006677534,
-0.0338710584,
0.0322129689,
0.0203416646,
-0.047143396,
0.0171241723,
-0.0237023812,
-0.0124905854,
-0.0155133959,
0.0094254678,
0.0044452082,
-5.689890774e-33,
-0.0198577214,
0.0249187741,
-0.0156517066,
0.0415584259,
-0.0729655176,
-0.0250749215,
-0.0228011627,
-0.0046613892,
0.0040823496,
0.0353655256,
-0.0456261523,
-0.0283839479,
0.0206245538,
0.0330911912,
-0.0161338989,
0.0386273973,
0.0385410786,
0.001704699,
-0.0412190184,
0.0262126867,
0.0349734835,
0.0199606903,
0.061601188,
-0.0746954381,
-0.0373936743,
-0.0007304201,
-0.0301867742,
-0.0180870071,
0.0616229624,
0.0111525441,
0.0116448579,
0.0331629999,
0.0006248152,
-0.0508579537,
-0.0283307564,
0.0401207618,
-0.0190720819,
-0.0454543494,
0.029878078,
0.001602929,
-0.0023606434,
-0.0215858258,
0.0344831161,
-0.0056132027,
0.0065937615,
-0.0222071912,
0.0345552489,
-0.0446173884,
0.0071748635,
-0.0694517419,
-0.0724095181,
0.0417919829,
-0.0088139353,
-0.0350236595,
0.028099658,
0.0391164869,
-0.0400197245,
-0.007761436,
-0.0645003244,
0.0193581954,
-0.0276553892,
0.0072441553,
0.0208016913,
0.0291760024,
-0.0258164871,
0.0664735734,
0.0231249519,
0.0529894419,
-0.0189620219,
0.0347332545,
0.039379552,
0.0750379637,
0.0233797207,
0.0837915018,
-0.0260877777,
-0.0216945745,
0.0441346727,
0.0350227356,
0.0712632239,
-0.0296873245,
0.0236362871,
0.023514377,
-0.0341169387,
0.0003050309,
-0.0397195965,
-0.005415712,
-0.0044935956,
-0.0179967415,
0.0171547383,
-0.025854826,
0.0018902338,
-0.0244504139,
0.0124038663,
0.0019511112,
0.0117055094,
-0.0181781407,
-0.0901381448,
0.0463371314,
-0.0440707356,
-0.0064992853,
-0.0243667848,
-0.0323263034,
0.0586283244,
0.067951642,
0.0482483618,
-0.0089402925,
-0.0034382949,
0.0563185625,
-0.0545255169,
-0.0228152089,
0.0098487772,
0.0544360317,
-0.0180196129,
-0.0239614584,
-0.0079989955,
0.0104186451,
-0.0231161024,
0.041978389,
-0.0130800316,
0.0028606455,
0.0163431689,
-0.0423911996,
0.0440257639,
0.0199041348,
-0.0535587855,
0.0230731145,
-0.0228665043,
-0.0864083916,
0.0116745559,
-0.0028165719,
0.0047498653,
0.008488724,
2.632e-7,
-0.0384010896,
0.046416454,
0.0131099522,
-0.0127139175,
0.0257746279,
0.0443855822,
0.007419867,
0.0196847618,
0.0453952067,
0.0107616903,
0.0312417056,
-0.0049523418,
0.1099020094,
-0.0060847383,
-0.1180877611,
-0.0217552837,
-0.0611848794,
0.0187268499,
-0.014425884,
-0.0219869502,
0.0880031511,
0.0197686255,
0.0124084456,
-0.0380161032,
0.0323117636,
0.0063720993,
0.040229816,
-0.0191584323,
-0.0143167153,
0.0353670605,
0.012445976,
-0.0422847345,
-0.0322473198,
0.0411279239,
-0.0131187821,
-0.0052307365,
0.0263598021,
0.0995159075,
0.0232166685,
-0.0249687992,
0.0077610025,
0.0266958904,
-0.0341787152,
-0.0152684618,
0.0451004766,
-0.0060513588,
-0.0511948019,
-0.0482251383,
-0.0668422058,
-0.0081556719,
0.0078941602,
-0.0255968329,
-0.0183231104,
0.0297260303,
0.016928263,
0.023219211,
-0.0439070277,
-0.0578419939,
-0.0061313161,
0.0125146313,
-0.0475610271,
-0.0261097457,
-0.0407141298,
0.0112751387,
0.0092765177,
-0.0287620295,
0.0365624465,
1.819063618e-34,
-0.0018811092,
-0.0005856144,
0.0273451433,
-0.0097674225,
0.0260632541,
0.0210695937,
0.0392682515,
0.0135275209,
0.0288436711,
-0.0833057761,
0.0177569706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08385v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08385v3 | ChOiRe: Characterizing and Predicting Human Opinions with Chain of Opinion Reasoning | 2023-11-14T18:48:27 | 2024-02-28T04:30:53 | Xuan Long Do, Kenji Kawaguchi, Min-Yen Kan, Nancy F. Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aligning language models (LMs) with human opinion is challenging yet vital to
enhance their grasp of human values, preferences, and beliefs. We present
ChOiRe, a four-step framework to predict human opinion which differentially
models the user explicit personae (i.e. demographic or ideological attributes)
that are manually declared, and implicit personae inferred from user historical
opinions. ChOiRe consists of (i) an LM analyzing the user explicit personae to
filter out irrelevant attributes; (ii) the LM ranking the implicit persona
opinions into a preferential list; (iii) Chain-of-Opinion (CoO) reasoning,
where the LM sequentially analyzes the explicit personae and the most relevant
implicit personae to perform opinion prediction; (iv) and where ChOiRe executes
Step (iii) CoO multiple times with increasingly larger lists of implicit
personae to overcome insufficient personae information to infer a final result.
ChOiRe achieves new state-of-the-art effectiveness with limited inference
calls, improving previous techniques significantly by 3.22%. We also show that
ChOiRe Steps (i) and (ii) can significantly better fine-tune opinion-aligned
models, by up to 18.44%. | [
0.0312181525,
0.1079652309,
0.0089086657,
0.0099014426,
-0.0161054973,
0.010007971,
-0.0063743545,
-0.0598459616,
0.0151272435,
-0.0486164801,
-0.0348232016,
-0.0206993558,
0.0011659841,
0.0221772715,
0.0047675385,
-0.0473403782,
0.0331539325,
0.0410732292,
0.0602499992,
-0.0280464981,
0.0530670434,
0.0711329281,
-0.0085093407,
0.019748671,
0.0039330833,
-0.024319116,
-0.0127313742,
-0.020660203,
0.0735844597,
0.0001545571,
0.0327481963,
0.0618324354,
-0.0140846772,
-0.0185591411,
0.0000022911,
-0.017506633,
-0.0039656004,
-0.0203113016,
0.0334663168,
-0.0193504579,
0.0464390069,
0.0570802055,
0.0071063889,
0.0300987456,
-0.0571635105,
0.0345627666,
0.0137655474,
0.0736907348,
0.092409648,
0.0174867045,
-0.0128938863,
-0.040778596,
-0.0436257832,
-0.004156176,
-0.0157639291,
-0.0226902552,
0.0266918205,
-0.0331261307,
-0.0603786297,
0.0471304841,
0.0445562564,
-0.005101522,
-0.02905434,
0.0065477765,
-0.000073663,
0.0083832061,
0.0116660064,
-0.0422368571,
0.0241461936,
0.0760340542,
0.0465249978,
-0.0367883295,
0.0061128722,
0.0001976012,
0.0075962762,
0.0150495786,
0.0029412517,
-0.0004855271,
-0.025459135,
0.0370620824,
0.0227517411,
0.0427944921,
0.0291036125,
0.0659974366,
-0.0229260065,
0.0835175812,
-0.0269371793,
-0.0231734738,
0.0291105155,
0.0268678777,
0.0015914089,
-0.0435483195,
0.0163361579,
-0.0207730234,
0.0004619751,
0.0297824182,
-0.0052054683,
0.0246171225,
-0.0030281367,
-0.0783592835,
0.0179398265,
0.04697809,
0.0026012256,
0.0301101599,
0.0011530844,
0.0159842502,
-0.0009761263,
-0.0100680245,
0.0155207803,
0.007316615,
-0.0284564588,
-0.0030327302,
0.0339577906,
0.0320832059,
0.0180501696,
0.0189926028,
-0.0547702387,
-0.0059317867,
-0.0649100691,
0.0060069202,
0.0096324664,
0.0385487303,
0.0088414056,
-0.0247467477,
-0.1025506034,
0.0634230748,
-0.0518272556,
0.0399465226,
-0.0105121369,
-0.0015540929,
0.050643865,
0.0073007313,
-0.0136250798,
-0.0035558832,
0.0155843003,
0.0354492813,
0.0333040617,
0.0189269111,
-0.0001565742,
-0.0150738275,
-0.0123259742,
-0.066798687,
-0.0142618977,
-0.0625789613,
0.0590534881,
0.0245508514,
-0.0053520538,
-0.0459507033,
0.032830283,
0.0644218251,
-0.0532920472,
0.0715163127,
0.0224383604,
-0.0023036618,
0.0028116491,
0.0196407773,
0.0234193821,
0.0495066717,
0.0035739541,
0.0627853572,
0.0212302357,
0.0069305389,
-0.0080922898,
0.0152845336,
-0.0103676775,
-0.0125143519,
-0.026547784,
0.0338086821,
-0.0602712668,
-0.0001125024,
0.0266969353,
0.0807862431,
0.0150217079,
-0.0361875892,
0.0778459683,
0.0395269766,
-0.0269204024,
0.0299626682,
0.0474713147,
0.0234852675,
0.0069851028,
-0.0206746235,
-0.0529370606,
0.0294350274,
-0.0020902227,
-0.0448709056,
0.0391882136,
0.0523612164,
-0.0283161364,
-0.0531856604,
-0.02181294,
-0.0167726167,
0.0510304794,
0.0255392026,
0.0040433737,
-0.0365683921,
-0.0313115381,
0.0159430411,
0.0656196773,
-0.0740887746,
-0.0228575449,
-0.0336915329,
0.0280082021,
0.0876412094,
-0.0081321402,
0.0219386257,
-0.0065528457,
-0.0277567562,
-0.0235087145,
0.0209133681,
0.0373637713,
-0.0304881372,
-0.037040107,
-0.0233719256,
-0.0174519233,
0.0359427445,
0.0019129619,
0.0379519612,
0.0332416147,
0.0114694163,
0.0122608189,
0.0045863199,
0.0013927344,
0.0015871301,
-0.013440947,
0.0137677016,
0.0159760751,
0.0473801307,
0.0480075255,
0.0466976017,
0.0418390073,
-0.0083632339,
0.0190392211,
0.0086417692,
-0.0646945983,
0.0051877624,
-0.0478163064,
-0.0110031767,
0.0041869641,
-0.0322493948,
-0.0454642139,
0.0228763744,
-0.02152922,
0.0094665112,
0.0216314811,
-0.0189314857,
-0.0240012482,
-0.0389062241,
-0.0095855296,
-0.0135638053,
-0.015050848,
-0.0228072442,
0.0753847063,
-0.0236488003,
-0.0163016524,
-0.0402806588,
-0.0352975614,
0.0111371856,
0.0061877966,
-0.038754385,
-0.0472203903,
0.0419326238,
0.0192421339,
0.0417117216,
-0.0159217846,
-0.0075039766,
-0.0273032524,
-0.0967575833,
-0.0398517959,
0.002161128,
-0.0006214631,
0.0088665914,
-0.0027609409,
0.0187114291,
0.0333065242,
-0.0472724065,
0.0101036262,
-0.0276964232,
0.0113874599,
0.0524970703,
-0.0132297892,
0.0187497102,
-0.0210886747,
0.0069926577,
-0.0457272567,
0.0223040432,
-0.0082299048,
-0.027730694,
-0.009937888,
-0.0111118704,
-0.1112262309,
0.0071962806,
-0.0141363833,
-0.0306871925,
-0.0106426431,
-0.0063890326,
0.0371788405,
0.0257489644,
0.0570044406,
0.0341915451,
0.0414666049,
0.0625791773,
-0.05031747,
-0.0133122215,
-0.0656320527,
0.0288873054,
-0.012113546,
-0.0367760547,
0.0063835066,
0.072668463,
0.0297316704,
-0.0071699717,
-0.0725561753,
0.0621894859,
0.0029158406,
-0.002570428,
-0.005497348,
-0.0254752077,
-0.0030521196,
0.0290733762,
-0.0045317495,
-0.0358960517,
0.1043773964,
0.0028089276,
0.052837573,
-0.0204189941,
-0.0270511601,
-0.0307749026,
0.0026944811,
0.0013645345,
0.0234196372,
-0.0004192285,
0.0385988355,
-0.0501728244,
-0.027851034,
-0.0130462255,
-0.0543651097,
0.0371166989,
-0.012945028,
0.0231036339,
0.0435073301,
-0.063191995,
-0.0270618703,
-0.0501375161,
-0.0521003753,
-0.0195444357,
0.0184194632,
-0.0219086874,
-0.0154294204,
-0.0248737726,
0.0056104753,
-0.0687851012,
-0.0097709773,
-0.0122382324,
0.01882031,
-0.0089398157,
0.0535323657,
-0.0222673379,
0.023265589,
-0.0171127897,
0.0085539194,
0.034488041,
-0.0165313017,
-0.0090433555,
-0.0402434915,
-0.0277754609,
0.0259439368,
0.012113316,
-0.0166402925,
-0.0062994654,
0.0203863699,
-0.0067516328,
0.0497094281,
0.1227139905,
0.0298054982,
-0.0796395987,
0.000300987,
0.0064891381,
0.0008945075,
0.0326203629,
0.0202918388,
-0.0480937846,
-0.0192914046,
-0.0137725193,
0.0252708048,
-0.0368942209,
-0.0382397138,
-0.0001327145,
-0.1109512225,
-0.0179916583,
-0.0208980571,
0.0376115702,
-0.0043719159,
-0.0422576033,
0.0322626568,
-0.0205204859,
-0.0015911526,
-0.0309331287,
0.0324488431,
0.0330600291,
-0.0243317746,
-0.068396911,
-0.0145875523,
0.0820222944,
-0.0118823582,
0.0177613441,
0.0568020046,
0.0722860545,
0.0288269483,
-0.0492972583,
0.029752221,
-0.0209305882,
0.0055805109,
-0.0106012318,
0.0574567504,
-0.0541168004,
0.0001389742,
-0.0598160997,
0.0355609246,
0.0067109396,
0.0112134749,
-0.0412781462,
0.0371674746,
-0.0160239041,
-0.0337629095,
-0.0103659071,
0.0637263581,
0.0349080972,
0.0990895182,
-0.0141175212,
-0.0954904482,
0.0003856291,
-0.0512435548,
-0.0085333167,
-0.0143681346,
-0.0751099288,
-0.0205634758,
0.0051730843,
-0.0290089529,
-0.0412869602,
-0.0580501184,
-0.0286545381,
0.0114407018,
-0.0051965117,
0.0070833489,
0.0442907996,
0.0142715303,
-0.0083249407,
0.0393459499,
0.0219286941,
0.0338829495,
-0.0097456286,
-0.0224147402,
0.0281979367,
-0.0246828329,
-0.0340787955,
0.0147841908,
-0.0226424504,
-0.0332182273,
0.0017285799,
0.0452573001,
0.0127161248,
0.0446893312,
0.0004939557,
-0.0354647338,
0.0281280819,
0.024230279,
-0.0248616133,
-0.0036996296,
0.0036127397,
0.1153913066,
0.0172719005,
0.0540187769,
-0.0227611586,
0.047157634,
0.0070217503,
-0.0507006608,
-0.0595972575,
-0.0693978965,
0.012906489,
-0.0234291237,
0.0411931574,
0.008700788,
-0.018069759,
-0.0084396899,
-0.0463892035,
-0.0308328196,
-0.0752012804,
-0.0174430795,
-0.0272340588,
0.0280890539,
0.0042512678,
-0.0368278809,
-0.0575722866,
-0.0185755081,
0.013586021,
-0.0295969769,
0.021355914,
0.0158287622,
0.0550379492,
0.00913144,
-0.0176518615,
-0.0045833327,
0.0036348139,
-0.0148562621,
0.0173753966,
-0.0216510911,
0.0581011809,
-0.0042133196,
0.0184279401,
-0.0092442948,
0.0061276527,
-0.0317439549,
-0.0175689477,
-0.0564048961,
-0.027302159,
-0.0536165349,
-0.0064474791,
0.0307109971,
-0.0025871757,
-0.0202036276,
-0.0067745168,
0.0629087463,
-0.0192107074,
-0.0273906458,
0.0129756443,
0.010882006,
-0.0233728364,
-0.0018183347,
0.0216138475,
-0.0066813249,
-0.0183039419,
0.0005110896,
-0.0590092875,
-0.0392989703,
-0.0133086713,
-0.0032384454,
-0.0036669963,
-0.0007361289,
0.0043196315,
-0.0801876634,
-0.0598764047,
0.0122746704,
-0.005981727,
0.0024928723,
-0.0025525829,
0.0308828019,
0.060561236,
-0.0067916252,
0.0656698644,
-0.0773516744,
-0.0076541672,
-0.0363058858,
-0.0237363148,
-0.0425746627,
-6.945139478e-33,
-0.026384566,
-0.0315620936,
-0.005442699,
-0.0001387114,
-0.0159444232,
-0.0117914639,
-0.0319543295,
0.0351408571,
-0.018243283,
0.0428172424,
0.0132561224,
0.0125310058,
-0.0045284526,
0.0034809629,
0.0168316681,
-0.0065998686,
0.0238266941,
-0.0025634249,
-0.0214390643,
0.0175440926,
0.0472717397,
0.0043402291,
0.0213474389,
-0.1187310964,
0.0434455872,
0.0224075727,
-0.0334967412,
-0.0011926458,
0.0036762094,
0.0270650946,
-0.0014521622,
0.0529008098,
0.0291675385,
-0.0208348539,
0.0097947028,
0.0721694753,
-0.0808930919,
-0.004652909,
0.0015736258,
-0.0094907815,
-0.0193935595,
-0.01347965,
-0.0063000284,
-0.0020384747,
-0.0466680527,
-0.0340744369,
0.063322939,
0.0083888099,
0.049246937,
-0.0399922058,
-0.0008835297,
0.0101448828,
-0.0317168422,
0.0119681032,
-0.0056115105,
0.0553090312,
-0.0142580578,
0.0465750694,
-0.0653799772,
0.0541369878,
-0.0567411445,
-0.0086578019,
0.0227999948,
-0.0258171279,
-0.0136723565,
0.1006608829,
0.0132870059,
-0.0060949991,
-0.0898964703,
0.0104430271,
-0.0002785967,
0.0192803666,
0.0111176716,
0.0252532624,
0.0044744555,
-0.0189941246,
-0.0252004024,
0.0332770757,
0.0496197827,
-0.0140187675,
0.0574007705,
-0.0073404689,
-0.0693976358,
-0.0387273394,
-0.0038308282,
-0.0710212961,
-0.0541249104,
-0.0306895208,
-0.0007114942,
-0.0046431534,
-0.047609102,
-0.0062388405,
0.0011820751,
-0.0456146076,
-0.0368701629,
0.0370411724,
-0.0608431213,
-0.0137014529,
0.0208795629,
0.0000705921,
-0.0484836325,
0.0359974951,
-0.0273766611,
0.0200045779,
0.0098866131,
0.0004984309,
0.02853138,
-0.0060052681,
-0.0643093735,
-0.0427905209,
-0.0087067829,
-0.0263455138,
-0.0372006744,
0.0436339825,
0.0423299596,
0.0343852118,
-0.016297305,
0.0412188135,
-0.0009942192,
0.0316763297,
0.0013236762,
-0.0260395389,
0.0150691932,
-0.0031225276,
-0.0295584965,
-0.0389033593,
-0.0172606353,
-0.0376676396,
0.0046618213,
-0.0515230857,
-0.0221187174,
0.0137230735,
2.936e-7,
0.0454254746,
0.0584705472,
-0.0276045743,
0.0029638326,
-0.0039112135,
0.0692239404,
0.045506984,
-0.0130197182,
0.0015723103,
-0.0503199808,
0.0005682444,
0.0306174122,
0.0457359031,
0.027016174,
-0.0838633031,
0.0132314442,
-0.0130443769,
-0.0064630662,
-0.0378962718,
0.0201466959,
0.0579577833,
0.0790467635,
0.0518950373,
-0.0170790032,
-0.0242850631,
0.0602127574,
0.043954093,
-0.0147447381,
-0.0330711417,
0.0106693832,
0.0057404833,
-0.0278101154,
-0.0029700485,
0.0115029579,
-0.0196720138,
0.0113102514,
0.0096138529,
0.0734721273,
-0.0059311399,
-0.0634754971,
-0.0150511703,
0.0295768902,
0.0109896567,
-0.0238584112,
0.0672222003,
-0.0467145294,
-0.0366092771,
-0.0296292733,
-0.0356270708,
0.0431506261,
-0.0040946458,
0.0188168064,
-0.0213911552,
0.0121571757,
0.0045502074,
-0.0339663476,
-0.026653491,
-0.0820756629,
-0.0178268868,
0.0010814365,
-0.0421644934,
-0.0369064994,
0.0005452201,
0.0602648705,
0.0372014306,
-0.026919527,
0.030050952,
2.837669536e-34,
0.0260918122,
-0.0165948737,
0.0124358954,
-0.0287109092,
0.0627897382,
0.0166155174,
0.0011878262,
0.0045246128,
0.0681457669,
-0.0594426841,
-0.0105747562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08380v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08380v2 | Direct Preference Optimization for Neural Machine Translation with Minimum Bayes Risk Decoding | 2023-11-14T18:43:51 | 2024-04-12T14:07:38 | Guangyu Yang, Jinghong Chen, Weizhe Lin, Bill Byrne | cs.CL | cs.CL | Minimum Bayes Risk (MBR) decoding can significantly improve translation
performance of Multilingual Large Language Models (MLLMs). However, MBR
decoding is computationally expensive. We show how the recently developed
Reinforcement Learning technique, Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), can
fine-tune MLLMs to get the gains of MBR without any additional computation in
inference. Our method uses only a small monolingual fine-tuning set and yields
significantly improved performance on multiple NMT test sets compared to MLLMs
without DPO. | [
0.0054530473,
0.0721733645,
0.0128028858,
0.0241712239,
-0.0070303474,
0.0354851782,
-0.0094398493,
0.0102273952,
-0.0359872505,
0.0069921799,
-0.0307602081,
-0.0249717385,
-0.0077492245,
-0.0192397255,
0.0180738084,
-0.0319820195,
0.0123791825,
-0.0418311507,
0.0015275094,
-0.0225483235,
-0.0245577376,
0.0206988882,
-0.0057308134,
0.0332102254,
0.0467172265,
-0.0073356689,
0.0041250153,
0.0189113673,
0.041920118,
-0.0382624529,
-0.0098170014,
0.0210421775,
0.0207285173,
0.0470905118,
0.0000022218,
-0.0336276777,
-0.0451270826,
0.0100426218,
0.0137208635,
-0.0061225682,
0.0469145216,
-0.0285650007,
-0.0198218133,
0.0283775497,
-0.0157911219,
-0.0279272795,
0.0748967156,
0.015348074,
-0.0068158433,
0.0814144835,
0.008999845,
-0.0170022883,
0.0095149521,
-0.0727329999,
0.0054530324,
-0.0491031185,
-0.0024064188,
0.0036752229,
-0.0297502019,
0.0106865354,
-0.0028753805,
0.0285302587,
0.0172963291,
0.025391506,
-0.0507554188,
0.0381039195,
0.0646095052,
-0.0298770666,
-0.0045856186,
0.0491688959,
-0.0546197593,
-0.0078200214,
-0.0128978845,
-0.0375948995,
-0.0300262291,
-0.0222727899,
0.0068050828,
0.0641927198,
-0.0139771644,
0.0314158574,
0.0767849088,
-0.0001692966,
0.0441771261,
0.0237000044,
-0.0681654438,
0.0424145572,
0.0137157468,
-0.0198654886,
0.0171323791,
0.0182967167,
0.0010600919,
-0.0089706173,
0.041389253,
-0.0550074093,
-0.0390390493,
0.0072617177,
-0.0197176225,
-0.0246168673,
-0.0008260295,
-0.0715460256,
0.0453977622,
0.0789409354,
0.0292933919,
0.0196707994,
0.0074787023,
0.0177316014,
-0.0466894396,
0.0141974026,
-0.035434112,
0.0138147408,
0.0088568227,
0.0304929204,
-0.0094521362,
0.013291169,
-0.0527330786,
0.0020394414,
-0.0132456729,
0.0009514638,
0.0148776416,
-0.0012095331,
0.0234843269,
-0.0185459461,
-0.0823470503,
-0.0169258658,
-0.0131013189,
0.0697638467,
-0.0120385075,
-0.0303593799,
0.0045522358,
-0.0239693038,
-0.0109413043,
0.0068200128,
-0.0277648643,
-0.0776608586,
0.0022895795,
0.1122662798,
-0.0295745339,
-0.0337876678,
0.0190839414,
0.006968772,
-0.0290762782,
-0.0365957506,
0.0180235654,
-0.0484870113,
0.0321788862,
-0.0032383674,
0.0113789635,
-0.045404803,
-0.0029046158,
-0.0168023258,
-0.041515857,
0.0617338642,
0.056029208,
-0.0405958034,
0.0212687142,
-0.0210016184,
-0.0118264938,
0.0749687999,
0.0373072214,
0.052881591,
-0.0027343531,
-0.0019680264,
-0.0608943179,
0.0559682548,
0.006740449,
0.0621350892,
-0.058102563,
0.0039246208,
0.0067040394,
0.0353230201,
0.058773458,
0.009275171,
-0.0545792654,
0.0084657986,
0.0612837858,
-0.0067275432,
0.0236166846,
-0.0102978488,
-0.0077311653,
0.0352090299,
-0.0346121527,
-0.0273612291,
-0.0254220515,
0.0565815121,
-0.0154142501,
0.0126921609,
0.0510315038,
0.0673205629,
0.0197382625,
-0.0200076438,
0.0228538401,
-0.0390791818,
0.0044781668,
0.0544137433,
0.0349361114,
-0.0085418448,
-0.0477245897,
-0.0020066013,
0.0294800904,
-0.0092326421,
0.0207229778,
-0.0408220999,
-0.0032471099,
0.0466362648,
0.047728844,
0.0041013397,
-0.0391326137,
-0.0371446311,
-0.0693747774,
0.0677168444,
0.0531403348,
0.0136344749,
0.0427046046,
-0.0638507605,
-0.0299390219,
0.0104111303,
0.0177260973,
0.0694402456,
-0.0123063121,
0.0351191498,
0.0035005324,
0.0104739834,
-0.0697800219,
0.00726488,
0.0062538767,
-0.0515753776,
0.0798780695,
0.0229068603,
0.0381890684,
-0.0113921184,
-0.0187736433,
-0.004826223,
-0.0252373591,
-0.0206050798,
-0.0281605348,
-0.0073068636,
-0.0559180193,
-0.0644984469,
0.0195610411,
-0.0250150431,
-0.0246854387,
0.0275518522,
-0.0299343765,
-0.0281842593,
-0.0131686162,
-0.0157412663,
-0.0041516293,
-0.0098514305,
0.014186522,
0.0163532868,
0.0088118836,
-0.0771564692,
0.0182038844,
-0.0302756671,
-0.013166423,
0.0091018509,
-0.0357765518,
-0.0132829612,
-0.0572364405,
0.0048811547,
0.0547426641,
0.0311268177,
0.0396347456,
0.0579038858,
0.071547471,
0.010014249,
-0.0358068049,
-0.009137989,
0.03179162,
-0.0303343181,
0.0294853076,
0.0350573435,
0.080999434,
0.0062719244,
-0.0179632548,
-0.0003980857,
-0.0026329088,
-0.0340079628,
0.012926057,
-0.0181677248,
0.0085079344,
0.0620877109,
-0.0167447738,
-0.0255380925,
0.0225653443,
0.0207873881,
-0.0258433856,
0.0223380569,
-0.0645858496,
0.0323702507,
-0.013512278,
0.0103892982,
-0.012322166,
-0.0448611975,
0.0040213689,
-0.0663964227,
0.0230720565,
0.084879607,
0.0073333145,
-0.0189565085,
0.0585074835,
0.0199310947,
-0.1072735786,
0.0175842736,
-0.0353379399,
-0.0338514671,
-0.0315817297,
-0.0503191799,
0.0214639977,
0.0386360846,
0.0065531726,
-0.0051814434,
-0.0735133961,
0.0271823667,
-0.0130908983,
-0.0361385979,
0.0105591603,
0.0738369673,
0.0081545096,
0.028652994,
-0.0136328666,
-0.0300700031,
0.0988641158,
-0.0127323996,
0.0020611009,
-0.0894585103,
-0.0093201483,
-0.0315763056,
-0.0242289137,
-0.0033485722,
0.043334242,
-0.0519381538,
-0.0381258279,
-0.0343514495,
-0.0182129592,
0.0437651686,
-0.004210534,
0.0331315771,
-0.0325297043,
-0.0078490032,
-0.038499359,
-0.0407843441,
-0.0031670716,
0.0180031452,
-0.0081595629,
-0.0313574038,
0.0223463885,
-0.0251285248,
-0.0164881349,
0.0036539095,
0.038063392,
0.059918087,
-0.0169421136,
-0.0050706076,
-0.017231077,
0.0012060533,
0.0427840501,
-0.0142252995,
0.010383416,
-0.0418883599,
-0.0174780227,
0.0123384148,
0.0126874531,
-0.0064560985,
-0.0347811133,
0.0086629121,
0.0736917704,
0.0005849667,
-0.0004660368,
0.0204428919,
0.013304702,
-0.0435656719,
-0.0065291836,
0.1015853435,
0.0224231556,
-0.0948980674,
-0.0208452623,
-0.0168581586,
0.0511798486,
-0.0090743909,
0.0579214208,
-0.0492296517,
-0.0394978635,
0.0075139026,
0.0678744689,
0.0416420028,
0.0016132487,
-0.0148139084,
-0.0795291811,
0.0101068346,
0.0289504416,
-0.0745613053,
-0.0345136784,
-0.0082789445,
-0.0418862104,
-0.0795643032,
0.0514134578,
0.0036676591,
0.0415618867,
0.0109080384,
-0.0105602043,
0.0496424958,
-0.0558528341,
0.0005868323,
-0.0352388881,
0.0120238792,
0.1084105521,
0.0165885407,
-0.0095234206,
0.0249354802,
0.0049106427,
0.0051588537,
-0.0252461024,
-0.0326884165,
-0.0151639953,
-0.0049631479,
-0.0086740311,
0.0212643184,
0.0180538334,
-0.0054631806,
0.0294577703,
0.018178599,
0.0421097539,
-0.0245326236,
0.016922757,
0.0374103598,
-0.0411375649,
0.0239933599,
0.0188285448,
-0.0014901661,
-0.078137733,
0.0016092119,
-0.0531160682,
-0.0241362546,
-0.0772555619,
0.0090881931,
0.0010068759,
-0.0209645368,
-0.0403339788,
-0.0743566155,
-0.0458535068,
0.0044814139,
0.0168331899,
0.0005007881,
0.0079536876,
0.0430739857,
-0.0296558365,
-0.018981928,
0.0323065892,
-0.0380093306,
-0.0072183353,
-0.0711334124,
0.0185633004,
0.0120434882,
-0.0605081096,
0.0128736235,
0.0091769798,
-0.0361302868,
-0.0824085549,
-0.0495366529,
0.0849914625,
0.0079809539,
0.0452369116,
-0.0310535729,
-0.061759308,
-0.0021100002,
0.0220909901,
-0.0092566228,
-0.0165750161,
0.0477194749,
0.002993406,
-0.0143234693,
0.0480420701,
-0.0127028087,
-0.0181051586,
-0.0060548787,
0.0616437234,
0.0183208473,
-0.0207602959,
0.0225282982,
0.0113295298,
0.0210860278,
-0.0611400791,
-0.0061761034,
-0.0588651858,
0.0304266978,
-0.0122332731,
-0.0044725426,
-0.0227914602,
-0.0027500261,
0.0718121156,
0.0079986081,
0.0031453087,
-0.0178097133,
0.024340339,
-0.0402528495,
0.0071077971,
0.0283105038,
0.0023070965,
0.0249021724,
0.0697096661,
0.0091598025,
0.0035232343,
0.0242132172,
0.0258365497,
0.0382778645,
-0.0460429639,
0.0481204614,
0.0289703384,
-0.0128403921,
-0.0061136843,
0.0125060668,
0.0067941071,
-0.0832453668,
-0.0093279071,
-0.0153253535,
0.087225914,
-0.0023962427,
0.1089642718,
-0.0261974856,
-0.0131484587,
-0.012034392,
0.0286952443,
0.0088761458,
0.001268974,
0.0053357342,
0.0128343925,
0.0092084799,
0.0344055966,
0.0705548078,
-0.004801413,
-0.0014513277,
-0.0169115271,
0.0101399925,
-0.029160101,
-0.0274338592,
0.0005004561,
0.0300513562,
-0.0457436703,
-0.012487405,
0.0045877569,
-0.0430989675,
-0.0233379453,
0.0174522959,
-0.0051108208,
-0.0075098732,
0.016473135,
0.0283160452,
-0.0420394801,
0.0112152556,
-0.0632375777,
-0.0160561353,
-0.0085566575,
-0.0288003255,
-0.0284089055,
-7.162561851e-33,
0.0009744666,
-0.0082714912,
0.0117307361,
-0.0704622045,
-0.0088237599,
-0.0311846007,
-0.0159276575,
-0.0326872692,
0.0135011291,
-0.0114204017,
-0.0102698132,
-0.0019533788,
0.0069144699,
0.0330573693,
0.0154269943,
0.0262782108,
0.0245679189,
-0.0018728868,
-0.053940285,
0.0119236279,
0.025389621,
0.0123759536,
0.0531544387,
-0.0082789315,
0.0110145742,
0.0537590571,
-0.0086010173,
0.0044559794,
-0.0535941571,
0.038139753,
0.0044193659,
-0.0211901609,
-0.0099879708,
-0.053419821,
-0.0167066958,
-0.0437193587,
-0.0832834467,
-0.0011048859,
-0.0126557155,
0.0386390686,
0.0166070107,
-0.0523280464,
0.0150188934,
0.0090151895,
0.0080435248,
-0.0077829617,
-0.016259646,
-0.0301274844,
-0.0504172333,
-0.0108436598,
-0.0311425757,
0.0241608471,
-0.0174452011,
0.0305497758,
0.0692937747,
0.0109596197,
-0.0339601114,
0.0245613065,
-0.0527274013,
0.0181759186,
-0.0038798642,
0.0322428346,
0.0723019391,
0.0320747644,
-0.0058385716,
-0.0244382005,
0.031658683,
-0.0327549018,
0.0818045288,
0.0143552246,
0.0263134558,
-0.0075868843,
0.0174619947,
0.0496671721,
0.0422040373,
0.0134168388,
-0.0581638776,
0.0320976004,
0.0050264625,
-0.0000408667,
0.0582220592,
0.0422663875,
-0.0440665893,
-0.0168655794,
-0.0775096714,
-0.0375392847,
-0.0444351546,
-0.0222495776,
0.0027406744,
0.0178495497,
-0.0430245847,
-0.0464362577,
0.0866921023,
-0.0053108232,
0.0102492478,
-0.0265049096,
-0.0392373428,
-0.0065951901,
-0.0256341863,
0.0391236991,
-0.0284232944,
-0.0279717222,
-0.009612212,
-0.0415777154,
-0.0314887837,
0.017601097,
0.0294638369,
0.004003759,
-0.0412391834,
0.02389176,
-0.0298834015,
0.0143358931,
0.0286304504,
0.0801802203,
0.0398691259,
-0.0443081371,
0.0053197793,
0.0545715764,
0.0547217615,
-0.0109927803,
-0.0120001193,
-0.0048753452,
0.0150315892,
0.0176473483,
-0.0180400535,
0.0478307381,
-0.0256977025,
0.0350974165,
0.0349404067,
-0.0638214052,
-0.0360938869,
0.0244421344,
2.97e-7,
0.0302670635,
0.094593145,
-0.0144012654,
0.0558364168,
-0.014827447,
0.0672823042,
0.0014898148,
0.0204341747,
0.0179608986,
0.0936292931,
0.0338053592,
0.0066116853,
0.0635858476,
0.0222750641,
-0.0812947825,
-0.050131049,
-0.0132968388,
0.0363270119,
-0.0428549089,
-0.0492305756,
-0.0047306586,
0.08921469,
-0.0029020584,
0.0026888319,
0.0267345812,
0.0139629627,
0.053128507,
-0.032274574,
-0.0131028928,
-0.0010955367,
0.004441991,
0.019903617,
-0.0547793359,
-0.0323384143,
-0.0368444175,
-0.0028691099,
-0.0007301291,
0.0831892341,
0.0249331594,
-0.0545180216,
0.0329032838,
0.0022840335,
0.0035105678,
-0.0298069958,
0.0424454436,
-0.0665389225,
-0.0256715417,
0.0259547997,
-0.0157992896,
-0.0055809896,
0.0359899774,
-0.062629126,
-0.0294831377,
0.0025637539,
0.0152863637,
0.0141781392,
-0.0148121612,
-0.0229835641,
-0.017760314,
0.0072109033,
-0.0039333818,
-0.0414801463,
-0.0113910576,
0.0124113709,
0.0128069445,
-0.0326422863,
-0.021086799,
2.794909092e-34,
0.0402096584,
-0.010500364,
0.0293779578,
-0.0324453339,
0.0386687107,
-0.0177442711,
-0.0138610033,
0.0116106402,
0.0254116543,
-0.0588312298,
-0.0636617914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08377v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08377v1 | Learning to Filter Context for Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2023-11-14T18:41:54 | 2023-11-14T18:41:54 | Zhiruo Wang, Jun Araki, Zhengbao Jiang, Md Rizwan Parvez, Graham Neubig | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | On-the-fly retrieval of relevant knowledge has proven an essential element of
reliable systems for tasks such as open-domain question answering and fact
verification. However, because retrieval systems are not perfect, generation
models are required to generate outputs given partially or entirely irrelevant
passages. This can cause over- or under-reliance on context, and result in
problems in the generated output such as hallucinations. To alleviate these
problems, we propose FILCO, a method that improves the quality of the context
provided to the generator by (1) identifying useful context based on lexical
and information-theoretic approaches, and (2) training context filtering models
that can filter retrieved contexts at test time. We experiment on six
knowledge-intensive tasks with FLAN-T5 and LLaMa2, and demonstrate that our
method outperforms existing approaches on extractive question answering (QA),
complex multi-hop and long-form QA, fact verification, and dialog generation
tasks. FILCO effectively improves the quality of context, whether or not it
supports the canonical output. | [
0.0293680914,
0.0177488849,
0.0050369073,
0.0415453278,
-0.013746243,
-0.0089260284,
0.0046921815,
0.0002415969,
0.0025192655,
-0.0562831946,
-0.0309012253,
-0.0459372438,
-0.0179036967,
0.0428979434,
0.0124069722,
-0.0278210267,
0.0678727701,
0.0116932131,
-0.0087650008,
0.0040380885,
-0.02031192,
0.0100475177,
-0.014037841,
0.046099171,
-0.0460722521,
-0.0252492353,
0.0041516437,
-0.005545482,
0.0284402817,
-0.0117832394,
0.0205934029,
0.0246148128,
0.0086348606,
-0.0093215574,
0.0000019803,
-0.0310985669,
-0.0264120903,
-0.0197843499,
-0.0383582823,
-0.0291654766,
0.0082018785,
0.0596487261,
0.0126643674,
0.0293577053,
-0.0611592457,
0.0242870133,
0.0127103282,
0.0589804426,
0.059179198,
0.0568152443,
-0.0051849685,
-0.0051903119,
-0.0013766751,
-0.0055206944,
0.0739429519,
-0.0223078374,
-0.0014631401,
0.0023442523,
0.0264657047,
0.0219076313,
0.0114526153,
0.0266356338,
0.0438637808,
-0.0023802114,
0.0054090866,
0.059795253,
-0.0410857163,
-0.0089827916,
0.0257376675,
0.0892135203,
0.0347363949,
-0.0166967306,
0.0106394403,
0.0346610397,
0.0053821402,
-0.0028839908,
-0.0424550623,
0.0334516689,
-0.0422656722,
0.0071253222,
0.0313749239,
-0.0081609199,
0.0001633622,
0.0208711401,
-0.0204576924,
0.067181319,
0.0087439213,
-0.0235806145,
-0.0162483603,
0.0176864229,
-0.0339691229,
-0.055655282,
0.0106499027,
0.0442245901,
-0.0405855216,
0.0087628895,
-0.0378907025,
-0.0061332141,
0.0303731561,
-0.0242227949,
-0.0399653129,
0.0284241401,
-0.0570769981,
0.0173974838,
-0.0424594767,
0.0041314112,
-0.0126733473,
0.0118037919,
-0.0463642813,
0.0028214634,
-0.0400273688,
-0.0133562172,
-0.0492432527,
0.0634310469,
-0.076941438,
-0.0177162345,
-0.0409949049,
0.0437058881,
-0.0088766245,
0.0150237782,
-0.04340351,
0.0553436242,
-0.0457854941,
0.0068274145,
-0.0308306422,
0.0003602285,
-0.0423911586,
0.0188517068,
0.0415251069,
-0.04417184,
-0.0363494605,
0.0178298596,
0.0132847866,
-0.0072879,
-0.0156311616,
0.0445403717,
-0.0133146495,
-0.0176126845,
-0.0422345288,
-0.0710213855,
-0.0237283539,
-0.0599291176,
0.0169838704,
-0.0318751186,
0.0073170597,
-0.0086001093,
-0.0424359664,
-0.0084456494,
0.0318174809,
0.0633592531,
0.0276090056,
0.0416116267,
-0.0087074088,
-0.0386774279,
0.0446734391,
0.0407383367,
0.006218296,
0.0520195961,
0.0084720654,
0.0196205527,
0.0218106769,
0.0485156439,
0.0179311484,
-0.0104880203,
0.0372809321,
-0.0051640207,
-0.0040557748,
0.0283987187,
0.004243867,
0.0020534061,
0.0228978563,
0.0317844413,
-0.0457299054,
0.0106531326,
0.0417643152,
-0.0035606995,
0.0638990477,
-0.0057924632,
0.0707634389,
-0.0214232262,
-0.0069962139,
0.0295444969,
-0.0475558862,
0.0423027351,
-0.040119011,
0.0295368396,
0.0142543558,
0.0379027613,
-0.0231305342,
-0.0466725342,
0.0070321481,
0.0163191073,
-0.0262850653,
0.03882467,
0.0188056827,
0.0422425829,
-0.0489998087,
0.0387140103,
0.0110445535,
-0.0583959669,
0.0003244163,
-0.0489399098,
0.0765640512,
0.0527402647,
0.0761307478,
-0.0244835429,
-0.0306507628,
-0.0020776826,
0.0104718246,
0.0478921346,
0.0026469394,
-0.0296206065,
0.0229828674,
-0.0434265807,
-0.011958845,
-0.0234017335,
0.0091818282,
-0.0162618496,
0.030415535,
0.0139132934,
0.0572993271,
-0.0236901101,
0.0115744947,
0.0363838151,
-0.0100163268,
-0.0559787974,
0.0194292087,
0.0098602008,
0.011397155,
0.0142780039,
0.0026758998,
0.0132849012,
0.0360486954,
-0.0418520384,
-0.0029563208,
0.0265136231,
-0.0854207948,
-0.0606975555,
0.0062157074,
0.0231182948,
0.0178365186,
-0.0061111818,
-0.0205259565,
-0.0482513793,
-0.0057274462,
-0.0280793551,
0.0406962447,
-0.0551854782,
-0.0182486977,
0.0640487596,
0.0291710328,
-0.0345148593,
0.1120976731,
-0.0061423322,
-0.0161364116,
0.060043063,
0.057783898,
0.0023523236,
-0.0350532606,
0.0141636468,
-0.0032418708,
-0.0268104821,
-0.0012136921,
0.0093459552,
0.0166071746,
-0.0795894042,
-0.0112679293,
-0.0888761431,
0.0334485695,
-0.0233355053,
0.0064715231,
0.0552101918,
0.008111693,
-0.0027644266,
0.0044778516,
-0.0528063551,
0.0246324204,
0.0245728884,
0.0130682569,
0.0199936219,
0.041242376,
-0.0179479215,
-0.0393413827,
0.0161564648,
-0.0076930346,
0.0450141728,
0.0073657543,
0.0076012607,
-0.0454389565,
0.0447233059,
-0.071604833,
0.0194286276,
-0.010948238,
0.0053349053,
0.0311403014,
-0.0181035455,
0.0371551178,
0.0539502278,
0.0332084335,
0.0331300497,
0.0252234098,
-0.0239434093,
-0.0484600738,
0.0447721146,
-0.0211068653,
-0.0025200625,
0.0349400751,
-0.0192491226,
0.0279476754,
0.0142733976,
0.0351005793,
0.0159997363,
-0.0299243014,
0.0339412354,
-0.0103103844,
-0.0291808434,
-0.0323342681,
-0.0007723977,
-0.0375318229,
0.0416207276,
-0.0451032966,
-0.0083513651,
0.0495808683,
-0.011137465,
0.0112538729,
-0.0581529252,
0.0085915364,
-0.0279056933,
0.0267180745,
-0.0172489081,
0.0223889686,
0.0038016641,
-0.0109772328,
-0.0453353263,
-0.001448356,
-0.0083732018,
-0.0662653521,
0.0487820767,
-0.0517101586,
0.0145800645,
-0.003114288,
-0.045261085,
-0.0964394882,
0.003081307,
0.0320559517,
0.0057890429,
-0.0374251343,
0.0126170209,
-0.0079235183,
-0.0186690874,
0.0417009108,
0.0538612604,
-0.0164585207,
-0.0351040922,
-0.0031317458,
0.0855356604,
0.06289763,
0.0203120057,
0.0193019211,
-0.0078396956,
0.0211306661,
0.0676552728,
0.0464842469,
-0.0263576098,
0.0198075995,
-0.0142174996,
0.002348904,
-0.0072909733,
-0.0144648803,
0.0506298617,
0.0662925839,
-0.0739373192,
-0.0779175013,
0.0797800422,
0.0440983139,
-0.0042043398,
-0.0029404277,
-0.0245012045,
0.0200956687,
0.0146004939,
0.0242019203,
-0.1125049517,
-0.0312412996,
-0.009808383,
0.0330083668,
-0.0139896106,
-0.0050783143,
-0.0143637778,
-0.108447887,
0.0630507693,
-0.0030177173,
-0.045138821,
-0.060956981,
-0.0091274381,
0.0081403283,
0.0324335098,
0.00869634,
0.0474358425,
-0.0052629248,
0.0181923844,
0.0171899758,
0.0573463142,
-0.03291668,
0.0366690569,
0.0022936941,
0.0168303698,
0.0581443049,
0.0057493458,
0.0394658558,
-0.050879471,
0.0057949573,
-0.0633548349,
0.0173834171,
-0.005314678,
0.0345302075,
-0.0037667574,
-0.0070878458,
-0.0305033624,
0.0367732234,
-0.0332584567,
-0.0539077967,
-0.001116298,
0.0240351334,
-0.048553355,
-0.0039109881,
-0.0330746248,
0.0624138527,
0.0375931002,
0.0724396482,
0.0567416176,
-0.0354000144,
-0.031233957,
-0.024689747,
0.0193143636,
-0.0791177973,
-0.0034306042,
0.0117006442,
0.0301844031,
0.0064702677,
-0.1290860027,
-0.0492846332,
-0.0005186754,
0.0673791468,
-0.0243678242,
0.0010972468,
-0.0450821668,
-0.0217597019,
-0.0221459102,
0.0178830847,
-0.0354954824,
-0.0175534096,
-0.0204216614,
-0.0134342359,
0.0366295688,
-0.0618622564,
-0.0200242493,
0.0661299974,
-0.0641670004,
-0.0407900214,
-0.0002334457,
0.0391324535,
0.0251901112,
0.0530501194,
-0.0049946262,
0.0338461809,
0.0487740748,
0.0504011586,
-0.0387782305,
0.0256444234,
0.0263938941,
0.0104079219,
-0.0054474832,
0.0233506449,
-0.073602289,
0.0312785432,
-0.014295795,
0.0477798805,
-0.0237093493,
-0.0370583832,
0.042358987,
-0.0210999157,
-0.0055984138,
-0.0087814853,
-0.0157590993,
-0.0257075839,
0.0177116618,
-0.0243810508,
-0.0168717783,
-0.021054104,
0.0352928191,
-0.0189351458,
-0.0235924888,
0.0333961919,
-0.0135182086,
-0.0175562538,
0.0638474524,
-0.0170265269,
-0.0698268414,
-0.0091486629,
0.0050859726,
-0.0024087192,
-0.0051837103,
-0.057644397,
0.0015348515,
0.001216503,
0.0672592372,
-0.0336079486,
0.1015293077,
0.0123697659,
-0.018646501,
-0.0289719608,
0.0320120417,
-0.0767877623,
0.0043407506,
-0.0662315413,
-0.0025928584,
0.0388322808,
0.0000550726,
0.0297811106,
-0.0349908769,
0.0040004347,
0.0058441507,
0.0262683649,
0.0127333999,
-0.0494335331,
0.0134807341,
0.0210238211,
0.0006262453,
-0.0283064526,
0.0894318894,
-0.048496861,
0.0543215312,
-0.0116386106,
0.0077826609,
-0.0555575155,
-0.0442009121,
-0.0382536165,
0.032898061,
0.0006486399,
-0.0060787359,
-0.0470862165,
-0.0540536419,
0.0310521852,
0.0153798321,
-0.002993657,
0.0040171053,
0.0649769008,
0.068867065,
0.0245814733,
-0.0602354966,
-0.0195742901,
0.0262399949,
-0.0094908699,
-0.0018607458,
-0.0140663851,
-6.76726808e-33,
-0.065101862,
-0.0406562649,
0.0491805188,
-0.0195412021,
-0.0335076042,
-0.0088644316,
-0.0560459346,
-0.0094664786,
-0.0260986947,
-0.0140581764,
0.0018280032,
0.010737922,
0.0055231354,
0.0334000513,
-0.0212624278,
-0.020626273,
0.0379630439,
0.001093806,
-0.0344339162,
0.0650592297,
0.0873917565,
0.004814283,
0.0124701783,
-0.050505247,
-0.0000247947,
-0.0133519471,
0.0060252598,
0.009568071,
-0.0221947767,
0.0480221994,
-0.0430807211,
0.0608219653,
0.0302828141,
-0.0306164287,
-0.0024720849,
0.0304719545,
-0.0862303898,
-0.041425474,
0.015919352,
-0.0410562046,
-0.0515506305,
-0.0562686026,
0.0398380458,
-0.0113736168,
0.0445397384,
-0.0023463201,
0.0212891754,
-0.0191087518,
-0.0144297406,
-0.0417334922,
-0.0748508796,
-0.0058390214,
0.0071029854,
-0.0290791467,
-0.0679838583,
0.0796567574,
0.0225927718,
-0.0262528099,
-0.0437651686,
0.0184732676,
-0.0124155339,
0.0389868356,
0.0535943024,
0.0166608747,
-0.0009526705,
0.0651552901,
-0.0008082725,
-0.0146374814,
-0.0470310599,
-0.0564899854,
-0.0054318937,
0.0417571925,
0.0023747743,
0.0680351257,
0.0197888166,
-0.0314574763,
-0.054104276,
0.0443992652,
-0.0383805968,
0.0318386219,
0.0095924623,
-0.0319412947,
-0.0227394607,
0.0010876389,
-0.0124914907,
0.0491592884,
-0.0368104093,
-0.0228465889,
0.0640910789,
0.0455712341,
-0.0021473058,
-0.0349024124,
0.0276576653,
0.0025867559,
0.0678168312,
0.0322900675,
-0.0625083074,
-0.0004720161,
-0.01504183,
-0.0057957689,
-0.0246829502,
-0.0036426687,
0.0610124394,
0.0054021701,
-0.0145316422,
0.0279590338,
0.0207519159,
0.0128834005,
-0.0317151211,
0.0325504392,
-0.0729829073,
0.0711041093,
0.001450791,
-0.0189833399,
0.0229346957,
0.021662049,
-0.0339989364,
0.0378001742,
-0.0045598652,
0.0139245279,
-0.0153987398,
-0.046153523,
0.0004767439,
0.0157463197,
-0.0542370602,
0.026449753,
-0.0232183393,
0.0542057306,
0.0064353105,
-0.0585025772,
-0.0182485729,
0.0215094145,
2.777e-7,
0.0215872899,
-0.011597001,
0.0275377762,
0.0249164887,
0.0016128692,
0.0166431461,
0.038111981,
0.0193001069,
0.0103337746,
-0.0205285791,
-0.0188275352,
0.0320102908,
0.0246938672,
0.0551515892,
-0.0579976104,
-0.0192290246,
-0.0406515747,
-0.0264906883,
-0.0310065653,
-0.0422724783,
0.0858816132,
0.0602457374,
-0.0257831272,
-0.0221367758,
0.0114260474,
-0.052713614,
0.0623563975,
0.020961415,
-0.0188497398,
-0.0092706848,
0.032933563,
0.0217380524,
0.01317982,
0.0007413447,
-0.031416446,
0.0022457554,
-0.0123683522,
0.030523451,
0.0111539429,
-0.0854052976,
-0.0040571447,
-0.0039402531,
0.038560126,
-0.0456040762,
0.0675034299,
-0.0361164659,
0.0129189659,
-0.0190575235,
-0.0288786422,
-0.0158277061,
-0.0051524583,
-0.0234677289,
-0.0197632108,
0.0217655469,
-0.0185864549,
0.010013965,
-0.0101132747,
-0.0863865986,
-0.0333030596,
0.0278918687,
-0.0572552234,
-0.0145444619,
-0.0409494936,
-0.0425980538,
0.0088335173,
-0.0435868762,
-0.0007843609,
2.593158905e-34,
-0.0166825708,
0.0002311122,
0.0010163565,
0.0418972857,
0.0091135763,
0.0016746125,
-0.0151412357,
0.0008138221,
0.0136049157,
-0.0570811704,
-0.0306408945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08374v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08374v2 | A Ship of Theseus: Curious Cases of Paraphrasing in LLM-Generated Texts | 2023-11-14T18:40:42 | 2024-06-06T23:14:32 | Nafis Irtiza Tripto, Saranya Venkatraman, Dominik Macko, Robert Moro, Ivan Srba, Adaku Uchendu, Thai Le, Dongwon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the realm of text manipulation and linguistic transformation, the question
of authorship has been a subject of fascination and philosophical inquiry. Much
like the Ship of Theseus paradox, which ponders whether a ship remains the same
when each of its original planks is replaced, our research delves into an
intriguing question: Does a text retain its original authorship when it
undergoes numerous paraphrasing iterations? Specifically, since Large Language
Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable proficiency in both the generation
of original content and the modification of human-authored texts, a pivotal
question emerges concerning the determination of authorship in instances where
LLMs or similar paraphrasing tools are employed to rephrase the text--i.e.,
whether authorship should be attributed to the original human author or the
AI-powered tool. Therefore, we embark on a philosophical voyage through the
seas of language and authorship to unravel this intricate puzzle. Using a
computational approach, we discover that the diminishing performance in text
classification models, with each successive paraphrasing iteration, is closely
associated with the extent of deviation from the original author's style, thus
provoking a reconsideration of the current notion of authorship. | [
0.0954705328,
0.0468874834,
-0.0406853221,
0.0453933626,
-0.0898575559,
0.0032103944,
0.0284117311,
0.0042911209,
-0.0272015575,
-0.0708150938,
0.0022929008,
0.0121988393,
0.0433272459,
-0.0679972172,
0.0383184031,
-0.0058703115,
-0.0068547288,
-0.0214726776,
0.0002749413,
0.0064486116,
-0.0190983079,
0.0128773535,
0.0540364124,
0.0315493234,
0.0245351885,
0.0008546993,
0.0117518865,
0.01675204,
-0.0079910867,
0.0634492859,
-0.0101913018,
0.0378933065,
-0.021908287,
0.0943668187,
0.0000016844,
-0.0537930876,
-0.0054484257,
0.0009489106,
0.0095941946,
0.0254067853,
0.0864335895,
0.035627488,
0.0043197386,
0.0036177165,
-0.0276588649,
0.0297755506,
0.0056338869,
0.0287050847,
0.0668440163,
0.0794782639,
-0.0106301559,
-0.0604050383,
0.0035194557,
0.0131783457,
0.0421304181,
0.0203417689,
0.0440838896,
-0.0193354841,
0.0230246391,
0.0234968774,
-0.0054506902,
0.0461350195,
-0.0074784188,
-0.0060480917,
-0.0120980609,
-0.0238544941,
-0.0014375425,
0.0327160917,
0.0282500349,
0.0081221908,
-0.0023277674,
-0.0758651868,
0.0278714206,
0.0312975943,
0.0070733507,
0.0474220105,
-0.013219771,
0.0498288758,
-0.029789919,
0.0048802849,
0.0329812765,
-0.0130100995,
0.0077618281,
0.0367966667,
-0.0067232624,
0.0106827328,
0.0208933838,
-0.0099200094,
-0.0473162718,
0.0048123924,
-0.0147454171,
-0.0594443195,
0.0214836057,
0.0184843987,
0.0117629301,
0.0070188376,
-0.0741665214,
-0.0522250086,
0.0139729502,
-0.0386683978,
0.0662719905,
-0.0049817031,
0.0116652399,
0.0322049446,
-0.014531848,
0.052676443,
-0.0209852271,
0.0556102507,
-0.0565599427,
-0.0040060738,
-0.0613598377,
-0.0287092999,
-0.0327375457,
0.0277875978,
0.0387123823,
0.0071777161,
-0.0416581593,
0.034459658,
0.0359514356,
-0.0038124861,
-0.0275353491,
0.01100842,
-0.012020492,
0.0141868321,
0.0061210776,
-0.0222129915,
0.0434943885,
0.0348967761,
-0.0341982953,
-0.004727236,
-0.0214959159,
0.0369857885,
0.0032320661,
-0.0407419614,
0.0218987558,
0.0203538258,
-0.0032241049,
-0.0422885083,
-0.0228864569,
-0.0393553525,
-0.0400076732,
-0.029656617,
0.0003948548,
-0.051169686,
0.0144637991,
0.0009964282,
-0.0261353552,
-0.0604492985,
-0.0039516781,
0.0403315313,
-0.0799046308,
0.0184615552,
0.0133849923,
0.0222571362,
0.0499136336,
-0.0170408301,
-0.0241459776,
-0.0262470171,
0.0881876945,
0.0356085487,
0.0581501424,
0.0112328958,
0.02206905,
0.0102851326,
-0.0123900417,
0.0276482366,
-0.029908441,
-0.0381561518,
0.002635784,
0.0255130529,
0.0204538666,
0.0741538927,
-0.002117076,
-0.0173953976,
0.1079355404,
0.0680551678,
-0.0179786086,
0.0653238073,
0.0786554217,
0.0004255929,
0.0621092618,
0.0571411364,
-0.0081516728,
-0.0279313494,
-0.0062705479,
0.0058400151,
-0.0261455197,
0.0004038716,
0.0131749623,
-0.0219679065,
0.0041053747,
-0.0092589157,
-0.0131838396,
-0.0222397,
-0.0042657834,
0.0253069606,
-0.0167334415,
-0.0037659651,
-0.0118784914,
-0.0815587565,
0.010178078,
-0.0454908237,
0.0185469482,
0.0631619319,
0.085105516,
-0.0269412976,
0.0381402858,
-0.0370610915,
0.0018018044,
0.0329530835,
-0.0045604371,
-0.0171355829,
-0.003087824,
0.0041491175,
0.0160152782,
-0.0419237241,
0.0248481482,
0.0103378138,
-0.0155533245,
-0.0183569863,
0.0195207298,
-0.0333809704,
-0.0696933791,
0.0664558932,
-0.015268174,
-0.0094747879,
0.014621065,
-0.0034427659,
-0.0112560447,
0.0112674562,
-0.0442410335,
0.0231281742,
0.0071688318,
-0.0608230606,
-0.0603805892,
0.0473673567,
0.0074911807,
-0.0085066836,
0.0435373709,
-0.0302612092,
0.0229912661,
-0.0038431752,
-0.0100220349,
-0.0379929617,
0.0489114635,
-0.0580937192,
0.0217533763,
-0.0226722211,
0.0605831407,
-0.0677612796,
-0.0045756502,
-0.0573099256,
0.0511550084,
0.0161518175,
0.048754219,
0.0145810535,
-0.0241647623,
0.0312998332,
0.0196413957,
-0.0115649449,
-0.0372025631,
0.0372816697,
0.0076068486,
-0.000223007,
-0.0320707634,
-0.0036885201,
-0.0873633623,
-0.062414512,
-0.0107598146,
-0.0219068825,
-0.0028027555,
0.0355611369,
-0.0206269417,
-0.002341642,
0.0101015065,
0.0047843694,
-0.0272232387,
-0.012154609,
-0.0078900419,
0.0731207579,
-0.0107519822,
-0.0170086436,
-0.0378258266,
0.031843856,
-0.0053326618,
0.0699211583,
0.062268842,
0.0075812503,
-0.0793983862,
-0.0022824646,
-0.0385020971,
-0.0240503103,
-0.0059004347,
-0.0099521307,
-0.0198389366,
-0.0217312723,
0.0271865204,
0.0720807016,
0.0283127297,
-0.0016072621,
0.0284040123,
0.028842194,
-0.0126076639,
-0.0395991765,
-0.0049423366,
-0.0300229527,
-0.0314565375,
-0.0630044565,
0.0353769772,
0.0285491515,
0.0271568671,
-0.0347263478,
-0.0114890495,
0.058895763,
-0.0016544699,
-0.0259458032,
0.0542288385,
-0.0459086075,
-0.0474460311,
-0.0002544076,
-0.0336067304,
-0.0496829189,
0.0269951262,
-0.0372923464,
0.0175544061,
-0.038716197,
-0.0134742735,
-0.0395482481,
0.0605347417,
0.0162735302,
0.0338712633,
0.026519455,
0.0060251923,
-0.0439857133,
0.0135593954,
0.0581573471,
-0.0184430368,
0.0296421926,
-0.0487194173,
0.0374520831,
0.025596166,
-0.0264904089,
-0.006125675,
-0.0735296905,
0.000624602,
0.0090120509,
0.0083649717,
-0.0076654162,
-0.0247326586,
-0.0668252334,
0.0572268404,
0.0370763168,
-0.0189120509,
-0.0145892231,
-0.0349926725,
0.0417838655,
0.0368681066,
0.0009540659,
0.0008995542,
-0.0278060455,
-0.0055335676,
0.0093186768,
-0.0047673299,
0.0260689426,
-0.0175313875,
-0.0101851458,
0.0088571971,
-0.0421915762,
-0.0703225881,
-0.0199742615,
0.0242187828,
-0.0289080981,
-0.0016685734,
0.1022822112,
0.0266070999,
-0.0290475488,
0.0054960344,
-0.0288938135,
-0.013473439,
0.0182987638,
0.0277895797,
-0.0473367386,
0.0095254844,
-0.0022690576,
0.0087653352,
-0.0423672982,
-0.0495663956,
-0.0347790197,
-0.0538363717,
0.0348112732,
-0.0075509595,
-0.0551646277,
0.0086414721,
-0.03083013,
-0.0287249871,
0.0214980859,
-0.0560048074,
0.0035760351,
-0.0278381705,
0.0243247468,
-0.0108149666,
-0.0015718258,
-0.0108431149,
-0.0355152003,
-0.04960135,
0.0097052967,
0.0491063222,
0.0655462816,
-0.0111325495,
0.0059482045,
-0.0215761997,
-0.0446730666,
0.0048248353,
-0.0104497094,
0.0684618726,
0.01743933,
0.0085398471,
-0.025526192,
0.0263431054,
-0.0004497618,
-0.0050347582,
0.0194588397,
0.039286647,
0.0066933227,
-0.0283342283,
0.0092133489,
0.000719342,
0.0007938878,
0.0528013594,
0.0362553075,
-0.0428832509,
-0.0676350966,
-0.0486727282,
0.0083070556,
-0.0489306413,
-0.0771299377,
0.0072436025,
-0.0310362149,
-0.0018269469,
-0.1190277562,
-0.0092385905,
-0.0522296019,
0.0122648096,
0.0658337176,
0.0657215565,
-0.0097606573,
-0.0372199006,
-0.0030487885,
-0.0557607636,
-0.0508253463,
0.0282464921,
0.0009121317,
0.0099978894,
0.0376248993,
-0.0196188577,
0.0290863812,
-0.0020164107,
-0.0797065869,
-0.0441507958,
0.0263632685,
0.0143636651,
0.0258843359,
0.0046026069,
0.0044337101,
-0.059239164,
0.0523807406,
0.0173566621,
0.0017246659,
0.0938067809,
0.0070310785,
0.0328403749,
-0.0226104874,
0.0545070246,
-0.0207966361,
-0.0077359448,
0.0707598999,
-0.0408382304,
-0.0328158624,
-0.0371908508,
0.0281711947,
0.0266169384,
-0.0247973558,
-0.0252280198,
0.0324835144,
0.0118558919,
0.0235055853,
-0.0218778905,
-0.0248623174,
-0.0393348262,
0.0076930365,
0.0434460193,
0.0102554383,
-0.0182427503,
0.0409970209,
-0.0235904623,
0.0567229651,
-0.0185981654,
-0.0119772712,
-0.0097000422,
0.0530523248,
-0.0361477211,
0.0228378382,
-0.0057444819,
0.0251944698,
-0.0180635694,
0.0486975312,
0.0117674368,
0.0188044067,
0.0238257349,
0.0004708386,
-0.0531168096,
0.0392153226,
-0.1383416206,
-0.0466859229,
0.0194003861,
0.0103668263,
0.0371621065,
-0.0036819126,
0.0864247084,
-0.0251097772,
-0.0155217322,
-0.0181412362,
0.0387837887,
-0.0083071077,
0.0216989927,
-0.0681784526,
-0.0193537232,
-0.0197030939,
0.0477544963,
0.0775709823,
0.0312999003,
0.0594548881,
0.0101561099,
-0.0320997871,
-0.0072821658,
-0.0835238844,
0.0203610677,
-0.0245415978,
0.0235247854,
-0.0197707508,
-0.0620730668,
-0.0248489697,
0.0708859712,
-0.0084785465,
0.0675726384,
-0.0724232271,
0.001561746,
0.058165092,
-0.0245403424,
0.0070971511,
-0.0758500919,
0.0612269193,
0.0222504884,
-0.025440963,
-0.0315752253,
-4.72461522e-33,
-0.0054914956,
-0.0185463969,
-0.0003548635,
0.0442689024,
-0.0365908481,
-0.0213062968,
-0.0333221257,
-0.0177649036,
0.0147171225,
-0.0052658767,
-0.0303721372,
-0.0154421153,
-0.0036131637,
0.0095566334,
0.0202831943,
0.0010328057,
0.0478850119,
-0.0222385079,
-0.04556299,
-0.0286650937,
0.0481039882,
-0.0094054472,
-0.0048147789,
-0.0818013102,
0.0346316993,
-0.0383008979,
-0.0300420299,
-0.0223054849,
-0.0182806756,
-0.0080516916,
0.0109351417,
0.0275424663,
0.012583877,
-0.0020246014,
-0.0282123517,
-0.0141631123,
-0.0262668636,
-0.0097021814,
0.0197686329,
0.0248356014,
-0.0050198426,
-0.0693899766,
0.0670509487,
-0.0333050601,
-0.0028733544,
0.0008320693,
0.0813074112,
-0.0179423019,
-0.0167004056,
-0.0143542774,
-0.0680855438,
-0.0057150009,
-0.0149636958,
-0.0009543715,
0.0077573159,
0.0190681778,
0.0078398297,
0.0350903757,
-0.074789986,
0.0212733559,
-0.0561693907,
0.0007140884,
-0.0222273543,
0.0042374879,
0.0407875776,
0.0351521596,
0.033080928,
0.0378382914,
-0.0184414927,
0.0180292223,
-0.0180768352,
0.0306161493,
0.0514040925,
0.0943037793,
-0.0027156838,
-0.0047553857,
0.0085865483,
0.0010712402,
0.0104563134,
-0.0591789596,
0.0187263824,
-0.016762903,
-0.0200859364,
-0.0540535264,
-0.0511062481,
-0.070253931,
-0.005627349,
0.0005809694,
-0.0052636624,
0.003147634,
-0.0376551226,
-0.0192500316,
-0.0130862277,
-0.0607287362,
-0.0280545279,
-0.0300051942,
-0.0587143153,
0.072816357,
0.0218590423,
-0.01076876,
-0.0077432031,
-0.0202130973,
0.0031784507,
0.0204941425,
0.0509759896,
-0.0032063765,
0.0683092326,
0.0348366164,
-0.0581672601,
-0.0039169323,
-0.0009282655,
-0.0073736021,
0.0029247024,
-0.0352322012,
0.0004858669,
0.0237024277,
0.0251540001,
-0.0240625758,
0.0412694439,
0.0032555091,
-0.0203414448,
0.0032450971,
0.0027131874,
-0.0072232499,
-0.0244633723,
-0.0028735425,
0.0016781643,
0.0388464741,
0.0178442076,
-0.0425044447,
0.0085454322,
-0.0430697724,
2.395e-7,
0.0538307652,
0.0231027342,
0.0146045042,
-0.0398149416,
0.0333195589,
0.0460356474,
0.009397096,
0.0043970859,
-0.0071601556,
0.0204076841,
0.0248141196,
0.0161600001,
0.0409518555,
-0.0143042076,
-0.1065861508,
0.0227964371,
-0.0504783317,
0.0150338542,
-0.0344053954,
0.0176348425,
0.0476656072,
0.0422564261,
0.0550397523,
-0.0594264492,
-0.036749281,
-0.0716938898,
0.0754505992,
-0.0155727901,
0.009947625,
0.0223965645,
0.0015162234,
-0.0122298608,
-0.0072865742,
0.0037311644,
-0.0053514414,
0.0135304518,
0.0130216498,
0.0482199863,
0.0306135584,
0.0283958316,
-0.0262940899,
-0.0565802865,
0.0171608254,
-0.0639042556,
0.0522834621,
0.0069710664,
-0.005479468,
-0.029120313,
0.0127126547,
0.0264901649,
0.0127249155,
0.006694356,
-0.0181806814,
0.0160065219,
-0.0061290115,
0.0291057248,
0.0057367822,
-0.056355983,
-0.0246022008,
-0.01952664,
-0.0616053194,
-0.0195710063,
-0.0156495217,
0.0373499691,
0.0519723669,
-0.0907540247,
0.0355794057,
2.252163835e-34,
0.0170271546,
-0.0115920687,
0.0281406231,
0.0291786771,
0.0283433106,
0.0205266885,
0.016462218,
0.0433782898,
-0.0173204336,
-0.0306534171,
-0.0107364897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08370v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08370v2 | SimpleSafetyTests: a Test Suite for Identifying Critical Safety Risks in Large Language Models | 2023-11-14T18:33:43 | 2024-02-16T09:42:19 | Bertie Vidgen, Nino Scherrer, Hannah Rose Kirk, Rebecca Qian, Anand Kannappan, Scott A. Hale, Paul Röttger | cs.CL | cs.CL | The past year has seen rapid acceleration in the development of large
language models (LLMs). However, without proper steering and safeguards, LLMs
will readily follow malicious instructions, provide unsafe advice, and generate
toxic content. We introduce SimpleSafetyTests (SST) as a new test suite for
rapidly and systematically identifying such critical safety risks. The test
suite comprises 100 test prompts across five harm areas that LLMs, for the vast
majority of applications, should refuse to comply with. We test 11 open-access
and open-source LLMs and four closed-source LLMs, and find critical safety
weaknesses. While some of the models do not give a single unsafe response, most
give unsafe responses to more than 20% of the prompts, with over 50% unsafe
responses in the extreme. Prepending a safety-emphasising system prompt
substantially reduces the occurrence of unsafe responses, but does not
completely stop them from happening. Trained annotators labelled every model
response to SST (n = 3,000). We use these annotations to evaluate five AI
safety filters (which assess whether a models' response is unsafe given a
prompt) as a way of automatically evaluating models' performance on SST. The
filters' performance varies considerably. There are also differences across the
five harm areas, and on the unsafe versus safe responses. The widely-used
Perspective API has 72% accuracy and a newly-created zero-shot prompt to
OpenAI's GPT-4 performs best with 89% accuracy. Content Warning: This paper
contains prompts and responses that relate to child abuse, suicide, self-harm
and eating disorders, scams and fraud, illegal items, and physical harm. | [
0.0337678343,
0.0276324227,
-0.031456057,
0.0189415589,
-0.0027627812,
0.0237646122,
0.0206720959,
0.0178191811,
0.0770964846,
-0.0496936217,
-0.0090798447,
-0.0386823155,
-0.0327485614,
0.0533892214,
0.0054788636,
-0.0279644672,
0.0607574731,
-0.0309739038,
0.048370339,
0.0091013797,
0.0252696089,
0.0290662795,
0.0038051687,
0.0804304928,
-0.0139131434,
-0.0192021262,
0.0201462135,
-0.0052969093,
0.0349779651,
-0.0741285756,
0.0291218683,
0.0414974242,
-0.0062380652,
0.0369257517,
0.0000021343,
-0.0490202531,
0.0266494621,
0.0001464506,
-0.0125133758,
-0.0113029759,
0.0551007092,
-0.0330510773,
-0.0262345802,
0.0475091971,
-0.0288481731,
0.0050517796,
0.0716286898,
0.0548949204,
0.0766872317,
0.0680778697,
-0.026216859,
0.0111527629,
0.0537427217,
0.0030028857,
-0.0166231263,
-0.0287250839,
0.0618817061,
-0.0246297196,
-0.0039812722,
0.0052193371,
0.000309553,
0.0268989913,
0.0231206883,
-0.0243013483,
-0.041372668,
0.0030458446,
-0.0414560214,
-0.0695918053,
-0.0010626036,
0.075331971,
-0.0342922918,
-0.0103110978,
0.0026124015,
-0.0326968282,
-0.0032102773,
-0.022679247,
-0.0063901795,
0.0470517687,
0.0023869805,
0.0029291925,
0.0246751495,
0.0287091769,
0.0391483232,
0.0434573255,
0.0557286926,
0.0553683266,
-0.0007158024,
-0.0171203762,
0.0413875617,
-0.0192403253,
0.0028805628,
-0.0611219928,
0.0052197957,
0.0013203677,
-0.0393866785,
0.0162235387,
-0.0491744652,
-0.0221497659,
0.0688339546,
-0.0909604952,
0.0367849842,
0.0219383612,
-0.0461628623,
0.0028775188,
0.0054307682,
0.0116904872,
0.0029873189,
0.0525887944,
-0.0194288716,
0.0450088196,
0.0225936044,
0.0022140355,
-0.016439857,
0.0016656339,
-0.0031340681,
0.0203210488,
-0.0564462319,
0.0184153263,
-0.0684862137,
-0.0004107695,
-0.00520973,
0.0082226861,
-0.0150880795,
0.0128182508,
-0.000531024,
-0.0224824008,
-0.0389073603,
0.0077235652,
0.0069071082,
-0.0405313522,
0.0139139863,
0.0239967704,
-0.0347652808,
-0.0172529332,
-0.0006440692,
0.0991224572,
0.0240901094,
-0.0176743995,
-0.066922307,
-0.039999608,
-0.0525887161,
-0.0380753577,
-0.013854485,
-0.0224740356,
-0.0235607829,
-0.0160421487,
-0.0166883916,
-0.0787778199,
0.0372767039,
0.0112523194,
-0.0536699519,
0.0455082096,
0.0052221147,
-0.0108051049,
0.0049478034,
0.053899955,
-0.0256983209,
0.0651004612,
0.0225767028,
0.0560185052,
0.0391548648,
-0.0131271947,
0.0233630724,
0.0420523286,
0.0044874721,
0.0414012782,
-0.0345823802,
-0.0023501029,
-0.0207635351,
-0.0203602016,
-0.0392221808,
0.0726538599,
-0.003371669,
-0.011428331,
0.0722638294,
0.0255345143,
-0.0407788008,
0.0223236009,
0.0410236679,
0.0057689147,
-0.0190850925,
-0.0268468317,
-0.0772514865,
-0.0064325342,
-0.0495411307,
-0.0316423364,
-0.0063681509,
0.0219118129,
-0.0125106219,
-0.0256295186,
-0.0381606109,
-0.0121258814,
0.0335822701,
0.0146349026,
0.0016091675,
0.0148755303,
-0.0292542279,
0.0121095786,
0.0488466881,
-0.0479237773,
-0.0363084786,
-0.0531190597,
0.0406805649,
0.0934346691,
0.0385100171,
-0.0129761836,
-0.0324822962,
-0.0479837023,
-0.000596791,
0.008896661,
0.0122605357,
-0.0021184981,
0.021490559,
-0.0306438748,
-0.0230554845,
0.042949792,
0.017861601,
-0.0216537062,
0.0367002599,
0.0158643853,
0.0232691094,
0.0256591346,
-0.0682544112,
0.0511589833,
-0.0102040945,
-0.0489634387,
-0.0111356098,
0.0207862835,
0.0407338329,
-0.0164296329,
-0.0012044254,
-0.0165665578,
0.0162096806,
0.0022990843,
-0.0115955919,
-0.0316670313,
-0.0374267586,
0.0446421802,
0.0255535282,
-0.0143486718,
-0.0140698673,
0.0637815595,
-0.0310396254,
0.0078526167,
-0.0192576237,
-0.0272135641,
-0.0279621165,
-0.028448727,
-0.0026654622,
-0.0142777599,
-0.0112152873,
-0.010462407,
0.050812602,
-0.0223629121,
-0.0129397912,
-0.0145604163,
-0.0426042378,
-0.0026280815,
-0.0163876843,
-0.0659273416,
-0.0173499901,
-0.0450319909,
0.0389793664,
0.0137526607,
0.0495558009,
-0.0223478619,
0.0023767147,
-0.0817920268,
-0.0080337543,
-0.0213170312,
-0.0117348982,
0.0058241067,
-0.0147965504,
-0.0271703526,
-0.0036509354,
-0.013197721,
0.0093392218,
0.0042299656,
0.0554960258,
-0.0220823325,
-0.0057964963,
-0.0188135393,
-0.0345612206,
-0.0002751695,
-0.047663644,
0.0305806976,
-0.0038484898,
-0.0402441733,
-0.0205346979,
0.036744725,
-0.0298574902,
0.0213730969,
0.0072211856,
-0.0662164986,
0.0214056503,
0.0109663438,
-0.0063175163,
0.0535799675,
0.0266016461,
0.0429882407,
0.0763351694,
0.0147432806,
-0.0418949462,
0.0101013668,
0.0062843547,
-0.0331204608,
-0.0030091915,
-0.0580309182,
-0.0187143609,
0.0409487225,
0.008582307,
-0.0021140689,
-0.0572078265,
0.0024486512,
-0.0680489391,
-0.0584177002,
-0.0045899814,
-0.0707794949,
-0.0337077379,
0.0267089531,
-0.0054392987,
-0.0485653877,
0.0616203435,
0.0126770092,
0.0259053558,
-0.0019322494,
-0.0287604462,
0.014189112,
0.0626978055,
-0.0158910137,
0.0417369157,
0.0379826948,
-0.0165195167,
-0.0018943424,
-0.0243102554,
0.0103570223,
-0.0250753369,
0.039982792,
-0.0569790676,
-0.0084842769,
0.0112659298,
-0.0596652329,
-0.0756466314,
-0.0835276693,
-0.0359834656,
-0.0276627634,
-0.0170001313,
0.0010874509,
-0.0185170509,
0.0057244496,
0.0120976856,
0.0163090266,
-0.0363572165,
0.0043550446,
-0.0023536349,
-0.0282596815,
0.0909107551,
-0.0717742443,
0.0408385508,
-0.0178092793,
0.0720506012,
0.0774483085,
-0.0167869125,
0.0211622659,
-0.0327863768,
0.0185575895,
0.0068127499,
-0.0002466674,
0.00354199,
0.0757884011,
0.0336971283,
-0.0465582013,
-0.0265290644,
0.0564814247,
0.0248236079,
-0.0303048585,
0.0327061005,
-0.013822672,
0.0215027314,
0.0151342554,
-0.0148141021,
-0.0680731535,
-0.017647244,
0.0085905995,
0.0345562175,
-0.0415320732,
-0.0259748921,
0.031332016,
-0.058066722,
0.0572494753,
0.0110162813,
-0.0594719611,
-0.0056009176,
0.0058848136,
-0.0099596689,
-0.0266869478,
0.0545401983,
-0.0244162176,
-0.0249390379,
-0.0544455908,
0.0073114624,
-0.0230844244,
-0.0395011492,
0.0521678217,
-0.0420324169,
0.0934927315,
0.0412882306,
-0.0020029664,
-0.0323403925,
-0.0175211169,
0.0488732196,
0.0206845906,
-0.0242283028,
-0.0063257911,
0.0506134331,
0.0126072541,
-0.0059429305,
-0.0268670246,
0.0333142541,
-0.0079679629,
-0.0248454455,
0.01581496,
0.0737751871,
-0.017387649,
-0.034362562,
-0.0343339257,
0.0453795195,
0.0481815748,
0.0785531029,
0.0230075698,
-0.0576269031,
0.0054920819,
-0.0342601463,
-0.0084979059,
-0.0016016196,
-0.0673003718,
0.0102151856,
-0.0263053589,
-0.0574315041,
-0.0650162026,
-0.0267337617,
0.0135294078,
-0.0321470983,
0.037471775,
-0.0644636825,
-0.0029127977,
0.0315866843,
0.0020603014,
0.0356420316,
-0.022689512,
0.0296548512,
-0.0373140872,
0.0776300579,
-0.0026690233,
0.0123727759,
-0.0135216014,
0.0619913824,
-0.0397928581,
-0.0644908026,
0.0542548858,
0.0955484286,
0.0226932671,
-0.0368779153,
-0.0387775265,
-0.0590463616,
0.0333363302,
0.0332900286,
-0.0387684852,
-0.0257565938,
0.0517227389,
-0.0374729857,
0.0234097224,
0.026285192,
-0.0364007801,
0.0216730163,
0.0097749606,
0.0188137963,
-0.0555245616,
-0.0289619789,
-0.0000422695,
0.0390047841,
0.0205864478,
-0.038709864,
-0.0174747352,
-0.021100685,
-0.0037179084,
-0.0127694178,
-0.0240280814,
-0.0086868517,
0.0554582588,
0.0479469262,
-0.0185327157,
-0.008594349,
-0.0239277948,
-0.0450706072,
0.0347079821,
-0.025855381,
0.0186408143,
0.0162267331,
0.0698948205,
0.0270236693,
0.0164691545,
-0.0458509848,
0.0452270508,
0.002180414,
0.0221640952,
-0.0125689944,
0.056317322,
-0.0099940943,
0.0135446163,
0.0109979743,
0.0431123264,
-0.0162319541,
-0.0471060388,
-0.0441381186,
0.0190678816,
0.0053676283,
-0.0006706209,
0.0504987314,
-0.0339547209,
0.0023680921,
-0.0366028063,
0.0013147944,
-0.0003602571,
-0.073788099,
0.0074797841,
0.006669397,
-0.0204697289,
-0.0026073023,
0.0648817271,
-0.0136780674,
0.0429099947,
0.0429308154,
-0.0282045435,
-0.0130733354,
-0.0134349875,
0.0340877771,
0.0407565273,
-0.0512574315,
-0.005776328,
-0.0846050456,
-0.0752518624,
-0.0223082155,
-0.0071999822,
-0.006059614,
-0.006077731,
0.007204215,
0.0101946034,
0.0261034314,
-0.0130968029,
-0.0238141622,
-0.0209188387,
0.0015327658,
-0.0113723269,
-0.0560098328,
-6.183678482e-33,
0.0197786428,
-0.0295106843,
-0.0281898286,
0.0010852964,
0.01439445,
-0.0028168829,
-0.0088511091,
0.0397720188,
-0.0182553586,
0.0328685306,
0.0108296694,
0.0194132049,
-0.0034279081,
-0.0008695669,
0.0259584188,
-0.0476586074,
-0.0094095608,
-0.0063552116,
-0.0202279165,
0.0292709898,
0.0325230993,
-0.010077741,
0.0281635895,
-0.1204440594,
0.054099299,
0.0096829841,
-0.0511598848,
0.0091125434,
-0.0487247594,
0.0710278526,
0.000201045,
0.0740934834,
0.0181977842,
-0.0278983563,
0.0213274509,
0.0325708054,
-0.0082231574,
-0.0344076119,
0.0268424507,
-0.0479832701,
-0.0432298668,
-0.0599117912,
0.036167603,
-0.0150074726,
-0.0173326284,
-0.0121841114,
0.0103539117,
-0.0171371084,
0.0045874859,
-0.0151658775,
-0.0526883043,
-0.0079820594,
-0.0029885969,
-0.0382856056,
-0.00401753,
0.0727789253,
-0.0027988476,
0.0045503648,
-0.0136340344,
-0.0151531594,
0.0358099304,
-0.0102545647,
0.031707298,
-0.0350021012,
-0.0515753552,
0.0653562024,
-0.0368182361,
0.0101371575,
-0.0091082808,
-0.0388693213,
0.0250452477,
0.0643746853,
0.0565401837,
0.044519268,
-0.0138830561,
-0.0303887837,
-0.0677853078,
0.0156791769,
-0.0014332214,
0.0488295443,
0.0243904218,
-0.0326859094,
-0.0828537866,
-0.0211145803,
-0.0234864559,
-0.0053982311,
-0.040729627,
-0.0254386365,
0.0472178794,
-0.0144429812,
-0.0316844508,
-0.0011804034,
-0.0191513151,
-0.0477511883,
0.0336126275,
0.000118628,
0.0270772036,
-0.0126260929,
0.0114887832,
0.0419531539,
-0.0183130875,
-0.00148548,
0.0111874519,
-0.0513425693,
0.0407441556,
0.0047759921,
0.0704468638,
0.0344833918,
-0.057990849,
0.0001575068,
-0.0034077477,
0.0723126531,
0.0230568014,
0.0506684296,
0.0073641534,
0.0224081464,
0.0118977455,
0.0258548483,
0.0579484105,
0.0310123432,
-0.0423247069,
-0.0121384468,
-0.0226261094,
0.0126128504,
-0.0088212974,
-0.0070897136,
-0.0274708271,
0.0425978974,
0.0498918407,
-0.0755366534,
-0.0040154029,
0.0109085068,
2.793e-7,
0.0288411789,
0.0620257109,
-0.0157677289,
0.0526695848,
-0.0077573215,
0.0671331808,
0.0160144102,
0.0566123091,
0.029178435,
-0.0089562647,
0.017019134,
0.0097899931,
0.0672039166,
0.0718409643,
-0.0502405688,
0.004935367,
-0.0863259882,
0.0042502526,
-0.0635702759,
0.0046648341,
0.0603423417,
0.0781744644,
0.0170908906,
-0.028801728,
0.0177486185,
-0.0314596295,
0.0127453245,
-0.0551332757,
0.0186940115,
-0.006276268,
0.0368126035,
0.0352014005,
0.0206038207,
0.0261638947,
-0.0226248521,
-0.033563111,
-0.0228498057,
0.0759104192,
-0.0322708935,
-0.0289436504,
0.0040810145,
-0.0312549733,
0.0191058014,
-0.0767953172,
0.0628672689,
-0.0210562218,
0.0089779031,
-0.0229626019,
0.004866017,
-0.0121843545,
0.040745914,
-0.0518158935,
-0.0307614692,
0.0132664163,
0.0216090083,
-0.0062825391,
0.0049652178,
-0.0312230382,
-0.0234743971,
-0.0147962645,
0.0184683222,
-0.0628845543,
-0.014930483,
0.0221741479,
-0.0282743461,
-0.0896838903,
0.038620647,
2.594914341e-34,
0.0169623625,
-0.0405793488,
0.0175708085,
-0.0019886578,
0.0374191701,
0.0573775843,
-0.0057242503,
0.0139193535,
-0.0192325953,
-0.0245075133,
-0.0117186839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08369v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08369v3 | How You Prompt Matters! Even Task-Oriented Constraints in Instructions Affect LLM-Generated Text Detection | 2023-11-14T18:32:52 | 2024-06-12T06:30:39 | Ryuto Koike, Masahiro Kaneko, Naoaki Okazaki | cs.CL | cs.CL | To combat the misuse of Large Language Models (LLMs), many recent studies
have presented LLM-generated-text detectors with promising performance. When
users instruct LLMs to generate texts, the instruction can include different
constraints depending on the user's need. However, most recent studies do not
cover such diverse instruction patterns when creating datasets for LLM
detection. In this paper, we reveal that even task-oriented constraints --
constraints that would naturally be included in an instruction and are not
related to detection-evasion -- cause existing powerful detectors to have a
large variance in detection performance. We focus on student essay writing as a
realistic domain and manually create task-oriented constraints based on several
factors for essay quality. Our experiments show that the standard deviation
(SD) of current detector performance on texts generated by an instruction with
such a constraint is significantly larger (up to an SD of 14.4 F1-score) than
that by generating texts multiple times or paraphrasing the instruction. We
also observe an overall trend where the constraints can make LLM detection more
challenging than without them. Finally, our analysis indicates that the high
instruction-following ability of LLMs fosters the large impact of such
constraints on detection performance. | [
0.0486833528,
0.0113426233,
-0.0088986624,
0.045852039,
-0.0378718935,
-0.0065808725,
0.040486183,
0.04581099,
0.0307402164,
-0.0666386113,
-0.0062493472,
-0.0377805755,
-0.0230713636,
0.0015456568,
0.0238781348,
0.0208742768,
0.0373226739,
-0.048072286,
-0.0123968432,
0.0310802255,
0.0246159006,
-0.0025115139,
0.0036991485,
0.0287301224,
-0.0085613793,
-0.0196669772,
0.0099969655,
0.0284643136,
-0.0086995373,
-0.0168983378,
0.0192020629,
0.0694136843,
-0.0115308696,
0.0409150571,
0.0000019444,
-0.0569525138,
-0.0150877731,
-0.0412870012,
-0.0295627117,
0.0575466007,
0.0653581619,
-0.0188294519,
-0.0345505588,
0.0277362373,
-0.0134539995,
0.0378455408,
0.0122509617,
0.0524762869,
0.0270441137,
0.0999071896,
-0.0154486382,
0.0459828898,
0.0371412672,
-0.0053740288,
0.0266959593,
0.0130307572,
0.0328372419,
-0.0473630317,
0.0142002543,
0.0471397899,
0.0031347317,
0.0156257339,
0.0090425285,
-0.0448120572,
-0.0242774729,
0.0203627832,
-0.0137807801,
-0.0098211803,
-0.0307035279,
0.0234804768,
-0.00822578,
-0.0214890558,
0.040157035,
-0.0305811949,
0.005651929,
0.031625621,
-0.023652574,
0.0369155705,
-0.045830179,
0.0034595437,
0.0316581763,
-0.008300148,
0.006752721,
0.0194277149,
0.025253851,
0.018461898,
0.0130192544,
-0.0685472637,
-0.0019842524,
0.0275784116,
-0.0176689886,
-0.0588804558,
0.0605286211,
0.0170584247,
-0.0284323152,
0.0071992017,
-0.0866041705,
-0.0492973924,
0.047492709,
-0.0216513369,
0.0815394148,
0.0378263406,
-0.0025276428,
0.0168979038,
-0.0647362098,
0.1028039753,
-0.0429834612,
0.0182782467,
-0.0201962832,
0.0534495562,
-0.012086845,
-0.0213237293,
-0.0265337788,
0.0070012859,
-0.0076895515,
-0.021409167,
-0.0419467539,
0.0543370508,
0.0221408475,
0.0143271927,
-0.044235494,
-0.0475518443,
-0.020268729,
0.0111055691,
0.0155114764,
-0.0027259002,
0.0018784315,
0.0119484542,
0.0105289044,
-0.0414993055,
-0.0175189432,
0.057380762,
0.0220731087,
-0.0249322765,
0.0069744764,
0.019062046,
-0.0129746171,
-0.0398197174,
-0.0428908281,
-0.048973795,
-0.0385808833,
-0.0226724483,
0.0031744728,
-0.0679423958,
-0.0245033596,
0.0065666526,
0.005582002,
-0.0262653399,
0.0225929469,
0.0508291088,
0.0145800561,
0.0189751983,
0.025312705,
0.0003130558,
0.0083195874,
0.0059887432,
-0.0094343387,
0.0629370809,
0.0196950305,
0.0724952668,
0.0371914469,
-0.0112717394,
0.0468592495,
0.0772078484,
-0.0142066535,
0.0393841006,
0.0299306475,
-0.0426222347,
0.012667424,
0.014073642,
0.04542128,
0.0524281077,
-0.0010516524,
0.0318154991,
0.0920061395,
0.08275076,
-0.0008883869,
-0.0234080292,
0.0356447659,
0.0390300825,
-0.0041190395,
0.073390834,
-0.014924176,
-0.0289711542,
-0.0202740207,
0.0011836404,
0.0076871128,
-0.0009097648,
0.0146644637,
-0.0439157486,
-0.0414568372,
-0.0095735677,
-0.0412630923,
-0.0045776688,
0.0348012224,
0.0079568634,
-0.060581211,
0.0184984077,
-0.0068613496,
-0.073720634,
0.0176367257,
-0.0622286759,
0.0314037353,
0.0753291994,
0.0604498908,
-0.0238888394,
0.0380989313,
-0.0184318889,
0.0644964129,
0.0706144348,
0.0429812185,
0.0182267409,
0.0004127173,
-0.0520445667,
-0.0220204014,
-0.0259255413,
0.0148277329,
-0.0100025944,
0.0319784954,
-0.0055123409,
0.0250723474,
0.0121287275,
-0.0757816806,
0.0616169758,
-0.0267953966,
-0.0511739887,
-0.0249225516,
0.0160036702,
-0.0206935704,
0.0048629059,
-0.0142228911,
0.016122818,
0.0113334786,
-0.0504145138,
0.0147121055,
-0.0612336993,
-0.0567023046,
-0.0066318861,
0.0060725734,
-0.039912682,
-0.0076296213,
0.0236017872,
0.0198699143,
-0.0259818453,
-0.0431559794,
-0.0519052558,
0.01295962,
-0.0205835756,
0.0347378887,
-0.0047633634,
0.0003566229,
-0.0414420068,
0.0353970677,
-0.0099813668,
0.0295913033,
0.0514002852,
0.0029026587,
0.0254340768,
-0.0377438553,
-0.0103002246,
-0.041430369,
-0.001056,
0.0092531638,
0.032256715,
0.0396554321,
-0.0314466245,
-0.0722594038,
-0.063287966,
0.037074279,
-0.0267239716,
0.0097028119,
0.0345751606,
-0.0210993867,
-0.0352671966,
0.0110895531,
-0.0112431468,
-0.0550544634,
0.01068334,
0.0144191822,
0.0429985076,
-0.0267319381,
0.0044423225,
-0.0223631561,
-0.0046554483,
-0.0333737507,
0.0108637149,
0.0502744876,
-0.0573526733,
-0.0771211535,
0.1105292067,
0.0477152392,
-0.0082117217,
0.0026817604,
-0.0288529415,
0.0113735273,
-0.0169601347,
0.0811145157,
0.1040796191,
-0.0195117947,
0.0082577672,
0.059731409,
0.0016162699,
-0.0467716865,
-0.0076213866,
0.0137150809,
0.0106102573,
-0.0198649615,
-0.0773054957,
0.0563836358,
0.0482961051,
0.0300330203,
-0.001282393,
-0.0227664858,
0.0005852158,
-0.0528546572,
-0.023072809,
0.0011139011,
-0.0371073671,
-0.0649571419,
0.0222391523,
-0.03731535,
-0.0661672503,
0.0306431055,
-0.0434604697,
0.000542151,
-0.0150184939,
-0.0066247717,
-0.0214159042,
0.0149466628,
0.0176857542,
0.0029085332,
0.0320543386,
-0.0297526419,
-0.039902702,
0.04682431,
0.0356821455,
-0.0273372047,
0.0546928458,
-0.0357509814,
-0.0146915419,
-0.0340027846,
-0.0170022529,
-0.0455800742,
-0.0636569262,
0.0256556999,
-0.0234200582,
0.0388795584,
-0.0197450556,
-0.0038314185,
-0.0174483601,
0.0151714571,
0.0688091367,
-0.0476674736,
-0.009808477,
-0.0553521849,
0.0275012944,
0.050482139,
-0.051134795,
-0.0223937538,
-0.0708697289,
0.0394399874,
0.059500996,
-0.0081054866,
0.0117291473,
0.0195646025,
-0.0002778606,
0.034930829,
-0.0145098763,
-0.0291801523,
0.0327328183,
0.0881890729,
-0.068315424,
-0.0223667063,
0.0941797569,
0.0235876702,
-0.0370445959,
-0.0289256386,
-0.0155145675,
0.0383016281,
0.0117388731,
0.003146017,
-0.0578791089,
-0.0335385688,
0.0295321792,
0.0524667613,
-0.0399501808,
-0.0042917365,
-0.0247055925,
-0.0756239593,
0.0170846749,
0.0025592255,
0.0151625117,
-0.0189962722,
-0.016260026,
-0.0071322713,
0.0186877046,
0.0168138128,
-0.0311756097,
-0.0367989279,
0.0043218005,
0.0280761588,
-0.0256272908,
-0.0232732464,
-0.0399415791,
-0.0478645079,
0.009199121,
0.0479039662,
0.011774472,
-0.0081883511,
-0.0269501396,
0.0477894731,
-0.0140872849,
0.0103532616,
-0.014841239,
0.0488759875,
0.0007455198,
0.0138678607,
-0.0423505716,
0.0356338136,
-0.0244985055,
-0.0087738317,
0.0518296808,
0.0517033339,
-0.0211561341,
-0.0268261768,
-0.0154956812,
-0.0029466448,
0.0192663819,
0.0923612118,
0.055216141,
-0.0678357333,
-0.0472692214,
-0.0521416254,
0.0020691864,
-0.1069708914,
-0.026254829,
-0.0062003578,
-0.0515455119,
0.010337959,
-0.0606443249,
-0.0336852409,
0.0017067267,
0.018750133,
0.0310092978,
0.0217340011,
-0.0188031178,
-0.0361360647,
-0.029206574,
0.012450601,
-0.0280860532,
0.0200784206,
-0.08161515,
-0.0158679876,
-0.0260610655,
-0.0084905382,
0.017240081,
0.0367617086,
-0.1093825102,
-0.0588268936,
0.0086471979,
0.0095937289,
0.0191455055,
-0.0080952384,
0.0091860946,
-0.0573577248,
0.0256652664,
0.0202657245,
-0.0227845237,
0.0313727222,
0.0189172775,
-0.0385913178,
-0.0156436022,
0.0012214981,
-0.021260757,
0.0013004873,
0.0514545441,
0.0117190257,
-0.0348710492,
-0.0229611937,
0.0218525771,
0.0284568947,
0.0370290428,
-0.0284586437,
0.0036495531,
-0.0343577936,
-0.0010036352,
-0.0153660011,
-0.0104891611,
-0.0256271604,
0.0123151764,
0.0250426754,
-0.0167749338,
-0.0016989353,
0.0429555289,
-0.0341697223,
0.0431953855,
-0.0569814555,
0.0498972312,
-0.0124389026,
0.0390731469,
0.0346211866,
-0.0121891508,
-0.0126860784,
0.0755636618,
-0.0109048942,
0.0235746466,
0.024033254,
0.0635240898,
0.0024759255,
-0.0071789278,
0.0298365317,
0.035922192,
-0.0661738887,
0.0182588808,
-0.0148707461,
0.0044163433,
0.0393289179,
-0.0237296671,
0.0615612566,
-0.0423395671,
0.0055938247,
-0.0368804522,
0.0411342569,
0.0384333953,
-0.021430105,
-0.0093655773,
0.0110397302,
0.0072168526,
-0.0266470164,
0.0765816495,
0.0187406484,
0.0134432549,
0.0129244905,
-0.0297493618,
-0.0366743132,
-0.0144444499,
0.0495212078,
-0.0031241842,
-0.0172245372,
0.0027000222,
-0.0507823564,
-0.0233915988,
0.0091423392,
0.0054495903,
0.0138758309,
-0.0336182043,
-0.0229311977,
0.0341611765,
-0.0330767259,
-0.0260033682,
-0.0394157469,
0.0204340313,
0.0085790483,
-0.0224398132,
-0.0339482203,
-5.683351719e-33,
-0.0300577823,
-0.0628494173,
-0.026065819,
0.0191059355,
0.0099858297,
0.0428042822,
-0.0365292951,
-0.0005526092,
0.0535991862,
-0.0113934483,
-0.0212118737,
0.0162479188,
0.0178465135,
0.0173566081,
-0.0012928311,
0.0125960847,
0.0512930788,
-0.0078442199,
-0.0680507272,
0.0004288836,
0.0395230241,
-0.0000128735,
0.0227979384,
-0.0149915218,
0.0469537377,
-0.0481204949,
-0.0065827197,
-0.0254210569,
-0.0297062173,
0.0802242383,
-0.0182766318,
0.0602275692,
0.0343530402,
-0.0242722686,
-0.036583297,
0.0948691145,
-0.02826575,
-0.0314535797,
0.0046092337,
0.0049967994,
-0.0073256781,
-0.0956216007,
0.0449685864,
-0.0205934141,
-0.0327064358,
0.0171246678,
0.0416009724,
-0.0198198445,
-0.0148985116,
-0.0403669402,
-0.0638961568,
0.0222204477,
0.0209570937,
-0.017358765,
0.0134864207,
0.0528947003,
0.0170770846,
-0.0210954677,
-0.0086486312,
0.0396920294,
0.0318818092,
0.0672776103,
0.0170369595,
0.0414560512,
-0.0451224595,
0.0399027988,
0.0027035321,
0.0365589596,
-0.0044654859,
-0.0363450088,
0.0241468959,
-0.0275605507,
0.0612008907,
0.0577294007,
0.0396398082,
-0.0117978388,
-0.0355778709,
0.0216065459,
0.0255888384,
-0.0179753937,
0.046917133,
-0.0274475794,
-0.0637362674,
-0.0381054282,
-0.0029675569,
0.0001203523,
-0.0197843779,
0.0002152015,
0.073666811,
0.0275332518,
-0.0016287316,
-0.0286899861,
0.023356555,
-0.0179842282,
-0.0210502092,
-0.0035089648,
-0.0234077182,
0.0145947943,
-0.0248264819,
-0.0024382384,
-0.043822147,
-0.0137599222,
0.0414475128,
-0.0116931014,
0.0337645859,
0.0149203613,
0.0424158983,
0.0111897141,
-0.0766379163,
0.004980363,
-0.0426949561,
0.0308009796,
0.0249422882,
-0.0016409116,
0.0462882482,
-0.0580444634,
0.0078767855,
0.036401052,
0.0279631615,
-0.0369714759,
-0.072611928,
-0.0173616745,
-0.0188025776,
0.0231162254,
-0.0344514176,
0.0048707752,
-0.0261014905,
0.0418520682,
0.0070309015,
-0.0481897928,
0.0076482701,
-0.0332347639,
2.486e-7,
0.0283361245,
0.0418242216,
0.0092388792,
0.0277882461,
-0.002001564,
0.0278841667,
-0.0354317464,
0.0085620517,
0.0005920734,
0.0219790582,
-0.0113802794,
0.0027452135,
0.0637340173,
-0.0038691184,
-0.0918080285,
0.0222013257,
-0.0138881467,
0.03913109,
-0.0687059239,
0.0114937639,
0.0888071507,
0.0244482625,
-0.014777638,
-0.0141394073,
0.0021502532,
-0.0911144316,
0.0418244712,
-0.038481839,
0.0159766022,
0.0144235156,
0.0552356243,
-0.0129215429,
-0.0013642393,
0.035857223,
-0.0182151292,
-0.025854297,
0.0145667912,
0.0871537551,
0.0348863639,
0.0089926524,
0.0148718357,
-0.0302683581,
-0.0127114514,
-0.0451221615,
0.0554173253,
0.0166363325,
0.0388067178,
-0.0219253004,
0.0166268945,
-0.0549886189,
-0.0262298118,
-0.0110817058,
-0.0101843849,
-0.0056281728,
0.0122076916,
-0.0203284174,
-0.0093858438,
-0.0406198427,
-0.0392635241,
-0.0175591186,
-0.0109108724,
-0.0497757271,
-0.0701925308,
0.0225146301,
0.0002391301,
-0.0887575895,
-0.0070555275,
2.896058315e-34,
0.0024748929,
-0.0247310288,
0.0422431193,
0.0171487238,
0.0155331381,
0.0255423654,
-0.0265607946,
0.0187111534,
0.0197163802,
-0.0522975847,
-0.0123162288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08360v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08360v3 | The Transient Nature of Emergent In-Context Learning in Transformers | 2023-11-14T18:03:20 | 2023-12-11T21:42:31 | Aaditya K. Singh, Stephanie C. Y. Chan, Ted Moskovitz, Erin Grant, Andrew M. Saxe, Felix Hill | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Transformer neural networks can exhibit a surprising capacity for in-context
learning (ICL) despite not being explicitly trained for it. Prior work has
provided a deeper understanding of how ICL emerges in transformers, e.g.
through the lens of mechanistic interpretability, Bayesian inference, or by
examining the distributional properties of training data. However, in each of
these cases, ICL is treated largely as a persistent phenomenon; namely, once
ICL emerges, it is assumed to persist asymptotically. Here, we show that the
emergence of ICL during transformer training is, in fact, often transient. We
train transformers on synthetic data designed so that both ICL and in-weights
learning (IWL) strategies can lead to correct predictions. We find that ICL
first emerges, then disappears and gives way to IWL, all while the training
loss decreases, indicating an asymptotic preference for IWL. The transient
nature of ICL is observed in transformers across a range of model sizes and
datasets, raising the question of how much to "overtrain" transformers when
seeking compact, cheaper-to-run models. We find that L2 regularization may
offer a path to more persistent ICL that removes the need for early stopping
based on ICL-style validation tasks. Finally, we present initial evidence that
ICL transience may be caused by competition between ICL and IWL circuits. | [
-0.0612807125,
0.0633321777,
0.0099310633,
0.0149420965,
0.0256891996,
0.0023845385,
0.0250056051,
0.0042584604,
-0.0511580408,
0.0453401096,
-0.0417582132,
-0.0090103364,
0.0120692858,
-0.0118137775,
0.0325545669,
-0.0168527011,
0.01211139,
0.0084452033,
-0.0836504847,
-0.0284009073,
-0.0198451336,
-0.0451599285,
0.0210529659,
0.0447118804,
-0.0218311474,
-0.0148227392,
0.0046327482,
-0.0066835047,
0.0163473636,
-0.0234517399,
0.0270448402,
0.0008966372,
0.0065139532,
0.0474116169,
0.0000022434,
-0.008835271,
-0.0188270137,
-0.0104895141,
-0.0528520867,
-0.0222126786,
-0.0167459715,
-0.0463028699,
-0.0108042965,
-0.0203965437,
-0.0227604862,
-0.0028397904,
0.0791946873,
0.0896074101,
0.0238447171,
0.0538391396,
-0.0110291103,
-0.0175625999,
0.0261808448,
-0.0382475071,
-0.0076222089,
-0.0040522665,
-0.020786399,
-0.0651579574,
-0.0587942936,
-0.0669187829,
-0.04011501,
0.0086931912,
0.0565315522,
0.0397783741,
0.0103103993,
0.0649884641,
-0.01983748,
0.0062648966,
-0.0119446358,
0.0008402802,
-0.065181084,
-0.0574310161,
-0.0372121558,
-0.0092613902,
0.0002349312,
-0.0189223904,
-0.0432986058,
0.0212740041,
-0.0032228432,
0.0402822122,
-0.0451566726,
0.0286256187,
0.0630209222,
-0.0436170958,
-0.0337779932,
0.0473107845,
-0.0002220145,
-0.0344303846,
0.0125309471,
0.0144824451,
-0.0321035907,
0.0007835557,
-0.0179089159,
0.011899299,
-0.0110729979,
0.0134262405,
-0.0241143536,
0.0054834783,
-0.0301586837,
-0.0127310008,
0.0394853428,
0.0107327411,
-0.0172778796,
-0.0159355402,
-0.0282291844,
0.039081648,
-0.0534832403,
0.0489455536,
-0.0228494518,
0.0226954203,
-0.0393506624,
-0.0115756532,
-0.0325515792,
-0.0079352623,
0.0323001668,
0.0053909966,
-0.0349252038,
0.0388415456,
-0.0346319079,
-0.0075825765,
-0.0155730816,
0.0363551565,
-0.0572986528,
0.0010799232,
-0.0143020945,
0.0646153912,
0.0272581391,
0.0177048501,
0.0173121467,
-0.0280838702,
-0.0387748368,
-0.000867894,
0.0235577542,
0.0077034743,
0.0478311442,
0.067908667,
-0.0228848606,
-0.0363930017,
-0.0600014143,
0.0165115818,
0.0052784677,
-0.0225194152,
0.0238111857,
-0.0306665059,
-0.0104413265,
0.0156904962,
0.027212264,
-0.0347835831,
0.0031628162,
0.029977588,
0.0230257772,
0.0872187242,
0.0031899316,
-0.0589658283,
0.0096031753,
-0.0069086198,
-0.0113605158,
0.0200745929,
0.0098639037,
0.0105776284,
-0.0135415737,
-0.0193901751,
0.0203169789,
0.0435120165,
0.0261910371,
-0.0014039173,
-0.0155744869,
-0.0553948767,
0.0021055383,
0.0089033535,
0.0271752384,
0.0087010544,
-0.0378625281,
0.017166961,
0.0725284517,
0.016878169,
0.0372369587,
0.0377894528,
0.0033631648,
-0.0234377589,
-0.0277458634,
-0.0016647644,
-0.0977653489,
0.0268298015,
-0.0250036772,
-0.0166928824,
-0.0840853602,
0.0092404233,
-0.0382883288,
-0.0573022552,
0.0102406535,
-0.0454226471,
-0.0317409039,
-0.0017005345,
0.0591010712,
0.0362941623,
-0.0551063716,
0.1079958975,
0.0282098968,
0.0125696985,
-0.0265404265,
-0.0516395941,
-0.0180178192,
-0.0334482379,
0.0058830385,
-0.0065931799,
-0.0145723661,
-0.0499585383,
-0.013554425,
0.0345119424,
-0.0341007337,
-0.0060550664,
0.0502071157,
0.0026426779,
-0.0303488877,
-0.0021075993,
0.0108797504,
0.0034283351,
-0.0215458106,
-0.0321478881,
-0.0183874052,
-0.0109050274,
-0.0242215879,
0.0248387158,
-0.0486744642,
-0.0371756181,
0.0360423028,
0.0079294974,
0.0202098936,
-0.0338574089,
-0.0084384866,
-0.0217671059,
0.0313497856,
-0.0364269316,
-0.0303264577,
0.0437829867,
-0.0986572579,
0.0272722598,
0.0253567081,
-0.0448317863,
0.0227303896,
0.0242239702,
0.0109733148,
-0.0188817345,
-0.0188994221,
-0.0436403714,
0.075992316,
-0.0024292008,
0.0073484387,
-0.0221931227,
0.0143472236,
-0.0433728136,
0.0403747298,
-0.0066263918,
-0.0326326564,
0.0105760731,
-0.0060279784,
0.0154507617,
0.0229266547,
-0.0205508526,
-0.0056400602,
-0.0481633432,
-0.0009764235,
0.0149349831,
-0.015786564,
0.004178314,
0.0072309617,
-0.0491300151,
-0.0161502101,
-0.0317914151,
-0.0183774866,
-0.0140255876,
-0.0214680582,
0.0151776019,
0.0203752946,
-0.0040207505,
-0.0094109951,
0.0079845181,
-0.0016110911,
0.0239311699,
0.0128370989,
-0.020133622,
0.0020476035,
-0.0332494006,
0.011935195,
0.0871106386,
0.0330702551,
0.0163528156,
-0.0519394465,
0.0092693642,
0.0528872497,
0.0175337158,
-0.0301445611,
-0.0149756297,
0.0070451451,
-0.0020266694,
0.0363188758,
0.0727828443,
0.0245939754,
0.0300894231,
0.0313511752,
0.0318924263,
-0.0308100246,
0.0128867608,
-0.0550756678,
-0.0403596535,
-0.0798663199,
0.0033953423,
0.0200594552,
0.0759059563,
-0.0323313214,
0.0161018893,
-0.031020619,
0.0164243076,
0.0109602241,
-0.0288686994,
0.0006035047,
-0.0194014199,
-0.0270127673,
0.0454314016,
0.0138938855,
-0.0449587032,
0.0347869433,
0.025764456,
0.0016730594,
-0.024132859,
-0.03246288,
0.0036299569,
0.0118488139,
0.0094816191,
0.0255878903,
0.0494100414,
0.0242050122,
-0.0621325001,
0.0298859421,
0.0189766735,
0.0236222241,
0.0583037697,
0.0061616078,
-0.0235088132,
-0.0083721671,
-0.0442361906,
-0.068337284,
-0.0010903571,
-0.0021281072,
0.0111463163,
0.0288307779,
-0.0398333892,
-0.0363250077,
-0.0126691116,
0.0145877665,
0.0440809913,
-0.0007686885,
-0.058437869,
-0.0098208291,
0.0219190344,
-0.0148213916,
0.0295837987,
0.0956654847,
-0.0696233362,
0.036291182,
0.0189586934,
0.0425585397,
-0.0181633495,
-0.0896127671,
0.0164974295,
0.0176369157,
-0.0048786392,
0.0059070708,
0.0323244408,
0.0272040442,
-0.0571806394,
-0.0513061248,
0.0435879119,
-0.0163679868,
-0.0936234593,
0.0159120355,
0.0073100957,
0.0204644781,
0.0329659618,
0.0377533212,
-0.0363715738,
-0.0140512884,
0.0084886001,
0.0386474393,
-0.0182472691,
0.0057286848,
0.0116305705,
-0.0479660854,
0.0461800136,
-0.0095544774,
-0.0331568643,
-0.032632187,
-0.0091429604,
-0.0492796674,
-0.0524632484,
0.0290454943,
-0.0036081586,
-0.0573884919,
-0.0358291119,
0.0568136089,
0.004402136,
-0.0475051142,
0.011709298,
-0.0336484276,
-0.0390545316,
0.0476675592,
-0.0520682894,
-0.0345944352,
-0.0570687577,
0.0720493346,
0.004965202,
0.0193667263,
0.0038887246,
0.0569764934,
0.0367063992,
-0.0312434938,
-0.0221340265,
0.046776142,
-0.0136592127,
-0.0384111553,
-0.0358603299,
0.0476403087,
-0.0212154314,
-0.0405251794,
0.0259174835,
-0.0341502354,
-0.0145571157,
0.0017257482,
-0.0082263211,
-0.0553718843,
-0.0326142386,
-0.0207005553,
0.0368809216,
0.0056188023,
-0.052467946,
0.031555254,
0.035117384,
-0.0825907812,
-0.0176044554,
0.0302774291,
-0.0588031486,
0.0754022598,
0.0146034118,
-0.0865148753,
0.0247768145,
0.0103591951,
-0.058473248,
0.0605099313,
0.0038466079,
0.0066804751,
-0.0700726509,
0.0073788324,
0.039250154,
-0.0687849447,
-0.0322934017,
0.0069128349,
-0.111392796,
-0.0245159622,
0.055689536,
0.0540464707,
0.0183811449,
0.077983588,
0.0189681426,
-0.0076688244,
0.1008406132,
0.0761936903,
0.0022894377,
0.0202045701,
0.0948962197,
-0.0292448048,
-0.017213624,
0.0066653709,
-0.0089701088,
0.0455922894,
0.0520242676,
-0.0281089637,
-0.0370862111,
0.0394158028,
0.0674486607,
-0.0504883751,
0.0637545139,
-0.0095622288,
0.0011403624,
0.007928499,
0.0406143442,
0.0721346289,
0.0027580354,
-0.0124847414,
-0.0666898042,
0.0340985954,
0.0671513155,
0.0057752365,
0.026533315,
0.076566495,
0.0162057672,
-0.0306414627,
0.0170541853,
0.0093132574,
0.0031493988,
0.024760535,
0.0564201511,
0.0184756406,
0.0165102873,
0.0121671734,
0.0415481441,
0.0139522627,
0.0354544446,
0.0434311852,
0.017544521,
-0.0719548389,
-0.0021979436,
-0.0801562294,
-0.0090707727,
-0.0295944661,
-0.0175176151,
0.0474667363,
-0.0336900018,
-0.0013239146,
-0.0333001912,
0.0053834813,
-0.003872751,
-0.0049530282,
-0.0045769392,
-0.0006645165,
0.0149362003,
-0.001932865,
0.0111359935,
-0.018222997,
0.0656075627,
-0.0215956103,
0.0457673557,
-0.0445383154,
0.0344686098,
-0.0359759741,
-0.0129478108,
0.0417222977,
0.0195326693,
0.0005631002,
-0.0425024554,
-0.0386783108,
-0.0299679376,
0.0485180505,
-0.0227378979,
0.0326779336,
-0.0548723862,
0.05217034,
0.0437385142,
-0.0080706282,
-0.0022532076,
0.048179958,
-0.0243934598,
0.0480457433,
0.022853734,
-0.0171277802,
-6.303091075e-33,
0.0135955224,
-0.0201389678,
0.0172927119,
0.0506297126,
0.0198124032,
0.014980793,
-0.0318466425,
-0.0184768122,
-0.0004125451,
0.0132814059,
-0.0256838221,
0.0033198139,
0.0116461534,
0.0351406634,
0.0199849121,
-0.0574031733,
0.0405643284,
0.0131058674,
-0.0001991165,
0.0125169167,
0.0103057912,
0.0313293934,
0.061678037,
-0.0498379096,
-0.030992249,
0.0067195147,
-0.0380794629,
-0.0065568709,
-0.0456631109,
0.0169705264,
-0.0345990844,
0.0450275019,
0.0068253716,
-0.0816639736,
0.0020798785,
-0.0137755377,
-0.0624951161,
0.0258752964,
-0.0696537942,
0.0126520451,
-0.0193023067,
-0.0142511111,
0.0763360336,
-0.0007781131,
-0.073523052,
-0.0426253416,
0.0451774001,
0.0004492654,
-0.0055050957,
-0.0720506236,
-0.027889641,
-0.0006147693,
-0.0089007048,
-0.0298169386,
-0.0231077299,
0.0623393171,
-0.0081479186,
0.0481901132,
-0.0786582232,
0.0090394448,
0.0077471035,
-0.005810305,
0.0435798764,
0.0567608811,
0.0063715652,
0.0424965583,
0.05107769,
0.0218673181,
0.0344271027,
-0.0612937361,
0.0589186065,
0.0383981764,
0.031078767,
-0.016366886,
0.0588624515,
-0.0196957309,
-0.0730357319,
0.011332877,
-0.0145497825,
0.0397208333,
0.0078760041,
0.0147545207,
0.0038601989,
-0.0299308877,
-0.0080369636,
-0.0332907401,
-0.0004476393,
0.0120703401,
-0.0023478267,
0.0380862355,
0.0106676947,
0.0398282818,
0.0198225528,
-0.0451283716,
0.0420421511,
0.0290395617,
0.0146845412,
0.023832975,
0.0136781931,
-0.0099030016,
-0.0381852686,
-0.0090524629,
-0.0394465514,
0.0200530719,
0.0139942644,
0.0077319834,
0.0480638742,
0.0686274692,
-0.020343516,
-0.0118148746,
-0.0598464534,
0.0249181017,
0.0192988142,
0.0202391781,
0.0530865826,
0.0179361124,
-0.0145247756,
0.0105266916,
-0.011491403,
0.0121666342,
-0.0172838941,
0.0718114004,
-0.0110973241,
0.0258244928,
-0.000939251,
-0.0313905291,
-0.0372023806,
0.0361367799,
0.0028931526,
-0.0995769277,
-0.0199049562,
-0.0125922738,
2.981e-7,
-0.0044844085,
0.0366015807,
0.0252456814,
-0.0148833375,
0.0467110984,
0.0304950885,
-0.0225337297,
0.0044215405,
0.0008633554,
0.0347523242,
0.0271051712,
0.0121325972,
0.0291267857,
0.0157837328,
-0.0538772792,
-0.0542513505,
-0.0584368072,
0.0446118563,
-0.0095820809,
0.0123252915,
-0.0198720526,
0.0715408772,
-0.0071709775,
-0.050352376,
0.0489017367,
-0.0091839824,
0.0643706024,
-0.0336914062,
0.0497646704,
0.0220457036,
-0.0366951562,
0.0120627973,
0.0077816388,
0.0153887793,
-0.0087207761,
0.0261181276,
-0.0211877227,
-0.0043189856,
0.0209548213,
-0.0400405973,
0.0156826805,
0.0758168846,
0.016089119,
-0.0262246672,
0.0352303535,
-0.1332677305,
-0.0266189985,
-0.0298384838,
-0.0366109386,
-0.0255397707,
0.013043561,
0.0203086212,
0.0091227479,
0.0046281805,
-0.0275337268,
0.0074055954,
-0.0348210074,
-0.0382630862,
-0.0347329043,
0.0397074968,
-0.0386561975,
-0.0277299415,
-0.055624254,
-0.0180243831,
0.0695558488,
0.0403530151,
-0.0188592933,
2.672907702e-34,
0.0207144637,
-0.0165717676,
0.0077282707,
0.0482223816,
0.012913811,
-0.0317826532,
0.0301144607,
-0.0102789635,
0.0485818088,
-0.0442847945,
0.0100131435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08349v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08349v2 | AI-generated text boundary detection with RoFT | 2023-11-14T17:48:19 | 2024-04-02T18:28:04 | Laida Kushnareva, Tatiana Gaintseva, German Magai, Serguei Barannikov, Dmitry Abulkhanov, Kristian Kuznetsov, Eduard Tulchinskii, Irina Piontkovskaya, Sergey Nikolenko | cs.CL | cs.CL | Due to the rapid development of large language models, people increasingly
often encounter texts that may start as written by a human but continue as
machine-generated. Detecting the boundary between human-written and
machine-generated parts of such texts is a challenging problem that has not
received much attention in literature. We attempt to bridge this gap and
examine several ways to adapt state of the art artificial text detection
classifiers to the boundary detection setting. We push all detectors to their
limits, using the Real or Fake text benchmark that contains short texts on
several topics and includes generations of various language models. We use this
diversity to deeply examine the robustness of all detectors in cross-domain and
cross-model settings to provide baselines and insights for future research. In
particular, we find that perplexity-based approaches to boundary detection tend
to be more robust to peculiarities of domain-specific data than supervised
fine-tuning of the RoBERTa model; we also find which features of the text
confuse boundary detection algorithms and negatively influence their
performance in cross-domain settings. | [
0.0485774986,
0.0137147745,
0.0025278362,
0.0710734278,
-0.0643016249,
-0.0047429311,
-0.0177638382,
0.0418438017,
0.0128814504,
-0.049896393,
-0.0124897501,
-0.0418772735,
-0.013235026,
0.0247166306,
-0.0210212022,
-0.0301248264,
0.0231822636,
-0.0204014704,
-0.0067477892,
0.0241491478,
0.032369338,
0.0039707189,
0.0013927495,
0.0049713776,
-0.0339192823,
-0.0075242543,
0.0014058566,
0.0413217917,
0.0318974964,
-0.0193542577,
0.0199799687,
0.0533718579,
0.0019915861,
0.1145632043,
0.000001697,
-0.0251055714,
-0.0600752495,
-0.0041995985,
0.0309523903,
-0.0222203042,
0.1035755575,
-0.0409798138,
-0.0392079055,
0.0129559785,
-0.0155758597,
0.0045246962,
0.0344469622,
0.0891969353,
0.0222542901,
0.0933448002,
-0.0287264492,
0.0325128362,
0.0369306467,
-0.0084952526,
0.0196550377,
-0.0433815904,
0.0312803462,
-0.0378939211,
-0.0105879083,
-0.0303526781,
-0.0451149829,
0.0013725837,
0.0148213096,
-0.0369485766,
-0.0556201749,
0.0146817509,
-0.0470693149,
-0.0067665377,
-0.021829227,
0.067073971,
-0.0270244312,
-0.0207811184,
0.0389947742,
0.0058114124,
-0.0057937638,
0.0334719978,
0.0202454552,
0.0102015864,
-0.0628243983,
0.0058467551,
-0.0246655494,
0.0149645451,
0.004652245,
0.0304549485,
-0.0349808447,
0.0441310816,
0.0180161577,
-0.0525476485,
0.0162502024,
0.0268206447,
0.011925525,
-0.0209804438,
0.0414313711,
-0.0023937838,
0.0104417987,
0.0043710661,
-0.096320875,
-0.0606625862,
0.0132328216,
0.0369887576,
0.0203913879,
-0.0001406067,
-0.050156571,
0.0335506424,
-0.0358193032,
0.0432760306,
-0.0490514264,
0.0077329241,
-0.0336226448,
0.0074052266,
-0.006879881,
-0.02747114,
-0.044199232,
-0.0125060957,
-0.0174375083,
-0.057941664,
-0.0135472212,
-0.012919982,
-0.0042694644,
0.009737717,
-0.0122874547,
-0.0320820361,
-0.0156376529,
-0.0117512951,
0.0280582663,
0.011134211,
-0.0077140639,
0.0084200492,
0.0008316271,
-0.0529282764,
0.0030891427,
0.0533618443,
0.0207606666,
-0.0136397257,
0.0083379317,
0.0315129831,
-0.0131019652,
-0.0536310226,
0.0011505384,
-0.0655234307,
-0.0446338505,
-0.0789655298,
0.040348012,
-0.0433979146,
-0.0165743344,
-0.0303143226,
0.0123015391,
0.0158989578,
0.0159569904,
0.0280408822,
-0.0015720482,
0.0733116642,
-0.0380477645,
0.0083333664,
0.0347701274,
-0.0021348603,
0.0403585956,
0.0559834018,
-0.0000471776,
0.037835978,
0.0735696629,
0.041726619,
0.0258603562,
0.0555161051,
0.0110883806,
0.007622093,
-0.0200879928,
-0.0149823111,
0.0085998019,
0.0063200719,
0.0331667028,
0.0314824544,
-0.0150064034,
-0.0224931315,
0.0392232463,
0.0693555027,
-0.0230291747,
0.0240091737,
0.0334213376,
0.0714873672,
0.0279479232,
0.0835602283,
0.0055026785,
-0.0460840352,
-0.0083688404,
0.0131681068,
0.0226303805,
-0.0157568268,
-0.0084717916,
-0.0074353465,
0.0073773507,
-0.0215906426,
0.0098912995,
-0.0348031521,
0.091223143,
0.0197762307,
-0.0613666587,
-0.0303890556,
0.0067627276,
-0.0457901731,
0.0122474935,
-0.0540134571,
0.0224559456,
0.0436177924,
0.0526822843,
-0.0663339049,
0.0417154692,
-0.0010011853,
0.0680253282,
0.0889656842,
0.0648494512,
0.0218471289,
-0.0236938577,
-0.0240998287,
-0.0284314808,
0.0194416046,
0.0309416167,
0.0149867544,
0.0359239802,
0.0070309928,
0.0164243691,
-0.0319845155,
-0.0301071648,
0.0659082308,
0.0068022786,
0.0394259058,
-0.0215114746,
0.0206004996,
-0.0334358625,
0.0288463179,
-0.0441271178,
0.0045109214,
0.0118775312,
-0.0510097183,
0.0056014424,
-0.0229150504,
-0.0062661138,
-0.0256396774,
-0.002566416,
-0.0687038302,
-0.0259737838,
0.0826997161,
-0.0048238463,
-0.0263275318,
-0.0082214829,
-0.0426664725,
0.0117909722,
-0.0743524954,
0.0230647791,
-0.0107782632,
0.0404865704,
-0.016534511,
0.0554483645,
0.0081151957,
0.0306379031,
0.0088600693,
-0.0613683946,
0.0608799979,
-0.0277068317,
-0.0256096479,
-0.0183061622,
-0.0296440385,
0.0242459346,
0.0065608434,
0.0040150997,
-0.0261448529,
-0.043025516,
-0.0563476905,
-0.0172452386,
-0.0405450948,
-0.0204992183,
0.0109561095,
-0.0236233901,
-0.0051192092,
-0.0309574567,
-0.0180930365,
-0.0253191609,
0.0356688984,
-0.0125396894,
0.0472421125,
-0.0237939656,
-0.0191943161,
-0.0177056547,
-0.0090793809,
-0.0175798181,
0.0338045619,
0.0363258235,
-0.0535306782,
-0.0877267867,
0.0057278876,
0.0246685687,
0.040960189,
-0.0201762114,
-0.0200796761,
-0.0179847348,
-0.014880117,
0.0074829706,
0.0788701773,
0.0245508812,
0.0518910363,
0.0144395716,
0.0331113674,
0.0089355567,
0.0121135833,
-0.0089084506,
0.0299143773,
0.0064378232,
-0.0172334313,
0.0467627123,
0.025755858,
-0.0241213795,
0.017614888,
-0.0139693841,
-0.0156281292,
-0.0428291447,
-0.0472971499,
-0.0017209678,
-0.0133621627,
-0.0228390992,
0.0704709366,
-0.0497142188,
-0.0442466326,
0.0509841107,
-0.0486819632,
0.0009252744,
-0.0666389018,
0.0154989781,
-0.042185463,
0.0174007677,
0.0179966018,
0.0300244447,
0.0089816488,
-0.0393114947,
-0.0455244035,
-0.0184172969,
0.0153232682,
-0.0186528601,
0.0308414362,
-0.0156394597,
0.0138016725,
-0.0147167444,
-0.01021579,
-0.0411986783,
-0.0365394652,
-0.0134365093,
-0.0267262384,
0.0061604944,
-0.0579543225,
0.0044143833,
0.0097333621,
-0.0077650147,
0.0715796277,
-0.0291888323,
0.0018560601,
-0.0248569418,
0.1025819108,
0.0599381849,
-0.0434485301,
0.014845537,
-0.0759731829,
0.0015051222,
0.0479464978,
-0.0207923688,
0.0224930029,
0.0205151699,
-0.0268423222,
0.0138738425,
-0.0043535274,
-0.0180420931,
-0.0202381369,
0.0205935165,
-0.0649901703,
-0.0196526516,
0.0877448544,
0.0211684667,
-0.0342426822,
-0.0330514461,
-0.0343917757,
0.0121036423,
-0.0078420462,
0.025157867,
-0.057379771,
-0.0261217877,
0.0186172277,
-0.0136431539,
0.000422016,
0.0195220485,
-0.005435585,
-0.0993728787,
0.0407780819,
-0.0211864207,
-0.0436256304,
-0.0416503139,
0.0238141827,
0.0245532058,
0.0516714305,
-0.0255468823,
-0.0266941302,
-0.0301369578,
-0.0349701494,
-0.0172939487,
-0.0010016967,
0.0006976163,
-0.0400844961,
-0.0598041415,
-0.0170210358,
0.0656837225,
0.0536794811,
0.0011855336,
-0.0529267751,
0.0611278489,
-0.0257692616,
0.0153410872,
-0.0095325988,
0.0796682462,
0.002432537,
-0.0113359243,
-0.011950505,
0.0168684348,
0.0010499213,
0.003789935,
0.0071839322,
0.0196251329,
-0.0172966514,
-0.0394212455,
-0.0267355833,
0.0382822417,
0.0019200853,
0.0804132447,
0.0213027429,
-0.0473457612,
-0.0873607844,
0.0024193388,
0.0552055053,
-0.0626432747,
-0.0328222252,
-0.0146213546,
-0.016004717,
-0.0758290216,
-0.0668045655,
-0.0078318436,
-0.0187078882,
0.0323664919,
0.0138260843,
0.0228036214,
-0.0053559314,
0.0248267576,
-0.055710163,
-0.0361309797,
-0.0563839525,
0.0355529487,
-0.045865614,
0.0395704284,
-0.0032280793,
-0.0738269016,
-0.0084987069,
0.0138543807,
-0.0512837954,
-0.0220621005,
0.0375625789,
-0.0535818711,
0.0252436865,
0.0496244207,
-0.0376941487,
-0.041138012,
0.0415787138,
0.0220351685,
-0.0351703018,
0.0338612422,
0.0242352858,
-0.0002359303,
-0.0520111024,
0.026283659,
-0.0230137613,
0.0091632223,
0.0155046117,
-0.0232440196,
-0.0356852598,
-0.0180851258,
0.0112490533,
-0.0388699062,
0.045193579,
-0.0203884598,
0.0083441082,
-0.0373142362,
-0.0151511114,
0.0018479453,
-0.0165358018,
-0.0421764478,
0.0061209416,
0.0280230809,
-0.0074122469,
-0.0055593695,
0.0167409983,
-0.0234294068,
0.0726418719,
0.0068401871,
-0.0049838829,
-0.0244003125,
0.0927629173,
0.0063782777,
-0.0124679171,
0.0221073125,
0.0554820858,
-0.0048930463,
0.0444802791,
0.0167795196,
0.0659150854,
0.0335619003,
-0.0678220466,
0.0015814885,
0.0101646744,
-0.066115804,
0.0360986739,
-0.0540890507,
0.0372725911,
0.0446796864,
-0.0062158909,
0.0361362584,
-0.0290902518,
-0.0331540555,
-0.0157103837,
0.0134740733,
0.0375740007,
-0.0313710794,
-0.0007223074,
0.0150578981,
-0.0163257439,
-0.0024583132,
0.0624265186,
0.0569659024,
0.0397312418,
0.029129969,
-0.0500390492,
-0.0426711664,
-0.0116586881,
0.0598278753,
0.0022555271,
-0.0108750984,
0.0287373811,
-0.0760793909,
-0.0286875237,
0.0624680929,
-0.0150766475,
-0.0157856978,
0.0193968061,
-0.0241778046,
0.0459778383,
-0.0100309746,
0.0161865819,
-0.044817023,
0.0219841395,
-0.0062940661,
-0.0160408281,
-0.0118683474,
-5.258436593e-33,
0.0076054246,
-0.0615347102,
-0.0433791466,
0.0056021446,
-0.027159296,
0.0376065746,
-0.0062239175,
-0.0045284168,
0.0094037959,
0.0442076176,
0.005020353,
0.0279644188,
0.0409343913,
0.0074965516,
-0.0695029125,
-0.0365835279,
0.0649600327,
-0.015590407,
-0.0109935496,
-0.002514333,
-0.0019017946,
0.0258477945,
0.0167317577,
-0.074186869,
0.002661898,
-0.0598313697,
-0.0327530131,
0.0293424278,
0.0102316383,
0.0392920263,
-0.021386914,
0.0058612414,
0.031176025,
0.0005495048,
0.0040448154,
0.0769067854,
-0.0584086962,
0.0095305247,
-0.0269163027,
0.0340953991,
-0.0215418451,
-0.0330998823,
0.0254930351,
-0.0282473937,
0.0178048313,
0.0092375102,
0.0776356459,
-0.0349547938,
0.0227644462,
-0.0226984061,
-0.0906488225,
0.0579233095,
0.0166635551,
-0.0374465808,
0.061905656,
0.0568017624,
0.0360348113,
0.001210444,
-0.0584669486,
0.0307226423,
-0.0108150933,
0.0220207684,
0.006511007,
0.0050309999,
-0.0410800949,
0.0620053671,
0.049116537,
0.0169918966,
0.0238350183,
-0.0429984778,
0.0278791264,
0.0026384583,
0.0370793343,
0.0837399587,
0.025421191,
-0.0148580112,
-0.0189999323,
0.0134306755,
-0.0179623347,
-0.0250785798,
0.0203649923,
-0.0286662318,
-0.0641668364,
0.0161269065,
0.004829485,
-0.0611275025,
-0.0419002213,
0.0281856153,
0.0385266766,
0.0617769323,
-0.0313516147,
0.0015883779,
0.0238082092,
-0.0485129729,
0.001127439,
-0.0188081879,
-0.0421954431,
0.0332127288,
-0.002687468,
-0.0083462717,
0.0084087532,
-0.0462223142,
0.0328700542,
0.0179147385,
-0.0109383883,
-0.0271346327,
0.070551917,
0.0032257584,
-0.0705811977,
0.0111183515,
-0.0062244786,
0.0285722986,
0.0277202409,
0.0573357791,
0.0237002037,
-0.0133543676,
-0.0052946024,
0.0264523886,
0.0472421236,
-0.013457003,
-0.0351112969,
0.0296335835,
-0.0232500061,
0.0174733847,
-0.0265744906,
-0.0020542336,
0.018329002,
-0.0001153438,
0.053282693,
-0.0447448343,
0.0182325002,
-0.0206811633,
2.2e-7,
0.043771185,
0.0089877052,
0.0796897858,
-0.013768171,
0.0088436762,
0.0311591551,
-0.0055771787,
0.0222301017,
-0.0399360955,
0.0311730634,
-0.0005485993,
-0.0063811862,
0.0941578001,
-0.0210408513,
-0.1006808504,
0.0179576557,
-0.0023221048,
-0.0128417155,
-0.0524111278,
0.0016385766,
0.0451941453,
0.049497243,
-0.0087859062,
-0.041278284,
0.0112819634,
-0.0622108914,
0.0535973348,
-0.0142113436,
0.0499480665,
0.027201578,
0.0050623058,
-0.0060211499,
-0.0245965812,
0.0379081815,
-0.004408597,
0.0046848021,
0.050279662,
0.0539792329,
0.0235420652,
0.0215877611,
0.0008848366,
0.0095416028,
-0.0011584891,
-0.0322287343,
0.046284385,
-0.006394323,
0.0135774389,
-0.0466387272,
-0.0155987116,
-0.0378738083,
0.0238455851,
-0.0224259831,
-0.0071681961,
0.0435887687,
0.0267464835,
-0.0077958619,
-0.0083162962,
-0.0565023497,
-0.0280374419,
-0.0484090857,
-0.0524636656,
0.0220673773,
-0.0747142881,
-0.0076203519,
0.0311226789,
-0.0715933591,
0.0204409007,
2.332736626e-34,
0.0514722951,
-0.0416166633,
-0.0329373591,
0.0021553731,
-0.0006661231,
0.0090539334,
0.0218882076,
-0.0028952735,
-0.0292128362,
-0.0235841889,
0.0380645394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08348v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08348v2 | MC$^2$: Towards Transparent and Culturally-Aware NLP for Minority Languages in China | 2023-11-14T17:45:50 | 2024-06-13T04:36:11 | Chen Zhang, Mingxu Tao, Quzhe Huang, Jiuheng Lin, Zhibin Chen, Yansong Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current large language models demonstrate deficiencies in understanding
low-resource languages, particularly the minority languages in China. This
limitation stems from the scarcity of available pre-training data. To address
this accessibility challenge, we present MC$^2$, a Multilingual Corpus of
Minority Languages in China, which is the largest open-source corpus of its
kind so far. MC$^2$ includes four underrepresented languages: Tibetan, Uyghur,
Kazakh, and Mongolian. Notably, we focus on the less common writing systems of
Kazakh and Mongolian, i.e., Kazakh Arabic script and traditional Mongolian
script, respectively, which have been long neglected in previous corpus
construction efforts. Recognizing the prevalence of language contamination
within existing corpora, we adopt a quality-centric solution for collecting
MC$^2$, prioritizing accuracy while enhancing diversity. Furthermore, we
underscore the importance of attending to the multiplicity of writing systems,
which is closely related to the cultural awareness of the resulting models. The
MC$^2$ corpus and related models are made public to the community. | [
0.042512849,
0.0959807709,
-0.0133933136,
0.020185953,
-0.0114948619,
0.0068807676,
0.04356822,
0.0060118865,
-0.0064961119,
-0.0138086816,
-0.0122243417,
-0.0958123058,
0.0191635098,
-0.0117672365,
0.0174542796,
-0.0513876639,
0.0086402576,
-0.0023849383,
-0.001866821,
0.0139380349,
0.05047765,
0.0454814583,
0.0142287668,
0.0537923276,
-0.0552383848,
-0.0386192426,
0.023217991,
0.0146023082,
0.0154189887,
-0.0188300256,
-0.0044557424,
0.0672817305,
-0.0256645847,
0.0787626803,
0.0000018953,
-0.0286957845,
-0.0334794,
-0.0150255477,
0.004485487,
0.0279065967,
0.0495178998,
-0.0324828401,
-0.0500029773,
0.0423103273,
0.0063746907,
-0.0372956321,
0.0781905651,
0.0639004484,
0.0500534996,
0.0482385121,
-0.006453577,
0.0182445087,
-0.0220897719,
-0.0085609863,
-0.059069816,
0.0102698551,
0.0207300894,
0.0217153821,
-0.0318637379,
-0.0237777419,
-0.0044249343,
0.033905752,
0.0103069628,
-0.0452919677,
-0.0250509791,
-0.0100574698,
-0.0678517893,
-0.0425269194,
0.0375941023,
0.0330608152,
-0.0057746228,
-0.0286032353,
0.0300228857,
0.0134485886,
-0.04442963,
0.0026359486,
-0.0238255803,
0.0405249223,
-0.0235992782,
0.0134298736,
0.0131850094,
0.0075554983,
0.0221314132,
0.0213153753,
0.0380087495,
0.015695449,
0.0223148689,
-0.0272832718,
-0.0145111727,
0.0160351954,
0.0010727147,
-0.0179023053,
0.0350615978,
-0.0180100407,
-0.025531143,
0.0017970114,
-0.015426768,
-0.0514154807,
0.0200209729,
0.0072748545,
0.0474558994,
0.0386836044,
-0.0418354608,
-0.0204459801,
-0.0320508145,
-0.0016433412,
0.0104443068,
-0.0304218382,
-0.0237292536,
-0.0286591444,
0.023537308,
-0.0085686883,
-0.0291811731,
-0.0100146169,
-0.0468285941,
0.0405407064,
-0.0169378892,
0.0149294017,
-0.0370310023,
0.0169978812,
0.0158570223,
-0.0353516527,
-0.0299139805,
-0.0123990411,
0.0123877414,
0.0093619768,
-0.0046723802,
0.0027832955,
-0.0501463339,
-0.0622756593,
0.0261703655,
0.0462331362,
0.0078318538,
-0.0034403042,
-0.0093840649,
0.0294624772,
0.0037395139,
-0.0126540596,
-0.0404751152,
0.0391606204,
-0.0206672866,
-0.0031094796,
-0.0181812141,
-0.0546084195,
0.0069840322,
0.0032016772,
0.0393244475,
-0.0247350801,
0.0114077823,
0.0179852527,
0.0302490611,
0.0282958075,
0.0199145228,
-0.0016881484,
0.0451161377,
-0.0157176852,
0.0116075492,
0.0617735907,
0.0406500213,
-0.0105709787,
0.0820088461,
-0.0110262809,
0.0218801554,
0.0251556616,
-0.0347495601,
0.0051062298,
0.0047756941,
0.0107858032,
0.0190809704,
0.0103976959,
0.0138481464,
0.04313761,
0.0188894756,
0.0059090895,
0.0495950468,
0.0342814438,
0.0001745808,
0.0177258067,
-0.0021376803,
0.008730026,
-0.0328803658,
0.0282073207,
-0.0110962559,
0.0100839091,
0.0092053991,
-0.0050470307,
0.0157730933,
0.0487440266,
-0.0292633921,
-0.0568724424,
-0.0606783144,
-0.0000983371,
0.0324898474,
-0.0335751139,
0.037090674,
-0.0122895325,
0.0216498431,
-0.0010168259,
0.0507196859,
-0.041968789,
0.0437912941,
-0.0166618954,
-0.0001865717,
0.043599613,
0.0337636583,
-0.0457626767,
0.0749945268,
-0.0077130552,
0.0001965821,
0.0752051994,
0.0110572716,
-0.027784206,
0.0260553304,
-0.0526414514,
0.0169991218,
0.0442202501,
0.0215864759,
0.0146569954,
-0.0020162091,
0.0249717217,
0.0103981551,
-0.0189918019,
-0.0587836839,
0.045257397,
-0.074843809,
-0.0035642369,
-0.0194129162,
0.0073900791,
0.000519109,
0.0419010893,
-0.060715232,
0.0025894251,
-0.0272437967,
-0.0389816575,
-0.0369437896,
0.021094285,
-0.0454960428,
-0.0522580966,
0.0327372849,
-0.0718675032,
-0.0078366417,
0.036344897,
-0.0169822853,
-0.0561179966,
0.0581584796,
0.0202968679,
-0.0241005495,
-0.0891094282,
0.0270483084,
0.0104492055,
-0.01560093,
-0.022239754,
0.0264398269,
-0.0102853822,
0.0244585946,
0.0082010543,
-0.0276267361,
0.0500163883,
-0.0370905958,
-0.0382967517,
0.03302994,
-0.002573845,
0.0235855374,
0.0456204936,
0.0314706713,
0.0099909026,
0.0020327985,
-0.063089557,
-0.0173413157,
-0.051225774,
0.0034021272,
-0.0002386744,
0.0221404862,
-0.0181556549,
0.0115742609,
-0.0350500271,
-0.0508929566,
0.0122537613,
-0.0214678831,
0.0419418104,
-0.0411422364,
0.0378650986,
-0.0016199206,
-0.0518433079,
0.0150223561,
0.003673919,
-0.0144068506,
-0.0551586635,
-0.0175707191,
-0.0306905024,
0.0066571473,
0.0112326359,
0.0047105406,
-0.049025692,
-0.0015561946,
0.0066586635,
-0.0088615296,
-0.0007275253,
-0.0064988812,
0.0079614669,
0.0465622917,
0.0199642554,
0.0250631422,
-0.0092833601,
0.0335227847,
0.0256834216,
0.0187777504,
-0.0681232065,
-0.006340872,
0.0676338822,
0.0163250603,
-0.0576874278,
-0.0723808035,
-0.0791768879,
-0.0774461478,
-0.0197880529,
-0.0026858132,
0.0104809403,
-0.0290605538,
0.0102410642,
-0.0608278587,
-0.0025984349,
0.0640826523,
-0.0335863084,
-0.0289986841,
-0.0020180836,
0.0123258512,
-0.0604553036,
0.0150131313,
0.0043744482,
0.0238668323,
0.0204600394,
-0.0389991105,
-0.045212809,
0.0294662323,
0.0184492487,
-0.020670522,
0.0207093358,
-0.0377141237,
-0.0008058317,
-0.044134602,
-0.042682644,
-0.0153719466,
0.0072579784,
0.0233093575,
0.0246851277,
0.0367665254,
0.011791355,
0.0111408187,
0.053806752,
0.0176372193,
0.0614050962,
0.0026811589,
0.0495192707,
-0.011801892,
0.0276792664,
0.0015317019,
0.0111427279,
0.029833151,
-0.0323152952,
0.0513165295,
0.0376931392,
0.0867715403,
0.0080856625,
0.075208962,
-0.0315226093,
0.0338794328,
-0.0002391476,
-0.0327464379,
-0.0327512212,
0.0718792081,
-0.027937796,
0.0182666536,
0.0937830508,
0.0233078953,
0.0072936667,
0.0193002727,
-0.0173951853,
0.021601757,
0.0140754031,
-0.0220910925,
-0.1398363113,
-0.008936354,
0.0418342352,
0.0134746367,
-0.0391593911,
-0.032337375,
0.0208517648,
-0.1119290367,
-0.0194474477,
0.023250442,
-0.0254547074,
-0.0258686468,
-0.0113914683,
-0.0218423065,
-0.0499090515,
0.0229542386,
0.0143252201,
0.0083530471,
-0.0008523543,
0.0668247938,
-0.060463082,
-0.060387969,
-0.0372825935,
-0.046057038,
0.0166495442,
-0.0209564734,
0.02854212,
-0.0435565375,
0.0143714035,
-0.0160477795,
-0.0606362782,
-0.0332102664,
0.0042158626,
-0.0004044498,
0.0133199589,
-0.0443649404,
-0.0215932801,
0.0351676159,
-0.0387550257,
-0.0061954451,
0.006357458,
0.0024889,
0.0215746667,
-0.0234754663,
0.0091755828,
-0.0076346756,
0.0199726373,
0.0831761286,
0.0024313058,
-0.0593786128,
0.0001983643,
-0.0652674958,
-0.0047025965,
-0.0393539816,
-0.0219794847,
0.0754153728,
-0.0084899664,
-0.0474709049,
-0.0941024125,
-0.0833861232,
-0.0046224389,
0.0214675181,
-0.0049352357,
0.0270037372,
0.0066118012,
0.0050749797,
-0.0160960983,
0.036025539,
0.0003652317,
-0.011078842,
-0.0574381091,
-0.046587225,
-0.0392126292,
-0.0440796688,
0.0166598279,
0.0165453032,
-0.0502791852,
-0.0302945394,
0.049837932,
0.0013727053,
0.0066904575,
-0.0313835591,
0.0121947918,
-0.0386053063,
0.0483376719,
-0.0189336985,
0.0142408125,
0.0041611479,
0.0278560463,
-0.051805038,
-0.00736146,
0.0458961874,
-0.0096725225,
0.0303714275,
0.0126825962,
0.0406518877,
-0.0420921743,
0.0534009561,
-0.0067833387,
0.0212389491,
-0.0055604111,
-0.0617389679,
0.0272691045,
-0.1034638137,
-0.0048175938,
-0.0349922962,
-0.0261252131,
-0.0543134101,
0.0034771031,
0.0258273482,
0.0571515821,
-0.0531475432,
0.0254696868,
0.0095423125,
0.0305141173,
-0.0222667512,
0.0299888942,
0.0269984454,
0.0744249299,
-0.0241588149,
0.0108491117,
-0.0155859636,
0.0618574768,
-0.046374727,
0.005335765,
-0.0039600297,
0.0047239275,
0.0002066359,
0.0083068945,
0.0696564615,
0.0232190285,
-0.019217575,
0.0241973158,
0.0034696162,
0.0136526404,
0.0882168561,
-0.0170591399,
0.0794295222,
-0.0262003839,
0.0023286936,
-0.0385418758,
0.0524660498,
0.0648909733,
-0.0426623672,
-0.0191444661,
-0.0057825455,
-0.0442458056,
-0.0440413728,
0.0816462561,
0.0092550674,
0.0220942758,
-0.0096657993,
0.0091073764,
-0.0010708134,
-0.0151158692,
0.0087454636,
0.0009126803,
-0.0263924915,
0.0055489135,
-0.0804706067,
-0.0673075467,
-0.0137511985,
-0.0226856247,
-0.0136862667,
-0.0035699198,
0.0016354576,
0.0364035256,
0.0187056381,
-0.0009330353,
-0.0681684762,
-0.0244488511,
-0.0218573585,
-0.0092385253,
0.0403386913,
-6.329198805e-33,
-0.011920196,
0.0123753091,
-0.0569381788,
-0.0504105426,
0.0545738898,
-0.0105188638,
0.0046966258,
-0.0085922536,
-0.0554673187,
0.0031060209,
-0.0528086126,
0.0151545042,
0.0172966104,
0.0513757095,
0.0154028963,
0.0411000736,
0.0489427298,
0.0275785569,
-0.0009490611,
-0.0108676795,
0.0791437402,
0.0240020063,
0.1007495001,
-0.0610178933,
0.0482050478,
-0.0140901254,
-0.0239582118,
0.0136871599,
0.0286893975,
0.0360406302,
-0.0365221128,
0.0939380899,
0.0403290167,
-0.0018270428,
0.0042777094,
-0.0189905334,
-0.0679456368,
0.0096859327,
-0.0257666931,
0.0478152297,
-0.0006121717,
-0.0194128808,
-0.0128051257,
-0.0451558344,
-0.006150593,
0.0261599571,
0.0215588678,
-0.0291883163,
0.0344535895,
-0.0180504117,
-0.03095413,
0.0619438402,
0.0132121015,
0.0578015074,
-0.0042445771,
0.0330578461,
-0.0136383567,
-0.0260629784,
-0.0490672737,
-0.0239978079,
-0.0113616465,
0.079618983,
0.0274933148,
0.0357761197,
-0.0034003146,
0.0203731786,
-0.0169416517,
-0.0077711791,
0.0515616499,
-0.0189827643,
0.0312440991,
-0.0451766588,
-0.0017616504,
0.0935727581,
0.0262151323,
-0.0683313161,
-0.0641052499,
0.0064456691,
0.0434073135,
-0.0141950557,
0.0129535748,
-0.0282769725,
-0.038848456,
-0.0329986066,
-0.001727329,
-0.0650637746,
-0.0063971845,
-0.0014225479,
0.0207282696,
0.0121156545,
-0.0333323777,
0.0140039986,
0.0277158115,
0.0007859604,
-0.0522304252,
0.0060441848,
0.0124078365,
-0.0187309068,
0.0009701857,
0.0492973961,
-0.0514262915,
-0.0543050654,
0.0046730591,
-0.017100824,
-0.0146048889,
-0.0053544464,
0.0567652769,
0.0417498648,
-0.0752498507,
0.0167313199,
-0.0158640556,
0.0451140516,
0.0471314043,
0.0492601693,
0.0044509368,
-0.0214988962,
-0.002265326,
0.0117465155,
0.0639812872,
0.013123095,
-0.0076553379,
-0.0395601653,
-0.0521080345,
-0.0118229389,
-0.0200573057,
0.0057256599,
-0.0115260361,
-0.0106749162,
0.0752224624,
-0.0125397509,
0.0159675088,
-0.0553688407,
2.595e-7,
0.0417328514,
-0.0071622273,
0.0282593835,
0.0219511092,
0.026284894,
0.0092655644,
-0.0281188395,
0.0608812198,
-0.0519972742,
0.031035563,
-0.0102426652,
0.0096532833,
0.1195348203,
0.0190025959,
-0.0658660233,
-0.0109887207,
-0.0187219493,
0.0185964927,
-0.025370853,
0.0319385007,
-0.0442033224,
0.0862321183,
-0.0263960678,
0.0061197868,
-0.0394674279,
-0.0676374137,
0.0436007529,
-0.0056272466,
0.0013138405,
0.0275772195,
0.0741788,
-0.0015650819,
0.001659067,
-0.0280882157,
-0.0182066113,
0.0297446661,
0.0537097938,
0.0687375739,
-0.0047197598,
-0.0183066465,
0.0320386849,
0.0037181473,
-0.0318669081,
-0.0272543766,
0.0592036806,
0.106569767,
-0.0337622538,
-0.0335641131,
0.0174019542,
-0.025906859,
0.0075144679,
-0.003440425,
-0.0337475613,
0.0492659733,
0.0176408831,
-0.0503501333,
-0.0078876605,
-0.0331381336,
-0.0897532031,
-0.0239332896,
0.0105839251,
-0.0563024394,
0.0236970317,
-0.0290585011,
-0.013712436,
-0.0039375476,
-0.0063296957,
2.189454885e-34,
0.040053159,
0.0030972154,
-0.0335830115,
0.0139332898,
0.0245514251,
-0.0310264044,
0.0052889585,
-0.0071181441,
-0.0155849289,
0.0031810179,
-0.0268889721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08329v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08329v4 | KTRL+F: Knowledge-Augmented In-Document Search | 2023-11-14T17:18:08 | 2024-04-18T07:08:21 | Hanseok Oh, Haebin Shin, Miyoung Ko, Hyunji Lee, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce a new problem KTRL+F, a knowledge-augmented in-document search
task that necessitates real-time identification of all semantic targets within
a document with the awareness of external sources through a single natural
query. KTRL+F addresses following unique challenges for in-document search:
1)utilizing knowledge outside the document for extended use of additional
information about targets, and 2) balancing between real-time applicability
with the performance. We analyze various baselines in KTRL+F and find
limitations of existing models, such as hallucinations, high latency, or
difficulties in leveraging external knowledge. Therefore, we propose a
Knowledge-Augmented Phrase Retrieval model that shows a promising balance
between speed and performance by simply augmenting external knowledge in phrase
embedding. We also conduct a user study to verify whether solving KTRL+F can
enhance search experience for users. It demonstrates that even with our simple
model, users can reduce the time for searching with less queries and reduced
extra visits to other sources for collecting evidence. We encourage the
research community to work on KTRL+F to enhance more efficient in-document
information access. | [
0.0442832187,
-0.026201915,
-0.0014000802,
-0.0120429303,
-0.0079638939,
-0.0213110074,
-0.0490910932,
0.0437940918,
0.0121497372,
-0.0126947472,
-0.0358299576,
0.0405588225,
-0.0688384026,
0.0291879307,
-0.0029530628,
-0.0393624008,
0.0552206039,
-0.0026179533,
0.0142509965,
0.0495645553,
0.0370357148,
-0.0109334635,
-0.0059510958,
0.012607499,
-0.0129281105,
0.0003901725,
-0.0601410083,
-0.0025699753,
-0.0066251727,
-0.0130936978,
-0.0116172628,
0.039207343,
0.0361751951,
0.0020410477,
0.0000022733,
-0.0213332511,
-0.0298897289,
-0.0129402867,
-0.0355454981,
-0.0130344899,
0.0414546132,
0.0124402931,
0.0519904457,
-0.0210362375,
-0.0025875496,
-0.0076102647,
-0.000877382,
0.0858183056,
0.0033117076,
0.0334848203,
-0.0093451748,
0.0305656977,
0.0051045422,
0.0056916154,
0.0870077461,
-0.032379467,
0.013018284,
-0.0328657702,
0.0617692471,
0.0238068588,
0.0240908153,
0.0606317744,
-0.0161398854,
-0.0172097441,
0.1047736332,
0.0199249797,
-0.0617419854,
0.0081764804,
-0.0029030996,
0.0297131166,
-0.0270427391,
-0.0144078508,
0.0257363711,
0.0185048822,
-0.0347766206,
0.062008772,
-0.0622049347,
-0.0285997801,
-0.058461424,
-0.0475384519,
0.0128912749,
0.032222826,
0.0560869686,
-0.0050418586,
-0.0044212132,
0.0335583352,
0.0033651935,
-0.071197845,
0.0529898107,
-0.0064304955,
-0.0119985957,
-0.0204377659,
0.0534662269,
0.0170421246,
-0.0078292964,
0.0176663753,
-0.0353913717,
-0.0521608144,
0.0537224784,
-0.0843767375,
-0.0124992002,
0.0228313152,
-0.0382298492,
0.1015829146,
-0.0257032085,
-0.0036969692,
-0.0180623941,
-0.0048359772,
-0.027570352,
-0.0022325527,
-0.0505732745,
-0.0300881416,
-0.0487763099,
0.0302573629,
-0.0336514413,
-0.0677447543,
0.0272134449,
0.0454703756,
0.0118549224,
0.0019225487,
-0.0342976525,
0.0067007588,
-0.0209317468,
-0.0174548253,
-0.0347567052,
-0.013775792,
-0.0344529301,
-0.0468975008,
-0.0047363313,
-0.0246727448,
0.0110511789,
-0.0072092908,
0.0161852501,
0.005525725,
0.0016940321,
0.0410280265,
-0.0003942354,
-0.0603610985,
-0.006509624,
-0.0748450309,
0.0126677183,
0.0263299979,
0.0023883199,
-0.0155569157,
-0.0092459852,
-0.0203786399,
-0.0301996488,
0.0174822342,
0.0138888592,
0.0593404323,
-0.0071675745,
0.0496915989,
-0.0390815027,
-0.0003866975,
0.02762351,
0.0417105034,
-0.0123436917,
0.0602909401,
-0.052230414,
0.0218427442,
0.0512218513,
0.0138478186,
0.0180567726,
0.0078874743,
0.0234009456,
-0.0183101315,
0.0059216395,
0.0482795909,
-0.0024379641,
0.049985826,
-0.049668137,
-0.0149489194,
-0.0272546038,
0.0119086886,
0.0269279648,
0.0642080456,
0.0135956798,
-0.0353469886,
-0.0407345407,
0.0209148005,
-0.0108600017,
-0.0270111598,
-0.0033256027,
0.0425140932,
-0.0310122985,
-0.010323829,
0.0486320704,
0.0060790968,
-0.0160704777,
-0.0213578958,
-0.0332455486,
0.0467254296,
-0.0409589745,
0.0264943745,
0.0469389521,
0.0006455266,
-0.0087584043,
-0.0006194146,
0.0149440179,
-0.0147705767,
-0.0115127033,
-0.0071707694,
-0.0221262984,
0.1067681462,
0.1190340891,
-0.0606971905,
-0.0284504946,
-0.0184975974,
-0.0055842507,
0.074319154,
0.0006535109,
-0.0037293974,
-0.0263297986,
-0.0336119719,
-0.0312129036,
-0.0043367115,
0.02399984,
0.0108669475,
-0.0015962407,
0.0306859389,
0.0129170213,
-0.039694611,
0.0143321045,
0.0449369885,
-0.0014630733,
-0.0343990102,
-0.016316643,
0.0363602564,
-0.0221666489,
0.0104811685,
0.0085111419,
0.0320896655,
0.0543171167,
-0.0269574299,
-0.0463294759,
-0.0102830324,
0.0289623924,
0.025897786,
0.0098448293,
-0.0510001853,
0.0239669252,
-0.0127355307,
0.0537237674,
-0.0287565514,
-0.0241607912,
-0.0456308834,
0.0773827434,
-0.0232966319,
0.0041892231,
0.0036697362,
-0.010902402,
-0.024284035,
0.0453649014,
0.0003834103,
0.0323495269,
-0.0122911781,
-0.020928992,
0.0161968432,
-0.0238583535,
-0.0364324301,
-0.0104634427,
0.0067283888,
0.0144536002,
0.0394978672,
-0.0457747504,
-0.0501348451,
0.0069667599,
-0.0770613775,
0.006356705,
-0.0122456579,
-0.0109788785,
0.0145697175,
0.0256260931,
-0.0231873859,
-0.0407931842,
-0.0326422378,
-0.0239972211,
-0.0036117325,
0.0278915223,
0.0127674891,
0.019389458,
-0.0156721193,
-0.0121467318,
-0.011841909,
-0.0002968588,
0.0109442296,
0.0310978442,
-0.0735830441,
-0.0005966314,
0.0186728444,
-0.0005143768,
0.0261053853,
-0.023754159,
0.0361018069,
-0.0013926604,
-0.0473738797,
0.00259046,
0.0608367324,
-0.0081122508,
0.0137926461,
0.0343052149,
-0.0322517082,
-0.0529970787,
0.0281998534,
0.0049382695,
0.0192145202,
0.0342418104,
0.0135834413,
0.0773361102,
0.0197262485,
-0.0135485465,
0.0038287409,
-0.0139700072,
0.0034667433,
-0.0032992116,
-0.0434110202,
-0.1033345759,
-0.0211112704,
0.0096561676,
0.0487233326,
-0.0110553438,
-0.014504578,
0.0499636345,
0.003450244,
-0.0007959679,
-0.0256488901,
-0.0067806337,
0.0142817535,
0.041286841,
-0.0185672101,
-0.0152039006,
-0.0182662308,
-0.0201199651,
0.0333020166,
0.0176649578,
0.0283035692,
-0.0522509366,
0.0404078327,
0.016557157,
0.0202145521,
0.0444421954,
-0.05561506,
-0.0309394319,
-0.0717366412,
0.0045812423,
-0.0403984822,
-0.0159217138,
-0.032715112,
-0.0720990896,
0.0279156379,
0.0443897471,
0.0405044854,
-0.0158179458,
-0.0742931813,
-0.0031200752,
-0.0174171962,
0.0561833084,
-0.063243188,
-0.0218761303,
0.0014988107,
0.0009061364,
0.0808627158,
0.0541809425,
-0.06549602,
0.029124191,
-0.0230789557,
-0.0014430446,
-0.0521233268,
-0.0302680787,
-0.0241739191,
-0.0654926151,
-0.0636949539,
-0.031183077,
0.0804762542,
0.0688048154,
-0.0771690458,
-0.0467351265,
-0.0672504902,
-0.0369157717,
0.0186967812,
0.0712447315,
-0.050624039,
-0.0271778442,
0.033578895,
0.0348885432,
-0.0261146221,
-0.0277856756,
0.0170798432,
-0.0673559606,
0.0224847775,
-0.0249149483,
0.0424595252,
-0.031946905,
-0.0582765415,
-0.0006863839,
0.0429624245,
-0.0482528694,
0.0262624342,
-0.0086860517,
-0.0087865274,
-0.0140011506,
-0.0112560662,
-0.0011105697,
0.032828562,
-0.0219323859,
-0.0574826114,
0.0748885572,
0.033436399,
0.0338924192,
-0.060209237,
-0.0235497076,
0.0193009004,
0.0049457201,
-0.0032086126,
0.0445320792,
-0.0395810306,
0.015477444,
-0.0466489904,
-0.002579509,
-0.0299961381,
0.018595187,
0.0149178123,
0.0569192097,
-0.02762964,
0.0462506451,
-0.0622778311,
-0.012842441,
0.0018169777,
0.06186001,
-0.0109498603,
-0.0092887208,
0.0157803074,
-0.0091096871,
0.0380621813,
-0.004087321,
-0.03147595,
0.0268640593,
-0.0229627192,
-0.0138151795,
-0.0733658969,
-0.0395153426,
0.0221224464,
0.0414250307,
0.0066401516,
0.0366271026,
-0.0317267478,
-0.0040970962,
-0.0550001934,
0.0086064618,
-0.0131403068,
-0.0061469465,
0.0272882394,
0.0369456187,
0.0446721613,
0.0049060616,
-0.0087335268,
0.0629901364,
-0.0003655229,
-0.009581862,
-0.0228881575,
-0.036523018,
0.0146377785,
0.0357535109,
-0.0682335198,
-0.0285251811,
0.0516107604,
0.0324609689,
-0.0792610124,
-0.023458451,
0.000024999,
-0.02922602,
-0.0035458568,
0.0032049611,
-0.0742953122,
-0.0182619281,
-0.0515500009,
-0.0363417976,
-0.017915355,
0.0057376795,
0.0411899574,
0.038061291,
0.0507085957,
0.0352674685,
0.0107229203,
-0.0246054549,
0.012631339,
-0.0222268235,
-0.0366952047,
-0.0012629643,
0.0202661529,
0.0140609471,
-0.0185251255,
0.026693482,
0.044484403,
0.0089304307,
-0.025710348,
-0.0117730452,
-0.0483299978,
0.0179433543,
0.0244685691,
0.0241131186,
0.0125744194,
-0.0236426201,
0.0204236656,
0.0165015943,
0.0520986281,
-0.0217398927,
0.0232913382,
0.0340567827,
-0.0195998102,
-0.0173348021,
0.003556231,
-0.0899091139,
-0.0227186251,
-0.007835093,
0.0086711617,
0.0261724554,
-0.0340530984,
0.0212232657,
-0.0594517104,
-0.0088414392,
-0.0103505654,
-0.0162452776,
-0.0024015959,
-0.0234587751,
-0.007886936,
0.0534605905,
0.0167834312,
-0.0305695254,
0.05751995,
-0.0352302305,
0.0443273,
-0.0148250153,
-0.0783266723,
-0.0378935337,
0.0292703081,
0.0121009517,
0.0729602426,
-0.0185357705,
-0.0063106911,
-0.0180694573,
0.0055373213,
0.0444004647,
0.0183622111,
-0.0316730291,
0.009175837,
0.0710310265,
0.1068848744,
0.018550558,
-0.0645138919,
-0.0174235348,
0.0483401455,
-0.0686592311,
-0.0058769719,
0.0238974895,
-6.786804062e-33,
-0.0249342397,
-0.0289536994,
0.0197440647,
-0.0220888089,
0.0013201316,
0.0235605054,
-0.0029129626,
-0.0097316392,
0.0185575169,
0.0072946432,
-0.0390671045,
0.0282186698,
0.0163396131,
-0.0231231861,
0.0202725083,
0.0070863627,
0.0250522457,
-0.0036438878,
0.0090761324,
0.0245112404,
0.103329137,
0.0673880428,
-0.0016289898,
-0.0388904288,
0.0249168184,
0.0047533521,
0.0153904902,
0.0275469758,
0.0313394368,
0.0338053107,
-0.0673060939,
0.0170635749,
0.0029771517,
-0.0268665552,
-0.0100834304,
0.0174197163,
-0.0745084584,
-0.0182495397,
-0.0236301385,
0.0308722947,
-0.0229998399,
-0.0056706672,
0.0469169095,
-0.0000456743,
0.0425522253,
0.0127136009,
0.0356708765,
-0.003857797,
-0.0675623119,
-0.0217426196,
-0.0390307643,
0.0294743683,
0.000302188,
-0.0014525017,
0.0240478236,
0.0282995235,
0.0390343927,
-0.0283736493,
-0.0533185676,
0.0067127948,
-0.024819361,
0.0436076112,
0.0305883531,
0.0077454061,
0.0159135517,
0.0797317401,
0.0115120718,
-0.0312266499,
-0.0367143936,
0.0223843157,
0.0345104598,
0.0311202854,
0.0351261161,
0.0376412272,
0.0651737079,
-0.0005024188,
-0.0125867873,
0.0294754859,
0.0180067495,
0.0004117481,
0.0503178723,
0.0301292893,
-0.0989978909,
-0.0031936551,
0.0120968856,
0.0244145617,
-0.0424495675,
-0.0320297591,
0.0631207228,
0.0511937402,
0.0407139584,
-0.0036167577,
-0.0123987673,
0.0274282731,
0.0516234152,
0.0349388011,
0.0047076913,
0.0214947388,
-0.0344799869,
-0.014554129,
-0.0252403338,
0.0380297229,
-0.0135561237,
-0.0029074231,
-0.022212306,
0.0217282549,
-0.0202792659,
-0.0404378362,
-0.0811398402,
-0.0135790706,
-0.0092276148,
0.0064846915,
0.0239046905,
-0.0578470938,
0.0677724928,
-0.012624165,
-0.0163214523,
0.0803814679,
0.0207836814,
0.0001978664,
0.0039462503,
-0.0393580496,
-0.0025792725,
-0.0216691718,
0.0207621641,
0.0111526949,
-0.0275341421,
-0.0309778769,
0.0212910511,
-0.0757842436,
0.0221890919,
0.0039549726,
3.152e-7,
0.0137318987,
0.0288308337,
0.0369200855,
0.0115360375,
-0.0081625786,
-0.004619658,
0.0143665047,
0.0200785883,
-0.0070323739,
-0.0396748446,
0.0171710681,
-0.0021463081,
0.0164736137,
0.0434080884,
-0.1365312934,
-0.0628108308,
-0.0066858465,
-0.0345623866,
-0.0467289723,
-0.0540378578,
-0.0141324084,
0.0204672311,
0.0119609218,
-0.004428925,
-0.0075215832,
-0.1210631207,
0.0520845689,
0.0092831161,
-0.0420131572,
-0.0238705892,
0.1005131155,
0.0501938313,
-0.0445762314,
0.0238627568,
-0.0213128235,
0.0140223624,
0.0490637422,
0.0107133063,
-0.0005913558,
-0.0127108889,
-0.0097973151,
-0.0135395965,
0.0043378044,
-0.0136815039,
0.0577318557,
-0.0056662289,
0.0174221229,
0.0275922138,
-0.0214002877,
-0.0340338834,
0.0233757868,
-0.0107313422,
-0.041757565,
-0.0003703862,
-0.0115742879,
0.0213885065,
-0.0096389204,
-0.0967858434,
0.0314301811,
0.0558931679,
-0.0450421236,
0.0179918855,
-0.0636278987,
0.0106884884,
0.0014059355,
-0.0511749461,
-0.0109041436,
2.84231733e-34,
0.0147835677,
0.0521095991,
-0.0192709118,
-0.0032407879,
0.0367873386,
-0.0019364521,
0.0043047057,
0.0095240232,
0.0441591144,
-0.120913282,
-0.01163927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08324v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08324v2 | Anti-LM Decoding for Zero-shot In-context Machine Translation | 2023-11-14T17:09:43 | 2024-04-02T19:03:15 | Suzanna Sia, Alexandra DeLucia, Kevin Duh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Zero-shot In-context learning is the phenomenon where models can perform the
task simply given the instructions. However, pre-trained large language models
are known to be poorly calibrated for this task. One of the most effective
approaches to handling this bias is to adopt a contrastive decoding objective,
which accounts for the prior probability of generating the next token by
conditioning on some context. This work introduces an Anti-Language Model
objective with a decay factor designed to address the weaknesses of In-context
Machine Translation. We conduct our experiments across 3 model types and sizes,
3 language directions, and for both greedy decoding and beam search ($B=5$).
The proposed method outperforms other state-of-art decoding objectives, with up
to $20$ BLEU point improvement from the default objective observed in some
settings. | [
-0.0066870959,
0.0441876538,
0.0239536706,
0.0512319766,
-0.0169693977,
0.0272137206,
0.014123382,
0.0031546159,
-0.0734612122,
-0.0068948236,
-0.0317805931,
-0.0563556999,
0.0035669631,
0.0194352046,
0.0135432119,
-0.0085743405,
0.0263946578,
-0.0176271312,
0.0286664274,
-0.0003932756,
-0.0123924743,
0.0096274856,
-0.0054072379,
0.0075476514,
0.012639395,
-0.0080576362,
0.0121672368,
0.0706444979,
0.0251559708,
-0.0796033964,
-0.0053807963,
0.0171520263,
0.0028938416,
0.0448828042,
0.0000020621,
-0.042822253,
-0.0281373058,
-0.0044774939,
-0.0348385423,
0.0034816507,
0.0744867697,
-0.0788556784,
-0.0198274665,
0.0297740381,
-0.0226360168,
-0.0106516862,
0.0724212602,
0.0072872974,
0.0258650258,
0.1081588939,
-0.009596345,
-0.0499159396,
-0.0058153979,
-0.0421765223,
0.015002246,
-0.0749318302,
-0.0039118626,
-0.0461100154,
-0.0341822989,
0.0359411277,
-0.0296923667,
0.047393728,
0.0133086881,
0.0211038329,
-0.0268223453,
0.0261063743,
-0.012120245,
-0.0241671558,
-0.0199869256,
0.0632863045,
-0.0435111262,
-0.043828167,
-0.0158585049,
-0.0333673134,
-0.0270307828,
-0.0841634646,
-0.0417249463,
0.0306516811,
0.017993385,
0.0243076161,
0.0471210778,
0.0668056905,
0.0332880095,
0.0012829964,
-0.0530991815,
0.0133316908,
0.0361992717,
-0.0404376164,
-0.0383679792,
0.0106033925,
-0.0499353707,
-0.0202962272,
0.0062402301,
0.0078155501,
-0.0318982117,
0.0110252323,
-0.0515978858,
-0.0211421456,
-0.0023122868,
-0.0227656402,
0.0341707878,
0.0801936686,
-0.0153953284,
0.0431655236,
-0.0083711743,
0.0371909253,
-0.0310047809,
-0.0194574539,
-0.0539426617,
-0.0011329016,
-0.0128817875,
0.0185512323,
-0.0152051859,
-0.0028314851,
-0.038888935,
-0.0126153138,
-0.0191452261,
0.0256635677,
0.0336492695,
-0.0188396983,
-0.0012000464,
-0.0054673553,
-0.0699244663,
-0.0362181962,
0.0398769118,
0.0516950488,
0.0103887748,
-0.0178992245,
-0.0237120241,
-0.0744980797,
-0.0577094741,
0.031918969,
-0.0040259277,
-0.0500727445,
-0.0028530166,
0.0912589803,
-0.0036071446,
-0.0650520846,
0.0129587622,
-0.0029964051,
-0.0420831889,
-0.0553906113,
0.0111917146,
-0.0411113314,
0.0154492613,
0.0151959844,
0.0075106006,
-0.0248638373,
0.0075912885,
-0.0085257934,
-0.0155128883,
0.0590669103,
0.0169840567,
-0.0360891856,
0.0221058503,
0.007212399,
-0.0187945794,
0.094968982,
-0.0055583203,
0.0272590593,
0.0093329754,
0.0375329107,
0.0072915852,
0.0668735281,
0.0484229587,
0.0535078868,
-0.0182886887,
0.0135189481,
0.0168035384,
-0.00488364,
0.0900834724,
0.0222789571,
-0.0541812368,
0.0005371444,
0.0484849587,
0.0081967264,
0.0212228764,
-0.015198268,
0.0153236119,
0.0247251503,
-0.0541163646,
0.0009837601,
-0.02889896,
0.0376224071,
-0.0514402017,
0.0065605366,
0.0431710966,
-0.0037431028,
-0.03061519,
-0.0021574125,
0.0196251385,
-0.0146348318,
-0.0216026418,
-0.0319961682,
0.0431872234,
0.0308600683,
-0.0791437179,
0.0106828529,
0.0061826766,
-0.0176671091,
0.0190591123,
-0.0044468455,
-0.0268600062,
0.0209177174,
0.0844014287,
0.0033265494,
-0.0197815243,
-0.0006799496,
-0.0082152486,
0.0712134615,
0.0082047656,
0.0276446473,
0.074463129,
-0.0296271238,
-0.0119766546,
-0.0230963696,
0.0277202576,
0.0217282437,
-0.0301733613,
0.0505698882,
0.030011382,
-0.0134607228,
-0.0047823088,
0.0421668775,
-0.0235591102,
-0.0740835518,
0.0321340002,
0.0060707051,
0.0360005908,
0.0033501771,
-0.0176935792,
0.0116769578,
0.0179637019,
-0.0533348061,
0.0137343323,
0.0111697372,
-0.070229575,
-0.1050419584,
0.02184912,
-0.0422087684,
0.0000133441,
0.0053560208,
-0.0261799619,
-0.0097299954,
0.0189713202,
-0.0056465454,
0.0704961941,
-0.0318903401,
0.0504250824,
-0.00044922,
-0.002186039,
-0.0525144525,
0.0347165279,
-0.0244300701,
-0.0125829456,
0.0212901607,
-0.0029751465,
0.0200165436,
-0.0357783921,
-0.0234325156,
0.0385261625,
-0.0012021827,
-0.010865204,
0.0092293238,
0.0417462774,
0.0055514546,
0.0140985223,
-0.0487676337,
0.0097760996,
-0.0406629145,
0.0206387602,
0.0556793064,
0.0273119006,
-0.0056661507,
-0.0249331146,
0.0181278195,
-0.0030530051,
0.0080733905,
0.0156978853,
0.0125214215,
0.0194866192,
-0.0106909638,
-0.0232560579,
-0.0128047643,
0.0098933466,
0.0394886024,
-0.0213067401,
0.0145253157,
-0.0727553219,
0.108705543,
0.0042239954,
0.0033638533,
0.0051101162,
-0.0473183841,
0.0079968181,
-0.0405516848,
-0.0203223024,
0.0430600755,
0.0016809001,
-0.00981142,
0.017657036,
-0.0023355545,
-0.0465492234,
-0.0243576095,
-0.0174443983,
-0.020183526,
-0.0072702668,
-0.0161474366,
0.0329531096,
0.0588890091,
-0.0022429025,
0.0338893309,
-0.0624376126,
0.0119542368,
0.0163932443,
-0.0540641919,
-0.0070193736,
0.0338706784,
-0.010467709,
0.0422910899,
-0.0313434005,
-0.0292611588,
0.0467563346,
-0.0365757272,
-0.0130370501,
-0.0358254872,
0.0276662521,
-0.0115851164,
0.0188786797,
-0.0294206254,
0.0094635403,
-0.0186716281,
-0.0434852727,
-0.0198364779,
0.0093224468,
0.0114082815,
0.0047152387,
-0.0217893012,
-0.0260857232,
0.0059934566,
-0.0370098352,
-0.013001156,
-0.0327823646,
-0.0444195457,
-0.0153242629,
-0.0211469047,
0.0114173312,
0.0070960009,
-0.0149898296,
0.0020433581,
-0.0210554972,
0.0836269557,
-0.0146562653,
-0.0086930292,
-0.0357050188,
0.0469181612,
0.0268540271,
-0.0606502071,
0.0094978306,
-0.0500278212,
0.031564083,
0.0244721491,
0.0141099105,
-0.0049031526,
-0.0279748458,
-0.004419466,
0.0649261326,
0.016501287,
-0.0305038244,
0.0211858954,
0.0382035114,
-0.0400362685,
-0.0221240558,
0.111478284,
0.0283048842,
-0.0638273507,
0.0136579275,
-0.0232776646,
0.0402169041,
0.0002077963,
-0.0039815237,
-0.1012889966,
-0.05814825,
0.0049466603,
0.0321447253,
0.0223591439,
0.0102246925,
-0.0236700624,
-0.1233495325,
0.0032532541,
0.0601332672,
-0.0450721644,
-0.0461187884,
0.003699823,
-0.0228803456,
-0.0542487018,
0.0210606437,
0.0314973742,
0.0172668528,
0.0005104606,
0.0015122584,
0.0468047038,
-0.0903560817,
0.0056752102,
-0.0668604225,
0.0542362966,
0.102870509,
0.0170266777,
0.0243495703,
0.0150758438,
0.021598462,
-0.0531860515,
0.0115708997,
-0.0309230797,
0.0265807696,
-0.0516162775,
-0.0100123277,
0.0248594396,
0.0149794053,
-0.039011687,
0.0048067505,
0.0040689399,
0.0322685651,
-0.02523572,
0.0221742187,
0.0075319353,
-0.0285732541,
0.0296315625,
0.0745982453,
0.0074314466,
-0.0530326813,
-0.0279027745,
-0.054622028,
0.0006922592,
-0.0851664916,
0.0046269237,
-0.0378403403,
-0.0009863976,
-0.0297516119,
-0.0597748943,
-0.0447883345,
0.0121926861,
0.0553690568,
-0.0422581919,
-0.0093213776,
-0.0598978139,
-0.0162756816,
-0.010569267,
-0.0020213104,
-0.0579440333,
0.0070375479,
-0.0628714189,
0.0509008095,
0.0127844503,
-0.0551826917,
0.0095778806,
0.0366392285,
-0.0732555687,
-0.0752713382,
0.0103770578,
0.0593473762,
0.024197435,
0.0574752986,
-0.0252381712,
-0.034648329,
0.0772326067,
0.022105366,
-0.0249175858,
0.0196681526,
0.0484144837,
-0.0020697969,
-0.0066634966,
0.0386785343,
-0.0139440214,
-0.0122160884,
0.0630715936,
0.0508417413,
-0.0492018908,
-0.0057606297,
0.0344824977,
-0.0171034094,
0.0595788471,
-0.0531544015,
-0.0563917086,
-0.0040851678,
0.0370297469,
-0.0416552834,
-0.002288929,
-0.0236430857,
-0.0099012451,
0.0442825444,
-0.0105174035,
-0.0049734022,
0.0202040225,
-0.0387159437,
0.0130078616,
0.0065793158,
0.0091033643,
0.0159391053,
0.0465343222,
0.0348808579,
0.0020878327,
-0.0084122065,
0.0332909226,
0.0012242853,
0.0207542013,
-0.0399492048,
0.0308259316,
0.014556489,
0.0223986097,
0.0005539824,
0.0469749905,
-0.0339798667,
0.0355190672,
-0.0423162468,
-0.035475485,
0.0779676959,
-0.0036882663,
0.0914846361,
0.0012998247,
-0.0090896077,
-0.0436875783,
0.0186993666,
-0.0230527911,
-0.027660897,
-0.0197582953,
0.015004579,
0.006771713,
0.0445832312,
0.0893875659,
0.0016934631,
0.0453216955,
-0.0027157597,
0.0340123288,
-0.0297166705,
0.0151612526,
0.0245732386,
0.0209531225,
-0.0202965513,
0.0032181088,
-0.0275842249,
-0.0441581942,
0.0101319253,
-0.0118221594,
-0.0122681372,
0.0147890262,
0.0143589433,
0.0350135118,
-0.047506284,
-0.0044325055,
-0.0248758998,
-0.0129517866,
0.0221370421,
-0.0207667388,
-0.0479299128,
-6.507323668e-33,
-0.0390939116,
-0.0177246463,
0.0199339483,
-0.0259298142,
0.0032083569,
-0.0052763866,
-0.0316360109,
-0.0048970967,
-0.0218709372,
-0.0240550376,
-0.0125128468,
0.0080033699,
0.0212164372,
0.019920323,
-0.023708079,
0.0034811811,
0.0669149458,
-0.0111610964,
-0.0434370637,
0.0022454741,
0.0237566847,
0.0464471728,
0.0285838358,
-0.0076673231,
0.0086283777,
-0.0321891159,
-0.049519632,
0.0262817796,
0.0296966452,
0.0145933302,
-0.0178735852,
-0.002501911,
0.0134401973,
-0.0155866984,
-0.0359205343,
-0.0359590091,
-0.0426401384,
0.0156388376,
0.0004354332,
0.0402452387,
-0.0020621307,
-0.066343233,
-0.0090617975,
-0.0162190869,
-0.0632323697,
0.0040784823,
-0.0264188088,
-0.0383595414,
-0.0217295941,
0.0046999105,
-0.0547687225,
0.027874928,
-0.0230400003,
-0.0228877738,
0.0420266911,
0.0477418974,
0.0096892649,
0.0530603416,
-0.0791113973,
0.0299463794,
-0.0214564055,
0.0435038619,
0.0917143822,
0.0211868752,
-0.0046164035,
0.0147386231,
0.0552087538,
-0.011559207,
0.0307309795,
-0.029304916,
0.0434628911,
-0.0222606976,
0.0284001101,
0.0603618659,
0.1023596525,
0.0018669337,
-0.0429044478,
0.0190531723,
-0.0278884321,
0.0318797007,
0.0330474973,
0.0618759245,
-0.0061035231,
-0.0099758189,
-0.027020812,
-0.0949813351,
-0.0406141728,
-0.0234153569,
0.0232281778,
0.0376649089,
-0.0333598107,
-0.0101711396,
0.1114525273,
-0.0214391202,
0.0536624417,
0.0480047204,
-0.0179699305,
0.0096814577,
-0.0235408563,
0.0441732779,
-0.0455958582,
0.0017714625,
0.042556271,
-0.017467957,
-0.0011603371,
-0.0255128611,
0.0261173621,
0.0213330761,
-0.0489092134,
-0.0196233355,
-0.0334831774,
-0.0167005025,
0.0119693996,
0.0413784273,
0.0373486131,
-0.0307405014,
0.0075215697,
0.0471911095,
0.0264356118,
-0.0229623988,
-0.0362960733,
-0.0048320959,
0.0156459082,
0.0309435967,
-0.0529929027,
0.0176038798,
0.0002824881,
0.0133291027,
0.0271869134,
-0.0589914992,
-0.0457765497,
0.013518679,
2.702e-7,
0.0535451844,
0.0670400932,
0.018379394,
0.0317096189,
0.0059962696,
0.0430773944,
-0.017924631,
0.020528147,
-0.002013396,
0.0234639551,
0.0324264094,
0.0249918923,
0.060964603,
-0.0020118214,
-0.0643715188,
0.0427207127,
-0.0164631512,
0.017487932,
-0.0350988545,
-0.0286197402,
0.0348036774,
0.0886957943,
-0.0264055841,
0.0008727929,
0.0161723122,
-0.0170686357,
0.0510007106,
0.0170107987,
-0.0234679934,
-0.0180233065,
-0.04156854,
0.0087777758,
-0.0389482453,
-0.0232950468,
-0.0199347287,
0.0066014603,
0.0084578563,
0.0658248365,
-0.0069223423,
-0.0868077204,
0.0177344084,
0.0359061658,
-0.0257748123,
-0.0035086675,
0.0719157606,
-0.0154242236,
0.0030834554,
-0.0085807731,
-0.0650415272,
0.0226089973,
0.016358532,
-0.0500282422,
-0.0334592573,
0.0034689489,
0.0502814241,
0.0294422414,
-0.0484343059,
-0.0245441776,
-0.0412869528,
-0.0172066446,
-0.0065734149,
-0.0277081709,
-0.0112462724,
0.0274430253,
0.046719972,
-0.03917614,
0.0176291745,
2.632806814e-34,
0.0532000996,
-0.0304139704,
0.0224247947,
0.0126234805,
0.013319917,
0.0113807116,
-0.0488804951,
0.0271552503,
0.0320990272,
-0.0566477403,
-0.024977535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08323v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08323v2 | The taste of IPA: Towards open-vocabulary keyword spotting and forced alignment in any language | 2023-11-14T17:09:07 | 2024-04-01T23:10:59 | Jian Zhu, Changbing Yang, Farhan Samir, Jahurul Islam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In this project, we demonstrate that phoneme-based models for speech
processing can achieve strong crosslinguistic generalizability to unseen
languages. We curated the IPAPACK, a massively multilingual speech corpora with
phonemic transcriptions, encompassing more than 115 languages from diverse
language families, selectively checked by linguists. Based on the IPAPACK, we
propose CLAP-IPA, a multi-lingual phoneme-speech contrastive embedding model
capable of open-vocabulary matching between arbitrary speech signals and
phonemic sequences. The proposed model was tested on 95 unseen languages,
showing strong generalizability across languages. Temporal alignments between
phonemes and speech signals also emerged from contrastive training, enabling
zeroshot forced alignment in unseen languages. We further introduced a neural
forced aligner IPA-ALIGNER by finetuning CLAP-IPA with the Forward-Sum loss to
learn better phone-to-audio alignment. Evaluation results suggest that
IPA-ALIGNER can generalize to unseen languages without adaptation. | [
-0.0494729131,
0.0868270397,
0.0191171616,
0.0307431109,
-0.0294242483,
-0.0114431353,
-0.0090220766,
-0.0056248317,
-0.0230168868,
0.0275987871,
-0.0889511853,
-0.0653591901,
0.0576148927,
0.0098585896,
0.0423382968,
-0.0101580499,
0.0451627821,
-0.0152102159,
-0.0108083477,
0.0049337056,
0.0298718009,
0.0260093324,
-0.0343337245,
0.03837635,
-0.0179979056,
-0.0127067845,
-0.0206085611,
0.0162333697,
0.0295666382,
-0.0184713956,
-0.002112837,
0.0063389912,
-0.0064710933,
0.0715606958,
0.0000015139,
-0.0230825394,
-0.000829321,
0.003978617,
-0.025080448,
0.0053302152,
-0.0233917367,
-0.0198523346,
-0.0406628139,
0.0504039973,
0.0004828142,
-0.0492389016,
0.1052486598,
0.0091970712,
0.0011053106,
0.063766405,
-0.0138167758,
-0.0562547594,
0.0656819716,
-0.0443319716,
-0.0500809103,
0.0258022752,
-0.0064026257,
-0.0916617736,
-0.0296571087,
-0.0574141741,
0.0015433603,
0.0450956561,
-0.0098816454,
0.0233924165,
-0.000061748,
0.0148967393,
-0.023550665,
-0.0487228967,
-0.0221610032,
0.0829269215,
-0.0368310288,
-0.0229859613,
-0.0218022056,
-0.0051544281,
-0.0373841524,
-0.0380329043,
-0.0395021923,
0.0240423977,
0.0336876772,
0.0348318554,
0.0467536524,
0.035962034,
0.0561622791,
-0.0201643817,
-0.0016944422,
0.0010392773,
0.070247978,
-0.0623877607,
-0.0094659459,
-0.0166132022,
-0.0310341679,
-0.0224268474,
0.0351031609,
0.0147343306,
-0.0206588712,
0.004429556,
-0.0143044088,
-0.0519987606,
0.0217599832,
-0.0280059408,
0.0219986439,
0.0703662932,
-0.0727416426,
0.0377741158,
-0.0126351239,
0.0559458919,
-0.0461700074,
-0.0134686707,
-0.0097689666,
-0.052644331,
0.009950093,
-0.0043351934,
0.025465956,
-0.0185709,
-0.0159357432,
-0.0195761397,
-0.016332062,
-0.0090059824,
-0.0003350694,
0.0473191701,
0.0072144694,
-0.0084936516,
-0.0480398647,
-0.0067872452,
0.0236327536,
0.0583246537,
-0.0007069081,
0.0181163177,
-0.0473430008,
-0.0410018526,
-0.0244871732,
0.0514173657,
0.0267274007,
-0.0022478749,
0.0209846236,
0.0414576791,
-0.0024526773,
-0.0390719026,
-0.0012246007,
0.0238869134,
-0.0591715947,
0.0026272659,
-0.0221463144,
-0.0515575036,
0.0393195935,
-0.0311934948,
-0.0078646457,
-0.0417396985,
0.0056123827,
0.0081484187,
0.0123144584,
0.0819680169,
-0.0021124121,
0.0088744592,
-0.0245510601,
-0.038671948,
0.0112816757,
0.0374757275,
0.0336970016,
-0.0694970265,
0.0324758179,
-0.0180106796,
-0.0310282279,
0.0834116414,
0.0129770096,
0.0275373235,
-0.0432607196,
-0.007413954,
0.0608407147,
0.062436305,
0.0578489266,
0.0338294022,
0.0147140156,
-0.0221561585,
0.036542058,
0.101234585,
0.0495568067,
0.0129875271,
-0.0069648135,
-0.0085481433,
-0.0437061489,
0.02241317,
0.0066543212,
0.0277710222,
0.0189544633,
0.0436122008,
0.0673039034,
0.0493515693,
-0.0373846665,
0.0140482495,
-0.0021675562,
-0.0304466467,
-0.0316070244,
-0.00568168,
0.0473015457,
-0.0087458845,
-0.049037952,
0.0385821685,
0.0571425073,
-0.0199540444,
0.0055757086,
-0.0102610718,
0.0448298752,
0.0436152257,
0.0105913086,
-0.0279275943,
-0.0073226388,
-0.0201646667,
-0.0470517948,
0.0934025124,
0.0285598673,
0.0055642789,
0.0407885835,
-0.0535533987,
-0.0133513296,
0.0285473168,
-0.0034666553,
0.0502676442,
-0.0112214843,
0.0461900458,
0.0075665577,
0.0003329411,
0.0117080798,
0.0015535998,
-0.0722096339,
-0.0289476495,
0.0090959929,
0.0146455746,
0.027346693,
0.0368600935,
-0.0367913432,
0.0151556805,
0.0132029112,
-0.0573580228,
0.0745879337,
0.0331240892,
-0.0482310429,
0.0145064099,
0.0635215715,
-0.0236992128,
-0.0058172485,
0.0583862253,
0.0160097219,
-0.0855121315,
0.0499597974,
0.0209439527,
0.0771921724,
-0.0509587526,
0.0526687354,
0.009792693,
0.0215798952,
0.0206603613,
-0.0123155825,
0.0178480633,
0.0021633559,
0.0133508956,
-0.0096427584,
0.0270767957,
-0.0100653023,
-0.0171084367,
0.0575359985,
0.0054964321,
0.0138516296,
0.0042296476,
-0.0234178919,
-0.0123644583,
-0.0049597155,
-0.0998925939,
0.0574313328,
-0.0145475576,
0.0249451566,
0.0101420544,
0.0387333818,
0.0180066954,
-0.0201639645,
-0.0530405454,
-0.0232890081,
0.0173343252,
-0.0252357032,
-0.018006552,
0.0009562218,
-0.0437470935,
-0.0723849088,
0.0036530735,
0.0259771198,
0.0200987477,
-0.0410143957,
-0.0379178748,
0.0006991039,
-0.0118814576,
0.0079137841,
0.0230793897,
0.0107245259,
-0.0444158763,
-0.0181828048,
0.0159879364,
0.0392292216,
0.0163169317,
-0.0332766846,
-0.0760093257,
0.0062390901,
-0.0242319293,
-0.0596534535,
-0.0173557885,
0.0282282755,
0.0071852491,
-0.0063893911,
0.0368555859,
-0.0391357653,
0.103265442,
-0.0277678762,
0.0069174613,
-0.0501586273,
-0.0474566929,
0.0049258177,
-0.0128591433,
-0.0029573664,
-0.0044567096,
-0.0637050793,
0.0164502971,
-0.0690011308,
-0.0503340848,
0.0358845852,
-0.0777759328,
-0.031507466,
-0.02511256,
-0.055840265,
-0.0305046383,
0.0090529779,
-0.0378410704,
-0.002489852,
0.0023342439,
-0.0221401844,
-0.0480751134,
0.0030012236,
-0.0132138375,
-0.0349403396,
0.0653284341,
-0.0067534186,
-0.0026732888,
-0.0137065314,
-0.0525168628,
-0.0502678938,
-0.0267174058,
-0.0421085916,
0.0277833454,
0.0139978901,
-0.0585174412,
-0.0156671554,
0.0082649151,
0.0252100937,
0.0529946946,
0.034768831,
0.0508282743,
-0.02723708,
0.0639088377,
0.0264954511,
-0.0059846612,
-0.0042288932,
-0.0081356764,
0.0232354291,
-0.0270633679,
0.0708586052,
0.0469858609,
-0.0340313762,
-0.0349634849,
0.0488244928,
-0.0052756923,
-0.0526587926,
-0.0190831032,
-0.0158157293,
0.0068545556,
0.0044762311,
0.0948217362,
0.0054154731,
-0.0295425076,
0.001841351,
-0.0165684931,
0.0465154275,
-0.0001801972,
0.003751898,
-0.062461812,
-0.053164877,
0.0275277421,
-0.0160950739,
0.0439915359,
0.0426881425,
-0.0113107124,
-0.1193025261,
-0.0335899517,
0.0485839024,
0.0011518876,
-0.0499167442,
-0.0107388869,
0.0086673619,
-0.0437573977,
0.0406693071,
0.0044925031,
0.0118633276,
-0.017189214,
0.0233588498,
0.0162472501,
-0.0620563999,
-0.0045949034,
-0.0941331089,
0.0646757782,
0.0610611439,
0.0256988667,
-0.0262240954,
-0.0706660673,
0.03896093,
-0.0308394693,
-0.0315741673,
0.0297415815,
-0.0151319942,
-0.0091594392,
-0.0335100926,
0.0052560009,
0.0091450699,
-0.0261321031,
0.0109028453,
0.0077198693,
0.0843336135,
0.0381378122,
0.0687216669,
0.0245611724,
0.0089093009,
-0.0113028334,
0.0395215526,
-0.0009528107,
-0.0447371863,
-0.0021987834,
0.0251486357,
0.0234500226,
-0.0504736938,
-0.0257247481,
0.0332488865,
0.0053498312,
-0.0491037183,
-0.0389321484,
0.0067341086,
-0.0232778266,
0.019775752,
0.0471507274,
-0.0043342141,
-0.044016853,
-0.0290954392,
-0.0483047292,
0.0437358208,
0.026375819,
0.0519534238,
-0.0816093758,
0.0052504176,
0.0297275148,
-0.0516345911,
0.0056210323,
0.0169236436,
-0.0259516612,
-0.0657660663,
-0.0051984238,
-0.0080419071,
0.0116034895,
0.0778429285,
-0.0438137166,
-0.002091212,
0.0468012244,
0.0032667872,
-0.043749053,
0.0170100518,
0.0441439748,
-0.0189752672,
0.009582378,
0.0446045175,
-0.0468697362,
-0.0198582243,
0.0069820043,
-0.0024046833,
-0.0199315697,
-0.053633824,
0.0010481107,
-0.0229886211,
0.0597063527,
-0.0289678089,
0.0145123675,
-0.0646973327,
-0.002617602,
0.0583543777,
0.0314756818,
-0.0182914119,
-0.0295138918,
0.0442000069,
0.0041699759,
0.0000211588,
0.0248743463,
-0.0217287242,
-0.0213516988,
-0.0043482045,
0.0295303948,
0.0192981865,
0.0154298451,
-0.003365427,
0.0277606398,
-0.0094507271,
0.0743378848,
-0.0512974672,
0.0337552167,
0.0008264086,
-0.0039618122,
-0.0337064192,
0.0261252467,
0.0427464433,
0.0084457146,
-0.0111275408,
0.0059730257,
0.0230631828,
-0.0151542313,
0.0796887353,
-0.0358627886,
0.0254262034,
0.0121742589,
0.0062908218,
-0.0027508899,
0.0330640711,
-0.0839400887,
-0.0014084515,
0.0189157706,
0.0212072413,
-0.0183559004,
0.005929125,
0.0520241968,
-0.0216110479,
0.0091371182,
-0.0236938782,
0.055562593,
-0.0040324843,
-0.0082389172,
0.0474898629,
0.0151576176,
-0.0384555683,
-0.0008955733,
-0.0103151072,
-0.0734283701,
0.0060635321,
0.0111803291,
-0.0066222101,
0.0202470459,
-0.013254012,
0.014682604,
-0.0229127295,
0.0452454165,
0.0304506626,
-0.0575740933,
-0.0125961751,
-0.0400591642,
0.0075926878,
-5.633064071e-33,
-0.0104807001,
0.0311834235,
-0.0078360811,
-0.0312902927,
-0.0342936069,
0.025818646,
0.0009260277,
-0.0006854489,
-0.0265629739,
-0.0408132188,
-0.0148895876,
0.0239006784,
0.0046950728,
0.030335851,
0.0204179455,
-0.0084991716,
0.0522157513,
0.0018914591,
0.0341390744,
-0.0223631114,
0.0346344709,
0.0257122144,
0.0486174859,
-0.0182228312,
-0.022526579,
0.00464263,
0.0170257054,
0.0120051596,
0.0036734655,
0.0549904481,
-0.0346581303,
0.0044101984,
-0.034186475,
-0.0107741533,
-0.0179465283,
0.0328531787,
-0.0673409179,
0.0252054296,
0.0392254926,
0.0677284524,
-0.0009445919,
-0.0281939525,
0.0290518068,
-0.0316908844,
0.0153806377,
-0.0016092622,
0.0051323036,
-0.0352339037,
0.0079709766,
0.022001138,
-0.0137479808,
0.0410622731,
-0.0036844423,
-0.0278748814,
0.0515021682,
0.0418387242,
0.0094598262,
-0.0101415776,
-0.0805811062,
0.0183084328,
-0.0002526668,
0.0351215713,
0.0725101307,
0.0279850028,
-0.0077378778,
0.0434685647,
0.0347779058,
-0.1031574458,
0.0465162508,
-0.0557261221,
0.0100854207,
-0.0186863728,
0.024289446,
0.0350908153,
0.0512881652,
0.0041970895,
-0.0282556824,
-0.030611014,
0.0266324747,
-0.0445719026,
0.0155627718,
0.0236118231,
-0.0303179603,
0.0031035056,
-0.0106733786,
-0.0406136364,
-0.046168942,
-0.0164228883,
0.021938229,
-0.0059716664,
0.0161472689,
-0.0027692057,
0.0650422201,
-0.0000267478,
0.0546197705,
0.0024587698,
0.0078180404,
-0.011893969,
-0.0247602146,
0.036421217,
-0.0864761025,
-0.0299183559,
0.027994154,
0.014235328,
0.0222736858,
0.0082538258,
0.0169347282,
0.0094744489,
-0.0609244071,
0.0027291982,
-0.0266777538,
-0.0103367576,
0.0047346014,
0.0049595404,
0.0739312917,
0.0170347299,
0.0013332762,
0.05150773,
0.0098112589,
0.0003992538,
-0.0024892457,
-0.0439618565,
-0.044774387,
0.0227404125,
-0.0342726447,
0.0179495532,
0.0131937303,
0.0094667058,
-0.0071996539,
-0.0152779007,
-0.0061172624,
0.0246692114,
2.422e-7,
-0.007325667,
-0.0596736148,
0.0439433679,
0.0163480155,
0.0221913345,
0.033164762,
-0.0402398035,
0.0163317043,
-0.0521518849,
-0.0102627249,
-0.0066856919,
-0.0218844805,
0.0764372423,
0.003289853,
-0.0807940364,
-0.0167329013,
-0.0814224482,
0.0412520654,
-0.0510558225,
-0.0221182723,
0.001994089,
0.1183821857,
0.001975362,
-0.0286049619,
0.0030337269,
-0.0170240626,
0.0320184045,
-0.0231005382,
-0.0003693298,
-0.0689870194,
-0.0314840116,
0.0039698035,
-0.0275315326,
0.0084660649,
-0.0425955281,
0.0822700039,
0.0344929397,
0.0087268697,
0.0064329761,
-0.0441730693,
-0.0091610895,
0.0314105526,
-0.0713597685,
-0.042178195,
0.0590486601,
0.0076719057,
-0.0384679362,
-0.0117172357,
-0.0477132313,
0.002882889,
0.0181294866,
-0.0128810173,
0.0115806339,
0.004137096,
0.0306518767,
-0.0279182736,
-0.0506758243,
-0.0120670442,
-0.0431580432,
0.0324819162,
-0.0002278191,
0.0070916405,
-0.0367165916,
-0.0162736997,
0.0204692464,
0.0128187556,
0.017460458,
1.919673077e-34,
0.0188337658,
-0.0310868919,
0.0216239579,
0.005181225,
-0.0029398652,
-0.0594011955,
0.0251973718,
0.0142237609,
0.0680628493,
-0.0126048895,
-0.0263018757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09252v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09252v1 | In the Red(dit): Social Media and Stock Prices | 2023-11-14T16:58:41 | 2023-11-14T16:58:41 | James Baker | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CE, cs.CL | Spearheaded by retail traders on the website reddit, the GameStop short
squeeze of early 2021 shows that social media embeds information that
correlates with market movements. This paper seeks to examine this relationship
by using daily frequencies of classified comments and buzzwords as additional
factors in a Fama-French three factor model. Comments are classified using an
unsupervised clustering method, while past studies have used pretrained models
that are not specific to the domains being studied. | [
0.0461938567,
0.0223485604,
-0.0263764914,
-0.0274398234,
0.0114720184,
-0.0069770184,
0.0381082408,
0.0441208445,
-0.0076808124,
-0.0757057741,
0.0061721453,
0.0022206572,
-0.0136127863,
0.0370648466,
0.0177362375,
-0.0291849524,
0.0134619698,
0.0035693694,
0.0274801124,
-0.0122058932,
0.051003471,
-0.0032177018,
0.0273372084,
0.0072747227,
-0.0385119095,
0.0175947323,
0.0115899201,
-0.0216344018,
-0.0027807483,
-0.0108262384,
0.0104132816,
0.0464270972,
0.0291788485,
0.0188678186,
0.0000017435,
-0.0287244897,
-0.0209447481,
-0.0282303859,
0.0657492951,
0.017176602,
0.0467012748,
-0.0495960638,
0.0590346232,
0.0175084379,
-0.069570452,
0.0030091561,
0.063937068,
0.0693886355,
0.031997554,
0.058124315,
-0.0292117838,
-0.049490273,
-0.0359239578,
-0.043810524,
0.0034839907,
-0.0438891202,
0.0325997956,
0.0385374203,
-0.0584551468,
0.0187607557,
0.015069508,
0.0156245967,
-0.0384665318,
0.0536170639,
0.0335131064,
0.0077867866,
0.0223773755,
0.0079788314,
-0.004078038,
0.0007059074,
0.0462075695,
0.0161276925,
0.0265555419,
0.0295993742,
0.0092104869,
0.0632558838,
-0.0436366498,
0.0039536105,
0.0115812747,
0.0285931546,
0.0139020514,
0.0317950137,
0.0197975542,
-0.0120463576,
0.0252626762,
0.0043325727,
-0.0442993231,
-0.047192201,
0.010688398,
0.0176299773,
-0.0029458334,
-0.0062399018,
0.0193834323,
-0.0193922725,
0.0479082577,
-0.0131260315,
0.0009929193,
-0.0079076057,
0.0435638949,
-0.1152672172,
-0.0818507373,
-0.0078952378,
0.0109660402,
0.0649454519,
0.0074981893,
-0.076171726,
0.0152275087,
-0.0730932206,
0.024686072,
0.0351491496,
-0.0797538906,
0.0287457351,
0.0193244442,
0.0495647267,
-0.0105842622,
-0.030570576,
-0.024117142,
0.0069961348,
-0.0180381853,
-0.0451976806,
-0.0018428622,
-0.0192226302,
0.0347185321,
0.0364559405,
-0.0125040067,
-0.0307646394,
-0.0844464526,
0.0568912663,
-0.0261607561,
-0.0066553704,
0.0514759012,
-0.0147211906,
0.031625662,
-0.0151873846,
-0.0344931893,
0.0447517261,
0.0387928672,
-0.0523351058,
-0.0789312795,
-0.0636330619,
0.0324210562,
0.013669786,
-0.0088507077,
-0.0239531305,
-0.0328855328,
-0.0134828538,
0.0122853843,
0.065510042,
0.0066339886,
-0.0020931638,
-0.0536370948,
0.0312747844,
-0.059882503,
0.0083407247,
0.0420110933,
-0.007602531,
0.0367590263,
0.0646403506,
-0.0540665388,
-0.015711857,
0.0807443038,
-0.0306645408,
0.007851433,
0.0473088399,
0.0081493082,
-0.0617714934,
-0.0238514803,
-0.017031515,
-0.0432382263,
-0.0644684955,
0.0084607676,
0.0131412502,
-0.0083458303,
0.0232200939,
0.0177688338,
0.05789854,
-0.0168438703,
0.0554193743,
-0.0230809506,
0.0129271075,
-0.0254157167,
-0.0420166403,
0.0465452746,
-0.0265224893,
-0.0470843278,
0.0199932288,
0.0871567577,
0.0055478169,
-0.0590952039,
-0.0414828211,
0.0414579846,
-0.0092549957,
0.0478586257,
-0.0606088266,
0.029327089,
-0.0814360157,
-0.0091641238,
0.014245172,
0.0355504565,
0.0129031753,
-0.0146739893,
-0.004288319,
0.0295406263,
0.0467459187,
-0.0337692201,
-0.0102197332,
0.0648074448,
-0.025384333,
0.0377993211,
0.0101341372,
0.0011867334,
0.0381118022,
-0.0843911693,
-0.0369086005,
0.0026612577,
0.0224329848,
0.0595671423,
-0.0319236591,
-0.0189558752,
0.0010508534,
-0.0274736006,
0.0190128405,
0.0130192917,
0.0000471424,
0.0992089957,
-0.0158727486,
-0.0316632055,
-0.0043220543,
0.020091176,
0.0308237355,
0.0053509003,
-0.0218493771,
0.015785668,
0.0000216694,
-0.0383527204,
-0.023418881,
0.0156143671,
0.0295753051,
-0.0199120063,
-0.0346091092,
-0.0106445765,
0.031007966,
-0.0059952298,
0.0076400945,
0.0903513283,
-0.025218334,
0.1031709239,
-0.0127447983,
-0.0864031911,
-0.0036867277,
0.0311969128,
0.0238720551,
0.0320616439,
-0.0453870781,
0.0275078155,
-0.0740337297,
-0.0535694361,
-0.012043396,
0.0458120778,
0.0430815592,
-0.0473048799,
-0.0391243137,
0.0672946051,
0.0375969447,
-0.0467406139,
0.0085541112,
-0.019978255,
-0.0571467392,
-0.0815344378,
-0.0309836045,
-0.0157920085,
0.01235676,
-0.0010794401,
-0.0258622263,
0.0061214906,
0.0053245462,
-0.0018112839,
0.0055961586,
0.0183660481,
0.0419342816,
-0.0079261586,
-0.0038752055,
-0.0452735946,
-0.0414699614,
0.0002641972,
0.0035196908,
0.0751210377,
-0.0927264914,
0.0347292572,
0.0235992502,
-0.0442549512,
-0.0151504241,
-0.0128842397,
0.0092601245,
-0.0107900752,
-0.0244093519,
0.0154019836,
0.0395094678,
0.0456769429,
0.0416771583,
-0.0303903706,
-0.0058996161,
0.002825594,
-0.0117434636,
-0.0567766093,
0.0169360563,
-0.020939894,
-0.0267920848,
0.035169892,
0.0401727781,
0.0177343357,
-0.0142992074,
-0.0680954009,
0.0388137475,
-0.0253929403,
0.0206249859,
-0.0218605362,
0.0055324151,
-0.0171361379,
0.0640656874,
0.0188395455,
-0.0675464347,
0.0057240389,
0.0229049437,
0.0364489295,
0.0150389075,
-0.0824172497,
-0.030519288,
-0.0144064827,
-0.0070183147,
-0.0294503048,
-0.0296112224,
-0.013021308,
0.0689217225,
-0.0095449882,
0.0076633431,
-0.0179365724,
0.0261793602,
0.0123230945,
0.0338596404,
0.0343329087,
0.0264648143,
0.0220347792,
-0.1000721008,
-0.0577704385,
0.0011931041,
0.0527778454,
-0.023117397,
-0.0399241671,
0.0495671034,
-0.031667117,
-0.0423504636,
0.0061228876,
-0.0515496694,
0.055848781,
0.0259042978,
0.0100827226,
-0.0397211835,
-0.0080848541,
-0.0495761707,
-0.0036616954,
0.0171434339,
0.031903632,
-0.0490195565,
-0.0176519882,
-0.0264138822,
-0.0203317218,
0.016848281,
0.0438968204,
-0.0153998397,
-0.0179290175,
0.0298535228,
0.0357070491,
0.0731918588,
-0.0098757399,
0.0084699551,
0.0240602866,
0.0476366468,
0.0082156081,
-0.0001110481,
-0.0122697344,
-0.0306699555,
-0.0014540179,
-0.0348233022,
0.004936554,
0.0324879475,
-0.0180678144,
-0.0095093772,
-0.1117878854,
0.0532442331,
0.0013765343,
-0.0095126033,
-0.0148021784,
-0.0484564938,
0.0082119033,
-0.0488878936,
-0.0253777131,
-0.0400941409,
-0.0299629495,
0.0323459245,
0.0128626749,
-0.0899974108,
-0.0221243054,
-0.0010401363,
-0.0295591559,
0.01077196,
-0.0142469332,
-0.0198384412,
-0.0285180043,
0.0106547689,
0.002558463,
0.0108430814,
0.0235904325,
-0.0253332537,
0.0533697791,
-0.0546627417,
0.0041845897,
-0.0109501109,
0.024670532,
-0.0304373242,
0.0570237339,
0.0164704379,
-0.0071002343,
0.003459645,
-0.0706859231,
-0.0079306895,
0.0547805391,
-0.0112975463,
0.0209751874,
0.0314080529,
-0.0123235779,
0.0179542098,
-0.0269368775,
0.0458280072,
-0.007690785,
-0.0419492014,
-0.0794152021,
-0.0043592872,
-0.0258680545,
-0.0677089319,
-0.036260251,
-0.0399363227,
0.0387103185,
-0.0106229577,
0.021801414,
0.0062728501,
-0.0081860218,
-0.0245653335,
0.0339038298,
0.0366212204,
-0.035877496,
-0.0192461144,
-0.0119569981,
0.0245420486,
0.0042963866,
-0.0378775857,
-0.0301912837,
-0.0530174896,
-0.0277249701,
0.0047689541,
0.0257950481,
0.0260417759,
-0.0136157572,
-0.0074865464,
-0.0125285452,
0.0121647203,
0.0601073429,
-0.0794246867,
-0.0208478682,
0.0407377928,
0.0105105788,
0.0218106937,
-0.0049736863,
0.0039567547,
0.0446718968,
-0.0287584774,
-0.0262493603,
-0.0955724195,
-0.0092873499,
-0.0490025282,
-0.0497666039,
0.1059740856,
0.0310621634,
-0.0077161221,
-0.0326429754,
-0.0588090196,
0.030280428,
0.0089457594,
0.0060665291,
-0.0419815704,
-0.000507666,
0.0258088298,
-0.0491632558,
0.0186024569,
-0.0171385948,
-0.028468417,
-0.0018338503,
-0.0065574609,
0.0137341451,
0.038229838,
-0.0393756256,
0.0308333635,
-0.0026979349,
-0.0006925898,
0.0104830451,
-0.0223700069,
-0.0025501873,
0.0184821468,
-0.0010233673,
0.0094651245,
0.0108000906,
0.0017659882,
-0.0320712626,
-0.0085421987,
0.0261636246,
0.0147979567,
-0.0132508148,
-0.0671566278,
0.0322338156,
-0.0110274004,
0.0098822694,
0.0080833361,
0.0367002487,
-0.0453453846,
0.002386237,
0.0085699838,
0.008904973,
-0.0747023672,
0.0184930936,
0.0636331066,
-0.0003706026,
-0.0185060389,
0.0152276605,
-0.0456140861,
-0.0324619301,
0.0136875473,
0.0582655817,
0.0299852807,
0.0211689584,
0.014536486,
-0.0387527011,
-0.0391766578,
0.0147016272,
-0.0173364673,
0.0143328682,
0.0393084697,
0.0245528053,
0.0562993735,
0.0107656019,
0.0566375181,
-0.0038806829,
-0.0055953651,
-0.0515713431,
-0.0105366092,
-0.0435285009,
-6.710949411e-33,
0.0161725003,
-0.0353077687,
-0.0255860575,
0.0311098713,
-0.0193515178,
0.0566574,
0.0026373183,
0.0497512668,
0.0314095803,
0.0004153263,
0.0254500434,
0.0321312547,
0.0180346817,
-0.0030624827,
0.052058395,
-0.0084286686,
-0.0086005004,
-0.0132954651,
0.024533283,
0.0071941875,
0.0134592811,
0.0366407037,
-0.0099116052,
-0.0144154644,
-0.0168210566,
-0.028318001,
-0.0196623392,
-0.0037552591,
0.0924663171,
0.0422726609,
-0.0146836871,
0.0475558229,
0.0508949161,
-0.024789067,
-0.0032966854,
0.0510561019,
-0.0050954795,
-0.0505590402,
0.0214546062,
-0.0336430445,
0.0052893385,
0.0328998081,
0.0564238876,
0.0290526338,
-0.0085024452,
0.0496414676,
0.0664803162,
0.0145052122,
0.0066653439,
0.0124369869,
-0.0403509922,
0.0408603922,
-0.032183107,
0.0555889122,
0.0247884449,
0.105602093,
0.047262568,
0.0316074789,
-0.0539532341,
0.0522638932,
-0.0297679957,
0.0199736524,
-0.0065247137,
-0.0007746523,
-0.0060672872,
0.041295927,
-0.0233620293,
0.0396703035,
-0.0195910819,
0.0480994768,
0.0195824094,
0.0413842574,
0.0179257095,
0.0613976642,
0.0159689523,
-0.0644349381,
-0.026875833,
0.0038294918,
0.0110601205,
-0.0435858369,
0.0332970507,
0.0059511233,
-0.0385151021,
-0.0347139277,
0.0226418395,
0.0415594094,
-0.0187902022,
-0.0237239674,
-0.0187715758,
0.0240601692,
-0.0344056301,
0.0193101484,
0.0337979421,
-0.0004182519,
-0.0807275549,
-0.0256840084,
0.0140923783,
0.0443792902,
-0.0080120377,
-0.0327735059,
-0.0296243895,
0.014318984,
-0.0001553556,
0.0133789331,
-0.0085592493,
-0.069368504,
-0.0171129312,
-0.0076315305,
-0.0218262002,
-0.0314945094,
0.0473196059,
0.006886445,
-0.0141925886,
-0.03305877,
0.0292042419,
0.0209948458,
0.0158552304,
0.0425074473,
0.0220516771,
0.0487766452,
0.0336473249,
0.0025778385,
-0.0609035529,
-0.0024632034,
0.0073536374,
-0.0122222006,
0.0004831061,
0.0246098712,
0.0125259012,
-0.0464614145,
-0.0134747457,
0.0082794251,
2.559e-7,
0.0516055226,
0.074260518,
-0.0129635455,
-0.0507350229,
0.0328039341,
0.0501740947,
-0.0120990826,
-0.004182158,
0.0112005621,
-0.0165652037,
0.0284666177,
0.0420076624,
-0.0066877562,
0.030632671,
-0.0247545335,
-0.0869395435,
-0.0383026861,
0.0175261907,
-0.0641900897,
0.0198966991,
-0.0304769333,
0.0354096368,
0.031593021,
-0.004756636,
-0.0638844818,
-0.0535481088,
0.0278992821,
-0.0647456795,
-0.0420516729,
-0.0008515017,
-0.0155458366,
0.0267419256,
-0.0371193923,
0.0186229907,
-0.0027621964,
-0.0278298389,
0.0038484405,
-0.0422695652,
0.0210981313,
0.0482088216,
0.0547878295,
0.0086941859,
-0.0230508,
-0.0183483064,
0.0060244622,
-0.0539627969,
-0.0422436707,
-0.0507793613,
-0.0359060876,
0.0246840436,
0.0522451513,
0.0125032263,
-0.0502923504,
0.0209067371,
-0.0163447466,
0.0175167099,
0.022132216,
-0.0346169844,
0.0365316719,
-0.0102552883,
-0.0653819814,
0.0118900137,
0.0268457476,
0.0067578764,
0.012845885,
0.0758405179,
0.0812053159,
1.570853623e-34,
0.0563491248,
-0.042637784,
-0.0074065491,
-0.0046088784,
0.0285293758,
0.0052957004,
-0.0591731295,
-0.0122120818,
0.0152527681,
-0.059332259,
0.0165848769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08306v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08306v2 | On-the-Fly Fusion of Large Language Models and Machine Translation | 2023-11-14T16:49:33 | 2024-05-06T17:13:27 | Hieu Hoang, Huda Khayrallah, Marcin Junczys-Dowmunt | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose the on-the-fly ensembling of a machine translation model with an
LLM, prompted on the same task and input. We perform experiments on 4 language
pairs (both directions) with varying data amounts. We find that a slightly
weaker-at-translation LLM can improve translations of a NMT model, and
ensembling with an LLM can produce better translations than ensembling two
stronger MT models. We combine our method with various techniques from LLM
prompting, such as in context learning and translation context. | [
-0.0115226861,
0.0370598547,
-0.0215079077,
0.0588600114,
-0.0422185771,
0.0449966118,
0.0014208877,
-0.0052886293,
-0.0279090721,
-0.0521224774,
-0.0229866896,
-0.0375950299,
0.0261648744,
-0.0091043049,
0.0475048535,
-0.019117238,
-0.0105278986,
-0.0448809862,
-0.0792174861,
-0.0074891741,
-0.0281665232,
0.0311914608,
0.0261680782,
0.0406761318,
0.0391034782,
0.0100974506,
-0.0141064432,
0.0489713214,
0.0476485416,
0.0145370746,
-0.0300562512,
0.011259974,
0.048159942,
0.0484643914,
0.0000019976,
-0.0352500826,
-0.0401921459,
0.0028743872,
-0.0118662957,
-0.013716273,
0.0611520633,
-0.0545279644,
-0.0257680845,
0.0462848693,
-0.0491455123,
0.0448377542,
0.0267032571,
-0.0216373987,
0.0493531413,
0.0721710399,
-0.0096521201,
-0.0216346607,
0.0094673075,
-0.0419681892,
-0.0044101854,
-0.0231822859,
-0.0007367969,
-0.01656501,
-0.0039251265,
0.0122922482,
0.0021540599,
0.0522402786,
0.0105496738,
-0.0076543358,
-0.0024198666,
0.0314490013,
0.0000221975,
-0.0121871065,
-0.0326923057,
0.0656750798,
-0.0444231108,
-0.004806581,
0.0180298742,
-0.0026448704,
-0.0198295917,
0.0241446663,
-0.0300719496,
0.0183230713,
-0.012330371,
0.0315906294,
0.0169319008,
-0.0320666656,
0.0631681755,
0.0278615039,
-0.0724917799,
0.0345524549,
0.0424595587,
-0.0224602893,
-0.0332170241,
0.0179923829,
-0.0168761648,
-0.0363741033,
0.0009233245,
0.0150779113,
-0.0155118005,
0.0288932938,
-0.0304393731,
-0.0294026025,
-0.004089254,
-0.0489603654,
0.0238766167,
0.0654440522,
-0.0225212015,
0.0636662915,
-0.0195568129,
0.0399404168,
-0.0417421311,
0.0052934508,
-0.1070665643,
-0.0304319169,
-0.0590862669,
0.0276634935,
-0.0124372048,
0.0015797127,
-0.0671157166,
-0.0161379352,
-0.0544018634,
0.0548287332,
0.034534391,
0.0119979251,
0.0070363106,
-0.0677861646,
-0.0601321906,
-0.0416091718,
-0.0029397269,
0.0256363507,
0.0368537158,
-0.0041858256,
0.0124236587,
-0.0530973673,
-0.0167475417,
-0.0059394147,
-0.0358313397,
-0.0260756593,
0.0023297304,
0.0806226283,
-0.0284872968,
-0.0497034043,
-0.0188011248,
0.0041015274,
-0.0153208813,
-0.0477496795,
-0.013572989,
-0.0733641982,
0.0623950809,
0.0045852098,
0.0155199729,
-0.0281554386,
0.0041586128,
-0.0132686729,
-0.0071156686,
0.1027890295,
-0.0009199209,
0.0165160485,
0.0274815485,
-0.0004542502,
-0.0175413657,
0.083513476,
0.0312286541,
0.0356037766,
-0.0094167814,
0.0128119998,
-0.0291414522,
0.0722150803,
0.0098373331,
0.0823293999,
-0.0625747666,
0.0014200927,
0.0344824754,
0.0260663796,
0.0077775316,
0.0435653105,
-0.0371241681,
0.0726228133,
0.0618074499,
0.0436352156,
0.028828565,
0.023737967,
0.0385702923,
0.0065418426,
-0.0385577902,
0.0062462548,
-0.0427231193,
0.023611974,
-0.0639664456,
-0.0000490466,
0.0689581484,
0.0724530071,
-0.0126709593,
-0.0416056402,
-0.0200560149,
-0.0455638021,
-0.0037669733,
0.0343892165,
0.0467745624,
-0.0003459182,
-0.0548123606,
0.0378562808,
-0.0000320607,
-0.0389525592,
0.020658575,
-0.0380075052,
-0.0376999341,
0.0875063166,
0.0589486435,
-0.0043232222,
-0.0321282633,
-0.0311021525,
-0.0085411258,
0.062945053,
0.0211678836,
0.0111465305,
0.0326265953,
-0.0514368191,
-0.0131535633,
0.0199751742,
0.0073594083,
0.0305314567,
-0.0103335949,
0.0165659655,
0.0318367258,
-0.0295705926,
-0.0274721887,
0.0117596043,
-0.055378627,
-0.0204387903,
0.0206255391,
0.0171786603,
0.0333252773,
0.0004222518,
-0.0133588193,
0.0053889249,
0.0372211188,
-0.0525863171,
-0.0561552793,
0.034533754,
-0.0480807759,
-0.0379432589,
0.0392398909,
-0.0015730595,
-0.0110421376,
-0.0432196371,
-0.0436097793,
-0.0679090321,
-0.0347743221,
-0.0261681341,
0.0161471572,
-0.0275904778,
0.0638189241,
0.0032317627,
-0.0142385345,
-0.0561124012,
0.0508774072,
-0.0160387736,
0.0002848658,
0.029689502,
-0.0088559762,
-0.0233588628,
-0.0112643735,
-0.0141957384,
0.0413525552,
0.041800119,
0.022502359,
0.0135578997,
0.0093078539,
-0.0101569379,
-0.0710922629,
-0.0776674822,
0.017339766,
-0.0218680073,
0.0290214531,
0.0466827378,
0.0490622111,
-0.0054410193,
0.0135207055,
-0.0117321806,
-0.0199716669,
0.0246507339,
0.0214043651,
0.0089294901,
0.0042201122,
-0.0119187385,
-0.0235966481,
-0.0000616245,
-0.0001890897,
0.0154815475,
-0.0035319705,
-0.0401340909,
-0.1025307849,
0.0066246483,
-0.0374717899,
0.0116814775,
-0.0216012765,
-0.0507621504,
0.013285283,
-0.0668107271,
0.0602825135,
0.066193223,
-0.0136832204,
0.0118403528,
0.0929957703,
-0.0099498816,
-0.0573567152,
0.0091756983,
0.0178118013,
-0.0318525359,
-0.0531471595,
-0.0478725955,
-0.0078240596,
0.0445330031,
-0.0155029483,
0.0073563098,
-0.0372954234,
-0.0025667637,
-0.0054271389,
0.0069261584,
-0.0407849774,
0.0141881993,
-0.0102471979,
0.0781938359,
-0.0080320174,
-0.0733026043,
0.0654790998,
-0.0409074016,
-0.0232449453,
-0.0379612446,
-0.0375869982,
-0.0413279086,
0.0302674845,
-0.026051769,
0.015629882,
-0.0274591912,
-0.0141001325,
-0.0519530587,
-0.0125999032,
0.0123639274,
-0.0430902578,
0.0881475955,
-0.0703721419,
0.0176030472,
-0.0299564358,
-0.0279805996,
-0.0249796566,
-0.0103630256,
-0.0377694704,
-0.0107762245,
-0.0026731035,
-0.0181811452,
-0.0284816343,
-0.0105702654,
0.0275680386,
0.0574028529,
0.011797471,
-0.0133821899,
-0.034076754,
0.0249255616,
0.00805627,
0.0184271261,
-0.0188665483,
-0.0468977392,
0.0634479448,
0.0025416836,
0.0385093987,
-0.0268371627,
-0.0364132375,
-0.0223338772,
0.0514248982,
0.0065131262,
-0.0258715171,
0.0176231544,
0.0264408458,
-0.0373064838,
-0.0250641908,
0.1245101541,
0.0259253886,
-0.0551477447,
-0.0245409552,
0.0058686384,
0.0161031019,
0.0139679974,
0.0222878847,
-0.0736637264,
-0.0433859751,
0.0335065983,
0.0169870127,
0.0381140336,
0.0165800899,
-0.0375745222,
-0.1050388291,
-0.0028186929,
0.0628095195,
-0.0071293185,
-0.0164122228,
-0.0101862159,
-0.0078169927,
-0.0206705052,
0.0406007096,
-0.005422045,
0.0106292237,
-0.0137196081,
-0.010382168,
0.0647528023,
-0.0741633102,
-0.0094983904,
-0.0332691111,
0.0319504514,
0.0538901053,
0.0552712828,
0.0063743,
-0.0307508837,
0.0631058589,
0.0048824954,
0.0071722013,
-0.0114089195,
-0.0040979586,
0.0165172461,
-0.0024781695,
0.0129854856,
0.0161346179,
-0.020628266,
0.0219045319,
0.0193445142,
0.0496144593,
-0.0534820855,
0.0309796445,
0.0083756074,
-0.0464280918,
0.0139125055,
0.043012958,
0.0098153679,
-0.0350551531,
0.010159147,
-0.0218028072,
-0.0367024764,
-0.0057943328,
-0.0154795432,
0.0020540601,
-0.0335210636,
0.0078122597,
-0.0813937411,
-0.0196354333,
0.0081184972,
0.0460556448,
0.0476130843,
0.0611655824,
-0.0040786867,
-0.0162980072,
-0.0108993025,
0.035928458,
-0.0373816304,
0.0456539318,
-0.0677344501,
0.0113841482,
0.0605162345,
-0.0423370078,
0.0208411682,
0.0114290174,
-0.1075975895,
-0.1110066324,
-0.0459635518,
0.0232630428,
0.0296350103,
0.0641720071,
-0.0284095369,
-0.0208216999,
0.0332431905,
0.0293534212,
-0.0247484893,
-0.0207664091,
0.0317814499,
0.0371252075,
-0.0148326252,
0.0406275168,
-0.0397709869,
-0.0109167807,
-0.004847704,
0.0279195663,
-0.0606853925,
-0.0622738153,
0.0199452192,
0.0269138888,
0.0725024939,
-0.0417690687,
-0.023213258,
-0.0189067591,
0.0244113188,
0.0013374909,
-0.0142850596,
-0.0534781218,
0.0054305769,
0.050529208,
-0.0145429131,
0.0198650714,
0.0134916259,
-0.0023053521,
-0.0259791799,
-0.0008486204,
-0.0055342689,
-0.048415985,
0.0278275385,
0.0454914272,
0.0118496418,
0.0107611092,
0.0420348458,
0.0002210243,
0.0080620125,
-0.0303689353,
0.0337030329,
0.019536145,
0.0149993952,
-0.0141954822,
0.0566495247,
-0.0472589955,
-0.0597091913,
0.0042549432,
0.0432097912,
0.1032605544,
0.0145326089,
0.1117639989,
-0.017543694,
-0.0052046496,
-0.0148695316,
0.0653848797,
0.0029751186,
-0.0043231277,
0.0361866504,
-0.0033561303,
0.0060360474,
0.0127246333,
0.0610212833,
-0.0122514563,
-0.0010475866,
0.0154436575,
0.0200567655,
-0.0202656146,
-0.0167436656,
-0.0013893254,
-0.0372256078,
-0.0225989316,
0.0226345994,
-0.0003487109,
-0.0545206778,
0.0162590742,
0.0077643064,
-0.0278003588,
-0.0404976755,
0.0012313648,
0.0513501726,
-0.0201789569,
0.0363385528,
-0.0476074442,
0.0177494232,
0.0302360486,
-0.0431809388,
0.0010266438,
-6.455623222e-33,
-0.0250997022,
-0.0360748954,
0.0277246796,
-0.0110456822,
-0.0205859356,
-0.0235411357,
-0.0068703857,
-0.0094319675,
0.0141496724,
-0.030547956,
-0.0273341071,
0.0307982527,
0.021255536,
-0.0122261085,
0.0190621912,
0.0051188683,
0.0521061495,
0.028906405,
-0.0170516167,
0.0105000269,
0.0181524679,
0.016652694,
0.0415662825,
-0.0234167762,
0.0235858485,
-0.0313060507,
-0.0177160855,
0.0331391841,
-0.0253715459,
0.0245708879,
0.0042208056,
0.004459742,
0.0049389568,
-0.0200899653,
-0.0433124825,
0.014885949,
-0.0444689505,
0.013007924,
0.0403279513,
-0.0014072879,
-0.0100343451,
-0.0600815117,
0.0455219038,
-0.0214627273,
0.0033501985,
-0.0208996441,
0.0019850119,
-0.0487253852,
-0.0627038181,
-0.015432463,
-0.0288230013,
0.0243952107,
0.007714258,
-0.0316046104,
0.050549265,
0.0147360722,
-0.0027376267,
0.0036449535,
-0.0511680059,
0.0084012328,
0.0235781185,
0.0568311699,
0.0757678598,
0.0401810221,
-0.0137903644,
0.0270505939,
-0.0305660181,
0.0058822315,
-0.0019942306,
-0.0157258883,
0.0176625587,
0.0257436,
0.0562062003,
0.038498126,
0.0112616615,
-0.0025858323,
-0.0121676913,
0.0527472347,
0.030732451,
0.0111569306,
0.028778322,
0.0464829542,
0.0081948191,
-0.0155079802,
-0.0559371375,
-0.007347865,
-0.035955321,
-0.0152070029,
0.0038130151,
0.0246381387,
-0.0219015423,
-0.0430903099,
0.0617095567,
-0.0054449216,
0.0255963821,
0.0134713063,
-0.017341651,
-0.018124463,
-0.0061032013,
0.0457320064,
-0.017549457,
-0.0518313162,
-0.000202967,
0.0204858147,
-0.0050701289,
-0.0081341248,
0.0222956929,
0.0191192422,
-0.0622203089,
0.0187077038,
-0.0541531891,
-0.009682538,
-0.0186693463,
-0.0102660796,
0.0382259116,
0.0008315421,
-0.0062299976,
0.0178239737,
0.021605324,
-0.0261781793,
-0.0415904559,
0.0156937186,
0.0026843941,
0.0325489268,
-0.0507328101,
0.0369170569,
-0.0142233837,
0.0239775535,
0.0637581795,
-0.0340953507,
-0.0309208408,
0.0115511967,
2.797e-7,
0.0333976075,
0.0454252213,
-0.0268212352,
0.0203839783,
0.008025174,
0.0210084133,
-0.0803288743,
0.0080042696,
0.0412983447,
-0.0052227275,
0.0200152807,
0.0216010157,
0.1047680303,
0.0353534184,
-0.0896643475,
-0.0168108363,
-0.0274259243,
0.0499069318,
-0.0622781627,
-0.00848787,
0.0298197959,
0.1052410603,
0.0098265773,
-0.0103266742,
-0.0120149981,
-0.0455181412,
0.0827938393,
-0.0324665196,
-0.0279062819,
-0.0070199231,
0.002466392,
0.0434400067,
-0.051624462,
-0.0010894687,
-0.0191946141,
-0.0057961671,
0.0215607621,
0.0736664459,
0.0167219918,
0.0166774653,
0.0080268541,
-0.0249441005,
-0.0119873183,
-0.0188227836,
0.0423796438,
-0.0509994589,
0.0111518782,
-0.00450231,
-0.0049761171,
-0.0288568847,
0.0402043685,
-0.0082852812,
-0.0323967785,
0.0544978566,
0.0377136916,
-0.0094668688,
-0.0006270825,
-0.0608372651,
-0.0328961238,
0.0119528724,
-0.0301033407,
-0.0422386266,
-0.0171937384,
-0.0038670793,
-0.0048898407,
-0.0389538035,
-0.013715947,
2.47409074e-34,
0.0233442746,
0.0003171394,
0.0253296327,
0.0418128707,
0.0231312588,
-0.0322302431,
-0.05233429,
0.006153537,
0.0087219747,
-0.0850457177,
-0.0174311027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08303v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08303v1 | Extrinsically-Focused Evaluation of Omissions in Medical Summarization | 2023-11-14T16:46:15 | 2023-11-14T16:46:15 | Elliot Schumacher, Daniel Rosenthal, Varun Nair, Luladay Price, Geoffrey Tso, Anitha Kannan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The goal of automated summarization techniques (Paice, 1990; Kupiec et al,
1995) is to condense text by focusing on the most critical information.
Generative large language models (LLMs) have shown to be robust summarizers,
yet traditional metrics struggle to capture resulting performance (Goyal et al,
2022) in more powerful LLMs. In safety-critical domains such as medicine, more
rigorous evaluation is required, especially given the potential for LLMs to
omit important information in the resulting summary. We propose MED-OMIT, a new
omission benchmark for medical summarization. Given a doctor-patient
conversation and a generated summary, MED-OMIT categorizes the chat into a set
of facts and identifies which are omitted from the summary. We further propose
to determine fact importance by simulating the impact of each fact on a
downstream clinical task: differential diagnosis (DDx) generation. MED-OMIT
leverages LLM prompt-based approaches which categorize the importance of facts
and cluster them as supporting or negating evidence to the diagnosis. We
evaluate MED-OMIT on a publicly-released dataset of patient-doctor
conversations and find that MED-OMIT captures omissions better than alternative
metrics. | [
0.0366350338,
0.0242941678,
0.0198491123,
-0.0290193688,
-0.0250715278,
0.0304411128,
-0.0024699795,
0.0046608341,
-0.0018261621,
-0.02207008,
0.01564488,
-0.0650579706,
0.0270918775,
0.0261832736,
0.0272538047,
-0.0715732276,
0.0159797128,
0.0258763023,
0.0423777848,
0.0015234977,
0.0060541038,
-0.0051678666,
-0.0111347437,
0.0431401692,
0.0284936912,
0.0074541476,
0.0439498797,
0.0038275432,
0.0510700792,
-0.0575380325,
-0.0309199188,
0.0135247055,
-0.0267627779,
-0.0101468824,
0.0000019192,
-0.0451622531,
-0.014067959,
0.0164751206,
-0.0047151088,
-0.0110322703,
0.0409490429,
-0.050607238,
0.0072106384,
0.0186678804,
-0.0251115412,
-0.0488178506,
0.0006776539,
0.0472724065,
0.0659363568,
0.0821718797,
-0.0174038466,
0.0175959282,
-0.0003089272,
-0.0373229831,
0.0057221591,
-0.0270143282,
0.0488164574,
0.0271228515,
0.0037883646,
-0.0109484131,
0.0085642859,
0.042697642,
-0.0216656476,
-0.0131739946,
0.0136687635,
0.0593155846,
-0.0111942096,
-0.0125616593,
0.0349363126,
0.0717707872,
0.0028078826,
-0.0042306911,
0.0573122501,
-0.0029354712,
0.0142378537,
-0.0101425406,
-0.0826758668,
0.0389913581,
-0.0156757254,
0.0127548184,
0.0009278478,
0.023148641,
0.026550319,
-0.0142420009,
0.012856761,
-0.0252097938,
0.0165355708,
-0.0076493872,
-0.0605656765,
-0.0168815069,
-0.0500002578,
-0.0810005516,
0.0350069478,
0.0294734556,
-0.0452982895,
-0.008239788,
-0.0196805913,
-0.0470325649,
0.0682424903,
-0.0427366532,
-0.0191224664,
-0.0169999115,
0.0272973217,
0.0518996008,
-0.0004147387,
-0.0097558005,
0.0234561581,
-0.0047756359,
-0.0588136017,
0.0156726185,
0.0101281507,
-0.01180379,
-0.0110849179,
0.0444541164,
-0.0287157353,
-0.0243659578,
-0.0770803764,
-0.0146798966,
-0.0153820869,
0.0141966408,
0.0112480707,
0.0296085067,
-0.0286552887,
0.0047629611,
0.0195999704,
-0.010534578,
-0.0139739448,
-0.0040911832,
0.0294807553,
-0.0161087029,
-0.0210789945,
0.0323297456,
0.0149403401,
0.0267934725,
-0.0186314434,
0.054697115,
-0.0075801751,
0.0057329475,
0.0253766198,
-0.0560299829,
-0.0522120222,
-0.0239825118,
-0.0106902039,
-0.0628850088,
0.0232254192,
0.0217968207,
-0.0131241521,
-0.0339433514,
0.0170800798,
0.0191136077,
-0.0380509607,
0.0052967388,
-0.0326180458,
0.0291326325,
0.0222827047,
0.0377187543,
0.0039153723,
0.0240972005,
0.0309647247,
0.0033904477,
0.0184499696,
0.0040607844,
0.0206317771,
0.007314526,
0.0345416255,
-0.0120818326,
0.0203509796,
-0.0192017723,
0.0141661912,
0.0432195961,
-0.0009729951,
0.1069938987,
-0.0261453353,
-0.0011787808,
0.0462871417,
0.0462358631,
-0.0015306786,
0.0039258162,
0.0313904658,
0.0006574081,
0.0036221803,
0.036808975,
0.0044152765,
-0.0000549401,
-0.0144997854,
0.0259202011,
0.0680194348,
0.014108941,
-0.0304204877,
-0.0446720049,
-0.0338134356,
-0.0087156566,
-0.0025119965,
-0.0027988697,
0.0201008711,
0.0125429267,
-0.0529109612,
0.065028742,
0.0411119424,
-0.0360565335,
0.0026859893,
-0.0386838913,
-0.0073873084,
0.0502678491,
0.0872227177,
-0.0223249663,
-0.0465890169,
-0.0087401792,
0.0151378782,
0.0110431835,
0.0324536562,
-0.0211535972,
0.0166888908,
-0.0396968611,
-0.0073005273,
0.0240238849,
0.0313484184,
-0.0618265606,
0.0005264619,
-0.0279255118,
0.0260273982,
-0.0264339577,
-0.050002899,
0.0324123017,
-0.0226944834,
-0.0079784645,
0.018306667,
-0.0355222076,
0.0275408495,
0.0211424232,
-0.0149488188,
0.0357338861,
0.02694517,
-0.0326553173,
-0.0387790389,
0.0153038409,
-0.0617203042,
-0.0546493456,
0.0132436594,
-0.057181932,
0.0122167524,
-0.0203810483,
-0.0418791287,
-0.0478770509,
-0.0167260487,
-0.0750880316,
0.0024332942,
0.0075285011,
0.0273232609,
0.0605041385,
-0.0111077251,
-0.0232609827,
0.047463432,
-0.0365993902,
0.0073740091,
0.0252044033,
-0.0160356779,
-0.0063226745,
-0.0393936858,
-0.0250292979,
-0.0028803635,
0.0078738201,
0.0045691463,
0.0208546072,
-0.0026536849,
-0.0086747808,
-0.0468572564,
-0.1515935361,
0.0024244781,
-0.0034224309,
0.0002046611,
0.0596670099,
0.049698431,
0.0035939016,
0.0126044536,
-0.0466199629,
-0.0199763775,
0.0478232391,
0.0195315871,
0.0507677682,
0.0528097823,
0.0100741768,
-0.0447750427,
-0.0161663368,
-0.0205686875,
0.0576650873,
0.01977049,
-0.0028660661,
-0.0011076604,
0.0166463442,
-0.055309929,
-0.0297627579,
0.0055620661,
-0.0081662796,
-0.0066396059,
-0.0102491705,
0.0402168669,
0.0241700895,
0.0427125394,
-0.009176434,
0.0282954387,
-0.0110604577,
-0.011503485,
-0.0110688936,
-0.0615696162,
-0.0141322818,
0.0278834254,
-0.0747200623,
0.0101366881,
0.0705106407,
0.0487654395,
0.0001472842,
-0.0403089598,
-0.013153756,
-0.0349091329,
0.0096478388,
-0.0517218821,
-0.0189011153,
-0.0266741794,
0.0314305313,
-0.0235139746,
-0.0371740684,
0.0857771188,
-0.0296432991,
0.0471194796,
-0.0430789217,
-0.0138151785,
-0.0521693937,
0.0015454033,
0.000158542,
0.037904676,
0.0271430649,
-0.0117744412,
0.0002920711,
0.0063787745,
0.0387558229,
-0.0544133596,
0.0709822029,
-0.0472802557,
0.0124660991,
0.01427765,
-0.0223073009,
-0.0179190896,
-0.0475681834,
-0.0026229799,
-0.0133456895,
0.0385443643,
0.0053899144,
-0.068999812,
0.0372329429,
0.0113061471,
0.0629483014,
0.0001219238,
0.0052168197,
0.0149139259,
0.0296581183,
0.0492196046,
-0.0150856674,
0.0202517845,
-0.0658428967,
0.0347221792,
0.070481807,
0.0005637565,
0.0030575709,
0.0371284299,
-0.0431207269,
-0.0335262269,
-0.0128754545,
-0.0159171242,
0.0214979332,
0.0650636107,
-0.0184559245,
-0.0066192937,
0.1197352931,
0.0115403971,
-0.0212664008,
0.020815542,
0.0203607231,
0.0300681535,
-0.0395323113,
-0.0147773167,
-0.0483626388,
-0.0166812036,
-0.0065063825,
0.0350799114,
-0.01651581,
-0.0519568808,
0.0114184609,
-0.0436383449,
0.0181352571,
0.0084032491,
-0.0423584133,
-0.0320736766,
-0.0583056584,
0.001146985,
-0.0239939783,
-0.0134679228,
0.0071309926,
-0.027627917,
-0.0048038126,
-0.0029682892,
-0.1107990593,
-0.0567340925,
-0.0063123945,
-0.008801016,
0.0250871535,
0.0468553752,
0.0252127592,
0.005751051,
0.0392246023,
0.0427653491,
-0.0081082284,
-0.0109280134,
0.0020414244,
0.1095044315,
0.014121714,
0.0088278418,
-0.0582118146,
0.0470561422,
0.0328856111,
-0.0311464388,
-0.0053474517,
0.0317950286,
-0.01132375,
-0.0498444103,
-0.0348853767,
0.0823460072,
0.0190343615,
0.0780796781,
0.0399972498,
0.0247881915,
-0.0242072828,
0.010348442,
0.049837824,
-0.0050819311,
0.0062166932,
-0.0090985745,
-0.0096837413,
-0.04570961,
-0.0944063514,
-0.0450926051,
0.0262387954,
-0.050133083,
-0.0012602272,
-0.001200881,
-0.0060134851,
0.0016256686,
-0.0411671922,
0.0187244285,
0.0207184777,
-0.0131578958,
-0.0214106273,
-0.0116494969,
0.0618645735,
-0.0039284364,
-0.0069555668,
0.0514011122,
-0.0682946965,
-0.0293839462,
-0.0186368749,
0.0381781943,
0.0188550632,
0.0064275721,
0.0040769801,
-0.0302033704,
0.0618583225,
0.0499029718,
-0.0121219065,
0.0330086015,
-0.0027820773,
-0.0014154436,
-0.0122346263,
0.016594151,
-0.0447151139,
0.0480230898,
-0.0155942868,
0.0393097773,
-0.0256847553,
-0.0294484682,
-0.0030638622,
0.0411560349,
0.0190505181,
-0.0302864499,
-0.001319312,
-0.024023816,
-0.0141753536,
-0.035526529,
0.0007592058,
-0.0199924093,
0.0282851607,
0.0030617272,
0.0126178693,
-0.0178043954,
0.0490403734,
-0.061880134,
-0.0107875029,
-0.044201415,
0.0132065751,
-0.0264768619,
-0.0503619388,
0.0260505788,
-0.0415503047,
-0.0312990285,
-0.0089955237,
-0.0260153823,
-0.0188551601,
0.0081984419,
0.0126907015,
0.0023711999,
0.0446248576,
-0.0049091484,
0.0383438021,
-0.0465426743,
-0.0137295071,
-0.0587361455,
0.0440880992,
0.027167473,
0.0066940351,
0.080694437,
-0.0109735876,
-0.0010149864,
-0.0433440432,
0.0442380495,
-0.0172528978,
-0.0060497071,
-0.0102580525,
0.0078644585,
0.012646568,
0.0056598075,
0.1042754725,
-0.0419464894,
0.0320146047,
0.0015250576,
-0.0392385237,
-0.0549355447,
-0.0551082976,
-0.0150099639,
0.0196794383,
-0.0263317805,
-0.0134082912,
-0.0932535008,
-0.0220104866,
0.0151463905,
0.007746791,
0.0002115977,
-0.0132273473,
0.0580440462,
0.0178773105,
0.002513953,
-0.0104293441,
-0.0334326364,
0.0458820574,
-0.0006279369,
0.0239024237,
0.0052927481,
-5.901357799e-33,
-0.0072905822,
-0.0383262075,
-0.0061843991,
-0.0010253274,
-0.0222166125,
0.0421602763,
-0.0698236749,
-0.0016816462,
0.0182204731,
0.050244268,
-0.0084272213,
0.0052778549,
0.0023885313,
0.0594522282,
-0.0244370494,
0.0030917523,
0.0501332022,
0.0014890912,
-0.0517894141,
0.0824706256,
-0.0067777545,
0.0295273978,
-0.0047827163,
-0.0562315732,
0.0141233839,
-0.0408003479,
-0.0108083086,
0.0105668576,
0.0297737904,
0.0319673307,
-0.0309781898,
0.0194341093,
0.0319001488,
-0.0107249981,
-0.058059115,
-0.0063393409,
-0.0379857346,
-0.005331168,
0.0402781181,
-0.085252136,
-0.0410032235,
-0.0432624742,
0.0433176346,
-0.0102423588,
-0.0044895466,
-0.0320376381,
0.0295570605,
-0.0275371112,
-0.0247331671,
-0.0599563085,
-0.0129150553,
0.0698706433,
-0.0157274511,
-0.0287427809,
-0.0267758444,
-0.0014018664,
-0.0254519694,
0.0228458699,
0.0076519498,
0.0488275029,
0.0579050034,
0.0209118947,
0.0057669822,
-0.0269400515,
-0.0038038243,
0.0776448846,
0.0120862843,
0.0092811147,
-0.0478449017,
0.0189597867,
-0.0868524164,
0.0110351238,
0.0351773351,
0.0204421524,
0.004695429,
-0.001406456,
-0.1010408774,
0.0458407626,
-0.1079074964,
0.0285218749,
0.0447671041,
-0.0282896291,
-0.0525504425,
-0.029720407,
-0.0208255313,
0.0326026939,
0.0067612785,
-0.011277914,
-0.0082199126,
0.0209533107,
-0.0261415467,
-0.0265907776,
-0.0056431382,
0.0008859728,
0.0536961742,
-0.0005574386,
0.0165594798,
0.0094503183,
-0.0413594469,
-0.0328059122,
-0.0479929335,
0.0135014532,
0.0576532707,
0.0194839407,
0.0201683268,
0.0212464742,
0.0206839088,
-0.032165423,
-0.0361516289,
0.0100135291,
0.0214100853,
0.0159837678,
-0.0464576706,
-0.0054887943,
0.0191893503,
0.0274016764,
-0.0055424729,
0.0517431349,
-0.0152316606,
0.0063776425,
-0.0202724561,
-0.0039552478,
0.0232279841,
-0.0109029524,
-0.0462733731,
0.0261238404,
-0.0144758346,
0.0327212662,
0.0687816516,
-0.0311128721,
-0.0200813077,
0.0015452686,
2.637e-7,
0.1007307619,
0.033219371,
0.0435193963,
-0.0113094393,
0.0272862986,
0.0251190253,
0.0046108644,
0.0145045109,
0.0267167762,
0.011006536,
0.0434120856,
0.0332562588,
0.0417060927,
0.0500713773,
-0.0616162978,
0.0014806014,
-0.1113657951,
-0.0686962679,
0.0006847013,
-0.0541269556,
0.0492065921,
0.0640824363,
-0.0601688959,
-0.0063617988,
-0.0018626601,
-0.0203740206,
0.0534510836,
-0.0375259258,
-0.0612692609,
0.0645576268,
0.0573442131,
-0.0007473223,
0.0117240716,
0.0178056154,
-0.0205535498,
-0.0379541852,
0.045704253,
0.1039650142,
-0.0031449157,
0.0084195659,
0.027070526,
-0.0029781158,
0.0309603736,
-0.0216379464,
0.0425103307,
-0.0949413627,
-0.0345528722,
-0.0259331781,
-0.0205398593,
-0.0032173076,
0.0366778225,
-0.0345344245,
-0.0444621779,
0.0482736193,
0.0032608777,
0.0141428709,
-0.0219156407,
-0.0679865628,
-0.0645254403,
0.0420363545,
-0.0413841829,
-0.0801147148,
0.0592574589,
-0.0238967668,
-0.0271308105,
-0.08047463,
0.0245738011,
2.503446416e-34,
0.0763816237,
0.0086828033,
-0.0365679972,
-0.0166140683,
0.0316547677,
-0.0299505629,
0.0027071084,
0.0024965911,
0.0278554503,
-0.0813563243,
-0.006370876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08300v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08300v1 | Workflow-Guided Response Generation for Task-Oriented Dialogue | 2023-11-14T16:44:33 | 2023-11-14T16:44:33 | Do June Min, Paloma Sodhi, Ramya Ramakrishnan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Task-oriented dialogue (TOD) systems aim to achieve specific goals through
interactive dialogue. Such tasks usually involve following specific workflows,
i.e. executing a sequence of actions in a particular order. While prior work
has focused on supervised learning methods to condition on past actions, they
do not explicitly optimize for compliance to a desired workflow. In this paper,
we propose a novel framework based on reinforcement learning (RL) to generate
dialogue responses that are aligned with a given workflow. Our framework
consists of ComplianceScorer, a metric designed to evaluate how well a
generated response executes the specified action, combined with an RL
opimization process that utilizes an interactive sampling technique. We
evaluate our approach on two TOD datasets, Action-Based Conversations Dataset
(ABCD) (Chen et al., 2021a) and MultiWOZ 2.2 (Zang et al., 2020) on a range of
automated and human evaluation metrics. Our findings indicate that our RL-based
framework outperforms baselines and is effective at enerating responses that
both comply with the intended workflows while being expressed in a natural and
fluent manner. | [
0.0483158641,
0.0524667352,
-0.013246078,
-0.0363023579,
-0.0295181256,
-0.0031141499,
-0.0119725112,
0.0024094875,
0.0064160493,
-0.0106504662,
-0.0251120441,
0.0016908762,
-0.0287548415,
0.0553264655,
-0.0320478305,
-0.0731522366,
0.0204609726,
-0.0176998787,
0.0253483243,
0.0147562595,
-0.0010351547,
0.0128428638,
-0.033796411,
0.0783703476,
-0.0021360589,
-0.001538638,
-0.0418952778,
0.0065497812,
0.02279355,
-0.0050493493,
0.0592569895,
0.0624802522,
0.0027980111,
0.0633896962,
0.0000021953,
-0.078000389,
0.0356309712,
-0.0158448815,
0.0066912193,
-0.057638187,
0.0210235603,
0.0072000753,
-0.0013935306,
0.0563322231,
-0.0680562556,
0.0017685489,
0.0557037555,
0.0751170442,
0.0715993494,
0.0718323663,
-0.0197258014,
0.0083989622,
0.0044686431,
-0.0025278071,
0.0147309164,
-0.029372124,
-0.0089071039,
0.0305566415,
0.007067393,
-0.0198431425,
0.0130457031,
-0.0206182413,
0.0116988393,
-0.0607864894,
-0.0282034576,
0.0153704807,
0.0177220944,
-0.0300699677,
-0.0296182055,
0.107653439,
0.0083390297,
0.0295501985,
0.0052347328,
-0.0296148937,
0.0050106677,
-0.0197407119,
-0.053611178,
-0.0214473922,
-0.0332355127,
-0.0286133923,
-0.0558643937,
0.0326138064,
-0.0157283675,
0.0076972931,
-0.0033797214,
0.0109038027,
-0.0314175561,
-0.0148776351,
-0.0016814199,
0.001685771,
0.0426086746,
-0.0558576658,
0.0084076812,
0.0480639115,
-0.118010059,
-0.010957215,
-0.0387528501,
-0.0003759416,
0.0365029797,
-0.0285930708,
0.0598681085,
0.0294770487,
0.0189113356,
0.0009622161,
0.0071819355,
0.0559553318,
-0.0228659026,
-0.0210161284,
-0.0142011503,
0.017917335,
-0.0789984316,
0.0067415079,
-0.0389205143,
0.0243604388,
-0.0776376724,
-0.0261131637,
-0.0358792469,
0.0724121705,
-0.0743225813,
0.0378093608,
0.0119306836,
0.0429721139,
-0.0394558124,
0.0192734879,
-0.0669143945,
0.0069196811,
-0.0206150524,
0.0268631838,
0.0277490821,
-0.0005644918,
-0.0078097461,
0.017030973,
0.0158230886,
-0.0145571427,
-0.0012624077,
0.0737837255,
-0.015226366,
0.0215648897,
0.0234169755,
-0.0450372621,
-0.0125720594,
-0.0609821379,
-0.0104422402,
-0.0604035594,
0.0453039818,
-0.0114712473,
-0.0557442643,
0.011318136,
0.0102883969,
0.0470457748,
-0.0054496038,
0.0206940267,
0.0318909213,
0.0002679262,
-0.0067845751,
-0.0057118442,
-0.0228282679,
0.0442502983,
0.0471123755,
0.0214412697,
0.0136055145,
-0.0047272905,
0.0176864546,
0.0046120952,
0.00434021,
0.0168927461,
0.02878334,
0.0501852594,
-0.0164984129,
0.0252256878,
0.0713345408,
0.015390465,
-0.0235625375,
0.0022127137,
0.0275412556,
0.0203781947,
-0.0425877906,
-0.0377695523,
0.0047834618,
0.0545893796,
0.0069267731,
0.0016033195,
-0.0083562601,
0.05229377,
0.0129286135,
-0.0025544257,
0.0194340721,
0.0015149532,
-0.0373444632,
-0.058096692,
0.021325767,
-0.0004858458,
0.0371337757,
0.0390623398,
0.0095239272,
0.0186246932,
-0.0840677172,
-0.0123342741,
-0.0088872425,
-0.0448631197,
-0.0429980122,
-0.0448933356,
0.0258333143,
0.0671541244,
0.0481548123,
-0.0257176161,
-0.0228334088,
-0.0653794408,
0.002072585,
0.0685278699,
0.0348878354,
-0.0330009907,
0.0474372022,
-0.0230835862,
-0.0432350151,
-0.0055469302,
-0.0188710913,
0.037496388,
0.0152181285,
-0.032595031,
-0.002566474,
0.0329159722,
-0.052540876,
0.0124537032,
0.0244851466,
-0.0271880217,
0.0724350885,
0.0066966554,
0.0669516027,
0.0192927085,
-0.001571725,
-0.0025917876,
0.0017630203,
0.0098385038,
-0.0071500451,
-0.0016328117,
-0.0328097492,
-0.0425884016,
-0.0070133205,
-0.0036650943,
-0.0218877457,
0.0402113162,
-0.0611836165,
-0.0378696844,
-0.0082444586,
-0.0098216645,
-0.0070909732,
-0.0322547182,
-0.0081106042,
0.036937058,
0.0092733763,
-0.039373938,
0.0144827785,
-0.0060133426,
0.0046553211,
0.0303114727,
-0.016525615,
0.0278570689,
-0.0349001847,
0.0514389053,
0.0027872983,
-0.0436650701,
0.0242940076,
0.0517843552,
0.0712304115,
-0.0271926578,
-0.0488399453,
-0.0643605664,
-0.015984809,
-0.0262348838,
-0.0055651302,
0.0008372497,
0.0046342844,
-0.0148512013,
-0.0373087376,
-0.0453670695,
0.0028757832,
0.0760920048,
-0.0085737677,
0.0521513708,
0.0020954723,
-0.0041399593,
-0.0360115841,
0.0144177973,
0.0153725259,
0.0017324621,
0.0112361098,
0.0125797819,
-0.0489024334,
-0.0103060016,
-0.0468237512,
0.0128882555,
0.0010873256,
-0.0266640838,
0.0509869792,
0.0196519587,
0.0345392786,
0.0498744994,
0.0409635641,
0.0385786556,
0.02045325,
0.0141078923,
-0.0805519819,
0.0561931096,
-0.0562836938,
-0.0261476059,
-0.036923904,
-0.0445139557,
0.0576420091,
0.0202541631,
0.0068487702,
0.0285316594,
-0.0431910679,
0.0056188656,
0.0441307202,
-0.034465719,
-0.0026135778,
-0.0052106204,
-0.0534037873,
0.0392633602,
-0.0399840809,
-0.0404909067,
0.0577809364,
0.037226975,
-0.0192124322,
-0.0610505193,
0.015242192,
-0.0153596858,
0.0549127832,
0.0092433617,
0.0075247926,
0.0149644827,
-0.0503409468,
-0.0574950352,
-0.0173842348,
0.0164140426,
-0.0420082361,
0.0110826613,
-0.0141978879,
0.0019443462,
-0.0209198389,
-0.0516156405,
-0.0682568625,
0.0221024845,
0.0187899917,
0.0160949118,
-0.0124583188,
-0.046321433,
-0.0055667907,
0.0024528212,
0.0178031269,
0.0589659773,
-0.0000506411,
-0.0401796103,
-0.0365685187,
0.0334423892,
0.0771128535,
0.0028541069,
0.0074048941,
-0.001684677,
0.0403472297,
0.0596089028,
0.0762654468,
-0.0071526673,
-0.005827127,
-0.0252413824,
0.0407033153,
-0.0251544602,
0.0570531487,
0.0421344191,
0.0472056456,
-0.0222967621,
-0.0139727434,
0.0937822908,
0.0339090303,
-0.0112092551,
-0.001786906,
-0.0038354821,
0.0541020967,
0.0224414635,
0.0588305108,
-0.0720575824,
-0.0201488752,
-0.0045351926,
0.0425859578,
-0.0164658763,
-0.0453734621,
0.0050661988,
-0.110520348,
0.0691055581,
-0.0367316641,
-0.0324958749,
0.0066936454,
-0.0457894728,
0.0209599547,
0.018623855,
0.0323110297,
-0.0066791018,
0.0144198686,
-0.0311392732,
0.0348746479,
-0.0089445328,
-0.0142354853,
0.0330723748,
-0.039173685,
0.0243391823,
0.0731597841,
0.076072745,
0.0190844312,
0.0208679195,
-0.0200374685,
0.0438256599,
0.0006584257,
0.0058452925,
0.0420467444,
0.0259824693,
-0.0085555017,
-0.0439362563,
0.0322120115,
-0.0229940712,
-0.0376776569,
0.0499133542,
0.0358523428,
-0.0654798746,
-0.0025358531,
-0.0233183373,
0.0149883665,
0.0726176798,
0.0340363383,
0.0011826655,
-0.0661394149,
-0.0641149133,
-0.0059560654,
0.0166336913,
-0.086705409,
0.0291234776,
-0.0573647767,
0.0130697722,
0.0137952566,
-0.094005622,
-0.0812617466,
0.0145128481,
0.0370895751,
-0.0107788872,
-0.0423975959,
0.0004491896,
0.0054176222,
-0.0536476001,
0.0067398525,
0.0140334452,
0.0462468937,
-0.0536241308,
-0.0223168712,
-0.025047183,
-0.0116795767,
-0.0079850554,
0.0325402729,
-0.0850818381,
-0.0229064152,
-0.0585988015,
0.0915750712,
0.0209566262,
0.0228117146,
0.010000119,
0.0024904523,
-0.0125626288,
0.0201265067,
-0.048647102,
-0.0420121029,
0.0630295873,
0.044160895,
-0.0368661694,
0.0050964076,
-0.0563623346,
0.007014296,
-0.0158046279,
0.0593259856,
-0.0034302741,
-0.0796646997,
0.0036597212,
-0.0383816883,
0.0179092567,
0.0018844104,
-0.0407709926,
-0.0267832391,
0.0289340969,
-0.0005247735,
-0.0101919137,
-0.0471168682,
0.0114564486,
-0.0356333628,
-0.0002578795,
0.0363566615,
0.0387798063,
-0.041429732,
0.0360632986,
-0.0341684297,
-0.0138116349,
0.0033283492,
0.0180228706,
0.0096887117,
0.0002611386,
-0.0248317067,
-0.0070862127,
0.0686169639,
0.0264471509,
0.0362917632,
0.0765813291,
0.026214391,
0.0236556977,
-0.0117947729,
0.0185144953,
-0.0809890851,
-0.0143544888,
-0.0118551077,
0.0195431672,
0.0197206698,
0.0176050179,
0.0301888883,
-0.0459312014,
0.0242538508,
-0.0314274207,
0.0587610081,
-0.0233982764,
-0.02186919,
0.0013622808,
0.0272873621,
-0.0058591217,
-0.0054586125,
0.0490261391,
-0.0400547013,
-0.0044588246,
-0.0339314826,
-0.0160860196,
-0.0511265285,
-0.0729541704,
0.0301066767,
0.0433884636,
-0.0197428446,
-0.007502981,
-0.0310527924,
-0.0251495987,
0.004039675,
0.0142131476,
-0.0092346873,
-0.0176267494,
0.0237592049,
0.0356877968,
0.0067760115,
-0.0068242839,
-0.0417845584,
-0.0464530364,
-0.0261651967,
-0.036206428,
-0.0664249286,
-5.885899314e-33,
0.0178129375,
-0.0541789383,
0.0309454259,
0.0084936973,
-0.0028602344,
-0.0373767354,
-0.0391288549,
-0.0032027487,
-0.0128050745,
0.0030572137,
-0.0302084722,
-0.0114905164,
0.0125114657,
0.0313848294,
0.0039570108,
0.0146707604,
0.0353063084,
0.0033897019,
-0.0432595313,
0.052388411,
0.0380036719,
-0.0137082515,
0.0135917757,
-0.0430561416,
0.0376034901,
0.0336997807,
-0.0223047864,
0.0281362776,
0.0095181353,
0.0624287911,
-0.0027027403,
0.0579581037,
0.0192425959,
-0.0154021354,
-0.0059201252,
0.0530531704,
-0.0686267689,
-0.0516182929,
-0.014014706,
0.0023428181,
-0.063690789,
0.010835371,
-0.0051196418,
0.0112899924,
-0.0279876515,
0.0021324293,
0.0284586567,
-0.0023107638,
-0.0372999124,
-0.0239125397,
-0.0749630556,
-0.0162300952,
-0.0218319055,
-0.0680140778,
-0.041357819,
0.0908737555,
-0.0025558888,
-0.0633748621,
-0.0394677557,
0.0123381708,
0.0090025896,
-0.0255664755,
0.0269186255,
0.0658870116,
0.0143534597,
0.0400001705,
0.0279320311,
0.0149018886,
-0.0019161603,
0.0044052997,
-0.0047956337,
0.0442694314,
-0.0158224255,
0.0378250629,
-0.0247004759,
0.0076940465,
-0.035323754,
0.0625720471,
0.0472718291,
0.0619864911,
0.0390476212,
-0.0291065276,
-0.033711113,
-0.0194687769,
-0.0233131964,
0.039614711,
-0.0049913363,
-0.0117425593,
0.0403065458,
0.0351075456,
-0.0011270951,
-0.0617010072,
0.0385705568,
-0.0113261146,
-0.0193703379,
0.0298000164,
-0.0468728468,
0.0048579387,
0.0023059724,
-0.0320869014,
-0.0329492763,
-0.0185229033,
0.0376431607,
-0.0128799947,
0.0097022373,
0.0126558207,
0.005740949,
0.0057867244,
-0.0773125514,
0.0177406762,
-0.0424678251,
0.0933891311,
-0.0379826427,
0.028916996,
0.0097000245,
-0.0142549211,
-0.005971665,
0.0809467062,
-0.0264660083,
-0.0446220897,
-0.0367205329,
-0.005497741,
0.0035238636,
0.0044348985,
-0.0323370583,
0.0091040945,
-0.0125959478,
0.0157654025,
-0.0082327249,
-0.0032323604,
-0.0178923532,
0.010332399,
2.752e-7,
-0.0237378832,
0.0057355124,
0.0203201436,
0.091849044,
0.0085874377,
0.0372288562,
0.0092941383,
0.0325414985,
0.0151716676,
0.0217026994,
0.0433911011,
-0.0112561993,
0.0629747435,
0.0046374737,
-0.0926158577,
-0.0481449328,
-0.0602669306,
-0.0064567667,
-0.0318348259,
0.0103904735,
0.0616527684,
0.0278357454,
0.0140685588,
-0.0191679448,
0.0180442482,
0.0202831514,
0.0393133312,
-0.0304420646,
0.0313277468,
0.0221994482,
0.0294051021,
-0.0684983134,
0.0396841988,
0.0182551146,
-0.0157936011,
-0.0062420359,
-0.0215577222,
0.0719930232,
-0.0044264509,
-0.0606550016,
-0.0351582915,
0.0105774524,
0.0537344031,
-0.0508681834,
0.0114830462,
-0.0651425496,
-0.010808548,
-0.0126363244,
-0.0092971316,
-0.0354137272,
0.0171657726,
-0.0196106993,
-0.0221460443,
0.0240954179,
0.008653922,
0.0244404692,
0.0070295595,
-0.0431957208,
0.0075417333,
-0.0149027156,
-0.0254100785,
-0.0363316834,
-0.0367726795,
0.0031797644,
-0.0011508032,
-0.009401802,
-0.0053588003,
2.321271194e-34,
0.0087656891,
-0.0051600398,
0.0089245327,
0.0501773544,
-0.0018697877,
0.0115954895,
-0.0107501922,
0.0300029367,
0.0926354825,
-0.0386085771,
-0.0141210379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08299v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08299v2 | VERVE: Template-based ReflectiVE Rewriting for MotiVational IntErviewing | 2023-11-14T16:44:16 | 2024-03-08T19:29:47 | Do June Min, Verónica Pérez-Rosas, Kenneth Resnicow, Rada Mihalcea | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Reflective listening is a fundamental skill that counselors must acquire to
achieve proficiency in motivational interviewing (MI). It involves responding
in a manner that acknowledges and explores the meaning of what the client has
expressed in the conversation. In this work, we introduce the task of
counseling response rewriting, which transforms non-reflective statements into
reflective responses. We introduce VERVE, a template-based rewriting system
with paraphrase-augmented training and adaptive template updating. VERVE first
creates a template by identifying and filtering out tokens that are not
relevant to reflections and constructs a reflective response using the
template. Paraphrase-augmented training allows the model to learn less-strict
fillings of masked spans, and adaptive template updating helps discover
effective templates for rewriting without significantly removing the original
content. Using both automatic and human evaluations, we compare our method
against text rewriting baselines and show that our framework is effective in
turning non-reflective statements into more reflective responses while
achieving a good content preservation-reflection style trade-off. | [
0.0875379145,
-0.0191525668,
-0.003549966,
-0.0427413322,
-0.0400116108,
0.0045940061,
-0.0401613712,
-0.0218537617,
-0.0740262568,
-0.0424150117,
-0.0198748969,
0.0573339947,
-0.0093943346,
-0.0226786435,
-0.0204969682,
-0.0789193958,
0.0169259515,
0.0313062556,
0.0753418133,
0.0262915734,
0.0165615249,
0.0512072332,
-0.0019167535,
0.0226033684,
0.0018142314,
-0.0417940654,
0.0320272148,
0.0483346768,
-0.0040658279,
-0.0509989075,
0.0448667854,
0.0107020568,
-0.0222914889,
-0.0232055914,
0.0000020098,
-0.0131330071,
-0.0296736509,
0.0165518969,
-0.0220707152,
0.0169680826,
0.0958316103,
-0.0284800399,
0.0143434396,
0.0328985043,
-0.0102102505,
-0.0206192695,
-0.0021327205,
0.0481636077,
0.1209042743,
0.0458494872,
-0.0215598512,
-0.0165336672,
-0.0384558924,
-0.021637233,
-0.0205298122,
0.0210725889,
-0.0191662218,
-0.0053557213,
-0.0111504579,
0.0056461142,
0.0010314769,
0.0139288381,
-0.0144772483,
-0.0274830069,
0.0342551544,
-0.0177419819,
-0.009119913,
0.0164825208,
-0.0080023017,
0.0401729196,
0.0654995516,
0.0011059679,
-0.0018310022,
-0.0139249181,
0.0384633727,
-0.0068370616,
-0.0386427492,
-0.0137534058,
-0.0034116642,
-0.0121068265,
-0.0327587537,
0.00820156,
-0.0219054669,
0.0030851003,
0.0152060268,
-0.0126422588,
0.0126346927,
-0.0422491916,
-0.0252289101,
0.004448039,
0.0615768917,
-0.0598001368,
-0.0088048643,
0.0253909323,
-0.055784896,
0.0016297523,
-0.0577144325,
-0.0485516079,
0.0015683246,
0.0475126654,
0.0586900488,
0.0123761892,
-0.0100899534,
-0.004085538,
-0.023461163,
0.0313456319,
0.0127981603,
0.024142744,
-0.0740067288,
0.0195099358,
-0.0589073151,
-0.0215657614,
-0.0616149493,
0.0667122453,
-0.0667960197,
-0.002028947,
-0.0623187125,
0.0255000703,
0.0003112824,
0.0071013798,
-0.0669863224,
0.0264928024,
-0.0412731022,
0.020268647,
0.0107371612,
0.040519014,
-0.0022643516,
0.006635786,
0.029143177,
-0.0314130485,
0.0381038301,
0.0182577558,
0.0263153128,
-0.0391674377,
0.0083369985,
0.049584344,
-0.0479205698,
-0.0091313645,
-0.0225346368,
-0.0269122031,
-0.0320741944,
-0.0095316572,
0.0052344548,
-0.0369246192,
0.0360693969,
0.0062944288,
-0.0129951173,
-0.0236776881,
0.039356228,
0.0216910355,
-0.0224305373,
0.0481988974,
0.0130878156,
-0.002599037,
0.0308016445,
0.0153479492,
-0.000942122,
0.0016093625,
0.0235940591,
0.0203074086,
0.0409440398,
-0.0339479409,
0.0324732102,
-0.047419738,
-0.0027778419,
-0.0087970709,
-0.0298148878,
0.046473477,
-0.0043129753,
0.0537392423,
0.0234977771,
0.0344367474,
-0.0443729199,
0.016455505,
0.0529401638,
0.0394759774,
0.0111421384,
0.0975745842,
0.0547329783,
0.0639719293,
-0.0223320406,
0.0543278493,
-0.0254388265,
0.0090726521,
0.0460443683,
0.0275955442,
-0.0250209849,
0.0085893134,
-0.0138642145,
-0.0453699827,
-0.0100317402,
0.0163540337,
-0.039145451,
0.0035601598,
-0.0543590188,
0.0479717888,
-0.068763867,
0.0136963036,
-0.0188893937,
-0.0819670483,
-0.016089879,
-0.0210803319,
0.0235473439,
0.0754642859,
0.0681779012,
-0.0203503631,
-0.0396774709,
-0.0379971266,
-0.0181661714,
0.0276208874,
0.0631343499,
0.0061736098,
0.020059308,
-0.043208085,
0.0064250017,
-0.0565348715,
0.0096032657,
0.0299346894,
-0.0048373179,
-0.0234943535,
0.0267861709,
0.0327579454,
-0.0540600456,
0.0692592934,
0.058913812,
-0.0656220615,
0.0787547305,
-0.0052171084,
0.0001897172,
0.0261305701,
-0.0232623052,
0.0415123738,
0.007284198,
-0.0134391095,
-0.0296118744,
0.0634840205,
-0.0550006777,
-0.0818676129,
-0.0098410789,
-0.0972527489,
-0.0003510998,
0.0079596005,
-0.018450845,
-0.0289396606,
0.0146795427,
-0.0637943596,
0.0584469251,
-0.0223853774,
-0.0015755184,
-0.0039460622,
0.0042536762,
-0.0210989546,
0.0100215776,
0.0480082184,
0.0216013007,
0.0431206785,
-0.087218821,
0.0165885109,
-0.0326703265,
0.0163445286,
-0.0498748459,
-0.0188516006,
-0.0234341566,
-0.0008543158,
0.0186890569,
-0.0461521149,
-0.0523059815,
-0.0962971225,
-0.0155746294,
-0.0194747504,
0.009182754,
0.0428494215,
-0.0208755285,
-0.009829714,
-0.0496570617,
-0.0172284171,
-0.0715172365,
0.0178582873,
0.0260941144,
0.0632423982,
0.0378139913,
0.0177772641,
-0.0234229341,
-0.0157415662,
-0.0164299961,
0.0269712452,
0.0221390538,
0.0338797979,
-0.0514024943,
-0.0039599896,
-0.0136984978,
-0.0337965302,
0.0298222527,
-0.0423385948,
-0.002762631,
0.0305649657,
0.0924475268,
0.0453102477,
0.0489489995,
-0.004035132,
-0.0267321933,
-0.0046592769,
-0.0203949381,
0.0117211649,
0.0073852069,
-0.0065563079,
-0.004269083,
-0.0582892299,
0.0362781547,
0.0091426913,
0.0520610474,
0.0105555262,
-0.0256574899,
-0.0300600305,
0.0021655178,
-0.0039019494,
-0.0466887765,
-0.0301052723,
-0.0036967758,
-0.0193125308,
-0.0256604869,
-0.0029292388,
0.0503700748,
-0.0027835844,
-0.0341021232,
-0.0574142411,
-0.0111922976,
-0.0447415821,
-0.0111257425,
-0.0534041524,
0.0263978131,
0.0265607908,
-0.0328406952,
-0.0221867915,
-0.1018348634,
0.0384061113,
-0.020884404,
0.0160355382,
-0.0773631334,
-0.0069407215,
0.0001664336,
-0.0360922068,
-0.0532852188,
-0.1008136198,
0.0246859882,
-0.0034002466,
-0.0226243623,
0.0235069618,
-0.042015668,
-0.0481098071,
0.0314708352,
0.0621329695,
-0.0200228579,
-0.020148797,
-0.0157395396,
0.0282226503,
0.0359006822,
-0.01100918,
0.0457102358,
-0.0356917791,
0.0553207733,
0.028834179,
0.063295871,
0.020909695,
-0.0135190533,
-0.020481972,
-0.036615964,
-0.034917932,
0.010589635,
0.0012311105,
0.032756485,
-0.0196055137,
-0.0253565609,
0.0786940977,
0.0012791337,
-0.0229197387,
-0.0159057695,
-0.0467816852,
0.0222953279,
0.0413206071,
0.0482695028,
-0.0354187898,
-0.0041809785,
-0.0168164279,
0.0565260239,
-0.0281844661,
0.0004723383,
-0.0307875369,
-0.0349970236,
0.051084131,
-0.007889878,
0.0323089808,
0.0092524346,
0.0403843857,
-0.0402437896,
0.0501664989,
-0.0021987378,
-0.0215116795,
-0.0618935972,
0.0259649269,
0.0240813754,
-0.0631656274,
0.015087775,
-0.0057044295,
-0.0027333288,
0.0059778765,
0.0383419916,
0.0527082458,
0.0080138063,
-0.0086676041,
0.002268896,
-0.0119822696,
0.0167449806,
0.0454055853,
0.0227441229,
-0.0215252638,
0.0249262154,
0.0066505829,
0.0545067638,
-0.0487248935,
0.0076973266,
0.0601591393,
0.0147281233,
-0.0161175486,
0.0352704301,
-0.008277202,
0.0367341042,
0.0280855801,
0.0517849661,
0.0688765347,
-0.0072273891,
0.0023520046,
0.0031571847,
0.0444920138,
-0.0430865549,
-0.0062578418,
-0.001904141,
-0.0485548005,
0.1138164625,
-0.0818643719,
-0.0549049787,
0.0263380837,
0.0299056377,
0.0062687434,
-0.0195790175,
-0.0752626508,
-0.0149493264,
-0.0493753217,
0.0126550812,
-0.018708393,
0.0533372238,
-0.009625474,
0.0084127448,
-0.007727392,
-0.0510259978,
-0.027046375,
-0.0438883826,
-0.0353119895,
0.012243988,
0.0240199398,
0.0322579183,
0.0110426378,
0.0239307564,
0.0260871388,
0.0169127416,
0.0369594358,
0.0038754668,
-0.0618935339,
0.0320975743,
0.0335357264,
0.0525385998,
-0.0036410503,
0.0100297127,
0.0027489632,
-0.0030911083,
0.0419041403,
-0.0038957165,
0.0560158119,
-0.0229084957,
0.0458336063,
0.027500255,
-0.0007781711,
-0.001892152,
-0.0196105316,
-0.0003593352,
0.0225579161,
0.0060968278,
-0.0514838807,
-0.0444634035,
0.0176380295,
0.0245382842,
0.014898777,
-0.0264752116,
-0.0098675415,
-0.068266049,
0.0334874131,
-0.0711225346,
0.0084070386,
-0.0273261312,
-0.0174044203,
-0.0335885473,
-0.004098929,
-0.0267321113,
0.0247752052,
0.0020338034,
0.0474961028,
-0.0051716333,
0.0875889957,
0.0229720101,
0.0017484052,
-0.0259656031,
0.022941187,
-0.0526012443,
0.0014902105,
-0.021601513,
0.0341713578,
0.0023169296,
0.0159001984,
0.0099496329,
-0.0139190974,
0.0167178717,
0.0307316054,
0.0447511822,
-0.0244736932,
-0.0322683267,
0.0309460666,
-0.0002776451,
0.0035177204,
-0.0140441144,
0.0139885992,
-0.0260668844,
0.0369492471,
0.0005889446,
-0.016081512,
-0.0639308766,
-0.0354118682,
0.0235865116,
0.050578095,
0.0056756521,
-0.0120630814,
-0.0771848336,
-0.0055956868,
0.0147026526,
0.0020797884,
0.0070366436,
-0.0743200108,
0.0252555516,
0.019952368,
-0.0079359775,
-0.0768345967,
-0.0736151934,
0.0588032901,
0.0317575745,
0.0061028437,
-0.0601686686,
-5.588128595e-33,
-0.0115060909,
-0.0002577896,
0.0095284283,
0.0350103676,
-0.0654867068,
0.003250462,
-0.0122814495,
-0.0083305184,
0.0178431422,
0.0269411169,
-0.03618709,
0.0318570063,
0.0009242515,
0.0382295251,
0.0012236194,
0.0383635499,
0.078086257,
-0.0121605219,
-0.056100931,
0.0002919067,
-0.0530391224,
0.0401749797,
0.0434947722,
-0.0579842851,
0.0019982534,
-0.0128587354,
-0.0079384111,
0.0158423986,
0.0184719469,
0.0184177328,
0.0019530974,
-0.014159848,
0.0238353703,
-0.0052392241,
-0.0147025194,
0.0266248006,
-0.0678878501,
-0.0143932011,
0.0385264456,
0.0002897847,
-0.0998867378,
-0.0543449447,
0.000964335,
-0.0340883583,
0.0480473973,
0.0025544839,
0.0179250501,
-0.015697768,
0.0204083361,
0.0708904415,
-0.0361143835,
-0.0158590432,
-0.0107639907,
-0.0291876141,
-0.0383779444,
0.0612983406,
-0.0180988126,
0.0045131827,
-0.0099204434,
-0.003802117,
-0.0059370026,
0.0376372561,
-0.0118222153,
0.0064415685,
-0.0545468517,
0.0121853892,
-0.0078120343,
-0.002043894,
0.021536177,
-0.0092149796,
-0.0540241264,
0.0130288443,
0.0376363955,
0.0800771266,
0.0290041454,
0.0280382093,
0.023380341,
0.0160170197,
0.0312997475,
0.0043561319,
0.0479558893,
0.0021709381,
0.0156947114,
-0.003419295,
-0.0637424514,
0.0056853225,
-0.0158142429,
-0.0203375258,
0.0522260517,
0.0417799316,
-0.0742512271,
0.0243521575,
-0.0137148099,
-0.0019864314,
0.0351039656,
-0.0015560414,
-0.037035279,
0.0074504181,
-0.01814932,
-0.0269691665,
-0.0411575288,
0.0283627082,
0.0512556583,
0.0537735596,
0.016191002,
-0.0218777936,
0.0554263778,
0.0169061497,
-0.0745983869,
0.0121023748,
-0.0200722888,
0.0572777428,
-0.0541262999,
-0.0218518693,
-0.0308928695,
0.0410284735,
-0.0170791782,
0.0421465747,
-0.0209589768,
-0.0173370466,
-0.0479085222,
-0.0293024462,
0.046507787,
0.032337673,
-0.0155245792,
-0.0104587236,
-0.0078786509,
-0.0073839743,
0.03189376,
0.0366104878,
-0.0009422906,
0.0132661276,
2.774e-7,
0.0125708068,
0.0088318018,
0.0673474893,
-0.0400665142,
0.0208421089,
0.0357236713,
0.0390655026,
0.036989551,
0.0092141861,
0.038291093,
0.055563692,
-0.0219134372,
0.0520089604,
-0.0207606461,
-0.092545867,
-0.0148931509,
-0.0751551017,
-0.020805642,
-0.0359955914,
-0.0260594077,
0.0869362131,
0.0392480344,
-0.0033422669,
-0.0115962476,
-0.0109237432,
0.0228590351,
0.04707589,
-0.0214233976,
0.0015353208,
0.0265737344,
-0.0185565259,
-0.0069997339,
0.005799897,
0.0119802328,
-0.0041023148,
0.0177880637,
0.0057075913,
0.069988966,
-0.0028412598,
-0.0212078691,
-0.0028367236,
0.067926459,
-0.0088765854,
-0.0205584262,
-0.0097936094,
-0.072670415,
0.0055445693,
-0.0466751382,
-0.0725965053,
-0.0018917803,
-0.0036509968,
-0.0086622583,
-0.0370649658,
0.0459556617,
0.0166350994,
-0.0028994135,
-0.0245199259,
-0.0470884554,
0.0040645381,
-0.0255743116,
-0.0176076423,
0.0422970094,
-0.016826421,
0.011911802,
-0.0423156731,
-0.1031640992,
-0.000046554,
2.454291237e-34,
0.0072175385,
0.0060663773,
-0.0010967931,
0.0349231847,
0.0483005829,
0.0136078512,
-0.028909564,
0.0237003099,
0.0054920367,
-0.0458133593,
-0.0195775498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08298v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08298v2 | A Survey of Confidence Estimation and Calibration in Large Language Models | 2023-11-14T16:43:29 | 2024-03-25T06:01:49 | Jiahui Geng, Fengyu Cai, Yuxia Wang, Heinz Koeppl, Preslav Nakov, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities across
a wide range of tasks in various domains. Despite their impressive performance,
they can be unreliable due to factual errors in their generations. Assessing
their confidence and calibrating them across different tasks can help mitigate
risks and enable LLMs to produce better generations. There has been a lot of
recent research aiming to address this, but there has been no comprehensive
overview to organize it and outline the main lessons learned. The present
survey aims to bridge this gap. In particular, we outline the challenges and we
summarize recent technical advancements for LLM confidence estimation and
calibration. We further discuss their applications and suggest promising
directions for future work. | [
0.0091317538,
0.0916092768,
0.0132105779,
0.056030944,
-0.0434907824,
-0.0176760517,
0.0041642315,
-0.0362279378,
-0.0249634925,
-0.0423439369,
-0.0350984782,
-0.1124259159,
0.05794679,
0.0068317773,
0.0196215697,
0.0150982523,
0.0263978969,
-0.050068669,
-0.008168512,
-0.0095363054,
-0.0207668673,
0.0069489204,
-0.0021976598,
0.0490276404,
-0.0063114678,
0.005631669,
0.0305771437,
0.0118308952,
0.0139553417,
-0.0293766186,
0.0178680886,
0.0448592193,
0.020352982,
0.1114720851,
0.0000015578,
-0.0381267741,
-0.0168691128,
0.007108625,
-0.0251162592,
0.0299421474,
0.0577000454,
-0.0164826587,
-0.0357201546,
0.0421849489,
0.0015967973,
0.0112147462,
0.0621517301,
-0.0303731225,
-0.0208677221,
0.0645622611,
0.0170264896,
0.0008828485,
0.0071689575,
-0.0229445267,
-0.0392178372,
-0.0375472605,
0.0422407351,
0.0154698929,
-0.0266986135,
-0.0068122218,
-0.0296268668,
0.0495195724,
-0.0160380993,
-0.0375776254,
-0.0302937664,
0.0074489629,
-0.0101529025,
-0.0194251481,
-0.0147798397,
0.0146660088,
0.0027096441,
-0.0257272143,
-0.0226245802,
-0.0193203725,
-0.0304220729,
-0.0050835661,
-0.0401297323,
0.0331247859,
0.0073606838,
0.051382985,
0.0025282963,
-0.0006458526,
0.0438728854,
0.0091011366,
-0.0259955265,
0.0895764977,
0.0445947349,
-0.0029068145,
-0.0262552258,
0.0335984863,
-0.0092642168,
-0.0339129083,
0.0197135936,
0.0135081485,
-0.0458937623,
0.0328540765,
-0.0560275316,
-0.0068494496,
0.0108987093,
-0.0292686783,
0.0474254116,
0.0177659746,
-0.0120153874,
0.0322741568,
-0.0040800842,
0.04786437,
-0.0153409354,
-0.0144793438,
-0.0173959844,
-0.0196859296,
0.0070621152,
0.0347183347,
0.0056814416,
-0.0301309563,
-0.016066812,
-0.0007336812,
-0.0676111877,
0.015169533,
0.0382963307,
0.0309506673,
0.00114057,
-0.0338052399,
-0.0256370548,
-0.0405248925,
0.0014807496,
0.0616134144,
0.0445755571,
0.0100427354,
-0.0244254451,
-0.0667262077,
0.0053008357,
0.021598218,
-0.006183363,
-0.0134817921,
-0.0147903608,
0.0344099812,
0.0162361469,
-0.0497244298,
-0.0262917653,
0.0032800729,
-0.0650476292,
-0.0752199665,
-0.0249021295,
-0.0736722723,
-0.0233709123,
0.0116972364,
0.0237472933,
-0.0387582816,
0.0221901722,
-0.0117175756,
-0.0365918279,
0.0526716113,
-0.0289184358,
0.0154190287,
-0.0091814408,
-0.0272971988,
0.0060252715,
0.0896526501,
0.0655878633,
0.0062454189,
0.0853556022,
0.0240473375,
0.0078933397,
0.0576078407,
-0.0229548402,
0.0178997666,
-0.0226216912,
-0.0272066146,
0.0275154579,
0.0268301554,
0.0222469736,
0.0742639676,
-0.0106597375,
0.0121912202,
0.0910051465,
0.0026730527,
-0.0017200275,
-0.0268094447,
0.0267294459,
-0.011366317,
0.0535057373,
-0.0026695051,
-0.0364062376,
-0.026758723,
-0.0350003093,
0.0255863387,
0.0670617074,
0.0607897714,
0.0091537451,
-0.0280229542,
-0.05102266,
-0.0250704903,
-0.0324811973,
0.0194510575,
0.0982511044,
-0.0494629592,
-0.01356267,
0.0136439512,
0.0221706163,
-0.0474676974,
0.0208123401,
-0.0502076633,
0.0270407815,
0.0427711196,
0.0367018804,
-0.0071788193,
-0.0128164897,
0.0099746659,
-0.0158832781,
0.042059727,
0.0254764147,
-0.0130071566,
0.0333015136,
-0.0553978533,
-0.0191284381,
0.0226090606,
0.0358963273,
0.0136953564,
0.0481906272,
0.0094933435,
0.0282379799,
-0.0367259495,
-0.0141318096,
0.0222659186,
-0.0119641973,
0.0270982943,
0.0112431878,
-0.0269948523,
0.0369832292,
0.0102298716,
-0.0313015357,
0.0183346644,
0.0063363928,
0.0051880525,
-0.0039757611,
-0.0156667903,
-0.0042898268,
-0.0121535193,
0.0888340473,
-0.0033541697,
-0.0093592629,
0.0024093145,
-0.0212308038,
-0.0416390933,
0.0059128096,
-0.0508452952,
0.0411577933,
-0.0550111532,
0.0574932285,
-0.0420116484,
0.0163847115,
-0.0361926705,
0.020199202,
-0.0005542668,
0.0181670897,
0.0220245793,
0.0049111028,
0.0285405796,
-0.0349061675,
-0.0526007563,
-0.0080537219,
0.0034619959,
0.0213857237,
0.0427491553,
-0.0179406069,
-0.0201303475,
-0.0347275101,
-0.0471498929,
0.010560737,
-0.0348174386,
0.0373386294,
0.000070925,
-0.0195352491,
-0.0238861591,
-0.0208395533,
-0.0068856813,
0.0058817002,
0.004193245,
0.0243953075,
0.0221776776,
-0.020709889,
-0.0392138921,
-0.0444189981,
-0.0227704011,
-0.0114021953,
0.0482876487,
0.0139597924,
-0.0273465049,
-0.1001879945,
0.0517252088,
-0.0316329412,
0.0470338836,
0.0043785716,
-0.0226915143,
0.0070950692,
-0.0184572786,
0.0225682519,
0.038477689,
-0.0096097654,
-0.0245438088,
0.0771235675,
-0.0240390226,
-0.0150773861,
-0.0289301388,
-0.0294114556,
-0.0581127219,
-0.0367661528,
-0.038013678,
-0.0207652245,
0.0585437417,
-0.0068892343,
-0.0365356393,
-0.0226013549,
-0.0184286181,
-0.0365270153,
0.0012275951,
0.0114859622,
0.0071086064,
-0.0181136765,
0.0445085689,
-0.0128612584,
-0.0849265158,
0.0437384658,
-0.0937536582,
0.0229709875,
-0.0310956389,
-0.0058271429,
-0.0111698424,
0.0394865908,
0.0172767211,
0.0046926411,
0.0267806705,
-0.0216372442,
-0.0363514312,
0.0074073644,
0.0383548103,
-0.0659435838,
0.0479029901,
-0.0790807381,
0.0404149443,
0.0138558475,
-0.019354023,
-0.0297664031,
-0.026722746,
-0.0680408627,
-0.0135900406,
0.0256490428,
-0.0646085739,
-0.0405063629,
0.01408346,
0.0206921343,
0.0195075218,
-0.0096208453,
0.0076085003,
-0.014647088,
0.0292800572,
0.0726868957,
-0.0002595754,
0.0729974136,
-0.0271210205,
-0.0227671955,
0.0478120223,
0.0245503746,
0.0598555952,
-0.0372034013,
-0.0484804884,
0.0608148463,
0.0028617668,
-0.0093900505,
0.0301990826,
0.0521439761,
-0.0145140411,
-0.0070776441,
0.143778652,
0.0293501355,
-0.0348799378,
-0.0138893351,
0.0085440492,
0.0104475822,
0.0125460392,
0.0050885864,
-0.05917155,
-0.0168441124,
0.0232825782,
0.019628793,
-0.0203204751,
-0.0180177037,
-0.0150084011,
-0.1308289319,
0.0201590341,
0.0238392726,
-0.020032024,
-0.0539123788,
-0.0484813079,
0.0391945951,
-0.0285452157,
0.0566070713,
0.0172121339,
-0.0074439938,
-0.0014555017,
0.0264573358,
-0.0592452511,
-0.0943181217,
0.0000502568,
-0.0667999163,
0.0771102384,
0.0591326579,
0.0181386508,
-0.0039785863,
-0.0150723681,
0.0018277061,
-0.0055384156,
-0.0450585224,
0.0085427174,
0.0314806998,
0.0070366287,
-0.0136337997,
0.0105702523,
-0.0000274568,
-0.025173068,
-0.0081893001,
-0.0288915019,
0.0331001207,
0.0004045038,
-0.0159930214,
0.0163616352,
0.0025636824,
0.0002614068,
0.0568341687,
0.0152378194,
-0.0166598186,
0.0017346403,
-0.0432520509,
-0.0060313423,
-0.032196831,
0.0156277809,
0.0372880585,
-0.0114881797,
-0.010589282,
-0.0487976335,
0.0262699872,
0.0405464396,
0.0199010763,
-0.0035277747,
0.0069048246,
0.0370814502,
-0.0155192213,
-0.0272955187,
-0.0092538018,
-0.0789201632,
0.054142613,
-0.0626135096,
0.047438059,
0.0314479284,
0.009947896,
-0.0058757979,
0.0491414145,
-0.1314498931,
-0.1032193229,
-0.0139322858,
0.0408462472,
0.0242473651,
0.0268772785,
-0.0374775864,
-0.0603221394,
0.0486803763,
0.0030212975,
-0.0074059847,
0.0079802899,
0.0043407045,
0.0102363508,
-0.0204280615,
0.0473423004,
-0.0312925838,
-0.0393481851,
0.0206449609,
0.0481535383,
-0.0090051712,
-0.0786977708,
0.006243113,
0.0088658705,
0.0552511029,
-0.0604477674,
-0.0040556504,
-0.0160164181,
0.0229613613,
-0.0234010741,
-0.018170001,
-0.0263853557,
0.0105807837,
0.0457123406,
-0.019924596,
-0.0325390249,
-0.0310322884,
-0.0172060654,
0.0402188785,
-0.0395946577,
-0.0044780946,
0.0148773408,
0.0106626414,
0.0518914424,
-0.0251474287,
-0.0038312015,
0.0224410444,
0.0347801484,
0.0358308218,
0.0335175954,
0.0153744435,
-0.0039386498,
-0.0401089378,
-0.0224113092,
-0.0084140068,
-0.0721498728,
0.0015107613,
-0.0571707822,
0.047746677,
0.0797273144,
0.0197183155,
0.0789811537,
-0.0309534147,
-0.0153834717,
-0.0581155047,
0.0356599167,
0.0095544141,
-0.0033504602,
0.0184641499,
-0.0291981436,
-0.0442747138,
0.0717058852,
0.0754711255,
0.0254572909,
0.0377982929,
-0.007350998,
-0.0720521957,
0.0012188463,
-0.0311193578,
-0.0113233253,
-0.0118704969,
-0.0560864732,
-0.0107355947,
-0.0443888344,
-0.0807409286,
0.0418452583,
0.0354643427,
-0.0022888198,
-0.0010985315,
-0.0495786816,
0.0468162447,
-0.0118675008,
0.0264693107,
-0.0553112663,
-0.0185475443,
-0.0002980094,
0.0157780722,
-0.0196537506,
-5.820690602e-33,
-0.0143640228,
-0.0091914432,
-0.0443212986,
-0.02185647,
-0.0171251893,
0.0161200501,
-0.0177441072,
0.0493817925,
0.0124582769,
0.0084359925,
0.0017675777,
0.0095762592,
0.0448092408,
0.023844555,
0.0118370727,
0.0076228734,
0.0329253264,
0.0038154395,
-0.0171706788,
-0.0165283605,
0.0380433388,
0.0107955728,
0.1001518667,
-0.0626093298,
0.0400124267,
0.0203538127,
-0.0336732715,
0.046329502,
-0.0094980923,
0.0648224503,
0.0049084225,
0.0620860159,
-0.0088842642,
-0.0124562243,
-0.0158010535,
-0.0295116808,
-0.0221080109,
0.0118530598,
0.013834456,
0.0327378027,
0.0085922927,
-0.0104865916,
-0.000568628,
-0.0184936635,
-0.0363548398,
-0.0055767247,
0.0001661138,
-0.0346978828,
-0.0259968881,
-0.0166956615,
-0.0237218644,
0.0420912579,
0.020642411,
-0.0011639807,
-0.0014543297,
-0.0078168083,
0.0290589575,
-0.0005613237,
-0.0448016711,
0.0183504689,
0.0324402563,
0.0660980642,
0.0759856179,
0.0401964709,
-0.0221938528,
0.0411441177,
-0.0114672137,
0.0005795141,
0.0075463066,
-0.0254932884,
0.0462562889,
-0.0314321145,
0.0277330466,
0.0764012709,
0.0007911243,
0.0108986506,
-0.0597032271,
0.0260243397,
0.0280144345,
0.0211035442,
0.0483066849,
0.0108396299,
-0.028266795,
-0.0158839505,
-0.0518193245,
-0.0428905413,
-0.021490857,
-0.0031124721,
-0.0168833267,
0.013432947,
-0.0107129216,
-0.0014480184,
0.0363208875,
-0.0555201434,
-0.0596537478,
-0.0223510135,
0.0065042493,
0.0252046082,
-0.0352007486,
0.076407969,
-0.0413078554,
-0.0203664713,
-0.0004738823,
-0.0091223251,
-0.0292393025,
-0.0168316495,
0.0209028274,
0.0228208564,
-0.0636749789,
0.0291741285,
-0.0319833942,
-0.0254866034,
0.0236279462,
0.0339217111,
0.0241641812,
-0.0180185754,
0.0038982772,
0.0199856386,
0.0183485206,
0.0292480681,
0.0279839672,
-0.0163211152,
0.0133663798,
0.0040848283,
-0.0300924629,
-0.007721582,
-0.028596554,
-0.0124130361,
0.0313773789,
-0.0059280661,
-0.0046272408,
-0.0101120938,
2.26e-7,
0.0787184015,
0.0448907726,
0.0069987425,
0.0243065469,
0.0121879047,
0.0064751795,
-0.0371912271,
-0.0099148052,
0.0267480332,
-0.0123057598,
-0.0118978024,
-0.0123386038,
0.0724518448,
0.0329470187,
-0.0677542388,
-0.0319572017,
-0.0274965949,
0.0265505016,
-0.021603113,
-0.0136998659,
0.0120971762,
0.1405658126,
-0.0051251762,
-0.0054443735,
-0.0036790827,
-0.0515518747,
0.0639816448,
-0.0064452183,
-0.0506191254,
0.0449016802,
0.030176634,
0.0079043983,
0.0011986912,
0.0039425264,
-0.0165636856,
0.0232362989,
0.0024010204,
0.0388511047,
0.0193951707,
0.0297723562,
-0.0206611063,
0.0052399542,
0.0084431563,
-0.0405346937,
0.0424094684,
-0.0256674048,
-0.011607334,
-0.069712244,
0.0272770878,
-0.0154515775,
0.0441706888,
-0.0382487141,
-0.0298449378,
0.0132110529,
0.0227612574,
0.0193992183,
-0.0326245911,
-0.0647990182,
-0.0369827971,
-0.0050136815,
-0.0392121598,
-0.0738845766,
0.0290617812,
-0.0231771506,
0.0257351883,
-0.0688115135,
0.0540391989,
2.030023183e-34,
0.0539823249,
-0.0053630476,
-0.0318050124,
0.0205094628,
0.0502603129,
-0.0148340724,
-0.0144402608,
0.0093104839,
-0.0057846121,
-0.07825201,
-0.0046591018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08287v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08287v1 | How Well Do Large Language Models Understand Syntax? An Evaluation by Asking Natural Language Questions | 2023-11-14T16:30:36 | 2023-11-14T16:30:36 | Houquan Zhou, Yang Hou, Zhenghua Li, Xuebin Wang, Zhefeng Wang, Xinyu Duan, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | While recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) bring us closer to
achieving artificial general intelligence, the question persists: Do LLMs truly
understand language, or do they merely mimic comprehension through pattern
recognition? This study seeks to explore this question through the lens of
syntax, a crucial component of sentence comprehension. Adopting a natural
language question-answering (Q&A) scheme, we craft questions targeting nine
syntactic knowledge points that are most closely related to sentence
comprehension. Experiments conducted on 24 LLMs suggest that most have a
limited grasp of syntactic knowledge, exhibiting notable discrepancies across
different syntactic knowledge points. In particular, questions involving
prepositional phrase attachment pose the greatest challenge, whereas those
concerning adjectival modifier and indirect object are relatively easier for
LLMs to handle. Furthermore, a case study on the training dynamics of the LLMs
reveals that the majority of syntactic knowledge is learned during the initial
stages of training, hinting that simply increasing the number of training
tokens may not be the `silver bullet' for improving the comprehension ability
of LLMs. | [
0.0835499018,
0.0075936173,
-0.0426745713,
0.0421576314,
-0.0425747558,
0.0357190259,
-0.0207485948,
-0.0117120557,
0.0149908243,
-0.0616207346,
-0.0306807458,
-0.0097907055,
-0.0443426445,
0.0048253676,
0.0567563288,
-0.0285972916,
0.0381457694,
-0.0456102677,
0.0096844332,
-0.0084362021,
-0.0143925762,
0.0084560877,
-0.0095014684,
0.0108230254,
0.0053515895,
-0.037198551,
-0.01839187,
-0.0214781761,
-0.0197582021,
-0.0266108122,
-0.0104833078,
-0.0169729814,
0.0016477569,
0.0039016476,
0.0000017312,
-0.1036903933,
0.0145297069,
-0.0013669919,
-0.0739564151,
0.0130171357,
0.0125612644,
-0.0010665257,
0.0172963105,
0.0233162642,
-0.06548848,
-0.0134029323,
0.0027153983,
0.013703445,
0.0262339506,
0.0626906678,
0.0183863156,
-0.0615523867,
0.0323305726,
0.0303831678,
0.0275482275,
-0.0441449173,
0.0301201921,
0.0215820875,
0.0174696147,
-0.0046591791,
-0.0088856667,
0.0178803373,
0.0344557688,
-0.0118173109,
0.0269867666,
0.0251050461,
-0.0299341809,
-0.0293628238,
-0.0339688137,
0.0178471506,
0.0085591245,
-0.0155303301,
-0.0292899124,
0.0130413799,
0.0359277055,
-0.0143883396,
-0.0736130327,
0.0617675371,
0.0025380633,
0.0314027034,
0.0403429456,
-0.0629059896,
0.0102055473,
0.0098208878,
-0.0058747423,
0.0873759612,
-0.0047063921,
-0.021271443,
0.0139876418,
0.0309506152,
-0.0513588414,
-0.0558960848,
0.0010415367,
0.0642782748,
-0.0127855586,
0.0226093046,
-0.0013144844,
-0.017479796,
0.0181393418,
-0.0608616434,
0.074515,
0.0123858033,
0.0061651212,
0.0477340035,
-0.0246348325,
0.0496951789,
0.0099270921,
0.0304940995,
-0.0507683828,
-0.0145881958,
-0.060762994,
-0.0567682162,
-0.0285286549,
0.0743220598,
-0.0048801797,
0.004506859,
0.0205049533,
0.0365656801,
0.0417461731,
0.0361727066,
-0.0141270421,
-0.0052764872,
-0.0335971043,
-0.0033742345,
-0.0860220268,
-0.0139532927,
-0.0430074446,
0.0333047174,
-0.0087590115,
-0.0638750866,
-0.0136930607,
0.0339588933,
-0.0100561567,
-0.0400675572,
0.0272947662,
0.0612103082,
-0.0138102686,
-0.0274233483,
-0.0524828099,
-0.0212081447,
-0.0344985984,
-0.0586844683,
0.0234394763,
-0.0600750335,
-0.02439522,
0.0507845916,
-0.0265719276,
-0.0126245813,
0.0074861525,
0.0086382786,
-0.0261492785,
0.0491125919,
0.0212240051,
0.0209129732,
0.0195706971,
-0.0499339662,
-0.0161061604,
0.0290906709,
0.0300998855,
-0.013352219,
0.0184843261,
-0.0252989139,
-0.0216580182,
0.0124449329,
-0.0180079304,
-0.0124953669,
-0.0682509616,
0.0519540198,
0.0303469896,
0.0220309086,
0.04297328,
0.0631392896,
0.0194883235,
-0.015937224,
0.0514143631,
0.0333887972,
-0.0343395844,
0.0423617959,
0.0849987492,
0.0066292547,
0.0381534956,
0.0199656989,
-0.0686676204,
0.0028675187,
-0.0562034994,
0.0237389356,
-0.0395448171,
0.0210611485,
-0.0055002463,
-0.0706207827,
-0.0412960798,
0.0100638783,
-0.0097176358,
0.0345652103,
0.0327447802,
0.0175447501,
0.0041805254,
0.0192691758,
-0.0017970093,
-0.0215600636,
0.0059260065,
-0.0482526161,
0.046444755,
0.0156263039,
0.002106406,
-0.0231412482,
-0.0786169916,
0.0021458121,
0.0031606315,
0.0373652428,
0.0565366633,
0.0070649115,
0.0115582701,
0.0123911984,
0.0197032206,
-0.0836786926,
-0.0002740084,
-0.01364436,
-0.037702769,
-0.0114712222,
-0.0104373461,
-0.0742445067,
0.0002800056,
0.0589912049,
-0.0156824179,
-0.0183779448,
-0.0280279815,
-0.0050551579,
0.0317910053,
0.0054652477,
0.0057463767,
0.0240921769,
0.0418851823,
-0.0448684432,
-0.0000322827,
0.0019789056,
-0.014174155,
-0.0263533648,
0.0492035896,
0.0012275287,
-0.0575303696,
0.0251596365,
-0.0056176959,
-0.0418271683,
0.0092544612,
-0.0663410723,
0.0622131564,
-0.038683217,
0.0231129061,
-0.0024197835,
-0.0084864013,
-0.0368347019,
0.08451619,
0.035875421,
0.0203113351,
-0.0240633916,
-0.0133491233,
0.0063750064,
-0.0047720382,
0.0027617244,
-0.014737769,
-0.0145772733,
-0.0267415959,
0.0134694232,
0.0264184885,
-0.0830634162,
-0.0266116709,
-0.0482697301,
0.0318681188,
-0.0029028279,
0.0600562096,
0.0161678605,
-0.0244972929,
-0.0185141433,
-0.0218568798,
-0.0318921357,
0.0224593095,
0.0091265505,
0.0054938574,
0.0713520348,
0.0214147475,
-0.0552296937,
-0.0332038291,
0.0089051602,
-0.0419498086,
0.0267194565,
0.0191199258,
0.0148028657,
-0.0461607277,
0.0453296192,
-0.0063275527,
-0.00885709,
0.0343377739,
-0.0589191541,
0.0192207359,
-0.0143183311,
0.0028940153,
0.118976675,
-0.0249251314,
0.0055595664,
0.050112918,
-0.0065883514,
-0.0455781743,
0.0240026675,
0.0036114966,
-0.0569467694,
-0.0804210976,
-0.0001581366,
-0.0133287581,
0.082484059,
-0.0077923625,
-0.0179396681,
0.0015025367,
0.0425578766,
-0.0241309274,
-0.0278614778,
-0.0241101924,
-0.0070013562,
-0.0100289145,
0.032362029,
-0.0003696119,
-0.0286776386,
0.0604781359,
-0.0059594517,
-0.0295605026,
-0.0716066211,
-0.036507953,
-0.0277865343,
0.0745414272,
0.0426777005,
0.0184759144,
0.0309476759,
-0.0522145182,
-0.0636743754,
-0.0090713119,
0.0144232828,
0.0171849448,
0.0087609831,
-0.0569803528,
0.0020043212,
0.0085401647,
-0.0316408239,
-0.0411958657,
-0.0427320898,
-0.0645032525,
0.0111706117,
-0.0044555175,
0.0158052687,
-0.0069778892,
-0.0191574767,
0.0363966338,
-0.0372821912,
-0.0124960039,
-0.0242501125,
-0.0483978353,
0.0180763397,
0.0394561626,
0.0458713882,
0.0045213643,
-0.0086524198,
0.0156646427,
0.0256823637,
0.030467052,
0.0320006683,
-0.0296651386,
0.0311018042,
0.0136999991,
-0.0403399095,
-0.0763466433,
0.0345339738,
0.0542782657,
-0.0507901013,
-0.0203250721,
0.1095194519,
0.0700649619,
-0.0017567591,
0.0209596585,
-0.0544028021,
0.0334210917,
0.0422520116,
0.0472790413,
-0.0312596299,
-0.0215340052,
0.0221772678,
-0.0223677922,
-0.0297507588,
-0.0180591773,
0.0003880396,
-0.1308102012,
0.0302545112,
-0.020390911,
-0.0379555784,
0.0108361822,
-0.0274489447,
0.0142376246,
0.0351754054,
0.0490775965,
0.0108136022,
-0.0545600019,
0.0022433226,
0.0288319644,
-0.0398899801,
-0.0054998356,
0.029306313,
-0.034966182,
0.0326415934,
0.0729915649,
0.0162930712,
-0.0461376756,
0.0113630537,
0.0284505654,
0.0077516395,
0.0316461474,
-0.0056265565,
0.0230814926,
0.0011037065,
-0.0058107488,
-0.0116455937,
0.0324933194,
-0.0415004119,
0.0263998993,
0.0332166255,
0.0893893167,
-0.033210285,
-0.013059495,
0.0008908721,
-0.0047697667,
-0.0544639118,
0.0784073472,
0.055373434,
-0.0230274647,
-0.0486968383,
-0.0507333316,
-0.0091468785,
-0.0090852259,
-0.007182356,
0.0649444908,
-0.001667752,
0.0334011801,
-0.0584032871,
-0.0604671463,
0.081052877,
-0.0114526432,
0.0013007893,
0.0166528244,
0.0277775861,
-0.0050689112,
-0.0003252214,
0.0183194466,
-0.0211233217,
-0.001854974,
-0.0423655249,
-0.0098769134,
0.0136876479,
0.0102346027,
-0.0332646258,
-0.0336851478,
-0.0365727916,
-0.0429652147,
0.0069906041,
0.0547236837,
0.0222960338,
-0.0018554883,
0.0059907185,
-0.0360066295,
-0.0273994058,
0.024709424,
-0.0283717997,
0.0381827839,
0.0018415786,
-0.0141900638,
0.0116552077,
0.0344160236,
-0.0281035472,
-0.0147219291,
0.013501077,
0.0354933515,
-0.0026943558,
-0.026838975,
0.0691072047,
0.0489967242,
0.0182119962,
0.0254962668,
0.0047062174,
0.0169605687,
0.0080360249,
-0.0488238111,
-0.0062999576,
-0.0154756401,
-0.0122174853,
0.0205913596,
0.0184871033,
0.0102325901,
-0.0143360058,
-0.0324377194,
0.054571759,
-0.0022540579,
0.0030420471,
0.028188346,
-0.0486223437,
0.002373039,
0.0126490649,
-0.0115978597,
-0.0174270608,
0.0202790778,
0.0181640573,
0.0149027118,
0.0173309986,
0.0247224532,
0.0036496758,
-0.0366059355,
-0.0122877024,
-0.0564439334,
-0.0765597075,
0.042351719,
0.0339719839,
0.0548053756,
-0.0460432284,
0.0326496996,
-0.0423815623,
-0.00315138,
-0.0029976857,
-0.0103447204,
-0.0064320918,
-0.0238322821,
0.0852060318,
0.0170129593,
-0.0358523764,
-0.0322134942,
0.071878545,
0.0278814919,
0.0488589853,
0.0290141944,
-0.0079757562,
-0.0249058511,
-0.0225322973,
0.0245819855,
-0.0369807668,
-0.0011777953,
0.041369196,
-0.0240465011,
-0.0703743771,
0.0076831663,
-0.0128830839,
0.0012737162,
-0.0797253475,
0.0179498047,
0.074424468,
0.0445713475,
-0.0847226977,
-0.0302778985,
0.0260025673,
0.0079002986,
-0.0070596221,
-0.0203793086,
-6.024373283e-33,
-0.0377419889,
-0.0244330522,
0.025131721,
0.0192302801,
-0.0132489298,
-0.0250862222,
-0.0192287602,
0.0002203132,
-0.0379616283,
0.0059448965,
-0.0274101458,
0.0357566699,
0.0185837485,
0.0191613603,
0.0485670753,
-0.0299651679,
0.0057796291,
-0.0492241718,
0.0125871897,
-0.0168460086,
-0.0040674866,
0.0288184658,
0.0408513471,
0.0264662355,
0.0171647202,
-0.0052639176,
0.021894427,
0.0405909978,
-0.0115109198,
0.0595339462,
-0.0206319578,
0.0198843535,
0.0274396893,
-0.0072320593,
-0.0112579679,
0.0197713301,
-0.0337022617,
-0.060107477,
0.0458959974,
0.018842807,
-0.0451092497,
-0.0515535101,
0.0619929656,
0.0036878064,
0.01069503,
0.0258743446,
0.0389192216,
-0.0286827851,
0.0132507561,
0.0305139422,
-0.0557339825,
-0.0159921069,
-0.0330955833,
-0.0105100684,
-0.0098432284,
0.0042579733,
-0.0182640143,
0.0131901158,
-0.0145553285,
-0.0136539424,
-0.0036328505,
0.0443737917,
0.0364708528,
-0.0141744995,
0.0302470233,
0.0105438018,
0.0024102451,
0.0014251142,
-0.003437594,
0.0456526205,
0.0155837508,
0.0492174439,
0.0010530779,
0.029828852,
0.027838096,
0.0431091301,
-0.0877302662,
-0.0059559001,
0.0285808034,
0.0936547443,
0.0038397906,
0.0087697962,
-0.005142644,
0.0092652356,
-0.0467099659,
0.0463603139,
-0.0152329272,
-0.0308833215,
0.0341945291,
-0.0620217584,
0.0104829436,
-0.0323359296,
0.0236719642,
-0.0405473411,
-0.0114296107,
-0.0120029915,
-0.0134574343,
0.0512996837,
0.019020522,
0.0781343728,
-0.0650027096,
-0.0257121809,
-0.0250035431,
-0.0431025773,
0.0208697915,
0.0409475937,
0.0275013633,
0.0052508968,
-0.0455717407,
-0.0093917996,
-0.0281733945,
0.0027110181,
-0.0292627346,
0.00730641,
0.0224193782,
0.0358757637,
0.0207722504,
0.0542161427,
0.0033885622,
-0.0224964488,
-0.0569072999,
0.0062562195,
-0.0191851761,
0.00322693,
-0.0332679003,
-0.0227699485,
-0.0425128378,
0.0317747854,
-0.0007993091,
-0.0310431961,
-0.0046239034,
0.0143752992,
2.6e-7,
0.0922007114,
0.068232581,
-0.0003497893,
0.0865544677,
-0.0031661806,
0.0375687554,
-0.0325140804,
0.0239305887,
0.0394825488,
-0.0197627153,
-0.0051091784,
0.035763476,
0.0021847896,
0.0209878497,
-0.0823573247,
0.0437902436,
-0.0549836494,
-0.0094357673,
-0.0605893694,
0.0075294012,
0.0440309569,
0.0784682482,
-0.0211291518,
-0.0116663342,
-0.0434346199,
-0.0957873687,
0.0312256608,
-0.0260200668,
-0.0438057445,
0.0181338154,
0.0292678252,
0.0205889605,
0.0037927588,
0.0591914952,
0.0260961298,
0.0091056144,
-0.0236108359,
0.0343576483,
-0.0025679795,
0.0095766531,
-0.0167261753,
-0.0310205277,
0.0151309408,
-0.0857378542,
0.0895786956,
-0.0825050175,
-0.0622557439,
-0.0064596799,
0.0005113791,
-0.0340500176,
-0.0202044193,
-0.0228523873,
0.0085521638,
0.0211828332,
0.0164116845,
-0.0451555736,
0.0008076857,
-0.006817197,
0.0027588157,
0.0386517681,
-0.0009963122,
-0.0277788769,
-0.0331509784,
0.0084911697,
0.0226967931,
-0.0212650374,
-0.0164526254,
2.051024125e-34,
0.0235600919,
-0.0080178864,
0.0485070087,
0.0397753157,
0.062699087,
0.0100210365,
-0.0582304969,
0.034551397,
-0.0098403674,
-0.1134561002,
0.011457948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08273v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08273v1 | Examining Modularity in Multilingual LMs via Language-Specialized Subnetworks | 2023-11-14T16:11:23 | 2023-11-14T16:11:23 | Rochelle Choenni, Ekaterina Shutova, Dan Garrette | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work has proposed explicitly inducing language-wise modularity in
multilingual LMs via sparse fine-tuning (SFT) on per-language subnetworks as a
means of better guiding cross-lingual sharing. In this work, we investigate (1)
the degree to which language-wise modularity naturally arises within models
with no special modularity interventions, and (2) how cross-lingual sharing and
interference differ between such models and those with explicit SFT-guided
subnetwork modularity. To quantify language specialization and cross-lingual
interaction, we use a Training Data Attribution method that estimates the
degree to which a model's predictions are influenced by in-language or
cross-language training examples. Our results show that language-specialized
subnetworks do naturally arise, and that SFT, rather than always increasing
modularity, can decrease language specialization of subnetworks in favor of
more cross-lingual sharing. | [
0.0209775697,
0.0255175661,
-0.0704095736,
0.0728533417,
-0.0026821396,
0.009066375,
0.0528454483,
0.0037945977,
-0.0351186059,
0.0009762083,
-0.105392538,
-0.0489060208,
0.0015745198,
-0.0302784536,
0.0726547316,
-0.0337876193,
0.0541601405,
-0.0280887019,
-0.0646175519,
-0.0347228609,
0.013466794,
-0.0186163709,
0.0276603736,
0.0214809943,
0.0286904387,
0.0291901212,
0.028458802,
0.0044404245,
0.0235556681,
0.0061242096,
-0.0144537678,
0.0539179556,
0.0247066189,
0.0123446826,
0.0000018221,
-0.00004008,
0.012894324,
-0.0210119784,
-0.0225917753,
0.0206799544,
0.0193158425,
0.0055255704,
0.038998872,
-0.0296544693,
-0.0207025781,
0.0052516963,
0.0772107393,
0.0199539345,
-0.0132669779,
0.0314253606,
-0.0198071916,
0.009483831,
-0.0196051039,
-0.0349578783,
0.0501916036,
-0.0152873155,
-0.0095154541,
0.0227277093,
-0.0371980183,
0.0050293198,
-0.0402880572,
0.0220736805,
0.0231562015,
0.0361106806,
0.0091482149,
0.0262441169,
-0.0058312407,
-0.0191615894,
0.0160206575,
0.0460689589,
0.0133431582,
-0.0126539078,
-0.0211394504,
-0.0149689978,
0.0152483955,
0.0205605458,
-0.0566445589,
0.0142273353,
0.0178465713,
0.0144281741,
0.0897685662,
-0.0148253497,
0.0451418534,
0.0194607265,
-0.0005892471,
0.0593044981,
0.0216354188,
-0.0154216718,
-0.0216088202,
0.0315651037,
-0.0187595394,
-0.0224929024,
-0.0236809012,
-0.016809335,
0.0156604573,
0.0105870776,
-0.011671355,
-0.0270436741,
0.0246122312,
-0.0159320571,
0.0340450071,
0.0312796161,
-0.0108839804,
-0.0020129834,
-0.0001068507,
-0.0012702005,
-0.0339349099,
0.0563958362,
-0.0425833538,
-0.0272898581,
-0.0403586328,
-0.0076270821,
0.0035941566,
0.0049667978,
-0.0119770756,
0.0212383531,
-0.0542990491,
0.0261488818,
-0.0150415562,
-0.0220828969,
-0.0096961344,
-0.0123849567,
-0.0520408787,
-0.0100448076,
0.0051314249,
0.050479237,
-0.0408443585,
0.0349411219,
-0.0064848675,
-0.0620100722,
-0.0030510349,
0.0268441718,
-0.0395766683,
-0.0496006198,
0.0251372773,
0.0698664933,
-0.011361639,
-0.0190038998,
-0.0290953312,
-0.0363719016,
-0.0158834644,
-0.0733593181,
0.028190447,
-0.07948865,
-0.0091077751,
0.0467723534,
0.0277342219,
-0.0063304286,
-0.0338105708,
-0.0557168834,
-0.0476243384,
0.0471319072,
-0.0039077969,
0.0050985739,
0.0081972061,
0.004540679,
0.0094955647,
0.0912508816,
0.0195607133,
-0.0173997562,
0.046343524,
-0.0221984722,
-0.0094929794,
0.0489517897,
-0.0070556351,
0.0522571355,
-0.0302866269,
-0.04222342,
0.0148653863,
-0.0390342399,
0.0150247877,
-0.0136133069,
-0.0428081788,
0.0175923351,
0.0670370832,
0.0404738858,
0.0541503318,
0.0562090464,
0.0086480808,
-0.0487392098,
-0.0133124478,
0.0591541454,
-0.0658330992,
0.0469933152,
-0.0053248233,
-0.0282021724,
0.003671977,
0.0389150269,
-0.073033236,
-0.034192767,
-0.0137117626,
-0.0140174283,
0.0255388413,
0.0270071756,
0.0411055908,
-0.0320153199,
0.0265558921,
0.077827163,
0.0546086803,
-0.0455652513,
0.036403995,
-0.0589673854,
0.0006116575,
0.0303904377,
-0.0027092427,
-0.0303878114,
-0.0305348132,
-0.0006476277,
0.0210609529,
0.0465672128,
0.0644372031,
0.0069227628,
0.0446776785,
-0.0473336801,
-0.0114341872,
-0.0296417791,
0.0295481756,
0.044226747,
-0.0151470657,
-0.002750793,
-0.0211753808,
-0.0317542627,
-0.0130495653,
0.0047551789,
-0.0460544713,
0.0251426697,
-0.0123160128,
0.0092593962,
0.0328198709,
0.0018607888,
-0.0228782371,
-0.0233207978,
-0.0172760561,
-0.0186040998,
0.0041774139,
0.0374234654,
-0.0332356356,
0.0012989584,
-0.0048072953,
-0.0248301253,
0.0064615165,
0.0153502608,
0.0052808793,
-0.0391838178,
0.040255338,
-0.0050632898,
0.0318865329,
-0.046485208,
-0.0020356386,
-0.0516879037,
0.0243274868,
-0.027630059,
0.0057682404,
-0.0273066517,
0.0334126018,
0.0071182568,
-0.0306405127,
0.0304148849,
-0.0004148311,
-0.0403039679,
0.0378222056,
-0.010796031,
0.0098221358,
0.0042916234,
0.0148267709,
-0.0284660161,
-0.0359356105,
-0.0904733464,
-0.0184219927,
-0.0443213768,
0.0214657802,
0.0502019972,
0.0182116721,
-0.002119978,
0.0087690335,
-0.0209536273,
0.037853308,
0.0281811524,
0.0593472421,
-0.0122668231,
0.0305434689,
-0.0153427785,
-0.0498073995,
-0.0524470918,
0.0304537732,
0.0292663444,
-0.0013513642,
-0.0050471034,
-0.0705867931,
0.0092555322,
-0.0723681524,
-0.0026089537,
-0.0323656537,
-0.0621869676,
-0.0048646899,
0.0066823503,
0.0300670136,
0.0415978655,
-0.0491833538,
-0.0165781472,
0.1043231711,
-0.012072484,
0.0089078816,
-0.0178948659,
-0.0161169954,
-0.0038170596,
-0.070425801,
-0.0488863029,
-0.0256199595,
0.0680060312,
-0.0059597236,
-0.0316710547,
-0.0350933112,
-0.0368186943,
-0.0214935448,
-0.0330225304,
0.0318389684,
0.0022517829,
-0.0077969059,
0.0668194517,
-0.0171401743,
-0.0952309147,
0.0441459939,
0.0013981101,
-0.0154082868,
-0.015289613,
-0.0186917577,
-0.0250270087,
-0.0052533364,
-0.007413635,
0.0173401963,
-0.0170806088,
-0.0431724228,
-0.0716420934,
-0.0162971169,
0.0452046022,
0.0172198974,
0.102646485,
-0.0167628285,
-0.0245970599,
-0.0363623761,
-0.0205258001,
-0.0012672375,
0.01170405,
-0.0125860553,
0.0385515504,
0.0577353872,
-0.0058355881,
-0.0298460852,
-0.0134987617,
0.0389223509,
0.0166249797,
-0.0449578948,
0.0060747708,
0.0040903748,
-0.0188367944,
-0.0057024863,
0.0389273651,
0.0312818252,
-0.0834269896,
0.0190834366,
-0.0340308733,
0.0237655118,
-0.0093539655,
0.0428328142,
0.0274722967,
0.0330352709,
0.0053935545,
-0.0438205339,
0.0209823623,
0.0828179345,
-0.0220987238,
0.0039462,
0.0643297583,
-0.0109365629,
-0.0847050548,
-0.0077887578,
-0.0714880452,
0.0488898493,
0.0608688444,
0.0089939404,
-0.0452977344,
-0.0106567042,
-0.0066297944,
-0.0209373441,
0.0064399159,
-0.0029591254,
0.0205809101,
-0.051686991,
0.0176949222,
0.0328638218,
-0.0918403342,
0.0002696972,
-0.0029579201,
0.0074078077,
-0.017571507,
0.0276814215,
-0.0455120765,
-0.0169194806,
-0.0485810302,
0.0037613055,
-0.02101155,
-0.0373764001,
-0.0091625312,
-0.0570331141,
0.0244274158,
-0.0049162954,
0.0036641117,
-0.035030432,
-0.0033401737,
0.047690466,
-0.0368142091,
0.0197124761,
-0.0405309945,
0.0494715162,
0.024834251,
-0.0165527761,
0.0115448777,
-0.0166891608,
0.0036190371,
-0.0141400127,
-0.0388344228,
0.0633347258,
-0.0205493774,
0.0217145998,
0.0326964408,
0.0005658235,
-0.0130725875,
0.0410390981,
0.0464614108,
-0.0232456122,
0.014060677,
-0.0161695015,
-0.0370733924,
-0.0015817668,
-0.0182429478,
0.01982655,
-0.0460675992,
-0.0146345664,
-0.025078617,
-0.0511119924,
0.0215065945,
-0.0211035945,
0.0311222412,
0.0605751164,
-0.0273634885,
-0.0282953642,
0.012551982,
0.0189451762,
-0.0396189876,
-0.0092587918,
-0.0496940389,
-0.0391756743,
0.0244270544,
-0.0597085729,
0.0283744559,
-0.0049549569,
-0.0860510096,
-0.0830805451,
-0.0010446307,
0.0498008318,
0.0202439558,
0.0687611103,
0.0300737396,
-0.0844919682,
0.022003958,
0.0234148446,
0.0021997015,
0.0353826024,
0.0375205204,
-0.022275269,
-0.0110230008,
0.0489638373,
-0.0300471857,
0.0070127854,
0.0784910098,
0.0014192841,
-0.0316557325,
0.0110361371,
-0.023500381,
-0.0089171138,
0.0314374678,
-0.0412794016,
-0.0162368529,
-0.0703628585,
0.0252595562,
-0.0121488357,
0.0116929831,
-0.0189781543,
-0.0632153377,
0.0204283558,
0.0054443702,
0.0124581885,
0.0672632307,
-0.0182075538,
0.0501376353,
-0.0125943935,
0.087196365,
-0.0307013448,
-0.0278752055,
-0.0060723037,
0.0784442127,
0.0178521145,
0.0093485285,
0.0107626962,
-0.005023872,
-0.0070422245,
0.0497903191,
-0.0029923923,
-0.0055314223,
-0.0665023625,
0.0325155929,
-0.0540360361,
-0.0786089525,
0.0193879474,
0.0159118641,
0.0628594682,
-0.0538356453,
0.0673685595,
-0.0316320471,
-0.0029911224,
-0.0308160502,
0.0413666181,
-0.0223895349,
-0.0002845346,
0.0505713448,
0.0148559343,
-0.0205714442,
0.0075264382,
0.0748997927,
-0.0092942175,
0.0305598211,
-0.0138389207,
-0.014917776,
-0.0110149533,
-0.0103687067,
0.0821101144,
0.0201490391,
-0.0442676023,
0.0005847722,
-0.0349394158,
-0.0743673444,
-0.009601526,
-0.0193914641,
0.0318327472,
-0.0200965758,
-0.0068691527,
0.0742390305,
-0.0226199776,
-0.0019801471,
-0.0225946102,
-0.0299553778,
0.0361077525,
0.0010219036,
0.0118291341,
-6.286195548e-33,
-0.0270719845,
-0.0009050055,
0.0067312922,
0.0634837598,
0.0004165325,
0.0080741858,
-0.0134795168,
0.0617888384,
-0.028326273,
-0.0084131891,
-0.0072538708,
-0.0039002795,
0.0167459939,
-0.0214599799,
0.0513026379,
-0.0097953156,
0.0407603346,
0.00592004,
-0.0201260019,
0.0282386318,
-0.014883955,
0.014980386,
0.1361704022,
0.0104581816,
0.041631449,
-0.0042101415,
0.0297896396,
0.0072485832,
-0.0316461474,
0.0658751205,
-0.0110423435,
0.0588608384,
0.0752324983,
-0.0362347662,
-0.0362308547,
-0.0113275256,
-0.0312285945,
-0.0448302329,
0.0585473627,
-0.0065398994,
0.0212620385,
-0.0617832877,
0.0531290546,
-0.0111591481,
-0.0369292013,
-0.0323815756,
0.0373893529,
-0.0229375232,
-0.0182018951,
0.0245096609,
-0.07976868,
-0.0082052192,
0.0150751136,
0.0144628631,
0.0405591428,
0.0275863763,
-0.0221374817,
0.0116595011,
0.0060178069,
0.0401990674,
0.0137041723,
0.0561763421,
0.0489625968,
0.036332,
0.0007912759,
0.0222704355,
0.0487737879,
0.0760508776,
0.0196889918,
-0.0062580137,
0.0920315534,
0.0237723663,
0.0639540702,
0.0713581443,
0.0477783829,
0.0044059013,
-0.0640686303,
0.0024514121,
-0.0091006327,
0.0313123465,
0.0194852892,
0.0335374027,
0.0293215998,
-0.0256771166,
-0.0482714102,
-0.0181357618,
-0.0389410444,
-0.031777598,
0.0006906317,
-0.0014753042,
-0.008694767,
-0.003031529,
0.1051314101,
-0.0478655025,
-0.0170179568,
0.0095012905,
0.0015859974,
0.0343731642,
0.0181647595,
-0.0387881622,
-0.0699171796,
-0.0521778651,
-0.0102815917,
-0.0059018065,
-0.0080775684,
0.0348290317,
0.0842516497,
0.0080661569,
-0.0152415205,
0.015441495,
-0.020006286,
-0.0284546223,
0.0324088112,
0.0696645603,
0.0203463994,
0.0047153439,
-0.0190604068,
0.0106896507,
0.0264543351,
-0.0228714626,
-0.0497450046,
-0.0254613925,
-0.024090562,
0.0566464067,
-0.0042547793,
0.0110438904,
-0.0891522244,
-0.0493969098,
0.0539889075,
-0.0215345044,
-0.0409496799,
-0.0123839239,
2.544e-7,
0.0132650519,
0.026894046,
-0.0398839675,
-0.0177231189,
0.0333158113,
0.0018910486,
-0.0538985431,
-0.004439211,
0.0257047303,
-0.0247079488,
0.02733244,
0.0509032942,
0.032482475,
0.0257532466,
-0.0371719413,
0.0304700639,
-0.0047748401,
-0.0053717373,
-0.0236448776,
-0.0036531615,
-0.02762964,
0.0615129173,
0.0071148206,
-0.0063305367,
0.0004615815,
-0.0143094203,
0.0683803707,
-0.087710537,
-0.0279334877,
0.0337036327,
-0.0096592503,
0.0363638327,
-0.0090463264,
0.0219621193,
-0.0210433304,
-0.0063741151,
-0.0243969038,
0.0240493547,
-0.0169773307,
0.0050413189,
-0.0010231547,
0.0138773136,
-0.0142781781,
-0.0549567379,
0.029369846,
-0.0255788583,
-0.0202346202,
-0.0199567117,
0.0364368819,
0.0087336982,
0.0871367604,
-0.0563519523,
0.0012505553,
0.0384678356,
0.0017340144,
0.0110478373,
-0.0107588107,
-0.0278296154,
-0.0159851927,
0.018111214,
-0.0753812194,
-0.064036198,
-0.0259348135,
-0.0418688431,
0.0049884156,
-0.0222474206,
0.0024182913,
2.189645674e-34,
0.0136182876,
0.0220897906,
0.0631411076,
0.033762034,
0.013253049,
-0.0200383533,
-0.063009955,
0.0291976985,
-0.0199113023,
-0.0738433003,
-0.0118788956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08268v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08268v4 | A Wolf in Sheep's Clothing: Generalized Nested Jailbreak Prompts can Fool Large Language Models Easily | 2023-11-14T16:02:16 | 2024-04-07T03:04:10 | Peng Ding, Jun Kuang, Dan Ma, Xuezhi Cao, Yunsen Xian, Jiajun Chen, Shujian Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT and GPT-4, are designed to
provide useful and safe responses. However, adversarial prompts known as
'jailbreaks' can circumvent safeguards, leading LLMs to generate potentially
harmful content. Exploring jailbreak prompts can help to better reveal the
weaknesses of LLMs and further steer us to secure them. Unfortunately, existing
jailbreak methods either suffer from intricate manual design or require
optimization on other white-box models, which compromises either generalization
or efficiency. In this paper, we generalize jailbreak prompt attacks into two
aspects: (1) Prompt Rewriting and (2) Scenario Nesting. Based on this, we
propose ReNeLLM, an automatic framework that leverages LLMs themselves to
generate effective jailbreak prompts. Extensive experiments demonstrate that
ReNeLLM significantly improves the attack success rate while greatly reducing
the time cost compared to existing baselines. Our study also reveals the
inadequacy of current defense methods in safeguarding LLMs. Finally, we analyze
the failure of LLMs defense from the perspective of prompt execution priority,
and propose corresponding defense strategies. We hope that our research can
catalyze both the academic community and LLMs developers towards the provision
of safer and more regulated LLMs. The code is available at
https://github.com/NJUNLP/ReNeLLM. | [
0.0537573695,
0.0526275598,
-0.0103525976,
0.0409685895,
-0.0553861335,
-0.0289140437,
0.037583027,
-0.0007929208,
0.0543899126,
-0.0227138661,
0.0111107165,
-0.0237457547,
0.0153203718,
0.0224988032,
0.0528355725,
-0.0059858207,
0.0345973782,
-0.0529749244,
0.0121468026,
-0.0056647663,
0.0092230411,
-0.0056635123,
0.0102728223,
0.0230181348,
0.0177791398,
-0.0204788242,
-0.0359385051,
0.0127011212,
0.0128084878,
-0.0467438102,
0.0007317018,
0.0425490253,
-0.0306699052,
0.0465165675,
0.0000023313,
-0.0393602625,
-0.0234553982,
0.0316716097,
-0.0309291501,
0.0948850214,
-0.0041448446,
-0.0315293558,
-0.0492313728,
0.0356753133,
-0.0242206771,
0.0073563755,
0.0155685516,
0.0370144397,
0.0848351792,
0.0731772482,
-0.0031731515,
0.0171587765,
0.0486728735,
-0.0100680022,
0.0298969597,
-0.0546393581,
-0.0025927152,
-0.0469104797,
0.009213144,
0.048280213,
0.0313738063,
-0.0186838992,
0.0290789418,
-0.0217513572,
-0.1004876047,
0.0079828883,
-0.028336497,
-0.0095877983,
-0.021932384,
0.0217860024,
-0.0495581329,
-0.0176650286,
0.0191948973,
0.0050347922,
0.0305100475,
0.0218814239,
0.0015362464,
0.0427371226,
-0.0217904504,
-0.0312353652,
0.0050702961,
-0.0153410584,
0.0435143374,
-0.0092967451,
-0.0101264901,
0.0448461212,
0.0341191031,
-0.0237798691,
-0.0261000004,
-0.0552009903,
-0.0053082732,
-0.0683210418,
-0.0043290518,
-0.0042811898,
0.0023773108,
0.007134398,
-0.0822531432,
-0.0200971458,
0.0470636226,
-0.0309307072,
-0.0320975482,
0.0383082181,
-0.0232218392,
0.0054422831,
-0.0143834641,
0.0143620875,
-0.0168189984,
0.0041954559,
0.0300634522,
0.0258953758,
0.0106734931,
-0.0058464664,
-0.0319347382,
0.0174950976,
-0.0087128952,
0.0357844271,
-0.0258088801,
0.0565039329,
-0.0189738497,
0.0448063985,
-0.0446301512,
-0.0032375264,
0.0060972194,
0.0129902307,
0.0512963943,
-0.0370538495,
-0.0204676166,
-0.0403243639,
-0.0056032105,
-0.0727825612,
-0.0250372812,
0.000611457,
-0.0777055547,
-0.0180637743,
-0.0188709293,
0.1239668876,
0.0254353844,
0.0041810237,
-0.0761176497,
-0.0970479324,
-0.0312878639,
-0.0210189596,
-0.016489869,
-0.0831398815,
-0.0331749432,
-0.0043376382,
-0.0036110994,
-0.0526975244,
-0.0053047333,
-0.0034977254,
-0.0189518947,
0.0477728508,
0.0302816387,
-0.0306804739,
-0.0091802021,
0.0531940982,
0.0168405622,
0.0421894491,
-0.0126746921,
0.0774980783,
0.0585296452,
-0.026521476,
0.0592546053,
0.0536525771,
-0.0155384568,
0.0349776037,
-0.0020437376,
-0.0130335269,
0.0682541952,
-0.020115165,
-0.0204872303,
0.0291012079,
-0.0044119572,
-0.0311271623,
0.0875299275,
0.042633038,
-0.060169939,
0.0499914326,
-0.0077443616,
-0.0015801943,
0.0056085573,
0.0127765443,
-0.0654710904,
0.0084566912,
-0.1039035544,
-0.0330556817,
-0.0253506079,
0.0347179547,
-0.0005973867,
0.0304592345,
0.0181528479,
-0.0098757995,
-0.0040417784,
0.0084784934,
-0.017097855,
0.0162755605,
-0.01529996,
0.0506561622,
0.0221539345,
-0.014083717,
-0.0433305465,
-0.0850972682,
-0.006145359,
0.0479584448,
0.0477992631,
0.013719256,
0.002213147,
-0.0023089768,
-0.0011414259,
0.0127441781,
0.0162242409,
0.0302649196,
0.0132718403,
-0.0030310713,
-0.0002171678,
-0.0387796871,
0.0281961709,
0.0525473393,
0.0016206822,
-0.0070106299,
0.0103803119,
-0.0116101019,
-0.0096308989,
0.0085467175,
0.0132679166,
-0.0446320102,
0.0255268328,
0.0215688106,
0.0095216362,
0.0062537561,
-0.0137780849,
0.0225213245,
0.0460872501,
0.0146444589,
0.0372819118,
-0.0109183257,
-0.0309240818,
-0.0314350687,
0.0109548559,
-0.0313351713,
-0.0096102254,
0.0637788549,
-0.0509563237,
-0.0016589807,
0.0652138665,
-0.0345929042,
0.0387718938,
-0.0004086557,
0.025291197,
-0.0024443248,
0.0018323426,
-0.0302366707,
0.0023263514,
0.0021855514,
0.0023417715,
-0.0027420407,
0.0503112487,
0.0161176249,
-0.0087097883,
-0.0564149506,
0.0120025342,
-0.0562636741,
0.0141077582,
0.0141819492,
0.0389646553,
-0.0019649507,
-0.0368303321,
-0.0496780239,
-0.0029225429,
-0.0200702641,
0.0246745721,
0.0522070751,
0.054227002,
-0.0371608548,
-0.0281681605,
-0.0279064253,
-0.0409177281,
0.0085993577,
0.0149396881,
-0.0048977504,
-0.0251323748,
-0.0471012853,
-0.0098521439,
0.0027896191,
-0.005225373,
0.0430177152,
-0.0343447104,
-0.0235669613,
-0.0102172941,
0.0003730124,
0.0057549002,
0.0045976555,
-0.0302569419,
-0.0447834991,
0.0400968939,
0.0116686663,
0.0044717747,
0.033696413,
0.038974762,
0.0455942787,
0.0746737868,
0.0077886456,
-0.0497993045,
-0.0292389784,
0.0456951857,
-0.0603518374,
-0.0166940372,
-0.0844088048,
0.0502965637,
0.0548902825,
0.0577009581,
0.0127127981,
-0.0264191292,
0.0331180021,
0.0108645102,
0.0059257955,
-0.006438937,
-0.0223603826,
-0.0416582935,
0.0086290957,
-0.0223978683,
-0.0625643358,
0.0743775889,
-0.0629715621,
0.0215194728,
-0.0265459623,
-0.0335286669,
0.0120769078,
0.0570057034,
-0.0298901014,
0.0141322082,
0.0763719305,
-0.0350363292,
-0.0219419803,
-0.0267728288,
0.0487011671,
-0.0054351124,
0.0268273242,
-0.0460338891,
-0.0177208986,
-0.008212843,
-0.0211173948,
-0.0396978743,
-0.0862608328,
-0.0122601613,
-0.042273391,
0.0340500437,
-0.0355468839,
0.0108971596,
-0.0149998469,
0.0362453982,
0.0167247262,
-0.0194215849,
-0.0093988981,
-0.0271956995,
0.0143917939,
0.0083773546,
-0.0870474577,
-0.0169488098,
-0.0035960872,
0.0553314127,
0.0820043311,
0.0338317938,
0.0327443182,
-0.0038274224,
0.0055017942,
0.0056056855,
0.0007937729,
-0.0208665188,
0.0536072664,
0.0348505713,
-0.0310816504,
-0.0214943625,
0.0465616547,
0.0260973964,
-0.0188747812,
0.0260856487,
-0.0060019861,
0.047041025,
0.0070053688,
0.0306672938,
-0.0766095519,
-0.0198157821,
0.0150355352,
0.0639227629,
-0.026021583,
0.0017646553,
-0.0421842188,
-0.0749492794,
0.0129286489,
0.0383013561,
-0.0261664912,
0.0347727351,
-0.0411192663,
-0.0280930176,
0.0430970825,
0.0123700742,
-0.0220010001,
-0.010864933,
0.0047877496,
0.000107022,
-0.0681637228,
0.0044280286,
0.0298666116,
-0.0344617255,
0.0506185293,
0.0728905648,
-0.0291090049,
-0.0281265043,
0.0291779786,
0.0499628484,
-0.0116261337,
-0.0292583257,
0.0232193507,
-0.0142349936,
0.0363558792,
-0.0012946926,
-0.0073544127,
0.0355782434,
-0.0014160441,
-0.042623315,
0.067009747,
0.0392269716,
-0.0160892513,
-0.0301425643,
-0.0171321537,
-0.0194357354,
0.0362884998,
0.0433200896,
0.0250565298,
-0.0372416116,
-0.0490132272,
-0.0931827426,
-0.0251235403,
-0.0562277585,
-0.0242638942,
-0.002335395,
0.0255327765,
-0.01827606,
-0.0373929255,
0.0182422865,
-0.0364192389,
0.0384240821,
0.0453843772,
-0.0047525456,
-0.0389832109,
0.0168726556,
-0.0095270462,
-0.0164672732,
-0.0142624117,
0.0427153036,
-0.0632546097,
0.0347582512,
-0.0258875359,
-0.0280599128,
-0.0074899225,
0.0168453176,
-0.0430149063,
-0.0762146935,
0.0093457643,
0.055710949,
0.0228428841,
-0.0080727106,
-0.0509597026,
-0.0598266721,
0.0666665584,
0.0712583065,
-0.0622675568,
0.0070658224,
0.0706286207,
-0.0129582491,
0.0161152892,
-0.0077061756,
-0.0346457064,
-0.0247135423,
0.0668673217,
-0.0189319067,
-0.0523952395,
-0.010160774,
0.0259887855,
0.0515093133,
0.0136453435,
-0.0075265355,
0.0083534559,
0.0399725996,
0.0091553144,
-0.0033459633,
-0.0386186093,
0.0232118126,
0.0132203475,
0.0193205699,
-0.0332924873,
0.0499134511,
0.0161335729,
-0.0077877613,
0.0044906498,
0.0130270422,
0.0228471439,
0.0199800525,
0.0599269569,
0.0795754865,
0.0100370022,
-0.0279830527,
0.0644700751,
-0.0042471699,
0.0308241136,
-0.0171284843,
0.0492701903,
-0.0213364344,
-0.0211405829,
-0.0056948643,
0.058349859,
-0.0723017231,
-0.0460256077,
0.0143868355,
0.0926857218,
-0.0021494359,
0.022895949,
0.0015686906,
-0.0121579608,
0.0186966602,
-0.0348997004,
-0.0330254994,
0.0078533283,
-0.0749456733,
0.0139752515,
-0.0101636257,
-0.0044334885,
0.0149359172,
0.0613737516,
-0.0000411348,
0.0403642021,
0.0331156626,
-0.032060612,
-0.0428767428,
-0.0094303144,
0.0566330329,
0.0324509963,
-0.0625764281,
-0.0622956194,
-0.0563570671,
-0.0631377921,
-0.0428693853,
0.0045070499,
0.0399837494,
0.0177974124,
-0.0358621962,
0.0578201711,
0.0128429299,
0.0366931669,
-0.063780427,
0.0493885763,
0.0120245442,
-0.0809161887,
0.0070221424,
-5.880194126e-33,
0.0167621784,
-0.0333219245,
-0.0582222752,
-0.022469094,
0.0360404104,
0.0061071804,
-0.045265656,
0.0268635955,
-0.0118680447,
-0.0384818874,
-0.0175000075,
-0.0186611041,
0.0069371262,
0.0052208877,
-0.0510432087,
-0.0179236606,
-0.0015308486,
0.0213629007,
-0.0461808518,
0.0466955528,
0.0442203805,
0.0065763518,
-0.0027570054,
-0.0230161678,
0.0504079424,
-0.0496326797,
-0.0392163247,
0.0081659164,
-0.0431703925,
0.0494734757,
-0.0009453917,
0.0136444215,
-0.0021933815,
-0.0235613734,
-0.0022044817,
0.0871578082,
0.0213454738,
-0.0177597795,
0.0305939671,
-0.0160946734,
0.002832283,
-0.0649178401,
0.0047141742,
-0.0111890966,
0.0003314,
-0.009683257,
-0.0190708134,
0.0116576264,
-0.0132635236,
-0.0128310826,
-0.0142439827,
-0.0056421906,
-0.0432786383,
-0.0123196393,
-0.0255117267,
0.0131078102,
0.0134894187,
-0.0231233444,
-0.0079013119,
0.0444701612,
0.032648433,
0.0009029748,
0.0288990252,
-0.011297469,
-0.0365178213,
0.044956293,
-0.035644006,
-0.0070406632,
-0.0032975809,
-0.0049329461,
-0.0091807023,
0.0364339463,
0.067744039,
0.0753938556,
0.0475129858,
-0.0223075822,
-0.0519666038,
0.0289345905,
0.0564047508,
0.01885904,
0.0363533758,
-0.0288012214,
-0.0404115729,
-0.0138515625,
-0.005933736,
-0.0246796682,
-0.0198094528,
-0.0645067841,
0.0179474931,
-0.0187296197,
-0.0319575071,
-0.0667103752,
0.0055633169,
-0.0543886796,
0.000489993,
0.0302778464,
-0.0045387968,
-0.0134798344,
-0.0179986563,
0.0384797603,
0.0466379337,
0.0108188745,
0.0096650906,
-0.0691529512,
0.0259076282,
-0.0039967927,
0.0210232139,
0.031542033,
-0.0711761937,
-0.0194765646,
-0.0350300148,
0.0478815772,
-0.0024905442,
-0.0000837531,
0.0081854397,
-0.0271538477,
0.0124506215,
-0.024777161,
0.0221525691,
-0.0394001082,
-0.0573700406,
0.0234252419,
-0.028839577,
0.0455660895,
0.0073273061,
0.0176624171,
0.0047335378,
0.0127958106,
0.0495108701,
-0.0311850328,
-0.0113721583,
-0.0203119516,
3.099e-7,
-0.0259266533,
-0.019354742,
0.0162171759,
0.0002657944,
0.0340788886,
0.0765368938,
-0.0181469116,
0.0975963473,
-0.0108841816,
-0.0367752351,
-0.0464992635,
-0.0401406437,
0.0603495091,
0.0382053591,
-0.0616448782,
0.0356268771,
-0.0729743019,
-0.0057235472,
-0.0840845481,
0.0171267092,
0.0520963036,
0.0652679205,
0.0063111563,
-0.0305427834,
0.0054559275,
-0.036145933,
-0.0058754524,
-0.011859729,
-0.0196593218,
-0.0025218269,
0.029120462,
0.019585602,
0.0293847732,
0.028148938,
-0.0274391435,
-0.0478200279,
-0.0575409159,
0.0606218465,
0.0537957214,
0.0033512868,
-0.0325815007,
-0.0432021581,
0.010702353,
-0.0666949451,
0.0717898682,
0.0123972418,
-0.0230630916,
-0.0234203134,
0.0148497457,
-0.074082613,
0.0065001566,
-0.0291807167,
-0.0068617603,
-0.0046146731,
0.011733192,
0.0174165871,
0.028167434,
-0.0445788875,
-0.0204710737,
0.0247593019,
-0.0120093916,
-0.0272763651,
-0.0145641407,
0.0422558337,
0.0532290116,
-0.0228775125,
0.0316031501,
3.137923395e-34,
-0.0151724946,
-0.0450207293,
0.02109975,
-0.0097163375,
0.0316578522,
0.0268994365,
0.0502202176,
0.0229445547,
0.0094329491,
-0.0135407848,
-0.0288155563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08263v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08263v2 | Fast Chain-of-Thought: A Glance of Future from Parallel Decoding Leads to Answers Faster | 2023-11-14T15:56:18 | 2024-06-04T03:10:34 | Hongxuan Zhang, Zhining Liu, Yao Zhao, Jiaqi Zheng, Chenyi Zhuang, Jinjie Gu, Guihai Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we propose FastCoT, a model-agnostic framework based on
parallel decoding without any further training of an auxiliary model or
modification to the LLM itself. FastCoT uses a size-varying context window
whose size changes with position to conduct parallel decoding and
auto-regressive decoding simultaneously, thus fully utilizing GPU computation
resources. In FastCoT, the parallel decoding part provides the LLM with a quick
glance of the future composed of approximate tokens, which could lead to faster
answers compared to regular autoregressive decoding used by causal
transformers. We also provide an implementation of parallel decoding within
LLM, which supports KV-cache generation and batch processing. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate that FastCoT saves inference time by nearly 20%
with only a negligible performance drop compared to the regular approach.
Additionally, we show that the context window size exhibits considerable
robustness for different tasks. | [
-0.0059481235,
0.0939826369,
0.0110095907,
0.038774848,
-0.0385811292,
0.0309958979,
0.0144012142,
-0.0074022976,
-0.0139032891,
-0.0049102814,
0.0488843173,
-0.0107215829,
-0.0051580663,
0.012763842,
-0.0091335773,
-0.0107016349,
0.0486650355,
-0.0198120493,
-0.0187751353,
-0.0339338146,
-0.0382255465,
-0.0061047263,
-0.0314301141,
0.0279633794,
-0.0163342804,
-0.0443296358,
-0.0592246279,
0.0014992899,
0.0450870171,
-0.0306230206,
-0.0230282769,
0.0182815399,
0.0120721962,
0.0445428565,
0.0000022017,
-0.0150281489,
-0.0099516623,
0.004113473,
-0.0183557086,
-0.0171224084,
-0.0346877649,
-0.0153026292,
-0.0046052989,
-0.0090119811,
-0.0381744616,
-0.0022250933,
0.0581659079,
0.0099438187,
0.0270477552,
0.034376476,
-0.001828778,
-0.0509383306,
0.0523312278,
-0.0078466777,
0.0197322294,
-0.0580885559,
-0.0027126344,
-0.0199849177,
-0.025358256,
-0.0203227364,
-0.0438429266,
0.0634038225,
0.0487360321,
0.0072956169,
0.0160269421,
0.0229939763,
0.0181206875,
-0.0079437215,
-0.0456946492,
0.0204015709,
-0.0047636814,
-0.0468020886,
-0.0118428571,
-0.0067420281,
-0.0255839881,
0.0066446378,
-0.0187083166,
0.0270821527,
-0.0364139043,
0.0266095251,
0.0557603166,
0.0490654856,
0.0285334326,
-0.0106343031,
-0.056150537,
0.0967064574,
0.0294890013,
0.0066499244,
-0.0199204069,
0.0375027582,
0.050957974,
-0.0492973253,
-0.0035120428,
0.026425736,
-0.0221407935,
-0.0068393033,
-0.0047848187,
-0.0270032324,
-0.0393855497,
-0.0188554302,
0.0314176232,
0.0841324851,
-0.0033500814,
0.0169400238,
-0.0352695398,
0.016501639,
-0.0655252337,
0.003470408,
-0.0456235707,
-0.002036501,
-0.0079641724,
-0.0202028006,
-0.0093853306,
0.0501678027,
-0.0452055298,
0.0010511354,
-0.0374303162,
0.0270490665,
-0.0013171,
-0.0269252583,
0.0196324438,
0.0474338084,
-0.0081857098,
-0.0230590813,
-0.0309216883,
0.0611469075,
-0.0554962941,
-0.0001518203,
-0.011870618,
-0.0416930132,
-0.0291484892,
-0.0152621325,
-0.0237656534,
-0.0266923048,
0.0087706614,
0.0948654711,
-0.0271588415,
0.0021169474,
-0.0552250259,
-0.0124698551,
0.0158408266,
-0.0632491484,
0.0709132552,
-0.0427328683,
0.001566628,
0.0427886546,
0.0419228226,
0.0308730118,
0.0135318283,
-0.0003187988,
0.0064362809,
0.0767893046,
-0.0195500534,
-0.0307191648,
0.0117644118,
-0.0048839245,
0.030799536,
0.107831113,
-0.0045636282,
0.0563462786,
-0.0291476194,
0.0192717612,
-0.0094296345,
0.0223843176,
0.0120851649,
-0.005315118,
-0.0382110886,
-0.0163144246,
0.0010793247,
0.0363107622,
0.0191220306,
0.0122428685,
-0.0287116505,
-0.0278252047,
0.0269027073,
0.0313944072,
0.0243245922,
0.033853773,
0.0374296457,
-0.0289046336,
-0.0059536519,
0.0152382208,
-0.0218753945,
0.1090596318,
-0.0195681751,
0.0240093023,
0.0034514351,
0.0379159041,
-0.0137013867,
-0.0272999592,
0.01783715,
0.0093359258,
-0.013923848,
-0.0118433442,
0.0612596311,
0.005129091,
-0.059600547,
0.0694019496,
-0.0035193171,
-0.0193137117,
-0.0603809729,
-0.0279753692,
0.0086890543,
0.0425586775,
0.0435263664,
-0.0164276734,
-0.0600761361,
0.0118173026,
-0.0299223773,
0.0365981981,
0.0027656856,
0.0086848652,
0.0184256546,
-0.0321185626,
-0.024333708,
0.0243947599,
0.0093854396,
0.0284152776,
0.0150215328,
0.0200593695,
-0.011793891,
0.0274491534,
0.0353500322,
-0.000809868,
-0.0025404361,
-0.0145675754,
0.0259801932,
0.0223412029,
0.0299658105,
0.0161789209,
0.0145202782,
0.0183453262,
0.0459053591,
-0.0572542362,
-0.0097045405,
0.0334984437,
-0.0889289975,
-0.0518970415,
0.0468466282,
-0.0421333238,
-0.0125395525,
0.0429470725,
-0.0461768396,
-0.0666494668,
0.0201770347,
-0.0268846676,
0.0581945404,
-0.0295720994,
-0.0212148633,
0.0129927462,
0.0179435052,
-0.0140634589,
0.0415591039,
-0.0490047,
-0.0110910088,
0.0246736668,
0.0333936773,
0.0177818723,
-0.0040119179,
0.0010743199,
-0.0016421051,
-0.0013469135,
-0.0278908592,
0.0324318483,
-0.0248895995,
-0.0264480244,
0.0123144863,
-0.0488256775,
-0.0174687989,
-0.0208237246,
0.0230093393,
-0.0098031843,
0.009071188,
0.0225340836,
-0.0024962106,
-0.0086576249,
0.0553858504,
0.0013419187,
-0.00922509,
-0.0067201615,
-0.0049096546,
-0.033300668,
0.0088131027,
-0.0258973967,
-0.016676316,
0.0656727701,
0.0019353864,
-0.0833785385,
-0.0174717754,
-0.0112908939,
0.0246751383,
0.0125439372,
-0.0181180928,
-0.0174945164,
0.0349381939,
-0.0490578003,
0.0220777113,
0.0303094946,
0.0084901359,
0.0103064943,
0.0224294886,
-0.0520610474,
-0.0202727076,
0.0332940333,
-0.0408449471,
-0.0426496454,
-0.0578609519,
-0.0085717151,
-0.0330423862,
0.0972793326,
-0.0016204224,
-0.006581184,
-0.065745756,
-0.0462491326,
0.036243394,
-0.091798231,
-0.0252748672,
0.0148503156,
-0.009964549,
0.0420783162,
0.0222742055,
-0.0458498783,
0.0691813529,
-0.0221421123,
0.0213595256,
0.0307220258,
-0.0023416523,
-0.0372939669,
0.060597185,
-0.0138770966,
0.0055453335,
-0.0378998257,
-0.0084292777,
0.0087344376,
0.065346919,
-0.0422084071,
0.0105047198,
0.0231383201,
-0.0471341424,
0.0185915716,
-0.0225227773,
-0.0347291306,
-0.0547591858,
0.0200961083,
-0.0485970713,
-0.0098750703,
-0.0041110297,
-0.0224756915,
-0.0358248577,
0.0051369937,
-0.0227551684,
0.0172904171,
-0.0387921408,
-0.0205373112,
-0.0164069869,
0.0162058435,
0.0346745476,
-0.0171112865,
0.0509824418,
-0.0268313233,
0.0540119447,
0.0634220466,
0.0295307431,
-0.0064393179,
-0.0833117738,
0.0355738513,
0.0434797332,
0.024410937,
0.0069639771,
0.0259865224,
-0.010763919,
-0.0576861948,
-0.0426296033,
0.0786306858,
0.0301339757,
-0.0709859431,
-0.0082177669,
-0.0233784709,
0.0071965861,
0.0213569105,
0.017883474,
-0.1118399352,
-0.0436775684,
0.0217702519,
-0.0173173659,
-0.0162104852,
-0.0471356809,
-0.0223947596,
-0.0554083325,
0.0373309031,
0.0125517705,
0.0111924401,
-0.0263984837,
-0.0202010516,
-0.0607200786,
0.0163846314,
-0.0354596116,
0.026834568,
0.0197196137,
0.012258091,
-0.0010360754,
0.0043297973,
0.0334871151,
0.015648311,
0.0206950735,
0.0137677938,
0.0408155881,
0.0099692354,
0.0017585251,
-0.0549853668,
-0.0105194552,
-0.0064254361,
0.0398273245,
-0.0501275696,
0.0018323639,
-0.0083829965,
-0.0113230255,
-0.0372874327,
0.0177595112,
-0.0250584539,
-0.0375191048,
-0.0053502996,
0.0867617428,
-0.0696282163,
-0.0199835394,
-0.0219365954,
-0.023133263,
-0.0154944798,
0.0366856381,
-0.0044121318,
-0.006735188,
-0.0605237819,
-0.054901775,
-0.0161949396,
-0.0591385216,
-0.014331637,
-0.0237374939,
0.073185645,
-0.0330925658,
-0.0149044441,
-0.0038236759,
-0.0259436574,
0.0361015052,
-0.006843748,
0.0063270777,
0.0340003297,
-0.0085499967,
-0.0999335721,
-0.0252570901,
-0.0184415467,
0.0199176725,
-0.0464810766,
0.022248162,
0.0477992706,
-0.0479100198,
-0.0036585166,
0.0867658257,
-0.1354271621,
-0.0513222851,
0.0197817273,
0.0597491711,
0.0279867016,
0.0547640249,
0.0276463479,
-0.0057157897,
0.0458542705,
0.0620317347,
-0.0409442671,
0.0393085107,
0.0136813298,
0.0121027129,
-0.0033443414,
0.0229119882,
-0.0111357067,
0.0092544015,
0.009829565,
0.0315987356,
-0.0229707602,
-0.0075018946,
0.0072859917,
0.0021301839,
0.0502227731,
-0.0249198396,
0.0049502775,
0.0134896645,
0.0539666191,
0.0037384559,
0.0290320534,
-0.043704696,
0.017388558,
0.0292492434,
-0.0317422375,
0.0074608484,
-0.0330761224,
0.0741772503,
-0.0537960865,
-0.0172500871,
-0.0195824765,
-0.0164870974,
0.0096995216,
0.033220645,
-0.0117551219,
-0.0015902574,
-0.0159903821,
0.0294275451,
0.0306511056,
-0.016075233,
0.0369919129,
0.0303499904,
0.0345337652,
-0.0484001711,
-0.0063334103,
-0.0977112502,
-0.0498661771,
-0.0149446027,
0.0150963068,
0.0592775717,
0.03871122,
0.0038943538,
-0.0566622317,
0.0140042463,
0.0115697989,
0.0360378176,
0.0101374779,
-0.0013719733,
0.031329643,
0.0087067802,
-0.008320081,
-0.0093880584,
0.0387843028,
-0.0039656088,
0.0407853685,
0.0180993378,
-0.0062221312,
-0.0489526652,
-0.0727662295,
-0.0564781576,
0.0261623673,
0.021947071,
-0.0167057794,
-0.0301433243,
-0.0408977829,
0.0310347993,
-0.0046016858,
-0.0094054304,
-0.0379340574,
0.040262714,
0.0148659246,
0.0042777155,
-0.0624500588,
0.0103864223,
0.0501026399,
0.0122504737,
-0.0026110783,
-0.0173085816,
-6.615405231e-33,
-0.0279419031,
-0.0344096087,
0.0607877001,
-0.0072023603,
-0.0101547251,
0.0131545682,
-0.03795816,
-0.0406827182,
0.0118484246,
0.021972701,
-0.0142492298,
0.017405441,
0.0283184461,
0.0177073237,
0.0425442196,
-0.0227282196,
0.0471434481,
-0.00944106,
0.030131679,
0.0124071203,
0.0461844578,
0.0687660575,
0.0587925389,
-0.0503717884,
-0.0261824839,
0.0094107343,
0.0054566376,
-0.0006641325,
-0.0461034663,
0.0025254553,
-0.0484116971,
0.0140422732,
0.0065655243,
-0.0820249394,
-0.028049523,
-0.0011210792,
-0.1060326621,
-0.0214183871,
0.0169221479,
0.0222332701,
-0.0493247248,
-0.0466585346,
-0.0389564373,
0.0633917227,
-0.0206628647,
-0.0523706377,
-0.0178024005,
-0.0229911506,
0.0075317714,
-0.0551453829,
-0.0294765681,
0.0180781204,
-0.021189753,
0.052363243,
0.0941378102,
0.0042754887,
-0.0165018495,
0.028131783,
-0.035860721,
0.0215294603,
0.0206630286,
0.0357772224,
0.1033985317,
0.0314530917,
0.0257823914,
0.0342852063,
0.0500809178,
-0.0309225898,
-0.0486570261,
0.0492785424,
-0.0021222178,
0.0473537482,
0.0021402966,
0.0083020739,
0.0585799627,
-0.0001959786,
-0.0629574656,
0.0012593402,
0.0036581201,
0.0553610548,
0.0442098081,
0.0125295324,
0.0060318662,
-0.0234968532,
-0.0070492607,
0.0044154045,
-0.0290917531,
0.0161880944,
0.015841566,
0.0382457301,
0.0121473707,
0.0067818682,
0.0543736443,
-0.0321173444,
0.0579869188,
0.0444040559,
0.0181018021,
0.0288372263,
0.0046814447,
0.013329939,
-0.03381522,
0.0009162147,
0.0084080808,
-0.0177653488,
0.0368905403,
-0.0008859375,
-0.0182508137,
0.0328152701,
-0.061146602,
-0.0194249637,
-0.0698428303,
0.0074831252,
0.0585710667,
-0.0335240625,
0.0381653942,
-0.0083811935,
-0.0173816308,
0.0463854857,
-0.0550428145,
0.0207872782,
0.0110066906,
0.0042501139,
0.0202032663,
0.0348673277,
-0.0299873929,
-0.0244939048,
-0.0314290114,
0.0100761596,
0.050184086,
-0.0989474282,
-0.042206157,
0.0699182302,
2.903e-7,
0.0276676826,
0.0315898061,
0.0764236748,
0.0285274889,
0.0116525777,
0.0120282788,
0.0227581114,
0.0154453861,
0.0316934474,
-0.0128617203,
0.0282100383,
0.0338352136,
0.057354793,
0.0299951583,
-0.0714757442,
-0.0125085004,
-0.0475799553,
0.0233153068,
-0.0100284778,
-0.0155023746,
0.0324736536,
0.0727302358,
0.0043239077,
-0.0087688258,
0.0693922713,
0.0391143039,
0.0343379788,
-0.007129286,
0.0174350925,
-0.0028162743,
-0.0402809829,
-0.0303561594,
-0.0250351466,
0.0313842148,
0.0069107171,
-0.0134010576,
-0.049741488,
0.0026692336,
-0.0052002678,
-0.0802518129,
0.0198754426,
-0.01902752,
0.0008669289,
-0.0117783425,
0.0695614368,
-0.0046219793,
-0.016851766,
-0.0102524795,
-0.0249852668,
0.0054296628,
-0.0115379272,
0.0169002451,
0.0628183708,
0.0055322386,
-0.0161682647,
0.0001982515,
-0.0092069218,
-0.0795225203,
-0.0448513031,
-0.0050276583,
-0.0679559186,
-0.051712472,
-0.0823835507,
0.0109498762,
0.0426129401,
-0.051313024,
-0.0358000733,
2.988653061e-34,
0.0341662243,
-0.0016985998,
-0.0088369595,
0.0706740171,
0.010792857,
-0.0466147177,
-0.0453764983,
0.0398985669,
0.011092986,
-0.0953681767,
-0.0565055236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14708v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14708v1 | Large Language Model-Driven Classroom Flipping: Empowering Student-Centric Peer Questioning with Flipped Interaction | 2023-11-14T15:48:19 | 2023-11-14T15:48:19 | Chee Wei Tan | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | Reciprocal questioning is essential for effective teaching and learning,
fostering active engagement and deeper understanding through collaborative
interactions, especially in large classrooms. Can large language model (LLM),
such as OpenAI's GPT (Generative Pre-trained Transformer) series, assist in
this? This paper investigates a pedagogical approach of classroom flipping
based on flipped interaction in LLMs. Flipped interaction involves using
language models to prioritize generating questions instead of answers to
prompts. We demonstrate how traditional classroom flipping techniques,
including Peer Instruction and Just-in-Time Teaching (JiTT), can be enhanced
through flipped interaction techniques, creating student-centric questions for
hybrid teaching. In particular, we propose a workflow to integrate prompt
engineering with clicker and JiTT quizzes by a poll-prompt-quiz routine and a
quiz-prompt-discuss routine to empower students to self-regulate their learning
capacity and enable teachers to swiftly personalize training pathways. We
develop an LLM-driven chatbot software that digitizes various elements of
classroom flipping and facilitates the assessment of students using these
routines to deliver peer-generated questions. We have applied our LLM-driven
chatbot software for teaching both undergraduate and graduate students from
2020 to 2022, effectively useful for bridging the gap between teachers and
students in remote teaching during the COVID-19 pandemic years. In particular,
LLM-driven classroom flipping can be particularly beneficial in large class
settings to optimize teaching pace and enable engaging classroom experiences. | [
0.0430389754,
-0.0445938073,
-0.0628926456,
0.0313592739,
-0.0600629598,
0.0036702473,
0.0485945158,
-0.0419707708,
0.0282666218,
-0.0224406663,
-0.0166638885,
-0.0080940388,
-0.0473538861,
0.0513686091,
0.0045838295,
-0.0924127102,
0.0283047315,
-0.0344450995,
-0.00447133,
0.0165527593,
-0.0104232626,
-0.0115279444,
-0.0760522261,
0.0409644544,
0.0111278668,
-0.0264660288,
-0.0598142967,
-0.0110236295,
0.0284250826,
0.0034067538,
0.019951541,
0.0418047234,
0.0029733251,
0.0306637846,
0.0000021726,
-0.0436793193,
-0.0306438562,
-0.0167282261,
-0.0137005122,
-0.0080429064,
0.0571612231,
0.072517857,
-0.0067993379,
0.028455453,
-0.0784707665,
0.0015522139,
0.0423040055,
0.0058206338,
0.063719213,
0.0329341814,
0.0251576025,
-0.0018878262,
0.0178712253,
0.0127094258,
0.0368873961,
-0.0116581591,
-0.0027346509,
0.0336308181,
0.0535383672,
0.0313884839,
-0.0462056398,
0.0122437179,
0.0616996959,
-0.0570092648,
0.0250518154,
0.0224448834,
-0.0377670228,
-0.0306585394,
-0.0383930244,
0.0557458475,
0.0128227137,
0.0162361283,
-0.010014534,
-0.006337394,
0.0554006137,
0.0554907098,
-0.0674872175,
0.038520664,
0.0095824618,
0.0076500429,
-0.0387098417,
-0.0050380072,
-0.0316281654,
0.0133460583,
0.003379052,
0.0313096866,
-0.0109835798,
-0.0044819321,
-0.0617213324,
0.0271219835,
0.0384560376,
0.0030731682,
0.0183486622,
0.0964498892,
-0.0331515484,
0.0219724253,
0.0097660972,
-0.034357395,
0.0073294649,
0.0243076142,
-0.0386921018,
0.0524314307,
-0.0271981023,
0.0054255193,
0.0390798002,
0.0357488766,
0.0194228943,
0.0362358205,
-0.0411405191,
0.0242616478,
-0.0462533832,
-0.007452121,
-0.0555019267,
-0.0023223816,
-0.0212369785,
-0.0023969226,
-0.0147137167,
0.0371753834,
-0.0020668374,
0.0225451924,
0.0077145607,
-0.0053682444,
-0.0138792358,
0.0299377665,
-0.0132441241,
0.1020448208,
-0.0072531868,
-0.0191595107,
0.0276323855,
-0.062477652,
0.0114294365,
0.0162445866,
-0.0141991908,
0.0004960177,
-0.0373708494,
0.0177163538,
-0.0471984409,
-0.002844196,
0.0061984467,
-0.0339683257,
0.0029399735,
-0.0210199784,
0.0282475147,
-0.056915503,
0.0002875994,
0.0087234126,
-0.0051413868,
0.0012439445,
0.0277578402,
0.0140988342,
0.0205779597,
0.0468825921,
0.0149544822,
0.0117470492,
0.0799488351,
0.0417703129,
0.0011172279,
0.0376703441,
0.0453228429,
-0.0076404307,
0.0388669521,
-0.0467217565,
0.0366725065,
0.0389878228,
0.0155618619,
0.0089273602,
0.0190721247,
-0.0223303996,
0.0964229032,
0.0365592949,
-0.0764214545,
0.0270415898,
-0.0075711985,
0.0407622568,
0.0374947898,
0.0281297583,
-0.0851867273,
0.0055532684,
0.0096315211,
0.0433455296,
-0.0067995307,
0.029571373,
-0.0195527468,
0.0572357886,
0.0249384139,
-0.0309807919,
0.0329865701,
0.0260629188,
-0.011697012,
-0.0661882535,
0.0046164165,
-0.0056480546,
0.0203660447,
0.0495130681,
0.0093463082,
0.0091264537,
-0.0088054761,
0.0339317769,
0.0005205453,
-0.0944502875,
0.0168924164,
-0.098897472,
0.0276353713,
0.0562001616,
0.0551675931,
-0.015404474,
-0.0605489351,
0.0075672502,
-0.0056044101,
0.0562870391,
0.0756603777,
-0.0073711746,
-0.0426574051,
-0.0198975522,
-0.0120776724,
0.0043776794,
-0.0071232175,
-0.00929718,
0.0039652362,
0.0114456266,
-0.0121937022,
-0.0267001037,
-0.0231091063,
0.0201261304,
-0.0700291097,
-0.0370567814,
-0.0210030433,
0.0387504846,
-0.0092231417,
0.004454942,
0.0093708485,
-0.0102351382,
0.0455134436,
0.008343271,
0.0156192165,
-0.0006735455,
-0.0214298442,
-0.0309846122,
0.0315206908,
-0.0240409616,
-0.0208395757,
0.0372708216,
-0.0259727128,
-0.0117174853,
0.0456874445,
0.0443144888,
0.0392090417,
-0.0142504126,
0.004320811,
-0.0239710938,
-0.0113157267,
-0.0421233773,
-0.0177312475,
0.0266864635,
0.0228082128,
0.0054054293,
0.0145790875,
0.0142054772,
-0.0341222063,
-0.0076214005,
0.0401122645,
-0.0230098478,
-0.0233798902,
-0.0338457003,
0.0269014947,
-0.0850331709,
-0.0432438962,
-0.0473086052,
-0.0231729429,
0.0049201348,
0.0049510556,
0.0351593681,
0.0054844813,
-0.0226209387,
-0.0249642208,
-0.0696388483,
0.0347679444,
0.0092580253,
-0.0150322393,
0.0130305141,
0.0213719495,
0.0111297164,
-0.0100176586,
0.0099326782,
-0.0186331999,
-0.0096125631,
0.0643406585,
0.029895898,
-0.0362479836,
0.0171650946,
-0.0157028884,
-0.0184673388,
0.0012279401,
-0.0397140905,
0.0496193953,
-0.0293324459,
0.0597625077,
0.0587696806,
0.0219268464,
0.0413560458,
0.0398254991,
-0.0354828313,
-0.0440185852,
0.0249069072,
-0.0076901452,
-0.0455791056,
0.0142840194,
-0.0553970039,
-0.0406746715,
0.0074502286,
0.016832808,
-0.0286189355,
-0.0284542646,
0.0189456474,
-0.0287651941,
0.0184299592,
-0.0272742193,
-0.0098703178,
-0.0233323332,
0.0005920795,
0.0101421345,
-0.0006085913,
0.0572020821,
0.0125960512,
-0.0053982171,
-0.0692326948,
0.0146739297,
-0.0301500447,
0.0665301234,
-0.0267709866,
0.0072778561,
-0.002863552,
-0.0146191455,
-0.0590710305,
0.0071190796,
0.0176669005,
-0.0684235021,
-0.0490608849,
-0.0594071746,
-0.0506011955,
-0.0267469622,
0.0045737335,
-0.0517386049,
0.0164375007,
-0.0155886719,
-0.0053644748,
0.0108263036,
-0.0175678618,
0.0075113378,
-0.0042185839,
0.0103491032,
0.0237945039,
-0.0475074016,
-0.0014018021,
0.0014974617,
0.023199426,
0.0006858899,
0.0025073453,
-0.0304202717,
0.0066267746,
0.0760602877,
0.0639218315,
0.0707436129,
-0.0120632742,
0.033237461,
-0.0231253691,
0.0401102938,
-0.0107066585,
0.0102950828,
0.0289017316,
0.0518542044,
-0.0543902591,
-0.0561501533,
0.0868975297,
0.026660217,
-0.0629623011,
-0.0250050314,
-0.0663779601,
0.0114585133,
0.005024835,
0.0525019169,
-0.0984153301,
0.0133401025,
-0.0482604131,
0.0288071055,
-0.0168825984,
-0.0193332061,
0.01376478,
-0.0846897438,
0.0539252721,
-0.0095814392,
-0.0348888636,
0.0565488935,
-0.0187962633,
-0.0007352608,
0.0262289047,
0.0326451957,
0.0012574809,
0.0205960851,
0.0368788689,
0.0180904847,
0.027064085,
0.0034584531,
0.0150509076,
0.0230214391,
0.0174561571,
0.0346748121,
0.0152210388,
-0.0034922173,
-0.0858949274,
0.016808752,
0.0270351022,
-0.0034392597,
0.0018170242,
0.0132998237,
-0.0179793518,
0.0034454735,
-0.0124442661,
0.0460288636,
-0.0116769439,
-0.021933049,
0.0653176606,
0.0844208822,
-0.0187580436,
0.0171021912,
-0.0362315662,
0.039144557,
0.0768771321,
0.0499140471,
0.0357208624,
-0.0560308322,
0.0346098356,
-0.0085524535,
0.0164809339,
-0.0157581102,
-0.0634543598,
-0.003411951,
0.0126220332,
0.0001343149,
-0.0204879455,
-0.0304299798,
0.0743891597,
0.0167795792,
-0.0001170285,
0.0066060238,
0.0281056985,
0.0570526533,
-0.0195445083,
-0.0232723542,
-0.0174137596,
0.0117755719,
-0.0770060495,
-0.0550042652,
-0.0113388086,
-0.058262825,
0.0128262108,
-0.0160781872,
-0.080107525,
-0.0477307923,
0.0174269397,
0.0297744777,
0.0194830038,
-0.0074941213,
0.027190486,
0.0357409865,
-0.0332608521,
0.0386261754,
-0.0148545401,
-0.0112072267,
-0.019625159,
0.0345142186,
0.0061032143,
-0.0145278992,
-0.0108727533,
-0.0314976722,
0.0151497545,
0.0020113862,
-0.0756135583,
-0.0593253337,
0.0339161679,
0.0348680392,
0.0586629026,
-0.0029698082,
-0.0130034257,
-0.0149242664,
0.0328005292,
-0.0284321979,
-0.0257179923,
-0.0230007153,
-0.0232047997,
0.0041859797,
-0.0217605326,
0.0251273904,
0.0325002819,
-0.0234928913,
0.0322228111,
-0.0365580656,
0.0438576005,
-0.0192404762,
0.0091252783,
-0.0053381026,
0.0143923564,
-0.0137668308,
-0.0085947635,
0.0517022163,
0.0509089865,
0.0340218805,
0.122552596,
0.004285166,
0.0008788275,
0.0392938443,
0.0190009642,
-0.052140601,
-0.06072101,
0.0162306707,
0.0561905578,
-0.0328809507,
0.050369896,
-0.0413577817,
-0.0182012934,
0.0226024296,
0.0244910419,
0.0254687909,
-0.0211357046,
-0.0758107975,
0.0084176874,
-0.0130184209,
0.0426758491,
-0.0028780517,
0.0312417112,
-0.0668579489,
0.0227189399,
0.0487804413,
0.024452839,
-0.022523826,
0.0096635837,
0.0541449524,
0.0035626432,
0.0255900361,
0.0282033384,
-0.0245407838,
-0.0266023334,
-0.0563600361,
0.0465372168,
-0.0096591422,
-0.0632452816,
0.0263002086,
0.0432291217,
-0.0343308747,
-0.0218582842,
-0.0440237075,
0.0924583748,
-0.0046728253,
-0.0273354873,
-0.0145267146,
-6.224285199e-33,
-0.0410638936,
-0.0581860356,
0.0473813824,
0.0406011753,
-0.0218018759,
-0.0401354246,
-0.0126397461,
0.0411215164,
-0.0453161821,
-0.0224355087,
-0.0040774853,
0.03240069,
0.001484025,
0.0380987301,
0.0194151979,
-0.0139890108,
0.0220662914,
-0.0238046367,
-0.0013536103,
0.0455506518,
0.0065514911,
-0.0028917543,
0.0374219157,
-0.0300552119,
0.0282224007,
-0.0492336564,
0.0070192134,
0.0074239834,
-0.083821021,
-0.023178244,
-0.0163421854,
0.0370115563,
-0.0007263343,
-0.0419593193,
0.0236801077,
0.05228585,
-0.0226288196,
-0.0762335286,
-0.0208668709,
0.0399065129,
-0.0291017406,
-0.0456121452,
-0.0011799185,
-0.0161142945,
-0.02252925,
0.001106267,
0.0385325924,
-0.0007315555,
0.0189945288,
0.0362780243,
-0.0593306571,
-0.0191681571,
-0.0396506079,
-0.0828730613,
-0.0581497513,
0.0587631762,
-0.0046575414,
-0.0413627438,
-0.0516273901,
0.0845010653,
0.0509144142,
0.0076151709,
0.0450339839,
0.0219845735,
-0.0225553755,
0.0093248244,
0.0035374914,
0.0344407745,
-0.0230892003,
-0.0387196168,
0.0251862053,
0.0162675548,
0.0593960881,
0.0739752948,
0.0088871121,
-0.0166340657,
-0.0316372626,
0.067568019,
0.104574047,
-0.0203245338,
-0.024377346,
-0.0085253231,
-0.0148007888,
-0.009830106,
-0.027958734,
-0.0556609444,
0.0068052537,
-0.0358682945,
0.0071358993,
-0.0251048021,
-0.0306359511,
-0.0570137054,
0.0164214633,
-0.028999567,
-0.0155594926,
-0.0298527274,
-0.0153140649,
0.0206252541,
-0.0341008119,
0.0074726469,
-0.0226547569,
-0.0010691548,
0.0066144126,
0.0040982449,
0.0012080576,
0.0383431613,
0.0103011411,
0.0220252294,
-0.0001471092,
-0.024106605,
-0.0425304472,
0.0198034216,
0.0350293592,
-0.0225213878,
-0.0093906904,
0.0141286897,
-0.0197678283,
0.0336061418,
0.0109450286,
-0.0360291973,
-0.0406437144,
-0.0413363874,
-0.0422034971,
-0.0354048796,
-0.0274913721,
-0.0025457765,
-0.0588399395,
0.0399730057,
-0.0131180882,
-0.0673840865,
-0.0072818086,
0.0108782137,
2.87e-7,
0.0188884325,
0.0060657412,
0.0084307231,
-0.011592377,
0.0009514972,
0.0023511599,
-0.003756576,
0.001546246,
0.0955068693,
0.0032733649,
0.0104122367,
0.0179049242,
0.0242847819,
0.0232606195,
-0.0937997326,
-0.0727384314,
-0.0245069396,
0.008352994,
-0.0204645749,
0.0572400279,
0.1079147011,
-0.0033438432,
0.0185938459,
0.0156350154,
-0.0024667259,
0.029190328,
-0.0003266972,
-0.0172410253,
0.0168442503,
0.0210571028,
-0.0677010193,
-0.0305619128,
0.0148980096,
0.0345519558,
0.0182470605,
-0.022871159,
-0.0246519167,
0.0192025006,
0.0196803231,
-0.0457774773,
0.0142647093,
0.02530865,
-0.0096399775,
-0.0974804312,
0.0557716228,
-0.0649782792,
-0.0022657081,
0.0635485053,
-0.0361935757,
-0.0268377643,
-0.0012078319,
-0.0301693827,
-0.0199060701,
0.0097561153,
-0.0180625468,
0.0002731466,
0.0104774041,
0.0183082465,
0.0106885042,
-0.0661254749,
-0.0567935705,
-0.0615453199,
-0.0447946973,
-0.0736490712,
-0.0315115117,
0.0295032021,
-0.0199818481,
2.169188398e-34,
-0.0231874529,
-0.0042734575,
0.0309508443,
0.021396568,
-0.0022102904,
0.0203791521,
0.0386391766,
0.0378487334,
0.0302447509,
-0.0263039153,
-0.0513760671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08252v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08252v2 | REST: Retrieval-Based Speculative Decoding | 2023-11-14T15:43:47 | 2024-04-04T11:37:01 | Zhenyu He, Zexuan Zhong, Tianle Cai, Jason D. Lee, Di He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | We introduce Retrieval-Based Speculative Decoding (REST), a novel algorithm
designed to speed up language model generation. The key insight driving the
development of REST is the observation that the process of text generation
often includes certain common phases and patterns. Unlike previous methods that
rely on a draft language model for speculative decoding, REST harnesses the
power of retrieval to generate draft tokens. This method draws from the
reservoir of existing knowledge, retrieving and employing relevant tokens based
on the current context. Its plug-and-play nature allows for seamless
integration and acceleration of any language models, all without necessitating
additional training. When benchmarked on 7B and 13B language models in a
single-batch setting, REST achieves a significant speedup of 1.62X to 2.36X on
code or text generation. The code of REST is available at
https://github.com/FasterDecoding/REST. | [
0.0450978056,
0.0706654713,
-0.0228321217,
0.0081750443,
-0.0476960614,
-0.0327026732,
-0.0593345724,
0.029507881,
-0.0526893139,
-0.0222951695,
0.0195430629,
-0.0874815583,
-0.0041581318,
0.067313686,
0.0070102219,
-0.0160972159,
0.0224348437,
-0.0183994975,
0.0351691805,
0.0229267664,
-0.0107629141,
0.0401818231,
0.0211461429,
0.0837383792,
-0.0213419963,
-0.0074160178,
-0.0306268614,
0.0313791297,
-0.0290558338,
-0.0300427377,
0.0295915809,
0.0443800539,
0.0161795877,
0.0160736479,
0.0000021709,
-0.0116738221,
-0.061853867,
0.003334003,
0.008195946,
0.0008489392,
0.0550705269,
-0.0175341517,
-0.043245025,
0.0526301451,
-0.0356014371,
-0.0194323678,
0.0613554828,
-0.0286484584,
0.0174477901,
0.0764121786,
-0.0074897986,
-0.0318694785,
0.0142409662,
0.018387774,
-0.012736382,
-0.0149363279,
-0.0052405084,
-0.0178771541,
0.0109805679,
0.0163981263,
0.0123845972,
0.0151614416,
0.0150653003,
0.0072102356,
-0.0239623412,
0.0240300689,
-0.0064698039,
-0.042947758,
-0.0289466213,
0.0200357288,
-0.0191135034,
-0.0795109197,
0.0044431617,
0.027516393,
-0.0347111896,
-0.0517052524,
-0.024157498,
0.0494915694,
-0.023853112,
0.0171701536,
0.0560530424,
0.0276821852,
0.0224723984,
-0.0016557756,
-0.0345743224,
0.0553288013,
0.0400648415,
-0.0056632743,
-0.0709808469,
-0.0118839946,
0.0160495304,
-0.0445605554,
0.0314928256,
0.0223709531,
-0.0186036564,
0.0139107024,
-0.0587723702,
-0.0737301409,
0.015635699,
0.0139360772,
0.0243318137,
0.0862011984,
-0.0132144941,
-0.0276747942,
-0.0426826216,
-0.0071432795,
0.0041359169,
-0.0412613824,
-0.0320713446,
0.0113677783,
-0.0319360681,
-0.0203931239,
-0.0953045264,
0.0390366912,
-0.0511694811,
-0.0334393419,
-0.0027037058,
0.0404248461,
0.036816448,
-0.005090035,
0.0173514243,
0.0040837619,
-0.0553517565,
-0.0028872348,
0.0454179011,
-0.0013156681,
0.0032196981,
-0.0346654058,
0.0365745276,
-0.0856128782,
-0.0016418899,
-0.0024916444,
0.0130629344,
-0.0166512523,
-0.0368596353,
0.0438545384,
-0.0156191075,
-0.0063292827,
-0.0414671935,
-0.0748964921,
0.0288445484,
-0.0470832996,
-0.0392363407,
-0.0696411431,
0.0028701557,
0.0125368712,
-0.0212542955,
-0.0355235226,
0.0295659546,
0.0278101247,
-0.0052859569,
0.0156702325,
-0.0863436386,
0.0096677449,
0.0173158608,
0.0182686914,
-0.0010676923,
0.0856883675,
0.0203217398,
0.0622998103,
0.0100756809,
-0.0029430583,
0.019362269,
0.0706750974,
0.0097426409,
-0.0139098419,
-0.0133169172,
-0.018745698,
0.0179973152,
-0.0058338721,
0.016786119,
0.0526661091,
-0.0495689288,
0.0421985984,
0.0231954586,
0.0273094773,
0.0035592252,
0.0433843918,
0.0789530948,
0.0592339896,
-0.0065880581,
-0.0261806548,
0.0036168338,
0.0070197298,
-0.0295073446,
0.0288226958,
0.0219668895,
0.0489518307,
0.0042470708,
-0.0139142321,
-0.0106316162,
-0.0205762871,
0.0018302003,
-0.0302571151,
0.0617910475,
0.0182150565,
-0.1059722677,
0.0497711524,
0.0106444536,
-0.0820515528,
-0.0011693459,
-0.0343876295,
0.0059858509,
0.0737437084,
0.0819847509,
0.0210510567,
0.0028990956,
0.023235254,
-0.0447430126,
0.0231387634,
0.037184082,
-0.0002715297,
0.0080246245,
-0.0744891092,
-0.0052601439,
0.0247346964,
0.0160375312,
0.0431434922,
0.039390862,
-0.004655866,
0.0393414535,
-0.0222940166,
-0.0244093034,
0.0162522681,
-0.0032551894,
0.0081463605,
-0.0051723188,
-0.0060443403,
-0.0026910387,
0.0095345033,
-0.0244415961,
0.0441314615,
0.0347801745,
-0.0311138127,
0.0230364334,
0.0317771286,
-0.0311589073,
-0.01613749,
0.0240113512,
0.039574489,
0.0223071259,
0.021480009,
0.02329126,
-0.0620030351,
0.055994533,
-0.0204274561,
0.0727957115,
-0.0405101888,
0.0563201644,
-0.011126698,
0.0099266777,
-0.0181631427,
0.0364872403,
-0.000865188,
-0.0026456721,
0.0021443185,
0.0001190466,
0.0223569572,
-0.0187906846,
-0.0008255205,
0.0018570804,
-0.0585580952,
0.0159145463,
0.027077755,
0.0203539059,
-0.000050419,
-0.0344001055,
-0.0817103609,
0.0062415903,
-0.0468399674,
0.0038221152,
0.027575152,
0.0505867861,
-0.0190202966,
-0.0070702219,
-0.0030619684,
0.0044363537,
0.0133573329,
0.0059460476,
-0.0196832698,
0.0088988924,
-0.0691519007,
-0.0071574887,
0.0012912318,
-0.0006159374,
0.0522538386,
-0.013457641,
-0.0232994165,
-0.0829525515,
0.0196141619,
0.00277561,
-0.0002570621,
0.02068628,
-0.0631728247,
0.0236558449,
-0.0679434687,
0.0147749763,
-0.0386360884,
0.0169123542,
0.008843245,
0.0302342363,
-0.0117370626,
-0.0417122804,
-0.0002255668,
-0.0152151547,
-0.0221859291,
-0.0129397539,
-0.0758362934,
0.0278984904,
0.0685140043,
0.0328723416,
-0.0026644273,
-0.0869485289,
-0.0096341185,
-0.0006098319,
-0.0280348696,
-0.019012833,
-0.0306274667,
-0.0232702624,
0.0673628077,
-0.0401893184,
-0.0645115003,
0.0519531704,
-0.0547801331,
0.0029757002,
-0.0581373759,
0.0028105513,
-0.0045219795,
0.0523237549,
-0.0109864855,
0.059255451,
0.0068050073,
-0.0650283098,
0.003386382,
0.062453974,
-0.0142262448,
-0.0468705222,
-0.0040017455,
-0.0437529869,
0.034981966,
-0.0097324308,
-0.020233918,
-0.0489127673,
-0.004525369,
-0.0130361505,
-0.0047749844,
0.0731892213,
-0.0293511562,
0.01633255,
0.0369768292,
-0.0371102504,
0.0399227031,
-0.0083148424,
-0.0094942255,
-0.0031620283,
0.0011400026,
0.024306925,
-0.0556776412,
-0.0150076877,
-0.0235612839,
0.0076008826,
0.0487420596,
0.0507833101,
0.0005653301,
-0.0625285134,
0.0066151791,
0.0614453256,
-0.0024724177,
-0.0091065597,
0.085575223,
0.0599686243,
-0.0465065055,
-0.0484831929,
0.0824562311,
0.0355789177,
-0.0451251939,
0.0136989132,
-0.01164384,
0.0923032537,
0.0097404206,
0.0308222659,
-0.0882742926,
-0.016697783,
0.0386818126,
0.0443576425,
-0.0043599908,
0.002486754,
-0.0364109688,
-0.0917899534,
0.0553759225,
0.023457272,
-0.0524838381,
-0.0035463884,
-0.0030681416,
-0.0468471497,
0.0636900663,
-0.019715162,
0.0787336752,
0.0301496498,
0.0244747475,
0.0235346537,
-0.0176716968,
-0.0230676439,
-0.0340413526,
-0.0155924801,
0.0214691274,
0.075543344,
-0.005911164,
0.0382378995,
0.0263141952,
-0.0186501835,
-0.0046320055,
0.0132651851,
-0.0248547979,
0.0025659006,
0.0033621949,
-0.0132058319,
0.0268035792,
0.0055670128,
-0.0685690716,
-0.0434005857,
-0.0173506085,
0.0402866378,
-0.0150032463,
0.0040335627,
-0.0330721848,
-0.0128535107,
0.0552936271,
0.034713123,
0.0339539312,
-0.0196021255,
-0.046600122,
-0.0627265871,
0.0314634256,
-0.1050837785,
0.0159575529,
-0.0439679734,
0.0278860666,
-0.0085911416,
-0.073366344,
0.0133464113,
0.0053346376,
0.053979408,
0.0126292957,
0.0405409411,
0.0121906716,
-0.0343842357,
-0.1117823273,
-0.0108271781,
-0.0050394656,
0.0160159953,
-0.0786351115,
-0.0428240933,
0.0022828432,
-0.0503336601,
0.0115824398,
0.0099008,
-0.0646560118,
-0.0631675869,
0.0099864835,
0.0526278429,
0.0236854684,
0.0162860416,
-0.0363408625,
-0.0400855169,
0.0208489764,
0.0187814608,
-0.0871285349,
-0.0094673792,
-0.0022864419,
-0.0079216231,
-0.0085617797,
0.0201130603,
-0.0305619091,
-0.0249569602,
-0.0304586049,
0.0598190613,
0.0175910518,
-0.0105995694,
0.0529171862,
0.0187237617,
-0.0148561373,
-0.0435034595,
-0.0152673647,
0.0100327749,
0.001174485,
-0.0217370056,
-0.0163759403,
-0.0444531813,
0.051394973,
0.0030706802,
-0.0423970334,
0.0376768745,
-0.0090018474,
-0.0008114362,
0.0502618887,
0.0476465188,
0.0066268416,
-0.0243453179,
0.0599837229,
0.0800237358,
-0.0214182567,
-0.0207514185,
0.0003509365,
-0.0218896419,
0.0396110676,
-0.0551483929,
0.0219822004,
0.0066285292,
-0.0066745207,
-0.0160471201,
0.0192495678,
-0.0289324671,
-0.0198675543,
-0.0497062579,
-0.0284055918,
0.0649995357,
0.014273108,
0.0525900982,
-0.0493927263,
0.0110871671,
-0.01990778,
0.0465008207,
-0.01625471,
-0.0426995791,
0.0042797676,
0.0006043965,
-0.0285812151,
-0.0084519479,
0.0871743709,
0.0081021758,
0.0262052026,
0.0054844772,
-0.0112941843,
-0.0261599347,
0.003194429,
0.0177813917,
0.046291817,
-0.0426013246,
-0.0089983661,
-0.0208450537,
-0.0386530608,
0.0292010289,
0.0141187264,
0.0153737552,
0.0033346207,
0.0267495308,
0.0874450728,
-0.0036502238,
-0.0084493328,
-0.0480628163,
0.006078437,
0.005734513,
-0.0258234665,
-0.0272410102,
-6.474309174e-33,
-0.0015026635,
-0.0212899465,
0.0128695834,
-0.0753236338,
-0.006603804,
-0.0136272628,
-0.0645091608,
-0.0068117208,
0.0443867929,
-0.0189629197,
-0.0105877211,
-0.0095473304,
0.0254090391,
0.0291961208,
0.0037265499,
0.0502866581,
0.0568362288,
0.000329387,
-0.0363043025,
0.02030419,
0.0547376797,
0.057900887,
0.023726318,
-0.0252585951,
-0.0260063149,
-0.0352666825,
0.0011269228,
-0.0130995577,
0.0267691258,
0.0315844491,
0.003691264,
0.0205641706,
0.0148325264,
0.0220762193,
-0.0464538224,
0.0022955604,
-0.0433269814,
0.0136908097,
0.0115640424,
0.0207024403,
-0.0000264521,
-0.0516645424,
-0.0017330904,
-0.0184838008,
-0.0135535151,
0.0431593843,
-0.0314637125,
-0.0197143052,
-0.0316562578,
-0.0406212173,
-0.0594643839,
0.0237215646,
-0.0014937015,
0.0089841364,
0.0437802859,
0.0223801937,
-0.0117342537,
-0.0227457322,
-0.0504057668,
0.025560556,
-0.0084407851,
0.0743685067,
0.0544145554,
0.0227063391,
-0.0056909998,
0.0235982276,
0.0226487704,
-0.0255297963,
-0.0274059996,
0.0494054705,
0.0452625044,
0.0322361104,
-0.0209727529,
0.0299921073,
0.0422517322,
-0.0553266928,
-0.0291872025,
0.0342729799,
0.0045733028,
0.0106285289,
0.0556418039,
0.023077162,
-0.0312121734,
-0.0340426527,
-0.0433825925,
-0.0186876375,
-0.0391942076,
-0.0377546921,
0.0467194766,
0.0286854133,
-0.041210141,
-0.0302245375,
0.0510376468,
-0.0422885455,
0.0154821323,
0.0396326371,
-0.0636873543,
0.036010161,
-0.0336025804,
0.037842758,
0.0149335153,
-0.0488596931,
0.0460129045,
-0.0239980835,
-0.0013013192,
0.0199791305,
-0.0385535955,
0.027710788,
-0.0375103094,
0.0195014086,
-0.0482172444,
0.0375798158,
0.0096968301,
-0.0051737805,
0.0208821632,
-0.0000162105,
0.0142373163,
0.0194715932,
0.0122772586,
0.0400528796,
-0.0344524905,
-0.0021064226,
0.0137286056,
0.0657947883,
-0.0146435592,
0.0294121504,
-0.0574084297,
0.0317466483,
0.0539088883,
-0.0140788918,
-0.0312200077,
0.0616392493,
2.806e-7,
0.0359385014,
0.0444890223,
0.0520486906,
-0.0057138344,
-0.0068116845,
0.0062008384,
0.0012690853,
-0.0091647292,
0.0202205125,
0.0184438489,
-0.0260129627,
-0.0089580724,
0.0673437268,
0.0188231785,
-0.0909241736,
-0.0192010775,
-0.0142666288,
-0.0002706381,
-0.0710725784,
-0.0103900135,
0.0450170338,
0.068080537,
-0.0323906057,
-0.018411288,
0.0300685372,
0.0201859009,
0.0275433008,
-0.0030037572,
-0.0155642005,
0.0352097265,
-0.0215483252,
0.0193086918,
0.0098921275,
-0.0297938921,
-0.0339467637,
-0.0028463909,
-0.0077412087,
0.0219993517,
-0.0104025248,
-0.0108076399,
0.0526275709,
-0.0086203674,
-0.0254813954,
-0.03395373,
0.0146128833,
-0.0028961042,
0.001730031,
0.0011509727,
-0.0437883474,
0.0340270884,
-0.0768500417,
-0.0237864461,
-0.0119353579,
0.0589029789,
0.0179096051,
0.0076167658,
-0.005858432,
-0.0468695723,
-0.0366319194,
-0.0187289454,
-0.0249593873,
-0.017956147,
-0.0453525707,
-0.0033571988,
0.008287481,
-0.0461464934,
0.029637577,
3.040061424e-34,
0.0345355757,
-0.0144245252,
0.0082527921,
0.0615162328,
0.0328859799,
-0.0161804464,
0.0357021466,
0.0531000607,
-0.0206922442,
-0.0430168174,
-0.0477343313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08249v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08249v1 | On Using Distribution-Based Compositionality Assessment to Evaluate Compositional Generalisation in Machine Translation | 2023-11-14T15:37:19 | 2023-11-14T15:37:19 | Anssi Moisio, Mathias Creutz, Mikko Kurimo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Compositional generalisation (CG), in NLP and in machine learning more
generally, has been assessed mostly using artificial datasets. It is important
to develop benchmarks to assess CG also in real-world natural language tasks in
order to understand the abilities and limitations of systems deployed in the
wild. To this end, our GenBench Collaborative Benchmarking Task submission
utilises the distribution-based compositionality assessment (DBCA) framework to
split the Europarl translation corpus into a training and a test set in such a
way that the test set requires compositional generalisation capacity.
Specifically, the training and test sets have divergent distributions of
dependency relations, testing NMT systems' capability of translating
dependencies that they have not been trained on. This is a fully-automated
procedure to create natural language compositionality benchmarks, making it
simple and inexpensive to apply it further to other datasets and languages. The
code and data for the experiments is available at
https://github.com/aalto-speech/dbca. | [
0.0259058867,
0.0715329647,
-0.0223554708,
0.0092861494,
-0.0497577414,
0.0183664802,
-0.0367404558,
-0.0281066261,
-0.0842467397,
-0.0024934579,
0.0032552085,
-0.0842374638,
0.0265655536,
-0.0114632556,
0.0425853916,
-0.0348361209,
0.0200132001,
0.0473251231,
-0.0553015284,
0.0002534334,
-0.0189075749,
0.0179363936,
-0.0102642765,
0.0286364518,
-0.0198383331,
0.0132865068,
0.0138049768,
0.0317685343,
0.0514672659,
0.0053532086,
-0.0144373216,
0.0353801996,
0.0065360838,
0.0257077496,
0.0000019086,
-0.0610577278,
-0.0087162815,
0.0167231951,
0.0454371385,
-0.0253798533,
0.0541578047,
-0.0379394852,
-0.0191809908,
0.0180581193,
-0.0241352003,
0.0009378569,
0.0664505512,
-0.0121467346,
0.0246849246,
0.0992840081,
-0.0260089152,
-0.0627826527,
-0.0111154541,
-0.0210864097,
0.0169370323,
-0.0089155314,
-0.0134067237,
0.0387845784,
-0.0112120938,
-0.0491003059,
-0.0385733657,
0.0471768826,
0.0369660221,
0.0093746008,
-0.0126676839,
0.0195272472,
-0.0754687041,
-0.0319744647,
0.0237658285,
0.0862908289,
0.0357579142,
-0.0245135874,
0.0125951068,
-0.00923739,
-0.0144253382,
-0.00878496,
0.0064592962,
-0.0047820671,
-0.0420831367,
0.0104748253,
-0.0115519036,
0.0249648187,
0.0421097092,
-0.0409085713,
-0.0512797236,
0.0603288263,
0.0410714597,
-0.0301586464,
0.0485320576,
-0.0046241623,
0.0247736014,
0.0145600038,
0.0089666098,
0.0062256274,
-0.0097142225,
-0.0020069634,
-0.0172681976,
-0.0662417933,
0.0228352789,
-0.0433383286,
0.0315193124,
0.0349606723,
-0.0127535714,
0.0254631992,
0.0158036109,
0.0724540651,
-0.0138605833,
-0.0044852467,
-0.0884705037,
-0.0192988943,
-0.0821620822,
0.0201208424,
-0.0208878275,
-0.0025919976,
-0.026962949,
-0.0128410598,
-0.0611098707,
0.0058009494,
-0.0237710271,
0.026978286,
0.0507276841,
-0.0143386694,
-0.0712835267,
0.0135730766,
0.0175864231,
0.0394943804,
-0.0205766913,
-0.0238016844,
-0.0200203713,
-0.0320695974,
0.0100040631,
0.0196064301,
-0.0234664194,
-0.0373396389,
0.0113755204,
0.0598310642,
0.0147236111,
-0.05833029,
0.0065864632,
0.0223970637,
-0.0468902886,
-0.111706242,
0.0139192203,
-0.0639698207,
0.0555613674,
-0.006837463,
0.0169379208,
-0.0066627231,
-0.0007131756,
-0.0019736132,
0.0139179658,
0.0712606907,
0.0323096663,
-0.0049453415,
-0.0076650484,
-0.0008688111,
0.0026204919,
0.0922655612,
0.0277852714,
-0.0438843183,
0.0123364767,
-0.0190183334,
-0.018676294,
0.00088672,
-0.0129662147,
0.0000929024,
0.0090818014,
0.023130523,
-0.0456177704,
0.0343261138,
0.0346915722,
0.0669253841,
-0.0118456967,
-0.0311277844,
0.0611643828,
-0.0092431903,
0.0725748092,
0.0209770612,
0.0657348782,
0.0027199457,
0.0139941508,
0.044197008,
-0.0251457244,
0.0073532253,
-0.0081571387,
0.0271447897,
-0.012150377,
0.0464067198,
-0.0211908296,
-0.0055311318,
-0.0111525264,
-0.0209115781,
0.045109652,
-0.0715713575,
0.0473270714,
0.0314862616,
-0.027243685,
0.0538356416,
0.0031736121,
-0.0669792295,
0.020008808,
0.0204908885,
-0.0017924116,
0.005070284,
0.0210461505,
-0.0207961854,
-0.0294473078,
-0.0052006938,
-0.0283067059,
0.047407534,
0.036142271,
0.0080510443,
0.0596458726,
-0.044979196,
0.0192319565,
-0.0159405917,
0.01881692,
0.0295363273,
0.0002690923,
0.0181723926,
0.0385522246,
-0.099280946,
0.0041852403,
0.019133646,
0.0431859381,
-0.0072541446,
0.0392594598,
0.01607785,
0.0506875664,
0.0459838621,
-0.0326838344,
0.0301929601,
-0.007535771,
-0.024535168,
-0.0539311767,
0.0643818229,
-0.0395621732,
-0.0328070708,
-0.0005380251,
-0.1210527718,
-0.00237489,
0.0119055295,
-0.0215435624,
-0.0456902981,
0.0229988657,
-0.0487766452,
0.0265415385,
-0.0462265238,
0.0292813648,
-0.0197433457,
0.0132427905,
0.0120912706,
0.044665426,
0.0057373182,
0.0061923829,
-0.0119656874,
-0.0039627161,
0.0349668339,
-0.0273698922,
-0.0553258806,
0.0355481952,
-0.0042134835,
0.0059034643,
0.0154615976,
0.0121226031,
-0.0605011098,
-0.041418124,
-0.066108644,
0.0270927101,
-0.0427948497,
0.0794143453,
0.0579843856,
0.0312794782,
0.0029171943,
0.0415331684,
-0.0057857865,
0.003800405,
-0.0151795149,
0.0224689469,
0.013144928,
0.0031958476,
-0.0013138157,
-0.009113702,
0.0178809445,
-0.0144623648,
0.0432067551,
-0.0225857981,
0.0218696948,
-0.040633902,
0.0103926081,
-0.0415885337,
-0.0274629164,
-0.0162986554,
-0.0734820291,
0.0035375704,
0.0324514546,
0.0925086215,
0.0104591241,
-0.0085483752,
-0.0115735037,
0.0557635166,
-0.0077272952,
0.0031237223,
0.0146332737,
-0.043931365,
-0.0161775537,
-0.0285839662,
-0.0356325097,
0.0090378886,
0.0419526771,
0.0095039299,
-0.0196186248,
-0.0664184466,
-0.0122876968,
-0.0534879975,
-0.004443509,
-0.0127995173,
0.02323246,
-0.0201047696,
0.0017860353,
-0.0129481293,
-0.0349718407,
0.0617787205,
-0.0349592902,
-0.0087309107,
-0.0540871806,
-0.0014198393,
-0.0494939238,
0.0567639433,
0.0017876186,
-0.0064068181,
-0.0031491404,
-0.045988638,
-0.0393325575,
0.0139758643,
0.0446832106,
0.0073797428,
0.0189032611,
-0.0616511963,
-0.0197270606,
-0.0135671124,
-0.0196456462,
0.0067108399,
0.0294013675,
0.0354943946,
0.035134919,
0.0651206225,
-0.0282370299,
-0.0251016244,
0.0061933356,
0.0045465059,
0.0159401204,
-0.0064881835,
-0.003457512,
0.0056906515,
0.0245508105,
-0.0176506378,
0.0243404172,
0.0133703649,
-0.0178790782,
-0.0175574422,
-0.0166570004,
-0.0169239603,
0.0223438926,
-0.0421625488,
-0.0062361863,
-0.0320309289,
-0.0218879282,
-0.0169788264,
0.0067584226,
0.0612732731,
-0.0264053345,
-0.0061789695,
0.0563841313,
0.0179205239,
-0.0180826504,
0.0083684484,
0.0294885375,
0.0267171673,
0.0502977557,
0.0265453309,
-0.1077696383,
0.0250703748,
0.0246500671,
-0.006773077,
-0.0141188242,
-0.0234879367,
-0.0534478277,
-0.08574076,
0.0135564534,
0.0230486207,
-0.0973208025,
-0.066518873,
-0.0244242959,
-0.0303700548,
-0.0522980019,
0.0042151352,
-0.0162688438,
0.0096073318,
-0.0280269533,
0.002747728,
-0.0363873243,
-0.0773574859,
-0.0140933264,
-0.0429053828,
0.005139377,
0.0345871896,
0.0546851717,
-0.0326538458,
-0.0039632567,
0.0193189979,
-0.0574597977,
-0.0237834901,
0.0338267684,
0.0301560946,
0.0110538006,
-0.0206162501,
0.0242695436,
0.0055697798,
-0.0160618145,
0.0285613332,
-0.0081839589,
0.0576512776,
-0.0062391656,
-0.0309761874,
-0.0024890807,
0.0308204312,
0.0368326604,
0.0580587611,
0.0627779961,
-0.0144559378,
0.0172529798,
-0.0125398524,
-0.0299871732,
-0.0703092366,
0.0198297054,
0.0501843058,
0.0147105381,
-0.0156242345,
-0.0995452702,
-0.0453096144,
-0.0217988901,
0.0401762649,
-0.0045726891,
-0.0047751809,
0.007694975,
-0.0304851122,
-0.0421636403,
0.0291753672,
0.0035611792,
0.0285108611,
-0.0552749597,
-0.0307992417,
-0.001775283,
-0.0137330387,
-0.0352351852,
-0.0318994522,
-0.1099499241,
-0.0739670992,
-0.0227311794,
0.0598044209,
0.0181901902,
-0.0009818468,
-0.0324962474,
-0.0293786786,
0.0318916254,
0.031803932,
0.0064575355,
0.0200868454,
0.044026494,
-0.0517966561,
0.018725004,
0.0230049249,
-0.0157833137,
0.0143425157,
-0.0106344689,
0.0519611649,
0.0911327973,
-0.0127544748,
0.029368937,
-0.0144991558,
-0.0044342992,
-0.0268273484,
0.0040658037,
-0.019374663,
0.0273346547,
-0.0378434397,
-0.0105303386,
-0.0136917448,
-0.0373403132,
0.0335683413,
0.0303943455,
-0.0223991498,
-0.0070442818,
-0.0478722267,
0.0351696722,
0.0225823075,
0.0508149713,
0.0649220645,
-0.0414053947,
0.0304288249,
0.0239842683,
-0.0050034751,
0.024802966,
-0.0301728211,
0.0169381723,
-0.0158875082,
0.0422837473,
0.0026080403,
0.0073978561,
0.0087818373,
0.0187954344,
-0.0267457981,
0.0495379828,
0.0055322149,
0.0151675474,
0.0871818066,
-0.0353135504,
0.0869864598,
-0.0180454887,
0.0085536567,
-0.029172143,
0.049802959,
-0.0292645413,
-0.0018381652,
0.0255678967,
0.0077986363,
0.0167003646,
0.0571873374,
0.073141478,
-0.0367896482,
0.0193703268,
-0.0107160434,
0.0162280388,
-0.0163791738,
-0.0290265176,
-0.0047901948,
0.0044529759,
-0.0315642133,
-0.0346250385,
-0.0652133599,
-0.0622027405,
0.0056180903,
0.0272757132,
0.0273191016,
0.0110102072,
0.033239644,
0.0912472382,
-0.0311607514,
-0.0037062138,
-0.0095387707,
-0.0677939504,
-0.005375952,
0.0285899304,
-0.0232774299,
-6.331528488e-33,
-0.0100811198,
-0.0187071562,
0.0000599578,
-0.0201821513,
-0.030084582,
0.0206401851,
-0.0061764605,
-0.0178447589,
0.0012830377,
0.0233531576,
0.0037706564,
0.0087605622,
0.010560357,
-0.0192248132,
-0.0175450072,
0.0285562333,
0.0244154725,
0.0411362089,
-0.0373625681,
0.0010595735,
0.0235733688,
0.0340894349,
0.101771906,
-0.0298206247,
0.0154177556,
0.0337947085,
-0.0234055277,
-0.0198961981,
-0.0092096571,
0.0447463952,
0.0043830243,
0.0513152294,
0.0392405763,
0.0036838395,
0.0097245518,
-0.0015726644,
-0.0642692819,
-0.0216601752,
0.05397553,
0.0042204252,
-0.0102862092,
-0.0151866283,
0.0493367687,
-0.0392726883,
-0.0053836443,
-0.0406131782,
0.0157162584,
-0.0166402124,
-0.0077347807,
-0.0993377939,
-0.1113507599,
0.0278666839,
-0.0059804213,
0.0189567637,
-0.0159214661,
0.0160805881,
-0.031685546,
-0.0012938906,
-0.0282423981,
0.0191463176,
-0.0446330123,
0.0347717591,
0.0382909998,
-0.0335919857,
-0.0114569981,
0.0044371886,
-0.0067297579,
-0.0010417065,
0.0092396988,
0.0168148559,
0.0265171006,
0.0050303717,
0.0394759849,
0.0668144897,
0.0416949503,
-0.0012000164,
-0.0386943966,
0.0209223889,
-0.0164809451,
0.0150151644,
-0.0046397541,
0.0255755503,
-0.026583381,
0.0098226657,
-0.059344925,
-0.0190406777,
-0.0163875315,
-0.0580910444,
0.0335463919,
-0.0202116705,
-0.0155765517,
-0.0144859189,
0.0316562131,
-0.016559111,
0.016119143,
0.0122404601,
-0.051571168,
0.0039885323,
-0.0140804145,
0.0386521444,
-0.0123376232,
-0.0466572456,
0.0405004621,
0.0564741604,
0.038157668,
-0.0230866801,
0.0457476079,
0.029453164,
-0.0462895595,
-0.0147287538,
-0.0449003987,
-0.0334706493,
-0.0538758188,
0.050381016,
0.0382542349,
0.0340719372,
-0.00850813,
0.0182550736,
0.0293306168,
0.0435739681,
-0.0167644955,
0.0253778622,
0.0133319721,
0.0742620528,
-0.0313811786,
0.0085742436,
-0.0094981929,
0.0128198704,
0.0708281174,
-0.0356561355,
-0.0248967484,
0.001294903,
2.799e-7,
0.0747797564,
0.0517855659,
0.0034241839,
0.0248388834,
-0.0016539788,
-0.034924712,
-0.0759820715,
0.0229760967,
-0.0418500043,
0.0085377907,
0.0582685061,
-0.0247145798,
0.0727421269,
0.0464888252,
-0.1105823293,
-0.0040650819,
-0.0801940262,
-0.02723662,
-0.0537417978,
0.0067137666,
0.0515489727,
0.0868577734,
0.0008988993,
0.0148569504,
-0.0121709742,
-0.0283482205,
0.0658837259,
-0.0240931883,
-0.0100702308,
-0.003571382,
0.0346753746,
0.0096094972,
0.0018418446,
0.012960162,
-0.0358784124,
0.0125953378,
0.0100465035,
0.0395836011,
0.0206684005,
0.0037559306,
0.0465722494,
0.0118905054,
-0.0384826474,
-0.059107706,
0.0326729491,
-0.0683629587,
-0.0266582333,
-0.0138144074,
-0.0488316305,
0.0284241773,
0.0819336846,
-0.0209953319,
-0.0033679057,
0.0324156657,
0.0320549831,
-0.0194058977,
-0.004221919,
-0.0446076654,
-0.0092637669,
0.0378294401,
-0.0008723302,
-0.0192766078,
-0.0058678286,
-0.0216001105,
0.0290217828,
-0.0204439927,
-0.0114274798,
2.397865442e-34,
0.0550974458,
-0.0231726095,
0.0283273682,
-0.0494525805,
0.0427235253,
-0.0237992574,
-0.0540309288,
-0.0032411881,
-0.0470061488,
-0.0351749733,
-0.0102548515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08240v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08240v1 | Investigating the Encoding of Words in BERT's Neurons using Feature Textualization | 2023-11-14T15:21:49 | 2023-11-14T15:21:49 | Tanja Baeumel, Soniya Vijayakumar, Josef van Genabith, Guenter Neumann, Simon Ostermann | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pretrained language models (PLMs) form the basis of most state-of-the-art NLP
technologies. Nevertheless, they are essentially black boxes: Humans do not
have a clear understanding of what knowledge is encoded in different parts of
the models, especially in individual neurons. The situation is different in
computer vision, where feature visualization provides a decompositional
interpretability technique for neurons of vision models. Activation
maximization is used to synthesize inherently interpretable visual
representations of the information encoded in individual neurons. Our work is
inspired by this but presents a cautionary tale on the interpretability of
single neurons, based on the first large-scale attempt to adapt activation
maximization to NLP, and, more specifically, large PLMs. We propose feature
textualization, a technique to produce dense representations of neurons in the
PLM word embedding space. We apply feature textualization to the BERT model
(Devlin et al., 2019) to investigate whether the knowledge encoded in
individual neurons can be interpreted and symbolized. We find that the produced
representations can provide insights about the knowledge encoded in individual
neurons, but that individual neurons do not represent clearcut symbolic units
of language such as words. Additionally, we use feature textualization to
investigate how many neurons are needed to encode words in BERT. | [
0.0092978915,
0.0364666507,
-0.0136583131,
0.0689863935,
0.0055634296,
0.009196246,
0.0211676322,
0.0275432635,
-0.0183153879,
-0.008449805,
-0.0343213268,
0.0229032505,
0.0277584791,
0.0434665158,
0.027830895,
-0.051740814,
0.0257930439,
0.0132747712,
0.0137724802,
-0.008210062,
0.0157716013,
-0.0243909769,
0.0151657192,
0.0620966256,
-0.0275054555,
-0.0303939916,
-0.0102456398,
0.0000918484,
-0.0025532602,
-0.0003126769,
-0.0641709566,
0.0195929613,
0.0655515119,
0.0464842655,
0.0000017625,
0.0056952462,
0.0142641366,
0.0040393039,
-0.0289997291,
0.0481428802,
-0.0218244791,
-0.0414449051,
0.0092772916,
-0.0428024232,
-0.0280546993,
-0.0094824228,
0.080482319,
0.0338443592,
0.0273276884,
0.029073406,
-0.0099895364,
-0.0393963605,
0.0460957848,
-0.0070520225,
0.0136041557,
0.0175876785,
-0.0111530926,
-0.021329619,
-0.0347372741,
0.0124991909,
-0.0676700994,
0.0282453001,
0.0410626456,
0.0087117702,
0.0471613258,
0.0506077595,
-0.0055287569,
-0.0254445653,
-0.000548444,
0.0491745099,
-0.0257091019,
-0.000486885,
-0.0134932548,
-0.0003652571,
0.0043872958,
-0.0015698285,
-0.0229381006,
0.0179599095,
0.0182700306,
0.0569646433,
-0.0422500223,
-0.0091853356,
0.0352572836,
0.0045584869,
-0.0415260531,
-0.0078012203,
0.0097290659,
0.0255428441,
-0.0300086793,
0.0028029932,
-0.049934987,
0.0225687474,
0.0447610542,
0.0161598288,
0.0276636351,
0.0334786847,
-0.040679507,
-0.0434885994,
0.0012713575,
-0.0692997798,
0.0900681093,
0.0212342851,
-0.0423571691,
0.0400235727,
-0.0323509052,
0.0458522141,
-0.0428852551,
0.0627503544,
-0.0213189404,
0.0067984816,
-0.0652440935,
-0.0437119454,
-0.0415963233,
0.0274276324,
-0.0093153389,
-0.0547357425,
-0.0113674505,
-0.0034751303,
-0.0233161356,
-0.0194013361,
-0.0346474238,
0.0439588986,
-0.0236196965,
0.0013359251,
-0.0107172402,
0.0325535387,
-0.0396974459,
-0.0021272318,
-0.0492907651,
-0.0249398835,
-0.0064696711,
0.0292090178,
-0.0001329894,
-0.0094530713,
-0.0080799721,
0.0811899453,
-0.01301945,
-0.0651949644,
-0.0287666488,
-0.0029003674,
-0.0211710148,
0.036868453,
0.0476267897,
-0.051171694,
0.0403055251,
-0.0025928637,
-0.0060806954,
-0.0312906243,
0.0009954573,
-0.0201839879,
-0.0248713661,
0.0968351886,
-0.0607693084,
-0.0147441728,
0.001344578,
0.0064987778,
0.0047716135,
0.0275959764,
0.0772332102,
0.050158754,
0.0176016521,
-0.0086122425,
0.0109264655,
0.0213224776,
0.0219621807,
-0.0006424358,
-0.0799745321,
-0.0545778722,
-0.0303016491,
0.0189737398,
0.0403311104,
0.0308890175,
-0.0634190738,
-0.0594346002,
0.0643880069,
0.0850496069,
0.0253958628,
0.0264907014,
0.0316362455,
0.0087293796,
0.04724833,
-0.0061547901,
-0.0351900533,
0.0200205706,
-0.0080925003,
-0.0185771659,
-0.0358532257,
-0.0036321413,
-0.017367322,
-0.0357464999,
-0.0128415553,
-0.0059419065,
0.0049557039,
-0.0222017691,
0.0606689192,
0.0184444487,
-0.0110472264,
0.0636998639,
0.0015181052,
-0.0256409328,
0.031711895,
-0.0802442878,
0.0063955835,
0.0603849851,
0.0429216921,
-0.0330304243,
0.0131646609,
0.0381145105,
-0.0301776361,
0.0486553982,
-0.0212164409,
0.0055939704,
0.0705288351,
-0.0171590969,
-0.0214593038,
-0.0302790608,
0.0144775109,
0.0181208216,
-0.0267479289,
-0.0564622805,
-0.0174399931,
-0.0558586381,
-0.0305288248,
0.0502234213,
0.0266202558,
-0.029641917,
-0.0136132138,
0.0121180229,
-0.0060344534,
0.0058084205,
-0.0372592583,
0.0261920504,
0.0175827518,
-0.0561523326,
0.0239423439,
0.012089448,
-0.020717511,
-0.041682478,
0.0248893443,
-0.0629141852,
-0.0124757206,
0.0303857643,
-0.0305830333,
0.0048918603,
0.0080722738,
-0.0832187384,
0.0684022158,
-0.0372058973,
-0.0208343994,
-0.0231360905,
0.01417231,
-0.009799445,
0.0649661124,
-0.0191069413,
-0.0173234642,
-0.0052852752,
0.0000553874,
0.0447659865,
-0.0121872406,
-0.0464485325,
-0.0001898089,
0.0082410043,
0.008175727,
0.0052765058,
-0.0113286572,
-0.0067525324,
0.0180469863,
-0.1152664572,
-0.0333277807,
0.0119614936,
-0.0137174595,
0.0315588154,
-0.0378547125,
0.0461861528,
-0.0076074805,
-0.0122246761,
0.02361729,
-0.0551348738,
0.0383781791,
0.0554036163,
-0.0125006223,
-0.0204051659,
-0.0302583072,
-0.0495798588,
-0.0300953481,
0.095546484,
0.0154005289,
-0.0349867754,
-0.0332269929,
-0.0068635824,
-0.0091395704,
0.0275047459,
-0.0029609944,
-0.055973541,
0.0628907979,
-0.0470086411,
-0.0050363429,
0.074742727,
-0.0058452403,
0.1101362929,
0.0348236151,
0.0099108275,
-0.0503680073,
-0.0263196751,
-0.0232757535,
0.038826026,
-0.0226482712,
-0.0260780398,
0.011432955,
0.0617399178,
0.0254464783,
-0.0005843568,
-0.0618760958,
-0.0104604512,
-0.0117627038,
-0.0488774516,
-0.0674772859,
-0.0062823836,
-0.0197208691,
0.0294512622,
-0.0380705968,
-0.0916202068,
0.0678162202,
-0.0135869617,
0.0096437288,
0.0165883992,
0.0197358504,
-0.0092906896,
0.1162874773,
0.025814876,
0.0208505057,
-0.03113194,
-0.0300697591,
-0.0377391279,
-0.0029859333,
-0.0230417233,
-0.0290767979,
0.027233582,
-0.0471119992,
-0.021234991,
0.0061249118,
-0.0056430628,
-0.0130478544,
-0.0141367037,
-0.0011227945,
0.0309670512,
0.0214280058,
-0.0366676487,
-0.0399541035,
-0.0235832147,
0.045626685,
0.0025002754,
0.008865783,
-0.0065886998,
-0.032074444,
0.0433952138,
-0.0135352788,
0.0182404909,
0.0243566018,
-0.0530384518,
-0.0408336632,
0.0526162162,
0.002873379,
0.0346667357,
-0.0830513015,
0.0358734429,
0.0058827335,
0.0113896979,
-0.0308536347,
-0.0176823474,
0.0526034124,
-0.0634492487,
0.0063183308,
0.0739685744,
0.0306368228,
-0.044296734,
0.0268692039,
0.0069203866,
0.0016963846,
-0.0007057193,
0.02727082,
-0.0582592338,
-0.0303917304,
-0.0282033924,
-0.0117031811,
0.0282817986,
-0.0120609319,
0.0041550873,
-0.068337962,
0.0010022568,
0.0119940396,
0.0234834347,
-0.053917896,
0.0011174707,
-0.0281783771,
0.0071032788,
-0.0038812105,
0.0154377036,
-0.0040757791,
0.0183663517,
0.0102920467,
0.0143096419,
0.0026639383,
0.0103457579,
-0.0236770809,
0.0121444101,
0.0771209523,
0.0338117294,
-0.0441683456,
-0.0635842979,
-0.0280763358,
0.0135562234,
0.0325071625,
0.0049368553,
0.0666569024,
0.010486736,
-0.0512110442,
-0.0143805528,
-0.0156633891,
-0.0086496351,
-0.0394284911,
-0.0764941275,
0.0140751842,
-0.0095738396,
-0.0179122332,
-0.0275417306,
-0.0077818753,
-0.0488477983,
0.0541093126,
0.0812148601,
-0.0485284328,
-0.0278529171,
-0.0025983634,
0.0154849244,
-0.0297230184,
-0.0414337479,
0.0122069288,
0.0099196453,
-0.0296078827,
-0.0431806371,
-0.0108711617,
0.0469254553,
0.0543812625,
0.011915125,
-0.0541442558,
-0.0076957354,
-0.0276144184,
-0.0610537715,
0.0615520068,
0.0086638471,
-0.0044899485,
-0.0259767212,
-0.0529648438,
0.0141571155,
-0.0191406365,
-0.0230149962,
0.0112111596,
-0.0304045305,
-0.032260634,
0.0318228826,
0.047748819,
0.0212391764,
-0.0165908262,
0.0003708405,
-0.0710902587,
0.0795577317,
0.0722178444,
0.0071055768,
0.0298877303,
0.0181423146,
0.0103314053,
0.0026165396,
0.0346350707,
-0.0095663052,
0.0139390994,
0.0110126408,
0.0190497842,
-0.0110506574,
0.0388155356,
0.0118663553,
0.0012711629,
0.0691920519,
0.0069346745,
0.0370916203,
-0.0227612853,
-0.0321415849,
0.0101676658,
0.017938545,
-0.0853931233,
-0.0074356114,
0.0299950782,
-0.011045089,
-0.0214747172,
0.0019956431,
0.0262286495,
-0.005775095,
-0.0139186522,
-0.0016293367,
0.0268785004,
-0.0324120298,
-0.0213181283,
0.0208559241,
-0.0223464854,
0.0640353337,
-0.0650649667,
-0.0169211552,
0.0069872956,
0.0019337146,
0.0216168035,
0.0064788363,
-0.0718649104,
0.0393379219,
-0.0481788255,
-0.0919790864,
-0.0012351524,
0.049168624,
0.0106059061,
0.0187897906,
0.0340664908,
-0.0316563509,
-0.0004959816,
0.0036053204,
0.0245917588,
0.013758176,
-0.0125449058,
0.0524001233,
0.0421153717,
-0.0066439561,
-0.0798641145,
0.0691113696,
0.0204702932,
0.0207542963,
-0.0382710509,
-0.015918931,
-0.0213290229,
-0.0135745313,
0.0744553953,
0.0104004424,
-0.0130737796,
0.0268050563,
-0.042841319,
-0.0685504973,
0.0352410935,
0.04912645,
0.0209309235,
0.0143184317,
0.0317351967,
0.0413547531,
0.0210094899,
-0.0201079994,
0.0069930018,
0.0264373831,
0.0205268655,
-0.0404176451,
0.0196294133,
-5.576697647e-33,
-0.0423845649,
-0.0488906465,
-0.0153265214,
-0.0054102233,
-0.0012656489,
0.0363511667,
-0.0284431018,
0.0216344427,
-0.0130607784,
0.0576644056,
-0.0042700418,
0.0213294253,
0.000589406,
0.0348719954,
-0.010806093,
-0.018707009,
0.0312842987,
-0.0129696298,
0.0065537239,
-0.0117010428,
0.0347147174,
0.0325899869,
0.0798041523,
-0.0223865639,
0.0188175254,
0.0378380045,
-0.0119777396,
0.0432945527,
0.0052670259,
0.0392896608,
-0.0326769948,
0.0377115794,
0.0188638568,
-0.0075488156,
-0.0292642508,
0.0031172191,
-0.067996785,
-0.0313803554,
0.0333347246,
0.0332271867,
-0.1033341885,
0.0011369211,
0.0991405621,
-0.0416717306,
-0.0018376294,
-0.0027962406,
0.0299391095,
-0.0178153273,
-0.0366287567,
-0.0007306412,
-0.0540958121,
-0.0029892826,
-0.0017041196,
-0.0088190353,
0.0612933114,
-0.0491299964,
-0.0153736146,
0.0319087282,
-0.0620288849,
-0.0212945119,
0.020987751,
0.0331383124,
0.0209568646,
0.03301787,
0.0398183763,
0.0959749296,
0.0674003959,
-0.0334003158,
-0.0291148182,
0.0027974849,
0.0649685338,
0.0535203554,
0.0486839414,
-0.0008350009,
0.0348433033,
0.0086524496,
-0.0334211849,
-0.0289980825,
-0.0009678489,
0.0113631403,
0.0409336425,
0.02412045,
0.0024397743,
-0.0208124332,
-0.0300997403,
-0.042620454,
-0.0487056039,
-0.0116144456,
-0.0093892654,
-0.0130449431,
-0.0437417291,
0.0388206616,
0.0228011999,
-0.0300586186,
0.0056047905,
0.0254526492,
0.0048966431,
0.0545225032,
0.0293722674,
-0.0130519392,
-0.0312828869,
-0.0406556986,
0.0042917244,
-0.0041522454,
0.028754307,
0.0223076995,
0.040887244,
0.0180758201,
0.011217148,
-0.0056017502,
-0.0450510234,
-0.095167242,
0.0233334005,
0.0329854898,
0.0449999496,
0.0011852334,
-0.0456349067,
-0.0144341197,
-0.0083560795,
0.0031192447,
-0.0023854198,
0.0262197591,
-0.0158157609,
0.0388650745,
-0.0225965679,
-0.0373015702,
-0.0529475324,
0.0350675359,
0.0520294085,
-0.0639559627,
-0.0220647249,
0.0121393437,
2.482e-7,
0.0737132281,
0.0478525683,
0.0334166512,
0.0083162505,
0.048074536,
0.0501752049,
0.0091205686,
0.0668023974,
-0.0494475402,
-0.0746791959,
-0.0064866105,
0.0548277795,
-0.0025592796,
-0.0057335421,
-0.0209891498,
0.0103913387,
-0.0423264876,
0.0323488079,
-0.023359295,
0.0034061626,
0.0758231133,
0.0726232082,
0.0202760808,
-0.0237610005,
0.0601023436,
-0.0412400551,
0.0838321745,
-0.0347894914,
0.0228952039,
-0.0177072696,
-0.0118490448,
-0.0165907666,
-0.0165044777,
-0.0048711491,
0.0071309749,
-0.0063032657,
0.0103316624,
0.0535072014,
-0.0450065956,
0.0015415028,
-0.0127734179,
-0.0259584039,
-0.0165723823,
-0.022577215,
0.0407987386,
-0.0493040234,
-0.0575664267,
0.0029431719,
0.027675882,
-0.0095994771,
0.0128959352,
-0.0381389298,
-0.0314025618,
0.0168366563,
-0.0077002025,
-0.0465291291,
-0.022958437,
-0.0530637614,
-0.0318972655,
-0.0422097966,
-0.059586931,
-0.0119154407,
-0.0842596591,
-0.0277165528,
0.0402246304,
-0.0384939238,
-0.0263534319,
1.950444971e-34,
0.0194380935,
-0.0225640573,
0.0132423379,
0.040003024,
0.0154711725,
-0.0069879503,
0.0385641158,
-0.0337028056,
0.0162794758,
-0.0493743196,
-0.0306534413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08219v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08219v1 | Eval-GCSC: A New Metric for Evaluating ChatGPT's Performance in Chinese Spelling Correction | 2023-11-14T14:56:33 | 2023-11-14T14:56:33 | Kunting Li, Yong Hu, Shaolei Wang, Hanhan Ma, Liang He, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | ChatGPT has demonstrated impressive performance in various downstream tasks.
However, in the Chinese Spelling Correction (CSC) task, we observe a
discrepancy: while ChatGPT performs well under human evaluation, it scores
poorly according to traditional metrics. We believe this inconsistency arises
because the traditional metrics are not well-suited for evaluating generative
models. Their overly strict length and phonics constraints may lead to
underestimating ChatGPT's correction capabilities. To better evaluate
generative models in the CSC task, this paper proposes a new evaluation metric:
Eval-GCSC. By incorporating word-level and semantic similarity judgments, it
relaxes the stringent length and phonics constraints. Experimental results show
that Eval-GCSC closely aligns with human evaluations. Under this metric,
ChatGPT's performance is comparable to traditional token-level classification
models (TCM), demonstrating its potential as a CSC tool. The source code and
scripts can be accessed at https://github.com/ktlKTL/Eval-GCSC. | [
0.0412235297,
0.0234735534,
0.0221768655,
0.0134843793,
-0.0700078085,
0.0072786161,
0.0200593509,
0.0184688885,
0.0088836765,
-0.0376055278,
-0.0409412272,
-0.0561564974,
0.04958928,
-0.0039909803,
0.0354593024,
-0.0563410334,
0.047842484,
0.0336715579,
-0.0014507709,
0.0095783127,
0.0181350894,
-0.0116002327,
-0.0210109632,
0.0788791999,
-0.0228612088,
-0.061550945,
0.0411046259,
0.019866867,
0.035042692,
0.010406442,
-0.0084742606,
0.0718263313,
-0.0564655587,
0.0625968724,
0.0000016764,
-0.0643842891,
-0.009887076,
0.0053802258,
0.0073962961,
0.0414491743,
0.0684455633,
0.0405178256,
-0.0540758558,
0.0411690809,
0.0095290598,
-0.0220397376,
0.0649583712,
0.0403318331,
0.0202907454,
0.068335034,
-0.0149481995,
-0.0073857768,
0.0390801579,
-0.0140685849,
0.0263857283,
-0.0129010519,
0.0073899413,
0.0295575429,
-0.0177647304,
-0.0234958939,
-0.0450104624,
0.0248047989,
-0.0192170125,
-0.0117950253,
0.0316316895,
0.013272929,
-0.0280915182,
0.0036948263,
0.0126291541,
0.0090049598,
-0.0171875153,
-0.0569997169,
-0.021424016,
0.0137609541,
0.0037918801,
-0.0133737596,
-0.0291149784,
-0.02666701,
-0.0161669757,
0.0285714678,
0.0281375516,
-0.0116909845,
0.0081200693,
0.0088043641,
0.0375123098,
-0.0044355062,
0.0548735671,
-0.0663964376,
-0.0431147814,
0.0219608974,
0.0069228169,
-0.0337244906,
0.0178904291,
-0.0210455917,
-0.0354563557,
-0.0177882742,
-0.012410813,
-0.0442574657,
0.0036890563,
-0.0377114415,
0.0087401532,
0.0470712148,
-0.0316164307,
-0.0136440694,
-0.0498371981,
0.0991269946,
0.0454159826,
0.0496517196,
-0.0414563082,
-0.0092282351,
-0.0744845718,
-0.0070051649,
-0.0652670041,
0.0058359918,
-0.0050758994,
-0.0235350523,
-0.11812675,
-0.0139916465,
-0.0236048009,
-0.0127217965,
0.0539658144,
0.0095159011,
-0.0273717307,
0.0103120999,
0.0110075884,
0.004422497,
-0.0031388088,
0.0041854847,
0.0050547486,
-0.0375731774,
-0.0017077544,
0.0122738387,
0.0241617598,
-0.0154015655,
0.0151312165,
0.0586458221,
-0.0397093743,
-0.0458193794,
-0.0055001755,
0.026386654,
-0.0399365872,
-0.0367269851,
-0.0481039099,
-0.0564943142,
-0.0237409547,
-0.0305038821,
0.0361187235,
-0.0050543756,
-0.008689289,
-0.0049149413,
0.0093351891,
0.0819498897,
0.0219709519,
0.0075371829,
0.0044119894,
0.0062265289,
-0.0094120968,
0.0207539201,
0.012382118,
-0.0064677717,
0.0579057671,
0.0092507107,
0.0506600775,
0.0205231495,
-0.0580722354,
-0.0548084043,
0.0144241452,
-0.0428292677,
0.0206053182,
0.0441531278,
0.0389543138,
0.0842713639,
-0.0396182165,
0.0090408036,
0.0644083321,
0.0396487415,
0.0634615943,
0.0309944525,
0.0452926047,
-0.0226025078,
0.0074204123,
0.0552232303,
-0.0122039774,
-0.00913506,
-0.0284655932,
0.0450976081,
0.0501490906,
0.0202381797,
-0.0287389457,
-0.0462675542,
-0.0203575399,
0.0139530189,
0.0134295365,
-0.0489266627,
0.042363409,
0.0389206223,
-0.0348009542,
-0.016631566,
0.0022066049,
-0.0761168674,
0.0026403987,
-0.076001808,
-0.0017721312,
0.1011934578,
0.1008449644,
0.0241940264,
-0.0464285798,
0.0252269246,
-0.0781262815,
0.0555834696,
0.0218546484,
-0.0274925176,
0.0008417355,
-0.0532593504,
-0.0028119283,
0.0404777043,
0.0067976015,
-0.0036718184,
0.049934946,
0.0059507168,
0.0226020273,
-0.0717475936,
-0.0266982112,
0.0414549224,
0.0179189388,
-0.0263354853,
-0.0050959405,
0.001642446,
0.029975988,
0.0135982828,
-0.0264212061,
0.0336332396,
-0.0433323309,
-0.0325448327,
-0.0383748896,
0.0129481358,
-0.0737416297,
-0.0746584609,
0.0390500464,
-0.0785656571,
0.0016258216,
0.0331915133,
-0.0240528099,
-0.0545253418,
0.0008819411,
-0.0276521295,
0.0413110144,
-0.1123306826,
0.0448054411,
-0.0022836453,
-0.0118069584,
-0.0134094059,
0.0328933783,
0.0213919468,
0.0270234514,
-0.0047548204,
0.0605638325,
-0.0049143466,
-0.0511490479,
-0.0308017619,
-0.0316879638,
-0.0034162933,
0.0336416997,
0.0142606813,
0.0594878495,
-0.0241090599,
-0.0510242581,
-0.0918130726,
-0.0102361506,
-0.0274791978,
0.003443866,
0.0399248861,
0.0173522905,
-0.0290845428,
0.0011998238,
-0.0139040416,
0.0075725568,
0.0208066311,
-0.003829513,
0.0341230966,
-0.0459830463,
-0.0149022033,
-0.0403194539,
0.0087226173,
-0.0017568473,
-0.0017453678,
0.0069322539,
-0.0380866379,
-0.0466513596,
0.0413769297,
-0.0275794435,
0.0047963788,
0.0408657528,
-0.0710457563,
0.0071318396,
0.0075812894,
0.1023588553,
-0.0100099137,
0.0200927425,
-0.0044294139,
-0.0089838263,
-0.0156359393,
-0.0049006701,
-0.0237379503,
-0.0072405571,
-0.0275144819,
0.0077079921,
-0.010976891,
0.0019939956,
0.0611352175,
0.0259441566,
-0.03673096,
-0.0549229346,
-0.024282096,
-0.0348187983,
-0.0072962348,
-0.0409960486,
0.0111809745,
-0.0474541336,
-0.0440247916,
-0.0320221633,
-0.0432605296,
0.0777320415,
-0.0575934649,
0.0012549078,
-0.0788574517,
0.0180045888,
-0.0188595951,
0.025690116,
-0.0210840609,
0.0353455395,
-0.0049777646,
-0.0424993336,
-0.0488670692,
0.0445944667,
0.039737571,
-0.0400893837,
0.0114631187,
-0.0251945406,
0.0306774043,
0.0040383381,
-0.0130215315,
-0.0242615715,
0.0215790346,
0.0271315686,
0.0258056298,
0.0858956426,
-0.01589863,
0.0251083616,
0.0534499064,
-0.0255014524,
0.0606469661,
-0.0138738975,
-0.0141247017,
0.009977689,
0.0231866892,
0.0021201428,
-0.0014971031,
-0.006188578,
0.0196931064,
0.0192135088,
0.0416666456,
0.0209092274,
-0.0146478461,
0.0016269513,
-0.0071412344,
0.0139163509,
-0.0383059196,
0.0203275606,
0.0073032444,
0.0582785159,
-0.0378904715,
-0.0601645447,
0.1168951988,
0.0236110725,
-0.0358899236,
-0.0205638111,
0.0101396013,
0.0137337204,
-0.0214864574,
-0.0184570197,
-0.052244734,
-0.028893536,
0.0288487002,
0.0108868042,
-0.0281981695,
-0.008023466,
0.0051407758,
-0.114926897,
0.0484178215,
0.0153333014,
-0.0459831432,
-0.0518081635,
-0.0138453506,
-0.0015440112,
-0.0240825918,
0.0271189697,
0.0230455361,
-0.0203618705,
-0.0072784056,
0.0153983478,
-0.0466744564,
-0.0403854623,
0.0356394537,
-0.0493993424,
0.0603636652,
0.0640045181,
0.0294819325,
0.0386454277,
-0.0566243902,
0.0286191534,
-0.0061023962,
-0.0147107681,
-0.0005505621,
0.0201199595,
0.0167310052,
-0.0116243428,
-0.0283523761,
0.0217481721,
0.017060563,
-0.0118307127,
-0.0139941033,
0.0319889039,
-0.0089904675,
-0.0104562435,
0.0004032016,
0.0443867445,
-0.0045797802,
0.0882743374,
0.0513344072,
-0.0436659753,
-0.0614480861,
-0.0313704573,
0.0215388574,
-0.0692261308,
-0.00279552,
0.0257497374,
-0.0250409581,
-0.0441404879,
-0.1010535583,
-0.0571341999,
-0.0039655864,
0.0307552796,
-0.0168602802,
0.0250585787,
-0.0501255058,
0.0249827299,
-0.0048512458,
-0.0234275982,
-0.0274615549,
0.00816165,
-0.0892407671,
-0.0163543038,
-0.0116448831,
-0.0154033033,
-0.0305443462,
0.0272984896,
-0.0558438711,
-0.0255419519,
0.0280691404,
0.0190431867,
0.0137415584,
0.0106993681,
-0.0299343895,
-0.0132047823,
0.0374327451,
0.0308309402,
0.0112605467,
0.0083489576,
0.0023394173,
-0.0159588512,
-0.0111042662,
0.0177599415,
-0.0001063847,
0.0337808207,
0.0374932177,
0.085209474,
0.0269951504,
0.0112098092,
0.0460912399,
0.0224099811,
0.0863034427,
-0.0600833446,
0.0199185479,
-0.0728372857,
-0.0093367761,
-0.0040545277,
0.0075875842,
-0.0116837984,
-0.0308297593,
0.0401165262,
0.00014416,
-0.0337482877,
-0.0096478416,
-0.0551043414,
-0.0010478068,
-0.0221229289,
-0.0221548062,
0.006472928,
0.0220080819,
-0.0076125925,
-0.0190632101,
-0.0187128112,
-0.0016242622,
0.0193156227,
-0.0128340526,
-0.0028940302,
0.0170564707,
0.0100763552,
0.0324813463,
0.0004925088,
0.0521056615,
-0.0230052024,
0.0634002686,
-0.0559873767,
0.0684091225,
0.0886909068,
0.0153211802,
0.0420723259,
-0.0379641131,
-0.0045624236,
-0.0428072661,
0.020685818,
-0.0107705658,
-0.0049019833,
-0.0259264596,
-0.0101790829,
0.0032079299,
-0.0489370748,
0.0742681995,
-0.0156179434,
0.0241068061,
-0.0267067291,
-0.0718921497,
-0.0272834301,
-0.0372113883,
-0.0219059791,
-0.0431566164,
0.0073173791,
-0.0185775813,
-0.0614907965,
-0.0781137943,
-0.0228688214,
0.0615931153,
0.024036942,
0.0449831411,
0.0316516459,
0.0543407016,
-0.0194630176,
0.0031449271,
-0.0373849124,
-0.0384539999,
0.0513559543,
-0.0237525944,
-0.0077150054,
-5.802321666e-33,
-0.0286728889,
0.0275624171,
0.0071980041,
-0.0022562663,
-0.0227969605,
0.0017359531,
-0.0313894041,
0.0005726649,
0.0071372166,
0.0374371856,
-0.0213594642,
-0.0061935359,
0.0240208376,
0.0255023651,
0.0144240567,
0.0272369683,
0.0614609569,
0.0300653111,
-0.019961793,
0.0088739339,
0.069405131,
0.0354772285,
0.0911086574,
-0.0113487765,
0.0291018952,
0.0148788113,
-0.0079517029,
-0.0109335957,
0.0357425585,
0.0482274629,
-0.0178254247,
0.0492097251,
0.0373984054,
-0.0004194293,
-0.0350892544,
-0.0005306524,
-0.092107363,
-0.0322889015,
0.0128849531,
0.011672236,
-0.0074763768,
-0.0191348549,
0.0302952938,
-0.0162618384,
-0.0563146137,
-0.0121099828,
0.0217683744,
-0.0362467207,
0.019054966,
-0.0400584266,
-0.0673783049,
0.0293869991,
0.0178046618,
-0.0111323921,
-0.0443803519,
-0.0006174202,
-0.0313673429,
-0.0043470347,
-0.0336407758,
0.0217604917,
0.0320719257,
0.0801103786,
0.0165427346,
0.0205398519,
-0.0087270821,
0.0122444462,
0.0093037086,
-0.0345219262,
-0.0102045033,
0.000810564,
0.0424286723,
-0.025984684,
0.0551793911,
0.043630112,
0.0425914116,
-0.0580812432,
-0.0192603692,
0.0643561333,
-0.0071898638,
0.024400346,
0.0101217646,
0.0166809447,
-0.022219982,
-0.033090394,
0.0102365129,
0.0116899647,
-0.0298875701,
-0.0263714977,
0.0601797104,
0.0050556646,
-0.0079002008,
-0.0236425456,
0.0255970489,
-0.0183149613,
0.0044138641,
-0.0022106697,
0.016472064,
0.0225351099,
-0.0258624125,
0.0063118716,
-0.028722601,
-0.039136149,
0.0554382466,
0.0476535447,
-0.0137075149,
-0.0312481187,
0.0380760245,
0.0184161216,
-0.0671219677,
0.0169190727,
-0.0356539227,
0.0060793431,
-0.0098800696,
-0.0382520147,
-0.0018429032,
-0.0067989333,
0.0077264961,
-0.0076240101,
0.0323377028,
0.0222635418,
-0.0051816651,
-0.0280179083,
-0.0141133144,
0.0060395626,
-0.0202213209,
0.0413128883,
-0.0425144732,
-0.0150634041,
0.0045335433,
-0.0268529821,
0.0067630261,
0.0161195211,
2.465e-7,
0.0549558438,
0.0301787257,
0.0457015224,
0.0026233259,
0.0028365739,
-0.0058817547,
-0.0088161239,
0.0203252938,
0.0109276408,
0.0472333096,
0.0464546233,
-0.0036884586,
0.0444105044,
-0.0049376348,
-0.0613550581,
0.0152803054,
-0.0808659494,
0.008956328,
-0.0062072803,
0.0258167926,
0.0343262106,
0.0510739572,
-0.0100160427,
-0.0226811767,
-0.0006245988,
-0.0572722554,
0.0294300783,
-0.0003267614,
-0.0155312987,
0.043282263,
0.0731090829,
0.0199817568,
0.067812264,
0.0057954774,
-0.0128388619,
-0.0123699326,
0.0839589387,
0.0173321906,
-0.0228738133,
0.0136568835,
0.0079081124,
0.0149344467,
-0.0047297371,
-0.068579562,
0.0478470474,
-0.0043494115,
0.0619313531,
-0.034514863,
-0.0313240066,
0.0298061874,
0.0399377607,
-0.0422756374,
-0.0666941553,
0.0623215027,
0.0377441719,
0.0233335737,
-0.0408036225,
-0.0312654264,
-0.0169239212,
0.0045687677,
-0.0111862179,
-0.0347856097,
-0.0028440608,
0.0003398552,
0.0111826397,
-0.0331816971,
-0.0107014086,
2.083686796e-34,
0.0229341518,
-0.0031051929,
0.0206623208,
-0.0394609049,
0.0214818791,
-0.0098661454,
0.0452957451,
0.0187485572,
-0.041184254,
-0.0507062152,
-0.033045087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08213v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08213v1 | Unlock the Power: Competitive Distillation for Multi-Modal Large Language Models | 2023-11-14T14:49:46 | 2023-11-14T14:49:46 | Xinwei Li, Li Lin, Shuai Wang, Chen Qian | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Recently, multi-modal content generation has attracted lots of attention from
researchers by investigating the utilization of visual instruction tuning based
on large language models (LLMs). To enhance the performance and generalization
ability of such LLMs, the practice of distilling knowledge from pretrained
multi-modal models (a.k.a. teachers) to more compact multi-modal LLMs
(students) has gained considerable interest. However, the prevailing paradigm
of instructiontuning in multi-modal LLMs knowledge distillation is
resource-intensive and unidirectional, neglecting the potential for mutual
feedback between the student and teacher models. Thus, we propose an innovative
Competitive Multi-modal Distillation framework (CoMD), which captures
bidirectional feedback between teacher and student models and continually
updates the multi-modal capabilities that the student model has learned. It
comprises two stages: multi-modal pre-training and multi-modal competitive
distillation. The first stage pre-trains the student model on a large number of
filtered multi-modal datasets. The second stage facilitates a bidirectional
knowledge transfer between the student and teacher models. Our experimental
analysis of diverse datasets shows that our knowledge transfer method
consistently improves the capabilities of the student model. Finally, the
7B-sized student model after four distillations surpassed the current
state-of-the-art model LLaVA-13B on the ScienceQA and LLaVA Test dataset, also
outperforms other strong baselines in the zero-shot setting. | [
0.0258211736,
0.0638353303,
-0.0066722799,
0.0231690425,
-0.0083055561,
0.0096196346,
0.0200401843,
-0.0232107844,
-0.0490856618,
-0.0657203346,
-0.0487417057,
-0.0295803379,
-0.0315087736,
0.0068939556,
0.025546683,
-0.0861954838,
0.0246342514,
-0.0580500104,
-0.0295493919,
-0.0020362637,
-0.0009385395,
0.0004216896,
-0.0155886067,
0.0132796606,
0.0103405574,
-0.0266005956,
-0.0387645923,
0.0081114266,
0.0303989276,
-0.0302568879,
-0.0064824722,
0.0764959604,
0.0631828532,
-0.0116342474,
0.000002368,
-0.0223367922,
0.0008661047,
-0.0110872248,
0.0171750635,
0.05328523,
0.0421818085,
-0.001346381,
0.0334048867,
-0.0085773272,
-0.0162769463,
0.0247080792,
0.0427923799,
-0.0117308991,
0.104605116,
0.0339135267,
-0.0025462727,
-0.0500325449,
0.0053837537,
-0.0114544155,
0.0115777608,
-0.0068631815,
0.037265826,
0.0493731126,
0.0035138368,
0.0193400979,
-0.074434191,
0.0488451235,
0.0298708882,
-0.0242307819,
-0.0194055978,
0.0131744612,
0.0107750371,
-0.0209472999,
-0.0140653523,
0.1003226116,
-0.0060448875,
0.0188467838,
-0.0162139963,
-0.0128875645,
-0.0031602667,
0.0296279136,
-0.0718583316,
0.0152408071,
0.012325706,
0.0358907655,
-0.0124001522,
-0.028883202,
0.0108062793,
0.0136977555,
-0.0056131016,
-0.0380747318,
0.0213858597,
-0.0077094897,
-0.016850289,
0.0298490841,
-0.0357036628,
-0.0324715972,
-0.000726843,
0.0477552824,
0.0156858079,
0.0231481027,
-0.0555956885,
-0.042598743,
-0.0107073411,
0.0105011547,
0.0787162781,
0.0222009104,
-0.0320723765,
0.0369280055,
-0.0196861997,
0.0396514721,
-0.0091210334,
0.0642389804,
-0.0544987693,
0.0068241614,
-0.0842125565,
0.0073194918,
-0.0272975471,
0.012193555,
-0.0279278792,
-0.0179349296,
-0.0183173791,
0.0004689101,
-0.0419023149,
-0.0262121204,
0.0345740654,
0.0072715548,
-0.0357525647,
-0.0076992004,
-0.0224282388,
0.1026887819,
-0.0132598206,
0.0229624659,
0.0144132385,
-0.0514213704,
-0.0064196656,
0.0180257652,
0.0072228061,
-0.010384066,
-0.0038099803,
0.0446440391,
-0.0903877243,
-0.0187629592,
-0.0654042587,
-0.0259584989,
-0.0276451949,
-0.0753893852,
0.0253779553,
-0.0566829368,
0.0317852572,
-0.0065208781,
0.015485391,
-0.0405522399,
0.0109235384,
-0.0187517311,
-0.0097299656,
0.0324334651,
0.0110192914,
0.0313769765,
0.0061291954,
0.0320232324,
-0.009830554,
0.1013773903,
0.0243682284,
0.0180436019,
-0.00712201,
-0.0178004447,
-0.0051236153,
0.0295379367,
0.0286894254,
0.0661639944,
-0.0515868105,
-0.0359463692,
0.0025378477,
0.0236043725,
0.0484828763,
0.0431635641,
-0.0629170239,
0.0241787191,
0.0859221667,
-0.0228089392,
0.0538299978,
-0.0009359776,
0.0716210604,
0.012125547,
0.0191262998,
0.0459799878,
-0.0188916512,
0.0251009986,
0.0039728964,
-0.0063393633,
0.0284709204,
0.067655921,
-0.0355594084,
-0.0485733487,
0.0265040379,
0.0054401173,
0.0125056338,
0.017516667,
0.071932219,
0.0134773385,
-0.0158335976,
0.041793745,
0.0673842877,
-0.0346477702,
0.0652367175,
-0.0585961938,
0.0211412087,
0.051488854,
0.0058067357,
-0.0050930409,
-0.0186147131,
-0.0001611696,
0.0483033508,
0.0252233557,
0.0463150479,
-0.0302147307,
0.0218022056,
-0.0593406968,
-0.0629217848,
-0.0466745012,
0.0123338634,
0.0291477423,
-0.0196891762,
0.034744367,
0.0106926998,
-0.0042131618,
-0.0170313753,
0.0344001055,
-0.0291455761,
-0.0257361867,
-0.0497265495,
0.0009156854,
0.0064182589,
-0.0115679549,
-0.0065659266,
-0.0208537541,
0.0184061602,
-0.031353537,
0.0323900431,
-0.0105164405,
-0.063272357,
-0.0635427535,
0.0283640251,
-0.0492082871,
0.0162865836,
0.0138508603,
-0.0400015153,
-0.0477063172,
0.0246969666,
-0.0037119177,
0.0269892719,
-0.0064481283,
0.0187838562,
0.0005346771,
0.002495063,
-0.0191601291,
0.0329913907,
-0.0159533918,
-0.0089373551,
0.0554389954,
0.0024585442,
-0.0123782502,
0.0081742676,
-0.0165202785,
0.0168896429,
0.0023513702,
0.0102409413,
-0.010369285,
0.0215677433,
-0.0590172932,
-0.0361975506,
-0.0769573227,
-0.0179441255,
-0.0245678332,
-0.0066452026,
0.0432624184,
-0.0121827992,
-0.004017272,
0.0070512448,
-0.019044226,
0.0219620802,
-0.0103109414,
0.0050525661,
-0.0126338871,
0.0409566872,
0.0030751443,
-0.0172418579,
-0.0103331599,
0.0152473515,
0.0316195525,
0.0071628611,
0.0209034272,
-0.036186181,
0.0441515781,
-0.0203803424,
0.0165965967,
-0.0017998368,
-0.039936021,
0.0199413653,
-0.0260904487,
0.0493344814,
0.0527403802,
0.0063512279,
0.0390339419,
0.0810977444,
-0.0470110327,
-0.0770694762,
0.0348978154,
-0.0158160869,
-0.0364526957,
-0.0567705669,
-0.0217426084,
-0.0273352209,
0.0718182772,
0.0060069147,
-0.0031837889,
-0.0658325106,
0.0009695012,
-0.0133579411,
-0.0477051362,
-0.0519998483,
0.0271840263,
-0.0069732056,
-0.0065614344,
-0.0195291378,
-0.044876311,
0.0584320165,
-0.0202065129,
-0.0034794712,
-0.023655761,
0.0078572836,
0.003808036,
0.0248464476,
-0.004204161,
0.0250179991,
-0.0234163851,
0.0203624908,
-0.0890020654,
0.0175597891,
0.0503853746,
-0.0189909171,
0.0489706509,
-0.0972837284,
-0.0272949729,
-0.0356975049,
-0.0153053431,
-0.0209039636,
-0.0128127849,
0.0136322556,
-0.005681959,
0.0264487769,
-0.0035636842,
-0.0347174406,
-0.0007237525,
0.0322970338,
0.0160547849,
-0.0218873974,
-0.005594057,
-0.0386187136,
0.0501340702,
0.0487308316,
0.0172477178,
-0.0359093547,
-0.0783629715,
0.0227154866,
0.0430248268,
0.0206958093,
-0.0204358995,
-0.0011941576,
0.0388734192,
0.0388090871,
0.0358184725,
-0.0188366547,
0.0282271318,
0.0820761696,
-0.0626681224,
0.0052195042,
0.0641860738,
-0.0061988947,
-0.0326198488,
-0.0135781802,
0.0365364887,
0.0408322439,
0.0102680149,
0.01674385,
-0.0749798268,
-0.0407928675,
-0.0249432102,
0.0065160799,
0.0286294799,
-0.0111983856,
-0.0420945175,
-0.0847821608,
0.0342531353,
0.0361079387,
-0.0215643141,
-0.0153219402,
-0.0097277667,
0.0085106296,
-0.0076090232,
-0.0024096083,
-0.0015058983,
-0.0355439596,
0.0068724961,
0.050704103,
0.0568204075,
-0.090348132,
-0.016006805,
-0.0107458625,
0.0213739555,
0.0141880745,
0.0191180967,
-0.0088475337,
-0.0581808686,
-0.0079466943,
-0.0131060062,
0.016979536,
-0.0033840057,
0.0397875197,
-0.0065462459,
-0.0114156017,
0.0075469879,
0.0457924195,
-0.0023846722,
-0.0362610035,
0.0034184433,
0.0699794218,
0.0168298203,
-0.0411456339,
-0.0279761311,
-0.0060741301,
0.0159641691,
0.0609094165,
0.0427935049,
-0.0606045909,
-0.0017964318,
-0.0221140906,
-0.0168344453,
-0.0546563864,
-0.0134780677,
0.0205041114,
-0.0401734188,
0.0136842979,
-0.0597483255,
-0.006414297,
0.0372631475,
0.0432745218,
-0.0043462701,
0.0143518616,
-0.0038940706,
0.0042560445,
-0.002452265,
0.0354315564,
-0.032595057,
0.0121618463,
-0.0656972453,
-0.0577096939,
0.0066223615,
-0.0479874276,
-0.0230942592,
0.0004550978,
-0.1160772368,
-0.0809136704,
-0.0127942115,
0.0578413121,
0.011621506,
0.0619254895,
0.0464788675,
-0.062152423,
0.0674139187,
0.0143592842,
0.0083432896,
0.010374791,
0.0116608748,
-0.0049108658,
0.0057611261,
0.0048162173,
-0.0295458231,
0.0127576469,
0.0338673107,
0.0486384705,
-0.0166570581,
0.0032480627,
0.0234962106,
0.0025041234,
0.0442343801,
0.0018411647,
-0.0050600814,
-0.0684845448,
-0.0061760577,
0.0063251662,
-0.002277799,
-0.075288184,
0.013135056,
0.0424007364,
-0.007255354,
0.0130772544,
0.0318825208,
0.0516905226,
0.0049734307,
-0.0599139072,
0.0347089916,
0.015821619,
-0.0188720133,
0.0540410765,
0.0453285128,
0.0105443662,
0.0279292669,
0.0004317976,
0.014341413,
-0.009369419,
0.0978782102,
0.0132563487,
0.0104236696,
0.003138958,
0.0344838388,
-0.0478288196,
-0.0205970202,
-0.061177887,
0.0523315445,
0.0449723415,
0.0279776193,
0.047880441,
-0.0313446932,
-0.0104326801,
-0.0123756276,
0.0404133275,
-0.0296383593,
-0.0037805687,
0.0442540199,
0.0291832779,
0.0224840902,
0.0055214921,
0.098564297,
-0.0166621394,
0.0648183748,
-0.0335381813,
0.0367669538,
-0.0258064922,
-0.0150921326,
0.0699403286,
0.0297256801,
0.0157133155,
0.0250371341,
-0.00790447,
-0.0425078124,
-0.0317899249,
-0.0060985708,
-0.0248391498,
-0.0212925486,
0.0537214242,
0.0365675949,
-0.0548245981,
-0.0207307022,
-0.0409055203,
-0.004394596,
0.0350880064,
-0.0127189979,
0.0015890935,
-6.865158842e-33,
-0.039077282,
0.0163971651,
0.0354917236,
-0.0188081041,
-0.0250064991,
0.0021627732,
-0.0143937441,
0.009792828,
-0.0199915618,
0.0327076651,
0.0334883928,
-0.0159341134,
0.0113702519,
0.0441205688,
0.0183454826,
0.0027800547,
0.0728260875,
-0.0042190962,
-0.0044470467,
0.0577613413,
0.0192309432,
0.0105324099,
0.0450675786,
-0.0314288959,
-0.0295335185,
0.005861802,
-0.0108543932,
-0.000464528,
-0.0166930109,
0.0430040285,
-0.0154361585,
0.043332573,
0.0112508042,
-0.0187180508,
-0.0601203293,
-0.0115453415,
-0.0427552462,
-0.032689143,
-0.000756027,
-0.0001534954,
-0.0813484192,
-0.0277125482,
0.0455613174,
-0.0061895517,
-0.0022614843,
-0.0320433863,
0.0383047722,
-0.0152507294,
0.00160179,
-0.0175394583,
-0.0506008305,
-0.000369519,
-0.0406492166,
-0.0599375032,
0.0120775243,
0.0483126566,
0.0158913713,
0.0192859434,
-0.0366807878,
0.067154631,
0.0604860708,
0.0366417915,
0.0960446224,
0.0532655455,
0.0003189957,
0.0425461568,
0.0071305558,
-0.0268487986,
0.0053561353,
-0.0296844207,
0.0684460998,
0.073379606,
0.0064133359,
0.0657349676,
0.0267959721,
0.0067815934,
-0.036202535,
0.0244082436,
-0.0250088181,
0.0337352604,
-0.0131944371,
0.0101899104,
0.030592218,
-0.0241448022,
-0.0622849986,
-0.0307840761,
-0.0113894641,
-0.0125066703,
0.041479893,
0.0148511836,
-0.0391234718,
-0.0278860051,
0.0554829575,
-0.0391350836,
-0.0190574639,
0.0200898796,
-0.0593171194,
0.0543702319,
-0.0078013982,
-0.0101895994,
-0.0854585096,
-0.0440077186,
0.0610102639,
-0.0309092347,
-0.014345902,
0.0162596144,
0.0200496707,
0.0450453945,
-0.0297228806,
-0.0034158307,
-0.044772286,
-0.0183488466,
0.051437702,
0.0001157757,
0.0356306657,
-0.0191334169,
-0.0505266003,
0.0289911348,
0.0371568985,
-0.0166174956,
-0.0067464858,
-0.0668099672,
0.0020211218,
0.024501089,
-0.0160056688,
0.0124707092,
-0.0612053908,
-0.0617723987,
0.0431480706,
-0.057660006,
-0.0261657629,
0.0209301561,
2.958e-7,
0.0353732966,
0.0245200358,
-0.030429801,
-0.0470372029,
0.0193559136,
0.0141828395,
-0.0447992906,
0.0047764792,
0.0349350683,
-0.0664505735,
0.0008532363,
0.0546965711,
0.0356137604,
0.0333305784,
-0.0434861518,
0.0125711542,
-0.0321927108,
-0.0200118124,
-0.0288218129,
-0.0477676205,
0.0549573563,
0.037194632,
-0.0049395291,
-0.0185946897,
0.0251316205,
-0.029770663,
0.0768169537,
-0.0119605968,
0.0056409105,
0.0292878337,
0.0003794557,
-0.0139565906,
-0.0091092512,
0.0039538178,
-0.0163425468,
-0.0047840276,
0.0099837435,
0.0652271807,
0.0067174421,
0.0066438522,
-0.0020910809,
0.0374789014,
-0.0412132144,
-0.0342664234,
0.0650770739,
-0.0768020451,
0.0192189477,
-0.0200384799,
-0.0164071638,
-0.0136708692,
0.0160295255,
-0.0327684134,
-0.0099319723,
0.0404080078,
-0.006587611,
0.0025966482,
-0.0578289703,
-0.0414879248,
-0.0098750982,
-0.031667944,
-0.0562496819,
-0.059931878,
-0.057594154,
-0.0649886131,
-0.0092458175,
-0.0297207348,
-0.0140320733,
2.493699915e-34,
0.0109495651,
-0.0263975766,
0.0462007485,
-0.0328519307,
-0.0025126762,
-0.0138623798,
-0.083258912,
0.0165337119,
0.0023783231,
-0.0868668556,
-0.0275416858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08206v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08206v2 | Human-Centric Autonomous Systems With LLMs for User Command Reasoning | 2023-11-14T14:42:28 | 2023-12-19T23:03:56 | Yi Yang, Qingwen Zhang, Ci Li, Daniel Simões Marta, Nazre Batool, John Folkesson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.RO | The evolution of autonomous driving has made remarkable advancements in
recent years, evolving into a tangible reality. However, a human-centric
large-scale adoption hinges on meeting a variety of multifaceted requirements.
To ensure that the autonomous system meets the user's intent, it is essential
to accurately discern and interpret user commands, especially in complex or
emergency situations. To this end, we propose to leverage the reasoning
capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) to infer system requirements from
in-cabin users' commands. Through a series of experiments that include
different LLM models and prompt designs, we explore the few-shot multivariate
binary classification accuracy of system requirements from natural language
textual commands. We confirm the general ability of LLMs to understand and
reason about prompts but underline that their effectiveness is conditioned on
the quality of both the LLM model and the design of appropriate sequential
prompts. Code and models are public with the link
\url{https://github.com/KTH-RPL/DriveCmd_LLM}. | [
0.03229573,
0.008558359,
0.004223648,
0.0541527085,
-0.0441919006,
0.0176047087,
0.027165059,
0.0012473934,
0.0230627097,
-0.0590480268,
0.0238528438,
-0.0184202977,
-0.006638011,
0.017099401,
0.0200542491,
-0.0193052664,
0.0091868462,
-0.0615888573,
-0.0149502866,
0.0080437111,
-0.0181787275,
0.0243330896,
-0.0337130539,
0.0329805091,
-0.0116461487,
-0.0062856828,
-0.0305205304,
0.0161732603,
0.0288058668,
-0.0244188532,
-0.011344132,
0.0505609103,
0.0825223923,
-0.0119946143,
0.0000019989,
-0.0738614425,
0.0179643352,
-0.0228180345,
-0.0756181702,
-0.0421400927,
0.0056854184,
0.0332776196,
0.0336149298,
0.0221576393,
-0.0142906969,
0.0030378974,
-0.0154011697,
0.0517288595,
0.0516633429,
0.0554278232,
0.005098307,
-0.0016034878,
-0.0204681437,
0.0152521459,
0.015457524,
-0.0283139609,
0.0179568939,
-0.0081059951,
0.0653783903,
0.0136651192,
0.0209389962,
-0.0070972554,
0.0468424782,
0.0137413582,
-0.0060350774,
0.0603599586,
0.0077643497,
-0.0202152859,
-0.009561439,
0.0493576191,
0.0011578113,
-0.0231575165,
0.0176686943,
0.0178709887,
-0.0081160879,
-0.0311516766,
-0.0132858027,
-0.0060771885,
-0.0481569767,
-0.0125652701,
-0.0315234065,
0.014869337,
0.0088381544,
0.0256300494,
-0.0354995094,
0.1027059481,
-0.0205896646,
-0.0279502496,
0.0400319956,
0.0039172429,
-0.0093543474,
-0.0725676417,
-0.0155603755,
0.0536331907,
-0.0848995894,
-0.0018608652,
-0.0053569102,
0.0410850383,
0.0060862242,
-0.0507317968,
0.0360289998,
0.0159687381,
-0.0393594019,
0.0721285716,
-0.0050422377,
0.0791841373,
0.0285441838,
0.0061517274,
-0.0309513006,
0.013314262,
-0.0512467138,
0.0046924911,
-0.0300427601,
0.0085712643,
-0.0054800492,
0.0161627438,
-0.0215137154,
0.0564386509,
0.0278868247,
0.0498047099,
-0.0271697342,
0.0531344451,
0.0160996616,
-0.0274032224,
-0.0270149391,
-0.0452736057,
-0.0250223614,
0.0433128476,
0.0116440598,
-0.0212664753,
0.0378896743,
0.0395803079,
-0.0182133745,
-0.0274261776,
0.0142748011,
0.0749841034,
0.0049799238,
-0.0324549116,
-0.0866249576,
-0.0556554571,
-0.0190240741,
-0.0668356419,
-0.0101150861,
-0.0699374229,
0.0301385988,
0.0293169059,
-0.0205899309,
0.0140577331,
0.0090847164,
0.0045740977,
-0.0051727034,
0.0869116187,
0.0224922802,
0.0100110257,
0.0327624157,
0.0216397773,
-0.0430103205,
0.0451319441,
0.0236437768,
0.0839882866,
0.0546824001,
0.0035693056,
0.0398622081,
0.0142333992,
-0.0620782264,
-0.012942153,
-0.0187942758,
0.0382249728,
-0.0404081419,
0.0303993765,
0.0260499306,
0.0253355,
-0.0072217602,
0.008302412,
0.053448204,
0.0822475553,
-0.0126061011,
-0.0219672844,
0.0570327081,
0.0388542265,
-0.0182790868,
-0.0270735454,
-0.052685421,
0.0130538801,
-0.0490392856,
-0.0059115547,
0.0148806116,
0.008450225,
-0.0347909294,
-0.0452326871,
-0.0036114354,
-0.0339198597,
-0.0109660383,
0.0024178212,
0.0480797552,
-0.0825718492,
-0.0178323574,
-0.0021554367,
-0.000468006,
-0.0023225006,
0.0085386056,
-0.0589180849,
0.0285794456,
0.0903293937,
0.018094264,
-0.0073701506,
0.0091914563,
-0.017780479,
0.0480730906,
-0.0283039641,
0.0097883325,
-0.0030775818,
0.0063413177,
-0.0162332226,
-0.0391499475,
0.0589698218,
-0.0036381395,
0.0078950319,
-0.0067080031,
-0.0068098493,
0.0271015912,
-0.0144634098,
-0.0105321603,
0.0333484299,
-0.007442147,
-0.0504133776,
-0.0304248501,
0.0492852964,
0.0109232869,
-0.0032149565,
-0.0085653672,
0.0055720834,
0.0300219338,
-0.0205402337,
-0.0388227813,
-0.0038607023,
-0.0324676968,
0.0025070936,
0.0299748946,
0.0115828868,
-0.0146430628,
0.0511448979,
-0.0483079851,
-0.038661059,
-0.0556786098,
-0.0407980755,
-0.0171635821,
-0.024452338,
0.0081250118,
0.0662307814,
-0.0313938484,
-0.01550713,
0.0400490575,
-0.0039245528,
0.0184717234,
0.0102320276,
-0.0199822094,
0.045703344,
-0.0392915718,
-0.0280336346,
0.0000376503,
-0.035676416,
0.0023462533,
0.010971183,
0.0175547916,
-0.0226437952,
0.0365961827,
-0.0794531852,
-0.0126274629,
-0.0424289368,
-0.0129839936,
-0.0039892411,
-0.0176280756,
-0.0138536431,
-0.013159805,
0.0181169827,
-0.0212741904,
0.0142661203,
0.0053948713,
0.0246142894,
0.0036475353,
-0.0510395616,
-0.008841034,
0.0063941875,
-0.0497343093,
0.0145880189,
0.0122996652,
-0.0113205034,
-0.080949463,
0.010995768,
-0.0131619573,
0.0314861648,
-0.0283946786,
-0.0233097188,
0.0450150855,
-0.009340805,
0.049355682,
0.0855758786,
0.0209705159,
-0.0038685733,
0.0469157659,
0.0109903794,
-0.0446414687,
0.0096058557,
-0.0236493871,
-0.0293352921,
-0.013030272,
-0.0224531516,
0.000248898,
0.0297293495,
-0.00088501,
0.0276817773,
-0.0530904159,
-0.0161877032,
-0.0177828316,
-0.0416869335,
-0.0942059234,
0.0000315518,
-0.0471664034,
0.0927720964,
-0.0029596242,
-0.0424996428,
0.0632075146,
-0.0401260965,
0.0037906296,
-0.0033299734,
-0.0323892497,
0.0026048021,
0.0753253102,
0.0206115637,
0.0000887433,
0.0325688012,
0.030518081,
-0.018067129,
-0.0015627471,
-0.046733018,
-0.019163115,
0.0486385673,
-0.0953598022,
0.0151484115,
-0.0064618462,
-0.0679929331,
-0.0426436812,
-0.0561404675,
-0.0523191951,
-0.0013580456,
-0.0400686972,
-0.0305564292,
-0.00511494,
0.0075067366,
0.044194866,
0.0557137057,
0.0144486492,
-0.0238156542,
-0.0351596996,
-0.0125200422,
0.0747829825,
0.0295390673,
-0.0226313137,
-0.0098198513,
0.0509172641,
0.0347329341,
0.0463735797,
0.0032365241,
-0.050616093,
0.0010271433,
0.0396272391,
0.0026010224,
-0.0031188237,
0.0835345462,
0.0468416139,
-0.0291322079,
-0.0127526252,
0.1102691218,
0.0207395256,
-0.0248568784,
0.0155613218,
-0.0285253637,
-0.0203385409,
0.0120034805,
0.038207043,
-0.0668993741,
-0.0546642169,
0.0173676927,
0.0335194319,
-0.0103934528,
-0.0283411928,
0.0012462457,
-0.0771649554,
0.0354621261,
-0.0221661478,
-0.0265006851,
-0.0177142527,
-0.055975467,
-0.0124358758,
-0.008187267,
-0.0038030404,
0.0404076912,
0.0079155378,
-0.0343786925,
0.0260618422,
-0.0436884165,
-0.0342754573,
0.0770342574,
-0.0441781431,
0.0215898938,
0.056850642,
-0.001326126,
-0.0014107804,
-0.0437326021,
0.0234249607,
0.0294528138,
0.027614193,
-0.0186314005,
0.0153312506,
-0.0312475972,
0.0209332947,
-0.0142448796,
0.047356952,
-0.0490997769,
-0.0329800844,
0.0203368701,
0.0973140821,
-0.0595278926,
0.0001712474,
-0.0510345586,
0.0186465532,
0.0082407156,
0.0746519342,
-0.0151542537,
-0.064933002,
-0.0437460877,
-0.0122072799,
-0.0684024617,
-0.0059517287,
-0.0401138142,
-0.0247424282,
-0.0229034796,
-0.0209682416,
-0.0254625436,
-0.0391195081,
0.05939354,
0.0250151344,
-0.0264350735,
-0.009994138,
0.0009822363,
0.0262925439,
0.0097092455,
0.0208220072,
-0.0185280535,
0.0462149568,
-0.0635684729,
0.0444003493,
0.0310654789,
-0.0251574982,
-0.0441502668,
0.0150184501,
-0.0207021199,
-0.0512701049,
0.0227782726,
0.0438072495,
0.0292338338,
0.0011651998,
-0.0186140388,
-0.053874597,
0.0349557735,
0.0241811648,
-0.0071896822,
0.0201062784,
0.0024217332,
0.0654065087,
-0.0177326612,
0.0354904756,
-0.0517762005,
0.0392353199,
-0.0105897635,
-0.0207007006,
-0.0474313572,
-0.0263825674,
0.0353157967,
0.0086764498,
0.0526777618,
-0.0256355871,
0.0059534814,
-0.0107954592,
0.0338085815,
-0.0003044637,
-0.0268975031,
-0.0241236389,
0.0224565361,
-0.0028986249,
0.0089603672,
0.0050869836,
-0.0583586469,
0.005836051,
0.0040289098,
0.003275899,
-0.0220684987,
0.0608579628,
0.0253238287,
0.0392810814,
-0.0419112034,
-0.0258652195,
0.0235076658,
0.0103272879,
0.0310078971,
0.0127149038,
0.1268491447,
0.022324536,
-0.0101400828,
-0.0110766599,
0.0270481389,
-0.0383028798,
-0.091486387,
0.018496599,
0.0173313562,
0.0279282294,
-0.0005679645,
-0.038653437,
-0.0610355586,
0.0140197249,
-0.0370708182,
0.0401451327,
0.035935048,
0.0055472786,
0.0557548329,
0.0519948713,
-0.0500891879,
0.0055571562,
0.0479848832,
0.0169844627,
0.0330497809,
-0.0050340779,
-0.0318927057,
-0.0761353672,
-0.0188339949,
0.0157798771,
-0.0115504973,
-0.0418470055,
0.0033559345,
-0.0609297045,
-0.0377897993,
0.0165451728,
0.0470705032,
0.012369507,
-0.0214878414,
0.020209752,
0.0391090177,
0.0038201853,
-0.0612524711,
0.006722054,
-0.0484062359,
-0.0317307897,
-0.0087773753,
-0.0505535081,
-5.955266705e-33,
-0.0049146651,
-0.014914291,
0.0371508189,
-0.0140647534,
0.0438763201,
-0.036321748,
0.0003787224,
0.042085018,
-0.0015466039,
-0.0158202145,
-0.0092701931,
-0.0068049189,
0.0202156827,
-0.0157937352,
0.0223064963,
-0.0312824957,
0.0115126111,
-0.0195968281,
-0.0207825676,
0.0119390786,
0.0648567006,
0.0073386566,
-0.0134094879,
-0.0543767698,
0.0475475267,
-0.0356623456,
-0.0262878072,
0.0780472904,
-0.0572127923,
0.0171212219,
-0.0246119238,
0.0301708039,
0.0349437408,
-0.012420455,
0.0105963396,
0.0652981922,
0.0033143249,
-0.0171905793,
0.0184951611,
0.0069268574,
-0.0459616296,
-0.0172003247,
0.0221870486,
0.0073067709,
-0.0291519593,
0.0126104811,
0.0466721058,
-0.0027495795,
0.0211898368,
-0.0131296106,
-0.022473,
0.0074055539,
0.012070151,
-0.0394271053,
-0.0037957462,
0.0945941061,
-0.026982354,
0.0125243468,
-0.0170698836,
-0.0045013148,
0.0158259403,
0.0206460059,
0.0524565615,
-0.0002214927,
-0.0259832479,
0.0552172512,
-0.0015809236,
-0.038299989,
-0.0543426611,
-0.0038774938,
-0.030673828,
0.0855790898,
0.0312544964,
0.053376995,
0.0018865875,
0.0160385743,
-0.0572670139,
0.0314840674,
-0.0163362846,
0.0558521524,
0.0545391589,
-0.0047205919,
-0.0705057234,
-0.0050151846,
0.0002006892,
0.021420395,
-0.0331705809,
-0.0160999522,
0.0550386459,
0.0199791659,
-0.0147388335,
-0.0487624332,
0.0565425716,
-0.0394720137,
-0.0075591784,
-0.0388871841,
0.0085831741,
-0.0107959984,
0.0040431847,
0.0165320579,
-0.0866947249,
-0.003232212,
0.0106531028,
-0.0201960448,
0.0258083045,
-0.0134373857,
-0.0068962267,
0.036984019,
-0.0202146005,
-0.0052776602,
-0.0411768556,
0.0121081965,
0.0283007436,
0.0409120396,
0.0683986545,
0.0098224645,
-0.0164191965,
0.0314641856,
-0.0382940024,
-0.0915028676,
-0.0289314669,
-0.0377981588,
-0.0227760691,
-0.0159326568,
-0.0190052483,
0.0023495811,
-0.0276701711,
-0.0103036603,
0.0231102426,
-0.0014462268,
0.0172586795,
0.004059229,
2.714e-7,
-0.0125755062,
0.0155241592,
-0.0198067352,
-0.0129466644,
-0.0088579487,
0.0707750097,
-0.0182267651,
0.0175365061,
-0.0195555203,
-0.0522276238,
0.0159829352,
0.0294048879,
0.063081339,
-0.0128319971,
-0.0483590178,
-0.0048440769,
-0.0195842683,
-0.0183195453,
-0.0769757107,
0.0289069712,
0.1386209577,
0.0568072982,
-0.0021910814,
-0.0230362024,
0.01194169,
-0.0471184067,
0.0110890465,
-0.057600487,
0.0146565605,
-0.0171781424,
0.0710987747,
0.0116061084,
-0.0006446763,
0.0415150411,
0.0216025561,
-0.0200654455,
-0.0303978641,
0.0862763524,
0.0025672328,
-0.036148876,
-0.0168077629,
-0.0338336267,
0.0163867529,
-0.0643709898,
0.0615526922,
-0.0397299044,
0.0255141724,
-0.0243715476,
-0.0070621669,
-0.0207273085,
-0.023843389,
0.0194173269,
0.0203665961,
-0.0059740948,
-0.0027067561,
-0.0115227504,
-0.0051845885,
-0.0997678265,
-0.0013836669,
0.0423269831,
-0.0507669449,
-0.0386032164,
-0.0164100584,
0.0542328097,
0.048251871,
-0.0652699545,
-0.0442993939,
2.238528331e-34,
-0.0123660685,
0.0148166213,
-0.0118035618,
0.0048105344,
0.0468974188,
0.0271445327,
-0.0460538939,
0.0151336016,
0.0187656488,
-0.0579973198,
-0.0056426427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08195v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08195v1 | Automated Fact-Checking in Dialogue: Are Specialized Models Needed? | 2023-11-14T14:29:00 | 2023-11-14T14:29:00 | Eric Chamoun, Marzieh Saeidi, Andreas Vlachos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prior research has shown that typical fact-checking models for stand-alone
claims struggle with claims made in dialogues. As a solution, fine-tuning these
models on labelled dialogue data has been proposed. However, creating separate
models for each use case is impractical, and we show that fine-tuning models
for dialogue results in poor performance on typical fact-checking. To overcome
this challenge, we present techniques that allow us to use the same models for
both dialogue and typical fact-checking. These mainly focus on retrieval
adaptation and transforming conversational inputs so that they can be
accurately predicted by models trained on stand-alone claims. We demonstrate
that a typical fact-checking model incorporating these techniques is
competitive with state-of-the-art models fine-tuned for dialogue, while
maintaining its accuracy on stand-alone claims. | [
0.0699068755,
0.0411259197,
0.0014660147,
0.0622952506,
-0.0452305302,
-0.0253544487,
-0.0065123457,
-0.0316887461,
0.0315054208,
-0.0777913928,
-0.0178563595,
-0.0247333217,
-0.0042987643,
0.0592566133,
-0.00954918,
-0.0224182308,
0.060666196,
0.0163422395,
0.085591279,
0.0062475395,
-0.0050722989,
0.0207525343,
-0.0452995338,
0.0287272818,
-0.0796398893,
-0.008582429,
0.0422341898,
0.0115040792,
0.0332384519,
0.0066861669,
0.0455071554,
0.0356516242,
0.0159832258,
0.0775135383,
0.0000015493,
-0.0363448933,
-0.0019291914,
0.0212716609,
-0.0550318174,
0.0184965804,
0.002022614,
0.0214090627,
-0.014479056,
0.0319737568,
-0.0161823593,
-0.0187164452,
0.0150371976,
0.0695690364,
0.0634738877,
0.1245188788,
-0.0079325819,
-0.0093087098,
0.0019777941,
-0.0018053711,
-0.0567943826,
-0.0473767072,
0.0399311967,
0.0464739576,
-0.0236531049,
0.0321428701,
0.0262598246,
0.040017534,
-0.0044429842,
-0.0288009159,
-0.016664071,
0.0114360284,
-0.061179854,
0.0099653043,
-0.0114507303,
0.0373530351,
0.0288309529,
-0.0346693881,
-0.005013186,
-0.0128866918,
0.014587081,
-0.0213838313,
-0.0113632623,
0.0303282384,
-0.0173647255,
-0.0104469787,
-0.0206151512,
-0.0010855445,
0.0088760331,
0.0261460319,
0.0173442401,
0.0661199614,
-0.0152802654,
-0.0506468154,
0.0032626456,
-0.0198537372,
0.0056165187,
-0.0283248853,
0.0108793452,
0.0051696422,
-0.0078925593,
0.0215189252,
-0.0166694149,
0.0230169389,
0.0359051079,
-0.0480427369,
-0.0100544859,
-0.0020646148,
-0.0769294575,
0.0702670142,
-0.0240944643,
0.0336214155,
0.0073174867,
-0.012540279,
0.0046342784,
-0.0435021333,
-0.0234453138,
0.0091037871,
-0.0676338747,
0.013436324,
-0.0645912439,
0.0028978446,
-0.0023685633,
-0.0028564529,
0.0020027906,
0.0227161143,
0.0043175216,
0.0336819217,
-0.0263386685,
-0.0357548892,
-0.0526693128,
0.0459348187,
0.0066330805,
0.0286654066,
0.0172318537,
-0.0835701376,
-0.0215465818,
0.0250567216,
-0.0027150325,
-0.0039678314,
-0.0093799531,
-0.0093175955,
-0.0020647352,
-0.0238764789,
-0.01160115,
-0.0146705806,
-0.0527595468,
-0.0614532642,
-0.0238178745,
-0.0207291804,
0.0309838727,
-0.0482410565,
-0.0134834368,
-0.0203993283,
-0.0028121378,
0.0246656798,
-0.0206962712,
0.0268724579,
0.0231364574,
0.0011109618,
0.0483588837,
-0.0024717629,
-0.0066524157,
0.0178874899,
0.0321882442,
0.0180376638,
0.0716692731,
0.0339336358,
0.0387969278,
-0.0173343848,
0.0606921799,
0.0071188286,
0.0630716383,
0.0211856812,
-0.0148048233,
0.0164283272,
-0.014164364,
0.0417455658,
-0.0169883929,
-0.0489710122,
0.0710005015,
-0.0009041305,
0.0048836735,
-0.0378404222,
0.0256600529,
0.0082150241,
0.0345377363,
-0.0070593543,
-0.0490398519,
0.0091388701,
-0.0180150289,
-0.0112637468,
0.0146019682,
0.0057260571,
-0.0070167747,
-0.0697038919,
-0.0228951033,
0.0151979206,
-0.0259653032,
0.0211168453,
-0.0001999418,
0.0396588407,
-0.0343548544,
0.0440245606,
0.0213730261,
-0.0425619818,
-0.0597581156,
-0.0758069977,
0.0168040115,
-0.0156946182,
0.0478013158,
-0.0116788531,
-0.0024638819,
-0.027810894,
0.0093213702,
0.0539765134,
0.1199321747,
-0.0146751972,
0.0294889156,
0.0006286808,
0.0113748992,
-0.026791133,
0.0563027821,
0.0028733548,
0.0490369014,
-0.0204910766,
0.0300590135,
-0.008722188,
-0.0164495204,
0.0093004964,
0.0311775971,
-0.0169357117,
0.054550074,
0.0121293748,
0.01461941,
0.0040420461,
-0.0235048309,
-0.0004047514,
0.0160994679,
0.0296954438,
-0.030271804,
0.0160830989,
0.0080660209,
-0.0584722497,
0.0179765765,
0.0193468332,
-0.0190071817,
0.0371722393,
-0.0265210532,
-0.0246262606,
-0.008163265,
-0.0242487546,
0.0199286025,
-0.0469551049,
-0.0187919512,
0.0342880972,
0.0144331306,
-0.0099733919,
0.0450972654,
0.007307495,
-0.009381609,
-0.0296146236,
0.0101597086,
0.0468628071,
-0.0696827322,
-0.0143743111,
-0.012330791,
-0.0106049674,
0.0561971813,
0.0379942805,
-0.0533082858,
-0.0250040833,
0.0048143025,
-0.1084031612,
0.0071716541,
-0.0176213365,
0.0065944172,
-0.0130868983,
-0.030202236,
-0.0094429329,
-0.0300577953,
-0.0228907242,
-0.0325409397,
0.0438454114,
-0.0007544892,
0.0464656129,
0.0253234804,
0.0118435631,
-0.0544612855,
0.0400323346,
-0.0063347323,
0.0085199131,
-0.0094624301,
-0.0561141893,
-0.0142474016,
-0.0260433145,
-0.0749790743,
0.042605713,
-0.0363746397,
-0.015533695,
0.0052687488,
0.0243645404,
-0.0006136627,
0.0558148511,
0.0495548956,
-0.0011126917,
-0.0126160663,
-0.0056626066,
-0.0435612649,
0.0629657656,
-0.0115076099,
-0.0157841668,
0.0082340734,
-0.0104425102,
0.0663229972,
0.0452291556,
0.0375726223,
-0.0113088172,
-0.0122857057,
-0.0110298619,
0.0141963419,
-0.0361449085,
0.0379839577,
0.012378131,
-0.0283402093,
0.0446610637,
-0.0251700934,
-0.0427882001,
0.0824895576,
-0.0526710786,
-0.0000551477,
-0.0268877037,
-0.0323510021,
-0.0076612029,
0.0362400189,
-0.0126223154,
0.0164782647,
0.0196106713,
0.0017899995,
0.0122044785,
-0.0478056185,
0.0423205122,
-0.0480051711,
0.0400265232,
-0.022763405,
0.0362221748,
0.0192202218,
-0.0620009564,
-0.0604826622,
-0.0648291111,
-0.0141582591,
-0.0017719697,
-0.0892203078,
-0.0141831208,
-0.1124296784,
-0.0254082941,
0.033492852,
0.0605009384,
0.0149967112,
0.0014016413,
0.0397307463,
0.0283447914,
0.0235973783,
0.0363879651,
0.0117504522,
0.0227143392,
-0.0058366265,
0.0582270995,
-0.0506239384,
0.043157503,
-0.0250995886,
-0.0882439688,
-0.0447493568,
-0.0059925285,
0.0227554999,
-0.0003335329,
0.0243349373,
-0.0557192713,
-0.0119767766,
0.0576604865,
0.0018157678,
0.0631716102,
-0.011618345,
0.021035742,
0.0028663273,
0.0151694845,
0.0218140259,
-0.087918587,
-0.0256025158,
-0.0192416161,
-0.0115301833,
-0.0409616232,
0.004408109,
-0.0305952933,
-0.0748293772,
0.0755813867,
-0.0071169934,
0.0020853921,
-0.0644138753,
-0.0163437538,
0.0248141848,
-0.0025166683,
0.0190869179,
0.0168099888,
0.0400881246,
-0.0217873994,
-0.006134328,
-0.0132154105,
-0.0062832213,
0.0428347923,
0.0117332656,
0.0435260944,
0.0240157302,
0.0345538929,
0.0260844026,
-0.0342376679,
0.0114978021,
0.0236337762,
-0.0374641232,
0.0133849783,
0.0416375995,
-0.0436482057,
-0.0022118355,
-0.0005632943,
-0.0134624299,
0.0456523336,
-0.0478173904,
-0.001410952,
0.0117676342,
-0.0275319554,
-0.0256354697,
-0.0182588752,
0.0574579947,
0.0385027304,
0.0728545338,
0.0083934553,
0.0437202156,
0.0068441937,
-0.0392586365,
-0.031691853,
-0.0263000522,
-0.0609783754,
0.0346102975,
0.0272045396,
-0.0052074054,
-0.1003991812,
-0.0125368787,
-0.0492701158,
0.0439077616,
-0.0609755553,
-0.0451009125,
0.0292314328,
0.0158103313,
-0.0064898338,
0.0287334379,
-0.0763444155,
0.0164516009,
-0.0232184734,
0.0026017211,
0.0732760653,
-0.0257669836,
-0.0189695843,
0.034789063,
-0.0366355777,
-0.0365950242,
-0.0460068658,
0.0321590453,
0.0184306893,
0.062740691,
-0.023824757,
-0.0105402097,
0.0134417554,
0.0315362513,
-0.0334676094,
0.0200725775,
0.0487272106,
0.007729996,
-0.0479657464,
0.0254436638,
-0.0262694787,
0.0448879786,
-0.0235741343,
0.0163047332,
-0.0457912385,
-0.095811829,
0.0407312699,
0.0190201942,
0.0670781359,
0.0606512204,
0.007504574,
-0.0456072465,
0.0323666334,
-0.0003516556,
-0.048519101,
-0.0106491521,
0.0253620334,
-0.0314086676,
-0.0360491388,
-0.0252126493,
-0.0445327871,
-0.0448024981,
0.0656003952,
-0.0394950956,
-0.0529691838,
0.0063222079,
0.0036289403,
-0.0279778522,
-0.0341793373,
-0.0459549539,
0.0424875543,
-0.0000273192,
0.0616765767,
0.016300736,
0.023009669,
0.0180099998,
-0.023762105,
0.0167382695,
-0.0429499112,
-0.0848922282,
-0.028178703,
-0.0468661413,
0.0015592971,
0.006971566,
0.0020468789,
0.0044398666,
-0.0351164602,
-0.0245780386,
-0.0165779144,
0.0091553479,
0.0020220184,
-0.0182099994,
0.0149123678,
0.0086803734,
-0.0195630845,
0.020490909,
0.0135018723,
0.0122912033,
0.0731958002,
-0.0041758837,
-0.0323677845,
-0.0648011789,
-0.0913594067,
-0.019548364,
0.0091518741,
0.0112421112,
0.0104677882,
-0.0505606383,
-0.034815073,
0.01990401,
0.0265947562,
0.0219253227,
-0.0008139539,
-0.0033291418,
0.0818690881,
0.0269979089,
-0.0256038196,
-0.0454819463,
0.0054992628,
0.014407522,
0.009512363,
-0.0217423104,
-5.537322995e-33,
-0.0340229943,
-0.0203339271,
0.0069855535,
0.0325366147,
0.0128824441,
0.0207903031,
-0.0321708284,
-0.027977502,
-0.058155138,
0.0642238706,
0.0107032517,
0.0559389107,
0.0063915807,
0.0071387626,
-0.0535322614,
-0.0038034467,
0.0611134879,
0.0196699277,
-0.0518478565,
0.0141248871,
0.0294719581,
-0.0164364912,
0.0387685299,
-0.0937618762,
0.0198185444,
0.0085614435,
-0.0354914144,
0.0453870073,
-0.0602145009,
0.0644558892,
0.0254924558,
0.0612165257,
0.0139669552,
-0.0161632039,
0.0227447208,
0.0132160839,
-0.0703799427,
0.0297791567,
0.0390491523,
-0.0095992135,
0.0087054232,
0.0287981629,
0.0336554684,
-0.0122879809,
0.0180577729,
-0.0210972037,
0.0113773383,
-0.0306414086,
0.0062623052,
-0.0096616736,
-0.0601516217,
0.0458879434,
0.0191231072,
-0.0457772389,
-0.0333584175,
0.0436050184,
0.0338654853,
-0.0000339205,
-0.0578234643,
0.0225831475,
-0.0412404388,
0.0120648053,
-0.0143656274,
-0.0416724682,
-0.0495824963,
0.0405002981,
-0.0317271315,
0.0390208587,
-0.0296993647,
-0.0061549619,
-0.0116871959,
0.046984937,
0.0260792263,
0.0968831256,
-0.0310135018,
-0.0422372445,
-0.0510504805,
-0.0065195747,
0.0385183431,
-0.0021998545,
-0.016338991,
-0.0181219466,
-0.0499603935,
0.0209689643,
-0.033126682,
0.0393830389,
-0.0301237218,
0.0542552844,
0.024499502,
0.0540348366,
-0.0092254262,
0.0322065651,
0.0167829078,
-0.0331081115,
0.035014499,
0.0128488606,
-0.0242348555,
-0.0255849976,
-0.0120441634,
0.0305438377,
-0.0445544831,
0.0146175427,
0.0258010011,
0.032055147,
-0.0183367264,
-0.0016725786,
0.0559888594,
0.0016896295,
-0.0599844195,
0.0444366373,
-0.0043102927,
0.0634101108,
-0.040346574,
0.0175478831,
-0.0083581852,
0.0228329264,
-0.0207599569,
0.0393238626,
-0.0492497496,
-0.0165465046,
-0.0554046631,
-0.0046518929,
0.0073616202,
-0.0002547853,
-0.0272767637,
0.0073406897,
0.0048976247,
-0.0047870171,
-0.0157759469,
-0.0428909771,
0.020576261,
0.0134747485,
2.284e-7,
-0.0059070238,
0.0423404351,
0.0181527231,
0.002951754,
0.0057182959,
0.0638736561,
0.0172937512,
0.0156930331,
0.0396934785,
-0.0960084572,
-0.034568008,
0.0358171351,
0.045904275,
0.0085682599,
-0.0697636381,
-0.0322217792,
-0.0623375326,
-0.0505770668,
-0.0227222778,
-0.0338348411,
0.0325242206,
0.0625001192,
0.0169012435,
-0.0080415122,
-0.0174209103,
-0.037310876,
0.0705364048,
0.0555113144,
-0.0485010892,
0.0243095066,
0.0603069477,
0.0331946872,
0.0097978162,
0.0066932607,
-0.0158502646,
0.0605176799,
-0.0258898269,
0.0851282179,
0.0132929059,
-0.0383462273,
-0.0542671606,
-0.0044980706,
0.0122640375,
-0.0326642692,
0.024865998,
-0.0237404332,
0.0276226625,
-0.0540876426,
-0.0254423022,
0.043624457,
0.0147636784,
-0.0135413175,
-0.0250465497,
0.0221871212,
0.0129218353,
0.0138783855,
0.0291666407,
-0.0643153936,
-0.0267023351,
0.006078104,
-0.0509340204,
-0.0293801613,
0.0318539441,
-0.02893533,
0.029771667,
-0.0660060495,
0.037998043,
1.524023145e-34,
0.0352893807,
0.0178111605,
-0.0053320648,
-0.0142596085,
0.0793247446,
0.023692837,
0.0122407032,
-0.0407768153,
0.015393679,
-0.0102368211,
-0.0152753647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08191v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08191v1 | GEC-DePenD: Non-Autoregressive Grammatical Error Correction with Decoupled Permutation and Decoding | 2023-11-14T14:24:36 | 2023-11-14T14:24:36 | Konstantin Yakovlev, Alexander Podolskiy, Andrey Bout, Sergey Nikolenko, Irina Piontkovskaya | cs.CL | cs.CL | Grammatical error correction (GEC) is an important NLP task that is currently
usually solved with autoregressive sequence-to-sequence models. However,
approaches of this class are inherently slow due to one-by-one token
generation, so non-autoregressive alternatives are needed. In this work, we
propose a novel non-autoregressive approach to GEC that decouples the
architecture into a permutation network that outputs a self-attention weight
matrix that can be used in beam search to find the best permutation of input
tokens (with auxiliary {ins} tokens) and a decoder network based on a
step-unrolled denoising autoencoder that fills in specific tokens. This allows
us to find the token permutation after only one forward pass of the permutation
network, avoiding autoregressive constructions. We show that the resulting
network improves over previously known non-autoregressive methods for GEC and
reaches the level of autoregressive methods that do not use language-specific
synthetic data generation methods. Our results are supported by a comprehensive
experimental validation on the ConLL-2014 and Write&Improve+LOCNESS datasets
and an extensive ablation study that supports our architectural and algorithmic
choices. | [
0.0420378856,
0.113498725,
0.0073378677,
0.0306999106,
-0.0448382646,
0.0212728474,
-0.0163857173,
-0.0366636515,
-0.0119223176,
-0.0207083765,
0.0162284356,
-0.009083638,
0.0233252514,
0.0425484031,
0.0245605092,
-0.0080276523,
0.0772505999,
-0.003377045,
-0.0082140015,
-0.0244198814,
-0.0028131756,
-0.018177893,
-0.0514916219,
0.0305372421,
-0.0614146516,
-0.0358571485,
-0.0122598764,
0.0504094362,
-0.0141770188,
-0.0202182606,
0.0332552381,
0.0487821326,
-0.0316581763,
0.0484028757,
0.0000021235,
0.0026238256,
0.0067930436,
-0.0453487784,
-0.0156356972,
0.0240885429,
-0.0075548324,
-0.0086090155,
-0.042193152,
0.0125607559,
-0.0049086865,
-0.0586285777,
0.0578743778,
0.0240657106,
0.0801366121,
0.11149396,
0.0007335625,
-0.0143883061,
0.0332635641,
-0.0412714146,
-0.0070235156,
-0.0143762315,
0.010107494,
-0.0335913748,
-0.0417092554,
-0.0041367742,
-0.0666549578,
0.0587330572,
0.0441147126,
-0.0521650724,
0.0179173145,
-0.0177432131,
-0.0042129518,
-0.0385040902,
-0.0439040735,
0.0292933136,
-0.0075428821,
-0.0424194485,
0.0092662619,
0.0091015883,
0.041222129,
-0.0252996031,
0.0086392239,
-0.0082017165,
0.0314659216,
0.0109444698,
0.0476782843,
-0.040982984,
0.0113138938,
-0.014813628,
-0.0108560398,
0.0607850477,
0.0330950953,
-0.0511164293,
-0.0628830045,
0.0233009029,
0.0121474946,
-0.0634612963,
0.0538538173,
0.006356047,
-0.0647836775,
-0.0229116846,
-0.0598217025,
-0.0538032167,
-0.0370143279,
0.010913237,
0.0211938471,
0.0175179448,
-0.0090778554,
-0.0121974647,
-0.0457894579,
0.047612574,
0.023756694,
-0.0040997085,
-0.0456693582,
-0.0101678846,
-0.0124164205,
-0.0202968642,
-0.0478375219,
0.037768729,
-0.04794164,
-0.0194745753,
-0.0523844026,
-0.0078533897,
-0.0099087935,
0.0212614164,
0.0227880385,
0.0283371415,
-0.0618300065,
-0.0164552145,
0.0029747968,
0.0410549827,
-0.0248676203,
0.0030220009,
0.033838369,
-0.0527003519,
-0.0602615811,
0.0449094661,
0.0359851271,
-0.0197965633,
-0.0178274978,
0.0213124864,
-0.0084756035,
-0.020858584,
-0.0218353868,
0.0030120835,
-0.0219619926,
-0.0333835967,
-0.0326173827,
-0.0865966976,
0.006968346,
0.0000501913,
0.004976213,
-0.0452110842,
0.0159311965,
0.0059725791,
-0.0154193863,
0.0407560207,
-0.0153476568,
-0.0132288737,
0.008408362,
-0.0396349654,
0.0373042971,
0.016678581,
0.0144589888,
-0.02059591,
0.0273898225,
0.0124037703,
0.0271264017,
0.0040874612,
-0.0010631519,
-0.0387760177,
0.0132333888,
-0.0415816419,
-0.0089334231,
0.0400138684,
0.0761677697,
0.0486138612,
-0.0325204283,
0.0184376054,
0.0299515631,
0.009176705,
0.0503551327,
0.0109689347,
0.0305618756,
-0.0313030519,
-0.0165774301,
0.0344629101,
-0.0176436733,
0.0107077826,
-0.0189132597,
-0.0051745167,
0.0498328693,
0.0093642781,
-0.0402105004,
-0.0558300614,
0.0270283092,
-0.0125716487,
0.0194186643,
-0.0446769819,
0.0411145315,
0.0778558701,
-0.050355196,
0.0570639744,
-0.0006785745,
-0.0573985726,
0.0114589343,
-0.00795973,
-0.0382377058,
0.0227569137,
0.0687830523,
0.0162076447,
-0.021653913,
-0.0161005072,
-0.0110001964,
0.0632118434,
0.0223133937,
0.0157956816,
-0.0121743437,
-0.0417415351,
0.019896023,
0.0223566853,
0.0214442126,
-0.0036731048,
-0.0070263268,
0.0205839686,
0.0285874419,
0.0074749039,
-0.0427740142,
0.0250888709,
0.007626649,
-0.0124249905,
0.0244424045,
-0.0006194643,
0.0486006029,
0.0341695175,
-0.0020733075,
0.0317378268,
0.0097398609,
-0.05123448,
-0.0492193252,
-0.0010481926,
-0.1071275249,
-0.1283186227,
0.0423610955,
-0.0424025506,
-0.0469385684,
0.0318538584,
-0.039912384,
-0.0820041299,
0.0847624242,
-0.0793320164,
0.0388321951,
-0.060255181,
0.0371199101,
0.0541680157,
0.0113304555,
-0.0112102106,
0.0333085246,
-0.0156193897,
0.0392785408,
-0.0278907754,
0.0222414322,
0.0044695302,
-0.0426750183,
-0.0389453061,
-0.0275384001,
-0.0132092899,
-0.0082105463,
0.018405281,
0.0140479375,
-0.0001921507,
-0.017093109,
-0.0466424786,
-0.0214753486,
-0.0431599729,
0.0056713703,
0.0248239264,
0.0395170525,
0.0075903879,
-0.0519940108,
0.0037601853,
0.0374221131,
0.0449817404,
-0.006787851,
0.0601000264,
-0.0372098945,
-0.0129930768,
-0.041137673,
-0.033472456,
-0.0150907775,
0.0128359841,
-0.0056925053,
-0.0231454745,
-0.0666489378,
0.0113902744,
-0.0209747069,
0.0360020399,
0.0333473757,
-0.0785975456,
-0.0029342568,
0.0019596266,
0.0489361659,
0.0279349051,
-0.0000445398,
0.0022396131,
-0.0388510898,
-0.0280395932,
-0.01815168,
0.0096201943,
-0.0225122515,
0.0277115796,
0.0085288174,
0.0133935716,
0.0300533045,
0.0466047823,
0.0109772738,
-0.0030746947,
-0.0065350351,
0.0016221897,
-0.0006666958,
-0.0250510462,
-0.0006398628,
-0.0186297148,
-0.0281823669,
0.0009768719,
-0.0456734374,
0.0292437617,
0.0715623051,
-0.0014326419,
-0.0082023097,
-0.0546191446,
0.0248178728,
-0.0207589287,
-0.0238660518,
0.0385702252,
0.0239749234,
-0.0522724614,
-0.0741686225,
-0.0212032422,
0.0206319094,
0.0458294265,
0.0024317328,
0.0422357246,
-0.0245652441,
0.0296256542,
0.024639545,
-0.0648928434,
-0.0216832813,
-0.0336312316,
0.0311648678,
-0.0367952436,
0.0169879217,
-0.0046999739,
-0.0653537437,
-0.0031621906,
-0.0019865003,
0.0689379647,
-0.017129628,
0.0120543251,
-0.0369472727,
0.0656177849,
0.0125285182,
-0.003890262,
0.0320667438,
-0.0027566859,
0.0110424524,
0.0498544574,
0.014605335,
0.0322844312,
-0.0148330461,
0.0443665572,
0.0341734067,
-0.0305122416,
-0.0127026867,
-0.0266465191,
0.0467863418,
-0.0485560931,
-0.0510477163,
0.0958044454,
0.0219028108,
-0.0538309477,
0.004977779,
0.0009442475,
0.0140223522,
0.0107192248,
0.0121135116,
-0.04673253,
-0.0215446129,
0.0390744545,
0.0361810401,
0.0157255623,
-0.017936198,
0.0233898871,
-0.124841176,
0.0411920287,
0.0359938182,
0.001860803,
-0.1040013731,
-0.0220467933,
-0.0062529892,
0.0122042214,
0.0445561521,
0.0690139458,
0.0042238142,
-0.0105801877,
0.0174620859,
-0.062666811,
-0.0671183169,
-0.0843858644,
-0.0384840257,
0.0840338618,
0.0750554949,
0.0156100048,
0.0151926186,
-0.0466338247,
0.0617702156,
-0.0126976771,
-0.0015818493,
-0.0094674909,
-0.0014786965,
-0.0010200604,
-0.0352789275,
-0.0207125321,
0.0435496718,
-0.0731602982,
-0.001214423,
-0.0288498532,
0.0611129552,
-0.0027720488,
0.0200312138,
0.0074554551,
-0.0174582638,
0.024714658,
0.029382715,
0.029193053,
-0.0292591155,
-0.0673160255,
-0.0788286403,
0.0237450991,
-0.0554854982,
0.0246605035,
-0.0069376361,
0.0299556702,
-0.0312959738,
-0.0592170618,
-0.0675765499,
-0.0102845067,
0.0299273394,
-0.0158391502,
-0.0345265865,
-0.0181073323,
-0.046397537,
0.0057862592,
-0.0028766405,
0.0056289337,
-0.0094243232,
-0.068849802,
0.0203554966,
-0.0009853399,
0.0640192181,
-0.0084667196,
0.0142972618,
-0.0286886971,
-0.03100143,
0.0578437522,
0.0537090339,
0.0021273657,
0.0246827491,
-0.0195152983,
-0.027394183,
0.0343873464,
0.0478544533,
-0.0244908333,
0.0391505547,
0.0073333434,
-0.035195522,
-0.004250729,
0.0219589937,
0.0079467129,
0.0098503586,
0.0330777876,
0.1179675609,
0.0037536095,
0.0117623527,
0.0473194271,
0.0234491546,
0.0476349853,
-0.0016906557,
0.0207844172,
-0.0572374985,
0.0368182622,
-0.0129913343,
-0.0083606616,
-0.0246506054,
0.0410313122,
0.0415715836,
-0.0146045769,
-0.0175454263,
0.0047371332,
-0.0280910153,
0.0224296656,
-0.0029805007,
-0.0013211564,
0.016402781,
0.0157284923,
-0.0047570821,
-0.0047974,
-0.0154050617,
0.0167306326,
0.0491505153,
0.0320413597,
-0.0373183861,
-0.0057775592,
0.0436247513,
0.0442613699,
-0.0172060002,
0.0257450622,
-0.0353536755,
0.0619573556,
-0.0448205583,
-0.0187310837,
0.1037403718,
0.0226092469,
0.0842518359,
-0.0014206236,
-0.000585738,
-0.0233981851,
0.0005133557,
0.0105206929,
-0.0260559246,
-0.0362132527,
0.0030974599,
-0.001184941,
-0.007332155,
0.0774675608,
-0.0367690474,
0.022219019,
-0.0121211009,
0.0069299242,
-0.0336215049,
-0.0147030139,
-0.0063858903,
-0.0184713583,
-0.0229635816,
-0.0043458971,
0.0181259271,
-0.0783313364,
-0.0054666833,
0.0440978557,
0.0114660952,
0.0066168685,
0.0416279435,
0.0323625207,
0.0202673525,
-0.013485413,
-0.0260459557,
-0.0011621802,
0.0434776209,
-0.0623457283,
-0.062515974,
-6.871837119e-33,
-0.0600101314,
-0.0255028512,
-0.0618728623,
-0.0055285539,
0.0016121706,
-0.0131946839,
-0.0353352092,
0.0018691235,
0.0519374534,
0.0342273787,
-0.0172973368,
0.0520966649,
0.0075510475,
0.056281019,
0.0738740638,
0.0405570529,
0.0781290308,
-0.0133764222,
-0.0109807951,
-0.0159479529,
0.017951468,
0.0581847206,
0.0407696739,
-0.0408709832,
0.0058021448,
0.0141534591,
-0.001167295,
0.0154823447,
0.0112504456,
0.016991213,
0.0175881833,
0.054711435,
-0.0004224028,
0.0045364266,
-0.0279009175,
-0.0253909398,
-0.0989044011,
-0.0705549121,
-0.0120526198,
0.0341485515,
-0.0194292795,
-0.0357486084,
0.0570432432,
-0.0117405988,
-0.0390380137,
0.0176728144,
0.0053647212,
0.0172424279,
-0.0013816325,
0.003354257,
-0.0294644237,
0.0109009026,
-0.0120394779,
-0.0078974813,
-0.0346661508,
0.0242752973,
-0.0128426338,
-0.0468923748,
-0.0979282856,
0.0007718437,
-0.0263868552,
0.0903518125,
0.0116159245,
-0.0054309438,
-0.0189525206,
0.0166244004,
0.0495213829,
-0.0195188001,
-0.0103268363,
-0.0002525599,
0.0062237261,
-0.0220237039,
0.0484623462,
-0.0018953998,
0.0556581989,
-0.0220952258,
-0.023031177,
-0.0200144444,
-0.0132330637,
0.0917670429,
0.0107262023,
0.009643794,
-0.007525099,
-0.0474005267,
-0.0142295705,
-0.0461371019,
-0.0275661666,
-0.0205146056,
0.0269497521,
0.0270983931,
-0.009055824,
-0.0204558894,
0.0001578578,
-0.0192980226,
-0.0298597254,
-0.0028222904,
0.0280280579,
0.0130145,
-0.0024386346,
0.0421612076,
-0.0487543344,
-0.0034337391,
0.0028655401,
0.020626964,
0.0135373566,
-0.0113179684,
0.0201801229,
0.045750495,
-0.059512265,
0.0015253198,
-0.0107825939,
0.0301561039,
-0.0195309408,
-0.0135787316,
0.0328960232,
-0.0028804848,
-0.0001676774,
0.0177159943,
0.0035687981,
0.0377692655,
-0.0164010338,
-0.0125625022,
0.0028766671,
0.0472342148,
-0.0181482974,
-0.0164060481,
-0.0532737151,
0.0315032043,
0.0055201799,
-0.0571365394,
0.0111990077,
0.0344631858,
3.012e-7,
0.0235216655,
0.0616299622,
0.0687333196,
0.0104889758,
0.0214335695,
-0.0131831979,
-0.0055449563,
0.0156320985,
-0.0078770295,
0.048063688,
0.0200215522,
0.0116438856,
0.0531871319,
-0.012905783,
-0.0643710345,
0.0421059057,
-0.0807843804,
0.0190743692,
-0.0301775578,
-0.0374841727,
0.0139831984,
0.05824681,
0.0024555975,
0.0020893409,
-0.0137348957,
-0.0179205909,
0.0244040415,
0.047478877,
-0.0443975031,
0.0111952042,
0.0678423569,
0.0047428072,
0.0166891608,
0.0071215611,
-0.0057505579,
-0.0013562521,
0.014625242,
-0.0131901139,
-0.0316397846,
-0.0847753584,
-0.0065073557,
0.0330827199,
0.0015709371,
-0.0060220817,
0.0191932898,
-0.0250419099,
0.0151958354,
0.0198368523,
-0.0546615198,
0.0582098588,
0.0240764357,
-0.0211304706,
-0.0664339736,
0.0034820125,
0.0872940198,
0.0459206216,
-0.011149317,
-0.0430800095,
0.0032062968,
-0.001544914,
-0.0265778881,
0.0101920525,
-0.0205620304,
0.02682353,
0.0296375491,
-0.0038223264,
-0.0325274132,
2.845113721e-34,
0.054729566,
-0.010841392,
0.0326192304,
0.0116064474,
0.0347211622,
-0.0142857535,
-0.0420434102,
0.022043597,
-0.0288000796,
-0.0481091961,
-0.0562401824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08189v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08189v3 | All Data on the Table: Novel Dataset and Benchmark for Cross-Modality Scientific Information Extraction | 2023-11-14T14:22:47 | 2023-12-18T04:01:35 | Yuhan Li, Jian Wu, Zhiwei Yu, Börje F. Karlsson, Wei Shen, Manabu Okumura, Chin-Yew Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Extracting key information from scientific papers has the potential to help
researchers work more efficiently and accelerate the pace of scientific
progress. Over the last few years, research on Scientific Information
Extraction (SciIE) witnessed the release of several new systems and benchmarks.
However, existing paper-focused datasets mostly focus only on specific parts of
a manuscript (e.g., abstracts) and are single-modality (i.e., text- or
table-only), due to complex processing and expensive annotations. Moreover,
core information can be present in either text or tables or across both. To
close this gap in data availability and enable cross-modality IE, while
alleviating labeling costs, we propose a semi-supervised pipeline for
annotating entities in text, as well as entities and relations in tables, in an
iterative procedure. Based on this pipeline, we release novel resources for the
scientific community, including a high-quality benchmark, a large-scale corpus,
and a semi-supervised annotation pipeline. We further report the performance of
state-of-the-art IE models on the proposed benchmark dataset, as a baseline.
Lastly, we explore the potential capability of large language models such as
ChatGPT for the current task. Our new dataset, results, and analysis validate
the effectiveness and efficiency of our semi-supervised pipeline, and we
discuss its remaining limitations. | [
0.0301337428,
0.0495416149,
0.0371491052,
0.0149804289,
-0.0345059633,
0.0237262379,
0.0098126903,
0.0201517921,
0.0446126014,
-0.0457304381,
-0.0881830901,
0.0176062044,
-0.0296777133,
0.0251236614,
0.0306737144,
0.0066285138,
0.0336906575,
0.0038575998,
0.0285512656,
0.0416663736,
-0.0063760839,
-0.0047816951,
-0.0034187725,
0.0038154575,
0.0266129803,
-0.0231147893,
0.0293078218,
-0.0397520922,
0.0403990373,
-0.0337090269,
0.0225132667,
0.0463767685,
0.0065179802,
0.0425489061,
0.0000018767,
-0.0102434335,
-0.0537831336,
0.0539502576,
-0.0069327289,
0.0280079469,
0.0323829427,
-0.0610044822,
-0.0175973736,
-0.0338575728,
0.0059295283,
-0.0628416911,
0.0297992546,
0.0486657992,
0.0204514377,
0.0536670126,
-0.0116838422,
-0.0202389564,
0.072981894,
-0.0266596414,
0.0274608154,
-0.0284902267,
0.0577798821,
0.0050359489,
0.026219083,
0.0451191328,
0.043134056,
0.0547961891,
-0.0020075885,
-0.0314706117,
-0.0063609495,
0.0544247329,
-0.0454255603,
0.0136078727,
0.0125404699,
0.0816278979,
0.0417132042,
-0.0218068883,
0.0749101266,
0.0142163578,
-0.0279867407,
0.0126959374,
-0.039062351,
-0.006487445,
-0.021355439,
-0.0278140958,
0.0538232587,
-0.0018151437,
0.0356987379,
0.0121641746,
0.0102335699,
0.0435871556,
0.0093999803,
-0.050644584,
0.016525425,
0.0005261087,
-0.0005433987,
-0.034707617,
0.0121593038,
-0.0038711596,
0.0210830029,
0.0088117672,
-0.0095243677,
-0.0660427809,
0.0189296398,
-0.0161311198,
-0.0374651402,
0.0050335904,
-0.0141509948,
0.071459718,
0.0001761578,
-0.0377488136,
-0.0454768501,
0.0333549343,
0.006193527,
-0.0248718206,
-0.0403265543,
-0.0104924534,
0.007933272,
0.0260322802,
-0.0296412837,
-0.0159498304,
-0.0326895826,
-0.0346750095,
0.0133524919,
0.0164818689,
0.0328244939,
-0.0530876517,
-0.0653849244,
-0.015303921,
0.0323288478,
0.0512008294,
0.0044385493,
-0.0060492437,
-0.0076228878,
-0.0505934358,
-0.0372275636,
0.0139639433,
0.0277245641,
-0.0556871146,
0.0243399553,
0.0745407045,
-0.0110033667,
-0.0461152643,
0.0048237615,
-0.0326915383,
-0.0100902952,
-0.0829699412,
0.0212495066,
-0.0222615134,
0.0558323041,
0.0046735881,
0.0043970477,
-0.0535368621,
0.0092243608,
0.0019726923,
-0.045051381,
0.0495394543,
-0.0382015705,
-0.0358481444,
0.0303563271,
0.002257695,
-0.0153154731,
0.049246449,
0.0454514176,
-0.0459343493,
0.0287401453,
-0.0149967615,
-0.024036875,
0.0367421135,
0.0410552546,
-0.0413726047,
0.0562845953,
-0.0011527735,
0.0295468383,
0.0309731457,
0.0073346868,
0.0315769017,
-0.0491670668,
-0.0075342618,
0.0034083549,
0.0310709421,
0.0097600613,
0.0303135272,
0.0111830784,
0.0150799705,
0.0434249304,
-0.0042388546,
0.0046483143,
0.0178672187,
0.0067720804,
0.0261662472,
0.0350171551,
0.0187156387,
0.0059574363,
-0.0001791563,
-0.0026625535,
0.0137932552,
-0.0287073497,
-0.0153049193,
0.1116829142,
0.0118076792,
-0.0246433299,
0.0022245173,
0.0561019294,
-0.0497763976,
0.0167441852,
0.0151196541,
0.0159621872,
-0.0155756371,
0.0404131562,
-0.0995569453,
-0.0404156782,
-0.004038278,
0.019222673,
0.0497187339,
0.0257240646,
-0.0489851683,
0.0092954198,
-0.0048910934,
-0.0270171519,
-0.0001323468,
0.0104223173,
-0.0148927886,
0.032007426,
-0.0166192055,
-0.0117278723,
-0.0509433113,
-0.0059941178,
0.0459053889,
-0.0683764294,
-0.0120504377,
-0.023147177,
-0.0376980752,
0.0488737077,
0.0029873585,
-0.0516686291,
0.0242680088,
0.0706629679,
-0.0433943644,
0.0075689577,
0.0101619344,
0.0293118469,
-0.0055567846,
0.0335989185,
-0.023937,
-0.028928047,
-0.013095106,
-0.009943868,
-0.0169972349,
-0.0128368679,
0.0213470589,
0.0062052486,
0.0002964684,
-0.0120040793,
0.0463146381,
0.0232208334,
-0.025155751,
0.0501467921,
0.0053905929,
0.0253449958,
-0.0015513771,
-0.0757111758,
0.0032908926,
-0.0238648672,
-0.0187140703,
0.0170057639,
0.0183181223,
-0.0342123546,
0.0204241555,
-0.0046940171,
-0.0394732244,
-0.0266930871,
-0.1008822322,
0.0613597929,
0.004984797,
0.0476024523,
0.0198919456,
0.0047809873,
-0.0110106273,
0.0009130667,
-0.0036960398,
-0.0087676961,
-0.043935705,
-0.0186588056,
0.0588807277,
0.0299180802,
0.0196297839,
-0.0463881008,
-0.025749078,
-0.0561152659,
0.040461123,
-0.0022237366,
-0.0738155916,
-0.0081128525,
0.0166291352,
0.0172521528,
0.0233190358,
-0.0237390101,
0.0196924116,
-0.0159046724,
-0.0147601478,
-0.0023366918,
0.0538979359,
-0.0012015073,
0.0228826944,
-0.003602603,
-0.0319441371,
-0.0473777391,
0.0218605399,
-0.0187215414,
0.041019436,
0.0168232359,
-0.0252787471,
0.0547140129,
0.0620861799,
-0.0449036695,
0.0145138744,
-0.0051142294,
-0.00006249,
-0.0038752849,
-0.0116344783,
0.0042802282,
0.0674139708,
0.0054104114,
-0.0096354187,
0.002031046,
0.0114613166,
0.0452062599,
-0.0496954918,
-0.0153152943,
-0.0445808433,
0.0244950466,
-0.0514973588,
0.0299942829,
-0.0121381516,
-0.0098179374,
0.0199160855,
-0.0145672746,
0.0074555515,
0.0166353751,
0.0069921487,
-0.0079398332,
-0.0007748621,
-0.0595500618,
0.0573673509,
-0.0306687467,
-0.0325932801,
0.0334826037,
-0.0423331521,
-0.0172793921,
0.0360326804,
0.0249795858,
-0.0490938723,
-0.0239794981,
0.0081297131,
0.040434964,
0.0593874045,
-0.0477095805,
-0.0148170907,
-0.0410767719,
0.0453593582,
0.0670464858,
-0.0220789202,
-0.0262233913,
0.0005118391,
0.0108080199,
0.1025011167,
-0.0182020254,
-0.0002445813,
0.0107655656,
-0.0071929428,
0.0022089761,
-0.0716285706,
-0.0053986525,
-0.0399082638,
0.0367359594,
-0.0431621633,
-0.0221187938,
0.0852223709,
0.015305086,
-0.0435012132,
-0.0385287218,
0.0165566541,
0.0209132899,
-0.01351994,
0.0168100614,
-0.08912348,
-0.0259314943,
-0.0118722953,
-0.0029292931,
0.0119872708,
-0.0814258903,
0.0033113053,
-0.0382965095,
0.0413319841,
-0.0066637704,
-0.0911206007,
-0.0311408751,
-0.0649863705,
0.0151319392,
-0.042002473,
-0.022963196,
0.0318521895,
-0.0308630057,
0.0036463796,
0.0251581818,
-0.0159107856,
-0.072073929,
-0.0012381386,
-0.0520720743,
0.0225081071,
-0.0068336716,
0.0494465195,
-0.0174870808,
0.0257469304,
0.0455630012,
-0.0188323781,
-0.0543232746,
-0.0349150039,
0.0815709382,
-0.0489831418,
-0.0083715823,
-0.0082321167,
0.0726050362,
-0.0231933519,
-0.0091811586,
0.0444243662,
0.0688696206,
0.0186158679,
0.0302041396,
-0.0221702959,
-0.017083047,
-0.0076930132,
0.0708234385,
0.0009804792,
-0.0205470603,
-0.0540568903,
0.0043646214,
-0.0124900481,
-0.0099281417,
-0.042968329,
-0.0081963222,
-0.0576544777,
-0.0299379788,
-0.0358961411,
-0.0351496674,
0.0359516144,
0.0099669863,
0.0026633686,
0.0153733073,
0.0002198308,
0.0049580261,
-0.0396748967,
0.0230261274,
-0.0413908809,
-0.0180672929,
-0.0200320967,
-0.0372825749,
0.0677464381,
0.0134888319,
-0.0331576467,
0.0207379926,
-0.0162102859,
-0.0454791598,
-0.0208518915,
-0.008796352,
0.0140209999,
0.0418615863,
0.0027675086,
-0.0103417002,
0.0074735023,
0.0133194076,
-0.048228763,
-0.0382049009,
0.0037897651,
-0.0295199063,
-0.012683847,
-0.0032789761,
-0.0181157123,
0.0224799365,
-0.0020483518,
0.0483888499,
-0.0496412814,
-0.0025759169,
0.0346904881,
0.0330090187,
0.0447242782,
-0.0051451847,
-0.0101275006,
-0.0519660711,
-0.0088095497,
-0.0583878011,
-0.0025855645,
-0.0164214503,
0.0355491079,
0.0227603018,
-0.0276930984,
-0.0268238615,
0.0644829646,
-0.0116878226,
0.0292618107,
-0.0366522968,
0.0309020933,
-0.0002271569,
0.0077778604,
0.0126503967,
-0.051958181,
-0.0089939069,
-0.0230749771,
-0.0119070532,
0.0340857692,
-0.0325279832,
0.011872286,
0.0296377316,
-0.018108312,
0.0016022462,
0.0343993194,
-0.0885566622,
0.0272191931,
-0.0463292301,
0.0552757569,
0.0281621441,
0.0068121818,
0.0870041773,
-0.0494963452,
-0.0611528195,
-0.0120511148,
0.059740372,
0.0220790841,
0.0573727861,
0.0339561068,
0.0088878768,
-0.0513861142,
-0.0132305557,
0.081491746,
0.0224257,
0.0410390124,
0.0378084891,
-0.0266329441,
-0.0641503185,
-0.0086165825,
-0.0264776796,
-0.0178362411,
-0.0111406529,
-0.0301856697,
-0.042035874,
0.0076264753,
0.0358864479,
0.0356127322,
-0.048570767,
0.0026004629,
-0.0136985164,
0.0491084829,
0.0229219981,
-0.0409126244,
-0.0573740564,
0.0482112169,
-0.0076932046,
-0.0525902323,
-0.0039947038,
-6.196952017e-33,
-0.0286923237,
0.0226137061,
0.0010811018,
0.0455954596,
-0.0057300925,
0.0488949195,
-0.0482016914,
-0.0238403138,
0.0170341283,
0.0244673472,
-0.0284068156,
0.0094557432,
0.0108743021,
-0.0137890028,
0.0162387379,
-0.0131491749,
0.0068220054,
-0.0137136513,
-0.0194065012,
0.0422756113,
0.0456937887,
0.0339189954,
0.0809104741,
-0.0957957879,
0.0615908653,
0.0309698209,
0.027086189,
-0.0299206208,
0.0181035865,
0.0385795012,
-0.0701219589,
-0.0131017333,
0.0082549872,
-0.0601591393,
0.010270861,
0.0053138807,
-0.1492160708,
0.0397464782,
-0.0202595461,
-0.0079047931,
-0.0180245619,
-0.0290425606,
0.0035908306,
-0.0087309638,
0.0030876875,
-0.0488140956,
0.0382908508,
-0.0097138425,
-0.0236669295,
-0.0477550142,
-0.0600908026,
0.0576574244,
-0.0147764673,
0.0277738068,
0.0887320414,
0.0308209807,
0.010422824,
0.0598960258,
-0.0385703593,
-0.0027366583,
-0.0247969311,
0.0460986905,
-0.002367503,
-0.0519026332,
0.039606601,
0.0539635047,
-0.0023154814,
-0.0019197999,
0.0210853536,
0.002381878,
-0.0159880687,
0.0270243641,
0.0013536524,
0.0189844612,
0.0388133079,
0.0285353847,
-0.0956347212,
0.0517233424,
0.0244565867,
0.0098990882,
-0.0173159987,
0.0083145127,
-0.0057945703,
0.0244418848,
0.0114271445,
-0.0465636216,
0.0188924614,
-0.0060193609,
-0.0154983597,
-0.0336376578,
-0.0366785675,
0.0531374179,
0.0303315874,
-0.0073269126,
-0.0499510318,
0.0344149023,
0.0082980506,
0.0410054289,
-0.0081077665,
-0.0147959832,
-0.1028095707,
-0.0584599674,
0.0169804692,
0.0101247523,
0.0346383154,
-0.0110614793,
0.0523026325,
-0.0197156593,
-0.0350465402,
-0.0399373956,
-0.0201942772,
0.0100401808,
-0.0100205224,
0.0512074158,
0.0096151084,
0.0191033892,
0.0333186425,
0.0275270119,
0.0671504661,
0.066397056,
0.0090670604,
0.0451578349,
0.0171989966,
0.0078654494,
0.0420231037,
-0.0021086063,
-0.0237305462,
-0.0106943687,
-0.0248100795,
-0.0509060882,
0.0306302495,
0.0073835314,
2.571e-7,
0.0802215934,
0.0387446806,
0.0720084384,
-0.0198646002,
0.0187799968,
0.0093488153,
-0.0171561446,
0.010880094,
0.0012486426,
-0.0098055918,
0.0130920345,
-0.0450204946,
0.049490381,
0.0206134971,
-0.0729258657,
-0.06220356,
-0.0524351634,
-0.056377992,
-0.0500378571,
-0.0038283283,
0.0157849658,
0.0497943833,
-0.0457409583,
0.0164438039,
-0.0241674054,
-0.0185500402,
0.0612359829,
-0.0532850847,
-0.013699498,
0.0896973908,
0.031236602,
0.0072083832,
-0.0105749071,
0.0262229983,
-0.0420529135,
0.027062621,
0.0254349783,
0.0603130385,
0.0112918951,
0.0331560075,
0.0313611515,
-0.0180433132,
0.043532379,
0.0094175218,
0.0678426176,
-0.0672766268,
-0.041510094,
-0.0370914191,
-0.0191604495,
0.013825519,
0.0109588271,
-0.0129899085,
-0.0097608995,
0.0507867262,
0.0190694276,
-0.0289275385,
-0.0296615772,
-0.0651005805,
-0.0133298784,
0.0640692413,
-0.032849703,
-0.0209321026,
0.0196894947,
-0.034645725,
-0.0333035886,
-0.0641240105,
-0.0322509371,
2.657594592e-34,
0.0262473449,
-0.0107575906,
-0.0177441053,
0.0558833629,
0.0304084029,
-0.0226171967,
0.0015346964,
-0.019501308,
-0.0577044636,
-0.0734153688,
0.0142950136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08182v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08182v1 | Self-Evolved Diverse Data Sampling for Efficient Instruction Tuning | 2023-11-14T14:10:40 | 2023-11-14T14:10:40 | Shengguang Wu, Keming Lu, Benfeng Xu, Junyang Lin, Qi Su, Chang Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Enhancing the instruction-following ability of Large Language Models (LLMs)
primarily demands substantial instruction-tuning datasets. However, the sheer
volume of these imposes a considerable computational burden and annotation
cost. To investigate a label-efficient instruction tuning method that allows
the model itself to actively sample subsets that are equally or even more
effective, we introduce a self-evolving mechanism DiverseEvol. In this process,
a model iteratively augments its training subset to refine its own performance,
without requiring any intervention from humans or more advanced LLMs. The key
to our data sampling technique lies in the enhancement of diversity in the
chosen subsets, as the model selects new data points most distinct from any
existing ones according to its current embedding space. Extensive experiments
across three datasets and benchmarks demonstrate the effectiveness of
DiverseEvol. Our models, trained on less than 8% of the original dataset,
maintain or improve performance compared with finetuning on full data. We also
provide empirical evidence to analyze the importance of diversity in
instruction data and the iterative scheme as opposed to one-time sampling. Our
code is publicly available at https://github.com/OFA-Sys/DiverseEvol.git. | [
0.0327917263,
0.0452683717,
-0.0293382108,
0.0276639126,
-0.0195508339,
0.030515125,
-0.0067920033,
-0.0225324854,
0.0089940662,
-0.0535663813,
-0.0466340929,
-0.0022506823,
-0.0202856436,
-0.0138438344,
0.0268377326,
-0.0405595079,
0.0524411611,
-0.0629982352,
-0.0472671203,
-0.0162549652,
-0.0341971889,
0.0185399074,
0.0042274394,
0.0152944354,
0.043929331,
-0.008678426,
-0.0199035611,
0.0119382562,
-0.0158484727,
-0.0069187297,
0.0356377847,
0.0877002776,
0.0315878689,
0.020475911,
0.000002195,
-0.0446529016,
-0.0272820573,
-0.0156812537,
-0.0411016531,
0.0469644479,
0.0203652829,
0.0411138572,
-0.0164458398,
-0.0006087434,
-0.0052678892,
0.0189077128,
0.0337643549,
-0.0501589887,
0.0612402931,
0.0466712415,
0.0253455397,
0.0001982126,
-0.0019505532,
-0.017403964,
0.0271810498,
-0.0015384934,
0.0175545383,
-0.0009195855,
0.0275608394,
0.0472423285,
-0.058665134,
0.0248293597,
0.020399183,
-0.001279995,
0.0261965655,
0.024810724,
-0.0130025912,
-0.0186154582,
-0.0169831272,
0.0732610896,
-0.0378364958,
0.0017604815,
-0.0103749875,
-0.0223399866,
0.0252985694,
-0.0092037804,
-0.0331189632,
0.0120740151,
-0.0129464222,
0.0291126408,
0.0449114032,
-0.0265904497,
0.0111399544,
-0.0084729111,
-0.00629876,
0.0495394357,
0.0202504545,
-0.0329092108,
-0.0091360528,
0.0190639496,
-0.0267717633,
-0.0319871455,
0.003508951,
0.0211796612,
-0.0238759182,
0.0416131206,
-0.069834128,
-0.034868639,
0.0150692975,
0.0017599752,
0.0960886329,
0.0485920459,
-0.0233765002,
0.0351792872,
0.0098849246,
0.0058896872,
-0.0094157653,
0.0472166799,
-0.0378677212,
0.0174044799,
-0.0664626062,
0.0239234697,
-0.0293387529,
0.0332443602,
-0.0230733249,
0.0426677987,
-0.035407722,
0.0582461394,
-0.0087983776,
-0.0417323932,
0.0307090208,
-0.0325727761,
-0.0784796402,
0.0354752392,
-0.0014143002,
0.0166106429,
-0.037441384,
-0.0044145943,
0.0062545724,
-0.0681026354,
-0.0018073794,
-0.0080325464,
-0.0157455914,
-0.0421152748,
0.0264443681,
0.0427433066,
-0.0267048404,
-0.0511818565,
-0.0604129173,
-0.0014724898,
-0.0151600009,
-0.0259057283,
0.0090237698,
-0.0798149332,
0.0217451062,
0.0064475602,
0.0008170878,
-0.0247764699,
-0.0058473404,
0.0040979143,
-0.0416849442,
0.011804916,
-0.0174514987,
0.0268442947,
0.0282612313,
-0.007024928,
0.0142983571,
0.0887665674,
0.0248318352,
-0.033131022,
0.0550995283,
-0.0086455159,
0.0071389168,
0.0457531326,
0.011106411,
0.0229620133,
0.0158437863,
0.0024733476,
0.0085270246,
0.0084791891,
0.024648536,
0.0030120157,
-0.024556946,
-0.0269393735,
0.0431334116,
0.0295696575,
-0.006572227,
-0.0037211939,
0.0480015427,
0.0290352125,
0.0108725931,
0.0391961858,
-0.0501457453,
0.0311674643,
0.0157595687,
0.0052040461,
0.0221749898,
0.0495336168,
-0.0225864649,
-0.0561826639,
0.009314958,
0.0116497884,
-0.0220103115,
0.0208923295,
0.0530578569,
0.0011098176,
-0.0233266503,
0.0393696241,
0.0881375223,
-0.0160051957,
-0.0027996716,
-0.0679442585,
0.0297286436,
0.0838413388,
0.0250118971,
-0.0449439622,
-0.0526065752,
-0.0176513866,
0.0710268095,
0.0028698421,
0.0474035405,
-0.017138131,
0.0287078954,
-0.0526411682,
-0.0673960969,
-0.0227513947,
0.0062433309,
0.0632353425,
0.0387002677,
-0.0391290672,
-0.0190944057,
-0.0201939996,
-0.067082949,
0.0512903668,
-0.062295448,
-0.032168217,
0.0109222773,
0.0037231313,
0.0284085888,
0.0094793504,
-0.0192033667,
-0.0146193001,
0.007682085,
-0.0015857469,
0.0275747702,
-0.0345316678,
-0.0623186454,
-0.0379681513,
0.0208941512,
-0.0312037021,
-0.0461301431,
0.009172597,
-0.0577438436,
-0.0396362096,
0.004513206,
-0.0488504954,
-0.033527907,
-0.0185266696,
0.0395820551,
-0.0359880961,
0.0213182233,
-0.073691003,
0.0370246843,
-0.0268407203,
-0.0047874353,
0.0392561294,
0.0241449047,
0.0044952133,
-0.0425553098,
-0.0317747109,
-0.026135657,
0.0100216214,
0.0362177081,
0.0011888249,
0.0334744342,
-0.0512095802,
-0.0598073788,
-0.0450741388,
0.0277945995,
-0.0318073258,
0.0104338648,
0.0376242027,
-0.002594945,
-0.0173145719,
-0.0185261108,
0.0040486492,
-0.0401022136,
-0.0049954196,
0.0424133241,
0.0033371518,
0.0226246659,
-0.0389734171,
-0.0270456299,
-0.0526166223,
-0.0109550925,
-0.0038992246,
0.0065071625,
0.0260267351,
-0.0775736794,
-0.0303672925,
0.0029361944,
0.0314135924,
0.0081427451,
-0.0178436488,
0.0242411681,
-0.0017639457,
0.0330769792,
0.0754274055,
-0.0031645687,
0.0098869074,
0.064547345,
-0.0046026884,
-0.0485965051,
0.0175184011,
-0.0451249704,
0.00139859,
-0.0364946611,
-0.0564365201,
-0.0191609953,
0.0819136873,
0.0133194001,
-0.0481894389,
-0.0594769232,
-0.0265101194,
-0.0173698869,
-0.0385660455,
-0.0330249779,
0.0169443432,
-0.0202545971,
-0.0125759989,
-0.0402057953,
-0.0567250624,
0.0866200775,
0.0089855641,
-0.0070966654,
-0.0701193139,
0.0095465565,
-0.0003927079,
0.000480628,
0.0219834689,
-0.0081616566,
0.0123345619,
0.0105209053,
-0.0657619536,
0.0241407771,
0.0311573129,
-0.0153624434,
0.0549629852,
-0.0815152898,
-0.0213277563,
0.0205415264,
-0.0105130915,
-0.0322092623,
-0.0022831291,
0.0393217206,
-0.0192359183,
0.0445847772,
-0.0126401102,
-0.0173035581,
-0.0389570817,
0.0134137869,
0.075967513,
-0.0434173904,
0.0012500078,
-0.0443035476,
-0.0375508554,
0.0389830433,
0.0114452867,
-0.0169839561,
-0.0645689964,
0.0061310385,
0.0274068099,
0.0376551859,
-0.0391233563,
0.00933789,
0.0701037198,
0.0364145897,
-0.0303584635,
-0.0259423871,
0.0457960404,
0.0724175125,
-0.0420418121,
-0.0321617648,
0.0931536779,
0.0236535948,
-0.0280028582,
0.0073711276,
-0.0130292801,
0.0589542761,
0.0385404713,
0.0564820208,
-0.0401020609,
-0.017695643,
-0.0210896321,
0.0626912788,
0.011325541,
-0.0194160268,
-0.0017256098,
-0.0941589847,
0.0351659134,
0.0152182346,
-0.0684072748,
0.0099886041,
-0.0339638256,
-0.0116330441,
-0.0132894544,
0.0314634778,
0.0103297243,
-0.0179117993,
0.017735105,
0.0676237866,
0.0064052888,
-0.0646901429,
0.0376262255,
-0.0224729199,
0.0721673444,
0.0482337922,
-0.0031585367,
0.0157832503,
-0.0193468705,
0.0351650976,
-0.0079926783,
-0.003350355,
-0.0141968904,
0.0693036765,
0.0093510561,
-0.0156658906,
0.0153652644,
0.0493308753,
-0.0265549161,
0.0247813147,
0.0234213565,
0.0908302665,
0.0006426215,
0.0380647592,
-0.0177492592,
-0.0508676618,
0.0088254111,
0.0481589735,
0.0594118163,
-0.0765863806,
0.0166970044,
-0.0424388871,
-0.0287995897,
-0.1044950411,
0.0074894973,
0.071231477,
-0.0896004736,
-0.0498746634,
-0.0628612265,
-0.0504647195,
0.0537552759,
0.0248514228,
0.0233549885,
0.019806616,
0.0227384418,
-0.0132440263,
-0.0105204722,
0.0239964221,
-0.0579831563,
-0.00609178,
-0.0991134197,
-0.1018684357,
-0.0050452393,
0.0026601574,
-0.0117611783,
0.0036268679,
-0.0903843343,
-0.0826664269,
0.0548250824,
0.0864524022,
0.008509418,
0.0965763852,
0.0144309578,
-0.0565089323,
0.043188937,
0.0129706338,
0.0277256183,
0.017848121,
0.0337433368,
-0.0564744174,
-0.0253077094,
0.0103745675,
-0.0324406922,
0.0408638939,
0.0680197105,
0.013812515,
-0.027875904,
0.008351624,
0.0075615551,
0.0083010849,
-0.0063770185,
-0.0443738066,
-0.0157838222,
-0.0494528562,
0.0195767954,
0.0309942551,
0.0099211736,
-0.0459678322,
0.0059705181,
0.0007777553,
-0.0402803198,
-0.0054234476,
0.0109473402,
0.0054322905,
0.0473951958,
-0.0568490624,
0.0323395431,
-0.018847065,
0.0464590788,
0.0224522334,
0.0307587162,
0.017317526,
0.0404660702,
0.0068704374,
0.0266047213,
0.0178521425,
0.0384840034,
0.0051760338,
0.0275215711,
-0.0021473486,
0.014805791,
-0.0587715954,
0.0103525976,
-0.0621438026,
0.0294868629,
0.0400217511,
-0.0211491566,
0.0453849137,
0.0063265916,
-0.0055965506,
-0.028960105,
0.0121475514,
-0.011827088,
-0.016190432,
0.0111877797,
0.0259550586,
0.0190461632,
-0.0076902187,
0.0686143562,
0.0143294437,
0.0590397306,
-0.0016105191,
0.0278760679,
-0.0604461916,
-0.014347259,
0.0056449585,
-0.0000141701,
-0.0124903144,
0.0317690894,
0.0104754064,
-0.0435486697,
-0.0144429458,
0.0246336367,
0.0102133267,
-0.0076532774,
0.0487209819,
0.0322409943,
-0.0475900024,
-0.0121788234,
-0.035497155,
0.0028407553,
0.0432397909,
-0.041952692,
0.0124366265,
-6.583973246e-33,
-0.0320662558,
0.0097106937,
0.0052826256,
-0.0257307217,
0.0366658829,
-0.0192700662,
-0.030425217,
0.006707781,
-0.0265363771,
0.0038082462,
-0.0098429769,
0.0062742848,
0.0146423783,
0.0334676355,
0.0564728118,
-0.0032471721,
0.030778788,
-0.0424230993,
-0.0239325501,
0.0476704314,
0.0264941845,
0.0182768907,
0.0585227646,
-0.0182011966,
0.0110417046,
-0.0151392529,
0.0411037467,
0.0145376846,
-0.0330122821,
0.0757865682,
0.0215683673,
0.0423291996,
0.0210023243,
-0.0484129079,
-0.0646167547,
-0.0396215692,
-0.060824573,
-0.0763035044,
-0.0085274661,
0.0252485313,
-0.0199869797,
-0.0412787274,
0.0342134312,
0.0008672902,
-0.029311223,
-0.023045104,
0.0482334942,
-0.0413741469,
-0.0360726416,
0.0277345534,
-0.0563676693,
0.0165449455,
-0.0172599442,
-0.0412895717,
0.0054158703,
0.0133650079,
0.0190985166,
0.0014311764,
-0.0195159782,
0.0478571393,
0.0780048519,
0.0668522939,
0.0746407434,
0.0389686041,
0.03056233,
0.0023588121,
0.0180247948,
0.0192248728,
0.0586345755,
0.004899832,
0.0409032591,
0.0363247916,
0.0111983335,
0.0012519608,
0.0020231989,
0.0113566993,
-0.0388292186,
0.0168917384,
0.0362121761,
-0.0480517745,
0.034489505,
-0.0070811771,
-0.0346555822,
-0.0209316723,
-0.012917717,
0.0035219872,
-0.0170549862,
-0.0079910513,
0.050702516,
0.0019748893,
-0.0716450736,
-0.0023090898,
0.0472784862,
-0.0349926502,
-0.0621752664,
-0.0175349601,
-0.0273766611,
0.0083762771,
0.0167007446,
0.0040455712,
-0.0551221184,
-0.0761431307,
0.0248536486,
-0.039520558,
0.0168915372,
0.0149927363,
0.0392805189,
0.0185742434,
-0.059644144,
0.0140413484,
-0.0362333544,
0.0407221504,
0.0165431742,
0.0147135081,
0.0181458052,
0.0008051464,
-0.0057613519,
0.0797353685,
0.0406113751,
-0.0261313617,
-0.0550027341,
-0.0172947515,
-0.0236278009,
0.0575770698,
-0.0262397025,
0.0064715981,
-0.0305700004,
-0.0281177796,
0.0011693946,
-0.0383624993,
-0.0107175494,
0.0043196068,
2.717e-7,
0.0229566935,
0.055365663,
0.0094519071,
-0.0253028069,
0.027601134,
0.0183998253,
-0.0555483326,
-0.00579945,
0.0341197774,
-0.0278648809,
-0.0064709126,
0.0436086021,
0.0383852422,
0.0063154111,
-0.0435278639,
0.0104735969,
-0.0251246113,
0.0621058606,
-0.0531464294,
0.0010008146,
-0.0227524675,
0.1044882387,
0.0328133628,
-0.0144694699,
-0.0163535122,
0.0025475302,
-0.0022487335,
-0.020241173,
-0.002630054,
0.0528803542,
0.0024572776,
0.016730953,
-0.0238928534,
-0.0027338567,
-0.0464694388,
0.006531355,
-0.0340119377,
0.0610876121,
-0.0236663017,
0.0252652634,
0.0407583416,
-0.0116966357,
-0.0265385248,
-0.0229066573,
0.0458020866,
-0.0460710526,
0.0009754559,
-0.0207528602,
0.0074777463,
-0.0064104334,
0.0010580603,
-0.0210958719,
0.0059598894,
0.0197168253,
0.023089502,
-0.0287424792,
-0.0019263361,
-0.0468518548,
0.0100187752,
-0.0090093678,
-0.0506862625,
-0.0744024292,
-0.0478776693,
0.0069634821,
0.0235155374,
-0.0299497861,
-0.007004498,
2.700526079e-34,
0.0321214274,
-0.0072914138,
0.0430289619,
0.0259631649,
0.0132001517,
-0.030656863,
-0.0277764108,
0.0308244843,
0.0151951984,
-0.0478018932,
-0.0457298756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08166v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08166v1 | MechAgents: Large language model multi-agent collaborations can solve mechanics problems, generate new data, and integrate knowledge | 2023-11-14T13:49:03 | 2023-11-14T13:49:03 | Bo Ni, Markus J. Buehler | cs.AI | cs.AI, cond-mat.dis-nn, cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cs.CL, cs.LG | Solving mechanics problems using numerical methods requires comprehensive
intelligent capability of retrieving relevant knowledge and theory,
constructing and executing codes, analyzing the results, a task that has thus
far mainly been reserved for humans. While emerging AI methods can provide
effective approaches to solve end-to-end problems, for instance via the use of
deep surrogate models or various data analytics strategies, they often lack
physical intuition since knowledge is baked into the parametric complement
through training, offering less flexibility when it comes to incorporating
mathematical or physical insights. By leveraging diverse capabilities of
multiple dynamically interacting large language models (LLMs), we can overcome
the limitations of conventional approaches and develop a new class of
physics-inspired generative machine learning platform, here referred to as
MechAgents. A set of AI agents can solve mechanics tasks, here demonstrated for
elasticity problems, via autonomous collaborations. A two-agent team can
effectively write, execute and self-correct code, in order to apply finite
element methods to solve classical elasticity problems in various flavors
(different boundary conditions, domain geometries, meshes, small/finite
deformation and linear/hyper-elastic constitutive laws, and others). For more
complex tasks, we construct a larger group of agents with enhanced division of
labor among planning, formulating, coding, executing and criticizing the
process and results. The agents mutually correct each other to improve the
overall team-work performance in understanding, formulating and validating the
solution. Our framework shows the potential of synergizing the intelligence of
language models, the reliability of physics-based modeling, and the dynamic
collaborations among diverse agents, opening novel avenues for automation of
solving engineering problems. | [
-0.038139537,
0.0658935681,
-0.0433539189,
0.036968831,
-0.0193057302,
-0.0084813805,
0.0468667597,
-0.0247410648,
-0.0155760711,
0.0203820132,
-0.0033806015,
-0.0513281152,
-0.0432532765,
0.0502973981,
0.0245956313,
-0.0423521772,
-0.0137031144,
-0.0421189666,
0.0255108457,
-0.0448579378,
-0.0168688148,
-0.0245054178,
-0.0390881747,
0.0162544139,
-0.0423281714,
0.0159700159,
-0.0198098663,
-0.0350327604,
0.0306908488,
0.0148379812,
0.0248395018,
0.0837335736,
0.0455398522,
0.0506854206,
0.0000022657,
-0.006375548,
0.0173362643,
0.0259188339,
0.0134989917,
-0.0013987186,
0.0109851742,
-0.0594815984,
-0.0421496779,
-0.0347274095,
-0.0442003496,
0.019137023,
0.0384996496,
-0.0610072985,
0.0377551578,
-0.0230477732,
0.0206282511,
-0.019205125,
0.0245095044,
-0.009703136,
0.0278552379,
-0.0583555959,
0.0080853347,
0.0287632402,
0.0497655012,
-0.0100150965,
-0.0232817885,
0.0293661933,
0.0553668328,
-0.0381133817,
0.011703955,
0.0337312259,
-0.0189422462,
-0.00552662,
-0.0291518979,
0.0489386469,
0.0357192643,
0.0075625293,
0.0024690663,
-0.0113109946,
-0.0149061102,
0.0705027431,
-0.0497041382,
0.0157310721,
0.0275928937,
-0.0170174092,
-0.0467191376,
-0.0387323461,
-0.0082432218,
-0.0229801908,
-0.0341319107,
0.0761692673,
-0.0155387484,
0.042384319,
-0.0312001407,
0.0065894332,
-0.0164713375,
-0.0141142132,
-0.0117017059,
0.0223995894,
-0.0001098338,
-0.0115544936,
-0.0234269872,
-0.0936839357,
0.01703256,
-0.0375026166,
0.0319291539,
0.0115180546,
0.0720632076,
0.0250258781,
-0.070412159,
0.0275600273,
-0.020719612,
0.0022560288,
-0.0316101238,
-0.0128247831,
-0.0590288192,
-0.0272579025,
0.0110128578,
0.0440104082,
-0.0304414723,
-0.0129793584,
-0.0270954333,
0.0340554006,
-0.0478339121,
-0.0251194518,
-0.04234346,
0.0405538566,
0.0117127951,
-0.0455872901,
-0.0288658012,
-0.0031002488,
0.0057433113,
0.0536469035,
0.0254809484,
-0.0149319079,
-0.0096619464,
0.0088588372,
-0.0258510336,
0.0345334075,
0.0009758068,
0.0791240633,
-0.0223040693,
0.0755236894,
0.0480286293,
-0.0432538502,
0.0255937465,
-0.0530375727,
0.0146386987,
-0.0588257834,
0.0351285003,
0.0133271785,
-0.0177402738,
-0.0771837085,
0.0398466848,
-0.0556240864,
0.0012162824,
0.0895323828,
-0.0144263562,
0.0343209058,
0.0453314334,
0.0102420282,
0.0000173177,
0.054106161,
0.0109103862,
0.0105885165,
-0.0239101872,
0.0044663432,
-0.0193765722,
0.0200948957,
-0.0069170753,
0.0279928837,
-0.0368128233,
-0.0422250926,
0.0389265493,
0.0647044852,
-0.0102911433,
0.0156266093,
-0.003017386,
0.0275732223,
0.0424488187,
0.0402808301,
-0.0344143063,
0.0942330435,
0.0298057292,
0.0207618866,
0.0340354554,
-0.0594499186,
0.0441075377,
0.0327881053,
0.014350119,
-0.0224560797,
-0.0045844419,
-0.000714154,
-0.0253424924,
-0.0693848357,
0.0176026896,
-0.0334851183,
0.0140046738,
-0.002556999,
0.071691297,
-0.0104880193,
0.0026456236,
0.003528937,
-0.0088409465,
-0.0277522765,
-0.0321479663,
-0.0067545734,
0.0261846446,
0.0338538513,
0.0277297739,
-0.0554586165,
-0.0840482488,
0.0281915516,
0.0402428098,
0.0042180349,
0.0091158273,
0.0158994328,
-0.0420940742,
-0.0202822778,
0.0001483267,
-0.0090414286,
0.0160384122,
0.0099876644,
-0.0063497489,
-0.030224381,
-0.0145343672,
0.0596763715,
-0.0801783055,
0.0145016452,
-0.0807013065,
0.0169714186,
0.0398831293,
-0.0075666481,
0.0270101763,
-0.0091755474,
-0.018457124,
-0.0193748251,
0.0467092022,
-0.0511856042,
-0.071651943,
0.0265721586,
-0.0059815859,
0.0263464227,
0.0493840761,
-0.080034405,
0.019472165,
-0.022448929,
-0.0173418,
-0.0425282046,
0.0679619834,
-0.0109157143,
-0.0129243834,
-0.0294697825,
-0.018176876,
-0.0060341451,
-0.0127417492,
-0.0077409414,
0.0221807472,
-0.0170365423,
-0.0101247523,
0.0066855769,
0.07202705,
-0.0123397354,
0.0117753893,
-0.0143498639,
0.0449615791,
0.0191713572,
0.0023933598,
0.0356920175,
-0.013699038,
0.0262099858,
-0.0555159599,
-0.0370431356,
-0.0339052081,
0.0326689146,
-0.0079439478,
0.0180022717,
-0.0175602194,
-0.0080823852,
0.0447464399,
0.0391808003,
0.0772760138,
-0.0171483476,
-0.0576278493,
0.0341074206,
0.0259137023,
-0.017594602,
-0.0114415064,
-0.0103004575,
-0.0515428334,
0.037275251,
0.1104604676,
0.0427720435,
-0.0498165973,
-0.0002618747,
-0.0244420301,
0.0267779194,
-0.0165688563,
-0.0892537758,
0.0139126396,
-0.0237465929,
0.0284959301,
0.0454389602,
-0.0503603816,
0.0214828476,
0.0185501054,
-0.0189849436,
-0.0349373333,
0.014408852,
-0.0356722139,
0.0027271553,
-0.0333301015,
-0.0239299927,
0.0041305544,
0.0581999421,
-0.0093616201,
-0.0182083528,
-0.0155237727,
0.0586478822,
0.0135526173,
-0.0397816114,
0.0232060663,
-0.0262353215,
0.0055068447,
0.02029543,
-0.0145390211,
-0.0035228909,
0.0751906186,
0.0275874827,
-0.0346061364,
-0.010243427,
-0.0137329083,
-0.0476803556,
0.0846472308,
0.0241685752,
-0.0156773776,
-0.0083671277,
0.0531822108,
0.0096264649,
0.0751739889,
0.0320033059,
0.0127986372,
-0.0085467352,
-0.0826032013,
0.0182609167,
0.0182540193,
-0.0467935167,
-0.0109339375,
0.0347727388,
-0.0181448739,
0.0462265909,
-0.0123505909,
-0.0888764486,
-0.0020814382,
0.0133009981,
0.0425086729,
0.0001683912,
-0.0171815027,
0.0364328139,
-0.0477189645,
-0.0124242762,
0.0054494576,
0.0511277057,
-0.004342413,
-0.0556032397,
0.0286129788,
0.0219886918,
0.0546908416,
-0.0062160501,
-0.0823279098,
-0.0157435909,
0.0114440704,
0.0351476781,
0.0141252168,
-0.0121398754,
0.0094742943,
-0.059648592,
-0.0108281104,
0.0337592773,
0.0081889415,
-0.0180111565,
-0.0111269802,
0.0077701407,
0.0425302647,
-0.0114275478,
-0.0038967875,
-0.0229652748,
-0.0148886824,
0.0018513385,
-0.0064110137,
-0.0017597121,
-0.0664472729,
0.0309731569,
-0.0852759406,
0.0584521107,
0.0133360261,
0.0019475621,
-0.023307018,
-0.0077431505,
0.0152050061,
-0.0214876346,
-0.0464189686,
-0.000338323,
0.0241831765,
-0.0028586588,
0.0304705575,
-0.0115581276,
-0.0659602582,
-0.0059784055,
-0.050596755,
0.0369697884,
0.0589280874,
0.0044379169,
-0.0755426064,
-0.0524332412,
0.0174983349,
0.0587962158,
0.0203607008,
-0.0265360959,
-0.0351281427,
0.04478788,
0.036869932,
0.0137625122,
0.0483607501,
-0.0649984851,
-0.0093599157,
0.0038698681,
0.0856477991,
-0.030499896,
0.0181626771,
-0.0431317128,
-0.0461000912,
0.0342676863,
0.0141055891,
-0.0279091671,
-0.0580355711,
-0.0571967177,
-0.0638999045,
-0.0293755736,
-0.0225183349,
-0.0420899354,
-0.0336788855,
0.0191858765,
-0.0162625071,
-0.0146801742,
0.0222474653,
0.0503562912,
0.0190315749,
0.0037057237,
-0.0252802391,
0.0263568237,
0.0244602244,
-0.0259362794,
-0.0286818929,
-0.0021834043,
0.0183240846,
-0.0022807124,
-0.0255034082,
0.0598268211,
-0.0414773524,
-0.0073728226,
0.0163529906,
-0.0305533465,
-0.0826296657,
0.0144475354,
0.0689677298,
0.014468913,
0.012922571,
-0.0433288515,
-0.0419792794,
0.0548534356,
0.0428474396,
-0.0959578454,
0.0012228695,
0.0061899535,
-0.0197427981,
0.0082683749,
-0.0162255876,
0.0165600572,
0.0299547911,
-0.012043572,
-0.0126076322,
-0.0651089773,
-0.0815889016,
0.0148055283,
0.0391258635,
-0.0018738688,
0.0037042156,
-0.0318849422,
-0.0331032574,
0.0226463303,
0.0054956153,
-0.018831782,
-0.0489671528,
0.0081814742,
-0.011824294,
-0.0649632961,
0.036148902,
0.018796619,
0.0832060874,
0.0547025986,
0.0050605857,
0.1186406314,
-0.009526467,
0.0624652132,
0.0342417806,
0.0265725739,
0.0508825257,
0.0257181562,
-0.0193280168,
0.0386573747,
-0.0126569169,
-0.0154483588,
0.0450808927,
0.0029202721,
-0.0329814889,
0.0096005676,
-0.0514538884,
-0.0916526467,
-0.0233442076,
0.0077742226,
0.0356675424,
0.0807572305,
-0.0218467098,
-0.0798446462,
0.0085624717,
-0.0054061506,
0.0256933626,
0.0009853834,
0.0239801016,
0.0401663929,
-0.005883629,
0.0124416845,
-0.0330302194,
0.0459374748,
-0.0205305796,
0.0309908595,
-0.0181763209,
-0.0118475938,
-0.0220102146,
-0.000974478,
0.0299325213,
-0.0248833057,
-0.0225194469,
0.0001814092,
-0.0106125856,
-0.0097282231,
0.0118818525,
0.0582516864,
-0.0105200019,
-0.0128716389,
0.0430625565,
0.0798226148,
-0.0462403037,
0.0091762654,
-0.0037573248,
0.0054339948,
-0.0425462872,
-0.0047014053,
0.009179296,
-5.647475264e-33,
-0.0039256494,
-0.0053737573,
-0.0042756442,
0.0078011877,
-0.0109839477,
0.0029532579,
-0.0311186239,
-0.0269995835,
0.0022038224,
0.0355157182,
-0.0058242558,
0.0155454641,
-0.029795466,
-0.0408676341,
0.0754870176,
-0.0010427908,
0.0302222464,
-0.027809063,
0.0243992396,
0.0112879854,
-0.036626339,
0.0266912561,
-0.0041246116,
-0.0662911534,
0.0300046504,
-0.0259293318,
-0.0311784297,
0.0245394334,
-0.0057543362,
0.0148184849,
-0.0137542617,
0.0299135204,
-0.0514306799,
-0.0388483964,
-0.0320390426,
-0.0119124176,
-0.0594444238,
-0.0359610394,
-0.025119001,
-0.0203203149,
-0.0592004322,
-0.0353126228,
0.0529895201,
0.0267436225,
-0.0815706849,
-0.0167138819,
0.0398258083,
-0.0348475464,
0.0377604701,
-0.007578175,
-0.0396367274,
0.002875786,
-0.0143896583,
-0.0106569557,
0.0501434579,
-0.0184793342,
0.0038202186,
-0.0003270689,
-0.0341770835,
0.0434500016,
-0.0138308443,
-0.0112571269,
0.0495897532,
-0.0138600813,
0.0591264814,
0.0482066795,
0.0466075838,
-0.0252939221,
-0.0575746633,
0.0186974276,
0.0271298345,
0.0758919716,
0.05102624,
0.0632042661,
-0.0183546152,
0.0023195397,
-0.0883585289,
0.0122052357,
0.0117420526,
0.027302172,
0.0105518056,
0.0358535573,
0.0026323528,
-0.0155418934,
-0.0114882607,
0.0040404792,
0.0435101502,
-0.0290597174,
-0.0574826114,
-0.0173551794,
0.0038078777,
-0.0325013213,
0.0101002958,
-0.0586095788,
0.0503488407,
0.0110363364,
0.0269781072,
0.0258278586,
0.0050739371,
0.0497181937,
-0.0676669553,
0.0137842195,
-0.0585382991,
0.0085930275,
0.0258721318,
0.0208661854,
-0.0081476187,
0.0565251298,
0.020518899,
0.0148087749,
-0.0417433083,
0.0032551633,
0.0375531465,
0.0040827249,
0.0388241298,
0.0074692676,
-0.0007063626,
-0.025502786,
0.0094254427,
0.0065917969,
-0.0180017985,
0.0349206738,
-0.0489412621,
0.0016925615,
-0.0484773517,
-0.0386703946,
-0.0239331704,
0.0046297857,
0.0311264917,
-0.0564754494,
-0.030621808,
0.048271127,
3.011e-7,
0.0001666167,
0.0496230349,
0.0302492045,
0.0066746911,
0.028344145,
0.0421875268,
-0.0461640581,
-0.0016384978,
-0.0049309102,
0.0194695052,
0.052613005,
0.0611173585,
0.0573549829,
-0.0030011251,
-0.1061830223,
0.0068032439,
0.0032647105,
0.0012262535,
-0.0657509491,
-0.0187043324,
-0.005177944,
0.0262274873,
0.0451812595,
0.0054811765,
0.0388293713,
-0.0345470421,
0.0136693222,
-0.0235857908,
0.0379846059,
0.0592277944,
-0.0282524079,
-0.0159034729,
-0.0443315171,
0.0318371505,
-0.0068515912,
-0.0073411404,
0.0033824721,
0.0028942653,
0.0039920094,
0.0465534553,
0.0309246443,
-0.0196142569,
0.0301370174,
-0.0141313998,
0.0077085621,
-0.0514491349,
0.0034488307,
0.0066987509,
0.0008157958,
-0.0351086073,
0.0311074983,
-0.0119910976,
0.0655453056,
-0.0329056121,
0.0009764793,
0.0007105884,
0.0026486507,
-0.0399924591,
0.0247211028,
0.0380931571,
-0.0905725807,
-0.0192751344,
0.0213930216,
-0.0108068949,
0.0301190875,
-0.0363403372,
0.0346784629,
2.527846419e-34,
-0.0061483099,
0.007367258,
-0.0102143837,
0.0800537691,
0.0210739784,
-0.0021142161,
-0.0125085199,
0.0136601403,
0.0410311557,
-0.0533906668,
-0.0377934203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08154v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08154v3 | Just Ask One More Time! Self-Agreement Improves Reasoning of Language Models in (Almost) All Scenarios | 2023-11-14T13:30:54 | 2024-05-24T14:11:21 | Lei Lin, Jiayi Fu, Pengli Liu, Qingyang Li, Yan Gong, Junchen Wan, Fuzheng Zhang, Zhongyuan Wang, Di Zhang, Kun Gai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Although chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting combined with language models has
achieved encouraging results on complex reasoning tasks, the naive greedy
decoding used in CoT prompting usually causes the repetitiveness and local
optimality. To address this shortcoming, ensemble-optimization tries to obtain
multiple reasoning paths to get the final answer assembly. However, current
ensemble-optimization methods either simply employ rule-based post-processing
such as \textit{self-consistency}, or train an additional model based on
several task-related human annotations to select the best one among multiple
reasoning paths, yet fail to generalize to realistic settings where the type of
input questions is unknown or the answer format of reasoning paths is unknown.
To avoid their limitations, we propose \textbf{Self-Agreement}, a generalizable
ensemble-optimization method applying in almost all scenarios where the type of
input questions and the answer format of reasoning paths may be known or
unknown. Self-agreement firstly samples from language model's decoder to
generate a \textit{diverse} set of reasoning paths, and subsequently prompts
the language model \textit{one more time} to determine the optimal answer by
selecting the most \textit{agreed} answer among the sampled reasoning paths.
Self-agreement simultaneously achieves remarkable performance on six public
reasoning benchmarks and superior generalization capabilities. | [
0.0437209755,
0.0416659676,
0.0099707954,
0.0419894606,
-0.0636990666,
0.0291134492,
0.0046503879,
-0.0519508459,
0.0150489863,
-0.0310199745,
-0.0149227837,
-0.016595047,
-0.0022648394,
-0.041351676,
0.0115130125,
-0.0303258188,
0.0546295978,
-0.0453146286,
0.010080439,
-0.0598993562,
-0.0073882318,
-0.0141065195,
-0.0452931188,
0.0320434459,
-0.0028716207,
-0.0372403637,
-0.0288401563,
-0.036861483,
0.0096851848,
-0.0204005055,
-0.0035895852,
0.1043857113,
-0.0056934645,
0.0260543004,
0.0000021431,
-0.0563916005,
-0.0143681886,
-0.0358421393,
-0.0549792051,
-0.0364274904,
-0.0630568489,
0.0716461763,
0.0345824175,
0.0462452397,
-0.0340807214,
-0.0042118998,
0.0406358019,
0.0375915803,
0.069236815,
0.0398628749,
0.0387758128,
-0.0277192909,
-0.0077008666,
-0.0084450664,
-0.0015277135,
-0.0411105081,
0.0061306464,
0.0088753421,
0.0071916212,
0.0159189738,
-0.0119198961,
0.0441162623,
0.0289158709,
-0.0128927343,
0.0021762003,
0.0436008573,
-0.0443200581,
-0.026224291,
-0.0288942754,
0.0791498348,
0.0416645855,
-0.0261031687,
-0.0255277157,
0.0026721875,
0.0108442353,
-0.0222654026,
-0.0145251406,
0.0470565446,
-0.0196465217,
0.0135958297,
0.005673802,
0.0619615428,
0.0026299795,
0.0136898933,
-0.0432925001,
0.1394854188,
-0.0123490142,
-0.0212237015,
0.0387119614,
0.0460548326,
-0.0281119216,
-0.0764635727,
0.0043248981,
0.0412824489,
-0.0431005359,
0.0366229005,
-0.0075874706,
-0.0386934765,
0.010994494,
0.0241234303,
0.0373154469,
0.0436731316,
-0.0079161087,
0.0667264238,
0.0153206559,
0.0261448398,
-0.0244031157,
-0.0145129245,
-0.0540634841,
-0.0234139878,
-0.056628,
-0.0051599755,
-0.0315080509,
0.0751003176,
0.0162861906,
0.0028378924,
-0.0389468074,
0.0219589546,
-0.0061379545,
0.0414829291,
0.0550904423,
0.0241726544,
0.0149699422,
-0.035790313,
-0.0217910632,
0.0437699519,
-0.0490028299,
0.0124302972,
0.0551022515,
-0.0265782923,
-0.0114591299,
0.0057865535,
0.0003684697,
-0.0088784127,
0.0047464771,
0.0188547391,
-0.0228535179,
0.0119544491,
0.0129942205,
-0.0211935379,
-0.0385929011,
-0.0703624636,
-0.0299549419,
-0.0662191063,
0.0707817897,
0.0263465922,
-0.0280276407,
-0.0199479107,
-0.0026123002,
0.0156528689,
0.0143401921,
0.056944415,
0.0070983856,
0.0119059589,
0.0608740859,
-0.0063230069,
-0.0201959703,
0.078736037,
0.0263682995,
0.0283159129,
0.0220671911,
0.0058213994,
0.0242864322,
0.0448721759,
0.0285378546,
-0.0394725241,
0.0337397195,
0.0528107323,
-0.0248578973,
0.0311590806,
-0.0051492159,
0.0594140738,
-0.0403131358,
-0.0418525748,
0.0334019847,
0.0625319257,
-0.0015297059,
-0.0297947191,
-0.0117191831,
-0.0015947757,
0.0333395228,
0.0275302567,
-0.0341489948,
0.0633098185,
-0.0587164387,
0.0044910619,
0.0431291759,
0.0297177695,
-0.0333739519,
-0.0543300919,
-0.017766254,
-0.0052102995,
-0.0047135982,
0.0650864765,
0.0391861163,
-0.0151845608,
-0.0138288541,
0.039728187,
0.0136392992,
-0.0283934232,
-0.031408444,
-0.0390545167,
0.0823844969,
0.0101035666,
0.0332483873,
-0.0101590464,
-0.0370729901,
-0.0203057919,
0.0063360459,
0.0289011355,
0.0189717822,
-0.0288222916,
0.0089367535,
-0.0418151878,
-0.0237944145,
0.042458836,
-0.0093810288,
0.0109010264,
0.0040958095,
-0.0228378586,
-0.0305480454,
-0.0059587369,
0.0082872687,
0.0215864629,
0.0007922871,
-0.0117856003,
0.0131222941,
0.0162125956,
0.0312657431,
0.0209753197,
-0.0040125432,
0.0282474738,
-0.0015165341,
-0.0198939964,
-0.0635864809,
0.0046000201,
-0.0920775458,
-0.0858588219,
0.0332516842,
0.003304143,
-0.0625523478,
-0.0055835205,
-0.0399731845,
-0.0493600257,
0.0209553689,
-0.0194218736,
-0.0108971838,
-0.0398643501,
0.0156671926,
0.0082092155,
-0.0268102717,
-0.0603351593,
0.071388416,
-0.0245976616,
-0.0125842439,
-0.0326466225,
-0.006639244,
0.0526379161,
-0.0440664589,
-0.0343205482,
0.0342973806,
-0.0118569192,
0.0017399105,
0.0555539839,
-0.0184476525,
-0.0763591975,
-0.0362876393,
-0.0851660147,
-0.0052342825,
-0.019625742,
0.0079145422,
-0.0009229563,
0.0034353221,
0.0048328382,
-0.0357766151,
-0.0690038279,
0.0278800502,
0.0062224763,
0.0007492587,
0.02647865,
-0.0157671962,
0.0242141448,
-0.0238844622,
-0.0104149682,
-0.0174527708,
0.0382479802,
0.0020287375,
-0.0137932999,
-0.0641943216,
-0.0060899621,
-0.0634661466,
0.0252631567,
0.0062045921,
0.0022003902,
0.0512999557,
-0.0081389314,
0.027640868,
0.0877319798,
0.0096461941,
-0.0394266918,
0.0659096763,
0.0215001609,
-0.1052540615,
0.0253306963,
-0.0118050007,
-0.0096003627,
0.0162684228,
-0.0176855829,
0.0186356269,
0.0771869272,
0.030323308,
-0.026846854,
-0.0560877472,
0.0055452748,
-0.0073642666,
-0.0492814519,
-0.0686662123,
-0.0457882993,
-0.0018722604,
0.0486098826,
0.0066095353,
-0.01854649,
0.1104531512,
-0.019231258,
-0.0062777572,
-0.0682934001,
0.0307677817,
-0.0335785858,
0.0706419051,
-0.0145129496,
0.0116880462,
0.0668982267,
-0.014399956,
-0.0416972712,
-0.0342691503,
0.0346311145,
-0.0667603984,
0.0379483327,
-0.0291459393,
0.0156071866,
0.0008539396,
-0.0717654601,
-0.0639557391,
-0.003302855,
-0.0365537219,
-0.0043625021,
-0.0029950636,
-0.0067223264,
0.0003005198,
-0.0114335837,
0.0420015641,
0.0113653708,
-0.0358211212,
-0.0111759929,
0.0058888383,
0.0517075099,
0.0474810041,
0.0489372574,
0.0219054967,
0.0000104237,
0.0532418452,
0.0716855377,
0.0521315522,
0.0124789178,
-0.0270163342,
0.0029250886,
0.0325576402,
-0.0270022545,
-0.015215667,
0.0222182665,
0.0566825904,
-0.0376703143,
-0.005714782,
0.1163302362,
0.060727261,
-0.0432943515,
-0.0221992787,
-0.0602648854,
0.0267222337,
0.0097467424,
0.0587375537,
-0.0471832007,
-0.0371787772,
0.007361108,
0.0103935115,
0.000534189,
-0.0501506552,
-0.0127498452,
-0.0830240846,
0.0180791002,
-0.0053933072,
-0.0219140518,
0.0347859785,
-0.0291698705,
0.0168583654,
-0.0303169917,
0.0120610241,
0.0363977998,
0.0460693538,
0.0188848935,
0.040729627,
-0.0486334488,
-0.0199850928,
0.0292537753,
-0.0496675707,
0.0719140023,
0.0820939541,
-0.0184713807,
0.013709791,
-0.0232447479,
0.0112154782,
-0.0232439693,
0.0000336264,
-0.0231819265,
0.0333182067,
0.011393806,
0.0069506862,
-0.0272769015,
0.0367307402,
-0.0203605555,
0.0072324635,
0.0516995005,
0.0921845138,
-0.0360327847,
-0.0104448413,
-0.0098530091,
0.0110447407,
0.0037955679,
0.0867562443,
0.0240915567,
-0.0436854511,
-0.014449494,
-0.0440399237,
-0.0219510235,
-0.0784115195,
-0.0148847373,
0.0232662894,
0.0644860491,
0.0138966972,
-0.0707911551,
-0.0689737499,
0.0587253384,
0.0523852631,
-0.0355356708,
0.0257483199,
0.0412741564,
0.0276717357,
-0.016185537,
0.0025856467,
-0.0314561315,
-0.0202705842,
-0.0346090347,
0.0108214105,
0.0215657353,
-0.0116030937,
-0.0159343444,
0.0278909989,
-0.0465262011,
-0.077925846,
-0.0008630005,
0.0442952365,
0.0199648794,
0.039074678,
-0.0167703051,
-0.0592380017,
0.0131206019,
-0.0081146285,
0.0313363858,
0.0048472593,
0.0159906391,
-0.0085219368,
-0.0127546126,
0.0396015868,
-0.019595908,
0.0382205956,
0.020399401,
0.0454908535,
-0.0212927442,
-0.0382056162,
0.0717258453,
0.0544331111,
-0.0106730303,
-0.013794112,
0.0125743216,
-0.0037790632,
0.0295354407,
-0.0080753695,
-0.0450866409,
-0.0186651852,
0.0103148874,
0.005818699,
-0.0886296406,
0.0121772019,
-0.0199555382,
0.0008095398,
0.0062228884,
-0.0031120416,
-0.0185081046,
0.005999872,
0.0352574475,
-0.003116233,
-0.0161411054,
-0.0309808478,
-0.010255212,
0.0230630506,
0.0468968377,
-0.0024909403,
0.0761829913,
0.051387649,
-0.0250257067,
-0.0076974751,
0.0177415237,
-0.0593977235,
-0.051724676,
0.0149018848,
0.0050966758,
0.0294530336,
0.0180782098,
0.0034870536,
-0.0102833938,
0.0024822578,
-0.0063326336,
0.0108695459,
0.0107895676,
-0.0176567882,
0.0307882037,
0.0252301507,
-0.0011152065,
0.0055945958,
0.0524056479,
-0.0646701679,
-0.010978655,
0.0020733036,
0.0285958182,
-0.0588804893,
-0.0046263551,
-0.0666100159,
-0.0050989273,
-0.0488118157,
0.0325287022,
-0.0288101435,
-0.039575465,
0.0044634007,
0.0277479701,
-0.0028327401,
0.0130891772,
0.0210191514,
0.0600762591,
-0.0044083749,
-0.0322713293,
-0.0030332378,
0.0292116106,
-0.0338758789,
-0.0166114755,
-0.0353550464,
-6.566592828e-33,
-0.025382122,
-0.0142499972,
0.0448887385,
-0.0530107543,
0.0104630906,
-0.0464321673,
-0.0413970686,
0.0396444984,
-0.0448350869,
-0.0121791866,
-0.0512714908,
-0.0106185284,
0.0034549753,
0.0375446007,
0.0427415632,
0.0001292509,
0.0044702734,
-0.0368945487,
-0.0619943216,
-0.005399954,
0.0474466868,
-0.011802271,
0.0105624106,
-0.0401140228,
0.0136069097,
-0.003113914,
-0.0066073933,
0.0429026596,
-0.0395491831,
0.0455758795,
-0.0271813627,
-0.010043731,
0.0228866935,
-0.0521897338,
-0.0132008111,
0.0192955453,
-0.0740595162,
-0.067875281,
0.0075736563,
-0.0040365248,
-0.0696967468,
0.0050723478,
-0.0029795694,
-0.0223006047,
-0.005230403,
-0.017860679,
-0.009434389,
-0.0113764787,
-0.0005385882,
0.0153929526,
-0.009642561,
0.0054884427,
-0.0134780202,
-0.0177064054,
0.0015935154,
0.0757781714,
-0.0156931989,
0.0225236006,
-0.0354877673,
0.0324130654,
-0.0096077332,
-0.000792078,
0.0833793581,
0.0051540127,
-0.0202595107,
0.0455116406,
0.0259308517,
-0.043613784,
-0.0630106032,
-0.0352342874,
-0.0151891932,
0.0302874092,
0.0697108358,
0.0182744823,
-0.0093278456,
0.0410973355,
-0.0550240539,
0.0398955792,
0.0488683693,
-0.0089056855,
0.0215912201,
-0.0020384339,
-0.0593651943,
-0.0233594347,
-0.0528448224,
0.0077470392,
-0.0425781272,
-0.0246446729,
0.0402077958,
-0.017390836,
-0.0275940839,
-0.0401101969,
0.0382782705,
-0.0212040786,
-0.0265664812,
0.0244468283,
0.0272242315,
0.0254028644,
0.0173800625,
0.0479991473,
-0.0368744656,
0.0545814708,
-0.0046036271,
0.0030035598,
-0.0054233703,
0.041084446,
0.0507609062,
-0.0011500895,
-0.044225283,
-0.0097885281,
-0.0459607653,
0.009734598,
-0.016624907,
-0.0161428656,
0.0282453615,
0.0408351943,
-0.0173891149,
0.0288775414,
-0.0009442436,
-0.0105559463,
-0.056973353,
-0.0014587691,
0.0118671674,
0.0283039976,
0.0003481326,
0.021884026,
0.0054065022,
-0.0177945942,
-0.0061198571,
-0.0064578964,
-0.0029224218,
0.0498148724,
2.741e-7,
0.0420213118,
0.0281591266,
0.0241645873,
0.0025983581,
-0.0055295611,
0.0375385284,
-0.0460117832,
-0.0120980944,
0.0181358829,
-0.0489971153,
0.0070672599,
0.0468292981,
0.0369022749,
0.0348329693,
-0.0507567823,
-0.0032515542,
-0.0381379388,
0.0146488212,
-0.0102879964,
-0.0139314635,
0.0488515832,
0.0767146945,
0.0065538874,
0.0125485202,
-0.037557479,
0.0076481225,
0.0487935357,
-0.0025592169,
0.014012266,
0.028591156,
0.0392509736,
-0.0383838713,
0.0143882437,
0.0347500369,
0.0157543458,
0.0110442471,
-0.0175719839,
0.0222078525,
-0.0067263856,
-0.040013101,
-0.0356429033,
-0.0067159734,
0.0310088489,
-0.0686191842,
0.0747028664,
-0.074249357,
-0.0397273712,
-0.0409941077,
0.0206161886,
0.0143479202,
0.0258675534,
0.0173653439,
0.0088202721,
0.0030043295,
0.0146342674,
0.0009258713,
0.0150464997,
-0.0791849941,
-0.0306779183,
-0.0079455441,
-0.047360193,
-0.0167954918,
-0.0137155596,
0.0242668688,
0.0213236976,
-0.0746887103,
-0.0264953617,
2.274824933e-34,
0.017063275,
-0.026789818,
0.0201362856,
0.0542444773,
0.0058439649,
-0.0241699275,
-0.0239844844,
0.0134966001,
0.028741248,
-0.0939510465,
-0.0250150319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08152v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08152v2 | Towards Reasoning in Large Language Models via Multi-Agent Peer Review Collaboration | 2023-11-14T13:27:07 | 2023-12-17T13:02:27 | Zhenran Xu, Senbao Shi, Baotian Hu, Jindi Yu, Dongfang Li, Min Zhang, Yuxiang Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in general
natural language processing tasks but often fall short in complex reasoning
tasks. Recent studies have explored human-like problem-solving strategies, such
as self-correct, to push further the boundary of single-model reasoning
ability. In this work, we let a single model "step outside the box" by engaging
multiple models to correct each other. We introduce a multi-agent collaboration
strategy that emulates the academic peer review process. Each agent
independently constructs its own solution, provides reviews on the solutions of
others, and assigns confidence levels to its reviews. Upon receiving peer
reviews, agents revise their initial solutions. Extensive experiments on three
different types of reasoning tasks show that our collaboration approach
delivers superior accuracy across all ten datasets compared to existing
methods. Further study underscores the effectiveness of integrating confidence
in reviews, demonstrates the superiority of feedback exchange over mere
solution sharing, and highlights the role of capability and diversity in
fostering successful collaboration. | [
0.0689967349,
0.0460655391,
-0.0138603467,
0.0373427756,
-0.0838015079,
-0.0086907977,
0.051472038,
-0.0383720845,
-0.0081100147,
-0.031231055,
-0.0429488569,
-0.0207323544,
0.0133072753,
0.023555737,
-0.0088323429,
-0.0295715444,
0.0079176659,
-0.0561073087,
0.0716086179,
-0.0457940139,
-0.0084645767,
0.0113231223,
-0.0258960947,
0.03716949,
0.0094122663,
-0.0253911931,
-0.006670922,
-0.0540429354,
-0.013444392,
0.0089739002,
-0.0140335141,
0.093892917,
0.0154198958,
0.0518868975,
0.0000017973,
-0.0540829264,
-0.0071928785,
0.0116481287,
-0.0349898115,
0.0038618946,
0.0146442978,
0.0311212912,
0.00119119,
0.0155354599,
-0.0430519916,
0.0048640743,
0.0107607236,
0.0300395079,
0.0579145476,
0.0278599802,
0.0293970034,
-0.0132856006,
-0.0187507123,
0.0015091513,
-0.0099318018,
-0.05154562,
0.0314503685,
0.0737580955,
0.0571963005,
0.0268376339,
-0.002240258,
0.0364268161,
0.0358604603,
-0.0603178851,
0.0122157121,
0.0338060409,
-0.0178050343,
-0.0377801023,
0.0026220742,
0.038932804,
0.0439852588,
-0.007601561,
-0.029746715,
0.0126173673,
0.0002313758,
0.0797283351,
-0.0524327271,
0.0537625998,
-0.0104009053,
0.0189153645,
-0.0181499142,
-0.0211720634,
0.0368344188,
0.0268329177,
0.0012699886,
0.1214201301,
-0.0139889792,
-0.0125200562,
0.0011242327,
0.0507420413,
-0.0139671154,
-0.0488967635,
0.0047403155,
0.0224160161,
-0.0531274676,
0.0178539436,
0.021417575,
0.0004917717,
0.0219198074,
-0.0262056328,
0.0399193577,
-0.0172851253,
0.0320994891,
0.0796952769,
-0.0222282149,
-0.0017945985,
0.0039043864,
0.0368513688,
0.0001912017,
-0.0230515134,
-0.1009513661,
-0.0165472347,
-0.0091296565,
0.0370353684,
-0.0000387256,
-0.001489916,
-0.0378481485,
0.0103392936,
-0.0309791695,
0.0235601682,
0.033339154,
0.0573090911,
0.0121196201,
-0.0449826643,
-0.0496313833,
0.0508735701,
-0.0068882573,
0.031576667,
-0.0087474305,
-0.0398130231,
0.0047764517,
-0.0309355557,
-0.0028534019,
-0.0028446489,
0.0018175745,
0.025027182,
-0.0017048469,
0.0094111552,
0.014576491,
-0.0644043013,
-0.0127553027,
-0.0862594396,
-0.0294802375,
-0.0862057954,
0.007638305,
0.0208085291,
-0.0100566475,
-0.0430290699,
0.0285470616,
-0.0307137072,
-0.0229543541,
0.1120550334,
-0.0413763672,
0.0501880087,
0.0381388627,
0.0401611067,
-0.0369126983,
0.0405469984,
0.0289079398,
-0.0017922064,
0.0298647154,
0.0180146713,
0.0422882326,
0.0067528822,
-0.010209945,
0.0033070282,
0.0160083622,
0.0004798037,
-0.0303399004,
0.0394925065,
-0.0443232097,
0.0595083013,
-0.0130608669,
-0.0080204951,
0.0914599523,
0.0645016581,
-0.0166247524,
0.0209903605,
-0.017689079,
0.0030034678,
0.0167155359,
-0.0247325897,
-0.0243497863,
0.0529711097,
0.0116163483,
-0.0171051864,
0.0255669877,
0.0051986245,
-0.0153129082,
-0.0406263247,
-0.024733562,
0.012904739,
-0.0247544143,
0.03453812,
0.0502000451,
-0.0066569564,
0.0098561952,
0.0142225726,
0.0131126894,
-0.046970021,
0.0106230313,
-0.0584721044,
0.0752267838,
0.0581879765,
0.0687809587,
-0.005269018,
-0.0209751017,
-0.0084570721,
-0.0063063116,
0.0088809924,
0.0466328785,
-0.0171454139,
-0.0506835356,
-0.0285212621,
-0.0571211725,
0.0179066956,
-0.006103693,
0.0050067347,
0.023912875,
-0.0245747622,
-0.0102385562,
-0.0041867374,
-0.0298396014,
0.0029136357,
-0.0346003063,
0.0363893807,
-0.013131842,
0.0021344332,
0.0260574501,
0.0293766055,
-0.0297198929,
0.0422123484,
0.0164045151,
0.0013782573,
-0.0983914137,
0.037414372,
-0.0022892293,
0.0070344587,
0.0289734919,
-0.0402013287,
-0.0292340182,
-0.0048537189,
0.003326531,
-0.0393890254,
0.0518946908,
0.0071794246,
0.0112411985,
-0.0214953814,
0.0091845607,
-0.023899721,
-0.0246051811,
-0.0114216991,
0.0412000753,
0.010151973,
-0.0035507937,
0.0076474668,
0.0203968659,
0.0018280287,
-0.0027345279,
-0.0101120677,
0.0391234085,
0.0514809601,
0.00633995,
0.0376363099,
-0.0422461033,
-0.0469709523,
-0.0370012,
-0.0539861731,
-0.0271254294,
0.0061645284,
0.0147144413,
0.0091779595,
-0.041712556,
0.0187718999,
-0.0046727215,
-0.0280689858,
0.0248107184,
0.0290108379,
0.0273584668,
0.0252781678,
0.0250143129,
-0.0239956416,
-0.0319056027,
-0.0074220379,
-0.0365685746,
0.0411746204,
0.0778777227,
0.014846636,
-0.0680777356,
0.0146354083,
-0.0610659532,
0.0224091839,
0.0161215775,
-0.0142735811,
0.0496471003,
-0.0109798722,
-0.0118767293,
0.0486243851,
-0.0272372626,
0.0062062107,
0.0907151178,
-0.0367332809,
-0.0695888475,
-0.0031779425,
-0.0065779751,
-0.0166126229,
-0.0236180648,
-0.0194081794,
-0.0408229791,
0.0335125923,
0.0162947159,
-0.052687984,
-0.0197257269,
0.0588079542,
-0.0065073944,
-0.0215677116,
-0.0267747398,
-0.0762187093,
0.0156356618,
0.0442509837,
-0.039661523,
-0.0235694684,
0.0999005362,
-0.0248523355,
-0.0115710525,
-0.0257354397,
-0.000374468,
-0.0510262288,
0.0962054878,
-0.0318929628,
0.000241781,
-0.0276122782,
0.017233599,
-0.0130784381,
-0.0188491736,
0.0623105913,
-0.0140309948,
0.0311992224,
-0.0889028162,
0.0173883066,
0.0042385114,
-0.0295714978,
-0.0159976408,
-0.0380909294,
-0.0740324259,
0.0435256772,
-0.0160831697,
-0.02527868,
-0.0693864673,
0.016344903,
0.0382035151,
0.0064245528,
-0.0191210099,
-0.0229285788,
-0.0238407906,
-0.026358271,
0.0020455092,
0.0029656284,
0.0509373434,
-0.0441371165,
0.0453469232,
0.07746429,
0.0358592197,
0.0071617928,
-0.0510615706,
-0.0299724136,
0.0052522207,
-0.0180712659,
-0.0035525067,
-0.0158953741,
0.0331089683,
-0.069053933,
0.0040729539,
0.1044932753,
0.0437471941,
-0.0747108161,
-0.0262836535,
-0.0481868386,
-0.0107376399,
0.033777386,
0.0239733066,
-0.0463507213,
-0.0123954052,
0.0127090216,
-0.0141786458,
0.000248849,
-0.0597687587,
-0.0027479499,
-0.1104657575,
0.0573732667,
0.0052426942,
0.0138401296,
0.0001188784,
-0.046706222,
0.00987163,
-0.0108392751,
-0.005376704,
0.0267327335,
0.0281013604,
0.0072039855,
0.0131004555,
0.010813687,
-0.0300557725,
0.066551052,
-0.059735395,
0.1011823416,
0.0429670289,
0.0145054767,
0.009595654,
-0.0388811119,
0.0092895962,
0.0407225527,
0.0212770253,
0.0172046218,
0.011320347,
0.0088163977,
0.0086490707,
-0.0063734804,
0.0081453584,
-0.0539452583,
-0.0154043529,
0.0300755054,
0.0963648632,
-0.0245737992,
-0.0232550967,
-0.0131714987,
0.0265884362,
-0.0260293428,
0.063691251,
0.0005729365,
0.0033501408,
-0.0316602103,
-0.0142541677,
-0.0523830839,
-0.0117252246,
-0.0452691652,
0.0163209029,
0.0105165346,
0.0028626849,
-0.0328248031,
-0.0246329363,
0.0710130408,
0.0165353753,
0.0152718788,
0.0100763505,
0.035604354,
0.0320693031,
0.025986135,
0.0239967424,
-0.0452027917,
0.0335114039,
-0.0277973227,
0.0056616892,
0.0075702057,
-0.0090985764,
0.0069972966,
-0.006115241,
-0.048711583,
-0.0818063095,
-0.0175337885,
0.0475595482,
0.0289522596,
0.0012317697,
-0.0282305647,
-0.0890371054,
-0.0036246588,
-0.0324463956,
-0.0331422985,
-0.019320365,
0.0051083434,
-0.0133038573,
0.0083343536,
0.0356216766,
-0.0066333427,
0.0203117412,
0.0217377748,
0.0167578291,
-0.0458835848,
-0.0670347437,
0.0319496356,
0.0092107216,
0.0169827025,
0.0197020695,
0.0260821208,
-0.0353657082,
0.0260717757,
-0.0311447866,
-0.044914335,
-0.0110103982,
0.0154826595,
-0.0121842576,
-0.0458473563,
0.0376993753,
0.0082928492,
-0.0042849374,
0.0314106569,
-0.0070942524,
0.0406446904,
0.042568367,
0.0039859028,
0.0134557048,
0.0000825729,
0.0022574267,
-0.0078129275,
0.0069439881,
0.0241177287,
0.0133489398,
0.0518371575,
0.0048028613,
-0.0267523285,
-0.0327131562,
-0.0108648557,
-0.1154664233,
-0.0734918416,
0.0469996668,
0.0408342108,
0.0304415636,
0.0665679723,
0.001725234,
-0.0586110167,
-0.0008609861,
-0.0044822083,
0.0112210587,
0.0021203691,
-0.013172823,
0.0241020247,
0.0212258808,
-0.0057744007,
-0.0110400803,
0.0524589159,
-0.0296426266,
0.035214711,
-0.0202534702,
-0.0588548221,
-0.0102313329,
-0.0450715646,
-0.0357304811,
-0.0015119202,
-0.0268827882,
0.0234534405,
-0.0398525484,
-0.0488568246,
-0.0091787903,
0.0475826636,
0.0034042413,
-0.0133287255,
-0.0212920327,
0.0638972968,
0.0056435531,
-0.0349956788,
-0.04812859,
0.0026670475,
-0.023162866,
0.0179532524,
-0.0395313464,
-5.983248246e-33,
-0.0190820787,
-0.0694697946,
0.0417371206,
-0.0174619015,
0.0267129913,
-0.012395747,
-0.0500847548,
0.0376441441,
0.0051949648,
0.0577481091,
-0.0343823619,
0.0268171486,
0.0158067476,
-0.0276651103,
0.0794485956,
0.0170863979,
0.0489360839,
-0.0063447761,
-0.0093223583,
-0.0149017069,
0.0194675997,
-0.0005171204,
0.037538901,
-0.070889622,
0.0534392595,
0.0202341806,
-0.02736656,
0.0618580207,
-0.0765368342,
0.0403971411,
0.0109027578,
0.0176504403,
0.0163233541,
-0.04868057,
-0.020140063,
-0.0209037513,
-0.0372251049,
0.0072804936,
0.0396695063,
-0.0085053826,
-0.0256624948,
-0.0012070386,
0.0305809136,
0.0118088592,
-0.03092747,
0.0128711164,
0.0324427001,
-0.0373128466,
0.0134629859,
0.037406452,
-0.0174832642,
0.0022559271,
-0.0240191184,
-0.0149778379,
0.0185942594,
0.0165759083,
-0.0247996487,
-0.0394170024,
-0.0524751581,
0.0587281995,
0.0252246857,
0.011169455,
0.0644046217,
-0.0130177783,
-0.0004661162,
0.0595878325,
0.0074567245,
0.0121925622,
-0.0635205954,
-0.0628941283,
-0.0073590288,
0.0724510849,
0.0820246637,
0.0822753906,
-0.0462328196,
0.0150648477,
-0.0269452892,
0.0080525335,
0.0347230993,
0.0407754332,
0.0648077205,
0.009213632,
-0.0266546942,
-0.0222120825,
-0.0662930235,
-0.0119576175,
-0.0450758785,
-0.0214156304,
0.0011804544,
0.010824739,
-0.0210641865,
-0.0109806741,
0.0066219904,
-0.0601673201,
-0.0477265902,
0.0097645111,
0.0240139551,
0.016964322,
-0.0174581278,
-0.0105414158,
-0.0684961155,
0.0225713458,
-0.0271787476,
0.0087246289,
-0.017502116,
0.0254677944,
0.027502114,
0.0042643202,
-0.0489025004,
-0.0038398241,
-0.061630372,
-0.0039097397,
0.048786927,
-0.0022176499,
0.0192044489,
0.0062289629,
-0.0210222322,
0.0164179355,
-0.0155929709,
0.0309855398,
-0.0136185829,
0.0651795045,
-0.0162920617,
-0.0343770832,
-0.0169460084,
-0.0289903805,
-0.0470233709,
-0.0193967465,
0.0352333859,
0.0191341061,
-0.0098984698,
-0.0063534081,
2.575e-7,
0.0258254912,
0.0581916273,
-0.0022801054,
-0.0245981812,
0.0348908827,
0.0433229432,
-0.0458130538,
-0.0173179694,
0.045522619,
-0.0312484596,
0.0207569674,
0.0513304658,
0.0249458048,
0.0750804171,
-0.0439758375,
-0.054480575,
-0.0555348583,
-0.0068337796,
-0.0381039344,
-0.0226104092,
0.0044648545,
0.0282656103,
0.056508489,
-0.0053143459,
-0.032679297,
-0.053367883,
0.046379704,
-0.0128860679,
-0.0186822433,
0.0322556943,
0.0261392929,
-0.0258477312,
0.0119359782,
0.0545097515,
0.0301246848,
-0.0110802259,
-0.0308308899,
0.056494493,
-0.0130773354,
0.0095229745,
-0.0324208885,
-0.0156847443,
0.0118444702,
-0.030535534,
0.0395502821,
-0.0604253635,
-0.059984006,
-0.0400515422,
0.040408954,
-0.0539620705,
0.0379746258,
-0.0090842973,
0.0192427635,
0.0168527849,
-0.0115269851,
-0.0161857326,
-0.009473999,
-0.070076175,
-0.0062653976,
-0.0284032114,
-0.0557706766,
-0.035093274,
0.0236836951,
-0.040655598,
0.0037935609,
-0.0456522703,
0.0246585868,
1.944671962e-34,
0.0306050554,
0.0168433376,
0.0107283769,
0.0380055904,
0.068805106,
0.0042589926,
-0.0382881127,
-0.0023425459,
0.0289688576,
-0.0653578714,
-0.0394049697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08147v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08147v1 | RECALL: A Benchmark for LLMs Robustness against External Counterfactual Knowledge | 2023-11-14T13:24:19 | 2023-11-14T13:24:19 | Yi Liu, Lianzhe Huang, Shicheng Li, Sishuo Chen, Hao Zhou, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou, Xu Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | LLMs and AI chatbots have improved people's efficiency in various fields.
However, the necessary knowledge for answering the question may be beyond the
models' knowledge boundaries. To mitigate this issue, many researchers try to
introduce external knowledge, such as knowledge graphs and Internet contents,
into LLMs for up-to-date information. However, the external information from
the Internet may include counterfactual information that will confuse the model
and lead to an incorrect response. Thus there is a pressing need for LLMs to
possess the ability to distinguish reliable information from external
knowledge. Therefore, to evaluate the ability of LLMs to discern the
reliability of external knowledge, we create a benchmark from existing
knowledge bases. Our benchmark consists of two tasks, Question Answering and
Text Generation, and for each task, we provide models with a context containing
counterfactual information. Evaluation results show that existing LLMs are
susceptible to interference from unreliable external knowledge with
counterfactual information, and simple intervention methods make limited
contributions to the alleviation of this issue. | [
0.0462956056,
-0.002973306,
-0.0225853603,
0.0334507152,
-0.0515193604,
-0.0071731266,
-0.0301553737,
0.0331446528,
0.0776076317,
-0.0549476407,
-0.0174141545,
-0.007653086,
-0.0483947583,
0.0042835041,
0.0269742012,
0.0222862214,
0.0459615625,
-0.0241287518,
0.0050981091,
-0.0359265395,
-0.0146484254,
-0.0159461182,
-0.0331273489,
0.0025018093,
0.0045476845,
-0.0195589401,
-0.0031046756,
0.0064763036,
0.0104869939,
-0.0232552849,
0.0167215727,
0.0129169524,
0.0044414187,
0.0081902789,
0.0000018114,
-0.0652503222,
-0.0182282757,
-0.0196781848,
-0.0914190412,
-0.0610187277,
-0.0483502932,
0.0168715082,
0.0213581808,
0.0195698906,
-0.0598873012,
0.099936597,
0.0013488833,
0.0208707005,
0.0375130028,
0.0874258727,
0.0290771294,
0.0352211595,
0.0394285023,
0.0172415543,
0.0490139313,
-0.0434850678,
0.0074494667,
0.0210077725,
0.0067144055,
-0.0064556738,
-0.0063341479,
0.0342495032,
0.0035812457,
-0.0004773959,
0.0107444329,
0.0259161796,
-0.0031743308,
0.0068816771,
-0.022588646,
0.0791524947,
0.0677042156,
-0.0164881442,
0.0076931347,
-0.015076708,
0.0459660925,
0.0573644862,
-0.054605253,
0.0112932092,
-0.0316562951,
-0.0354781933,
-0.0290770624,
-0.0118679162,
0.042779658,
0.0325228348,
0.0214096308,
0.0972713828,
-0.0022965346,
-0.0408615619,
0.0041318433,
0.0069040512,
0.0220885016,
-0.0714896098,
0.0011337369,
0.0964625105,
-0.0386474133,
0.0295199472,
0.002020264,
-0.0047909683,
0.0424321704,
-0.0552916229,
-0.0115204183,
0.04315437,
0.0020561924,
0.0298142321,
-0.0255701691,
0.0588005632,
-0.0195159689,
0.03403062,
0.007813273,
-0.0009898222,
-0.0444329493,
-0.0396193936,
0.0025778254,
0.0738664716,
-0.0057036299,
0.0187947433,
-0.0241652429,
0.052877754,
-0.0401576534,
0.0381599665,
-0.0044434965,
0.0199114271,
-0.0032834262,
-0.0355759598,
-0.099785313,
-0.0027341947,
-0.0272345971,
0.0228319727,
0.0213158522,
-0.0848652273,
-0.0045925686,
0.0081830751,
-0.018497156,
-0.0056491625,
0.003702234,
0.1342969239,
0.0240467973,
-0.01169034,
-0.0634159595,
-0.0837802142,
-0.0038706108,
-0.0739650279,
0.0429015979,
-0.0341826677,
0.0200470518,
0.0163367968,
-0.0364478342,
-0.0082982313,
0.0060664965,
0.0086138248,
0.0001249813,
0.0442070179,
-0.0257988311,
0.0009473124,
0.0600911602,
0.037606515,
-0.0598486215,
0.0494823158,
0.016107453,
-0.0047800662,
0.053071022,
0.034397088,
0.0221137553,
0.0109974714,
0.0479623601,
0.0035568185,
-0.0117116477,
0.0419854559,
-0.0302821528,
0.0291022621,
-0.0086011188,
0.0368646421,
-0.0326832682,
-0.0292891189,
0.0782541484,
0.0018004782,
-0.0054359161,
-0.0055852025,
0.0136237033,
-0.0032021315,
0.0172030143,
0.0637280717,
-0.0276883692,
0.0523981638,
-0.0863545239,
0.0219628885,
0.0137545625,
-0.0072954814,
-0.0281730965,
-0.0620500781,
-0.0175955389,
-0.0268611647,
-0.0110891014,
0.0294646099,
0.0426742435,
-0.0044179396,
-0.0205252133,
0.0464123674,
-0.0113496296,
-0.0194532778,
-0.0028160447,
-0.0835871845,
0.0234531332,
0.0807551816,
0.0632803217,
-0.0492163077,
-0.0788655728,
0.0086054876,
-0.0363072157,
0.0375404246,
0.034072645,
-0.0047772611,
-0.0101533029,
-0.0253035091,
-0.0130276,
-0.0299984124,
0.0054943734,
-0.0079211127,
0.0484070703,
0.0208606292,
-0.0065480499,
-0.0287984144,
0.0347758979,
0.0279659331,
-0.0618274733,
-0.0081589017,
-0.0362518355,
-0.0099643087,
0.0288751852,
0.029227268,
0.0110621881,
0.0284526311,
0.0587117821,
0.0084922863,
-0.0578292832,
0.008189287,
-0.0199738089,
-0.0311817322,
0.0564955585,
-0.0131104952,
-0.0352267101,
0.0232924763,
-0.0205650441,
-0.0314003937,
0.0194620937,
-0.0364094786,
0.065848127,
-0.01658432,
-0.0093786092,
0.0146427136,
-0.0168473851,
-0.0201931484,
0.0643750206,
-0.0491820313,
0.0156530198,
0.036695417,
-0.009465755,
0.0014022806,
-0.0573608391,
0.0220959187,
-0.0142104374,
0.0102306753,
0.0093673654,
0.0141382227,
-0.0112492116,
-0.0855916142,
-0.015528704,
-0.0602661185,
0.0078826211,
0.0001944686,
0.0270356983,
0.0113684451,
-0.0492034629,
0.0027040145,
-0.0286991969,
-0.0559618175,
0.0505227484,
0.0324102752,
0.0289806016,
0.0558597967,
0.0054382612,
0.0189258531,
-0.0227219183,
0.0241489671,
-0.0011337348,
0.0024959669,
0.0224577785,
-0.0357510261,
-0.0523115806,
0.0362597853,
-0.0830219537,
0.0076616723,
-0.0175284389,
-0.0041338229,
0.0245096162,
0.0096199997,
0.0167955365,
0.0471674427,
0.0205389056,
-0.0182523783,
0.0501258746,
0.0004734875,
-0.0776992291,
-0.0005353308,
-0.0042246687,
-0.0298516471,
-0.0290813427,
-0.0257129185,
-0.0112376912,
0.0060853851,
0.0073856786,
-0.0087965885,
-0.0166401714,
0.021562919,
0.0214365907,
-0.0526903272,
-0.0224316958,
-0.013961317,
-0.0305050556,
0.042260617,
-0.0103714224,
-0.0390563123,
0.0865356103,
-0.0037122236,
0.0434170663,
0.0351252444,
-0.0291960239,
-0.0184344184,
0.0253290739,
-0.0290631764,
0.0153300269,
-0.0092193419,
0.0053155231,
-0.0732798204,
-0.0115725882,
0.0343119577,
-0.0511448905,
0.0180512127,
-0.0491819829,
0.0117435651,
0.0032385681,
-0.0242156219,
-0.0721093118,
-0.0168070644,
-0.005363002,
-0.0071699736,
-0.0157351643,
-0.0261729807,
-0.0136412093,
-0.0258584525,
0.0350364,
-0.0091715315,
-0.0137577606,
-0.0264547635,
-0.0123462677,
0.0363889337,
0.0309084971,
0.0607909188,
0.0551978983,
-0.0419599377,
0.0241812505,
0.0711637959,
0.0069917236,
-0.0460061319,
0.0139235957,
-0.0313451178,
0.0071588429,
-0.0330878831,
-0.007401716,
0.0339631848,
0.0316018611,
-0.0252632145,
-0.0175719317,
0.0913184062,
0.0149385296,
-0.0050091282,
-0.0044614188,
-0.0350795686,
-0.0069197351,
0.0253477655,
0.0029923066,
-0.0691144988,
-0.0013939106,
0.0047406149,
0.0169100519,
-0.0521560349,
-0.056157168,
-0.0130107542,
-0.1062356606,
0.021060694,
-0.0116909174,
-0.0065634032,
-0.0284369458,
-0.0101694381,
-0.0155911427,
0.0281690694,
0.0150141632,
0.0180079304,
0.0151731363,
-0.0214933418,
0.0091075962,
-0.0607703179,
-0.0262713339,
0.006208152,
-0.0053038229,
0.0655470192,
0.0238320455,
0.0249866247,
-0.0004759294,
-0.0151544837,
0.0357905068,
0.0038130758,
0.0327607319,
-0.0130730355,
0.0652832165,
-0.0114041856,
0.0294807926,
-0.0391604789,
-0.0148418229,
-0.012768019,
-0.0093405508,
0.0226104595,
0.0745669156,
-0.0498575233,
0.0119306715,
-0.0262856651,
0.025172947,
0.0018593478,
0.0746115148,
0.0043849163,
0.004836502,
-0.0214050654,
-0.0266592894,
-0.0137513755,
-0.0155229,
0.0065854318,
0.0132347373,
0.002513489,
0.0407674238,
-0.1041651815,
-0.0406830572,
-0.0148838358,
0.0170648675,
-0.0164249763,
0.0358149521,
-0.0045703962,
0.0092994785,
-0.0287990123,
-0.0246997662,
-0.0561855286,
-0.0046157106,
-0.0051407372,
-0.0071344832,
0.0287946276,
-0.049074851,
0.0063269734,
0.0107428692,
-0.0690533221,
-0.0755400881,
-0.0361113697,
0.0496000573,
0.0391244553,
0.0373364538,
-0.0074004494,
-0.0272856336,
0.0290188566,
0.0335662328,
-0.0517196953,
0.0331034102,
0.0140350573,
0.0676153451,
-0.0171113294,
0.0302237645,
-0.0816010684,
-0.04433259,
0.0157536045,
0.0270258691,
-0.0483275056,
-0.065846324,
0.0226401668,
0.0520136058,
-0.0271315668,
0.0016693545,
-0.0026085626,
-0.0049280627,
0.0361863039,
-0.0217979494,
-0.0058190296,
0.0013958417,
0.001641942,
-0.0020695447,
-0.0244632922,
0.0253139902,
0.0016266006,
-0.0239126291,
0.0322805047,
-0.0154664302,
-0.0235844683,
0.0078552607,
0.0179037545,
0.0146250967,
-0.0082889544,
-0.0356522352,
0.0170349088,
0.018841479,
0.0373143665,
0.0232069008,
0.0444026925,
0.0130283684,
-0.0098688919,
-0.0000497969,
-0.0079046292,
-0.0957031026,
-0.0727821812,
-0.0109948535,
0.0616512336,
0.0536052436,
0.0526436381,
0.0091208769,
-0.0296330918,
-0.0022678971,
-0.0216163583,
0.0045576771,
0.0230015293,
-0.0087698689,
0.0671217591,
0.0114046,
-0.0135030765,
0.0375192948,
0.0765853152,
-0.0216610786,
0.0547715537,
-0.0397219881,
-0.0114614703,
-0.0392712876,
-0.0549886003,
-0.0038258892,
0.0142519902,
0.0129921809,
-0.0006724602,
-0.0733577907,
-0.0695968792,
0.035592705,
0.0446962565,
0.009273448,
-0.0289784465,
0.0230477359,
0.0410284847,
0.0476974025,
-0.0252783317,
-0.0371905118,
0.0334374979,
-0.0384229906,
0.0264495816,
-0.0262759402,
-5.893382437e-33,
-0.0471712984,
-0.0919464156,
0.0533705615,
-0.0071236985,
-0.0087761059,
0.0028239884,
-0.0148106674,
0.0073586018,
-0.0212590229,
-0.0114183184,
-0.0133091323,
0.0374822356,
0.0042561102,
-0.027532747,
-0.009984632,
-0.0608247258,
0.0081363944,
-0.0263982192,
-0.0204924531,
0.0152680892,
0.0423965864,
0.0149432113,
0.0318017192,
-0.0595723391,
0.0627961755,
-0.0458368436,
0.0147530893,
0.042702008,
-0.0688146278,
0.0596422032,
-0.0075429035,
0.0505574048,
0.0418863744,
0.0098469984,
-0.0127221411,
-0.0166256446,
-0.0138366744,
-0.0636496991,
0.0273179691,
-0.0174994115,
-0.0198256634,
-0.0413576216,
0.0469944924,
0.0022169433,
-0.0272679646,
0.0044425777,
0.0151201086,
-0.0449757352,
-0.0123864971,
-0.0143092116,
-0.0333613306,
0.0191479903,
-0.0014690952,
0.0008342796,
-0.0449503586,
0.0653833225,
0.0181525145,
0.0060679968,
-0.0520511903,
0.0219959859,
0.0008149202,
-0.0175158866,
0.0900994614,
-0.0060629705,
-0.0127475467,
0.0611139759,
-0.0051982342,
0.0375433452,
-0.0093303323,
-0.0523943305,
-0.0228713248,
0.0512291417,
0.0602667145,
0.0747231841,
-0.0119680241,
-0.0050730682,
-0.0825223699,
0.0386236608,
0.0394261032,
0.0045553725,
0.0148782153,
-0.0092982529,
-0.0308362879,
0.0166870132,
-0.0369067937,
0.0310580973,
-0.0254176334,
-0.0138237542,
0.0239118505,
0.0156679433,
0.0522784367,
-0.0649640337,
0.0005305799,
-0.0373636112,
0.0202385001,
0.0252355877,
0.0060312552,
0.0052697989,
0.0217725337,
0.0311721731,
-0.0468088426,
-0.0034581237,
-0.0022743458,
0.0044898051,
0.0140396925,
0.024176117,
0.0024091378,
-0.0027703189,
-0.0243516974,
-0.0109015135,
-0.0437210985,
0.0244123414,
0.0056461762,
-0.0794334188,
0.0328268409,
-0.013760861,
-0.016000947,
0.0573737547,
-0.0041817394,
-0.0123399887,
0.0031923384,
0.0059144958,
0.0084841615,
0.0167119466,
-0.0321500152,
0.0210622139,
0.0165882744,
0.0510056391,
-0.0302566309,
-0.0451991037,
-0.0020197264,
-0.0004458928,
2.58e-7,
0.0319433995,
0.0195593517,
0.026182469,
0.0666354969,
0.0334994644,
0.0175093859,
-0.0555252507,
-0.0134455636,
-0.0021676451,
-0.0321964286,
0.0142685771,
0.0453493893,
0.0356739052,
0.0321561582,
-0.03390361,
-0.0157244354,
-0.0662810132,
-0.0383573249,
-0.0175638702,
-0.0038540738,
0.0833623335,
0.0043298285,
-0.0054618777,
-0.0016843193,
-0.0153836496,
-0.0542442203,
0.0745770112,
-0.0435333215,
-0.0112194046,
-0.0071693854,
0.1020461172,
0.0202428587,
0.0057852282,
0.059425164,
0.0030238586,
-0.01437891,
-0.0445615202,
0.0375469364,
0.0150781488,
-0.0880095437,
-0.0078119128,
-0.0296276789,
0.0355521925,
-0.0139325242,
0.0645566508,
-0.0109623233,
-0.0199832935,
-0.0070270621,
-0.0150540937,
-0.0443737172,
0.0059138932,
-0.0192474499,
-0.005925003,
-0.009165273,
-0.0146727366,
0.0194723457,
0.0149007235,
-0.0536704734,
0.0008236371,
0.0269558039,
-0.0450077429,
-0.1243799701,
-0.0318744406,
-0.0005445339,
0.0223332606,
-0.0590129048,
0.0052071768,
1.992769885e-34,
0.0212317258,
0.0036532551,
-0.0030527171,
0.0638484061,
0.0315849222,
-0.0027715329,
-0.0219906289,
-0.0040916894,
0.0256809201,
-0.0356442071,
-0.0141082639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08143v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08143v1 | Sinkhorn Transformations for Single-Query Postprocessing in Text-Video Retrieval | 2023-11-14T13:20:23 | 2023-11-14T13:20:23 | Konstantin Yakovlev, Gregory Polyakov, Ilseyar Alimova, Alexander Podolskiy, Andrey Bout, Sergey Nikolenko, Irina Piontkovskaya | cs.CL | cs.CL | A recent trend in multimodal retrieval is related to postprocessing test set
results via the dual-softmax loss (DSL). While this approach can bring
significant improvements, it usually presumes that an entire matrix of test
samples is available as DSL input. This work introduces a new postprocessing
approach based on Sinkhorn transformations that outperforms DSL. Further, we
propose a new postprocessing setting that does not require access to multiple
test queries. We show that our approach can significantly improve the results
of state of the art models such as CLIP4Clip, BLIP, X-CLIP, and DRL, thus
achieving a new state-of-the-art on several standard text-video retrieval
datasets both with access to the entire test set and in the single-query
setting. | [
-0.0077613411,
0.0125902593,
0.0046447087,
0.0131636662,
-0.0261677802,
-0.0181780122,
0.0161930621,
0.0833338425,
-0.0586055443,
-0.0546623692,
-0.0281359442,
-0.052100528,
-0.0272668358,
0.0159925949,
0.0419842415,
-0.0455763973,
0.0403729863,
0.0239366256,
-0.0837042928,
0.0104439249,
0.0250709057,
0.0113821384,
0.0028746382,
0.0150543014,
-0.0902371779,
0.0543558002,
-0.0332156494,
0.0342418663,
0.0360209867,
-0.0096327262,
0.0215027202,
0.0451844335,
0.0597795546,
0.0020375766,
0.0000020253,
-0.0364657082,
-0.0188099332,
-0.0039857021,
0.0502104387,
0.0340598039,
0.0223073997,
-0.0120353866,
0.0546630062,
0.0047816909,
-0.0321387909,
0.0065758983,
0.0229394622,
0.0150781544,
0.0658381879,
0.0559236668,
-0.0443432555,
-0.0349294879,
-0.0065485998,
-0.000394029,
0.0339820571,
-0.0573112965,
0.0326081477,
-0.0456509404,
0.0237799101,
0.0214630608,
0.0261252318,
0.0592665933,
-0.0199179891,
-0.0063550351,
-0.0128298867,
-0.0120503865,
-0.0519486926,
0.012067616,
0.0078026499,
0.0213593394,
-0.0800309479,
0.000625852,
0.0150552457,
0.0347529091,
0.0187008493,
-0.0029224597,
-0.0468602329,
0.0129683381,
0.0172160678,
-0.0139328213,
-0.127031669,
0.0323111787,
-0.000688088,
-0.0008447842,
0.0016556568,
-0.0469760261,
0.016926026,
0.0212461501,
-0.0109719746,
0.0240402371,
-0.0295708869,
0.0686292127,
0.0100963283,
-0.0231812298,
-0.0011979768,
-0.0100034997,
-0.026341496,
-0.0269724429,
-0.0011712869,
-0.0499159358,
0.0701318905,
-0.0070251361,
-0.0488894843,
0.0656602457,
-0.0486758612,
0.0107675493,
0.0009834485,
0.0128318146,
-0.0094886059,
-0.0140479831,
-0.0570247956,
0.0074740499,
-0.0251024943,
0.0490769222,
-0.0066135451,
0.0047303201,
0.016896639,
0.0098121567,
-0.0491167642,
-0.0319619775,
-0.0382496566,
0.0011187653,
-0.0451159477,
-0.0413294807,
0.0013081651,
0.0560915135,
-0.0009310497,
0.0232398473,
0.0042936825,
-0.0333675966,
-0.0063064923,
0.0331285931,
-0.0045322385,
-0.0190730281,
0.0431766137,
0.0117723765,
-0.0763981491,
-0.029703714,
-0.0496166162,
-0.0139844036,
-0.05031991,
0.0035712568,
0.0134035256,
-0.0493874736,
0.0668759048,
-0.0119786467,
-0.0157328248,
-0.0241521392,
-0.0086670611,
0.0376028083,
-0.0149181839,
0.0745644867,
0.066736728,
0.0009104105,
0.025739681,
0.0037376243,
-0.0148647949,
0.1108231619,
-0.038894169,
0.0766950995,
0.0414547734,
0.0276606232,
0.007373265,
0.0566330627,
-0.0088845799,
0.0182097629,
-0.1017592251,
0.0054375962,
0.0294459872,
0.0080218893,
0.0229396056,
0.039395459,
-0.0370789319,
-0.038918525,
-0.0015120277,
0.043291714,
0.0227878392,
-0.0340838842,
0.0020353573,
-0.0141767375,
-0.0159033313,
-0.017745411,
0.0125707565,
0.0436827987,
-0.0264162328,
-0.0112169776,
-0.0108170751,
0.0199603178,
-0.0427121669,
-0.0059649553,
0.0180817135,
-0.0056898934,
-0.0066921152,
-0.0151946414,
0.0796221197,
-0.0333218053,
-0.0349572748,
0.059187375,
-0.0003001153,
-0.0174874887,
-0.001206485,
-0.0670058355,
-0.0661387295,
-0.0403700471,
0.0208685007,
-0.0646947473,
0.0222126655,
0.0130092818,
0.0046435334,
-0.0163433123,
0.0176856685,
-0.021376038,
0.0062542292,
-0.0418001041,
-0.0284282491,
0.0049877041,
0.015542414,
0.0301999096,
-0.0107703777,
0.0446729846,
0.022827955,
-0.0328569636,
0.0076505421,
0.0360564739,
0.0591000915,
0.017685283,
0.0185912363,
0.0173391048,
-0.0039806799,
-0.0021952912,
-0.0289764516,
-0.0018961104,
0.0362556502,
0.0202936139,
-0.0066423169,
-0.0483976305,
0.0020172959,
-0.0309375636,
0.0048678825,
-0.07030572,
0.0402409136,
0.1016968414,
-0.0192990843,
-0.0300065484,
-0.0148901576,
0.0221168976,
0.0078218821,
-0.0563431196,
0.0161392987,
-0.0096709915,
-0.006297519,
-0.0743833855,
0.0202892479,
0.021500947,
-0.0096828062,
-0.0511390045,
0.0082124723,
0.0218855832,
-0.033289358,
-0.0518713407,
0.0404196046,
-0.0694706291,
0.0456496365,
0.0170199107,
-0.0131023219,
-0.0418570451,
-0.0197857041,
-0.0210660733,
0.0192299131,
-0.0184810609,
-0.0103106983,
-0.0061469059,
-0.0240486227,
0.0121127032,
-0.0559906736,
-0.0142626557,
0.0001716844,
0.0045291823,
0.0193726216,
0.0147694349,
0.0399618819,
0.0576172993,
-0.0092917308,
-0.0507481284,
0.015468752,
0.0466907173,
-0.0737460107,
-0.0848047808,
0.0072083431,
0.0259064827,
-0.0048174835,
-0.0100457799,
-0.0117701562,
0.0150529798,
-0.0012021349,
-0.0641271174,
-0.0091591813,
0.0672012269,
0.0615043417,
0.0249694157,
-0.0269776583,
0.0061113019,
-0.0508271903,
0.0192715824,
-0.0224565845,
-0.0513026565,
0.0217689797,
-0.0002809208,
0.014043306,
-0.0728017315,
-0.0124234958,
0.0294042975,
-0.0137888175,
-0.0042295163,
0.0287149195,
0.0188038945,
-0.0867201313,
0.0074810125,
-0.0009228194,
-0.0078197327,
-0.0276819766,
-0.0191747416,
0.0014094271,
-0.0312914141,
-0.0349007882,
-0.01143994,
-0.009052786,
-0.0100776795,
0.0739584118,
0.0266130436,
0.0127977142,
-0.0127786435,
-0.0354470648,
-0.0482683629,
0.0113935946,
0.0065303859,
-0.0320138372,
0.0657552406,
0.0400778353,
0.016666485,
-0.0180266704,
-0.0072323941,
-0.0176345482,
-0.0232091993,
0.0287761204,
-0.0202007238,
-0.0116856098,
0.0061690742,
-0.064173542,
0.0548668951,
0.0252393205,
0.0146629494,
-0.0395838432,
0.0003679774,
0.0053145923,
0.0532737561,
0.0178501792,
-0.0087771947,
-0.0864368007,
-0.0079744598,
-0.0185579378,
0.0518934056,
0.0398210213,
-0.0288178474,
-0.0423813239,
0.0113870222,
0.0251645297,
0.0074028098,
-0.0140370633,
0.0059528896,
0.0156080853,
-0.045675423,
0.0207492448,
-0.00095486,
-0.0009843722,
-0.0587358885,
-0.0361198373,
0.0509884842,
0.0114142234,
0.0380247682,
0.0354497805,
-0.0298185237,
-0.0679417923,
-0.0023038771,
0.0404059365,
0.039300967,
0.0202969965,
-0.0022862027,
-0.0818829089,
0.0488442183,
0.0162268076,
-0.0161062796,
0.0076357331,
-0.0445240811,
0.0132901268,
-0.0227853432,
-0.0444613472,
0.011509914,
-0.0223269444,
-0.0339286961,
0.0073097083,
0.0528898686,
-0.0432418697,
0.0023323004,
-0.0099078314,
-0.0534524173,
0.0425342061,
0.0035175397,
-0.0385997817,
-0.0372581556,
0.0349192955,
-0.058906287,
0.0298259631,
0.0139882592,
0.0705929101,
-0.0332353413,
-0.0242961552,
0.0211610477,
0.0330853835,
0.0471914858,
0.0177232437,
-0.030245591,
0.0324239284,
-0.0065810196,
-0.009100765,
-0.0486952215,
-0.0095062293,
-0.0200743228,
0.0182006489,
-0.0287712757,
0.0100775789,
0.0122014079,
0.0467531383,
-0.0224958658,
0.0144530199,
-0.0746785477,
-0.0121702505,
-0.0324527621,
0.0282369312,
-0.0464745127,
0.0178447887,
0.0299151484,
0.116485931,
-0.0715966448,
-0.0148803415,
-0.0492902584,
0.0232647117,
-0.0644914284,
0.0980206951,
0.0138953542,
0.029906759,
-0.0273914449,
0.0375534259,
0.0768856928,
-0.0158777591,
-0.0164657887,
0.0167955123,
-0.035005793,
-0.0372390896,
-0.0350706726,
0.0096400138,
0.0216985699,
0.0245704427,
0.0271338709,
0.0234111957,
0.0182498079,
0.0802378207,
0.0414660871,
-0.0010542956,
0.0406390876,
-0.0784825534,
-0.0709211826,
0.0161973629,
-0.0409198701,
0.0208462067,
-0.0461600646,
-0.0001726846,
0.0201057307,
-0.0301725958,
-0.0008811504,
0.0056545311,
0.0907855555,
0.0281342026,
-0.0025336749,
-0.0266261213,
0.0122965304,
-0.0061395313,
-0.023588866,
-0.0254586916,
0.0215060469,
-0.0168238096,
-0.0185011141,
0.0175406151,
-0.0170323327,
0.0403431579,
-0.0117302053,
-0.0338726938,
-0.0348595716,
0.0170440823,
-0.0215543043,
-0.0247001816,
0.0282706469,
0.0152508104,
0.0221824553,
0.0436733291,
0.0499290451,
-0.0319625959,
0.040818315,
0.0381076895,
0.0019888578,
-0.0479694828,
0.046053119,
-0.0126876999,
0.0441376641,
-0.0611968823,
-0.0260496698,
0.0277780537,
-0.0540696606,
0.017311817,
-0.0107977688,
-0.0378404707,
-0.0477379188,
0.0014237703,
-0.0043825596,
-0.0370898508,
0.0138199553,
-0.002784739,
0.0232934523,
0.0168274362,
0.0451222844,
-0.0427000187,
0.0153615586,
-0.023959076,
-0.0325304084,
-0.0042830589,
-0.0051066075,
0.0861448646,
0.0406319052,
-0.0134288669,
-0.0676499903,
0.0040171565,
-0.0304717869,
-0.0114281047,
-0.0346979983,
-0.0082946913,
0.0285163224,
0.0605909005,
0.0515322238,
0.0428478271,
0.012882744,
0.0092258472,
-0.0385292694,
0.0182458553,
-0.0090535581,
0.0254870579,
-6.144523499e-33,
-0.0000876651,
0.0454599112,
-0.0142073017,
-0.0194056612,
-0.0416137204,
0.0180396158,
0.0372406989,
0.0311735962,
-0.0215741023,
-0.0009121069,
-0.0119015127,
-0.0284825768,
0.0269781109,
0.0203694515,
-0.0123884017,
-0.0162519198,
0.0360816605,
-0.0501047634,
-0.0172641166,
0.0208185352,
0.0259046555,
0.0363823362,
0.0392149203,
0.0187750366,
-0.0742127523,
0.0258193798,
-0.0624568015,
0.0262087788,
0.0389585122,
0.0144825131,
0.0211134814,
0.0001377524,
0.0083883274,
-0.0793064982,
-0.020096764,
-0.0168421268,
-0.0325439498,
0.0088400813,
-0.0410976335,
-0.001098888,
-0.0276021305,
0.0395984054,
0.0624172986,
-0.0405668654,
0.0205248017,
-0.0351142548,
0.0200297292,
-0.0093511688,
0.0044891601,
0.0037285865,
0.0249233581,
0.0189485401,
0.004357581,
-0.0284719449,
0.0534610227,
0.0053679035,
0.0239070542,
-0.0225485712,
-0.0709161162,
0.0364714637,
-0.027633246,
0.053478796,
0.0493312478,
0.0100119188,
-0.022695329,
0.069968082,
0.0598878488,
-0.007828719,
0.0488110967,
-0.0518011525,
0.0835344121,
0.0549477004,
0.0417645313,
0.045865804,
0.0501428396,
-0.0378206633,
-0.0477619059,
0.0374459624,
-0.0344892256,
0.0281777866,
-0.0082866745,
0.0195647702,
0.0179996826,
-0.0116483327,
-0.0332024097,
0.0046535861,
-0.0159721449,
-0.0307094324,
0.0155464914,
0.0436914489,
0.0175405573,
0.0608682781,
0.1027779654,
0.0172025431,
0.0235832315,
0.0079502249,
-0.0454797819,
0.0766264871,
-0.0200714562,
-0.0063394043,
0.038532149,
-0.0226252265,
0.0207500514,
0.03693657,
-0.0018051666,
-0.0048619723,
0.0000549151,
0.0265171006,
-0.05769182,
-0.0049853651,
0.00115174,
-0.0274445098,
-0.0304049328,
0.0290470701,
0.0106855733,
0.0039296048,
0.0185512528,
0.0741082728,
0.010214542,
-0.0007087327,
-0.0352105685,
-0.0614838079,
0.0165711287,
0.0018229005,
-0.003025949,
0.0664732382,
-0.0588842072,
-0.0571020134,
0.049269639,
-0.0496646836,
-0.0043940037,
-0.0001745465,
2.877e-7,
0.0075958758,
0.0320782997,
-0.0264288187,
0.012023598,
-0.0283222459,
0.04202592,
-0.0312743932,
0.0378260538,
0.017581651,
-0.0228476599,
0.0146346055,
-0.0107220635,
0.012082451,
0.0033690103,
-0.0555311516,
-0.0384931602,
-0.0099389609,
-0.0101219648,
-0.0672506019,
-0.0335416086,
0.02227154,
0.0865169391,
-0.0140284235,
-0.0109623848,
0.0156739298,
-0.0387702659,
0.0632332712,
0.046551697,
-0.0123946937,
0.020759413,
0.0615509339,
0.0062128929,
0.000796006,
0.0358245037,
-0.0317139626,
0.0074728159,
0.0721060187,
0.0126641896,
-0.0231494121,
-0.0992366076,
0.0083812084,
0.0631123856,
-0.0167810339,
-0.0362845138,
0.0692018718,
-0.0007561012,
0.0201664362,
-0.001091429,
-0.0235521179,
0.0159546807,
-0.0133070536,
0.0061675082,
-0.0116684595,
0.046248626,
0.0113229994,
0.0385242775,
-0.0282815136,
-0.100793764,
0.0212339628,
0.0224119034,
-0.02352098,
0.0219991673,
-0.0280231927,
0.0005578984,
0.0227860752,
-0.0398749113,
-0.0628567562,
2.545540593e-34,
0.0131155532,
0.015496376,
0.0069110217,
-0.0503285192,
-0.0225298051,
0.0027739054,
-0.029120395,
0.0365119427,
-0.0498331562,
-0.0424312018,
-0.026162995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08123v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08123v1 | Memory-efficient Stochastic methods for Memory-based Transformers | 2023-11-14T12:37:25 | 2023-11-14T12:37:25 | Vishwajit Kumar Vishnu, C. Chandra Sekhar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Training Memory-based transformers can require a large amount of memory and
can be quite inefficient. We propose a novel two-phase training mechanism and a
novel regularization technique to improve the training efficiency of
memory-based transformers, which are often used for long-range context
problems. For our experiments, we consider transformer-XL as our baseline model
which is one of memorybased transformer models. We show that our resultant
model, Skip Cross-head TransformerXL, outperforms the baseline on character
level language modeling task with similar parameters and outperforms the
baseline on word level language modelling task with almost 20% fewer
parameters. Our proposed methods do not require any additional memory. We also
demonstrate the effectiveness of our regularization mechanism on BERT which
shows similar performance with reduction in standard deviation of scores of
around 30% on multiple GLUE tasks. | [
0.0229348429,
0.0521319434,
0.0165419504,
0.0206214674,
-0.0141008059,
0.0087931454,
0.0189225283,
-0.0204723608,
-0.0264939405,
-0.0405430086,
-0.0408490561,
-0.0810562521,
0.0394409932,
-0.0331418701,
0.0347377472,
-0.0652128682,
0.0177489128,
-0.0322257355,
-0.0603849478,
-0.0025697048,
-0.0087920874,
-0.0095843179,
-0.0182765815,
0.0351868048,
-0.04353166,
-0.007106619,
-0.0034781117,
0.0075237039,
0.0427394807,
-0.0060348255,
0.0072360616,
0.0479487181,
0.0135122063,
0.0333725475,
0.0000018929,
-0.0400997736,
-0.0095374845,
0.004398955,
0.0069306176,
0.0024005082,
-0.0161522552,
-0.0201626234,
-0.0362802781,
0.0434953347,
0.0000773633,
-0.0152190132,
0.0762427449,
0.061362762,
0.044051379,
0.049937252,
-0.0301384125,
-0.0725381896,
0.0373119228,
-0.0432432853,
0.0361926518,
-0.0446795747,
0.0224579591,
-0.0496615134,
-0.0338160321,
-0.0325944722,
-0.0527468212,
0.0461983904,
0.0082900086,
0.0202650633,
-0.0152778039,
0.0526359528,
-0.0635641366,
0.0146503951,
-0.0013024854,
0.0589705035,
-0.0363906249,
-0.0039379126,
-0.0263623185,
0.0336186141,
-0.0400852114,
0.0132884914,
-0.0208757706,
0.0291392449,
-0.0072849724,
0.0066706701,
-0.0130725959,
-0.0060429708,
0.01108988,
-0.0226526037,
-0.0830966681,
0.0136425756,
0.0490724891,
-0.0418036878,
0.0047822329,
0.0142682586,
-0.0136319632,
-0.0085643949,
0.0182679538,
0.0454490855,
0.0058321557,
0.0405264944,
-0.0281135608,
-0.0632501841,
-0.0071097505,
-0.0549159981,
0.0127588613,
0.0415071994,
-0.0285209883,
0.0369960591,
-0.0664283559,
0.036867056,
-0.0526064932,
0.0250609592,
0.0066793147,
-0.0411611833,
-0.0461239405,
0.0025260388,
-0.0837332234,
0.0217311587,
0.0126226386,
-0.0056623216,
-0.0540591963,
0.0054606218,
0.025772674,
-0.025027886,
0.0403745361,
-0.011706233,
-0.0903024897,
0.0121049965,
0.0086211348,
0.0454830937,
-0.0123099536,
-0.0227411743,
-0.0217927936,
-0.0308221206,
-0.0388295054,
0.0409115106,
0.027156055,
-0.0472208336,
0.0033906777,
0.0791252702,
-0.0416890085,
-0.0530703366,
-0.0481164567,
0.0353319496,
-0.0234655943,
-0.0476617888,
-0.0001404092,
-0.0634715259,
0.0298598725,
0.0125979921,
0.0155049879,
0.0158621836,
0.0117572267,
0.0182346106,
-0.0094079003,
0.070451133,
0.0306351911,
-0.0314897075,
0.027381178,
0.0165495295,
0.0165353008,
0.0402277894,
0.034347415,
0.0015172495,
-0.0193338618,
-0.0179161076,
0.0060189362,
0.060955096,
0.0176353287,
0.0047858055,
-0.0273485482,
-0.0254909806,
0.0304076206,
0.0140996715,
0.0104057323,
0.0940181389,
-0.0433937088,
-0.0090568429,
0.0322434269,
0.0185250491,
0.0528446995,
0.020142002,
0.0515429825,
-0.0314791016,
0.0082828142,
0.0142316399,
-0.0234444626,
0.0238711461,
-0.0045718979,
0.0236306898,
-0.0430660062,
0.0345407538,
-0.0557821244,
0.0190779455,
-0.0029408017,
-0.0501842126,
-0.0033713202,
-0.0273613222,
0.0776243284,
0.0219780523,
-0.0769725218,
0.1446344256,
-0.0057160561,
-0.0428152196,
0.007046984,
-0.0555864982,
-0.0293788146,
0.0138215786,
0.0462547541,
-0.0441825315,
-0.0459136926,
-0.0234086569,
-0.0163646359,
0.0704181716,
-0.0124368565,
0.0093411636,
0.0178482365,
-0.0556134768,
-0.0146840839,
0.0301272608,
-0.0166005008,
0.0464564487,
0.0500606075,
0.0210101213,
0.0289026629,
-0.0034164444,
0.0401314199,
0.0448451303,
-0.044404652,
-0.005932339,
-0.0070073376,
0.0312844105,
0.01792478,
-0.0070397868,
-0.0216063149,
0.0070203487,
0.0176616628,
-0.0558795147,
-0.0168022867,
0.0362689383,
-0.0954321101,
-0.0383319743,
0.0330649279,
-0.0280750431,
0.0006524391,
0.0448135808,
-0.0007207405,
-0.0526709706,
0.0011368069,
-0.0675114989,
0.0859943926,
-0.0398425199,
0.0322236232,
0.0048266095,
0.0231657177,
-0.0414695255,
0.0591600947,
-0.0207475834,
-0.0030574251,
0.019225752,
0.0289942324,
0.0275306944,
-0.0249483306,
-0.0671346933,
-0.0047585922,
-0.0145295812,
0.0166946109,
0.0113995867,
-0.0192971919,
-0.0127696889,
-0.0846995041,
-0.0590479821,
-0.0202370454,
-0.042421516,
0.0132913934,
-0.0044521731,
0.0402613319,
0.0255291369,
-0.009327637,
-0.0201358926,
-0.0093462467,
-0.0280584227,
0.015176476,
-0.0038549821,
0.0222318005,
-0.0322578661,
-0.0058446364,
-0.0357376747,
-0.0045697438,
0.0508555882,
-0.0133873178,
-0.0228557847,
-0.0667883083,
0.0339815058,
-0.0012208881,
0.064528048,
-0.0126448981,
-0.0430882424,
0.0129183996,
-0.0300230794,
0.1108085066,
0.0341551751,
0.0345575809,
-0.0079484871,
0.0216935743,
-0.0259564947,
-0.0376561098,
0.0308749657,
-0.0217442121,
-0.0452627577,
-0.0662311614,
-0.0030998155,
-0.0205414444,
0.0952397212,
-0.0126254112,
0.0190876275,
-0.070443891,
-0.0477540717,
0.0172242671,
-0.0196686704,
0.0320027731,
-0.0031521958,
-0.024068119,
-0.0081807673,
-0.0065890951,
-0.0078900168,
0.0725199208,
-0.0587556921,
-0.0039028251,
-0.0206400882,
0.0055264193,
-0.0373512842,
0.0350686871,
-0.0173946545,
0.0300561376,
-0.0319928937,
-0.0511271209,
-0.055680044,
0.0025981532,
0.0101296818,
-0.0175410472,
0.0577980429,
-0.0033394429,
0.0287277978,
-0.0350546502,
-0.025167197,
-0.0769351423,
0.0057190387,
-0.0084380787,
-0.0006999499,
0.0458914451,
-0.0429322682,
-0.094012104,
0.0635611564,
0.0297016464,
0.0582730807,
0.0311805364,
-0.0173906647,
0.0023347712,
0.0591099188,
0.0066673299,
0.0219214223,
0.0021361099,
-0.0261478461,
0.0174610056,
0.029642202,
0.0472708233,
-0.0057232506,
-0.0280986391,
-0.0172789209,
0.026779009,
-0.021881137,
-0.0058302307,
0.0027014201,
0.0140021099,
-0.0421394147,
-0.0462097041,
0.1005256325,
0.0283710621,
-0.0414779782,
-0.0322034284,
-0.0056187487,
0.0377805047,
0.0022239748,
0.0299352668,
-0.0660318807,
-0.0245694164,
0.0062504932,
0.0040413877,
0.0224764198,
-0.0260715429,
0.0066898158,
-0.1130828485,
-0.0157130621,
-0.0089509469,
-0.0541010424,
-0.0408988185,
-0.0359326527,
0.0009816374,
-0.0160562191,
0.0212211199,
0.0040582265,
-0.0166124199,
-0.0444770753,
0.0210474543,
0.0001409098,
-0.0245179683,
0.0308954511,
-0.0391278937,
0.0135900332,
0.0660073087,
0.0086056208,
-0.0006538766,
-0.0466082096,
0.0106599359,
-0.0254337024,
0.0165622029,
-0.0025658386,
0.0603524968,
-0.0246112794,
-0.038598761,
-0.0009979034,
-0.0062053781,
-0.0153754186,
-0.0096171666,
-0.0395992026,
0.0573065095,
-0.001769359,
0.0038568857,
0.0229083616,
0.0081539741,
0.0172862206,
0.0693708286,
-0.0042620813,
-0.046284087,
-0.0369790792,
-0.0046002497,
0.0398178287,
-0.0421383306,
-0.006214323,
0.0227915887,
0.0132410182,
-0.0503349714,
-0.0473431498,
-0.0225441083,
0.0392363369,
0.0422737114,
0.0157268345,
-0.0235347096,
0.0185477659,
0.0356732979,
-0.0430436321,
-0.0072419904,
-0.0202373825,
0.0418390483,
-0.0672903284,
-0.0038699962,
0.0477925204,
0.0211023279,
-0.0019037853,
0.0296847746,
-0.0881453007,
-0.040380504,
0.0409202613,
0.0408255197,
0.0177877452,
0.0594533458,
0.0011926463,
-0.0167421643,
0.0135512911,
0.020502558,
-0.0124950921,
0.0290925782,
0.0558394529,
-0.00611836,
-0.0180945396,
0.0156696141,
-0.0306680594,
0.0134310387,
0.0214207657,
0.0689175054,
-0.0325107016,
-0.0082098013,
0.007461234,
-0.0106984824,
0.0393364243,
-0.0347588435,
0.0399631858,
-0.0020384612,
0.0522731245,
-0.0043307464,
0.0274579842,
-0.0242259018,
-0.0028107034,
0.0321638919,
-0.0125826271,
0.0104098972,
0.0185637064,
-0.0051861713,
0.0084022945,
0.008598947,
0.029862158,
0.0048547341,
-0.0360668786,
0.0398530215,
0.0200480446,
-0.0111262966,
-0.0108287092,
0.0483737551,
0.0253754929,
-0.0251302216,
0.0420898423,
0.0179666337,
0.0057466794,
-0.0107761836,
-0.0005144273,
-0.0280857384,
-0.0011045648,
-0.0123670744,
0.0068351058,
0.0420155637,
-0.0197878573,
0.0256337915,
-0.0262329504,
-0.0009834527,
0.0123981675,
0.0159456283,
-0.0053848745,
0.0158906486,
0.0289416853,
0.0071650627,
0.0168654956,
0.0025346316,
0.0842986032,
0.0105307288,
0.041401729,
-0.0222278051,
0.010769587,
-0.0454113148,
-0.0302903224,
0.0213103276,
-0.0057599503,
-0.0265896916,
-0.0122337574,
-0.0502957068,
-0.0592988916,
0.0619898848,
-0.0360812992,
0.0097414479,
-0.0058983262,
0.0372563265,
0.0365046598,
0.0022685737,
0.0300205722,
-0.0009067248,
-0.0053434293,
0.0332586765,
-0.0119160702,
0.0074382443,
-5.705873823e-33,
-0.0368105881,
0.0065985792,
0.0176875312,
-0.0076873912,
-0.0289515723,
0.0054662987,
-0.0387223512,
0.0082673943,
-0.0195907839,
-0.020359166,
-0.0240269862,
0.0087550962,
0.0213640258,
0.0367704295,
-0.0371426381,
-0.022255538,
0.0611504801,
0.0096522234,
-0.0035510689,
0.023143772,
0.0410380028,
0.0741351172,
0.0806798711,
-0.0274028555,
-0.0324786901,
-0.0055655395,
0.0255670864,
0.0090208761,
0.0363166966,
0.0468348004,
-0.0350289457,
0.0277565718,
0.0120838014,
-0.0824659392,
-0.0043104608,
0.0345606804,
-0.1263917685,
0.0059406403,
-0.0082635907,
0.0241645034,
-0.0179365538,
-0.0018336223,
0.0110060312,
0.0001968969,
0.0264982507,
-0.0350089297,
0.0409104452,
-0.0123550761,
-0.0417602211,
-0.0593958609,
-0.0733443424,
0.0184341632,
0.0127789285,
-0.0116595533,
0.0098642195,
0.0255783163,
0.0083478661,
0.0584332272,
-0.0561068729,
-0.0212828107,
0.0108969444,
0.0484713838,
0.0376472473,
0.0591751561,
-0.0128752375,
0.029973371,
0.0130865006,
0.0055167754,
-0.0040018591,
-0.0312736034,
0.0687540919,
0.0276743826,
0.029938478,
0.0047578923,
0.019526979,
-0.0083966246,
-0.0862680078,
0.0084832907,
0.0115774656,
0.083630465,
0.0231832098,
0.0123799257,
-0.0154954651,
0.0006613724,
-0.0253712367,
0.0204812307,
-0.0225862861,
-0.0052666808,
0.0080319075,
0.0458424054,
-0.0450793579,
0.0082547078,
0.0719751865,
-0.0164227877,
0.012791872,
0.0260598287,
0.0187762436,
0.0269928612,
-0.0488940515,
0.0331804603,
-0.0359292515,
-0.0348896571,
0.0223290604,
0.0336586051,
0.0065766415,
-0.0086748283,
0.0374784656,
0.0454231054,
-0.0828750357,
-0.0080089085,
-0.0454533175,
0.0342354886,
-0.0308877621,
0.0686911568,
0.0205413662,
0.0187369324,
0.0032466983,
0.0174446031,
-0.0222850703,
-0.0233210213,
0.012598617,
0.0105536059,
0.0395915508,
0.014942199,
-0.0215605423,
-0.010361054,
-0.0407458134,
0.0028213449,
0.0449956469,
-0.080465287,
-0.0036178364,
0.0147192907,
2.527e-7,
0.0373893008,
0.0191152971,
0.0693662986,
-0.0004322488,
0.0176110882,
-0.0069885119,
-0.0116753858,
0.0180325639,
-0.0049645659,
0.0040926905,
0.0082375435,
0.0069393497,
0.0369294025,
-0.0048223236,
-0.1075269654,
-0.0403359644,
-0.0632682964,
0.0107715605,
-0.0332203247,
-0.0110482248,
0.0249133948,
0.1116798297,
-0.0300983842,
-0.0240361001,
-0.0001421862,
-0.0060693719,
0.0944700241,
-0.0076060831,
0.0138074737,
0.0261635669,
0.0259647314,
0.0459375791,
-0.0024661922,
0.0088550476,
-0.0312560126,
0.0010624235,
0.0132389506,
0.0534264855,
-0.0132110855,
-0.0670005381,
0.0498716272,
0.0052116117,
-0.0419744328,
-0.0002949062,
0.0178225003,
-0.0944224149,
-0.012609385,
0.0268045813,
-0.0173340458,
0.028007092,
-0.0095353061,
-0.0249957442,
-0.0210819524,
0.0211665966,
0.0246549826,
-0.0163288061,
0.0020422714,
-0.1076131836,
-0.0161972828,
0.0140318293,
-0.0354192369,
-0.0404159091,
-0.0206151586,
-0.0653121546,
0.0417589024,
-0.0462182984,
-0.0085613877,
2.355547416e-34,
0.0420942307,
-0.0021627119,
-0.0073810327,
0.0428337976,
-0.0065329871,
-0.026430795,
0.0374186747,
0.0032090822,
0.0045513795,
-0.1041987315,
-0.0295844637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08117v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08117v1 | Insights into Classifying and Mitigating LLMs' Hallucinations | 2023-11-14T12:30:28 | 2023-11-14T12:30:28 | Alessandro Bruno, Pier Luigi Mazzeo, Aladine Chetouani, Marouane Tliba, Mohamed Amine Kerkouri | cs.CL | cs.CL | The widespread adoption of large language models (LLMs) across diverse AI
applications is proof of the outstanding achievements obtained in several
tasks, such as text mining, text generation, and question answering. However,
LLMs are not exempt from drawbacks. One of the most concerning aspects regards
the emerging problematic phenomena known as "Hallucinations". They manifest in
text generation systems, particularly in question-answering systems reliant on
LLMs, potentially resulting in false or misleading information propagation.
This paper delves into the underlying causes of AI hallucination and elucidates
its significance in artificial intelligence. In particular, Hallucination
classification is tackled over several tasks (Machine Translation, Question and
Answer, Dialog Systems, Summarisation Systems, Knowledge Graph with LLMs, and
Visual Question Answer). Additionally, we explore potential strategies to
mitigate hallucinations, aiming to enhance the overall reliability of LLMs. Our
research addresses this critical issue within the HeReFaNMi (Health-Related
Fake News Mitigation) project, generously supported by NGI Search, dedicated to
combating Health-Related Fake News dissemination on the Internet. This
endeavour represents a concerted effort to safeguard the integrity of
information dissemination in an age of evolving AI technologies. | [
0.0725846738,
0.0463665612,
-0.0291259419,
0.0344740488,
-0.0306429267,
0.0204913784,
-0.0027236529,
0.0251403563,
0.0427428558,
-0.0453474112,
0.0135076633,
-0.057819847,
0.0134219481,
0.0175230131,
0.0216574222,
-0.0325092003,
0.0505190343,
-0.0163885709,
0.0098622227,
-0.015374897,
0.0190891027,
0.0225718413,
0.014520362,
0.0577938408,
-0.0091453474,
-0.0207304489,
0.0120018702,
0.0046807504,
-0.0113744885,
-0.0136727672,
-0.0239199884,
0.0424398109,
-0.0041686939,
0.0845903531,
0.0000019679,
-0.0449976176,
-0.0022684375,
0.0059992005,
-0.0281375647,
-0.0012200495,
0.023944445,
-0.0261601396,
0.0045294082,
0.0473053977,
-0.0461247303,
0.0124680167,
0.0356461033,
0.0680799708,
0.0910553783,
0.0919060409,
-0.0106167905,
-0.0069840946,
0.0557396673,
0.018142309,
0.0443078391,
-0.0141902678,
0.0528385006,
-0.0033489941,
0.0038032273,
-0.010163256,
0.0235562064,
0.036931973,
0.0011364397,
0.0054967799,
-0.0304420646,
0.0223261937,
-0.0644408837,
-0.0526766405,
0.0039562415,
0.0374198183,
-0.0298851635,
-0.0614341311,
0.0406821556,
0.0167482216,
0.0106231589,
0.0312176626,
-0.034101259,
0.0500752069,
-0.0476226956,
-0.0094774449,
0.0578994118,
-0.0341384076,
0.0432259105,
0.0462099351,
-0.0433051288,
0.0652859882,
-0.0020656062,
-0.0318357982,
-0.0061678509,
-0.0046066195,
0.0012900927,
-0.0830838084,
0.0351149254,
0.0517501198,
-0.0348396115,
0.0039431765,
-0.0495046116,
-0.0096056033,
0.0587263331,
-0.10581211,
-0.0219610669,
-0.0099581694,
-0.0205419064,
0.0216200631,
0.0046616509,
0.0137492884,
-0.0454353727,
0.0682773814,
-0.0109494664,
0.0093183415,
-0.0167239513,
-0.0211363696,
-0.0242583472,
0.0518489853,
-0.0003590807,
-0.0176052265,
-0.0144529166,
0.0293090977,
-0.0339640677,
0.0375020728,
-0.0202178862,
0.0279772691,
0.0064421869,
-0.0209680423,
-0.0087309983,
0.0166441072,
-0.0054846606,
0.0155488858,
0.0157772377,
-0.0676790848,
-0.019273866,
0.0314449184,
-0.030369604,
0.0153643433,
-0.0068287556,
0.0284580495,
0.0285707116,
0.0097034853,
-0.0280585922,
-0.0828966349,
-0.0413544849,
-0.0581868887,
0.0060421708,
-0.0605525859,
-0.0042007985,
-0.0054404722,
-0.0243006665,
-0.0377816334,
0.0201368853,
0.0453370474,
-0.0663336739,
0.0571243167,
-0.0340561979,
0.0061416854,
0.0805325806,
0.055233743,
0.0009156633,
0.0483517461,
0.0188023783,
0.0570134297,
0.0401841253,
0.0224409793,
0.0749180242,
0.0151764322,
0.0250575319,
0.0229651686,
-0.0061772405,
-0.0038481504,
-0.0283100698,
0.0004359671,
-0.0502570011,
0.0840500072,
-0.0143475719,
-0.004939443,
0.0852659643,
0.0136293508,
-0.0238576923,
0.0079161506,
0.0228582434,
-0.0169814937,
-0.0007907511,
0.0648890585,
-0.0463903509,
0.0006288212,
-0.0625291169,
-0.0204047542,
0.0349899158,
0.0228657965,
-0.0037731749,
-0.0453095138,
-0.0205478519,
-0.0025357064,
0.0061023617,
-0.0034498239,
-0.0063882782,
0.0148064764,
-0.0355369076,
0.0181458332,
0.004001115,
-0.0237745009,
0.0250002332,
-0.0773666278,
-0.0014013184,
0.0811745152,
0.0696174726,
-0.0188216865,
0.0074195289,
-0.0377341956,
0.0320379324,
0.0466942303,
0.0142101357,
-0.0106810732,
-0.0501584075,
-0.0194174759,
0.0082372101,
0.0063597579,
0.0307210758,
-0.0376180746,
-0.0195755884,
0.0300609842,
-0.0080632949,
0.0062867245,
-0.0752038211,
0.026868511,
-0.0027154055,
0.0021085273,
-0.0329833739,
-0.0002263795,
0.0208213646,
0.0187656432,
-0.0188668668,
0.0376691744,
0.0323601365,
-0.0341154523,
-0.0586072803,
-0.0067849634,
-0.0119402632,
0.0110588707,
0.0149953486,
-0.0254191551,
0.018942954,
0.0101941666,
-0.0038075012,
-0.0222615041,
0.0070919134,
-0.0701443553,
0.0151575021,
-0.0357079431,
0.0474314764,
-0.0159530398,
0.050275553,
-0.011229299,
0.0670197979,
-0.0560127124,
-0.0127420565,
0.0339438766,
-0.0170019697,
-0.0094235074,
-0.0090142302,
0.0000907107,
0.0279561747,
0.0210574791,
0.0373470597,
0.0183088575,
-0.0540179983,
-0.0283884443,
-0.0270205438,
-0.0784194693,
0.0063111433,
-0.0240596645,
0.0077288565,
0.036543645,
-0.010994304,
-0.003032428,
0.0101680299,
-0.0283869859,
-0.009169206,
0.026442742,
0.0370275527,
0.0223102495,
0.0057638553,
-0.0164190065,
0.0116964802,
0.0235646851,
-0.0369033404,
0.0464338176,
0.0101046665,
-0.0627942383,
-0.0944165289,
0.0188525822,
-0.0752685145,
-0.0045873327,
-0.0016292855,
-0.0075069321,
0.0069305524,
0.0003657277,
0.0072246278,
0.0590030067,
0.05866348,
0.0346490145,
0.0609558076,
0.0328860618,
-0.0200083256,
-0.0338910818,
-0.0051318328,
0.0215886664,
0.0052795941,
-0.0715633333,
0.026813291,
0.015905628,
0.0424432568,
0.0037630363,
-0.030792404,
0.0893174112,
-0.0432231762,
-0.0456664115,
0.02201996,
-0.0706931502,
-0.0240821373,
0.0430244803,
-0.0273471158,
-0.0473772474,
0.078789413,
-0.0223500375,
0.0584918261,
-0.0320092067,
-0.0167214982,
-0.0018010925,
-0.0010070954,
-0.0102729686,
0.043188531,
0.0169042498,
-0.0069082938,
-0.0217850246,
-0.0135204457,
-0.0079082847,
-0.0593874641,
0.0195568949,
-0.0385996848,
-0.010104212,
0.0266716611,
-0.0256568659,
-0.0551808327,
-0.0618542023,
-0.005200611,
-0.0414700136,
-0.0072639063,
0.0059537352,
-0.030538084,
-0.0036976165,
0.0292239301,
0.0202605557,
-0.0297982562,
-0.0165506508,
-0.0023390669,
0.0301019568,
0.0695740506,
-0.0252847932,
0.0699325129,
-0.0260872561,
0.0307124108,
0.0946863964,
0.0197510663,
0.0391439535,
0.0226773489,
-0.0349871367,
0.0126617188,
-0.0165259466,
-0.0430768318,
0.0152906049,
0.0082673058,
-0.055938676,
-0.0356455743,
0.0777665377,
0.0524513014,
-0.0503604636,
0.0173654146,
-0.0218960885,
0.0181472059,
-0.0087986831,
-0.011745302,
-0.0840321109,
0.0199473966,
-0.0053710588,
0.0012412306,
-0.0729541406,
-0.0245070457,
-0.0173983667,
-0.0612549037,
0.0269047916,
0.0217514336,
-0.0121833198,
-0.0352022499,
-0.0342556909,
-0.0363034084,
0.0575548187,
0.035711579,
-0.0143685751,
0.0338520892,
-0.033486478,
0.0181733165,
-0.040518593,
-0.0131308557,
-0.0124637373,
-0.009453618,
0.0553230718,
0.0688253939,
0.0428474694,
-0.0238991659,
-0.0503861457,
0.0282175522,
-0.0022642773,
-0.0101467399,
-0.0191716608,
0.0830213875,
0.0080957497,
0.0079640038,
-0.0214349218,
0.0161816757,
-0.0201573446,
-0.013979475,
0.0203122552,
0.0856186226,
-0.0540085584,
-0.0837499276,
-0.031054683,
0.0336137973,
0.0217936765,
0.0561992303,
0.0172566585,
-0.0241338667,
-0.0464047492,
-0.0371192619,
0.0469382666,
-0.0205110367,
-0.0534992889,
0.0458281972,
0.0379066654,
-0.038032569,
-0.0942143202,
-0.0288181826,
-0.0286349244,
0.0153634539,
0.0073353075,
0.0391472243,
0.0076559829,
-0.0160342306,
-0.0064692702,
-0.0079575181,
-0.0187911578,
0.0083703957,
0.0026053041,
0.0098392572,
0.0148390755,
-0.0161240865,
0.0180071983,
0.0301638599,
-0.0703058243,
-0.0517892949,
0.013760577,
0.0336576551,
0.0321313217,
0.0285322629,
-0.0079363715,
-0.0472518876,
0.0844117105,
0.0287700612,
0.0005218504,
0.0164965261,
0.0152174663,
0.0003323039,
0.0179483816,
0.0175525881,
-0.0184851829,
-0.0027182777,
-0.0129087418,
-0.019103827,
-0.0429277159,
-0.0046701725,
0.0299561992,
0.0244209077,
-0.0380787291,
-0.020855004,
0.0042834682,
-0.003968854,
0.0011622143,
-0.047621794,
-0.0306658521,
-0.0017164552,
0.0073016915,
0.0203341246,
-0.0027741273,
0.0113121206,
0.0015933694,
-0.0541281588,
-0.0163077842,
-0.0271769259,
-0.0311247688,
0.0078344727,
0.0390977003,
0.0295672398,
-0.0169304609,
-0.0350258462,
0.0338860676,
-0.0007955208,
0.0526893213,
-0.0052936599,
0.0516212694,
0.0111475317,
-0.0392688401,
0.0073016961,
0.0350659937,
-0.0700126514,
-0.0873420984,
-0.0210910421,
0.0314841978,
0.0396712087,
0.0287246704,
0.0476124808,
-0.0022065772,
-0.0041610179,
-0.0071855732,
-0.0061611105,
0.036522001,
-0.0359273776,
-0.0299781598,
0.0120197441,
-0.035417553,
0.0202624034,
0.083740212,
-0.0245898478,
0.0452784896,
0.0130068781,
-0.0707403719,
-0.0179633871,
-0.0526354834,
-0.0569563806,
0.0210261773,
-0.0228399467,
-0.0407632478,
-0.0837860256,
-0.0579460189,
0.0053796382,
-0.0024437641,
0.0208548941,
-0.0157742184,
-0.0072123236,
0.0729158297,
0.0241760369,
-0.0128119076,
-0.0432803556,
0.0179400742,
0.0067806793,
0.0052512861,
0.0253055319,
-6.474994634e-33,
0.0238786694,
-0.080995366,
0.004191454,
-0.0197256245,
-0.0147838555,
0.005910133,
-0.0082374495,
-0.0015379846,
-0.0111501729,
0.0160949547,
0.0098912539,
0.0285704136,
0.0024002073,
0.0028253959,
-0.0287604313,
-0.0328378901,
0.0302095283,
-0.0073815407,
-0.0401028879,
0.0457400158,
0.0388244428,
-0.0135802813,
-0.0149109587,
-0.0724481493,
0.0587399602,
-0.0364449248,
-0.0393075086,
0.0160998404,
-0.0301844515,
0.0440253988,
-0.0063641942,
0.0566244498,
0.0450030901,
-0.0159738734,
-0.0171321891,
0.0418474451,
-0.0071985102,
-0.0225496925,
0.0185901225,
0.0078870226,
-0.0226153992,
-0.0411365032,
0.0717563704,
-0.0325498879,
0.006720643,
0.0072477623,
0.0258181226,
-0.0372566022,
-0.0214234497,
-0.0028651194,
-0.0327817611,
-0.0117568579,
0.012750973,
0.0100049768,
-0.0100042531,
0.0529124364,
0.0010981779,
0.0064637461,
-0.0847187191,
0.0219942275,
-0.0043361653,
-0.0144419651,
0.0509004742,
-0.0319740623,
-0.0113048702,
0.0579863228,
0.0627041236,
0.0318072736,
-0.0658690259,
-0.01901922,
-0.0212935805,
0.0406418368,
0.0650650412,
0.02176998,
0.0151258213,
-0.0296362117,
-0.0667973831,
0.0142095573,
-0.0477008931,
-0.0053970129,
0.0629365817,
-0.05334647,
-0.0721042603,
-0.0226649754,
-0.0078454204,
0.0053034229,
-0.0445646867,
-0.0238123164,
0.007838768,
0.0114400312,
-0.0204236247,
0.0104791708,
0.0104370043,
-0.0688976347,
0.020658467,
0.0319571272,
-0.0099326931,
-0.0152306613,
0.003376689,
0.0177028123,
0.0067655589,
0.0121589219,
0.0035080193,
-0.0039867717,
0.0404644273,
0.0253078472,
0.0380321182,
-0.0097021293,
-0.0548489392,
-0.0005980125,
-0.0323874839,
0.0315755568,
0.0116268974,
-0.0131618278,
0.0421215966,
-0.0095402459,
-0.0131050637,
-0.0129482811,
0.0358513296,
0.0438125096,
-0.0356392637,
0.019658979,
-0.0448706336,
0.0217206571,
-0.0526261404,
-0.0185744017,
-0.0370452739,
0.0366739221,
0.0366735868,
-0.1135184616,
-0.0187107287,
-0.0455969274,
2.823e-7,
0.0112176994,
0.0713398606,
0.0093062893,
0.0284552891,
0.0398735106,
0.0267959479,
0.0288702194,
0.0146080088,
-0.0096386252,
-0.0404141881,
-0.0120384097,
0.0300176721,
0.0211230554,
0.0603855215,
-0.0543460213,
-0.0115159675,
-0.0630761236,
0.0181536861,
-0.0762761831,
-0.0150980735,
0.0492928624,
0.0575927123,
0.0061277905,
-0.0366133191,
-0.0195518229,
-0.0484014302,
0.0419124998,
0.0349446051,
-0.0064532883,
0.0390169248,
0.0529802181,
0.0304345693,
0.0232022088,
0.046255473,
-0.0230203252,
-0.0358342789,
-0.0046886513,
0.0312496256,
-0.0253775325,
-0.0474415384,
-0.0147244399,
-0.0463887341,
0.04721855,
-0.0841968134,
0.085209243,
-0.0117846234,
-0.0350135267,
-0.0250039808,
-0.0130076334,
-0.0521710664,
0.0401096791,
-0.0082710786,
-0.0098498054,
0.040936619,
-0.0115256775,
0.0565475225,
0.0468078814,
-0.0522889718,
-0.0069797174,
-0.0072574993,
-0.0245108791,
-0.0527825952,
0.0003223113,
-0.0038207925,
-0.0163194779,
-0.0730583742,
0.0345917977,
2.914151515e-34,
0.0111927437,
-0.0166885052,
0.0168184508,
0.0302424971,
0.0251334608,
0.0109170182,
0.0203169417,
0.0009047317,
0.0344395116,
-0.0348946638,
-0.0169004966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08110v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08110v2 | Improving Hateful Meme Detection through Retrieval-Guided Contrastive Learning | 2023-11-14T12:14:54 | 2024-06-04T23:06:36 | Jingbiao Mei, Jinghong Chen, Weizhe Lin, Bill Byrne, Marcus Tomalin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Hateful memes have emerged as a significant concern on the Internet.
Detecting hateful memes requires the system to jointly understand the visual
and textual modalities. Our investigation reveals that the embedding space of
existing CLIP-based systems lacks sensitivity to subtle differences in memes
that are vital for correct hatefulness classification. We propose constructing
a hatefulness-aware embedding space through retrieval-guided contrastive
training. Our approach achieves state-of-the-art performance on the
HatefulMemes dataset with an AUROC of 87.0, outperforming much larger
fine-tuned large multimodal models. We demonstrate a retrieval-based hateful
memes detection system, which is capable of identifying hatefulness based on
data unseen in training. This allows developers to update the hateful memes
detection system by simply adding new examples without retraining, a desirable
feature for real services in the constantly evolving landscape of hateful memes
on the Internet. | [
0.0667197257,
0.0635389313,
-0.0246714447,
0.0522296168,
0.0071042855,
0.0336102024,
0.0073979315,
0.0256677289,
0.00117937,
-0.0563612133,
-0.0312086754,
-0.0257241204,
-0.0312005728,
0.0166141652,
0.0127839427,
-0.0644761622,
0.0135425376,
0.0672960058,
0.0190487523,
-0.0044584535,
0.0587460659,
-0.0038754102,
0.0187403671,
0.0434653424,
-0.0772245526,
-0.0180276688,
0.0584096014,
0.0301367305,
0.0498579293,
-0.0247586258,
0.0708936974,
0.0059168809,
0.0042344662,
0.036319267,
0.0000018804,
-0.0041216481,
0.0150627168,
-0.0034113773,
0.0123649007,
-0.0504136942,
0.0959513336,
-0.0440086722,
0.0045069554,
0.0380468778,
-0.0337629281,
0.010603291,
0.0733084157,
0.0583141483,
0.0876575708,
0.0642585456,
-0.0225336682,
-0.0376384221,
-0.0038765559,
0.0010027608,
0.013419548,
0.0392381698,
-0.0003968722,
-0.0459305085,
-0.054443378,
0.0342940316,
-0.0242556389,
0.0224365424,
0.0144976117,
0.0475478061,
0.0281017628,
-0.0100989826,
-0.0212431978,
-0.0195131004,
0.0107493317,
0.0481656939,
-0.0381088927,
0.0109301517,
-0.0159705896,
0.0006117516,
-0.003352219,
-0.0316143483,
-0.0432118364,
-0.0051696897,
-0.0152348755,
0.030319104,
-0.0230570547,
0.0121305855,
0.038969256,
0.0399983414,
-0.0102564199,
-0.0601090863,
-0.0043322458,
-0.0282961726,
0.0067207678,
-0.0101350276,
-0.019309435,
0.027861746,
0.0109156277,
-0.0041018799,
-0.0092053292,
0.0058712615,
-0.0665711239,
-0.0679739937,
0.0064963391,
-0.0407221206,
0.0443317927,
0.0125265187,
-0.0768784136,
0.0103376321,
0.0161311943,
0.0332582742,
-0.0058724764,
0.0052971193,
-0.008590905,
0.0046160426,
0.0072574969,
-0.0013255916,
0.0182146765,
-0.0090779616,
-0.0257854629,
0.01107758,
-0.0392344706,
0.0005484484,
-0.069996126,
-0.0245889407,
-0.0253915768,
0.0166206621,
-0.0084969178,
0.0086101545,
-0.0227991361,
0.0144683244,
-0.0241599623,
-0.0040024668,
-0.0339110568,
-0.0827993453,
-0.006697461,
0.0212382693,
-0.0097188186,
-0.0168234501,
0.0376675241,
0.0908824131,
0.0434978306,
-0.0571462773,
-0.0389813855,
-0.0350561999,
-0.0492821783,
-0.0284150131,
0.0266639162,
-0.0563818701,
-0.0005698458,
-0.0339892805,
-0.0213386957,
-0.081501618,
0.0077338,
0.0137047721,
-0.0362130366,
0.0922412649,
-0.0084510259,
-0.055967886,
0.0026509531,
0.036287304,
-0.0331884958,
0.0358985588,
-0.0181949139,
0.0559761338,
0.0628725737,
0.0015371767,
-0.0080774771,
0.0208021998,
0.0562724955,
-0.0104497233,
-0.0586819425,
0.0283912253,
-0.0459285788,
-0.0295351092,
0.0347479992,
0.0570387878,
-0.0266728532,
-0.1048198864,
0.0469723232,
0.0606170148,
-0.0465357974,
0.0388340503,
0.0253426116,
0.0315646529,
-0.0338458866,
-0.0290153809,
-0.0527987927,
0.0259026065,
-0.0280400924,
-0.0208306629,
0.0617369302,
0.0705518872,
-0.0220992267,
-0.0466077998,
-0.0229543,
-0.0332421623,
0.0086481702,
-0.0447603017,
0.0579195358,
0.0264175665,
-0.0379099064,
-0.0056349318,
0.0466718711,
-0.0328130722,
-0.017089719,
-0.0250983331,
0.0088028321,
0.0619006418,
0.0145070367,
-0.0264405776,
-0.0162316673,
-0.0386810564,
-0.0340354107,
0.0176697411,
-0.0231396146,
-0.0012121319,
0.0197924394,
-0.0289508123,
-0.0221985914,
-0.0124942698,
-0.004782463,
0.0203304458,
0.0314019285,
0.0303485859,
0.0159170013,
0.056708809,
-0.0104868812,
0.0201964229,
0.0249471515,
-0.0176588148,
-0.0126981633,
0.049341999,
0.0599110872,
0.0041512409,
-0.04108385,
-0.0483385399,
0.0234355647,
-0.0385988727,
-0.0324491002,
0.014434088,
-0.0467900261,
-0.0559616461,
0.036627356,
-0.101292327,
-0.0026396343,
0.1207256466,
-0.0008709977,
0.0385907069,
0.0977372676,
-0.0343926139,
0.021388419,
-0.0220954902,
-0.0380488224,
-0.0269507319,
0.0280139968,
-0.0153683955,
0.0743736923,
-0.0461840108,
-0.0117886011,
0.0264744237,
-0.0245841332,
0.0270508081,
0.0452227555,
-0.0550515689,
-0.0594018772,
-0.0432560556,
0.0094767669,
-0.0052834838,
0.0016712161,
-0.0394715853,
0.0075029051,
-0.0720969513,
-0.0099529997,
-0.0281963665,
-0.0253830124,
-0.0007541401,
-0.0021054016,
0.0067227962,
-0.026987277,
-0.0275794957,
-0.0209307652,
0.0134033961,
0.039309945,
-0.0133692957,
-0.034260612,
0.0258715842,
-0.0682236329,
-0.01864543,
0.0319342613,
0.0225303974,
-0.0197522379,
-0.012144547,
0.0394997522,
0.0221557394,
-0.0263874289,
0.0367734544,
-0.0173867885,
-0.0476094671,
0.0318938307,
0.0065061371,
0.0179574303,
0.0618206188,
0.0573347285,
0.1231969893,
-0.0245875008,
0.0131547553,
-0.0339165889,
0.0221575834,
-0.0072455485,
0.0139590986,
-0.0157278366,
-0.0288044848,
0.0003486103,
0.0600017309,
0.0216152407,
0.0037701689,
-0.0588790812,
0.0645135641,
-0.0298635177,
-0.0332215987,
-0.0100367665,
-0.0122515364,
0.013041676,
-0.046621073,
-0.0427871458,
-0.0906562507,
0.0481614359,
0.0124322455,
-0.0145992553,
0.0213453099,
-0.015006463,
0.0204809383,
0.0724163353,
0.0012588182,
0.031052243,
-0.02161658,
0.010800791,
-0.0020790501,
-0.0262314789,
0.0057766312,
-0.0254235175,
-0.0180283748,
-0.0052374788,
0.0045882598,
0.0068712439,
-0.0840006694,
-0.0612823963,
-0.0501755662,
-0.0206888169,
-0.0621552095,
0.0362876095,
-0.0087980507,
-0.0250699464,
0.0167448502,
0.0252489373,
-0.0257214159,
0.0001806177,
-0.0411977209,
0.0375445858,
0.0058038784,
0.0470697805,
-0.0215412509,
0.0283078868,
-0.0070340447,
-0.0493655764,
0.0637008846,
-0.0067763017,
0.0015267136,
-0.0363961235,
0.0103582097,
0.0253857076,
0.0349037163,
-0.0057871067,
-0.0204619411,
0.0092021078,
-0.0010142674,
-0.0190848988,
0.0503700525,
-0.0073110829,
-0.0192044731,
-0.0005779694,
0.0215715468,
-0.0119980089,
0.0298256371,
-0.0191691704,
-0.0421613753,
-0.0440754406,
-0.0618777834,
0.032365527,
-0.0317467488,
0.0132174315,
0.005882388,
-0.0746926293,
0.0276512913,
0.0105408588,
-0.0152390748,
-0.0523610003,
0.0365666263,
0.0346923061,
-0.0208348017,
0.0003891689,
-0.025332557,
0.0067752888,
0.0079850536,
-0.0092107477,
-0.0207342058,
-0.0158283394,
-0.022914866,
-0.03414106,
0.0152851529,
0.0378000513,
0.0360644273,
0.0003081922,
-0.0757144019,
-0.003518072,
-0.0072350092,
0.0009402753,
-0.063177526,
0.0942575857,
-0.023527395,
-0.0289391857,
-0.0313845053,
-0.0024026139,
-0.0115476577,
0.016720552,
-0.0324310139,
0.043656271,
0.0021409611,
0.025085222,
-0.0939547345,
0.020894289,
0.0225329697,
0.045438651,
0.0335380621,
-0.0463153608,
-0.0009367426,
-0.0383354798,
0.0077341245,
-0.0451906919,
-0.0458972305,
-0.0292444974,
-0.0022442618,
0.0239272527,
-0.0364515074,
-0.0371762738,
-0.0196650047,
0.0283358358,
-0.0017698799,
-0.0490555614,
-0.0429118313,
-0.0112309558,
-0.0758877471,
0.0270034783,
-0.0020506892,
0.0214298852,
-0.0172840767,
-0.0172666032,
0.0184813794,
-0.0205562953,
-0.0339392573,
0.021520596,
-0.0326037258,
-0.0326420926,
0.0015470306,
0.0963268504,
0.0117949406,
0.0333193988,
0.0182535574,
-0.0112792756,
0.0857129321,
0.0653445274,
-0.0131786885,
-0.0200303849,
0.0582827926,
-0.0251794364,
0.0257737916,
0.0178050473,
-0.0199706387,
0.0383025706,
0.0353926234,
-0.0433206074,
-0.0226207618,
0.0153938103,
-0.0144103756,
-0.0486446805,
0.0763157606,
0.0062849745,
-0.0033090811,
0.0062822727,
-0.007981875,
0.0092097307,
-0.0141215688,
-0.0326591805,
0.0070818583,
-0.0024855528,
0.0156200659,
-0.0377820209,
-0.0186207406,
0.00757467,
0.0216854792,
-0.0378897376,
0.0010813997,
0.0544354431,
0.0009127852,
0.0137640527,
0.0384289697,
-0.0033758543,
0.0251106471,
0.0052230824,
0.0003681243,
-0.014757094,
0.0270105228,
0.001367139,
-0.0011306852,
0.010293426,
0.0271443203,
0.0397189595,
-0.0209747981,
-0.0440555476,
-0.0589474887,
0.0249551702,
-0.0348604769,
0.0221649967,
0.0148691637,
-0.0108010834,
-0.0136559978,
-0.009455204,
-0.0412970632,
-0.05260906,
-0.0020257807,
0.0324802026,
-0.0170953758,
-0.0161694791,
0.0511796065,
-0.0619922914,
0.0276385266,
0.0270262361,
-0.0527948067,
-0.0289846864,
0.0329366177,
0.0722954348,
0.0500567034,
0.0284925997,
0.0253909845,
-0.0425520875,
-0.0634945035,
0.0273830574,
-0.0251788106,
0.0230447035,
0.0324038006,
0.0266281869,
0.0655125529,
0.0239457358,
0.0039816857,
0.0201140605,
-0.0021914977,
-0.0303072594,
-0.0531570241,
-0.001007507,
-6.012543769e-33,
0.0001062491,
-0.0159406532,
-0.0264975987,
-0.0293429438,
-0.0172583051,
-0.0009018605,
0.019226037,
-0.0026663381,
0.0228155274,
0.0155994473,
0.0112215299,
0.022598505,
-0.0106948968,
0.0257057603,
-0.000509308,
-0.0037262908,
0.0278182868,
0.0256160423,
-0.0011689147,
0.0051228032,
0.0528068952,
0.0420005098,
0.0122256177,
-0.0599914566,
-0.0075227087,
-0.0116149401,
0.0006676578,
0.0186481941,
0.055429887,
0.0759689584,
-0.0152242463,
0.0883858576,
0.0325772427,
-0.0098765483,
-0.0215519778,
0.0278551206,
-0.05360974,
-0.0239688307,
-0.0043136594,
-0.0037466639,
-0.0411663763,
-0.0193804428,
0.0768492743,
0.0019132725,
-0.0221773311,
-0.0508070476,
0.0437153876,
-0.0165493805,
0.0280886237,
-0.021904951,
-0.0661020428,
0.010519092,
-0.0290502496,
-0.0200612694,
0.0124562057,
0.0442586839,
0.0618220866,
0.0243860595,
-0.0733519569,
0.0373141505,
-0.0431540757,
-0.0352994204,
-0.00121095,
0.0081803519,
0.0315299705,
0.0871675834,
-0.0106776766,
0.0126938513,
0.0231699813,
-0.00559755,
0.0233755242,
0.0407610983,
0.045899529,
0.0556951202,
0.0623099394,
-0.0580038615,
-0.0310775433,
0.018399749,
-0.0199236404,
0.0222460162,
0.0224854648,
0.0108131748,
-0.0518125631,
0.0106923245,
0.0324814096,
-0.0553639308,
-0.0282542612,
-0.0659805909,
0.0391713157,
-0.0246632509,
-0.016023986,
-0.0058630244,
0.0347909592,
-0.0378082506,
0.0199793726,
0.0536274388,
-0.0179980919,
-0.0057117059,
0.0238577668,
0.0155161908,
-0.0256752167,
0.0378397554,
0.0244422127,
-0.0278550535,
0.0139925508,
0.0019912207,
0.0740121305,
0.0290964376,
-0.083064191,
-0.0012819389,
-0.0189354438,
0.0382091142,
-0.0285926946,
0.0445256233,
0.0183326267,
0.0542997606,
-0.0215612035,
-0.0211359877,
0.0104970196,
-0.007363711,
-0.0611003563,
-0.0190864932,
-0.0253074039,
0.0070996592,
0.0039462373,
-0.0305889621,
-0.0369277447,
0.0222482756,
-0.0049649538,
-0.1060009301,
0.002457882,
-0.0275281854,
2.594e-7,
-0.0272574741,
0.0164624956,
0.0173616856,
0.0243777111,
0.0272521134,
0.053684745,
0.0257648099,
0.0215166789,
0.0040659029,
0.0048721679,
-0.0031590736,
0.0602479875,
0.0109403944,
0.0405603833,
0.0032876069,
-0.0022824456,
-0.0530197732,
0.003431143,
-0.0271378551,
0.0004509625,
0.0538664907,
0.0820141956,
0.0697660893,
-0.0581950173,
0.0019273991,
-0.0165370423,
0.0319068357,
-0.036592003,
0.0328602791,
-0.0730478168,
0.029899938,
0.0446130373,
-0.0035227367,
-0.0506802201,
0.0029450359,
-0.0115342215,
0.0008941682,
0.0171030425,
0.0047825612,
-0.012669811,
0.0222052317,
0.0392528847,
-0.0041896719,
-0.0146213146,
0.0167639609,
-0.0261560827,
0.0093078483,
-0.0856262594,
-0.0205659699,
-0.0261471346,
0.0510772653,
-0.0150417639,
-0.0269050412,
-0.0136784771,
0.0329729021,
0.0072604162,
0.0137663819,
-0.1198688075,
0.0070820325,
0.0357139409,
-0.0179293156,
0.0113586336,
-0.037718527,
-0.0030424481,
0.0495322198,
0.0347440317,
0.021581525,
1.766542668e-34,
0.0162512865,
-0.0455837771,
0.0140798241,
-0.0174724218,
0.0129543263,
0.0160289928,
-0.0222630445,
-0.0191197749,
0.0430106036,
-0.0214197449,
-0.0002631328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08107v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08107v2 | SAIE Framework: Support Alone Isn't Enough -- Advancing LLM Training with Adversarial Remarks | 2023-11-14T12:12:25 | 2024-03-01T00:42:58 | Mengsay Loem, Masahiro Kaneko, Naoaki Okazaki | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) can justify or critique their predictions
through discussions with other models or humans, thereby enriching their
intrinsic understanding of instances. While proactive discussions in the
inference phase have been shown to boost performance, such interactions have
not been extensively explored during the training phase. We hypothesize that
incorporating interactive discussions into the training process can enhance the
models' understanding and improve their reasoning and verbal expression
abilities during inference. This work introduces the SAIE framework, which
facilitates supportive and adversarial discussions between learner and partner
models. The learner model receives responses from the partner, and its
parameters are then updated based on this discussion. This dynamic adjustment
process continues throughout the training phase, responding to the evolving
outputs of the learner model. Our empirical evaluation across various tasks,
including math problems, commonsense reasoning, and multi-domain knowledge,
demonstrates that models fine-tuned with the SAIE framework outperform those
trained with conventional fine-tuning approaches. Furthermore, our method
enhances the models' reasoning capabilities, improving both individual and
multi-agent inference performance. | [
0.0474700443,
0.0945753828,
-0.013307523,
0.0533163622,
-0.0293545146,
0.0148124201,
0.0264848229,
-0.0301978216,
-0.0097474474,
-0.0658033788,
-0.0639463365,
-0.0026277923,
-0.0047552511,
-0.0175310317,
0.0489120819,
-0.0682384223,
0.0391031466,
-0.0323545896,
0.0081478627,
-0.0100742858,
0.0135448417,
-0.003613217,
-0.0257633924,
0.0116391731,
-0.0137014473,
-0.0115336534,
-0.0265009254,
-0.0043198611,
0.0237985961,
-0.0120768324,
0.0142781455,
0.0614274964,
0.0540967956,
0.0454978645,
0.0000019822,
-0.0413577557,
0.0031853763,
0.0092429509,
-0.0574159287,
0.0268155597,
0.0228351504,
-0.0037663488,
0.008072502,
-0.0157863293,
-0.0577742122,
-0.0095323259,
0.0286993291,
0.0533132404,
0.0673156381,
0.0634817183,
-0.0003187713,
-0.0343253985,
-0.0038364574,
-0.0356001817,
-0.0207555722,
-0.0899972692,
0.0205824599,
0.0220706426,
-0.0247563757,
-0.0047389306,
-0.0187870748,
0.0243379772,
0.0628572479,
-0.0315218121,
0.0068572657,
0.0311679523,
-0.0211619046,
-0.0242623203,
0.0032543538,
0.0641112775,
0.0404393785,
-0.0285019651,
-0.0394185968,
0.0059028403,
0.0316554494,
0.0537035763,
-0.0512188487,
0.0102939578,
0.0052312654,
0.0087424153,
0.0092844814,
-0.021744268,
0.0482736044,
0.040646743,
0.0095949275,
0.0480610467,
-0.0075784586,
-0.0118990969,
0.0098548532,
0.0167279989,
-0.0567589253,
-0.0518746041,
-0.0094006993,
0.0355647355,
-0.0412290394,
0.0200787149,
-0.0317369513,
-0.0398649126,
-0.0051165996,
-0.0405143276,
0.0577457808,
0.0334450752,
-0.0128714908,
0.0432570614,
-0.0384301357,
0.0032754887,
-0.0008957234,
0.0264287367,
-0.0083082272,
-0.0024909766,
-0.0472240448,
-0.0315949023,
-0.0281386431,
0.0127359387,
-0.0595599003,
0.0163278822,
-0.0288826358,
0.0404219776,
-0.0262205712,
0.0217209533,
-0.0099993451,
0.0412241556,
-0.0218789075,
-0.01794184,
-0.0676982477,
0.0116158817,
-0.0638133436,
0.0272110067,
0.0227275919,
-0.0508663096,
-0.0496931411,
0.033010181,
-0.0250988416,
-0.0201554801,
-0.0144195482,
0.1051924825,
-0.0222374089,
0.0005266039,
-0.0287699383,
-0.0189944394,
-0.0163278878,
-0.076733686,
0.0036458916,
-0.0146254459,
0.0098812152,
-0.0146116232,
-0.0137631819,
-0.0469017439,
0.0123471115,
-0.0288050696,
-0.0037741899,
0.110264957,
-0.0256747119,
-0.0137742059,
0.0299789216,
0.0566987135,
-0.0169759728,
0.0660917014,
0.0121429414,
-0.0110242143,
0.0064389929,
-0.0053699869,
-0.0016558317,
0.0088358205,
0.0349335074,
0.012132708,
-0.0253667515,
0.0115077067,
-0.0125386659,
0.0512947403,
0.0157701615,
0.04698449,
-0.0457677767,
-0.0459533744,
0.0753201544,
0.0462460965,
-0.0145706134,
0.0558489673,
0.0250457134,
0.0220168829,
0.007317204,
0.0180499014,
-0.0677843615,
0.0401304364,
-0.0171849784,
-0.0125242639,
0.0167232398,
-0.0100629525,
-0.0278085619,
-0.0686123222,
-0.0133525524,
-0.0200753473,
0.0462211668,
0.0551289357,
0.0467036031,
0.0342705883,
-0.0227598567,
0.0505226627,
0.0452137552,
-0.031243233,
-0.0032391201,
-0.0762384534,
0.0507574081,
0.0491315648,
0.0437048189,
-0.0240167491,
-0.0373299941,
-0.013955269,
0.0209098607,
0.0490272641,
0.051794298,
-0.0319726057,
0.0325017646,
-0.0444073565,
-0.0302420091,
-0.0607142486,
0.0223727003,
0.0358261205,
0.0421053655,
-0.0382966325,
0.022720255,
-0.0064881593,
-0.0179876816,
0.037914183,
-0.0427102596,
-0.0105029754,
-0.0176989026,
-0.0005179013,
0.0312090963,
0.0048998673,
-0.0168851707,
0.0046188436,
0.0392882302,
-0.010813511,
-0.0193558969,
0.0536075458,
-0.0412801616,
-0.0454589799,
0.0253791884,
-0.0057979166,
-0.0346736349,
0.0090689762,
-0.0268816575,
-0.0089107305,
0.0490660593,
-0.0156688951,
0.0133492937,
-0.0394699164,
-0.0002160159,
-0.0062928214,
-0.0069492934,
-0.0262784567,
0.0585693009,
0.0196894631,
-0.0374495052,
0.0324109904,
0.0271784924,
-0.0076246038,
-0.0357390307,
0.0167375132,
0.0000147284,
0.0240936447,
-0.0190563612,
-0.0010467864,
-0.0011203861,
-0.0591032468,
-0.0192859359,
-0.0665582791,
-0.0492897034,
-0.0257863235,
0.0298710037,
0.0195381381,
-0.0261167381,
0.0014391134,
-0.0201156307,
-0.0157343,
0.0078794891,
0.0027508466,
0.0094846152,
0.0535886995,
0.0125966836,
0.0114140995,
-0.0552658588,
0.0082703745,
0.001539827,
0.0414419733,
0.0503455885,
0.01831026,
-0.0603965446,
0.0299633704,
-0.0427477323,
0.0361449905,
-0.0339500941,
-0.0430042036,
0.043261487,
-0.0011459027,
-0.0188918766,
0.1190172508,
0.006500429,
0.0756373405,
0.0487497635,
-0.0020897109,
-0.0702742487,
0.0386912264,
-0.012153198,
0.0127726831,
-0.0766500831,
-0.0004533342,
-0.0174014345,
0.0741480812,
-0.0060491366,
-0.0039181542,
-0.0337746143,
0.0520370714,
0.0182751417,
-0.0527422242,
0.0139291612,
-0.0355923325,
-0.0008546638,
0.0200137813,
-0.0347950906,
-0.0337611809,
0.1239362434,
-0.0153779946,
-0.0331871919,
-0.0367713422,
-0.0222949274,
-0.0452858433,
0.0510324985,
-0.0300415736,
-0.0116593847,
-0.0027608005,
0.023415558,
-0.0762057975,
-0.0560940169,
0.0595434085,
0.0102293333,
0.03528855,
-0.0526505001,
-0.0147612402,
0.0011473085,
-0.0418516397,
-0.0506648757,
-0.0373206101,
-0.0453061648,
0.0187775977,
-0.0196873285,
-0.0325542353,
-0.0329422913,
-0.0171423145,
0.0104064196,
-0.0098921116,
-0.0152158802,
-0.0206991509,
-0.020533463,
-0.0155883394,
0.0432452448,
0.0426026173,
0.0246902052,
-0.0850272179,
0.0572862066,
0.0668691173,
-0.0011645575,
0.0180012286,
-0.0364350528,
-0.018843513,
-0.0019709666,
0.0109723322,
0.013964694,
-0.0048079481,
0.0805919096,
-0.0581447259,
0.0026715095,
0.1149101555,
0.0044462364,
-0.0020862373,
0.0079335421,
-0.0417484194,
0.0515857153,
0.0218863767,
0.0125413826,
-0.071979098,
-0.0439173169,
-0.0012340065,
0.0165287722,
0.0131751951,
-0.018261278,
-0.0043816254,
-0.0897773951,
0.0298711136,
0.0012357093,
-0.0329096839,
0.0214109514,
-0.0345895104,
0.0156300347,
-0.030756712,
0.0440819077,
-0.0172975119,
0.0306721404,
0.018818086,
0.0149942217,
0.0126968818,
-0.0339299701,
0.0147651341,
-0.0408290774,
0.0351088308,
0.0641043782,
0.0281374436,
0.0117013548,
-0.0370584875,
0.049841065,
0.0136529058,
0.0319992416,
-0.0276857987,
0.0534382947,
-0.0326636322,
0.0105228545,
-0.0152702956,
0.0402456485,
-0.0146618644,
-0.0275848247,
0.0220693946,
0.0284841359,
-0.0118501168,
-0.0154707227,
-0.0063688373,
0.0321408771,
-0.009195324,
0.0713609979,
0.0555588417,
-0.0122669516,
-0.0168220419,
-0.0457379632,
-0.041556824,
-0.0373915732,
-0.0134435929,
-0.000591854,
0.0296507794,
0.0229430944,
-0.036540091,
-0.0523677506,
0.0420090109,
0.0258097742,
-0.0059798807,
-0.001301997,
-0.0320187956,
0.0128079606,
0.0006892809,
0.0567512065,
-0.0102172177,
0.0020208803,
0.0116399312,
-0.0387764014,
0.0100518735,
-0.0470428318,
-0.0014559156,
-0.0027519083,
-0.0798792839,
-0.0914257243,
-0.0303487144,
0.0773853213,
0.0297314189,
0.0862348005,
-0.0201888513,
-0.0519326627,
0.0192061849,
0.0422392003,
-0.0232325569,
0.0000299433,
0.0512095243,
0.009613608,
0.0272415169,
0.0499290228,
-0.0016589493,
-0.003613679,
0.0497610532,
-0.0053380779,
-0.0534106307,
-0.0438021645,
0.0172230583,
-0.0156624243,
0.0334272869,
0.0148876328,
-0.0400624685,
-0.0192016456,
0.0296159461,
-0.0396622866,
-0.025176838,
-0.0454243124,
0.0157432351,
-0.006377555,
-0.0120953312,
0.0261849239,
-0.012106888,
-0.0039219265,
0.0397440232,
-0.0192343611,
0.0526124686,
0.0496637709,
0.0099438103,
0.0003350595,
0.0168020092,
-0.0028773465,
0.0050088512,
-0.0073028244,
0.0339576602,
0.0137338825,
0.0661411732,
0.0355335549,
-0.0079890238,
0.0252145436,
0.0053523597,
-0.0882800296,
-0.0825361013,
0.0061760098,
0.0399993844,
0.0124923056,
0.0236235466,
0.0330898352,
-0.0522928424,
-0.000874338,
0.0232570004,
0.0569123439,
0.0003971675,
-0.0390603431,
0.0451443233,
0.0231279749,
-0.0144930938,
-0.0166694969,
0.0412743278,
0.0073609487,
0.0500891134,
-0.0138124106,
-0.0006533514,
-0.0503923893,
-0.066258058,
0.0251054522,
0.0023293246,
-0.0140768616,
0.0347307213,
-0.0227628034,
-0.072921522,
-0.034846209,
0.0379813164,
-0.0071723768,
-0.0219747145,
0.0377192274,
0.0618423969,
-0.0145205446,
-0.0236362144,
-0.0134972883,
0.0124662397,
0.0043356749,
-0.0234103687,
-0.0252142623,
-6.236928376e-33,
-0.0406501181,
-0.0579729043,
0.0297235176,
-0.0213150065,
-0.039401833,
-0.0158532541,
-0.0878919661,
0.0131412679,
-0.0300462563,
0.0244783517,
0.0083314348,
0.0427695625,
-0.000550007,
0.0051174471,
-0.0042076157,
-0.0568432733,
0.037828777,
-0.0108751245,
-0.028651882,
0.0030179142,
-0.0027119042,
0.0273008943,
0.0636589378,
-0.052262947,
0.0645799413,
0.0257613864,
-0.0169952959,
0.039911218,
-0.0658230036,
0.0512666255,
-0.0058505181,
0.0201305076,
0.0119145717,
0.0083436361,
-0.0112023195,
-0.0086359689,
-0.0511798449,
-0.0132411532,
0.0378712006,
-0.0013834549,
-0.0860049278,
-0.0205191225,
0.0533416085,
-0.0022299436,
0.0018037466,
-0.0032115986,
0.0290188305,
-0.0322076119,
-0.0097023286,
0.0087970952,
-0.0557493009,
0.0089762686,
-0.0338268094,
-0.0271629766,
0.0315558463,
0.017229639,
0.0144990319,
-0.0223616268,
-0.035594102,
0.0106130941,
0.0212000422,
0.011869519,
0.0604759268,
0.0074139424,
0.0242980421,
0.0603075288,
0.0092735933,
0.0032569349,
-0.0504829921,
-0.0362536013,
0.0267736726,
0.0547406785,
0.0519269258,
0.075668104,
0.002566196,
0.0145241609,
-0.0611349903,
-0.0051174704,
0.031317316,
0.0636036545,
0.0202467144,
0.023418555,
-0.0305563845,
-0.0220881011,
-0.0589225292,
-0.0323608294,
-0.0235706568,
-0.0382285975,
-0.0096270675,
0.0095974607,
-0.0263829604,
-0.0012951643,
-0.0330846943,
-0.0450190119,
-0.0078914994,
-0.0052527902,
0.0112134879,
-0.0129166208,
0.0045266445,
0.0033351916,
-0.0646045133,
-0.0079250615,
0.0050545298,
0.0215335041,
0.0168442111,
0.0050495341,
0.0501174964,
0.0027924331,
-0.0222866293,
0.0022411479,
-0.0375094339,
0.0310752988,
0.0231581908,
0.022048777,
0.0072582029,
0.0187487639,
-0.0312320981,
0.0459109396,
-0.0095118014,
-0.0082999161,
-0.0481304824,
0.0260070879,
0.0070600309,
0.0062038153,
-0.0262139421,
-0.0338783115,
-0.0105946278,
-0.0405012704,
0.0325758792,
-0.0651500672,
-0.0167101007,
0.0088234367,
2.625e-7,
0.0313581787,
0.0388064012,
0.0180476755,
0.0008823041,
0.0416106582,
0.0611773916,
-0.0236455631,
0.0114097102,
0.0177597906,
-0.0157781672,
0.0072688134,
0.0761093646,
0.0683466047,
0.0449672602,
-0.0663287863,
-0.0195090286,
-0.070577763,
-0.0182352476,
-0.0160159599,
0.0055966754,
0.0422164537,
0.0732714683,
0.0211109389,
0.0098890336,
0.0066536739,
-0.0337094329,
0.063619405,
-0.0436197855,
-0.0003012719,
0.01580243,
0.0072617815,
-0.0157429967,
0.0156061593,
0.0330377631,
-0.0018713429,
-0.0104220277,
-0.0546154901,
0.0613609031,
-0.0030624105,
-0.0384005196,
-0.0277660545,
-0.0002377909,
0.0175891072,
-0.0453207344,
0.0620742515,
-0.0982616097,
-0.0662280545,
-0.0115647111,
0.0102890218,
-0.0379519686,
0.018419927,
-0.0091768466,
-0.0035607854,
0.0099550774,
0.0084597478,
-0.0263660625,
-0.0023619139,
-0.0724629536,
-0.0298732091,
-0.0298907571,
-0.0590141937,
-0.0306521636,
-0.0147389192,
-0.012607445,
0.0436209738,
-0.0278688055,
0.0085646641,
2.133241689e-34,
0.0439050235,
0.0172288008,
0.0104654757,
0.0706604347,
0.0581789017,
0.0124567496,
-0.0334393047,
-0.0214677863,
0.0563870892,
-0.0532464534,
-0.0332654789
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08106v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08106v2 | Carpe Diem: On the Evaluation of World Knowledge in Lifelong Language Models | 2023-11-14T12:12:02 | 2024-04-20T07:11:39 | Yujin Kim, Jaehong Yoon, Seonghyeon Ye, Sangmin Bae, Namgyu Ho, Sung Ju Hwang, Se-young Yun | cs.CL | cs.CL | The dynamic nature of knowledge in an ever-changing world presents challenges
for language models trained on static data; the model in the real world often
requires not only acquiring new knowledge but also overwriting outdated
information into updated ones. To study the ability of language models for
these time-dependent dynamics in human language, we introduce a novel task,
EvolvingQA, a temporally evolving question-answering benchmark designed for
training and evaluating LMs on an evolving Wikipedia database. The construction
of EvolvingQA is automated with our pipeline using large language models. We
uncover that existing continual learning baselines suffer from updating and
removing outdated knowledge. Our analysis suggests that models fail to rectify
knowledge due to small weight gradients. In addition, we elucidate that
language models particularly struggle to reflect the change of numerical or
temporal information. Our work aims to model the dynamic nature of real-world
information, suggesting faithful evaluations of the evolution-adaptability of
language models. | [
0.0499615557,
0.0577777512,
-0.0213145781,
0.0222072396,
-0.0140589708,
0.0192140844,
-0.0488480814,
0.0154728293,
0.0019318298,
-0.0369180888,
-0.0049259202,
-0.0547358617,
-0.0117014637,
0.0230545122,
0.0019656424,
-0.0126586696,
0.0682823882,
-0.0510483421,
-0.0465669446,
-0.01341125,
-0.0068615717,
-0.0243204255,
-0.019618066,
-0.0156929176,
0.0217046589,
-0.0289923642,
-0.0365421623,
-0.0544790365,
0.026374761,
0.0283300113,
0.0417108834,
0.0449375324,
0.0421980396,
0.0227846205,
0.0000015875,
-0.0724425316,
0.0245713908,
-0.026332479,
-0.0782332495,
0.0224211793,
0.0112844519,
0.0276961476,
0.0010425164,
-0.0097723566,
-0.0717164278,
0.0005216274,
-0.0141217448,
-0.018298056,
0.1038906723,
0.0336807258,
0.0388941541,
-0.0080382237,
0.0490772948,
-0.0438116826,
0.0479086302,
-0.0359174311,
0.0541015416,
0.0207510628,
-0.0289465971,
-0.0096364319,
-0.0188990664,
0.030410517,
0.0238058604,
-0.0241837632,
0.0418626256,
0.0519070141,
0.0051424932,
0.0342502035,
-0.0117657138,
0.0652626231,
0.0134994686,
-0.0113883317,
-0.0120702228,
0.0313823,
0.0032758375,
-0.0192892104,
-0.0640507713,
-0.0061570792,
0.0224559363,
0.0016879337,
0.0181574952,
-0.0377934985,
0.0128337769,
0.0394128151,
-0.0372524075,
0.0666254684,
0.0204671957,
-0.0159916263,
-0.0128835198,
-0.0301516354,
-0.0146639626,
-0.0512675717,
-0.0132588269,
0.0878774971,
-0.0010559073,
0.0370559432,
0.0034494689,
0.0202399772,
0.0306952782,
-0.0803361684,
-0.0054956982,
0.0331377089,
0.0153162619,
0.0948900059,
-0.0180304367,
0.0568838082,
0.0112546403,
-0.0471469313,
-0.0312639289,
-0.0051690661,
-0.0905532911,
-0.0597841926,
-0.0003012654,
0.0669174045,
-0.0009959221,
-0.0097476998,
-0.0211439915,
0.0447610579,
0.0044090869,
-0.0141166048,
-0.0045825839,
0.0080967732,
-0.0284946151,
0.0252918173,
-0.072809048,
0.0298584513,
-0.0277602114,
0.0113520352,
-0.013467608,
-0.0222943649,
-0.0166546032,
-0.0032678174,
0.0080230059,
-0.0100522432,
-0.0098155243,
0.0484206639,
-0.01145967,
0.0043661511,
-0.0184834749,
-0.0008088753,
-0.0277645979,
-0.0285607427,
-0.0131286094,
-0.0357713662,
0.0648298785,
-0.0068575623,
-0.0151217543,
-0.0341440961,
0.0090077324,
-0.0012194251,
-0.0369870886,
0.0598134696,
0.0065971259,
0.0264862981,
0.0401113406,
0.0078222472,
0.0284159817,
0.079854019,
0.0112592094,
-0.0645569041,
0.0315577872,
0.0184256602,
-0.0229271762,
0.034359321,
0.0300755277,
0.0502906293,
0.0015722181,
0.0604511499,
0.0146523854,
0.0444052331,
0.0128402701,
0.0212748684,
-0.0184135549,
-0.0375253186,
0.0520338044,
0.011341841,
0.0168299004,
0.0377968699,
0.0268980674,
-0.0289967004,
0.0433767736,
0.0022857799,
-0.0259619206,
0.0026234745,
-0.0348389149,
0.0081323367,
-0.0371948034,
-0.0195904896,
-0.036131423,
-0.0347411446,
0.0160640404,
0.019373823,
0.001477965,
-0.0247843917,
0.026167402,
0.03206167,
0.0035473865,
0.0934839547,
0.0346818939,
-0.0250115525,
0.0397912934,
-0.0432718731,
0.0409116261,
0.0910308138,
0.0235714782,
-0.0277140234,
-0.0676630437,
-0.0165369734,
0.0232824851,
0.006606733,
0.0347532369,
-0.0616113581,
0.0381040387,
0.0153028136,
-0.0171076767,
-0.0236464404,
-0.0045942082,
-0.0149636678,
0.0494602807,
0.0467897803,
0.0014361476,
-0.0730074868,
-0.0283074416,
0.0359494463,
-0.0731117874,
-0.0056451233,
0.0083972728,
-0.0272987373,
-0.0171658192,
0.0006834595,
-0.009025069,
-0.0043598046,
0.0461587533,
-0.027949173,
-0.0269223526,
0.0287996661,
-0.0229491629,
-0.0344841518,
0.0902387798,
0.0224130619,
-0.0208263844,
-0.0123065263,
-0.0432334356,
-0.0130071826,
0.0237881597,
-0.0471260175,
0.0617582351,
-0.0384240262,
0.0040065781,
-0.0380672403,
0.0085957684,
-0.0461852327,
0.0810369849,
-0.0335688889,
-0.0049517592,
0.009169328,
-0.001215229,
-0.0102598201,
-0.058685407,
-0.014997324,
0.0123847928,
0.019824475,
-0.0062021241,
0.0098991431,
0.0185865462,
-0.063191101,
-0.0083772037,
-0.079724215,
0.0009745507,
-0.0225693099,
0.031838648,
0.0599886999,
-0.0103631131,
-0.0031082164,
-0.017103089,
-0.0214112587,
0.0241110884,
-0.0021968207,
0.0175897479,
0.0688228384,
0.0398401581,
0.0211435631,
-0.041920688,
-0.0265293978,
-0.0278473794,
0.0734644905,
-0.0210429654,
-0.0061649806,
-0.046400018,
-0.0214330032,
-0.0714379251,
0.0201586243,
-0.0061432784,
0.00680192,
-0.0107560931,
-0.0083571412,
0.054773733,
0.0403509513,
0.063072741,
0.0286739897,
0.0442578793,
-0.0151806306,
-0.0532181151,
0.0205354597,
-0.0383439399,
-0.0089249397,
-0.0460293144,
-0.0140454667,
0.009405544,
0.0379693769,
-0.0059749475,
-0.0342871957,
-0.0413646065,
0.0427461751,
-0.0426895991,
-0.0048735333,
-0.054686252,
0.0157183353,
-0.0404912271,
-0.0058657788,
-0.044638928,
-0.0361833647,
0.082612507,
0.0408583805,
0.008666778,
-0.0306992326,
-0.0019170415,
-0.0391414277,
0.0609571822,
-0.0280421861,
0.0227837898,
0.0030004175,
0.0026393731,
-0.0555922948,
-0.0101865809,
0.0290547255,
-0.0372329988,
0.0394261479,
-0.0593414418,
0.0397966355,
0.0118041467,
-0.01623003,
-0.048555851,
-0.0126044136,
-0.0035355953,
0.0068967175,
-0.0596849099,
0.00493237,
0.0169501044,
0.0060393969,
0.0356095619,
0.0076966202,
-0.0146033065,
-0.0351366587,
-0.0018509558,
0.0416241586,
0.0798876062,
0.0549483895,
-0.0029421314,
-0.0281210244,
0.0524929576,
0.0191867147,
0.0411139652,
0.0175614841,
-0.0211507212,
0.0328188986,
-0.0003252835,
-0.0596525893,
0.0067279474,
-0.0125860376,
-0.0107734594,
-0.0257193446,
-0.0199666303,
0.0940566435,
0.0387551896,
-0.0258323736,
0.0117978249,
-0.0298910998,
-0.0080535738,
0.021704277,
0.0446780883,
-0.0791219026,
-0.0083063692,
-0.018091647,
0.0298864767,
0.0290160272,
-0.0688414425,
0.0028365159,
-0.0878383443,
-0.0316628665,
-0.0116041694,
-0.026616931,
0.0270505268,
-0.0304183774,
0.0187916271,
-0.0122946054,
0.0062864958,
0.0291409045,
-0.014357415,
0.0032344316,
0.0292180851,
-0.0466999635,
-0.0461421274,
0.0454891957,
-0.002180449,
0.038569551,
0.0470501296,
0.0415937565,
-0.0066526001,
-0.0297422372,
0.0684302971,
-0.0531318448,
-0.0025812946,
-0.0058561391,
0.0368232988,
0.0036637962,
-0.0120205358,
-0.0154875396,
0.0068153632,
-0.02897151,
0.0009794559,
0.0167857241,
0.0904053897,
0.012266295,
-0.018834997,
-0.018987719,
-0.0522159189,
-0.004656482,
0.0677168146,
0.0071407943,
-0.0604128949,
-0.0162314605,
-0.0092881918,
-0.01916207,
-0.0119111938,
-0.0617389977,
0.003873508,
-0.000260713,
0.0267623272,
-0.0802607089,
0.0004728103,
-0.0147948302,
0.0173871201,
0.0174431857,
0.019190317,
0.0107266959,
-0.0129640074,
-0.0678190365,
0.0005450599,
-0.0447755717,
-0.0169994719,
-0.0340411253,
-0.0232463814,
0.0755220056,
0.0049435385,
-0.0229957327,
-0.0105135571,
-0.0993694216,
-0.0665475577,
0.0244272165,
0.0405182727,
0.0254499782,
0.0568191968,
-0.0276949797,
-0.0427218564,
0.0677407831,
-0.0013148931,
0.0158538148,
0.0336582884,
-0.0146340849,
0.0168477073,
-0.0069490783,
0.0496275909,
-0.0618312731,
-0.0536161661,
0.0207759533,
0.0613617897,
-0.041108001,
-0.0205681678,
0.0081302896,
-0.0138226459,
-0.042282857,
0.0234307963,
-0.0717999637,
-0.0015423306,
0.0119200302,
0.0347755738,
-0.0243218094,
-0.0010666165,
-0.0010691237,
0.0241587553,
-0.0117404629,
-0.0036347669,
0.0528614931,
0.0155756846,
0.0203035176,
-0.040547885,
-0.0502344519,
0.0332305543,
-0.0053585144,
0.0410019495,
0.0152355768,
-0.0106689259,
-0.0144127235,
-0.0311738886,
0.0382824428,
-0.0044883024,
0.0029222392,
0.0230346117,
-0.0278652795,
-0.0013907775,
0.0061059203,
-0.0926309004,
-0.0723494664,
-0.0400150083,
0.0266054329,
0.0555036515,
0.0292120464,
0.0403122343,
-0.0099549945,
-0.016383497,
-0.0301793665,
-0.0532666147,
0.0150141818,
-0.0011801679,
0.0266075544,
0.0336490422,
0.002546577,
0.0726311803,
0.0646675453,
0.0168729201,
0.072310932,
-0.0159193762,
-0.003644889,
-0.0189515334,
0.00209427,
-0.0431355014,
-0.0035928229,
-0.01536154,
0.0382643491,
-0.031816531,
-0.063051872,
0.0312541053,
0.0225262512,
0.0047580269,
-0.0024107248,
0.0185763929,
0.0395277813,
0.0297123678,
-0.0172836892,
-0.0289047379,
0.0630512908,
-0.0011763918,
-0.001548283,
-0.0409004316,
-5.923518439e-33,
-0.0241709519,
0.0178759359,
0.0167436581,
-0.0004087808,
-0.0664023235,
0.0251115579,
-0.0543757714,
0.0035865626,
-0.0460176207,
-0.0199696589,
-0.0066759312,
0.0522035733,
-0.0153766787,
-0.0107205315,
0.0248746723,
-0.0583015755,
-0.0004867291,
-0.0262908991,
-0.0296967421,
0.0106928078,
0.0303444769,
0.0503324568,
0.0672454759,
-0.0223382469,
0.0571241193,
0.0186674707,
0.0246278774,
0.0969596952,
0.001537614,
0.0691897273,
-0.057196781,
0.0549570285,
0.0227587298,
-0.0467879772,
-0.023789838,
-0.0581721254,
-0.1207275763,
-0.0403018743,
-0.0052392548,
0.0107892323,
-0.0315285809,
-0.0288353991,
0.0394998752,
0.0285163,
-0.0137973139,
0.0105730183,
0.0349058248,
-0.0298193134,
-0.0257061645,
-0.0171631463,
-0.02130026,
0.0106549934,
-0.0099041881,
-0.0006538475,
-0.0672432706,
0.0047082198,
0.015456167,
-0.0258317161,
-0.0702158138,
-0.0006188983,
0.0156470109,
0.0188335907,
0.0392799601,
-0.001713815,
0.0382117629,
0.0308343563,
-0.0007343809,
0.0210682359,
-0.0036379606,
-0.0277518239,
0.0341782272,
-0.0133875459,
0.0310432315,
0.0078788307,
0.0173815656,
-0.0012918109,
-0.0460325405,
0.0015527431,
0.0460401103,
0.0743316561,
0.0121865058,
0.0070248544,
0.0241885185,
-0.0146229509,
-0.059245158,
0.0278596934,
-0.0370795913,
0.001206044,
0.0324430205,
0.0236591697,
-0.0453517362,
-0.0129917189,
-0.0135557335,
-0.0686558262,
-0.0361456871,
0.0305774864,
-0.0096394718,
0.0097964453,
0.0507341921,
0.0524920411,
-0.0042372989,
0.0067281784,
-0.0124156112,
0.0163614042,
0.0119259376,
-0.0069671781,
-0.0102468077,
0.021225607,
-0.0323545448,
-0.0112520885,
-0.0067816093,
0.0010339507,
-0.0117082568,
0.0128926123,
0.0115014203,
-0.0004811556,
-0.0046769436,
0.0159728751,
0.0469218045,
0.0143061252,
-0.031518776,
0.0335056372,
0.0461713374,
0.0434473865,
-0.0137314806,
-0.0283225551,
0.0053287162,
0.0720971972,
-0.0327030532,
-0.0475136749,
0.0020696437,
0.0306304544,
2.356e-7,
0.0505140051,
0.0356699154,
0.039643988,
0.0037644426,
0.0757126883,
-0.0060055419,
-0.0430203266,
0.0063950932,
0.0096398881,
-0.0181009881,
-0.0103946691,
0.0615709238,
0.0215145126,
0.0165257528,
-0.043463774,
-0.0405553356,
-0.0579915717,
-0.0158575233,
-0.0692629591,
-0.0183870681,
0.00098843,
0.0426157936,
0.0257054903,
-0.0123452116,
0.0055338452,
-0.0821026266,
0.0979228094,
-0.0005970167,
0.0326978602,
0.0075900415,
0.0074948282,
0.0315818973,
0.0116677312,
0.0098066991,
-0.0184620228,
0.0235376377,
-0.0222067833,
0.0365004577,
-0.0094609587,
-0.0124511989,
-0.0106780725,
-0.0224946029,
0.0356062092,
-0.0500307381,
0.0993885025,
-0.030816121,
0.029914774,
-0.0431953929,
0.0004426285,
-0.0089868158,
0.0171441808,
-0.0159384068,
-0.0502408445,
0.0016347452,
0.0092674792,
0.0371471047,
-0.0154389385,
-0.0836863294,
-0.0221350119,
-0.0075734933,
-0.0578404516,
-0.066139929,
-0.0414354838,
-0.0052378052,
0.0075987061,
-0.0525177754,
0.0555548258,
1.765955954e-34,
0.00366625,
0.018630743,
0.0086353514,
0.0450715125,
0.0159200169,
-0.0188316014,
0.0112962816,
-0.0440558232,
0.0506948754,
-0.0759494305,
-0.0230250955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08105v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08105v2 | DiLoCo: Distributed Low-Communication Training of Language Models | 2023-11-14T12:05:45 | 2023-12-02T14:10:14 | Arthur Douillard, Qixuan Feng, Andrei A. Rusu, Rachita Chhaparia, Yani Donchev, Adhiguna Kuncoro, Marc'Aurelio Ranzato, Arthur Szlam, Jiajun Shen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language models (LLM) have become a critical component in many
applications of machine learning. However, standard approaches to training LLM
require a large number of tightly interconnected accelerators, with devices
exchanging gradients and other intermediate states at each optimization step.
While it is difficult to build and maintain a single computing cluster hosting
many accelerators, it might be easier to find several computing clusters each
hosting a smaller number of devices. In this work, we propose a distributed
optimization algorithm, Distributed Low-Communication (DiLoCo), that enables
training of language models on islands of devices that are poorly connected.
The approach is a variant of federated averaging, where the number of inner
steps is large, the inner optimizer is AdamW, and the outer optimizer is
Nesterov momentum. On the widely used C4 dataset, we show that DiLoCo on 8
workers performs as well as fully synchronous optimization while communicating
500 times less. DiLoCo exhibits great robustness to the data distribution of
each worker. It is also robust to resources becoming unavailable over time, and
vice versa, it can seamlessly leverage resources that become available during
training. | [
0.0132989865,
0.1065999269,
-0.0085205743,
0.0390535034,
-0.0149935205,
0.007695307,
0.0833406374,
-0.01491627,
-0.0037653355,
0.0122599564,
-0.0236377027,
-0.0794720724,
0.0281202924,
-0.0222894624,
-0.0000912974,
-0.0028444906,
0.033940766,
-0.003477294,
-0.0502866022,
-0.0619461462,
-0.0162218362,
0.0090080537,
0.0056039123,
0.0181317218,
-0.0153373238,
-0.0500289015,
-0.0077195354,
0.0108727766,
0.0285543855,
-0.0057885014,
0.0472661369,
0.035965737,
0.026565047,
0.072830826,
0.0000019108,
0.0045857457,
0.0027171487,
-0.0127850892,
0.0089883693,
0.0471780412,
0.0590131991,
-0.0184787717,
-0.0301866662,
0.025781896,
-0.0208567679,
-0.0356099308,
0.0611141697,
-0.0368078351,
0.0778613091,
0.0648415759,
0.0115292985,
-0.0449805483,
-0.0056550149,
-0.0506852008,
-0.0932088345,
-0.0468390696,
0.0411052294,
0.0331275165,
-0.0168738533,
-0.0074306992,
-0.0174522158,
0.02245708,
0.0199258476,
0.018611934,
0.0266822074,
0.0295046084,
-0.0441805646,
-0.0340751298,
-0.0392878689,
0.0541801453,
-0.0223490056,
-0.0318702757,
0.0009403521,
0.0053982246,
-0.0580670908,
-0.0199470278,
-0.0113171292,
0.0046600569,
0.0145721873,
0.0173867345,
0.0083871474,
-0.0291670356,
0.0489347577,
0.00322729,
0.0206041932,
0.0622129813,
0.0097970385,
0.0129545303,
-0.0183419324,
0.0204946436,
-0.048343394,
-0.0583239011,
0.0364644416,
0.03251151,
0.0031471073,
0.0161854923,
-0.0574402846,
-0.0535831451,
-0.0085861683,
-0.0268351343,
0.0497044437,
-0.0084692864,
0.0411147438,
0.0559649393,
-0.0202751271,
-0.0391149819,
-0.0165262111,
-0.061462339,
-0.0277369805,
0.0214544814,
-0.0344376639,
-0.0206242278,
-0.0157708023,
0.0370550714,
-0.0442055315,
-0.0159009844,
-0.0140309371,
0.025103502,
-0.0224683322,
-0.0164704751,
0.0003007887,
0.0155209564,
-0.032673046,
-0.0189497899,
0.035764657,
0.065494284,
-0.0335708782,
0.0317400843,
0.003968046,
-0.0556191914,
-0.0260904208,
0.0024360202,
-0.0106846336,
0.022394212,
0.0174648073,
0.0370096974,
-0.0198123381,
0.0155857923,
-0.0065201651,
0.0021136762,
0.0123105161,
-0.0724295005,
-0.0543522015,
-0.0679146573,
0.0290196165,
0.0065368558,
0.0299133211,
-0.0597276017,
0.0223738663,
0.0002551425,
-0.0108942604,
0.0533772707,
-0.031536825,
-0.0168319922,
0.0469435677,
-0.0023922399,
0.0215362143,
0.0873791873,
0.0206275638,
0.0322335698,
0.0250127017,
0.0102975192,
-0.0548722669,
0.0549516529,
0.0552656613,
0.0568609275,
-0.0140583031,
-0.0261709876,
0.0042756628,
0.0532438122,
0.001772927,
0.0872467458,
-0.0307249594,
-0.0257398393,
0.0884669125,
0.0630135462,
-0.0093254009,
0.0350008681,
-0.0314987488,
-0.0029253738,
-0.0096189836,
-0.027500106,
-0.007096095,
-0.0084634637,
0.005013098,
-0.0126688229,
0.0359555371,
0.0713172704,
-0.0437745601,
-0.0240559857,
-0.0363371298,
-0.013773446,
-0.020549709,
0.011718642,
0.0587300025,
-0.038377516,
-0.0296521448,
0.0014612743,
0.0664094985,
-0.0420514606,
0.0177784283,
-0.0155772837,
0.007622919,
0.035878446,
0.0417830721,
0.0122854961,
-0.0180085208,
-0.0387108885,
0.041593615,
0.0323462635,
0.0116969002,
-0.0113518192,
0.0239570029,
-0.0391496979,
0.0003885732,
0.0548652299,
-0.0172589216,
0.0145684397,
-0.0057207453,
0.0067153387,
-0.0281473361,
0.0491461977,
-0.0468781218,
-0.0037957565,
-0.003687846,
-0.0071356432,
0.0090021798,
0.0025330742,
0.0552310795,
-0.0028327205,
-0.0290066972,
-0.0293004271,
0.0183507092,
-0.0572133996,
-0.030204637,
-0.0011418317,
-0.0347480066,
-0.0110406578,
0.0346289948,
0.0061989333,
0.0193610881,
0.0409765132,
-0.023126591,
-0.0464249477,
0.0458015837,
-0.0344014056,
0.0533826388,
-0.0163360815,
0.0104413964,
-0.0218263492,
0.0505203977,
-0.0022040345,
0.0602094568,
-0.0362335518,
-0.0154375555,
-0.0282481275,
0.0127168139,
0.0101195602,
-0.046779342,
0.013083213,
-0.001343266,
0.034348771,
0.0462217666,
0.0038654229,
-0.0027886354,
0.0311855897,
0.0062011885,
-0.0861114711,
0.0226740595,
-0.0582211688,
0.0384190194,
0.0445487387,
0.0171449911,
0.0090544978,
-0.0110463863,
0.0173466243,
0.0761867017,
-0.0351907946,
0.0265677758,
-0.0067076958,
0.0251989216,
-0.0562661253,
-0.001861086,
-0.0788679719,
0.015732266,
0.0352595225,
0.0168153346,
0.0000460815,
-0.0741875023,
-0.001702282,
-0.0261225216,
0.0364214629,
-0.0115428315,
-0.0131580653,
0.0071863793,
0.012593735,
0.0050227623,
0.1003787145,
-0.0159567129,
0.0212774258,
0.0291666221,
0.0036833396,
-0.048799213,
0.0063303234,
-0.0246870015,
-0.0218176749,
-0.0305759758,
0.0026912931,
-0.0187147725,
0.0838690773,
-0.0184223577,
-0.0417679995,
-0.0233340487,
-0.0134718008,
-0.0269192643,
-0.0492078438,
-0.0541186482,
0.0249719713,
-0.002785601,
0.0039232452,
0.0020042183,
-0.0595620163,
0.0814557299,
-0.0325773992,
-0.0120425913,
-0.053939037,
-0.0678861141,
-0.0215989668,
0.0261315908,
0.0055036675,
0.0415821075,
-0.0957780853,
-0.0252366774,
-0.004232306,
0.0353815407,
-0.0048948969,
-0.0022331192,
-0.0039813146,
-0.0076705022,
0.0394088738,
-0.0210605059,
-0.0964302719,
0.018866729,
-0.0097071435,
-0.072372824,
0.0071252938,
0.0229676757,
-0.0520154871,
-0.0086955801,
0.0388327874,
0.0206149202,
0.0499798022,
-0.0273169037,
0.0008338207,
-0.0286773704,
0.0046185954,
0.038775932,
-0.0636722147,
-0.0247603152,
-0.0556561872,
-0.00495223,
0.044788111,
0.0871599913,
-0.0041652541,
-0.0403546356,
-0.0211671013,
0.0181356221,
-0.0261810385,
-0.0047052461,
-0.0116214305,
0.0580265783,
-0.0282979123,
-0.0173367597,
0.0378544778,
-0.0170303602,
-0.0887313783,
0.0005644997,
0.0146081755,
0.0606463663,
-0.0148900319,
-0.0047927443,
-0.0521348566,
-0.0337689258,
0.0223522689,
0.0311635379,
0.038505353,
-0.0063755107,
-0.023951998,
-0.0870016441,
-0.0090526007,
0.0368018486,
-0.0127529614,
-0.017484542,
-0.0908817872,
0.0200641938,
-0.0524750762,
0.0292699318,
0.0313479193,
0.0069211936,
-0.0031556054,
0.0140403677,
0.0164094232,
-0.0242171027,
-0.0096681397,
-0.0341947637,
0.039030619,
0.0371380635,
-0.0249681603,
-0.0155584821,
-0.0336256661,
0.0299046468,
0.0274169799,
-0.0081559196,
-0.0449740998,
-0.0449958071,
-0.0246062279,
-0.0326958746,
0.0126500288,
0.0320154689,
-0.0068549514,
0.0205047186,
0.0143971313,
0.077043958,
0.0057223658,
-0.0029889666,
0.0301951263,
0.0065045743,
0.0342623368,
0.027790742,
-0.0066840234,
-0.0580569766,
-0.0204451494,
-0.0009511182,
-0.0005802728,
0.0325865075,
0.0240263417,
-0.0110101635,
0.0047033681,
-0.0056521222,
-0.0431722328,
-0.0121987173,
0.0163639821,
0.0531695113,
0.0260577872,
0.0156020168,
0.0636663213,
0.0162119828,
-0.069041051,
0.0010030699,
-0.0523573384,
0.0246191323,
-0.0324774981,
-0.0031030725,
0.0240218546,
0.0032407702,
-0.0173587482,
0.036043264,
-0.1128286496,
-0.0838643685,
0.0133820456,
0.024279641,
0.0217707325,
0.0484389551,
0.0022103491,
-0.0912622288,
0.0382814594,
0.0407223254,
-0.0337124094,
0.060554333,
0.0115677649,
-0.0520332232,
0.0272523127,
0.044373475,
-0.0328715071,
0.0341257714,
0.0406921059,
0.0138078313,
-0.0386678837,
-0.0488002487,
-0.050497245,
-0.0138978977,
-0.0113541791,
-0.0080917329,
-0.0091107739,
0.0004281717,
0.0487070829,
0.0358705372,
0.031400416,
-0.0418634191,
0.0086834356,
0.0021416196,
-0.0146148643,
0.0198232736,
0.0282424148,
0.0785633102,
-0.0141358301,
0.0068714423,
0.0139068495,
-0.0085047465,
-0.0016580515,
0.0647355914,
0.0278136358,
0.0085626338,
0.0147031462,
0.0118199782,
0.0442143604,
-0.0260317065,
0.0016995904,
0.0172119271,
-0.0104344143,
-0.0225177128,
0.0190242678,
-0.0505996086,
-0.0790338591,
-0.0266910922,
0.0113720289,
0.0968517363,
0.0563872978,
0.0520225167,
-0.0369560532,
-0.0239664614,
-0.0406164788,
-0.0164391417,
-0.046346806,
-0.0249080993,
0.0251674689,
0.0249060281,
-0.0047047506,
0.0724111348,
0.054193221,
-0.0138612892,
0.0328951143,
0.0148376292,
0.0228201207,
-0.0484754108,
0.0058704917,
0.0216035619,
0.0475958288,
-0.0282766223,
-0.020265555,
0.0209136643,
-0.0493781194,
-0.0045460854,
0.0028306921,
-0.0144714965,
-0.0244089421,
0.0340677723,
0.0255916826,
-0.0183590762,
-0.0096456707,
-0.0248208139,
0.0427798182,
0.0001613102,
0.0021329294,
0.0021193267,
-6.755205304e-33,
0.0110786967,
0.0191950407,
0.0017285082,
0.0007952102,
-0.0155072063,
0.0382871777,
-0.0039804634,
-0.0213659219,
0.0037989279,
0.0113840932,
-0.0440467075,
0.0449309871,
0.0357773304,
0.0258598067,
-0.0124448854,
0.0128369443,
0.0528929643,
-0.0260910913,
-0.0341701135,
0.0548246652,
0.0395212695,
0.0468671434,
0.0222562645,
-0.0095355576,
-0.0046230806,
-0.0417694263,
-0.0025355436,
0.027736729,
-0.0006235305,
-0.0054536555,
-0.0519374609,
0.0459377468,
-0.0113439737,
-0.0351961441,
-0.0036909829,
-0.0041511632,
-0.0440832227,
0.0298006311,
0.0011340503,
0.0139148058,
-0.0514259189,
-0.0045146286,
0.0218078587,
0.0234389734,
-0.0389750041,
-0.0109398365,
0.0021404163,
0.0063729603,
-0.0534509458,
0.0011383304,
0.0113541894,
0.0196636934,
0.0318950117,
0.0128344633,
0.022745477,
-0.0683937222,
-0.013047589,
-0.0213852823,
-0.049194891,
-0.0011523401,
-0.0169815216,
0.0697302967,
0.053365618,
0.0338300131,
0.0313399546,
0.0619392022,
0.0772826895,
-0.016741978,
-0.0321502276,
0.0398436375,
0.0152304275,
0.0126350829,
0.0125259124,
0.0017420632,
-0.0215662252,
-0.0245790463,
-0.0670998767,
-0.0534476303,
0.0649684742,
-0.0031373468,
0.000996415,
0.0021256132,
-0.0237661861,
-0.0347770825,
-0.0224890858,
-0.0412379391,
-0.0103342952,
-0.0288916267,
-0.0167173818,
0.0525055826,
-0.0294085927,
0.0108283628,
0.0266655628,
-0.0536106192,
-0.0063165533,
0.0433877446,
0.0498683415,
0.0101463823,
0.0249875952,
0.0195695218,
-0.0759228468,
-0.0118128685,
-0.0746365041,
0.0191633441,
0.0061049587,
-0.0141488127,
0.0222382564,
0.0089618945,
-0.0433045551,
-0.0125889294,
-0.0278857294,
0.0237764344,
-0.0040481044,
0.0306931213,
0.0797736719,
0.0060089277,
0.0248047244,
0.0838546306,
0.0129598733,
0.0444198288,
0.0043540425,
-0.0026089901,
-0.031898275,
0.0237719901,
-0.0165527835,
0.0206347089,
-0.0561400764,
0.0515769757,
0.0267841406,
-0.072043635,
-0.0023478165,
-0.0189823471,
2.658e-7,
-0.0284164958,
0.0244427845,
-0.001988081,
-0.022457283,
0.0336633027,
0.0034603993,
-0.0089994166,
0.017356718,
0.0106351553,
0.0145460917,
-0.0162338968,
0.0346053019,
0.0674294308,
-0.0002756978,
-0.0639419183,
-0.0096797943,
-0.0986729786,
0.0637058914,
-0.0316385813,
-0.0637350902,
-0.0684712082,
0.0926307887,
0.0480405837,
-0.0308644269,
0.0066483328,
-0.0283738542,
0.0384681821,
0.0147196027,
-0.0400565751,
0.0095066205,
0.0176797491,
0.0315682068,
-0.0231144726,
-0.0175596308,
-0.0178686008,
0.0260570571,
-0.0444682203,
0.0674564764,
-0.0090052765,
0.0407974534,
0.0034030941,
0.0137964021,
-0.0631301031,
0.0110698566,
0.0554543398,
-0.0132392198,
0.0059350277,
-0.0586180948,
0.0513776876,
-0.0396737419,
0.037486393,
-0.0290126242,
-0.0074393195,
0.0103000961,
-0.0041007572,
-0.0246219244,
-0.0082555981,
-0.038907852,
0.0099180471,
0.0166672282,
-0.0575605929,
-0.0969612747,
-0.035950426,
0.0325835757,
0.0143956095,
-0.0192008,
0.0042977934,
2.201686914e-34,
0.0721404552,
-0.0376407728,
-0.0021630966,
0.0398208201,
-0.0154690826,
-0.0598262995,
-0.0136721209,
-0.0201864131,
-0.0132058766,
-0.0765183195,
-0.018006742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08103v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08103v1 | Exploring Semi-supervised Hierarchical Stacked Encoder for Legal Judgement Prediction | 2023-11-14T12:03:26 | 2023-11-14T12:03:26 | Nishchal Prasad, Mohand Boughanem, Taoufiq Dkaki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Predicting the judgment of a legal case from its unannotated case facts is a
challenging task. The lengthy and non-uniform document structure poses an even
greater challenge in extracting information for decision prediction. In this
work, we explore and propose a two-level classification mechanism; both
supervised and unsupervised; by using domain-specific pre-trained BERT to
extract information from long documents in terms of sentence embeddings further
processing with transformer encoder layer and use unsupervised clustering to
extract hidden labels from these embeddings to better predict a judgment of a
legal case. We conduct several experiments with this mechanism and see higher
performance gains than the previously proposed methods on the ILDC dataset. Our
experimental results also show the importance of domain-specific pre-training
of Transformer Encoders in legal information processing. | [
0.023025468,
0.04686822,
-0.014548962,
0.0369897559,
-0.0304373447,
0.0356058031,
0.0313537605,
0.0281167962,
0.0261672158,
-0.068451643,
-0.053223487,
0.0007491611,
-0.0452381894,
0.00543303,
-0.0237117466,
-0.0593300536,
-0.0004284844,
0.0233376138,
0.0666422173,
0.0072591226,
0.029543221,
-0.0048849117,
0.0095456168,
0.0262378473,
-0.0403017737,
-0.0162045993,
-0.0268746354,
-0.0335084237,
0.0019871092,
0.0036362398,
0.0342657045,
0.0525510646,
0.0534931198,
0.0108630108,
0.0000018749,
-0.0322927274,
-0.0051491829,
-0.0264425091,
-0.0190118104,
0.0272695869,
-0.027159309,
-0.0453098007,
-0.0096812351,
-0.0041223802,
-0.0362259857,
-0.0263864025,
-0.0199322719,
0.0591587685,
0.0303597134,
0.0672489926,
-0.0110977245,
-0.0654955208,
0.0489605591,
-0.0454312079,
-0.0242097862,
-0.014692422,
0.0138181057,
-0.0002685738,
-0.0167481638,
-0.0227914248,
-0.0144708473,
-0.0157075357,
0.0569901392,
-0.0328686871,
0.0092292801,
0.0282352697,
-0.042656105,
0.0161576681,
0.0005110862,
0.0473398231,
0.0219775699,
-0.0017218335,
-0.0269784462,
-0.0018602327,
0.0391350761,
0.0131516252,
0.0160880573,
0.070829846,
0.0021347732,
0.0313969776,
0.0035390831,
0.0629962236,
-0.0347980112,
-0.0288245212,
-0.0237773191,
0.0678940117,
-0.0042669983,
-0.070512563,
0.0086028026,
0.0281327814,
0.054626599,
-0.0458951555,
0.0564208515,
0.0186414272,
0.0349373631,
-0.0085941236,
-0.0365854874,
-0.0337740779,
0.0206077881,
-0.082706444,
0.0022092701,
-0.0059948377,
-0.013894585,
0.0697779357,
-0.0367290676,
0.0017180557,
0.0004629629,
0.0315000676,
-0.0177865457,
-0.0342529379,
-0.0288760643,
-0.0258576665,
-0.0302742273,
0.072656408,
-0.0613983721,
-0.002950391,
-0.0260121059,
-0.001135827,
-0.0132707944,
0.0060924841,
0.0109151853,
0.0151380422,
-0.0052994443,
-0.0120231146,
-0.050740473,
-0.0117081571,
-0.02370538,
0.0300034359,
-0.0083283652,
0.0315461531,
0.0005421672,
0.0299869385,
0.0150264809,
-0.0024942802,
0.0206580367,
0.0806716308,
-0.0268880688,
-0.0449117534,
-0.041210521,
-0.0250067189,
-0.0207427535,
-0.0439474806,
-0.0174479596,
-0.0372646824,
0.0325817354,
-0.0103877196,
-0.0332079045,
-0.0240516216,
-0.0093387589,
0.001201693,
0.0093368934,
0.0431537591,
0.0207294468,
-0.0476664677,
0.0031877551,
-0.0000947782,
0.040074382,
0.0230850764,
0.0228768438,
0.0565118492,
0.0230111536,
-0.0211965106,
0.0247151963,
0.0251089595,
0.011513711,
-0.0111286994,
-0.0117717963,
0.0068151499,
-0.014422005,
0.0057386793,
-0.0077331611,
0.0165470745,
-0.0120134298,
-0.001548512,
0.0003720307,
0.0264128465,
0.0188653469,
0.0475929789,
-0.0105810435,
0.0081821792,
-0.000301344,
0.016562663,
-0.021264784,
0.0205596834,
-0.0249941796,
-0.0065720566,
-0.0378371812,
-0.000199211,
-0.0513864681,
-0.039635893,
0.0335201696,
-0.0183209926,
0.0236764029,
-0.0212120824,
0.0476413816,
0.0248872954,
-0.0281399749,
0.0557269044,
0.0189002883,
-0.0437153019,
-0.0003653105,
-0.0062872232,
0.0260995571,
0.017491186,
0.0452086143,
-0.0483617596,
-0.0123619698,
-0.0214844681,
-0.0339064971,
0.0464571491,
-0.0097361458,
-0.0123002306,
0.0061157625,
-0.0561230406,
-0.0772444904,
0.0032926297,
0.0195484329,
-0.0000021662,
-0.0418219902,
0.0316025279,
0.0489743389,
-0.0842939317,
0.0593028255,
0.0278371014,
0.0190477222,
-0.0347964838,
0.0449741669,
0.0298735276,
0.0335954092,
0.0072948933,
-0.0245297253,
-0.0335106775,
0.0281778201,
-0.0177488402,
-0.0520943813,
-0.0150752608,
-0.0168774053,
-0.0886739418,
-0.0050686267,
-0.0584823638,
-0.026435636,
-0.0143904379,
-0.0388406627,
-0.0117727853,
-0.0562428236,
-0.0183768496,
0.0361248292,
-0.054134082,
-0.014597876,
-0.0037814586,
0.001344073,
-0.0005703308,
0.0637605339,
-0.0113461018,
-0.0361597724,
-0.0692124292,
-0.0347269326,
0.0360406861,
0.0067315795,
-0.0085889464,
-0.0205092076,
-0.0162333809,
-0.0228033327,
0.0299283992,
0.0070720911,
-0.0170008633,
-0.0424856953,
-0.0940134898,
-0.0029677986,
-0.0474362262,
-0.0048216251,
-0.0281398203,
-0.0126811098,
-0.0027354145,
-0.0288139526,
-0.0536780357,
-0.0347460657,
-0.0059497491,
-0.0054747746,
0.0390049256,
-0.0324556641,
-0.0078121452,
0.0056775375,
-0.0336279199,
-0.0219534431,
0.07529632,
-0.0002068863,
-0.0257986337,
-0.0382124521,
0.0276746266,
0.0065670875,
-0.0094885863,
-0.0260466877,
-0.0026346247,
-0.0246702489,
0.0268832035,
0.0206890721,
0.033053495,
0.075291723,
0.0293064024,
0.0082081826,
0.0328787714,
-0.0446422808,
0.0204179231,
-0.02544,
0.0652080849,
-0.0376085825,
0.0486159846,
0.0289873462,
0.0470421053,
0.0213870071,
0.0014872259,
-0.0249844287,
-0.0530734919,
0.0164204016,
-0.0044076797,
-0.030557584,
-0.0312104337,
0.005203234,
0.0333016738,
0.0337765478,
-0.0646907464,
0.081595853,
0.0071898866,
0.0284394585,
-0.0512386598,
0.0008618482,
-0.0609912649,
0.0702723712,
0.0361115038,
-0.0146629699,
-0.0378379747,
-0.0495978184,
0.0475225523,
0.0053203572,
0.02353522,
-0.0016436683,
0.0419439971,
0.0337172374,
0.0243967753,
-0.0324921794,
-0.0665757135,
-0.0351371132,
-0.0389835015,
0.0211988091,
0.0152084501,
0.0376487076,
0.0312739797,
-0.0738513544,
-0.0198841132,
-0.0192358717,
0.0475604534,
0.0128216762,
-0.0015524515,
-0.0182562135,
0.057774093,
0.0018529029,
-0.0334428325,
-0.0133105982,
-0.0444478504,
-0.0019627244,
0.0334647968,
-0.0312208366,
-0.0005670227,
0.0153749585,
-0.0124294776,
0.0002205253,
-0.0604441613,
0.0238935426,
0.0350980461,
-0.0091672176,
-0.0419792645,
0.0379314981,
0.1085075811,
0.0342288651,
-0.0423201472,
-0.0047706561,
0.0078332229,
-0.0012307493,
0.0081602801,
0.00319746,
-0.0838750377,
-0.0114502124,
-0.0110462215,
-0.0369525701,
0.0072999811,
-0.0267810319,
0.0335516371,
-0.0803177729,
0.0625711977,
0.0009011436,
0.0217201486,
-0.0494375303,
-0.0314566568,
-0.0145738041,
0.0030700557,
-0.0173379835,
-0.0064487695,
0.0126768351,
-0.0432214215,
0.0036101397,
-0.0924872831,
0.0114020137,
0.0494691171,
-0.0326228254,
-0.0143659469,
0.0148007553,
0.0319894068,
-0.0277685057,
-0.0554349385,
0.002718216,
-0.0135917068,
-0.0005398977,
0.0328046829,
0.0789802298,
-0.050153736,
0.0393186286,
-0.0578316487,
0.0566717461,
-0.0136463949,
-0.0280496255,
0.0506247729,
0.0528295897,
-0.0443996117,
-0.0473447442,
-0.0169340484,
-0.021037614,
-0.0141895656,
0.0478315987,
-0.0058612148,
-0.0340096094,
-0.0420910306,
-0.0126430457,
-0.0001086375,
-0.0146650383,
0.0244246349,
0.010030116,
-0.0105618006,
0.0148874195,
-0.033685986,
-0.0455329046,
-0.0000046502,
0.0307456907,
-0.0071806069,
-0.0240708049,
0.0523048714,
-0.0127172843,
-0.0552403405,
0.0170356818,
-0.0090428032,
-0.0177848563,
-0.0348868184,
0.0152430208,
0.0377056487,
0.0220760629,
-0.0216583963,
-0.0488845333,
0.0264421068,
-0.0140314121,
-0.0160843581,
0.0068188971,
-0.0024896946,
0.0258104187,
-0.0427370109,
-0.0151004242,
0.1246358156,
0.0552364327,
-0.0346836895,
-0.0419408903,
0.06731648,
-0.0766412169,
-0.0185463503,
-0.0062896395,
-0.022039758,
0.0557196066,
0.015932288,
-0.0088266674,
-0.0270063449,
-0.0154413376,
0.0123149883,
0.006250653,
0.0995705277,
0.0042315787,
0.0054205209,
-0.0401748605,
0.0568079315,
-0.0393644832,
0.0065272157,
-0.0155429579,
-0.0220353305,
0.0156493653,
0.0013659147,
-0.0264929049,
0.1232820898,
-0.0058139553,
-0.0150010176,
-0.0205457658,
0.0882459506,
0.021565482,
-0.0210975986,
-0.0028349042,
-0.0190876238,
-0.0096584512,
-0.0160896815,
0.0222684946,
0.0342005119,
-0.0098990696,
0.0494024158,
0.0221457444,
0.0410944559,
-0.0113870604,
0.0318853892,
-0.0235784221,
0.043877013,
-0.0533779263,
0.0149837285,
0.0238515828,
-0.0351685807,
-0.0496049486,
-0.0078814793,
0.0010637263,
0.0131636662,
0.0390094966,
-0.0194052514,
-0.0475126989,
0.0249382015,
0.0107048266,
-0.0526270531,
0.0168986674,
0.0463536866,
-0.0041316464,
0.0123932138,
0.0085248249,
-0.018889498,
-0.0636988282,
-0.0315627567,
0.0501236692,
0.0190897547,
-0.0206541475,
-0.0249621756,
-0.0231967513,
-0.0029656887,
-0.0011269378,
0.0068829986,
0.0109556615,
0.0247684456,
0.0383579396,
0.0411338247,
0.0153610529,
-0.0163987875,
-0.0385841802,
0.0221312623,
0.0344203562,
-0.0043456536,
-0.0140364282,
-5.714984639e-33,
-0.0114746224,
-0.0194031484,
-0.0225419328,
0.0439760275,
0.0010276486,
-0.0024444475,
0.0170010533,
-0.0202014875,
0.0191713497,
0.0533669442,
-0.003087352,
0.0215312578,
0.009911892,
0.0421943553,
0.0296310168,
-0.0275045913,
0.0228090733,
0.0087591298,
-0.0221041851,
0.0194502492,
0.012633157,
0.0339688957,
0.0423718728,
-0.0742227659,
-0.0192247089,
0.0428995565,
0.0111406352,
-0.0250478853,
-0.029562898,
0.0432656445,
-0.0009733274,
0.0242982469,
0.0263186581,
-0.0659512952,
0.0022597045,
0.0538847446,
-0.0633828416,
0.0082463548,
-0.0573117398,
0.0066970084,
-0.0061576213,
-0.0058434648,
0.0170855969,
0.0263482053,
-0.0226282347,
-0.0221237559,
0.055343736,
-0.0172228571,
-0.028280912,
-0.105429478,
-0.0639025792,
0.0400038771,
-0.0223294888,
0.0024727986,
0.0337856486,
0.0154220881,
0.0231898166,
0.0526660644,
-0.10693717,
-0.0079408782,
-0.0282063223,
-0.0022796665,
-0.0056297737,
-0.043673113,
-0.0092181824,
0.0755074173,
-0.0299596898,
0.018231323,
-0.0888614804,
-0.0100208428,
0.0134062637,
0.071747683,
0.0268608108,
0.009839993,
0.0707152933,
-0.0512539037,
-0.1051017791,
0.0339164771,
0.0253536683,
-0.0098574609,
0.0204607453,
-0.0026048806,
-0.0446351729,
-0.0052517033,
0.0065228394,
-0.0341895223,
0.0155777447,
0.0099811535,
-0.0045092641,
0.0199550074,
0.0552813858,
-0.0301243775,
0.0148332799,
-0.0248366147,
0.0244203899,
0.0351425186,
-0.0050842692,
0.0211574435,
0.002176625,
0.0069251452,
-0.0421165302,
-0.0417032801,
0.0373830795,
-0.0174722504,
-0.0127665233,
-0.0140721388,
0.1006168127,
-0.0124939866,
-0.0514409915,
-0.0034774519,
0.041698467,
0.0056341966,
0.022892978,
0.058444906,
-0.0122224558,
0.0266099889,
0.005897468,
0.0540835932,
-0.026786847,
0.0361106284,
-0.019945899,
0.010191109,
0.0323467739,
0.0001958351,
0.0261883717,
-0.0193109065,
-0.0156109016,
0.0257769339,
0.0174156707,
-0.0470138267,
0.0300617777,
0.052259136,
2.586e-7,
0.0473225191,
0.0576332398,
0.0314571522,
-0.05647346,
0.0314240828,
0.0494177863,
0.0322209634,
0.0701362714,
0.0092064226,
-0.0227286667,
0.0402997397,
-0.0101142935,
0.0547749139,
0.031858325,
-0.0776303634,
-0.0331266969,
-0.0534750819,
-0.0611823238,
-0.0623675585,
0.0103964964,
0.0677182898,
0.1143376082,
0.0170121398,
-0.0036256213,
0.0126331272,
-0.0060384492,
0.0682968572,
0.0072106295,
-0.0220829472,
0.0011965673,
0.0350277498,
-0.0457329117,
-0.0101222899,
0.0641799048,
-0.0278527923,
0.0943233296,
-0.0168486051,
0.0429877527,
-0.0064439909,
0.0333565585,
0.0145226577,
0.0052616894,
-0.0127124479,
0.012943767,
0.0648922622,
-0.058636006,
-0.0438231975,
0.0376234353,
-0.0497118644,
0.0009163268,
0.0346335508,
0.0290035065,
-0.0156547856,
-0.0114257829,
0.046205122,
-0.0202724934,
0.0267496463,
-0.0855981484,
0.0241972525,
0.0370986797,
-0.0720201135,
0.029559372,
0.0115012471,
-0.0344981886,
0.0830985382,
-0.070873186,
0.0324868783,
2.096316473e-34,
0.0288081262,
-0.0000521817,
-0.0125772292,
-0.0130743664,
0.0341351889,
-0.005670697,
0.0249743052,
-0.0324332044,
-0.0112758027,
-0.0779763609,
0.030081274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08097v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08097v4 | Empowering Multi-step Reasoning across Languages via Tree-of-Thoughts | 2023-11-14T11:49:43 | 2024-06-21T06:06:51 | Leonardo Ranaldi, Giulia Pucci, Federico Ranaldi, Elena Sofia Ruzzetti, Fabio Massimo Zanzotto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Reasoning methods, best exemplified by the well-known Chain-of-Thought (CoT),
empower the reasoning abilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) by eliciting
them to solve complex tasks in a step-by-step manner. Although they are
achieving significant success, the ability to deliver multi-step reasoning
remains limited to English because of the imbalance in the distribution of
pre-training data, which makes other languages a barrier. In this paper, we
propose Cross-lingual Tree-of-Thoughts (Cross-ToT), a method for aligning
Cross-lingual CoT reasoning across languages. The proposed method, through a
self-consistent cross-lingual prompting mechanism inspired by the
Tree-of-Thoughts approach, provides multi-step reasoning paths in different
languages that, during the steps, lead to the final solution. Experimental
evaluations show that our method significantly outperforms existing prompting
methods by reducing the number of interactions and achieving state-of-the-art
performance. | [
0.0218510944,
0.0168028567,
-0.0065267887,
0.0502162948,
-0.0638341755,
0.0370722301,
0.0325792767,
-0.0450137854,
0.0067585828,
-0.0074288785,
-0.0261548925,
-0.0424918905,
0.0105921309,
-0.0073305201,
0.0044477107,
-0.0469244123,
0.0388676636,
-0.0769242346,
-0.0142998928,
-0.0496177003,
-0.0072563333,
0.0357151479,
-0.0310796294,
0.0328433998,
0.0022609723,
-0.0561972857,
-0.041102495,
-0.0173416249,
0.0384857729,
-0.0343663879,
-0.0249808617,
0.0516763143,
0.0182273928,
0.059760198,
0.0000022292,
-0.0543889441,
-0.0109761395,
-0.0098515544,
-0.0209374893,
-0.0113052055,
-0.024045093,
0.0012287155,
0.0117376801,
0.0137871234,
-0.0355157554,
0.0150918644,
0.0331688002,
0.0517447554,
0.0450009629,
0.0534761697,
-0.00170816,
-0.0520667844,
-0.0121498574,
-0.005393249,
0.0193731841,
-0.0452356264,
-0.0012640359,
0.0145310219,
0.0248065367,
0.0050914339,
-0.0024080009,
0.0350573435,
0.0518316887,
-0.0221422501,
-0.0363946594,
0.0305836555,
-0.0005025647,
-0.0314820409,
-0.0334125981,
0.0569926165,
-0.0131936232,
-0.0200042482,
-0.0260025822,
-0.0119858719,
-0.0080011459,
-0.0033805626,
-0.0484736152,
0.0465434976,
-0.0011098897,
0.0213311836,
0.0447006039,
0.0049337032,
0.0133100785,
0.0208091792,
-0.0589212589,
0.0901465043,
-0.0020925,
-0.0457224064,
0.0554751083,
0.0290784445,
0.0320013687,
-0.0872293338,
0.0103202425,
0.0525639057,
-0.0616471767,
0.0200268775,
0.0253676102,
0.0041033216,
-0.007324554,
-0.0325222798,
0.0197454933,
0.0635378286,
-0.0314598009,
0.0647546723,
-0.0431175493,
0.0299151056,
-0.0307023302,
0.0201019142,
-0.0432914048,
-0.0274163615,
-0.0705826655,
-0.0114450455,
-0.0345474668,
0.0354669765,
-0.031482704,
-0.0026581502,
-0.0240036715,
0.0149662122,
-0.0210565124,
0.0228229277,
0.0334178731,
-0.002322932,
0.0365505628,
-0.0296025947,
-0.034327589,
0.0652453676,
-0.0498945341,
-0.0034820605,
0.0132680098,
-0.0002403922,
0.0009797793,
0.0072168922,
-0.0349015221,
-0.0381435789,
0.0356674455,
0.047252655,
-0.0300080106,
0.0257627238,
-0.030660985,
-0.0261548087,
-0.0010645296,
-0.1014724672,
0.0232326258,
-0.0892071947,
0.031575568,
0.0176522471,
-0.0034165385,
0.0085680289,
0.0239250604,
0.0310324766,
-0.025142502,
0.0527622886,
-0.0044233557,
0.0289739762,
0.0050644083,
0.0000065616,
-0.0270030666,
0.0679887757,
0.0213233065,
0.0127370944,
0.0104084499,
0.0151629131,
-0.0213936102,
0.0369581878,
-0.0007032187,
-0.0150740845,
0.0131599568,
0.0232380982,
-0.0209426172,
0.0459735245,
-0.0136107989,
0.0305097178,
-0.0086341426,
0.0399778672,
0.0211007576,
0.0503218919,
-0.0133191654,
0.0321707949,
0.052119825,
-0.0241571665,
-0.0150087411,
0.0098405331,
-0.0494507998,
0.0607190393,
-0.0343358852,
0.0008848076,
-0.0139635187,
0.0556384847,
-0.0413632356,
-0.0236813929,
0.0095325811,
0.0255331583,
0.0181572493,
0.0433432646,
0.0527528375,
-0.0040991316,
0.0056843157,
0.0303061567,
0.0258625541,
-0.0333362408,
-0.0320855193,
-0.0260543972,
0.0296127182,
0.0471504368,
-0.0011410143,
0.0115296319,
-0.0365030095,
-0.0126651814,
0.0376245528,
0.0400191508,
0.0186549481,
-0.0172823239,
-0.0223867688,
-0.0537940674,
-0.040716581,
0.0003798659,
-0.0325088315,
0.0336139612,
-0.0179342367,
0.0228395853,
-0.003406777,
-0.0047608106,
-0.0130990166,
0.0097306091,
-0.0184461083,
0.0182790421,
0.0088265715,
0.0529350936,
0.0064726584,
0.0409115925,
0.0085414918,
0.0134928878,
-0.0052998536,
-0.0391193107,
-0.0381150432,
0.0229247753,
-0.0566146336,
-0.0494235642,
0.0453752875,
-0.0024299568,
-0.0797192305,
-0.0241635125,
-0.041108083,
-0.0412302464,
-0.0001892964,
-0.009833483,
0.0096811634,
-0.0372333825,
0.0347110629,
-0.0010535115,
-0.0385095328,
-0.005541984,
0.0971093103,
0.0121263517,
0.0343674943,
0.0508779064,
-0.0127880462,
0.0538284481,
-0.0066311532,
-0.0210735798,
0.050589025,
0.0025342945,
-0.0235110577,
0.0298068505,
0.0677871183,
-0.0467732251,
0.0074481284,
-0.1080006734,
-0.0084307129,
-0.0202982146,
0.030956639,
-0.0002819818,
0.0052910754,
0.0078093046,
-0.01901545,
-0.0887796506,
0.0107382573,
0.036958795,
0.027943477,
0.0234549511,
-0.0219731927,
-0.0132514788,
0.009657573,
0.0020380395,
-0.0312517323,
0.0414715298,
-0.003617777,
-0.0427893437,
-0.0436162092,
0.03800207,
-0.0801667422,
0.0193377491,
-0.0030325393,
-0.0177471191,
0.033194717,
-0.0101606278,
0.055005189,
0.0616491027,
-0.0184592307,
-0.0575964004,
0.0890302435,
-0.0306161903,
-0.0442239866,
0.029040549,
0.0005673766,
-0.0029228926,
-0.0075327167,
-0.0238010157,
-0.0216154233,
0.0620407276,
-0.0203204714,
0.0023021961,
-0.0701774731,
-0.0047653774,
-0.0100714592,
0.0026176039,
-0.0469661355,
-0.0165875833,
0.0128645096,
0.0861961916,
-0.0112933898,
-0.0039279615,
0.1133347526,
-0.0307752658,
-0.0251743831,
-0.063195996,
0.0185044091,
-0.0475236066,
0.0948713869,
-0.0322800763,
0.0399753302,
0.0044375253,
-0.0094284294,
-0.0784195513,
-0.0110083837,
0.024102943,
-0.0068695373,
0.0428285077,
-0.0426768176,
0.0006702165,
-0.019303767,
-0.0703483447,
-0.0350955129,
0.0061283377,
-0.0513509773,
0.0091711404,
-0.0201395787,
-0.021153478,
0.0009005026,
-0.0104342606,
0.0696893632,
0.0201778077,
-0.0148415146,
-0.0206547622,
-0.0010720615,
0.0178672746,
0.0276877936,
0.0121398037,
0.030190222,
-0.0228699204,
0.0796120837,
0.0381414481,
0.026591124,
-0.0077488534,
-0.0097619509,
0.0203763749,
0.0202161931,
0.0067627579,
-0.0341938324,
-0.0011625135,
0.0462227054,
-0.0562058762,
0.0024804126,
0.1047201604,
0.0472571813,
-0.0571512841,
-0.0060494933,
-0.0776183829,
0.0299632363,
0.0341859832,
0.0387837179,
-0.1082791984,
-0.0363021381,
0.0204930324,
-0.039622169,
0.0041412553,
-0.0272151381,
0.0003499577,
-0.1532083452,
0.0321735591,
-0.0015404539,
-0.0169391409,
-0.0249184389,
-0.0147560863,
-0.0071319253,
0.0342302062,
-0.0045263232,
0.0125037795,
0.0084500089,
-0.0129210008,
0.0079338839,
-0.0043942067,
-0.0217796043,
0.0557621755,
-0.0282157101,
0.0026240598,
0.0457295105,
0.0431168154,
0.0385364182,
-0.0521550439,
0.0230705235,
-0.003479097,
0.0057708793,
-0.028680604,
-0.0290071033,
0.0365551375,
-0.0138051845,
-0.0216519497,
0.0211667549,
-0.0156922732,
-0.0064989068,
0.0536744706,
0.1296610087,
-0.0148641197,
-0.0130148903,
0.0145650981,
0.0210969187,
-0.0126434173,
0.066045098,
0.0089309299,
-0.0330262482,
-0.0451919325,
-0.0304396711,
-0.0663893223,
0.0002578235,
-0.0267142206,
0.0439738408,
0.0002398672,
-0.0051348615,
-0.0448103733,
-0.0548306815,
0.0507626794,
0.0364232585,
0.0234274343,
0.0033465163,
-0.0032528692,
0.0224396493,
0.0030251988,
0.0166248623,
-0.0283489712,
0.0461596809,
-0.0150814457,
0.0292412676,
0.0081652552,
-0.0287229437,
-0.0126653323,
0.0225662775,
-0.0510484949,
-0.0704535767,
-0.0831592903,
0.0447074287,
0.0200635493,
0.0452550575,
-0.0046490976,
-0.029088106,
0.01229594,
-0.0114212828,
-0.0278400835,
-0.024090115,
0.0342205018,
0.0418888628,
0.0136969052,
0.0547989644,
-0.0362035893,
0.0119052706,
-0.0033567112,
0.0630029887,
-0.0396380611,
0.0019392445,
0.0353844091,
0.010787392,
0.0022399186,
-0.0156067144,
0.0041378322,
-0.0425815284,
0.047779046,
-0.0399333723,
-0.0584979355,
-0.0261200164,
0.0229899082,
0.0114141647,
-0.0199692491,
0.0320987962,
-0.0243256129,
0.0059519922,
-0.0459078439,
-0.0114875222,
0.0133385034,
0.0331878327,
0.0569145568,
0.0398037136,
0.0008439759,
-0.0188731607,
-0.0226043109,
0.0369339809,
0.0248194188,
-0.0292218477,
0.1197642013,
0.0392300263,
-0.0108080404,
-0.0247064456,
0.0000098021,
-0.0482841097,
-0.0959342271,
0.043537885,
-0.018920159,
0.0779488236,
0.0170187354,
0.0335599445,
-0.0384101756,
-0.012059195,
0.0307414532,
0.0290710405,
0.0199795812,
-0.0470191427,
0.012730605,
0.0089642089,
0.0044817738,
-0.0153437573,
0.0304483287,
-0.0630889237,
-0.0117739746,
0.0140547138,
-0.0132694524,
-0.0141938329,
-0.0428420343,
-0.0413981192,
0.0124978228,
-0.0245197788,
0.0210105199,
-0.0662571788,
-0.077313751,
-0.03208277,
0.0069775605,
-0.0272279009,
0.0184292831,
0.0474489145,
0.0707298964,
0.0001846186,
-0.01950044,
-0.0076595596,
0.0015253053,
-0.0221157093,
-0.0401726998,
-0.0575916059,
-6.169729037e-33,
-0.0020957731,
-0.01692231,
0.0657089427,
0.0301988143,
-0.0137934247,
-0.0255025588,
-0.067935884,
0.0167506468,
-0.0214806348,
0.0392531343,
-0.0312761776,
-0.0239059869,
0.0085943528,
0.0169838145,
0.0434718318,
0.0025511915,
0.0179785825,
-0.0028720761,
-0.0190174188,
0.0186630674,
0.0514279567,
0.0013730887,
0.0574203432,
-0.041657269,
0.0413141809,
0.0065427441,
-0.0007123235,
0.0577123985,
-0.0324090868,
0.0382499546,
-0.0107577546,
0.0231732149,
0.0316116065,
-0.0160764474,
0.0004971844,
0.0265105385,
-0.06103044,
-0.0489522107,
0.0536749139,
-0.0047567631,
-0.0355952308,
-0.0119246366,
-0.0305443667,
-0.0244024824,
0.0042771539,
-0.0080373846,
0.0173951909,
-0.0227440335,
0.0141966539,
-0.0167719554,
-0.0631745532,
-0.0051131002,
-0.0376672894,
-0.0366767608,
0.0409134477,
0.091630511,
-0.0152912475,
-0.0350324474,
-0.0382626988,
0.0323813669,
-0.0069811507,
-0.0060571562,
0.0893023983,
-0.0200091172,
0.0055196923,
0.0380515791,
0.0263116173,
-0.0188257564,
-0.0392085873,
0.0178091787,
-0.0046227048,
0.0255384482,
0.0635760501,
0.0140887266,
-0.0007130051,
0.052958224,
-0.102908209,
-0.0064528566,
0.037995398,
0.0463987924,
0.0263494812,
-0.0155565608,
-0.0079689529,
-0.0268924348,
-0.0313868336,
-0.016332861,
-0.0377312601,
-0.0398219824,
0.0221855249,
-0.0149921961,
0.0028797891,
-0.0207576919,
0.0401452035,
-0.0049537933,
-0.0323698372,
0.0529347695,
-0.0062645418,
0.0203818996,
0.0091866879,
0.0535785109,
-0.044623483,
-0.0052669104,
-0.0291489009,
-0.0134747913,
0.0117261708,
0.0185997821,
0.0474022999,
-0.0075976606,
-0.0534130409,
0.0018150366,
-0.0809212998,
0.0280667841,
-0.0303871911,
0.0258457158,
0.0347941704,
0.0109561607,
-0.0107835233,
0.0346195213,
-0.004276712,
-0.0240912996,
-0.0459721498,
0.0066864369,
-0.011548778,
0.02091741,
-0.0081910221,
0.0045293602,
-0.0492682606,
0.0183204133,
0.0358645841,
-0.0446002185,
-0.0070604431,
0.0463948771,
2.826e-7,
0.0012704772,
0.0240641441,
-0.013605278,
0.0316743143,
0.0069892891,
0.0214411542,
-0.0393621549,
-0.0377051458,
0.0241323095,
-0.055794362,
-0.00505136,
0.0470532924,
0.0605000146,
0.049515333,
-0.0995975584,
-0.0048913527,
-0.0526767038,
-0.0391894542,
-0.0632513389,
-0.0024655757,
0.0433064699,
0.0486743525,
0.0053679617,
-0.0185579583,
-0.0033305758,
0.0004412995,
0.0527158417,
-0.0186677966,
0.0094297631,
-0.0058153975,
-0.0077769151,
-0.0245092623,
0.0024462563,
0.0348227397,
0.0062128818,
0.0377404206,
-0.0176434666,
0.0290861782,
0.0008548856,
0.001139071,
-0.0043967147,
-0.0249106064,
-0.0131976055,
-0.0775924101,
0.0692441687,
-0.0502654798,
-0.0165220834,
-0.0050498601,
0.035358835,
-0.0255845226,
0.04265723,
-0.0045079314,
-0.0195602234,
0.0239761434,
0.026580032,
-0.0263531581,
0.0133617269,
-0.0653482974,
-0.0130882896,
0.0302849486,
-0.0092175305,
-0.0133584179,
-0.0288840234,
0.0027418288,
0.0000832711,
-0.03538936,
-0.0115138544,
2.468118678e-34,
0.0202299934,
-0.0335131623,
0.0313314758,
0.0311656725,
0.0315376408,
-0.0026182723,
-0.0070008598,
0.0081699248,
0.024604734,
-0.0661779717,
-0.0357028022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08093v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08093v1 | Spot: A Natural Language Interface for Geospatial Searches in OSM | 2023-11-14T11:35:09 | 2023-11-14T11:35:09 | Lynn Khellaf, Ipek Baris Schlicht, Julia Bayer, Ruben Bouwmeester, Tilman Miraß, Tilman Wagner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Investigative journalists and fact-checkers have found OpenStreetMap (OSM) to
be an invaluable resource for their work due to its extensive coverage and
intricate details of various locations, which play a crucial role in
investigating news scenes. Despite its value, OSM's complexity presents
considerable accessibility and usability challenges, especially for those
without a technical background. To address this, we introduce 'Spot', a
user-friendly natural language interface for querying OSM data. Spot utilizes a
semantic mapping from natural language to OSM tags, leveraging artificially
generated sentence queries and a T5 transformer. This approach enables Spot to
extract relevant information from user-input sentences and display candidate
locations matching the descriptions on a map. To foster collaboration and
future advancement, all code and generated data is available as an open-source
repository. | [
0.0155846681,
0.0336084478,
-0.0218010321,
0.0089915646,
-0.0355531909,
-0.033737693,
-0.0050219996,
-0.0095107984,
0.0163057391,
-0.042646464,
0.0096461512,
0.100866653,
-0.0090357764,
0.0131223369,
-0.0251421724,
-0.0594073124,
0.0387860276,
-0.0130488174,
-0.0099672694,
0.0448636711,
-0.004047181,
0.0536981747,
-0.0080199447,
0.0310540143,
0.0056931996,
0.0188801661,
-0.0373479873,
0.011788181,
0.0252317004,
-0.0688967779,
-0.0446797349,
0.0086800009,
0.0229157116,
0.0064826328,
0.0000018603,
0.0017583994,
-0.0512645654,
-0.0056715123,
0.0495099202,
-0.0193944219,
-0.0076464,
-0.020635223,
0.001021968,
0.0143461842,
-0.0566228665,
-0.0248820856,
0.0698191896,
0.004590895,
0.0683763027,
0.0533516519,
-0.0259751212,
-0.0228999928,
-0.0379723087,
0.0458102822,
0.0149806431,
0.0081450576,
-0.0235445015,
-0.0581910983,
0.0625033528,
0.0851992443,
0.0619327202,
0.0081603816,
-0.0448387191,
-0.0116861537,
0.0052014976,
0.0511939563,
-0.0412298329,
-0.0102359047,
0.0238123052,
0.0160970297,
0.0204552878,
0.0006961601,
0.0420834683,
0.02161856,
-0.0289571583,
0.0186195336,
-0.0558468364,
0.0091354372,
-0.0307182986,
0.04805867,
-0.0379828997,
-0.0080777882,
0.0078679156,
0.043627739,
-0.0108952932,
0.1019172296,
0.0074123307,
-0.018660631,
-0.0638318583,
0.0128131257,
-0.0224837642,
-0.036443267,
0.0366766639,
0.0382054634,
-0.0376568474,
0.0033007264,
-0.0225136317,
0.0143195977,
0.035914734,
-0.0539683029,
0.0188019946,
0.0020623887,
-0.0240241122,
0.0407602228,
0.0305230431,
-0.0008746108,
0.0256930515,
0.0324757025,
-0.0114155412,
-0.0395029224,
-0.0535023436,
-0.0132603319,
-0.039891284,
0.0212399531,
-0.0630013496,
0.0150127644,
0.0088970587,
-0.0030007076,
0.0183256157,
-0.0185505711,
-0.0532165356,
0.0343104117,
-0.0166642498,
-0.0135568129,
-0.0340232886,
0.0119037256,
-0.0334132239,
0.0089654587,
0.0027376327,
-0.0046422598,
0.0070774383,
0.022693079,
0.0687155649,
0.0273323171,
-0.0520295277,
-0.0197983719,
0.0273147617,
-0.0300048254,
-0.0830515772,
-0.0097868256,
-0.0156955663,
0.0184086971,
-0.0069273766,
-0.0829473436,
-0.026688708,
0.0145103466,
-0.0357271843,
-0.0016241961,
0.0008535621,
0.0850750059,
-0.0242587738,
0.0611924529,
-0.0587536693,
0.0197268222,
0.0557743087,
-0.0175257847,
0.0777035505,
0.0453140475,
0.008512849,
0.0809788629,
0.0565487482,
0.0340082943,
0.0286147818,
0.0182581116,
-0.042012129,
-0.013991259,
0.0126302177,
0.0150077054,
-0.0346517712,
0.0497387089,
-0.018778557,
0.0375591479,
0.0295916852,
0.0405815989,
0.0428337082,
0.0700422078,
-0.0017938336,
-0.0133168129,
0.0155441174,
0.0847193897,
-0.0326138325,
-0.0614219606,
-0.028434461,
0.0068534389,
-0.0124254497,
0.0187206287,
-0.0163657088,
0.0412661284,
0.0181454066,
-0.0188833177,
-0.052819822,
0.0279352237,
0.0365335122,
-0.0050809174,
0.0260924436,
-0.0329130553,
-0.0010501688,
0.0477886051,
-0.0203928836,
-0.0012114983,
0.0161316898,
0.0098600537,
-0.0016189232,
0.0272954423,
0.0136443404,
-0.0073508322,
0.035598956,
-0.0084217135,
-0.0126353428,
0.0720765442,
0.0222542845,
0.0181761514,
-0.0252090208,
-0.0353330821,
-0.0142433774,
0.0097994907,
0.0385468788,
-0.0226598736,
0.0585371815,
0.0608166642,
0.0394557491,
-0.0810972452,
-0.0103322202,
0.0203790944,
0.0513953492,
0.0040015434,
-0.0157074016,
0.02838834,
-0.0595754199,
0.0197524801,
0.0196643062,
0.0323303603,
0.0497646928,
-0.00119803,
-0.003320578,
0.0099724494,
0.0352201313,
0.03696879,
0.0032092172,
-0.0763665438,
0.0025362053,
0.0439074896,
-0.0252855234,
-0.0250049084,
-0.0223852247,
-0.0623886846,
0.0119111845,
-0.0161280204,
0.0069448147,
0.022568984,
0.0131473681,
-0.0616126992,
0.0574122071,
0.0056193215,
-0.0006138075,
0.0181133486,
-0.0398729108,
0.0420080908,
0.0092547974,
0.0196927469,
-0.028878862,
-0.0355016552,
0.0054530199,
0.0055632573,
0.0083776163,
-0.0298169963,
-0.0325469188,
-0.1100571007,
0.0143055199,
-0.0109574255,
0.0271454658,
0.0098709846,
0.0365742035,
-0.0298599303,
-0.0073341643,
-0.0076902821,
-0.0302777775,
0.040098872,
-0.0225188527,
0.0412233621,
-0.0028963618,
0.0253274422,
-0.0156633556,
0.0322214253,
-0.0277845562,
0.0109103033,
0.0188298579,
-0.0517905317,
-0.03401687,
-0.0093171988,
-0.0188113339,
-0.0024364772,
0.0363505892,
-0.0319611691,
0.0514544956,
-0.027349066,
-0.0009845812,
0.0200955849,
0.0347171128,
0.014694524,
0.0258592609,
-0.0280860923,
-0.0238214806,
0.0014932313,
-0.0289234314,
0.026537057,
-0.0124717522,
-0.0382513367,
0.0392388515,
-0.0217690542,
0.0009604158,
0.0338847935,
0.0250598378,
0.0036827812,
0.0041700411,
0.0396525972,
-0.0056285113,
0.0322543867,
-0.0022050824,
0.0946012586,
-0.0290497225,
-0.0371966511,
0.0261740424,
-0.0250522159,
0.0300095975,
-0.0474693142,
-0.0242666882,
-0.0572225712,
0.0768848807,
-0.0237417668,
0.0184485689,
0.0445552692,
-0.0282715894,
0.0289335493,
-0.0561067536,
0.0066237794,
0.0005593325,
0.0050514811,
-0.0311051533,
0.0071792272,
0.0082103545,
-0.0359953754,
0.0049865944,
-0.036799863,
-0.0471002944,
-0.0168155208,
0.0272774603,
-0.0430140011,
-0.0113161625,
0.050374113,
0.0170346182,
0.053155221,
-0.0076296655,
-0.0208218694,
-0.0123352502,
0.0216921344,
0.0576782413,
0.063528426,
-0.0179790109,
0.073191911,
-0.0605091937,
0.0276595801,
-0.0192984715,
0.010302431,
-0.003850535,
0.0053004413,
0.0461834334,
-0.0474212728,
-0.0446555205,
0.0130122509,
0.0044487445,
-0.0485825054,
-0.052885443,
0.0873899236,
0.0677124783,
-0.0218449216,
-0.0140334154,
-0.0372661166,
-0.018147964,
0.0364191048,
0.0633483231,
-0.0787397027,
-0.0000491717,
-0.016636759,
0.0264305342,
-0.010754901,
-0.0316376537,
-0.0170434024,
-0.1067060083,
0.0575688891,
-0.0297322776,
-0.046430923,
-0.0081602875,
-0.0834746286,
-0.0132844606,
0.0010926398,
-0.0882887989,
-0.0272126123,
-0.0268208981,
0.004455932,
0.0016227693,
-0.0455081426,
-0.0209757034,
-0.024698386,
-0.1056644022,
0.0238906946,
0.007340536,
0.0883280784,
0.0203600917,
-0.0574782714,
-0.0443989076,
0.0594189093,
0.0240011197,
-0.0304171592,
0.0089093456,
-0.0213085078,
-0.0132088223,
-0.0370308384,
-0.0007331524,
-0.0118823489,
-0.0313880704,
-0.0061649224,
0.0714166537,
-0.0414993949,
0.0826000124,
-0.0404418446,
0.0415761136,
0.0362909362,
0.0036714242,
-0.0131391631,
0.0205740612,
-0.0325542577,
-0.0380434841,
0.0116891824,
-0.0400967114,
-0.0575476214,
0.0509461164,
-0.0102584595,
-0.0807099193,
-0.0276992954,
-0.0205409825,
0.03622007,
0.0442650318,
0.0035801094,
-0.0107607711,
0.0299621392,
-0.00166954,
-0.0513350777,
0.0360023305,
-0.0072524822,
0.016367659,
0.0148610258,
0.0222304948,
0.050527472,
-0.0201446731,
0.0047426028,
0.0300038606,
-0.0386509746,
-0.0316862054,
0.0426352397,
-0.0003652902,
0.0214148425,
0.0060657253,
-0.0506092198,
-0.0201517623,
-0.0066929231,
0.0796638131,
-0.0877950564,
-0.0617136285,
-0.021900015,
0.0153062316,
0.0163294282,
-0.0055839466,
-0.0345993601,
-0.0020968851,
-0.0633314922,
0.0081446869,
-0.0596383102,
-0.006979045,
0.0384793095,
-0.0213657599,
0.1368370652,
-0.0053527309,
0.0074888347,
-0.0266998541,
-0.0435174666,
-0.0413266048,
-0.0353842117,
-0.0073161284,
0.0175401345,
-0.0307641197,
0.0204471666,
0.0111872461,
0.040350277,
-0.0433635786,
0.0100779301,
0.0063120965,
-0.0012408685,
0.0273313485,
-0.027190201,
-0.0430394746,
0.0082097705,
-0.0199950393,
0.0151231186,
-0.0397711098,
0.0366569608,
-0.0247088689,
-0.0261484273,
0.0182457473,
-0.0052560698,
-0.011931519,
0.0320297293,
-0.048144456,
-0.0400815196,
-0.0106969997,
0.0223634895,
0.0635622218,
0.0001212162,
0.0043562669,
-0.0198525079,
0.0018698697,
0.0225293282,
0.0144501077,
0.0108558973,
-0.0689523444,
0.0217053518,
0.0087443264,
-0.0291622505,
-0.0081046019,
0.0210777428,
0.0000974365,
-0.0042261141,
0.0344194844,
-0.0916874334,
-0.0122589925,
0.0135062905,
-0.0114803836,
0.0314327516,
-0.0093542766,
-0.0117156021,
-0.022215398,
0.0035598197,
0.0312074125,
0.0154792415,
-0.0236019548,
-0.0000627478,
0.0233616922,
0.0411760621,
0.0368449651,
-0.0513753891,
-0.0380168892,
0.0023463089,
-0.0732684582,
-0.0365223736,
0.0146212205,
-6.242150509e-33,
-0.0310090762,
-0.1093458012,
0.046687033,
0.0081218118,
-0.0198623575,
-0.0351077616,
-0.0077028689,
0.0188615546,
-0.0209198091,
-0.008387872,
-0.0259147473,
0.0192226265,
0.0305358358,
0.0317915156,
-0.0008454123,
0.0141332941,
0.0363321453,
0.032986965,
-0.0319576114,
-0.0433540009,
0.0564270057,
-0.0029679178,
0.0490408167,
-0.0602807924,
-0.0123138269,
0.0009901304,
-0.0370351747,
0.0377452411,
0.0462207273,
0.0592188686,
0.0125464005,
0.059058629,
0.0020711403,
-0.0072163185,
-0.004921536,
0.0328005105,
-0.0397108905,
-0.0138160773,
0.0009307604,
0.0241812132,
0.0172997154,
-0.0332798697,
0.0253543798,
-0.0042632199,
0.0144325364,
0.0482509956,
0.0562003888,
-0.0147330286,
-0.040557947,
0.023968501,
-0.0394624732,
0.0146988705,
-0.00020431,
0.0125859641,
-0.044001136,
0.0247739609,
0.0050934204,
0.0010982613,
-0.0205479339,
0.0413313769,
0.034648478,
0.0304208584,
0.0342421159,
0.0137274461,
-0.0149631975,
0.0627509356,
-0.0299763232,
-0.0275152326,
-0.0310770031,
0.0013219859,
0.0427189991,
0.063403964,
0.0252469853,
0.0506822951,
-0.0169860274,
-0.0073729842,
-0.0149202598,
0.0502784476,
-0.0453159846,
0.0299703404,
-0.0220349934,
0.039788872,
-0.0116566289,
-0.0287494212,
0.003168843,
-0.0322925784,
-0.0435847417,
-0.0228001103,
0.0390661322,
0.0156051898,
-0.0259360261,
0.0658462122,
-0.0097796023,
-0.0126062175,
0.0108176023,
-0.019886706,
-0.0088220704,
0.0058242381,
-0.0505370945,
0.0193333905,
-0.0473866276,
0.0009535566,
-0.0051424592,
0.0312154256,
-0.0101434225,
0.0360441394,
-0.0472439602,
0.0194433779,
-0.0665553361,
0.0130468458,
0.0148874922,
-0.006853783,
-0.0556369424,
-0.054118067,
0.0126053439,
-0.0447633229,
-0.0047428333,
0.0267678834,
0.0221300311,
0.0366769321,
0.0047757118,
-0.1077172309,
-0.0005368266,
0.0191918332,
0.0251578614,
0.0351276956,
-0.0274163447,
-0.0084826676,
-0.0156158069,
-0.0304932185,
-0.0130569581,
0.0257843491,
2.641e-7,
0.0427705646,
0.0682707131,
0.0185610652,
0.0573929772,
-0.0418464579,
0.0120360637,
0.0612747036,
0.01540366,
-0.0376361534,
0.0226422288,
-0.0029317371,
0.0096588554,
0.014478121,
0.0726326853,
-0.1067199558,
0.0403511673,
-0.0171162467,
-0.0226771235,
-0.0952781439,
0.0163872521,
0.0846480429,
0.0487305149,
0.0184650365,
0.016970234,
-0.0374593697,
-0.0241281223,
-0.0072405119,
-0.0178011376,
-0.0401018038,
-0.0076912651,
0.038473323,
0.0037444653,
0.0025797787,
-0.0462775417,
-0.0181467943,
-0.0330604725,
0.0274784323,
0.0109020239,
-0.0059507145,
-0.0206141192,
-0.0135969426,
-0.0979990438,
-0.0010680645,
-0.0895373523,
0.0388165526,
-0.0435348228,
-0.0021111558,
-0.0001743419,
-0.0243420787,
-0.0166637134,
0.0021186089,
-0.0264300965,
-0.0436507612,
-0.0324148163,
0.0254287887,
-0.0060022878,
-0.0137483589,
-0.046241194,
-0.0225847177,
0.0095189596,
0.0051145623,
-0.0024626194,
-0.0397142842,
0.0246316753,
0.0366717055,
-0.0065982314,
-0.0021408261,
2.171419771e-34,
-0.0259528551,
0.0537781939,
-0.0549119338,
0.0236710347,
0.0544179119,
0.0237772502,
-0.0201305822,
0.0194823798,
-0.0011271063,
-0.044240348,
-0.0083079729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08089v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08089v2 | Improving In-context Learning of Multilingual Generative Language Models with Cross-lingual Alignment | 2023-11-14T11:24:08 | 2024-06-12T12:25:51 | Chong Li, Shaonan Wang, Jiajun Zhang, Chengqing Zong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual generative models obtain remarkable cross-lingual in-context
learning capabilities through pre-training on large-scale corpora. However,
they still exhibit a performance bias toward high-resource languages and learn
isolated distributions of multilingual sentence representations, which may
hinder knowledge transfer across languages. To bridge this gap, we propose a
simple yet effective cross-lingual alignment framework exploiting pairs of
translation sentences. It aligns the internal sentence representations across
different languages via multilingual contrastive learning and aligns outputs by
following cross-lingual instructions in the target language. Experimental
results show that even with less than 0.1 {\textperthousand} of pre-training
tokens, our alignment framework significantly boosts the cross-lingual
abilities of generative language models and mitigates the performance gap.
Further analyses reveal that it results in a better internal multilingual
representation distribution of multilingual models. | [
-0.0185989998,
0.0499219038,
-0.0062531927,
0.0480329804,
-0.0470821187,
0.0046793888,
0.0073453342,
-0.0598245896,
-0.0306751318,
0.0044351625,
-0.0632161722,
-0.0496038757,
-0.0064429012,
-0.023104107,
0.0583638139,
-0.0519916564,
0.0374417081,
-0.0173118562,
-0.0258773956,
-0.0205310117,
0.0168159883,
0.0427524336,
0.0056036888,
0.0144053791,
0.0072937342,
-0.0559803843,
0.0201654695,
0.0223002266,
0.0656166971,
-0.0024603312,
-0.0001973358,
0.018141903,
0.0056145014,
0.0473331474,
0.0000016339,
-0.0418705009,
-0.0302148238,
0.0177522004,
0.0390074067,
0.0087683825,
0.041905839,
-0.0619515441,
-0.0272247475,
0.003004496,
-0.0360329375,
-0.0197696611,
0.0696808994,
0.0269207116,
0.0196689516,
0.0675111935,
-0.0345420502,
-0.0500544943,
0.0173897482,
-0.0585351177,
-0.0162996184,
-0.0301706158,
-0.0061566331,
0.0082691824,
-0.0510925166,
0.0035267815,
-0.0190620255,
0.044724457,
0.0157150514,
0.0106364656,
-0.0280437078,
0.0169043019,
0.0041202586,
-0.0103337243,
-0.0170258079,
0.050594978,
-0.0654289126,
-0.0346549824,
-0.03256635,
-0.0120453853,
-0.0094373971,
-0.0287165083,
-0.0419144481,
0.0316959694,
0.0082192188,
0.0411712527,
0.0545519963,
0.0221291464,
0.0468594134,
-0.0357640684,
-0.0130809201,
-0.0136142727,
0.0736070201,
-0.0100416047,
-0.0164946206,
0.0373311229,
-0.0168576557,
-0.0325412378,
-0.0192983877,
-0.0072400789,
-0.01673037,
0.0314436667,
-0.0499095656,
-0.0495662987,
0.027025288,
-0.034465611,
0.0161079783,
0.071367681,
-0.0352892391,
0.0427544229,
-0.0461027585,
0.0553449877,
-0.0523867458,
-0.0003330641,
-0.0708417371,
-0.0693540424,
-0.0074332254,
-0.0171102528,
-0.0154551314,
-0.0332586579,
-0.0491647795,
-0.0314950272,
-0.0482155159,
0.0289211031,
0.0076563051,
0.0078261262,
0.022821648,
-0.0432974771,
-0.0611866266,
-0.0035374784,
-0.0040600947,
0.0545760281,
-0.0140183354,
-0.0000456707,
-0.001633546,
-0.050275512,
-0.028539978,
0.0139491959,
-0.0034397393,
-0.0527342819,
-0.0083348732,
0.0805520862,
-0.0494800024,
0.0008891551,
-0.0171749275,
0.0135344183,
-0.0256679989,
-0.0673955679,
0.0056314399,
-0.0658119991,
0.0737086087,
0.026419593,
-0.0002996648,
-0.0356040522,
0.0074728262,
0.0007715645,
0.0126207657,
0.0417504236,
0.0379329994,
-0.0212228708,
-0.0175896212,
-0.0421421565,
0.0247563124,
0.0868142545,
0.0014139264,
-0.021556722,
0.0208178777,
0.0104314499,
-0.0444835946,
0.0665787384,
0.0308551211,
0.0230870862,
-0.0375137888,
0.0047897133,
0.0866902322,
0.0284796413,
0.0732487291,
0.0321580395,
-0.0115227113,
0.0440979116,
0.0533800758,
0.0015077023,
0.0247981306,
0.0386427119,
0.0730132908,
-0.0285861529,
-0.0631729513,
0.0241959505,
0.0073268744,
0.0356641822,
0.014750069,
0.0450605899,
0.0457878597,
0.0909963027,
-0.0357949473,
-0.0112221381,
0.0124405297,
-0.0201669652,
-0.0000597914,
0.0002599865,
0.0669806376,
0.0323033221,
-0.0612935685,
0.0328948759,
0.0710099041,
-0.0503726304,
0.0134724006,
0.025558101,
-0.0036826341,
0.0579077154,
-0.0118460804,
0.0368342586,
-0.0303063188,
0.0136142084,
-0.0306322016,
0.0490958318,
0.0518949851,
0.0053550033,
0.0355483405,
-0.0462165326,
-0.0288307276,
-0.0675449818,
-0.0143334782,
0.0613679476,
-0.0133663751,
0.0406401753,
0.0084480308,
-0.0527032651,
-0.0054431506,
0.0158988778,
-0.0654494539,
0.0026354517,
-0.0121224411,
0.0322733931,
0.0065923696,
0.0113498541,
0.0080191521,
-0.0022499959,
0.0101908576,
-0.0539678298,
0.0224699937,
0.0616938844,
-0.0707251132,
-0.0827384517,
0.0263607595,
-0.0278585628,
-0.0189354271,
-0.0187334828,
-0.0275917277,
-0.039234329,
0.0192313101,
0.0289028808,
0.0502202101,
-0.042990569,
0.0076109124,
0.0243431963,
0.0545579344,
0.0011065452,
0.0566332974,
0.0213726182,
0.0335754082,
0.0033200067,
0.007380913,
0.035749048,
-0.0223959927,
0.0112262312,
0.0084888376,
0.0103731612,
0.0154850679,
0.0244163964,
-0.0045606671,
-0.0000391592,
-0.0012592659,
-0.0760249496,
0.0312767848,
-0.0079117855,
0.0283175819,
0.0530864634,
0.0315197073,
0.0026880908,
-0.0062817656,
-0.0567924529,
-0.0100986678,
0.025376711,
0.0043733865,
0.0303875152,
0.0130739706,
0.0074286186,
-0.0276850276,
0.0166083574,
0.0119529758,
0.046756018,
-0.0168258827,
0.0040385434,
-0.052611053,
0.0402836762,
-0.032541357,
0.0131544005,
-0.0197233278,
-0.0464540757,
-0.0075943456,
0.0120057352,
0.103631191,
0.0319119953,
-0.0276448503,
-0.0224501155,
0.0455969609,
0.0085707558,
-0.0408489294,
0.0191565938,
-0.0002527562,
-0.0232264828,
-0.0615838915,
-0.0170099009,
-0.0193110462,
0.0678353831,
0.0081191054,
-0.0145708472,
-0.0678255185,
-0.0193678271,
0.0175498091,
-0.0108749289,
-0.0018540962,
0.0315390266,
0.0019369785,
0.0356903411,
-0.0429196134,
-0.0358807296,
0.0523851775,
-0.038982749,
-0.0160982367,
-0.0514022671,
-0.0067778449,
-0.0263115894,
0.0438695326,
-0.003859825,
0.0486774705,
-0.0111636231,
-0.0118021537,
-0.0650361031,
0.0025739523,
0.0304937195,
0.0133741908,
0.0157554206,
-0.0258654226,
-0.005579147,
-0.0288029071,
-0.0496430807,
-0.0353891738,
-0.0069664158,
0.0097141238,
0.0270123817,
0.0432913713,
-0.0007064761,
-0.0278098844,
-0.0103158765,
0.0426123515,
0.0248972457,
-0.0099297008,
0.0161956195,
-0.0184866078,
0.036563471,
0.045329053,
-0.0292759482,
-0.0064655882,
-0.0523109175,
0.0100902235,
0.0073660333,
0.0022978361,
-0.0292003565,
-0.0189976972,
-0.0314761735,
0.0442868546,
0.0021242988,
-0.0436495058,
-0.0157268103,
0.0594323985,
-0.0043628472,
-0.0199194308,
0.0667749494,
-0.0139393285,
-0.0306623802,
-0.0035827616,
-0.0200797487,
0.0274704061,
0.0196705014,
0.0258518066,
-0.0756415427,
-0.0148442909,
-0.000777108,
-0.0385073908,
0.0338291414,
0.046783518,
-0.0306011774,
-0.1557329297,
0.0002935821,
0.0312020984,
-0.08353962,
-0.0342988335,
-0.0000026386,
-0.0164375044,
-0.0084969318,
0.0260736346,
-0.0308257248,
0.0089262044,
0.0077003338,
0.0101311458,
0.0516831204,
-0.057585571,
0.0001645726,
-0.0599763505,
0.0036875773,
0.071741119,
0.0434272625,
0.0205131397,
-0.0359640941,
0.0121188276,
-0.0317884982,
-0.0055250945,
0.0192762446,
0.0153064542,
-0.0001140609,
-0.0272199772,
0.0353369042,
0.0241625942,
-0.0201704782,
-0.0021299773,
0.0039257575,
0.064113006,
0.0523168445,
0.0151683344,
0.0157402903,
-0.0080929054,
0.0270665307,
0.0527009778,
-0.0038977726,
-0.0360674337,
-0.0099183535,
-0.0197886582,
0.0085546337,
-0.0673771501,
-0.0015722509,
-0.0017429445,
-0.0070296237,
-0.0298464056,
-0.0663842782,
-0.058445204,
-0.0112252571,
0.0445120893,
0.0122805331,
0.0211469382,
-0.0768614486,
-0.0103001473,
-0.001473025,
0.0061083655,
-0.0109611191,
0.0003583126,
-0.0260141119,
-0.016368445,
0.0220892541,
-0.0533373132,
-0.0184709337,
0.012574737,
-0.0470195785,
-0.0740765482,
-0.0446854085,
0.058080893,
0.0013377554,
0.0729611963,
-0.0142575074,
0.0211459883,
0.0373030379,
0.0282295309,
-0.0325670093,
-0.0073057842,
0.0390468799,
0.0338441953,
0.0078099617,
0.0477598608,
-0.0435619354,
0.0139333615,
0.0304653272,
0.0766959637,
-0.0019945716,
-0.0544357635,
0.0230648331,
-0.0127284443,
0.031230703,
-0.0591872782,
0.0022010049,
-0.0437863506,
0.0054008728,
-0.0494347438,
-0.0394388884,
-0.0275995526,
-0.011882063,
0.0581670813,
-0.0036368128,
0.0182056259,
0.0363645107,
0.02442405,
-0.0205904376,
-0.0251614116,
-0.024327755,
0.0238235239,
0.0258325916,
0.0052086064,
0.0383803584,
0.0092475079,
-0.0261144601,
-0.0033357572,
0.0173240732,
-0.0577038713,
0.0100617232,
0.0164821856,
0.0234929044,
0.0027250031,
0.0009299744,
0.0003640561,
0.0082829949,
-0.0242295191,
-0.0332279652,
0.0912241787,
-0.0177295022,
0.1003995985,
-0.0134840347,
-0.0303536262,
-0.0022634307,
0.0662337318,
-0.0148102921,
-0.0575624518,
0.0120550953,
-0.0157009792,
-0.0212893281,
-0.0148667507,
0.0822315142,
-0.0310020316,
0.0163118392,
-0.016630521,
0.0198099855,
-0.0312770978,
-0.0242840685,
0.0341810435,
-0.03357004,
-0.0141712977,
-0.0042182412,
-0.0049280184,
-0.0699653551,
0.0047378377,
0.0170431659,
-0.0304105207,
0.0187043156,
0.0380975865,
0.0829282328,
-0.0410979614,
-0.0117696393,
-0.0393467732,
-0.0034221744,
0.0180148464,
-0.0070466246,
-0.0280417893,
-5.573695361e-33,
-0.0281054955,
0.0463736057,
0.0201915205,
-0.053363882,
-0.002291223,
-0.021142805,
-0.0374671854,
-0.019447742,
-0.0130748423,
0.0114051094,
0.017336607,
-0.0230690856,
0.0120912436,
0.0463295132,
0.0241442565,
0.0257425625,
0.0525275208,
0.0077334745,
-0.0016091659,
0.0202202965,
0.0525101982,
0.0365562215,
0.1040928289,
-0.0214070957,
0.0179340784,
-0.021632148,
-0.0100704534,
0.0096340962,
0.0483080521,
0.0472462587,
-0.0061139734,
0.009649029,
-0.0108353365,
-0.0285274833,
-0.029794896,
-0.0064687347,
-0.0472787656,
-0.0125802029,
0.0503713489,
0.0154217584,
-0.0186645035,
-0.0757628679,
0.0116571141,
-0.0431379452,
0.0090878177,
-0.0315612778,
0.0423782729,
-0.0314792283,
0.0044819093,
-0.0436889343,
-0.1115038022,
-0.0064720386,
-0.0172209851,
0.0052436027,
0.0034805662,
0.0515675917,
0.0274262298,
0.0356469452,
-0.0481256768,
0.0155005539,
-0.045464702,
0.0381326266,
0.0919527113,
0.0223479569,
0.0259701014,
0.0234913025,
0.0072906697,
-0.0321881436,
0.046306029,
0.0062275045,
0.019696869,
0.0034308422,
-0.0029950191,
0.1059572399,
0.0194029547,
0.0165510662,
-0.1131018922,
0.0315828174,
-0.0173943192,
-0.0134200398,
0.0342223682,
0.0242783464,
0.0087628551,
-0.0069254288,
-0.026598677,
-0.068469353,
-0.0134820193,
-0.047287453,
0.008102322,
0.0086422293,
0.0195195768,
-0.0097268447,
0.0571895726,
-0.0196374543,
-0.041016601,
0.0353427865,
-0.0505021885,
-0.0049187862,
-0.0084648086,
0.048462525,
-0.0676194578,
-0.0421117954,
-0.0089295479,
0.0277823992,
0.0088842828,
0.0105755776,
0.0724949837,
-0.0051710401,
-0.0805202201,
0.0306628365,
-0.0735637397,
0.0034304366,
-0.0209546946,
0.0090957275,
0.0361923054,
0.00185345,
-0.0229276381,
0.0297178384,
0.0383928046,
-0.0198681895,
-0.0025657474,
-0.0228797905,
-0.0063891225,
0.0337406881,
-0.0343762562,
0.0198474675,
-0.0347566791,
0.009257352,
0.0444381237,
-0.0282794163,
-0.0212999322,
0.0292838402,
2.363e-7,
0.0540378019,
-0.0247222893,
0.0098747192,
0.014470635,
0.0018093225,
0.0101596015,
-0.0381313674,
0.0484867617,
-0.0058430834,
0.0047683287,
0.0101249451,
0.0284064803,
0.0527183004,
0.0207344815,
-0.0595189184,
0.0486276224,
-0.0344844349,
0.011793131,
-0.0311238468,
0.0292130597,
-0.0135055203,
0.106419012,
-0.0057787756,
0.02788179,
-0.0016276197,
-0.0358117297,
0.1045063958,
-0.0342311226,
-0.0374395512,
0.0122919828,
-0.0416621119,
0.014671796,
-0.0372966677,
-0.0230207965,
-0.0209642202,
0.0441071615,
0.0314613245,
0.0440151468,
0.0246621594,
-0.0428361483,
0.0025204758,
0.0127322478,
-0.037407618,
-0.0486249737,
0.0261004511,
-0.0304946154,
-0.0148730353,
-0.0161433332,
-0.0245096255,
0.0362997204,
0.0376658775,
-0.0094189104,
-0.0514704175,
0.0166267194,
0.0564188175,
0.0155337052,
-0.0464727879,
-0.0165385976,
-0.0441719033,
0.037809696,
-0.020216262,
-0.0360101126,
0.0020786615,
-0.0136629874,
0.0244775992,
-0.0225341916,
0.0243774094,
1.849465759e-34,
0.0165042095,
-0.0124613876,
0.0073649348,
-0.0131248552,
0.0030140865,
-0.0555996709,
-0.0373062305,
0.0098227672,
0.0158276651,
-0.032558579,
-0.0194198824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08057v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08057v1 | Data and models for stance and premise detection in COVID-19 tweets: insights from the Social Media Mining for Health (SMM4H) 2022 shared task | 2023-11-14T10:30:49 | 2023-11-14T10:30:49 | Vera Davydova, Huabin Yang, Elena Tutubalina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI, I.2.7; J.3 | The COVID-19 pandemic has sparked numerous discussions on social media
platforms, with users sharing their views on topics such as mask-wearing and
vaccination. To facilitate the evaluation of neural models for stance detection
and premise classification, we organized the Social Media Mining for Health
(SMM4H) 2022 Shared Task 2. This competition utilized manually annotated posts
on three COVID-19-related topics: school closures, stay-at-home orders, and
wearing masks. In this paper, we extend the previous work and present newly
collected data on vaccination from Twitter to assess the performance of models
on a different topic. To enhance the accuracy and effectiveness of our
evaluation, we employed various strategies to aggregate tweet texts with
claims, including models with feature-level (early) fusion and dual-view
architectures from SMM4H 2022 leaderboard. Our primary objective was to create
a valuable dataset and perform an extensive experimental evaluation to support
future research in argument mining in the health domain. | [
0.0002544599,
0.0624106787,
0.0345454589,
-0.0026386261,
-0.0085733384,
0.0067465003,
-0.0018082078,
-0.0518619642,
0.0248610731,
-0.0199876316,
0.0177203901,
-0.031536486,
-0.0120569803,
0.0405437611,
-0.0006110454,
-0.0371343195,
0.016589595,
0.0485207587,
0.0633369908,
0.0090974336,
0.0171561427,
0.0356547572,
-0.0536249205,
0.0529460795,
-0.0145291481,
-0.0215995573,
0.0417634025,
-0.0189700276,
0.0938435644,
-0.1022756547,
0.0630156398,
0.0056986888,
0.0136995967,
0.0380908735,
0.0000019501,
-0.012548958,
-0.0245337337,
-0.011159109,
-0.0060099615,
-0.017141873,
0.0419034064,
-0.0341521278,
0.0072896681,
0.0597062856,
-0.0581944771,
-0.0175300669,
0.0421899892,
0.0817048028,
0.0568997562,
0.073538214,
-0.0198342744,
-0.0329352655,
0.0195905548,
-0.0194609985,
-0.0591016486,
-0.0055663013,
0.0233043395,
-0.0311554596,
-0.0256385971,
0.0357721746,
0.0485169105,
0.0267306175,
-0.0003525483,
-0.0122417286,
-0.04419256,
0.0627955496,
-0.01974505,
-0.0282473266,
0.004128973,
0.0556889847,
0.0000665426,
-0.0417299196,
0.034485355,
-0.0248158146,
0.0171685647,
0.0144297238,
-0.0430196896,
-0.0103087109,
-0.0204593502,
0.0689571276,
0.0314640179,
0.0315325335,
0.0535763726,
0.0342928916,
0.0154850073,
-0.0003064311,
-0.0645931214,
-0.0259006061,
0.024779249,
0.0081836227,
-0.0263544638,
-0.0411021635,
0.0410771482,
0.0102231735,
-0.0016997103,
0.033146143,
0.0178911146,
-0.021333253,
0.0592418648,
-0.1208416,
-0.0310685858,
-0.0090836845,
-0.0001361045,
0.0442667566,
-0.0049379212,
-0.0624682494,
-0.0332842916,
-0.0161223486,
0.0442628562,
0.0075363019,
-0.0686922222,
0.0158865228,
-0.0072606979,
0.0124207959,
-0.0172061175,
0.0126437489,
-0.0315637477,
-0.0345088243,
-0.0292231776,
-0.0181087274,
-0.0179880522,
0.0218334347,
0.0228064992,
0.001501094,
-0.0133911651,
0.0573155396,
-0.0002486983,
0.0238914229,
0.013895398,
-0.0346262977,
-0.027209254,
-0.0107611716,
0.0197297875,
0.0141592398,
-0.0076936306,
-0.0404563695,
0.0066382964,
0.0032325848,
0.0167067703,
-0.0379436314,
-0.0390189476,
-0.0419853851,
-0.0004108535,
-0.0898800418,
0.0408408009,
-0.0236351676,
0.0136201726,
-0.0488716513,
0.0051776702,
0.0393284932,
-0.0341270491,
0.0266013276,
-0.0105904425,
-0.0330720171,
0.0436778143,
0.0505295731,
0.0053884625,
0.0581354909,
0.005172085,
0.0526586957,
-0.0112018408,
0.0199788176,
-0.0187741667,
-0.0333985426,
0.0703117996,
0.0207559559,
0.0833756402,
-0.0015616027,
-0.027173765,
0.0057409839,
-0.0739692301,
0.0354589783,
-0.0062216814,
-0.0328091793,
0.0364535153,
0.0345607586,
-0.0254107341,
-0.030128181,
0.0066826702,
0.0381987132,
0.027402956,
-0.0431663804,
0.0072609945,
0.0026222139,
-0.0169155803,
-0.0357296951,
0.0022805624,
0.0532874875,
-0.0128460601,
-0.0648025647,
-0.0246315245,
-0.0072664707,
-0.007688913,
-0.0290635191,
0.0010697594,
-0.0308580566,
-0.0398533866,
0.0214466657,
0.044811286,
-0.0505888127,
-0.0333920158,
-0.0584661663,
0.0008433282,
-0.0287527293,
-0.010198758,
0.0045673298,
-0.0661006272,
-0.0221498869,
0.0404836982,
0.0350461118,
0.0670094416,
-0.0237480458,
0.0016735045,
-0.0118734222,
-0.01249268,
-0.0347431451,
0.0235976726,
-0.0019205114,
-0.0173680317,
0.0064134779,
0.0028603901,
0.0614382848,
-0.0236942414,
0.00908978,
-0.000680133,
0.0310933087,
0.0142414747,
0.0325631835,
0.0515954942,
0.0465154648,
0.0298491325,
0.0244418662,
0.0568218082,
-0.0436214469,
-0.031122487,
0.0388260558,
-0.0102902213,
-0.03725731,
0.0225997288,
-0.0500336513,
-0.0373331271,
0.0169944316,
-0.0661192462,
0.0212699194,
0.0202019438,
-0.0094872545,
-0.0347164348,
-0.0164512638,
-0.037796583,
-0.0049850824,
0.0201441757,
0.0046608644,
0.0764490739,
-0.0336545557,
-0.0322127678,
-0.0014430261,
-0.0530788824,
0.0136464247,
-0.0354908891,
0.0277407877,
-0.0097952066,
-0.0004008897,
0.0006734484,
0.0089939246,
-0.0589409694,
-0.0318255089,
0.00472089,
-0.1273137331,
0.0050175949,
-0.0176356118,
0.0207838658,
0.018888833,
-0.0258751959,
0.0054382915,
-0.0215762388,
-0.0284162574,
-0.0288924165,
0.0204313025,
0.0193046797,
0.0272701494,
-0.0116847688,
0.0416227877,
-0.0265913941,
-0.0087264106,
-0.0716969743,
0.0000105715,
0.0300637502,
-0.0355662443,
0.0093674986,
-0.0474683866,
-0.0505312271,
-0.0038023435,
-0.0073125684,
-0.0048949816,
0.0420718938,
-0.0051201587,
-0.0085805645,
0.0284652058,
0.0161459018,
0.0401541516,
0.0442635715,
0.0483089946,
-0.026216289,
0.0178388469,
-0.0312903225,
0.0548043177,
-0.002671283,
-0.0260794889,
0.0359588116,
0.1062625498,
0.0058717034,
-0.0005210996,
-0.0545553006,
0.0500733517,
-0.0178875234,
-0.0187831633,
-0.0018773734,
0.014948993,
0.0073374468,
0.0094653089,
-0.0374348126,
-0.0230161473,
0.0458909236,
0.0038622573,
0.0429237485,
-0.0792106465,
-0.0518241934,
-0.0296191033,
-0.0164416507,
0.0242875423,
-0.0088058021,
0.0401594788,
0.0407507718,
0.0551773869,
-0.0448759049,
-0.0090032155,
-0.0368055813,
-0.0116917593,
-0.0201445464,
0.0287330523,
-0.0027551842,
-0.0578655154,
-0.0282933749,
-0.076973021,
-0.0690742806,
-0.0221295524,
-0.0332500599,
0.0118062822,
-0.0213067029,
-0.0166258663,
-0.0180281699,
0.0515902229,
0.0261442568,
-0.0171838924,
0.0292914901,
-0.0105077643,
0.0168625861,
-0.0128970901,
0.02712797,
-0.0113182003,
0.0232780091,
0.1006600633,
-0.0007808796,
0.0294492226,
-0.0511198863,
-0.0358480923,
-0.0246616937,
0.0008359699,
-0.0105701424,
-0.0170210693,
0.0475639142,
-0.0566282757,
0.0391767919,
0.0785913467,
0.0238134265,
0.0137748448,
0.0127301048,
0.0129928719,
-0.0190727506,
-0.030240424,
-0.0024784068,
-0.0367118046,
-0.0032121961,
-0.0336247794,
-0.0062172855,
-0.0393567756,
-0.0178372972,
0.0039914395,
-0.0274900682,
0.0479046404,
-0.01213264,
0.0072177756,
0.0049655973,
-0.0852768421,
0.036799632,
-0.0414046608,
-0.0133652966,
-0.0437320359,
0.0166333448,
0.009036039,
0.0253259372,
-0.0479717515,
-0.0093461666,
0.0084474431,
-0.0151996547,
0.005330414,
-0.0086287931,
0.0871525183,
0.0187588111,
-0.0665639415,
0.0207696669,
0.0074024084,
-0.0239097849,
-0.0286838096,
0.074906148,
-0.0056720637,
-0.0115708457,
-0.0265498124,
0.0348595865,
-0.0352117494,
-0.0590758733,
-0.0093877735,
0.0725777894,
-0.0235241763,
-0.0378156006,
-0.0388348959,
0.0795399547,
-0.0082160542,
0.0236849487,
0.0186144002,
0.0297100786,
-0.0069756154,
-0.0096492991,
0.0211207084,
-0.0887337327,
-0.0169879589,
-0.0091949776,
0.0085951472,
-0.0172159746,
-0.0435655415,
-0.0247407779,
-0.0118739028,
0.0123280669,
-0.0624727085,
-0.0500309579,
0.0556109957,
0.0205276422,
-0.0474344715,
0.040484786,
0.0230318569,
0.0301375594,
-0.0219251867,
-0.0045429007,
0.0453797467,
0.0289388262,
-0.0281441491,
0.0241696406,
-0.0333412066,
-0.0573352128,
-0.0324516445,
0.0152925439,
0.0078683402,
0.0352678187,
-0.0058382964,
0.0207539853,
0.0665253326,
0.0546515733,
0.0238320213,
-0.0506948195,
0.050887689,
-0.0073048952,
0.005998686,
-0.0026628459,
0.0455460772,
0.0224540476,
0.0127187818,
0.0141320033,
-0.0502378978,
0.0599890724,
-0.0066909096,
-0.0340819694,
0.0803009346,
0.0244820919,
-0.0763125122,
-0.0390921496,
-0.0044419579,
0.0035312036,
-0.0011798816,
-0.0054888823,
0.017919872,
0.0082640052,
-0.0253455229,
-0.0406459682,
0.0326621681,
-0.0224057063,
0.0596706942,
-0.0442362353,
0.0203513261,
0.0049222521,
0.0483008362,
-0.0228330679,
-0.0433404855,
-0.0222630426,
0.0051788781,
0.0095293233,
0.0063910414,
-0.0010092718,
0.0174901523,
0.0095038125,
0.0094701564,
0.0371562578,
0.0299033727,
-0.0427341126,
-0.0357508771,
-0.0694302246,
-0.0193749461,
0.0059805592,
-0.0154685536,
0.0477749594,
-0.0000142894,
-0.0271253381,
-0.0161674935,
0.0310555305,
-0.0384217463,
0.0012554257,
0.0322901346,
-0.0029102867,
-0.0248902645,
-0.0322391987,
0.0328849815,
-0.0215920676,
0.0633647889,
0.0622095391,
-0.0338286981,
-0.0222339649,
-0.0366532058,
-0.0163323786,
0.029882364,
-0.0283452496,
0.0345614403,
-0.0437544473,
-0.019713711,
0.0515624732,
-0.0146743804,
0.0003793598,
0.0376650095,
-0.024377713,
0.0433007628,
0.019511342,
0.0199901666,
-0.0355924517,
0.0204852838,
0.0094494298,
-0.0190479513,
-0.000993569,
-6.797963177e-33,
0.0249308534,
-0.0210224576,
-0.0140543934,
0.0005479023,
0.0197633952,
0.0392859541,
-0.0219526272,
-0.00777832,
-0.0241048522,
0.0768521503,
0.0274319109,
0.0339564681,
0.0038304368,
0.0196103305,
-0.0161578525,
-0.0021040014,
0.0398961455,
0.0102024404,
-0.0313997492,
0.0387883373,
0.0484026521,
-0.0038926841,
0.0519574545,
-0.0798001513,
0.0456087887,
0.0127489325,
0.0245524291,
0.019265715,
-0.0346131995,
0.0644481033,
0.0007503378,
0.033418905,
0.0766902715,
-0.0371729769,
0.0236841906,
0.0557793826,
-0.0559896939,
-0.0520550013,
0.0042448165,
-0.0595610999,
-0.0564302243,
-0.0477980301,
0.0203596335,
0.0468982272,
-0.0017338076,
-0.0238305163,
0.0042323242,
-0.0147333862,
0.0500828288,
-0.0199874267,
-0.0441970006,
0.0473901108,
-0.0231882371,
-0.0180461146,
-0.027872581,
0.0354119465,
0.0045987908,
0.0860100985,
-0.0424959697,
0.0143913142,
-0.0388232879,
0.00089612,
0.0005912909,
-0.0447514504,
-0.0310390741,
0.0598187111,
-0.023600664,
-0.0035223365,
-0.0884714648,
0.0252913125,
-0.0296348538,
0.0591857992,
0.0625836849,
0.0326219276,
0.0386728793,
0.0138643011,
-0.1044544205,
0.0169768296,
0.0282743275,
0.0410732217,
0.0034315002,
-0.0047252085,
-0.003165839,
0.0041528856,
-0.0138454409,
-0.0397911519,
-0.0095546367,
0.0085313674,
-0.0460197516,
0.0284849778,
-0.024863096,
0.071822077,
-0.0120622097,
0.0066912468,
-0.004236077,
0.0111429282,
0.0535578132,
-0.0364407301,
0.0195492618,
0.0387004763,
-0.0596434809,
0.0397629179,
0.0028489989,
0.0294757038,
0.0305727012,
-0.0143549116,
0.0519983731,
-0.0362144485,
-0.0346832573,
-0.0168157369,
-0.026173899,
0.0248720795,
-0.0498116724,
0.0727279484,
0.0253500286,
0.0379132852,
0.013810846,
0.0413156413,
-0.0192338172,
0.0122118453,
-0.0242113248,
0.0017312116,
-0.0476746485,
0.0033786499,
0.0045075929,
-0.0148561187,
-0.0017674224,
0.00127453,
0.0004025255,
-0.1240037084,
-0.0054869791,
-0.0216644108,
2.73e-7,
0.0733957589,
0.0459150039,
-0.0067067677,
-0.0460454971,
0.0311220996,
0.0409194343,
-0.0179493651,
0.0162830539,
0.0217699017,
-0.0342547037,
-0.0383271575,
0.0567718036,
0.0137703847,
0.0570108704,
-0.0643954277,
-0.026079867,
-0.057285998,
-0.0121459924,
-0.0288922433,
0.0075014546,
0.0237599723,
0.0541655868,
-0.0040526311,
-0.0177029707,
0.004907378,
0.0509132445,
0.0543776788,
0.0024730184,
-0.0395186096,
0.0038356534,
0.0357520469,
-0.0558091253,
0.0008776709,
0.0068899635,
-0.0455419309,
0.0119658224,
0.0012335827,
0.0658550262,
0.0155404611,
0.0059770616,
0.0009394642,
-0.0291775949,
0.0115071712,
-0.0083293663,
0.0586548522,
-0.1093998626,
-0.0672892779,
-0.0423860699,
-0.0500231311,
0.0406328626,
0.0534820072,
0.0185503643,
-0.0342713483,
0.0251449291,
-0.0116884178,
0.0080400445,
0.010649655,
-0.0809420347,
-0.0207950994,
-0.0210508388,
-0.0338115133,
-0.0404189751,
0.0337366872,
-0.0356719233,
0.0238608681,
-0.0439527854,
0.0393263437,
1.974887907e-34,
0.0405095071,
-0.0019525496,
-0.0157216862,
-0.0293311495,
0.0161590204,
0.0085393982,
-0.0204804614,
-0.002193423,
0.0269742832,
-0.0259138253,
0.0260522645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08045v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08045v4 | Adversarial Preference Optimization: Enhancing Your Alignment via RM-LLM Game | 2023-11-14T10:10:31 | 2024-06-03T11:34:05 | Pengyu Cheng, Yifan Yang, Jian Li, Yong Dai, Tianhao Hu, Peixin Cao, Nan Du, Xiaolong Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Human preference alignment is essential to improve the interaction quality of
large language models (LLMs). Existing alignment methods depend on manually
annotated preference data to guide the LLM optimization directions. However,
continuously updating LLMs for alignment raises a distribution gap between
model-generated samples and human-annotated responses, hindering training
effectiveness. To mitigate this issue, previous methods require additional
preference annotation on newly generated samples to adapt to the shifted
distribution, which consumes a large amount of annotation resources. Targeting
more efficient human preference optimization, we propose an Adversarial
Preference Optimization (APO) framework, in which the LLM and the reward model
update alternatively via a min-max game. Through adversarial training, the
reward model can adapt to the shifted generation distribution of the LLM
without any additional annotation. With comprehensive experiments, we find the
proposed adversarial training framework further enhances existing alignment
baselines in terms of LLM helpfulness and harmlessness. The code is at
https://github.com/Linear95/APO. | [
0.0293195322,
0.0818980262,
-0.0141137224,
0.0548256487,
-0.0224811099,
-0.0019689712,
-0.0455906428,
-0.0258139614,
-0.0171154086,
0.0090435548,
-0.0772802457,
-0.03712124,
0.0137366997,
-0.0260123666,
0.035913948,
-0.0444695465,
0.048592031,
-0.0092480788,
-0.005842506,
-0.0158841889,
0.0197988376,
-0.0004074851,
-0.0007227936,
0.0219372977,
0.050446637,
-0.0081618298,
-0.0158842728,
0.0247770362,
0.0515609458,
-0.0367530845,
0.028239917,
0.0578833409,
-0.0182427093,
0.0711447597,
0.0000019626,
-0.0496855974,
-0.0118236868,
-0.0100442609,
-0.0165906455,
0.0147915184,
0.0303358845,
0.0135117099,
-0.0144291045,
0.0181561839,
-0.0415425785,
0.00218132,
0.0595772453,
0.0284895822,
0.0553199612,
0.0835809335,
0.008824409,
-0.0188378524,
0.0241166782,
-0.0724019036,
0.012134715,
-0.0420366339,
0.0169099681,
-0.0261156466,
-0.0107143475,
0.0029410059,
-0.0167158134,
0.0175674688,
0.0025976244,
0.008131858,
0.0158990435,
0.038345091,
-0.0124036837,
-0.0026709707,
-0.013145796,
0.091575183,
-0.033171244,
-0.0172788203,
-0.0058109066,
-0.0233186688,
0.0168084279,
-0.0120435823,
-0.0210901182,
-0.0228611436,
0.0019525803,
0.0392384566,
0.0025967681,
-0.0176951308,
0.0485061519,
0.0292254649,
0.0060492079,
0.0766642019,
0.0225746427,
-0.0192072894,
0.015552504,
-0.0003939115,
-0.0540703088,
-0.0660373941,
-0.0011073959,
-0.0163023639,
-0.0504771657,
0.02092194,
-0.0571472868,
-0.0155674648,
0.0244868323,
-0.0341493636,
0.0645661131,
0.0330280811,
-0.0010265824,
0.0349381529,
0.0262697246,
0.0489158034,
-0.045612555,
0.0277985521,
-0.0445157327,
0.0288505722,
0.0136491582,
-0.0054520802,
0.032827545,
0.0119951321,
-0.0287192371,
0.0043749032,
-0.0493655242,
0.0267995447,
-0.012683928,
0.055574134,
0.003901771,
0.0322205722,
-0.0516657867,
-0.0134948082,
-0.0476581044,
0.0304502342,
-0.0425237417,
0.0083929915,
0.0248957165,
-0.0189196263,
-0.0175396763,
0.0303842276,
-0.0335961394,
-0.0711033493,
-0.0192713831,
0.0914769098,
-0.0074382485,
0.0116501497,
-0.0020588092,
0.0075350045,
-0.0295349583,
-0.0714869201,
-0.0034209786,
-0.0650663674,
0.0370315462,
-0.0115305232,
-0.0288861934,
-0.0602836348,
-0.0030415868,
-0.0004761154,
-0.0341889225,
0.0849839821,
0.0063360813,
-0.0188324712,
0.0100046629,
-0.0085814158,
-0.011362155,
0.0744480789,
0.0576502122,
0.0606387369,
0.0155645721,
-0.0063361661,
-0.0339613371,
0.0728273615,
0.0409336835,
0.0142136738,
-0.0251515657,
0.0065154941,
0.0031217898,
0.0813379213,
0.0550956279,
0.0315132663,
-0.0288404785,
-0.0724412799,
0.0903982073,
-0.0017972327,
-0.0083144903,
0.0017340033,
-0.0322278552,
0.0284405109,
-0.0238146205,
0.035374321,
-0.0606903285,
0.0548795462,
-0.0466755331,
0.0010342717,
0.0310221892,
0.0337400772,
-0.0143362954,
-0.034722887,
-0.0030953349,
-0.0286943521,
0.0152481459,
0.0229934491,
0.0247869082,
-0.0097396066,
-0.0373792015,
-0.00457867,
0.0347737446,
-0.0251023974,
0.0166241042,
-0.0153653147,
0.0470134877,
0.0566124506,
0.0594527423,
-0.0268985871,
-0.0187890269,
-0.0152694453,
-0.0495135486,
0.070474118,
0.056064181,
-0.0278633367,
0.0276101772,
-0.0526225902,
-0.0347235873,
-0.0088647688,
-0.0131097529,
0.0481659994,
0.0329103209,
-0.0391307622,
-0.0118385321,
-0.0148348203,
-0.0263036173,
0.0333468206,
-0.02737955,
-0.0240206327,
0.0015491924,
0.020846501,
0.0603453815,
-0.0021368158,
0.0101314913,
0.0008697537,
0.0299902912,
-0.0163736064,
0.0262012538,
-0.0035076009,
-0.0337676704,
-0.0482976995,
0.0592902936,
0.0047300574,
-0.0498992801,
0.0680962503,
-0.0583801344,
-0.0120915007,
0.0004375004,
-0.002334184,
0.0555655062,
-0.007494167,
0.0161855388,
0.0059689465,
0.0037571345,
-0.0796070695,
0.045759894,
-0.025285447,
0.0021355166,
0.013752887,
-0.0126899509,
-0.0049265702,
-0.0556082539,
-0.0097502125,
0.0216178019,
-0.0009522542,
0.0110998424,
0.0397419333,
-0.0131476671,
-0.0487954617,
-0.0378758982,
-0.0422946773,
0.0323060937,
-0.0065438263,
0.0237537194,
0.0344695263,
-0.0010535906,
-0.0031018439,
-0.0020665608,
-0.0493356362,
-0.0204793364,
-0.0303089898,
0.0117579158,
0.0422805436,
0.0154536469,
-0.003523997,
-0.0808156952,
0.0078699896,
0.0086157108,
0.00248337,
-0.0157969035,
0.0134529453,
-0.0466184132,
0.0216364469,
-0.0312760882,
0.0263172872,
-0.0312087145,
-0.0545600913,
0.0132541275,
0.0334542431,
0.034195032,
0.106782794,
0.0212256331,
0.0250937957,
0.0544384494,
0.0305972602,
-0.0819529518,
-0.0097503401,
-0.0188366305,
-0.0153062707,
-0.0637056008,
-0.0320012867,
-0.0026805319,
0.0782813877,
0.005765825,
0.0090793567,
-0.041233521,
0.0172595717,
0.0250509866,
-0.0385733098,
-0.0049991859,
0.0111217955,
-0.0617979541,
0.0232621022,
-0.0592641681,
-0.0550309084,
0.0970710739,
-0.0390662737,
-0.0053635617,
-0.0435385816,
0.0132219316,
-0.0093573248,
0.0085081048,
0.0267317891,
0.0194411296,
-0.0132003855,
0.0034441757,
-0.1029216945,
-0.051418148,
0.041749686,
-0.0249912851,
0.0415531881,
-0.0199676622,
0.0036698619,
-0.0224154517,
-0.0508482344,
-0.0581845716,
-0.0492369868,
-0.0047741719,
-0.0088078408,
0.0163896363,
-0.0256547444,
-0.0269872434,
-0.0180876516,
0.0039123949,
0.0183762293,
-0.0303270295,
0.013937789,
-0.0165985953,
0.0379474089,
0.1144235283,
0.0186945517,
0.0007317311,
-0.0388076082,
-0.018488463,
0.0503468104,
0.0172297452,
0.025523359,
-0.0224820655,
-0.0228690207,
0.0482711233,
-0.0323914103,
0.0041107587,
-0.0007440849,
0.0347481593,
0.0038022399,
0.0263740085,
0.0842549205,
0.0185632911,
-0.0481051132,
0.0230961628,
0.0050066863,
0.10316699,
0.0075455625,
0.0279851966,
-0.0686909631,
-0.0160333924,
0.0078377826,
0.0670085847,
0.0142409373,
-0.0107261473,
-0.0144257499,
-0.1331707239,
-0.030348856,
0.029755963,
-0.0446628071,
0.0180114266,
-0.0106819654,
0.0170609988,
-0.0560493097,
0.0524825901,
0.0151722953,
0.0353641659,
-0.0022788858,
0.0098145809,
0.0168428645,
-0.0325519666,
0.0023184272,
-0.0471788123,
0.0772291273,
0.1212572753,
0.0567418523,
0.0016330238,
-0.0177296121,
0.0306467097,
0.0347067565,
-0.033534281,
0.0004869317,
0.0432224683,
-0.0316938907,
0.0063913288,
-0.004782232,
0.0447587743,
0.0119567038,
-0.0136878164,
0.0013259929,
0.0260732211,
0.0244985148,
0.0120441858,
0.0016986507,
0.0025978673,
0.0204502158,
0.0644699782,
0.0036421863,
-0.0697366074,
0.0013531778,
-0.0397107974,
-0.001157237,
-0.0798419937,
-0.0167126525,
0.002144018,
-0.0026736499,
-0.0037343549,
-0.0807479098,
-0.0403222516,
-0.0184038263,
0.0007702782,
0.0110817021,
0.0114285685,
-0.0423360057,
-0.0141180726,
-0.0138167366,
0.0346811637,
-0.0351163,
0.018632587,
-0.0414584801,
-0.0379473604,
-0.0059011029,
-0.0490339287,
-0.0069368202,
-0.0084892716,
-0.0593812913,
-0.0995186716,
-0.0103677446,
0.0646380708,
0.0198525339,
0.0911905393,
-0.0033323858,
-0.0578361489,
0.0068035494,
0.0567072257,
0.0041469787,
0.0074489764,
0.0274422895,
0.0020402037,
-0.0060269819,
0.0373882242,
-0.0407429226,
-0.0228457768,
0.0546998344,
0.0312403124,
-0.0199930388,
-0.0323844925,
0.0274583958,
-0.0081713675,
0.0485547706,
-0.0501775891,
-0.0056511755,
-0.0246645156,
0.0055226847,
-0.0129185831,
-0.0190167502,
-0.0224716552,
-0.0441895127,
0.0411929972,
-0.0124785993,
0.0162514057,
-0.0228305571,
-0.0012334812,
0.0252847709,
-0.0207693558,
0.0056188693,
0.0233217422,
0.0158460829,
0.0419527218,
0.0420370586,
-0.0077615068,
0.0230394229,
-0.0006188895,
0.0678507611,
0.0081701018,
0.0290573239,
0.0396648981,
-0.0044805547,
0.0187344812,
0.0255212858,
-0.0132945022,
-0.0149011919,
-0.0534582771,
-0.0016519006,
0.0520020835,
-0.0215526596,
0.0612959974,
-0.0077375006,
0.0001517594,
-0.0336765461,
0.0197660439,
-0.0553430058,
-0.0306073613,
0.0277414117,
0.0161081888,
-0.0238950551,
0.018651098,
0.0803335682,
0.0216736998,
0.0253749602,
-0.04237286,
0.0171464868,
-0.044331193,
-0.0268150326,
0.024112178,
0.0141822379,
-0.0583855063,
-0.0134506263,
-0.0236924868,
-0.0609191954,
-0.0429825783,
0.0371795185,
-0.0124217365,
0.0049901167,
0.0357528552,
0.0292076729,
-0.0479939282,
0.0127168102,
-0.0405893847,
0.0046813847,
-0.0164850689,
-0.0495725311,
-0.0216494706,
-6.553896754e-33,
-0.0441740081,
-0.0270930845,
0.0042183236,
-0.0315208361,
-0.0352389552,
-0.0444816276,
-0.0222881455,
0.0213769972,
-0.0260295961,
-0.0362669379,
-0.0058205435,
-0.0282962825,
0.0063820868,
0.0181486327,
-0.0085062133,
-0.0248613767,
0.0339099951,
-0.000466392,
-0.0649078414,
-0.0081440816,
0.0042357361,
0.0049100709,
0.0491900556,
-0.0510604903,
0.0375668332,
0.0077972226,
-0.0204273816,
0.0201273486,
-0.0205342509,
0.0690391436,
0.0144778574,
0.0066992445,
-0.0009894549,
-0.0026371677,
-0.0046877866,
-0.0125409719,
-0.046049539,
-0.0118379742,
0.0528430454,
0.0326663442,
-0.0212876163,
-0.0452410765,
0.047085166,
-0.0188668407,
-0.0172863975,
-0.0004707761,
0.0276219323,
-0.0356137529,
-0.0567287877,
0.0561801381,
-0.0574947894,
0.016729692,
-0.0099413339,
-0.0178437512,
0.0075933617,
0.0261907242,
0.0344722159,
0.0478456095,
-0.0709006265,
0.0329285562,
-0.005972717,
0.048047062,
0.0877644345,
0.0503974184,
0.0302417763,
0.0627445579,
0.0183095615,
-0.0190409124,
0.0247312635,
-0.020792257,
0.0247446634,
0.019496873,
0.0242151953,
0.0715088546,
0.0291404426,
-0.0291858036,
-0.0361475013,
0.0434534065,
0.0486553013,
0.0081473645,
0.0146946814,
0.0632337332,
-0.0280230604,
-0.0165692214,
-0.0293364245,
-0.0620612614,
-0.0274698995,
-0.0582060516,
0.0079310862,
0.015387441,
-0.0296159238,
-0.024065759,
0.014255615,
-0.0445435494,
-0.0273114238,
0.0092380829,
-0.0253022928,
0.0052457945,
0.0039787507,
-0.0015841546,
-0.0745444372,
-0.0040585618,
-0.0100169554,
-0.0335911438,
0.01112362,
0.0451136976,
0.0531227142,
0.0109678227,
-0.0363753922,
0.0158007313,
-0.0382717922,
0.0055586379,
0.0041091805,
-0.0018818269,
0.0372019894,
-0.0261730254,
-0.0064764982,
0.0454087295,
0.0317031518,
0.0114987064,
-0.0499846637,
-0.0045487504,
-0.0107592698,
0.0098624956,
-0.0248702597,
0.0087244399,
0.0128590316,
0.0090843225,
0.0099904854,
-0.0431838259,
-0.0226943437,
-0.0433462523,
2.574e-7,
0.0234351903,
0.0455383211,
0.0300653167,
0.0038410188,
0.0096608549,
0.0602425672,
-0.0316778086,
0.0236711539,
0.0130895767,
-0.0116057619,
0.0115593867,
-0.0015245504,
0.0641761869,
0.0247477498,
-0.0851385221,
0.0216022413,
-0.0841523409,
0.0302522276,
-0.0158794988,
-0.0177342072,
-0.0037285923,
0.1060336754,
0.040827062,
0.0098560145,
0.0081954235,
0.0079313731,
0.0655399561,
-0.0647604018,
-0.0095462855,
0.0205907896,
-0.003282489,
-0.0273268558,
-0.0203181095,
-0.0466391519,
-0.0087734666,
0.0126026357,
-0.0102135343,
0.0672520846,
-0.0069017801,
-0.0810286403,
-0.0178378969,
-0.0039854343,
0.0044691651,
-0.0595650263,
0.046763774,
-0.0442392007,
-0.0494049639,
-0.0310375132,
-0.0162881948,
-0.0038200771,
0.0199735016,
-0.0328426436,
-0.0144529259,
-0.0106972205,
0.0259971432,
0.0065683662,
-0.0301334374,
-0.0305480305,
-0.0521452986,
0.0017081238,
-0.0502698161,
-0.0529991202,
-0.0243021101,
0.0252734423,
-0.0211886372,
-0.0323336907,
-0.0118470322,
2.175205231e-34,
0.0153911365,
-0.0196248647,
0.0290659573,
0.0015389493,
0.0231963862,
0.0051257019,
0.015342094,
0.0363564976,
0.0491305627,
-0.0405772366,
-0.0234044194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08011v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08011v2 | Forgetting before Learning: Utilizing Parametric Arithmetic for Knowledge Updating in Large Language Models | 2023-11-14T09:12:40 | 2024-02-16T15:49:42 | Shiwen Ni, Dingwei Chen, Chengming Li, Xiping Hu, Ruifeng Xu, Min Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased their
remarkable capabilities in text understanding and generation. However, even
stronger LLMs are susceptible to acquiring erroneous or obsolete information
from the training corpus. Direct secondary fine-tuning with data containing new
knowledge may be ineffective in updating knowledge due to the conflict between
old and new knowledge. In this paper, we propose a new paradigm for fine-tuning
called F-Learning (Forgetting before Learning), which employs parametric
arithmetic to facilitate the forgetting of old knowledge and learning of new
knowledge. Experimental results on two publicly available datasets demonstrate
that our proposed F-Learning can obviously improve the knowledge updating
performance of both full fine-tuning and LoRA fine-tuning, simultaneously
outperforming the existing baselines in most cases. Moreover, we have also
discovered that forgetting old knowledge by subtracting the parameters of LoRA
can yield a similar effect to subtracting the parameters of full fine-tuning,
and occasionally even surpass it significantly. | [
0.015400731,
0.0774835423,
-0.0163749978,
0.0133350007,
-0.0150615079,
0.0198616274,
-0.028464919,
0.0068991282,
-0.0718709007,
-0.0665724725,
-0.0482337363,
-0.0374138542,
0.0396491401,
0.0030090883,
0.047518719,
-0.0201600194,
0.0345373787,
-0.0362883396,
-0.0013753052,
-0.0027835539,
0.0185218751,
0.0108487019,
-0.0025799775,
-0.0169658624,
0.0269893501,
-0.0182267912,
-0.0088887028,
-0.0186675079,
0.0189148895,
0.0022551815,
0.029239133,
0.038547758,
0.0226877965,
0.0533801951,
0.0000018914,
-0.0509009734,
-0.054147847,
-0.0147857983,
-0.0220623594,
0.0584594086,
0.0382107571,
0.0076107779,
0.0067785946,
0.0303369872,
-0.0681892559,
-0.0038104861,
0.0151567413,
0.0115931472,
0.0602156408,
0.0873026699,
0.0115240896,
-0.0235500764,
0.0280960333,
-0.0565162003,
-0.0122745074,
-0.0374646075,
0.0522555076,
0.0008309265,
-0.0513064079,
-0.0271771457,
-0.0139843859,
0.0066316533,
-0.0066203368,
0.0132427532,
-0.0036402,
0.0242165215,
-0.0166923106,
-0.0106967259,
-0.0039044928,
0.0591632687,
-0.041120965,
-0.0099680498,
0.0280666314,
0.0037353416,
-0.0295913015,
-0.0090073142,
-0.0626054034,
0.0019236007,
0.0003476334,
0.0140702724,
0.007651492,
-0.0772889778,
0.0295328498,
0.0357933119,
-0.0218791887,
-0.0012231431,
0.0365190692,
-0.0211160369,
-0.0258937702,
-0.0511849336,
-0.0779771358,
-0.0261061862,
-0.019887846,
0.0727825761,
-0.0211737361,
0.0236145146,
-0.054755237,
-0.026960725,
0.0518410951,
-0.0480232649,
0.0491640829,
0.0223301332,
-0.0014391356,
0.0260153748,
-0.0443326756,
0.03872649,
0.0272531267,
-0.0106388936,
-0.024361236,
0.0609178357,
-0.0371469222,
-0.0243828222,
-0.0507078804,
0.0420822501,
-0.0017941869,
0.0312206894,
-0.0328639708,
0.0163877644,
0.0119836228,
0.0329193659,
0.0048585143,
-0.0372035578,
-0.0377599634,
-0.0013448192,
-0.000403271,
0.0449999608,
-0.0372518897,
0.04276447,
0.0139323603,
-0.0464658551,
-0.0230582263,
-0.0259172916,
0.0357400961,
0.0064331638,
0.0372069106,
0.0267091468,
-0.006362271,
-0.0444144718,
-0.0969901159,
-0.0493129045,
-0.0122889262,
-0.1004923061,
-0.0156422015,
-0.0508227572,
0.0102697536,
0.0009518252,
0.001273726,
-0.0141181424,
-0.0104488106,
0.0276994798,
-0.0388288498,
0.029292997,
-0.0129367886,
0.001818002,
0.0366393477,
0.0023487562,
0.0180406664,
0.0903758109,
0.0245646313,
-0.0023707214,
0.0035295938,
0.0000798623,
-0.0394681543,
0.0237097573,
0.0349980332,
0.0493994094,
-0.04507339,
-0.0243842937,
0.0164635032,
0.0095175682,
0.0128239086,
0.0110200718,
-0.0469336621,
0.0039706347,
0.059963312,
-0.0503189676,
0.0304006096,
0.0588238835,
0.0311912782,
-0.039052967,
0.0265094228,
0.0372166075,
-0.0303066634,
0.0086547267,
-0.0775554404,
0.0299411453,
0.0006278486,
0.0340990499,
-0.0535285696,
-0.0515548475,
0.0129824523,
-0.0128958225,
-0.0140654612,
-0.0212543327,
0.0684842914,
0.0490432382,
-0.0299536567,
0.0611676574,
0.0500938743,
-0.033989653,
0.0359134302,
-0.0329210497,
0.0343216695,
0.0390006304,
0.0679918081,
-0.0632038489,
-0.0498197377,
0.001268665,
0.025017811,
-0.0303066261,
0.0495651476,
0.0024664465,
-0.0132067474,
-0.0859436169,
0.012723933,
-0.0158853326,
0.0261252876,
0.0047246851,
0.0166612733,
0.0203476697,
0.0419052653,
-0.0469083674,
-0.0355948582,
0.0213213079,
-0.0541250668,
-0.0096787224,
-0.0128844902,
0.0142966248,
-0.0276608113,
-0.004737807,
0.0056053698,
0.0050391178,
0.042054601,
0.0025846362,
0.0101083014,
-0.0175709296,
-0.0393731408,
-0.0295607932,
0.0477097854,
0.0448648222,
0.0194492396,
0.0094976509,
-0.0656333715,
-0.0305896197,
0.0370490588,
-0.0111597441,
0.0507121682,
-0.0535976477,
0.0723391101,
0.0009994758,
0.0038461389,
-0.0371719711,
0.0701924637,
-0.0130833434,
0.0189342722,
-0.0296512321,
0.0030672585,
0.0073784352,
-0.0298640318,
-0.0241470598,
0.0147528341,
-0.0123408753,
0.0320100375,
0.0113657834,
0.0081298845,
-0.0578768402,
-0.0503244586,
-0.0414260589,
0.0088961516,
-0.0362500958,
0.0351591334,
0.0338806435,
0.0038342564,
-0.0035861721,
-0.0189452432,
-0.0335070863,
0.0411731787,
-0.0060146851,
0.0257831402,
0.0407012515,
0.0253477227,
-0.0130282128,
-0.0261900034,
0.0048086909,
0.011781374,
0.0368148312,
0.01782679,
0.0337207466,
-0.0841552466,
0.0632660761,
-0.0708430335,
0.0208711121,
-0.0135330316,
-0.0478103161,
-0.0299895778,
-0.0352877676,
0.0441555418,
0.0290750749,
-0.0102318237,
0.0222633053,
0.0631124228,
0.0208722148,
-0.0100881103,
0.0022779219,
-0.0332872644,
-0.0617737137,
-0.0147194741,
0.01624218,
-0.0235831924,
0.0329975523,
-0.0206181873,
-0.0067138285,
-0.0348783955,
0.0513151363,
-0.0380673259,
-0.0053308397,
-0.0313760191,
0.0176928826,
-0.0148140406,
-0.0213899352,
-0.0348563157,
-0.0456392467,
0.0471811928,
-0.0302167125,
0.0119775087,
-0.0402218029,
0.022060547,
-0.0516722649,
0.0171829313,
0.0027801727,
0.0371759161,
0.0139544718,
-0.0200642031,
-0.0616430379,
-0.0028201353,
0.0343336724,
-0.0420748889,
0.0640111566,
-0.0726975277,
0.0256339218,
-0.0032938176,
-0.0329375118,
-0.0193279851,
-0.0428133272,
0.0056207497,
0.0136612402,
-0.0303666461,
-0.0301785767,
0.0145331696,
-0.005020916,
0.0168733746,
0.0279485658,
-0.0317400247,
-0.0130512202,
-0.0371885151,
0.0311783683,
0.0625036657,
0.0266093295,
0.0109260809,
-0.0424608886,
0.0216544587,
0.0280541852,
0.0564639121,
0.0196009483,
-0.0243603513,
0.0229588225,
-0.0021431928,
-0.0304940697,
-0.0291225333,
0.0098807653,
0.0016435095,
-0.0513768382,
-0.021176504,
0.0986279249,
0.0131712668,
-0.0376016051,
0.0082465671,
0.0050063315,
0.0379773974,
0.0186420027,
0.0060991771,
-0.0746320561,
-0.0092709782,
0.0077700093,
0.0421660021,
-0.0134752886,
-0.0404119827,
-0.0102584884,
-0.102234982,
0.0046104528,
0.0513958968,
-0.0489462875,
-0.0344578251,
-0.0257102996,
0.0006649495,
0.0166603699,
0.0226559453,
0.0453550853,
-0.0474098437,
0.0067036226,
0.0456996448,
0.0217538271,
-0.0708474219,
-0.0062246509,
-0.0106398221,
0.0196899734,
0.0267114509,
0.0415927209,
0.0060206135,
-0.0145233972,
0.0262561459,
-0.0245301649,
0.0046193353,
-0.0195807628,
0.0375694185,
0.0393955484,
-0.0217948724,
0.0382375903,
0.0322800055,
-0.017002672,
-0.0199276544,
-0.00581261,
0.034673281,
0.008085005,
0.0164931361,
0.0536335483,
-0.0088263508,
-0.0087865153,
0.0459498316,
0.0412303507,
0.0045355749,
0.0088389479,
-0.0100368513,
0.0127371727,
-0.004565177,
0.036966797,
0.0372650251,
-0.0492109135,
0.0171990786,
-0.0865677223,
-0.0094272429,
0.0419866033,
0.0543527938,
0.0078255814,
0.0372392908,
0.0261397567,
-0.0052410113,
-0.0525857359,
-0.0252309237,
-0.0545344576,
-0.0178900734,
-0.0362119973,
-0.0238949992,
0.0545967072,
-0.0398970209,
0.0024550962,
0.0060297251,
-0.1015331745,
-0.0703442767,
0.011256475,
0.0512825698,
0.0299890265,
0.0512095131,
-0.0099414308,
-0.0549000353,
0.0493575446,
0.0419345871,
-0.0402090959,
0.079083316,
0.0011108079,
-0.0130143939,
-0.0343857408,
0.048030559,
-0.0437997989,
-0.024545338,
0.0402449891,
0.0405474864,
-0.0304493122,
0.013920947,
0.0406689383,
0.0600276291,
0.0115367211,
-0.0109269405,
0.0046820943,
-0.0143011371,
0.0434866548,
0.0038697857,
0.0077538174,
-0.0114381369,
-0.0146066593,
0.0033050359,
0.013466293,
-0.0403874293,
-0.0117673324,
0.0269553941,
0.0436714962,
-0.0068566976,
-0.028169604,
0.0005745617,
0.0513052382,
0.0680516586,
-0.0020723252,
-0.018237235,
0.0247142725,
0.0128199803,
0.0280249044,
-0.0414077304,
0.0506025329,
0.0133138895,
-0.002770734,
-0.1029941216,
0.0317866169,
-0.0184500571,
-0.0974017009,
-0.0371133909,
0.0220080577,
0.0558083765,
-0.0077452338,
0.0601899661,
-0.0365292653,
-0.0220416635,
-0.0181733947,
0.0044490304,
0.0067944652,
-0.0049460446,
0.0000068909,
0.0045936792,
-0.0064950944,
0.0259673782,
0.0841112509,
0.0076199952,
0.1055416986,
-0.0285401773,
0.025359638,
-0.0307287872,
-0.0249671973,
-0.006147143,
-0.0080127669,
0.0034847411,
-0.0093217911,
-0.0386347584,
-0.0587016642,
-0.0054954709,
-0.0266371313,
0.0189373344,
-0.0197687186,
0.0427315757,
0.0628816709,
-0.0475185588,
0.0226466618,
-0.0569135509,
0.0083813267,
0.0063322657,
-0.0114310393,
0.0072302492,
-6.392164894e-33,
-0.0179457851,
0.0137967039,
0.0453603566,
0.012588853,
-0.0321218744,
-0.0093114395,
-0.0105178831,
-0.0197055731,
0.0136289839,
-0.0235402565,
-0.0033631332,
-0.0031295456,
-0.0036293354,
0.0117290057,
-0.0318185538,
-0.027731467,
0.0674586594,
-0.0140347239,
-0.0349537544,
0.0398976542,
0.0650226995,
0.0534196384,
0.0759163499,
0.0117634879,
-0.0121108284,
0.0210133176,
-0.0591655895,
0.043644648,
-0.0596238263,
0.0467765667,
-0.0040999455,
0.0451442152,
0.0179360285,
0.0063151689,
-0.0295638945,
-0.0277536772,
-0.1008365899,
-0.0243302509,
0.0166670382,
0.0153037729,
-0.0071340827,
-0.0230176579,
0.0604039282,
-0.0046877949,
-0.0087575503,
0.0129079036,
-0.0030414471,
-0.0544531271,
-0.057374604,
0.002615788,
-0.0361744128,
0.015517666,
0.0069677075,
-0.0308154356,
-0.0059979833,
-0.0156414714,
-0.0101587577,
-0.0141592082,
-0.0485545211,
0.0077047655,
0.0820586756,
0.0844028518,
0.004845527,
0.0311481841,
-0.0185990874,
0.0392749086,
-0.0107125547,
0.0169586241,
0.0420682169,
0.0063706008,
0.0494139381,
0.0241257008,
-0.0150784021,
0.0297305975,
0.015277178,
-0.0551381893,
-0.0899264216,
0.0038560762,
-0.0133938761,
0.071290575,
0.0079365829,
-0.0049306471,
-0.0044660615,
-0.0145139946,
-0.0868303254,
-0.0060722949,
-0.0542477407,
0.0199351665,
-0.0046401098,
0.0619486608,
-0.0236299522,
-0.0446259715,
-0.0157525931,
-0.0072203302,
-0.0111396117,
0.0333037116,
-0.0431949273,
0.0283604786,
-0.0186484139,
0.023586832,
-0.0468177572,
-0.054246597,
-0.0014354896,
0.0033929208,
-0.0112037044,
-0.0155414762,
0.0512634963,
0.051673267,
-0.0584872104,
0.0202874895,
-0.0314234383,
0.0467614084,
0.0432592295,
-0.0279201493,
0.01881372,
-0.0017637153,
0.0075090956,
0.0603585951,
0.0471872874,
-0.0169484559,
-0.0255096052,
-0.0004085003,
0.042288322,
0.0533409901,
-0.017684862,
-0.0117949722,
0.0105470214,
-0.016559165,
0.0432464816,
-0.0604462512,
0.0157694221,
-0.0149318464,
2.724e-7,
0.0125451861,
0.0411287621,
0.0166641697,
-0.0151633667,
0.0133014824,
0.0236717202,
-0.0524936132,
0.0187134817,
0.0150049226,
0.0462542176,
0.0362798274,
-0.0033388683,
0.0337780677,
-0.0058122189,
-0.0819184855,
0.0175962094,
-0.0715927258,
0.0138006061,
-0.0492559746,
-0.032127168,
0.0030343812,
0.0796554238,
0.0357703976,
-0.0107968245,
0.0112886922,
-0.0616175048,
0.0939699039,
0.0142717781,
-0.0420365706,
0.0312089995,
0.0439135395,
0.0316643342,
-0.0207697283,
0.0175961982,
-0.0227662418,
0.0040921955,
-0.0152027365,
0.0614550337,
0.023720732,
0.0081353243,
0.0156085687,
0.0153776305,
0.005280335,
-0.0450394638,
0.0539417453,
-0.0553849079,
-0.0143661788,
-0.0071382648,
-0.0109340595,
-0.0186124817,
0.0073947832,
-0.0408054143,
-0.0361512341,
0.0365891233,
-0.0107750921,
0.0392838679,
-0.0329647511,
-0.0676480159,
-0.0026111698,
0.0437896512,
-0.0224609729,
-0.0706065297,
-0.0361214951,
-0.0196836386,
0.02239234,
-0.0811228454,
0.0414346978,
2.403471081e-34,
0.0313948058,
-0.0323521458,
0.0007385137,
-0.0036221971,
0.0403837785,
-0.0053901225,
0.0018076645,
0.0486778021,
0.0125299422,
-0.0864373818,
0.0082386788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08010v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08010v1 | Distantly-Supervised Named Entity Recognition with Uncertainty-aware Teacher Learning and Student-student Collaborative Learning | 2023-11-14T09:09:58 | 2023-11-14T09:09:58 | Helan Hu, Shuzheng Si, Haozhe Zhao, Shuang Zeng, Kaikai An, Zefan Cai, Baobao Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Distantly-Supervised Named Entity Recognition (DS-NER) effectively alleviates
the burden of annotation, but meanwhile suffers from the label noise. Recent
works attempt to adopt the teacher-student framework to gradually refine the
training labels and improve the overall robustness. However, we argue that
these teacher-student methods achieve limited performance because poor network
calibration produces incorrectly pseudo-labeled samples, leading to error
propagation. Therefore, we attempt to mitigate this issue by proposing: (1)
Uncertainty-aware Teacher Learning that leverages the prediction uncertainty to
guide the selection of pseudo-labels, avoiding the number of incorrect
pseudo-labels in the self-training stage. (2) Student-student Collaborative
Learning that allows the transfer of reliable labels between two student
networks instead of completely relying on all pseudo-labels from its teacher.
Meanwhile, this approach allows a full exploration of mislabeled samples rather
than simply filtering unreliable pseudo-labeled samples. Extensive experimental
results on five DS-NER datasets demonstrate that our method is superior to
state-of-the-art teacher-student methods. | [
0.0577921942,
0.0600597672,
0.0136938635,
0.0086703813,
0.0461660437,
0.0577379651,
0.0407487564,
-0.0351937301,
0.0367554128,
-0.0234374553,
-0.0374872908,
-0.028034294,
-0.0273869131,
-0.0207916293,
0.0371845663,
-0.0468181483,
0.0030084271,
-0.0004842866,
0.0262532867,
0.0334613323,
-0.0115246,
-0.0291825309,
-0.0204180665,
-0.0090764798,
-0.0398854427,
0.0174832083,
-0.0139880525,
0.0241857041,
0.0551560037,
-0.0516690984,
0.0496655889,
0.0321721137,
-0.0243066754,
0.0471076369,
0.0000018408,
-0.0187352225,
-0.0528662801,
0.0146512268,
-0.0469762981,
-0.0096434597,
0.0101189725,
0.0214367993,
-0.0098520834,
-0.0050628707,
-0.0152808065,
-0.0729466751,
0.0723677352,
0.0680305287,
0.033644408,
0.0617651679,
0.0059033809,
-0.0081128608,
0.0063862503,
-0.0239855349,
0.0080557372,
-0.0643598288,
0.0469003581,
-0.0236007012,
-0.0219594892,
0.0270551573,
-0.0062324083,
0.0225934107,
0.0075886068,
-0.0163418707,
0.0311333425,
0.0360380635,
0.0082651507,
-0.0139580723,
-0.0083120363,
0.0904270038,
-0.0041412287,
0.010187787,
0.0523786098,
-0.0323432609,
-0.0135310926,
0.0044771112,
0.0017399046,
-0.0090826005,
-0.0319265611,
0.0103933392,
-0.0208579917,
0.0409395956,
0.0228528641,
0.0099541387,
0.0157269202,
0.0087070074,
-0.0362164937,
-0.0454569235,
0.0219381265,
0.0580166578,
-0.0205831416,
-0.0189301111,
0.058410354,
0.0123234373,
0.0082646683,
0.0287372656,
-0.0405174829,
-0.0386926122,
-0.0196565967,
-0.0149100972,
0.0002535565,
-0.0097934948,
-0.0223831292,
0.0390511937,
-0.0274537522,
-0.0240721386,
0.0275314022,
0.0480074622,
0.0061573624,
0.0059884372,
-0.075898014,
0.0434385985,
-0.0446989499,
0.0503851958,
0.016981259,
0.013028848,
-0.0533036068,
-0.0140047912,
-0.0210120641,
0.0545495488,
0.019225033,
0.0103860367,
-0.0204049479,
-0.0054393914,
-0.0076966621,
0.0442790128,
0.0154951243,
0.0039752894,
-0.0058062715,
-0.0355974026,
-0.0069814273,
-0.0342342891,
0.0095369527,
-0.0259596594,
0.0127528347,
0.0517150909,
0.0181352068,
-0.0813494772,
-0.075050585,
0.0082664704,
-0.0171186905,
-0.0267486311,
-0.0016778238,
0.0107736206,
0.0010484401,
-0.0217690747,
0.0005375295,
-0.0801839232,
0.0367658548,
-0.0464391634,
-0.047109697,
0.0740829036,
-0.1034520641,
-0.0449662767,
0.0344757661,
0.02800682,
-0.0099773444,
0.0374972485,
0.0678171441,
-0.0019155648,
0.0233259834,
0.0160756707,
-0.0041325768,
-0.0191735364,
0.0618584417,
-0.0179509539,
-0.0010682247,
-0.0148149747,
0.0463301688,
0.0056796116,
-0.0202316437,
0.0323358066,
0.0098170741,
0.0136661557,
0.0443250686,
-0.0312218424,
-0.0166207645,
-0.0156850796,
-0.0147428438,
0.0003041203,
0.01538633,
-0.0176330358,
-0.0497009382,
0.0097942855,
-0.0237218067,
-0.0110818222,
0.0306361411,
0.0128519041,
-0.0109683359,
-0.056911774,
-0.0115272477,
-0.0189064704,
-0.0189571828,
0.0230365079,
0.0670485795,
-0.0098846462,
-0.0291919969,
0.0186755322,
0.0423381031,
-0.0074576093,
0.0415831469,
-0.0019420646,
0.0330123417,
0.0492700525,
-0.0027344595,
-0.0562657453,
-0.0579792932,
-0.0460372306,
0.0004552603,
0.0197493583,
0.0380367227,
-0.032491181,
0.0262387116,
-0.0382245779,
-0.0540978387,
0.050062079,
0.025872197,
0.0224121585,
0.0212853663,
0.029683806,
0.0371420234,
-0.0487391502,
-0.0726846978,
0.0389685147,
-0.0133473342,
-0.0457421802,
-0.0040714522,
0.0439401269,
0.0119293937,
0.039471224,
-0.0186734498,
-0.0334650837,
0.0163842812,
0.0062669883,
-0.0163541734,
-0.0719395354,
-0.0107619204,
-0.0396595895,
0.0326497927,
-0.0026837506,
-0.0239305422,
-0.0300909746,
-0.0609003305,
-0.0639679283,
-0.0181769803,
-0.0114656612,
-0.0197333228,
-0.0109907454,
0.008508333,
0.0313147306,
-0.0074120644,
-0.0285250023,
0.0418732092,
0.020770954,
0.0341361985,
-0.0276928693,
0.0215701219,
-0.0027309223,
-0.0306799728,
-0.0497055277,
-0.0107555026,
0.0016441213,
-0.0412874557,
0.0007537949,
-0.0078864442,
-0.0858430937,
-0.013942888,
-0.0135775786,
-0.028228052,
-0.0168753471,
0.0336485989,
-0.0126590421,
-0.004518684,
-0.0258411523,
-0.0426251478,
-0.0085102981,
-0.0141523639,
-0.0576058999,
-0.0097952597,
0.0168072693,
0.0277662147,
0.0007103081,
-0.0066529205,
0.0041530775,
-0.0255806725,
0.0035320902,
0.0430437997,
-0.0723742023,
-0.0930273309,
0.0507227629,
-0.0457173511,
0.0269900449,
0.0386941023,
0.0295657273,
-0.0375971645,
0.0355917923,
-0.0414421372,
0.0306600798,
-0.0482709259,
-0.0026367733,
0.0249315221,
-0.0161431152,
-0.0317269936,
0.0379993916,
-0.0260101669,
0.0220887475,
-0.0012979875,
-0.015915744,
-0.0456693657,
0.0550999977,
-0.0322805904,
-0.0092533259,
-0.0438776538,
0.031396471,
-0.0294434633,
-0.0017844258,
-0.0095220637,
0.0216590036,
0.0287919529,
-0.0142794969,
0.0018026482,
-0.0009935354,
0.1078725979,
-0.0071738437,
-0.0037483447,
-0.0134554897,
-0.0400930084,
0.0329257511,
0.0010645112,
0.00667276,
-0.0076634334,
0.0781752095,
-0.0478371121,
-0.0017581211,
-0.002146004,
0.0445460714,
-0.0393435508,
-0.0191733781,
-0.0092118513,
0.0438916795,
-0.0220689364,
-0.0278147608,
-0.0454326235,
-0.0225708224,
-0.0456196517,
-0.0077147065,
-0.0228766147,
-0.0271848477,
0.0088549294,
0.0366134122,
-0.018629387,
0.0534432195,
-0.0004628437,
-0.0115109226,
-0.0055181794,
0.0342518128,
-0.0147001753,
-0.0310356952,
0.0318069197,
-0.0136724394,
-0.0230589025,
0.0174307805,
0.0526519082,
-0.020459177,
0.0095554329,
0.0041030855,
0.0097538773,
-0.0215374231,
0.0113614034,
0.0115322899,
0.0453534611,
-0.0243233498,
-0.0333235674,
0.078712821,
0.0109703746,
-0.0165839307,
-0.0230405517,
0.0405146517,
-0.0029968666,
0.0186662786,
0.0281342026,
-0.0308172181,
-0.0255659968,
0.0120900339,
0.0471287668,
0.0124269305,
-0.0853092745,
-0.0012833461,
-0.0828081071,
-0.0033622612,
0.0100390734,
-0.054122217,
0.021843072,
-0.0634173527,
0.0173812155,
-0.0352699347,
0.0172267016,
-0.0344289541,
0.0102168079,
0.0063176714,
0.0805274621,
0.0036220213,
-0.0743489936,
-0.0429934599,
-0.0306376386,
0.0812004283,
0.016872352,
-0.0337450616,
-0.0113270292,
-0.0413476788,
-0.0064720055,
-0.0492603406,
-0.0172441155,
-0.0088864826,
0.0853900537,
-0.0411224216,
-0.0421992056,
0.0167548563,
0.0034061053,
-0.0287203304,
-0.0163800884,
0.003847247,
0.0640795976,
-0.0085405968,
0.0260458011,
0.0173396692,
-0.015501976,
0.0853782967,
0.0324716195,
0.0055270432,
-0.0225905348,
-0.014741865,
0.0255621448,
0.0160420947,
-0.0051509626,
0.0224711336,
0.0403844491,
-0.0724033415,
-0.0346157514,
-0.0175971668,
-0.076785937,
0.05979665,
0.0491444804,
0.0271287486,
-0.0196774583,
0.0509028733,
0.0160065871,
-0.0443503149,
0.018505821,
-0.0200790521,
0.0172928851,
-0.0269224141,
-0.0044932277,
0.042271629,
0.0362906717,
-0.0297347624,
0.0098017622,
-0.1050373986,
-0.0654094219,
0.0268778391,
0.0194831807,
0.0065268795,
0.0321840458,
-0.005323871,
-0.0567724593,
0.0550431944,
0.0994731784,
-0.0111595094,
-0.036669258,
0.0367256589,
-0.0056680152,
-0.0019721903,
0.0201574191,
-0.0455352105,
0.0119985975,
0.0702477396,
0.0430056117,
-0.0601937398,
-0.0282007121,
-0.012824337,
0.0026967169,
0.1126902401,
-0.0092936829,
-0.008853822,
-0.0611381121,
0.0380034894,
0.035014376,
-0.0065457663,
-0.02451922,
-0.0032057988,
0.0316334963,
0.0182869229,
-0.0229362119,
0.0472311564,
0.0227400009,
0.0402846187,
-0.0240736194,
-0.0174632408,
-0.0051841293,
0.0155547485,
0.0141392173,
-0.0113609852,
-0.0124227703,
0.037196219,
0.1041627601,
0.0478428341,
0.005344958,
0.0127417361,
0.0392894931,
0.0181870852,
0.0099312132,
-0.0225102678,
-0.0732608438,
0.0043558427,
-0.0720710233,
0.0548907071,
0.0396691784,
0.0105508016,
0.0048872917,
-0.0353125781,
-0.0028633636,
0.0057403916,
-0.0165586341,
-0.018055629,
-0.0119614191,
0.043507427,
0.004089829,
0.0054784301,
0.0318581648,
0.0494829379,
0.0250094384,
0.0356398225,
-0.0089146644,
-0.0026759752,
-0.028463494,
0.0101972194,
0.019118486,
-0.0099335946,
-0.0242549535,
0.0023993962,
0.0117348665,
-0.0776583999,
0.0539577305,
-0.0171044525,
-0.0164227113,
0.0090912869,
0.0094923722,
-0.0276342314,
-0.0158953425,
0.0121319927,
-0.0112860687,
-0.0005156681,
0.0724155381,
-0.0238599405,
-0.0061305058,
-6.252200251e-33,
-0.0536980666,
-0.0531588644,
-0.0203424543,
-0.0111609856,
-0.0058401008,
0.0262439139,
0.0035279407,
0.0027683433,
0.0158081241,
0.0072357841,
-0.0046061515,
0.0204577483,
0.0480965599,
0.0224398095,
0.0109768258,
-0.0734030083,
0.0660188198,
0.0049935775,
0.0078132385,
-0.0005449465,
0.0270766225,
0.0839672759,
0.1079767346,
-0.1597684622,
0.0669670999,
0.0214371383,
-0.0035156731,
0.0128908539,
0.0579756275,
0.0236281585,
-0.0068936651,
0.0031683524,
-0.029748179,
-0.0153570734,
0.0068295347,
-0.0480177216,
-0.136734277,
-0.0177202579,
-0.0722505897,
0.0565254427,
-0.007682262,
-0.0097113363,
0.029108908,
-0.007471662,
0.011316454,
0.0027289588,
0.0368410945,
-0.0235192329,
-0.0067256875,
-0.0422815271,
0.0163867828,
0.0368097015,
-0.0049502468,
0.0244947337,
0.0244089998,
-0.0142817171,
0.0423745438,
-0.0302080214,
-0.1160888523,
-0.0064049801,
0.0334511846,
-0.0074587758,
0.0166613795,
0.0379980318,
-0.024328053,
0.0453876294,
0.0563727319,
0.0059595229,
0.0018162472,
-0.0520797968,
-0.0019184541,
0.0000159796,
0.0218216833,
0.0362365842,
0.0400937237,
-0.0058821402,
-0.0750126541,
0.0113820974,
-0.0295220409,
-0.0404604338,
-0.0413644537,
-0.0057492377,
-0.0676500276,
-0.0161375701,
0.0044701248,
-0.0795681998,
-0.0316092446,
0.0054518408,
-0.0063474607,
0.0272984151,
-0.0556569099,
0.0622588731,
-0.0110923108,
-0.0371702053,
-0.0695787892,
-0.0430611894,
0.0623005442,
0.0031645717,
-0.0138552627,
-0.0221828334,
-0.0617581122,
-0.0589875542,
0.0147928139,
-0.0032202017,
0.0030308417,
-0.0071271472,
0.0863886252,
-0.0020335042,
-0.0636970773,
-0.0013672721,
0.0188385732,
0.0179297291,
0.0157967526,
-0.0257128887,
0.0352698155,
-0.0269566327,
-0.0204887595,
0.052264329,
0.0801708028,
0.0258395374,
0.0354732424,
0.035875421,
0.0149655603,
0.0005093114,
-0.0151429679,
-0.0307212714,
0.0246638954,
-0.0209599901,
0.0075031631,
-0.0728484467,
0.0243315808,
-0.014916881,
2.655e-7,
-0.0025358584,
0.019747084,
0.0239053834,
-0.042550128,
-0.0066901799,
0.0310707726,
0.0015067152,
0.0296552163,
-0.0028335901,
-0.026627861,
0.0365169421,
-0.0186354816,
0.0268695857,
0.0501572005,
-0.0540106557,
-0.0444127209,
-0.0003854345,
0.0038786468,
-0.0216602497,
0.0341667756,
0.0558812134,
0.0437342301,
0.0693636388,
-0.0165188443,
-0.0214446411,
-0.0308042001,
0.0419622734,
0.0138435801,
0.0339220352,
0.0193806216,
0.0522094928,
0.0047150627,
-0.0289028585,
0.06545531,
-0.0009699803,
0.0024725432,
0.0152976532,
0.0258912202,
0.0162214544,
0.0117574343,
-0.0288912803,
0.0094488887,
0.0504865758,
0.0069150389,
0.0427729972,
-0.0903057158,
-0.0097890021,
0.0706820264,
-0.0052486546,
-0.0396129005,
0.0415172428,
0.0220069531,
0.0193315744,
0.0114504313,
0.0003396851,
0.0128692314,
-0.0213746373,
-0.0464352071,
0.0262741502,
-0.0114015881,
0.0225554444,
-0.0402533896,
0.0224728603,
-0.0053550131,
0.036593087,
-0.0281876661,
0.0076489025,
1.868413373e-34,
0.0009417532,
-0.0008697945,
-0.0086539024,
-0.0157020949,
-0.0333717391,
-0.0025036237,
-0.0371524468,
-0.0233646538,
0.0020554725,
-0.0156048974,
0.0063873315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08002v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08002v1 | TempTabQA: Temporal Question Answering for Semi-Structured Tables | 2023-11-14T08:57:01 | 2023-11-14T08:57:01 | Vivek Gupta, Pranshu Kandoi, Mahek Bhavesh Vora, Shuo Zhang, Yujie He, Ridho Reinanda, Vivek Srikumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Semi-structured data, such as Infobox tables, often include temporal
information about entities, either implicitly or explicitly. Can current NLP
systems reason about such information in semi-structured tables? To tackle this
question, we introduce the task of temporal question answering on
semi-structured tables. We present a dataset, TempTabQA, which comprises 11,454
question-answer pairs extracted from 1,208 Wikipedia Infobox tables spanning
more than 90 distinct domains. Using this dataset, we evaluate several
state-of-the-art models for temporal reasoning. We observe that even the
top-performing LLMs lag behind human performance by more than 13.5 F1 points.
Given these results, our dataset has the potential to serve as a challenging
benchmark to improve the temporal reasoning capabilities of NLP models. | [
0.0326919034,
0.0603204407,
-0.0160576291,
0.0168509353,
-0.0419954248,
0.0194344576,
0.0087410202,
0.034429878,
0.0176603831,
-0.0367361456,
0.0041760164,
-0.0186375882,
-0.0305747241,
0.020609485,
0.0021785982,
-0.0208456777,
0.0602025539,
-0.0067032166,
-0.0483893156,
0.0147470934,
0.0039437432,
-0.017550718,
-0.0533131212,
0.0060102055,
0.0147167323,
-0.0509810001,
-0.0428428873,
-0.0301275421,
0.0037911509,
-0.0195665751,
0.009416406,
0.066273436,
0.0100204749,
-0.018182382,
0.0000017572,
0.0207433403,
0.0083195055,
-0.0199688543,
-0.0757861137,
0.0310193691,
-0.0601242669,
-0.01032566,
0.0176973827,
-0.0230820123,
-0.0563473962,
-0.0134900007,
-0.0196440984,
0.0533832759,
0.0611047596,
0.053193111,
0.0218843203,
0.0194825213,
0.0227497574,
-0.0055655753,
0.0642096028,
-0.0584232584,
-0.008783102,
0.0012635164,
0.0360328779,
-0.0166670177,
0.0055143442,
0.0333456099,
0.0614312775,
0.0068087857,
0.0007925957,
0.0400135852,
-0.0195081383,
0.0506817587,
-0.0280742571,
0.0807705224,
0.0693441406,
-0.0053954306,
0.0114668747,
0.0168469232,
-0.0115390345,
-0.0233945623,
-0.0339252315,
-0.0255459938,
-0.0021823747,
-0.029842766,
0.0212696493,
0.0113200489,
0.0163396243,
0.0155357961,
-0.019986134,
0.1177969426,
-0.0078365617,
-0.0254750382,
-0.0349012986,
-0.0325145088,
0.028757995,
-0.0471576229,
0.01215191,
0.0927114263,
-0.0100147976,
0.0118051358,
0.0280788131,
0.0191494357,
0.0175532717,
-0.0279114302,
-0.0214097444,
0.0546930619,
0.0198910721,
0.0704681799,
-0.010664328,
0.0267219488,
-0.0369683467,
0.0263908543,
-0.0211317576,
-0.0136683937,
-0.0610299557,
-0.0234097987,
0.0069662011,
0.0302289557,
-0.0405516773,
-0.0072703674,
-0.0053594126,
0.0122220553,
-0.0094442982,
0.006437236,
0.0059610046,
0.0523120761,
0.0058447323,
-0.014874828,
-0.1020317301,
-0.0111511871,
-0.057456743,
-0.0081331404,
-0.0171198864,
-0.0411403924,
-0.0299896207,
-0.0337688439,
-0.0056857509,
-0.0554660484,
0.0080619724,
0.0843816996,
-0.0349099971,
0.0122843403,
-0.0769344792,
-0.0544706583,
0.0037784481,
-0.0395089537,
0.0112512112,
-0.0291116796,
0.0552699156,
0.0072269007,
-0.0277302098,
-0.0229822341,
0.0108857611,
0.0453343429,
0.0156090176,
0.0750972703,
0.043514479,
0.0233723726,
-0.0075896671,
0.0104802856,
0.0324000493,
0.0481925271,
0.0168831479,
-0.0391276069,
-0.0083563682,
0.0119750965,
-0.0479428731,
0.0307518467,
0.0541818216,
-0.0019739908,
-0.0165277086,
0.0719636828,
-0.0056265546,
0.0589018092,
-0.0104789929,
0.0096053425,
-0.0263043754,
-0.0334344395,
0.0199292991,
0.0174075123,
-0.0191018265,
0.0082663596,
0.0575580411,
-0.0328646824,
0.0408519097,
0.0033927704,
-0.0089531019,
0.0307326671,
0.0015780329,
0.0135025922,
-0.000970582,
-0.0035735071,
-0.0287039336,
-0.0369167067,
-0.0012931364,
0.0199561641,
0.0026964163,
0.0177634619,
0.0433370247,
0.0166762918,
-0.0479134545,
0.0662520975,
-0.0221816339,
0.0054510888,
-0.0053198156,
-0.0054447944,
0.0404794067,
0.0985503867,
0.0416759625,
-0.0671148524,
-0.0503687337,
-0.0161446184,
0.0359968618,
0.0068786154,
0.0633350834,
-0.0393139385,
-0.0050143651,
0.0191195756,
-0.0187750366,
0.0109950202,
0.0117327161,
-0.0410014987,
0.0521812961,
0.0204925369,
-0.0118126627,
-0.0384336784,
0.0364838168,
0.0257945843,
-0.0218479298,
-0.0195643604,
-0.0522755906,
0.0142330229,
-0.0003365001,
0.0197110232,
0.0183158461,
0.015791947,
0.0459165275,
-0.0320244879,
-0.0117167113,
-0.0010621276,
-0.0368983112,
-0.0680227503,
0.0482027121,
0.0275798049,
-0.0633464679,
0.0059839971,
-0.0481630675,
-0.0360094272,
0.0136890616,
0.0111346235,
0.010567015,
-0.023835633,
-0.0034362045,
0.049091205,
0.0234341789,
-0.0497105643,
0.078672424,
-0.0430978425,
0.0340831727,
0.0152001278,
-0.0350924358,
0.026620578,
-0.0593743399,
0.0311438181,
-0.0130855842,
-0.0067996215,
-0.0146712158,
-0.0086175418,
-0.0049580331,
-0.096178785,
0.0127906138,
-0.0689096749,
0.0279615261,
-0.0206031632,
0.0286196265,
0.0214129053,
-0.0135879191,
-0.0048863762,
-0.020584913,
-0.0401098989,
-0.0291851945,
-0.0235701762,
0.0071983971,
0.0883277059,
0.0173731688,
-0.0020411978,
-0.0149651235,
-0.0316867642,
-0.0587454587,
0.0549195856,
-0.0343149826,
-0.0384132303,
0.0218234174,
-0.024167221,
-0.0152179748,
0.0116944117,
0.0073516802,
0.019068731,
0.0097019095,
-0.013383803,
0.0307669118,
0.0536535606,
-0.0118291723,
0.0061737071,
-0.0050366819,
-0.0186573491,
-0.0731015056,
0.0601133928,
-0.004990919,
0.0306969918,
-0.0022982815,
-0.0450864546,
-0.0082019204,
0.0494355373,
-0.0248840638,
0.0110573312,
-0.038634412,
0.0344586745,
0.0041282354,
0.0170186069,
-0.0673535764,
0.0436842963,
-0.0087820031,
0.034905564,
-0.0557267852,
0.0189284366,
0.0414332263,
-0.0025572849,
0.0175197665,
0.0457119569,
0.0082739508,
-0.0612857081,
0.0874772668,
0.0063262647,
-0.0214043874,
-0.0062926379,
-0.0271338504,
-0.0491764657,
-0.0021661541,
0.0062267324,
-0.0241272766,
0.0654899031,
-0.0269530248,
0.0190687291,
-0.0144307017,
-0.0205093753,
-0.0201213937,
-0.0737205967,
-0.0357028358,
0.0077074366,
-0.0486260392,
-0.0025147828,
-0.0117635485,
-0.015299744,
-0.0278149899,
0.0139274886,
-0.0275758132,
-0.0319724381,
-0.0165358819,
0.048392266,
0.0449800007,
0.0484943651,
-0.0121866018,
-0.0193819478,
0.0428077355,
0.0281636529,
0.0486525632,
-0.0328037739,
-0.0406331681,
0.0325065702,
0.0094689354,
-0.0402284116,
0.0095864031,
0.0170009565,
-0.0035763453,
-0.0713372678,
-0.0143777914,
0.080926761,
0.0512736142,
0.0310362354,
0.0101629132,
0.0056242635,
0.0297462735,
0.020894615,
0.0196432024,
-0.0870696828,
-0.0479283743,
-0.0018867546,
-0.0312585197,
-0.0051526437,
-0.0716892257,
-0.0077508567,
-0.0840405747,
-0.0101591619,
-0.035201475,
-0.0128273182,
-0.0261447262,
0.0100970538,
-0.0201811586,
0.0009791369,
0.0101736682,
0.0490861274,
-0.005065674,
0.0090410747,
0.0272700842,
-0.0370215625,
-0.0123345191,
0.0724962801,
0.0020893717,
0.0626017898,
0.0186310299,
0.0342631936,
0.001546776,
-0.0248682089,
0.0313319713,
-0.012876668,
0.0014261734,
-0.000169272,
0.0735234469,
0.0069531263,
-0.0174004789,
-0.011896451,
-0.0007781059,
-0.0553995594,
-0.0116317114,
-0.0128614809,
0.0963169411,
-0.0520440936,
0.0145469299,
-0.0117933648,
-0.0056669717,
-0.028120162,
0.0612883791,
0.0143127209,
0.0210113693,
-0.0864855647,
-0.0023421536,
-0.0606440306,
-0.100343436,
-0.0195576306,
0.0110112755,
0.0163420532,
0.0420433395,
-0.0659204796,
-0.0585087128,
0.0037091598,
0.0216391273,
-0.0109037338,
0.03390738,
-0.0391864665,
-0.0027106712,
-0.049210377,
0.0273616537,
-0.0211010501,
0.0168390237,
-0.0364859849,
-0.0261019282,
-0.0134667316,
-0.0116655212,
-0.0215666778,
0.0259663686,
-0.0875184387,
-0.0009609227,
-0.0076400596,
-0.0248166099,
0.0171547942,
0.0290124156,
-0.0137034385,
0.0037483752,
0.0087717939,
0.0092462264,
-0.0607348606,
-0.0277802367,
0.0129174395,
0.0179413725,
0.0033539219,
0.0454657301,
-0.047765445,
-0.032971926,
-0.0093586277,
0.0473912768,
-0.0279057249,
0.0297751632,
0.0335795246,
-0.0224827621,
-0.0145140151,
0.0529025234,
-0.0467024595,
-0.007725752,
0.0292802453,
-0.015612673,
-0.0176068209,
0.0100194141,
0.002409179,
0.0170133412,
-0.0414001159,
-0.032970041,
0.0074063316,
0.0232694186,
0.0256301574,
-0.0256051328,
-0.0115921265,
0.059743695,
-0.0261522997,
-0.0028548904,
-0.0085431887,
-0.0129591273,
0.0100223217,
-0.0094540035,
0.039654348,
-0.0050983643,
0.0127002122,
0.0291238241,
0.0091965981,
-0.0436817035,
-0.0120690772,
-0.1025046632,
-0.0239565019,
0.0224852171,
-0.0170649625,
0.0500628278,
-0.0075419927,
0.0067390357,
0.0052309735,
-0.0137211829,
0.0270810518,
-0.0060949018,
0.0609001592,
0.0201871041,
0.0566152073,
0.0254131015,
0.0059964387,
0.0139653534,
0.0682400912,
0.0196035523,
0.0603654422,
0.034795478,
-0.0223212056,
-0.0324885063,
-0.0229475237,
-0.0734316409,
-0.0260738414,
-0.0217726082,
-0.0076928651,
-0.0504617989,
-0.0650436506,
0.031427864,
0.035757076,
-0.0375046544,
-0.0026016098,
0.0075804312,
0.0308958739,
0.0868887082,
-0.0512389839,
-0.036987137,
0.0466880724,
0.0232810117,
-0.0159789287,
-0.0613408573,
-6.046169887e-33,
-0.0351083539,
-0.014069288,
0.0501035601,
-0.0244675763,
-0.0153398532,
0.0197825655,
-0.043316137,
-0.0250820816,
-0.0378373526,
0.0017223665,
-0.0433006808,
0.0688083991,
0.0228861608,
-0.0116747851,
0.0189155824,
-0.0912830234,
-0.0092647299,
-0.0307405163,
-0.0028555945,
0.000377164,
0.0399316885,
0.0512003228,
-0.0052269557,
-0.0185834616,
0.0360678546,
0.0085285902,
0.0060880394,
0.0355578437,
-0.0327458978,
0.0577300563,
-0.0318693891,
0.0095593976,
0.0425187536,
-0.0458757989,
-0.0142436242,
-0.0159495063,
-0.1588354558,
-0.0239621848,
-0.0205938518,
0.0049483269,
-0.0359967761,
-0.0349167809,
0.0129235545,
0.0048549818,
0.0227724463,
-0.0220943876,
0.0215322115,
-0.0342527293,
-0.0077320673,
-0.0390368961,
-0.0144699859,
0.0322870053,
-0.0434119292,
0.0052550356,
0.0234173909,
0.0614381172,
0.035415601,
-0.0091564078,
-0.0417770259,
0.00301822,
0.0030199133,
0.0244172532,
0.0473391898,
-0.0292245653,
0.0184465796,
0.0396628231,
0.0176167302,
0.0297068506,
-0.0324309953,
0.0331831612,
-0.045673646,
0.0330475941,
0.0378351584,
-0.0190108642,
0.0261853728,
0.0192427505,
-0.0744385421,
0.0339444987,
0.0325567164,
0.0243618935,
-0.0192883201,
-0.0331330076,
-0.0189883187,
0.0077781044,
-0.029527273,
0.0450832993,
-0.0198129732,
0.0144814057,
0.0324974619,
0.0092893299,
0.0418249853,
-0.0129500646,
0.0028766876,
-0.0108604552,
-0.0024333999,
0.0405240692,
0.0082666213,
0.0045694476,
0.0307854991,
0.042380169,
-0.0318615213,
0.0060534081,
-0.0055859871,
-0.0307071432,
0.0235605873,
0.0152227394,
0.0209807586,
0.0113586988,
-0.0435382649,
-0.0455980152,
-0.049320206,
0.0340851769,
-0.0373424143,
-0.0189782176,
0.0318943895,
0.0017397557,
-0.0239093229,
0.0499909036,
0.0350549258,
0.0111051016,
0.0075696781,
0.0191192683,
0.0035191809,
0.0054016435,
0.035592664,
-0.0081143435,
-0.0268157329,
0.029577069,
-0.0135676945,
-0.0259728134,
0.023313811,
0.0379351303,
2.27e-7,
0.0749523714,
-0.0033292768,
0.0402169526,
0.0904205889,
0.0126781547,
-0.0146271726,
-0.0190191846,
-0.0239809155,
-0.0478827581,
-0.0093346555,
0.0363376923,
0.0240515582,
0.0485389158,
0.024441747,
-0.0200686138,
-0.0497996844,
-0.0401005782,
-0.0090253726,
-0.060707327,
-0.0336553566,
0.0497281812,
0.0564311706,
-0.0102066584,
-0.0005170479,
-0.021933496,
-0.0387371667,
0.0659336746,
-0.0360688865,
0.0063512884,
0.0372283831,
0.0609527268,
-0.015702134,
0.0148666892,
0.07202705,
-0.0262552314,
-0.0099958768,
-0.0092614153,
0.0463367403,
0.010061508,
-0.052016791,
-0.0469947569,
-0.0931950286,
0.0215516519,
-0.0119751059,
0.130632937,
-0.0392875411,
-0.0154591994,
0.0742881522,
-0.015836399,
0.029236408,
0.0127042271,
0.0426067822,
-0.0124504864,
0.0129785668,
0.0181560349,
-0.007525065,
0.0247060005,
-0.0945313647,
-0.0534600243,
0.0332754403,
-0.0379058719,
0.0043438142,
-0.0188511778,
-0.0021920563,
-0.0184440017,
-0.0324465893,
-0.0462567694,
1.917746713e-34,
0.0330517292,
0.0214462411,
-0.000714835,
0.0635805875,
0.0554893613,
-0.0334090889,
0.0267092772,
-0.0465886779,
0.0252211299,
-0.0584846772,
-0.0054076407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08001v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08001v1 | A Comparative Analysis of the COVID-19 Infodemic in English and Chinese: Insights from Social Media Textual Data | 2023-11-14T08:55:11 | 2023-11-14T08:55:11 | Jia Luo, Daiyun Peng, Lei Shi, Didier El Baz, Xinran Liu | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL, physics.soc-ph | The COVID-19 infodemic, characterized by the rapid spread of misinformation
and unverified claims related to the pandemic, presents a significant
challenge. This paper presents a comparative analysis of the COVID-19 infodemic
in the English and Chinese languages, utilizing textual data extracted from
social media platforms. To ensure a balanced representation, two infodemic
datasets were created by augmenting previously collected social media textual
data. Through word frequency analysis, the thirty-five most frequently
occurring infodemic words are identified, shedding light on prevalent
discussions surrounding the infodemic. Moreover, topic clustering analysis
uncovers thematic structures and provides a deeper understanding of primary
topics within each language context. Additionally, sentiment analysis enables
comprehension of the emotional tone associated with COVID-19 information on
social media platforms in English and Chinese. This research contributes to a
better understanding of the COVID-19 infodemic phenomenon and can guide the
development of strategies to combat misinformation during public health crises
across different languages. | [
0.0334808379,
0.0323198996,
-0.0272820089,
-0.0073939958,
-0.012877374,
-0.0209606588,
-0.0429298431,
-0.0004435453,
0.0052146325,
-0.0274203736,
0.0317364335,
-0.0071489331,
0.0174533837,
0.0258760918,
0.002821428,
-0.0646376461,
0.0170282107,
0.0775178,
0.0756298825,
0.0080290847,
0.0441113412,
0.0302148461,
-0.0081225252,
0.0534637123,
0.0019845061,
-0.0100838887,
0.0407035463,
-0.0106749106,
0.0622127876,
-0.1061316133,
0.0414092056,
-0.0096479831,
0.0445684716,
0.0097489646,
0.0000018114,
-0.0367883556,
-0.0257111341,
-0.0085151074,
0.0474775024,
-0.0110481763,
0.0950831771,
-0.0867166668,
0.0072823758,
0.0207498632,
-0.0376329795,
-0.0394929573,
0.0403435789,
0.0714374408,
0.0541122146,
0.0806519389,
-0.0324943922,
-0.029591782,
0.00036275,
0.0320729688,
-0.0354461633,
-0.00185566,
0.0333975479,
0.0145382416,
0.0077253468,
0.0057993806,
0.0286289137,
0.014255709,
-0.0471481383,
0.020693196,
-0.0395183004,
0.0542190038,
-0.0485477895,
-0.0676574782,
0.0129976692,
0.0308894068,
0.0526269935,
-0.0173448771,
0.0356005765,
0.0052315751,
-0.0107348105,
0.0421133377,
-0.0394113064,
-0.0083810687,
-0.0041145794,
0.0525875501,
0.0276264884,
0.0199098475,
0.0359829292,
0.0242004488,
0.0116648516,
0.0587457716,
-0.0265885256,
-0.0514760651,
-0.031828884,
-0.0564787425,
0.0065945275,
-0.0227449629,
0.0278007984,
0.018997062,
0.0106164804,
0.0484850071,
0.0301133078,
-0.071082361,
0.0566372201,
-0.1691123694,
-0.0805766881,
-0.0003704199,
0.0287454501,
-0.0198336281,
0.0769738331,
-0.0610584803,
0.0232314579,
-0.0014183893,
0.016829025,
0.0218999926,
-0.0568812191,
0.0372015461,
-0.0163416658,
-0.016957745,
0.04774753,
0.0343783498,
-0.0384029299,
-0.0380570441,
-0.0224962179,
-0.0224039797,
-0.0556510203,
0.0157788955,
-0.0123983109,
0.0168739352,
-0.0007974128,
0.056153547,
-0.0569187999,
0.0292610731,
-0.0343355872,
0.0274597108,
0.0407606438,
-0.0090804761,
0.0308625158,
0.0287248362,
-0.0226040818,
-0.014638369,
0.0166842118,
0.0259311181,
-0.0083388444,
-0.013575648,
-0.0295875985,
-0.0080806054,
-0.037236236,
-0.0653627887,
-0.0131177157,
0.0318216719,
-0.013520143,
0.0290507581,
0.0219808649,
0.0161167849,
-0.0800979286,
0.0064708721,
-0.0400016978,
0.0038672462,
0.0493457206,
0.0418484323,
0.0412663929,
0.0205410533,
0.0047606062,
0.0539388098,
0.0490891635,
-0.0004574591,
-0.0185386594,
-0.0248755366,
0.0221063904,
0.0252821799,
0.0081411842,
-0.020131506,
0.0111003537,
-0.033646971,
-0.0393027067,
0.0249831267,
-0.0016482972,
0.0171101131,
-0.0045455103,
0.037991304,
-0.063542448,
-0.0183710773,
-0.0324696787,
0.077270098,
-0.0087881917,
-0.0018758385,
0.0243806541,
-0.0220640469,
-0.009499765,
-0.0099038444,
0.0219655465,
0.0344529413,
-0.0147763407,
-0.0222558081,
-0.0424417593,
0.0173420049,
0.0407957733,
-0.0475056507,
-0.0077851261,
-0.0514815077,
-0.0126286577,
0.0254376177,
0.0602644309,
-0.046802301,
0.0059269397,
-0.0067450423,
0.001724398,
0.067127578,
-0.017002061,
0.0018523738,
-0.0403051078,
0.000888341,
0.0347138382,
0.005346261,
0.0104014222,
-0.0063371086,
-0.0582594126,
-0.0110200569,
0.00621911,
0.0188579354,
0.0306219105,
-0.0110607203,
-0.0050658146,
0.0670440048,
-0.0230985004,
-0.0055011781,
-0.044776544,
0.0118416371,
0.015700506,
0.0264944118,
-0.0424802452,
0.0115634119,
0.0385251492,
0.0283467136,
0.0142892748,
0.0083278064,
0.0721855462,
-0.028042974,
-0.0594220161,
0.0346317217,
0.0056364289,
0.0077231159,
0.0115160234,
-0.0585089512,
0.000768706,
0.006192279,
-0.0482380912,
0.0116881467,
0.0643812343,
0.0093993768,
0.0118728811,
-0.006303709,
-0.0051523163,
-0.0374176465,
0.0209611002,
0.0387122519,
0.0279802009,
-0.0341879092,
0.0016032176,
-0.0318633169,
-0.0456358455,
-0.0062392619,
-0.0121969879,
-0.0028211481,
0.005231637,
0.01041253,
0.0157382879,
0.0292764138,
-0.0327059664,
-0.0085149938,
-0.0005555237,
-0.0972200111,
-0.0324242339,
-0.01718737,
0.0224244706,
0.059615612,
0.0053112819,
-0.0213675927,
0.0196434893,
-0.0217612945,
0.002797663,
-0.0144487983,
0.0061142887,
0.0134115908,
-0.007060736,
-0.0010079661,
-0.026158737,
0.0216032825,
-0.0587489232,
-0.0351840816,
0.0445047766,
-0.0942611098,
0.0015309697,
-0.0200404599,
-0.0631401017,
-0.0256881248,
-0.0229966156,
-0.0485604033,
-0.0169025715,
0.0147604868,
0.0167605337,
-0.0579468198,
0.0398058742,
0.0742121115,
0.0717818066,
0.0316326246,
0.0062618204,
-0.002103583,
-0.0560311228,
0.0171321593,
-0.0106848134,
-0.0950857773,
0.0414958484,
0.0188601147,
0.0365030393,
0.0288736522,
-0.0256492179,
-0.0182632562,
-0.0549148768,
-0.0022427305,
-0.0390187949,
-0.005493857,
-0.0116176289,
-0.0042347531,
-0.0035761488,
-0.0077179754,
0.0048987293,
0.0142361075,
0.0732451901,
-0.0834757537,
-0.0421059728,
-0.0167367645,
-0.0309275836,
-0.0254303273,
0.0243575964,
0.0315168165,
0.014137608,
0.0495318994,
-0.0448723771,
0.0016080606,
-0.0141939828,
-0.0036578898,
0.0017888533,
-0.0035884308,
0.0187755004,
0.0021527407,
-0.0115787461,
-0.0607297458,
-0.0413404442,
-0.0047004251,
0.0558736809,
-0.0031609137,
-0.0193373132,
0.0140473098,
0.0197789855,
-0.0398414582,
0.045487307,
-0.01381547,
0.0591977574,
-0.0119262226,
0.0037328843,
-0.0525632501,
0.0184865035,
0.0116373394,
0.0240438506,
0.0579756871,
0.0308635514,
-0.0286571793,
0.0023923297,
-0.0075270087,
-0.0096578412,
-0.0104434853,
-0.0159159396,
0.0161025524,
0.0319595039,
-0.023778649,
0.0521305762,
0.0766109675,
0.0298731271,
-0.0043393434,
0.0305781551,
-0.0460919812,
-0.0211239774,
0.0062974771,
0.0173657816,
-0.0191698261,
0.0245601237,
-0.0290786978,
0.0033320761,
-0.0242165886,
-0.0057240822,
-0.0233658534,
0.0082757035,
0.0264050569,
0.0174376592,
0.006770744,
-0.0124206338,
-0.0684382319,
0.019323932,
0.0210078284,
0.0060909963,
-0.0661230385,
0.0098284669,
-0.0106293159,
-0.0219038036,
-0.0914083719,
-0.0253495481,
0.0082497513,
0.0174223147,
0.0056480397,
-0.0025394969,
0.1065119132,
-0.0410889611,
-0.0361115783,
-0.0120088272,
0.0082000215,
-0.0133037753,
-0.0285901148,
0.0612860955,
-0.0000890789,
0.0135556366,
-0.0308711547,
0.0085873026,
-0.0315683559,
-0.0213176701,
0.0395960286,
0.0646484345,
0.0043697283,
-0.0674813911,
-0.0404314697,
0.0646414533,
0.0273569059,
0.0299221035,
0.0097296787,
0.0303659961,
0.0411259457,
0.0093004005,
0.0503031425,
0.0074628545,
-0.0073452843,
-0.0230094753,
-0.0549100153,
-0.0992553979,
-0.0705076158,
-0.0303300936,
-0.0064610555,
-0.0304662567,
-0.0219055507,
-0.0257270299,
0.0663498491,
-0.030314099,
-0.0149685051,
-0.0088661434,
0.0348809771,
0.0234653559,
-0.019557694,
-0.0351377465,
0.0080024023,
0.0569120869,
0.005097257,
0.009632837,
-0.0111595206,
-0.0542222001,
0.0228714719,
-0.0516809933,
-0.0012050204,
0.0032416305,
0.001816861,
0.0227565933,
0.0676240847,
0.0356097668,
-0.0435645916,
-0.0374744534,
0.0102710808,
0.0133863501,
0.0260294639,
0.014177803,
0.012522921,
0.0225272961,
-0.0154878059,
0.0151390051,
-0.0673512518,
0.0111942114,
0.00685137,
0.0179756545,
0.0496908166,
-0.0001869751,
-0.0307037048,
-0.0492640547,
-0.0454185754,
-0.0012697611,
-0.0266531575,
0.0392895155,
-0.0212976318,
-0.0107728224,
-0.0177976787,
-0.058335904,
0.0628779382,
-0.0340873152,
-0.0508930422,
-0.028121464,
0.0516174622,
0.0092371413,
0.085770674,
0.0130279241,
-0.018276792,
0.0296270177,
0.0103253955,
-0.0002240819,
-0.0307058953,
-0.0153457876,
-0.013395125,
-0.0236500837,
-0.0056108693,
0.0148627181,
0.0000115667,
-0.0268094484,
-0.0320959203,
-0.0153251588,
-0.0183937736,
0.0142069934,
0.0048465426,
0.0452376567,
-0.0295104254,
-0.0346803665,
-0.0140141705,
0.0333753303,
-0.0468093939,
-0.037170697,
-0.0017089712,
-0.020257391,
-0.049841892,
0.0240154658,
0.0491892099,
-0.0571146458,
0.0512384959,
0.0787977055,
-0.0477454923,
0.0149279078,
0.0153342355,
0.0447109938,
0.0153789539,
-0.0156041188,
0.0333951861,
-0.0741578937,
-0.0238402132,
0.0783188641,
-0.0715685561,
-0.0333137773,
-0.0192967933,
0.0022110569,
0.0392547064,
0.0066033318,
0.0537909381,
-0.0550700463,
0.0239811204,
-0.0263917707,
-0.0180944633,
-0.0079103922,
-6.425507792e-33,
0.0357500538,
-0.0310996082,
-0.0268492214,
-0.004587038,
0.0168665964,
0.0284298304,
-0.0180669948,
0.0049880315,
-0.0125831431,
0.0612341538,
0.0333060436,
0.0185648333,
-0.0006346981,
-0.0238538869,
-0.0032212574,
-0.021461837,
0.0413839743,
0.011200347,
-0.0237684418,
0.0290329754,
0.0786387697,
0.0280692633,
0.054478731,
-0.082138285,
0.0574854948,
0.0024583908,
0.0077175288,
0.0025325685,
0.0873217881,
-0.002771779,
0.0004648758,
0.0664491132,
0.0516440272,
-0.0146268886,
-0.0061641447,
0.0226686038,
-0.0330066681,
-0.0714478344,
0.0197894704,
-0.0454111807,
0.0165385641,
-0.0108167753,
0.0290532652,
0.0125482166,
-0.0049995277,
0.0551064201,
0.0431576185,
-0.0003949227,
0.03206091,
-0.012606604,
-0.0445315614,
0.0330978446,
-0.0258969031,
0.0518279336,
-0.017292209,
0.0515625887,
-0.0169982649,
0.0657348782,
-0.037816979,
0.0308655147,
-0.0135236746,
0.0226257499,
0.0138051566,
-0.0537821576,
-0.002032367,
0.0490117036,
-0.0218416303,
0.003872134,
-0.0462020077,
0.0373554379,
-0.0100733805,
0.0244009998,
-0.0089922575,
0.0751866698,
-0.0028766801,
-0.0614347346,
-0.0632216036,
0.0596417114,
-0.0277033914,
0.0380279124,
0.0140696894,
0.0019801592,
-0.0431273058,
-0.0269586854,
0.008369809,
-0.0009239154,
-0.0128285903,
-0.0142164296,
-0.0417940207,
-0.0131097091,
-0.0383012444,
-0.010152421,
-0.0305920076,
-0.0049448167,
-0.0381220542,
0.033465527,
0.0072374707,
-0.0247700941,
0.0109355003,
0.0583084375,
-0.0780691952,
0.0131268557,
-0.023197392,
0.0553369038,
0.0033691281,
0.0034174968,
0.0215502754,
-0.0125863049,
-0.0312922075,
-0.0089244312,
0.0233236384,
-0.0311856586,
-0.0102942763,
0.0038144202,
-0.0047931657,
0.0184166655,
0.0036498909,
-0.0098588718,
0.0498022139,
0.033638183,
0.0341739506,
-0.0684866607,
-0.0827056542,
0.0162354652,
-0.0278837718,
0.0118478425,
-0.0456875898,
0.0316141769,
0.0252291411,
-0.0853585899,
-0.0277181175,
-0.0474840924,
2.705e-7,
0.0790025964,
0.0598334298,
-0.0262707695,
0.0148984902,
0.0017272718,
0.0320988707,
-0.0212341975,
0.0177638531,
-0.0179776736,
-0.0436216071,
-0.0021001769,
0.0264376234,
-0.034176223,
0.0639176816,
-0.0134309148,
0.0478163473,
-0.068764165,
0.0189135727,
-0.0220210645,
0.0289701093,
0.0042863372,
0.0493190698,
-0.0036983914,
0.0208384842,
-0.0400108956,
0.0348277092,
0.0138305686,
-0.0456583239,
-0.0583682545,
0.0432142951,
-0.0122620277,
0.0276744347,
0.0061060889,
-0.025676528,
-0.0224204436,
-0.0338055342,
-0.0008265007,
-0.0078829462,
0.0186486449,
0.0277049094,
0.0162174478,
-0.0254745521,
0.0000589911,
-0.0175751783,
0.0261298753,
-0.0675312579,
-0.0824342147,
-0.0097068697,
-0.0012034207,
0.0399214253,
0.0331687815,
-0.0271724369,
-0.0800032094,
0.0541245006,
-0.0114413444,
0.0103987092,
-0.0158136114,
-0.0257680919,
0.008778153,
-0.0148530472,
-0.0101801781,
-0.0450857058,
0.0228623394,
-0.0111804754,
0.0023843616,
0.0018310649,
0.0932061747,
1.830630987e-34,
0.0384776667,
-0.0015429388,
-0.0912345722,
-0.0400164016,
0.0211477913,
-0.0168540273,
-0.0233372431,
0.0018372161,
0.0097115999,
-0.0037393107,
0.0071443245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07996v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07996v1 | How Well Do Text Embedding Models Understand Syntax? | 2023-11-14T08:51:00 | 2023-11-14T08:51:00 | Yan Zhang, Zhaopeng Feng, Zhiyang Teng, Zuozhu Liu, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text embedding models have significantly contributed to advancements in
natural language processing by adeptly capturing semantic properties of textual
data. However, the ability of these models to generalize across a wide range of
syntactic contexts remains under-explored. In this paper, we first develop an
evaluation set, named \textbf{SR}, to scrutinize the capability for syntax
understanding of text embedding models from two crucial syntactic aspects:
Structural heuristics, and Relational understanding among concepts, as revealed
by the performance gaps in previous studies. Our findings reveal that existing
text embedding models have not sufficiently addressed these syntactic
understanding challenges, and such ineffectiveness becomes even more apparent
when evaluated against existing benchmark datasets. Furthermore, we conduct
rigorous analysis to unearth factors that lead to such limitations and examine
why previous evaluations fail to detect such ineffectiveness. Lastly, we
propose strategies to augment the generalization ability of text embedding
models in diverse syntactic scenarios. This study serves to highlight the
hurdles associated with syntactic generalization and provides pragmatic
guidance for boosting model performance across varied syntactic contexts. | [
0.030823525,
0.0295150504,
-0.0083694747,
0.0621719733,
-0.0148681961,
0.0391510874,
-0.0308294892,
-0.0021249631,
0.0078636715,
-0.0675824732,
-0.013530992,
-0.0335861333,
0.007218848,
0.0295484476,
0.044502221,
-0.0510392189,
0.0182151571,
0.0254240893,
0.0002293448,
0.0327551179,
0.0493513346,
-0.0161578003,
0.047713127,
0.0459484048,
-0.0359778218,
-0.0190059952,
0.0239816457,
-0.0079548741,
0.0127465175,
-0.0214722026,
-0.0039904225,
0.0161177255,
0.0335198194,
0.0232881773,
0.0000016351,
-0.0167994611,
-0.0010488081,
-0.0155637152,
-0.0279093701,
0.0282347668,
0.0515431613,
-0.0890347883,
0.0128081767,
-0.0027298017,
-0.0283836834,
-0.0465674661,
0.0115013728,
0.0359500572,
0.0259409677,
0.0485756285,
-0.0214308575,
-0.0333035514,
-0.0032499577,
0.0006100255,
-0.0235905219,
0.0084167216,
0.0246612038,
0.0060433135,
-0.0181900393,
0.0277210679,
-0.0068242815,
0.0189967342,
0.0157537144,
0.0174675938,
0.0428812392,
0.0346813574,
-0.0587107241,
-0.0152507778,
0.013438195,
0.057997331,
-0.0207945276,
-0.0209250152,
0.0032793696,
0.0065203919,
-0.0177930016,
-0.0181009825,
-0.0323170684,
0.0033397917,
0.0119313458,
0.0455878638,
0.0299773309,
0.0313773453,
0.0454867631,
-0.0106030498,
-0.0091894167,
0.0681088716,
-0.0247535557,
-0.0237903036,
0.0157811176,
0.0214814432,
-0.0713163242,
-0.025415048,
0.0314626805,
-0.0255731046,
0.0194440875,
0.0305339694,
-0.0449921712,
-0.0571980327,
0.0098038381,
-0.0632214397,
0.0412078612,
0.0215918012,
0.0085011162,
0.0436963513,
-0.0508405268,
0.0384992436,
-0.0081233047,
0.0028928663,
-0.0227352418,
0.0147646945,
-0.0709479153,
-0.0005529271,
-0.0221616998,
0.019140305,
-0.0087445052,
-0.0550840609,
0.0250737611,
0.0459183156,
0.0180210844,
0.0610556044,
-0.0289132986,
-0.0034524673,
-0.016562473,
0.0209956337,
-0.0148611506,
-0.0542074516,
-0.0460078195,
-0.0058266595,
-0.0355743654,
-0.0403450504,
-0.0408763774,
0.0250141434,
0.0125238374,
-0.0211929437,
-0.0399414785,
0.0319296941,
0.0116225872,
-0.0397650227,
-0.0074106483,
-0.0072599249,
-0.0576260909,
-0.0359908156,
0.0014979807,
-0.0463571511,
0.0130128888,
0.0397495516,
-0.0071958359,
-0.0383860208,
0.0038645435,
0.0168088768,
-0.0338222906,
0.0848984495,
0.0035775024,
-0.0493235104,
-0.0320604853,
0.0061779534,
-0.0094374865,
0.0615136698,
0.0194361713,
-0.0029652193,
0.0194548666,
0.0138997994,
-0.0270437542,
0.0098011652,
-0.0215022378,
-0.0102103595,
-0.0424142703,
0.037476141,
0.0278544836,
0.0383065268,
0.0052032545,
0.0454920493,
-0.0205724165,
-0.0403668284,
0.023294352,
0.0417174883,
-0.0050828103,
0.0266310126,
0.0714277402,
0.0318525881,
0.0027287514,
0.0144714955,
-0.050151594,
-0.0416196287,
-0.0131514687,
-0.0007656466,
-0.0312052835,
-0.0049928483,
-0.0089079654,
-0.0405690148,
-0.0739956945,
-0.0282749943,
0.0357854478,
-0.0286977999,
0.0206048042,
0.0192916784,
-0.0285526607,
0.0300160702,
0.0298690125,
-0.0570639186,
-0.0070633269,
0.0362185426,
0.0047162888,
0.0457852073,
0.070530124,
-0.0375695787,
-0.0156304147,
-0.0150657613,
0.0095720114,
0.0207731873,
0.0299989153,
-0.0061928462,
0.0437526479,
-0.0332522951,
-0.0496121347,
-0.0383848585,
0.0476883575,
-0.0125154778,
-0.0120001212,
-0.041327171,
0.0210135169,
-0.0718456134,
-0.0033726385,
0.0609414503,
-0.0082009668,
-0.0047339485,
-0.0265688077,
0.0222919956,
0.0007449922,
0.0062604733,
-0.0089220004,
0.0210216716,
0.0265805926,
-0.0618951358,
-0.0111951949,
-0.008661381,
-0.0611210987,
-0.0701022223,
-0.0124617387,
-0.0324025378,
-0.0055193221,
0.0343733802,
-0.0337333418,
-0.0012905106,
-0.0092306584,
-0.0424617156,
0.051301416,
0.0004667799,
-0.0002295865,
-0.0131446263,
0.0233487077,
-0.018019462,
0.0684897751,
0.008505295,
0.01444175,
-0.0150079522,
-0.0020641466,
0.0484468453,
-0.0059941281,
-0.0525914468,
-0.0237757731,
-0.0249215793,
-0.0166231506,
0.0100844251,
-0.0140401274,
-0.0412925482,
-0.0079307463,
-0.0735721141,
0.011173103,
-0.0423205607,
0.0273283459,
0.0317009389,
-0.0215747003,
0.014319337,
-0.0168691073,
-0.0167944729,
-0.0187463779,
-0.0501069725,
0.0134863183,
0.0920591876,
-0.0027507162,
-0.0477811918,
-0.0602220744,
0.0114607085,
-0.0539995991,
0.0981559306,
0.005588077,
-0.0056435876,
-0.0126409475,
0.0508332923,
-0.0062018652,
-0.0089969365,
0.0148239639,
-0.036505457,
0.009522167,
0.0109472293,
0.0029954112,
0.0887002423,
-0.0444442034,
0.0417739637,
0.0428301692,
0.013217303,
-0.0698476136,
-0.0098646739,
-0.0044872998,
0.0402866453,
-0.0404480994,
-0.0241070166,
0.0085115684,
0.111291945,
0.0099528087,
0.0056191762,
-0.0504829101,
0.0316656567,
-0.048542656,
0.0003432827,
-0.0293776784,
-0.0167583749,
0.0118011609,
0.0204111673,
-0.037346337,
-0.0236759149,
0.0618640296,
-0.0341909565,
-0.0315858796,
-0.0436111204,
-0.0349195227,
-0.0624182895,
0.0634195134,
0.0445138216,
0.0026848414,
0.0535848401,
-0.0221687686,
-0.0225431137,
0.0241868291,
0.0057853428,
0.0181761924,
0.0369401649,
-0.013127326,
-0.0073583629,
0.0004458771,
-0.0452294685,
-0.0282496624,
-0.0704105273,
-0.0318685658,
-0.0018627896,
0.0325254314,
0.0200254843,
0.0104704937,
0.0202680118,
-0.0135913519,
0.0036643369,
0.0090404889,
-0.0283359364,
-0.067848891,
-0.0005348603,
0.0228585638,
-0.0325805098,
0.014909598,
0.0230567884,
0.0429950282,
0.0382062383,
0.0502566174,
0.0174748972,
-0.0725266933,
0.0222355556,
0.0282877292,
-0.0330513529,
-0.0777960345,
-0.0152898068,
0.0476559922,
-0.0406735539,
-0.0195740014,
0.1234182194,
0.0797824562,
0.0005585724,
0.0259902645,
0.00304291,
0.0725164115,
0.0109792519,
-0.0128181605,
-0.0680327564,
-0.0505936742,
0.0174852479,
-0.0309893936,
0.0137038957,
-0.027279282,
0.0062328675,
-0.0452989899,
-0.0133839324,
-0.0001077563,
-0.0006381223,
-0.0149148218,
-0.0273257196,
-0.0055467216,
-0.0453584753,
0.0205474645,
-0.0202392265,
-0.0267328806,
0.0094456011,
0.016040504,
-0.073743239,
-0.0533790588,
0.029139569,
-0.0686363131,
-0.024337681,
0.0474743396,
0.0403770544,
0.0198775735,
0.0131573789,
-0.0210005045,
-0.0123905819,
-0.0080698403,
-0.0046688761,
0.0672060102,
-0.0184203964,
-0.0042609298,
-0.0040777391,
-0.0001601155,
-0.0578949451,
-0.0037756143,
-0.0287945513,
0.0625235736,
-0.0040079253,
-0.0092111435,
-0.0243838485,
-0.0037915169,
-0.0204861388,
0.0927055031,
0.0646235198,
-0.022380542,
-0.0419094786,
-0.0654898509,
0.0360505134,
-0.0372980349,
0.0009254075,
0.0125594931,
0.037233334,
-0.0000228088,
-0.0571621954,
-0.0827990696,
0.032731723,
-0.0026981726,
0.0107361879,
0.0061155045,
-0.0081524374,
-0.0488296226,
0.005794236,
0.0476830788,
-0.0006264049,
-0.0008371149,
0.0129248118,
0.0284138899,
0.0028569163,
0.039694611,
-0.0361346193,
-0.0227219071,
-0.0657367259,
-0.0354415141,
0.005463114,
0.008643317,
0.0107643036,
0.028808469,
-0.0235273279,
-0.051009845,
0.0081052668,
0.0139547344,
-0.0284226723,
-0.0009304113,
0.062078055,
-0.008957793,
0.0378134474,
0.0671674982,
-0.0320579037,
-0.0029242579,
-0.0111700101,
0.0324926712,
-0.0399602316,
-0.0051231976,
0.0306424201,
-0.0238843933,
0.0574355237,
0.0416759551,
-0.0009571127,
0.0107532721,
0.0000795515,
-0.0423867777,
-0.0197566319,
-0.0551882125,
0.0026660229,
0.0573281758,
0.0222828947,
-0.0325566158,
0.0226088613,
-0.0158932786,
0.0824439079,
-0.0259599611,
0.0253970735,
0.0610685013,
-0.0156538077,
0.0239264537,
0.0090893237,
-0.0157146733,
0.0065412251,
-0.03082655,
-0.0222970396,
-0.0214112643,
-0.0070345108,
0.007640515,
-0.0101060588,
-0.0085745687,
0.0061955089,
-0.0512776487,
-0.0024547302,
0.028145086,
-0.0079348683,
0.045108255,
-0.062823981,
0.0461109802,
-0.0180616751,
0.0059915707,
0.0023596138,
0.0357776694,
-0.0054468634,
-0.0429337807,
0.0517152548,
0.0287770927,
-0.0596378297,
-0.0293410625,
0.0691216141,
0.0433615148,
0.0381312184,
0.0273013115,
-0.0364668667,
-0.039383553,
-0.0028122307,
0.0662752837,
0.040435534,
-0.0124840494,
0.018434912,
-0.0462540276,
-0.0521703809,
0.0446015373,
-0.0169191211,
-0.0283088274,
-0.0139555158,
0.0099484995,
0.0665236115,
0.0149348546,
-0.0326340944,
-0.0310785566,
-0.0137044201,
0.0080680316,
-0.0332546309,
-0.0297695156,
-5.875766553e-33,
-0.0150292525,
0.0070801643,
-0.0350792594,
-0.0039415061,
0.0183727629,
0.0261015017,
-0.0332667604,
-0.0002653222,
-0.0197594147,
0.024264235,
-0.0117105935,
0.0237157475,
0.007931699,
0.0278056562,
-0.0010707394,
-0.0217689499,
0.0229134317,
-0.0139265833,
-0.0303638335,
-0.0351956598,
0.0192859787,
0.0520971715,
0.046978265,
-0.0048135375,
0.0406762287,
0.0039016237,
0.0158474464,
0.0112195509,
0.0433588326,
0.0723910555,
-0.0389814898,
0.0289550163,
0.0227961875,
-0.0010639882,
-0.0501890033,
0.0831575766,
-0.0742553398,
-0.0460888743,
0.0127283027,
0.0203841142,
-0.0630711615,
-0.0006467536,
0.0502281189,
-0.0171894804,
0.0033622938,
0.0021571021,
0.0353122093,
-0.0026509624,
-0.0197339784,
0.0252431221,
-0.0474116206,
0.04926553,
-0.0204362962,
0.0163128898,
0.0660480261,
0.0514250956,
0.0456026345,
0.0545283258,
-0.0679078177,
-0.0428697914,
-0.0468256027,
0.0359209813,
0.0176629107,
-0.0142921284,
-0.0081718564,
0.0758843943,
-0.0305790287,
-0.0278654452,
-0.0470151417,
0.0056816381,
0.024171738,
0.025905529,
0.0383224227,
0.0353567339,
0.0122179165,
0.0403642729,
-0.0704948977,
-0.0148792751,
0.0427994467,
0.0292049628,
0.0148629854,
0.0442702807,
-0.0776165426,
-0.02585846,
-0.0797114819,
0.0003541636,
-0.0147687383,
-0.0412074514,
0.0411412865,
-0.0210168213,
0.0118724136,
0.0285841711,
-0.0001953335,
-0.055451829,
-0.0224257149,
0.0446513779,
0.000821175,
0.0222803447,
0.0352830216,
0.0403051712,
-0.0637442768,
-0.0287380572,
0.0054381341,
-0.0134285893,
0.0371548496,
-0.0129110962,
0.0833041146,
-0.010433292,
-0.0356164426,
-0.0254261699,
-0.0365005694,
-0.0503435656,
-0.0395845398,
0.0180029366,
0.0645807385,
0.0323007815,
0.0015919574,
0.059656024,
0.0358950272,
0.0083134165,
-0.0357286185,
-0.0133084515,
-0.022968119,
0.0112968422,
-0.0045753056,
-0.0531216227,
-0.0115685202,
0.0121634174,
0.0380265936,
-0.0425478183,
0.0003230372,
-0.0151756676,
2.303e-7,
0.0890716314,
0.0615140572,
0.0161417834,
0.0176094677,
0.0211841688,
0.0731134713,
-0.004715113,
0.0503177419,
-0.042264726,
-0.0272157677,
-0.0029283708,
0.0082817292,
0.0304541979,
-0.0013038054,
-0.0808157176,
0.0221983269,
-0.0719667673,
-0.0113509689,
-0.018769322,
-0.0287034921,
0.0617726445,
0.1214341372,
-0.0025869189,
0.0145212524,
-0.049692709,
-0.0810038596,
0.0674576163,
-0.0521527976,
-0.0288712811,
0.0348017476,
-0.0008978627,
0.0296911262,
-0.0034593698,
0.0203876235,
-0.016447261,
0.0340829492,
0.0348281004,
0.0607358925,
0.0005832602,
0.0370123535,
-0.023367973,
-0.0251788907,
-0.0006027446,
-0.0771146044,
0.0951055437,
-0.0695568621,
-0.0302966498,
-0.0020809569,
0.0085962471,
0.0096805859,
0.0454707667,
0.0338621363,
-0.0178353656,
0.0230769515,
0.0226951111,
-0.0413994119,
-0.0164492819,
-0.0843641236,
-0.0426084101,
0.0547904037,
-0.0111614931,
0.0460398011,
-0.0506214052,
0.0138509953,
0.0499996319,
-0.027922634,
-0.0195959397,
2.645332028e-34,
0.0150484908,
-0.0149293756,
0.0280508455,
0.0201247539,
0.0568101853,
-0.0134069137,
-0.0186987575,
0.0138013707,
0.0041475915,
-0.0588526987,
0.0464618504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07989v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07989v7 | Unifying the Perspectives of NLP and Software Engineering: A Survey on Language Models for Code | 2023-11-14T08:34:26 | 2024-06-26T07:11:00 | Ziyin Zhang, Chaoyu Chen, Bingchang Liu, Cong Liao, Zi Gong, Hang Yu, Jianguo Li, Rui Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE | In this work we systematically review the recent advancements in software
engineering with language models, covering 70+ models, 40+ evaluation tasks,
180+ datasets, and 900 related works. Unlike previous works, we integrate
software engineering (SE) with natural language processing (NLP) by discussing
the perspectives of both sides: SE applies language models for development
automation, while NLP adopts SE tasks for language model evaluation. We break
down code processing models into general language models represented by the GPT
family and specialized models that are specifically pretrained on code, often
with tailored objectives. We discuss the relations and differences between
these models, and highlight the historical transition of code modeling from
statistical models and RNNs to pretrained Transformers and LLMs, which is
exactly the same course that had been taken by NLP. We also go beyond
programming and review LLMs' application in other software engineering
activities including requirement engineering, testing, deployment, and
operations in an endeavor to provide a global view of NLP in SE, and identify
key challenges and potential future directions in this domain. We keep the
survey open and updated on GitHub at
https://github.com/codefuse-ai/Awesome-Code-LLM. | [
0.0533946343,
0.070386529,
-0.0452956595,
0.0330602936,
-0.004985,
-0.0050863125,
-0.0752474889,
0.0065279775,
0.0077929781,
-0.0547055304,
-0.015225566,
0.0271711163,
0.0029774758,
0.0435516313,
0.0457260795,
-0.0403379202,
0.0406287126,
-0.0351096392,
-0.0231504012,
0.0652857348,
0.0179872215,
0.0489518344,
0.0036054,
0.0912129581,
0.0107929846,
-0.0192117393,
0.0073336996,
0.0178806037,
-0.0229287222,
-0.0294663031,
0.0197482295,
0.0337789543,
-0.0014965304,
-0.0144183571,
0.0000020286,
-0.0472881235,
-0.0091410792,
-0.0068229055,
0.0071874876,
0.0115863802,
0.0134474812,
-0.0172327291,
-0.0252443831,
0.0208040159,
-0.0467473045,
-0.0080209384,
0.0720911622,
-0.0136273531,
0.0609052666,
0.053229671,
-0.0027637829,
-0.0222694576,
0.0098855924,
-0.0117242225,
0.0232418515,
-0.0434630066,
-0.0052862586,
0.0307827722,
0.0372642912,
0.0440203473,
-0.0010795941,
0.0302744489,
0.0130457766,
0.020945074,
0.0186527949,
0.0199739225,
-0.0253925696,
-0.008925477,
-0.025224233,
0.0274655856,
-0.0608298294,
-0.0293355808,
0.0176295489,
-0.0219444428,
-0.0431938618,
-0.0264261179,
-0.0186861437,
0.0214668885,
0.0183201283,
0.0224308651,
0.01900924,
-0.019221751,
0.0052101812,
-0.0182609465,
-0.007387117,
0.068047002,
0.0003364459,
0.0071432861,
-0.0027206382,
-0.0138243334,
0.0022986976,
-0.0626414791,
0.0083643002,
0.0658646747,
0.0127237532,
0.0205112491,
-0.0056624883,
-0.0286789872,
0.0434122272,
-0.0110854534,
0.0170732364,
0.0284686852,
-0.0291414261,
0.0085953865,
-0.0312237572,
0.0928779766,
-0.0002424421,
-0.002600169,
-0.0239243004,
0.0085486574,
-0.0731308684,
-0.0367584787,
-0.0558502376,
0.0297411513,
0.0149121732,
0.0244679172,
-0.0270610098,
0.0519187339,
0.0187006481,
0.0468283296,
0.0225271694,
-0.0221865103,
-0.0648629665,
0.0113156233,
-0.0062351627,
-0.0111458348,
-0.0072445315,
-0.0453619175,
-0.012073366,
-0.0438860692,
0.0044222693,
0.0251381658,
-0.0534203015,
-0.0090965135,
0.0086244354,
0.0936753079,
0.0510189459,
0.010576902,
-0.0456453636,
-0.0166421179,
0.0115349824,
0.0027890843,
-0.0234398879,
-0.0872526467,
-0.0458897799,
0.0157303549,
0.0219687205,
-0.08623413,
-0.0036920919,
0.0042904955,
0.0210512392,
0.0505309738,
-0.0549086891,
0.0359150544,
0.0223075841,
0.0123360232,
0.0276026446,
0.0498076268,
0.0603958257,
-0.0026072706,
0.0319717564,
-0.0396331362,
0.0800497979,
0.0533794984,
-0.0520206951,
-0.0295633674,
0.005958776,
0.0143137556,
0.008527902,
-0.0286228824,
0.0091182524,
0.0149149466,
0.0260993782,
0.0250117406,
-0.009344181,
0.0727397129,
0.0261490215,
0.0438302793,
0.0698183849,
0.0326397046,
-0.007861726,
-0.0366978794,
-0.0193139669,
0.0366769321,
-0.0039890311,
0.0270546526,
-0.0373279601,
0.0400070511,
0.0017509796,
-0.0845003948,
-0.0432750545,
-0.0291876346,
-0.0043630474,
-0.0112804929,
0.0321190581,
0.0193902832,
-0.0453120619,
0.0474560857,
-0.0034353358,
-0.0413860567,
-0.0048810714,
-0.055646006,
-0.0116739012,
0.0351643264,
0.0630418956,
-0.0830099657,
-0.0530190729,
-0.0060807718,
-0.0561049543,
-0.0095240166,
0.0348467566,
-0.0177289117,
-0.0015028495,
-0.0438353606,
-0.0186014008,
-0.0343658216,
0.0100254714,
0.0229190085,
0.0269640107,
-0.0166629516,
0.0367221683,
-0.0329582058,
-0.0758845657,
0.0607316531,
-0.0405009799,
-0.0151879638,
0.0134149576,
-0.0151050165,
0.0186859798,
-0.0127235781,
-0.0293733012,
0.0035151886,
0.025788106,
0.0007714883,
-0.0133655323,
0.0008058172,
0.0055524926,
-0.014950823,
0.016795123,
-0.0439843945,
-0.0173702687,
0.0368180759,
-0.0437129326,
-0.0034385708,
0.0461638942,
-0.0180077311,
0.0096950242,
0.0306291003,
0.0097121904,
-0.0125384694,
-0.0222699288,
-0.0552882701,
0.0175272487,
0.0202629194,
0.0175030977,
-0.0059961975,
0.0471579693,
0.0436080694,
0.0065639694,
-0.0600499436,
0.0326300859,
-0.027107222,
0.0419196859,
0.0371372178,
0.0741735399,
-0.0384275094,
-0.0540998317,
-0.064002648,
0.0338872485,
-0.0090019125,
0.0315919146,
0.0118779065,
0.0287875123,
-0.0151786525,
-0.0187994391,
-0.013419468,
-0.0423987135,
-0.0262216069,
-0.0350734144,
0.0505156554,
-0.0171009805,
-0.0421998315,
-0.0505283624,
-0.0020745485,
-0.0504693836,
0.0321491025,
-0.0188959111,
-0.0194604825,
-0.0898358673,
0.0844397321,
-0.0037765447,
0.0155491801,
-0.0133499643,
-0.0574588627,
0.018699171,
-0.0124098305,
0.0738281608,
0.026305588,
-0.0244887769,
-0.0040051122,
0.031908799,
-0.0098282639,
-0.040096648,
0.0075146914,
0.0176467653,
-0.0590883382,
-0.0060442956,
-0.0356540307,
0.0713853091,
0.0904719681,
-0.0124271549,
-0.0270805601,
-0.0394869633,
-0.0077335029,
-0.0366712101,
0.037774805,
0.0330411531,
-0.0343884043,
0.0021735043,
0.0505063385,
-0.0067395335,
-0.0710241124,
0.0757709295,
-0.0500729382,
-0.0225287527,
-0.0754938051,
-0.032814689,
-0.058547996,
0.0703485534,
-0.0070569087,
0.0021883906,
0.0213928316,
-0.0370506048,
-0.0166993532,
-0.0015371941,
-0.0476008914,
-0.0233842134,
0.0659136698,
-0.0711847246,
0.0155788194,
-0.0078620063,
0.0126717435,
-0.0331760384,
0.0173997488,
-0.0396478288,
0.0135271819,
0.0112640848,
0.0186212361,
0.0163624566,
0.0247298665,
-0.0070101446,
0.0362750702,
0.05066083,
-0.0481257997,
-0.0350306034,
-0.0493309125,
0.0087568657,
-0.027852701,
-0.0119856177,
0.0325078443,
-0.0163409188,
0.0047174729,
0.061491251,
0.0496027134,
-0.078564696,
0.0025145989,
0.0256424695,
-0.0526573546,
-0.0269502942,
0.0570182651,
0.043073263,
-0.0497265756,
-0.0098168058,
0.1031430885,
0.0453505218,
-0.0237583145,
0.0124953939,
0.0349557102,
0.0255544633,
0.0893299952,
0.0308677386,
-0.0657858029,
-0.0373518169,
-0.009923514,
0.0132354917,
-0.0004865449,
0.0038533513,
-0.0299543031,
-0.0747869387,
0.0043452578,
-0.0046671322,
-0.0110370573,
-0.0441011079,
-0.0287401881,
-0.0127320159,
-0.0235455763,
-0.0294745825,
-0.0111469971,
-0.0143511072,
0.0324563682,
0.0140994834,
-0.0753364265,
-0.0050132698,
0.0367380679,
-0.0462913141,
0.0462628491,
0.116383478,
0.0078413868,
0.0007975106,
0.0003882333,
0.0544182174,
-0.0393197164,
0.035883747,
-0.0153808743,
0.0137506239,
-0.0044671716,
-0.0344301909,
0.0503905229,
-0.0163270347,
-0.1090430543,
-0.0208993088,
0.0471364893,
0.0618840195,
-0.0200906359,
-0.0001569759,
-0.0326322354,
0.0080161272,
-0.0099028153,
0.0194619838,
0.0553321429,
-0.0163772628,
-0.0372933745,
-0.0731198117,
0.0381843969,
-0.0482888892,
-0.0797702596,
-0.0060910988,
0.0132090086,
-0.0026635258,
-0.042646464,
-0.0270552561,
0.0139894681,
0.0110779246,
0.0500282384,
-0.0063148448,
0.0525681041,
-0.000612085,
-0.0272033568,
0.0384690911,
-0.0126859788,
0.0019806563,
-0.0368133821,
-0.0295439996,
0.0400924832,
-0.0031734875,
-0.0264483262,
0.0115001379,
-0.1045315489,
-0.0286472067,
-0.0283835214,
0.0724693239,
0.0211088229,
-0.0093126427,
-0.0591861084,
-0.0749476254,
-0.0548154749,
0.0210328288,
-0.0459017716,
-0.0088043818,
0.028058039,
0.0163679905,
0.0173383579,
-0.0065086139,
-0.0525869951,
0.0232534967,
0.0022468136,
0.0034628315,
-0.008715733,
-0.0111008584,
0.0297488254,
0.0208186917,
0.0311260056,
0.0167807005,
-0.0076503535,
-0.0103693483,
-0.0311392229,
0.0312109776,
-0.0206211824,
-0.0551061258,
0.0433632545,
-0.0067083174,
-0.0160389841,
0.0127051976,
0.0078534465,
-0.063361302,
0.0421095118,
0.0112235574,
0.063946262,
0.0379799791,
0.0253811199,
0.0086738076,
-0.000334464,
-0.0118956314,
0.0137044713,
-0.0238906834,
0.0170848612,
-0.005304188,
0.0392287411,
0.0080320351,
0.0369062237,
0.015233567,
0.0377052985,
-0.0291434377,
-0.0522116683,
0.0000771797,
-0.0122270761,
0.014806971,
0.0288637225,
0.0178360175,
-0.0334335901,
0.0425623544,
-0.0175434276,
0.0690255389,
0.0023960972,
-0.0127583649,
0.0094996979,
0.0180584397,
-0.0270464402,
-0.0557237975,
0.0796344802,
-0.0107065113,
0.0026388585,
0.0044638463,
-0.0281290356,
-0.0297437478,
0.0265925676,
0.0464626737,
-0.0380447768,
-0.0172484443,
0.0119220773,
-0.0332118459,
-0.063011907,
0.0097021703,
0.0242348742,
0.0449566208,
-0.0245798882,
0.0255573802,
0.1095333993,
0.0048450432,
-0.0090471264,
-0.0111884866,
-0.0242358595,
0.0294610821,
-0.0309474468,
-0.0614078715,
-5.472619745e-33,
-0.0200549047,
-0.0379257128,
0.0274837706,
0.0166470762,
-0.0039921394,
0.0112617807,
-0.0439461544,
-0.010283648,
-0.0135557,
-0.0486399122,
0.0200936235,
0.0278423633,
-0.0289794169,
-0.0331971049,
0.058447998,
-0.0053563383,
0.0177376065,
0.0182457007,
-0.0430872478,
0.031841144,
-0.056269791,
0.0069632712,
0.0652562976,
-0.0465847068,
0.0235977806,
0.0049323202,
0.017503351,
-0.0115532326,
0.036533799,
0.0524745323,
-0.0283741262,
0.0238600578,
0.0228188969,
-0.0493793041,
-0.0432845131,
-0.0313112885,
-0.0096323472,
-0.0529374965,
0.0162870027,
0.0014423274,
0.0168893561,
-0.048358161,
0.0784839094,
-0.012974794,
-0.0320678726,
0.0290180072,
0.0644712299,
0.0072137881,
0.0370718315,
-0.0148657542,
-0.0725984722,
0.0466121621,
-0.06503959,
-0.0046967361,
0.0182206724,
0.0176141318,
0.000535341,
0.0693904012,
0.0073111397,
-0.0179009419,
0.0246150345,
0.0751496777,
0.0666450411,
-0.0216737166,
-0.0155927818,
0.0104397368,
-0.0061561838,
0.0175824407,
-0.025433911,
-0.003527425,
0.059732426,
0.0361652598,
0.0209114831,
-0.0125544351,
0.0220615435,
-0.005848872,
-0.0262785628,
0.0385631472,
-0.0154344225,
0.0295575578,
0.0107968068,
0.0428735092,
-0.0420430563,
0.0012763386,
-0.034997005,
-0.0225086864,
-0.0092893057,
-0.0329744816,
0.0413738936,
-0.0175027903,
-0.0219739564,
0.0359408446,
-0.0086641358,
-0.0627574176,
-0.0013733961,
0.0005576817,
-0.0368981399,
0.0306813028,
-0.0179479811,
0.0497556552,
-0.0062418571,
-0.0042043836,
0.020164514,
0.0192080326,
0.078652665,
-0.0226563439,
-0.0094412975,
0.0322712809,
-0.0546757318,
0.0035894972,
-0.0340996049,
-0.0067734672,
-0.0231206194,
0.0437912196,
-0.0184489023,
0.0064529926,
0.0093917241,
0.0286516212,
0.0039909203,
-0.0625199005,
-0.0463764258,
0.0394521616,
0.0062782099,
0.0185673703,
-0.0302424971,
-0.0418783017,
-0.0301288776,
0.0229885392,
0.0144522926,
-0.0103658922,
-0.0570560805,
0.0311774891,
2.66e-7,
0.0471965224,
0.0243808813,
0.0224532634,
0.0294489656,
-0.0034630129,
0.0305077545,
-0.024500208,
-0.0191299878,
0.0407451317,
0.0076782196,
-0.0444597118,
0.0205541309,
0.0245580152,
0.0134773105,
-0.0617774837,
0.0169573091,
0.0033704098,
0.0199203975,
-0.0743304715,
0.0266393293,
0.0531207956,
0.07690835,
-0.0048313839,
0.0259152818,
-0.0280202981,
-0.0387878083,
-0.0303146262,
-0.0257646516,
0.0503078587,
0.0892599151,
-0.0194229726,
0.0444910191,
0.0034741648,
-0.0124878213,
-0.0169270784,
-0.0169783551,
0.0250838585,
0.0541270562,
-0.0209513623,
0.0098032802,
0.0293093175,
-0.0041413642,
0.0062348954,
-0.0794621259,
0.0300238598,
-0.0266661439,
0.0056670359,
-0.0182752945,
-0.0086062644,
0.0015306917,
-0.0199936312,
-0.0089203594,
-0.0033471338,
0.025674602,
0.0115832034,
-0.0264617894,
-0.0462597683,
-0.069582127,
-0.0214222819,
0.02918447,
-0.0142572979,
-0.0232120603,
-0.0584861524,
0.0226666909,
0.0095260916,
-0.0342413187,
0.0193126053,
2.720125611e-34,
0.0178786237,
-0.0381603427,
0.0170753188,
0.0402268954,
0.0635232404,
0.0028478042,
-0.0264983699,
0.0222346094,
-0.0257001389,
-0.0145994779,
-0.0316470489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07978v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07978v2 | How good are Large Language Models on African Languages? | 2023-11-14T08:10:14 | 2024-04-30T16:04:16 | Jessica Ojo, Kelechi Ogueji, Pontus Stenetorp, David Ifeoluwa Adelani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent advancements in natural language processing have led to the
proliferation of large language models (LLMs). These models have been shown to
yield good performance, using in-context learning, even on tasks and languages
they are not trained on. However, their performance on African languages is
largely understudied relative to high-resource languages. We present an
analysis of four popular large language models (mT0, Aya, LLaMa 2, and GPT-4)
on six tasks (topic classification, sentiment classification, machine
translation, summarization, question answering, and named entity recognition)
across 60 African languages, spanning different language families and
geographical regions. Our results suggest that all LLMs produce lower
performance for African languages, and there is a large gap in performance
compared to high-resource languages (such as English) for most tasks. We find
that GPT-4 has an average to good performance on classification tasks, yet its
performance on generative tasks such as machine translation and summarization
is significantly lacking. Surprisingly, we find that mT0 had the best overall
performance for cross-lingual QA, better than the state-of-the-art supervised
model (i.e. fine-tuned mT5) and GPT-4 on African languages. Similarly, we find
the recent Aya model to have comparable result to mT0 in almost all tasks
except for topic classification where it outperform mT0. Overall, LLaMa 2
showed the worst performance, which we believe is due to its English and
code-centric~(around 98%) pre-training corpus. Our findings confirms that
performance on African languages continues to remain a hurdle for the current
LLMs, underscoring the need for additional efforts to close this gap. | [
0.0918460041,
0.0548901968,
0.022119863,
0.0433003232,
0.0201268457,
0.0496077612,
0.0256298836,
-0.0388480648,
-0.0128925471,
-0.0476655066,
-0.0448650941,
-0.0971092507,
0.0444165729,
-0.0061684786,
0.0174120609,
-0.0541660935,
0.0164722446,
-0.0264056996,
0.0036366037,
-0.0213796496,
-0.0076512634,
0.047970809,
0.0352916531,
0.0343662687,
0.028385561,
-0.0022013737,
0.0006433654,
-0.0269049183,
-0.0013517813,
0.0124222552,
-0.0087613892,
0.0408220328,
-0.0276797675,
0.0401408598,
0.0000019919,
-0.0657860488,
0.0177938361,
-0.0202003568,
-0.000140507,
0.0796244144,
0.0436203964,
-0.021527946,
-0.0160585623,
0.0479151234,
-0.0362819247,
-0.0227642264,
0.0498664379,
0.025180677,
0.0493863896,
0.0750301257,
0.0167786665,
-0.0388891771,
0.0895282328,
-0.0560018569,
-0.0269113872,
-0.047605969,
0.0232445151,
0.0176866017,
-0.0026221434,
0.0367917977,
-0.0136810727,
0.0169798564,
0.0081141395,
-0.0072043366,
-0.0028014933,
0.0183888376,
-0.0402901098,
-0.0446890555,
-0.0067102839,
0.0232544355,
-0.0139993196,
-0.0142956655,
-0.0178113431,
0.030686751,
-0.0334332883,
-0.0103309462,
-0.0383401103,
0.066812627,
0.0044119698,
0.0423537344,
0.0381580815,
-0.0001702561,
0.0537529364,
0.0227903128,
-0.0471813641,
0.0222010091,
0.0098274676,
0.0187392458,
0.011494725,
0.0473218858,
-0.0533026494,
-0.0494779274,
-0.0132111385,
-0.0063196649,
0.0058952891,
-0.030067103,
0.0154782403,
-0.0076040905,
0.0396218561,
-0.0622793138,
0.0137142409,
0.0239074994,
-0.0197284725,
0.0484695025,
-0.0360675566,
0.0364759676,
-0.0392108187,
-0.0050788773,
-0.0364829265,
-0.0466880351,
-0.0303678885,
-0.044293873,
0.0014614649,
0.0255304277,
-0.0485112965,
0.0204439666,
-0.0689569637,
0.0156282354,
0.0095487731,
-0.0327903479,
-0.0131618017,
-0.0221848246,
0.0048290147,
-0.0176533014,
-0.0039808615,
0.0373145044,
-0.0104518579,
0.0331318565,
-0.0259472765,
-0.0921770409,
0.0425215177,
-0.0284511764,
-0.0347312354,
0.0195538718,
0.0383206829,
0.0373214409,
-0.0139715858,
-0.0688117966,
-0.061428871,
0.0150520075,
-0.0289393943,
-0.0515799373,
-0.0518612191,
-0.0746579096,
0.0188107286,
0.0282572266,
0.0443594195,
0.0087555498,
0.0055522914,
0.0045393743,
0.0066152555,
0.0452758372,
0.0152604301,
0.0149350511,
0.0991743281,
0.0177059565,
0.0748617202,
0.0678476021,
0.0209926255,
0.0115982369,
0.0192364939,
0.018339524,
-0.0513142236,
0.0441706702,
-0.0062937518,
0.0028375564,
0.0009862495,
0.0308977477,
0.0205442719,
-0.0159903169,
0.0453947522,
0.0398520902,
0.0134335896,
0.007248017,
0.0552914478,
0.0400141999,
-0.0273552462,
0.0525451042,
0.0186672304,
-0.012850049,
0.0097059123,
-0.0322500803,
-0.0039165984,
0.0087239118,
-0.0265545994,
-0.0265739225,
0.0885436162,
0.055385381,
-0.0367841013,
-0.0390756615,
0.0090080341,
-0.0229709204,
0.0060596205,
0.0367227495,
0.0359455682,
-0.035444241,
0.0061553665,
-0.0037191149,
0.0679034144,
-0.0539036207,
-0.0060692295,
-0.0541837811,
0.0726219937,
0.0278536305,
-0.0195549466,
0.023215998,
-0.0018383862,
-0.0258033145,
0.0197916236,
0.0392246805,
0.0461982153,
-0.0227840021,
0.01396323,
-0.0219784807,
0.0191000272,
-0.0243247151,
-0.0058106352,
0.0424380489,
0.0230836794,
0.0632848665,
0.022877153,
-0.0288638249,
-0.0191141069,
0.0136232749,
-0.0415590666,
-0.0000838061,
0.0203200355,
0.0038793625,
0.0720808133,
0.028696036,
-0.0033605762,
0.00323324,
-0.0180727076,
-0.0770426318,
-0.0297279619,
0.0135261044,
-0.0535154603,
-0.0167884398,
0.0269006472,
-0.0141372019,
0.0180242881,
0.0403718129,
-0.0033184309,
-0.0379070118,
0.0426715836,
-0.0162344929,
0.0291653685,
-0.0572032779,
0.0204039998,
-0.0277863853,
0.0148828663,
-0.015184273,
0.0579543486,
0.0078982161,
0.0158089865,
0.0103745628,
-0.01129732,
0.0472846366,
0.0081812255,
-0.0168185327,
0.0633685663,
0.0197307672,
-0.0052073481,
0.0254780483,
0.0097758295,
-0.0224539358,
-0.0173856057,
-0.1478094012,
0.0356551073,
-0.0332466997,
0.0283132866,
0.0088241464,
0.0787022561,
-0.0165006667,
0.0191626735,
-0.0160882063,
-0.0415388606,
0.0144393621,
0.0146319596,
-0.0218887143,
0.0109541407,
0.0057028416,
-0.0503557064,
-0.0073972107,
0.0439299345,
0.0468393154,
-0.0096572433,
-0.0228960812,
-0.0294057038,
0.03528402,
-0.0231975671,
-0.0234613512,
-0.0085714022,
-0.0338288099,
-0.0342093706,
-0.0261208508,
0.0325905979,
0.0232082084,
0.0157646462,
-0.0021039238,
0.0367224738,
0.0244614724,
-0.0303745139,
-0.0093802446,
-0.0251885522,
-0.0357274674,
0.0045451089,
-0.0212047864,
-0.000373345,
0.09185756,
0.0235976819,
0.0102773961,
-0.0389861874,
-0.013812351,
-0.0343888924,
-0.0063958694,
-0.0189325344,
-0.0013603446,
0.0160350539,
0.0396981314,
-0.0506659634,
-0.0219810195,
0.0627809837,
-0.0036412035,
-0.0120014064,
-0.0515668094,
-0.0232647248,
-0.0642370656,
0.0358439982,
-0.0009325242,
0.0130772516,
-0.0214047655,
-0.029015271,
-0.0162305813,
0.0041750385,
0.0358895026,
-0.0097173592,
0.0510293394,
-0.0382247418,
0.0324327126,
-0.0264333393,
-0.067648299,
0.0107622957,
-0.0508868024,
-0.0522871614,
0.0061433013,
0.0214178711,
0.0024838692,
0.0047571822,
0.0305045545,
0.0362647176,
-0.0024191698,
-0.0020417396,
-0.0090869544,
0.0245086588,
0.0559250973,
0.0008541381,
-0.015333781,
0.0044385679,
-0.0352109075,
0.0163752176,
0.0172217265,
-0.0101325037,
-0.0056310329,
-0.0245706365,
-0.0320373215,
0.0342717208,
-0.0322463512,
-0.0646376908,
0.0086271754,
0.0460081175,
-0.0148319071,
0.0031517744,
0.1029546186,
0.0347487368,
-0.0138794668,
0.0052455943,
-0.0396496877,
0.0185694899,
-0.0078097843,
0.0028311617,
-0.0743238404,
-0.038745489,
-0.0336637124,
0.0032227063,
-0.0044932589,
0.0053466125,
0.0060969698,
-0.1352411956,
0.0146160126,
-0.0003340425,
-0.0545305498,
-0.0317895412,
-0.0539870448,
-0.0373616815,
-0.0231744889,
0.0017831464,
-0.0060274978,
-0.0149558829,
0.010737773,
0.0486097783,
-0.0229517482,
-0.0570526868,
0.0210811049,
-0.0235032178,
0.0229763482,
0.0622283444,
-0.0027384756,
-0.0360319726,
0.0360257998,
0.0171797033,
-0.0414322056,
-0.0066934195,
-0.0360867307,
0.0104310755,
0.0361475199,
-0.0250959005,
-0.0223576669,
0.0079604248,
-0.0170337241,
0.0238117222,
-0.0173534658,
0.0510229766,
-0.0038467173,
-0.0221806373,
-0.0345363431,
-0.0135249654,
-0.0189689044,
0.0516081378,
0.0435032994,
-0.0584389195,
-0.0546715595,
-0.0018462645,
0.0144815389,
-0.0328324102,
-0.0219924208,
0.0085113747,
0.0023349109,
-0.0354183875,
-0.0510435179,
-0.0727346465,
-0.000712456,
-0.0565737821,
0.0001517415,
0.0229317266,
0.0044911462,
0.0000478441,
-0.0363671184,
0.0330474712,
-0.0179750025,
0.0125742853,
-0.0468717478,
-0.0019956138,
0.0701151192,
-0.0295764301,
-0.0065927859,
-0.0066638538,
-0.1164998934,
-0.0721946508,
-0.0112087289,
0.0121404827,
0.0150026502,
0.0148946382,
0.0410312973,
-0.0734139755,
0.0064432994,
-0.003721148,
-0.0205472969,
0.0308708809,
-0.0079612667,
0.0618523546,
-0.0032413229,
0.0480022244,
-0.0213609096,
0.0542670228,
0.014670305,
0.0118696596,
-0.0530062467,
-0.0281202365,
-0.0382773876,
-0.0317968167,
0.0272282958,
-0.0359249264,
-0.0621862337,
-0.0433867425,
0.0031519057,
0.0280724801,
0.0147642652,
-0.0146088647,
-0.0161601957,
0.0432278439,
0.0028352304,
-0.0342756435,
0.0338735133,
-0.0037637386,
0.0132892029,
-0.0241782162,
0.0478915423,
0.0195765886,
-0.0250424799,
0.0076217633,
0.0341504626,
-0.0279656593,
0.0076353108,
0.0188353732,
0.039865464,
-0.0328478739,
0.0207501128,
-0.0182178821,
0.0036697269,
0.0209851675,
0.0047952658,
-0.0565459095,
-0.0003782279,
-0.0278314035,
0.0472212397,
0.0971802473,
-0.0233175326,
0.0561768375,
0.0156851113,
-0.0193877909,
-0.0334707126,
0.015303771,
-0.008121198,
-0.033202108,
0.04029027,
-0.0145245567,
-0.0071858102,
0.0416958146,
0.0927229375,
0.0064047384,
0.029780427,
0.0381874703,
0.02016012,
-0.0250031017,
-0.0193679277,
0.0176449958,
-0.0330814607,
-0.0109576667,
0.0565214828,
-0.0375788733,
-0.0426312536,
0.016470572,
-0.0463831089,
-0.0068898564,
-0.018644914,
0.0340533853,
0.0448126569,
0.0018428589,
0.0083254427,
-0.0609674305,
-0.0127130654,
-0.0210954919,
0.0050247731,
0.0017627929,
-6.350650107e-33,
-0.0066250376,
0.0298974775,
-0.0123212403,
-0.0096077994,
-0.0058166576,
-0.0008521952,
-0.0425164625,
0.0227962285,
-0.0502221547,
-0.0084748175,
-0.0250736196,
0.0192998871,
0.0079600951,
0.0581025854,
0.0295852125,
0.0203278437,
0.0428117402,
0.0065888818,
-0.0264426433,
0.034171477,
0.0333347879,
0.0441668779,
0.0480994098,
-0.0231245272,
0.0335820355,
-0.0428261757,
-0.0133478902,
-0.0167412013,
0.0248025246,
0.0470220968,
-0.0311260279,
0.0424888879,
0.0357606485,
-0.0417208821,
0.0077125328,
0.0375077315,
-0.0822978392,
-0.0187095981,
0.0428408459,
-0.0044290232,
-0.0158466231,
-0.0780215412,
0.0337220803,
0.0074838512,
-0.0242887866,
-0.0102280807,
0.0227511637,
-0.0478040315,
-0.0273299925,
-0.0680758581,
-0.0557984002,
0.0443927124,
-0.0053830692,
0.000636321,
0.007845941,
0.0075856918,
-0.0459204465,
0.0307155456,
-0.0383055657,
0.0002984488,
0.0312356278,
0.0444028415,
0.0303517021,
0.0381887071,
-0.0479231216,
0.0367009267,
-0.001917159,
-0.0188118163,
-0.0017613521,
0.0047745644,
0.0100130308,
-0.0425755605,
0.0127248988,
0.0422944389,
0.0289812293,
-0.0194958784,
-0.0929994881,
0.0277640801,
0.0031490487,
0.0239206739,
0.0265363753,
-0.0269674249,
-0.037880227,
-0.0442399941,
-0.0302364528,
0.0092898384,
-0.0252992604,
-0.0081267646,
0.0540254749,
-0.0126149347,
0.0136531098,
0.003295827,
0.0247644447,
-0.029160019,
-0.017312292,
0.0149604501,
-0.0119909588,
0.0190776587,
0.0242484063,
0.0330071487,
-0.0959086344,
0.0237050503,
-0.03858741,
0.0064779087,
-0.034844391,
-0.0079548331,
0.0273306146,
-0.0101169189,
-0.0953392535,
0.0317251533,
-0.0016919567,
0.0406689979,
-0.0234008525,
0.0709778965,
0.0014290594,
-0.0055557908,
0.0222411621,
0.0555806421,
0.0097850021,
0.0122449333,
0.0012471344,
-0.0171873383,
-0.0046469355,
0.0040683229,
-0.0394977629,
0.0186121203,
-0.0115107605,
0.0712627694,
-0.0063845455,
-0.0343552083,
-0.008623722,
0.0177829619,
2.542e-7,
0.0327671394,
0.0188210979,
0.0173392892,
-0.0292750616,
-0.0091500552,
0.0358206816,
0.0260601044,
-0.0169167779,
0.0355089381,
0.0512301438,
-0.0139913959,
0.0279204994,
0.0738827661,
0.0222414248,
-0.0776344538,
0.0354448631,
-0.054514505,
0.0100508276,
-0.0496662036,
-0.0274539478,
-0.0049126064,
0.1757507324,
-0.0253815595,
-0.0374010131,
-0.0801827908,
-0.0476561263,
0.1058824584,
-0.0298757087,
-0.0517090708,
0.018429812,
0.0138901938,
0.0933049321,
-0.0183473434,
-0.010236579,
-0.040401645,
0.015725838,
0.0182486381,
0.0656056255,
0.0041649486,
0.0233144257,
0.030803781,
-0.0025498881,
-0.0195766017,
-0.0563083552,
0.0852232277,
-0.0198101047,
-0.0631363019,
-0.029489696,
-0.0089006256,
-0.0346568562,
0.0254195593,
-0.0444099456,
-0.0043700053,
0.0018489633,
-0.0089118918,
-0.0848943591,
-0.0110762091,
-0.045200333,
-0.0123965694,
0.0140977614,
-0.011248407,
-0.0183780808,
0.0081224563,
0.025121944,
0.0184474103,
-0.0289830603,
0.0423147529,
2.134119407e-34,
0.0464467406,
-0.0195330065,
0.0093710925,
0.0135087166,
-0.0253451243,
0.0077959634,
-0.0097627537,
-0.0151780518,
0.0024020544,
-0.0353615768,
0.0203798395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10760v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10760v1 | Non-Parametric Memory Guidance for Multi-Document Summarization | 2023-11-14T07:41:48 | 2023-11-14T07:41:48 | Florian Baud, Alex Aussem | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-document summarization (MDS) is a difficult task in Natural Language
Processing, aiming to summarize information from several documents. However,
the source documents are often insufficient to obtain a qualitative summary. We
propose a retriever-guided model combined with non-parametric memory for
summary generation. This model retrieves relevant candidates from a database
and then generates the summary considering the candidates with a copy mechanism
and the source documents. The retriever is implemented with Approximate Nearest
Neighbor Search (ANN) to search large databases. Our method is evaluated on the
MultiXScience dataset which includes scientific articles. Finally, we discuss
our results and possible directions for future work. | [
0.0603647232,
0.0247558672,
0.0252039172,
-0.0189207084,
-0.0203332026,
-0.0089677069,
-0.0458157733,
-0.0040325955,
-0.0257991701,
-0.039600309,
-0.0389389619,
-0.0217671636,
0.0022330866,
-0.043886587,
0.0054296958,
-0.0674211308,
0.0336039662,
-0.0146954739,
0.0327676944,
-0.0057392223,
0.0031005985,
-0.0111110797,
0.0289230403,
-0.0110958321,
0.0352815799,
-0.000981534,
-0.0138635542,
0.0097153326,
0.0403147005,
-0.0407134891,
0.0093451748,
-0.0165662747,
0.0068252273,
-0.0140936999,
0.0000018667,
-0.0351236388,
-0.0535817072,
0.0280395746,
0.0464251526,
0.0123818852,
0.0715419427,
-0.0617623217,
0.0312828571,
0.0099700326,
0.0169577692,
-0.0023569122,
0.0323496722,
0.0381678566,
0.0715155974,
0.0500997938,
-0.0068640322,
-0.0545502901,
0.029411627,
0.014252414,
0.0105058225,
-0.0276885778,
0.0334341303,
0.0089599602,
0.02851386,
0.0154415537,
0.0089671779,
0.0400238968,
-0.0346336439,
-0.0108162649,
-0.00268006,
0.0379416794,
-0.0320405029,
-0.0037871925,
0.0227124766,
0.0618460551,
-0.0158037767,
-0.0071622115,
0.072335355,
0.0062091006,
-0.0323107131,
0.048499655,
-0.0817264989,
0.0809411481,
-0.0454388261,
-0.0133665418,
-0.0290561616,
0.0390870869,
-0.0055392981,
0.0341903605,
-0.015637638,
-0.0133494847,
0.0158249084,
-0.0499365851,
-0.0196826383,
-0.0260250736,
-0.0037851646,
0.0019729948,
0.0490540937,
0.0392141417,
-0.0083971964,
0.0185627826,
-0.0316800177,
-0.081326507,
0.0587311126,
-0.0743013248,
0.0210766774,
0.0034390853,
0.0172918215,
0.0409691967,
-0.0231180247,
-0.0134019079,
-0.0209180657,
-0.0110617075,
-0.0580494218,
-0.0529343821,
-0.0602215677,
-0.0131371478,
-0.0219651069,
0.0784240514,
-0.0092691993,
-0.0115797622,
-0.0280903094,
0.020340804,
0.0180348177,
-0.0183517803,
0.0146564748,
0.0366419964,
-0.04610103,
0.0119652012,
-0.0185737573,
0.0189401954,
-0.0266398098,
-0.0660880134,
0.0115708942,
0.0110860467,
-0.0393723324,
0.0297576357,
0.0532143675,
-0.0170359109,
0.0080571352,
0.0425462946,
-0.0105711976,
-0.0598048978,
-0.0398438722,
-0.0513325445,
-0.0109492857,
-0.0584980324,
0.0247481838,
-0.0605130829,
0.0581232347,
0.0005608064,
-0.0408973359,
0.0011318377,
-0.0014548482,
0.0430821329,
-0.05986166,
0.0060360008,
-0.0084546395,
-0.0235143509,
0.0523304828,
0.0011422138,
0.0420287363,
0.0539644063,
0.0158860181,
0.0195131898,
0.0295275468,
0.0149785811,
-0.0185501985,
-0.0551955067,
0.0417942889,
-0.0150294155,
0.002651907,
0.006843233,
-0.039801944,
0.0111911464,
0.0314446054,
0.0479866564,
-0.0441740379,
0.014428366,
0.0260031894,
0.0692236647,
0.018781729,
0.0231976621,
0.0164651908,
0.0229813103,
-0.0023823488,
0.0356675535,
0.011707522,
0.0842773616,
-0.0365914479,
0.0766846389,
0.1169589311,
0.0311112646,
-0.0424488075,
-0.0200388487,
0.0137373609,
0.0004492379,
-0.0225218292,
-0.0098461648,
0.0453684293,
0.0138719091,
-0.0328958072,
0.0855832174,
0.0122099798,
-0.0442955866,
0.0130418828,
0.0189145785,
-0.0114093367,
0.0014273832,
0.0349886082,
-0.077322714,
-0.0189312659,
0.0184979998,
-0.0106930919,
0.0333366282,
0.0249771141,
0.0017113793,
-0.0050800913,
-0.072371833,
-0.029799778,
-0.0332542993,
-0.0184471849,
0.0149623565,
0.0045027053,
0.0044910638,
0.064972572,
-0.0198098626,
-0.0372906104,
-0.0084074428,
-0.020664854,
-0.0018851939,
0.0165396929,
-0.0446426123,
0.0235076956,
0.0330966637,
-0.0247561019,
0.0518988147,
0.0562702008,
-0.0189130176,
-0.0470514335,
-0.0128596434,
-0.0246581342,
-0.0312885307,
0.0077316524,
-0.0655395612,
0.055061765,
-0.0135447048,
-0.0247267149,
-0.0908039212,
0.0614625104,
-0.051791247,
0.0123716379,
-0.0322441608,
0.0004814561,
0.0247630626,
0.0017710101,
-0.020385107,
0.08150886,
-0.0098022521,
0.0437413715,
0.0604311936,
-0.0323162302,
0.0142807495,
-0.0488721952,
-0.0156747699,
0.0095337359,
0.0030688895,
0.0128830317,
0.0717335343,
-0.0268096458,
-0.0154116098,
-0.0424172021,
-0.0729919672,
0.0215279069,
0.007042638,
0.0007224138,
0.0446851365,
0.0399088524,
0.0300074816,
-0.0101838252,
-0.0230584107,
-0.02913877,
0.006032493,
0.0206690971,
0.0378713645,
0.0353182927,
0.0254519656,
-0.0537968799,
-0.0422547311,
-0.0181224477,
0.0367991664,
-0.0070337555,
-0.0424286872,
-0.0309482515,
0.0214880686,
-0.0556306876,
-0.0104399649,
0.0024505884,
0.0380173586,
-0.012620098,
-0.0317892358,
0.0299240276,
0.0583095215,
0.0304401964,
-0.0223790854,
0.0627995059,
0.00223164,
-0.0523727238,
-0.0027804347,
-0.0347275883,
0.0241681412,
0.0611104853,
-0.0207704119,
0.0462148823,
0.0428494811,
0.0336663425,
-0.0139397075,
-0.0013102833,
0.0294467509,
0.0029697607,
-0.0023061119,
-0.0552030094,
0.0131367641,
0.0134842088,
0.0186151695,
-0.0062800231,
-0.0051269466,
0.0687553212,
-0.0135071445,
0.017520858,
-0.0628946796,
0.0097914627,
-0.058647003,
0.0205521956,
0.0113845272,
0.0423632301,
-0.0152561283,
-0.0136001678,
0.0081834048,
-0.0400962122,
0.045021046,
-0.0052971384,
0.0501323529,
-0.0548170954,
0.0301947836,
-0.0191800594,
0.0085973069,
0.01100682,
-0.0151726417,
0.0366511345,
0.024082372,
0.0146863842,
-0.0040215715,
-0.0689829662,
0.010693253,
0.0814723745,
0.073367998,
-0.048279129,
-0.0358992182,
-0.0223359223,
0.0454325713,
0.0688706636,
-0.0356448479,
0.0033577243,
-0.0268457588,
0.0122414734,
0.076870732,
0.0285819732,
-0.0125400294,
0.0088869873,
-0.0191957261,
-0.0196199007,
-0.0638865232,
-0.0126073435,
-0.0290411524,
-0.01860388,
-0.0257885735,
-0.0297181141,
0.0843120292,
0.0294732731,
-0.0572003536,
-0.0163566675,
0.0019777047,
0.0068117343,
0.0250012837,
0.0303898752,
-0.020962242,
0.0102222916,
-0.0469832793,
0.0387182981,
0.00331115,
-0.046199128,
-0.0372487046,
-0.0409928747,
-0.0004219324,
0.0048888833,
-0.0690167919,
-0.0337463245,
-0.047665596,
-0.0435484797,
-0.0006205788,
-0.0195230581,
0.0570701174,
-0.033688046,
-0.0208599363,
-0.0042833532,
-0.0243355948,
-0.0009540489,
-0.0192078874,
-0.0243198276,
-0.0318492837,
0.0242608711,
0.0378770605,
0.0255274102,
0.0466940925,
0.0031427676,
-0.0491764098,
0.0237204563,
-0.0120008579,
0.0552536771,
0.0016114201,
0.0095927659,
-0.0180959627,
0.0253535397,
-0.0197774731,
-0.0043569701,
0.0219717156,
0.0293872189,
-0.0144492388,
-0.0149979806,
-0.0824211761,
0.0139494576,
-0.0360171832,
0.0550569519,
-0.0059847017,
0.0071648574,
-0.0344111137,
0.0058935247,
-0.0103086149,
-0.0284608491,
0.0035338376,
-0.0206134152,
-0.0633454993,
-0.0073418869,
-0.0811140984,
-0.0298895128,
0.0074297772,
0.0181655623,
-0.018159613,
-0.005763052,
0.0273279585,
-0.004128777,
-0.011001084,
0.0039516981,
-0.0133668734,
-0.0411856659,
0.0015955404,
-0.0216140784,
0.1158066466,
-0.006249507,
-0.009568247,
-0.0077655162,
-0.0240889024,
-0.0426919945,
-0.06720604,
0.0466688313,
0.022459114,
0.0694002733,
0.0242920406,
-0.0105229486,
0.055795297,
0.0373046659,
0.0172912925,
0.0207431149,
0.0091972873,
0.0153431259,
-0.0211420897,
-0.0140620507,
-0.0755007192,
0.0287283063,
-0.0415999703,
0.0421472974,
-0.01641226,
-0.041935388,
0.0273837335,
0.036094714,
0.0315516479,
0.0015731857,
0.0322866552,
-0.0169636104,
-0.0148034384,
-0.0332213752,
-0.0076472503,
-0.0176579878,
0.0574047454,
-0.0132632134,
-0.0077927215,
-0.0117841428,
0.0165644046,
-0.0206336882,
0.0222360343,
0.005633329,
-0.0353576429,
-0.0072219474,
-0.0277735535,
-0.0289198291,
-0.0183512028,
-0.0650485754,
-0.0155972615,
-0.0265337881,
0.022351766,
-0.0245163348,
0.0353786424,
0.0340858474,
0.0281312726,
-0.0169542897,
0.0040405341,
-0.1141652986,
0.0219577421,
-0.0645038262,
0.0031452139,
0.0318449512,
-0.0543300621,
0.0480738208,
-0.0082386229,
-0.0026269031,
-0.0156682096,
0.0274641309,
0.0447342023,
-0.0022122567,
-0.0097990809,
0.0435221568,
0.0185163599,
-0.0047624623,
0.1061050072,
-0.0007956527,
0.0245253909,
-0.0028810797,
-0.0133088753,
-0.0435539298,
-0.0515644774,
-0.0109488834,
0.0475675426,
-0.022532301,
-0.0524492115,
-0.0237897411,
0.0229744799,
0.0707646683,
0.0129729416,
-0.006963185,
-0.0258101113,
0.0660701096,
0.0175698455,
-0.0059491317,
-0.0204950776,
-0.0396535881,
0.0135363517,
-0.0187388584,
-0.0059287422,
0.0032029373,
-6.206759313e-33,
-0.0205503404,
-0.0271670911,
-0.0136518367,
0.0075077824,
-0.0075246384,
-0.0062110568,
-0.0564299971,
-0.045302663,
0.0138833905,
-0.0280325562,
-0.0120858047,
0.0315387174,
0.0067559252,
0.0246049911,
0.0247535855,
0.0233335476,
0.0246559568,
-0.001471182,
-0.0058069336,
0.0660883561,
0.0416555703,
0.0257034153,
0.0449180119,
-0.0437206849,
0.0214247033,
0.0069893892,
0.0285568517,
-0.013858567,
0.0265459493,
0.0141177904,
-0.0080787055,
0.0178285018,
-0.0008285791,
-0.025100138,
-0.0572515428,
-0.031310901,
-0.0590258799,
-0.0285336319,
0.0387415029,
-0.0581351072,
-0.007370505,
-0.0337314755,
0.0370188951,
-0.0419352576,
0.0582086965,
-0.0339068212,
0.061103791,
-0.0293337665,
-0.1062984988,
-0.0886852071,
-0.0212992076,
0.02405826,
-0.0156895947,
0.0347496569,
0.0230122376,
0.0382550359,
-0.0152739966,
0.0455694534,
-0.0166912116,
0.0435853377,
0.0121422475,
0.0733355805,
0.0086234091,
0.0141266081,
0.0525643416,
0.0584007092,
0.0505929887,
-0.0157077368,
0.021526251,
-0.0238911789,
-0.0192207526,
0.0020879549,
-0.0140719516,
0.0182408001,
0.0521923937,
0.0567488447,
-0.0282681659,
0.060688626,
-0.0225435067,
0.0378738903,
0.024633484,
0.0039717439,
0.0098410882,
-0.0317687504,
0.0049216039,
0.0191260651,
-0.0283517241,
-0.0126009556,
-0.0110418499,
0.0243826099,
-0.0655935183,
-0.0016985852,
0.0099457139,
-0.0151827466,
0.027320398,
0.0537428483,
0.0223526135,
0.0237198975,
0.0009703211,
-0.0470194072,
-0.0448614769,
-0.0453429781,
-0.0162986964,
0.0005563886,
-0.0006148907,
0.0205737371,
0.0066334307,
0.0150388815,
-0.0395667925,
-0.0160081666,
0.0048080194,
-0.0040148557,
-0.0560393482,
-0.0064939349,
-0.0361669362,
0.0257543325,
0.0211823117,
0.0626806915,
0.0299122352,
-0.0043611783,
-0.003093783,
0.0139578041,
0.0368857495,
0.0284166932,
-0.000982349,
0.0290779117,
-0.016170131,
0.0078419717,
0.0340575464,
-0.0574383661,
0.0026858619,
0.0315464549,
2.689e-7,
0.0211052168,
0.0399400219,
0.0750432014,
-0.0197993685,
-0.0063309753,
-0.0063728392,
-0.0079873083,
0.0301723145,
0.0137335332,
-0.0116012441,
0.0294599887,
-0.0052806842,
-0.0137484483,
0.0300736167,
-0.1454447359,
-0.0042203511,
-0.1047448739,
-0.0741999075,
-0.0394489244,
-0.0312166102,
0.0104357433,
0.055659391,
-0.0357664824,
0.0195838567,
-0.0298322458,
-0.0427853018,
0.0738690719,
0.0097383726,
-0.0064269952,
0.0389744602,
0.0832245871,
-0.0186238084,
-0.0333209895,
-0.0021080144,
-0.0051589417,
-0.0106875496,
0.0399571694,
0.0660554394,
0.0119368313,
-0.0202336758,
0.061991293,
-0.0229006335,
0.0150630949,
0.0462488011,
0.0204611812,
-0.0716349334,
-0.0017518036,
-0.0164721366,
-0.0034660732,
0.0311558377,
-0.0243358593,
-0.0031407517,
-0.0169859473,
0.0371228047,
-0.0337382965,
0.0087012937,
0.022701975,
-0.0523359589,
-0.0354875624,
0.0658596829,
-0.0064499276,
-0.0360025689,
-0.0057130717,
-0.0173060633,
0.0339642465,
-0.084756501,
-0.0341083109,
2.349837314e-34,
0.0971332788,
-0.0068749147,
-0.0254803132,
-0.0460945778,
-0.0079336818,
-0.0169945564,
-0.0176290516,
0.0174559709,
-0.0008695051,
-0.0760976672,
-0.0386874862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07961v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07961v1 | The ART of LLM Refinement: Ask, Refine, and Trust | 2023-11-14T07:26:32 | 2023-11-14T07:26:32 | Kumar Shridhar, Koustuv Sinha, Andrew Cohen, Tianlu Wang, Ping Yu, Ram Pasunuru, Mrinmaya Sachan, Jason Weston, Asli Celikyilmaz | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
generative abilities, but can they judge the quality of their own generations?
A popular concept, referred to as self-refinement, postulates that LLMs can
detect and correct the errors in their generations when asked to do so.
However, recent empirical evidence points in the opposite direction, suggesting
that LLMs often struggle to accurately identify errors when reasoning is
involved. To address this, we propose a reasoning with refinement objective
called ART: Ask, Refine, and Trust, which asks necessary questions to decide
when an LLM should refine its output, and either affirm or withhold trust in
its refinement by ranking the refinement and the initial prediction. On two
multistep reasoning tasks of mathematical word problems (GSM8K) and question
answering (StrategyQA), ART achieves a performance gain of +5 points over
self-refinement baselines, while using a much smaller model as the decision
maker. We also demonstrate the benefit of using smaller models to make
refinement decisions as a cost-effective alternative to fine-tuning a larger
model. | [
0.0183331072,
0.0880133435,
0.0024657568,
0.0300304443,
-0.0441193432,
0.0081749493,
0.0054787705,
-0.0022889348,
-0.0280396082,
-0.0323277861,
-0.0327092819,
-0.0290884748,
-0.0024857274,
-0.0149658965,
0.033501979,
-0.0021982356,
0.0810729489,
-0.0731767789,
0.0355809815,
-0.0207948517,
-0.0300135519,
-0.0080563743,
-0.0148639707,
0.0060903393,
0.0041966746,
-0.0381056815,
0.0067145401,
-0.0044446979,
-0.0006157276,
-0.0115802782,
-0.0004626876,
0.0655431747,
0.0119273998,
0.0391850695,
0.0000019665,
-0.0589355379,
-0.0091671254,
-0.0139384177,
-0.0625712425,
0.0288095642,
0.0005704302,
0.0133943046,
0.0045039398,
0.0331433266,
-0.0599395335,
0.0251137745,
-0.0157131273,
0.0139276367,
0.0795423314,
0.0684984773,
0.038897492,
-0.0461375527,
0.0143714231,
-0.0203679055,
0.0304835495,
-0.0544138476,
0.0114062335,
0.0422308296,
-0.0081483107,
0.0264734179,
-0.0439413786,
0.0588592216,
0.0473052785,
-0.0239857025,
0.0114559475,
0.0078677526,
-0.0295235217,
-0.0047545764,
-0.0050129923,
0.0186890271,
-0.0089704199,
-0.031724602,
-0.0353937596,
0.0020717471,
0.0186205935,
0.004056219,
-0.0529340357,
0.0369925722,
-0.0096821869,
0.0195841063,
-0.0031468968,
-0.0282249302,
0.0470523126,
0.0174610876,
-0.0396672376,
0.1096841916,
-0.0102522913,
-0.0445633829,
0.0094199209,
0.0273844432,
-0.0461831503,
-0.0467120856,
0.0060950108,
0.0472916625,
-0.0158412233,
0.0416141488,
-0.0149804708,
-0.0039656116,
-0.0063238912,
0.0237247813,
0.0320030674,
0.037758328,
0.0056872298,
0.0482672006,
-0.0419969745,
0.0672994033,
0.0047944714,
0.0333381966,
-0.0409703739,
0.0048452499,
-0.0331930742,
-0.0444936231,
-0.0316762254,
0.0282335412,
0.0114136487,
-0.0033950338,
-0.0533143245,
0.032147713,
-0.0015874746,
0.0234597046,
0.0272710565,
0.0024367911,
0.0068499846,
-0.0367403179,
-0.0771374702,
0.0181182642,
-0.0094739962,
0.0273003113,
0.0209859628,
-0.0709722117,
-0.0356874056,
-0.0000772575,
-0.02482819,
-0.0024315859,
-0.0050099539,
0.0386411995,
-0.0295078717,
-0.0197605584,
-0.0679521486,
-0.0393019281,
-0.0324755646,
-0.067854248,
0.0311709158,
-0.0680323318,
0.0313459672,
-0.0129724164,
-0.0116648981,
-0.0530896857,
0.0031101548,
-0.0093769729,
-0.0217150487,
0.0663071498,
-0.0012745562,
0.0372195318,
0.0258184727,
0.0332108326,
0.0031559553,
0.0435860455,
0.0438257232,
-0.0331291445,
0.039536301,
-0.0119053815,
0.0165655669,
0.0260398965,
0.0174464863,
-0.0117766,
0.0013977675,
0.0108153941,
-0.0356202386,
0.0391865149,
0.0336004943,
0.0447579511,
-0.0492483377,
-0.0277772173,
0.0569145866,
0.0283992328,
0.0277640875,
0.0033711372,
0.0210758839,
-0.0292891841,
0.0267422125,
0.0238981191,
-0.053485021,
0.0263765808,
-0.0003258188,
0.0198338088,
0.0307413936,
-0.0202411748,
-0.0299633574,
-0.1041191891,
-0.0363859273,
0.0185304508,
-0.0180806629,
0.0230198875,
0.0452966839,
0.0400588177,
-0.0189141948,
0.0477315821,
-0.0164147113,
-0.0438713022,
-0.0065989094,
-0.0798248947,
0.0849670768,
0.0616427585,
0.0577903688,
0.0023469995,
-0.063542679,
0.012204851,
0.0026762495,
0.0266199522,
0.0497708917,
-0.0079494668,
-0.0068374337,
-0.0284957085,
-0.0241340008,
-0.0516478568,
0.026364373,
-0.0178976394,
0.0549621172,
-0.0156185115,
0.0221138131,
-0.0675826445,
0.0089999493,
0.033663664,
-0.0233216565,
-0.0341865458,
-0.0150828026,
-0.0135318702,
0.0058366694,
-0.0091592446,
0.0018318357,
0.0599253289,
0.0209313054,
0.0008972826,
-0.0096428413,
-0.013971528,
-0.0548102744,
-0.039999444,
0.0477550775,
0.0185176209,
-0.0193434525,
-0.0012599974,
-0.0696367547,
-0.0310880281,
0.038058348,
-0.0304202233,
-0.0029552078,
-0.0348785147,
0.057036262,
-0.0073616728,
-0.0013497585,
-0.0407522507,
0.0701113641,
-0.0190566126,
-0.01091999,
-0.0054238588,
0.0306593422,
-0.0019941696,
-0.0467460714,
-0.0098452801,
-0.0149823539,
0.0082964422,
0.0041433084,
-0.0026475801,
0.0111396555,
-0.0692734346,
-0.0305998139,
-0.0377445184,
-0.0061075892,
-0.0030290752,
0.0350187905,
0.0071109054,
-0.0353758447,
0.0019122632,
-0.0224708859,
-0.0133313257,
0.0246749762,
0.0346258171,
0.0259077009,
0.0596902072,
-0.0171273798,
-0.0111744208,
-0.0274176933,
-0.0265847929,
-0.0087804869,
0.0417524539,
-0.0053380234,
0.0438667051,
-0.1004548892,
0.0177045204,
-0.0951551124,
0.0007239479,
0.006369018,
-0.0017203991,
0.0295290388,
0.0003183443,
0.0276586805,
0.0871640369,
-0.0128835887,
-0.0005404562,
0.0691709146,
-0.0136774369,
-0.0479095243,
0.0248834528,
0.0036318589,
-0.0352338217,
-0.0096313134,
-0.0278386008,
0.0034904638,
0.0881382227,
-0.0079771038,
-0.0169426911,
-0.0349931717,
0.0435669497,
-0.0123718986,
-0.0117680272,
-0.0146321785,
-0.0226454437,
-0.0071386746,
0.073723942,
-0.036006134,
-0.0719047636,
0.0771535188,
-0.0111807939,
-0.0052298647,
-0.042612832,
0.0166999139,
-0.0405902937,
0.0392284244,
-0.0164599139,
-0.0236312114,
-0.0192708597,
0.012311589,
-0.0574183501,
-0.0402243882,
0.0413676426,
-0.0450821556,
0.0765290037,
-0.0866348371,
0.0083099222,
0.0043799519,
-0.0712555125,
-0.0511266068,
0.020840982,
-0.0523382537,
0.0196818896,
-0.0084671741,
-0.0006327693,
-0.01478945,
-0.0142675489,
0.0143327806,
0.0219319221,
-0.0302622132,
-0.0347006135,
0.0053408667,
0.0312122721,
0.0323437415,
0.0463555418,
0.0588632636,
-0.0386023223,
0.034691114,
0.0396245047,
0.0303258374,
0.0136913937,
-0.0467524379,
0.0206923913,
0.0187620223,
-0.0162892193,
-0.0369513482,
0.0069005867,
0.0487486757,
-0.093307808,
-0.0241092555,
0.1141784415,
0.0357722491,
0.0389369652,
-0.004664035,
-0.0687791035,
0.0269676354,
0.0196066704,
0.0293408372,
-0.0686137006,
-0.0268301275,
0.0243408419,
0.0357831642,
0.0087639298,
-0.0230199397,
-0.0221680682,
-0.1079040095,
0.0699610934,
0.0240207762,
-0.0044557885,
0.024311332,
-0.0276636165,
-0.0086540505,
0.0039704801,
0.0270053539,
0.0709230527,
-0.0078727622,
0.0130340755,
0.0298424885,
-0.0343444571,
-0.0518656969,
0.0111411642,
-0.0251772311,
0.0082512656,
0.0431361087,
0.0129217375,
0.018827524,
-0.0869832039,
0.0757059753,
0.0172599871,
0.0436036475,
-0.0462245829,
0.0166968387,
0.0117250169,
0.0003697681,
-0.0106723206,
0.0066878819,
-0.0135313114,
-0.0315269567,
-0.0111786183,
0.0959909782,
-0.031289909,
-0.0436704494,
-0.0013026503,
0.0133852074,
-0.0816264525,
0.0569343828,
0.0295313932,
0.0077629578,
-0.064636521,
-0.0355701819,
-0.0223422498,
-0.0430237651,
-0.0164967999,
0.0407906137,
0.0340033136,
0.0253846329,
-0.0640956461,
-0.0093478113,
0.0259795301,
0.0242288224,
-0.0206968989,
0.0036144559,
-0.0155383367,
-0.0112345479,
-0.0348406695,
0.0119022233,
-0.0543628223,
-0.0131296255,
-0.0480730012,
0.0187549368,
-0.0005041008,
-0.0086869616,
-0.0260890573,
0.0198336951,
-0.1069335118,
-0.0595815592,
-0.0047185719,
0.0698454008,
0.0315045044,
0.0245135669,
-0.0080371406,
-0.0534903742,
0.0213812701,
-0.0075929924,
-0.0202869233,
0.059000276,
0.0222991593,
0.010030102,
-0.0100541757,
0.0301233195,
-0.0264242571,
-0.0078170663,
0.036044661,
0.034467008,
0.004537127,
-0.0309111662,
0.0225032978,
0.0276545901,
0.0190745424,
-0.0035598963,
0.0212957878,
-0.0261654276,
0.0423761681,
0.0210948177,
-0.0160796475,
-0.0305549465,
0.0248767193,
0.0215380546,
-0.0404075384,
-0.0021254544,
0.0233544894,
-0.0038786302,
0.0330425836,
-0.0196779203,
0.0148226498,
0.0247787423,
-0.0038192787,
0.0014325787,
-0.0153405787,
-0.0113803167,
0.0177342948,
-0.0261638239,
0.0620294698,
0.0169020686,
0.040466737,
0.0080947829,
0.0030132707,
-0.048110418,
0.0018538754,
-0.0820347965,
-0.090173699,
0.025874408,
0.0342732444,
0.0216279421,
0.0349233598,
0.0313138179,
-0.0308021717,
0.000466603,
-0.0119427545,
-0.013202494,
0.0289598946,
-0.0229964498,
0.0522557199,
0.018299628,
-0.0018515561,
-0.0141494963,
0.0658094436,
-0.0034796209,
0.0484677404,
-0.0254237056,
-0.0080972845,
-0.0381606854,
-0.0539810359,
-0.0070164613,
-0.0251022968,
-0.018692337,
-0.0121858632,
-0.051813554,
-0.0772164166,
0.0138100041,
0.0398127027,
-0.0059228139,
-0.0223657545,
0.0140048098,
0.0920714587,
-0.0245044641,
-0.0553050674,
-0.0131475497,
-0.0069336486,
-0.0170171708,
-0.0085735144,
-0.018053297,
-6.211970427e-33,
-0.0265319608,
-0.0339810476,
0.0638526604,
-0.0345731713,
-0.0099426489,
-0.011694314,
-0.0487364307,
0.0177401882,
-0.0267442651,
0.0152153019,
-0.0285479594,
0.0451975241,
0.0134913689,
0.0011653545,
0.0218297876,
-0.02536547,
0.0347907469,
-0.0170657206,
-0.0522986427,
-0.0288822055,
-0.0071954313,
0.0196834914,
0.0733981803,
-0.0293275509,
0.02202411,
0.0254498702,
-0.0140649946,
0.0568392202,
-0.061121285,
0.0668950826,
0.0001423877,
0.0111771701,
0.0277160034,
-0.0562112853,
-0.0234779008,
-0.0189037602,
-0.0558791496,
-0.0368487388,
0.0506868139,
-0.0055739665,
-0.0771190226,
-0.0254544709,
0.0491009913,
0.0339329727,
-0.0493017733,
-0.004938914,
-0.0126960566,
-0.0379427001,
-0.0239263736,
0.0033616619,
-0.0259596352,
0.0347740203,
-0.0042932299,
-0.0330589861,
-0.0007612195,
0.0292581953,
-0.0289670601,
-0.0003991266,
-0.0257392824,
0.0073840842,
0.0371765196,
0.0342390426,
0.0825069323,
-0.0032242809,
-0.0158291608,
0.0334570259,
0.0034058206,
-0.0154283959,
-0.0258791205,
-0.0434899554,
0.035504099,
0.0560804382,
0.0700594783,
0.0142577831,
0.0007613928,
0.0229093358,
-0.0530808009,
-0.0020050548,
0.0030649793,
0.0852236748,
0.0177848581,
0.0189030487,
-0.0113535039,
-0.0337850451,
-0.0696890578,
0.0166444853,
-0.0441200919,
-0.005405196,
0.0344820581,
0.024825789,
-0.0135606993,
-0.0252566524,
0.0099981586,
-0.0075775194,
-0.0021476613,
0.0014138875,
-0.0071926937,
0.0015867216,
-0.0156252384,
0.0292175375,
-0.0234622005,
0.0103925094,
0.0118289068,
0.0059270617,
0.0095912041,
0.0018293695,
0.0169278737,
0.00382578,
-0.055147361,
-0.000230274,
-0.0439962633,
0.0137090869,
0.01640567,
0.0037681162,
0.0395325422,
0.0304760449,
-0.015422022,
0.0420360453,
-0.0015207696,
0.0034640618,
-0.0297622923,
0.0660218149,
0.0068394067,
0.0225710738,
0.0023791133,
0.0095998738,
0.0034719121,
0.0339579992,
-0.0246747751,
-0.0420938805,
-0.0095378915,
0.0644550845,
2.701e-7,
0.0640999675,
0.064692311,
0.0126268007,
0.0273913369,
0.0339786075,
0.0038888545,
-0.0377034433,
-0.0640007183,
0.0089726578,
-0.0242886189,
0.0157717112,
0.0646901503,
0.0628672838,
0.0458503775,
-0.0382293314,
0.0113658914,
-0.0741733611,
0.0038856645,
-0.0334363319,
-0.0349613205,
0.0269813314,
0.0776026919,
0.0025764741,
-0.026672706,
-0.011126278,
-0.0509377941,
0.0811756104,
-0.0107736392,
0.0027670611,
0.0297407582,
0.0372691043,
0.0064104204,
0.0319202393,
0.0237171091,
0.0012645945,
0.0091860807,
-0.0179398544,
0.0721715167,
0.0092491638,
-0.0072798422,
-0.0287374444,
0.0059166662,
0.0116168829,
-0.090567939,
0.08351174,
-0.0197108332,
-0.0212526582,
-0.0263620764,
0.0361414962,
-0.022877235,
0.0358589925,
-0.0175792444,
-0.0033808309,
0.0221447647,
0.0342188217,
0.0097032236,
-0.022524558,
-0.0828485414,
-0.0309850015,
0.0008272016,
-0.043582838,
-0.0546123497,
-0.0345967263,
0.0216274597,
0.0233887453,
-0.0464273468,
-0.0118110972,
2.360750815e-34,
0.0450288653,
-0.0128730964,
0.0311978776,
0.0497218184,
0.0325888023,
0.0044387649,
-0.0053792722,
0.0148285832,
0.016497178,
-0.0578397065,
-0.0249143336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07954v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07954v2 | A Closer Look at the Self-Verification Abilities of Large Language Models in Logical Reasoning | 2023-11-14T07:13:10 | 2024-03-23T13:54:44 | Ruixin Hong, Hongming Zhang, Xinyu Pang, Dong Yu, Changshui Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Logical reasoning has been an ongoing pursuit in the field of AI. Despite
significant advancements made by large language models (LLMs), they still
struggle with complex logical reasoning problems. To enhance reasoning
performance, one promising direction is scalable oversight, which requires LLMs
to identify their own errors and then improve by themselves. Various
self-verification methods have been proposed in pursuit of this goal.
Nevertheless, whether existing models understand their own errors well is still
under investigation. In this paper, we take a closer look at the
self-verification abilities of LLMs in the context of logical reasoning,
focusing on their ability to identify logical fallacies accurately. We
introduce a dataset, FALLACIES, containing 232 types of reasoning fallacies
categorized in a hierarchical taxonomy. By conducting exhaustive experiments on
FALLACIES, we obtain comprehensive and detailed analyses of a series of models
on their verification abilities. Our main findings suggest that existing LLMs
could struggle to identify fallacious reasoning steps accurately and may fall
short of guaranteeing the validity of self-verification methods. Drawing from
these observations, we offer suggestions for future research and practical
applications of self-verification methods. | [
0.0220247712,
0.0383837186,
-0.0118409032,
0.046875257,
-0.0550897047,
0.0204673279,
0.0293954127,
-0.0004611545,
0.0833072811,
-0.0381704941,
-0.0068973345,
0.0007873947,
0.0016968042,
0.0196974333,
0.0423344001,
0.004874602,
0.0546705239,
-0.063232623,
0.0075067566,
-0.0289201532,
-0.0210334808,
-0.003418596,
-0.0086621726,
-0.0091551589,
-0.0083346581,
-0.0313569643,
-0.0010320507,
0.0014750623,
0.0008589685,
-0.0235947352,
-0.0181712992,
0.0338495411,
-0.0075860466,
0.0564786755,
0.0000019427,
-0.0558528602,
0.0113739735,
0.0004501335,
-0.0713908821,
0.0260255244,
0.0149516016,
-0.0091975154,
-0.0450567789,
0.0277300272,
0.0022325842,
-0.0159366243,
0.0219501071,
0.0564934872,
0.0740930885,
0.0700328127,
0.0228431784,
-0.021346679,
0.0168773998,
-0.0120166056,
0.0044197803,
-0.034871649,
0.0539348684,
0.0629657879,
0.0000711378,
-0.001882571,
-0.0012178415,
0.0112670455,
0.0347785242,
-0.0320887081,
-0.0365947671,
0.0036802897,
-0.0458553545,
-0.0240226407,
-0.0202858653,
0.0062364377,
0.0054458738,
-0.0736298114,
-0.011810937,
0.0036454278,
0.0046084528,
0.0065006069,
0.0271038935,
0.0568478741,
-0.0156646576,
-0.0052420031,
0.0607259125,
-0.0135288136,
0.0538829155,
0.0163091626,
-0.0389957242,
0.1139913872,
0.0012149566,
-0.0786746964,
0.0331060849,
-0.0061523439,
0.0086443508,
-0.0996953622,
-0.005459703,
0.0376980379,
-0.0212870687,
0.0398329087,
-0.0254843514,
0.0155846812,
0.0416186079,
-0.0436271727,
0.0166410599,
0.0164927207,
-0.0041000522,
0.0649122894,
-0.0336072966,
0.0689525604,
-0.0227425471,
0.0274071191,
0.0018992727,
-0.0091098538,
-0.003504171,
-0.0258278158,
-0.0125088515,
0.0581992678,
0.035303019,
0.0132660568,
-0.0548659898,
-0.015243602,
-0.060262803,
0.0637275428,
-0.0217575412,
-0.0155433621,
0.0234124009,
-0.0696476102,
-0.07887391,
0.000213685,
-0.0009012708,
0.0096196486,
0.007152922,
-0.0527424999,
-0.0069426191,
0.0118916668,
-0.033839453,
-0.0112828221,
0.0321847573,
0.0326249637,
0.0361277163,
-0.010567192,
-0.0654489398,
-0.0289312676,
-0.0437227748,
-0.0870232806,
-0.0083546909,
-0.0677148327,
-0.0085206674,
-0.0365872011,
-0.0024440798,
-0.0322811157,
-0.0026742402,
0.0009241139,
-0.013894937,
0.0792765543,
-0.021205483,
0.0219829809,
0.0588046052,
-0.0038215243,
0.0162367057,
0.0431036092,
0.0101760598,
0.0139394822,
0.0219604969,
-0.0020484878,
0.0324128345,
0.0055132662,
0.0215513203,
-0.0067801154,
-0.0511869527,
0.0285372268,
-0.0581344068,
0.0290730223,
-0.0221333597,
0.0853527933,
-0.0289252345,
-0.0171260294,
0.0222051796,
0.0449063741,
0.0313864984,
-0.004537839,
0.0527896546,
-0.0645669177,
0.0198907293,
0.0140489303,
-0.0693842173,
-0.005686224,
-0.0371311568,
-0.0116586862,
0.0302533582,
0.009217619,
-0.0202879943,
-0.0949728787,
-0.0345859863,
0.0089400066,
-0.0090271449,
0.0177854989,
0.0505726002,
0.0305263475,
0.017057959,
0.0212473646,
0.0101803262,
-0.052625291,
-0.0186695494,
-0.0725039318,
0.0418979675,
0.0425573438,
0.0497994795,
-0.0358472615,
-0.0293607302,
-0.0077376636,
0.0137305949,
0.0262480248,
0.0890828446,
0.0016953371,
-0.0479412973,
-0.0028695457,
0.0112489685,
0.000326736,
0.0524947383,
-0.0154409949,
0.0177067295,
-0.0063237655,
0.0039232951,
-0.0267705936,
-0.0159794874,
0.035808064,
-0.0361597091,
-0.0058373748,
-0.0103877569,
0.0075243143,
0.0238895789,
0.00352319,
-0.0220738854,
0.0180755034,
0.0118002817,
0.0035545509,
-0.0647718981,
-0.0262717493,
-0.0011413798,
0.0055980319,
0.0714334249,
-0.0082877781,
-0.0560640655,
0.0126120672,
-0.0413097478,
-0.0120173227,
0.0400385708,
-0.0237161946,
-0.0376310498,
-0.0301650707,
0.0365417451,
-0.0064156558,
-0.0202715956,
0.0279887058,
0.0831751227,
-0.0277461428,
0.0107221184,
-0.0391062237,
0.0490966886,
0.0151695125,
-0.0613832623,
-0.0125361625,
-0.0087838033,
-0.0060497071,
0.0211977251,
0.0045878179,
-0.0260763224,
-0.0421893746,
-0.0349149369,
-0.0360054821,
-0.0032610456,
-0.0092046577,
0.0167267341,
0.0062650568,
-0.041728355,
-0.0064417534,
-0.0098907817,
-0.0065257465,
-0.0193314329,
0.061482735,
-0.0019259481,
0.0466428474,
-0.0360488184,
0.0000885773,
-0.0093999607,
-0.0049415426,
-0.056148164,
0.022096768,
0.0105431806,
0.0291594323,
-0.0615111142,
0.0189279374,
-0.0390566178,
0.0279848166,
0.0033870873,
-0.0328335017,
0.0195615329,
0.0005452689,
-0.0116148666,
0.1111966446,
0.0070118755,
0.0240691248,
0.0745115429,
0.0001682607,
0.0110738548,
0.0243154839,
-0.0006310946,
0.0143118883,
-0.0168266632,
-0.0370744988,
0.0011930013,
0.0278681181,
-0.0220508054,
-0.0083476212,
-0.023079481,
0.0621841066,
-0.019448353,
-0.0323806927,
0.0444964617,
-0.0468881615,
0.0033405614,
0.0679609478,
-0.0111523336,
-0.0339198075,
0.0575997457,
-0.0225692205,
0.0474441797,
-0.006178515,
0.0001223084,
-0.0299820732,
0.0561406165,
0.0040884456,
0.0057616709,
0.0233487487,
-0.0126169622,
0.0083366707,
-0.0337272659,
0.0451624952,
-0.0222515054,
0.0436353572,
-0.0581756011,
0.0225750282,
0.0336527936,
-0.0795044601,
-0.0361421295,
-0.0203183889,
-0.0658236817,
-0.0438615754,
-0.0673679337,
-0.0118152639,
-0.0297529865,
-0.023574112,
-0.0042976271,
0.0061352747,
0.0089014806,
-0.0074328822,
-0.0097062765,
-0.0296294428,
0.0212278143,
0.0338367373,
0.0416152701,
-0.0047852844,
0.0426186807,
0.0302116331,
0.0152801024,
0.0265831556,
-0.0636651665,
0.0056253825,
-0.0350243486,
-0.0188815109,
-0.0008577497,
0.0087798219,
0.009087339,
-0.0675650537,
-0.0085127661,
0.1092541888,
0.0229009576,
0.0329064801,
-0.0154348873,
-0.0396450013,
-0.0240288936,
0.0097006401,
0.0017389605,
-0.0815700889,
-0.0248101987,
0.0264237244,
-0.003507843,
-0.0177878272,
-0.032132376,
0.0171907563,
-0.1312794238,
0.0755980536,
0.0320738517,
0.0085806046,
-0.0439931378,
-0.0189838633,
0.0071479399,
-0.01167183,
0.0088663334,
0.0326311104,
-0.0020676674,
-0.045814041,
-0.0028502985,
-0.0603487939,
-0.0488838144,
0.0413225107,
-0.0378739722,
0.071586743,
0.0478580408,
0.0253928956,
-0.0064079491,
-0.0186454114,
0.0228619482,
-0.0125924824,
-0.0233874414,
-0.0035411809,
0.0281148851,
0.0008080908,
-0.0007814557,
0.0027088979,
0.0182641726,
-0.008565885,
-0.0115083298,
-0.0083533116,
0.0821528286,
-0.0266096946,
-0.0800386667,
-0.0103250146,
0.0140457647,
-0.0384025015,
0.0606648773,
-0.0049989391,
0.0220149234,
-0.0780864805,
-0.0376001261,
-0.0371361822,
-0.0244554151,
-0.037148416,
0.0595497191,
0.0538808666,
-0.0282169729,
-0.0345590562,
-0.0431226119,
0.000374381,
-0.0114858849,
-0.0219441578,
-0.0133222248,
0.0214920435,
0.0017726773,
0.0077935667,
-0.0169201195,
-0.0739277601,
0.0026790171,
-0.0348816328,
0.0450545251,
-0.0064120931,
0.001944983,
0.002472145,
0.0431351662,
-0.0746098831,
-0.0573184863,
0.0049330383,
0.0566383488,
0.0216038153,
0.0302435998,
-0.053757254,
-0.055343017,
0.027273478,
0.0265682619,
-0.0094945235,
0.0357121602,
0.0255287271,
-0.0309917517,
0.0048398571,
0.0322959535,
-0.0008999052,
0.0465314873,
0.0200542416,
0.019429354,
-0.0295765176,
-0.0128855128,
0.0572989471,
0.04894609,
0.0072244024,
0.0270536523,
0.0469614491,
-0.0178727023,
0.0286086537,
-0.034960106,
-0.0641532689,
0.0248781797,
0.0537234657,
0.0138790216,
-0.0309694503,
0.0120539702,
-0.0519257039,
-0.0351219289,
0.0047972715,
0.0169532634,
0.0024553081,
0.018954603,
0.0453369208,
0.023115132,
-0.0383457728,
-0.0061758501,
-0.0010445972,
0.0165911913,
0.042788595,
0.0221855622,
0.0196300261,
0.0447329879,
0.004733047,
-0.0288886763,
-0.0192948189,
-0.0539824478,
-0.054087989,
0.0506477095,
0.0036264013,
0.0681553036,
0.0162217673,
0.0012760342,
-0.0389022455,
-0.0346722864,
-0.0337230191,
-0.0246035829,
0.0597200207,
-0.022211805,
0.0419612154,
0.0141162826,
-0.0192562342,
-0.0307914838,
0.0122664981,
0.0040511638,
0.0563795306,
0.034269955,
-0.0216479599,
-0.0398378447,
-0.0569034368,
-0.0899158269,
-0.041186288,
-0.0345962383,
-0.0163136888,
-0.0613961332,
-0.1177990735,
0.0404914953,
0.0866754055,
0.0305493288,
0.0001588903,
-0.0397470891,
0.0855540559,
0.0450699888,
0.0049675968,
-0.0272457078,
0.0148097919,
-0.0391886346,
0.0068322239,
-0.016774185,
-5.6169609e-33,
-0.0309706833,
-0.0848657116,
0.0447339229,
-0.0288491268,
0.0332203656,
-0.0174648445,
-0.0347344838,
0.0023620497,
-0.0226276424,
0.0768636838,
-0.002342429,
0.0574995838,
0.01301469,
-0.0106938118,
0.0144451922,
-0.0074983658,
0.0465868637,
-0.0084647546,
-0.0294243991,
-0.0205038618,
0.0071368385,
-0.0462508537,
-0.0126371132,
-0.0604501255,
0.007775553,
-0.0136493212,
-0.032838352,
0.0481228828,
-0.0667494908,
0.0754965618,
-0.0092186239,
0.0075957077,
0.0094857942,
0.0296298359,
0.0313574038,
0.0182431471,
-0.0485716872,
-0.0224134587,
-0.0022865264,
-0.0120398663,
-0.0384186357,
-0.0293908659,
0.0449623652,
0.0143444557,
-0.042916026,
-0.0137560219,
-0.0158588048,
-0.034212593,
0.0419110246,
0.0185590386,
-0.0407747217,
0.0382794514,
0.0012500549,
-0.0215353724,
0.0046008765,
0.0188943017,
-0.0095260497,
-0.0069013387,
-0.0452183895,
0.0167800654,
0.0278910995,
-0.0215290152,
0.0691298097,
-0.0343478546,
-0.0215443671,
0.04879025,
0.0341118798,
0.0282340031,
-0.0584733076,
0.0050981063,
-0.0107985539,
0.0342657454,
0.0777871981,
0.0174059905,
0.0154183172,
0.0057615791,
-0.0695293769,
-0.0336174853,
-0.0173921175,
0.0462295227,
0.0254216585,
-0.0403518341,
-0.0606193207,
0.0191239659,
-0.052543316,
-0.0068873307,
-0.0390202701,
-0.0234088786,
0.0289927721,
0.0212774388,
0.0174073074,
0.0019594119,
-0.0216377042,
-0.050835982,
-0.0215459447,
-0.0078810137,
0.0028231668,
-0.018972436,
-0.0055997828,
0.0450429954,
-0.0158565249,
0.0023523967,
-0.0288315248,
0.0099246772,
0.0082793841,
0.0152890077,
0.0216507185,
0.0283845961,
-0.058238104,
0.0102602132,
-0.0188509487,
0.0080986153,
-0.0034657675,
-0.0036613287,
0.0647544116,
0.0067808991,
0.0100324629,
0.01774396,
0.0093562976,
-0.0172475036,
-0.0488257296,
0.0756569132,
-0.0097092129,
0.0253462307,
0.0087470012,
-0.0006439938,
-0.0462193713,
0.0317655727,
-0.0088300044,
-0.0435596742,
0.0254729446,
0.0070538055,
2.558e-7,
0.0088714939,
0.0645129308,
0.0178171787,
0.053657297,
0.0339075848,
0.0501720309,
-0.0367997214,
-0.017073201,
0.0003666399,
-0.0284471586,
-0.0104182698,
0.0659121498,
0.0396966822,
0.0433509238,
-0.0191865824,
0.0452345833,
-0.0419799089,
-0.028882686,
-0.0495643206,
-0.0140945883,
0.0423511826,
0.0668458939,
0.0481342077,
-0.0243815258,
0.0003489467,
-0.0658120513,
0.0553396009,
0.0338053815,
-0.0024663222,
0.0275393538,
0.0294352975,
0.0485560857,
-0.0130334459,
0.0544036329,
0.0020651286,
0.0031681606,
-0.0383424275,
0.0362025723,
-0.0076380488,
0.0151405688,
-0.0756300762,
-0.0112916529,
0.0130619826,
-0.043269854,
0.0741856098,
-0.0300759599,
-0.0232845824,
-0.0396330878,
0.0164062474,
-0.0216098949,
0.0307383668,
-0.0081177959,
-0.0186742041,
-0.0086454023,
0.0136731137,
0.0173398461,
0.0214185603,
-0.0816219971,
0.0041680806,
0.0269644,
-0.0330991372,
-0.0127838701,
-0.0050534955,
0.0459385663,
0.0306999534,
-0.0430975519,
0.0112348581,
2.022426551e-34,
0.0331141688,
-0.0270713419,
-0.0000857529,
-0.0083054844,
0.0768991634,
0.0290567707,
-0.0395270959,
0.0075819241,
0.0022435295,
-0.0231658462,
-0.000364871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07945v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07945v3 | First-Step Advantage: Importance of Starting Right in Multi-Step Math Reasoning | 2023-11-14T06:45:31 | 2024-07-01T13:25:57 | Kushal Jain, Moritz Miller, Niket Tandon, Kumar Shridhar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models can solve complex reasoning tasks better by learning to
generate rationales for their predictions. Often these models know how to solve
a task but their auto-regressive decoding nature leads to incorrect results if
they start incorrectly. We observe that smaller models in particular when
corrected, can solve a task that they would have otherwise struggled with. We
demonstrate this phenomenon by using a larger model to guide smaller models,
which leads to significantly improved performance (up to +24 points on the
GSM8K dataset by 7B models). To assist smaller models in initiating the
starting step, we propose QuestCoT, where a smaller model first asks itself how
to start, before proceeding with a chain of reasoning. On various multistep
mathematical reasoning datasets over multiple smaller models, we show that
getting the right start can lead to significant performance gains across all
models (gains of up to +6 points on GSM8K, +9 on SVAMP, +5 on ASDiv, and +7 on
MultiArith). | [
-0.0170151945,
0.1105984375,
-0.002185913,
0.0094880052,
-0.0613733158,
0.0443486087,
0.0278283451,
-0.0236600023,
-0.0375768095,
-0.0227299035,
0.0280086026,
-0.0371850245,
0.0078262733,
0.0244355351,
0.0231918078,
-0.0385801308,
0.0366717018,
-0.0767933726,
0.0337861292,
-0.0303670634,
-0.0456203073,
-0.0032729821,
-0.0463415571,
0.0136578837,
-0.0021023492,
-0.0496382825,
0.0011635314,
-0.0282748621,
-0.0106963897,
-0.0466678478,
-0.0162719004,
0.0454614498,
0.0405551381,
0.0369954854,
0.0000023756,
-0.0566047616,
0.0003993776,
-0.0056509888,
-0.0939101577,
-0.0057205074,
-0.0566123165,
-0.0102285193,
0.0175545663,
0.0271831397,
-0.0676176473,
0.0284666736,
0.0141473701,
0.0080023194,
0.0383485444,
0.0490440466,
0.0110719483,
-0.0660364106,
-0.0092919655,
-0.0101794265,
0.0111348098,
-0.0638877004,
-0.0112359896,
0.0559759215,
0.0120804254,
0.024388697,
-0.0258811992,
0.0305665992,
0.0496440493,
0.0126595898,
-0.0234270152,
0.0334580056,
0.0088453637,
-0.0248004254,
0.0069278912,
0.0443126187,
-0.0180834606,
-0.0395034775,
-0.017693352,
-0.024570711,
0.0118187563,
-0.0012820811,
-0.0764668062,
0.0665723607,
-0.0058797868,
0.0347374342,
0.0234617647,
-0.0020099368,
0.0390991047,
0.0051813154,
-0.0577352606,
0.1150170043,
-0.0153938569,
-0.0230755582,
0.0212763585,
0.0097974055,
-0.0520334318,
-0.0573627055,
0.010128635,
0.0648608282,
-0.0014426525,
0.0192767959,
0.0060189744,
-0.006438009,
-0.029429514,
0.0011213997,
0.0372011811,
0.0896376222,
0.0170854144,
0.0400297381,
-0.0485916846,
0.0496582948,
-0.0216635223,
0.031588316,
-0.0089011211,
0.0283553898,
-0.0421253927,
-0.0263937693,
-0.0193976648,
0.0508512259,
-0.0354084335,
0.007157831,
-0.0478278995,
0.0039902646,
-0.0252462793,
0.0153244445,
0.0194194596,
-0.0070520914,
0.0215167254,
-0.0330003165,
-0.0319069028,
0.0268632676,
-0.0654361099,
0.0358071811,
0.0238577984,
-0.0380883701,
-0.0373314433,
-0.0263538416,
-0.001965947,
-0.0196429696,
0.01566891,
0.0495738648,
-0.0056423969,
0.0033527871,
-0.0405555815,
-0.0428422727,
0.0459398255,
-0.1033746898,
0.0162712373,
-0.0706754029,
0.0456633493,
0.0373068973,
-0.0221648589,
-0.0358256772,
0.0078689251,
0.0188339259,
-0.0141308401,
0.0918670297,
0.025282355,
0.0197732933,
0.0015434042,
0.0010039026,
-0.0347776376,
0.0772534385,
0.0140597625,
-0.0348381735,
0.0048988215,
-0.0059648044,
-0.0066003185,
0.0195783973,
0.035640426,
-0.0222231597,
-0.0084737688,
0.0173316207,
-0.0026954305,
0.0371604562,
0.0060099587,
0.0164787788,
-0.0515789017,
-0.0022242982,
0.0245123282,
0.0747955963,
0.0209193733,
-0.0055639925,
0.0206887424,
-0.0324738473,
0.0195567328,
-0.0048461608,
-0.0859426931,
0.0426568277,
-0.0458029881,
-0.0007666712,
-0.0062981839,
0.0140471645,
-0.0188747197,
-0.0639633164,
-0.0232795142,
0.0044639963,
-0.0025622782,
0.0191121697,
0.0751899406,
0.0047250353,
-0.0157908667,
0.0313382335,
0.000281212,
-0.0413302854,
-0.0225966275,
-0.0617850535,
0.0284241047,
-0.0297279209,
0.0339664035,
-0.0278229397,
-0.0196518563,
-0.0143770147,
0.0153435972,
-0.0177523848,
0.026340384,
0.0021688323,
-0.0099649001,
-0.0353177749,
-0.0292054228,
-0.0226353537,
0.0253369454,
-0.0146501092,
0.0251283571,
0.0130722802,
-0.0087338723,
-0.026512783,
0.0319986381,
0.0310910158,
-0.0550716668,
-0.0278313737,
-0.0181454811,
0.0145275658,
-0.0086410819,
-0.0041043106,
0.0371035114,
0.0462834351,
-0.0002390887,
-0.0161915328,
-0.0411284901,
0.0019405239,
-0.0790647268,
-0.0666116849,
0.0505674593,
0.0283808187,
0.003522889,
0.0277592149,
-0.0324838124,
-0.0310088787,
0.0622674413,
-0.0194712561,
0.0105398726,
0.0168980919,
0.0335787125,
0.0093044834,
-0.0074791117,
-0.0096533094,
0.0782526508,
-0.0022837771,
0.0231929701,
-0.0025921878,
0.0086597297,
0.0104190614,
-0.0036438711,
0.0412084609,
0.0081060305,
-0.0368045643,
-0.0006463273,
-0.0171556175,
-0.0134473974,
-0.0341719165,
0.0008512497,
0.0105004376,
-0.0149146197,
-0.0083401734,
0.040078491,
0.0059002959,
-0.026650887,
0.0158814657,
-0.0247465186,
-0.0154413916,
0.0057165828,
0.0260334089,
0.0155406315,
0.0304344036,
0.0023373887,
-0.0064198757,
-0.0230127741,
-0.039765574,
-0.0514346287,
0.0651340634,
0.0155983092,
0.0404047966,
-0.0464078225,
-0.0031996628,
-0.0532214306,
-0.0145533392,
-0.0148154227,
-0.0223123152,
0.0291521084,
-0.0280032028,
0.0069914712,
0.0904236063,
-0.0153772626,
0.0322693363,
0.0417441577,
-0.0211675204,
-0.0546264425,
0.0091501931,
-0.0257525444,
0.0147643751,
-0.0229592603,
-0.032583423,
-0.0475820266,
0.0932948738,
-0.0137415826,
-0.001377878,
-0.0358418562,
0.0585182309,
-0.0047278707,
0.0077724224,
-0.0323152952,
-0.0137502691,
-0.0067623099,
0.1113160774,
-0.0093884347,
-0.0384781323,
0.0681228563,
0.012730483,
-0.0286902357,
-0.0458824933,
0.0360379145,
-0.0290056299,
0.0750044808,
0.0092656771,
-0.0105130374,
-0.0035796771,
-0.0167201534,
-0.0380905494,
-0.0198309198,
0.065232642,
-0.0153444782,
0.0609789193,
-0.0599497259,
-0.0012152328,
-0.0291746669,
-0.0513636246,
-0.0600416027,
0.0239427947,
-0.0465617441,
0.0341319293,
-0.0395381674,
-0.0293853935,
-0.0273275468,
-0.0041311351,
0.0288023315,
0.0371328928,
-0.0390103124,
-0.0290350728,
0.0052257939,
-0.0025064785,
0.0080294814,
0.0353944786,
0.0749298558,
-0.0519698784,
0.0841773972,
0.0254621077,
0.0853148028,
-0.0106896749,
-0.0123858843,
0.0310822092,
0.0199499484,
-0.0166024491,
-0.0440552942,
0.0378065668,
0.0502246842,
-0.0799853802,
-0.0136854863,
0.1175386757,
0.0429777503,
0.0338512324,
0.0112533476,
-0.0857650638,
0.034924034,
0.0398089364,
0.0026680918,
-0.0766918957,
-0.0335086733,
0.0549049787,
0.0279273801,
0.0150824776,
-0.0360089317,
-0.0102796648,
-0.1052301824,
0.0515045747,
0.0320325978,
-0.038082201,
0.0036715949,
-0.0472016595,
-0.0183929801,
-0.0138298888,
-0.0232400373,
0.0625600889,
-0.0064373715,
0.0211013556,
0.0134585081,
-0.0303958617,
-0.0042141043,
0.0203831699,
-0.0250413045,
0.0264567416,
0.0180442575,
0.0213821828,
0.0131747937,
-0.058920335,
0.0232384838,
0.0332025588,
-0.0286721699,
-0.029875176,
0.027170714,
0.0270999148,
-0.0173816979,
0.0003367531,
0.0636594743,
-0.0553357713,
-0.0460173115,
-0.0155874873,
0.0957774222,
-0.0221572928,
-0.0384209007,
-0.0068142787,
0.0279591419,
-0.0490589105,
0.0677852407,
0.0292037707,
0.0017230175,
-0.0814680606,
-0.0540303551,
-0.0310495514,
-0.0455978438,
-0.0302989427,
0.014108873,
0.0699081272,
-0.0004298104,
-0.0357328914,
-0.0431734733,
0.0237042997,
0.0680328906,
-0.0229779165,
-0.0072351587,
0.0184504893,
0.0073896972,
-0.0301684961,
0.0252533499,
-0.0164163988,
0.0153179495,
-0.0521307588,
0.0325837135,
0.0115051987,
-0.0260483772,
-0.043430455,
-0.0260928571,
-0.0850156173,
-0.049095273,
-0.0062979646,
0.0376969576,
0.0311023537,
0.0267931633,
0.0115490239,
-0.009861622,
-0.0124197677,
-0.0173969306,
-0.025949223,
0.0147206988,
0.0670246109,
-0.0168813113,
0.0061377678,
0.0341125056,
0.0066860653,
0.0241727121,
0.0015296228,
0.0575328693,
-0.0283705536,
-0.0077003986,
0.021994872,
0.0323537774,
0.033237204,
0.028851347,
0.0203711223,
-0.0211769249,
0.026921507,
-0.0295867454,
-0.0054735299,
-0.0216706246,
0.0396383479,
0.0146122621,
0.0036257554,
0.0060322955,
-0.034325622,
0.0215688832,
0.0083890157,
0.0015192546,
0.048611965,
-0.0078646438,
0.0435979553,
0.023680687,
-0.0318911038,
0.0019449799,
0.018320689,
-0.010799841,
0.0479537845,
-0.032754533,
0.0607836172,
0.0279453155,
0.0278217997,
-0.0332099721,
-0.0382435583,
-0.0650918782,
-0.1036519408,
0.0302480049,
-0.0331216976,
0.0342201516,
0.001673846,
0.0150362402,
-0.046822492,
0.0039053927,
0.0149200885,
0.018386608,
0.0229646936,
-0.0259186681,
0.0463368297,
0.0205178298,
0.0021391064,
-0.0359372534,
0.0410650261,
-0.0227767993,
0.0678342804,
-0.0058534574,
0.0216204468,
-0.0192400832,
-0.0709379688,
-0.0263574645,
-0.0002600068,
-0.0043455157,
0.0322773419,
-0.0674412996,
-0.0773834288,
-0.0433185175,
0.0050351643,
-0.0148933884,
-0.0075437091,
0.0402499475,
0.0488133021,
-0.023218669,
-0.0435266979,
-0.003174389,
0.0065554576,
-0.0178544484,
-0.0002589605,
-0.0069788843,
-6.562646105e-33,
-0.0053423997,
-0.020312883,
0.0602277853,
-0.011992245,
0.0264603049,
-0.0426543057,
-0.0392298922,
0.0263377689,
-0.0477877073,
0.019555727,
-0.0272092987,
0.0229624342,
0.0122972112,
0.0215545408,
0.0322723761,
0.0136341089,
0.0135628348,
-0.0314836279,
-0.0450817682,
-0.0135435434,
0.0184637066,
0.0210466534,
0.0544235781,
-0.0178547017,
-0.0046056719,
0.0146549512,
-0.008796284,
0.0255686343,
-0.0637278035,
0.0457924306,
0.0001063017,
-0.0230998676,
0.0266743414,
-0.0426549166,
-0.0318196788,
0.0142211644,
-0.0680069998,
-0.0400013253,
0.0142258918,
0.0153053952,
-0.0603374802,
-0.0063667907,
0.0122666694,
0.012078872,
-0.0242273062,
-0.0450939424,
-0.0047077672,
-0.0442312695,
-0.0058080731,
0.0367073566,
-0.0432685949,
0.0252793171,
-0.0208365582,
-0.0353129357,
0.0449253321,
0.0417312793,
-0.0259513929,
-0.0005418739,
-0.0005850323,
0.0199424867,
0.014368806,
0.0210372861,
0.0464903712,
0.0045222952,
-0.0091674021,
0.0283366833,
0.0195818692,
-0.0546207875,
-0.0383444913,
0.0042739306,
0.0319254808,
0.05927049,
0.0746032819,
-0.0228552539,
0.0616092719,
0.02371688,
-0.0860808194,
-0.0236795899,
-0.0039191158,
0.0367876515,
0.0113345189,
0.0021736412,
-0.0323669277,
-0.0110334884,
-0.0662244335,
-0.0092369551,
-0.0539292358,
-0.0131170964,
0.0175846405,
-0.0018997974,
0.0021474764,
-0.0184487514,
0.0309179388,
-0.0253501255,
-0.027789209,
0.0401654467,
0.0151301539,
0.0042590844,
-0.0142268771,
0.0333836488,
-0.0482242666,
0.0052444385,
-0.0054804473,
0.0145888906,
0.0277257934,
0.0235796627,
0.0093826354,
0.0131366765,
-0.0677590892,
-0.0265550725,
-0.0562064052,
0.0086827157,
0.0450327061,
0.0314765088,
0.0538002662,
0.0116741881,
-0.0037460346,
0.0592260398,
-0.0291645695,
-0.0405753329,
-0.0555445477,
0.0370932482,
-0.01743659,
0.0555567518,
-0.0148841375,
-0.0334761776,
-0.0470896102,
0.0297052711,
0.0214519538,
-0.0543235727,
-0.0207387917,
0.0443966947,
3.079e-7,
0.0402302444,
0.0532369204,
0.0041569369,
0.0596675165,
0.0052267606,
0.0457335152,
-0.0577673987,
-0.0566793233,
-0.0023566068,
-0.0127071822,
-0.0052556219,
0.0512706414,
0.0244007353,
0.0391646288,
0.0072457665,
0.0046607563,
-0.0584926829,
-0.0098099113,
-0.0336507857,
-0.0111848153,
0.0467586927,
0.0687535629,
0.032094501,
-0.0087846182,
0.0085661458,
-0.0050989427,
0.0433766693,
0.022289006,
0.0351500176,
0.0167400334,
-0.0126478113,
0.0087713683,
0.0228705686,
0.011536249,
-0.0115631362,
0.0240808874,
-0.0290014595,
0.0602956451,
0.0030570258,
-0.012305798,
-0.0322925448,
-0.0030245432,
0.0031670814,
-0.0569782704,
0.070335798,
-0.0699929222,
-0.0334431082,
0.0025916654,
0.0028872441,
-0.0250020102,
0.0221607797,
0.009808029,
0.020528933,
0.0078660334,
0.0206843037,
-0.008431307,
0.020516973,
-0.105895184,
-0.0279626362,
0.0495260917,
-0.0232270788,
-0.0296915285,
-0.0308192782,
0.0098348754,
0.0531172641,
-0.011989193,
-0.0504651517,
3.025320908e-34,
0.0314225517,
-0.0188925341,
0.0318214148,
0.0546695814,
0.029345084,
-0.0241039824,
-0.0213229042,
0.0233015288,
0.035709478,
-0.0435937308,
-0.0329388157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07941v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07941v1 | Non-autoregressive Machine Translation with Probabilistic Context-free Grammar | 2023-11-14T06:39:04 | 2023-11-14T06:39:04 | Shangtong Gui, Chenze Shao, Zhengrui Ma, Xishan Zhang, Yunji Chen, Yang Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Non-autoregressive Transformer(NAT) significantly accelerates the inference
of neural machine translation. However, conventional NAT models suffer from
limited expression power and performance degradation compared to autoregressive
(AT) models due to the assumption of conditional independence among target
tokens. To address these limitations, we propose a novel approach called
PCFG-NAT, which leverages a specially designed Probabilistic Context-Free
Grammar (PCFG) to enhance the ability of NAT models to capture complex
dependencies among output tokens. Experimental results on major machine
translation benchmarks demonstrate that PCFG-NAT further narrows the gap in
translation quality between NAT and AT models. Moreover, PCFG-NAT facilitates a
deeper understanding of the generated sentences, addressing the lack of
satisfactory explainability in neural machine translation.Code is publicly
available at https://github.com/ictnlp/PCFG-NAT. | [
0.0017187959,
0.1065469086,
0.0027190428,
0.016522048,
-0.0477845892,
0.0147448173,
0.0401881263,
-0.0203418918,
-0.0688165799,
-0.0175085105,
0.0315660536,
-0.0362852849,
0.020828614,
0.0612594485,
0.0385998338,
-0.0317278393,
0.0199439153,
-0.0233946051,
-0.0078297704,
0.0214328263,
-0.0166223329,
0.0168653764,
-0.0219217408,
0.0669102892,
-0.0602286011,
-0.0033143023,
0.0143456496,
0.0480544083,
0.020594066,
0.0110683264,
-0.0196534079,
0.0407189243,
-0.0158724394,
0.0236663707,
0.0000021997,
-0.0063193832,
-0.0431587249,
0.0300843734,
0.0116775772,
-0.0107535794,
0.0197040215,
-0.0454584807,
-0.023868287,
0.0121125551,
-0.0307789873,
-0.0110091446,
0.047021471,
0.0481792502,
0.0410261974,
0.1022017747,
-0.0109385764,
-0.0383192673,
0.0018072457,
-0.078394413,
-0.0241801217,
-0.0329523422,
-0.0485090427,
-0.060370937,
-0.0665429756,
-0.0007807166,
-0.0180221274,
0.0497367866,
0.0630205944,
-0.0546209589,
0.024700202,
0.0328471027,
-0.019784214,
-0.0319078192,
0.0012440139,
0.0520670861,
-0.0510448329,
-0.0230369344,
0.0246493015,
-0.0276155435,
0.0041802437,
-0.0231856834,
-0.0418653451,
0.0549335703,
0.0042543914,
0.0386936888,
0.0381971337,
0.048091881,
0.042163495,
-0.0095029147,
-0.0515079647,
0.0098253721,
0.0309492946,
0.028696496,
-0.0743331537,
0.0049698357,
-0.036068093,
-0.0085651353,
0.0319608301,
-0.0022142762,
-0.0036407176,
0.0087694395,
-0.0343635194,
-0.009580059,
-0.0393390432,
0.0017475563,
-0.0074276323,
0.0609138906,
-0.0000752041,
0.0264367666,
-0.0469659269,
0.0469024219,
-0.0544037335,
-0.0315573141,
-0.0373178162,
-0.0194690656,
-0.0229861382,
-0.0054194396,
-0.0159157217,
0.0125026181,
-0.0683978721,
-0.0217195116,
-0.0266055856,
-0.0144610694,
-0.0099646077,
-0.0281148218,
0.063260287,
0.0055928482,
-0.0764025375,
-0.0042417105,
0.0061342958,
0.0656562299,
0.0072605363,
-0.0482383817,
0.0412186012,
-0.0852173045,
-0.0281432811,
0.0484942533,
-0.0025280227,
-0.0277318843,
-0.0251689758,
0.0919354782,
-0.0112606883,
-0.0085195452,
-0.0035573852,
-0.0328636244,
-0.0126355477,
-0.0449951105,
0.0192411337,
-0.0385502577,
0.0314990878,
0.0237827804,
-0.0022033907,
-0.01457725,
0.0083528813,
0.0154889887,
0.0076099071,
0.0413655825,
0.0350677706,
-0.033853177,
-0.0097360853,
-0.0075158402,
-0.0009508408,
0.0448840149,
0.0411675088,
-0.0004923664,
-0.0015210886,
-0.0027807388,
-0.0019350317,
0.0009422384,
-0.0124871358,
-0.0209566839,
-0.0180084147,
-0.0422873124,
0.0324430726,
-0.0103548057,
0.0441549197,
0.0586429387,
-0.0056859087,
0.0076148682,
0.0253924709,
-0.0040282076,
0.0388378575,
0.0345863104,
0.0749480203,
0.0038959654,
-0.0272937659,
-0.014867058,
-0.0525499545,
0.0641523749,
0.0048205941,
0.0093479902,
-0.02575868,
0.0542652421,
-0.0003520933,
-0.066310592,
0.0305311829,
-0.0496798046,
0.013017864,
-0.0363580883,
0.067077063,
0.0329051428,
-0.0408599749,
0.05029938,
-0.0227684081,
-0.0611617938,
0.0078726914,
-0.0536117442,
-0.0134978108,
0.0211006571,
0.0473818406,
0.0150032975,
-0.0260189138,
-0.0345678106,
-0.0299546961,
0.0729629025,
-0.0025068948,
0.0632492304,
0.0296338554,
-0.0306507554,
-0.0060826894,
0.0013355698,
0.0200986117,
0.0295938049,
-0.0081446916,
0.0339292809,
0.0749477521,
0.019682873,
-0.027305346,
0.0339960381,
0.0100110825,
-0.001455448,
0.0745711029,
-0.0048227673,
0.0404133089,
0.0339166336,
-0.0243018307,
0.0483598672,
0.0226753578,
-0.081967555,
-0.0438411571,
0.0761789754,
-0.1082272455,
-0.0618508346,
-0.0070667965,
-0.0486897118,
-0.0126890987,
-0.0057959501,
-0.023679113,
-0.0739911571,
0.0490800589,
-0.0371977761,
0.0529652946,
-0.0308741573,
0.0061917291,
0.0584896915,
0.0257189944,
-0.0157282278,
0.0470331199,
-0.0018881386,
-0.0251473039,
0.0045408201,
0.0357854515,
0.0208099205,
-0.0052027171,
0.003439676,
-0.001330338,
-0.0305263102,
-0.0170081425,
0.0292013977,
0.0103201,
0.008277406,
-0.0379798897,
-0.0319729708,
-0.0138039757,
-0.0453417301,
0.0231679305,
0.0197157282,
0.05736937,
0.0231660809,
0.0000167668,
-0.029362997,
0.0061904187,
0.0145667614,
-0.0008318563,
0.0097864009,
-0.0329027586,
0.0069221947,
-0.0282949787,
-0.0274319332,
-0.0107610887,
0.0705756843,
0.0283536259,
-0.0112485755,
-0.0594720282,
-0.0011545097,
-0.006296529,
-0.000673537,
-0.0246478356,
-0.0546278059,
0.0245166533,
-0.0422255993,
0.0293491893,
0.0417590402,
0.0023072446,
-0.0294090007,
-0.0107669253,
-0.0060596657,
-0.0468513258,
0.0083379513,
-0.0443363898,
0.0026413044,
0.0036450217,
-0.0404309705,
0.0005274893,
0.0666715428,
0.0295911599,
-0.0299458373,
-0.057626836,
-0.0035289496,
-0.0063232677,
-0.0250279233,
0.0161197633,
-0.0121047199,
0.0098102558,
0.011731552,
-0.0150156701,
-0.0452733785,
0.0639226288,
-0.0499989241,
-0.0090496084,
-0.0215851236,
0.0021810397,
-0.0457498245,
0.0521096773,
0.0105142221,
0.0045242193,
0.0308948625,
-0.0359659679,
0.0042728418,
0.0264561381,
0.0051292949,
0.0104975244,
0.0407831222,
-0.0514144786,
0.0019558619,
0.0036626244,
0.0022667528,
-0.0258190781,
-0.0482302904,
0.0075901584,
0.0069520781,
0.046068836,
-0.0372714661,
-0.0055782958,
0.0310465917,
-0.0091105951,
0.0647917762,
-0.0450086072,
0.0062144753,
-0.0044617825,
0.0544574745,
0.0144227603,
-0.0039270306,
0.0282431003,
-0.0255763624,
-0.0107565802,
0.0350586101,
0.0084091276,
0.0090201842,
-0.0564089604,
0.0013958362,
-0.0331886858,
0.006222568,
-0.0535770357,
-0.0240182597,
0.0190197043,
-0.0563607588,
-0.0176121201,
0.1133103892,
0.0089843944,
-0.0452028066,
0.0103891063,
-0.0078288782,
0.0476092026,
0.0119463867,
0.0252774227,
-0.0493185483,
-0.0419646055,
-0.0026842777,
0.0255123395,
0.0215364769,
-0.0051176604,
-0.0096250558,
-0.0713115558,
0.0263743661,
0.0113088088,
-0.0431384258,
-0.044401858,
-0.0430296287,
-0.0502084158,
-0.0505202673,
-0.0040706685,
0.0019415702,
0.0139758335,
0.0176823232,
0.0235789381,
-0.0376067385,
-0.0498022288,
-0.029434206,
-0.0490074456,
0.0439078733,
0.0768202394,
-0.0025288907,
0.0019413139,
-0.0190224033,
0.0368054882,
-0.0424638204,
0.0499715656,
-0.0290156715,
-0.0136485118,
0.0259580724,
-0.0277022328,
-0.0101906834,
0.0058589862,
-0.0381419845,
0.018873306,
-0.0156599004,
0.0606624484,
-0.0150524024,
-0.0179376919,
-0.0132034458,
-0.0303140972,
0.0115405349,
0.055498708,
0.0352108926,
-0.0269760098,
-0.0579710267,
-0.0471454188,
-0.005100315,
-0.0559047014,
-0.0044156113,
-0.0254966039,
0.0251752157,
-0.0972835794,
-0.0729319677,
-0.028899245,
0.0013708688,
0.0623188242,
-0.0448648222,
0.0080616372,
0.019389404,
-0.0116981585,
-0.0184869729,
0.0649239942,
0.0093985964,
0.0028020756,
-0.0419664457,
0.0222614761,
0.0395865999,
0.0043467293,
-0.0120602176,
0.0285028033,
-0.082712464,
-0.0760344043,
0.0059392769,
0.0564700849,
0.0190569125,
0.0258042905,
-0.0442991592,
-0.0007391192,
-0.0027232023,
0.0539066903,
-0.0140194604,
-0.0146638537,
0.0268802084,
-0.0050681606,
0.0005410675,
0.0283074547,
0.0011793276,
-0.0080419965,
-0.020089874,
0.0932695046,
-0.013804039,
-0.0082543585,
0.0012149242,
0.0123597262,
0.0501294285,
-0.02904585,
-0.0167005267,
-0.0134571977,
0.0046734083,
-0.0379648842,
0.0157911796,
-0.0661809742,
0.0363605581,
0.0326063335,
-0.0022316808,
0.0164086968,
0.0111614913,
-0.007892658,
-0.0061840038,
0.0182611216,
0.0003629033,
-0.019646408,
0.002086468,
-0.0163449515,
0.0099717854,
0.0059186034,
-0.0202039704,
0.0077467915,
-0.0047188504,
-0.0518543869,
0.0396363959,
-0.0002588917,
0.0157985948,
-0.0334505923,
-0.006622476,
-0.038874086,
0.0552337505,
0.0085435156,
-0.0135511719,
0.0503960624,
-0.0087433131,
0.123469457,
-0.007394535,
0.027796058,
0.005451479,
0.0695829019,
0.0679795891,
-0.0038858261,
0.0152653335,
-0.0205928888,
-0.0118769621,
-0.0006457412,
0.0847037211,
0.0133663518,
-0.032917954,
-0.011235116,
0.0249505118,
-0.0308156833,
0.0108633088,
-0.0158460289,
-0.0338933468,
-0.0161124654,
0.0194245782,
0.0098052183,
-0.0436484627,
-0.00968521,
-0.0061322986,
0.0122021241,
-0.0190953072,
0.016677985,
0.0648483709,
-0.0277354158,
-0.045727089,
-0.0510511883,
0.0464536138,
0.0397505276,
-0.0241399445,
-0.0339224599,
-7.220316093e-33,
0.0104502961,
-0.048153244,
-0.0272052493,
-0.0290835071,
-0.0153632583,
0.0018163723,
-0.043862395,
-0.0072438358,
0.021272447,
0.0105864713,
-0.0089856675,
0.0471859314,
0.0220634434,
0.0480810665,
0.0302746147,
-0.0047537265,
0.0645559281,
0.0061147357,
0.0084234942,
0.0351664051,
0.0354829207,
0.0516764075,
0.0434986278,
-0.0726579279,
0.021343695,
-0.0166208185,
-0.0222310983,
0.0222792234,
-0.0031096779,
0.0280834995,
0.0112899477,
-0.0038584815,
0.0206607152,
-0.0456436016,
-0.0181499943,
-0.0219084658,
-0.1016381532,
-0.0130970236,
0.0127711426,
0.0243631043,
-0.0235289875,
-0.0548009984,
0.0625195056,
-0.0183110293,
0.003041886,
0.0061212177,
0.0150612788,
-0.0041300524,
-0.0097486936,
-0.024745781,
-0.0419627316,
0.0304723326,
-0.0058094324,
0.0271186214,
0.0113115795,
0.0675145388,
-0.0407260284,
0.0071588582,
-0.059643738,
-0.0009210411,
-0.0217364021,
0.0819214582,
0.0957861841,
0.0273449421,
-0.0059112329,
-0.014371004,
0.0362149626,
-0.0116055701,
-0.0468004979,
-0.000943742,
0.0057018804,
0.0172698181,
0.0979885161,
-0.0134502063,
0.0531913303,
0.0108075747,
-0.076839596,
0.0218537841,
0.0105395271,
0.0396828502,
0.0232391972,
-0.0050446689,
-0.0410877876,
-0.0179105233,
-0.0161262937,
-0.0581776388,
-0.0209306609,
0.0010711027,
-0.0033447295,
0.0415245406,
-0.0345128849,
-0.0330908597,
0.0529012308,
-0.0024603368,
0.0173554011,
0.0250436477,
0.0117871407,
0.0026303851,
-0.0370857902,
0.0163315088,
-0.0047986573,
-0.0059116287,
0.0189641174,
0.0078923404,
0.0339828618,
-0.0304929968,
0.0160981528,
0.05147909,
-0.0410385281,
-0.0115831885,
-0.0537221842,
0.0309662912,
-0.0160702504,
0.0091805849,
0.0115554854,
-0.0069369329,
-0.0336953923,
0.0322094448,
0.0041009556,
0.065083988,
0.002441643,
0.0195830092,
0.0213731918,
0.029746227,
-0.0450498126,
-0.0061729397,
-0.0257151797,
0.0755270794,
0.0573214404,
-0.0729029626,
-0.0429498591,
0.0509326197,
2.925e-7,
0.049668666,
0.0762992948,
0.0231632628,
0.0032904702,
0.0273592398,
0.0255266074,
0.0043396349,
-0.0018389038,
-0.0152751142,
0.0472825803,
0.0021386342,
0.0031137583,
0.0789905116,
0.0356900394,
-0.081124723,
0.0109968642,
-0.0708812997,
0.0052966774,
-0.0389628299,
-0.0128614064,
0.055450622,
0.1010544971,
-0.0410032608,
0.0134750996,
0.0145218857,
-0.0012016598,
0.034375485,
0.0051617264,
-0.0251605343,
-0.0134231579,
0.0791589841,
0.0031376807,
-0.0041291397,
-0.029372381,
-0.0251522902,
0.0003716986,
0.0182447433,
0.0697893053,
-0.0224159881,
-0.0297112856,
0.041707959,
-0.0035128153,
0.0111196246,
-0.0288642086,
0.0547113195,
-0.0671391413,
-0.0109103844,
0.0307225212,
-0.055220712,
0.0303445905,
0.0042038709,
-0.0078720236,
-0.0572604761,
-0.0000072625,
0.0333617181,
-0.0290442519,
-0.03263532,
-0.0745619386,
-0.0626096353,
-0.0231846962,
-0.0355745666,
0.0139139229,
-0.0426099896,
0.0019732413,
0.0567265749,
0.0251829103,
-0.0393900946,
2.868487921e-34,
0.0518372655,
0.0045540212,
0.0013706684,
-0.0171952415,
0.0439026579,
0.0115059977,
-0.045558814,
0.0075797001,
-0.0156409275,
-0.0861183852,
-0.0579146706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07930v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07930v1 | It's All Relative! -- A Synthetic Query Generation Approach for Improving Zero-Shot Relevance Prediction | 2023-11-14T06:16:49 | 2023-11-14T06:16:49 | Aditi Chaudhary, Karthik Raman, Michael Bendersky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent developments in large language models (LLMs) have shown promise in
their ability to generate synthetic query-document pairs by prompting with as
few as 8 demonstrations. This has enabled building better IR models, especially
for tasks with no training data readily available. Typically, such synthetic
query generation (QGen) approaches condition on an input context (e.g. a text
document) and generate a query relevant to that context, or condition the QGen
model additionally on the relevance label (e.g. relevant vs irrelevant) to
generate queries across relevance buckets. However, we find that such QGen
approaches are sub-optimal as they require the model to reason about the
desired label and the input from a handful of examples. In this work, we
propose to reduce this burden of LLMs by generating queries simultaneously for
different labels. We hypothesize that instead of asking the model to generate,
say, an irrelevant query given an input context, asking the model to generate
an irrelevant query relative to a relevant query is a much simpler task setup
for the model to reason about. Extensive experimentation across seven IR
datasets shows that synthetic queries generated in such a fashion translates to
a better downstream performance, suggesting that the generated queries are
indeed of higher quality. | [
0.0438288599,
0.0163012426,
0.0208680537,
-0.0098775206,
-0.0312517136,
0.0130097643,
0.0149735585,
0.0318382196,
-0.0015455554,
-0.0648874342,
-0.0480434746,
-0.0325366296,
-0.0524701886,
-0.0087013263,
0.017579874,
-0.0095793391,
0.0647093281,
-0.0047823018,
-0.016900558,
0.0144986203,
-0.0193755664,
0.027488254,
0.0185719002,
0.0319834687,
0.001750845,
0.0134897539,
-0.0125314537,
0.061373163,
-0.0451872349,
-0.0182419121,
-0.001260506,
0.0609516203,
0.0223650932,
0.0618044026,
0.0000015955,
-0.0508282892,
-0.0039608045,
-0.0003819553,
-0.0434188358,
-0.014914819,
0.0663436577,
0.0281549953,
0.0391914174,
0.0343088657,
-0.0404784419,
-0.0219294634,
0.0326722302,
0.0306901541,
0.0088308901,
0.0675525442,
0.0138920182,
0.0067893951,
-0.016749667,
-0.0202235617,
0.1079432666,
-0.0613376722,
0.0163407587,
-0.042148184,
0.0494191535,
0.04118466,
-0.008884524,
0.0230819285,
0.0270011779,
-0.0394972675,
0.0218754765,
0.0402943455,
-0.0956425816,
-0.0179182887,
0.0430200547,
0.0512580685,
-0.0401091911,
-0.0370652191,
-0.0094859609,
0.0118012866,
-0.0096025998,
0.0004318538,
-0.0562202148,
-0.0038703005,
0.0064674611,
-0.0064487923,
0.0055518155,
-0.0016938838,
0.0292195622,
0.0172858983,
-0.0388709903,
0.0504542254,
0.0322332494,
-0.025207771,
0.0180548579,
0.000853379,
-0.0332428776,
-0.0388542116,
-0.0526781827,
0.0225015022,
-0.0453209504,
0.0251899567,
-0.0464726128,
-0.0213317778,
0.0486097895,
-0.0568903759,
0.0026251602,
0.0445001125,
0.0233265832,
0.0615653656,
-0.0220275652,
0.0375732854,
0.0111316778,
0.0232005548,
-0.0780095384,
-0.0420230329,
-0.0664486811,
-0.0171090756,
-0.0481191091,
0.0218582824,
-0.0512151904,
-0.0254250653,
-0.0036318288,
0.0385631807,
0.0474541448,
-0.0423227176,
0.0305264536,
0.0218427014,
-0.0912385285,
-0.0065062884,
-0.0287711862,
0.0162135232,
-0.0103879841,
-0.0214321408,
-0.0153794605,
-0.0762265325,
-0.0101992534,
0.0244411565,
-0.0053990278,
-0.0407607295,
-0.0032551852,
0.0182894841,
-0.0167770516,
-0.0470312648,
-0.0478330255,
-0.0349236354,
0.0429627411,
-0.0339800119,
0.0203626826,
-0.0252298564,
0.0252923816,
-0.0216133129,
-0.0058434308,
-0.0257179458,
-0.0053322883,
0.0517509915,
-0.018119419,
0.0574946664,
0.0085965209,
0.0143096233,
0.0287642647,
-0.0024959394,
0.03017978,
0.1251221448,
0.0012424716,
0.0037177543,
0.0515873395,
0.014174941,
0.007682384,
-0.0015213719,
0.0275865402,
0.0224075802,
-0.0397519208,
0.0395424068,
0.0104545746,
0.0319643728,
-0.003556099,
0.0044517624,
-0.0335784741,
-0.0260878447,
0.0001230196,
0.0162295923,
0.0763474554,
-0.0247059353,
0.0751480237,
0.0441678427,
-0.0436737053,
-0.0084480681,
-0.0623205267,
0.0315579176,
-0.0128861759,
-0.0019070274,
0.0367755704,
-0.0197760593,
-0.057595484,
-0.0366642103,
0.0102409776,
0.0389912389,
-0.079694584,
0.0094718607,
0.0443041474,
0.0296724383,
-0.0297834501,
0.0114141749,
0.0151039623,
-0.0346781388,
0.0420597792,
-0.0614146665,
0.011177768,
0.056299638,
0.0871463269,
-0.0373963565,
-0.0213933419,
0.0363564231,
0.0054290267,
0.030228626,
0.0580354258,
-0.0282069314,
0.0208217688,
-0.0363522731,
-0.0649608672,
-0.0153238475,
0.0278251525,
-0.0210873131,
0.0142020388,
0.0099908495,
0.0336165652,
-0.0955768228,
-0.0136443414,
0.0487584248,
-0.0372260511,
-0.0716223791,
0.0447786786,
-0.0085892919,
-0.0124560427,
0.003512159,
-0.0051984577,
0.0358112864,
0.0400143974,
0.0117875533,
-0.0115212183,
-0.0427053645,
-0.0052691237,
-0.0373886265,
0.0063395253,
-0.0177332275,
0.0333622508,
-0.0139660966,
-0.0253778007,
-0.0411594808,
-0.0013271867,
-0.0119343577,
0.0580747202,
-0.048159536,
0.0015449987,
-0.0150137749,
-0.0029311331,
-0.0540582351,
0.0437687524,
0.0326499976,
0.0240646079,
0.0379037261,
0.0066950521,
-0.0060807634,
-0.0453862362,
-0.0025205254,
0.0128326043,
-0.0032558762,
-0.0027949493,
0.0227194931,
0.02650778,
-0.0476308055,
0.0086404448,
-0.0851674601,
0.0138811134,
-0.0254420768,
-0.0190640576,
0.0266585406,
0.0259777382,
-0.0112873567,
-0.0117657948,
-0.0127002867,
-0.0625880882,
0.004417886,
0.0468151718,
-0.00962687,
0.0315121822,
0.002820373,
-0.0317271054,
-0.0478023179,
-0.004569836,
0.0830359906,
0.0266458001,
0.0095674861,
0.0039766822,
0.0364069417,
-0.0373250842,
0.0172181781,
-0.0115449559,
0.0173797607,
-0.0001733665,
-0.0672770962,
0.0022182772,
0.0469218343,
0.0258864462,
-0.0319807045,
0.05824624,
-0.0070288,
-0.1075913012,
0.0162562151,
-0.0583434477,
-0.0262460653,
0.0012869228,
-0.0513759293,
0.0148003455,
0.0009956516,
-0.019783549,
-0.0101662213,
-0.0626104251,
0.0410546325,
-0.0041187219,
-0.0428292453,
-0.0633079633,
0.0314835012,
0.0398067236,
0.053583432,
-0.0123715699,
-0.0328561962,
0.0581424944,
-0.0022394264,
-0.0065702843,
-0.0482894629,
0.0314430185,
-0.0344641767,
0.0375616997,
-0.0158778224,
0.0049011665,
-0.0004584555,
0.0099394098,
-0.0389458798,
0.0042376765,
0.0066284337,
-0.0225211196,
0.0304276608,
-0.0168429576,
0.043343395,
0.0141162891,
-0.0060714441,
-0.0440243036,
-0.0566431917,
0.031763535,
0.0171451475,
-0.0159325972,
-0.0145823425,
-0.0436702669,
0.0216508545,
0.0263524037,
0.0415111482,
-0.0405736901,
-0.0497831218,
0.0194060858,
-0.0028309475,
0.0563514084,
-0.0305339359,
-0.019122012,
0.0050548147,
0.0420302525,
0.0135400556,
0.094233498,
-0.0291380584,
0.0104880752,
-0.0105422297,
0.0282299854,
-0.0102374172,
-0.0192153286,
0.0121326782,
-0.0200453307,
-0.0289507285,
-0.0522780903,
0.0774918497,
0.0347613953,
-0.0679944828,
-0.0178710036,
-0.0396252982,
0.0488569178,
0.0427760109,
0.0748511329,
-0.0653361604,
-0.0224409513,
0.0152615616,
0.0585550629,
-0.0105827646,
-0.0222617388,
-0.0436598696,
-0.1265732348,
0.0622959882,
-0.0167974792,
-0.0102627557,
0.0100818537,
-0.0411389023,
0.0050242743,
-0.0268462878,
-0.0172939114,
0.0566296242,
-0.0250820089,
0.0068634329,
0.0154033685,
0.0490304269,
-0.0649143234,
-0.0092553254,
-0.004627496,
-0.0055459281,
0.0375624411,
0.0201027021,
0.0515681989,
-0.0136759337,
0.004045052,
-0.0483467206,
0.0242781546,
-0.0640937984,
0.0795068294,
-0.0294491276,
0.0116531299,
-0.0059661348,
-0.0097810533,
-0.025660472,
0.0183037613,
-0.0214749239,
0.0652353242,
-0.051666975,
0.0094792238,
-0.0692262426,
-0.0302464031,
-0.0115166875,
0.0769376978,
0.0208812933,
-0.0086178845,
-0.0388077423,
-0.0204097629,
0.0093387365,
-0.0659099296,
-0.0295086633,
-0.001594885,
-0.0374286026,
-0.0327511281,
-0.022541387,
-0.0343838148,
0.0286260918,
0.0545894392,
-0.0144255077,
0.0222177487,
-0.0596301295,
0.0048046885,
-0.0409005024,
0.0249612145,
-0.0401833355,
0.0012467909,
-0.0407768153,
0.0088218339,
0.0743151531,
-0.0412223078,
-0.0224064998,
-0.0316346511,
-0.011458369,
-0.0408558138,
-0.011876246,
0.0183180384,
0.0240258258,
0.0423279069,
-0.0407132693,
-0.0422697626,
0.0316150747,
0.0798773244,
-0.0323885418,
-0.0008553977,
0.0216270816,
-0.030842647,
-0.0096938014,
0.0543269254,
-0.0761294886,
0.021134926,
-0.00272058,
0.0541169345,
-0.0297657307,
-0.0185965877,
0.0482468642,
0.0250239428,
0.0538592227,
-0.0090711461,
0.019652281,
-0.0173893515,
0.0303207021,
-0.0217641816,
-0.0349364877,
-0.0377447419,
0.0395875983,
0.0137399361,
0.0063859122,
0.0029496436,
0.031239802,
-0.0735591501,
0.0617677979,
-0.0321726911,
-0.0379635245,
0.0241139606,
0.0054187533,
0.0095620835,
-0.004578073,
-0.0129091907,
0.0202032942,
0.0003555492,
0.0350771882,
-0.0502177663,
-0.0049312161,
0.0305553116,
0.008728045,
-0.0156357847,
-0.0001692352,
-0.0975129381,
-0.0398127511,
-0.042416241,
0.0079223961,
0.0450857542,
0.0023327565,
-0.0094759408,
0.0076243347,
-0.0034881847,
-0.0121508529,
0.0000620188,
0.03809065,
-0.0380871184,
0.0187093522,
0.044201117,
0.0004309122,
0.0146104228,
0.0812476426,
0.016391037,
0.0682973787,
-0.0352245383,
-0.0304221213,
-0.0179594159,
-0.0218852423,
0.0557633862,
0.0245036837,
-0.0058689276,
-0.0016674253,
-0.0626391694,
-0.0345746763,
0.0117251957,
-0.0078360504,
-0.0244514346,
0.0010132166,
0.0628173649,
0.0765167326,
0.0058223321,
-0.0172301996,
-0.0387862995,
-0.0002584372,
-0.0159088559,
-0.0183719508,
-0.0118971206,
-5.923369298e-33,
-0.0087489067,
-0.0136393039,
0.0304376688,
-0.0290932097,
-0.0112903798,
-0.0034069538,
-0.0177912991,
-0.0308262855,
-0.0383996032,
-0.0178114232,
-0.0491475277,
0.0332284421,
0.0130925681,
-0.0006993682,
-0.0046201302,
-0.0217776112,
0.0494602323,
-0.012333977,
-0.0217431486,
0.0346400142,
0.0520968884,
0.0386173427,
0.02395574,
-0.0188581552,
-0.0018348102,
-0.0279473606,
-0.00014355,
0.0396030545,
-0.0183965899,
0.0732842684,
0.0063144714,
0.056885235,
0.0324288495,
-0.0505247414,
-0.0050718994,
0.0034794142,
-0.0387336873,
-0.0599495582,
0.0106563764,
-0.0125677269,
-0.0296628531,
0.0029418019,
0.0381173566,
-0.0030360296,
-0.0148069933,
-0.0076849349,
0.031676922,
0.0158942696,
-0.0605871752,
-0.0518413372,
-0.0264778677,
0.0117136203,
0.0349053741,
-0.0211664531,
0.0120826848,
0.0946893394,
0.0194476824,
0.0559499189,
-0.0055554686,
0.0466059744,
-0.0361102484,
0.0701069459,
0.0629922375,
0.020442659,
0.0084403148,
0.0328051113,
0.0213604439,
-0.0146212904,
0.0258098003,
-0.0407909527,
0.0444064699,
0.018182788,
0.0250734184,
0.0739627108,
0.0700355247,
0.030839812,
-0.0401186645,
0.0453799739,
-0.0060881623,
0.0263998881,
0.0110290889,
0.0168827754,
-0.0332643539,
-0.0260992199,
-0.0525623001,
-0.0004960192,
-0.0742655322,
-0.0073197349,
0.0534633398,
0.0405166224,
-0.0231609084,
-0.0003238521,
0.0584699251,
-0.0157169327,
-0.0043415721,
0.0422512218,
-0.0025623965,
-0.0008083489,
-0.0007812592,
0.0008260266,
-0.0156749506,
-0.0307294931,
0.0525541343,
-0.0125570614,
-0.0405820385,
-0.0139049217,
0.007267667,
0.0289575979,
-0.0261497293,
-0.0350585282,
-0.0175279453,
0.0136264917,
-0.0114339544,
-0.0229866747,
0.0205156337,
0.0496440232,
0.0015472629,
0.0731685683,
0.026493581,
0.0030324552,
-0.0065802536,
-0.0459893383,
0.0062980712,
0.0275713205,
-0.0244804285,
0.015935313,
-0.0156169981,
0.0226539206,
0.0221802201,
-0.0479614884,
-0.0361930057,
0.0746446922,
2.457e-7,
0.0561204143,
0.022402931,
-0.0155178756,
0.0342932716,
-0.0164303314,
0.0263777841,
-0.0026007297,
0.0136699937,
0.0290897768,
0.0059566665,
0.0270251986,
-0.0021732675,
0.0200349987,
0.0129005378,
-0.0751128271,
-0.0333323926,
-0.049343057,
-0.0213831477,
-0.0525234826,
-0.0286698472,
0.0422438942,
0.1096121967,
-0.0024803507,
-0.0215957034,
-0.0120021431,
-0.064594917,
0.0426697135,
0.0098731415,
-0.0157868601,
0.0303114466,
0.0229692832,
0.0131103043,
0.0242922027,
0.0186988432,
-0.0342095271,
0.0090169441,
0.0091498485,
0.0266100802,
-0.0206624549,
-0.0424238779,
0.0153896715,
-0.0149637572,
0.014183227,
-0.0438056998,
0.0934222713,
-0.0237637535,
0.0344268233,
0.0269349478,
-0.0201727916,
0.0287543945,
0.0197314899,
-0.0467344485,
-0.0296836291,
-0.0021369248,
0.0234734528,
0.0045858445,
-0.0081862761,
-0.0607302263,
-0.0018356408,
-0.0221006405,
-0.0426842943,
-0.0223976914,
-0.0345670208,
0.0243693627,
-0.0065435083,
-0.0098613389,
-0.0164334532,
2.360219776e-34,
0.0475606062,
0.0193496738,
0.0024878019,
-0.0007773261,
-0.0146605792,
-0.0011924386,
-0.0146276532,
0.0047439383,
0.0364301987,
-0.1018954888,
-0.0325785093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07925v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07925v1 | Brain-Driven Representation Learning Based on Diffusion Model | 2023-11-14T05:59:58 | 2023-11-14T05:59:58 | Soowon Kim, Seo-Hyun Lee, Young-Eun Lee, Ji-Won Lee, Ji-Ha Park, Seong-Whan Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Interpreting EEG signals linked to spoken language presents a complex
challenge, given the data's intricate temporal and spatial attributes, as well
as the various noise factors. Denoising diffusion probabilistic models (DDPMs),
which have recently gained prominence in diverse areas for their capabilities
in representation learning, are explored in our research as a means to address
this issue. Using DDPMs in conjunction with a conditional autoencoder, our new
approach considerably outperforms traditional machine learning algorithms and
established baseline models in accuracy. Our results highlight the potential of
DDPMs as a sophisticated computational method for the analysis of
speech-related EEG signals. This could lead to significant advances in
brain-computer interfaces tailored for spoken communication. | [
-0.0386067554,
0.0301765632,
-0.01723627,
-0.0106999157,
0.0053832564,
0.0137264887,
0.0293593518,
0.0182424709,
0.0233833343,
0.0100692343,
-0.0140819149,
-0.0499924272,
0.0431040786,
0.0767482445,
0.035659615,
-0.011706314,
0.0352536961,
-0.0109973289,
-0.0014359686,
-0.0654288903,
0.0190551542,
-0.0085359896,
-0.0645418838,
0.022960458,
-0.0137732839,
0.0474940948,
-0.0186906233,
-0.0282276385,
-0.0149420956,
-0.0180392787,
-0.0671803579,
0.0391004719,
0.0502613634,
-0.0693488792,
0.0000019203,
0.0155500798,
0.0288470984,
-0.0382302925,
-0.0412424728,
-0.062088985,
-0.0176614989,
0.0357240215,
0.0348717906,
-0.0169847459,
-0.0095472448,
-0.0303327218,
0.0598727278,
0.0328127369,
0.0539477989,
0.0336966105,
-0.0246731266,
-0.0118597904,
0.0633390248,
-0.0522552244,
0.0370198078,
0.0248894934,
0.019531263,
-0.0050132931,
-0.0148863113,
-0.0354271941,
-0.0395631567,
0.0232272428,
0.0196776539,
0.0153138256,
0.0732751787,
0.0392348878,
0.0610283948,
-0.066387251,
-0.0317322761,
0.0507682897,
0.0188070685,
0.0078680459,
-0.0008940155,
0.0013461516,
-0.0203121454,
0.0519276969,
-0.0205905642,
-0.0373319089,
0.0508077629,
0.0444061235,
-0.0194134619,
-0.005328902,
0.0446343906,
-0.0406427644,
-0.0302305166,
0.051460214,
0.0103267729,
-0.0104884757,
0.0139030702,
-0.0075367042,
0.0029741055,
-0.0203794967,
0.0389712825,
-0.005091649,
-0.0170213748,
-0.0446529165,
-0.01007389,
-0.0424310677,
-0.0321659707,
0.0370058827,
-0.0468052179,
0.045440454,
0.0530366749,
-0.014319378,
-0.0296312496,
-0.0280416291,
-0.0187939871,
-0.024743231,
-0.0084286472,
-0.0115070669,
-0.0117105916,
0.0161114875,
0.0235624276,
0.036797516,
0.0105554005,
-0.0346367992,
-0.0492753536,
-0.0142957941,
-0.0312283002,
-0.0181791726,
0.0256897528,
0.015781939,
-0.010390996,
0.0229055919,
-0.0124735832,
0.0176174343,
-0.0156137897,
0.0318106972,
0.0307037123,
0.0235134531,
-0.0158457216,
0.0185486451,
0.0436008386,
-0.0234948974,
-0.0361238457,
0.0208747257,
0.0401839614,
0.0170014966,
-0.0321699195,
0.0175625104,
-0.0036412308,
0.0298132375,
0.0190805793,
-0.0809578821,
0.0037333791,
-0.0081079863,
0.0090866974,
-0.0779668763,
0.0020369666,
-0.0739830211,
-0.0035622215,
0.0372013263,
-0.0148765361,
0.0012725882,
0.1003213152,
0.0155143132,
0.0087435693,
0.0055589629,
0.0291418172,
-0.018176388,
-0.0406733714,
-0.0329685286,
-0.0296992306,
0.0224696361,
0.0280584116,
-0.0175963063,
-0.0552405007,
-0.0810986981,
-0.0104363048,
0.0033665642,
0.0683245957,
0.0181468204,
-0.0322263911,
-0.0246537533,
0.0447387956,
0.0693537444,
-0.0275221374,
-0.0297808778,
0.0062263398,
0.0509097762,
-0.0739439949,
-0.04532912,
0.0518671423,
0.0018404116,
0.0180422105,
-0.0193052609,
0.0506720394,
-0.0475113094,
-0.0054593175,
-0.033950951,
0.047839392,
-0.0644764155,
0.0612315387,
0.0594840683,
0.0560741536,
-0.0427859873,
-0.0028091881,
0.028405739,
0.0457465313,
-0.0191319045,
0.035722129,
-0.0079485513,
0.0386241116,
-0.0095636798,
0.0086023454,
-0.0070811603,
0.0359368138,
-0.0456935167,
-0.0129217971,
0.0033767051,
-0.0145351486,
0.0244172886,
0.0251281634,
-0.0330504552,
-0.0778474584,
0.042851422,
0.0083387913,
0.0105577596,
-0.0630052388,
0.0304434299,
0.0201064218,
0.0068234568,
-0.0087476475,
0.0004757016,
-0.0045743911,
0.0316088535,
0.0529353358,
-0.0026728869,
0.0493962206,
0.0038319449,
-0.0750645027,
0.0120671485,
0.002518656,
-0.0616853796,
-0.030796377,
-0.0326095149,
-0.0419302806,
-0.0243310109,
0.0006207955,
0.003798763,
-0.0066743251,
0.0201068558,
0.0246216301,
-0.037302576,
0.0324153304,
-0.030245401,
0.0205493793,
-0.009838799,
-0.0145696346,
-0.0059000584,
0.0357934088,
-0.0103832837,
0.0175296366,
-0.0236006547,
-0.0239190068,
0.0219067391,
0.0212957449,
0.0473122634,
-0.0494670048,
-0.0409116596,
-0.0372435451,
-0.0065230979,
-0.0498888195,
0.0163350347,
-0.0267103035,
-0.0166425481,
0.02936613,
-0.0653253123,
-0.0245579742,
-0.0091566276,
0.0011007595,
0.0035257332,
0.0471314192,
-0.0052402713,
0.0129263336,
-0.0093223173,
0.0138208112,
0.0195898637,
-0.0296983235,
-0.0168428365,
-0.0371150672,
-0.002128962,
-0.013367367,
-0.0209253933,
-0.0487928651,
0.0537037887,
-0.0256166514,
-0.0453093313,
-0.0040313853,
0.0502978228,
0.0010360683,
0.0395262241,
-0.0044734771,
-0.0017672557,
0.0199026447,
-0.0284977071,
0.0403862149,
0.0242675543,
0.0098427515,
0.0004021371,
0.0300517995,
-0.0283538699,
-0.0086850924,
-0.0199806206,
-0.0326257423,
0.1071577743,
-0.0346230417,
-0.0302048605,
-0.0328735486,
0.0301160868,
0.084951058,
0.0203544889,
-0.0256927665,
-0.0190212075,
0.005654322,
-0.035363365,
-0.0136130042,
-0.0208347049,
-0.0192048624,
0.0370408855,
-0.0359716639,
-0.0027624501,
0.0685267001,
-0.0259337984,
0.0308467634,
-0.0313166566,
-0.0280080996,
0.0411240757,
-0.0315410756,
0.0274203029,
0.0200330466,
-0.0323933028,
0.0021415937,
0.0143336542,
0.0276786294,
-0.0286236517,
0.0155739523,
-0.0071901567,
0.0037056704,
-0.0143354284,
0.0647144318,
0.0226404406,
-0.0529693402,
-0.0501082279,
0.0211071242,
-0.0083953785,
-0.0251826234,
0.0496876203,
-0.0380700268,
-0.0068835919,
0.0066606426,
0.0091078393,
0.0240181983,
-0.0124814827,
0.0194414165,
0.0831974074,
0.0466654524,
0.0573124662,
-0.0283664986,
-0.0085342964,
0.0056262305,
-0.0001098414,
0.0253506266,
0.0172371604,
-0.0501354523,
0.0352393314,
-0.0359978117,
0.002570064,
0.017292669,
0.0281354561,
0.0368882716,
-0.0056629637,
0.0021235063,
0.1044252142,
-0.0063870936,
-0.1015729234,
-0.0054120114,
-0.0355426818,
0.0730591863,
0.0086354828,
-0.0281259362,
-0.0392353833,
-0.0275454335,
-0.0418205224,
-0.0053708279,
0.015021693,
0.0131130554,
0.0470493734,
-0.0224057734,
0.0176784638,
0.0216289759,
0.0358911976,
-0.0136174485,
-0.0930142179,
0.0205806494,
-0.0044623562,
0.0240565818,
-0.074001886,
0.0227430426,
0.0085215196,
0.0421504304,
-0.0213684607,
-0.0813981369,
-0.0089491522,
-0.0020465299,
0.0808345824,
0.0439726524,
-0.0190552995,
-0.0497521162,
-0.0525392927,
-0.00221489,
-0.0106078293,
-0.0331189521,
-0.0236629788,
-0.0030491746,
0.0346310101,
-0.0025864008,
0.0153915072,
0.0350441523,
-0.0515955165,
-0.0393908136,
-0.023499269,
0.0870987028,
-0.0631404519,
-0.0126541816,
-0.0063542468,
-0.0189063363,
0.0577280708,
-0.0005079792,
0.0755736157,
-0.0490760431,
-0.0181410313,
-0.0089615947,
0.0785794929,
0.0616925061,
-0.0596744791,
-0.0313634314,
0.0145528559,
-0.0531279817,
-0.0287088603,
-0.0076854038,
0.007232782,
0.0227868631,
0.0471991599,
0.0614118688,
0.0922932327,
-0.0684926286,
-0.0288261939,
0.036709927,
0.0414050594,
-0.0135315517,
0.0036308945,
-0.0119021581,
0.0033181268,
-0.0304557625,
-0.0151261017,
0.0004335101,
-0.0722835064,
-0.0472949855,
0.0260570943,
-0.0045832717,
0.0123140533,
0.0182150584,
-0.0257510841,
-0.0390783437,
0.0971508622,
-0.0013736454,
-0.0050252499,
0.0488151237,
-0.0130715817,
0.006966712,
-0.017422663,
-0.0117984135,
-0.0250200592,
0.047826916,
-0.0392326228,
0.009140403,
-0.030191008,
0.0550877899,
-0.040533822,
-0.0115869092,
0.0546246357,
-0.0194431935,
0.0533416532,
-0.0419701599,
-0.0109089036,
0.0212616436,
0.0260708444,
-0.0169164706,
-0.0399779677,
0.0541684888,
0.0171587002,
-0.0037336869,
0.0014059993,
-0.0135986041,
-0.0550843701,
-0.0216815751,
0.0064982977,
-0.0030434986,
-0.0127360746,
-0.017598236,
0.0232292358,
0.000343257,
0.0241237413,
0.0068794922,
0.0311276577,
-0.0160381049,
0.0485429168,
-0.0098170722,
-0.0133141801,
-0.0323103853,
-0.0098108863,
-0.0109874392,
-0.0657618493,
0.0671649277,
-0.0141839432,
0.0055861725,
-0.0082963007,
0.0358831063,
0.0326170921,
0.0401277058,
-0.0496641919,
0.0315754935,
-0.0447492898,
0.0106234746,
0.0562526584,
-0.0161622353,
0.0155644976,
0.0236537196,
0.0394552574,
-0.0238079671,
0.0236683637,
-0.0396350846,
0.0051516299,
-0.0256876629,
-0.0415775739,
-0.0093872938,
0.0462358445,
-0.0565454736,
0.0222406369,
0.009541316,
-0.0423856564,
-0.0292518791,
-0.0281347446,
0.0206893571,
-0.024811212,
0.030379869,
-0.0125112282,
-0.0197526533,
0.0137545448,
0.0156524628,
-0.013968355,
0.0044840449,
-0.0422253273,
-0.0170107689,
-6.096183866e-33,
0.0212163012,
-0.013956055,
-0.0582091548,
-0.0093233967,
-0.0307300314,
-0.0252750237,
-0.0672622621,
0.0442652367,
0.0412468538,
0.0039587161,
0.0146014635,
0.0509513579,
0.0095937997,
0.020789165,
0.0237803757,
0.0040988289,
0.0072251116,
-0.0319309048,
0.0148671772,
0.0091029974,
-0.0032643967,
0.0280499794,
0.0432707034,
-0.0740117803,
0.0116454568,
0.0297535062,
0.0398354307,
-0.0236362442,
0.0156231457,
-0.0110150808,
-0.0701306388,
0.0486438386,
0.0202342123,
0.0598927736,
-0.0174809471,
-0.0145275425,
-0.0063241622,
-0.0138600403,
-0.0428423956,
-0.0246607736,
-0.0635749549,
-0.0161450729,
0.1442888379,
0.0347347967,
-0.0051245266,
0.0502876341,
0.0539434813,
0.0145901954,
-0.0340146087,
0.0226638839,
0.0031382414,
0.0017443565,
-0.0278495401,
0.0261858478,
0.0331928581,
-0.011338993,
-0.0512158535,
0.0247980133,
-0.091016233,
0.0066609764,
-0.0292381272,
0.0238291342,
0.0401772261,
-0.0399591587,
0.067730844,
0.0718425065,
0.0985164717,
0.0287593547,
-0.0341248922,
-0.0012687278,
0.0442565791,
0.036243327,
-0.0191321895,
-0.0362783819,
0.0197940338,
-0.0582141541,
-0.0851607099,
0.0399245135,
-0.0203786455,
0.0447943956,
0.0141577534,
-0.0149165504,
-0.0060272543,
-0.0475850813,
-0.0217422154,
-0.0181151405,
0.0111925369,
-0.0008303627,
0.0048598996,
-0.0842918828,
-0.0137885669,
-0.0459006913,
0.0446299203,
-0.0202023815,
0.0223214738,
-0.0515916757,
0.0135622034,
0.0093513299,
0.0571752861,
-0.0313530527,
-0.0465530753,
0.0038364443,
-0.0021978552,
0.0002596865,
0.0371869691,
-0.012299058,
-0.1022526473,
0.0346827656,
0.0324758627,
-0.0311486274,
-0.0171951558,
-0.0253428742,
0.0221864525,
0.0529714935,
0.0341257453,
-0.014674142,
0.0023514086,
-0.009833022,
-0.0370980017,
0.0123580843,
-0.0071789459,
-0.0264537763,
0.0452199876,
0.0488438532,
-0.0218149237,
-0.0358750932,
-0.0350879543,
0.0489794612,
0.0519764014,
-0.0266207773,
-0.0328360945,
0.0272526573,
2.784e-7,
0.0158042498,
0.0159295574,
-0.0217567086,
0.0162733104,
0.0163159724,
0.0256914478,
-0.0249155797,
-0.0216060113,
-0.0109897088,
-0.0819839835,
0.03350031,
0.067745626,
0.029170081,
-0.0517928228,
0.0046771946,
-0.0390058979,
-0.0020262455,
0.0328741297,
-0.0065274467,
-0.0036044777,
-0.003382511,
0.0359603241,
-0.0049722334,
-0.0164635796,
0.075074017,
0.0574184023,
0.0916192532,
-0.0202147923,
0.0197224077,
0.0162296128,
0.0034798975,
-0.0368495286,
0.0114562521,
0.0438617468,
0.0141255315,
0.0388409607,
0.0021749509,
-0.018105872,
-0.0594780482,
-0.0348593444,
-0.0048716548,
-0.001408982,
0.0063759494,
0.0228325017,
0.0364319757,
-0.0177986305,
-0.0624938644,
0.0277543291,
-0.0366349854,
0.0208585709,
0.1058490723,
0.0108836964,
-0.0479963832,
-0.0717388988,
-0.0186981577,
0.0088601466,
0.0171181783,
-0.0175473504,
0.0222866293,
0.0200658925,
-0.1054116189,
0.0093324548,
-0.001285055,
-0.0224332456,
0.0117441658,
0.0288786869,
0.0151913567,
1.818627973e-34,
-0.0150253456,
0.0093294419,
-0.0233605523,
0.0201523229,
-0.0059436504,
-0.0447502546,
-0.0123134144,
-0.0407461524,
-0.0015207949,
-0.0553365014,
-0.0297297798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07919v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07919v2 | Qwen-Audio: Advancing Universal Audio Understanding via Unified Large-Scale Audio-Language Models | 2023-11-14T05:34:50 | 2023-12-21T10:20:42 | Yunfei Chu, Jin Xu, Xiaohuan Zhou, Qian Yang, Shiliang Zhang, Zhijie Yan, Chang Zhou, Jingren Zhou | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recently, instruction-following audio-language models have received broad
attention for audio interaction with humans. However, the absence of
pre-trained audio models capable of handling diverse audio types and tasks has
hindered progress in this field. Consequently, most existing works have only
been able to support a limited range of interaction capabilities. In this
paper, we develop the Qwen-Audio model and address this limitation by scaling
up audio-language pre-training to cover over 30 tasks and various audio types,
such as human speech, natural sounds, music, and songs, to facilitate universal
audio understanding abilities. However, directly co-training all tasks and
datasets can lead to interference issues, as the textual labels associated with
different datasets exhibit considerable variations due to differences in task
focus, language, granularity of annotation, and text structure. To overcome the
one-to-many interference, we carefully design a multi-task training framework
by conditioning on a sequence of hierarchical tags to the decoder for
encouraging knowledge sharing and avoiding interference through shared and
specified tags respectively. Remarkably, Qwen-Audio achieves impressive
performance across diverse benchmark tasks without requiring any task-specific
fine-tuning, surpassing its counterparts. Building upon the capabilities of
Qwen-Audio, we further develop Qwen-Audio-Chat, which allows for input from
various audios and text inputs, enabling multi-turn dialogues and supporting
various audio-central scenarios. | [
-0.0056243325,
-0.025063891,
-0.0019625935,
0.0440805852,
0.0188793186,
-0.0060013686,
0.0448213927,
-0.0410176776,
-0.0221387912,
-0.0055344491,
-0.0993634239,
0.0014362951,
0.0135318991,
0.0358459763,
0.0158564616,
-0.0791262314,
0.0253533162,
-0.0490125008,
0.017044561,
-0.0160689168,
-0.0059872381,
0.0049395743,
-0.060599152,
0.0524753407,
-0.0270264558,
-0.0095231449,
-0.0360657834,
0.043495968,
0.0170129128,
-0.0084389523,
-0.0142279295,
0.0298559759,
0.0651222542,
0.0015080092,
0.0000015593,
-0.0022292663,
0.0148090506,
-0.0118110543,
-0.0311490688,
-0.0225781407,
-0.0155903762,
0.0144262007,
-0.0371653475,
0.0078903139,
-0.0102417115,
-0.0240654796,
0.0464183055,
0.050706923,
0.0771369785,
0.0314681605,
-0.0105800359,
-0.0401037447,
-0.0160745438,
-0.0328656472,
0.0325015821,
-0.086829938,
-0.0113470005,
0.0291679185,
0.0295293592,
0.0242719743,
-0.0360332727,
0.0576970242,
0.0399152301,
0.0253657699,
0.0507592522,
0.0351582952,
-0.0429544412,
-0.0221442822,
-0.0329167023,
0.1002888829,
0.0214067567,
-0.0100376885,
0.000075157,
0.0400329828,
0.0080520147,
-0.0558724105,
-0.0489075221,
-0.0043156291,
-0.0157274846,
0.0102780983,
-0.0425867103,
0.0365664251,
0.040993277,
-0.0439239591,
0.0089704562,
0.0348683484,
-0.0060633146,
-0.0230070781,
0.0258400571,
-0.0157495793,
-0.0290970262,
-0.0217697863,
0.0479600951,
0.0020308625,
-0.0502352193,
-0.0203625876,
-0.0296463128,
-0.0075731217,
-0.0334884338,
-0.0264146253,
0.0196370222,
0.0368774012,
-0.0566351302,
0.0874067247,
0.0325271226,
-0.0039316933,
0.0053345244,
-0.0244122948,
-0.0062062438,
-0.0127477329,
-0.0371183269,
-0.0333780274,
-0.0166032277,
-0.010802228,
-0.0304074064,
-0.057006862,
0.0050806203,
0.0161009077,
-0.0534481965,
0.0325152613,
0.0396415852,
0.0010672192,
-0.0483789854,
0.0073878258,
0.0497457571,
0.0541586466,
-0.0299085695,
0.0736611411,
-0.0104981968,
-0.0356495455,
-0.0258357506,
0.0092285704,
0.0243312251,
-0.0252678376,
-0.0104877846,
0.0586799644,
-0.0229524393,
0.003779782,
-0.0020662688,
-0.0175450612,
-0.0178356953,
-0.0137626324,
-0.0091220345,
-0.0076825735,
0.0583244264,
-0.0275338218,
-0.0051812008,
0.0016445637,
-0.0123070432,
-0.0096734818,
0.0024313265,
0.078768082,
0.0016706575,
0.0493163578,
0.0560596026,
0.0543785691,
-0.0233133305,
0.0468768924,
0.0701362565,
0.0035349352,
0.0270456932,
-0.0567007437,
-0.0365198143,
0.0694708154,
0.0041381191,
-0.0323022455,
0.0203040373,
-0.0134030841,
-0.0049860994,
0.0469788685,
0.0311976485,
0.0264402777,
-0.0535258502,
-0.0488133132,
0.0582474358,
0.0109218992,
0.0000392042,
-0.0106768254,
0.0357670784,
0.0266977232,
-0.0049054497,
0.0114553887,
-0.0329861231,
0.0637683645,
0.018958617,
0.0064894655,
0.048114676,
0.0114473812,
-0.0312087182,
-0.0057508652,
0.0042289509,
-0.0056264806,
0.0101918792,
0.0030146434,
0.0302095395,
0.0340920202,
-0.0240937565,
0.0158890355,
-0.0063184486,
-0.0664011464,
-0.0055731609,
0.0080194827,
0.0131009733,
0.0798655674,
0.0306538437,
-0.0335997455,
-0.0060700513,
-0.0141579006,
0.0271232091,
0.0385905765,
0.0273602549,
-0.0337785669,
0.0730786771,
-0.0453990661,
-0.0591429509,
-0.0169766061,
-0.0033947115,
0.0525849201,
-0.0096299192,
-0.0115789883,
0.0035973517,
-0.0199630391,
0.0498700589,
-0.0109824939,
-0.0220086388,
-0.027044598,
-0.0162542053,
0.0151364515,
0.0493376255,
0.0458289757,
-0.0540868305,
-0.0009399212,
0.0249086637,
-0.0252189841,
0.0125416992,
0.0410423242,
-0.083142668,
-0.0222023781,
0.0260864757,
-0.0405552462,
-0.0098366486,
0.0447270125,
-0.008080665,
-0.0387114435,
0.0367029458,
0.0033251666,
0.0592142977,
0.0045780656,
-0.001555538,
0.0286663305,
0.0022575504,
0.0314079151,
-0.0004496217,
0.0250038747,
-0.0197801236,
0.0106694652,
-0.0011173279,
0.0092789428,
-0.0486694649,
-0.0387428552,
0.0261934474,
-0.0050812252,
-0.0124472734,
-0.0226678085,
-0.0197984092,
-0.0441752113,
0.0072942395,
-0.0968761817,
0.0124676954,
-0.0355683602,
0.0005452527,
0.0092995223,
0.008673436,
0.0094510941,
-0.0735015944,
-0.0192404073,
0.0035023035,
-0.0175978635,
0.0128132962,
-0.0751984566,
0.0143162804,
-0.0054484764,
-0.0099306088,
-0.0121576516,
0.0424195081,
-0.002974174,
-0.0010534019,
-0.0276052076,
0.0129330512,
-0.0045863092,
-0.0032737195,
0.0261456296,
-0.0133546824,
0.0079874471,
0.0005888234,
0.0091057112,
0.0421475284,
0.0595814735,
-0.0117940055,
0.0258923918,
0.0264769234,
-0.0322023667,
-0.0542401336,
0.0223645959,
0.0285973605,
-0.0072387983,
-0.0462246723,
0.024574466,
-0.0267930534,
0.0841472819,
0.0387326814,
0.0256133322,
-0.0639885291,
-0.0539864004,
-0.0260585025,
-0.0635148287,
-0.0403370261,
-0.0589911006,
-0.024651181,
0.015736375,
-0.0430240743,
-0.0138186254,
0.0557138436,
-0.053484261,
-0.0764967501,
-0.054854501,
-0.0492816791,
0.0033156173,
0.0612796843,
-0.0499955602,
0.0066027064,
0.0070920442,
-0.0299006794,
-0.0345220268,
0.0485086106,
0.0119809527,
-0.0496911965,
0.0000976459,
-0.0349118896,
-0.0123431571,
-0.0048643788,
-0.0300090071,
-0.0061358041,
0.0243063085,
-0.0234686565,
0.0092769228,
-0.0025874968,
-0.0125681469,
-0.0108544137,
0.0358680859,
0.0348074771,
0.0546732061,
-0.0022261019,
0.0196754541,
-0.026344832,
0.0273702685,
0.0118050193,
-0.0152123868,
-0.056786038,
-0.0429319739,
0.0469229519,
0.0182475988,
0.0520077348,
-0.0279050209,
-0.0244953167,
0.0311658792,
0.0290946793,
0.0232226681,
-0.0674046874,
0.0549948029,
0.0369720943,
-0.0757000819,
0.0087775309,
0.1141615137,
0.0234419275,
-0.0571945719,
-0.0101240855,
0.0020766272,
-0.0017765271,
0.0002607117,
-0.0235906597,
-0.0931467935,
-0.0417068452,
0.0515310094,
0.022540465,
0.0829259902,
0.0237134546,
0.0099581173,
-0.0493192896,
0.0267770216,
0.0181986671,
-0.0265872087,
-0.0396535359,
0.0070345062,
-0.0059644794,
-0.0143615836,
0.0399693921,
-0.0061185053,
-0.0005360306,
0.003727715,
0.0265333913,
0.0033437731,
-0.0522265472,
0.0431447551,
-0.0442394279,
0.0856448784,
0.0899677202,
0.043379277,
-0.0045689405,
-0.0103103844,
-0.007820447,
0.027563693,
-0.0120453872,
0.0047498373,
0.0448038541,
-0.0240485631,
0.0033124653,
0.0310278721,
0.0345897526,
-0.0205623042,
-0.0000117554,
0.0327568874,
0.0534713715,
-0.0115803601,
0.0062936526,
0.0085393041,
0.0575118065,
0.0273281336,
0.082293205,
0.0330208391,
-0.0186812151,
-0.0032325545,
-0.0186252501,
0.0072801346,
-0.0826854408,
0.0159280431,
0.0207367018,
-0.0236160159,
-0.0599845797,
-0.0169125125,
-0.0001550596,
0.0154272597,
-0.0015882887,
0.033030618,
-0.002003809,
0.0096003739,
0.0210975539,
-0.0528143384,
0.0377855264,
0.0180063564,
0.0685289949,
-0.0292558912,
-0.0388814248,
0.0447495542,
-0.0242018718,
0.0000572205,
0.0527454019,
-0.0612082332,
-0.0551276095,
0.0089603933,
-0.0028915706,
0.0235059056,
0.0723974258,
-0.0140423384,
-0.0309718587,
-0.0328359678,
-0.009732415,
-0.0650702938,
0.0632830784,
0.0536222346,
-0.000497802,
-0.0000205212,
0.0406667739,
-0.091998294,
0.0448342599,
-0.0368978903,
0.0302419011,
-0.0232295189,
-0.0567661561,
-0.0157923587,
-0.0614211485,
0.0343088396,
0.0092697842,
0.0353855677,
-0.0179610942,
0.0345815122,
-0.0129401172,
0.0189199187,
-0.0666466206,
-0.0047490462,
0.0225342289,
0.0222934317,
-0.0242162272,
0.0497138612,
0.0343073122,
0.0230228174,
-0.0390642136,
0.032260064,
0.0149973119,
-0.07867603,
0.0184814706,
-0.0157060083,
0.0234718453,
-0.0115670515,
0.0495033041,
0.0040440676,
0.0317509323,
0.068915911,
-0.0070673563,
-0.0107871732,
0.0217952151,
0.0498969294,
-0.0537387393,
-0.0200544763,
0.0163940135,
0.0068332893,
0.0427874736,
0.0037919634,
0.0180600919,
0.0288067944,
0.0160996579,
-0.0172697436,
0.0536949262,
-0.0379756093,
-0.0277353451,
0.0251219291,
-0.0083475206,
-0.0115857907,
0.0124468692,
0.057593327,
-0.0306006446,
0.0101488167,
-0.0268002301,
0.0251983833,
-0.0231942516,
-0.0345576927,
0.0049181958,
0.0440517589,
-0.0252838731,
0.0122963889,
0.0017011132,
-0.0715501681,
-0.02057725,
-0.0001945723,
0.0086564356,
-0.0039581796,
0.0503449924,
0.0354981832,
-0.0318086669,
-0.0223573614,
0.0255328324,
-0.0518685766,
-0.0220539067,
-0.017218817,
0.0037734576,
-5.236169423e-33,
-0.0457596928,
0.0117643783,
-0.0041342871,
-0.0002523919,
-0.0189204887,
-0.0321549214,
-0.0543472357,
-0.0176169202,
0.0001505621,
0.0013453327,
0.0245526955,
0.0477553755,
0.0242971089,
0.0181440562,
0.0174096283,
-0.0214361623,
0.0912137479,
-0.0482359044,
0.0036940498,
0.0328412764,
0.0391336456,
0.038859304,
0.0102261426,
-0.0455502532,
-0.0009780212,
0.0185002442,
-0.0051084301,
-0.0027811273,
0.009075338,
0.0248037837,
-0.0019583444,
0.0019388354,
-0.0117094042,
-0.0459179059,
-0.0202391092,
0.0566172451,
-0.1094614863,
0.0012263138,
-0.009016688,
0.0574681386,
-0.0163232349,
0.0034955922,
0.0249115583,
0.0177890435,
-0.0004100153,
-0.0377848148,
0.0325137712,
0.0060288012,
-0.0138143292,
-0.0545667894,
-0.0054140906,
0.0030615362,
-0.0595150404,
-0.0707845017,
0.0670541376,
0.0733200461,
0.0112956176,
-0.0144382352,
-0.075331226,
0.0461790487,
-0.0454096943,
-0.0102724396,
0.0485497564,
0.036819905,
-0.000108195,
0.0354254283,
0.008142774,
-0.0593790971,
-0.0176281352,
0.0007878648,
-0.0199821275,
0.0526618622,
-0.0236690491,
-0.0234884936,
0.0118570141,
0.0086006066,
-0.0060098763,
0.012060089,
0.0047446471,
0.0076295314,
-0.0350750908,
0.0679410398,
-0.0542525351,
0.02273193,
-0.0344237983,
0.0024364239,
-0.0124291461,
-0.0394415259,
0.0567592718,
-0.0016576246,
0.0206451863,
0.0036633981,
0.0631950572,
-0.0460782684,
0.0238339752,
0.0186068788,
-0.0091392575,
0.0182000697,
0.000036196,
0.0154550895,
-0.0487856269,
0.0104491357,
0.1060772464,
-0.0075479876,
0.0263899583,
-0.0221722052,
0.0062523386,
0.0671292171,
-0.0393644869,
-0.0263414755,
-0.0106721316,
0.0131412195,
0.0230484065,
0.0561670102,
0.0314485617,
0.0356457718,
-0.0534671172,
0.0529769436,
-0.0435343795,
0.0222784933,
-0.0453734025,
-0.0622426718,
-0.0492883064,
-0.0186487343,
-0.0337336324,
0.0071506645,
-0.0326664448,
-0.0469841771,
0.0283011496,
-0.0405440852,
-0.0370509028,
0.0348484106,
2.495e-7,
-0.0196304694,
-0.0342778899,
0.0120705403,
-0.0171856023,
0.0564579703,
0.0265999325,
-0.053461995,
0.0500061139,
-0.0198755823,
-0.0212994181,
0.0224142857,
0.0233216863,
0.076239951,
0.003437551,
-0.1283635795,
-0.0356622711,
-0.0777440444,
0.0175459869,
-0.0309225284,
-0.0010349627,
0.0329279304,
0.0861367807,
0.0103328032,
0.0107916575,
0.0423632674,
0.0074128592,
0.0356880352,
-0.0343216918,
0.0162572544,
-0.0209260061,
0.0012659617,
-0.0226633605,
-0.0403227657,
0.0215666518,
-0.0580443963,
0.0110456934,
0.0266221259,
0.0756843314,
0.0118920859,
-0.0606121123,
-0.047420226,
0.0338101946,
-0.026367113,
-0.0050822906,
0.0527701303,
-0.0258076526,
-0.0405655466,
-0.00328971,
-0.0432603434,
-0.0260988865,
-0.0353387631,
0.0165682063,
0.021950122,
-0.0280809235,
-0.008818537,
0.0041513159,
0.0015161311,
-0.0669081733,
0.0120246019,
0.0333468318,
-0.0814433917,
-0.0239319168,
-0.0335983448,
-0.0318732895,
0.0160323232,
-0.040571101,
-0.0170204695,
1.470504288e-34,
0.0077251652,
-0.0543118976,
0.0275714528,
0.011641196,
0.0065605189,
-0.0383397713,
-0.0283946265,
0.0069215698,
0.0157397483,
-0.0127201499,
-0.029299397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07918v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07918v1 | Automated title and abstract screening for scoping reviews using the GPT-4 Large Language Model | 2023-11-14T05:30:43 | 2023-11-14T05:30:43 | David Wilkins | cs.CL | cs.CL | Scoping reviews, a type of literature review, require intensive human effort
to screen large numbers of scholarly sources for their relevance to the review
objectives. This manuscript introduces GPTscreenR, a package for the R
statistical programming language that uses the GPT-4 Large Language Model (LLM)
to automatically screen sources. The package makes use of the chain-of-thought
technique with the goal of maximising performance on complex screening tasks.
In validation against consensus human reviewer decisions, GPTscreenR performed
similarly to an alternative zero-shot technique, with a sensitivity of 71%,
specificity of 89%, and overall accuracy of 84%. Neither method achieved
perfect accuracy nor human levels of intraobserver agreement. GPTscreenR
demonstrates the potential for LLMs to support scholarly work and provides a
user-friendly software framework that can be integrated into existing review
processes. | [
0.0469750129,
-0.0309560616,
-0.0156967398,
-0.0199292768,
-0.0215991326,
0.0194114819,
0.0590945743,
-0.0048094844,
-0.0067014406,
-0.0391371623,
-0.0250971764,
-0.0299505666,
0.0178178549,
0.0435714759,
0.0129262218,
0.0200759154,
0.0264259502,
-0.0086938478,
0.0456734076,
0.0182333197,
-0.0273217876,
0.0096647944,
0.0240250118,
0.0240058005,
0.0968730822,
-0.012605614,
0.0158665385,
-0.0391553454,
0.0144964298,
-0.0748420954,
0.0018530918,
0.0736965016,
0.0039242143,
0.0708279386,
0.0000024664,
-0.0463970788,
-0.0344658941,
0.0348933563,
0.0473909415,
0.0357540324,
0.0669186711,
-0.0054208818,
0.0124990502,
-0.0068642893,
0.0110892821,
-0.0430958122,
0.0245374013,
0.0346230827,
-0.0573914684,
-0.0207178798,
-0.0081528332,
-0.0022435286,
-0.00492456,
-0.0198370013,
0.0037133768,
-0.0130225196,
0.0482984446,
0.0313750096,
0.0327375084,
0.072863631,
0.0332138464,
0.0170059055,
-0.0459998064,
-0.0295688305,
0.0117073506,
0.0338677354,
-0.031728901,
-0.0364963338,
0.0415003188,
0.0234024134,
0.0583093986,
-0.0239382777,
0.0182511546,
-0.0160258953,
-0.022216212,
0.0798817798,
-0.0253461227,
-0.0073143924,
-0.0002670562,
-0.0234492011,
-0.0061524655,
0.013600572,
0.0145680644,
0.0258247051,
0.0114007154,
0.0186328012,
0.0095783239,
-0.0600312091,
0.0694062039,
0.026764201,
0.0083134091,
-0.0612507984,
-0.0092478115,
-0.0401592962,
-0.0113266632,
-0.0298853796,
0.0950781778,
0.0185501892,
0.0760847703,
0.0053424588,
0.0094326613,
-0.0384868942,
0.0135671273,
0.0095430352,
0.0274340212,
-0.0514572039,
-0.0348138772,
-0.0407955013,
0.0214609951,
0.0570082739,
-0.0306378528,
-0.0202300865,
0.018552579,
-0.0096014012,
-0.036646422,
-0.0043327436,
-0.0739285052,
-0.0207068492,
-0.0087740105,
-0.0174130164,
-0.0045261546,
-0.002896593,
-0.0241139811,
0.0348467901,
0.001728296,
0.0260981917,
0.0052293232,
0.0313227177,
-0.0422760546,
0.0461899191,
-0.0107333548,
0.0128106903,
0.0120208338,
-0.0159606058,
0.0227853805,
0.0259388257,
0.0289350934,
-0.038274087,
0.0602973849,
-0.0193288084,
-0.0506890602,
-0.0526727922,
0.0263714213,
-0.0685921237,
0.0009549132,
0.0044085891,
0.0376898646,
0.0201726388,
-0.0299137942,
0.009106799,
-0.0121430112,
0.0188429989,
-0.0885394067,
-0.0046658507,
-0.0202892404,
0.0121076927,
-0.0120958919,
0.0088888006,
-0.0494850427,
-0.0087538436,
0.0208479371,
-0.015579097,
0.050285358,
-0.0243076012,
-0.0558953285,
0.0424021222,
0.0607421547,
0.034941908,
0.0101086842,
-0.0046571922,
-0.016946163,
-0.0053643961,
-0.0757910609,
0.0204716735,
0.0353793651,
0.0943595842,
-0.0328178741,
0.0643772259,
-0.0036230322,
0.034212742,
0.0251534078,
-0.026649015,
0.0092550525,
0.0384225957,
-0.0113822464,
0.0111988047,
-0.0012452416,
0.0051793396,
0.0171423871,
-0.0193159226,
-0.0191122852,
0.0471757166,
-0.0195570234,
-0.0142231956,
0.0471942537,
-0.0221680887,
-0.0236864854,
-0.0375942774,
0.0275942534,
0.0280979536,
-0.0127454661,
-0.0107388059,
0.026580805,
0.0162211936,
0.044624798,
-0.0179046616,
-0.0195232742,
-0.0425264053,
-0.0091394112,
0.0234041978,
-0.0154069718,
0.0106403958,
-0.0079779923,
-0.0181405488,
-0.0336179957,
-0.0237148441,
-0.0055747447,
0.0433795191,
-0.015205903,
0.031079812,
-0.0165750328,
0.0191536751,
-0.0793594122,
0.0075008017,
0.0189819355,
0.0115093291,
0.0121052321,
-0.0459256098,
0.0540734008,
-0.0005189697,
-0.0468085632,
0.0253569074,
0.0289790258,
0.0367652811,
0.0100183059,
-0.0096624689,
0.0459036119,
0.0630514473,
-0.0053671333,
-0.0501981229,
-0.0056269509,
0.0143534774,
-0.0189253986,
0.0164494459,
0.0160554145,
0.0279785506,
-0.0146719432,
0.0048367162,
0.0138554033,
-0.0303935036,
-0.0257695317,
-0.0039713504,
0.0173097402,
0.0339861438,
0.0491975397,
-0.0106572602,
-0.0776132345,
0.0191964433,
-0.0259266198,
-0.055108048,
0.0294086598,
0.0032873065,
-0.0186569132,
0.0651486591,
0.0480860285,
-0.0127089173,
-0.0410269164,
-0.0598609596,
-0.003639038,
0.0445782654,
-0.0078548919,
-0.0102423681,
-0.0599887036,
0.0015060215,
0.0284197107,
0.0367081687,
-0.0503289253,
-0.0157189928,
0.009326118,
0.0351015963,
-0.0225554444,
-0.0006926141,
-0.0677246973,
-0.0347228907,
-0.0094226813,
0.0243796781,
0.0881545842,
-0.0253053717,
-0.0271903072,
0.0515942015,
-0.0225426201,
-0.0460643657,
-0.0146284606,
0.0232633129,
0.0263668001,
0.021369325,
-0.0407113768,
-0.009205251,
-0.0279297028,
-0.0545520857,
0.0960031301,
-0.0295535233,
-0.0285721719,
-0.0265137292,
0.0093854601,
-0.0274104867,
0.0178524666,
-0.0439927988,
0.0561419949,
-0.0093459142,
0.0056711072,
-0.0001221928,
-0.0192226134,
-0.0096575115,
-0.0407513455,
-0.0156424288,
-0.0400021821,
-0.0442684144,
-0.0302098058,
0.0636690706,
0.0068015056,
-0.0397001319,
0.0279163439,
-0.0169507246,
-0.0077461232,
-0.1178798452,
0.0546934791,
-0.0221168716,
-0.0067418795,
-0.0217806175,
-0.0243810844,
-0.0106360763,
0.0208087638,
0.0288408119,
-0.0023576163,
0.0155335832,
-0.0087716002,
0.0409975834,
-0.0189828444,
0.0204512253,
-0.0008970905,
0.00948512,
0.0336712636,
0.0161573365,
-0.0303205233,
-0.013622066,
0.0478582978,
-0.0214212835,
-0.0300213303,
0.0493345633,
0.0620089695,
0.0369210839,
-0.0294237211,
-0.0233739633,
-0.0134348897,
-0.0435730405,
0.0551848784,
-0.1086987704,
0.0425979458,
-0.0021550008,
0.0370012969,
0.0153368367,
-0.0217175316,
0.0039590751,
-0.0356988683,
-0.0070033032,
0.0194164906,
-0.0362937488,
-0.0367721766,
-0.0014345997,
0.0101538096,
-0.0051430892,
0.0289603118,
0.089768447,
0.0137234069,
-0.1325528771,
-0.0538729168,
-0.0361753702,
-0.0440393053,
0.006903301,
-0.0016480758,
-0.0546986908,
0.0355178826,
0.001732922,
0.0140944337,
-0.006708697,
-0.0221431237,
0.0066788965,
0.004951016,
0.0968084335,
-0.0198093243,
-0.0591924079,
0.0108184218,
-0.0334010348,
0.0355199724,
-0.0292970799,
-0.0491090603,
0.0275923666,
-0.0412580706,
0.0157557465,
-0.0308807045,
-0.0720440447,
-0.0276545268,
0.0685907081,
-0.0526393279,
0.0065568741,
0.0071553979,
0.0186493248,
-0.0371835493,
0.048415985,
0.0420886576,
-0.045630578,
-0.0413751714,
-0.0350071155,
0.0681441054,
0.0291599501,
0.0523263216,
-0.0553746782,
0.0023901556,
0.0103855329,
-0.0195485093,
0.0422536992,
0.0597455502,
-0.01661052,
-0.0473411642,
-0.0119921332,
0.06134817,
-0.0230290908,
0.0458928421,
0.0166900158,
0.003294596,
-0.0050285007,
0.0312491152,
0.0020670495,
0.02128537,
-0.0286865514,
-0.0323869772,
-0.0433488674,
-0.0123770209,
-0.0402703322,
-0.0239697006,
0.0451484323,
-0.0162422303,
0.0282377321,
0.0839591175,
0.0269922242,
-0.027796356,
0.0090823323,
0.0418921635,
0.0362203456,
0.0020392935,
0.0030867658,
-0.0029452071,
0.0999141559,
0.0367225185,
-0.0111246901,
0.0502140634,
0.0568962619,
-0.0057496442,
-0.0467754826,
0.0035639908,
0.0271952935,
-0.0086985342,
-0.0022297185,
-0.0178471077,
0.0289012585,
-0.0376440808,
0.0154786343,
-0.0069084684,
-0.0096147293,
0.0242450144,
-0.0111239338,
-0.0471262559,
-0.0196527429,
0.0417443514,
0.0023930792,
-0.0458748676,
0.0027675731,
0.0282080751,
0.016440982,
0.0057973522,
0.0371862762,
-0.0577163361,
0.0124004465,
-0.0075942473,
-0.0321062915,
-0.0154445823,
0.0039913007,
-0.0146312565,
0.0203474723,
-0.0045584096,
-0.0000444715,
-0.0456517115,
0.0378685258,
-0.0547356047,
0.054916814,
-0.0451490134,
0.0751909763,
0.0051466161,
0.0239148177,
0.0500454195,
-0.0104752053,
-0.0275807232,
-0.0568072796,
-0.0569247454,
0.0022627355,
0.0147489654,
0.0289941691,
-0.0139539437,
-0.0162397753,
0.0068878275,
0.0270024966,
-0.0702602267,
-0.0402184092,
-0.0126565835,
0.004004275,
-0.0092912372,
0.007610064,
0.0823538452,
-0.0286016446,
-0.0169727448,
-0.0538797937,
0.019873701,
-0.022293102,
0.0719183683,
0.0279653464,
0.0087664453,
-0.0409007743,
-0.0480530076,
0.0151157072,
0.010439991,
-0.0443716347,
-0.0022915492,
-0.0784189701,
-0.0025639734,
-0.0605954565,
-0.0475226827,
0.0070550325,
-0.0150809921,
-0.0363694727,
-0.0604529381,
-0.0105061596,
-0.0252114851,
0.0049211965,
0.0157183036,
0.0045103142,
-0.0543653853,
0.0508856215,
0.0283699036,
-0.0431363322,
-0.0268535111,
-0.0267671403,
0.0003656149,
-0.0431882218,
-0.0391751938,
-6.902129609e-33,
0.0234140176,
-0.0283884648,
0.0006959197,
0.0283180512,
-0.015005636,
0.0323783793,
-0.0369825922,
-0.0047356971,
0.0382790975,
0.0472482257,
-0.0341723748,
-0.0007912998,
-0.0029380161,
-0.0474715009,
0.104447104,
0.0530867018,
0.0188900009,
-0.0021041296,
-0.0076926998,
0.0171543732,
-0.0173963122,
-0.0193550214,
0.0316741951,
-0.0199217778,
0.0717601553,
0.0237559117,
0.0080650691,
-0.0391395614,
0.004750716,
0.0327029489,
-0.0431975275,
-0.0177901648,
0.0274736471,
-0.0526833311,
0.0030918336,
0.0131334066,
-0.0623435862,
-0.0078438902,
0.0594172478,
-0.0420401953,
0.0119085796,
0.0223776232,
0.0143605676,
0.0064718965,
-0.0652137175,
0.0037106094,
0.0470918566,
-0.0188060068,
-0.0326720886,
-0.0669599175,
-0.0410966016,
0.0363496542,
0.0186046269,
0.0703403875,
0.0183364172,
0.0742499977,
-0.0050132866,
0.042143099,
0.0065115602,
0.0285694525,
0.0279951505,
0.0042352197,
-0.0130932964,
-0.0184906628,
0.004220326,
0.0502377152,
-0.051497329,
-0.0046019624,
0.0341806598,
-0.0525549911,
-0.0032308872,
-0.0187155139,
0.0281344838,
0.0306456778,
0.0171616375,
-0.0059014899,
-0.0690721571,
0.027322486,
-0.0281225685,
0.0605479665,
0.0908085704,
-0.0487993099,
-0.0055770925,
-0.0466056503,
0.0103528704,
-0.0226395559,
-0.024147613,
-0.0246978793,
0.027232727,
-0.0153955678,
-0.0139853684,
0.0330629759,
0.0257867482,
-0.0214098133,
0.0000441922,
0.0226445682,
-0.0263311695,
0.0396553539,
0.0100110713,
-0.0312880427,
-0.0248508714,
0.0317944735,
-0.0097825546,
0.0342333093,
0.0492304042,
-0.0378598496,
0.0014056294,
-0.0265539028,
-0.0621846467,
0.0097316969,
0.000600548,
0.0280305333,
0.0101186717,
0.0076420614,
-0.022263974,
-0.0049786591,
0.0268589985,
-0.0031018096,
0.0405590087,
0.0308712367,
-0.0044416073,
0.0663495511,
-0.0238544531,
0.0157532524,
0.0146150151,
0.0159434825,
0.0233146846,
-0.0285493247,
0.0609344579,
-0.0001751893,
-0.0025047937,
-0.0118850414,
3.283e-7,
0.0477115735,
0.0707768276,
-0.0536041856,
-0.0350921191,
0.0293320585,
0.0002116354,
-0.0067402604,
0.0046796571,
0.040671248,
0.0286553055,
0.0443930961,
-0.0300540142,
0.0141446479,
0.0258835908,
-0.0707658902,
-0.0341536477,
-0.0613284335,
-0.049043972,
-0.0487762056,
-0.0281583276,
-0.0376833566,
0.0094074309,
0.0031767453,
0.014574972,
-0.0642304122,
-0.019828923,
0.0139452079,
-0.0734814778,
0.0023145555,
0.0414618887,
0.0556931198,
-0.0351868123,
-0.0038279805,
0.0276285969,
-0.0044701663,
-0.0038253111,
-0.0232820325,
0.0017336686,
0.0287713204,
0.0398190506,
0.04520794,
0.0043069301,
0.0346608274,
-0.0806635544,
0.0281333048,
-0.0438067392,
-0.0276441593,
-0.0339110196,
-0.0626029298,
-0.0321714729,
0.0742110536,
0.0003187206,
-0.0021280013,
0.050132148,
-0.0480978601,
-0.0105764586,
-0.0118222898,
-0.0188524015,
0.0400245041,
0.0548404418,
-0.0518441796,
-0.055482842,
0.0089868847,
-0.0682299361,
-0.01188643,
-0.0556389019,
0.0430235676,
3.335937714e-34,
0.1170819998,
-0.0430046469,
-0.0151881762,
-0.0262053218,
0.0155412108,
0.03308874,
-0.0493140034,
0.0231220983,
-0.0074423789,
-0.0613835342,
0.0006949125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07914v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07914v2 | Can Knowledge Graphs Reduce Hallucinations in LLMs? : A Survey | 2023-11-14T05:21:57 | 2024-03-16T03:19:25 | Garima Agrawal, Tharindu Kumarage, Zeyad Alghamdi, Huan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The contemporary LLMs are prone to producing hallucinations, stemming mainly
from the knowledge gaps within the models. To address this critical limitation,
researchers employ diverse strategies to augment the LLMs by incorporating
external knowledge, aiming to reduce hallucinations and enhance reasoning
accuracy. Among these strategies, leveraging knowledge graphs as a source of
external information has demonstrated promising results. In this survey, we
comprehensively review these knowledge-graph-based augmentation techniques in
LLMs, focusing on their efficacy in mitigating hallucinations. We
systematically categorize these methods into three overarching groups, offering
methodological comparisons and performance evaluations. Lastly, this survey
explores the current trends and challenges associated with these techniques and
outlines potential avenues for future research in this emerging field. | [
0.002086845,
0.0242785122,
-0.0143568702,
0.0723573789,
-0.0325634815,
0.0051801908,
-0.0380242541,
0.0353188254,
0.0734463781,
-0.0088467197,
-0.0089721102,
0.0409594998,
-0.0239926632,
-0.0333573483,
0.0333909094,
-0.0187747255,
0.0232393164,
-0.0300020613,
-0.0150475465,
-0.0276230592,
-0.018975554,
-0.016457567,
-0.0340279005,
-0.0172555204,
-0.0040309527,
-0.030648822,
-0.0291124862,
0.0439726748,
0.0406386741,
-0.0311153848,
-0.041281648,
0.0322179198,
-0.0060275057,
0.0005499684,
0.0000022579,
-0.0484022982,
-0.0283023156,
0.0013983154,
-0.0570200458,
-0.0181071814,
-0.0257965252,
0.0299694594,
0.0521587394,
0.0005261276,
-0.0434723385,
0.0291941334,
0.0050548743,
0.0463104397,
0.0034148919,
0.0416196845,
-0.0069067068,
0.0011075792,
0.0335711092,
0.0301639251,
0.0937157497,
-0.0012913089,
0.0183742587,
0.0520771816,
0.0656122565,
-0.0646291524,
-0.0231016167,
0.025806386,
0.0118586142,
0.0238631647,
0.0701948404,
0.0052738138,
-0.0089896498,
0.0286830328,
-0.003680249,
0.0625500605,
0.0191910863,
0.0210928395,
0.0019789692,
-0.0116415434,
0.0481466763,
0.0679178014,
-0.049895376,
-0.034956038,
-0.0543291941,
-0.0173478201,
-0.0092454208,
-0.0124974754,
0.0799952671,
0.0197736882,
-0.047191374,
0.1041760147,
-0.007586041,
-0.0424505807,
0.0683569387,
0.0102736773,
0.0219656248,
-0.0286798794,
0.011594601,
0.0534634627,
-0.0317911766,
0.0096186912,
0.0470814891,
0.0445122607,
0.0202979743,
-0.0265221894,
0.0167653169,
-0.00094787,
-0.0326882899,
0.0352015756,
-0.0326898284,
-0.0053526084,
-0.031787511,
0.0738941282,
-0.0227365363,
0.0155693283,
-0.0664340854,
-0.0029833978,
0.0153077617,
0.0559462532,
0.0003886294,
-0.0060587903,
-0.0321047194,
0.0422786437,
-0.0526882894,
0.0667390078,
-0.0091633461,
0.0401718505,
0.0773423463,
-0.0406394638,
-0.0799140781,
-0.0250039212,
0.0077016177,
0.0363319144,
0.018413661,
-0.0352609828,
0.0034936899,
-0.017410988,
-0.0255382061,
0.0217783079,
-0.0011954855,
0.0839676186,
0.0560193472,
0.0151062328,
-0.0695260763,
-0.0787011608,
0.0051806541,
-0.0471741222,
0.0332667567,
-0.0498379022,
0.0080133025,
-0.002777271,
-0.0136929126,
-0.0290195309,
0.0245577302,
-0.0274021309,
-0.039556805,
0.0900719166,
-0.1075920984,
0.0149907907,
0.0018106898,
0.0552765951,
-0.0541930348,
0.0483379513,
0.0099175153,
-0.0048745987,
0.0076009994,
0.0045751864,
0.0516428687,
0.0167777743,
-0.0014826789,
-0.0011084012,
-0.0045099887,
0.012398703,
-0.0475666821,
0.0164107457,
-0.0282948557,
-0.0342328064,
-0.049842149,
0.0294128433,
0.0588855557,
-0.0010704527,
0.0519499443,
0.0156003702,
-0.0226681698,
-0.0299187582,
0.0058587398,
0.0238129608,
-0.0619793311,
0.0590029247,
-0.0474303178,
0.0162581727,
0.0247971788,
-0.0020005484,
-0.0244172458,
-0.0704332218,
-0.0132398522,
0.0120119154,
0.0219821036,
0.0451402888,
0.0312002227,
-0.0082334829,
0.0033934629,
0.0568778999,
0.0235568322,
-0.0154706798,
-0.0184977427,
-0.0412890539,
-0.0349006057,
0.1253300011,
0.0781719461,
-0.0697975978,
-0.0897210017,
-0.0045960434,
-0.0154796373,
0.0325788148,
0.0038555877,
0.0086707203,
-0.0365037136,
-0.0463722758,
-0.0562950186,
-0.0294471197,
0.0105626266,
-0.0002888408,
-0.0158645231,
-0.0149185574,
-0.0100120753,
-0.0848566815,
-0.0112799238,
-0.0026015041,
-0.0399631001,
0.0384197012,
-0.0092700478,
-0.0066992459,
0.0157075301,
0.0463100933,
0.0419304222,
0.0450320281,
0.0252997987,
-0.0168470126,
-0.0525567792,
0.0198891964,
0.0046495199,
0.0059903529,
0.0428471938,
-0.0255165342,
0.014443568,
-0.0737334415,
-0.028567329,
-0.0233072136,
0.0294544678,
-0.009930823,
0.0764857829,
-0.0186411683,
0.0018487961,
0.0152009707,
-0.0320970155,
0.013812637,
0.0565144457,
-0.0468971953,
0.0011848505,
0.033323057,
-0.0039672838,
0.0169807039,
-0.0044967653,
0.0617221929,
-0.0092377821,
0.0197817925,
0.0135648241,
-0.0352261215,
-0.0439204313,
-0.0806791559,
0.0140360529,
-0.0707166344,
-0.0072545987,
0.0098742135,
0.0150486985,
-0.0075545716,
-0.0417001434,
-0.0150900427,
-0.0144646736,
-0.0329144038,
0.0288022701,
-0.0071057258,
0.0077897152,
0.0029438296,
0.0093929283,
-0.0394758619,
0.0259607416,
0.0076333443,
-0.0169265922,
0.0151118077,
0.0123706395,
-0.0388796739,
-0.0494224802,
0.0464380011,
-0.0617050603,
-0.0164661072,
-0.0122612324,
0.0622797087,
-0.0009847034,
0.0014107235,
0.0051874071,
0.0190763026,
-0.0539605804,
-0.0005750494,
0.0611491539,
-0.0646622032,
-0.0425231643,
-0.0107592139,
0.0000393128,
0.0227588974,
-0.0245016813,
-0.0306112003,
-0.0294338372,
-0.0318887867,
0.0081525743,
0.0000713221,
-0.0150152249,
0.0265318304,
-0.0068051144,
-0.0427013151,
0.0012301304,
-0.0275667347,
0.009291091,
0.0417702906,
-0.0220251679,
-0.0240142792,
0.0556193367,
0.0171198789,
0.0377860777,
0.0334191695,
0.0031300103,
-0.019818591,
0.0148901148,
-0.0123721594,
-0.0114142904,
-0.0210667159,
-0.0130906729,
-0.0323046967,
-0.032887917,
0.0060518123,
-0.0561738089,
0.0551247187,
-0.0479097329,
-0.0222958196,
0.0341313854,
-0.0035354567,
-0.0554553755,
0.0377291553,
-0.0040687984,
0.0277117807,
-0.0234804899,
-0.0076883184,
0.0015402503,
-0.046813149,
0.0032703879,
-0.0387964398,
-0.0035412484,
-0.0451932959,
-0.0132807149,
-0.0108413575,
-0.0067635048,
-0.0015227571,
0.082991384,
-0.0529688857,
0.0092480788,
0.05452995,
0.015529938,
-0.0706364512,
-0.0204743706,
0.0012466328,
-0.010725324,
-0.0121642388,
0.005586511,
0.0112404469,
0.0051059364,
-0.0382068083,
0.0194887575,
0.0785171688,
0.031114934,
-0.0319007002,
0.0129933786,
-0.065309234,
0.0123777911,
0.0434260182,
-0.0017951574,
-0.0938029066,
-0.0065550418,
-0.0163725019,
0.0284370966,
-0.0140948873,
-0.0648215786,
-0.003974841,
-0.060927324,
0.0587993972,
0.0401717685,
0.0343013778,
-0.0211453699,
0.0161683448,
0.019102335,
0.0065216646,
-0.0315123461,
-0.0031396279,
0.002533365,
-0.0249625184,
0.0275163911,
-0.0499596708,
0.0165790003,
-0.0328122862,
-0.0202258714,
0.0222405307,
-0.0054648216,
0.0051990985,
-0.0105937822,
-0.0839097574,
0.0128331054,
0.0584759898,
0.0423155054,
-0.0204126649,
0.0390219316,
0.0420328416,
0.0318258293,
-0.007554451,
0.0105724251,
-0.0264892541,
-0.0354267955,
0.0317129754,
0.1185687035,
-0.0511427745,
-0.0289019216,
-0.0112604015,
0.0219542347,
-0.0119685316,
0.0320407078,
0.0044660177,
0.0032251531,
-0.0070214979,
-0.0436613597,
0.0003385269,
-0.0132703381,
0.0084754676,
0.0584997311,
0.0209404845,
0.0197104383,
-0.0185314193,
-0.0417993926,
0.0234826319,
-0.0030921553,
0.0185281392,
0.064718999,
-0.0155717181,
-0.0239287559,
-0.0305099674,
-0.011680101,
-0.032119751,
0.0103326198,
0.0713386908,
0.0178459939,
-0.023451753,
-0.0512497164,
0.0349279642,
-0.0061611091,
-0.0406066738,
-0.0552836284,
-0.0254095178,
0.0300653242,
0.031677369,
0.068201296,
-0.0173186027,
-0.0207208581,
0.0747341141,
0.0754655525,
-0.0093027158,
-0.0146479821,
0.0159581974,
0.0320734605,
0.0138913123,
0.0111653386,
-0.0469814166,
-0.0423964038,
0.0167606063,
0.0228658933,
-0.0632112101,
-0.0141774984,
0.0096022068,
0.0282679629,
-0.016309591,
-0.0040417477,
0.0136986617,
-0.0239901822,
0.0431268774,
-0.0427146293,
0.0022654408,
-0.0016404892,
-0.0132358959,
0.0144503536,
-0.0216143485,
0.0385504961,
-0.0186568946,
-0.0067152409,
-0.0165892262,
-0.0236844104,
-0.0140879061,
0.0140478946,
-0.0314074233,
0.0400104262,
-0.0151787773,
-0.0022601364,
0.0305720512,
0.0272180419,
0.0391988046,
0.0169873927,
0.0851817727,
0.0144613395,
-0.0128420871,
-0.0534927286,
-0.0001792456,
-0.0203868076,
-0.111638993,
0.016735455,
0.0380082577,
0.0534857064,
0.0392837711,
0.0212744158,
-0.0397255123,
0.0192895364,
0.0313824788,
0.001641017,
0.0111835888,
-0.0069138268,
0.0075640334,
0.0320643745,
-0.0213885102,
-0.0218977425,
0.0288196243,
-0.0271931998,
0.0485882387,
-0.0546177998,
-0.0253753252,
-0.04780012,
-0.0601631999,
0.0026556409,
0.0279961675,
-0.0300018489,
-0.009126802,
-0.1048142239,
-0.0602092817,
0.0124570597,
-0.0058017438,
-0.006578282,
-0.0124931848,
0.0283314716,
0.0409075506,
0.0119603062,
-0.0504111722,
0.0115201529,
-0.0197929442,
-0.0196979698,
-0.0003632779,
0.0308595281,
-6.072922302e-33,
-0.008294276,
-0.0707248077,
0.0568804294,
-0.0060886792,
-0.0258988086,
-0.0452800207,
0.0061878967,
0.0342893265,
0.003500771,
0.03269374,
0.0016346576,
0.0100530572,
-0.0062124929,
-0.0384857245,
0.0472090356,
-0.0335685574,
0.0047514252,
0.0198417362,
0.0159212127,
0.0098920977,
-0.0047596344,
0.0134226857,
0.0271896832,
-0.0723236054,
0.0496469922,
0.0027464523,
-0.0105825728,
0.0193727911,
-0.0468295664,
0.0260074809,
-0.0055280826,
0.0322983414,
0.0119276028,
-0.0068897465,
-0.0383323021,
-0.0445574559,
-0.0199841056,
-0.0264027379,
0.0315438248,
0.0041840523,
-0.0436288156,
-0.0304139331,
0.0541234724,
0.0269254111,
0.0023069389,
-0.0550307333,
0.0333835259,
-0.0815068483,
-0.0441351421,
-0.0161575526,
-0.0151475361,
0.0026461696,
-0.0105600273,
0.0392966568,
0.0180831477,
0.0118936393,
-0.0170955695,
-0.0234934874,
-0.0750933662,
0.0264910907,
0.0131920762,
-0.0543540977,
0.0807577223,
-0.0158134121,
-0.0021186802,
0.0331242271,
0.0030908787,
0.0121970037,
-0.0543614663,
0.0009724938,
-0.0249147434,
0.1336180568,
0.0407286994,
-0.017258158,
0.0103788562,
0.0007724703,
-0.0690679625,
0.0003129332,
-0.0548779853,
0.0108607709,
0.0384434201,
0.0031192366,
-0.058781717,
-0.0191488583,
0.0120223407,
0.0229879115,
-0.0223200358,
-0.0385908671,
0.0016163725,
-0.0167026129,
0.0176961031,
0.0003089763,
-0.0286536682,
-0.0582030453,
0.0077741817,
0.0008865152,
0.0309730545,
0.0067960983,
-0.0102676954,
-0.0233337115,
-0.0266225673,
-0.0357204266,
-0.0177786704,
-0.0029568514,
0.044478938,
0.0196405388,
0.0328083374,
-0.0207707193,
-0.0275612716,
-0.0070016473,
-0.0550686531,
0.0333504267,
0.0553035028,
-0.0808261782,
0.0311628375,
0.0099254949,
-0.0092539135,
0.0117251221,
0.0400188453,
0.0188388377,
0.0282034818,
0.0473840423,
-0.0345248878,
-0.0024112889,
0.0156636611,
-0.0039485842,
0.0065015801,
-0.0470101796,
0.0334877186,
-0.035681501,
-0.0337708592,
-0.0040075537,
2.913e-7,
0.0150405802,
0.0476425514,
0.0018652887,
0.0343976729,
0.0363507606,
0.0069263247,
-0.0178352799,
-0.0395200513,
0.0240892917,
-0.0849288478,
0.0338235274,
0.0548311956,
0.025982216,
0.058367148,
-0.0420879424,
-0.0437072106,
0.0445153452,
-0.0333458222,
-0.0484698415,
-0.0061127148,
0.0555453114,
-0.0447995998,
0.0482385531,
-0.0155183244,
0.0133896889,
-0.0549361743,
0.0416050889,
-0.0360084586,
-0.0006426243,
0.0284203403,
0.1056790873,
0.0174064245,
-0.0037400615,
0.0741636977,
0.0125238458,
-0.0086490987,
-0.0224413387,
-0.0229228977,
-0.0124628702,
-0.035916537,
-0.0084916214,
-0.0479086414,
0.0441346318,
-0.0264085587,
0.0458529964,
-0.014640593,
-0.0279573202,
0.0434458852,
-0.0352749638,
-0.0355841257,
0.0159770902,
0.0072187097,
0.0372644626,
-0.0193894356,
-0.0045725973,
0.0155916931,
0.006901083,
-0.0457953513,
0.0139657687,
0.0589023903,
-0.0227877349,
-0.0615257397,
0.0232339222,
0.0221307911,
-0.0103934882,
-0.046980001,
-0.0178608261,
2.74858038e-34,
0.0029957932,
0.0285228547,
0.0293350499,
0.047260724,
0.0151522141,
-0.0061338241,
0.0017108637,
0.0061562615,
0.0177553874,
-0.064631097,
0.0065721236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07911v1 | Instruction-Following Evaluation for Large Language Models | 2023-11-14T05:13:55 | 2023-11-14T05:13:55 | Jeffrey Zhou, Tianjian Lu, Swaroop Mishra, Siddhartha Brahma, Sujoy Basu, Yi Luan, Denny Zhou, Le Hou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50 (Primary) 68T99 (Secondary), I.2.7 | One core capability of Large Language Models (LLMs) is to follow natural
language instructions. However, the evaluation of such abilities is not
standardized: Human evaluations are expensive, slow, and not objectively
reproducible, while LLM-based auto-evaluation is potentially biased or limited
by the ability of the evaluator LLM. To overcome these issues, we introduce
Instruction-Following Eval (IFEval) for large language models. IFEval is a
straightforward and easy-to-reproduce evaluation benchmark. It focuses on a set
of "verifiable instructions" such as "write in more than 400 words" and
"mention the keyword of AI at least 3 times". We identified 25 types of those
verifiable instructions and constructed around 500 prompts, with each prompt
containing one or more verifiable instructions. We show evaluation results of
two widely available LLMs on the market. Our code and data can be found at
https://github.com/google-research/google-research/tree/master/instruction_following_eval | [
0.0383514464,
0.0500771143,
0.0001691857,
0.0345350429,
-0.0415636413,
0.0242070388,
0.0035345417,
-0.0114211328,
0.0337149799,
-0.0491450951,
-0.0475749075,
-0.0331780538,
0.0026256812,
0.0085911322,
0.0368819796,
-0.0259958319,
0.0509905145,
-0.0707451329,
-0.0025323289,
0.0049598371,
-0.0050173434,
-0.0046264352,
-0.0084007112,
0.0461377054,
0.0227682218,
-0.0271847621,
-0.0132023403,
-0.0211425759,
-0.0016208421,
-0.0317944735,
-0.0131992139,
0.0397652984,
0.0043185879,
0.0089445403,
0.0000020841,
-0.0546492971,
0.0322522894,
0.0118079809,
-0.0650804639,
0.0690044612,
0.0401533544,
0.0024897321,
-0.0206312705,
0.0198534485,
-0.0249991547,
0.0062444326,
0.0183650535,
0.0312131736,
0.0801910385,
0.0909989253,
0.019525269,
-0.0118363695,
0.0455125123,
-0.0219135433,
0.0116553232,
-0.0656509697,
0.0151071157,
-0.0085203834,
0.0336778946,
0.0479738265,
-0.0018960204,
0.0463051759,
0.053153459,
-0.0218734592,
-0.0198035557,
0.0210255757,
-0.0244756564,
-0.0249600727,
-0.0319473371,
0.0629394874,
-0.0004003594,
0.0093998956,
-0.0128143737,
0.003013304,
-0.0023547756,
-0.0206382647,
-0.0235607903,
0.0557741001,
0.0236618668,
-0.018528033,
0.0249014776,
0.0046116174,
0.0182309859,
0.0062957224,
-0.0177364573,
0.0854451656,
0.0158209242,
-0.051759053,
0.0206632856,
-0.0111051565,
-0.0119387284,
-0.0969926566,
-0.0156881195,
0.040160086,
-0.0601049513,
0.0144541338,
-0.0554067045,
0.0194846187,
0.0476556085,
-0.031727653,
0.0990060493,
0.0298905466,
0.0019348739,
0.0506481826,
-0.0190439653,
0.1162429303,
-0.004467533,
0.0366917849,
-0.0096220747,
0.0273927506,
-0.0390723459,
0.0138813211,
-0.0214773025,
0.0257734507,
-0.0078043044,
-0.0207117107,
-0.0363368765,
0.0141121643,
-0.0290766638,
0.0545765385,
-0.0018953508,
-0.0331596434,
0.0091355704,
-0.012606211,
-0.0304518584,
-0.0299169049,
-0.0406758003,
0.0144755384,
0.0063070063,
-0.0577598028,
0.0041957395,
0.0206484068,
-0.0184158236,
-0.0108304983,
0.034517657,
0.0732861981,
0.0142968446,
-0.0306775179,
-0.013939213,
-0.0265409518,
0.0019192976,
-0.0897327885,
-0.014911646,
-0.0619758591,
0.0165346581,
-0.0109567372,
-0.006256545,
-0.0215497762,
0.0140686044,
0.0548775643,
-0.0038155518,
0.0566333085,
0.0411189348,
0.0203619003,
-0.0263534822,
0.0222463794,
0.007073476,
0.0245389771,
0.0361746475,
0.051229462,
0.0259945747,
-0.0050271531,
0.021008933,
0.0567813292,
0.0028887233,
0.0181521513,
0.0101229036,
0.0398308113,
-0.0205778778,
0.0255198628,
0.0185925569,
0.095540531,
-0.0035030423,
-0.0110605638,
0.0197963063,
0.0602078363,
-0.0167619344,
-0.0353295095,
0.0946168378,
0.0305311363,
0.0300030317,
0.0095486417,
-0.0997174978,
0.0090800654,
-0.0248298068,
0.0046543856,
0.0272659641,
-0.0013952143,
-0.021552531,
-0.0548196509,
-0.0047180997,
-0.0044725831,
0.0131917913,
0.0260819178,
0.0075693657,
-0.002156327,
-0.0448281616,
0.0009398117,
0.0115040801,
-0.0361242369,
-0.0205279663,
-0.084572278,
0.017098397,
0.0738395825,
0.0536065325,
0.0125340959,
-0.0091413837,
-0.0035167688,
0.0210049078,
0.0422441661,
0.0353323109,
-0.0082787257,
0.001136187,
-0.0324984081,
-0.0201296266,
-0.0278845876,
0.0182194076,
0.0121772187,
0.0453969873,
-0.0055433586,
0.0075574173,
-0.0054312642,
-0.0739354044,
0.0409548059,
-0.0302812811,
-0.0720216408,
-0.0207505412,
0.0062883329,
0.0320089087,
0.0061927093,
-0.0184265263,
0.0320702679,
0.0207310561,
-0.0156464502,
0.0029461542,
-0.0460236482,
-0.0416729897,
-0.0024466906,
0.0324460268,
-0.0235840343,
-0.0391218737,
0.0382071882,
-0.0233633891,
-0.0291920342,
-0.0063434131,
-0.0603292063,
0.0069495258,
0.0032142212,
0.0503104329,
-0.0032475661,
-0.0082763275,
-0.0173032917,
0.0320874006,
-0.0317780934,
0.0261463504,
0.0544298291,
0.0252811126,
-0.0000323944,
-0.0326230936,
-0.0330876932,
-0.0153312935,
-0.0104394509,
0.0201278199,
0.0298908278,
0.049073413,
-0.0451756641,
-0.0311153084,
-0.0969598815,
0.0360275917,
-0.0282606725,
0.0351538286,
0.025511004,
-0.0174124092,
0.0009885385,
0.0063796262,
-0.0314080603,
-0.0386324897,
0.00838817,
0.028743241,
0.0073314728,
-0.0083820401,
-0.0468530692,
-0.0381022021,
0.0018160809,
-0.0260095764,
0.0123451836,
0.0230405871,
0.0283565391,
-0.0535862781,
0.0515273362,
-0.0073801717,
0.0178767052,
-0.0107641155,
-0.0484778173,
0.0357103534,
-0.000327848,
0.024262188,
0.0826461613,
-0.0088784965,
0.0109474007,
0.0512795784,
-0.0049447636,
-0.0671439394,
0.012969018,
0.0200354531,
-0.0239745118,
-0.0326146111,
-0.0621271804,
0.0095923012,
0.0661031157,
0.0107940864,
0.0188307464,
-0.025715813,
0.0050455597,
-0.0367604941,
-0.031724643,
-0.0079598185,
-0.0203421246,
-0.0358905196,
0.0208799373,
-0.0319058597,
-0.0654197112,
0.0636949465,
-0.0550593771,
-0.0209401399,
-0.0319468752,
-0.0196071863,
-0.0221421085,
0.0751952752,
0.0195730701,
0.0077290507,
-0.0104357544,
-0.0137231434,
-0.012204011,
0.0004200631,
-0.0080805635,
-0.0331363343,
0.0560356267,
-0.0459308289,
0.0065230303,
0.0107177524,
-0.0161575843,
-0.0580062568,
-0.0569219515,
-0.0249296799,
0.0281616673,
0.0321695618,
-0.0400024913,
-0.0345435478,
-0.0196595564,
0.0631404892,
0.0304179881,
-0.0071056564,
-0.0131926667,
-0.0394152887,
-0.0274898484,
0.0568438135,
-0.0018730918,
0.0000045245,
-0.0422474854,
0.0406962745,
0.0374377482,
0.0456262603,
0.0244614128,
-0.040729668,
0.0060757124,
0.0261447001,
-0.0420963243,
-0.0083528869,
0.0563642532,
0.0771932676,
-0.0689746216,
-0.0150232101,
0.1356443763,
0.024474049,
-0.0392345786,
0.0149856685,
0.0093482779,
0.0097514866,
0.019781502,
0.0452988893,
-0.0871221945,
-0.0395897664,
0.0170536861,
0.0284214541,
-0.0092237573,
-0.0048992238,
-0.0122199664,
-0.1206908077,
0.0483678915,
-0.0079289591,
-0.0196978487,
-0.0443309993,
-0.038942866,
-0.0106139295,
-0.0007524108,
0.020051552,
0.0127244424,
-0.0392439552,
-0.0270900391,
0.0027682909,
-0.031789083,
-0.0369806923,
0.1061276123,
-0.0532066897,
0.0835806876,
0.0932219625,
0.0001274699,
0.0054299315,
-0.055417981,
0.0245903544,
-0.0099934377,
-0.0000133693,
0.0077853831,
0.0362313204,
-0.0138624487,
-0.0093707368,
-0.016205309,
0.0197468679,
-0.0338471681,
0.0313161239,
0.0343235284,
0.061756175,
-0.0269604884,
-0.0280320421,
-0.0052084313,
0.0101361666,
-0.0018657087,
0.081019491,
0.0364664234,
-0.0390421972,
-0.0461100154,
-0.0369814001,
-0.0417165123,
-0.0639879555,
-0.0587439686,
0.0177444927,
-0.0356148705,
-0.0009658642,
-0.0522701256,
-0.0607779995,
0.0226109065,
0.0203373246,
0.0126661519,
-0.0289455932,
0.0305433813,
-0.0058196676,
-0.0012236485,
0.0225819387,
-0.0381050594,
0.0616989732,
-0.0921367034,
-0.0341119766,
0.0190112907,
0.0302879494,
-0.0247445069,
0.0352071524,
-0.0699905306,
-0.0563445911,
-0.0054241419,
0.0856682733,
0.0218642373,
0.0265782401,
-0.0395488068,
-0.0426875502,
0.0044774651,
-0.0087112626,
-0.0378839187,
0.0276399851,
0.0279623587,
-0.0043246108,
0.0033295271,
0.029194925,
-0.0192819424,
0.0353586413,
0.0119490139,
0.0330001749,
-0.0405026115,
-0.0516483188,
0.0154389013,
0.0539058521,
-0.0038024366,
-0.0129533792,
0.016284775,
-0.009745474,
-0.0005549937,
-0.007368715,
-0.0295558255,
-0.0498599969,
0.0201986749,
0.0342862345,
-0.0246367641,
0.0045302594,
-0.007421351,
-0.0268886089,
-0.0136470925,
-0.0414197929,
0.035087321,
-0.0038375277,
0.0431638956,
0.0140301697,
-0.0046768282,
-0.0370148644,
0.0444823205,
-0.0070414525,
0.0499123372,
-0.0016999824,
0.053721752,
0.0028635298,
0.0062545654,
-0.0105696628,
0.0434004143,
-0.0506730787,
-0.0508046821,
0.0102847163,
0.0362400822,
0.0397769697,
0.0113131031,
0.0461820774,
-0.0235773791,
0.0183207318,
-0.0411279462,
0.016326772,
0.0048930733,
-0.0478916727,
0.0226755533,
0.0429635532,
-0.0058388994,
-0.0031264122,
0.0582048818,
0.0117262928,
0.0349857919,
0.013321328,
0.0061386381,
-0.0512374006,
-0.0466655605,
-0.0059514735,
-0.0031520538,
-0.0318160243,
0.0168248694,
-0.0321855843,
-0.07233987,
-0.023617344,
0.0496161468,
0.0202448368,
-0.0280695353,
0.0245990958,
0.0410256609,
-0.0011869402,
-0.0194516145,
-0.0561908446,
-0.0148547571,
-0.0117268451,
-0.042531196,
-0.0428794362,
-6.200347726e-33,
-0.0377857983,
-0.0334284715,
0.0530996099,
-0.0146831125,
-0.014665124,
0.0202259775,
-0.0513777025,
0.0054844217,
-0.0101051321,
0.017751608,
-0.0065204324,
0.011446056,
0.0126976501,
0.002558304,
0.0198852122,
-0.0064048646,
0.0299291853,
-0.0088373274,
-0.0391392857,
0.0354665481,
-0.0023220228,
-0.0279460289,
0.0020333698,
-0.0605555065,
0.0561194122,
-0.0080276337,
-0.0216041561,
0.006699645,
-0.0412688144,
0.0778911039,
-0.0353617556,
-0.005699812,
0.0115610436,
-0.0513721481,
-0.0158237331,
0.0283126365,
-0.0310780648,
-0.0321961008,
0.0360490046,
-0.0012692654,
-0.0798652023,
-0.0412758589,
0.0284087155,
-0.0258145817,
-0.0593830161,
0.0198137835,
0.0164192282,
0.0072910008,
-0.0014273628,
0.0206802953,
-0.0676484481,
0.0304610655,
-0.0025629641,
-0.0640335605,
-0.0100683384,
0.0256614536,
-0.0037012277,
-0.0236107204,
-0.0258990116,
0.0040463982,
0.0268064216,
0.0384216644,
0.0727509037,
-0.0189767871,
-0.0151901692,
0.0493518449,
0.006248611,
0.0189691875,
-0.0201162286,
0.0017038106,
0.0232083183,
0.0531005859,
0.024519274,
-0.0104674278,
0.00543364,
0.0320573039,
-0.0266474858,
0.0176900215,
0.0233485345,
0.059199702,
0.0254755542,
-0.023839483,
-0.078797996,
-0.0020310821,
-0.0480876416,
0.0219839755,
-0.0432581194,
-0.0179777667,
0.0743991211,
0.0200596061,
-0.0293192137,
-0.0284774322,
0.0198208261,
-0.036766734,
-0.0254067015,
0.0230761766,
-0.0120996591,
0.0200016797,
-0.0086039267,
0.0334402397,
-0.0499086529,
-0.0078357859,
-0.0025424846,
-0.0108517855,
0.0507492013,
0.0204114337,
0.0069918209,
0.0400295742,
-0.0702112839,
-0.0087632751,
-0.0436198413,
0.0201129597,
-0.0090836938,
0.0037786262,
0.0413883477,
-0.0037393891,
-0.0098689375,
0.0704695061,
-0.0310313031,
-0.0296514425,
-0.0255939439,
-0.0110159712,
0.0208078865,
0.0218193289,
-0.0493367948,
0.0139828259,
-0.0601533279,
0.0280401073,
-0.028285034,
-0.0293392483,
0.0132410685,
0.0112032034,
2.715e-7,
-0.0089276582,
0.0604053661,
0.0281120203,
0.093575649,
-0.0101794535,
0.0257125385,
-0.0368132964,
0.0038382111,
-0.0089937598,
-0.0024107206,
-0.0085754152,
0.0618961006,
0.037342675,
0.0023385005,
-0.0457667001,
0.0043635103,
-0.0555970632,
0.0131260054,
-0.0626570955,
-0.0032757302,
0.0286026392,
0.0714415237,
0.0017317485,
0.0042816973,
0.0050528473,
-0.05868797,
0.0278932583,
-0.0063069342,
-0.0107896514,
0.0226150937,
0.0338710919,
0.047465194,
0.0011175807,
0.0153529188,
-0.0050428724,
0.0031922874,
-0.019495843,
0.1270366609,
-0.0045437585,
-0.0035671231,
-0.0010936195,
-0.0484082699,
-0.0021030435,
-0.0358732976,
0.0630280599,
-0.0090720486,
-0.0156061659,
-0.0471579954,
-0.0008583767,
-0.0272966865,
0.0116545754,
0.0009568849,
-0.0083971377,
0.0097079491,
0.0211356468,
-0.0556553975,
-0.0203882325,
-0.0563710183,
-0.0086034453,
0.0015558309,
-0.0085922284,
-0.0530392975,
-0.0666135848,
0.0142749771,
0.0025947881,
-0.0754134879,
-0.0333608128,
2.555324517e-34,
0.039241761,
-0.0291084368,
0.0427375883,
0.0207721908,
0.0581936687,
0.030173257,
-0.0489124842,
0.0129039735,
0.0243273843,
-0.0946982726,
-0.0237827729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07897v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07897v1 | CPopQA: Ranking Cultural Concept Popularity by LLMs | 2023-11-14T04:10:40 | 2023-11-14T04:10:40 | Ming Jiang, Mansi Joshi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prior work has demonstrated large language models' (LLMs) potential to
discern statistical tendencies within their pre-training corpora. Despite that,
many examinations of LLMs' knowledge capacity focus on knowledge explicitly
appearing in the training data or implicitly inferable from similar contexts.
How well an LLM captures the corpus-level statistical trends of concepts for
reasoning, especially long-tail ones, is still underexplored. In this study, we
introduce a novel few-shot question-answering task (CPopQA) that examines LLMs'
statistical ranking abilities for long-tail cultural concepts (e.g., holidays),
with a specific focus on these concepts' popularity in the United States and
the United Kingdom, respectively. We curate a dataset containing 459 holidays
across 58 countries, generating a total of 6,000 QA testing pairs. Experiments
on four strong LLMs show that large models are capable of ranking long-tail
cultural concepts regarding their statistical tendency. Notably, GPT-3.5
displayed superior performance and exhibited its potential to identify
geo-cultural proximity across continents. | [
0.0234338008,
0.0528151132,
-0.022822978,
0.034894783,
-0.0240470953,
0.0221740846,
0.0154618621,
-0.0229425915,
-0.0041268962,
-0.0165487472,
-0.0323031023,
-0.056237381,
-0.0090090595,
-0.0190207977,
0.0092637492,
-0.0245096684,
0.0390241928,
-0.0163666494,
0.0002756217,
-0.0337854289,
-0.0258869454,
0.0205267314,
0.0087819193,
0.0104512312,
0.0434505492,
-0.0066490616,
0.0311841462,
-0.0608924069,
0.047955431,
-0.0219034851,
-0.0028267493,
0.0250090435,
0.0219973139,
0.0328242593,
0.0000017868,
-0.0524936952,
0.0165532194,
-0.0322684683,
0.0213768799,
0.0511973426,
-0.0074095912,
0.009940532,
0.005288152,
-0.0025360757,
-0.0538433343,
0.0341454372,
0.0145340711,
0.0046553011,
0.0079527134,
0.0249237828,
0.0230193622,
-0.060338553,
-0.0316208526,
-0.0505144708,
0.0171317384,
-0.0399555638,
0.0236952398,
0.0208253935,
-0.0048723193,
0.0038008697,
-0.0387610048,
0.0070930948,
0.0239441078,
0.0282617323,
-0.0415677391,
0.0552538484,
-0.0675756782,
0.0294621382,
0.0341219231,
0.0665951073,
0.0307142101,
-0.0016574417,
0.0162561797,
0.0206426736,
-0.0235575438,
0.0017519237,
-0.0782827213,
0.0069595068,
0.0071900301,
0.0171302333,
0.0430517904,
0.0098758582,
0.0081140976,
0.0609505363,
-0.0176028889,
0.0961641297,
0.0187189076,
-0.0108815525,
-0.0244956948,
-0.0163158011,
-0.0566657297,
-0.0216623917,
0.018051587,
0.0389702767,
0.0105876941,
0.0304181054,
0.0413173884,
0.0546113178,
0.0542688631,
-0.0172634944,
-0.0014973717,
0.0312693305,
-0.0403919443,
0.0730739161,
-0.0090835579,
0.0424081236,
0.0022671106,
-0.0064081745,
-0.0167472064,
-0.032905262,
-0.0480174348,
-0.021518657,
0.0586219952,
-0.0017526189,
0.0092318896,
0.0258864854,
-0.0597707853,
-0.0077844709,
0.0007915414,
-0.0284001641,
0.0065342807,
0.0133065199,
-0.0035536787,
0.0188516565,
-0.0623647906,
0.0659377947,
-0.0836144388,
-0.007691578,
-0.0269743912,
-0.0328753591,
0.0201748814,
0.0104931984,
-0.0248237029,
-0.029512994,
0.0139303291,
-0.0191730056,
-0.0191578865,
-0.0115762977,
-0.0391987599,
0.012447509,
-0.0256120469,
-0.0548994504,
0.0267230198,
-0.0956603736,
0.0250929408,
-0.0119099468,
0.0031538869,
-0.0079006888,
0.0231657382,
0.0492717847,
-0.0246892218,
0.0005490628,
0.0427977741,
0.019891765,
0.0493009426,
0.0150418505,
0.0071431482,
0.0760488361,
0.0256684572,
0.0031192319,
0.080390282,
-0.0194017943,
-0.0326208472,
0.0148273837,
0.0001262455,
0.0132800722,
-0.0421363004,
0.0404104479,
-0.0184263233,
-0.0306159407,
0.041306667,
0.0078730676,
-0.0169399437,
-0.0400682241,
0.0279174391,
0.0745546073,
-0.0526175871,
0.0249254499,
0.0508414917,
-0.0255645383,
-0.0050349599,
0.0077607664,
-0.0061979075,
0.0325093344,
-0.0265455227,
0.0017498479,
0.0113963895,
0.0848522261,
-0.0507779531,
-0.0484205596,
-0.0091811586,
0.0131006949,
0.0299976151,
0.0422268026,
0.0596644729,
-0.0412371606,
0.0293534789,
0.0354221649,
0.0116380043,
-0.0056358459,
-0.0051550688,
-0.0119617861,
0.043504972,
0.0520694926,
-0.0026140071,
-0.0008579072,
-0.0204743017,
0.0257567018,
0.0737237111,
0.000195047,
0.0185428131,
-0.0024405858,
0.0290715657,
-0.0154206213,
0.0137345623,
0.0021508355,
0.0056180833,
0.0088426778,
0.0493080318,
0.0577737577,
0.0047564912,
-0.073431693,
0.0475015976,
-0.0263979677,
-0.0289335288,
-0.0092516867,
0.0228616651,
-0.0147991674,
0.0135887004,
0.0388135575,
-0.0108455373,
-0.000450595,
0.0158197172,
-0.0631011501,
-0.0125730755,
0.0262379795,
-0.0228750892,
-0.02955072,
0.017794637,
-0.0348527692,
-0.0380605683,
0.042539347,
-0.0538375638,
-0.0201968253,
0.015833633,
0.0050537949,
0.0292595569,
-0.046965573,
-0.0286749955,
0.0113477614,
0.0319145471,
-0.0433422364,
0.0988604128,
-0.034658704,
0.0535338372,
-0.012116787,
0.0159563906,
0.0358071774,
-0.0442881994,
-0.0316666253,
0.0269069187,
0.0213473383,
-0.0442721099,
0.0465362035,
0.0141168041,
-0.0392080955,
-0.0143925129,
-0.1115540043,
0.0190706961,
-0.0208717473,
0.0299003646,
0.0063277958,
-0.0179585963,
-0.0215488244,
-0.0193264317,
-0.061383225,
-0.0173360966,
0.0030687752,
0.0706325248,
0.0513299368,
0.0020144295,
-0.0045552189,
0.0097151138,
-0.0371961407,
-0.0088415323,
0.0296968278,
-0.0357660241,
0.0168864466,
-0.0088289194,
-0.0217892695,
-0.1137831658,
-0.025111435,
-0.0183268823,
-0.0574154854,
-0.0140728196,
0.0105552096,
0.0410644934,
0.0478159226,
0.0375569798,
-0.0708397478,
0.0644341931,
-0.0106128668,
-0.0269913636,
-0.0174925756,
-0.0327228643,
0.0122311935,
0.0181602705,
-0.0752450004,
-0.0529552139,
0.0640869588,
0.0229063556,
-0.0171832517,
-0.0121390512,
0.0366496742,
-0.0208112244,
-0.0065415339,
-0.0522669069,
0.058950156,
-0.0290621147,
0.0685332492,
-0.0286548734,
-0.0340533778,
0.0224911235,
0.0065838238,
-0.0052401265,
-0.0171683151,
-0.0094515057,
-0.0771393329,
0.0485106669,
0.0058646793,
-0.0061448384,
-0.0005460535,
-0.0208096206,
-0.0526302718,
-0.0331959985,
0.0021027112,
-0.0532788262,
0.0327476971,
-0.0319403037,
-0.0181429442,
-0.0122754602,
-0.0089805787,
-0.019183021,
-0.022575479,
-0.0348324329,
0.0215803795,
-0.0245989431,
0.0114232488,
0.0396840125,
-0.0199694261,
0.0395139344,
-0.0359238312,
-0.0009671056,
0.0096007278,
0.0341706611,
0.036164239,
0.0906159505,
0.0448637791,
0.0052359835,
0.0208074544,
-0.0030253276,
0.0230638329,
0.0608614571,
0.0072422093,
0.0120082665,
0.0065097213,
0.0132457707,
-0.0308483001,
-0.0292140134,
0.0153665263,
0.0225185994,
-0.0207014456,
0.0137020499,
0.1006945893,
0.0506852716,
0.004025904,
0.0033704874,
-0.0293905381,
0.0719214156,
0.067251198,
0.0373848118,
-0.1157621667,
0.0024784864,
-0.0264125485,
0.0070428173,
-0.0292801131,
-0.0372977592,
-0.0226563383,
-0.1203285307,
0.0272741895,
-0.0127238389,
-0.0318271481,
0.0080115376,
-0.0459338464,
0.0089566903,
-0.0294268206,
-0.025402531,
-0.0360302925,
-0.0195688345,
0.0208326411,
-0.0043984209,
-0.0576292127,
-0.0263510831,
0.0885846466,
0.0017114826,
0.0165519509,
0.0437397026,
0.0360597521,
-0.0425613001,
-0.0441602096,
-0.0244971644,
-0.0377120003,
0.0050902991,
-0.0189659726,
0.0070386757,
0.0315055102,
-0.0192441214,
-0.0076906164,
-0.016027635,
-0.0302659161,
0.0029204253,
0.0412428863,
0.0913869888,
0.0247689765,
-0.0299066026,
-0.0043704766,
0.0390708819,
-0.030919319,
0.07956177,
0.0227859672,
-0.0086259078,
-0.003119505,
-0.001354172,
-0.0114536118,
-0.0199627001,
-0.0679807216,
0.020340668,
-0.0105620148,
-0.0130280275,
-0.061750412,
-0.0450385697,
0.0177605338,
0.0243712962,
-0.0225318223,
0.0302168448,
-0.0416545607,
0.0208428204,
-0.0240232814,
0.0201376081,
-0.0388483517,
-0.0214567427,
-0.0230261832,
-0.0088154981,
0.0616514385,
-0.0092271529,
-0.0437483266,
-0.0202227421,
-0.0889259353,
-0.0370915309,
0.0094341729,
0.0348329507,
0.0136407251,
-0.0066526979,
0.007410205,
-0.0269960184,
0.0429441631,
0.0274221413,
-0.0074180509,
0.0014202353,
0.0064626071,
0.0267059151,
0.0061602443,
0.0210595448,
-0.0473563373,
0.0553077012,
0.0044528255,
0.065539822,
-0.0632973239,
0.0124906041,
-0.0063314503,
0.0038704451,
0.0073642931,
-0.0130098574,
-0.0342572927,
0.0000305781,
-0.0013071296,
0.0046103089,
0.0032208823,
0.0142200077,
-0.0324637443,
0.0119027086,
-0.0481733009,
-0.0240880847,
0.0216417238,
0.0183481183,
0.0446470678,
-0.054494977,
0.0067073028,
0.0148040978,
-0.0003345717,
-0.0600269884,
0.0243426971,
-0.0183150172,
0.0268458556,
0.002623148,
0.0600852668,
-0.0177544989,
0.0793547258,
-0.0195030402,
0.009640133,
-0.0073663807,
0.011765019,
-0.0668497086,
-0.0515321419,
0.0289979633,
-0.000689871,
0.0864468068,
-0.0307128411,
0.0135869887,
0.0231188126,
-0.0263143983,
-0.007203558,
-0.0134794172,
0.0027722795,
-0.02231564,
0.0235280264,
0.0232016388,
-0.0203620642,
0.0194701143,
0.0692684427,
-0.030306289,
0.0040302263,
0.0770487785,
-0.050036747,
0.0004755793,
-0.0319222137,
-0.0022596556,
-0.0204788893,
0.0127212871,
0.0235275012,
-0.076274775,
-0.0747195408,
0.0220893789,
-0.0326846354,
-0.0084806383,
-0.0085572004,
0.0101617808,
0.0730024427,
-0.0100284219,
-0.011167014,
-0.0560069829,
-0.0013499868,
-0.020002814,
-0.0055825389,
-0.0099047087,
-6.5731778e-33,
-0.0154404053,
-0.0240634009,
-0.0032793398,
-0.0252772197,
0.0099479659,
0.0056696441,
-0.0172463078,
0.0084312623,
-0.0657971799,
0.0177623779,
-0.0277438164,
-0.0059559485,
0.014396904,
0.0056414637,
0.0429689772,
-0.0145584233,
-0.0318233296,
-0.0034245411,
-0.0036721239,
0.0151783684,
0.0557506867,
0.0148327192,
0.0668272227,
-0.0170863494,
0.0094147194,
0.0237000398,
0.0365365855,
0.020049395,
0.0309013706,
0.07813254,
-0.0175247118,
0.059463691,
0.0565226972,
-0.0551509634,
-0.0099932076,
0.0068402225,
-0.0904156268,
-0.0931621194,
0.0426038392,
-0.0388564765,
0.02084429,
-0.0322396569,
0.0077002109,
-0.0304406621,
0.014296025,
0.0046438444,
0.0392984822,
-0.021928193,
0.0033423759,
-0.0308429562,
-0.0100857159,
0.0324921831,
-0.0119843408,
0.0403687991,
-0.0160460211,
0.0385938287,
-0.0007254109,
0.0654064193,
-0.0249273926,
0.0364018083,
0.0121819992,
0.0466838144,
0.0502251051,
-0.0389488451,
0.0190315433,
0.0486667603,
0.0119173229,
0.0197571982,
-0.0065966207,
-0.0192126799,
0.0200847052,
-0.0279873628,
0.0287144855,
0.1053103358,
0.0712225288,
0.0006326804,
-0.0746927485,
0.0266407337,
0.0925733075,
-0.0283182859,
0.0248352662,
-0.0145557672,
-0.0236353446,
-0.0037540335,
-0.0173284337,
0.0653016195,
-0.0413044244,
-0.0524411574,
0.0481851734,
-0.0100795794,
-0.015470176,
-0.0010940897,
0.0711009577,
-0.016920479,
-0.0163606275,
0.0407384299,
0.0291610286,
-0.0110740419,
0.0384551249,
0.0299571622,
-0.0863123536,
0.0037049334,
-0.0306960903,
0.0092885466,
0.0041445899,
0.0026350145,
0.0004270359,
0.0004313441,
-0.0601597503,
-0.0126824286,
-0.0139391329,
-0.0209220573,
-0.0457270816,
-0.0197484214,
0.0075164824,
0.0074684583,
-0.0103817256,
0.0164417103,
0.0467702895,
-0.0081729852,
-0.0130036594,
-0.0657303259,
-0.0261930674,
0.0259914063,
-0.0238290299,
-0.0117813693,
-0.0000471273,
0.031795755,
-0.0125172948,
-0.01374825,
-0.0118632913,
0.0122128092,
2.595e-7,
0.0637395978,
0.0229141079,
-0.0441985764,
0.0709245875,
0.0131612038,
-0.041938778,
-0.0060033095,
-0.0078259772,
0.0145511758,
-0.0283014607,
0.0086424993,
0.0244841278,
0.0316644013,
0.0711991563,
-0.1109672189,
0.0091222581,
-0.0359591991,
-0.0071428698,
-0.0362621024,
-0.0305254124,
0.0111173159,
0.0891715363,
0.0108886929,
0.0044899774,
-0.0562777258,
-0.0333079658,
0.0562385321,
-0.0444556586,
-0.0236577578,
-0.0027268936,
-0.0036564402,
-0.0181881934,
0.007113948,
0.0036561859,
-0.0051630181,
0.0144777084,
0.0325771049,
0.0480474196,
0.0103253415,
-0.0447953567,
-0.0150486128,
-0.0009346298,
0.0057588024,
-0.1050229073,
0.0971939191,
-0.0488840975,
-0.0644497648,
0.0286236592,
-0.0174237248,
-0.0062552434,
0.043523632,
-0.0159908757,
-0.0218184032,
-0.0224839281,
-0.0040716934,
-0.0152452542,
0.023761671,
-0.0633561164,
-0.0084434757,
0.012837097,
-0.0322345644,
-0.0620005243,
-0.0007517175,
-0.0436880849,
-0.056946028,
-0.0198211651,
-0.0103907147,
2.370196096e-34,
0.0428606197,
0.0138570014,
-0.0056533613,
0.0508219898,
0.0483603999,
-0.0082799504,
0.0212471783,
-0.0127667068,
0.0333863534,
-0.0312878974,
0.0044652275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07884v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07884v2 | Fair Abstractive Summarization of Diverse Perspectives | 2023-11-14T03:38:55 | 2024-03-30T03:54:06 | Yusen Zhang, Nan Zhang, Yixin Liu, Alexander Fabbri, Junru Liu, Ryo Kamoi, Xiaoxin Lu, Caiming Xiong, Jieyu Zhao, Dragomir Radev, Kathleen McKeown, Rui Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | People from different social and demographic groups express diverse
perspectives and conflicting opinions on a broad set of topics such as product
reviews, healthcare, law, and politics. A fair summary should provide a
comprehensive coverage of diverse perspectives without underrepresenting
certain groups. However, current work in summarization metrics and Large
Language Models (LLMs) evaluation has not explored fair abstractive
summarization. In this paper, we systematically investigate fair abstractive
summarization for user-generated data. We first formally define fairness in
abstractive summarization as not underrepresenting perspectives of any groups
of people, and we propose four reference-free automatic metrics by measuring
the differences between target and source perspectives. We evaluate nine LLMs,
including three GPT models, four LLaMA models, PaLM 2, and Claude, on six
datasets collected from social media, online reviews, and recorded transcripts.
Experiments show that both the model-generated and the human-written reference
summaries suffer from low fairness. We conduct a comprehensive analysis of the
common factors influencing fairness and propose three simple but effective
methods to alleviate unfair summarization. Our dataset and code are available
at https://github.com/psunlpgroup/FairSumm. | [
0.0507975928,
0.0509114265,
0.0123786153,
0.001146115,
-0.0085330149,
-0.0070349285,
-0.0123684732,
-0.0403359234,
-0.0365549065,
-0.0592306033,
-0.0012370293,
-0.0446892381,
0.0276657455,
0.0112106455,
-0.0109920288,
-0.1016436741,
0.0168948285,
0.029149849,
0.0449880026,
-0.0190329887,
0.0635000467,
0.0224340558,
0.0186578576,
0.0656479672,
0.0149479927,
0.0132218543,
0.0520946458,
-0.0080106556,
0.0550224818,
0.0129357819,
0.0032828164,
0.0590180866,
-0.0356954969,
0.0346677974,
0.0000018291,
-0.0433486514,
-0.0162473861,
0.0022495058,
0.0460506715,
0.0343405716,
0.0927439556,
-0.034745004,
0.0266519729,
0.0313653313,
-0.0301355142,
-0.0021159539,
0.0168146677,
0.0631676614,
0.0926753804,
0.0065654875,
-0.0080555771,
-0.0271693002,
-0.0265233889,
-0.024878921,
-0.0243649464,
0.0007290916,
0.0100129582,
0.0230434984,
-0.0364263095,
-0.0183366276,
0.0268602986,
0.0272167921,
-0.0110144038,
-0.006072165,
0.0324663892,
-0.0049884929,
-0.0725895166,
-0.0273223966,
0.0380287319,
0.0777644143,
0.0310712177,
-0.0121240728,
0.0200347472,
-0.0171046592,
0.0261087716,
0.0233772732,
-0.0686320588,
0.0683991387,
-0.0088472236,
0.0480985343,
-0.0278235618,
0.0683542117,
0.0094193257,
0.021634005,
0.0000268667,
0.0452441089,
-0.0054519051,
-0.0069912402,
-0.0218628868,
0.0368401818,
-0.0119318794,
-0.0460592508,
0.0036201032,
0.000784877,
-0.0165983289,
-0.0073832753,
-0.0242190715,
-0.0461471193,
0.0643547997,
-0.0646873489,
0.0055975169,
-0.0222807676,
0.031705793,
0.0256287828,
0.0392135456,
-0.0214804113,
0.015722841,
0.0036904649,
-0.0314189345,
-0.0440174751,
-0.0049070884,
0.0157334171,
0.0183997713,
0.0378014781,
-0.0538800545,
0.0203622654,
-0.0577415712,
0.0074872323,
-0.0495755859,
-0.028137479,
0.0109203393,
0.0134856077,
0.010663582,
-0.0022615357,
-0.0389606431,
0.0108365025,
-0.0512700416,
-0.005966146,
-0.0173057541,
-0.0087447409,
0.0202530306,
0.0174197014,
-0.0021906993,
0.0212634411,
-0.0307665151,
0.0182890352,
0.0071696006,
-0.0133498935,
-0.012728353,
-0.0455646068,
-0.0015726268,
-0.0377360173,
-0.0429701693,
-0.0887624994,
0.0285422672,
0.0142015005,
-0.0001037466,
-0.0162306167,
-0.0231564883,
0.0319194682,
-0.042346485,
0.0249261316,
0.0076938216,
0.0219259765,
0.0635478646,
0.0290267728,
0.0079720635,
0.0612551086,
0.0415110886,
-0.0086098742,
0.0628037304,
0.0239862427,
0.0130376946,
0.0073954989,
0.0090339212,
0.0321340263,
0.0348817632,
-0.0078943577,
-0.0547547303,
-0.0249239989,
0.0203705952,
0.1058709323,
-0.0061117918,
-0.0054529938,
0.0536045805,
0.0787783638,
-0.0428812504,
0.0408327468,
-0.005812454,
0.0561459623,
0.0128661841,
0.0480139516,
-0.008395886,
0.0190727059,
-0.0265062228,
0.0121592404,
0.1168531105,
0.0302031953,
-0.0206562933,
-0.0370186418,
0.0049612359,
0.0054284544,
0.038975928,
-0.0010553005,
-0.0213153902,
-0.0113170408,
-0.0007477233,
0.0745362267,
0.0146723893,
-0.079140991,
0.0164128412,
-0.007983828,
0.0336759724,
0.0203677081,
-0.0001587528,
-0.0212134942,
0.0229752492,
-0.0302571319,
-0.0261058435,
0.0515527688,
0.071442917,
-0.0126070371,
-0.0280528087,
-0.037198931,
-0.0254457202,
0.0205898359,
0.0225302856,
0.0005850007,
0.0174741372,
0.0012591067,
0.0431616455,
-0.0259550605,
-0.0622486696,
0.0075737094,
0.0094988868,
0.0081082396,
-0.0114560835,
-0.0238211453,
0.0299397781,
0.0688670352,
-0.0249746125,
0.0164750442,
-0.0074744653,
-0.0197476372,
-0.02702404,
0.0135175344,
-0.061815545,
0.0203855522,
0.0291217957,
-0.1051969975,
-0.0028887296,
0.0377254747,
-0.023625955,
-0.0453317687,
0.0438000262,
-0.0236580521,
-0.0103323068,
-0.0177013986,
0.012222141,
-0.0160014145,
-0.0224154852,
-0.0369753242,
0.0498498417,
-0.00414115,
-0.0032026661,
0.0333720706,
-0.0991145894,
0.0138873225,
-0.0319873393,
-0.0365224704,
0.0080107562,
0.0282484405,
0.0364105441,
0.0688885525,
-0.023995053,
-0.0337538235,
-0.0163712483,
-0.0926268026,
-0.0122650638,
-0.0187928043,
0.0085525988,
0.0414213426,
0.0259117931,
0.0018763427,
0.0082940664,
-0.058610145,
-0.0505281538,
0.0182063524,
0.0179377012,
0.0319217145,
0.0270149224,
0.0539736561,
-0.0684051663,
-0.0381878614,
-0.006933779,
0.0543379746,
0.0354412571,
-0.0172837805,
-0.0327640101,
-0.0374696627,
-0.0438091196,
-0.0138744581,
0.0029753225,
0.0212600455,
-0.0125566293,
0.0412014723,
0.0362238437,
0.0024591165,
0.0517912209,
-0.0045625991,
0.043465741,
0.0356279388,
-0.0333256125,
-0.0403930061,
-0.0242837556,
0.0134485783,
0.0217445847,
-0.0726072118,
0.0516932011,
0.0432593301,
0.038130261,
-0.017648574,
-0.0726449564,
0.0380765013,
-0.0676484257,
-0.0077345958,
-0.035903275,
-0.0446666069,
-0.0148750432,
0.0111521538,
-0.0310078915,
-0.0174653493,
0.0475309864,
-0.0253845528,
0.0712856501,
-0.0473987088,
-0.0055364347,
-0.065963544,
0.0108262515,
-0.0197057445,
0.019706361,
-0.00648857,
0.0018680973,
-0.0373772532,
-0.0403207317,
0.0680188835,
-0.0415296853,
0.1077684611,
-0.0349262878,
0.0131660104,
-0.023059953,
-0.0216845423,
0.006604163,
-0.0903332308,
-0.0151472827,
0.0394642279,
0.0582573675,
-0.0122859739,
-0.0229321159,
0.0333839394,
0.0368705913,
0.0196178537,
-0.0140615152,
-0.0001640827,
0.0016353909,
0.0152661167,
0.0548719056,
-0.02081847,
0.0469632372,
-0.0438763238,
-0.0002010224,
0.0460644029,
0.0261966567,
-0.0033388841,
0.038874235,
-0.0552191325,
-0.0146922227,
-0.070155412,
-0.017298013,
-0.0235836245,
0.0724756569,
-0.0069647706,
0.0627325624,
0.1098092645,
0.0155886961,
-0.0853959024,
-0.0059011956,
-0.0049692034,
0.0268597603,
0.0054371813,
-0.0093162097,
-0.0693855956,
0.0177622009,
-0.0269606989,
0.0529883616,
-0.0310932416,
-0.045362141,
0.0058101811,
-0.0964978933,
-0.0164938681,
0.0188059621,
-0.0505947508,
-0.0635387003,
0.0024575794,
0.037529055,
-0.0136166662,
0.0202988591,
-0.0044437465,
-0.0125163076,
0.037215367,
0.0113335475,
-0.0919527337,
0.0198518727,
0.0066056573,
-0.0635987371,
0.0186586715,
0.0314902961,
0.0319946669,
0.0079787178,
0.0050187544,
0.026027631,
-0.0751326308,
-0.0405297689,
0.0159056615,
0.0546912253,
-0.0176778995,
0.0256786291,
-0.0461526439,
0.0326905362,
0.0234343205,
0.0099422317,
0.0060054064,
0.0017531506,
0.0250655301,
-0.0248348657,
-0.0599496886,
0.0331892483,
0.0008296485,
0.0809343532,
0.047369469,
0.0034894694,
-0.0205351431,
-0.0561208315,
-0.0005319591,
-0.0585852154,
-0.0535021685,
-0.0052027889,
-0.0189358853,
-0.0365618616,
-0.0686179921,
-0.0706758872,
-0.0137064978,
-0.0475431569,
-0.0147485612,
-0.0200071596,
0.0507424325,
0.0050889631,
-0.0179494396,
0.0066563222,
-0.0206875093,
0.0142641915,
-0.0043882951,
-0.0471039638,
0.026671011,
-0.0025615296,
-0.0164189693,
0.0298126787,
-0.0296157561,
-0.0457246862,
-0.0147427274,
-0.0035723068,
0.0226774048,
0.0395080671,
-0.0026864782,
-0.0333567746,
0.0448681153,
0.0175452624,
0.0293219779,
0.0250897184,
0.0013511439,
0.0571549423,
0.0005569226,
0.0298210792,
-0.0650678352,
0.0137191862,
-0.0284318235,
0.0203024894,
-0.0367336608,
-0.0461807251,
-0.0115812933,
0.031077465,
0.0021329243,
-0.0028043066,
-0.0130405184,
-0.0350023508,
-0.0515965149,
-0.0309722722,
-0.0233032759,
-0.0261526033,
0.009712805,
-0.0204880703,
-0.0070195529,
-0.035863135,
0.0394078232,
-0.0206538998,
0.0427524485,
-0.0588235781,
0.0422517471,
-0.047655642,
-0.0149190994,
-0.0504767708,
-0.0253176298,
-0.0515901782,
-0.0171476118,
-0.0458821654,
0.0081520285,
0.0108669177,
-0.0080213714,
0.0091209896,
0.0176780373,
-0.0064979279,
0.0309722256,
-0.0598523989,
0.0018004969,
-0.0404140912,
0.0186158121,
0.0091843987,
-0.0166307483,
0.0916190967,
0.0079743434,
-0.0047212364,
-0.0153728388,
0.0327427089,
0.0004567338,
0.0253376495,
-0.0031199446,
0.00019064,
-0.004917827,
-0.0072718998,
0.0897953361,
-0.0339091234,
0.0010239129,
-0.0105102994,
-0.0627331063,
-0.028869357,
-0.0159670543,
-0.0181509182,
0.0137477536,
0.0007832097,
-0.0392300598,
-0.0921117887,
-0.0211475641,
0.0289948285,
0.030067578,
0.0159830991,
-0.0071825841,
0.0119607057,
0.053385105,
-0.0001580516,
-0.0050548734,
-0.0533985868,
-0.0167354215,
-0.0153558254,
0.0211009998,
-0.0117759816,
-6.392633623e-33,
-0.0253475383,
-0.0275754072,
-0.0709879994,
0.0192493871,
-0.0411304496,
-0.0063376352,
-0.0376265608,
0.0282966346,
0.0042080604,
0.0184666067,
0.0105356704,
0.0422115847,
0.0148778185,
0.0236621406,
0.0110246446,
-0.0152007472,
0.04022469,
0.0074799573,
-0.0484402813,
0.0632152259,
-0.0036699646,
-0.0354470052,
0.0275824182,
-0.071161598,
0.0835586712,
-0.0196941141,
-0.001200942,
-0.0125036072,
0.0197454263,
0.0390591808,
-0.0039076149,
0.0789501145,
0.0487062261,
-0.0310340598,
-0.0362087153,
0.0408531092,
-0.0462812036,
-0.0193352215,
0.055674959,
-0.0380885825,
-0.0278977249,
-0.0419263467,
0.0596507341,
0.0182117261,
-0.0571468584,
-0.0430860035,
0.0638711527,
-0.0209365133,
0.0195886865,
-0.0675046816,
0.0019440022,
0.0476402715,
-0.0191576574,
0.0198305342,
-0.0027451785,
0.0061931876,
0.007956245,
0.0337155759,
-0.0220128931,
0.0423065014,
0.0160749089,
0.0026884214,
0.0293885898,
-0.0023847714,
0.0170642398,
0.0622002222,
-0.0155752106,
0.0135052102,
-0.0475982539,
-0.0396794751,
-0.0270225871,
-0.0414110683,
0.0209401026,
0.0803135335,
0.0205261577,
0.0260346401,
-0.0233987328,
0.0629998446,
0.0057580317,
-0.0082880389,
0.0607913695,
-0.0217845142,
-0.0149215087,
-0.0187670644,
-0.0319388732,
-0.0261792876,
-0.0071791452,
0.0161093418,
-0.0349598117,
0.0113666039,
-0.0554615743,
0.0097216908,
0.003614231,
-0.0470871441,
-0.0106268339,
0.0284964591,
-0.0225744043,
0.0059498134,
0.0145585621,
-0.040614821,
-0.0501977243,
0.0538225062,
0.0001723633,
0.0249143429,
-0.0061344989,
-0.0041147922,
0.0138787124,
-0.0091042193,
-0.0610414557,
0.0055160234,
0.0331226699,
0.0364012234,
-0.0388802737,
0.015315949,
-0.0060668238,
0.0227785893,
0.0044609825,
0.0273747481,
-0.0045539872,
0.0089408038,
-0.0092916628,
0.0119834319,
0.0034404008,
0.0111591043,
-0.0290871076,
0.0068840049,
0.0159602519,
0.0070423121,
0.0575901382,
-0.0107723307,
-0.0244951583,
-0.0367673561,
2.466e-7,
0.0873162448,
0.0371787697,
0.0209866501,
-0.0010030533,
-0.0104366019,
0.0412185565,
0.0586610958,
0.046837274,
0.0070648636,
-0.0198410265,
0.0026175487,
0.0311425645,
0.0226580892,
0.0469719321,
-0.0702228546,
-0.011352988,
-0.0874229521,
-0.0045408383,
-0.0142548168,
0.0127190901,
0.0529247187,
0.0534073152,
-0.0175934602,
0.0111331968,
-0.0205670502,
-0.0061593833,
0.0273097325,
-0.0398297831,
-0.0470126607,
0.0221521817,
0.0788015053,
-0.022825595,
0.0348770432,
-0.0090431534,
-0.0033522625,
-0.0089337854,
0.041680526,
0.0290717203,
0.0262749437,
-0.0244809724,
0.0016299326,
-0.0163946897,
0.0276683141,
-0.0243685972,
0.0282075573,
-0.0097560026,
-0.0278302282,
-0.058854524,
-0.035712868,
-0.0080496259,
0.0223075394,
0.005418431,
-0.0466503277,
0.0351295061,
0.0020724894,
0.0017837882,
-0.0096883113,
-0.0525075644,
-0.0548612177,
-0.0092617981,
-0.0060196137,
-0.0476717912,
0.0161956847,
-0.0148448385,
-0.0304980353,
-0.0301015172,
0.0568858869,
2.188568214e-34,
0.0786782876,
0.0114728715,
-0.0152615132,
-0.039141275,
0.0317532197,
0.0061372821,
-0.0307915099,
-0.0228443965,
0.0090822205,
-0.0436871387,
-0.0019893742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07879v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07879v2 | Toxicity Detection is NOT all you Need: Measuring the Gaps to Supporting Volunteer Content Moderators | 2023-11-14T03:18:28 | 2024-02-17T04:30:54 | Yang Trista Cao, Lovely-Frances Domingo, Sarah Ann Gilbert, Michelle Mazurek, Katie Shilton, Hal Daumé III | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Extensive efforts in automated approaches for content moderation have been
focused on developing models to identify toxic, offensive, and hateful content
with the aim of lightening the load for moderators. Yet, it remains uncertain
whether improvements on those tasks have truly addressed moderators' needs in
accomplishing their work. In this paper, we surface gaps between past research
efforts that have aimed to provide automation for aspects of content moderation
and the needs of volunteer content moderators, regarding identifying violations
of various moderation rules. To do so, we conduct a model review on Hugging
Face to reveal the availability of models to cover various moderation rules and
guidelines from three exemplar forums. We further put state-of-the-art LLMs to
the test, evaluating how well these models perform in flagging violations of
platform rules from one particular forum. Finally, we conduct a user survey
study with volunteer moderators to gain insight into their perspectives on
useful moderation models. Overall, we observe a non-trivial gap, as missing
developed models and LLMs exhibit moderate to low performance on a significant
portion of the rules. Moderators' reports provide guides for future work on
developing moderation assistant models. | [
0.1149065346,
0.0211292468,
-0.046249304,
-0.0320870653,
-0.0177692976,
0.0257037729,
0.0374007858,
0.0045758169,
0.0271914583,
-0.0545427315,
0.0139934765,
0.0089334827,
-0.0571185015,
0.0272024423,
-0.0280523021,
-0.0180540681,
0.0150283622,
0.0238029156,
0.0259606503,
0.0316500589,
0.0725865364,
0.0142760361,
0.002627844,
0.0394920297,
-0.0251881685,
0.0075511071,
0.0114512313,
0.0072179786,
0.0283387993,
0.0294951312,
0.021354666,
0.0265991166,
-0.0073012607,
0.0438973829,
0.0000019745,
-0.0436131395,
-0.0064804824,
-0.0170889683,
-0.0067441091,
-0.0352041088,
0.103893593,
-0.0107612032,
-0.0262871906,
0.0566376783,
-0.0057618441,
0.0323702395,
0.0276537221,
0.0187000409,
0.057364732,
0.0071881213,
-0.0291892011,
0.0659582689,
-0.0190054793,
0.0040350733,
-0.0124376807,
0.0317623056,
0.0474519543,
-0.0207779389,
-0.0359288566,
-0.0393125862,
0.0153665468,
0.0189470872,
0.0135418558,
-0.0388487242,
0.0122433696,
-0.0406770147,
0.0151346531,
-0.0469194241,
-0.0014655098,
0.0412210934,
0.0016827059,
-0.0242041275,
0.024187075,
0.0080427071,
0.0498053916,
0.0893805921,
-0.0392064638,
0.0291945059,
-0.0557068512,
-0.0171758495,
-0.0005605022,
0.0054536127,
0.0321456753,
0.0309466254,
0.0811470598,
-0.0309015121,
-0.0230999961,
-0.0350647904,
-0.0126917651,
0.0013774496,
0.0412581228,
-0.0133396024,
0.0715851113,
0.012987772,
-0.0380424447,
0.0030637684,
0.0022003176,
-0.0394513421,
0.064126797,
-0.0536635444,
0.0051574493,
0.0426994935,
-0.0444916859,
0.057663206,
0.0061980118,
0.0026004268,
0.0015796623,
0.0553472899,
-0.0054729031,
0.0371192917,
-0.0241328645,
0.0354108885,
-0.0048520197,
-0.0079547456,
0.0441509075,
0.0361773558,
-0.0154298311,
0.0342840403,
-0.0469523445,
-0.0100547234,
0.0681188479,
0.0187836345,
0.0062117283,
0.033645831,
-0.0529921278,
-0.0288192164,
-0.0485929027,
0.0547048934,
-0.0195738487,
-0.0216582455,
0.0107764006,
0.0155718205,
0.0032398319,
0.0013458966,
0.0486152433,
0.0591980554,
0.0669352263,
0.0014783355,
-0.0513624698,
-0.0199569426,
-0.0220334101,
-0.0212022867,
-0.0277809072,
-0.0620006584,
0.0339810885,
-0.0198919289,
-0.0159862991,
-0.020861879,
0.0010457367,
-0.0060866447,
0.0131929787,
0.0424018838,
-0.0027481886,
0.0222884566,
0.0328884125,
0.0531614088,
-0.0234973468,
0.033284042,
-0.0413715169,
0.0592148453,
0.05821402,
0.0156691093,
0.0157674737,
0.0213231556,
-0.027494913,
0.0358112566,
-0.0270432234,
0.0031981498,
-0.0574527979,
-0.0354209654,
-0.0168908723,
0.0529936142,
-0.0193759315,
-0.026778223,
0.0597518459,
0.0350076966,
-0.0369012021,
0.016225528,
0.0771491006,
-0.0306705367,
-0.0258654449,
-0.0204447974,
-0.0355503298,
0.0161482207,
-0.0227441397,
-0.0668138862,
-0.0272008777,
0.0882482231,
-0.0215909593,
-0.074982971,
-0.0154521167,
-0.0415994003,
0.0674209148,
-0.00455266,
0.0228807684,
0.0079822531,
0.0054635885,
-0.0495813861,
0.0198554341,
-0.0213647392,
0.0115813557,
-0.0801488981,
0.0654180348,
0.0873140916,
0.0258092377,
-0.0371855907,
-0.0147759691,
-0.0887494236,
0.0523303337,
0.0000322976,
0.0394053683,
-0.0156471375,
-0.0725549683,
-0.010910023,
-0.0561764166,
0.0204082988,
0.0232763626,
0.0167108551,
0.0189844184,
0.0140929343,
-0.0370221809,
0.0275191907,
-0.0249867346,
0.0426917672,
0.0248636901,
-0.0199079402,
-0.0450703017,
0.0272946488,
0.0740004107,
0.011811058,
0.0279361326,
-0.0117042186,
0.027071042,
0.0095960321,
-0.064280659,
-0.0351840034,
0.0466161929,
0.0673838481,
0.0454990081,
-0.0316286832,
-0.0009959564,
0.0264394488,
0.03063423,
0.0539369211,
0.0178442765,
0.010516759,
-0.0778678283,
-0.0354242921,
-0.027886074,
-0.0415842086,
-0.0217677299,
-0.0282486081,
0.0542825535,
-0.0142899519,
0.0066623571,
0.0468142852,
-0.0714306086,
0.0169804227,
0.0361922532,
-0.006348921,
-0.0607219711,
-0.0338859558,
0.0225056224,
0.0326012,
-0.0215758588,
-0.0189696029,
-0.0440525562,
-0.0659552217,
-0.0293330438,
-0.0167781487,
0.0202627219,
0.0470312908,
-0.0019132127,
-0.0024974043,
0.054478094,
-0.0145863341,
-0.0475543998,
0.0231381804,
0.0090149567,
0.0073012477,
-0.0515634678,
-0.0448220149,
-0.0276061818,
0.0147132855,
-0.0325560793,
-0.0263647735,
0.0320463702,
-0.0815680698,
0.0408173315,
0.0329913609,
-0.0753835365,
-0.0149598345,
-0.0139027545,
-0.0704792738,
0.0018530872,
-0.027488118,
0.001549567,
0.0389758237,
0.0514072701,
0.0802840292,
0.0492423661,
0.0351632275,
-0.0464637913,
-0.0099577345,
-0.0206511561,
-0.015893463,
-0.0099382307,
-0.0214167181,
0.0360527784,
0.0169900134,
0.0176459886,
0.025195796,
-0.0559662879,
0.0855595917,
-0.0412436239,
-0.0128249535,
0.0046653212,
-0.069735229,
0.0243542045,
0.0154671995,
-0.0199913345,
-0.0365946405,
0.061625801,
0.0311901048,
0.0332525596,
0.0268665906,
-0.0548468083,
-0.0419106111,
0.0252736621,
-0.0165318865,
0.034432251,
0.0163847208,
0.0272180997,
0.0154113984,
-0.0185323767,
0.1066824049,
-0.0610681586,
-0.0475665852,
-0.0233095214,
0.0065581128,
-0.0016182041,
-0.0436368957,
-0.0183291901,
-0.0339162424,
-0.0275751948,
-0.0151287597,
0.0023644001,
0.0556737483,
-0.0138280019,
0.0453768298,
0.0372999161,
-0.0374483801,
0.0103527298,
-0.0319049731,
0.0323584005,
-0.0281140301,
-0.0300706904,
-0.0113957655,
0.0041390802,
0.0034860282,
0.0166689828,
0.0561283566,
-0.0458854064,
-0.022799423,
0.0233348254,
0.0145657221,
0.02013194,
0.0002665614,
0.0052082692,
-0.0036588667,
-0.0175174884,
-0.0200933143,
0.0368030928,
0.0296372157,
0.0411020704,
-0.0143914903,
-0.0296075586,
-0.0489610098,
-0.014655076,
0.0304629356,
-0.0135812266,
-0.0625188425,
0.0233146232,
0.0080343494,
0.023101151,
-0.1004038379,
-0.0469796807,
0.0338547975,
-0.0160452593,
0.0474826992,
-0.0109458333,
-0.0404823683,
-0.007645505,
-0.0616358481,
-0.0022942182,
-0.0602128245,
-0.0002562311,
-0.0234582927,
0.0072827358,
-0.007342923,
0.0213368107,
-0.0137465792,
-0.0104286848,
-0.0088988934,
-0.0510313958,
0.0383649282,
0.0108010555,
0.0073491791,
-0.024940243,
0.0027811714,
0.0531879142,
0.0271261223,
-0.0291667096,
-0.0042561479,
0.0661384314,
-0.0068971673,
-0.0070996317,
-0.0563351028,
0.0656156838,
-0.0065910639,
0.0175745208,
0.0024697962,
0.0718249455,
0.0515265949,
-0.0142971072,
-0.0543837324,
0.001858506,
0.0447794311,
0.0255034883,
0.0248929746,
-0.0629744828,
-0.0084244013,
-0.0507037938,
0.0027619484,
0.0030438146,
-0.1009376124,
-0.0316191539,
0.0210962445,
-0.0153794223,
-0.0286548492,
0.008172716,
0.0102399392,
0.0111634731,
0.0489593074,
-0.0006725874,
-0.0206624251,
0.0003482997,
0.0376694202,
-0.0019159907,
-0.0093649784,
0.0405615121,
-0.0236691739,
-0.0020983226,
-0.0211640354,
0.0044379234,
-0.0148941847,
-0.0235014409,
-0.0037493911,
-0.022706626,
0.0576791316,
0.0757422894,
0.0230698604,
-0.0337124243,
-0.0250036679,
-0.0040024836,
0.0074142679,
0.0649574026,
-0.0310221016,
-0.0204293132,
0.0430689454,
0.013536837,
0.0148735605,
-0.006049491,
-0.0395014733,
0.0344077274,
0.0208630506,
-0.0560468622,
-0.040442124,
0.0194412116,
0.0298239328,
0.0319910496,
-0.0360662118,
0.0223368797,
-0.0548280962,
-0.0168776382,
-0.035199374,
0.0110212462,
-0.0425993614,
0.0097677987,
0.0357858948,
0.0181068964,
-0.0164889134,
-0.00987544,
0.0150853498,
-0.0281848144,
0.0514301881,
-0.0382409357,
0.0215908382,
0.00791921,
0.0168219935,
0.0273730569,
-0.019062357,
-0.0323075727,
0.0375869796,
0.0223919358,
-0.019623993,
-0.0221212078,
0.0195559971,
-0.0130766127,
0.0272825044,
0.0058004819,
-0.0015153128,
-0.0168637317,
-0.0593461506,
-0.0060547083,
0.0247424096,
0.0043288744,
0.0091345394,
-0.0117194103,
0.0125180809,
-0.0330125652,
-0.0132588828,
0.01578198,
-0.0062352028,
-0.0010001187,
0.0387619622,
0.0411431566,
-0.0252552629,
-0.0163328331,
-0.0169912931,
-0.0112127541,
0.0229115393,
-0.0047311052,
-0.0577567257,
-0.024891194,
-0.0133994222,
0.0012291117,
0.0384408422,
-0.0155809289,
-0.0071877982,
-0.0790926814,
-0.0056851828,
-0.0299132708,
-0.0151992477,
0.0246110968,
-0.0301938206,
-0.0384557322,
0.0446251109,
0.0311754979,
0.0472483262,
-0.0334528461,
-0.0084612994,
-0.0269921012,
-0.0253264848,
-0.0036655823,
-5.712101372e-33,
-0.0058887,
-0.0462347567,
-0.0131943729,
0.0366428904,
0.018832434,
-0.0589381121,
0.030379707,
0.0200842768,
-0.001506316,
0.0011866696,
-0.0100962427,
-0.0091973078,
-0.0019075591,
-0.0694244578,
0.0094866883,
-0.0356054157,
0.044300314,
-0.0375291519,
-0.0263002608,
0.0091690309,
-0.009917222,
-0.0038501252,
-0.0565666929,
-0.0906131566,
0.0181291532,
0.0115347663,
-0.024972992,
0.037266925,
-0.0352849029,
0.0909846425,
0.0013372072,
0.0384296104,
0.0446454696,
0.0068774023,
0.0422324352,
0.0266136304,
-0.0841237828,
0.023944078,
0.0289606899,
-0.0333357751,
-0.0030558654,
-0.0074587562,
0.0376701578,
0.0075676506,
-0.0123856068,
-0.0210451875,
0.0564501025,
-0.0349370241,
0.0015461756,
-0.0603219867,
-0.0218834765,
-0.0094356444,
-0.0435334407,
-0.0113214562,
-0.011561729,
0.0583054572,
0.0030029328,
0.060966976,
-0.015887415,
-0.0087972665,
-0.0431489944,
-0.0442504957,
-0.008518721,
-0.0068920162,
-0.012686816,
0.0560158938,
-0.0157802086,
0.0592255555,
-0.0497261733,
0.0033566831,
-0.0103832986,
0.0450841039,
0.0456624702,
0.0430959761,
-0.0120826922,
-0.09254843,
-0.0721062049,
0.010820861,
0.0602122359,
0.0253309179,
0.0288310256,
-0.047293473,
-0.0463678725,
-0.0126567306,
0.0132784778,
-0.0927358046,
-0.0431219414,
-0.0346538946,
0.017600745,
0.0261127222,
-0.0705675259,
-0.1113194674,
-0.0150350807,
-0.028694354,
0.0143966954,
0.043792855,
0.0231144354,
0.0149844903,
0.0379868522,
-0.0055393139,
-0.0695618913,
0.0055367183,
-0.01913183,
-0.0295446869,
0.0353022777,
-0.0485398807,
0.0490615182,
0.0557955578,
-0.0378957652,
0.0092137791,
-0.0045625353,
0.0567621887,
-0.0119273392,
0.0751245543,
-0.0287984964,
0.0199895278,
0.0225914102,
-0.0279942416,
0.0182599574,
-0.0089563616,
-0.0227187704,
-0.0054980619,
-0.0332842432,
-0.0116110127,
-0.029249819,
-0.0324338637,
-0.0234572664,
0.039945323,
0.0496023297,
-0.0511215627,
0.0163146537,
-0.0591645911,
2.755e-7,
0.0163143035,
0.0232011415,
-0.0010567197,
-0.0395847894,
0.0505162179,
0.0096437521,
-0.0030243173,
0.007297134,
0.0264266804,
-0.0341714956,
0.0300210826,
0.0203250796,
0.0191417821,
0.0359848887,
-0.0259432141,
-0.0432951562,
-0.0219639614,
-0.018475676,
-0.0402508639,
0.0239784885,
-0.01398513,
0.0082848845,
0.0362252034,
-0.0277084764,
-0.0036125008,
-0.036041677,
0.0218509771,
-0.0476522893,
-0.0036757507,
0.0139891049,
0.0792375654,
0.0062107504,
-0.0041361488,
-0.0135667194,
0.0190841593,
0.0166297965,
-0.0216619708,
0.071704641,
0.0346402526,
0.0336548127,
0.0318171047,
-0.0353223532,
0.0470531732,
-0.0182694253,
0.0561082996,
0.0048442916,
-0.0041289665,
-0.0775072575,
-0.0289355107,
-0.0547716357,
0.0377735831,
-0.0186480824,
-0.0407324955,
-0.0089660315,
-0.0256998744,
0.0104216086,
0.0135197258,
-0.0305394754,
0.0112969605,
-0.0499740168,
-0.0248525385,
-0.1065155789,
0.0236025658,
0.0307710413,
0.014038166,
0.0334535092,
0.0497372262,
2.411503243e-34,
0.0246808324,
-0.015964767,
0.0280439854,
-0.0429006144,
0.0179975759,
0.0193675812,
-0.0144781051,
-0.0334636383,
0.0175099596,
0.0002666272,
0.0156603586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07853v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07853v2 | Learning Mutually Informed Representations for Characters and Subwords | 2023-11-14T02:09:10 | 2024-04-08T15:23:39 | Yilin Wang, Xinyi Hu, Matthew R. Gormley | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Most pretrained language models rely on subword tokenization, which processes
text as a sequence of subword tokens. However, different granularities of text,
such as characters, subwords, and words, can contain different kinds of
information. Previous studies have shown that incorporating multiple input
granularities improves model generalization, yet very few of them outputs
useful representations for each granularity. In this paper, we introduce the
entanglement model, aiming to combine character and subword language models.
Inspired by vision-language models, our model treats characters and subwords as
separate modalities, and it generates mutually informed representations for
both granularities as output. We evaluate our model on text classification,
named entity recognition, POS-tagging, and character-level sequence labeling
(intraword code-switching). Notably, the entanglement model outperforms its
backbone language models, particularly in the presence of noisy texts and
low-resource languages. Furthermore, the entanglement model even outperforms
larger pre-trained models on all English sequence labeling tasks and
classification tasks. We make our code publically available. | [
0.0236391872,
0.0590181649,
0.0108808791,
0.0488021299,
-0.0167620108,
0.0636134744,
-0.0109504759,
0.0475818291,
0.0286071301,
-0.0732363686,
-0.0476591252,
-0.0573403053,
0.0153287025,
0.0758189037,
0.0501437858,
-0.0709878728,
0.0688140392,
-0.0433099121,
-0.0334816054,
0.012062924,
0.0293057878,
-0.0008218373,
0.0164317042,
0.026505718,
-0.0084127616,
-0.002130812,
0.0070727766,
0.0045641498,
0.000544338,
0.0166487861,
0.0075290906,
0.0429506414,
0.0334136784,
0.0151231885,
0.0000018214,
0.0028797837,
-0.0175914075,
-0.0119283786,
0.0096553173,
0.0064074476,
-0.0103070531,
-0.0486875251,
-0.0029347641,
0.0088125337,
-0.0018392403,
-0.0367834419,
0.0687237829,
0.0726219714,
0.0483890101,
0.0591550395,
-0.0267717987,
-0.0381786302,
0.0312457215,
-0.0517466739,
0.0069287717,
-0.0100943595,
0.0187197365,
-0.0021198788,
-0.0382815525,
0.0077734734,
-0.0348308682,
0.0078307651,
0.0048675705,
0.0017942177,
0.0310785305,
0.0392198302,
0.0446556509,
-0.0281892624,
-0.0000628388,
0.104270637,
-0.0607312173,
-0.012817028,
0.0055923718,
-0.0340942815,
-0.0314559713,
-0.045722574,
0.0171857662,
0.0241275597,
0.0019591085,
0.028277019,
-0.0035437092,
0.0368801877,
0.0344874188,
0.0177318528,
-0.0389592648,
0.0182034299,
0.032381285,
-0.0121964356,
-0.032396432,
-0.0165474974,
-0.0304313991,
-0.0555710196,
0.0061152317,
-0.0035787893,
0.0339200012,
0.0279342514,
-0.0390214734,
-0.0208152756,
-0.0142821213,
-0.0394274257,
-0.0087242769,
0.0442705415,
-0.0117581626,
0.0471983477,
-0.0394637659,
0.0230501648,
-0.0205444563,
0.0487161763,
-0.0081962962,
-0.0461581908,
-0.0383115187,
-0.0082247965,
-0.0318084545,
0.0599017739,
-0.0295044668,
-0.0392197967,
-0.0208139364,
0.0043726042,
0.0066142059,
-0.0013696473,
-0.0343392268,
0.0008262826,
-0.0135162342,
-0.0345703177,
-0.0182527769,
0.0336542949,
-0.0224970728,
-0.0077653197,
-0.0352882668,
-0.0247752648,
-0.0153487977,
0.0567937903,
0.0072576245,
-0.0532681867,
0.0047711334,
0.0875927582,
-0.0130073987,
-0.0833455548,
-0.0380311571,
0.0126894796,
-0.0176861901,
-0.0204081684,
-0.0348417945,
-0.0577831306,
0.0249574743,
0.0025341273,
0.0126687149,
-0.0601548217,
0.0210062005,
0.0033082415,
-0.0496635474,
0.1238261387,
-0.0418730415,
-0.0410649851,
-0.0125573045,
0.0414975621,
0.0904861838,
0.0565478988,
0.0570296086,
0.052273795,
0.0082826596,
-0.032777071,
0.00479544,
0.0422233455,
-0.0015629106,
-0.0236577429,
-0.0553933121,
0.0025509847,
0.0431166142,
0.0070554004,
0.0206228122,
0.0793102384,
-0.0488523208,
-0.0013705529,
0.0485953018,
0.0513812117,
-0.0045205862,
0.0342669971,
0.0254184175,
0.0121503714,
-0.0153980739,
0.0092681283,
0.0022068003,
0.0230690744,
-0.0241940189,
0.002428829,
0.0166963805,
-0.0176549014,
-0.0375958011,
-0.0427350365,
-0.0120115345,
-0.0530260205,
0.0356317461,
-0.0142483097,
0.0649130493,
0.0274785329,
-0.0913442001,
0.0104815988,
0.032887809,
-0.0452140346,
0.0356235057,
-0.0454471819,
0.022121463,
0.0926830694,
0.0232320894,
-0.0357274599,
0.0072977766,
-0.038364619,
-0.0160532501,
0.0412023254,
0.0176377296,
-0.0203341171,
0.040350005,
-0.0594727024,
0.0084394319,
0.0184535477,
-0.0201829653,
0.0440403931,
-0.0077651176,
-0.023176454,
0.0162802339,
-0.0129880402,
-0.0023022704,
0.0503326803,
-0.0270406175,
-0.0249085613,
-0.0091366889,
0.0255595054,
0.0102937408,
-0.0093579162,
-0.0393572003,
0.0210887995,
0.02612889,
-0.0462712571,
-0.0272370353,
-0.0145848617,
-0.0116070453,
-0.027346354,
0.0048216921,
-0.0108905202,
-0.004385741,
-0.0121624833,
-0.0130229481,
-0.0553021692,
0.005617314,
-0.0219775382,
0.0609674826,
-0.0469369888,
0.0143370954,
0.019710701,
0.0123520987,
-0.0649999008,
0.0520833172,
-0.039838668,
0.028212674,
-0.0059412038,
-0.0330137014,
0.0205299649,
-0.0060287165,
-0.0126968678,
0.035515286,
0.0245513394,
-0.0098116687,
0.0191873834,
-0.0304387268,
-0.0075031449,
-0.0384803116,
-0.0774373859,
-0.0238125306,
-0.0082991971,
0.0062357252,
0.0029883778,
0.0242274329,
0.0060341214,
-0.046727661,
-0.0152858384,
-0.0216138568,
-0.0310330223,
0.0051996177,
0.0549430102,
-0.0053910376,
0.013860804,
-0.0429246724,
-0.0139358947,
-0.0180529505,
0.0579611063,
-0.019439809,
-0.0755557343,
-0.0573605746,
-0.0109783122,
0.014099218,
0.039807003,
-0.0074280491,
-0.0440416709,
-0.0092441887,
0.0017550086,
0.0424184576,
0.0371127874,
0.0068759932,
0.0666649044,
0.026574377,
-0.0117764082,
-0.0183323566,
0.0009349158,
0.0036862916,
0.0224012844,
-0.0280936211,
-0.0134760337,
-0.0138422791,
0.0850668848,
-0.0052760239,
0.0364395715,
-0.0840871185,
-0.0137341609,
0.0118044503,
-0.0263082907,
-0.0531990938,
-0.031867709,
-0.0217085425,
0.020544447,
-0.0507347137,
-0.0495195724,
0.0495207049,
-0.05229114,
-0.0127024548,
-0.0175436288,
0.0014578324,
-0.0271441787,
0.0846268088,
0.0458154343,
0.026192883,
0.0126323299,
-0.055544626,
-0.0447724089,
0.0248505063,
-0.0224284176,
-0.0238864925,
0.0275997501,
0.0136925122,
0.0220728274,
0.0029767582,
0.0055077048,
-0.0305616315,
-0.0465012975,
-0.0290989168,
0.0346304737,
0.0143146841,
-0.0409680456,
0.0025789014,
0.0436071455,
0.0112245185,
0.0391495191,
0.0276519377,
0.015216317,
-0.043829754,
0.0337085165,
0.0430238247,
-0.029890215,
-0.0028116226,
-0.0482445061,
0.0076137311,
0.0396645591,
-0.0215559341,
-0.0145052001,
-0.0056222398,
0.0090347445,
0.0622135513,
-0.025461128,
-0.0172559787,
-0.0060009183,
0.0433435179,
-0.0428131483,
-0.0137463305,
0.1370353699,
0.0325515755,
-0.0387863144,
-0.0007145253,
0.0561649092,
0.0064980732,
0.0143499756,
-0.0003964037,
-0.0762923807,
-0.0542338379,
0.0093023097,
-0.0130902166,
0.037962012,
-0.0254002642,
0.005130792,
-0.0779592097,
-0.0163984671,
0.0088501405,
-0.0045028916,
-0.0658256412,
-0.0094648078,
-0.0032923431,
-0.0026864936,
-0.0241896529,
-0.0140753333,
-0.0204414669,
-0.0144116906,
0.017793268,
0.0053376025,
-0.0078245103,
0.018306924,
-0.0446747541,
0.0252165198,
0.0830315799,
0.0289567355,
-0.025901923,
-0.0257899929,
-0.004263306,
-0.0446269326,
-0.0110162469,
-0.0015284336,
0.0533250049,
-0.0711623877,
-0.0359012671,
0.0099964151,
0.008669354,
-0.0344142206,
-0.043376226,
-0.0490298495,
0.0111628138,
-0.0143033713,
0.015112659,
0.0162756294,
-0.0056431978,
0.0100286677,
0.0741728395,
0.0235059094,
-0.0463412553,
-0.0203089733,
-0.016896164,
0.0346741751,
-0.0191756412,
-0.0065449681,
-0.0239102747,
0.0012072946,
-0.0432311408,
-0.0798871443,
-0.0024409785,
0.0511430241,
0.0363922343,
0.0092320452,
0.0094153164,
0.0029828486,
-0.0163246468,
-0.046432294,
0.0140485326,
-0.0021428224,
0.0222456846,
-0.0775326565,
-0.028932469,
0.0131488154,
-0.039269127,
-0.0390576459,
0.0053933328,
-0.0759913623,
-0.067450501,
-0.0018362921,
0.0390550829,
0.0163124707,
0.0359153189,
-0.0377640463,
-0.073155798,
-0.004691388,
0.0257953778,
-0.0140994843,
-0.0211247243,
0.0285941586,
0.0103952438,
-0.0216960702,
0.0137659879,
-0.0226565748,
0.0167175382,
0.0369584896,
-0.0091922749,
-0.0501976833,
-0.0347416438,
-0.004102312,
-0.027387945,
0.0620191395,
-0.0267251786,
0.0108716702,
-0.0581231564,
0.0176181961,
0.0107177095,
-0.0075100167,
-0.033362262,
-0.0205094758,
0.0541855469,
-0.0185374673,
-0.0229744781,
0.05226117,
0.0096891122,
0.0088295313,
0.0045730411,
0.0261299144,
-0.0088322824,
0.0439993814,
-0.0144659523,
-0.0018741539,
0.0148248654,
0.0450985543,
-0.0248720888,
0.0022523592,
-0.0319768488,
0.0252444558,
0.0111102406,
-0.0048460048,
-0.0173878632,
0.0355324857,
-0.0529716648,
-0.02342562,
-0.0389388166,
0.049726855,
0.03327737,
-0.0124328779,
-0.0012196109,
-0.033372052,
-0.0117008612,
-0.0085734772,
0.0511550047,
-0.0021400105,
-0.010654957,
0.0239220485,
0.0320962369,
-0.0541970357,
-0.007412306,
0.0876745433,
0.0482693575,
0.0380517244,
0.0230130814,
-0.0096719814,
-0.0385645069,
0.0065580523,
0.0302458405,
0.0831424445,
-0.0263501555,
0.0744984373,
-0.0350088105,
-0.0530016832,
0.0126143731,
0.0029236069,
0.0139013194,
0.022512611,
0.0374715775,
0.0186488274,
0.0237879734,
0.0074622165,
-0.0512522385,
0.0085591124,
0.0755126476,
-0.0235602539,
-0.0121437432,
-6.280150568e-33,
-0.0399886072,
0.0049019475,
-0.0361117348,
-0.0008454722,
-0.0125936093,
0.0295739416,
-0.0159670487,
-0.0035542864,
-0.0149001526,
-0.0297858957,
0.0210285634,
0.0416797251,
0.0172047764,
0.0273331236,
-0.02403895,
-0.0283570196,
0.0724085048,
0.0134643251,
-0.0034695913,
-0.0066353949,
0.0387012251,
0.054529734,
0.0940023884,
-0.0331025533,
0.0313543826,
-0.0312891938,
-0.0179790836,
0.0085817007,
0.032212507,
0.04912588,
-0.0532096513,
0.0100636762,
-0.0004324139,
0.0175379757,
-0.0156145636,
0.0433194712,
-0.1130128577,
0.0167708378,
0.0238606595,
0.0106343646,
-0.0493808649,
-0.0226641186,
0.0409226865,
-0.0224102456,
0.0483109914,
-0.006953727,
0.0346844085,
0.0053048227,
-0.0090574063,
-0.0126522165,
-0.0743397251,
0.0394131131,
-0.0126749286,
-0.0092734955,
0.063421987,
-0.004663643,
0.0394335613,
0.0318432897,
-0.0696660653,
-0.0052815159,
0.0281614773,
0.043115247,
0.0074454183,
0.0529395863,
-0.0065813833,
0.0854756907,
0.0255776756,
-0.0331265889,
-0.0417999476,
-0.0142037133,
0.0347666442,
0.0319506526,
0.045320306,
0.0161996949,
0.0501891971,
-0.0328907035,
-0.0815250501,
-0.0175569467,
0.0133757852,
0.0360727236,
0.000842138,
0.0177888218,
-0.0543403998,
-0.0154732438,
-0.0254223924,
-0.0611440018,
-0.0362261683,
-0.0323187746,
0.0070780129,
0.0136389835,
-0.0441921055,
0.0328073502,
0.0491323583,
-0.0325297937,
-0.0185642745,
0.0151402317,
0.0253016651,
0.0288332403,
0.0029209594,
0.0445297621,
-0.0602590106,
-0.076422058,
0.0368071944,
-0.0257477481,
0.0165669788,
0.0018361284,
0.0582878105,
-0.0056443512,
-0.0683643669,
-0.0071291095,
-0.0290958006,
-0.0103254411,
0.0031863812,
0.0309896916,
0.0398673899,
0.031462539,
-0.0301904436,
0.0504921675,
-0.009841606,
-0.0123474468,
-0.0067148712,
-0.0582581908,
0.007367779,
0.0543002225,
0.0021014293,
-0.0210372005,
-0.0118341222,
0.0136213992,
0.0475532487,
-0.0289421622,
-0.0051568588,
0.046694912,
2.558e-7,
0.0804642588,
0.035607934,
0.0621354654,
-0.0333897471,
0.0189666674,
0.0381203629,
-0.0037889355,
0.0397537537,
-0.0401392952,
-0.0226500183,
-0.0161485597,
0.0074642873,
0.0273328722,
-0.0196188223,
-0.0503490195,
0.029120896,
-0.012497792,
0.0107802451,
-0.019431198,
0.0205596946,
0.0890466645,
0.1091609001,
0.0247354843,
0.0167668276,
0.0257560145,
-0.0262704473,
0.0861920044,
-0.026299201,
0.0040632891,
0.0082920985,
-0.0117337033,
0.0721238181,
-0.0093068508,
0.0408480018,
-0.0193896722,
-0.0004926831,
0.0842033029,
0.028543951,
-0.0483903922,
0.0084739951,
-0.0278989226,
0.0034820784,
-0.0227155071,
-0.0238234792,
0.1078216136,
-0.02972758,
-0.019981103,
-0.0291210543,
-0.0016903507,
0.0419258028,
0.0116708698,
-0.0111626731,
-0.0721766278,
0.0388606898,
0.031579636,
-0.018411966,
-0.0189188384,
-0.0812576339,
-0.0238894857,
-0.0282113999,
-0.0139734596,
0.0040316982,
-0.0486406907,
-0.0250618346,
0.0341117643,
-0.0587335341,
-0.0208823849,
2.503138997e-34,
0.0267363358,
-0.0096191578,
-0.0389974341,
0.0448259078,
0.0216924641,
-0.0400322266,
-0.0075196484,
-0.0011758263,
-0.0084983055,
-0.0446928367,
-0.0059312396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07850v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07850v2 | Bring Your Own KG: Self-Supervised Program Synthesis for Zero-Shot KGQA | 2023-11-14T02:05:29 | 2024-05-22T02:46:08 | Dhruv Agarwal, Rajarshi Das, Sopan Khosla, Rashmi Gangadharaiah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.LG | We present BYOKG, a universal question-answering (QA) system that can operate
on any knowledge graph (KG), requires no human-annotated training data, and can
be ready to use within a day -- attributes that are out-of-scope for current
KGQA systems. BYOKG draws inspiration from the remarkable ability of humans to
comprehend information present in an unseen KG through exploration -- starting
at random nodes, inspecting the labels of adjacent nodes and edges, and
combining them with their prior world knowledge. In BYOKG, exploration
leverages an LLM-backed symbolic agent that generates a diverse set of
query-program exemplars, which are then used to ground a retrieval-augmented
reasoning procedure to predict programs for arbitrary questions. BYOKG is
effective over both small- and large-scale graphs, showing dramatic gains in QA
accuracy over a zero-shot baseline of 27.89 and 58.02 F1 on GrailQA and MetaQA,
respectively. On GrailQA, we further show that our unsupervised BYOKG
outperforms a supervised in-context learning method, demonstrating the
effectiveness of exploration. Lastly, we find that performance of BYOKG
reliably improves with continued exploration as well as improvements in the
base LLM, notably outperforming a state-of-the-art fine-tuned model by 7.08 F1
on a sub-sampled zero-shot split of GrailQA. | [
0.0271172449,
0.0193178989,
0.0052188924,
0.025699107,
0.010636677,
-0.002106363,
-0.0140687274,
-0.0279202219,
0.0449089929,
-0.0460069999,
-0.017811181,
0.0615826435,
-0.0757362247,
0.0418092795,
0.02098657,
0.007220862,
0.0338489264,
-0.0218307152,
0.0017609581,
-0.0180730168,
-0.0240731761,
0.0316059329,
-0.0153840957,
0.0292582419,
-0.0138197932,
-0.026629921,
-0.0569396392,
0.0116922855,
-0.0125425188,
-0.0453391783,
-0.0351176821,
0.0143700382,
0.0331577957,
0.0173925664,
0.0000020874,
-0.0521351509,
-0.0082097789,
-0.0124274958,
-0.0673718154,
-0.0346416384,
-0.0170901604,
0.0389329828,
0.0234940518,
-0.0154509451,
-0.0538313836,
-0.0180515256,
0.0191308092,
-0.0020541078,
0.0551412664,
0.0554896407,
0.0110710356,
-0.0376534685,
-0.0111749433,
0.0049556615,
0.0543602444,
-0.04845047,
0.0052569425,
0.0367977768,
0.0409405865,
-0.0116928956,
-0.0194045566,
0.0297754854,
0.0166917313,
-0.0041928957,
0.027631402,
0.0276156534,
-0.0543618537,
0.0124757951,
0.0100127095,
0.1162550524,
0.0146900322,
-0.0404656157,
0.0237833913,
0.0013398824,
0.0227760877,
-0.007991665,
-0.0446045622,
0.0104299281,
-0.0043076337,
-0.0169181786,
-0.0275604371,
-0.0067720837,
0.0212814547,
-0.015289343,
-0.0452020839,
0.0928322598,
-0.0025279794,
-0.0068835658,
0.0041053151,
0.0065645352,
-0.0160003603,
-0.0342928357,
-0.0609016009,
0.0871136785,
-0.0243525505,
0.0273121819,
-0.0097898562,
0.0235429108,
-0.0016041803,
0.0164025202,
0.0323411375,
0.054678008,
0.0318308771,
0.0560308099,
-0.0346249677,
0.0306208376,
0.0068158396,
0.0378026702,
-0.0590924919,
-0.0121136755,
-0.1008803546,
-0.0203315057,
-0.0571227521,
0.0816230699,
-0.0372877382,
-0.0106607517,
-0.0088688014,
0.0691233948,
0.022720933,
-0.0060847625,
0.0099258581,
0.0619461723,
-0.0189616103,
0.0041718874,
-0.0400538966,
0.002246019,
-0.0879072994,
-0.02144037,
0.0178627893,
-0.0315691493,
-0.0301180296,
0.0072680409,
0.0209300946,
-0.0080850339,
0.010571003,
0.1042752713,
-0.017274132,
-0.0183131378,
-0.0189606957,
-0.0716322511,
-0.004727833,
-0.0403110757,
0.0139140356,
-0.0861722603,
0.025907401,
-0.0023361868,
-0.0360623747,
0.0130650569,
0.0307395775,
0.024349181,
0.0083517358,
0.0477528423,
-0.0175820123,
-0.002554558,
0.0224977769,
-0.0007867704,
-0.0236844905,
0.081255652,
0.0138804987,
0.0162742436,
0.0398186892,
0.0248625707,
-0.0008634037,
-0.0016762508,
0.0415194742,
-0.0055932552,
-0.0054007913,
0.0371843055,
-0.013966213,
0.0256513506,
-0.0113562504,
-0.0134894121,
-0.0237482525,
-0.0222416464,
-0.0227376372,
0.0709745809,
0.0034850864,
0.0037092536,
0.0481114648,
0.0279809665,
0.0156750903,
-0.0526587777,
-0.0445708893,
0.0697500855,
-0.0339622609,
0.0312540121,
-0.0166826826,
-0.014543321,
-0.0569437109,
-0.0462445542,
0.005323661,
0.0243735034,
-0.0081229964,
0.0002696173,
0.0474892445,
0.0437359512,
-0.0359869376,
-0.0020367522,
-0.0026532602,
-0.0234130081,
-0.0153977266,
-0.0446728989,
0.0672707632,
0.0511248372,
0.076863572,
-0.0196728278,
-0.0238845386,
0.0134480372,
0.0020970746,
0.0086965282,
-0.0352957137,
-0.0279413722,
0.0041491911,
-0.0216019601,
-0.0347845927,
-0.0775389597,
-0.0035039815,
0.0296869725,
0.0273766071,
0.0274229031,
0.0142376237,
-0.0929164514,
0.0202534106,
0.0109884012,
-0.0152930096,
-0.0641932338,
0.0285863262,
-0.0011103617,
-0.0094856583,
0.0247591473,
0.0128433555,
0.0394807905,
0.0368003771,
-0.0176252313,
-0.0751214698,
0.0068675829,
-0.0254889857,
-0.0789489523,
0.0340373702,
-0.0458293594,
0.0106314141,
0.0023856133,
-0.0506325513,
-0.062379431,
0.0526282638,
-0.0028463353,
0.03039979,
-0.0334499516,
-0.04930887,
0.0343370028,
-0.0389501676,
-0.0268373601,
0.0603754856,
0.0366579406,
-0.0211687777,
-0.0021135937,
0.0250026714,
0.0210787803,
-0.0419779308,
0.0172706638,
-0.0153882811,
-0.0315994471,
0.0080285789,
-0.0096626598,
0.0103914523,
-0.0443736985,
0.0329093076,
-0.1188569739,
0.0346396118,
-0.0118007353,
0.0040568849,
0.0236309618,
0.0047515016,
-0.0023368385,
-0.0457562581,
-0.0238584839,
0.0381283872,
0.0414134413,
0.0019638729,
0.0304950867,
0.0420710184,
0.0095284665,
-0.0173514672,
-0.0056841928,
-0.024946833,
0.0458101518,
0.007714089,
0.013991341,
0.0108013982,
0.0007217979,
-0.0591636375,
0.0283937603,
-0.0066399411,
-0.0096101929,
0.0453763455,
-0.0466380827,
-0.0435887054,
0.0600830019,
-0.0254622232,
-0.0033729037,
0.0374597982,
-0.0189365689,
-0.0675548986,
0.0454135835,
0.0060143312,
-0.0479437746,
0.0075127436,
0.0245508403,
-0.0027829001,
0.0504603758,
-0.005238825,
-0.0042964076,
-0.0504922681,
0.0581929348,
0.0327322334,
-0.0331396721,
-0.0621224046,
0.0293861963,
0.0217857398,
0.018483568,
-0.007333192,
0.0009971808,
0.0835991427,
0.0353582948,
-0.0152525781,
0.0018424151,
-0.0025427672,
-0.042005267,
0.0710007548,
-0.0322556794,
0.0146504659,
-0.0103154862,
-0.000693901,
-0.0493870527,
-0.0141471373,
0.003535002,
-0.0010739033,
0.0222311243,
-0.0308656916,
0.0341447555,
0.0203138776,
-0.0167561863,
-0.0531952791,
0.0074093211,
-0.0591303036,
0.0025201959,
-0.0313080326,
0.0048883501,
0.0059510786,
-0.009891334,
-0.000713349,
-0.0139405038,
-0.0076024551,
-0.028594505,
-0.0226539131,
0.008853144,
0.0675294474,
-0.0026392124,
-0.0104120411,
0.0212159026,
0.0604723766,
0.0592426434,
0.0295225102,
-0.0178613868,
0.0164752249,
-0.0012177207,
-0.0210459437,
-0.0308440644,
-0.0173918195,
0.0209983177,
0.0450863577,
-0.0605344661,
-0.0306962579,
0.0784574375,
0.0396301784,
-0.0071722618,
-0.0052451692,
-0.0492265262,
0.0306156669,
0.0565854236,
0.0560481958,
-0.1262856722,
-0.0679556727,
-0.0304618031,
0.0628955737,
-0.0057532233,
-0.0540184379,
0.0061067194,
-0.1432151943,
0.0231553782,
0.0093338769,
-0.0593369938,
0.0238703694,
-0.0440050773,
-0.0343670957,
-0.0088780578,
-0.0673594922,
0.0328811072,
-0.0255835764,
0.0223726165,
-0.0169260874,
0.0136326337,
0.0126331709,
0.0577987954,
0.0092751794,
0.0298385508,
0.0403515436,
0.0096001793,
0.0205355901,
-0.0146912513,
-0.001905228,
-0.0249119084,
0.0465415865,
-0.0078301094,
0.0265631154,
-0.0255340803,
-0.0099135283,
-0.0244668368,
0.0421910882,
-0.0645295605,
-0.0204877853,
0.0350934342,
0.081496112,
-0.0162669756,
-0.0236976109,
-0.0321052708,
-0.0057714419,
-0.0264996588,
0.0587580651,
0.0125144096,
0.0042499066,
-0.0833184496,
-0.0469208732,
-0.0127236266,
-0.0760676935,
-0.0275036972,
0.0086221704,
0.0056821187,
0.0334988385,
-0.0666130483,
-0.035287831,
0.0589775108,
0.0675505325,
-0.0219470542,
-0.0148937777,
-0.0368161015,
0.0216222275,
-0.0680891275,
-0.0018001085,
-0.0546852089,
-0.0245944802,
-0.0285099745,
0.007323382,
0.0153370183,
-0.03309156,
-0.005707609,
0.0047368538,
-0.0363269299,
-0.0433072448,
-0.033193931,
0.0756648406,
0.0162995588,
0.0579151325,
-0.0119745787,
0.0087598413,
0.0879263356,
0.0603225231,
-0.0075784069,
0.0076864273,
0.036313992,
0.0054530315,
-0.008600424,
0.0321362987,
-0.10512615,
0.0079990653,
-0.0055902139,
0.0502307713,
-0.0374879017,
0.0011536329,
0.0290473718,
0.0329839699,
-0.0177066494,
0.0221509747,
0.0049102637,
0.0001615815,
0.0116472039,
-0.0157465916,
-0.0013087329,
-0.0507698618,
0.0159256738,
-0.0045804996,
-0.0410468727,
0.0391276106,
-0.0281890836,
-0.062080577,
0.052337151,
-0.0135506969,
-0.0147527335,
0.0311956499,
0.0090607703,
0.0190935489,
-0.0096045416,
-0.0224632584,
0.037807975,
0.0254898556,
0.0609006956,
-0.001343793,
0.0354932509,
0.0345171802,
0.0037514975,
-0.040113613,
0.0309373401,
-0.0824872553,
-0.0874802917,
-0.0185956452,
0.0221420098,
0.0374724418,
0.0402833074,
-0.0404613391,
-0.0062797922,
-0.007384426,
0.0153455799,
-0.0035349131,
-0.0018021767,
-0.035730198,
0.0281848609,
0.0493957996,
-0.0053656348,
-0.0203452595,
0.0533075854,
0.0165660176,
0.0485153235,
0.0110844905,
0.0180900078,
-0.0358975828,
-0.0176049322,
0.0142087061,
0.0352726988,
0.0210370887,
-0.0108828899,
-0.032896284,
-0.07440795,
0.0117753167,
0.027796993,
-0.0395720899,
-0.0008523695,
0.0561638027,
0.0273661874,
0.0442376472,
-0.0460610911,
-0.0189432409,
0.0413520448,
-0.0495515056,
-0.0177527051,
0.0176765788,
-5.930539079e-33,
-0.0180572681,
-0.033109542,
0.0474294573,
-0.0303222649,
0.0063253455,
-0.0207948629,
-0.0555965081,
0.0081123626,
-0.0260168072,
0.0187754855,
-0.0065592276,
-0.002822163,
-0.0074212095,
-0.0027201364,
0.023267528,
-0.0336222798,
-0.0073258248,
-0.0006889621,
-0.0192962755,
0.0253532697,
0.0445068143,
0.0226624496,
0.0118095968,
-0.0019619232,
0.0016347873,
-0.0347594842,
0.0189928785,
0.037561737,
-0.0125394939,
0.0530526862,
0.0196763854,
0.0303592812,
0.0055145454,
0.0087240152,
0.0100847026,
-0.012770161,
-0.0667235106,
-0.075657919,
0.0110246036,
-0.0316722691,
-0.0461615138,
-0.0299842712,
0.0156923663,
-0.011752353,
0.0049577085,
-0.010569104,
0.0309815537,
0.0195959229,
0.0029187873,
-0.0424559377,
-0.0258673951,
-0.0081574041,
-0.0355572216,
-0.0236734655,
-0.0177839845,
0.0430483371,
0.0087117339,
0.032556802,
-0.0332371928,
0.0060097245,
-0.0120285144,
-0.0093940441,
0.0856360048,
0.0247647297,
0.0427597463,
0.0175184906,
0.0143330032,
-0.0070518032,
-0.0561892018,
-0.0014547497,
0.0077075446,
0.0571964644,
0.0380780362,
0.0537844412,
0.0442118347,
0.0328682996,
-0.0775798708,
0.039635282,
-0.0056558074,
0.0402499698,
-0.0273746997,
0.0344018564,
-0.0321766846,
-0.0131020332,
-0.0274068024,
-0.027267063,
-0.045450978,
-0.0472703539,
0.0456100106,
-0.0065636351,
-0.0559262224,
-0.0367180184,
0.0109757222,
-0.0617247559,
0.041768007,
0.0449793488,
-0.0291729718,
0.0287340637,
-0.0022977248,
0.0412111543,
-0.0377281122,
0.0053614797,
0.0647689477,
0.0017110094,
0.0227940213,
0.0368235335,
-0.0258379318,
0.0176253282,
-0.0350966007,
-0.0256349891,
-0.0366331749,
0.0236684941,
-0.0124299442,
-0.0547237583,
0.0038723655,
0.0380254388,
-0.0067843315,
0.0479665212,
-0.0147777414,
0.0001822316,
0.0143828606,
0.0302971154,
0.0048756409,
-0.0095647098,
-0.0125289652,
0.0152512547,
-0.0240520369,
0.0347318575,
-0.0232556909,
-0.0680419654,
-0.0117722657,
0.0639978051,
2.765e-7,
0.0312397871,
-0.0022657376,
0.0182796717,
0.0450975597,
-0.0099141244,
0.0386021137,
-0.0009849941,
0.0273065716,
0.0217912253,
-0.0532839149,
0.0082852384,
0.0640995875,
-0.0256670434,
0.0309374891,
-0.1124375015,
0.0598514266,
-0.0125619164,
-0.0294774491,
-0.0582379662,
-0.0211877618,
0.0501437709,
0.0419983119,
0.0047449367,
0.0023929672,
0.0227924138,
-0.0678839609,
0.0385656171,
0.0407524854,
-0.0006188413,
0.0097755697,
-0.0216251574,
0.0071700462,
-0.0009960493,
0.0243706293,
-0.0071388348,
0.019493442,
-0.0090884697,
0.0284571201,
-0.0285062436,
-0.0650439039,
0.0115616154,
-0.0452625342,
0.0592666976,
-0.0444785133,
0.1034531817,
-0.054490909,
-0.0079979608,
0.0270505827,
-0.0219177958,
0.0001718709,
-0.0289477631,
-0.019806562,
0.0136157535,
-0.0056858351,
0.0014131243,
-0.0065194145,
0.0218538307,
-0.0584284663,
-0.0026739205,
-0.0291451477,
0.0053153005,
-0.0049570841,
-0.0213777479,
0.0150120351,
0.0074363146,
-0.0158527326,
0.0065588453,
2.459879197e-34,
0.0244381893,
0.0178811196,
0.0132467058,
0.0206383187,
0.0168412942,
-0.0065231393,
-0.0382752717,
-0.0085178148,
0.0593059771,
-0.05460402,
-0.0132758413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07838v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07838v3 | LLatrieval: LLM-Verified Retrieval for Verifiable Generation | 2023-11-14T01:38:02 | 2024-03-27T11:36:46 | Xiaonan Li, Changtai Zhu, Linyang Li, Zhangyue Yin, Tianxiang Sun, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Verifiable generation aims to let the large language model (LLM) generate
text with supporting documents, which enables the user to flexibly verify the
answer and makes the LLM's output more reliable. Retrieval plays a crucial role
in verifiable generation. Specifically, the retrieved documents not only
supplement knowledge to help the LLM generate correct answers, but also serve
as supporting evidence for the user to verify the LLM's output. However, the
widely used retrievers become the bottleneck of the entire pipeline and limit
the overall performance. Their capabilities are usually inferior to LLMs since
they often have much fewer parameters than the large language model and have
not been demonstrated to scale well to the size of LLMs. If the retriever does
not correctly find the supporting documents, the LLM can not generate the
correct and verifiable answer, which overshadows the LLM's remarkable
abilities. To address these limitations, we propose \LLatrieval (Large Language
Model Verified Retrieval), where the LLM updates the retrieval result until it
verifies that the retrieved documents can sufficiently support answering the
question. Thus, the LLM can iteratively provide feedback to retrieval and
facilitate the retrieval result to fully support verifiable generation.
Experiments show that LLatrieval significantly outperforms extensive baselines
and achieves state-of-the-art results. | [
0.0493319258,
0.0581239052,
0.0093452297,
0.0345818698,
-0.0450671948,
-0.0216992907,
-0.0131897414,
0.048708044,
0.018302286,
-0.0335454866,
0.0331633352,
-0.0425427593,
-0.0374128595,
0.0149413142,
0.0415854976,
-0.0110845072,
0.0340722762,
-0.0106896861,
0.020366637,
-0.0134242149,
0.0005707272,
0.0138658667,
0.003149244,
0.0118689118,
-0.0378358923,
-0.0015159565,
-0.0076964893,
0.0134546189,
-0.0044113984,
-0.0217466615,
0.0248887297,
0.0406897552,
-0.0031167702,
0.0457655117,
0.0000020118,
-0.0489382073,
-0.0440989956,
0.0221385267,
-0.0594475046,
-0.0080662528,
0.0108015621,
0.0327556655,
-0.021306349,
0.0401373655,
-0.0478345677,
-0.0039086104,
0.0148095898,
0.0136660729,
0.065572679,
0.0829055458,
0.0029715693,
-0.0034472151,
0.0285247862,
-0.0032282113,
0.0473263934,
-0.0221236534,
0.009757746,
0.0244550332,
0.0404859558,
0.0563221388,
0.0424584858,
0.047728017,
0.0242946036,
-0.05633929,
-0.0066781184,
0.0122878319,
-0.0238304082,
-0.0107601238,
0.0028563854,
0.0270597991,
0.0287883636,
-0.0331923701,
0.0153932907,
0.0086315237,
-0.0231308714,
0.0401627496,
-0.0372354314,
0.0729508251,
-0.0197183862,
-0.0215580985,
-0.0085986089,
-0.0089219566,
0.0308379736,
0.0137066683,
-0.0033325588,
0.0522632152,
0.0350840464,
-0.0529604331,
-0.0096897883,
0.0115929833,
-0.0070049274,
-0.066886805,
0.0241751373,
0.0624914989,
-0.0406082198,
0.025243964,
-0.0271672793,
-0.0387000144,
0.0975010395,
-0.0206355341,
0.0285361167,
-0.0067158267,
-0.0242837518,
0.0347445384,
-0.0647645295,
0.0506645367,
-0.0441844799,
-0.0258751623,
-0.0258626267,
-0.0103981039,
-0.0096833901,
-0.0332351178,
-0.0467703417,
0.0524932221,
-0.0334992148,
0.0004498973,
-0.0208150148,
0.0376982428,
-0.0086327419,
0.062273521,
-0.0161834601,
-0.000077788,
-0.0231503323,
-0.0240890197,
-0.0203739926,
0.0150216231,
-0.0465353206,
0.0095142862,
0.0606746152,
-0.0747415274,
0.0030206777,
0.0330147073,
0.0178314112,
-0.0020890643,
0.0321488716,
0.041682899,
-0.0063136169,
0.0008535137,
-0.031107679,
-0.0788256228,
0.0031897821,
-0.0639326721,
-0.0084007541,
-0.081656009,
0.0147011532,
0.0139933424,
-0.04374405,
-0.0130417375,
0.0069363215,
0.0772641078,
0.0153991329,
0.0086064246,
-0.0291391816,
-0.0062058275,
0.0339117795,
0.0091492105,
0.0131763555,
0.0098855225,
0.0002469727,
0.0648835674,
0.0689270943,
0.0303137042,
0.0307012592,
0.0112738097,
0.0407740325,
-0.0034073873,
0.0072949775,
0.0236540157,
0.0133763999,
-0.0147171849,
-0.0450741164,
0.0839116648,
-0.0488257185,
-0.002440505,
0.021253366,
0.0346194319,
0.0184593461,
-0.0158299617,
0.038637206,
0.0016174482,
0.0257146396,
0.021511063,
-0.0278335493,
0.034060888,
-0.0599964075,
0.0089076441,
0.0236265045,
-0.0004927311,
-0.0140384817,
-0.0402331203,
-0.0280069001,
0.0099598737,
-0.0471353978,
0.0204488765,
0.0387095399,
0.017879786,
-0.0335733406,
0.0653049722,
0.0046584904,
-0.1028472558,
0.0041908771,
-0.0356972814,
0.0887014419,
0.0306036565,
0.0791695938,
-0.0164941605,
-0.0075275167,
0.0189013518,
-0.0006218992,
0.0397404581,
0.0394591503,
-0.0044001448,
-0.0330997333,
-0.0414487459,
-0.0272093602,
-0.0172816068,
-0.0030339484,
0.0037127461,
0.0902485177,
0.0073916935,
0.0509772114,
-0.0341317467,
-0.0212477893,
0.0285218004,
-0.0324636139,
-0.0389932394,
0.0023754416,
-0.0077554472,
0.016243482,
0.0062520006,
-0.0268755127,
0.0399554782,
0.0464271046,
-0.0064160386,
-0.0322471336,
-0.0158633981,
-0.0227139145,
0.0237607341,
0.0318697505,
-0.0204214416,
0.0031210103,
-0.0037386324,
-0.017291965,
-0.0370923765,
-0.0263395607,
-0.058597941,
-0.0210474934,
-0.0870737657,
0.0052908873,
0.0171158053,
-0.024903575,
-0.0543262698,
0.0582290478,
0.0147451498,
0.0149191506,
-0.01095057,
0.025013499,
0.0441021733,
-0.0488320291,
-0.0292974878,
0.026934823,
-0.0245803092,
0.0465129986,
0.0780999884,
0.0115563776,
-0.0509901196,
-0.067394264,
-0.057015989,
0.0366763361,
-0.0185927972,
0.0241133589,
-0.0080535384,
-0.004999938,
0.0044787042,
0.0053010574,
-0.0705861449,
0.0086878976,
0.088141419,
0.0192686617,
0.0107478537,
0.0121525368,
0.0061791041,
-0.0355055518,
-0.0113974968,
0.0243845638,
0.03571897,
0.0274873823,
0.0165649541,
-0.064582251,
0.0403294787,
-0.0545031279,
0.0146936988,
0.0110308472,
0.0107960254,
0.0523716696,
-0.0716400445,
-0.0082909465,
0.0009174909,
0.0502152033,
-0.0308671929,
0.0243724585,
-0.0178745333,
-0.0868292451,
0.0048157987,
-0.0225046109,
-0.0531038642,
0.0198402777,
-0.0182324611,
0.0391869508,
-0.001088628,
-0.0128591601,
-0.0096471449,
-0.0197702907,
0.0216971282,
0.0192519203,
0.0132217947,
-0.0168865249,
-0.0152249821,
-0.0100752702,
0.0334577151,
-0.0343690477,
-0.0634645745,
0.0462847501,
-0.0498983748,
0.0129316859,
-0.0082253274,
0.0140220486,
-0.0067132716,
0.0524753109,
-0.0060314466,
0.025650885,
-0.0153019605,
0.0053555225,
-0.0209659804,
-0.0050368477,
0.0342645049,
-0.0906563774,
0.020030247,
-0.0225256886,
0.049967818,
-0.0199477579,
-0.034372367,
-0.0831397772,
-0.0043082987,
0.0205003824,
0.0102916555,
-0.0118139703,
-0.0163305532,
-0.0425660722,
-0.0343830921,
0.0527581051,
0.0062773055,
-0.0185699109,
-0.0149360411,
-0.0107178418,
0.0416828841,
0.0502530932,
-0.0019601483,
0.0342972614,
-0.0454954691,
-0.0249700341,
0.1047662422,
0.0228612013,
0.00502611,
-0.0096370969,
-0.0318026431,
0.0300005767,
-0.0288331099,
0.0070780497,
0.0115749659,
0.0053580333,
-0.0663803965,
-0.0394701883,
0.0643253103,
0.0218192767,
-0.0227150191,
-0.0457610302,
-0.0360679887,
0.0221089236,
0.0071661985,
0.0802563503,
-0.1084782928,
0.0190799851,
0.0103899743,
0.0356709622,
-0.0023508226,
-0.0209011585,
-0.0194305684,
-0.1162509397,
0.0845792517,
0.0185232367,
0.0172812827,
0.0026997398,
-0.0403497629,
-0.0229870453,
0.0653490722,
-0.000445741,
0.0721066892,
-0.0015291115,
0.0003207466,
0.0112999678,
0.0451975577,
-0.0097873518,
0.0048204469,
-0.0463987701,
-0.0023670297,
0.0631816238,
-0.0024349208,
0.0201211646,
-0.0655073896,
0.0102489498,
-0.0228375532,
-0.003010005,
-0.007172347,
0.0296501704,
0.0117172059,
0.0000921894,
-0.0283459313,
-0.0046653957,
-0.0032867081,
-0.0190055873,
0.0339075997,
0.0358115546,
-0.0129035553,
-0.0071468037,
-0.0312881768,
0.0098775141,
0.0121514238,
0.0485447459,
0.0125869866,
0.0158516821,
-0.049386967,
-0.0239337068,
0.0122082466,
-0.0413471647,
-0.0121758003,
0.0191312004,
-0.0016331108,
0.055671338,
-0.0812979713,
-0.0017522377,
-0.0108374413,
0.0790128633,
-0.0216632597,
-0.0091134189,
-0.0124337673,
-0.0345834419,
-0.0649776757,
0.0245068297,
-0.0757183284,
0.0194303766,
-0.0615560599,
0.0115734376,
0.0083021084,
-0.0456199497,
0.0041797189,
0.0249661356,
-0.0517751686,
-0.0586738326,
-0.0410859585,
0.0567785203,
0.0263968632,
0.0198496636,
-0.0001970997,
-0.0384670943,
0.0572246276,
0.0286715031,
-0.0378358662,
0.0158388037,
-0.010138331,
-0.0279064216,
-0.0294492748,
0.0053562806,
-0.0742786974,
0.0165171251,
0.0054198853,
0.0526651442,
0.0129321329,
-0.0487455055,
0.0194597319,
0.0973086655,
-0.0161476657,
0.0099794259,
0.026790712,
-0.0111330245,
0.0241167843,
-0.0205512568,
-0.0369247831,
-0.0212355703,
0.0336602032,
-0.0138771161,
-0.0594509467,
0.021467533,
-0.0057050199,
-0.0263766088,
0.0952916071,
-0.0165771879,
-0.0119948778,
-0.018141916,
0.0178743117,
0.0328036956,
-0.0237993225,
-0.0250168759,
0.0061068395,
-0.015669154,
0.0856365412,
-0.0147475451,
0.0270006098,
0.0204264484,
-0.0120332092,
-0.0213316213,
-0.0010682569,
-0.0549026579,
-0.0594187751,
-0.0427541994,
0.0024314551,
0.0464800075,
0.0220388677,
0.0421069562,
-0.0350776426,
-0.020531198,
-0.033600647,
-0.0166259725,
0.0375944227,
-0.0468327254,
0.0120555395,
0.0195082538,
-0.0050021582,
0.0135601973,
0.0352872945,
-0.0238292776,
0.0025778972,
-0.0214127321,
-0.0076093227,
-0.050637871,
-0.0496013798,
-0.0323364697,
-0.010025965,
-0.0113899838,
-0.0316666774,
-0.0017861262,
-0.055201795,
0.0370675512,
0.0498743914,
-0.0049678464,
0.0185641814,
0.0069933361,
0.0907975137,
0.0294668246,
-0.0324512683,
-0.0434691869,
0.0398540385,
-0.0528572313,
-0.0137108965,
0.0142455734,
-6.228622773e-33,
-0.046605777,
-0.0622577444,
0.0304019768,
-0.0186643191,
-0.0093054585,
0.0328649618,
-0.0581988394,
-0.0268467758,
0.0002040862,
0.014308041,
-0.0200463943,
0.0048096264,
0.0199940987,
0.0278520714,
0.0095894141,
0.024792999,
0.0383207835,
0.008157107,
-0.0532186478,
0.0443195961,
0.0665337741,
-0.0018913004,
0.0034846747,
-0.0728885457,
0.0216428079,
-0.0204431973,
-0.0114020733,
0.0278219078,
-0.0499777161,
0.0603166521,
0.0037080522,
0.0441948958,
0.0092886463,
-0.0104653817,
-0.0103903981,
0.0129987439,
-0.053474348,
-0.0118882097,
-0.011621126,
-0.0450611115,
-0.0511101484,
-0.0438279845,
0.0364641398,
-0.0458409786,
0.0051548309,
0.0131643368,
0.0079748444,
-0.0253850482,
-0.0375165492,
-0.0822032243,
-0.0305095334,
0.0333384536,
0.0451924279,
0.0227611307,
-0.0147981532,
0.0540022887,
0.0104333274,
-0.0084784105,
-0.0212200731,
0.0248530135,
0.0010519152,
0.046171058,
0.0259462353,
-0.008719923,
-0.0234815516,
0.0559755713,
-0.0101412237,
-0.005294784,
-0.0181694292,
-0.0287011079,
-0.0006403472,
0.0592077114,
0.048288282,
0.0765166953,
0.0063822716,
-0.0014197923,
-0.0407023206,
0.064828217,
0.0093748365,
0.0612502061,
0.054600291,
-0.0361661129,
-0.0291070659,
-0.0025432513,
-0.0385098159,
0.0163434558,
-0.0470670313,
-0.0381997265,
0.0369779281,
0.0443498045,
-0.0445461422,
-0.0383424908,
0.0298015587,
-0.0274946075,
-0.0093179801,
0.0620019883,
-0.0232156087,
-0.0225707218,
-0.0331848487,
0.0392215587,
-0.0169009529,
-0.0148204183,
0.0121388491,
-0.0306889415,
-0.0442744978,
0.0486516505,
0.0006028313,
0.0070871315,
-0.0641592667,
0.0324842446,
-0.0463562571,
0.0526678786,
0.0010984993,
-0.0478288457,
0.0323400274,
-0.0010891074,
0.0174512751,
0.0418118834,
-0.0092612365,
-0.0060436246,
-0.0134128435,
0.0000378837,
0.0365905315,
0.0315246806,
-0.0121578109,
0.0542605408,
-0.044985503,
0.0470639728,
0.0017896595,
-0.0164083876,
0.0389108062,
0.0076843007,
2.734e-7,
0.0025681183,
0.019192718,
0.0533477776,
0.0323664844,
-0.0068500219,
-0.0034691219,
0.0030098709,
-0.0177663174,
0.0360241346,
-0.0174989477,
-0.0320371613,
0.0326517746,
0.0650511533,
0.0553292818,
-0.0470130816,
-0.0094860941,
-0.0561805703,
-0.0289501417,
-0.0410168394,
-0.0346651822,
0.0707870498,
0.0282613691,
-0.0114421183,
-0.038310349,
-0.0136643993,
-0.0837877244,
0.0802006572,
0.0150160445,
-0.0288024824,
0.0147224348,
0.082827501,
0.0140440073,
0.0323550366,
-0.0179088805,
-0.0194501393,
0.0232951958,
-0.0321420133,
0.0694856495,
0.0302962419,
-0.02372922,
-0.0031714295,
-0.050883323,
0.0195209365,
-0.0513297692,
0.0375101641,
0.0041853297,
0.0385868587,
-0.0434719399,
-0.0617661476,
-0.0592161976,
-0.0103096655,
-0.0265427008,
-0.0081462814,
0.0257437769,
-0.0056036576,
0.0125147626,
-0.0086988267,
-0.0581325889,
-0.0362928212,
-0.0139796222,
-0.0532127954,
-0.0271707959,
-0.0207428467,
0.0106400931,
-0.0253425166,
-0.0522582009,
0.0174981225,
2.518925518e-34,
0.013377321,
0.0096042249,
0.0173326582,
0.0022781037,
0.0542593561,
0.0233527906,
-0.0163262784,
0.0475647263,
-0.0068417671,
-0.06831,
-0.0293974038
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.